The Nation 1905-11-30: Vol 81 Iss 2109

Page 1

Re ie a RE VOL. LXXXI—NO. 2109. THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 30, 1905 The Nadsan “” "7 ¢,'* TP i “4 "Warne ac pow Col vine ——---—— = NEW BOOKS OF DISTINCTION A SHORT HISTORY OF ITALY By Henry D. Sepewick “In this Mr. Sedgwick gives a clear and correct impression of Italy as a whole, laying emphasis upon the matters of greatest general interest, the papacy and the Renaissance. His special object was to put in high relief those achievements which make Italy so charming and interesting to the world and to give the largest possible space to the great men to whom these achievements are due,"'— Cleveland Leader. With maps d, $2.00, net, Postpaid, $2.17. IN OUR CONVENT DAYS THE FARCE OF MASTER PIERRE By Acnes Repp.ier PATELIN oo he rs | Englished by Ricnarp Hoterovuk “Perfect stories, warm from the heart and spirit of the writer, alive | The first translation of this s 2 2 , parkling comedy, ina modern tongue, that definable thrill that means an impeccable reality and truth | delightful not only to read, but also to perform. Illustrated, $2.09, to nature.”’--Chicago Record-He: ald, 1.10, net. Postpaid, $1.20 | net Postpaid, $2.12. THE PARDONER’S WALLET By Samvuet M. Croruers * It is time that the country awoke to the fact that in Samuel M, Crothers it has a humorist of the first rank, a satirist of no mean ability, and an essayist to be reckoned with,""—Chicago Tribune, By the author of * The Gentle Reader.” $1.26 net. Postpaid, $1.36 SIDNEY LANIER JAMES RUSSELL LOWELL JAMES G. BLAINE By Epwin Mims By Ferris GREENSLET \By Epwarp Stanwoop P= , “Mr. Greenslet has moulded an independent , It is an —— pny Seaimtenine. impression of Lowell's life, getting at the | ho ne ll dhapdtin gen dae dmnrt judicions, | otelligent and sympathetic uter- genuine self of the real man and keeping his | Mer 4 as 8 pictur pretation."—The Outlook, New York. With 0) sense intact." — Boston Advertiser. | coque and entertaining.”-—-New York Times | With portrait. $1.25, nef, Postpaid, $1.87. portrait, $1.50, net. Postpaid, $1.62. Illustrated, $1.50, net. Postpaid, $1.62. PART OF A MAN’S LIFE By Tuomas Wentworth Hicornson ‘These ripe and scholarly chapters—ripe with the varied experience of eighty years and more, amd scholarly with the scholarship of a lover not only of books, but of men—have an interest and value far exceeding anything that another pen might contrive to say about them."'—The Dial, Chieago. Fully illustrated, $2.50, net. Postpaid, $2.08. ENGLISH HOURS PARADISE By Henry James By Atick Brown “Mr. Penneli's illustrations represent the most pictu:esque of scenes “Few writers of fiction have equalled Miss Brown in their un- throuvhout Eog and, and th-y bring back, as do also Mr. James's | derstanding and analysis of the New England character, and few pleasant chapte s, genial me nories 0' tours hither aud thither through have been so skillful in endowing the creations of her imagination the English town and c sunty.”—Boston T. anscript. Illustrat d by | with actual life, ‘ Paradise’ is, in short,a very human story.”—Bos Joseph nell, $3.00 ton Transcript. $1.0). — THE ENGLAND AND HOLLAND OF THE PILGRIMS By Morron DexrTer “ So thorough and honest e% ‘torical work can afford to have its merits and limitations known at once. In a word, we have here the results of solid, long-continued, pe cing research, with correction and recorrection of the first work and of various mistaken impressions, confu- sions and inferences of oth. _ ters.”"—The D.al, Chicago. Illustrated, $3.50, net. Postpaid, $3.73. BRET HARTE’S HER LETTER | THE STORY OF NOAH’S ARK Illustrated by Arruur I. Kevrer' By E. Borp Ssrra “I wish that something nowadays could give me the thrill of delight =“ A Bible story treated humorously and yet reverently! And there is not a grown-up but will chuckle at all of these pictures, which are that these poems of Bret Harte did when I first read them."—Jean- netie L, Gilder, editor of The Oritie, With 44 full-page pictures in | Doth erlistle Sid nea ee en blur, nit ® Picture book, indeed; color and tint and many decorations in gold. $2.00. | $2.00, mt. Postpaid, $2.19, HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & COMPANY, BOSTON AND NEW YORK mam. en me ES LS GT GENERAL LIBRARY, UNIV. OF MICH,

Page 2

— ae The Nation. [Vol. 81, No. 2109 The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science and Art, FOUNDED IN 1865, [Entered at the New York City Post Office as second-class matl matter. | CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. Tus Ween cveceesoeces 433 EDITORIAL ARTICLES; Solicitous about New York"’ A Little Insurance History ........6seeees Football Reform by Abolition ee “Fundamentals"’ In ¢ oepeeed ee vcccccecesess James Davie Butler .... ee BPECTAL CORRESPONDENCE Erte AGetes cccccceccesccccccesececooceos 439 The Russian Peasant. mle cccceecveesoeses 44) Jehol . bese soeesecsoesdeeesse 442 CORRESPONDENCE The Anglo-Japanese Treaty Again......... 445 The Rapert of the Committee of Fifty..... 445 "The Sweet Roman Hand” .......6.+++5. 444 The GEE GAMO ccccccccsccsccececcececeoce 444 The Inversion of “Graft” ....ccccscceeces 444 Him and Her ecccceeeeseccose 444 Nores sec cvvee 444 Book Reviews The House of Mirth, and Other Novels..... 447 PROCES TORE coccccccecccececesevccoeseos aay Ohildren’s Books.—Il, 2... cece eccccceeeces 44y The Confessions of Lord DUG accuccecsee 450 The Reconstruction of Sotigions Belief .... 4651 Greatness in Literature ........... secon Ge Wolfe and Montcalm .......ceccccecceeees 452 Books or Tus Wee ones --«» 452 TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three dollars per year in advance, postpaid, in any part of the United States or Canada; to for- eign countries comprised in the Postal Union $4. The date when the subscription expires ts on the address label of each paper, the change of which to @ subsequent date becomes a receipt for a remit- tance. Noother receipt is sent unless requested. Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unies* made by registered letter, or by check, express order or Postal Order payable to “ Publisher af The Nation.” When a change of address is desired, both the old and new addresses should be given. Address THE NATION, Bia 704, New York. Publication Offtee, 208 Broadway. TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Fifteen centa per agate line, each insertion; 14 linea to the inch Twenty per cent, advance for choice of page or top of column A crtumn, $29 each insertion; with chotce of page, $t4 A page, #60 each insertion; front cover page, $80. Advertisements muat be acceptable in every reapect Copy received until Tuesday, SP. M. Discounts upon application. THE NATION t& tent free to those who adver- tise in U as long a4 advertisement continues. *,* Copies of the Nation may be procured in Paris at Brentano's, [17 Avenue de l'Opera; in London of B. F. Stevens & Brown, Trafalgar Square, Charing Cross. Beethoven—Franklin—Rousseau: Kave..'s Portenita, woot soereves in the high. est manner of the art an i] size 9x11 inches, market ~ poe paper: now rp i a e~P- subscribers on the LF A, & se wate ae 9 sent, carriage free, on PUBLISHER OF > tos Nation, New York, Educational. MASSACHUSETTS. OSTON UNIVERSITY Law School. New features. Address the Dean. M. M. BIGELOW. Mentally Deficient Children THE BANCROFT-COX TRAINING SCHOOL at Haddonfield, N. J., is a resident school for children who are mentally deficient or back- ward. It offers the most systematic, ecient, and beneficial training to be secured. SPECIAL TEACHER IN T1E HOME A special teacher from the school may be en- gaged to come to the home where conditions make it undesirable to send child to the school, HOME CORRESPONDENCE COURSE This is a course of instruction by mail which fits a parent or guardian to undertake the train- ing of a child at home. BOOK ON HOME CARE AND TRAINING This is a book of general suggestions for home treatment, and wilh be sent on receipt of — Cireulars describing school work aw dence Course sent free. Address 19, HADDONFIELD. 5 N. J. ROCK RIDCE SCHOOL Por Beys. Location high and Laboratories. Sho for Mechanic A Strong An est boys. t new gymnasium with owtaaning pool. Fite for College, Scientific School and business. Illustrated pamphiet sent free. Please address Dr. G. R. WHITE Principal, Wellesley Hills, Mass. School Agencies. 'WE FISK TEACHERS AGENCIES Everett O. Fisx & Co., Proprietors. 4 Ashburton Place, Boston; 1505 Pa. Ave , Washington; 155 Fifth Ave., New York; 414 Cent. Bid., Minneapolis; 533 Cooper Bldg. . Denver: 80 Third St., Portiand; 203 Mich. Bivd., Chic: ; 8¥5 Stimson Block, Los Angeles; Hyde Block. Spokane: 420 Parrot Bidg., San Francisco. Ae TEACHERS AGENCY, 81 Chapel 8t., Albany, N. ¥.—Provides schools of all grades with competent Linebeon Assists teach- ers in obtaining positions. Haran P. Frencn, Proprietor. AY i ee S Teachers’ Agency, Teachers—Schools—Tutors—Governess—Property. Tel. 6120 L&Sth. Jouw C. Rocxweut, Magr., 3 E. 14th 8t., N. ¥. C. Books, de /uxe publications, brochures and commemora- tive volumes designed, illus- trated and manufactured for publishers, authors, socie- ties, and institutions. Appointments may be made, or questions of manufacture | may be discussed by letter | F. D. NICHOLS COMPANY 31 Union Square, New York 6 Beacon Street, Boston | Se Astor Edition of Poets is the best for schools and colleges. $B von List price, ®e. per vol. (price to schools 40c SEND FOR LIST Thomas Y.Crowell @Co., New York SIR GALAHAD NEW FRANCE nEERED SS FOGKENE Coebetsn, vew CATALOGUE of Americana, rs of Periods. Cuanx, Peckakill, R. OS 7-OF-PRINT AND NEW BOOKS Ave., New York. Merrill's Elementary Text-Book of Theoretical Mechanics This book is intended for the upper classes in secondary schools and for the two lower classes in college. Only a knowledge of elementary algebra, plane geometry, and ough comprehensio presents only those principles and methods which are ot the sremeat importance, and thus overcomes many of the difficulties now encountered by students who are looking for- ward toan industrial career in engineering. The explanation of each topic is followed by a few well-chosen examples to fix and apply » a se involved. P, -. = tables of natural cop ¢ functions appear at the end of t AMERICAN BOOK COMPANY New York Cincinnati Chicago Bost NE of the joys ot life is to possess for one’s very own a WATERMAN'S IDEAL FOUNTAIN PEN, not ideal in the literal sense, but a very real and prac- tical good thing. Always ready,” saves time, trouble, and the exasperated feel- ing .that a scratchy, spluttering pen breeds in the most patient of mortals. Nota man alive who has ever owned one of the Water- man’s Ideal would be willing to do without it, and gratitude unstinted would be show- ered upon the giver of a Christmas present of the genuine ‘*%Ideal,'’ and don't think they're only for business men. Your old- est boy would be proud indeed to have one in his vest pocket, and would be on hand with the goods whenever a pen was needed. A wife, sister, or sweetheart would appre- ciate one also, and whether she writes the free bold ‘‘ twenty words to a page’ style or the fine Italian hand of an earlier day, the special kind of pen she likes is to be found among the Waterman ‘‘ Ideals."’ The Lowell Offering A reprint of the famous magazine written entirely by the mill girls of Lowell, in 1845, is one of the new leaflets just added to the Old South series, Send for complete lists. PRICE 5 CENTS A COPY. $4 PER too. DIRECTORS OLD SOUTH WORK Old Sou.h Meeting House WASHINGTON STREET, BOSTON HANDBOOK OF UNITED STATES POLITICAL HISTORY By “Ltn OLM paste. Send for FRE Catalogue ‘LEE & SHEPARD CO. Financial. s We, bar A. sell — of honey ow Europ Lor = oarere. and South” * itrtos ays cRrRepit °°! lections and issue Fate gf lers’ Credite avaliable in all et. oa Internationa! Cheques, Certificates of Deposit. BROWN BROTHERS & GO., NO. 50 WALL STREET, NEW YORK. ADIT LAAN em ct tt

Page 3

ae ae elie Nov. 30, 1905] The Nation. The Philippine Islands By Frep, W. ATKINSON Northern Trails It is to be commended because it gives in brief compass an o e r wncenally clear and systematic account of the subject.—New In Labrador and Newfoundland or rioune, Clear, comprehensive, conservative survey of the field,— Chicago Evening News, _ 189 illustrations. 439 pages, $3.00 net. | By WILLIAM J. LONG | One feels the exhilara- How the United States Became a Nation tion of the northern air (1789-1865) of that great undiscover- By Joun Fiske 254 pages. $1.25 | ed country of Labrador as the author carries him away from the arti- | | Studies in Modern German Literature By Orro HELLER 310 pages. $1.50 net ficiality of the man-made By Irene Weir 370 pages. $3.00 net sy fragrance w h ic h speaks of fir balsam and Poems of Tennyson birch smoke and the still white woods. Chosen and edit by Henry Van Dyke. An unusually at- | Greek Painters’ Art ’ | town to the subtle wood- | tractive volume, 470 pages. $1.50 net There are books, and books butjquite the best written one that | hasappeared this yearis Mr, William J. Long's abt ty oe - The Education of the Wage Earners Ayers *y oa ‘ 7IDSON ; , P If body should say **Give me the title of a book of exceptional By bi eng — — — Edited with introductory chapter by | merit — ageropetete one gift toa boy in his teens ortwa vouns girl," ES M. BAKEWELL. ; we should without a moment's hesitation say “NORTHERN TRAILS.” A contribution toward the solution of the educational prob- —Syracuse Herald lem of Democracy. 247 pages. 75 cents. Trade Unionism and Labor Problems | The Great Out-of-Door Book of the Year J N . Cor ONS 5 7 2 on Bn nn oe pages. EA? net Frontispiece in colors and gold, 12 full-page and 200 smaller Trusts, Pools and Corporations illustrations, by Charles Copeland. 400 pages. $1.50 net By W. Z. Rircey 500 pages. $2.15 net Did you read “A Little Brother to the Bear” and “School of the President Roosevelt’s Railroad Policy Woods,” by Mr. Long--uniform with “NORTHERN TRAILS” ? Cc. A. Prov Ss Dav WILLCOox GE GROSS > iK . : eg _ AP Mages, Lunes = camen —— Send your name on a post card for our Out-of-Doors Calendar GINN & COMPANY Publishers, Boston | FROM DUTTON’S AUTUMN LIST. | . In The Country of Jesus From the Italian of MATILDE SERAO Translated by Richard Davey. Illustrated. $2.00 net. ] This book has had the distinction of having passed through thirty edi- tions in Italy since its publication. The author is a firm believer, and, accepting the Gospels and the ancient traditions, writes a delightful record of a journey through the Holy Land. It brings delight every month throughout the 4 The Cities of Umbria It solves—easily, de- ay ft: Se all HUTTON i — oe ' uthor of “ the ians.” lightfully—the Christ |] 20 illustrations in color by A. Pica. 12mo, cloth. $2.00 net. mas problem. Mr. Hutton is a traveler who has the faculty of seeing what is really worth P See while and telling it well. “The Cities of Umbria” is full of the spirit of Italy, A years subscription and one of the most delightful of the holiday books of travel. to The Century. 4 —— 5 ovesecrsumter ering st toma} |} He Diary of a Girl in France in 1821 Ward's novel) and December number (begin- By MARY BROWNE carters whe vegia CUE kanaary, 1900. 60.00. | With illustrations by herself. 8vo, in box. $2.50 net. Full of a child’s impressions of foreign travel before the days of modern railways and hotels. The War in the Far East Illustrated with Portraits, Maps, Plans, etc. By THE MILITAR CORRESPONDENT OF “THE Alden Genealogy, 1620-1902 . LONDON TIMES.” wie ur itte end toe Cantey, ee eT thera tiaras se S| EF, P, DUTTON & COMPANY ‘i 31 West 23d St, New York a copy of page of Pilgrim autographs. | HENRY SHAW Room 123, State House, Boston.

Page 4

[Vol. 81, No. 2109 The Nation. THE UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO PRESS NEW BOOKS | SMALL —— General Sociology ALBION W. Professor Small’s main proposition is that the traditional sciences relating to the spiritual sides of life are sterile, unless they are carried out to a point at which they blend in one system of knowledge. The book is an exposition of the development of social theory from Spencer to Ratzenhofer, and a plea for the completion of the general structure of social 753 pp.; 8vo, cloth; net $4.00, postpaid $4.23. science. A Decade of Civic Development CHARLES ZUEBLIN The author gives a concise and spirited account of certain definite measures—political, econ- omic, social, and artistic—for the betterment of American cities. Professor Zueblin was formerly president of the American League for Civic Improvement. He is the author of American Municipal Progress and other volumes. 200 pp.; oe a ‘i om Primary Facts in Religious Thought Seven short essays intended to state, in a simple and practical manner, the essential princi- ples of religion, and to clear them from the confusion arising from theoretical changes and 125 pp.; 12mo, cloth; net 75c., postpaid 82c. 12mo, cloth; net $1.25, postpaid $1.39. ALFRED W. WISHART historical criticism. A Study in the Social Premises of Religion Louis wALtis In this essay the author first sets forth the proposition that “egoism is the only ‘force’ propel- ling the social machine.” This :hesis he then proceeds to demonstrate by evidence drawn from biblical history. Lastly he shows its practical bearing on the present social problem. 137 pp.; 16mo, cloth; net, 75c, postpaid, 85c. Egoism: Methods in Plant Histology CHARLES J. CHAMBERLAIN An indispensable book for students of Botany. and preparing plant material for microscopic investigation. to be published on this subject. Second edition, illustrated. 272 pp.; 8vo, cloth; net $2.25, postpaid $2.39. The volume contains directions for collecting : It is the first complete manual RECENT BOOKS Christian Belief Interpreted by Christian Science CHARLES CUTHBERT HALL rhis inte: esting volume conteins the “ Barrows Lectures " delivered by President Hall io the leading cities of India aad Japan, in connection with the lectureship founded by Mrs. Caroline E. Haskell. In these days, when the momeotous events in the Far East have qtickered an interest in all things Oriental, this thoughtful and earnest work should be welcomed by everyone who desires to go below the sur- fac: fcran explanation of the message from the mysterious East for which all are waiting 0) pp. ; Svo, cloth ; net $1.50, postpaid, $1.66, Prophetic Element in the Old OF IMPORTANCE | Russia and Its Crisis PAUL MILYOUKOV The New York Times, under date of August 26, says: “It is not often that an author is so forcibly reminded of the truth of his own printed words as Professor Paul Milyoukov has been. His book = — sia, which we review this week, describes the ‘attem 4 eo "gees racy and liberalism,’ now under way in his native 5 tow days have given a ——s = emplification of both the bseation ond the autocracy. The Czar issued his rescript instituting a National Assembly, and within a fortnight of it his Government has arrested Professor Milyoukov for his activity in promoting agitation for reform in the empire.” 602 pp.; 8vo, cloth, net, $3.00, postpaid, $3.20, Place of Industries in Elementary Testament WILLIAM R. HARPER Education KATHARINE E. DOPP A scholarly handbook for advanced students. This volume is the “ The book deals with the basic ot a of ae traini L- is latest in the series of Constructive Bible Studies. 150 pp.; Avo, cloth ; a distinct contribution to the aoa pomeney, toda rd edi- tion. Revised. Illustrated. Ore pp. be ie net, $1.00, postpaid, $1.11. postpaid, $1.00 A Bul etin of New Books, which contains detailed announcements for the year will be malied free upon request. ADDRESS DEPT. 21 THE UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO PRESS CHICAGO or NEW YORK —_——

Page 5

: : : z Nov. 30, 1905] The Nation. .) e THE BEST CHRISTMAS GIFT Useful, Reliable, Attractive, Lasting, Up to Date and Authoritative. No other gift will so often be a reminder of the giver. 2380 pages, 5000 illustrations. Recently enlarged with 25,000 new words, a new Gazetteer, and new Biographical Dictionary, edited by W.T. Harris, Ph.D.,LL.D., U.S. Com. of Ed’n. Grand Prize, World’s Fair, St. Louis. Ww — e 7 o cur abridquents ‘Regular on4 Thin Paper editions, Jnsurpassed for elegance and con- venience. 1116 p ges and 1400 illustrations. Write for “ The Story of a Book”—Free. G. & C. MERRIAM CO., Springfield, Mass. GET THE BEST. LIBRARY SERVICE We aim to serve librarians with the greatest efficiency. We have (1.) Competent and thoroughly equipped book men. (2.) The largest miscellaneous book stock in New York City. (3.) A valuable line of order lists —as follows— A. Monthly Bulletin of the Lat- est and Best Selling Books. B. Standard Library Catalogue. C. Clearance Catalogue. Do You Get These? Sent Free. THE BAKER & TAYLOR Co. WHOLESALE BOOKSELLERS, 33-37 E. 17th St., Union Sq , North, New York Atlantic “Monthly FOR DECEMBER Published December Ist. Riches: A Christmas Essay. By Epwarp S. Martm. Qne of Mr. Martin’s delightful essays, full of mellow philoso- phy and quiet humor. Henry Irving. By Taccorr WitiiaMs. An appreciative esti- mate of the great actor by a personal friend and competent critic. Is the Theatre Worth While? By JAMES S. METCALFE. Mr. Metcalfe is dramatic critic of ‘* Life™ and is widely known by his fearless attacks upon the theatrical trust. Woman’s Suffrage in the Tenements. By E.izavetu McCracken. Miss McCracken knows tenement life as do few writers of to-day. Her discriminating social studies are both witty and wise. Five Unusual Short Stories. A Daughter of the Rich. By WiLuiiaM J. Hopkins, author of ** The Clammer.” Flowers of Paradise. By Atice Brown. The Choice of Circumstance. By Caroutine Durr. An Interchange of Courtesies. By CLARE BeNEpicT. Judge Bank’s Mary. By Rose E. Youns. Verse, Book-Reviews, Essays, and the Contribu- tor’s Club. SPECIAL OFFERS 4 Tris! Subscription /r three months sent to new subscribers on receipt of fifty cents. Three issues, October, November, and Decem- ber, 1905, will be sent free to new subscribers for 1906 on receipt of $4.00. 35 cents a copy, $4.00 per year. Illustrated Prospectus for 1906 sent free upon application. HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO., 4 Park St., Boston, Mass. MANSIONS OF ENGLAND IN THE OLDEN TIME By JOSEPH NASH INTERNATIONAL STUDIO SUPPLEMENT ito Wrappers, $2.00 net. Cloth, $3.00 net, postage % cts. A splendid series of reproductions of the most interesting drawings in English domestic architecture ever issued THE STORY OF THE PRINCESS DES URSINS IN SPAIN By CONSTANCE HILL 12m0, $1 50 net, postage 14 « An account of what befell the lady appointed by Louis XIV to the post of Mistress of the ceed s Household (Camerera Mayor) in the Bourbon Court at Madrid, Sally Wister's Fournal. “Ob, gracious! Debby am all alive with fear. The English & on Chestnut Hill, our army three miles this side. What will of us?’’ writes Sally Wister in 1777, two months after the ttle of Germantown. Get her charming “Journal,” beauti- fully illustrated, and see the Revolu- tionary War through her eyes. $2.00, postpaid. FERRIS & LEACH, Pubs., Philadelphia, or any bookstore. sexo ron ~JQHN LANE COMPANY, New York xu4s IST THE BODLEY HEAD, 67 Fifth Ave. SHAKESPEARE | The Complete Works of First Follo Edition ABRAHAM LINCOLN Edited by Porter-Clarke, Printed by DeVinne Authorized Edition VOLUMES NOW KEADY “ Midsummer Ni ht's | Dreame,” “Love's Labour's Lost, " “Comedie o = Full particulars on application. rere, eX Hercment & Ms af ” ae od ee ull 4 FRANCIS PANY wear,”’ “Hamlet ng Lear.’ ce, In clot 7 bp cents pt volume ; limp leatuer, $1.00 per volume, ANC D. TANDY COM postpald Dept. B 38 Bast ast St., New York Thomas Y, Crowell & Co., New York | ‘Handy Volume Classics STANDARD AUTHORS IN SETS Balzac, e+ Bulwer, wot Cooper, Dick- ens, Dumas, Foe, Eliot, Fielding, Gibbon, Sots, Hawinorne, Hug, ring, e-— Poe, 6 us mo espeare Thackeray, Tolstoi. —_ : Send for Descriptive Booklet. THOMAS Y.CROWELL & CO.New York French Collection For Sale Private collector wishes to sell his gopaine l- lection of genres Books and Pam (2,000 00) ‘Fe ieties to the French Revolution. or on Pavia xV a. % ton, ete. Lafayette, Mira nt ete. An extremely rare 4 a y tam cualty for ina vu ) Connaught St Londen G Rogined Used by schools and colleges everywhere 155 The only WALT WHITMAN life of vols... ay A List prices, cloth, 3c. per vol. this great writer is published in the Beacon Bilo- limp The . . per vol. (Special prices to graphiea. Beautiful photogravure frontispiece. | we bape p and colleges.) P Handsomely bound in cloth. Price 75 cents net. ' : SMALL, MAYNARD & COMPANY SEND FOR CATALOGUE. 31 Arrow Street Cambr'dge, Mass. Thomas Y.Crowell & Co., New Y ork To recetve the current Have You Read “THE QUAKERESS”’? | sumbers ina convenient By CHARLES Heper CLARK (Max Adler), author of | (temporary) form. Sub- “Out of the Hurly Barly.” Postpaid : 50. stantially made, bound THE JOHN C. WINSTON CO., Publishers, Philadelphia ia cloth, with Tas Na- TION stamped on the side AMERICANA in gold. Holds about one The Travels of John Lederer from Virginia t Caro. | volume. Papers easlly me in soso aeg 1670. Published London, 167%. Bean- | end neatly adjusted. tiful reprint of this very rare book, limited to 300 . copies, with facsimile of the Map. Price $2.00 Bent, postpaid, on re GEORGE P. HUMPHKEY, Rochester, 8. Y. ceipt of 75 cents.

Page 6

vi The Nation. [Vol. 81, No. 2109 New Macmillan Publications JUST READY Mr. Samuel Isham’s History of American Painting With 12 full-page photogravures and 100 illustrations in the text. Uniform with Mr. Taft’s “History of American Sculpture,” and Mr. Elson’s “ History of American Music,” in “The History of American Art,” edited by JOHN C VAN D YKE, L.H.D. Cloth, imperial 8vo, handsomely bound in red and gold. $5.00 net (carriage extra) The author traces the development of art in this country, showing the external influences that were brought to bear and how they were developed by the social conditions of America and the personality of the artists. The preceding volumes of this series have each been ranked by the best critics as “undoubtedly the most comprehensive and best work of its class,” in its independent field. PUBLISHED ‘THIS WEEK Mr. Herbert Paul’s History of England. /ourth Volume “His work must rank as a vigorous, lucid and scrupulously fair history of modern times in England.” —Soston Advertiser. “It is this very quality, plus the brilliancy and crispness of Mr. Paul’s manner of telling his story, that makes his book so attractive.” Brooklyn Eagle. Cloth, Svo, gil top. $2.50 nett (postage 17 cents.) The Life and Writings of Benjamin Franklin Second Volume Edited by ALBERT H. SMYTH, Philadelphia. Limited Library edition, with portraits and other illustrations. In ten volumes, cloth 8vo, $3.00 net per volume Dr. Smyth’s edition of the writings of Benjamin Franklin will be by far the most complete and inclusive. It will contain several hundred letters and minuscripts unknown to previous editors of Franklin, half of which are original letters and other writings by Franklin himself, among these being many of the most imp ortant documents by Franklin that have ever been discovered. The Works of Maurice Hewlett Fourth Volume Uniform with the limited editions of the works of Walter Pater and Matthew Arnold. Ten volumes issued monthly. “New Canterbury Tales,” uniform with “ The Forest Lovers,” “Richard Yea-and-Nay’”’ and “Little Novels of Italy” already issued. 500 sets on large paper. Olive green cloth, gilt, $3.00 met per velume When they are all printed, when the novels and the poems are all in this form, with ‘Earthwork Out of Tuscany,’ and the ‘ The Tuscan Road,’ the well proportioned octavos, gleaming in their appropriately sylvan green and gold, will warm the heart of every reader who watches contemporary literature for the things which promise to last."—The New York Tribune. Recollections By William O’Brien, M.P. The book takes one behind the scenes of the Parnell movement in dramiutic fashion, in telling the life history of a distinct lively ind original personality. Cloth, 8vo, 518 pages, $7.50 net Mr. Clyde Fitch’s The Girl with the Green Eyes Cloth, r6mo. 75 cents net An original American play in four acts. Dedicated to Miss Clara Bloodgood as the “ideal interpreter of ‘ Jinny.’ ” READY NEXT WEEK Miss Agnes Laut’s Vikings of the Pacific Being a continuation of “Pathfinders of the West.’’ Richly illustrated. Cloth, er. 8vo, $2.00 net Mr. B. L. Patnam-Weale’s The Re-shaping of the Far East By the author of ‘Manchu and Muscovite.”’ ///ustrated from exceptionally fine photographs supplied by the Japanese Government Ready next week. Svo Dr. Nathaniel Schmidt’s The Prophet of Nazareth By the Professor of Semitic Languages and Literature in Cornell University and Director of the American School of Archxology in Jerusalem. A reinterpretation of the Life of Jesus in the light of the author’s researches in Palestine. Cloth, &vo OUHER NEW BOOKS SUITABLE FOR GIFTS NEW NOVELS Mr. Harwood’s Mr. Charles Major’s New Creations in Plant Life Yolanda, Maid of Burgundy By W.S. HARWOOD. An Authoritative Account of the Life Appears this week in a third large edition, Cloth, $1.50 ae an ey ae ver ay bn Be as — Mr. F. Marion Crawtord’s ere? nnveaek Saari’ (postage 15 cents) Fair Margaret 4 /ortrait § Cith, $150 Almont every character is individual and delightful "'— Cleveland Mrs. Saint Maur’s Leader A Self-Supporting Home ’ Mr. Emerson Hough’s Mrs. SAINT MAUR describes how she set about establishing Heart’s Desire Cloth, $1.50 a self-supporting home in the country with absolutely no capital. It will be fully illustrated. ‘ Embodies with in.’efinable affection, humor and pathos, the West Cloth, $1.75 net (postage 14 cents) » R of our dreama,"’—Chieageo Tribune ruled ~~ THE MACMILLAN COMPANY “Fah ve by ay ey ew

Page 7

Rn ery pee NEW YORK, THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 30, 1005 The Week. President Roosevelt's letter dismissing William S. Leib, Assistant United States Treasurer at Philadelphia, is neither short nor sweet. On several occasions the President has paid his respects to delinquent officials—the gentlemen tak- en in the postal frauds and the cotton- report scandals—in no uncertain tone? The letter to Mr. Leib matches the best of these denunciatory epistles. Leib had all the political backing that any- body could want. Senators Penrose and Knox requested a special hearing for him, and Representative Patterson de- fended him. But no machine has com- manded respect since November 7; and the Pennsylvania machine has been in such unusual disrepute that to throw a brick at it is everywhere regarded as an act of special virtue. The stoutest par- tisans will never dare to accuse the Pres- ident of ignoring the claims of “the organization” and thus imperilling the nation. Leib is an old and hardened offender. The only thing to regret is that he was not beheaded earlier. In this regret the President himself shares. “If the case had at that time [some months ago] been called to my attention,” says Mr. Roosevelt, “my belief is that |! would have then requested your resigna- tion.” Secretary Taft intimates that he ex- pects Congress to investigate the Pana- ma Commission. It would fail of its duty if it did not. The prima-facie evi- dence of waste, extravagance, and mis- management is abundant. One result is pretty certain to be established—the fol- ly of appropriating $10,000,000 to be ex- pended in the discretion of any man. The temptation of such a sum available without a detailed estimate submitted to Congress is not unlike that of a huge life-insurance surplus: it makes people mad to get at it. Congressmen who have seen the salary list of the Panama Com- mission are amazed at it. It has some- thing of the air of a royal civil list. Then there are many contracts and pur- chases made by the Commission into which Congress should feel it obligatory to look. Furthermore, the conditions on the Isthmus seem to call for scrutiny. The Herald printed on Friday the pro- tests of American clergymen in Pana- ma against the “monstrous iniquity” of the importation of hundreds of aban- doned women, with the consent of the canal authorities, the object being to make the laborers “contented.” And physicians on the spot are speaking out The Nation. against the certain result of this kind of “sanitation.” All told, an inquiry into the whole affair by a committee of Congress bids fair to be fruitful. The system of control which Congress exercises over the Post-Office involves the appropriation of all the money need- ed for the entire establishment every year, and the subsequent return of the gross receipts to the Treasury. Thus, Mr. Cortelyou accompanies his request for $12,000,000 more money for next year with the prediction that he will be able to reduce the postal deficit from last year’s figure of $14,572,584. He pro- poses to keep the clerical force practi- cally at its present size, and has econ- omized somewhat in the special facili- ties of railway transportation. Increase, of course, is regularly to be expected in the general lines of the department work, and rural free delivery is natur- ally growing at a rate much beyond that ot the rest, but the natural end of this would seem to be a condition of equili- brium in which all parts of the coun- try faré substantially alike, and growth keeps pace merely with the in- crease of population. That may be the time for going to the fundamentals of the postal-deficit problem. At present, the unprofitable departments of the ser- vice are growing so much faster than the income-producing ones that predic- tions as to anything but the immediate future are not to be trusted too much. Apart from the merits of the case, Mid- shipman Meriwether’s trial at Annapolis brings out some amazing facts about the student “code” at the Naval Academy. Under it, not only have there been a score or more of pugilistic fights, under the rules of the prize ring, but official duty, not to speak of the obligations of a gentleman, has been steadily disre- garded. The Annapolis “code,” in fact, has many of the absurd: features of the duello. There is the same perverted sense of “honor,” the same compulsion to fight, the same wild notions about what the fight establishes. Thus, it was testified that these brutal encounters of- ten resulted in “handshaking” and a general withdrawal of insulting epi- thets. It was said that Meriwether, af- ter calling Midshipman Branch a “sneak,” a “coward,” and “no gentle- man,” discovered after twenty rounds that he was one of the finest fellows on earth. This is too fantastic to be al- lowed in an Academy where men are supposed to be taught realities. Apart from the fatal result in this case, the whole system, as disclosed, with its semi- barbarous and obsolete standards of per- sonal honor, clearly calls for instant re- form, and by reform we mean abolition Joseph Ralph Burton, United States Senater from Kansas, is reported to b somewhat depressed, and not withou' reason, for he has a second time been convicted of exerting his official influ ence in behalf of an enterprise which was using the mails to defraud. The first conviction was set aside on the purely technical ground that the payment to Rurton was made outside the jurisdi tion of the trial court. Burton threaten: to appeal again, and he may conceiy ably succeed in having this second ver dict set aside. While he is waiting fo. the decision of the higher court, he wil! enjoy the seclusion of private lif “Though he is still a United States Sen ator,” says his counsel, “he will not take his seat. I do not believe this would be proper or dignified, and Senator Burton does not think so either.” We commend Burton's modesty to the attention of two New York statesmen. Of a certain kind of strenuous life, Gov. Jeff Davis of Arkansas is a most admirable example. It is not his fault if he is not now the idol of every bar room, the hero of every prize-fighter and gutter ruffan. Monday's personal en counter in which he had his skull crack ed by a pistol in the hands of ex-Con gressman Dinsmore, was only his fifth fight within three years. He fought a draw with the Republican candidate fo: Governor in August, 1902; was knocked out by Judge Carroll D. Wood a year later; yas prevented by friends from clinching with A. F. Vandeventer in Ox tober, 1903, and had another stand-up fight with Judge Wood in December, 1993. He was threatened with death by his Attorney-General in September of this year, but still survives to fight again—and, incidentally, to show the world how low a blackguard can become a Governor. An experienced, not to say hardened, protectionist will only smile at the de- mand of the artists that they be no longer protected by the tariff on art. These gentlemen meet in convention in this city to declare that the tariff as it affects them is blind and behind the times; but what has that to do with the case? If proving our fiscal system both stupid and obsolete could have altered it, we should have seen it changed years ago. Protection does hot object to hard names; call it what you like, provided you vote for the men who uphold it Mr. Kenyon Cox asserted that the ar- gument against the art duty is simply “unanswerable.” We agree with him: so is the argument against a hundred

Page 8

434 duties, but what good does that Protectionists will let you have all if only other do? the logical triumphs you want remain in control of Congress they may and keep the schedules intact. The standpatters have no desire to get the better of the argument; all they wish is to have the better of the voting in com- and on the floor. The situation would be different if the artists had a political following, or were in the habit of making large campaign contributions. In that case they would be an “interest” mittee to be taken care of; as it is, they are, from the of the protec- tionists with a Congress and the lot of amiable enthusiasts whose protests and appeals of view grip President, merely a point on can be disregarded with perfect safety. The truth is, the protectionists maintain that the American citizen is allowed to French painting paying a tax on it, the sched- on imitation rails, and pickled sheepskins will go toppling that notoriously the middle-class American regulates his expenditures for underwear, and garden hose solely with reference to the price he has paid for the oil paintings in his parlor. If that schedule is touched, all the oth- moment an buy a without steel ules jewelry, down: crockery, ers must go too. It seems to have been expected by almost no one that the anti-cigarette laws passed by Indiana and Wisconsin Yet the reports now coming from both those last winter would ever be enforced. States indicate that neither one is being allowed to become a dead-letter. Whethb- er this means that they are to remain permanently on the etatute-book or will be repealed with alacrity, depends on the temper of the people. There is one point, however, in which such a law is to be distinguished from the prohibi- tion of liquor. If a “blind pig” is ac- cessible and properly supplied, a drink- man can imbibe there about as well He place ng is accustomed to for his But the cigarette-smoker expects as anywhere else pota- resort to a special tions to indulge himself while going about his usual occupations He has never ex- pected to go to some retired place to moke Cigarette-smoking, in other words, ceases to be attractive if it must be clandestine, and therefore the law has, in this special aspect, a better chance of regulating it And as the ob- ject of these laws was not to stop smok- ing In general, but this particular kind, every convert to the cigar or pipe is a living monument to the wisdom of the Weatern legislators. So, may add, ly the young Nebraskan fined $50 and costs for rolling, otherwise “manufacturing,” a cigarette for his we recently own use, Boston is not so sure that her system of primary nominations is all that she thought it was, A fortnight ago the pri- The Nation. selection of candidates for Mayor were held. Five men—two Democrats and three Republicans—had stumped the city, and roused more in- has been show: in a mu- nicipal election since the late Mayor Collins put himself at the head of the Boston Democracy. Representative John F. Fitzgerald was the choice of the Dem- ocratic primaries, Louis A. Froth- ingham of the Republican. But H. 8. Dewey, one of the defeated Republican became suspicious of the methods by Mr. Frothingham’s campaigners to secure a bare 300 plural- ity. A ery of fraud was set up and a recount demanded. The result was to cut Mr. Frothingham’'s plurality in half, and Mr. Dewey still insisted that he had been defeated by fraudulent votes, and announced that he would run as an in- Doubtless he Is maries for the terest than and aspirants, used dependent candidate. spurred on by Moran's success in win- ning election as District Attorney inde- pendently. But, to judge from the com- ments of the Boston newspapers, there is little likelihood of Judge Dewey's be- ing hailed as a New England Jerome. “Preserving the gold standard” is too good a phrase to be lost; we should in- corporate it permanently in our politi- cal vocabulary. In 1896 the big insur- ance companies were paying $50,000 each to the Republican campaign fund in or- der to preserve the gold standard. In 1900 the standard still seemed to be in danger. In 1904, ordinary men ceased to have apprehensions; but the far-sighted presidents of our insurance companies continued to see the menace on the dis- tant horizon, and cheerfully handed out the $50,000—takerm as usual, from the pockets of the policyholders. Nothing but the salvation of the country and the preservation of the gold standard, they assured us solemnly, could have induced them to contribute to a political party. They regarded State issues and local issues as beneath their notice. On November 21, however, Senator Thomas C. Platt testified in effect that he had a little gold standard of his own which he was preserving very industriously. He was not interested in the national but in the State, campaign; and yet the Equitable paid him $10,000 a year, and the Mutual often gave as much. Presi- dent Richard A. McCurdy, by the way, who swore that the Mutual did not give to the State campaigns, was the man with whom Platt had dealings. Plat is not the only man who had a gold standard. The Equitable has carried on its payroll for twenty-three years an old Tammany politician, Thomas Coman, at a salary ranging from $2,000 to $6,000. His duty has been to preserve the gold standard of individual officers of the company, and he mentioned specifically Mr. Alexander, Mr. Hyde, Mr. Tarbell, and Mr. Jordan. He would keep these [Vol. 81, No. 2109 gentlemen on good terms with the city government and get their tax assess- ments reduced. For such eminent ser- vices to the country $6,000 a year from the money of the policyholders was a miserably small reward. The testimony of Mr. George W. Per- kins on Monday did not reveal him in an absolutely new light—it was of a piece with what had gone before; but it was astonishingly replete with eva- sions, shifts, doublings, reluctance to come to the point, hollow excuses, pre- tences, and finally the most damaging admissions. Here was an enormous fiduciary business managed in the spirit of a Bowery shop for second-hand cloth- ing. Deceit and misrepresentation were the chief stock in trade. The public was bamboozled, the Superintendent of In- surance was hoodwinked, the policy- holders were deceived and cheated. Ac- counts were doctored, minutes of impor- tant meetings were falsely kept, black- mailers were allowed to bleed the com- pany at will, political contributions were made under lying entries in the books, and the whole vast system of irregular- ity and crookedness and graft covered with a thin veneer of the most disgust- ing hypocrisy. Mr. Perkins and his fel- lows have made themselves impossible. They have forfeited all respect,and must lose their trust positions. If any of the trustees of either the Mutual or the New York Life think that their business can be saved except by the most radical changes of personnel, they are living in a fool’s paradise. Why, policyholders by the thousand are turning to Tom Law- son in preference to McCall or McCurdy or Perkins! That is only a hint of the desperate situation which requires des- perate remedies. Public confidence can be restored only by dismissing the men who have destroyed it. Mr. Tarbell’s views in the matter of deferred-dividend policies are such as would naturally be expected from the head of a life-insurance company’s agents. Mr. McCall, in his testimony of October 7 before the Armstrong commit- tee, defended the “twenty-year policy,” and expressed his objection to “straight life” annual dividends, on the ground, very largely, that to get good solicitors the company must pay good commis- sions, and that agents’ commissions on a deferred-dividend policy are much larger than on ordinary life-insurance contracts. This argument would nat- urally appeal to an officer whose duty it is to “show results” in new insurance. Mr. Tarbell undertook, however, to set forth arguments in defence of the defer- red-dividend principle itself. Briefly, his points are that such policies, matur- ing at a stated date, add to the safety of insurance by the large surplus funds accruing in the interim; that they pro-

Page 9

Nov. 30, 1905] vide for the family when the policy ma- tures; that they are cheap insurance, be- cause no dividends so high can be paid on the annual basis; that they attract “good lives,” because men not in good health would mistrust their chance of surviving to get the benefits of the “pool”; that they induce men to in- sure who would not insure if a “death risk” alone were the basis of their in- surance; and that they do not lapse as “straight life’ policies often do. These arguments do not impress us. To say that withholding dividends for twenty years, and then paying them in a lump, adds to the safety of insurance, begs the whole question. If the funds reserved against such accruing divi- dends are calculated merely on the basis of safe insurance, then the company as a whole is protected neither better nor worse than it would have been without them. On the other hand, if the mon.- strous evils, extravagance, and corrup- tion of which our great companies have been guilty, do not lie directly at the door of the abnormal surpluses thus ac- cumulated, then the Armstrong commit- tee’s researches have been in vain. As to the second point, a “twenty-year pol- icy” at least provides no better for a family than a _ savings-bank account maintained by similar payments during the same period; it is capable of proof, indeed, that its provision is far less adequate. That these policies, with their excessive charge for premiums and their exceedingly meagre return of ac- cumulated dividends, are the cheapest form of insurance, we had not supposed even Mr. Tarbell would seriously con- tend. If allowance he made for those who lose all their dividends through death in the period prescribed, we take it to be the most extravagant form of insurance in the field. Mr. Tarbell’s other arguments hardly call for answer. Our own view of the matter is summed up in the Frick report’s conclusions, which we have quoted heretofore; we may add, with approval, the following remarks, addressed to the Insurance Commissioners’ Convention last Septem- ber by Insurance Commissioner McGiv- ney: “The purpose of a mutual life-insurance company is not to have its members gam- bling on the misfortunes of its other mem- bers. The deferred-dividend plan is the medium of building up large surplus funds which are not required by law to earn any interest; it furnishes a ready means to make up losses from extravagance and waste, and ts a temptation to the manage- ment for hazardous and risky speculation in the policyholders’ funds.” “For ways that are dark,” but for tricks that have not been vain, com- mend us to the insurance grafters. John A. Nichols received for some years $1,000 from each of the three great com- panies with which to stop the mighty pen of the “rantankerous friend” at Al- The Nation. bany, W. S. Manning. But the latter Swears he got of late only a miserable $300 annually as his “legal” retainer Profit for Nichols, just $2,700 a year. As for the mighty McCalls and MecCurdys and Alexanders, this leaves their boast- light. Any up-river graybeard with a sancti ed business ability in a sorry monious air could stand them all up against a wall and make them hold up their hands while he extracted from their pockets just what he wanted. Sv easy was this game that it makes the trade of a blackmailing society editor seem like an elaborate business transac- their methods were crooked, and so they paid tion* But the magnates knew every one who came along to save them- selves from exposure. Assemblymen,. Strikers of the Manning type, avaricious lawyers, United States Senators—all knew a good thing when they saw it, and worked their mine for all it was worth. What mattered it if the money was stolen from men and women who toiled and slaved and saved pennies to pay premiums? The woods were full of them; the agents roped them in by the hundreds; surpluses piled up; the State Insurancé Department connived willingly, no danger was in sight, and all went merrily. Is it any wonder that the McCalls and McCurdys have a sense of deep personal injury at the thought that their little paradise has been rude- ly invaded? There will presumably be considerable maneuvring for position betwee the Liberals and the Tories before the. im- pending dissolution and general elec- tion. If Parliament were in session, the King would no doubt send for Sir Henry Campbell-Bannerman and ask him to form a Ministry. Then the budget would be passed and the appeal to the country made. But Sir Henry is too old a bird to be taken in the net which Mr. Balfour is now spreading before him—the suggestion, that is, that he form a Government in the dark, drift aiong till February, then suffer a vote of no confidence in the House and be compelled to dissolve. He will refuse unquestionably, to fall in with the stra- They must either do their own dissolving, or stagger on under a still heavier burden of discredit. Of the outcome of the general election, there can be no reason- able doubt. Chamberlain talks valiant- ly about “closing up the ranks” and get- ting rid of “blunt swords,” but such advocacy of a snug little party all of one mind is folly in an appeal to a ereat electorate where, as Lord Hugh Cecil remarks, success is “a matter of nose- tegy of the Tories in that way. counting, and each free-fooder has his nose.” The signs all point to a crushing defeat of the Chamberlain policy in the election of the new House. The argu- ment has been strong against it; trade- _ 435 returns still stronger. Chamberlain himself expects to be beaten in the first His hope is that the Liberals and that onset. will make a mess of it in office, years, his second chance will come. All this is in the lap of the gods; the only certain thing after a couple of that the great issue is soon to be pu to the electoral test, and that, whoeve may hereafter lead the Conservativ: party in whatever paths, we are now witnessing the passing of Arthur Bal! four. The executive committee of the Zemstvo Congress, in pledging its sup port to the Witte Cabinet, “so long as it follows the path for the accomplishment of the liberties promised by the mani festo,” gives encouraging evidence that Russia has advanced far on the road to liberalism. The force of events, which is daily converting conservative leaders and journalists into adherents of the new régime, is not lost upon Witte him self. He appears sincerely intent upon gathering around him men who enjoy the confidence of the Liberals. Only four years ago, there appeared in Stutt gart a secret memorandum (in Russian) by Witte, then Minister of Finance, on “Autoecracy and the Zemstvo,” in which he attempted to prove that, “under an absolutist government, the labor of the social forces is incomparably more pro ductive to the country and the people at large than it can be under a parlia mentary Government.” To-day, as the Premier of a LAberal Ministry, he prom ises universal suffrage and the widest possible concessions to the toiling masses throughout the land version is ‘evidently accepted as genuine by a majority of the zemstvo leaders, “Octobrists,” as His con though the Moderates they significantly call themselves—de clare that Russia is not ripe for a con stituent assembly. Among the men who enjoy alike the confidence of Count Witte and the zemst voists there are not a few eminent names. Prince Urusoff, Witte’s first choice for Minister of the Interior, a prominent Liberal, was formerly Gov- ernor of Tver, but resigned under the Plehve administration. Prince Eugene Trubetzkoil of the University of Kiev is now one of Witte’s trusted advisers. Prince Volkonsky, M. Stehepkin, and Prince Paul Dolgoruff, long identified with the reform movement, are wield ing great influence in the Congress; and even M. Petrunkevitch, the president of the Moscow Agricultural Seciety, a for mer exile in Siberia and a Radical lead er, declares the restoration of order to be the first duty of the hour. But prob ably the most difficult problem that con fronts Witte lies in the vacillation of the Czar, which is certainly, in this seeth ing time, more excusable than ever.

Page 10

436 “SOLICITOUS ABOUT NEW YORK.” If the President, and every other Re- publican with a shred of decency, were not, as Mr. Roosevelt writes that he is, “very solicitous about the political con- ditions in New York,” they would be both stupid and callous. Apparently, the President had in mind only the sordid quarrel between Odell and Platt. But last week's testimony by the latter un- reverend corruptionist, before the insur- ance inquiry, carries us far beyond that. We have now a full revelation of the way in which the Republican party in New York has been for years a political bawd, selling itself for money. Corrup- tion has been its daily bread. It has lived upon dishonesty, thriven upon blackmail, and grown great on bribery. We now see that its Legislatures have been made up of men hired to do dirty work, its Governors more or less con- sciously the tools of thieves, and its United States Senators common carriers of rottenness. Senator Platt frankly took off the manhole cover and showed us his party sitting in the sewage. Republicans, from the President down, must feel disgraced as well as astonish- ed by Platt’s cynical admission that the party has lived in this State by bleeding corporations and robbing widows and orphans. But what is to be done about it? Restitution, we suppose, cannot now be made, but the promoters and bene- ficiaries of the shameless corruption can be whipped from public life as they al- ready are expelled from the society of decent men. We for our part can see nothing for it but at once to call upon Platt and Depew to resign their offices. They have brought disgrace on the State; the people of the State should demand that they no longer flaunt their infamy in the Senate. Even in that body their presence would hereafter be re- garded as infectious; even its indicted or convicted members would say that their punishment was greater than they could bear if they were held to have sunk so‘low as Platt and Depew. With those two spokesmen in the Senate, New York is not only misrepresented, but made a hissing. Neither of them can show himself in his seat without having every finger in the galleries pointing to the outward sign of New York's deep disgrace. The unbought and self-re- specting press of the State should take this up Immediately. Honest citizens should lift up thelr votces. Petitions should be sent to the Legislature. Gov. Higgins should be addressed; does he not care that New York is made a by- word and a reproach by its two United States Senators caught in the political stews? Platt and Depew must go. Their co-parceners {n corruption—the insur- ance officials—are being driven out: so must they be. It will not do to fall back and leave it to nature soon to snuff out the flickering flame; indignant New Yorkers must see to it that its last Nation. ‘The [Vol. 81, No. 2109 ghastly light is not made to reflect upon the fair fame of the State. President Roosevelt has an imperative duty laid upon him. One striking way to show his disgust with Pilatt’s con- fessed villany is to break with him openly now. The hoary blackmailer and trafficker in legislation ought never to be seen in the White House again. If he will not resign, and has business to transact, the President ought to compel him to do it by letter or messenger. The hand of Theodore Roosevelt should never again be laid in that of Thomas Piatt. Here is a real chance for ostracism—social and political—and the President will be on the defensive if he does not apply it to Platt. Nor can Mr. Roosevelt or his friends allege that this corruption does not touch his white garments. That, indeed, may be alleged of the trust funds obtained last year to elect him President. But how about 1898, when he was elect- ed Governor? That was a close-fought campaign. Mr. Roosevelt’s plurality was narrow. Yet in that year Platt was boss, he was collecting his $10,000 from the Equitable, his $10,000 or whatever it was from the Mutual, and (as the Tribune has asserted, defying Platt to sue it for libel) blackmailing corpora- tions promiscuously. Mr. Roosevelt, moreover, went to consult Platt about the conduct of the campaign. He star- tled his best friends by recognizing the boss as rightful leader; so that a pecu- liar obligation rests upon him to clear his own skirts, and to come to the rescue of His own State, by aiding or leading in every movement to rid public life of the Platt poison. It is not strange that Platt’s habitual defenders and lauders are struck dumb. All the old talk about his “wonderful sagacity” and “unsurpassed manage- ment” and “extraordinary power of at- taching to himself devoted followers,” is now put in its right place. It always was absurd to the eye of reason, and now the dullest can seeit tobe so. Platt a statesman, a leader! He is simply a “striker,” a blackmailer, a purchaser of votes, a seller of nominations and of legislation; carrying the bag, he has carried the party in it. Paymaster-Gen- eral of the forces of corruption, he has held himself in power by precisely the same means as Croker. And how fool- ish, in the light of his own confessions, appears the common remark: “Well, at any rate, none of the money which Platt handled stuck to his own fingers.” How can that be known? He has had millions given to him, and he himself states that he has kept no accounts. He could do with the money what he pleas- ed. There were no tell-tale checks; It was, as he testified, cash by special messenger. From the insurance com- panies alone he appears to have had more than $500,000 in the last twenty years. Well, we cannot stand about holding our noses. We must fall to disinfecting. Here is a work of sanitation before the President greater and more urgent than anything which confronts him at Pana- ma. And the first step should be to re- tire Platt, Depew, and Odell, so that they will no longer be in control of the cor- rupt management of the Republican par- ty, both receiving and giving infection. A LITTLE INSURANCE HISTORY. The reappearance of the name of David B. Hill in connection with life-in- surance affairs recalls an incident which took place while he was Governor of New York. In the year 1880 the State Legislature passed a law to tax life-in- surance companies. It imposed a tax of one per cent. per annum on the gross amount of the premiums, interest, or other income (except from rents), re- ceived by such companies of this State from persons residing in this State, or from investments represented by, or based upon, property situated in this State. This act was chapter 534 of the Laws of 1880. : The companies paid the’ tax until somebody discovered that it might be unconstitutional. The State Constitu- tion provided that every law imposing a tax should state the object to which it was to be applied. The law of 1880 did not do so. The amount received from the tax had passed into the Treasury and had been appropriated to the gen- eral expenses of the State. The compa- nies thereupon ceased paying until the arrears amounted to $1,000,000 or there- abouts. Meanwhile, the Legislature had passed another tax law without any men- tion of the object to which the revenue should be applied. This was the col- lateral-inheritance law. Under this act a case arose in the courts almost imme- diately which was destined to settle the dispute. Mrs. .Mary McPherson died, leaving a will containing bequests to other persons than her direct heirs. The taxing authorities demanded the por- tion due to the State, which the execu- tors refused to pay, on the ground that the law fixing the tax was unconstitu- tional, since it did not state the object to which it was to be applied. It was at once perceived that the decision in the McPherson case would cover the question raised by the life-insurance companies. Accordingly, its progress was watched with great and growing in- terest, and it came to pass that before it reached the Court of Appeals a dozen or more of the ablest lawyers in the State ranged themselves on the side of the McPherson heirs. The fees of these lawyers, if charged at the usual rates, would have swallowed up the estate in controversy several times over, and the natural inference was that the life-in- surance companies were fighting the battle of the McPherson heirs. ee a San

Page 11

ee a eee eee Nov. 30, 1905] The Nation. 43 The case was decided in favor of the State in February, 1887, without a dis- senting voice. The court held that the provision in the Constitution which re- quired that every law imposing a tax should state its object, applied to the annual recurring taxes known at the time of the adoption of the Constitution (1846), i. e., the general property tax, but did not apply to the specia! taxes subsequently devised and enacted. It was absurd to suppose that the State could not reach new sources of revenue without specifying in each instance how it should be apportioned among the sev- eral objects of public expenditure. This case is known as “the matter of Mc- Pherson” (104 N. Y. 306). When the decision was announced, it was general- ly assumed that the delinquent compa- nies would pay the back taxes due to the State, but no such thing happened. A bill was forthwith introduced in the Legislature, then Republican in both branches, not only to release them from the arrears, but to repeal the law of 1880 altogether, and this movement gained such headway that the State Comptroller (Hon, Alfred C. Chapin), in order to save this source of revenue for the future, proposed a compromise, re- linquishing one-half of the arrears and keeping the law of 1880 in force. Charges of bribery and corruption began to reach the newspapers from their Albany cor- respondents, and these rumors worried the supporters of the bill not a little, but did not stop the measure. Cecimp- troller Chapin’s bill was voted down and the repealing bill was passed by both branches. It is chapter 699 of the Laws of 1887. Undoubtedly some votes were cast for it honestly; some men voted for it then who would not do so in the light of recent revelations. Senator Fassett, for example, supported it on the ground that the money released by the State would, in the case of the three leading com- panies (the Equitable, the Mutual, anda the New York Life), enure to the bene- fit of the policyholders, who ought not to be taxed. The possibility that the State might lose the money, and the pol- icyholders lose it also, had not present- ed itself to the Senatorial mind. More- over, the superstition that policyholders ought not to bear any part of the bur- den of government was stronger then than it was in 1880, or than it is now. Making all possible allowance, however, for the simplicity of legislators who voted to these rich companies a million dollars actually due to the State Treas- ury, and many other millions to become due, there can be no doubt that this bill ‘was “handled” by such characters as “Judge” Hamilton and “Al” Fields, backed by the use of money. The bill passed the Senate on the 19th of May, and went immediately to Gov- ernor Hill, who took a long time to consider it. Not until the 25th of June did he make up his mind what to do. Meanwhile, the Legislature had adjourn- ed. If he should simply witbhold his signature, the bill would be dead, and the Comptroller would forthwith collect the back taxes. The companies must have been very much in the same state of mind as the Mercantile Trust Com- pany was last year, with the Ambler bill hanging as a sword of Damocles over its head. But the Governor made up his mind at last that it was a good bill and ought to pass. So he signed it. And now we learn that in 1895, while he was a Senator of the United States, Mr. Hill received from the Equi- table Life an offer of a retainer, which he accepted with thanks, saying that it came very “handy” at that time. FOOTBALL REFORM BY ABOLITION. Never before has a football season ended amid such a well-nigh universal chorus of denunciation of the game, or with such a record of fatalities. At last our college presidents have found their voices; some of them at least have got beyond the fear of losing students by attacking what has become an intoler- able evil, and are ready to follow Presi- dent Eliot’s lead in demanding a change. Thus, President Wheeler of the Univer- sity of California declares that the game “must be made over or go”; Presi- dent Hopkins of Williams feels that the game is doomed unless it can be radical- ly altered; President Schurman thinks it time for the college presidents to act; and Chancellor MacCracken has asked President Eliot to call a conference of the heads of our educational institu- tions. But the best utterance of all is that of Prof. Shailer Mathews, dean of the Divinity School of Chicago Univer- sity, who thus states the truth: “Football to-day is a social obsession—a boy-killing, education-prostituting, gladia- torial sport. It teaches virility and cour- age, but so does war. I do not know what should take its place, but the new game should not require the services of a physi- cian, the maintenance of a hospital, and the celebration of funerals.” There is danger, however, that, in the multiplicity of denunciation and of plans for reform, the true nature of the evil may be lost sight of. For instance, the proposed changes in the eligibility rules, |, to guard against professionalism, sug- gested by the repentant sinners of the University of Pennsylvania, are likely only to distract attention from the main issue, even if their inspiration is from within the White House. The question of injuries and deaths, too, serious as it is, has become now of smaller impor- tance—merely incidental. It is, of course, most gratifying to read such straight talk as has come from Dr. F. R. Oastler, in charge of the Columbia squad. Most surgeons of athletic teams have been content to drug and stimulate the players, to patch them up so that they may enter the fray again, even at the risk of their lives. This physician has had enough of silence, and demands the abolition of the game. “I have been,” he says, “surgeon of the Columbia team for six years, and I think it is the most brutal exhibition I have ever seen or heard of to call a sport. The players zo on the field expecting to be hurt, and are glad if they come off with nothing worse than a broken bone.” The real question before the public to-day is whether it is worth while to attempt to modify the game, or whether it should not be abolished forthwith. For twenty years modern football has been on trial in one form or another, and it has gone steadily from bad to worse. It has been shown beyond dis- pute in these columns, as well as in the pages of McClure’'s Magazine, Collier's Weekly, Public Opinion, and in news- papers all over the country, that the following evils have come in the train of football: (1) the introduction of paid athletes and bogus students, such as teamsters and ex-prizefighters; (2) the demoralization of the secondary schools by the recruiting sergeants of the universities; (3) the use of unfair and immoral methods to win games: (4) the steady increase in the gambling and betting features of intercollegiate contests; (5) the ever-growing danger of injuries from mass plays; (6) the demoralization of the student body by false standards of what is honorable and dishonorable in athletics, and the utterly disproportionate emphasis placed upon athletics as opposed to mentai training. This indictment itself would seem to be enough to make the end of the game inevitable. But there are still other facts to be recorded. College presidents and faculties have every- where been terrorized by student opin- ion. “The boys have wanted the game,” and desired to win at any price. Hence the college authorities have abdicated their proper functions, always trembling lest a radical stand decrease the en- rolment and drive students to a rival institution where teams, mayhap, have won three or four years out of five. Even at Harvard there are timid souls who ask whether this year’s decreased at- tendance is not perhaps due to Presi- ‘dent Eliot's hostility to football. At any rate, the loss of students seems to them to make this time “inopportune” for the greatest American university to win fresh prestige by uprooting this ath- letic evil Professor Mathews is right. Football has become a “social obsession,” from which education has suffered terribly. We hear of instance after instance in which preparatory-school pupils are forced to play by their teachers, often against their own and their parents’ wishes, and under penalty of ostracism. In Harvard it is notorious that football has now become the best and easiest way to enter the undergraduate socie-

Page 12

438 ties Your “grind” may rank as high is he pleases in his studies; it is the fellow who has broken an arm in a scrimmage who has the plaudits and the admiration of his mates, and before whom the doors of the chapter houses swing open as if by magic. To say that this obsession can be cured by ignoring the fatuous rules committee, and de- ciding whether there shall or shall not be “offside interference or mass plays,” is like turning a hose on the roof of a building when the first floor is in flames Football has become not merely intol- rable in itself, but a grave menace to American scholastic ideals and develop- ment \ uch it should go forthwith There is no time like the present in which to right this wrong. \ few «hools and small colleges have abolish- ed football, but its death-blow must come from such an institution as Har- vard or Columbia. There should be no lack of rivalry for the honor, and no time wasted in considering how the game can be “radically altered” or “made over.’ “FUNDAMENTALS” IN COLLEGE. The Harvard Overseers’ Committee on Reports and Resolutions, Charles Fran- cis Adams, chairman, has recently pro pounded a question which should set col lege men to thinking. The committee asks whether, “under conditions exact- ing some measure of retrenchment,” it is better “to impair the efficiency of the fundamental courses of instruction, pur sued by large numbers of students, or to effect the necessary économies by re- ducing the number of special courses.” Che conmittee had before it the needs of the English department. According to a report made to the Overseers by the Committee on English Literature, the allowance for this department was cut $9,800 in 1904-05. “The practical re- suit of this economy,” says the commit- tee, “has been the reduction in the num- her of courses provided, and a curtail ment in the force of assistants requisite for proper supervision of the men in the larwe courses.” The Committee on English supports its case by particu- lars, and concludes that “the department is at present undermanned, to the detri- ment of the atudents in the large courses and of the progress of the Graduate Hehool.” Mr. Adama'’s committee, accepting the atatementsa in this report on the Ene lish department, directly raises the Is ane as to the educational policy involv- ed. The English courses are “elemen- tary and fundamental,” “attended by no while there attended b leas than 2,131 students, are many special courses but few students or even by single atu denta., Referring to the experience and policy Yale under similar circumatance it ha been tated that. of a total number of The Nation. 181 courses, it wae there found that 70 [ Vol. 81, No. 2109 were taken by fewer than ten students each; 36 by fewer than five; 8 by fewer than three; and 11 by a single student each only. Under these circumstances, the total num- ber of courses in the Yale programme was, as a measure of necessary retrenchment, reduced from 263 to 249, and of the 249 re- maining courses it was stated that ‘between 50 and 60 would be cut out unless a suffi- cient number of students elected them to make it worth while giving them.’ *’ Other colleges, we may add, have, in pe- riods of stress, been forced to make cuts quite as vital. Mr. Adams’s com- mittee does not undertake to answer the question which it brings forward. Were a college a factory, Mr. Adams could not hesitate to reply in seven words, “Cut along the line of least re- sistance.” But a college, though its business needs the most skilful man- agement, is not a commercial enter- prise. For example, the head of a fac- tory or a store must think twice before incurring a deficit; the president of a college must think twice before not in- curring one—for the administration which always keeps within its income will stand still. President Eliot’s delib- erate plan, if we may judge by appear- ances, has been to press steadily a little beyond immediate income. Thus he has been able to show conclusively that more money can be profitably spent by Har- vard, and make an irresistible plea for it. Had he always crept along cau- tiously, never taking chances, Harvard would now be where it was two decades ago. Occasionally his advance has been slightly retarded by successive deficits; but in general he has led the way, and the friends of Harvard have responded to his call. A similar principle must be applied to the solution of the problem which Mr. Adams outlines: If a college can- not afford terrapin—to borrow the hap- py phrase of an insurance officer—must it forthwith restrict its diet to tripe? No college can permanently cripple the large “stock” cqurses. In the long run, these must be creditably maintained whatever else is lopped off. But that is not to say that temporary crippling is not now and then justifiable. One of Harvard's sources of strength, for ex- ample, is the group of advanced courses, attended by but few students, which perhaps no other institution is prepared to offer. These cannot be supported in- definitely at the expense of the large courses; but for terms of two or three years Harvard might suffer less in pres- tige and that leadership which is its glory, might contribute more to the cause of education, by carrying on cer- tain special courses for the few till mon- ey is found to man them. There can be no hard-and-fast rule. College au- thorities must weigh the value of the large courses to be sacrificed for the moment, and of the small ones to be saved, and must settle the individual case on ite merits. The effect on the teaching force must also be taken into account. The in- structor’s mind becomes deadened by repetition year after year of the elemen- tary and fundamental courses. He must have an opportunity for expansion and refreshment in the small advanced courses, devoted perhaps to research. One reason why teachers in secondary schools tend to mental atrophy is that they are steadily held down to tripe, with seldom even a sniff of terrapin. This view is forcibly presented by Pres- ident J. G. Schurman of Cornell in his last annual report just from the press. “No man,” he says, “can do valuable original reflection if he is always wearied with lectures and teaching.” President Schurman would therefore make provi- sion “for reducing the time demanded for the instruction of students from pro- fessors who are exceptionally qualified for and devoted to the work of original investigation.”” This change, as Presi- dent Schurman notes, no less an author- ity than Lord Kelvin declared to be the most imperative called for in our Amer- ican university system. Thus, in econ- omizing there must be considered the possibility of impairing the efficiency not merely of the fundamental courses, but of the teachers themselves. In short, the abilities and the tempera- ment of individual instructors must be seriously regarded in formulating the scheme of retrenchment. JAMES DAVIE BUTLER. There passed away in Madison, Wisconsin, on November 20, the “first citizen’’ of that university town, known and beloved of all, and whose home was thronged on every suc- ceeding birthday; who attained his nine- tieth year on the 15th of last March, and, being chaplain of the Senate, was honored by that body with roses and the spreading of his response upon the minutes. Dr. But- ler was then entering on the twenty-fourth year of his connection, as a literary con- tributor, with the Nation. “To-morrow, he wrote to us on Novem- ber 14, 1904, “closes the second third of my ninetieth year. The third third of it has been the end-all of two of my longeval male kindred; and how can my span outrun theirs? Yet my joy in ewistence is like the gaudia certaminis, while study in all lines rouses in me a higher joy than exist- ence can ever yie-d. Thanks to being near- sighted, I have never used or needed in reading or writing to ‘succor old age or any age with subsidiary sight.’ “In politics, always a Mugwump, I sit here a central peace subsistimg at the heart of endless agitation, Vilas and Spooner— both neighbors of mine! I live half-way between each, and no more than a bileck from either, and recall my A®gean sail be- tween Athos and Ida, each in plain sight, and that with a pilot who, as a boy, had been ‘prentice to his father at Navarino— which was long after I began to promote Greek Independence in my own person.” In truth he was just six years old when the Greek Revolution broke out and fired the sympathetic imagination of this coun- try, prompting Dr. 8. G. Howe to join By- ron. “As a boy of seven,” wrote Dr. Butler at elghty-five, “I was arrayed in a speci- men Greek dréss, and sent to every house in Rutland [Vermont, his birthplace), to RD ee + oe Ee bla at

Page 13

—— Nov. 30, 1905] call the women together and make gar- ments for the naked children of the Sciots’’—consequent upon the Turkish isl- and massacre in the spring of 1822. There was a prophecy in this, for, after graduat- ing at Middlebury College and taking the theological course at Andover, and filling Congregational pastorates in his. native State and in Massachusetts, he became professor of Greek at Wabash College, Crawfordsville, Indiana, from 1854 to 1857, when he was drawn to Madison, and from 1858 to 1867 occupied the corresponding chair at the Wisconsin University. His ° first European tour was made in 1842-3; and as he returned poor, he took to lectur~ ing, dispensing widely the fruit of his ob- servations as a traveller, with few rivals in the field. He never lost his roving dis- position. He celebrated his fifty-third birthday by climbing Mt. Tabor, in Pales- tine; the next year, 1869, we find him scal- ing the Yellowst6ne Park with John Muir, his quondam pupil. At seventy-five he made the circuit of the globe alone, and in 1890-1 was writing letters to this journal from the Inland Sea of Japan and from Fatehpur, India. Always Dr. Butler returned joyfully to his study and to the freedom of the Wis- consin State Historical Society’s Library, his daily mile-end walk up to his ninetieth year. He was for upwards of thirty years the Society's curator. He had been admitted a member of the American Antiquarian Society at Wor- cester, Mass., in April, 1854, and a more genuine or catholic antiquarian has never been gathered into that company. He made some noticeable, published researches into portraits of Columbus; he published ‘Hapax Legomena, or Words used once for all by Shakspere’; he discussed the cen sus, the rainfall in Wisconsin, Washington's tutor, Raphael's Hous, reindeer in Alaska. All that pertained to the Northwest and its early settlement interested him, and he flung himself with ardor into the Lewis and Clark revival initiated by the late Dr. Elliott Coues. He was a@ prominent figure in the movement to secure Sergeant Floyd's grave from the remorseless tooth of the Missouri, and to erect the present" monument. His publication in the Nation, in 1893, of the prospectus of Frazier’s Journal led to the reprint of Gass's rare Journal of 1811 and the finding of Floyd's and Whitehouse’s, now available to all students. In brief, Dr. Butler might be describea as a Notes and Queries man pur sang. Above all, however, his passion was for words. On February 12, 1904, he wrote to us: “N. E. D. [New English or Oxford] Dic- tionary has intensified my interest in lin guistic in all lines, and | watch for each new section more than they who watch for the morning. It has helped me to live long, and will help me to live longer. It must illuminate, or at least give glow-worm glimpses of, the dark backward and abysm of time.” His saturation with the language of Scrip- ture, of Shakspere, and of the Greek authors oozed up in his writings, giving a characteristic quaintness to his style; sometimes, no doubt, too redundantly. He began to write for the Nation towards the close of 1881, significantly with a Note on the fifth volume of the Catalogue of the Wisconsin Society's Library; and the Note was his favorite, though not exclusive, The Nation. vehicle for nearly a quarter of a century. He both volunteered his contributions and accepted or bespoke books for review, the very last of-these being ‘Coryat's Crudities.’ His review of that work was unique in the Nation's annals, as having been the product of a full nonagenarian He was in general as prompt and as much to be de- pended on as the average contributor, but on this occasion he offered an apology. In his still bold hand he wrote—for the last time but one—under date of July 7, 1905 “It was my purpose to dispatch this ar- ticle as soon as my last had been published, if not even sooner. Nor would I have fail- ed to do so but for a complication of clogs such as never before have fettered my ac- tivity. The chief of these were age and weakness, both used by doctors and daugh- ters for hemming me in on every side. “Further delay could not much modify my view, which, though novel, I hold to be the most credible—as well as creditable “It has not been my custom to quote par- agraphs from the books I review, and those that now appear needful have been cut short. A paragraph on the words we owe to C., and the grounds of his coinage, look ed desirable; but as to that and several oth- ers IL felt silence imperative. “Instead of my old saying, Add, sub- tract, multiply, ete., I will adopt C.'s KLacarnificate! “Regardfully, “JAMES D. BUTLER.” Dr. Butler was of slight and wiry build, below the middle height, quick and active in his motions. In his New England stock was woven a Huguenot strain which might Stand for vivacity and dan. His disposi tion was genial and kindly. Never had his circumstances been pinching, and both in body and in mind he enjoyed extraordi- nary freedom to explore the universe. In July, as above intimated, his first physi- cal failing began. The decline was at- tended with a minimum of suffering, and his mind remained clear until a few days before his departure. He furnished an in- spiring example of enduring mental fibre, sustained by contact with the world and by a boundless thirst for knowledge. We part with him with regret, a loyal and unfailing friend, an assistant sui generis IRISH AFFAIRS, DUBLIN, November 12, 1906. During the last six months, under the rule of Chief Secretary Long, there has been a return to the system of administrative worrying, petty perseculions, and prosecu- tions of Nationalists for alleged offences or breaches of laws supposed to be, or that had been in effect, obsolete. Under Chief Secretary Wyndham there had been a ces- sation of what is generally and vaguely known as “coercion.”” Professed sympathy with popular demands, profuse though un- fulfilled promises, abst’nence from irritat- ing administration, helped to get the last Land Act passed with but little opposition and with insufficient criticism in Parlia- ment from the Irish par'ty. The effect of the Act has been to increase by nearly 50 per cent. the prices paid by tenants purchasing their farms; and, this object having been attained, the policy of conciliation ceased. The Gaelic League is a widely spread and powerful organization, with hundreds of branches. It is non-political, but there is no doubt that it tends to foster and in- crease the spirit of Nationality. Numbers of towns and villages hoNM an annvail 439 “feish,"’ or Gaelic festival. Irish singing, dancing, recitations, history, compositivn plays, and games constitute the programmes at these festivals. The objects of the League are the fostering and preservation of th Irish spoken language, the study of Irish history and literature. In compliance with a generally expressed desire, and some po litical pressure, the Government a_ few years ago sanctioned the allocation of part of the educational grant to the teaching of Irish in primary schools as an extra sub ject and under very stringent limitations rhis grant has now been withdrawn, nom nally by the Education Commissioners, bu actually by direction of the English Treas ury. Consequently, the Gaelic League is in arms against British adm'!nistration Contemporaneously there is a renewal of prosecutions for the teclinical breach of a law that requires the name of the owner to be affixed to all vehicles in legible le ters. Fine and imprisonment for their non payment have been inflicted for the offence in several Irish-speaking districts of havitg the owner's name on his cart in Gaelic let- ters. These cases are usually tried at Peity Sessions, where the presiding magistrate is a paid official holding office at will of the Government, his colleagues being of the lo- cal “gentry” class. The prosecutions are initiated by the police, presumably by the direction or with the approval of Dublia Castle. The practice hitherto has been to convict and fine as a matter of course, but recently a Mayo bench of magistrates, in a district where three-quarters of the people are Irish-speaking and Gaelic Leaguers, al- lowed common sense to prevall and dism/ss ed the case brought before them. Notwith sanding this, the police prosecuted the same man in the following week, with the same result. A dismissal in a sim lar case was given in Galway; but in County Ro common an offender fined the nominal sum of ope shilling went to jail for three days sooner than pay it. In Wexford, for an un paid fine of four shillings and sixpence for a like offence, the police seized the crim! nal’s goods in the shape of books, but, as the proceeds of the sale amounted to only one shilling, another seizure will be made In Dublin a merchant and AMerman named Cole was prosecuted for having his name on his carts In Gaelic letters His goods were seized for non-payment, and the fine Alderman Cole then substituted Roman for Gaelic letters, but retained the Gaelic spelling, ‘McCumhaill.” Another prosecution was instituted before the Chief Magistrate of the Dublin Police Court, a skilled lawyer holdimg a practically inde- pendent office. He characterized the pro ceeting as “monstrous,” “s'upid,” and “most iIrritating.”” The police prosecutors claimed that Alderman Cole had trangress ed statutes passed In 1366 and 1465 which required the inhabitants of Ireland to “leave off entirely the manner of naming used by the Irish,’ and that every Irishman sbould take an Bnglieh surname of a town, or color, or art, science, or office. The magi«- trate convicted and imposed a fine of ten shil‘ings. Instead of deterring, these prose cutions tend to etimulate the Gaelic League realized to increased activity and to convert it into a political and anti-Bnglish organization A prominent Gaelic Leaguer has just been sent to jail for five days in default of pay- mg @ fine of sixpence for refusing to take

Page 14

440 [ Vol. 81, No. 2109 it a dog license unless his Gaelic signa- was accepted Other State prosecutions have been for the dissemination of anti-enlistment lit- rature The would-be victims of the Crown were youths who distributed leaflets | placards appealing to Irishmen not to ! in army, navy, or police. The same ments have been over and over again 1 in newspapers peeches, bal ! ind often in sermons. On the occa- he King’s taking the coronation ooth. which describes the Catholic religion tolatrou the Cathol Archbishop le a public appeal in the newspapers to n not to join the army and navy. I Saxon Shilling’ is a well-known p ballad. Similar sentiments find England through the Quaker ! he Pea Society, radical newspa ol ind in eountless books with a wide t lation Even if the authors of the had been known, it is unlikely that veld ha been made amenable. How- F } youths who posted these placards t luly ommitted for trial at the in- i of the Crown, and were acquitted ib! nz seditious libels by Belfast Dublin juris the only result of these rials being the wider publication he press of these ‘‘seditious libels.” rt e Government prosecutions cost a reat deal, and the expenditure is charged lt 1 revenue Crown lawyers get very f ind no expense is spared to ons The Corporation of vhich has to pay for, but has no rol over, the metropolitan police, has ked that the expenditure of the police x shall be audited and published as their r accounts are It appears that within ty years the amount charged by Govern- for the police has increased from 60,000 to $814,000, while the numerical ease of the force has been only thirty- ght met The answer, of the Govern o he objection of the Corporation in order by the Lord Lieutenant di- me othe um claimed by the Corpora- o be leducted from the payments by the English Treaspry to the local itie iccount Under the prevalent i ystem, certain grants are made in ald of local taxation to United Kingdom, and Wales ul ity ions Oo the eland, Seotland Any il to levy or apply local rates in the pre ribed by Parllament can be met ‘ ilirawal of these grants, This has Wales, where the local coun- ref 1 to levy part of the education ' } expenditure of which they " 0 idequate mtrol However, the the Dublin Corporation, and its ' re onable lemand for an audit of police account may be made effective the Irish party in Parliament The unending land war is the occasion of many State prosecutions under the Co- ercion act Some recent cases illustrate he condition of affairs Slattery, an old man, held a plot of land in Mayo under a lease for aixty years, granted by the father of the present landlord, who, alleging that } father had not power to give such a ease, succeeded in setting it aside, after putting Slattery, who had been in posses- on for thirty-nine years, to ruinous cost. Slattery was evicted, his sick wife being taken out of bed and left on the roadside; he had offered as a compromise to give The Nation. up one-third of the farm and to pay the entire rent for the house and remainder of the land. An open-air meeting was held to express indignation, and appeal to the landlord to show mercy to the old couple, who, deprived of their home, had no refuge but the workhouse. The meeting was at- tended by police note-takers. John O’Don- member of Parliament for the dis- trict, spoke, saying that the landlord should seriously consider before refusing Slat- offer, for no one would take the farm, and the tenant would ulti- mately be reinstated. It should be noted that there is a special provision in the Land Act enabling the Land Commission to reinstate evicted tenants and make grants of money for rebuilding their houses. Slat- retook possession of his farm, and have been prosecuted by the land- under the ordinary law for trespass; O'Donnell was prosecuted under the Coercion acts for making a speech calcu- lated to cause social disorder, and condemn- ed to three months’ imprisonment. Slat- tery died, and a collection is now being made for the support of his wife. tenant ow- nell, tery’s evicted tery might lord but In another part of Mayo a ing £4 17s. of rent was evicted. The land- son and agent admitted that the had been punctually paid as long as remember. One Paden took the farm At a meeting held to de- the eviction, two members of Par- O'Dowd and Conor O'Kelly, and magistrate named Mills, recom- mended that Paden should be boycotted; but they appealed to him in the interests of peace and good feeling to give up the He consented to do so on payment of £26, which he claimed to have laid out on the farm. This was agreed to, but, be- fore payment was made, the police charged Messrs. O'Dowd, O’Kelly and Mills before two “removable” magistrates with inciting to boycotting, and they will be tried under the Coercion acts at the next Assizes be- fore a specially selected jury. I will give one more example from the county: Two small farmers, McAn- McHugh, were evicted on the McHugh’s rent had been raised by the landlord from £4 to £14, afterwards fixed at £9 by the Land Commission After eviction, like a hunt- ed rabbit, McHugh, a feeble old man, crept back the house he had built. He was put in the dock, charged that “with and arms and a strong band, he had interfered with the landlord’s He and his wife were sent to the landlord had demolished the lord’s rent he could ‘ v if ted nounce liament, J. a local farm. same drew and same estate and into force unlawfully property.’ jail, and house, to prevent the family seeking shel- ter there again McAndrew was sent to prison for a like offence. He is seventy- two years old, and, till a year or two ago, when he became crippled with rheumatism, he went year by year to England, earned the rack punctual- ly to the An example from a different sphere may be given of the tendency of the anti-popular minority to look for the aid of the Govern- ment to suppress exhibitions of popular feeling and to magnify trivial expressions of into the crimes of sedition and disloyalty. The Royal University is an ex- amining body with power to grant degrees to persons, both men and women, who quali- fy at the University examinations. There are no resident students. rent, and remitted it landlord. discontent At the ceremony of conferring degrees, a number of students prevented the playing of “God Save the King.” The Chancellor of the University, Lord Meath, a pompous philanthropist, con- vened the Senate and enjoined them to take steps for the discovery and punishment of the offenders. He intimated that Parliament would withhold its vote of £20,000 a year if such disloyalty went unpunished. This was a most unwarrantable and misleading sug- gestion, as the funds for the University are not voted by’ Parliament, but are gerived from the funds of the disestablished Episco- palian Church. Parliament has nothing to do with giving or withholding the grant. The students replied by a manifesto published over their names, avowing their participa- tion in the concerted demonstration, and stating that their protest was directed not against the King, but against the King’s present Government, whose prime minister has several times publicly acknowledged the educational injustice under which Catholic students in Ireland labor, but has done no- thing to redress it. The students further pointed out that the Senate possessed no disciplinary powers over them; that its functions were limited by its charter to holding examinations and conferring degrees upon those who qualified. The Senate met, having summoned a few of the recognized offenders to attend. The students held a meeting outside the Senate House, passed resolutions affirming their grievances, and protesting against the mis- government to which the country is sub- jected in the matter of university education. The attention of the police, a strong force of whom attended, was called to the illegali- ty of the court which the Senate was hold- ing, and its summonses; the holding of sim- ilar courts by the Land League having been held contrary to law. The speakers prom- ised a renewal of their protest for next year. Lord Meath, the chancellor, did not attend; the vice-chancellor suggested that, as the University was not invested with powers to try or punish the graduates or undergraduates, and as the charges were very vague, it would be best to leave them to be dealt with by the legal tribunals of the country. The law adviser of the Senate concurred that it had no power to try or punish, and so the storm foolishly raised by Lord Meath might have ended. How- ever, a majority of the Senate carried a resolution that a case should be submitted to the law officers of the Crown, and so the foundation is being laid for a State trial of over one hundred young men and women for riot, sedition, disloyalty, and such like crimes. Cobden described the government of Ire- land as alternately “patching and bayo- nets.” It is so still. The short period of conciliation at the commencement of Chief Secretary Wyndham’s reign was marked by profuse promises. Ireland was to be gov- erned according to Irish ideas; political prisoners were released; an acceptable uni- versity scheme was to be established; co- ercion prosecutions ceased; grants for teaching Gaelic in primary schools were au- thorized; evicted tenants were to be re- instated; police expenditure was to be re- duced and their mischievous activity curbed. This did not last long. Wyndham threw over Sir Antony MacDonnell, who had been engaged as conciliation agent; secret instructions paralyzed the action of the Land Commissioners. Under Chief Secre-

Page 15

Nov. 30, 1905] The Nation. 441 tary Long administration runs in the old groove. Local governing bodies are wor- ried and harassed about matters of little moment; police interference in trifling mat- tera is stimulated; members of Parliament visiting their constituencies are dogged and prosecuted. The present English Govern- ment is near its end. Will the Liberals do any better? At the beginning of last ses- sion the whole Liberal party supported John Redmond’s resolution, declaring that “the government of Ireland is in opposi- tion to the will of the Irish people, gives them no voice in the management of their affairs, is ineffective and extravagantly costly, does not enjoy the confidence of any secton, is productive of universal discon- tent and unrest, and has been proved inea- pable of promoting the material and in‘el- lectual progress of the people.” Campbell-Bannerman, leader of the Lib- era! party, then said: “I defy the wit of man to give Irishmen any control, any ef- fective voice, any management of their own affairs, unless there is an execu‘ive respon- sible to a body in which the elective ele- ment shall have the decisive voice.” With- in the last month John Morley, referring to the Liberal vote on Redmond’s resolution, said: “I cannot believe that the new Par- liament will run its course without any attempt to remedy so monstrous a state of things.”’ Some of the Liberal leaders have, however, spoken in less satisfactory terms, and have shown an inclination to turn their backs on the resolution they support- ed, to treat it as a pious opinion, a ques- tion that may be postponed to a more conve- nient season. ‘The Irish party and the Irish electors in England are not likely to tole- rate such shuffling. At the approaching general election candidates in English con- stituencies, where there is any body of Irish voters, will be required to state spe- cifically their views on the subject of Home Rule. A general impression exists that, in view of the coming general election, the Govern- ment is seeking to evoke expressions of popular discontent, and even disorder, in Ireland on which to base an Anti-Irnish and Anti-Home Rule appeal to the English electors. AN IRISHMAN. THE RUSSIAN PEASANT.—II. SEVASTOPOL, October 16, 1905. In Moscow there are something over twenty thousand droshky drivers, a large number of whom own their equipment, while many of them own several. The business has not yet been monopolized in the Russian cities as in most other coun- tries. One result of this is that the droshky @rivers favor themselves in stormy wea- ther, so that those who depend upon them are likely, when needing them most, to be put to serious inconvenience. As yet there are no electric tramways in St. Petersburg, while in Moscow the electric system has been only partially inaugurated. In St. Petersburg one will find the regulation price for droshky service considerably less in winter than it is in summer and autumn, owing to the fact that so many peasants come into the city with their equipment after the crops are secured. Not only is the agricultural population organized into Mirs, but artisans and fish- ermen also are generally organized, in their way. While it is true that labor unions such as dominate Western Europe and the United States have not come to pre- vail in Russia, it has long been the case that small organizations, known as “Ar- including from ten to twenty work- men each, have been generally prevalent. These, like the Mirs, are democratic ganizations, electing their own foreman, who bargains for them, and with whom the employer finds it for his interest to deal. The recent great enlargement of manufacturing industries has brought about conditions to which the Artels have not become fully adjusted. The lack of the more comprehensive organizations is the cause to which many attribute the dis- @strous excesses of the recent labor trou- bles in Russia. Jn the fisheries of the Don and Ural rivers the smaller labor organ- izations have, however, been for a long time combined to secure the rights of all. For long distances up these rivers the fish- ing is begun simultaneously upon the fir- ing of signal guns. The small organiza- tions are operated upon a mutual policy, individual receiving an equitable share of the results, and giving to the own- ers of the nets a proportionate § share agreed upon at the outset. These various democratic survivals among the Russian must be reckoned with in any scheme for promoting the progress of th people according to modern ideas. The Government at St. Petersburg is far from being omnipotent. The statesmen at the helm, even of an autocratic government, are compelled to consider carefully the nature of the element through which they aré guiding their bark, and the fierceness of the storms which may be aroused by their own temerity. The Russian peasant is extremely conservative and very te- nacious of his opinions. tels,”’ or- each people Curiously enough, the Russian Dissent- ers from the Established Church (the so- called Raskolniks) do not furnish a pro- gressive element, but, on the contrary, are most violently opposed to all progress. They are the champions of the status quo as it existed in the time of Peter the Great. They glory in the name of Old Be- lievers, refusing to accept the least change in the Liturgy or in their personal habits. Notwithstanding frequent severe persecu- tions and the constant imposition of heavy disabilities, they have continued to in- crease until they number, according to the best authorities, more than twelve miil- lions. The Raskolniks form a most pe- culiar element in the Russian population. They hold themselves entirely aloof from the Established Church, and maintain their own places of worship by voluntary con- tributions. Most of them, however, are orderly in their conduct, except in re- ligious matters, and are extremely in- dustrious and frugal, so that they have accumulated property to a far greater ex- tent than the ordinary Russian has done. In some of the provinces they are the principal property-owners, while wealthy Raskolniks abound in the mining districts of the Ural Mountains and among the mer- cantile classes of the large cities. A large share of the steamboats on the Siberian rivers are owned by them. Their prosper- ity is partially, if not largely, due to their extreme opposition to the use of intoxicat- ing liquors and tobacco. Their savings, due to their temperate habits, amount in the aggregate to a fortune. There are from S8t, thousands of village communities in Rus- sia and Siberia where the extreme Probi- bitionists of America would find things after their own heart, since it would be impossible to purchase a drop of intoxicat- ing liquor for love or money. In the regular Russian Church service one will witness a marvellous spectacle of democracy, illustrating how susceptible the common people may be to the influence of truth when presented in msthetic forms Aesthetically, the Russian Church service has reached the height of perfection. The Liturgy, which has come down from the days of the “golden-mouthed"’ Chrysostom, is the most beautiful presentation of the sublime truths of Christianity which has ever been made. The symbolism accom- panying it has been carefully attdied to meet the wants of the most highly culti- vated classes, while the music reached a stage of absolute perfection. If one enters a Russian church anywhere, Petersburg to Vladivostok, he will witness the service in the same per- fection, and he will find himself in a crowded congregation, three-fourths of whom has are men, and the majority of them of the working class, all of them suffused with tender emotion, under the combined influ- ence of the music, the symbolism, the associations, and the Liturgy itself. There is no more democratic assembly in the world than one finds in the Russian Church. There are no seats. High and low, rich and poor, learned and unlearned, men, wo- men, and children, all stand for hours at a time to share in the stream of emotion which is the natural result. This partly accounts for the remarkable musical de- velopment of the Russian people. From earliest childhood, the poorest peasant hears in the church the highest and best class of sacred music, prepared for him by the greatest musica] masters. I was often struck with this elevation cal taste among the- common people while travelling through Siberia, on meeting the and on stopping over in the smaller cities. In Blagovestchensk, for in- stance, there was a local musical society which could with ease render the choruses of Saint-Saéns’s “Samson and Delilah.” For all‘these things the Russian peasant loves his Church. It furnishes him what he wants. It adds to his life an element of idealism which most gratefully breaks the dull monotony of his dally life. It is a mis- take to speak of the Russian peasant as priest-ridden. The Church is the object of his choice. The priest and his family are his companions and servants, carrying into the remotest settlements elements of cul- ture which it would be impossible for him to obtain in any other way. It is affecting, in travelling on the Siberian Railroad, to see the people gather about a Church car, which stops upon a siding to furnish tem- porary provision for the religious wants of the settlers. This devotion of the Russian to his Church must be reckoned with in any effort to remodel the social and political character of the empire. The Russian Church has ever been the servant of the State and a main influence in promoting patriotism among the people. Some other prejudices must also be reck- oned with in all practical schemes for the remodelling of Russian society. Among the most important of these is that which is felt towards the Jew. Indeed, the Jewish of musi- regiments,

Page 16

442 problem in Russia is more serious and more dificult to deal with any other It is in many respects much like faces the United States in its There are twice as many rest of the into the than in country. that negro population, Russia as in all the world They bave mostly come empire by annexation of western provinces. In Russia, as everywhere else, the Jews are especially sharp in business bargains, and easily take advantage of the more simple- therefore almost which Jews in minded peasants. It is impossible to avoid frequent collisions, which take the authorities unawares and lead to deplorable results Until in the United States we can more completely put into effect our laws for the protection of the negro, it is in poor taste to blame the Russian failure to anticipate Government excessively for its and suppress all ra ; clal troubles which arise among its varied peoples Another in dealing with the Russian peasant is that prejudice not to be neglected which he entertains against any system of education which is forced upon him from the outside In his attachment to his communal system he resents any interfer affairs except so far as it necessary for the ence with his may seem directly pre- servation of the honor of the empire to belongs, and loyalty to which is Czar, which he summarized in his devotion to the its lawful head. It seems to many outside theorists a very simple matter for an au- tocratic Government to promote the educa- long as the long-es- educational re- masses But so Mir with its tion of the cognizes the authority, slow (gar re tablished local make but the medium through into effect cal influences We similar condition of things in the districts of the progress, since they are largely of lo- forms can which car- ried consists so have in America a somewhat Appalachian Mountain Southern States, where there are two mil lion illiterate mountain whites who have been scarcely affected at all by the best made State educational laws. The Russian peasant even more than the Southern white resents the inaterference of the general Government with what he considers his pri vate affairs, He is strongly attached to the principle of local option. The Czar finds it hazardous to interfere with these local prejudices leat it diminish the loyalty of hi ibjects. In short, the Russian em pire has an unwritten constitution which in as effective In its way as is the English In travelling from one end of Russia to the other, we have seen no Indications of When in the cen disorders have been disorder or discontent tre of the empire, the those in Colorado The have not is far from u a were last year from Ohlo disorders dur ing the la four months affected the which the appre clably great peasant popula tion upon stability of the em pire depend Nor do the peasants seem to interest themselves deeply in the elections to the Duma It approaching t well known that Interest in the Zematvos fell off rapidly, owing to the peasants’ fear that they would favor addi- lonal interference with the Ilfe of the They would rather truat parliament village commune the Czar than a When one takes into consideration this conservatiam of the peasant of the great central prov- inces, and the heterogeneous character of the populations which hate been brought The Nation. [Vol. 81, No. 2109 under Russian rule by annexation, he will disappointed if parliamentary gov- makes slow progress for a while, something that in the Duma it The Anglo-Saxon, how- expect it to be wholly af- not be ernment Yet it is will really ever, need not ter his pattern begin G. FREDERICK WRIGHT. JEHOL. Jeno., CHINA, September 29, 1905 In 1860, when the Emperor Hien Fung fled from Peking before the advance of the allied French and English armies, he took refuge mountains in his sum- mer hunting-palace at Jehol. Here he died not long afterwards, since which time ths place has not been visited by its imperial Nor many European or American travellers had the curiosity to make the trip, which, nevertheless, well re- pays whatever slight trouble it may cost. The distance frem Peking can be comfort- ably covered on horseback in five days, and by harder riding in four. The country traversed is for the most part mountainous and picturesque, the road is good enough as Chinese roads go, and the accommodations on the route are those of the usual Chinese inn. For the rcturn journey one does well to take boats from Jehol down the Lan River till one reaches the railway line from Shan-hai-kwan back to Peking. This also is an affair of four to five days, and few ex- periences are more lazily agreeable than gliding with the stream in a flat-bottomed craft, propelled by the steady rowing of two men in the bow and one paddling in the stern, or every now and then hurried along by a rapid. The sights on the way are full of interest, for the Lan through some very fine gorges, where the crags bee- tle over the bubbling water below, and the hundreds of boats comfortably descending with the current or painfully being hauled up against jt lend continual animation to the scene. In particular, the view through the river gate of the Great Wall is a thing beyond the masters have passes to be remembered. Jehol itself ig a commonplace Chinese town nestling at the foot of a line of hills park that contains the various imperial dwelling-places, kiosks, storehouses, and the like, Although the re- treat was already used by the Mongol em- perors, the wall of the enclosure was not built till the time of the present dynasty, with whom the palace is especially connect- ed. It was here that in 1793 Lord McCart- first envoy sent by England to China, after following the Emperor K’ien Lung up from Peking, was graciously en- tertained by him at a feast in the garden. However, almost the only result of the em- bassy was an arrogant letter in which the Son of Heaven told George III: occupied by the ney, the “As the requests made by your ambas- sador militate against the laws and usages of this our Empire, and are at the same time wholly useless for the end proposed, I cannot acquiesce in them. I again admon- ish you, O King, to act conformably to my instructions, that we may preserve peace and amity on each side, and thereby con- tribute to our reciprocal happiness.” Much has changed in China, as elsewhere, since these words were first written, and now Jehol has not been visited by a sov- ereign since the one who died there a fugi- tive century ago; but, on nearly half a the other hand, it is open to any tourist with a permission from the Foreign Office in Peking. As might be expected, almost every por- tion of the buildings and grounds shows obvious signs of neglect and decay. The total effect, of old, must have been far more brilliant than at present, for most of the once yellow tiles have preserved hardly a trace of their imperial color which once made the roofs so bright; and the woodwork, too, although remarkably little affected itself, has usually lost its coat of paint long ago. In like manner, several of the short massive stone bridges are only passable, if at all, owing to the planks thrown loosely over the gaps in the mid- die; but still, when we remember the out-- at-elbows condition of much in the actual abodes of Chinese royalty and of the shrines where they worship in state, like the Tem- ple of Heaven, we are ready for anything in places deserted by them. What remains here is, first and foremost, the landscape architecture, with its combination of hill and dale, shady walks and grassy banks, lake, island, and grotto, graceful kiosks and charmingly shaped houses. The ten- storied pagoda, too, is architecturally pleasing, besides commanding an excellent view of the grounds; and in every direction the grass is alive with spotted deer, who, free from danger, are almost as tame as sheep. The Imperial storehouses excite the longest attention, for here are kept the household furnishings of the Palace, until they shal] next be called into use. To be sure, the closed doors of these houses are sealed with mystically inscribed strips of paper; and as the windows also have paper panes, nothing in the interior would be vis- ible were it not that everywhere many of these same panes are badly torn. All we have to do is to follow the example of the eunuch officials who are guiding us, and peep in at the piles of porcelain, blue, red, yellow, what not; the cloisonné work, the splendid screens, the lacquered tables, the chairs, the thrones, etc., ete., enough to make the collector’s mouth water. All of these articles are covered with dust, and such as can fall to pieces of themselves are doing so; but still the great majority only need to be brought forth and cleaned to resume their proper place in the world. It makes one long for another imperial visit, when perforce the whole mass of this fin- ery would have to be furbished up. On the other side of the Palace Park from the city are the Lama Temples, the second great “sight’’ of Jehol. They are in charge of monks—in this case, Mongols— who, in their faded yellow diesses, loiter about them; and each has its own special attractions, The buildings are in an unequal state of preservation, although, of course, all are in the more or less advanced stages of the usual Chinese decomposition; Some of them are only curious, but others are really fine architecturally, and the internal decoration is often particularly good. In the Ta Fo 8’Su (Great Buddha Temple) there is a colossal wooden statue of Buddha, said to be exactly the same height as the on¢ in the Lama Temple in Peking; In the Lo Han Tang are five hundred and eight Buddhis: worthies, gilt wooden statues of heroic size and of very considerable artistic merit; In- deed, many of them have a great deal of ex- pression, and as a lot they are far superior to those in the Temple of the 23,333 Buddhas

Page 17

Nov. 30, 1905] in Kioto, of which one is reminded. In the Hsing Kung (Imperial Travelling Palace) the distinguishing feature is the number of little figures of the Buddha in brass or clay. Just how many of these there are it would be hard to guess, but there must be several thousand. Undoubtedly, the most interest- ing of all the temples is the Potala, whose exterior is a reproduction on a smaller scale of its namesake, the residence of the Dalai Lama in Lasa. As one gazes from below its great bare rectangular shape, familiar to us from the pictures of its model ment one has the illusion of actually being at for a mo- in the sacred city itself. The interior of the structure is unfortunately in a par- ticularly dilapidated condition, but therg is a fine inner shrine with a profusion of teresting offerings and ornaments, and a gorgeous gilt ceiling. Such are the “monuments” of Jehol. Old without being venerable, all of them in ne- glect, many of them in ruin, they somehow retain a magnificence which appeals to the in- imagination, and charm the stranger for their very decay. Truly, this is a strange land, with many things in that are strange—especially to us Anglo-Saxons; but the traveller who has once been to China, even if the merest globe-trotter, will return again with a fresher, livelier interest and more fascination at each succeeding visit ARCHIBALD CARY COOLIDGE Correspondence. THE ANGLO-JAPANESE TREATY AGAIN. To THE EpiTor OF THE NATION: Sir: May I, please, make a few remarks concerning the new Anglo-Japanese treaty? The first treaty was concluded and faithful- ly observed by both parties, their mutual interests. Japan to be secured, in her attack against the intervention of Euro- pean Powers. England, on the other hand, was, after her South African experience, more than eager to gain an ally in a pos- sible conflict with Russia; or, rather, Eng- land desired to have Japan attack and crip- ple Russia before the latter Power could think of attacking England in India. The question arises: Has England’s pol- icy been successful? It seems that it has not. The English appear to be more uneasy than ever about their position in India, as is evident, for instance, from recent like that on “National Defence Edinburgh Review of last October. misgivings are not without foundation. the first place, Russia knows well whom she has to thank the Japanese. because it served was anxious upon Russia, papers in the Their In enough for her war with The morale of the Russian army has not suffered to any extent. Rus- sia is bound to come triumphantly out of the throes of internal disorders which ren- der her weak and helpless for the present. The greater liberties granted to her peo- ple cannot fail to make the Russians strong- er, more capable of developing the as yet hardly-touched rich natural resources of their vast dominions, and, last but not least, more patriotic. The want and need of a suitable seaport as an outlet for their Asiatic possessions remains unchanged and unsatisfied. Having found resistance ” too | strong in the Far East, why should they not The Nation. whether not less in a direction? Why not undertake to restore their weakened pres- tige by avenging themselves wpon an adver- sary whose land forces have always proved try resistance is southern should they to be a “‘quantité négligeable,”” and whose ships can neither fight on land nor pour reinforcements into India as quickly as the two Russian strategical railroads can? But for that very treaty Japan in has England concluded new not reason a Japan? That bound herself maintaining general peace in the regions of Asia and India. She has even prom- ‘ome to the assistance of her ally, ten-year indeed true England is with has to assist Eastern ised if the unprovoked to threatened “by of attack arising, latter reason aggressive action, part of any other Power or Powers."" Between a promise made a promise kept, there however, a deal of difference. Will Japan be able, and, if able, will Japan be willing, to come assistance, Russia India? Lord Roberts mands an army of 500,000 British soldiers to defend against a Russian tack. however, unless it the is or wherever on the and is, vast to England's in case should invade de- India possible at England, intro- duces ‘conscript system,” cannot main- than The Japa- in a European army of much mor: that as has been 100,000 men in distant country Russians, proved in thé nese war, may easily hurl over 600,000 men against while leaving an 500,000 Eastern churia; India, army of Mant- on a 1,500,000 men in Siberia and for the Russian army, even footing, amounts to almost and distance is only half as great as that from Rus- pe ace men, the from Ruesia to In- dis sia to Mantchuria, while at instead there are the disposal of the Russian forces. A Russian army of threatening the of Korea and the gions held by the Japanese on the mainland time at the railroads same of one two 500,000, frontiers other re- of Asia, will undoubtedly prevent the latter from sending any reinforcements to their English allies in India. They will even com- pel the Japanese to keep peace. Japan is no longer as strong for attacks as she was before the By laying her hands upon Korea and a part of Mantchuria, has given the strongest possible pledges for her war. she future good behavior to the Powers of the world. She must keep out of all foreign entanglements, because in any such com- plication she is bound to find Russia and Russia's allies siding with her enemy. England, on her part, is no longer in a position to offer Japan any real help. There is no sea-power, or combination of sea- powers, that does or might threaten Japan, as long as the foreign policy of that coun try keeps within proper bounds. Under it Japan would fruits late victory actually attacking that again, if it should enter upon an aggressive policy against the English possessions in Asia. There considered in circumstances, that of her these is im- the by even extremely prabable dare risk over Russia Power is, moreover, to be Who should bear the expense for the sending of, let us say, 200,000 Japanese soldiers to India, in order to meet invasion of that country? The war has left the Japanese without any war indemnity. They certainly cannot pay the war debts incurred in the course of the next ten years. Will another point this connection. a Russian present —. ——— r they be able and willing to incur a dou! “ of their war debts by entering upon another war with Russia merely for friendahip's sake, because of the blue eves of Albion I don’t think anybody in England exp: that much from the little brown fellows the Japanese seas, There surely are agri ments which are and will be kept secret promising the necessary cash to Japan ’ case she has to mobilize her army for Ene land's use. That fact admits of no dowb But will history repeat itself? WIHUIIl proud Japan stoop to do what petty (: ‘ princes did in our Revolutionary war not queer that English diplomacy, at beginning of the twentieth century ar conceive the idea of defending s | sions across the seas by hiring the soldier of some foreign potentate? It seems to nv that the new Anglo-Japanese treaty is no worth the Ink it is signed with It illu trates nothing but the difficulties which ! set statesmen who have to defend tert tories grown s0 large that the governing race cannot or will not defend them w its own blood.—Yours truly Wau. Weren BELLEVILLE, ILL, November 20, 1005 THE REPORT OF THE COMMITTEE OF FIFTY. To THE EprTror or THE NATION Sir: In the Atlantic Monthly for October I saw the announcement of the publication early in the autumn, of ‘A Summary of In vestigations conducted by the Committe of Fifty into the Liquor Problem.’ I sent at once for the book, in the hope of a quiring thereby some new and effective weapon, derived from American experien for combating the all but universal use of alcoholic beverages in Germany, where a movement for total abstinence has but just fairly begun, and is struggling against pre judice and long-established habit But I was sorely disappointed, especially in the first portion of the book, which treats of the physiological aspect of the drink question. The fact is, that the most important evidence for the harm done by the habitual use of alcoholic beverages. is not as much as mentioned Assuredly the question whether or pot, and to what ex tent, the moderate habitual use of beer is injurious to health, is a question of statistics, and we are in possession of such statistics on a grand scale, collected with the utmost care, inasmuch as large amounts of money were involved I refer to the experience of several great English life “United Kingdom Temperance and Genera! Institution,”” which lated experience for more insurance companies, notably the Provident has accumu than sixty years and has kept atrictly separate accounts of its Abstinence Division and its Non-Abatin ence Division. The mere fact that this company grants to abstainers a rebate of fifteen per cent. on their annual premium whereas non-abstainers are required to pay in full, is proof abundant of the greater longevity of the abstainers This subject, with extensive tables treated lucidly in an article by T. T. Wilt aker, M. P., in the March number, 1904, o the Contemporary Review From this ar ticle I quote a single sentence: “It will be observed that, during the strenuous working years of manhood, from twouuty

Page 18

+44 to sixty years of age, the annual mor- five tality rates among abstainers were, on the average, forty per cent. lower than among non-abstainers.”’ Now, I submit that since non-abstainers do not in general die of well-known alco- , hol-diseases, such as delirium tremens, but are taken away by the most various dis- eases, be it consumption, typhoid fever, or what not, there is no escaping the con- clusion that he who habitually indulges in the of alcoholic thereby greatly weakens his constitution, diminish- es his power of resistance to diseases, and his life These facts are not surprising when it is remembered that possess only very crude and inefficient means of examin- health of the organs of circulation and the kidneys and the liver; and that, in case of death, say by use beverages shortens physicians ing the digestion, especially monary consumption, the physician can- whether and to what ex- not pos sibly say tent the patient had injured his heart, stomach, liver, kidneys, by the habitual use of alcoholic beverages before the in- ception of the fatal disease. Another very important physiclogica! ef- fect is not even hinted at in the report of the Committee of Fifty, namely, the gradual, but grave, dulling effect upon the intellect and the ethical nature of man by the ha- bitual use of beer Very respectfully, WERNER A. STILLE. Hanover, Germany, November 2, 1006 “THE SWBRET ROMAN HAND.” To THe Eprror or Tug NATION: Sim: My friend Mr. Edward H. Whorf calls my attention to a phrase in “Twelfth Night" which I do not find noted in Dyce’s Glossary, O'Connor's Ihdex, Furness’s Va- riorum Edition, the Century Dictlonary; n fact, I find it im no usual place of search. The phrase is ag follows: “I think we do know the sweet Roman hand” (Act Iil., cene 4, line 28). The meaning of “Roman hand’’ may be so obvious to the learned and commentators that they have not ought it worthy of explanation. It is pos- ble, but not likely, however, that it has baffled their knowledge. Be all this as it may, | subm!it my evidence with due hesi- ition, for I have never before written a word concerning Shakspere, and probably hall never write another. In ‘The Pens’ Excellencie or the Secre- tarle Delight, Written by Martin Bil- lingsley (lo: Sudbury & George Humble in opeshead Alley, London, 1618)’ occurs this engaging passage “The third ts Roman, which hath his de- nomination from the place where (it seemes) it was firet written, viz: Rome. A hand of great account, and of much vee in this Nealme, especially in the Vaiuersities; and it Im concelued to be the easiest hand that written with Pen, and to be taught in he shortest time: Therefore it is veually taught to women, for as much as they (hau- he patience to take any great besides phantasticall and humor- une) must be taught that which they may netantly learne? otherwise they are yvn- ertaine of their proceedings, because their ninds are (vpon light occasion) easily drawne from the first resolution.” ng no paines Billingsley dedicates his book to King Charies L, then Prince Charles, to whom he was writing-master at the time of the publication of his excellent little treatise [Vol. 81, No. 2109 The Nation. His depreciation of the capacity of women was clearly within his right, for a writing- master as well as a college president may safely stigmatize a whole sex as not being so well equipped as he in his special craft. I find that Miss Jennett Humphreys, in her article on Billingsley in the Dictionary of National Biography (vol. 5, p. 36), has al- ready come upon this passage with evident relish. The only definition I have found of “Ro- man hand” states that it is the “Italian hand”—a wholly different style, as the ex- cellent B!llingsley points out. I am strength- ened in my hopes that the meaning of “Roman hand” is caviare not to che general alone, for Mr. Albert Matthews, to whom I have timorously shown this “find,” and who encourages me to send it to you, points out that Schmidt, in his ‘Shake- speare-Lexicon,’ compares the passage witn that one in “Titus Andronicus” (v., 1, 139) which reads as follows: “And on their skins, as on the bark of trees, Have with my knife carvéd in Roman letters, ‘Let not your sorrow die, though I am dead.’ "’ Here we have one distinguished commenta- tor who is distinctly wrong, if Billingsley, a contemporary of Shakspere, is right; for Schmidt means only that the letters are Roman, not Italic, and that is not much an elucidation of either passage. If Schmidt is in the dark, he may perchance have learned company. But if this meaning of was common knowledge to the glossary makers and commentators, they surely ought to have imparted it to those for whose benefit glosses are made. LINDSAY SWIFT. Boston Pustic Liprary, November 15, 1905. THE OLD GAME. To THE EprTorR oF THE NATION: Str: The letter enclosed will perhaps suf- ficiently speak for itself; but if it really runs as close to impropriety as it strikes me as doing, the promptest of reprobation is due at the hands of some journal not just now interested in a stock of books for sale. In point of fact, university men are coming to recelve over-many propositions of this kind, and the best time to balk is possibly when one doesn’t much care for the partic- ular set of books in question. Cases of this sort invoke the general principle that the especially needy have especial claim to be delivered from temptation. Yours respectfully, H. J. DAVENPORT. Iurversiry OF Curcaco, November 20, 1905. Hernert Daverrort, Esq., Chicago, Ill. Dear Sie: The Outlook, acting in conjunction with The History Aesociation of London, desires to place in your hands a set of The Historians’ History of the World, with the view of gaining your endorsement and coiperation in the general sale of the work which will shortly begin, Our proposition is in the nature of com- pensation for the time required by you to intelligently examine and pass an opinion on the Looks The enclosed booklet will give you a general idea ot the scope and character of the twenty- five volumes. The fact that not since 1779 has there been published an adequate world history, gives an added interest to the present anncuncement. If you are in position to consider the offer referred to above we shall be glad, on receipt of the enclosed post card, to send you full particulars, also a description of and illustra- tions from the work itself. THE OUTLOOK, per R. 8. T. New Yorx, November 18, 1905. THE INVERSION OF “GRAFT.” To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: I was interested in your correspon- dent’s quotation from Governor Folk’s defi- nition of Graft. Strange as it may seem, this good West of England word means hard work: work: a job: a livelihood. It has become il] assorted by base usage. Mur- ray points out that, among men who gain their living on the highway, “the roadster proper is distinguished from the tramp by having a ‘Graft,’ or, in other terms, a vis- ible means of support!” Sincerely yours, Boston, November 25, 1905. Wm. S. Booru. HIM AND HER. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: In this strenuous town even the little girls play football. Passing a group of them yesterday I was surprised to hear one, as she fell on the ball, exclaim, “I’ve got him!" Have we not here the solution of that linguistic curiosity, the tendency of the male controller (engineer, sailor, etc.) of an object to allude to the object under control as “her’’—an instinctive expression of a fundamental duality? The girl was about twelve years old. Would any boy have called a ball “him?”—Yours, AN OBSERVER, New Haven, Conn., November 22, 1905. Messrs. Putnam have in preparation ‘The Connecticut River,’ by Edwin M. Bacon, and ‘Episcopal Reminiscences,’ by Bishop Henry C. Potter. Mr. William J, Hay, Edinburgh (John Knox's House), whose ‘Old Houses in Edin- burgh’ we have lately noticed, will publish next month ‘The Hammermen of Bdin- burgh and their Altar,’ extracts from the records of this incorporated trade, a. D. 1494-1558, with introductory notes by John Smith. Velhagen & Klasing, of Bielefeld and Leipzig, announce a new, fifth and “Jubilee” edition of Andree’s ‘Grosser Handatlas,’ which is being edited by A. Scobel. It Is just twenty-five years ago since the first edition of this excellent work was issued. The number of maps has been increased from 186 sheets in the fourth edi- tion to 207 in the fifth, the new additions being chiefly of countries which have come into prominence in recent years. The size of the page is 16 by 9% inches. Statistical trade and economic geography especially is made prominent in the new Atlas, which is to appear in 56 Lieferungen. The first has just been issued. It is a far cry (a quarter century) to the first edition of Andrew Lang's ‘Oxford,’ one of his earliest books, indeed. It is now re-— vived (Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott Co.) very handsomely in brightly stamped covers, with fifty illustrations, the first in

Page 19

Nov. 30, 1905] color. But whereas only three designers were originally called in, now there are nine at least. Happily the later drawings or etchings have been made to correspond with the earlier by MM. Brunet-Debaines, Tous- saint, and Thomas; if “process” is not wholly excluded, there is no intrusion of plain photography. In other words, the pictures still harmonize with the text, not as real appearances, but as “impress ons.” This is proper treatment of a good book. The “popular edition’ of Sir Walter Arm- strong’s masterly Life of ‘Sir Joshua Rey- nolds’ (London: Heinemann; New York: Scribners) is separated from its more sump- tuous predecessor by but five years. It is itself elegantly made, and its visible “pop- ularity” (apart from the reduced cost lies in its having been converted from a folio into a royal octavo. It can, in other words, be now read with at least four times as much ease and convenience, and possession of it will imply that it has been purchased to be read. The public is to be congratulat- ed on having so authoritative a work thus brought within reasonable reach while maintaining a high standard of manufacture. Within three years Mr. Ernest W. Cle- ment’s laudable “Handbook of Modern Ja- pan’ (Chicago: McClurg) has reached a sixth edition, showing that the sale has profited by the great war come and gone during that interval. In proper return, the author has added a chapter on the struggle with Rus- sia, supplying a useful chronology of the leading events, and a summary—of losses, cost, ete.—which will need much overhaul- ing when the respective combatants write their official histories—if they ever do! Among the noticeable reissues of the week or fortnight are ‘The Ingoldsby Legends,’ Oxford Edition (H. Frowde), with Barham’'s portrait and twenty-five illustrations by Leech, Cruikshank, and others—the text somewhat condensed, typographically, but legible enough; still another form, for the hand or pocket, of Stevenson's ‘A Child's Garden of Verses’ (Boston: Herbert B. Tur- ner & Co.), very tasteful in all its appoint- ments; and a revised edition of Prof. Charles F. Richardson's well-known manual, ‘The Choice of Books’ (Putnams). Th's author depends much on quotation from others to fill out his chapters. The two related ones on “Remembering What One Reads’ and “The Use of Note-books” omit two practi- cal methods—one, to think over what has been read immediately on shutting the book; the other, a particularly useful disci- pline for the young, to write down the.im- pression of every work perused. This edi- tion has been somewhat overhauled. It has helpful suggestions for household li- braries. We receive for the second time the bulky, rather undigested English monograph on ‘St. Helena, the Historic Island; from its Discovery to the Present Date,’ by E. L. Jackson (New York: Thomas Whittaker). For a book of reference, in spite of its lack of an index, it has its utility, and the photographic illustrations have a curious worth. Some of these were taken shortly after the Boer war, and show the Boers yet interned in the island. A British business man’s views of eco- nomic conditions in Japan, Korea, and Chi- na, during a journey made three years ago, are entertainingly set forth in the well-illustrated and indexed book, ‘Far Eastern Impressions, by Ernest F. G. . The Nation. Hatch, M. P. (Chicago: A. C. McClurg & Co.). The outbreak of the Russo-Japanese War suggested to Mr. Hatch the idea of making a record of his notes, with revision and additions, which was done before the treaty of Portsmouth. The half- tone reproductions from photographs, num- bering over four-score, are unusually good, and these, with the excellent maps show- ing at a glance railway development in the three countries, make this an attractive and timely volume. The illustrations seem about as valuable as the text, for little of purely original matter of any great im- portance enters into the book, which is rather too rich in quotations. Mr. Hatch crossed the Pacific Ocean to Japan with Kang Yu Wei, the radical Chinese reform- er, and then had interviews with such op- posite characters as Li Hung Chang and Sir Robert Hart. The author calls attention to the resources of the Shansi coal field, which has an area of 13,470 English square miles, with a probable minimum quantity for the whole area of 630,000,000,000 tons of coal. This is anthracite, with a thick- ness of 12 metres and a specific weight of 1.5, calculated to cover the coal consumption of the world at its present rate (300,000,000 tons annually) for a period of 2,100 years. Besides the deposits of coal and iron, the cheapness and abundance of labor in the mining region have en- abled practical iron manufacturers to dem- onstrate that a ton of pig iron could be produced in Shansi at three dollars a ton. Other titbits of economic information are seattered throughout this interesting book. ‘China’s Intercourse with Korea from the XVth Century to 1895," by William Woodville Rockhill (London: Luzac & Co.), though but a pamphlet of sixty pages, is as a nugget of purest metal in the heap of ore of gold, fool’s and otherwise, which interest in Korea has made visible in the market. This scholarly writer, in treating of the political status of the peninsular kingdom, shows why and how men of Oc- cidental mind, looking only at forms of European diplomacy, have been so belud- dled; for the term in Chinese and Korean official documents usually translated “‘vas- sal kingdoms,” or “‘flefs,’’ really means re- lationship, which furnishes at once the key to the problem. The Ming emperors of China were “fathers to Korea,’ and the Mantchu emperors of the reigning dynasty have been “elder brothers’; the present Chinese Emperor, in an edict of 1882, re- ferring to the Korean royal family as his “near kindred.’’ “‘Tribute,”’ brought to Pe- king by such so-called vassal states, was really at the expense of China, and was solely a quid pro quo for the privilege of trading with the Chinese under extraor- dinarily favorable conditions; the mer- chants and merchandise being brought to the market and returned home free of all charges. The chapter on the Mantchu In- yasions of Korea is very full and rich in detail, as the author has availed himself of the fruits of recent research by Amer- jean and other scholars in Korea, An ad- ditional chapter on certain laws and cus- toms of the land is interesting. A fond- ness for alcohol and tobacco is a national weakness, and sauntering a fixed habit; the kukyeng (picnic) being part and parcel of the life of the inhabitants. Apart from Japanese political interference, the real Ko- rean problem seems to be how 6,000,000 abie- some time and is 445 bodied males can, during daylight hours, support in their mouths a tobacco pips from three to five feet long while doing work enough to get food and clothes. After this, the next question before a possible progressive Korea is the elimination of the mob of female sorcerers that have so long existed as blood-sucking parasites on the body economic and social, while fully equal in their power of wastefulness to the predatory nobility that lives at the exprnss of the common people As correct information about of Japan's policy in Korea will be of con tinuous and increasing interest, it is well to note that in addition to the magazine, the Aorea Review haps not anti-Japanese, while yet sever: ly critical of Japanese methods, the Seul Press is issued daily, with a weekly edition This paper contains news of happenings in the country itself as well as in lands ad joining, with comment and correspondence, all indicating general approval of Japan« policy, with explanation defence methods. Perhaps the Koreans, the most part, at present are utterly indi ferent to the world at large, may. like the Japanese, profit by the steady streams of criticism which play upon them from both periodicals. the details moothtiy which is per and who Part 2 of Prof. Angelo De Gubernatis's ‘Dictionnaire International des fFerivains du Monde Latin’ carries the work from Carretto to Evelyn same sprinkling of non-Italian scholars and writ ers who have come in touch, in one way or another, with the “Latin World.’ Several Italians of international reputation turn uy for treatment—notably, Gabriele D'Annun zio, of whom it is candidly said: “It possesses an exceptional talent, he any whatsoever, work would been beneficent; one admires his natural gifts motions of a fallen angel disgust oftener than they attract. For the moment, one regards him as a phenomenon which terrifies." Of Edmondo De Amicis, on the other hand, only good is spoken. He is placed next .0 Manzoni and the writer who has handled Italian with most ease and geniality; he is sald to excel all others in descriptive talent, in sentiment and in revealing pily for the great and small miseries to which mankind ts heir. The Dictionary justifies expectations In future editions it will be possible to give a larger representation to foreigners The work is published by the author at Rome. The Beilage of the Munich Allgemeine Zeitung, the oldest and most influential! general scientific journal in Germany, con tains in its No. 233 a vigorous editoria! from the pen of Dr. Oskar Bulle, entitled “Kon greese und Ueberproduction,’ in which th« writer rather sharply criticises the endlesa number of congresses, conventions, and other meetings that nowadays seem to b« regarded as indispensable for every phase of research or public life. It is pointed out among other things, that, as commonly con ducted, these conventions do not ensure a thorough discussion of the subjects cerned, but that a large proportion of their deliberations is practically “playing to th galleries.” The that the best interests of modern progress demand that the number of such assemblies be ma- terially curtailed, and lim'ted to One notices the as he had had conscience his literary have ‘ but all his us much DAzeglilo, as prose con- declares writer lines of

Page 20

446 work in which public discussion rather than private research is profitable; and, irther, that when conventions are actually held the committees of arrangements hould make it their chief business to cut fown the programme to what is absolutely necessary or really beneficial. Dr. Bulle thirks that, as at present conducted, the iverage congress is “too much of a good thing and that the best interests of science and of the public problems of the day re- juire a thoroughgoing reform in these popu- lar but generally superficial meetings The the international Government of Egypt has agreed tbat Congress, Athens Archwological which convened thi year in hall hold its next convention in Cairo in 1007. The Khedive has consented to appoint n local committee of arrangements; the to retain the Athenian committee, however; general managemert. It is aiso announced that the Transactions of the convention held Athens are to appear within the next few week and are to be sold through the trade at an exceptionally low price The surplus of physicians over and above he demand is o great in France that range consequences have resulted. A cor pondent « he London Lancet reports ha he medical men of the town 0 Chok in Anjou, have united ' gning i document which has ippeared n he leading medical urnals of France, warning all outside phy joebar gain ettling in Cholet \ char ible a wiation in another town has de led that the members of their medical iff may reccive only 45 centimes for office consultation and 70 centime for visiting i patient, even if this happens to be a night eall or includes a minor operation The taf’ has struck, and refused to render its ervices for such trifles The report of the Commission of Inquiry nto the Administration of the Congo State, ron ting of the Advocate-General of the Urussels Court of Appeals, the President of the Court of Appeals at Boma, and a Swiss added for the Belgian clement jurist purpose of introducing has been published, ind from a summary in the London Times '| would appear to substantiate the charge of grievous crueliies and abuses. There has heen a& great delegation of power to per- utterly unfi o exercise it, and an iimosxt complete absence of the supervision by which such persons should have been mtrolled The report condemns the the ory that all untilled land belongs to the ite, which has been made the warrant r forbidding the native to change his lence or pa land without a ' over this ' he not discussed, as rmit question of freedom of trade | being outside mupetence of the commission, which wcknowledges that there is virtually ne trade among the natives, and nat.ve In- dustry i non-exlatent ‘.. regard to forced lnbor, the statement is made that “it is on th basis alone that the Congo can enter into the pathway of modern civilization. and that the population can be reclaimed from ite natural state of but the principle should be applied in an equit barbarism”; able and paternal manner, and the enforce ments limited to the strict necessities of the Stat Thi not the case in regions ex plo.ted by the commercial rocieties. more particularly in that controlled by the Abir Company, where the imprisonment of wo- [Vol. 81, No. 2109 The Nation. men as hostages, hina ‘tee and various acts of cruelty are not contested. In one village there were in recent years, on native testimony, 120 murders. The commissioners recommend that the right to use force in the collection of the labor tax should be taken away from the com- panies and vested in the supreme authority. We note the formation of a Pennsylvania History Club, consisting at present of about forty members, and restricted to historical writers of consequence upon themes Penn- sylvanian. It is an openly avowed adjunct to the Historical Society of Pennsylvania, and will hold its meetings in that society's building. We cite a few of the leading names: John B. McMaster, Isaac Sharpless, Sydney George Fisher, Samuel W. Penny- packer, Joseph G. Rosengarten, William B Rawle, John W. Jordan, Burton N. Konkle, Ellis P. Oberhoitzer. In his ‘Washington and the West’ (The Century Co.), Mr. A. B. Hulbert prints the diary of Washington’s journey to his lands on the Ohio, in 1784, and ac- companies it with a running commentary based upon personal visits to the localities and research among historical records. The result is an interesting and valuable book, too strongly colored by certain the editor from Washington can “expansionist” in and no one such a somewhat prejudices which affected the beginning of his task. hardly be held the modern sense of the word shrunk from Philippine purchase. the responsibilities territory defined by the and he looked upon the the true western boundary States. His interest lay in developing the Western territory in such as to give it commercial connection the East. This he desired as a na- tional policy, and incidentally would make his large holdings of lands in the Ohio basin profitable to himself. The journey was primarily to view those lands settle disputes with settlers who had refused to recognize his title. Secondarily, he wished to see the possibilities of con- necting the Virginia rivers with the Ohio, so as to tap the growing commerce of the West, and enable Virginia to compete suc- cessfully with Pennsylvania and New York. up as an sooner the with have of folly as He content entailed by the 1783, would piece was treaty ofl Mississippi as of the United a way with because it The printed by Sparks, but in full, and Mr. Hulbert claims to give diary was not an exact reproduction of its text. Unfortu- nately, his copyist has played him some tricks, and especially in the spelling of proper names Washington's writing is very clear after a few twists have been mastered, and it showed carelessness to print Casson more than once for Cannon, or Nacarenger Hd’ aten for Holston, or hewis for Lewis, especially for NSwearengen, or as the editor gives the correct spelling in his commentary. Nor was it Trickett (p. 28) but Nnickers of whom Washington wrot« A glance at the manuscript would have prevented such errors, as in each case the words are clearly and correctly written Nor is the editor himself care- ful In his references. He writes Luzerene for Luzerne, and places the Braddock march in 1775. His notes are full to dlf- but he has made a very readable book, and the diary dese:ved to be printed In such an admirable form. Mr. Hulbert fuseness, could have found additional information as to Washington’s land ventures and his in- terest in the navigation of Virginia rivers. This interest was awakened and fostered by his half-brother Laurence, and the sum- mary of the results of this journey of 1784 make an essential chapter in the history of the internal commerce of the Middle and Southern States. That the expectations of Washington were never realized takes away nothing from his excellent judgments upon the situation in his day and what the in- terests of Virginia demanded. —Miss Anna B. McMahan has carried out satisfactorily her excellent plan of col- lecting from Shelley’s diaries, letters and printed works all local references to his stay in Italy. This material, to which she gives the title ‘With Shelley in Italy.’ (Chicago: McClurg), has a two-fold in- terest,for it appeals to the lovers of Shelley and to the lovers of Italy. With the evi- dence thus concentrated, the student of Shelley’s genius can realize, what he may have only dimly felt, that Italy, whither Shelley went in April, 1818, was a vital inspiration for him. The poems which he wrote from that date till his death in July, 1822, so obviously transcend all his pre- vious work that we hardly exaggerate in saying that they are the real Shelley, that the earlier work hardly counts, and that but for Italy he might never have developed. In Italy, he found the spiritual climate indispensable to his genius. and he throve and blossomed and bore fruit in prodigal luxuriance. There he found also the material conditions without which he had been irritated and checked. There, too, was the landscape which, etherealized in his imagination, made the scenery of his masterpieces. There was the land “Where music and moonlight and feeling are one."’ Miss McMahan has followed him from place to place, and, besides quoting his descriptions and poems, she supplies ad- mirable summaries of his life year by year. She illustrates her book with three score or more views of buildings and scenes mentioned by Shelley, and of his various dwellings. The whole forms a delightful sort of poetic itinerary, whether for per- sons who are actually in Italy, or for those who travel in imaginatian only. —The charm of French rural and provin- cial life, closed to the casual tourist, Mme. Mary Duclaux (A. Mary F. Robinson) once again brings before us in the republication (London: Chapman & Hall; Philadelphia: Lippincott) of “The Fields of France,’ a beautiful quarto with twenty reproductions of water-color sketches by W. B. Macdou- gall, chiefly in illustration of French dwell- ings from farm-houses to chateaux. These pictures, done in light tints and with great suggestive deftness In simple handling, are wonderfully accurate in conveying the feel- ing of French landscape, except that in the Loire country sketches we miss something of the subduing grays and glowing yellows of that lovely region. Of the writer's part, a reviewer fortunate enough to have en- joyed informa! French hospitality, to have chatted with farmer or peasant In fleld and vineyard, can but speak in terms of eager pleasure. The seven divisions of her book carry one from Normandy to Provence with apparently equal sympathy and shrewd ob- servation, in the same spirit as Miss Beth- am-Edwards’s kindred work dealt with

Page 21

Nov. 30, 1905] The Nation. 447 other aspects of French social life. What a contrast with corresponding books of a few generations ago! We would draw spe- cial attention to the first study, “A Farm in the Cantal,’ which covers the annual rural pursuits of a modest establishment— Mme. Puclaux’'s own—in the mountains of Auvergne; also, to the admirable exposi- tion, “The French Peasant,” in which the author traces the vicissitudes of the rural population in general through the develop- ing changes of legislation, old or new. Her contention is that the peasant is relatively worse off to-day than in the Middle Ages. The account of a country day at “A Manor in Touraine” is absolutely exact (p. 72), and could be matched in any department of France, save the very poorest. Altogether, this is a delightful book. Through an excellent and inexpensive reprint (Lane) the ‘Memoirs of Lady Fan- shawe’ are once more rendered accessible. This work, which holds a high place in the biographical literature of the Stuart era, is specially serviceable as helping to correct a vulgar error. Because the Cavaliers of the pre-Regicide period were gay and to a certain extent dissipated, it is still thought by many that the strife between them and the Roundheads was a contest between irreligion and religion. Such an idea, as a sweeping generalization, is ill-grounded. Nowadays few people read Sir Robert Fil- mer’s ‘Patriarcha,’ but the arguments there advanced in support of absolute monarchy are strictly Biblical, and the serious-mind- ed cavalier who fell at Edgehill deemed that he was giving up his life no less for the faith than for the crown. Lady Fan- shawe in her youth was a very sprightly person who, before her marriage. was among the gayest of the gay when the King kept court at Oxford. Yet even then her mirth was not of the kind which brings repentance, while, under the influence of her husband, she gained dignity and ser- iousness without losing her original verve. The most famous passage in the ‘Memoirs,’ the account of her parting with the King, is instinct with that kind of piety which was as native to the Cavaliers as the watchwords of Puritanism were to the Roundheads. ‘‘He stroked me on the cheek and said, ‘Child, if God pleaseth, it shall be so, but both you and I must submit to God's will, and you know in what hands I am.” ... Thus did we part from that glor- ious sun, that within a few months after was murdered, to the grief of all Christians that were not forsaken by God."’ The hero of these ‘Memoirs,’ however, is not Charles I., but the writer’s husband, Sir Richard Fanshawe. Composed for the edification of her son, Lady Fanshawe's pages though with tact and good taste, the vir- tues of his father. Fanshawe, who was an excellent scholar and a thoroughly honor- able man, returned to Eng ‘d at the Re- storation in the Kiag’s ‘n ‘diate train, and was soon rewarded wit. the post of ambassador at Madrid. Toward his me- mory his wife is able to mali iin an at- titude of true devotion without ‘ling into what has been styled the “door saat” pos- ture of adoration. The standard of com- parison which one naturally thinks of in this case is set by Mrs. Hutchinson's vol- ume on the virtues of her husband; but, as Beatrice Marshall points out in an iutro- duction to this reprint, “the Royalist Am- recite, bassador’s wife is incomparably sparkling and anecdotic than the Colonel's.” Speaking broadly and with re- ference to sheer historical Mrs Hutchinson must, we think, be placed be fore Lady Fanshawe; but, trinsically, the present volume is a record of very considerable value more Puritan value considered in —Dr. George Bryce’s ‘Mackenzie, Selkirk, Simpson,’ in the ‘Makers of Canada” series (Toronto: Morang), is with the commercial rivalry which made the North- west of Canada a battleground between two great companies. The volume includes, it is true, occupied an account of Mackenzie's travels and the subsequent explorations of Simpson, but the main motive is furnished by that bitter sjruggle for trade between the Hudson Bay Company and the Montreal merchants who ventured to the field them, under the name of the Northwest Company Lord Selkirk’s experiments in colonization were affected by this rivalry no less than enter against the routine traffic in beaver skins, and though his attempts to establish a Scot- tish settlement in the valley of the Red River is a self-contained episode, it fits in well with Dr. Bryce’s narrative of the great commercial war. Selkirk, for example, an- the the Northwest Company, was assailed by them in lawsuits and sentenced at their instance to pay con- siderable Few incidents in the history philanthropy are more tragic than the efforts of this Scottish peer distress by the wretched of his countrymen to make homes for themselves upon the virgin soil of the tagonized members of damages. of modern to relieve enabling more prairie. One important paper, as yet un- published, Dr. Bryce has procured in the memorial that Selkirk addressed in 1802 to Lord Pelham, then Home Secretary. That is to say, nearly ten years before his first emigration project was matured, he had made up his mind regarding the objective point. “At the western extremity of Cana- da, upon the waters which fall Lake Winnipeg, and, uniting with the great river of Port Nelson, discharge themselves into Hudson Bay, is a country which the Indian into traders represent as fertile, and of a cli- mate far more temperate than the shores of the Atlantic under the same parallel, and not more severe than that of Germany and Poland. Here, therefore, the colonists may, with a moderate certain of a comfortable and they may also raise some valuable objects of exportation.” This contains, perhaps, the earliest forecast of agricultu- ral resources in Western Canada to be ex- ploited on a large scale the indigent classes of Great Britain. Dr. Bryce, who is one of the first authorities on the annals of the Canadian Northwest, gives us here an interesting sketch of Mackenzie and Simp- son, but his account of Selkirk is, we think the most striking thing in the present yol- ume. exertion of industry, be subsistence, passage for THE HOUSE OF MIRTH, AND OTHER NOVELS. The House of Mirth. By Bd th Wharton. Charles Scribner's Sons. Jules of the Great Heart. By Lawrence Mott. The The Century Co Deep Sea's Toll. By James B. Con- nolly. Charles Scribner's Sons. The Professor's Legacy. By Mrs. Alfred Sidgwick. Henry Holt & Co The Toli of the Bush. By William Satchel! Macmillan. The Mountain of Fears. By Henry Row land. A. 8S. Barnes & Co At least writers have expressed a view The authoritative of Mirth n Preacher two serious and memorable words whose w.sdom is enshrined in the Book of Eecl« siastes, was a man of moods; in a dreary moment he turned a gloomy eye on Mirth lescr bed her house as the house of Milton, a he Preacher, and, and han to think greater discernment, of more se Mirth, hail and free,”’ beg fools less impetuous inclined poet we are a man of date habits, gized genially at ing “Goddess fair ging “admit great literature, Mirth and of the mains her as a her to him of her crew."" In the character o, of her (for most of that great 1 therefore, habi'u¢s house re undetermined, and us) to consider any subject has been in discussed in terature the conclusively is to dwell forever in shadow of doubt Mrs. Wharton, is already hailed in who is a serious writer and some quarters as an authoritative one, appears to have escaped Perhaps overlooked while Milton, with the blight of indecision meditating Mirth, could a clear herself has written a she ind therefore the more easily, conscience and earnest conviction Preacher A long book in range beside the all events she sup tale of American 80 assures us that the that a bi truth port of his dictum, a clety, which Preacher Was a prophet, and ter epigram may incorporate literal In order to do justice to Mrs. Wharton's book. a disposition to challenge her atti ude towards her subject should be re pressed. Having made up her mind, she sedom wavers or falters. Her weak mo ments are few She is “thorough."’ The main prop of her argument is perspica cious'y chosen A woman, young, beaut ful, and poor, whose only object in life Is to make a great mach (as American slang appropriately has it, “to marry rich’’) a pillar of sirength for the purpose of de lineating a society that has neither mind morals, nor manners—a desiiiute society rolling in money. Many novelists have dé scribed the soc‘al career of this ill-fated young person, general’y representing her as a victim of cirgumstance, herself pos- sessing intrinsic virtues which either con quer superficial and accidental attribu‘es or make enough show'ng to reader's sympathy. Not in lenient fashion Mrs. Wharton seen and judged Miss Lily Bart. The image cons antly and consistently before her, most vividly presented, is not that of a natural- ly good girl, of an essentially nice girl hurt, hardened, degraded by with a wicked world, but that of a girl born at he wicked world’s level, who, falling to get a firm footing therein, is driven by bitter and repeated @isappointment to take her leave by the agency of an over-dose of choral. Miss Bart never willingly faces 1ifé beyond the precincts of the House of Mir'h, but outstays her welcome there, re sorting to ignominious shifts, pocketing ra- ther deadly insults, until she is pushed out of doors and down, step by step, to the com- mon h ghway. Occasionally Mrs, Wharton's clear, severe vision wavers. She intimates that ber Lily at least a good engage the this has most contact

Page 22

448 The Nation. [ Vol. 81, No. 2109 Bart is superior to her world, that she chafes in chains, and has intermittent at- tacks of soft and even sanctifying emo- tions. Mrs. Wharton is weakest when she is merciful. Miss Bart does seem to throw up her game at a critical moment and to let coveted prizes slip through her fingers; but such misfortunes strike us as unforeseen results of her folly or of an unexpected checkmate. There is no evi- dence of instinctive recoil from an inten- tion recognized as ignoble. Even her final rejection of the monstrous conditions on fulfilment of which Mr. Rosedale has ex- pressed a willingness to marry her, fails to establish any moral worth. Blackmail is a resort of the infamous. A decent girl, one not necessarily clever or kind or well-bred, would have sent Mrs Dorset’s compromising letters back to her as soon as they fell into her hands. It is by the temptations that Miss Bart permit- ted to visit her that her character finally fails to commend itself for sympathetic judgment or compassion. “Dingy” is her favorite appellation for those who do not live in splendor on their own or other peo- ple’'s incomes She had a mortal horror of dinginess, external dinginess, but lived and moved delightedly among souls of a dinginess incomparable, beyond furbishing. The poor girl's inward eye was a feeble or- gan not susceptible of cultivation. \ hasty mental comparison between Miss Part and famous heroines of society fic- tion, both English and French, suggests many points of resemblance, though in one respect she stands alone in dreary isola- tion. She has not a particle of genuine, fundamental, good human feeling, and has very little bad. Her assumed tender emo- tion for the cautious, not to say canny, Mr. Selden (a cold prig), never convinces any one, not even him. She cherishes no af- fectionate sentiments towards the mother who did her poor best for her, the aunt who supported her, the rich women who dressed her, or the poor friend who adored her. In no society could such a being exist except in that where the dismal and (to the reader) often tedious drama of her life goes on. The denizens of her House of Mirth’ are revolting. They eat and drink, expensively and often, but are never mer- ry. They never think, and their talk is as the crackling of thorns. They break the seventh commandment without the excuse of passion, apparently playing with adultery and divorce (as they seem to play bridge for high stakes and drive motor-cars) in order to assert privilege, to earn the ab- surd epithet, “smart.” They have no ideas, no Intellectual Interests, neither wit nor humor nor tact nor grace. If this is American society, the Amer- lean House of Mirth, it is utterly unsuit- able for conversion into literature Lit- erature demands all that such society has not—Iideas, Intellectual interests, sentiment, passion, humor, wit, tact, and grace; it can get along perfectly well without mo- ney, which is the only desire or posses- sion of such society, ita only claim for re- cognition even by the newspapers. A feel- ing for fair play obliges us to protest Mrs. Wharton's picture as a prejudiced one, yet it is not consciously wunveractous. Though depressing, it is not wholly un- profitable. A perusal of Miss Bart's mel- ancholy history will hardly incite those who are in society to pause and examine themselves, but it may cause those who are outside the ring to praise God for that he has been pleased to make them “dingy.” ‘Jules of the Great Heart’ is a story of the life of trappers in the Hudson Bay re- gion in early days. The hero is a “free” trapper—a poacher, that is to say, on the recognized thunting-ground of the Hudson Bay Company. He set few traps of his own and lived by stealing from the traps of the Company. This was, of course, enough to make him an outlaw with a price on his head, but Jules throve and easily outwitted the Indian trappers of the Company. What proved the greatness of his heart was the fact that he was always ready-to help a man in distress, and he gradually won over the friendship of nearly all the trappers who had vowed to take his head back to the trad- fing-post. The sentimental character of certain of the episodes would make Jules a suitable figure in Sunday-school literature if it were not for his irreconcilable enmity with the Indian Tritou, whom he kills in a manner that leaves no doubt of the savage disposition beneath. The book offers in- teresting reading for boys, and even older readers may enjoy the vivid descriptions of the hard life of the trapper in those wilder- nesses of snow where the bodies of the trapped furry animals are quickly frozen stiff, and a man’s life often depends on his skill in making himself the right kind of snow shelter for the night. Since Mr. Kipling’s ‘Captains Courageous,’ the New England fishing fleets have been promoted to a high place in the fiction of seafaring. This is no more than their due in these days when the fleld of the romance of sailing-ships is necessarily limited, and the novelist is driven to make the engine- room the centre of interest in typhoons. The storm-swept deck of a trawler off Georges Shoals on a bad night, or the north- east bar of Sable Island, the Graveyard of the Atlantic, will furnish all the old sen- sations, and there are few adventures more perilous than being lost in a dory in a snowstorm, a hundred miles from the coast. Mr. Connolly, in ‘The Deep Sea’s Toll,’ con- tinues the series of stories of deep-sea fishing begun in ‘Out of Gloucester.’ They are admirably drawn pictures of the hardest life a man can choose. The constant fac- ing of death as part of the day’s work be- gets characters of the most simplified type, and, whatever may be the reaction on shore, there is no such school of heroism and un- selfishness as the Atlantic trawler. It is to be hoped that some English writer of short stories will be inspired by Mr. Con- nolly’s success to describe the no less in- teresting existence of the English North Sea fishermen, where the conditions are, how- ever, somewhat different; the absences from home on the Dogger are longer, and, since the fish are collected from the trawlers by a steamer, and the fleet is less scattered, there is more cojperation and, in the absence of Russian battleships, less danger. In ‘The Professor's Legacy,’ Mrs. Sidg- wick bas revived a situation that had a great vogue in the eighties. In Bngland it was the theme of ‘Agatha’s Husband,’ a novel which, in the familiar old yellow cover of those days, thrilled every English reader of sentimental] fiction. The German version of a similar plot was ‘The Second Wife,” and perhaps the most successful variation of all was Ohnet’s ‘Ironmaster.’ The young wife, who confides to her hus- band, within a few hours of their wed- ding, that she loves another, or that she is, at any rate, indifferent to himself, reg- ularly, in this type of fiction, fares bet- ter than she deserves. Her statement is always received with becoming dignity, and a week has seldom elapsed before she finds that her husband is the real hero of her dreams. After thig there is very slight” variation in the course ef the plot. The repentant wife is treated with the great- est consideration in all externals by her husband, whose complete skepticism as to the state of her affections the lady nov- elist depicts as almost brutal. His cold- ness naturally precipitates the crisis, the wife’s declaration. It is at last discovered that, under that exterior of icy politeness, is disguised an ardor that matches her own. We have observed that the bride- groom in the early stages is never so thor- oughly disillusioned by his bride’s declara- tion of independence as to be permanently cured of his own passion. Yet that state of things would lead to a far more com- plicated and interesting and perhaps more probable situation. The scene of Mrs. Sidgwick’s novel is partly Germany, where her heroine-is brought up, partly the, north of England, where her husband brings her to live. The scenes of English life are well done, and the tale as a whole is quite as entertaining as any one of the earlier ro- mances of the same type. William Satchell’s ‘The Toll of the Bush’ is a New Zealand story full of life and swing. The title is derived from the native superstition thus stated in chapter x.: “Every bushman knows the toll of blood de- manded by the virfin forest. It is fixed and inexorable.” This is an appropriate term for the tragic if slightly theatrical denouements whereby the treacherous bride- groom breaks his neck on his wedding day. There are two courses of true love pur- sued by the two brothers Hernshaw, and the smoothness of both is obstructed. Rob- ert, the younger one, has only to over- come his brigie’s scruples at the idea of saddling him*with her drunken father and a mother who has thrown moral conven- tions to the winds. In the end the mother is perfectly happy in her unlawful, home, and the drunken father dies saving his own children from a fire he has himself kindled. In contrast to this rather startling pic- ture of poetic justice, Robert and his young wife are the best drawn characters in the book. We ought, perhaps, to ex- cept the delightful “Bush Oracle,”’ a wood- man’s wife, whose maxims are so shrewd and quaint that we forget their often un- naturally fine English. The other love story, of Geoffrey Hernshaw and Eve Mil- ward, has too many of the customary com- plications to be altogether convincing. There is the successful rival, criminally unscrupulous for all his holy orders; there is the unfounded suspicion which Geoffrey is too proud to refute and Eve too jealous to ignore; finally, there is the exonerating letter discovered too late, and the revul- sion of feeling which drives the newly mar- ried bride out into the Bush, to be found and sheltered by her true lover. Yet even these incidents are so well told as to keep us in pleasing uncertainty to the very end, and there is about the whole book a fresh- ness and a flavor of the wilds that gives it a most welcome individuality. DAbA; an oS updedinrtinta aed

Page 23

ee ca Nov. 30, 1905] The Nation. 4499 In ‘The Mountain of Fears’ we have some of the most unpleasant short stories it was ever the fate of an author to invent. As they deal with strange and exotic regions such as Papua, the Orinoco, Borneo, Cura- cao, Sulu, the South Sea Islands, Hayti, and the Malay peninsula, the ordinary read- er cannot be a judge of their verisimili- tude; but, if the writer is to be trusted, man in those spots “where every pros- pect pleases” must be “vile” indeed. Drinking, murder, abduction, fraud, brutal- ity, cowardice—such are the contents of the book. There is no denying that, in spite of some exaggeration and tall talk, the stories are exceedingly well told, but why tell them? Or, to quote the query j of the hero, Dr. Leyden, whose adventures as a collector form the connecting thread of the volume, why must the writer rake the lockers of his recollection for the mor- bid and anomalous? There is, however, just one story, “Rosenthal, the Jew,” which shines out as a bright spot; its characters are not wholly detestable, it has humor and real pathos, and arouses our breath- less interest. Perhaps in his next volume Mr. Rowland may employ his undeniable gifts on something more of the same kind. PICTURE BOOKS. The two latest issues of the Newnes Art Library (Scribners) are devoted to Filip- pino Lippi and to the early work of Titian. They have the value of other volumes of the series in giving a larger number of re- productions of the works of the artists dealt with than are readily to be found elsewhere, and the quality of the reproductions is im- proving; but they are much less useful than they might be made if the works were ranged as nearly as possible in chronologi- cal order, or if all ascertainable facts as to date and place of execution were given in a note to each picture. The text of the volume on Filippino, by P. G. Konody, is a more serious performance than most. of the contributors to this series have offered us. The same publishers add to their series of books of “Drawings of the Masters” a volume of the drawings of J. M. Swan, one of the most vigorous of British artists and one of the best painters of animals any- where. Not but what Mr. Swan paints the figure also, but the few figure studies here given, while far better than those of Mr. Poynter lately published in the same series, are scarcely first-rate. It is in his studies of animals, particularly of the great cats, that the artist is quite at the head of living practitioners, and has scarcely been sur- passed even by Barye. The quality of the reproductions is quite wonderful, giving the very look of the materials employed, even to the shine of black lead pencil, as well as more important things; and, in the ab- sence of the originals, the possession of this volume will be a delight to the real art- lover. The importers of this volume are the publishers of a book of drawings by a master of a very different kind—a master whose drawings, hitherto, have been an end in themselves, not a means to the produc- tion of other works of art. We are in- formed that Mr. Gibson’s tenth book, ‘Our Neighbors,’ is ‘o be his last; and while it is impossible not to sympathize with the ambition of the brilliant illustrator to be- come a painter, we feel that the immediate result of that ambition must be our loss, whatever may be the ultimate gain. A much wider public than the American will miss what has heretofore been the great- est attraction of more than one of our fore- most periodicals. He leaves us quite at his best, and his humor has never been keener or his technical ability more astonishing than in the present collection. It is perhaps unjust to Mr. EB. V. Lucas to rank his bogk, ‘A Wanderer in Holland’ (Macmillan), among the picture books, for the text has an Interest of its own; its pleasant mingling of personal narrative with compilation from various sources providing considerable mild entertainment. Still, it is doubtful if the twenty illustrations in color by Herbert Marshall and the thirty- four reproductions from paintings by the Dutch masters must not be considered the real raison d’étre of the publication. Mr. Marshall’s drawings, if in no wise great, are yet distinctly clever, and succeed in conveying some idea of the picturesqueness and the abiding charm of Holland; while the Dutch masters, though the examples se- lected are not always of the first impor- tance, are always welcome. Mr. Lucas makes no pretension to connoisseurship, but his untechnical remarks on pictures are nearly always interesting, and, to one reader at least, prove the most attractive part of his writing. No apology is necessary for rating Gus- tave Geffroy’s ‘The National Gallery’ (Frederick Warne & Co.) as a picture book, for one cannot imagine the text, not in- competent but quite perfunctory, existing without the illustrations. The National Gallery, which Sir Walter Armstrong calls, in his introduction, ‘‘on the whole the com- pletest collection of pictures in the world,” is so rich in masterpieces that the book, with any text or none, would be supremely welcome if only the plates were well exe- cuted. Unfortunately, many of the photo- gravures are but mediocre, and most of the process cuts are wretched, so that what should have been a feast of art is little more than an aid to memory. It Is a pity that a fine scheme should have been so mangled in the execution, a fine opportunity so misused. Miss Singleton’s ‘Great Portraits as Seen and Described by Great Writers’ (Dodd, Mead & Co.) hardly answers to the title. Some of the portraits figured are great, some are good, and some are neither the one nor the other; while such authors as Crowe and Cavalcaselle, Carl Justi, Wolt- mann, and others, whatever their value as critics or historians of art, have slight claim to be called great writers. On the whole, the compilation has little to recom- mend it, and some of its faults are inex- cusable; the worst of these being the ap- pearance of entirely different works under the titles and appended to the descriptions of Hals’s “Maria Voogt” and Raphaels’s “Maddalena Don!.”’ There are very few pictures in the last of our picture-books, but then there is so little of anything else! Under the title of ‘Womanhood in Art’ (San Francisco: Paul Eider & Co.), plates of the Venus of Milo, Dagonet’s Eve, Mona Lisa, Beatrice Cenci, the Madonna of the Chair and the Sistine Madonna are printed in a thin yvol- ume and tied together by some pages of gushing sentiment by Phebe Estelle Spald- ing, for the benefit of what public it ts dit- ficult to imagine. CHILDREN'S BOOKS.—II. In his new book, ‘The Champions of the Round Table’ (Charles Scribner's Sons), Howard Pyle continues the work begun two years ago in his ‘Story of King Arthur and his Knights.’ It is evident that this writer brings to his task wide knowledge and great enthusiasm; we could wish that he did not in large measure spoll the good effects of both by diffuseness, affectation of style, and prosy sermonizings. The volume deals with Sir Launcelot and Sir Tristram, whose stories we may, in spite of many interpola- tions, trace more or less distinctly to books vi., viil., ix., and x., of the ‘Morte d‘arthur’; the book of Sir Percival is not drawn from Malory, whether in his book xiv. or else- where. The names of the heroes are well known to all, but, as Mr. Pyle practically ignores the Guinevere affair, omits the mar- riage of Sir Tristram with the second Isoud (La Blanche Mains), and tells us nothing about the Quest of the Sangreal, we find few of the familiar landmarks to help us on a somewhat weary course through 329 pages. The tllustrations, even, do not cheer our way, being stiff and black imita- tions of fifteenth-century woodcuts. It must, however, be remembered that chil- dren do not mind long narratives, and do like constant fighting; so for their sakes Mr. Pyle may be congratulated on having produced a ne plus ultra in both direc- tions Mr. F. Jameson Rowbotham has given us, in his ‘Tales from Plutarch’ (Thomas Y. Crowell & Co.), a pleasant glimpse into the famous Parallel Lives. It is true that he omits the parallelism, and that his four stories, Theseus, Romulus, Fabius, and Alcibiades, are Nos. 1, 2, 10, and 11, so that the two last appear without thelr corresponding mates. But {[t is to be hoped that this pretty little volume is only the prelude to a more comprehensive series. It is, indeed, doubtful whether the illustrations will add to the pleasure of any reader how- ever young, and it is certain that the mor alizing, especially obtrusive in the mytho- logical stories, might be omitted to very good purpose. Again, an excision of such inaccurate or pecullar expressions as “who laid in wait,” “Straits of Peloponnesus,”’ “lithesome,” “valiancy,”’ “you have reason, my son,” “Delphes” and “Cannes” for Delphi and Cannm, would be very advantageous, as also a closer adherence to the text. Thus, Plutarch says that the Athenians sent Minos their living tribute every nine years, but Mr. Rowbotham prefers to make it every year. In the original, Theseus mere- ly protects the new laws, while in this ver- sion he retains the power of framing them In one place the word Tribune is used as a generic term for any magistrate, and Iu another a farmer of the taxes is confused with an ordinary farmer. Again, the title of the third story, ‘“‘Hannibal's Schoolmas- ter,” shows an unfortunate misconception of the jest contained in the word Pmda- gogus as applied to Fabius and his cau- tious attendance on Hannibal's every move- ment. ...Such instances might be multiplied, but it would be an ungracious task. In spite of its defects, this little book Is a

Page 24

450 The Nation. [Vol. 81, No. 2109 welcome addition to the children’s library of classics, ‘Adventures in Pondland,’ ens (McClurg & Co.), is a minute erally entertaining study of the plant and animal life of a little fresh-water pond or pool. Two children, whom the fairy of the pond made free of her realm under the wa- ter, paid frequent visits thither from March till September, and watched the develop- ment and interaction of many forms of life —frogs, toads, dragon-flies, newts, water- spiders, May-files, and a multitude of other creatures—that lived in the cool green for- ests of water-weeds at the bottom or among the rank tangles on the margin, or skimmed the surface in their gay but brief term of aerial life. The book ought to give young readers new interest in humble or- ders of life, and some idea of nature’s adaptation of means to end. ‘The Family on Wheels,’ adapted from the French by J. MacDonald Oxley (Crowell & Co.), is an odd and attractive story of four orphan children, who, with a sagacious trick elephant, an Intelligent old horse, and a clever poodle, travel from one French village to another in a showman’s van, and, before rustic spectators, earn a poor living by the mountebank’s trade inherited from their father. The children are modest, brave, and self-reliant through many hard- ships, and the three animals, which play an important part in the story, are well worth knowing. The story of a Spanish child, daughter of an impoverished nobleman who cast his lot with Columbus In the first voyage to the New World, comes to us in ‘Lady Dear,’ by Millicent BE. Mann (McClurg & Co.). Little Juanita falls into the hands of a wicked kinsman, who covets the ancient castle poverty had forced her father to leave her unguarded in his absence. A faith- ful nurse, a devoted and adroit jester, a se- cret stairway, and a perilous journey to the court of Isabella, who proves herself gen- erous and just, are features that suggest the outline of the story. The writer has succeeded better than many others who un- dertake work of this romantic type in mak- ing her heroine, if not lifelike, at least con- celvable and winning The Menehunes: Their Adventures with the Fisherman and How They Built the Ca- by Emily Foster Day (San Francisco: by Frank Stev- but gen- where noe,’ Paul Elder & Co.), introduces us to the tiny wood-people of Hawalian folk-lore who plant and tend the trees, ferns, and shrubs. ‘The ancient folk-lore of the isl- ands is full of tales of their wonderful works; and If any one wants more proof— why, there is the great water-course of Kaual, cut through the golld rock—no man knows by whom else.” The little book is attractively illustrated by Spencer Wright. Katherine Chandler has gathered from many collection of interesting little stories from folklore of the Pacific sources a Coast. It is called ‘In the Reign of Coyote’ (Ginn & Co.), because for many of the tales the coyote is the deus ea machina. “How the Animals Secured Fire,” “Why the Snakes Change their Skins,” “Why the Coyote Is so Cunning,” are titles that uggest the character of the book. A lit- tle Spanish brother and sister and three Indian raconteurs bind the legends togeth- er with a pretty thread of story Pleasant Tragedies of Childhood (Har- pers) is a series of twenty-nine delightful full-page drawings, by F. Y. Cory, set to appropriate rhymes by Burges Johnson—a felicitous combination for both young and old. The twelve that delineate trials of a first baby are the best part of the book. ‘The Adventures of Tommy Post-Office,’ by Gabrielle E. Jackson (McClurg & Co), tells the story of the pet cat of the Hart- ford (Conn.) post-office—a real cat, the writer says, that is now flourishing to a green old age among the mailbags, ready to be interviewed, “To witness if I He.’ The story is a record of moving accidents and hairbreadth ‘scapes, but it also has its seasons of serenity and even of romance. It is brightly told, and will interest children, and their elders who like cats. This is the centennial year, not only of Schiller and Trafalgar and Mazzini and Gar- rison, but of Hans Christian Andersen; hence a “centenary edition” of the genial Dane's ‘The Ugly Duckling’ (New York: Moffat, Yard & Co.). It is a small quarto in boards, printed on a sort of buff paper, with the added distinction of illustrations by M. H. Squire, four colored plates and some pen- drawings; the last of these the best. Any child will like this book. The more decorative and fanciful the pen-drawings of Willard Bonte in Mr. Clif- ton Johnson’s collection of favorite fairy tales, “The Oak-Tree Fairy Book’ (Boston: Little, Brown & Co.), the more successful they are, and generally on the small scale rather than on the large. Such a tail-plece as that at page 33 is a good example. The favorite tales are a rather individual as- sortment, handsomely printed in clear type. Even more elegant in this respect is the edition of ‘Afsop’s Fables’ to which Miss Cary furnishes an introduction, for adults (Moffat, Yard & Co.). Here the accompany- ing designs are by J. M. Condé, both in color and in black and white. All the ani- mals are dressed up, and on the whole we find the spirit of the artist too burlesque, especially for an edition in which the moral is carefully preserved and printed in bold- face type. McLoughlin Bros. send us ‘Wee Pieces for Wee Speakers’ at home and school entertain- ments, and a grave fault is that it has no table or index. All the contents is in verse, and is a medley. Coleridge’s Christmas Carol has been so docked as to be incohe- rent. The Upton sisters pursue their absurd creation with ‘The Golliwogg’s Fox-Hunt,’ in which the antics of the wooden dollies and their attendant blackmore are as amusing as ever, and the verse as smooth (Longmans). In ‘Occupations for Little Fingers’ (Seribners), Blizabeth Sage and Anna M. Cooley have given a plain answer to the question of grade teachers, mothers, and settlement workers, What can we give the children to do? This little manual illus- trates and describes simple forms of hand- work; including cord and _ raffla-work, coarse sewing, paper-cutting and folding, clay modelling, furniture and upholstery for a doll's house, and crocheting and knitting. The writers are teachers, who have worked out with their classes the things of which they write. Their models are simple and use;ul articles that will interest the child his und give work practical connection with the world about him. They also make valuable suggestions about materials, in- cluding a chapter on “How to Use Nature's Materials,” and they give with each lesson the necessary cost. The Confessions of Lord Byron. Compiled by W. A. Lewis Bettany. London: John Murray; New York: Charles Scribner's Sons. 1905. The above suggestive title may disap- point persons interested in ancient scan- dals, if any such persons still exist. Mr. Bettany’s book is more correctly described in the sub-title as a collection of Byron's “private opinions of men and of matters,”’ and contains few references to incidents and relations of his private life which, in his own day and long after, excited as much public interest and criticism as did his poetry. The compilation of letters and extracts from journals is made from the elaborate Murray edition, only recently completed, an edition that includes over a hundred letters not previously printed. Mr. Bettany has not followed the chronologi- cal order of the Murray edition, but has arranged his matter under headings—‘By- ron’s Reflections on Himself,” ‘Religious Views,” “Opinions of the Literary Life, of Friends, Contemporary Poets,’ etc. The advantage of his method lies in the fa- cility offered for reference, but it presents the matter with a formality which detracts somewhat from the energy and spontaneity of opinions and reflections flung out hap- hazard to the poet’s intimate correspon- dents. It is a very deterring and unsat- isfactory method for a reader who wishes to observe the growth of Byron’s mind, or to form a substantial estimate of his char- acter from his own careless, casual, vo- luminous revelations to his sister, his friends, his solicitor, and especially to his long-suffering publisher, John Murray. Mr, Bettany’s selections are, however, judicious, and, in spite of frequent detachment from iduminating context, do the writer no in- justice. Byron had a fine, an inexhaustible store of grievances against the world at large, particularly against his own English world; and one most bitterly felt was a popular tendency to identify him with his poetry— that is, to construct out of ‘Childe Harold,’ ‘Cain,’ ‘Manfred,’ ‘Don Juan,’ a monster, hight Byron, whose existence was a menace to the homes and Constitution of England. Poetry, he frequently protested, Is an ex- pression of exalted passion; a man cannot live from hour to hour in a state of ex- alted passion. Perhaps not; nevertheless, an inference from Byron's letters is that he almost could. They confirm many of the hints of character derivable from the poems, but at the same time demolish the monster of Barly Victorian legend. Byron the poet was a supreme incarna- tion of the Romantic ideals of his period, born to concentrate in immortal verse the great emotions then agitating mankind. Therefore, however vulnerable to criticism in detail, his rank as a great poet, a world poet, is unassailable. The poetry declares a man of strong, disordered passions, of aggressive intellectual independence, vain, extravagant, profligate, witty, insolent, with all good qualities enhanced, and even gross defects transmuted into some- thing fine and inspiring, by the constant presence in him of the will to be free, and

Page 25

yeep ® Nov. 30, 1905] of an irrepressible ardor to goad the slave to rise up and claim his birthright. His let ers declare the same man at relaxed tension, dropped to the prose level. He seldom treats his correspondents to image- ry or verbal decoration, but quotes clas- sical and English literature very freely, not always correctly. Mr. Bettany has been enough interested in his author's easy command of literary allusion to count the quotations from Shakspere, and give most of a long preface to discussing Byron's in- debtedness to Dr. Johnson. His argument strikes us as a little strained, and we feel that Dr. Johnson could have made a me- morable comment on his conclusion that “the leading man of letters of the eigh- teenth century and the leading man of letters of the early years of the nineteenth century are never found in such dire antag- onism as precludes their meeting one an- other on a common platform of love of humanity and love of truth.” In his estimate of Byron, Mr. Bettany perhaps insists too much on the “taint of the histrionic spirit.” He says that this histrionic spirit is the natural birthright of a man of aristocratic race and temper— a theory that prompts speculation and would bear elucidation. He also thinks that it provoked Byron to make “Italy the centre of his stage, and to let the lime-light play quite impartially on all his qualities, good, bad, and indifferent.” Ex- citable people, plebeian as well as aris- tocratic, often appear histrionic; and if Byron had desired to dwell in the glare of the lime-light he would surely have stayed at home. Several more probable reasons for his self-imposed exile easily suggest themselves. To possess the Ro- mantic spirit is equivalent to possessing a poignant distaste for the conditions to which one is born, and a burning contempt for the thing that is. The true Romantic has always been a vagabond and a dis- senter. Aristocratic England has never, on the whole, been dissatisfied with itself, critical of its conditions, eager to breathe a rarer ether. Byron simply stifled in the England of his day. From his boyhood he kicked against the pricks. He wanted the remote, the ideal, the fabled blue flow- er, the moon. And if more prosaic rea- scns should be required to relieve him from the imputation of prolonged, rather vulgar insincerity, is it not enough to say that he was poor and leved splendor—a taste that could be gratified more cheaply in Italy than in England; that he delighted in political revolutions, conspiracies, and even casual street fights, for all of which Southern Burope afforded more opportuni- ties than did the British Isles; and that, finally, after his separation from his wife, he really could not live in the same king- dom with his mother-in-law, and hope to retain his sanity? The Reconstruction of Religious Belief. By W. H. Mallock. Harper & Brothers. 1906. For the last four hundred years there has been a continuous series of attempts to adjust religious belief to the discov- erles of science in astronomy, geology, eth- nology, and biology. The defenders of the current orthodoxy (largely clergymen) have usually begun by denying the conclu- sions of science; later, forced to accept The Nation. | them, they have undertaken te bring them in.o harmony with religion, commonly by some modification of theological dogma. There are exceptions, but this has been the rule. In one respect Mr. Mallock differs from most of his predecessors in the task of reconstruction: instead of denying or trying to minimize scientific results, he ac- cepts them all fully and unreservedly, giv- ing attention mainly, however, to the most recent discoveries in physics, chemistry, and biology. There is no essential differ- ence, he holds, between living organisms and what is commonly called dead mat- ter—al] matter is alive. Mental activity is part of the universe, having its seat in the } thought-organs of the brain, which asso- ciate and combine the impressions prepared by the sense-organs, and every act of man is conditioned by preceding events that reach back in a causal chain to the re- motest conceivable aspect of the universe. Having thus frankly stated his position, he is free to express his contempt for those champions of theology who, in his opinion, misunderstand or dodge the ques- tions at issue, and particularly for the method of arguing which, but that it Is practised in good faith, he would call “‘the- ological card-sharping’’—-that is, the dem- onstration of some obviously true proposi- tion, and then the adroit substitution, in its place, of the proposition to be proved, examples of which procedure he adduces from Romanes and Lloyd Morgan (pp. 208 ff.) For himself, boldly accepting and adopting all that science has proved, he undertakes to show that science in part forces on us the acceptance of the fun- damentals of religion, in part offers no ob- stacles to the acceptance of them. These fundamentals he makes God, freedom, im- mortality—other elements of orthodox dog- ma he rejects as untenable or ignores as unessential. He argues not for any one system of religion, but simply for relli- gion. Mr. Mallock offers nothing really new in his argument, but it derives a novel color- ing from its relation to recent scientific views, and piquancy from his wit and hu- mor. To summon Spencer (his representa- tive of agnosticism) and Haeckel (his rep- resentative of atheism) as witnesses for religion, this is to turn the tables to some purpose. But his reasoning is serious and impressive, if not always convincing. After pointing out the value of belief as a factor in human conduct, he goes on to insist on the part played in higher civilli- zation by the belief in human freedom, a conscious Deity, and human immortality. It is true, as he says, that belief in these things has been a concomitant of civiliza- tion. Obviously, however, this means mere- ly that up to the present time such be- lief has been found to be the best work- ing theory of life; we cannot be sure that this theory will hold in the future—the semper ubique et ab omnibue repr ts but a fragment of human experience, and is not a final argument. To say that the recognition of the supreme Principle as good “results in what by all is recognized as human development” (p. 232), is to con- found cause and concomitant. As soon as society became organized, the necessities of life led mento enter into friendly rela- tions with the higher Powers; this kindly, quasi-constitutional form of divine govern- 451 ment (Iike the similar form in human po litical government) is not the cause of hu man progress, but one of its elements. Two points Mr. Mallock brings out forc!- bly. He cites scientific authority for the proposition that all-thatis, is implicit in ali that was, that the universe, as a connect- ed whole, must always have contained in itself every one of its evolved products, not only molecules, but also inatincts, ap- titudes, combinations, and arrangements. The inclination or emotion that leads one atom of oxygen to unite with two of hydrogen to form one molecule of water, and the inclination that leads the brain to form thoughts—these two are essentially one, and must have existed in the original structure of the universe. And so, he adds, Spencer’s primeval homogeneity of matter is, from the point of view of science, im- possible; matter must always have been highly differentiated, and must always have contained life, with its elements of thought and emotion. He concludes that, for such a universe, instinct from the beginning with all that is highest in man, the only ex- planation is a theistic one. As to the crucial points of human free- dom and divine goodness, Mr. Mallock frankly abandons all attempts at explana- tion, and falls back on the fact that there is no difficulty in religious belief that does not exist in all other belief. Our concep- tions of space, time, the constitution of mat- ter, motion, consciousness, all involve in- soluble contradictions—they are logically unthinkable, yet men accept and act on them. These belong to ordinary, every-day life. In the higher life the ideas of good- ness and freedom as constituent parts of the universe, equally unthinkable, are equally necessary. As to whether they have their source in a conscious and good divine being, some conclusion must be ar- rived at, for mere negation, the utterance of despair, is fatal to life. Science, Mr. Mallock holds, forces on us the conviction that man’s conscious, moral nature, with its freedom and purposive character, belongs to the essence of the universe. Religion is thus firmly established in the nature of things, but, to retain its ascendancy, it must accept all the ideals of knowledge, culture, mundane progress, and enjoyment which hitherto it has barely tolerated. Mr. Mallock may be said to show that there is nothing in the recent results of physical science (he does not deal serious- ly with philosophy) that forbids religious belief, and much that accords with and leads to it—that religion, in a word, if not absolutely demonstrable, is, from the point of view of physical science, not irration- al. The book is brightly written and the thought is throughout interesting. The proof-reading leaves something to be de- sired. Greatness in Literature, and Other Papers. By William P. Trent. T. Y. Crowell & Co. 1906. This volume contains, besides the titu- lar essay, seven papers on related subjects: “A Word for the Smaller Authors and for Popular Judgment,” “The Aims and Mrth- ods of Literary Study,” “Criticism and Faith,” “Literature and Gcience,” ‘Teach- ing Literature,” “Some Remarks on Mod- ern Book-Burning,” and “The Love of

Page 26

452 The Nation. [Vol. 81, No. 2109

Poetry.” All of these are papers or ad- dresses rather than essays, for though Pro- fessor Trent is a very clear and fluent writer, there is a certain lack of savor, of closeness of grain, in his style. His fluency is a little the fluency of the journalist who throws fn a stock word rather than run the risk of clogging his vein in the search for the right one. Thus, in an at- tempt at a heightened passage about the purity and charm of the sixth book of the Odyssey, Mr. Trent allows himself to write “pristine purity,” “paradisaical charm”; but the hacneyed adjective and the ambi- tlous one alike are off the key. This is a slight matter, but the case is typical of the quality that makes Mr. Trent’s writing op just short of distinction. Nevertheless, this collection of papers is uncommonly readable; it is full of a thor- ough love of the best in literature; it is marked by a considerable shrewdness of judgement in matters whereupon it is both easy and popular to go astray into the emotional; and it is guided by a native bias toward the best academic authority, which, if not of the profoundest doctrinal grounding, yet finds lucid, sincere, coherent expression. There is, too, a good deal of piquancy In Mr. Trent's humor, as, for ex- ample, where he remarks with feeling that it Is not easy to teach the delights of poetry to superior young persons who, with the wide knowledge of human life derived from afternoon teas or the football field, think of ene as merely a harmless old fool.” To the professional mind, at least, the most interesting and provocative of Mr. Trent's papers is that on “The Question of Greatness in Literature,” in which he adventures that most delightful occupation of the human understanding, and draws up a echeme for a graded hierarchy of liter- ary masters. The grouping is as follows: Class One: “The Universal Geniuses’: Homer, Sophocies, Virgil, Dante, Shak- spere, Milton, Cervantes, Goethe, Mollére, and, possibly, Scott, Hugo, Balzac. Clase Two: “The Very Great Writers”: Such poets as Pindar, Lucretius, Petrarch, fasso and Ariosto, Chaucer and Spenser, Schiller and Heine; such prose writers as Rabelais and Montaigne, Swift and Gib- bon Class Three: “Great Writers’: Such writ- ers as Catullus and Horace, Leopardi, Jon- son, Dryden, Pope, Gray, Burns, Coleridge, Keats, Wordsworth, Tennyson, Byron, Shel- ley, and Browning There ts material here to occupy all the erities of the earth in joyous debate until they are outdinned, whether by the sound- ing lyre of a new “universal” poet, or by the thunder of the trumpets of the night. We can do no more than quote Mr. Trent's five suggestive teste for the detection of a universal genius in case any one should have need of them. In the first place, the irt, the technique, of the universal genius » “always high and uniform.” In the gec- nd place, “the genius of none of these upreme writers seems cramped; their power is sovereign and sustained; their range is either universal or very lofty.” In the third place, “each of these supreme masters has achieved a long, sustained masterplece, or a number of masterpieces.” ‘In the fourth place, “the world writer, as his name implies, has conquered the cifvil-

ized world. Whether he is read or not, his name is widely known, and his place is yielded him ungrudgingly.” In the fifth place, the fame of the universal genius endures.

Wolfe and Montcalm. By the late Abbé Cas- grain. Toronto: Morang. This contribution to ‘The Makers of Can- ada” series has at length been published. To close students of Canadian history it presents nothing new since its author's views regarding such leading actors in the campaign of 1759 as Wolfe and Montcalm, Vaudreuil and Lévis, Bougainville and Bourlamaque were set forth during his life- time In numerous volumes and essays. But those who have not devoted special atten- tion to Canadian affairs may be surprised to find that the most voluminous French Canadian writer of recent years deems Lévis to have been a greater general than Montcalm. “Montcalm and Lévis had in common,” says the AbbéCasgrain,‘‘great military qual- ities, unflinching bravery and a consummate knowledge and experience of the art of war; the latter had the better judgment, more broad-mindedness, greater coolness, and even superior intrepidity in action. It was Wolfe’s good fortune not to meet Lévis on the Plains of Abraham; otherwise, while the engagement at Montmorency was only a temporary check to his plans, that of Sep- tember 13 might have meant to him only disaster and ruin.” Since he was writing a volume in the popular series, the Abbé Casgrain may have felt absolved from the duty of waging war- fare against the most determined of his op- ponents in the historical field, M. Kerallain. He simply affirms, although the balance of opinion at present makes against this view, that Bougainville was completely outwitted by Wolfe, and through culpable negligence made his general lose the decisive battle. At what date the Abbé Casgrain com- pleted his manuscript we are not told, but the publishers, in issuing the book, have thought it necessary to furnish a special introduction dealing with the more debata- ble points, and also a set of notes wherein matters growing out of recent literature are discussed. ‘‘We are assured,” runs the introduction, “that the readers of this book will find their interest in the narrative deepened by very reason of the strength of the author’s convictions, and it is in order that these strong convictions may not give the book an undue tincture of prejudice that we have thought it proper to embody in the introduction views that are not infrequently at variance with those which the Abbé Cas- grain has so ably expressed.’’ There follows a review of evidence on the various points at issue between Casgrain and Doughty, and it should be possible for the discriminating reader to see where the Abbé went rather farther in defending his favorite positions than he ought to have gone. At the same time we must acquit him of having, in this his latest volume, been blinded by patriotic prepossessions to the faults of Vaudreuil. In our opinion, it is true, the Governor of New France recelves less condemnation than his action deserved. However, Cas- grain was showing considerable candour when he wrote: “His character was feeble, and he was irresolute, unenlightened, jeal- ous of his authority, and was taken ad- vantage of by a corrupt entowrage which he was incapable of dominating.” These words

could not have been written without a cer- tain pang, and in closing our notice of Cas- grain’s final work we would think of him as one who strove to secure from Laval University a recognition of Parkman's emi- nence, and as a widely read historian who has done something to adjust the perspec- tive by placing in high relief the cause and ideals of New France.

BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Alden, Ebenezer, and Henry Shaw. The Descend- ants of Polly and #benezer Alden. Boston: Gev. Aldin, Cecil "A Gay Dog. Dutton, Antrim, M J Knocks: Wirt | --—. Philadelphia: George W Bevan, Arthur P Fishes I Have Known. A. Wes- sels Oo. $1.26. aenny of —— of Mediseval and Mod- ern Euro) $1.50 itty, Wise, . coos & i Cesaresco, Evelyn MB. HL Blache Madonna of the Scales. Oxford: 2 lack well. Chamberlain, Charles Methods in Plant apt ogy. The University of Chicago Chicago Press, $1.25 (Caxton iy aan Geoeten) ) by Sertb- ners. $1.25 net. = ie ay aH Sivegge Macy of the Quill- aude LP atignienne. eat H. M. quae’ oS. 5 ees ay 4 eet People. 2 Deutsche Reden. by Radolf Tombo. Bos- ton: D. = ‘3 YR 90 cen “tr A 2 ow oS Patelip, ths. Bs 5 sob nce net. cogs

rr 8 Art Library.) Frederick Geftroy, Gust vee National Gallery. Frederick i. Trusts, and Kartells. The History of American Paint- Jullan, Caaries. The 1 ‘Last Lent ot the Stuarts. Denver: Kelly, R. Talbot. Derma: Painted and Described. Macmillan Co. Knowles, Frederic Lawrence. On Life’s Stairway. & Co. $1. Latrobe, The Journal of Latrobe. sptcion OOS wet ‘ — —The Confessions of & 5 — Ge. Mac- millan Co. A. ~ each. > Easy Mathematics. Macmillan Co. » eierea Life and Matter. Putnams. $1 Lacas, E. V. The Friendly Town. London: Me- thuen & Co. Madan, A. ©. Swahile Grammar. Frowde. Marlowe, Christopher. a Plays and ‘oems of. (Caxton Thin — Classi mported by Serib- ners. $1. Me Vickar ney Ww. nape eton. $1.50. Meakin, Budgett. tories ama vi hoot A. Wessels Co. Mercier, Charles, Criminal Responsibility. Henry Frowde. , Anna C. Cardome. P. F. Collier & Son. $1.10. Negri, Gaetano. Julian the A ate. Translat be Duchess Lita, Visconti Arese. 2 —~ ~y Prevost Ww vol, th 2 vols. Putnams. $5 net. : “ BGfeperem, ¢. G. Astronomy in the Old Testament. Henry F Shuckburgh, ome a Lif of the : : Bagire. Mow nae

Four Portralts of the Lord Jesus sie Ge, UE eention by Ane br ~ ty Xe cpiedeiptis: aS. Titian, --% nef, £ Art Li War in net. wae Inflation in the o F Story of Orean Mumte. 25 net. Ww = of Our- by

a ee pee ee Sr oma UR RRR TE

Page 27

2 me ee mage tion,” —. The Williamsons’ motor romances, uni- form illustrated edition. ($1.60 each.) a — one glad one lives,” says ‘ost, while of THE LIGHTNING ©O R it says, “such delig delightful scenes.”’ Nov. 30, 1905] The Nation. HENRY Published at 29 West 234 St., N. Y. NATURE LANKESTER’S EXTINCT ANIMALS. The says: “Opens up a world of new interest . . . popular rather than technical.” ($1.75 net.*) KELLOGG’'S AMBRICAN INSECTS. The latest and most comprehensive book on its subject, yet pleasant reading. (823 illustrations. $6.00 net.*) LOTTRIDGE’S ANIMAL SNAPSHOTS. Some 85 remarkable photographs of famil- iar wild animals and birds with interesting papers on their lives and habits. of comeiners S Stream says: “‘No more commendable book” | treating of wild life has ever come under our notice.” ($1.75 net.*) JORDAN’S GUIDE TO THE STUDY OF FISHES. The latest work on this subject, by the leading American icthyologist, and highly “‘readable.”” (Two volumes, 934 illus- trations, 1223 pp. $12 net.*) STOPFORD BROOKE ON TEN PLAYS OF SHAKBESPBA An interpretation of the methods of Shakespeare as an artist. Not so much an analysis as an apprecia- tion of “Midsummer Night’s Dream,” “‘Win- ter’s Tale,” “Merchant of Venice,” “As You Like It,” “Richard IL,” “Richard III,” **Macbeth,” “Tempest,” “Romeo and Juliet,” and “Coriolanus.” ($2.26 net.*) STEPHENSON’S SHAKESPEARE’S LON- DON. A vivid portrayal and a careful an scholarly study of the topography, customs, and picturesque side of Blizabethan life. Ill’d from old prints. ($2.00 net.*) RUSSIA AND THE PHILIPPINES WALLACE’S RUSSIA, REVISED AND -TO-DATE, is steadily growing in popu- larity. The London Times says it is “in the same class as Mr. Bryce’s ‘American Com- monwealth.’” ($6.00 retail.) ‘WILLIS’S OUR PHILIPPINE PROBLEM. The Evening Post says: “The authoritative indictment of our Philippine policy to date.” ($1.50 net.*) CHAMPLIN’S YOUNG FOLKS’ CYCLOPAEDIAS ‘Profusely illustrated, $2.50 each. COMMON THINGS PERSONS AND PLACES LITBRATURE AND ART GAMES AND SPORTS NATURAL HISTORY FICTION Mrs. Alfred Sidgwick’s THE PROFES- SOR’S LEGACY. “Marked by admirable humor .. . but has more than mere humor or simple characterization to com- mend it. . . . Most capable and satisfy- ing.” —N. Y. Sun. Charles T. Jackson's F CK.”’ A filibustering romance. “It sweeps you along.”"—Times Review. “The reader pur- sues eagerly to the last vty - sorry when he gets there.”—Ohicago Pos Mrs. Fraser's MAID OF ne “an ideal gift oe in every respect.” —N. A Globe. ($1.26 Miss poss nah THE DIVINE FIRE “tow- ers above the ran contemporary fic- Literary *Add 10% of price for postage. “ Pillar’d around by everlasting hills, Robed fn the drapery of descending floods." | NIAGARA FALLS One of the natural wonders of | the world. A charming place at any season of the year, reached | from every direction by the | | | NEW YORK CENTRAL LINES | A visit to the Falls is an ob- | ject lesson in Geography; an | exhibition of landscapes that no painter can equal, and a glimpse industrial worla. A coor a of Four-Track Series No. 9," Two Days at Ni Falis,” will be sent free, upon re- ceipt o atwoo ent stamp, by George H. Danteis, rend Central Sta- General *Pessenaer Agent, | | of thelatest developments of the tion, New York. | A year’s sub- scription to St.Nicholas is such an easy solution of the Christmas gift problem. @ For any girl or boy under eighteen. JUST PUBLISHED THE NEW RAMBLER From Desk to Platform Essays and Addresses. By Sir Lewis Morris. Large crown 8vo. $2.00. LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., New York THE AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF ABRAHAM LINCOLN Sent on receipt of 10 cents to cover expense. FRANCIS D. TANDY COMPANY Dept. B 38 Best aust St., New York City BOOKLETS POSTAL CARD PACKETS Our well-known Packets are ready, and need only brief mention. First 7 Packs, post paid, for $3.85. 10 Packs, postpaid — Noe. 1. Por 54 cents, 17 Xmas Cards and Hang No. 3. 54 cents, 10 Fine Cards and H. Sy No. 3. * 1.08, 25 Xmas Cards and let No. 4 “ §1.08, 40 Pine Postal Cards (20 Kmas of the 40) No. 5. “ 64 certs, 20 Fine Postal Cards (all diferent) No. 6 * $1.08, 10 Beautiful Calendars 7 pa cents, ) —-) ~~ reneeeeeee No. 6. “ 27 cents, 10 ards No. 9. “ Gécents, 5 Booklets and Calendar No.10. “ 64 cents, 25.8unday-School Cards, or 20 Fine Birthday Cards er Special Packets and lots put up to order TEACHERS ¢ ~~ 1 OB, 5O Cards, no two alike 4 cents, 25 Cards, no two alike y mee ag Pe aper by the pound, 15 H. H. CARTER @ CO., Satisfaction 5 Somerset St., Boston. Guaranteed. Full Cireulara on Application Now Ready wes adecen DECISIONS JOHN MARSHALL Edited by JOSEPH P. COTTON, Jr. 2 volumes large 8v0, with Photo gravure Frontispieces, half leather or fall sheep, gilt tops, $5.00 net per vol. These volumes present in a popular but complete form Marshall's opinions in this division of law, of which he is the acknow! eiged master, with such notes as show the facts of each case, a history of the questions arising in it, its piace in Marshall's theory of constitutional government. and its effect on the later law. Send for Full Descriptive Circular. G.P. Putnam's Sons, 2342.8." THE MOSHER BOOKS @ The new catalogue for 1905 revised and enlarged in for ma/,printed in red and black, 64 pages. Free on request. THOMAS B. MOSHER Portland, Maine F, W. CHRISTERN (DYRSEN & PFEIFFER, Successors), ite tne “Waldorf.” New York Importers Books, Agents for the leading Parts | Tauchnite’s British authors. Teu! ner’s Greek Classica. Catalogue of stock matied on lew books received from aris and Leipzig as soon as issued. RED FOX: RED FOX: By CRASS G. D. ROBERTS Author of “The Heart of the Agetent Wood,’ THE LEADING FALL BOOK “The Kindred of the Wi,’

Page 28

The Nation. L¥ee 81, No. BIOS The Most Complete The Most Exhaustive THE VFARIORUM EDITION OF SHAKESPEARE Edited by HORACE HOWARD FURNESS The Fourteen Volumes which have thus far appeared are Macbeth Romeo and Juliet The Winter’s Tale Stes Mewens Peaven, 3c The Tempest Twelfth Night King Lear A Midsumnier Night’s Dream Much Ado About Nothing Othello As You Like It Love’s Labour’s Lost The Merchant of Venice Hamlet (Two volumes) (Postage, 30 cents extra) Royal octavo, gilt top, uncut edges, $4.00, net, per volume. Half morocco, gilt top, $5.00, net, per volume. ‘Mr. Furness’s noble work will be a lasting honor to American letters.’"— Vew York Times. ‘It is a truly monumental edition.’ — Pall Mull Gazette. ‘This is the most valuable work recently contributed to our Shakespzarian literature, and America has the honor of pro- ducing the best and completest edition of Shakespzare’s immortal plays.’’—Birminghim (England) Daily Post. JUST PUBLISHED. LIPPINCOTT’S NEW GAZETTEER Edited by ANGELO HEILPRIN and LOUIS HEILPRIN A GEOGRAPHICAL DICTIONARY OF THE WORLD A work of inestimable value to all libraries, private and public. A necessity for schools and colleges. A compilation of industrial and allied facts that no manufacturing business, jobber, or exporter can afford to be without. Over 2000 pages. Quarto. Sheep, $10.00 net, Half Russia, $12.50 net. Patent index, 50 cents extra. ‘A volume remarkable for the amount of information it contains, based upon official data from every quarter of the globe.”’ — The Boston Herald. LIPPINCOTT’S STANDARD REFERENCE WORKS THE NEW 1905 EDITION Lippincott’s THE NEW EDITION OF Chambers’s | Pronouncing Dictionary of Chambers’s Cyclopaedia Biography and Mythology =| of English Literature wen geste ae Ee ee ee There is no single work of more im- | This magnificent work, which for years | portance for library, school, and college he corner-stone of any library is a | has been in its department without a rival | than this. good encyclopaedia—it is indispensable. | in the estimation of scholars, has lately A clear and comprehensive survey of English | undergone an extensive revision, which | a eee e twentieth | was rendered necessary by the great | contsins an authentic b hy of . eve Chambers’s strides that have taken place in every field | | American and English writer note, whether poet, dramatist, novelist, or historian. The material c »ndensed into the three volumes of Chambers’s — ja of English Litera- Encyclopaedia of human activity in the last few years; it is now offered to the public in a greatly is not only the acknowledged encyclo- | | improved form, embracing beside the re- ture would ordinarily fill a dozen or more paedia for the busy man and student, but | vision of the articles included in previous | also carries the finest illustrations of any | issues, numerous new biographical | tis “isthe nf clanttle nenpe authoritative reference encyclopaedia | sketches of persons who have lately be- m5, ee ee - 9TEA , come of sufficient prominence to merit valuable books in English literature, and is a COMPLETE IN TEN VOLUMES, | COM ° library in itself. aT : Lilustrated with approved portraits and ONE DOLLAR secures the use of omarorr — rv = large octave drawings, Contains over 2500 pages. A the entire set atonce, COME §=AIFO CHESSER FAG detailed Table of Contents in each volume. and the balance can be paid in little-at-a- | Buckram, $15.00; half russia, Complete in three imperial octavo volumes time amounts ' $17.50; half morocco, $20.00. stoutly bound. Sample pages and full particulars of these valuable works sent on application. J. B. LIPPINCOTT COMPANY, . Philadelphia

Page 29