The Nation 1906-04-05: Vol 82 Iss 2127

Page 1

GENERAL LIBRARY, UNIY. OF MICH, ‘The Nation » inte VOL. LXXXII—NO, 2127. “THURSDAY, APRIL 5, 1906. PRICE TEN CENTS. ‘ mo APR b Important New Publications fg. Page's What some of the Critics of England and America are saying about List Mr. Morley Roberts’ unusual novel THE IDLERS THIRD PRINTING The English Press London Literary World: **Mr. Roberts has done for the fast set of London what Mrs. Wharton did for the same social class in America It is a powerful novel—a merciless dissection of modern society.” London Mcerning Post: “Mr. Morley Roberts has written many excellent books, but none so good as * The Idlers." The character of Renée is made the occasion of one of the most vivid and tragic scenes in fiction.” London Graphic: ‘A vigorously written tale containing much of the keenest observation and very admirable character draw ing London, St. James's Gozwtte: “An occasionally unpleasant but decidedly readable novel of modern society. Contains situations wh would be the finest French farce were they not treated by the author with a somewhat ghastly seriousness.” London Queen; “Mr, Roberts indulges subtleties, and is never afraid to call a spade aspade. The story goes with a swing a: a gallos which carries its readers over a good many stiff fences.” The American Press New York Sur: “The story makes absorbing reading. It isfull of clever irony. The interest is maintained and is sharp every «her i dialogue, the description and the comment. There isa dramatic part that runs to tragedy and that will make the reader it up The characters are ingeniously imagined and skilfully handled, They supply both comedy and tragedy.” St. L- wis Republic: “ There issomething of the Bernard Shaw about him, but he isa trifle pleasanter, and, possibly, cleverer Then, too, he figures to provide alwavs the wholesome contrast between the agreeable and disagreeabie, His is at once a broader view than Shaw's. and he can occasionally see Other than the ills, oddities, meannesses, baseness, folly and inconsistency of the human being. He is a saver philoso" pher and truer artist, which accentuates the piquancy of his pessimism and trenchant cleverness, when he does happepr upon ilis, which, by the way, is most of the time.’’ Chiergo luter Ocean: “Ane ntertaining galaxy of English types, portrayed with brutal directness; an interesting story, full of strong sii ua tions and clever and cynical satire.” N. Y. Times Saturday Review: * Mr. Roberts believes in love.in honor, even in comradeship, though he jeers at some things which wear those pames. Hecause of these things and a knack that way, the story isa story for people who like their romance spiced with wit and anchored.-to a sense of things as they are Bo ton Advertiser: “A real story, rather ugly in - he but vibrant with life and vigorously told. One may rail against some of Mr. Roberts ideas, but he will not suffer the fate of one ignored.’ Boston Transcript : “ The story is well told, has many dramatic situations, some brilliant satire, and alyo abundant humor, or it could not be from the pen of Morley Roberts.” Phila. North American; ‘The accomplished author of ‘Rachel Marr,’ a great novel of genuine passion, has raked the British gilded muc! heap, and found material for hi« practised hand, ‘The Idlers’ bristies with dramatic situations, the final scene being a tragedy of appalling intensity.” OTHER IMPORTANT SPRING BOOKS By LILIAN BELL | Ms =o oi Second Printing CAROLINA LEE Author of “Hope Loring,” ete. With frontispiece in colors, By G. SIDNEY PATERNOSTER THE CRUISE OF THE CONQUEROR: Author of “The Motor Pirate.” inti Frontispiece by Merrill. $1.50 Second Printing Being the Further Adventures of The Motor Pirate By RUPERT SARGENT HOLLAND Just Ready THE COUNT AT HARVARD Decorated cover, $1 50 Being the Adventures of a Young Gentieman of Fashion at Harvard University L. C. PAGE & COMPANY (all bookstores) BOSTON @ 1906 eee 2s ;

Page 2

ll nn N . The Nation. { WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED Tt Politics, Literature, Science and Art. FOUNDED IN 1865, Pntered at the New York City Posat-Ofice as second-class mail matter. | CONTENTS OF.THIS NUMBER. Tus Wee« ove 27 EDITORIAL ARTICLES; Pertla of ‘Cornfield Law 274 Gur Consular Diegrace 274 Sky-Scraping Tarif? Taxes 275 Difficulties of Retrenchment 275 The Morocco Settlement 276 BPReCIAL CORRESPONDENCE The New Monat Pelte Napoleon, King of Elba CORRESPONDENCE Meyer's Work on Rallway Rates 279 Poor Richard's Poetry 279 NoTes 270 Hook REVIEWS Sally 282 Holman Hunt's Autobiography.—Il 283 Shaler’s Man and the Earth 285 Vikings of the Pacific . 286 John Koox and the Reformation.—Jobn Knox, the Hero of the Scottish Reforma tion sees 287 The Risen Sun 288 The Story of Cambridge 288 Boones or Tas WeeK 20 TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three dollars per year in advance, postpaid, in any part of the United States or Canada; to for- eign countries comprised in the Postal Union, $4. The date when the subscription expires is on the address label of each paper, the change of which to a subsequent date becomes a receipt for a remit- tance, No other receipt ts sent unless requested. Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter, or by check, expr: 3s order, or Postal Order payable to “ Publisher of The Nation.” When a change of address ts desired, both the old and new addresses should be given. iddress THE NATION, Box 794, New York Publication Office, 208 Broadway. TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Fifteen cents per agate line, each insertion; linea to the ineh, Twenty per cent. advance for choice of page or top af column, 4 column, $20 each insertion; with choice of page, $t4 A page, $60 each insertion; Advertisements must be reapect Copy received unt] Tuesday, 56 P. M 1h front cover page $80 acceptable in every DISCOUNTS. Time 4 Insertions 5 per cent. “ i8 ig “ uw 16 = at) 20 . 52 a 6 * Amount $100 within @ year .10 per cent 250 a . 1g% * | =H Te eee 15 760 20 a 1,000 .. 6 e wT O TT eee . 80 o Gee 6 —s =. nucocecceccstones . t% * THE NATION ta sent free to those who adver tise tn it as long as advertisement continues. *,* Copies of the Nation may be procured in Paris at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de l'Opéra ; London of B F. Stevens & Brown, Trafalgar Square, Charing Crosa,

The Nation.

[ Vol. 82, No. 2127

Columbia University Studies in History, Economics and Public Law

Volume XXIV. No. 1. The Place of Magic in the Intellectual History of Europe By LYNN THORNDIKE, Ph D. Sometime University Fellow in European History ¥UST READY

110 pages, 8vo, paper, 75 cents net No. 2. The Ecclesiastical Edicts of the Theodosian Code By WILLIAM K. BOYD, Ph.D, Sometime Fellow in European History. 12247 pages, 8vo, p “per, 75 cents net No. 3. The International Po- sition of Japan as a Great Power By SEIJI G. HISHIDA, Ph, D 289 pages, 8vo, paper, $2.50 net

PUBLISHED BY The Columbia University Press Agents, THE MACMILLAN COMPANY 64-66 Fifth Ave., New York

lL:ducational. MaBssSacuusetTtTs, Boston. Bs TON UNIVERSITY Law New features. Address the Dean M.M Bradford Academy One Hundred Third Year. Thirty miles from Boston. Prepares for all the leading colleges for women; also General Course and two years’ Course for High School Graduates. New gymnasium and field sports of all kinds. For catalogue and book of views, address the Principal, Miss LAURA A. KNOTT. A.M., Bradford, Mass ROCK RIDGE SCHOOL For Boys. Location high and dry. Laboratories, Sho for Mechanic Arts. Strong teachers. High ideals. yi new pees with swimming pool. Fits for college, scientific school and business. Illustrated pamphlet sent free. Address Dr. B. C. WHITE, Rock Ridge Hall, Wellesley Hills, Mass. Se hool, BiekLow. for Young Women

Selections and Documents in Economics Edited by WILIAAM Z. RIPLEY, Professor of Economics in Harvard University. An application of the case system af the law schools to the teaching of economics. ALREADY PUBLISHED Ripley's Trusts, Pools and Corporations Trade Unalonism and Labor s and Social ss ed Readings in lic CINN & COMPANY, BOSTO N &% Astor Edition of Poets is the beat for schools and colleges. % vols. List price, e. per vol. (price to schools #c.). SEND FOR LIST.

NEEDED in every HOME, SCHOOL and OFFICE. Reliable, Useful, Attractive, Lasting, U Date and Authoritative. 2380 Pages, 000 Illustrations. Recently added 25, New Words, New Gazetteer and New Biographi- eal Dictionary. Editor W. T. Harris, Ph.D., LL.D., United States Com. of Ed’n. Highest Awards at St. Louis and at Portlan Webster's Collegiate Dictionary. Largest of our abr ents. Regular and Thin Paper editions. Unsu for elegance and con- venience. 1116 pages and 1100 illustrations Write for “‘ The Story of a Book” — Free. G. & C. MERRIAM CO., Springfield, Mass. GET THE BEST.

Now Completed Rolfe’s New Shakespeare 40 Volumes. 56 cents each This new edition of Rolfe’s Shakespeare in- corporates the results of recent advancement n Shakespearean scholarship and research. Among the changes are the omission or abridgment of the original notes on textual variations, and the substitution of comment y the editor for selections from other critics. The books are of handy size for the pocket, and most attractive in appearance. AMERICAN BOOK COMPANY New York Cincinnati Chicago Boston

Thomas Y. Crowell & Co.,New York School Agencies. WE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES Everett O. Fisx & Co., Proprietors. 4 Ashburton Pl..Boston 150 Ave, Washington 156 Fifth Ave., New York 414 Cent. Bid.. Minneapolis 203 Mich. Ave. ,Chicago 1200 Wiliiams Av., Portiand 401 Coo Bid., Denver 525 S8time’n Bik. Los Angeles 813 Rook’ry BIk., Spokane 717 Market 8t., San Fr’nciseo Send to any address above for Agency Manual. An Agency is valuable in > to ite mIn- fluence. If it merely hears of va- cancies and tells th t is something, but if it is asked to you Sos them a Ly sesequnen a teacher and rec. thatismore. Ours CW. BARDEEN, Byracuse, N.Y. Recommends LBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY, 81 Chapel St., Albany. N. Y.—Provides schools of all grades with competent teachers. Assists teachers in obtainin, itions. -_ Haran P. Frenon, Proprietor, CHERMERHORN’ S Teachers’ Agency. ‘eachers—Schools—Tutors—Governess— Property. T Tel. 6129 18th. Joun C. Rooxwett, Mgr., 3 E. 14th St., N. Y. C.

Travel. FRENCH WOMAN ( Teacher), expe-

ge ee. would aceompany or chape- ron the summer in nee. Fluent owiten ~ < — references. Address MADEMOISELLE L. C., care of Nation. ~—High-class tour: Small of ladies— EUROPE": cone, ny 3d. Bouthern rae pany. Address M BARBOUR. & Atlantic cuy NJ a ANTSANTIQUIES OF ATHENS, Large “Toliows Bae 9 "Volume iret a

Soomrh 1.— Poer ; velgmes New tion. n eaited row William Kinnard, At shat Lon- : Rev Taevcawert, ¥ Kansas,

Page 3

pare? April 5, 1906] The Nation. lii Atlantic Monthly FOR APRIL Published April 2d The Reform in Church Music. By JUSTINE BAYARD Warp. What should be the spirit and form of ideal church music ? Criminal Law Reform. By GEORGE W. ALGER. Why our criminal law should be made more simple and swift in operation. Questions of the Far East. By Jonun W. Foster. A sum- mary of recent important books dealing with the Chinese problem. Making Education Hit the Mark. By WILLARD GILES Par SONS. A plea for a clearer recognition of the difference between “vocational” and “cultural’’ studies. What Shall We Do with the Public Documents? By W.S. ROSSITER. If public documents are worth anything, they are worth paying for. Shall they be distributed by gift or by sale? Four Complete Stories SPECIAL OFFER. A Trial Subscription /. three months, this and tewo succeed ing issues, will be sent to new subscribers on receipt of fifty cents. 35 cents a copy, $4.00 a year. Illustrated Prospectus for 1906 sent free upon application HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO., 4 Park StT., BOSTON Mass. ° N . Importing Notice We beg to announce that we have greatly extended our facilities for the importation of English books, so that we now are equipped to fill orders of this sort with the greatest efficiency and intelligence. Promptness, good service and low prices will rule in this department, as they do in all our business. THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO. WHOLESALE BOOKSELLERS, 33-37 E. 17th St., Union Sq. North, New York LIBRARY RESEARCH Topics of all kinds and in any language looked up in the Boston and Harvard libraries, for scholars, writ- | ers, and others. Abstracts, copies, translations, and bibliographies made. Proof-reading and revision of manuscript. Highest university and ad references. I8s M. H. BUCKINGHAM, 06 Chestnut Street, Boston, Mass. Financial. We buy and sell bills of exchanges and i LETTERS make cable transfers of money on Europe, OF Australia, and South Africa; also make CREDIT collections and issue Commercial and Travellers’ Credits avaliable in all parte of the world, International Cheques. Certificates of Deposit. BROWN BROTHERS & CO., NO. 50 WALL STRERT, NEW YORK. The Ben Greet | Players "IN SHAKESPEARE’S PLAYS | Acted as Shakespeare wrote them | | in a setting representing an old English Hall i or Theatre. ALSO IN OPEN AIR PLAYS | Beginning May 20th at Washington | Colleges and Clubs desiring to book this at- tractive combination kindly address | BEN GREET, care of Walter Jordan, Empire Theatre, N. Y. SCIENCE AND A FVUTVRE LIFE By Prof. JAMES H. HYSLOP 81.50 net. Postage 12 cents extra HEKBERT B. TURNER & CO., Boston These trade-mark lines on every package. F GLUTE DYSPEPSIA SPECIAL D C FLOUR. K. C. WHOL T FLOUR. Unlike all Ask Grocers. For write Farwell & Rhines, N. Y., U.S.A. Ghe New BENSON Nowel THE ANCEL OF PAIN “A remarkable book.” — Chicago Tribune. AT ALL BOOKSTORES J. B. LIPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia JOHN WILEY & SONS 43 and 45 East Nineteenth St. NEW YORK CITY Text-Book on Mechanics, Statics. Vol. L. A Text-book designed for Colleges and Technical Schools. By LOUIS A. MARTIN, Jr., ME. AM., Stevens Institute, Member American Math. So F.A.A.A.S (la press.) This text contaius numerous compictely solved esamples and many exercises These are tot duced directly after each pripciple they serve to illustrate. It is designed as an introductory test to Applied Mechanics. Introduction to the Real Infini- tesimal Analysis of one Vari. able By OSWALD VEBLEN, Preceptor in Mathema les, Princeton University, and N. J. LANNE, | structor in Mathematics in the Wendell Phillis Hiigh School, Chicage. (ln preparation.) The Adjust ments of the Engineer's Transit and Level By HUWARD C. IVES, C.E., Assistant Professor of Civil Engineering in the Usiversity of Denney! Vaula Second Edition ldme Boards, 2% Plane Surveying A Huud-book for Use as a Teat in the Classroom and im the Field By JOHN ©. TRAOY, Asalst aut Professor of Structural Magineering, Yale Uni versity (lo preparation Ready in the fall of 1906.) The History of Chemical Theories and Laws By M. M. PATTISON MUIR. 8vo., Cloth Occurrence and Properties of Clay and Its Distribution in the United States By HPFINRICH RIES 8vo Cloth Stone and Clay Products Used in Engineering Ry FAYWIN C. FOKEIL 8vo. Cloth The Disposal of Municipal Refuse hy H. DE B. PARSONS. 8vo. Cloth American Garbage Crematories By WILLIAM MAYO VENABLE vo Cloth The Building Mechanic’s Ready Reference Series Volume I. Oarpenter & Woodworkers’ Edition By H. G. RICHEY. ié6mo. Electric Machine Design By H. F, PARSHALL aod H. M. HOBART Small dto. Electrochemistry Authorized translation from the German of H Dannee! by FE. S. MBRRIAM, Professor of Chem istry in Marietta College, Marietta, Ohio. 12mo An Introduction to Chemical Crystallography By P. GROTH, Professor of Mineralogy and Orys tallograpby in the Universit of Munich. Author —~ ——- by Haugh Yrarsball, Lecturer « Obemist and on Crystallography in the Univer sity of nburgh. 1dmo. Symmetrical Masonry Arches EFINITE OFFERS OF BOOKS and Periodicals solicited "y A. 8. CLARE, Peekskill, N Y By MALVERD A. BOWE, Professor of Ciril Ko ineering in the Kose Polytechnic Institute. Syo. ‘loth. (In preparation.)

Page 4

iv The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2127 “The most engaging story yet written of Southern life” is said by a Southerner of Mr. Owen Wister’s 9 new novel ready this week Lady Baltimore ‘‘* Lady Baltimore’ is the most engaging story yet written of Southern life. It is the quiet annals of an old Southern town told in the half whimsical, wholly sympa- thetic style of ‘Cranford,’ to which it is closely akin in charm. It reminds one, too, of Margaret Deland’s admirable ‘Old Chester Tales,’ for it is written with the same loving appreciation of a simple neighborhood. With what a sense of humor, with what a delicacy of touch, with what a finished skill Owen Wister has made an exquisite picture you must read to see. It is like a dainty water color portrait, delicious in itself even if it were not true; but to its truth there will rise up a crowd of witnesses. ‘I am ready to venture that any Southern man or woman who reads it will stop often, with finger between the leaves, to say, ‘Ain’t it so! This is exactly the way it is back home. This is us.’ . . . The book is charming in every par- ticular.’’"—The Chicago Record- Herald. lhe scenes of **the most appealing, the loveliest, the most wistful town in America” are admirably reproduced in drawings in the text. Chth, $7.50 New Books of Notable Interest Mr. Egerton Castle’s new novel [If Youth but Knew By the Author of ‘‘the Pride of Jennico,’’ ‘‘Young April,’* et Cloth, $1.50 Mr. Eden Phillpotts’s new novel The Portreeve By the Author of ‘‘Children of the Mist,’’ ‘‘The Se:ret Woman,"’ etc. Cloth, $1.50 ae. Jenn Spargo’s social study The Bitter Cry of the Children inal investigation of the conditions of poverty affecting children. Cloth, $1.50 net (postage 13.) Mr. Hugo R. Meyers’s thorough, timely, and interesting study of Municipal Ownership in Great Britain States the facts of experience with figures, sources and dates fully given Cloth 1r2mo. $1.50 net (postage 13¢.) Memoirs of Archbishop Temple 4» Seven Friends Che story of a life whose characteristic was breadth and strong personal influence. Tavo volumes, 8vo, $9.00 net Prof. C. T. Winchester’s Life of John Wesley ‘ Better than any other biography this brings out the personality of this plain little man of such wonderful mastery over Cloth, 8ve, $1.50 net (postage 17¢.) men Tribune, ronished THE MACMILLAN COMPANY “iinare by

Page 5

i eet Del, GS rk ety Fie A aie sale The Nation. every bituminous mine until every bi- NEW YORK, THURSDAY, APRIL 5, 106, The Week. All students of legislation have agreed in denouncing the Congressional prac- tice of passing general legislation as part of the appropriation bills. This year, at the hands of a group of embattled members, the House of Representatives got, as the phrase is, “just what was coming to it.” Out of a difficulty of its own creation it extricates itself by an action which, however “practical,” is without justification in logic, law, or precedent. In the face of the absolute- ly definite rule against expenditures not authorized by existing law, the Appro- priations Committee has followed its own sweet will so far that the Legisla- tive, Executive, and Judicial bill has been “riddled” by perfectly valid points of order, and can be saved only by a special rule to the effect that it shall be passed whether legal or illegal. The point of order in Congress has long been regarded simply as a club. The Speak- er does not enforce the rule against new legislation or provisions not germane unless somebody brings the case to his attention. Thus many of the most nec- essary bills, as in the present instance, come upon the floor in a shockingly vul- nerable state. As for the extraordinary expedient adopted to save the measure, we hope the incident will merely be a salutary warning to the House, and not the beginning of a line of precedent that will still further tighten the grip of the Speaker and the Rules Committee upon the organization. Never, certainly, was there a bill which appealed to more sorts or condi- tions of people than that reported from the Ways and Means Committee provid- ing for free alcohol. The farmer and the manufacturer stand side by side in its favor. The former expects to gain a new market for odds and ends of grain, potatoes, and fruit, the latter to get greatly cheapened a material important to almost every line of industry. The Trust-buster—-for the Standard Oil Com- pany is reported as strenuously opposed to free alcohol—makes common cause with the automobile-owning magnate. Even the temperance organizations, it appears, favor the bibulous-sounding bill on the psychological ground that the special kind of alcohol the production of which is to be encouraged will be poisonous, and that its general use and familiarity will cause the coming gen- eration unconsciously to regard all al- cohol as a poison, and not a beverage. The bill thus has plenty of friends. Whe- ther they are the kind that can make an impression on a Congress, especial- ly a Senate, which gets itself into an artificial hurry in the years of the long session, is another question. Legisla- tion that would cheapen anything would be regarded by some as a bad prece- dent, Every one interested in the preserva- tion of Niagara Falls should second President Roosevelt's recommendation that there be enacted into law the sug- gestions of the American members of the International Waterways Commis- sion. If the Falls are to be saved, there is no time to lose. The Commission was composed on both sides of able and far- sighted men, who are strongly of the opinion that any further diversion of water will bring ruin with it. There was substantial agreement on the facts Ly both Canadians and Americans, and the Canadian Government, it is an- nounced, is ready to act. According to its Minister of Public Works, the right to export power will henceforth be granted only subject to revocation at short notice, while the water-power companies will be subject to such rules and regulations as the Government sees fit to impose. The preservation of the scenic beauty of the Falls will hence- forth be the special care of the Govern- ment. The United States must not lag behind. Congress ought to adopt the suggestion of the Commission, which the President, with his well-known love of nature, is so prompt to reinforce. The destruction of Niagara Falls for money would forever stamp this country abroad as a nation dead to anything but what touches the pocket. President George F. Baer was quite right in telling President John Mitchell that the order to the anthracite miners to quit work on Monday, pending an agreement, was “most extraordinary.” The operators had expressed their entire readiness to meet their employees and discuss the points of difference. The postponement of such a conference till after the first of April had been in def- erence to President Mitchell’s own de- sire. Under the circumstances the call- ing out of the miners was a gratuitous exhibition of bad manners. The act, however, relates to etiquette rather than principle; and the operators are well advised in proceeding with the confer- ence as if nothing unpleasant had hap- pened. Both sides are in duty bound to take up the negotiations in a concilia- tory mood. The United Mine Workers have apparently begun to realize that they cannot have everything they ask for. At first they proposed to tie up tuminous operator had yielded— a relent- less ané wholly unjustifiable sympathet- ic strike. John Mitchell, however, now urges them to work for any operator with whom they can come to terms. Un less his advice is followed in this re- spect, the mine workers can succeed in nothing but the alienation of public sym- pathy. The “Dawkins Bill,” lately vetoed by Gov. Warfield of Maryland, Is a fine example of labor legislation rampant. What organized labor demanded, and what but for Gov. Warfield the Legis- lature would have granted, was this: Baltimore is to spend something like $10,000,000 in public improvements, in- cluding a sewer system; the work is to be done, at the direction of competent engineers, as quickly as possible under the stimulus of the “new and better Bal- timore”’ movement; but the labor leaders of that city conceived it to be a fine op- portunity to show their hand, and Mr. Dawkins introduced a bill into the Leg- ielature providing that only registered voters of Maryland should be employed on public work in Baltimore. Ae first drawn, the bill included architects, eng!i- neers, contractors. Later, it was amend- ed, as a great concession, to except “technical employees.” In both House and Senate this extraordinary proposi- tion to create a labor monopoly was passed by large majorities, the labor lobbyists threatening political vengeance in the event of an adverse vote. But, to the credit of the Governor, he dis- posed of the bill in so effective a veto message that upon its resubmission to the Legislature it won only the slightest showing of support. Judge Greenbaum’'s reputation as a careful and firm magistrate wiil be heightened by his action in making per- manent the injunction against violence by the striking printers. The evidence was overwhelming that the typograph- ical union, or its agents, had resorted to assaults as well as threats, in its ef- forts to deter free printers from accept- ing the work offered them. At the hearing, this was not denied. Nor could Judge Greenbaum find that the union had ever protested against the brutal outrages committed in ita behalf, or done anything to punish the guilty. It ap- pears that the union has no “rules” cov- ering such cases. It is quite right, therefore, and highly necessary that the courts should enjoin organized labor from acts of intimidation and violence In Washington, also, the Typothetm have secured a similar ruling from a judge there. He took occasion to lay

Page 6

2Z272 down the sound opinion that lawless acts are especially criminal when di- rected against the liberty of a man to take what work and wages he may please. The Republican situation in this city is rapidly going from bad to worse. The wave of reform which put Herbert Par- sons in the county chairmanship and led to the selection of Mr. Wadsworth as Speaker, seems to have spent its force, and decent Republicans are once more confronted with the fact that Odell dominates the situation. Through all the righteous attacks upon him he has held on with brazen effrontery to the State Chairmanship, and on Thursday he came to town and calmly annexed the City Committee. Twenty-two of the thirty-six district leaders joined him at the Fifth Avenue Hotel, and mapped out a Senate and Assembly reapportion- ment act in accordance with his desires. Mr. Parsons was deliberately ignored. Halpin, Van Cott, Alexander, and all the rest of the gang were there, and L. E. Quigg, too. It was not so very long ago that Odell, in his fine zeal to reform the city’s politics, declined to see Quigg at any time or place; yea, rumor had it that he would not even hold telephonic communication with him. Bidwell, Quigg, Frank Platt, Dunn, and others were to be driven out of public life for the good of the party. Evidently, these rumors were base fabrications. Mr. Odell sees that the way to reform is to cherish the professional politicians and spurn the reformers. Mr. Parsons had better look out; a silk-stocking of his kind ought to get ready to resign. Odell is in the saddle to stay, and respectable Republicans had better submit—Choate, Root, Higgins, Roosevelt, and all the rest. We never did think that Mr. Jerome could long be content with his strange- ly chosen role of William the Silent. So it was no great surprise to find him passing, on Friday morning, from his stern “nothing to say" to four columns of carefully prepared explanation. This, at least, is the man we knew—the Je- rome of extraordinarily developed sen- sitiveness to popular feeling, the frank and talkative official, the “good adver- tiser.”’ Better late than never is what he now says about his own campaign fund. None of it, he tells us, came from corporations; certain proffered contribu- tions were refused, because Mr. Jerome looked the gift-horse in the mouth. So far excellent. The only wonder is that Mr. Jerome did not say as much long ago. His assumption that he was in- sulted by questions on that point was wholly gratuitous, and his temporary pose as the strong man contemptuous of public opinion was not at all in char- acter. Now that he has, abandoned all The Nation [Vol. 82, No. 2127 that, we expect him to go on and make that full statement about his campaign receipts and expenditures which their important bearing on the whole question of electoral reform renders pertinent and urgent. Mr. Jerome’s apologia as respects his handling of the insurance cases does not do much, unhappily, to explain how it was that, having advised the Grand Jury to ask instructions from Judge O'’Sulli- van, he became angry when those in- structions did not square with his own expressed views. He does not make it clear why, after having, as he says, con- vinced himself in his conscience and on his oath of office. that Mr. Perkins was not guilty of grand larceny, he had him arrested on that charge. We hear but one opinion about this unfortunate va- cillation of Mr. Jerome’s, which may easily prejudice the legal determination of the criminality of the insurance gifts to political corruptionists. But the Dis- trict Attorney now practically admits his blunder. In all that remains of the insurance cases, he is evidently prepar- ing to act with greater vigor and di- rectness. He has asked for and ob- tained a special Grand Jury for May, to devote itself exclusively to the in- vestigation of insurance offences. It will be a chastened Jerome who devotes him- self to that critical inquiry, and we look for no mishandling of it. The important amendments of the in- surance bills introduced on Thursday for the Armstrong committee enlarge the permissible ratio of “contingency re- serves” to outstanding insurance; extend the maximum ratio of expenditure on obtaining new business, and allow the companies to retain such collateral trust bonds as they now possess, though fur- ther investment in those securities is still prohibited. The change in the “contingency reserve” section is a con- cession to the argument presented by President Ide at the recent hearing. He contended with much force that abso- lute restriction of this fund amounted to “putting a limit on conservatives.” With the proposed limitation applied in 1903, shrinkage of Stock Exchange val- ues would have placed one of the three largest companies in a position of tech- nical insolvency. These objections the committee now meets by raising sub- stantially the maximum limitation on such reserves, and by permitting the companies, with the assent of the Insur- ance Superintendent, to go beyond even the new limitation in case of a general fall of investment values. To the origi- nal bill for limiting first expenses, three objections of weight were made at the hearing—one, that the limitation would not allow a living profit to the agent; another, Mr. McClintock's statement that so rigid an artificial limitation as was proposed “‘would cramp the company and increase the cost of its business”; a third, that the committee’s own esti- mates of resonable first cost had not included due allowance for medical and other routine outlay. To these argu- ments the committee defers, enlarging moderately the agents’ commission and renewal rights, and allowing for other necessary first charges. These amendments have to do with technical questions, and do not affect the original aim—namely, to put an absolute barrier in the way of extravagance in the race for the “biggest showing of in- surance written.” A different question arose in the collateral trust bond matter. Such investment of insurance funds was forbidden in the commit- tee’s bills, on the perfectly proper ground that bonds whose sole securi- ty is the stock deposited behind them, must be classed with the stocks as an investment, and should therefore be ex- cluded as are the stocks themselves. It developed, at the hearing of March 9, that $107,000,000 of such ponds are al- ready held by New York insurance com- panies. It was then contended that com- pulsory sale of that amount, even in a five-year term, would seriously upset values. This was a matter of opinion; the committee, however, has deemed it best to err, if at all, on the side of con- servatism in its changes, and it allows the companies to keep such collateral trust bonds as they already hold. If this is a concession in principle, it is nevertheless probable that no harm will result from it; for further purchase re- mains prohibited, and holdings of ac- tual shares in other enterprises, to which the practical objection was more serious, must still be sold within the five-year period. To all budding logicians we commend Gov. Higgins’s latest utterance on tae subject of investigating the Banking Department: “I believe that the Banking Department should be investigated, and the responsi- bility for action now rests with the As- sembly. There is a bill before them. The Assembly passed a resolution, which the Senate did not see fit to approve. The Senate has sent to them a bill which I do not think any one can honestly ques- tion.”’ In other words, the Assembly pa-ses 4% bill for a thorough and genuine investi- gation—the kind of thing which Gov. Higgins and his friend, Superintendent Kilburn, do not want. The Senate re- jects the Assembly bill and proposes a limited, whitewashing investigation. No cne opposes the Senate bill except those leaders of a forlorn hope who wish to see the Banking Department adminis- tered without fear or favor; and these idealists in politics do not count, if they refuse to assent to the plan of sprinkling rose-water over Mr. Kilburn, ee

Page 7

RE i Jee suet ime *, wdslale April 5, 1906] The Nation. 273 they are, in the view of Gov. Higgins, responsible for the failure to investi- gate. Nothing could be plainer or more convincing. The Assembly passed on Thursday by a large majority a resolution changing the requirement for the passage of Con- stitutional amendments. It was doubt- less greatly influenced by the almost ridiculously small vote on the amend- ments last submitted and adopted. When only about 8 per cent. of those partici- pating in an election take the trouble to vote upon such propositions at all, the process of submitting them seems farci- cal to many. It has been the general experience with the referendum that the affirmative sentiment on a proposition has a far better chance of casting its vote than that on the other side. Hence, it is urged, the vote does not fairly rep- resent popular sentiment, and all sorts of proposals can be carried by the vote of a small minority of the population. On the other hand, the system provid- ed by the resolution which on Monday passed the New York Assembly, making 2 majority of the total vote at the elec- tion necessary to adopt a Constitutional amendment, would render it almost im- possible to carry any proposal submit- ted. This may be, in some ways, a good thing, but its consequences should be carefully considered. For instance, in 1903, when the canal question was sub- mitted and carried, the affirmative vote was 673,010. The vote in the State elec- tion for judge of the Court of Appeals that year was 1,412,788. So, had the canal improvement involved a Constitu- tional amendment, it would have been defeated under the proposed new rule. Whatever the final count may show, in the contest between Governor Davis and Senator Berry of Arkansas, the peo- ple of that State have really succeeded in electing a Senator by popular vote. Heretofore the Senatorship has been an issue at the party primaries, but mem- bers of the Legislature have been bound only by the vote of their separate con- stituencies. This year, however, Gov- ernor Davis and Senator Berry agreed to abide by the result of the Democratic primary throughout the State, and the campaign has been as active as the Mon- tague-Martin primary fight in Virginia last year. Davis has won on the face of the returns, and if he proves to be the Legislature's choice for Senator, it will be another triumph for the “stormy petrel” school of statesmanship. In his five campaigns in Arkansas—one for Attorney-General, three for Govern- or, and the present one for the Sena- torial nomination, Davis has made 2,000 speeches, has had half a score of per- sonal encounters, and has ridden rough- shod over all kinds of opposition in his party. He is charged with the re- sponsibility for the reduction of a nor- mal Democratic majority of 70,000 to less than 20,000. As a “cornfield” statesman, Davis is proud of his sharp angles, and has even made political cap- ital out of his rebuke by President Roosevelt. Milwaukee made the first trial the other day of the primary law passed after such a long fight. A great many citizens, according to the report, could not seem to get through their heads the distinction between the primary and the regular election. The newspapers were full of warnings against ticket-splitting on the analogy of the November elec- tion, for Republicans, seeing the name of a high-class aspirant for the Demo- cratic nomination, were prone to put his name on their own ticket. This diffi- culty will doubtless disappear when the law becomes more familiar. But, for one thing, it shows strikingly how little the people knew about the process of making nominations under the old sys- tem. That is, they failed to understand the primary because the old caucuses, vhich theoretically corresponded, were absolutely unfamiliar to the average citizen. For a first test of the new law, the Milwaukee primary vote of 43,000 seems to us encouragingly large. While the figure is some 13,000 short of the vote in the last Presidential election, it is estimated by the Evening Wisconsin to be at least 16,000 greater than the attendance at the 1904 caucuses. In fifteen inches of closely printed amendments to the football rules, we cannot find a line that is likely to im- prove the game. The penalties for va- rious kinds of foul play are greatly in- creased, but umpires practically never enforced the old penalties. Reducing the defensive line from seven to six largely offsets the ten-yard rule. The requirement that the two rushlines must stand separated by the longest diameter of the ball is practically incapable of enforcement. An additional blind um- pire is provided, but no rule is drawn by which he shall be forced to penalize foul play when he sees it. Minor pro- hibitions, such as that of hurdling, of kicking the ball on the ground after a kick, actually makes against a more open game. We believe there were just two ways of handling the football sit- uation. An experimental trial of the ten-yard rule without further modifica- tion might have resulted in restoring the open game of the eighties. Failing that, there was nothing to do but to reform the game altogether, by reverting to Rugby of the English or New Zealand type. As things stand, complicated rules become more complicated than ever, and old measures of reform that have proved ineffectual are merely redupli- cated. Ever since the Taff Vale decision established the financial responsiblity of unions for damage inflicted in their b« half, labor leaders in England have been seeking legislative immunity for union funds. The present Liberal Gov ernment would virtually grant this im munity, by stipulating that unions shal! be held in damages only for acts clear ly authorized by their governing bodies As a matter of fact, it is practically im possible to prove that acts of violence in 2 labor war are thus authorized. Com mon sense suggests that a certain re sponsibility attaches to the body that profits by the lawless deed. However, the lubor members were not thus satisfied They require not immunity for union funds, but an ex plicit and comprehensive release from any financial responsibility whatever This, as the Attorney-General remarked would confer an exceptional exemption upon the proletariat, and cries from the Laborite benches showed that precisely this was demanded. With this claim of superiority to the organic law we are only too familiar in America. Only the other day, Mr. Roosevelt had to admin ister a sharp reminder that one class of labor cannot set itself up as priv ileged beyond the rest. In England the unions have long been conducted along saner and more business-like lines. The chjection of the labor members at West minster to a measure giving more than they can reasonably demand, indi cates a change of temper, and hints of 2 future closer alliance between British unionism of the opportunist type and the more advanced forms of Socialism merely practical To have changed front, or retreated outright, twice in one week, is what the new English Government may be charg- ed truthfully with having done. Per- haps the very size of its majority gives it, with Falstaff, an alacrity in sinking At any rate, the Colonial Office lost lit tle time in capitulating to Natal. Of course, Lord Elgin rode off on the ex- cnse that, if the government of that colony had kept him fully informed about the proposed execution of natives, he would not have intervened at all, but that is palpably a lame horse. The obvious inference is that the Colonial Secretary acted hastily, and then re- versed himself still more hastily. Even more significant as a sign of divided counsels and of vacillation is the yield- ing of the Premier to the Labor party in the matter of giving trades unions what is practically immunity from the law. There may be good arguments for this course, but for Sir Henry Camp bell-Bannerman to turn round after the stand made by the Attorney-Gen- eral and incontinently go the full or ganized-labor length, certainly looks like poor management and unstable con victions.

Page 8

274 PERILS OF “CORNFIELD” LAW. Senator Tillman has invented a new phrase to describe the attitude of men like him who make light of legal and Constitutional difficulties in legislation. Hle is, he says, only “a cornfield law- yer.” As such, however, he gayly sallies forth to rail at the arguments of real lawyers like Senators Knox and Spoon- er on the Republican side, and of Messrs. tailey and Culberson on his own. His pose is simply a variant.of the old one of pitting rough-and-ready horse sense against legal expertness. The President is reported to be much taken with this method of Tillman, who continually re- fers to himself as merely a nurse in charge of Mr. Roosevelt’s baby. There has been, the dispatches say, much hearty laughter and applause in the White House for “cornfield” law. It has, however, its drawbacks and perils. Some of them were exposed by Senator Knox in his weighty speech on March 28. The gist of it was a plea for the courts as against the cornfield. The ex-Attorney-General contended that care and skill are necessary in drafting intri- cate legislation, with a knowledge of the legal effect of the language used, and some faint effort to shape your impor- tant bill so that it will not be judicially found null and void. Mr. Knox made an unimpassioned legal argument. He did not attempt to answer Tillman with homely or proverbial phrases. Had he done so, he might have reminded the South Carolina Senator, who is so will- ing to “chance” it with the Constitution, that it is better to be sure than to be sorry. The Administration has just emerged from an experience with cornfield law which ought to make it a little more chary of that article. It was in the finest manner of a cornfield jurist that the President set about the prosecution of the Beef Trust. He cheerfully mixed up friendly inquiries with criminal in- dictments—the Bureau of Corporations with the Department of Justice. To a man with a hoe in a cornfield, this would have seemed an eminently fitting procedure. Firat get your suspected magnates confidentially to admit their evil deeds, then prosecute them. But the courts have had a word to say about that. There is such a thing, they held, as recognized criminal process. The Government had ignored it. It had made the defendants immune without intend- ing to do so. They could not be first asked to make privileged communica- tions and then tried on the strength of them. Thus one little decision by a judge upset that entire cornfield prose- cution. The cornfield lawyer, we see, is in danger of taking his own impulses, good and unselfish as he is sure they are, for sound legal maxims and trusty guides to action. They have a way, The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2127 however, of proving not to be. The President strongly urged Congress, for example, to undertake the Federal regu- lation of life insurance. He perceived that the subject was one of national in- terest; hence it was clear to him that it was one under national jurisdiction. That, be it said with all respect, was the cornfield view. The legal and Con- stitutional view—and, incidentally, the conclusive view—has just been enunciat- ed by the Judiciary Committee of the House. Its members did not settle the question with a hoe or cultivator, but studied law and precedent and the de- cisions of the Supreme Court, and came unanimously to the conclusion that the course recommended by Mr. Roosevelt was plainly unconstitutional. What is the present status of the ar- gument on the railway-rate question? Such, we think, as to call imperatively for the amendment of the Hepburn Dill. The best lawyers of the Senate have been heard from—Foraker, Rayner, Bai- ley, Culberson, Spooner, and finally Knox. There is practically a consensus of opinion among them that the Hep- burn bill, as it now stands, is unconsti- tutional, and would surely be so held by the Supreme Court. Most of the Sen- ators named have offered amendments intended to cure the legal vices of the bill. These relate chiefly to the want of due provision for a judicial review of the findings of the Interstate Commerce Commission. On this point Senator Knox spoke with much emphasis and confess- edly great authority. He has himself introduced an amendment which would remove the Constitutional objection while safeguarding the rights of both shippers and carriers, and providing for a speedy hearing and determination of all cases. Why is there any hesitation in taking the advice of so sound a law- yer, so well-approved a prosecutor of oppressive combinations? Apparently, because the word has gone out from cornfield and cottonpatch that they must have the Hepburn bill, the whole bill, and nothing but the bill. Pass it un- amended, is the cry of the men who, like Senator Dolliver, profess to be di- rectly inspired by the President. But this foolish attitude is becoming daily more discredited. The weight of argu- ment is too heavily against the cornfield. And there seems now to be little doubt that an amendment guaranteeing judi- cial review will be adopted by the Sen- ate, and that the President will accept it with the assurance that it is the thing above all others which he from the first ardently desired. OUR CONSULAR DISGRACE. The confidential report in regard to our former conguls in the Bast, publish- ed on Thursday, must everywhere evoke a sense of shame. This is not the testi- mony of a sensational writer, or of a politician in search of notoriety, but a sober, official statement filed with the Secretary of State by an Assistant Sec- retary of State detailed to make a spe- cial investigation. From Mr. Peirce’s report it is plain that the most impor- tant consular representatives of the United States in the Far Hast have been either common drunkards or grafters— men who accepted office merely to fill their own pockets, legally or illegally. The official report recalls the statement of the American admiral who, returning from a long cruise in European waters, declared that half our consuls in the Mediterranean had been in jail, and that the other half ought to be there. Con- ditions in the East seem to have been fully as bad, for if ever men ought to go to jail, they are official representatives of this Government whose misconduct re- flects upon the entire country. Americans not in the Fabit of trav- elling abroad have often wondered why it is that the United States has stood so low in foreign estimation. They even rejoiced that the favorable outcome of the Spanish war seemed to assure this country a better position. But if any one factor has helped to give foreigners a poor opinion of the United States, it is our wretched consular representation. Of this the proof is unending, but rarely has it been put before the public so con- cretely and authoritatively as in Mr. Peirce’s report. The more one studies it, the more the wonder grows. If there is anything that the Americans are proud of, it is their reputation as busi- ness men. Yet, with all their eagerness to obtain foreign trade, to show the back-number German, the frog-eating Frenchman, or the antediluvian Hungar- ian a trick or two along trade lines, they have supinely sat by and let the poli- ticians run the foreign business of the country with men of low calibre such as no reputable mercantile house in this country would think of employing. Because the men most severely crit- icised by Mr. Peirce are now out of the consular service, or because a reform bill is on its way through Congress, it must not be thought that nothing re- mains to be done. While there has been much progress, there are many consuls who do not reflect credit on the country. There was the one at Coburg, for instance, who turned the consulate into a disreputable resort, and made every exporter contribute a “sample” for use in furnishing the consulate or to be disposed of for the benefit of the consul’s pocket. Careful investigation would have shown the man’s unfitness for office before his ap- pointment. The State Department re- moved him for the “good of the service,” but Mr. Roosevelt, in the eyes of the Co- burgers, added insult to injury by ap- pointing as his successor that Saylor who obtained unenviable notoriety by ere Wee. — ERE ELAM I oe

Page 9

od April 5, 1906] The Nation. 275 trying to defraud the State of Pennsy!- vania when serving in its Legislature, and who was officially denounced by the Governor. There are plenty of other cases on record in which the President or the State Department connived at the appointment of unfit men. Mr. Peirce found that no less than eighty- two charges were on file against Consul- General Goodnow of Shanghai. Yet Mr. McKinley knew precisely what kind of man Goodnow was when he selected him. Delegations expressing the best moral sentiment of Goodnow’s home town went to Washington and protest- ei against his appointment, on the ground that his character was detest- able. Mr. McKinley, indeed, was responsible for all the men who figure most prom- inently in Mr. Peirce’s chronique scanda- leuse. McWade at Canton, who was “disgracefully drunk” on one public oc- casion, and, while “boisterously drunk” on another, swore and wanted to fight because some one said “hurrah for Ire- land,” and who was believed throughout China to be notoriously corrupt, bore McKinley’s commission. So did Oscar F. Williams, who was appointed to Sin- gapore after a blemished record else- where. Mr. Greener of Vladivostok, “whose habits are said to be extremely bad,” and Levi L. Wilcox at Hankow, who “cannot be said to be a useful con- sular officer,” are, we believe, also of the McKinley régime. Their careers and the dishonor they have brought on the country ought to facilitate the pas- sage of the Consular Reform bill, now in conference. Much of the “starch” has, unfortunately, been taken out of this measure; as it now stands, it is merely a changeling substitute for Mr. Root’s hopeful child of the early session. Yet, such as it is, it is a great step forward, and it is bound to raise the tone of the service. The blight of politics will be largely lifted. Neither permanency of tenure nor regular promotion is guar- anteed, but these may be established by special acts as time goes on. Most of the civil-service reform fea- tures have been cut out by the Con- gressional spoilsmen. Much can be done by the President, however, to offset this. He can prescribe regulations precisely as he and his predecessors have done for the civil service, and he can absolutely decline to appoint men who, although able to pass examinations, are still not men of the highest character. Consuls and consul-generals are still “demand- ed” by Senators and Representatives, but President Roosevelt ought to be able to decide for himself. Secretary Root is certain to continue his agitation for a complete reorganization of the service, and a readiness on the part of the Ad- ministration to do its full duty would complete the reform it has so well be- gun. SKY-SCRAPING TARIFF TAXES. The Republican delegation from Mas- sachusetts in the House of Representa- tives, having failed by ordinary meth- ods of petition and argument to obtain the free hides and other tariff conces- sions it needs, has now announced its purpose to make itself a centre for all the revision sentiment in Congress. Without being over-sanguine, the mem- bers hope to attract to themselves, a few at a time, other disaffected Republicans, a handful who want free lumber here, @ group who want the steel schedule revised there, and so on, until, possibly in some far-off happier day, the scale may turn and the revisionists compel some sort of action. It is a more cour- ageous thing to do than the public un- familiar with the ways of Washington understands, and, even if it does not yield results in the statute-book, it gives new and public backing to an important cause. We noticed the other day the hu- morous petition of a small group of Michigan manufacturers for the imposi- tion of a 125 per cent. duty on. wooden shoes, in order that this promising. though hitherto unheard-of, American industry might be able to hold its own with foreign competitors. So far as we have yet seen, no one has regarded this request as anything but a joke. The Protective Tariff League is thus far si- lent, and Mr. McCleary, the higher-duty advocate, has not said a word. Apwpa- rently, such of our citizens as still wear wooden shoes are welcome to buy them in whatsoever country turns them out most cheaply. Yet the band of Massa- chusetts revisionists can, if it chooses, point to a large number of duties high- er than the wooden-shoe makers’ re- quest, and to some quite as preposterous. To be specific, there are twenty-one different commodities on which there were collected in the last fiscal year duties equivalent to more than 125 per cent. ad valorem. There were fifty- seven instances of duties equivalent to over 100 per cent. The facts in these cases are obtainable by any one from the reports of the Bureau of Statistics in the Department of Commerce and Labor. Mr. John Sharp Williams tabu- lated the particular data for use in a recent speech. Of course, there is no clause in the Dingley law which men- tions any such rates. These are all spe- cific duties or specific duties combined with moderate ad-valorem rates; but the rate actually charged may be figured from the simple ratio between stated values and duties paid. Moreover, to- bacco and spirituous liquors, where a high tariff tax is laid to offset the rev- enue tax, are not included. There have been extreme instances, as in the case where mica, under the turn of the law, was made to pay 4,000 per cent. on its commercial value. But these are interesting chiefly as curiosi- ties, and the highest duty regularly ex acted is, according to this table, a bare 251.73 per cent. This was collected on vanillin, the active principle of vanilla, of which $423 worth in 1905 paid $1,064.80 duty. Vanillin, it is true, is not a necessity of life, and perhaps even a prohibitive tariff would not be gen- erally felt. But shoddy, which affects the poor only, paid the equivalent of 250 per cent. Silk handkerchiefs of a cer tain grade paid 221.27 per cent, and dress facings or skirt bindings, not bleached, dyed, or printed, paid 201 per cent. The articles on which duties between 200 and 125 per cent. are collected may be briefly given here, with the under- standing that in most instances the rate stated applies only to a particular grade of the product, and in some cases to unimportant or unusual ones. Per cent. Articles. 185.76 Bay rum. 165.11 Dress goods. 150.32 Blankets 157.52 Dress goods. 151.93 Oloths, woollen or. worsted, 151.07 Pilate glass. 143.72 “Other manufactures of wool."’ 141.02 Plushes and other pile fabrics. 140.29 Plate glass. 140.06 Plushes and other pile fabrics 139.7 Boracie acid. 138.06 Yarns. 136.44 Plate glass. 130.70 Fiannels for underwear. 120.80 Mineral waters. 126.70 “Other manufactures of wool."’ 125.44 Blankets. We have stopped this list advisedly at the rate of duty asked for in the ridic- ulous wooden-shoe petition. Is there a single one of the schedules above men- tioned which could be defended on its merits on the floor of Congress, or any- where else? Is there one of those duties which a nation not made up of luna- tics would even think of levying if it had the task of making a tariff de novo? And if it is preposterous to establish a new 125 per cent. duty for the benefit of a few struggling Western wooden- shoe factories, is it not just as prepas- terous to retain similar duties for the benefit of other interests which have grown great on tariff favors? We have cited merely the extremes, the cases about which most men, whatever their political opinions, would agree without hesitation. But to grant tnat the 251 per cent. duty on vanillin differs only in de- gree of extortion from a dozen of the schedules on the commonest and most necessary articles of life is a logical step from which Republicans draw back. The very men who laughed at Mr. Wiliiame’s “banana speech” will not é@xfend and apply his reasoning. DIFFICULTIES OF RETRENCHMENT. The case of the Engiish Liberals just row illustrates a tendency of govern- ment which is more and more coming to prevail all over the world. We mean = SS EE a PESin aeNE ee eee eee eee —— ne ee | rer | ere

Page 10

276 The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2127 the fact that public expenses are stead- ily rising, and that it is steadily more difficult to cut them down. A distinct item in the Liberal election programme was retrenchment. The Tories were ac- cused of having pushed the public out- lay, not only above all precedent, but beyond all reason; and the people were asked to elect a Government that would economize. Well, the economies in pros- pect are beggarly: the new objects of expenditure already pressed upon Parlia- ment make lavish demands. The army bill, into which the Liberals were going i» thrust so deep-cutting a knife, they have been able to pare down by only $50,000 Meanwhile, projects urging new appropriations of many millions are insistently urged upon the Govern- ment. The Chancellor of the Exchequer reminded the House the other day of the promises with which his party had taken office, and then ran over the list of measures calling for great and fresh outlay advocated by Liberals within the even days past, ending with the sarcas- tic: “Pretty well for one week.” Yet this same Chancellor of the Ex- chequer, Mr. Asquith, in addressing dele- gates from the Conference of Taxing \uthorities, agreed that, in municipal- itles at least, it is impossible “to cut down or arrest your expenditure.” The reason he gave was as follows: We are constantly adopting a higher and, I may eall it, a more exacting stand- ird of municipal life Sanitation, edu- ition, and a number of other interests f that kind, the due attention to which all feel to be bound up with the real roaperity and welfare of the community these are things which you cannot put ipon one side or postpone without serious risk to the interests which our municipal bade ire intended to represent. There- fore it is of paramount importance that ome additional reservoir should be found upon which, in justice and equality, drafts in be made to meet the ever-growing sities of the community.” This is undoubtedly true. It is as true of American as of British cities. It i true of our State and national gov- ernments as well as our municipal. * In i) of them we believe that great re- trenchment could be effected. The pub- lic business is extravagantly or waste- fully done Almost anywhere, a vig- orous and trained administrator in pub- lle offl©ee could cut off sinecures and lop leaks Yet his most unremitting efforta would not prevent the gradual rise in the seale of public expenditure. It mounts not alone absolutely, but rela- tively; and so far as we can gee, is bound to do so for some time to come. Every extension of the functions of gov- ernment is costly, yet the people are everywhere demanding that they be more and more extended. What they keep on demanding they are pretty cer- tain to obtain, at the end of the chap- ter; and if they get a bigger tax bill along with it, they should not grumble but they do. This was Mr. Asquith’s point, and it is the chief one to bear in niind in the whole business. Expenditure goes with taxes, and as the former mounts so do the latter. Indeed, from the states- man's standpoint, the increase in taxes is more directly significant than the in- crease in their outlay. He has to find the added revenue. This means either a screwing up of old taxes or the dis- covery of new ones. In either case the result, for the taxpayers, is the same. They are called upon to surrender a larger and larger part of their income to the State. This is really the practi- cal aspect of the matter which it 1s pri- marily more important to understand than any question of theoretic Socialism. Hence there was point in the remark of the old professor of political economy to the eager young fellow who came asking what he should study in order to grapple with the questions of municipal and government ownership, socialistic experiments, and what not. The reply was: “Study taxation.” The duty of counting the cost thereof is too often overlooked in plans for en- larging and improving the activities of government. Yet it is vital to the whole question. ‘Take the proposal that pub- lic schools should give the children of the poor at least one nourishing meal a day. Its latest eloquent advocate here distinctly dismisses the question of ex- pense. Into that, he has not thought it worth while to go. He is sure that it “can be managed.” Perhaps it can, but note what happens when the same pro- posal is brought up in Parliament and reduced to pounds, shillings, and pence. The Minister of Education, Mr. Birrell, had exact estimates of cost prepared, and showed that the total would be too great for the Imperial Exchequer to un- dertake at present. The step may yet be taken in England, as we presume it will be in American cities. but it certain- ly will make necessary new forms of taxation. Taxes will surely become more bur- densome as the functions of government are multiplied. That is a truth which ardent social reformers should not at- tempt to deny. They will have to pay more themselves; so will all their friends. The old professor was right. Fundamental to every new govern- mental experiment is the question where the money to carry it on is to be found. We are not now saying that such ex- periments ought not to be made, but they should be made with our eyes open to the fact that taxpayers will have to foot the bill. THE MOROCCO SETTLEMENT. Last Saturday, just a year after the Kaiser's sensational visit to Tangier, the Algeciras Conference arrived at the following agreement: The Sultanate is to be policed by troops under French and Spanish officers, who are jointly answerable to the Sultan and to the dip- lomatic corps at Fez. In the important havens of Tangier and Casablanca there will be both French and Spanish offi- cers; Spain will have the exclusive of- ficering of Tetuan on the Mediterranean and of Larache on the Atlantic, France that of the four Atlantic ports, Mogador, Safi, Mazagan, and Rabat. This po- lice agreement holds for five years. On the financial side, France gets a sub- stantial plurality interest in the new Morocco bank, holding three out of fif- teen shares, of which no other European nation controls more than one. Such, in brief, is the settlement of a highly delicate, and at times fairly ominous, dispute. In the compromise, France gets prac- tically all her concrete claims, but her pretensions to exclusive jurisdiction in Morocco are disallowed; Germany ob- tains full acceptance of her abstract championship of internationalism, but is denied all but the very smallest part in the actual administration of Morocco. One may fairly say that both the ideas of Germany and the policy of France have prevailed, with the important dif- ference that France has renounced the monopolistic claims set up by Delcassé with the assent of Madrid and London, and has accepted a temporary but re- newable trust as mandatory of the Eu- ropean Concert. Germany has made it plain that she must be consulted in Med- iterranean matters, and has called a halt to limited agreements like that be- tween France and England. On the oth- er hand, the conference has shown that if the Powers admit the German prin- ciple of internationalism, they are dis- inclined to invite the practical aid of Germany in the Mediterranean. In fact, the most striking diplomatic result of the conference is the demonstration of the isolation of Berlin. The new friend, Russia, was as cold as the old ally, Italy, towards any plan that put Ger- many even indirectly in control of the police or the bank. Only Austria saved Germany from standing alone before united Europe. Since Germany has gained all she con- tended for as a matter of principle, why does she appear to have suffered a re- buff? The reason must be found in the sadly mixed motives, the sudden shifts of ground, the wearisome delays that characterized all the actual negotiations of Germany before and during the Al- geciras conference. Had the Kaiser made his altruistic intentions clear and unmistakable from the first, he mignt to-day claim an unclouded victory. Had he maintained his pose as the champion of the open door and the enemy of par- ticularism as regards weak Powers, he would to-day be as unmistakably the hero of the play as poor M. Delcassé is, in retrospect, its villain. As a matter of fact, the position of Germany was from the first unhappily ambiguous. Professedly the tribune of Europe, Ger- q * 1 2 Ck etna a!

Page 11

vee cout ob, 7 plc dia ee a April 5, 1906] The Nation. many fell under the unfortunate suspi- cion of taking up that policy of grab which France, by dismissing M. Delcassé and by consenting to the conference, had expressly disavowed. Of course, anything like justice be- tween nations is usually obtained in such tortuous ways. National motives are apt to be mixed. Yet it is clear that if the German Foreign Office had taken a passive attitude in the conference, any settlement whatever must have been hailed as a victory for German diplo- macy, while no settlement was likely to have conceded more to France than she now gets. The honors are distinctly with M. Rouvier. His withdrawal of the extreme claims made by M. Delcassé, his frank, opportune, and moderate statement of the minimum programme of France, his patience under the am- biguous and obstructive policy of Ger- many, constitute an admirable example of straightforward, considerate, and en- lightened diplomacy. Equally praise- worthy was the moderation of the French press—the better sort, we mean —throughout the controversy. Every- where was shown a disposition to meet Germany, if possible, and to discounte- nance talk of war. The general feeling that Germany has met with a check is exaggerated, per- haps, by a natural confusion between the diplomatic manners and the diplomatic aims of the Wilhelmstrasse. To do a disagreeable duty as disagreeably as possible is no royal road to popularity. It would be interesting, for example, to inquire how far the impression of Ger- man defeat is due merely to the brist- ling and masterful personality of Count Tattenbach. Such a temperament al- ways gives the impression of intending more than it really intends. Yet it is fair to add that at no time has the Ger- man Government pushed the point of national prestige to perilous extremes. Retrospectively, the Kaiser and M. Del- cass6 must share a common regret that the conference was not called very promptly and conducted in a non-con- tentious spirit. M. Delcassé must see how little France had to fear from the appeal he combated so stubbornly, and the Kaiser must perceive how hopeless it always was to seek from Europe in council any admission of especial Ger- man prerogative in Morocco. THE NEW MONT PELBE. FORT-DE-FRANCE, MARTINIQUE, March 11, 1906. The better part of three years has elapsed since I last visited the great mountain whose name is still in the mouth of every inhabitant of this beautiful, even if deso- late, isle of France. Eh bien, le volcan? It is the old inquiry which has now become almost sympathetic with the people, but which has lost none of its significance in consequence of the recent earthquake dis- turbances. On February 16 the capital city of the island saw thirty of its loosely con- structed habitations marked out for re- pairs, heaps of débris stood in the place of former walls, and the affrighted people were camped in the sarane which surrounds the noble statue of Josephine. Some two dozen or more earthquake tremors have been registered since that date, and night- fall still sees many of the less courageous departing for the campagne, where low wooden buildings, perched on breezy hill- tops, place one, if not necessarily outside of the field of the seismic movements, at least beyond reach of the much-dreaded raz de marée. Naturally enough, Pelée is held largely responsible for the recent hap- penings, and the observations on the vol- cano that are at frequent intervals sent down from the observatory of Morne des Cadets, are eagerly scanned and studied But these observations tell only that the mountain is “calm,” or is “covered,” or that it “disengages much vapor."’ Mont Pelée has, in fact, entered upon a period of repose, and not since June last has it given signs of a recrudescence of ectivity. It is true that its smoldering dome is still far from being a picture of quiet nature, but the luminous points have entirely disap- peared, and one hears no more of that ominous rumbling and roaring which is so happily expressed by the French word grondement. Pelée is to-day much less active than is Vesuvius, and it has again taken its place among the beautiful objects of nature. Veg- etation is slowly but steadily creeping up its deeply rifted slopes, the desert sands have already largely disappeared beneath the new growth of tree-fern, grass, and moss; and even on the smouldering dome diminutive oases of green are being wrap- ped about the fuming fumeroles. It would be difficult to find a more enchanting view than that which overlooks this mountain from the Morne des Cadets. It is the Bay of Naples over again, both in mountain form and in color—lacking, of course, near- ly everything that is indicative of man’s activities, but exuberant in all that a bountiful tropical nature offers. The grands bois of Martinique, with their giant tree-ferns, bamboos, and broad-leaved cannas as the distinctive physiognomic vegetable types in a wilderness of mela- stomes, magnolias, cecropias, and figs still cover the rugged mountain slopes, and only here and there in the deep valleys have they yielded place to fields of cane or to planations of cacao and coffee. The for- ests are silent, perhaps more silent than they were before the cataclysm of Pelée, and only at rare intervals is the life within made known through the exquisite piping tones of the little bird that is here called the siffleur de la montagne. Three years ago Pelée was a mountain’ of almost exactly the height, in its normal summit, of Vesuvius, but it was then capped by a giant obelisk of rock which earried its apex a full thousand feet high- er. To-day this obelisk, except in jagged teeth that mark where it was implanted on top of the voleano, no longer exists, and, with its destruction, the geologist has noted the disappearance of one of the most remarkable features of the earth's surface. Vast blocks of rock, some of them hardly less large than the cases of the villagers who at one time looked up with awe to Q77 this stupendous monument of nature, lie scattered about in the wilderness of débris that helps to fill in the former crater- basin, and they read well the story of disruption and fali. I made the ascent of the voleano on the 27th of February, with the hope of being able to descend into the | crater-basin and of studying these rock débris close at hand. Until now the Pelée tower had repelled direct scientific inves tigation, and the constitution of its rock mass remained necessarily within the do- main of hypothesis. To-day the fires of the mountain have been drawn, and approach is made possible. I selected for my descent into the crater a position on the northwestern border, where the bounding-wall had been reduced to a height of perhaps not more than a hundred feet, and where the angle of slope hardly exceeded 65 or 70 degrees. A sharp wind swept over the knife-edge, which we were obliged to straddle, but with some caution we passed the line of first offence, and before long reached the crater-floor the rainure of the French Scientific Com- mission. Here we were placed directly in face of the giant dome, which still carries at its summit the jagged remains of the former obelisk. The day, unfortunately, was not so favorable as one might have wished for. Clouds passed and repassed in seemingly endless masses, and only once did the dome disclose itself in its entirety But that one occasion revealed a splendid spectacile—the giant mound of rock-débris, here and there scarred by lines or ridges of solid lava, rising to a height of about 500 feet, and from its sides puffing out noiseless streams of heated and sulphurous vapors. Carefully measuring the stability of the loose-lying débris, we slowly crawl ed up the steep slope of the dome; my associate, at whose habitation | had passed the fateful night of August 30, 1902, giv- ing me the advantage of his personal guid ance. He had attempted this same ascent | a few weeks earlier. We reached a posi tion on the dome which clearly overlooked the bounding-wall of the crater, and beyond which only bad counsel would have dic- tated further progress. This was the limit of our journey. I had attained the object of my mission —the determination of the structure of the rock-mass which formed the great tower of the volcano. A vast andesitic block, as solid and compact as the more ancient masses which constitute the core of the island of Martinique, it gives evidence of having been heaved up from the deep in terior in its present condition, firm and rigid—a monument of the Titanic force of the awakening volcano. ANGELO HEILPRIN, NAPOLEON, KING OF ELBA. Paris, March 14, 1906 M. Paul Gruyer has just published a very fine volume, illustrated with engravings, on a subject which cannot fail to draw at- tention—‘Napoleon, King of the Island of Elba.” We see on the first page a fine re- production of the well-known picture by Paul Delaroche of Napoleon at Fontaine- bleau, before his departure for the Island of Elba. The Emperor is aitting in a chair, bareheaded, with his high boots still a pre ee ee a = eee ee ny

Page 12

278 The Nation. [ Vol. 82, No. 2127 on, looking tired, grave, full of dark thoughts; his sword lies beside him on a table He wears his gray coat, already legendary, without any decoration. On the llth of April, 1814, it was agreed, in Article III. of the treaty signed in Paris with the approbation of the Provisional Government of France—by the plenipoten- tiaries of the Allies, and by Caulaincourt and Marshal Ney for Napoleon—that the Island of Elba, “chosen by Napoleon as his place of residence, should form, during his lifetime, a separate principality, which he would possess in full sovereignty and ownership.” An income of two millions. inscribed in the Grand Livre of France, was assigned him. The King of Elba was to receive all the honors due to crowned heads, but he ceased to be a French citizen. On the 20th of April, after the famous adieux to the Garde in the court, Napoleon left Fontainebleau in a post-chaise. All the in- ‘idents of his journey are well known: he was accompanied by a number of people, among them four commissioners of the armies of the Allies—an Austrian Gen- eral Kohler, the Russian General Shu- valoff, the Prussian General Waldburg- Truchsess, the English Colonel Sir Neil Campbell. The Emperor went aboard the Undaunted at Saint-Raphaél, the very place where he had disembarked fifteen years be- fore, on his return from Egypt. He landed at Porto Ferrajo in the island where he was to remain till the 15th of February, 1815. “What is,” asks M. Gruyer, “and what was the Island of Elba, and what did the Emperor do there during these ten months? What was the existence of the man who was yesterday at the summit of the Occi- dental world, and in twenty-four hours had become something like the sovereign of the Val d’Andorre or of San Marino?” Na- poleon’s sojourn on the Island of Elba is a period which has never much detained his- torians; they have been more occupied with the events which were taking place at the time In France. “The Island of Elba,” says M. Gruyer, “has remained a mere name. It evokes no idea, no precise image, like Saint Helena and Corsica, which call up Hudson Lowe and the familiar house at Ajaccio.” M. Gruyer had the curiosity to visit Elba. When he arrived there, in this terra incognita, he imagined he should find some bare rock fronting the sea, and was surprised to find a varied and pic- turesque surface. Civilization has not much affected it, and he had the pleasure of view- ing the same houses, the same rocks, which Napoleon had often seen. Even the Italians seldom visit Elba, though the distance from Porto Vecchio or Leghorn is very short. Porto Ferrajo, where the traveller lands, was founded by Cosmo de’ Medici in 1548; ite bay Is very fine, and resembles that of Naples. The first scream M. Gru- yer heard on landing was that of a man who ran by his side: “Signor! la testa di Napoleone,” and who conducted him to the church where, in an ebony coffin, he saw the bronze head of a dead Napoleon, a copy of the mask which Dr. Antommarchi took In plaster at Saint Helena after the death of the Emperor. The inhabitants of Elba pay annual honors to this tomb, with its bronze mask, on the 5th of May, the anni- versary of the death. The coffin is placed on a catafalque surrounded by wax can- dies, and in the presence of the official authorities a solemn mass is said. At the Town Hall is kept the flag which Napoleon adopted, white with a red band, on which are three bees. In the Council Room there is a copy of Gérard’s fine por- trait, sceptre in hand, a gold laurel crown on his head and an ermine mantle on his shoulders. In the library is found what re- mains of the Imperial Library—a motley collection, where, side by side with various scientific and military works, occur Mon- taigne, La Fontaine, ‘Don Quixote,’ Vol- taire, the ‘Cabinet des Fées’—forty volumes containing fables and legends. Napoleon was received with much enthu- siasm in the island. The inhabitants were proud to welcome him and to become his subjects. The Emperor landed in his green uniform, with white breeches; he wore the Legion of Honor and the Iron Crown of Italy. He had put on his “petit chapeau” the new cockade of Elba. Behind him were Jens. Bertrand and Drouot. A Te-Deum was sung in the church, and the Emperor had the Town Hall for his first residence. In his first conversation with the notable inhabitants, he astonished them by his acquaintance with all the resources of the island and its needs; he knew how much the salt tax yielded annually, how many fishing boats were employed; he was ac- quainted with the date of foundation of all the cities and villages, he was familiar with the topography, with the altitude of the mountains. At Fontainebleau he had before starting asked for all the official documents concerning the island, and had mastered them with the rapidity and con- cision to which he was used. He had stud- ied all the maps.and books concerning the island, and among others a ‘Journey to the Island of Elba,’ published in 1808 by Arséne Thiébaut. The day after his arrival he visited the iron min*s, famous for the ex- cellent quality of their ore. He made in turn a visit to all the communes, constant- ly accompanied by two chamberlains, two officers, a captain of gendarmerie, the sub- prefect Balbiani, whom he had appointed General-Intendant of the island; the mayor, and the presiding justice of Porto Ferrajo, by the faithful Bertrand and the English Commissioner Campbell. Everywhere he was received under rustic triumphal arches with showers of flowers. He examined with care all the forests. He rode ten hours a day without seeming to experience any fatigue. He chose for his residence a house which was called the Palace of the “Mu- lini.” He had it rebuilt and enlarged, and was his own architect. The furniture was partly sent from the Palace of Piombino, which had belonged to his sister Eliza. There are in M. Gruyer’s volume two inter- esting photographs, one of the garden and the terrace of the Mulini, with their fine view over the sea; another of the great «drawing-room, now entirely empty. Napoleon was allowed to keep a small de- tachment of his Guard. The old soldiers joined him in the island; he added to their number a battalion of Corsicans, and after a short time had a little troop of 1,592 men, which did not seem alarming to the Powers that had seen him at the head of great § armies. He had i besides a small fleet. He had about four millions of francs when he started from Fontainebleau; the French Government was to ensure him an income of two millions of francs. With these resources he had to cover all the expenses of the administra- tion of his small kingdom. He entered on his new role with his usual ardor; issued decree after decree, created establishments of all sorts, improved the coast trade, uni- formed his soldiers, fortified the coast, gave an entirely new life to the sleepy little island. His activity was partly instinctive and natural; partly it was a mask with which he covered further designs. He wished to create in the government of the Bourbons and the Allied Powers the belief that he had really abdicated, had renounc- ed his dreams of ambition, and had retired to his little island to live in peace and quietness. There was a witness who kept a constant eye on him, and who alone remained to watch the formidable exile, viz., Col. Camp- bell, the English commissioner, who had fought in Portugal and Spain under Well- ington. . He fulfilled his mission as a gen- tleman, but took daily notes of all he saw. Napoleon heard at Elba the news of the death of Josephine; he was expecting day after day Marie Louise, but she did not appear. He had a visit from the Countess Walewska, whom he had first known in Po- land, who had borne him a son and had joined him at Fontainebleau. She was at first taken for Napoleon’s wife. She gave him news of the Empress. She could stay but a short time, and, crossing the island on horseback during a gale, she reémbark- ed for Italy at Porto Longone. Soon after- wards arrived at the same port his sister Pauline Borghese. While she was with him he learned that Talleyrand had pro- posed to the members of the Congress of Vienna to transport Napoleon to a safer place than Elba. Several islands of the Atlantic Ocean were mentioned, among them Saint Helena. The Emperor affected not to be moved by the alarming informa- tion he received from different quarters. “Europe,” said he, “will not do such a thing. From the point of view of Eng- land especially, Saint Helena above all is impossible. I should be too near India. And, after all, I can defend myself here for two years.” In reality he was alarm- ed. An unknown visitor, who stayed only two hours with him, seems to have pre- cipitated the crisis. Napoleon was afraid of being kidnapped or even assassinated; he received warning and confidential let- ters from many sources; he became very restless. M. Gruyer enters into the most minute account of the life he led, going from place to place incessantly, occupied with a thousand details, receiving visits, trying to keep his little army disciplined, and to get recruits in the place of the old soldiers who were leaving him. There can be no doubt that the idea of a return to France never left him for a mo- ment; he had kept the secret to himself from the day when he left Fontainebleau, but it became more and more imperious in the solitude of Elba. The agitation in which he lived was factitious; his little government of Elba was a mere comedy. He was determined to try fortune once more. The return from Elba is well known; history has followed Napoleon from the day when he landed with his small troop on the French coast at Antibes to the battlefield of Waterloo, and to the island of Saint Helena. M. Gruyer’s volume is a very interesting ne A ——- =r. a Ree ee eee

Page 13

ote Anda teeeins a ane April 5, 1906] The Nation. re contribution to Napoleonic literature. It has been published with much care by Hachette, and its illustrations bring vivid- ly before the reader the incidents of Napo- leon’s brief sojourn in the lonely little isl- and of the Mediterranean. Correspondence. MEYER’S WORK ON RAILWAY RATES. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Srr: In connection with the review of Prof. Hugo R. Meyer’s book on Govern- ment Regulation of Railway Rates in the issue of the Nation for March 8, may I call the attention of your readers to a review of the same book in the January-February number of the Archiv fiir Eisenbahnwesen by Dr. Alfred v. d. Leyen, a recognized authority upon the subject of transporta- tion, who has written much concerning both American and German railways? This review, which is devoted mainly to a con- sideration of the portion of the book relat- ing to Germany, shows that Professor Meyer’s treatment, under cover of an ap- parent erudition, is quite superficial, and that he is in many places guilty either of deliberate misrepresentation or of in- excusable ignorance. I feel constrained to call attention to this review becauge the book has been widely read in railroad cir- cles, and has been accepted as a true state- ment by those who are either unable or unwilling to test its assertions by an in- vestigation of the facts. FRANK HAIGH DIXON. Hanoves, N. H., March 27, 1906, POOR RICHARD’S POETRY. To THE EpIToR OF THE NATION: Srr: May I add a postscript to my letter in the Nation for March 22? A good deal of the poetry printed in Poor Richard’s earlier almanacs was derived from ‘Witts Recreations,’ a humorous mis- cellany published in London in 1640, and reprinted, under the title of ‘Facetiae,’ in London in 1817. This volume accounts for ten pieces of verse in each of the first two almanacs, for six pieces in the issue for 1736, for the two “fantasticks’’ set down for September and October, 1738, and for a dozen of the shorter epigrams printed be- tween 1735 and 1746. In some cases the space which the almanac devoted to poetry (“on the heads of the months’) was filled by combining two four-line epigrams, not always on closely related subjects. Exam- ples may be seen in the verses for August and November, 1734, and for August and September, 1736. Another volume which ought to be men- tioned here is ‘A Collection of Epigrams,’ printed for J. Walthoe, second edition, Lon- don, 1735. This collection seems to have supplied Poor Richard with about twenty pieces of verse (eight for 1737, five for 1738, two for 1741, and three couplets for 1739). And perhaps it is worth while to add that the verses for March, 1737, and January, 1739, occur in ‘The Muses Choice: or The Merry Fellow,’ London, 1754. W. P. Musrarp. Haverrosp. Pa., March 20, 1906. Notes. One of the features of the International Exposition to be held at Milan next autumn will be the meeting of the first Historical Congress of the Italian Risorgimento, which has been organized under the direction of the most eminent historical authors and students in Italy. The congress will open on November 1, and, besides sessions at which papers and discussions will be in or- der, there will be an exhibition, chronologi- cally arranged, of documents, letters, and memorials of all kinds concerning the Risorgimento—the period, that is, between 1796 and 1870. Committees have been ap- pointed for each section of Italy and for France, England, Germany, and the United States. The delegate for the United States is Mr. William Roscoe Thayer, who will be glad to communicate with any persons who may have documentary or other material | which they may be willing to lend to the congress. His address is No. 8 Berkeley Street, Cambridge, Mass. A Life of Sir Henry Irving, by Bram Stoker, is to appear in the autumn with Macmillan’s imprint. Other announcements by this firm are a Life of Lord Leighton, in two volumes, by Mrs. Russell Barrington; a Life of Walter Crane; and ‘Vacation Ram- bles in London,’ by E. V. Lucas. We welcome the seventh issue of Mr. James Clegg’s handy and valuable ‘Inter- national Directory of Booksellers and Bib- liophile’s Manual,’ whose further descrip- tion of itself merits quotation in extenso: “Including lists of the Public Libraries of the World, Publishers, Book Collectors, Learned Societies and Institutions, Uni- versities and Colleges; also, Bibliographies of Book and Library Catalogues, Concord- ances, Bookplates, etc., etc.” And if we proceed to analyze the etcetera, we must add as novelties in the present triennial revision Bookbinders in London and the Provinces; Record and Literary Searchers, Translators, and Indexers; Colonial and Foreign Learned and Scientific Societies; Literary Agents; South African Public Schools; and American Educational In- stitutions. But we can assure our readers that there is much more beside for one who carefully examines this compact thesaurus. It should be in every public library. Mr. Clegg’s address is the Aldine Press, Rochdale, England. Two more volumes have just appeared in the charming series of “Les Classiques Francais” (Dent-Putnam). One is George Sand’s ‘Mare au Diable,’ the other a selec- tion from Sainte-Beuve’s ‘‘Lundis,”’ ‘Profils Anglais’—the first profile being of Franklin, and the others of Mary Stuart, Gibbon, Chesterfield, and Cowper; solid entertain- ment. Each volume has the author’s por- trait, a biography with appreciations, and a choice bibliography. In Sainte-Beuve's, one may read a French translation of Words- worth’s “Scorn not the Sonnet.” Mr. Eustace Ball, a writer by no means inexperienced in this sort of composition, has issued a small guidebook to Rome (London: Black; New York: Macmillan), about which the most that can be said is that it is perhaps no worse than some others of the same sort. The author had apparently several of the best-known guidebooks in English open before him, and has drawn upon them, but to no useful is- sue. No one ought to write even briefly upon the remains of ancient Rome who must pick up miscellaneous scraps of in- formation from various, and often discord ant, tertiary authorities, and trust to luck abovt his reconstruction of them. The re- sult is sure to be an incongruous and mia leading conglomeration, and to abound in blunders that are sometimes ludicrous. The publishers are perhaps responsible for in serting a plan of the Forum which is label led as up to date (1904), but is merely a slight modification of J. H. Middleton's plan, and even leaves the Comitium and the Basilica A®milia still buried No two artists could well be more un like, either in person or in production, than the subjects of two of the latest of the Knackfuss ‘Kiinstler-Monographien,”” An selm Feuerbach and Constantin Meunier (Lemcke & Buechner). Feuerbach never tired of painting his own handsome face, and, from the pretty boy of 1846 to the splendid swell of 1878, it is always the ro mantic ideal of an artist that he repre- sents. Of Meunier we have only photo- graphs vividly presenting the home-spun ugliness of an elderly workingman Yet the romantically beautiful Feuerbach was that most tiresome of created beings, a German classicist; the plain Belgian arti san was a true Romanticist of great indi viduality and power. To look over the plates of Feuerbach’'s pictures and the pre- liminary studies for them is be appalled at the result of the misapplication of so much knowledge; to glance at the cuts after Meunier’s sculpture is almost to wonder, at first, whether any academic knowledge is necessary to an artist of native force. Of course the truth is that Meunier’s work is much more learned than it looks, and that Feuerbach’s learning is much less sufficient than it seems. Th remedy for any revolutionary feeling into which one may be betrayed is a coursg of the old masters or of the greatest French- men. E. B. Greenshields has made an oddly composite book of ‘Landscape Painting and Modern Dutch Artists,’ which is pub- lished by the Baker-Taylor Co. It begios with a brief history of landscape painting, goes on with a discussion of the theories on art of various artists and critics, and then, at page 127, comes to the real busi- ness of the book, which is a presentation of the work of seven Dutch painters, Bos- boom, Israels, Mauve, the three Marises, and Weissenbruch. The gist of the first part is the elaborate proof of what, at this day, seems hardly worth proving, viz., that art should be “subjective.” The re- sult of the method is to give the impres- sion that not only are these Dutchmen fine painters, but that they are the heirs of the ages, for whom the world has been waiting—the first truly great landscape artists. Fine painters they are, but there were heroes before Agamemnon. ‘Bruges and West Flanders’ (London: Biack; New York: Macmillan) is one of the typical books of travel, illustrated in colors, which modern methods of color- printing have made common. The text, by G. W. T. Omond, accompanies thirty- seven water-colors by A. Forestier, inter- esting in subject, and sound, if not dis- tinguished, in drawing; but, whether

Page 14

280 The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2127 through the fault of the artist or of the process of reproduction, rather violent and sometimes quite inharmonious in color. In especial there is a prevalent raw purple which we find most distressing Prescott F. Hall's ‘Immigration’ (Henry Holt) is the first of a proposed series of volumes dealing with the political and economic problems of the day, which is to be brought out under the editorial direc- tion of R. C. Ringwalt The author is ecretary of an association formed to ad- vocate the restriction of immigration It was time for a new book upon this subject to appear, since Mayo-Smith’s treatise is already out of date and represents a point of view long outgrown Mr. Hall has made a careful study of a mass of ma- terials, and has produced a readable work containing a large amount of valuable information He advocates various addi- tional restrictions upon immigration, but does not take a narrow or illiberal atti- tude towards the question. Especially to be commended is the discussion of the racial effects of immigration The book would make an even more favorable impression if the footnotes did not sometimes indicate 1 lack of discrimination in the use of ma- terials It may be accepted, however, as 1 trustworthy géneral guide; and to col- lege debating societies—which, we suspect, the editor of the series has especially in mind—it should prove a godsend Studies in American Trade Unionism’ (Henry Holt), edited by Professors Hollan- Vier and Barnett, is a volume of essays by members of the seminary of economics of Johns Hopkins University The several papers deal with the organization, govern- ment, finances, and policies of leading la- bor unions, and conclude with an essay upon the Knights of Labor and the Amer- ican Federation of Labor. They are based, mn considerable part, upon original re- earches made possible by a private gift of money and a grant from the Carnegie Institution. Though confined to particular features of particular trade unions, the data dealt with are comprehensive and typical; so that the result is a substantial contri- bution to our knowledge of trade-union tructure and functions, even though the discoveries of the investigators do not al- ways have the charm of novelty. The pre- face, by Professor Hollander, is devoted lurgely to the consideration of economic method, in which the only thing that calls for eriticiam is his apparent conviction of the importance and necessity of such a dis- cussion Whatever may or may not have been true some twenty years ago, it seems unnecesgary to-day to remind us that safe theorizing in matters economic must be hased upon “qualitative data,” amassed as deliberately and laboriously as chemical or physical data are collected by the natural clentiat. It is needless also to dwell upon the unwholesome relation which existed between political economy and the laboring class for the first three-quarters of the nineteenth century.” However, if any of our readers need reassurance upon either of these points, they will find comfort in the excellent studies brought together in this volume Dr. Alfred A. Woodhull’s ‘Personal Hy- ziene’ (John Wiley & Sons) contains with- in 200 pages the substance of lectures on personal hygiene given at Princeton “in the last few years.” It embodies in the first place a short but practical and suffi- cient account of the anatomy and physiol- ogy of the different organs and functions of the body, and then considers, one by one, the reasons that should guide us in exer- cise, in food, in bathing, in our choice of clothing, and in reference to stimulants and narcotics. The position which the writer takes in reference to these questions is temperate and sensible, and while total- abstinence reformers will not find support for their extreme position, both they and all moderate-minded people cannot fail to be pleased to note in the author's argu- ments a decided leaning toward pronounc- ed temperance In the 300 pages of Dr. Edward Curtis's ‘Nature and Health’ (Henry Holt & Co.) very interesting subjects are taken up. The reason why we should ventilate our houses, and the arguments for and against open windows at night; the chemical principles and the social considerations that should guide us in the choice of food and in the manner of serving it; the alcohol and to- bacco question; the risks to which we are exposed as regards our sight and hearing; how we should keep the body and mind properly exercised without fatigue; even the problems of living and dying, and many other questions of like sort, are all touched upon in a practical fashion. The style of the writing is easy and uncon- ventional, possibly at times a little too colloquial. A dictionary is a book which does not lend itself to brief reviewing, and it is per- haps enough to say that ‘Black’s Medical Dictionary’ (Macmillan) is well executed, and that the illustrations are interesting and well chosen, at least from the physician's point of view. It and the two foregoing works are all unusually good presentations of practical medicine for those who wish to be their own physicians. Black's Diction- ary, indeed, goes further than this, and fur- nishes good food for many a practitioner or studious layman. The Essex Institute of Salem, Mass., has recently published a valuable monograph on the ‘Physical Geography, Geology, Min- eralogy and Paleontology of Essex Coun- ty, Massachusetts,’ the result of twelve years of patient work by John Henry Sears, curator at the Peabody Museum, in Salem; a quarto of 417 pages, with many plates and figures, and a geological map. The rocks are elaborately described according to modern petrographic methods, and their in- tricate structure is unravelled. Glacial geology is also treated in detail, and a dis- cussion of postglacial subsidence is pre- sented, with the conclusion that it is still progressing at the rate of about two feet in a century. Although fossils are rare in this district, careful search has found some specimens in the ancient (Cam- brian) rocks of Nahant and in the post- glacial (Leda) clays at various points. The Mat of minerals includes over 100 kinds. The learned world has waited forty-five years for the appearance of the second volume of the Catalogue of Sanskrit Manu- scripts in the Bodleian Library. The first volume, by Aufrecht, did not contain all the titles (some being accidentally omitted) of the manuscripts then in the library, so that a nucleus of material for the second volume was at hand even before the first volume was published. Inthe meantime there have been many accessions, and the present volume, begun by Professor Winternitz and completed by Mr. Arthur Keith (‘Cata- logue of Sanskrit MSS. in the Bodleian Li- brary,’ Oxford: Clarendon Press; New York: H. Frowde), makes good the de- ficiencies of the first volume and continues the work to date. Among new acquisitions are the famous Bower MS. and the Weber Fragments (of the fifth century), several MSS. of the tenth and eleventh centuries, and nearly five hundred MSS. of the Hultzsch collection. The importance of the present volume will therefore be apparent to all Indie scholars. It should be in every public and university library. The imprint of the Clarendon Press is a guar- antee of the care with which the work has been done, and the excellence of its typography. Dr. Paul Cohn of the Industrial Museum in Vienna, who visited this country in 1904 as a member of the International Jury of the Louisiana Purchase Exposition, and prepared an important report to the Aus- trian Handelsministerium on the Chemical Industries at that Exposition, has col- lected his observations on American educational affairs in a pamphlet, ‘Das Bildungswesen in den Vereinigten Staaten von Nordamerika’ (Vienna; Hélder). The bulk of his notes is devoted to the colleges and universities, and gives as clear a view of the difference in administration and organization of the various kinds of our higher educational institutions as could well be expected in the small compass of forty-seven pages. The author has evi- dently made very careful studies, and might well have filled a much larger vol- ume to advantage, had he been so inclined. Especially do the introductory and con- cluding chapters, on “The Creation of the American Nation” and on “The Future of the American Nation,” seem too condensed. The latter contains a much-needed warning to “Europeans who pay a short visit to the United States and want to see and study everything on the run, and who turn up their noses at everything because every- thing is not arranged according to Euro- pean notions, which they regard as ‘high- er.’”’ A well-made index—not a common thing in a German book of this size—en- hances its value as a book of reference. The report of the Geographical Society of Berne for the year 1903-04 contains an account by Dr. W. Volz of his impressions of the Sandwich Islands, together with some facts in regurd to the fauna and flora. Other articles are by Dr. M. Groll on the Oeschinensee, a Swiss mountain lake, and an interesting paper on weather prophets by Prof. EB. Briickner. The earliest whom he mentions were the priests of Apollo at Delphi, who for money would foretell the weather at any required time. The Ro- man astrological forecast, in which Cicero, Virgil, and Tacitus were believers, was ob- tained by dividing the year by seven, the remainder indicating the planet which ruled the weather for that year. The planet for 1906 is Venus, whose characteristics are an excess of moisture and heat. In treating of modern weather prophets, Briickner con- fines himself to the Germans, and espe- clally to the late Rudolf Falb. The first number of Petermann’s Mit- teilungen for the present year opens with x

Page 15

5 NT arent IP itemise i singe lh April 5, 1906] The Nation. 281 the route notes of an expedition for the geologic study of the Bolivian Andes head- ed by Prof. G. Steinmann. Among the places of interest visited in the heart of the mountains was Cochabamba, a flourishing city of 30,000 inhabitants, the centre of a rich and well-cultivated region, the gran- ary of the land. Rittmeister Isachsen sum- marizes, in a series of quotations from the reports of Arctic explorers, beginning with our Capt. Hall of the Polaris, 1871-3, the condition of the palwocrystic ice, and con- cludes that the existence of glaciered land to the north of Greenland and America is highly improbable. Some of the results of an investigation of the four atmospheric strata of the Atlantic, a continuation of the work of the Prince of Monaco by Pro- fessor Hergesell, are given by the editor, Professor Supan. The departure is chron- icled of Dr. Sven Hedin on his new ex- pedition, the expense of which is borne by King Oscar, E. Nobel, and others. After an examination of the deserts of Eastern Persia, he will visit the sources of the Indus and Brahmaputra Rivers, and from thence go to the great lake region of cen- tral Tibet. A German scientific expedition has sailed in the steamer Planet to deter- mine, among other things, the temperature and salinity of the waters of the Bismarck- Archipelago, as ‘well as to analyze the gases suspended in the sea-water and to study the atmospberic strata. Prof. Edward G. Bourne, chairman of the Historical Manuscripts Commission of the American Historical Association; Mr. Worthington C. Ford, of the Library of Congress; and Dr. J. Franklin Jameson of the Carnegie Institution, have issued joint- ly a four-page leaflet of suggestions re- specting the transcription and printing of historical manuscripts. The suggestions are eminently sensible, and follow as a rule the accepted practice of the best modern editors. The leaflet should be carefully studied by all whose duty or pleasure it is to prepare historical documents for the press. The American Committee of the Egypt Exploration Fund, which was constituted in 1902 upon the discontinuance of the long- standing relation between the Fund and its active representative in this country, has now resigned, and, after July 31, 1906, the London Committee will itself assume di- rect control of the work of the Fund in the United States. Mr. Edward R. Warren and Miss Grace I. Gay, who will serve respec- tively as treasurer and secretary for Amer- ica, will continue the Boston office of the Fund in the Pierce Building, Copley Square. The University of Aberdeen has issued invitations to certain academic bodies to send delegates to her celebration next September of the happy completion of her fourth century of life. The older of the colleges that now form the single uni- versity was founded in 1494; but the birth- day party was postponed till it could be held in the new academic buildings, which are now completed. The precise date has not yet been fixed, apparently in expecta- tion of adjusting it to accord with the con- venience of King Edward, whose presence at the festival is hoped for. The authorities of the Royal Library in Berlin, of which Professor Harnack is now the head, have appointed a commission, consisting of recognized experts in the de- partment of incunabula, or imprints of the fifteenth century (the total number of which is estimated to be about 30,000), In order to furnish an exhaustive historical and literary description of these precious publications, and thus eventually prepare a Gesamtkatalog. It is estimated that the work will take about ten years, and that the total cost will be nearly 100,000 marks For the first year’s work 12,000 marks has been appropriated. The town of Montmorency in France has opened an international subscription to- wards erecting therea statue to J. J. Rous- seau. A century and a half ago this ge- nius was composing on the spot his mas- terpieces, the ‘Nouvelle Héloise,’ the ‘Con- trat Social,’ and ‘Emile’; and this fact, with the ineffaceable memories of the Hermitage of Mme. d’Houdetot, Mme. d’Epinay, and the Maréchale de Luxembourg, will forever make Montmorency a literary and political Mecca. Subscriptions of any size may be addressed to M. le Receveur Municipal de Montmorency. Announcement is made of a meeting commemorative of Paul Laurence Dunbar, the well-known colored poet, lately deceas- ed, in the vestry of the Rev. Dr. Hale’s church in Boston next Sunday. Col. Hig- ginson will read some of Dunbar’s short poems; some of his best songs will be sung; and there will be addresses. Contributions will be solicited for a modest memorial to be erected at the poet’s grave in Dayton, Ohio. —The Atlantic is particularly strong this month in reform literature, taking the term in its better meaning, and not in the sense of the yellow journalist. Wil- lard G. Parsons pleads for more definite aims in education, and especially for the rescue of cultural courses of study from would-be scientific methods, which are ap- propriate only to vocational courses. Mrs. Justine Bayard Ward writes of the move-, ment back towards the Gregorian Chant as the appropriate form of church music, confining herself chiefly to the music of the Catholic Church, where the movement has the earnest support of the Pope. Her chief argument is that appropriate church music must pass the test not only of its beauty as music, but also of its capacity to weld harmoniously with the spirit of prayer. From this point of view, she holds, the modern forms, with all their beauty simply as music, are far inferior to the Gregorian. George W. Alger presents the necessity for reform in the substance and methods of the criminal law, if it is to win the respect of the masses and answer present social needs. He does not strength- en a good argument, however, by attribut- ing lynching almost wholly to disgust with the non-enforcement of the law against murderers, since lynching is and has been most prevalent in a class of cases in which the law would work with all due speed if left to itself. In fact, the enly great danger in such cases would be that the law would proceed too swiftly to ensure proper iden- tification and proof of guilt. In review- ing a group of books on the Far East, John W. Foster makes use of the occasion to plead for justice ‘n our dealings with China, while V' = ».1 8S. Rossiter of the Census Bureau asks or reform in the pub- lication and distribution of public docu- ments. Alexander D. Noyes writes of rall- way securities as an investment, and here, too, we have an incidental plea for reform, in the matter of publicity of accounts on the part of enterprises appealing to out- side investors. Four short stories, three poems, aad a few miscellaneous topics save the predominant note from danger of monotony. The Century opens with the hitherto un published narrative by Lady De Lancey of her experiences during the last days of the life of her husband, Col. Sir William Howe De Lancey, who was mortally wounded in the battle of Waterloo. In 1825 the manu- script was shown to Scott, who said that he had never read anything which affected his feelings so strongly. Dickens read it tn 1841, and referred to it as an astonishing and tremendous account, the perusal of which constituted an epoch in his life. The narrative is introduced by the comments of Scott and Dickens, contained in letters written to Capt. Basil Hall, Lady De Lan cey’s brother. The harrowing features of the account, however, are personal, and involve no general description of the hor rors of the battlefield It is hard to see that the reproduction of Romney's painting of Lady Hamilton as a Bacchante illus- trates the sad narrative in any fitting way, notwithstanding such mention of Lady Hamilton as it contains. Christian Brin ton contributes a short paper on Constantin Meunier, the sculptor of the laborer, with a half-dozen reproductions. Mr. Bryan's mani fold energy attempts,in four pages of space, to reconcile the individual and the socialist, as two workers who are both striving for the good of society and may each have something of value to contribute —Harper’s opens with another English paper by Mr. Howells, an account of a visit to Great and Little Brington, famous as the residence of the Washington family after the vicissitudes of the civil war had driven them from Sulgrave. The science article of the month, by Robert Kennedy Duncan, borders a little on the sensational in set- ting within very narrow limits, about nine- teen years hence, the date when the starva tion of the human race is to begin, provid- ed some new source of nitrogen for fertiliz- ing purposes is not discovered in the mean- while to take the place of the saltpetre beds of Chili, then to be depleted. But, of course, there is hope left, as nitrogen-fix- ing microbes innumerable are waiting for the job, and the raw material immerses the whole earth at the rate of about 33,580 tons over each acre. The Senate may as well go on with the Rate bill discussion, and there may even be time to revise the tariff before the nitrogen supply is wholly ex- hausted. Professor Lounsbury comes to the defence of usage against the pedants again, this time in behalf of the very common em ployment of the present tense with future significance, and of a direct object with ‘a passive verb. An extremely interesting bit of biography is given by two ladies who for eight years, 1889-1897, kept house for Herbert Spencer, and have felt disconcerted that all that has been said of him comes either from great men who care only for his philosophy, or little men who can see only his quaint peculiarities. A youthful disap- pointment in love, lingering still after fifty years, is one of the incidents related, and will doubtless serve as a basis for much —E

Page 16

282 - The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2127 theorizing as to the subsequent course of his life. In Scribner's, Mr. Brownell’s apprecia- tion of Cooper challenges special atten- tion. Cooper's early environment rendered his literature inevitably unliterary. It was perhaps even a piece of good fortune that he did not know the meaning and value of literary art, for he was thus left unhampered by a consciousness of his ar- tistic deficiency. No writer of one-tenth his ability would to-day commit his faults, but the vitality and Jargeness of his con- ceptions triumph over all defects. The “stock”’ Indian generally supposed to de- rive from Cooper, is not Cooper’s at all. His Red Men are at once Indian to the core, and thoroughly individualized as well 4 whole section is devoted to a spirited defence of Cooper's women against the shafts of Professor Lounsbury, “who is the wittiest of writers, and, in conse- quence, a little at the mercy of a master faculty.”” As to the phenomena of nature, “nowhere else has prose rendered the woods and the sea so vividly, so splendid- ly, so adequately—and so simply.” The assertion of critics that Balzac derives largely from Cooper is taken as striking evidence of the vivid reality of Cooper's characters, for nothing but a very ener- getic vitality could impose imitation on a romancer conspicuously noted for his orig- inality Again, Cooper was distinctively, but rationally, American. It is slander to attribute his democracy in Europe to pure idealism, and explain his disgust with demagogy on returning home, as due to an irascibility which changed his opin- ions The discriminating American must naturally be an advocate of democracy when abroad, and a critic of it at home, as shown by the example of Lowell, for instance. That some of Cooper's work is inferior is willingly admitted, but his good work is so abundant and so good as fairly to earn negligibility for such exceptions as ‘Mercedes of Castile’ and ‘The Ways of the Hour.’ Mr. Brownell’s paper, and the discussion which it has already set in motion, are likely to result in a distinct revival of interest in Cooper's works Mr. Duncan Campbell Scott, whose sto- ries and poems have given pleasure to many readers of Neribner’s Magazine, now appears in the role of a historian. Be- sides acting as editor of the “Makers of Canada” Series (Morang), he contributes to this work its latest volume, the life of John Graves Simcoe. Sometimes a_ transition from the domain of pure literature to that of biography involves but a slight wrench, since so many lives are neither more nor less than a glorified romance. In the pres- ent case, however, the hero's career offers little of the picturesque. Simcoe did, in- deed, see much active service during the Revolution, and won personal recognition from George Ill. by his activity in leading the Queen's Rangers; but there is nothing in his personal or professional experiences to make him stand out brilliantly from many soldiers and colonial administrators of his time. For example, he possesses neither the individual interest nor the his- torical importance of Lord Dorchester, with whom his views clashed on more than one occasion. Here, as Mr. Scott points out, fortune was unkind, not that Simcoe failed to reach Dorchester’s emitience (for that is a@ separate question), but that, like his fa- ther before him, circumstances prevented him from realizing public expectation. With health impaired by the hard- ships of guerrilla warfare, he came to Up- per Canada as its first governor under the Act of 1791. His chief function during the next five years was to organize according to the terms of recent legislation a region whose inhabitants were drawn largely from the stern and unbending Loyalists of New York. Simcoe, as a Tory of somewhat more pronounced views than Lord Eldon, enjoyed the opportunity thus afforded him of guiding Upper Canada into the paths of conservatism. Gifted with excellent parts, he added thoroughness and geniality to his other qualifications for a post which im- posed considerable responsibilities. Non tibi sed patria was the self-effacing motto of his family, and Mr. Scott considers that he lived up to this lofty sentiment by ac- cepting an office which made heavy de- mands upon his health while at the same time retarding his promotion in the army. Simcoe’s limitations as a colonial governor are to be found in his lack of sympathy for democratic aspirations, and in a stub- bornness which sometimes degenerated into unworthy suspicion of his opponents. The crisis of 1793 disclosed the nature of his trials more clearly than they are illus- trated by any other episode of his career in Canada. Considering that his part of the British dominions was certain to be at- tacked by his old foes, the Americans, he took the most active measures for the de- fence of the frontier, and probably would have welcomed a brush with Wayne. At the same time, his official letters show how inferior he was to Dorchester in control of temper and in power to take a broad view of the problem. This lucid and well- ordered sketch by Mr. Scott exhibits a stur- dy and active Briton whose resentments were seldom kindled save by those whom he looked upon as enemies of his king, his church and his nation. —One of the latest publications of the British Academy is Dr. F. J. Haverfield’s ‘Romanization of Roman Britain’ (Oxford: Clarendon Press; New York: H. Frowde). The author is the leading epigraphist of the United Kingdom; and it is on arche- ological data, not on considerations sug- gested by law or philology, that he bases the results of this paper. According to most English writers the Romans remained as distinct from the Britons as the mod- ern English from the Indians. They left them almost as Celtic as they had found them. Dr. Haverfield maintains, on the contrary, that, in the south and east at any rate, Britain shared the fortunes of the other western provinces. Before the age of Constantine, Romanization had ob- literated the differences between conquer- ors and conquered in material civilization, in politics, and in language. Relying on the evidence of extant remains—those at Silchester for instance—Dr. Haverfield points out that the public buildings in the civilian area, the private houses, the decor- ations and household furniture were al- most always on the Italian pattern. Art, ditions, notably in the New forest urns and the Castor ware from the banks of the Nen. But, in spite of exceptions, Dr. Hav- erfield holds that the rule stands that the it is true, shows survivals of Celtic tra- | external fabric of life was Roman. He thinks that this was true also of the legal and economic framework. The province must have been made up of Roman mun- icipalities, of imperial estates, and, most numerous of all, of tribal “‘civitates” con- stituted on Roman lines. Again, he shows reason for believing that Latin was spoken in the towns not only by the upper classes, but, judging from the Silchester graffiti, by the lower classes as well. Possibly, too, it may have been the language of the rich in the country districts. While he thus lays stress on the Romanization of Britain, Dr. Haverfield denies that there, any more than in other provinces, it uni- formly and at once destroyed all traces of national sentiments and fashions. Un- der the superimposed layer of Roman cul- ture there must have remained, at least in the remoter districts, a native element which, if not actually Celtic, was capable of atavistic reversion. The departure of the legions was followed not only by an English invasion, but, in the military areas, in Cornwall and Devon, in Wales and the North, by a Celtic revival. “SALLY.” The Dissociation of a Personality: A Bio- graphical Study in Abnormal Psychology. By Dr. Morton Prince. Longmans, Green & Co. 1906. Pp. x, 569. In the scientific study of abnormal psy- chology, in which France was the first to take the lead, she is now being outstripped ‘by America, as regards both the intrinsic interest of the cases observed and the man- ner in which their observation is recorded. A year or two ago Drs. Sidis and Goodhart described the strange case of “Mr. Hanna,” which stands alone in the completeness of the amnesia it exhibited, and in the wealth of suggestion it contained for psychologists, moralists, and philosophers in general (cf. Nation, No. 2067). And now Dr. Prince regales us with the full biography of the “Beauchamp” family, of which he hadalready published a fascinating but somewhat tan- talizing sketch five years ago, in the Pro- ceedings of the Society for Psychical Re- search (Part 40). The present work is in- tended as a preparation for a more tech- nical and theoretic study yet to come of the problems of abnormal psychology (for the purpose of furthering which we are glad to note that Dr. Prince and Dr. Sidis are also establishing a special journal); but it is complete in itself, well written, and, despite its length and some little repe- tition, of absorbing interest, even to such as usually confine their reading to lighter literature. But even those who take up Dr. Prince’s book in this spirit will find the fortunes of the “Beauchamp family” a first- rate romance of the “detective novel” or- der, whose interest clusters round the search for “the real Miss Beauchamp,” and the question, “Who was Sally?”; and we can assure them that the secret of the first is well kept to the end, while the problems presented by the latter will probably exer- cise psychologists for years to come. “The Beauchamp family,” it is now high time to explain, was a group of secondary personalities into which the original “Miss L. Beauchamp” was dissolved in consequence of a severe nervoug er eee ee eee

Page 17

Pre aired) >it April 5, 1906] The Nation. shock. As finally added up by Dr. Prince (p. 465), their total number amounted to no less than sixteen, all occupying, or in- herent in, the same body, and coming to the fore as the vicissitudes of life com- pelled, or the ingenuities of experimenta- tion evolved them. The chief actors, how- ever, in the dramatic history of this very distracted family were only three, to wit, “B I,” “the Saint,” who came under Dr. Prince’s care in 1898 as a pronounced neu- rasthenic; “B IV.,” the irascible “Idiot,” so called because she awoke in 1899 with no knowledge of the past six years; and “B III,” the irresponsible but continuously conscious and ever-entertaining “Sally.” The medical problem, of course, was to reconstitute the original “Miss Beauchamp” out of the fragments into which she had been shattered, and thereby to cure the neurasthenia of “BI.” For both purposes hypnotism was resorted to. All the person- alities could be hypnotized and given sug- gestions to remember each other's lives; and the theory was that if “B I and “B IV” could be thus amalgamated, they would have so great a working majority of the psychic processes connected with “Miss Beauchamp’s” body that “Sally” would be suppressed. That such methods are effect- ive was proved by the Hanna case; but the results here were different. When “B I” and “B IV” were made aware of each oth- er’s nature and past, they were shocked and disgusted, and so far from agreeing joyfully to recombine, like “Mr. Hanna’s” two selves, “B IV” resisted her own extinction and formed a coalition with “Sally,” who also declined to be “‘squeezed’”’ back into subconsciousness. How together they re- sisted Dr. Prince’s curative suggestions, baffled him for years, and nearly defeated him, how they fought and tormented each other, and afflicted their common body, must be read in full in the chronicles of the “Beauchamp” family. It would not be fair to Dr. Prince to betray the secret of his triumph and the dénouement of his tale. Suffice it to say that in the end “the real Miss Beauchamp” was reintegrated, and that she now seems capable of maintaining herself so long as she is not subjected to too much emotional disturbance. When this happens, “B I’ and “B IV” resume their in- terrupted lives and dissensions for a sea- son, and “Sally” her pranks. Still, with “therapeutic suggestion at regular intervals to offset the wear and tear of her life,” “the real Miss Beauchamp” can manage to exist in comfort. At the time of writing, Dr. Prince tells us, she had persisted with- out a relapse for six months. Thus the restoration to existence and health of the real Miss Beauchamp has set- tled the medical aspect of the case. For the psychologist, however, “Sally” remains over as a unique and fascinating problem. Who or what was “Sally”? She came upon the scene when the hypnotized “B I” (= “B II") was allowed to rub her closed eyes until she got them open; and ever after was able periodically to control the organism until “the real Miss Beauchamp” was restored, when not even automatic sig- nals could any longer be elicited from “Sally” to prove her continued ‘existence. But though thus born into the external world so late as 1899, she at once claimed to have existed internally long before. In- deed, she professed to go back to “Miss Beauchamp’s” earliest infancy, to have had memories and points of view distinct from those of the primary personality from the first, to have experienced and watched her whole life, though impotent to act, to be continuously and unsleepingly conscious of all that happened to the organism, to know everything that the other personalities did, and everything that all but “B IV” thought. She had, moreover, great power over them; she could “bring” either ‘““B I" or “B IV”; she could instruct them by visions or afflict them with illusions and hallucinations (positive and negative), often of the most painful and terrifying sort (as, e. g., the grisly story on p. 484), even when she was not in control of the organism. Now these are large claims to credit on the ipse dizit of so enigmatical a being, and Dr. Prince shows commendable caution in his mode of presenting them. At the same time, they were verified so far as they could be tested, and Dr. Prince not only plainly shows that he himself was convinced of their substantial truth, but also succeeds in imparting this conviction to his reader. The latter’s sympathies, indeed, will mostly be with “Sally.”” She was by far the most interesting member of the “Beauchamp” family, and her racy and unconventional letters and amusing pranks contribute vast- ly to the literary value of the book. Scien- tifically, also, “‘Sally,’’ despite her dislike of “psychological rot,””’ was a godsend; without her priceless information and co- operation, Dr. Prince would hardly have achieved success. Morally her self-sacrifice in assenting to her own extinction (p 487-9) is pathetic, and her inability to re- sist “B IV’s” bribes (pp. 499-501) most hu- man. And so Dr. Prince’s suppression of her seems a little cruel. His theory about her was that she was the subliminal or sub- conscious self, in the sense of “a co-acting mind of which the primary self is not aware,” and a phenomenon of dissociation We venture to think this far from proved. “Subconsciousness” is clearly nothing but a provisional label put upon perplexing facts. And as a subconsciousness “Sally's” case is certainly unique; it goes definitely beyond anything that has so far been in- dicated as to the existence of double con- sciousness and hypnotic selves (cf. 49). Nor can she be simply disposed of as patho- logical. It was no doubt a disturbance of the normal psychological structure that gave her an opening; but the evidence goes to show that, even when suppressed, she continues her latent existence, and mani- fests again whenever the pressure is relax- ed. She must therefore be regarded as a normal constituent also of the healthy “Miss Beauchamp.”’ And if it be true that the “abnormal” arises only out of the per- version of the ‘“‘normal,”’ does not the whole case strongly suggest that something anal- ogous to “Sally” exists normally in all of us, though we become aware of our sub- conscious double only when a disturbance of equilibrium enables it to manifest itself through the various forms of automatism? Psychologists, indeed, have yet to realize how entirely “normal” certain dissociations of personality really are. That our dream self, ¢. g., is normally dissociated more or less from our waking self, is proved by cur rapid forgetfulness of dreams. But even this is not all, for the dream-self does = —_— =———SSSEEETED not make its own dreams; it is the victim of an unknown “maker of dreams” behind the scenes. And the “Beauchamp” case seems strongly to suggest that what came to the surface as “Sally” is really this mysterious dream subconsciousness. She confesses that she is conscious of the dreams of the other personalities, and that what she thinks they sometimes dream (p 332); she has the power to produce dream like visions and hallucinations in them even in their waking life. She herself, on the other hand, neither sleeps nor dreams (pp. 340, 376). Dreams, moreover, have in general just such a character as might be given them by a childish, sportive, teasing imp like “Sally,” relieving the tedium of a pent-up existence by a fantastic play with the contents of our consciously or sub- consciously noted memories. “Sally” does not, indeed, confess to quite so much, but this can hardly be regarded as untruth- fulness, seeing that apparently she was never asked about her relation to the dreams of the other personalities. It is to be hoped, therefore, that when Dr. Prince discusses the theory of the case, he will consider the possibility that in “Sally” science has at last caught and dragged to light the dream-constructing imp that lurks in all of us. And whether or not Dr. Prince can solve the mystery of “Sally,” only an incorrigible skeptic could doubt that he has shown the “Beauchamp” case to be in truth, as he says, “a perfect gold mine of abnormal psychology’’—a mine, it may be added, likely to be fraught also with much enlightenment as to the normal functioning of the human soul. HOLMAN HUNT'S AUTOBIOGRAPHY.-~Ii Pre-Raphaelitism and the Pre-Raphaclite Brotherhood. By W. Holman Hunt, 0.M., D.C.L. With 40 Photogravure plates and other illustrations. The Macmillan Co 1905. It was while drawing in the British Mu- seum that the acquaintance with Millais began, which soon ripened into a warm friendship, and was one of the completely fortunate events of Hunt's life, for no changes of fortune or differences in aim and style of work altered the affection of those two friends. Hunt gives a most at- tractive description of the talented young fellow whose success began at the early age of eight, when he carried off the medal of the Society of Arts. Millais’s facile talent and luck were extraordinary; he had also every encouragement and ald of adoring parents to further in every way his progress. This especially struck Hunt as remarkable, his own experience of the family attitude towards art being exactly the reverse. The pages in which Hunt tells of his relations with the Millais fam- ily are perhaps the most charming In the book: the mother finding subjects for Jer son, making up costumes for his pictures, looking up questionable points for him; the father ready to sit for various figures in the same work in any disguise, the devoted and admiring elder brother and the delight- ful boy full of happy self-assurance and high spirits, never demurring at difficulties, because certain of success in the end, sure of getting his own way at home by affec- tionate flattery and bluster, however way- ward and absolute he might pe. This

Page 18

284 The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2127 friendship was of great importance and encouragement to Hunt at that juncture. The young men consulted each other about the pictures they were carrying on at home while they were still working in the Academy Illumination came from an unexpected channel. While Hunt was copying the “Blind Fiddler” of David Wilkie, a visitor, looking over his shoulder, remarked that Wilkie’s system was to thoroughly finish each bit day by day without any dead coloring The speaker, Claude Lorraine Nursey by name, had been a pupil of Wil- kie’s. He subsequently showed his own work, which he carried on in this manner. This proved to be of immense value to Hunt, for he recognized that the purity of color of the quattrocentist painters was due to the surety of touch which fresco- painting exacted. From that time he prac- tised this method, his taste for clear forms and tints developing the while. The read- ing of Lanzi further convinced him that all the great Italian artists, including the cinquecentists, had grown in a training of patient self-restraint imposed by masters who had never indulged their hands in uncertainty and dash, and that the wise and enthusiastic pupils had delighted in the de- votion of humility till far on in their ma- turity The dandelion clock in the ‘St Catherine,’ by Raphael, and the flowers— notably the purple flags—in the ‘Bacchus and Ariadne’ of Titian, were edifying ex- amples of this spirit in the great masters, wilfully overlooked by modern students.” These convictions were shared with Mil- lais, whose ambition was to seek out a truer method of interpreting nature in his pictures, putting aside received rules. The young men's discussions on these new aims and ideas, their impressions of the work of old masters, and other kindred topics, are given in conversational form. Holman Hunt conscientiously tells us in a note (what must occur to every one) that these cannot be vouched for as verbally exact, although the substance of the arguments remain vividly impressed on his mind. It was also the reading of ‘Modern Painters’ by an Oxford graduate which suggested the high mission of the artist, who, like the prophets of old, is appointed by God to carry a sacred message to the world. Keats's poems fell into Hunt's hands at this time, and filled his brain with images which inspired illustrations. From “The ive of St. Agnes” he chose the subject of the escape of Madeline and Porphyro from the castle as the subject of his next Academy picture, and communicated his enthusiasm for Keats's poems to the less- impressionable Millais, who also found con- genial themes for pictures in them In their observation of the methods of old masters, the young men used their judg- ment untrammelled by accepted authority, coming to their own conclusions. Raphael's “Tranefiguration,’’ for instance, which at the time held such a transcendent position, was condemned as a signal step in the de- cadence of Itallan art for its artificiality of arrangement and the pompous posturing of the Apoasties The fellow students at the Academy, hearing these unorthodox criticisms, called Hunt and Millais “Pre- Raphaelites” as a reductio ad absurdum— a designation which Hunt accepted as ap- propriate It was at the opening of the Academy that Rossetti, who was known to Hunt only through occasional meetings at the school, approached him with impulsive cordiality, congratulating him on his picture, which he loudly proclaimed to be the best in the collection, and asked permission to call at his studio, where a few days later Hunt showed him the beginning of “Rienzi,” and expounded his views, which in this instance he meant to carry out rigorously for the first time by direct application to nature for every part. Rossetti was much im- pressed by the soundness of this system of work, and confided his own discouragement in his art studies. Madox Brown had con- sented to direct these on terms of pure friendship, and, after setting him to paint a copy from a study of his own of cherub angels watching a crown of thorns, had recommended him to study still life from pickle jars and bottles lying about in the studio. In desperation at the dulness of the task, Rossetti had thrown it up and consulted Leigh Hunt, a complete stranger to him, as to the likelihood of his being able to earn his living by poetry, submit- ting his small collection of poems to his judgment. Leigh Hunt too well knew how unremunerative poetry was; he counselled the youth to follow painting if he had any chance of success at it, although he was very appreciative as to the poems. Rossetti asked for Holman Hunt's advice as to the necessity of exercise in still life, and was recommended to choose one of his own de- signs which had been much admired by Millais and himself in the folio of the Cyclographic Club to which many of the young artists contributed. The design once transferred to canvas, he might begin by painting the still life carefully so as to acquire proficiency before arriving at the figures. The suggestion pleased Rossetti, who immediately determined to try this plan and wished to do so under Hunt’s imme- diate direction. This was not practica- ble at the time, as Hunt had another pupil, but soon after, when he quitted his father’s house and took a studio, Rossetti shared it, paying half the rent, and it was there that he painted the “Girlhood of Mary Virgin,” his first work in oil. The idea of an association of a few ardent spir- its to reform art appealed strongly to his enthusiastic nature; he wished to be ac- cepted as a member himself, and shortly after pressed Hunt to extend the circle to certain elect spirits—Woolner, a young sculptor who wished to be enrolled; his own brother William, who joined the sub- scription life school Rossetti had instituted, and who arduously worked at night at conscientious transcripts from the nude, while by day holding an appointment in the Inland Revenue Office; James Collinson, a young painter who had achieved a certain amount of success in genre painting; and F. G. Stephens, who had done nothing, but who was Hunt’s nominal pupil, and, car- ried away by the whirl of enthusiasm, seemed likely to become an artist. Millais, on his return to town after executing some decorative work at Leeds, expressed sur- prise at Hunt's enterprise in adopting these adherents; D. G. Rossetti being the only one who by the originality of his designs seemed likely to help them in the advance- ment of their views. On entering into this question of the ori- gin of the Pre-Raphaelite Brethren and their aims, ethical and pictorial, we come to the point that chiefly preoccupied Hol- man Hunt during the writing of this book, which asserts his first claim to the ideas and leadership of the movement, and his still greater and less just pretensions to its subsequent influence on the entire art of England during the last century, ascribing to its pioneership and the battles it fought against well-worn traditions and the Acad- emy at large, the high position accorjed later to artists of views so entirely differ- ent from his own as G. F. Watts, Leighton, Burne-Jones, Walter Crane, etc., besides the reform in house decoration and stained glass effected by William Morris and the reproduction of lustre ware by W. De Mor- gan—truly exorbitant pretensions when we note the short duration of this coalition; Millais asserting his independence even be- fore joining the Academy ranks, while Ros- setti soon gave up exhibiting his pictures and never conformed to what he called “Hunt's hide-bound theories.”’ The accounts published in England and abroad Hunt considers far from exact. The idea, generally received, that Madox Brown, although never a member of the Brother- hood, had been the pioneer of the move- ment, having exhibited works in which a closer approach to nature had been ob- served, he repudiates entirely. Another point to which Hunt reverts with acrimony is that it is supposed that D. G. Rossetti was already proficient in painting in oil when he shared Hunt’s studio, having ac- quired this knowledge of Madox Brown, while, to quote our author, “had he not been very closely, thoughtfully, and affec- tionately guided by me hour by hour in my studio for seven or eight mogths, I unhesitatingly maintain that he could not have appeared as a painter in 1849, and not even in 1850, if ever.” This is too great a claim in the face of such decided gifts as those of D. G. Rossetti, for, with his unlimited enthusiasm and unwearying industry when interested in his work (according to Hunt’s own ac- count), he must surely have found for him- self a method of expression sooner or later even without guidance. Those who have known the great artists of our day must have observed with how much generosity they are always ready to impart their espe- cial methods to serious workers without at- taching much importance to these favors. The frank admiration Madox Brown felt for the pictures produced by Millais and Hunt during the early years of the Pre-Ra- phaelite Brotherhood, and his sympathy with their aims, led to his adopting many of their methods, especially after Millais, in the exuberance of his confiding nature, explained to him their newly found system of flesh painting, which ensured purity and brilliancy of tint. The elder painter’s works later on are classed by Hunt as Pre-Ra- phaelite, although he never adopted their restrictions, being averse to cliques. Hunt emphasizes the fact that he was never in- vited to join the circle, as his eccentricities in design made them fear to attract the further opprobrium of the critics on their already much derided society. That. foreign critics should have attrib- uted to Rossetti the leadership in the Pre- Raphaelite Brotherhood is another griev~- ance for Hunt, who maintains that these mistakes on the part of French art critics are due entirely to the writings of William et a a ae

Page 19

Te Nera April 5, 1906] The Nation. 285 Rossetti, F. G. Stephens, W. B. Scott, Hall Caine, etc., and he brings this accusation with scant courtesy against his old friends. With regard to Rossetti, his adherence to Pre-Raphaelitism was not of long duration, for so original a genius would not be em- barrassed by formalities and proscriptions. Hunt claims only two of his pictures as conforming to the schooi—"The Annuncia- tion,” now in the National Gallery, and “Found,” which was never finished and is now in Mr. Bancroft’s collection at Wil- mington, Delaware. On the publication of Chesneau’s book, ‘Les Nations Rivales dans l’Art,” in 1868, Rossetti at once wrote the following to the author. “En ce qui concerne la qualification de ‘Chef de I’Ecole Pré-Raphaélite’ que vous m’attribuez d’aprés vos renseignements, je dois vous assurer le plus chaudement possible qu'elle ne mest nullement due. Loin d’étre ‘Chef de I’Ecole’ par priorité ou par mérite, je puis A peine me reconnaitre comme y appartenant, si le style du peu que j'ai fait en peinture venait a étre com- paré avec les ouvrages des autres peintres nommés Pré-Raphaélites. Ainsi, quand je trouve un peintre si absolument original que l’est Holman Hunt, décrit comme étant mon ‘disciple,’ il est impossible de ne pas me sentir humilié en face de la vérité, et de ne pas vous assurer du contraire avec le plus grand empressement. Les qualités de réalisme é6motionnel mais extréme- ment minutieux, qui donnent le cachet au style nommé Pré-Raphaélite se trouvent principalement dans tous les tableaux de Holman Hunt, dans la plupart de ceux de Madox Brown, dans quelques morceaux de Hughes, et dans l’ceuvre admirable de la jeunesse de Millais. C’est la camaraderie, plut6t que la collaboration réelle du style, qui a uni mon nom aux leurs dans les jours d’enthousiasme d’il y a vingt ans.” This complete disclaimer to leadership having been published in Edouard Rod's ‘Btudes sur le Dix-neuviéme Siécle’ in 1888 and in William Rossetti’s Memoir of Dante Gabriel Rossetti in 1895, one would think this matter closed. With even greater injus- tice and bitterness Hunt attacks the char- acter of his old friend and Pre-Raphaelite brother, F. G. Stephens, who for many years was art critic of the Athenrum, and whose frequent and eulogistic reference to Hol- man Hunt’s work and the narrative of his experiences when in the East did much to establish the latter’s position and to keep him before the public during his long absences from England. Mr. Stephens, in a letter to the Times, emphatically repu- diates the passages in the book which Hunt quotes from the Athenvum as his, he not having had any connection with that paper at the time they were published fifty years ago. He shows other allegations to be ut- terly fallacious. After the lapse of a few years, Hunt's position as an artist being firmly estab- lished by his exhibited pictures and the patronage of certain lovers of art who ac- quired his works at generous prices, he was enabled to carry out the project he had for many years entertained of visiting the East, the Holy Lani especially, and painting scenes from the New Testament from their actual surroundings. This he felt to be his life’s mission, hie contribution towards making the history and teaching of Christ more tangible by the actual representation of Palestine and the knowledge of the manner of life and customs of its people It was in 1854 that he first went out—a moment when the difficulties and expenses of travelling were enormously greater than at, the present time, for the enterprise of Cook had not msJe Easterners familiar with the appearance and eccentricities of West- ern people. Obtaining models at Jerusalem was no easy tisk, since painting was re- garded as witchcraft, endangering the sit- ter’s soul. Theu, fever was inevitable and cholera often supervened in the places stayed at. Hunt's indomitable will enabled him to surmount innumerable hardships and to pass throush serious ordeals. His pic- ture of the “Finding of Christ in the Tem- ple’ was completed in London six years later, and he has no reason to feel disap- pointed in the attitude of the English public from this time forward with regard to his art. He received for that picture, painted when he was thirty-three, the high- est price whicn had hitherto been given for any modern wor, viz., £5,500 sterling. It was exhibited ip a special gallery by itself, with the pomp and circumstance of dra- peries and a darkened room, the full light being on the picture—also quite unusual then. It attracted, by its own merits and the way it was judiciously advertised by the press, a very special public, which has remained faithful to Holman Hunt's pic- tures ever since, and in which the clerical element predominates. Every new work is to his admirers the goal of a pilgrimage, even from remote parts of the country, for the artist is supposed to reveal new truths connected with the Bible, and his sym- bolism is discussed with bated breath and extreme reverence. Only two years ago his larger replica of “The Light of the World” was bought by the Right Hon. Charles Booth, who, sympathizing with the artist's desire that it should be seen in the Trans- vaal, has generously sent it to be exhibited throughout the colonies before being pre- sented to the national collection at the Tate Gallery. Few artists of our day have achieved such manifest popularity as Hol- man Hunt while asserting independent views and remaining outside the Academy. He was, according to his own showing, the first and remains the last Pre-Raphaelite painter. The illustrations in photogravure, which are extremely good, besides reproducing all Holman Hunt's pictures, give examples of the work of J. E. Millais, Madox Brown, D. G. Rossetti, R. Martineau, Sir W. Rich- mond, Henry Wallis, Spencer Stanhope, Charles Collins, and others; and in the text there are pen-and-ink sketches and stu- dies after Holman Hunt which are full of interest. SHALER’S MAN AND THE EARTH. Man and the Earth. By Nathaniel S. Shaler, Professor of Geology, Harvard University. Fox, Duffield & Co. 1905. We have known Professor Shaler as an Interpreter of Nature, but in this little volume he assumes the role of a Prophet, and foretells, from his study as a geologist of the past history of the earth and of man's interference with the processes of nature on its surface, what the probable fate will be of our globe, and of the veg- etables and animals subsisting on its rocks, soils, waters, and atmosphere. Primitive man, like other animals, de- pleted earth's resources no less rapidly than nature repleted them, but civilized man is drawing lavishly, and even reck- lessly, on nature’s stores; therefore, the questions are vital How long will these continue to supply his demands’? And if he exhausts material which now seems essential to his well-being and his pro gress, are there in nature available sub stitutes for it? To the solution of these questions much scientific research has been devoted. In his ‘Earth and Man’ Profes sor Shaler gives his answer in popular form and untechnical language Almost as essential as food to our ex istence to-day is fuel, and of it we po: sess in sight and in prospect a compara tively limited quantity. Accepting the as sumed life of the accessible coal deposits of the world as about 300 years, and al lowing but a few decades as the duration of supply of liquid and gaseous fuel, from even the most prolific petroleum fields Professor Shaler allays our fears as to the suffering of our very great-great-grand children from cold by pointing out that heat being, as Tyndall described it a mode of motion,”” the winds, the torrents and the tides, as long as the sun shines can be turned into heat with less toil than the grimy concentrated sunshine which we dig with so many labor trou bles from our coal mines. The secondary battery, when improved, or some better appliance for storing energy and accumu lating power, will remove the objection to the use of these intermittent and variable agents As to petroleum, the world pos sesses a substitute, though it will be cost ly, in bituminous shale. The term “coal oil,” which came to be subsequently ap- plied to the oil from the Pennsylvania wells, was first used for the light product of distillation of these shales from Scot land, Australasia, and from this country Professor Shaler computes that “the oil which may possibly be had from the Ohio shales alone will much excel in volume the amount of water contained in Lake Su perior.” His forecast of the world’s supply of use- ful metals is less cheerful than that of its heat and power-giving capabilities Mi Carnegie, in his St. Andrews address, al lowed sixty years as the life of our rich iron deposits. Our author reduces this es- timate to fifty years. Our copper mines, which have been so prolific for thirty years, will certainly not continue to help us to maintain our preéminence in the metal markets of the world as long as will our iron and steel. Of all the gifts of nature which we selfishly spend and sometimes waste, as though we were actual owners instead of trustees for future generations none are more transitory than the metals The miner himself watches with regret the progressive signs of exhaustion in his es- tate which he cannot repair like the farm- er. The historian of mines describes the actual disappearance of copper mining during last century from the list of Brit- ish industries, and the decline of Chili from being the world’s main source of sup- ply in 1870 to its present insignificant post- tion in the ranks of copper producers. Nev- ertheless it is difficult to conceive of the actual obliteration from commerce of an article which, when plentiful, seems essen tial to our economic system: yet this will actually take place, and many centuries may not pass before substitutes for som« if not most, of our useful metals will have to be found. In his despair, Profe Shaler, like other speculators who dip into a eee -

Page 20

286 The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2127 the future, falls back on aluminum, the base of which exists in clay. Though noth- ing is inexhaustible, this ingredient of the earth's crust exists the world over in quan- tities immensely greater than the ores of the metals, and is still being produced from decaying feldspathic rocks. Aluminum pos- sesses qualities which, when its cost per- mits, will enable it to take the place of iron and copper. However, the exhaustion of what we ac- count ore to-day, leaves intact vastly great- er quantities of the metals as constituents of the rocks of the earth, which our chil- dren will extract through the application of such improved methods as their wider knowledge and greater skill will enable them to invent and apply. There need, therefore, be no apprehension lest the world at large suffer from scarcity of iron and copper, within a measurable length of time; but the ungovernable speed with which we are drawing on our own rich re- sources of iron and copper, will within a few generations involve our loss of su- premacy in the production of these metals and possibly shift the centres of metal- lurgical activity to foreign shores, and al- moet certainly raise the price of these staple articles of the world’s industrial life. Professor Shaler sees a less gloomy pros- pect than did Crookes, in his Toronto ad- dress as president of the British Associa- tion, of remote generations of our children starving for want of corn. The lands un- der salt and fresh water which can be recovered to the use of man by efficient dykes and drains; the large area of the earth's surface, now desert, which will be rendered prolific by artificial irrigation, will provide enough new land for the in- creasing population. Meanwhile, better conservation of the land, by preventing the upper soil and its valuable soluble salts from being wastefully washed into the sea, and the extraction, if need be, from the atmosphere of its carbon and nitrogen, for the restoration to the soil of its depleted fertility, may prevent the famine from which our posterity might suffer by having grown too numerous to be supported from the present arable lands of the globe. There is a moral to all such vague spec- ulations, interesting and depressing as they may be; and the moral is, that while * there may be doubt as to the fulfilment of these prophecies, there is no doubt that the good things of this world are fleeting, and that, being limited in quantity, they should be consumed in moderation and not wasted. Petroleum as a cheap illuminant has brightened many gloomy dwellings where the tallow candle formerly made darkness visible. No one believes it to be stored in lasting quantities in the buried sandstones of the earth's crust, and yet it is tapped so recklessly that, in a new district where the first wells belch it forth faster than it can be caught, new wells are nevertheless sunk almost as close to- gether as derricks can be erected, and the oll flows so much faster than it can be caught and transported to market that the price shrinks below a figure at which it can be normally produced. For a time it is then burnt under a boiler by the tank-carful, instead of in a lamp by the gallon. Under our existing uneconomical systems, this misuse of one of the most precious resources of nature cannot, perhaps, be avoided, but we are guilty of avoidable wastes of which less reckless manufactur- ing communities are innocent. To take an example: we are converting into coke an- nually 40,000,000 tons of coal. From retort coking ovens, such as are almost exclusively used in Germany, the volatile constituents of coal are caught, and from éach ton of coal there is recovered about 7 per cent. more coke than when the same coal is coked in the more cheaply constructed but more wasteful bee-hive oven, and there are re- covered from the gases, per ton of coal, 10 gallons of tar, and ammonia enough to make 20 pounds of ammonia sulphate. And yet, of the 40,000,000 tons of coal which we coke, only about 7 per cent. is coked in by- product ovens. From the balance, coked in bee-hive ovens, whose gases escape into the air,are wasted 370,000,000 gallons of tar,and ammonia to make 370,000 tons of ammo- nia sulphate, besides heat enough to gener- ate over 6,000,000,000 horse power, or prob- ably more than werealizefromallour water powerscombined. Most of thiswasteis made in Pennsylvania and Virginia, in the very heart of our industrial system. The value of these wasted coal products should not be estimated in dollars and cents. Our forests are being cut away in a great measure to supply the railroads with ties. The best wood preservative is creosote, a distillate from tar; and if the creosote from our coke ovens were recovered, and used as a preservative, what we now waste would treat about 37,000,000 ties a year. There would then be less temptation to go to Ven- ezuela for bitumen, as the heavy residue after the extraction of the creosote from the tar would be a substitute for that po- litically troublesome material. While de- stroying our forests in building our rail- roads, our farmers are reluctant to restore the fertility of their fields, depleted by continuous cropping, by reason of the high cost of manure, and yet we are wasting monthly in the Ohio valley itself over 400,- 000 tons of the very richest ingredient of artificial fertilizers. The importance of these problems cannot be overestimated; and while state interfer- ence with our industrial activity may be repugnant to our principles and habits of business, it must sooner or later be en- forced, if not to regulate production, at least to forbid waste. Our children will be obliged by necessity to find a solution, but the difficulties imposed on them will be the greater the longer we neglect our own obligations and duties. Vikings of the Pacific. By A. C. Laut. The Macmillan Co. 1905. 8vo, pp. xviil., 349. Ill. No wilder and more romantic tales have been given to the world as fiction than may be inferred from the scanty records of the exploration of the shores of the North Pa- cifle up to the first quarter of the nine- teenth century. The innumerable reprints of Cook’s Voyages and the success of the books of travel In which the work of less distinguished explorers is recorded, testify to the popular interest they have always excited. To bring before a new generation of readers the tales of heroism and endur- ance, of savagery and greed, of the pursuit of fortune in defiance of starvation and death, which the bare records offer, is a worthy ambition, and it is this which Miss Laut has attempted. Her book is divided into three parts, the first dealing with Russian explorations, be- ginning with Bering and his two voyages eastward from Kamchatka. Then follows an account of the expeditions of the free Promishleniki consequent upon the reports brought by Bering’s crew of the sea otter and fur seal obtainable on the newly dis- covered coasts. After them are treated the companies formed to exploit the trade as capital and organization became neces- sary, and, finally, the adventures.of the escaped exile Count Benyowski afford ma- terial for a chapter. The second part takes up successively Drake’s voyage; the work of James Cook on the coast of America; Gray’s discovery of the Columbia River; John Ledyard’s adventures;- and Vancou- ver’s explorations. Vancouver, by the way, is called the “Last of Pacific Explorers,” as if the North Pacific coast terminated at Cook’s Inlet. Part third has two chap- ters. The first, entitled the “Russian Amer- ican Fur Company” (which was not the name of the organization described), ifs headed ‘‘1579-1867,"" though why the forays of Yermak in western Siberia, in no way connected with the fur trade, should be con- sidered part of the history of a nineteenth- century corporation, is not clear. The last chapter is devoted to the history of Bara- noff, resident director and virtual creator of the Russian American Company as a successful instrument of Russian commerce. The arrangement of material, it will be observed, is illogical; the natural sequence of events would have been better observed by a chronological treatment. As it. is, Drake in 1562 is made to follow the Pro- mishleniki of 1760, and so on. No account is given of the Cossack expeditions which long preceded Bering at the strait named after him, and were the probable cause of the organization of the later official explo- rations. As we have intimated, the genuine re- cords are in many cases surprisingly brief. Bering’s report of his first voyage occupies only a few pages, and to the labors of Archdeacon Coxe we owe almost all our knowledge of the voyages on the part of | the Russians immediately succeeding those of Bering, the whole of which is preserved in one smalloctavo volume. Chaplin’s jour- nal with Bergh’s commentary occupies a little duodecimo. The manuscript records relating to Bering’s voyages were reported by the Russian Government to our State Department as comprising about four thou- sand folio pages—not “thirty thousand,” as stated in Miss Laut’s preface. The orig- inal records of the minor explorations in eastern Siberia perished by fire in Yakutsk about a century ago, and we have only the extracts fortunately made by Miller and the emissaries of Coxe. To these data the literary purveyor may be justified in adding for the general read- er such a modicum of imaginary back- ground as will fill out the picture and com- plete as a consistent whole the version which in itself is an unfinished outline. But this justification is dependent upon several qualities in the added matter, such as accuracy in detail, a truthful atmos- phere, and a subordination of the added fiction to the framework. of fact it is in+ —e

Page 21

1 ee he hw a had a er eee AW arrows a Se OR eet April 5, 1906] The Nation. we. +. tended to illustrate and adorn. These qualities can hardly be attained from book lore; the writer must himself have had some personal experience of conditions, natural and social, in the region treated of, ang self-repression enough to let the facts relating to persons tell their own story and awake in the reader his appropriate judgment on the characters depicted. The writer may have, and exhibit, an opinion of his own, but too eager an insistence on it makes of the text a sermon, and not litera- ture. Miss Layt seems, from the character of her text, not to claim English as her native tongue; which, if it be the case, to some extent excuses certain blunders that mar the flow of her narrative. For example, in endeavoring to reproduce the eighteenth- century atmosphere by employing marine slang,she repeatedly uses the word “‘beach- comber” as meaning a “breaker” on a reef or shore. But “beachcomber” is a South Sea Island hobo, usually a deserter from some ship, living as a parasite on the na- tives—not a breaking wave. The word “wash” seems to have a fascination for her; terrible things happen in the ‘“‘wash’”’ or “backwash” to which she is fond of re- ferring, and which seems to mean the “‘un- dertow.”” In her endeavor to furnish a nat- ural background, the author goes too far in many instances; one might almost be- lieve she had inspected the dunnage of the sailors on Bering’s expedition. Many things are reported ‘“‘verminous,” as, for instance, hammocks, though these would be about the last articles likely to harbor vermin; nor is there any reason to suppose the Rus- sian adventurer was more uncleanly than other men of his time, especially as the weekly steam-bath was regarded by him as his chief luxury. Leaving petty incongruities of style, one may inquire into the accuracy of the facts of historic origin which the author has woven into her text. In the main her nar- rative is fairly correct, after one rejects its imaginary setting and presumptuous epithets. She has followed the chief au- thorities, though not always the latest, and in the main her stories need no serious correction in their historic matter. Yet even here a certain carelessness is obvfous even so early as the table of contents. The baptismal name of Count Benyowski was Moricz Aguston, or Maurice Augustine in English, not “Mauritius,” as Miss Laut prints it, and his shrewd and gallant fight for freedom from the barbarities of Russian exile is hardly deserving of her epithet of piracy. He doubtless fought the devil with fire, but to one who, like the present reviewer, has seen, fifty years after Ben- yowski, a Polish exile in Kamtchatka, who, for participation in some plot, had his nose cut off and was condemned to total loss of civil rights, and lived perpetually in danger of the knout—to put up a pretty good fight seems a tolerably natural thing under the circumstances. Miss Laut, tak- ing her cue from Lauridsen’s partisan Life of Bering, is profuse in her derogatory epi- thets for the scientific men who were or- dered to accompany Bering on his second voyage, and ignores the undoubted facts that to Miiller and Steller, two of these scientists, is due the preservation, as well as the collection, of nearly all that was valuable in the results of this expedition. Bering was deficient in the chief necessity | of a commander, namely, executive capac- at ‘dark Worcester and bloody Dunbar’. | they include the Cromwellian conquest of ity; he cringed before the petty nobility of his environment, and signed himself “your slave” in his report of his first expedi- tion. During his second expedition he be- came a broken man, physically as well as mentally, and at the last was dependent upon the tender and faithful service of the scientist Steller, who stands out as the one capable person in Bering’s own party, af- ter the expedition set sail. Miss Laut, in the case of Captain Cook, passes over unmentioned his chief claim to the gratitude of posterity, namely, the reorganization of the commissariat of his expedition, so that by suitable food and drink the plague of scurvy was banished from his own and subsequent expeditions Vancouver was an even more capable ex- plorer than Cook, but Cook had the first chance at the shores of the new ocean, and Vancouver was his pupil. We may summarize by saying that, in spite of imperfect accuracy and style, Miss Laut has succeeded in giving a vivid pic- ture, as she has conceived it, of a strenu- ous series of explorations which will al- ways be of interest to the adventurous reader. To some future Parkman remains the task of putting the vivid picture in a setting both accurate and harmonious; meanwhile, Miss Laut’s work is consider- ably better than nothing. John Know and the Reformation. By Andrew Lang. Longmans, Green & Co. 1905. John Know, the Hero of the Scottish Refor- mation. By Henry Cowan, D.D. (Heroes of the Reformation Series.) G. P. Put- nam’s Sons. 1905. When a man reaches the historical emi- nence of John Knox, books may, not un- fitly, be written about him at any time. That the Quater-centenary should have been celebrated in 1905 seems a little unfor- tunate, since probability fixes the date of his birth several years later. However, chronological exactness is not very impor- tant to the promoters of festivals, who as a rule feel that they have done their duty in paying some sort of homage to the deci- mal system. Last year having been marked, whether rightly or wrongly, by a commem- oration of Knox, we get the usual crop of occasional literature. To notice all the publications thus provoked would be im- possible, but we bring together two of the most notable. Any one who has kept up with Mr. Lang's writings, whether literary or historical, would hardly expect to find him writing a panegyric of John Knox, and in this case one’s natural forecast is justified by the event. As giving the point of approach, we can do nothing better than cite the opening paragraph: “ ‘November 24, 1572. John Knox, minis- ter, deceased, who had, as was alleged, the most part of the blame of all the sorrows of Scotland since the slaughter of the late Cardinal.’ It was thus that the decent bur- gess who, in 1572, kept The Diurnal of such daily events as he deemed important, cau- tiously records the death of the great Scottish Reformer. The sorrows, the ‘cum- ber’ of which Knox was ‘alleged’ to bear the blame, did not end with his death. They persisted in the conspiracies and rebellions of the earlier years of James VI; they smouldered through the later part of his time; they broke into far-spreading flame at the touch of the Covenant; they blazed Scotland, and the shame and misery of the Restoration; to trace them down to our own age would be invidious.” Prof. Hume Brown, who also stands among the biographers of Knox, has re cently given it as his opinion that, “in the struggle between the old and the new re- ligions, a national life in a real sense first began in Scotland.” When one thinks thus he can hardly avoid ascribing to Knox the honor of creating the Scottish nation. To be sure, Melville shaped the lines of Pres byterian government, but between the two men as personal forces there is no compar ison, even if we leave out of the question Knox's priority in point of time. But nel ther Mr. William Law Mathieson nor Mr Lang is willing to admit that on the cre ative side Knox was conspicuously success- ful. Mr. Mathieson is confident that na- ture intended him to be the leader of a revolution, while destiny, at cross purposes with nature, gave himformative work to do “We are accustomed to think of Knox as a lover of truth; and in the sense of fidelity to the best that was in him, or to what he believed to be such, no man ever served it more faithfully; but of that other and rarer form of truth, which consists of sobriety of judgment, clearness of vision. ‘seeing things as they really are,’ he was not so much devoid as utterly incapable.” The highly qualified enthusiasm for Knox which Mr. Mathieson displays in his ‘Pol- itics and Religion,’ appears once more in the present work by Mr. Lang Indeed, both writers have been anticipated by Lord Hailes, Hume, Robertson, and Hal- lam. Mr. Lang's special quarrel is with Knox's head. The Reformer'’s heart, he admits, was essentially sound “That Knox was a great man; a disin terested man; in his regard for the poor, a truly Christian man; as a shepherd of Calvinistic souls, a man fervent and con- siderate; of pure life; in friendship loyal; by jealousy untainted; in private charac ter genial and amiable, I am entirely con- ~ vinced. In public and political life he was much less admirable.” The work which illustrates his peculiar shortcomings most strikingly is his ‘His- tory,’ with its strong partisanship and its penchant for special pleading. One of the littlenesses in Knox as a writer is his fond- ness for petty scandal. Wherever, for ex- ample, Mary of Guise is mentioned, it is always with a slight or an innuendo; and in disparaging enemies of the faith gen- erally he accepts hearsay with the same readiness which Milton displayed when waging wordy strife against Salmasius and Morus. Among the many episodes which Mr Lang examines in detail with a view to disclosing Knox's aptitude for sailing near the wind, none is more characteristic of the Scottish Reformation than the Truce of July 24, 1569, between Mary of Guise and the Lords of the Congregation Outnumbered two to one by the Regent's forces, the Protestant leaders were forced from the field and compelled to accept an armistice of nearly six months. It was an age when public opinion supported au thority, when Calvin denounced opposition to rulers in ‘the strongest terms, and when Elizabeth of England, a prop upon whom the Scottish Protestants largely re- Hed, loathed nothing so much as a rebel According to Mr. Lang's elaborate plea, A ET SA RA ne te ——————— eee a en

Page 22

288 Knox and those of his party were anxious to mg full eredit for loyalty, while ac- ively contriving the overthrow of estab ished government Regarding the nature the terms agreed to, and the wav in vhich these terms were kept, there are ertainly many equivocal statements in the History “At this point,’ says Mr. Lang Knox narrative becomes so embroiled hat it reminds me of nothing so much | civ war, private envoys were dispatched of Claude Nau's attempts to glide past iwkward point in the history of his mployer, Mary Stuart.” How far Knox is misled, or of set purpose deceived, by roneous information, seems to be the nly question in doubt, for numerous dis itches of Sadler, the English ambassador, ike clear the duplicity of the Lords in dealings with the Regent Through he account which he gives of 1559, Knox is either shutting his eyes, or is de eived, or is deceiving himself. While Mr. Lang is not unsuccessful in isclosing the perfidies of the Protestant lords and in exhibiting the self-persuasive wer of their apostle, he has let rather 0” much cleverness and subtlety creep into his book. Whether through eagerness to prove his point, or repugnance to Cal- vinistic intolerance, he permits his volume o assume tho character of a pamphlet. \dmitting in general terms the historical greatness of Knox, he takes it for his par- icular function to disclose the Reform- er’s shortcomings. Such compliments as are paid to Knox in his private character carry little weight when balanced against the tale of his inconsistencies as a writer or leader. Those who would see why the Reformation left a crop of rancors in Scotland may well turn to these pages, but it helps one little if any to understand the fundamental strength of a nature which made itself the rallying-point of a na- onal movement Dr. Cowan's work is less a piece of de- iction or of eulogy than a plain narra- ve of events, with occasional comment up- on the main issues which claimed Knox's ef- fort. The most potable single statement which have discovered in it is suggested by he quarrel between Knox and Moray, where it is said of the reformer: ‘He pre- ferred Internal conflict with all its hazards, vhile a Protestant ascendancy was main- ned, to internal peace which would give ltomanists the opportunity of recovering heir strength, increasing their numbers, ind preparing for a future struggle.” This observation sums up, in our opinion, the whole state of the case as between Knox Having gained omething from the concessions of the Gov- erament, they were willing to temporize in 65, at the critical moment of the Scot- tish Reformation Knox, who was deter- mined not to hold parley with the ac- cursed thing, kept on his way in complete egard of the effect to be produced by on upon the peace of Scotland, then or ind his aristocratic allies ubsequent generations It is doubt- | worth Mr. Lang's while to define the nature of Knox's limitations, but modern Seotiand chiefly remembers the fact that hia illiberality brought with it emancipa- tion The Risen Sun. By Baron Suyematsu New York: EB. P. Dutton & Co. The Japanese Government has many times Nation. followed precedents furnished by the United | States and to the advantage of the nation. Furthermore, no modern people has been more eager in seeking to know, or sensi- tive in responding to, the best public opin- ion of the world than the Japanese. They have carefully studied the American way from the days of Franklin and Adams to those of Lincoln and Seward. As, in our | beyond sea to explain and defend the Union cause, so, on the eve of the outbreak with | Russia, Mutsuhito dispatched several elect, highly cultivated and amply equipped ser- vants to win and hold the world’s sym- pathy Baron Kaneko, graduate of Har- vard in America, Takahashi, pupil of American missionaries, as financial director on both continents, and Baron Suyematsu, student at Cambridge, and able to use Ger- man, French, and English in Europe, have creditably fulfilled their mission. Their pens have conquered for Japan both cre- dence and credit, sympathy and aid. No less skilfully than Oyama and Nogi and Kuroki, Togo and Uriu on field and deck have the Japanese controlled the sources of information and maripulated the levers of world-moving opinion. While we wait for Kaneko’s book and Takahashi’s report, we have Suyematsu’s London-made volume named by the British publisher. It is well edited and attractive- ly presented. The title is hardly a product of Bushido, which aims at modest self-re- pression and depreciation of one’s own. Among the most conceited of men and quite equal to the Yankee, is the Japanese gen- tleman, but he is refined even in his me- thods of egotism. This volume is made up of the papers contributed by Baron Suye- matsu during the war to various books or periodicals in three languages. The mat- ter is distributed tripartitely, the ‘“‘books” being severally entitled: Antecedent to the War; A Nation in Training; and,. External Relations. Light in hand but weighty in contents and indexed, the volume is of per- manent value. That portion, already in- cluded in Stead’s ‘Japan by the Japanese,’ treating of ethics and religion, has been already glanced at in these columns. Since these papers are all accessible in periodicals, we need not examine each in detail, but inquire as to the real riches and note the possible poverty in the col- lection now so conveniently at hand. To put these valuable products of mind, heart, and pen in a special volume is to ipeur the responsibility of scientific ap- praisal and frank criticism. It is well to know the Japanese ways in the art of writing of history. 4 While great, the sin of apologetic the virtues are omission is of equal proportions. As is now said of Motley by perhaps all the Dutch historians and critics—he grasp- ed the outside relations and set forth ad- mirably the story of the Netherlanders for foreigners, but never really entered the penetralia of Dutch politics; so, with consummate adroitness, our Japanese writ- er answers the questions and refutes the objections lying on the surface, but is apt to parry searching scrutiny that might lay open unpleasant realities. As cool, as ju- dicial, as self-restrained as Benjamin Franklin, he shows in four chapters how the Russians brought on the war. In his opening paper on “An Anglo-Japanese View [Vol. 82, No. 2127 of the Far Eastern Question,” before the | Constitutional Club in 1904, he rightly pames as the key to the situation the An- glo-Japanese Alliance, which made Japan’s path clear to smite the Muscovite. while sustaining Great Britain’s position in the Far East. When he expatiates on woman's education, ethics, freedom of conscience, ete., ete., the inquirer into reality is hard- ly satisfied. Do the Japanese really want their women to have and to enjoy the higher education? If so, why do they leave the work and cost to private initia- tive and expense? And why is the reform of licensed prostitution left almost wholly t» aliens? Why is the atrocity of parental sale of daughters still permitted? So long as the demands of filial piety override woman's strongest hope and ambition— chastity—can Japan be called civilized? As for all the intellectual and religious free- dcm boasted of, can the sun have risen when freedom of academic investigation is under ban? We can understand “the real significance” of hara-kiri, even while we see clearly its moral poltroonery. What kind of courage is that of suicide? Can self-murder be justified even though one’s face is saved? So long as the tombs of assassins are flower-covered by an admir- ing populace, and the victim of defeat or failure can shirk inquiry and deserved disgrace, so long as a villain can re- deem his reputation by the belly-cut, non- Japanese opinion will be cool in its admira- tion. Again, in writing of “The Great Change in Japan’’ consequent upon the introduction of Western civilization, our author in the first paper utterly ignores the Hollanders’ influences of a quarter of a millennium, and in the second paper unduly minimizes it, while giving no credit whatever to the American teachers who began, nine years before the Tokio Government got into pow- er, to fill the minds of native lads (now and since 1870 among the leading men of the country) with the ideas of freedom and representative government. In brief, why, in the days of “The Risen Sun,’ when con- cealment of facts is no longer possible, should so frank a scholar, refined gentle- man, true patriot, and man of the world as Baron Suyematsu is, and with so noble a recorded service, seek to imitate the un- canny fashion of his old-time literary brethren? The paper on the historical expansion of China is an admirable bit of scholarship. The naturalization of foreigners in Japan is also explained, but one contemplating the step had better read Lafcadio Hearn’s profound and penetrating work on ‘Japan: An Interpretation’—as frank as a mission- ary report, and as pitiless in its exposure as a Salvation Army tract—in which it is clearly shown that the Japanese family is still in the Homeric stage of evolution. The word “family,” an expression of a legal entity only, has not the meaning or perspective which the English word car- ries. The Story of Cambridge. By Charles W. Stubbs. Illustrated by Herbert Railton. London: J. M. Dent & Co. 1905. How curious it is that we cherish Ox- ford and ignore Cambridge, when there are so many reasons why it should be just one a a a er - le ae ena Ta? Se

Page 23

Fee: etal. bales) ANSI os I Caner ee Apt s 5, , 1906] the other way about. Is Oxford older? Both universities spring from a remote past that defies the dating power of antiquari- ans. Is Oxford more beautiful? She has | no single building that compares with King’s College chapel; she has no glimpses so lovely as may be found at every step | of that wonderful half-mile along the Cam- bridge backs from Queen’s Bridge to the Bridge of Sighs at St. John’s. Has Oxford produced greater men? Far from it; more than her share of the great names of Eng- land is associated with Cambridge. Bacon, Cromwell, Macaulay, Byron, William Pitt, Newton, Tennyson, Milton, Darwin, Wordsworth—such are a few that come haphazard to the memory. Has Ox- ford any more intimate association with America? On the contrary. Oxford has always stood for King and Church, Cam- bridge for Parliament and freedom The eastern counties, swept by the stinging winds from the North Sea, long produced the hardiest race of England; and if now the counties of Cambridge and Lincoln and Norfolk no longer show the vigor that marked them from the time of the Danes to that of the Commonwealth, the reason is largely that, in the seventeenth century, the best part of the population crossed the Atlantic and founded New Eng land. Go from Cambridge in any direction, but especially north and east, and you will pass through the towns whose names are those of Massachusetts. Ipswich and Nor- wich, Ware and Milton, Boston and Lynn, Malden and Lincoln, and many familiar villages are all within those eastern coun- ties that fed the University of Cambridge and peopled New England in the past. And although at the present day Oxford and Cambridge no longer draw their students from a local constituency, yet much of the old tradition survives; all good Oxford and Cambridge men are content that the two AMERICAN TRADE UNIONISM J. H. Hollande> and G. E. Barnett, Editors. 380 pp Svo. $2.75 net, by mail $2.98. 3 Discusses the government and working methods of representative Trade Unions “A study of trades unions in the concre te, impartial and thorough. “Expertiy written, with no waste of words.”—Nerw York Times Review. “ The facts are set forth without color or bias Dr Hollander furnishes an excellent intr: duction.”—Chicago Evening Post. s HENRY HOLT & CO Siew teat Sally Wester’s Journal This famous book, the real diary of a real girl of 1777. gives us a new view of ! the Revolutionary war. Her flirtations with Washington's officers are told to her girl friend with the most charming fre dom. Beautifully fliustrated. A capital gift book. $2 postpaid, or at bookstores. FERRIS & LEACH, Pubs. Phila. THE BURROWS BROTHERS COMPANY OF CLEVELAND, OHIO are the leading booksellers in the United States along certain lines. They issue a Catalog of Rare Volumes monthly, and this, together with their List of Publica tions deyoted to American History, will be SENT FREE to any one making the request LITERARY CRITICISM Of English and American Authors. 680 to 1905. In eight royal 8vo volumes. 6,000 ptive matter and specimen pages on request. MOULTON PUBLISHING CO., Buffalo, New York FIONA MACLEOD The Mountain Lovers: A Novel. 1I2meo, @1.50. JOUN LANE CO.,, The Bedley Head, N. Y. The Nation | universities should be equal sisters in learning and culture, and yet there persists a difference of tradition and of ideal which should, but does not, draw Americans rather to the banks of the Cam than to those of the Isis This little book is a handy guide to the university town, which it may be hoped | many will use. It will prove sufficiently ac- curate for the ordinary traveller, and even for those who stay at home it may give a pleasing impression by its exceptionally | well-executed illustrations It is a pity, ; however, that an artist of such ability and charm as Mr. Railton will not make any concessions to accurac}) BOOKS OF THE WEEK Adams, Andy. Cattle Brands. Boston: H Mifflin & Co. $1.% Amelung, Walther, cas Heinrich Holtzing rh Museums and Ruins of Rom 2 vols. Dutton $3 net. | Arbiter in Council, The Macinilla ‘ $2.50 Bankside Shakespeare. Love's Labour's Lost Ealited by Isaac H. Piatt fhe Shakesp Sock ‘ New York. Reach, Rex. E. The Spoilers. Harpers. $1.60 Bedford, Randoip The Snare of 3 ig Bb ton: Herbert B. Turner & Co $1 50 juckley, James M. The Fundamentals and their Contrasts. Eaton & Mains. $1 net Burroughs, John. Bird and Boug Boston Houghton, Mifflin & Co. $1 net Cheney, Warren. The Challeng: Indianapolis: The Bobbs-Merrill Co. Church Hymns and Tunes Edited by H B Turner and W. F. Biddle. A. 8S. Barnes & Co Conover, James P. Memories of a treat School master. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Od. $1.50 net : Crimmins, John D. Irish-American Histor'cal Mis cellany. Published by the Author. Oust, Robert H. Hobart. Giovanni Antonio Bazzi 1477-1549. Dutton. $6 net. Daun, Berthold. Veit Stoss. Lemcke & Buechner Demosthenes against Midias. Edited by W i] W. Goodwin. Macmillan Co. $2.2 DeVries, Hugo Species and Varieties: Their O gin by Mutation Chicago Open Court Pub lishing Co Diehle, Charles. Figures Byzantines Paris: Ar mand Colin. Evans, Henry Ridgley. The Old and th New Magic. Chicage: Open Court Publishing Co. Fechner, Gustav Theodor. On Life after Death 1icago: Open Court Publishing Co. swell, Laura Fain. In the Sixties and Seven ties. Boston: Herbert Turner & Cx $3.50 net Frothingham, Eugenie Brooks. The Evasion tos ton: Houghton, Mifflln & Co. $1.50. RECENTLY PUBLISHED The Subjection of Women By JOHN STUART MILL. Edited, with Introduce tory Analysis, by Stanton Coit, Ph.D. New Popular Edition. Crown 8vo. $0.40, nef LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., New York Forty Years of Critical Re- search, from an All-Inclusive Viewpoint, Summed up in CHRISTIAN ORIGINS By OTTO PFLEIDERER, D.D. Professor of Theology at the University of Berlin Translated by Danie: A. Hvensen, Ph.D. All Booksellers, $1.75 net. Circular on Request B. W. HUEBSCH, New York F. W. CHRISTERN | (DYRSEN & PFEIFFER, Successors) 16 West 334 St., opposite the “ Waldorf,” New York, Importers of Fore Books, Agents for the leading | - Beethoven—F ranklin— Rousseau: Paris Publishers. Tauchnitz’s British authors. Teub- ner’e Greek and Latin Classics. Catsiogue of stock matied on demand. New hooks recetved from Parte and Leipzig as soon as fasurd THE MUSES LIBRARY 64 cents per volume app ication, x. P. DUTTON & OU. «© - SEW YORK Haverfeld, F. J. The Romanization of Roma Britain. Henry Frowde. Haverstick, Alexander C 1s lay Sel Ki dergarten Milwaukee Y g Cl a ‘ SO cents net. History of All Nations Vol. X\ The Ag Frederick the Great By Mart! Philips Vol. XVI.: The French Rev pred the of Napoleon. By Theodor Fila i Lea Brothers & Co. Hodgkin, Thomas The History of ! I Longmans. §2 net per + Hi@ding, Harald. The Philosophy of Rellg Translated by B. E. Meyer Ma : ’ Holder, Charlies Frederick. The Loe of a Sea A gier. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Go. $1.50 ne Holland as Seen and Described by Pamous Writer Edited by Esther Singleton, Dodd, Mead & « $1.00) net Holt, Henry. Calmire.—Sturmesee. Boston: Houg ton. Mifiiln & Co Hopktns Willem John The Clammer Bost« optic. Mifflin & Co. $1.25 Hume, Fergus Lady Jim of Cure : w Dillingham Co legend of St. Juliana. Translated by Charica W Kennedy Princeton: The University Library Loeb, Jacques. The Dynamics of Living Matt Macmillan Co. $3 Markham, Sir Clements A Memoir of A st Markham, 1719-1807 Henry Frowd: Ss. net Orinda Booklets. I.: Katherine Philips il Re ert Heath lil.: Henry Re 7 I\ Thon i: Flatman Hall, England rut Pembroke Booklete 1.: Sir Philip Sidr M Sidney, Matthew Royden, U1.: Thomas Trahert Thomas Vaughan, John Norria. iil Nichol Breton, George Wither, William Krow: Iv Sir John Suckling, Sir Charles Sedley, Joho W mot Hull, England: J. R. Tuatin Pope, G. t A Handbook of the Tami! Languag Henry Frowde, Ga. net Rice, Cale Young. Plays and Lyrics. MeClur Phillips & Oo Rothschild, Alonzo. Lincoln Master of Men. Bo ton: Houghton, Mifflin & Co. 83 net Rudmose Brown Thomas RB La \ atio Francaise et la Versification Anglals ‘ Allier Fréres Smith, 1 Hopkinson, The Novels - ‘ Sketches. of Vol Xl At Clos I V as : The Wood Fire in No. 3. 8 $1 n each | smyth H. Warrington Mast and 8 ) Puro and Asia. Dutton, $6 net Spofford, Harriet Prescott OM Washing bh ton: Little, Brown & Co $'.50 Stall, Sylvanus What a ae. Ought Know r hilade Iphia: The Vir Px ch ing Co. § Stiefel, H. C. Slices from a Long Loaf J Ogilvie Publishing Co 1 Stubbs, Charles William The Christ of Engi Poetry Dutton $2 net. Stubbe, William Lectures on Early English A tory. Longmans Swift, Morrison I. Marriage and Race Death r Morrison I. Swift Press. $1.10 Thompson. Charlies Willis Party Leaders Time, G. W. Dillingham Co. $1! 75 mm Thomson, John Hither and Thi r. Vhilade phia George W. Jacobs & Co Wessex. Painted by Walter Tyndal Deserib by Clive Holland. Macmillan Co. $6 Whitcomb, Selden L. The Study of a Nov Bo ton: D. C. Heath & Co. The Novels of Henry James A STUDY By ELISABETH L. CARY, Author of ‘* The RKossettis, © et som with Photagravu Porty (mel , ** This is a Surprising ly acute and sy tematic piece of criticism. Miss Cary has studied her subject with admir able patience and insight. Readers of Henry James will recognize the truth of her analysis. On every page of this book we find criticisms that are just, appropriate and distinctive. ‘The book is one worth reading and re-reading. London Speaker Send for new Illustrated Catalogue. G.P. Putnam's Sons, 234.289" Krosi.’s Portraita, wood-engraved in the high- est manner of the art and printed on Japan paper, size 9x11 me ge! market price Twenty Dollars each, now offered at half rate to subscribers on the | books of the Nation, and sent, carriage free, ot ' receipt of Ten Dollars. — Address Preteens of THe Natiow, New Yor)

Page 24

290 The Nation. [ Vol. 82, No, 2127 ANNOUNCEMENT OF OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS, AMERICAN BRANCH The World’s Classics 18mo, cloth, 50 cents, postpaid ; Leatuer, Limr, Gitt Top, 75 Cents, Postrarp (Size 6 x 4 IncueEs) “These miracles of publishing are both the cheapest and the most charming series of classics in existence.” The best recommendation of THE WORLD'S CLASSICS is the books themselves, which have earned unstinted praise from all the leading critics and the public. Upwards of 14 million copies have been sold. Already issued—Stxty-five volumes. Forty are in a Second or Subsequent Impression FICTION (continued) 8. Dickens’ Oliver Twist. Second Impression. 10. Emily Bronte’s Wuthering Heights. Second Im- pression. 14. Charlotte Bronte’s Shirley. Second Impression. 17. Defoe’s Robinson Crusoe. Second Impression. 20. Swift’s Gulliver's Travels. Second Impression. 21. Poe’s Tales of Mystery and Imagination. Second Impression. 26. Hawthorne’s Scarlet Letter. Second Impression. 28. Thackeray’s Henry Esmond. Second Impression. 29. Scott’s Ivanhoe. Second Impression. 31. George Eliot’s Mill on the Floss. Second Im- pression. | 38. Dickens’ Tale of Two Cities. Second Impression. | 40. Sterne’s Tristram Shandy. Second Impression. BELLES LETTRES 47. Charlotte Bronte’s Villette. 50. Thackeray's Book of Snobs. 63. George Eliot’s Adam Bede. 66. Borrow’s Lavengro. POETRY | 3. Tennyson's Poems. 1830-1858. Fourth Impression. 7. Keats’ Poems. Third Impression. | 9. The Ingoldsby Legends. Third Impression. | | 13. English Songs and Ballads. Compiled by T. W. H. Crosland. Second Impression. 16. Herrick’s Poems. Second Impression. 18. Pope's Iliad of Homer. Second Impression. 27. Macaulay's Lays of Ancient Rome. 34. Burns’ Poems. Second Impression. 36. Pope's Odyssey of Homer. 37. Dryden's Virgil. 42 and 56. Chaucer's Works. Vols. land II. From the text of Prof. Skeat. Complete in 3 Vols. 58. Robert Browning's Poems. Vol. I. 2. Lamb's Essays of Elia. Fourth Impression. 5. Hazlitt’s Table Talk. ‘Third Impression. 6. Emerson's Essays. Fourth Impression. 15. Hazlitt’s Ske:chesand Essays Second Impression. 19. Carlyle’s Sartor Resartus. Second Impression. 22. White's History of Selborne. Second Impression. 23. De Quincey’s Opium Eater. Second Impression. 24. Bacon's Essays. Second Impression. 25. Hazlitt’s Winterslow. 30. Emerson's Enylish Traits. Second Impression. 32. Selected English Essays. Chosen and arranged by W. Peacock. Second Impression. 33. Hume's Essays. Second Impression. a gr pohncad 5) ig wete ie riceh ean 43. The Prince. By Niccolo Machiavelli. Trans- 46. Essays and Letters by Leo Tolstoy. Translated lated by Luigi Ricci. : by Aylmer Maude. Second Impression. 54 and 59. Adam Smith's Wealth of Nations. Vols. 57. Hazlitt’s Spirit of the Age. | [and II. Complete. 61. Holmes’ Autocrat of the Breakfast Table. 62. Carlyle’s On Heroes and Hero Worship. 65. Montaigne’s Essays. Vol.1. Complete in 3 Vols. _ 12. Bunyan’s Pilgrim’s Progress. Second Impression. 49. Of the Imitation of Christ. Thomas a Kempis. 60. The Meditations of Marcus Aurelius (shortly) 35, 44, 51, 55, and 64. Gibbon’s Roman Empire. Vols. Land Il. Second Impression. Vols. III-V. Complete in 7 Vols. | 41, 48, and 53. Buckle’s History of Civilization. Vols. land II. Second Impression. Vol. III. 11. Darwin's Origin of Species. Third Impression, IN PREPARATION | Gibbon’s Roman Empire, Vols. VI and VII. FICTION Montaigne’s Essays, Vols. II and III. 1. Charlotte Bronte’s Jane Eyre. Third Impression. | Chaucer's Works, Vol. III. 4. Goldsmith'sVicar of Wakefield. Second Impression. | &e., &c.. &e. For Sale by all Booksellers. Send for Catalogue. OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS, AMERICAN BRANCH, 91-93 Fifth Avenue, New York

Page 25