The Nation 1906-02-01: Vol 82 Iss 2118
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
aCe ae GENERAL LIBRARY; UNIV. OF MICH. FEB 2 1906 ‘The Nag —SS a 3 Peary VOL. LXXXII—NO, 21 18. THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 1, 1906. 1 1 Img TEN CENTS PUTNAM ‘SS NEW BOOKS ‘*In balance of judgment and proportion of interest there is no history so helpfui.”’ ~The Congregati onalist. A HISTORY OF ENGLAND FROM THE EARLIEST TIMES DOWN TO THE YEAR 1815 Written by various authors under the direction and editorship of C. W. C. OMAN Deputy Chichele Professor of Modern History in the University of Oxford, author of ‘‘ The Art of War in the Middle Age **A History of the Peninsular War,'* etc To be in Six Volumes, 8vo. Cloth. Each net $3.00. Three Volumes now ready ll. England Under the Normans and Angevins. 1066-1272 By H. W. C. DAVIS, Fellow and Tutor of Balliol College, author of ‘‘ Charlemagne * Will take a bigh and permanent place in the literature of its subject, Not so much a history in the ordinary sense of the word as a sustained and luminous commentary upon history; high toned and impartial." — The Athenaeun. IV. England Under the Tudors. 1485-1603 By ARTHUR D. INNES, author of ‘‘ Britain and Her Rivals,'* ‘‘ A Short History of the British in India, * et: * Mr. Innes has comb ned in a remarkable manner accuracy of research and a pre ‘historic understanding of principles and movements with a power of graphic narrative. His characters are not casual notes to the text, but real personalities, clearly realized and firmly dra wn He bas.taken a century of Eazlish history, and, without overloading his book with detail, has contrived to give us the period in a series of dramatk pictures, with the movements of spiritual and intellectual change showing clear in the background.''—Spectator “If the admirable temper, at times eloquence, and bay * fs ghout lively and connected narrative of this volume be maintained throughout the series, the success of the new history is already assured "—WN. Y. Globe. Vv. England under the Stuarts. 1603-1714 By G. M. TREVELYAN, Fellow of Trinity College, Cambridge, author of ‘‘The Age of Wycliffe “His clear and rapid writing, bis strong and imaginative grasp of personalities, his deep human sy mpomy, his sense of the greatness and dignity of life and the glory of liberty, all make him eminently the man for such a task as this, t is no mere summary of results we have here, but the salient features of a period as they present themselves to a reflecting mind.” ~ Guardian. “a tour de force for mastery of the subject and vigor of treatment."—Joseph Jacobs in N. Y. Times In Preparation: I. FROM THE BEGINNING TO 1066. By Professor OMAN. Ill, FROM 1272-1485. By OWEN EDWARDS. VI. FROM 1714-1815. By C. GRANT ROBERTSON. Send for Full Descriptive Circular The Development ofthe European Nations, 1870-1900 By J. HOLLAND ROSE Two volumes, large 8vo, with maps. Each, net, $2.50 A discussion by a scholar of authority of those events which had a distinct formative influence upon the development of European States during the latter part of the nineteenth century, a period remarkable because of the great progress made by the people of Europe in their effort to secure a larger measure of political freedom for the individual, and the legitimate development of the nation. New Edition Now Ready The Life of Charles Lamb By E. V. LUCAS, Editor of the “ Works and Letters of Charles and Mary Lamb."’ 2 volumes. 8vo. 50 iiacwations. Net $6.00 “A perfect book about Charies Lamb, his sister and hisfriends. . . biography which for its prehensiveness asa record, ite store of anecdote, its sympathetic tone, and its winning style, promises to take olathe as a classic... Y. Tribune. G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS At all Booksellers New York and London
Page 2
ii The Nation. | Vol. 82, No. 2118 a he N: ation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science and Art. FOUNDED IN 1865. [Mntered at the New York City Post Office as second-class mail matter.) CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. PRB WEBE. ..cocccccccsccccccccccsccescccescces .. 85 EprrortalL ARTICcLes ‘Society’’ Journalism ‘ : ecsccce SS ‘The Wasteful West" oeeceesese ay The Bennington Courts Martial e° . xO Joseph Wheeler ove coe Authors of Preside vatial Messages > ———— Mozart eecccecs 2 BPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE: Benjamin Franklin and Electricity 93 Winter Exhibition at the Royal Academy... % Old-Age Pensions In Australasia be 96 CORRESPONDENCE Black versus Itallan Labor........... > NorTes ‘ ‘ o -eeece eecccces 97 Boox Revigws Bayard Taylor ; .. 100 The First Earl of Dudley ‘ oo Ean Rusela nese . scoese EE George Bernard Shaw ‘and his Plays . 10 A History of Egypt.—Primitive Art in Kgypt.—-The ee | of the Ancient Egyp- tlans 104 lu Further Ardenne secesececeecooes EE A Self-Supporting UE ee ee ee BOOKS OF THE WEEE. .... 0.6 ccee cacceececccceeccwees 105 TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three dollars per year in advance, postpaid, in any part of the Untted Sta‘es or Canada; to for- eign countries comprised in the Postal Union, $i The date when the subscription expires is on the address label af ench paper, the ch unge of which to a subsequent date becomes a recet;t for a remit- tance. No other receipt ts sent unless »vequested Remittances at the risk of the aubscriber, unless made by regtatered letter, or by check, express order or Poatal Order payable to “ Publisher of The Nation.” When a change of address ia desired, both the old and new addresses should be given Address THE NATION, Box 794, New York. Publication Office, 208 Broadway. TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Fifteen centa per agate line, each insertion; 14 lines to the inch Twenty per cent, advance for choice of page or top of column, A column, $20 each insertion; with choice of page, ts A page, $60 cach insertion; front cover page, $80. Advertisementa must be aceeptabie in every reapect Copy recetved until Tuesday, 6 P. M. DISCOUNTS. Time 4 insertions.... 5 per cent. 2 a £000 0s secccegoeneoeoeooooooooes HY sd Pr) . ; oeccees ie © ne - eee ocecccecoces #0 ved 64 “ seee «+» 8S ” Anoust - 100 within a year eece -sseeeweces 10 Per cont. 450 = _yemeaneents . oo 600 e pee ceccceece 15 eS 700 * on ; ; cvveee = 1,000 e . see -- 5 bed 1,600 e © ee ; eee . 0 « 2.000 a “ say THE NATION ia sent $ free & to those who adver. tise in U as long as advertisement continues. *,* Copies of the Nation may be procured in Paris at Brentano's. 17 Avenue de l'Opéra; in London of B. F. Stevens & Brown, Trafgigar Square, Charing Cross. Atlantic Monthly FOR FEBRUARY Published February 1st. Exploration. By Professor N . S. SHALER. An informing and picturesque history of the results of exploration, and a discussion of their scientific value. The United States Senate. By Wit1iam Everett. A searching study of the present status and effectiveness of our prin- cipal legislative body. The Statesmanship of Turgot. By Anprew D. Wuire. The first of two historical papers on the great French statesman and economist. Eliana: the Latest Windfall. Recently discovered letters of Charles Lamb, now printed for the first time, and edited by William C. Hazlitt. Industrial Securities as Investments. By CuHarves A. CONANT. The first paper in the series on “Sane Finance;” by the treasurer of the Morton Trust Co. Short stories by MAARTEN MAARTENS, LATTA GRISWOLD, and Henry A. Beers, a review of the Art Books of the year by Roya. Corttssoz, and other articles of interest. SPECIAL OFFERS on receipt of fifty cents. A Trial Subscription three months sent to new subscribers Three issues, October, November, and December, 1905, will be sent free tonew subscribers for 1906 on receipt of $4.00. 35 cents a copy, $4.00 a year. 1906 sent free upon application. Lilustrated Prospectus for HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO, 4 Park St., Boston, Mass F:ducattonal. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston. OSTON UNIVERSITY Law School. New features. Address the Dean. M. M. BieELow. Bradford Academy ‘von Women One Hundred Third Year. Thirty miles from Boston. Prepares for all the leading colleges for women; also General Course and two years’ Course for High School Graduates. New gymnasium and field sports of all kinds. For catalogue and book of views, address the Principal, Miss LAURA A. KNOTT. A.M., Bradford, Mass. ROCK RIDCE SCHOOL For Beys. Location high and dry. Laboratories. , Sap for Mechante Arta. Strong teachers. Harnest bo new gymnasium with ewimming pool. Fits for C silege, Selentific School and business. [llustrated pamphlet sent free. Please address Dr. G. R. WHITE, Principal, Wellesley Hills, Mass. School Agencies. Y betes FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES ¥vererr 0. Fisk & Co.. Proprietors. 4 Ashburton P1., Boston; 1505 Pa. Ave., Washington; 156 Fifth > Ave, New York; 414 Cent Rid., *Minnea ite; 401 Cooper Bidz., Denver; 1200 Wiillama Ave.. ort'and: 208 Mich. iva. Chicago; 545 Stimson Bik., Loa Angeles; rs 8 Rookery Bik., Spokane; 717 Market &t., San Fran- claco, LBANY TEACHERS AGENCY. 81 Chapel 8t., Albany, N. Y.—Provides schools of all oe with competent teachers. Assists teach- ere fo obtaining positions. Hagiaw P. Frenou, Proprietor. S¢ HERMERHORN’'S Teachers’ Agen eachers —S8chools— Tutors —Governess— Pro * Tel. 6120 14th, Jouw C, Rooxwann, Mgr., 3 E 14th St. N. ¥. ©. FOR SALE.—Petermann’s Mitteilungen, 1905. All maps. Perfect condition. $3.00 and advertisement. H, L. D., 13 W. H., Cambridge, Mass. Just Published Brooks and Hubbard's Composition - Rhetoric $1.00 The fundamental aim of this volume is to give pupils the ability to use language for a purpose. It is essentially modern and practical in its character. In Part I. are the elements of description, narration, exposition, and argument; also special chapters on letter-writing and poetry. A more complete and comprehensive treat- ment of the four forms of discourse is furnished in Part II. In each part the effort has been made to adapt the material presented to the maturity and power of thought of the pupil. AMERICAN BOOK COMPANY few York Cincinnati Chicago Boston LIBRARY RESEARCH Topics of all kinds and » one language looked up in a ton and Harv ibraries, for echo writ- and others. ieeeste, copies, translations, and bibliographies made, Proof-reading and revision of manuscript. mighess patveretty enn iad wn references. 96 Chestnut Street, Goaon, Mass. Financtad. s We L, A-- sell a! of exc and pa eg og hy one an CREDIT ‘Travellers’ Credits available in all parte of the world. International Cheques, Certificates of Deposit. BROWN BROTHERS & CO,, NO. 6@ WALL STREET, NEW YORK, Kee mnet ln
Page 3
NEW YORK, THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 1, 1906. The Week. The real debate over the Statehood bill, in corridors and cloakrooms, hav- ing lasted ever since Congress convened, the House devoted a day to open dis- cussion, and on Thursday passed the bill. It must have been a day of un- commonly cogent argument, for the net result was that four of the Republicans who opposed the special rule on Wed- nesday voted for the bill the next day, and five others did not vote at all. This, by the way, reduces the gallant band of thick-and-thin “insurgents,” who stuck by their colors through both the tar- iff and Statehood fights, to only sixteen. The fight is now carried to the Senate, where there will be something more than a few hours of cut-and-dried speechmaking. The outcome is as un- certain as it was last year. The gen- eral opinion last autumn was that there was a drift of sentiment favorable to the amalgamation of New Mexico and Arizona, but this impression has been somewhat counteracted by the more than ever vigorous opposition developed in the lower house. There are few dis- interested advocates of immediate State- hood for Arizona and New Mexico sep- arately, but there are many who favor the postponement of a final decision un- til it can be seen how far their prom- ise for the future can be actually real- ized. Whatever the disposition of the Senate, we trust that Oklahoma and In- dian Territory may no longer be kept waiting on the determination of an ab- solutely unrelated question. Of Secretary Taft’s eleven army bills submitted to Congress,two are especially important, that providing for an army reserve of 50,000 men, and the proposal to “eliminate” officers in order to get rid of the deadwood and provide for a regu- lar flow of promotions. The army re- serve plan is a modification of one urg- ed by Secretary Root, which Congress wisely refused to consider, and which called for 100,000 men. The marked de- crease in this new measure shows that some doubts as to the practicability of the larger body had arisen. Indeed, it may well be asked whether 50,000 is not beyond the range of possibility. Several years ago Congress authorized the estab- lishment of a list of men qualified for service in the Federal Volunteers, to be made up of resigned officers, members of the militia of the several States, etc. The list is still pitifully small. The rates of pay of the enlisted men in this new reserve are to be graded in accordance with their wages while in the regular The Nation. army, and they must be ready for ten days’ drill every year during an enlist- ment of five years. Now every one knows that the men who leave the army are largely men who wander; many of them are not worth having in a reserve, and one in ten deserts. It will be no easy matter, therefore, in our judgment, to find 50,000 men under forty years of age who are worthy graduates of the regular army and are willing to join this reserve. Moreover, to keep track of men of this kind will be enormously la- borious. Inadvertence seems to be in the Cab- inet what aphasia is in insurance cir- cles. Through inadvertence, Secretary Taft candidly admits, he exceeded his power in making a monetary agreement with the Panama bankers. But he ex- plains that the damage was not great, since a contract made in disregard of law could at any time be broken in dis- regard of equity. “It may not be fair to the other parties, but it can be done,” were his words. Reviewing the transaction, the irregularity of which he freely conceded, he put the blame upon Congress for failing to leg- islate for the canal strip. The argument was, in effect, If you gentlemen turn a ticklish business over to us without in- structions, you must take the chances of our mistakes. We have no wish to judge Secretary Taft harshly, though his defence before the Senate Commit- tee on Finance comes curiously from a trained jurist and one often mentioned for the Chief Justiceship. We wish mere- ly to call attention to the happy-go-lucky fashion in which the great canal enter- prise is being conducted. It may be no great matter that a Cabinet officer should innocently overstep his powers; it is a grave matter that Congress and the Executive should be perfectly satis- fied with a régime in which this sort of straining of constitutional prerogative is regarded as natural, and even neces- sary. Another absent-minded official is Sen- ator Lodge. The other day, in sheer gayety of heart, he had spoken of the Dominican protocol as “the beginning of a great policy.” This was said “inad- visedly”; he meant the “continuance” of a policy handed down from the fathers. Having cleared away this misappre- hension, he proceeded to reveal to the Senate the limitations of its treaty- making powers. Not theirs to inter- fere in delicate negotiations; not theirs to question the terms of a treaty until it should please the Executive to lay it before them for ratification. Let them keep within their own powers, and trust Mr. Roosevelt's wisdom until the fulness of treaty-making time. So speaks Mr. Lodge, the strict construc- tionist, forgetful of a certain Lodge who, in Scribner's Magazine for January, 1902 proclaimed the “treaty-making power of the Senate,” and vindicated its right to be consulted in advance in all important preliminaries to a treaty. Possibly, this article was written “inadvisedly”; we can conceive reasons for the author's being willing to forget it when no paltry reciprocity treaty with Newfoundland is at issue, but the “continuance” of the routine policy of intervention, bequeath- ed to us by the founders of the republic. Evidently, the treaty-making power of the Senate is delightfully elastic—com- prehensive when you wish to burke a treaty unpopular with your constituents, strictly limited when you wish to sup port a President “going it alone.” Senator Spooner defends with spirit our limited representation at the Alge ciras Conference. “In the long, long reach of time,’ says the Senator in cos- mic purview, “are we to confess that we dare not send delegates to international conferences to protect American inter ests, because we fear they will not know when to withdraw?” ‘In other words, how are our diplomatists to learn how to get out of bad boxes unless first they get in? How may they practise the irodest and useful art of self-effacement unless first they have obtruded them selves? Such an argument takes us back to those early Christians who, to demonstrate their faith, voluntarily ex- posed themselves to the direst tempta- tions. These experiments as often re- vealed the frailty of the flesh as the might of the spirit. But, on the point of slipping away adroitly, Mr. Spooner emphasizes the President’s capacity for seizing psychological moments: “The President of the United States, who hit upon the psychological moment to in- tervene and bring to an end the deplor- able war between Russia and Japan, can be trusted to determine the psychologica! moment when Ambassador White and his colleague, Minister Gummere, must with- draw from the Moroccan conference in or- der to save this country from all danger of unfortunate European entanglements, should such a moment come to pass." Now the crudest intelligence of the most craven American can grasp the evident fact that there is no use in per- ceiving the psychological moment for withdrawal unless you have something to withdraw. Evidently, if you are to recall your delegates at the instant when the peace of the world wavers in the balance, you must first send them. This explains all. If Congress ever does order the Treas-
Page 4
86 ury Department to put the customs ma- chinery on a business basis and abolish at the same time ports of entry whose expenditures exceed receipts, it will also be destroying one of its annual sub- jects for discussion. Mr. Brundidge this year has performed the task of procur- ing the list of such ports for the in- formation of his colleagues. There were fifty-one of them—four more than there were two years ago. There is really a story in every one. Some are seaports of old-time renown, now forgotten and decaying. Some are custom-houses cre- ated in preposterous places as the out- come of Congressional log-rolling. Some, like Brazos de Santiago (Brownsville, ‘lex.), are really only stations for the apprehension of smugglers, and have a value out of all proportion to the reve- nues they turn in. There are ten ports which, with aggregate expenses during the last fiscal year of $5,160.33, turned in actually not a penny of revenue. While, for the reason already stated, it is not true that every port operated at a loss ought to be closed, and some offi cer is needed at most of these places, yet this feature of the system of customs collection is a crying absurdity. Charges of political heresy are said to have been brought against Representa- tive Brownlow, national committeeman from Tennessee; and before the excite- ment of the Congressional campaign be- gins, he is likely to receive a formal trial before Chairman Cortelyou. The proceeding itself is unusual, and the line of defence, according to report, is to be more novel still. Mr. Brownlow’s free- silver speech in 1896 he justifies by con- fessing that he merely used the gist of 1 former speech on the money question by his party’s Presidential candidate, McKinley If anything like a general inquisition is planned, we fear that similar defences would be pretty often heard. What proportion of the Repub- lican laity, even the Republican priest- hood, we wonder, subscribes to all the thirty-nine articles of its faith? The poor wretch suspected of Anti-Impertial- ism, as the thumb-screw is turned, will shriek out the names of the group of regular Republicans, a member of the Ways and Means Committee among them, who voted in the House the other day for a declaration favorable to Phil ippine independence. The trembling heretic dragged to the stake for his re- visionist views is no more guilty than half his brethren, if the truth were but known. And the rack would be broken down before all the dissenters on the canal policy, rate regulation, or ship subsidies were purged of their sins. Neither is it a favorable time for such reformatory action, nor is a Congress- man who has “taken more appropria- tions for his State thar any other man” a good choice for the first victim. The Nation. [ Vol. 82, No. 2118 The country’s great prosperity is eloquently indicated by all the financial weather-signs of the period. Exchanges of bank checks during December in the whole United States, lately compiled and published, afford some astonishing com- parisons. They not only run 12 per cent. beyond the previous December maximum of 1904, but are actually dou- ble the same month’s total as recently as 1898—itself a year of real financial prosperity. Iron consumption, another and even more accurate index of gen- uine trade activity, similarly surpassed all precedent. December’s output ex- ceeded that of the year before by no less than 25 per cent.; that for the whole year 1905 almost exactly doubled the figure of 1898—a rather striking parallel to the testimony of the bank exchanges. Reports of our foreign trade, lately published for December and for last year as a whole, are perhaps less impressive in comparison, but they, too, bear witness to the active industrial movement of the country. December’sex- ports reached unprecedented figures; its imports have been equalled in only five other months of the country’s history, and four of those five months fell in 1905. The year itself far surpassed the record both in exported and imported merchandise; its total outward and in- ward trade ran half a billion dollars be yond 1900, and the fact that the sur- plus of exports, under such circum- stances, was smaller than in that pe- culiar year is, we should say, a sign of greater economic health. These are the dry statistics of the industrial situation. They are abundantly corroborated by descriptions of the trade situation, com- ing from every quarter of the country. Ic is probably true that the United States has at no previous time reached such a level of uniform prosperity. Notwithstanding Gov. Vardaman’s ef- forts to put an end to mob law in Mis- sissippi, there was an increase in the number of lynchings in that State during 1905—twenty, as against eighteen in 1904. All the victims were negroes, but only two were guilty of the “usual crime.” One was murdered by a mob for writing an insulting letter, and an- other for uttering a threat, while four were murderers and four had attempted to kill. Three had attacked or fired on officers of the law. Sixteen were hanged and four were shot to death; six after being taken from official custody. In one case of rape the mob was com- posed entirely of colored men, the victim also being colored. Encouraging fea- tures of this bad year for law and order were Gov. Vardaman’s dispatch of spe- cal trains and prompt ordering out of the militia to save prisoners, with the first recorded conviction of a white man, Rob- ert Young, for killing a negro criminal. Young was given a life sentence after conviction by a white jury for having shot a manacled negro when he was on a train bound for the penitentiary. In all probability, Young will be pardoned ere long, but the conviction will none the less have a salutary effect. More- over, four “prominent citizens” of Hat- tiesburg have been indicted for partici- pating in a lynching; but the men ac- cused of killing Sheriff Poag of Tate County because he defended a white prisoner, were acquitted after a long and heated trial. The existing election law in this State does not seem to have a solitary friend willing to speak a good word for it, but its hostile critics are increas- ing in numbers. The presentment of the Special Grand Jury which has been investigating election cases, reviews the abuses which have been known to exist for many years, but which came into especial prominence at the last election. Not only were the rights of watchers disregarded, but “many disputes arose at the polls by reason of different views as to the proper method of counting disputed ballots.”” What else could any one expect from a law which provides an indefinite number of alternative methods for doing the same thing, and expresses its intent so dubiously that the Supreme Court itself does not pre- tend to understand all its provisions? There are really two separate questions involved here. The rights of watchers and the proper registering of their pro- tests can be secured only by having election officers who better understand their rights and duties. But so long as the present rules of marking and count- ing exist, it is ridiculous to talk about the elimination of wrangling and bad feeling over the polling-place returns. The Grand Jury, like the State Superin- tendent of Elections, puts in a word for the use of voting machines. These, of course, do eliminate all disputed counts and minimize the harm that a bad election board can do. Yet we are strongly of the opinion that the adoption of a new form of ballot resembling either that of Massachusetts or Montana should precede the purchase of the ma- chines. The Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals has not, under its present management, the slightest claim upon public confidence. The proceed- ings at Thursday’s annual meeting show clearly enough why President John P. Haines has so steadily refused to ren- der a detailed accounting of the moneys which he has received and expended. If there has been no actual stealing—and there are a number of suspicious items to be explained—at least the bookkeep- ing has been incredibly slack and inac- curate. What the eminently respecta- ble gentlemen of the board of managers ba teed Sat ce ic Reh Home By eat ome yh
Page 5
: 2 a ? q ‘a : ae eT aes Feb. 1, 1906] have been doing in recent years is a question which should be pressed home, not only by every subscriber to the funds, but by every taxpayer who is interested in seeing that dog-license fees are properly disbursed. The inefficiency of Mr. Haines’s administration has been notorious; and yet some of the best- known men in this community have consented to play the réle of dummy di- rectors, and by their acquiescence in abuses try to delude people into the be- lief that all is well with the Society. What is needed now is a clean sweep, both of those who have been directly guilty of maladministration and of the managers who have been recreant to their trusts and have supinely assented to wrong-doing. Now that the Funeral Drivers’ Union has been organized here, and the clos- ed shop agreed upon, deaths and burials will no doubt be put on a far more bus- inesslike basis. It has long been a cause of complaint that thoughtless people choose exceedingly inconvenient hours and places for departing this life. Here- after, persons wishing to die will be rotified to do so between 8 a. m. and 5 r M., with an hour off at noon for din- ner. Deaths occurring after hours or on Sundays or holidays will be charged for at the rate of time and half-time. No person will be accepted for burial un- less he has a union car¢ ‘| his pocket. Walking delegates wil ant clergy- men at the services. Contracts may be entered into with the New York Cen- tral and Interborough Railway Compa- nies to arrange all accidents according to a systematic plan, say, on Monday, Wednesday, and Friday afternoons, thus not interfering with the Saturday hajlf- holiday. Visitors to cemeteries in the Bronx will be required to go by the Union Railway, in which case they will probably be old enough when they get there to know better than to come back. In that way they will spare the funeral drivers needless work. Finally, the old- fashioned “At Rest’’ on tombstones will be discarded in favor of a neat union label. In offering the Curatorship of Paint- ings to Mr. Roger Fry, the Metropoli- tan Museum takes a step that promises the best things for the impending re- construction of the staff. Mr. Fry is a young English painter who has made for himself an excellent position as an historian and critic of art. He thus combines a practical knowledge of the materials of painting with a wide ex- perience of all the European schools. His personal preference is for the Ital- ian primitives, and this is fortunate, since the Museum, now lamentably de- ficient in that field, may count upon an intelligent and systematic building-up in this neglected branch. In all his Th e Nation. dence of a judgment not only keen, but also controlled by good sense. His work has been free from the aberrations so common among connoisseurs. Among our artists and amateurs he is no stran- ger, and both personally and officially he may be sure of his welcome. His appointment will mean, we are confi- dent, that the curators are to be re- sponsible for the upbuilding of their own departments and are to have the spending of their own funds. On no other principle can a museum grow sat- isfactorily. And if an officer is not com- petent to judge the needs of his own de- partment and make his requisitions on the treasury judiciously, the remedy is not to tie his hands or subject him to delays in consultation, but to replace him with one who has the obvious qual- ifications for a curatorship. Mr. Fry's coming, then, will be a welcome indica- tion that the complicated and unbusi- messlike system which has trammelled the Museum from its foundation to the present day, is about to yield to what we may call the “cabinet idea,” by which the heads of departments shall jhave ministerial independence and re- sponsibility. Another art museum is in luck; the Field Columbian Museum at Chicago will receive a bequest of $8,000,000 from the estate of the late Marshall Field. It is the largest gift ever made for such a purpose. To transpose this sum of mo- pey into terms of art is difficult, yet comparisons may aid. Even with a lib- eral deduction of income for adminis- trative purposes, the Chicago museum will have a larger purchasing fund than any European museum. With our own Metropolitan Museum and that of Wor- cester, the Columbian is in a position to compete in the art markets of the world. In this power there is some compensa- tion for being late in the field. Yet i brings some corresponding dangers. Al- ready the Metropolitan Museum is beset by the most absurd and extravagant pro- posals. Similarly, Chicago will now be- come a shining mark for the rampant enthusiast and the guileful art broker. The danger is of letting the new-gotten riches burn in the corporate pocket. The museum that marks every day with a white stone will soon accumulate a most undesirable deposit of minerals. Such cautions are not amiss when this country steps, in a year or two, from the last to the first position as public buyer in the art market. It is only fit- ting that the funds gathered through the most enlightened business methods, by such benefactors as the late Jacob 8. Rogers, Stephen Salisbury, and Marshall Field, should be expended with similar eare and judgment. The British election returns, now practically complete, only confirm the critical work Mr. Fry has given evi- S87 extent of the Unionist defeat. With nine constituencies yet to be polled, the maxi mum Ministerial majority, reckoning in Nationalists and Laborites, has reached 353, while the actual Liberal majority is 95. For the moment there has been returned only a handful of Mr. Balfour's Cabinet to constitute the Front Bench Opposition; and though this ragged fir ing line will undoubtedly be recruited by the withdrawal of Unionist mem- bers to make place for ex-ministers in safe constituencies, it is clear that Mr. Balfour’s reported plan of heckling “C B,” will be pursued under considerabie difficulty. The Independent Labor party has returned 45 members. This group, in conjunction with the 84 Irish Nation- alists and the Unionists, might make trouble in case of dissension on the Gov- ernment side, but it is hard to imagine circumstances that could lead to so un- natural an anti-Liberal alliance. The party that has converted the Conserva- tive majority of 134, in 1895, to a Liberal one of 95 to-day, need hardly fear any sudden reversal of the verdict of the country. Unionist editors will take what comfort they may from the fact that the majority of votes cast is relatively small! in favor of the Government. This is due partly to the plural vote. As mem- bers of a university convocation, as pos- sessors of offices in the City, or of resi- dences in both London and the coun- try, many Englishmen vote in two or more constituencies. And, enough, it is precisely in Street, among the aristocracy and among the intellectuels of the universi- ties, that Chamberlain has exercised the greatest glamour. curiously Lombard To have provided kings for two new thrones, those of Greece and Norway, and queens for Great Britain and Rus- sia, is something of a title to remem- brance, and the late Christian IX. of Denmark will possibly be remembered chiefly from the honors that fell ao read- ily to his children and children’s chil- dren. The eagerness with which greater monarchs sought alliances with the house of Oldenburg, and European chan- celleries welcomed its scions as candi- dates for debatable thrones, testifies not only to the strict neutrality of Denmark, but also to general confidence in the royal stock. Its daughters have been judged worthy to bear kings, and its sons to rule justly. Few monarchs have been more sorely tried than King Chris- tian. Early in his reign the Danish Duchies were torn from his kingdom by Germany, and England permitted the spoliation with a supineness that aroused Mr. Robert Cecil, later Lord Salisbury, to his highest flights of sa tire. The last years of King Christian were saddened by the growth of a rad- icalism which, while disapproving, he accepted with all loyalty and equanim ity.
Page 6
ited = —— “SOCIETY” JOURNALISM. The acquittal of Norman Hapgood on the charge of criminal libel is a great victory for decency. The editor and the proprietors of Collier's Weekly were ac- tuated by a high sense of duty when they told the unvarnished truth about Justice Joseph M. Deuel’s connection with Col. William d’Alton Mann and his nasty sheet, Town Topics. Fortunately, Collier’s is prosperous as well as cour- ageous, and, when called upon to defend itself, was able to wage the contest to the bitter end. It secured skilled coun- sel, and in the collection of evidence it spared neither energy nor expense. The result was a sickening revelation of the weakness and vanity of men prominent in the financial and the fashionable life of this community. Town Topics was exposed as a parasite upon the social body. Its editor, a bankrupt in fortune and in character, was filling his pockets by bullying the rich who might be lia- ble to attack in his columns, by selling them stock at preposterous prices, by borrowing from them on worthless se- curity, or by whining at their doors. A more repulsive picture of journalism of the gutter has never been drawn. All these facts Collier's fearlessly laid bare. The medicine, though bitter, has been wholesome. If New York society and the country in general profit by it, the credit will be due to Collier’s, which fought the good fight. And how about the complainant in this action? Collier’s declared that it was disgraceful for a judge to be con- nected with “a paper of which the occu- pation is printing scandals about people who are not cowardly enough to pay for Justice Deuel appealed to the courts for redress. It took the jury seven minutes to decide that Collier’s was right, and that, as a matter of fact, Deuel’s conduct was disgraceful. He has violated the provision of the char- ter which forbids him to accept employ- ment outside his regular duties. This silence.” employment, had it even been legal, would have been impossible for any man who was not lost to all sense of pro priety or honor. Deuel is no callow youth, upon whose ignorance or inexper- lence Mann has imposed. His hairs are white with age. He could be under no Illusion as to the nature of the enter- prise In which he embarked. When he went to the office of Town Topics, week after week, to read the proofs and ad- vise the writers how to avoid libel suits, he was aware that he was engaged in the dirtiest business in town. He waded into the slime with his eyes open. His pretences of virtuous indignation against the follies and sensualities of the “smart set” are transparent hypoc- risy. But enough of this wretch—for, as Mr. Jerome observed, he emerges from the trial shattered in reputation. Back of these two sinister figures, The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2118 Mann and Deuel, stand the people upon whom they preyed. Our polite and re- fined society must share the shame of its scavengers. Town Topics would have died of inanition long ago had it not been for the criminal rich and the silly rich. The first class, swollen with ill-gotten gains, men whose business is gambling and swindling, and whose pastime is vice, have furnished abun- dant material for salacious paragraphs; and, when attacked beyond endurance, have paid handsomely for being let alone. Their troubles, however, are pri- marily due to their own guilt. The silly rich are the ones whose plight is pitiful. They are often innocent, well-meaning folk. With a guilelessness that ap- proaches imbecility, they suppose that they gain distinction when their names are printed in the society columns of Town Topics and other newspapers, and when they are asked to subscribe to the ridiculous ‘Fads and Fancies of the Four Hundred.’ A _ three-year-old girl art- lessly displaying a new ribbon is a model of dignity and reserve compared with the grown women who give descriptions of their gowns to society reporters, and who thrill with pride when the lists of their guests are thrust before the public. It is upon the bad taste, the ignorance, and the vanity of this tribe of the wit- less that Mann and Deuel have batten- ed. By flattering, cajoling, and threaten- ing those who have everything but scund judgment, they have made Town Topics and its allied ventures a gold mine. It was like stealing candy from a baby. If our silly rich are incapable of taking to heart the lesson of these dis- closures, they would remain unmoved by the thunders of Sinai. It must be a disagreeable revelation to some of our contemporaries that maintain a “society column,” to find themselves in the Mann galley. Several of their “society editors,” it appears, have been purveyors of tattle and scan- dal to the general sewer for that sort of thing now laid open. The result ought to be, we think, to raise sharply the question how we are going to distinguish between the reputable and disreputable in that kind of journalism. “I hear,” said Matthew Arnold with one of his sweetest smiles, speaking to a youth who had got an article into an English “society journal’’—‘I hear that you have become one of ———’'s hired Stabbers.” Col. Mann's list of contributors, as dis- closed on the trial, was plainly not com- posed entirely of stabbers. Literary folk have often an innocence equalled only by their need of money, and we have no doubt that many a book-review or gen- eral article has been written for Town Topics with honest intent by honest writers—though their cheeks must now be tingling as they think with what a crew they were associating. But we fear the same cannot be said of the thorough- ly sophisticated ‘society editors’ who were in Col. Mann’s employ. {ft may be set down for certain that they were not hired for their beauz yeux. Indeed, the evidence was clear that, in one case at least, a society editor was paid to fetch and carry servants’ gossip. This certainly casts a comic, or ghast- ly, light upon the reports of doings in elegant and exclusive society printed in many reputable newspapers. How much of this class of news is handed out at the area-door like cold victuals? How tmany enterprising society editors get admission into the houses of the great, as the Newport correspondent did, dis- guised as a musician? If it is the ser- vants’ hall, and not the drawing-room, whence comes the tittle-tattle over which so many of the people whom Thackeray called the “would-be genteel, the silver-fork worshippers,” pore in the rapt conviction that they are thereby brought into touch with the richest and therefore the most enviable of mortals, the fact ought to be known. But the entire blame for these absurd- ities cannot be loaded upon the shoul- ders of silly or venal writers for the press. They could set up the defence which is offered, for what it is worth, in the case of other kinds of journal- ism. They could say that they are giv- ing “society” what “society” demands— or, at least, likes. If the coarse smutch of social notoriety were offensive to the majority of those upon whom it is laid by much of the current newspaper “Gos- sip of the Clubs” and “Notes of Society,” the thing would be stopped. We have seen how a few gentlemen drew the line at blackmail; if all the ornaments of society found the glaring publicity giv- en to their parties and their gowns equally distasteful, they would soon cease to be victims. But every news- paper knows that many not only like it, but foster it—even clamor for it. Per- sonal missives detailing the glories of the writer’s (or the writer’s wife’s) rai- ment, communications from regular ad- vertising agencies giving all the par- ticulars about a “quiet little musicale” or an account of a “very exclusive re- ception about which society is agog,” are far too frequently thrown upon an editor’s desk for him to imagine that a shrinking sensitiveness is our chief social ailment. Let us, then, not be too mirthful over the fine ladies and gentlemen who now have the mortification of seeing their laughable social plans and aspirations and their ridiculous social hangers-on exposed to the public gaze; let us, rath- er, ask if the whole thing does not be tray a false standard, for setting up which each of us is in his way partly responsible. Are we all, in practice, be- lievers in the truth that the highest so- ciety is the most intellectually and mor- ally refined society? Do we all hate and shun the little tricks of réclame? Is it — aa ee ee a
Page 7
otal Feb. 1, 1906] The Nation. S89 a real annoyance to us to be among the mentioned or the photographed on occasions which set the crowd agape? Do we think more of the conversation at a dinner than the wealth and dress of the company or the excellence of the food? Would we give more to keep out of the Court Circular than to get into it? In the lifting the roof off Town Topics we have had given us a picture of “so- ciety” as illuminating in its way as the picture of high finance which Mr. Hughes had previously drawn for our instruction and reproof. But in one case as in the other the true moral strikes far and wide, and hits spectators and censors as well as the immediate and exemplary sufferers. And as the insur- ance disclosures will fail of their due effect unless they make us all more scrupulously honest and delicately hon- orable, so the bringing of this huge basket of social scandal to the public laundry will avail us little unless out of the disgust spring a new simplicity and sincerity, with fresh resolves to make of social intercourse, not a mil- liner’s show or a crackling of thorns under a pot, but a means of furthering whatsoever things are true, lovely, and of good report. “THE WASTEFUL WEST.” The conviction on Friday of the Rev. George G. Ware, an Episcopal rector of the frontier and the manager of a Ne- braska cattle company, for conspiracy to defraud the Government by means of false homestead entries, marks a fur- ther victory in Secretary Hitchcock’s war on the land thieves and wasters. It is a significant comment apon the spirit of the heedless West, confirming what Mr. Emerson Hough, in writing of the pine-lands adventurer recently, says of the careless waste of the people. Scarce- ly more than half of the available good timber in the country has been used— mere waste has accounted for the rest. Though, as Mr. Hough says, “if we had our forests back, we could afford to wage two civil wars and not be in debt for either,” and could wage one on the value of the burned and rotted timber, forest waste is only one item in the big bill to be charged against the reck- less ‘West. Against the cattlemen, who have enclosed areas equal to principal- ities and reserved for the use of their seattered herds States capable of sup- porting New England’s population, the charge of prodigal extravagance holds equally; it holds to a less degree against the miners; and the very farmers them- selves—our models of frugality and pro- ductive economy—have tilled their fields apparently with the idea that when the land was exhausted by their unvarying crop routine, they could move across the road to fresh soil. It is only when this big “God A’mighty’s estate” has shrunk to a small fraction of its original value that any one in authority has stopped to con- sider the waste. Because the good tim- ber has absolutely passed out of the pos- session of the public, the West is begin- ning to listen to the new talk about for- est conservation and the replanting of denuded areas. But in the cattle coun- try to-day they speak of Secretary Hitchcock's honest efforts to protect the settler against the big pasture pirates as the fancies of a man suddenly gone insane. To the cattle owner it does not appear to be waste to bribe soldiers’ ‘widows and orphans to “enter” forty sections of public land to be turned over to him, and then coolly to fence forty more sections of the domain supposed to belong to the public. He says, and believes, that every head of stock he owns must have twenty-five acres of range. Millions of acres of land classed as “worthless, except for grazing,” is in the possession of the herd owners, and only a few settlers who are in search of good land know that the classification is a farce. Mr. W. R. Lighton, in the Bos- ton Transcript, cites a case in illustra- tion: “One year ago a ranchman in the neigh- borhood of Lusk, Wyoming (twenty-five miles west of the Nebraska line), bought a tract of 320 acres which had been in use at cattle range for many years. The price paid was $1,000. By way of experiment this tract was enclosed by fences to ex- clude grazing animals, and the wild bunch- grass was permitted to grow undisturbed. With absolutely no other attention, three hundred tons of hay were cut last summer, . which was sold in the stack on the ground for seven dollars a ton.” This particular tract of grass land was not exceptional; it was “high-divide” land, like millions of acres of the kind upon which the twenty-five-acres-to-a- cow rule holds. It is in the same re- zion, on the North Platte, in western Nebraska and eastern Wyoming, that ‘$3,300,000 has been allotted by the Gov- ernment to a project to reclaim 100,000 acres of “‘desert’”’ land by irrigation. No ,wonder President Roosevelt's irrigation policy has proved so popular in the West! The man who could divert the bothersome settler from the grazing lands to the absolutely arid regions by turning water into the sage brush and making the settler pay for it, deserves a monument, and the cattlemen would undoubtedly subscribe to build one. But for Secretary Hitchcock no cow-country memorial will be raised; no “timber Senator” will ever sing his praises, and only the Federal grand juries that re- turn indictments agaist the mineral land thieves, the “timber-land miners,” will breathe his name with respect. His one idea seems to be to get the man— cowman, sawmill owner, or miner—off the land he does not own and which is owned by, and held in trust for, the landless. Consider the contrast: The reclamation service has spent, or is to spend, $28,000,000 to reclaim a million acres of desert for which settlers will pay $28 an acre; the Interior Depart- ment in the past year has found more than 500 indictments in nineteen States against land thieves, and this “is but the result of preliminary skirmishing.” Under one law, the Kincaid act, some 2,000,000 acres of land in Nebraska have been fraudulently obtained by the cow men. rhis Kincaid act is an illustration of the general official laxity in. regard to the public land. It was a bit of special legislation providing for the creation of “grazing homesteads” of 640 acres in western Nebraska—the ordinary home stead, of course, being 160 acres. Now here was an inexcusable legalization of waste, tried as an “experiment” with the support of the President, who in his message to Congress referred to “the proposed extension of it to other States.” Instead of a prompt pulling up on the part of Congress, we have Mr. Lighton's assurance that “already Congressmen Martin of South Dakota and Brooks of Colorado are fashioning bills upon the Kincaid model; Mondell of Wyoming is to follow suit in the interests of his eager constituents; Montana is also in this waiting line, and there are indica- tions that a half-dozen other States are to help in the formation of a flying- wedge which will carry the deal through.” The attitude of the West toward the wasters of the public domain is like the attitude of Wall Street toward the in surance grafters. It is an “open game,” with equal chances for all. As Fred Du- mont Smith, a Kansas State Senator and a valiant fighter of the Standard Ot| monopoly, who was indicted recently in connection with land frauds in his State, says of the new activity of the Interior Department, “the United States is in mighty small business’’ when it prose cutes those sturdy pioneers who ara making Government land fertile with windmills. The only trouble with Sen ator Smith’s argument is that these “best citizens” and “sturdy settlers” of west- ern Kansas are, as a rule, wealthy resi- dents of cities far from their humble ranch firesides. The history of the pil- lagers of our forests is being repeated in the public-land States. As it waa thought impossible to exhaust our mag- nificent pine lands, so it is taken tor granted in the West that “God's out o’ doors” will last indefinitely. THE “BENNINGTON” COURTS-MAR- TIAL. The acquittal of Ensign ‘Wade, the en- gineer officer of the ill-fated Benning- ton, with the all but similar decision in the case of her commander, Lucien Young, by the court-martial which tried them, is very unfortunate. The court of inquiry was so certain that Ensign Wade was responsible for the accident that it recommended the court-martial. Secre-
Page 8
90 Bonaparte differed from it to the that Commander Now, the question tary extent of insisting Young also be tried is whether any one is to be held respon- Is this disgraceful affair to be dis- Providence? sible missed as a visitation of Commander Young was reprimanded merely for failure to attach his signa- ture to the “smooth steam log” of the Rennington during the seven months of 1904 and .1905 antedating the disaster. On every other specification of the charges against him he was acquitted. Obviously, no sane person can attri- bute to this technical carelessness of the commander the disaster to his ship. The Judge Advocate-General and the Secre- tary of the Navy alike disapproved of the court’s decision as to both Young and Wade, and returned the findings in the latter’s trial for a revision, which resulted only in the court’s adherence to its original decision. Since no officer is to be punished for what could only have been due to gross negligence or in- efficiency, the public has the right to ask several pertinent questions. For in- stance, is it not fair to conclude that this representative court-martial, in ac- quitting these officers, meant to throw the responsibility on the present naval engineering system? And what assur- ance is the Navy Department now pre- pared to give that there will not be a similar disaster any day? When the eecident occurred, Secretary Bonaparte earnestly besought press and public to thhold eriticism or condemnation un- til the facts could be ascertained. His request was granted. It is now time, in view of the failure of his judicial ma chinery to exercise a deterrent influ ence by such severe punishments as would have been inevitable in the Brit- ish navy, for the Department itself to place the blame and to let the public know whether men or system were at fault. Was the Bureau of Steam Engi- necring lax, or does the final responsi bility rest on the Bureau officer who put Wace It] that arrangement of and officers in sole charge of the engines? the system which is now on trial, which line and to serve 1899 by engineer became one, are now supposed to be ready deck or in the engine room, as on the the happen to be assigned. Under it the conditions in the from bad to Lonaparte himself has published his un- Rear Admiral Melville, has repeatedly may navy have gone teadily worse Secretary ensiness over it beat naval engineer, gainst it in-chief, Rear annual report Even the present Admiral Rae, In called for addi specialistse—82 In ‘out a er ine his last tional engineering number—and admitted the present dan- rerous conditions by saying that “such i plan, if systematically carried out, would soon furnish the service with a body of competent engineers, and would place engineering where it properly be- longs, in the line of the navy.” But just The Nation. why 82 engineering specialists, most of them doing permanent shore service and never going to sea, should be con- sidered as part of the line, except by courtesy, may well be asked. Plainly, this plan is nothing but a compromise; an endeavor to have a separate body de- voting all its time to engineering, and yet indistinguishable from line officers by rank, dress, or title. Still another defence of the amalga- mation is that by Lieut.-Commander Chandler in the current Proceedings of the Naval Institute. He is certain that the Bennington disaster and the conse- quent attacks upon present conditions should not alter the law of 1899. Like Rear-Admiral Rae, he admits that so young and inexperienced an officer as Ensign Wade should never have been given full charge of the Bennington’s engines. Such defects as have arisen in the working of the law, he attributes to the “enormous deficiency in the total number of officers, and the compara- tively little time and attention given to steam engineering in comparison with other branches of education.” Young officers, he finds, have not been encour- aged to give special attention to engi- neering, and those who have taken it up have done so without any particular as sistance from the Navy Department. The fact that a few line officers have by their own personal exertions perfected themselves in engineering is to him proof positive that amalgamation can be made all that was expected of it, pro- vided only that the law be lived up to. Yet even he admits the necessity of some change in the original plan in or- der to provide the navy with designers of engines as well as operating engi- neers. Rear-Admiral Luce has put the ques- tion now before the public in the small- est compass in the current North Amer- ican Review. It is “whether or not a man can master two professions.” Can he be at once a competent steam-engin- eer and also a naval officer, whose duties may require him to be a torpedo and gunnery expert, a navigator, an infan- try drill-master, an astronomer, and a master of international law? To Rear- Admiral Luce the task seems impossible; and so he heads his article “a piea for an engineer corps in the navy,” coming out flatfooted for a return to the old state of affairs—with the one exception, that, in order not to bring about the old-time rivalry between line and staff, he would not have the engineers educated partly for the line at Annapolis, but wholly for the engine-room at some centre,like New York or Philadelphia, where engineering work in modern machine shops could go hand in hand with theoretical studies. In other words, he would give the en- gineer officers a more thorough train- ing than that of the old days. To some such plan as this we are con vinced that the Bennington disaster [Vol. 82, No. 2118 should lead. We are of the same opin- ion as in 1899 that the amalgamation law aims at the practically impossible. In view of the reflection upon the De- partment in the outcome of the Ben- nington court-martial, some decision as to a change should be reached at the earliest possible moment. Either Rear- Admiral Rae’s plan must be attempted, or Rear-Admiral Luce’s. The former will inevitably lead to the latter, in our opinion. But what the public wants now, and has the right to demand, is the prompt assurance that no such inex- perienced officer as Ensign Wade shall ever again be put in charge of engines, no matter how short-handed the De- partment may be, and that this whole engineering question shall at once be threshed out by a joint board of naval experts and civilians, in order that prop- er legislation may be prepared without any delay. The frank admission on all sides that the engineering service is in chaos, with the failure of the Mare Is- land court to punish, should lead to im- mediate action. JOSEPH WHEELER. The death of Gen. Wheeler emphasizes afresh the end of an era. There sur- vives not a single one of the great mili- tary commanders of the Confederacy. Mosby, the scout and guerrilla, now re- siding in California, is perhaps the last of the Southern military leaders whose doings at one time were in every mouth. But of the Confederates of high soldierly renown won by the hardest kind of fight- ing in battle after battle not one still lives, unless we except Simon Bolivar Buckner or A. P. Stewart. The North- erners who commanded corps or inde- pendent forces and remain to tell of their exploits may almost be counted on a man’s fingers: Schofield, Schurz, How- ard, Dodge, Sickles, Grierson, Merritt, T. J. Wood, Wilson—the list is pitifully short, particularly when one considers that three-quarters of a million of the rank and file are still on our pension rolls. A great cavalry leader Joseph Wheel- er undoubtedly was before he was twen- ty-seven years of age. Robert E. Lee ranked him next to J. E. B. Stuart, who is admitted to have been the greatest cavalry genius produced on either side during the civil war. The Confederacy never had any prejudice against young men or West Point graduates. It did not allow them to be shoved aside by political generals as so often happened in the North. Hence, men like Wheeler, Stuart, Beauregard, the Lees, Johnston, Longstreet, and a number of former of- ficers of the “old army” came to the front early in the South and continued os the stars of the service until the end. In the North, on the other hand, Grant, Sherman, Sheridan, Meade, and Thomas were long in obtaining high commands.
Page 9
‘ Feb. 1, 1906] In the cavalry particularly, the South had the advantage, especially as there were sO many more practised horsemen to draw upon than in the North. Be sides natural-born cavalry leaders like Stuart, Wheeler, and Fitzhugh Lee, it had Forrest, Mosby, and Morgan for scouting and guerrilla work, and for a time these men had things a good deal their own way. Gradually, however, the North found men to combat them at their own game. Sheridan, Merritt, Custer, Pleasonton, Grierson, Averell, Wilson, Kilpatrick—to mention a few— appeared upon the scene, and were capa- ble not only of being the eyes of the army and protecting its flanks, but of conducting long raids into the enemy's country, destroying communications, and harassing an army by persistent sticking to its flanks. This latter was a habit of Gen. Wheel- er’s in which he excelled. When Sher- man marched to the sea, Wheeler was ever in touch with him, refusing to be driven off and clinging like a leech. Lat- er on, when Sherman marched north- ward from Savannah, Wheeler again went after him, sticking to him no mat- ter how worn his horses or tired out his men. That northward march of Sher- man’s is rightly of the extraordinary physical difficulties encountered, owing to bad roads and worse weather. But what he did, Wheel- er did too. Those same optimistic qual- ities which distinguished the little gen- eral at Santiago and made him confident that that city would soon be taken, even when he was down with fever and Gen Shafter wanted to retreat, were then manifest, together with determination and aggressiveness. He and his asso- ciates and Northern rivals practically revolutionized the handling of cavalry, and made of it an extremely mobile mounted infantry, fighting with equal ef- ficiency on horseback or on foot, as quick to throw up entrenchments as infantry, and able to endure extraordinary hard- ships and cover great stretches of ter- ritory with surprising speed. Europe was slow to learn the lesson of this, and has not yet wholly acquired it. To.the British, however, the Boers brought it home, and, as Gen. Sir Ian Hamilton has recently said, Europe must speedily digest this and other teachings of our civil war if it would make progress in a military way. celebrated because While history will thus always have a very high place for Gen. Wheeler, it will also dwell much on the sentimental aspect of his career, which arises from his resumption in 1898 of the blue uni- form which he, a rebel, had laid aside thirty-seven years before. It is not nec- essary to speak of this action of his and of Gen. Fitzhugh Lee as typifying the final reunion of the North and South to lend it its proper importance. In some aspects, the North and South are The Nation. to-day as far apart as in 1861, and must continue to be, so long as there are radical differences between them over fundamental questions like that of the suffrage. years doubted that, in the event of a for- eign war, the South would fight with all its old-time bravery and dash. Certain- ly no American citizen looked for any- thing else in 1898. Nevertheless, the return to the Unit- ed States Army of Fitzhugh Lee and Joseph Wheeler was both picturesque, Moreover, nobody had for striking, and (waiving the morality of the war itself) praiseworthy His- tory contains few parallels. That men branded in 1861 as traitors and rebels, as deserters from an army in its hour of need, from a Government which had educated and them, within theif life-time be given high rank and important commands in that same army, would have seemed impossible as late as 1880. the far-sighted wisdom of the magnani- mous policy of the victor towards the supported could It was the final proof af vanquished which must ever be one of the glorious pages in American history. Had Jefferson Davis and his Cabinet been hanged, and his generals imprison- ed, permanently disfranchised and ex- cluded from participation in the Gov- ernment, there must have remained en during sores and lasting grievances. As it was, Lee and Wheeler had no personal grudges to hold them back in 1898. It was not given to them to be of great mil- itary value to the Union in the war with Spain and the subjugation of the Fili- pinos, but their commissioning was well worth while from every point of view, and must have been for them the great- est happiness of their lives. AUTHORS OF PRESIDENTIAL MES- SAGES. Professor Dunning of Columbia has reprinted from the Proceedings of the Massachusetts Historical Society his in- teresting paper on the first annual mes- sage of Andrew Johnson. That publie document was, in fact, written by George Bancroft. This is the strange discovery which Professor Dunning when rummaging among the Johnson papers in the Congressional Li- brary. His story of the identification has almost a detective flavor. The notes and rough sketches of all of Johnson’s messages were preserved in large envel- opes, but the one covering the message of 1865 had little in it but a complete draft. This was in a handwriting not Johnson's or that of any person in his employ at the time. While Professor Dunning was mildly wondering at this manuscript, Mr. Worthington Ford came up, and, noticing the writing, said, “Why, that is George Bancroft's hand.” There- upon it flashed upon the Professor that he had seen in the files of Johnson's let- ters a note from George Bancroft, mark- nade | 91 ed “private and confidential.” It ran as follows My ask A I rie o-morrow 18 no one knows what I am about and as I am my own secretary, | must ask a day or two more for a careful revision and for making a clean copy, which must be lone with my own hand The date of that letter was Novem- ber 9, 1865. It was on December 6 that the message was sent to Congress. The interval was, therefore, just about what would have been natural for Bancroft's copying, and we have the draft of the message in the same handwriting as the note speaking of his_“task,” and refet ring to a “copy which must be done with my own hand.” Careful collation of the Bancroft draft with the message as actually sent in and published, shows that there were only a few modifica- tions of the phrasing, with here and there the insertion of a routine para- graph summarizing the work of a de partment The demonstration is com- plete. The real author of the President's annual message of 1865 was, not An drew Johnson, but George Bancroft This fact, we can now easily see, had much to do with the high favor with which the message was received by the country. Johnson was in a trying pos tion. Not only had his unequal hand to be put to the work dropped by the mighty Lincoln, but he had, if possible, to overcome the unhappy impression made by his public behavior on enter ing office. It was feared that he would prove to be a boor of low habits. Hence it was certainly a stroke of luck for him that his first important state paper should bear the hall-mark of dignified writing. It won instant and wide praise Professor Dunning quotes some of the current approval. The Evening Post, he reports, found the message “frank, dig nified, direct, and manly,” with “not a single ambiguous sentence.” He notes also: The Nation—and here was praise from the very throne itself—declared that any American might read it with pride, and found solid hope for democracy in the fact that such a document should have been pro luced by ‘this Tennesseean tailor, who was tolling for his daily bread in the humblest of employments when the chiefs of al! other countries were reaping every advan tage which school, college, or social pos! tion could furnish.’ " Probably no other message was ever “conveyed” so bodily by a wise Presl- dent, yet our Chiefs of State have usu ally been ready to exercise a sort of literary eminent domain. Whenever a friend or adviser had a happy thought or a well-written passage, apt for mes sage or speech, Presidents have made it their own by appropriating it. more of Hamilton than Washington in the Farewell Address. Many of Andrew Jackson's public utterances came hiss- ing hot from the fire of his kitchen cabinet. Mr. Cleveland was, no doubt, much beholden to the pens of others Daniel Manning and David A. Wells are There is
Page 10
YR The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2118 supposed to have been responsible for some of the phraseology of his famous tariff message; and Gresham and Olney left their sign manual on the Hawaiian and Venezuelan messages. But Presi- dents have always leaned heavily, in such matters, upon their Secretaries of State. It was noted that President Mc- Kinley’s speeches and state papers gain- ed an unwonted and welcome literary quality after Mr. Hay had entered the State Department. In a Boston speech, that least poetical of Presidential orators dropped into verse from a little-known poem of Mr. Hay’s own. As for our present voluminous producer in the White House, no one living man will have the audacity to claim personal re- sponsibility for anything but a few drops of that mighty flood; yet there are lit- erary claimants, even here, ranging all the way from Jacob Riis to President Mellen. We are dealing, of course, with no vulgar question of plagiarism. The problem of authorship, strictly speaking, seldom arises in connection with Presi- dential messages. They, as a rule, are mosaics; and only the higher critic who can confidently dissect out the docu- ments in the Pentateuch would venture to assign the various bits to the Secre- taries, or others, who contributed them. Indeed, it is hard to think of a Presi- dent as an Author. Greater things are for him. Of none of our Chief Magis- trates could it have been written what Horace Walpole said of a young sprig of nobility for whom he played the part of literary godfather: “He thinks no- thing so charming as Authors, and to be one.” The charming author, to a Presi- dent, is the one to whom he can go in the seigniorial spirit of a Moliére and take from him for his own use the noble sentiments he finds nowhere else so well expressed. This, it may be, is the rea- son why President Roosevelt quotes so often from himself. MOZART. Saturday afternoon's performance of “Don Giovanni” was the only contribu- tion of the Metropolitan Opera House to the celebration of the one hundred and fiftieth anniversary of Mozart's birth, although “The Marriage of Figaro” and “The Magic Flute” may come as post- ludes later in the season. In our concert halls the jubilee week has been celebrat- ed by putting at least one Mozart num- ber on every programme. In Germany and Austria there has been a real Mozart revival, with headquarters, naturally enough, at Vienna, where the master spent the greater part of his short life and where he died. When Director Mahler, of the Imperial Opera in that city, accepted his post, nine years ago, he made the conscientious, artistic pro- duction of Mozart's operas the main ob- ject of his managerial activity. Begin- ning with “The Magic Flute” and “Fi- garo,” he gave performances which serv- ed as models for all Europe in the same way in which Wagner intended the Bay- reuth festivals to demonstrate to the world the right method of interpreting his own music dramas. Mahler once confessed that his under- standing of Mozart had come much more slowly than his appreciation of other masters. Others have had this experi- ence. Edvard Grieg wrote a magazine article a few years ago in which he be- rated the Wagnerites for underrating Mozart, although Wagner himself had said: “I believe in God, Mozart, and Beethoven.” Grieg tells us that he him- self “loved Mozart, then for a time lost him, but found him again, nevermore to lose him.” Tchaikovsky wrote to Frau von Meck: “I not only like Mozart, I idolize him. The music of ‘Don Juan’ roused in me a divine en- thusiasm which was not without after- results. It is thanks to Mozart that I have devoted my life to music.” Gounod wrote: “The score of ‘Don Gio- vanni’ has influenced my life like a re- velation.” To him Mozart was the mas- ter of masters. The three composers just cited belong to Norway, Russia, and France; their testimony bears witness to Mozart’s remarkable influence beyond the boundaries of Greater Germany. Such internationalism seems particular- ly meet in his case, as he himself rep- resents a fusion of Italian and German elements, with a dash of French influ- ence; for Paris, during the several months he spent there as a youth of twenty-two, taught him not a little, es- pecially in the line of orchestral color- ing. On Italy, Mozart exerted a deep in- fluence through Rossini and his follow- ers; yet, oddly enough, although he wrote all but two of his operas in the mellifluous Italian style and to Italian words, none of them has ever been real- ly popular in that country, whereas the rugged, boreal music-dramas of Wagner are much in vogue there. Herein lies one of the mysteries of musical history. One of Director Mahler’s experiences in Vienna illustrates the present atti- tude of music lovers in general toward Mozart's operas. Five years ago he mounted “Cosi fan tutte” in the most sumptuous and artistic manner. No de- tail was neglected that might help to ensure success, but the deficits report- ed from the ticket office compelled him, after two months, to drop the opera. Last December, in view of the impend- ing jubilee, he tried to revive it—but in vain; only the first performance drew a satisfactory audience, although the cast was excellent and the attention to de- tails had gone so far as to give the lead- er a chance to accompany the recitatives on a genuine, specially constructed elayi- chord. It is useless to meddle with the n.usical dial. Opera-goers in Vienna, as in New York, have long since made up their mind that of Mozart’s seven chief operas (‘“Idomeneo,” “Entfiihrung,” “Cosi fan tutte,” “La Clemenza di Tito,” “Figaro,” “Don Giovanni,” and “Magic Ilute”), only the three last named suf- fice for an evening’s entertainment. The others contain some gems, but on the whole not only fail to move us, but do not even arouse our interest, except as students of musical history. In other departments the ravages of time are even more conspicuous. Of Mozart’s three dozen or more songs, only one sur- vives in concert halls; of his forty-one symphonies, only three are heard to- day, and those not often; of his still more numerous sonatas and other pieces for pianoforte, barely half-a-dozen are known to modern concert-goers. It would be incorrect to make the flight of time entirely responsible for this state of affairs. Bach was born seventy-one years before Mozart, yet his works are steadily gaining ground while Mozart’s are losing. The conditions of the latter’s unfortunate life, and his manner of composing, account for the ephemeral nature of most of his works. He wrote music as other people write letters. Grieg relates that one time, when in Vienna, he saw the MS. of the D minor concerto for piano. “In the finale Mozart was in some way or other interrupted in his writing. When he again took up his pen he did not con- tinue where he had left off. A stroke of the pen over the excellent piece, a new finale, the one which we all know! No laborious search for the lost thread.” In some cases this impromptu method worked well; in others it did not. A great proportion of his 626 works are mere pieces d’occasion. He wrote songs for his friends as they wrote their names in albums, and cared not what became of them. Many of his pjanoforte works were composed specially for his pupils. “The silkworm produces its smooth, reg- ular ball of silk without effort,” writes Professor Shedlock, “and in like man- ner Mozart could turn out allegros, rondos, sets of variations @ discrétion. The sonata in C minor is, to our think- ing, the only one in which he was en- tirely absorbed in his art.” When, however, Mozart was thus en- tirely wrapped up in his work he achiev- ed results equalled by few and surpass- ed by none. His “Don Giovanni” and “Magic Flute,” in particular, contain imperishable pages of inspiration; here are oceans of melody and marvels of dramatic characterization, which make it seem probable that had he lived more than a paltry thirty-five years he might have anticipated Weber and even Wag- ner. He knew better than any one else that he had just arrived at the threshold of his greatest possible achievements. “And now I must go,” he said on his deathbed, “just as it has become possible for me to live quietly. Now I must leave
Page 11
| ea ee ee ee a eee Feb. 1, 1906] ~ The Nation. 93 my art just as I have freed myself from the slavery of fashion, have broken the bonds of speculators, and won the privi- lege of following my own feelings, and composing freely and _ independently whatever my heart prompted.” Although Mozart's life was thus, like that of Schubert, whom he resembled in 80 many ways, an “unfinished sym- phony,” he wrote not only much immor- tal music, but music whicn it is particu- larly important that the composers of our time should study and take as a model, because it is preéminent for two important elements which they foolish- iv neglect, to wit, melody and simplicity. Richard Strauss, the leader of the con- temporary culprits, has expressed his great admiration of Mozart; but if imi- tation is the sincerest form of flattery, then his own works are a criminal libel on Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart. BENJAMIN FRANKLIN AND ELBCTRI- CITY. CAMBRIDGE, MASs., January 23, 1906. One notes a tendency among certain phy- sicists to return to Franklin’s one-fluid theory of electricity, and to identify his electric fluid with the e‘her. This tendency is seen, perhaps, more strongly in England than on the Continent, and it is accompa- nied by an idealistic trend of thought which forms one of the most remarkable reactions between physics and metaphysics. It natur- ally leads one, on this anniversary of his birth, to examine his work in electricity, and to comment upon the attitude of the philosophers who seize the present confusion of physicists in the presence of radium and the mysterious phenomena of the X-rays to proclaim the ultimate reversion of the thinking world to an idealistic conception of matter and energy. It is not often that a scientific man can appeal by his experiments to the whole ‘hu- man race so that, from the most ignorant to the most cultivated, the experiments be- come household lore. Franklin, we have believed from our infancy, drew the thun- derbokts from the sky; in our minds he is the incarnate Prometheus. His kite experi- ment was dramatic, and the setting of the siage more impressive than an Irving could accomplish. Great cumuli, formed, like the fisherman’s genie, out of thin air, darkened the heavens, and, flashing with ire, came on the rising wind to the accompaniment of thunder. The ca’m philosopher stood with bared head at the centre of the stage, and, by ‘his renowned action, stirred to jife the Promethean myth—the strange myth which seemed to foreshadow the relinquishment to man of a celestial fire. Without detracting from his philosophic insight, it can be said in passing that his safety in making the kite «xperiment is one of the most convinc- ing examples of luck on record. An im- mediate follower of his example was killed, and to-day no one, even a boy, would dare to repeat the experiment. Instead of being covered with opprobrium for what the com- mon-sense Yankee still calls “monkeying”’ with lightning, he became the greatest elec- trician of his age, thus uniting a command over one of the most subtle manifestations of nature to his influence over “that flery particle, the mind of man.” His kite ex- periment led to a renewed interest in ex- periments with Leyden jars and electrical machines—experiments which were not due to him alone, but which were brought into notice by his dramatic experiment. The fashionable world of Paris amused it- self with electrical experiments; and, in- stead of playing bridge, the court ladies 3.90d on insulated stools and gave eparks to adoring courtiers. In most colonial houses, fifty years ago, there was a popular engraving representing Franklin at the court of Louis the Sixteenth, being crown- ed by the ladies in the presence of a bril- liant assembly of courtiers. Artists paint- ed him gazing out of the canvas with that imperturbable smile ‘‘o’er al! the ills of lightning victorious,’’ while forked flashes were seen through the open window. When we examine Franklin’s work in electricity, we discover that the results of his experiments and the repetition of those of foreign investigators are embodied in his one-fluid theory—a theory which seems to have been given a new lease of life by the modern theory of the negative cor- puscle. In Franklin’s view, the negative state of a body was explained by a deficit of a fluid. The negative-corpuscle theory accounts for it by the detachment of a negative corpuscle from a positively charg- ed body. A _ positively charged pith-ball shows a negative state when the negative corpuscles are detached, in comparison with a positively charged pith-ball which re- tains its full complement. We can picture to ourselves a species of electrical vacu- um thus created between the balls. The electrical condition of the surrounding space is disturbed and the balls are forced together. This statement merely expresses what takes place, without giving any il- luminating reason for the action; and we have to confess that we are no nearer a decision between the claims of the one- fluid theory and the two-fluid theory which was in vogue before Franklin enunciated the former, than the philosophers were 200 years ago. The truth is, that Franklin got hold of the hardest end of electricity, and could not make much progress. His experiments were interesting, but did not really lead to the great development of electricity seen in the nineteenth century. The electric spark may be said to contain the whole potentiality of electricity. Dur- ing 200 years we have learned little more than Franklin knew about it; and it must be confessed that our study of lightning has not conduced to the great development of practical electricity. Indeed, lightning is still a terror and an impediment to electrical enterprise. It was reserved for that remarkable race, the Italians, through Galvani and Volta, to open a more fruit- ful method of studying the phenomena of electricity. Without the battery, Frank- lin’s results would have remained on a par with the philosophic observations of the Greeks—somewhat more extensive, but food for philosophy rather than for science, be- ing devoid of measurement. Without mea- surement, science cannot advance beyond the wild surmise of the philosopher. It must be said, however, that Franklin had the merits of an early explorer, and dowbt- less excited the imagination and increased the interest in the subject of electricity. The explorer on the Peak of Darien, gaz- ing on the mysterious ocean spread be- fore him, doubtless thought of Eldorado new peoples, and wonderful products of new climes. As long as philosophers work ed with electrical sparks without measu: ing instruments, their vision did not in clude an electrical Eldorado. Franklin had a clear sense of the un! versality of the manifestations which he studied; and when Mr. James Alexaniler of New York suggested that the velocity of electricity could be measured by allowing it to run down certain rivers and to work its way back by other water-courses Franklin showed clearly that al! parts of such a circuit would respond instantly to an electrical stimulus. He evidently t« lieved, however, with Mr. Alexander, that electricity would follow the water-courses — instead of being instantly dissipated in the earth; for he ranked water with metals in respect to electrica] conductivity When we class Franklin with the non- measuring philosophers, we shall be ask- ed, “Did Faraday ever make a quantitative measurement?’ and we can answer that Faraday had essentially a mathematical mind, which did not express itself in sym bols: he was a scientific poet without the rhyme. His mathematical conception of lines of force forms the basis of the most mathematical and the best treatise on elex tricity ever published, Maxwell's treatise on electricity and magnetism. therefore, to class Franklin among phi! osophers who have contlescended to study nature—the type which has a raison d'étre, but which is not the best working type, for they have not the essential tools His principal work in electricity resulted in the formulation of the one-fluid theory, which we may class as a philosophical pro duction, not engendering any unanimity o! belief; and in the kite experiment, with the application of the result to lightning- rods. Even to-day there is not a realizing senge of the amount of energy which is often manifested in a lightning discharge, We propose, and which no lightning-rod is competent to carry to the ground. The early experi ments with glass electrical machines and with Leyden jars, and the celebrated kite experiment, gave an erroneous impresafon of lightning. Timid people still seek safe- ty in a thunderstorm in featherbeds, ») on chairs provided with glass legs, stand on plates of glass, or feel con- fidence in rubber boots A moment's re flection will convince us that a discharge of lightning often many hundred feet in length cannot be prevented by a few inches of glass or any insulator. It would b« highly unsafe to repeat Franklin's kite ex periment if one stood on a plate of glass in proximity to the string, for light- ning exhibits a side flash. From the iact that Franklin was not killed, certain elec- tricilans believe that be did not actually draw lightning from the skies, but merely showed that there was a difference of elec- trical state between the higher regions of the sky and the ground. On many days under a clear sky one can obtain sparks from a kite string suitably conducting. Lt was reserved for Faraday to show that the only complete protection from lightning ts a metallic cage. I should soon lose the attention of the general reader if I endeavored to develop at length the theory that all matter is electrical, and that it consists of knots in the ether. This theory is based au fond
Page 12
[ Vol. 82, No. 2118 94 on what is termed electric inertla—that 1s, the disposition of an electric current to continue when the circuit, or wire carrying it, is broken, and to resist starting when the circuit is made, or the ends of the connecting wire are coupled with the dyna- mo or battery. This illustration of some- thing resembling the inertia of matter is not a very scientific one, but it perhaps enables one to grasp the idea that the re- actions between currents of electricity formed in space might cause the inertia which enables us to conceive of matter. The attitude of physicists toward this elec- trical theory of matter is simply this: Let us see how far a mathematical treatment based upon this new conception will carry us, for In this analysis we may be able to clarify our views without committing our- selves finally to a theory which seems at first be so opposed to daily ex- perience, a theory of no matter. Franklin, in his one-fluid theory, did not identify electricity with possible motions or knots in a universal ether. He held fast to the usual conception of matter, something that could hit your head against; and he conceived of a subtle fluid, the electric fluid, which was contained in different pro- portions in all bodies. The particles of the fluid are supposed to repel one another, ac- cording to the law of the inverse square of the distance, and to attract those of matter according to the same law. Those of matter are supposed to repel each other and at- sight to you tract those of electricity. We have, then, cases of surcharge and cases of deficit, which are analogous, perhaps, to concep- tions now much in yogue in England, and which arise from the theory of the nega- tive corpuscle. The power of words has never been more strongly exemplified than by the effect on mankind of the celebrated line of the Frenchman, “Eripuit ce@lo fulmen, scep- trumque tyrannis.” I have analyzed the major part of this proposition, and I leave the minor part to the historians. JOHN TROWBRIDGE. WINTER EXHIBITION AT THE ROYAL ACADEMY LONDON, January 1, 1906. For some few months past, various ru- mors have been about as to the change the Academy proposed to make in the char- acter of its Winter Exhibition. Acade- micians, it was said, had discovered that the the annual show of Old Masters their own work, and had therefore decided that, to bring back academical masterpleces into favor, there was nothing to do but to boycott the Old Masters It looks, however, as if, when the time came, the Academicilans had the courage of their weakness, To judge from the exhibition just opened, in to avold too abrupt a change, they hit upon a compromise, and resolved to boycott only the foreigner, planning a rep- English masters Dobson to the result of was the depreciation of not order resentative showing of from the days of William very last Academician who died but yes- terday. Then, at the last moment, appar- ently they hesitated again—afraid of the public, afraid of the critics, afraid of the Morellians, for whom the Winter Exhibi- tion has lately been a happy hunting- ground—and a few foreigners were allowed the utter destruction of to creep in, to The Nation. whatever unity in the series had been proposed. I do not write this to find fault. for, as it happens, the little group of foreign work contains two or three of the most im- portant pictures in the gallery. The show would be notable were it only for the ap- pearance in it of a Franz Hals, hitherto, in modern times anyway, unknown to fame. That it should have remained un- known so long is the more extraordinary because it is so large a canvas you would hardly think it could have passed unno- tieed, especially as it is years now since interest in Hals was revived and he took his rank again, as he should, among the masters. The painting belongs to Colonel Warde, who, it is said, now insures it for ten thousand pounds, though it was bought early in the last century for virtually a song, a mere trifle of eighteen pounds. Prices, it is true, have nothing whatever to do with the real value of a picture, but they make an amusing commentary on the changes of fashion among art patrons, who think themselves people of taste. It is a characteristic Hals, a large portrait group of “The Painter and his Family,” according to the Catalogue—of any other family rather than his, according to some critics. Against a landscape background husband and wife sit side by side, their hands clasped. By the father stands the son, a mere lad; the daughter, young and demure, stands near the mother; between and a little behind them, a small black boy, the one solemn person in the group. To the right of the girl, you look to a wide stretch of open country, beautifully suggested, and, in the distance, a town, a low red blur on the horizon. The picture has not the irresistible gayety, the life, the delightful abandonment of that memor- able portrait of Hals and his wife in the Rijks Museum at Amsterdam. The rich- ness and joy of youth have left her, just as the touch of rose has gone from her cap, and he—if it is Hals—no longer Swag- gers with the old light-hearted irresponsi- bility. But the picture is full of the most splendid, the most vivid, the most mas- terly passages. The painting of his own long, brown boots, turned down loosely at the top, is as amazing as anything Hals ever did, and the two children have more charm than is always found in his figures. The little girl, so tenderly, so broadly ren- dered, becomes positively beautiful in her shy, smiling homeliness, positively grace- ful in the childish awkwardness of her pose; one hand hanging stiffly at her side, the other holding a fan, And the way some of the detail is put in—her gloves, for in- stance, as well as the unclasped hand of the wife, and Hals’s boots—is like a fore- cast of the splendid breadth of execution, the overwhelming truth, of those two mar- vellous groups of old men and old women at Haarlem. This picture will probably monopolize the interest in the little series of Dutch and Flemish masters. But among the few Van Dycks of varying degrees of merit there is one of bis very finest, “The Wife of Snyders.” You have only to look to know that it was turned out by no dili- gent factory of pictures, that it is the work of the master, in which no pupils, no apprentices, no assistants, had part. It is very simple—a three-quarter length of a woman, seated, wearing a dark gown and the prim ruff and cap of the day. But it has the splendor, the unity of tone, that marks the masterpiece. The face and the hands, too, are full of character. The de- tai! of lace and embroidery is most deli- cately indicated, and there is, on a table in the background, a vase of flowers so well subordinated to the figure that you do not see it at first, but, when you do see it, it strikes you as a little master- piece in itself. One other picture in the group I must mention, because it is the finest portrait I remember by Cornelius Janssens, a painter who so very often leaves one cold and indifferent. The title in the Catalogue is “Portrait of a Lady in Black,”’ so that it does not, as in the case of the Van Dyck, borrow additional interest from the per- sonality of the sitter. It has all the Dutch austerity of arrangement. It is a half-length; the lady is standing; her pose is simple, her dress is quiet, her jewels make no lavish display. But here again the charm is in the suggestion of char- acter, the beauty of tone, the artist's fine sense of design. In so restrained a scheme he knew how to make everything tell, even to the little coat of arms placed in an up- per corner, the one touch of brilliant color in the solemn harmony. This series covers little more than the wall of one room. The English pictures fill all the other galleries. It is not easy to say upon just what system they were selected. At first, when it is found they begin with Hogarth, one thinks the idea was to make a representative and chrono- logical collection; but many gaps are soon discovered. If, in the third gallery, one goes even further back than Hogarth, to Dobson, who here seems but an English re- echo of Van Dyck, there is nothing by Walker, the contemporary of Dobson, and the painter of that fine “Cromwell” in the National Gallery. There are good Wil- sons and Turners, but Constable, Boning- ton, and Crome are poorly represented, and there is no Cotman at all. Coming down still later, it is hard to say why, if Rosset- ti and Burne-Jones are included, Ford Madox-Brown should be left out; why, if so much space is reserved for Simeon Solo- mon, whom the Academy did not care to recognize during his somewhat tempestuous and disreputable life that has only just ended, none could have been spared for an Academician like Dyce, who had much in common with the Pre-Raphaelites and was so much more scholarly than any one of them. The inclusion of Rossetti, Burne- Jones, Simeon So'omon, and others, to whom the Academy remained indifferent when generous recognition would have been of use to them, might almost suggest a be- lated act of reparation on the part of the Academy. But when their pictures are reached, after passing through three gal- leries of the work of the earlier British painters, one is inclined to believe the reparation not altogether untinged with malice. I have said who the foreign Old Masters are, and tried to give some idea of their work. If the earlier British pictures have been gathered together without any par- ticular rhyme or reason, a number of them show what great things had been accom- pilshed by the British school before the protest of the Pre-Raphaelites made itself seen—and heard, teo—in the Victorian wil-
Page 13
i lil la Settee. whe ith EME NE ERA i
Feb. 1, 1906] The Nation.
95
derness. There is nothing of Hogarth’'s to equal “The Shrimp Girl” in the National Gallery, but the portraits are fairly good examples of his power of observation and his tremendous command of technique, and there is a group at Wanstead House that, if somewhat naive.y stiff in the arrangement and pose of the little figures, has, in the room where they are gathered, the beauty of tone and the stateliness he knew how to get out of the domestic architecture and decoration of his time. I have seen more distinguished Reynoldses before this at Bur- lington House, but it is interesting to come upon the originais of mezzotints and color- prints so popular just now. And then his “Miss McGill, afterwards Countess of Clan- william,” from Cobham House, I do not think has been publicly exhibited before for many years,and his huge portraits of George Ill. and Queen Char.otte, if conventional and perfunctory presentments of royalty, are treated with a dignity and an impres- sive and appropriate sumptuousness of col- or rarely, if ever, found in the royal por- traits of to-day, the royalty of our genera- tion seeming instinctively to want the wrong thing in art, and the painters, on the other hand, becoming paralyzed in the royal presence. Gainsborough, too, I have seen to greater advantage in previous ex- hibitions. But there is a “Miss Adney,” a half-length in an ova! frame, all delicate rose and white, that is lovely as decora- tion if the face is unusually flat and pret- ty, even for Gainsborough, whose talent was not for vigorous and solid modelling. His “Giardini,” the violinist, also tells— the portrait of a man in red coat, that has real beauty of color and much more vigor and life than many of his more celebrated “canvases. And the not very well-known portrait of his two daughters has a per- sonal interest, though it fades and the figures seem vague and impersonal when they are compared to the wonderful chil- dren in the Hals group. On the whole, the most striking portraits of the British School come from the men of lesser reputation. The Raeburns are nu- merous, and are mostly excellent examples, but there is among them one in particular —“Of a Girl” is the indefinite title—that possesses a charm not very often char- acteristic of his work. The child, delight- fully placed on the oval of the canvas, sits with her hands folded in her lap, her long, loose brown mits repeating the note of dull gold in her hair. She is without the senti- ment, she is spared the accessories, Rey- nolds loved. Just as she is in the portrait, so Raeburn may have seen her many times, shy and quiet, sitting with her elders. The pose natural to her was the pose that pleased him, nor did he attempt to improve upon her simple white dress, content to give it no new beauty except the beauty of the triumphant sweep of his well-charg- ed brush. Among the Romneys, also, there is one that stands out above the others, “Mrs. Dawes,” a lady long past her first youth, full of the fascination of Lady Ham- ilton, so that he was able to see more than prettiness in her face, to enjoy the amusing color in her silk gown of orange shot with green, the fine quality of her laces, the depth and air in the gray background. More surprising, however, is the “Portrait of Mrs. Warde,” by Opie, who so seldom has any surprises in store for us, But this is really charming in the sympathetic render-
ing of a charming head and the decora- tive pattern got out of the placing of the latge straw hat with its blue ribbons. The selection of the landscapes has not though for this very reason they had on Press Day the greatest success with the critics, who see small use been so fortunate for a picture that cannot be attributed to @ painter never cred ted with before. “Ts beautiful?” is no longer asked, but, “Is t right?’ <A stately “Rouen,”’ the white cathedral towering above town and river ind bridge, catalogued as a Turner, was dismissed as “not right at all, though the very thing the American would pronounce Turner may never have painted it, but why the deceit a characteristic example.” should take in the American particularly, it would be difficult to say, since, if it had not been for the mistakes a!l Europe made during centuries in the cataloguing of char- acteristic examples, where would be the modern game of “attributions? However, right or not right, there are a few very beautiful landscapes, none more beautiful in my eyes than a little “Lake of Nem!" by Richard Wilson, classical in ariange- ment it may be, with the towered town on a height in the foreground, but so full of light and air--the far hills with houses scattered over the slopes gradually fading into a gray haze on the horizon—that Corot might have signed it. There are also two or three good Turners—a ‘Venice,”” a “Pilot-Boat.’’ And De Wint, with a som- bre, imposing “Lincoln,” is the surprise among the landscape painters as Opie Is among the portrait painters. Altogether, if there are not many great masterpieces, the average of the work of the earlier British masters is excellent. It sets the standard you carry with you into the first of the rooms devoted to the more modern painters—a Pre-Raphaelite room, Holman Hunt is absent, because the death of the artist is a necessary qualification for the admission of his pictures. But Millais and Rossetti appear, and, with them, hang Burne-Jones, their immediate disciple, and Simeon Solomon, a later follower, and Val Prinsep, who, evidently from the canvas now shown, was very much with them at one time. And how does Pre-Raphaelitism come out of the test to which it is now put? Honestly, my feeling was entirely one of disappointment. There was such youth, such romance, such audacity in the Pre- Raphaelite movement—though I ought to add that the more the members of the Bro- therhood write about it, the less romance and the less audacity remain; but not even the confessions of Holman Hunt can rob it of its youth, and the movement was a revolt as truly as the Romanticism of les Jeunes in France in the thirties, as the realism of the ardent little group of the sixties and seventies. In the other galeries you can form some idea of what it is the Pre- Raphaelites revolted against. There are landscapes with the brown tree and the brown grass that were the deadly sins of art to Holman Hunt; there are a couple of Wilkies, with the trivial tale and senti- ment that were to him anathema. And what did the Pre-Raphaelites give in the place of the old conventions? Millais’s “Knight at the Ford,” the only one of his Pre- Raphaelite pictures shown, may Se taken as a fairly typical example. It is in many ways very fine, a remarkaDle performance for a youth—if, in looking at it, one could
only forget the delightful caricature Sandys made of it, the lithograph, now very rare, told me offended Ruskin father much more than Ruskin himself Holman Hunt, in his big book, has jus been explaining again what were the meth that Sandys once ods of this little band of reformers rT) same explanation is in some of Millais letters already published. The young men went down nto he country with all the enthusiasm of missionaries, painted their landscape background from natu: day after day, and all day, no matter what the effect or how it changed with the rising or sinking of the sun in the heavens. They left spaces for the figures they afterwards copied from their models when they came I doubt if the “Knight at the Ford” was done quite as scrupulously as th “Ophelia” or “The Huguenot," but all the defects of the method still clung to Miliais when he painted it. The horse, with its burden of three figures, in the foreground looks as if it had been cut out and past ed on. Turn from it, back into the othe: room, to that big canvas by Hails How well in the landscape the figures are, how up to town. entirely they belong to it! The Pr: Raphaelite gives a thin flat surface of paint; the Dutchman, with no mission in the world except to paint as wel! as he knew how, gives nature, gives life, as | is. It may be that the Pre-Raphaelites soar ed to higher themes than Wilkie, with } tiresome “Blind Man's Buff" and “Rabb on the Wall,” but they were apt to let th: subjects get the better of them. Some of the pictures I have always remembered as the most splendid by Burne-Jones have a place—‘‘Love among the “Laus Veneris."” But look at the “Laus Veneris, with its group of women in bright crim- son and scarlet and blue, and then turn back again to the Hals and lock at the group there, and you will see how much Ruins,” more splendid and sumptuous the coior is in their sombre Drown and black. Burne Jones's design seems as much a pie f tapestry as the tapestry he painted on the wall behind the women; and as for the distance out of the knights pass, it has not the beauty that even Wilkie could give, in the little “Kr- rand Boy” in another room, to so insigaifi window, where. the cant a feature as a distant rose-flushed cot tage wall with a green against it The Pre-Raphaelites have proved nothing so much as that subject does not make great art, and that con scientiousness is not the chief virtue of the artist. Holman Hunt might fill a dozen more large books with his profession of their faith, bimself as their high-priest and prophet-in-chief, and still could not make us discover in their pictures a beau- ty that had not been surpassed by the great masters—and some of the little masters, for that matter—who were to him no better than renegades and infidels. After the old- er work in the collection, the paintings in this series look weak and thin and empty It is in the chance for this comparison that I found my chief interest in seeing them at the Academy. Besides, there Is the less need to dwell on individual exam- ples because they have Seen so many times described—for instance, Rossetti's ‘The Beloved” and ““Mnemosyne,”’ and several! of the s#mall water-colors, really the best things he ever did; Burne-Jones’s series of “The Princess Sabra.” The Simeon Solo mons hardly seem to me to justify the at- water-hutt set
Page 14
96 tention this artist is just now attracting in London. His drawings, which are not ex- hibited, are better than his overworked paintings and mystery-laden, self conscious water-colors. Of the other paintings there is little to be said except that there is a fine landscape by Cecil Lawson, who was never in the Academy, and work by recent Academicians and Associates that ought to make the Academy do penance in sackcloth and ashes for the rest of its existence. There are some interesting things in the water-color room, among them a number of Turner’s mountain peaks and mountain lakes, and here and there a delicate little drawing by artists like Fred Walker and Pinwell. The Black-and-White Room is devoted to a col- lection of drawings and sketches Sy Watts, studies for his pictures, which would have been more appropriatelyshown with the ex- hibition of his paintings last winter. N. N. OLD-AGE PENSIONS IN AUSTRALASIA. SypNeyY, December 25, 1905. New Zealand has just been the theatre of one of the most keenly contested strug- gles these colonies have witnessed. Al' Australia hung, breathless, on the late tri- general elections in the souther Within the British Empire the sun rises earliest in New Zealand, and there (to Daniel Webster's fine image) the drum-beat of State Socialism started, in company with ft, on its journey round the world. The system on which the co’- ony timidly embarked thirteen years ago, with the Socialist developments which Australia is day by day adopting from it, and which the Motherland, under the new Liberal ministry, may now begin to adopt, ennial colony. borrow was on its trial. Industrial arbitration, old-age pensions, and the nationalization of the land were the chief bones of con- tention. Both sides made extraordinary efforts. In the preceding session the Gov- ernment carried a number of Socialist measures. It increased the amount of the old-age pension by almost 50 per cei. It devised a large scheme of State dwell- for workmen. It legislated against Trusts, It proposed to augment by 50 per the sum annually devoted to repur- chasing private estates in order to provide small farms for the moneyless settler. Net content with these performances added to the long list of suchlike measures already on the statute book, the Cyclopean energy of the Premier was lavish in promises. He undertook to build 3,000 workmen's homes and (reviving an old idea of John Bright's) to provide “a free breakfast-table” in ev- ery one of them. He held out the hope that old-age pensions would yet be made universal. The Opposition, for ite part, showed no lack of resource. It created two more par- the New Liberals and the Independ- Labor party. It expowed the financiai condition of the colony—the heavy burden its Socialism was laying on HM in an in- debtedness of sixty millions sterling, the pressure of taxation Increased in ten years by a guinea a head, and the cost of living raised by at least 20 per cent. It recalled the “gagging bill’ passed last session, by ings cent ties ent which freedom of speech on the platform It denounced the despotiem was restricted. The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2118 of the Premier who has for twelve years been governing New Zealand as Bismarck ruled Prussia, the slavery of the civil ser- vice, which must vote as he orders, and the reign of terror that is extinguishing ev- ery spark of independence throvghout the colony. All its efforts were worse thau fruitless; they recoiled on itself. The New Liberals were decapitated. The Independ- ent Laborites were wiped out. The Op- position was almost annihilated. The Gov- ernment majority of two to one was con- verted into a majority of more than threc to one. By what seemed a virtually unani- mous vote, the colony riveted on its own neck the yoke of its Socialist adminis- tration, its autocratic Premier, its moral enslavement. If it is in chains, it is in love with its chains. A closer scrutiny gives a somewhat dif- ferent complexion to the result. In round numbers, 200,000 males and females (for the suffrage is bisexual) voted for the Government, and 170,000 voted for the Op- position. Had 30,000 individuals voted dif- ferently, ithe relations of parties wouid have been reversed. Had an equitabie method of voting been in use, the Opposi- tion would have been returned with six- sevenths as many members as the Min- isterialists, whereas it has less than one- third as many. An enlightened Minister vainly tried to introduce the Hare method into the colony, and similar unsuccess at- tended its attempted introduction into the Commonwealth; but it has for years been in force in the two chief towns of Tasman- ia, and the Tasmanian Government late'y proposed to extend it to the entire State. Proportional representation is the dream of all liberals in countries where no con- stitutional limits are set to legislative om- nipotence. Though old-age pensions were a bone of contention between the rival parties at the late general elections, the contention was to determine which should have the most of it. The leader of the Opposition vied with the Premier in proposing to univer- salize them. There was no question of re- pealing the act creating them. The mere suggestion would have been fatal to the party making it. Those who are in the re- ceipt of them, those who are looking for- ward to enjoying them, and all on whom both classes would be dependent, would have combined to defeat the proposal. The sentiment in Australia is almost the same. Though Tasmania, South Australia, and West Australia profess to be too poor to introduce them, no ministry would venture to abolish them in those States where they have been established. The retrenching Victorian ministry is at heart opposed to them, but all it has dared to attempt is to reduce the amount of the pensions and surround them with a variety of restric- tions. The reforming ministry in New South Wales is no less secretly hostile, but it seeks only to lighten the cost of admin- istering them, to sweep away abuses, and to expose the wrongful acceptance of them by individuals whose relatives are well able to support them. Queensland is about to introduce such pensions. Even the only free-trade ministry the Commonwealth has seen, though anti-Socialist on principle, was willing to enact a general system, ap- plicable to all Australia, provided the va- rious States would consent to the respec- tive amounts being deducted by the Com- monwealth treasurer from the proportion (three-fourths) of the customs duties re- turned to the States. The old-age pension is on its way to become a standing insti- tution, permanently incorporated in the structure of the colonial governments. Whether these adventurous colonies will be able to sustain the burden they are laying on their own shoulders, and by what means, are questions that are causing their administrators no little anxiety. More than twenty years ago, when the subject of old- age pensions was first broached, a pioneer Socialist minister toured New Zealand and expounded a plan for raising the neces- sary funds by means of voluntary contri- butions collected by the State and there- by made compulsory. That was on the mo- del of the impracticable German system, which is even now advocated by moderate Liberals; but the tour was a failure, and the scheme could by no possibility have been a success. The more alluring Danish model has been deliberately adopted in both New Zealand and Australia. The principle of self-insurance has been ig- nored; all attempts to provide by special taxation for the consequent expenditure have been abandoned, and the outlay is be- ing met from ordinary revenue. It is de- pleting, and in all the three colonies it far exceeds the original estimates. The va- rious acts may, indeed, be affirmed to have been passed on false pretences, though it is doubtful whether the popular pressure could in any case have been resisted. In fact, the moment the bill was passed, a rush was made, and, for a time, till mea- sures were taken to thin it, the crowd of applicants continued to swell. Were they all bona-fide, and such as the act contem- plated? Very much the contrary. The income-tax and old-age pensions together are making perjurers of a large portion of the popula- tion of Australia and New Zealand. A late Premier of Victoria admitted that there had been “‘some shocking cases of imposition.” In New South Wales old and respected colonists are sent to prison for under- stating their income or their property. Others forge false declarations about them- selves or the ability of their children to support them. In New Zealand the regis- trar states that “the extent of the impo- sition practised and the amounts obtained by unscrupulous persons are almost incredi- ble.” In 1902, and again in 1908, large sums were recovered, by legal proceedings or otherwise, from pensioners who had been paid under fraudulent claims. In 1902 and 1903 many were struck off the rolls. And here the writer may be permitted to cor- rect an error of his own in the Yale Re- view for August, 1904. He there stated that it was now practicable to measure the cur- vature of the parabola described by old- age pensions in common with all other so- clological phenomena. After only five years of the operation of the act, i seem- ed that the curve had reached its apex, and the diminution of the pension roll by the death of old pensioners exceeded its enlargement by the addition of new pen- sioners. It was a sanguine conclusion. It is a fact that in 1903 and 1904 there was a notable decline in the number of pension- ers, but this was not owing to the deaths overtaking the additions to the roll. I was exclusively due to fraudulent pensioners. - the excision of The pension rol)
Page 15
wre | 3 ; 4 ‘s Feb. 1, 1906] yearly lengthens, and the Premier of New Zealand estimates that the increase will continue for years to come. Two recent amending acts have in various particulars changed the complexion of the systeminNew Zealandand NewSouth Wales. On the eve of the general elections. the Premier of New Zealand introduced a bill which the Opposition described as “a mag- nificent electioneering bribe.” The first and most important new provision was that the amount of the pension was raised from £18 to £26 annually. Mr. Seddon asserted that, since 1898, when pensions were first grant- ed, the cost of living, in house-rent, food, and clothing, had so materially increased that £26 would now go nofarther than £18 did then. The admission, if it is well- founded, seems to be a condemnation of the legislation that has brought about the in- crease; but that is by the way. The pros- perous southern colony, it must be allowed, has shown remarkable self-restraint in so long refusing to yield to pressure by aug- menting the pension. With far less ex- cuse, impecunious Victoria began by fixing the amount at £26, which a retrenching ministry afterwards endeavored to cut down to £17, but was compelled by the Legisla- ture to raise it to eight shillings a week, or almost £22. In New South Wales, not then at the end of a long chain of annual deficits, it was from the first extravagantly fixed at £26. Even now a reform Minis- try does not dare to reduce the amount, which may be considered as henceforth the unalterable figure in all the colonies. New Zealand, a pioneer in all social in- novations, sound and unsound, has been the first to face the issue involved in the grant- ing of old-age pensions. Is the pension a right or a dole? If it is a right, then all persons over sixty-five years of age, who have resided in the colony for twenty-five years, are entitled to receive it, and a late Minister for Works in New South Wales as- serted that it is a right; but no other lead- ing public man has ventured to take the same advanced ground. As already stated, the leader of the Opposition in New Zealand proposes that the difficulties arising from the necessity for discriminating between fit and unfit claimants should be obviated by making the pension universal, and the Pre- mier looks wistfully in the same direction, but is scared by the vision of the enormous burden that would thus be laid on the shoulders of the colony. Successive purg- ings have brought down from 42 to 35 per cent. the proportion borne by actual recip- fents of pensions to those qualified by age and residence to receive them, but the reg- istrar professes to be unable to forecast the numbers that would be thrown on the rolls should a period of industrial depression succeed the present somewhat factitious prosperity. General destitution would then make the pension practically universal. The declarations of Australian Premiers on the character of the pension are uncom- promising. A late Premier of Victoria aver- red that to call it anything else than a charity was mere “sentimental moonshine,” and the Victorian Government has re- trenched its pension roll by one-fourth on the score that the relatives of 4,000 of its pensioners were in a position to support them. The Premier of New South Wales asserts that a pension granted only to the necessitous cannot be described as other than a charity, and a chief feature of his The Nation. amending statute*is the machinery created to test the eligibility of applicants. He re- fuses to make it obligatory on near rela- tives to maintain a pensioner or a claimant but great powers are conferred on the of- ficers administering the act to make search- ing inquiries into all the circumstances of the applicants. A special clause gives ef- fect to the avowal of the Premier that, !f applications for pensions are made in open court, there will be an incentive to wealthy persons not to leave their poor relations unprovided for. In introducing the bill Mr. Carruthers (the first native-born Pre- mier New South Wales has had, and the head of the first ministry consisting entire- ly of natives) gave ludicrous accounts of the well-to-do class of persons who havs« been literally enjoying pensions, and he confirmed the statement of his predecessor in office, that thousands whose relatives are well able to support them are in receipt of pensions. No feeling of pride deterred them from accepting their ten shillings a week On the contrary, not a few individuals are proud of being pensioners, though it is doubtful if this sentiment will survive. They certainly must not be confounded with paupers. The intention of the act was, like the Danish system, to supply an honorable provision for superannuated wage-earners such as shall not be in the nature of poor- relief. The two categories, of pauper and pensioner, are quite distinct, and, so far are the pensions from having diminished the amount expended in State charitable aid, as it was claimed would be the case, that the two are mounting side by side. Perhaps the pension might be described as a cross between an equity and a charity. J. C. Correspondence. BLACK VERSUS ITALIAN LABOR TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: May I be permitted to point out what appears to me to be an injustice, uninten- tional no doubt, in the account of the recent meetings of the American Economic Asso- ciation at Baltimore, in the Nation for Jan- uary 18? In speaking of the last session, devoted to the “Economic Future of the Negro,” your correspondent sums up the papers and discussions in the following words: “On the one hand, the black was shown to be a thrifty, reasonably industrious peasant, whose standard of life rises rapid- ly under favorable conditions; and on the other hand, he was characterized as a be- sotted degenerate, from whom neither pro- gress nor even stability may be expected.” In so far as the second part of this state- ment is intended to apply to the leading paper of the session, that by Mr. A. H. Stone of Mississippi, it seems to me a most unfortunate misrepresentation. Mr. Stone took for his subject ‘“‘The Factor of White Competition,” and, after briefly showing how white labor has prevailed in Northern cities, he took up the question of white com- petition as a possible factor in Southern agriculture, where until recently the negro has been supreme. After showing that, during the ten years covered by the last census, the negro has lost ground slightly, he get forth the results of competition dur- ing the last seven years between Italian and negro labor on a large plantation at Sunny- 97 side, Arkansas. The results were so mark ed in favor of the Itallan that an inquiry into the causes of the negro failure was in order. These are to be found in well known traits and haDits To quote Mr Stone’s words: “Too much time spent out of his crop; too much putting off to a more convenient season; too much waiting for the weather to improve; a too constant and a too suc cessful besieging of those in authority for money accommodations and supplies; too little reckoning against the future day of settlement; too much ‘leaning on the Lori,’ and too little upon himself in things not spiritual; too much living for to-day and not enough for to-morrow.” From the point of view of the planter, the greater efficiency, thrift, and, above all, re liability of the Italian make him more profitable as a laborer. Yet Mr. Stune point ed out that, on his own plantation, Dun leith, with negroes only, he had been able to make as good a showing, so far as the crop was concerned, as had the owner of Sunnyside with Italian labor. This was not due to difference in soil, for there is prac- tically no difference, but to what he de- scribed as “about the most paternalistic system of plantation management since the war.” Showing thus that it was possible for negro labor, closely supervised, to com pete with white labor, little supervised, he« pointed out that the negro could not hope always to be shielded from the full effect of white competition. He said “I do not believe it will ever come to me to do them [the negroes] a greater service than now, if only my voice could reach them, by telling them that here is the only key to the safety of their future economic po- sition; it lies in arresting the growing agi- tation throughout the South of the move- ment for foreign immigration—by remuving its cause. I believe the negro still has it in his power to do this, at least in larg» measure, by making of himself an efficient and dependable factor in the econoniic ilfe of the South? I believe he can do this, but will he? It would mean a revolution in the present social and industrial life and hab its of the masses. To me the outlook for such a course does not seem encouray'ng It will be a slow process of attrition. when it really comes, the working out of the re sults of competition It will not be at- tended by any sensational features. There will be nothing sudden about it nor will it mean the extinction of the negro as an economic factor. It seems to me tha: its effect will be merely to submerge tho in- competent mass, and elevate in that very process such as can weather the storm.” It is true that Mr. Stone’s view is not that of the blind optimist who judges the negro masses by the talented tenth; but it is equally remote from that of the blind pessimist who regards the negro as a “‘be sotted degenerate, from whom neither pro- gress nor even stability may be expected.” Mr. Stone has proved himself so truly the friend of the negro, both on Dunleith plan- tation and in his spoken and printed utter- ances, that it seems to me only fair that when his attitude is, however unintention- ally, misrepresented, some corrective state- ment should be made. W. G. LELAND. Canseats InetrTrurion oy Wasntnoros, January 27, 1006. Persons having letters of important bear- ing upon the life and work of George Ban- croft, the historian, are requested to com municate with M. A. DeWolfe Howe,
Page 16
98 Brimmer Street, Boston. Originals wil! be carefully copied and returned. The Ban- croft family have placed in Mr. Howe's hands a!l the collected biographical ma- terial for an authoritative Life and Let- ters Macmillan Co.'s spring announcements embrace ‘Napoleon and his Times,’ in the Cambridge Modern History Series; the sec- ond part of Thomas Hardy's drama, ‘The Phillips's new play, Development of Shakspere by Prof. Geo. P. Baker; John Wesley,’ by Prof. C. T. Winchester; ‘The Cyclopedia of American Agriculture,’ edited by Prof. L. H. Balley; Tarry-at-Home Travels,’ by Edward Ever- Dynasts"; Stephen “Nero”; ‘The as a Dramatist,’ a ‘Life of ett Hale, with illustrations; ‘Mars and its Canals,’ by Percival Lowell; ‘Wireless Telegraphy and Telephony,’ by Prof. Do- menico Mazzotto; “The Manufacture of Wine,’ by Paul Pacottet; and ‘India,’ by Flora Annie Steel. Great-Grandma’s Looking-Glass,’ a poem 1y Blanche Nevin, with full-page silhouettes by Annis Dunbar Jenkins, is announced by Robert Grier Cooke. A slavish following of our practice of let- Enghish publisher of ing the name of the an English book precede that of the Ame- rican led us, in the title-page caption to our recent notice of Miliukoff's ‘Russia and its Crisis," to imply that the Chicago Uni- versity Press was not the original publish- or Our attention has been called to this by the Press. The book-buyer may have no quarrel with us, but the bibliographer has grounds for one In a notice of the ‘Further Recollections of a Diplomatist,’ by Sir Horace Rumbold, we indicated the probability of another volume to complete the series, and it has now appeared under the title of ‘Final Rec- (London: Ed- ollections of a Diplomatist’ ward Arnold). The story of diplomatic life s brought down from 1885 to 1900, and covers Sir Horace’s experiences at Athens, he Hague, and Vienna His account of t bre courts and of the leading personages ittached to them is mildly interesting, but leaves the Impression that diplomats have very littl to do except attend balis and other soclal gatherings Possibly it was in excessive interest in these serious mat- ers that delayed Sir Horace’s diplomatic promotion, or it may have been a suspected incapacity for the lighter labors of diplo- neacy Whatever the cause of this delay, Sir Horace considers that his merits were not properly appreciated by the Foreign Office, and he winds up his story with another grievance—that a retired diplomat nobody at all “Ol git Piren, qui ne fat rien Pas mOme Académicien."’ Another book of “water-colors and pen- ind-ink sketches in India,” which is re- markable more for the pictures than the print, Ile before us, “The High-Road of Empire,” by A. H, Hallam Murray (BE. P. Dutton & Co.) It recalls agreeable mem- ories to one who has travelled in that country, and contains chiefly pictures of well-known places such as the bathing- ghate of Benares, Less familiar are the Bijapur sketches and views of Jodhpur. The aged author relates that he was easily able to leap across a stream feet wide—a somewhat unusual effect enervating climate of India. The Views of Agra, ete. ten the of The Nation. [Vol. 82, No, 2118 text is pleasant, gossipy talk, with a due modicum of history and archeology. The ‘Memoirs of Catharine Grace Loch,’ Senior Lady Superintendent of the Royal Red Cross in India, edited by A. F. Brad- shaw, M.A., with an introduction by Lord Roberts (Henry Frowde), is a tribute to a cheery and brave soldier of the cross, who united executive ability with the “faculty of inspiring affection,” as the editor says. She was a pioneer in the excellent work done for the soldiers of the crown in India, and her premature death after a few years of service left vacant a post difficult to fill. The memoir is largely autobiographical, be- ing drawn from her letters and diary, and gives a very real picture of the conditions under which the work was carried on, as well as an insight into the noble character of this modest heroine of peace. The fifth volume of the translation of Jiitakas, begun under the editorship of the late Professor Cowell (Cambridge, Eng., University Press; New York: Macmillan), will be welcomed by all students of folk- lore to whom the original text is a closed hook. The present translation is by H. T. Francis, who did part of the translation for the third volume in tne same series. R. A. Neil, who assisted Mr. Francis in the former translation, died in 1901, leaving the whole burden upon the shoulders of the latter scholar. This accounts for the long delay in the appearance of the fifth volume, which includes books xvi.-xxi (Jitakas 511-537), bringing the translation up to the end of the same volume of the text. The latter appeared in 1891. An- other volume will see the whole excellent work completed. The article of greatest general interest in the Geographical Journal for January is the Rey. Walter Weston’s account of his trav- els in the Southern Japanese Alps. His de- scriptions of the wonderful scenery are il- lustrated by some remarkably fine repro- ductions of photographs. Of the peasantry he says that their simple, unaffected polite- ness and kindly hospitality leave the most delightful memories behind, while their honesty is demonstrated by the fact that in fourteen journeys among them he has been robbed but once. He had frequent oppor- tunities of observing how their habits of life prepared them for the hardships and privations of the Mantchurian campaigns, as well as developed self-restraint, patience and resourcefulness. Their social organiza- tion is extrao:dinary, each village headman having a rough map of his district and be- ing able to furnish the minutest informa- tion of the circumstances of any given fam- ily. What their powers of endurance are may be gathered from the statement that in Kofu, one of their most progressive towns, some of the silk filatures employ several hundred persons, chiefly young girls, whose hours are said to be fifteen per day, without a break for meals, or even a Sunday holiday, and this continues all the year round, with the exception of two months in the winter. The exploration of the Beaufort Sea, lying to the north of Alaska, is advocated by Sir C. R. Markham. It is the least-known part of the Arctic re- gion, and the hoped-for discovery of land on the edge of the polar sea would solve an interesting geographical problem. The account of canal irrigation in the Punjab shows a wonderful achievement. On a tract three times as large as Rhode Island, which a few years ago was an uninhabited waste used only for grazing, are now raised an- nually crops mainly of wheat, oil seed, and cotton valued at $20,000,000. The paper read by Prof. W. M. Davis at the Johannesburg session of the British Association, entitled “The Geographical Cycle in an Arid Cli- mate,” is a study of the phenomena pre- sented Sy the deserts of the world. The report of the Librarian of Congress shows the Copyright Office up to date in the handling of its vast business, so profitable to the Government in cash profits and in the books and other articles secured for the Library. The Manuscripts Division has out- grown its cabinets, which must be doubled. Apropos of the recent acquisition of some Franklin Pierce papers, it is stated that “In 1901 the Library possessed the papers of no President of the United States. It now holds the papers of Washington, Jeffer- son, Madison, Monroe, Jackson, Van Buren, Polk, Pierce, and Johnson. Breckinridge and Crittenden papers mark a notable in- crease in the Southern collections. In lit- erary MSS., the Library is defective. The St. Louis Exposition contributed hand- somely of its spoils to the Library, by in- ternational comity, as usual. Two appen- dices are given up to lists of prints from the Chalcographie du Louvre and of fac- similes of copper and wood-engraving of the old masters from the German Reichs- druckerei—more comity. The Librarian states that an international agreement on the subject of cataloguing is almost in sight. It is a reasonable inference from the care lavished upon its catalogue to the ideals and standards of a publishing-house. The ‘Portrait Catalogue’ just issued by Houghton, Mifflin & Co., is a more than fair example of the work of the Riverside Press, and is a desirable possession in it- self. It is not the first of its class put forth by this firm, but it stands at the head in point of beauty of manufacture, without and within. The title-page alone is enough to stamp the quality of the Riverside book- makers. It is beautifully invented. The portraits, domestic and foreign, are very numerous, and there is a brief history of the firm, with accounts of the several de- partments. The evolution of the title-page device is curiously illustrated at the close. The “Riverside” has been completely elim- inated from Vedder's original conception. Berlin papers report the establishment of a German-American literary ‘“Vermit- tlungs-Bureau,” called “The European Literary Bureau,” with headquarters in Berlin W., Motzstrasse 41. This establish- ment represents American book and peri- odical publishers, and has for its ‘spec- ial purpose to act as an agent betweeu American and German publishers. Even in cases where it cannot undertake the hand- ling of manuscripts, it aims to secure the rights of German authors and publishers in the United States, taking advantage of the law passed March 3, 1905. The bureau has also dealings with English and German theatres, and undertakes to handle plays io either country. Financially, it derives its support from the American participants, so that German auitbors and publishers are put to no expense if one of their books or theatrical plays is reproduced in this coun- try. In order to assist impecunious students in working their way through the univers-
Page 17
aude Coatigdbom plain te Rt ont eg Feb. 1, 1906] ity. Arbeiteimter have been established, not by the university authorities, but b7 volunteer students’ associations, in all the leading university towns of Germany. They offer to students of all nationalities and religions the opportunity of earning money by tutoring or becoming Haualehrer, by as- sisting in collecting data for scientific re- searches, excerpting and transcribing docu- ments, preparing indices, proof-reading, and the like. The services are free of cost to all applicants, and are rendered by volunteers from the students’ associa- tions. According to the Frankfurter Zeitung. the philosophical faculty of Giessen has decided henceforth to issue its diplomas in the German and no longer in the Latin language. We believe this is the first in- stance of such an innovation by a German university faculty. The Zeitung expresses the hope that the bombastic exaggeration which the doctor diplomas inherited wii the Latin will also be discarded, as now- adays the average doctor is anything but a rir doctissimus. With this change an- other piece of medieval Zopf in academic life becomes a thing of the past. A report comes from Rome thai the Cen- tral Commission for Antiquities and Fie Arts, by a vote of seven to four, has de- cided to take up for serious deliberation the proposal of Professor Waldstein to es- tablish an international association for the purpose of engaging in the excavation cf Herculaneum. In the Mitteilungen of the German Ori- ent-Gesellschaft, the leader of the German expedition, Dr. Koldewey, reports a dis- covery of great importance for the topo- graphy of the city of Babylon, and for tue location of the castle of Nebuchadnezzar. This is the famous Arachtu canal, so. of- ten mentioned in the inscriptions. News given of the work only re- cently undertaken by the Society in ex- amining the ruins of synagogues in Gal! lee, in charge of the three savants, Kohl, Watzinger, and Hiller. A work 1s thus for the first time being done that Ernest Renan so warmly pleaded for more than for. years ago, as these synagogues are o{ great importance from the standpoint of archi tecture and the development of civilization in Palestine. How urgent the undertaking Was, may be judged from the fact that a number of such sites, reported only a few years ago by various travellers, have now entirely disappeared, and the commission could report on only eleven remains, but all instructive specimens of their kind. The Protestant College at Beirut, Syria, is rematkable among similar institutions for several reasons. Founded thirty-nine years ago by Dr. Bliss, with three rooms and ten students, it has now, says a writer in the Churchman, numerous and spacious buildings costing half a million dollars, and 736 students. The number would be much larger, many applicants for admission be- ing refused, if it had funds for more land, buildings, books, and apparatus. Seven- tenths of the cost of instruction is borne by the students themselves. Its cosmopoli- tan character is shown by the fact that thirteen nationalities are represented in it, and, all race prejudices being laid aside, are working harmoniously iogether. In the pre paratory department, English is taught, as it is the medium of instruction in the is also i The Nation. Schools of Commerce, Medicine, Biblical Archeology, and Philology, though Arabic Turkish, French, and German are taught also. The distinguighing characteristic, however, is the catholic spirit with which the college is administered, so that the members of twelve distinct churches or re- ligious bodies are to be found in it. Incor- porated under the laws of the State of New York, it is independent of the missionary organization of any church, being one of the leaders in practical federation, welcoming and finding the codperation of all Mr. Ellsworth Huntington, the American traveller, well known for his remarkabl journey through the Great Caflon of the Euphrates, is engaged, together with an other American, Mr. R. L exploration of the Tarim Basin in Chines¢ Turkestan the London Times, we gather that the sum- mer and early fall of 1905 were spent in Barrett, In au From a dispatch summarized in studying the river system in the southern part of this region, with a view to supple- menting the work of Dr. Sven Hedin in elucidating its physical history. The resem- blance of the basin, with its sand waves, huge shingle beach, and green tide-flats, to an inland sea is striking, and, but for the absence of water, it would be a genuine Mediterranean. The ruins of ancient vil- lages were found to be considetably more numerous and to cover a much larger area than had been expected. Three new sites were discovered, of which the farthest in the desert must have been once the centre of a large agricultural population The abandonment of these places was due, ac- cording to local tradition, to the failure of the water supply, which, if correct, would indicate the gradual desiccation of Cen- tral Asia in historic times. This winter Mr. Huntington proposes to study the Lop Nor region, and in the spring to visit the curious Turfan depression to the north The statement, made in this journal sev- eral years ago, that, since the introduction of tables and chairs, systematic physical training for all, improved diet, etc., in Jap- anese schools, the legs of the new genera- tion had lengthened a half-inch, was chal- lenged. growing taller are ample, as shown by the The proofs that the Japanese are reports of ‘he army surgeons, who in 1882 examined 348,337 men applying for enlist- ment, and in 1902 431,093 men. At the for- mer date, the number in stature below 5 feet was 20.17 per cent.; in 1902 the per- centage had fallen to 16.20; and that of men below 5.2 feet, from 37.93 to 36.07. Between the same dates the percentages were, of men 5.4 feet and over, 10.06 and 12.67; and of men between 5.2 and 5.4 feet, respective- ly, 31.84 and 35.06. The change of the na- tional fashion from sitting, often for many hours, on hams and heels to chairs, and the introduction of habits of physical exerc!se for all classes during the growing period, dates from 1870, when the first of the 1,200 or more American and other foreign teachers began the modern system of edu cation in Japan. Enlarged data on this point will be among the results of Japan's putting a million of men In arms during the struggle with Russia. The edition of ‘The Poetical Works of William Blake,’ which has been prepared for the (Marendon Press (H. Frowde) by Mr. John Sampson, is, in point of laboriour research and painstaking arrangement, one of the most admirable pieces of editing that we have lately seen. Blake's poetry, owing to his peculiar meth od of publishing, or not publishing, is of a special complication, and the matter ha not been greatly helped by the prone: of previous editors to evade rather than master difficulties, and to make Blake writs what they think he ought to hav rather than what he actually Mr. Sampson preserves for the the integrity of the source He zg poems in the Rossetti MS., the Pickering MS., ete of lumping them under the customary of Good antl each in a group by Itself instead quite arbitrary (title, “Ideas Evil’; and what is more important, he prints Blake rerbatim et literatim WW find, for example, many curious bits of spelling, capitalization, and punctuation like Tyger! Tyger! burning bright that greatly enhance the weirdness and it tensity of Blake's intense and weird in agination. The very copious bibliograph cal and textual! notes which underrun th text are, perhaps, too minute and elabor ate to be of service to any but he mors devoted student, but Mr. Sampson's happy thought of printing in footnotes passag from the Prophetic Books illustrating th symbolism of the poems, will be helpful and suggestive to the less thoroucheoin amateurs of Blake For a volume » In tricate in substance, the book i uneo! monly pleasant In typography We hay noted but a single slip, and that a pardonable and not unengaging on On p. 76, a certain copy of the ‘Songs of Inn cence’ is said to be in the possession of a fortunate gentleman residing in ‘Prov dence, N. Y." Since the appearance of Greenough and Ki-tredge’s ‘Words and their Ways,’ we have met with no book of comparahb'e scope solid and so suggestive as Prof. Otto Jes persen’s new work on the ‘Growth an Structure of the English Language’ zig: B. G. Teubner), or so likely to realize the Copenhagen scholar’s ideal of profit at once to the layman and “the expert philolo gist.” To the technical reviewers, very !\ke ly, chapter iv., “The Scandinavians,” will prove most attractive, since it organizes critically, the conclusions of such investi gators as Bjérkman, Flom, and Brate, and alioge her, puts a new construction on Scan dinavian influence in Old and Middle Eng- lish. To the layman may be recommend ed especially chapters i. and ix. Ohapter is “a rapid sketch of the language of our own days,’ as it strikes a foreigner a foreigner who has devoted much time to the study of English, but who feels tha’, In spite of all his efforts, he is only able to look al it as a foreigner does, and not exactly as a native would.” Judged by the style of his book, Mr. Jespersen’s sense for Ping Yet, rat ing that sense at less than its actua! value lish idiom is not ‘o be sneezed at and granting to the native the Dane's un usual linguistic training, we must s‘lil cred it the “foreigner” with an immense supe- riority of perspective when it comes to a general characterization of cur language. In comparison with other tongues, Pnglish in its sys-em of sounds, ita rhymes, its con cision, sobriety and restraint, its cadences ite sparing use of diminutives, its direct werd-order, seems to Mr. Jespersen “pos!
Page 18
100 The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2118 tively and expressly masculine’: “it is the language of a grown-up man, and has very little childish or feminine about it.” In chapter ix. the time-honored statistics on the comparative richness of the vocabularies of Shakepere, Milton, and the day-laborer get a salutary shaking up, somewhat to the aivantage of Milton and the day-laborer, and without injury to Shakspere. “It is easy,”’ we read on page 214, “‘to prove that [Milton's] vocabulary really contained many more than the 8,000 words found in a Con- cordance to his poetical works. We have only to take any page of his prose writings, and we shall meet with a great many words not In the Concordance. The greatness ot Shakspere’s mind is not shown by the fact that he was acquainted with 20,000 words, but by the fact that he wrote about so great a variety of subjects and touched upoa so many human relations that he needed this number of words.’’ The whole book is full of interest. Mr. E. E. Soderho!z, whose name is well known in connection with s‘:udies of the “Old Colonial” architecture in the Unit- ed States, has illustrated, with the help of “others,"" a book on ‘The Country House,’ by Charles Edward Hooper (Doubleday, Page & Co.). It is not unfair to treat the iilustrations as the most striking and sug- gestive part of such a book, although one is left wondering whether the selection of sub- jects and the judicious taking of negatives from them Is “illustration” in any accepted sense. Here are an enormous number of really admirable details of existing houses stairs, fireplaces, verandas, bay-windows, door-pieces, and the like, with, moreover, scores of exterior views, generally with plans to match; and again views of outbuildings and of gardens and garden- houses, perrons, studies of rock-work, and some the like. In short, here is a perfect icono- graphic encyclopedia of house-building and decorating; and even the end papers or lin- ings of the volume are treated with photo- graphic views—with two large landscape photographs showing in each case a per- gola with vines, and such other accessories as a large formal garden might present. The is a serious analytic s:udy, in which, for instance (chapter vi.), “Windows and Window Motives” are considered—the struc- ext ture of the window sash and frame, its set- ting In the wall of the house, its modifica- tion and extension into the bay window, the oriel, and the like; all very intelligent and sufficiently complete. And in connection with this, another word about the Illus- tra‘ions secans in order—the unusual and really charming character of many of the subjec's chosen. It is not to-day only that we note the easy superiority in the Ameri- can community of simple domestic building and its appliances over the big and formal architecture of the state-house and court- house, the bank and the city mansion; but such a round bay window as that shown on page 109, and such a combination of porch and “Palladian Venetian] window” as we find on page 105, would at once rec- ommend the book to the student. It Is a small quarto in shape and appearance, con- taining 330 pages and at least 359 pictures. ? &. —On the great subject of Shinto, the indigenous religion of the Japanese, Mr. Ernest Satow, formerly student-interpreter in Japan and now British minister in Pe- kin, wrote abundantly with profound schol- arship, acknowledging at the close of his labors that the last word had not been said on Shinto, being himself uncertain as to its indigenous origin. Chamberlain sug- gested that its mythology of the Kojiki, or Book of Origins, had been inspired by Chi- nese legends, but neither professed to em- ploy the comparative method, though Sa- tow advised it. Happily for scholarship, one who has studied Shinto not only in its literary monuments and in the interpreta- tions of aliens, but who has dwelt long on the soil and made direct and profound ob- servations, has taken up the task, and part of his work is now in print. ‘Le Shinn- toisme,’ by Michel Revon (Paris: Ernest Leroux), is a work of original research, in which the author, applying the theory of evolution and the comparative method, arrives at some results, scientific, original, and very important. So far from having its deepest roots in Chinese soil, as some have thought, Revon has demonstrated that the God Way is a spontaneous religion, and in most respects similar to all the other primitive religions, that the mythology of the Kojiki (now accessible in English and German) ig autochthonic, and that the magic and myths of Shinto are connected with the oceanic religions. Dr. Revon was for a decade professor in the faculty of law in Tokio, and is now in charge of the course of history of the civilizations of the Far Bast at the University of Paris. His works on Hokusai (in French) and on the Flora of Nippon Archipelago (in La- tin), and his monographs on modern Ja- pan and on Japanese civilization, beside his text and copious references to author- ities, show a keen observer as well as a student of the first books of importance treating of the Malay, Chinese, and Jap- anese worlds. He is well able to criticise those native scholars, like Hirata and Ma- buchi, whose fanatical patriotism and anti- Chinese bias so often mar the conclusions of their genuine scholarship. Revon is pos- sibly the first author in print, though not the first thinker on the subject, who has wondered how the very numerous oceanic myths of the primitive Japanese could be correlated to Chinese outlook and fancy. The Kojiki stories of origins are very largely those of the “blue plain of the sea” and of lands beyond the waves. Revon has shown clearly that these are allied to Malay lore. Complete demonstration of derivation from Malay origins may be giv- en in the succeeding portions of this in- teresting study. Most fascinating is the author’s notice of the many interesting survivals in popular customs. He demon- strates that phallicism was an organic part of the primitive Shinto system. This is the ablest contribution in recent years to the study of a religion which has struck its roots more deeply into the Japanese soul and national system than any import- ed from the Continent. BAYARD TAYLOR. On Two Continents: Memories of Half a Century. By Marie Hansen Taylor. With the Codperation of Lilian Bayard Taylor Killani. Illustrated from Contemporary Portraits and Paintings by Bayard Tay- lor. Doubleday, Page & Co. 1906. Pp. xi., 309. Few echoes of the recent past will be more acceptable to the student of Ameri- can literature than this unpretentious vol- ume of reminiscence, recalling the portly form, the winning voice and the restless activity of Bayard Taylor. In simple, di- rect narrative as charming as that of An- dersen in ‘The Story of My Life,’ Mrs. Tay- lor tells of her childhood in the old town of Gotha, in “a by-gone time” when court- ladies sat knitting their stockings by the faint light of a candle-dip, and a young girl was thought clever if she but learned to keep house, acquired a smattering of French, said little in company, and never looked wise. Mrs. Taylor’s father was the eminent astronomer, Peter Andreas Hansen, declared by Simon Newcomb “the greatest master of celestial mechanics since La- place’; and, as affectionately sketched by his daughter, we see him stealing away from his young wife at a ball to solve an abstract problem, and forgetting to re- turn, or surprised in his dressing-gown and slippers by a party of fashionable duchess- es. From this typical, secluded German circle, the young girl set out on her first trip to Rome, and there, under the guid- ance of her uncle, Emil Braun, the archex- ologist, a friend of the Brownings, she revelled in the Eternal City of Goethe, with its “walking Caryatids,” until she found “the home of her soul.” Returning to Germany, Marie Hansen met Bayard Taylor first in 1851, on his way back from the Orient, where he had fallen in with her uncle, Bufleb, on the Nile. Be- neath the starry skies of Bgypt the affec- tionate German told the traveller of his niece at home, and she in turn learned from her uncle how the wandering Ameri- can was seeking. to recover from the loss of his first love, to whom he had been wedded but shortly before her death. Five years later, Taylor reéntered the little cot- tage provided especially for him at Gotha; but “as he did not know how to carry on a courtship,” his relations to the German maiden “remained on a footing of simple friendship.” The winter of 1856-7 found Taylor in Sweden and Lapland, but in the budding month of May he came back to Thuringia, and a few days afterward he and Marie Hansen were engaged. A trip to the Land of the Midnight Sun postponed the marriage in Castle Friedenstein until September 27, 1857, when, through Taylor’s wit, the court Prediger proclaimed him “Landowner and Citizen of the United States,” and then the young couple made a visit to London and a tour of Greece. In the following summer they returned to Gotha to reside until their only child, Lil- ian, was born, and two months later all three sailed for the New World. The story of Mrs. Taylor’s early experi- ences in America, told with rare candor and engaging modesty, presents her as a large-hearted, affectionate, patriotic wo- man, tactfully adapting herself to the new environment among her Quaker relatives in the home of Penn. Journeying from New York to Wilmington by rail, and thence fourteen miles by buckboard over rough roads to Kennett Square, Bayard Taylor and his family were welcomed to a table laden with ham, roast-beef, vege- tables, preserves, and pie, all crowded to- gether; and, after glorious autumnal days, Mrs. Taylor decorated the first Christmas tree set up in that part of America. Now and then the plucky wife accompanied her
Page 19
et Bae irs 5 evens. ghia Feb. 1, 1906] The Nation. 10 husband on his lecturing tours, in 1859 go- ing even to California by way of the Isthmus, a perilous but “wonderfully beau- tiful voyage”; and, again, she remained alone courageously long weeks at home, while the overworked lecturer toured the sparsely-settled country. The civil war, too, stirred her inmost soul; she led the women of her neighborhood in preparing supplies for the soldiers, she guarded her home from marauders incensed by Taylor's connection with the Tribune, and she ven- tured with her husband, in his capacity as war correspondent, almost on the field of battle. Vivid and full of local color are the letters of the young wife to her anxious relatives on the fall of Richmond, the surrender of Lee, and the assassination of Lincoln; and equally absorbing are the tidings of the great struggle between Ger- many and Austria sent by the aged parents from Gotha, to the borders of whose town- ship the theatre of Buropean war had changed. The decisive move at Kénig- gritz, and the beginning of Bismarck’s brilliant career, showed Mrs. Taylor how thoroughly German she had remained; while the tremendous victory of the Ger- mans in their life-and-death struggle with the French was celebrated by the poet as well. All in all, however, the years passed pleasantly with the Taylors in their new and spacious “Cedarcroft,” designed and érected by Taylor near the scene of his birth and amid the staid old Quakers, whose sterling merits both the alien Bayard and his German wife appreciated. Of modest tastes, Taylor’s chief extravagance was booke, pictures, flowers, and an overpow- ering hospitality that brought guests from near and far and kept them for weeks, not to mention the neighbors who tarried so long under the welcoming roof that there was nothing else to do but to put them to bed! Taylor came to number Long- fellow, Bryant, Whittier, Emerson, Lowell, and Alice and Phebe Cary among his friends and guests, and other Americans whom he often entertained at ‘“Cedarcroft” were Putnam and Fields, his loyal publish- ers; Willis, his early patron; Mrs. Botta and Susan Warner, the eloquent young Cur- tis, Boker and Furness, the steadfast Gree- ley and his eccentric wife, Edwin Booth, Aldrich, Bret Harte and McEntee, J. L. Graham, Sidney Lanier, Stedman and Stod- dard, who called the company of poets, artists, and authors thus gathered together “a nest of singing-birds.”” In the mean- while, Taylor and his wife crossed and re- crossed the ocean, now spending a night with Tennyson at Farringford, then sleeping in the room occupied by Goethe at Iimenau, and again enjoying the hospitality of the Grand Duke of Weimar, and so came in contact with many representative Euro- ‘peans. These chance acquaintances or more enduring friendships afford the author studies of the Poet-Laureate, the Brown- ings, Wolf von Goethe, Thackeray, Riick- ert, Barry Cornwall, Swinburne, Garibaldi, Freytag, Bismarck, Auerbach, Karl Witte, Preller, Tupper, Schiller’s grandson (Von Gleichen), Lord Beaconsfield, and Alexan- der von Humboldt, who told Taylor that he would politely try to live until he should see the daughter of Hansen! Once Tay- lor went to St. Petersburg as chargé- @affeires, assured that, upon the retire- ment of Mr. Cameron, he should be given the post of minister, and there are spicy recollections of court life among the affable Russian nobility, the cordiality of the Brit- ish Ambassador, Lord Napier, and his wife, who studiously avoided any reference to the War of the Rebellion, and the marked coldness of the German legation, “If I had been an American born,’ says Mrs. Taylor, “the diplomatic corps would have approved of me to a greater degree; but as a Ger- man, and not of the nobility, I was a stum- bling-block in their path which could not be ignored on account of my husband's off- cial position.’"” On the strange conduct of Secretary Seward, however, in promis. ing Taylor the mission to Persia, and then leaving him to wait for months in Europe while Lincoln thought that he was at the court of the Shah, Mrs. Taylor throws no new light, probably because nothing fur- ther is or ever will be known in the mat- ter. Time, reverses, and toil worked a baneful influence on Taylor's dreamy and hopeful nature; little by little “Cedarcroft" proveda greater burden than even his broad shoul- ders could bear; and, to the sorrow of many, the poet and his wife bade good-bye to the pleasures of country life, and began that restless existence in the grinding me- tropolis which was later to hurry Taylor so swiftly to his fate. “‘We made mistakes,” says Mrs. Taylor, referring to their venture at Kennett Square, “that we were after- ward obliged to atone for as the way of the world demands. And yet, what mattered it in the end! If men and women can be happy, we certainly were.” “The heavy burden of journalistic slavery dropped from Taylor's shoulders’’ when he became Minis- ter to Germany, ‘‘but other demands were made upon his strength which were by no means salutary.”” Entering upon his high office when already stricken with a fatal disease, Taylor hastened his death by de- votion to General Grant, who was then touring the world and had reached Berlin. In the Prussian capital, on December 19, 1878, Bayard Taylor breathed his last. Taylor's personality, as portrayed by his wife, is natural and attractive. He is af- fectionate to his kin, taking his brothers and sisters and parents to Europe, and sell- ing a share of Tribune stock to equip his younger brother for a captaincy in the Un- ion army, and he is devoted and tender as a husband and father, playfully giving his wife a watch hidden in a hat-box, and writ- ing to his little daughter rare descriptions of Indians and “back-woods” natives met with on his lecturing tours. His wit and humor come to his aid when beset by bores, whom he coughs away, intimating the prevalence of a contagious disease; his patriotism is evidenced by the defence of country and home; and the veil is par- tially lifted from his real religious views, the evolution of which had been but inti- mated in his poetry. He is par excellence a linguist, delighting the Czar by his rapid acquisition of Russian; he works prodig- lously at prose, wearing himself out in the service of the Tribune; as a lecturer he is “not a born orator, but has adapted himself to the profitable temporary profession be- cause it is demanded of him’; he sketches the Acropolis and the canals of Venice, sets up a studio at Rome or whiles away Sun- days in the country painting the beauties of hedge or lawn; while as a poet with ideals as high as those of “Dewkalion, a type far superior to all other men,” he dis plays facility in both English and German writing sixteen stanzas of “St. John” at a sitting, and translating six lyrical poems as part of a long review of two volumes of Hugo made in a single afternoon and even ing. With all his poetic spirit, however, he is dominated for some time by a former task; he chafes under the restlessness of American life, and he cannot talk to others of bis ideas until they have ripened into form. Little by little we see the “Faust taking shape in English, a “heart-rending but fascinating” toil, the poet making “in- numerable drafts of the Song of the Spirits” alone, while his gifted wife follows with the original before her eyes; his tribute “An Goethe” is submitted for criticism to Gustav Freytag, who finds it “cast in a single mould of true German spirit and Ger- man feeling, and needing no improvement.” We are sadly conscious of the peculiar gifts which Taylor possessed for a Goethe-Schil- ler biography, and the facilities—unequalled at that time—assured him by the Duke of Weimar and the scholars of Germany; and we see only too well that, had he settled down to that great work and said nay to the Muse that “came, returned, and would take no denial,’"’ we might to-day boast a sympathetic interpretation of the Weimar Duumvirate such as graces no literature. Nearly half a century of stirring life passes along these ‘Two Continents’ of Mrs. Taylor, illustrated by the unique portraits of Taylor, Hansen, and Bismarck, and an notated with clever translations by the poet’s daughter; and yet it would be de lightful to hear more of Taylor's wooing to know Marie Hansen's part in his literary development and in his masterpiece, the “Faust,” and to gaze longer at the bedside of the poet expiring in a _ foreign land There is also less about Longfellow and his friendship with Taylor than might be ex pected, there is no mention of Lowell, nor is there any reference to Taylor's lecture in German on American lit erature at Weimar, where the story of an eye-witness would be very acceptable. But the volume brings much that is new, and what was previously known has been well retold. There is, in general, a wise discrimination as to con tent, and the whole work shows the value of that lost art—the keeping of a diary THE FIRST EARL OF DUDLEY, Lettere to “Ivy,”’ from the First Earl! of Dudley. By 8. H. Romilly. Longmans, Green & Co. 1905 John William Ward, first Earl of Dudley, escaped greatness by 80 narrow a margin as vividly to recall Dryden’s line regarding the close alliance between genius and madness Unlike the Earl of Peterborough, whose brilliant successes during the War of tie Spanish Succession took England by storm, he was neither a soldier nor a man of ab- normally energetic temperament. The af- fliction which clouded his life and almost nullified his extraordinary gifts, was an undue sensitiveness of temperament ari«ing from an organic cause in malformation of the brain. Otherwise, he possessed almost every advantage of rank, intellect, and eharacter. He had bigh birth, great wea.th,
Page 20
The Nation. [ Vol. 82, No. 2118 noble aims, great Intellectual acquirements and power of application. Nothipg but un- certain health and the same sort of fas- tidiousness which baffled Lord Acton seems to have stood in his way. Had the gods who gave him so much but given a little more, he might have vied in politics or lit- erature with almost any of his contempo- raries. Such, at least, is the impression one is bound to form of Ward's qual- ities from the statements which were made about him by those who were quite competent to appreciate his parts. Even the Quarterly Review and the Edinburgh Review could unite to praise him. “Fulfilling Lord Bacon's grand recipe,” says the Quarterly, “his reading made him full, his writing exact. His wit was prompt, sparkling, and epigrammatic; it was play- ful and indulgent, not, however, from weak- ness; it was the giant’s strength which could afford to be generous. To all these qualities of the head was superadded a gen- tle and affectionate disposition, a freedom from pride and vanity, a simplicity of hab- its and tastes—in a word, all the striking features of that noblest of creations—a real English gentleman.” While the Quarterly could speak thus, Brougham fn the Edinburgh was not to be outdone: “He possessed one of the most acute and vigorous understandings that any man was ever armed with. His quickness was not accompanied with the least temerity; on the contrary, he was as sure as the slowest of mankind. His wit was of the brightest order, combining with the liveliest percep- tion of remote resemblances and mere dis- tinctions all that nice relish of the ludicrous, especially in character, out of which perfect humor is engendered. .. . And it was none of the least enviable of his great qualities that, in union with all these endowments, and in spite of that fortune and station usually so inimical to laborious pursuits, he possessed the faculty of in- tense application, passing his life by pref- erence in the study, and having acquired the habits of unremitting intellectual la- bor as completely as if he had been born a poor man, by necessity become a student, gifted with a slow understanding, and at once devoid of fancy and acuteness.” These words from the lips of his contem- poraries will serve to give Lord Dudley his place among the élite of Englishmen during the age of Castlereagh and Can- ning For the rest, it may be said that his temper was so fastidious that any literary remains saved from the wreckage of his life must awaken curiosity if they do not end in eliciting admiration. There is not even an oll portrait of him, and the one pencil drawing—that by Slater in the rooms of Grillion’s Club—is sald to have been crunched up, put in his pocket, and long supposed to have been destroyed. It shows an extremely refined and Intellectual face, uch as any artist might have been de- lighted to portray It is true, there al ready exists in print a portion of Ward's correspondence with Bishop Copleston, his college tutor; but this collection of letters created a sense of disappointment from the formality of its tone and its failure to re- veal the charm and power which the writer undoubtedly posneane d "Than the firet Martyr's Dudley's fate Still barder must be owned; Stephen was only stoned to death Ward has been Coplegtened."' Apropos of the foregoing epigram, Mr. Romilly observes: “This was certainly hard luck upon the man of whom no less an authority than Madame de Staél has said that ‘he was the only man in England who really understood the art of conversa- tion.’ ” The “Ivy” of these letters was Mrs. Du- gald Stewart of Edinburgh, in whose house Ward had lived for some time during his early years. Concerning Mrs. Stewart's personality little need be said here, save that she had a degree of attractiveness which made a host of eminent people her lasting friends. Sixteen years older than Ward, she had at first given him the af- fectionate care which, through his moth- er’s neglect, he had never known at home. The whole correspondence is couched in a tone of familiarity blended with real de- ference, and is wholly unlike the stiffness of Ward's style in his correspondence with Copleston. It was long believed that Mrs. Stewart on her death-bed destroyed the whole of Ward's letters to her; but, though she probably did burn some of them, a great many were preserved, either in the original hoiograph or in a careful copy. Mr. Romilly, the present owner of them and also the editor of this volume, re- ceived them on the death of a relative who, as a child, had been brought up in Mrs. Stewart's family. It was only two years ago that chance led him to open the manuscripts and familiarize himself with their contents. The correspondence here published runs parallel during the greater part of its course with the ‘Creevy Papers,’ and covers some of the ground traversed by the first volume of Greville. Ward was a far abler, more acute and more scholarly man than either of these contemporaries, and in his more detailed letters reaches a height to which neither of them attained. As an historical record, the main defect of the papers now printed Sy Mr. Romilly must be found in their disconnected and sporadic character. There are considerable breaks in the chron- ology, and no single topic is so fully illus- trated by them as is the nature of Whig politics in the ‘Creevy Papers.’ Ward had an intellectual disinterestedness which kept him from becoming a party hack, and, though he ended his political career by be- ing Foreign Secretary under Canning, he had passed through the stage of moderate Whiggism, and could even admire the genius of Napoleon without being in the least swayed by patriotic prejudice. For exam- ple, his letters from the Continent after the Emperor's first abdication are filled with cordial eulogy of the great public works carried out under Napoleon’s care; and once, when Metternich asked him at dinner what he thought about Napoleon himself, the answer was: “Mon Prince, je ne suis pas militaire, mais il me semble qu'il a rendu la gloire passée douteuse, et la re- nommée future ImpossiDle.” And, apropos of epigrams, to Ward may be ascribed more truly than to Lord John Russell the say- ing that the cant of patriotism is not so bad as the recant. Although we find it impossible to make this notice include passages from Lord Dud- ley’s letters which would give an adequate impression of their style, we must state that the book contains a good deal that would stand separation from the context. Ward's sub-satirical strain is very pleasant, for, without striving after effect, he can be witty, and his wit is not ill-natured. While far removed in both conception and manner from the ‘Etchingham Letters,’ the tone of Dudley’s correspondence is not unlike the clever trifling one gets from Sir Frederick Pollock and Mrs. Fuller Maitland. Speak- ing broadly, one-third of the letters may be called unimportant, since they are but hasty notes illustrating merely the writer's filial affection for Mrs. Stewart. The other two-thirds consist of moderately long epis- tles—epistles, at any rate, which are long enough to disclose the nature of Ward's tastes and mind. The representative pas- sages that we are unable to cite, include a remarkable scene between Ward and Lady Caroline Lamb (pp. 95-98), the whole series of letters from Italy and France (pp. 262- 301), and the appreciation of Canning (pp. 325-328). So far as the architecture of a house can be represented by a single brick, the following paragraph regarding Sir James Mackintosh may be called a fair sample: “Mackintosh is here on his way to Switz- erland. I spent a very pleasant evening yesterday with him and Constant. He is, in truth, a most delightful creature. If I were a king, I should make an office for him in which it should be his duty to talk to me two or three hours a day, and then if my queen offended me, I would send Lady M. to talk for an equal time to her. He should fill my head with all sorts of knowledge, but, out of the great love I should Dear to- wards my subjects, I would resolve never to take his advice about anything. He has got Rogers with him, who, as you know, has published a new poem entitled ‘Jacque- line,” for which Murray has been goose enough to give him a guinea a line. But then ‘Lara’ precedes it, and I suppose he has been obliged to buy the lean rabbit along with the fat one, according to ancient usage.’’* In short, the interest attaching to these letters is much greater than that belonging to the average volume of eighteenth-cen- tury correspondence, and, quite apart from their service in recalling the memory of an extraordinary man, they bring us much nearer to Dudley himscif than do any of his other writings. Russia. By Théophile Other Distinguished French Travellers and Writers of Note. Translated from the French, with an additional chapter upon the struggle for supremacy in the Far East, by Florence MacIntyre Ty- son. Illustrated by numerous photograv- ures. In two volumes. Philadelphia: The John C. Winston Press. 1905. Théophile Gautier’s work is too well known in the former editions which have presented it to the English-reading public during its already fairly long life, to re- quire detailed notice. In general, it may be said that it stands the test of time wonderfully well; and while minor details of custom or costume have changed in recent years, it seems destined, on its sterling merits, to preserve a perennial freshness and charm. No one has ever de- scribed more poetically, with more ex- quisite imagery, the aspects of nature in Russia, and Gautier’s sympathy is of im- value in keeping his mental com- Occasionally he seems inclined to generalize on insufficient grounds; oc- casionally, also, he imagines facts as to which any Russian could have set him right Gautier, and by mense pass true. *Rogers and Ward were not good friends, Ward condemned ‘Columbus’ in the Quarterly and Rogers retaliated by launching the well-known epigram: “Ward has no heart, they say; but I deny it; He has a heart, and gets iis apesches by it.”
Page 21
ee ee ow Ps F) # 3 iy Feb. 1, 1906] had he thought of mentioning them in time. For instance, in describing the church ceremony (which precedes the Blessing of the Neva on Epiphany Day), in the Winter Palace cathedral, he asserts that from the gallery he beheld “the Em- peror and the Imperial Family in the sanctuary whenever the Holy Doors in the ikonostasis were opened.” This is abso- lutely impossible, as under no circum- stances are women, even of the reigning family, allowed in the sanctuary. The per- sons thus seen were, probably, assisting priests, and if the Imperial family were not standing in plain sight, twenty feet in front of the ikonostasis, they were ab- sent, tn the Imperial withdrawing-room on the right; or the Empress (it was in the reign of Alexander II.) was in the glass box below the gallery, which was specially constructed for her in her invalid years. Either Gautier or the translator confus- ingly substitutes ‘“‘Bastern” for “Western” in the elaborate description of St. Isaac. He errs, also, when he states that the Eastern ritual requires all four sides of a church to be exactly alike; and in some other points. Probably the “Romanoff” monastery referred to, near Moscow, should read “Simeonoff,” and is a translator's mistake. In order to furnish a sort of compendium on Russia, various chapters have been add- ed. “The Mir, the Rural Commune,” by Anatole Leroy-Beaulieu, is too classic an authority as to conditions at the time it was written to require anything but bare mention. “The Russian Army and Navy” (author not named) represents matters pre- vious to recent disasters, including the attribution of Grand Duke Alexis to the general command. ‘Religions and Sects.” by Gustave Lejeal, is an attempt to sum up the entire question, and contains some extraordinary statements. Speaking of thx Greek Church, he says: “She refuses to admit the creed of the Council of Nice,” meaning that the Eastern Church does not admit to its creed the filioque clause, and being obviously ignorant that that is precisely the form in which the Council of Nicwa established it. A little later on he alludes to nine slight differ- ences between the Greek and Russian Church customs, and omits to mention that, so far as Russia is concerned, many of these points refer only to the Church pre- vious to Nikon’s reforms, though he does mention Nikon. Where, we wonder, in “the orthodox catechism” (which confines itself to spiritual matters) is the Tsar called “the curator and protector of the Church”? Bishops are said to have large revenues, which allow them “to hold with dignity their places in the best society’’; but this is a gratuitous assumption, on the model of the Roman Church, for Russian bishops are supposed to abjure society and devote themselves to their diocesan af- fairs. In his description of the peculiar sects either M. Lejeal or the translator is responsible for the infelicitougs state- ment (or construction): “There are even a few, fortunately, who think a child should be baptized and fed with his mother’s blood”; which is calculated to exaggerate even the legitimately painful doctrine. In the same manner, Sutaieff's doctrine is made to read: “The kingdom of God must come below’’—intended for “from within,” The Nation. possibly, or “from below.” Just above (vol. ii, p. 193) a typographical error makes ‘“samaboys” out of ‘“‘samabogs" (self-gods). The most remarkaDle doctrin- al statement of all, however, is connected with Count L. N. Tolstoy: “A new sect has been grafted upon one of the last works of this great writer, ‘The Kreutzer Sonata.’ Its adherents, people of wealth and learning, would abandon a brilliant po- sition to give themselves up to manual labor.” As a matter of fact, the preaching by Tolstoy and adoption by his “adepts” of the manual-labor doctrine long preceded the work named—which is devoted, by the way, to the enforcement of a totally differ- ent doctrine! The section on “Literature” is furnish- ed from the long-familiar works by M Louls Léger and Vicomte E. M. de Vogiié, and deals only with the older writers, but is, of course, admirable, so far as {it goes “Russian Art,’”’” by M. Marius Vachon, Is highly appreciative, but hardly competent in the department of architecture, which it assumes to present very fully, (Had the translator, by the way, either rendered the title of the famous old Kieff church, the “Dime,” as “The Tithes,” or Jeft it its accented i, the effect would have been better as well as more intelligible.) M. Vachon relies too much on the pronounce- ments of Viollet-le-Duc, who was badly informed as to Russian origins and styles in general. Possibly the translator is re- sponsible for “the worship [instead of “reverence”’] of images’; and for “Palace of the Corners,”’ as a title for the “Facet- ed Palace,” correctly rendered in Gautier’'s work. Gautier, by the way, got very much mixed up over that, the Golden Champer, the Great Palace of the Kremlin, and the Treasury, as well as over the situation of Napoleon’s statue there, evidently trust- ing too much to a belated memory. M. Jules Legras’s book on ‘Siberia’ is incorporated, with great good judgment. It appeared about eight years ago, and deserves to be known. The translator's own concluding article, on “Russian Policy in the Far East,” is brief but excellent. As to her rendering from the French of the various selections, we regret to say that, while it is, on the whole, extremely good, she too frequently loses touch with the idiomatic turns of both languages; and precisely because of its high degree of attainment in most respects, these blem- ishes are the more noticeable. “The so simple disposition we are fancying,’’ ‘‘forc- ible’ (for “perforce’’), and “principal” (for principle’) will serve as specimens of this regrettable carelessness. The illustrations are very numerous, very beautifully reproduced, and well chosen; but it would have been well worth while to have had them labelled by a person acquainted with the country. Rarely does a splendidly prepared work suffer so much in this respect. In volume 1., the plate labelled “Tomb of Peter the Great” rep- resents the canopied resting-place of some prelate of the Roman Church (in a Gothic cathedral), surrounded by statues of pre- lates with the pointed Roman mitre, card- inals’ hats, coats of arms, and so forth. Peter the Great lies in a plain, slab-cov- ered tomb, in a horribly rococo church. “The Church Imperial, St. Petersburg” is im reality the church of the great palace at Peterhof, twenty miles from the capital. 108 “Place Sonbrinsk!, Moscow” is intended for “Place Lub/anski.” In volume ! “Entrance to Kremlin from Chinese Town, Moscow” should read: “To Chinese Town from the White Town.” “The War De partment, St. Petersburg.” represents one end of the Admiralty and neighboring buildings. “Assumption Cathedral and Ivan’s Tower, Moscow,” should read: “The Synod Church.” “Poshkoff’ Museum, Mos cow” arises from a confusion of names It represents the Rumyantzof! Museum formerly the residence of Mr. Pashkoff The “Palace of Peter the Great, Moscow offers a view of the wall, holy gate, and churches in the Novodievitche Convent, several miles from the Petroveky Palace, which is intended; and the ‘Cathedral In terior,” with its Gothic vaulting, pews, and unscreened altar, is unmistakably Roman Catholic, not Russian. The volumes are beautifully printed and bound. Gicorge Bernard Shaw and his Playa By Henry L. Mencken. Boston: Jobn W Luce & Co. 1906. A great deal too much has been written about Mr. Shaw and his opinions, especia! ly by himself. When the London theatres were making experiments with Ibsen's plays in the eighties, the vast majority of those who saw or read them were far from sure what the author was driving at. Bu Ibsen was a reserved person, who eith¢ did not know or neglected the uses of sel! advertisement. Mr. Shaw, no doubt, real ized from such an example that if you let discussion languish, the intelligent will simply absorb and give out your theories again in a more popular form without any thanks to you, while the general public wi!l regard your name as a synonym of th: suspiciously obscure. The author of th ‘Quintessence of Ibsenism’ did his bes: to prove that Ibgen had a persistent purpose (which, however, remains doubtful, sin: Ibsen himself seems inclined to smile a the assertion that he has always used bh plays to expound his social philosophy) But Ibsen, at any rate, kept carefully in the background. He challenged outworo ideals, and showed us situations in which happiness depended on giving them up and following the lead of one’s own individu ality. For Mr. Shaw, an ideal qua idea is a héte noive, except, indeed, the old classical ideal of the Perfect Man, who is no more likely nowadays to become rea than when the Stoics dreamed of him. Ib- sen has left his mark and made his disc! ples because he was in earnest, and b: cause he did not stultify his own teaching by a wholesale condemnation of every con- vention and ideal that has been evolved by the human race. This Mr. Shaw does, and the iconoclastic spirit of youth would prob- ably secure him disciples enough if he did not indulge the freakish irony which drives him to turn and laugh In the face of his admirers directly they try to form- ulate a Shavian doctrine. It is this ex- cess of irony that shocks the French tas\«, and has made M. Filon, the critic and historian of the drama, refuse to see in Mr. Shaw's plays any real attempt to re- form society; only that mania for tear'nse down fences and setting fire to commons which he has ascribed to one of his own characters. The fences are repaired, and
Page 22
104 The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2118 the common grows up again all the green- er, and there is an end. Mr. Mencken, in this brief volume of about one hundred pages, attempts to do for Mr. Shaw what was done for Ibsen in the ‘Quintessence of Ibsenism,” years ago. But it is not so easy to write a Quintes- sence of Shavianism unless one is ready, as Mr. Shaw was in his itract, to go all the way with one’s subject, or even fur- ther, and to wring the quintessence out of him. This Mr. Mencken cannot do. What made the ‘Quintessence’ valuable was the peculiar equipment of Mr. Shaw for the task, just as George Meredith's ‘Idea of Comedy’ has become a classic because he himself was a master of the comic spirit. But the writer of the present volume does little more than give us a résumé of the plays and novels. The book is, in fact, in- tended for those who, after seeing a per- formance of “Man and Superman,” are dis- inclined for the exertion of reading those plays that are not now being presented on the stage. The truth is, that the time has not yet arrived for a book on Mr. Shaw Newspaper paragraphs answer the purpose where anything has been left un- said by Mr. Shaw himself in his prefaces, or by the characters who are the mouth- piece of his opinions. Who can tell whe- ther Mr. Shaw will ever settle down to the task of one who takes his reforms seri- ously, as a reformer must do unless he in- tends to create mere bewilderment? As the average Athenian appre- clate what Socrates was driving at, or whether he would have any permanent place in the history of thought, as we can properly place Mr. Shaw. And Socrates was at least terribly in earnest, and was never tested by becoming the enfant gdaté of the public Moreover, Socrates had not been forced to suppress himself for years as a struggling journalist before he could let himself go as a social iconociast. It is not easy to interpret the plays of a playwright with a purpose. This fact the ingenious Mr. Verrall is once more demon- strating in his interpretations of the plays of Euripides. Mr. Mencken, how- ever, rather describes than interprets, and his book will no doubt find grateful read- ers among Mr. Shaw's American audiences. What he means when he tells the playgoer “Man and Superman’’ is “in purpose little could that one with the ‘Odyssey,’"’ we cannot imag- ine, for we had always thought that there was a purpose in the play, and there is none in the ‘Odyssey,’ save to delight the weary Mr. Mencken says of “The Devil's Disciple’ that, among the religious, only “‘a man given to constant self-anelysis—the v00th man in the thousand’ could appre- clate it This is probably an echo of Mr. Shaw's one realist in a thousand in the ‘Quintessence.’ But he was, of course, the thousandth man, not the 999th Mr. Mencken's Boglish is rather too col- loqguial for elegance. “When Darwin bob- bed up,’ “A young woman of money,” “oldster’ (a horrid analogous formation), are a few of his faults of style. Nor can the tone of the blographical note It is not in good taste to drag in aman’s relatives as evidence of his private circumstances—at any rate, not until he is we admire dead and has been handed over to his biographers for dissection. Of the Shaw family Mr. Mencken writes: “Its present head is Major Sir Frederick Shaw, Bart,. D.S.0. of Bushey Park, Dublin. A re- spectable, well-sounding name and ad- dress."" What has this to do with Mr. Shaw or his plays? Mr. Shaw has shown a rather indecent lack of reticence about his mother, but we might leave his cousins and uncles alone until he has put them, also, into a preface. In the introduction, Mr. Barrie's play is referred to as “Agnes- sit-by-the-fire’; Beerbohm is spelt Beer- hobm; Sudermann’s piay is more than once referred to as “Johnnisfeuer.”” The Berke- ley Lyceum is not in Forty-fifth Street (p. 97). A History of Egypt trom the XIXth to the XXXth Dynasties. By W. M. Flinders Petrie, D.C.L., etc. With numerous il- lustrations. Charles Scribner’s Sons. 12mo, pp. xx., 406. Primitive Art in Egypt. By Jean Capart. Translated from the revised and aug- mented original edition by A. 8. Griffith. With 208 illustrations. Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott Co. 8vo, pp. xx., 304. The Religion of the Ancient Egyptians. By Georg Steindorff, Ph.D. G. P. Putnam’s Sons. i12mo, pp. ix., 178. Three notable works on Bgypt are these which have just come from the press. They are the works of specialists, and form val- uable additions to the literature of the sub- ject. Professor Petrie is recognized as the most expert and experienced excavator who has ever operated upon the archwological field of Bgypt. For many years he has labored in Egypt or Palestine laying bare multitudes of sites and preserving such a record of things just as he found them, that the later investigator is practically as well off as though the excavations had been his own. His professional training as an en- gineer has stood him in good stead, and his memoirs, issued by the Egypt Exploration Fund, are models of conciseness and of thoroughness. His ‘History’ has now reach- ed its conclusion, at least it has reached the limit of the dynasties of Manetho. But to say that the history is “completed” is a different thing. No history of Egypt will be finished till the last monument is found and all the mountain tombs have given up their story. There seems to be no sign of ex- haustion, and the discoveries by a country- man of our own during the winter of 1904-5, have well nigh eclipsed all that have pre- ceded. But Professor Petrie has completed the task of portraying all of Manetho’s thirty dynasties, and he has done it well from a scholarly point of view. He has made a book for students and for special- ists, a book which enables us to say that the best and most inclusive history of Egypt is in English; but it is not one that can be read with ease or possesses literary merit. Dynasty follows dynasty, and reign follows reign, and the same method of treatment is used in each case, modified only by the fulness or paucity of material. The various forms of the name of the king are given in Bnglish transliteration, and in hieroglyphic character, with the dates of his life. Then follow lists of the monu- ments which contain his name, tell of his deeds, or testify to his building activity; liets of his wives and children; and in some cases texts are cited showing from whom a given king received divine honor and worship. Then a narrative account of all known facts follows, and illustrations are introduced and make the story plain and more vivid. Frequently there are half- tone representations of the cartouches of kings taken from scarabs and other ob- jects. The present volume and those which pre- ceded are mines of historical information up to date for the time of composition. Sub- sequent discoveries have made revision nec- essary, and the first volume especially should be again subjected to this process. The detail of the volume before us is so immense as to make a correspondingly de- tailed judgment impossible. One almost stands aghast at the magnitude of the task, and the book is a constant source of wonder that we are able, with such minute- ness and such accuracy of statement and chronology, to follow the movement of events in times which long preceded the be- ginning of our era. We are here taken back more than thirteen hundred years be- fore Christ, and yet the materials dovetail together so closely that the author declares there is no unfilled gap longer than ten years. A similar claim is scarcely made for any other history so ancient. The en- tire series is now completed except the vol- ume on ‘Arabic Egypt,’ originally assigned to Mr. Stanley Lane-Poole. ‘Primitive Art in Bgypt’ is by the Keeper of the Egyptian antiquities in the Royal Museum at Brussels. It is from first to last a tribute to the labors of Professor Petrie in excavation and exploration. Pro- fessor Capart gives credit where it is due, and cites throughout the various “Memoirs” of Petrie, and the works which he publish- ed independently as well as on behalf of the “‘Archwological Survey’ and the “‘Re- search Account” of the Egypt Exploration Fund. The yolume is sumptuously got up. The type is large, and the illustrations nu- merous and excellent. On these, of course, the value of the book depends in large mea- sure, and in nearly all important cases the pictures are made by the half-tone process. The body of the text is a plain descrip- tive narrative based on the objects them- selves. At times it approaches a catalogue in its baldness, and generally it is an at- tempt to describe the objects and such in- cidental resemblances as have been discoy- ered to objects of other provenience. The order of treatment is dictated by the au- thor’s idea of the natural progression of an uncultured people toward artistic expres- sion; first, objects of personal adornment; second, ornamental and decorative art; third, sculpture and painting; and fourth, historical and dynastic monuments. The particular points of interest in this phase of Egyptian art are two—that it is pre- historic, in the sense of predynastic, and that it forms the newly discovered back- ground which explains the otherwise sud- den emergence of Egyptian hieroglyphic writing on stone of a high degree of tech- nical excellence at an early point in the “Ancient Kingdom.” And the discoveries which have given us these almost startling revelations of primitive conditions along the Nile are mainly the work of one man and his pupils, and have been made with- in a decade and a half. Professor Capart agrees in the main with Professor Petrie’s theories, but he does not obtrude any dog- matic views upon the reader. He looks to
Page 23
ett snssnenediaaimmananane De Ria BP
3 : : 4 i H
Feb. 1, 1906] The Nation.
105
a distant future for a solution of the prob- lems which he attempts to state, and to- ward the solution of which he has gather- ed some materials. Dr. Steindorff, who writes upon the ‘Re- ligion of the Ancient Egyptians,’ is profes- sor of Egyptology at the University of Leipzig, where he succeeded the late Prof. George Ebers. His work contains a series of five lectures, which were delivered about a year ago in various places in the United States, under the auspices of the “Com- mittee on Lectures on the History of Re- ligions.” It is not large, nor is it burden- ed with notes and references, though these are not entirely wanting. The treatment is assuredly popular. Footnotes would have given a more scholarly appearance, to be sure, but they would not have rendered the lectures themselves more scholarly. In fact, the lectures are learned, notes or no notes, and they are the product of year-long study and investigation by one of the ablest and most brilliant of the younger school of Egyptologists in Germany. There have been many books on the religion of the Egyp- tians. Some of them have been swamped by details, some have been covered up and obscured by speculations and conjectures, and some have been loaded with things that simply were not true. In the present vol- ume these faults have been avoided, and we have the most reliable, readable, and sane treatment of the religion of Egypt which has appeared. Of course, thousands of things are omitted, but, for a survey of the field and an account of the essential facts, Professor Steindorff’s treatise is preémi- nently satisfactory. He takes us back to the earliest times, and thence traces the development through Egyptian history and out into the non-Egyptian world. Midway he stops to discuss the temples and the ceremonies, magical arts, the life after death, and the graves and methods of burial. The gods are discussed incidental- ly, and the system of belief is portrayed with as much coherence and consistency as it actually possessed.
In Further Ardenne. By the Rev. T. H. Pass- more, M.A. London: J. M. Dent & Co.; New York: E. P. Dutton & Co. 1905. Popular books on the Grand Duchy of Luxembourg are so few that Mr. Passmore has revelled in a little-exploited field, the best part of which he has tramped over with a sympathetic eye for nature and a far from common tolerance of things or people un- English. His results appear in a fine vol- ume illustrated with full-page photographs equally characteristic and excellent, though . the addition of a few of Turner’s marvellous sketches would have corresponded more completely with the spirit of the region which the author seeks to render. An ample historical sketch traces the fortunes of the Duchy through its vicissitudes as a battle- ground of Central Burope to its present state as neutral, inviolable territory; the remaining, and larger, part of the work dealing with description and comment con- cerning people, life, and customs as studied by the author. In the historical portion, breadth of treat- ment brings ou: the successive occupations with a somewhat exuberant wealth of words. For instance, “Feudal Society” (ch. iii.) seems to devote too much space to details
of medigwval life common to Central Burope in general. The eagerness to over-drama- tize historical movements carries the author away into rhetorical outbursts at least as open to attack as those of the “progressive liberals” so freely indulged in (p. 62). On page 29 we read: “Many know-alls at this day know all about the selfishness and self- indulgence of monks, their ‘cowardly flight from temptation,’ and the rest. Mr. Rus- kin’s pedant crudities in ‘Ethics of the Dust’ may be taken as apostolically exponent of this lofty school.” Verily, the oratory of the pulpit is a dangerous habit to give way to in a secular publication. We may add that the victory of Sadowa was not the culmination of a “Seven Days’ War’ (p. 108); Moltke required a trifle more time for his great strategies. When we turn to the real body of this work, the writer, without change of tone. conveys, notwithstanding, a vivid impres- sion of a charming little country hitherto saved from the personally-conducted mob, where the pedestrian can still roam with- out incessant fret from horn, dust, or whiff of motor-car. Any wayfarer who knows Esch-le-Trou, Clervaux, Meysembourg, or Vianden can renew through Mr. Passmore’s pages some of the experiences of restful en- joyment which the throng of travel renders so rare to-day. Similar appreciation of the Luxembourgeois character emphasizes the simple qualities of application, thrift, and devotion to country and customs which seem to secure to the peaceful folk not merely security from foreign aggression or encroachment, but the same kind of pros- perity which the casual tourist observes in Switzerland. And yet, would that Mr. Passmore had put all his experience in simpler phrase. His command of verbal wealth and imagery too often leads him from standards safe astray. How much, for instance, is there of verifiable generalization, how much of mere showy antithesis, in the following (p. 62): “They [the dark ages] contributed maraud- ers, brigands, oppressors, rebels; we pro- vide anarchists, female post-office officials, dynamitards, Hooligans, the man-woman, regicides, sots, and—a commodity unknown to those older ages—vulgarity”? Again, from machicolated walls the besieged hurl- ed “a rain of scented, warmed, or poly- angular objects—those ‘at home’ cards, so to speak, which formed so cheering a fea- ture of young Buropean society’ (p. 64). We may have no reverence for Louls XIV., but our feeling finds imperfect reflection in the description, “‘painting the closing de- cades of the seventeenth century red” (p. 96). A Self-Supporting Home. By Kate V. Saint-Maur. The Macmillan Co, 19065. In this day of crowded cities where rents and aliments are more or less of excessive price, and conveniences are out of pro- portion to discomforts, a practical method of escaping urban life without risking greater difficulties should be hailed with enthusiasm. The plan of a self-supporting home in the country, as depicted by Mrs. Saint-Maur, is intended to assist in this accomplishment with entire ease. It is essentially within the reach of women. It suggests a way by which the sex may emancipate itself from the restrictions of
a city home, without revolutionizing do mestic traditions, and with economy The first twelve chapters of the book deal chronologically with the problems likely to arise in each month of the year Mrs. Saint-Maur describes the methods to be employed. These have been carefully embalmed, for reference, in a note-book whose contents, the outcome of nine years experience, have supplied her with ma terial for her volume, which is really valu able by reason of definite, practical infor mation covering a wide range of topics The raising of fowl and pheasants, breed ing pet cats and rabbits, care of bees cows, orchards, gardens—these are some of the suggested activities which are given adequate treatment, and are discussed in a businesslike manner. The supremely op timistic tone of the book will arouse ap prehensions in some minds. Even a cheer ful person will doubt the possibility of life being made so unfailingly joyous and prosperous. In the author's calculations as to the multiplication of animals and dollars, little allowance is made for failures or accidents. No one without the aid of a corps of assistants would pre sume, in the day of twenty-four hours, to try more than a small number of the many industries prescribed as “necessary additions” to welfare in country living Yet it is clearly shown, in spite of the en thusiastic gloss, that if enough are unde: taken to make the venture pay at all, they must be conducted so conscientiously as to consume a woman's entire time. This is a drawback. Most women would object to the seclusion in the country, away from friends, facilities for social intercourse, and change to a life of quite ag strenuous a tivity along rural lines as that which a town existence demands. The book is less a profitable guide to the “simple life than a logical statement of old facts, with suggestions of many new ones, regarding those agricultural pursuits which may b: followed in a less ambitious way by any woman who has at her command a plot of ground, either in the suburbs of a city or in the more open country. The style of the author is simple and un affected. What she says will sound easy of accomplishment to the veriest novice. There is a convenient index, which enables the reader to find readily the special aub- ject in which he may be interested. The illustrations, in some cases suggestive, in others are quite superfluous BOOKS OF THE WEEK Allen, oe. Pe Seat easions of John Allen. Ch! e ili Oo varfog-Goult 8. A Book of the Rivicra Dut Campbell, BR inaid. The Song of Ages x. < Armateeng $1.25 net A, ol a Bellaire. Century Co. $1.50. Erckman-C atrian. Histoire d'un Homme du Peu le. Henry Frowde. Fisher, Clarence 8. Excavations at Nippur. Part lL. University of Pennsylvania. Geddard, Joseph. Beauty and pmapenaion in Muate Imported by Seribvers. $1.25 ne Hall, A. D. The Book of the Rothamsted Eaperi ments. Dutton. F net. Koowling. A J. Pann nd of we Paul to Christ. ted by Scribners. $3 ne Letters eal” xercises of the Elisabet bau Seno master, John Conybeare. Edited by Fredervk € Conybeare. Henry Frowde. Mallett, W. B. An Introduction to Old English ed beer! Tm. $1.50 net ‘ arden of Nuts. A. oo Brees. 81-38 oon. Mr. Scragge. The Graf. ¢ ate Ce LA Competition. M eee i) the =. Pit Edited by @ cente ata Ne Paree Boston en
Page 24
106, “A more delightful volume of criticism it says the Boston Tran- would be hard to find,”’ script of Stopford Brooke: On Plays of Shakespeare By mail $2.37. Henry Holt & Co. *Qx"e4 8! New York $2.25 net. RECENT PUBLICATIONS Atkinson's Philippine Retil price seutete .»-- $3.00 net ng’s Northera Trails 1.50 net oP ey’s Trasts, Pools and 5 net Corporations Common’s Trade Unionism and Labor Problems. ; President Roosevelt's Rail- road Policy Weir's Creek Painter's Art CINN & COMPANY, BOSTON 2.50 net ) cents 2.00 net STANDARD AUTHORS IN SETS Balzac, Bront#, Bulwer, Carlyle, Cooper, Dick ens, Dumas, De Foe, Eliot, Fielding, Gibbon, (iuizot, Hawthorne, Hugo, Irving, Macaulay, Poe, Reade, Ruskin, Scott, Smollett, Shakespeare, rhackeray, Tolstoi Send for Descriptive Book THOMAS Y. CROWELL & CO., New York | Sally Wirster's Journal The best fiction is tame in compart- son with this delightful rr. writ ten by a real young girl of 1777 for ber girl friend Never was a story of love and war more charmingly told. Washington's young officers live and move in its fascinating pages. Beautifully 1 lustrated postpaid, or at bookstores FERRIS Ve LEACH, Publishers, Philada F. W. CHRISTERN (DYRSEN & PFEIFFER, Successors) 16 West 33d St., opposite the “ Waldorf,” New York Importers of Foreign Books, Agents for the leading Parts Publishers Fauchnitz's British authors, Teub ner’s Greek and Latin Classics Catalogue of stock matied on demand. New books received from Paris and Leipzig as soon as issued SIR GALAHAD + NEW F: By WILLIAM HENRY JOHNSON. $1.50 Hased on the Huguenots’ attempt to settle in Florida. HERBERT B. TURNER & CO., Boston Ten NCE | | Importing Notice m N We beg to announce that we have greatly extended our facilities for the importation of English books, so that we now are equipped to fill orders of this sort with the greatest efficiency and intelligence. Promptness, good service and low prices will rule in this department, as they do in all our business. THE BAKER & TAYLOR CoO. WHOLESALE BOOKSELLERS, 33-37 E. 17th St., Union Sq. North, New York JUST PUBLISHED ‘The Principles of & _ Religious Ceremonial By the Rev. WALTER HOWARD FRERE, M.A., | Of the Community of the Resurrection. Crown 8vo. $1.40 net. (Oxford Library.) LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., New York THE REST ANIMAL STORY RED FOX: RED FOX: By CHARLES G. D. ROBERTS Author of “The Heart of the Ancient Wood,” “The Kindred of the Wii,” ete. THE LOVER'S ..,2)%,,.0m0 | mee , & RU BAIYAT gift "ter eweethearte and a novelty for collectors of Omar. By post 80 cts. SMALL, MAYNARD & COMPANY 31 Arrow Street Cambridge, Maas. The Nation. cre 82, No. 2118 The New Star Chamber and Other Essays By EDCAR LEE MASTERS CONTENTS: The New Star Chamber; Theodore Roosevelt; John Marshall; Tho- mas Jefferson; Alexander Hamilton; Im- plied Powers and Imperialism; Elect the Federal Judges; Despotism Revamped ; The Philippine Conquest; The New Pol- icy; Political Tendencies; Mr. Bryan’s Campaigns; Observations on Democracy. 12mo, boards, 213 pages. $1.00 postpaid A collection of forcibly written essays. . Much sound doctrine upon impe- rialism. —The Dial. Food for thought on subjects imper- fectly understood. . . —Boston Transcript. Nothing has been published in years that goes so far in so little space. —Chicago Daily News. It is a book which thoughtful Ameri- cans ought to read. —Johnstown Democrat. Open-minded readers will find much in it to awaken thought. —Chicago Record-Herald. t; also Book Catalogue sent free on reques' specimen copies of THE PU — AJ nal of Fundamental Democ and Weekly Narrative of History in theMaki — F. Post, Editor. Subseription $1, yearly THE PUBLIC PUBLISHING COMPANY First National Bank Build ag, Chicago Beethoven—Franklin—Rousseau: KRUELL's Portraits, wood-engraved in the high- est manner of the art and printed on Japan paper, size 9x!1 icches, market price Twenty Dollars each, now offered at half rate to subscribers on the books of the Nation, and sent, carriage free, on | receipt of Ten Dollars.— Address Pvs.tisner or Tas Nation. New York | THE MUSES LIBRARY List on application. NEW YORK 50 cents per volume. Pr. DUTTON & CO. «- = EFINITE OF FERS OF BOOKS and Pertodicals solicited by A. 5, CLARK, Peekskill, N. Y. "ALUABLE REFERENCE BOO: HANDBOOK OF UNITED STATES POLITICAL HISTORY By MALCOLM TOWNSEND $1.60 net, postpaid $1.75 LOTHROP, LEE & SHEPARD CO., Poston VALUABLE BECAUSE TRUE YOUNG JAPAN “iciinti® J. B. LIPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia SELECTIONS from the Bnei F of JOHN Authortees Edition by Lucy and Tracy Roprnson. », $2.50 net. Postage 14 cents JOuN LANE CO. The Bodley Head, N. Y. of the Cross.’ Durkish invasion of 1682 to 1683. ‘Romantic, dramatic, masterly work by a masterly writer.’'— New poetic and eee ork Globe A New Novel by the author of ‘Quo Vadis,’’ ON THE FIELD OF GLORY By HENRYK SIENKIEWICZ Translated from the Polish by Jeremiah Curtin. [ his important work is the only one written by this renowned author since the year 1900, when he completed ‘‘ Knights [he scenes are laid in Poland and the period is the rei Sienkiewicz has woven displayed his great genius more strikingly a oonbestel humao by turn, it isa | zn of the famous Kin romance of great ‘A brilliant romance, full of strong yy oo! drawing and full of love."’—Jeannetre L. Gitper, Editor of the Critic, etc. 12mo, Cloth, $1.50 ohn Sobieski, just before the brilliancy, and in no book has he Published by LITTLE, BROWN & CO., BOSTON