The Nation 1906-04-19: Vol 82 Iss 2129

Page 1

GENERAL LIBRARY UNIV. OF MICH. “APR §° 1906 The N Qtsex | MH Ore. . THURSDAY, APRIL 19, 1906. PRICE TEN CENTS. VOL. LXXXII—NO. 2129. THE GERMAN UNIVERSITIES FRIEDRICH PAULSEN Translated by Frank Thilly and W. W.Elwang. $3.00 net, postage 26 cents. A systematic account of the nature, function, organization, and historical development of the German university. It is the most satisfactory exposition of university problems and the most helpful, practical guide in solving them published in recent years. A book so rich in valuable information, so full of practical suggestions, that it will prove most useful to all connected with university life, either as teachers or students ‘*Piulsen is not only a strong but an attractive writer, and his views of education always deserve respect Evening Post THE. NEW FAR EAST A HISTORY of the REFORMATION I. The Reformation in Germany. by by i THOMAS F. MILLARD THOMAS N. LINDSAY, M.A., D.D. ; ‘*There is so much of unquestioned truth in the book Principal of the United Free Church College, Glasgow that it is of great value. ‘This is the first effort to set forth the situation without prejudice. It will undoubtedly cause much comment.’'—The Inquirer. his new volume in the International ‘Theological Library is an able and scholarly account of the Reformation from the beginning in Germany to the religious peace of Augsburg $1.50 net, postage 13 cents. $2.50 net | JOSEPH JEFFERSON By FRANCIS WILSON Reminiscences of a Fellow Player Intimate and delightful reminiscences of Joseph Jefferson, his conversations, his opinions on literature and art—especially the art of the actor—told by Francis Wilson, the well-known actor. There are many of Jefferson's characteristic stories, full of his wise and witty comments on life, accounts of his recreations as a fisherman with Mr. Cleveland and other friends, his development of the play “Rip Van Winkle” and many other things. ‘« The sketches of personalities are intimately and charmingly done. New light is thrown on the best qualities of Jef ferson, his amiability, his genial humor, his sound artistry.’’—N. Y. Times Saturday Review. Fully illustrated. $2.00 net, postage 19 cents, NEW NOVELS i! THE TOWER SIX STARS { By By " ' MARY TAPPAN WRIGHT NELSON LLOYD ** The charm of the story is in the way itistold. There **A distinc? note of freshness in the American short story is sentiment, vivid description of scenery and nature, and a great A constant spirit of genial humor pervades the book.’ deal of quiet fun.’"—N. Y. Sun. Chicago Inter Ocean $1.50. Illustrated. $1.50. ; aed IONE RO Np Gm, we er ee BOB AND THE GUIDES By MARY R. S. ANDREWS “*A book that is sure to be passed approvingly through the family until every member has tasted of the delight of Mrs Andrews’s humor and inhaled the crisp woodsy atmosphere of her yarns hicago Evening Post. Illustrated, $1.50. CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS, New York ae Bits AX ea ~ a 2 te ead ™ wo

Page 2

ao ee The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2129 The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science and Art. FOUNDED IN 1865. | Mntered at the New York City Post-Ofice as second-class mail matter. | CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. Tus Weex.. cccccesceccoe ee EDITORIAL ARTICLES; Our Sentimental President . B14 Secretary Shaw and Gold Imports . 14 Rural Corrupt Practices .. 815 A Problem of Administration, Not Race - 316 Decorative Arts in America . 317 Nathaniel Southgate Shaler ‘ -. 318 SPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE On India’s Frontier .. 819 General Lamarque : coccee Oe CORRESPONDENCE Literature Versus Philology. ... : . 821 Sancta Simplicitas ; - 821 Comparative Literature’’ and ‘‘Philology’’. 321 Norges eccese 821 Book REVIEWS; Recent Poetry : eueee o00eetece lard Hobbouse P o¢ : .. S27 Cloud Studies eteeseosesesccer -» 828 Problems of Philosoph see oo SD The Life of Oliver Elleworth.............. 328 China and her People.. . evecee , . 830 Lirica Itallana Antica .. , ceccceees 830 Florentine Palaces and their Stories...... 331 Books or Tum Weex ° C00 cocccccccecccce TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three dollars per year in advance, postpaid, in any part of the United States or Cana‘ta; to for- eign countries comprised in the Postal Union, $4. The date when the aubscription expires is on the address label of each paper, the change of which to a subsequent date becomes a receipt for a remtt. tance, Nov other receipt is aent unless requested. Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter, or by check, express order, or Postal Order payable to * Publisher of The Nation.” When a change of addreas is desired, both the old and new addresses should be given. iddress THE NATION, Box79s, New York. Publication Office, 008 Broadway. TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Fifteen cents per agate line, each insertion; 14 linea to the inch, Twe ty per cent. advance for choice of page or top af column, A column, $20 each insertion; with choice of page, at. A page, $60 each insertion; front cover page $80 Advertisements must be acceptable in every respect, Copy received unt] Tuesday, 6 P. M DISCOUNTS. Time 4 tneertions . 5 per cent. 8 - 160 Cl is” 12% Pia) 15 Mw a es ou e oecee “5 Amount $100 within a year , .. 10 per cent 250 6 = cooonedae mw e e cocecs ne os 750 - ya , . eee 20 - 1,000 =O” os eeee ; ¥6 o 1,500 = = secs . wo oe 2,000 ee = say Ct THE NATION t sent free to those who adver- tise in if as long as adveritsement continues, THE BURROWS BROTHERS COMPANY OF CLEVELAND, OHIO are the leading booksellers In the United @tates along certain tines. They lesue « Catalog of Rare Volumes monthly, and this, together with their List of Publica- tions devoted to American History, will be BENT F E to any ove making the request. NOTEWORTHY NEW BOOKS Brooks & Hubbard’s Composition-Rhetoric $1.00 The fundamental aim of this volume is to give pupils the ability to use language for a purpose. It is essentially modern and practical in its charac- ter. In Part I. are the elements of description, narration, exposition, and argument; also special chapters on letter-writing and poetry. A more com- + - comprehensive treatment of the four forms of discourse is furnished in Part Il. Harding’s Essentials in Mediaeval and Modern istory ‘ ‘ ‘ ‘ ‘ - $1.50 This work begins with a survey of the world from the fall of the West- ern Empire to the year 800. From the latter date there is given an account of the development of the various important countries which have influeaced the progress of civilization. The maps and illustrations are particularly note- worthy. Not only are they numerous, but they have been prepared and collected with unusual care. Long’s American Poems . ....__. 90 cents All the American poets from 1776 to 1900 who are worthy of recog- nition are here treated simply, yet suggestively, and in such a manner as to illustrate the growth and spirit of American life as expressed in its verse. Each writer is represented by some of his best-known poems, which are preceded by brief biographical sketches, designed to entertain and awaken interest. Our new Illustrated descriptive catalogue of High School and College Text-Books for 1906 is now ready for distr.bution. It will be sent to any address on request. Rolfe’s New Shakespeare. 40 Vols. Each, 56 cents This new edition of Rolfe’s Shakespeare, just completed, incorporates the results of recent advancement in Shakespearean scholarship and re- search. Among the changes are the omission or abridgment of the original notes on textual variations, and the substitution of comment by the editor for selections from other critics. The books are of handy size for the pocket, and most attractive in appearance. Jordan’s Elementary Latin Writing . $1.00 This book aims to teach the student to write good Latin prose. The first part of the book contains a brief summary of the general rules of syntax, arranged by topics. The second part is devoted entirely to helpful exercises, which furnish more advanced and connected work than that previously encoun- tered. An English-Latin vocabulary completes the book. Smiley’s Manual of American Literature, 60 cents This little manual opens the way to a more extended study of the mas- terpieces of American Literature. The treatment is biographical rather than critical. Suggestions for readirig, both with reference to each author's work and along biographical lines, appear at the end of the chapters. Gannett, Garrison, and Houston’s Commercial 5. otek oe te ee This text-book treats of: Commercial Conditions, physical, social, and economic, that influence commerce in every region; Commercial Products, vegetable, animal, and mineral, together with the treatment of the soil and its cultivation; Commercial Countries, with special reference to the industries and commerce of each. The very latest statistical information has been used, and the present condition of the world’s commerce is accurately portrayed. AMERICAN BOOK COMPANY New York Cincinnati Chicago Boston Atlanta Dallas San Francisco - : x 4 ae mew won ie

Page 3

) ; i April 19, 1906] The Nation. a [ree CROWELL’S BOOKS FOR SCHOOL USE ae ae ROGET’S THESAURUS of English Words and Phrases New Enlarged Edition. Cloth, $1.50; with Index, $2.00. Half Calf, $3.00. “A dictionary of synonyms is a necessity to every student and writer. Roget's Thesaurus co been for many years regarded as the one complete and perfect book of the kind in the language.” DURUY’S GENERAL HISTORY Translated and edited by Prof. E. A. Grosvenor. 25 colored maps. $2.00. “The most satisfactory world history of its kind in existence.” Public Opinion, DURUY'S ANCIENT HISTORY. Maps, index, $1.00 DURUY’S MIDDLE AGES. Maps, index, $0.75 DURUY’S MUDERN TIMES. Maps, index, $1.00 Being Parts I., Ul., and Ill., of the ‘‘General History,’’ Edited by Prof. E. A. Grosvenor. “I know of no historical handbook of equal comprehensiveness which is at once so up-to-date, so authoritative, and so attractively written.”’—Witiram F. Warren, President of Boston University. DURUY’S HISTORY OF FRANCE Translated and edited by Prof. J. F. Jameson. 12 colored maps. $2.00. “The best of all short summaries of French history.”—Anprew D. Waite. AMERICAN CHARITIES By Amos G. Warner, Ph.D. Cloth, $1.75. “As a manual on a subject of the most vital importance the book is a model, ana its value is hardly to be overestimated."—Boston Ad vertiser. SOCIALISM AND SOCIAL REFORM By Richard T. Bly, Ph.D., LL.D. Cloth, $1.50. “ Here for the first time the public is presented with a full and ac- curate account of socialism as it is."— Chicago Times. SOCIAL THEORY By John Bascom. Cloth, $1.75. “Very practical and ethically stimulating "--The Advance PUNISHMENT AND REFORMATION By FP. H. Wines, LL.D. Cloth, 31.75. “ Will educate its readers in a subject on which there is, as yet altogether too much sentimentality on the one hand, and brutal sever ity on the other.""—N. Y, Observer CONTEMPORARY HISTORY By Prof. B. A. Grosvenor. Maps and index, $1.00. ‘A compact and handy volume of reference.’'— Review of Heviews. IRRIGATION By FP. H. Newell, Chief U. S. Hydrographer. is6 IMlustrations. $2.00 net. (Postage ® cts.) “ Nothing on the subject has been published for years so effective, clear, and popular.’’—The Lite ary Worid ECONOMICS OF FORESTRY By B. E. Pernow, N. Y. State College of Porestry. $1.80 net. (Postage 15 cts.) “No other book of like authority. To be commended in the highest terms,"’— Philadelphia Public L-dger THE POETRY OF BROWNING By Stopford A. Brooke. $1.s0 net (los age lS cts.) “The most satisfactory and stimulating criticism of this poet yet published .""—Londun Times FRENCH LITERATURE Fy Perdinand Brunetiére. Cloth, $2.00. “ This is a real history. the best history of French literature in ex istence."’—Prof, E. A. Grosvenor THE BIBLE AS LITERATURE By Drs. Moulton, Peters, Bruce and «thers. introduction by Lyman Abbott. $1.50. “One of the ost important analyses of the subject that has ever been attempted,”—C mmercial Adve: liser. ASTOR EDITION OF POETS For Schools and —_________— Colleges What a Prominent Pro- fessor Says: 96 Volumes 12mo, Cloth “T am delighted with the books, and shall use the Astor Edition henceforward in my classes. The books are so well bound that they may well List Price ... . 60c form a part of any student's - library when he has ccase Price to Schools . . 40c. 9-4 reateyaranie my use them in the class-room.” THE ASTOR PROSE SERIES The Best Books in all prose literature, printed on good paper and neatly bound, with frontispieces and title-pages printed in two colors. Cloth, assorted colors. 322 volumes. 12mo. Per volume, 60 cts. Price to Schools, 40 cts. ** The best books for the money published in England or America."'—From a Customer. HANDY VOLUME CLASSICS Pocket Edition for School Use A School Principal's Opinion : ‘lam pleased to say we are highly satisfied with them Typography, binding, paper. combined make these volumes 168 Volumes 18mo, Cloth almost ideal for class use, . Kindly send me acopy of your List Price . - - + 35¢e. catalogue so that I may learn Price to Schools. . 25c. what other volumes you pub- lish in the same series,” SHAKESPEARE’S WORKS “First Folio Edition,” Edited, With Notes, Introductions, Glos saries, Lists of Variorum Readings, and selected Criticiams, by Caarvorte Porter and Heien A. CLakke, Editors of the “Camberwell” Edition of Robert Browning. To be completed in 40 handy volumes, size 4'4 x 644. Sold separately. Cloth, 75 cents; limp leather, $1.00 per volume, The following volumes are ready: A MIDSOMMER NIGHT’S DREAME LOVES LABOUR’S LOST THE COMEDIE OF ERRORS THE MERCHANT OF VENICE MACBETH JULIUS CAESAR HAMLET LEAR “Tt will prove, I am sure, the most desirable edition which has yet been pablished.”—Dr. Hinam Conson. ‘ THOMAS Y. CROWELL & CO., 426-8 West Broadway, New York j wong ae ke * wore ee mere Dek ine Potala

Page 4

New and Recent Books. IN Supplementary Reading wi »p will be sent by mall - sthald Judson and Bender, Graded Literature Readers: First Book, ... a . »$.25 Second Book.... — ae - stele a oat Third Book..... 45 | Fourth, Fifth, Sixth, Seventh, and Eighth Books, each... .. Se a ee Judson, the Young ‘American 60 Graded Supplementary Read- ing Series: rurpin, Classic Fables. .... jae ee Se Turpin, Grimm’s Fairy Tales........... .40 rurpin, Andersen’s Fairy Tales.... 40 rurpin, Stories from American History. .40 Whitcomb, Heroes of History......... -60 Abernethy, American Literature... ..1.10 Graded Poetry Readers, eight books, each .20 Maynard’s English Classics Series: Scott, The Lady of the Lake..... 36 Scott, Ivanhoe sam AO | rennyson, Idylls of the King ea . 36 Irving, Life of Goldsmith 40 Cooper, The Last of the Mohicans. 40 MAYNARD, MERRILL & CO. 44-60 East 23d St., New York City A History of the American Civil War By W. BIRKBECK WOOD, M. A., and MAJOR J.E. EDMONDS, R. E With an Introduction by H. SPENCER WILKINSON, Svo, with Maps and Plans, net $3.50. “It is characterized by understanding, by impartial attitude, and by thorough- ness of treatment. It is written froma trategical standpoint, and campaigns rather than battles are its main considera- tion.”’-. The Independent. “To Americans, the value of the book is to be found mainly in judgments ar- rived at by the competent critics who are thoroughly impartial on all questions. Their disinterested views on matters of controversy are worthy of the most serious consideration.”’—The Dial Send for New Illustrated Catalogue. a7 & 20 West G.P. Putnam's Sons,23¢322.n. 7" Sally UU tster’'s Journal Thin famous book, the real diary of a real girl of 1777. gives usa new view of the Hevolutionary war. Her flirtations with Washington's officers are told to her giri friend with the moet charming freedom Beautifully tlluetrated \ capital gift book sy postpaid, or at bookstores FERRIS & LEACH, Pubs, Phila EVERYMAN’S LIBRARY List on request. Cloth, 50 cents: leather, $1.00 gk. P. DUTTON & CO... - + NEW YORK The Nation. Saas 82, No. utatig WHAT BETTER USE could you make of ONE DOLLAR than to send it for a Three Months’ Trial Subscription to THE LIVING AGE? That small sum will entitle you to re- ceive Thirteen Numbers, postpaid in the United States, Canada or Mexico, of a magazine which for more than sixty years has given its readers the cream of English periodical literature, ranging all the way from the stately Quarterlies to the Spectator and Punch. Your trial subscription will give you more than 800 pages of the best essays, fiction, poetry, travel sketches, literary, art and musical criticism, discussions of social, religious and educational questions, and papers upon Public Affairs and Interna- tional Politics. Published weekly—-More than 3,300 pages each year—-Annual subscription postpaid, six dollars, THE LIVING AGE CO. 6 Beacon Street, Boston, Mass. TEN BOOKS AT THE PRICE OF ONE That is a fair statement of the price of books in the Humboldt Library of Science What others charge $1.50 for we give at 15 cents, Over one hun- dred of the leading lights repre- sented, Get our catalogue and see for yoursolf. A limited number of complete sets, bound in 18 volumes, now TEN FOR ONE ready. 20TH CENTURY PUBLISHING CO, 129 W. 20th Street, New York. Importi tice mporting No We beg to announce that we have greatly extended our facilities for the importation of English books, so that we now are equipped to fill orders of this sort with the greatest efficiency and intelligence. Promptness, good service and low prices will rule in this department, as they do in all our business. THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO. WHOLESALE BOOKSELLERS, 33-37 E. 17th St., Union Sq North, New York The Ben Greet Players IN SHAKESPEARE’S PLAYS Acted as Shakespeare wrote them in a setting representing an old English Hall or Theatre. ALSO IN OPEN AIR PLAYS Beginning May 20th at Washington Colleges and Clubs desiring to book this at- tractive combination kindly address BEN GREET, care of Walter Jordan, Empire Theatre, N. Y. JUST PUBLISHED Outlines of English and American Literature By J. H. GiLMoreE, Ph.D., of the University of Rochester. An outgrowth of the classroom. Emphasizes the principal authors and salient facts in our literary history. Conforms to the plan of work recommended by “The Committee of Fifteen.” Adapted to advanced High School or College work. 12mo, cloth 267 pages; price 75c net. Special rates for introduction. Correspond- ence solicited. SCRANTOM, WETMORE & CO., Publishers, Rochester, N. Y. Forty Years of Critical Re- search, from an All-Inclusive Viewpoint, Summed up in CHRISTIAN ORIGINS By OTTO PFLEIDERER, D.D. Professor of Theology at the University of Berlin. Translated by Danie. A. Hugssca, Ph.D. All Booksellers, $1.75 net. Circular on Request. B. W. HUEBSCH, New York LITERARY CRITICISM Of English and American Authors. 680 to 1905. In eight royal 8vo volamesa, 6,000 criptive matter and specimen pages on request. MOULTON PUBLISHING CO., Buffalo, New York F. W. CHRISTERN (DYRSEN & PFEIFFER, Successors) 16 West 33d St., opposite the “ Waldorf,” New York, Paria Pu of Fore Books, Agents for the legding Publishers. Taachnitz's British authors. Teub- ner’s Greek and Latin Classics. Catal e of stock malied on demand. New books received from and Leipzig as soon as LIBRARY RESEARCH Topics of all kinds and * any la) ge looked up in the Boston and Harvard libraries, for scholars, writ- ers, and others. Abstracts, coptes, translations, and bibliographies made, Proof-reading and revision of manuacript. Highs ‘university and seers ree references. 06 Chestnut Street, Boston, Mass. KATE DOUGLAS WIGGIN’S ROSE 0’ THE RIVER | By the Author of « Rebecca "’ hee hme Rend

Page 5

oe Rea * April 19, 1906] Educational. MaSSACHUSETTS, Boston. OSTON UNIVERSITY Law School. New features. Address the Dean. M. M. BiarLow. PaILADELPalA, Chestnut Hill BOARDI NG AND DAY Mrs. Chapman and “io ror Miss Jones GIRLS. Thorough College Preparatory and Finishing Courses, with special opportunities for culture. Number of pupilslimited. Classes small, insur- ing individual attention. Large, comfortable house with pleasant grounds. Tennis, basketball, and skating. ROCK RIDCE SCHOOL For Beys. Location high and dry. Laboratories, Shop ik Mechanic Arts. Strong teachers. High ideals. ~ cyeenum with swimming pool. Fits for college, on school and business. Illustrated pamphiet sent free. Address Dr. B. C. WHITE, Rock Ridge Hall, Wellesley Hills, Mass. School Agencies. WE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES Everert O. Fisk & Co., Proprietors. hburton Pl., Boston 1505 Pa. Ave., Washington {se Firch Ave., New } ork 414 Cent. Bid.. Minneapolis sy } + Ave, Chicago 1200 Wiliiams Av., pay t ro ahs Bid., Denver 525Stime’n Bik.,Los Adgeles St3 ieee , Spokane 717 Market 8t., San Fr’ncisco Send to any canine above for Agency Manual. The Nation. Vv THE FRANKLIN BI-CENTENNIAL THE STANDARD WORK 18 THE Life of Benjamin Franklin WRITTEN BY HIMSELF Edited by Hon. JOHN BIGELOW New Fifth Edition Revised and Enriched “The life of one of the greatest Americans is presented in a form that must be well nigh definitive.""New York Sun In Three Handsome Volumes, Illustrated. Cloth Bound, Gilt Top, $06.00 WRITTEN CLEARLY, FRANKLY AND WITHOUT PREJUDICE THE TRUE BENJAMIN FRANKLIN By Sidney George Fisher Iilustrated. S8vo, Cloth, $2.09. Half Levant, $5.00. is valuable in proportion to its in- An Agency fluence. If it merely hears of va- cancies and tells tha t is something, but if it is asked to you about them recommend a teacher and rec. omumpente ou, thatismore. Ours C. W. BARDEEN, Syracuse, N. Y. Recommends J. B. LIPPINCOTT COMPANY, Philadelphia ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY. Has Good Positions for Good Teachers with Good Records. Send for Circular on Free Registration. HAKLAN P. FRENCH, 81 Chapel St., Albany, N. Y CHERMERHORN’S Teachers’ Agency. Teachers—Schools—Tutors—Governess— Property. Tel. 6129 18th. Joun C. Rock wk, Mer., 83E 14th St., N. Y. C. Travel. FOREIGN TRAVEL. A university graduate and experienced teacher of wide acquaintance with European life and travel, would like to take charge of a few boys or accompany a smal! party of adults wishing to spend the summer abroad. For further informa tion or references address A. M., P. O. Box 1217. Providence, R. I. EURO -High-c ieee tour: Small party of ladies— June 21—Sept. 3d. Southern route. Terms moderate. 17th tour. pny. Address MISS BARBOUR, Atlanttc City, N Selections and Documents in Economics Edited by WILLIAM Z. RIPLEY, Professor of Economics in Harvard University. An meee 1 of the case system of the law schools to the teaching of economica. ALREADY PUBLISHED Ripley’s Trusts, Pools and Corporations Common’s Trade Unionism and Labor Problems Carver’s Sociology and Social ys Bullock’ s Selected Readings in Finance CINN & COMPANY, BOSTON blic A Universal Exchange of All Varieties of Earmest Religious Thought THE HIBBERT JOURNAL Each number comprises 240 pages. Yeurly subscription $2.5). Post free. Single numbers 75 cents, Post free CHIEF CONTENTS OF APRIL NUMBER Is the Religion of the Spirit a Working Religion for “lankind ? By Dom Curusenr Berier How Japan Buddhi Appeals to a Christian Theist. ty Professor J, Faruin Canrentrer Does Christian Belief require Metaphysics ? By Professor h, 8. Drowns Mr. Birrell’s Choice. By the Right Rev, Lord Bishop of Carlisle The Working Faith of the Social Reformer. By Professor Henry Jones St. Catherine of Siena. By Enuunn G. Garvner. The Laws and Limits of Development in Christian Doctrine. By the Rev Paucirran W. Jonge Davies The Salvation of the body by Paith. By the Author of “ Pro Christo et Ecclesia” The Resurrection. A Layman’s Dialogue. By T. W. Rotesros Christianity and Science Il. The Divine Element in Christianity. Hy Sir Oviver Lonur With a Number of Signed Reviews and Bibliography of Recent Literature. Subscriptions are booked and single numbers sold by G. BE. STECH IRT & CO., 129-133 West Twentieth St., New York; AME RICAN UNITA2IAN ASSOCIATION, 25 Beacon St., Boston, from any good. bookseller or WILLIAMS & NORGATE, 14 Henrietta St., Covent Garden, London, W. C. Shakespeare Our new Catalog 118, entitied Shakespeare, His Works, His Times, His Influence ; inc uding Em- blem , and Dances of veath. Contains 60 numbers, all of which are of interest to the Shake- spearian collector. It is annotated in English with full references to the Bibliographies Sent gratis on application by LUDWIG ROSENTHAL’S ANTIQUARIAT, Hildegardstrasse 16, MUNICH, GERMANY. Financial. TT We buy and sell bills of exchanges and LE ERS make cable transfers of money on uro OF Australia, and South Africa; also make CREDIT {2 collections and issue Commercial and veliers’ Credits availabie in all parts oft the world, International Cheques. Certificates of Deposit. BROWN BROTHERS & CO., NO. 50 WALL STREET, NEW YORK SIBLEY’S HARVARD GRADUATES By the Former Librarian of Harvard College We have about © each Vols. 2 and 3. Vol, 2, 1650-1677, Vol, 3, 1678-1000 To close these out we will send you the 2 Vols. on receipt of $1.00. These were published at $5.00 per Vol We still have a few sets, Vols. 1, 2, 3. Price, $20.00 for the set. GEORGE H. KENT, University Bookstore, Cambridge, Mass. UNIVERSITY of GENEVA (Switzerland) HOLIDAY COURSE OF MODERN FRENCH 17th July—30th August, 1906 Write for detailed Syllabus to SECRETARY OF THE UNIVERSITY. oS ee antmeeget P Re ge ete eer! Bee Seater oo eae Pinas ae de te tar wa ht al

Page 6

Vi The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2129 — PRIZES FOR ECONOMIC ESSAYS | THIRD YEAR In order to arouse an interest in the Study of topics relating to commerce and industry, and to stimulate an examinat on of the value of college training for business men, a committee composed of Professor J. Laurence Laughlin, University of Chicago, Chairman ; Professor J. B. Clark, Columbia University; Professor Henry C. Adams, University of Michigan; Horace White, Esq., New York City, and Hon. Carroll D. Wright, Clark College have been enabled, through the generosity of Messrs. Hart, Schaffner and Marx, of Chicago, to offer again in 1907 four prizes for the best studies on any one of the following subjects : The practical wisdom of freeing raw materials, essential to subsequent manufactures, from customs-duties 1. when entering the United States. 2. ‘The best methods of obtaining an elastic currency in times of panic. 3. To what extent, and in what form, are Socialistic tenets held in the United States? 4. In what respect, and to what extent, have combinations among American railways limited or modified the influence of competition ? 5. The best methods of avoiding resort to force by labor unions in their contests with employers. 6. The effect of “ trusts” upon the prices of goods produced by them. 7. How far does the earning power of skill obtain under a regime of trade unions? 8. A critical study of modern commercial methods for distributing products to consumers. 9. ‘The development of economic theory since John Stuart Mill. A First Prize of One Thousand Dollars, and A Second Prize of Five Hundred Dollars, in Cash are offered for the best studies presented by Class A, composed exclusively of all persons who have received the bachelor’s degree from an American college in 1895, or thereafter; and A First Prize of Three Hundred Dollars and a Second Prize of One Hundred and Fifty Dollars, in Cash are offered for the best studies presented by Class B, composed of persons who, at the time the papers are sent in, are undergraduates of any American college. No one in Class A may compete in Class B; but any one in Class B may compete in Class A. The Committee reserves to itself the right to award the two prizes of $1,000 and $500 to undergraduates, if the merits of the papers demand it. Che ownership of the copyright of successful studies will vest in the donors, and it is expected that, with- out precluding the use of these papers as theses for higher degrees, they will cause them to be issued in some permanent form. Competitors are advised that the studies should be thorough, expressed in good English, and, although not limited as to length, they should not be needlessly expanded. ‘They should be inscribed with an assumed name, the year when the bachelor’s degree was, or is likely to be received, and accompanied by a sealed envelope giving the real name and address of the competitor, and the institution which conferred the degree, or in which he is studying. The paper should be sent on or before June 1, 1907, to J. Laurence Laughlin, Esq., University of Chicago Box 145, Faculty Exchange Chicago, Illinois ‘ ee eS a ae

Page 7

April 19, 1906] Nation. vi i “It is to 1905 what the first pronouncing gazetteer was to 1855—the best book of its kind published in English, on this or the other side of the Atlantic.”’— The Churchman. Lippincott’s New Gazetteer **Up to date and invaluable.’’ —New York Sun. ‘‘The Gazetteer is indispensable.’’ ~—Boston Herald, No Library Is Complete Without It Bradstreet’s.—“A great Geographical Dictionary.” Boston Evening Transcript.— ‘A monumental work of almost incalculable value.” Public Opinion.—“ This book is as essential to the library as the dictionary or the encyclopxdia.”’ Boston Daily Globe. —‘‘ Accurate, up to date, practical, it is an absolute necessity for libraries, schools, colleges, and institutions of every kind.” The Outlook.—* For the newspaper office, the library, and the increasing number of business men whose field is the world and who must have accurate information about it, Lippincott’s Gazetteer in its new form will be as indispensable as is an unabridged dictionary.” Three-Quarter Levant, $15.00 net. Patent Index 50 cents extra. Over 2000 pages. Quarto. Sheep, $10.00 net. Half Morocco, $12.50 net. LIPPINCOTT’S STANDARD REFERENCE WORKS THE NEW 1906 EDITION LIPPINCOTT'S | THE NEW EDITION OF Chambers’s Encyclopaedia The corner-stone of any library is a good encyclopaedia—it is indispensable. Pronouncing Dictionary of ‘Chambers’s Cyclopaedia Biography and Mythology of English Literature | There is no single work of more im- portance for Library, school, and college | than this. | A clear and comprehensive survey of English literature from the beginning to the twentieth By JOSEPH THOMAS, M.D., LL.D. This magnificent work, which for years has been in its department without a rival 9 in the estimation of scholars, has lately eanear Chambers’s pen ~~ extensive revision, which | Contains on oushontis biography of every was rendere necessary by the ¢reat American and Engiish writer of note, whether Encyclopaedia a. & | Host, dramatist, novelist, or historian. material condensed into the three volumes of Cham bers's Cyclopaedia of English Litera. ture would ordinarily fill a dozen or more books. j It is the cheapest authoritative reference work of similar scope now in print. | It contains the essence of hundreds of the most valuable books in English literature, and is a library in itself, Illustrated with approved portraits and drawings. Contains over 2500 pages. A detailed Table of Contents in cach volume. Complete in three imperial octavo volumes, stoutly bound. of human activity in the last few years; it is now offered to the public in a greatly improved form, embracing, besides the re- vision of the articles included in previous issues, numerous new biographical sketches of persons who have lately be- come of sufficient prominence to merit mention. strides that have taken place in every field | is not only the acknowledged encyclo- paedia for the busy man and student, but also carries the finest illustrations of any encyclopaedia. Complete in ten volumes. secures the use of ONE DOLLAR the entire set at once and the balance can be paid in little-at-a- time amounts. | Subscription volumes. edition in two large octavo 2550 double-column pages. Sample pages and full particulars of these valuable works sent on application. J. B. LIPPINCOTT COMPANY, Publishers, Philadelphia See a eS Se a 0 ee we A ee weteg ed Bs emir ies oe Gr ns aes

Page 8

Vill The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2129 “No former edition of Franklin’s Writings has ever approached this in fullness.” —The Review of Reviews. The Writings of : Benjamin Franklin Edited by Atserr H. Smyru, Professor of the English Language and Literature in the Central High School, Philadelphia, with Portraits and Illustrations. Special Limited Edition in Ten Volumes, Cloth, 8vo. Price per volume, $3.00 net (carriage extra). . COMMENTS OF THE PRESS BOSTON: TRANSCRIPT: ‘A valuable and interesting compilation of the writings of Franklin, revealing more completely than any other the private character of the man. BOSTON HERALD: ‘‘Franklin’s significance in literature appears when we remember that he was the first American to transcend provincial boundaries and limitations, and the first author and scientist to achieve wide and permanent reputation in Europe. His autobiography was vivid, truthful, thrilling with life, for it was the simple, fascinat- ing narrative of a career that began in lowly surroundings and ended in splendor. It contained therefore the substance of the stories that have chiefly interested the world.”’ CHICAGO TRIBUNE: ‘There was never a man whose interest extended to so many widely severed fields as did Franklin’s. Besides the scientific problems which he studied out to a satisfactory solution, we find foreshadowed in his casual suggestions the germs of many later discoveries. His literary and political activity is mirrored in his writings, and his own autobiography is one of the classics of English literature.” NEW YORK TRIBUNE: ‘‘No more worthy tribute to the great philosopher and patriot could well have been contrived than the wholly admirable edition of his writings which Professor Smyth has collected and edited with so much reverent scholarship and painstaking research, ”’ THE FORUM; NEW YORK: : ‘‘Everywhere we touch him he is the human and therefore the fascinating Franklin - when his limitations have been duly considered, it remains true that Franklin, like Defoe, and for much the same reasons, is one of the most fascinat- ing of mortals, at least to stud nts who examine his character by means of his self-reveiling writings.’’-—W. P. Trent, Columbia Uurversity. BALTIMORE SUN: ‘Of all the editions of the works of Franklin, this is the best.”’ ruvichel THE MACMILLAN COMPANY, “i've. by

Page 9

nee SSS =x NEW YORK, THURSDAY, APRIL 18, 1906 The Week. A long step, if not towards a national law of marriage and divorce, at least tewards a better national rule in such matters, was taken by the Supreme Court on Monday. Its decision that a di- vorce granted under the loose laws of one State need not be given “full faith and credit” in another, deals a blow at the long-standing scandal of “Dakota divorces.” The court holds that the val- idity of a divorce granted almost er parte in Connecticut can be successfully attacked in New York. Justice White, who read the opinion, had undoubtedly a difficult position in constitutional law te maintain, but his moral reasoning is certainly powerful. He shows how ab- surd it is for one State to be asked to give full faith and credit to the act of another which would destroy its own laws. “If,” he says, “the-full-faith-and- credit clause were now to be held ap- tlicable to the enforcement in the States generally of decrees of divorce of the charcter of the one here involved, it would follow that the law of nearly all the States would be overthrown.” The upshot of the decision appears to be that a divorce of two citizens of one State can be binding, when granted in avother State, only when both parties were there present. This should either double or destroy the “divorce colony” in Sioux Falls and elsewhere. At any rate, the decision of the Supreme Court will do much to end the more disgrace- ful hugger-mugger of divorce that has so long been a national reproach. Congressman McCall makes the point that the President might betier busy himself about repealing unjust laws that conduce to swollen fortunes, than be s0 anxious to tax them when accumu- lated. Mr. Roosevelt declared that we must “grapple with problems connected with the amassing of enormous for- tunes”; yet he himself has always fa vored, and now appears to favor, the class legislation which not only diverts wealth into the hands of a privileged few, but carries with it the sting of so- cial injustice. The President at this moment is urging a ship-subsidy bill which is designed to put public funds into private pockets. He has never lifted a finger against the tariff, though it enables its beneficiaries to levy taxes upon the people. Think of the many “steel” fortunes “swollen beyond al! healthy limits”; then think of the steel schedules in the Dingley tariff, and re- member that the President has been so The Nation. intimidated that he cancelled the tariff- reduction message which he had written. I'ar more important than the taxation of great fortunes after they are made, is the prevention of their being heaped up Ly means of purchased laws which de- stroy the only equality possible. Senator Bailey's reputation, already great, will doubtless be heightened by his speech of April 10. To have held a crowded Senate and packed galleries for four hours listening to a close-knit legal argument, is an extraordinary achleve- ment. On the validity of his conten- tions about points of law, we will not here undertake to pronounce, but he had a distinguished convert, in the very act, in the person of Senator Hale. The feel- ing was general that Mr. Bailey’s speech had put a new face upon the whole rate- however, it is gratifying to note that the President stands absolutely firm Just where he stands, no one appears to know, but his friends indignantly deny that he has budged an inch from his original position, whatever that may have been. Seemingly, he has not got out of the realm of abstractions He is heart and soul for a bill which will do “equal and exact justice,” which will be “fair to railroad and shippers alike,” and which will stand the test of con- stitutionality; but as to the actual de tails of a concrete bill, he refuses to commit himself. It is most reassuring, however, to get it on authority that he has not “surrendered.” It is obvious that a desperate effort is making to get the ship-subsidy grab through this session, after all. The bill slipped through the Senate, after per- functory debate, though with marked Republican opposition, on the distinct understanding that the House would not touch it this year. Speaker Cannon's hostility to it was well known But Grosvenor's approaching retirement from Congress seems to have spurred him to new exertions: his committee has begun a series of “hearings’’; the lobby is at work; the press is being used; and the plan is plainly to make a grand onslaught and pull this bounty out of the Treasury, if possible, before the country is aware of the raid. The movement has every appearance of a sort of foreclosure on the Republican party by the ship-subsidy men. How much they gave to elect Mr. Roosevelt, Mr. Cortelyou could tell, but will not They are now demanding that the goods they paid for be delivered. So trans- parent is this situation, and so unblush- ing the demand for a subsidy from the bill situation. In all the vacillation, | | folly than for the Republican manag | ers to give way to the impudent appea! could not well be imagined. Their Con gressional campaign looks none too sidy on top of the tariff burdens which they have refused to touch with one of | | bright as it is. If they pile a ship sub | | their fingers, the outlook for them wil! be black with political disaster The House Committee on Election which has reported favorably upon a re: olution providing for the election of Sen ators by direct vote, has heeded a grow ing sentiment. “Has again heeded would be more accurate, of course, sinc the House has on four separate occa sions passed such legislation as the com mittee now recommends As a matte: of fact, action by Congress to compel th: | choice of Senators by popular vote becoming relatively unimportant Ihe | States are falling into line, one after av | other, in insisting that at the State ele tions Senatorial candidates shall submit themselves to the judgment of the vo ers. So far, the popular verdict has no been regarded as absolutely mandatory) | but practically the people's choice is a | sure of being ratified ‘formally by | Legislature as is the decision of the vot ers in a Presidential contest by the Ble toral College. The Legislatures of Vi: ginia and Arkansas may refuse to seni to the Senate the man: who won at th: Democratic primaries; but the chanc: of this are small. It would be strange if the Unite States, which opened Japan to Western nations, should be the first to shut thie door in the face of the Japanese immi grant. In Congress the other day M: Hayes of California spoke in support ot @ bill to extend the Chinese exclusion laws so as to embrace the subjects of ti Mikado and the Koreans. He profs to represent 95 per cent. of the people o! his State in this matter, which, he sai! is one of domestic policy, not of ints national law. He admitted that the Jay anese had shown extraordinary Iinte!! gence and courage in the conduct of the war, but he condemned them for thei: dishonesty as a people, and declared that the vast majority “do not understand the meaning of the word ‘morality.’ it would, indeed, be unfortunate if the Arcadian simplicity and purity of polities were to be corrupted by admit ting our Asiatic neighbors. The ero nomic aspects of the question deserve more consideration. Mr. Hayes. who is himself an employer, presented sta tistics going to show that the Japanese coolie could greatly underbid the Euro pean and American workman. However public funds, that a greater piece of this may be, it is to be hoped that Con font ate Br ernreee- Sy Sk a Soll

Page 10

312 gress will never exclude the Japanese who come here to attend our univers!i- ties and technical schools. A continu ance of intellectual relationship should increase the friendship between the two nations The American Federation of Labor evidently meant business when, through President Gompers, it announced that it was in politics He now is circulating | among the labor unions what must pass for a pretty definite programme Its chief terms are these: The working peo- ple “will act as a unit at the polls of every election.” It will “elect men from our own ranks to make new laws and administer them along the Ines laid down in the legislative demands of the American Federation.” Alongside this manifesto it savors of the bathetic to read that all labor candidates must have “clear, unblemished, paid-up union cards in their possession.”’ President Gompers undoubtedly realizes that, however de sirable a possession an untarnished union card may be, it is by no means the equivalent of a certificate of elec tion The labor leaders generally are probably encouraged by the success of | their British colleagues It was proved the other day, in the Commons, in the matter of immunity of union funds from damage suits, that about ten min utes of Mr. Keir Hardie’s reefer was worth an hour and a half of the Attor- nev-General's robes. Mr. Gompers possi tly foresees similar triumphs in the Cap itol. However that may be, nobody need regret that American unionism is about to try ite political luck We are glad that the people are going to have a chance to vote on the claims of the labor oligarchy, and we have no fear of the verdict Even for unionism itself we ‘anticipate only good from a policy that will abate the present guerilla warfare, ubstituting therefor a comprehensive nd unambiguous plan of campaign. Secretary Taft's speech at Tuskegee ha tirred up the Southern press not a little Several editors are so frank aa to say that no matter how far the negra may progress in wealth, education, and civie worth, he will never be allowed to vote The Atlanta Journal finds in the Seeretary’s remarks fresh reason for he proposed Georgia disfranchisement lawe, which, it tells its readers, “will in ive the elimination of the ignorant and venal negro vote without disfranchising i single uneducated white man for at cast the next quarter of a century.’ One Georgia editor haa expressed great indignation at Mr. Taft for letting the negro know that, after the expiration of the grandfather clauses, he will be in an enviable political position, holding the talance of power between the two par- tles. Thia editor, betraying that regret table ignorance of the educated colored The Nation. nan so noticeable among Southern men, exclaimed bitterly: “Mr. Taft tells the negro just what we have been trying to keep from him.” As well might the South attempt to keep from the blacks the colors in the American flag as to hide from them any phase of the politi- cal situation. On this the negroes are becoming better informed and more dis- | satisfied every day. They do not share Mr. ‘Taft's roseate hopes of what will happen after the grandfather clauses ex- pire, for they fear that they will be de- fravded auew. Recently two teachers in a Virginia school, one white, the other black, and both worthy American citi- | zens, were disfranchised because they were held to Lave failed to answer prop- erly some abstruse Constitutional ques tions propounded by an ignorant “poor- white” registrar for the deliberate pur- pose of disqualifying them. The lynching at Springfield, Mo., pre- sents anew the too familiar paradox of an apparently civilized—at any, rate a representative American-—-community suddenly inflamed by the lust of blood. Springfield is a county seat. It is evi- dently a public-spirited town, for, with | a population of some 23,000, It contains a college, a private academy, a high school, and maintains a zodlogical garden. It is, presumably, like most cities of the Middle West, a religious community. In fact, one of the most distressing details of the dispatches is the description of Sunday-school children searching the ashes in the spot where three negroes were burned—for souvenirs. The inhabi- tants of Springfield employ probably the | considerate courtesy common to all com- | munities with an infusion of Southern blood, Yet they disputed, on Sunday, a bit of the charred skull of a negro whom the mob had taken from the jail and consumed in a bonfire. Individually the citizens of Springfield would deny any lack of personal courage: but a sheriff and a group of armed deputies discreetly effaced themselves while the mob battered in the jail doors, wrecked the building, and hanged the prisoners from the windows. Probably Springfield would deeply resent any insinuation that | its civilization is defective in sweet rea- sonableness. It perhaps reads with some amazement Gov. Folk’s just char- acterization of the members of the mob as murderers. But what must one tnink | of the civilization of a community where race hatred lies so near the surface that | the representation of an incendiary play, the occurrence of a crime of violence, the consumption of bad whiskey, are sparks enough to kindle an auto-da-fé? We must in fairness add that both city iund State are making such amends as | } are possible for the atrocity. The mil- itia has cowed the mob, the bench has promptly issued warrants for the ring- leaders, and the “better element,” we are [Vol. 82, No. 2129 informed, is “shocked” at the belated discovery that the wrong negroes were Iynched. Gov. Folk, in particular, has acted with exemplary vigor, both in sup- plying troops and in condemning the mob. {n Gov. Deneen's hurry call for an ex tra session of the Illinois ‘.egislature to remedy the defects in ' primary law passed last year, and just declared by the Supreme Court of the State to be unconstitutional, he says: The old nominating system has been discredit- ed. . . . The people have demanded the substance instead of the semblance of participation in the nomination of candidates.”” The Governor's general interpretation of State sentiment has been supplemented by ex-Gov. Yates’s illuminating remarks upon the act that has been declared to be of no effect. Yates, of course, is an aspirant for Sen- ator Cullom’s seat, and he has been conducting a campaign for some months with the expectation that the choice would be made at the Republican pri maries. Now he charges that the law as it passed the Legislature last year was “doctored” by “the friends of the Senatorial machine in Illinois.” He de- clares that these plotters intended that it should be declared unconstitutional, and that they prefer the old convention system to any primary at all. We may doubt Yates’s implication that it was all a plot hatched to kill his boom for the Senate; but it is evident that Gov. Dineen has public sentiment behind him i. his desire to secure the prompt amendment of the faulty statute. or “Comic” is the only word to apply to the surprise and pain of our own rose- water and angel-cake Socialists, now that they have discovered that Maxim Gorky is not a hero for the Ladies’ Home Journal. Gorky in turn is equal- ly amazed and puzzled. He cannot un- derstand why Americans who pine for that intellectual and moral freedom which will result from destruction of the existing social order, should look askance on a man who does a little de- stroying on his own account. Gorky is astonished at his own moderation. He has done nothing but leave his wife in Russia and come to America with another “spiritual affinity.” The per- formance is not strictly legal, but—like all such cases—it has the sanction of the “higher law.” Can it be that our own apostles of emancipation are still the slaves to grovelling superstition? Do they still make a fetish of the bour- geois virtues? Would Robert Hunter, James Graham Phelps Stokes, and Ed- win Markham shackle a man to one wo man for all his days? When she has borne two or three children and has lost her youthful comeliness, must he still 28

Page 11

eos wre April 19, 1906] The Nation. be compelled to gaze at her, fat and forty, across the breakfast table? This is to tie a soaring soul to earth and turn it to a clod. Mr. Markham’s Man with a Hoe has a jolly time of it com- pared with the Man with One Wife. Let us drop a passing tear for victims of eruel and stupid conventions, and then push on to the goal of a revolutionized, glorified, and polygamous humanity. For a good many years past the American Grocer has performed the im- portant service of translating the Gov- ernment excise statistics into current retail prices, and thus determining how much the people of this country actually spend for beverages, both alcoholic and non-alcoholic. The data thus obtained serve as valuable and exceptionally ac- curate indications of current changes in certain social habits and conditions. The figures for 1905, just issued, show a continuation of the same steady an- nual increase in this item of national expenditure as has been observed in the years previous. We spent for beverages $1,548,708,307, as against $1,498,622,715 in 1904, $1,451,633,379 in 1903, $1,369- 098,276 in 1902, and $1,273,212,386 in 1901. The total drink bill to-day, as the com- piler states, is “one-fourth of the total estimated production of the _ cotton, wheat, corn, hay, and tobacco crops, and every other product of farms, orchards, cattle ranches, dairies, and every other agricultural industry. It amounts to one-eighth of the nation’s total expendi- ture for food.” Although this increase has been larger not only absolutely, but relatively to the population—21.6 per cent. during a period when the population increased 6.5 per cent.—it would hardly te contended by any one that it has been a period of increased intemperance. It has been characterized, it is true, by the abandonment of statutory prohibi- tion in two small States, but the local- option system has made great headway at the same time, and the area of le- galized liquor selling has been very considerably decreased in many States, especially in the South. Corporations in certain lines have taken to requiring total abstinence from their employees, and the demands of industry have stead- ily become less compatible with over- convivial habits. If we compare the per-capita consump- tion of liquors in 1905 with that for 1840, the first given in the current statistical abstract, we find a tremendous change in the relative proportion of alcoholic beverages consumed. Here are the fig- ures in gallons per capita: Malt Distilled Wines. liquors. spirits. Total Becesccesdecs 29 1.36 2.52 4.17 Bee prcercceces 43 18.50 1.45 20.28 That is, in sixty-five years, the aver- age American has increased his allow- ance of beer fourteen times, and learned to drink half as much again of wine, | but at the same time cut off three-sev- enths of his consumption of whiskey Only one of these changes, however, has been at all steady. The consumption of wine, as shown by the official sta- tistics, has been wholly erratic 313 When Emperor William's epitaph comes to be written, it will need to be almost the reverse of the satiric one on the English king who never said a fool ish thing and never did a wise one. The Kaiser @oes a great many wise things, | but whenever he speaks or writes—-espe ranging as high as .63 gallon in 1902 and | as low as .26 in 1896. The individual consumption of whiskey and other spir- ite showed an irregular decline until it reached its minimum of 1.01 gallons also in 1896, after which it mounted again steadily for eight years to 1.48 gvllons in 1904, and only this year has cially whenever he telegraphs—-he is apt to go off in a blaze of indiscretion. His telegram on Friday to the Austrian For eign Minister, apropos of the Algeciras | Conference, is about as needless a blun der as one could well imagine. He the increase ceased and a slight decline | been indicated. But the increase of beer- drinking has been as steady and seem ingly inevitable as that of population From 1863 to the current year there have been only six years in which set- backs of even a fraction of a gallon oc- curred. In the days when practically untaxed whiskey sold for 25 cents a quart, this was emphatically a whiskey- drinking country. The question is now whether the present changes are to go on until we are to settle down beside Germany as characteristically a beer- drinking nation. The Harvard Overseers having voted their disapproval of the Athletic Com- mittee’s decision to continue football at that institution next fall, the situation at Cambridge is in a worse muddle than ever. Faculty and Overseers, it will be remembered, voted against the game; the Corporation is still to be heard from, and has been holding off with a view to getting the final decision of the Athletic Committee. That body, it seems, failed tc comply with the request of the Over- seers to submit a report on the pro- posed changes in the game, and decided to go counter to the opinion of both Faculty and Overseers. Obviously, Har- vard is suffering from a division of powers, and it would be difficult to forecast what the next step will be The Athletic Committee may persist in its attitude, in which case the Corpora- tion might end the whole controversy by abolishing football outright. The pres- ent condition of affairs contrasts unfa vorably with the clear-cut action of other colleges. Surely, the oldest of American universities ought by this time to have reached a decision and, like Columbia and Northwestern, forbidden the game, or, like Wisconsin, prohibit- ed it for a year. Harvard ought, also, to limit the powers of the Athletic Committee in such a way that it should be incapable of delaying the settlement of broad questions of policy. Curiously enough, the undergraduate members of the committee have generally been more radical and more sensitive to public sen- timent than either the graduate or Fac- ulty members, speaks of Austria as his “brilliant sec ond on the duelling ground.” But this is to imply that there was a deadly com bat, not a free and friendly conference ai Algeciras. It implies also that Ger many was badly beaten. The “brilliant second” and the German principal were repeatedly outvoted; thus, according to the Kaiser's awkward figure of speech Germany must have received several ugly thrusts in the “duel” at Algeciras This is ineontinently to repudiate Prince Biilow’s public statement that the German contentions had been satis factorily upheld. So much for Imperial rushing into print. Some one ought to send the Emperor a copy of Van Buren’s old counsel of political wisdom: “Walk eleven miles rather than write a letter.” In the Kaiser’s case this might advan tageously be amended: “Sail a thousand leagues rather than send a telegram.” Vesuvius will very soon be in politics In fact, the legislative sequel of the eruption may very well outweigh its recent spectacular interest. The destruc tion of entire communes will push thou sands of people over that narrow mat gin which in all Southern Italy separ ates a scanty livelihood from dire dis tress. Successive Parliaments have dealt with this South-Italian question without arriving at a solution. To-day that problem, to which Premier Sonnino has devoted especial study, becomes dou bly acute. These Vesuvian villages are typical of Southern Italy generally Their inhabitants suffer under a griev ous burden of taxation, amounting in the case of small farmers to a full quar tir of annual income Besides the na tional and local taxes, an over-numet ous priesthood takes toll of a supersti tious populace. Of course, the distressed communes will be promptly relieved, both by suspension of taxation and by cirect gifts; but this will only make the burden heavier elsewhere in Calabria and Apulia. In other words, the de |} struction on the Vesuvian plain fur- | tishes the strongest argument for carry ing promptly into effect the benevolent irtentions long expressed towards the “Mezzogiorno.” Tax reform is the moat pressing need, but it is probable that a rather paternalistic programme of pub- lic works anc agricultural improvement will also be instituted, a ne Sethe I zeta et ee digg en mmagir* acces oe Ae ee ten te

Page 12

314 OUR SENTIMENTAL PRESIDENT. Mr. Roosevelt has become a fearsome Socialist a little too suddenly to be en- entirely credible in that guise. He did, indeed, ruin his carefully prepared cor- ner-stone speech on the Man with the Muck Rake by a chance phrase which made him look to the unwary like the Man with the Crowbar, ready to prize over the pillars of society. As a mere in this was deplorable enough. His speech was wholly sacrt- ficed to one interjection. It was much as if the preacher of a temperance ser- mon had wound up by inviting all his hearers to go out and take a drink with lapse taste, him—they would not remember what had gone before. But we cannot our- selves see in the President’s happy- thought proposal to limit private for- tunes the deliberate and formidable po- litical programme which some are read- We have had too many of his impulsive utterances before to be unduly alarmed. His choice of a text from Bunyan should have suggested the true character in which he appeared on Saturday. One of the prototypes of our day whom the inspired tinker “saw in his dream” was Talkative. He thus do- scribed his own function: ing into it “T will talk of things heavenly or things earthly; things moral or things evangeli- cal things sacred or things profane; things past or things to come; things foreign or things at home; things more essential or things circumstantial.”’ Thereupon Christian smiled, and sagely remarked to Faithful: This man with whom you are so taken, will beguile, with this tongue of his, twenty of them that know him not.’ In short, are inclined to think that those who know our Presidential ralkative will not be so much frighten as amused by identifica- tion of his own temporary personal feel- ing with the policy which the nation ought to adopt permanently He has gayly done the same thing many times we ed his latest before It does, indeed, require a cer- tain “pitch of presumption,” as Burke said, for a man to think of his coun- try as merely a plece of white paper which “to seribble whatever he but no one has ever accused President Roosevelt of erring through too great distrust of himself A thing which appears to him overnight as real- ly excellent proposition, becomes ipso facto wise, feasible, Constitutional. So it was with his ready and confident that take over the regulation of life insurance. He thought it ought to be done, and that was dem But the House Ju- diclary Committee felt compelled to look into the laws and Constitution, and then unanimously reported that the Preasl- dent's plan was absolutely unconatitu- tional. Since then he has made haste to “forget it.” So it would be with any upon pleases,”’ an proposal Congress onstration enough other splendid idea which occurred to The Nation. | Vol. 82, No. 2129 him yesterday, and which he will aban- don to-morrow. People are beginning to have a more correct idea of Mr. Roosevelt’s nature. The conception of him, fostered by some indiscreet friends and easily given color Ly his tremendous energy and loud speech, as a man of iron will and slow- ly formed determination and far-reach- ing thought and mature choice of line of action, is breaking down. We know better now what his “spontaneity” implies. His public speech is filled, like his private conversation, with whatever pops into his head. His view of his duties is essentially jovial. He loves to slap the country on the back with a “bright” thought, just as he delights to startle a foreign visitor by wild and whirling words that make the hair of the timid stand on end. He means no mischief by it. It is time we understood that it is sen- timent which predominates in the Pres- idential character. He has a surge of feeling; this he immediately translates into what he calls a “personal convic- tion”; then he identifies that with true public policy. No one should imagine, however, that he has given real thought to the matter, or that he will not drop it as hastily as he took it up. In a word, he seems to belong to what Cobden call- ed the “genus sentimentalist.” Of pub- lic men in that class he said: “‘They are not to be depended on in political action, Leecause they are not masters of their own reasoning powers. They sing songs or declaim about truth, justice, liberty, and the like, but It is only in the same artificial spirit in which they made odes to dewdrops, daisies, etc. They are just as likely to trample on one as the other, notwithstanding.” Yet this, the most charitable explana- tion of the President’s vagaries, does not diminish the regret and disquiet which his unconsidered deliverance on Saturday must cause. The very fact that, as he confessed, he had not thought out a single detail of his proposal to fix a limit beyond which private wealth should not go, and that he is absolutely without the Governmental means to ef- fect that purpose, makes his rash utter- ance a serious discredit to him. It is too much like a boy wantonly thrusting a stick into a delicate machine. A truly responsible statesman, urging such a revolutionary proposition, would come forward as if with a halter round his neck, and request that it be drawn if he could not show that a law could be drafted to carry out his ideas. But what giimmering of a suggestion did Mr. Roosevelt make about his “progressive tax on all fortunes,” to be laid by the national Government, with the end of keeping them within “healthy limits’? An inheritance tax would not do the business. Besides conflicting with State taxes of that kind, and leading to the grossest injustice, it would not accom- plish the purpose at which the Presi- dent professes to aim. He himself, for example, is said to have inherited some- thing like $500,000. Of course, to a thor- ough-going Socialist that would be a thoroughly “unhealthy” fortune; but suppose that a Federal inheritance tax could be devised which would forbid any one from coming into a greater amount than that. It is clear that a man of Mr. Roosevelt’s energy and abil- ity, inheriting $500,000 at thirty-five, could double or treble his fortune before he died. So the only way of keeping him “healthy” would be a progressive income tax which would take all above $500,000. But here comes in the vexing trifle that the income tax has been de- clared unconstitutional. We do not expect any terrible results from the President’s happy-go-lucky re- mark about a subject to which, it is plain, he has given no serious thought. It will be a mortification to his friends, and a real public misfortune, that his mouthing has made Bryan appear a re- actionary, Hearst a conservative, and has elevated Debs and Powderly to the level of Presidential statesmanship. But our laws, the Constitution, the inertia of our institutions, the common sense of the people, the ineradicable tenden- cies of human nature itself, may still be trusted as against either demagogues or improvisators. SHAW AND GOLD IM- PORTS. Before passing judgment on Secre- tary Shaw’s announcement regarding his use of Government money to “facilitate” gold imports from Europe, it will be best to make perfectly clear three points— what the situation was which prompted such a decision, what the law is under which his action is taken, and what its effect on the markets is likely to be. It is well known, in the first place, that the strain on our money markets this season has been abnormally great. The usual recourse is heavy borrowing from foreign markets. If this movement is large enough, New York exchange on London falls to a point where gold from abroad can be profitably imported. This is what happened last week; in response to the fall in exchange to the “gold point,” gold was engaged for New York in London. ‘With a decline in money rates, however, exchange on London last Thursday rose again to a price which, by general agreement of foreign bank- ers, rendered further gold imports un- profitable. This was the moment chosen by the Secretary to use the Government surplus to facilitate imports. In the words of Mr. Shaw’s own announcement, “the price of exchange having reached the point where gold ought to have been imported, SECRETARY

Page 13

ore April 19, 1906] and believing the reason why it was not engaged to be the loss of its use dur- ing transit,” the Treasury notified banks holding public money that it was will- Ing “to increase the deposit to any amount when assured that the money would be immediately used in the en- gagement of gold for shipment to the United States,” and that, as security for these new deposits, “bonds available as security to savings banks” would be ac- cepted. What the Secretary means by “loss of use in transit” is that a banker, engaging, say, $1,000,000 gold in Lon- don for import to New York, must fore- go the interest on that sum during the week when the gold is on the ocean. By making a special seven-day loan of pub- lic money to the banks—this is what the Secretary’s plan really amounts to —the cost of importing gold is reduced by precisely the sum of “interest dur- ‘ing transit.” With such allowance, gold could be profitably imported by a bank without waiting for sterling exchange to fall to the normal “gold point.” It should be clear, then, that Mr. Shaw’s arrangement is an interference of the Government with the market. Had the Secretary merely announced that the Treasury was again absorbing the market’s money supplies through a surplus revenue, and that therefore pub- lic deposits in banks were to be in- creased, the action would have followed precedent. That this was not the pri- mary purpose of last week’s step is shown by the conditions laid down by Mr. Shaw. Deposits will be increased only “‘when assured that the money will be immediately used’ for gold import purposes, and, furthermore, it must “be returned immediately on the arrival of the gold.”” As a matter of fact, the ex- cuse of Treasury absorption of money did not exist last week. Since March 1, the surplus revenue has been $4,600,000; but, in the same period, public deposits in banks have been increased $12,000,- 000. The fact, however, that the Sec- retary explicitly provides that the bank must pay back the Treasury money when the gold arrives, shows that he is not thinking of the Treasury drain at all. Under what warrant does the Secre- tary make this unusual arrangement? The Federal law undoubtedly gives rather broad powers in the matter. Its stipulation is that the Treasury shall require banks holding public funds “to give satisfactory security, by the de- posit of United States bonds and other- wise”; beyond this it states that they “shall be depositaries of public money, except receipts from customs, under such regulations as may be prescribed by the Secretary.” It is a somewhat violent construction of this clause to regard the supplying of Government funds to invest in gold imports as with- in the meaning of the “regulations” re- ferred to, yet we suppose that construc- The Nation. tion to be the Secretary's recourse. But something more is involved than the letter of the law. The use of Govern- ment money, avowedly to influence a financial market with whose movement the Treasury is not itself concerned, 13 something new. Government bond re- demptions, Government bank deposits, and “anticipation” of Treasury inter- ests are expedients which have been adopted repeatedly in times of money stringency; but always on the ground, most carefully set forth, that excessive surplus revenue had caused the trouble. It is true, also, that Government credit has been employed, as in 1895, to en- able bankers not only to influence but to control the foreign exchanges and the flow of gold. But President Cleveland's “Government-bond-syndicate contract” was a measure adopted to rescue the Treasury itself from a “run” which threatened suspension of Government gold payments—which is a very dif- ferent thing from using public money to reduce the normal cost of a banker’s private operations. Our own judgment is that this extra- ordinary move by the Secretary is whol- ly unjustified by the law or the circum- stances. We further think that it will be futile—if indeed it do not further complicate an already tangled money situation. It cannot be properly com- pared with the occasional offer of “in- terest in transit’’ by the Bank of France or the Bank of Germany. Such offers have been made by banks, not by a Gov- ernment, and made because banks saw a profit in the operation. Furthermore, it is questionable whether such an offer, in any market, ever actually caused gold imports. With gold going out from London or New York, it is easy to un- derstand why “allowance of interest in transit” by the French Bank might draw all the exports to Paris rather than to Berlin. But the special inducement’ would not have caused the shipment; that is an old and exploded delusion very current in Wall Street during 1892 and 1893, and which we are sorry to see the present Secretary share. All that. this very remarkable Government interference has accomplished, so far as concerns the market of the day, is slightly to alter the “gold-import point,” as Mr. Sherman, in 1892, altered the “gold export point” by raising the ex- port tax on bullion. Mr. Sherman thought, apparently, that his plan would stop gold exports by making them more expensive, just as Mr. Shaw seems to think that he can cause gold imports by making them cheaper. Both ideas are pure economic delusion. That the ef- fort to further so hare-brained a scheme should have been made through a high- ly questionable use of the public moneys, does not help the matter. 315 RURAL CORRUPT PRACTICES. It is generally agreed by those who have worked hardest and longest at Al- bany this year to secure the passage of a corrupt-practices act, that the strong est opposition has come from country members of the Legislature. The bill went up with an impressive backing from this city. Other large centres of population in the State were at least ready to give their assent. There would have been no great difficulty about get- ting the delegations from “corrupt cit- ies” like Buffalo and New York to sup- port the measure, but the pure-minded representatives from the innocent rural regions were the ones who got in the way. They first amended the bill so as to make it as ineffective as possibile; and then proceeded to dilly-dally over it until there is now admitted to be grave doubt whether the act in any form can be got from the present Legislature. The country Senators and Assembly- men who object to a law more stringent- lv controlling the outlay of money in elections, and calling for complete pub- licity of the accounts of party commit- tees, do not, when you press them, con- ceal their motives. Behind their assum- ed legal scruples and doubts on the ground of public policy, lies an intimate acquaintance with the way in which par- ty primaries are carried and elections won in the sparsely settled districts of the State. There the cost is, we believe, much greater per voter than in the cit- ies. It is not charged that direct cor- ruption is resorted to on any great scale: but there are countless methods of indirect bribery. Old Bill Jones of Stony Hill Road cannot really be ex pected to get to the polls unless paid for the wear and tear of his team. If he brings his hired man along, that neces- sarily means $5 more. And if he stops on the way to pick up half-a-dozen friends, why, he and they must have at least what the economists call the “re- wards of abstinence.” They have ab- stained from earning $100 on their farms, and naturally should, in all fair- ness, have it made up to them. The habit spreads all through the district, and is clearly one of the most expensive habits known to politicians. The amount of money which it is cunsidered abso- lutely “necessary” to put out among country people in a political campaign is notoriously large. The debauchery of the hill towns of Connecticut, by such means, has been made the subject of careful study. Investigators in darkest New York, meaning thereby the sweet, clean, unsophisticated villages and farms, would find material as unplea- santly instructive. We have at hand a slight unveiling of conditions in Putnam County. A con- test for control within the Republican party has been going on there, the rivals being Assemblyman Yale and “the Ray Ne Sen sw A — LO tn gn ee ee aie wh Feta in

Page 14

B16 friends of the Hon. Hamilton Fish.” Put- nam County has, of course, long been a sort of preserve of the Fish family, and the effort to wrest it away could not be other than arduous, spectacular, and costly. Many picturesque details are given in the Putnam County Courier, published at Carmel, of April 6. From Ludingtonville, for example, came an account of the Republican caucus of March 31. The Yale men beat the Fish men by 104 to 49. This was not bad— if3 votes when the registry showed a total of but 163 voters in a district which the Democrats carried last fall. Some of The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2129 which the provisions of the corrupt- practices bill are read at Albany, since the contested country primary is not | very different from the country election. the forcing methods used to make two | Republicans grow in the caucus where | only one grew in the election, are sug gested in the following: “Tt is estimated that over $5,000 was paid directly to the voters, and that, with the preliminary expenses, over $6,000 was expended. The successful faction paid $40 per vote, and the losers averaged about $16. We hear of one family of four voters who were paid $200, and the Fish faction in some cases is said to have offered as high as $20 for a vote.” It was, however, at Adams Corner on April 2 that the hottest contest was wag ed. The Courier’s correspondent waxed enthusiastic in his account of the mag- nificent political strategy displayed and the glorious fighting witnessed. An ex- pert Republican politician from Peeks- kill was on the ground to see what he could learn of skilled caucus-packing, and “spoke in the most favorable terms of the impression he had received.” It was hoped that Mr. Fish would be at the scene in person to cheer on his Section 203, for example, provides that “every political committee shall have a treasurer, and shall cause him to keep detailed accounts of all money or its equivalent received by or promised to, and of all expenditures, disbursements, and promises of payment or disburse- ment made by the committee or any of its officers or members, or by any person acting under its authority or in its be- half.” Imagine that put in force in Putnam County! A PROBLEM OF ADMINISTRATION, NOT RACE. In his suggestive essay on “Race Questions and Prejudices,” in the cur- rent International Journal of Ethics, Prof. Josiah Royce discusses with great ability and charm a question which for Americans daily becomes of larger and larger import. No one can hereafter claim to be an authority on race antag- onisms unless he has acquainted himself with this scientific and masterly treat- ment of the subject. Here is the college investigator at his best, for Professor Royce has obviously written without prejudice and solely with the desire to establish certain truths. But he has not contented himself with theoretical stud- ies; a part of his paper rests upon per- sonal observations of the relations of whites and blacks in the West Indies. Professor Royce’s intimation that the race problem is a misnomer for a diffi- culty of quite another character, of it- self throws light. Neither in Trinidad | nor in Jamaica did he discover what is followers, but “at the very last moment he telegraphed that, it beng Monday, | his busy day at the Sub-Treasury, it would be impossible for him to be pres- ent Yet Deputy Collector of Interna! Revenue Donohoe was presert “in the interest of Mr. Fish,” and “paid strict attention. ’ Democrats as well as Re- publicans were “lined up on either side,” so that, “in looking the crowd over, one could not be sure whether it was a R publican or a Democratic caucus that had been called.” But all knew why the gathering was so large. Farmers’ wag ons were never so thick, and as much as $50 was said to have been paid for a lift When the vote were finally counted, the score stood: Yale 127, Fish 122 Thus the Yale faction appeared tv be winning, and the Courier’s know ing correspondent remarks “It will be necessary for six to change the!r minds in the convention in order for Mr. Fish to win. Can Mr. Fish manage so many? Hile friends believe he will.” It is but right to add that the Courier Hence its zeal in exposing the corruption of the la a Democratic newspaper. other fellow may have made its de tails too precis« jut the main out- lines of the picture, with its life-like rendering of the very atmosphere, are drawn with a veracious pencil. It heips us to understand the holy horror with known as our Southern problem. There are no mobs there and no bitter antag- onisms. There are other topics of con- versation than the negro; the whole economic and political life of the islands does not revolve around him. The ques- tion of intermarriage between blacks and whites is not the final outcome of every conversation dealing with the fu- ture of the islands. Your white West Indian would be astounded to read such an indictment as a Southern white man presents against his own section in the current South Atlantic Quarterly. The Rev. John E. White there declares that the source of the South’s “past and pres- ent weakness” was and is “the absorp- tion of the Southern thonght by one sin- gle issue—the question of the negro.” The Jamaica race question, Professor Royce reports, was solved “by the sim- plest means in the world, viz., by Eng- lish administration and by English reti- cence,” and in this he confirms the view of an English colonial official, as ex- pressed last year in the International Quarterly. When once the sad period of emancipation with its consequent dis- order had passed, the Englishman or- ganized Jamaica, established good courts which by fair treatment gained the con- fidence of the blacks, and then trained negroes to police the other negroes un- der white direction. The courts dealt with the too forward and litigious negro by encouraging him to alr his griev- ances in court and by punishing him moderately when he deserved it. This, says Professor Royce, is a “truly Eng- lish type of social pedagogy,” which makes of the negro a “conscious helper towards good social order.” But administration did not stop there. It filled the island with good roads, re- duced tropical diseases to a minimum, established a civil service for which in due time black men qualified, taught the population loyalty and order, and help- ed them “up from slavery.” In this work, reticence played a great part: the superior did not dwell upon his supe- riority nor the other’s inferiority; “su- periority is best shown by good deeds and by few boasts.” Moreover, there was an absence of certain irritating and annoying customs familiar to our South. Legal hanging is regarded as more de- sirable than lynching; there are no at- tempts to “make an example” by burn- ing up a negro quarter as at Springfield, Ohio; and black women are not regard- ed as deserving of abominable violence because of mere relationship to an al- leged murderer, as has happened in Mis- sissippi and elsewhere. In short, the law takes its course, and the population remains calm. All this leads Professor Royce to say to the Southerner: “The problem that endangers the sanc- tity of your homes and that is said some- times to make lynching a necessity, is not arace-problem. It is an administrative problem. You have never organized a country constabulary. Hence, when various social conditions, amongst which the habit of irritating public speech about race- questions is indeed one, though only one condition, have tended to the producing and to the arousing of extremely danger- ous criminals in your communities, you have no adequate means of guarding against the danger. , If you insist that in some districts the white popula- tion is too sparse or too poor, or both, to furnish an efficient country constabulary constantly on duty, why, then, have you not long since trained black men to po lice black men? Sympathy with the law grows with responsibility for its adminis- tration. If it is revolting to you to see black men possessed with the authority of a country constabulary, still, if you will, you can limit their authority to a control over their own race.” Whether it would thus be possible to limit the powers of a colored constabu- lary is open to question. But the record of the American negroes in the army of the United States, under both colored and white officers, makes it perfectly plain that they can be trained to be obedient, faithful, and _ self-restrained servants of the law. At Tuskegee the spirit of discipline inculeated by color- ed teachers is the school’s most remark- able exhibit. We have long maintain- ed that, in view of all the conditions Nee ee ee) et ee ee eee See

Page 15

eee ne ee eee ee April 19, 1906] in the South, his own ignorance, and his terrible heritage from slavery, the negro is singularly docile, singularly law-abiding. That he is wholly without that desire to use a knife or revolver so characteristic of the Italian and the Greek, is creditable to him, and a great piece of good fortune for the country. We shall not dwell further on the contrast between Jamaican and South- ern administrative conditions, save to speak of affairs in Louisville. Its citi- zens complain that the negroes are a menace, and that they are retrograding. Yet they do next to nothing to elevate them, while setting the worst possible example of bad government before them. As if this were not enough, the city is without modern housing or sanitary laws, and the negroes are crowded into cellars or abandoned stables—precisely the conditions for a high death-rate and for a low morality. Here English ad- ministrative methods would work a rev- olution, if only because the best whites would coéperate with the best blacks even if they did not eat with them. Truly, Professor Royce is correct. Too | many Americans, North and South, | “view as a fatal and overwhelming race- problem what is a perfectly curable ac- cident of our present form of adminis- tration”; and this is as true in the slums of New York as in the desolate stretches of Mississippi or Arkansas. DECORATIVE ARTS IN AMERICA. An English architect visiting among us has made some stir by pointing out the low estate of decoration in America. His criticism touched particularly upon the uninteresting and stereotyped na- ture of our designs for furniture, and upon the inappropriateness of our arch- itectural ornamentation. A number of local decorators and mural painters who commented on these strictures, agreed in the main. A movement in the National Arts Club to found a school of fine craftsmanship shows a feeling that all is not well in this field. The Di- rector of the Metropolitan Museum un- doubtedly feels that he is acting as a missionary in partibus when he brings over specimens of fine wood-carving and copies of old interiors. A certain un- easiness on the topic is periodically ex- pressed. Our fathers and mothers hoped to be saved esthetically by installing “Eastlake” chairs—uncommonly uncom- fortable they were to sit or look upon— and we ourselves are only gradually escaping the domination of “Mission” carpentry and “fumed” woodwork. In the matter of furniture and interior decoration, we have never fully recov- ered from the hideousness of the deca- dent Empire style, and the even worse anarchy that prevailed through the six- ties and seventies, One has only to ob- serve the woodwork of the houses built The Nation. in the forties or earlier to perceive that then a standard of taste, narrow, to be sure, but cultivated and intelligent, still ship which, if by no means inventive, was at least competent. A comparison of a very humble interior of that period with those of to-day would show that we have passed from intelligent adapta- tion of two closely related styles—the so-called Georgian and the early Empire —to haphazard and lifeless copying of all the historic styles. From this point of view, the unenterprising devotion of the Louis XVI. style has at least the merit of being a protest against the rul- ing flabby eclecticism. It may be that a nish a basis for future invention. All along the line is displayed the same incapacity for the simpler elemen- tary forms of design. The best mural painting of our artists is set up amid rmuachine-made decoration, usually of the most inappropriate sort. Unhappily, the average mural painter is incapable of designing the simplest arabesque for himself; both he and his architects are reduced to selecting a border or mould- ing from the books, which is coldly cop- ied by a mediocre craftsman. Those art- ists who, like Mr. La Farge, have re- belled against this condition. and have sought to attain an harmonious setting for their wall paintings, have struggled against practically insurmountable diffi- culties. In external decoration for arch- itecture the case is the same. How rare- ly is the eye pleased by a bit of truly in- ventive design like the facade of the New York Yacht Club, or even by well- executed and effectively distributed or- nament, such as one finds in the new Madison Square Church. Henry James, in his recent analytical ejaculations upon transformed New York, finds the particular root of the evil in the checkerboard skyscraper. When a building must consist of the greatest possible amount of rentable window space, he asks, Where is the place for beautiful design or incidental ornament? This seems to lay upon a particular form of speculative building the blame that should fall upon the pub- lic taste generally. One should con- demn not the thrift that insists on these steel and glass houses, but the vanity on the owner’s part and the hurry on the architect's, which fill these vast wall spaces with superfluous and ineffective ornament, Would that more architects might take the time not to decorate! That might force some study of the ac- tual problem of design, and might lead, along the line of color, perhaps, at least to skilful evasion of the present sieve- like effects. The real responsibility for the fallen estate of decorative art among us must be sought in the undue contempt in 817 which it is held by artists and the artist- existed, and was served by a craftsman- | } our handful of Beaux-Arts architects to | scholarly revival of one style will fur- | ic minority, and in the general absence of taste among the newly-rich classes. This scorn of applied design on the part of the artistic is eminently provincial and bespeaks a limitation. The best artists of the Renaissance were willing to decorate furniture, design frames, or undertake an entire interior. They passed readily from painting to sculpture and architecture. Raphael and his school evidently took a keen delight in the invention of arabesque patterns. Even in the eighteenth century, the cul- mination of academic ideals, nobody seems to have thought it was infra dig. for Clodion and Falconnet to apply their exquisite sculpture to the adornment of furniture and clocks. Condemned by the | professional artist and misunderstood by its best patrons, decorative design either has fallen into commercial hands, or has fared worse in the keeping of an army of ill-trained amateurs. Mr. La Farge has invented the beautiful art of painting in opalescent glass, only to see it commercially vulgarized in his own lifetime. In architectural bronze work and iron work alone can one discern a promising condition. Meanwhile eager amateurs here and there glaze pots which they have bought in open market, painfully imitate colonial needlework, bind books in unhandy fashion, set stones in random collocations of precious metals, or otherwise illustrate the inep- titude of the individual when unsustain- ed by an artistic tradition. The remedy will come, we believe, not by direct effort, but by the education of the wealthy classes into something like taste. To syndicate a regiment of un- der-trained and craftsmen into a school would merely increase the output of bad and eccentric craftsmanship. On the other hand, the moment that our rich men and our rul- ers who have the say in public building, learn to know good design from bad, good design will follow their demand. The growth of museums and the indis- criminate collecting that is going on should further this process of education. The possessor of a single piece of fine wood-carving should gradually come to see the inferiority of those poor excerpts from French chateaux and Italian pal- aces with which his mansion is decorat- ed, It should not forever be possible to live with the best Persian carpets and the finest tapestries of Flanders and France and tolerate the kind of wall and floor covering that our commercial dec- orators affect. One may at least hope something from the generation of priv- ileged children that is growing up amid a mixture of the best and the worst dec- oration. A child’s taste is usuaily sin- gularly sensitive and correct, and de- spondent @sthetes among us may fair- ly take this comfort, that, if we are in worse state than our grandfathers, we have at least emerged from our fathers’ over-individualized ° Sen. jeer Mayenne wy fo Som

Page 16

318 The Nation. [ Vol. 82, No. 2129 complacent acquiescence in ugliness. Our children may actually rise to the conception that an identical merit ob- tains in a fine mural painting and a fine door escutcheon, that the makers of both are artists, and that a keen appreciation of the minor arts is the surest guaran- tee of a healthful condition in the fine arts. NATHANIEL SOUTHGATE SHALER. Dean Shaler died at his home in Cam- The fluctyations of his bridge on April 10 than a last illness, extending over more fortnight, were followed with intense anxiety, not merely in Cambridge, but throughout the community Among Har- vard students and graduates he enjoyed a unique popularity. By a common impulse, the flags on the students’ clubs and on the city buildings were hung at half-mast; and on the afternoon of his funeral the shops in Old Cambridge were closed—a tribute which, during the past generation, no other Harvard professor has had In his death the Nation likewise mourns an old friend and contributor. His first re- view, on “Volcanoes and Earthquakes,” was printed in 1869, in the eighth volume of this journal, and he continued on its ac- tive staff of reviewers until 1898. Professor Shaler was born near Newport, Ky., on February 20, 1841. His people had migrated from England to the West In- dies, and thence to New York State. His great-uncle, William Shaler, was appoint- ed in 1815 by President Madison consul- general to the Barbary States, with dence at Algiers, where, in concert with Commodore Decatur, he negotiated the peace that put an end to Algerine piracy on American commerce. His father, Nathan- lel Burger Shaler, after graduating from Harvard College in 1827 and from the Med- leal School two years later, spent some time in Jamaica, then settled in Kentucky, and came to hold an honored place among the physicians of his section. He married into the Southgate family, which had crossed the mountains from Virginia. Thus, in stock and antecedents, the future scien- tist had a fortunate inheritance. His early education he received from a tutor, a learned German named Escher, who taught him the humanities, discussed philosophy with him, and fostered his insatiable appe- tite for reading. His father encouraged his taste for natural history In 1859 the youth was sent to Harvard, where he enrolled himself in the Lawrence Scientific School, and very soon attracted whether by his hearty and down- right manner or by his quick, keen, and versatile mind. He pursued the course in zoblogy, did special work with Louis Agas- siz, and graduated Bachelor of Science in 1862. Not waiting for Commencement, Mr. Shaler hurried to Kentucky, enlisted in the Federal army, and was commissioned captain of the Fifth Kentucky Battery, which came to be known as “Shaler’s,” and resi- notice, during the next two years he saw active service, for the most part in his native State At one time he was on Tillson’s staff, at another he was chief of artillery for fortifications under Burnside; at Perry- ville, in 1862, he helped to repulse Bragg’s invasion, and in 1863 his command was sent to intercept Morgan's raid into Ohio. The military experience, besides giv- ing him wide human contacts, taught him self-discipline. The impress of it made one feel, in later years, that behind the delightful talker, with his flashes of daz- zling speculation, was the man of action, who had looked danger in the face. Broken in health, he resigned from the army in 1864, and returned to Cambridge, where he received an appointment as in- structor in Paleontology, and in 1869, at what even then was an unusually early age, he was promoted full professor. This chair he held continuously till his death, its title after 1888 being changed to Geology. As he was one of the first American men of science to accept evolution, it required courage in him to interpret that doctrine under the very eyes of Louis Agassiz, who still adhered to the old cosmogony; but he had tact as well as courage, and his rela- tions with the then “pope” of American science remained untroubled. After Agas- siz’s death in 1873, Mr. Shaler had a free hand at the Museum, where, needless to say, Darwinism speedily prevailed. In 1891, on the resignation of Prof. W. S. Chaplin, he became Dean of the Lawrence Scientific School, which, under his direc- tion, has grown rapidly in numbers, and, what is of real consequence, in efficiency It was Dean Shaler who, in 1893, brought Prof. I. N. Hollis to Harvard to take charge of the Department of Engineering; he plan- ned the metallurgical instruction, which 1s already second to none in America; and he has been largely responsible for the improvement in the intellectual standard and moral character of the members of the School. The last months of his life were devoted to the organization of the Gradu- ate School of Applied Science, an object long in his mind, and at length made pos3- sible through the magnificent bequest which, at his suggestion, the late Gordon McKay left to Harvard. But while Mr. Shaler in these and other ways stamped his influence on the struc- tural growth of the University, it was not as an able administrator that forty class- es of Harvard students knew him best; it was as a lecturer of unique qifts and as a friend that he stirred their interest and kindled their admiration and affection. He gave a course in geology, knowr as “Natural History 4," which became the most popular of any at Harvard, frequented by so large a proportion of undergraluates that in the space of a generation it attract- ed more than seven thousand of them into his lecture-room. There they found a thin, wiry man, somewhat under six feet in stat- ure, but erect, quick of gesture, with a great mass of tawny hair brushed German- fashion away from his forehead, a tawny beard, a long, prominent nose, aad pale blue eyes, which had, on occasion, now a penetrating flash, now a humorous twinkle. This was Shaler, and, as soon as lie began to lecture, his hearers discovered that he was unlike every one else they had ever heard. He poured out a stream of wonder- ful entertainment; science, anecdote, wit, humor, reminiscence, pertinent illustration, or mirthful aside, followed each other in sparkling sequence. He used a wholly in- dividual language, strong, vivid, pie- turesque, with plenty of simple Saxon raci- ness, and, at need, he coined fantastic but expressive words, or drew from the Shak- sperian vocabulary. His laugh, which had many stops, was the laugh of the wan of humor, and often confirmed or carried for- ward his meaning. He alone knew with how large a number of students he came into personal relations, how mary he help- ed with advice or money, how many he found positions for after they Isit college. If any was sick, Mr. Shaler mad+ straight for his room or the hospital, to see that everything was done for him. But Mr. Shaler’s popular lectures, and his personal friendly oversight of hundreds of students, consumed only a part of his time. He always conducted one or more advanced courses in palwontology, and during the past fifteen years he had shouldered the growing responsibilities of his deanship. He also directed the Summer School, which, in fact, grew out of his practice, early in the seventies, of offering in- struction to volunteer students during the long vacation. Still, these various services to Harvard did not exhaust his energy. Appointed in 1872 Director of the State Geological Survey of Kentucky, he held that post for seven years. From 1884 to 1900 he was geologist in charge of the Atlantic Division of the United States Coast Sur- vey. As a geological expert, his advice was sought by some of the largest mining enter- prises in the country. At different times he was a member of Massachusetts commis- sions on highways, agriculture, and the ex- termination of the gypsy moth. As if this were not enough, he took part in local po- litical matters, to the extent at least of aiding in the election of proper candidates, and he expressed himself freely on national issues. Mr. Shaler began to print early, and be- fore his death he had brought out twenty- five or thirty volumes, besides unnumbered magazine articles and scientific papers. His books illustrate the breadth of his in- terests. In science, for instance, there are a geological manual, ‘The Story of Our Continent,’ ‘The Interpretation of Nature,’ ‘Illustrations of the Earth's Surface,’ ‘Fossil Brachiopods of the Ohio Valley,’ ‘Features of Coasts and Oceans,’ ‘Ameri- can Highways,’ and ‘Domesticated Ani- mals.’ To history belongs the volume on Kentucky in the “American Common- wealths” series. “The United States of America’ gives an encyclopedic survey of the physical and material elements of the republic. In quite a different class fall four books which have appeared in the past five years—‘The Individual: A Study of Life and Death,’ ‘The Citizen,’ ‘The Neigh- bor,’ and ‘Man and the Earth.’ These pre- sent in clear and often striking language what we may call Mr. Shaler’s philosophy, his final views on the relations of the in- dividual with the infinite, on his political and civic contacts, and on his social and human ties, with an examination, half- scientific, half-prophetic, of man’s prob- able destiny on the earth. Only a critic endowed with Mr. Shaler’s versatility could pass an intelligent opinion on this great body of work; but even an unscientific reader cannot fail to do justice to the Shaleresque qualities of these later vol- umes, so rich in suggestion, so stimulating, so alert, and so human. A few years ago, Professor Shaler surprised his associates and the reading public by publishing at a single volley five dramas under the

Page 17

April 19, 1906] The Nation. 319 general title ‘Elizabeth of England.’ He undertook their composition to disprove the assertion of one of his colleagues that the pursuit of science destroys the poetic imagination. These plays certainly show 1 that in his case the imaginative faculty never languished, and they are much more than a mere tour de force. After all, it is the great university fig- ure whose passing we deplore. By his many talents and his ceaseless industry, wedded to a large, helpful nature, he showed that the calling of a university professor has the noblest possibilities; he humanized it. There is the constant danger | that the drudge, the bookworm, the nar- row specialist, shall bring learning into disrepute by divorcing it from life; it was Mr. Shaler’s distinction to prove by his example that a professor may touch life on all sides, carrying to the world the dis- interestedness of the university, taking to the university the higher practicalness and vitality of the world, and teaching both that that is the true learning which most enriches life and best reveals ‘‘come l'uomo s’eterna.” ON INDIA'S FRONTIER. i PESHAWAR, February 2, 1906. In these days when the Amir of Afghan- istan so rigorously excludes all white men from his dominions, there is to the travel- ler a certain satisfaction in obtaining at least a glimpse of his borders; and when such a glimpse combines a visit to Pesha- war and the historic Khaibar Pass near by, a trip to the northwest frontier of India proves to be well worth while. Peshawar itself is reached from Delhi by a journey of thirty-six hours in the train northwards through the Punjab. It is a city with a distinctly northern atmosphere, and, though anything but beautiful in itself, 4 has a decided attraction in its inhabitants, 4 who are for the most part tall, strapping Afghans, clad in dirty white shawls and fantastically wound turbans. They have , very light skins and fierce, bearded faces. From their general lawless, if not des- perate, appearance we can understand that in entering the native city after dark, an Englishman takes his life in his hands, if | he does not actually throw it away. Ten miles to the west rises a chain of mountains, part of the system of natural barriers which shut off India from Central Asia, but at this very point pierced by the famous Khaibar Pass, through which from time immemorial, from Alexander to Tam- P erlane, ambitious conquerors have led t their invading armies. The pass, which is some thirty miles long and extends across the strip of No Man’s Country dividing India from Afghanistan, is in charge of an English officer, called the political agent of the Khaibar, and is fortified by several blockhouse posts, mounted at intervals on the hillsides so as to command the road below. Three quarters of the way through the pass the English have their furthest post, a strong fort called Landi Kotal, garrisoned by several hundred native troops. Six miles further on, the moun- tains end, and a broad valley marks the beginning of Afghan territory. There are probably few more unsafe re- gions in the world than this Afghan bor- derland. Th unruly mountain tribes, who a ee live practically in a state of anarchy, have for generations spent their lives in raid- ing villages, robbing caravans, and quar- reliing among themselves As a result they are recklessly bloodthirsty, fighters first and foremost, holding life appallingly cheap. Thus the Khaibar Pass is closed, except on Tuesdays and Fridays, when the hills on both sides are heavily picketed On these days native caravans toll through the defile escorted by squads of native troops. It seems rather cur.ous that these troops should be recruited from the same Afridi villages, and even families, whose warriors are likely to murder passers- through, but the English could not with safety employ other races of Sepoys in such a hostile neighborhood. At the same time internal warfare is so common among the Afridis themselves that they see nothing unnatural in having a son in the English service shoot his own father or brothers who are engaged in some predatory raid Ordinarily tourists and even British of- ficers are not allowed in the pass as far as Landi Kotal, but have to be content with the bit extending to Ali Masjid. Fortu- nately, however, we secured the necessary “special permission’ to proceed to Landi Kotal, and, armed with a note in Hindus- tani to that effect, we set out early one gray morning in a_ two-wheeled tonga, drawn by a pair of swift ponies. Quickly outside of Peshawar, we raced for an hour over a bare level plain towards the moun- tains. Then we passed Fort Jumrud, a post connected with Peshawar by a military railroad, and in a few minutes were in the mouth of the pass, ascending the winding and twisting road (also military) which the English have carefully built from one end of the pass to the other. Another hour among the mountaifs brought us to Ali Masjid, where we dismounted to present our pass, while the driver found a relay of ponies. On this Friday we found starting on its way to Kabul a large caravan of camels, huge, awkward, shambling beasts laden with heavy packs, accompanied by a number of ragged, uncouth drivers on foot, and escorted by a guard of “Khaibar Rifles,” the regiment of Afridi troops sta- tioned at Landi Kotal which pickets the pass—against its own relatives. Soon distancing the slow-moving caravan, we found that the chief interest of the day was about to begin, for a few miles be- yond Ali Masjid, we came upon our first Afridi villages, square, mud-walled forts, some of them strengthened by tall mud towers pierced with narrow slits for rifles. From now on, the road, passing through a widening valley, led past several score of these unique communities, each resembling an isolated stronghold. They are in the nature of family dwellings, containing from fifteen to forty inhabitants, and cover on an average perhaps half an acre of ground. The enclosures give one the im- pression that each Afridi is at war with his neighbor, and that is not far from the truth, for life among these people is any- thing but tranquil. The pass is wide enough at this point to allow of a certain amount of agriculture, by which they find means of subsistence. But their fighting qualities are predominant, and the distin- guishing institutions among the Afridis is the blood feud. It is in this that we find the explanation of their fortified homes. Since the Afridis cannot always unite in slaying common foes, their blood thirsty instincts find expression in the system of hereditary feuds, tribe against tribe, section against section, sub section against subsection, down to family against family The whole thing, with its complicated code of etiquette, presents a maze of quarrels, murders, and revenges far too perplexing for a Western mind to grasp, and entails a familiarity with fam) ly pedigrees, histories, and relationships for generations back, quite bewildering to any but these spirited Mobummedans—for they are Mohammedans, and, though thei: religion does not prevent blood feuds, it regulates to some extent their prosecution Truces, often of months, are declared at times of religious festivals, marriages, and the like; and a truce may be declared at any time when both parties are willing An elaborate code of etiquette, scrupu lously observed and rarely broken, is per haps the strangest feature of the feud sys tem For instance, the Government road is held to be neutral ground, and no man will harm his bitterest enemy on this high way. Upon this the English insist; other wise, as far as the authorities are con cerned, the murdering goes on unheeded Accordingly, many of the houses near the road are connected with it by deep trenches protected by stone walls, by which houss holders may reach neutral territory with out exposing themselves to the fire of their neighbors, who may be sitting, rifle in hand, in their towers near by. Another condition of neutrality recognized by etl quette is that of service in the British forces Hence, as many of the Afridis spend a part of the year in the ranks, two men at deadly feud will serve in the same company as Losom friends. Then, as soon as their uniforms are off, they return to their native village and shoot each other at sight. At the present moment two im portant natives at feud have made a truce in order to undertake in partnershiv a Government contract for a road When the road is finished and the rupees ars divided, they will be once more marks for each other’s rifles. All the people in the pass on one side of the road are at feud with those on the other. Of course, for the most part, such big tribal feuds by mutual consent are allowed to lag, what with truces and festivals, and only the bitterest private feuds are prosecuted without ces sation. Thus two families may wage vio lent war though their respective sections or tribes are at truce. In the most vehe ment enmities, where there can be no truce it is a case of war to the knife; one of the families is ultimately exterminated, includ ing the women and children down to the last family dog or chicken. According to the authorities, there have been about ten “casualties” in the last four or five months, besides some indiscriminate ‘“‘popping.” Passing by the Afridi houses—each one of which might well be called its possess- or’s “castle’—we approach the large fort at Landi Kotal, where we find a hospitable Englishman in command, busily drilling some raw recruits from the neighborhood On climbing a high spur across the valley, crowned by a small outpost, we obtain a splendid view throvgh the end of the pass into Afghanistan. In the clear, bracing air we can see for miles over a broad valley a nevi ani an ST deh htt Tee

Page 18

320 — The Nation. dotted with villages until our sight loses itself beyond in successive walls of high mountains covered far down their sides with snow. Sixty miles in a straight line beyond those mountains lies Kabul, while Jelalabad is but half that distance—prac- tically as near Landi Kotal on the west as Peshawar on the Finally, de- seending to the fort again, we take lunch with the Commandant. From him we learn something of the general state of affairs is east. on the frontier and hear some amusing tales about the inhabitants of the Khai- bar Dark comes on early at Peshawar, and as we have a three-hour drive before us, we take early leave of Landi Kotal, and are soon passing to right and left the silent Afridi There are almost no people on the road, and few signs of life in sight save a group of old women with jars on their heads, who are fetching water from a well to one of the houses. Now and then on the hillside we notice stray couples of pickets, stalwart Afridis in khaki uni- whiling away their duty with a smoke and a chat. Before long we leave behind the last enclosure with its intrench- leading the and its expanse of forbidding brown walls unbrok en except by rows of loopholes. The pass narrows, and thereremain only fifteen miles strongholds forms, ed pathway to road, of barren mountains between us and the plains of India The day has been most itisfactory Thanks to the pickets, we have been able to penetrate into the Khai- far to something of the conditions of life among the Afridi tribes- in fact, we have so nearly crossed the desired bar enough see men; wild borderland into the forbidden beyond the of the Afghans uninviting of their moun- to find than the as to get glimpse state Judging by the tainous country, we should expect still character and aspect Afghanistan more inhospitable ite Indian frontiers RicnarRpD B. HoparRtT GENERAL LAMARQUE PARIS, March 28, 1906 M. Bertrand Lasserre has used the in- edited papers of General Lamarque for a volume which he has just published on the period of ‘The Hundred in La Ven- dée.” Let us first say a few words about (ieneral Lamarque, who is known now only by eloquent peeches in the French Chambers, and the popular which took place the of his funeral. He war for twenty-two years during the period of the He spent five years in Italy from 1807 to 1811, four years Days his political career, his demonstration day made te volution and the Empire in Spain. On the fall of the Empire he comed condemned to reat, but the pe- riod of the Hundred Days gave him a part tv play in Brittany and the Vendée. This ode is not much known; it was lost in the history of the great but brief struggle ot Napoleon againat the Allies, which end- Waterloo the ‘ at in mind, Brittany and the Vendée are confused even in our times; in the Rive: cuts in two these where civil war so long raged. On the north of the Loire we find Brittany proper, Quiberon, Maine, the land of the Chouans and of Cadoudal; on the south is the Vendée. popular Loire reality, regions, Le [Vol. 82, No. 2126 “During the Revolution, as well as dur- ing the Hundred Days,” says M. Lasserre, “on both sides of the river people fought for the same cause, without ever succeed- ing in coérdinating or uniting their ef- forts; the insurrection to the north and the insurrection to the south remained, at different times, completely distinct. In 1815, the events which form the subject of General Lamarque’s notes concern only the Vendée—that is to say, the vast quad- rilateral bounded on the north by the Loire, from the Ponts-de-Cé to its mouth; on the west, by the ocean; on the south by the Sévre Niortaise; on the east by the meridian of Bressuire, the hills of low- er Poitou and the flat land of the Gatine.” In this vast region there are three parts of very different aspect, commonly called the Bocage, the Plain, the Marsh, names which constantly occur in the history of the insurrection of the Vendée, which you will find in the memoirs of Madame de la Rochejacquelein, in Balzac’s admirable novels, in a hundred other books. This enormous surface, which at the time of the Consulate and the Empire was intersected by very few roads, is attached to the cen- tral part of France like a sort of virgin island. Its inhabitants, who belong to the Celtic race, were like a people apart. The inhabitants of the Bocage especially, a very sylvan region, had been preserved from all outside contact; of pure life, savage and distrustful, brave almost to madness, at- tached to Church and King from genera- tion to generation, they had among them natural leaders, captains of parishes, chiefs of districts, whom they blindly followed. The Royalist party of the Vendée remained quite torpid under the Consulate and the Empire; it began to revive only in 1814. Louis XVIII. disappointed the local chiefs of the Vendée by ordering the Chouans, Bretons, and Vendéans to surrender to the Government their old guns of great calibre for the equipment of the National Guards. The effect of this ordinance was disastrous, La Vendée felt wounded. It was nearly disarmed when Napoleon returned from Elba The King was urged for a moment to retire to the Vendée; he preferred to go to Lille, and to remain in touch with the allied Powers. He sent the Duke de Bour- bon to the Vendée; the Duke obeyed. The Duke d’'Angouléme and his wife were at Bordeaux; the Comte d’Artois was on the road to Lyons. The Duke de Bourbon had left Paris in great haste, without any staff, almost without money; he arrived at Angers on the 14th of March, preceded by M. d’Antichamp. He found at Nantes the Count de Suzannet and Prince Louis de la Trémoille. The Duke de Bourbon, father of the unfortunate Duke d’Enghien, found the Vendée irritated against Louis XVIII. “In order to draw the province out of its discontented reserve and to galvanize it as in old days, there would have been need of another man than the Duke de Bourbon, the ex-commander-in-chief of the useless army of Coblentzs, an old man of fine pres- ence, but of weak and almost vacillating character. Besides, the peasants were far from having their old temper; more than one chief discovered with much sadness the weakening of the royalist energy by the slow infiltration of the new ideas.” The Duke de Bourbon tried, however, to organize some armed battalions, byt he soon felt that his efforts were vain when he heard of Napoleon's return to Paris. The Prince left Beaupréau, where he had established his headquarters, in the night of the 24th of March, alone with the Count de Rully; he travelled from farm to farm, and, after a journey of eleven days, he em- marked at Paimbeuf in a small vessel which took him to Spain. Curiously enough, it was only after his departure that the royalist chiefs became more active, each of them working in his own district. The principal officers were Saint-Hubert, Du- pérat, Duchaffault, Ludovic de Charette, Suzannet, Sapinaud, D’Antichamp. Louis de la Rochejacquelein, having accom- nied the King to the frontier, left him to go to England to procure arms and muni- tions, and reached the coast of La Vendée. Gen. Canuel, who had adopted the cause of the Bourbons in 1814, was among the in- surgents and had become their major-gen- eral. On the arrival of the Marquis de la’ Rochejacquelein,the insurrection, whichhad been prepared in secret, broke out, on the 15th of May. Four army corps were to occupy the Vendée, under the command of D’Antichamp, of Sapinaud, of Suzannet, of La Rochejacquelein. The insurgents hoped to have fifty-one thousand men under arms, but the reality was far below this ex- pectation; two-thirds of the peasants had no other arms but their old-fashioned guns, one-third had no arms at all. On the 17th of May the Emperor heard at the Tuileries the news of the rising in the Vendée and of the arrival of the Mar- quis de la Rochejacquelein; he immediate- ly dispatched troops to the Loire. General Corbineau was sent to the Ven- dée, but the means placed at his disposal were insufficient, as the Emperor intended to limit his efforts in the West, and was giving all his attention to the approaching campaign against the Allies. M. de Su- zannet and Sapinaud recognized La Roche- jacquelein as the general-in-chief; they all three marched on Napoléon-Vendée. They sicpt at Aizenay oa iiie 20th of May, and were surprised in the night and obliged to fly. At Cholet, La Rochejacquelein had an interview with another Vendéan chief, D’Antichamp, who delivered his command to him; they all marched towards the coast in order to protect a second disembarka- tion of English arms and munitions. By that time Gen. Lamarque had arrived and taken command of all the troops of the west, which formed the army of the Loire; he put everything in order, interrupted all communications between the two sides of the river. Full powers were given to him; fourteen departments were placed under his orders. His headquarters were estab- lished at Angers. Fouché, head of the police, sent three agents to the Vendée, in order to make overtures to the insurgent chiefs; he was well acquainted with their divisions, their jealousies, and had always had a foot in both camps. He was as ready to serve the royalist cause as the cause of the Empire; he knew that the fate of Napoleon would soon be decided on the battlefield, and his object was to gain time. The mission of his envoys had for its first effect to create division in the ranks of the insurgent chiefs. The Marquis de la Rochejacquelein and M. d’Antichamp were both jealous of preéminence, and their forces ceased to act in common. The first basis of a paci- fication was discussed; the forces of Sapi- naud, Suzannet, and D’Antichamp returned to their homes. They met on their march Gen. Travot, and, notwithstanding their su-

Page 19

April 19, 1906] The Nation. periority in numbers, they did not attack him. It is difficult to give a clear account of the confused events which followed. La Rochejacquelein lost his life in an engage - ment, and consternation became general among the insurgents. Sapinaud took the command; there was another battle at Roche-Serviére, in which the Vendéans were defeated, and M. de Susannet mortal- ly wounded. Military operations came nat- urally to an end after Waterloo; and the Vendéan chiefs signed at Cholet a treaty of peace with Gen. Lamarque. The new Provisional Government formed in Paris after the abdication of the Emperor gave little attention to the pacification of the Vendée; it is to the credit of Sapinaud and his companions that, on the circulation of a rumor in the Vendée that the allied Powers intended to dismember France, they informed Gen. Lamarque that they would unite their forces with his in order to fight against the foreigner. Louis XVIIL, on his return, discharged the Army of the Loire. Gen. Lamarque was exiled for a time, till 1818. In 1828 he was elected Deputy from the Department of the Landes. The his- tory of the brief insurrection of the Vendée in 1815 is told with much care by M. Las- serre, though he recognizes that it was an affair “of pure sentiment. Caused by the return from Elba, it had a laborious be- ginning, and developed at random, irra- tionally, according to the caprice of differ- ent chiefs, and committed suicide in the end.” He adds that twenty thousand men were kept in Brittany and in the Vendée in order to quiet these provinces, and that “these twenty thousand men, flung on the battlefield of Waterloo, would perhaps have hindered the disaster.” Correspondence. LITERATURE VERSUS PHILOLOGY. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sin: Your editorial article in No. 2128 on “Teaching Literature in Colleges’’ must strike a responsive chord in the breasts of a large number of American university men who were compelled to forego the study of literature for the sake of phil- ology—either because the instructors all stressed philology, or because it was practically impossible to get a degree with high credit based on purely literary work. But shall we not have to wait until a change comes over the “American spirit” before we can hope for a change in the methods of teaching ‘literature’? So long as this measures the value of a college course by the extent to which it will in- crease a man’s money-making power; so long as we have the “strenuous” spirit penetrating more and more into every de- partment of life, just so long will the Gradgrind method which enables a man's work to be weighed, measured, or counted, be the prevalent method. We Americans are mad for tangible results; and in seeking them we lose sight of the spirit of life which gives force and mean- ing to these results. G. 8. W. Greensnono, N. C., April 18, 1906, SANCTA SIMPLICITAS. To THE EpITOR oF THE NATION: Sir: Cannot something be done to check the assaults of those subsidized vandals, the Simplified-Spelling Board, upon the finest of modern arts, the traditional Eng- lish orthography? They would destroy at one bluw if they could, a nice and delicate | sense for visual symbols which has been built up through centuries. Consider, for | example, the following quotation from one of Keats's letters to George and Georgiana Keats, written under date of February 14, 1818: “We—-i. ¢., Brown and I—sit opposite one another all day authorizing (N. B., an ‘s’ instead of a ‘z’ would give a different mean- ing).”’ Is this fine perception of a difference be- tween authorizing and authorising utterly worthless? Has it no artistic or literary value? Or, to ask a more pertinent ques- tion, what is its equivalent in United States Steel bonds? I call on the Simplified- Spelling Board for a reply. PHILOLOGUS “COMPARATIVE LITERATURE” AND “PHILOLOGY.” To THE Ep!Tor OF THE NATION: Sir: In connection with your recent sug- gestive editorial on “‘Aspects of Compara- tive Literature” (Nation, March 29, 1906), it may not be out of place to recall two prior, authoritative utterances on similar themes. Trustworthy documents on the general conception of literary and linguistic study have been relatively infrequent on this side the water, where, perhaps, they are at present needed most; we should do ill to neglect the few that we already possess. At all events, a comparative ex- amination of your editorial and the two earlier articles in question might be of considerable advantage to many teachers of language and literature in this country, if only by way of fostering precision in the use of fundamental and inclusive terms When, for example, we are handling a weapon of great range like ‘“‘philological”’ or “comparative literature,” us to discover the right end and the proper make. The expression ‘comparative literature,’ as Prof. C. M. Gayley pointed out several years ago (Atlantic Monthly, July, 1903), is fashioned improperly; it is a rude, even barbarous term, unfit, assuredly, for em- ployment in the defence of polite learning To speak plainly, we may brand it as a virtual solecism. According to good usage, the word comparative is associated in sim- ilar combinations, not with a noun repre- senting an objective material—such as literature, in any customary sense—but with a noun containing the idea of a verbal action, a methodical process—such as anatomy, physiology, philology, and the like Thus, we say not comparative embryos, but comparative embryology; not comparative forms (of plants, etc.), but comparative morphology; and, finally, not comparative language, or literature, but, as our safest teachers tell us, comparative philology.* *Or simply philology ; comparative |« superfluous, The progress of knowledge in ev. ry field, great or small rests necessarily upon two bases, observation and comparison. The scientist begins with the observa it behooves | B21 The marriage of comparative with litera ture was not made in Germany. Compared literature (la littérature comparée) we might say, with the French, were the phrase not objectionable on other grounds Comparative study of literature, though clumsy, is tolerable, and may pass mus- ter with those who cannot accustom them selves to the true and inclusive significa tion of that much-abused word philology This word we Americans almost in- variably grasp by the wrong end, al though the Germans since the day of the immortal August Boeckh hav« been trying to teach us and others its real function Apparently, we have been willing to appropriate from them anything in or around the realm of Sprachwissenschaft and Litteraturgeschichte save a knowledge of the origin and appli cation of this single, embracing term Philoloav As a result, most of us recog nize no term whatsoever that comprehends the study of language and literature com bined, though these two things are never separate in nature; and, in our teaching some of us even try to divorce what God has joined together. At any rate, the con sequence of a lack of precision at the top of our nomenclature is a certain amount of confusion in our thinking all the way down to the bottom of literary and lin guistic disciplines. Professor Gayley, of course, has come to our rescue here also | with the admirable essay cited above | “Comparative Zodlogy “What is ‘Comparative Literature’? But more particularly, your readers may be referred to Prof. Albert 8. Cook's presi dential address on “The Province of Eng lish Philology,” delivered before the Modern Language Association of America in 1897, and printed subsequently in the Publications of that society, Vol. XIIL, No 2 Professor Cook’s plea for a broader definition of philology seems irresistible Fortunately, this valuable address is to re appear shortly in a volume of essays by th: same author, te be published by Messra Houghton, Mifiin & Co. A reprint of Pro fessor Gayley’s article would be welcome LANE COOPER Irmaca, N. Y., April 12, 1006 [The late Asa Gray used to object to " in the title of | the Agassiz Museum at Cambridge.—Ep NaTIon.] Notes. G. P. Putnam's Sons announce for speedy appearance Bishop Potter’s ‘Reminiscences of Bishops and Archbishops,’ and a transla- tion of Fogazzarro’s ‘I) Santo.’ Recent political events lend special in- terest to the announcement of a new illus trated history of Norway from the earliest time to 1905, by six of the leading histori cal writers of that country, each of whom will be responsible for the period as to which he is a recognized authority. The first volume, dealing with the Viking pe- riod and bringing the story down to 1035 tion of smaller, contiguous magnitudes, and proceeds to greater and more remote Comparative Uteralur: ye some such thing as oberrvative Uteraturs yur universities ought really to have estabilebed chairs in the latter before they took care of the former ae ee ee © aero eae barra ee ee ee ae ee

Page 20

BRR The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2129 will be written by Prof. Alexander Bugge, and will appear early in 1907. The sixth volume, which treats of the union with Sweden, will be by Prof. Ernst Sars. Under the title of ‘Les Sources Inédites de V'Histoire du Maroc,’ the famous Afri- can traveller, Count Henri de Castries, will publish through the Paris house of Leroux three-volume collection ranging from 1530 to 1845, the material consisting of the reproduction of manuscripts, reports, let- ters, and other documents. The first vol- ume, of almost 700 pages, has just left the press. The author secured his,materials in the archives and libraries of France, Eng- land, Austria, Spain, and other countries, und what he gives is the result of years of labor. The work is divided into three parts for as many dynasties. It closes with 1845 because In that year the definitive set- tlement of the boundary lines between the Moroccan and Algerian territories was made, and the modification of the treaties between the various European states and Moroceo took place Count de Castries criticises quite severely the elder literature on Morocco, especially Sir Lambert Play- fair’s ‘Bibliography of Morocco.’ The Monuments of Egyptian Sculpture, as revealed in typical examples historical- ly and chronologically ordered, are to be luxuriously illustrated in a folio issued at Munich by F. Bruckmann (New York: Lemeke & Buechner). The text will be in German. The twelve parts proposed will be concluded at furthest by the end of 1907. The sample illustration is convincing Among the works which are being edited for the Hakluyt Society, London, are some of interest to Americans Mr. Bol- ton Corney, the chief medical officer of the Fiji Islands, is preparing Four Narratives of Voyages undertaken by order of the Viceroy of Peru, in 1774, with detailed ac- counts of Tahiti and Easter Island Mr A. P. Maudslay is editing the translation, from the original MS. in Mexico, published by photography in 1904, of ‘The True His- tory of the Conquest of Mexico." The hon- orary secretary and treasurer of the So- clety, Mr. Basil H. Soulsby, of the Map De- partment, British Museum, is bringing out a translation (from the copy in the Gren- ville collection at the British Museum) of Jacques Cartier’s Short Narrative of the Voyage made to the Isles of Canada, Hoche- lage, and Saguenay, which was published at Paria in 1545. In view of the approaching tercentenary of the founding of Quebec, in 1608, this is a very timely republication The second edition of Sir Walter Raleigh's Discoverie of Guiana, the first Hakluyt edition of which was so admirably edited by Sir Robert Schomburgk, is still promised by Sir Everard im Thurn, now Governor of Fiji, who was for some years an officer of the Government of British Guiana, in which colony he travelled much and familiarized himeelf with the ways of the Indians Volume IV. of Mr. J. W. Fortescue’s ‘History of the British Army,’ now just appearing, ought to awaken fresh interest in the islands of the Caribbean Sea, the Mediterranean of the New World The story of the campaigns there, from 1793 to 1798, is told consecutively in this volume, for the first time Among the commanders who figure in it ts Sir Charles Grey, after- wards Ear! Grey, and father of the Lord Grey of the Reform Law (of 1832), and grandiather of the present Governor-Gener- al of Canada. It was this Sir Charles Grey who was named to be the British com- mander-in-chief against the Americans, had not peace been made in 1783. The volume is a long one, extending to 900 pages, and the author has found this part of his work the most difficult to handle of any subject he has yet attempted, owing to the com- plications of the narrative. The original letters in the Public Record Office, London, are the backbone of Mr. Fortescue’s work; but many collections of private papers have been thrown open to him, s0 that abundant materials are available. The next volume will probably be delayed, ow- ing to Mr. Fortescue’s appointment to be the King’s librarian at Windsor, and that will also necessitate his relinquishing the calendaring of the Colonial Series of State Papers at the Record Office, in which ser- vice he has so ably followed the late Mr. Noel Sainsbury; but it is hoped that he may yet find himself able to supervise those who will hereafter carry on the work, which is of such deep interest to all who are stu- dents of the colonial period of American history. From the office of the Publishers’ Circular, London (New York: Publishers’ Weekly), we receive ‘The English Catalogue of Books for 1905,’ the 69th issue of this standard list. We need say no more of it except that it is typographically very neat in appear- ance, and that an appendix gathers up the names and output of learned societies, printing clubs, series, etc., and is follow- ed by a directory of publishers, British, American, and Canadian. Some American books are included in the main list, and in the appendix. Harper & Bros. have brought out in pale blue covers, rather taking except for the front design, a popular edition of ‘Through the Looking Glass,’ ‘Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland,’ and ‘The Hunting of the Snark.’ The illustrations are Peter New- ell’s, less enjoyable than Tenniel’s, whose distinction they lack, but at their best very humorous. The Russo-Japanese war is already losing some of its prominence as a topic of the hour, but the struggle of the Russian pev- ple towards light and knowledge has never been more vividly before the public. For the latter if not for the former reason, J. Taburno’s ‘The Truth about the War’ (Kansas City: Franklin Hudson Co.) may well attract readers. The author, an engi- neer by profession, sets down readably, candidly, and naively the impressions he received while with Kuropatkin in Mant- churia. The way in which his eyes were gradually opened to the shortcomings of the Russian Administration and to the virtues of the Russian peasant may be taken as typical of the larger process at present in active operation throughout the Empire. Prof. John 8. Phillimore has published through the Clarendon Press a verbal index to Propertius, which he had made in prep- aration for his intended commentary on that poet. It is far more complete than such Indices usually are, even including full records of such particles as et, -que, ut, and non, which are generally disposed of with a few examples and a comprehensive et- cetera. Thus, while the Propertian index, in the Delphin edition omits et altogether, Professor Phillimore’s claims to register 606 recurrences, with 75 under ab to the Del- phin’s four. The index is not strictly an- alytical, and yet sufficiently so to seem in- consistent because not always so. For ex- ample, et for etiam is separately listed; but et. . . et (both and) is not; wt is listed by the mood governéd, but both uts, the adverb and the conjunction, are listed together; expertus in I., iii., 18, is listed with the other forms of experior without note of its relatively unusual pass- ive sense. But this does not seriously af- fect the usefulness of the index, nor could it be expected that a list made to meet the needs of one workman should equally suit those of all. It is interesting to note that Propertius’s vocabulary does not much exceed three thousand words; but those to whom this seems a limited thesaurus should remember that many words are, either wholly or in certain inflections, ex- cluded from elegiac verse. ‘Contributions to the History of American Geology,’ by George P. Merrill, head Curat- or of Geology, United States National Mu- seum, has just been issued as an extract from the report of that institution for 1904 (Washington). It is a serviceable re- view of the personal side of our geological progress, refreshed by numerous portraits, among which those of Dana, Logan (our es- teemed Canadian neighbor, if not of our own country), Hall, and Powell are excel- lent likenesses of strong personalities, which the geologists of the younger gener- ation will do well to look upon. Outline maps give definite location to the routes and fleld of study of the earlier explorers. After chapters on what are called the Ma- clurean (1785-1819) and Eatonian (1820-29) eras, the chapters proceed by decades, re- viewing the work and workers of State sur- veys up to 1869, and of the national surveys in later years. Four peculiarly American problems are given chapters by themselves —the fossil footprints of the Connecticut Valley, in which Deane and Hitchcock are the leading figures; the Eozoon question, championed by Dawson of Canada and now a past issue; the Laramie question, on which the geologists of the Western plains and mountains were for a time divided into hostile camps; and the long-lasting Taconic question, over which the Eastern geologists have had many a battle, and concerning which many “last” words have been said and are probably still to be said. An ap- pendix contains brief sketches of 196 Amer- fean geologists, with references to fuller biographies. Of Pope’s ‘Handbook of Tamil’ (Oxford: Clarendon Press; New York: H. Frowde), already noticed by us as the several pre- ceding parts have appeared, the fifth part, ‘Prose Reader,’ has just been published in the seventh edition. It consists of read- ing exercises, adapted to the Handbook and Dictionary by the same author, with specimens of classical prose and business Tamil, suited to the use of officials, to- gether with thirty-one easy stories and some additional tales, especially intended for those studying for the Higher Pro- ficiency Test and drawn from the Pafica- Tanthiram. Considering the small type, the number of errata is reasonably small. For Englishmen fitting themselves for ac- tive service, this Handbook is the best, and it may be studied with profit by any one desirous of beginning Tamil. =r

Page 21

2 1 Fa nar April 19, 1906] The waves of influence from Mr. William James's ‘Varieties of Religious Experience’ have gone far and have touched strange shores. Perhaps the farthest and strang- est is the paper by Prof. Asin y Palacios of the chair of Arabic in the University of Madrid, on the psychology of ecstasy as exemplified in the two great Muslim mys- ties, al-Ghazzali and Ibn Arabi, which ap- peared in La Cultura Espanola for Febru- ary. Al-Ghazzali, for a Muslim theologian, is a comparatively well-known figure even to non-Arabists, thanks largely to Pro- fessor Asin himself. But Jbn Arabi, im- portant as he undoubtedly is for the his tory of theology and philosophy in Chris- tendom as well as Islam, has been little studied even by Arabists. Such a treat- ment. therefore, as we have here of the emotional psychology of Ibn Arabi can be confidently commended to those students of philosophy who still retain an interest in its history and threads of influence, to psychologists of even the latest school, and t» all interested in religious phenomena. Professor Asin begins frankly with Profes- sor James's book and the reaction which it marked and induced. A student of Mus- lim mysticism of some years’ standing, he is interested in seeing modern philosophy come round to him, as it has done with great completeness. The pragmatists are as good Ghazzalians as al-Ghazzali him- self could have asked for. But that he only touches, going on to develop with learn- ing and skill, as an Arabist and a psychol- ogist, the phenomena of religious ecstasy, the resultant theological conceptions and their consequences for life, as experienced and stated by Ibn Arabi especially. He also brings forward some other evidence in support of the thesis, already laid down by Professor Ribera, that Raymond Lully was under deep Muslim influence, and might be described as a Christian Sufi and an imitator of Ibn Arabi. That there was communication and influence, one way and another, between the Christian and the Muslim mystics of Spain, can hardly be doubted. Some things in this paper re- mind strongly of visions of Santa Teresa; mystics, too, it may be remembered, are seldom fanatical. The circle of modern Arabic dialects studied and reduced to phonetic form is steadily rounding out. For north Africa there are several excellent books by Stumme; for Egypt many, from Spitta down; for Damascus Oestrup, and for Beirut and its neighborhood Hartmann; for Central Palestine Christie, and now for Jerusalem and southern Palestine Dr. Max Léhr(‘Der Vulgaérarabische Dialect von Jerusalem, nebst Texten und Worterver- zeichniss,’ Giessen, 1905). What is left is practically Arabia proper; and Socin did something in the north and east, and Land- berg is doing much in the south. The grammatical part of Dr. Loéhr’s investiga- tion is full and careful, and the little Arabic-German lexicon will amply cover all ordinary usage. But, as the vocabu- lary is not also given reversed, the begin- ner in Jerusalem will have to find his way by instinct, or use some other guide, such as Hartmann's golden little cook The texts, too, are over scanty; for that, Litt- mann’s gatherings will help out. But the grammatical treatment can stand by itself 323 Institute School, in many respects taking The Nation. Portable copies of the ‘Divine Comedy’ in the original are always in order, and the | the lead, while undoubtedly that of Mr new pocket school edition (edizione | J. 1. Wyer, jr., the new vice-director of minuscola) just issued by Hoepli in Milan | the New York State Library School at Al will find everywhere a wider circle eager bany, is the most significant, in that It to possess it Both publisher and editor | expresses the purpose of the authorities Prof. Raffaello Fornaciari, rightly dwell on | of that institution to develop it into a real this. The 577 pages are, by means of an graduate school by eliminating many ele opaque thin paper, reduced to half an inch | mentary courses and giving particular at- in thickness; the letter, though necessarily | tention to bibliographical and administra small, is round and clear; the notes are tive subjects These accounts are suppl disposed at the foot of the page There mented by statements of students: among is a prefatory word on the poet's life and | these the letter from Mr. Leon M. Solis the meaning of his poem The text and Cohen, a recent graduate of Albany, de mainly the notes alike are derived from | serves special attention for its frank crit! Cassini, Passerini and Secartazzini (Ath cism edition). The covers are flexible The Library Journal for March opens It has remained for a Frenchman, Dr with a thoughtful paper by Dr. E. ¢. Rich Paul Mantoux, to write the first satisfac | ardson on “The Library in the Community tory account of the Industrial Revolution | whie h emphasizes the function of libraries, in England, ‘La Révolution Industrielle au both private, corporate, and public, in en XVIIle Siécle’ (Paris: Cornély, 1905). Ina solid but well-written work of 540 pages, Dr Mantoux reviews instructively the condi tion of English industry in the first half | ®!nger’s breezy and amusing account of her experience in “The Organizatidn of a Li larging the ideas of the members of the community. The most interesting paper In this number is certainly Miss E. D. Ren of the eighteenth century, describes the great mechanical inventions which wrought | >rary in a Small Town.’ She relates how the sudden transformation, traces their in she was led to believe there was a strong troduction into the several branches of | 494 active organization behind the mo manufactures, and then considers the eco ment, but found, when she came to the nomic and social results of the Revolu- | Place, that it was pushed by only two py sons—the chairman of the Library Depart ment of the local Civie Club and the tion With evident mastery of materials and clear insight into the working of com cently ¢ te f ‘ ccount o plex and sometimes obscure economic ently appointed librarian Her @ = : her ains rance and indolence causes, he has produced what should be, or Gght against ignorance and even and ultimate success must be read in full for a decade or more, the standard treatise , . . ; to be appreciated The Balkan question is the subject of upon its subject. The work is of such in | most general interest treated in the Annalra terest to English and American students that it should be translated as speedily as possible to teachers of economic history, de Géographie for March Professor (vil of the University of Belgrade states, as the it will prove a great boon. ‘L’Empire de l’Argent,’ by Joseph Dubois result of investigations made during his travels in that region, that the great ma jority of Macedonian Slavs have no exclu (Paris: Guilmoto, 1906), is an elaborate study of the monetary system of Chi- na It explains fully and clearly the with tional Bulgarian nor a national Servian sive patriotism. They have neither a na existing currency system, deals the perplexing question of exchange with gold-standard countries, and gives feeling, but could be transformed easily into either Bulgarians or Servians under the force of circumstances Bulgaria is a detailed account of Chinese bank ing institutions, both native and foreign. | 4¢ Present in greater evidence because of Then, after reviewing recent experiences | the activity of the revolutionary commit tees and the establishment of a national church More than a third of the Slava, of certain provinces with French and Rus sian coins, it concludes with a vigorous at tack upon the plan of monetary reform | however, have refused to abandon the for proposed by the late American Commis- | eign Greek Church for the Exarchate. In sion. M. Dubois is strongly of the opinion | treating of the language, he says that Bul that the existing silver standard is so | 84rian is not an ethnographic term. It firmly established in China, and rooted so | designates a man of simple laborious life deeply in the habits and prejudices of the | While Serb and Slav are interchangeable people, that it will long be maintained, in | Further study is needed to determine whe spite of the well-intended but uninvited | ther or not there is a distinct Southern advice of other nations. He thinks that | Slav language or dialect. Light is thrown the American Commissioners, “le profes- | upon the present condition of Algeria in an seur Jenks en téte,” were deceived by “les | account of the evolution of the nomads of sourires fallacieux de quelques mandarins,”’ that country, who are gradually changing and failed to appreciate the coolness of the | their habits of life. Instead of the tribes reception accorded their proposals. The | following their flocks to their different pas book is one which the American student | turages, they now abide in one place, and may well place on file beside the reports | trust their flocks, as is done in EFurope, to of the American Commission on Interna- | the care of shepherds. Lieut. Desplagnes tional Exchange gives a brief but encouraging account of the development of the rich basin of th: Middle Niger. The peaceful conditions es tablished by the French are inducing the The March number of Public Libraries is | largely devoted to matters relating to li- | brary instruction Members of the facul- | ties of the various library schools and people who sought refuge in the mountains from the raiding nomads, to come down to the plain and cultivate it. This paper and one on the geology and physical geography of Morocco are illustrated by some beauti training classes have contributed more or less full accounts of the history, character- istics, and ideals of the schools with which they are connected, the statement of Missa and will not need redoing Mary W. Plummer, director of the Pratt | ful reproductions of photographs

Page 22

The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2129 324 Alexander Lange Kielland, whose death was recently announced, was born in Sta- vanger, Norway, February 18, 1849. He studied law in Christiania, but never prac- tised, preferring to devote himself to busi- ness With the exception of some time spent in Copenhagen and Paris, Kielland lived in Norway, most of the time in Sta- vanger. His earliest publications, two vol- umes of novelettes (1879-1880), one of which was translated into English, show the marked influence of Daudet; but his novels, which appeared between 1880 and 1891, be- long to the modern Scandinavian school of realistic fletion, with some direct indebted- ness to Zola Among the best of these eight volumes are ‘Garman and Worse,’ containing many autoblographical touches, Working People’ and ‘Skipper Worse,’ somewhat in the style of Jonas Lie. ‘Ja- cob,’ the last of the novels, is a brilliant but unpersuasive study of a business man who, like the patriarch, bases a brilliantly successful life upon a fraud. Kielland’s chief merit as a writer is the extreme ele- xance and finish of his style. Most of bis novels have been translated into German and Swedish, and several into English. In is9l Kielland was appointed burgomaster of hia native town, and was later promoted to the position of Amtmand, or sheriff of the district. The last fifteen years of his life were practically without literary out- put rhe former Liberal Prime Minister of Norway Johannes Steen, whose second term of office extended from 1898 to 1902, died April 1, at the age of seventy-eight. A week ago to-day we received from Dr. Richard Garnett a letter, not in his own hand, dated London, April 2. In it he spoke of suffering from an affection of his eyes, which had prevented his executing a certain review for the Nation, but he looked forward to a somewhat tedious recovery. On the day following the receipt, namely, April 13, he passed away, in consequence (as the cable reported) of a hemorrhage; and at this writing we know no more. Dr. Garnett was a library product if there ever was one. His father, whose name he re- peated, a clergyman, was Assistant-Keeper of Printed Books in the British Museum, sod he himself, becoming an employee of that institution at an early age (he was born in 1835), rose to be Keeper of the same department (1890-1899). As such he was well and graciously known to all Amer- icane having need to profit by his official position. It was in the year of his retire- ment, when recreation by “change of oc- cupation, dolce far niente,” was his aim, that he voluntarily entered into relations with this journal, and latterly became @ highly valued reviewer for it: his prodigi- ous habit of work could not be repressed, Hie list of published works is extensive. He was a poet and the biographer and edi- tor of poetse—Shakspere, Milton, Dryden, Shelley, Blake, Emerson; a poetic transla- tor from the German and the Italian, an historian of Italian literature; au encyclo- pmdist for collaboration with the Britannica and the Dictionary of National Biography; editor with Mr. Gosse of the splendidly Illustrated Record” of ‘Knglish Literature’ concluded two years ago. But we need enumerate no further. As genial bookman and gifted imaginative writer and learned maker of books, Dr. Garnett lived the ideal life of the scholar spirit. He gave as freely as he absorbed, and directed and will continue to direct a multitude of students in the paths of literature, English and for- eign. His death, at seventy-one, must be thought untimely, and he will be greatly missed. —It is several years since the late Gae- tano Negri published his well-known work on ‘Julian the Apostate,’ but until now this interesting essay in criticism has not been available for those who read English only. The present translation (Scribners) is from the hand of the Duchess Letta-Visconti- Arese, and appears with a delightful intro- duction by Professor Villari. The facts of Negri’s career as here recited throw much light upon his personal attitude towards Julian, and have also a pathetic interest of their own. We do not refer merely to the accident which cost the author his life when we suggest that there is an element of pathos in the details narrated by Pro- fessor Villari. Negri was a man of great eloquence, attractiveness and versatility, who, either through force of circumstances or excess of talent, failed to do the one central thing that posterity looks for as the hall-mark of eminence. Perhaps his main achievement was the upbuilding of Milan, where for the years 1886-1889 he was Syndic or Mayor. We have at least Professor Vil- lari’s word for it that during this tenure of office “he achieved notable results in the material, moral, and commercial trans- formation of Milan, for he was one of the first to see its coming prosperity and im- portance.” Dispossessed eventually by the Socialists, Negri turned his energies to his- torical and literary pursuits. Among mod- ern writers George Eliot aroused his great- est enthusiasm, and he considered that his own best work was to be found in the criti- cism of her novels, which he published after a long and analytical study of them. Towards the close of his life, he was turn- ing more and more to historical subjects, and particularly to those problems of Church and State which emerged during the latter part of the fourth century. Though as a philosopher he was a pure rationalist, he felt drawn by a strong impulse to the personality of St. Augustine, while on the eve of his tragic death he was collecting materials for a book on St. Ambrose. —-We condense these facts from the pages of Professor Villari because they will be new to most of our readers, and because they furnish us with Negri’s point of de- parture in approaching the saints and phil- osophers of the later Roman Empire. He was not a specialist in the minuter points of erudition, but yet a scholar who had read the principal sources for his period and reflected deeply upon them. Perhaps no one in modern times has so completely identified himself with the thoughts of Julian and reproduced them in bis own experience. He maintains truly enough that his book is neither an attack nor a panegyric. “My aim in writing this book has been purely objective, and it will re- quire a large dose of good, or I shall rather say bad, will to construe it otherwise. He who possesses a critical temperament regards moral phenomena with the same absolute impartiality with which the chem- ist analyzes a substance or the astronomer determines the orbit of a celestial body.” The claim to impartiality thus made is not unwarranted by the tone of the book; and if Negri is drawn to what is best in Ju- lian’s Hellenism, he is by no means blind to those curious oddities of mind and tem- per upon which Glover has laid so much stress. Some slips will be found in these two volumes, and one rather large error— the acceptance as genuine of Julian’s let- ters to Iamblichus. But, with whatever limitations, the work deserves on the score of eloquence and talent to find a large circle of English readers. —Negri’s rationalism, however blended with a genuine interest in the subject- matter of theology, leads him at times to pass frank criticism upon both the Church of the fourth century and Christianity. But his temper in this respect is gentle and sympathetic when compared with the posi- tive animosity of Mr. W. G. Holmes. Jus- tinian and Theodora have been dealt with in a great variety of ways and by authors who differ as widely as Ludewig and Sardou, but biographies of them remain scarce. For many years the hope was en- tertained that Mr. Bryce might publish a life of Justinian, prompted thereto by the nature of his Oxford professorship. Wheth- er he will ever find time for such an un- dertaking may well be doubted. Meanwhile we have from Mr. Holmes the first volume of a history entitled ‘The Age of Justinian and Theodora’ (Bell). A biography in any limited sense of the word this does not promise to be. The author’s motive, so far as it can be briefly indicated, seems to be expressed by the following sentence: “When Grecian science and philosophy seemed to stand on the threshold of mod- ern enlightenment, the pall of despotism and superstition descended on the earth and stifled every impulse of progress for more than fifteen centuries.”” These words, while they refer to the first century of the Christian era, indicate with sufficient clear- ness Mr. Holmes’s attitude towards “the disintegrating and moribund Byzantine Empire.” As for his dislike of Christiani- ty, we can best convey its nature and ex- tent by one or two quotations: “The Yggdrasil of Christian superstition spread its roots throughout the Roman Empire, strangling alike the nascent ethics of Christendom and the germinating science of the ancient world.” In modern times ‘“‘an intelligent hypothesis of existence has been deduced from observation and experiment, idealism and dogma have been recognized as the offspring of phantasy and fallacy, and the mystical elements of Christianity have been dismissed to that limbo of folly which long ago engulfed the theogonies of Greece and Rome. The sapless trunk of revelation lies rotting on the ground, but the undiscerning masses, too credulous to inquire, too careless to think, have al- lowed it to become invested with the weeds of superstition and ignorance; and the pro- geny of hierophants who once sheltered be- neath the green and flourishing tree, still find a cover in the rank growth.” Mr. Holmes has collected a good deal of cu- rious information, or rather his book dis- closes solid erudition. At the same time he has not kept his text free from small inaccuracies, like placing the Vandal con- quest of Africa in 439, nor from as large a one as placing the desertion of Britain by the Romans in 446. His gibes at Chris- ASA eae ne ta atari.

Page 23

heat a A ai Bh rc te Wats April 19, 1906] The Nation. 325 tianity are expressed in such form as to remind one of the question which Elizabeth Bennet addresses to her father after hear- ing Mr. Darcy's first letter: “Can he be a sensible man, Sir?’ Finally, Note 1 on page 340 (and it does not stand alone) re- minds us of the French sarcasm regarding “l’obscénité froide et érudite de Gibbon.”’ —Count Paul Hatzfeldt was an able and distinguished Prussian diplomatist who, after the usual training in subordinate po- sitions, became successively ambassador at Madrid, at Constantinople, and at London, where he died in 1885. From 1868 to 1874 he worked in immediate association with Bismarck in the Foreign Office, and during the war of 1870-71 he was with the Chan- cellor in France. He married in 1863 an American wife, the daughter of a Mr. Moul- ton, who had become a resident of Paris During the whole French campaign Count Hatzfeldt wrote to the Countess in Berlin almost daily letters. These have been translated from the French, in which they were written, into smooth and idiomatic English, by Mr. J. L. Bashford, of Trinity College, Cambridge; and they are now published, with a brief preface by the Countess Hatzfeldt, under the title of ‘The Hatzfeldt Letters, 1870-71’ (E. P. Dutton & Co.). They are eminently conjugal letters, full of affection and of little domestic so- licitudes. A letter from Saarbriicken, Au- gust 10, 1870, is a fair sample of the rest It begins with a description of Spicheren heights and the evidences of the hard fight- ing a few days before; gives rumors of French discouragement; asks the Countess to send his frock-coat; complains that he has had no letter “either yesterday or to- day,’ which “‘is very annoying’’; and closes (as printed): “Tell me how you have ar- ranged your household and how much you spend on it per month.’ The hardships of the Moultons, shut up in Paris; the ex- posed situation of their summer residence outside in the zone of siege opera- tions; and the expectation and ad- vent of a daughter, born while the Count was at Versailles—these matters naturally bulk much bigger than the military and po- litical events of the year. There is occa- sionally a bit of interesting description, and we get side lights on historic events and personages; but there are no “revelations.” Careful foot-notes give all the necessary information concerning the persons men- tioned in the letters, and* there is an in- adequate index. RECENT POETRY. We have come to know pretty well what to expect in a new “tragedy” by Mr. Ste- phen Phillips. In ‘‘Herod,” “Ulysses,” and “The Sin of David’’ the poetic promise of “Paolo and Francesca’ was decreasingly fulfilled; a growth in the skilful manage- ment of melodramatic spectacle kept pace with a loosening grip on tragic structure and a lessening ability in the handling of dramatic verse. His latest play, “‘Nero” (Macmillan), has little in it to defeat this discouraged expectation. The old Mar- lowesque world-straining of phrase, that for a time held critics spellbound, ig still there. In the very first line is “the daz- zling doom of kings,"’ and within the space of a few pages we find such characteristic | | touches as “the windy chair of the world,” “the deep heart of the mighty world,” “this pulsing world his theatre,"’ and “O | wine of the world, the odor and gold of it.”’ | | Nor do we have to read very far before finding passages of that mellow charm, that | mannered, somewhat wistful, beauty that made his ‘‘Marpessa’’ so lovely and so mem- orable. Take this of Poppma: Yet hath none fairer strayed into the world Or wandered in more witchery through the air Since she who drew the dreaming keels of Greece After her over the Ionian foam."’ This is pleasant in its reminiscential sug- gestion and in its musical suavity, pitched, as is habitual with Mr. Phillips in his pur- ple patches, in the key of ‘“‘w’’; but it is put into the mouth of Acte, Poppwa’s un- successful rival in Nero's regard, and, like most of Mr. Phillips's more striking pas sages, it is conspicuously void of dramatic propriety. The conception of Nero's character and the construction of the fable show a similar defect of dramatic instinct. If we mistake not, Mr. Phillips has made a most careful study of Mr. Bernard W. Henderson's re- cent learned and (to use a wearying word in an unhackneyed connection) sympathetic volume on ‘The Life and Principate of the Emperor Nero.’ Something of Mr. Phillips's understanding of the melancholy estheti- cism of Nero’s temperament, as well as sev- eral pieces of business, seem to be derived from this source. Yet there is a firmer dramatic structure, a more moving libera- tion of pity and terror, in Mr. Henderson's historical study than in Mr. Phillips’s play. He has oddly chosen to conclude his piece in four acts with the burning of Rome— following hard upon the death of Popprwa— which Nero takes as a kind of atonement for the murder of Agrippina. This is the spectacular ending of the play as it stands: Nero- Biaze! Rage! Blaze! (The fame flashes up more fervently. } For now I am free of thy blood, I have appeased and atoned, Have atoned with cries, with crash ngs, and with flaming. Thy blood is no more on my head; I am purged, I am cleansed, I have given flaming Rome for the bed of thy death! O Agrippina! [He falls in a swoon. Acte runs towards him, | In “‘The Sin of David” the chief source of dramatic weakness was, as we took occa- sion at the time of its publication to point out, too soft and slight an expiation of a tragical sin. The defect in “Nero” is al- most precisely the same. The lines above, uttered by Nero in his ranting delusion, would have made an admirable conclusion to a fourth act, provided there was to have been a grim, ironic fifth act in which Otho should have had the “innings’’ which his- tory (for once more philosophic than poet- ry) conceded him, and Nero should have atoned in the only way that has ever proved permanently impressive in tragedy, by his death, for his tragical sins against Agrip- pina, against Otho, and against the inex- orable order of the world. Such an ending added to the piece exactly as it now stands might almost have persuaded us that Mr. Phillips is a dramatist. As it is, how- ever, it proves him more conclusively than his previous plays did a talented writer of elegiac verse, an expert composer of cyclo- ramic spectacle, who thinks habitually | rather in terms of poetic phrase than, as has been the way of the true dramatist | in terms of character, of concerted situa tion, of human destiny as it is shaped from | the clashing, fatal actions of men. The second part of “The Dynasts"’ (Max millan), Mr. Thomas Hardy's “drama of the Napoleonic Wars in three parts, nins teen acts and one hundred and thirty scenes,”” prevails a little over the regret that we expressed at the publication of the first part that so fine a faculty as Mr Hardy's should be employed in so uncouth and monstrous a production There is a greater proportionate amount of prose in this part, and Mr. Hardy's prose is always more readable than his rough-héwn, un melodious verse. There is, too, here rather less of unconvincing, supernatural machin ery, while of the hundred speaking parts of terrestrial personages all are vividly ac- tualized. The gift of panoramic vision over the face of the historied globe which con stituted the chief element of imaginative force in the first part, persists throughout the second, and Mr. Hardy's pessimisti philosophy of history as the operation of “Unmaliced, untmpassioned, nescient Will,"’ becomes still clearer. We hesitate to com- mit ourselves to an opinion of the final meaning and achievement of ‘‘The Dynasts”’ before the publication of the third and last part In the meantime, from the curious assortment of lyrical interludes, in metres ranging from Sapphics to terza rima, wherewith Mr. Hardy has chosen to adorn his colossal enterprise, we may select this fine bit of ‘“‘aerial music’’ as a specimen of his poetic vein at its best “They come, beset by riddling hail; They sway like sedges in a gale; They fail, and win, and win, and fall. Albuera! They gain the ground there, yard by yard, Their brows and hair and lashes charred, Their blackened teeth set firm and hard Their mad assailants rave and reel, And face, as men who scorn to feel, The close-lined, three-edged prongs of steel! Till faintness follows closing-in, When, faltering headlong down, they spin Like leaves. But those pay well who win A buera. Out of six thousand souls that sware To hold the mount or pass elsewhere, But eighteen hundred muster there. Pale Colonels, Captains, ranksmen lie, Facing the earth or facing sky; They strove to live, they stretch to die Friends, foemen, mingle; beap and heap Hide their hacked bones, Earth!—deep, deep, deep, Where harmless worms caress and creep Hide their hacked bones, Karth!—deep, deep, deep, Where harmless worms caress and creep. What man can grieve? what woman weep? Better than waking is to sleep! Albueral” The ‘Last Poems’ of ‘Laurence Hope” (The John Lane Co.) is the ultimate record of a fervid life lately brought to a tragic close Mrs. Nicholson, it may be said now with regretful candor, kept too closely to her favorite theme of “Love's supreme surren- der,” too rarely varied the sombre mono- chord of unresisted passion, for her work ever to achieve quite the position that her very remarkable abilities promised. To a Sapphic intensity of devotion to youth and the lure of youth, she added at times a note eae ae am mete. atta bnrastne tend hits adhins deaniei it cane ta

Page 24

The Nation. (Vol. 82, No. 2129 326 of frank savagery, as in these stanzas of “Atavism"’; “Deep In the Jungle vast and dim, That knew not a white man's feet, I smelt the odor of sun-warmed fur, Musky, savage, and sweet. Scent of fur and color of blood:— And the long dead instincts rose, I followed the lure of my season's mate,— And flew, bare-fanged, at my foes."’ At other times, as in the following lines, her Sapphic mood dissolved in visionary whimsies that yet found expression as viv- id and fragrant as Blake's: “My paramour was loneliness And lying by the sea, Seft songs of sorrow and distress Hie did beget in me. Later another lover came More meet for my desire. ‘Radiant Beauty’ was his name; His sons had wings of fire!’’ Yet such variety was not habitual with her. In the long run she was an Anglo- Indian “poetess of passion,’’ whose lyric torrent of words and gift of throbbing me- tre never quite availed to idealize the Ori- ental provocation of her themes. Her “Translations from the Book of Indian Love,’ as the present volume is styled in its sub-title, are likely to stand rather as a slightly dubious “human document” than as an addition to the true poetry of pas- sion Nevertheless, there are in it many pieces of unalloyed poetry. It is pleasant to take leave of her with such a pure and plaintive, and in a way symbolic, melody as this of “Kristna and his Flute”: ‘Be still, my heart, and listen, For sweet and yet acute I hear the wistful music Of Kristna and his fute. Across the cool, blue evenings, Throughout the burning daye, Persuasive and beguiling, He plays and plays and plays. Ab, none may hear such music Resistant to its charms, The household work grows weary, And cold the busband'’s arms. I must arise and follow, To seek, in vain pursuit, The blueness and the distance, The sweetness of that flute! In linked and liquid sequence, The plaintive notes dissolve Divinely tender secrets That none but he can solve. Ob, Kristna, I am coming, I can no more delay. My heart has flown to join thee,’ liow eball my footsteps stay?" Mr. Andrew Lang, the variously delight- ful and invariably readable, is never more delightful and readable than when he turns for a little while from Anthropology, or ottish History, or psychic phenomena, or the literary gossip of London, to meditate the poetic muse. His ‘New Collected rhymes’ (Longmans) have the metrical facility and grace, the urbane humor, that make his ‘Ballads of Books’ of such pleas- ant memory. The variety of the collection, however, Is rather unexpected. There is a series of Jacobite lyrics, a handful of ericket rhymes, some parodic Jubilee Po- ems, a group of Folk Songs, and three ballads written, as Mr. Lang tells us in his preface, “in competition with the street minstrels of the close of the six- teenth century.” All of these are spirited performances, but most of them are inter- esting rather archaically than methetical- ly. For the amateur of poetry the most attractive pieces are those described with a touch of mockery as “Critical of Life, Art, and Literature,” in which Mr. Lang exhibits his mingled aptitudes of critic, humorist, and verse writer. These stanzas from his “Rhyme of Oxford Cockney Rhymes (Exhibited in the Orford Maga- zine)" are a fair sample of his vein at its freshest: “Though Keats rhymed ‘ear’ to ‘Oytherea,’ And Morris ‘dawn’ to ‘morn,’ A worse example, it is clear, By Oxford Dons is ‘shorn.’ G——-y, of Magdalen, goes beyond These puny Cockneys far, And to ‘Magrath’ rhymes—Muse despond!— ‘Magrath’ he rhymes to ‘star’! Yes, G—~y shines the worst of all. He needs tu rhyme ‘embargo’; The man had ‘Margot’ at his call, He had the good ship Ary; Largo he had; yet doth he seek Further, and no embargo Restrains him from the odious, weak, And Cockney rhyme, ‘Chicago’! Oh, Hoxford was a pleasant plice To many a poet dear, And Saccharissa had the grice In Hoxford to appear. But Waller, if to Qytherea He prayed at any time, Did not implore ‘her friendly ear’ And think he had a rhyme."’ He would be a temerarious critic who should venture to make unfavorable ani- madversions upon Mr. Harry Seymour Koopman’s ‘At the Gates of the Century’ (The Everett Press), for Mr. Koopman can express his opinion of critics with pungen- cy, if not with urbanity. In one place he writes: ‘Whence comes your skill from song's vast mines The richest ore to choose? I simply gather up the lines Condemned in the reviews."’ In another, of Shelley’s “Prometheus Un- bound”: “Unbound, for who would bind it? the perplexed And sneering critics of the poet cried, Whose son saw English scholarship divide Over a doubtful comma in the text."’ In another: “Always the asses in chorus denounced the poet's arrival, Drowning the voice of his mus‘c, drowning his gathering praises, Idle to answer them, vainer to scold them than scolding the weather, For they will always be with us, the asses, and always be—critics."’ In still another: “The critic snarl at the Maker, what has it ever meant But jealousy of the Potent on the part of the Impotent?"’ Fortunately, there is little in Mr. Koopman’s slender but pithy book to arouse any other sentiment than admira- tion for his gift of compact, suggestive phrase. The amenities may prevail; and we may concede the truth of his epigram: “He riddles the mark and the neighborhood With a Gatling gun; I send one shot through the heart of the white, For I have but one."’ It would be unfair to Mr. Wilfred Camp- bell to insinuate that his poetic method is that of the Gatling gun, yet his ‘Collect- ed Poems’ (Revell) would have gained in poetic value by a more rigorous standard of selection, and by the drastic pruning of some of the pieces selected. At times Mr. Campbell shows himself the master of that long unsuspected accomplishment of M. Jourdain. No American poet is more con- sistently stirred by the “high emotion” which, as Mr. Campbell very justly declares in his Introduction, is the essence of poetry; none is more _ uninterruptedly capable of decorous, sonorous phrase. Yet at the best his phrase is, if we may venture a distinction, felicitous rather than hap- py. Read _ consecutively, his ‘Collected Poems’ are a little lacking in vivid poetic life, a little overweighted with irreproach- able moral, political, and msthetic senti- ments. Nevertheless, it is a volume ad- mirable in its sustained idealism; and at times, as in these stanzas from an elegy upon Archibald Lampman, Mr. Campbell’s poetry, touched with deep personal emo- tion, attains a forceful eloquence: “Soft fall the February snows, and soft Falls on my heart the snow of wintry pain; For nevermore, by wood or field or croft, Will he we knew walk with his loved again; No more, with eyes adream and soul aloft, In those high moods where love and beauty reign, Greet his familiar fields, his skies without a stain. . « « Like some rare Pan of those Old Grecian days, Here in our hours of deeper stress reborn, Unfortunate thrown upon life’s evil ways, His inward ear heard ever that satyr horn From Nature’s lips reverberate night and morn, And fled from men and all their troubled maze, Standing apart with sad, incurious gaze. And now, untimely cut, like some sweet flower Plucked in the early summer of its prime Before it reached the fulness of its dower, He withers in the morning of our time; Leaving behind him, like a summer shower, A fragrance of earth’s beauty, and the chime Of gentle and imperishable rhyme. Songs in our ears of winds and flowers and buds And gentle loves and tender memories Of Nature’s sweetest aspects. her pure moods, Wrought from the inward truth of intimate eyes And delicate ears of him who harks and broods, And, nightly pondering, daily grows more wise, And dreams and sees in mighty solitudes. Soft fall the February snows, and soft He sleeps in peace upon the breast of her He loved the truest; where, by wood and croft, The wintry silence folds in fleecy blur About his silence, while in glooms aloft The mighty forest fathers, without stir, Guard well the rest of him, their rare sweet worshipper."’ The ‘New World Lyrics and Ballads’ of Duncan Campbell Scott (Morang & Co.) are pieces of a keen poetic tang. Mr. Scott has taken imaginative possession of the cool, pine-grown, history-haunted Canadian country, and has sung of it in spare athletic verse. His poetic background is not of the broadest, his “criticism of life” not perhaps of the deepest, but he rarely fails to give his reader that delicious shock of surprise of strange and vivid beauty that is the final test of Poetry as distinguished from poetry. The seventh edition of Mr. Theodore Watts-Dunton’s ‘The Coming of Love, and Other Poems’ (The John Lane Co.) is de- scribed on the obverse title as “enlarged and revised."”" The enlargement consists chiefly of a “Dedication of the Seventh Edi- tion,” in which the coming of love is styled by Mr. Watts-Dunton, somewhat romantic- ally for so good a critic, “the expression of the heart-thought of my life,” and in the addition tothe title poem of certain sections which “had been lent to friends in manu- script and mislaid,” and “were not avail- able at the moment when the material of PPC ty — eS a ie ee ee

Page 25

ea oe ar fhe Nate wee April 19, 1906] The Nation. 327 the book was put together for the press.” Whether or not this statement is part of | the artistic mystification wherewith Mr. Watts-Dunton has filled his other ample and numerous Prefatory Notes to the poem, we do not presume to say. It is certain, however, that the additions add nothing to the completeness of the story, and that, in retarding its speed they rather dull its charm. Yet, for all the clap-trap that Mr. Watts-Dunton has chosen to spread round the poem, and despite these additions, its Gypsy zest and tragic passion do not lose their potency. Among the “other poems” the only new piece is this awkward but suggestive sonnet: NEW YEAR'S MORNING, 1867, AFTER THE LIBERATION OF VENICE. (The poet goes to the window of his bedroom and gazes down the Grand Canal, over which the morning is glowing.) “Man's knowledge, save before his fellow-man, Is ignorance—his widest wisdom folly. In Nature's eyes still gazing, dazzled wholly By sights his own eyes make, how should he scan Pictures like those in Nature's iris-span? Hers show the cypress, his the melancholy, His shine with Christmas, hers with simple holly That knew no mirth till Yule-tide feasts began."’ So Reason says; yet to my heart it seems That yonder sun, firing the mists of morn, Gilding each dome that scorned the Austrian’s scorn, Painting the Grand Canal with rosy gleams, Looks conscious down on me and vanished dreams— But—Freedom's year o'er Venice smiles new- born! Thofigh Mr. John Burroughs is not at his best as a poet, his little volume of nature poems, ‘Bird and Bough’ (Houghton, Mif- flin & Co.), is pleasant reading. The fresh- ness and precision of Mr. Burroughs’s ob- servation need no comment. He is a master of clean-drawn phrase, and, despite a tendency to lapse into sing-song, has a good gift of short-lined metre. So far as his work is poetry rather than versified nature study, it is so by virtue of a certain single-minded affectionateness of interest in Nature, as in these lines: “I hear the wild geese honking From out the misty night,— A sound of moving armies On-sweeping in their might; The river ice is drifting Beneath their northward flight. I hear the bluebird plaintive From out the morning sky, Or see his wings a-twinkle That with the azure vie; No other bird more welcome, No more prophetic cry. I hear the eparrow’s ditty Anear my study door; A simple song of gladness That winter days are o'er; My heart is singing with him, I love him more and more. I hear the atarling fluting His liquid ‘'O-ka-lee’’; I bear the downy drumming His vernal reveillé; From out the maple orchard The nuthatch calls to me. O, spring is surely coming, Her couriers fill the air; Each morn are new arrivals, Each night her ways prepare; I escent her fragrant garments, Her foot is on the etair."’ ‘Selections from the Poetry of John Payne,’ made by Tracy and Lucy Robinson with an | Lane Co.), is a fairly representative selec- | lines, as in all of Mr. Payne's work, and in | manner: “Could we but hope the all-engrossing earth, That for the eternal rest Took back her blighted beanty to its breast, Might yet enrich our dearth With some unknown, enchanted wonder-birth Of blossom, brilliant as her starry eyes, Sweet as her balmy breath, Some flowerage of heaven, defying death, Wherein our yearning memory might retrace The frankness of her face, The spirit-prime of her lost loveliness, Born as it were again Of mortal grossness by the purge of pain,— Or might we deem the unresponsive air, That bore her gentle spirit far away And scattered it for aye Beyond the confines of the night and day To all the winds of being, nor would e’er Vouchsafe to our despair One echo of her voice’s dulcet strain, Should yet grow great with graciousness and bear Some mystic birth of music strange and fair, Some seraph-song of Paradisal bird, Some melody of mortals never heard, Whereip her silver speech And the far memory of her voice might reach Our longing ears and witness to our faith She was not all disfeatured by the scaith Of unrespective death, That something of her sweetness yet survives In interstellar lands Or in the sunset-calm of epirit-lives, Nor was all scattered by the ‘scape of breath!"’ copiousness of phrase, make but a single sentence, something of Mr. Payne’s ability to sling poetic ink, if the expression be al- lowable, begins to be perceived. Yet that they are lasting poetry is not so clear. Mr. Payne, as we are emphatically told in the Introduction, is a devoted amateur of music, and the music of the vers- es, as is customary in the poet- ry of great music-lovers (notably movement of the lines, in the more obvious tricks of alliteration, than in those subtler harmonies of vowelled speech which make the quenchless music of poetry. Further- Introduction by Lucy Robinson (The John more, there is, if we mistake not, in these tion of the original work of one of the most | talented and indefatigable translators of | found in modern France their most sym our time. We do not hold with those who pathetic models, a tendency for profusion believe concerning Mr. Payne that “pos- terity will place him between Tennyson and William Morris, side by side with Swin- burne and D. G. Rossetti’; and that it is wholly “Mr. Payne’s lack of acquaintance with journalists and journalism” that has kept his work in the background. The first impression made by the selection is that of a marvellous virtuosity, an amazing metrical and verbal ingenuity. There are pieces in | French, pieces in Italian, and English poems of an astonishing variety and fluency of form. Of the poeticalness, so to say, of Mr. Payne’s literary impulse there can be no doubt. His mind fairly brims over with poetic thoughts, poetic emotions, and the imagery of all the romantic poetry of the world. Yet there can be but one conclu- sion: if Mr. Payne possessed at the begin- | ning of his literary career a poetic faculty that might have placed him beside Swin- burne and Rossetti, then the facility that comes from the life-long habit of transla- tion can only be regarded as the dissipa- tion of it. This crucial strophe from a mu- sical but somewhat over-long elegy for a dead girl, entitled “The Grave of All My Songs,” is a fair specimen of Mr. Payne’s | In whose bright beauty thought might recognize In some new earth, delivered from the press When it is observed that these lines, | with their variety of image, their easy | Sidney Lanier), is rather in the impetuous | | the work of most English poets who have to become diffusion that is a source of weakness. But if these poems have not such stuff of immortality in them as his sponsors think they find, it is, neverthe- less, not fair to Mr. Payne to dismiss him as a kind of Magico Prodigioso working his wonders from the more curious contents of the New English Dictionary. For a leisure ly reader there is a certain mild Spenserian charm in his narrative poems. And signs | have not been wanting that Mr. Payne, fol- lowing in the path of his master, the poets’ poet, is like to achieve a position of some permanency as the minor poets’ poet LORD HOBHOUSE Lord Hobhouse: A Memoir. By L. T. Hob- house and J. L. Hammond. London: E- ward Arnold; New York: Longmans. 1905 Lord Hobhouse was the incarnation of the intelligent Liberalism of 1850 to 1870 | In him we see the finest characteristics and | also the limitations of the Liberals who at that era represented all that was best in the public life of England He assuredly displayed all the finest traits of the body of men to whom he belonged. He was a com- | plete English gentleman; he was also, what many excellent gentlemen are not, a man of singular ability. Ill health, fortunately for his country and fortunately for himself, ar- rested his career at the bar. Had his bod- ily strength enabled him to stand the stress of an exciting and competitive professional career, he might probably have been a law officer of a Liberal Government. He might, if fortune had favored, have risen with gen- eral approval to the Chancellorship. He almost certainly, if he had failed to gain | the highest of legal prizes, would have passed the latter part of his life as a Lord Justice of Appeal. All this he would have done if his strength had held out, and theh he would have been, like other eminent judges, forgotten. He would have done ex- cellently work that many others could do as well as he. The misfortune which turned him away from the bar did not in reality deprive him | of appropriate employment, and it enabled | him to show, as no merely legal career | could, his intense and absorbing devotion to public affairs and to everything that con- cerned the interest of the nation. It is this high, enduring, absolutely disinterested public spirit, combined with rare ability in the transaction of public business, which gives its whole color to Hobhouse’s career, and this fine public spirit and devoted ap- plication of trained intelligence to the con- duct of affairs are exactly the traits which lent a certain nobility to the energetic and intelligent Liberalism of the Victorian era. | No doubt the virtues of a time which seems now so far removed in feeling from | modern England, are represented by Hob- | house in their best and noblest form. Still, one can never for a moment forget, and his biographers do not suffer us to forget, that he was, when Liberalism was in fashion, and also when Liberalism of his type was out of fashion, essentially “‘a Liberal of the old school.”” None of the ideas he enter- tained can be called original, but then they are some of the best ideas of the party to Ce tame

Page 26

B28 The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2129 which he belonged, and Hobhouse held them He esteemed high- with singular tenacity ly the new Poor Law of 1834. He distrusted, rightly enough, the effect of endowments. He fought, tooth and nail, as an Endowed School Commissioner, for the destruction of all the noxious charities which, under the pretence of furthering education, really gave effect to the bitterness, vanity, or ec- centricity of some so-called pious founder. In India, as the legal member of the Gov- ernment’s Council, he fought hard, and probably did much to promote just legisla- tion, and opposed with all his vigor the forward policy of Mr. Disraeli and of Lord Lytton Every kind of injustice, or everything which Hobhouse thought was injustice, was to him hateful He hated war, and fully believed in the blessings of peace on almost any terms He believed in local govern- ment, and generally adhered to the Liberal doctrine that to give men a share in local government is the way to teach them to govern wisely. Till towards the end of his life, he seems to have felt, in common with the Liberals of the day, the trust in the people which at one time was the watch- word of Mr. Gladstone and his followers. To everything, again, which savored of at- tack on freedom of opinion he offered zeal- ous opposition. He supported Bradlaugh in 1888, and a year later had a friendly correspondence with Holyoake; not be- cause he agreed with their views, but be- cause he regarded them as the defenders of free thought. Amid arduous judicial work he “found time” (to use the pompous language of his biographers) ‘“‘year by year for the furtherance of many movements— London government, land reform, and even the liberation of Sunday from the trammels of the Judaic law’’—trammels, by the way, which sit with extraordinary lightness on English men and women of to-day. Let no one deny—we assuredly do not deny—that these labors were in the main the work of a good man, and that Hobhouse himself left behind him something even better than his work, namely, the “example of a man who, through a long life, put the public service above personal ambition, who found in work its own reward, small and great, with equal thoroughness, because it was work and had to be done.”’ All this is excellent, and we fully believe that a eulogy which savors somewhat of an inscription on a tombstone has the rare merit of absolute truth. Still, a eritic who ought not to be a flatterer must insist upon the patent fact that the virtues, the principles, and the ideas of Lord Hobhouse, though they were his own, yet were also in a special sense the characteristics of the political school to which he belonged. Hobhouse's own character, moreover, be- trays the moral and intellectual limitations of the Old Liberals They were men of [trong common-sense But then, common- ense is occasionally a very different thing from wisdom I have intimated,’ writes Hobhouse, “my deep distrust of a-priori reasoning on practical subjects." The sentiment is a sound one, but, as employed by a Liberal of 1850, it too often meant the failure of any attempt thoroughly to understand either his own principles or those of his opponents. The tendency of the day was, indeed, to mistake maxims for well-established principles. Whenever Lord Hobhouse deals with any’ matter which re- quires subtlety or even play of thought, one feels that he never gets to the bottom of it. “He held,” say his biographers, “that no fundamental distinction can be drawn between the obligations of nations and those of individuals.”” This maxim would probably command pretty general assent, but any one who thinks over the matter at all will see that it embodies a doctrine which is far from self-evident, and can be accepted only with considerable limitations. To the confusion of maxims with axiom- atic truths is due another defect which is strangely visible in every word that Lord Hobhouse utters about opponents. The men who dissent from the Liberal creed are considered by him as persons distinctly in the wrong. He cannot credit them with either genius or insight. Consider the many allusions throughout the memoir to Dis- raeli. In none of them is there the least recognition of the great fact that he was a man who, with all his faults, had quali- ties which will make him remembered when Lord Hobhouse, Lord Melbourne, Lord Cardwell, and all the good and respectable Liberals of 1850 are forgotten. Lord Bea- consfield is, in the eyes of Hobhouse and his friends, nothing but the adventurer and the charlatan which he appeared to his critics of 1852. A comparison between Lord Hobhouse’s attitude towards Disraeli and Mr. Bryce’s estimate of Lord Beaconsfield in ‘Studies of Contemporary Biographies’ displays the whole difference between the condemnation of a worthy but unintelligent opponent and the judgment of a thoughtful and impartial critic. Lord Hobhouse, lastly, in common with the body of Old Liberals, pursued a path of which he hardly, till towards the close of his life, foresaw the end. Trust in the people is a maxim which points directly towards democracy. But the last thing per- ceived by Liberals who confided in the wis- dom of the people was, that the people—or, in other words, the mass of the wage-earn- ers—were little likely in the long run to accept the social or political doctrines of Liberalism. Hobhouse looked, in 1897, with grave suspicion on measures such as the Workmen's Compensation Act. He, by that time, at least, had perceived the contradic- tion between the dogmas of Old Liberalism and the tendencies of democratic Socialism. He felt that “there is nothing for the isolated thinker to do except to sit by and wonder what will come next. I guess that the next thing will be to throw all the burden of individ- ual misfortune on ‘the State,’ which the wise leaders of the artisan classes teach them to look upon as an omnipotent being, existing apart from individual men and wo- men, with an inexhaustible purse filled by some magic, and ready to remove all the ills of life. And so they cry more and more for ‘State’ aid, not knowing that they them- selves are the State, and that payments by the State come mainly out of their own pockets and are to a large extent a device for making the industrious and thrifty pay for those who are not such.” Did it, even in 1904, dawn upon him that the day might be near when the Labor Party would destroy all that he most val- ued in the creed of the Old Liberals? Cloud Studies. By Arthur W. Clayden, M.A. E. P. Dutton & Co. 1906. Not only meteorologists, but laymen who care for the ever-changing panorama of the sky, will welcome this fine book, first pub- lished in London by John Murray. Titles of some of the subjects treated will give an idea of its scope: “Cloud Types,” “Alti- tudes,” “High Cirrus,” “Formation,” “Cu- mulus,” “Influence of Hills,’ ““Nomencla- ture,”” and the like. More than sixty ex- cellent illustrations from photographs serve to show many forms of classified and inter- mediate clouds, heretofore but slightly dif- ferentiated. Not until 1803 was there any attempt at uniformity of description. In that year Luke Howard proposed three names for three dis- tinct varieties—cirrus, stratus, and cu- mulus; by combinations of these words other types were identified; and because the discharging cloud may partake some- what of the character of all three, it was called nimbus. Mr. Clayden does not re- gard this as a special type, but includes it in the general stratus variety, using the word nimbus as an adjective, and only to indicate that rain is falling from a certain cloud. While some meteorologists will agree to this departure, others will prob- ably not accept it. What may be called the observational part of cloud study is still in its infancy, despite the fact that countless generations have viewed the sky with a general desire for information as to the weather. No common language, or system of terms, was employed, by which early experience could be accurately transmitted. A curious scarcity of cloud names occurs in all lan- guages, and personal equation often caused existing designations to be used for quite different phenomena. Accordingly, the de- cisions of the International Meteorological Conference at Munich in 1891 were welcom- ed, even if not the most perfect of classi- fications. A revised scheme of nomencla- ture was presented by the late Hon. Ralph Abercromby and Prof. H. Hildebrand Hil- debrandsson of Upsala, with the idea that such a convenient arrangement would be- come useful at meteorological stations and in the navy. For the sake of simplicity, only ten forms were proposed, as now given in the International Cloud Atlas. While sufficient, however, for general purposes, a great many subdivisions were of course necessary in specialized work, in cloud transformation, or the relation of types to weather. Each of these large divisions changes by varying gradations into many other sub-species, whose names should in- dicate their origin and characteristics. The Atlas did not appear until 1896, and meantime the Rev. W. Clement Ley had published some excellent suggestions, which, however, came too late. Meteorologists in Germany, England, and America have attempted an extended and detailed cloud-nomen- clature, and Mr. Clayden carries this excellent work forward with praiseworthy clearness and simplicity. The next world- gathering assembled to discuss these sub- jects will probably effect any desired changes along lines of modification rather than substitution. It is now possible, through this wide discussion and uni- formity of designation, to arrive at some- thing like precision of description, a first essential to a satisfactory system; in spite of which many pictorial illustrations must still be employed, so delicate is the grada- tion from one type of cloud to another. By the use of soft pastels aided by the finger- wets

Page 27

§ senna Ss i ' : i ih Sete ak he April 19, 1906] tip in sketching cloud forms, satisfactory results can sometimes be obtained, but oil and water-colors are scarcely rapid enough to follow changes exactly. Only the most sensitive photographic plates can repro- duce the infinite delicacy of detail. Some of the illustrations in Mr. Clayden’s book from direct photography are exceedingly beautiful—poetic as well as scientific, and the directions given for obtaining them, in the chapter upon this method of study- ing forms, are of great value. Mr. Clayden remarks pertinently that it would be well if artists of landscape would occasionally give some little study to the clouds they introduce, instead of presenting the usual vague splashes of white so gen- erally made to do duty for pictured skies One recalls the cry in one of Ruskin’s let- ters: “I want to be able to draw clouds, and to understand how they go—and I can't make them stand still,nor understand them —they all go sideways. .. .” The story of a thunder-shower is sci- entifically, even dramatically, told, with careful description of changes in the cu- mulus headquarters of the storm, and with remarkable attendant photographs. The author’s views as to the causes of differing cloud forms are exceedingly probable, and the book is full of suggestiveness for fur- ther investigation. Exact personal obser- vation forms the basis of the entire volume, which cannot be too highly recommended to students of this delightful branch of celes- tial research. All the varieties depicted and described have been selected from hundreds of examples, as showing differences due to conditions of formation. Diagrams and other purely technical matters are avoided, so that the book, while of great value to specialists, is hardly less interesting to the general reader, and will be immense- ly helpful in continued and more accurate study of this fascinating subject. Such a book is well worth an index of more than two pages. Problems of Philosophy; or, Principles of Epistemology and Metaphysics. By Dr. James Hervey Hyslop, Ph.D., LL.D. Mac- millan. Pp. xiv., 647. 1905. Dr. Hyslop’s book has an abundance of defects and lays itself open to criticism in a variety of ways. To begin with, it ex- tends to 650 pages, and is too heavy to hold. The average length of its chapters is 50 pages, and in one case exceeds 100. with- out a section or a break to articulate them; and even its paragraphs not infrequently prolong themselves to three pages. It has no literary charm, and its wording is often obscure. It bears many marks of its origi- nal lecture form, which should have been eliminated. It gives no references. It con- tains a large number of highly dubious historical statements. In short, it is a book which a _ hostile or wearied critic would have ample excuse for condemning utterly. And yet, in spite of all these serious faults, we have found Dr. Hyslop’s book in some respects an impressive work. It is, in the first place, very honest. We seem to see its author sturdily wrestling with the great problems of philosophy; and even when he plainly seems to be worsted, we find ourselves reflecting that those prob- lems have always proved too great for any The Nation. man. Thus its very defects have something humanly attractive; they evoke the sympa- thy we naturally feel for an honest strug- gle against overwhelming odds. And so long as so many philosophers aim at no- thing higher than mere dialectical clever- ness in playing with problems which, after displaying their mental agility and (it must be added) disingenuousness, they leave pretty much where they found them, the moral atmosphere of Dr. Hyslop's work is decidedly refreshing. In the next place, Dr. Hyslop, if not startlingly original, is distinctly independent He has the cour- age to swim against the stream and to ig- nore the fashions. Lastly, he seems to be fundamentally right about some of his main contentions, such as that idealism ought in consistency to confess to solipsism, that the antithesis between it and realism prop- erly concerns epistemology rather than metaphysics, that the real metaphysical an- tithesis is between materialism and spiri- tualism, and that what renders it really im- portant is that the former denies, while the latter affirms, the possibility of a fu- ture life. By “spiritualism’’ he means the denial that consciousness is a function of material organization, and the affirmation of the reality of soul, without, however, telling us what he precisely means by “soul.”” This philosophic usage easily de- velops an affinity for the vulgar sense of “spiritualism” when it is added that the question of the existence of a “‘soul’’ can be decided, not by philosophic speculation, but only by scientific research In this contention Dr. Hyslop is doubtless right; but might not the same be said of every philosophic topic? Does speculation ever do more than explore the ground be- fore science proceeds to effect a stable oc- cupation? In all these points Dr. Hyslop’s views seem sufficiently interesting and im- portant to sanction a regret that, instead of entangling and stifling them in masses of unessential words, he did not bethink himself of the wise old Greek adage that sometimes the half is greater than the whole. The Life of Oliver Ellsworth. By William Garrott Brown. Macmillan. 1905. Pp. ix., 369. It is, on the whole, surprising that Oliver Ellsworth should have had to wait so long for a biographer. The task, it must be admitted, presented some difficulties. Un- like many of his contemporaries who, with him, were making American histecry, Ells- worth was a singularly reticent man. His legal opinions were excessively brief. He did not indulge in “journalizing.”” He wrote few letters, and most of these dis- appeared. Of the great number of papers to which, in the course of a long and ac- tive life, he must have set his hand, few of importance have survived. His bi- ographer, accordingly, finds a dearth of material, and is forced to rely much up- on that indispensable and most danger- ous faculty of the historian—imagination Yet the career of Ellsworth, if not as a whole of first-rate significance, was nev- ertheless such as to give him high rank among the founders of his country. He was a lawyer of solid attainments, a clear- headed and effective judge, a forcible and convincing debater, and a skilful manager B29 of men. As a member of the Connecticu’ pay-table, he largely directed the Revolu tionary policy of his State. As a member of the Congress of the Confederation, he labored unceasingly to build up the federal administration. In the Federal Convention of 1787, no influence was superior to his, and some of the most important provisions of the Constitution are due mainly to him He was admittedly the leader of the Ser- ate so long as he was a member of it He was a dignified and industrious chief- justice, and an astute and broad-minded represeytative of his country at the French court. With all, he was a New Englander and a gentleman. Yet his name and his work passed quickly out of particular re membrance, and he has waited nearly a century for some one to tell worthily the story of his life The reasons for this neglect are not however, altogether obscure. The lack of literary remains has doubtless told heavily against him Had he kept a diary, like John Adams, or copied his letters, like Jefferson, or written pamphlets and news paper articles, like Hamilton or Madison or elaborated his legal decisions, Ike Marshall, we should long since have had a limited and costly edition of his collected works, and been able thereby to measure his importance mere nearly as it appeared to his contemporaries Again, while he was a stanch advocate and able expounde: of Federalism, he lacked the ability so to present his ideas as to make them seem original with him. He never, for example rivalled Hamilton as an expositor of the theory of the Constitution, though he did rather more, on the whole, than any on: else to give pructical effect to Hamilton's views. Further, he lost a great opportunity in the Federal Convention to restrain the growth of slavery, and perhaps, as Mr Brown suggests, to put an early end to the system altogetler, by his attitude towarda the slave trade And, finally, he never reached an entirely sound theory of consti tutional law, as appears in his contention that the Unit:.1 States, as well as the States, inherited the common law, and his erroneous interpretation, in Wilson vs Daniel, of the constitutional provisions re- garding the appellate jurisdiction of the Supreme Court. It is true that Ellsworth lived in a formative period, when prece- dents were to Se made rather than quoted, and that he was far oftener right than wrong; but there were others of the time who, at these several points, builded more solidly than he, and for this reason, prob- ably, posterity has adjudged him not al together great. Yet the character of Ellsworth was so lofty, his devotion to the public welfare so sincere and unseifish, and his industry so painstaking and tireless, as to win for him a high place even in a generation thickly set with great names. In his dignified bear- ing, his industry, frugality, and thrift, his combination of aristocratic reserve and emotional restraint with rare conversation al powers, and his serious regard for re ligion, he was typical of the eighteenth century New England in which he was born and bred, and whose welfare he always held dear. The public service was with him a public trust, aod a long career in positions of responsibility and exaltation brought with it no taint of mora! weakness or su % RIS. SO A ey AO wor nns ea eee

Page 28

330 picion. His devotion to the wearisome and interminable details of administrative and judicial business, in a day when the or- ganization of such business had as yet reached but slignt development, was beyond all praise, as it was also one of the secrets Nothing, indeed, but ex- powers and an iron of his influence. traordinary physical will could have enabled him to do what he did. No preseave save that of Washington was more imposing, no words more weighty than his, and he won alike the respect of men and the affection of children. Mr. Brown has done his work with not- able success. The materials which he has used have been widely dispersed and far from abundant, but he has gathered them industriously and employed them with skill, and has 1:efrained from drawing upon conjecture for facts. The chapter on Ells- worth's work in the Federal Convention is especially abl Of course, the book Is readable, for Mr. Brown is the happy pos- sor of a brilliant style; but readers who have found the author's earlier works too strikingly phrased, will note with satis- faction in this one evidences of greater maturity and restraint. As a judicious and sympathetic study of a notable American tatesman and jurist, the volume is heartily to be welcomed China and her People By Charles Denby. 1905. Boston L. C. Page & Co The American who is thoughtful as well as patriotic does not swell with pride when he looks over the list of our envoys and plenipotentiaries in the Far East, though some names that shine with the permanence of the while the in- fluence of their lives rather increases than Such a man was our minister to China, Charles there are stars, diminishes as the years roll on Denby A Virginian and ex-soldier, Colonel of the Eightieth Regiment, Indiana Volun- teers, during the civil war, he was in 1885 minister to Peking by Presi- thirteen years he rep- appointed dent Cleveland, For resented his country during three adminis- trations and part of a fourth, holding also the unbroken of the Chinese ties As the story of Verbeck, In confidence author and Williams, in China, has demon- foreigner who asks no per- Japan atrated, the sonal favors and has nothing to do with that marketable commodity called in Amer- ica “pull,” but who attends to the business on which he was sent and serves all un- selfishly, can win and hold the permanent respect of men who, besides understanding the lower motives common to most mortals, quick moral superiority in an alien have discernment of the proofs of rhe present publication, edited from the deceased author's manuscripts by his son, two or three additional chapters, ial value in the fact that it is who adds has its apex not a mere description of things seen or read about, nor is it a mere traveller's tale It is rather the leisurely reflections, with delightful comment, spiced by wit and wis- dom, of a man who saw into causes, and read human nature searchingly, but with sympathy Apparently he laid aside those prejudices which usually mar an allen’s judgment His pen pictures of the great men of China and Japan who were his con- temporaries are incisive and interpretative. His own very important part in the me- The Nation. diatory negotiations which brought the Chino-Japanese war of 1894-5 to an end are frankly and modestly stated. The Boxer | uprising is treated with insight and sym- pathy. Yet we cannot find that he does justice to the behavior of the American Admiral (whose name is spelled wrongly) who upheld the American policy of non-in- tervention and refused to bombard the Chinese forts in time of peace. Indeed, the two statements in the author’s text, on pages 191 and 200, do not correspond as to the important points of the day, the hour, and the reasons for the attack, while it is intimated that the Monocacy was “present” in the actual fighting, without taking part, instead of being, as she was, some distance away in shelter, the shell striking her being a spent missile. For- eign life in Peking is pleasantly described, and the criticisms of Great Britain's policy and of Russian methods are those of a man with a well-balanced mind, keen vision, and practised pen. Mr. Denby per- ceived clearly the underlying causes of the Russo-Japanese war. From the be- ginning of his work in China, he stood boldly and bravely for the policy of the open door, while with all his ability and persuasive power he protested against the partition of China. His sympathy with the missionaries and his correct and judicial attitude toward them arose from the fact that, by personal investigation and jour- neys in various parts of the empire, he knew exactly what they were doing, both in spirit and in method. He could thus judge them at first hand and forecast their ultimate influence. The concluding chapter, by the editor, on the Russo-Japanese war, is bright and readable, though the Admiral Togo pictured is the junior officer, born in Echizen, and not the mighty Togo of Satsuma. It is discreditable to a respectable writer to talk about “Japs” instead of Japanese. The middle name of Commodore Matthew Perry was Calbraith, not Galbraith. These, and a few similar inaccuracies, however, are but minor blemishes in a very de- lightful and informing book, in two daintily clothed and easily held volumes, beautiful- ly illustrated. While Dr. S. Wells Wil- liams’s ‘The Middle Kingdom,’ after a half- century of original writing and a quarter of a century of revision, still continues to be standard and in the van, ‘China and her People’ is perhaps the most readable work upon a country and people of whom it be- | hooves Americans to know more. Lirica Italiana Antica; Novissima Scelta di Rime dei Secoli xiii., xiill., xv., illustrate con sessanta riproduzioni di pitture, mi- niature, sculture, incisioni e melodie del tempo e con note dichiarative. Da Eu- genia Levi. Florence: Leo S. Olschki. 1906. Signorina Levi has already made herself known by an anthology of contemporary Italian poets under the title of ‘Dai Nostri Poeti Viventi’ (third edition, Florence, F. Lumachi, 1904). That book labors under the disadvantage common to its kind, in that, in attempting to pass a more or less decisive judgment on living authors and their works, it assumes a task that can be accomplished only by time. Palgrave, in the preface to the second volume of his [Vol. 82, No. 2129 ‘Golden Treasury of Songs and Lyrics,’ tes- tifles that his second series cost him thrice the labor of the first, for the reason that “nothing is harder than to form an esti- mate even remotely accurate of our own contemporary artists, whatever the sphere of their art.” In like manner the book now under review is better than the other, not only because it deals with the greatest period of Italian literature, but also be- cause many authors and many poems have already been chosen from out the mass by the infallible verdict of centuries. Mr. Gilbert Murray, in his ‘History of Greek Literature,’ remarks that, although by separating instrumental music from its originally chief function of accompanying the human voice, the modern world has de- veloped music as an independent art to a perfection and power of expression un- known to the ancients, modern lyric poetry suffers by the inevitable law of compensa- tions from a disunion with its natural part- ner of vocal and instrumental music. Aris- totle’s assertion in the ‘Poetics’ (I., 4) that performers on the flute and lyre employed only tbe elements of and pv@ués (“music” and “‘rhythm”’), 1s enough to show that. independent instrumental music was known to the Greeks. But we have no evi- dence that the idea of polyphonic instru- mentation ever occurred to them. It is indeed true that no form of Greek art, not even their painting, is so hopelessly lost to us as the art of Greek lyric poetry; and it is much to be feared that the glory and freshness of that age when the lyric poet wrote his notes along with his verses, never thinking of one without the other, when the two were in performance equally inseparable, are gone forever. But Mr. Murray might have observed that the Ital- fans of the Middle Age possessed a lyric poetry which was almost as closely allied to music as that of ancient Greece. The poets of the thirteenth century and their successors did not, to be sure, compose music for their own songs; but these al- ways, or nearly always, received their set- ting from a musician like Dante’s friend Casella. Even in Elizabethan England, the same condition prevailed, though perhaps not to the same extent. Milton’s thirteenth sonnet, addressed to Mr. H. Lawes, shows how much importance he attached to the skilful musical setting and performance of lyric poetry. Therefore it was an excellent plan of Signorina Levi's to print along with her text some examples of the music to which popular poetry was sung during the three centuries from which the poems are drawn. To be sure, the melodies to which the songs of the great poets were sung have not come dowa to us in many instafices. Signorina Levi gives us the notes of only one song by a known author who flourished earlier than the beginning of the fifteenth century, namely, the hymn of Beato Giovanni Co- lombini of Siena which begins, In su quell’ alto monte (p. 130). We believe that there is no similar example from an earlier pe- riod. However, it is a well-known fact that it was the custom in Italy from very early times to sing religious hymns to popular airs. The editor tells us in her introduction (p. xxv), that in almost all the hymn-books, printed or manuscript, which she had occasion to consult, belong- ing to the Sfteenth and early part of the appovia ee ATE In" ion wt eae et Ee

Page 29

; A t q : Andes. oa April 19, 1906] The Nation. 331 sixteenth centuries, she found above or be- to Guido Orlandi, of which the first qua- low the text of the hymns the words Cantasi come, followed by the first line of a profane song. Accordingly, most of the melodies reproduced in her book go with religious lauds of unknown authorship if they are early, sometimes by known au- thors if they are of more recent date. For example, we find the music for hymns com- posed by Savonarola, Lucrezia de’ Medici, train runs: “Una figura della doona mia s’adora, Guido, a San Michele in Orto, che di belle sembianze, onesta e pia, de’ peccatori @ gran rifugio e porto."’ The note on this sonnet does not tell the | reader that the Guido addressed was Guido Orlandi, or that he wrote in reply a beauti- | ful sonetto doppio: and Lorenzo de’ Medici. And thus, although | we have unhappily lost the airs to which | the lyrics of the great poets of the earlier period were sung, we can at least form some notion of their character. But it is not only with melodies that Signorina Levi has illustrated her text. Since all the art of the great period was produced under the same conditions and in- formed with the same spirit, she has also introduced sixty reproductions of pictures, miniatures, sculptures, and engravings; and, in order to avoid printing the whole book on heavy paper, she has caused the photo- graphic reproductions to be pasted on sep- arate sheets. Under each illustration she gives the name and date of the artist when known, the material, subject, and present locality of the original, and a brief decrip- tive note, sometimes culled from Vasari and other early writers; and we can assure our readers that it is most delightful to read Guido delle Colonne’s Amor che lusingamente m’ ai menato, with a facsimile on the opposite page of the song in a manuscript, adorned with beautiful min- jatures; Dante’s Donne ch’ avete intel- letto d’amore, seeing at the same time Giotto’s figure of Hope from the Capella degli Scrovegni at Padua; or Politian’s La non ouol esser pik mia, illustrated with a detail from Benozzo Gozzoli’s fresco in the Camposanto at Pisa. The editor has shown excellent sense and spirit in furnishing her readers with very full tables and indices. After a chronologi- cal list of writers and artists, comes an “S'avessi detjo. amico, di Maria gratia piena e pia rosa vermiglia se’ piantata in orto,"’ in which he reproaches his friend for his light comparison of his mistress to the Virgin, and for his irreligious contempt of the Frati Minori. In fact, in such an an- thology, the sonnet should never have been included without its reply In the fourth line of Cavalcanti’s sonnet, Signorina Levi reads, instead of gran rifugio e porto, “‘rifu- gio e conforto,” a version which we have never seen before, and which is not recog- nized as a variant in Arnone’s complete critical edition of Cavalcanti’s poems (Florence: Sansoni, 1881). The reading of the proofs must have been | very carelessly done. We have discover- index of first lines arranged under the | names of the poets, then indices (1) of poems arranged according to their various forms, with definitions of these forms, often quoted from famous writers, (2) of the illustrations, and (3) of the melodies, followed by a brief account of early Italian music, and notes explaining the music printed im the book. After the text come brief explanatory notes, and finally a bib- liographical index of texts and editions cited. We are sorry, in reviewing a book so praiseworthy in conception, to be compelled to call attention to serious lapses in its execution. Explanatory notes in such an edition must of necessity be brief; but brevity does not necessarily imply meagre- ness, and Signorina Levi’s commentary is of that meagreness which seems to come of insufficient knowledge. Although Eng- lish readers will always think of Shelley's translation in connection with Dante’s Guido, vorrei che tu e Lapo ed io, it is perhaps too much to expect an Italian editor to notice it, but in any commentary worthy of the name no such obvious imi- tation ought to pass unmentioned as that of Horace’s ode, ©O Venus, regia Onidi Paphique (Carm. I, 30) in Lorenzo de’ Medi- ci’s sonnet, Lascia Pisola tua tanto diletta. Again, every lover of Italian poetry will remember Guido Cavalcanti’s fine sonnet ed, quite incidentally, the following print- er’s errors not corrected in the errata. In heading No. 6, p. xxvi, Gentil should read Umil, and the page number 289 instead of 295. On page ix, line 12, read della instead of lalla, and on page 213, line 14, una in- stead of uta We were surprised not to see the name of Cina da Pistoia in the combined index of authors and first lines. But, having accidentally discovered one of his sonnets in the text, we looked through the whole book and found that four of his poems are given, on pages 121, 131, 174, and 180. Florentine Palaces and their Stories. By Janet Ross. With many illustrations by Adelaide Marchi. London: J. M. Dent; New York: E. P. Dutton & Co. 1905. The history of the principal Florentine palaces, with that of the great families to whom they owe their origin, is full of ro- mantic incident and adventure. Hence Miss Ross’s book cannot fail to attract the reader, for she has a special talent for choosing from severe history what is most characteristic and picturesque, and her knowledge of Italian sources of informa- tion, ancient and modern, is very exten- sive. She describes no less than seventy- six palaces, beginning with their architects and ending with their present owners. Of these many are comparatively unimportant, some having been much altered in recon- struction, while preserving still some nota- ble architectural feature of their past like- ly to attract the careful observer of an- cient buildings. These would naturally have no mention in the ordinary guide- book, so that this work will be found use- ful for reference, besides affording good reading. It is to be regretted that the il- lustrations are neither effective nor useful; for the most part they represent well- known themes in pen-and-ink outline with little shading, while the text seems to de- mand innumerable cuts of architectural detail. In telling of the principal palaces, such as the Palazzo Vecchio, the Bargello, the Riccardi, the Strozsi, the Passi, the Pitti, etc., all the important and tragic scenes in Florentine history are very fully given from documents of the time, and Miss Ross always when it is possible translates from these original sources directly, besides quoting from old letters and other data which have more recently come to light The book describes the manner of life and individual bistory of all the principal Flor Buck, Gertrude entine citizens who built palaces known to fame, beginning with the Acciatuoll, in 1109, down to quite recent times The reader will get an accurate idea of Floren tine ceremonies, customs, business rela tions, marriage contracts, vendettas, and all the incidents which go to the making of life, but the volume will be found more interesting for reference than for consecu tive perusal. BOOKS OF THE WEEK Abeille, Léonce. Marine Francaise et Marines Etrangéres. Paris: Armand Col.n Arthur, Richard. Ten Thousand Miles in a Yacht Dutton. 2 net Baedeker's Deutschland Lemeke & Buechner Barrows, Charles H. The Personality of Jesus Boston: Houghton, Mifiin @ Co. $1.25 net Benattar, César. L’Eaprit Libéral du Coran. Paris Ernest Leroux. Blochmann, Reinhart. Scientifie German Henry Holt & Co. SB) cents pet Bradford, Gamaliel, i Ketween Two Masters Boston: Houghton. Mifliin & Co. $1.% Branch, Joseph G. Heat and Light from Municipal and Other Waste. St. Louls: Wm. H OU Briea Printing and Publishing Co A Course io Narrative Writing Henry Holt & Co, 80 cents net Burgess, Gelett. A Little Sister of Destiny. Bos ton: Houghton, Mifflin & Co 1.00 Butler, — Parker. Pigs is Pigs. McClure, Phillips & Co. Cappelli, A. Cronologia and Calendario Perpetuo lameke & Buechner Chesterton, G. K., and W. Robertson Nicol! Rob ert Louis Stevenson James Pott & Co i) cents. | Cutting, Mary Stewart More Stories of Married life. McClure. Phillips & Co Dodge, Henry Nehemiah. Mystery of the West Boston: Richard G. Badger Demey. M. E. Tangled Threads. Boston: Richard sadger Fariss, Amy Cameron. The Sin of Saint Desmond Boston: Richard G. Badger Finberg, A. J The English Water Colour Paint ers. Dutton, 75 centa. Fisher, Irving. Infinitesimal Calculus Macmil lan Co Genung, Geo. F. Leviticus and Numbers Phila delphia: American Baptist Publication Soctety Gilmore, J. H. Outlines of English and American Literature. Rochester: Scranton, Wetmore & Co Gorky, Maxim. Creatures that Once Were Men Translated by J. K. Shiraz! Funk & Wagnalls Xo. TS cents Hale, Edward Everett. The Foundations of the Republic. James Pott & Co. 75 cents net meer. O, The Four Million McClure, Phillips & . Hewlett, Maurice, The Works of. Vol. VIII: The Fool Errant. Macmillan Co. $3 net Hitchcock, Alfred M. A_ Practice-Book in English Composition, Henry Holt & Co, SO cents net Jaurés, Jean. Studies in Socialism Putnams $1 net. Jefferies, Richard After London, Dutton. $1.50 Life Stories of Undistinguished Americans as Told by Themselves. Edited by Hamilton Holt James Pott & Co. $1.50. Lincoln, Abraham, Complete Works of. Edited by John G. Nicolay and John Hay. Vols. Ill and IV. Francis D. Tandy Co. Little, Frances. The Lady of the Decoration Century Co, Maitiand, 8. Jobn ne Co. Newell, Frederick Haynes. Irrigation in the United States. Thomas Y. Crowell Oo. §2 net Paine, Albert Bigelow. The Lacky Piece The Outing Publishing Co. $1.5 Robertson, Florence H Shadow Land. Boston Richard G. Badger Rewland, Henry ©. In the Shadow. Appleton The Reformation in England Shaw, Bernard. Plays: Pleasadt and Unpleasant 2 vole. Brentano's Shaw, J. Austin. The Best Thing in the World Norwich, Conn.: Chas. C. Haskell & Co Siegfried, André. Le Canada. Paris: Armand Colla Sill, Louise Morgan. In Suan or Shade. Harpers $1.50 net. Simpson, E. Balantyre: ly Tauls Stevenson Boston: Jobn W. Lace Co, % cents net Ta oan, Eva March. } AM. Hero Stories Houghton, uitiie & Co. SS cents net Trinitarian, Porgeries ated by « Monothelst ress White, William 450. In Our Town { \ .». Wilde. Oscar. The vecms of 2 vol. F. M Buckles & Co. $2 ne Wilkinson, BR. J. Malay Beliefe. Londoo: lLuzae Wilson. Francis Joseph Jefferson Seribners nans, Walter. Practical [Rifle Shooting Put- bams, WO cents vet McClure, aD Se OTe ee Hee Tey rere ee *.08- 30

Page 30

332 The Nation. RECENT BOOKS IN ENGLISH AND MODERN LANGUAGES Henry Holt and Company @ WEST 28D 8T., NEW YORK 378 WABASH AVE., CHICAGO Englisb All Prices Net Newcomer and Seward’s Rhetoric in Practice By 4. G. NEWOOMER, Professor in Leland Stanford University, and SAMUEL S. SEWARD, Jr Inatructor in the same 285 pp. ec. An entirely fresh treatment of the rudiments of rhetoric, adapted to elementary composition. There are abundant suggestive exercises supplemented and commented upon by the text Each sub- ject tle treated as an independent unit, implying nothing that precedes, so that the order of treat- ment is left to the teacher Literary topics for composition are avoided. The book is decidedly lear, interesting, and stimulating ISABEL GRAVES, High School, East Orange, N. J.:—Of some ten text-hbooks in composition and rhetoric recently examined, this comes closest to my present ideals and needs {After adop on The book for a month has given a month's full justification of my expectations. Buck and Morris’s Narrative Writing By PROFRSSOR GERTRUDE BUCK, of Vassar College, and ELISABETH WOODBRIDGE MOR nh Is 2) pp. l2me Mle niform in style and method of treatment with Buck's Argumentative Writing and Buck and t Woodbridge’s Expository Writing Bronson’s English Essays Edited by PROP W. ©. BRONSON, of Brown 404 pp. Large 12mo. $1.25 net. Re presentative eaeays by Bacon, Milton, Browne, Dryden, Swift, Steele, Addison, Defoe, John- wen oldamith Bu ke, Hazlitt, Lamb, Landor, De Quincey, Carlyle, Macaulay, Thackeray, Ruskin, Newman, Arnold, Pater, and Stevenson, with brief selections from prose writers before Bacon. CHARLES |} McCLUMPHA, Professor in the University of Minnesota:—It is quite the most seful and ably chosen set of essays to be presented to the student world The Lincoln-Douglas Debates Edited by PRO} A. L. BOUTON, of New York University 297 pp 16mo. (English Read- ings.) Ge net Includes Lincoln's opening speech, the Freeport and Galesburg and Alton debates entire, and Lincoln's Cooper Institute address Stopford Brooke On Ten Plays of Shakespeare tll pp. Sve. $2.25 net (by mail, $2.37) Not so much an analysis as an appreciation of ‘Midsummer Night's Dream,’’ ‘‘Winter’s Tale,"’ Merchant of Venice,’" ‘‘As You Like It,"’ ‘Richard II “Richard III.,"" ‘‘Macbeth,’’ ‘‘Tempest,’’ Komeo and Jullet,"" and *Cortolanus."’ Temple School Shakespeare Each volume, 35 OPNTS NET The Tempest. (Oliphant Smeaton.) Hamlet. (Oliphant Smeaton.) Macheth. (George Smith.) Richard Il. (W. Keith Leask.) Julias Coesar. (Ff. Armytage Morley.) The Merchant of Venice. (KR. M' Williams.) As You Like It. (Flora Masson.) Henry V. (R. H. Case.) Reecnt Wale Studies in English Kadited by Prof. Albert 8. Cook of Yak Bound in paper, unless otherwise indicated. Svo Index to Old English Glosses of the Durham Hymnarium. (Harvey W. Chap man.) in Seleet Transtiations from Sealiger’s Poetics, (Frederick M. Padelford.) The The Poetaster, by Ben Jonson. (Herbert 8. Mallory.) 82.00 Cloth, $2.50 The Devil is an Ass, by Ben Jonson. (W. 5S. Johnson.) $2.00. Cloth, $2.50 The Language of the Northumbrian Gloss to the Gospel of St. Luke. (Mar garet Dutton Kellum.) 7& Eiplicerne, by Ben Jonson. (Aurelia Henry.) $2.00. Cloth, $2.00, net German Terts Blochmann’s Introduction to Scientific German: Air, Water, Light, and Heat: i W. MEISNEST, Univ. of Wisconsin.) WITH VOCAB 210 pp 80c Goethe: Iphigenie auf Tauris. (MAX WINKLER, University of Michigan.) ve+211 py GO Nebbel: Herodes und Mariamne (BDWARD 8. MEYER, Western Reserve Univ.) xxxvill+192 pp. Gc Heyse: Die Blinden iw HW. OARRUTH. University of Kansas, and BE. } ENGEL, Assistant Professor in the same.) With vocab 131 pp. l6mo. 35 cents, net Saar: Die Steinklopfer ‘Dr, OHAS. H. HANDSCHIN and Prof. EDWIN ¢ ROBRDDER, Univ. of Wisconsin.) With vocab. 117 pp 14imeo M% cents, net Schiller: Minor Poems, (JOUN 8&8. NOLLEN, lowa Oollege.) 377 pp. 16me. SO cents, net Schiller: Geschichte des dreissigjahrigen Kriegs. Drittes Buch, (ARTHUR H. PALMER, Yale.) With vorab. 183 pp l6mo. 35 cents, net Sudermann: Teja. (HPRBERT C. SANBORN Bancroft School.) With vwoeab 110 pp. lémo 35 cents, net Withelmi: Hiner muss heiraten, and Benedix: Eigensinn, (WILLIAM A. HERVEY, Columbia.) With vocab 124 pp. iI6mo. 35 cents, net French Terts Rambeau’s French Reader Kased upon PASSY-RAMREAU'S Ohrestomathie Francaise.’ By A. RAMBEAU, rign Language Inatruction In the Manual Training High School faneas Olty, Mo cents, net Bazin: Les Oberlé (CHARLES W. CABEKEN, Syracuse Univ.) 20 pp. ldmo. 40 cents, net Daudet : Robert Helmont Ww. O. FARNSWORTH, Yale 150 pp 16mo. 40 cents, net. Erckmann-Chatrian : Waterloo VICTOR EB. FRANCOTS, College of the City of New York With vocab. 226 pp. i6mo. 40 cents, net. France: Le Livre de mon Ami oO. G. GUBRLASC Cornell 14 pp 16m. 40 cents, net Director of For- is4 pp 16mo [Vol. 82, No. sich Fiscal Reform Speeches (1880-1905) With a Preface, together with a Reprint of the Pamphlet “Economic Notes on Insular Free Trade,” and Letters from and to the Right Hon. Joseph Chamberlain, M.P. (Septem- ber, 1903). By the Right Hon. ARTHUR J, BaLFour,M.P. S8vo. Net, $1.25 LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., New York WITH WALT WHITMAN IN CAMDEN QThis illuminating diary record has been truly likened to Boswell’s Johnson in the fulness and veracity of the reve- lation of the poet's daily life and thought. @His conversations and his correspon- dence with a host of world-famous men- of-letters show afresh the breadth of his human interest and the acuteness and candor of his critical judgment. By HORACE TRAUBEL. 35 full-page portraits and facsimiles. 500 pp. ($3.00 net; $3.20 by mail.) JOHN FISKE @This, like the above, is an inti- mate biography, by a lifelong friend, THOMAS SERGEANT PERRY —and the only life of the great Ameri- can philosopher and historian. It is the latest issue in the famous “Beacon Biographies,” and maintains the standard set for that unique series of handy pocket volumes : “to furnish brief, readable and authentic accounts of those Americans whose personalities have impressed them- selves most deeply on the character and history of their country.” With photo- gravure frontispiece. (75 cents net; 80 cents by mail.) SMALL, MAYNARD & COMPANY : Boston a) MAS OF HICAL RESEARCH [By Epo: JAMES H HYSLOP, PRD., Vice Presidemt of the Soctety Psychica) Researe A comprehensive account of the peoaiee tion ae PCrystal Vision, Telepathy, Dream incidents, Apparitions, Premonitions, voyance, Mediumistic Phenomena, etc., by that eminent group of scientific men com- posing the Council of the Society for Prych- ical Research. Also by the same author on the astew @xta accumula’ y Sir Oliver Willem Crooks, William James, Dr, Richard Sldgwick, NewbeiM, F. W. Myers, pret. 3 at ey eee {cal Phenomena. Each, bound tn doth, ” VKhEERT B. TURNER & CO, AUCUSTINE THE MAN By Amélie Rives (Princess Troubetzkoy) Photogravure Frontispiece by Marchioness of Granby. “The most important work Amélie Kives has done.” —N. Y. Times JOHN LANE CO., 67 FIFTH AVE., N. Y.

Page 31

—~ . —— ss » r ‘ bis . ~ sss ’ . . . ¢ ' “ i ~ in — ~ , a sd a . ad a — ws. = - . * ’ . isi ae e * ae