The Nation 1905-08-31: Vol 81 Iss 2096

Page 1

GENERAL LIBRARY, UNIV. OF MICH, SEP 2 1905 The Natiein Sis10410/) ayerg VOL. LXXXI—NO 2096, THURSDAY, AUGUST 31, 1905 PRICE TEN CENTS. The Macmillan Announcements INCLUDE THE FOLLOWING AMONG OTHER IMPORTANT NEW BOOKS OF HISTORY Mr. Herbert Paul’s History of Modern England The first three volumes of Mr. Paul’s “History” have been very highly praised for their trenchant, popular, comprehensive and impartial account of public events. The fourth is in preparation for early issue. Ready tn October OF BIOGRAPHY Wm. Garrott Brown’s Life of Oliver Elisworth i By WILLIAM GARROTT BROWN, Author of “ The Lower South in American History,” “The Foe of Compromise and Other Pa Essays,” “A Gentleman of the South,”’ etc. Ready 1m Octooer Mrs. Barrington’s Reminiscences of G. F. Watts By Mrs. RUSSELL BARRINGTON. Containing five full-page plates in color, four photogravure portraits, and twenty-seven othe: illustrations from hitherto unpublished drawings. Cloth, super royal Sve, $5.00, net. Now read OF PUBLIC INTERESTS Dr. Hugo Richard Meyer’s Government Regulation of Railway Rates Professor HUGO RICHARD MEYER is said to have proved to be the one man in this country competent to give the Senate Commit tee on Inter-State Commerce certain vital information. Railroad men quote him as the best posted man on the subject in the world. Unusual interest and value attach themselves to his new book, which is a comparative study of the results of publ.c regu lation of railroad rates, pointing out clearly the two opposing policies, with their respective advantages and d sadvantages. Cloth, 12mo. Avaat Restrictive Rallway Legislation By Henry S. Haines Fo'lows the growth of railroad legislatio: corresponding with the development of our national railroad system in its several field of activity: in railroad ‘corporation, finance, construction, operat on, and traffic. Cloth, 12m Keady shor! OF TRAVEL AND SPORT Mr. Sandys’s Sporting Sketches By EDWYN SANDYS, Author of “Sportsman Joe,” “ Trapper Jim,”’ and “Upland Game Birds.”’ Iilustrated. Cloth, Crown § Mr. Outram’s In the Heart of the Canadian Rockies By JAMES OUTRAM. Fascinating adventures and a grat deal of incidental information about a region as yet little known ever to sportsmen. Iliustrated. Cloth, OF SCIENCE Dr. Auslin Flint’s Handbook of Physiology By AUSTIN FLINT, M.D., LL.D., Professor of Physiology in the Corn-il University Medicil College. Richly Illustrated. : An Atlas of forty-eight reproductions of histolo.ical specimens, im ‘he colors actually scen under the microscope, is an achievement never before possible in a text-book of mod:rate price. Ready Sept. 13 New Creations in Plant Life An Authoritative Account of the Life and Work of LuTH#ER Bursank, the man who has produced more new forms of plant life than any other ever did. With forty-nine full-page plates. By W. S. HARWOOD Cloth, 12mo THE MACMILLAN COMPANY, Publishers, 64-66 Fifth Avenue, New York

Page 2

ae ee ‘The Nation. [Vol. 81, No. 2096 r . ° Lhe Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science and Art, FOUNDED IN 1865. Entered at the New York City Poat Office as secoad-class mail matter CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. rus WeeK 173 EDITORIAL ARTICLES Governmental Automatism 176 Reform by Precept 176 The Last of Addicks 137 Transcontinental Rallway Bullding 178 liymnals, Old and New 178 SPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE Chinese Studentsa in Japan 170 I ‘rovincee of the Mezzotint 1st CORRESPONDENCE I I lippines and tl I , IS2 Lhew nd Dived 182 I ad Lem Is2 Nore 182 Book Revigws Sidewick’s Essays and Addresses ISS I ' Hegarth si rt bvolution f th Constituthon of the United States of America, and History of Mun « Dootrine ISS I nd Around Venles Isu Vasais d'Histoire Diplomatique Américalne Iso 1sv Hooks or THe Week TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three dollars per year in advance, postpaid, in any part: f the United States or Canada; to foreign wountries comprised in the Postal T’nion $4 The date when the subscription expires is on the address label of each paper. the change of which » a auheequent date bee »mes a receipt for a remit lance Vo Remittances at the risk of the suhacriber, untess nade by registered letter, or by check, express or der or Postal Order Pp tywable to“ Publisher of The Nation When a change of address tia desired, both the other re-eipt is sent unless requested, old and new addresses should be given Address THR NATION. Box 794, New York Publication Office, 208 Broadway TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Fifteen cents per agate line, each insertion; 1h lines to the ineh T'wen'y per ceat. advance for choice af page or top of column i co’umn, gf page, 824 i page, §0 each insertion ; front cover page, $80. idlvertisements mud be ae ept shle in every re- ) each insertion; with choice of speet Obpy received until Tuesday, 5 P.M DISCOUNTS. Time 4 insertion 5 per cent “ 10 = iP lv, ‘ re 15 tv 0 ° be ' 25 e Awouwr 8' 00 within «a year i per cent ay 136 wi © 5 oo) 7h ‘ oe 20 an Loo ‘ 2 ° 100 “ 0 ¥.000 oo 33% * THER NATION ta vent fr ¢ 1) those who advertise in tf as long aa advertisement continues. *,* Copies of the Natriow may be procured in Paris at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de Opéra; in London of B. F. Stevens & Browa, Trafalgar Square, Charing Cross. E:ducational. Connecticut, Old Lyme. OXWOOD MANOR SCHOOL For Book of Information address, Mise I. Loviss Tenperrs, Prin. Massacuvuserts, Boston. POSTON UNIVERSITY Law School New features. Address the Dean. M. M. BreetLtow. Massacuuserrs, Cambridge. [#4 GILMAN SCHOOL FOR GIRLS. Arruvr Gruman, A.M., Director. UTDOOR STUDY ALL WINTER. English Classical Schoo! for Girls. Art, Music, Col- lege Certification. Anna B. Orron, Prin., Pasadena, Ca). fF ETHLEHEM PREPARATORY SCHOOL, Bethlehem, Pa. Prepares for leading A. Foratse, B.S., Principal. coileges. Catalogue. H COORDINATE SCHOOLS. ST. MARGARET'S MALL. San Mateo, Cal, gn Teepetrs, Acting Principal, BOoxwooD scoot "FOR "GIRLS, Old Lyme, Conn. Ipa L. Tesserts, Acting Principal. Same courses. Same rates. Same management. Pupils of either school may spend a year at the other school, for climatic or other reasons, without interruption of studies or disturbance of school dix cipline, and without added expense except in so far as additional expense is incurred by the journey across Continent. For further information address either school, either principal. THE BERKELEY STREET SCHOOL (FORMERLY MISS INGOLS’S) CAMBRIDGE, MASSACHUSETTS, will reopen on Thursday, September 28, 1005, under the direction of Miss Lillian M. Munger and Miss Constance B Williston The school will admit girls at ten years of age and prepare them for college. To students not de siring to go to college, a general course will b> Further details can be obtained from elther of the principals. . Morristown ts Morristown School for Boys tmous tor vs h ealthfulness and beautiful surroundings. Morristown School —a boarding school for boys—has a record for thorough- ness in ite preparatory work, whether for college, scientific school, or good citizenship. Sports for health and pleasure under unusually good conditions. Trustees: € mgezes Scribrer, President; Rev. Wynant Vanderpool, John I. Waterbury. Carroli Dunham. M. D., Wilifam B. Boulton, Grinnell Willis, T. Quincy Browne, Jr., Archur P. Bucler, and Francis C. Woodman, Head Master DOES YOUR CHILD WORRY YOU? Nervous, precocious, difficult to discipline, back- ward? Groszgmann School for Nervous and Atypical Children Individual attention, expert treatment, modern educational methods, splendid equipment. OO feet above sea level. Address THE GROSZMANN SCHOOL, “‘Watchung Crest,”’ Johnston's Drive, Plainfield, N. J. New York University Eves ing C Lasser, PR to 10 Law School! and a. * ‘Tultloa @ $100. ha’ —y lreas L. J TOUPKING, Sec... ‘Washington 8q.. New York. ROCK RIDCE SCHOOL Fer Boys. Location high and dry. Laboratories. Shep for Mechanic Arta, Strong teachers. varnest boys new gymnasium with swimming pool. Fits for College, Sctentific School and business. (Clustrated pamphiet sent free. Please address Dr. G. R. WHITE, Principal, Wellesley Hills, Mass. SAINT GEORGE’S SCHOOL RUTHERFORD, NEW JERSEY. A home boarding school for limited number of gen- tlemen’s sons. Situated In the country, 30 minutes from New York. Prospectus on application. i. GUY RAWLINS, Headmaster. BERLIN, CERMANY WILLARD SCHOOL FOR AMERICAN GIRLS General Courses In German, French, Literature, Art, Music. Prepares for American Colleges Foreign travel. Twentieth year opens Oct. 4. For circular address wr. ALICE H. LUCE, Auburn, Maine. The HIGHLAND MILITARY ACADEMY, Wercester. Mass. 50th year. The Rt. Rev. Alex. if. Vinton, D.D., LL.D, Springfield, Visiter. Says a present patron; “The best Investment [ have ever made was eelrre of my sons lo oer echool.”” Address JOSEPH ALDEN BHA A.M.,.HeadMaster zwsth, 1905. Day Cingece, sessions 3:30 to M. ta YEAR Opens Sept. Inpiana. Indianapolia, Classical School for Girls eA ee NEW YORK | Dey mohool { 35 Nassau St., LAW SCHOOL { Evening School | New F, fork City. ° Dwight Methed"’ of instruction. LL.B. in two years. LL.M. in three years, Send for catalogue. G ok CHASE, Dean. WEBSTER’S UP TO DATE AND RELIABLE RECENTLY ENLARGED WITH 25, 000 New Words and Phrases ALSO ADOED New Gazetteer of the World New Biographical Dictionary Paitor in Chief, W. T. Harris, Ph.D., LL.D., United States Commissioner of Education. 2380 Quarto Pages. 5000 Illustrations. fT 18 A PACKED STOREHOUSE OF ACCURATE INFORMATION. QRano Prize (Highest Award) Worto’s Fain St.Lours, Also Webster's Collegiate Dictionary 1116 Pages. 1400 Illustrations. Regular Edition 7x10x2% inches. 3 bindings. De Luxe Edition 5% x 8% x 1"; in. Printed from same plates, on bible paper. 2 beautiful bindings. FREE, “Dictionary Wrinkles,” also Illustrated pamphleta. G.&@éC. MERRIAM CO. Publishers, Springfield, Mass., U. S. A. GET THE BEST School Agencies. WE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES Everetr 0. Fisk & Co., Proprietors. 4 Ashburton Place, Boston; 1505 Pa. Ave. Washington; 155 Fifth Ave., New York; 414 Cent. Bid., Minneapolis; 583 Cooper Bidg., Denver; 80 Third St., Portland; 203 Mich. Bivd., ¢ *hieago; 325 Stimson Block, Los Angeles; Hyde Block. Spokane; 420 Parrot Bidg.. san Francisco. LBANY TEACHERS AGENCY. 81 Chapel St., Albany, N. Y.—Provides schools of all grades with competent teachers. Assists teach- ers in obtaining positions, HarRuan P. Farenon, Proprietor. CHERMERHORN’S Teachers Agency. Teachers—Schools—Tutors -Governess—Property. Tel. 6120 18th. Joun C. Rockwett. Mer., 3 E. 14th St.. N. ¥. C Teachers, etc. .D. (Fellow) OF FOHNS HOPKINS University, and student at Leipzig and Munich, broadly trained, with experience in the teaching of Ger- man and English, seeks position as Instructor in German at University or high-class Co'lege, or in literary or grammatical werk. Dissertation. and excellent references from leading Germanists of America and Germany on application. Only best post- tiona, with chance of advancement, will be considered. Dr. H., box 297, Johns Hopkins University, Baitimore, Maryland. EUROPE Ladies desiring to travel leisurely, comfortably, after crowded season, orto study Art, Music, Languages. References exchang- ed. Address Exrentencep Cuarrrone, the Nation. CASH PAID FOR EDUCATIONAL SERIALS Back numbers and volumes of Educational Review, Education, School Review, Barnard’s American Journal of Education, and others, wanted by THE BOSTON BOOK CO., 89 Francis St... Back Bay, Boston, Mass. Complete collated periodical sets for sale to libra- ries and institutions. Send list of wants. Financial. We buy and sel! bills of enchangse and r make cable transfers of noney on Europe, LETTERS Austrailia, and South Africa; ale» make or Hections and issue Commercial and CREDIT Travellers Credits available in all parts of International Cheques, Certificates of Deposit. BROWN BROTHERS & CO., NO. 60 WALL STREET, NEW YORK. a Slate ae ee ee ee ee eee trates be

Page 3

| | : : Aug. 31, 1905] _ The Nation. —ae RECENT PUBLICATIONS HISTORY Myers’ Ancient History (Revised Edition) A thorough revision of the most widely used text-book on the subject. Myers’ Medieval and Modern History Revised Edition Robinson’s History of Western Europe Robinson’s Readings in European History. Vol. /. ECONOMICS Ripley’s Trusts, Pools and Corporations A collection of important documents by economic and legal spectaliets bearing upon the greatest problem tn domestic politics now before the country White's Money and Banking Second Revised Edition In this revision the work has been practically rewritten to adapt It to the requirements of classroom use. A simple and direct road to @e sources of European history. READY IN SEPTEMBER Boynton’ sSchool Civics A simple, straightforward story of the development of governme nt ta Cheyney’s Short His- tory of England THE ELEMENTS OF BUSINESS LAW By ERNEST W. HUPPCUT Dean of the College of Law Cornell University Intended for students in commer Montgomery’s Stu- dents American His- tory (Revised Edition) cial courses tn high schoolsand col- leges, this book presents the leading LANCGCUAG ES principles of business law together with simple, concrete examples and Collar’s First Year roblems showing these principles n their application to commercial German transactions. meral and of our own Government TRADE UNIONISM AND n particular. LABOR PROBLEMS By G. R. COMMONS ENCLISH Professor of Political Economy in ia , the University of Wisconsin. Burke’s American — Taxation, Edited by This volume applies the “case . system” of the me schools to the James Hugh Moffatt. teaching of economics, The entire labor field ts covered by a series of actual cases with all the attendant circumstances. Specimen Letters, Ed- ited by Albert S. Cook and One year’s work in speaking, read- ing, and writing German. Allen R. Benham. Duerr’s Essentials of German Grammar Written with the hope of doing away with superfluous memorizing the book alms to develop the few great principles which are in constant evidence in Ger- man accidence and syntax. International Modern Language Series Eighty-seven volumes, presenting in convenient form the best works of modern foreign literature. RECENT ADDITIONS Guerlac’s Selections from Standard French Authors, ors Der Schusa von der Kanzel ( Haertel). Essays of Fielding. Edited by Gordon Hall Gerould. Sonnets of Shakespeare. Edited by H. C. Beeching. Elizabeth Barrett Browning. Selections. Edited by Elizabeth Lee. Principles of Argumentation, (Revised Edition.) By George P. Baker and H, B. Huntington For some years this has been the standard text tn the subject. The recent Moliere’s Le Malade Imaginaire (Olmstrad). comprehensive revision has made It stfli more adequate . Cc NEW YORK CINN & COMPANY, Publishers LONDON CROWELL’S BOOKS FOR SCHOOL USE ROGET'S THESAURUS of English Words and Phrases New Enlarged Edition. ay $1.50; with Index, $2.00. Half Calf, ‘$3. 00. “A dictionary of synonyms is a necessity to every student and writer. Roget's Thesaurus has been for many years regarded asthe one complete and perfect book of the kind in the language.” DURUY’S GENERAL HISTORY Translated and edited by Prof. E. A. Grosvenor. 25 colored maps. $2.00. “The most satisfactory world history of its kind in existence.” Public Opinion. DURUY’S ANCIENT HISTORY. laps, index, $1.00 DURUY’S MIDDLE AGES. Maps, index, $0.75 DURUY’S MODERN TIMES. Maps, index, $1.00 Being Parts I., Il. and Ill., of the ‘‘General History,’’ Edited by Prof. E. A. Grosvenor. “TI know of no historical handbook of equal comprehensiveness which is at once QA -to-date, so authoritative, and so attractively writ- ten,” —Wiiuiam F. Warren, President of Boston University. DURUY’S HISTORY OF FRANCE Translated and edited by Prof. J. F. Jameson. 12 colored maps. $2.00 “The best of allshort summaries of French history.""—ANprew D. Wuirte. AMERICAN CHARITIES By Amos G. Warner, Ph.D. Cloth, $1.75. “Asa manual on a subject of the most vital importance the book is ee and its value is hardly to be over-estimated."'—#oston Adver er SOCIALISM AND SOCIAL REFORM By Richard T. Ely, Ph.D., LL.D. Cloth, $1.50. “ Here for the first time the public is presented with a full and ac- curate account of socialism as it is." Chicago Times. SOCIAL THEORY By Johan Bascom. Cloth, $1.75. “ Very practical and ethically stimulating.”The Advance PUNISHMENT AND REFORMATION By FP. H. Wines, LL.D.- Cloth, $1.75. * Will educate its readers in a subject on which thre is, as yet, alt gether too much sentimentality on the one hand, and brutal severity on the other.”"—N. Y. Observer. CONTEMPORARY HISTORY By Prof. E. A. Grosvenor. Maps and Index, $1.00. “A compact and handy volume of reference,".Rev. of Reviews, IRRIGATION By FP. H. Newell, Chief U. S. Mydrographer. 156 Iifustrations. $2.00 net. (Postage, 2 cts “ Nothing on the subject has been published for years so effective clear, and popular.’’—The Literary World ECONOMICS OF FORESTRY By B. BE. Pernow, N. Y. State College of Forestry. $1.50 net. (Postage, 15 cta.) “No other book of like authority. To be commended inthe highest terms." — Philadelphia Public Ledger. THE POETRY OF BROWNING By Stoptord A. Brooke. $1.50 net. (Postage, IS cts) “The most satisfactory and stimulating criticism of this poet yet published."’— London Times. FRENCH LITERATURE By Ferdinand Brunetiere. Cloth, $2.00. “This is a real history, the best history of French literature in exis tence.’’—Prof, E. A. Grosvewnon. THE BIBLE AS LITERATURE By Drs. Moulton, Peters, Bruce, and ow introduction by Lyman Abbott. 1.50 “One of the most important analyses of the subject that has ever been attempted." —Commerciul Advertier. THOMAS Y. CROWELL @ CO., 426-8 West Broadway, New York _ ere

Page 4

a Vv The Nation. [Vol. 81, No. 2096 BOOKS FOR EDVCATORS A New Series of Life-Stories for Supplementary Reading and Nature Study work in the Elementary, Middle, and Upper Grades THE LIFE AND NATURE SERIES Selected, Edited, and Arranged by CHARLES WELSH 6 Ne is a series of Life Stories by several well-known writers for use in supplementary Reading and Nature Study in the grades, presenting their work without further editing or adapting than is necessary to fit them for the schools—a brief introduction, showing the place and use of each in the school-work, and a set of questions for the use of teachers in review work at the end of those books tnat need such. Notes of any kind have been omitted; they are not necessary in the books for the lower grades, and it is better to send the children in the higher grades to the dictionary and books of reference for the meaning of unfamiliar words and remote allusions than to make their work too easy by means of notes A complete prospectus will be sent upon request, TWO VOLUMES READY THE BEE PEOPLE ~~ LADY LEE %itScories 5'4 x 74g Inches, 175 Pages. 544 x 744 Inches, 175 Pages. 60 cents net. 75 cemts net, One Hundred and Seventy-five Dollars Represents the annual subscription cost of more than thirty English periodicals which tee drawn upon regularly for the weekly num- rs of The Living Age Readers of that magazine secure the most im- et and timely articles in this long hst of glish quarterlies, monthly reviews and magazines and literary and litical weekly journals, reproduced + a y and without abridgment. for only SIX DOLLARS a year, More than 3,300 pages each year. Trial sub —_ ptions, three months thirteen numbers, one ollar, THE LIVING AGE CO. 6 Beacon St. Boston, Mass. A SELECTION FROM The GREAT ENGLISH POETS With a Critical Introduction and an Essay on the Reading of English Poetry by SHERWIN CODY Editor of ‘' The World's Greatest Short Stories)’ “ The Best English Essays,” *The World's Great Orations,” Ete. "T’O MR. CODY must belong the credit of having discovered a new field in “practical”’ literature, the foresight of having realized its possibilities, and the industry to de velop it consistently and logically. His compilations have been remarkably successful both in a popular sense and with educators ; his books have been adopted in many lead- ing institutions, and to these especially the announcement of this new volume will be most welcome. It does not conflict with any existing anthology, and it is marked by all the dis- tinctive features which have made his other books so useful—the helpful general intro- duction, the discerning comments on the work of the great poets, and the instinctive good taste and editorial sense shown in the selections. 16mo,over 600 pages, printed on thin Bible paper. $1.00 net; delivered, $1.09 SCIENCE AND A FUTURE LIFE By Prof. JAMES H. HYSLU?, Ph.D., LL.D. $1.50 net. 12c. extra, postage. ased on Scientific Investigation of Psychic Phenomena. HERBERT B. TURNER & CO., Boston A.C.McCLURG @ CO., PUBLISHERS, CHICAGO. TIMELY CHILDREN’S BOOKS THE BIRD-WOMAN OF THE LEWIS AND CLARK EXPEDITION By KATHERINE CHANDLER 36 cts. In this centennial year of the Lewis and Clark Expedition, there are few books on this subject suited to young children. Every incident in this little volume is found in the Lewis and Clark Yourn:z/s and is woven into a continuous narrative, through which moves the picturesque figure of the Indian woman— the “wonderful Bird-Woman,” AMERICAN PIONEERS 65 cts, By WittiamM S. Mowry and BLANCHE S. Mowry The three great waves of American migration are dramatically pictured in these lives of the adventurous men and women whose careers have made American history--not only discoverers and patriots, but pioneers along the line of thought and education—lawyers, teachers, reformers, nurses. In bio- graphical form, the stories are full of action and anecdote, SILVER, BURDETT & COMPANY NEW YORK BOSTON CHICAGO WALT WHITMAN fo" this great writer is published in the Beacon Bio- graphiea Beautiful photogravure frontispiece. Handsomely bound fn cloth. Price 75 cents net. SMALL, MAYNARD & COMPANY 31 Arrow Street Cambridge, Mass. F. W. CHRISTERN (DYRSEN & PFEIFFER, Successors), 16 West 33d St., opposite the “Waldorf,” New York Importers of Fore Books, Agents for the lead Paris Publishers, ‘auchnitz’s British authors. Teu ner’s Greek and Latin Classics. Catal e of stock matied on demand. New books received from Paris and Leipzig as soon as issued. READ y HUGO MUNSTERBERG’S The Eternal Life on ours The Bess of Little Arcady I OTHROP By HARRY Leon WILSON Postpaic, $1.50. — REE Book Li« LIST A —4 for e's F Le tea LIBRARY RESEARCH Topics of all kinds in any language looked up in the Boston and Harvard Libraries for scholars, writers, and others. Abstracts, copies, translations, and bibliographies made, Prooef-reading and re- vision of = ee oer university and library references . BUOKINGHAM, 06 Chestnut Street, am ain. RUSSIA AS IT REALLY IS By CARL JOUBERT J. B. LIPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia Hurlbut’s Story of the Bible Send for Illustrated Descriptive Ciroular. THE JOHN C. WINSTON CO, Philadelphia S. CLARK, 218 Washington 3 Street, Peekekill, N. Y., “dealer in Americana. ogue ‘or the asking. Resorts. TWILIGHT PARK IN THE CATSKILLS Seven room cottage, fully furnished; rent $60, for September, ©. F. WINGATE, Haines Falls, N. Y.

Page 5

ar I hte aetien Sear whi ee a Se oe AR eee cael, Oh er a GAB oon a ee OO Pak Macatee 6K: a Aug. 31, 1905] The Nation. —_ hej CROWELL’S POPULAR SERIES of CLASSICS HANDY VOLUME CLASSICS ASTOR EDITION OF POETS For Schools wr seaias Pocket Edition at a Prominent A Sehool Principal's and Colleges for School Use ' f Professor says Opinion © , 7a ile a ‘lam pleased to say we are 94 VotumEs, 12m0, CLorH pe seet delighted with the 168 VotumeEs. 18m0, CrorH highly satisfied with them Edition henceforward in my Typography. ye = classes. The books are so comiaed make — welt bound that they may umes almost ideal for class List Price ’ - 60c. = — a part of any stu- List Price - - 35c. of y 1 ‘to ‘that | ent’s library when he has pon . . » . Price to Schools - 40c, ceased to use them in the Price to Schools - 25c. emas ~~ Eh. . ft, a class-room, a * series ASTOR PROSE SERIES SHAKESPEARE’S WORKS THE BEST BOOKS Glossaries, Lists of Variorum Readings, and selected Criticisms, by Cuartorre Porterand Heven A. Cirarke, Editors of the Camber THE in all prose literature, printed on good paper and neatly thee a: s oe | och eget j ten ° . . “ ) indy volumes, size x64. Sole bound, with frontispieces and title-pages printed in two fate og Cloth, 75e; limp leather, $1 per vol ume colors, Cloth, assorted colors, 322 volumes. 12mo. Phe falas ealadads: tre veal A MipsomMer Niouts Dreame Per Volume, 60c. Loves Larour’s Lost Tue Comepig or Errors Tue MercHant or VENICE Price to Schools, 40c. ; MacBETH Jutius CaAgsAR HAML«t It will prove, 1am sure, the most desirable edition which has yet | *—F ROM ‘s published.” —De. Hiram Corson “ The best books for the money published in England or America.’ a CUSTOMER. THOMAS Y. CROWELL & CO., —_— 426-8 West Broadway, New York The Second Educational Number of THE NATION Will be issued on September 7 and will reach the professors in the leading colleges and academic institutions in the country. Four thousand extra copies of this issue will be sent to persons interested in educational affairs in addition to those sent to regular subscribers. This issue will be sent to teachers of Philosophy, Physics and Chemistry, Mathematics, and Natural Sciences. Copy for this number should be received on or before September 5. ie. THE NATION Publication Office, 206-210 Broadway, New York City.

Page 6

The Nation. [Vol. 81, No. 2096 LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO.’S NEW BOOKS WORKS BY WILLIAM MORRIS The Earthly Paradise: A Poem. By WILLIAM Morris. A New Edition in large) type, with an In- troduction by Mr. J. W. Mackail, and a photogravure portrait hitherto unpublished. In four volumes, crown 8vo, cloth, gilt top (boxed), $5.00. This Edition may also be had in separate parts, bound in gray paper boards, cloth backs, as follows: | Part VIII.—Tae Story or AconTius 4ND CyDIPPE. Tue Man Wao Part l. Protoeve: Tae Wanperers. Crown 8vo. Net $0.36. sant Il A ‘s Race. Tar Maw Bory To pe Kina, Net $0.96. ran a oe # 7 $0 | Never Lavonxep Acan. Net $0.36. Part IIl.—Tasr Doom or Kine Acatsive, Tae Proup Kine. Net $0.36. | Part IX.—Tue Story or Ruoporr. Tae Lovers or Gupruy, Net $0.75. Tue WRITING OWN THE Part 1V.—Tuse Srory or Cuvrip anp Psycne. ’ Imace. Net $0.96 | . | Pant X.—Tae Gotpen Appies, Tae Fosrerine or Astave, Net $0.36. Parr \ Tue Love or Avcestia. Tar Lapyor tae Lanp. Tas Son or Cresus. Tas Warcutne or tae Fatcon. Net $0.34 Part XI.—BeLierorpnon at Arcos. Tue Rivne Given To Venus Net . 0,36, Parr VI.—Pyemation ann THelImMace. Ocrer tHe Dang. Net $0.36 $ EPILoGvuE Part XIL—BeLLeRopHoN in Lycia. Toe Hit or Venus. 75 lus LAND East oF THe Sun anp West | L’Envor Net $0.7 Parr VIl.—Tae Dearu or Paris or THE Moon Vet $0.6 Plain, which has been also called the Land of Living Men or the Acre of the Undying. By [Longmans’ Class Books of English Literature.] Square cloth. $0.50. [Long- The Story of the Glitterin WILLIAM Morris. With Introduction and Glossary. With Introduction and Notes. The Man Born to Be King (from “The Earthly Paradise”), By WILLIAM Morris. mans’ Class Books of English Literature.] Crown 8vo. Cloth. $0.50. By WILLIAM Morris. Cheap Edition. Feap, 8vo. 256 pages. $0.75. The Defence of Guenevere and other Poems. Octavo, cloth, gilt. $2.50. Complete in one volume. The Earthly Paradise. List of Works by William Morris will be sent upon request. A full New York LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., 93 Fifth Avenue, THE CLARENDON PRESS The Elements of Railway Economics *The Railways and the Traders,” &c. Svo, cloth, 70c. W. M.A era, au f rhe allways of England An Intelligent man, if) supply bis mind for a few hours to the study of this little book, may have a clearer understanding of the problem of railway ‘ nanifested t f our public speakers and newspaper editors. Mr. Acworth has explained a difficult problem with such admirable luc idity as wit! popula iprehension, and he would have been censurable had he hid his light ander abushel. While his book may have been intended for «at Che London Sehool of Reonomiles, and while bis {Mlastrations and applications are primarily English, the American people stand In especial need of its us it will be during the coming years.” The Evening Post, May 8, (905 Minor Poets of the Caroline Period. Vol. |. « Pt sronnida ~y? KE ngland’s Jubiice, Benlowe’s Theophila, and the Poems of Katherine Philips and Patrick Hannay. Edited by ‘ Cha erlayne A cloth Specimens of the Elizabethan Drama With Introductions and Notes by W. H. Writtams, M.A. Crown Svo, cloth, $1.90, t l to Shirk A.D, 1580-A.D. 1642 me a of the Rood tributed to Cynewulf English Language and Literature in Yale University. Extra Edited by ALagrt 8. Cook, Professor of the 1 hog oer “Ungebetene Gast, and Other Plays Extra f'cap Svo. cloth, 60 cents, ” ote vl Beries of Short German Plays hoocnnmeim Oxford Modern French Series. New Volumes UNE HAINE A BORD. By de ta Landelie, Edited by R, BE. A. Carasex, Instructor in French in H.M.8. Britannia, LES NORMANDS EN ANGLETERRE ET BN PRANCE. By Thierry. Edited by A. H.Ssrrna. 60 cents. LE SERMENT. By Jules David. Edited by Chore Hueon, Assistant Mistress in Exeter High School for Girls. 40 cents. VOYAGE EN ESPAGNE. By Gautier. Edited by Genato Goovricn, Modern Language Master, St. Mark's School, Windsor. UNE TENEBREUSE APPAIRE. By Batzac. Edited by Mantes Pécninet. © cents. {LSO PUBLISHED BY HENRY FROWDE: 75 cents. With a Map. 60 cents, Author and Printer \ Guide for Authors, Editors, Printers, Correctors of the Press, Courpositors and Typists With Full List of Abbreviations. An Attempt to Codify the Best lypographical Practices of the Pres Day. By F. Howarp Cottine. Crown Svo, cloth, $2.25. OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS, American Branch, 91-95 Fifth Avenue, New York

Page 7

The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, AUGUST 31, 1905. The Week. To Japan her meed of praise. She has magnanimously won a moral vic- tory over herself worthy to rank with those compassed by her arms on. land and sea. She has revoked her untenable claims, though underwritten by her} British ally as wholly reasonable, and apparently regarded by President Roose- velt, in his endeavor to effect a com- promise, as at least inevitable and ir- resistible. Japan may be thankful that Russia did resist, and that the good old rules, “They that take the sword shall perish by the sword” and “Those who dance must pay the piper,” are still operative. We need not repeat the rea- sens we advanced last week why the peace now being formulated at Ports- mouth is a genuine peace, and not a breeder of fresh conflicts in years to come. Each side sponges the slate, and the high contracting parties are not the same who began their stupendous trial of strength at Port Arthur and on the Yalu River. The Russia of February, 1904, is dead, thanks to the happy co- incidence of pressure from within and without; and with this new Russia it should be Japan’s policy to come into friendly relations. She is a natural ally, and never more so than now, when her sea power is shattered and her mo- tive for making hostile demonstrations in Far Eastern waters is removed. The English alliance is factitious, based on fear and hatred of the old Russia, and not on any special regard for Japan. It may have been renewed, as rej drt- ed, but it is hollow. Japan, like the re- public of Venice, has cast the die and committed herself to expansion on the mainland, where to be on good terms with her mighty neighbors is surely the part of wisdom. The United States has the honor of be- ing the scene of this ever-memorable peace-making. The President has the personal renown of having brought about the conference; but too little is known of the circumstances of his intervention. He will be lauded by the multitude for having assisted in breaking the deadlock, but he entered upon this delicate task in a manner to impugn his impartiality, and with a scheme which had no ehance of acceptance. On this it is not neces- sary to dwell now. The rejoicing of the hour is, that further slaughter has been averted, and that the Old World has composed its differences in the New. If we could hope that this event marks the last great war between nations calling themselves civilized, then there is no holiday in our calendar which we might not exchange for the date of ratification —not even the Fourth of July. “There never was an hour in all our splendid history,” said the ardent Mr. Fairbanks on August 23, “when there was a more acute moral sense among the great masses of our people and more uprightness in their relations of life than there is to-day. There is a widespread determination among the people that those who pollute the law shall be compelled to answer for it.” Participating in these sentiments as he undoubtedly does, there must be some unpleasant features about the Vice-Presi- dent’s position. For instance, a new charge has been made against Senator Burton, of taking, with a brother who is not remembered at Washington, $14,000 for representing the Chickasaw Indians before the Interior Department. Then a further addition is made to the roll of Senators “under fire’ by the reported discovery that Senator Hopkins of IIli- nois received from the sanitary district of Chicago fees between two and three times as large as the law allowed. In two years, to be specific, he was voted $24,034, although the statute limited the compensation of any one attorney to $5,- 000 per annum. These may be called purely technical offences, as were those charged in the original prosecution of Burton. But there could not be better examples of that “thought of personal aggrandizement” so deplored by the Vice-President, who has to preside over the deliberations of these men, and show them that “courtesy” to omit which in the Senate is worse than the crimes of any of its members. a Secretary Bonaparte is by no means so anxious as Van Buren to waik in the footsteps of his predecessor. An- other order of Paul Morton’s he has just reversed, so as to invite competition from Canadian railways in carrying na- val supplies across the continent. Mr. Morton, with a stern patriotism which his railroad friends could not too high- ly admire, had ordered that contracts should be made only with lines that ran “exclusively in American territory.” He could not bear to think of ammunition and stores destined for American ships in the Pacific being sullied by crossing Canadian soil. But Secretary Bona- parte, as a less high-soaring but more business-like official, was desirous of getting his freight bills as low as pos- sible, and so opened the bidding to all hands. Nor was he to be moved from his purpose when some able strategists employed by the American roads went to him and pointed out the grave danger that, if naval supplies were forwarded over foreign railways, “there would be an opportunity for foreigners to obtain information regarding them"! Mr Bonaparte shouldered even that awfui responsibility. People will more than half believe that the Republicans are afraid of los- ing Ohio if Gov. Herrick keeps on flying signals of distress. In addition to his attempt to dissociate himself from Boss Cox of Cincinnati, he has now gone on his knees to Senator Foraker, implor ing him to come and stump the State. Be it remembered that the Dick-Her rick-Cox machine has been fighting and snubbing Foraker in the most open and cruel way. After he had said that, in his opinion, the renomination of Gov. Herrick would be unwise, the smug lit- tle organization took pains to show ita hatred for the Senator, and its con tempt for his political influence. But it is one thing to carry the primaries and control the State convention tri- umphantly, quite another to produce the necessary votes at the polls. As the lat- ter task must so soon be undertaken, Senator Foraker has been sent for to come to the help of the alarmed bosses We presume that a pledge to support him for reélection to the Senate mist be involved, so that Ohio may yet be spared the unspeakable disgrace of see ing Boss Cox fulfil his ambitions and become Senator Cox. Though somewhat overshadowed by the contest for the Senatorship between Gov. Montague and Senator Martin, the campaign for the nomination for Gov- ernor at the Virginia Democratic pri- mary, which was held on August 22, was of unusual interest. Representative Claude A. Swanson, the successful can- didate, had to some extent thrown his political fortunes in with Senator Martin, and the party organization undoubtedly helped them both to win. But Swanson had also struck out on local issues that made a strong appea! to the young and progressive element. He was first to take up the demand for more State aid to education, pledging himself to do his best to turn an ex- pected surplus of three-quarters of a million dollars next year over to the schools. As the first test of the new pri- mary law, under a Constitution that has practically eliminated the negro and many ignorant white voters, the resuit is encouraging. The “white aristoc- racy of electors,” as a Richmond corre- spondent of the Boston Transcript a few days ago predicted they would, “looked a little cross-eyed” at the candidacy of Lieut.-Gov. Willard, which was thought

Page 8

174 to be based largely upon a rich man’s desire for political honors, while Judge Mann's appeal as the enforcer of the Mann temperance law, was too limited t» produce any great effect. The diatribe which Atlanta’s Mayor launched against Chicago's on Thurs day before the League of American Mu nicipalities was properly ignored by the delegates Yet his wild charges were not much more ridiculous than the views of those who see in Chicago's present situation a vindication of the municipal ownership idea. The time to draw con clusions from an experiment is when it begins to show results, and even if all were progressing smoothly in Chi- cago no one could reasonably have ex- pected anything decisive in less than six months. As a matter of fact, aside from a few preliminary victories in the courts, Mayor Dunne’s plans have not by any means gone smoothly. Condi- tions have forced the Mayor, who made his campaign on an extremely distinctive ind positive platform, into substantial- ly the position occupied not only by the rival candidate, Mr. Harlan, but by his predecessor, Mayor Harrison, as well Hie is now doubtful of the wisdom of condemnation proceedings to secure the unexpired street railway franchises, and s confining his proposals to those lines on which the franchises have already run out In other words, instead of treating the traction system as a unit, the city will enter the field as a com- petitor of the existing lines, but with a sadly incomplete system. This system will have to be built by private capital in any case. It includes ‘70 miles of track, and, roughly, covers the city. The Mayor himself considers it “a satisfactory municipal system of treet-car lines.” But it has been promptly pointed out that several of the treets embraced within this system, ome very important to it, were also included by Judge Grossecup'’s recent de- cision in the list of streets where the franchises remain in foree until 1958 even walving this point, the result will Tr m the Chicago Daily News puts tt, that “the double fare will then become in ail quarters of the city a prominent feature of travel between one’s home and one’s place of business. In short, to simplify the traction ques tion, Mayor Dunne would make it more complex. To wipe out existing difficul- ties, he would make more difficulties. To cure the present bad service, he would invent new abominations.” This, after ull, may not be quite a fair argument for Chicago. The city made up tte mind to endure herole treatment, if neces ary; professed itself to be perfectly willing to undergo hardship to the de- sired end. But other cities should no- ‘tice Just how heroic Chicago's treatment The Nation. [ Vol. 31, No. 2096 is likely to be. And, when all is said and done, that city’s opinion on the gen- eral desirability of municipal ownership is worth no more to-day than the views on warfare of a recruit who has just taken his first enlistment papers. Mr. Jerome will probably be confirm- ed in his unwillingness to be a candi- date for Mayor by the evidence of di- vided counsels in the City Committee of the Citizens’ Union. One-third of its number voted on Thursday against rec- ommending Mr. Jerome’s nomination. Now it is plain that he is in no sense an active candidate. He has not said, as no public-spirited citizen ought to say, that no great emergency could arise which would make it his duty to stand for the Mayoralty. Yet his at- titude and peculiar position are such that nothing but an imperious and unit- ed demand could swerve him from his announced plan of offering himself to the people for another term as District Attorney. It appears, however, that the Citizer.s’ Union is far from being of one mind on that subject. The Republican organization would pretty clearly ac- cept Jerome for Mayor only as a bitter dose, or with reservation of all rights to vote for him or not as it pleased thereafter. At present, therefore, we do not seem to have the political con- ditions which would make the nomiua- tion of Mr. Jerome for the Mayoralty either possible (from his point of view) or desirable. That anxious search has to be made for a commanding anti-Tammany candi- date, is a biting comment upon the kind of men our party politics is breeding. Is it not extraordinary that, in a city of 4,000,000 people, there is not to-day one man who, by conspicuous public ser- vice, by proved integrity and capacity, by hold upon popular confidence and admiration, is spontaneously turned to in such a crisis as the present? In no other field is New York so barren. If it were a question of finding a leader in some great financial undertaking, in a vast engineering work, in scientific in- vestigation, in art, in learning, in phil- anthropy, dozens of names would leap to the lips. It is only in politics that the careful selection of small men has final- ly eliminated nearly all the towering fig- ures. The hope of better conditions, in this particular, is one of the things held out to us by Mr. Jerome's independent candidacy. If he succeeds, it will be a signal to men of generous nature and honorable ambitions the country over to come forward and seek that public ser- vice for which they are fitted, but from which the boss system excludes them— except at the cost of intolerable indigni- tles and loss of manhood. The answer of the Equitable Life As- surance Society to the suit brought by Attorney-General Mayer is a virtual ad- mission of all the serious charges against the management. The counsel of the Equitable frankly confesses the misconduct of the officials, and prays that they be compelled to restore the money which they have wasted, lost, or stolen. This statement removes the last vestige of doubt as to the scope of the legislative investigation. Members of the committee have been reported as saying that they were aiter “conditions, not men.’ True, the committee is not a grand jury; but in this instance it cannot even begin to uncover the condi- tions without uncovering the men who created them. People have a right to know how much of the looting is charge- able to the greed of Alexander, Hyde, Depew, and others high in office, and how muci to political intrigue; to know, for example, who got that mysterious sum of $685,000. We cannot tell how and why the policyholders of the Equi- table were robbed without telling who robbed them. Whether the trail leads to the Republican National Committee or to the State Republican machine and Edward H. Harriman and Benjamin B. Odell, jr., it must be followed to the very end. In the Oneida district of Pennsylvania on August 23, 800 miners were sus- pended because they “knocked off” work on the occasion of John Mitchell's visit, in order to give him an elaborate re- ception. President Mitchell denounces this as “tyrannical,” and promises that the “rights” of the men shall be pro- tected. On what theory the privilege of parading before the union leader during the working day can be called a “right,” we are at a loss to see, unless, indeed, Mitchellism is a religion, and the sus- pension of these men interferes with “the free exercise thereof.” Just so a Mohammedan’'s employer must allow him certain periods for prayers. Or, possi- bly, it may be argued that the clause of the 1903 agreement providing that “no suspension of work shall take place by lockout or strike, etc.,”’ implies that suspension of work shall take place for other reasons, such as a union jamboree. Natural as is the desire of the mine workers to do honor to a beloved and successful chief, it is incompatible with the commonest rules of industrial or- ganization to stop work for this pur- pose whenever the spirit moves. John Mitchell at Tamaqua on Sunday, explaining his demand for recognition of the union, said that he had found to his satisfaction that there could be no “permanent industrial peace’’ without it. What is his view, then, of the present conditions in the mining region, where the Board of Conciliation has worked for the last two years with conspicuous

Page 9

Aug. 31, 1905] success? The award of the anthracite coal strike commission in 1900 express- ly adjudged and awarded: “That no per- son shall be refused employment or in any way discriminated against on ac- count of membership or non-member- ship in any labor organization. . % Certainly the anthracite region has never borne outwardly a more peace- ful aspect than in the last two years and a half. Differences were never set- tled with less friction. Probably the con- dition of the miners themselves was never so good, even if the steady em- ployment at the mines has enabled the operators to provide themselves with stores of coal against a future strike. But all these considerations are as no- thing beside the fact that the union must have something specific to fight for. Membership can be drummed up at the promise of a battle when a mere- ly prudential organization among this class of workmen would be in danger of falling to pieces. Mr. Mitchell may reiterate that his mission is “one of peace”; but the knowledge that his fol- lowing grows in times of strife but de- clines when things are quiet, does not naturally encourage the leader to play the part of pacificator. We have been almost ashamed to com- ment upon the outcry in the South over Booker Washington's having sat down to dinner with Mr. Wanamaker in a hotel. One hates to believe that so many of his fellow-countrymen can be _ so childish. We had also hoped that South- ern people had taken to heart the les- son of their silly attacks upon Presidert Roosevelt for eating with Mr. Wash- ington. But here comes the Charlotte Observer asserting that “Mr. Wanamak- er’s offence is greater than Mr. Roose- This, it is explained, was be- cause a dinner in a public room is “purely a social function,” and “a negro was unmistakably on a social equality.” Mr. Washington, the Observer admits, ‘s “a good negro; more than that, he’s a great man,” but still, the purity of the race, ete., etc. And it is men capable of such sentiments who complain if they are called backward and provincia! in setting up standards which the rest of the civilized world has outgrown. velt’s.” The advocates of an _ international system for collecting agricultural statis- tics and issuing crop reports have made the most of this summer's cotton-report scandals. David Lubin of California, speaking before the Statistical Institute at London, declared that, statistical science having secured a stable medium of exchange, its next task should be to “eliminate from dangerous price fluctuations the most important things of exchange, the things known as the staples of agriculture.” Continuing, he reasons; “Under the proposed Par. riculture it will be the farmers of the world and the consumers of the world who will determine the price between them.” But will not the chief tug of war take place between the various crop-producing areas? If our Southern States can be roused to wrath by our own cotton estimate when they consider it too large, what will be their feel- ings when such a bear report emanates from an international bureau in which cotton-buying England and Germany have a hand? Imagine the influences that would affect the inter- national grain market in such a Presi- dential 1896, low prices for farmers’ products might have turn- ed the election the other way. Whether the substitution international jea- lousies and rivalries for the specula- tor’s wiles will greatly improve matters, is a point which the champions of the suggested system need to consider. seek to year as when of While we are palavering about a trade agreement with Germany, France has gone to work and made one with Rus- sia. .The two situations are not unlike. France takes large of raw materials from Russia, as Germany does from the United States. Something like $40,000,000 a year of Russian lumber and flax and cereals and oil enter France. French exports to Russia, like Germany's to us, are mostly of manu- factured goods, and are comparatively small in amount. About $9.000,000 was tue total last year. Of course, the thing the French commissioners in St. Peters- burg had to debate about was, not the desire of the two peoples to exchange goods at a profit but the ef- forts of the two Governments to make trade difficult--that is, the tariff. The Russian scale of customs duties is high and advancing. The French have their maximum and minimum tariffs, and their sacred protectionist system as well as we. But an agreement, so it is reported, was come to; tariff barriers are to be mutually lowered. Protection is mighty, but business is mightier. When American business men really be- come angry, and demand that the tariff get out of the way, they will be sur- prised to see how meekly it will take its hat and go. quantities to each, Dr. Karl Peters, who recently return- ed to Germany from his South African expedition, is more than ever convinced that that part of the world was never intended for white men, even though there are now railways and towns where Livingstone found a wilderness to ex- plore. He has expressed his opinion that the whole of South Africa is unsuit- able for agricultural purposes of a per- manent kind, and that therefore the scheme of the “United States of South Africa” will remain a dream, a6 the 175 country, being a mining region, has a too fluctuating populatidm. It has come more and more markedly a min er’s camp; and long the of diamonds, gold, copper, iron, petroleum, etc., lasts, it will be in part a white man’s country—after that, it revert to the dark Already so-called Ethiopian movement, with the motto, “The black continent for the blaeks,” is making headway rapidly. The champions of it are mostly ministers of be 80 as supply coal, will races the the Abyssinian Church, and the Zulu press is used as well as the pulpit, with results which Dr. Peters calls “simply astonishing.”” The treatment of the blacks by the English, with their so called “contract" system, resulting in conditions not unlike slavery, is as oj) on the flames. Noteworthy also is the growth of the Asiatic element in Africa Hindus and Chinese every where There are already entire towns of Hin dus, and the suburbs of Capetown and are Johannesburg are Hindu Dr. Peters sees in this invasion “the first grea reaction of the temperance nation against the alcoho!l-drinking Euro peans,” providing a rich fleld for future conflicts. Sir Martin Conway makes an appeal for contributions from the United States, as well as England, in aid of th: newly formed “League for the Preserva tion of the Beauty of Switzerlan!t.” {t aim is announced to be to prevent that “building of hotels, making of railroads enclosure of waterfalls,” by of which many of the spots in the Alps are in danger of los ing a part of their charm. Sir Martin remarks that the Swiss imagine that all that has been done is etc., reason most beautiful “agreeable to the tourist-crowd,” but he warns them that they are killing the goose that lays the golden hotel-bills. Just what is to be done, however, he does not indicate. His real complaint, we suspect, he does noi openly state. It that there should be a tourist-crowd at all. When people say natural beauty, they an exclusive opportunity enjoy it And there is much to be said for that view. How can a landscape seem truly beautiful with a group of those German parvenus in the foreground whom /'lir gende Blitter so loves to caricature’ What mountain or valley can really pear of unsullied beauty when beset by agile Americans who haye been “doing some jumping” through Italy, and are row furiously covering their Switzer land, travelling every night, and star ing nature out of countenance day? Modern social conditions really at the root of Sir Martin wav'’s trouble, and they changed. The man who having beautiful nature all to himeelf has, in these days, either to “git up airly,” or to retire to a more and mor’ inaccessible peak in Darien is some mean to every are Con be upon cannot insists

Page 10

The Nation. [Vol. 81, No. 2096 176 GOVERNMENTAL AUTOMATISM. The demand of the times is for graft- proof systems of administration. Cor- vinced by sad experience that untrust- worthy men will get into office, and de- spairing of raising the standard of pub- lic morality, the aim of a certain school of statesmen seems to be to invent plans that can be administered by dis- honest men, if worst comes to worst, without serious harm to the public in- terest. A minor, though very apt, illus- tration of this tendency came last week from South Carolina. A legislative in- vestigating committee has discovered that the local agents of the State Dis- pensary have sought and received large sums of money and costly presents from brewers and distillers for putting their particular brands of liquor on sale. Sen- ator Tillman, father of the system, prac- tically confesses the abuse, and offers a remedy. Is it the appointment of bet- ter men for local dispensers? No; but the elimination of all the commercial brands of beer and whiskey at once, by having the State bottle its own liquors. “If we have to discriminate,” runs the argument, in effect, “dishonesty creens in. Let us, therefore, give everybodys the same thing, whether it is what he really wants or not.” There is hardly a line of administra- tion in which a similar theory cannet be traced. The matter of buying sup- plies is the most conspicuous instance. The Post-Office has to fasten its letter- boxes somehow. It picks out a partic- ular box-fastener, and we have Machen and Lorenz and the Groffs to deal with. The Navy Department wants submarine boats, and, because there is more than one kind, we have a scandal in Congress. But the statutes try hard to minimize the possibilities of such happenings. Every man trained in private business methods who enters Government ser- vice chafes under the necessity of ad- vertising for bids for every trivial lot of supplies, and taking the lowest, what- ever his private opinion may be of the bidders. Read the restrictions which every city charter or administrative act throws about the purchase of patented articles to see how much thought has been given to heading off corruption. In administration, every detail tends to reduce itself toa hard-and-fast form- ula. The efforts of Mr. Madden, the Third Assistant Postmaster-General, to purge the lists of publications entitled to the second-class rate probably re- sulted in as much ill-feeling and re- crimination as any bit of governmental activity In recent years. A librarian or a buyer for home perusal has little doubt as to what publications are “legitimate” and what features objec- tionable. Yet the efforts of the Depart- ment to draw the line led it into all manner of difficulties, with unreason- able and inconsistent rulings. If condi- tions are becoming more satisfactory, it is because absolutely definite rules as to sample copies, premiums, prize offers, ete., are being worked out. It has been assumed by many stu- dents of the railway-rate problem that Government regulation would mean, within a short time, a system of zone or distance tariffs, not because this is de- sired in itself, but because of the sheer inability of any commission to stand the pressure of rival localities. Favoritism and inflexibility are thought of as the solealternatives. Some of the safeguards alluded to have been tested by experience, and no one would dream of upsetting them. The merit system itself rests on the same fundamental theory. But in the general effort to make laws that are virtually self-enforcing, there may be danger of forgetting the fact that we are merely exchanging specific responsi- bility of the executive for general re- sponsibility of the legislature. And the legislature itselt has wrestled just as hopelessly with the everlasting diffi- culty. The case of national pensions con- tains the whole story. Our system was demoralized first by the difficulty of de- ciding whether admitted disabilities were or were not traceable to the war. So Congress in 1890 said: “Never mind whether the veteran's ills are due to the war or not. Give him the pension if he is disabled.” But “disability”—a term most elastically defined—had still to be discovered, until the famous Or- der No. 78 said, in effect: “Never mind whether he is disabled or not. Give him a pension if he is sixty-two years old.” Congress retained the right to alleviate the harshness of existing law by pass- ing private pension bills for those whose needs the statute did not precisely meet. These private bills are defended as a sort of system of equity, tempering the rigors of the law, giving more heed to all the circumstances of the individual case. Yet what is the result? Simply that every Congressman or Senator is told how many such bills he can have in a session. Injustices may cry to heaven in one district, while another may not have a surviving Unionist un- pensioned; but the quota rule prevails. The whole practice of legislative log- rolling has its origin in this same weak- ness of officialdom—confessed inability to exercise wise discrimination. Con- gress as a whole could not muster the courage to say squarely: “Mud Hen Creek has no commercial importance and no possibilities, and doesn’t deserve a dollar of the public money.” So every other member claimed as much river and harbor money as the Mud Hen Creek statesman, and some of it went for extremely good purposes. And, if the shameless scramble for “pork” has largely been done away with—a most important reform for which the present chairman of Rivers and Harbors de- serves much credit—it has been by lay- ing down hard-and-fast tests which any stream must meet in order to receive improvement. After all is said and done, we must trust somebody in the public service. If we reduce the duties of an execu- tive officer to the mere application of a yardstick to the matters that come in his way, we are simply transferring our faith to the authority which provides the yardstick. Government by the meth- ods of the slot-machine, though the log- ical end of the attempts to make Gov- ernment functions automatic, might not prove to be the best thing in the world. REFORM BY PRECEPT. We are in the habit of looking to the annual address of the President of the American Bar Association for direct dealing with the moral and social prob- lems of the hour. Professor Tucker did not, last week, depart from this good precedent. In one passage of his speech he took up specifically President Roose- velt’s Harvard complaint against those members of the bar who, for great fees, prostitute their great abilities to the service of unscrupulous wealth in the working out of “bold and ingenious schemes to evade the laws.” Partially admitting that the charge 1s well found- ed, Professor Tucker proposed a remedy for the evil. It is the adoption in all law schools of “an enlarged and com- prehensive course in ‘legal ethies,’ to be taught by men of lofty ideals.” With all respect, we submit that this is quite to mistake both our malady and its cure. We are not perishing for lack of knowledge. Every shyster law- yer who extorts an illegal fee from a poor and ignorant woman, as well as every “leader of the bar” who gets rich by devising methods for wealthy scoun- drels to cheat and steal and yet go un- whipped of the law, knows perfectly that he is doing a disreputable thing. He does not need to be told that his acts are as repugnant to the ethics of his profession as they are to elemen- tary morality. It is not ignorance that we have to attack, but moral perversity. Motives, passions, desires are at fault, and social standards are awry, not in- tellectual perceptions. And whenever a society is suffering, as ours is to-day, from topsy-turvy morals and blinding ambitions, it cannot be won back to clear honesty and true estimates of life by the exhortations of a thousand pul- pits or of ten thousand professors. Education as of itself a moralizer of whole peoples is no longer preached by men who try to keep their brains clear of cobwebs. Against Professor Tucker, we cite Prof. William James: “Fifty years ago, the schools were supposed to free us from crimes and unhappiness; but we do not indulge in such sanguine hopes to any such extent to-day.” And in the address from which we quote,

Page 11

Aug. 31, 1905] Fae seen: 177 this loyal son of Harvard added—never more loyal than when he said it— “There is not a public abuse on the whole Eastern coast which does not re- ceive the enthusiastic approval of some Harvard graduate.” Let Lodge, let Penrose, let James H. Hyde deny it! Young men are not to be fooled by mere words. You may tell them in the law schools till you are gray and bald and bent that the legal profession ought to be a beacon of the purest honor, a bulwark of morality and the saving salt of the commonwealth; but so long as students see a Depew pocketing unearn- ed and suspicious thousands, yet ac- counted one of the most successful men of his generation, honored by State, Church, and University, your moral plat- itudes will have no more effect upon them than the idle wind. Not what you say, but what he does, will sway the youthful mind. We had, on the same day with Presi- dent Tucker’s address, a striking ac- knowledgment of the futility of preach- ing the purest moral and religious doc- trines to men off whose hearts they re- bound. The Rev. Dr. Morgan, the elo- quent and devout English clergyman, left behind him as he sailed a searching re- buke of American church-goers. He had detected an alarming lack of infiu- ence upon their daily lives of the solemn truths which they professed to believe. Creed and practice are not at all articu- lated. Business men sit twice a Sun- day under the tremendous utterances of prophet and apostle, only to go out and all the week cheat, if not with holiness and zeal, at least with entire uncon- sciousness that their religion has any- thing to do with the exchange and the counting-room. Lord Melbourne himself could not be more indignant than they at the pretence that Christianity has any right to invade private life. And we know how shocked politicians always are when any minister essays the Nathan role with them. They make literally their own the old complaint of the satir- ist, Bramston: “‘Not long since parish clerks with saucy airs Apply’d King David’s Psalms to State affairs.’’ But if precept thus has so little re- forming power, where shall we turn for help? To example. Let Messieurs the great lawyers commence. If they would reéstablish noble ideals in their profes- sion, let them display them in their own persons, rather than urge law students to do as they say, not as they act. Let the leaders of the bar assert their leader- ship in the exemplification of unbending probity, scorn of rich men bearing bribes, eagerness to ostracise or chastise every trickster and money-grabber in their profession, readiness to volunteer their services in defence of public rights, em- phasis upon the rewards of a good con- science and approval by the discerning rather than upon $100,000 retainers and being let into the “good things” of the bad men they help steer clear of jall. We would point also to the silent work- ing out of the great moral laws which the Creator has written in the heart of man and stamped upon human society. The true standards have a terrible way of asserting themselves in the lives even of men who snap their fingers at them. Awful warnings are, from time to time, given to a society in which morals seem hopelessly confused. The sight of emi- nent evildoers caught at last in the ma- chinery of the mills of the gods avails more than all the moral teachers put to- gether. It is Providence itself doing the teaching and flogging at home. It is in this view that we have to regard our late exposures of lights of the law and paragons of society and pillars of the church, as immensely tonic. We firmly believe that the present plight of Sena- tor Depew is a greater and more impres- sive contribution to “legal ethics” than could be made by all the lecturers in all the law schools talking moral abstrac- tions for a lifetime. 4 THE LAST OF ADDICKS. The news that J. Edward Addicks is disposed of as a political factor in Del- aware, now carried beyond ordinary rumor by the desertion of his chief lieutenant and proxy Senator, Mr. Allee, brings a sigh of happy relief to the country, which has anxiously watched the sixteen years’ fight against this ad- venturer. In a peculiar sense, his cam- paigns have been the concern of decent citizens in every section. Other States might be bought, but none by such sor- did and shameless methods as were ap- plied to Delaware; other preposterous candidates have aspired to Senatorships —yes, and won them—but none whose unfitness was so gross and palpable, whatever standard was to be applied. Thus not only did the name of Ad- dicks become a synonym for every- thing that was evil in American poli- tics, but it is to be feared that other communities comforted themselves by the thought that their own political con- ditions, however bad, could not be com- pared with those which were smelling-to Heaven in the old Blue Hen State. The original choice of Delaware as a field for the operation of buying a Sen- atorship is the first feature of this amaz- ing political story to demand attention. On the score of venerable traditions in politics, Delaware should have been an unpromising place to begin. Its politics had long been dominated by powerful families, like the Bayards and the Saulsburys, and it had sent an unin- terrupted succession of Democrats to the Senate for thirty-two years when Ad- dicks came on the ground. Yet under the surface were elements of weakness. Delaware was small; the $250,000 which Addicks admits having spent in his cam- paigns would be the equivalent of more than $9,000,000 in New York. Then the rural counties, which had far more than their just representation in the Legisla- ture, were wretchedly poor and contain- ed a large negro element. Vote-buying —-though on a relatively small scale— had long been indulged in by both par- ties. A State where common speech made the distinction between a man's “charging for his vote” and “voting his sentiments,” was not entirely unprepar- ed to receive a corruptionist. Moreover, while the southern counties had declin- ed in prosperity, New Castle County, which contains the city of Wilmington, had grown rapidly in wealth and popu- lation and had developed manufacturing interests which predisposed it to Re- publicanism. Addicks undertook to ob- tain a Senatorship in the same way that he would have obtained a gas charter from the same Legislature. It is not quite correct to credit Ad- dicks alone with the “redemption of Delaware,” for on the last day of De- cember, 1888, when, at midnight, he made his appearance at Dover, the Re- publicans had already elected a Legis- lature. It was easy to laugh then, as everybody did, at the pretensions of this stranger. But to review the events of the years that follow is to admire the pluck and determination of the men who stood fast against that was continually becoming stronger. In 1889 Addicks had no votes at all in the Legislature. In 1891 there was no Sen- ator to be elected, and in 1893 the Leg- islature, chosen in the year of the Dem- ocratic landslide, returned Senator Gray. Even in 1894-5, Addicks had only six ad- herents on the Senatorial ballot. Two of these fell away from him, but by par- liamentary trickery these four men contrived to prevent the choice of Col. Du Pont, who lacked a single vote of a majority when the session adjourned in May. This year was the critical one in the fight. Not only did it see the for- mal split between the factions, but the pressure rallying cry, “Addicks or nobody,” then began to carry a real menace. Thus far, the anti-Addicks men had been in the comfortable position of any established organization which is re- pelling an interloper. The most trying test of their temper was to come. After 1897, when the Democrats once more chose a Senator, Mr. Kenney, the Re- publicans again secured a Legislature. This time there were more Addicks men than Regulars. He had 18 Republican votes out of 31, but 27 were neceasary to elect. Failing to make headway in the Republican party, he turned to the Democrats. Three of them voted for him on the final ballot, and it has al- ways been believed that others were willing to, but had not the courage in the face of the cries of “Judas” and the threats of violence that accompanied the rollcall. Again it was “nobody”; but Addicks now held the whiphand,

Page 12

178 The Nation. [Vol. 81, No. 2096 In 1900 there were rival Republican delegations to the national convention, as there had been four years earlier, but this time the Addicks men were seat- ed. The influence of Mark Hanna and of President McKinley himself was by this time on the Addicks side. One of the Senatorships was offered to Samuel M. Knox, the anti-Addicks leader, as the price of his Six other were won over, and Addicks 22 out of the 27 Republican acquiescence. Regulars it last had votes. But he still lacked five, and those five were not to be had at any price. On November 11, 1902, President Roosevelt appointed William M. Byrne, Addicks’s unsuccessful candidate for Congress, United States District Attor- and Postmaster-General Payne, the politician of the Cabinet, an- that the Administration was to recognize the “Union Republican” faction on account of its numerical su- ney; practical nounced periority In the next Legislature Ad- dicks, now claiming that his “regular ity had been acknowledged by every authority competent to certify it, owned 21 votes. This time a prolong- ed deadlock was ended by the choice of an Addicks man, Allee, for the long term, and a Regular, Ball, for the short, of which only two years remained, so the 1905 had again a Senatorial vacancy to fill. But again Addicks lacked five votes of the consum- mation of his designs. That Ad«4cks is not now a Senator 1 not to be credited to Delaware as a whole- it was complaisant enough—but to the group of steadfast men, a minor- ity of their who resisted, year after year, every form of political They, a business mar, a stock dealer, two farmers, and a telegraph operator, have saved their State from the long-threatened degrad- party Legislature of own party, pressure known to this country. leal by two manufacturers, ation TRANSCONTINENTAL RAILWAY BUILDING. transcontinental rall- Two projected ways, the Grand Trunk Pacific In Can- ada and the Western Pacific in the United States, are now likely to be car- ri@t forward to speedy completion, The financial support of each undertaking provided, and contractors are preparing estimates cach = line promises to have an Important Infln- ence, not only upon the territory through which it will run, but upon Pacific Coast and Oriental commerce. seemea to be The Canadian Pacific was opened throughout In 1887, and it has since bullt and obtained control of a num- ber of feeders and branches. The total length of the system, including leased lines under construction, ts ‘Poor's Manual’ for 1904, as The road is now very lines and given, tn 11,019 miles. prosperous: the stock is quoted at 160, though in 1904 it was as low as 109. The evidences of this prosperity are abun- dant. Two through passenger trains from Montreal to Vancouver are run each way daily. This year the rush of travel has been so heavy that the trains have often run in at least two sections, and the Canadian Pacific hotels in the Rocky Mountain resorts have been com- pelled to turn away many travellers. The low rates to the Lewis and Clark Exposition at Portland have, of course, drawn large crowds, but, aside from this special cause, the rapid settlement of the wheat belt and the North Pacific coast assures a steadily growing passen- ger traffic. No expert testimony is need- ed to explain the source of freight earn- ings. From Winnipeg to Calgary the country is becoming rich. The volume of advertising in the Winnipeg news- papers is one of a thousand signs. On every siding, cars are loading and un- loading freight. At every junction and distribution wint, such as Regina, Medicine Hat, and Calgary, vast stocks of agricultural machinery are in plain sight from the car windows. The Grand Trunk proposes a line through the country farther to the north. That there is room for a rail- way there, that the business is increas- ing so swiftly as to furnish enough for both railways, no one seems to doubt. In- deed, the extension of the Grand Trunk ought, if precedent be of any value, to be a benefit to everybody concerned. The United States was importing wheat last autumn; and it cannot be many years before the world will require the prod- ucts of all the wheat lands which may be opened by both the Canadian Pacific and the Grand Trunk. On this side of the border the West- ern Pacific is hailed by residents of the Pacific Coast as the long-desired rival of the Southern Pacific. Whether it will be an active competitor remains to be seen. The north coast is in the hands of the Hill lines, which have ports at Seattle, Tacoma, and Portland. The Southern Pacific also runs into Portland, and it controls practically all the rail- way traffic in California, where its re- lations with the Santa Vé seem entirely amicable. California has not submitted to this monopoly without many protests, but they have hitherto proved unavail- ing. In the old days the mine owners bitterly complained that the railways were eating up their profits, and there was more or less hostility between the “mining group” and the “railway group” of capitalists. The farmers and fruit- growers, who are now adding so much to California's wealth, are in a state of chronic rage against the Southern Pa- cifle. It has tied itself up to a pri- vate-car monopoly, which, the farmers declare, charges extortionate rates for carrying fruit in cold storage to the Eastern markets. The merchants of San Francisco, Los Angeles, and the smaller cities and towns present their grievances in still another bill of par- ticulars. The Southern Pacific controls coastwise steamships. It has also been deep in State politics. Indeed, the pic- ture of affairs in Frank Norris’s ‘Oc- topus’ is by no means pure fiction. The news that, under the organiza- tion of the Western Pacific, the Gould system will reach out from Salt Lake City to the coast and furnish a through connection to the Atlantic seaboard, has therefore provoked extraordinary inter- est in California. The papers have been full of it. Men on the street are eager to discuss it. No doubt a road which should deliver California from the Har- riman monopoly would be a strong stim- ulus to the development of all the in- dustries of the State and to trans- Pacific trade. One need not accept the extravagant estimates of enthusiasts as to the capacity of the Pacific Coast to support a large population. One may have his doubts about twenty or thirty millions of people in the near future, but he can still believe that two million resi- dents in California and three-quarters of a million in Oregon are far below the possibility. Both States contain many undeveloped resources. Capitalists, as well as farmers, are naturally reluctant to put their investments at the mercy of a corporation which has provoked so much hostility as the Southern Pacific. The fruit-grower who finds that icing and freight charges to New York amount to more than the price of his fruit, re- fuses to put any more land under cul- tivation. If the Western Pacific does nothing more than force the Southern Pacific to adopt a more conciliatory pol- icy, it will be a great boon to the whole Coast. HYMNALS, OLD AND NEW. A new hymnal is announced by the Methodist Book Concern, a book which niust soon find its way into all Meth- odist churches, North and South. A vol- ume which reaches so many people— over four million members, with an equal number of adherents—is an edu- cational force to be reckoned with; to hundreds of thousands it will be a hand- book of poetry, music, and religion. In Methodist—as in other non-liturgical— churches, the Bible lessons and the hymns are the most elevating part of the service. In neither prayer nor ser- mon can any preacher of the denomina- tion hope to offer such a stimulus to mind and soul. Nor can the minister take offence when members of his con- gregation flee from the commonplace in- consequence of his discourse, and take refuge in the pages of the hymnal. Hosts of sincere worshippers find church tol- erable because they can close their ears to the droning exhortation, and commit to memory a hymn or two. This wo say, in spite of the fact that

Page 13

Aug. 3 I, 1905] : so much religious poetry is neither re- ligious nor poetic. Hymn-books are overloaded with stuff which has nothing to recommend it but doctrinal soundness. Fervor of emotion and beauty of diction are absolutely wanting. In this matter, however, there has in recent years been considerable improvement. The late Rev. Charles S. Robinson, for example, compiled a hymnal which was a decided advance on those in general use. The Episcopal Hymnal, published about ten years ago, marked another step forward; but it contains too much—679. hymns. The new Methodist Hymnal has 717; but it supplants a collection containing 1,117 an appalling mass of mediocre verse The difficulties of discarding any hymn, once admitted, are apparent. However banal the words or flat the jingle, they have pleased some people, have become hallowed by searching of heart, high as- piration, hope of eternity, and sorrow for the dead. The joint commission, which saved but 477 of the old hymns and add- ed 240 new, has therefore shown un- common firmness. Of course, not all the new are recent- ly written; they are drawn from all sources, ancient and modern. The whole of the last century, with Heber, Keble, Newman, Bonar, Montgomery, Faber, and Neale has produced hardly 240 worthy hymns. Two of the new hymns, Tennyson’s “Crossing the Bar” and Kip- ling’s “Recessional,” are sure to provoke adverse comment. Both are solemn and in a way devotional; but “Crossing the Bar” seems almost too elaborately meta- phorical, too artificial, to make a direct and telling appeal, while the “Reces- sional” owes something of its vogue to the fact that it isn’t a Barrack Room Ballad. Earnest souls have accepted it as proof that the profane Kipling of “Fuzzy Wuzzy” has reformed, and is bringing forth fruits meet for repent- ance. The world is yet waiting for a volume of hymns on the scale of Palgrave’s ‘Golden Treasury of Songs and Lyrics,’ the choicest, and nothing else. The num- ber of selections would probably range between two and three hundred. The task has been more than once attempt- ed, but never with great success. No denominational hymnal can supply the want. That work is compiled with an eye to the traditions and temperament of a sect. The keen theologians who pass upon the work scent Arminianism. Socinianism, or other vile heresies in the most innocent and odorless sylla- bles. As a critic of this Methodist Hymnal notes, “Hymns, flawless in themselves and eminently congenial, say, to Presbyterian or Congregational worship, might not meet the demands of the Methodist spirit of worship.” The men who undertake a small anthology of hymns, then, must be blessed with a catholic and unprejudiced taste. The phrase “spirit of worship,” just The Nation. quoted, suggests another limitation. All hymns are religious verse, but all relig- ious verses are not hymns. A metrical statement of the doctrine of the Trin- ity or the theory of atonement may be as valueless for purposes of worship as a metrical statement of the proposition that the square described on the hypothe- nuse of a right-angle triangle is equal to the sum of the squares on the other two sides. Indeed, too many of the hymns written in periods of religious contro- versy have been weighted down with doctrinal theory. John Wesley himself, in the preface to his collection of hymns, dated 1779, boasts that these hymns “contain all the more important truths of our most holy religion, whe- ther speculative or practical,” “illustrate them all,” and them both by Scripture and reason: and this is done in a regular That, indeed, is the defect of the book: it contains tod much that is expository, argu- mentative, or hortatory. ‘Take, for ex- “prove order.” merely ample, two stanzas: than God pain “Tavers of pleasure mors For He suffer'd Swearers, for you he spilt His blood; And shall He bleed in vou vain? *“*Misers, for you His life He Your basest crime He bore; Drunkards on Him laid That you might sin no more.”’ pald; your sins were These lines might easily be matched in all of the older denominational hymnals, Some of the inspiring hymns were the product of the early ages of faith. Nothing of the sophisticated Vic- torian era has touched their simplicity and vigor. When hel’ was a pit of phy- most sical torment and heaven a city of pearly gates, the Christian’s fears and hopes were absolutely definite. For Bernard of Cluny there was in all real- ity a “Jerusalem, the golden, with milk and honey blest,” a “sweet and blessed country, the home of God's elect”: and Bernard's cry came from his heart: “For thee, O dear, dear country Mine eves their vigils keep; For very love bebolding Thy holy name, they weep."’ No vague remarks on ethies in this—no thin generalizations about the pleasure of doing good, or about joining the choir invisible. The hymn-book that shall gather up the best of this pas- sion of worship is yet to be made. CHINESE STUDENTS IN JAPAN. Seu, July 21, 1906. Ten years ago, when China fought Japan, the Cantonese, had you asked him what he thought of the war, would probably have shrugged his shoulders, or inquired, in turn, “What war?” It was the Peking Govern- ment, not the Chinese nation, that was bat- tling in Mantchuria. To-day we find the merchants in every treaty port threatening to boycott American goods, students refus- ing to attend American schools, house boys declining to serve American masters, China is waking. She may not fight with machine gups and automatic pistols, but she is ca- 179 pable of waging a war of dollars. The Chinaman is a man of commerce, and in a mercantile battle would be tagonist. The Japanese victories have un doubtedly been measure for this sudden dig nity, but the Japanese schools will have a greater effect than her battleships and her undefeated armies. In January, 1906, there were 2.409 Chinese students in Tokyo. By the end of June that number had almost doubled. More than half are self-supporting, the others have been sent by the national or provincial gov ernments, or are the holders of scholarships founded by groups of officials and literat: The students are of all ages, from boys ot thirteen, preparing the middle schools, to who have already worn their official bu tons and held office at home. There Chinamen in practically all the Government institutions, and in a large number of the private, while a few been es pecially established for their instruction. The no mean an responsible, in a assertion of China’s elther to enter Japane men of forty and ove are schools have greater proportion study engineering, law or military science. Medicine claims many and railroading, photography, weaving, printing, dyeing, and soap manufacturing are less popular. The Chinese Governmen! allows each of its students twenty-five yen per month. authorities, and penses, aliowing the pupil a certain sum for incidentals. This sum is paid to the school they in turn meet all ex- Japanese students of the sam: class are generally allowed fifteen month, for eight yen pays for a four-mat room and the cheap food on which the atu yen a dent is expected to live. All students are nominally placed in charge of a Superintendent of Education, or, in ease none has been appointed, under the Chinese Minister at Tokyo. A set of rules regulating the acts of students was prepared by Chan Chih Tung, the Hankow Viceroy, and was signed by Mr. Uchida, the Japanese Minister to China. The agreement never seems to have been regarded very seriously by the Japanese. It gives elaborate direc tions governing the entrance of the student into Japanese schools—that he must at tend only those jnatitutions recommended by the Chinese Minister, and that the school shall admit him only apoo presentation of a certificate issued by the Cer penalties are also the non-observance of the above, but the Japan ese authorities refused to interfere where pupils were accused of offences purely poli ordinary matters, of have the Legation tain provided for nature, In the students tical in course, same status ae other resident Chinamen. Of the many articles, the only one calculated to render the whole effective, deals with the recently established system of ‘rewards.’ Fora very serious breach of the rules, only, student be punished by his provincial off cials on his return to China however, brings laurel wreaths and pleas ant places. Chan Chih Tung bopes to ac complish his ends by appealing to the am bitious rather than the di affected. The Emperor has that anese degrees are to be recognized aa the equivalent of the old Grades. Men whose conduct has been ex amplary, and who have entered the schools specified, will be given, upon a reéxamina tion, which may be a farce, Chinese degrees would a Obedieuce, by penalizing Jap proclaimed Chinese’ Literary

Page 14

180 as well. Five years’ study and a middle- school diploma entitle the holder to the Kungsheng grade A student who, after eight years, secures a certificate from the higher schools is awarded the Chiijen. Three years’ further study and a university de- gree call for a Chinshih. A Master's de- gree in addition claims the Hanlin, while a Doctorate insures an appointment in the Government service, given only to Hanlins of standing. In addition to the above it is provided in the new regulations that those who had completed their studies be- fore the regulations came in force, shall, upon reéxamination, be given the Chijen degree, and that those who have not grad- uated in Japan, but have been in the Gov- ernment employ, may be credited with their term of actual service. For years Chinese students have been go- ing abroad. The Government sent a num- ber to America 'n 1872, but later recalled them, as it was feared that they would re- turn to their own country too fully impreg- nated with Western ideas. Many went to England, others to the Continent, most of them men from Canton and the Yangtze provinces. Chinese interest in the outside world was growing, and the war with Japan opened the eyes of many a thinker. In 1896 a number of Chinese students went to Japan In 1898 the authorities of Che- kiang, Kwantung, and Kiangsu sent a few of their fellow provincials to the Island Em- pire, and they were followed the next year by others from the north. After the coup d'état which brought Kang Yu Weil's brief power to an end, a number of young men went over at their own expense, They were anxious to learn something of Japan's progress and of those modern ideas respon- sible for her great development. When the Boxer trouble broke out, there were a number of Chinese students in To kyo. They had not, at that time, any par- ticular organization, save the association common to all Chinamen abroad. One of the Secretaries of Legation was notoriously a frequenter of tea houses and places of Ill repute, The students resented this, and gathered one day at the resort where he was known to be. They drove him out, and then complained to the Minister, stating that, while their country was in a parlous state, with foreign troops occupying her capital, it was not a suitable time for their officials to be dissipating and making merry. This was the first occasion on which the students had taken united action. Tsai, the Chinese Minister in Tokyo, was forced to reprimand his assistant, and the inci- dent was closed. The diplomat, however, cherished towards the students an ill will which he displayed two years later. Up to 1900 the Central Government had taken little notice of the student move- ment—each province was maintaining its own group In 1902, however, there was further trouble between Twal, the Minis- ter, and the young men In the Tokyo schools A number of them, self-supporting, desirea to enter the Milltary Academy. The Japan- ese authorities refused to receive them un- leas they were recommended by their Min- ister, The Peking officials were at that time much worried by the activities of the so- called Reform Societies in the South and West, and were anxious that only Govern- ment pominees should study the art of war. Teal, therefore, had been instructed to re- fuse all requests for permits. The appli- The Nation. [Vol. 81, No. 2096 ecants, learning that the Minister's refusal was prompted by the Home Government and not by any unwillingness on the part of the Japanese to admit them, went to the Legation en masse. Thirty men refused to leave the premises, and for two days sat there without food waiting for their chief to relent, The police were finally called in, and two of the ringleaders sent back to Chi- na, whereupon the whole body threatened to leave Japan. A Superintendent was ap- pointed, and the matter was finally smooth- ed over and the desired permits granted. Nineteen hundred and two was an event- ful year for this little scholastic community. They managed to pro- test successfully against the placing of Formosan Chinamen in the Aborigines Vil- lage at the Osaka Exposition. On the Kuantung Viceroy Wang Chih Chun’s rec- ommending that French troops be called in to quell the rebellion in his provinces, the students wired their Government de- manding that the traitor be cashiered. The recent attempt on Wang's life in Shanghai was an outcome of this affair. In the year following. the number of students had in- creased, and they seemed to take an even greater interest In their home politics. A club was started with 274 charter members, at which topics of the day were discussed. The ‘“‘Supao” * case was considered in mass meeting, and subscriptions were raised to assist in paying the costs of defence in the Shanghai courts. Shen Chen, the re- form journalist who was beaten to death by the orders of the Empress Dowager, was worshipped by many as a hero. Owing to the failure of the Japanese to include the Dragon flag in the decorations, the Chi- nese students refused to attend the gradu- ating exercises at the Military Academy, even after the mistake had been rectified. When Russia, in April, 1903, ignored her evacuation agreement, the so-called “‘Chi- nese Students’ Army” was organized. About three hundred men drilled regularly for three months until the Japanese authori- ties requested them to change their names and cease their exercises. When the 8th of October found Russia still in Newchwang. the men in Tokyo telegraphed Yuan Shih Kal, the Viceroy of Chihli, crying tor war and yolunteering for the struggle. The Club is now the centre of Chinese student life in Tokyo, Each member, and there are some 4,500, pays an nominal fee of twenty sen a month. The Legation contributes 1,200 yen annually, and Chinese officials passing through are entered in the Benefactors’ list for varying sums. All provinces have their subsidiary organizations, which hold fre- quent meetings to consider questions of in- terest. They elect their own leaders who represent them in the Club councils. Be- sides a library, well stocked with books of reference, there are reading, dining, and reception rooms, open daily from seven in the morning till ten at night. The students are well organized, and take good care of their countrymen. Their agents in Tientsin and Shanghai are always ready to look after men who have just arrived from the interior, to help buy their tickets and to furnish information regarding their voyage. From these points the travellers are sent with letters of introduction to *Four journalists were arrested in the Shanghai Fore Foretgp Settlement for printing seditious articles. unicipal Council refused to turn them over tw bay B Ubinese authorities. The mratter was finally referred to Peking. other agencies in Nagasaki or Kobe, then by train and steamer to Tokyo, where the Club takes charge of them until they are safely lodged and established in their new surroundings. In recent years the idea of China for the Chinese has been definitely taking shape. The students in Japan are imbued with the new spirit, and in the past year or two the number of men who are prepared actively to voice their ideas has vastly increased. So far, there have been 411 graduates from Japanese institutions, 142 have studied in the military schools, 184 have made them- selves ready to teach their countrymen. Their sentiments are expressed in their publications, most of which are issued sub rosa. Four magazines, printed in Tokyo, are circulated throughout China. Provincial journals, published by students from Che- kiang, Hunan, Hupeh, and Kiangsu, stand for as many different means to the same end. The Hunanese are the most rabid and unreasoning in their denunciation of the Mantchus. The Chinese, they say, are worse than the Indians, for they recognize only the English as their masters, while the Chinese bow down before the Mantchus, who, in turn, are helpless in the hands of the foreigners. Hupeh and Chekiang are working upon more or less similar lines. They desire a Council, a Parliament to reg- ulate expenditure and to check official cor- ruption. They talk of public opinion, and claim that the people only need represen- tation to work out their salvation and bring the nation to the fulfilment of its destiny. Kiangsu, on the other hand, blames this same “people,” and preaches education as their one hope. Liang Chi Chao, an exile, at his desk in Yokohama, writes stinging editorials against the Mant- chus in the pages of the New People’s Re- view, while Kang Yu Wei, another patriot with a price on his head, leads the “Pao Hung Hui,” a society whose object it is to support the Emperor against the Dowager. All political discussions are forbidden in the Middle Kingdom, except in Shanghai, where the Chinese authorities have found it impossible to bridle the native press. The revolutionary pamphlets, however, have been spread broadcast by newsdealers, usually Japanese, who have opened shops, and, presuming on extra-territorial rights, sell their wares in defiance of the local of- ficials. Everywhere in China newspapers are being more widely read. The people are beginning to understand. Those who cannot read hear the news bandied about in the tea houses, for the Chinaman is a great talker, and, in a land where rumor is eagerly credited, fact must find a ready welcome. The Chinaman is primarily a practical person. He is a business man, and if it can be brought home to him that the adoption of certain measures will bring prosperity, if he can be made to realize that any partition of China would be preju- dicial to his own interests, he will be the last man to stand idly by and see the bread taken from his mouth. It is well known that Chinamen flourish nowhere as they do under an alien flag, safe from the rapacity of their own officials. This the student will grant you, and tell you that his first duty will be to become an official himself, and insure his country- men at home the same freedom they enjoy abroad. It is a mistake to say, as many ere

Page 15

Aug. 31, 1905] The Nation. 181 have said, that the Chinaman is not pat- riotic. His sense of responsibility has, possibly, been undeveloped, but he has a good foundation upon which to build. No man is more ardently attached to his vil- lage and his family than he; it would be a step, and not a difficult one, that would raise his local pride to the dignity of na- tional sentiment. The whole body politic is loosely bound by an elaborate network of village and district ties. China is an association of provinces rather than a unit- ed empire. It is the student's ambition to make the aggregation a unit. The men who return from Tokyo will have greater influence with their country- men than those who have been educated in the West. During their school days they have lived more after the fashion of their own land. They have constantly associat- ed with their nationals, discussing with them their home problems in the broader light of the new learning, the mastery of which is their day’s work. Instead of be- ing lost in the midst of a civilization entire- ly different, and influenced by a race whol- ly alien, they are in constant touch with a life which is a development of their own, remodelled and modernized. The student desirous of inaugurating reforms at home has constantly before him, as an example, the realization of the very schemes he cherishes as his own ideal. The saner and older men among the students know full well the material with which, and upon which, they must work, and the sentiments to which they must appeal. They do not ery for the expulsion of the Mantchus, un- less it be found that the present dynasty is unfitted for its responsibilities. The Mant- chu and the Chinaman, they say, are prac- tically the same; the former has been ab- sorbed by the latter people. They do not demand a Parliament, although three of the great Viceroys, Yuan Shih Kai of Chihli, the Metropolitan Province; Chan Chih Tung of Hankow, and Chou Fu of Nanking, have memoralized the Throne concerning the establishment of a constitutional govern- ment. They know that the time is not yet ripe, that recognition of the rights of the individual is not as essential to the happi- ness of the Asiatic as it is to the Anglo- Saxon. The great mass of the people are content to till their fields and let politics take care of itself if they be left to their own devices and not troubled by official interference. The latter-day idea is rather to build railroads, not as heretofore with foreign, but with Chinese capital. There must be a common tongue, the Pekingese must be able to converse with the man from Amoy or Fuchau in words, and not by writ- ten characters alone. The students hope to make the people realize that they are part of a great na- tion, not merely members of the thousands of cities and small communities throughout the Empire. When China understands that what affects the north must also affect the south, that commercial disorder in one province must have a ruinous effect in an- other, that the peril of one is the peril of all, then will she present a solid front to the world. The Chinaman must be edu- cated. He must be convinced that official corruption and the lack of united effort will be fatal not only to his neighbor, bat to himself. His patriotism must, in the be- ginning, be prompted by eelf-interest. China is waking. The change will be gradual. The students from Tokyo will be the leaders in the Renaissance, and it Is for that purpose they are training themselves to-day in the schoolrooms of Japan. WILLARD STRAIGHT. THE PROVINCE OF THE MBEZZOTINT. LONDON, August 15, 1965. Your readers may not be displeased if I supplement what I may call the social- historical Mr. Sidney Colvin's exhibition of mezzotints at the British Museum, in your the third in- stant, with some technical observations on the same remarkable show. Mr. Colvin says, in his preface to the catalogue, that he displays less than a twentieth, probably less than a thirtieth, of the mezzotints in the Museum, But there are quite enough for every purpose, and they have been se- lected so as to give a representative his- review of issue of torical series of the best prints in their best states from Von Siegen and Prince Rupert, about the middle of the seven- teenth century, down to the engravers who reproduced Hoppner Lawrence and Beechey in the first part of the nineteenth century. The and result of a study, under these auspices, of mezzotint engraving as practised in the days supposed to be its greatest, is the conviction that never has an art suffered more from its admirers and patrons. Mezzotint has some very beautiful qualities, and is full of delightful possi- bilities for the artist who understands it. There is no method of engraving that yields such rich blacks, such depth and color, such variety in texture; one would think, that lent itself so well to the reproductions of paintings. But it has the defects of its qualities, and proba- bly there is no method of engraving that can be so easily abused, that abounds in so many pitfalls of mere prettiness and meretriciousness, One of the extraordinary things about it is that, technically, its in- ventor (or rather the pupil of its in- ventor) left so little chance of improve- ment or development. There is not a mez- zotint shown finer than that famous copy of Spagnoletto’s “Executioner,” by Prince Rupert. It revealed at once all that can be got out of a plate when the engraver works on it in what the French appro- priately call la maniére noire. And it re- vealed more than this—or would have re- vealed more had Prince Rupert's followers had eyes to see—for it showed the value of restraint. The men who reproduced Reynolds and Romney only too often threw restraint to the winds, and sought, above all, the much-vaunted “velvety black” that delighted their fashionable friends but becomes cloying in the end. The blacks in Prince Rupert's print have far more virility and vigor, far more variety of gradation, far more truth of tone. It is no less curious that the mezzo- tinters who came immediately after Prince Rupert should have made the mistake of over-dryness in their plates, In compari- son with that splendid “Executioner,” the prints of Blooteling and Vaillant, of Francis Place and George White—with oc- casional exceptions, more particularly by Blooteling ahd Place—have a tendency to hardness and colorlessness. These engray- none, ers seem either not to have known what they could do with mezzotint, or else, knowing, to have been afraid to do it. It ie the more inexplicable because the later generation of mezzotinters, when the art had been popularized, went to the other extreme of softness and exaggerated color, even the very best of them. To go through the numerous prints by McArdell, and Dickinson, and Valentine Green, and John Raphael Smith, Wards, the Watsons, and the others, is to be satiated by their sweetness, to weary of their con- and the and ventional charm. What is apt to be for- gotten, since the modern collector has made the old mezzotint the rival of the Japanese print and the postage stamp, ia that all these men worked almost exclu Sively for fashionable patronage, and rare ly, like the original engraver, primarily for their own amusement People went to the mezzotint engraver as they went afterwards to the photographer; what they wanteu from him was what they get more to their fancy from the and the faker of photographs—l mean the “artist-pho tographer."” The mezzotinter could serve his clients so satisfactorily, for the simple reason that business was to make portraits from life, but to re- produce them from paintings—usually from the work of the most distinguished paint- ers of the period. However, he did his ut camera hot his now most, and it must be confessed, if we are honest, that the distinguished painters often played into their hands. Reynolds and Romney and their school were not al- ways above adapting their work to their sitters’ taste; and, besides, the traditions of Van Dyck, by the time they reached the English portrait-painters of the eigh- teenth century by way of Lely and Kneller, tended to artificial elegance and a tiresome decorative formula; and, in the fashionable mezzotint, elegance and decoration intensified a hundredfold. Nothing was spared in the affectation or languishing of a pose: draperies swirled with a more abandoned grace, ribands flew out at more tender angles, and, in the background, fo liage became more feathery, clouds more an affair of curves and pattern. All these things were rendered and exag- gerated with the greatest skill, for the mezzotinters of the day were masters of their craft. That they were often artists, too, is proved in plates where the fashion- able demands upon them were less stringent, where grace and decorative prettiness were at a discount. I do not think any can go to the British Museum, look dispas sionately at the collection there, and then deny that the masterpieces of mezzotint are found, not among the portraits of women now fetching sensational prices in the sales rooms, but among the portraits of men now to be had for a comparative song. In these you feel that the engravers were doing the work they cared for in the way that pleased them most. McArdell’s “Lords John and Bernard Stuart,” after Van Dyck; Edward Fisher's ‘“‘Laurence Sterne,”’ after Reynolds; James Watson's ‘Samuel Johnson,"’ Thomas Watson's “David Garrick,” John Raphael Smith's “Lord Richard Cavendish,”’ Dickin- son's “‘Duke of Rutland,”’all after Reynolds; and, to me one of the most successful, Va!- entine Green’s beautiful interpretation of Reynolds's portrait of himself, so dignified and simple in treatment, so true in tone, such subtle gradation im the grays and were one

Page 16

182 The Nation. [Vol. 81, No. 2096 blacks—these as you are the prints that arrest you pass, the prints that are the great glory of the art Altogether, the real lover of mezzotint with regret fine a method should have been at the mercy of fashion, both in its prime, when fashion ordered the prints, and to-day, when fashion collects them. Prince Rupert, in his the famous Englishmen in portraits of men, demonstrated what the of figures; must fill the that so exhibition **Executioner,” have method can do in ean do their beyond a doubt the rendering what it in the suggestion of landscape may be seen—not in the exhibition, where there are only two or three landscapes—but in the all too few examples by Turner for his ‘Liber Studiorum,’ and in the simpler plates by Lucas after Constable I cannot help wishing that Mr. Colvin, while omitting, as he has rightly, the inferior work of most of the men who carried on the traditton tin teenth century, had given a place to these by Turner and Lucas, for | know of none that explain better how adapted the to land- scape, how entirely it finest effects for subjects that can be expressed in the nine mezzotinis admirably medium is reserves its large, simple masses and broad outlines, without tedious detail and niggling. Here, really, is its province, though one in which it has been least developed. It is when you consider the great achievements of which the art the great has accomplished, in the translation into black and-white of good portraits of men by dis- is capable, things it tinguished painters; when you remember the chance it offers to the original artist who has fought so shy of it, that you re.- sent the money inflicted on it by fashion— first, by tempting the engravers during their lifetime with a sure and easy means of making a livelihood, and then by giving pre- their important, their artistically) When all is said, however, it is only fair to admit popular women ina the eighteenth-century school least (that is dominance to least vigorous work through a passing fad of the collector that the portraits of mezzotint, by of engravers after the eighteenth-century portrait painters, are far better worth col. lecting than the feeble and foolish color prints that are no less the tad of the mo- men N. N ! Correspondence, rHE PHILIPPINES AND THE BOYCOTT luo Tee Roiton oF THe NATION: Shin: What is the matter with the im perialieta’ From 1898 until recently they have proclaimed in unmeasured terms the value of the Philippines as a satrateg'« point commanding the trade with the Orient, ote ele Many Americans were deluded the grievous and shameful burden of the Philippines in view the China’s Let them now promise with the fulfilment, that the Imperialiatic hollow pretence info accepting of ite prising open door of markets to their commerce contrast the perceive and admit fiction was a to cover a sordid land-grabbing acheme; that the poa- session of that wretched archipelago has no bearing whatever on American trade with China; that when a Chinaman de- clipes to buy from them, fleets and stra- tegic points are alike impotent; that trade depends s0 largely on mutual good will that it is folly to kick a possible purchaser and then expect him to buy a bill of goods. The Chinese reply to the Imperialistic contention is simply a boycott. So, Mes- sieurs les Impérialistes, marry, come up— what are you going to do about it? Your answer is impatiently awaited by AN ANTI-IMPERIALIST. Boston. August 20, 1005. DOVE AND DIVED. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sin: In your issue of the 17th inst., I find on page 139 this sentence: “it is not gen- erally known that the American submarine Porpoise dove [sic] 120 feet, etc.” I have subscribed to your valuable paper for many years, and have been, during that time, an attentive reader of it. I therefore dislike to criticise anything therein con- tained. It, however, seems to me that “dived"’ is the correct word to use—not “dove.”’ CRITIC. KaGLesmere, Pa., August 20, 1905. {In Edward FitzGerald’s translation from Calderon, “Such Stuff as Dreams vre Made of,” first act and scene, “Crit- ic’ may read this figure of the setting sun. The lines are from the mouth of Rosaura’s attendant, Fife: “Ah, be's himself past catching; as you spoke He heard what you were saying, and—just so— like some scared water-bird, Ae we say in my country, déve below."’ FitzGerald's “country” was, of course, Suffolk. Dr. Murray, in the Oxford Dic- tionary, under Dive, enumerates dove among the various forms of the preter- ite, with the simple label, “U. S. and Eng. dial.,” to which he adds: “The modern dialectic past tense dove is ap- parently a new formation after drive, drove, or weave, wove.” His earliest lit- erary quotation is from Hayes’s ‘Open Polar Sea,’ 1867. We think our corre- spondent is needlessly skittish of the form either as dialect or as an Ameri- conism.—Ep. Natton.] LOAN AND LEND. To THE EprToR OF THE NATION: Sin: In a belated copy of the Nation 1 find, on page 133, the phrase, apropos of a German loan to the Sultan of Morocco: “‘To money to him is practically to loan money to Moroceo.”” I am writing remote from dictionaries, but is it really justifiable to use “loan” as a verb? The usage is common in the United States and Canada inp commercial circles, but much less so, I be- lieve, in England.—Yours truly, Grorace M. WRONG. PornTe av Pic, Murnmay Bay, Quaener, Auguat 25, 1005. loan {Any noun may be used as a verb, but not all such applications will find favor. Dr. Murray gives a chapter to the verb loan, remarking “Now chiefly U. 8.” There are equivocal examples of its use as far back as 1300; the first assured occurs in an act of Henry VIII. Bonamy Price did not stick at the word in 1880. —Ep. NatTion.] Notes. Among the fall announcements of Mac- millan Co, are ‘New Creation in Plant Life,’ an account of Luther Burbank and his work, by W. S. Harwood; the ‘Recollections’ of William O’Brien; ‘Life of Oliver Ells- worth,’ by William Garrott Brown; ‘Na- poleon and his Times,’ in the Cambridge Modern History; ‘Pre-Raphaelitism and the Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood,’ by W. Hol- man-Hunt; ‘The History of American Painting,’ by Samuel Isham; ‘India,’ by Flora Annie Steel, with colored illustra- tions by Mortimer Menpes; ‘Persia, Past and Present,’ by A. V. Williams Jackson; ‘A Wanderer in Holland,” by E. V. Lucas; ‘In the Heart of the Canadian Rockies, by James Outram; ‘Sperting Sketches,’ by Edwyn Sandys; ‘The Far East and the Great War,’ by B. kL. Putnam Weale; ‘Venice, by F. Marion Craw- ford, illustrated by Joseph Pennell; the second volume of the enlarged edition of Grove’s ‘Dictionary of Music’; a ‘History of Education,’ by Prof. Paul Monroe; ‘A History of Political Theories, from Luther to Montesquieu,’ by Prof. William A. Dun- ning; and ‘Nero,’ by Stephen Phillips. From A. C. McClurg & Co.'s fall list we select ‘With Shelley in Italy,’ by Anna Ben- neson McMahan; ‘Remenyi: Musician and Man—An Appreciation,’ by Gwendolyn Kelley and George P. Upton; ‘Arts and Crafts of Old Japan,’ by Stewart Dick; ‘Far Eastern Impressions,’ by Ernest F. G. Hatch; ‘Home Life in France,’ by Matilda Betham-Ed- wards; and ‘In the Land of the Strenuous Life,’ from the French of the Abbé Félix Klein. B. W. Huebsch, New York, announces ‘Christian Origins,’ translated by Dr. D. A. Huebsch from the German of Otto Pflei- derer; and ‘Beethoven’ and ‘Mozart,’ as re- vealed in their own words as man and artist, respectively, from the German of Friedrich Kerst by H, E. Krehbiel. ‘Perdita, and Other Poems,’ by Charles J. Bayne, will shortly be published by the Cole Book Co., of Atlanta, Ga. The eminent Swedish philologist, Prof. Adolf Noreen of Upsala, author of standard Old-Norse-Icelandic and Old-Swedish gram- mars, is now publishing his great Grammar of Modern Swedish, through Gleerup (Lund). This vast undertaking is designed to be comprised in four parts, filling nine volumes of 500-600 pages each, so that the whole work will contain some- thing like 5,000 pages. The first part con- sists of a general introduction; the second deals with phonology, the third with semasiology; the fourth, besides including morphology, will provide a detailed in- dex to the whole work. Those who are familiar with the scientific methods follow- ed by Professor Noreen in his earlier pub- lications know what to expect from the rare combination of scholarship, imagina- tion, and critical acumen, of phonetic training and philogical learning, which have rendered this author one of the greatest living authorities in the fleld of Scandina- vian languages. The completion of the work will be eagerly awaited. We have received two dozen volumes of

Page 17

Aug. 31, 1905] the reissue, after eight or ten years, of Routledge’s ‘““‘The Muses’ Library,” with the American imprint of Dutton. In their size, 1é6mo, and rather small print, they make a popular appeal, but Dr. Richard Gar- nett, W. B. Yeats, G. A. Aitken, Alfred Pollard, and Other authoritative writers have been called in as editors. The poets whose works are included in this collection range from Adelaide Anne Procter and Coventry Patmore to Keats, Blake, Cole- ridge, Goldsmith, Gray, Herrick, Donne, etc., ete. The volumes are annotated at the end Although an apology for Napoleon, Henri Houssaye’s ‘1815: Waterloo,” is rec ognized abroad as a brilliant and valuable book, The translation by S. R. Willis (Kansas City: Franklin Hudson Co.) hardly does justice to the style of the original. but will serve to convey its meaning, and for that reason is welcome. ‘Maria Sophia, Queen of Naples,’ trans- lated from the Norwegian of Clara Tschudi by Ethel Harriet Hearn (E. P. Dutton), is rather too slight in substance to make a book of. Maria Sophia was queen for only two years, and although during that short time much happened, including Gari- baldi’s expedition, she played but a modest part in it. Still, Miss Tschudi succeeds in rousing an admiration for her heroine's fine qualities, and our sympathy for her personal sorrows. Maria Sophia, who still lives, comes of that Wittelsbach family on which a curse hangs like that which blast- ed Pelops’s line. Louis II. of Bavaria went mad and drowned himself; her young- est sister, the Duchess d’Alencon, was burned to death at the Charity Bazaar in Paris; her second sister, Elizabeth, Bm- press of Austria, was assassinated in Ge- neva. “A Digit of the Moon, and Other Love Stories from the Hindoo,”’ translated from the Original Manuscripts by F. W. Bain (Putnams), bears date 1905, but there is no explanation in it of the puzzling fact that it contains a preface to the first edition of 1898, without itself being called a second edition. Nor does it appear whether the present edition is original or pirated. At least one of the four stories appeared sep- arately in London, two years ago. As for the “Stories from the Hindoo,” though palpably a pretence, they are graceful fan- cies, and might as well have appeared for what they really are instead of masquerad- ing as ‘“‘translations.”” No Hindu, unless of this generation and under foreign influence, ever conceived these stories. They are an amalgam of delicate European thought and flowery Hindu expression. The native at mosphere has been rather cleverly caught, and the author has adopted several Hindu tricks of story-telling. His acquaintance with Hindu literature appears to be limited to a few often translated classics; but he gets the local Indian color and has a well imitated (though considerably chastened) Hindu style. Many persons will deem his stories charming. At any rate, they are touchingly sentimental and written in ex- tra-florid English. Moreover, they are of a strict propriety, whereas original Hindu love stories would put Rabelais’s ghost to the blush. One so well versed in Sanskrit as is the author should in future editions correct the spelling of usriydéyam (p. 137) and purushdrta (p. 174). The “in my garden” sort of book is los- ing its novelty. Even India has produced The N a tio m. 183 two or three. The last, if we remember correctly, was from Kashmir. Now comes one from Lucknow, ‘My Garden in the City of Gardens: A Memory, with Illustrations’ Lane). The author's name is dis- creetly suppressed. The chapters are head- ed with the pames of the months from October to June, when the Mem Sahib de- serts her garden and flees to the hills. There is less garden than quotation—main- ly Latin, French, and early English—and the chief impression produced by the book is that in India the Englishwoman wishes were back jin England Reminiscences of the Mutiny abound, a well-authenticated ghost story is given in detail, and dengue fever is derived from ‘“‘Aden-ague"! As gar- den-books go, this one is sufficiently enter- taining, and the descriptions are as good as the photographs ‘Sanctuaires et (John she Paysages d'Asie,” by An- dré Chevrillon Hachette), is a book of impressions. The author voyages in Ceylon, India, and Burma, and brings be- fore the reader each he sees it, in a series of sentences (Paris scene as more or less de- nuded of verbs, and closing with exclama- tions. The publishers kindly the reviewer not only with the book but with its ex- furnish a ready-made review pointing out cellences. To conversant with Eastern thought it that the impressions here reproduced are sufficient- must neces- one not may be said ly real, and reflect what one sarily seeing the strangé life of Benares and the Buddhism of Bur- ma. The Orientalist will not discover any great originality either of thought or de- scription. Here is an example from the chapter entitled‘‘La Mort A Bénarés”: “Oui, étrange, cette humanité, étrange sa vie, au point de présenter, plus pressant, plus ac- ecablant que d’habitude, le mystére de toute vie Cette vie, je ne puis la conce- voir directement; ... simplement, c'est une forme que j'ignorais, tine des innombrables formes de l'éternelle Petites ruelles de Bénarés, ardeurs cir- culaient et nous partaient A travers leur fiévreux labyrinthe!"’ etc., 361 pages. Records of personal intercourse’ with Goethe during the different periods of his life furnish some of the most attractive and valuable contributions to his biog- rapby. Following Falk and Eckermann at a long interval we had, in 1869, Fried- rich von Miiller’s ‘Unterhaltungen' mit Goethe,’ edited by Dr. Burkhardt, director of the Grand Ducal Archives in Weimar, from the author's diary, and issued twenty years after his death. To Dr. Burkhardt we are now indebted for ‘Goethe's Unter- haltungen mit Friedrich Soret,’ also derived from a diary written in French and pre- served in the Weimar archives. Soret was born in 1795 in St. Petersburg, where his father, a native of Geneva, had the posi- tion of court-painter, but from his fifth year he was reared and educated in Geneva and Paris. He began the study of theology, but soon abandoned it for natural science, in which he acquired distinction, especially as a crystallographer. In 1822 he came to Weimar as tutor of the heir to the throne, Karl Alexander, then only four years old. The discharge of this duty brought him into intimate association with Goethe, who soon learned to hold him in high esteem, and often entertained him as a welcome In their frequent conversations the his views with experience in vie. quelles guest. venerable poet expressed remarkable freedom, and thus = revealed some new and striking features of his char acter, which in no other worka of this kind are so distinctly and impartially portrayed One curious revelation was Goethe's super stitious fear of March 22; he alwaya felt anxious as this day approached, and great ly relieved when it was past It was on March 22 that he died. In the decline of his bodily vigor this dread may have na turally determined the date of his death It is the intention of Dr. Burkhardt to pub lish Soret's the The eighth volume of Publications of the diary in original Freoch Buffalo Historical Society might be said to consist of several books Orrin Bdward Tiffany treats extensively (pp. 1-152) the Relations of the United States to the Can adian Rebellion of 1837-8; the narrative with many ments and numerous facsimiles of placards illustrating that heated time on the border Robert B Abolition of Railroad Grade Buffalo, a half-century task, hundred pages more, can consultation by other municipalities vexed by the same problem. The Dobbins Papers relating to Daniel Dobbins, a demand 120 pages. Passing over other tl! tles, we will mention the closing reminis cences of Buffalo Social Life in the Thir ties, by Martha Fitch Poole, which ars light and pleasant reading. The War of 1812, it need not be said, figures promi nently in this bulky volume. supplementing inedited docu Adam's History of the Crossings in occupies a valuable for and but be Lake pilot upon an jude repub the Though Liberia is apparently entering era of prosperity and development, ing from the account of the lic by Sir Harry Johnston in Geographical Journal for by far the larger part is still dense forest penetrated only by narrow native paths, or negro August more often only elephant tracks, he found last year that in many places the coast land which, at his first visit in 1882, was heavily wooded, had been cleared for plan tations and towns. He noted a decided im provement in the physique of the Ame: ico-Liberians, due partly to intermarriag: indigenou with women of the vigorous races. Up to within ten years there have been constant struggles between these for eigners, who number some twelve or fif and their native subject two million strong teen thousand, who are about ous result of which is “that the white man in Liberia everywhere great friendliness, because he is not asso ciated in the minds of the with anything like conquest or oppression.”’ Ke cently there has been a marked advance in good relations between the American set acuri with is received natives tlers and the natives, which has been greatly promoted by the wise policy of President Barclay. The Government n conjunction with two British companies, | seriously endeavoring to the re sources of the vast forest wealth of rubber-bearing trees, plants, vines (twenty-two different species having develop which, in It and been discovered), is without parallel in any other part of Africa, except it may be in one or two smal] areas in the Conge Basin. The foreign quarter ef Monrovia the capital, has broad streets, substantia! well-built, comely looking houses, church es, offices, and public buildings. The at tractiveness of the houses is greatly in creased by the beautiful clumps of trees and the gardens filled with flowers which

Page 18

184 The Nation. [Vol. 81, No. 2096 ——_.___ —_ surround them While many signs of progress are to be seen in the settlements of Grand Basé, the most progressive and Americo-Liberians are to be Palmas), where there is a society which is doing a good work in collecting and print- the country. It is a there is a remarkable energetic Harper (Cape philosophical found at about that mosquitoes and to a certain ex- Liberia, though ing Statistics singular fact absence of malarial fevers in ' fent of ts swamps would seem to be an ideal home for them The address delivered several months ago by Lord Rosebery at the banquet of the Edinburgh, in uncritical ac- English book-dealers in which he that the ceptance of manuscripts and untruthful an- publishers declared houncements of new books by responsible for the increasing the book trade of Eng- land, has furnished leading German periodi- were largely overproduction tin cals with a welcome text for a lecture on the ethics of publication to the book trade of that “country of authors and thinkers.” For Instance, Dr. Oskar Bulle, in the Beilage of the Munich Allgemeine Zeitung, No. 149. applauds the position taken by Lord Rose- bery He the phenomenal where the annual output is equal of England, France, and America be the “Schreibewut,”" or writing mania, of the Germans themselves. Only about a year ago the Strassburg pub- declared it his de- liberate conviction thatonlyone out of every pronounces the prime cause for literary overproduction in Germany t o that combined—to lisher, Triibner, to be en book manuscripts offered by German authors gets published A second chief ause, according to Dr. Bulle, is the con- clenceless way in which book publishers in Germany announce and advertise their publications, with small regard to truth and fact Especially does he criticise the ut- terly false that accompany the copies sent to the press for announcements generally review, and for which the Germans have the rather undignified but characteristic name of “Waschzettel,” or laundry list Complementary to our Korean correspon- lence on another page, we find in the Chi- nese Recorder tor July a noteworthy paper on “Japanese Educational Influence in China,” by Tasuké Harada of Kobé, Japan, lelegate to the recent educational conven tion In China Until a seore of years ago, every Japanese looked up to China as his superior and teacher; Chinese classics be- Ing regarded as the source of wisdom, and China, except in the matter of science and mechanics, equal to Europe Even nine- teenth-century Japanese sages believed that the Utopia for Japan was a state of society in which the ethics of Confucius and the mechanical arta of the Occident were harmonized Until the war of 1894- *%, China was a great mysterious power, but the vietory of Japan exactly reversed the posttions of the two nations of the Far Kaat Now a new era in the liberation and enlightenment of China “A child on a man's shoul- modern has been entered upon river, points out to der, as he crosses a him the shallows," runs the proverb of Nip pon To-day, Japan influences China edu- cationally through Japanese teachers in Chi and Jap literature Chinese Near Shanghai there is a school for train young Chinese It who na, Chinese students in Japan, anese translated into men mn 150 graduates, ing Japanese has 820 students and are now scattered all over China, there be- ing now fifteen full professors in the Chi- nese Government colleges, besides 159 Jap- anese subjects in other educational insti- tutions in China. They receive from four to six times the amount of salary possible at home. Chinese lads and maidens, to the number of 2,399, are studying in thirty- seven schools in or near Tokyo, the pref- erence being, in their order, for the mili- tary, naval, legal, and medical sciences, music and art. These students represent every one of the eighteen provinces; Hu- peh, Hunan, and Szechuen having each more than 300. The statistics, good for February 1, 1905, might now probably be increased one-third. Most remarkable is the enormous number of Japanese books, from primary-school text-books to volum- inous works on science, history, and phi- losophy, which have been put into Chinese. One publishing house in China has a list of 608 titles, divided into fourteen sections, and covering almost every branch of human knowledge. Japanese in China publish books and magazines, and “a vast number of youngChinese men and some women” read books and papers in the Japanese language. Many Chinese students in Japan return home without fully completing their stu- dies, and lose also somewhat of their good manners and economic training, yet, like Chinese generally, when away from home they are the more susceptible to beneficial change. The tenth biennial session of the Inter- national Statistical Institute was held in London during the first week in August, members from nineteea different countries, including Japan, being present. There were from the United States John Hyde and Professor Willcox of Cornell, Govern- ment delegates; Dr. J. S, Billings and Ed- ward Atkinson. France was most largely represented, and the official language was French. In his opening speech as honor- ary president, the Prince of Wales called attention to the fact that his grandfather, Prince Albert, held a similar position at the international statistical congress in London in 1860. Among the subjects dis- cussed were occupational censuses, the sta- tistics of unemployment, of workmen's wages, and the economic balance of nations. M. Yves Guyot contributed a paper on the incidence of customs duties, in which he said that his figures led him to the conclu- sion that only 3 per cent. of the total occu- pled population derive any benefit from protection in France, and that, with the exception of cotton and flax spinners and metal workers, all a certain number of other industrials would profit by free trade. In Chili there has been within the last few years an extraordinary growth of in- dustrial life, stimulated largely by the high prices ruling in Europe for three of her staple products—nitrate, wool, and cop- per. In consequence of this increase, na- tional capital is rapidly supplanting for- elgn. In Tierra del Fuego and Magellan, for instance, there has been a remarkable boom in sheep farms, and land which was largely held by British sheep farmers on lease or yearly tenancy has been bought by large Chillan companies, which in many cases employ British managers. Very high prices have been paid, one British-owned farm bringing a million dollars, and this in a region which till recently was almost unknown. The Academy of Sciences in Vienna, if not the first to appreciate the value of the ‘phonograph for scientific purposes, has made as yet the most systematic and suc- cessful use of this instrument for the pro- motion of scholarly research, especially in the province of comparative philology. “The Phonographic Museum,” founded by this learned society, contains an exceedingly in- teresting and constantly increasing collec- tion of phonograms, not only of the utter- ances of distinguished personages, but also of languages and dialects spoken in differ- ent European countries and in many other lands. Expeditions are sent every year to remote parts of the world, in order to pho- nograph the voices, tones, and manner of speaking peculiar to different peoples, so that they may be heard long after these races have become extinct. Dr. Poech is now in Australia recording the speech of the native tribes. These investigations are not confined to mankind, but include also the lower animals, thus enabling zodélogists to study the sounds, vibrations, and undu- lations in the voices of various species. Such phonograms ought to facilitate the study of animal speech, to which Pro- fessor Garner has devoted himself with laudable zeal, if not with remarkable suc- cess. —To the recovery of the body of John Paul Jones and consignment to its appro- priate resting-place, we owe the stanzas contributed to the September Century in honor of the occasion by Edmund Clarence Stedman. A reproduction of the copperplate engraving of Jones by Moreau, together with the Peale portrait and two views of the Houdon bust, will justify to most read- ers, we think, the claim that the Moreau representation is far superior to that of Peale. The reproduction is from the print picked up in an old shop by the late B. F. Stevens, about twenty years ago, and later presented by him to the Bostonian Society. Christian Brinton presents, with appropri- ate comment, a number of illustrations from the plans of Messrs. Carrére & Hastings for the improvement of the national Cap- itol; and from the same pen we have a few highly appreciative paragraphs concern- ing the new church edifice of Dr. Park- hurst’s congregation, on Madison Avenue and Twenty-fourth Street. The architects, Messrs, McKim, Mead & White, have suc- ceeded admirably, Mr. Brinton thinks, in overcoming the difficulties of the site, with its fifteen-story sky-scraper at the back, its 600-foot tower opposite, and its possi- bility of additional neighbors of the same type in the future. A color drawing, by Jules Crow, accompanies the brief descrip- tion. Margaret E. Noble contributes a very timely and convincing paper on “Ole Bull as a Patriotic Force,” but doubtless some disciple of the later ideas in political de- velopment will step in to inform us that the forces underlying the present Norwegian upheaval are at bottom purely economic. In his stories of the Far Northwest, the fourth of which appears in the present is- sue, Lawrence Mott is serving up in bits a character which would have made admirable material for a sustained plece of fiction. The short-story habit is doing a real harm to literature when it breaks in pieces so lifelike a creation as Jules Verbaux.

Page 19

Aug. 31, 1905] The Nation. = — —— —Volume viii. of the Publications of the Mississippi Historical Soctety (Oxford) tes- tifies to the laudable activity of this body. The civil war, in one form or another, con- tinues to occupy the minds and the pens of most of the contributors, though the In- dians receive an unusual degree of atten- tion, and there is a timely exposition of the dispute over their Gulf boundary be- tween Mississippi and Louisiana, now di- vided elsewhere by shotgun boundaries in consequence of yellow fever. Another nov- elty (for us) is an “index to campaigns, battles, and skirmishes in Mississippi from 1861 to 1865'’"—a gazetteer of conflicts, petty and major. This has been drawn from the Official Records, by Stephen D. Lee. In con- nection with an account of Confederate cemeteries in the same State, by Prof. R. W. Jones, there are lists of their respective dead. Quite the most significant paper is that by Col. J. H. Jones, “‘Reconstruction in Wilkinson County.”" We cannot forbear to quote a passage or two: “It must be confessed that the Mississip- pi Legislature of 1865 and 1866, assembled under President Johnson's plan of recon- struction, afforded good reasons for belief in the minds of the ignorant negroes that their old masters were secretly conspiring against their newly acquired freedom, and only waited for an opportunity to put their plans into effect. Looking back upon the methods by which that Legislature under- took to deal with the negro problem, one is amazed at such stupidity, at such a dis- play of monumental folly committed by men of ordinary intelligence. . They began to amend the slave code by conferring ‘ad- ditional rights on freedmen, free negroes, and mulattoes.. Among the ‘additional rights’ conferred was the privilege of marrying in the same manner as white per- sons. That is, they were graciously per- mitted to live in holy matrimony, after God's own ordinance, and were no longe! to be compelled to disregard the marriage relation and live in legal adultery as re- quired under the slave code. ... Are we free from responsibility for the almost to- tal indifference to the obligations of mar- riage which characterizes the negroes to- day?” (p. 155). —This is refreshingly plain-spoken for a Southerner addressing Southerners. Mr. Jones goes further, and confronts North- ern apologists who inveigh against the be- stowal of suffrage on the negroes, hy de- claring (p. 158): “When I read these laws of our Legislature of 1865 and 1866, pre- sumably enacted by the best intelligence of the State, I was not at all surprised that bitter Abolitionists like Thad Stevens, himself a miscegenationist, should have be- lieved that the Reconstruction acts were necessary to the proper administration of justice in the South.” A writer ca- pable of such candor can still betray in himself the root of the evil of all injustice at the South. Says Mr. Jones (p. 163): “The men of Wilkinson County were high-spirit- ed, and were never so depressed as to sub- mit to personal insults from any one, and especially from negroes. They were soon made to understand that while they could drum and fife and parade and vote the rad- ical ticket, and make fools of themselves generally, insolence to a white man would provoke a bullet in return.” Does Mr. Jones here speak detachedly, simply as his- torian? *—The third volume of the Heath Papers, printed by the Massachusetts Historical So- clety, is full of good historical material. The greatest surprise lies in the quality of Heath's own letters. They leave a dis- tinctly better impression of the man than can be derived from his stilted memoir. Whether in command at West Point, with the French at Rhode Island, or on leave, he was careful in his duties, considerate in his relations to State and Allies, and capable of a mastery of details united to a certain breadth of judgment that made him useful in holding together a somewhat disorganized body of troops. The post at West Point was of the highest importance, commanding, as it did, the communications with New England, and good management was needed to maintain it with troops badly fed, paid, and clothed. For this task Heath was admirably equipped, and his tact ‘gave rise to an impression of a_ certain want of decision. He was himself sensi- tive as to recognition, and his feelings were hurt by an apparent preference given to a foreigner. His mission to the Eastern States demanded decision and exactitude, and what he obtained undoubtedly aided the success of the Yorktown venture. He showed consideration to his associates and subordinates, and smoothed over many dif- ficulties which might have led to serious mutinies. It is creditable to his com- mand that it was ready to march against the mutineering regiments of Pennsyl- vania and New Jersey. Only when the new ration contracts of 1782 had failed was there an outbreak. —A large number of interesting subjects might be noted from this volume. The let- ters from Lafayette describing the etiquette to be followed with the newly arrived French forces is entirely characteristic, and lays down principles sound in themselves, but difficult to pursue with ragged regulars and untrained militia. Heath made a very diplomatic reply; but in truth no forms were and the Allies grew to respect one another in spite of the great disadvantages under which the Americans labored. Many details of the French stay in Rhode Island are given, as well as the proposed attack on Halifax, the required, operations in northern New York, and the descents on Long Isl- and. Some letters from “S. G.” add to what is known of the secret service, so efficient under Tallmadge, and that officer describes the death of André. Complaint is often raised against the poor quality of the recruits, old men, negroes, and boys, but mention is made of Col. Greene's “‘very small"’ regiment of blacks, which was di- vided when united to the main army, ‘so as to abolish the name and appearance of a black corps.” The militia comes in for a share of condemnation, and even their lack of spirit in throwing up fortifications attracted attention. This volume proba- bly closes the Heath series, as the last letter is dated 1797. The editor, Charles Card Smith, shows his usual judgment and sound selection, and the notes are few but suggestive. A reference to the Washing- ton Papers would have supplied some mat- ter omitted because of torn sheets; and the appearance, without explanation, of a letter of 1777 (p. 153), among the letters of 1781, leaves a curious impression. —In his ‘Studies on Anglo-Saxon Institu- tions’ (Macmillan), Mr. H. Munro Chadwick of Clare Cellege, Cambridge, marshals the evidence regarding a great many obscure and difficult points in the early history of England. Almost all writers on constitu- tional] subjects have, when dealing with the Heptarchic period, taken over from the laws, the chronicles, and the general literature of the time a large number of special terms and employed them in their own writings without attempting to define the exact sig- nificance of each. The result is that few save professional students have any real grasp of Anglo-Saxon terminology, even where it affects the foundations of our his- torical knowledge It is the aim of Mr Chadwick in this book to preface all discus sion of larger political, social, and economic themes by such an account of technical words as will reveal their meanink at dif- ferent epochs. Take, for example, the term “shilling,” one of the commonest units in the monetary system. Prior to the eighth century it may have been a coin, but from this period forward, for a_ considerable time, it was simply a unit of account, and by no means an invariable unit at that Mr. Chadwick's conclusions, which are part- ly the result of codrdination and partly the fruit of original research, affect the funda mentals of investigation, especially for the age which precedes the reign of Exigar Every one knows how largely our informa- tion regarding social conditions in Eng land during the first four centurles, and more, after the beginning of the Germanic invasions, depends upon the tariffs of Wer geld which were established in the different kingdoms. Mr. Chadwick opens his first chapter thus: “The classification of Teu tonic society in ancient times may perhaps be most conveniently attempted by observ ing the gradations in the monetary pay ments to which persons belonging to differ- in compensation purpose a entitled For this ent classes were for various injuries clear understanding of the monetary sys tem is an _ indispensable’ preliminary.” From money we are taken to the social system, thence to administration, and from a topographical survey of the older countries in connection with their mag- nates, to the constitution of the national council, and finally to the origin of the no bility. A large part of Mr. Chadwick's work runs parallel with Seebohm’s ‘Tribal Custom in Anglo-Saxon Law,’ and those who take an interest in primitive conditions will be apt to follow carefully the variation of opinion between the two writers. Mr Chadwick's chapters are divided into num erous paragraphs with special titles, and over each of these the heading ‘“‘excursus” might with some fitness be written. But while the text on analysis represents a large number of separate and technical in vestigations, the volume is not destitute of unity, since each study is made to bear upon some large institution For the Hep- tarchic period in particular Mr. Chadwick's results are of real value SIDGWICK’S BSSAYS AND ADDRESSES By 1904 Viacellaneous Exssaya and Addresses. Henry Sidgwick. The Macmillan Co It is a severe test of an author's work to reprint for the public a collection of essays which appeared, for the most part, in the magazines, and which cover a period of more than thirty years. The volume above named bears it well. It includesa wide range of subjects—economics, education, and literature—and it treats them all wits

Page 20

= The Nation. [Vol. 81, No. 2096 = —— = a solidity, a fulness of knowledge, a many- sidedness, and an occasional sparkle of dry light which keep them alive and informing even when their immediate interest has be- gun to shiftor wane. Most of us have forgot- ten the stir that was raised about ‘Ecce Iiomo’ in the sixties; some of us are al- ready forgetting the dazzling generaliza- tions of Mr. Kidd's ‘Social Evolution’; but there are very few who will not be bene- fited by reading the essays in which Mr. Sidgwick applies a dose of history and of ound reasoning, and brings his piercing analysis to prick the amateurish bubbles of each of these brilliant works. The long and important essays on Ben tham and Benthamism, and on the Relation of Ethics to Sociology, as well as the ad dress before the British Association on the Scope and Mevhod of Economic Science, be long, of course, to the author's specialty and carry the weight of a distinguished and independent investigator The remaining papers, on the poems and prose remains of Arthur Hugh Clough, on Shakspere's Meth- ods and the Romantic Drama, on the Pur- ult of Culture as an Ideal, and on the Theory of Classical Education, illustrate the extraordinary breadth of Sidgwick's ympathies, as well as the range and depth and thoroughness of his studies Wide as this range is, there is in his treatment of this varied matter absolutely nothing of the amateur. Whether he is discussing the niceties of the hexameter in English, or the ubtieties and affinities of Clough's very ubtle genius, the breadth of his equipment is as remarkable as his insight: he need ask no favors nor allowances from the professional littérateur. The discussion of Shakspere’s use of Plutarch and of Holins- hed, or of his transitions from prose to verse is full of thought and suggestive ness it reveals the scholar who knows his editors and commentary well, and his suthor even better than the commentators (On the whole, with a bent and method which are strictly scientific, Professor Sidg- wick here presents in himself an admirable illustration of his own conception of the meaning and value of culture The closing essay sums up this ideal, and puts it very clearly “To pursue culture is to live in the fullest manner, exhaust- ing those higher modes of mental and so- cial life from which our finest human pleas- Whether this is needful he ures pring low not discuss: he had never heard of one of our great universities expressly disclaiming cuiture as the end or aim of any one of ite hundreds of courses of in truction lie assumes that cullture—the training of a supple intelligence, the ardor of scientific curiosity, the pursuit of ideas constitutes one of the betterments of Ife. To join thie with a trained taste and sensi- bility to beauty is “the problem for those who pursue the idea of good.” The exer- cise of these tastes and powers, the assimi- lation of varied knowledge and ideas, till : man's soul becomes a harmonious organ iam looking out on the world through many windows, and from each receiving views and impressions which modify and delight the denizens within—this may well be the goal of a general education. The pedant, then, is not a man of culture; the specialist is not a man of culture, even so far as his special knowledge goes—on the contrary, he must strive apd struggle against the cramping of his thought, to escape from the prison of his specialty. Science is an exacting mistress, and seems to claim an exclusive devotion. It claimed everything from Darwin, for instance, as it might from Mr. Burbank; but Darwin had a mission, Mr. Burbank is called. The rest of us, generally speaking, are not so sure that we have a mission, a vita vola. The student, then, must struggle against this exclusive claim of his specialty, against cramps and fetters; and in this “noble conflict,” as Mr. Sidgwick calls it, nothing helps more than the habit of delight in the best literature. The longest and one of the weightest essays is that entitled ‘““‘The Theory of a Classical Education,”” which was published in 1867 as a contribution to the collec- tion edited by F. W. Farrar under the name of “Essays on Liberal Education.” This is a cool and thorough analysis of the metbods and claims of classical educa- tion, In England more especially, at that period; and, at the same time, an estimate of the share which Greek and Latin might contribute toward an ideal training and edu- cation. It is an estimate made by a ju- dicious and dispassionate friend of classi- cal studies, who understands every side of the subject and treats it with an inti- mate, inside knowledge of its details. His object is to weigh accurately the exact kind of culture and mental discipline which classical studies may impart, and to settle the rival claims of certain other subjects which should be included in a rounded edu- cation. He shows himself in firm posses- sion of the essential facts of the case, while resorting neither to sentiment nor invective, nor to vague and sweeping state- ments—snares which peculiarly beset the discussions of enthusiastic classicists, and from which the calmer scientist is not en- tirely free. The old-fashioned headmaster, when rhaspsodizing over the mystic virtues that reside in the practice of Latin compo- sition, is, like a fond parent, capable de tout—"No religious nation,” says Mr. Thring, ‘can give up Greek!" If Mr. Sidg- wick has once lapsed into eloquence, it is in the admirable appeal which he makes for the study of Physical Science as an es- sential part of the equipment of every thoughtful and intelleftual man of our epoch. How can such a man absolve him- self from the effort to frame a reasoned synthesis of the facts of the universe? How couldthe most devout Platonist absolve himself from such an obligation, since Plato once required geometry as the passport to his Academy? At the same time, he pro- tests against the notion that Science and Literature are alternatives between which a choice must be made. He had never met the recent girl-graduate who had spent a painful year on experiments in dredging, and who announced herself as “an engi- neer, thank Heaven, without culture!" He insists, on the contrary, that all boys, what- ever be their special bent and desiination, should be really taught literature—to en- joy poetry and eloquence, to interest themselves in history. and in whatever concerns the life and spirit of mankind. It is not possible to dwell on Sidgwick’'s minute and careful appraisal of the value of classical training and of its defects; but a few striking points miy be summarized. Greek and Latin are not Siamese twins; for educationa) purposes they may be separated with great convenience and advantage. The main objects of the study of an ancient lan- guage may be successfully attained by teaching only one of these two, and for many good reasons that one should be Latin. The vocabulary of Latin is easier to learn and easier to retain; it is profusely mixed and entangled with the vocabulary of Eng- lish, French, Italian, and Spanish—it ex- plains the meanings of many words in all of these languages, and the verbal forms in three of them. It may almost be said that it saves time to begin a study of the Ro- mance languages with a knowledge of Latin; to annex any one of these to Latin is a highly labor-saving process. Moreover, it is a method to be commended for another reason. For the first two years the begin- ner in Latin creeps at a snail's pace, and his soul is fed chiefly on Caesar's ‘Gallic War.’ It helps much to associate with this some easier language which permits more rapid reading, and, for this purpose, none is superior to French. As the final aim in learning an ancient language is to read its literature, the true way to attain this power is to read and to keep on reading, care- fully and with comprehension. To write Latin is a very different matter. It is use- ful to fix the idioms and the grammar; but anything beyond this is surplusage. So far from being a useful introduction to English composition, as some of the schoolmasters contend, it might prove a damage to English style. Neither Shakspere nor Aristophanes had the privilege of such practice. Each language has its.own rhetoric, in a way its own idiom and laws of periodic rhythm. The practice of another language is not likely to further acquaintance with these; it might, indeed, blunt the natural instinct, the unconscious tact which are essential to the bloom of literature. No great stylist ever wrote his best in a foreign tongue— much less, therefore, a great poet. Latin or Greek versification is a sort of embroidery to be cultivated by those who have the. knack of it. Professor Jebb’s lyrics may even be useful practice for an editor of So- phocles or of Pindar. They give pleasure to himself and to scholars. Would they have given pleasure to Pindar? In this general appraisal of the resulis of classical training, Sidgwick compares it with that afforded by the sciences. He re- marks that the discipline derived from the study of language is, within certain limits, analogous to that afforded by the study of any one of the natural sciences; each of them exercises memory, attention, com- parison, generalization, and the application of rules, the habit of applying these with quickness and accuracy, and finally the habit of using the faculty of judgment. Of course, this quasi-scientific discipline does not come at all to the student who avails himself of the short-cuts offered in Bobn’s Library. Nor, again, does the study of language afford the slightest discipline in the most important of the scientific habits—the habit of rea- soning from effects to causes and from causes to effects. For this discipline we look naturally to physics and chemistry. “The training in classification which most immediately fits us for life, is that which the natural sciences afford; the processes which fhe student applies in these, afford just the lessons in method and arrangement which he must apply to any part of the ee eae em ht Sit Baw l ee eae er es Sagara rer

Page 21

Aug. 31, 1905] The Nation. 187 business of life.” So, at least, thinks Sidg- wick, and in this we follow him with some misgiving. The upshot of Sidgwick's heresies goes no further than to recommend that school- boys should receive a substantial course of instruction in English literature and in nat- ural science; and that the study of Latin should be accompanied by the study of French. Greek he would exclude from the earlier stage of the school curriculum; at the age of sixteen a boy who is already wel! grounded in Latin and French would readily grasp sufficient Greek for an ap- preciation of the literature. He is strong- ly opposed to “teaching a large number of things all inadequately and superficially, so that verbal memory is substituted for real apprehension.”” This was the pro- gramme which Sidgwick urged in 1867; he is arguing with schoolmasters who believe in the primacy and the divine right of the classics, and he is obliged to make an ap- peal for a modicum of science and of Eng- lish. It is interesting to see how complete- ly the tables are turned in the present day and in England. The recent debates at Ox- ‘ord, it is true, revealed a few glimpses of the ancient bigotry; and at a meeting of “The Classical Association of England and Wales,’ Professor Ramsay reported from certain enthusiasts—a land agent, a distinguished surgeon, and a general—how in moments of trial they had been sustained by the vigor and dexterity acquired in writing Latin verses. Such pious faith it would be irreverent to gainsay or dispute. But the general tone of that discussion is of men on the defensive, driven back to the entrenchments of sober common sense and practical usefulness. An avowed object of the Association is “‘to improve the practice of classical teaching by free discussion of its scope and methods.” On our side of the water Sidgwick’s pro- gramme offers no surprises. If he had been summoned as privy-councillor, the colleges and universities could hardly have followed his advice more implicitly. We are speaking, of course, of those universi- ties which are something more than groups of technical or strictly professional schools. The predominance of English, the require ment of some science, are firmly estab- lished; the combination of Latin and French or German, or both, is almost universal; while for many years instructors in the classics have been conspicuously sober and moderate—chastened, almost—in their claims. One surprising result of the adop- tion of this scheme of studies is the extra- ordinary pedestal to which Latin has been raised, and its unaccountable popularity. The wise and able report of the “Com- mittee of Twelve’’ experts on classical stu- dies in the secondary schools took final shape in 1898, and presented a remarkable situation. This was, in brief, that while the increase of pupils in the secondary schools, within nine years, far outran the increase of population, the enrolment of pupils in Latin exceeded the rate of in- erease in any other study; it had, in fact, gained 174 per cent., while that in Greek had gained 94 per cent. About one-half of all the pupils took Latin, while about one student in twenty chose Greek. The Com- mittee expected “in the next decade an even more rapid increase in the enrolment in Greek.” This expectation is far from be- ing fulfilled. Commissioner Harris's tables show that in 1902 the total number of stu- dents in Greek had actually fallen off about three thousand from 1898, while the Latin enrolment had gained fifty thousand; al. gebra alone had displaced the supremacy of Latin in the public high schools. Dr. Collar, after a lifetime spent in teach- ing Latin, makes an elaborate confession that he is struck more and more with the difficulties it presents to the tyro. Roger Ascham, who wrote Latin fluently, com- promised slightly with its subjunctives, and managed nevertheless to maintain his scholarly peace of mind. Sidgwick keenly observes that, though Latin grammar forms an excellent introduction to the principles of universal grammar, nine-tenths of the special rules of Latin syntax the or- dinary student may conveniently and cheer- fully forget. All this goes to prove that the vogue of Latin is somewhat artificial; like Greek, though in a less degree, it re- quires to be a protected study. If Latin ceased to be required for admission to col- lege, if it were begun in the university, how long would its extraordinary vogue flourish? Protection in such cases seems entirely justifiable. It is the function of the university not merely to meet the wants of the people, but to dictate to the people, to prescribe de haut en bas their tastes and training. In the realm of intellect “the rule of the many is not good,” a strict democ- racy is impossible. vet It is quite certain that there is some- thing a little artificial in the present de- pression of Greek study in this It has been the subject of a strong and deliberate “‘bear’’ movement. It has been pelted skilfully with epithets which would be successful in any political caucus; it has been called ‘“‘dead,”’ a fetish, and, worst of all, “unpractical."" That word would settle its merits in the eyes of parents who do not reflect that chemistry is unpractical, or mathematics, or any modern language, in a lies fallow and disused in a student's mind after leaving school or college Much more is their judgment influenced when such as- saults are made by men in high places in education. Again, there is no true sense in which a poem of Sappho or a play of Euripides can be called dead. The latest country. single sense, if it vaudeville or melodrama is more accessi- ble, but it is not so much alive. The “Agamemnon” or the “Medea” may out- live “Pelléas et Mélisande,’ or ‘‘The Second Mrs, Tanqueray.”’ The “Lecture against Lecturing,”’ sus- tains with delightful humor and originality a thesis advanced by Darwin in his auto- biography. Why should students be com- pelled to listen to lectures if they can read and digest the same matter at leisure from the printed page, or the instructor can pro- vide it in a printed form? In reading, the quick and clever student can vary his pace and compare passages at his own con- venience; he can skip what is familiar, and dwell on what he finds difficult, and this is a much greater advantage than any help which he derives from the inflections and emphasis of the lecturer. The very act of taking notes interferes with the benefit that might be derived from attention to the speaker's voice and manner. The task of taking notes, at its best, is the task of @ stenographer, and in its fina) result is equivalent to the process of multiplying copies by the printing-press. Neither is it so accurate as printing. The mishears occasionally, and is misled by his own mistakes. He may spell “the unl with an eye as a faithful pupil have in his report of a series of lectures on the doctrines of Trans cendentalism ing, then, in many cases, vival of the media@val invention of printing? There are, of course, exceptions and lim itations. Some be dispensed with and art in which specimens must be introduced, courses which appeal to the emotions or in which the method is dialectic. But in linguistics, in mathematics, in history and student versal It" is said to done Is not the practice of lectur a wasteful sur schools before the classes of lectures cannot for example, those on science experiments or and dis moral science, the ordinary expository le ture is an “antiquated survival.”” The stu dent, if he has any intelligence and eager ness, should first of all be supplied with printed sources, and the lecture should be supplementary, devoted chiefly to explana tions and discussions of difficulties. The lee turer should be encouraged to print his own contributions to science, them in the pupil's hands, instead of holding them back as he does present, if he prints, his secret is out-—he has killed the goose that lays the golden egg, if the com parison be permitted. It is a pity that such and such a_ predicament tramme! the progress of the student It is for the élite that Sidgwick recommends this economy of time. In the case of the ordin ary academic crowd, it may increase, per- haps, the chance of their learning something if they are dragged to stated hours. Yet it is well known that, largest university, students are daily led to such knowledge chiefly in the forenoon hours, and that they successfully escape drinking the refreshing waters. They prefer till the last moment and resort to Sidgwick's ald of the printed pages or abstract; they do this at the end, however, instead of at the begin ning of their terms. Their case is a capital illustration of the futility of lecture-courses for the multitude and the common herd, i! anything accomplished There is a further exception to be made to these strictures A great or unusual per sonality may be so impressive and inspiring that it is more fruitful to listen to him than to read the printed pages. Most of us are fortunate enough to recall instances of this kind—the speaker whose thought flows fresh as he speaks, and kindles the thought of his hearer. Such a gift may warm even a lec ture on Modern Algebra or on the Law of Torts, and the fortunate listener will do well to take a minimum of notes and give the undivided attention of his brains. and pu now At motives should lectures at in our droves of fountains of to wait serious is to be BROWN’S HOGARTH. William Hogarth. By G. Baldwin Brown, M.A. (The Makers of British Art.) Lou- don: The Walter Scott Publishing Co.; New York: Charles Scribner's Sons. 1905 In the preface to this book the author comments on the varied products of Ho garth’s genius, and goes on to say: “The relations of these very different kinds of work to each other and to his whole @were are not easy to Gx, and the

Page 22

Nation. The [Vol. 81, No. 2096 188 judgments of critics on their comparative values have varied from age to age. Hence there is always room for a fresh and in- dependent treatment of Hogarth’s life and art, such as is attempted in the following pages ~ In his own time, and immediately after- wards, Hogarth made such an impression by the obviousness of his moralizing and satirizing that his qualities as a painter were hardly thought of at all, and it was almost forgotten that he painted pictures— not merely designed moral plates to be spread abroad by heap engraving. His earlier commentators were literary men who thought only of his meanings, never of his art, and Charles Lamb conceived he was paying him the highest possible trib- ute when he said: “His graphic repre- sentations are indeed books; . . . other pictures we look at—his prints we read.” Gradually it has dawned upon the world that Hogarth was a sound and admirable painter, if not a brilliant one, and that his little genre pictures, entirely apart from their literary value, are capable of giving a pleasure analogous in kind, if not comparable in degree, to that afforded by the works of the wonderful little Dutch- men; while his portraits, if they have not the sensuous charm of those of Reynolds or Gainsborough, are yet solid and serious presentations of husman personalities. The more his work has been studied from this fresh point of view, the better it has been liked, and there has been a tendency in each new treatment of Hogarth to rank him higher as a painter; but until now no one has had much to say for those “his- torical pictures’ which the artist himself was quite sure were equal to the works of any old master whatsoever, but which no one else could be induced to take se- riously Strangely enough, Hogarth was himself largely responsible for the contempt with which his most ambitious efforts were treated He believed them to be great works, but his hatred of foreigners, his corn of pretence, and his robust self-con- celt led him to minimize the effort they had cost him and the degree of his preparation for them, and to proclaim himself self- taught He shouted aloud: “See how easy it ia! This I did with no study of your Itallans, with no humbug about the grand style, with no training but a habit of ob- servation.”” The world took him at his own valuation, but refused so to take the pletures, and considered them the amateur- ish and rather impudent efforts of an un- educated artist, who had no business to leave his copper-plates and set up for an Listen to Northcote, Sir Joshua's pupil, echoing and exaggerat “As to his large pleces,” he says, “they appear to be the offorta of imbectiity; he was totally with- historical painter ing hia master’s opinions out the practice required for such works.” The orlginality of Professor Brown's book is in his effort to show that these much- Mecried works are far more respectable than they have been thought, and that Ho- garth's preparation for them waa far greater than he chose to believe—that, In fact, he was fairly well grounded in the traditions of art, and worked In the style of his own time and school. “The blunder- ers in the matter of historical painting,” says Professor Brown, “‘were not Hogarth or his predecessors, but the later men of the period after Reynolds, who took them- selves seriously”; and, again: “To Rey- nolds, and through Reynolds to his suc- cessors, this ‘grand’ or ‘historical’ style be- came a mystery that was to be approached in the spirit of a candidate for initia- tion. There is really no mystery about the style. It is simply figure-painting on a monumental scale applied to subjects of a religious, or classical, or allegorical order.” From reading the text alone of this book, one might believe that Professor Brown had fairly well made out his case, and, indeed, an inspection of the plate of “‘The Pool of Bethesda” is sufficient to show that that picture is by no means the work of an audacious innovator relying entirely on his own genius and his personal observation of nature, Its faults are many, but the most obvious of them is its utter conventional- ity. It is an evident piece of imitation of the traditional art of the earlier eigh- teenth century, and, but for its lack of elegance, might be labelled “made in France."’ But because Hogarth was unorig- inal in this work, it does not follow that he was well equipped for it, or because it was done before he was forty that it was not the experiment of a painter trained in another school. The question really re- solves itself into that of the justice of ‘Sir Joshua Reynolds’s strictures on Ho- garth, which are quoted as follows: “After this admirable artist had spent the greater part of his life in an active, busy, and, we may add, successful, attention to the ridicule of life; after he had in- vented a new species of dramatic painting, in which probably he will never be equal- led, . . . he very imprudently, or rath- er presumptuously, attempted the great his- torical style, for which his previous habits had by no means prepared him; he was, indeed, so entirely unacquainted with the principles of this style that he was not even aware that any artificial preparation was at all necessary.” Professor Brown tries to show that Rey- nolds was wrong both in his statement of fact and in his criticism. As to the facts, Appendix I. shows clearly, as the text does not, that Reynolds was substantially right. “Hogarth’'s ambitious efforts at St. Barthol- omew's,”’ says the Professor, “date from an early epoch [1736] in his career.” Now, as Hogarth was born in 1697 and died in 1764, he may quite literally be said to have spent the greater part of his life before 1736. But if that is a quibble, let us con- sider these dates. Hogarth’s first plates date from 1720, his small ‘conversation pieces" in oi] from 1725, so that he had been an engraver for sixteen years and a painter for ten before he tried the grand style. The “Harlot’s Progress” was pub- lished in 1732 and the “Rake’s Progress” in 1735, so that he had certainly invented his “dramatic painting,” and, indeed, per- fected and long practised it, before he be- gan “The Pool of Bethesda."’ Reynolds may have been thinking of the “Sigismunda” of 1759, and have forgotten earlier essays in the same direction; but his instinctive feel- ing that Hogarth had abandoned a style of work in which he was a master for one in which he was a novice, was justified by the facts. As to the criticism, he was still more indisputably in the right. It is all very well to sneer at Reynolds's solemn phrases about the “great historical style,” but, after all, there is something more requisite to the style he called by that name than will @t out an admirable painter of genre. The “grand style” is, if you like, “nothing more than figure-painting on a monumental scale’’; but that scale, and the difference of subject, do demand some “ar- tificial preparation.”’ The composition which is quite satisfactory for a “conversation piece” will not answer for a great mon- umental picture; the observation which will insure the lifelike representation of a bea- dle or a bailiff will not extend to the beau- tiful rendering of the nude figure; the skill in coloring which will make charming a canvas thirty inches long, will not make splendid one of thirty feet. The two arts are eternally different, and success in either does not guarantee success in the other. Probably Veronese could not have painted like Ver Meer—certainly Ver Meer could not have painted like Veronese. That Reynolds himself was but an in- different practitioner in the “grand style” is nothing to the purpose. He could not produce it, any more than could Fuseli or Barry or Haydon, or any other English painter; but he knew what it was, he knew that Hogarth had failed in it, and he had a perfect right to say so. Tu quoque is the poorest of arguments. If Reynolds might not criticise the performance of Ho- garth because his own was little better, what becomes of the right of any of us, including Professor Brown, to criticise Rey- nolds? And that we have discarded the vo- cabulary of eighteenth-century criticism, that we have readjusted the eighteenth- century scheme of values, that we recog- nize a great artist in Chardin and suspect a pompous humbug in Anibale Caracci—all this is no reason for confusing unlike things, and maintaining that Chardin could have decorated the Sistine if he had had the opportunity, or that Hogarth was other than a bungler in his attempts at monu- mental painting. If we have devoted so much space to this topic, which really occupies but a small portion of the book under review, it is be- cause it is the only portion which is espe- cially new. With the exposition of the better known side of Hogarth's art, as with the account of his life, we have no quar- rel. Indeed, it is partly because the volume is much better than the average of the series to which it belongs that we have no- ticed it at such length. But, really, a Pro- fessor of Fine Art in the University of Edinburgh should have a better sense of perspective. The Evolution of the Constitution of the United States of America, and History of the Monroe Doctrine. By John A. Kasson. Houghton, Mifflin & Co. 1904. Mr. Kasson’s account of the Evolution of the Constitution was orig'nally written at the request of the Constitutional Cen- tennial Commission. The first edition was published as a part of two memorial vol- umes, and was soon exhausted. The pres- ent revision is designed to meet a popular demand, and for the use of students of Constitutional law. For this purpose the concise historical method adopted by the author is well fitted. In a couple of hun- dred pages he contrives to give an ac- count of the organization of the Govern- ment (as well as of the events which led to it) in a narrative form, while the pro- ceedings of the Convention are classified by subjects, ¢. g., the legislative power, the pa ee Se

Page 23

Aug. 31, 1905] The Nation. judicial power, the executive power, in the usual way. This ought to be a good hand- book for beginners, but is not a_ law- book, and does not cover the field occu- pied by such a book as Cooley's well-known treatise. Fifty pages are added on the history and theory of the Monroe Doctrine, which Mr. Kasson declares “has acquired so much authority, both at home and abroad, that its influence over our people and their representative statesmen has become almost equal to that of a provision of the National Constitution.”” We do not know that Mr. Kasson’s theory of the Doc- trine is original, but it is certainly very comprehensive, and we suppose reflects pretty accurately the views of those now in power. We cannot witness any new colonization by European Powers, nor any new European military or naval position “in whatever way acquired’; nor, again, the transfer to any other European Power of any existing colony. Mr. Kasson ad- mits that the Doctrine is not a part of in- ternational law, and does not bind other nations, but thinks it an effective reply that the European doctrine of the Balance of Power was not international law either. But this is not the real crur of the Mon- roe Doctrine. The Balance of Power was quasi-international law for such nations as assented to it, though it might in- fringe the rights of others; the Dectrine is in conflict with the ordinarily recognized rights of every nation, and hence, if it is permanent, must be imposed upon us single-handed. Mr. Kas- son seems to think that our correlative obligation not to colonize cr interfere in Europe makes it a two-sided arrangement; but since we have taken the Philippines from a European Power, in the quarter of the globe where expansion is most attrac- tive, this is neither obvious nor maintain- able. The Doctrine, as here expounded, prohib- its any European Power from settling ques- tions at issue with American Siates as it otherwise might. Such a power may make war, but may not secure the fruits of con- quest; it may collect debts by seizure of custom houses, or by other measures “short of war,’ but may not permanently hold any- thing. On the other hand, we notice (p. 269) that our relations with Canada are already causing “‘anxiety to thoughtful American statesmanship,”’ from which there now appears no certain issue “‘except its independence.” If we ask ourselves what the Doctrine, so interpreted, means, not to us, but to Eu- rope, it is impossible to avoid the conclu- sion that it creates for the United States a virtual protectorate of the American continent. If we shield Venezuela or San Domingo from the consequences of their acts, we assume a responsibility for these governmen's which we can never escape. Thus, the Doctrine is actually producing a receivership of San Domingo under our pro- tection, while our fatherly interest in Vene- zuela is leading no one knows yet to what. In the end we shall probably escape from such consequences as we do not like by dis- regarding the extreme view of the Doctrine here put forth; but why is it necessary to have a “doctrine” at all? The devotion to it of shrewd, long-headed public men like Mr. Kasson is always a little surprising to us, It seems with American politicians to have taken the hold upon their minds which to be the world by religious dogma might énce have gained and any new definition of it becomes moré and more positive and less and less prac- ticable. After all. the relations of with one another can no more be regulated by a doctrine than the relations of indi- viduals. To educate people to regard it as a fetish is full of danger, may add, absurdity. States and, one In and Around Venice. By Horatio F. Brown. London: Rivingtons. 1905. It is many years since Mr. Horatio Brown began those delightful sketches of Venic¢ which he subsequently gathered into a vol- ume entitled ‘Life on the Lagoons.’ They showed him to be better qualified than any other Englishman of his time for writing such skeiches. He had lived long in Venice, not as a foreigner, but as one in full sym- pathy with the people; he loved their cus- toms, their legends, their life; he had a marked talent for description, and a thor- ough acquaintance with the fine arts; and, later, he made himself conversant with Ve- netiaa history. So his sketches were not the mere impressions or emotions of the passing foreign tourist, but such intimate revelations as a cultivated Venetian might have made for his English friends. Mr. Brown's new volume characteristics. The very wide; it includes seven papers ‘In the City,” as many more “On the Lagoon,” and nine “In the Country.” As an introduc- tion, there is a general rambling essay on Venice, which, in of many attrac- tive parts, gives one the impression of be- ing a warming over of material which Mr. Brown more appetizingly at other times. The short papers vary as wide- ly in subject as in treatment. Here one finds a careful account of the Campanile of San Marco and the loggetta of Sansovino followed by a diagrammed description of the columns in the Piazzetta, which an archi- tect might prize; there he describes, with vivid realism, floods on the mainland, or, with an Alpinist’s enthusiasm, relates his ascent of Pavione. His trips to the main land, including a voyage to Istria, furnish several papers on out-of-the-way places which one is glad to see through his eyes Very keen eyes they are, missing no detail of nature or of art, and so sensitive to color that many of his descriptions might be a landscape painter’s memoranda. Mr. Brown has the happy gift of desultori- ness. He can, if required, write a matter- of-fact statement; but more often his style goes clad in agreeable garb, and he pauses at will to throw in a reflection, or to ex- plain an historical difficulty, or to tell a story. Being saturated with Venetian lore, he rarely introduces it of set purpose. It is in this lack of insistence, in this ability to suggest an atmosphere, that he differs from most alien writers on Venice. Take the ‘Italian Backgrounds’ of Mrs, Wharton, for instance, and you will find them by comparison the work of a foreigner; de- lightful work of their kind, and revealing a sympathetic understanding of Italy, yet still foreign—just as Symonds’s sketches are— with a didactic or an insistent manner of discussing aft and life which Mr. Brown long since outgrew. Some of his papers are slight, and in others there are repeti- tions; but, taken as a whole, this volume the same topics is has variety of Spite has served is a@ worthy successor to ‘Life on thé Lagoons.’ Eesais d Histoire Diplomatique i mericaine Par Achille Viallate Paris: Guilmoto 1905, The favorable impression produced by M Viallate’s the best be described as a Although thirds of with such burning book is result of what may cumulative the or lately burning, ques process two matter deals tions as Panama and the Spanish War, y« from his first to his last page thers not one heated word, not one opinion pu forward denoting bias of any sort When such a frame of mind is united to the larg: and accurate knowledge that is to be ex pected from a professor at the Paris School of Political the but be valuable. M. Viallate deals with three subjects, all related: the two just the expansion of the American His method is strictly historical, and his great merit is that, to look for his facts yet he gives which, alas, is its due place as The American reader is new to him in the account ous questions, but certain inevitableness of political develop- ment that the centuates. The slips are on the whole unimportant, Sclence, result cannot mentioned, and people although he is accustomed in diplomatic public very papers, American opinion often undiplomatic a rightful political factor find little that of these struck will vari- may be by a author constantly ac- and the proper names are so much more correctly given than is usual in French books, that the occasional mistakes must not be complained of. There are two or three points, however, to which the author's attention may be drawn. In his picture of our relations with Spain the years preceding the civil war, and particu- larly the period of Mr. Soulé’s agitated mis sion, are inadequately treated. The same remark applies to the Panama Congress From M. Viallate’s account, it would ap pear that Admiral Ammen approved the Panama route, whereas at the Congress he supported Nicaragua. More generally, it may be said that it was incumbent on the author, however distasteful to a French man, to state clearly that the Pana- ma Congress was packed, that its vote was worthless, and that De Lesseps went into knew nothing about; this what one had a right aspect of the subject by M French an enterprise he was the minimum of to look for on that In two places, sourerainecté is control used Viallate for the word is too wide, and in a diplomatic docu ment the alteration of sense might in- volve very large consequences. In con clusion, it may be said that a translation of this work might be of great use io students at our colleges, who could but gain by studying our own history ap proached from the standpoint of such a de tached, temperate, and informed observer our word not BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Auchincloss, W. 8. The Book of Daniel Unlocked LD. Van Nostrand Bible, Howard W George D. Smith Chariton, Jobn. 5%; ‘hes and Addresses, Political lAterary, and Keligious. Terovto: Morang & Co Giddie, John. Romantic Edinburgh. §2 Mw Hope, Anthony. A Servant of the Public. Fred erick A. Stokes Co Kemp, N. 8 Ande Trembath. OC. M. Clark Pub lishing Oo, Le. Tides of Thought« New York

Page 24

190 Henry Holt & Co. 20 W. 231 ST... NEW YORK A NEW EDITION RE-WRITTEN AND UP-TO-DATE , s. $5.00 of Wallace’s Russia Pci “In the same class as Mr. Bryce’s American Commonwealth.""—LONDON TIMES Next to the revised edition of Mackenzie Wal- lace’sa monumental work, the most useful account the actual condition of the Czerar's dominions will be found in "NN, ¥. SON Russia From Within 61.75 net. Russian By ALEXANDER ULAR. Revolu- The author believes that the tion has already begun. His book analyzes the personality of the Romanoff rulers, the ecanomic and governmental, moral and social condition of Russia He tlumines his conclusions by all manner of Information and anecdote. He carries his reader along with him by a style that is clear, eloquent, and witty, with now and then a touch of pathos 1.50 net. Our Philippine Problem »,*rsi,ti0 fy Prof. H. P. Willis of Washington and Lee University, former editorial writer on the ve- ning Post, ete. A frank discussion of our colonial administration based on personal investigation. Pedagogues and Parents By Evia Catista WILson $1.25 net By mall $1.37 An extremely entertaining’’ book by a thought- ful educator who is first a parent beok to set tongues and pens to wagging.’’— riMES BOOK REVIEW » teacher but will be alded by reading the conelusions and eriticisms.’’—SCHOOL JOURNAL. he triumphant talk of a gifted woman.’’— CHRISTIAN REGISTER. We can heartily recommend it to both (ped “cogues and parents) as an entertaining and stive contribution.’’—N. Y. TRIBUNE, \ N. ¥ Nx SUuxkE Rhetoric in Practice NEWOOMER and SAMUEL & By Prof. ALruonso G Sewarp, Ja., of Leland Stanford. 285 pp. 1@mo, 0c. net rhe backbone of the book is its written themes and oral clase exercises, which are fresh, inter- esting, and bring the composition work of the stu inte direct contact with his everyday life Each division of the subject is treated as a unit sod may be taken up in any desired order. The teacher can start, for example, with Words, or or Punetuation, or Paragraphs, venlently as with the Forms of Discourse Iie is thus enabled to adjust the book to the training and capacity of any given clam. Sentences Gioethe’s Iphigenie auf Tauris Edited by Prof. Max Wrivkuer, University of Michi Hic. net gar ev.+211 pp The introduction gives a particularly fall account of the growth of the play and its relation to the tireck sources Schiller’s Poems Edited by Prof. J. 8. Nouian, of Indiana University sll1.4 581 pp. S80c. net A selection of poemea thoroughly representative of the different periods of Schiller’s ife and work. Schiller’s Dreizigjahrigen Krieges Edited by Prof. A. 1. Patmwen of Yale With vocabulary, xxx114+844080 pp. S85c, net. The Third Book of Schiller’s THIRTY YEARS’ WAR le recommended by the Committee of Twelve it is here presented in a form especially adapted based on “Passy — Ram to echool purposes “u's Chreastomathie an _ A French Reader wav ¢ Ty Dr. A. WaAMBeAU Of he Kansas City High School. 144 pp. Se. net Daudet’s Robert Helmont Edited by W. O. Fanneworru of Yale lary, tx+00400 pp. 400. net A vivid account of the siege of Paris and the impressions produced by it upon an eyewitness. Erckmann-Chatrian ; Waterloo Edited by V. & Frangore of the Coltege of the City of New York. With vocabulary. «14145441 pp. 40c. net. France’s Le Livre de Mon Ami ROOK itl WUh vocabu = [Vol. 81, No. 2096 he Nation. THE MUSES’ LIBRARY A Choice Edition of the Poets, Under the Editorship of A. H. Bullen. 16mo, Cloth, 50c. per Volume. Leather, $1.00 per Volume. THE MUSES’ LIBRARY occupies a high and unique place among editions of the Poets. the general reader. BLAKB, W.: Edited by W. B. Yeats. BROWN OF TAVISTOCK: 2 vols. Edited by Gordon Goodwin. Introduction by A. H. Bullen. CAREW: Edited, with introduction, by Arthur Vincent. COLERIDGE, 8. T.: Edited, with introduction, by Richard Garnett. DONNE: 2 vols. Edited by E. K. Ohambers and introduction by George Saintsbury. DRUMMOND OF HAWTHORNDEN: 2 vols. Edited, with introductory memoir, by W. C. Ward. EARLY ITALIAN PORTS, together with Dante's Vita Nuova: Translated and prefaced by D. G. Rossetti. GAY: 2 vols. Edited, with introductory memoir, by John Underhill. HERRICK: 2 vols. Edited, with Life, by A. W. Pollard, and prefaced by Swin burne. E. P. DUTTON & COMPANY, It is edited by men of the first rank in literature, and fully serves the student as well as JOHNSON, GOLDSMITH, GRAY, and COLLINS: Edited, with introduction, by T. M. Ward. KEATS: 2 vols. Edited, with critical introduc- tion, by Robert Bridges, and a biographical memotr. MARVELL: 2 vols. Edited, with introduction, and biographical notes, by G. A. Aitken. MORRIS (Sir L.): Authorized selection. PATMORE: Introduction by Alice Meynell. POP: A biographical sketch by Nathan H. Dole. PROCTOR, ADELAIDE: With a chaplet of verses not hitherto reprinted. TENNYSON: Poems from 1830—1869. VAUGHAN: 2 vols. Edited, with biography, by W. K. Chambers, and a critical introduction by Canon Beeching. WALLER: 2 vols. Edited, with introduction, by G. Thorn Drury. Other volumes to follow. 31 WEST 23D STREET, NEW YORK, CHESTERTON George Bernard Shaw and others, NAPOLEON THE FIRST PHASE By OSCAR BROWNING, THE DUKE OF REICHSTADT By EDWARD VON WERTHEIM WILLIAM WATSON BEACONSFIELD TROLLOPE Over 100 Beautiful Reproductions A new Book of Essays, by GILBERT K. CHESTERTON, entitled HERETICS. wherein are set forth the ‘* Heresies” of Rudyard Kipling, W. B. Yeats, Omar and the Omarites, Some chapters on the Boyhood and Youth of Bonaparte. 1769-1793. “Deserves a place beside Lord Rosebery’s LAST PHASE.”"—N. Y. Tribune, The first authentic account of P's ill-starred son, ** L’AIGLON ” With numerous Illustrations, two Photogravure Portraits, and a Facsimile Letter . Mr. Watson's complete and authoritative collection of his POEMS. Edited and arraged with an Introduction by T. A. Spender. 24mo. (6 x 3% inches.) Cloth, 75 ceats net per vol. A Reissue of the Novels of the Earl of Beaconsfield. thin and opaque paper, Each with an Introduction by the Earl of The Novels of Trollope in the same series, NEW POCKET LIBRARY. ART IN PHOTOGRAPHY Special Supplement to THE INTERNATIONAL STUDIO. of American All Illustrations mounted as Separate Full Page Ill $1.50 net With Portraits. 8vo. $3.50 net 8vo. Ornamental Cloth, $5.00 net 2 vols. 12mo. $2.50 net ther, $1.00 = per vod. on specially made desleigh. From clear t ~~ “ee its and sagene Work. 16 Photogravures. ustrations. FOHN LANE COMPANY, New York THE BODLEY HEAD, 67 FIFTH AVENUE “A Delightful XIIIth Century Allegory’ The Lady Poverty Sacrum Commercium Beati Fr Domina Paupertate. [Circa A. D. 1287.) Translated by MONTGOMERY CARMICHAEL. 209 pages; cloth, gilt. $1.75 postpaid, TENNANT & WARD, 287 Fourth Ave., New Yor, Edited by Prof. O. G, @ugRLAc, of Cornell, xxlll + 154 pp. 40c. net. Autoblographical and one of the most characteris tie productions of this well-known author. SEND FOR New Announcement Lists G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS, 27 ‘West 23d St, N.Y. JUST PUBLISHED Mrs. Jim and Mrs. Jimmie The new book by the author of THE SECOND MRS. JIM Burns Collection For Sale Advertiser who has for many years collected edi- tions of and works relating to Burns, ecb Gaeta ee Gases acne a act

Page 25

Aug. 31, 1905] The Nation. vil The Highest Standard} BEST NEW BOOKS Robinson’s Selections from the Public and ? Private Law of the Romans oe Oe Edited by James J. Robinson, Ph... formerly iastractor in Latin, Yale University, || Gleason’s Greek Prose Composition By Clarence W. Gleason, A.M., Roxbury Latin School. Walker’s Essentials in English History ° By Albert Perry Walker, A.M., Master in History, English High Seventeenth Edition School, Boston. In consultation with Albert Bushnell Hart, LL.D., | Professor of History, Harvard University. Revised to 1905 | Hart’s Essentials in American History By Albe.t Bushnell Hart, Professor of History, Harvard Untversity BY A. W. REINOLD, M.A., F.R.S. Pearson’s Essentials of Latin for Beginners... $0.90 By Henry C. Pearson, Horace Mann Schoo!, Teachers Coll Professor of Physics Royal Naval New York. College, Greenwich, England oe ee ee Harry’s Aeschylus. Prometheus Edited by J. E. Harry, Ph. D., Professor of Greek, Univ. of Cincinnati WM. WOOD AND COMPANY Lamberton’s Thucydides. Books If. and III. $1.75 Edited by W. A. Lamberton, A.M., Ltt.D., Professor of Greek, 51 Fifth Avenue University of Peunsylvania. NEW YORK § Burton’s Selections from Livy Edited by Harry E. Burton, Ph.D., Associate Professor of Dartmouth College Mather's Caesar. Episodes from the Gallic and Civil Wars .. Edited by Maurice W. Mather, Ph.D., formerly instructor Latin, Harvard University. LIBRARY SERVICE We aim to serve librarians with the greatest efficiency. We have (1.) Competent and thoroughly equipped book men (2) The largest miscellaneous book stock in New York City. @.) A valuable tine of order lists —as follows A. Monthly Bulletin of the Lat. est and Best Selling Books. B. Standard Library Catalogue. Cc, Clearance Catalogue. Do You Cet These? Sent Free. THE BAKER & TAYLOR Co. WHOLESALE BOOKSELLERS, 33.37 E. 17th St., Union Sq., North, New Y ork Send for complete illustrated Descriptive Catalogue of High School and College Text-Books AMERICAN BOOK COMPANY New York Cincinnati Chicago Boston A MODERN AND DAINTY SHAKESPEARE A New Pocket Edition of the Complete Works of WILLIAM SHAKESPEARE Edited by ISRAEL GOLLANCZ This latest edition of Shakespeare is a complete handy-volum: set of the Plays, Sonnets, and Poems, adapted for use in schools and colleges, as well as for the purposes of private reading. li follows the latest Cambridge text of William Aldis Wright. Introductiors to the differeat volumes, and the c»mmentary which follows the text of each play, are by Dr. Israel Gollancz, the well known Shakesperian scholar and editor. The type used is long primer, and the text is never crowded. This is the cheapest large-type edition of Shakespeare ever before the public. [ts ccnvenient size, 4x6 inch cover, total weight 3 oz., clear typogra- phy, strong opaque paper, and subs antial binding unite to make it attractive and serviceable. 40 PLAYS AND POEMS. UNIFORM BINDING, 18mo. Special Form for Schools and Reading Clubs, flexibie cloth, illuminated covers, 15 cents net; Postage 2 cents extra Cloth, per volume ........ SEE AE Be borcccce 25 cents | Flexible leathe:, illu@trated........... ».+»I0 cents DANA ESTES & CO., Publishers, Boston a Sanne SS —~———

Page 26

Viii The Nation. FOUR MODERN CLASSICS TUDOR JENKS In the Days of Chaucer In the Days of Shakespeare In the Days of Milton In the Days of Scott Here is the way ancient England appeals to the popular mind. Tudor Jenks is the worldly wise scholar, a man of pop- ular mould. To read after him is to walk the streets and mix with the living people of old England. He has made the merry-hearty England of Chaucer's time live in our imagination. He creates again our Shakespsare for us— Will Shakespeare, the boy in Stratford, the young man who went to seek his fortune in London and later returaed to the life of a country gentleman, a sportsman and a neighbor. ‘ The England of John Milton is the England from which America drew its life, and Mr. Jenks has pictured Milton, the affectionate friend, the blind seer, the lonely prophet of a great new world. This remarkable set is completed by the story of Walter Scott, his comrades and his romances. Dr. A. J. George, Professor of English in the Newton High School, says that he shall put these books in the way of his pupils as “tempting morsels.” Price $1.00 Each Illustrated. A. S. BARNES & COMPANY, NEW YORK Memoirs of Henry Villard JOURNALIST AND FINANCIER 1835-1900 [wo volumes, with Portraits and Maps, $5.00 net. Postage, 35 cts. An autoblographical record of the varied and romantic career of the war journalist who subse- juently became a power in the financial world, and carried the Northern Pacific Railroad to comple tion =Fullof incident and valuable for its reminiscences of Lincoln and other prominent men of the time, as well as for ita descriptions of important battles of the Civil War. ‘A book of extraordinary interest. It is written with great ability, ia a clear and flowing style; it details with perfect candor the incidents of a great career; it isan admirable report of great allof which the writer saw, and a large part of which (after 1870) he was; it exhibits the rise growth of a rich and powerful personality and a character at once remarkable for its simplicity and ite variety.”—Jous Warre Caapwic«, in the New York Times Saturday Review ‘This p sthumous autobiography of the late Henry Villard is a work of exceptional Interest.""— Commeretal and Maancial Chronioie, November 12, 1904, HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO., Boston & New York + {Vol Se, No. 2096 School Trustees, Principals. Teachers, And others interested, are invited to consider the advantages offered by the ation as an advertising medium. School advertisements are printed in a uniform typography, with the ad- dress in the first line, classification being made by States, alphabetically, unless especially ordered displayed on other pages. The Nation, in its special field of political and literary criticism is un- like any other periodical, American or foreign. About 10,000 cop.es are circulated weekly, but these figures do not accurately represent the num- It is taken by reading clubs and literary associations ber of its readers. in a large number of places, and may be found on file in every iibrary of importance in the country. There are probably few weekly periodicals whose columns offer so favorable an opportunity for reaching an audience interested in educational matters. Advertising rates, 15 cents a line each insertion, with the following dis- counts: 5 per cent, on 4 insertions, 10 per cent on 8 insertions, 12% per cent. on 13 insertions, 15 per cent. on 26 insertions, 20 per cent. on 39 in- sertions, 25 per cent. on 52 insertions. The Nation is sent free while ad- vertisemeat continues. Orders may be forwarded through any responsible advertising agency, or directly to Tue Nation, 208 Broadway, N, Y. To receive the current numbers ina convenient (temporary) form. Sub- stantially made, bound in cloth, with Taz Na- TION stamped on the side in gold. Holds about one volume. Papers ecastly and neatly adjusted. Bent, postpaid, on re- Ceilpt of 75 cents.

Page 27

te.