The Nation 1902-08-07: Vol 75 Iss 1936
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
PABEDAN pens eget nc Rapa. The N atian
VOL. LXXV—NO. 1936.
aa ga a a a oa Ready in September| A New and Revised Edition of ONE THOUSAND AMERICAN FUNGI By CHARLES McILVAINE and R. K. MACADAM With thirty-eight full-page color plates By far the most complete book of American Fungi. Over 1,000 species are classified with full botanical de- scriptions, and the book is illustrated with 38 full-page color plates, 25 full-page engravings and over 300 etch- ings. The volume contains acomplete glossary, val- uable color charts and a record of marked cases of toad- stool poisoning, with their treatment; also many val- uable recipes for cooking the edible species of fungi. Tue ONLY Compiete Book ON THe SuBsEcT. Wer ARE Now ENTERING OXDERS TO BE SHIPPED ON THE DAY OF PUBLICATION ONE VOLUME, QUARTO, NET, $5.00 Ghe Bowen-Merrill Company INDIANAPOLIS, U.S. A.
NOW READY!! CHR. FR. GRIEB’S Dictionary of the English and German Languages Tenth Edition. Rearranged, Revised, and En- larged, with special regard to Pronunciation and Etymology, by ARNOLD SCHROER, P’h.D., Profes- sor of english Philology iv the University of Freiburg, i. B. In two volumes. Volume L, English-Ge 1 $41.00. Volume II, German- English, $4.5 For sale by all Booksellers. Send for Catalogue. OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS: (AMERICAN BRANCH) 91 and 93 Fifth Avenue, New York. F. W. CHRISTERN (DYRSEN & PFEIFFER, Successors), 29 Sth Ave., bet 38th and 39th Sts, New York. {Importers of Foreign Books, Agents for the leading Paris publishers; Tauchnitz’s — authors, Teub- ner’s Greek and Latin Classics. Catalogue of stock ‘nailed on demand. New books received from Paris and Leipzig as soon as issued IRONQUILL | Some of the Rhymes of Ironquill. 12mo, $1.50. G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS, NEW YORK. THE POCKET BALZAC. The superb Wormeley translation, complete fn 30 vols. $1 per vol. in cloth; $1.25, in limp leather. Any volume sold separately. Send for descriptive circular, specimen illustration, sample pages and special offer. No agents. LITTLE, BROWN & CO., Publishers, Boston.
American Traits From the Point of View of a German. By HVGO MUNSTERBERG HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO., Boston and New York.
ACK NUMBERS, VOLS. AND SETS of Tus NaTIon bought and sold. A catalogue of second-hand books woe appeeises. A. 8. CLARK, 174 sd whee Street, New York Read THE KINDLED OF THE WILD. CHARLES D. Koperts., Price, $2.00. L. C, AGE & COMPANY, Pubs.. Boston,
THU RODAT, AUGUST 7, 1902. | William Watson’: ~ Contiiian Ode | In spite of the Coronation fatal- | | ists, August 9 will see Edward | VII. crowned! Have you yet | ‘read William Watson's glorious | | poem, that tripie mirror, re- | fecting Britain’s Past, Present, |and Future? Every American | heart will swell with sympathetic | pride on reading WILLIAM |\WATSON’S CORONATION ODE, the greatest poem written these fen years The Philadelphia Press: “One of the rare sustained efforts of a poet whose art is unequaled among his living En; dish brethren."’ The London Times: “Who will surpass its fit splendor of words, who will equal its grave memory of the solemn tenure on which England holds the glories of ber vast inheritance ?"’ 12mo. Boards. $1.00 net. Edition de luxe, Vellum, $3.50 net. JOHN LANE : New York The Baker & Taylor Co. SCHOOL BOOKS AND ALL OTHER BOOKS A perfectly developed system A varied and complete stock A record and an experience of 80 years All make ours the best place at which to buy books If OBEArr ACCURACY, ana DISPATCH count. THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO., 33-37 E. 17th St., New York.
ow, | When ames abease. ask for ert. | wieseur fen need a book DISCOU: address Mr. Grant. Before ae books write for quotations. An as- sortment of catalogues and special! siips of books at reduced prices sent for 10-cent stamp. PF. BE. GRANT, Books, 23 W. 42p Sr. . - . NEW YORK. (Mention this “advertisement and receive a discount.) “A Romance of the Affections.” Stralghtlo. wat "* Margaret LE. Saugster
ASK FOR. CROWELL’S POETS OLD BOOKS AND MAGAZINES | <2, ‘or ,cxta.
A. J CRAWFORD, 10th & Pine Streets, St. Louls, Mo “Ary, {2 Oxy 8 PRICE TEN CENTS,
EVERYBODY
Remington Typewriter adapted to his work Wyckoff, Seamans & Benedict (REMINGTON TYPEWRITER COMPANY) 327 Broadway, - New York
Travel. To Europe With Safety and Speed. Average voyage less than 7 days, Boston to Queenstown and Liverpool Take one o gs Palatial New Twin Screw jteamers of the DOMINION LINE Sailing from B. & M. R.R. Docks as follows: MERION (new), June 25; New Exotanp, Jaly &, and Wednesdays thereafter. Further Information of RiCHARDS, MILLS & CO , 77-81 State St., Boston GOING ABROAD on a BICYCLE TRIP? Send for “* Bicyciing Notes for Tourists Abroad ° LEYLAND LINE Boston— Liverpool—London Immense new steamers. First Cabin, $65 wup- wards, depending on steamer * Hanove erian ’ August 6 and Sept. 10 ‘Armenian ’........August 20 and Sept. 24 * Devonian”. ... Sept. 3 and Oct. § FP. O. HOUGHTON & CO., Gen'l Agts., Telephone 1359 Main. ms State Street, Boston.
European and American Plan The BERKELEY HOTEL Boston. John A. Sherlock. Proprietor. Facing on Berkeley, Boylston, and Providence Streets; but one block from the far-famed Pub’ t« Gardens and the same distance from Copley Square, is but two minutes’ walk from the Art Museum and Trinity Church; t« directly oppoatte the Inatitute of Technology, and buat five minutes to all theatres. shops, and the basiness seci lon Kestaurant & ia Carte, Dining-Room, Table a’ Hote, Café and Bililard-hoom for Gentlemen
Page 2
Nation. The [Vol. 75, No. 1936 The N ation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science, and Art. FOUNDED IN 1865. [ Entered atthe New York City Post-Office as second- class mail matter. | CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. DU FRE nce pens ntenccevcsvesecsraseses’ Seeoeenes 101 EDITORIAL ARTICLES: Iowa and Tariff Reform .........ccceeeeees 104 BE. TRACE POORMEE woo ecw rcccesecsesecos 104 The Handicap of Militarism .............. 105 The Teaching of Art in Universities ........ 106 Education for Women in Germany .......... 107 SPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE: A Frenchman’s Dairy in Our Civil War pi Oe RK yr errr ere ree 108 The St atus of History in Southern Education 109 CORRESPONDENCE: The Atlantic Fishery and Protection........ 111 Congressional Encounters, New and Old..... 112 i rr eee 112 The Washington-Jefferson Letters ......... 112 IR aw oie FA vaio bo dcbncnceoendahys secdebereekoendaks 113 Book REvIEWws: Beer Oe -eMOGR b. k cv icctevernevesdscesegiss 116 i MN 4. os 6 oan cnennced opepeesbenteete 117 oe Ro ES. eer ress 118 GE DS. 35,04 bose 6s b¥0Gbe0800b000 03 118 po. RP er eee ee 118 Les Syndicats Industriels de Producteurs en Prance ot G PRTONGOP ..cccscccccsevccce 119 Pra eer 119 Tetraeuangelium sanctum juxta simplicem Syrorum versionem ad fidem codicum, mas- sore, editionum denuo recognitum ........ 120 DOOM GH TU WE 6 ook sc civiesececsictceccsecdecses 120 TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three Dollars per year in advance, postpaid, to any part of the United States or Canada; to joreign countries comprised in the Postal Union, $4.00. The date when the subscription expires is on the address label of each paper, the change of which to a subsequent daie becomes a receipt for remittance. No other receipt is sent unless requested. Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter, or by check, express or- der, or Postal Order, payable to ‘Publisher of the Nation.” When achange of address is desire d, both the old and new addresses should be given, Address THE NATION, Box 794, New York. Publication Office, 208 Broadway. TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Fifteen cents per agate line, each insertion; 14 lines to the inch. Twenty per cent. advance for choice of page, or top of column. A column, $20 each insertion; with choice of page, $2h. A page, $60 each insertion; front-cover page, $80. Advertisements must be acceptable in every re- spect, Copy received until Tuesday, 6 P. M. DISCOUNTS. Time 4 insertions,........... 5 per cent, s o eobuduedeshaudsnvnonsesaseeuael ae "K 1% * jane cemedasesacsesseienses | Peed 26 © «ss pan gagpeboncdeebunasedesdpeseas 15 ee BY 2 pesos kb cntpenseeeéeesencntee wd = 52 “ sapabe deekespn suis 25 “ AMOUNT $100 within @ year iebhucoaséases ‘ 10 per cent, 250 eebbuetestedeedsevees EE 500 : © | ipeucdbasaenenseauecweaees 15 o 750 nif me” . Sgnbeagen gevenvseedeves 20 ne 1,000 ¢ “ Sse seigasxonseee Oe ms 1,500 gf 2 pebeveconsdonegeuceeehson B80 $e ¥,000 ™ - sveeeee ° 1» 83% “ The NATION is sent free to those who advertise in it as long as advertisement continues, *,* Copies of the Nation may be procured in Paris at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de l'Opéra, and in London of B. F. Stevens & Brown, Trafalgar Square, Charing Cross. Educational. MARYLAND, Baltimore, 122 and 124 W. Franklin St. y¥PGEWORTH BOARDING and Day 3a, “a0 hool for a gg ree. will begia September t rs. H. P. LEFEBVRE, } iN Miss E. D. HUNTLEY. joes, Massacuvu SETTS, Boston. Ro: STON UNIVERSITY Law School. Address the Dean ia eae ay ; _SAMUEL Cc. Benner. — ‘Manaacuvanrrs, Cone ord. ONCORD SCHOOL. Special attention given to boys preparing for col- lege. Location exceptionally attractive, near the his- toric village of Concord. Ball field, tennis-courts, and boathouse. A family school with individual attention. THos. H. EcKFELDT, Head Master. MICHIGAN, Detroit, 73 Stinson Place. ETROIT HOME and DAY SCHOOL, 25th Year. Prepares for all omegne open to wo- men. 20 received in the school family. a Th e Misses LieGerr, Prine ipals. — New York, Tarrytown-on-Hudson. E OME INSTITUTE. A Boarding and Day School for Girls. College pre- paration. Reopens Sept 18. Miss M. W. METcaLr, Prin. PENNSYLVANIA, Philsdelphia, Germantown, 59 High St. YY Oo Preparatory to Bryn Mawr and other colleges. __Address Miss Mary E, STEVENS. _ Reemgegramt Rosemont, 1 mile from Bryn Mawr College HE MISSES KIRK, formerly connected with Bryn Mawr College, will begin the 4th vear of their College oeneeneety Se School for Girls in anew and larger house, on tober 2, 1902. Number of boarders limited to twelve. Careful individual instruction. SWITZERLAND, Geneva. Z| SELECT HOME SCHOOL for 6 American boys in cultured French-Swiss home. Unique advantages. For pamphlet, etc., address J. C. Du FOUR, M A.. 20 20 Ave. de Lancy, ¢ Geneva. a ME SS ANABLE'S Boarding and Day d School for Girls. Established in 1848. Circular on application. 1350 Pine St, Philadelphia. St. Agnes School: 4z24Wy, X. Y. Estab. 30 yrs. in the interest of the best education. For girls of all ages it combines the best Physical, Moral, Intellectual, Domestic, and Religious Training, with ideal Home Living. Built on high ground above the historic Hudson, A with every progressive feature of and Recreation, including a laborato- ry for” scientific work, gymnasium, art studios, lecture hall, and library. High standards in art and music. Prospectus on request, Miss Catherine R. Seabury, Head of School. PENNAYLVANIA, Bryn Mawr. Miss Baldwin’s School for Girls Preparatory to Bryn Mawr College Miss FLORENCE BALDWIN, Principal. Within 11 years more than 145 pupils have entered Bryn Mawr College from this school. Diploma given in both general and College Preparatory Courses, Fine fire-proof stone oduilding, 25 acres of beautiful grounds. For circular, address the Secretary. Mrs. Delafield and Mrs. Colvin’s SCHOOL FOR GIRLS 2 Successors to Miss Heloise E. Hersey. : An institution of the highest scholarship Offering exceptional surroundings and relation- ships to those who value them at an increased cost. Only thirty pupils with eleven teachers secures the most careful personal supervision. No pupil rec’d withouta personal tnterview. Terms, $1,250 a year. 25 and 46 Chestnut Street. Boston. F:ducationad. Michigan Military Academy Will open for its twenty-sixth year September 17« This is a thoroughly equipped school in an ideal loca- tion, giving especial attention to the preparation of students for the leading r tor bt It also prepares for West Point, aad. = iy sanees. For zeeegne address STRONG, Sup * Orchard Lake” Nien. ia year opens New York Oct. 1, 1902 Day Classes w sessions from to University ; i. LL.B. after two La S h 1 penned Ls eal er 8 Ww cnoo after three years.) Gradu- ate Classes lead to LL.M. Tuition, $100. For circulars address L. ~§ TOMPKINS, Registrar, Washington Square, N. Y. City Girls’ Classical School Indianapolis, Ind, 21st year opens Sept. 17. Best equipment for College =paratory and Academic work. Separate buildings for school and residence. Gymnasium. Household Science. Catalogue eodore L. Sewall, Founder. May Wright Sewall, Principal. NEW YORK /35 Negeau( “DWIGHT |, N ME LAW SCHOOL} York | City.(of Instruction, LL.B. in two years; LL.M.in three years. High stan- dards. Prepares for Bar of al! States. Send for Catalogue. GEORGE CHASE, Dean. Abbot Academy “‘wass”® A high grade school for girls Fine situation. Com- plete modern e a. ine buildings. Ample pro- vision for outdoor exercise Personal attention of teachers. Address The Principal. A SCHOOL ROCK ror BOYS RIDGE snus WABAN SCHOOL, “ABA. Twenty-five boys accommodated J.H. PILLSBURY, A.M., Principal. — SOUTHERN HOME SCHOOL for Girls. ene No orc T1002. Miss Bor Baltimore, Md. styear. Oc Iss DUFF, Miss PENDLETOY. { Principals. Teachers, etc. BRYN MAWR GRADUATE de sires a position as tutor in i for college. Languages a specialty Would travel. References. Address N.N., care Publisher Nation. School Agencies. WE FISK TEACHERS AGENCIES. Everett O. Fisk & Co., Proprietors. 4 Ashburton Place. Boston, 1505 Pa. Ave., Washington, 156 Fifth Ave., New York, 414 Cent. bldg..Minneapoli 533 Cooper Bldg., Denver, 80 Third St., Portland, 20 Mich. Blvd., Chicago, 525 Stimson Block. Los Angeles, Hyde BIk., Spokane, 420 Parrot Bldg., San Francisco. LBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY, 81 Chapel St., Albany, N. Y.—Provides schools of all grades with competent teachers. Assists teachers in obtaining positions. Rents and selle School Property. HARLAN P. FRENCH, Proprietor. CHERMERHORN Teachers’ Agency. Teachers—Schools—T utors—Governess—Property. Fg Te Joun C. ROCKWELL, Mgr., 3 E. 14th t., N. TRAINING SCHOOL for NURSES, Children’s Hospital, Boston, Mass. A three years’ graded course, including housekeep- ing, diet-kitchen work, in a comfortable nurses’ home; thorough training and careful supervision of pupils; under the direction of the Sisters of St. Margaret. Address SISTER CA ROLINE, Superintendent. THE HIGHLAND MILITARY ACADEMY, Worcester Magee. 47th year. Healthful loc ation. Generous table. Preparation for college, scientific, or business life. Newly equipped laboratories. Athletic field. Small classes The Rt. Rev. ALEXANDER H. VINTON, 2. Visitor, JOSEPH ALDEN SHAW, A.M., Head Master. Geronee ScuHooL, BucKs Country, Pa. GEORGE SCHOOL, Under the Management of Friends. 227 acres. College preparation. Heavily endowed, 800 per year. Je SE He 8. WALTON, _ Principal, The Browne and Nichols School Jambridge. Mass, 20th year. Course, 8 years Classes limited to 15. No subordinate teachers; pupils continu- ously under head teacher in each department. Excope tional facilities for fitting for Harvard, [lus trated catalogue. THE NATION an independent weekly journal, was estab- lished in 1865. Its contributors include the most prominent names in literature, science, and art, both in this country and abroad. It is emphatically found in the homes of people of culture and refinement. No intelligent American, desirous of keep- ing abreast of the best political an diiterary thought of the day, can afford to be with- out it. Subscription price, $3.00 a year, postpaid. Address PUBLISHER OF THE NATION, 208 Broadway, New York City. ee ¥ 4 ¢ *
Page 3
Aug, 7, 1902] Financial. THEODORE WETMORE & CO. REAL ESTATE, COMMERCIAL PAPER, STOCKS, BONDS, AND MORTGAGES. All cities are experiencing sharp advances in real estate. Now is the time to purchase Minne- apes real estate. We offer some bai d properties, some of whi assessed value. MINNEAPOLIS. MINN. If You Have Any Property in Duluth or Superior, Which You Desire to Sell, WRITE TO Pulford, How & Company 100 Trust Company Bidg., DULUTH, MINNESOTA. LAWTON & FERTIG Colorado Springs, Colo. An experience of twenty-five years in Iccal Realty makes our judgment competent in the safe selection of Six Per Cent. Loans, as well as the wise purchase of city property for in- vestment, An unbroken record of success in the profitable handling of money for a large list of Eastern investors is the best reason for your confidence. desirable income-bearing ch we will sell for less than We i and sell bills of exchange and dle make Ca transfers of money on E urope, oat poe Australia, and South Africa; aiso make collections and {ssue Commercial and CREDIT. Travellers’ Credits available in all parts of the world International Cheques. Certificates of Deposit. BROWN BROTHERS & CO., NO. 5@ WALL STREET, NEW YORK. Back Numbers of “The Nation. ee In response to frequent inquiries from subscribers: An incomplete set of Tue NATION has little or no mar- ket value. Partial sets, bound and unbound, are always obtainable (usually lacking the earliest volumes), and do not command high rates. The bindings generally count for nothing, owing to great diversity of styles. Vol- ume I. has readily brought 810 and upward when com plete, bound or unbound, but it will bring very little in proportion if a single number is missing. Volumes IT, and III. are also scarce, but not so high-priced as the firet. Complete sets, both bound and unbound, have sold for $100, with tolerably quick bidders, and have an increas- ing value year by year. Single numbers not more than a year old can usually be supplied by the publishers at 10 cents each. For num- bers more than a year old purchasers are referred to H. Williams, 114 Fifth Ave., J. W. Christopher, 47 Dey $t., or A. 8. Clark, 174 Fulton St., New York The publishers no longer undertake to buy or sell numbers or volumes more than a year old, and can only recommend sellers or purchasers to negotiate with a dealer or to advertise in Tux Nation. (Publication was begun July 1, 1865, Vol. I. compria- ng the last half year. Two volumes per year have since been issued, Vol. LX XIV. compristng the firet half year pf 1902.) _The Nation. School Trustees, Principals. Teachers, And others interested, are invited to consider the advantages offered by the Va/ron as an advertising medium. School advertisements are printed in ad- a uniform typography, with the dress in the first line, classification being made by States, alphabetically, unless especially ordered displayed on other pages. The ation, in its special field of political and literary criticism, is un- like any other periodical, American or foreign. About 10,000 cop.es are circulated weekly, but these figures do not accurately represent the num- ber of its readers. It is taken by reading clubs and literary associations in a large number of places, and may be found on file in every iibrary of importance in the country. ‘There are probably few weekly periodicals whose columns offer so favorable an opportunity for reaching an audience interested in educational matters. Advertising rates, 15 cents a line each insertion, with the following dis- counts: 5 insertions, per cent, on 4 10 per cent. on 8 insertions, 12% per cent. on 13 insertions, 15 per cent. on 26 insertions, 20 per cent. on 39 in- sertions, 25 per cent. On 52 insertions. The Mation is sent free while ad- vertisement continues. Orders may be forwarded through any responsible advertising agency, or directly to THE Nation, 208 Broadway, N., Y. —- ee eee for Sale and to let. For Saleat Duluth, Minnesota. One of the Finest School Properties in the Country. Ballding modern and convenien 4 Ss apt ments Surroundings ideal and beautiful A wide field for a preparatory scho and to the right party the price reasonable and terms of payment easy or infor od —_ L. MENDENHALL. D etait Ses. DO YOU KNOW That you can buy % Gold Bonds on in- stallments-and mean- while have them insured. A good investment | for you - if you live. A splendid protection for your family-i you die. For tull information till § up and mat! coupon below. THE EQUITABLE SOCIETY, Dept. No. 22 120 Broadway, New York. Please send me information regarding your new issue of Gold Bonds. Base figures on a block of $ issued at years of age. eee eeeeeee eter |
Page 4
iv The Nation. [Vol. 75, No. 1936 The Most Important Whist Book in Many Years THE PRINCIPLES AND PRACTICE OF WHIST By LENNARD LEIGH and ERNEST BERGHOLT. With EXAMPLES ILLUSTRATIVE DEALS, CRITICAL ENDINGS, MATHEMATICAL CALCULATIONS, TABLES OF PROBABILI- TIES, etc., etc., including an Essay on PROBABILITIES, by WILLIAM H. WHITFIELD, M. A. Cantab. “The book is admirably planned for the student. It is a very important and valuable addi- tion to whist literature.’”’-—FisHer Ames, author of *‘A Practical Guide for Whist.” “A better guide for the learner or book of reference for the expert could hardly be de- vised."’~-CHARLEs E. Corriy, author of * Gist of Whist ” “I believe it will be of great benefit to whist players and to the game of whist.’’—The late Gen. A. W. Drayson, author of ‘The Art of Practical Whist,” after seeing MS. “Precisely what was required by the whist world to bring the grand old game into thor- oughly healthy grooves.”.—Co Long. B. Lows.ey, author of ** Whist of the Future.” “You have produced a work on whist which will prove serviceable both to the beginner and to the advanced player.’’—N. B. Trist, author of ‘*‘ Whist.” “An exceedingly valuable addition to whist literature.”’—Wu..iam S. FENOLLOSA. “It is the best work on the game ever issued in this country, and for completeness in giving everything a whist student could require is the most satisfactory and best gotten up work ever offered to the public.”.—ELLwoop T. BakEr. “IT have no hesitation in pronouncing the book the soundest, most thorough and convincing exposition of basic whist principles that has ever been written."".—W. A. Porrer, Whist editor of Providence Journal. “No book on the game has ever been praised so generally and so highly. We strongly recommend it to all whist players; the poor players will be instructed, the good ones will profit by it, and the experts will find it agnever ending source of enjoyment.’’—W. H. Samson in the Rochester Post Express. Crown 8vo. Cloth, extra gilt top. Net, $1.50; by mail, $1.68 “As dainty as finished, and as beautiful asa miniature.” THE WESTCOTES By A. T. QVILLER-COVCH Illustrated by J. L. GEROME-FERRIS I2mo. Cloth, $1.00 THE WESTCOTES has been running as a serial simultaneously in ‘‘The Era” in this country and “ Blackwood’s Magazine”’ in England. The London “Spectator” and “The Speaker’? both give it high praise. It is a charming tale, with all Mr. Quiller- Couch’s delicacy of touch and high literary quality. “It is very rare to come across a book which so fully satisfies the demands of the fastidious reader.”’-—London Bookman. “Admirably written romance.”’ — London Spectator. “There is a chirming old-world courtesy about this book, a faint and rare fragrance emanating from it, a mellow, a fine tone sound- ing through it.”—The Academy, London. “A delightful story, told in his usual felicitous style.*’—Chicago Journal, “A sweet and tranquil idyll, fluttered, but not overwhelmed by genuine passion.”—N. Y. Tribune. “Treated with infinite delicacy.”’—London Saturday Review. “It has quite as much literary distinction of manner as any of its author’s books,’’—The Outlook, N. Y “The book shows that the author has pro- gressed in his art to a position warranting a be- lief in his permanence.’*—N. Y. Times Satur- day Review. “A tale of rare delicacy and feeling.’’—De- troitsFree Press. HENRY T. COATES & CO., Publishers, Philadelphia. LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO.”S NEW BOOKS PROFESSOR JAMES'S GIFFORD LECTURES Ghe Varieties of Religious Experience Being the Gifford Lectures on Natural Religion delivered in Edinburgh in 1901-1902 By WituraM James, LL.D., etc., Professor of Philosophy at Harvard | University, Corresponding Member of the Institute of France and of | the Royal Prussian Academy of Sciences. &vo, pp. xii.-531, gilt top, | $3.20 net. By mail $3.40. “Ifa preacher, or any man whose function it is to study and appeal to | humanity on its religious side, were to ask us which of this season's books it Is most essential for him to possess, we should, without hesitation, point to this volume . . . Thisis not merely aclever and interesting work, it isa contri- bution of the highest value to a subject always pertinent, but never more so than at the present time ’—Christian World, Tendon. “‘A volume which deserves the careful study of all who care for religion Professor James has already enriched us with masterly books, but his latest volume will add greatly to his reputation. He has read widely, asthe extraor- dinary variety of his extracts shows; he has thought deeply. as many fine, sug- gestive passages prove; and the result isa book which is full of lucid expression of a great teacher's ideas.”—Araminer, London. The Path to Rome. By Hivarrne Be..oc, Late Scholar of Balliol College, Oxford, Author of | “The Life of Danton,” “ Paris,"’ “* Robespierre,”’ etc. With 80 Illus- trations from Drawings by the Author. Crown 8vo, 464 pages, gilt top, $2.00 net. By mail $2.20. “The one certain thing about it fs that it must be counted among the most | charming pieces of literature that have appeared for a long while, Taken in | conjunction with the author's monographs on Danton and Robespierre it marks | the revelation of anew writer who Is already of real distinction. Mr. Belloc has now gained the freedom of the Republic of Letters, Henceforth he may write of whatever he pleases, from child-study to the industrial system of Japan, and he will not lack an andience.. . . (ne may safely urge him to keep on writing and writing hard, while his youth #tfll Intoxicates him. Let him travel whitherso- ever he will—to Timbuctoo or Pittsburgh—if only he will give us more of this and plenty before the mood dies away. . . . The reader's pleasure is enhanced by a number of exquisite Ilustrations, sometimes scarcely larger than thumb- nall aketches.”—New York Timea Saturday Review Memoirs of Sir Edward Blount, K.C.B., Etc. Edited by Sruartr J. Rew, Author of “The Life and Times of Sydney Smith,” etc. With 8 Photogravure Plates. Svo, pp. vili.-308, $4.00, [Just ready | | Dale has written. illustrations. kept a place in history. ing, an Spectator. By Lucy Dag, late Scholar of Somerville College, Oxford. 8vo, pp. xii. 509, $1.50 * “There was roomin our historical literature for just such a book as Mrs- | She is an admirable interpreter, a most graceful, | clever and interesting writer, a scholar with a fresh mind and a vivacious style, and her book is not merely instructive but illuminative. 7 | thoroughly scholarly work : but it aims at communicating the ripe and nourish- ing fruits of scholarship to those not able to garner them for themselves by their own labor.” — Scotsman. Seven Roman Statesmen of the Later Republic The Gracchi, Sulla, Crassus, Cato, Pompey, Ceasar. Oman, M.A., Deputy Professor of Modern Histor Oxford, Author of *‘ A Histor Crown &vo, pp. iv.-348, $1.60,* ** We welcome Mr, Oman’s eloquent and lively book, not merely for its own merits, but because it carries us back to the good old days when heroes still AMERICAN GEACHERS SERIES New Volumes. The Teaching of Chemistry and Phsyics in the Secondary School By ALEXANDER SmiTH, B, Sc., Ph. D., Associate Professor of Chemistry in the University of Chicago, and Epwin H. Hay, Ph. D., Professor of Physics in Havard University. and Bibliographies. Crown 8vo, about 380 pages, $1.50. [/mmediately With 21 Diagrams, and References The Teaching of History and Civics in the Elementary and the Secondary School. By Henry E. Bourng, B.A., B.D, Professor in the College for Women, Western Reserve University. With Bibliographies and Index. Crown 8vo, pp x.-385, $1.50. The Principles of English Constitutional (Just ready . History. Crown [Just ready tisa By CHARLES at University of jith Portraits and of Greece,” etc. [Just ready ery e of his brilliant book is worth read- - « Eve we cannot wish a student better luck than to come across It before the austerity of the Germans has killed his interest In the history of Rome.’’— LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., o1-93 Fifth Avenue, New York
Page 5
‘ ye @ % My The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, AUGUST 7, 1902. The Week. The Evening Post’s staff correspon- dent in the coal regions undoubtedly gives us the real and secret motive of those who engineered the strike. They were putting their trust in politics. Their success two years ago in getting an advance in wages through playing upon the fears of politicians, led them to hazard a second attempt along the same lines. As before, they counted upon the good offices of Senator Hanna. He himself, in the remarks which he made to his employees in Cleveland on Mon- day night, admitted his peculiar rela- tions with the anthracite strikers. Of course, he puts his interest in them now on the ground of his noble ambition to “bring capital and labor nearer to- gether.” Unfortunately, however, he does not clear away the suspicion that his activity this year, as in 1900, may, have a political bearing. The way for him to dissipate all such doubts, if they are unworthy and unfounded, is plain. We would not ask him to live up to the Scriptural test of selling all that he has and giving to the poor, but he could at least make it certain that he is not yearning over laboring men for the sake of their votes. He could do it by say- ing unmistakably, as he has thus far failed to do, that he is not and will not be a candidate for the Presidency. He could also disavow any thought of mak- ing his philanthropy aid his political power, by resigning as National Chair- man, and renouncing all idea of con- trolling the convention of 1904. Until Senator Hanna does in some such way leave himself free to work for the cause of labor, without any entangling alll- ance with politics, we fear that an in- credulous world will hardly rank him with St. Francis or St. Dominic. Judged by the published text of them, the West Virginia injunctions against la- bor leaders do but follow well-establish- ed and sound judicial precedent. They enjoin, that is, against interference with the management and operation of the mines, and also against attempts to deter employees from going to work “by menaces, threats, or intimidation.” All the incitements to strike which the in- junction forbids are specifically describ- ed as “unlawful”; and, of course, the statutes of all civilized countries pre- scribe penalties for any act that is taint- ed with violence, There is in all this, it will be observed, no denial of the right of labor to organize, or of trades-unions peaceably to persuade employees to strike. The right of persuasion has beep upheld by leading decisions of the New York courts. Some of them are collected | in a pamphlet recently published by Mr. G. W. Alger of the New York bar. He also points out that the Pennsylvania courts have taken a narrower view of the laborers’ right to induce men to quit work. In one case, the highest court re- ferred to the plea of the striker’s counsel, namely, that the Union’s committee had only exercised their ‘“‘right to talk to new men to persuade them not to go to work,” and roundly declared, “There was no such right.” The court went on slightly to qualify this denial of the right of per- suasion, by introducing the consideration of “an improper time,” but the decision as it stands is certainly very stringent. It may yet play a part in the Pennsylva- nia mining troubles, should they be taken into court. It is to be hoped that the managers of ex-Gov. Pattison’s canvass in Pennsyl- vania will take their cue from the ad- mirable address, devoted exclusively to State issues, with which Mr. Henry Budd opened the Democratic campaign in Philadelphia on Monday night. The “ills worth mentioning’ which the speaker described, presented a formid- able appearance, and it would be both interesting and instructive if some means could be devised to hold Judge Pennypacker and the Republican cam paigners to the discussion of them. Such a course has always been peculiarly diffi- cult in Pennsylvania. During the cam- paign of last year, when the principal issue in Philadelphia was the election of a District Attorney, the Republican speakers spent most of their time beg ging the people to “uphold the hands of President Roosevelt in his effort to carry out the plans and policies of Pres- ident McKinley.” Apparently the peo- ple were willing to tolerate talk of this sort, for the result was the usual Re- publican victory. Nevertheless, consid- erations of political expediency, as well as of political morality, urge the Demo- cratic managers this year not to relax their efforts to force the Republicans to the discussion of the local issues. If they follow out the lines indicated by Mr. Budd’s address, they must certain- ly accomplish something toward awak- ening the people of Pennsylvania to a realization of the political conditions which beset them. A horrible scandal has developed at Philadelphia. It has been discovered there that when the City Council, about a year ago, gave away, without a penny of compensation for the municipality, franchises worth many millions of dol- lars, a clause was inserted by somebody with the evident purpose of safeguarding | , : . ; the people’s rights in one particular. The details of this betrayal of the very pri- vate interests which “owned” the Coun- cil is shrouded in mystery, like most deeds of darkness. But there the clause is, in the ordinance granting the fran- chise. “Said motors,” it says, “to be sup- plied from underground wires, or such other system as shall not require ower- head wires or poles.” Of course the first impulse of the Philadelphta officials and their intimates who are said to be “be- hind” the franchise deal, on learning of the existence of this restriction, was to find out the name of the miscreant who inserted it. Members of the Council who had previously borne untarnished repu- tations for “standing without hitching” fell under suspicion. But second thought is better than first impulse. It soon be- came clear that nothing, not even the enforcement of discipline, should be per- mitted to delay the undoing of the mis- chief. The City Council fs to be asked at once to repeal the clause in question. Time enough to hunt the offender after this is accomplished! “Devery, thou art translated,” must be the secret comment of every Shaks- perean in Tammany Hall, as he watches the antics of the ex-Chief of Police on the way to a district leadership. I¢ Is Devery’s distinction to have thrown over- board all the niceties of the code under which he has been trained, to have so stripped off from “practical politics” the “human nature” that one may see the very bestial shape of cupidity which is the body of our political death. He has no time for the graces of district leader- ship, but imposes himself upon the peo- ple by the sheer glitter of money gotten in ways that he has never told, and which would not bear telling. It is Dev- ery who pays the butcher bills of the poor, who yesterday settled the rent of several poer women—and told of it; who offers “pleasure” to the entire district; who, seeking a political office, makes not so much as a perfunctory appeal to poiit- ical principles, being, in fact, profoundly ignorant of any political principle other than this, that the city Is the politicians’ cow, and that a place near the udder can be had only by purchase at a great price. What the answer of the plain people of the Ninth District will be to an ex-offictal with a malodorous record, who frankly offers to buy them up bodily with butch- er’s meat and picnics and the payment of their rent, we do not presume to predict. But we do not think so meanly of any portion of this city as not to feel that thousands of self-respecting citizens of the Ninth District must regard Devery with amazed contempt, and the rabble that he so easily gathers around him with unconcealed scorn. In any event, reform-
Page 6
The Nation. [Vol. 75, No. 1936 =cscall ers can cheerfully put up with any trans- lation of Devery that does not involve his silence and obscurity. He is to-day at once the most diverting, most disgust- ing, and most profitable spectacle that the city affords. A pending transaction between the Mayor of the city, the consulting archi- tect of the Borough of Manhattan, and the Municipal Art Commission is worthy of note. The case in brief is this: The consulting architect, Mr. Aiken, who is planning certain alterations of the inte- rior of the City Hall, requests the Munici- pal Art Commission to pass upon the plans. The Mayor expresses pleasure in communicating the request, and says: “This building is so fine a specimen of architecture that I am anxious that no changes should be made in it except such as have been well considered and are be- lieved by the Municipal Art Commission to be proper.” But, some one might say, “This is only as it ought to be. No change should be made in a beautiful, historic building without the most care- ful consideration.” The real significance of a transaction which, according to the letter and spirit of the City Charter, is merely normal, can be grasped only when one imagines the alteration of the City Hall under, let us say, Mayor Van Wyck. For Mr. Aiken seeking advice from the Art Commission, substitute Horgan & Slattery standing on their dig- nity as “city architects’; replace Mayor Low, with his solicitude for the beautiful building in which he serves the city, by Mayor Van Wyck, with his chronic af- fectation of boorishness and ignorance; finally, imagine, instead of the Municipal Art Commission, working for the seemli- ness of the city, a horde of sub-contrac- tors and vendors of building supplies hanging upon the edge of the contract. The plan of exchanging fellowships between Columbia and the higher schools of Paris—two Americans to study in Paris, two Frenchmen in New York—is important rather for the spirit in which it is introduced than for any large prac- tical effect it is likely to have. It would be a mutual recognition of the value of American and French university train- ing, and it would in some degree tend to strengthen the academic relations of the two countries, It should not be for- gotten that holders of French fellow- ships have already chosen to study in America rather than elsewhere, so that the present plan merely gives official form to relations that already exist. To establish two more travelling fellowships in Columbia will have no very great ef- fect upon the practice, constantly in- creasing, of pursuing higher study in France, If the French Ministry, how- ever, should provide for two travelling fellowships for America, it would consti- ‘ute among French students a kind of sanction and advertisement of university study iu America. This would tend to bring them regularly to our graduate schools, where now their presence is ex- ceptional. Such a result would be hearti- ly welcomed. Detailed statements about the United States Realty and Construction Company show that the scheme is even more com- prehensive than was at first supposed. For the management of a general realty and building business, indeed, the organ- ization is singularly complete. By means of its close association with other large financial and industrial corporations, the new organization will be able to buy its own properties, search its own titles, put up its own buildings, and dispose of the finished product, either en bloc or in the shape of securities. By its con- nection with certain large lending insti- tutions, it will have unusual advantages in securing loans; by its association with the Steel Trust, it will be able to obtain the most essential building material on especially favorable terms—giving the latter corporation a monopoly, by the way, of a very important market. In the development of great properties, indeed, it is difficult to see how the new corpora- tion can have any possible rivals. There are certain conspicuous building sites in New York which have been hitherto ne- glected for the want of a great and re- sourceful corporation capable of under- taking the task, but a corporation which is capitalized at $66,000,000, allied with leading financial institutions, and man- aged by the most expert talent in the field, would be able to cope with an un- dertaking of any magnitude. At first sight only the financial aspects of the United States Realty and Conctruc- tion Company strike the mind. But those who have marked the considerable ad- vance in handsome building under ordi- nary conditions will see in this great con- solidation, and those which are undoubt- edly to follow, an opportunity by which art-lovers should be quick to profit. It is not merely that these enormous com- panies will be free to undertake building operations of a magnitude too great for private enterprise, but that, like all large aggregations of capital, they will be freed from the necessity of seeking a quick profit at the expense of a perma- nent one. If their managers are wise enough to plan for a long future, their activities will incidentally do much to beautify the city. That it pays to build well and handsomely is already general- ly recognized. But these great corpora- tions will have exceptional facilities for good building, which they should not fail to utilize. Nothing could better guaran- tee the public-spirited character of the company now forming than the appoint- ment of an architectural board which should see to it that, within the limits of cost and usefulness, every building that it erects should be an ornament to the city. It may be hoped, too, that in some cases these companies will follow the example of the Astor estate and open streets through the longer blocks, thus relieving the congestion of the city while benefiting themselves. It would proba- bly be practicable to redeem certain por- tions of the town for better residence purposes, by erecting great apartment buildings with a liberal provision of open courtyards and small gardens. Certain quiet and delightful parts of the Fau- bourg St. Germain in Paris would serve as a model; and while there might be a period of waiting for returns, a few years would amply justify so bold an innova- tion. President Schurman is performing an invaluable public service in discussing on all proper occasions our national pol- icy in the Philippine archipelago. His address last Saturday before the Chau- tauqua Assembly should be carefully read by those who carelessly believe that the Philippine problem is settled. Pres- ident Schurman finds that the war has united the Christian Filipinos in a com- mon sentiment of nationality. With this sentiment we must deal with the ut- most respect. To ignore it would be as fatal as it was to ignore Aguinaldo’s in- cipient republic in 1898. Meanwhile, as President Schurman points out, we must face this alternative for the future Phil- ippine commonwealth—statehood or in- dependence. No one can doubt towards which solution statesmanship will in- cline. Nothing forbids the Republican party to promise by resolution of Con- gress eventual independence for the Fil- ipinos. It will become a duty to do so as soon as the Filipinos have, under the Government now forming, proved a ca- pacity for self-rule—an event which may be confidently predicted for the near fu- ture. A choice still lies before this na- tion, and that choice must be a right one —this is the tenor of President Schur- man’s clarifying discussion. In view of his proper aititude in the case of Gen. J. B. Smith, it is cause for regret that President Roosevelt did not see fit to rebuke the court-martial which tried Major Glenn. That tribunal let off this chief offender among the water-cure torturers with a petty fine of $50 and only one month’s suspension, while Licut. Gaujot escaped with a fine of $150 and three months’ suspension. As we have already pointed out, the President has no power to increase the sentence of a court- martial, and disapproval in these cases would merely have let the guilty officers escape without any penalty. But it was in the President’s power to rebuke a court-martial which so flagrantly failed to guard the honor of the service by impos- ing sentences commensurate with the of- et ee EE ee
Page 7
gia Nes Ne Se ta 4 Aug. 7, 1902] fence. In the case of Lieut. N. E. Cook of the Philippine Scouts, found not guilty, the President did withhold his approval of the findings. In other words, he be- lieves Lieut. Cook to have committed the crime alleged. But here, too, the Presi- dent was silent. It may well be that he considered his statement in the Smith ease sufficient; nevertheless, he has let slip a rare opportunity for improving the spirit of the army. It is interesting to note in this connection that, of the six officers thus far tried, three have been found guilty by the court and three by the reviewing officers, despite confident assertions that there was no such thing as official wrongdoing in the Philippines. A question cf considerable interest, in relation to the proposed Cuban loan of $35,000,000, concerns the prospect of floating such securities. The situation is peculiar. If the information cabled from Havana is correct, the bond issue cannot bear a higher rate than 5 per cent., and cannot be sold for less than 90. Now, a 5 per cent. loan of a strong government, sold for less than par, would be a very inviting investment. It may be that the rate and the discount would attract investors in this case. If the loan is really necessary, and if the pros- pect for its redemption has been pru- dently calculated, it is to be hoped that it can be floated, and it probably can. But the matter is not simple. The loan would have to be raised in New York city. It is almost certain that it could not be placed abroad. London is find- ing trouble in placing securities of its own colonies. It has lately had to with- draw from a market a British Columbian loan, already offered. Of Government securities now outstanding, bonds of states in high credit sell, to be sure, at a level which yields not more than 3 per cent. on par. But the question of credit is closely scrutinized. Brazilian 5 per cent. funding bonds sell below par; Chilian 5s, for less than 90; Argentine 6s, below par. It is true that the currency question cuts a figure in some of these quotations; but it is clear enough that, without a United States guarantee, the Cuban borrowings would be judged abroad in the light of experience with other West Indian and South American republics. The revenue-reduction law enacted last April contemplated, roughly; $75,000,000 curtailment in annual public income. As the surplus revenue for the fiscal year ended with June, 1901, was $92,000,000, the reduction seemed sufficiently conser- vative. It probably will turn out to be so, though results for the first month in the new fiscal year are somewhat curi- ous. To begin with, internal, revenue, in which last April’s cuts were made, falls $6,700,000 under lasf July. This is about the monthly average expected. The Nation. against this reduction, the month’s cus- toms revenue rises $3,100,000 over 1901, and $4,800,000 over 1900. This offset would be effectual but for a third change in the fiscal movement—-an increase of $4,500,000 in the month’s expenditure The nei result is an unexpectedly large deficit. The Treasury reports that most of this increased outlay comes from pay ment on old State war claims. If so, the normal expenditure would be only a trifle over 1901, and for future months the rise in customs receipts and fall of internal revenue would be left to score against one another. We are inclined to think however, that the increase in public ex penditure, under the larger appropria tions of the last session of Congress, will go on. When Mr. months ago, was explaining in court the reasons for the Northern Securities Pierpont Morgan, five “holding company,” he remarked that its $400,000,000 stock was an important consideration. The company would con trol the Northern Pacific, the Great Northern, and the Burlington, and, Mr Morgan added, “it is not within the range of human probabilities that any single interest will be able to buy the control of the Northern Securities Com- pany away from its present owners.” This was a logical proposition; its prac- tical working out, moreover, involved merely the issue of new shares for old. The Burlington purchase at 200, to be sure, was extravagant, and the issue of bonds io pay for it was an exceedingly dangerous example. But, as to this, Mr. Morgan testified that the price was paid “because we could not get the control at any lower figure.’’ The Rock Island pro ject, now officially set forth, shows that the theories of our capitalists to-day have drifted as far from Mr. Morgan’s position of last March as that position had moved from the original ‘““communi- ty-of-interest” plan. Where Mr. Morgan’s plan contemplated companies whose con- trol would be so costly that no one could pay the price, the new idea looks to a company whose control will be so cheap that its present owners can keep it for a trifle. In the famous Northern Pacific contest, a majority of the company’s $150,000,000 stock was actually purchas ed, costing some $78,000,000; but Mr. Morgan thought that half of the $460,- 000,000 Northern Securities would not easily be purchased. Control of Rock Island, as acquired by the present ruling party, is thought to have cost some $45,- 000,000; but, with the present fixing of virtual control in $54,000,000 new pre- ferred shares, which will sell at a heavy discount, the same interests can proba- bly keep control through the use of bare- ly $16,000,000. It is not so long ago that Mr. G. K But as Chesterton, or some other commentator of British society, was writing on th lack of originality in m naires, and the subject has been again the “Contributors’ Club” of the last Af lanti Naturally, Mr. Carnegie and his perennial gilts Of libraries W mot Acton en! man in England who is best fitted to u them to his own and the common profit and when this vast collection in media associations from the fact that, througl Mr. Carnegie’s courte heir to the book and lite l naterial of Lord Acton. It i lom ven to generous With this grace, and tl will be memorable in the annals of grace ful giving which saw the timely pu chase of the poet Carduce bo the Queen Dowags of | and the transfer of Lord Acton rary to Mr John Morley Another bye-election has gone again the English Government, and so unex i! ‘ 1 +} pectediy and with such a staggering re versal of majorities as to amount to a political disaster North Leed ha been Conservativy since 1880 it wa put down as the safest of safe seats, th Tory majority in the last general « tion being 2,500. Now the Liberals have won it by more than 700 Moreover they fought their campaign on what the imperialists would call the most miser able of parochial issues—the Edueatioy Bill (which the Government has give too much the appearance of class favor Lord Rosebery’: saying that the victory should bs itism) and free trade warning to the Liberals not to sup port Irish Home Rule, was a singularly ill-chosen comment on it. The fact was that the Liberal candidate, Mr. Barrar had for some time avoided in his canvass all mention of the Irish question, but a last, under pressure from | constitu favor of the historic Gladstonian policy. But for thi ency, had declared himself in and the winning of the Irish vote, it was ' thought he could not possibly have been elected. It would be a queer thing, ther for Rosebery and his Imperial League to meet to congratulate the new membe and improve the occasion to de nounce the programme on. which he For the rest Lord Rosebery’s speech seems to hav: secured his triumph been rather a darkening of Liberal coun sels, and a quite unnecessary and {Ii timed insistence upon the things that di vide a party in great need of being unit ed
Page 8
104 The Nation. [Vol. 75, No. 1936 IOWA AND TARIFF REFORM. The Republican State Convention held last week at Des Moines, Iowa, has excited a national interest by reason of the lively controversy which preceded and attend- ed its meeting, as to the attitude which it should take toward the tariff ques- tion. Albert B. Cummins, a representa- tive of the younger generation of poli- ticians, as compared with Senator Alli- son and other veteran party leaders, was elected Governor, last year, upon a plat- form which recognized the necessity of tariff reform and demanded the requisite legislation. After declaring adherence to “the historic policy” of the party in giving protection to American industry, and “pointing with pride” to its vindi- eation in the extraordinarily rapid de- velopment of our national resources ascribed to this policy, the resolutions of 1901 proceeded to affirm that “we favor such changes in the tariff from time to time as may become advisable through the progress of our industries and their changing relations to the commerce of the world.” This was followed by an endorsement of reciprocity as “the nat- ural complement of protection,” and a call for its development as necessary to the realization of our highest commer- cial possibilities; and then came a plain- spoken demand for “any modification of the tariff schedules that may be required to prevent their affording shelter to mo- nopoly.” Last year was an “off year” in our politics, only a very few States keeping Iowa company in the choice of a Govern- or, and no national officials being elect- ed. This year the lower branch of Con- gress is to be elected, and a number of States will choose Legislatures which must in turn name members of the Sen- ate. Moreover, the Congressional elec- tion which comes midway in a Presiden- tial term is regarded by many politi- cians as “the opening gun” for the na- tional campaign, two years later. In 1901, therefore, the question which was raised by the Iowa Republicans in their tariff deliverance was largely academic, while in 1902 it is a matter of practical importance how they stand on an issue that will surely be raised in the Con- gress to which the other forty-four States as well as Iowa elect Representatives. It is a long time since there has been a more vigorous contest in any common- wealth as to the position which the party should take on a question not only of concern to the nation, but having a bear- ing on the relations of the party in one State to the organization as a whole. Practically, the issue came down to this, whether the Republicans of Iowa ought to declare themselves in favor of such a revision of the tariff as would remove its shelter to Trusts, or ought to ignore the whole question. The division was not strictly along lines of age, but, as a rule, the older leaders, like Senator Allison and Speaker Henderson, favored a policy of silence, while most of the younger generation, represented by Gov. Cummins and Mint Director Roberts, who now controls the leading party or- gan, advocated a reaffirmation of the resolutions adopted last year. It was urged, on the one side, that a State Con- vention ought not to attempt to make national platforms for the party, but an appeal to the records showed that, a quarter of a century ago, in 1877, when the financial issue was burning, Iowa Republicans expressly demanded the resumption of specie payments. It was also argued by the conservatives that the resolution in question was virtually a plea of guilty to the Democratic charge that the tariff is the parent of Trusts; but the progressives replied that the lan- guage expressed the exact views of a large majority of the party, that it had stood the test of one campaign, and that its elimination would make it an issue in this year’s campaign, put the party on the defensive, and lead the people to believe that the party was changing front on the Trust question. The fight was waged with great vigor in the Com- mittee on Resolutions, but, when the op- ponents of tariff reform had been beaten there, they concluded to surrender, and not a voice was raised in opposition to the platform when it was reported to the Convention. It is interesting to note that in this action there is a reversion on the part of Iowa Republicanism, under new lead- ership, towards the position on the tariff which was occupied by the party in the same State twenty-five years ago. When the late John H. Gear (afterwards Sena- tor) was first elected Governor in 1877, he stood upon a platform which declared that “we favor a wisely adjusted tariff for revenue”; and this resolution was adopted without change by the conven- tion of 1878—a year-of Congressional elections—as well as by that of 1879, when Mr. Gear was nominated for a second term. Mr. Allison, then in middle life, and serving the first of his five terms in the Senate, was in sympathy with this attitude, and nobody questioned the or- thodoxy of any Republican who held such views. Gov. Cummins and his school may therefore claim that they are only following in the footsteps of their fathers. The action of the Iowa convention would be significant and encouraging if the Des Moines platform stood by itself as an index of Republican sentiment in the Middle West. But there is abundant evidence that a host of Republicans throughout that section agree with their Iowa brethren in this matter. If the re- cent Wisconsin convention had been al- lowed by the party dictator to express its views on national questions, it would undoubtedly have shown its sympathy with the demand for tariff reform, but Gov. La Follette insisted that the cam- paign should be made on State issues. Even some Republican leaders of the old- er generation openly and earnestly favor such a declaration of principles as the Iowa convention has made. The veteran Senator Cullom of Illinois told the Tri- bune correspondent in Washington last week that he believed the Iowa expres- sion “just about voices the sentiment of the Republican masses throughout the West,” adding: “I know it is the way the Republicans of my State feel, and I am convinced that, the sooner we take this matter up and dispose of it, the better it will be for the country and the party.” The Tribune, to be sure, in its editorial columns attempts to minimize the impor- tance of the Iowa plank by emphasizing the fact that it was only a repetition of a declaration which made no great stir a year ago; but its Washington corres- pondent is more candid in admitting that this circumstance “does not detract from the importance of the action from the point of view of party leaders here.” The same authority represents the movement as of vital importance in at least three Congressional districts of Iowa, which are now represented by Republicans who opposed “reaffirming” last year’s deliv- erances at Des Moines, and who say they will not make their own campaigns on any tariff-revision platform. It does not need the evidence which other newspa- pers furnish from all parts of the coun- try to show that shrewd politicians rec- ognize the action just taken in Iowa as highly important. MR. BABCOCK RECANTS. Seldom can a public man have more unblushingly advertised his own incon- sistency and insincerity than has Con- gressman Babcock, in the statement which, as Chairman of the Republican Congressional Committee, he gave to the press in Washington on July 30. He not only swallowed his own words and spit upon his own acts, but went out of his way to do it, and gloried in trampling upon his own record. “There is only one thing worse than the cant of poli- tics,” said Lord John Russell on a cer- tain occasion, “and that is the recant.” Mr. Babcock has recanted, and has added to that humiliation by appearing to be unconscious of his own shame. It is not every prominent man who can thus cheerfully give the world the option of believing him either knave or fool. The melancholy details of Mr. Bab- cock’s moral suicide can be briefly given. He comes out, like a master of jeers and flouts, with ridicule of the Democratic contention that tariff protection should be removed from manufactured goods which are sold cheaper abroad than at home. What if they are? asks Congress- man Babcock airily. It is only “a rule of the trade,” he says, that surplus prod- ucts must go cheaper to the foreigner. The Democrats can make nothing of that issue. “We are not afraid to ask the iN OLS PSI pis
Page 9
‘ r, s ee a a LSA GSE BS. estas: ER lke FS Be Aug. 7, 1902] country to continue the Republican par- ty in power in order that those policies {the present tariff] may be continued in effect.” But if he was not afraid of that, did he not dread that his own previous attitude and language would be thrown in his teeth? Who was it that was making all the row last winter about removing needless and abused pro- tective duties? Congressman Babcock. Who made himself so offensive on this subject to the party leaders that Speak- er Henderson was urged to keep him off the Committee on Ways and Means? Mr. Babcock. Who introduced a bill to take off the tariff from iron and steel prod- ucts, spoke for it, voted for it, divided the Ways and Means Committee on it, boasted of it,swore he would never aban- don it, vowed that the party would be defeated if it rejected the measure? Why, this same Joseph W. Babcock! Almost exactly a year ago he was ex- pounding his unalterable convictions to the editor of the Southwestern Wiscon sin which published his letter. “I main- tain,” declared the then valiant Babcock “that it is a part of the policy of pro- tection to protect the consumer.” He ex: plained precisely what he meant: “We can to-day produce and underseil the world. Shall we continue a tariff on ar ticles that are, in fact, articles of ex port? If Congress maintains a tariff on such articles, the whole theory of pro- tection falls to the ground, and it sim- ply inures to the benefit of those who may secure the control of any such com- modity, since by its aid they can fiz exorbitant prices in the domestic mar- ket.” Then, with a swell of indignant virtue in his voice, Mr. Babcock asked, “How can such a policy be defended?” Well, he has answered his own question. Get yourself elected chairman of the campaign committee, show how beauti- fully “holler” you are fashioned in order to “swaller”’ with ease your own princi- ples, and you can defend with moral vehemence this or any other policy which you have previously denounced as infamous. D’Azeglio explained the process in the case of the Carbonaro who was asked to break his oath: “Eccellen- za, I cannot; it is impossible. . . You understand, I have taken an oath— give me at least another ducat!” Mr. Babcock’s sad case is worth dwell- ing upon because he illustrates, in his not very important personality, the too common recklessness of American poli- ticians in pitching their character out of the window. They seem to think that stability and unshaken honesty are of absolutely no value in politics. To ac- quire a reputation for sobriety and cour- age and independence seems to be often their aim for a time, as it was appar- ently Mr. Babcock’s; but when the cru- cial day comes, they throw it away, as he has done, with incredible indifference, and the most coofly insolent assumption that the public will not perceive any- The Nation. thing amiss, or will not care if it does. But this is really an insult to the people | which they have never been slow to re- sent. They will not fail to do so, we be- lieve, whenever the occasion fairly of- Unless the whole American na- tion is to become a mere weather-cock like the frivolous Babcock, it will re- main in its old choice of solidity and consistency and clear honesty in the men whom it delights to honor. The affair runs beyond the mere per- son of the unfortunate Babcock in other particular. the less hypocrisy of the pretence of the Re- publican party that it will, all in good time, and if only let alone, reform the tariff itself. All its talk in that been uniformly and historically hol- Not fers. an- It shows bottom- vein has low. one of its has, in this matter, been able to sustain the Al- ways, as we see again to-day, the stir- party platforms weight of a single campaign. rings of Democratic opposition, or mut- terings within the ranks of the Republi- can party lead the tionist Old Man of the Sea to grip the Republican neck with a more strangling clutch. We shall never see tariff abuses made an end of until an impulse comes from those who suffer from tariff ruption, not from those who profit by it in both pocket and politics. man Babcock’s indecent retreat from his own position shows that there will have to be an exterior force, a vis a tergo, applied, before Americans may hope to have the monstrosities of their tariff shorn away. itself, only protec- cor- Congress- THE HANDICAP OF MILITARISM. That the Czar has not abandoned his hope of bringing about partial disarma- ment in Europe, is asserted in a recent dispatch from Rome. It explains that the late visit of the King of Italy to St. Petersburg led to an exchange of views on the possibility of an interna- tional agreement for reducing European armaments. The same subject, it is fur- ther stated, will be discussed by the Em- peror William and King Victor when the latter makes his approaching jour- ney to Berlin. What the European Pow- ers are said to be more and more clear- ly perceiving is that the modern world is an industrial world, not a fighting world; that the race is to the nation which, other things being equal, carries the lightest burden of taxation; and that | the risk of a war on the Continent is now so slight that the crushing military expenditures of the several countries may be cut down in a way to enable them to face with more composure “the American peril’—that is, a trade inva- sion by the United States. We do not accept these reports for gospel truth. There is doubtless in them much drawing the bow at a venture. Eu- rope will not disarm to-morrow, nor the day after. But if her rulers are not 105 = 2 openly saying that their peoples are stag- gering under too great a weight of mill- tarism, in the struggle for commercial supremacy, they are saying it privately; if they are not thinking about this evil as one which threatens public peace and content, they ought to be. King Victor is said to be a monarch of clear eyes and progressive ideas; how, then, can he fail to reflect often on the ruinous taxes which drive so many of Itzly’s sons over-seas every year to escape the misery that overwhelms them at home? With the military budget cut down one-half or more, the forced exile of Italians would not be what we see it. And if the autocratic rulers of Russia did not feel themselves compelled by military neces- sity to wring taxes from the wretched peasantry who spend their lives but one step from starvation, no one can doubt that they would find the task of gov- ernment made immensely easier. The thing that comes home to an American with force, in all this talk of Europe's shaking her toilera free of the traditional soldier strapped on the back of each of them, is that we are preparing to load ourselves down with the same burden, at the very mo ment that our industrial rivals over the ocean are planning to get rid of it. But a few days ago we had a long and half- official account from Washington of the about to be played by army and navy near this city, and especially the great concentra- tion of the fleet in West Indian waters next winter, as a means of whipping Congress into granting “big appropria- tions.” We must have a much stronger navy, is the cry of the War College; and to make the matter precise, we are in- that leading “scholar” in strategics is convinced that we shall have a war with Germany in 1907-—-that sardonic scheme to use the “War game,’ formed our is, unless we make our navy so power- ful that Germany will not dare to attack us. This “thoughtful officer” observes that the maximum of the German ship- building programme will be attained five years from now; it has been revealed to him that Germany will about that time make a desh for the Dutch islands in the Caribbean; and accordingly he declares it our immediate duty to get ready a navy able to frighten off the Kaiser's strongest. This particular bit of naval meta- Nothing shows the officer in question to be more truly “thoughtful” than the which he singled his antagonist. Does the thoughtless reader suppose he had any special enmity against Germany? physics has its amusing side. eare with out Not the least in the world. It simply happens that the German navy, 3&8 planned, is the next above ours in strength. It is, therefore, the one we must first surpass. Hence this transcen- dental speculation about the coming war with Germany. Why did not the pro- phetic soul of the “thoughtful officer,”
Page 10
— The Nation. [Vol. 75, No. 1936 brooding on wars to come, predict one with France, or even Great Britain? We make few pretensions ourselves to alarm- ist “thought” of this kind, but we would undertake to point out an even greater likelihood of a clash with the French or British navy than with the German. But, don’t you see? if we were to call upon Congress at once for as many battle- ships as France or England has, the peo- ple would take alarm, and the whole game would be given away. So we must restrict our gaze for the present to mere- ly the next strongest naval Power, and get up a scare about the others later. The whole question of the connection between heavy military expenditure and heavy taxation, and between heavy taxa- tion and a handicapped trade and dis- content and revolution, had its classic discussion and its correct settlement in England between 1845 and 1860. It was not only the free lance, Cobden, but the responsible Minister, Sir Robert Peel, who laid down the true principles in this business. He bluntly repudiated the lying old maxim, “If you wish peace, pre- pare for war.’ His reasons were two: if a Government were to listen to the ad- vice and warnings of military experts, even the most overwhelming taxation would not produce money enough, and the people would be driven to despera- tion. More than that, Sir Robert boldly said, itis “impossible to secure a country against all conceivable risks.’”’ Risk must be run. Peaceful nations cannot go about armed to the teeth because it is possible some mad aggressor may wickedly attack them, any more than the average citizen is in duty bound to carry sword and re- volver to repel a barely possible assault by a highwayman. We have to be guid- ed by reason and probability; and reason and probability are dead against overbur- dening an industrial nation with taxes that may be unnecessary, and that are certain to disable it in competition for the world market. It was this practical consideration, mainly, that made Cobden a lover of peace, To free industry from. the shackles of militarism was his dream and aim. This was why he said that he should “die happy” if he could feel “the satisfaction of having in some degree contributed to the partial disarmament of the world.” Now, is it not a perverse thing, a very irony of fate, that free America, just emerging into the sight of the world as the greatest manufacturing and exporting nation, should voluntarily handicap herself in this way? Already we spend $78,000,000 a year on our navy more than three times its annual cost ten years ago. Must this vast sum be dou- bled? To guard ourselves against remote and speculative dangers, must we throw away our great opportunity for the pres- ent industrial conquest of the world? If we do, under the persuasion of our mili- tary theorists, we shall be guilty of an act of national folly unparalleled in history. THE TEACHING OF ART IN UNIVER- . SITIES. The announcement of the proposed formation of a Department of Fine Arts by Columbia University, and the highly interesting comments thereon of Mr. Russeil Sturgis, in an open letter to President Butler, dated June 10, bring up for discussion by others the whole question of the teaching of art in uni- versities. How much and what kind of instruction in the arts of design should be attempted by the university? That some such instruction should be attempt- ed, we may take for granted all agree. It has been one of the greatest weak- nesses of education in the past that it has been too exclusively literary, so that the most highly educated have often been men for whom the arts of design searcely existed; men who, if they trou- bled themselves at all about such arts, entirely and profoundly misunderstood them, and misconceived their purpose and methods. The self-made millionaire has, at least in English-speaking coun- tries, been much more likely to have an interest in and an eye for art than the college president. This is lamentable, but it is true, and the result is a literary narrowness that has marked some of our greatest scholars, our deepest think- ers, and even our highest poets. They have understood the poetry of Greece but not its sculpture, the history of the Middle Ages but not their architecture, the thought of the Renaissance but not its painting; and in each case they have failed to understand what is precisely the most characteristic manifestation of the race and of the age. Some teaching of art, then, is admittedly necessary to a broad general culture. What shall it be? Mr. Sturgis’s answer is this: It ‘should be limited to history, theory, critical ex- amination of ancient and modern works of art, and of the schools and large groups into which we divide them for the sake of convenience; and, ... in connection with this theoretical study, such arts as are not manual arts may may be taught “more or less well” by a is that “university education has to do with all that can be taught in words, and all that is expressible in the lan- guage of words,” while “a manual art has nothing to do with the thoughts which are expressible in words; by it thoughts are expressed wholly other- wise.” He would allow that architecture may be taught “more or less well” by a university, because architecture is hard- ly so much an art to-day as a science: sculpture and painting are distinctly “manual arts” in his view—‘‘they are the result of the skilled hand of man in- spired directly by the mind which has, by nature and by training, a peculiar ability not noticeable in the ordinary pursuits of mankind.” Such training cannot be given by words or by any con- ceivable course of lectures; it must be given “by what used to be called ap- prenticeship, by the actual touch of the matured artist, watched, imitated, analyzed insensibly, studied continually by the pupil.” Moreover, this appren- ticeship, whether, as preferably, in the master’s own workshop or, as is most likely under modern conditions, in the “art-school,” should begin early in life. Fifteen is, according to Mr. Sturgis, and he is right, none too early an age for its beginning. In modern times a few artists have achieved greatness in spite of late beginnings; but they have seldom been technical masters; and in the days when men really knew how to paint, they were put to the trade in their earli- est youth. This reasoning we take to be perfectly sound and conclusive, as far as it goes. The university can never make painters and sculptors as it makes doctors and lawyers, and attempts to make musicians and architects. Does it follow that it should not try to teach some drawing and modelling? In the first place it may be pointed out that in painting, for instance, there is an art, a science, and a handi- craft. The art cannot be taught at all and never has been; the craft cannot be successfully taught by a university; the science, that of visual aspects, is as much a scientific study as any other; and if all science is the province of the uni- versity, this science also should be taught there. It cannot be taught by words alone, without actual practice in drawing and painting; therefore, some practical instruction in such work should be a part of the scientific equipment of a universi- ty. We do not attempt to teach chemis- try without a laboratory, or anatomy without dissection, so that, in a sense, manual training is already a part of uni- versity education. After all, why should university edu- cation have to do only with “all that can be taught in words and all that is ex- pressible in the language of words’? Is it not the ideal of the university to pro- duce the highest human efficiency as well as the broadest culture, and is not ath- letics to-day really a part of every uni- versity curriculum? The Greeks would have thought little of an education that trained the brain without training the senses. To-day we seem all agreed, on utilitarian grounds, that drawing should be taught in the public schools; why should that teaching cease when univer- sity training begins? Drawing is a lan- guage and a science, and every human being would be more efficient in any de- partment of life if he had as much of that language and that science as he was capable of mastering. Suppose, however, that we scorn util- ity, and that our idea of a university is, like Lowell’s, that it should be a place where nothing useful is taught. We al- low that the history and theory of art, that archeology and esthetics, are prop- er subjects of instruction. But it is pre- 2 PRASAD CLT Rae ROM LE ATID. Ss Be a Ey
Page 11
SR ates eee aP% PLEA ERAS RR eye CERO e cays . a Aug. 7, 1902] The Nation. cisely because these things have been taught by men with an exclusively lit- erary education that they have been taught wrongly. No man without some practical training in art ever at all un- derstood the art he theorized about; and those who have thought that education should deal only with what is expressi- ble in words have spun words endlessly and darkened counsel. Goethe knew bet- ter, and, when he wished to saturate vith the Greek spirit, he drew from the antique. It is not probable that he drew very well, but it is prob- able that he learned more than if he had spent the time reading Winckelmann. The few books on art that are worth reading have been written by practising artists; and more insight into what painting really is and what painters try to do is to be got from an hour of Fro- mentin or La Farge than from a year’s study of esthetics. To conclude: The university will not succeed in training practical artists. Art is, however, one of the most important activities of humanity, and the works of art left us by the past are the most per- manent record of the feelings and ideals of mankind. Some knowledge of and feeling for art, especially the arts of de- sign, is requisite to any true and high culture, and the university should en- deavor to give such knowledge and to cultivate such feeling. This has never been done, and can never be done to any purpose without some practical training in drawing and modelling, or both. Therefore the university, besides courses of lectures on art history and theory, il- lustrated by such collections of works of art or of reproductions of them as it can attain to, should give practical in- struction, by the best masters, in the arts of design. EDUCATION FOR WOMEN IN GER- MANY. The recent death in Leipzig of Frau- lein Augusta Schmidt, for years one of the ablest leaders of the German move- ment for larger social and educational opportunities for women, has called forth respectful tributes to her ability and her high ideals from many German newspapers. Like Frau Louisa Otto- Peters, who died in 1895, Frl. Schmidt was a pioneer in this field of activity, entering it when the slightest connec- tion with the woman’s-rights movement entailed unlimited abuse and ridicule. Their opponents were quick to say that it was not more schools and industrial openings for women at which these agi- tators really aimed, but the upsetting of the entire social order and the unsexing of women. They were, therefore, rank- ed with anarchists, socialists, and So- cial-Democrats, even when Augusta Schmidt declined to let Social-Democrat- ic women’s clubs enter the national as- sociation of women’s clubs, which she had founded after an American model. That Frl. Schmidt should have lived long enough to see old prejudices over- thrown in many directions, and to have won respectful obituaries even from her severest critics, is proof positive of the marked change in the status of women which has taken place in Germany with- in the last thirty, or even twenty years. Herself a teacher, it was her knowl edge of the difficulties besetting young women who desired to become really qualified instructors that first led Au- gusta Schmidt into movements de signed to benefit her countrywomen as a whole. With Frau Otto-Peters she founded, in 1865, the Leipzig society for the education of women. By 1890 she was able to take part in the establish ment of a national women teachers’ as- sociation, and in 1895 she became the first president of the League of German Women's Clubs, already referred to. In 1865 she was one of two or three German women to dare to speak in public. In 1902 she not only saw her cause warmly championed by the political party nu merically strongest in the Empire, but even heard the Minister of the Interior declare in the Reichstag that much must be done to widen the present industrial opportunities for women. Any one fa- miliar with the ordinary German atti tude towards women, and the intense feeling existing, ten or fifteen years ago, against those engaged in industrial pur- suits, must admit that Augusta Schmidt and her fellow-laborers expressed from the beginning a tendency and a move ment of the times which can no more be stayed by German conservatism than by French prejudice or American indiffer- ence. In her exhaustive study of the woman question recently published in Leipzig Frau Lily Braun has traced the growth of the movement of which Augusta Schmidt died the leader. The organiza tion of her countrywomen in clubs she finds as significant as the similar move ment in the United States has proved ta be. Since the state would not help in educating women, some of these women’s clubs undertook the task. The Lette- verein began this work in Berlin in 1866 with the aid of and under the direction of men. “We demand only that the arena of work be opened to women,” was the motto of Augusta Schmidt’s Leipzig society. It had among its members many, like Fanny Lewald-Stahr, who worked secretly to keep body and soul together “because it was not proper for women of her class to earn money.” They were not daunted by many indignant rebuffs when they applied for Government help in es- tablishing advanced schools for women teachers, or by the general condemnation of the learned classes. Their example wae rapidly followed in other parts of the empire, but it was not until well along in the eighties than an Englishwoman was able to establish the first high school for 107 women in Berlin, by the aid of the Lette verein and private generosity, together with the encouragement of the late Em press Frederick. By the end of the eighties the agitation for improved educational facilith 4 better organized, and becatr that from that time forward su tin victories were won Phe inive soon began to receive German wor but only as “guests.”” In 1893 were allowed to take the ffhal exami: tions at the Government boys’ sch called gymnasia. In many cities cou corresponding to those taught in gymnasia were established by p associations or by the municipal auth tic In two of the smaller cities were admitted to the boys’ scho Munich and Breslau then attempted to establish gymnasia for women, but th was too much for the Minister of Publ Instruction. He declared that he mu “put out this spark before it became a and Government devastating flame sanction for the undertaking promptly withheld. It mattered not Russia had already had such schools f{ thirty years, and that China wa } to establish one; int instance the f ward movement met check. But it Was only for a mom 1S99 women were admitted to th examinations in medicine and pharma Since then the German Cabine i working diligently to remove ev stacle in the path of women docto: Spite the fact that, when the first } bearing on this matter was presented to the Reichstag in ISG. it was deemed a revolutionary document, full of | tial American teaching a! of women, and not even a hearing granted. State examinations for } seeking places as Oberlehrerinnen (ad vanced teachers) were established at th Victoria Lyceum and the Humbo Academy in Berlin, and at the Unive of Gottingen. Most gratifying of however was the action of the Uni ties of Heidelberg and Freiburg in Bad: in admitting women to all the privileges pertaining to men Even in Germany the world has moved case with surprising suddenness, consid ering the conservativism of ecenturis ) be overcome, But the advocates of equa licationa! privileges for women are by no mea: content with these advances Cont ing them with what has been at plished elsewhere, Frau Braun fi progress slow and hesitating, | may seem to an outsider, and she state that in the industrial world there at few victories to rejoice ove Pher none the less, a great change in pub! sentiment to record. No one would have dreamed, twenty yea ag iat an im- perial minister would dare to ask great industrial openings for women, who out number the men in Germany by no k
Page 12
108 SS SEE than a million souls. Nor would any German prefessor have ventured in the eighties to declare publicly, as Professor Harnack did last May, that the woman’s educational movement is in every sense praiseworthy, and that the woman with- out a profession or occupation.is a dead weight in the community. He confident- ly expects an improvement in the morals of men and women, and better relations between the sexes, as a result of the changes now taking place. It must not be forgotten that the presence of hun- dreds, if not thousands, of cultured and attractive American women has helped to instil into German minds a higher ideal for womankind than that typified by the Hausfrau—too often a mere upper servant, whose ignorance renders men- tal companionship with husbands or sons an impossibility. A FRENCHMAN’S DIARY IN OUR CIVIL- WAR TIME.—IV. January 14, 1865.—With Commodore Drayton, visited the Navy-yard. In the evening, dined with Senator Sprague: Chase, Sumner, Agassiz, Dana, M. de Gerolt. Off for City Point, armed with a pass from Mr. Lincoln written wholly in his own hand. Arrived at the wharf of embarkation, in military occupation, I show my pass and go aboard the steamboat with numerous officers and some _ civilians—paymasters, army contractors. No civilian is allowed to take his baggage to his state-room—a precaution adopted against incendiaries, who might introduce combustibles. All the baggage is collected in a room guarded by a special officer. The boat puts out amid river ice. We have a view of the huge buildings of the Arsenal, the hay maga- zine, the hills crowned with forts. At every moment boats cross our course, Everything with an engine has been requisitioned, even to old ferry-boats. We stop at Alexandria to take on conva- lescent soldiers returning to the army; on the wharf, quite a population of black stevedores. Proceeding, we perceive the white walls of Mt. Vernon, behind the trees of the promontory. State-rooms were al- lotted after leaving Alexandria. A young colonel of the 130th New York obligingly procures one for me. He belongs in Tro- briand’s brigade and praises his chief high- ly. The morale of the army is excellent. Since Grant interdicted whiskey, there has been no more drunkenness, and few punish- ments are necessary. I scrape acquaintance with a big, square-headed German with gray moustaches, a revolutionary Forty-eighter from Hesse-Darmstadt. He is an officer of engineers, and kindly sketches for me the lines before Richmond—three front lines protected by forts, a rear line like- wise protected. The army is camped in this gigantic gut. In the evening the pilot perceives a great fire which is for a moment taken to be a burning steamer, but turns out to be a house. In the morning I woke not far from Fortress Monroe, the most important on the coast. On the tiny island, the Rip- Raps, facing it, a large stone fort is in process of construction to command the entrance to Chesapeake Bay. We enter the The Nation. [Vol. 75, No. 1936 vast Hampton Roads. At Newport News is visible on the beach the skeleton of the Congress, sunk by the Merrimac in its con- test with the Monitor; further on, some remains of the Oumberland, which went down in the same fight. We pass near the Florida, a Confederate pirate, whose two canting masts are almost wholly out of wa- ter. The air is very mild. The broad and lazy river James flows between wooded banks. We cross the bar, meeting some transport constantly. Curious types of of- ficers—a few foreign veterans; youngsters silent and thoughtful; old heads, bronzed, fagged, gaunt, with shaggy beards and hair; no apparent hierarchy. For a detail of cos- tume: each officer wears the characteristic badge of his corps d’armée.—Fort Powha- tan, dominating the plain reached by Grant’s army after his bloody campaign across Virginia. From there the army threw itself upon Petersburg.—Deserted planta- tions of the Wilcoxes, the Seldons (whose house was built two centuries ago of Eng- lish brick), the Harrisons. At Harrison’s Landing one may still see traces of the camps in which the Army of the Potomac was shut up for two months.—At last, City Point, announced by a forest of masts. We draw near amid a fleet of schooners, trans- ports, and tugboats. Improvised wooden structures line the levee. A railroad built on the muddy slope of the stream appears. I exhibit my pass and am directed to headquarters, which overlooks the harbor and is indicated by a large stars-and- stripes. I am taken to the Office, a log cabin consisting of but a single room. Lt. Col. Bowers reads Charles Sumner’s letter to Grant brought by me, and examines my pass in Lincoln's handwriting. He tells me the General is ill, but he himself is en- tirely at my disposal. As there is no empty tent to-day for night occupation, I must sleep at the hotel, a big wooden affair run up in several days. Walked about the camp and came upon a black regiment. Dined with the officers of the General Staff; a short and silent meal. At the Office in the evening. The next day I set off by rail, Col. Bowers giving me a young officer named Porter to accompany me to Meade’s headquarters. We traverse great woods, at this moment given over to remorseless choppers. Meade Station—Hancock Station—Parke Station; before us is Meade’s flag, at the top of a small knoll, I seek Gen. Hunt, chief of artillery, who breakfasts me and takes me to the lines. Visit Fort Wadsworth, Fort Wilcox, situated on the extreme left, whence we perceive the line of Federal pickets marked by smoke; beyond, the line of Confederate pickets; and still beyond, a Confederate fort. Visited the Federal plek- ets. At present there is a tacit truce. We see distinctly the Confederate sentinels pacing deliberately, gun under arm. We examine them at our leisure with a fleld-glass; we might talk with them if we raised our voices slightly. During such truces the pickets of the two camps com- municate with one another, in spite of their officers’ orders. They exchange coffee for tobacco, New York papers for Richmond. I chat a moment with a group of German pickets, who téll me, laughing, that a mo- ment before our arrival some Confederates had gone for wood to a thicket where the Federals were cutting, and had retired without being molested, The Johnnies and the Yankees are almost friends at this ex- treme limit where the armies are closest together. The General is disturbed only by the new Confederate fort, which is go- ing up in a good position, and intends to mount guns of heavier calibre in Fort Walsh. I bid adieu in German to the soldiers wila whom I have been talking, and we return to headquarters. Smoke hangs over the c:mp and fills the aisles of the pine forest. Dus- tant drums, military brass, galloping stecds, braying mules, lowing cattle in their pens, fill the air with strange sounds. Nigbt falls. The tent-lights, the sparkling smoke, spot here and there the illimitable pitchy background. We dine in the tent. After a modest repast, Gen. Hunt conducts me to Gen. Meade’s wooden house. I see a tall, lean-faced man, with gray beard, retreat- ing and bald forehead, large nose suggesting a bird of prey, a face without much char- acter. The General himself accompanies me back to the station through the quagmire. In default of passenger-coaches, I return to headquarters in a baggage-car in com- pany with a German officer of the topo- graphic service. I spend some time at headquarters. Tle General Staff is very small, and its work enormous, yet done methodically and with- out fuss. An Indian colonel, with the copper color of the Redskins, is one of the workers. On the eve of my departure, Grant, hitherto silent, asks me to walk wilh him after dinner. He talks of Sumner, who had given me a letter to him, and expresses his sympathy for him, his policy, and his character. He speaks of Lincoln with equal respect and sympathy. He hopes the war will end with the capture of Richmond. Slavery will not survive the war. His language is simple, frank, decided, stripped of all ornament and artifice. I wes in- finiiely touched by this confidence. In Washington once more. Dined at Sea- ator Morgan’s with Mr. Seward, his daugh- ter-in-law, Secretary Welles and his wife, Postmaster-General Denison, Charles Sum- ner, Admiral and Mrs. Farragut. A very sumptuous dinner; Seward very lively, very chatty, as usual. It would be difficult to say against which he is most incensed for their attitude towards the United States, Eng- land or Napoleon III. January 25.—From Washington to New York. Called on General Scott; fine and imposing face, and a very grand air. He has just published memoirs. In the eve- ning saw Booth as Hamlet, the best acting of the part I have ever seen: a Dantesque, poetic face, no little grace of movement. He represents a simulated madness, and very happily accentuates the incoherences, oddities, the distraught and unconscious side of the réle. Went with Bancroft to Bierstadt’s studio (he is the landscape painter of the Rocky Mountains and the Yosemite Valley), and to that of Church, more poetic, very much of a colorist, an imitator of Turner. Amer- ican landscape painters seek the grand ra- ther than the humble, the fantastic rather than the simple. January 30.—Weymouth. Extracts from a letter of this date to the Duc d’Aumale. ‘“Monseigneur—I send you a little draw- ing which will explain to you better than many words the result of my visit to the Army of the James. . . . “Neither shall I undertake to describe
Page 13
ee ae LO ty Hie al aa aK 4 a a 2 Bs i Aug. 7, 1902] camp life to one who knows it better than anybody. The little I saw of it left agreeable impressions. I am grieved to say that I found in all grades of the Army (I except Grant and Meade, who are not very communicative) great irritation England. Perhaps as great France, but out of politeness was conceal- ed from me. I recall among others a young officer from Vermont, me from City Point to Washington, saying, ‘I have served my time out: I have three years in the army, and been in fifty eight engagements or battles. I have done my duty, but I do not like war. What I have done, I have done because my country needs soldiers. I am glad to return to my family and business, and I hope never again to draw the sword. But, sir, if war were declared against England, were it ten years hence, or twenty, I would not wait a day to enter a regiment, as a private if need be.’ “Such is the feeling. I do not discuss it, I simply relate. It is this that renders very difficult the work of Sumner and Sew- ard, who are truly friends of peace. Nev- ertheless, I have not much faith in the breaking out of war between America and England. The latter country can re- trace her steps in time; but every day I grow more apprehensive lest the Mexican affair should drag ourselves into war with the United States. I believe that the American question and the Mexican ques- tion are destined to become one of the principal battle-grounds of the French Op- position. It would truly be too unfor- tunate if some day, through the Empe- ror’s fault, it should be our lot to bear the cost of a war with the United States, after having lost the opportunity of con- quering, without drawing the sword and by a few simple words of sympathy, a pre- cious alliance. The grand policy which governs us and whose profound combi- nations are so much admired, is quite ca- pable eventually of converting traditional sympathy, already chilled by its fault, into sentiments of genuine hostility. Who is to profit by this policy inspired by the simple necessity of doing something diffe- rent from what old France did? Russia, who alone had the sense to declare her friendship for the United States without making the least sacrifice; and England, who will be charmed to see America’s flood of wrath and bitterness diverted from her- self, and to whom, in case of war between the United States and France, will fall the world’s commerce and the decision of all the great questions relating to the law of nations. “Unfortunately there is nobody in France to say all this. No one there has yet com- prehended the immense scope of the war and of the revolution in the United States. We Parisians prefer the geography of Schleswig-Holstein to that of a vast con- tinent in which Schleswig-Holstein would be but a fly-speck. A great minister like Richelieu or Cavour would have done everything to assure the friendship of the United States. Old World affairs have found lodgment in those of the New World, and will never be absolutely detached from them. America has felt her strength, and will want to make use of it like the bird that feels its wings. We ought to have held ourselves in readiness to profit by this new force, material as well as moral.” only against exists against who returned with been believe I The Nation. Meeting at Music Hall, in which Garrison proclaims his con- fidence in Lincoln. He will not, like Wen- dell Phillips, make the question of negra suffrage a weapon against the Government. The right of suffrage is not a natural right. The black man once liberated, the task of an end; the social place of the freedmen in the United States will be determined by manifold considera- tions over which the abolitionists have na control. Gen. Butler, who succeeded Garri- son, pleaded at length in favor of the politi. cal equality of the two races. His delivery was pompous and vulgar. Butler was re- lieved from command of the Army of the James. He is almost tragtorous in his at- tacks on Grant and Sherman. Weymouth.—The Universalist Church of this town has for pastor a woman, the Rev. Olympia Brown, who studied theology at Oberlin College (Ohio). The church edifice is small and of wood, and looks like a lecture-room. Miss Brown occupies a plat- form at the far end of the hall. Her dress is black and she has no ornament in her hair. Pale and thin, her face has distinc- tion. After the singing of a hymn, she of- fered prayer, followed by another hymn. She then read her discourse, her one theme being the amendment of the Constitution. This great change has been due not to the war, for war has no liberal action, but to God, to the action of immutable laws. All this was very well phrased, in a firm voice and refined manner. The audience were serious; some of the women wept when the speaker referred to the victims of the war. What especially pleased me in the sermon was that it had a genuine religious accent, and did not appear to have been patterned upon newspaper articles. After the closing hymn, Miss Brown an- nounced to her congregation a temperance meeting to be held shortly. Then, to my great surprise, she remarked that, one of the members of the congregation having asked for some particulars about a French philosopher, Diderot, of whom she had re- cently spoken, she would put at his dispos- al a book from her library. Finally, sh gave notice that, at the afternoon service, she would, by the request of several per- sons, preach on the belief in hell. February 4.— Boston. the abolitionists is at February 14.—James Russell Lowell came to spend the day with us at Weymouth. He is witty, and not stingy of his wit. He spoke much of England; he loves her, for is she not “the old country’’? Politically, he is a decided partisan of the present Ad- ministration. He considers Lincoln to be a superior man, whose glory will equal Wash- ington’s. He began to appreciate him af- ter the speech at Gettysburg. Lowell is greatly attached to the memory of Clough, a dreamy spirit, disquieted and poetic, who passed a year at Cambridge, Mass. I met Lowell again at the Atlantic Club, where we dined with Longfellow, Holmes, Agassiz, Governor Andrew, E, P. Whipple. It was very diverting. Holmes related his impressions as a lecturer: “When I go from place to place, I seem to be constantly meeting the same public everywhere. It is a sort of multivertebrate animal, a serpent that comes every eve- uncoil itself at my feet, looks at me and listens, ready to devour me. The hardest moments for lecturers are tose spent in waiting for belated traias. Often, in some out-of-the-way etation, in bitter ning to “109 cold, we wait and listen the slifahteat noises become perceptible—not ily =the far-off snapping of a branch uuler the weight of snow. but the subjective sounds of the human organs. Sight undergo ex altation as well as hearing; the stars seem to grow bigger At last the socomotive draws bear, the train arrives; we jump on the car platform—the vividest image of salvation.” George William Curtis, one of the most lecturers, went to a of New York ty differences they popular once ia the State In view of par- begged him not to talk nothing in realiness Nodody in read one of his on politics He had except a lecture on Thackeray the audience had novels Curtis’s allusions and criticism fell upon the void At the close of the iecture, the chief personages came to greet hin. “Mr: Curtis,” said the schoolmaster, ‘“‘you uiust bring about an agreement among us wo one point. For a week here we have been disputing over Longfellow, whether he is dead or isn’t dead.” “I dined with him,” answered Curtis, ‘‘a fortnight ago.’ A‘,”° said the schoolmaster, visibly disappoint- ed; then, presently: “Anyhow, I'm sure somebody is dead."’ Farewell supper at Norton's in Cam bridge, with Longfellow, Lowell, and Child. Attended a philosophical of William R Mrs. Howe titled, “Limitations,” soirée at the Lcuse Alger, a Unitarian clergyman read an essay en second in a series she is about to publish. The next day [ dined with her and her oldest daughter, a charni- ing young person. AUGUSTE LAUGEL, THE STATUS OF HISTORY IN SOUTHERN EDUCATION. RANDOLPH-MACON COLLEGE, VA., July, 1902. One would naturally expect a keen ap- preciation of historical studies on the part Nowhere in the Union is there such tenacious reverence for the past and its traditions, nowhere els¢ make the section a of Southerners. does each individual so readily history of his State or personal matter Yet there is no section of the country in which both local and national history is so little studied stood. To be writers and but the pleaders, and the text-books are dependent on books writter at the North, pot on in- I pro- and so imperfectly under- there are Southern text-books, main sure, strictly Southern writers are in the special vestigation of the sources at hand. pose to inquire briefly into the causes of this backwardness. The ruling classes of society are usually responsible for the kind of training the young receive, and this applies particularly to collegiate training. Education is direct- ed from above, since the teachers in gen- eral take into the lower schools the ideas prevalent at the higher. For this reason the status of history in colleges will re- ceive my principal attention. The Southern college is modelled after the University of Virginia; add Thomas Jefferson oracle of that institution. His education was versatility rather Than mastery; so the curriculum of his great high-school was arranged accord- ing to the humanist ideals of the sixteenth century, #4. ¢., with Latin, Greek, mathe- was the idea of favorable to
Page 14
110 The Nation. [Vol. 75, No. 1936 matics, and philosophy as the four founda- tion-pillars of learning. The sciences, both natural and social, were made adjunct to these, or at least secondary. The subjects of study for a Roman youth of the early Imperial period were made the principal subjects of study in Virginia eighteen hun- dred years later. All that the world had learned during the long interval of time, all it had experienced, was of but secondary importance. As this university grew, the idea of a universal knowledge for the young student gained constantly in the minds of Jefferson’s successors. The Master’s degree soon came to mean the completion of all the studies offered there, and not special ex- cellence in a single group. As Jefferson anticipated, the youth of the land, more particularly Southerners, ‘‘flock- ed to the Virginia fountain.’’ They re-. turned home feeling that education meant the ability to scan a line of Latin and ren- der into fair English a Greek play. And the class of men who went to the Virginia University were those who built up other schools, who controlled the politics of the South. But, parallel to this influence in education, another had grown up and was quite powerful during the fourth and fifth decades of the last century, when the two coalesced, so far as educational policy was concerned. It was the party of Christian education, reinforced by the success of similar teaching at the North, especially in New England. The Presbyterians, the Baptists, and Methodists all agreed be- fore 1830 on the policy of an educated clergy. And so (in Virginia) Randolph- Macon, Richmond, Emory and Henry, (in North Carolina) Wake Forest and David- son Colleges, were established during the years 1830-40. A little later (in South Car- olina and Georgia) Furman and Mercer Uni- versities were opened. All these schools adopted outright the policy of the Univer- sity of Virginia, with the exception that philosophy was modified so as to serve the ends of Christian education. As _ history had only a secondary place at the Univer- sity of Virginia, it likewise received little attention at the younger institutions. In a few instances there were older institutions which had acquired considerable influence before Jefferson’s university was estab- lished. The College of Charleston, South Carolina; Hampden-Sydney and William and Mary, in Virginia; the University of North Carolina, and Franklin College, in Georgia, were the most important. None of these had ever given any systematic courses of instruction in history, and there was little change necessary when, about 1830, they readjusted their curricula, owing to the guecess of the great institution at Charlottesville, Va. It was not until after the civil war that any break in the ranks of the college quad- rivium was made; and this was done by Prof. Thomas R. Price, now of Columbia University, New York. He succeeded in getting the first chair of English in the South established in Randolph-Macon Col- lege, and from this high-grade denomina- tional school the University of Virginia se- cured its first professor of English. Grad- ually the other Southern schools followed suit. This gave the college five culture (or disciplinary) courses, and these compose to-day almost the entire work of the Southern college student. The conservative forces of nearly all our educational insti- tutions deny positively that any other sub- ject has anything like the culture value of one of these. It will be asked, Did not his- tory form any part of the training given by the colleges? It did. The University of Virginia required its language profes- sors to teach the history of the people whose language was being studied. Hence arose the custom of associating the his- tory of Greece with the Greek language, the history of Rome with Latin, and so on with France and Germany. And, as has been seen, what ‘Virginia’ did, the other colleges imitated. About 1880, Johas-Hopkins University es- tablished the department of historical and political science, with Herbert B. Adams at its head. In a few years graduates of this institution began to clamor for the crea- tion of chairs of history; and in 1892 Trin- ity College, North Carolina, then under the control of an able Northern man, President Crowell, yielded to the demand, and the first independenf department of history in the South was established. This new depart- ment immediately showed signs of great vitality, and history soon commanded a place beside Latin as an educative subject. From the beginning Trinity College has led in the scientific study of history in North Carolina, and in some respects in the whole South. The department has never been wanting in students. Such an object-lesson could not long re- main without influence, especially since the Johns Hopkins continued to send out many well-equipped students ready, like mission- aries, to undertake and push forward the study of their chosen subject. The State universities, the denominational and techni- cal colleges—the most important of them— have established chairs of history, though in most instances combining with history some other subject, such as economics or sociology. But even now, in nearly all first- rate colleges, history is not accorded full rank as a culture subject. It is given toa teacher who as often as otherwise makes some other subject his specialty, which, of course, practically destroys the so-called less important course. Again, the college president who has some spare time from administrative duties is often given the department of history. To illustrate the in- significance of the subject as viewed by some college trustees, one of the largest denominational schools in the South has just given its professor of Latin the new de- partment of history, and, in order the bet- ter to advertise their indifference, the Trus- tees elected a specialist in history to the chair of English! But this is not general. A spirit of advance is to be found in the most progressive institutions. Yet the status of these departments, rela- tive to others—such, for example, as Latin or Greek—is not satisfactory. For the A. B. degree the humanities have the right of way. History, as shown by the catalogues of a large number of Southern colleges, is required for this course (1) in the univer- sities, three hours a week for one colle- giate year—-a course which gives only the outlines of general history, beginning with the early Greeks and closing with the year 1789; (2) in the high-grade denominational colleges, three to five hours a week, the same sort of instruction. In the technical schools, neither \in Virginia nor in North Carolina, is any knowledge of history, either European or American, required. Georgia and the States further south gen- erally require from three to five hours a week in American and English history for the B. S. degree. In the largest universi- ties, in the courses looking to the Master’s degree, three additional hours are required if history is one of the elected subjects; and the same holds for the denominational colleges. In the technical schools there is seldom any demand for other than the pri- mary work done in the same schools for the B. S. As for highly specialized study in particular fields of history, the University of Texas alone makes any creditable show- ing. As to the number of men teaching his- tory, only two universities employ more than one man; and some institutions having from six to eleven hundred students enrol- led, and enjoying incomes of from seventy- five to one hundred thousand dollars a year, have no need for more than one man! The number of students who take history even in preparing for the law is amazingly small, which indicates the nature of the work done; and as for becoming specialists, one seldom finds a young man so visionary. Why the study has found such tardy rec- ognition, and why it is even now opposed most persistently, is a question which natu- rally arises. I shall attempt to give two or three answers in explanation: (1.) It was the influence of the humanist tcachers in the early part of the last cen- tury, when Southern life was being fixed in certain grooves. Southerners are the most conservative people in the United States; and when a certain kind of training has come, whether reasonably or not, to be recognized as part of a gentleman’s education, any change at all is the same as an attack on the existing order of things. It is this sheer conservatism in favor of the classics in the first instance that causes Southerners to neglect the study of history, even of their own section. (2.) Another cause is the complete change of all economic conditions in the South since 1865, which has revolutionized society in general, and which has turned backward the tide of intellectual advance. In i880 the percentage of illiterate whites in the South was not so great as it is to-day! So there is no great demand for development in intellectual matters. Few teachers of his- tory are required in the secondary and high schools. A large number of those who at- tend colleges everywhere expect to devote their lives to teaching. They study what niust be taught again—that is, the more conservative subjects. And, again, as a re- sult of the upheaval of 1865, the wealth of the country has changed hands, and it is too soon for the owners of this wealth to be so cultured as to care for a liberal educa- tion for their so0ns—and history must always be more or Icss of a culture study, a study for people who bave leisure. (3.) The last explanation is the condition of public opinion. Notwithstanding the rad- ical changes which have taken place, public scutiment has been and is still controlled by men who were either participants in the great Civil War or whose fathers were. This public opinion positively demands that teachers of history, both in the colleges and in the high schools, shall subscribe unre- servedly totwotriteoaths: (1) that the South was altogether right in seceding from the Union in 1861; and (2) that the war was not waged about the negro. No investigation, ‘ g ? BE ui Retr
Page 15
Aug. 7, 1902] no honest unbiassed work can ever be hoped for when such a confession of faith is made a sine qua non of fitness for teaching or writing history. To illustrate this, I have but to cite the case of a fine old gentleman of ante-bellum antecedents, a member of a good family, whose knowledge of history consists in having memorized the standard texts of some twenty years ago. This gen- tleman is professor of history in one of the largest State universities in the South. On a vacation ramble about a year ago the writer happened into his lecture-room, and learned from a well-worn copy of Oman's ‘History of England,’ and from some students who still lingered about the classic walls, that this single text con- stituted the whole work of the senior his- tory class in that college! On the margins of the pages were recorded in very small characters the stock stories and jokes doled out to patient students from year to year The text was repeatedly marked, ‘Tell jokes No. 1, or No. 2, at this point.’ What is it that keeps scores of such good old gentlemen at the heads of the most im- portant departments of study in South- ern schools? Clearly, a public sentiment which taboos the most vital subject in American history, a sentiment which mands from every one a full justification of the South in all its past history. Behind these men is the individual influence of the Confederate veterans, who, having once had a share in making history, now demand that their views of its teaching and writing shall be everywhere accepted. They meet togeth- er in great assemblies, and, without critical knowledge or even careful examination of the books used in schools and colleges, make out a list of authors whose works may be used. It is not difficult to say what class of writers are commended. Next to the Confederate soldier’s influ- ence in retarding the advance of true his- torical studies is that of the Southern pub- lisher, who makes capital of the so-called patriotic sentiment. He feels the pulse of the Confederate veteran and takes the mea- sure of the reviewer, who is usually of the accepted type, and then publishes his Southern text-books. The representative of the largest publishing-house in the South recently refused so much as to read the manuscript of a piece of investigation in Southern history, though posing all the while as the champion of Southern history- writing, its very Mecenas. It will be seen that, under such condi- tions, no healthy criticism can exist. The results of investigation are fixed for an author before his work begins. The tence of the reviewer is likewise dictated by an uncompromising public dogmatism. These, then, are some of the conditions which check the development of scholar- ship, which prevent the higher institutions of learning from taking their rightful stand, and which seriously retard the educational and intellectual advance of the South. They are natural conditions, to sure—con- ditions which, until recent years, prevailed at the North, but which, as is indicated by the discussion of the recent proposition of Charles Francis Adams to erect a monu- ment in Washington to R. E. Lee, are fast disappearing, and it is to be hoped they are also passing away in our section. In truth, healthy~ beginnings are made at many points. In every Southern State there are honest and able young stu- de- sen- be being The Nation. dents who are beginning to address them- selves to the task of writing in true charac- ters the history of their sections who are becoming authors of books which require no recommendation, and which find publishers in any part of the country. In South Carolina a great scholar is giving to students the public a history of that State in the Revolution which compares favorably with similar work produced t American in Alabama there arisen a small coterie of competent critics ever any y an writer; has who, by the aid which the State is freely giving, promise much for that part of the country; in Texas, at its great University, in North Carolina and Tennessee, magazines of history and biography are doing pioneer, almost missionary, work in their fields. So it is not altogether an unpromising future which we face. And present two movements of origin which brighten still more the promise of the future. These are the educational revo- lution of which the Ogden Association is a part, and the campaign, best illustrated in North Carolina, the establishment of rural and town libraries. In North Carolina about five hundred small established last An public may be influenced and a reading pub- lic may be convinced. May not these be- ginnings be the harbingers of intellectual emancipation, of independent literary pro- duction? WM. E. Dopp. there are at quite recent for alone libraries were year. educated Correspondence. THE ATLANTIC FISHERY AND PROTEC- TION. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: It is one the most remarkable anomalies of the twentieth century that the two leading republics of the world, France and the United States, the that boast the loudest of should be each distinguished for their ad- hesion to an absurd antiquated system of of two countries their freedom, protection, which utterly disregards the true interests of the people, and is dictated sole- ly by a ring of monopolists for their own selfish ends. Take, for instance, the ques tion of a drawback on Cuban sugar. Every motive of national honor and sound policy demanded liberal treatment for the south ern island by her great bor and protector, yet, notwithstanding President Roosevelt's stir- republican neigh as we have seen, ring words, American good faith, the repu tation and character of a great country, was to be trampled in the and brought into contempt before the whole world sim ply to protect the beet-sugar monopolists. When we come to look into the workings of protection in both France and the United States, the plain man finds absurdities and dust monstrosities worthy of the grotesque poli tics of Laputa. France easily leads the van. Here in North America the ernment, in order to keep up a fishery in Newfoundland, gives (1) a bounty exceed ing the intrinsic of the fish; drawback quite equal to the bounty; (3) 50 national Gov value (2) a frances a head for every one engaged in the fishery, plus 50 francs per fisherman given by the Municipal Coun ell St. Pierre for every Frenchman en gaged the Newfoundland (4) a bounty of 4,000 frances distributed among her transatlantic more of on coast; 111 shore fishermen. Outside the cost of thre« expensive war-ships, Fran pays $240 per man for every one of her at bjects engaged in this trade. ‘ The follies and utter absurdities of pro tection could hardly go further. But when we come to examine the American policy of excluding foreign fish, and preventing tt public from obtaining this most necessary and valuabk 1 food at reasonab! can perceive that their system is just a absurd, and as mischievou the high tax on a necess logical, as the France A nation as ridiculous methods of ary artick of food which amounts to an actual prohi bition of its free consumption by the public, is a burden which no free people should suffer. The English people would not bear it for a moment. The Americans are a pa tient people they suffer the monopolists gladly who plunder them on fuel and light the Meat Trust stirred This price of Only odious seems to have outrageous attemp*t food their point with the them the up to raise touched tomachs, a tender great re public Has it ever occurred to the citizens of this great nation that, for a century, they have been burdened with a tyrannical mo nopoly in their food supply as grievous as the attempted Meat Trust? There is not a shred of an argument of any kind in favor of the fish monopoly It used to be claimed that it manned the national navy. The of ficial naval experts have completely explod ed this idea. The men protected are not even Americans; by far the greater portion of the deep-sea fishermen are provincials and foreigners. To aid this motley alien crew and the fish rings, all Americans have to eat dear fish The toiling millions of Europe could not exist without eating cheap fish food. Take uch a common product of the sea as the herring; all over England and the Conti- nent its cost is two cent or three for five cents. In the States a single herring costs five cents, or three times the price at which the English workman enjoy his bloater What makes all thi Oo monstrous and ab- surd is the ridiculously small number of people, a few hundred, who benefit by this protection to their petty trade, in compari son with the venty millions who have pay for the monopoly. The American dee; ea fishery to-day is a poor decaying indu try It is not even American, and a con siderable portion of its product is not even caught by American It does not furnish one-fourth of the supply of sea fish which should be consumed in the same proportion as in Europe The policy of the American Government in dealing with this vital question of the Atlantic fishery, for a great nation, has been contemptible in the extreme They isk in the meanest way every favor from their smaller British neighbors, but they will give nothing in return. It is thorough ly well known that, without free access to the Newfoundland bait, the Bank fishery could not be carried on by the American fishermen It is also officially reported the revenue officer th th »-called “American industry the winter frozen herring business, i a giganti fraud Brought in free as “‘American products there is not one thing American about the whole business except the Yankee gold that pays for the fish All are caught and frozen by the English residents What I have pointed out in former papers on thig
Page 16
[Vol. 75, No. 1936 —_ subject is not only the cruel absurdity of a tax on food in the twentieth century; in this special case the monopoly acts as an actual barrier to the public supply of most valuable sustenance. If these barriers were thrown down, British North America could furnish the States with an abundance and variety of cheap fish, as full and ample as England now enjoys. Sir John A. McDonald always maintained that there was nothing to expect from the liberality or enlightenment of the Ameri- can Government. Their dealings with Brit- ish America were always a compound of ar- rogance and selfish meanness, as_ short- sighted as contemptible. It is now cer- tain that this peddling policy in regard to the fisheries will be checkmated in a thoroughly effective way. The union of Canada with Newfoundland is a foregone conclusion. The island colony is even now making the American fishermen pay a fixed price for his bait, besides a big fee for his license. When the Dominion obtains con- trol of all the British fisheries, the Ameri- cans will be simply at their mercy. The Newfoundland bait supply, on which they depend, will either be prohibited altogeth- er, or else made too dear to be purchased. Gloucester has already sounded the note of alarm, and sees a reciprocity treaty loom- ing in the distance. What will the Ameri- can Government do in these circumstances? Will it wait until free trade is forced upon them, or gracefully accept the inevitable? D. W. PROWSE. Sr. JOHNS, NEWFOUNDLAND, July 28, 1902. CONGRESSIONAL ENCOUNTERS, NEW AND OLD. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: In looking through some old num- bers of Charles Dickens’s magazine, House- hold Words, I chanced upon a paragraph or two that might well be republished—with- out comment—to-day. In No. 330, under the title, ‘‘The Congressional Prize Ring,’”’ comment is made upon the then recent as- sault of Preston 8S. Brooks of South Carolina upon Charles Sumner of Massachusetts in the Senate on the 22d of May, 1856. As cer- tain events and casualties of the session of 1902 are fresh in interest, it may be edify- ing to print the following quotation: “The forcible mode in which debates are conducted in the parliament of the United States, and the personal encounters which sometimes follow them, are believed by the present generation to be novelties and only recently brought to a culminating point by the Hon. Preston 8S. Brooks’s life- preserver upon the head, face, eyes, and body of Senator Charles Sumner. This is a mistake. Fifty years ago, exciting de- bates often ended in a regular stand-up fight in the lobby of the House of Repre- sentatives. The combatants stripped, a ring was formed, bottle-holders appointed, and the latter fought and reported quite in the style of Moulsey Hurst and Bell's Life in London. “In corroboration of this statement, we present to our readers the following par- agraph copied from the New York Hvening Post of December the thirteenth, eighteen hundred and five, into the Annual Register for eighteen hundred and aix: = ‘On Friday last, the well-known Leib, one of the Representatives of Pennsylvania and leader of the Duane party, and Joseph H. Nicholson, one of the Representatives of Mary- land, met in the Congress lobby about one o'clock, when Leib immediately called Nichol- eon a liar; and thereupon commenced one of The Nation. the best-fought battles recorded in the annals of Congressional pugilism. The fight continued till the sixty-fourth round, when Leib had re- ce:ved such blows as deterred him from again facing his man. He protracted the fight, falling after making a feeble hit. In the round which ended the fight, those who backed him advised him to resign; which he did after a combat of one hour and seventeen minutes. The com- batants were both very much beaten.’ ”’ ALBERT C. PHELPS. NEw ORLEANS, July 22, 1902. NICE DISTINCTIONS. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: The War Department acknowledges receipt of a report relative to the action taken by Gen. Chaffee in the case of Lieut. Lytle Brown of the Engineer Corps, U, S. A., who was recently tried for assault and battery on Charles O. Ziegenfuss, a citizen of Manila. It appears from the testimony that Lieut. Brown took offence at an article in the paper conducted by Ziegenfuss, and, in consequence thereof, proceeded to the latter’s house one night, and ‘“‘did then and there unlawfully, wilfully, and maliciously assault said Ziegenfuss by striking him with his, the said Brown’s, clinched fist, and the said Brown did then and there otherwise beat, bruise, wound, and illtreat the said Ziegenfuss, knocking out two teeth of him the said Ziegenfuss. Said Brown did kick and jump upon the said Ziegenfuss with the feet of him, the said Brown, and did cause him, the said Ziegenfuss, to suffer great bodily pain and anguish.”’ So the charges and specifications read. That which seems incomprehensible, to the ordinary mind, at this distance, is the principle upon which army officers base their code of honor. Lieut. Brown was found guilty of the charge of assault and battery and sentenced to be “‘reprimanded.”’ Of the second charge, of “conduct unbecom- ing an officer and a gentleman,” in connec- tion with the same offence, he was found not guilty. It is presumed from the finding of the court that nothing less than the kill- ing of the said citizen would be regarded by it as unbecoming an officer, and such killing, in truth, would not—in the section of the country south of here from which Lieut. Brown undoubtedly hails—be regard- ed as unbecoming a gentleman. On the other hand, suppose it had been a private soldier who, smarting under ad- verse criticism, had at night entered the house of a citizen and comported himself in the same manner as that of his superior of- ficer, would the court-martial have been satisfied with imposing the farce of a “reprimand”? We are of the opinion that, under the circumstances narrated, the law- breaker would have been turned over to the civil authorities and would have had to ex- piate his offence by a goodly number of months in jail, suffer the loss of pay and emoluments, and thereafter -dishonorably be discharged the service. Privileges and distinctions of this nature can hardly be regarded as conducive to good order and military discipline. VETERAN. THE WASHINGTON-JEFFERSON LET- TERS. To THE Epitor OF THE NATION: Sir: It has been known that, after Wash- ington’s death, Tobias Lear permitted Al- exander Hamilton to withdraw from his papers certain letters and documents. It was also rumored that Jefferson enjoyed the same privilege and used it to destroy all evidence of an interchange of caustic letters between Washington and himself. At intervals this rumor reappears, with variations and embroideries, and has al- most attained the dignity of an historical fact. It is always difficult to treat such elusive matter, for the evidence support- ing it is, as a rule, mere hearsay evidence, and yet is attributed to such sources as give it every semblance of truth. It was with pleasure that I found what is per- haps the earliest evidence in writing upon this Jefferson-Washington correspondence. Whatever Custis may have been, he was not a reliable witness on any question concerning his guardian. Weak of will, and possessed of an inordinate vanity,with- out real ability in amy one line, and de- pending for his position and reputation on his connection with Washington, he bab- bled and romanced to any one who would listen to him. The solemn assertions in this letter, written to a kinsman, are ludi- crous when examined according to the sim- plest rules of evidence. His promise of a more definite account in his volume on Washington was not kept, for that work is even less full and satisfactory on this point than the letter. In 1854, the chapter as it appears in the memoirs was printed in the National Intelligencer. The editor published a short note from Custis, in which he said: “The story of the Lost Letters of the Rawlins Book I have put off to the last. It is a painful subject to me, but it was a bounden duty upon me, as Washington’s Biographer and the last of his domestic family, to place this matter in the only light in which it can ever appear to the world.”’ The famous letter of Jefferson to Mazzei was first published in Italy, at Florence; a translation into French appeared in the Moniteur, and from that paper it was translated into English for the Minerva, the Federalist paper at New York, in which it was printed May 14, 1797. So far as is known, no letter passed between Washington and Jefferson after that date. There was too much to be explained on Jefferson’s side, and too great sensitive- ness and dignity on the part of Washing- ton to make even an inquiry or explanation likely. I was unable to find any evidence in Washington’s letter-books of mutila- tion, and am quite familiar with the books in Rawlins’s writing. Now that we have what is intended to be the solemn testi- mony of one who always claimed to be in possession of the facts of the matter, it is safe to reject the whole story. The nar- rative of Custis is almost childish in its simplicity, but that is the least of its many weaknesses. He believed his own story, but his own evidence is against him. WORTHINGTON C. FORD. Boston, July 24, 1902. Arlington House, Oct 8" 1832, My D* Sir Your very interesting Letter of the 25th ult* came duly to hand. Cholera among my people, and myself much indisposed, must plead my excuse for the too long delayed answer. I have a most vivid recollection of all that happened at Mount Vernon, touching certain Letters supposed to have passed between Gen- eral Washington, & Mr. Jefferson, subsequent to the famed Letter Ww Mazzei. All the details sey Py LR Ys ea aR
Page 17
Aug. 7, 1902] Nation. you have given of the conversations {n the sitting Room, &c., are correct. As relates to myself, over & above my share in the general conversation, I have to observe that Colo. Lear called me into the Hall, and pressing my hand affectionately, remarked with emphasis—-The gentlemen are mistaken, I tell you my Dear Washington. THere Were Letters. He then retired, without entering into explanations re- specting the character or tendency of the letters he had thus solemnly declared to have passed be- tween the parties. Some time afterwards Colo. Lear visited me at Arlington House, previous to his journey to Boston, for embarkation to Algiers. I re- newed the subject of the Letters, and pressed the Colo. to enter into the necessary explana- tions as a mean of healing the breach which had occurred between himself, Dr. Craik, & other of the friends & relatives of Washing- ton. He complained sorely of the coolness, which he had experienced from those with whom he had been in long years of friendship & intimacy, prior to the conversation at Mt. Vernon; declined saying further on the subject of the Letters, but promised that he would write to me on his arrival at Boston. He wrote, but it was simply a most kind & affectionate adieu, and thus the character of the Letters, so far as Colo. Lear was concerned in developing the same, partake of the silence of his untimely grave. To one who feels the devotional enthusiasm that I do for both men & things of the Revo- lution, it is with painfull regret that I disturb the ashes of the author of the Declaration of Independence, or of my old Master and early friend, who whatever may have been his faults (if any he had) towards others, was ever most kind to me. But truth my Dear Sir, “‘is mighty,’’ and should allways prevail. The Lives & actions of distinguished men belong to their countries, and to History. No action in the long & meritorious life of the Great Wash- ington, shuns the light, and the light and truth of History shall still beam upon the long hidden & mysterious affair of The Letters if I can dispel the darkness, so help me God, amen. I am happy that you are about to anticipate my Private Memoirs of the Life & Character of Washington. The Public should be put in possession of the facts touching the Letters, & no one can doubt that there were Letters after the repeated & solemn declarations of Colo Lear to that effect, to whose sole care was en- trusted all the precious deposits of the Cheif, for History. The volumes of his public & prt- vate correspondence. Of the character of the Letters we have the evidence of Rawlins, who copied the same under the orders of the Cheif, and here it may be proper to be known, that Albin Rawlins was of respectable birth & con- nections, in the County of Caroline, State of Virginia, an intelligent, & amiable young man, whose correct moral deportment, pleasing man- ners, and attention to business, won for him the esteem of the whole Family of Mount Vernon, where he resided several years. Rawlins when questioned, declared that there were three Let- ters on the part of Washington, the first cour- teous, & a mere letter of enquiry. To this was returned an answer in the usually elegant style of Mr. Jefferson, who was assuredly the most finished epistolary writer of the age in which he flourished. In the second, the old Cheif pressed the Philosopher home, bringing him to the point of guilty or not guilty. The answer was said to be couched in terms of conciliation, spoke much of antient friendship, and of the long and happy intercourse & kindly reminis- cences of by gone days. The last letter of Washington, to use the words of Rawlins, was awfull, so that R declared, my hand trembled as 1 wrote it down. The subject of the Letters will be found at large & treated from facts only, in my Recol- lections & Privute Memvuirs, of the Life @ Character of Washington, a work too long de- layed from the American public, which has most kindly received various extracts from it, as published in the papers. My ‘“‘poverty not my will” has heretofore prevented my visiting Europe, a mission indispensable to the comple- tion of the work, & which I hope at no distant period to be able to accomplish. Enough is now elicited my D* Sir, to convince the American Public, & the World, that Letters did pass be- tween Gen'l Washington & Mr Jefferson subsequent to the Letter to Mazzei. And that the said Letters of Washington were of no friendly character. Ever yrs George W. P. Custis P. S. Copy this badly written scraw! Addressed: Majr Lawrence Lewis, Audley, near Battle Town, Frederic County, Virginia Endorsed: ‘1832. G. W. P. Custis respecting correspondence between Washington & Thos. Jefferson, confirming what I have stated on several occasions.’ Gen! Notes. A uniform series of reprints of standard historical novels is to be undertaken by Henry Holt & Co., and, “so far as prac- ticable, the series will present what systematic general view of history’’; always with regard to “high literary qual- ity’’ as well as interest and (the most du- bious item of the three) “trustworthiness.” Some account of the author and his work will be given. Houghton, Mifflin & Co. promise for the coming autumn an édition de lure of John Fiske’s works; two compilations of Mas- terpieces of Greek and Latin Literature, re- a some- spectively, chosen from the most famous English translations; a ‘‘Cambridge Edi tion’ of the late Professor Child’s ‘Eng- lish and Scotch Popular Ballads,’ edited by his daughter, Miss Helen Child, with an introduction by Prof. George L. Kit- tredge; and ‘A Study of Prose Fiction,’ by Bliss Perry, editor of the Atlantic Monthly. The late W. E. Channing’s ‘Thoreau, the Poet-Naturalist,’ published Brothers 1873, and print, is to appear in a new and enlarged edition, edited by his literary exector, Mr. by Roberts in long since out of F. B. Sanborn. It will be brought out handsomely in October by Charles E. Good- speed, Park Street, Boston, in two edi- tions—the more expensive with extra illus- trations. ‘The Career and Conversation of John Swinton,’ a sketch by his friend Robert Waters, will be published next month by the author in West Hoboken, N. J. (Chi- cago: Charles H. Kerr & Co.). ‘De la Formation des Maitres de |'’En- seignement Secondaire Aa l’Etranger et en France,’ par M. Dugard (Paris: Armand Colin), is one of the numerous publica- tions which show how widespread, in all civilized countries, is the feeling of a need of better secondary schools. The author states the problem clearly and treats it in a systematic way. The book may be consulted with interest and profit. The decline of Spain as a political Power and the loss of its prestige among modern nations in art and literature are now lead- ing many thoughtful and patriotic Span- iards to inquire into the causes of this lamentable decay, and to suggest means of resuscitation and regeneration. Such is the purpose of a work of 207 pages, entitled ‘Psicologia del Pueblo Espafiol,’ by Profes sor Altamira, the second volume of the “Biblioteca Moderna de Ciencias Sociales,” a series of treatises on sociology now be- 118 ing published in Madrid. The author maintains that this national degeneracy is due not to any defects or incapactties in- herent in the to the development and systematic suppression of the superior qualities which it is naturally endowed, and that a remedy must be sought in a more careful and cultivation of the intellectual faculties The state, under the of the Church, has grossly neglected popular edu cation, and in which the public money expended for bull-fights, the are not paid even their and thus reduced to the ignominious choice be tween starvation beggary The first volume of Dr mann’'s ‘Die Sixtinische Kapelle,’ lished by Bruckmann the unique race, but imperfect with general influence many provinces, In is lavishly school-teachers meagre salaries, are and trnst Stein just pub Munich, describes of this archi is an in and decoration of construction ecclesiastical IV., and ceedingly valuable contribution to the his latter half from a political as specimen tecture under Sixtus ex- of the Renaissance in the of the fifteenth century tory well as from an artistic point of view The author is a German scholar residing in Rome, who has made a thorough study of the subject, and presents the results of his researches with remarkable complete in German works attractive and (what is this kind) text is ness of The cellent details of the of Perugino, landajo, and other artists rare in a very style profusely illustrated with ex reproductions of the architectural edifice and of the painting Botticelli, Ghir The second devoted chief Pinturicchio, and concluding volume will be ly to Michelangelo “Municipal Socialism,” the first title of the Consular Reports for July, is an in teresting array of facts relating to the ownership by municipalities in England of public or semi-public enterprises, as street- , and to the hous- who are dispossessed for This 1s the absorbing which, “‘it railways, waterworks, ete. ing of the poor sanitary problem owns reasons. in Liverpool, is sald more revenue-producing real estate than any other municipality in the world its income from this source being about half a million dollars a year The report closes with two observations: “Speaking generally, municipal government in Great Britain is honest, intelligent, and energeti: and, as a rule, politics has but littl to do with the engagement or retention of civ employees."”’ The Antwerp Labor Exchange, whose recent opening is chronicled, is an outcome of the great dock strike two years ago. At that time a federation of employers and workmen formed to develop the interests of the shipping trade The members, are “guaranteed lack of work, and mutual-benefit associa tions among the Never has ther« plete understanding between masters and men than under these conditions. Day has now proved so efficacious that the pe cessity for overtime work has greatly di minished.”” The Exchange, club in fact, with lavatories and a dispen was protect and numbering over 5,000 indemnity now an in case of dockers are encourag: existed a more com WOrK a workman sary, “furnishes at cost excellent beer, cof- fee, and tea, but no gin.”” The lack of fo: ests in China leads our consul at Niu chwang to believe that there will be a per- manent and extensive demand in that coun- try for our Pacific Coast lumber. He states
Page 18
The Nation. [Vol. 75, No. 1936 aS that “probably more wood is used for cof- fins than for any other purpose.” East of Asia is the title of a handsomely printed eighty-page magazine, 11x7 inches in dimensions, issued at Shanghai at the North China Herald office, and richly illus- trated with reproductions from _ photo- graphs showing how the Russian, German, and British occupation of parts of China is influencing architecture, the landscape, and the old landmarks. Dr. Arthur H. Smith writes on The New Peking, describing the fortified area of the legation district. Mr. C. F. Voskamp pictures brightly ‘‘the story- teller and his methods in China,’’ where every common object grows myth and le- gend as a moist stone collects moss. Mr. L. Odontins’s readable digest in German of the remarkable pamphlet of the reforming Viceroy or governor-general of the two Hu provinces is here put into English from the German. Mrs. Timothy Richards treats - with woman’s insight of Chinese social cus- There articles, by competent hands, with reproductions of photographs taken this year, on the German Kiao-chau territory, on Port Arthur, the Russian place of occupation, and on Wei Hai Wei, the British portion; and between text and pic- ture one gets a good idea of contem- poraneous northeastern China. The plot of a Chinese play entitled “The Cattle Butcher’s Retribution,” and a spirited full- toms, are page colored print, make up a very at- tractive magazine interpreting modern China. Most striking of all the nume- rous illustrations is that of the cutting of the double eagle, with appropriate inscrip- tions (in both German and Chinese), deep into the face of the natural rock at Tsing- tao, the where the first German troop, under the command of Admiral von Diederichs, took possession in 1897. Strikingly illustrative of the methods and spirit of the rival political parties and leaders in Japan that are to measure their strength at the polls during August, 1902, is the literary magazine the Waseda Bungaku. About twenty years ago Count Okuma—in- corrigible optimist and ‘“‘martyr to the cause of the foreigner in Japan,’’ ex-Pre- officer, whe founded and has been for years the leader and oracle of the Progressive party—established the School of Literature, Politics and Law at Waseda, in Tokio. He has made it by his ability and energy a worthy rival, in some the Imperial Univer- on spot mier and cabinet respects at least, of Everything is taught in Japanese by English and Chi- is to educate Japanese young thoroughly in the three literatures and languages most need- ed in this generation. In coéperation with the school is a translation and publishing sity. native professors, except The object and nese, men women department—long conducted at a loss, but now more than paying its expenses—which literature of puts the substantial modern many countries (chiefly English, French, and German) into excellent Japanese. Of the several hundred copies of the Waseda monthly magazine that have passed under our review, that for June, 1902, is typical. In the list of works noted in this literary digest we find the names of Dicey, Barton (‘Semitic Origins’), Dunning (‘Political Theories’), Hanna (‘The Scotch-Irish’), Nolhac, Helmholt (‘Welt- Jacquemot, Kroger, and translated in part or commented upon, besides those by Chi- De geschichte’), Brandes, others, whose works are nese and Japanese authors. Some of the numbers contain critical articles on Japa- nese topics—political (but non-partisan), legal, economic, and literary—which are invaluable to the scholar in Japanese. Twen- ty thousand copies of this literary magazine are distributed monthly. “Kikuyu,’”’” by Major R. Crawshay, the most noteworthy article in the (eograph- ical Journal for July, is an account of a district on the Uganda Railway. He draws a most attractive picture of the little vil- lages ‘“‘with their toy-house-like granaries with tiny conical roofs,’’ surrounded by herds of cattle and flocks of sheep and goats, the men and women at work in the plantations, the boys herding the live stock, the innumerable fires lighted for no other purpose than the companionship of their smoke. The people, an unusually manly and intelligent race, differ from the neighboring tribes {fn having a patriarchal form of government with graded punish- ments for various crimes, in their moral- ity, their industry, their trustworthiness, and their splendid physique. They also are exceptional in that ‘‘they have none of that wild-beast-like craving for meat for which the majority of African tribes are so fa- mous. They eat no other flesh than that of domestic cattle, sheep, and goats.”’ Their vice is drunkenness. In an account of the recent eruptions in the West Indies, Mr. H. N. Dickson infers, from the reports of earthquakes in April and May in both hemispheres, ‘‘probably one of the, most profound and _ widespread disturbances which have affected the earth’s crust with- in historic times.’’ Mr. E. André gives the results of his observations of St. Vincent, in the course of which he says “the whole country looks as if millions of barrels of cement had been emptied over it.’’ Refer- ring to Dr. Sven Hedin’s return from ‘one of the most remarkable and successful ex- peditions ever undertaken in Central Asia,” Sir Clements Markham says that “his maps alone, if spread out, would cover nearly a quarter of a mile.” The principal maps, accompanied by notes, are of the glaciers of Kangchenjunga and of Lake Nyasa. It is nearly a century and a half since Voltaire wrote to Rousseau the letter in which he acknowledges the receipt of the ‘Discours sur l’Inégalité’ and so wittily de- fends letters and science against Rousseau’s attack. Those who imagine that no such defence is called for in our own day would be surprised at the seriousness and ability with which the German teachers, at their recent meeting in Chemnitz, discussed the subject of “The Importance of Popular Ed- ucation to the Morality of the People.’’ The proceedings of the meeting of this largest of all teachers’ associations—its member- ship amounts to 85,000—are published in re- cent numbers of the Paedagogische Zeitung, and show that it is still important for the friends of popular education to meet the arguments of its enemies, new and old. The stenographic reports are full of interesting historical facts and well-taken points. We can here mention only the statement of an old prison teacher, who said that, during his twenty-five years of service, he had found that, of all the criminals under his instruction, only one-fourth were in pos- session of what might be factory education, called a satis- In Germany even novelists are obliged to be savants. At any rate, one gets that im- pression on reading about the examination which Paul Heyse passed at the University of Berlin, fifty years ago. Becker question- ed him about Romance literature and lan- guage, Trendelenburg about Spinoza, Boeckh about Greek literature, conversing with him in Latin, Ranke on the history of Spain and the Crusades, Von Hagen on the history of German poetry. The result of the examination was a “‘multa cum laude” for Heyse. His dissertation was entitled ‘Studia Romanensia,’ and the special theses he had to maintain orally related to Goethe’s ‘Wilhelm Meister,’ to Spinoza, and to Michelangelo. What would happen to our American novelists under similar cir- cumstances? In a recent academical address, Professor Hjelt, Rector of the University of Helsing: fors in Finland, gave an interesting account of the education of women in that institu- tion. The first female student was a young girl, who passed the required exam- ination and was matriculated in 1870. A serious obstacle to the movement was a decision made by the Russian Government in 1882 that no woman should be admitted without special permission, in each indi- vidual case, from the authorities in St. Pe- tersburg. The result of this bureaucratic regulation was that only seventeen women -entered the University during the next eight years. In 1890, men and women were placed on an equal footing in this respect, in consequence of which the number of women applicants rapidly increased, so that till now 749 have pursued their studies at Helsingfors; at present they number 120, and form nearly a fourth of the whole body of students. Professor Hjelt regards co- education in Helsingfors as a success. The presence of young women in the lecture- rooms has exerted a wholesome influence and promoted the proficiency of the young men in learning. Only two women have studied theology; 7 per cent. have devoted themselves to jurisprudence, 65 per cent. to history and philology, and 28 per cent. to physics and mathematics. The women ex- cel in modern languages, esthetics, lit- erature, and history; but their average standing in philosophy is not as high as that of the young men. The instances of superiority in mathematics are striking, but exceptional. A twofold service was rendered to litera- ture by the late Mr. C. Kegan Paul, who will be remembered both as an author and as a publisher. His best-known books were biographical—the ‘Life of Godwin,’ ‘Biographical Sketches,’ and ‘Memories.’ The second of these consisted of a series of valuable critical memoirs of Edward Irving, Keble, Maria Hare, Rowland Williams, Kingsley, George Eliot, and Newman, of most of whom Mr. Kegan Paul had per- sonal knowledge. When the development of his Positivist views—to be succeeded later by submission to the Church of Rome —resulted in the resignation of his position as an Anglican clergyman, he became lit- erary adviser of Mr. Henry S. King, in which capacity he had much to do with the production of the International Scientific Series. Later he associated himself with a son of Archbishop Trench in the purchase of Mr. King’s business, and remained the managing director when it was transform- ed into a company under the name of Ke- gan Paul, Trench, Triibner & Co. His ‘Me- mories’ contains many interesting particu-
Page 19
Aug. 7, 1902] The Nation. 115
; > ? “flac 4 oy 30 - ir eR igth but literatu . e lars of his relations with Tennyson, Bage- | ‘imental reflections on the Desert, a sub virtues at lengtl i ‘ ature, W i hot, and many other prominent men of let- | Ject which has taken a strong hold on the} can commend Miss Davidso workmans! ; ters, as well as some lively recollections of | {™agination of magazine writers, assisted, | to the attention of our own Ph.D.’s, ma F the perils to which a publisher is exposed. | ®° doubt, by the recent volume of Prof. | culine and feminine, who a too apt On the business, as a whole, however, he John C. Van Dyke. While Mr. Reed draws ; scorn culture in their wooing sclet : pronounces the judgment that, “supposing | °™ the desert solitude the thought that | and, while learning foreign languag 4 any one to have the capital and the literary “whatever is is right,” it is the temper of | forget how to write their own the age to draw from its material unpro ‘tiveness . es at the desert self work.” ductiveness the idea that the « eset itsel at times att (06) that Mamenset Gemeave is all wrong, and to proceed vi et armis skill, I can imagine no more interesting In the Annales of the Paris Internation ; > sto » report of the fifth section —The August Century has some fifty | ¢, reduce it to cultivation tive History, the repo ve fifth pages of interesting matter on earthquakes : concerned with the History Science, con and volcanoes in general, and the Mar- It may seem quixotic to recommend to} tains nothing of greater consequence than tinique and St. Vincent disasters in par- the “summer reader” any rival to the | one might expect as the printed residuum of ticular. The opening paper of the group is | SUPer» vitality” of Dorothy Vernon of} such a meeting, after the separate pu by Professor Kemp of Columbia University, who goes extensively into the causes of | "Ot parted with all his good sense and good | jing spirit of the section was evidently M seismic and volcanic action. This is follow- | '@5te and his intelligent curiosity as to the | paul Tannery. Heiberg prints for the first ed by a vivid description of the Martinique | "¥™an comedy, he may well be allured by | time the Greek text of Anatolius ou ‘I Haddon Hall; yet if the summer reader has i of several contributions. The lead cation )
catastrophe in the form of a detailed re- | * ™odest and charming volume which has | frst ten numbers, a Pythagorean Christian port to the Bishop of Martinique, absent | "® fault except that it is instructive «s/ tract by an Alexandrian Peripatetic of th: in Paris at the time, by the Vicar-General | “® l as amusing and entertaining. The ti third century. It contains an otherwise un of the island, the Very Rev. G. Parel, whose | “le of this, we hardly dare to say, is ‘Trans known fragment of Heraclitus, and has a sense of duty to the people under his care | /@tions from Lucian,’ by Miss Augusta M. | certain interest as probably representing a freed him of all fear and kept him alert to Campbell Davidson, M.A. (Longmans, | Jost book of Nicomachu Several of the all that was going on. Another valuable | Green & Co.). If Lucian’s vogue is on the | Jonger papers of the volume relate to m¢ addition to the record was secured for the | Wane, as Miss Davidson observes, it may] jj@yal medicine and surgery: and t Century by the chaplain of the Divie, in the | be partly because he has been superseded, | one by Nicaise on tt ite of anatomy and form of a file of the leading newspaper of | ‘2 4 Way, by Voltaire; but the Attic sauce | physiology at the time of Vesalius and Hat & St. Pierre, Les Colonies, for the week imme- | With which his dissertations are served up| yey Tannery prints nine letters addressed diately preceding the disaster. Severa] | Might pique the appetite of the most jaded | tg the celebrated Pére Mersenn sho. at : pages of extracts from this paper are | 2nd indolent mind, The reader who glances | the time of Deseart scted as a mediun = printed, and they warrant the conviction | into this ancient mirror of a decadent age tf actantifie intetiinence. & 7, that it was for a time the policy of the | if he has a grain of sense and seriousuess | gives an interesting account of the different editor to belittle the real danger. The | in his composition—will see in it the refle compromises between Ptolemy and Coper St. Vincent disaster is described by two | tion of our own times—our fashionable fads | njeus that were proposed in the <teent! eye-witnesses, Capt. Calder, Chief of Police | and crazes, our scepticism dashed and] and later centuries. In a paper by André of St. Vincent, and T. McGregor McDonald, | mingled with the grossest superstition; he | [alande, the pendulum of opinion al owner of one of the most famous planta- | Will recognize that his own generation con- | Prancis Baconswings to so wide a d tions of the island. The group fitly closes | sists large'y of Lucian’s “dead people] that PDeseartes is alm represented with a translation of the two famous letters | Warmed over,’ as Dr. Holmes used to say; | haye borrowed from him the idea of ex in which the younger Pliny describes to | only the clothes and the scenery are Just) pjaining all physics on mechanical prin
Tacitus the great eruption of Vesuvius | 4 little different. We need hardly go back | ples. It is the ‘Valerius Terminus’ to whict in the year 79. Still further papers are to | to the memoirs of Mme. Roland to parallel | appeal is made for support of th Galit be added in the September issue. Aside | the sycophancy and snobbery and bad man zyne communicate letter and pictorial from this collection, the most important | pers that are pictured in the sketch of the | cpetches sent to Catharine If. in 1783 bs feature of the number is “The Tragedy of | sorrows and trials of “Paid Companions,’ the Russian Minister in Pat to inform the Range,” Mr. Baker’s continuation of his | nor to a Cagliostro to match the maguifi her about the ballooning exploits of Mont series of papers on the Southwest. It is a | cent impudence and world-wide success of | golfier and Charl There are n inter story of almost incredible mismanagement | that juggler and impostor, Alexander of | esting papers about Comtism: for the rest and waste of great natural resources, due | Abonoteichus, whose astounding career is | not very much to attract other readers thar no more to the folly and ignorance of the | described in one of these excerpts. As to] minute students in special departments of immediate agents than to the lack of con- | his dupes, are they not the same peop!e as] the history of sciences cern manifested by the legislative and ex- | our neighbors on the next street, if not our In the Historical section of the Arsales ecutive departments of the United States | own friends and intimates? Besides these in Kid Wiis iipatheniae o eumten t yovernment. lively sketches, Miss Davidson has included tai tot Stak eoate of the Wales este —Martha Baker Dunn, in the August Aft- | ‘““The Sale of Philosophers,’’ “The Orator’s who, in 1605, after the death of Boris Go lantic, writes helpfully of “The Browning | Guide,” “Hermotimus,’’ the delightful bit dunoff, succeeded in imposing himself on Tonic,” but the logic of her argument is | Of satire and burlesque entitled “Zeus the Russia as the son of Ivan the Terrible, who spoiled in the end by a mistaken applica- | Tragedian,’’ and also ‘‘The True History,’ had died in 1584. At Cracow, in 16 tion. Courage and endurance are good quali- | @ witty and fanciful extravaganza, the pr Pretender. in the hands of the J ties,and the soldiers in the Cuban war doubt- | ©Ursor of Munchausen, which possibly sug- | | ki, had professed Catholicism, and less displayed them in as great a measure | 8¢Sted some ideas for Swift’s Gulliver jured the Orthodox faith; he had promis: as was possible when fighting for a dubious As to the quality of Miss Davidson’ to render Russia Catholic ind to lead a cause; but it does no honor to these quali- | translation, there can hardly be two opin crusade against the Turl To insure the ties to invoke them in behalf of an attitude | ions. It is the work, so to speak, of al suces of his enterpriss however h of silence towards suffering produced, not lady and a scholar—a rather remarkabl apostasy had to be kept ecre and by the real necessities of warfare, but by specimen of well-bred, racy English, which | hoped to procure a papal dispensation to the incompetence and dishonesty of officers | recalls the letters of Dorothy Osborne. It | enable him to take. from the Orthode employed to provide the men in the field | is characterized by ease, urbanity, spright Patriarch, the communion which was an « with such food, clothing, medical atten- | illness, and an unfailing fluency of idiom | sential feature of his coronation Rou dance, etc., as will make them most efficient | without the slightest taint of slang. It re delayed, however, and Sawicki was distra in the work they are set to do. An article | yeals great skil! and ingenuity in turning | ed with doubt, both as to th and the com on the poetry of Edward Rowland Sill, the phrases of a highly idiomatic writes plications that would inevitably follow. Hs signed ‘‘W. B. P.,”’ might easily be under- so successfully that it reads like an orig consulted the incio at ¢ 4 stood as distinctly unfavorable, but is bet- | inal, not constrained by any foreign mouid. } latter referred the question to the Roman i ter considered as showing the solid worth | [It is naturally somewhat free, and occa Holy Offic Dmitri was crowned July : of the poet by calling attention to the dis- | sionally becomes a discreet paraphrase; and mu lave tak | irist m th } advantages against which his fame is stead- | but it is entirely adequate for the purpose hand of a hers (wl : npardor i ily making its way. Verner Z. Reed con- of the public for whom it was desigued able), while the Inqu tion dallied, and it | tributes some entertaining moral and sen- |! Ww: regret that we cannot illustrate the Was not unti] N mbe hat it evaded
Page 20
116 The Nation. [Vol. 75, No. 1936 decision by telling Sawicki that he must consult the canons and act according to his conscience. Then the question presented itself anew, for Dmitri had promised to marry Marina, daughter of George Mniszek, Palatin of Sendomir, a powerful Polish magnate, who had aided his enterprise. She, of course, was a Catholic, and at her coronation she too would be expected to take the sacrament. Mniszek assembled a trio of theologians, who concluded that Dmitri should be urged to omit the com- munion in the ceremony, and that Rome should be asked to grant a dispensation in view of the enormous advantages antici- pated for the Church. On the one hand, Dmitri succeeded in suppressing the com- munion at the coronation of his bride; on the other, as evasion would no longer serve, the Inquisition again examined the ques- tion thoroughly, and in a solemn session held March 2, 1606, under the presidency of Paul V., it decided adversely with but one dissenting vote. In this it proved to be wise, for prolonged dissimulation would have been useless, seeing that Dmitri was put to death on May 17, and with him van- ished the dreams of subjecting Russia to the Holy See. ROSE’S NAPOLEON I. The Life of Napoleon I. Including new ma- terial from the British Official Records. By John Holland Rose, M.A. The Mac- millan Co. 1902. 2 vols., pp. 471, 547. Now that impartiality is looked upon as 2 prime virtue of the historian, a new field is thrown open to the English biographcr. It becomes legitimate for him to write about Napoleon in any one of several forms. If learned, he may prepare a work of erudi- tion for specialists; if well informed, he may dispel many prejudices which. still haunt the mind of the general reader; and even if he be a mere bookmaker, he wiil de- serve to escape the reproaches of the re- viewer so long as he approaches the subject with a mind unwarped by patriotic preju- dice. In the moments which immediately followed his first abdication, Napoleon spoke thus of England. To Caulaincourt he said: ‘She has done me much harm, doubt- less, but I have left in her flanks a poisoned dart. It is I who have made this debt, that will ever burden, if not crush, future gen- erations.’” A century after the Peace of Amiens that debt has not been paid, and perhaps there will be a survival of rancor in the English heart until the distant day when the nation shall have cleared off the last account which can be laid to the charge of the “Corsican usurper.” In the mean- time it would be unreasonable to expect from the generality of Englishmen any out- burst of hero-worship. Under existing cir- cumstances, the historical spirit wins a no- table victory whenever an isolated scholar in Great Britain comes forward to treat the career and character of Napoleon with fair- ness, As a mere academic statement, this may sound trite, but it is necessary that some such comment should precede any detailed review of Mr. Rose’s work. From a great va- riety of passages, some general and some minute, one can see how carefully the au- thor has sought to guard against preposses- sions of whatever kind. Mr. Fyffe, by the degree of his antagonism to Napoleon, re- , calls the days of Scott and Alison. Free- man, going farther still, recalls the sugges- tion which the Times made when the Bellerophon arrived at Torbay: “‘The first procedure, we trust, will be a special Com- mission, or the appointment of a court- martial, to try him for the murder of Capt. Wright.” Dr. Fitchett, whose volumes cir- culate widely, informs us that ‘‘Napoleon’s amazing success is not explained by his in- tellectual gifts. His epoch explains his ca- reer. An exhausted Revolution needed a military dictator and was certain to crystal- lize into one. If Napoleon had not played that part, Moreau [sic] would, or Hoche, or Bernadotte.” Such is the attitude of re- cent well-known writers in England. On the contrary, Mr. Rose holds his bal- ance with a firm and even hand. We have mentioned Fyffe, Freeman, and Fitchett. There remain the late Sir John Seeley and Mr. Goldwin Smith, from both of whom Mr. Rose dissociates himself. With a fuller knowledge of Napoleonic literature than has yet been shown by any Englishman, he has a graver sense of the inherent diffi- culties and a clearer determination to face the thousand problems of fact and motive. While om the one hand he escapes from the bias of inherited antipathy, he succeeds, more conspicuously than Lord Rosebery has done, in keeping his mind free from the overmastery of Napoleon’s genius. If Mr. Rose’s views have been deeply affected by those of any contemporary, we should ven- ture to conjecture that he has felt the touch of the late Lord Acton, whoreceives the ded- ication, and whose article on Napoleon in the second volume of the English Histori- cal Review discloses much of the same spirit. We dilate upon this aspect of the work because, where it is a question of the Re- formation, the French Revolution, or Na- poleon, everything depends upon the ani- mus, the point of view. Mr. Rose confronts as delicate and hazardous a subject as Dr. Creighton did when he set out to write the history of the Papacy during the period of the Reformation. They are alike, also, in learning and openness of mind. It is therefore interesting to see that Mr. Rose concludes his preface with the following words: “That I have escaped altogether the pitfalls with which the subject abounds is not to be imagined; but I can honestly say, in the words of the late Bishop of London, that ‘I have tried to write true history.’ ” Napoleon and his age are so important, while among all the books which have been written about them so few are really good, that it is a duty to single out and praise the rare work of merit when it ap- pears. Mr. Rose has won high honor where most fail lamentably or absurdly. Though his special researches may have been less arduous than those of Chuquet and Van- dal, of Houssaye and Lumbroso, he has made his original contribution to knowl- edge of fact, and, by gathering up the re- sults of a thousand monographs into a con- nected biography, he takes his place beside Fournier, Thus, while he helps to redeem his countrymen from the reproach of hav- ing studied Napoleon casually and in a wrong spirit, he has produced a book that will be of great value to all who speak Eng- lish. It deserves moreover, to be trans- lated into the languages of Continental EBu- We shall not overpraise Mr. Rose by saying that he has produced a Thucydidean rops. classic, or that his view of Napoleon will convert the world. He has written, in the narrative form, at which, he says, history ought always to aim, a learned and thoughtful, a compact yet animated, ac- count of Napoleon’s life. Having thus referred to Mr. Rose’s out- look and attainment, we may now pass to the subject of his own independent re- search. He says in the preface: “I should not have ventured on this great undertak- ing, had I not been able to contribute something new to Napoleonic literature. During a study of this period for an ear- lier work [‘The Revolutionary and Napo- leonic Era’], published in the ‘Cambridge Historical Series,’ I ascertained the great value of the British Records for the years 1795-1815."" Drawing from the War Office and Admiralty Records and from the For- eign-Office Archives, he has carried out an investigation which has already been pur- sued in the case of Russia, Austria, and Prussia. The importance of this quest for Napoleonic material in British instructions, dispatches, and reports is supported by a passage taken from M. Lévy’s ‘Napoléon Intime’: “The documentary history of the wars of the Empire has not yet been writ- ten. To write it accurately, it will be more important thoroughly to know foreign ar- chives than those of France.” Mr. Rose’s comment upon this quotation runs: “TI think that I may claim to have searched all the important parts of our Foreign Office Archives for the years in question, as well as for part of the St. Helena period.” Here no allusion is made to what Mr. Rose has discovered in British state papers regarding the period of the Consulate. Yet, like Mr. Bowman, he has examined the Peace of Amiens in the light of information gained from this source, and he has found something new about the part of British officials in the Royalist Plot of 1804. As the conspiracy of Pichegru and Georges Ca- doudal was the immediate means of rais- ing Napoleon to the purple, the incident has some significance of its own, while it illustrates forcibly the First Consul’s meth- ods of meeting his enemies, and the mental feebleness of the Addington administration. Mr. Rose calls it “the most famous plot of the century,” and the fresh facts which he has established deserve to be selected as an example of his diligence. During 1803-04 two plots were in progress at the same time. The Comte d’Artois and other leaders of the émigrés, with certain allies in France, were seeking to effect the assassination of Napoleon; and he, watch- ing their stupid mancwuvres, with all the confidence of superior skill, was trying to enlarge the circle of the conspirators until it should include some of his most formid- able opponents. By the help of Mehée de la Touche, a skilful agent provocateur, Fouché kept the First Consul informed, ‘‘while he also wove his meshes round plotting émigrés, English officials, and French gen- erals.’’ What has repeatedly been alleged, on the authority of memoirs and other evidence of varying quality, Mr. Rose now proves from British archives, namely, that British officials were guilty of helping for- ward Pichegru’s scheme. Among the For- eign Office Records there is a letter (Au- gust 30, 1803) from the Baron de Roll, a Bourbon emissary,to Mr. Hammond, Perma- nent Under Secretary of the Foreign Office, asking him to call on the Comte d’Artois
Page 21
Aug. 7, 1902] at his residence, No. 46 Baker Street. Dur- ing October of the same year, a secret mem- orandum follows, in which the Comte d’Ar- tois reviews Bonaparte’s career, showing how, at the present moment, all the lead- ing generals and politicians of France ar: against him. Active complicity is proved by a document of November 18, wherein is noted the payment made by the British Government to royalist officers ‘“‘who had set out or were ready to set out.’’ “Another ‘most secret’ Admiralty letter, of January 9, 1804, orders a frigate or large sloop to be got ready to convey secretly ‘an officer of rank and consideration’ (probably Piche- gru) to the French coast. Wright carried over the conspirators in several parties, un- til chance threw him into Napoleon’s pow- er and consigned him to an ignominious death, probably suicide.”’ Finally, Mr. Ar- buthnot, Parliamentary Secretary at the Foreign Office, wrote to Sir Arthur Paget (March 12, 1804) about the “‘sad result of all our fine projects for the reéstablishment of the Bourbons: . greatly apprehensive for poor Moreau’s safety.”’ In view of these facts, Mr. Rose brushes away all ministerial denials. Perhaps it was a plot which embraced young and hot- headed officials rather than the respecta- ble chiefs. Perhaps it may be slightly condoned by a French plot of the same kind against George III. ‘“But,’’ Mr. Rose con- cludes, ‘‘when all is said, the British Gov- ernment must stand accused of one of the most heinous of crimes. The whole truth was not known at Paris, but it was surmis- ed; and the surmise was sufficient to en- venom the whole course of the struggle be- tween England and Napoleon.”’ When he comes to the wars of the Em- pire, Mr. Rose is likewise able to increase previous knowledge by details that he has drawn from the British records. These are especially interesting for the war of the Third Coalition, during the course of which Napoleon won such brilliant victories over Continental troops supported by English subsidies. We can hardly say that the new evidence thus gathered will cause many verdicts of history to be reversed, but it is always interesting and often valuable. Napoleon is the subject of the book, not British diplomacy; yet few of the incidental topics are so important as the latter. In the end, after ridiculous inconsistencies, the British Foreign Office came to have a settled policy. we are, of course, “Nevertheless,” says Mr. Rose, ‘the splendor of the finale must not blind us to the flaccid eccentricities that made Brit- ish statesmanship the laughing-stock of Europe in 1801-3, 1806-7, and 1809. Indeed, it is questionable whether the renewal of the war between England and Napoleon in 1803 was due more to his innate forceful- ness or to the contempt which he felt for the Addington Cabinet. When one also re- members our extraordinary blunders in the War of the Third Coalition, it seems a mir- acle that the British Empire survived that life-and-death struggle against a man ol superhuman genius who was determined to effect its overthrow.”’ We would not have it inferred from what has been said that Mr. Rose exalts Na- poleon’s relations with Great Britain above everything else in his career. The duel be- tween the Emperor and England is but one feature, however stfiking, in an experience of unparalleled activity and diversity. Mr. Rose has studied a particular aspect of the The Nation. subject more thoroughly than any of his predecessors, and this fact we have sought to bring out. At the same time he writes a remarkably well-modelled biography, ip which the English element is given no more than its due share. The first volume closes with the collapse of the Boulogne flotilla; the second extends from the campaign of Ulm and Austerlitz to the last hour at St Helena. If any period has, of conscious purpose, been treated briefly, it is that which comes between 1809 and 1811, when imperial prestige reached its height. Every- thing essential has been discussed—origin and training, personal and family relations, wars, political aptitudes, the creation of in- stitutions, contact with the Revolution, ef- fect upon European statecraft, character and genius. These things have been taken up by Mr. Rose, not in a loose and nebulous way, or as affording themes for phrases, but with a sure grasp of fact and in stern subordination to a well-wrought plan. If necessary, he can stop to tell a story, even though the telling occupies a whole page as in the case where he relates how Joseph and Lucien tried to dissuade Napoleon from parting with Louisiana. The story is a good one, but it is not told merely because it is an amusing anecdote. In any life of Napoleon war must fill a large share of the space, and for this rea- son the author is sure to feel at a great disadvantage unless he has received special training in military history. Mr. Rose cannot claim to have the grasp of strategy and tactics which the late Mr. Ropes pos- sessed, and we imagine that he would be the last to suggest such a comparison. He writes of war like the intelligent amateur who, after comparing the judgments of tae best experts, has used common sense in reaching a conclusion of his own. The campaigns are fully described and with admirable clearness. Even where a moot point arises, like the share of Augereau in the credit for Castiglione, or the recon- struction of what actually took place at Marengo, or Napoleon’s mistake in the dis- position of his forces just before the battles of Jena and Auerstadt, Mr. Rose is not afraid to state his opinion, since it has been formed after a careful scrutiny of the evidence. We shall not try to state in a single word what Mr. Rose’s attitude is towards either the genius or the character of Napoleon. These are complex questions which cannot be disposed of with a plain yes or no. But there is one manifest disposition of the writer that can be briefly indicated. Mr.Rose is fond of analysis and the investigation of motives; yet at times he reaches the point where he stops short in a mood of pious agnosticism. For example, he will not de- cide definitely whether in 1805 Napoleon planned his expedition for Ireland serious- ly, or whether he simply meant it for a feint while he dealt the chief blow at Lon- don. “Both Nelson and Collingwood believed him to be aiming at Ireland. But Napoleon is often unfathomable. Herein lies much of the charm of Napoleonic studies. He is at once the Achilles, the Mercury, and the Proteus of the modern world. The ease with which his mind grasped all new prob- lems and suddenly concentrated its force on some new plan, may well perplex pos- terity as it dazed his contemporaries.” And again, after describing the wonderful battles of February, 1814, he says: 117 ‘“‘Whatever the mistakes of these lead ers, and they were great, there is some thing that defles analysis in Napoleon’: sudden transformation of his beaten, di pirited band into a triumphant array b« fore which four times their numbers sought refuge in retreat. But it is just this tran scendent equality that adds a charm to th character and career of Napoleon. Wher: analysis fails, there genius begins.” Finally, Mr. Rose does not blink the Em peror’s shortcomings, but he grows elo quent over his achievements. It is in the following strain that this thorough anid mature work closes: “The man who bridled the Revolution and remoulded the life of France, who laid broad and deep the foundations of a new life in Italy, Switzerland, and Germany, who rolled the West in on the East in the greatest movement Known since the cru sades, and finally drew the yearning thoughts of myriads to that solitary rock in the South Atlantic, must ever stand in the very forefront of the immortals of human story.” The Service. By Henry David Thoreau. Ed ited by F. B. Sanborn. Boston: Charles E. Goodspeed. 1902. The brief article which Mr. Sanborn has had so handsomely printed (500 copies on French hand-made paper and 20 on Japan), has had a curious and interesting history It was sent by Thoreau to the Dial, bear ing the date July, 1840, the same as that of the first number of the Dial, in which he made a double appearance, in poetry and in prose. Margaret Fuller, then one of the editors of the Dial, turned It over to Emer- sor, one of her two associates, with a com- ment intended for Thoreau, which probably he never saw. She found it full of thoughts but these so out of their natural order that she could not read it without pain “It is true,” she continued, ‘“‘as Mr. Em erson says, that essays not to be compared with this have found their way into the Dial. But then these were more unassum- ing in their tone, and have an air of quiet good-breeding which induces us to permit their presence. Yours is so rugged that it ought to be commanding.” Whence it appears that Emerson desired its publication, but, on becoming sole editor of the Dial, the courage of his opinion wa not equai to the act he had advised. Afler Emerson's death, the manuscript found its way somehow into Mr. Sanborn’s hands, and now the stone which the lapidaries rejected has been set in a manner equal to, if not beyond, its just deserts. It will add nothing to Thoreau’s reputa- tion, but it will furnish the critics of Trans cendentalism with one of their most strik ing illustrations of Its occasional extrava gance. Here is a kind of writing which makes the most unintelligible passages of the earlier Emerson seem miracles of clar ity. Jeremiah Mason would have been twics confounded by it, and hardly could his ‘‘gals’’ have understood it. Here are colors floated off from Emerson's palette, and here are the stiffness and the involution of Eng lish prose before Dryden took it in hand As for the militant rhetoric, Mr. Sanborn considers this a counterblast to the peace sermons that were getting written in 15840 and about that time. One of the most no- table of Channing's had appeared in 1839. The article has a triple division, the first part being headed ‘‘Qualities of the Re cruit,”’ the second, ‘What Music Shall W« Have?” the third, “Not How Many, but
Page 22
118 Where the Enemy Are." There is evidence on every page of Thoreau’s familiarity with natural things and with classic literature. But the natural things seem to exist for him only as symbols of spiritual realities, their frank concreteness affording him no such relish as it did further on. That play- ing upon words and that delight in para- dox which were ever his besetting sins, have here some of their grossest exhibi- tions, and these sins are mingled strangely with some of the rarest virtues of his thought and style. For example: - a “They who are alarmed lest virtue should so far demean herself as to be extremely good, have not yet wholly embraced her, but described only a slight arc of a few seconds about her, and from so smalland ill- defined a curvature you can calculate no centre whatever; but their mean is no bet- ter than meanness, nor their medium than mediocrity.” And this for paradox: “What shame, then, that our lives, which might so well be the source of planetary motion, and sanction the order of the spheres, should be full of abruptness and angularity so as not to roll nor move ma- jestically!”’ There are sentences and passages of sin- gular beauty, and some of great nobility and splendor, while others jostle them that are absurd either in their expression or in their thought, as where Thoreau finds that “the grand and majestic have always some- what of the undulatoriness of the sphere,” and declares that this is “the secret of majesty in the rolling gait of the elephant, and of all grace in action and in art.”’ He in- stances the great Tippecanoe and Tyler ball which the grave citizens of Concord rolled from the Concord battle-ground to Bunker Hill. ‘I seem,” he says, “‘to discover each striving to imitate its gait and keep step with it, if possible to swell to its own diameter.’’ Doubtless Van Buren Demo- crats, witnessing the same phenomena, gave them a different interpretation, fan- cying an excessive use of the hard cider of that silliest of all political campaigns. But the main intent is admirable—a variant of Emerson's self-reliance and Channing’s greatness of the soul—and there is much striking illustration. “A man’s life,’’ we read, “should: be a stately march to an unheard music; and when to its fellows it may seem irregular and inharmonious, he will be stepping to a livelier measure which only his nicer ear can detect. There will be no halt, ever, but at most a marching on his post, or such a pause as is richer than any sounds, when the deeper melody is no longer heard, but implicitly consented to with the whole life and being. He will never take a false step, even in the most arduous circum- stances; for then the music will not fail to swell into greater volume, and rule the movement it inspired.’”’ With the Wild Gecse. By Emily Lawless. With an Introduction by Stopford A. Brooke, M.A. London: Isbister & Co. Pp, xxvi, 95. Miss Lawless is rightly esteemed one of the best authors of modern Irish fiction, if not the best. She here appears as a poet. The contents of this volume have, it ap- pears, already been handed around in pri- vately printed form. It is due to Mr. Brooke’s persuasion that they are now given to the public, upon condition that he “would write a preface to them which should explain certain matters—among the The Nation. [Vol. 75, No. 1936 rest the title of the book—to those English readers to whom Irish history is an un- known wilderness.”’ The preface is not only an explanation necessary for such readers, but a warm appreciation of the work. “Wild Geese” is the name given to those Irish exiles who, ‘‘like the wild birds and with their wailing cry, migrated to the Con- tinent before and after the battle of Aughrim and the surrender of Limerick in 1691."" Between that date and 1745, 150,000 Irishmen are said to have died in the ser- vice of France alone. Others fought for Spain and Austria. “No words that I have read,’’ says Mr. Brooke, “have realized with more insight and sympathy the temper of these daring, high-bred, honorable, reckless, and sorrow- ful men than those with which Miss Law- less has clothed the bitterness of their exile, their passion for fighting, and their longing for their native land.’’ Besides a fine prefatory address to the Atlantic, laving the shores from which most of the ‘‘wild geese”’ took flight, we are given eight poems on the author’s main theme, two dirges on the Desmond War, six themes suggested by life in the Aran Islands, and five miscellaneous pieces. The intensity of feeling and passion in many of these will, at least to those who have felt deeply about Ireland, suggest the spirit running through ‘Childe Harold.’ The collection opens with a poem of seven stanzas entitled ‘After Aughrim,”’ in which Ireland is supposed to speak: “She said, ‘They gave me of their best, They lived, they gave their lives for me I tossed them to the howling w: Aste, And flung them to the foaming sea. “She said, ‘Ten times they tons zht for me, Ten times they strove with might and main, Ten times I saw them beaten down, Ten times they rose, and — again.’ “She said, ‘God Rnows they owe me nought, I tossed them to the foaming sea, I tossed them to the howling waste, Yet still their love comes home to me. Two poems are entitled ‘‘Fontenoy’’—one describing the joy of the weary Irish sol- diers at the prospect of engaging their Eng- lish foes; the other the weird return to Ireland of the spirit of the victorious dead: “Jesus save you gently! why are ye so white Sitting all so straight and still in this misty light? “Nothing ails us, brother; joyous souls are we, Sailing home together on the morning sea.’’ A lovely address, “To a Tuft of White Bog-Cotton, Growing in the Tyrol,” is in a different strain from most of the other pieces. We quote the first of the seven stanzas: “And Is it thow, small playmate of the fens, Child of damp haunts and pallid sea-borne fogs, Light flutterer over dank and oozy glens, White-tufted, starry friend of Irish bogs! What dost thou, tossed upon this mountain here, Flaunting thy white crest in this alien air? Thy little pennon swelled by this loud breeze Far out of reach of every low compeer; Far from tby barren moor lands, wvste and bare, And distant moan of sullen Celtic seas. The last piece closes with the aes of Ireland’s future: ““T see her in those coming days, Still young, still gay; her unbound hair Crowned with a crown of stariike rays, Serenely fair. I see an envied haunt of peace, Calm and untouched; remote from roar, Where wearied men may from their burdens cease On a still shore.’’ We are mistaken if this volume, attrac- tive in its typography as in its contents, be not destined to take a permanent place on the bookshelves of lovers of Ireland, Forest Neighbors. By Willlam Davenport Hulbert. McClure, Phillips & Co. Biographies of a beaver, a brook trout, a lynx, a porcupine, a loon, and a deer make up this book. Though the author vouches for some of the incidents, he does not say that he has drawn his material from the life of any particular animal which he has known, or that he has made a composite sketch of several such lives; he appears, rather, to have combined ex- periences common or possible to the kind in a bit of clever fiction that does not contradict scientific truth. The book gives evidence of reading and observation join- ed with marked perception of the condi- tions of an animal’s life, and considerable skill in portraying them. Even the sea- soned reader of nature stories gets here a fresh realization of the animal’s struggle for existence, in which it must hold out against hunger, accident, disease, the ri- valry of its own species, and the violence of predatory animals and hostile man. The pain and fear of the trapped creature come home to one sharply in the stories of the beaver and the lynx. Without sermoniz- ing, the book quickens sympathy and makes cruelty hateful. “The King of the Trout Stream” contains good work in em- bryology, and is perhaps the best illus- tration of the author’s knowledge of nat- ural history and his ability to show the interesting side of even an unpromising subject. ‘‘The Making of a Glimmerglass Buck”’ is the most dramatic of the stories. It ends with an unusual incident: “As he [the buck] neared the spring, treading noiselessly on the soft moss, he heard two little clicks, and stopped short to see what they meant. Both were quick and sharp, and both had come exactly at the same instant; yet they were not quite alike, for one had come from the shut- ter of a camera, and one from the lock of a rifle. Across the salt lick a photo- grapher and a hunter were facing each other in the darkness, and each saw the gleam of the other’s eyes and took him for a deer. . “The buck stood and watched, and sud- denly there came two bursts of flame— one of them so big and bright that it _ the woods like sheet-lightning. . . flash-light printed on the sensitive viste a picture of a hunter in the act of fir- ing, and the rifle sent a bullet straight through the photographer’s forehead. The buck saw it all as in a dream—the white flame of the magnesium powder; the rifle belching out its fire and smoke; the cam- era, silent and harmless, but working just as surely; the two men, each straining his eyes for a sight of the game; the water gleaming in the fierce light, and the dark ranks of cedars all around.’”’ Topical Architecture: A Library of Classified Architectural Motives and Details. Edited by William Rotch Ware, Fellow of the Boston Society of Architects. Boston: American Architect and Building News Company. Renaissance Doorways: Italian, I. (1901). Door and Window Grilles in Bronze and Iron, I. (1902). Two parts have reached us of the above work, but there is no statement as to whether these are Parts I. and II. of the whole work, or whether others have ap- peared already. We are therefore unable to inform the reader how far this work may be expected to go. Each volume before us is a collection of plates without text, and with legends merely sufficient to give locality, name of building, and sometimes date or approximate date. Thus, we have, “Doorway leading to the Sacristy, Badia di Fiesole, [1462.] Brunelleschi, Architect,” and, in another case, “Doorway to the eR FSS REISER ISS eer OH TS
Page 23
Feige Aug. 7, 1902] Palazzo Brignole, Genoa. Galeazzo Aless!, Architect”; the first of the plates so named being a half-tone print, the second a re- production from a print in line and credited to the Revue Générale de V Architecture. Some of the doorways are shown in full front— that is, in photographs taken exactly oppo- site the axis of the design, or by reproduc- tion from elevation drawings: though probably the minority, are very picturesque drawings made in the artistic way, or, if wholly photographic, then from a point of view which gives more interest- ing results. It is, however, with deliberate purpose, no doubt, that the more formal way of presentation is chosen. The chief utility of such books as these is to draughtsmen in offices, nor can there be any doubt that those gentlemen prefer the front view, upon which they can apply their dividers without the trouble of making mental calculations as to the true signifi- eance of the details before them. In what we have said, we have dealt only with the book on doorways. The gratings show a more diversified scheme, for some of them are modern and some are ancient; some are on a large scale, and occasionally there are two or even five in a plate; some are in pure photography, and others are photographic copies from outline prints. It need hardly be explained that some of the pieces are very commonplace indeed. Fortunately, it is also true that some there are which have a_ peculiar charm, and even the great merit of being well and originally designed light metal work. It is right to say of the books that, al- though there is no text, there is a two-fold table of contents; the one part managed as an index by location (as Berlin, Prussia, with two specimens; London, England, with four; New York, with perhaps thirty), and the other an index by authorship—that is to say, by the names of the architects who are the designers (as Clinton & Russell with five plates; McKim, Mead & White with five plates; the majority with one plat each). We have tried to describe exactly these books for the benefit of possible pur- chasers, and the description of a folio of miscellaneous examples hardly allows of much enthusiastic praise. It is quite evi- dent that the books will be of great value for those to whose use they are especially devoted. others, metal Les Syndicats Industriels de Producteurs en France et & ’Etranger. Par Paul de Rousiers. Paris: Armand Colin. 1901. Pp. viii, 290. The author of this volume is well known in France as a student of American and English industrial conditions, for he has already published several trustworthy works in that field. The present one is a comparative study of industrial combina- tions, and is divided into three roughly equal parts, dealing respectively with the United States, Germany, and France. M. de Rousiers investigated our own Trusts dur- ing a visit to this country in 1896. During 1899 and 1900, he examined German com- binations, and, in 1901, studied the French selling-pools. In discussing industrial de- velopment outside his own country, he is probably better Informed than most for- eigners who have taken up the subject, The Nation. and his work fs entitled to respect, al- though every one who reads it ifs likely to feel that it is more instructive upon foreign conditions than upon those prevail- ing in the reader’s own country. We think that this is particularly true of the sec- tions relating to the United States. M. de Rousiers has availed himself of most of the recent sources of information, like the work of the Industrial Commission, and has read all the recent books on the sub- ject—such as those of Jenks, Ely, and oth- ers. Despite this careful study, he some- times strays rather far away from his ma- terial. The discussions of French and Ger- man conditions give the same impression. As a whole, the distinctly sketchy. M. de Rousiers analyzes the nature and organization of the principal combinations in the three countries of which he treats. He finds that the chief differences between them lie in the extent to which industries have been concentrated, and in the degree of ruthlessness with which consolidation has been brought about. The United States is regarded as the extreme type of concen- tration in industry. Its Trusts have been formed for the sake of industrial domina- tion; their managers have not hesitated to trample rivals under foot, and the pri- vate ownership of railways has enabled large producers to get illegitimate advan- tage in the shape of discriminating freight rates. Conditions in Germany have been less trying for the small producer. While it is true that the principle of monopoly has been recognized by the volume is yovernment, some Trusts being directly supported by it, there has been far less effort to exclude the small manufacturer from the market. The consolidations have been unions of producers at the expense of the consuming class, and their main end has been to limit output and so maintain prices at a point that may be profitable for all. In France, most combinations have aimed simply at certain economies of production and dis- tribution and at an equitable division of business. In all three countries, however, M. de Rousiers recognizes the existence of certain tariff Trusts which control special lines of production through Government favor, without any of the reasons for ex- istence that prevail in other industries. The author is weakest when he deals with the combinations from a theoretical stand- point. The only explanation of the ex- istence of the Trust that he gives is that “industrial and commercial concentration, necessitated by modern economic evolu- tion, compels those who are engaged in in- dustry to draw closer and to unite their efforts in order to rise superior to new tendencies.”” As Gen. Walker once sald, “Some evolutionists ought to be hanged.” What is needed in the discussion of the Trust problem is not a mere reference to evolution as the ‘“‘cause’’ of the Trust, but some clear indication of the industrial result to be expected from the combina- tions and of the changes they are likely to introduce into economic theory. About all that M. de Rousiers has to offer on this aspect of the question is the well-worn ob- servation that the combinations do no harm so long as they confine themselves to industrial affairs and hold aloof from political activity. 119 Prisoners of Russia. By Benjamin Howard M.A., M.D., ete. D. Appleton & Co. 1902 Those who, some five or six vears ago, in this city, heard the late Dr. Howard lecture on his “personal study of convict life in Sakhalin and Siberia,” or have read the lecture in the Proceedings of the American Geographical Society, are already acquaint ed with the admirable spirit of fairn sympathy, and common sense which distin guishes this volume from many others on allied subjects. Dr. Howard's long famil iarity with prison problems in other coun tries also rendered him eminently qua 1 to pronounce with authority on the m and demerits of the Russian exile sy which is seen in its worst representat ; in Sakhalin, to which this work is mainly devoted. He, in common with some of Great Britain's Fenian ex-prisoners (whos« on this of years ago), regards the Russian system, ments subject we printed a number with its principle of making use of the criminal for the good of the State, allow ing him comparative freedom and exert cise, with the ultimate prospect of a free life, as infinitely superior to any system in vogue in other lands. He mak: a strong argument from the conditions formerly pr vailing in Australia, and the effect upon the moral character of prisoners in som« There is some repetition on this point and a few others, what similar circumstance indicating that his chapters originally fig ured as separate lectures or articles Revision in this respect, and in regard to the Russian quoted, would have im proved the volume as to literary qual- ity and accuracy. The author also fall into errors when he makes statements about the rites of the Eastern Catholic Church, such as, that the children receive the Holy Communion in advance of the priests; that little white loaves, with spear-shaped in cisions, are purchased after the morning service by the congregation at will; that it is a rare and unusual thing (so much so that he had never met a foreigner who had had the experience) to see the various services connected with baptism, chrisma tion, and ablution on the eighth day, ‘‘all, and in their proper order of succession, on a single occasion,” together with the “Prayers for a Woman on the Fortieth Day after the Birth of a Child” (correspondit to the “Thanksgiving of Child-birth’” in the Church); and, most astounding of all, that the “‘Athanasian Creed, Women aft Anglican-Episcopai according e&x to the English version,” Is recited during one of these services As to these state- Athanasian Creed is absolutely unknown, in any form ments, it may be said that the whatever, to the Eastern Catholic Chure! the sole one in use being that of Nicea Constantinople; that the priests invariably communicate first, although in some plas (chiefly in the Greek branch) children un- der seven years of age are given the bread and wine before consecration, which | probably what Dr. Howard saw; and that the first three rites above mentioned, orig inally separate, are now performed in im mediate succession, and can be seen aime any Sunday in the year, even in the Ru t sian churches in various American ¢ while the last is equally frequent, though not generally performed at the conclusion of the others. The little loave moreover, have been purchased | wre the service (not at the end), and spear-shaped particles
Page 24
The Nation. [Vol. 75, No. 1936 120 ; have been removed by the priest in the | sanctuary, accompanied by prayers for the health of the living or the repose of the dead persons indicated by the purchasers, who merely receive back their loaves at the end of the service. Hence, Dr. Howard here misses the import of the custom as well. Dr. Howard is under the impression that no work exists, in any language, on the subject of Sakhalin, by any person who has ever actually lived there. In this he is mis- taken; a fine one does exist, by a ‘‘politi- cal,”’ who lived there for years, and who even sets forth, in plain language, the af- fair at Onor to which Dr. Howard alludes by a quotation from an English newspaper of 1892. He is also mistaken—obviously so, in the light of this last fact cited—in his re- mark: ‘‘As the result of my inquiries, not only in Sakhalin itself, but in various parts of Russia as well, I came to think that it is rather the policy of the Russian Govern- ment to discourage any definite informa- tion about Sakhalin from reaching the Rus- sian people’’—and so forth. Yet the ex- political’s book above mentioned was li- censed, pictures and all, by the censor! On the whole, however, Dr. Howard's book should be read by every person who is interested in Russia, or in prison prob- lems (and he makes valuable suggestions on other points as well). It is delightful in style, and inspires one with a high and af- fectionate regard for the man who could write such an impartial, eminently practi- cal work. Tetraewangelium sanctum juxta simplicem Syrorum versionem ad fidem codicum, massore, editionum Oxford : Clarendon Press; New York: H. Frowde. Pp. xvi, 608. The editio princeps of the New Testament in Syriac appeared at Vienna in 1555. Less than forty years had passed since the editio princeps of the Greek text had seen the light; now this new venture came to add its element to the breaking up of old things which Erasmus had wrought. The unmatch- ed authority of the Vulgate had been blown down the wind; was the Greek original in its turn to yield to something still more original? That Widmanstadt, the editor of the Syriac, had any clear idea on this may not be certain; it is certain from his ram- bling preface, full of strange learning mix- ed with personal history, that he felt him- self launching out on an unknown sea of vague possibilities. He did not belong to the first fresh dawn of humanism, either Latin or Greek, but to that later time when the world was opening east and west, and the Orient was beginning again to pour its treasures on Europe. The place of Greek fugitives as teachers of new lore was taken for him by Syrian Christians in the Rome. Names on his lips denuo recognitum, schools at The Nation, 74¢e Bookbuyer, The Dial, The Times’ Saturday Review, The Tribune, The Outlook, Life, Public Opinion, The Literary World, The Brooklyn Eagle, The Chicago Post, and The Philadelphia Times, are some of the leading authorities that praise Miss Godfrey’s Romance, THE WINDING ROAD (Cireular on application.) Henry Holt & Co. xen Yor: , are those of Magellan, Reuchlin, Ximenes, Pico de Mirandola, Leo Africanus—above all, Theseus Ambrosius, the first of Syriac scholars in Europe. Of his meeting with the last and the inspiration gained from him for this edition, he gives a vivid account. It was the Oriental renaissance. And thus it is not strange that the conception of Syriac as the native tongue of Jesus should have haunted him; so he had learned to think of it from his Maronite teachers. He had clearly grasped the modern position that a sound exegesis and understanding of the Gospels must be based on an appreciation of the fact that their ultimate sources, writ- ten or oral, were Aramaic; that the life in them had been lived in an Aramaic atmos- phere. The editio princeps was followed by oth- ers in rapid succession; there were at least seven more in the sixteenth century. But neither then nor until now was there one which could claim to present a new and critical text. The sources of the editions of Urmia and Mosul, which came closest to this, were unknown, and these editions could rank only as single and probably good MSS. To all appearance, the Widmanstadt text had come to be regarded as a sufficient- ly faithful reproduction of the original Peshita, the accepted version of the an- cient Syriac Church. It took the great critical controversy over the Greek text itself, which culminated in the edition of Westcott and Hort, to shake this trust. The Syriac accepted text agreed most closely with the “received” Greek text, and disagreed most strikingly with the now reconstructed critical text. Did, then, this Syriac text actually represent the text re- ceived by the Syriac Church in the fourth century and earlier, or had it been cor- rupted in process of time as was alleged to have befallen the Greek text? So stood the problem. The defenders of the tertus re- ceptus, notably Dean Burgon, buttressed themselves with the Syriac, and branded the Westcott and Hort text as the most cor- rupt ever printed. To maintain this posi- tion and to resolve the question, an elab- orate critical edition of the Gospels was planned by the late Philip Edward Pusey. He had collated many MSS. and collected much material when, in 1880, his lamented death intervened. Thereafter the work was tween Jacobites and Nestorlians. | these are little things, and we leave this taken up by the present editor, George Henry Gwilliam. He has made use of forty- one MSS., ranging from copies of the fifth century down, of the Urmia edition and of the Nestorian Massoretic MSS. His result, which can hardly be impugned, may be given in his own words: ‘‘We can demon- strate that the Peshitto version of the Gos- pels has not been corrupted in later times; but, on the contrary, that whatsoever va- riations it exhibits from the Greek, date from a most remote antiquity. Our au- thorities are products of both the great | Woodward, schools of Syriac Christianity, while our most ancient copies connect our readings with those of the undivided Syriac Church.” The fixed fact, then, appears to be that the Syriac version crystallized much earlier than did the Greek text, and, since that crystallization, has been handed on with a unity of recension which reminds most of all of the Massoretic text of the Old Testa- ment; further, that this crystallized form, existing certainly in the fifth century, was in close agreement with the Greek terlus receptus. Mr. Gwilliam would be inclined to go much further, but so far there can be no disputing his results. Yet this simply raises new problems. We have now got the ecclesiastical text of the ancient Syriac Church. What relation does it bear to the Curetonian MS., to the Si- naitic MS., to the version used by Aphra- ates, to the old Latin version, and to the Codex Beze? Here be questions! The fountains of the great deep, which were thought effectively and finally sealed by Westcott and Hort, are broken up again, and those who followed in the forlorn hope of Dean Burgon are meeting with their re- ward. It may not turn out to be precisely what they expect or want, but it was no mare’s-nest which they found. Of Mr. Gwilliam’s present edition it is hard to speak in other terms than of the most absolute praise. He has executed his task admirably, and it is in the hope that he is now at work on the remainder of the New Testament that we would venture the following criticisms. The Latin version— added for the benefit of theologians who do not know Syriac, and of these there should be none—is too literal. It will often mis- lead the non-Syriac reader as to what the Syriac really means. Next, the chapters should be indicated on each page; at pres- ent, only luck or patience enables the read- er to find his place. Again, the proof- reading of the Syriac could be more careful. But that is a thorny subject; in proof- reading the heart knoweth its own bitter- ness. The annotations, too, contain an ex- cellent apparatus criticus, but there is also in them a number of notes, grammatical and otherwise, which would perhaps be bet- ter away. The user of this edition may be presumed to know his Syriac grammar and such matters as differences of spelling be- But all edition with an expression of renewed hope that it may soon be completed. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Budge, E. A. W. chaic Periods. H. Frowde. Hutton, Edward. Studies in the Lives of the Saints. London: Archibald Constable & Co.; New York: E. P. Dutton & Co. $1.25. Purser, L. C. M. Tullii Ciceronis Epistolae, Vol. Ill. Henry Frowde. 2s. 6d. On a Donkey’s Hurricane Deck. I. H. Blanchard Co, Egypt in the Neolithic and Ar- Nature Study and Life By CLIFTON F. HODGE | } of Clark University. | “Tt is not too strong praise to say that this is | an epoch making book, and should find its way | | Intoevery home as well aa achool,”"—J. R. Srreer | of Syracuse University in Journal of Pedagogy, | | June, 1902. | GINN & COMPANY, Publishers, | | Boston New York Chicago London | Chickering Pianos The OLDEST in AMERICA ; THE BEST in the WORLD WRITE Chickering & Sons FORTE MAKERS MASSACHUSETTS FOR CATALOGUE PITANO BOSTON,