The Nation 1906-01-18: Vol 82 Iss 2116

Page 1

The Natian. Aan, ~ rd WT A204 14,5 —_ VOL. LXXXII—NO. 2116. THURSDAY, JANUARY 18, 1906, PRICE TEN CENTS. GENERAL LIBRARY; UNIV. OF MIC#, JAN 19 1906 OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS American Branch IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENTS FOR 1906 NOW READY SHAKESPEARE — Facsimile Reproductions of the Portions of Shakespeare Not Included in the First Folio Each volume has been prioted by the collotype process from the finest accessible copy of the original issue. and, except in point of size, is of similar character to the collotype reproduction of the Shakespeare First Folio which the delegates published in 14n This series of reproductions has been executed under the superintendence of Mr. Sidney Lee, who has embodied in full introductions the lates: results of his researches regarding the bibliographical history of each of the four volumes of Shakespeare's poems and of the play of Pericles The number of copies printed, of which only a portion now remaios unsold, is limited to 1,250, of which 2) are for America. All copies are numbered, and Venus and Adonis, the first volume of each set, is signed by Mr, Lee Style A, In five volumes, bound in vellum - - $50.00 Style C. Ina single volume, rough calf $35.00 Style B. In five volumes, bound in boards 35,00 Style D. Ina single volume, boards BO NOW COMPLETE THE LETTERS OF HORACE WALPOLE Fourth Earl of Oxford. Chronologically arranged and edited by Mrs, Paget Toyxeer. Contains 400 ‘vtters not included in the Latest Edition of the Collected Letters, 100 of which have never before been printed. With additional Notes, full Avalytical Index, 50 Photogravure Illustrations and 3 Facsimiles of Original! Letters. Complete in 16 volumes I. Demy 8vo. Special Limited Edition, printed upon hand made paper, 16 volumes Bound in boards, with paper labels, $175.00 net, per set Bound in full straight-grained genuine morocco, $225.00 net, per set Crown 60. Oxford India Paper Edition, in 8 doubl+ volumes, cloth, gilt edges, $5.75 net. each, or $46.00 nef, per set Ill, Crown 8vo. Ordinary Paper Edition in 16 volumes. cloth, gilt top, $2.00 net, each, or $32.00 net, per set THE, OXFORD HISTORY OF MUSIC General Editor, W. H. Hapow ; Vols. Land II by H. E. Woo.iprines ; Vo!. IIT by Sir C. H. Parry ; Vol. IV by J. A. Futter Marr ann; Vol. V by W . H. Hapow; Vol. VI by E. Daywrevrurr, Now complete in 8vo volumes, with copious musical illustrations, price, $5.00 per volume. or $30.00 the set The six volumes embrace the History of Music from the beginning of the fourth to the middle of the nineteenth century; extending its rang: in certain directions, as late as to the death of Verdi. JOHNSON’S LIVES OF THE POETS Edited by the late Georce Birkeeck Hitt, with a brief Memoir of Dr, Hill by his nephew, Haro.p Spencer Scorr, and a full Index In three volumes, medium 8vo; half roan $i0 50. These volumes complete the cycle of works connected with the writings of Dr. Johnson, which was promised by Dr. Birkbeck Hill in the Preface to his edition of Bosweli’s Life. He there right!y described the editing of Lives of the Poets as a still more arduous task even tha: that of Boswell’s great book; but he worke! at it unflinchingly to the very end of his life, and left it finished in ita main outlines, awaiting only the general supervision and final touches which a posthumous work must always require. All lovers of Johnson's memory owe a deep debt of gratitude to Mr. H, Spexcer Scort, Dr. Birkbeck Hill’s nephew, who, with truly filial affection, undertook the heavy task of revising the whole mass of references, and of reading, not once oc twice unly, the entire proots of the book at every stage. THE PLAYS AND POEMS OF ROBERT GREENE Edited by Pror. Cuavrtron Couns, uniform with the Clarendon Press editions of Kyd (edited by Mr. Boas) and Lyly (edited by Mr. Bond In two volumes, &vo, cloth, $6.00. This edition is the result of great labor. In the Life of Greene, the editor has incorporated much new information, collected by persona! research in Norfolk ana elsewhere. THE POETICAL WORKS OF WM. BLAKE Edited by Jon~ Sampsox, Demy 8vo. $3.5) Mr. Sampson has spared no pains to produce a really deflaitive edition containing everything that Blake wrote in metrical! form Also a daintily printed edition of the Lyrical Poems of William Blake with a preface by Professor Walter Raleigh, Price Wx CRIMINAL RESPONSIBILITY By Caara.es Mercier, M.B,, F.R.C.P., F_R.C.S8,, Lecturer on Insanity at the Westminster Hospital Medical School and at the Medical School of the . Royal Free Hospital. 8vo, cloth, $2.50 NEW LARGE TYPE SHAKESPEARE Complete Works. Edited by W. J, Craic, M.A. With portrait and a Glossary. Crown 8vo, cloth, $1. Oxford India paper edition, cloth, $2.4; Vene morocco, $3.75; Persian morocev, $4.0. Oxford India paper edition, with illustrations from the Boydell Gallery, cloth, $3.00. Venetian morocco, padded, $5.00 a For sale by all booksellers—Send for catalogue. OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS—AMERICAN BRANCH, 91-95 Fifth Avenue, New York. WO

Page 2

The Nation. [Vol. 82, No, 2116 ll Tt T : Lhe Nation. 4 WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science and Art. FOUNDED IN 1865. Entered at the New York City Post Office as second-class mail matter | CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. Tux Were eece - & EprrorntaL ARTICLES Congress on Roosevelt's Hands ° 46 The President and the Bosses , - 46 One Way Out of the Phillppines........... 47 Dariuae Green'’a Progemy.........scceeeeceee 48 Paying the Doctor ....ccccccccweceeceeeees 48 The Function of an Endowed Press ecocececee 49 BPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE: The Modern Language Association of Amer- a a eseces ececccsese ) The American Ex ‘onomic " Association at Bal- SEITD ccvceccoceeeeceeeseooceesesese coon CORRESPONDENCE Our Paulty Monetary System.............+- 52 The Oanal and the Oo6t. ....ccccccccnceeece 53 NOTED, ....cccccccsccccccrs cccccessosecorsecvocccece 53 Boox Revisws Sir Wemyss Reld’s Memoirs............++: 56 The Russian Crigis. .... 66. ccecceweeeeeeenes 67 Swinburne peccerceeceeseseeseooesoees 658 WTS GF MACETO ccccccccccccccccccecccocss se Bidmey LABS .cccccccccccccccccccccccceces th) eee AECSUEE cccoccnceeecessgcoesseeoe cee 61 Australian Life in Town "and ‘Country cevce 61 Napoleon's Notes on English History...... - & BOOKS OF THR WEEE.......-.ccee cocceeeerccceceveves 62 ‘ TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three dollara per year in advance, postpaid, in any part of the Untted Sta‘es or Canada; to for- eign countries comprised in the Postal Union, $4 The date when the subscription expires is on the address label of each paper, the chiunge of which foa subsequent date becomes a recet;t for aremtt- tance. No other receipt ts sent unless requested, Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter, or by check, express order or Postal Order payable to “ Publisher of The Nation.” When a change af address ia desired, both the id and new addresses should be given tddress THE NATION, Box 794, New York. Publication Office, 208 Broadway. TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Fifteen cents per agate line, each insertion; 14 lines to the inch Twenty per cent, advance for choice of page or top of column A column, page, eth A puge idvertisements $20 each insertion; with choice of $0 cach insertion; muat be front cover page, $80. acceptable in every reapect Copy recetved until Tuesday, 5 P. M DISCOUNTS. Time 4 insertions 4 per cent. 4 ‘ “ 18 o eeces ; 1334 un ‘ ; oe pas 1v : sevccecees $3 bed 52 a ; vo» 8S S Amount 8100 within a yoar eee sees. 10 per cont, 20 1% “ 600 “ e coccccece 15 = 750 . 7 +e 0 = 1,000 e vas : “6 ped 1,600 = ses eee 80 bod 2.000 aes = SBMS . THERE NATION ta sent free to those who adver- tise in U aa long as advertisement continues. *,* Copies of the Nariow may be procured in Paris at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de l'Opéra; in London of B. F. Stevens & Brown, Trafaigar Square, Charing Cross. Educational MASSACHUSETTS, Boston. OSTON UNIVERSITY Law School. New features. Address the Dean. M. M. BrieELow. Pattape para, Chestnut Hill BOARDING AND DAY Mrs. Chapman and Aico. For Miss Jones GIRLS. Thorough College Preparatory and Finishing Courses, with special opportunities for culture. Number of pupilslimited. Classes small, insur- ing individual attention. Large, comfortable house with pleasant grounds. Tennis, basketball, and skating. ROCK RIDCE SCHOOL For Beys. Location high and dry. Laboratories. Sho for Mechanic Arta. Strong teachers. Earnest boys. new gymnasium with swimming pool. Fits for College Scientific School and business. L[llustrated pamphiet sent free. Please address Dr. G. R. WHITE, Principal, Wellesley Hills, Mass. Important Announcement Adams’s Lysias — Selected Speeches Edited by Charles Darwin Adams, Ph.D., Lawrence Professor of Greek, Dartmouth College. $1.50 This volume will serve as an introduction to Attic oratory. and will open the way for the study of Demosthenes, To each speech there is added a chapter of detailed criticism of its argument and style. and io the =. dix there is a discussion of the princip f periodic prose style and a summary of rhe- torical terminology. Special attention is given to the tenses, to the use of preposi- tions, and to the force of certain particles. School Agencies HWE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENC/ES Fvenerr 0. Fisk & Co.. Proprietors. 4 Ashburton P1., Boston; 1505 Pa. Ave., Washington; 156 Fifth Ave., New York; 414 Cent. Bid., Minneapolis; 401 Cooper Bidz., Denver; 1200 Williams Ave., Port'and; 208 Mich. Bivd., Chicago; 525 Stimson BIk., Loa Angeles; 3: 3 Rookery Bik., Spokane; 717 Market ¢t., San Fran- claco, LBANY TEACHERS AGENCY, A 81 Chapel St., Albany, N. Y.—Provides schools of all ades with competent teachers. Assists teach- ers in obtaining positions. Hagian P. Frencu, Proprietor. CHERMERHURN’S Teachers’ Agency. Teachers—Schools— Tutors—Governess— Property. x Tel. 6129 18th. Joun C. Rockwe1t, Mgr., 3 E. 14th St., N. Y. C. FECENT PUBLICATIONS Atkinson’s Philippine Islands . Long’s Northera Trails Ripley’s Trusts, Pools and Corporations Retvil price oe net 1.50 net 2.15 net Common’s Trade Unionism and Labor Problems........ 2.50 President Roosevelt's Rail- road Policy Weir’s Greek Painter's Art. 3.00 net CINN & COMPANY, BOSTON SHAKESPEARE First Folio Edition Edited by Peorter-Clarke. Printed by DeVinne VOLUMES NOW READY: “Midsummer Night's Dreame,” “ Love’s Labour's Lost.” “«omedie of Er- rors,” , Merchant | of Venice,” “Macbeth.” “ Julius Cosar,” “ Hamlet,” “King Lear.” Price, in cloth, 75 cents per volume ; limp leather, $1.00 per volume, postpald Thomas Y. Crowell] & Co., New York net *From the Autobiography. AMERICAN BOOK COMPANY New York Cincinnati Chicago Boston LIBRARY SERVICE We aim to serve librarians with the greatest efficiency. We have (1.) Competent and thoroughly equipped book men. 2.) The largest miscellaneous book stock in New York City. 3.) A valuable line of order lists —as follows— A. Monthly Bulletin of the Lat- est and Best Selling Books, B. Standard Library Catalogue. Cc. Clearance Catalogue. Do You Cet These? Sent Free. THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO. WHOLESALE BOOKSELLERS, 33-37 E. 17th St., Union Sq, North, New York Franklin’s Boyhood Franklin's Let- ters on War and Peace, and his Plan for Western Colonies are just added to the OLD SOUTH LEAFLETS Nos. 161-163 No. 9, The Plan of Union, 1754, is an- other Franklin Leaflet. Send for complete lists. Price, 5 cents a copy. DIRECTORS OF OLD SOUTH WORK Old Sou.h Meeting House WASHINGTON STREET, BOSTON Sally Wrster's Journal The best fiction is tame in compart- son with this delightful ” urnal, writ- ten by a real young girl of 1 for her girl friend. Never was a story of love and war more er | told. Washington's young officers live move in its ll ~ ed il- lustrated. postpal bookstor & LEAC n° "publishers. "Philada. Then ree DO YOU ADVERTISE? : «:: ble assistance towards effective results from our book, ge | THEORY “OF ADVERTISING. Price, postpaid, $2.15. Send for it to-day. SMALL, MAYNARD & COMPANY 31 Arrow Street Cambridge, Mass, SIR GALAHAD + NEW FRANCE BY WILLIAM HENRY JOHNSON $1.50 BASED ON THE HUGUBNOTS AT. TEMPT TO SETTLE IN FLORIDA. HERBERT B. TURNER & CO, Boston. A VALUABLE REFERENUCB BROOK HANDBOOK OF oaTre STATES POLITICAL HISTORY my MPL COUE ERY BEND LOTH & PARD CO., Boston KATE DOUGLAS WIGGIN’S ROSE 0’ THE RIVER By the Author of «+ Rebecca ’’ Financial. We bay one | ey | of exc LETTe make cable ‘ers of money => ae, Rs Austraita, and South x, .—*- collections and iss Com CREDIT Trave Howe’ and.”ianue Commercial ‘and the world. International Cheques, Certificates of Deposit. BROWN BROTHERS & CO., * ‘NO, 6@ WALL STREET, NEW YORK.

Page 3

Jan. 18, 1906] The Nation. School Trustees, Principals, Teachers, And others interested, are invited to consider the advantages offered by the /Vation as an advertising medium. School advertisements are printed in a uniform typography, with the ad- dress in the first line, classification being made by States, alphabetically, unless especially ordered displayed on other pages. The asin, in its special field of political and literary criticism, is un- like any other periodical, American or foreign. About 10,000 cop.es are circulated weekly, but these figures do not accurately represent the num- ber of its readers. It is taken by reading clubs and literary associations in a large number of places, and may be found on file in every iibrary of importance in the country. There are probably few weekly periodicals whose columns offer so favorable an opportunity for reaching an audience interested in educational matters. Advertising rates, 15 cents a line each insertion, with the following dis- counts: 5 per cent, on 4 insertions, 10 per cent. on 8 insertions, 12% per cent. On 13 insertions, 15 per cent. on 26 insertions, 20 per cent. on 39 in- sertions, 25 per cent. on §2 insertions. The Nation is sent free while ad- vertisement continues. Orders may be forwarded through any responsible advertising agency, or directly to Tue Nation, 208 Broadway, N. Y. The Words of Garrison: A centennial selection (1805-1905) of chi wracteris- | tic sentiments from the writings of William Lloyd | Garrison, with a Biograph- ical Sketch, a Select List of Portraits, a Select Bib- liography, and a frontispiece Portrait. a Chronology, A multum in parvo for | reading and for reference. For sale by all booksellers, or by the publishers, Hough- ton, Mifflin & Co., $1.25 net. Boston. Price, ( POETS and POETRY of the | NINETEENTH CENTURY Edited by A. H. MILES A comprehensive series of specimens of rep- resentative verse of the century, with asketch of each poet. 6x4!4 inches; Red Cloth, Net, 50 Cents; Red Lambskin, Net, $1.00 1 Grate to Coleridge. 2—Southey to Shel ley. —Keats to Lytton. 4—Tennyson_ to Cflou 5—Kingsley to Thompson. 6—WII- iam } a. to Buchanan. Six others in preparation. E. P. Dutton & Company 31 West Twenty-third St., New York | F. W. CHRISTERN (DYRSEN & PFEIFFER, Successors) 16 West 33d 8t., opposite the “ Waldorf,” New York Importers of Foreign Books, Agents for the leading Paris Publishers. Tauchnitz’s British authors. Teub ner’s Greek and Latin Classics. Catalogue of stock matied on demand. New books received from Paris and Leipzig as soon as issued. EFINITE OF FERS OF .BOOKS and Periodicals solicited b A. 5. CLARK, Peekskill, N. Y. THE JOURNAL or Political Economy A New Departure TO BE ISSUED MONTHLY Beginning with Volume XVI, January, 1%, Tux JOURNAL OF POLITICaL Economy, heretofore a quarteriy, Will be issued as & monthly, ten bum bers a year, becoming the only American econo mic mouthiy. Subscription to Remain $3.00; Singie Numbers $0.35. Wile puvucation mouthly involves increase! expendi.ure, by adVvauce iD ‘eee ru aly weof the Journai is contempiated. The price of single numbers 18 reduced frum $1.00 to 8.55. Ax imsues of the Jou: nai are stsicty limited, Lhe editors cannot i.sure libraries and others, Who du Bot subscribe at once, complete fies lo obtain livrary subscriptions at this time and avoid em barrassment in the Lulure a special offer is be ing made vo libraries. For vetais address below Contents ot the January Number lI. BALLWAY BATas As PRUTHECTIVe TARIFFS Huge MK. Meyer il EMPLOY Me aT OF WOMEN IN INDUSTRIES ophonisbe I. Kreekinridge } a | Edith Abbott lll. NOTES i ACADEMIO LIBERTY J. Laurence Laughilo KRaecandd Iiianvie Dacisions Kewanabin: INJUACTIONS IssUED 1h THE Lvl Kok OF DOT RIA RS hroust Freund AMEKI as hownomi John \u ME&KIING OF 10K AsouliaTION lV BOUR KRVIbWS Vv. NEW PUBLICATIONS nings ADVISORY EDITORS LYMAN J. GAGE, ate Secretary of the Treasury B, BENJ, ANDKEWS, Chancellor Univ. of Nebraska WwW. W. FOLWELL. Professor Univ. of Mina A. N. KRAER, Director of Statistics, Norway. ADOLF ©. aaah - _ Re essor, Univ, of Oallf, PAUL LEROY ‘BE AULIED, ebalor, France. DAVID KINLE x" Professor, Univ. of LUlinols. MOFFES P — ALKON|. puty, Rome, Italy. ALFRED M AnSitAL L, SHYT University, England OARROLL D. WH President Clark College. HORACE Wate Late Kd. N. Y¥. Bvening Post. WM. A. SCOTT, rote ssor, Univ. of Wisconsin JAMES H, EO KEL late ; “er of Currency EMILE LEV — K, Metber Institute, CHARLES R CRA ~~ a Chicago. EAGEN VON * "HL IPPOVICH, Univ. of Vienna France Austria-Hungary The University of Chicago Press DEPARTMENT 21 CHICAGO AND NEW YORK OTTO HARRASSUWITZ, Leipzig. LIBRARY ‘(ARCH Topics of all kinds and 3 any language looked - AL the » See and }. a libraries for scholars, w . t a and eS made. Pr — ~% ~ vision of manuscript. Highest anivers r' h- brary references. MISS . BH. BUCKINGHAM, 96 Chestnut Street, Boston, Mass in gold. 75 cents. To receive the current numbers in a convenient (temporary) form. cloth, with THE NATION stamped on the side Holds about one volume. and neatly adjusted. Sent, postpaid, on receipt of Substantially made, bound in Papers easily

Page 4

[Vol. 82, No. 2116 SHINTO. (the Way of the Gods.) By W. G. ASTON, C.M.G., D.Lit. Author of “A Grammar of the Japanese Spoken Language,’’ “The Nihongi”’ (translation,) etc. With 14 Illustrations, reproduced from Japanese Wood Engravings. $2.00 met. ly a repertory of the more significant facts of Shinto thé of Japan before the introduction of Chinese learning and hapter dealing with the later history of Shinto, its wlern sects and its present position ana pros This book is chief d Native religion Buddhism rhere ts 4, val « relations with Buddh its cts Mrs. Fitzherbert and GeorgelV. By W, H. WILKINS, M.A., F.S.A., Author of “The Love of an Uncrowned Queen,” etc. Portraits and Other Illustrations. 8vo, 476 pages, $ Postage 25 cents extra. With 57 $5.00 net such ts this An English royal romance, retold with fulness and ‘new lights’ n The v imes are by far the most interesting of the gossipy works in . Mr. Wilkins has sought to resuscitate for us the Court life of England 1” Georgian era Dai hrov ¢ “oo nd pyright edition nearly ready. VEW BOOK BY MXR. LANG New Collected Rhymes By ANDREW LANG Crown Svo, $1.25 net. Cricket Rhymes—Critical Folk Songs— Ballads »yal Lyrics Poems Dedicatory—L« Jubiies CONTENTS of Life, Art, and Literature A Staff Officer’s Scrap-Book During the Russo-Japanese War By Lieut.-General Sir IAN HAMILTON, K.C.B. With Illustrations, maps and plans. 8vo, 372 pages. $4.50 net. 5 by far the most Interesting book on the Russo-Japanese War that has yet appeared from the pen of an eye-witness.””— The Times, London. The Great Plateau Being an Account of Exploration in Central Tibet, 1903, and of the Gartok Expedition, 1904-19095. By Captain C. G. RAW- LING, Somerset Light Infantry. 8vo. Pp. xii-318. With 57 Illustrations from photographs taken by the Author, and 2 Maps. $5.00. *,* The first expedition penetrated into the interior of the unin- habited and barren regions of the Northern Desert at a time when Tibet was rigidly closed to foreigners, The second led through the rich and thickly populated valleys of the Brahmaputra, and was made with the cognizance and permission of the Lhasa Gove: nment, though only ren- dered possible by the notable success of Sir Francis Younghusband’s mission, JUST PUBLISHED Life of Sir John T. Gilbert LL.D., F.S.A., Irish Historian and Archivist, Vice-President of the Royal Irish Academy, Secretary of the Public Record Office of Ireland. By His Wife, ROSA MULHOLLAND GILBERT. With 2 Portraits and 4 other Illustrations 8vo, $5.00. SIR JOHN T. GILBERT was, during his whole life, devoted to h storical research, with the result that a‘l his work is based on docu- mentary evidence throwing light on obscure passages of his country's history, The biography. which contains the record of fifty years of un- flagging work in the service of Ireland, traces his career from a boyhood already absorbed in study of the past, to a manhood labouring strenu- ously in the cause of truth. as appears most obviously in his ‘* His- tory of the Confederation and the War in Ireland, 1641-52."" LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., 91 and 93 Fifth Avenue, New York THE LIFE OF JAMES ANTHONY FROUDE A brilliant piece of biography by one « ne of the books of the year tainly stand as o f letters.”’— London Daily News ntemporary men « It will ce ic mplished of ex THE CITY: The Hope of Democracy Boston Tri meacripl be extremely stimulating reading,”’ *It will be found t St, Paul Dispatch incere treatment of an urgent subject.’ A HISTORY OF EGYPT mt valuable and interesting work It gives us what. A mm im possible to get ist not fail to until a sane idea of the prehistoric period and of the first dynasties, mention the wealth of illustrations excellently selected."*—The Independent. By HERBERT PAUL Illustrated, $4.00 net most f the By FREDERIC C. HOWE $1.50 net. 13 cents postage ‘A sane and By JAMES H. BREASTED Professor of Egyptology and Oriental History at the University of Chicago Illus., $5.00 net. Postage 36 cts. very lately, it was New Volume in LIBRARY OF ART biographies Art Interchange $2.00 net An aimirable series of artistic Each volume Illustrated. By M. STURGE HENDERSON The Independent CONSTABLE An admirable short biography. By G. F. HILL ’ Tribune PISANELLO A little treasure-house of needed information.” —N, } By BASIL DE SELINCOURT sare well seasoned.’ London Times GIOTTO Patient, acholarly. sound His view New Volumes in DRAWINGS OF GREAT MASTERS This series beautifully reproduces the best work of the great masters. Each volume $2.50 MENZEL With a critical introduction by Professor HANS W. SINGER ‘His drawings in this volume are sure to be made the subject of muc sh study and discussion.”"—V. Y. Tribune. SWAN With a critical introduction by A. F. BALDRY * The quality of the reproductions is quite wonderful.” Rvening Post. With a critical introduction by F, MARTIN WOOD “The critical comment by F. Martin Wood adds much to the value of the work,"’— Bultimore Sun, ROSETTI CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS, New York

Page 5

The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, JANUARY 18, 1906. The Week. Senator Hale’s frank admission in the Senate on Monday that he wished the President had sent no delegates to the Morocco Conference, suggests fresh in- quiry what its work is to be. It is to concern itself with the internal reforms needed in that country. It is to discuss, first of all, the organization of the po- lice and the suppression of the contra- band trade in arms. Next in order is the reform of the nation’s finances, which calls for the establishment of a state bank, improved methods of col- lecting duties, and the creation of new revenues. Then comes the “outlining of certain principles destined to safeguard the economic liberty of Morocco.” In addition, there is on the programme the special question of the policing of the Moroccan and Tunisian boundary and the controlling of the traffic in arms across it, which naturally concerns France and Morocco exclusively. Just which of the nations shall undertake this work of reorganization will, of course, be the knotty point in the dis- cussions. Old residents of Morocco are firmly of the opinion that, however sym- pathetic the Sultan may be, the Moroc- cans themselves cannot be depended on to carry out the reforms. What is need- ed is such an economic upbuilding as that which has gone on in Egypt under Lord Cromer—an administration under which peace and order shall be perma- nent, and every inhabitant profit to the fullest extent by the national outlay. At the same time, the Sultan’s indepen- dence is not to be assailed, and the re- organization of the country is to be be- yond all else carried on by peaceful methods. The fanaticism of the inhabi- tants and their intense hatred of for- eigners will call for quite as much tact and wisdom in the actual carrying out of the reforms as Lord Cromer has dis- played in Egypt. The mere statement of the problems to be considered must increase the wonder of Senators that the United States should be participating in the Algeciras Conference. If we really have any busi- ness in settling the national affairs of Morocco, we must be prepared next to go to work in Crete and Macedonia. and to take part in any future coercion of the Sultan of Turkey. Our trade rela- tions with Morocco are so slight as not to call for a separate item in the month- ly and yearly summary of our foreign commerce, being grouped under “All other Africa,” which is credited with ex- ports of only $33,813 for the eleven months of 1905 ending with November, and imports of $478,140 during the same period. It was a Republican Congressman, Mr. McCall of Massachusetts, who on Fri- day exposed in the House the hollow- ness of the pretence that the tariff would one day be “revised by its friends.”” “If the tariff cannot be re- vised when two-thirds of the member- ship of both houses is Republican, when,” he asked, “is revision to come?” He went on to make the prediction, im- plied in the lettér of Gov. Guild of Mas- sachusetts to President Roosevelt, that if the Republicans prove unequal to the work, the country will put the Demo- crats in power to do it. But there is one form of tariff revision for which the Republicans are reported ready—re- yision upwards. They cannot take off 10 per cent. to relieve Americans, but they can clap on 25 per cent. to fight Germans, and make the plight of Amer- icans worse than before. In tariff wars both combatants are certain to lose, yet it is upon a tariff war with Germany that Congress is now preparing light- heartedly to enter. In answer to the protest of our alarmed exporters that our stupid tariff policy endangers their business with Germany, it is proposed to make it more stupid, and, if possible, cut off business with Germany alto- gether. All this from the party of en- lightenment, at the very moment that the policy of tariff retaliation is being trampled under foot in England! The postmastership of Podunk is, after all, the vital question before Con- gress to-day. A few private citizens, whose desires are unworthy of consid- eration, seem to be anxious about the construction of the Panama Canal, about railway rate regulation, the Philippine tariff, revision of the Dingley sched- ules, and Statehood; but real statesmen know that the progress of the country depends upon the distribution of pap. Thus, Representatives Overstreet of In- diana and Denby of Michigan have —in the expressive language of trans- cendental politics—‘gone up in the air’ because they could not “land” their men. Two of the Missouri delegation have openly joined the Republican in- surgents against the Statehood bill, and others threaten to follow—not because they care a rap about Statehood one way or the other. The noble principle for which they stand is that the Missouri postmasterships belong to them. For that cause they will pour out their life- blood and kill every bill that is dear to the President or the Speaker. Repre- sentatives are no fools. They see that if they cannot settle questions of pat ronage, statesmanship is a hollow sham. The only thing left for a Congressman is to frame laws, prepare arguments, and discharge his duties as member of committees. But that is beneath the dignity of the Representative of a great commonwealth—mere work for office- boys and private secretaries. No man of parts will fritter away his talents over legislation when he should devote them to fighting for jobs for his henchmen The government at Washington must and shall be preserved. As was expected, the bill for consular reform has been reported by the Senate Committee on Foreign Relations with nearly all the reform knocked out of it A system of appointment and promotion by merit is too strong meat for the weak Senatorial stomach. What it needs is pap—the pap of patronage simply loathe the idea that consuls Senators should be originally selected for capacity and promoted for efficiency. The adop tion of such a plan would be a terrible blow to party “workers,” and would even impair Senatorial grandeur. Conse- quently, the bill which Secretary Root advocated as a means of taking the con sular service out of politics, and mak ing it responsive to the needs and de mands of American business men, nas been reported in a sadly mangled con dition. Consuls are to be named, trans ferred and promoted “as at present” that is, by political favor. The Senate is willing, however, that they should be classified and their salaries increased, involving, we suppose, the abolition of the fee system. But the thoroughgoing reform pressed by the State Department the Senate will none of. Here is an ex- cellent opportunity for the President to “do it anyhow.”” He would be entirely justified in making rules for the first ap pointment and subsequent promotion of consuls purely in accordance with the merit system. His friends have asserted from time to time that he would take such a step. If the Senate persists in treating the consular service as spoils, American commercial interests will turn to the President with redoubled appeals to rescue it. Since the Washington air is surcharg ed with rumors of American expeditions to be landed at Canton or Shanghai, San Domingo or mayhap Venezuela the report of the army Genera’ Staff in regard to our lack of transports is very enlightening. It is published by Senator Gallinger ag part of his argument for the ship-subsidy bill, thus showing that the General Staff has civilian uses as

Page 6

bed well as military. Over against the grim threats a week ago of landing Gen. Fun- ston and two brigades in China in the twinkling of an eye, the General Staff admits frankly that to move a force cor- responding to our present military estab- require practically all lishment ‘“‘would the American shipping of suitable char- Atlantic waters, and more than acter in the entire tonnage in Pacific waters.” Most Americans, we fancy, will regard this lack of army transports as far from an undesirable state of affairs. if it will only keep the present Administration from plunging into oversea adventures, it is a condition to be tolerated. At least, it should make the Government see how impossible would be any of- fensive war with a great Power. Even if Senator Gallinger and the other sub- idy men could, by enriching private hip-owners, create a great fleet of avail- able transports, the question of coaling, provisioning, and landing abroad would still be impossible of solution, on a large ‘ ale Gov. Higgins’s reasons for fearing an investigation of the various departments of his Administration, especially Insur- ince and Banking, are painfully obvi- ous. Nobody is in the least deceived by the shallow pretext that the Legisla- ture has no legal right to investigate. Such paltry quibbling is unworthy of a high-school debating society. There is one reason and only one why the Gov- ernor of New York dreads publicity: He knows one else knows, that his two personal cronies and political upporters, Hendricks and Kilburn, are either dishonest or grossly incompetent. Thelt in office is a _ public scandal and offence; but they command o much influence that Higgins dares not touch them till their terms run out. The Fiseal Supervisor of Charities, H. Hi. Bender, is resorting to every techni- in order to escape the conse- quences of his violation of the civil-ser- but the Governor is too tim- orous to move against him. The Cor- poration Tax Bureau rests under specific of venality, but the Governor wants to keep the Legislature from in- terfering. The shocking revelations se- cured by the Armstrong committee have roused suspicion against the whole Administration—notably the Rallroad Commission; yet the Governor dreads to clean house or to have any one do it for He rather have the State xovernment stew In ita own corruption. as every presence cality vice laws; charges him would rhe rejoicing of this country over the unprecedented steel exports in the month of December would mean more if we knew the prices at which these consign- ments of metal were disposed of abroad. It is not such a remarkable achievement ell gooda of any kind, even in the if one is willing to to largest quantities, , The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2116 put the price low enough, and some other customer stands ready to bear whatever loss may accrue. How, as a matter of fact, did the purchasers of these rails and billets and structural materials fare by comparison with American consumers? It is not known exactly, but the details of many similar transactions are public property. Tes- tifying before the Merchant Marine Commission a year and a half ago, for instance, James C. Wallace, then vice- president and since president of the American Shipbuilding Company, said: “Recently one of our largest steel mills sold abroad 100,000 tons of steel plate. They delivered it, I understand, at Belfast at $24 a ton. That would practically mean, with ocean rates as they are, $22 a ton at tidewater. They are charging us to-day at Pittsburg $32 a ton.” If such a difference existed with ref- erence to the 52,000 tons shipped from Eastern ports alone in December—leav- ing out all consignments from South- ern and Pacific Coast points, it meant a discount of approximately a half-million dollars in a single month to the foreign purchaser. But, of course, all the ex- cess price paid by the home consumer goes straight to the pockets of honest American workingmen, and they, and not the Trust, would suffer were Con- gress to equalize this by a change in the tariff. The late President Harper of Chicago University habitually deprecated the fame he had attained as a money-getter, and would have chosen to be remem- bered by the innovations he framed in university administration and teaching. It was these that fairly gave him his nickname, “the business president.” Ef- ficiency was his watchword long before it was Lord Rosebery’s; and most of his peculiar policies were based on the con- viction that our traditional methods of higher education are backward and time-wasting. Thus, at the outset he abolished the long vacations, .or, rather, made them optional with students and professors, continuing the University terms throughout the calendar year. This permitted the diligent student to shorten his course, the provident in- structor to accumulate vacations beyond the regulation three months, and requir- ed the occasional recruiting of the facul- ty by temporary (quarter-year) appoint- ments from outside. All these changes were in the direction of flexibility. Again, when it was discovered that the University of Chicago lacked college life and spirit, college life and spirit were straightway improvised, or at least en- couraged, by the appointment of a fam- ous athlete to the faculty, and later by the building of dormitories. No detail of university life escaped President Har- per. He urged the duty of frequent pub- lication and a discreet publicity upon his professors, as he did that of enthus- iasm upon his students. To slow meth- ods of incubation he was temperament- ally averse, whether it were a case of a scholastic magnum opus or of alluring the minor colleges and universities of the Middle West into feudal relations with the University of Chicago. When one considers the actual accomplishment of his fourteen years’ tenure, it must be admitted that rarely has so much thought and energy been thrown in an equal time into a similar work. The colleges are at last making ath- letic reform hum. At Harvard the over- seers have forbidden football to be played until the rules are changed to their satisfaction; Yale is said to be willing to desert the old Rules Com- mittee; at Union, football has been abol- ished, and, strange to say, by vote of the students; the University of Wiscon- sin has faced the athletic problem broadly by instructing its delegates to the Western conference to vote for the suspension of intercollegiate contests. Everything indicates that the agitation is serious, and that this time some- thing will be done. Meanwhile, it is wise to distinguish between athletic abuses that are a result of American conditions in general, and those that per- tain to any particular branch of sport. The much-advertised reform of football should be regarded as merely a begin- ning of a new dispensation in college sport generally. It might, theoretical- ly, be possible to impose upon inter- locked rushlines the leisurely affability of so many “floorwalkers,” and yet the inflated expenditure, the overcrowding, the generally exaggerated excitement attending the games would persist. The remedy, for the present, lies in a re- duction of intercollegiate games to the minimum, and in encouraging sports within the colleges. By this means, the field demonstration of the effect of new football rules, which President Eliot is said to desire, could best be effected. London’s first pollings destroy the last hope of the Tories, that they might yet escape disastrous defeat. If they can- not save their seats even in London, it is all up with them. In 1900 the Tories carried 55 out of the 62 metropolitan constituencies; at the present rate they may win barely 20. And the Liberal tri- umph goes on mounting throughout the country. Seat after seat reckoned se- curely Tory has been snatched. Mr. Bal- four’s brother Gerald went down at Leeds on Monday, and another member of his Cabinet, the Secretary for Ireland, Mr. Long, was beaten at South Bristol. Even Liberals must regret the defeat of Lord Hugh Cecil and Gibson Bowles. Both were ornaments of the House for industry, wit and character, and the debates will be duller for their absence. The fact that both these Unionist free- traders owed their defeat to a Chamber-

Page 7

_eeen lainite running independently against them, will further embitter the party against Chamberlain. His plight is piti- ful. Hard on to seventy years, and with a Liberal Government before him good for four or five years, his dream of be- coming Prime Minister on the protec- tion issue must now have vanished. Tory as for the last twenty years Manchester has been, Saturday’s polling shows that it is still loyal to the fun- damental doctrine of that school of po- litical thought to which it gave its name. In the Corn Law days it was Liberal and Radical. Nearly seventy years ago, when Gladstone was not yet twenty-eight, and when he was fast be- coming what Macaulay, a couple of years later, called him, the rising hope of the stern and unbending Tories, Manchester would have none of him. In 1837, in consequence of the death of William IV., Parliament was dissolved. Gladstone was put up for Manchester, but he was left at the bottom of the poll. In the next half-century both the statesman and the city changed position. Glad- stone, first a Free Trade Conservative, then a Liberal, had for the last thirty years of his life, in the eyes of his Tory opponents, all the seeming of a danger- ous Radical. Manchester, thoroughly and uncompromisingly Liberal so long as Protection in any of its forms was at all a political issue, drifted towards Conservatism when Free Trade had been, as it then seemed, definitively won. Even before the great Liberal leader's championship of Home Rule had split his party elsewhere, Manchester had passed over to the Tories. At the elec- tion of 1885, when Parnell was still or- dering his followers to vote against evey Gladstonian candidate, the Conser- vatives carried five of the six divisions of Manchester. Since then their party has never held less than one-half of its seats, and, for the greater part of the time, of its six members only one has been a Liberal. At the election of 1900 there was no Liberal candidate at all for Northwest Manchester, the very di- vision for which Winston Churchill was on Saturday returned by a majority of 1,241. Six years ago, in the other five divisions, the aggregate Conservative majority was 6,000 in a total vote of 41,- 000. On Saturday every division was contested. There were upwards of 57,- 000 votes returned. Mr. Balfour and ey- ery other Conservative candidate were beaten, and the aggregate Liberal and Labor majority was 13,000. For the first time since the passage of the Reform Act of 1868, no Conservative will sit in the new Parliament for the great cot- ton metropolis. In proportion to the to- tal vote polled, the overturning in Man- chester is as great as that which would The Nation. A 5 be required to turn McKinley’s plurality of 143,000 in New York in 1900 into a Democratic plurality of 325,000 in 1906. It may be noted in passing that, though the total vote was much the heaviest ever returned in Manchester, it is only about half that which is cast at a warm- ly contested election in an American city of the same size. Manchester has about as many people as St. Louis or Baltimore. In 1900 the former cast 125,- 000 votes, and the latter 113,000. Forty-one writers, artists, and schol- ars in Germany have memorialized their English colleagues for a better un- derstanding between the two nations. They regret extreme anti-British ex- pressions made in Germany during the Boer war, and they protest against false and reckless statements in the British press which embitter relations and ren- der most difficult the task of peace-mak- ing that lies before the Morocco Con- ference. These Germans maintain that the two nations have been and are bound together by reciprocal ties of cul- ture, religion, art, and scholarship, and bespeak a setting aside of prejudice and a more cordial recognition of the solidarity of British and German civ- ilization. To such an overture of good will but one answer was possible. For- ty-one British worthies promptly wel- comed this open letter, and responded with counter expressions of friendship, and with sincere deprecation of “the af- fected belligerency of some of our jour- nals.” Such an interchange of good wishes must in a measure make against the chauvinism that equally afflicts both nations; and if it be said that these pa- cific sentiments are adopted only by cer- tain intellectuels, without influence upon the masses, one can only reply that in- ternational understandings have histori- cally always becun among this educated class. To show that the German protest against unfriendly treatment by the British press is not made without rea- son, we cite a characteristic instance, not from the yellower precincts of the Strand, but from the Times. Shortly be- fore December 27, the German Emperor, speaking in a private gathering, de- nied that there was a war party behind him, professed the most pacific inten- tions, praised the “tact and firmness” of M. Rouvier in the thorny Morocco negotiations, and declared that the “most conciliatory instructions” had been given to the German Ambassador at Fez. This most welcome news was forwarded by the Times's Paris correspondent under date of December 27, and printed briefly as a ‘‘rumor.” Next day the Paris cor- respondent had his doubts. The alleged Imperial statement was purely unofficial. A “trustworthy source” had provided a supplementary clause, in which the Kal- ser had subordinated his zea! for peace to the maintenance of national honor: There were reports of military prepara tions on the railroads near the Belgian frontier. The third day, the Imperial utterance being officially confirmed Berlin correspondent points out tha: means no essential change in attitude the Paris correspondent finds overture “does not appear to have niads any impression on the French pu! at all events, not the kind of jmpre« sion which was apparently intended this, that, and the other Paris journa ist remain skeptical. A formula based on this case would run as follows Subject all news creditable to German good sense and feeling to these thre operations: (1) Print it without em phasis; (2) question its authenticity (3) if that be established, minimize its value and challenge its sincerity v1 dently the gospel of peace itself would come off badly in the Times office unde the application of this rule of three Count Witte’s answer to his critics might be in the words of the French statesman when asked what he did du: ing the Reign of Terror: “I lived.” The Russian Premier has survived an un paralleled series of risings against the powers of government, and, if order does not reign in Warsaw and Moscow, chaos at least has not taken its place He has not, it is true, won over the an tagonists who distrusted him when he assumed office. Even seml-official pa pers, like the Slovo and the Novoe Vremya, continue to speak of him as a juggler; reactionaries and bureaucrats detest him; Moderate Liberals and Con servatives give him but guarded support, while Radical Liberals concede to him at best the ability of a Necker, with all the limitations of the French financier “Witte’s ideal,” says Prince Kropotkin, “is a liberal, half-absolute and half constitutional monarchy, of which he would be the Bismarck, standing by the side of a weak monarch. He wil! not be a great statesman, because he scoffs at those who believe that in politics, as in everything else, complete honesty is the most successful policy.”” Witte him- self has deplored the fact that only the revolutionary elements in Russia seem to have a common purpose, while the friends of order are divided and un willing to support the Czar and his Gov- ernment. To foreign criticism of the arbitrary acts of his Ministry he re- plied: “Foreigners, in truth, do not ua- derstand Russia at all. Before the events of last October they were axreed that all would be well as soon as a Con- stitution was granted. Now they are frightened because everything appears to be in disorder. As a matter of fact, their anxiety is just as exaggerated as was their previous hopefulness.”’

Page 8

46 CONGRESS ON ROOSEVELT’S HANDS Without accepting too confidingly all the stories that come from Washington, it is evident that the relations between the President and Congress are strained. the beginning of the _ session have not gone smoothly. The programme has visibly From things A (ministration stuck on the ways. And a personal ele- has contributed to the tension: many have taken offence at Mr. Roosevelt, for one reason or an- other, and do not conceal their pique. That the President himself has lost something of his customary amiability, we may believe without depending upon the gossip, partly amusing, partly dis- quieting, which is traceable to recent callers at the White House. Mr. Roose- to Congress last week was one long burst of ill temper. It ar- cued a frame of mind poorly fitted either to perceive the actual situation ment Congressmen velt’s message clearly in Congress, or to deal with it. President Roosevelt obviously suffers from never having served in Congress, and so caught something of its point of view. Next to his lack of legal training, his frequent inability to hit off the tone of a representative and legislative body is perhaps his greatest handicap as President. Only think of McKinley’s un- failing skill in that regard! He had an instinctive feeling for the Congressional way of looking at all questions, and sel- dom failed to adjust himself to it with the nicest tact. Whenever he stroked Congress, the resultant purr was audi- ble: but Mr. Roosevelt seems usually to rub the fur the wrong way, and to elicit such angry spittings and clawings as we It is a defect at once in his experience and his temperament. The between President and Congress springs partly from the old curse of patronage. Even in the hands of a President who had been a zealous civil-service reformer, that government- now see, trouble al evil has lost little of its power to work mischief Exasperated Senators and inflamed Representatives are as thick In Washington as in the days when the spoils system frankly reigned. And the is that the Presi- dent appears to be using the arguments of a spoilsman at the same time that he is professing to make appointments in the spirit of a reformer. That is to say, in his efforts to aid Speaker Cannon in rallying a party majority in the House, the President appeals, and threatens, on the ground of patronage, McKinley or a Grant might have done. This is happy neither way: it does not satisfy or appease Congress- men; make reform appear either strong or consistent. Behind patronage, policies. Some of those which the President is backing are distasteful to Congress. While dear to Mr. Roosevelt's heart, he cannot arouse worst of it urges, just as a it does not public enthusiasm about them, because the public is almost wholly indifferent. The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2116 Where is the evidence that the people care a straw about San Domingo? The President’s Panama troubles are like- wise a matter largely between himself and Congress; the public cannot be made excited about them. Thus Mr. Roose- velt is left to fight those quarrels un- aided. The old heart-filling hurrahs from the people do not come to spur him on. Meanwhile, the causes upon which he might have appealed strongly to the general sentiment of the country are held in abeyance. The Machiavellian “railroad schemers’” whom Mr. Roose- velt’s friends so often see in affrighted visions, must be chuckling over the way in which the railroad-regulation bill has been subordinated to San Domingo, Pan- ama, Mr. Bishop, and Mrs. Morris. One cause of President Roosevelt's impatience with Congress is his con- sciousness of being still the people’s darling. ‘There is no sure sign that his popularity has diminished appreciably; he even added to it by his part in bring- ing about peace between Russia and Ja- pan, last summer, and by his tour through the South; how, then, dares Congress to withstand him? But there is an old political truth which Mr. Roosevelt does not appear to have suffi- ciently weighed. This is that an Ad- ministration, no matter how strong it may seem in popular support, no sooner begins to live than it begins to die. Mr. Cleveland perceived this in 1892. Short- ly after his triumphant election in that year, he wrote a letter to Mr. Lamar which predicted the troublous days of his coming Administration, and which is a monument to his political sagacity. A President once in office, and pledged as Mr. Roosevelt is not to seek another term, becomes a more negligible quantity than he likes to think. Political inter- est soon centres elsewhere. Who is to be the successor? What faction, what machine of the many which are assem- bling their parts, is to force the next nomination? ‘Those are the instinctive questions of politicians who always has- ten to prostrate themselves before the rising sun. They are doing it in Wash- ington to-day. So many Presidential booms are in the making that the au- thority of the President who has been made is necessarily impaired. Congress- men are more anxious to be “solid” with Fairbanks or Shaw, Foraker or Taft, Root or La Follette, than to wait upon orders from the White House every day. It is this scheming within the party which partly accounts for the President’s inability to whip it into line for his pet measures. And when we add to that the inveterate and unyielding greed of the protected interests, against which the President’s Philippine bill has run as against a stone wall; the disposition of Congressmen selfishly to consult their individual political fortunes more care- fully than the President's; and Mr, Roosevelt's ill-judged acts and utter- ances, we have little difficulty in ex- plaining the coil into which he has got himself with Congress. It would be rash to prophesy that he will not pull himself out gracefully, or at least victoriously. He has immense resources; real political skill; proverbial good fortune. Once fairly in a corner, he knows how to yield with a smiling face, and claim a great triumph. So it is possible that the present war-clouds on Capitol Hill will roll away; but mean- time we are to have a severe test of the President's political generalship. THE PRESIDENT AND THE BOSSES. Current rows and heartburnings at Washington over Federal patronage raise again the whole question of the complicity of the National Government in fastening the tyranny of corrupt bosses upon States and cities. Mr. Wayne MacVeagh, in his North Ameri- can article on the triumph of honesty at the polls in Philadelphia, points to the extraordinary fact that the whole effective power of the Administration at Washington was against the reformers. This was because the President had al- lowed the Pennsylvania Senators to dic- tate all the appointments. Consequent- ly, though Mr. Roosevelt might express sympathy with the good cause privately, and though Secretary Root might open- ly wish the honest citizens of Philadel- phia godspeed in their efforts to oust “a corrupt and criminal combination masquerading under the name of Repub- licans,” the whole force of Federal offi- cials was working night and day to save the bosses from the wrath to come. Mr. MacVeagh states, in dwelling on the “alliance between the Executive Depart- ment of the National Government and the bosses cynically engaged in despoil- ing Philadelphia and Pennsylvania,” that “almost every person in Pennsyl- vania who had been honored with a commission bearing the signature of President Roosevelt, was the avowed, persistent, and reckless opponent of that decency and honesty in politics for which President Roosevelt has so cour- ageously battled all his life.” That is sorrowful history. The la- mentable present fact is that the same process is apparently in full vigor once more at Washington. In meekly knuck- ling to the demands of Senators in the matter of appointments to office, Mr. Roosevelt is, by so much, declaring him- self in favor of the rehabilitation of the bosses. Ever since last November’s election the question of thoughtful citi- zens has been: “Shall we be able to se- cure the fruits of the people’s victory? Are the swashed machines to remain in fragments, or will they be put to- gether again and set running more remorselessly than before?” Well, the repair gang has called upon the

Page 9

Jan. 18, 1906] The Nation. President for aid, and he is giving it to them. For example, note the significance of his throwing just now an extra ap- pointee to Senator Beveridge of Indi- ana. It is promptly and properly taken as a favor to the Beveridge machine. The newspapers are beginning to reckon up how many “men” the Senator now has on guard. Thus, we read in the Washington Post of Thursday: “With this appointment, Senator Bever- idge will now have in the Federal building at Indianapolis the following personal ap- pointments: Judge Baker, of the United States Circuit Court of Appeals; Judge Marsh, pension agent; Elam Neal, collector of internal revenue; H. W. Bennett, post- master; Mr. Pettit, United States marshal, and Mr. Rothschilds, surveyor of the port.” We are far from asserting that Sena- tor Beveridge is a corrupt politician. He has, it is true, shown a pretty taste in spoils. With Scriptural zeal, he has insisted that the Government provide for those of his own household. We suppose, however, that he wishes to cre- ate and control a machine more for po- litical than for pecuniary objects. Yet the same vicious system is illustrated in his case, tolerably innocent though that may be, which in Pennsylvania, in Ll- linois, in Ohio, in New York, and New Jersey has fixed upon those Common- wealths and their chief cities a ruth- less organization of plunderers. Let there be no mistake about this. A local boss, just in proportion as he is cunning and corrupt, reaches out his hand for Federal patronage. It is not, of course, his smirched palm that is thrust into the President's face; a re- spectable Senator is sent to do the ask- ing. But we all know how endless are the affiliations, the plottings, the secret influences, the threats, the bribes, tne trickeries, the betrayals of the boss. No- thing is too small for him to attend to; nothing too large for him to aspire to control. His “system” works up and down through all the commercial ana political life of his State. It was easy for Quay to get “eminent bankers” or “distinguished jurists” to back his pet scoundrels. Writes the blunt Mr. Mac- Veagh: “What Mr. Jerome has recently said of some of the judges of New York, is eminently true of some of the judges of Philadelphia and throughout Penn- sylvania, im all the grades of our ju- diciary.” The machine knoweth its own. Having created judges and Senators, it calls upon them to fall down and wor- ship their ’creator. The messenger to the White House may be a Senator, but the principal is waiting in some secret of- fice, miles away, with his ear to a tele- phone, anxious to learn whether fhe President has made one more place for a serviceable tool. When Senator Dick was demanding a consulate last year, what surgery could have dissected out his real personality from that of Boss Cox? In Pennsylvania, Penrose and Durham were blended indistinguishably. The President could not smile upon the Senator without fawning upon the Boss. Here in New York we see the peril threatening. In the room of the de- posed Odell, it is proposed that Aldridge or Woodruff be set up. Either wouid soon make Odell seem fairly respecta- ble. In any case, the restoration of tae New York machine with a new boss is buzzed about all over the State, and the implication is that the President will turn over the desired patronage. Tne Senatorial intermediaries do not count with us just now, but it will not be long before the new machine has its errand- boys in the Senate, and then the ques- tion will be whether Mr. Roosevelt wil: help forge anew the chains of political slavery for us. He will do it infallibly, just as he will do it in other States, if he abdicates his Constitutional function in favor of the Senate. No overmaster- ing desire to obtain legislation from that body—as to which he may easily be be- trayed again—should blind him to the fact that the surrender of the power of appointment to Senators means giving fresh courage to the bosses everywhere. The very best fight against the return of the crew which the people spoke their minds so emphatically about last No- vember, would be made by a Chief Ex- ecutive who should point clamorous boss-made and boss-allied Senators to the Constitutional provision: The Presi- dent shall nominate.” ONE WAY OUT OF THE PHILIPPINES. Congressman McCall has rev ved a plan to get this country out of the Phil- ippine difficulty. He has introduced a resolution authorizing the President to enter into negotiations with the Pow- ers of Europe for the purpose of making neutral territory of the Philippine areh- ipelago, with an independent govern- ment recognized internationally. This proposition would spike the guns of those who are seeking, on one pretence after another, to tie us up to the Philip- pines indefinitely for purposes of com- mercial exploitation. It has been their favorite contention that if we should withdraw from the archipelago, Japan or Germany or some other Power would immediately pounce upon the prey. For us to permit any such aggression, it has been alleged, would be nothing less than a breach of faith with the Filipinos, for no other country could possibly have such humanitarian motives as ours. What Mr. McCall proposes can be as- sailed on the ground neither of prece- dent nor of feasibility. Switzerland and Belgium have long been neutralized by international agreement. Switzerland would in all probability have been ab- sorbed by envious neighbors had it not been that her perpetual neutrality and the inviolability of her territory were guaranteed in 1815 by Austria, Great Britain, Portugal, Prussia, and Russia. No nation has ever tried to violate this agreement, and none would be allowed to. The same is true of Belgium. In 1831, Great Britain, France, Russia, Aus- tria, and Prussia settled the quarrel! be tween Holland and Belgium, provided for the separate existence of the latter, and declared it to be thenceforth a per- petually neutral state. When the Bel gian frontier was menaced by the war ot 1870, Great Britain served notice that she would take sides against whichever combatant should violate Belgium's ter ritory. This warning was enough. Nel ther France nor Germany cared to bring England into their strife. This idea that beyond the reach of land-grabbing Pow national means been overlooked in the years since 1831. The United States, by the Monroe Doctrine and its subsequent in a territory can be put ers by agreement, has by no terpretations, has practically assumed to do that for South Later, Secretary Hay, in his efforts China, very thing America for the the open door in induced great nations to promise to keep their hands off China during the war be tween Russia and Japan And the Portsmouth treaty of peace, together with the new Anglo-Japanese pact, has practically neutralized China for a long time to come. Mr. McCall's suggestion is therefore in line with our best traditions as well as in accord with the historic American spirit of fair those who are weak. Its adoption would free the future of the Filipinos from un- certainty. More than that, there is not a single obstacle in the way of an in- ternational agreement. Japan and Png- land would welcome it as simplifying the Eastern problem in which they are deeply concerned, while the German Emperor would undoubtedly the opportunity to show once more his gen- uine friendliness the United States, and confute those Jingoes who, ever since the blunders of his Admiral Diedrichs in Manila Bay, have insisted on his hostile intentions. France, Rus- sia, and Italy could also make no pos- sible objection. Indeed, if Mr. velt would but bring to the task a tenth of the astuteness, enthusiasm, ergy which he applied to the Russian and Japanese peace negotiations, the matter could be carried through within the year. But the hitch, it may be said, will come over the proposed independent government. Secretary Taft will be cer- tain to rise up once more and solemnly argue that no man must utter the word independence out loud and couple with it a promise or a date. But there are signs that his party has got yond him. His own specially organized excursion to the Philippines failed to arouse enthusiasm among its members If President McKinley could return to earth he would be astounded at the change in sentiment. He would hear many party leaders privately wishing play towards seize towards Roose- and en- well be-

Page 10

48 The Nation. ————— the islands anywhere but in our care. He would be surprised by the number of Imperialist newspapers, like the Min- neapolis Tribune, which are heartily sick of the whole business; and would find Congress in a sad snarl over the simple question of giving the Filipinos a chance to export their sugar and to- bacco free of any tax. But far more sig- nificant is the total absence of any real interest in the Philippines in the current debates. Mr. Taft and the President may appeal all they please to the honor and generosity of Congressmen; the lat- ter want nothing except to wash their hands of Philippine affairs. In this hurly-burly, Mr. McCall's pro- posal should fall gratefully. The fact that it is fathered by a Republican Congressman and is to have the en- dorsement of Senator Crane in the Sen- ate, will relieve from the charge of party irregularity any Republican who speaks or votes for it. Best of all, it can be said for the neutralizing plan that it would be an act of justice, relieve us from the expense and worry of maintain- ing troops, forts, and fleets to guard them, and enable the Filipinos to begin to govern themselves at once, free from interference, no matter how many times they may stumble and fall before they learn to stand on their feet. DARIUS GREEN'S PROGENY. In one respect, at least, the develop- ment of the art of flying by human con- trivances has been unique. General pub- lic interest was not aroused in steam- boats until one was able to propel itself; there was never a public view of the telegraph until it was so perfected that messages could be sent by it; and most other inventions, whether small or great, have been given to the world when they had been made workable, and not be- fore. But the progress toward a prac- ticable flying apparatus has all been made in the open. Inventors have, of course, carried on their experiments with the customary privacy, but as each one has worked out only some small part of the problem, the public has been enabled to watch substantially every step. The Aero Club's exhibition, which opened in this city on Saturday evening, has thus one entirely novel aspect. It is, In a sense, an assembling, from all parts of the world, of the constituent elements for an invention which has not yet been made, namely, a machine that will fly after the fashion of a bird. The steering of balloons was at first the only problem that aeronauts consid- ered practical. According to the accept- ed physical formula for determining the sustaining power of a column of alr, a bird the size of a duck would have had to expend the better part of a horse- power to keep Itself off the ground; and te lift a man, let alone an engine, by means of wings or planes, appeared ab- solutely visionary. Only rural “cranks,” of the Darius Green order, seriously tried the thing. Then came the series of experiments that not only exploded the old formula, but showed it to be comparatively easy to construct an en- gine that will lift its weight against the air. Sir Hiram Maxim constructed a large apparatus with wide supporting planes and rotary propellers which could be started along ordinary rails, and, when it reached a certain speed, would rise so that its wheels ran along the under side of another set of rails placed above the first. The assumption then was that if such a machine were launch- ed in a spacious enough place, it would fiy, and the difficulty of finding such a place in England was the reason why the inventor paused. As a matter of fact, the question of balancing, which was then considered a secondary matter, has since been real- ized to be the crux of the whole prob- lem. Otto Lilienthal, who met his death in pursuit of his hobby, studied the art of soaring from a height by means of rigid wings that were elevated or de- pressed merely by the balance of the operator’s body. Professor Langley of the Smithsonian Institution has made several models that “flew,” but it was too erratic flight that wrecked his last creation, the “Buzzard.” The success of the Wright brothers in controlling aeroplanes has received much notice in the last two years, and their invention has just been bought by the French Gov- ernment. So progress has been made in the art of actual navigation as well as on the purely mechanical side. In the meantime, Santos-Dumont and his disciples on both sides of the water have brought the dirigible balloon to such perfection that it will run against a very light breeze, and in still air can perform any evolution. Of course, the gas-filled airship is a fundamentally dif- ferent thing from a craft which rises by its own power; but the experiment- ers with the former have been steadily lightening their motors, and every re- duction in the number of ounces per horsepower is a help to the work of the other group. “Man will be able in due time to soar after the manner of the eagle, which utilizes the energy of the wind against which it files for its own propulsion.” This is the prediction of Prof. Alex- ander Graham Bell, one of whose kites only this month performed the feat of lifting, thirty feet above the ground, a 185-pound man with tackle weighing 62 pounds. Professor Bell's device has never yet been made a part of an air- ship or been combined with an engine and propeller, but it {is unquestionably one of the most important inventions ‘yet made in connection with the con- quest of the air. On the lines followed by the pioneer inventors, it might be [Vol. 82, No. 2116 ible to make a small apparatus practicable where a large one would fail. With a given design, while the sustain- ing power increased with the square of the dimensions, the weight would in- crease with the cube. Even the box- kite, with which many experimenters have worked, requires bracing whenever several kites are bound together, and in- creases in weight faster than in lifting power. Professor Bell's tetrahedral kite over- comes this objection. It is merely a frame of six sticks of equal length fast- ened at the corners so as to form a tri- angular pyramid. Two sides are cov- ered with some thin fabric. Each of such units is absolutely firm and sta- ble, needing no additional bracing; and they can be bound together in any de- sired number without impairing their efficiency. So, according to the publish- ed studies, the lifting power increases exactly as the weight. Ten units weigh ten times as much as one and will lift ten times as much. There would seem to be no theoretical obstacle to con- structing such a kite or aggregation of kites capable of lifting any given weight into the air. If a man and his chair, why not a motor and propelling fans? Should this turn out to be the solution of the problem, the flying machine of the future will bear the appearance not of one great bird, as it is commonly figured, but of a flock of little birds, for that is what the photographs of the Bell kite most resemble. Kipling’s navigators of the twenty- first century are made to speak dis- paragingly of the days when men “flew kites over thorium engines.” It looks as if commonplace steam and vapor en- gines would have to come first. But even that stage is awaited with impatience. We have seemingly accomplished the preliminaries; but who will be the man to make the airship as practicable as the automobile? PAYING THE DOCTOR. When a New York dentist was said to have charged Prince Louis $1,000 for filling four teeth, the general comment, public and private, was that the bill was outrageous. The question of doctor’s fees is raised again by correspondence printed in a recent issue of the Medical Record. A New York surgeon asked $1,000 for an operation for gangrenous appendicitis; the mother of the patient, after consultation with friends, offered $600. The surgeon politely protested, cit- ed testimony of brother physicians to prove that his fee was not unusual, and finally received the remainder. The let- ter enclosing the last check ran thus: “My discussion with you has been a friendly one, and so you will not, I am sure, suspect me of any acrimony when I say that my feeling about the present excessive charge of surgeons is a very 1 one, and the reflection of a sentiment that is ee

Page 11

ny lnc. soon te everywhere one of surprise and dissatisfac- tion. We do not question your ability, but we feel you make us pay too dear for it.” Indubitably, the writer of the letter just quoted voices a common sentiment; and that sentiment is not without basis in fact. Some surgeons seem to have adopted the motto, “Your money or your life.” They charge a patient as much as they think he can possibly afford. This, of course, is refined and intelli- gent highway robbery. On no theory whatever can it be defended. There.are, however, certain principles, perfectly clear, though not always well understood or consistently applied, which explain why a twelve-minute operation for ap- pendicitis may be worth more than five or six hours of tooth-filling. In the first place, all professional! fees are graded according to the standard of living in the community. In small cities and villages the doctors, dentists, and lawyers, often extremely skilful, would never dream of asking what New York doctors and lawyers regularly ask. Sur- geons in Poughkeepsie, Albany, New Haven, and Springfield can probably re- move the appendix as successfully as any one in New York, but they might charge their richest patients no more than $500, and possibly as little as $150. People who are unfamiliar with New York prices are therefore aghast at the thought of fees which hardened New Yorkers take for granted; and the voices of these strangers within our gates help to swell the chorus of complaint. Moreover, the position of a doctor dif- fers widely from that of a lawyer .or engineer. The latter are not called upon in crises of life and death to give their services freely. Every surgeon of stand- ing devotes much time and energy to hospital practice and cases in which his fees are merely nominal. As a hu mane man he cannot do less. He ex- pects and his patients expect that he shall partly reimburse himself from those who can afford to pay handsome- ly. Physicians as a class are not con- sumed with greed. The vast majority set professional honor and their ser- vices to mankind above other consider- ations, and are content with a moderate return for their labor. A surgeon is entirely warranted in fixing a maximum fee, say, $1,000, or even more, for ap- pendicitis, demanding this maximum from his rich patients, and charging others less, according to his private judgment as to mercy and justice. By this we do not mean that when he saves the life of a millionaire he shall ca- priciously set his figures in the thou- sands or tens of thousands, but that his maximum shall be determined seriously and honestly. In such a reckoning he may often take account of factors which a lay- man (as the correspondence already re- ferred to shows) might overlook. The element of time, for instance, is often The N ation ‘ relatively unimportant. A _ physician carries a child through an ordinary case of measles in three or four calls, and charges for each call. In a prolonged but not grave illness he may not deem it quite fair to charge rigidly for every call. For a twelve-minute operation for appendicitis he properly asks far more than for the hours spent over measles or mild lingering sickness. The serious- ness of the malady, the difficulty and risk of the operation, and the skill and previous medical training required must all be considered. A painful flesh-wound from an accident may take five times as long to heal as an incision for appendicitis; the surgeon may dress it daily for weeks; and yet the flesh- wound may never threaten life itself, and the treatment may be so simple and easy that it demands from the surgeon nothing but attention and average knowledge. An abdominal operation may—thanks to extraordinary special knowledge, acquired at great expense— be so quick and brilliant that, though the patient has literally been snatched from death, he and his friends may im- agine that nothing much was the mat- ter. He is subjected to less inconve- nience and agony than he might suffer from having four of the most workman- like gold fillings put in his teeth. The bills, however, should not be the same. THE FUNCTION OF AN ENDOWED PRESS. Rumors are current that one of our greatest universities is soon to be en- dowed with a press; if so, let us hope it will be put to good use, for it would be altogether hasty to assume that a uni- versity press is of necessity a blessing, and dangers of the most obvious kind are readily to be foreseen. It may, for one thing, become the servant not so much of learning and education as of the institution it represents; it may be run, in plain words, to advertise the university and to push its graduates. The evil is evident in the gross, but ex- tends far in subtle and demoralizing ramifications. Such a policy would, for instance, incidentally tend to encourage the promiscuous printing of doctors’ theses, and foster the spirit of hot-bed forcing that is the chief cause of the immaturity and crudeness for which too much of our American scholarship has made an unfortunate reputation. Close- ly akin to this is an evil not unknown even to the Pitt and the Clarendon Presses. These institutions enjoy the special advantage of knowing before- hand the subjects to be set for univer- sity examinations, and they suborn young scholars whose time might be far better and hardly less remunerative- ly spent, to prepare text-books for these examinations. With our system this could not so largely be the case; yet who can doubt that text-books and doctors’ AG theses might easily become the chief product of such a press? There is another danger, even more grave, that requires statement at some length, for it opens up the whole sub ject of the teaching of literature at our universities. Yet this is no incidental matter, for the press, after all, is the greatest of the teachers of literature. Un der the influence of men with much spe cial but little general education, work would probably be published unworthy of a university in its standard of expression It is perhaps an indirect result of the present extraordinary effort in the teaching of English and literature that both teachers and learners, to say no thing of those who are neither teachers nor learners, have measurably lost sight of what literary expression is; whence their ill success. One of the most de plorable things at our universities is to see men who profess literature, con sciously or unconsciously setting before their students the idea that literary ex pression is an end to be achieved by di rect study, and which may be turned to commercial advantage. But literary ex pression is nothing more than a means to an end: it is the employment of the symbols of written language in the man- ner most closely adapted to conveying thought. We must learn to think first and after that learn to convey what we have thought. Most of our teaching, however, is how to express ourselves regardless of the cultivation of the tn tellect, and this teaching is carried on with such intensity that thought which should be stimulated by literature ts, on the contrary, crushed out by it. Literature under this system tends to become a specialty. The master pieces of English prose and verse are no longer the sacred repositories of the highest thought of our race, claimed by every educated man as his equal birthright; they are delegated to special ist educators—-the term is a fit one-—as instruments for technical study and pre ferment. At many, if not all, of our universities, English literature is already suffering from undiscriminating specia! ism, and many of those engaged in other pursuits affect an often comfort ing disdain for literary expression as a matter that concerns some learned col- league, but not themselves. They for get, those who have ever known it, that a clear thought can be crystallized only by a clear expression. And so, to leave generalities and come to particulars, we find that even in the study nearest akin to that of literature, namely, that of his tory, something distinctly worse than bad style is winked at and, on occasion, encouraged. Is it safe, under such cir cumstances, to trust a college faculty with a press? And yet the need for an endowed preas is crying. To enumerate all the good purposes it might serve would be to ex- ceed the unavoidable bounds of this ar-

Page 12

50 The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2116 ticle, and only one will be adverted to, one not generally recognized and yet perhaps most important of all—the pro- duction of serious literature at a low price. It is-one of the weaknesses of our Anglo-Saxon civilization (for in this matter the argument applies to England even more than to ourselves), that whereas the price of newspapers, of magazines, and of fiction has steadily tended downwards, such has not been the case with what may be described conveniently as serious literature—lit- erature that ranges from poetry through history to philosophy. How seriously our national position is affected may be shown by a comparison with France. That country happily has a standard price of publication, 70 cents a volume, at which the bulk of current literature, both light and serious, is produced. Bourget’s latest novel and Henri Hous- saye on Waterloo appear on the book- stall side by side and at the same price, and as often as not the good Paris bourgeois purchases the more valuable book. And to say that this is simply because French serious literature is bet- ter written than ours is an enormous exaggeration, as may be demonstrated. A few years ago a London publisher set out to produce a translation of the com- plete works of Nietzsche. The first vol- ume met with little encouragement; the second was accompanied by a slip from the publisher stating that unless the public responded better he would have to abandon the enterprise; the third has never appeared. In France, all of Nietzsche’s works have long since been translated, and the least sold had run some years ago into several thousands. Here we have not a question of style, but of price; not of the positive value of Nietzsche, but of intellectual curiosity. And here we get a rough demonstra- tion that in France, with less than forty millions of people, there are probably from five to ten persons who buy serious books to one in the English-speaking countries with nearly four times the population. If that is so, if it is only approximately so, it is a terrible re- proach to our civilization, and it is largely the result of the inflated prices charged for new works of serious liter- ature. It should not be forgotten that the class of the community which buys, or might buy, such books, is one that fvela very keenly the difference between paying less than a dollar or from two to six dollers. In Paris the publisher who should raise his price would lose his public; In London or New York the pub- lisher who should lower his price would find the public unprepared and irre- sponsive. From the publishers there ie nothing to hope, for the present, save cheap reprints of works out of copyright, but might not an endowed press, working with steady policy over a course of years, help us? By inflexibly demanding adequate literary expression, by standardizing its prices at a low figure, by giving unknown authors a chance on their mer- its, by supporting scholars in difficult but little-trodden paths, it might serve a great national purpose, and in time shake the publishers and the public out of the vicious rut into which they have insensibly slipped. THE MODERN LANGUAGE ASSOCIATION OF AMERICA. HAVERFORD, December, 1905. The experiment of holding a meeting of a learned society in a small town is gener- ally regarded as hazardous, but in the two eases in which the Modern Language As- sociation has tried it—at Charlottesville, Va., and this winter at Haverford, Pa.— the result has been most satisfactory. The total attendance, though smaller than the gatherings in New York, Cambridge, and Baltimore, has been quite up to the aver- age; while the proportion of members ac- tually present at the sessions has been larger than usual, and, most important of all, the opportunities for social inter- course have been better than they ever can be amid the varied distractions of a city. About half of the members, this time, chose to take rooms in the Philadel- phia hotels, which can be reached almost as readily from Haverford as from the Uni- versity of Pennsylvania; the others were comfortably housed in the college dorml- tories. Meals were served on the grounds, and a fine club-house offered everything that the most exacting taste could require. Reduced railway rates added to the gen- eral cheerfulness. Many of the visitors this year were at- tracted, no doubt, by the prospect of hear- ing an address from Professor Gummere, president of the Association for 1905; many, too, were interested in seeing a college so highly esteemed yet so Mlittle known. Neither of these expectations was disap- pointed. The presidential allocution con- sisted, as had been generally hoped, of an exposition of some of Professor Gummere’s views concerning the production of ballads. This kind of poetry, being in its origin es- sentially a game or an outgrowth of the dance, is naturally dramatic rather than narrative; it portrays a single scene, and develops its theme by a process that is aptly called “incremental repetition.” In conflict with this congenital immobility is the world-old love of story-telling, which tends to transform the ballad into a little epic, substituting a complete tale for a self-explanatory situation. A _ delightful feature of the address was the reading of ballads illustrating the two types. It is safe to say that few of the outsid- ers left Haverford without a twinge of envy for those colleagues whose lot is cast in this homelike little college. Beautiful grounds, extending apparently as far as the eye can reach, where the happy profes- sors dwell, untaxed, in a friendly com- munity of thelr own, enjoying all the plea- sures of rural life within easy reach of a great city; adequate but unpretentious bulldings; a comfortable endowment, which makes it possible to offer unusual induce- ments to exceptional men; a sensible ad- ministration, a small but well-selected corps of Instructors, a choice and not over- large body of students; a high standard of scholarship, combined with a total ab- sence of vulgar boastfulmess and blatant advertising—these advantages make Haver- ford a model of what the little college should be. Would that more institutions had the same opportunity and could follow the same enlightened policy! The programme was of evenly good qual- ity. Constant attendants at the Associa- tion meetings have noted, from year to year, a marked improvement in the choice of subjects and the presentation of them. There are now none of those intolerable bunglers who do not know what they have written and cannot read their own hand- writing; there are few of those enthusiasts who have to be gently plucked by the coat- tail at the expiration of their allotted twenty minutes; and there are not many of those microscopic specialists whose work is too technical to be followed even by a scientific audience. The regulations adopt- ed some years ago prevent crowding and leave plenty of time for debate. Discus- sion, this year, was abundant and lively, and the repose of somnolent members was full of interruptions. Of the twenty-two papers read, not one could be called fee- ble; scarce half-a-dozen* were really unin- teresting—and even these were so well written and so convincingly delivered that the hearers half believed they understood. Six or seven were sufficiently general to entertain any educated public. All the papers but one dealt with literary topics, and that one was of a purely popular char- acter. English literature naturally pre- dominated, but French and German were ably represented, and there was an agree- able sprinkling of other languages. A wel- come surprise was the appearance of a fady among the readers. One striking fea- ture of the programme was the size of the Cambridge delegation; nearly half of the speakers were men now or formally con- nected with Harvard. Equally striking was the absence of any direct offering from Johns Hopkins. We may see in these facts evidence of a notable increase in produc- tivity at Harvard, without (let us hope) postulating a corresponding decline in Bal- timore. Contributions were made by twenty-one colleges or universities, scat- tered across the continent from Montreal to the Pacific Coast; only one, however, came from the South. The papers actually read were divided among fourteen seats of learning. The two that called forth most comment were “American Speech,” by Mr. Leigh R. Gregor of McGill College, and ‘“‘The Prosody of Walt Whitman,” by Prof. F. N. Scott of the University of Michigan. Mr. Gregor took as his starting-point Henry James's address “On the Question of our Speech,” and, in the form of a highly amusing dia- logue between John Bull and Brother Jona- than, discussed with great sagacity the chief linguistic differences between England and America, dealing impartially with the shortcomings of both; he then considered the possibility of maintaining separate standards for the two countries, and the chances of a final reconciliation through mutual concessions. Professor Scott demon- strated that Walt Whitman’s poetry was by no means an impetuous production, but was the fruit of long experiment, thought, and study. Collecting all the poet's utterances about his art, he noted Whitman's belief —

Page 13

es OT Jan. 18, 1906] The Nation. 51 that prose is a more elastic and less con- ventional form than verse, his susceptibility to large, free movements and rushes of sound, his fondness for the swaying, glid- ing effects that characterize rhythmic prose. Following his previously published theory that prose rhythm is essentially a combina- tion of pitch variations, while verse rhythm consists in sequences of varied stress, Pro- fessor Scott showed that Whitman's prosody “is an attempt to construct with the units of prose rhythm a pattern similar to that which other poets had constructed with the materials of metre."’ This thesis was illus- trated by readings and comparisons. It may be added that Professor Scott evident- ly does not regard Whitman's creation as likely to have any lasting effect on English poetry. Among the other papers, mention should be accorded to Dr. W. W. Lawrence's “Structure and Interpretation of the ‘Wid- sith,’ ’’ a masterpiece of argument and pre- sentation, and Dr. Karl D. Jessen’s pene- trating study of “Margaret Fuller's Criti- cism of Goethe.” In 1904 there was presented to the As- sociation the “Report of a Joint Committee, representing the National Educational As- sociation, the American Philological Asso- ciation, and the Modern Language Associa- tion of America, on the subject of a Pho- netic English Alphabet.’’ The proposals of this body, though approved as a whole, were criticised in some details, and a com- mittee of five, consisting of Professors Sheldon, Grandgent, Bright, Hempl, and Weeks, was appointed to revise the work. The new committee reported at this meet- ing, suggesting certain modifications in the alphabet, which make it simpler, more logi- cal, and less divergent from other systems. The report was unanimously adopted; simi- lar action was subsequently taken by the Philological Association, in session at Ithaca. The plan is to urge all makers of dictionaries and text-books to use this al- phabet in indicating pronunciation; and some hope is entertained that, as the pub- lic gradually becomes accustomed to the phonetic notations, the logical spelling may ultimately replace our traditional orthog- raphy. The new alphabet is well adapted to both these ends, being easy, clear, sys- tematic, and not too outlandish in appear- ance. The prospect for phonetic spelling now seems brighter than ever before. The Association also voted approval of “the pro- posal to hold an international conference of experts in phonetics for the purpose of con- sidering a uniform method of graphic rep- resentation of the sounds of speech.” The president for 1906 is Prof. H. A. Todd of Columbia. The Association has received from President Hadley an invitation to hold its next meeting at Yale. THE AMERICAN ECONOMIC ASSOCIA- TION AT BALTIMORE. BALTIMORE. January 4, 1906. The eighteenth annual meeting of the American Economic Association was beld with the Johns Hopkins University in Bal- timore during the Christmas recess, joint- ly with the American Political Science As- sociation, and simultaneously with the ses- sions of the American Historica: Associa- tion. In large and representative attend- ance, in sustained interest and spirited discussion, and in general helpfulness to the science and its devotees, the meeting was one of the best in the history of the Association. it is hoped that the social arrangements were found agreeable, and that the opportunities for personal con tact and informal intercourse were ade quate. The general plan of the meeting was the selection of five general topice—Beonomic Theory, Regulation of Railway Rates, Municipal Ownership, Labor Qvestions, Economic Future of the Negro—and the assignment of one session to the con- sideration of each such topic In most cases two papers were submitted, pre- senting the respective sides of the matter in controversy, which were discussed first by designated persons, and therehfter, to the amount of time available, by the general meeting. On the whole this plan, to which the Association has for some years been steadily drifting. worked admirably. In some instances the issue was drawn too narrowly, and aca- demic calm in at least one instance was replaced by unnecessary warmth. But the discussions were more unified and profit- able. The opening session of the meeting on Wednesday morning, December 27, was de- voted to Economie Theory. Prof. Jacob H. Hollander of Johns Hopkins University presented a formal paper on “The Present State of the Theory of Distribution,”’ and this was discussed by Profs. John B. Clark of Columbia University, Willlam M. Burke of Albion College, Charles A. Tuttle of Wabash College, Roswell C. McCrea of Bowdoin College, Frank A. Fetter of Cor- nell University, and Simon N. Patten of the University of Pennsylvania. After pointing out that the theory of distribution has been the primary endeavor of economic inquiry during the largest part of its sys- tematic pursuit, and briefly outlining the development of the doctrine, Professor HolJander stated that the theory as now current is discredited by two recognized criteria of scientific progress—(a) prac- ticable applicability, and (b) agreement as to fundamental principles. This deficiency is due less to incompleteness of result than to the use of inappropriate method. Three conceivable methods may be em ployed by the economist in his search for sa theory of distribution, conveniently dis- tinguished as: (1) Historical; (2) Metaphysical; and (3) Analytical. Whatever hope may have been entertained as to the usefulness of the historical method in con- structing a body of economic doctrine, was born of reaction. The metaphysical meth- od is a mean between closet speculation and dialectical hypercriticiem bearing in- sufficient relation to the concrete facts of economic life. The analytical method, on the other hand, assumes that the details of economic distribution are capable of observation, arrangement, and classifica- tion; that when so arranged they reveal certain uniformities, that these uniformi- ties may be formulated as hypotheses, aud these hypotheses may be demonstrated as laws. It is the method of positive science capable of application to every field of systematic study other than the purely philosophical disciplines. The successful use of the analytical method by the econo- mist has been delayed by the absence or inadequacy of necessary material required by the deductive stulent for his actual synthesis and for his ultimate verifica- tion; by the inductive investigator for bis essemtiial subject-matter The corrective proposed, therefore, by Professar Holland- er is an arrest of further text-book didactl- cism, an abandonment of hypercritical dialectics, and a reduction of metaphysical speculation, as the exclusive apparatus serviceable in search for the law of eco- nomic distribution, to a minor réle. Meas- urably in leu thereof, and largely in con nection therewith, was suggest«! a detaii- ed sysiematic acquaintance with the actual contemporary subject-matter, as the prepa- ration and equipment for its scientific in- terpretation. President Taussig’'s address on Wednes day evening, on “The Love of Wealth and the Public Service,”” was a notable depar ture from the narrower limits of economic theory and practice into the broad fleld of social philosophy. He undertook to con sider the motives that actuate able men in the conduct of large industrial enterprises, and the possibility of enlist.ng in greater degree the services of such men in the ad ministration of public business. The com plex desire for wealth was analyzed into four constituent elements: first, love of ease and comfort; second, desire for distinction; third, the impulse to activity; fourth, the passion for power and mastery. The moat potent of these forces, the impulse for achievement and for mastery, finds nothing attractive in the administration of public affairs in consequence of the peculiarities of the political machinery of our own coun- try. Not until our political life offers some reasonable chance of prolonged tenure and substantial power, will it attract men of the needed stamp. Even thereafter, all the elaboration of more effective governmental apparatus will prove useless unless the public really wishes for better government As to the ultimate outcome, President Taussig ranged himself unhesitatingly on the side of the angels: “Our political machinery is improving, and is likely still further to improve. The worship of wealth ig diminishing, and the respect for public service is increasing. Men of character and capacity will win, in the long run, the suffrage of the people, and corruption and jobbery will be rebuked. The fundamental virtues are not lacking, and we may base upon them our devices for enlist- ing high-minded ability, for raising general intelligence, for bettering the working de talls of government. We may expect that the sphere of public enterprises will be en larged, as the lessons necessary for the successful conduct of such enterprises are learned. We may hope for greater repres sion of the selfish motives and the sordid activities, for freer play to noble ambition and public-spirited effort, and not only for a stronger government, but for a better and purer democracy.” The session of Wednesday afternoon was devoted to “Railway Rate Regulation,” with Hon. Martin A. Knapp of the inter. state Commerce Commission in the chair Prof. Hugo R. Meyer of the University of Chicago and Prof. B. H. Meyer of the State Railway Commission of Wisconsin were scheduled to present the opposed sides of the question in issue, and Prof. Frank H Dixon of Dartmouth, Mr. L. G. McPherson, lecturer on transportation at Johns Hop- kins, Prof. Don C. Barrett of Haver- ford, and Prof. Willard C. Fisher of Wes- leyan undertook to discuss the papers. As a matter of fact, the inspiration of environ- ment was overpowering, and the announced

Page 14

2 The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2116 topic was relatively neglected “The Chi cago Meyer” paid his respects in emphatic terms to the record of the Interstate Com- merce Commission, and “the Wisconsin Meyer’’ prefaced his formal paper by a spirited and direct arraignment of the state- ments and citations of the preceding speak- er. Some such conflict was perhaps in- evitable, but the profit of the discussion uffered The interest of current affairs was re flected by a joint session on Thursday morn- ing with the American Political Science Association, devoted to “The Case for and against Municipal Ownership.’ Principal pa- pers were presented by Mr. Frederick C. Howe of Cleveland and Prof. Winthrop M Daniels of Princeton University. Thereaf- ter a vigorous and competent discussion was carried on by Prof. Leo 8. Rowe of Penn- sylvania, Prof. John A. Fairlie of Michi- gan, and Dr. M. R. Maltbie. Labor questions engaged the attention of the meeting on Thursday afternoon. Prof. H. W. Farnam of Yale presented a quan- titative study of the labor movement in new groupings of the statistical data made available by the United States Commission of Labor, and suggested a larger use of liagrammatic apparatus and exhibits in the publications of that body United States Commiesioner of Labor Neill took part in the interesting discussion which followed. The second formal paper of the session was by Prof. Thomas 8. Adams of the University of Wisconsin, on the extent and tendency of violence in strikes, and this was entertain- ingly discussed by a social philosopher in the person of Prof. N. P. Gilman, of Meadville; by an economist, Dr. George B. Barnett, of Johns Hopkins, and by a labor leader, Mr. William B. Prescott, ex-presi- dent of the International Typographical Union In keen interest and actual substance the closing session of the meeting on Friday morning, devoted to “The Beonomic Future of the Negro,” left nothing to be desired. Mr. Alfred H. Stone of Mississippi and Prof. W. EB. B. DuBois of Atlanta University read the principal papers, and Prof. Charles L. Raper, of the University of North Carolina, Mr. Theodore Marburg of Baltimore, Prof. M. B. Hammond of the Ohio State Univer- ity, and Mr. R. C. Bruce of Tuskegee sub- mitted minor communications. Manifestly here was a group of men qualified in very unusual degree to speak upon the matter inder discussion, and, with barely an excep- tion, the papers were positive and acute. But he contrariety of opinion—indeed, the op- position of facts—was so marked as to de- press even the most optimistic bellever in the possibility of a “solution” of the negro question. On the one hand, the black was hown to be a thrifty, reasonably indus- (rious peasant, whose standard of life rises rapidly under favorable conditions; and, on the other hand, he was characterized as a besotted degenerate, from whom neither progress nor even stability may be expected. The session was barely rescued from utter ‘mnosticiam by requesting the Bxecutive Committee of the Association to consider he propriety of a committee to collect facta bearing. upon the industrial position and prospects of the negro Two business meetings of the Association were held, at which the constitution was so amended as to replace the overgrown Council, as a governing board, by a some- what enlarged Executive Committee. The affairs of the Association, as reported by its officers, were found in prosperous condition. Progress was also made in the long-consid- ered plan of further publication activity. Prof. J. E. Jenks of Cornell University was elected to the presidency; and Prof. W. M. Daniels succeeded secretary-treas- urer Fetter, whose long and efficient ser- vice received appreciative recognition. The association adjourned to meet at Providence, with Brown University, in the Christmas re- cess of 1906. ao te ae Correspondence. OUR FAULTY MONETARY SYSTEM. To THE EprTorR or THE NATION: Str: The editorial in the current issue of the. Nation (No. 2115) upon Mr. Schilff's warning is eminently sound and pertinent. Nevertheless, neither it nor Mr. Schiff’s remarks, as it seems to me, quite touch the root of the evil, so far as our bank- ing and monetary system is concerned. That evil is imherent in the system as at present constituted. It is undoubtedly true, as you have pointed out, that the re- cent stringency in the money market is attributable, not to the working of our Sub- Treasyry system, bad though that may be, but to the locking up in Stock Exchange speculations of the free loanable capital upon which the commerce of the country is dependent. It is also true that “this autumn’s episode” is ‘a disgrace to a civ- ilized community,”’ and to the banking fra- ternity in particular. But what are the bank managers to do? As certainly as the summers come around, does this loanable capital, temporarily freed from use, accumulate upon their hands. They pay interest upon it—with rare ex- ceptions; unwillingly, it may bé, but of ne- cessity because their competitors do so. The country bankers, having no use at home for their accumulations, send them to the cities, where they get interest upon their balances at a rate not governed by market conditions as in other countries, but fixed for the entire year. The banks in the emaller cities, being similarly situated as regards the plethora of loanable funds, pass their surplus along to the larger cities; and they in turn deposit theirs with the banks in New York. What, then should the New York bankers do under these circumstances? Refuse to take the capital on deposit and pay interest upon it? That would be the wise and prudent course, but it is a course they dare not take. Self-interest interposes. The few who perceive the danger are helpless; should they turn away deposits for which their rivals are clamoring, they would in- jure their own business without relieving the general situation. This capital—deposits or credit balances, as they call it, or “money,” in the par- lance of the Street-—must be forced into use regardless of the difficulty, if not the Impossibility, of withdrawing it when need- ed for the active commerce of the au- tumn and winter. If, in their effort to find employment for the “funds” thus commit- ted to their charge, the bankers play into the hands of the millionaire speculators, they are not so blameworthy as it may seem when viewed from without. These speculators are among the very best cus~- tomers of the banks; they carry the larg- est balances without interest; they offer the most readily marketable security; they control, directly or indirectly, many sources from which the banks derive prof- itable business. Moreover, the purpose for which loang upon collateral are negotiat- ed, is not, as a rule, known to the lend- ers. ven the personality of the borrow- ers is commonly hidden when brokers are employed. Nor is this all. Much of the borrowing is from individuals, trust com- panies, insurance companies, and also from banks in other cities. But, whoever the lenders, the pressure comes upon the New York banks, where the credit balances are carried. From their intimate relation to the finan- cial transactions that pass through their hands, the bankers cannot plead ignorance of what is going on in the field either of le- gitimate business or of speculation. But in- dividually they are not free agents; the working of the system is more powerful than they are. Collectively, they do not act; the number of independent rival insti- tutions precludes concerted action even fcr the protection of themselves and the general public. What is needed is radical reform in both our banking and currency systems. As now constituted, our banking system may aptly be compared to a high-pressure boil- er under full and steadily increasing duty, but without a safety-valve. Such a safety- valve would be afforded by a bank currency like that of the Canadian banks. By con- tracting automatically when commerce slackens, it would put pressure upon the banks at the season when it is needed, thus preventing in large measure the excessive accumulations that are now such a fruit- ful source of trouble. But, to be stable, such a currency must be issued by large in- stitutions under stringent provisions as to redemption, and careful supervision in other respects; to work smoothly and efficiently it calls for branch banking. It thus in- volves a sweeping change in our present system—if system it can be called—of sev- eral different kinds of banking institutions, all pushing each other into more or less un- sound practices, but pulling apart and forc- ing disaster when a crisis becomes immi- nent. Commenting editorially upon Mr. Schiff's address, the Chicago Record-Herald re- marks, concerning proposed remedies, that “the differences of the expertB are very perplexing to the lay mind.” The cause of these differences is that most of the bank- ers, few of whom are really experts on these matters, are blinded by self-interest or fear. Therefore, poor makeshift proposi- tions are put forward, though fathered and supported by weighty names. Even those who see clearly what should be done assert that it is hopeless to try for it, since the country bankers, to a man, are set against branch banking. There is force in the ar- gument they adduce, that no eystem is proof against the consequences of bad manage- ment; but a bad system, such as that we now have, compels wrong practices, which under a good system would as inevitably be discouraged. FREDERICK W. GOoKIN. Curcaeo, January 14, 1906. > ante ne ena a

Page 15

en Jan. 18, 1906] The Nation. — == THE CANAL AND THE COST. TO THE Epitor OF THE NATION: Sin: If the Panama Canal is opened for traffic in ten years, and has then cost us, including interest, which is already running, $500,000,000—which seems not an improbable amount—then at four per cent. the interest on the cost will amount to $20,000,000 annually. If the average charge for each vessel passing through is $4,000—about that of the Suez Canal— it will require the passage of 5,000 ships a year to meet interest charges alone. If $6,000 a ship is required, it would still require 3,333 vessels a year to meet in- terest charges. Is any such amount of traffic supposable?* Moreover, the cost of maintenance can- not of course be estimated at less than $1,000,000, more probably at $2,000,000; and to meet this alone, at an average of $6,000, would require the passage of 333 vessels.—Yours, BR. A. FP. CaMpriper, Mass, Januery 13, 1906. Notes. A. C, McClurg & Co., Chicago, have in preparation ‘Hawaiian Yesterdays,’ by Dr. Henry M. Lyman of Chicago, a missionary's son, who now presents his boyish recolilec- tion of island life. In the course of the present month Messrs. Bell & Sons will publish ‘The Itinerary in Wales of John Leland in or about the years 1536-1539.’ The editor is Miss L. Toulmin’ Smith, who is already well known to students of English on both sides of the Atlantic. In this volume are gathered together and arranged the por- tions relating to Wales scattered through four parts of Leland’s works; the place- names are identified, and there is a map and a full index. The book is intended to form part of a new edition of Leland’s celebrated ‘Itinerary through England and Wales,’, upon which Miss Smith is stiil engaged. In the Globus, R. Lehmann-Nitzsch an- nounces that Mr. E. Antran of Buenos Ayres recently found in the heart of the Argentine Republic twenty-eight unknown letters of Alexander von Humboldt. They were addressed to Bonpland, and have been handed down in that naturalist’s family as a portion of his literary remains. They are to be published in the near future in con- nection with the posthumous writings of Bonpiand. A preliminary report on the whole find ha&8 been made public by Ed. L. Holmberg. The Royal Association of Sciences in Co- penhagen and the Academy of Sciences in Berlin have agreed jointly to prepare a catalogue of the Greek and Latin medical writers. The ulterior purpose is to sub- mit this to the Internationa! Association of Academies with a view to having a com- plete and scientific edition of all the medi- cal works of classical antiquity prepared and published. The next convention of the International Association, to be held in Vienna in 1907, at Whitsuntide, is expected to take definite action in the matter. After the present year the works of Heinrich Heine will no longer be protected in France, where copyright extends fifty years after the death of an author. The Gaulois declares that interest in Heine is still growing in France, and the demand for his works now greater than ever. Probably the first edition of Goethe's poems to be issued in Japan made its ap- pearance recently in Tokio from the pub- lishing house of K. Nakane, in a volume of 244 pages, embellished with a portrait of Goethe and a reproduction of the well- known picture, “Goethe's Familie." The author is Tadao Hashimoto, already known for an early edition of Heine and for his advocacy of the study of German literature; and, besides the poems, in the German let- ter, there are translations of some forty- eight of Goethe's best-known ballads and lyrics, with explanatory notes in Japanese The translations, in Japanese verse, do not, of course, satisfy the metrical conditions of the original. In his introduction Mr. Nakane presents the question, What is the character of the poetry of Goethe which has been so much praised? For his part he finds in the poems of the German Olym- pian unusual vigor, fulness of life, an earnest spirit that is always a confession of the soul, a mysterious strength and calmness that yields sound like that of music, abundance of touch with human life simplicity of style, and a form that is in strict accord with the content The edit- ing of Goethe’s works, Mr. Nakane says, was a labor of love, undertaken for the youth of Japan, who are as yet quite unfa- miliar with the poet. There is also a preface to the work by a friend of the edi- tor, who styles himself Chiku-fu, or “The Wind in the Bamboo,” and who compares Goethe to a kettle into which all kinds of metal have been poured and melted to ef- fect his unique genius. The Japanese, says Chiku-fu, are very fond of Heine, whom they know rather well, but he is only a sort of shuju or ‘“Confucius-disciple” of Goethe, and between Heine and his master there is as much difference as between earth and heaven. Two more volumes in the Arthur H. Clark Co.’s reprints, “Barly Western Trav- els, 1748-1846," embrace three interesting narratives; the longest, Gregg’s ‘Commerce of the Prairies (1802-1839),’ being also the most valuable—indeed, a well-established classic, accurate and well written. This author describes the barbarous New Mexi- can sport of eorrer el gallo, which still sur- vives (or did up to the civil war) in our Southern States as ‘‘gander-pulling.”” Gregg has also a brief sec'ion on the Mormon s¢t- tlement in Independence, Mo., but has most to tell of the aborigines and the fauna of their country as observed by a veteran trader of the Santa Fé Trail. A New Bedford Quaker, George W. Ogden, re- lates his experiences as tourist and so- journer in the Oblo Valley, ‘Letters from the West, 1821-23." The common sights of slavery on the Southern side of the river draw from him strong expressiong of hu- mane displeasure as well as of pride in his sect’s testimonies against slavery; he devotes a closing section to this subjec*. W. Bullock, an intelligent Englishman, keen for natural curiosities for his mu- seum, supplies a ‘Journey from New Or- leans to New York, 1827,’ which has for its chief feature (though of minor interest) a description of Niagara Falls. Various causes have delayed our noticing three sump‘uous folio volumes which we owe to the courtesy of the State Department of Mexico, entitled ‘Mexico: Its Social Evo lution.” Plain “History’’ would have a swered as well as “Evolution,’’ as the pu lishers (Mexico: J. BalleschA & Co.) seem to feel. The original composition was } Spanish, in 1899, for the cose of th tury; and the retrospect has been worth translating into English. It was po; +h ularly conceived and entrusted » Many hands, as is usually the ease in such album works; and this involved some repetitions witness the Mexican war, to which there a return under “The National Army.’ Th most valuable chapter we judge to be that on “The Public Treasury,”’ so large a factor in Mexican history of the pas: half cen tury; and with it we should couple the chap- ter on “National Education,”’ though it is one of the most poorly translated. The work was set up and printed in Barcelona, and while literal errors are comparatively few a faulty idiom throughout makes teadinog dificult, to say nothing of the Spanish Lit rary habit, which manifests itself in need less abstractions and verbiage The lack of a genera! index is to be regretted. There are two folding maps of Mexico, one for het railroads, and a great profusion of proces: llustrations of a high order, including nu merous portraits. From these last and from the architectural views Americans may a quire a chastening respect for the villza tion of our Southern neighbor The books on Egypt written sinc great Napoleon virtually rediscovered |: and hie savants for the first time tried to dese %e scientifically its physical fea tures and archeological treasures, would fill a large library Some of them, like Eliot Warburton’s ‘Crescent and the Cros were written under the inspiration of a enthusiastic afflatus which gave a rosy color to the most commonplace scenes but others, like H. W. Dunning’s ‘To-day on the Nile’ (James Pott & Co.), were mere handbooks of travel. In a dahabiyeh which was the only vehicle for travel ou the Nile half a century ago, and which is still the most delightful, a traveller may dream away three months of delicious leis- ure and intellectual enjoyment while cove: ing the same iength of river as is plough ed in a fortnight by a steamer filled with a noisy. unsympathetic crowd of tourists who are hurried from temple to temple and from tomb to tomb by a dragomano with a kurbash The traveller in th dahabiyeh will take beside his Wilkinson Maspero, and Budge, his Warburton a1’ Prime and Amelia Edwards; but the tripo- per on the Cook boat or the Anglo-Amer! can steamer cannot do better than pre pare for his journey by reading Mr. Dur- ning’s popular but scholarly chapters on Egyptian history and mythology; and, aa he rushes about, he will have no more than leisure enough to supplement and even to correct the harangue of the dragoman by Mr. Dunning’s concise dec- scription of what he will see, for the phy - sical fatigue of exhausting Egypt In a for' night leaves neither time nor power for thought. ‘Animal Heroes,’ by Ernest Thompron Seton (Scribners), gives the histories of a cat, a dog, a pigeon, a lynx, a rabbit, two wolves, and a reindeer. The stories are more or less composite the author say but are each founded on the life of a veritable animal hero. “A hero is an in- dividual of unusual gifts and achievements.

Page 16

34 The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2116 Whether it be man or animal, this defini- tion applies; and it is the histories of such that appeal to the imagination and to the hearts of those who hear them.”’ Mr. Seton thus defines his subject and his literary aim. Probably few readers will unsettie their enjoyment of his stories over the question whether it is he or Mr. Burroughs that is right about the existence of animal heroes, or whether they see his animals in the light of his fancy or that of com- mon day. He does touch the heart and the imagination, his methods are not sensa- tional, his literdry art is excellent, his knowledge is wide. Of all the modern nature students in whom the human in- terest in wild creatures dominates the merely scientific interest, he is, in Mr. Bur- roughs’s opinion, the best, though with “romantic tendencies’ that must be re- membered when one reads his works as natural history Ernest Crosby's ‘Garrison the Non-Re- sistant’ (Chicago: The Public Publishing Co.) is in effect one of the now rather numerous minor biographies of that phil- anthropist. It is not, however, structurally organic; one part has, avowedly, been pub- lished before, and probably several. Thus, chapter v. is on “The Civil War,” but also chapter x. is on “Garrison and the Civil War.” There is much desultory discussion of whether war was the best way to end slavery, and of the politico-social results of the war at the South, disfranchisement, lynching, etc. This gives the little volume the aspect of a tract, but, if not strictly pertinent, it is often suggestive, as, con- spicuously, the story of the Beast book at page 108 In the personal narrative there are several minor errors of fact, and at page 16 it is implied that the doctrine of immediatism was first urged by Garrison in the Liberator instead of in the Genius of Universal Emancipation. The apocryphal story of slapping a soldier on the back (p. 85) shows a defective criterion of testi- mony; slapping any one on the back was not Mr. Garrison's style. The point of view selected by Mr. Crosby is perfectly just, being fundamental; but, as a whole, his presentation cannot compare with that other, also of Tolstoyan non-resistant pro- venance, Tchertkoff and Holah's admirable ‘Short Biography,’ published in London in 1904 Miss Ella Noyes, who contributed an ex- cellent volume on Ferrara to the ‘Mediaeval Towns” series, has written ‘The Casentino and its Story’ (London: Dent; New York: E. P. Dutton), a book in which picturesque description and historical reminiscence are pretty equally blended. The Casentino, it need hardly be said, is that beautiful region of the upper Arno, shut in by mountains, which abounds in scenery, old towns and castles, and in rich associations. Vallom- brosa looks down into the valley on the west, La Verna, the rock of St. Francis, guards it on the east. Dante, who spent part of his exile here, immortalized the brooks of the Casentino in one line of “Hell,” and fought In the battle at Cam- paldino. Here the Counts Guidi, Dante's friends and patrons, upheld the Ghibelline cause. Here St. Romualdo founded the first monastery of the Camaldoll. Miss Noyes describes all this, and much more, with enthusiasm. She has an unusual talent for making pen pictures of scenery vivid, and she seems to have overlooked none of the literary, artistic, or historical memorabilia of the valley. If at times her material is spun rather thin, that is a defect inevitable in works of this kind. The illustrations, by Miss Dora Noyes, really add to the interest of the book. There are twenty-five full- page sketches in color, and as many more line drawings which give the true Tuscan quality of scene, of tone, and of peasant life. The Clarendon Press (New York: H. Frowde) publishes a very beautiful collo- type reproduction of the Bodleian manu- script of Jerome's Latin version of the Chronica of Eusebius. The editor, Mr. John Knight Fotheringham of King’s College, London, has written an Introduction and four critical appendices, showing most careful examination of the manuscript and thorough comparison of it with all others known to exist. Two other appendices, by Dr. R. L. Poole and Mr. C. H. Turner, add greatly to the interest of the publication. The appendix of Mr. Turner is a biblio- graphical study of Bishop Jean du Tillet of Meaux (d. 1570). The December Bulletin of the New York Public Library contains a notable list of its works relating to woman in the several manifestations of her training, talents, oc- cupations, and aspirations. One _ subdi- vision consists of a ‘Dictionnaire de la Femme: Encyclopédie manuel des connais- sances utiles A la femme’ (Paris, 1877); an ‘Illustrirtes Konversations-Lexikon der Frau’ (Berlin, 1900); and a ‘Dictionnaire des Préciceuses’ (Paris, 1856). We have already announced the Univer- sity of Chicago’s two new periodical ven- tures, Classical Philology (quarterly) and the Classical Journal (monthly, November to June). The prospectuses now before us show in the editorship a very distinguished array of American scholars, impartially distributed among the universities, to- gether with Prof. Wallace M. Lindsay of St. Andrews, Scotland. The managing edi- tor is Edward Capps. We are told that “in so far as Classical Philology shall fulfil its object, it may be looked upon as an offshoot of the American Journal of Philology, and as a witness to [Professor Gildersleeve’s] influence upon American classical scholarship." The Classical Jour- nal will Se directed by the Classical Asso- clation of the Middle West and South, and will meet the wants of teachers. The man- aging editors are Gordon J. Laing and Ar- thur Fairbanks at the University of Chi- cago. The Balkan conditions were graphically described by Mr. James Bryce in a recent address before the Balkan Committee, of which he has been president for three years. From the fact that he spent some weeks last autumn in Macedonia and Bul- gatia, additional force was given to his statements. He eaid that there was no open war nor massacres on such a scale as those of two years ago, but in many dis- tricts isolated murders are frequent. “At present, no native’s life or property is safe." As to the success of the new scheme for financial control, he could not express a confident opinion; but unless constant pressure is exerted to carry its provisions into effect, t will be of little use. ‘The lo- cal officials will do nothing unless such pressure is steadily applied. Indeed, they can do nothing; for what strikes one on visiting the country is that even the better officials—and sometimes the Turkish of- ficials are honest, well-meaning men—can accomplish little, because they are thwart- ed in good or compelled to do wrong by orders from Constantinople.” He empha- sizes the absolute need of doing everything to induce the Christian races to abandon their guerrilla warfare, which is lamentable in itself and ruinous to their common cause, and profitable only to the Turkish Government, which does its best to foment the strife. If conditions are not improved it will be impossible to prevent a war be- tween Bulgaria and Turkey. The little mountain principality of Mon- tenegro has entered upon a new era in her eventful history. Prince Nicholas has abolished the autocratic and patriarchal system of government which he inherited and has administered for forty-six years, and has substituted in its place a parlia- mentary system. In a proclamation issued last October, the opening paragraph of which asserts that “every man belonging to civilized society should be a free citi- zen,” he calls upon “my gallant people” to select Deputies: “Let them assemble around me; I shall teach them their duties, and by our united action we shall bring about a great development of the liberties and prosperity of our country.” On No- vember 27 there was elected one Deputy from each of the fifty-six military dis- tricts and four towns; the Prince reserv- ing to himself the nomination of six min- isters of state and three ecclesiastical Deputies, representing the Orthodox, Ro- man Catholic, and Mussulman churches. Various reasons have been assigned by friendly and hostile critics for this extra- crdinary step on the part of the Prince. The main causes of the present anti- foreign movement in China have been ascribed to Japan’s victory over a Euro- pean Power, the influence of Chinese stu- dents educated in Japan, and the leniency, interpreted as a sign of weakness, with which our Government has treated the boy- cott. A British merchant who has closely studied the situation during a recent busi- ness tour through the leading cities of China, calls attention (in a letter to the London Times) to another significant way in which the movement is being fostered by the Pekin authorities. The Dowager Empress not long ago issued an edict can- celling the old curriculum for the official examinations, and ordering examinations in Western learning in their stead, with- out, however, providing for the details of such a vital change in the established or- der of things. The result is that all those Chinese men of letters who, in the ordi- nary course of things, would have become officials, are deprived of their careers, and are converted into a mass of discontented men spreading all over the Empire. In addition, some 200 printing-presses, former- ly employed in printing text-books and educational matter under the old system, are idle, and the employees are added to the malcontents. The writer points out that this state of things strongly resem- bles that produced by the reformed edict - which preceded the Boxer outbreak of 1900. Mile. Dosne, the sister-in-law and heir- ess of Thiers, has presented to the Insti- tute the famous historic H6tel Thiers in Paris, together with the bequtiful gardens surrounding it on the Place St. Georges, with the proviso that it is to be used as a

Page 17

a Se - Ah le A rc etn Yi Jan. 18, 1906] The Nation. 55 library of historical writings. The ven- erable lady, who is known as the editor of Thiers's ‘Notes et Souvenirs,’ has already established the “Fondation Thiers’ for the stimulation of university students. The new gift is the famous structure that on two occasions, in 1870 and in 1871, was about to be demolished by the Paris rab- ble, and was saved only by being declared to be “national property.”” When the Commune was crushed, the demolition was already under way, and Thiers had a good deal of trouble in restoring the structure. —Last July a weekly journal of reputable standing and wide circulation printed in facsimile, with an accompanying article, a part of a Cape Fear Mercury of June 3, 1775, containing resolutions purporting to be those adopted by a convention held in Mecklenburg County, N. C., on May 20, de- claring independence of the crown of Great Britain. At first sight the article, written by one unknown among writers on history, S. Millington Miller, seemed a bit of mid- summer madness, intended to amuse by an historical fiction. The tone of it, however, and the number of documents reproduced, carried weight, and. aroused much interest in the South, where the tradition of such a convention and declaration has persist- ed for a century. The Mercury was sought by many, and large sums were offered for it if proof of its being genuine could be furnished. Finally, the Historical Com- mission asked Mr. Worthington C. Ford, head of the manuscripts division in the Library of Congress to study the news- paper held by Miller. His report was that the document was a forgery, a very clever one in its general manufacture, and that the evidence presented in support of it by Miler could not bear examination. It is hardly possible that a sale will now be made, but it is unfortunate that some steps cannot be taken to impound such a forgery and punish the forger. —‘The Bird Watcher in the Shetlands, with Some Notes on Seals—and Digres- sions,’ by Edmund Selous (E. P. Dutton & Co.), is a summer continuation, made two years later, of the spring studies of lit- tle-known Northern sea-birds recorded in the author’s ‘Bird-Watching.’ Mr. Selous has his own place among natural'sts, by virtue of his unfamiliar fields, his o. iginal- ity of thought, and his power of giving to truly scientific matter the medium of a strong and cultivated literary style. This last distinction may well belong to a wil- derness-lover and book-lover, whose idea of an earthly paradise is “the veldt or Bra- zilian forests, or Lapland or the Spanish Marisma, with the British Museum library round the corner.” A close student of na- ture and of Darwin, Mr. Selous is a kind of scientific free-thinker, a zodlogist with- out gun or cabinet, who goes afield pre- pared to see and to think. He unites with faithfulness of observation considerable boldness of speculative theory. He finds going on among individuals of certain spe- cies gradual change and differentiation, which he regards as stages of evolution; for instance, he Selieves that the influence of sexual selection is modifying the plain, dark Arctic skwa into a beautiful light- colored bird. He maintains that the same influence has evolved the brilliant color of the buceal cavity of several Northern spe- cies, through the nuptial habit, common to both sexes, of opening wide the beak. He argues, too, for a process of inter-sexual selection—the male, also, exercising choice —in species of which the sexes closely re- semble each other, or of which the sexes differ markedly and are both handsome. His studies of a guillemot chick and of the play and repose of seals are delightful, and show how a naturalist may have sympathy and imagination, yet refrain from too subjec- tive an “interpretation.” Altogether, the book commends itself for unusual sugges- tiveness and interest. —Daniel Webster, the Expounder of the Constitution,’ is the title of a volume by Everett P. Wheeler (G. P. Putnam's Sons). It is at the same time a memorial by an enthusiastic professional admirer of Web- ster, and a convenient manual for any one who wishes to get in a small com- pass a view of Webster's career as ex pounder. Of the importance of the part he played in the development of our con- stitutional system there cannot be two opinions, and he will always share with Marsball the fame of having laid the foun- dations on which our existing régime has been built. By taking in their order the leading cases in which he was engaged, Mr Wheeler is able to direct the reader's at- tention to all the great stages in Web- ster’s forensic career, and bring out his extraordinary gifts and industry, as they reveal themselves to the sharpest of all critices—those of his own profession Be- sides being a great Constitutional lawyer, he was a great publicist in any field to which he turned his mind, and no doubt a companion monograph equally striking, to those familiar with the ground, might be made from his diplomatic papers. Mr. Wheeler seems to think that as a states- man, also, his fame is or ought to be no less high than in either of the two more restricted flelds, and he appears to believe that the Seventh of March speech illustrated only Webster's devotion to ideals, just as his argument in the Dart- mouth College case illustrated his mastery of Constitutional law. This is rot the common opinion, and not even Mr. Wheel- er’s zeal can make us believe that it will become so. We get here into the most contentious of all political arenas—that of a country brought to the verge of a civil war by a great historical abuse in- trenched in its law and Constitution. Mr. Wheeler may be right in thinking that Webster's ideas about slavery were not essentially different from the very conserv- ative views originally held by Lincoln, but Webster's conservatism helped slavery, while Lincoln's discovered a means to de- stroy it; Webster lost us the road, while Lincoln found it for us again. In great crises a public man’s disposition is often of more importance than his ideas. —The Civil Service and Patronage’ (Long- mans, Green & Co.) is the title of a care- ful and useful historical study by Carl Rus- sell Fish. The problem of civil-service reform has been treated not from the standpoint of expediency, but by giving fully the development of policy and prac- tice as to patronage and the civil service, from the foundation of the Government to the present day. A final chapter is devoted to the present status of the civil-service reform movement. Not enough attention has been paid to the long agitation which preceded the adoption of the new system, and we do not clearly make out whether the author's examination should lead us to think that the vast number of unclas- sified positions will be brought within the rules by the natural progress of events, or that they are, under the operation of a natural law of politics, to remain ‘“‘spoile.” The considerations bearing on this are certainly important, both practically and historically, but they are not often ad- verted to. That the reform should have had the great success we see, allhough the ag! tation was devoid of wide popular backing, the author attributes to its inherently democratic character, and also to the fact that it is essentially a change in the di- rection of business-like management, which he thinks a feature of all American life to-day as compared with what was Amer ican fifty years ago. The old colonial founders knew what was a good civil ser vice, and that it Involved established ten ure, by the instinct of a governing class of inherited traditions We know it, be cause we are all more or less veraed in business methods. Jackson and his co horts, between the two periods, were bar barian hordes, who swept away the earlier civil service, and established the spoils system in government as barbarians ¢s tablish it everywhere. If this view i# cor- rect, the optimist will look forward to all the unclassified offices being brought with in the system; the pessimist, however, who thinks the root of our barbarism (o be in universal suffrage (also a product of the middle period), will not be convinced until he sees it done —In ‘Madame Geoffrin, her Salon and her Times,’ by Janet Aldis (London: Methuen New York: Putuams), we find a number of entertaining episodes and anecdotes con cerning literary or other notabilities o eighteenth-century France compiled from the usual well-known sources mentioned ia the bibliography, with the strange omis sion, however, of Sainte-Beuve. The per sonality of Madame Geoffrin is, in deed, almost obscured here and there, as we try to follow her in the throng of her guests, whom she admittedly ruled, direct- ed, and even controlled with perhaps more adroitness than any of her rivals. Much care has been given to the coitrdination of events into, as it were, a moving picture of the time; and some of the chapters, such as the vicissitudes that befell the ‘Encyclo- pédie’ (ch. x.) and the imprisonment of Mar montel (ch. xill.) are conducted with spirit and humor. The estimate of Grimm is some- what inadequate and cold, for the Gallicized German proved his real worth in many delicate and trying circumstances Revi- sion by a trained French hand would have reduced errors of detail. Maréchata (p xiii.) is neither English nor French; blonde et blanc (p. 37), Harengs fraises (p. 72), de vroté (p. 87), @ dimanche (p. 101), cette homme n'cat bon pas qu'd manger du veau (p. 212) might be deemed errors in proof-reading, did we not find (p. 172) a passage which seems to indicate the author's belief that quinconce is French for “‘quince-tree.” One may note that she makes no remark on the fact that the social power of women was never more gladly accepted than in the age which gave such influence the sanction of consent, not of legislative enactment

Page 18

56 The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2116 “The German translation (by Richard Palleske) of the book on ‘Iceland at the Beginning of the Twentieth Century,’ by the Icelandic scholar and member of the Althing, Vaktyr Gudmundsson, has, thanks to the difference in time of appearance, cer- taln advantages over its original, even for those who read Danish with the same ease as German. The author gives here, in about 160 pages, a brief, but fairly exhaustive and profusely illustrated, account of Iceland's status at the beginning of the present cen- tury, with a synopsis of the development, luring the last century, in population, pub- lic life, education, literature and art, fi- nances, industries, means of communication, sanitary conditions, and charities. To this ire added samples of Icelandic prose and poetry in German translation, as well as ome hints for travellers in Iceland. Dr. Gudmundsegon was the prime mover of that amendment in the Icelandic Constitution of 1874 which was finally adopted in the year 1903, changing the seat of the minister for iceland from Copenhagen to Reykjavik. Ice- land is a vast and barren country, but a large part of that lack of energy which eems to be characteristic of a majority of its population, must doubtless be ascribed to the unhappy conditions under which the people have lived, subject to the will of a foreign ruler and nation, who, when they have not been bent upon exploiting the country, as was the case in the eighteenth entury, had only a slight understanding of and interest in the needs of the inhabitants. It i therefore, interesting to note what progress the country has made since, in 1874, it obtained a sort of semi-indepen- dence, and was thus enabled to take such measures within its means as were most likely to advance the material and intellec- tual welfare of the people. Roads and bridges have been built, schools and hos- pitals have been erected, telephones have been introduced, the steamship connection with the outside world has been regulated, and a cable connection with Europe is in t fair way of being brought about, The population of the island was, in 1901, about 80,000, showing a considerable gain during the last decade, due to the fact that the emigration to America has almost ceased. There are in America (chiefly in Manitoba ind North Dakota) about 20,000 Icelanders, vho have here several churches and news- paper if their own Sik WEMYSS REID'S MEMOIRS Vemoire of Sir Wemyss Reid, 1842-1885 Edited, with an Introduction, by Stuart J). Reid. With portrait in photogravure Cassell & Co. 1905. Pp. xxxvi., 396 Wemyss Reid was potable as a literary man, & blographer, and a writer of fiction Hut his Memoirs are chiefly important as hose of the editor of the Leeds Mercury, a powerful paper of the moderate Liberal chool in a stirring time He flourished in what was perhaps the palmiest epoch of British journalliam, when the editor of a great journal himself directed its policy and was a statesman of the pen, not a mere organist or the manager of a Yellow oncern rhe Leeds Mercury was the property of he Baines family, a house memorable in way. Edward Baines the first was a young printer whose gifts the original pro- prietor of the journal had recognized with the best results. Edward Baines the sec- ond, who afterwards edited the paper, was a politician as well as an editor. He sat in Parliament tor Leeds, but lost his seat through the fanaticism of Proh.bitionists, who, enraged at his moderation, voted against him, and as a result got a local brewer elected in his place. The Baines family were Liberals of the moderate school, Nonconformists and Puritans. As Puritans, they showed their faith by excluding from their paper, no doubt at a considerable sac- rifice, betting news and theatricals. If their example in excluding betting news had been followed, the country might have been saved fron one of its worst pests. The exclusion of theatricals was clearly a Puri- tan error. The theatre must live and have its influence. It is for the press to take care that its influence shall be moral. Wemyss Reid was the son of a clergyman at Newcastle-upon-Tyne. He wags sent to a school in Scotland, a circumstance to which we owe a charming little picture of a Scotch Sabbath (p. 6): “It was on Sunday, however, that the full severity of the Scotch Puritanism of that day made itself felt in my inmost soul. Oh, the dreary monotony of those Sabbaths at St. Andrews! The long, long service and yet longer sermon in the fore- noon, the funereal procession of the congre-~ gation to their homes, the hasty meal, con- sisting chiefly of tea and cold, hard-boiled eges, which took the place of dinner, and the return within a few minutes to the kirk, where the vitiated atmosphere left by the morning congregation had not yet pass- ed away. Even when the second service had come to a close, the solemnities of the day were not ended, for the Sunday-school met in the late afternoon, and remained in session for a couple of hours. “But it was not the public services, ter- rible though these were, that formed the most depressing feature of Sunday in St. Andrews; it was the rigid discipline which pervaded her home life. My grandfather, I believe, was looked upon as being some- what lax in his religious views, and he was undoubtedly more liberal—perhaps one might say more advanced—than many of his neighbors. Yet even he had to ren- der homage to the universal law. So when Sunday came round, the blinds were close- ly drawn, lest the rays of the sun should dissipate the gloom befitting the solemn day, whilst no voice in the household was raised above a sepulchral whisper. Lucky for me was it that I was sent to bed early, and that thus the horrors of the Sabbath were in my case abbreviated. The o’der members of the family sat in a silent semi- circle round the smouldering fire, each holding, and some possibly reading, a book, the suitableness of which for use at such a time was beyond question. The Bible. the metrical version of the Psalms, and one or two volumes of discourses by di- vines of undoubted orthodoxy, formed the only literature recognized on these occa- sions. For myself, I had brought with me from home a copy of the delightful, though now-forgotten, book called ‘Evenings at Home,’ and my Sabbatical sufferings were intensified by the sight of this volume on a high bookshelf, where it remained beyond my reach from Saturday night till Mon- day morning.” Reid was at first put as clerk into a commercial house, but his aspirations were literary, especially journalistic. They were fulfilled. He became a reporter and a writer at the same time; then editor of the Preston Guardian, and at last of the Leeds Mercury. As a reporter he made a slip which might have been serious in reporting a speech of Lord Russell on the American civil war. Russel] sald that in the New World was seen that which had been so often seen in the Old World—a struggle, on the one side for independence, and on the other side for power. The reporter, being rather dazed, misconstrued the symbol for independence and made Russell say: “A struggle on the one side for empire and on the other for power.” Fortunately, the misreport made nonsense, Gladstone's slip, which also occurred in a speech at Newcastle, might otherwise have been doubled. The member of the Baines dynasty on whom the editorship of the Mercury naturally devolved, became a Plymouth Brother, or, as a lady by a slip of the tongue called him, “a Yarmouth Bloater.” He deemed editorship inconsistent with his religious profession, and Weymss Reid was taken in his place. As the district organ of moderate Liberalism, the Leeds Mercury collided with the extreme Radical party, then head- ed by Mr. Chamberlain, whose principles the Tories compared, without much ex- aggeration, to those of Jack Cade. The first encounter was in the case of the Sheffield election (p. 210): “At Sheffield a candidate came forward in the extreme Radical interest, whose speeches attracted some notice in York- shire, though they passed unobserved by the larger public beyond. This was Mr. Joseph Chamberlain, who now made his first attempt to win Parliamentary honors. Up to that moment I had only known Mr. Chamberlain as a young Birmingham poli- tician, who was fond of saying things both bitter and flippant, not onlv about his po- litical opponents, but about the older mem- bers of his own party. He had made him- self one of the fuglemen in the cry raised against Mr., Forster, towards whom he seemed to entertain a feeling of almost personal antipathy. At Sheffield he made himself conspicuous by his sneers at Mr. Gladstone and almost all the recognized leaders of Liberalism. His own political opinions appeared to be based upon a crude and intolerant Radicalism of the Sccialistic type. He evidently believed that promises of material benefits would enable him to win the support of the mass of tLe elec- tors, and he conceived also that the best method of displacing his seniors in the party of which he was a member was to assail them with a rather coarse invec- tive.” Mr. Chamberlain was then forming in each of the cities a ‘Radical caucus to con- trol the local politics of his party and neminate its candidate for Parliament; Birmingham being the centre of the whole, and the constructor of the Machine being its master, into whose hands the represen- tation of the cities would thus have come. The extension of this mechanism to Leeds inevitably brought on a struggle between a master of the caucus and the editor of the organ of moderate Liberalism, in which Reid seems to have pretty much held his own. He was evidently a man o? force, as well as of principle. A special object of Reid's admiration as a type of moderate Liberalism was W. E. Forster, a man unquestionably of high principle and of solid qualities, prevented, perhaps, from rising to the highest place by his extreme want of social tact and un- couthness of manner. Forster, by taking a middle course on the subject of national education, had incurred the political hos- tility of Mr. Chamberlain and Mr. Morley, who were allies, as might be gathered, by negative evidence at least, from some pas- sages of Mr. Morley’s ‘Life of Gladstone.’ -- oe

Page 19

A atte Se oe ere: Jan. 18, 1906] Wemyss Reid states positively that the Patt Mall Gazette, edited by Mr. Morley, became virtually the mouthpiece of Mr. Chamberlain. It is very unlikely that Mr. Morley would have allowed the journal! of which he was the brilliant editor to be- come anybody’s mouthpiece but his own; still more that he would have allowed it to become anything like the instrument of an intrigue of a member of the Government against a colleague who was desperately struggling against disaffection in Ireland. We are to have some day a further instal- ment of Reid’s Memoirs, with revelations of certain phases in the annals of the Lib- eral party which may be expected to throw light on the dark subject of the extrusion of Forster from the Cabinet. Of John Morey, Reid says (p. 283): “The charm of John Morley’s manner, and the brightness of his talk, have been felt and acknowledged by all who have been brought into contact with him, and it would be superfluous on my part to say anything about his literary reputation. But I have always felt that neither his fine gifts nor his peculiar temperament were suited for the rough and tumble of political warfare I have felt this whether I have been, as has often happened, marching behind him in thorough unison with his opinions, or, as has also occurred at times, directly opposed to him and to his policy.” Reid was perhaps not alone in this opin- ion. But the answer is that the “rough- and-tumble” element is sufficiently large to bear the infusion of a little high mo- rality even in a philosophic form If Forster was Reid's demigod, Gladstone was his god. He has given us astonishing proofs of the great man’s powers as a popu- lar—it would be profane to say stump— speaker. At the election of 1880, Gladstone ran for Midlothian, which became the scene of a miraculous display of his oratorical powers. But his party at Leeds elected him there also, that in case of his rejection at Midlothian he might have a seat. He after- wards came to thank Leeds, and there spoke to an audience of thirty thousand people crowded into a temporary building literally to suffocation, so that holes had to be brok- en ia the roof to give them air. The hub- bub was deafening (p. 297): “But suddenly Mr. Gladstone raised his hand, and it was almost as if a miracle had happened. In an instant there was a deathlike silence in the hall, and every man in it seemed to be holding his breath. The speaker's voice rang out, clear and musical as of old, and it reached to the furthest corners of the mighty apartment. But he had not got further than the con- ventional opening words when his audience seemed to go mad with delight. A frenzied burst of cheering, far exceeding that which had welcomed him on his first appearance, proclaimed the joy with which they had heard the voice of the man they adored. Again it was some minutes before Mr. Gladstone was allowed to proceed, but once more his uplifted hand ensured silence, and from that moment until he had reached the end of an hour's speech, every syllable that he uttered was heard distinctly by his thir- ty thousand listeners. It was, I think, the passionate eagerness of the audience to hear his voice, and their outburst of delight when its notes first fell upon their ears, that formed the most striking feature of that great meeting.” At the public dinner Gladstone was ob- served, before rising to speak, to cover his face for some time with his hands. Mrs Gladstone afterwards explained that he had been praying. and that such was his habit. There can be no doubt that religion was to — eee The Nation. him a real motive-power and a support io all the trying moments of his life. Other interesting characters appear, among them Cowen, the Radical philan- thropist of Newcastle, champion of oppress- ed nationalities and of all victims of tyr- auny throughout the world At Cowen's house Reid met the Italian revolutionists, among them Orsini, to whom Cowen un- wittingly supplied the funds for the attempt on the life of the French Emperor. Reid was ravished with Orsini’s personal beau- ty. Cowen was an eccentric man of genius and very eloquent. though he spoke with a Northumbrian burr, which he seems to have cherished as democratic, and which, when he had finished a splendid speech and won loud applause, gave Disraeli an opening for the supercilious remark that he was sorry that the speech, which appeared to have created enthusiasm, was in a language which he did not understand. There can be little doubt that Orsini frightened the French Emperor into going to war for the liberation of Italy—a rare instance of a good end attained by criminal means. The second instalment of the Memoirs, when it comes, is likely to be of political import ance. THE RUSSIAN CRISIS Russia and its Crisis. By Paul Miliukov (Crane Lectures for 1903.) London: T Fisher Unwin; The University of Chicago Press. 1905. It is difficult to find words strong enough adequately to express the inestimable value of Professor Miliukoff’s book for every one desirous of understanding Russia in the past, the present, and the future. It is hard reading—even hard to grasp as 4 se- rious text-book, which is its real character; but it will repay all the study that may be bestowed upon it. It lays bare the historical soul of the country, so to speak, in all its intricate recesses, which are, practically, inaccessible to a foreigner In the present apparent topsy-turvydom and labyrinth of politics and party-combinations, it offers both the only and the all-sufficient guide, and demonstrates logical sequence, where both logic and sequence would often appear to be utterly lacking, by furnishing the historical clue. Moreover, it is illuminat- ing in the highest degree, because of the apt compariéons instituted § at points between Russian and American con- ditions; and, being brought down to date, in effect (February 12, 1905), it offers the latest practicable information on general lines which can be required The author himself is the best type of modern Russian-learned, liberal, reason- able; neither a violent agitator nor a blind supporter of the autocracy whose inevit- ableness and gradual development from imperative conditions he so ably sets forth His careful definition of the two (morally) distinct Russias now in conflict for the con- trol is worthy of especial attention, in contrast with the unsatisfactory vagueness of similar attempts on the part of less well-informed and accurate thinkers. After Stating them to be: the Russia of Leo Tolstoy, of the “intellectuals,” liberty, the people, the future; and the Russia of Plehve, official, an anachronism deeply rooted in the past, despotism, he explains that Tolstoy's system of Christian anar- various OT ohiam merely stands as the synonym for liberty in general, the negation of abs lutigsm only, not as a system in itself. et the “intellectuals’’ care little for the ¢ tlan element, and vo anarchism ex Russia What he doe no add connection, bul wha “0 worth ad x is, that many Russiatr who are deve ly attached to Christianity and ‘ na na Church and entirely out of yinpathy with Tolstoy (except a i great | a ‘ are loyal adherents of liberal Ru " en to the apparent inconsistency of rema g still, perforce, attached to the haied } reaucracy. It is encouraging ut the friends of Russia and pros general to have the opinio expert as Professor Miliukoff that all the much-condemned mere ailments of growth (which ha ways existed), and that mot one able, any more than are the evils o apid growth in the United States, which a sort of parallel in many respect Nothing in the volume is of more yp» nent interest than the consecutive stration of the perfectiy natural, inevitable development of the autocracy forced uy the infant, adolescent and full-grown ate by geographical conditions and the lack of barriers against attacks from without which rendered a powerful central orgar zation of the government absolutely nece sary. Equaliy instructive is the picture of the essential difference between the R sian and the American type of chara which, under somewhat parallel na conditions, has led to radically op; results in the exploitation of resourc: and their present condition A certa phousness, a certain plasticity in R manners and character h regard ‘ the chief feature in the national typ« ul to that, the sole though negatiw he ance from the past, he attribuls ly everything good or bad w) ever been asserted abou the na il character, by both foreign and natiy servers ‘A backbone is m ng both in Russian virtues and Russian vice he says, declaring tha to ts flex bility, its accessibility to every new impression, are due both the good and the bad traits of the national type, and that Russian history has not furnished enough social education to provide the body of clal tradition which works out the formula that may act as stimulus or coercion, The is a lack of continuity in the social tion. In discussing the origin, growth, an various currents of The Nationaliatic Idea,”’ our author makes an ijluminating comparison, which is invaluable as a clue to general study of Russia and to the cau of its tardy progress “Between Russia and other Buropean countries the contrast was not so gr ai the moment of their first meeting. som centuries ago. as it is perhaps now fh tween Japan and the Europe of to-da Therefore the contrast between naltiona, ism and foreign culture could not be four! out in Russia in such a rapid and resolut: way, and the victory over ofd tradition could not be 80 soon and completely wou as would be the case to-day Instead that, there followed a long pro of compromise and assimilation, whic n Russia is even yet not completed When Professor Miliukoff undertak: 0 consider “The Religious Tral't ! proaches the subject from the

Page 20

58 The Nation. [ Vol. 82, No. 2116 at least semi-hostile) point of view fre- quently adopted by educated Russians, who include the Church in their hearty dislike of existing institutions, and thus some- times fail to render full justice to that which must, inevitably, in all countries, be understood by a sense other than the purely intellectual. He also fails to bear in mind the parallel conditions and action elsewhere For example, he refers to the services in the case of illness and so ferth as “magic rites and solemn incanta- tions” to expel the evil spirits, which he says, the village priests perform to- day exactly as the first bishop of the monastery in Kiev did in the eleventn century. He might have made his com- parison strenger (though even less con vincing on the “magic’’ side) by referring to Christ's expulsion of devils as the cause of disease in the New Testament, and to similar services in other Christian church es. He appears to forget, also, that Rus- sia and the Eastern Church are not alone in having adopted and adapted pagan fes- tivals and in their dealings with the an- client pagan gods; and that the Russiac Church is no more amorphous in its con- ception of God and the saints, or no more realistic in its pictorial representations of them, than are other branches of the Chris- tian Church, to which the reader is led to assume (by implication) it is fatally inferior in many of the respects enumerat- ed. It would require more space than is at our command to enter into the matter in the deta which such unfairness— whether voluntary or involuntary—justly demands; but we may characterize the whole presentment of the religious ques- thon as resembling the reflection beheld in a skewed mirror. Even the summary of the old attitude toward poverty, the quo- tations from the writings of an ancient popular theologian, the description of the Church as “a kind of Eternal Life Insur- ance,”’ could be used with equal justice and effectiveness of any other Christian com- munity; and if the labels were omitted, their origin could not possibly be divined by the keenest experts. Nevertheless, if one is already sufficiently well informed to be able to discriminate, there is much valuable and curious information not read- ily obtainable elsewhere, to be gleaned from this chapter. For instance, after de- ascribing a sect established in the second half of the eighteenth century by “a vaga- bond dreamer, Euphemius” (Evhimy), in- cluding his theory of the land, Professor Miliukoff calla attention to the fact that this fugitive soldier anticipated Count L. N. Tolstoy's doctrine of Christian anarch- lem by one hundred years When he deals with “The Political Tradi- tion’’ he is on firmer ground, and clearly demonstrates the assertion with which he starts, that the idea cherished by the Rus- sian nationalists, to the effect that au- tocracy never has changed and is unchange- able, is wholly erroneous. He shows that the theory is of very recent origin; and incidentally he sets forth the facts concern- ing the successive degradation of the aris tocrats and the elevation of the lower classes by which the autocracy was clever- ly maintained. This point has not been hitherto presented to the foreign student; if at all, certainly never so lucidly or in so thorough a degree. Arising in necessity for preservation of the State, considered as so impregnable in practice that no legal authority for it was ever sought, or even exists, the autocracy is shown to have be- come logically impossible as well as un- necessary at the present day. The innu- meraDle lines in which autocracy had come to exercise irresistible authority before it was recently abolished by the Imperial de- cree, are described, with pertinent in- stances, judiciously selected, and all the more convincing because they have not been selected (as is too often, obviously, the case with sensational writers on the subject) with an eye solely to exaggerated effect. Incidentally, the whole tangled quar- rel aDout the classical (as opposed to the more modern, scientific) system of educa- tion is fully explained. A chapter on “The Liberal Idea” nat- urally follows. In it the bureaucracy is traced from its useful and necessary origin to its present position of being generally detested, not only by those outside of it, but by its own progressive members, who would gladly reform it; and the subject is not devoid of lessons for our own parallel ‘ureaucracy, which has developed most of the evils so reprehended by the Russians in their own. In treating of the radical and socialistic ideas which made their ap- pearance, in due time, in Russia, Miliukoff significantly comments: “Russian radical- ism fancied Russia able to jump clean over what was thought to be a transient stage, to the highest requirements of the most advanced theory. Without knowing it, in so doing they had chosen the way of bitter disappointment and of sad practical experi- ence.” The analysis of the political parties —their infinitely varied and often startling groupings and changes—is invaluable for those who would grasp the genesis and se- quence of the parties which are now striv- ing for the control of the dangerous and complicated situation in Russia; and the whole vitally important question of the Zemstvos is stated in a masterly manner beyond the reach of foreign observers. The student of history will be interested to find that the famous and much-discussed ‘‘Con- stitution” of Alexander II., which that Bm- peror’s sudden death halted, was not a con- stitution in any sense of the word, accord- ing to Professor Miliukoff’s knowledge. This eliminates (for those who accept this new- est version) the interminable discussion of Alexander IIIL.'s and Mr. Podiedonostzeff's action in regard to it. In “The Socialistic Idea’ Miliukoff sums up the subject at the start: “Russian So- clalism, then, differs from German Social- ism in that it carries to an extreme the features which have made German Socialism differ from English and American”; and he explains (among other things) that, in Rus- sia, democracy was awakened by Socialism, instead of contrariwise, as is usually the case. In referring to the much-lauded Mir, or Commune, he shows how this gself-gov- erning, vote-owning institution was ruled, in true American fashion, by the few for the benefit of the powerful and wealthy. The possibilities thus suggested for misrule when universal suffrage shall have been acquired are not reassuring. Historical at- tempts at a constitutional monarchy and the reasons for’ their failure are briefly set forth, as is the ¢orced inception and gradu- al development of serfdom, together with the origin of the idea among the péasants wLich has created and is destined still to create untold mischief, as to the suppres- sion of imperial edicts of wide scope in their favor by the upper classes. One of the most curious points in the book is the statement of the manner in which the peasants received the Socialists who preached communism. Another is the state- ment: “It is very important to emphasize that ‘nihilism,’ though peculiar to Russia as a psychological disposition of mind, as a theory ig undoubtedly of foreign extrac- tion. In Russia it was only the belated reverberation of a movement which had had its day in both France and Germany.” In this connection it is worth while to correct an error of translation which was not no- ticed by the friends who helped the author with his English (any more than was the characteristically Russian and sometimes misleading use of the different past tenses of verbs), though it will prove puzzling to readers. In elucidating Lavroff's theories, he says: “He even admitted that, so far from destroying the State, it would be necessary to preserve it, even ‘the other day of the Revolution.’” For “‘the other day” read “the day after,”’ and the sense and cogency of the remark become clear. Of the chapter on “The Crisis and the Urgency of Reform” we can only say that nothing short of a quotation in full could do justice to its incomparable value, re- garded either as a historical document, as a guide for the present difficult situation, or as a suggestion for the future, in its complete mastery of every line of the com- plicated subject, and the calm, reasonable, and judicial treatment of all the correlated branches. In the significant ‘“‘Conclusion,”’ the most pregnant passage is the follow- ing: “Increased and united as they are, the forces of opposition are still not strong enough to replace the Government by a violent overthrow. But they are strong enough to make the use of violence con- tinuous, and by increasing this to preclude any further peaceful work of civiliza- tion. . . . Public opinion will not now be satisfied with a consultative chamber, and will not join the extremists who want a federative republic and a referendum. The great majority will be glad to have ... a constitution similar to that which was sanctioned in Bulgaria by the Russian Czar twenty-five years ago, which in- cludes universal suffrage and one chamber. The habitual argument of the Conservatives that Russia is not ready for a constitution is cut short by this example of Bulgaria. The broad democratic basis of the Constitu- tion of that country did not correspond to the degree of political development of the Bulgarian people, but it proved highly val- uable as a means of promoting their polit- ical education.” The six maps make a valuable addition to the text; and if the unusual system of transliteration for Russian mames and occa- sional words is disturbing to those who understand the language, and positively baf- fling to those who do not (through its ob- scuration of names familiar im their ordi- nary forms), it has at least the merit of representing the pronunciation as well as the accepted methods. Swinburne. By George Edward Woodberry. (Contemporary Men of Letters Series.) McClure, Phillips & Co. 1905. Mr. Woodberry's little book about Swin- burne is in no sense a biography, or even

Page 21

ieee Le Jan. 18, 1906] The Nation. a literary portrait. It is, rather. a subtie and subjective study not so much of Swin- burne’s poetry as of his poetic impulse. Even this poetic impulse is not touched, save in a phr«se here and there, chro- nologically. It is treated as an accom- plished spiritual fact, analyzed, displayed and invested with issues of power and beauty, that, as some may think, procewd rather from the compelling fervor of the interpreter than from the achievement of his author. There are many who woulc have welcomed a more consecutive account of Swinburne’s forty years of poetic labor, and would have been grateful for some suggestions of his personal quality and his milieu. There are, however, many insidious dangers that beset the man who makes a book about a contemporary. Mr. Wood- berry has probably chosen the safer as well as the more dignified course, and in the long run this study of the in: piration of the first English poet at the beginning of the twentieth century by one of the finest and truest of American poets will have a permanent interest for the discern- ing few that no gossipy personal record could possess, and that even a _ bi- voluminous “Life’’ will mot totally blot out. Mr. Woodberry is first impressed by Swin- burne as “a figure sole and supereminent, the poet republican’; and he is so at one with the revolutionary republicanism that he even finds pleasure in the poe.’s most effusive and fevered denunciations. “These,” he says, “are curses to rejoice the heart. They mark their victims m- delibly for hell.”” Next he is impressed by Swinburne’s poetic scholarship, his cili- zenship in realms of gold. Of this be writes in one of the best of his para- graphs: “He is, in fact, in his greater work of the imagination, remote from current life. He lives, withdrawn in his own thoughts, in that sphere of the poetic imagination where there is a true timelessness—the solitude thronged with figures that appear at any moment from any age, an‘ drift across the vision or play their mimic parts before the mind’s eye and disappear. It is the world of the great artists. Locrine, Erechtheus, Meleager are natural there, so are the stormy passion of the Scotch peers, the craft of English statesmen, the spectacle of Venetian pride; or Sappho or Faustine. The world of Swinburne is well symbolized by that Zodiac of the burning signs of love that he named it the prelude to ‘Tristram of Lyonesse’— the signs of Helen, Hero, Alcyone, Iseult, Rosamond, Dido, Juliet, Cleopatra, Fran- cesca, Thisbe, Angelica, Guenevere; un- der the heavens of these starry names the poet moves in his place apart, and sees his visions of woe and wrath and weaves his dream of the loves and the faies of men. He is a myth-lover, a dreamer, a companion of the myths and the dreams of the past, an artist of the imagination.” Then, after a brilliant if somewhat over melodious passage on Swinburne’s melody, Mr. Woodberry passes in his fifth section, with a slight confusion of structure, to “the second salient trait’ of his poet’s work, its “rendering of the experience of pas- sion,” its paganism, in short. From Swin- burne’s passion he proceeds to his medita- tive power, with its impressive dealing with fate. These two, with the treatment of na- ture, which is the subject of the seventh section, Mr. Woodberry considers the three “great monochords” of Swinburne’s verse. Under the last heading he has a paragraph of searching yet sympathetic criticism | which is perhaps the most ponderable in the book =a 59 beasts human motives and methods. It re; hia ¥ we after a fresh s lv of @ mal life and instinct In the various essays “Fire, air, earth and water are the four elements from which his very vocabulary seems made up; flame, wind an?’ foam, and all the forms of light are so much a part of his color-rhythm that they become an opaline of verse peculiarly his own; hs mannerism in diction and etyle is chiefly a thing of his fascination wiih these ele- menial phases of matter and sensation, which are more abstractions of motion, hue and luminousness than simple objects of sight and hearing. The blurring effect of this mass of indefinable sensation, espe- cially when metaphorically employed, even more than the overcharge of vocal sound in the verse, accounts for that impression of vacuity of meaning that Swinburne’s poe try in general makes on readers not ha- bituated to his manner.” Finaily, after a section upon the human affections as they stir in Swinburne’s pos ry. Mr. Woodberry concludes his rhapsody of the liberty, melody, passion, fate, na- ture, love and fame, which are “‘the seven chords which the poet's hand, from its first almost boyhood touch upon the lyre, has swept now for two-score years with mu- sic that has been blown through the world.” Mr. Swinburne will be fortunate if he ever again finds an interpreter so elo- quent and sympathetic as Mr. Woodberry. Yet, despite the arresting eloquence, his final high estimate of Swinburne's achieve- ment is but partially convincing. At one point in particular does it seem to us that Mr. Woodberry protests too much. He has a great deal to say of the essentially Bng- lish quality of Swinburne’s Muse. He was, says Mr. Woodberry in the very beginning, “sprung of the strength of English blood,” and again: “He is English, bred with an Bu- ropean mind, it is true, like Shelley, like Gray and Milton, but in his own genius, temperament and the path of his flight charged with the strength of England’; and yet again: “The things of strength are in his verse; it is English genius and Eng- lish strength, racial in lyric power, in free intellect, in speech—none more so—and English also in its poetic scholarly tradi- tion,”’ Now it is precisely in the “paths of his flight’’ as well as in his “poetic scholar- ly tradition’’ that Swinburne may most rea- sonably be maintained to be totally un. English He has loved England and her old poets well, but his true and self-avow- ed masters in verse have been Hugo and Baudelaire—neither exactly of the British temperament In his beautifully colored and cadenced wash of words, there is scant trace of the pregnancy, the weight, the sense of reserve power that made the true strength of English poetry. His is the weakness rather than the strength of pas- sion, and it will be one of the greatest critical surprises in the history of litera. ture if, as Mr. Woodberry expects, there shall increase “‘with every passing genera- tion”’ the number of those “in whose hearts his poetry is lodged with power.” Ways of Nature. By John Burroughs. Bos- ton: Houghton, Mifflin & Co. 1906. This book springs from a reaction in the author's opinions of anima! intelligence, occasioned by the work of recent nature- writers, who, unwarrantably, he thinks, read the lives of wild creatures in the light of human experience, and impute to birds and that make up the book, he turns the subjec' over and over to get light from different angles, and the gradual development of his opinions appears in the successive essays Our summary cannot, of course, represen the wealth of illustration which the book contains The reaction referred to appears to have carried Mr. Burroughs far when he says that the founding of hospitals for sick or homeless cats and dogs, and the condemna , tion ofall forms of vivisection, and the desire on our part to believe that animals are guided by reason and not by instinc’, ar: sentimentalism. Another passage, however, states his position more happily: “To attribute human motives and facul ies to the animals is to caricature them; bu: to put us in such relation with them hat we feel their kinship, that we see their lives embosomed in the same iron necessity as our own, that we see in their minds a humbler manifestation of the same psychic power and inteNigence that culminates and is conscious of itself in man—that, I take t, is the true humanization.” Fear, love, and hunger—the need of safe ty, offspring, and food—are, Mr. Burroughs maintains, the prime motives of the lower animals. Three factors shape their lives imitation, experience, and Instinct Imit tion is doub:less unconscious, and only sec ondary things are learned in this way. Ex- perience develops greater cunning, both in the species and in the individual, and teaches what not to do; but of positive knowledge our author believes that it ac- cumulates li:tle if any in the case of indi- vidual wild animals. “That old birds build better nests or ging better than young ones it would be hard to prove,"’ he says, “though it seems reasonable that it should be so,” and though young birds reared in captivity practise a long time before they sing well Instinct, or natural prompting, is nine tenths of the whole matter—inborn Inatin« acted upon %y outward stimulus Th animals inherit, in this, all that they need to know to preserve their existence, the accumulated knowledge which neces sity, during the evolution of the ape cles, has taught their progenitors. This in- Stinct, some'imes apparentiy resourceful and flexible in adapting itself to new condl- tions, looks like reason; but Mr. Burroughs holds that it is not reason. It is a part of the cosmic intelligence that is operative ia he vegetable as well as the anima) world, and that rises in man to the height of rea soning intelligence; but the difference be- tween animal intelligence and human rea- son, though one has been evolved from the other, is a difference, not of degree, but of kind, as, by analogy, light or electricity differs in kind from the heat that was its source. “Animal life parallels human ilfe at many points, but it is in another plane. Something guides the lower animals, but it is not thought; something restrains them, but it ila not judgment; they are provident without prudence; they are ac- tive without industry; they are skilful with out practice; they are wise without kaow!- edge; they are rational without reason; they are deceptive without guile. . . When they are joyful, they sing or they play; when they are distressed, they moan or they cry; . and yet I do not sup- pose they experience the emotion of joy or sorrow, or anger or love, as we 4o, be- cause these feelings in them do Gt involve

Page 22

60 The Nation. [ Vol. 82, No. 2116 reflection, memory, and what we call the higher nature, as with us.”’ Wild animals have, we are told, the facul- tiles of perception, sense memory, and as- sociation of memories, and little else. Their instinct is intelligence directed outward, never inward, as in man. They share with man the emotions of his animal but not of his moral or msthetic they know no altruism, no moral code. Mr. Burroughs maintains that we have no proof that animals in a state of can reflect, form abstract Ideas, associate cause and effect. Animals, for instance, that store up food for the winter simply follow a provident instinct, but do not take thought for the future, any more than does the tree that forms new buds for the coming season. The captive animal chafing in its cage suffers merely physical discomfort, and is reacting instinctively against the barriers, not picturing to it- self the joys of freedom. The nature of the animals prompts them to their acts, and we think of them ag the result of a mental process, because similar acts in ourselves are the results of such a process. Remarkable incidents of what looks like reason, reported of wild animals by some writers, are here discredited on the ground that they contradict general observation and are probably the result of inaccurate or prejudiced seeing. Well-authenticated in- stances reported of domestic animals are explained as the result of association with man. Domestication, Mr. Burroughs thinks, demoralizes instinct. Apes and elephants show something akin to reasoning intelli- gence, and “the dog is almost a human product.” Mr. Burroughs takes issue sharply with the popular belief that animal parents con- sclously alm at instruction of their young. Nature provides, he says, merely that the unconscious example of the parents shal! stimulate imitation in the young. The par- nature, nature; nature ents have no store of ideas to communi- cate, no knowledge in the strict sense of the word, no solicitude about the future. They have only emotions—fear, suspicion, etc.— to communicate, and all communications must refer to the moment, and be made in presence of the thing that arouses emo- tion, It is the Instinctive play of animals that is mistaken for anattempt to teach the young. The parents sometimes take part, but do not direct; all is spontaneous and haphazard, but, by nature’s provision, is always along the line of the animal’s fu- ture struggle for life. Kittens play with a ball or stick as if it were a mouse; dogs race and wrestle as in the chase; birds circle and dodge as if escaping a hawk The playground, then, is the only school of the woods, and, so far as the animals know, what goes on there is merely for pleasure Nelther will Mr. Burroughs accept the popular idea that animals of the same spe- cles vary markedly in individuality. Anl- mals have not, he says, the complex needs, relations, and aspirations that in man give rise to great diversity of character and capacity; therefore he is skeptical about the individual types and exceptional en- dowments often claimed for them. “If he {the animal-story writer) proceed upon the thought that the wild creatures have as pronounced individuality as men have, that there are master minds among them, in- ventors @>d discoverers of new ways, born captains and heroes, he will surely ‘o’er- step the modesty of nature. Domestic animals, he admits, show some individual- ity; solitary wasps, a good deal. He sug- gests that the latter are differentiated by solitude, as men are, and that among the larger wild animals the solitary may dis- play more individuality than the gregari- ous. Of this, however, he finds no proof. It appears to the reader, indeed, as if the inevitable lack of wide and intimate knowl- edge of the individual life of most wild creatures must seriously hamper the dis- cussion of at least this part of the subject. Sidney Lanier. By Edwin Mims. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co. Pp. vil, 386. 1905. The chief tests of a biography are ac- curacy and charm. The former this book seems to fulfil; we have not found any mis- statement nor noted any omissions. Charm the book does not possess. It is pleasantly written, and will be a stimulating reminder to those who knew and loved the man as well as know and love his work. A reader coming to this book in entire ignorance of Lanier must admire the individual and might be led to read his poems, but the book scarcely compels to either, and by no means ensures a complete perusal of itself except to one already interested in its sub- ject. Its chief fault is that it casts no en- chantment over us to lure us on whether we will or bo. Specific instances of discretion and good taste are many, and examples of the reverse are few, yet it would have been far better to omit the excerpt (pp. 305-307) from Mme. Blanc’s article in the Revue des Deus Mondes. Perhaps some revelation of the flagrancy of the extreme Lanier cult would be felt needful by any one writing his life; but, on the one hand, the facts recorded in these passages must pain those who admire his writings without overvaluing them, and who love the character of the man himself without deifying him, while they must re- pel those whom a life of Lanier should al- lure to read his better works and to gain inspiration from what they can learn of his rare individuality. On the other hand, Mr. Mims misses the subtle Gallic flavor in what he quotes. The rehearsal of laudations, even of the greatest authors, is likely to irritate those not already under their spell, while the pointing out of defects in the work or char- acter of one admired as a creative genius, and revered as a man, is far more likely to arouse interest in those who are strang- ere to his compositions and personality. Intentionally or otherwise, this last is what Mr. Mims has done. The steady glow of his general admiration is made all the more telling by his repeated noting of Lanier’s shortcomings, as on pages 2, 238, 248, 345, 346, 364-367. On page 364 he says: “He never attained, except in a few poems, that union of sound and sense which is charac- teristic of the best poetry.” This repeated caution of statement or positive understate- ment of praise gives an air of fair-minded judgment to the book as a whole which makes ite laudatory portions far more con- vincing than if they were not relieved by contrast; and such a sweeping reservation as that just quoted lends weight to the exposition of the biographer’s belief in Lanier’s capacities in the line of fertility and artistic finish. Mr. Mims (p. 126) at- tempts to gloze Lanier’s characterization of the college he attended as “farcical,” but he has the courage to print several healthy utterances of unwelcome truths. Delightful is what he quotes on page 290 from a letter of 1873 about a bad novel: “And so far from endeavoring to serve the South by blindly plastering it with absurd praises, I think all true patriots ought to unite in redeeming the land from the imputation that such books are regard- ed as casting honor upon the section. God forbid that we should really be brought so low as that we must perforce brag of such works; and God ,be merciful to that man (he is an Atlanta editor) who boasted that sixteen thousand of these books had been sold in the South. This last damning fact ought to have been concealed at the risk of life, limb, and fortune.” Altogether this book tells Lanier’s life in a straightforward, if not brilliant, man- ner, and honestly attempts to characterize him as a man, a musician, a scholar, a poet, and a critic. Much space is given to his critical utterances and to valuation of them. Particularly good (p. 351) is what Lanier said of his own critics: “Nothing has amazed me more than the timid solicitudes with which they rarefy in one line any en- thusiasm they may have ccndensed in an- other, forever conciliating the yet unrisen ghosts of possible mistakes.”’ Con- sidered as a critic, he is attractively pre- sented, again by general commendation with emphasis upon defects which, like the faults in his poetic make-up, add to rather than detract from one’s conviction of his inher- ent capacities, for they are essentially the defects of genius. This biography offers no explanation of the fact that while Lanier’s utterances, viewsand creations roused widespread interest and elicited varied response, they have never- theless failed to win at home or abroad general acceptance of his admirers’ claims. Again, and chiefly, this book acknowledges but totally fails to solve the main problem before a writer on Lanier. He thought himself a great poet, and hoped for a span of life wherein he might win all the world’s adherence to his belief. A great proportion of those who knew him conceded the reasonableness of his faith, and many to-day feel that, had he been in vigorous bodily heaith at the date of his death, had he survived, were he alive to-day, he would have become a dominant figure in Ameri- can literature and a noble presence among the great English poets. And yet no recol- lection of his poverty, of his ill health, anxiety, and forced haste can explain en- tirely such a pitiful array of quotations as even Mr. Mims’s ardor has to put up with, on pages 369-375, as the best that can be culled from all his poetry. A foreigner glancing at these gleanings would dismiss Lanier from his mind as absurdly over- rated and wholly negligible. A definitive biography, if it maintains the negative, must explain whence came the general im- pression of Lanier’s greatness; if it main- tains the positive, must succeed in convey- ing to its readers some adumbration of the poet’s thrilling effect on his acquaintance. Mr. Mims leaves the riddle as he found it. As good an index as this has, we crave in every biography.

Page 23

i ta M8: ti Jan. 18, 1906] The Nation. 61 Radio-Activity. By B. Rutherford. Second edition. Cambridge (Eng.): University Press; New York: Macmillan. 1905. 8vo, pp. 580. A throng of public sensations due to ad- vances in natural science crowd upon a sexagenarian’s recollection (Stewart's syrup was the greatest personal sensation of his infancy), ¢. g., vulcanized rubber; daguer- reotypes; the telegraph; Dr. William T. G. Morton’s demonstration of the anwsthetic property of ether (and the ether wonder was not a week old when news came of the discovery of the planet Neptune), the same memorable year bringing straw paper, gun- cotton, and the sewing-machine; the stereo- scope; then, the doctrine of the conserva- tion of energy, long debated, though at first pooh-poohed by scientific magnates; the mechanical theory of heat; the Ruhmkhorff coil; Foucault’s pendulum experiment; Bes- semer iron; aniline dye-stuffs; the Atlantic cable; wood pulp; Pasteur’s refutation of spontaneous generation as an ordinary event; spectroscopic analysis with rubidium and cwsium; the theory of natural selec- tion; Deville’s aluminium; the extensive use of nitroglycerine; Andrews’s discovery of the critical temperature; the wonderful Holtz machine of 1865 (the simultaneous and equivalent Tépler machine somehow be- ing less noised abroad), and, three years later, the Gramme dynamo; in 1869 Men- deléeff’s periodic law; then a long calm, hardly broken by such successes as that made by the ammonia soda process, or such half successes as Loomis’s wireless tele- graphy, which, however, came into wider notice in 1877, when the telephone and phonograph had turned public attention in- to that channel; the first confirmation of Mendeléeff’s law in the discovery of the metal gallium, duly melting, according to prediction, in the warmth of a man’s palm; the azo-dyes; Pasteur’s germ-theory, fol- lowed by Koch’s detection of the tubercle- bacillus, and, later, by the enzyme theory; osmotic pressure; the incandescent light; stereochemistry; Weismapnism; Cowles’s aluminium; smokeless powder; kodaks; the new physical chemistry guided by Willard Gibbs’s phase rule, and leading to liquid air and hydrogen; the successful linotype (though that can hardly be reckoned as a scientific sensation); Hall’s aluminium; the electric furnace and acetylene; argon; the Réntgen rays; the flutter about Herzian waves; the contact process for the manu- facture of sulphuric acids and anhydride; and, latest, radio-activity and radium. Of all these the last promises to mark the deepest revolution of scientific conceptions, by reducing matter.from the rank of pri- mordial substance to that of a special state of electricity. After that, we shall be pre- pared for anything, even for experimental demonstration of the tychist’s doctrine that electricity is a psychical phenomenon. To any person who wishes to be thor- oughly informed concerning radio-activity, the above-cited complete digest of all that is known about it, worked out as it is to the utmost secure conclusions of a general kind, is entirely indispensable. It is, to be sure, only the second edition of a work of which the first edition seemed as perfect as possible, and follows that first edition by but fifteen months. Nevertheless, it is largely rewritten; and it would deserve no- tice if there were nothing more remark- able about it than that, though the preface is dated the 9th of last May, the contribu- tions to its science made in April are so fully discussed that it is manifest that a considerable part of the rewriting of the first edition must itself have been again rewrit- ten while the new edtion was going through the press. The fact that the second edition is almost a new work, although the first edition was everywhere hailed as most re- markable, simply evidences the won- derful advance of the science in which Professor Rutherford js himself so large and active a factor. The methods he pursues are wholly novel, though they rest on familiar and indubitable principles, and his conclusions are not open to intelligent doubt. Accordingly, we are to know that all elements whose atomic weights exceed that of bismuth, 208, are endothermic com- pounds, which are undergoing spontaneous dissociation accompanied wiil a liberation of heat energy millions of times as much as that which could be due to the combustion of as much matter. This decomposition seems to consist in the separation of hel- jum, whose atomic weight is 4, leaving an element whose atomic weight is only 4 less than that of the element first taken. How- ever, as to the products of the disaggrega- tion, it is not likely that any one rule will cover all cases. We simply mention what seems to be the prevalent type. Radium is a metal, extremely like bar- ium, except that its atomic weight is about the sum of those of barium and of stron- tium, and except that the average life of an atom of radium is only about two thousand years. It casts off helium, and what is left is a chemically inert gas, some- what like xenon. The average life of the atom of radium emanation is only five days. It decomposes, and its principal constituent, called Radium A, is left as a deposit on the surface of the vessel. The average life of the atom of Radium A is only four and a third minutes. It is converted by throwing off helium .or something like that into a somewhat more volatile element called Ra- dium B, of which the average life is half an hour. Radium B is decomposed in a differ- ent way, little studied as yet, into another, less volatile element, Radium C, whose atom has an average life of 40 or 41 minutes. This gives off, not merely such rays as radium itself emits, but, besides others, great pene- tration, and there is left another element, a little more volatile, called Radium D. The average life of the atom of Radium D is over half a century, and in its decomposi- tion no rays at all are given off, and the very non-volatile element, Radium B, re- mains. This has an average life ofinearly nine days, and, in decomposing, gives off only the more penetrating rays, none of those by which radium affects the photo- graphic film, and is converted into the first of the new elements discovered by Mme. Curie, polonium, which has an average lifs of ten months. But we will not pursue these vicissitudes further. Polonium is an ele- ment very much like bismuth. Dr. Boll- wood holds that all these changes come to an end with the production of lead, but we cannot understand that in an absolute sense; and it is not particularly unlikely that lead should be converted into gold. In fact, the tales of the philosopher's stone and of pro- jection do not seem to-day half so marvel- lous as what we may see at any moment by looking into a spintharoscope, The index, though it is not quite as ful! as we could wish, fillls twenty-two pages of double columns. Australian Life in Town and Country By E. C. Buley. G. P. Putnam's Sens. 1906 Pp. x., 288. Illustrations. We are not sure whether Australians will feel complimented by being included with Japanese, Chinese, and others in a series of books on “Our Asiatic Neighbors.’ We have not, however, often read a volume in which solid information was conveyed in a nore pleasing style. The illustrations, while hav- ing little apparent direct relation to the text, are well chosen. Hannan Street, Kal- goorlie, in 1895 and again in 1905, is espe- cially interesting. Land and climate, coun- try and town life, politics, education, !!tera- ture and art are all treated. The last chapter is on “Australia’s Des- tiny.”” We here find a widely different Aus- tralia from that of which we were accustom- ed to read, and of which some of us had practical experience half a century ago Deep-shaft and scientific mining have tak- en the place of the tin dish and cradle Sheep are shorn by machinery. Bush hands seek work on bicycles. Stately mansions, in which are to be found grand pianos and the newest books, have taken the place of the slab huts formerly occupied even by rich squatters. Foxes, introduced to kil! off rab- bits, have themselves become pests Cam- els are in certain districts used as Beas‘'s of burden—we are informed that the native bred is a much finer animal than his West- ern prototype. Ox teams no longer cumber the streets of Melbourne and Sydney. Aus- tralians live in a soberer atmosphere ‘han in the old “Cheer, boys, cheer!"’ days. Cas- ual visitors—how much more ‘old hands"'! must feel drawn by the beckoning mystery of the pathless and still but imperfectly ex plored country stretching inland—the ‘‘nev- er, never land” here so graphically describ- ed. As the clack of a windlass and the smell of tar may tend to call many an old sailor against his better judgment aga'n to tempt the deep, so may the pages of this book rouse the desire in some o'4 Austra lians again to shoulder their “swags” and take to “the wallaby track.” Whatever changes irrigation and ar- tesian wells may bring about, Australia, with its vast proportion of desert and its uncertain seasons, can never become a United States. One would gather that the mental outlook is narrow. Sport, music and, in a certain degree, evangelicism, have become disproportionately large Interests in life. Australia does not enjoy the ad vantage of having been primarily colon ized by men in search of religious and political freedom. One of the most in- teresting chapters in Mr. Buley’s book is on State Socialism. In the bush, with the State for landlord, remittances of rent are threugh political influence obtained in bad seasons. The State owns the railways and is often compelled to advance money for roads and bridges. The State trains teach ers and manages the schools. Help and supervision in the establishment of new industries is constantly demanded. After bad seasons the State sometimes provides seed, and even advances money to tide farmers over till next harvest. The State regulates the hours of labor, fixes wages, and decides industrial disputes, Al! this

Page 24

62 The Nation. [Vol. 82, No, 2116 cannot tend to strength and jndividuality of character, and necessitates the existence of a large official class. Public debts are out of all proportion to population, urban country population. The new Federal has a difficult task before It. Protection the different States was logically forwarded by the creation of differing railroad gauges, insuring the transfer of merchandise at frontiers. Uni- fic of gauge throw additional heavy on now to Covernment between an united Com- the States of will burden the Jealousy ation between the monwealth. has so far prevented foundation a central capital revenue matters, find it that Sydney holds second as to the It is de- Turning to we dificult to belleve place in the British Empire of property rated for taxation. that the Bulletin, and most widely read journal Australia, ‘frankly advocates the independence of Australia under a republican form of government."’ We are told that a vigorous national life is more and more asserting itself, under which the “Australians for Australia’ is being for Austral- conceal the pic value learn as the ablest interesting to scribed in ery ubstituted Our shades O01 for ‘Australia author not in his generally sunny Australian life ins does larker of Australia and ire Notes on HKnglish History, Made Napoleon's on the Eve of the French Revolution. By Henry Foljambe Hall. London: J. M Dent & Co 1905. The yaluable part of this book is that in of the notes Napoleon in translation taken by which appears a on English history he year 1788, when he was much occupied with historical and philosophical reading. rhe notes are for the most part extremely oncise, and give only occasional and not very illuminating glimpses of the person- ility of their author. They were discovered ome twenty or more years ago by Masson; they appeared shortly afterwards in the Paris Gaulow, and were later reprinted by Masson and Biagi in their well-known book Napoléon Inconnu.” They are now offered ON TEN PLAYS OF SHAKESPEARE By Stopford Brooke $2.25 net, by mail $2.37 An interpretation of the methods of Shake sre asanartist. It is not so much an analy as on ‘Wlnver's Tal of “Midsummer Night's Dream. . nter's Tale,’ * Merchant of Venice,”’ “As You Like It,” Rich ard Il,” Richard III.,’' “ Macbeth," Tempest,’’ Romeo and Juliet,’ and Cortolanua.' HENRY HOLT & CO. N.Y, THE REST ANIMAL STORY RED FOX: RED FOX: By CHARLES G. D. ROBERTS Author of “The Heart of the Ancient Wood,” The Kindred of the Wii,” ete Beethoven—Franklin—Rousseau: Kave..'s Portraita, wood-engraved in the high. est manner of the art and printed on Japan paper, size 0x11 loches, market orlee Tweaty Dollars each, now offe ai half rote to subscribers on the hooks of the Nation, and sent, carr age free, on recelpt of Ten Dollars. — Addrens Prve.rener or Tae Natiox. New York, | | | | | sults to the English-speaking public, translated by the late Mr. H. F. Hall, illustrated, as he informs us, from contemporary histo- rians and refreshed from the findings of later research. The refreshments set forth by Mr. Hall were hardly necessary, but, as they form the major part of the book, and as in his introduction he appears to at- tach far more importance to them than to his author, they cannot be without a word of comment. Perhaps the most characteristic thing about this curious ‘book is that, next to Na- poleon's the best thing in it is an excellent frontispiece portrait of Rapin de Thoyras French historian of the seven- century, who has, in Gilbert’s im- words, “nothing to do with the There is not a scrap of evidence, so far aware, to show that Napoleon ever read a word of his; but Mr. Hall has, which is undoubtedly a distinc- tion nowadays, and hence the frontispiece. Mr. Hall has a queer outlook on historical scholarship that produces most curious re- Sir Walter Scott is apparently his admiration among the general his- torians of Napoleon, and Dr. Emil Reich, as he believes, of psychologi- alas, what will Lamprecht ?), is his philosophic guide. It is doubt- less the comDination of Scott and Reich that leads him to statements of this sort: “One must never forget that Napoleon owed mental and physical, to the salt notes, a teenth mortal case.”’ is as this reviewer greatest the inventor, cal history (but, say 0 his grit, savor of the sea. All that is best in Corsican, Frenchman, or Englishman |} comes from their ancestors, the Sea-rov- |} ers." Comment is needless. A few more examples may be given. The great ques- | tion involved in the ceremony of corona- tion by the Pope from Charlemagne down to Napoleon is dismissed as one which Na- | poleon settled by crowning himself, ‘“‘know- | Mr. of pampering a Pontiff.” say, is a devotee of for the popularity of the dangers Hall, the epilepsy ing needless to theory, | which we have to thank Lombroso, Nordau, Nisbet, and Nietzsche; when it comes to specifying in what particular the alleged epilepsy affected the course of history, we GRIEG By H. T. FINCK 12mo. $1.00 net. Postage Sc. The Only Biography of the Great Norwegian Composer. MACDOWELL By LAWRENCE GILMAN 12mo. $1.00 net. Postage Sc. A Biography and Interpretation of America’s Most Popular and Distinguished Composer. JOHN LANE COMPANY, WV. Y. THE BODLEY HEAD, 67 Fifth Ave. RUSSIA AS IT REALLY IS By CARL JOVBERT J. B. LIPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia passed over | are, also of course, not enlightened. But to continue further is unnecessary. The value of the book is not in the editor’s work, but entirely in the translation. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Avehinonte’ Directory, 1905-06. William T. Oom- stock. t. Aston, W. G. Shinto (The Way of the Gods). Longmans. 4 Blake, William. Poetical Works. Edited by John Sampson. Henry Frowde. Cartwright, Julia. Raphael. Dutton. 75 cents net. Cepestanes. Fourth Series. Oxford Historical So- ciety. Dante, Gabriele Rossetti. Newnes'’s Art Library. De Quincey’s Essays. Edited by Carol M. New- man. Macmillan Co. Dussaud, René. Notes de Mythologie Syrienne. Paris: Ernest Leroux. Ellis, Elizabeth. Barbara Winslow, Rebel. Dodd, Mead & Co. $1.50. Eltzbacher, O. Modern Germany. Dutton. §2 net, Finck, H. T. Edvard Grieg. John Lane Co. $1 bet. Glasgow, Ellen. pe Wheel of Life. Doubleday, Page & ©», - Hannah, Henry King. The Bible for the Sick. Thomas W hittaker, $1 net: | Hooper, Chas. a The Country House. Double- day, Page & Inman, Henry. The Ranche on the Oxhide. Mac- millan Co. $1.5 Johnson, Samuel. — of the English Poets. Ed- ited by George B. Hill. 3 vols. Henry Frowde. Jordan, Clara B. Elementary Latin Writing. American Book Co. ; and J. E. Sterrett. The Modern Macmillan Co. $2.50 net. A Primer of Essentials in Gram- American Book Co. Lewis and Clark Expedition. Edited by Reuben G. Thwattes. Vol. VIII. Atlas. Dodd, Mead & Oo. Merrill, George F. Elementary Mechanics. can Book Co Kirkbridge, F. B., Trust Company. Knight, Marietta. mar and Rhetoric. Ameri- Murray, A. H. The High-Road of Empire. Dut- ton. 5 net. Koopman, Harry Lyman. At the Gates of the Century. Boston: The Everett Press. Norris, Zoe Anderson. Twelve Kentucky Colonel Stories. J. S. Ogilvie Publishing Co. Oppenheim. E. Phillips. A Maker of History. Boston: Little, Brown & Oo. $1.50. National Educa- Addresses of the So- Proceedings and Published by the tional Association, 1905. clety Puyis de Chavannes. ve wnes’s Art Library. F. Warne & Co. $1.25 . Selden Society. Year Books of Edward II. Vol. Ill. London: Bernard Quari tech. The ‘Author's Apology from Mrs. Brentano's. The Song of Youth. Boston: Shaw, Bernard. Warren's Profession. Shvemaker, Blanche. Richard G. Badger. Smythe, William E. The Sone st of Arid Amer- ica. Macmillan Co. $1. Soyder, Harry. Dairy Chemistry. Macmillan Oo. $1. Stewart, Alexander. The Life of Christ. Phila- delphia: Lippincott. tdward. Gitz Krafft. Berlin: Rich. Stilgebauer, D Siraubenmiiller, Gustave. A Home Geography of New York City. Boston: Ginn & Stubbs, Charles W. The Story of Cambridge. Mac- millan Co. Tibullus. Edited by J. P. Postgate. Henry Frowde. A History of England Written by various authors under the direction and editorship of ©. W. C. OMAN, Deputy Chichele Professor of Modern History, Oxford, Six volumes, 8vo, cloth, each, net $5.00. Three volumess now ready. Il. England under the Normans and Angevins. 1066-1272. By H.W. C. Davis. IV. England under the Tudors 1485-1603. By Arthur D. Innes. V. England under the Stuarts. By G. M. Trevelyan. hand permanent “Will undoubtedly take a h Vf oy Y ct. Not so much place ip the literature of its sub, a history, in - ordinary sense of word, asa sustained an H upon history, high-toned oot impartial,” —The A . Send for Descriptive Circular. 27 & 29 West G.P. Putnam's Sons, 2342.7

Page 25