The Nation 1905-04-13: Vol 80 Iss 2076
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
GENERAL LIBRARY} UNIV. OF MICH. APR 14 1905 The N; atl a Asvagyy {Us20a1,) 28g VOL. LXXX—NO. 2076. THURSDAY, APRIL 13, 1905. PRICE TEN CENTS. «The Messrs. McClurg are doing a great service to historical students by the publication of their series of reprints of Americana. In this series we have already had the pleasure of noticing the beautiful editions of the ‘Journals of Lewis and Clark, in many ways superior to the edition at ten times the cost now being issued by a New York publisher. In it are also Father Hennepin’s ‘A New Discovery’ and Gass’s ‘Journal of the Lewis and Clark Expedition. The makeup of these volumes is of high character in paper, printing, and binding, the work leaves nothing to be desired, and the manner of their editing calls forth large praise from those versed in the subject of early American history. The series deserves a place in every library, and will without doubt receive universal ac- ceptance.”—Bastimore Sun. MCCLURGS LIBRARY REPRINTS OF AMERICANA Seldom has the perfection of modern bookmaking, as evidenced by noble and dignified simplicity, been so nearly attained as in these beautiful volumes. The four titles so far issued, uniform in style, makeup, and binding, are published in two forms. The regular edition in cloth, and the large paper edition on Brown’s hand-made paper with illustrations on Japan vellum, and bound in boards, with vellum backs stamped in gold. The Expedition of Lewis and Clark | Gass’s Journal of the Lewis and Clark Expedition Reprinted from the edition of 1814. In two volumes, with introduction Reprinted from the edition of 1811. In one volume, with an Introduction by James K. Hosmer, LL.D., an analytical Index, new portraits, and fac- by James K. Hosmer, LL.D., an analytical Index, facsimiles of the origina! simile maps. Limited edition. $15.00 ner. Library edition, $5.00 net. illustrations, and a rare portrait. Limited Edition $9.00 mer. Library edition, 7 $3.50 net Hennepin’s «A New Discovery’’ Lahontan’s «New Voyages to North America’”’ An exact reprint of the edition of 1698. In two volumes with an Intro- An exact reprint of the English edition of 1703. In two volumes, with duction, Notes, and an analytical Index by Reuben Gold Thwaites, LL.D., Introduction, Notes, and analytical Index, by Reuben Gold Thwaites, LL. D., facsimiles of the original title-pages, maps, and illustrations, Limited edi- bibliography by Victor Hugo Paltsits, and facsimile maps and illustrations tion, $18.00 net, Library edition, $6.00 ner. Limited edition, $18.00 ner. Library edition, $6.00 ner *," Send for large descriptive circulars, A. C. McCLURG & CO., Publishers, Chicago
Page 2
The Nation. [Vol. 80, No. 2076
The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TC Politics, Literature, Science and Art. FOUNDED IN 1865. {Entered at the New York City Post Office as second-class mail matter. | CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. Wa WE soi eco cccvcscc sie cccccsecocccdccdssscdbees . 279 EDITORIAL ARTICLES: President Hadley on Railways............ 282 The Canadian Scheol Question . <a 282 Rozhestvensky in the East...... em 283 Biletory at GUBSOEE. oc ccccscccevececrescnce 284 SPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE: Parliamentary Decadence in Italy . 285 ‘1815’ oe ae RA TSE eo ppc ee CORRESPONDENCE: The President and Judge Kohisaat.......... 288 THO CRE CORNNIOR ook ccc vecenecseaves 288 PeORtrict CHO TUMERBE. oc cesicscecacdersecece 288 WUOGE GEE TOD 6 asc ctnvavcspscessecinse Be The Chek PROLCRROT 200s dc csc ctcedscnsdcn 289 POUSOCO CORRS obs cs sowie shee ett ee ten esa 289 Nores nbs) 0d es enebenenns bo cepatasaweences 289 Book Reviews:
OOOE POOTET «o's 0 05.009. 0¥'00'0'sb.00 008s ba bane 292 VORGE © REND 6 cacccvsesttscussviuens 295 A Gardener's Year Svecaveeiseuennaee Can 206 The Long Ago and the Later On.......... 206 _.... 2. SRA Sa ea reas: 207 Oe eer rrr et eee 297 Co Eero rer ror er 208 Dunte’s Divina Commedia . 5o niko 0 6 RF ear errs 209 Type Studies from the Geography of the United States y DOC CF I ein aon cant senesced acca censcescans 299 TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three dollars per year in advance, postpaid, in an part ofthe United States or Canada; to foreign countries comprised in the Postal Uni-n $4.00, The date when the subscription expires is on the address label of each paper, the change of which to a subsequent date becomes a receipt for a remut- tance. No other receipt is sent unless requested, Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter, or by check, express or- der or Postal Order payable to “* Publisher of the Nation,”’ When a change of address is desired, both the o'd and new addresses should be given, Address THE NATION, Box 794, New York. Publication Office, 208 Broadway. TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Pifteen cents per agate line, each insertion; 1; lines to the inch. Twenty per cent, advance for choice of page or top of column A column, $20 each inssertion; wtth chotce of page, $4. A pajye, $60 each insertion ; front cover page, $80. Advertis: ments muat be acceptable in every re- speet, Copy received until Tuesday, 6 P. M. DISCOUNTS. Time 4 insertions onnebnes . 5 per cent, a “ ‘ soo ~ { o : eo ooeennn - 26 Pe ‘ 13* ” fiw ” . ....80 “ 62 * . . . 86 bad AMOUNT. $100 withina year : sveeses LO per cent, 250 “ ye - Wig ** i “ , Kees 16 e 70 86° oe eehaed os eryy: | - 1,000 “ OT rT eS Ba 1,500 “ ee a ‘ 8O “ 2,000 “ si sovesecees 33% * THE NATIONis sent free to those who advertise tn t as long as advertisement continues. *.* Copies of the Nation may be procured in Paris at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de l'Opera; in London of B. F. Stevens & Brown, Trafalgar Square, Charing Cross. é Important New Text-Books
Revised Edition of Rolfe’s Shakespeare Price, 56 cents per volume The volumes of this new edition have been entirely revised and reset, and appear with every possible mechanical improvement The books are smaller and more convenient in shape, and p!entifully supp!icd with attractive_ illustrations. The changes made in revision reflect the results of the editor's studies and the experience gained by the use of the firs edition. Earle’s Medea of Euripides $1.25 In this edition of the Medea, special attention has been given to the re- construction of the Greek text, in which the best authenticated conjectural readings have been incorporated These changes, and other matters of textual criticism, are exhaustively treated in the appendices. An extended and scholarly introduction fully discusses the life and works of Euripides, Keller’s Bilder aus der Deutschen Litteratur Revised Edition, $1.00 In the present edition of this popular book there have been added 134 pages, which contain longer selections from the principal German authors, rendering the work as much a book for reading as for study. The author gives, in twenty-one chapters, a survey of the German language and litera- ture during the most important epochs.
An illustrated descriptive catalogue of High School and College Text-Books will be sent to any address on request. Correspon- dence is cordially invited and will receive prompt and careful attention.
Gateway Series of English Texts General Editor, HENRY VAN DYKE A series of eighteen volumes, which includes all the college entrance requirements in English. The books are convenient in form, attractively and substantially bound, and printed from clear type. The editing of these volumes is carefully and judiciously done, the actual needs and capacities of young people having been borne in mind. Spieker’s Greek Prose Composition $1.30 Intended for use in colleze classes, this book gives for the ordinary course one hundred and twenty exercises, followed by .wenty-five based especially upon Demosthenes and Plato. The introduction does not try to take the place of grammar, but gives merely the main points which will be of special assistance to the student. Kayser and Monteser’s Brief German Course $1.20 This introductory German Course provides careful drill upon pronun- ciation; memorizing and frequent repetition of easy colloquial sentences: drill upon the rudiments of grammar ; exercises in word formation; and the read- ing of graded and connected selections in prose and poetry.
AMERICAN BOOK COMPANY New York Cincinnati Chicago Boston
di vatitanoins etittsdinaDcke detail Pinker eenctige ren
=
Page 3
April 13, 1905] The Nation. il BOOKS FOR SCHOOLS AND COLLEGES ROGET’S THESAURUS of English Words and Phrases. New Enlarged Edition. Cloth, $1.50; with Index, $2.00. Half Calf, $3.00. “A dictionary of synonyms isa necessity to every student and writer, Roget's Thesaurus has been for many years regarded as the one complete and perfect book of the kind in the language.” SOCIAL THEORY By John Bascom. Cleth, $1.75. “ Very practical and ethically stimulating."— The Adv .nce PUNISHMENT AND REFORMATION By F. MH. Wines, LL.D. Cloth, $1.75. “ Will educate its readers ina subject on which there is. as yet, alto gether too much sentimentality on the one hand, and brutal severity on the other.’ —N, Y. Ubserver. AMERICAN CHARITIES By Amos G. Warner, Ph.D. Cloth, $1.75. ‘‘As a manual on a subject of the most vital importance the a model."’"— Boston Advertiser. SOCIALISM AND SOCIAL REFORM By Richard T. Ely, Ph.D., LL.D. Cloth, $1.50. “ Here for the first time the public is presented with a ful! and ac- curate account of socialism as it is,""—Chicago Times ECONOMICS OF FORESTRY By B. B. Fernow, N. Y. State Coll. of Forestry. $1 1.50 net, (Postage, 15 cta.) “ No other book of likeauthority. To be commended in the highest terms."’— Phila. Public Ledger THE POETRY OF BROWNING By Stopford A. Brooke. $1.50 net. (Postage, 15 cts) * The most satisfactory and stimulating criticism of this poet yet published.""—London Timea. FRENCH LITERATURE By Ferdinand Brunetiere. Cloth, $2.00. ** This is a real history, the best history of French literature in exist- | ence.’’—Prof, E, A. GROSVENOR ' THE BIBLE AS LITERATURE | By Drs. Moulton, Peters, Bruce and others. Introduction by Lyman Abbott. $1.50. “One of the most important analyses of the subject that has ever been attempted." - Commercial Advertiser, DURUY’S GENERAL HISTORY Translated and edited by Prof. E. A. Grosvenor. | 2s colored maps. $2.00. | 4 “The most satisfactory world bistory of its kind in existence.”— a Public Opinion, DURUY’S ANCIENT HISTORY. DURUY’S MIDDLE AGBS. DURUY’S MODERN TIMES. Being Parts I., book is Maps, index, $1.00 Maps, index, $0.75 Maps, index, $1.00 Il., and lll., of the ‘‘General History,’’ Edited by Prof. E. A. Grosvenor. “TI know of no historical hand-book of equal comprehensiveness which is at once so 4 to date, so authoritative, and so attractively writ- ten.”’—WiLuiaM F. Warren, President of Boston University, DURUY’S HISTORY OF FRANCE Q Translated and edited by Prof. J. F. Jameson. : 12 colored maps, $2.00. y “The best of all short summaries of French history.” 2 WHITE. -AN DREW D. CONTEMPORARY HISTORY By Prof. E. A. Grosvenor. Maps and Index, $2.00. “A compact and handy volume of reference.’ — Review of Reviews. IRRIGATION By F. H. Newell, Chief U. S. Hvdrographer. net. (Postage, 20 cts.) “Nothing on the su ba has been published for years so effective, clear, and popular.’’—The Lilerary Werid. Be terete ee 156 Illustrations. $2.00 a REI, Erno meneenliyeamns FOX DUFFIELD & CO 36 EAST 21ST, NEWYORK De FDS | THOMAS Y. CROWELL & CO., 426-8 West Broadway, New York PUBLISHERS OF THE ———— INTERNATIONAL QUARTERLY. OLD MASTERS AND NEW By Kenyon Cox, Essays in art criticism, by one of the foremost American painters. THE CASE OF RUSSIA A Composite View. By ALFRED RamBavp, VLADIMIR SimKovitcs, J. Novicow, Peter Roperts, ani Issac A. Hovawica. $1.25 net; postage 10 cents, HERBERT SPENCER By Prof. Jostan Royce, of Harvard, with a chapter of personal reminiscence by James Cottier, Spencer's secretary. 13 cents. $1.50 net; postage 10 cents. Cloth, $1.25 net ; postage CROZIER’S GENERAL ARMORY (2¢ £éition) A registry of American families entitled to coat armor. Cloth $3.00 net; leather $4.00 net ; THE VIRGINIA COUNTY RECORDS: Vol. L. Spottsylvania Published under the auspices of The Genealogical Asscciation: including Wills, Deeds, Marriage License Bonds, Guardians’ Bonds, Administration Bonds, and Revolutionary Pensioners. Limited to 1,000 copies. $10.00 net; postage extra. ; TEN GIRLS FROM DICKENS By Kare Dickinson Sweetser. A charming introduction to Dickens, for young folk; with pictures by G. A. Williams. MISREPRESENTATIVE MEN By Capt, Harry Granam; illustrations by F. Strothmann. j EVERYMAN (34 edition) The Fifteenth Century Morality Play. $1.00 postpaid. i THE INTERNATIONAL QUARTERLY | “The best of our serious reviews.” — Evening Post, New York, w# FOX, DUFFIELD & COMPANY, postage 10 cents. Cloth, $2.00, (jd Edition) Pleasantly satirical verses on * Misrepresentative” celebrities from Adam down. $1.00 $4.00 a year; $1.00 single numbers, New York ~&
Page 4
lv The Nation. [Vol. 80, No. 2076 FOR READERS AND STUDENTS BLISS PERRY’S STUDY OF PROSE FICTION EVA MARCH TAPPAN’S WILLIAM EDWARD SIMONDS’ THOMAS WENTWORTH HIGGINSON and H. W. BOYNTON’S READER’S HISTORY OF AMERICAN LITERATURE SHORT HISTORY OF ENGLAND’S LITERATURE (JUST PUBLISHED) STUDENT’S HISTORY OF ENGLISH LITERATURE 1.25 1.25 85 1.25 BOSTON NEW YORK HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & COMPANY CHICAGO WILLIAM R. JENKINS 851 & 853 Sixth Ave. N. W. Cor. 48 St., New York. 3 No Branch Stores. Publish the Bercy, Du Croquet, SauveuR, and other standard methods for teaching FRENCH AND OTHER FOREICN LANCUACES The French and German methods are modern and are used in many of the most progressive schools and colleges throughout the country. The general stock of {mported books is very large, for we supply not onl our own publications but those of ad/ publishers at home and abroad. Our Romans Choisis, Contes Choisis, an other sortes, tastefully printed and low priced, contain masterpieces of French, spanish and Italian authors. They are used extensively for class reading, many having notes in English. A complete catalog of all publi- cations, also of imported books, will be sent when requested. SOME RECENT PUBLICATIONS. The Complete Pocket Guide to Europe. Edited by EpMcunp CLARENCE STEDMAN and Tuomas L. STEDMAN. Revised Edition for 1905. Besides giving the best_routes, select hotels, many maps, etc., of Kurope, it gives advice as to: Arrangements for the Journey ~Steamships—Ocean Journey—Money, etc.— Hotel Expenses—Railway Travel—Golfing—Cycling—Customs Regulations—Health Resorts—Diplomatic and Consular Agents of the United States—Travel Phrases in Four Languages—Travelers’ Telegraphic Code, etc. It is handy, concise and accurate, and has stood the test of years, and is revisea from year to year. It gives just the information needed on the spur of the moment. The authoritative wealth of in- formation contained in it has saved travelers many times the price of the book. No one need fear extor- tionate demands of the foreign purveyor if he adheres to the advice given. Size: small enough for one’s pocket or muff. One volume, 537 pages, size 8% x 5 in., full leather binding, $1.25 nel. MISCELLANEOUS—Simple Rules for Bridge. By K. N. Stex._e. 2d edition revised. It is by an acknowledged “ Bridge” authority. Size 444x534, paper, 25 cents nef. FRENCH-—L’ Abbe Daniel. By, ANDRE THevuRieT. Edited with notes in English by C. Fontaine, B.L. L.D., No, 26 Roman Choisis, 12mo cloth, 85 cents; paper, 60 cents. 2! Le Verre d@’ Eau ou Les Effets et Les Causes. By EvGkNe Scrise. Edited with introduction and notes by F. G. G. Schmidt, Ph.D., Professor of Modern Languages, State University of Oregon, No, 21 Theatre Contemporain. 12mo, paper, 25 cents. Carte de Lecture Frarcaise By Misses Gay and GarBer. 20 French reading charts, 36x24 inches each printed In large type and profusely illustrated. Price $5.00. SPANISH—tI Cautivo de Dona Mencia. By Don Juan VaLeEra, edited with explanatory notes in English by R. Diez de la Cortina, B.A., No. 5 Cuentos Selectos. size 644x4%, cloth, 50 cents; paper, 35 cents, Los Puritnnos y Otros Cuentos, By ARMANDO PaLacto VaLpBs, edited with introduction and ex- planatory aotes in English by W. T. Faulkner, A.M., of the Columbian University. 12mo, cloth, 75 cents- paper, 50 cents, ANY BOOK SENT PREPAID FOR THE PRICE WILLIAM R. JENKINS, 85! & 853 Sixth Ave., N. W. Cor. 48 St., New York JUS? PUBLISHED IDIOMATIC STUDY OF GERMAN COMPLETE IN ONE VOLUME By OTTO KUPHAL, Ph.D. This scholarly work marks an epoch in the study of language. The great simplicity of the work enables any student to acquire a thoreugh knowl- FOR THE COLLEGES NEW TEXT- THE An Introduction to Psy- chology. 1.60 net By Dr. J. CLARK MURRAY. A Short Constitutional History of the United BOOKS| States. 1.75 net By Prof. FRANCIS NEWTON THORPE, LITTLE, BROWN & CO., Boston edge of German within the shortest pos- sible time. The book contains 547 pages including a treatise on “The Passive Voice,” a treatise on “The Conditional Sentence,” and a treat- ise on “The Incomplete Hypothetical Pe- riod.” vols., pocket size. and colleges ) Price, $2.50 net SEND FOR CATALOGUE. Specimen pages sent on application. Handy Volume Classics Used by schools and colleges everywhere. 155 List prices, cloth, 85c. per vol., limp leather 75c. per vol. (Special prices to schools Thomas Y, Crowell & Co., New York GEO. GOTTSBERGER PECK, Publisher 117 Chambers St., New York City. waukee, Wis. BOOK re 8 ‘Japan vellum, “Band PLATES Sext,.smp for booklet. Gin Be Educational. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston. OSTON UNIVERSITY Law School. New features. Address the Dean. M, M. BIGELow. BERLIN. GERMANY WILLARD SCHOOL FOR AMERICAN GIRLS General Courses in German, Art, Music. Prepares for American Colleges, Foreign travel. For circular ad- dress Dr. ALICE H. LUCE, Principal, 27 Luitpold Strasse, Berlin, Germany. ROCK RIDCE HALL A School for Boys. Location high and dry. Laboratories. Shop for Mechanic Arts. A new gymnasium with swim- ming pool. St teachers. Harnest boys. Fits for College, Scientific School and business. Illustrated pamphlet sent free, Dr. G. R. WHITE, Principal, Wellesley Hills, Mass. EDGEWORTH Boarding and Day School for Girls. 122 and 124 West Franklin Street, Baltimore, Md. Will reopen September 29, 1904. Mrs. H. P. LeEFeBvre, Miss F.D Huntuery, Principals. School Agencies. ‘HE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES Everett O Fisk & Co., Proprietors. 4 Ashburton Place, Boston; 1505 Pa. Ave., Washington; 155 Fifth Ave., New York; 414 Cent. Bldg.,Minneapolis; 533 Cooper Bldg., Denver; 80 Third St., Portland; 203 Mich. Bivd., Chicago; 325 Stimson Block, Los Angeles; Hyde Block, Spokane; 42v Parrot Bldg., San Francisco. LBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY, 81 —— St.. Albany, N. Y.—Provides schools of all grades with competent teachers. Assists teachers in obtaining positions. HARLAN P. Frencu, Proprietor. CHERMERHORN’S Teachers’ Agency. Teachers—Schools—Tutors—Governess—Property. Tel. 6129 18th. Joun C. ROCKWELL, Mear., 3 E. 14th 8t., N. Y. C. Teachers, etc. RIVATE TUTORING in New York. —Harvard A.M., seven years’ experience in college reparatory work, prepares boys for school or college, Tp sompcrerily absent from school prevented from falling behind in their studies. For terms, references, etc., apply D. K., the Nation. | NEW BOOKS Weir’s The Greek Paiaters’ Art Retail price, $3.00 net Ripley’s Trusts, Pools, and Co: ns Retail price $2.15 net ers’ Mediaeval and Modern History v' . List price $1.50 ‘ers’ Ancient History ised. List price $1.50 Cheyney's Short History of England 5 in Ba List gs $1.40 Vor L Piet price #150 | GINN & COMPANY, BOSTON | d CATALOGUE OF OLD, RARE, and ke can and Lees} . om. Fe AS Ns La RT Set — btn OL ESR ARR IE Lae bi pair!
Page 5
Ses ORES, 3 £ i“ $ i SAG et April 13, 1905] Vv New Publications, Just Ready, April, 1905 Disunion Sentiment in Congress in 1794 A CONFIDENTIAL MEMORANDUM HITHERTO UNPUBLISHED. Written by JOHN TAYLOR of Caroline (Senator from Virginia) for James Madison. Edited, with an Introduction, by GAIL- LARD HU Author of the Life of James Madison. Editor of the Writings of James Madison. 4to, 23 pages, with facsimile of the original manuscript, handsomely printed. Edition Limited to 300 copies. $2.00 net. This manuscript was not included in the files of Madison’s papers which he prepared for posterity and which the Government bought, nor was it among those which Mr. J. C. McGuire collected, but was kept seperate by him and after his death by his wife. m Mrs. Madison’s death it fell into the hands of her nephew, the late James Mad- ison Cutts, from whose widow it was recently pur- chased by the publishers of this work. The care- ful and close custody of the manuscript for so many years shows it was considered of the highest se by Madison, and historical students will welcome its present publication as throwing much new light on a subject of great interest, and as giving rticulars of an episode concerning which the torians of the period have been hith- erto uninformed. The Humble Request Of the Governour and the Company Late Gone to New England TO THE REST OF THEIR BRETHREN OF THE CHURCH OF ENGLAND London; 1630 New Edition, in Facsimile of the Rare Original, with a Bibliographical Note by WILBERFORCE EAMES and an Historical Introduction by JOHN L. EWELL Small 4to, oS pee Edition limited to 100 copies. Net $2.00. This tract signed on the eve of their departure for the New World by the leaders of the Winthrop Colony, in 1630, is of great importance as showing the ardent friendly wor ge the colonists to the Established Oburch of giand, and the great rarity of the original edition (of which only three pri are known) should make this facsimile re- nt desired by those interested in early New gland history. W. H. LOWDERMILK AND COMPANY, JOHN T. LOOMIS, Managing Partner. 1424 and 1426 F Street, Washington, D. C Travel. “In the heart of the continent.” 12,000 MILES. This vast mileage of railway lying | east of Chicago, St. Louis and the Mississippi River, with its eastern terminals at New York, Boston and Montreal, its lines passing through the centers of population and reaching the gateways of commerce, makesup the system called the NEW YORK CENTRAL LINES For No. 3 of the Four-Track Series, contain- ing a map showing this Great System send a two-cent stamp to George H. Daniels, General Passenger Agent, Grand Central Station,New York. | THE UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO PRESS The Progress of Hellenism in Alexander’s Empire By Joun P. Manarry, Sometime Professor of Ancient History at the University of Dublin Professor Mahaffy has ia this book e itomized the results of his studies, extending over more i than twenty years and covering all the amen records of Greek influence in Alexander's empire The book is thus a compendium of rare value: to the student it presents an accurate summary & most brilliant culture epoch; to the casual reader it offers an oytiine for more extender! reading. 81.00 net, prepaid $1.10 The Messianic Hope in the New Testament By SHAILER MaTuEws, Professor of New Testament His tory in the University of Chicago New Testament study along his. | torical lines and embodying the latest results of critical work in popular form ts extremely rare in America. this book {s an example of such study. It subjects the nar- rative to a searching criticism and seeks to determine which of the concepts common to the writers are of local application and con temporary, and whichare applic- able under all circumstances of time and place. The messianic hope forms the main theme of the discussion. $2.00 net, prepaid 82.14 Studies in Generali Physiology (In two volumes.) Py Jacgugs Logs, Head of the Department of Physi ology in the University of California. Professor Loeb hae long been endeavoring to ascertain the laws controlling physical life pheno- mena, and espe. tally those involv ed {n reproduction. He has finally succeeded In artificially fertilizing ova, and has been able to develo the ova thus treated. The expert- ments have not been elsewhere re- corded, so that these volumes pos- sess a special value to physicians and other students of biology. For many years Professor Loeb's re- sults will form the point of depar ture fo similar investigations 87.50 net, prepaid 87.90 Lectures on Commerce Edited by Henny R. Hatrigip Formerly Dean of the College of Commerce and Adminstration in the University of Chicago These lecturea—sixteen in num- ber—were delivered before the College of Commerce and Admin- istration in the University of Chicago. They treat of railways, banking, trade. industry; and tn | asmuch ae the lecturers Include ' such men as Secretary Morton, | Ex-Comptrolier Kckels, Vice Pres ident Forgan, Professor Laugh- lin, they.are extremely interesting | to all who wish a firsthand ac eount of modern and successful business methods. The book Is of exceptional value to young men. $1.50 net, prepaid $1.63 The Place of IndustriesinElementary The Psychology of Child Develop- Education ment By Kataarine E, Dopp, Instructor in the Untversity of Chicago By Irvine Kina, Professor of Psychology in Pratt Institute, Brooklyn This book recognizes the relation between the | periods of growth in the child and the stages or ages of industrial development in the race. It is pointed out that better results in primary This book is the first attempt to apply the functional point of view to child psychology, and it promises to tra .form the study from a dreary catalogue of “ facts” for which none but education can be attained only by assigning to | a few enthusiasts care, to a really illuminatiog the industries a much larger place inthe curric- | and scientific account of child-life. To those ulum than heretofore. A recent revision has | teachers who have felt the stimuius of Dr. enlarged the volume by some seventy pages of Dewey's educational thought this application text and sixteen full-page illustrations. c* his method will be welcome and inspiring #1.00 net, prepaid $1.11 %1.00 net, prepaid #1.10 ‘ A History of Matrimonial Institutions ('"**r:*) By Grorce E. Howarp, Professor of Institutional History in the Unversity of Nebraska. Professor Howard has given in these volumes the most complete study yet published on the history of marriage and divorce, The work isin three parts. In the first the author fixes the sociological basis for the discussion ; the second treats of the development of marriage in Evg land ; the third is devoted to marriageand divorce in the United States. Every one following the widespread discussion of the marriage and divorce problem should have access to this work 810.00 net, prepaid #10, 72. ' The Trend in Higher Education By WiiuiAM Rainey HARPER, Religion and the Higher Life By WituiaM Raregy Harper, President of the University of Chicago. President of the University of Chicago Here, within the limits of a single book, Presi- | Inthis book President Harper attempts to dent Harper gives the gist of his addresses and | suggest a solution for the reiigious problems papers upon the general subject of higher edu which confront men and women during the cation. It goes without saying that the volume | periods of late youth and early manhood or is meeting a hearty welcome from that large | womanhood. The book has its message for all class of readers who are interested in thede , who are honestly and apncetiy striving to velopment of our educational system; especiaily | answer the questions which inevitably arise in those actively engaged in perfecting the organi- connection with the religious life; it is also a zation of the high schools, the colleges, and the | faithful index of religious conditions in our universities, colleges and universities $1.50 net, prepaid $1.66 $1.00 net, prepaid $1.10 THE UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO PRESS ig ping ret voex THE ENCHANTED WOODS THE ENCHANTED WOODS And Other Essays on the Genius of Places THE APPRECIATION OF SCULPTURE By RUSSELL STURGIS Companion volume to“ How to Judge Archil- tecture,”’ by the same author, and * Pictortal Composition,” by Henry KR Poore. By VERNON LEE Author of ‘‘Hortas Vitac.’’ 12mo. $1.26 net. The Literary World (London): * 4a writer she ts always entertaining, but the ts something more. There will be few readers of her latest book who do not gain from it mental stimulus and a widened outlook’ | JOHN LANE - NEW YORK Each volume, over 80 illustrations, net $1.50 (Postage, 14 cents.) Special Edition of THE APPRECIATION OF SCULPTURE, net $3.00. (Postage 24 cts.) The third in a series of handbooks, invaluable to those who would master the fandamentals in the understanding and appreciation of art. THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO. 33-37 East 7th Street, New York
Page 6
The Nation. [Vol. 80, No. 2076 A Monumental Work THE UNITED STATES 1607-1904 A History of Three Centuries of Progress in Population, Politics, Industry, Commerce and Civilization 4 Ne By WILLIAM ESTABROOK CHANCELLOR and FLETCHER WILLIS HEWES To be in 10 volumes, Svo, containing numerous diagrams and tables showing industrial and financial development and compre- hensive maps. Each volume covers a distinct period and is fully indexed. Sold separately, Each $3.50 net Ready: VotumE I.—Colonization, 1607-1697 ‘(VotumeE II.—Colonial Union, 1698-1774 Go be followed by Revolution and Constitution, 1775-1788 The Early Republic, 1789-1821 Industrial Awakening, 1822-1845 The Great Debate, 1846-1860 Vol. 7. The Civil War and Reconstruction, 1863-1869 Vol. 8 The New North and the New South, 1870-1885 Vol. 9. Economic Crises, 1886-1897 Vol. 10. A World Power, 1898-1904 Send for Full Prospectus. WHAT THE CRITICS SAY: The London Academy (Eng.):—‘‘Arrests attention by its thorough scholarship, its breadth of treatment, and its lucidity of style. Its liter- ary qualities are most evident. The authors recognize the solidarity of history. . . . Vivid. . . . Clear. . . Concise.” Journal of Education:—"A wealth of information in a delightful literary setting.’ Congregationalist ;—‘A brilliant, easy flowing narrative. Strong in the brief biographies. The single page on Magellan is a wonderful mono- graph. A sturdy common-sense which inspires confidence.” Education :-:"This history will meet with the approval of thoughtful people and take a permanent place among the popular histories of our country.”’ At All Booksellers G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS New York and London ~ PME eT RC a LONGMANS, GREEN, & 00.’S NEW BOOKS CUBA and the Intervention BY ALBERT G. ROBINSON (“A. G. R.’”) Crown 8wvo, Cloth, Net $180. By mail, $1.92 “A book which is destined long to figure among the most valuable materials for a comprehension of Cuba’s history at a crit- ical conjuncture. . . The author was an eyewitness of the events that he describes, and he brought to his task a mind quali- fied by education and experience for the work of observation.” —NM. Y,. Sun. “A work which should at once take rank as a valuable record of one of the most remarkable international episodes in the history of civilization.” — Washington Star. “ A book which gives one an excellent idea from the Cuban point of view of the first steps toward the formation of the present republic. From documents and reports, but better than all from per- sonal investigation, the author has collected material of the greatest value for the future historian, for the statesman, and for the general observer of events. There are interesting chapters on the first year of intervention, on the military occupation, on the Platt amendment, and the struggle for tariff concessions.”’ —Chicago Tribune. |The United States and Porto Rico With Special Reference to the Problems Arising out of our Contact with the Spanish American Civilization By Leo 8. Rowe, Ph.D., Professor of Political Science in the University of Pennsylvania, President of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, Member of the Commission to Revise and Com- a the Laws of Porto Rico (1900-1901), Chairman of the Porto Rican ommission (1901-1902). Crown 8vo. Pp. 280. Price, $1.80 net; by mail, $1.40. The Burden of the Balkans By M. Eprra Durnam, author of “Through the Lands of the Serb." With Illustrations and Map. 8vo. $4.00 net. By mail, $4.16. In this story of her sixth visit to the Balkan Peninsula, Miss Durham, after an historical survey of the causes of of the present state of affairs, gives an account of her work 4s relief agent for the Balkan Committee, and finally describes Albania and the Albanian, ‘‘the root of all the Kalkan difficu ties.” The book contains a number of Illustrations from sketches by the author. “Miss Durham, who has made six journeys through the peninsula, has exe- cuted her task with singular force and vivaci iF She presents an unconventional view of the situation. . ._. Hers is one of the most entertaining books that the season has produced. I) is more than entertaining—it has genuine value as * picture of a group of peoples who still belong to the Middle Ages.”—N. Y. ribune. The Crisis of the Confederacy A HISTORY OF GETTYSBURG AND THE WILDERNESS By Ceci. Bartiye, Captain Fiftee.th King’s Hussars. With a Colored seactrees of the Battle-Flags of the Confederacy and 6 Maps. vO, “We have not space at command to follow Cogene Battine’s excellently lucid narrative, but must be content with generally «ommending it to our ers. They can hardly find a more satisfactory narrative, with so much matter In so moderate a space, The story of years of serious fighting is com- p into something less than four sy od pages. ‘Then comes a chapter in which the lessons of the war are drawn in a very 1: structive way.” — Spectator, London, LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., 93 Fifth Avenue, New York
Page 7
Ee NEW YORK, THURSDAY, APRIL 13, 1905. The Week. The President’s prophecy, spoken to his Indian Territory audiences, that that Territory will soon become a State, “probably in conjunction with Oklahoma,” will, we trust, be ful- filled. But enough uncertainty exists to add zest to whatever single State- hood campaign he chooses to instigate. In Oklahoma a movement of signifi- cance has been started looking to the immediate setting up of that Territory as a separate State. A call for a Con- stitutional convention, to be held this summer, has been sent out, and Is un- derstood to have the backing of Gov. Ferguson, ex-Delegate Flynn, and the Republicans in control. From Delegate Maguire’s accepted organ, the Enid Eagle, comes a protest against waiting upon the settlement of tribal affairs of Indian Territory before admitting Okla- homa. At least 75 per cent. of Okla- homa’s population, it is estimated, will back up 2 protest against the reénact- ment of the Hamilton bill, which pro- vides for single Statehood. But it would be unfortunate if Oklahoma’s impatience for the dignity of two Senators should result in splitting a logical vommon- wealth in two, or in making necessary the patching on of Indian Territory later. The Senators who deformed the Hay- Bond treaty had fair warning that New- foundland would retaliate, though the extent of the reprisals was probably not foreseen. As a matter of fact, she is planning to cripple our fisheries on that coast. By prohibiting the catching or buying of bait along shore, the banks fleet can be seriously embarrassed. The imposition of an export duty equal to our import duty will effectually put a stop to the traffic in frozen herring, now furthered by evading our customs. Grav- er yet, the embargo will mean that the formerly liberal policy of Newfoundland has been relinquished, and that a period of petty international tempests in the fishpots will begin. The reopening of the fisheries dispute will bring about con- traband fishing and baiting by enter- prising fishermen, with the constant chance of acts of violence. Perhaps those who defeated the treaty in order to encourage the Gloucester fleet as a “nursery of the American navy” may re- gard such minor broils as an excellent preparation for possible war, but our State Department will hardly take that view when its’ dealings reassume the fishy and most vexatious complexion of some twenty years ago. The Nation. The reciprocity treaty with Cuba has now been in force for two-thirds of a year. Our exports to Cuba during that time have been 42 per cent. more than during the corresponding period of 1903- 1904, while our total imports from the island have increased by only 16 per cent. The latter increase is chiefly in the single item of sugar, which rose from $24,666,517 to $29,848,042. Our ex- ports, however, increased in many lines: cars and carriages, beween 10 and 25 per cent.; flour, cattle, lumber, and corn, between 25 and 40; mineral oils, bacon, and furniture, between 40 and 50; while in cotton cloths our exports to Cuba have considerably more than doubled. It is worth noting that the early results of Cuban reciprocity under the McKinley act were nearly the reverse of this. Our exports to Cuba in 1892 were only about 6 per cent. more than in 1890, while our imports from Cuba increased in the same time by more than 40 per cent. The differences in the two arrangements ex- plain this. Instead of free sugar mere- ly, we grant Cuba now a 20 per cent. re- duction from all the Dingley rates, while, on our side of the bargain, we receive concessions running in many cases as high as 40 per cent. Error may be lucky for a day, but truth wins at the last. This is likely to be one’s reflection on reading the recent address of Rear-Admiral George W. Mel- ville, retired, before the American Acad- emy of Political and Social Science at Philadelphia. Admiral Melville focuses attention on the fact that our Philippine possessions are a heritage of enormous naval weakness—a pwsition no one but a degraded Anti-Imperialist, least of all a conspicuous naval officer, would have dared to assume four or five years ago. Our triple expansion policy of policing the Philippines, digging the Panama Ca- nal, and assuming the office of receiver- general of bankrupt and recalcitrant South and Central American States gives this naval expert the most serious appre- hension. The anticipated military suc- cess of Japan will soon put “the fighting man of the East” on our Pacific frontier. The French, Danish, and British West Indian possessions “menace” from a doz- en military standpoints our control of the Isthmian Canal. To remedy this in part, Admiral Melville advocates first of all “the immediate abandonment, at the slightest possible financial loss, of every distant possession that is likely to re- quire a fleet to defend it.” Our immunity from foreign aggression so long as we maintained unimpaired our continental solidarity and minded our own business we have senselessly given up for the sorry spectacular role of posing as a world power. The news of the desertion of 6060 men from Rear-Admiral Evans's great fleet at Pensacola comes hard on the heels of the publication of the views on this sub ject of the Bureau of Navigation. It was carefully explained by the chief of the bureau, Rear-Admiral Converse, that, of an enlisted force of 30,066, “only” 10.7 per cent. ran away last year. Among the seamen the desertions were 7.97 per cent., While 17.10 per cent. of the engine- room force violated its pledges. The heaviest percentage was among the mess men, nearly one-quarter of whom, or 23.15 per cent., “jumped” the service The latter fact the Bureau sought to ex plain on the ground that there were many foreigners among these messmen and that the servant question is, after all, “one which is not wholly confined to the naval service.” In the engine rooms, too, there would seem to be a good many foreign-born Americans, for five of the six men of the Jowa who were given medals of honor ten days ago for bravery in connection with a boiler accident bore the following names Johannes J. Jo- hannesen, Patrick F. Bresnahan, Hein- rich Behnice, Frederick Behne, and Demetri Corahorgi. The truth is, that neither alien birth nor the servant ques- tion offers the proper solution. There is something radically wrong either with the official treatment of our men or with the men themselves. The native Amer- ican seems to resent being “cabined, cribbed, confined”’ by superior authority as inconsistent with American demo- cratic ideals, and, ‘first-class fightin’ man” that he is, does not care to serve long in time of peace. Our Jingoes must reckon with this temper in their plans for a navy with 80,000 or 90,000 enlisted men. “Administrative entity,” a phrase somewhat ill-understood in Mr. Hay’s circular note in behalf of Chinese neu- trality, is now fully accounted for as of German origin. It was the Kaiser who prompted the appeal to the Powers: in diplomatic correspondence just publish- ed he thanks the President for his “in itiative and codperation” in matters Chi nese. This explains the dubious phrase which must be simply the translation of entité administrative—a Gallic meta morphosis, for diplomatic purposes, of some still more metaphysical Teutonism whose determination we leave to philo- sophica! philologers. Mr. Hay, appar- ently, no more knew what it meant than Lord Lansdowne, who frankly asked. But the thing to be explained‘ is not the formula supplied from Ber- lin, but the motive that ruled at that time in the Wilhelmstrasse, Into this one should not inquire too curiously. It might be surmised, for example, that
Page 8
280 The Nation. [ Vol. 80, No. 2076 Germany knew that strict observ- ance of Chinese neutrality was more fa- vorable to Russia than to Japan, and prompted Secretary Hay to his old pur- suit in order to aid Russia. To such a view the fact that the only outrageous breach of Chinese neutrality, in the Ryeshitelni case, was committed by japan, lends a certain color of truth. Yet it seems more likely that Germany was merely grasping the first opportuni- ty to associate herself actively with Mr. Wiay’s campaign for the open door. As a great trading nation, she might take such ground without suspicion of ulte- rior political motives. This view of the case is confirmed by Germany’s present overtures at Wash- ington in behalf of equal commercial privileges in Morocco. In the light of this remarkable initiative, the Kaiser’s recent visit and speech to Tangier must be read. It may pique him personally that the Western Mediterranean question was settled without reference to Germa- ny, whose trade with Morocco is consid- erable and growing; and, so far as his ostentatious cruise was a reminder that Germany has Mediterranean aspirations, its bearings were political. In the main, however, the calm tone of the French press is evidence that Germany’s designs in Morocco are regarded as purely com- mercial, and of a kind that France is disposed to allow cheerfully to all na- tions. Finally, the most interesting fea- ture of the situation is the overture for a diplomatico-commercial rapproche- ment between ourselves and Germany, a possibility fraught with vast import- ance. The stiffening of the moral backbone of St. Louis, accomplished while Gov. Folk occupied the Circuit Attorney’s of- fice, has apparently sufficed to reélect Rolla Wells, the Democratic “business Mayor.” He has given the city an ad- ministration notable chiefly for its “‘re- spectability,” as contrasted with the “good-fellow” rule of his predecessor, “Uncle Henry” Ziegenheim. In the or- dinary course of events, Wells would have been succeeded by another “lib- eral” Republican. The early returns, from the dock and slum wards, showed the expected plurality for Judge Talty. the Republican candidate, who was up derstood to favor a “wide-open” town, but the “white shirt and collar’ wards remembered Folk and his teaching. Mayor Wells was backed not only by the Folk faction, but by the followers of Harry Hawes and the Jefferson Club of odorous memory. It is an interesting commentary on the practical efficacy of the Folk idea that the so-called Jeffer- son Club “Indians,’’ under Hawes’s lea- dership, should have been swung to the support of a candidate whg, it was com- plained, was stiff and unapproachable by “the boys.” The enthusiasm for the “business Mayor,” however, was not great enough to carry through a propos- ed bond issue of $9,000,000 for municipal improvements. The public-ownership candidate, Lee Meriwether, received tri- fling support—a strong contrast to the result in Chicago. The real traction question in Chicago will come up, now that the Mayoralty election is over. Judge Dunne, the suc- cessful Democratic candidate, favored a line of policy which, while more radical than that of Mr. Harlan, the Republican, is at the same time much harder to carry out. Harlan offered a plan which was safe and economical, and would give the city a chance ultimately to try public operation of street cars, if it chose, un- der the most favorable auspices. But the people of Chicago agreed with Judge Dunne that it was better to run some risks and begin to take up the lines at once. If the city refuses to grant any new franchises or renew old ones, the companies have left—to quote one of Dunne’s converts—‘‘(1) a second-hand plant for which a second-hand price will be paid; (2) the right to operate for some fifty years over what Mayor Harri- son has called ‘a maimed and crippled system of streets, with but 50 per cent. of the entrances in the downtown dis- trict..”” The Democratic orators con- tended that the prices for the companies’ securities—which remained fairly stable throughout the campaign—were based partly on the expectation of new fran- chises, and, with that hope gone, would fall to a figure commensurate with the real value of the companies’ prop- erty. None the less, if the price paid by the city for the lines taken over is to be based on stock quotations, the incen- tive for keeping prices at an artificially high figure is greater than ever since Dunne’s election. In spite of the all but unanimous pro- tests of the Philadelphia newspapers, the Legislature of Pennsylvania on Thursday put through the three so-called “ripper” bills, taking from the Mayor of Philadelphia the power to appoint di- rectors of the several departments, and giving it to the City Council. Unless Gov. Pennypacker decides to veto the measures, Philadelphia will, on the first Monday in April, 1907, when the bills take effect, revert to a system of divided responsibility that has nothing to justify it except the desire of the Republican “machine” to insure its control. The advocates of these “ripper” bills explain that, under the Bullitt law, passed in 1885, the heads of departments in Phila- delphia are little better than clerks. They propose to relieve the Mayor of the power to appoint the Director of the De- partment of Public Safety (the police commissioner), the Director of the De- partment of Supplies, and the Director of the Department of Public Health and Charities. The City Council, elected yearly, shall then choose these officials for a term of three years each. The only real argument for this change advanced by the ‘‘machine’s” backers is that the law that has served the city for twenty years is un-American, and tends to the establishment of a one-man power. The influence of trades unions upon immigrants is the subject upon which Carroll D. Wright tried to secure in- formation in a recent investigation of the Chicago stock yards. His finding is that the unions are helpful in Ameri- canizing and bettering the conditions of the Poles, Bohemians, Lithuanians, and Slovaks, who form so large a percen- tage of the laborers. Before the unions were organized, each race kept closely to itself. It had its own church, its own schools, is own benevolent associa- tions, its own social life. It attempted, when the unions were started, to or- ganize these also on race lines. The leaders, however, objected, and, for the first time, Irishmen, Germans, Poles, Bohemians, and the rest were forced to mingle—to hold common meetings, to learn a common tongue, and to take com- mon action. To a certain extent, also, the unions have been educators in political science. Here the Eastern immigrant first learns the value of his vote, and gets some vague notion of his relation to the State. Again, through the union he seeks to improve his condition. Bet- ter wages, shorter hours, better homes, better clothes, larger opportunities for himself and children—these, according to Mr. Wright, are the staple subjects of talk at the union meetings. Pushed to the extreme, these ideas may have unfortunate results; .but in general the lesson is a valuable one. Similar influ- ences, Mr. Wright would discover, are operating in New York, especially in the clothing trades. The Jewish workmen do not take naturally to the trades- union idea. They join in large num- bers when some prominent issue, like the open shop or a wage increase, is at stake; and then, after the crisis is pass- ed, drop out. In the quiet season the unions, with decreased membership, do exist, but usually as social organiza- tions and debating societies. With the temperate Hebrew they often take the place of the saloon as the poor man’s club. In this field the activity of the unions is admittedly wholesome, The sale of thirty-one obsolete war- ships by the British Government for leas than one-twentieth of their original cost is a surprising transaction, but nothing could better illustrate the rapidity which modern fighting machinery comes worthless. The casual reader likely to imagine that these vessels 5 i Rn ae Awami eae
Page 9
Acai alan 9a RR SD Ht i AG ia eS cs Rei NE A April 13, 1905] The Matior longed to the elder day of sea fighting try proposes a reduction of the tea duty, —that they were of the type whose decks | so that what favor the budget loses in were trod by Marryat’s heroes. No such thing. The Galatea was completed in 1889 at a cost of £258,390, the Warspite and the Australia in 1888, costing £529,- 332 and £259,390 respectively, and the Northampton in 1878 at a cost of £395.,- 804. Thus three of the cruisers now sold for junk, with the requirement that they be broken up at once, were brand new and up-to-date only sixteen or seventeen years ago. The young girls who smashed champagne bottles over their bows at the launchings are not yet middle-aged. In even less time, the progress of invention may make the ships launched this year equally worth- less. This is the nature of a Govern- ment’s investment in naval armaments, and it is one of the things to be kept in mind when the Jingoes are urging still larger budgets. There is much in Mr. Austen Cham- berlain’s Budget of public revenue and tax expedients for the new British fiscal year, submitted to Parliament on Mon day, which should be highly gratifying to the British people; there are some provisions which in certain quarters will arouse resentment. The mere fact that a@ $15,000,000 surplus revenue is report ed, for the twelve months ending March 31, is a matter of encouragement—rhe more so since it exceeds by nearly $12.,- 000,000 the estimates framed by the Chancellor of the Exchequer a year ago, and since the unlooked-for increment has come from an increased import trade— a sign of reviving English prosperity. On the other hand, the well-to-do ciasses, which have been bearing, ever since the South African war ended, an income tax larger than any imposed in time of peace for fifty years, had looked with much confidence for some remission, and will certainly be chagrined at the news that none is to be made. One shilling in the pound is not, as American ideas of taxes £0, a very oppressive burden. Amount ing as it does to 5 per cent., it is heav ier than the Federal income tax impos- ed by Congress during 1894, and later declared unconstitutional, but it is prob- ably lighter than the burden placed on incomes by the property tax of New York State. The pending mortgage-tax bill, in so far as that affects aggregate incomes, calls for a tax of 10 per cent. or thereabouts. So of the tax on other forms of property, which, if collected to the last farthing, might easily take for the State 20 or 25 per cent. of income other than salaries or wages. Never- theless, the fact that the shilling figure has, for half a century or more, been synonymous with a British war-tax, is reasonably sure to render those who must continue to bear the burden angry and resentful, and it may in that way affect the fortunes of the Ministry. For the rest of the voting public, the Minis- one direction it may gain in another and possibly more politically useful quarter. The marked decline in the consump tion of alcoholic spirits in Great Britain proved to be the significant sociological feature of Mr. Austen Chamberlain's Budget speech. In the fiscal year end ing March 31, 1905, the drink duties in dicate the smallest consumption of beer and spirits in fifteen years. The notice able decline in this source of imperial revenue has gone steadily on since 1900 The young Chancellor of the Exchequer was well advised in not following the lead of cynical financiers who have ar gued, as did the author of The Fable of the Bees, that private vices are pubiie benefits. However great the loss in reve nue from excises on spirits, the gain in general productive power which lessen- ed consumption of alcohol implies is tantamount to an enhanced ability to pay other taxes. Austen Chamberlain ascribes the decline in drink duties to the changing habits of the people, who are sp*nding more on outdoor excur sions and recreations and less in the tav erns of Gin Lane. The reproach which Englishmen their countrymen of drunken nation” have themselves heaped being shows signs of losing upon a its significance—a omen. most encouraging The defeat of a member of the Govern ment in the stalwart Unionist constit- uency of Brighton is the severest rebuff Mr. Balfour has received in a score of electoral mishaps. Mr. Gerald Loder, recently appointed Junior Lord of the Treasury, was chiefly on the Thus Brighton adds to that of many other constituencies formerly Unionist its verdict of distrust of Mr. Chamberlain's protectionism and of dis- gust with Mr. Balfour’s shilly-shallying. The loss of a seat contested by a minor beaten fiscal issue. member of the Government is not neces sarily a signal for the resignation of the Ministry. On the other hand, the present Parliamentary of Mr. Balfour’s Government is hardly compati- While Mr. Balfour from all opposing not only the position ble with self-respect. is running away manner of resolutions Chamberlain plan, but also his own retaliation, the enthusiastically against both. That is, the are deciding Parliamentary upon an issue which Mr. Balfour has abandoned in Parliament as of no im Evidently, this sharp differ- ence between a_ self-governing constitu- voting people policy of encies are elections portance. people and its Government cannot be of long duration, and while Mr. Balfour seems to have as many political lives as a cat, he ean hardly avoid an appeal to the country after the budget has been ap- proved. 281 on which to hang a demand for politi cal reforms, the Czar might well be lieve that his autocracy is slipping away from him. Here are thirteen hundred doctors gathered together in Moscow, ostensibly to take measures to protect the physical health of the poor; instead they find themselves called upon to pre scribe first for the diseased body politi They have merely pointed out again that the welfare of the people is best presery ed by good government These physi cians find it of little use to suggest medi cal reforms when the carrying out must be intrusted to corrupt and autocratik officials. If they have perhaps veiled their true feelings under an avowed fear of the ignorant have plainly joined the lawyers, the stu population, they dents, the teachers, the scientists, and the other learped professions in their in against the existing tellectual revolt state of affairs. Of what use is it, when men like these speak out, to talk of dan ger from the peasants or the anarchists or to attempt to suppress the open agi tators and protestants’ We cannot be lieve the authorities blind to this con sideration, The Cabinet kaleidoscope in Italy has taken a fresh turn since our correspon dent's narrative (on another page) was Tittoni’s expectedly obtained concluded exposition” un a majority of 121 and it was supposed that the Cabinet would at once proceed to business. On the contrary, the next day Signor Tit toni gave out that the whole Cabinet had resigned; the Deputies were dis missed, and it was announced that Tit toni and Fortis were entrusted with the formation of the new Ministry, with the result that Luzzaitti is replaced by Carcano, Ronchetti, Minister of Justice, and Orlando, Minister of Public Instrue tion, are also retired. Ferraris, who succeeds Tedesco as Minister of Pub lic Works, was reporter of the committee chosen to draw up the railway bill, and is supposed to be a competent authority on the burning question of the day, Tit toni remains at the Foreign Office. For tis, President of the Council, assumes the Home Department. If names denote anything nowadays, the Cabinet may be said to be half “Right,” half “Left.” All seem agreed that the railway men shall be prevented from striking or obstruct ing, but whether the 7ist and 72d arti cles of the railway bill will be adopted is not known. sies that the Ministry will be of short duration, but if the majority is divided into sects and groups, the minority is far from homogeneous The 160 who voted against the Ministry embraced members of the Centre, of Sonnino’s Op position, of the Right (all conservatives, including the clerical) Cameroni), of the old historical Left, of the Radicals, Re- publicans, and Socialists. The press freely prophe
Page 10
282 The Nation. [ Vol. 80, No. 2076 PRESIDENT HADLEY ON RAILWAYS. Nothing is more absurd, said Macau- lay, than the British public in one of its periodical fits of morality. Whether ab- surd or not, the American public is giv- en to periodical outbursts on railway regulation. The present is such a period. The members of the House of Represen- tatives preferred not to face their con- stituents until they had passed the Esch-Townsend bill. The more leisure- ly Senate, concluding that some vent must be given to pent-up public opinion, has constituted a committee of inquiry whose hearings will doubtless occupy a good part of the summer. At this junc- ture President Hadley’s deliverance on “The Public vs. Railways,” which ap- peared in the Boston Evening Transcript of April 1, is timely. Testimony in this matter from one who is both well-in- formed and impartial is “like a light shining in a dark place,” to which we do well to take heed. The frenzied advocates of drastic rate regulation, as well as the reactionary railroad men who urge the repeal of all Federal transportation statutes, will both be disappointed to find that Presi- dent Hadley gives to immediate legisla- tion a place decidedly subordinaie, The issues which he puts in the foreground are the service which our railroads on the whole render the public, and the present tendencies in management. It is the second of these issues that is the most serious. The threatening tendency, according to President Hadley, is the growing ossification, the decay of in- itiative, in railway enterprise. Twenty years ago railroading offered a career to talent. To-day the field of oppor- tunity is narrowing. Stereotyped meth- ods are displacing the almost reckless experimentation under which our trans- portation system was built up. Though it is admitted that there “are still splen- didly strong men as presidents and general managers,” these survivors, it is alleged, are the first to confirm the truth that “there are only a few of us left." The decadence of vigor is at- tributed {in large measure to a divided allegiance. The employee now attempts to serve both the union and the com- pany; and the manager, to compromise hetween the dominant banking inter- ests on the directorate and the actual needs of transportation service, Bither hecause of these impediments or because German railroads have enjoyed advan- tages denied to ours, the superiority of our transportation system to that of Germany, #0 Indisputable in 1885, has now become uncertain. If the facts be as President Hadley asserts, his dedue- tion that we cannot, “look at the future in a spirit of complacent optimism” is unnecessarily guarded, The lesser counts urged against our railroads are dismissed in general as not well substantiated. Monopoly in trans- portation is conceded, but is declared to be inevitable. The remarkable in- crease in railroad net earnings, from $327,505,716 in 1895 to $592,508,512 in 1903, is regarded by President Hadley as only a reasonable offset for the lean years from 1893 to 1898. The increase of only 5 per cent. in the rates per pas- senger mile and freight mile, between 1899 and 1903, when all other prices con- currently. advanced from 10 to 40 per cent., he pronounces “virtually a_ tre- mendous and gratifying decrease.” On the recent car shortage he comments with some severity, but the shortage of locomotive power he allows to pass un- challenged on the ground that electricity will shortly displace steam. In short, on the allegations of excessive profits, exorbitant charges, inadequate service, or increasing discrimination, the roads are let off with a verdict of “Not guilty.” It doubtiess requires the rule of aver- ages to reach a conclusion in matters of this kind, but the professed ability to reduce the heterogeneous to a com- mon measure reminds one of the judge returned from circuit who averred that, while in some cases innocent parties had been convicted, and in some cases guilty parties had been acquitted, on the whole justice was done. Coming to the matter of proposed changes in Federal law affecting inter- state commerce, President Hadley favors a special Federal railroad court, co- ordinate in authority with the circuit courts. The present Interstate Com- merce Commission he would transform into a board of experts made up of prac- tical railroad men, three from the traf- fic department, and one each from the operating and financial departments. The Commission’s function would then be to. ascertain matters of fact on which the court might base its decisions. Evident- ly, he entertains the hope that a regu- lar judicial tribunal so constituted might eventually set aside unreasonable rates at the instance of a complainant, and even advance to the point of indicating clearly “how much rates would have to be reduced in order to be reason- able.” One may concur in the verdict that the present Interstate Commerce Com- mission has fallen between two stools in attempting to exercise at one and the same time the functions of traffic manager and judge, without assenting in toto to President Hadley’s scheme. In the first place, competent authorities have seen difficulties in the plan of de- vising a Federal court whose jurisdic- tion is to be determined, not by terri- torial limits, but by the subject-matter involved in litigation. Judge Grosscup, however, in a recent address, advocates just such a special tribunal. In the sec- ond place, if a bureau of transportation experts is to be created for the purpose of obtaining information, it would seem better to make it a bureau of the De- partment of Justice, or of some other executive department, rather than to im- pose on a court the duty of supervising such an expert detective force. Indeed, Judge Grosscup insists that this board of inquiry should be an active branch of the Executive. In the third place, if a court can be induced even by indirec- tion to set prices for transportation ser- vices, it will be more hardy than courts in Englisa-speaking countries have hith- erto been. The intent of our law at present is to do away with discrimina- tion. If there are loopholes in the stat- ute they should be stopped up. But un- til an honest and vigorous attempt has been made to enforce our present law against discrimination with our present system of Federal courts, and to em- ploy criminal prosecution when the law authorizes it, we shall do well to go slow in the creation of a special kind of circuit court with an attendant commis- sion of expert industrial inquisitors. THE CANADIAN SCHOOL QUESTION. The relation of state to religious edu- cation, which has_ sorely disturbed France and England of recent years now becomes an urgent issue in Canada, The western territories of Saskatchewan and Alberta are to be erected into self- governing provinces, and Sir Wilfrid Laurier seeks so to frame their organic law that sectarian schools shall perma- nently have a right to support from the public funds. Sir Wilfrid, it will be recalled, was the author of the famous Manitoba compromise, which nine years ago put an end to a bitter sectarian strife by secularizing state education, allowing, however, the representatives of any sect half an hour a day for re- ligious instruction in the schoolhouse. In view of the eminent success of this agreement, it baffles comprehension that Sir Wilfrid should now wish to saddle sectarian schools upon the entire North- west. For this volte-face two explana- tions are given: First, that the Premier finds himself bound by the Constitution to perpetuate separate schools; next, that the peculiar conditions of the new provinces make a mixed system expedi- ent. As for the constitutional plea, the British North America Act, the school clauses of which were framed with re- spect to the conflicting claims of Pro- testant Ontario and Catholic Quebec, stipulates that, when a province is admit- ted to the Dominion, its religious schools shall retain all rights enjoyed at the time of admission, How far Alberta and Saskatchewan, not even geographical names at the promulgation of the Brit- ish North America Act in 1867, are to be regarded as provinces, is clearly a prob- lem for Canadian legists, There is plau- sibility, however, in the view that the school clause applied only to provinces actually in being when the organic law was drawn. Much is to be sald also for rer. 47
Page 11
wap eames April 13, 1905] The Nation. 283 the common-sense argument that it is folly to bind an autonomous province perpetually to any form of education. In short, the common sense of Canada will regret that Sir Wilfrid has given the benefit of the doubt not to generous ideals of provincial independence, but to a very contestable and possibly obso- lete clause of the Constitution. But, unluckily, common sense may have rather little to do with the matter’ one way or the other. While Protestants are trying to starve out existing Catholic schools, Catholics are seeking to secure an inalienable lien upon the public purse. The political atmosphere is sur- charged with suspicion. We were told that the Premier had struck hands with the Papal Ablegate, Mgr. Sbaretti, to re- store the separate school system in Man- itoba. It was charged that the extension of that province to Hudson Bay, most eagerly desired by its inhabitants, was to be made conditional upon abolishing the secular public schools. Sir Wilfrid de- nied the charges of collusion in toto; Mer. Sbaretti admitted overtures to the Manitoba Government. These rumors suggest the heat with which the reopen- ing of the old quarrel has been accompa- nied. Now the picture of Sir Wilfrid hiding under the cassock of the Ablegate of the Holy See was frankly incredible. The Premier is emphatically his own man, and when he both belies his own record and fathers a most unpopular policy, he unquestionably does so for his own rea- sons. Obscure these reasons certainly are, but it may fairly be assumed that they are political. There are no pecu- liar social conditions in the great wheat- growing territories which make a sepa- rate school system imperative. In fact, the influx of Protestant settlers from the United States is so great that the vested interests of the Roman Catholic schools would soon be intolerably burdensome. Evidently, Sir Wilfrid’s eye was less on the territory of the dispute than on the general political status of the Dominion. It is possible that he sees in an avowedly pro-Catholie policy a means of repairing the disorganization caused in the Liberal stronghold, Quebec, by the resignation of the Parent Ministry, and of pressing the advantage recently gained in Ontario through the overthrow of the Ross gov- ernment. But if such be his hope, we believe it will be disappointed. There has been no more jealous advocate of self-government in the past than Sir Wilfrid Laurier. His famous solution of the Manitoba school contest rested upon that theory; only recently he has claim- ed for Canada greater powers of diplo- matic negotiation than Great Britain al- lows her. For him now to regulate in perpetuity the school affairs of autono- mous provinces must excite as great dis- may among his real friends as bitterness among his enemies. In fact, the successive amendments of the clauses requiring separate schools show that the Government is by no means sure of its ground. Attempts have been made to attenuate the meas- ure, which stands, however, in its pres- ent, more offensive than in its original form. At first, the principle of separate religious schools was explicitly imposed; now a sort of local option is proposed, but any sect which believes itself ag- grieved in its own locality has especial facilities of appeal to the Government at Ottawa. This is as much as tg say to the infant provinces, “You are absolute- ly free until we see fit to twitch the lead- ing strings.” In the long run the good sense of Canada, whether affected to the Protestant or Catholic faith, will be against superfluous leading-strings: and whatever the immediate fate of Sir Wii- frid’s measure, which he may very well succeed in passing by a strictly partisan vote, he can hardly be absolved from having handled a great problem in statesmanship under some not very clear consideration of temporary political ex- pediency. ROZHESTVENSKY IN THE EAST. Admiral Rozhestvensky has success fully passed the Straits of Malacca A Japanese scouting squadron, it will be remembered, touched at Singapore as far back as December 22, and proceed- ed into the Indian Ocean. On the 18th of March a strong Japanese squadron touched at Labuan, Borneo, only a few days’ steaming from Singa- pore. Togo himself rejoined his fleet after a brief rest at Tokio fully two months ago, and long before that time the Japanese navy department was pre- paring a very considerable fleet of auxiliary cruisers and torpedo-boat de- stroyers for service against Rozhestven- sky. To assume that the Russians com- pletely fooled Togo by sending some col- liers in one direction and themselves proceeding along the most frequented and direct route, is to ascribe to Togo a mental simplicity quite inconsistent with his achievements hitherto. It has long seemed the best policy for Togo to allow Rozhestvensky to reach For- mosan waters, which are far enough away from the Yellow Sea to permit traffic with Port Arthur to go on undis- turbed, and at the same time give the Japanese accessible ports for repairs and refitting, and for harboring prizes. For the Russians, Hongkong or Amoy would be the nearest places of refuge, with prompt internment staring them in the face. Whatever the Japanese strategy, the fact remains that Togo must in some manner hold in check the Viadivostok cruisers, destroy or turn back Rozhest- vensky’s armada, and still preserve enough vessels to defeat Niebogatoff’s smal] squadron now in the Red Sea, and such other ships as may yet be resurrect- north of ed from the Russian naval cemetery in the Baltic. The perseverance of Rozhest- vensky has once more altered the entire aspect of the war, for even if he sinks oniy a couple of Togo’s battleships, the Japanese may yet make peace on far different cerms than the evacuation of Mantchuria and the payment of a war indemnity of $500.000.000, which they are now thought to have in mind. On the other hand, the result of a Japanese victory is obvious Any one would be rash who should in advance pick either fleet as the winner. Rozhestvensky has the Togo in cruisers and in advantage in heavy ships; torpedo vessels. The Japanese crews have shown their indifference to death and their mastery of their business; the Russians stand convicted of firing on harmless fishermen and on each other during a veritable panic on the night of October 22 last. If they have reached a battle-ttemper and attained a creditable accuracy of marksmanship, it is only because of incessant drilling during their long stay in Madagascar waters— a training naturally far inferior to that of Togo’s men during their year of war. Again, of the seven Russian battleships, four are modern and homogeneous ves- sels, while the cruisers are an extraord|- nary assortment of vesse's of all ages, sizes, and speeds, many of them similar to the discarded ships England last week sold at auction. The fastest vessels are undoubtedly the converted German mer- chant steamers, which, to the number of four or five, accompany the warships. But a fleet has at best only the speed moreover, the months vessels of the slowest member: difficulty of coaling and the which have elapsed were docked and cleaned, make it obvl- ous that the obtainable in an emergency cannot be much more than since the speed ten knots an hour. Superior speed is to modern naval combatants what the windward position was to the men who fought the Constitution and her contem- poraries. Togo possessed it in the bat- tle of August 15, and could, therefore, pick his own position and maintain it and pound his enemy at will with his superior long-range cannon. It will be remembered that when nightfall put an end to that contest, Togo drew off his heavy ships and sig- nalled to his torpedo boats to close in, without the latter achieving any results. Indeed, since the beginning of the war only a single vessel has been definitive- ly put out of action by torpedo-boats, and that was the Sevastopol, at anchor and undermanned. To place much faith in Togo’s superiority in scouts of this class is therefore unwarranted, Nor would it avail now to enter into a care- ful comparison of the fleet ship by ship, to show, for instance, that Japan’s six good armored cruisers offset to a large degree Rozhestvensky’s preponderance in battleships. The truth is that no
Page 12
284 [Vol. 80, No. 2076 The Nation. partment knows just what forces Togo can muster—whether, for instance, the Japanese battleship Mikasa, which was terribly pounded in the last fight, has yet been able to take the sea, and whe- ther the old monitor which is sometimes reckoned with Togo's battleships can really take a place in the line of bat- tle. Nor has any writer here or in Eu- rope any idea just how many merchant- men like the America Maru and the Yawata Maru have been added to the fleet cruising in the South China Sea. From the most trustworthy calcula- tions which have yet been made, the Japanese would seem to have a siight preponderance in the amount of metal the rival vessels will be able to dis- charge at one time. But, after all, an accident at the outset may more than even matters up, and so would a failure on Togo’s part to concentrate every available vessel at the hour of combat. We have heard a great deal about the great lesson of this war being the need of battleships. Too little weight has been laid upon the temper of the men who man them. A dozen battleships would not have given Spain the victory at Santiago, and we may yet have a demonstration of how even an unpro- tected cruiser, well handled, may irre- trievably injure towering structures of armor plates and turrets. Only so much may be said: If the spirit which per- vades Rozhesvensky’s fleet is no better than that which actuated the Port Ar- thur vessels, the Japanese will go into action with the paper superiority of the Russians more than discounted, HISTORY AT OXFORD. Confirmatory rumors aside, it may be gathered from a passage in Mr. Firth’s preface to the pamphlet edition of his inaugural lecture (H. Frowde) that Ox- ford circles have been somewhat flutter- ed by the first deliverance of York Pow- ell's successor, “I learn with regret,” says the new Regius Professor, ‘that a passage on page 28 has been construed by some of the teachers of modern his- tory as if it were a personal reflection upon themselves, It was not so intend- ed, and had | thought it could be so taken [ should have expressed myself differently.” The passage in question is probably this: “I cannot infer from anything I have seen that the posses- sion of a proper professional training for the study of history is one of the requisites held necessary for teaching it.” The people here referred to are the college tutors, and by some of them at least Mr. Firth’s inaugural lecture seems to have been thought an unduly severe onslaught upon existing conditions. The establishment of the History School at Oxford and the success which has marked its efforts are notable facts in the life of that university during the one outside of the Japanese Navy De- past generation. Mr. Firth, however, is far from satisfied with the progress al- ready made, and comes forward with a counsel of perfection at the very mo- ment of taking his chair. The existing state of things with its shortcomings is thus set forth: “Our Modern History School was never so large and so flourishing as it now is. Last summer there were some 215 candi- dates, men and women, and there must be now 400 or 500 persons reading for it. From my point of view it has one great defect. It does not train men capable of adding to knowledge. It produces very few historians. I have gone through the class list for the last twenty years with great care, and it is surprising to note how rarely one finds there the name of a man who has since published historical work of any kind, still less historical work of any value. An his- torian seems to be merely an accidental by-product of the school, and not one of the natural results of our elaborate sys- tem of teaching.” A statement like this takes one back immediately to first principles. What does Oxford intend to do for the hun- dreds of students who are giving them- selves up to Modern History? Bent as she long has been on producing states- men rather than scholars, it may be doubted whether she cares to make pure erudition the goal of the History School. Mr. Firth’s quarrel with the present sys- tem is that under it history fs made an instrument and not an object. All that the course attempts to do, he says, “‘is to give men who do not wish to study classics, or mathematics, or science, a sort of general education through his- tory.” As the result of existing theory and practice, well-informed politicians, journalists, and civil servants are turn- ed out, but no true grounding is given in methods of original research, nor is provision made for the technical train- ing, in special branches like paleography and diplomatic, which the graduate in honors should have. Mr. Firth’s assault upon the present programme likewise includes a criticism of the rule which as- signs almost exclusive attention to poli- tics and institutions. The provision that “candidates will be expected to make themselves acquainted with the social and literary history of their period” is, as he says, a dead letter; while, apart from this neglect to read outside the field of politics, everything is done to crowd the memory at the expense of the understanding. Such strictures on the established or- der could hardly be hailed with delight by the college tutors, nor is it by any means certain that Mr. Firth will be able to effect a radical change without their support. At present, he maintains, no scheme of advanced historical in- struction or post-graduate study in his- tory is apt to succeed; and, as an ex- ample, he appeals to the experience of his predecessors in the chair. “I have seen the experiment made twice; once by Professor Freeman and once by Pro- fessor York Powell. In each case it failed. Both may have made mistakes in the execution of their schemes; but neither diligence, nor skill, nor learn- ing could succeed under the conditions with which they had to struggle.” For the present, he urges in conclusion, “the question is not whether I personally am to be'enabled to teach my subject effec- tively, but whether any efficient and suc- cessful scheme for the higher teaching of history is to be established here.” ’ The considerations to which Mr. Firth appeals are undoubtedly strong, but a history tutor in defending the present arrangements would not be left al- together without a case. It does seem hard that the Englishman who takes up the study of history with professional intent should’ be unable to get the grounding he requires at a great seat of learning like Oxford. Mr. Firth appeals to his own experience, and states that it has cost him much la- bor to learn imperfectly in later life what, under other circumstances, he might have learned from a_ specialist while he was still in the junior stages of his preparation. “Since our future historian cannot obtain the special train- ing he needs in the Modern History School, the question arises, where is he to obtain it? Is he to get it in Oxford at all, or must he go to Paris or the Universities of Germany to find it? Now though it is desirable that some should go abroad to get this training, it is not possible for all to do so, and therefore it is necessary to supply it here.’ Begin- ning with his own class, Mr. Firth pro- poses to take up the printed and manu- script authorities for English history between 1605 and 1714, “showing what the materials for writing that history are and where they are to be found.” The discipline to be gained by students following this course will undoubtedly be most valuable for those who enter upon it at all. But the Regius Professor has never, when he meant to do any- thing serious, attracted a large number of students. As soon as the need of in- tensive research is suggested at Oxford, some one objects that the Modern His- tory School “is not meant to give a pro- fessional, but a general training.” Upon this ground the college tutor would take his stand in combating ‘Mr. Firth’s de- mand for a more thorough knowledge of professional method, even though the change of system entailed some sacrifice on the side of general information. If there are four or five hundred persons reading in the Modern History School at the present moment, no one can expect that, under any scheme, more than a tenth of the number will give them- selves up to the professional study of history in after life. Considered from a broad educational standpoint, the inter- ests of the nine-tenths would have to come before those of the saving remnant, assuming that there need be a clash of educational interest at all. Of course, some go so far as to recommend the ad- WER. RC ee saree Maas
Page 13
— Sc SERRE aR Ne eS RRR HN SIS NS NR sada Maiti det erin ict Me i gh tite ORR SEY —-* April 13, 1905] The Nation. mission of undergraduates to seminary courses of a technical character, believ- ing the disciplinary value of such cours- es to be of the highest order. On the cther hand, the view is maintained with much force that the undergraduate should not be set at work of Specializa- tion until he has gained a good deal of historical information—enough, at least, to carry with it some sense of historical perspective. Accordingly, when Mr. Firth comes forward with a sharp criticism of the History School at Oxford, he not only lays his finger upon a local shortcoming, but enters, more or less consciously, the field of educational theory. With his desire to provide means for the profes- sional training of English historians in England, or indeed at Oxford, every one must sympathize, but if his lecture meant the entering wedge of an attack upon the main conception of the Modern History School, as now constituted, he must expect to find himself opposed by a good many who recognize to the full the worth of professional attainments. The discussion thus started is all the more interesting in the light of a new foundation at Oxford. Mr. Firth refers more than once to the new chair of Co- lonial History, as when he says, in con- nection with his projected course on thé seventeenth century, “For the Colonial and American section I hope for help from the future Professor of Colonial History.” Some of those who are con- cerned with the establishment of this new chair feel, we may presume, a stronger interest in political propaganda than they do in pure erudition. If the new Professor of Colonial History Is to give courses on the primary authorities, he is likely, even though he be not an enthusiastic loverof cartography,to have a small class. Now that a few special- ists only should sit under the lecturer on things colonial, is not part, we imagine, of Mr. Beit’s programme. How the new chair is to be filled, how its objects are to be defined, we do not yet know, but our curiosity in the matter is consider- ably heightened by the perusal of Mr. Firth’s lecture. Of this deliverance itself we must speak with warm praise. Mr. Firth is an eminent scholar who expresses his convictions in the most direct and forci- ble terms. That he look’ for the tri- umph of the professional ideal over the conception which now holds sway at Ox- ford, may be judged from his concluding words: “The difficulties are not natural difficulties which beset the teaching of history everywhere; they are local dif- ficulties arising out of defects in our academic organization, difficulties of our own creation, which it is in our power to remove if we have the will. I am confident that we shall remove them.” Such is his own aspiration. The best witness he summons in support of his general position is Stubbs. “Since 285 Creighton left,” says Stubbs in a letter to Freeman (1885), “and even he was scarcely to be regarded as free from the tutorial bias, the historical teaching of history has been practically left out in favor of the class-getting system of training.” Mr. Firth quotes the latter part of this sentence, but it means more when given in full. PARLIAMENTARY DECADENCE ITALY. FLORENCE, March 22, 1905. IN Parliamentary government in Italy, throughout Europe, is everywhere on trial. Even in its birthplace it is far from satis- fying the manifold needs and requisitions of modern times. In France it has never succeeded; in Hungary it was never more than a modus virendi, and has come to a deadlock. Germany is, in reality, a des- potism; Spain is past praying for; and now Italy offers a spectacle that grieves her friends and rejoices her enemies. After the elections last autumn Giolittl appeared to be supported by an immense majority; and when—despite the fact that, though his majority was two-thirds com- posed of clerical conservatives, he still maintained his position as head of a Liber- al Government—he presented the ultra-Rad- ical Marcora as his candidate for the Speakership of the Chamber, his nominee was duly elected by a large majority. The fact was that the country and the Cham- bers were willing to support any ministry that would maintain order and prevent a recurrence of the disorders of last Sep- tember. Another victory was gained by Giolitt! when the law for the civil list was presented. Many are the opponents of the grant of sixteen millions by a country so poor as Italy, but Giolitti succeeded in re- newing it without much opposition. Fi- nally, on February 23, the bill for the resumption by the State of the railways operated for the last twenty years by pri- vate companies was presented. The first fifty-three articles designate the methods of the State operation, which is to be ex- ercised by an autonomist administration Other eighteen articles relate exclusively to the personnel of the railways; only the last seven, and especially the last two, gave rise at once to adverse comments and finally to violent opposition—to obstruction with the threat of a general railway strike. Articles 68, 69, 70 have no special bearing on the question of compulsory arbitration, and, had the bill ended there, it might have passed after considerable amendment. But (owing, it seems, to pressure from Luzzatt!) Giolitti and Tedesco, Ministers of the In- terior and of Public Works, were persuaded to introduce two articles which would have been justifiable in a general law for the regulation of the duties and rights of the employees in the service of the public, but which, intruded into this bill transferring the railways from private companies to the State, were regarded and resented—not only by the railway men and their special cham- pions, but by impartial outsiders—as a di- rect provocation and menace to a special class of proletaries who, it should be re- membered, notwithstanding their exorbi- tant and unjust pretensions, did not take part in the general strike of September. Article 71 provides that the chiefs, promot- ers and organizers of any concert between three or more persons, even if these be extraneous to the administration of the State railways, whose object is to cause suspension, interruption, or service, shall be punished imprison ment. If their object be attained, the prisonment may last year; meanwhile they will be struck the rolls of service, with right to pension or assistance plices may also be dropped from the rolls, lamage to the with im- from six months to a from loss of all “he ac the om- with loss of all right to pension or to as- sistance; or if the think right to retain them in the they punished by diminution of pay or of right to norma! increase. The be assigned to the institutions of assistance Council service may be the forfeits will according to article 56 article 71 will apply The dispositions of railroads con- such treatment to to the ceded to private companies, if panies agree just their employees and to accept The to certain branches of railroads which it is com- to accord compulsory article (72) relates arbitration. last proposed to relinquish to private compa- nies, at least for a time Giolitti, who had been absent for some days on account of present while his colleague Tedesco presented his bill. The latter suggested the examination of it by the committee which had completed the study of the railway question prior to the general elections, but the clined the proposal, as the complete and the time limited, but agreed to another suggestion, viz., that each of the nine offices destined to examine and report on all bills should name each a single mem- ber, and these, united in a committee, should duly report. Giolittl, who was look- ing extremely ill and weary, took no part in the discussion, the House as soon as the question of reference was decided. Meanwhile, the railway organizations con- voked the central committee of members, protesting that the was disastrous to their interests; that pledges given by the Minister of Public Works in the last interview had not fulfilled, and that the the right to strike were a violation of the established law of the realm. The Social- ists in the House determined at opposition; three of them to the conference of the with closed doors—the entire press cluding the Avanti) being excluded. It was soon known, however, that two distinct tendencies were manifest; one inclining to Parliamentary efforts for the withdrawal of the obnoxious articles, the other, to an immediate and general strike—the delegates from the southern provinces unanimousiy insisting on the latter measure. The three Deputies exerted themselves to the utmost to nip this fatal project, insisting that its only result would be the return to the “conventions” and draconian measures against the whole body of railway servants, which would be sanctioned by the general public, exasperated by the pretensions of one section of workingmen to sacrifice the interests of the entire nation to their ex- orbitant exactions. All that they could ob- tain was the substitution of general ob- struction for that of a general strike. This system was first applied materially at Genoa last year, and consisted in the illness, was House de- studies were and withdrew from forty-five bill the whole been articles denying once on were summoned held (in- “forty-five”
Page 14
286 The Nation. [Vol. 80, No. 2076 scrupulous application, by the custom-house servants, of the regulations, the whole reg- ulations, and nothing but the regulations, They triumphed, and the railway servants bethought themselves to repeat the experi- ment. Their regulations amount to several hundred, none of which, even the most necessary, are in general observance. Thus, by rule, passengers must present them- selyes with the exact sum for the purchase of their tickets, but hitherto change has always been given. Now, the regulation was enforced; the ticket purchaser had to go out and get change or lose his train. The luggage, registered, has to be locked, sealed, and corded, so that no thief can extract articles from the portmanteau or trunk, but few attend to the rule; now, all luggage had to be sealed and corded afresh. The personal baggage taken into the car- riage ought not to exceed a certain size and a certain weight, but a good fee to a porter insured the entrance of any amount, so that often a later comer could find no room for a handbag or hat-box. Now, every bag or packet was measured and weighed. Deputies, who travel gratis, should have certificates in their pockets, and, if re- quested, sign their names. Hitherto, it has sufficed to show their medals; now, they were requested to produce their certificates and sign their names. By regulation all the carriages must be cleaned and the lamps polished, the windows cleaned, the hot-wa- ter tins filled with boiling water. Travel- lers can attest to the filthy state of the carriages, to the stone-cold tins, smoking and stinking lamps, broken windows, car- riage tops letting in rain, wind, and snow. Now, all was to be perfection. Vainly, the station masters, the train conductor, hurried on the men. They were obeying the “reg- ulations’; their superiors could not demur. Hence, delays in passenger trains of from one hour to twelve. Sixty-four trains were suspended at Rome, passengers to Frascati, to Albano, ete., had to charter carriages, and the old diligences reappeared. As for the goods traffic, that had ceased entirely, and the post-office authorities gave notice that they could not be responsible for par- cels-post deliveries. Here, in the market, fish, fresh vegetables, and fruit arrived too late for sale. The public, patient and often amused for the first day or so, gradually became rest- ive, clamorous, finally furious; many of the railway men, such as porters, were depriv- ed of their daily bread, which depends on the tips of the passengers, who ceased to yisit Florence, Rome, and other cities where obstruction obtained. Appeals to the Gov- ernment from all the commercial and in- dustrial classes dependent on visitors were made in vain. Gilolitti kept silence, and, being Minister of the Interior, was held responsible for the situation, “He was too ill to present himself to the House.” There and in the Senate the Minister of Public Works had to reply to the protests and the interpellations. He declared that he had no intention to withdraw the obnoxious ar- ticles; that the Home Minister had no Iin- tention of using force against the obstruc- tionists, but that they would use means to compel the responsible companies to fulfil their duties and comply with the terms of their contract. How? The ‘‘superiors” could not compel their “inferiors’ to dis- obey the regulations; they-might be com- pelled to pay fines for delays for non-trans- mission of goods, but that would not bring the trains in on time or deliver the goods stalled at the depots. Meanwhile the obstructionists were grow- ing weary of their long hours of labor, and were shamed by the reproaches of their companions who were injured by their tac- tics—specially the engine-drivers of the suppressed trains, who were paid by the mile. In short, the proverbial patience of the Latin race was giving way. The Dep- uties, not only Socialists, but Radicals and Republicans, well-wishers, advised the men to yield, reminding them that the bill was in the hands of the committee, that they were fighting no longer private companies, but the national Parliament. Pantano, their most zealous champion, made an eloquent appeal both to their own interests and to their position among the proletaries. Cola- janni lashed them right and left as a self- ish, arrogant, unreasonable crew, who, having decent wages and the certainty of constant employment with a pension for themselves and widows, were damaging the whole of the starving and semi-starving proletaries, assuring them that while they might continue so to do, they would in the end ruin themselves. In short, between weariness and shame, they had resolved to put an end to obstruction as soon as they could induce the rebellious southerners to submission. Then, like a bolt from the blue, in the middle of a debate in the House and Senate, Tedesco announced the resignation of Gio- litti, Premier and Home Minister, on the plea of illness, and the King’s accep- tance of his resignation. “Flight the tourth,” said his enemies; and in fact this is the fourth time that Giolitti has with- drawn suddenly from the Ministry without any vote of want of confidence in the House. His friends and supporters, instead, maintained that he had remained at his post only too long, and that another forty- eight hours might have proved fatal. In either case, his withdrawal from the scene of action saved the amour propre of the ob- structionists, who instantly ceased their manceuvres, and ordered all the railway men on the continent and in the islands to celebrate their victory by returning to their ‘“‘non-obedience to the regulations,” as their tactics had compelled the Minister to take flight—the Ministry, they might have added, as the entire Cabinet resigned on the same evening. Here was a curious situation for the King, who, if he had been well advised, would have accepted the retirement of Gio- litt! alone on the plea of ill-health, re- taining the other ministers bound to his programme, supported by his majority in the House. Then the King would only have had to name a President and Minister ad interim, following the precedent of old Piedmont in 1864. At the commencement of that year, poor Farini gave signs not only of failing health, but of mental de- rangement. King Victor Emanuel, after seeing that he was duly cared for, named Minghetti, hitherto Minister of Finance, Minister of the Interior in his stead, and the Cabinet continued its business without interruption. As Giolitti resigned solely on account of illness, why should not the King have named one of the Ministers in his place? Why, indeed? Such, it seems, was his intention, but the divisions and jeal- ousies among the Ministers themselves and the pretensions of the various groups ren- dered this impossible. Tittoni, Minister for Foreign Affairs, had a considerable party, and to him, as it now turns out, the King inclined, but the opposition was such that he was compelled to summon an outsider, and this, by Giolitti’s advice, was Alexander Fortis, who, as the whole Ministry had re- signed, set to work to form a new one, ex- cluding d@ priori Tedesco, Minister of Pub- lic Works (as Fortis, though favorable to the State working of the railroads, did not intend to endorse the famous articles re- lating to the railway men, reserving for a separate bill the question of strikes by the employees of public services), and Orlando, the Minister of Public Instruction, who has given great offence to the clerical-con- servative majority by siding with the par- tisans for the exclusion of religious in- struction from the elementary schools, and has also given great offence to certain “people of importance’? who consider that public. instruction was instituted in the interests of professors and teachers rather than in that of scholars and students. From the first moment the Opposition bat- teries assailed Fortis in front, on flank, and rear. Fortis was from a lad an ardent Maz- zinian, and one of Garibaldi’s bravest sol- diers, but he joined Crispi’s Ministry from 1887 to 1891. Moreover, as an advocate, he was mixed up with the Tanlongo banking scandals, and so is dubbed ‘“‘immoral.”” The Republicans and Socialists will none of him; and Sonnino, head of “his Majesty’s Oppo- sition,” told him point-blank that the at- tempt to solve the crisis was unconstitution- al, that he would not assist in its solution in this fashion, and that he would oppose the new Ministry if formed. The Zanardellians were also hostile, and Fortis could not find a single competent person willing to assume the difficult department of Public Works or that of Public Instruction. The days drew on to ten, and at last Fortis decided to pre- sent the whole Ministry as it existed at the time of Giolitti’s retirement. But here he met with a refusal from Tedesco and Or- lando, who declined to return to posts “which had been put up at auction,” and only reoffered to them because no bidders appeared. So Fortis had to resign the man- date, well aware who was the deus ex ma- china that put spoke after spoke into his wheels, and that hoped to be summoned by the King on his failure. But the young King was not inclined to satisfy Luzzatti, espe- cially as he had come to grief with the Min- ister of War, and summoned instead Tit- toni, Minister of the Foreign Office, naming him Premier and Minister of the Interior, bidding him present himself with all the old members of the late Ministry to the House, and to demand explicitly a vote of confi- dence. This is the state of affairs at the present moment, and a more disgraceful one can scarcely be imagined. March 23. The first sitting of the House, with more than 400 Deputies present, listened to Tit- toni’s “exposition” in ironical silence. The brilliant orator of the Radicals, Barzilai (the first of seventeen members listed to speak), ridiculed the presentation of phantoms evok- ed from their tombs, blamed Giolitti for his sudden withdrawal from the scene of action when, had he remained at his post for an- other day, the railway obstruction would have been ended, biamed his colleagues for following his example, which acts put them —
Page 15
Seip ‘April 13, 1905] The Nation. a “out of court.” He affirmed the necessity of rendering railway strikes impossible, as they signify public disaster and cut the main arteries of the life of the State. Face to face with the right to strike stands the right of citizens to legitimate protection, the right of the State to legitimate defence. But the seventy-first and seventy-second articles are inapplicable; the penal code contains an arsenal of effectual measures. Other ora- tors followed, but the House was impatient, and cries of ‘‘Closure!’”’ were heard. To- morrow, possibly, the vote may be taken, but it will decide only the acceptance or the non-acceptance of the old Ministry. J. W. MM. HOUSSAYE’S ‘1815.’ Paris, March 22, 1905. M Henry Houssaye has published in one volume his very dramatic studies on the events of the close of the year 1815, in the series forming a sequel to his ‘1814,’ which has had a very rapid and well-deserved success (it has already attained a forty- sixth edition). The new volume is the third part of ‘1815.’ The first had for sub-title “The First Restoration—The Return from the Island of Elba—The Hundred Days”; the second was entirely devoted to Water- loo (these two parts have likewise attained a forty-fifth edition). This popular success shows that M. Henry Houssaye has struck a sensitive chord in public opinion. The people have always worshipped heroes, and in this respect such men as Carlyle and Emerson have felt like the people. The great prevailing curiosity on the sub- ject of Napoleon does not prove that the Bonapartist party is in the ascendant: it might almost be said that this curiosity is purely historical and sentimental. The Empire is a thing of the past, and is treated as such with the spirit in which we ap- proach distant events surrounded with a poetical halo. There is no party spirit in the judgments that are formed on the Na- poleonic era; the popular mind is forcibly drawn towards the figure of Napoleon as in other times it was drawn towards Charlemagne and his preux; few, if any, hope or desire new Napoleonic chapters in our history, as we cannot forget the end of such chapters—Waterloo and Sedan. We can quite understand the violence of the passions which followed the second Restoration. The émigrés had hardly en- joyed a moment the reéstablishment of the old régime when they were wakened from their dreams by the return of the Emperor from Elba. The King fled to Ghent. It is easy to imagine with what feelings he re- turned to the Tuileries after Waterloo. To do him justice, he maintained a calm and composure not shared by the royalists. We must admire the conduct of the Duke de Richelieu, who was charged with the diffi- cult mission of ending the diplomatic rela- tions with the Allies. Richelieu enjoyed the personal friendship of the Czar, but Alex- ander was obliged to make allowance for the feelings of his Allies. The peace pre- liminaries were signed on the 1st of Octo- ber, and the treaty of peace on the 20th of November. France had to cede four fort- resses—Landau, Sarrelouis, Philippeville, Marienbourg, and a territory of 395 square leagues, to demolish the fortifications of Hiningen; she was to be occupied along the frontier for a period of three to five years by an army of 150,000 men, paid and fed by her, and was to pay an indemnity of 700 millions. “After Richelieu put his trembling hand to the preliminaries, he returned to the Council. He was as pale as death. He had contained himself before the foreigners; now he burst out: ‘Iam dishonored. Hav- ing consented, I should bring my head to the scaffold. Could I do otherwise? What resistance can France make in the state she is now in? Why did 1 return to my unfortunate country? It would have been better for me to remain in Asia.’” The pacification of France was no easy mat- ter; the King had to sign an ordinance for examining the conduct of the officers of all ranks who had taken service during what was called the usurpation. The new Cham- ber was animated with the most ardent pas- sions; it was afterwards called, on account of its violence, ‘‘la Chambre introuvable.” The most famous incident of this period was the trial of Marshal Ney. It came at the moment when Murat was shot in Cala- bria. Murat, after his dethronement, re- paired to a villa in the neighborhood of Toulon till the end of July. Learning that the royalists were going to arrest him, he took flight and embarked for Corsica on the 2ist of August. He for some time found there a refuge in the house of Gen. Fran- ceschelli, at Vescovato. He sent an emis- sary to Metternich to obtain a safe-conduct; receiving no answer, he took a desperate step, and tried to reénter the Kingdom of Naples, hoping to meet with the enthu- siasm which Napoleon had encountered on his return from Elba. He embarked with ten officers and 200 soldiers in several boats. They were separated by a storm, and Murat arrived at Pizzo with twenty-six officers and men only. It was a Sunday; the population, with the help of some gendarmes, took Murat and his followers to the prison of the fortress. The order came from Naples to try Murat, and he was executed on the 14th of October. The same fate awaited Marshal Ney. He left Paris on the 6th of July, with pass- ports under the names of Falize and of Neu- bourg. He learned at Lyons that the roads to Switzerland were guarded by the Aus- trians; he returned in the direction of Paris, and, after some hesitation, took ref- uge in the chateau of Bessonies, which be- longed to a relation of his wife, the Princess de la Moskova. He was recognized on the way, and reported to the prefect. His ar- rest took place on the 3d of August. “It will be a great example,” said Talleyrand, when he heard the news. The Prince de la Moskova was conducted to Paris and con- fined in the Conciergerie on the 19th of Au- gust, the day of the execution of La Bé- doyére. A council of war was formed, com- posed, among others, of Marshals Mon- cey, Masséna, Augereau, Mortier. Masséna excused himself on the plea of ill-health, so did Augereau; Moncey alsoalleged ill-health, being determined not to become the judge of Ney, and wrote to Louis XVIII. a letter in which he said: ‘Can I be the judge of an accused man to whom our laws give the right to object to me, since he cannot be ignorant that I was the first to put in the hands of your Majesty the material proof of his defection, and to manifest my in- dignation at it?” The answer of Louis XVIII. was short: “Marshal Moncey is cashiered; he will be imprisoned for three months,” The trial began after a long Instruction. Ney’s lawyers pleaded the Incompetence of the Council of War, and the members of the Council declared themselves incompetent The case had to be brought before the House of Peers. It clearly resulted from the examination of witnesses that Ney had acted without premeditation. When he left Paris, he had firmly resolved to arrest Na- poleon; in the strongest language he had promised the King to do so. “He had done,’ writes M. Houssaye, “everything for five days to maintain his feeble army corps in obedience, and to gain the flank of the Bonapartist column. But, seeing the national revo- lution swelling round him—the people in the cities and in the country—seeing the national flag floating on every church spire, half of his troops in march to join the Em- peror, and the other half all ready to mu- tiny, he lost his head and threw himeelf into the current. Ney clearly was wrong; he ought not to have accepted the mission of marching against Napoleon, or, having done so, he ought not to have remained at the head of his army corps when it prepared to join Napoleon.” Condemnation was just and inevitable, in the opinion of the lawyers who undertook his defence (Berryer and Dupin). They de- fended their client solely on the plea that he was screened by an article of the con- vention of Saint-Cloud, signed by the Allies, in virtue of which “all the individuals who were at the time in Paris could not be prosecuted for their functions, their con- duct, or their opinions.’” There was much discussion about this convention, which in reality was purely military; but Ney and his defenders had many illusions on this point. The convention had an equivocal text; when Berryer tried to invoke it, the Chancellor intervened and said: “In virtue of my discretionary power, I forbid dis- cussion of a treaty in which the King had no participation.” Ney was born at Sar- relouis, which had ceased to be French. The lawyers used this as an argument; upon which Ney rose and said loudly: “Il am French, I will die a Frenchman. Thus far my defence has seemed to be free; I see that it is no longer so. I am ac- cused against the faith of the Treaties, and I do not wish them to be invoked. I will do as Moreau did, and make my ap- peal to Europe and posterity.” When the vote was taken on the question submitted to the court, ‘‘Did Marshal Ney make an attempt on the security of the State?” Lanjuinais said, ‘Yes; but he was covered by the terms of the capitulation of Paris.”” A single peer said “Nay.” He was the youngest of the House, a Royalist by tradition and sentiment. His father died on the guillotine under the Terror. This was Victor de Broglie, and he gave the rea- sons for his verdict: “There is no crime without a criminal intention. I see in the facts with which Marshal Ney is justly reproached neither premeditation nor intention to betray. At the last moment, he succumbed to an en- trainement which seemed to him general, and which was only too much so. It was @ weakness which history will judge severely, but which does not fali, in the present case, under the definition of the law. There are events which soar above human justice.” The details of the last days of Ney and of his execution are dramatically told by M. Houssaye. This execution was one of the great blunders of the Restoration. The country did not forgive it. Ney remained in its eyes what Napoleon had once catied him, “the bravest of the brave.” A tew
Page 16
288 The Nation. [Vol. 80, No. 2076 years afterwards, when M. de Ségur wrote his book on the Russian campaign and re- treat—a retreat which Ney made on foot, among the soldiers—the Duchess of Angou- léme, hearing this chapter of the retreat read aloud, exclaimed: ‘‘Oh, if we had only known!” Alas! party spirit is often blind, and sometimes wilfully blind. How many times in the history of a nation might these words be spoken: ‘‘If we had only known!” Correspondence. THE PRESIDENT AND JUDGE KOHL- SAAT. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Your comments on the promotion of Christian C. Kohlsaat from district judge to United States circuit judge in Illi- nois are based, of course, on the formal charges against him as they appeared in the public prints. As is usually the case, these are only the surface indications of conditions which make this appointment a reproach to the appointing power, and a cause of deep regret to those who have hoped for a higher standard of action in President Roosevelt in filling judicial of- fices. As is well known, Judge Kohlsaat’s origi- nal appointment was made to pay an accu- mulation of indebtedness, political and financial, from Mr. McKinley to H. H. Kohl- saat, Judge Kohlsaat’s brother. The unfit- ness of the appointee has been daily demon- strated since. He is not supposed to be corrupt, but not only is he without legal attainments or ability—his stupidity is both moral and mental. It may well be as- sumed that he was not fully conscious of the impropriety of the appointments which placed about him a band of vicious self- seekers to gather the profits from the vast aggregate of bankrupt estates which crowd the threshold of his court. They were his son and his brother-in-law, and his faithful attendant, Whitney. It was well under- stood at the bar that the naming of the right man for receiver or trustee was a con- dition precedent to the progress of a cause. The estimate of his quality by the bar is well enough evidenced by the fact that sucb written opinions as were delivered by him were universally attributed to the brain and hand of another, a confidential em- ployea, The means by which he secured his recent promotion is a proper sequel to the history of his original appointment, and is to the lasi degree discreditable to the President, for the facts were all before him. Senator Hopkins, whose primary use for political position is the opportunity it affords for his personal benefit, and whose political and moral standards are not unswerving, has a son who, after one unsuccessful effort, was admitted to the bar at twenty-five. He has never taken life seriously, and some of his habits may have caused the Senator appre- hensions for his future. A regard for the usefulness and dignity of the courts or the welfare of suitors could not have prompted his demand that Judge Kohisaat appoint this immature youth to the responsible po- sition of master in chancery. He may have looked for a development, jn this office, of the young man’s mental and moral nature. In exchange for the proposed obsession of the judicial function, he had to offer to Judge Kohlsaat a promotion to a higher place yet to be created. The Bar Associa- tion of Chicago by a unanimous vote pro- tested against the appointment, and ap- pointed a committee to procure, if possible, its retraction. The facts were all be- fore the President. The appointment was a conscious subordination by him of the pub- lic welfare and the usefulness of the bench to indefensible political considerations. It has confirmed in the minds of many sup- porters and admirers of Theodore Roose- velt the growing conviction that the pro- tection of the bench from the lowest po- litical influences will receive no considera- tion at his hands. In fact, there were oth- er candidates for the three judgeships which were filled by him at the same time, much superior to any of those whom he ap- pointed. These appointments are often referred to as a complete answer to the ad- vocacy of an appointive judiciary as against an elective one. The average of the three is distinctly below the average of judges on the local bench in Chicago. JOHN A. WOODRUFF. Curoaao, April 3, 1905. [Is President Roosevelt’s solemn pledge to carry on the policy of McKin- ley of no avail here by way of extenua- tion? Let the Canton Monument an- swer.—Eb. NATION.] THE CHICAGO OBSESSION. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sr: The touching, childlike, popular ob- session that, in some way not clearly un- derstood but firmly believed in, any and every government possesses miraculous powers, transcending all ordinary human knowledge, and defying the ordinary rules of logic derived from human experience, was illustrated recently by the municipal elec- tions in Chicago. The street-car service be- ing undeniably bad, it was voted that the public authorities of the city should take it over and administer it, presumably on the supposition that, by such change from private to public administration, the ser- vice would be bettered. The long vista of possible patronage and delectable pickings is undoubtedly attractive to the hungry horde who now administer public affairs extravagantly and inefficiently; but the willingness of the public to put more pow- ers and responsibilities into the hands of unfaithful and incompetent servants is ex- plicable, not on grounds of common sense and business principles, but by that curi- ous survival in free and enlightened and democratic America of what was once known as the divine right of kings. Scrof- ula used to be cured by the King’s touch; the traction question will be cured by the Mayor's touch, Any man of good, rugged sense, with a pair of eyes in his head, would say that the city had reached its limits in the way of surface street railways, and that a subway, like those of similar cities, was needed. Not so in Chicago! All that is necessary here is to select a gentleman of the legal profession—a man wholly without experience in the fleld of tractlon—elect him to a high public office, and set him on the throne, with his proper regalia, and, thus endowed with transcendent miraculous powers, he will touch the knotty problem with his magic wand, and presto! ’tis done. Query: In writing political and economic history, where will future historians mark the end of the Middle Ages? M. RESTRICT THE SUFFRAGE. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: It is really cheering in these days of ultra democracy—or, still better, ‘‘mob- democracy”—to read such bold words as those of Mr. EB. L. C. Morse in the last number of the Nation. What the whole country needs is better suffrage rather than more suffrage. The North may possibly fear to curtail its “blocks of five’ lest the South say Ju quoque. The South had to protect itself, and restricted suffrage in various ways. The North thinks the ne- grees are wronged by their loss of voting power. What the negroes have lost is the power to do themselves and others harm. While they had the vote, they were the pliant tools of the unscrupulous. Were they to receive the unrestricted power to vote again, they would at once fall into the hands of the unscrupulous. The white man, by the bestowal of suffrage on the black man, would do the black man no good, but would do himself a wrong. It would give the professional politician an opportunity of adding one more to the vices of the poor black, the corruption of his vote. Were the whole country to restrict the suffrage, no wrong would be done to those deprived, but a power of wrong-doing to others would be withdrawn. A democracy is very liable to be dominated by mere words. Suffrage, manhood suffrage, sounds so kind, so generous, and withal so logi- cal, that any restriction must have its Nemesis, when, in reality, the Nemesis is being invoked by this very logic. Unre- stricted suffrage at the present time, in this country, when the North is flooded with the hoi pollot of Europe and Asia, and the South is largely African, is neither kindness nor generosity, but a_ striking symptom of insanity. For a democracy to be undemocratic may be illogical, but there can be worse things than bad logic, such as conduct with bad and subverting tendencies. The next thing to doing good is to take away the power of doing ill. That this is a time for the negative virtues is obvious to the dullest observer, but the laborers in the vineyard are few and their efforts feeble. J. A. BARTHOLOMEW, NapPues, N. Y. [Our correspondent may fancy him- self standing on Mr. Morse’s platform, but there is (or we are mistaken) an “open door” between them. Is this de- fender of the South’s “restriction” of negro suffrage prepared to restrict (in the same section, of course) white suf- frage on the same terms honestly ap- plied? Is he prepared to defend and help maintain—and does he really de- sire—a negro’s fulfilment of the condi- tions laid down? Or is he, in short, in favor of a white oligarchy in perpetuity? —Ep. NATION.] i ERR — a
Page 17
ee April 13, 1905] The Nation. WACK AND BOULGER. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Srr: The first part of Mr. Henry Welling- ton Wack’s ‘The Story of the Congo ,Free State,’ reviewed in your No. 2,075, is so strikingly like an earlier work by Mr. De- metrius C. Boulger, ‘The Congo State’ (Lon- don, 1898), that the resemblance can hard- ly be accidental. The similarity begins with the chapter headings, viz.: WACK. BOULGER, II. Leopold’s Concep- | I. The Conception of tion of the Congo; the Congo State. Free State. } Ill. The Founding of | Ill. The Founding of the Free State. } the State. IV. Early Belgian Ex- | II. The First Belgian ixpeditions. peditions. V. The Waterways of | IV. The Congo and its Affluents. the Congo. VII. The Horrors of} V. The Slave-trade and the Arab Slave Trade. its Horrors. XI. The Second Brus- VII. The ee sels Conference. fiviesete Cotiference XII. The Congo be- a a * King’s Will queathed to Belgium. and the Aing’s as XIII. The Tribes of | XVIII. The Peoples of the Congo Free State. the Congo State. XIII. The Congo Pub- lic Force. XIV. The Congo Pub- | Cam-| 1X. The Arab Cam- lic Force. XV. Belgian paigns against the paign. Arabs. } XVII. The Suppression | XI. The Extinction of of Slavery. XX. The Mutinies of the Batetela Tribe. Slavery. XIV. The Mutinies. Batetela The similarity does not rest with the chapter headlines. Mr. Wack is good enough to be independent in the first four pages of his book. He then paraphrases Boulger, using much of the same phraseolo- gy and the same sequence of thought, so that his pages 4 to 16 will be found to cor- respond to Boulger’s pages 3 to 18. This method is continued through the first half of the book as follows: Wack’s pages 4-16; 19-28; 32-41; 42-58; 92-103; 134-144; 145-150; 164-170; 177-185; 189-196; and 216-219, will be found to correspond respectively to the following pages of Boulger: 3-18; 41-58; 20- 30; 75-85; 57-70; 146- 161-169; 175-181; 242-246. 153; 154-159; 225-235; In other words, about 94 pages of Mr. Wack’s book are paraphrased from 105 of Boulger’s. One paragraph taken at random will show Mr. Wack’s method: WACK (page 40), “The first station to be founded was Vivi, and six months were spent in fortifying it. Then came the con- struction of a road from Vivi to Isanghila —fifty miles higher up the river—required for the conveyance of the steamers in section, stores, merchandise, etc. This proved a formidable task, and took a whole year to accomplish. But Stan- ley and his men prov- ed equal to it, and an- other station was founded at Isanghila. At that station, fortu- nately, the Congo was found to be navigable, and Stanley pushed on to Manyanga by boat, where he founded a third station. It was while at Manyanga that Stanley first learned of M. de Braz- za’s having set up the French flag on the northern shore of Stanley Pool, and call- ing it Brazzaville.’’ BOULGER (page 28.) | “The next task | proved to be more uuous. It consisted of constructing a cart- road from Vivi to Isanghila, over fifty miles higher up the river. It required twelve months’ inces- sant labor to con- Struct the road and to convey along it the steamers in sections and the merchandise and stores of the ex- eae Isanghila Stanley founded another sta- tion similar to that of Vivi, and, availing himself of the short section of navigable river between that place and Manyanga, he floated two of his steamers and reached Manyanga by water. There he founded a third station. . Stanley soon attained striking evidence of the perils of any de- lay, by learning that M. de Brazza, the French traveller, had appeared on the north shores of Stanley Pool, and founded Brazzaville in the name and under the flag of France,’’ Very respectfully yours, Jesse 8. REEVES. Ricumonp, Inprawa, April 7, 1905, THE CHEAP PROFESSOR. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sin: We college professors are made to feel in many ways the estimation in which we are held by most people not closely con- nected with academic pursuits. At the out- set we are commonly angered by it; wards it drives us to woe; finally we learn after- | to see its sadly humorous aspects—the sad- | ness doubtless due to the consciousness that we to some extent are charged. guilty as As some of my fellow-professors are said not to read fiction, permit me to use your columns to call their attention, in this connection, to the gist of a story, entitled “The Spirit of Partnership,’’ which has just appeared in the April number of Harper's Vagazine. No slur at the story, as such, is intended, for it is quite up to the usual magazine level, but I have never seen in print anywhere a more delicious expression of this general estimation of us than it gives. Mrs. Rogers has again been made presi- dent of the “Business Woman's Club,” so the story runs, ‘‘which had grown under her hands from a small Woman’s Exchange to an institution with many departments.” To the office is to be attached hereafter a small salary (sum not mentioned). She sits down to think it over in the presence of the furniture, now worn and shabby, which her father gave her at her marriage some thirty years ago. Just then her husband comes in, “a deprecating little figure.”’ “He had worked at on« desk, on one salary, ever since she had known him.” Even when they married, it was inadequate (sum not mentioned). Moreover, he has long cherished a desire to write a learned book which she, though his wife, feels sure would be a failure. Now he comes to tell her that he has been discharged and can find no other job. After this humiliating con- fession he finds a letter, delivered in his absence, which gives him an electric shock. In his desperation he had written to a friend at the State University to know whether his “ancient languages and history hadn’t some chance for usefulness.’”’ The answer is an offer of the chair (evidently more of a settee than a chair) at a smaller salary (sum not mentioned) than he has been getting, “but a house with ground enough for a garden goes with it, and liv- ing in Barville won’t cost-——.” I pass by the ethical, or social, or eco- nomic (I am really at a loss for the proper adjective here) question whether a woman who has just been elected president of the Business Woman’s Club of a city, with a small salary, has the right to follow her husband to the State University at Bar- ville, at a still smaller salary. Besides, two other matters interest me more: (1) The State University at Barville, which gives its professorships to discharged and none too efficient bookkeepers of over fifty. (2) The wives of the professors of the State University at Barville after the arrival of Mrs. Rogers—for, of course, she sacrifices herself for her husband. W. R. FOLK-LORE COINAGE. To THE EpDITOR OF THE NATION: Sin: Having had occasion of late to in- vestigate a certain phase of (American) Indian folk-lore, I spent a few hours over a volume entitled ‘Legends of the Ozarks,’ published in 1880 at St. Louis In the in troduction, the author makes this state- ment: “The writer has succeeded in re ring from the musty relics of the past e of the most interesting legends having their origin with the Indians and the famous Hot Springs of Arkansas, and now seeks to pre- serve them by issuing this little book, con taining the stories illustrative of the ex- quisite imagination and veneratior ancient tribes of America Small as is the volume, there is enough in it to excite suspicion, and it may serve others if I state that I now hold in my hands the written confession of the author that the tales in question “have no histori- cal value whatever, being colnages of tke imagination, my imagination.” In view of this frank confession, I will neither parade the author's name, nor discuss the ethics of his forgery; but it student of folk-lore should be in possession is only right that the of the facts A good many volumes of In- dian folk-lore have been published within the last few years. How many may be due to the imagination of the Yankee more than to that of the Redskin, seems to me a ques- tion deserving of attention. Yours sincerely, E. WASHBURN HOPKINS New Haven, Conn., April 6, 1905 Notes. Sport in England has at last its ‘Who's Who.’ Two-thirds of A. Wallis Myers’s ‘Sportsman's Year-book’ for 1905 (London: Newnes; New York: Scribners) is taken up with biographies of champions and ex- champions, of motorists, Jockeys, even club secretaries—on a principle of inclusion not strictly defined by the editor, who hints at enlargement, upon the requisite support. Richard Croker is here to be met beside a son of Francis Darwin, distinguished at golf. Women occur more sparingly, of course, but are devotees of hockey, gol, tennis, croquet; own breeding kennels, or hunt the pack with their harriers. The fore part of the Year-book is occupied by readable summary statistical reviews of the several lines of sport during 1904 Many illustrations ef man and beast adorn the uncommonly attractive volume, typographi- cally considered, From C, Mitchell & Co., ceive the sixtieth issue (‘diamond jubiiee"’) of their ‘Newspaper Press Directory.’ De- cidedly the most interesting thing about this work (confined to the United Kingdom and the British Isles) is Mr. Walter Wells- man’s modest statement that he assisted the founder with the first issue, in 1546; In 1857 became sub-editor; in 1859, upon Mr. Mitchell’s death, chief editor, which he still remains. This is a gazetteer in its way. Ot maps it gives but one, from which we perceive that even in the Orkneys two newspapers are published in a single town, Kirkwall. Among unexpected contributed matter is an article on ‘The Australian La- bor Party and the Empire,’ by the Hon. W. P. Reeves, Agent-General for New Zealand From Messrs. Scribner we have the fourth issue of ‘Baedcker's Northern France,’ the field bounded by Dunkirk, Antwerp, Cologne, Strassburg, Basel, Blols, Le Mans, Alengon, London, we re-
Page 18
290 The Nation. [Vol. 80, No. 2076 and Havre; exclusive of Paris. There is, besides this proper map, a larger map of northwestern France from below the Loire, together with the customary detailed sec- tions, charts, plang of cities, etc., inserted amid the itinerary. In a handsome quarto volume, ‘The His- tory of the Victoria Cross’ (London: Archi- bald Constable & Co.; New York: Dutton), Philip Wilkins relates the 520 conspicuous acts of bravery which have called for as many bestowals of the decoration, institut- ed in 1856 and made retroactive for the Crimean war. These plain tales are ac- companied by a remarkably large number (392) of portraits of the recipients; by statutory and narrative appendices; by a table of awards of the cross by branches of the service; and by a personal index. The scheme has been very carefully and soberly carried out, and as many of the decorated attained high rank in army or navy, the portrait gallery is decidedly val- uable, as well as interesting to the stu- dent of physiognomy. The first award was for picking up a live shell dropped on the deck of H. M. 8S. Hecla in 1859 by Mate (now Rear-Admiral, retired) Charles Davis Lucas; the latest is Lieut. (now Capt.) Wallace Duffield Wright’s standing off in Nigeria 1,000 cavalry and 2,000 infantry with only one officer and forty men, and finally putting the enemy to flight, in 1903. Mr. William L. Scruggs’s new edition of his ‘Colombian and Venezuelan Republics’ (Boston: Little, Brown & Co.) is mainly a revision; it contains, however, a new chap- ter on ‘Panama Canal Projects,” which brings the history of the canal very nearly down to the present time, and gives an out- line of the facts connected with the birth of the Republic of Panama. Mr. Scruggs’s book is almost entirely descriptive and his- torical. In his Panama chapter there is nothing of any critical value. The opera- tion by which we ousted Colombia and sub- stituted Panama is represented by him to have been justifiable, in the interests of “civilization,” though he admits that there have been, and possibly still are, some dif- ferences of opinion about it. But the peo- ple “have endorsed the action of the Prest- dent, and, moreover, what has been done is an accomplished fact, and cannot now be undone, even if that were desirable.” The author represented this country in Colom- bia and Venezuela for many years, and had excellent opportunities for observation and study. He writes generally with fairness, but superficially. In his chapter on Cura- ¢ac he describes the local patois as “a curious jargon made up of corrupted Dutch, Spanish, and English words, quite unintel- ligible to foreigners.” This is a very in- sufficient if not misleading account of a philologically interesting phenomenon, Ow- ing to the separation of Curacao from the fortunes of the mainland, and the vicissi- tudes of its history, a genuine local lan- guage was developed, of which there is a regular grammar, and in which newspapers are or were recently published, and busi- ness carried on. It might be called a lingua franca, but to go out of the way to notice it as an unintélligible jargon, seems in an old resident of Carfcas to argue a kind of ineptitude for critical observation. The book contains several illustrations and maps. The extraordinary output of Nature Books of one kind or another we owe doubtless to the greatly improved methods of preparing illustrations by photographic processes. Many of these processes are well-nigh per- fect, and can be criticised unfavorably only by those who deplore the inevitable de- cline of wood-engraving. Among the most insistent, and perhaps the most attractive, of these nature-books are the wild-flower and the garden series of all sorts. We had occasion lately to notice an excellent practical work on the Iris. This has been followed by a small book on the Lily, ‘The Book of the Lily,’ by W. Goldring (John Lane). The author gives a clear general statement in regard to the cultivable spe- cies, hybrids, and varieties, and illustrates the handy treatise by exquisite pictures of a few of the best kinds and their most art- istic setting. Few persons realize, until they see concrete examples, how much beauty can be brought within the compass of a group of hardy plants. The gem of the collection in this book is the ‘‘white lily growing among rosemary at Sandhurst” —a lovely scene, in which “the lilies had not been disturbed for ten years.” Readers who understand that economics is a science rather than a branch of polite literature, Prof. T. N. Carver explains, are those to whom his treatise, ‘The Distribu- tion of Wealth’ (Macmillan), is offered. To read it requires as much mental effort as to read a treatise on physics, chemistry, or biology. We do not need to say that Pro- fessor Carver is well known to this select audience, and that they will appreciate his careful study of a very difficult subject. As to ithe practical use of developing theories based on purely hypothetical examples, opinions may differ. It is hard to get back to the concrete unless you start from it; but there is no question about the disciplinary value of such exercitations as this. The revival of protectionism in England has led Mr. Sampson §. Lloyd to translate Friedrich List’s work, ‘The National Sys- tem of Political Economy’ (Longmans). Prof. J. S. Nicholson writes an introductory chapter, in which he points out that the particular opinions of List are altogether inapplicable tto present conditions, but that his principles and fundamental ideas are of real value. ‘‘These ideas are always to be reckoned with; they suggest questions which the statesman must answer, whatever the change in conditions.”” It seems hardly necessary to go back to List for a state- ment of tthese ideas, for they have been stated clearly enough in recent times. But we must remember that List impressed his theories on our Philadelphia’ school of economists, and that our tariffs have been usually made under the influence of this school, There is some rather grim amuse- ment to be derived from comparing the practical results which have been brought about with the precepts laid down by List. He would be infuriated by the excesses of those who call themselves his disciples. The history of an institution which has had great results is given in ‘The Working- men’s College’ (Macmillan). The records of the College, and the recollections of many of those who have been connected with it, are here arranged and edited by the Rev. J. Llewelyn Davies, and he has embellished his work with fine portraits of Maurice, Hughes, and many another of the noble men who threw their hearts into this truly philanthropical undertaking. The College has always had slender pecuniary support—perhaps gaining for this reason in the quality of its teachers; but it is now in position to indulge itself in a commodious building in Crowndale Road, St. Pancras, erected with its own funds. Mr. G. Horner’s edition of the ‘Coptic Version of the New Testament’ in the Northern (Bohairic) dialect has now been completed by the publication of vols. iil. and iv., containing the Pauline and Catholic Epistles, Acts, and the Apocalypse (Oxford: Clarendon Press; New York: H. Frowde). The critical apparatus, as in the first two volumes noticed in these columns seven years ago, is carefully prepared and con- veniently arranged. For the Epistles and Acts, the text of MS. “Oriental 424” of the British Museum has been followed, and for the Apocalypse that of the Curzon MS. The collation of other MSS. seems to be exhaustive. The translation (given on the page facing the text) attempts complete literalness, often at the expense of English idiom. The Greek words that are trans- literated in the Coptic are printed in italics in the English—a convenient method of in- dicating the extent and character of the borrowing. Every page bristles with loan words, which include a number of particles and almost the whole of the religious vocab- ulary except the terms “faith,” “love,” “wisdom,” and a few others. Mr. Horner has done good service in thus bringing out a critical Bohairic text of the New Testa- ment in full. He does not attempt compari- son of the Coptic with the Greek, but he has furnished trustworthy material for such comparison. Whatever the date of the Bohairic version (a question still under discussion), it is a valuable witness for the original text of the New Testament, and it is to be hoped that this new edition may aid in the determination of the relation between the Egyptian versions and the great Greek uncials. To the ninth volume of the ‘Jewish En- cyclopw#dia’—Morawcezyk-Philippson—(Funk & Wagnalls Co.) applies in general the estimate given here of those which have preceded. The standard cannot be said to be rising; the proportion of staff-written articles seems to be on the increase. Still, if only for its wealth of biography, espe- cially English and American, the book is indispensable for reference. There is a distinctly good article on Music, and the list of Periodicals 1s very full. Numis- matics and Palwography are also good; Peshitta is strangely behind the times. Benzinger’s Palestine is, naturally, satis- factory. The illustrations are often of con- siderable interest, but commonplace photo- graphs of modern buildings are still too numerous, The second edition of Willmore’s ‘Spoken Arabic of Egypt’ (London: David Nutt) calls for a word only of notice. It is re- vised throughout, equipped with an armed preface in answer to critics, and is un- doubtedly the fullest recent introduction to its subject. In Professors Gottheil and Jastrow’s “Semitic Study Series’’ two new parts have appeared (Leyden: Late E. J. Brill), one, the Abu Habba Cylinder of Nabuna’id, edit- ed by Prof. J. D. Prince and autographed by Mr. R. J. Lau; the other, a forty-page extract from the ‘Prolegomena’ of Ibn Khaldun, edited by Prof. D. B. Macdonald. Both have glossaries in English and Ger-
Page 19
Hime te pany nom eas cided gua 4 Rye RETR Tange gn BR: s i April 13, 1905] The Nation. 291 man. The series is excellent in plan, and will undoubtedly meet a sensible want. The eminent Romance philologist Adolfo Mussafia, having reached the age limit for service in Austrian universities, has given up his work at the University of Vienna. On February 15, his seventieth birthday was celebrated by the presentation to him in Florence of a handsome volume of 760 pages, prepared in his honor by some sixty contributors, and entitled ‘Bausteine zur Romanischen Philologie: Festgabe fiir Adolfo Mussafia’ (Halle: Max Niemeyer). As is usually the case in these memorial volumes, which it has become the fashion in Europe to dedicate to eminent scholars, there is considerable variety in the con- tributions, which come from various coun- tries and are printed in various languages. One proceeds from America, ‘Old Portu- guese Songs,’ by Prof. H. R. Lang of Yale, and contains the original text and an English translation of nine songs, with notes. The volume includes a bibliography of the writings of Mussafia himself, 336 in number, prepared by his colleague, E. Mad- dalena. A native of Spalato in Dalmatia, Mussafia is at home in many languages, and has written both in German and in Italian. The best known of his publications is bis Italian grammar for Germans, first issued in 1860, which has gone through twenty- seven editions, and is still widely used. The Dante minuscolo, recently issued by the enterprising Milanese publisher, Ulrico Hoepli, shows once more that, in the me- chanical part of bookmaking, Italy can at least hold her own with any country. Al- though the six hundred pages and the bind- ing together are barely half an inch in thickness, the paper is of such excellent quality that the print does not show through. The type is unusually distinct. The size of the charming little volume is about three inches by five, and the weight is less than three ounces. In addition to the complete text of the ‘Divine Comedy,’ there are some twenty pages of introduc- tion, and also admirably complete but con- densed footnotes by Prof. Raffaello For- naciari. This highly competent editor has naturally avoided controversy, and in gen- eral has followed the traditional reading and interpretation. One could not wish a more satisfactory pocket edition of Dante, and the price is exceedingly moderate. It was inevitable that some one should draw ‘Who’s Who’ upon Dr. Osler. Possibly many have done so, but the first really heavy shot from this ever-loaded gun seems to have been fired by Prof. Edwin G. Dexter of the University of Illinois in the April Popular Science Monthly. Of twenty-five different classes of men, aggregating nearly seven thousand, only sixteen per cent. at- tained the dignity of admission under forty. Of course, ‘Who’s Who’ does not show di- rectly how many of the older ‘‘Whos’’ be- came so under forty, but, by the ingenious application of mortality tables to the facts which are available from its pages, we are brought logically to the conclusion that more than fifty per cent. of the entire num- ber arrived at the assumed degree of emi- nence necessary to constitute one a ‘““Who”’ after the fortieth milestone had been passed. By the way, the records under the name of Dr. William Osler in this same vol- ume are interesting. He was born in 1849, and took his position at the Johns Hop- kins University when he had just completed his fortieth year. The medical works by which he is so widely known have come from the press at various intervals since that date, and thus represent only the com- paratively feeble efforts of his declining years. In the interests of the general health, one might wish that many other medical writers would leave their work for a similar decline. Dr. W. H. Workman’s account of his Himalayan explorations in 1902-'03 is the feature of the March number of the Geo- graphical Journal. Though largely occu- pied with the scientific description of an immense glacier, it is full of graphic touches and incidents, such as the fall of an avalanche half a mile wide. One of the greatest causes of suffering at the highest altitudes reached was the heat, which at noon with fresh snow became intolerable, the reflected heat being harder to bear than the direct rays. The highest sun tempera- ture registered was 204° Fahrenheit at an altitude of 17,322 feet, the maximum sun temperature in 1903 for a place near Cal- cutta being 161.9° Fahrenheit. A large number of photographs add much to the in- terest of the article, as is also the case with Capt. Crosthwait’s narrative of a journey in Patagonia. The seventh of the papers giv- ing the results of the Scotch Lake Survey deals with the lochs of the Shiel district. Mr. A. J. Herbertson discusses the possi- bility of dividing the lands into great natu- ral regions—that is, the development of a systematic geography, especially adapted for technical education. Petermann’s Mitteilungen, number one, is largely devoted to Dr. E. Wagner's report on the Eighth International Geographic Congress in Washington. As regards its scientific work and its significance in the future, he holds it to have fallen below the level of the previous congresses. This was owing to the lack of a subject of absorbing interest, like the Antarctic Exploration at the Berlin Congress, to the vastly too great number (270) of papers presented, and to the excursions. He also says that the recognition accorded the Congress by our officers of state was far less than in the European countries where the _ previous congresses have been held. A. F. Stahl de- scribes a recent journey in Persia, an in- teresting episode of which was a visit to the tombs of Esther and Mordecai at Hama- dan. This is still a sacred spot, and a lamp is kept burning before them. Dr. F. Nansen discusses the three causes of ocean currents —the interior heat of the earth, the attrac- tion of the moon and sun, and the heat of the sun’s rays, which he considers the prin- cipal cause. In number two the editor, Dr. Supan, gives an appreciative notice of our Government reports on the island of Guam, reproducing the map which accompanies them. We mention further a statistical description of the natives of the Carolines and Marianne Islands, together with the second and concluding parts of the articles of Nansen and Stahl. The latter calls at- tention to the recent growth of Tabriz, which is now a city of 300,000 inhabitants and with a large commerce. ~The April Allantic is noticeable for two strong articles of protest against present national tendencies, one on the Cost of War, by Prof. Charles J. Bullock of the Department of Economics in Harvard Uni- versity; the other, on the Right and Wrong of the Monroe Doctrine, by Charles F. Dole While Prof. Bullock's article has mostly to do with that part of military expenditure which is measured in dollars and cents, he gives also a very forcible summary of the enormous cost of war in the moral and political degeneracy sure to accompany its progress and to survive its nominal cessa- tion. Mr. Dole shows very effectively the folly of the constant appeals to prejudice in the name of the Monroe Doctrine, in view of the fact that the dangers which justified the original declaration can by no stretch of the imagination be supposed to exist at the present time. With the South American countries in their present condi- tion, no possible colonization schemes of any existing European power can be sup- posed either to threaten a despotism over the native inhabitants or to be inimical to our own interests, granting that it is not to our own interests to make conquest of these countries for ourselves. On the one hand, then, the Monroe Doctrine is not needed, and, on the other, the constant ap- peal to unreasoning prejudice which is pos- sible under cover of it drives us into the support of an enormous burden of utterly unnecessary military and nava] expenditure On the purely literary side an appreciation of Henry James, by W. C. Brownell, is the chief attraction. Whether the reader will rise from Mr. Brownell’s forty-five columns with entire clearness of mind regarding Mr. James is doubtful, for we have here one over-subtle mind analyzing another. But as we go along we find steady enjoyment, at least, and occasional very just discrimina- tion. —A small volume entitled ‘English Archi- tecture’ comes from E. P. Dutton & Co Its author is Thomas Dinham Atkinson, architect, and it has 200 very small illus- trations. It is, perhaps, not surprising that each one of the numerous little handbooks devoted io this subject should improve upon its predecessors; but this book is notably sensible in its historical and critical re- marks. Its illustrations, too, however un- attractive, are perfectly well chosen and are intelligible. The constant recurrence of the first person plural, the author iden- tifying himself with his fellow-countrymen and speaking of ‘“‘us’”’ and ‘‘our art,” Is, of course, vexatious. But, in spite of this fault, the tone is critical, and we should like to quote the summing-up which {fs to be found on page 181. A sentence or two may be given: “Right or wrong, we remain intensely insular. It is perhaps our strength and our weakness that our aims were al- ways characteristically modest and even humble. Under the influence of the Nor- man we laid down immense buildings. We never surpassed them. ... The interior of the nave of Durham, the western transept of Ely, both inside and out, the central tower of St. Albans—these are rough-hewn epics which dwarf the efforts of later days.” This, we think, is novel. It is impressive as showing an observation of the Gothic churches of England, of early and of later times, which is more than mere national self-glorification. The analysis, two or three pages long, which follows this, is always suggestive and more than sugges- tive, going on to the close of the time of Wren, and touching each epoch and each important event with singular firmness and ease. It would be well for any student advanced enough to understand the wording
Page 20
292 The Nation. [Vol. 80, No. 2076 to learn those four or five pages by heart. The book is divided into history and an- alysis without express statement of that fact. Chapter i. deals with Romanesque, chapter ii. with Gothic, chapter iii. with Renaissance art, then chapter iv. seems to begin again with “Churches” and a study of the pagan basilica, chapter v. deals with Monasteries, chapter vi. with Houses; in every case, beginning with the earliest ves- tiges and coming down to the eighteenth century. Chapter vii. entitled ‘‘Conclu- sion,” deals with French influence upon England at the time of the beginnings of Gothic art, and also with the English resisting power which prevented French influence from carrying everything before it, as it was doing in western Germany and in northern Spain and the Low Countries. In spite of the strong interest which every English architect of insight must needs feel in mediwval art, this book deals with seventeenth-century and even eighteenth- century building with equal fairness and completeness; and what it has to say about Inigo Jones as the first ‘‘architect” in Eng- land, about the character of his design and of his influence, and about certain examples of buildings dating from 1650 to the close of the eighteenth century, is all intelligent quite beyond the custom of such essays. Robert Stephen Hawker (1803-75), Vicar of Morwenstow, has long been a picturesque and familiar figure. Shortly after his death, two rival memoirs appeared. That by Dr. I. G. Lee, who shared his subject’s ‘ad- vanced” views and Romeward tendency,’ is little known, and was largely polemic. The other, by Mr. S. Baring-Gould (who did not consult the family), had more charm but less authenticity; it was twice revised and reprinted, and did much to spread the fame of Hawker's eccentricities, virtues, and abilities. His “Cornish Ballads’? (1868), as I’roude wrote him, ‘belong to a kind which cultivation can no more create than it can create a living flower or tree’; his poems, as collected in 1879, called forth a kindly response from Longfellow and a pension to the widow. His Trelawney ballad (1824) is well known, and a brief hymn of his had been confounded with one long previously used, And now his ‘Life and Letters,’ by his son-in-law, C. E. Byles (John Lane), leaves nothing to be desired. The large volume is enriched by numerous quaint por- traits and sketches of Cornish buildings and monuments; the text deals frankly with the vicar’s excitability, extravagance, gene- rosity, hospitality, humor, ete., and has plenty of personal and local color and no lack of anecdote. Thus, when a _ tourist asked for his “views and opinions,’ the host led him to a window, and pointed out “the highest cliff on this coast, on the right; the church on the left; the Atlantic Ocean in the middle. These are my views. My opinions I keep to myself.””. He thought the alr full of spirits, and the lower ani- mals sharers in a future life; he cited Origen to show that “He who careth for cattle hath appointed a spiritual guardian for them each in its rank.” In 1863, vexed at the failure of punishment for Colenso’s heresies, he wrote, “Ours js a Church of de- portment without dogma or discipline’; in the spring of 1875, “My mind—it is gone.” On August 14, the evening before his death, he was received into the Church of Rome, Long before this he had worn a medal celebrating Pope Pius IX. and the Immacu- late Conception. —Since Italian literature began, the ques- tion of the language has always been a burning one in Italy. In spite of volum- inous dialect literature, periodic reversions to Latin, and occasional attempts to snub the Florentines as a lot of pedantic purists, the melodious and highly idiomatic speech of Tuscany has been the foundation of the literary language from Dante’s day to the present. Dante’s own works fixed it se- curely in this positicn, even though he him- self denied that either the Tuscan or any other dialect was suitable for literary use. So universally is it recognized that the Tuscans have as their birthright the ideal form of Italian speech, that writers from other parts of the peninsula—men like Ari- osto, Alfieri, and Manzoni—have done their best to assimilate their style to that of Florence. And now the most popular of living Italian writers, who was born and lives in the North, Edmondo De Amicis, has published a book in defence of the Tuscan vernacular, ‘L’Idioma Gentile’ (Milan: Fra- telli Treves). It is not a systematic treat- ise on grammar or rhetoric, but a collection of notes, sketches, and discussions, con- nected by their common purpose of stirring up the easy-going Tuscan to an apprecia- tion of the beauty and nobility of his native speech, and of inducing other Italians to improve theirs. De Amicis’s books sell by the hundred thousand, without the artificial stimulus that sometimes produces a demand for large editions, and his influence is whol- ly good. He believes that a common lan- guage is a potent means of attaining the unification of Italy. His own numerous works are notable examples of good taste and purity in writing; and, in spite of his Northern birth, he has so far mastered the Tuscan speech that the most captious Flor- entine academician rarely catches him in a word or phrase that is not of the purest Tuscan. His new book is full of instruc- tion and interest; it cannot fail to be valu- able to every one, foreigner and native alike, who wishes to perfect himself in the understanding and use of the lingua di si. And withal, it is fascinating reading. It has already created a sensation in Italy. —While Danish literature is fairly well provided with books dealing with America and American life—notable among which is Cavling’s ‘Fra Amerika’—Norwegian literature has been comparatively poorly off; only the last year or two has produced any at all readable works in this line. We refer to ‘Om Chicago,’ by Peter Daae, and ‘Det Norske Amerika,’ by Thoralf Klaveness, both published by Cammer- meyer in Christiania. The author of the former work has for a good many years been a resident of Chicago, working on the staff of a Norwegian paper published there, and is accordingly familiar enough with the several phases of life in the Western metropolis, which he describes as “America’s most American city, and the third largest Norwegian city in the world.” His aim is, in 150 pages, to ac- quaint the Norwegian reading public with Chicago and its institutions, its population, its criminals and its courts, its theatres, literature, ete., and at the same time, so far as Chicago may be said to be typical of America, with American life as a whole. Errors and misstatements are fewer than in most foreign books de- scribing American life, and become ap- parent chiefly where a more general and comprehensive view or a more detailed and specialized study is required for the under- standing of some institution. The absence of illustrations is to be regretted, and the author’s language bears plain witness to his long stay in Chicago. The other book above mentioned is more ambitious in its character. Mr. Klaveness is the editor of a provincial paper, who spent some months in the United States at the ex- pense of the Norwegian Government, with a so-called journalist’s scholarship. His 260 richly illustrated pages (with no apparent connection between illustrations and text, however) purpose to give an account of the life of Norwegian emigrants to the United States, with casual reference to American life in general. The book naturally contains a good many enlighten- ing remarks, but also abounds in errors and misstatements, and the author evident- ly takes himself rather more seriously than most of his readers will feel inclined to do. An introductory autograph letter from Bjoérnson praises the work highly, particu- larly the style. The latter may, in fact, be said to be a clumsy § imitation of Bjérnson’s own. —Gustav Kruell’s new engraving of Frank- lin, in size, in technique, and in authority, takes its place securely among the fore- most of his triumphs on the wood block; and for connoisseurs this statement is all- sufficient. The Japan proof before us be- longs in this artist’s later series for color, and displays his power to produce a solid and coherent personality—a portrait in which every things “hangs together’ and there is no fumbling. For his original, Mr. Kruell resorted to the Duplessis pastel of 1778 now in the possession of the Philadel- phia Academy of Fine Arts, and leaving much to be desired on the score of distinct- ness and detail, as is so often the case with this vehicle. Unlike the more senile pastel of 1783 by the same Frenchman, owned by Mr. John Bigelow and engraved on steel as the frontispiece to his ‘Life of Franklin from his Works,’ this presentment looks to the left. It is again distinguished by a fur collar; but, above all, the mouth is a line of singular subtlety, by which it would almost be as proper to characterize this re- markable print as to identify the work of the old painters by a chair or other acces- sory. It is the first thing to fix the atten- tion. The flesh, the flowing hair, the several components of the dress, are executed with the customary mastery; indeed, the way in which the bust is handled, with its diversity of stuffs and folds, is delightful to study, while this and the background are both sub- ordinated to the face and ever lead us back to it. Clearly, the hand which successfully delineated Lincoln and Webster and Beet- hoven and all the great subjects between, - has lost none of its cunning or its patience Mr. Kruell’s address is No, 102 Sussex Ave- nue, East Orange, N. J. RECENT POETRY. In the six ornate but rather ill-printed volumes of the collected edition of Mr. Swinburne’s poems (Harpers), we have, in some respects at least, the most important body of poetry by a living writer. About nets ~~ ee ben ——s
Page 21
Aer. + — asetlicsili | pagent pue April 13, 1905] the only wholly new offering in the set is a dedicatory epistle of twenty-five pages addressed to Theodore Watts-Dunton, in which the poet, in some highly characteris- tic prose, endeavors to forestall both ‘“‘the purblind scrutiny of prepossession’” and “the squint-eyed inspection of malignity,” of which he has had some experience in the past. The epistle is in the main a some- what grandiloquent synopsis of the succes- sion of fervid moods which Mr. Swinburne has voiced in his verse, with repeated as- surances of their sincerity. Not all of its asseverations are quite verified in the poetry that follows. ‘‘My first if not my strongest ambition,”’ he says, ‘‘was to do something worth doing, and not utterly unworthy of a young countryman of Marlowe the teach- er, and Webster the pupil, of Shakspere, in the line of work which those three poets had left as a possibly unattainable example for ambitious Englishmen.’ Despite this ex-cathedra pronouncement, it seems to us, in reading all the six volumes, that the striking thing about the poetry of Mr. Swinburne is that it is not essentially, in form and spirit, English poetry at all; that it is rather the work of a spiritual country- man of Hugo and Baudelaire. The char- acteristic marks of great English poetry we do not find in it very plentifully. If we mistake not, there has never been an Eng- lish poet of the first rank who did not show the native English gift for terse and gnomic expression—the ability to throw an apothegm into a line of verse. In English poetry, in the very turbulence of passion there has always been a certain moderation and reserve approaching almost to curt- ness. Hence, even in English poets of the second rank, the fine, closely-packed single line has been more in evidence than in any other poetry outside of Dante and Virgil. Yet nowhere beneath the swirling, Strauss- like measures of Mr. Swinburne’s resound- ing poems, with their celebration of ‘panic’ and ‘‘nympholepsy,”’ do we find much trace of this gift of terse wisdom; and memorable single lines are few. Per- haps the most English thing in him is his deep love of the sea in all the phases which he enumerates in a clause of the epistle, which, isolated, strangely echoes the ca- dence of his most characteristic lines— “The revels and the terrors and the glories of the sea."’ But if Mr. Swinburne’s ample collected achievement lacks that last element of po- etic permanence which comes from a deep national quality, it is clearly of a larger and more momentous volume than it has always been possible to recognize. No modern poet except his master, Hugo, has been more constantly capable of a certain kind of music: the echo, as Hugo said of his own verse in the notable Preface, to ‘Les Voix Intérieures,’ ‘‘bien confus et bien affaibli, sans doute, mais fidéle, l'auteur le croit, de ce chant qui répond en nous au chant que nous entendons hors de nous.” No living poet has studied the intricate cadences of Greek choruses more minutely and imitated them more successfully. No living poet has taken a more unwavering stand as the singer of human rights, even if he has envisaged them from the angle rather of a Continental revolutionary than of a poet of the isles where Freedom broadens slowly down from precedent to precedent. And, finally, no living poet has drunk more deeply of the old wells of poesy The Nation. in literature. As he says in a heightened passage of the dedicatory epistle, which would make exemplary reading both for our parlor performers in poetry and for those slighter members of the Tribe of Walt who are so dissident from the apostolic succes sion of poets: “The half-brained creature to whom books are other than living things, may see with the eyes of a _ bat, and draw with the fingers of a mole, his dullard distinction between books and life; those who live the fuller life of a higher animal than he, know that books are to poets as much a part of that life as pictures are to painters or as music is to musicians, dead matter though they may be to the spiritual still- born children of dirt and dulness who find it possible and natural to live while dead in heart and brain. Marlowe and Shak- spere, A°schylus and Sappho do not for us live only on the dusty shelves of libra- An uncommonly masculine volume is that of the ‘Selected Poems’ of John Davidson (John Lane). Mr. Davidson has drawn from his seven earlier volumes with a shrewd critical sense. He has shown an evident velleity in the selection to play up, so to say, a single phase of his talent. As that phase, however, is h’s most characteristic, the volume is, as a matter of fact, pretty adequately representative. That gift of haunting song which readers of his other volumes remember, is not very much in evi- dence here; but this has never been more than a passing interest in his wilful work His unusual mastery of narrative construc- tion in verse, his energy of conception and readiness in the fundamental mind-work of poetry, are all shown here at their best in the “Ballads,”” which make the bulk of the book. Mr. Davidson envisages life with a deep tragic sense. He sees it steadily yet he does not see it quite whole—sui- cide and seduction do not play quite that chief part in the world which they do in Mr. Davidson's poetry; yet, for all the grimness of Mr. Davidson's habitual mood, the vigor and color of his poetic speech are marvellously refreshing. How vividly star tling is the conclusion of his “Ballad of Hell,” where the lady who has been be- trayed into killing herself for love escapes from the pit: ‘‘Across the weltering deep she ran; A stranger thing was never seen: rhe damned stood silent to a man; They saw the great gulf set between ‘To her it seemed a meadow fair; And flowers sprang up about her feet. She entered Heaven; she climbed the stair And knelt down at the mercy-seat. ‘“Seraphs and saints with one great voice Welcomed that soul that knew pot fear; Amazed to find it could rejoice, Hell raised a hoarse, half-human cheer."’ In his ‘Musa Verticordia’ (John Lane) Mr. Francis Coutts shows a similar en- deavor after sincerity and directness. At times this mood seems to partake of a cer- tian prosaic hardness of view, of phrase, and of versification, that gives to a poem the effect rather of a tersely turned para graph of prose than of musical and mem- orable verse; but Mr. Coutts is always thoughtful and always sensitive to the imaginative import of his ideas, so that sometimes, when a true poetic glow is im- parted to him by the energy of his sub- ject, his writing is, to adopt an overworked but useful word, suggestive. His ‘‘Bay- reuth: An Antithesis” presents him at his 293 best. The first member of the antithesis is Parsifal: “Deep in the forest's a ui’n mc } Dangeoned in te Kaights of t a 1 The a a fa eit “ ‘ There ‘ There “ Sir Parsifal is tempted by a 2 Half ghost himself; sine t er knew So the verse runs on, in an adn able pre- sentation ¢ the wan mediwval mood of morbid fervor. The second member of the antithesis is ‘“‘Die Meistersinger,”” which pre- sents, as Mr. Coutts sees it, an honester view of life ‘Released f hat ia ‘ And com ‘ t! ad With him who cobbled and High on the hills of fe we “Well met, Hans Sa: We grasp 5 and We look you full in the face and feel iat men who in the sunshine Need neve in tt darkness k ‘The Twin Immortalities and Other Poems,’ by Charles E. Russell (The Ham- mersmark Publishing Co.) avowedly an attempt to further that Anderestreben of the arts of music and poetry, of the wisdom of which w have in th olumns been constrained to express a certain skepticism. In the titular poem of the volume we have a sonorous rhapsody of that heaven of song where the masters of poetry and music together go: There dwell forever now the » Whose strains remembered bring the stars to earth There mighty Bas by Milton stroll Made one by springtime’s mirt! Bartholdt walks by Suekling’s sick Great-browed and pondering Or in vision after vision wande xg Brahms seeks the ways untried Schumann and Shelley through the i est lands Or past deep hills hold thoughtful pa Reethoven close by Hugo star Wi lemn, tender face And kindly Iike the sun in fall Phe splendid light of Shakspers ' In other poems in the volume Mr. Russell has made a set attempt to follow the a classical sonata. We have, structure of for example, in a fine poem on Graubiinden, that cradle of democracy, four movements Andante cantablle—Allegrorisoluto, Adagio, Allegro con brio, and Rondo. Mr. Russell has made in these poems an uncommonly intelligent but not quite convincing experi- ment. In any concerted poem a close anal- ysis of the succession of moods is likely to reveal something of essential musical structure. Even writers of prose in the least imaginative must sometimes have been vaguely aware of a similar constrain- ing principle in the ordonnance of their paragraphs. The trouble is, however, that the music of poetry can never be a matter of pure sound, for its material is words, which have the awkward characteristic of embodying ideas, concepts, and notions Readers of poetry through some thousands of years have come to expect these ideas, concepts, and notions, and they are pretty sure to come away from the reading of the poetry which is written with set musical intent with a certain sense of frustration, and a feeling that they have been defrauded of an essential part of true poetic pleasure, We like Mr. Russe!! better in those poems where his musical structure is only im- plicit. He has an admirable gift of phrase, which at its best is alive to its finger tir He would do well, however, to consider the
Page 22
294 The Nation. [Vol. 80, No. 2076 modicum of truth which is in Poe’s dictum that a long lyric is a contradiction in terms; for his poetic impulse is so unflag- ging, and his mind so full of remembered cadences and colors, that too many of his pieces come to be a little overdrawn. Yet it is not often that one finds a volume of verse more fulfilled of the true poetic unc- tion, more fervent with the old dream of hu- man brotherhood. Some of the least am- bitious pieces are best of all—witness this picturesque rowing song: “Sweep—sweep—sweep By winding shore and willowy screen, Sweep—sweep—sweep Across tree-shadows gray or green, By shelving beach of crinkling sand, And deeps where drowsing cattle stand; By white vine-scented cottage trim, And where the red vine clusters peep, Sweep—sweep—sweep And the strong white eddies leap Where the broad blades run in the burning sun With their sweep—sweep—sweep ‘By mouldering pier-heads that still keep Their watch and ward on silent streams, By grand-dams in wide doors asleep And dreaming who shall say what dreams. And further in cool breaths of pine That taste like some old-vintage wine, Where searce one ray of the saffron day Through the arch of the incense shrine makes way, Where the shadowy walls an echo make To the sweep--sweep—sweep And the dancing globes in my wake Of tree-top line and gold-leaf shine The tinted image take. ‘‘Sweep—sweep—sweep Now where great domes of cloudland drift, Sweep-—-sweep— sweep Now where long shafts of sunlight shift Through blue and white and golden brown, Where sloping fields of wheat come down, Where through burnt fumes of summer bloom The slender village steeples loom Or broken in the bow-wave’s curl, Sweep—sweep—sweep And the face of a country girl Round-eyed and brown from the bridge looks down To watch the foam-wreaths whirl “Sweep sweep sweep The oar rings true like a crystal bell; Sweep sweep—sweep The rushes lisp in the tiny swell; And the treble tinkling of the song Up where the keen prow shears along Keeps tune and time with the plashing chime, Keeps note for pote with the sterner rhyme Of the grumbling gear of the sliding seat. Sweep-—-sweep—sweep And beneath the hard-pressed feet The ripples rise, the slim bow flies To the song of the sliding seat."’ ‘The Garden of Years, and Other Poems,’ by the late Guy Wetmore Carryl (Putnams), is a sorrowful volume in its indication of defeated promise. It shows Mr. Carry] just working out of the Byronic mood, with fore- gleams of a sincerity and eloquence in verse which, coupled with hig exceptional mastery of the long rolling line and of the largo movement, might have carried him far. His quality can be no more fitly shown than in the verses entitled “On the Prow,” which, with something of a Tennysonian color, recall, without imitating, a familiar poem of Clough’s: “Strange, silent Kast! Across the solemn calm The slender ship outward and onward strives, Bearing to odorous shores of date and palm The burden of a bundred little lives, “On a light course drift I toward the verge Beyond which lies what now I may not know; Yet my heart whispers, “These gray wastes of surge , Stretch whither it is good for me to go.’ “Youth like the speeding sun left far behind— Unanswered questions mutely sent before— O great, dim East, what welcome shall I find When thy wide arms unveil the distant shore? “The prow knows not the harbor that it nears. Nor I if thou shalt bring the seeker rest Yet the strong hand the fragile ship that steers Will guide her to the haven that is best."’ Mr. Robert Loveman, in his ‘Songs from a Georgia Garden’ (Lippincott), proves himself again one of the verse writers whose gift is for the thumbnail sketch rather than for the large canvas. His range is slender, and a certain eccentric slight- ness and fragility is his habitual quality. Sometimes, however, his little unnamed poems are very individual and right—a kind of poetic pin-prick, pleasantly pro- vocative, as in this: “What! I fear death? Believe me, no; Out of a mystery we come, Into the light we go. “What! I fear death? I swear to thee My chiefest thought is one Of curiosity.” A similar gift for terse poetic expres- sion, with a considerably greater burden of thought and feeling, is seen in ‘Cassia, and Other Poems,’ by Edith M. Thomas (Badger). In Miss Thoraas’s verse there is, however, always something of a strug- gle between a native endowment of song and the disposition to ratiocinate, that sometimes results in crabbed verse. The best of the poems which Mrs. Flor- ence Earle Coates has brought together in ‘Mine and Thine’ (Houghton, Mifflin & Co.) are those which deal with persons, ranging from Socrates to William B. Yeats. These are always sympathetic to the essential quality of the man. Sometimes they are ex- cellent examples of sonnet eloquence, like this, of Jean Francois Millet: “Not far from Paris, in fair Fontainebleau, A lovely, memory-baunted hamlet lies, Whose tender spell makes captive, and deties Forgetfulness. The peasants come and go—- Their backs too used to stoop—and patient sow The harvest which their narrow need supplies; Even as when, earth’s pathos in his eyes, Millet dwelt here, companion of their woe, Loved Barbizon! with thorns, not laurels, crowned, Iie looked thy sorrows in the face, and found Vital as seed warm nestled in the sod The hidden sweetness at the heart of pain; Trusting thy sun and dew, thy wind and rain, At home with nature, and at one with God.’’ In the ‘Poems’ of Hildegarde Hawthorne (Badger) a graceful lyric gift, a vein of pretty fancy, and a habitual mood of ideal- ity are very little inconvenienced by dis- turbing mental processes. The volume con- tains several songs as tuneful as this: “Sing me a sweet, low song of night Before the moon is risen, A song that tells of the stars’ delight Kacaped from the day's bright prison; A song that croons with the cricket's voice, That sleeps with the shadowed trees; A song that should bid my heart rejoice At its tender mysteries! “And then when the song ts ended, love, Bend down your head upto me, Whisper the word that was born above Kre the moon had swayed the sea; Kre the brightest star began to shine Or the farthest sun to burn, The oldest of words, O heart of mine, Yet newest, and sweet to learn.” ‘A Pageant of Life,’ by Gamaliel Brad- ford, jr. (Badger), is the intelligent verse of a scholarly man of fine sensibilities, who has meditated the literary history of the world long and minutely. This history is poetically presented in a series of son- nets. It begins with one on Heraclitus, touches in passing on such subjects as “‘Alexander’s Empire,”’ ‘‘Lucretius,’’ ‘‘Saint Anthony,” ‘‘Cervantes,’’ and “Ka*i,’’ and ends with one on ‘‘Democracy,’’ wherein we have a rather pessimistic picture of mod- ern man, who “chants with might and main, In penny sheets, self-laudatory hymns— Monster, with arms, legs, belly, and no brain.’’ Besides the ‘“‘Pageant of Life’’ there are some gracefully turned songs and a few admirably close and sympathetic transla- tions from Leopardi. For a reader of book- ish tastes this is a pleasant volume. For the vast unconsidereq remainder of what may be called by the generic name of Badger poets, Mr. Philip Green Wright may stand as fairly representative. In a “foreword” to Mr. Wright’s ‘Dial of the Heart,’ Mr. Charles A. Sandburg says: “Of the making of verses, doggerel, yawps, and blats, there is no end. Rare is the one who has approached his task, say- ing: ‘I want to make something fine, something that will show the _ best and truest of myself, something that will be a gratification to the highest and strongest in me.’ Yet that is the spirit in which I believe Philip Green Wright has written out these pieces of poetry. Are they to be classic? Not all of them. But there are passages that so ac- curately, so sincerely, and with such heart- stir reflect what every thinking, feeling man and woman knows, that they will live a long time.’ Revolving the work of Badger poets as a class, the salient and essential quality of all is seen to be this trait which Mr. Sand- burg has so memorably named heart-stir. A single specimen of it from the writings of Mr. Wright will perhaps be adequate. It is a “Quatrain”’: “Oh, to throw off the incubus! Oh, to laugh long and free as though I had blond, curly hair! Not to care a damn for men or fate, To feel myself an elemental force, one with rain, sunshine, and wind.’’ Heart-stir being thus rife in the land, we might expect that the momentous events of present years would find some expres- sion in song. This is, indeed, the case. ‘The Senator: A Threnody,’ by the Rev. Henry Carver McCook (George W. Jacobs), is a memorial poem of 171 pages, dealing with the life and political activity of the late Mareus A. Hanna. The fourth canto of the poem is “A Plea for Immortality,” and the fifth contains some description of the life beyond, all conducted with a skill evidencing considerable homiletic experi- ence, Another poem for the times is “An In- augural Ode,” by Mr. Alexander Blair Thaw (Nelson, N. H.: The Monadnock Press), which presents the conventional emotions of a thoughtful and well-read man on In- auguration day, with considerable metrical facility. A considerable fervor of feeling, accom- panied by an easy command of poetic rheto- ric, gives at first reading to Mr. Frederic Lawrence Knowles’s ‘Love Triumphant’ (Dana Estes & Co.) a pleasant individuality. Despite a good deal of straining after the “modern note,’’ the poetry of Mr. Knowles is markedly reminiscent. In weaving the variations about the old theme of yester years he is particularly skilful. In the x 3 a # cf 4
Page 23
April 13, 1905] first and title poem of the volume we have the fine, if somewhat loosely imaged lines: **Helen’s lips are drifting dust; Ilion is consumed with rust; All the galleons of Greece Drink the ocean's dreamless peace,’’ etc.. and so on to the lesson of the perdurability of love. In the next poem, the same theme is handled in a pretty new measure: ‘‘Lovers kissed and parted, Eyes were moist and blue, In the Midian meadows Moses knew. Cheeks were wet with weeping, Brows were hot with fire, Ere the hand of Homer Swept the lyre. And this masque of midnight And the moon’s white face Looked on Nile and Jordan Thebes and Thrace,’’ and so on to the end: “Press thy lips to mine, dear. Thus—and thus—and thus— Space and time sball perish Slain by us. All the lands of wonder, Years of pain and bliss, We will taste together In that kiss!’’ This is all rather pleasant in its warm fluency, but, as one reads on through the book and re-reads, the rhetorical virtuosi- ty becomes more obvious and the poetry less. Mr. Knowles’s writing would gain by a more rigorous selection, by the un- sparing pruning of the pieces selected, and by a more laborious study to replace the specious loud rhetorical phrase by the in- evitable word of poetry. VAMBERY’S MEMOIRS. The Story of My Struggles: The Memoirs of Arminius Vambéry. E. P. Dutton & Co. 1904. 2 vols. Pp. 492. There have been few autobiographies at once so outspoken and so evidently truth- ful as this. Dr. VAambéry, without ques- tion, knows himself, and he has here com- municateq that knowledge without reserve. The details of his life, from his unrecorded birth of unknown date, to his residence now at Budapest as an authority of the first rank on the politics of Europe and Asia, are set forth clearly. Equally clear are the analysis and statement of his mo- tives, beliefs, and ideals, his whole inner life. His estimate, too, of his opportuni- ties, powers, and achievements is of evi- dent soundness. Ruling out the inevitable blind spot, not many men have seen them- selves so steadily and so wholly as they are, as has this Hungarian Jew. It is the life of a linguist, not of a schol- ar; of a looker-on of Oriental politics, not of an official nor even of a politician; of a Jew-cosmopolitan, not of a Hebrew; of an amateur in religions and a disciple ot Voltaire and Strauss; of a man of one great journey, not of a man with wander- ing in his blood. There is a deep pathos, too, in it all. His country callg him a Jew, and a Jew is not a Hungarian; he would not call himself a Hebrew, and the syna- gogue will have none of him. His atti- tude towards religion in general is that of the over and done eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries—an attitude which sees priestcraft only, and holds that Hu- The Nation. rope leads the world in spite of Chrjstian- ity. He has done better work for England than many English statesmen, and yet is almost without a country, so out of touch in race, religion, and country he is and has been with all his environment. But there is another side. The place of these primary garments of existence has been taken for him by the broadest spirit of hu- manity. Not simply to see men and cities, nor even to survey mankind in philosophic leisure, has been his life. But to merge himself in every race and in every kind and condition of men—to lose his mother- tongue and to know none as such save the tongue of the hour—to act a part with all the histrionic genius of the Hebrew race, until (following the command of Muham- mad, ‘“‘Weep when you read the Qur’an, and if you cannot weep, feign weeping; in time you will weep’’) these mimic words and actions became his own—to turn cosmopo- lite, in no cold, detached sense, but by tak- ing the world (at least, the Orient world) to his heart—this has been for him the sub- stance of his life, and its own exceeding great reward. And so, at the last, he looks back to the sneering advice of his cleri- cal teacher in the gymnasium, ‘‘Moshele, why dost thou study? It would be better for thee to be a butcher,” and knows that it was well to study and that his life has been worth living. So it was from the very beginning. Lame, poor, half-starved, contemned, an irrepres- sible vitality, loquacity, industry kept him moving steadily on a course which was in essentials that of all his life to come. His religious beliefs dropped away from him without a struggle. They simply vanished, ard he went on without them. They had never interpreted or vitalized the world to him, and, when they were gone, the world was still as of old—very good and needing no interpretation. His Catholic in- structors used him as acolyte at the Mass; he served very calmly, just as he was to take part thereafter in Dervish dhikrs. He was a good student, but ordered study with its certificates and regular promotions did not interest him. Languages, for him, were everything, and these he learned for use, not discipline. He talked if need be to him- self; he read, above all, poetry and imagi- native literature. He learned, too, to de- pend upon himself, and to take short views into the future. He felt secure that he would come through somehow, although starvation seemed round the next corner. An iron industry at the things which he liked, an unquenchable hopefulness, and a power of making things turn up carried him along. Then came the first journey to the East, begun on some scanty savings as a private tutor. At Constantinople, Vambéry finally found himself. His savings soon gave out, but, as a tutor in languages, a reciter of poetry in cafés, and finally as an accepted member of Turkish households, known as Reshid Efendi and as good as a Muslim, with no questions asked on either side, he slipped into the smooth, easy-going cur- rent of Oriental life. It was now that he learned to know the East on the inside. He had long heard it calling, and recognized that it was a career. Libraries, too, opened to him; MSS became accessible, Chagataic texts raised again for him the problem of the origins of the Hungarian race. These last saved him, too, from the fatal spell of 295 Oriental sloth Commissioned by the Magyar Acaceomy to investigate in Central Asia the reiationships of the Magyar lan guage, and furnished by them with scanty funds and a magniloquent Latin letter of safe conduct, he left Budapest in 1861 on his great journey But little good for that lay in these Eu ropean helps. It was to Constantinople that his real success was due. When he left there in turn, it was as Reshid Bfendi with official passport and letters of com mendation to the Turkish Minister at Teheran. He was to be a real Turk there after, and a dervish dependent on alms, and journeying to the sacred shrines of Bu khara. In Persia, it is true, he was, as a Turk, a Sunnite heretic; but religious de tails sat easily upon him, and a dervish has a large latitude allowed and taken. At Teheran a fresh start was made, and this time in Sunnite Central Asia the Turkish commendations had full weight. Added to this, and more weighty than all, was a solemn passport from the Turkish Ambas- sador, giving him the title of Hajji. This, above all else, carried him through, but it may be a subject of meditation how much lying, first and last, the use of it must have involved. Burton, it may be remarked, held that no one who had not actually been through a pilgrimage could maintain such a title. The knowledge required could be gained at first hand only. Into this great journey there is no need to enter here. By it Vambéry became known and remains known; he never made another. His knowledge of the East he had practi- cally gained before, but this spectacular feat gave him the ear of Europe. And yet, as he says himself, there was nothing in it so different from his early life. The expe- riences of the young Jew, despised and mock- ed, hungry and weary, had been much those of the mendicant dervish in the terrors, phy- sical and mental, of the steppes of Asia. All his life he had been playing parts until they had become a reality for him. Further, it was not accident which now led him to England and made him the champion of Eng land against the world. To his own coun- try he was a very dubious Jew; though he writes himself to this day a Hungarian, in Hungary no theatre existed then for his public appearance. The two powers to which he might naturally turn were the Eastern rivals, England and Russia. But with Rus- sia, plainly, he could have no part. He and his race and his country knew Russia too well. The Jewish people and the oppressed nationalities of Eastern Europe had no ques- tion where friendship for freedom might be found. So to London he went with his book, and discovered how England receives the man who has done something—above all, has been where no one else has been, and who knows something bearing on the moment and can tell it clearly. His future was thus fixed. He was to be a political Orientalist, a writer of books, magazine articles, news- paper letters, and paragraphs bearing on living situations. To this part of his life Professor V4m- béry gives his second volume as a whole, It is marked throughout by the same keen insight into others as into himself, the same absolute frankness and truthfulness. His characterizations are full of good-humored appreciation. Of his own little vanities he makes no secret, and of how flattering and pleasant he found the attentions of (for ex- —
Page 24
296 The Nation. [Vol. 80, No. 2076 ample) both Victoria and Edward VII.—how wounded, too, he was by the long neglect which he met with in his own country, and how unquenchable has been his love of dis- tinction and fame. A childlike naiveness that disarms criticism runs through all this. The pictures, moreover, which he puts be- fore us are so bright and telling; the at- mosphere of the whole is so garrulously at- tractive; the spirit is so transparently hon- est, and the ideals for the liberty and prog- ress of the world are so uncompromising, that it would take the most pronounced anti-Britisher to be irritated by his vision of the destinies of England. Nor is there at any point a touch of bitterness; even Mr. Gladstone is dealt with playfully. Few choices, indeed, have been so speedily and completely vindicated by events as his be- tween the twe great Oriental Powers. With every day, at present, the difference which he saw is becoming clearer to the most prejudiced, The same holds true of his judgments on the present condition of Persia and Turkey. The pages which tell of his intercourse with the present Sultan and with the late Nasre- din Shah are among the most weighty in his book. No European has known the Sultan as he; certainly none has published his esti- mate so fully and frankly. What is said here is evidently meant to mark the close of a long and difficult acquaintance, and is practically a confession of failure to solve that problem in character. Yet some points are made absolutely clear: one, that Abdul Hamid still regards the Turkish empire as the personal property of himself and his dynasty; and another, that the Armenian massacres, with or without cause, were de- liberately planned by him. A “box on the ear’ he called them to Vambéry, when in- cautiously speaking of his purpose. It is characteristic for the linguist in the strict sense that two passages (pp. 127, 365) are quoted in hopelessly bad Arabic, and as- cribed to the Koran, where they assuredly do not occur. More strange, for one more of a Turk than the Turks, is the definition (p. 373) of a “‘Khaliph,”’ as ‘‘a lawful de- scendant of Muhammad.”’ Professor V4am- béry must write with a very running pen indeed. But there can be no question of the truth of his colors; and that, here, is the main thing. A Gardener's Year. By H. Rider Haggard. With plan and twenty-five illustrations. Longmans, Green & Co. 1905. A great charm of all honestly written books on gardening resides in the frankness with which disappointments and mistakes are recorded. Such records are instructive and attractive just in proportion to the openness of the confessions. Mr. Haggard has much literary skill, and he knows how to turn to best account the history of his errors, The errors and failures serve as the most admirable background to-bring out into strong relief the guccesses and peaceful triumphs. The successes in this well-man- aged garden have been many, and the mis- takes are relatively few. There are, in truth, two gardens under de- scription, one by the easternmost shore of Suffolk, in England, where the author has waged a vigorous battle with the encroach- ing sea; the other, a diversified estate of about three acres, with six glass~houses, is the main subject of the pfesent book. The record runs through a varied year from Jan- uary, 1903, and comes to a close in Decem- ber, with comments of satisfaction that the months have been, on the whole, well spent, and that the garden is in better condition than when the year began. An American must remember, as he reads this pleasant book, that English skies are not like ours, and, secondly, that the writer of the record has passed much of his active life in a coun- try where the climatic extremes are not wholly unlike those which try our souls. Mr. Haggard evinces a patience under the trials of English weather which has been evolved from climatic conditions in the south of Africa. The sudden and unwelcome changes of weather, in both the large garden and that near the shore, appear to have been borne by the writer with admirable equanim- ity and even taken as a matter of course. There is not much that can be quoted from the book to illustrate its agreeable style or to indicate the large amount of sound infor- mation which it contains, but attention must be called to one statement which shows the good courage that characterized the efforts of this lover of plants. At the author’s place, in Kessingland, in Suffolk, the cliffs and sandy shore are swept by fierce winds from the northeast. Under the steady beating of the wind and sea, great encroachments were being made upon the sandy beach. To protect in a measure this treacherous and shifting barrier, the writer planted a beach-grass (Ammophiia arenaria) in considerable quantity, and left the plants to struggle for a foothold. Seawalls are worthless as defenders—they are costly and unsatisfactory; but, after five years of Ma- rum grass, the beach had risen about twelve feet in height, in some places coming over the grass itself. In all the high tides not a single clump has been washed away, and the extreme limit of the sea seems to have been pushed back more than twenty yards. Some of the strongly entrenched tussocks of the Marum plants are now three feet through, and hold the shifting particles together firmly, binding them into a band of steel instead of a rope of sand. Along our ex- posed coast from the elbow of Cape Cod to its finger-tips at Provincetown, there are many places where sand-stays have been tried, but at times with only indifferent suc- cess, and they have been used ineffectually on our doomed Sable Island off the coast of Nova Scotia. It would seem as if the good results obtained by Mr. Haggard should again brace up our courage to a renewal of the fight against the sea. It may be well to call attention also to the excellent judgment shown by Mr. Haggard in his indulgence to his laborers. On his place of three acres, where there were all sorts of plants cultivated, he had a head gardener, an assistant of twenty-one, an old man of seventy, and a general workman. The ‘old man was of little use except to look after an oll-engine and attend to jobs around the house; the general workman came only when he was specially needed. Therefore, the staff consisted of two active men. But the relations which existed between the master and men were so amicable that both employees were loyal in the highest de- gree, Every now and then the head-gardener, Mason, would have his way, and that is as it should be, Nothing does a lover of a gar- den so much real good as to be now and then sharply headed off in his plans by a skilled workman who is devoted to his craft, loyal to his special garden, and faithful to his master. And nothing does the master more permanent good than to keep his temper during these struggles for supremacy. Mr. Haggard has, in his garden, an even temper, and appears to be a good judge of men. He is certainly, too, an excellent amateur gar- dener. The Long Ago and the Later On; or, Rec- ollections of Eighty Years. By George Tisdale Bromley. San Francisco: A. W. Robertson, 1904. Pp, 289. “Uncle George,” eighty-eight years old, who now for the first time ventures upon the field of authorship, is a prince in Bo- hemia—not in the province of which Prague is the capital, nor in that boundless prov- ince whose leaders are found in London, Paris, and New York, but in that limited and reserved Bohemia which maintains a club in San Francisco, famous for its pro- motion of wit, merriment, and friendship, to say nothing of its contributions to art, letters, and music. ; In the outside world, Mr. Bromley has held several positions which might give him title to grateful remembrance upon the Pacific Coast, but doubtless that which would give him most pleasure is “Uncle George of Bohemia.’’ Like his brother Isaac, well known in the newspaper world ot New York, he is prodigal in humor, un- premeditated and genuine; much of it, however, so effervescent that its sparkle vanishes at the sight of pen and ink. He is a blend of New England Puritanism and of California freedom. Never unmindful of the lessons of his younger days, he has always been ready for adveniure, good- fellowship, and fun. If he had devoted himself to the pen, he might have won a place with John Phoenix, Bret Harte, Mark Twain, and other humorists of California. He has their keen appreciation of droll sit- uations, and their readiness for unexpected sallies, their love of local color, but he has not their command of written speech. At “high Jinks’ and “low Jinks,’ at an after-dinner speech, at an unexpected call in any assembly, he was sure to bring down the house. His healthy frame, his plea- sant manners, his overflowing good nature, his spontaneity, his unexpectedness, made him welcome in Tokio, Tientsin, and Pe- kin, as well as in San Francisco and New York, in the mining camps, on shipboard, or in the more restricted circles where propriety is installed. For example, he was called upon offhand to make a speech at an alumni meeting in Berkeley, where he recognized among the dignitaries on the dais a younger townsman of his, and forth- with volunteered a chapter of comparative biography, which aroused shouts of laugh- ter from the assembled graduates: ‘We have known each other long and well. The same lovely New England town that can boast of being his birthplace, I also honored by having beer born there; we have flown our kites by the same east- nor’west wind, swam in the same river, skated on the same pond; and although he was a Congregationalist and I was a Bap- tist, it did not prevent us from attending the same circus—a yielding of doctrinal points exceedingly rare in those days. I remember well when he left the old roof- tree to plunge into the mysteries and mis- erles of a Yale college career, and I went whaling; he to consume the midnight oil, and I to furnish the supply. And now here, in this far-away land, we find our oc- aig aR Sed RAT Madey SS een ee ee aoe Be a accel ANN AAD
Page 25
SORA AG SARS EPA Laan April 13, 1905] The Nation. cupations running parallel. He is here in Berkeley, teaching the young to go forth and fight the battle of life, while I am in San Francisco, caring for the understand- ings of the people by running a street- sweeping machine.”’ Any one who wishes for an inside view of the Bohemian Club has only to run his eye over these pages. One of the best chap- ters describes the reception of Henry Ir- ving. Mr. Bromley’s life has not all been spent in Bohemia. In his youth he was a sailor, looking for seals on the coast of Africa; in later days he took an active part in local politics. In an impecunious stage of his experience, an unsolicited opportunity came te him. A Senator in Washington tele- graphed: ‘Sir: You are appointed United States consul at Tientsin. Hope you will accept.’”” This appointment took him to China and Japan, where he had many live- ly adventures. In later years Uncle George has been the pet of his Bohemian friends; and the verses which they have addressed to him, if not of the finest poetry, are full of the finest appreciation of a capital com- rade, born to make life merrier and to relieve its burdens and anxieties by good spirits and good will. Sydney Smith. By George W. E. Russell. (English Men of Letters Series.) Mac- millan. 1905; Sydney Smith was born in 1771, “‘of the most numercus and most respectable family in England,” as he used to say of the whole tribe of Smiths. When some one asked him about his grandfather, he replied with be- coming gravity: ‘‘He disappeared about the time of the assizes, and we asked no ques- tions.’”’ He was forced into the Church, as so many Englishmen have been, because his father could not afford the Army or the Bar, and he always thought himself a great lawyer manqué. He was a born reformer. If he had been a lawyer he would have tried to reform the Bar, but there was plenty of room for his activity in the Church. He was the managing type of ecclesiastic, who, when he has given a genial and uncritical assent to the Church’s doctrines, turns with zest to the business side. He could never forbear a joke at the expense of his pro- fession; but, as he looked back on the so- cial changes that he had lived through, he saw that there had been a real improve- ment in the morale of the clergy. “Whenever you meet a clergyman of my age,’’ he said to Gladstone, in 1835, ‘‘you may be quite sure he is a bad clergyman.” In theology he took little interest, and there are anecdotes to prove that his ac- quaintance with the Bible was somewhat superficial, that he had to be reminded by a neighboring squire of the names of Job's daughters, and could not tell you offhand whether certain famous passages were in the New Testament or the Old. He was not the sort of parson who becomes a bishop, and he could not tolerate interference from one of these dignitaries. One of his most trenchant reforming articles is called ‘‘Per- secuting Bishops,” and it is no wonder that bishops themselves are apt to read the sub- stantive in that title as an accusative. A man with a taste for reform could not in the last half of George the Third’s reign keep his hands off politics. The question of Catholic Emancipation was the theme of Sydney Smith’s famous ‘Letters’ written un- der the pseudonym of “Peter Plymley.” Canning and Perceval, who were opposed to Emancipation, he could not endure, and some of the bitterest personalities in the ‘Letters’ are directed against them. From Catholics it was a short step to Irish Cath- olics and their peculiar grievances: “The moment the name of Ireland is men- tioned, the English seem to bid adieu to common feeling, common prudence, and common sense, and to act with the barbar- ity of tyrants and the fatuity of idiots Whatever your opinion may be of the fol- lies of the Roman Catholic religion, remem- ber they are the follies of four millions of human beings, increasing rapidly in num- bers, wealth and intelligence, who, if once wrested from their alliance with England, would in three years render its existence as an independent nation impossible.’’ Conciliate Ireland and all will be well. What one observes in all these vigorous and amusing ‘Letters’ is that Sydney Smith has little te say about abstract justice. He can make a better argument by appealing to expediency, and it is in the name of the expedient that he calls for the fair treat- ment of Irish Catholics. This leads him into reasoning that oddly from a clergyman: comes “If a rich young Catholic were in Parlia- ment he would belong to White's and to Brookes’s; would keep race-horses; would walk up and down Pall Mall; be exonerated of his ready money and his constitution; become as totally devoid of merality, hon- esty, knowledge and civility, as Protestant loungers in Pall Mall, and return home with a supreme contempt for Father O'Leary and Father O'Callaghan. . . . The true receipt for preserving the Roman Catholic religion is Mr. Perceval’s receipt for de- stroying it: it is to deprive every rich Catbolic of all the objects of secular am- bition, to separate him from the Protes- tants, and to shut him up in his castle with priests and relics.” These ‘Letters’ were often compared on their publication with the ‘Provincial Let- ters’ of Pascal, and Macaulay said of them that they proved Sydney Smith to be “a great reasoner, and the greatest master of ridicule that has appeared amongst us since Swift.” Sydney Smith dearly loved London, and grasped at any preferment that would allow him to live there. He passed from an obscure curacy in a Wiltshire village to a private tutorship in Edinburgh, where with Jeffrey, Murray, and Brougham he founded the Edinburgh Review. He stayed only long enough to edit the first number, and then left it in the hands of Jeffrey. But the Review was always to him not only a useful source of income (he_ received forty-five guineas a sheet for his countless reviews), but, what he cared for even more, a good outlet for his vigorous opinions. At the age of thirty-three we find him settled in London, gradually accumulating edd clerical jobs and giving crowded public lectures on Moral Philosophy. He soon be- came the fashion, and was presented to a living in Yorkshire. But, like all epicures, he cared nothing for the country and pined for society. The happiest period of his life was that spent in his house at Amen Corner as Canon of St. Paul’s. By this time he was about sixty, and vas content to leave re- form to others. “I love liberty, but hope it can be so managed that I shall have soft beds, good dinners, fine linen, ete., for the rest of my life.’ In spite of his rural exile, he had never lost touch of London society and the Holland House circle, where he was the most brilliant of all the wits, and al- 297 lowed unusual license by Lady Holland. If there is any fault to be found with Mr Russell's book, it is that he does not dwell long enough on the purely social side of Sydney Smith. We have page after page of quotations from his militant but few witticisms. The that nis wit was ef the kind that is hard writings fact is, however to take out of the context. It was perfectly spontaneous and wel] in never found it in the least was regularly expected to be hand, so that he atiguing that he witty The bloom is off the fragments now, and th best way to enjoy its quality is to watch for the occasional flashes reported in the inemoirs and correspondence of the famous men of his day. His prose style is simp! and excellent, and we cannot do better than conclude with a specimen, the locus classicus for Mrs. Partington “The attempt of the Lords to stop the progress of reform reminds me very forcibly of the great storm at Sidmouth and of th: conduct of the excellent Mrs. Partington on that occasion. In the winter of 1824 there set in a great flood upon that town—the tide rose to an _ incredible height—the waves rushed in upon the houses, and ev erything was threatened with destruction In the midst of this sublime and terribl storm, Dame Partington, who lived upon the beach, was seen at the door of her hous¢ with mop and pattens, trundling her mop squeezing out the sea-water, and vigorously pushing away the Atlantic Ocean. The At lantic was roused; Mrs. Partington's spirit was up; but I need not tell you that the contest was unequal. The Atlantic Ocean beat Mrs. Partington. She was excellent at a slop or a puddle, but she should not have meddled with a tempest.” Mr. Russell's brief but interesting biog- raphy is well indexed, and provides such copious extracts from Sydney Smith's writ- ings on all possible subjects that it is not a bad substitute for his ‘Works,’ which are not ‘easily accessible to the general reader Babel und Bibel: Dritter (Schluss-) Vortrag von Friedrich Delitzsch Stuttgart Deutsche Verlags-Anstalt; New York Lemecke & Buechner 1905 Pp. 69. The German Emperor is greatly interest ed in Oriental explorations. He is a patron of the Orient Gesellschaft. Recently he gave 23,000 marks towards the excavations now in progress at Megiddo, in Palestine He has acquired some of the most valuable Turkish em- pire, through his personal relations to the Sultan, notably the facade of the extraor- Mesheytta, east of the arch@ological remains in the dinary building at Jordan, which was Berlin. This interest in Oriental research induced him, in to Prof Friedrich Delitzsch the honor of delivering a lecture before the court, which, at the Emperor's wish, was later repeated in the palace at Berlin. Delitzsch chose for his topic “Babel und Bibel.” the subject raised a storm among the ortho dox theologians of Germany; and, by way of answer, a second lecture on the same topic was delivered before the Orient schaft, in the presence of the Emperor, in January of the following year These two lectures, translated, with notes answering the strictures called forth by their contents recently removed to 1902, to accord Hig treatment of Gesell- , were published in book form in this coun try and in England in 1903. Delitzach has now completed the series by this third and last lecture. The reader used to modern discussion of
Page 26
The Nation. [Vol. 80, No. 2076 the relations of Assyrian, Bgyptian, and other Oriental research to the Bible Its somewhat perplexed by the excitement aroused by these lectures. They present no original discoveries. Indeed, it is not in popular books of this gort that the au- thor would undertake to present new dis- coveries. It is to be presumed that the cir- cumstances of the delivery of the first lec- tures, and the Emperor’s connection with their delivery, seeming to give to their con- tents the approval of the head of the Ger- man State and the Prussian State and Church, had much to do with the sensation which they aroused. The last lecture, now before us, may be described as a sort of apologia for the re- ligion of the Babylonians. Delitzsch writes as an apologist, defending the Babylonian religion against the accusations of idolatry and immorality which have been made against it from the time of the Hebrew prophets onward. His defence against the charge of idolatry is that the images used in worship merely served to indicate the presence of the god represented by them. He maintains, in fact, that their use was the same as the use of images by the most highly cultivated Roman Catholics. This part of his volume is a rather amusing case of special pleading. The writer deals only with selected expressions of the highest thinkers, not with the actual practical re- ligion of the people. As formerly, he points out the close de- pendence of very much in Hebrew literature and religion upon the Babylonian; in this lecture especially in the matter of the Psalms. He is concerned, however, only with resemblances and dependences. His presentation gives one, on that account, an impression of undue dependence. There is no recognition of that which differentfates Hebrew religion and literature from the Babylonian; which is of vastly greater im- portance in the end than that which unites them with one another. The closing part of the lecture deals with the difference between the Sumerian religion and the Babylonian, which replaced it. In the latter, he finds a peculiarly Semitic tendency towards the development of human gods as over against the nature worship of the Sumerians. Ac- cording to him, the Semitic idea was every- where one god for one people—an idea de- veloped to its highest degree in Judaism and islam. Out of the relations to one another of various peoples and cities and their gods was developed, according to him, Semitic polytheism, The book is written in an attractive style; in parts it is eloquent; it is always in- teresting, and it is spiritual in tone. It is illustrated by numerous cuts from Assyrian- Babylonian monuments. There are a few notes of a somewhat more technically scientific character than the text, and, ag an appendix, a translation of the Psalm of Iahtar. William Cagton. By E. Gordon Duff. Chi- cago: The Caxton Club. 19065. The Caxton Club has celebrated its tenth anniversary by publishing a bibliographical monograph on William Caxton, written by the well-known English bibliographer, E. Gordon Duff. It is a handsome quarto vol- ume of 118 pages, beautifully printed on American handmade paper,, with 25 fac- simile plates, chiefly of pages in books printed by Caxton, all reproduced in the exact size of the originals. The edition numbers only 250 copies, three of which are printed on Japanese vellum. Each of 148 copies, including those on vellum, is accom- panied by “a leaf from an imperfect copy of the first edition of Chaucer’s ‘Canterbury Tales,’ printed by William Caxton, and formerly in Lord Ashburnham’s library, having been purchased for this purpose by the Caxton Club.’’ Lord Ashburnham pos- sessed four copies, which were sold at the sale of his library in 1897 and 1898; one was very nearly perfect, the other threu had from one-half to three-quarters of the 372 leaves which go to make up a complete copy. Only nine copies of this edition are known to exist, and Mr. Duff states that this first edition is “so rare that it is be- lieved that no genuine perfect copy is in existence.”” Under the circumstances it is well-nigh incredible that a club of book- lovers could have deliberately destroyed one copy, even though very imperfect, of this first printed edition of one of the earliest classics of’English literature. The author lays much emphasis on Cax- ton’s great interest in English literature; instead of printing Greek and Roman classics, or learned works on theology and law, as did most of the early printers of Italy, France, and Germany, Caxton “gave the people the classics of their own land, and, at a time when the character of our literary tongue was being settled, did more than any other man before or since has done to establish the "English language.”’ The scarcity of Caxton’s books is a clear evidence that this was good business. Cax- ton was a successful business man before he became a printer, and presumably did not cease to be a business man when he altered his occupation, though Ten Brink and H. Morley may have insisted too much on this aspect of him. Mr. Duff has not much to say on this question, but stoutly contests Gibbon’s and Isaac Disraeli’s low opinion of Caxton as “a printer without erudition,’’ who ‘‘was reduced to comply with the vicious taste of his readers’’—a fight against windmills, it would seem. The earlier bibliographers, such as Ames and Dibdin, are occasionally quoted, and fre- quent references are, of course, made to Blades’s standard ‘Life and Typography,’ but more recent writers are ignored; not even Dziatzko’s important study, ‘Warum Caxton Buchdrucker wurde,’ is mentioned, though in all important particulars Mr. Duff has reached the same conclusion as that writer. The complete absence of bibliographical references must be regretted; perhaps the club may supply that omission hereafter. Mr. Duff's book is evidently intended for the collector rather than for the critical student. He describes the several Caxton books with all reasonable fulness, in a ‘pleasant, smoothly flowing style, void of technicalities. In most cases he tells of the whereabouts of the copies known to be in public collections, and gives the number of copies in private hands. It is always care- fully stated how many leaves a complete copy should have, including blank leaves, and especial emphasis is laid on the fact that a copy made up of fragments of two or more copies is not genuinely “complete.” An appendix gives an alphabetical list of the books printed by Caxton, and after his death with his types, with full collations; the list of plates states in each case with which type the book in question was print- ed, using Blades’s numbering of Caxton’s types. This information is supplied in a general way in the text, but the reader is in each case compelled to look either back in the text or at the list of plates, or even forward to the appendix, in order to get all his facts relating to a certain book; and even then he is not able to tell the exact size, either of letterpress or paper, unless the book is represented among the plates. It would seem that a catalogue, arranged chronologically, giving in one place, and in uniform, even if in more technical, terms, the description, collation, and history of each book, would have been more practically useful to both the collec- tor and the student. A little more care in proofreading would have removed such an inconsistency as the reference to the printer of Caxton’s Sarum Missal as ‘‘Maynial’’ in the text, ““Maynyal”’ in the appendix, and ‘‘Maynial, or Maynyal’”’ in the index. Though the book bears the imprint 1905, the author’s preface is dated May, 1902, which explains a curiously out- of-date reference to the invention of print- ing. The index is very full; as a curiosity it may be mentioned that the books print- ed by Caxton are entered under their titles, with references from the names of the authors. Dante’s Divina Commedia. Translated into English Prose by the Rev. H. F. Tozer, M.A. Oxford: Clarendon Press; New York: H. Frowde. 1904. That any one under the spell of the Odys- sey or the ASneid or the Divine Comedy should persist in the Sisyphean attempt to make an English metrical translation of it, is conceivable; but there seems to be no good reason for the multiplication of prose versions, for the qualities to be desired in @ prose version are limited in number, and, if they have once been attained, why should the work be done over again? In the case of the Divine Comedy, we believe that Prof. C. E. Norton’s translation is so generally excelient—in spirit, in phrase, in style—as to make almost superfluous the new version by the Rev. H. F. Tozer. We say this, al- though we fully recognize Mr. Tozer’s mer- its. His work seems as satisfactory as that of Mr. Butler, unless it may be urged that Mr. Butler surpasses him in literalness. The most obvious quality of Mr. Tozer’s translation is its readableness; its inferior- ity to Mr. Norton’s lies in a less profound Dante scholarship, and in a certain loose- ness of style which springs now from a ten- dency to paraphrase, and now from the use of inappropriate words. A few examples will serve, better than much writing, to il- lustrate these points. Take, first, the opening lines of the elev- enth canto of “Hell’’: “In su l’estremit& d’un’ alta ripa Che facevan gran pietre rotte in cerchio, Venimmo sopra pid crudele stipa'’— which Mr. Tozer renders thus: “‘On the edge of a lofty bank formed by huge rocks broken all around we reached a point over- looking a throng of more woful sufferers.” Mr. Norton’s version is: ‘‘Upon the edge of a high bank which great rocks broken in a circle made, we came above a more cruel pen.” Evidently, Mr. Tozer’s ‘throng of more woful sufferers” is a loose para- Rv Dla 2 a:
Page 27
ie hl Neha ae rita a ay eA ec April 13, 1905] phrase for “pit crudele stipa’’; moreover, it is a paraphrase of a dangerous sort, for it represents neither the letter nor the spirit of the original. As a second example, chosen likewise at random, turn to “Purgatory,” vil., 85-89: ‘“**Prima che il poco sole omai s’annidi,’ "’ Comincid '1 mantovan che ci avea vOltl, ‘Tra color non vogliate ch’io vi guidi. Da questo balzo meglio gli atti e 1 volti Conoscerete voi di tutti quanti, Che nella lama gid tra essi accolti.' " Mr. Tozer translates this: “ ‘Until the sun who is sinking attains his rest’—thus be- gan the Mantuan who had directed us— ‘desire not that I should lead you among that company. From this ridge ye will better observe the mien and the counten- ances of them all, than if ye were received in their midst in the level below.’’’ Mr. Norton’s version runs as follows: ‘‘ ‘Before the now diminished sun sink to his nest,’ began the Mantuan who had turned us thither, ‘do not desire that I guide you among these. From this bank ye will better discern the acts and countenances of each and all, than when received among them on the level below.’’’ Here Mr. Tozer has not only changed the figure of the sun sinking into its nest for a very commonplace sub- stitute, but he has also added unnecessary words, besides the questionable phrase, of which he is fond, “in their midst.” A final specimen we quote from ‘Paradise,’ xvii., 118-120: “E 8’ io al vero son timido amico, Temo di perder viver tra coloro Che questo tempo chiameranno antico.’’ Mr. Tozer: “Yet, if I am faint-hearted in advocating the truth, I fear lest I should cease to live in the memory of those who will call our time the days of old.” Mr. Norton: ‘‘And if I am a timid friend to the truth, I fear to lose life among those who will call this time ancient.” Mr. Tozer not merely paraphrases but dilutes Dante’s y onumental lines; it is as if he had sub- stituted putty for granite. The quality of readableness is not to be underrated, but to our ears Mr. Norton has it quite as abundantly as Mr. Tozer; and he has the compression, imagination, and severity of phrase which truly repre- sent those characteristics in Dante’s orig- inal, b:.t which we too seldom find in Mr. Tozer. It would not be fair, of course, to pass judgment on Mr. Tozer’s translation from a few citations, if these were excep- tions; but the above are truly typical, and others like them could be taken from every page. A comparison canto by canto simply confirms this impression.. By our method of parallel quotations, each reader can de- cide for himself which version reproduces more nearly Dante’s texture of thought and diction, so far as these can be reproduced in the prose of a foreign tongue. As we do not find in Mr. Tozer any fine renderings of difficult passages, or illuminating sugges- tions, which might give special value to a work in other respects not entitled to great praise, we can say, at most, that his ver- sion is readable, but not the best. Narragansett Bay: Its Historic and Ro- mantic Associations and Picturesque Set- ting. By Edgar M. Bacon of Tarrytown, New York: G. P. Putnam's Sons. This sumptuous volume of nearly 400 pages is printed in clear type, on good pa- The Nation. 299 per, and illustrated by the author’s sketch- es and a few photographs, and is wel] in- dexed. As the title implies, it Ig q@ col- lection of superficial descriptions aad co- lonial legends woven into readable ferm. The subject is not treated in any orderly way, either chronological, histerical, or geographical, and the manner in which the reader is forced to skip from one place to another on the borders of the Bay precludes the possibility of his ever remembering his route. The author is at his best in the re- telling of more or less trustworthy legends, and in the description of scenes where there is play for the imagination. Original documents are occasionally introduced, no- tably in the account of the Gaspee affair, to make the story more graphic. And yet there is very little sifting of evidence, tra- ditions being apparently as much accredited as documentary facts. The book is chiefly deficient in failing to show the powerful influence of the Bay on the social and economic develop- ment of the State. The existence of this broad sheet of water, dangerous and navigable with difficulty by the earliest col- onists, as furnishing an explanation of the lack of unity between the settlers of Provi- dence at its head and those of Newport at its mouth; the subsequent rise of boat- building and of commerce, which made of the Bay a servant instead of a master, con- ducing to unity rather than forming a bar- rier; the influence of the peculiar geograph- ical environment upon Rhode Islanders of the eighteenth century which produced a race of sailors, seafarers, shipbuilders, trad- ers and merchants, and nourished shrewd- ness, independence and individuality; the presence of so many river mouths on the border of this great expanse of water as contributory to the rise of manufacturing in which the State became preéminent—all these subjects are ignored except as some description or narrative dimly reveals their importance. The volume contains many egregious lapses from fact that cannot possibly be blamed on the unresisting printer. That Brown University was incorporated in 1769, and had its origin in the town of Warwick, and that the Hon. Ray Greene, United States Senator in 1799, was lieutenant-gov- ernor during Gen. Burnside’s administra- tion, will be facts undoubtedly new to Rhode Islanders. Numerous other errors, to be sure, such ag the misspelling of proper names, may be ascribed to the author’s un- familiarity with the subject, growing out of the fact of his residence in another State. Type Studies from the Geography of the Unit- ed States. First Series. By Charles A. McMurry, Ph.D. Macmillan. 1904. Pp. 288. This volume is in striking contrast to the old geographies, which usually give a series of figures and a few general facts of but little interest to the average child, who naturally dislikes hunting out places on the map for the sake of the practice, appar- ently, nothing having been given him to fix his interest and attention. This auth- or’s plan has been to choose in each local- ity the point of most general interest, re- marking fully upon that, and incidentally to give all necessary information on minor points: a slight reference to the geology (as, for instance, that of the Hudson River vajley), a good description of the natura! scenery, and usually a sufficiently full ac- count of the principal industries of the re gion. Places so treated cannot fall to be more real to children, whether it is a ques tion of the brick industries of the Hud gon valley, the quarries of stone so much used in New York city. or the tale of the building of the Hoosac Tunne! Incl dentally the author tells of the Mount Cenis and Saint Gothard as wel! as the tunnel which furnishes Chicago with water. The Gloucester fisheries receive more than a passing notice, and a remarkabiy clear idea is given of the hardships of the life of the fishermen. Niagara is very fully described —not only the natural beauties, but the powerful] energy as well. Thence Dr. Me- Murry proceeds to the James River, and before a child shall have left his account he will have a fair working idea of the cities, the country, its products, and the rivers which drain into the Jame: His mind has certainly taken in very fully the value of the river systems of-the country as special attention is given in every in- stance to them and their effects on the climate, commerce, and health of the peo- ple. Coal-mining next receives an exhaust! ve description. The output for Illinois alone in 1889 is given as 11,597,963 tons This would suggest an arctic climate, a notion somewhat modified, however, by the de tailed account of the various fruits pro- duced in Florida and California. The log ging camps are made very interesting, and stress is laid on differences in soil between the Northern and Middle States The wheat fields of the Northwest in par ticular—with much mention of Minneapolis and St. Paul as milling and distributing centres for this wheat—the hardwood for ests of Ohio and Indiana, the Tennessee mountains, the Mississippi delta with its cotton-growing, are well described. Later on we find a good account of the Far West- ern States in natural order, in contrast with what we must think to be the weakness of the earlier chapters, where the tale shifts forests from one section to another for no appar ent reason. It would seem that a child would get and keep a better idea of each section should he study it in connection with its neighbors. Apart from this criti- cism of the order of arrangement, we feel the book to be most admirably compiled BOOKS OF THE WEEE. Amerika. Herausgegben vou Dr. E. von Halle. Hamburger Bérsenhalle. Auction Price of Books. Falited by Luther 8. Liv ingston. Vol. I. A to Dick. Dodd, Mead & Co tain, R. Nisbet. Scandinavia. Macmilian Co. §2 net. Bigg, Charles. The Church's Task under the R« man Empire. Henry Frowde. 6s. net. Bradley. William Aspenwall. William Cullen Bry ant. Macmillan Oo. 75 cents net. Buchanan, Thompson. Judith Triumphant. Har pers. 50. Bunyan'’s Pilgrim's Progress.—Marcus Aurelius’s Meditations.—Shakespeare’s Works, Vol. 1.—Jaene Austen's Novels, Val. 1.—Bacon's English Works Vol. 1.—Gibbon’s Decline and Fall of the Rowan ire. Standard Library. London: Methuen & \ Burton-Fanning, F. W. The Open-Alr Treatment for Pulmonary Tuberculosis Chicag: w 1 Keener Oo. $1.50 net Butler's Hudibras. (Cambridge English Clasa cs Macmillan Oo. Calvert, Albert F. The Life of Cervantes. John lane. $1.25 net. : Carlyle’s Herces and Hero Worship. Edited by Annie BE. Marble. Macmillan Co , Willa Sibert. The Troll Garden. Me jure, Me ~ od & Co. Chesterton, Gilbert K. The Club of Queer Trades Harpers. $1.26. : Clark, Charles Heber. The Quakers. Philadelphia Joba C. Winston Oo. $1.50 net Old Masters and New. Fos, Dut Oox, ‘ field & Oo. $1. net.
Page 28
300 The Nation. [Vol. 80, No. 2076 Cramp, Walter 8. Psyche. Boston: Little, | Lucke, Charles Edward. —e Engine Design. D. | Sand, George. La Mare au Diable. American Brown & Co, $1.50. Van Nostrand & Co. $3 ne Book Co, Cutting, Mary Stewart. Little Stories of Court- | Liitzow, Count. Lectures on “th Historians of Bo- | Sargent, Charles Sprague. Manual of the Trees of ship. MeClure, Phillips & Co. hemia. Henry Frowde. 5s. net oo. America. ton: Houghton, Mifflin & Co. Dickinson, G. Lowes. teligion: A Critic:sm and | Mahaffy, John Pentland. The Progress of Hellen- $6 n a Forecast. MeClure, Phillips & Co. ism in Alexander's en University of Chi- Pi Aa ‘Kathrine Lois, and Olive B. Horne. Stories Dionne, N. FE. Samuel de Champlain. Toronto: cago Press. $1 ne of Musicians. American Book Morgan & Co,, Ltd. Mairet, Jeanne. La ‘cler d'Or. American Book | Scott's Ivanhoe. Edited by Frases H. Stoddard. Eggleston, George Cary. A Rebel'’s, Recollections. Co. American Book Co, New ed. Putnams. 1. Martin, Edward 8. The Courtship of a Careful | Scott's Lady of the Lake. cent by Raymond M. Eliot, Sir Charice, The East Africa Protectorate. Man, Harpers. $1.25. Alden. American Book C Longmans. £5, ‘ New English Dic tionary. (Ree- Reign.) Henry | Shakespeare’s King ry | the Fourth, Parts 1. and Farmer, John S., and W. E. Henley. A _ Diction- Frowde. ‘ Il.—Muech Ado About Nothing.—King Henry the ury of Slaug and Colloquial English. Dutton. | Nursing, A Hand-Book of. New ed. Philadel- Eighth.—Comedy of Errors.—The Taming of the $2.50 net. phia: Lippincott. Shrew.--The Winter's Tale.—King Richard the Flint, George Elliot. Power and Health through | Oreutt, William Dana. The Flower of Destiny. Second.—Antony and Cleopatra.—King John. Edit- Progressive Exercise. The Baker & Taylor Co. Chicago: A, C, McClurg & Co. ed by W. J. Rolfe. American Book Co. $1.50 net. Overton, Frank. Nature Study. American Book Co. | Smith, Perey F., and Arthur Sullivan Gale. Intro- Flux, A. W. Economie Principles. Dutton, $2 net Peckham, George W. and Elizabeth G. Wasps, duction to Analytic Geometry. Boston: Ginn & Grant, Robert The Orchid. Seribners, $1.25. Social and Solitary. Houghton, Mifflin & Co. Co. Harper, Vincent. The monenege on the Brain. $1.50 net. Solberg, Thorvald. Copyright in Congress, 1789- Doubleday, Page & Co. $1.5 Peet, Louis Harman. Trees and Shrubs of Central 1904. Washington. Henry, Arthur. The Unwritten tw A. 8. Barnes Park, Manhattan Press, Stephen, Leslie. Free ' wares and Plain Speak- & Co. $1.50. Powell, E. P, The Orenard and the Fruit Garden. ing. Putnams. Jefferson, Charles Edward, The Minister as Prophet. MeClure, Phillips & Co. net. Stuart, Ruth Me Enery. he Second Woving of Thomas Y. Crowell & Co. 90 cents net. Rateau, A. The Fiow of Steam a Nozzles Salina Sue. Harpers. $1.2 Jones, Paul. The Commercial Power of Congress. and Orifices. D. Van Nostrand & Co. $1.50 net. | Tales of France. With B.A and notes by Privately printed, | Roberts, Morley. Lady Penelope. Boston: L. C., A. G. Cameron. American Book Co. Jos@phe, Flavius. Antiquités Judaiques. Livres Page & Co. Tennyson's The Princess. Edited by Katharine L. X1.-XV. Traduction de Joseph Chamonard. Paris: | Rolfe, W. J. A Satchel Guide to Europe. Boston: Bates, American Book Co. EK. Leroux, Houghton, Mifflin & Co. $1.50 net. Valera, Juan. El Comendador Mendoza. American Lamb, Osborn R. The Iberian: As Anglo-Greek Rowland, Helen. The Digressions of Polly. Baker Book Co. Play. Ames & Rollinson. $1.50 net. & Taylor Co. 0. Wells, Cardlyn, and Harry Persons Taber. The Lord, Eliot, and others, The Italian in America. | Sanborn, Alvan Francis. Paris and the Social Matrimonial Bureau. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin i. F. Buck & Co. Revolution. Boston: Small, Maynard & Co, . $1.50. Henry Holt and Company ’ Seager’s Introduction to Economics He Henry Rogers SRacer, Professor in Columbia University. 560 pp., 8vo, OO net. F. H. Dixon, Professor in Dartmouth College; “Professor Seager has written what is probably the ‘best text-book on the elements of economics that hax yet uppeared, . The feature of the book is the exhaustive treatment of the subject of distribution, to which efght chapters are devuted. The mental balance of the writer is here most evident, for in spite of his Austrian training he finds himself unable to foi ow the Austrian writers ia their extreme positions. His acceptance of much of the thinking of the classical school in combination with the more conservative port‘'ons of modern theory, results in a pre-entation which, far from being wavering and in- definite, as one might fear, is consistent, sane, and satisfying.” Bronson’s English Essays By Waiter C. Bronson, Professor in Brown University. (May. A collection of represe ntative essays by Bacon, Milton, browae, ‘bwitt, Addison, Steele, Defoe, Goldsmith, Burke, Hazlitt, Lamb, Landor, Carlyle, Ruskin, Arnold, Pater and Stevenson. Newcomer and Seward’s Essentials of Rhetoric By A. G. Newoowrr, Professor {+ Leland Stanford University, and SAMUEL 8. SeEwakp,Jr., instructor in the same, (/une.) This book will be characterized by an abundance of fresh and suggestive exer- elses, including drill work on words and sentences, but with emphasis on wholes. The Temple School Shakespeare The volumes so far published are The Tempest (Oliphant Smeaton), Mere chant of Venice (8. M’William), Macbeth (George aan). Julius Caesar (F. Arniyt+ge- Morley), Hamlet (Oliphant Smeaton) Richard Lf. (W. Keith Leask) and As You Like It (Flora Masson). Price 35 cents net each. Sornie C. Hanr, Profess rin Wellesley Coliege: “Recently I went over them in detail and with a singul r sense of satisiaction. Tomy mind they represent the most intelligent selection of Shakespeare sch larship and research within the limits of a school edition, What impresses me most fs the good Judgment that lies behind the preparation ofthe books. The illustrations are charming and give a distinct sense of atmosphere.’ Recent Yale Studies in English Kdited by Prof. ALHenr 8. Cook of Yale. Paper 8vo0. (Full at of these “ studies" on application.) The Cross in the Life and Literature of the Anglo-Saxons. By Dr. William O. Stevens. 75c. net. King Alfred's Version of St. Augustine’s Soliloquies turned Into Modern English. By Dr. Henry Lee Hargrove. 75c. net. Jonson's Bartholomew Fair. Edited by Dr. Carroll Storrs Alden, $2.00, —.— The Poetaster. Edited by Dr. Herbert 8. Mallory. $2.00 (el, 82.50). The Staple of News. Edited by Dr. deWinter.* $2.00 (cl, $2.50), Otis’s Elementary German Grammar Thoroughly revised and provided with new exercises by W. H. Cankutu, Pro- feseor in the University of Kansas, xiil.4+856 pp. 16mo, 80c, net, The chief features of the revision are a new set of exercises and the fus'on of the two parts into one continuous sertes of thirty lessons; in addition some subjects receive a fullertreatinent in the book as it now appears, ‘Ihe new exercises are fuller than the old and have a certain continuity, 29 W. 23RD ST., NEW YORK 878 WABASH AVE., CHICAGO Biedermann: Deutsche Bildungszustande Fdited, with introduction and notes, by Jonn A. Wauz, Professor in Harvard University. xix.+205pp. 16mo. ‘ioe. net, Schiller; Minor Poems Edited with introduction and notes by JoHn 8. NOLLEN, Professor in Indiana University. (June.) Gerstacker : Germe!shausen 7% with introduction, notes, vocabulary and exercises, based on the text, by A. McLouTu, Professor in New York University. vi.—124 pp. 16m 0. S0c. net. Meissner: Aus Deutschen Landen With vocabulary by JosEFa SCHRAKAMP. 196 pp. 16mo. 35c. net. Sealsfield: Die Prarie am Jacinto Fdited with Notes and Vocabulary, by A. B. Nicnoxs, Professor in Simmons College. 131 pp. i6mo. 85 cents. A vivid picture of life on the American frontier early in the last century. by a os a fugitive Austrian monk who wrote under the pseudonym of Charles eaistiel Nichols’s Two German Tales I. Goethe’s Die Neue Melusine. II Zschokke’s Der Tote Gast. With introduction, notes and vocabulary. By Prof. A. B. NICHOLS. (May.) Rambeau’s French Reader By Prof. A.RamBaau. 190 pp. 16mo. ( April.) This uew reader is based u oy Passy-Rambeau ‘“‘Chrestomathie Francaise.” but ie not like the larger work honetic characters. The matter of the new book is more vivacious and interest ng in style than that of the traditional French reader, and Includes selections in both prose and verse. The brevity of the book is in accord with the present tendency not to tarry long on a reader. Schrakamp’s le Livre Francais By Josgra SCHRAKAMP. 195pp. 12mo0. 75c. net. Bertua Moscovirz, Girls’ Technical High School, New York City: ‘‘Combinea the rare qualities of everyday useful matter for conversation with excellent and in- teresting reading matter that is onoolly adapted for memorizing and gives the learner a good insight into the life and feelings of the French.” Margueritte: Strasbourg Edited with introduction, notes anc vocabulary by Oscar Kvuuns, Professor in Wesleyan University. 238 pp. 16mo. 385c net. Zola: L’Attaque du Moulin and Other Pieces Authorized Edition. FKdited by ARNOLD Guyot CamEron, Professor in Prince- ton University. 704+288 pp. 16mo. 80c. net. Labiche et Martin: Le Voyage de Monsieur Perrichon With introduction, notes and vocabulary b Boy tga len EFFINGER, Professor in the University of Michigan, 128 pp. !6mo, Erckmann-Chatrian : Waterloo Edited, with introduction, notes and vocabulary, by Victor E. Frangors, In- structor in the College of the City of New York. (May.) * Astor Edition of Poets is the best for schools and colleges, 93 vols. List price, (0c. per vol, (price to schools 40c.). jar om chogmsbens comes ISLAND For Sale on the Maine Coast | ..2"'70,.2%% Bore: lot Vicki" cibbon, One of the most beautiful islands in Penobscot Guizot, Hawthorne. Hugo, Irving, Macaulay, Poe, A one night’s journey oe Lowel and close to STANDARD AUTHORS IN SETS Reade, Ruskip, Scott, Smollett, Shakespeare, Thackeray, Tolstoi. the JAN The ts of the ti a tite geo is Send for Descriptive Booklet, SEND FOR LIST on an hk, ‘soloed on pees e ‘ boats, with dee ago Cheseahes Thomas Y.Crowell @Co., NewYork shore. Tt com Ki “bleh BO cree of igh oar THOMAS Y. CROWELL & CO,, New York are numerous bea —_ >= bold rocky ANEW NOVEL BY THE AUTHOR OF “DODO.” at almost every poin ~~4 au tial views of PROTHERO'’S $2.90 net. stereeed THE CHALLONERS ‘ .S2son. | Statect in At all Booksellers. isjands sed siosnteles. The sur- must te eo The Psalms in Human Life E. P. DUTTON & CO., NEW YORK Beisel iti acta Heed Speaks ROE Gah E EEA NipeaTe
Page 29
April 13, 1905] The Nation. Memotrs of Henry Villard Journalist and Financier 1835-1900 Two volumes, with Portraits and Maps, $5.00 net. Postage, 35 cents. An autobiographical record of the varied and romantic career of the war journalist who subse- quently became a power in the financial world, and carried the Northern Pacific Railroad to com- pletion. Full of incident and valuable for its reminiscences of Lincoln and other prominent men of the time, as well as for its descriptions of important battles of the Civil War. “A book of extraordinary interest. It is written with great ability, in a clear and flowing style; it details with perfect candor the incidents of a great career: it {s an admirable report of great events, all of which the writer saw, anda large part of which (after 1870) he was; it exhibits the rise and growth ofarich and pow- erful personality and a character at once remarkable for its simplicity and its variety.”’"—JoHn Wuire Cuap- WICK, in the New York Times Saturday Review. “This posthumous mare of the , late Henry Villard ig a work of exceptional interest.”—Commer- cial and Finaneiai Chronicle, November 12, 1904. HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO., BOSTON AND NEW YORK The Literature of The English Language From the Earliest Times up to our day Biography, Bibliography, History, Criticism. Composite Studies of all English and American authors who have made important contribution. All contained in THE LIBRARY OF LIT- ERARY CRITICISM. 8 Royal Octavo Voi- umes, over 6,000 pages 250 portraits. No other work like it. Set $4000. Customary terms. For full information and free sample pages address MOULTON PUSLISHING COMPANY Mooney Building. Buffalo, N, Y. BROKE of COVENDEN “There is no living writer to whom it would not be a credit.”—Springfleld Republican. Cloth, $1.50. Postpaid, HERBERT B. TURNER & CO., Boston. of Ripon MR. BALFOUR AS SOPHIST. Prof. Henry ophy, Glasgow. THE CRUX OF THEISM. W.H Mattock. APRIL NUMBER NOW READY THE HIBBERT JOURNAL A Quarterly Review of Religion, Theoiogy and Philosophy Annual subscriptions, which may commence with any number, $2.50. Single numbers, 75 cents. CHIEF CONTENTS OF APRIL NUMBER THE EDUCATION OF A MINISTER OF GOD. The Rt. Rev. W. Boyn Carpenter, DD, Bishop Jones, M.A., LL.D THE LORD IS A MAN OF WAR. Rev. F. W. CHRISTIAN, GREEK, OR GOTH? H. W. Garrop, Fellow of Merton College. Oxford THE RESURRECTION OF OUR LORD AND RECENT CRITICISM. Kev. ©. F. Nottoru THE KNOWLEDGE OF GOOD, Prof. W. R. Sortey THE TESTAMENTS OF THE TWELVE PATRIARCHS. Prof. C. H. Cuan.es THE HISTORICAL JESUS AND THE CHRIST OF EXPERIENCE. RELIGION OF ROME, CLAS-:ICAL AND CHRISTIAN. M. A. B. TeKer. Discussions, a number of signed Reviews, and a Bibliography of recent Literature Orpe-Warp, B.A Subscriptions are booked and single numbers sold by G. E. STECHERT, 9 East 16th Street. New York. INTERNATIONAL NEWS CO., 88 and &% Duane Street, New York THE AMERICAN UNITARIAN ASSOCIATION, 25 Beacon Street, Boston, and any other good bookseller, or from the publishers direct, WILLIAMS & NORGATE, | 4 Henrietta Street, Covent Ga-den, London, W.C. . Professor of Moral Philos Romayvus SHAKESPEARE First Folio Edition. Edited by Porter-Clarke. Printed by DeVinne VOLUMES NOW READY * Mid sommer Night's Dreame,”’ “Love’s Labours’ Lost, *Come die. of Fr rors.” **Merchant of Venice,” “ Macbeth,” “Julius Ceesar,”’ “Hamlet.” Price, in " eloth, 75 cents per vol ume; limp leather, $1.00 per volume, postpald. Thomas Y. Crowell & Co., Now York | F.W. CHRISTERN (DYRSEN & PFEIFFER, Successors), . 16 West 33d St., opposite the “ Waldorf,” New York. Importers of For ign Rooks, Agents for the leading Paris Publishers. Tauchnitz’s British authors. Teub ner’s Greek and Latin ¢ lassics. Catalogue of stock matied on demand. New buoks received from Paris and Letpzig as svon as issued, LIBRARY RESEARCH Topics of all kinda and in any language looked up tn large libraries for scholars, writers, ard others who have not at hand the books needed In preparing theses, lectures, addre-ses, club papers, books. or articies for publication, or in any plece of iavestigation. Highest university and library references. Miss M. H. Buca ine HAM, No. ¥f Chestnut Street, Boston, Maas, Financial. Letters of Credit Issued in Pounds Sterling ©» Parrs Bank, London, and available in all the principal cities of the world, also issued in dollars for the use of travelers in this country. Full particulars upon application. Redmond & Co., BANKERS, 41 Wall Street, NEW YORK. 507 Chestnut St., PHILADELPHIA. as be bi 4, ~ im - hap of exchanges and l ETTE make cable transfers of money on Europe, OF Australia, and fouth Africa; also make ~ lections and {ssue Commercial and Travel- CREDIT = © Sateagreny available in all parts of the International Cheques, Certificates of Deposit. BROWN BROTHERS & CO., NO. 59 WALL STREET, NEW YORK. JUST PUBLISHED The whole story of the Bible told in 168 complete connected chapters HURLBUT'S STORY OF THE BIBLE. By Jesse LyMAN Hereiaut, DD. 14 Three-Color Plates, 262 Half-Tone Engravines, nearly S00 Pages. Cloth, $1.50, postage. At all bookstores THE JOHN C. WINSTON CO., Philadelphia. WALT WHITMAN *"" life of this great writer ts published in the Beacon Blo graphies. WHeautiful photogravure frontispiece, Handsomely bound tn cloth. Price 75 cents net. SMALL, MAYNARD & COMPANY 31 Arrow Street Cambridee, Mase. ‘DWIN LAWRENCE GUDKIN.— _¢ Japan proof of Portrait, engraved on wood in the highest style of the art, sent, charges paid, on receipt of five dollars (85) by Gueray Keven, 102 Sussex Avenne, Kast Orange, N. J 75,000 BOOKS in Stock. Just purchased—$20,000 Library, consist- ing mostly of modern subscription Library Sets, at ‘6 the original cost GEORGE H. RIGBY. 1113 Arch Street, Philadelphia, Pa. FOR THE MIDDLE-AGED AND BEYOND A BOOK THAT YOU OUGHT TO READ “DIET IN RELATION TO AGE AND ACTIVITY” With hints concerning habits c onducive to longevity. By Sin Henry Trowrson tc Ss, (London), ete. limo, cloth. ONE DOLLAR. “Full of hints as to when, and under what cireum stances, the diet should be changed.” — Phila. Inquirer ee Al booksellers; or. postpaid on receipt of pri F. WARNE & CO., 36 E. 22nd St., N. ¥- A Tale of the Great Southwest. THE HUMAN TOUCH By Edith M. Nicholl Postpaid, $1.50. send for onr FREE Book List Lothrop, Lee & Shepard C., Bestes eee ———ES Resorts. Beautifully «ituated above the ROSEVILLA, lake with wide view of the Alpe WEUCHATEL, strc ii ition nen | all the yvar 4 ouse weated by ay La ny ag Or apply for information to The Misses Kirk, Rosemont, Pa. Travel. Middle-aged Gentlewoman will chaperone young people to and from Europe. Best references. Apply to | Mes. Pottarp, Washington, lowa. ; in gold. 75 cents, To receive the current numbers in a convenient (temporary) form. cloth, with THE NATION stamped on the sde Holds about one volume. and neatly adjusted. Sent, postpaid, on receipt of Substantially made, bound in Papers easily
Page 30
li The Nation. [Vol. 80, No. 2076 NEW SCRIBNER BOOKS ITALIAN LETTERS OF A DIPLOMAT’S WIFE By MARY KING WADDINGTON “ In this new volume of familiar letters Mme. Waddington offers as pleasant a ‘dish of gossip’ as that which has sent her collec- tion of epistles from London into many editions. . . . The whole is graceful, easy, animated, full of glimpses of interesting people and delightful places.’—W. Y¥. Tribune. With 24 full-page Illustrations. $2.50 net (postage 20 cents) ICONOCLASTS: A Book of Dramatists By JAMES HUNEKER “Eye-opening and mind-clarifying is Mr. Huneker’s criticism. No one having read the opening essay in this volume will lay it down until the final judgment upon Maurice Maeterlinck is reached.” — Boston Transcript. $1.50 net (postage 135 cents) COVENTRY PATMORE By EDMUND COSSE “Mr. Gosse has made a delightful little book about Coventry Patmore, . . . what the judicious reader must recognize as a singularly complete and satisfactory comprehension of the poet.”"—W. Y. Times. $1.00 net. Illustrated (postage 10 cents) NEW FICTION THE ORCHID SHINING FERRY by by ROBERT GRANT A. T. QUILLER-COUCH “ The vivid social picture is crisply condensed and audacious “It abounds in quaint humor; it has the smell of the sea; it in conception and decidedly a contrast to Mr. Grant’s later lS contains charming descriptions of children.”— Zhe Outlook. Hlustrated in color. $1.25 $1.50 AT CLOSE RANCE TWELVE STORIES anda DREAM b b e HOPKINSON SMITH H. G. aii “In fact, these simple tales contain more of the real art of ae : : : . character drawing than a score of novels of the day.” Stories comic, tragic and prophetic, told with great power —WN. Y. Evening Post. | and charm. Illustrated. $1.50 $1.50 TO BE PUBLISHED SHORTLY FOLLOWING THE SUN-FLAC By JOHN FOX, JR. A Vain Pursuit Through Manchuria An entertaining and picturesque account of experiences in Tokio and Manchuria, told with much humor and great literary charm. $1.25 net (postage extra) ERNEST RENAN | ITALIAN BACKGROUNDS b | y WILLIAM alias D.D. EDITH WHARTON Phases of Italy generally overlooked by the conventional sn t An able snd Det TAGGING SE's comieaite nae sight-seer described in Mrs. Wharton’s most delightful manner. $1.00 net (postage 10 cents) Ilustrated by Peixotto. $2.50 net (postage extra) STINCAREE AT THE FOOT OF THE ROCKIES by by E. W. HORNUNG CARTER GOODLOE zation. Illustrated. $1.50 Hlustrated, $1.50 THE BIOGRAPHICAL EDITION of the works of ROBERT LOUIS STEVENSON A new and attractive edition with a series of intimate and sympathetic introductions written by MRS. STEVENSON, telling of the circumstances under which the books were written. Each volume sold separately. Cloth $1.00. Limp leather $1.25 net CHARLES ;SCRIBNER’S SONS, New York