The Nation 1902-06-12: Vol 74 Iss 1928

Page 1

VOL. LXXIV—NO. 1928. THURSDAY, JUNE. 12, 1902. PRICE TEN CENTS. : & } t IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENT TO BE PUBLISHED THIS FALL History of the Expedition of Captains Lewis and Clark 1804-5-6 OTWITHSTANDING that in America few names are more familiar upon the tongue than Lewis and Clark, it is a singular fact that at the present moment a full and adequate account of what they did is almost unattainable. The complete journals of the explorers are still in manuscript. The published work of 1814, abridged and adapted from the journals by the accomplished Nicholas Biddle (though the name of another appears on the title-page as editor), has long been out of print. The frag- mentary accounts that preceded the Biddle edition have become very rare, as also the various foreign presentments, English, Dutch, German, and French. The noble reprint of the Biddle edition which appeared in 1893, prefaced, annotated, and supple- mented in every needful way by Dr. Elliott Coues, a work of great bulk and cost, has quite disappeared from the market. At the present moment whoever desires to own the story of Lewis and Clark must content himself with abridged compendia or unsatisfactory reprints, or pay high for copies, usually tattered and mildewed, in auction rooms and the stores of dealers in old books. The lack thus existing, felt now more and more as the centenary of the great ex. ploration draws near, Messrs. A. C. McClurg & Co. propose to make good. In the early Fall of 1902, there will appear over their imprint a beautifully printed edition of the Travels in handy form, at a popular price, which will be planned to fill all the requirements of libraries and private buyers, and thus become the standard edition of this great American classic. The text will be that of the Biddle edition, which must hold its place as the only account approaching adequacy. This new edition, then, will be a reprint of the Biddle text of 1814 complete. Its bulk will not be increased by annotation, but it will be carefully supervised by Dr. James K. Hosmer, Librarian of the Minneapolis Public Library, a well-known specialist in matters pertaining to Western history, the author of ‘‘ A Short History of the Mis- sissippi Valley” and ‘A History of the Louisiana Purchase.” Dr. Hosmer will prepare a careful analytic Index, a feature which the original edition lacked, and furnish an Introduction giving the events which led up to the great expedition, and the vast development that has flowed from it, in a way to make plain the profound significance of the achievement. Fac-similes of all the maps of the 1814 edition will be given, together with the best extant portraits of the heroes of the enterprise. The edition will be in two square octavo volumes of over 500 pages each, printed from a new font of pica old style type, on an extra quality soft laid paper, with uncut edges. . In Two Volumes, with Portraits and Maps, $5.00 net. A.C. MCCLURG & CO., PUBLISHERS, CHICAGO

Page 2

The Nation. [Vol. 74, No. 1928 The Nation. 4 WEEELY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science, and Art. FOUNDED 1865. [ Dntered at the New York City Post-Office as second- class mail matter. | CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER, BE Hie rcbckches sass cteccccteescusesaur sone eneee 455 EDITORIAL ARTICLES: Overloading the President ................ 458 The House Philippine Bill ....... -. 458 "TREAIOTURIGR” noc 00 ccnedavccss - 459 Our — % riority in Manufacturing 460 England After the War ......... 460 American Scholarships at Oxford .. 461 SPROIAL CORRESPONDENCE: The Paste Galees ocvacesvccsecvsanvacness 462 Mediwval Art at the Diisseldorf Exposition 464 CORRESPONDENCE: Rasa CR OTE OE © iis 5506 once t btsesvesese® 465 Early Puppet-Show Pictures ............. 465 Wordsworth’s ‘‘Ode to Duty’’ ............ 465 OCG, 0csnnnses cine cndons nbvébedeteedicatersesenteesss 466 Book REevirws: oR ee ee ee eee 468 Novels, Mostly of American Life.......... 469 Americad GATORS 2 .cccccccsccceseccesvece Uncle Sam, Trustee WUMIARE ccccccessnvvcveses TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three Doliars per year in advance, postpaid, to any part of the United States or Canada; to foreign countries comprised in the Postal Union, $4.00. The date when the subscription expires is on the address label of each paper, the change of which to a subsequent date becomes a receipt for remittance, No other receipt is sent unless requested, Remitiances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter, or by check, express or- der, or Postal Order, payable to ‘Publisher of the Nation.” When a change of address is desired, both the old and new addresses should be given. Address THE NATION, Box 794, New York. Publication Office, 208 Broadway. TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Fifteen cents per agate line, each insertion; 1,4 lines to the inch. Twenty per cent, advance for choice of page, or top of column. A column, $20 each insertion; with choice of page, $21. A page, $60 each insertion; front-cover page, $80. Advertisements must be acceptable in every re- spect, Copy received until Tuesday, 6 P. M. Discounts upon application. DISCOUNTS. Tims— 4 IMOOTHIONS. .....cccscccrccovecssesecccces 5 per cent. 8 > see - 10 R 18 ” 26 = uv 62 i) AmouNT— $100 within DIOR o cccntovscesscevcccnves’ 10 per cent. 250 - 1vlg “ 1 ,600 “ “ $000 “« *« The NATION is sent free to those who advertise in it as long as advertisement continues. *,.* Copies of the Nation may be procured in Paris at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de l’Opéra. and in London of B. F. Stevens & Brown, Trafalgar Square, Charing Cross. Educational. MABYLAND. Baltimore, 122 aud 124 W. Franklin St. DGE WORTH BOARDING and DAY School for Girls—39th year will begin September 26, 1901. Mrs. H. P. LEFEBVE: Miss ie: D. Huxrier, ¢ Principals. MassaCuusETtTs, Bosto OSTON UNIVERSITY Law School. Address the Dean, SAMUEL C. BENNETT. Massacuvsetts, Hyde Park, Suburban to Boston. frAiRMOont SCHOOL for right girls, Sixth year. Mrs. S. A. Foster, ncipal. MICHIGAN, Detroit, 73 Stinson Place. ETROIT HOME and DAY SCHOOL, 25th Year. hag: pe for all ee open to wo- men. 20 received in the school family. The Misses Liege xtt, Principals. New York, Washington Heights, Depot Lane. A SCHOOL FORK ATYPICAL AND NERVOUS CHILDREN. Healthy location. Sum- mer course, Expert educational home treatment. MAXIMILIAN P. «. GROSZMANN, Pd. 1.D., Director. PENNSYLVANIA, Rosemont, 1 mile from Bryn Mawr ollege. HE MISSES KIRK, formerly connected with Bryn Mawr College will begin the 4th year of their College Preparatory School for Girls in a new and larger house, on October 2, 1992. Number of boarders limited to twelve. Careful individual instruction. TSS ANABLE'S Boarding and Dey School for Girls. Established in 1848. Circular nf application. ©pensSept 26. 1850 Pine St., Phila, Pa. Royal Victoria College, McGILL UNIVERSITY, MONTREAL. A residential Ooliege for the Women Students of McGill University. For con‘itions of entrance — arships, courses egrees, terms of residence, and oth particulars, address THE WARDEN, Royal Victoria College, Montreal. Lasell Seminary AVBURNDALE, MASS. Aschool of the first class for young women. Gives thorough tratning in a liberal arts course _ wholly for young women, adding its specialty of House- hold Economics. Boston Masters in Music and Art Annex de ,—yo of household practice a decided success. For catalogue, address C.C. BRAGDON, Principal. MASSACHUSETTS, ANDOVER. Anpover THEOLOGICAL SEMINARY NINETY-FIFTH Year Begins Sept. 17, 1902. Thorough instruction for college graduates in all branches of theological study. Elective system. Large library. Special lectures upon missionary and practica questions. Student associate work in Boston and other city churches. For catalogues or information apply to Professor C. O. DAY. Educational. Massachusetts Institute of Technology, BOSTON. HENRY S. PRITCHETT, Ph.D., LL.D., President. The Institute offers four-year courses in Civil Mechanical, Mining, Electrical, Chemical, an Sanitary Engineering, in Architecture, Metallur- gy, Chemistry, Physics, Biology, Geology, on Na- val Architecture, and in General Studies. Special advantages are offered to teachers. Summer Courses in June and July Catalogues and detailed circulars of informa- tion will be sent free on application. H. W. TYLER, Secretary, 491 Boylston St., Boston. — PORTLAND SUMMER SCHOOL, Portland, Maine. JULY 14 to AUGUST 22. ARNOLD WERNER-SPANHOOFD, Director “ Better than going yp 2 ay and the best preparation for a trip abroad.” The Portland Summer School can claim the honora- ble distinction of being the oldest summer school in the United States. It is the direct descendant of the famous Sauveur Summer School. founded in 1875 at Amherst College, and is heir to all its best traditions. Courses in German, French, English, Italian, Spanish, Latin, Greek, Art, and Music. For illustrated Circular, apply to the Sowmetees Mrs FRANK B. CLARK, 133 Emery 8t., Portland, Maine. HARVARD UNIVERSITY EXAMINATION FOR ADMISSION will be held in New York City, in the lecture-room of the Y. M.C. A. Building, 23d St., cor 4th Ave., andin Newport, R I, in the Rogers High School Bui ilding, on ‘on June | 23 to 28 inciusive. RADCLIFFE COLLEGE EXAMINATION FOR ADMISSION And the Harvard Examination for women will be held in Albany, at the place and time as stated above for the xamination for admission to Har- vard University. Harvard Medical School SUMMER COURSE IN PHYSIOLOGY Address THE DEAN, 688 Boylston St., Boston, Mass. PENNSYLVANIA, Bryn Mawr. Miss Baldwin’s School for Girls Preparatory to Bryn Mawr College Miss FLORENCE BALDWIN, Principal. Within 11 sone more than 145 pupils have entered Bryn Mawr College from this school. Diploma given in both General and covere ao nt! Courses. Fine fire-proof stone building acres of beautiful grounds. For circular, address ine Secretary. MASSACHUSETTS, CONCORD. Miss White’s Home School. Exceptional advantages. Individual progress as- sured. _ Circulars. SWITZERLAND, GENEVA. A SELECT HOME SCHOOL for 6 BOYS. Ex rienced American tutoring in acultured French- sshome. Summer inthe Alps. Unique penvanenges, For F ber let and superior references, OUR, M.A., No, 20 Avenue de Laney, Geneva. Mrs. Delaiield and Mrs. Colvin’s SCHOOL FOR GIRLS Successors to Miss Heloise EF. Hersey. An institution of the highest scholarship Offering exceptional surroundings and relation- ships to those who value them at an increased cost. Only pene | a with eleven teachers secures the most careful personal supervision. No pupil rec’d without a personal interview. Terms, #/,250 a year. 2« and 46 Chestnut Street. Boston. ° The Browne and Nichols School Cambridge, Mass. 20th year. Course, 8 vears. Classes limited to 15. No subordinate teachers; pupiis continu- ously under head teacher in each department. Excep- tional facilities for fitting for Harvard. lilus- trated catalogue. THE HIGHLAND MILITARY ACADEMY, Worcester, Mass, 47th year. Healthfu: location. Generous table. Preparation for coliege, scientific, or business life. Newly equipped laboratories. Athletic field. Small classes. The Rt. Rev. ALEXANDER H. VINTON, D.D.. Visitor. JOSEPH ALDEN | SHAW, A. \.M., _Head Master. Rock 2°09 povs at Welleste Hill |-atelers Mas a use tts Abbot Academy “wass”™ A high-grade achool for girls. Fine ye Com- plete modern equipment. Fine bulldi Ample pro- vision for outdoor exercise. Personal. “attention of teachers. Address The Principal. Camp Portanimicut 4 8UMMER camp South Orleans, Mass. Golf, baseball, salt-water swim- ming and sallin Tutoring. Address GIBSON BELL, A.B., 8t. Paul’s School, Concord, N. H. Teachers, etc. M. WEBER. B.D., PA.D. (Universities: Bonn, Strassburg, and Yale.) Instructor in Languages and Mathematics, 455 George St , New Haven, Conn. Coaching for entering any de- partment of Yale University a specialty.

Page 3

June 12, 1902] The Nation. The Johns Hopkins University BALTIMORE, MARYLAND. —_— TWENTY-SEVENTH YEAR. Beginning October 1, 1902. President : Ina Remsen; Dean of the Medical Faculty : Wrmu1am H. Howeii; Dean of the Col- lege Faculty : Epwarp H. GRIFFIN. Instruction. For GRADUATE STUDENTS: (a) In Philosophy and the Arts. (Courses for candidates for the degree of Ph. D.) (b) In Medicine. (Courses for candidates for the degree of M.D.; courses for physicians. ) For UNDERGRADUATES : (c) As candidates for the degree of B. A. (d) As special students. Libraries. 105,000 volumes. 145.000 volumes. 200,000 volumes. University, Peabody Institute, Pratt Library, Laboratories. Directors. Chemistry. Ira Remsen. Physics. Joseph S. Ames. Geology and Mineralogy. William B. Clark. Zoblogy. William K. Brooks. Anatomy. Franklin P. Mall. Physiology. William H. Howell. Pathology and Bacteriology. William H. Welch. Pharmacology. John J. Abel. Physiological Chemistry. Clinical Medicine. John J. Abel. William Osler. Seminaries. Directors. Greek. Basil L. Giidersleeve. Latin. Kirby F Smith. Sanskrit. Maurice Bloomfield, Semitic. Paul Haupt. German. Henry Wood. Romance. A. Marshall Elliott. English. James W. Bright. History. John M. Vincent. Economics. J. H. Hollander. Mathematics. Frank Morley. Physics. Joseph S. Ames. Undergraduate Courses (leading to B. A.) Groups. 1. Classical (the “told college course”’). 2. Mathematical-Physical (leading up to engineering). 8. Chemical] Biological (leading up to medicine). 4. Geological-Biological. 5. Latin-Mathematical. 6. Historical-Political (leading up to law). 7. Modern Languages. Serial Publications. American Journal of Mathematics (vol. XXIV). American Chemical Journal (vol. XXVIII). American Journal of Philology (vol. XXIII). Studies in Historical and Political Science(vol.XX). Modern Language Notes (vol. XVII). Memoirs from the Biological Laboratory (vol. V). Contributions to Assyriology (vol. IV). Journal of Experimental Medicine (vol. VI). Terrestrial Magnetism (vol. VII). University Circulars (vol, XXI). Programmes of the courses offered to graduate students in Philosophy and the Arts and in the de- partment of Medicine, and also of the under- graduate or collegiate courses, will be sent on ap- plication to the Registrar. An Unusual Book by a New Author ‘‘In the Country God Forgot” shows marked originality and gives a fine pic- ture of Arizona life. We have depicted the strange, burning hate of an old Ari- zonian for his only son. —Pniladelphia Felegraph. IN THE It is essentially a rugged book. It pos- sesses a compelling power which forces the reader to continue to the end. —N. Y. Com'l Advertiser. COUNTRY The literary value will give it a perma- nence which not one in a hundred of the tales of adventure with which the ooun- ters of the booksellers are crowded to-day can hope to attain.— Boston Courier, GOD FORGOT By Frances Charles 12mo, 338 pages. $1.50 LITTLE, BROWN & CO.,Publishers, Boston Parliamentary Usage FOR Women’s Clubs. By EMMA A. FOX, Recording Secretary of the General Federation of Women’s Clubs. I6mo, cloth, 65c. net. Flexible leather, net, $1.00. Designed for the use of women’s assembiles. Mrs. + ox is the recognized authority amo.ug club women, on the subject of parliamentary law. Her book is ciear, con ise, and authoritative. THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO., New York DAVIS’ ELEMENTARY PHYSICAL GEOGRAPHY. By Prorgssor Davis of Harvard University. xvili+40! pages. With Maps and [llustrations. List Price $1.25; Mailing Price $1.40 GINN & COMPANY, Publishers, Boston New York Chicago London BOOKS When calling please ask for AT MR. ‘GRANT. LIBERAL Whenever you need a book DISCOUNTS. address Mr. Grant. Before buying books write for quotations. An as- sortment of catalogues and special slips of books at reduced prices sent for 10-cent stamp. P. BE. GRANT, eaener 23 W. 42p Sr. - NEW YORK. (Mention this ation and receive a discount.) School Agencies. HE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES. Everett 0. Fisk & Co., Proprietors. 4 Ashburton Place, Boston, 1505 Pa. Ave., Washington. 156 Fifth Ave , New York, 414 Cent. Bidg.,Minneapoils, 633 Cooper Bidg.,Denver, 40 Third St.. Portiand. 203 Mich. Bivd., Chicago, 545 Stimson Biock, Los Angeles, Hyde BIk., Spokane, 420 Parrott Bidg., San Francisco LBANY TEACHERS' AGENCY, 81 Chapel St., Albany, N.Y.—Provides achools of all grades with competent teachers. Assists teachers in obtaining positions. Kenta and sells School Property HaRBLan P. Furenon, Proprietor. “CHERMERHORN Teachers’ Agency. » Teachera—Schools—T utors—Governess ye. ao Fs of Joun C. Rockwmii, Mgr., 3 E. 14th t »* Remington Typewriter lasts longest—so does the Remington operator. The Remington does not overwork the operator. The operater cannot over- work the Remington. WYCKOFF, SEAMANS &@ BENEDICT (Remington Typewriter Company 327 Broadway, New York Travel. A Trip to Colorado at Small Cost During June an going to ae d o} tourist tickets $25 from ; hic at les t ago, $21 fron : ' ames and address tors. informationabou fishing, guides, livery and with the book I will ser telling about the ticket rates and train Service Laciret Address P. S. EUSTIS Traffic Manager, Chic igo, Bur & Quincy Ry., 209 Adams St., ( n senger ngton hicago. To Europe With Safety and Speed. Average voyage less than 7 days. Boston to — and Liverpool Take one of the Palatial Row Twin Screw DOMINION LINE Sailing from B. & M. R.R. Docks as follows: MBRIvS (Dew), 24; New ENGLaNv, June 4, and Wednesdays the e 4. Further information of RICHARDS, MILLS & CO., 77-81 State Bt., Boston GOING ABROAD on a BICYCLE TRIP? Send for “ Bicycling Notes for Tourists Abroad.” LEYLAND LINE Every Wednesday. Boston—Liverpool—London First Cabin, $65 upwerds, depending on steamer. Immense new steamers. Splendi: d steamer “Armenian,” June 11; ** Devo- nian,” June 26; “Iberian,” to Loadon June 38: * Caledonian,” to London June 21; “ Iberian,” to London July 8. P. 0. HOUGHTON & CO., Gen’! Agts. Telephone 1359 Main. 11g State Street, Boston.

Page 4

lv The Nation. [Vol. 74, No. 1928 The Most Important Whist Book in Many Years THE PRINCIPLES AND PRACTICE OF WHIST By LENNARD LEIGH and ERNEST BERGHOLT. With EXAMPLES, ILLUSTRATIVE DEALS, CRITICAL ENDINGS, MATHEMATICAL CALCULATIONS, TABLES OF PROBABILI- TIES, etc., etc., including an Essay on PROBABILITIES, by WILLIAM H. WHITFELD, [1.A. Cantab. “The book is admirably planned for the student. It is a very important and valuable addi- tion to whist literature.’’-—FisHer Amxs, author of “A Practical Guide for Whist.” “A better guide for the learner or book of reference for the expert could hardly be devised.” —Cnar_es E. Corrin, au'hor of “Gist of Whist.” **T believe it will be of great benefit to whist players and to the game of whist.’’—The late Gen. A. W. Drayson, author of ** The Art of Practical Whist,” after seeing MS. * Precisely what was required by the whist world to bring the grand old game into thor- oughly healthy grooves.’’—CoLonEL B. Lows.ey, author of ‘‘ Whist of the Future.” “You have produced a work on whist which will cong serviceable both to the beginner and to the advanced player.’’—N. B. Trist, author of ** Whist.”” ** An exceedingly valuable addition to whist literature.”°—WIL.iam 8. FENOLLOosA. ‘It is the best work on the game ever issued in this country, and for completeness in giving everything a whist student could require is the most satisfactory and best gotten up work ever offered to the public.”"—ELLwoop T. BakER ‘I haveno hesitation in pronouncing the book the soundest, most thorough and cunvincing exposition of basic whist principles that has ever been written.”—W. A. Potrsr, Whist editor of Providence Journal. ‘No book on the game has ever been praised so generally and so highly. We strongly recommend it to all whist players; the poor players will be instructed. the good ones will profit by it, and the experts will find it a never ending source of enjoyment.""—W. H. Samson in the Rochester Post Express. Crown 8vo. Cloth, extra gilt top. Net, $1.50; by mail, $1.68 ‘* As dainty, as finished, and as beautiful asa miniature.’’ THE WESTCOTES By A. T. QVILLER-COVCH Illustrated by J. L. GEROME FERRIS. I2mo, Cloth, $1,00 THE WESTCOTES has been running as a serial simultan ‘ously in “ The Era’’ in this country and “Blackwood’s Magazine’ in England. The London “Spectator”? and “ The Speaker” both give it high praise. It is a charming tale, with all Mr. Quiller- Couch’s delicacy of touch and high literary quality, “It is very rare to come across a book which so fully satisfies the demands of the fastidious reader.”’—London Bookman. Aineianhiy written romance.’’—London Spec- ator. “There is a charming old-world courtesy about this book, a faint and rare fragrance emanating from it, a mellow, a fine tone sounding through it.."—The Academy, London. “A delightful story, told in his usual felicitous style.”"—Chicago Journal. ““A sweet and tranquil idyll, fluttered, but not overwhelmed by genuine passion.’’—N. Y. bune. “Treated with infinite delicacy.’”°—London Saturday Review. “It has quite as much literary distinction of manner as any of its author’s books.”—The Outlook, N. Y. “The book shows that the author has pro- gressed in his art to a position warranting a be- lief in his permanence."’"—N. Y. Times Saturday Review. ‘A tale of rare delicacy and feeling.”’—Detroit Free Press. HENRY T. COATES & CO., Publishers, Philadelphia. LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO.’"S NEW BOOKS The Path to Rome By HILAIRE BELLOC, Author of “The Life of Dinton,’”’ “Robespierre,” etc. With 80 illustrations from Drawings by the Author. Crown 8vo, 464 pages, gilt top, $2.00 net. By mail, $2.20. *,* The author herein describes a walk of 600 miles taken last summer from the town in Lorraine, where he was once in garrison, to Rome, il- lustrating in some eighty sketches the scenes through which he passed. The All,” etc. NEW STORY BY EDNA LYALL. Hinderers A Tale of the Present Time By Edna Lyall, author of “Donovan,” “We Two,’ “In Spite of Crown 8vo, $1.00. The book is not only a description of his journey, but contains also a number of such anecdotes and stories as occur to him, or are suggested by his adventures. The German Empire of To-day Outlines of Its Formation and Development By “VERITAS.” With Map. Crown 8vo, pp, x-340, $2.25. *,* This book deals in broad outline with the formation of the present empire up to 1871. and with its subsequent development up to 1900, The object of the author is to place before the British public reliable informa- tion on such subjectaas the Army, Navy, Commercial and Colonial Policy, Colonial Possessions, National Education, and German Finances. Tommy Cornstalk Being Some Account of the Less Notable Features of the South African War from the Point of View of the Australian Ranks. By J. H, M. ABBorT, late Corporal,.ist Australian Horse. 8vo, pp. xii.-264, $2.00, ““A more valuable book on the war has not yet been written, nor one more vivid. nor one more interesting."’— Daily Graphic, Crown *,* The story opens on the day of Queen Victoria's death and closes in January Of the present year. It deals with the subject of Peace and War, and gives the experiences of a heroine who is suddenly transported from a quiet home in the tropics to “Smart Society” in England. 4 The Foundations of Belief Being Notes Introductory to the Study of Theology. By the Right Hon. ARTHUR J. BALFour. Eighth Edition Revised. With a New Introduction (28 pp.) and Summary (21 pp.). Crown 8vo, $2.00 net. By mail, $2 15. Color Problems A Practical Manual for the Lay Student of Color By EMILY NOYES VANDERPOEL. With 117 Plates in color. $5.00 net. By mail, $5.22. ‘A better understanding of color would be of great value to decora- tors, designers, lithographers, florists, women, in their dress and home decoration, and many others. For such to combine the essential results of the scientific and arti tic study of color in a concise, practical manual, and to classify the study of color in individual a in light, in history, and in nature, has been the aim of the author of this book. Also as color cannot be full Tp leapevete by any written description, the text has been made as brief as possible, the plates full and elaborate.”—From Author's Preface. 8vo, LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., g1-93 Fifth Avenue, New York

Page 5

Silda DA alae ar oA ae mei The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, JUNE 12, 1902. The Week. In substituting its own bill for the Senate measure for protecting the Pres- ident and punishing anarchists, the House has been well advised. The terms of the Senate bill are less carefully guarded, from a legal point of view, than those of the House; and the proposal to make even an attempt upon the life of the President punishable with death is one to which American penal laws will probably not long, if ever, give place. As a deterrent it would be, from the nature of the case, valueless. So would be the provisions against the immigra- tion and naturalization of anarchists, which are contained, tonearly the same effect, in both bills. The Senate bill, how- ever, takes the palm for absurdity in the clause providing a bodyguard for the President, consisting of a detail from the regular army. This would be exceed- ingly distasteful to any conceivable Pres- ident; most of all, one would say, to Mr. Roosevelt. Certainly, it would take an active and well-mounted bodyguard to attend him. ‘ They’ll have fleet steeds that follow,” he would say, Lochinvar- like, as he set off for his daily cross- country. The House very properly refus- ed to agree to anything like a Swiss Guard at the White House. The conclusion of the debate on the Philippine bill in the Senate was dark- ened by a tale of torture quite as hor- rible as the acts of Major Waller and the orders of “‘Hell-Roaring Jake.” Just be- fore the vote was to be taken on the bill, Senator Culberson said that he had been trying to secure the passage of a resolution calling for copies of charges preferred by Private Andrew K. Weir of the Fourth Cavalry against Lieut. Arnold and Sergeant Edwards of that regiment, but that action on the reso- lution had been deferred from day to day, at the instance of Senators Spoon- er and Lodge, who desired to know first whether a court-martial had been or- dered in the case. Mr. Culberson had got tired waiting for other Senavors to satisfy their private curiosity, and ac- cordingly had procured for himself a copy of the charges of Private Weir, and also a copy of a report made thereon by Capt. P. W. West of the Fifth Cavalry as Inspector-General of the Department of Northern Luzon, These papers he sent to the Secretary’s desk to be read. Before they were read Senator Lodge de- sired to know how they came into Sen- ator Culberson’s possession, but was not enlightened, Capt. West's report was dated August | 97 27, 1901. The question naturally arises Where has this report been kept during the past ten months? After the reading had been concluded, Senator Beveridge desired to know where Senator Culberson had obtained it. The latter declined to gratify his curiosity. Then Mr. Beve- ridge asked the frank question whether these two papers had been obtained, either directly or indirectly, from Gen. Miles. As Senator Culberson made no answer, Beveridge added, “That is all,” conveying the idea that the culprit had been discovered at last. And it seems to be the prevailing notion in high quarters that the first thing to be done is to pun- ish the Commanding General of the Army if it shall be found that he di- | vulged these shocking facts. The men who practised these horrible atrocities May or may not be punished; the man or men who concealed the facts will certain- ly not be punished; but if it can be shown that Gen. Miles either gave out or connived at giving out this damning report, then we may see discipline exer- cised upon him at all events. The charges of Private Weir were em- braced in a letter dated April 10, 1901, and addressed to the writer’s uncle (name not given). It began by saying that the writer thought that the army had been sent to the Philippines to rep- resent law and civilization, and he want- ed to know whether the Constitution of the United States and international law did not prohibit torture. He said that he had been an unwilling witness to tor- ture inflicted by an officer on captured insurgents, and that he told this officer that, if he did not stop it, he should re port him to higher authority; that the officer replied that he would stop it, for which reason he (Weir) did not report the facts that he had witnessed. But he had learned that the officer had not kept his promise, but ‘“‘was doing the same cor even worse every day.” He then pro ceeded to tell what he had witnessed. A prisoner was captured, from whom the officer (Lieut. Arnold) desired to obtain information. So he told Sergeant Ed- wards to take the man and get what in- formation he could out of him. Ed- wards took the man and asked him what he knew. The man replied that he had no information to give. So Edwards caused him to be stripped naked, and laid on his back. Then the “water cure” was administered to him, and while he was undergoing this, he was whipped and beaten unmercifully. He was then stood up and “asked to confess.” As he did not do so, he was beaten and clubbed again, and strung up by the thumbs, and, while so held up, was beaten again. As this treatment was ineffective, the man was strung up by the neck At this point, Private Weir went to Lieut. Ar- nold and told him what Edwards was do- ing, and remonstrated against such prac- tices. Arnold became very angry, and threatened him with court-martial for insubordination. He said “When I give a man to Sergeant Edwards, I want information; I do not know how he gets it, but he gets it any way.” He said that “these people,” meaning the Filipinos. “should not be treated as human beings” Mr. Weir told of other cases of torture inflicted by Arnold, even worse than the one here described, but these other cases had not been personally witnessed by Weir. The charges against Arnold were inquired into by Capt. West, whose re- port concluded with the words: “I be- lieve that a thorough investigation into this matter will substantiate the charges made by Private Weir.” The growth of Imperialist opinion on the water cure is practically com- plete with the testimony of Major Glenn before the court-martial which is try- ing him on charges of cruelty to the na- tives. Major Glenn declares that the notorious “water cure,” to which he had submitted himself for experimental pur- poses, is by no means painful, and only slightly uncomfortable. The criticism that it has received is therefore unwar ranted. Thus is a torture described in the old histories of the Inquisition re- duced to a humane expedient for getting information. To this complexion are its apologists come. There was a time not a year ago, when the fact that a native torture was being employed by Americans in the Philippines was indig nantly denied. Next, in the face of over- whelming evidence, it was admitted that sporadic instances of torture had oc curred under circumstances of extreme provocation. So far no one doubted that to undergo this “cure’’ was an aw- ful experience, and it was only the oth- er day, though the correspondent of a society paper had given some hint of this view, that the innocuous and pos- sibly beneficent effect of having some gallons of water poured into one was fully set forth by Major Glenn. Thus a fact once denied, then grudgingly ad mitted, is at last explained away. But is it, until we know first how far Ma jor Glenn is correctly reported, and next how crucial was his experiment of the cure? The German spas recognize cures and half-cures. Did Major Glenn’s phy- sician hold his pulse so that the water might be administered until the heart was on the point of stopping from the pressure of the distended stomach? Did Major Glenn try dirty water, which in one of the recent trials was recommend- ed as efficacious where clean water had

Page 6

raete dl The Nation. [Vol. 74, No. 1928 failed? These are some of the things one would wish to know before adopt- ing the water cure as a harmless and hygienic recreation. One must hope that Major Glenn has been misreported, for the army at least should be free from the cant of the “benevolent assim- ilators.” We are in receipt of a pathetic appeal from brothers of the press in Manila. The editors and proprietors of the Manila Frecdom—so named, we believe, from its policy of making free with all the good things in the Philippines—inform us that they have been arrested by the Philip- pine Commission for “scurrilous libel and sedition,’ and that “the liberty of the press in these islands” is endangered. It seems that Freedom accused the Commissioners of various rather vague offences, such as appointing Filipino rascals to office instead of Americans down on their luck, of having “press agents” to place Government ‘‘advertis- ing patronage’ where it would do the most good—not in Freedom, we'll be bound—and, in general, undertaking “too much work.” Simply for this the arrests followed, and the alarmed editors ask the press of the United States to come to their rescue. For our part, we must de- cline. These newspaper gentlemen are merely getting a useful experience of what military government is. They were perfectly willing and even anxious to have its severities fall upon 10,000,000 na- tives, and now they are offered a taste of it themselves. In this we see rather a case of poetic justice than of out- rage, and as for “liberty” in the Phil- ippines, it remains just where it was— namely, in the hand of the General com- manding. Before our benevolent § assimilators leave off rejoicing over the strength of “Expansionist sentiment” on the Pacific Coast, they should note the language in which that sentiment is locally express- ed. The Portland Oregonian, for ex- ample, frankly said on the eve of the election that the “policy of National Ex- pansion” was simply one of “business sense,”” with an eye to the “great gain” which was to be had from the “exploita- tion of the lands of the Pacific.” But this is nothing compared with the San Fran- cisco Argonaut. That truly Imperial- istic newspaper feels that “the talk about benevolent assimilation is insufferable cant,”’ and lays down the true doctrine of Expansion as follows: **Wedo not want the Filipinos. We want the Philippines. The islands are enormous!y rich, But, unfortunately, they are infested by Kilipinos, There are many millions of them there, and if is to be feared that their extinction will be slow, The development of the islands cannot be successfully done while the Filipinos are there, Therefore the more of them killed the better.” 7 We like such frankness, and could wish there were more of it. The Argonaut is to be commended for “stripping,” as it says, “all hypocritical verbiage from national declarations.” It is aware that “certain excellent gentlemen now in Congress” would repudiate its senti- ments as “brutal.” But its retort is unanswerable: “We are only saying what they are doing.” Custom requires that the Democratic State Convention held midway in a Presidential term shall “reaffirm” the National platform upon which the party had made its campaign two years be- fore. Thus, the Indiana Convention of 1898 declared that “we reaffirm and em- phasize the platform adopted by the National Democratic Convention of 1896 at Chicago,” and also that “we ex- press our undiminished confidence in William Jennings Bryan, our peerless leader in the National campaign of 1896.” The Bryanites at Indianapolis last week therefore had on their side the argument that to “reaffirm” the Kansas City platform of 1900 would be the natural thing, and that a refusal to do so would be interpreted as a rebuke to Bryan. The opponents of Bryan ac. cepted this issue and carried the day. forcing the adoption of a set of reso- lutions which contain no _ reference whatever to either the platform or the candidate of the last National Conven. tion. In other words, the party wipes the slate clean and takes a fresh start. The platform adopted is noteworthy for the ingenious device by which the old silver issue is discarded. The Conven tion at the corresponding time in 1898 declared that “we are in favor of the free and unlimited coinage of both gold and silver at the existing ratio of 16 tc 1, without the aid or consent of any oth- er nation.” This year’s platform “rec: ognizes as an economic fact the increase of standard money, arising from the vastly increased production of gold from our own and foreign mines, as a dem- onstration of the truth of the quantita tive theory of money,” and says not a word about silver. 4 The plank on the tariff issue is brief, but it packs the whole logic of the sit- uation in this compact statement: “We denounce the Dingley Tariff Law as the breeder of Trusts, and demand that tariff duties shall be levied for the pur- pose of revenue only, and limited by the needs of the Government, honestly and economically administered.” Clear and definite also is the declaration of principles regarding the Philippines. After condemning the policy of the Re. publican Administration as having “embroiled the republic in an unneces- sary war, sacrified the lives of many of its noblest sons, and placed the United States, previously known and applaud ed throughout the world as the cham- pion of freedom, in the false and un- American position of -crushing with military force the efforts of our former allies to achieve liberty and self-govern- ment,” the resolution on this subject proceeds: “The Filipinos cannot be citizens with- out endangering our civilization; they can- not be subjects without imperilling our form of government; and, as we are not willing to surrender our civilization to con- vert the republic into an empire, we favor an immediate declaration of the nation’s purpose to assist the Filipinos to establish for themselves an independent government, protecting them from outside interference, and securing to this country such commer- cial and naval rights and advantages as would be just and fully and fairly protect American interests.” Texas has been a stronghold of Bryan- ism and silverism, and it is therefore significant that the Democratic Congres- sional convention in the Fifth District of that State was as silent about both as the Democratic convention in Indiana. It seems to have been a representative body, and its platform lays chief stress upon the question of the tariff and Im- perialism. ‘We denounce the Dingley Tariff Law as the breeder of Trusts,’ it says, “and demand that tariff duties shall be levied for the purposes of revenue only, and limited to the needs of the Government honestly and economically administered.” The Philippine policy of the present Administration is denounced, and what is favored in its stead is set forth in the identical phraseology of the Indiana platform above quoted. Finally, these Texas Democrats declare that “‘we believe that the question of Imperialism and the Trust-breeding tariff should be the paramount issues in the next nation- al campaign.” There is no place where small favors are more gratefully received than at the New York Custom-house, and Secretary Shaw has deserved well of everybody by facilitating the delivery of express par- cels and liberalizing the system of mak- ing individual payments at the customs. The plan is a very simple one. The express companies keep at the Sub- Treasury a daily deposit large enough to cover all possible duties on the consign, ments of that day. The Collector simply draws upon this deposit the amount of the duty as soon as it has been properly assessed. The express companies may also act as agents for individuals. Thus it is possible for an incoming tourist to turn over his baggage to an express company immediately after the exami- nation. This saves considerable delay at a time when delay is particularly vexa- tious, and will undoubtedly be a more satisfactory arrangement than can be made with a Custom-house broker, The saving of time on express packages is ex: pected to be eight or ten days. Secretary Shaw again deserves credit for removing obstacles to traffic which have grown up in the customs service, and especially,

Page 7

June 12, 1902] for doing everything in his power to make the first landing of a guest or the return of a native something less than a punishment for foreign birth or absen- teeism. For the first time in its century and a half of existence, Princeton chooses a layman for its President. This marks the final step in that secularization of the American college of which Prof. A. B. Hart writes in the Harvard Gradu- ates’ Magazine for June: “Whatever might be thought on that subject by the President of Bowdoin, or Dart- mouth, or Amherst, or Wesleyan, or Chi- cago, there is no doubt that the layman is now preferred for such appointments; nor that the dominie has ceased to be the typical teacher and guide of aca- demic youth. . The community of college graduates, and their associates throughout the country, seem convinced that the educational side of a univer- sity is best cared for by the trained educator.” Every word of that descrip- tion might be applied to the President- elect of Princeton University, and it might be added that, besides the catho- lic sympathies and knowledge of af- fairs which are implied in the title “educator,” he bears a high reputation as a brilliant investigator of problems of politics and government, and holds an honorable position in American let- ters as a judicious essayist. It is very rarely the case that the candidate for a university presidency can show so complete and convincing a register of qualifications, and it was this obvious fitness of Dr. Woodrow Wilson which made it possible for an old president to step out and for a new one to be appoint- ed the same day—a case unparalleled in recent times—without so much as causing a proper feeling of surprise. President Patton’s resignation was also of an unusual kind. Leaving in the full vigor of middle life. with health and popularity unimpaired, he resigns a charge which he has administered with indubitable success, because he feels the call of his old studies, and because he realizes that a man of different train- ing may more advantageously utilize the prosperity which he has done so much to procure. Manitoba and the Canadian North- west are repeating with great rapidity the history of the winning of our West. The problem of absorbing the Galicians, Russians, and other refractory races is specifically Canadian, but the remark- able influx of American settlers in these regions must affect both Canada and ourselves. As yet we have no accurate statistics of this agrarian invasion, but some idea of its significance may be gained from the following figures. In the years 1899-1901 the total immigra- tion from America to Canada was, re- Th Nation. spectively, 11,945, 15,500, and 17,987. By June 1 of the present year the Great Northern Railroad alone had carried 25,- 000 immigrants into Manitoba. While some of these were taken directly from the incoming steamers, many were eith- er American-born or thoroughly Ameri canized. This cannot continue without producing its effect upon the relations of the two countries. The United States cannot wholly repudiate her children who have taken up Canadian farms and accepted Canadian citizenship. A con- stant social interchange and common agricultural interests in the Northwest will more and more reduce the boun- dary to its definition as an “imaginary line.” The palpable “Chinese wall’ now absurdly maintained between Canada and this country will never seem quite so absurd as it does where it prevents John Smith of North Dakota from sell- ing surplus produce to or buying it from John Smith, jr., of Manitoba. The reported combination of several British steamship companies, including the Cunard, Allan, Castle, and Elder- Dempster Lines, has the similitude of truth. The law of self-preservation re- quires the companies not included in the Morgan combination to take commen action, since it would be possible for the combination to coerce them one by ore, as it did perhaps coerce the German lines. Naturally, the outside concerns think that they must hang together, un- less they would hang separately. The question of most importance to them is whether they can secure railway con- nections on this side of the water to off- set a possible combination of the Fas: and West trunk lines in the United States with the steamship consolidation. If the shipping syndicate should be able to offer a preferential rate from the Western grain fields to English ports which the other steamships could not match, the latter would be at the mercy of the former. Hence we are not sur- prised to hear that the Cunard Company and its allies are looking to the Canadian Pacific Railway asa resource in the event of an adverse railway combination. The Canadian Pacific could tap the wheat- fields of the Red River valley, and even if it did not itself carry much wheat to the seaboard, it could put a strong curb on the competing American lines. There is talk also of a British Government subsidy to the opposition line; but such a thing is most unlikely. The two com- binations, if there are two, must work out their problems for the present with- out Government interference. Meanwhile a new factor will appear upon the scene before long. The private shipping that has been employed in connection with the Boer war, estimated at two million tons, will presently be released, and will be looking for freights elsewhere. It will find employment partly in the North Atlantic, and its influence in the 457 coming struggle will be not inconsider- able. The new British Ambassador, the Hon. Michael Herbert, is comparatively un- known beyond the British Foreign Of fice. So Lord Pauncefote at the time of his appointment to Washington. One may assume that, like his predeces- the new Ambassador will be a working, not a talking diplomat, seek- ing to win confidence rather than the reputation for brilliancy. His training is of the most thoroughgoing, and he comes with the prestige of long service in the most highly organized diplomatic corps of our day. This training pro- duces men of the office rather than men of the platform. In fact, no other diplo- matic service than our own could per- mit personalities as American repre- sentatives at the of St. James. Lowell, Phelps, Bayard, Hay, and Choate were free to do an amount of speechmak- ing that would have infallibly terminated the career of a European diplomat. We believe—-where our selections have been was sor, itself such a succession of salient the Court carefully made, as_ for has been a has England—it fortunate dispensation that given us gaging diplomacy; since the expansiveness that our Minis not diplomats, but en excursionists in ters at London now are required to main tain has generally brought them a sound personal popularity which has been more valuable than the treaties they have ne- gotiated. The tion of sugar bounties in Germany have culminated in a project to make the sugar industry a Government monopoly difficulties attending the aboli- There are other state monopolies in the Old World. es, for France, Tobacco and friction match- example, are monopolies in and Bismarck tried in vain to create a tobacco monopoly in Germany. These, however, are monopolies for pub- They are assumed by the Government to enable individuals to Such would seem to be the aim of the proposed Gov ernment The bounty on German sugar is of two kinds. It consists, in part, of the excess of re- lic revenue. not dispose of a losing business. sugar monopoly export bate paid by the Treasury over the in ternal tax the and in part of the cartel, which enables the sugar manufacturers to charge high for sumption than to exporters. This is made possible by the tariff on sugar of foreigi production. The ties on exports has been decreed by the Brussels Convention, to take effect in tac autumn of 1903. What to do with the property into life by this hot house treatment is a puzzle on all hands Apparently, the owners have conceived the plan of unloading it upon the tax- payers, and very likely they ceed, collected on beet roots, er prices to buyers domestic con boun abolition of all nursed will suc

Page 8

458 The Nation. [Vol. 74, No. 1928 OVERLOADING THE PRESIDENT. The ill-advised attempt to induce President Roosevelt to intervene in the coal strike was but the latest of many recent symptoms of an unhappy politi- cal tendency: we mean the resort to the President in every time of trouble. Whether the difficulty be industrial or political, regional or national, small or great, we run with it tothe White House in childlike confidence, or else in weak dependence. We are coming to think of the Chief Executive as if he combined in himself the attributes of an Oriental King and a medieval monarch—as if he were a Solomon to decide all our con- troversies, and a Louis to decree right- eous judgment from a “bed of justice.” Congress inclines more and more ta call upon the President to cut its Gordian knots for it. Is it a question of wisely choosing the route for an Isthmian canal? Senator Hoar introduces a bill to leave the matter wholly to the Presi- dent. Do legislators find it a hard task to draw a bill for reciprocity with Cuba in such a way as to cut off the Sugar Trust from all benefit? Senator Spoon- er would refer it to the President. Let him execute a law which it passes the wit of the Senate to frame. Or is the rebate plan to be adopted, and is the objection made that the money voted might not go to deserving Cubans? Put it all in the President’s hands, urges Senator Burrows; he will see to it that our dole reaches only the right persons. Allah is great, and the President is his prophet! We consider this increasing willing- ness limply to lean upon the President as most mistaken and perverse. It is bad for him, and bad for us. It injures his office, while changing it and impair- ing its true efficiency; and, on the other hand, it cuts the nerve of self-help and initiative among the people, and enables Congress to dodge and shift where it should debate and decide. The Presi- dency is already overburdened. If the strain of responsibilty which it imposes was so great in Jefferson’s day that he cried out at the “splendid misery” of his office, what would he say to the daily besetment and besieging of our later dwellers in the White House? In mercy to our chosen chief we should spare him these added cares. Besides the danger of breaking him down physi- cally, we expose him to the more seri- ous danger of a day so devastated by intruders and a night so spent in con- sultations that he has no time to think, no leisure to clarify his mind, and form his convictions, in the larger matters of national policy to which his best strength ought to be given. Burke warn- ed us that “they who always labor can have notrue judgment”; and our grow- ing habit of invading the White House on every occasion and with all possible forms of business, tends directly to de. grade our Presidents to the level of his men who “exhaust their attention, burn out their’ candles, and are left in the dark.” What alarm this magnifying of the President would have struck to the hearts of the framers of our Constitu- tion, need not be said. They lived in the remembrance and shadow of the time when the people’s representatives resolved that “the influence of the Crown has increased, is increasing, and ought to be diminished.” To them, our pres- ent-day adulation of the President, and turning over to him of power after power of the state, would have seemed the entering upon a path at the end of which is the figure of a ‘“‘man on horse- back.” Frankly, we do not now fear that traditional shape of dread. What we are afraid of is, not a man on horse- back, but a man in his private office dictated to by politicians. They, of course, are really aiming to add to their own power, under pretence of exalting the President’s. When they induce Con- gress to “leave it all to the President,” they expect, in their secret hearts, that he will, in turn, leave it all to them. Not tyranny, but corruption, is our most threatening foe; and there is no instru- ment of corruption like a President wielding the vast and abdicated powers of Congress in a way to suit the schemes of party bosses. The practice got a great impetus under Mr. McKinley. That it has been continued with his succes- sor, Shows that the party managers have as yet found no reason to be dissatisfied with their plan of usurping power by ostensibly giving it to another, By this repeated reference of contro- verted matters to the President, Con- gress advertises its own humiliation, and writes itself down as either too lazy or too stupid to do its proper work. What are legislators there for but to legis- late? It is the President’s business sim. ply to execute the laws which they enact. Is it pretended that he is a fountain of supernatural and unfailing wisdom? Would he, for example, in the choice of a canal route, have a particle of information or expert advice not free- ly at the service of Congress? Everybody knows that he would not. What he would do, if Congress were to put the responsibility upon him, would simply be to turn to those skilled investigators whose report is before both houses. But if that is the right thing for him to do, why do they not do it? Will they confess themselves either shirks or incompe- tents? Their proposed action speaks ominously of a deepening disinclination for the serious work of legislation, for that forging of laws in the heat of de- bate and under the hammer of argument, which has been the glorious tradition of Parliament and Congress. Are we grown so weary of the burdens of liberty that we must make haste to shift them to other shoulders? Nor can we omit to mention the par- tisan aspect of the matter. To call upon the President as the deus ex machina is, just now, a pretty obvious scheme of the Republican leaders in Congress to get their party out of a scrape. It is torn to pieces over Cuba. It is discordant about the Isthmian Canal. So the man- agers blandly propose to the Democrats to pass along both questions to the Great Father in the White House. But the Democrats ought to fight the plan, tooth and nail. As it stands, it is a partisan manceuvre. It is designed to free the Republican party from an irksome re- sponsibility, and, at the same time, to give it, through a back-door use of the Presidency, the prestige and advantage which it is not able to win by intelli- gent legislation in Congress. Let the thing be squarely stated. If the Repub- lican party is not able to make the laws which it has promised and undertaken to pass, and for enacting which it has an ample majority in both houses of Con- gress, let the disgraceful confession be openly made. To hide behind President Roosevelt’s coat-tails the party should be ashamed to attempt, and its oppo- nents should die in their tracks before allowing it. THE HOUSE PHILIPPINE BILL. The most important action to be tak- en by Congress during the remainder of the session will be the disposition of the measures for the civil government of the Philippine Islands. The chief point of difference between the Houses and Senate bills is that the former pro- vides for an actual beginning of Philip- pine self-government, while the latter merely continues the present régime of conquest and subjugation. A notable impulse was given on Saturday last to the measure proposed by the House by the publication of a dispatch from Act- ing Governor Wright, saying that the archipelago is now pacified, and that no reasons exist why civil government should not be established in all the provinces except the Moro country. By the phrase civil government he meant municipal as distinguished from mili- tary government in the provinces; but if pacification has been secured, the same reasons which point to withdrawal of military rule are potent for the begin- ning of representative government on a larger scale. The Senate bill provides for nothing but the taking of a census, and the extension of local municipal government “so far and so fast as com- munities in such civil divisions are capable, fit, and ready for the same.” The authority of Gov. Taft has been given distinctly in favor of the House bill. In an article written by him and published in the Outlook of May 31 he says: “We of the Commission are very earnest and sincere in our hope that at least the provision for the election of the legislative assembly and of the two delegates con-

Page 9

June 12, 1902] The Nation. tained in the House bill shall be embodied in legislation. We think that the Filipino people would accept this provision as the most indubitable evidence of the desire of the United States that self-government should be given to the people in as large a measure as they are capable of carrying it on.”’ At the time of writing this article Gov. Taft was aware that certain mem- bers of the Senate Committee believed that the organization of a legislative assembly in the Philippines was too rad- ical a step. They believed that men would be chosen as members who would make seditious speeches and stir up fresh strife. Gov. Taft considered this danger wholly imaginary. Even if the Assembly should select Aguinaldo or Mabini or some other insurgent leader to represent it in Washington, he would not consider such action dangerous or undesirable. A representative assembly would give scope for the political aspirations of the people, and would be a great education- al school for the better class of Fili- pinos. Mr. Taft, while differing from President Schurman as to the time when full freedom should be given to the Christian people of the islands, agrees with the latter that the growth of free institutions can be promoted only through their exercise by the peo- ple whose destinies we have taken charge of. In short, the two highest authorities we have to guide us in the premises—the first and the second Philippine Commis- sions—concur in favoring the House bill. A more important reason for support- ing the House bill is the fact that it is in harmony with American principles, or, at all events, not in conflict with them, as the Senate bill certainly is. The latter measure is the same kind of an impasse that we have been toiling in from the beginning. It leaves every- thing undecided. It does not even point the way to anything better than the existing condition. It does not even contain the element of hope. It is a bad education for both Filipinos and Ameri- cans. Every day that the present arbitrary government lasts is a bad omen for both sides of the Pacific Ocean. It teaches the lessons of despotism to both the rulers and the ruled, and no one can say to which of the two the injury is the great- er. The House bill has the inestimable advantage that it turns our faces once more towards the sun of liberty. This change ought to be most welcome to the Republican party at the present time, when it is about to enter into a campaign rendered doubtful by the exposure of shocking cruelties practised upon a dis- tant people in order to overcome their desire for liberty and independence. In comparison with the actual begin- ning of representative government, which the House bill provides for, all other matters are relatively insignifi- cant. Even the proposed establishment of the silver standard in the monetary system of the islands is a secondary con- sideration. Yet all signs point to a stub- born fight on this question also, and we hope that the House will adhere to its rational plan of assimilating the cur- rency of the islands to that of the United States. “EDITORIALENE.” This is the name for the editorial writing of commercialized newspapers which is suggested in the striking arti- cle in the June Atlantic Monthly on “The Newspaper Industry.” The writ- er, who signs himself “Brooke Fisher,” is evidently a man who knows at first hand the thing he describes. After tracing the way in which the tyranny of the counting-room has, in too many instances, smothered editorial utterance, he hastens to add: “Of course there will be the usual quan- tum of matter that looks like editorials, but on examination it is found to be what might well be patented under the name of editorialene. Editorialene shrewdly selects men of straw to trample upon. It enunci- ates axiomatic platitudes with a ponderous affectation of wisdom. It ‘socks it to the satraps’ of a safe distance in the past and a safe geographical remoteness. It also twitters sprightly commonplaces about minor moralities. But you will seek it in vain for direct, courageous, helpful deal- ing with the burning questions, the politi- cal and social and local issues really en- grossing the best minds of the community.” We are all painfully familiar with this product of the “business-run press.” “Yes,” said a college professor, “the editorials of the New York are favorites of mine, since they furnish just what I need—complete mental rest.” A witty literary man was asked recently if he was reading the editorial) page of another New York paper, set- ting up to be a model. He said he was not. He had tried to, but found it only a simulacrum of real writing; “and yet,” he added thoughtfully, “it has every appearance of being a newspaper, too.” It was all “editorialene.” We will not multiply illustrations. Anybody in search of them could find an endless store in the treatment of the revela- tions of the Waller court-martial by the great organs of the American press. First silence, then deprecation, then calling for a suspension of judgment, then terrific arraignment of unnamed “slanderers,” then noble tributes to our glorious army—their whole course could have been accurately forecasted by any one familiar with their editorial pages. This power to predict exactly what certain editors will say on given subjects is one of the proofs that their speech is not free. As the Atlantic writer says, their writing is of the per- functory type which any one may fore- see, and which a moderately skilled pen could duplicate in advance. Now this tendency to commercialize the press, which Mr. Fisher depicts in rather sombre colors, is one which has obviously been operative for a long time. Like the parallel commercialization of education and of religion, of which we = hear so much, it is largely an incident of our passing from the day of small things to the time of large undertakings. The capital required by a modern daily news- paper is too great to be furnished by one man. Editor and proprietor can no longer, except in rare instances, be unit- ed in one personality. A corporation necessarily has control; and, whether it has a soul of its own or not, it is cer- tainly not so anxious to save the souls of others as the editors of an elder day used to be. As primarily a business cor- poration, its first concern is naturally dividends. Hence has come about inev- itably that paralysis of the editorial function, as compared with the money- making function, which the Atlantic ar- ticle describes. It is, in many ways, de- plorable, yet it was not wholly preventa- ble. Is there now any remedy? Is the out- look so dark as Mr. Brooke Fisher represents it? We may put aside at once his preposterous suggestion that the weekly paper will rise in importance as the daily declines in vigor and inde- pendence. There is no evidence that the average weekly is any less under orders from the counting-room than is the aver- age daily. In any case, the people will demand the news twice a day, and this puts the weekly hopelessly out of the running as a competitor. With the news in their bands, readers will not wait a week to get an editorial opinion on it. Nor can we expect the owners of news- papers to turn philanthropists, as a class, and pocket losses in order to propagate ideas. Exceptional proprietors have done this, but the newspaper business, as a whole, has to be conducted on business principles; and unless they will justify in the long run, a fearless and unfettered editorial page, we shall not see it re- stored. But it may be hopefully contended that independent and honest editorial writing is more and more coming to seem a good investment for a newspaper. We believe that the counting-room has been far too timid and short-sighted. Color- less newspapers are not good property In the anxious effort to offend nobody, they disgust everybody. To suppose that the public likes blind flattery and time- serving is to underrate the general in- telligence. Happily, there are multiply- ing instances of newspapers that are highly successful, though entirely inde- pendent, and ready at any time to speak their minds freely in the face of party or local prejudice. Their owners have made the fortunate discovery that there is money in courage and ability. It is in the spread of education and of toler- ance, and in the power of honest and earnest writing to command respect and appreciation, if not approval, that we see the hope of a press unbribed and unafraid. People will not, in the end, be imposed upon by “editorialene,” any more than by repeated newspaper — ae

Page 10

460 The Nation. [Vol. 74, No. 1928 “fakes.” Abraham Hayward heard a cab- man under his windows in 1870 rebuke a newsboy for foisting upon him a fraud- ulent Echo: “If you goes on selling me battles as haven’t been fought, I’m d—d if I don’t kick you.” When newspaper- owners are given to understand that such will be the indignant attitude of the public towards insincere or flabby writ- ing on the editorial page, as well as to- wards invented news in the other col- umns, they will encourage more than they do now the free expression of well- considered views, and will agree with Thomas Arnold that the times will bear whatever an honest man has to say. SUPERIORITY IN MANUFAC- TURING. A man of large affairs and clear mind, like Mr. James J. Hill, cannot make a public address, as he did before the Illinois Manufacturers’ Association at Chicago last week, without uttering a suggestive word. The most instructive thing he said seems to us his quiet but sure pointing to the true reason for American superiority in manufactures. This can be traced, he affirmed, to our “enormous natural resources.” It is not the protective tariff which brought about the tremendous growth of our iron and steel industries, but, primarily, the vast deposits of iron ore in Michi- gan, Minnesota, Wisconsin, and else- where. This is in line with what Mr. Carnegie said in London the other day. America must be reckoned with, he told the Englishmen, because she can pro- duce “the cheapest steel.” And the rea- son we can produce it is, in the last analysis, simply that nature has given us the largest and cheapest stores of iron and coal to be found anywhere in the world. It is well to remind ourselves of this truth, both for reproof and instruction. We hear too much idle boasting on this subject, too many mistaken explanations of our superiority. It is often said, for example, that American machinery is what insures our triumph. But Ameri- can machinery rapidly finds its way to all countries. It is speedily put at the service of our commercial rivals, There is no export tax on American inventive- ness. Indeed, our makers of machinery are among our chief exporters. The dis patches have recently told of the forma- tion of a Pneumatic Tool Company in London, backed by American capital, to introduce the American pneumatic riveter and other labor-saving devices of the kind into British and Continen- tal ship-yards and shops, This process is going on ali the time. Mr. Vanderlip has told us of finding the very latest Yankee contrivances in the hands of German workmen. In the nature of the case, it must be so. We are but repay- ing an old debt. Improved machinery for our cotton-spinning we borrowed OUR from England; now she comes to us to buy or copy the best she can find in our factories. It is clear, therefore, that it is not upon our superiority in labor- saving machines that we can depend for beating the foreigner. We sell him those machines as fast as we invent them. Much the same may be said about the assumed finer talent for business pos- sessed by Americans. Now no one can surpass us in admiration of the shrewd- ness and energy and administrative ge- nius of our captains of industry. But it is obvious that, if these are inherently American qualities, they existed in our national character generations ago. Yet a half century since no one was saying that Americans were the best business men in the world. It was to England and France that we then looked for the typical masters of finance, princes of commerce, and kings of industry. Ifthe American as such is so superior to all mankind in the capacity for business, why was he condemned to so long a period of apparent inferiority? The an- swer is plain. The development of the country’s natural resources had not then reached a point to give American ability in that direction free scope. That is, it is what nature has done for us that real- ly opens the way for our commercial conquest of the world, An alternative explanation is some- times offered in the assertion that it is our industrial organization, our com- binations of capital,- that haye given us our successes. Some who are willing to admit that the American is not neces- sarily so superior to all other men in point of sheer mental power, yet point to our system of manufacture by Trusts as the secret of our great commercial expansion. But as to this, two things are to be said. The first is that, if there is any sound and lasting merit in this form of manufacturing organization, we cannot keep it to ourselves any more than we can our newest machinery. For- eigners will be as quick to take over the benefits of the one as of the other. In fact, they are doing it. So we must not think that we have any mysterious and exclusive patent, inthe shape of the Trust, to assure our preéminence. The other remark about the Trust is that, if it has industrial advantages, it has also financial vices. This was trenchant ly expressed by Mr. Hill when he said that too many Trusts were organized for the purpose of manufacturing, not commodities, but “sheaves of securities.” Here we come upon another reason often advanced for our industrial tri- umphs—the vast capital now under cor- porate control. This has undoubtedly been a striking feature of our develop- ment during the past half-dozen years. Cheap and abundant capital has been at our command. But what evidence is there, aside from our continued ability to develop the natural products of field and mine, that this will be continued, that we can go on borrowing from all Europe? Capital available has ebbed and flowed before, and it may again. No- thing is more certain than that a bad year or two, with the tumbling down of a few of the topheavy and overcapital- ized concerns whose “sheaves of secur- ities” have been unloaded upon a “gen- erous and confiding people’—to use the politician’s phrase—will produce a stringency where now we have a ple- thora. In any case, capital is but the incidental and shifting element in our national prosperity. The solid bases of our manufacturing superiority rest upon the fact that nature has lavishly endowed us with the raw materials which enter into manufacture. That is what we come to in the end: our indus- trial lead, as has been pointed out by a clear-headed English economist, Mr. Courtney, is due to our advantage in having cheaper coal at the pit’s mouth than any other nation, and iron ore in quantity and at a cost beyond the pow- er of any competitor to rival. If any morals are to be drawn from all this, they are, obviously, (1) that our thanks should be addressed to Provi- dence, and not to a tariff; (2) that any form of squandering our natural re- sources, or making them needlessly cost- ly, as by artificial prices paid at the be- hest of either Trusts or labor unions, is a form of national madness; and (3) that all schemes of militarism or pater- nalism which would impose the burden of heavy and needless taxation upon our powers of production, are a direct play- ing into the hands of competing nations. They cannot beat us by direct rivalry or by force of arms; but they may van- quish us by the aid of our own follies. ENGLAND AFTER THE WAR. Current reports of the formation of an English shipping combination, of sufficient magnitude to rival the huge Ship Trust capitalized under American auspices, occurred rather strikingly in the week of the Transvaal peace an- nouncement. Whether the _ reported “rival combine” is or is not as large as rumor would have it, and whether it does or does not contemplate keen com- petition with the Morgan undertaking, the mere fact that such a project is on foot directs attention to an extremely interesting phase of the present situa- tion. The question which the next few years will have.to solve is the question how far the recent decline of Eng- land’s supremacy in foreign trade has resulted from causes permanent in their nature, and how far from the temporary exhaustion due to a costly war. It is needless to point out the great sig- nificance, to the world’s commercial fu- ture, which is involved in this question. The question cannot be answered yet with absolute confidence, because too

Page 11

June 12, 1902] many varying influences have been at work simultaneously. Political econ- omy has a way of cheating the seeker after principles by confronting him with two or more independent causes for a given result—causes often con- flicting in their nature. Nowhere is this confusion greater than in the in- dustrial sequel to a war. We believe it to be the fact that many intelligent people, even in high circles of finance contend to-day that the recent immense prosperity of the United States, and par- ticularly the overflowing of its capital into foreign markets, was somehow con- nected with the waging of a successful war. No particular effort is made to demonstrate how the war could have caused the prosperity; whether the pros- perity would have come had our har- vests failed and our industry not been on a sound basis; whether the Napole- onic and Crimean wars, for instance, had the same results. Precisely such confusing influences as were at work in causing American prosperity after the Spanish war have had a hand in Eng- land’s industrial reaction during the Transvaal struggle. Three influences have been operating against England’s commercial prestige during the past three years—a _ pro- longed and enormously expensive war; the blockade of the Transvaal gold- mines, from which fully $75,000,000 annually in gold had previously been drawn; and aggressive compe- tition from the United States, whose entry into the contest for neutral trade took place at the moment when England’s own energies were being di- verted. How far the drain of war ex- penses—on capital through the heavy loans, and on incomes through the heavy taxes—crippled Great Britain’s financial vigor, is something which cannot be ex- actly measured. The cost of the war, it is estimated in London, has not fallen much short of $1,250,000,000. The strong- est nation cannot divert such a sum from ordinary commercial purposes without feeling the strain severely. There is sometimes a partial compensation in the fact that the capital thus raised by a Government is paid out to home pro- ducers, for ships, ammunition, food sup- plies. But a very great part of England’s war expenditure—perhaps the greater part—had to be made in other countries. The army was operated in a country which could not feed it; most of the sup- plies were bought in the United States. And what was spent for war material, at the British iron-mills, was placed at a time when orders for outside trade were at a maximum, and when, therefore, the manufacturer lost a chance in the field of international competition by the very fact of his Government contracts. The reality of the financial strain has been shown plainly enough in other ways. England could undoubtedly have placed all its loans at home, as it did _The Nat J 1071. the $3,000,000,000 loans which were con- tracted during the Napoleonic wars. But the result, for the $730,000,000 bonds is- sued since 1899, as for those issued be- tween 1793 and 1815, would probably have been so low a price as to make the cost to the Government exorbitant. This is why $103,000,000 of the consols and the war loan were allotted direct to American subscribers. The very unusual effort to shift the burden, however, shows how heavily it weighed; and, in fact, it has been frankly admitted by English financial critics that the London money market would have been seriously strained, even after the foreign allot- ments of consols, had not the Paris bank- ers taken the bulk of the temporary Treasury bills and thus helped to finance the Exchequer. The embargo on Transvaal gold sup- plies necessarily added to England's dif- ficulties. Most of the mines from which the $80,000,000 product had previously been taken annually, were owned in England. Barely $12,000,000 gold in all was produced between September, 1899, and the opening of 1902, and this was at least as heavy a loss in the productive- ness of British capital as if harvests had failed or mill products become unsalable. It is quite true that English banks have kept good, and even increased, their gold reserves, and that Continental banks, ex- cept that of Russia, have simultaneously increased their own, despite the Trans- vaal bleckade. But with England handi- capped in foreign trade, even this process must have been costly as compared with the former imports direct from Johan- nesburg. In short, it is plain that the war it- self is responsible for a good part of England’s recent seeming sluggishness in the race of international competition. The next question to find solution, there- fore, is, What figure will England cut in the same race during the next few years? The strain on English capital is already relaxing. Probably there will be no more loans; the proceeds of the $160,- 000,000 April issue ought to cover not only the cost of bringing home the troops, but the $15,000,000 grant for re- habilitation of the farms. The output of Transvaal gold has already doubled since December. It is likely to double itself again in the next few months, and Eng- land’s gold imports from South Africa, which have already risen from $629,000 in May, 1901, to $3,437,000 last month, may increase, later on, to the monthly $8,500,000 of a few years ago. It cannot, therefore, be very long before Great Britain enters the world’s markets again without so serious a _ handicap. We shall then know exactly how much truth there has been in the lately familiar as- sertion that her methods are antiquated and no longer fitted to lead in the strug- gle for neutral trade. That Great Brit- ain will regain her old position of un- challenged supremacy is not probable, 461 in their of these and America But neither two competitors is likely henceforward to enjoy immunity from British compe- tition. with Germany present position. AMERICAN SCHOLARSHIPS AT OX FORD It has been advocated by some writ ers, e. g., by Mr. F. C. S. Schiller, in the May Fortnightly and by Mr. John Corbin in the preface to his ‘An American at Oxford,’ that the Rhodes scholars should be selected from who have already graduated at Ameri If this course is fol certain--they will colony. This will come to pass on account, not so much of their nationality is true that there have been cases which, to qualities, a freshman of comparatively mature at home with his juniors; but as Revie ”, men can universities. lowed, one thing is become a separate as of their age. Ii in personal owing exceptional years has made himself quite a rule a discrepancy of this kind is a serious hindrance to complete freedom of social intercourse. Moreover, the actual terms of the bequest itself appear to make the election of graduate scholars quite in consistent with the intention of the tes tator. in part, by ter of the candidate’s school”; The choice is to be determined, a report from “the headmas the suc resi cessful candidate is “to commence dence as an undergraduate’—not as a research student--at some college; and special stress is laid upon the advan tages of the residential system of Ox ford, for the reason that, without it, | students “are, at the most critical pe riod of their lives, left without any supervision.” The third consideration is regarded as of so great importance that the lack of such a system at Edinburgh is the reason which induced Mr. Rhodes to refrain, evidently with great reluctance, from establishing scholar- ships at that university. It is therefore likely that the trustees will find them selves compelled, both by the letter and by the spirit of the will, to impose a limitation of age, done by the Oxford Colleges themselves in the cass of their which are usually open to the competition of can under nineteen of ags only. Prof. H. Morse Stephens has sug- gested, in the June World’s Work, that to such a limitation should be added the condition of celibacy also, but gne may reasonably hope that the social pace in this country has not yet become so rapid that the first requirement would not make the second unnecessary. In order, therefore, to realize the sit uation that is about to be created, we must imagine a group of American youths who have just passed through the high school—the flower of the sec ondary education of Nevada and Arkan sas as well as of Massachusetts and sole as is own scholarships, didates years

Page 12

462 The Nation. [Vol. 74, No. 1928 New York—exploring the High Street and the Cornmarket, and “prospecting” for academic quarters. At this point some of them will encounter a difficulty which was hinted at by Prof. T. Case in the May National Review, but which our press, with its usual optimism on educational affairs, has either entirely ignored or mentioned only to dismiss it as unworthy of serious consideration The difficulty in question is the fact that, no matter where he applies for ad. mission, the Rhodes scholar will find himself confronted by a college entrance examination—an examination quite dif- ferent from the university test known as “Responsions” or “Smalls.” In the June Review of Reviews Prof. F. H. Stoddard says that he “will no doubt be assigned to a college, rather than be allowed to choose one,” as Mr. Rhodes’s will expresses the desire that the American students shall be distribut- ed among the various colleges. Profes- sor Stoddard adds that all the colleges, “educationally considered, are equal.” In each particular he is seriously mis- taken. Each college retains absolutely in its own hands the right of deciding who shail be admitted to its member- ship. No university authority can over. rule its decision in this respect, and it would be interesting to watch the face of a “head of a house” if it were sug- gested to him that the “society” of the college should delegate its power of the keys to some outsider, whether English or American. The Oxford colleges are very jealous of their privileges, and are quite unlikely to give way in the least degree on so important a question as the conditions of entrance. Then, it is not the case that all the colleges, “educa- tionally considered, are equal,” except in the sense that undergraduates of all the colleges are on the same footing as re- gards the degree examinations. Cer. tain colleges—for instance, Balliol, New, and Corpus—admit no freshmen except those who intend to read for honors, and accordingly impose a much severer entrance test than those colleges which do not object to receive passmen also. That there is a real difference between the standards of various colleges is il- lustrated in the case of Mr. Rhodes him- self, who was rejected by another col- lege before he was admitted at Oriel. Many of the Rhodes scholars will nat- urally wish to join one of the colleges which possess the greatest educational reputation. They will probably be sur prised at the difficulty of the initial test in such cases. Even the colleges most hospitable to mediocrity require from freshmen a knowledge of Latin and Greek which, however elementary it may appear to boys coming from the higher forms of the English “public schools,” will be regarded with greater respect by candidates fresh from the high-school curriculum of some sections of this country. It will not be surpris- ing, then, if some of the Rhodes schol- ars knock at the doors of several col- leges before they find an entrance at any, and if others are rejected wherever they apply. Such failures are the more likely to occur owing to the remarkable fancy qualifications prescribed for his scholarships by Mr. Rhodes. It has been said that every Rhodes scholar will be at liberty to choose for himself whether he shall read for a pass or an honors degree. This is, no doubt, literally true, yet most American students, whatever their intention on entering, will soon find themselves strongly influenced in the direction of an honors course. They will discover that not only in Oxford but in England out- side Oxford, great importance is attach- ed to the class in which a man grad- uates. They will also find themselves regarded as picked representatives of the educational products of the Unite States, by whose success or failure in “the schools” the quality of American education will be popularly gauged. The desire to reflect credit upon one’s own State will be another incentive. It is true that prowess on the river or in the football field also counts highly for per- sonal distinction, but such success is not at all inconsistent with a good showing in examinations, and is therefore not regarded as absolving an able man from the obligation of gaining a first or sec- ond. The decision to read for honors means in every case a concentration of study. Each candidate is confined to one range of subjects: he makes his choice between classics, mathematics, modern history, étc., and by that choice he must abide. Even with such limita- tions, the curriculum makes severe de- mands upon the diligence of well-equip- ped undergraduates, in vacation as well as in term-time. Considerable anxiety has been ex- pressed, especially by writers somewhat tinged by Anglophobia, as to the pos- sible corruption of the democratic sim- plicity of the Rhodes scholars by the “glamour of ancient traditions and monarchical institutions.” As a matter of fact, there is less snobbery in the life of present-day undergraduate Ox: ford than in any section of American society. There is less “tuft-hunting” in Oxford than in New York. It is possi- ble, however, that some of the Rhodes scholars may prefer to remain in Eng- land rather than to return to their own country. Those, for example, who in- tend to enter the teaching profession will in some cases find better opportuni- ties open to them there than here. It has escaped general attention that sev- eral years ago one of the Australian colonies established a scholarship, ten- able in England, open to the competi- tion of graduates from the local univer- sity. After a fair trial the scholarship was discontinued, as it was found that in operation it was really a fund for preparing clever natives of the colony for a career in England. As an evidence of the denationalizing effect of an Eng- lish university education upon youths of foreign birth and parentage, one might quote the conspicuous instance of Lord Milner, son of Dr. Kar! Milner, profes- sor at the University of Tiibingen. On the other hand, there are the equally conspicuous instances of W. H. Wadding- ton, who was a high classic at Cam- bridge and rowed in the inter-university boat race, but afterwards became Prime Minister of France, and of Mr. Smuts, also a Cambridge graduate in the high- est honors and recently a leader of a Boer commando. Perhaps the degree to which life in his own State will ap- pear attractive to the Rhodes scholar when he has taken his Oxford degree, will depend very largely on the tone of local public opinion as to whether he is to be praised or blamed for having gone abroad for his education. THE PARIS SALONS. PARIS, May, 1902. You hear it said on all sides this year that the two Salons are deplorably dull. French critics, weary of their task, dealers in search of a novelty to draw custom, chance visitors looking less for art than for sensation, artists eager for new creeds and new pronouncements, all will tell you the same thing: there is nothing in the old Salon; in the new the level is lower than it has ever been. But then the old Salon always has been dull since the second Society came into existence, and this year I found it pleasanter in some respects, probably because less crowded. The new Salon, I admit, has been more stimulating and amusing and sensational, but the mis- take is to expect its exhibitions always to equal the first when every effort had to be made to justify the secession from the Artistes Francais, and exhibitors borrow- ed liberally from their work during many years past. As you enter the new Salon through the little garden facing the Avenue d’Antin, your eyes fall at once upon three strange nude figures raised on a high wooden plat- form. These are the symbolic forms—‘Les Ombres’’—by M. Rodin that are to crown his Gate of Hell, and that the French, who have a genius for ordering these mat- ters as they should be, have placed in their relative positions at the height at which they will eventually be seen. Fierce emotion, ex- pressed and fixed for ever by the sculptor’s art,isyour first impression as you look at the bowed headsandalmost distorted limbs; and it is not until afterwards that you begin to question their monumental, their sculptur- esque value; that you feel, as in the “‘Bour- geois” of Calais, their want of harmonious balance, of noble outline, of just those qualities which distinguish the work of the Greek sculptors who are to M. Rodin, as he has just been assuring a reporter in Lon- don, the great masters of all time. This year, whatever M. Rodin might choose to exhibit would attract the attention even of a public hitherto indifferent, so extraor- dinary have been the demonstrations in his honor in London—the horses unharnessed,

Page 13

4 $ ‘1 FY is bi June 12, 1902] The Nation. 46 and his carriage, with Mr. Sargent on the box, dragged triumphantly through the streets by the Slade students. But for those who care, the three “brooding giants,”’ as they have been described, need no such sen- sational advertisement, and the exhibition that contains them cannot be wholly com- monplace. When you have entered the building and mounted the stairs, in the first gallery you find yourself standing before a huge deco- rative panel, where beautiful women and Satyrs are at play in a fair garden with its presiding deity overlooking them from a tall white pedestal, while more Arcadians come to join in their revels, rowed across the blue lake from a town lying like a white dream at the foot of the far hills, under a cloudless summer sky. This is M. Besnard’s ‘ile Heureuse”; and though I have seen many pictures by him that 1} thought more splendid in color, more dar- ing in experiment, more stately in com- position, still, as a work not without charm by a painter of deservedly great reputa- tion, this cannot be passed over in silence, nor can the exhibition in which it is hung be called dull without reservation. The truth is, in almost every gallery 1s something that gives one, if not pleasure, at least reason for thought. Take the big characteristic Salon machines. None may be very remarkable. M. Gervex has paint- ed the “Banquet of the Mayors” in 1900, and has made what was wanted, a record, more accurate and interesting than any photo- graph could be, of the principal personages who assisted at the function. M. Rixens has given a similar version of the formal tribute paid to Pasteur, more than photo- graphic in its accuracy, less than artistic in its accomplishment. M. Dubufe has pro- duced an enormous symbolic group, with Gounod—an excellent portrait, I believe— surrounded by musical angels in the cor- rect symbolic poses. Still better are M. Detaille’s two huge decorations for the H6tel de Ville, in the old Salon, with inci- dents of the Revolution and First Empire for subjects, astonishingly vigorous and vi- tal in their straightforward statement of historical facts. And best of all, from a decorative standpoint, is M. Aman-Jean’s panel—and for this you must retire to the new Salon—a prim, formal garden; in the foreground a few languid ladies, in lan- guid-hued draperies, languidly posed, play- ing with a peacock, very charming in senti- ment and very graceful in design, but I cannot help wondering how its languor and pale tones, the color already faded in its first freshness, will stand the practical test of decoration. Even M. Aman-Jean has often been seen to greater advantage. If, however, more powerful and more beau- tiful work of the kind has been shown in previous exhibitions, these ambitious exer- cises are the proof that every year brings with it, of the workmanlike training, the complete technical knowledge and ability demanded as a matter of course of the French artist. He knows his trade, and this alone is a virtue, after the parade of ama- teurishness and incompetence in the Eng- lish Academy. When it comes to the portraits, there is much not only vigorous but original. Mr. Whistler, who had nothing last year, sends a group of five pictures. An exquisite little nude, ‘“Phryné la Superbe,” I have already described, I think, at the time it was ex- hibited in London at the International, where the two other smaller paintings, a shop and a marine, were also hung. But the portrait of Mrs. Vanderbilt, ‘ivoire et or,’ has never been shown anywhere be- fore, and very beautiful it is; the canvas is oval in shape, the figure is seen in less than half-length, and is painted with a re- straint and dignity that would be its pass- port into the Louvre. Nothing could be sim- pler. Over the shoulders, a dark wrap is thrown, its soft white ruffles of lace open- ing at the neck and making a high collar from which the head rises with infinite grace and distinction. But how well the figure fills the space, what character there is in the face; and how beautiful the sur- face Mr. Whistler gives, how entirely he succeeds in following his own counsel and concealing the means by which he has made it the perfect work of art it is! Below is the picture of a child in a red cap, “‘grenat et or,’”’ *‘Le Petit Cardinal,’’ a flower-like little face, as lovely as the scheme of color of which it is the motive. There is nothing by M. Boldini, unfortunately, and Mr. Al- exander also is unrepresented. But Mr. Sargent has that amazing portrait of two sisters which was at the Academy last year, and which seems as brilliantly clever, as daring, in Paris as it did in London. In the power of realizing character and fearlessness in expressing it, M. Lucien Simon is not to be outdone by Mr. Sargenz. He has two large groups this year. One, of a family party lingering over their coffee after dinner, with, for background, a win- dow opening on a tranquil twilight land- scape, is not so interesting, probably be- cause the people themselves did not give him the same chance. But the second is not a bit less striking than Mr. Sargent’s. Two Little Sisters of the Poor and an old lady they are visiting on their daily rounds have been his sitters, and it is easy to see the pleasure he has found in por- traying and insisting upon the contrast be- tween the two faces of the nuns—between the shrewdness, the benevolence, the hu- morous self-confidence of the older sister, and the shyness, the painful self-conscious- ness, the shame almost of the younger; be- tween the old shrivelled flesh, lined and wrinkled, and the fresh young flesh, smooth and blood-warmed, the rich red line of the mouth telling so well in its sombre setting of black and white. But M. Simon has lit- tle sense of style. His work is brutal in its realism. He presents the facts before him as he finds them, and there his respon- sibility in the matter ends. It is a pity, for if his pictorial feeling equalled his powers of observation and technical proficiency, he might do wonderful things. In point of size and enterprise M. Ca- rolus-Duran’s big family group, “En Fa- mille,’”’ is, without question, the most inipor- tant of the portraits. On a colossal stretch of canvas he has painted himself, his wife, his children, his grandchildren, even the beribboned bonne of the youngest, and the dog of the household—seventeen figures in all. The picture has the meretricious air of elegance so unpleasant in most of M. Carolus-Duran’s later portraits, and the composition is without unity or dignity; but, on coming from the Royal Academy to the Salon, the very ability of the work and the physical energy it implies seem astounding. M. Dagnan-Bouveret’s portraits of Gé- réme, in his palm-leaf embroidered coat, and two ladies in costly gowns draw the crowd, but the determination with which the paint- er reduces everything—flesh, stuffs, orna- ments, backgrounds—to one smooth ivory- like surface is, to me, intensely disagree able: he appears to flaunt his ultra-refine- ment of technique in one’s face. Better, because more honest and straightforward, is M. Kroyer’s open-air study of Bjérnson, a vigorous piece of realism. M. Blanche, too, is unusually good in his portraits of M. Cottet, the painter, M. Paul Adam, and a youth, as if he found it a relief to be free from the silks and draperies of the ladies of fashion he has so often painted. But M Gandara once more has two portraits of beautiful gowns, one a filmy black stuff over white, rendered with a marvellous skill that would be delightful did it not reduce the woman inside to a mere lay model. Miss Cecilia Beaux hardly seems to me at her best in her three portraits. And if I meu tion a pastel, a charming arrangement in white and red, by M. Aman-Jean, a mas terly little portrait of the late Cosmo Monkhouse by Mr. McLure Hamilton, and the work of M. Picard, Mr. Lavery, and Mr Austen Brown, I think I have completed the list. M. Zorn and M. Edelfelt are among the absent. It is in landscape, however, that paint ers begin to display the most marked in- dividuality. Sometimes, it must be admit ted, the striving after this individuality leads to absurd affectation and mannerism But it is a good sign that painters are no longer content to make an accurate inven- tory of nature with Bastien-Lepage, or to record an impression that is less theirs than Monet's. It is true, Monet still has his disciples; the strong work of M. Claus and M. Buysse, the Belgians, and the pris- matic effects of M. Eliot, are tributes to his influence, just as the noble landscapes of M. Harpignies and M. Pointelin in the old Salon prove that the romantic tradi- tion is not yet exhausted. But, as a rule in the new Salon each man seems eager to use his eyes for himself and invent a new formula, though, it may be, in a few years’ time when we look back, there will be found more of unity in their aims and accomplishments than we are now conscious of. M. Ménard sees a world all pale gold and green, with tender distances and silent waters, and great white clouds piling them selves up on a luminous sky. In such a landscape this year he has set the long, low walls and towers of Aigues-Mortes, and few things in the Salon have quite the same solemn sentiment and beauty, the same magic of light and atmosphere M. Le Sidaner takes any commonplace sub- ject which happens to present itself—for instance, the garden of a little suburban villa, where the table has been spread for dinner, and a lamp lit before all the after glow has faded from the heavens—and, by sheer truth of tone and light, produces a harmony that has a very intimate, personal charm. M. Cottet paints the sad litle gray Breton village on the barren shore by the sea in the cold winter light, with a dig nity and pathos that make me wish he had cut down his big canvas and left out the heavy black-robed figures of the peasant women on their way to mass in the village ehurch. Mr. Morrice, whether in a Vene- tian café at evening with the Salute ig

Page 14

464 The Nation. [Vol. 74, No. 1928 sight, or on the shores of the northern sea, always sees his subject in decorative lines and masses and delicate color ar- rangements. But it is impossible to name all the painters of good landscape. Lher- mitte, Billotte, Lagarde, Lebourg, Thau- low, and as many more, all have pictures of more or less note. Then there are M. Raffaélli’s characteristic streets. And I was interested to see a series of five can- vases by Mr. Childe Hassam—the Quai Voltaire in Paris, the Spanish Steps in Rome, flowers, fruit—though I do not think they have quite the personal quality of much of his work; it is almost as if he had felt the necessity of suggesting French masters out of deference to the Salon. I should not give an adequate idea of the exhibition, perhaps, if I did not at least refer to some of the other paintings which I have not space to describe—the six studies of the same face, each differing in expression, but all alike mist-enveloped, by M. Carriére; the enigmatic figure in armor by Mr. Humphreys-Johnston; the Venetian impressions by Mr. Vail; the care- fully studied little interiors by Mr. Walter Gay; the rather monotonous seas by Mr. Harrison; the peasant bride and groom by Mr. Melchers; the brilliant effects of light in a ball-room by Mr. La Touche; the still- life studies by M. Zakarian, who has had the temerity to borrow the exact subject and arrangement of one of the Chardins in the Louvre. Nor is the element of sensa- tion altogether missing. M. Veber, with his dwarfs and grotesques and spirit of “La Machine,” is beginning to take the place in public favor of M. Béraud, who stays away altogether. M. Louis Legrand, too accomplished an artist to need such aids, seeks to “épater le bourgeois’ by his bold use of the palette knife and the way he appears to be trying to model in relief with his paint. M. Flandrin, M. Mil- cendeau, M. Charles Guérin, and two or three others do what they can. to revive the old fashion of eccentricity. But, on the whole, sensation is but feeble and faint- hearted. I might also point out that the more distinguished German painters, like Von Uhde and Liebermann, do not con- tribute. The prints do not fall away from their high level of excellence and originality, though-there is not, as in some previous years, any very new departure or move- ment or experiment calling for special no- tice. In the old Salon there are lithographs by M. Dillon (but where is M. Willette?), etchings by Mr. Pennell, a wood-engraving by Mr. Wolf; in the new Salon the wood blocks and etchings of M. Lepére, M. Flo- rian, M. Renouard, M, Legrand, among others; the lithographs of M. Lunois, M. Riviére, M. Veber, and a long series of the various kinds of engraving by men who are masters of these different arts. But it is curlous how little attention is given to original drawings for illustration. With few exceptions, most of the black-and-white drawings are simply sketches and notes for the artist’s own use. As usual, the average is nowhere higher than in the sculpture courts. Again, as of- ten before, one sees on every side work of the technical distinction that never fails the French, and that made the decoration of the Exhibition buildings of 1900 possible. And it is because of this average that it becomes so difficult to write of the sculp- ture in such limited space. All that can be done is to call attention to a few of the more important contributions, I have already spoken of the work of M. Rodin, who towers over everybody, and whose in- fluence reveals itself everywhere in subjects chosen and methods of treatment. He has also a bust of Victor Hugo in the new Salon, where a fragment of a tomb by M. Bartholomé, and two busts of laborers by M. Meunier, whose influence is as mark- ed as M. Rodin’s, are among the most not- able things. In the old Salon, M. Frémiet’s “Duguesclin” is full of go and vigor, and the sculptor has not been afraid to give a certain homely character, curiously con- vincing, to his hero, though M, Frémiet never designs an equestrian statue that one does not at once compare it, to its disad- vantage, with the Jeanne d’Arc in the Place des Pyramides. Mr. MacMonnies’s ‘‘General Slocum” is a fine, spirited performance, but Mr. MacMonnies is so accomplished that the action of horse and officer becomes almost too spirited in its truth—will not both, you cannot help asking, at the next step plunge into space? M. Hamar is show- ing the base of the Rochambeau monument in Washington; seen without the figure on the top, it seems too restless, while spreadeagleism, in its most rampant mood, is expressed by the allegorical bird. More and more space is being given to the decorative work included under the general classification of objets d’art. The furniture, as a rule, repeats the exaggera- tions to which the grandiloquent name of “L’Art Nouveau” has been given. But many of the smaller articles, especially among the goldsmiths’ exhibits, are of genuine beauty, while the French craftsman has al- ways the proper respect for his medium: he does not, like the English craftsman, take rough peasant’s work as a model, It is interesting, too, to find many artists, already distinguished as painters, sculptors, and draughtsmen, appearing as decorators. A scheme for a billiard-room, in which M. Chéret, M. Charpentier, and M. Bracque- mond have collaborated, is shown; and al- so a piano painted by M. Besnard and carved by M. Charpentier. N. N. MEDIAZVAL ART AT THE DUSSELDORF EXPOSITION. DisseLvorr, May, 1902. The success of the Rhenish-Westphaliap Exposition at Diisseldorf, whose formal opening on the first of May was.signalized by the first public speech of the German Crown Prince, is an event of more than local, nay, of more than merely national importance. Planned towards the end of the nineties, at the height of an era of in- dustrial expansion and enterprise, carried through during the financial depression of the last year and a half, it is a striking evi- dence of the foresight, pluck, resourceful- ness, and skill with which German business men and manufacturers have weathered the crisis that is just passing. Limited as it is to the Rhineland and Westphalia, it dem- onstrates all the more impressively what enormous strides Germany is making in every domain of industrial production. For it is no exaggeration to say that the ex- hibit made here by two provinces only may well challenge comparison with the total of the German exhibit at the World’s Fair .of 1898. And there can be no question that, to the industrial world of both Europe cad America, this provincial Exposition will im- part lessons in a way even more instructive than those taught by the monster exhibits of Chicago and Paris. It was a happy thought—a thought con- ceived principally by the Rey. Schniitgen, canon of Cologne, and Prof. Clemen, curator of Rhenish antiquities at Diisseldorf—to connect with this display of modern Ger- man industry and art an exhibition of the artistic productions of Rhenish Germany in the Middle Ages, chiefly in the domain of ecclesiastical architecture and sculpture. To be sure, it is a great contrast to step from the enormous halls of the Krupp iron works or the Westphalian mining com- panies, with their gigantic machinery and their ceaseless hubbub, into the quiet rooms where statues of saints and the portals of cathedrals proclaim the ideals of the past. But who would deny that these ideals have lost vitality only with regard to their out- ward form, that their essence holds good for us as well as our forefathers, and that the restless activity of modern life is more and more tending toward a reshaping and a rehabilitation even of their outward forms? To the antiquarian, the most in- teresting part of this mediwval collection is likely to be a superb array of church utensils and ornaments, sent hither by the ecclesiastical authorities of both the prov- inces concerned. Since practically all the great cathedral seats of northwestern Ger- many—Aix-la-Chapelle, Cologne, Miinster, Paderborn, Hildesheim, Osnabriick among them—have showered their treasures upon this Exposition, there is here offered an unequalled opportunity for studying from the originals what medieval handicraft pro- duced in textile industry, in ivory, wood, in- taglio, bronze, silver and gold work. Never before have altar shrines and other reli- quaries been brought together in so im- pressive numbers or in so instructive a selection; never before has the develop- ment of their forms from the austere so- lemnity of the Byzantine manner to the wilfulness of Gothic naturalism been placed before us so systematically or with so much detail. The most striking feature, however, of this mediw#val museum—at least to the lay- man—is that here, for the first time, has been successfully tried in Germany what the Trocadéro and the South Kensington Museum have already accomplished for France and England: the reproduction, in plaster-casts, of large monumental works of native architecture and sculpture. It is really astonishing how little Germany, which ‘has done so much for the study of the history of the plastic arts of other countries, has thus far done towards bring- ing the greatness of her own artistic past home to the popular mind. It is undoubt- edly legitimate that, as a means of esthetic culture, the history of Greek sculpture should occupy a place in the national educa- tion superior to that of any other similar study. But that the great mass of German students should be absolutely ignorant of the wonderful creations of German architec- tural sculpture in the Middle Ages; that the German section of the great collection of plaster-casts in the Royal Museum at Berlin should embrace two small rooms on a floor the main body of which is given over to the rich Egyptian collections; that even

Page 15

June 12, 1902] The Nation. in the Germanic Museum at Niirnberg the plaster-casts of medieval monuments should be crowded together in dark passages and cloister-like halls, where a proper inspection and careful study are entirely out of the question—these are facts which prove once more how recent a thing the growth of a strong national consciousness has been in Germany. In Diisseldorf, for the first time, a mediz- val exposition has been attempted that has a truly medieval setting. There is no place in its halls where the visitor would not feel something of the quiet grandeur of a medi- geval church, whether entering through the graceful portal of Our Lady’s at Tréves (the same which the Emperor is going to give to the Germanic Museum at Cambridge), or standing under the massive arches of the ‘Paradise’ of Miinster cathedral, with its solemnly archaic statues of the apostles, or passing by the splendid choir screen of All Souls’ Chapel in the cathedral of Aix-la- Chapelle. That there may be dangers in this architectural framework of a museum of national civilization cannot be denied; the temptation involved in it to sacrifice scientific correctness to picturesque ar- rangement is obvious, and several even of the best-known museums in Europe have fallen victims to this temptation. On the other hand, the connection between archi- tecture and sculpture is so close that a statue deprived of its architectural back- ground in most cases becomes an isolated, lifeless number; and mediwval sculpture in particular is absolutely unintelligible if it is not studied ‘‘on the spot,’’ i. e., in its or- ganic relation to its sister-art. It is to be hoped, therefore, that the Diis- seldorf example will be followed in the two great museums of medieval art which are now being planned in Berlin and in Munich. As for America, we may congratulate our- selves that the most conspicuous feature of the Emperor’s noble gift to the projected Germanic Museum of Harvard University consists in this very combination of monu- mental sculpture and architecture. It would be a consummation of which America might justly be proud, if the whole of this museum were to be carried out in conformity with this magnificent beginning. KUNO FRANCKE. Correspondence. RABELAIS ON WAR. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: In ‘Gargantua’ (chap. xlvi.), Grand- gousier, in reply to Touquedillon, who re- veals Picrochole’s plans of conquest, says: “C’est trop entrepris: qui trop embrasse peu estrainct. Le temps nest plus d’ainsi conquester les royaumes, avec dom- mages de son prochain frere christian: ceste imitation des anciens Hercules, Alexandres, Hannibals, Scipions, Cesars et autres telz, est contraire a la profession de l’Evangile, par lequel nous est com- mandé garder, sauver, regir, et adminis- trer chascun ses pays et terres, non hos- tilement envahir les autres. Et ce que les Sarrasins et barbares jadis appelloient prouesses, maintenant nous appelons brigan- deries et meschancetés. Mieulx eust il fait soy contenir en sa maison, loyallement la gouvernant, que insulter en la mienne, hos- tilement la pillant; car par bien la gouver- ner l’eust augmentée, par me piller sera destruict’’ (édition Burgaud des Marets et Rathery). These words of the great French writer of the first half of the sixteenth century are full of interest. If we lay aside all moral considerations, and suppose that a part of the millions sunk in Cuba and the Philip- pines were spent in making roads, in irri- gating the arid lands of the West, in pro- moting education, in helping the small college, ete., the benefit to our country would be incalculable. TIMOTHY CLORAN. VANDERBILT UNtvERSITY, NASHVILLE, TENN., June 5, 1902. EARLY PUPPET-SHOW PICTURES. TO THE EDITOR OF THB NATION: Sir: One of the most attractive of the papers presented to Dr. F. J. Furnivall in honor of his seventy-fifth birtnday, is M. Jusserand’s ‘“‘Note on Pageants and ‘Scaf folds Hye’"’ (‘An English Miscellany,’ pp. 185-196). The text, to be sure, contains little that has not long been well known but it is accompanied by two pictures, re- produced from an early manuscript, repre- schting, in M. Jusserand’s opinion, ‘‘scaf- folds” or ‘‘pageants’’ such as were used in the great cycles of York, Wakefield, New- castle, Preston, Kendal, Louth, Chester, Coventry, Norwich, and otuaer towns. These at once arrest the attention, not only cn account of the notable skill of the artisr, but because, as M. Jusserand truly says, no contemporary picture of an English Corpus Christi pageant has yet discovered. Pictures and plans of similar pageants or stages in France and Germany exist, and are now easily accessible; for the pageants of England we have been obliged to cou- tent ourselves with imaginative reconstruc tions, based upon the detailed account giv- en by Archdeacon Rogers, towards the end of the sixteenth century, and the scattered details found in the expense books of the “companies” or ‘‘gilds’’ concerned in the plays, as printed by Sharp, Fitch, Furnivall Morris, Miss Toulmin-Smith, and others. Most of these accounts date from the six- teenth century; the earliest go back to the beginning of the fifteenth. Pictures of such pageants from a_ fourteenth-century manuscript would therefore have a double claim upon the attention of all students of the early drama. Unfortunately, the pictures reproduced by M. Jusserand are not pictures of pageants in a Corpus Christi play. They are, as any one may discover by careful examina- tion, pictures of puppet-booths. In the first one, especially, the traditional figures of Punch and Judy are clearly recognizable. What names they bore then, what acts they performed, or what dialogue delighted the children before the booth, may, to borrow one of Sir Thomas Browne's phrases, ‘‘ad- mit of a wide solution.”’ The attitude of Punch and the presence of his club suggest that action and dialogue did not depart es- sentially from the delightful brutality of present-day performances. These pictures are, moreover, not so en- tirely unknown as M. Jusserand supposes. In 1848 Mr. J. O. Westwood published the first picture in the Archwological Journal, and accompanied it with a brief discussion in which the true character of the perfor- is definitely stated and duly com- mented upon (v., 198 ff.). In spite of these facts, our indebtedness to M. Jusserand is undiminished. Few, even been mance among scholars, now read the early volumes of Archwologiaor the Archeological Journal, and the history of puppet-shows in the Mid- dle Ages is one of the most interesting and perplexing chapters of an interesting and perplexing subject Notwithstanding the minor contributions that have made and the books that have professed to con tain an adequate treatment, almost every thing remains to be done. Yours very truly, Joun M June 5, lvoe been MANLY CAMBRIDOR, Mass, WORDSWORTH'S “ODE TO DUTY.” To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Your correspondent, in the Nation of June 5, who inquires about an expunged stanza of Wordsworth’'s “Ode to Duty,” will find it in the ‘Poems’ of 1807, where it ap- pears as the sixth stanza. I myself reprint- ed it, accidentally, in a collection of verse, ‘Through Love to Light,’ which I publish ed in 1896. It brought me a number of inquiries, some of them from devout and critical Wordsworthians, to whom I should have thought the ‘Poems’ of 1807 would have been known. The poem was, I be lieve, written in 1805, presumably with this stanza as a part of it; and, is to the other stanzas, we inferior as it are undoubted ly indebted to Wordsworth's wiser second thought for its exclusion from editions sub sequent to that of 1807. Yours very truly, JOHN WHITE BrRooxiyn, N. Y., June 5, 1002 CHADWICK TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Professor Knight, in his latest edi- tion of Wordsworth (the Eversley of 1896), in volume il., page 71, refers to a “proof copy of the sheets of the edition of 1807, which was cancelled by Wordsworth,” in which the entire poem is unlike its later form, particularly in the first four stanzas; and in this proof copy is your correspon- dent’s sixth which was printed in 1807 only. Fortunately, Wordsworth’'s cretion” led him to change this first copy, with the exception of the stanza referred to. Two stanzas only stand as originally written, though the change in the seventh is very slight. Professor Knight use this cancelled stanza in his text gives the entire note. Professor Dowden was not unaware of this stanza, which surely is unworthy of being recalled, for he wrote me about this earlier draft in 1890, soon after it was discovered by Mr. J. R. Tutin of Hull. The sheet which gives this earlier version of the entire poem was found in a copy of the poems of 1807 Mr. Tutin had the sheet printed with the following heading, ‘‘Can- celled Version of Wordsworth’s Ode to Duty.” Both Mr. Tutin and Professor Dow- den sent me a copy, and I shall be glad to edition stanza, “dis- does not He proof-copy version in a printed send one to any interested person who may not have access to the Eversiey edition of 1896. I find after writing the above that Mr Hutchinson, in his (Oxford) of Wordsworth’'s Poems, has given this same sixth stanza in brackets in the test of the poem; which undoubtedly accounts for A. T. Quiller-Couch’s using the stanza in his ‘Ox- ford Book of English Verse.’ This use of the stanza by Mr. Hutchinson is question- edition

Page 16

466 The Nation. [Vol. 74, No. 1928 able, as it certainly mars the poem. Finally, I discover a note without a reference, and therefore easily overlooked, on the ‘Ode to Duty’’ at the end of volume iv. of the Dowden edition of the Poems. The can- celled sixth stanza is quoted in it. Sincerely yours, CYNTHIA MORGAN ST. JOHN. IrHaca, N. Y., June 8, 1902. Notes. Among the fall announcements of Little, Brown & Co., Boston, are a three-volume edition of hitherto uncollected speeches and writings of Daniel Webster, and Helen Hunt Jackson's ‘Glimpses of California and the Missions,’ for the first time by itself, and with numerous illustrations by Henry Sandham. The publication of Mr. W. A. Linn’s ‘Story of the Mormons’ is closely followed by the announcement of ‘The Founder of Mormonism,’ by I. Woodbridge Riley, for immediate issue by Dodd, Mead & Co. E. P. Dutton & Co. have nearly ready a work on ‘The English Lake District,’ by Mr. Ruskin’s biographer, Mr. W. G. Col- lingwood. Among Macmillan’s reprints which call for no more than passing mention, as hav- ing been already considered in these col- are Walter ‘Line and and Foster-Milliar’s ‘Book of the Rose,’ In a second edition, thoroughly re- vised seven years. Thackeray's ‘Henry Esmond,’ in two volumes, carries on the Dent edition of this author, Messrs. Longman the eighth edi- tion of Mr. Baltour’s ‘Foundations of Be- lief.” It has been somewhat enlarged with explanatory notes, and is provided with a new introduction and argumentative sum- mary. umps, Crane’s Form,’ after offer The Sonnets of Shakspere were, of course, bound to find a place in John Lane’s dainty and companionable ‘Lovers’ Library’’—the text in green ink, the borders in violet; yet how much more ornamental would have been an index of first lines. A real service to present-day readers alike and to the memory of a true man is the edition of ‘The Serious Poems of Thom- as Hood’ (London: George Newnes; New York: Scribners), just added to the Cax- ton Series. Mr. H. Granville’ Fell’s illustrations, or most of them, we could forego, for the thin -paper volume with blue limp covers is pretty enough without them, and the weakest are something of a dis- figurement. Here are “One more. un- fortunate,” ‘‘We watched her breathing through the night,”’ “I remember, I re- member,’ “Eugene Aram,” ‘“‘The Haunted House,"’ “Hero and Leander,” ‘The Mid- summer Fairies,’ and many more products (not all wholly “serious’’) of the sad hu- morlist. The punctuation needed more at- tention than it has received. In reviewing, four years ago, Mr. W. A. Paton's ‘Picturesque Sicily’ (Harpers), we pointed out the free use he had made of Gaston Vuillier, and also his own strug- gles with the Italian language. It seems in keeping with this that his work has now been done into Italian, ‘Sicilia Pittoresca,’ and published, with 48 half-tones, in Milan (Remo Sandron). The compliment to the solider portion of this American work is not undeserved. ‘The International Year Book’ for 1901 (Dodd, Mead & Co.) maintains the standard of previous volumes. The United States has thirty-one pages, Great Britain four- teen, France, China, and Cuba each ten, Ger- many eight, the Transvaal seven, the Phil- ippines six, with a cross-reference for military operations. There are _ twelve maps and some thirty-five illustrations. The sciences receive adequate attention, and the editor’s care seems to have been bestowed on every topic that belongs to “the world’s progress during the year.” Obituary notices are full for Victoria and McKinley, less extensive in the cases of Crispi, Li Hung Chang, and others. Au- thors (as Mr. Kipling) who had put forth nothing of great importance during 1901 are relegated to the articles on Literature, which for America and England covers nine pages, for France four, for Germany less than two, for Russia one: Gorky, as a notable new arrival, gets an individual notice. Six pages are devoted to educa- tion in the United States, and Mr. Car- negie’s gifts and Mr. J. P. Morgan’s exploits are duly chronicled. The impossibility of being wholly up to date, or down to date, is shown in the case of the Panama Canal, here considered under that of Nicaragua; next year the positions may probably be reversed. ‘The History of India for Boys and Girls,’ by Sri Hemlota Devi, translated by M. S. Knight (Longmans), can safely be recom- mended as an elementary history of her country by a Hindu—especially valuable as treating of the native religions from a na- tive standpoint. Two-thirds of this little book are devoted to the pre-European period of government. Maps, plans, and engravings illustrate the text, and the price brings the book within the reach of all. Allowed as a school-book in India, it 1s necessarily reserved upon many subjects concerning which most Indians feel deeply. In this its English form it will probably be appreciated more by elders desirous of having some elementary knowledge of In- dian affairs than by ‘‘boys and girls.” J. Vendryes, a pupil of Henry, Havet, and Thurneysen, in a recent work, ‘Recherches sur l’Histoire et les Effets de l’Intensité Initiale en Latin’ (Paris: Klincksieck), seeks to overturn the now commonly ac-, cepted view that the Latin accent was an accent of stress, and to find in it, at least in the classical period, a tonic or melodic accent, a view to which C. W. L. Johnson inclines in an article included in the ‘Studies in honor of Professor Gilder- sleeve.’ M. Vendryes admits, however, for the prehistoric period an accent of intensity resting upon the initial syllable, and to the phonetic effects of this accent the main portion of his work is devoted. In some points he is in agreement with Sommer in his ‘Handbuch der Lateinischen Laut- und Formenlehre’ (1902); in others he differs. The effect of intensity upon quantity, and the subject of syncope and absorption, are treated at length, and with an abundance of illustration. In an appendix a new at- tempt is made to solve the vexed problem of the Saturnian, bringing in the theory of initial intensity. The work concludes with an “Index des principaux mots latins étudiés."’ The author challenges criti- cism at many points, but his exposition is always clear, interesting, and sugges- tive. The History of Uganda, in the native lan- guage, which has just been printed in Eng- land, is a remarkable testimony to the pro- gress made in that country in the past twen- ty-five years, as well as a noteworthy con- tribution to literature. The author is the Katikiro (Prime Minister) and the repre- sentative of his countrymen at the corona- tion, and his book, so far as our knowledge goes, is the first published history of an African people written by a native in his owu tongue. In it he gives some account of their mythology before the teaching of Christianity, and it is curious to note that, as with the Dasuns of Borneo, so this cen- tral African tribe attributes the origin of evil to a woman. When the Creator sent his grandson Kintu and his wife Nambi to the earth to people it, he strictly enjoined him to go early in the morning so that “your brother Death may not see where you go, for if he goes with you he will kill all your children.”’ In obedience to this in- junction, “before it was light, he packed up all his things, and set out, and came down to earth; but his wife suddenly remembered that she had left the corn behind which was to feed a fowl she had with her. She said to her husband, ‘I have left the corn for the fowl in the porch of the house, IT must go back and fetch it.’ Her husband Kintu refused, and said, ‘You must not go back, for if you do you will meet Death.’ But his wife was obstinate,’’ and went back and got the corn. As she was returning to the earth, ‘‘Death met her, and said to her, ‘Why have you left me, my friends?’ So he went with Nambi, the obstinate wife, ‘ and when Kintu' begat children Death killed them.’’ Our extracts are taken from a translation printed in Uganda Notes. The Annales de Géographie for May con- tains an interesting account, by M. Gaston Bonnier, of his experiments in what he terms a “new chapter of science,” geo- graphic botany. One series consisted in cul- tivating shoots of the same plant or tree near Paris and on the Mediterranean shore, and observing the manner in which each set adapted itself to the different conditions of soil and climate. Another was in taking plants growing in the neighborhood of Paris and subjecting them, through artificial cold and electric light, to Arctic conditions. The results of these experiments convinced him that they constituted a positive argument in favor of the hypothesis that the specific characteristics of the plants of any region have been gradually acquired through adaptation to the climate. An article on the rainfall of northern France, an oro- graphic and geological description of Al- geria, and a discussion of the products of Argentina also deserve mention. The ex- tent of the undeveloped resources of this South American country may be gathered from the single fact that if all the land on which wheat could be grown were culti- vated, the amount of the crop would be increased twenty-four times. An encour- aging report is given of the progress of Madagascar in agriculture and the means of communication. Mr. Edward Wilson James continues in the first part of volume iv. of his Lower Norfolk Co. (Va.), Antiquary his valuable lists of slave-owners—here for Princess Anne County, in 1778. In an interesting foot- note itistold of Jacob Hunter, senior, who ig

Page 17

June 12, 1902] The Nation. set down as the master of sixteen human chattels, that he lost twenty-eight negroes in the Revolutionary war—not by being car- ried off by the British, but by some distem- per imported from them by a negro by the name of Frank. Frank was an habitual run- away, and his ‘‘treatment consisted in be- ing stripped naked and hoisted to the top of a tall pole, where the wind could blow on him.”’ “Many negroes ran away to the British,’ and such as were recaptured by the Continental frigates or privateers were sold at auction, subject to the equity of their owners. In spite of its pronounced character, the face of the late Edwin L. Godkin offered some difficulties for portraiture by pencil or camera. Among the more successful at- tempts is the “‘imperial panel’ photograph made by F. Gutekunst, Philadelphia, some years before Mr. Godkin’s bodily vigor had been impaired; and now reissued. For a lat- er period there is nothing better than George C. Cox’s photograph (South Orange, N. J.). In its own field, G. Kruell’s wood- engraving, of masterful technique, has no rival (East Orange, N. J.). —The Ruin of Education in Ireland’ (Lon- don: David Nutt) is a remarkably outspok- en treatise by a sincere Catholic (proud of his religion, and respectful regarding its essentials) concerning what he believes to be the ecclesiasticism and undue influ- ence of the Jesuits and the bishops, which are tending to impoverish and mar the intellectual progress of Ireland. It is un- fortunate for the views put forward that the author, Frank Hugh O’Donnell, has been such a discontented element in Irish affairs through the last third of a century. Nevertheless, the book must be taken on its merits, and Mr. O’Donnell’s exposition of educational tendencies in his native coun- try cannot be lightly set aside and will have its influence. He is’ especially strong against the clerical monopoly of teaching, and the spending of vast sums by the heads of Irish Catholicism upon un- necessary buildings and gaudy ornamenta- tion, to the neglect of education. He con- trasts the comparative liberality of his church upon the Continent and elsewhere with its narrowness in Ireland, and em- phasizes the belief of most thoughtful Irish Home Rulers that it is accorded more pow- er over teaching and ordinary affairs of life by a Protestant Government, in its attempt to maintain its position, than it would be by a Home Rule Government. —Scholarships which are of the nature of prizes given solely on the strength of an open competitive examination are the rule in England and the exception in America. So far as it leads to the absorption of val- uable scholarships by those who have means of their own, the English system in- volves some waste of endowments; on the other hand, the standard of excellence maintained in scholarship examination un- doubtedly is higher in proportion as the field is wider from which competitors are drawn. The standard required for English scholarship is high, and this makes every ambitious schoolboy aim at some scholar- ship, and also centres more attention and consideration upon serious work than ath- letics are commonly supposed to allow. In scholarships, then, we find a corrective for the too great interest in athletics. Holders of scholarships at English colleges and schools certainly take a position of dis- tinction which, under favorable circum- stances, easily amounts to a sort of ac- knowledged leadership. Nor do those of them enjoying a good income independently of their scholarships at all invariably ac- cept its stipend. Some recent foundations, indeed, provide in set terms that the sti- pend shall revert to the foundation or go to a second scholar when the scholar-elect does not stand in need of it. such provision exists in the case of the recently Some founded musical scholarship which com- memorates Lewis R. Nettleship at Balliol Nettleship dreamt of music as a power which should unite the jarring sects and septs of mankind by promoting generous human intercourse unaccompanied by the danger of luxury. But these good offices could, he thought, be well performed only when learned things the late Perhaps both and had their views clarified on this point, by the curious position still made at Oxford Oxford musicans habitually and this view Sir John Stainer also shared. of them other than music, were moved to dissent, thus for degrees in music. Alone of all baccalaureates (there are six others), for the B.Mus. no residence at Oxford is re- quired. At all events the most pointed dissent from the notions of musical educa- tion these tainly embodied in the Nettleship scholarship. underlying regulations is cer- institution of the —The for Nettleship scholar is required to read and the avenues to the B.A. degree afforded by the Oxford, Honors; varied as are eight honor schools at not one of them contains any music unless it be found in ‘“‘Animal Morphology’ under “Hearing and the Ear.’’ Our scholar may take his honors in Animal Morphology if he so chooses, although his previous studies would hardly make the choice a prudent one; but otherwise his work for the de- gree has no direct bearing upon music whatever. Nevertheless, the standard rig- idly enforced at Balliol in electing the Net- tleship scholar insures his being so excep- tionally gifted that he cannot possibly dis- the prosecuting which he finds more than com- petent the Thus the college community secures an in- fluence which plays no small part in under- graduate life, where, so far as music goes, the Nettleship scholar is inter pares. Organized by the college ganist, the concerts of the Balliol College continue serious pursuit of music, in assistance in college organist. always primus or- Musical Society, one of the most successful of Jowett’s innovations, had already taken firm hold the Nettleship a very before foundation. That these concerts now have so definitely their place in the front rank, and yet not only have retained the inti- mate character which makes all social do- ings in a college more like family gather- ings than public assemblies, but also keep than undiminished hold the the undergraduate has largely been made possible by the Nettle- a more upon interest of world, ship foundation. Details from programmes might be quoted to show the important part played by its beneficiaries. Nor is this all. A vista of the further possibilities of use- fulness from the Nettleship foundation has been opened up by the frequent participa- tion in these concerts of Mr. Donald Tovey, pianist and scholar the the rising Nettleship now a elected composer, when 467 in 1894. From time to time Mr. Tovey has also lectured scholarship was founded publicly in the College Hall. One of his lectures was on the Sonata Appassionata of Beethoven, the nature of a tragedy; a second dealt with concision and diffuseness in musical and he has lately entered his caveat against the abuse viewed as of style in current musical criticism of the terms “intellectual” and ‘‘emotional.” —The Seventh Annual Report of the Rrit- ish School at Athens (Macmillan) Is chiefly to an account of the excay 1901 of Dr. Arthur J. Evans on the ancient palace at Knossus in Crete, with a briefer the D. G. Hogarth at Zakro, on the eastern end of the Never results of like extent and importance devoted ations in the site o report of explorations of same island before have been so promptly and withal so satisfactorily published, with many plans and other illus- trations. Mr. Louis Dyer's recent letter on the House of the Double pated summary of antici- Dr. Other British excava- Axe has any our own of Evans's revelations tions at Prwsos have brought to Hgeht an inscription in an unknown tongue, but in Greek characters of the fifth century Bp which the the lets. of may be helpful if language is that of Dr seals, and far mors same Aas Evans's clay tab- Some impressions seals, were discovered, of which several bear representations of a man with a bull's head, clearly the Minotaur the finds at Zakro were hundred nodules of clay Among nearly five bearing impressions of in- taglios, and two of these which are repro duced in this Report are of the Minotaur type joyd Dawkins discusses the skulls from cave-burials at Zakro, but comes to no final judgment on vexed questions At the close of the volume is a reunion of two a Greek inscription, one British Muse the other h School at to the fragments of part im and Athen Wilhelm, the most brilliant of living Greek epigraph being in the in the Briti 3, due ingenuity of Dr wko is perhaps ists Dr. Evans reports that the Throne toom of the palace at Knossus has been enclosed and roofed-in-—‘‘a work rendered urgent by the effect which exposure to the weather was already beginning to produce, and the seats and will be but both on the throne itself His successor grateful this parapet.” to him for provision, What excavated ruins which are this the question arises at once, will become in a few years of the not quite valuable enough to receive are to be the damage special care Apparently they left exposed to the elements, and next likely to two thou twenty years areé them than the last objects which have been excluded from the more and Organtl« air for a long time are notably wont to crumble on being exposed, and even a cas- the shows marble in the Elgin that, ual examination of the British polished Museum after has liable to surface of the stone scale-like flakes When the process of disintegra be gins, it Probably the Athens worn away, great break off. tion are once goes on with increas- surface of the suffered obviously from the action of the elements the last the thousand ing rapidity. Parthenon at has mors than in Many an far les during century pre ceding ancient Greek legible to-day than on its discovery half a century years inscription, too, is

Page 18

468 The Nation. [Vol. 74, No. 1928 ago. Thus the intense vigor of archeologists in excavating the remains of antiquity is in imminent danger of leaving to following generations an imperfect heritage. The importance of making the most accurate and complete publications of discoveries is emphasized when we remember that many of the objects found will not remain long unchanged. In this matter is to be seen a much-needed lesson for Americans. The tombstones of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries in New England grave- yards are disintegrating now more rapidly than ever before, and many important fam- ily records are disappearing. When the reader thinks of the recognized necessity of covering the Egyptian granite of the obelisk in the Central Park with a slip of paraffine, in order to preserve it, he will need no long consideration to see that the marble, slate, and sandstone monuments of our graveyards need similar treatment if they are to be preserved. Many a town has old stones of which the citizens are proud now, but of which the inscriptions will become illegible if care is not soon taken. These stones are for the most part seldom seen, and so are out of mind, but some are near the crowded streets of our cities, and yet are neglected. This genera- tion has obligations to its successors, and it will be blamed if it transmits to them only printed copies of the originals. —Old Korea, like Britain with England, Wales, and Scotland, was a territory inside of which were three kingdoms. These had a long history of intestine struggle and bor- der wars, with alternating invasions or succor from China or Japan. In the old books they are called Kaokuli, Sinlo (Silla), and Petsi (Pak-je), the first and most war- like being in the north, the second in the southeast, and the third in the west of the peninsula. Silla, cultivating commerce and the arts of civilization, carried on trade even with the Arabs, in whose books the kingdom and its products are described. China made Silla its ally, and in a great in- vasion, 660 A. D., Chinese armies overran the peninsula, overthrew a dynasty nearly 700 years old, and annexed Pak-je as a province of China. The victory was com- memorated by uprearing a great stone ten feet high and seven feet wide, but the next year the son of the deposed Korean King raised the standard of revolt, and tumbled the big token of imperialism and conquest into the river which flowed past his father’s capital. Four centuries later, during the great drought (1047-1084), the stone was exposed, and the people drew it to the bank, but did not set it up. Cov- ered with the débris of eight centuries, it lay undisturbed until 1886, when Mr. Tong, then Secretary of the Chinese Legation in Seoul, and now Taotai of Tientsin, jour- neyed to Pu-yu and had excavations made at the spot indicated. After eighteen feet of earth had been removed, he _ struck and uncovered the prostrate stone. Clear- ing off the surface, he first took a care- ful rubbing, which is reproduced word for word in the Korea Review for May, 1902, and made preparations to remove the stone. Unfortunately, that night a terrible storm of wind and rain, which unroofed houses, swept away scores of dwellings, and caus- ed loss of life by the river-flood, roused the superstitious fears of the people. Thinking the spirits were angry, they filled up the pit. In substance, the text, after the usual fulsome compliments to the Chi- nese Emperor and his Generals, praises the “benevolent assimilation,” and de- clares that the King, Crown Prince, thir- teen Ministers, and 700 courtiers were car- ried to China, while five Chinese Generals or Military Governors were left to ad- minister the seven districts (250 prefec- tures), which, according to the text, had a population of 6,100,000. THE SIEGE OF QUEBEC. The Siege of Quebec and the Battle of the Plains of Abraham. By A. Doughty, in collaboration with G. W. Parmelee. With plans, portraits, and views. Six volumes. Quebec: Dussault & Proulx. 1901. [1902.] The six volumes of this work constitute the most extensive and important mono- graph which has so far been written in Canada on any episode in the country’s annals. But the interest of the subject outstrips all bounds that are merely local. Montcalm’s defeat and the English occu- pation of Quebec were great events in the history of the whole continent. In the world struggle between England and France they rank even before the battle of Plassey, and they adorn the last days of a hero with sudden, brilliant, and de- cisive triumph. The campaign of 1759 has frequently been described, for the theme is a spirited one and there is no dearth of information. Of recent narratives the most valuable and the most typical are Parkman’s in ‘Montcalm and Wolfe,’ Casgrain’s in ‘Montcalm et Lévis,’ and Kerallain’s in ‘La Jeunesse de Bougainville.’ Parkman may be said to rep- resent the English historian; Casgrain, the French Canadian; and Kerallain, the French. In comparing these three, it must be stated that the differences between the second and third are more pronounced than those between the first and second. Cas- grain is a champion of Vaudreuil, Lévis, and the local militia. The strongest sym- pathies of Kerallain are with Montcalm, Bougainville, and the French of France. Mr. Doughty, who is the chief author of the present work, has unquestionable advantages over all his predecessors in re- spect to his material. What others have collected, he can coérdinate; but that is by no means all. His quest for new docu-% ments in foreign archives has been highly successful, and family papers, both French and English, have been put in his hands by descendants of the leading staff officers. It is obvious that such discoveries as can now be made must relate to details rather than to essentials, but the business of research- ers consists in getting at the facts, even where critical issues are not concerned. We do not mean to imply that Mr. Doughty’s investigations have led merely to the de- termination of minutiw, For example, he shows that the attack which settled the fate of Canada was planned by Wolfe, and not by his brigadiers; but the aim of the study is to settle a number of vexed ques- tions rather than to upset views of the campaign and the battle which are general- ly accepted. We have spoken of the fresh evidence. It fills three large octavo vol- umes, and other volumes will be published at a later date in separate instalments. Most of the new data come from Eng- land and France, but some striking illus- trations of European interest in the war before Quebec have been drawn from the Private Archives of the Czar. The main clue to the contents of this work has already been given in the statement that the documents, as opposed to the text, occupy three volumes. In other words, the first half of the space is devoted to narra- tive and the last half to pieces justificatives. Of the materials we shall not be able to speak at any length. Of the text, the first volume fs devoted to biographies of Wolfe and Montcalm, the second to an account of the siege from its beginning until the first days of September, and the third to a care- ful and precise narrative of the battle, with its immediate consequences. Regarding the biographies we shall only say that they are genuine lives of the two generals, and not sketches of their time. The life of Mont- calm, which has been furnished by the Hon. Thomas Chapais, is the most exhaustive biography of him that has yet been publish- ed in English, while Mr. Parmelee’s life of Wolfe adds a good deal to the information supplied by Wright. The special value of the work, as an independent study of sources, arises from the quality of the second and third volumes. In commenting upon the text we shall therefore restrict our notice to them. A number of moot points may be men- tioned to show the range of the discussion. Some are antiquarian and some historical. As an instance of the first and least im- portant class, we may recall a debate which has arisen over the exact scene of the bat- tle. Two years ago hue and cry was raised in Canada (and in England, too) by a report that the Ursulines of Quebec were about to sell for building purposes the famous Plains of Abraham. Partly in consequence of the sentiment thus aroused, the Dominion Gov- ernment bought the property in September, 1901, and made it over to the city of Que- bec. Now the land represented by this pur- chase has nothing to do with the battle, and the Government knew it, though the public were under a wrong impression. “The deeds of this transfer,’’ says Mr. Doughty, “‘show that the purchase and pres- ervation of this estate was not made upon the erroneous assumption that it formed part of the historic battlefield, though much of the indignation aroused, both at home and abroad, when it was learned that the land was to be divided up and sold foy building lots, was due to the mistaken idea that it was the actual site of the conflict of Sep- tember 13, 1789.’ The originator of the popular mistake was Alfred Hawkins, whose ‘Picture of Quebec with Historical Recollections’ appeared in 1834. Mr. Doughty goes back to the un- equivocal evidence of the early maps and descriptions, thereby correcting an error, equally complete and curious, which has for many years prevailed in Quebec itself. The historical doubts involved are, how- ever, considerably more important than those presented by topography. Several of them may be stated for illustration. Was the idea of scaling the heights conceived by Wolfe or by his brigadiers? In the disputes between Vaudreuil and Montcalm had the Governor or the General the juster cause? Was Bougainville guilty of heinous and fatal remissness on the night of September 12-13? Did Townshend seek unfairly to vilify Wolfe, and was he justified in signing the Act of Capitulation without first show- ing it to Monckton? Did Ramezay fall short

Page 19

June 12, 1902] of his duty in surrendering Quebec? These aresome ofthe questions which Mr. Doughty seeks to solve. His analysis of the opera- tions about Beauport is also carefully stud- fed; but the chief interest of his narra- tive centres around such disputed points as have just been indicated. Let us take up one or two of these, considering particular- ly Wolfe’s relations with his brigadiers. When Pitt was preparing for the cam- paign of 1759 in Canada, Wolfe desired a larger armament than could be given him, but as a concession he was allowed much latitude in the choice of his officers. Monckton and Murray, the first and the third of his brigadiers, enjoyed his confi- dence, and so did other leading officers, like Carleton and Barré. Townshend, on the contrary, was put forward by influence, and cannot be considered a general of Wolfe’s own choice. From being second brigadier, he had great prominence in the campaign, and after the Battle of the Plains, where Wolfe was killed and Monck- ton wounded, he became the acting com- mander-in-chief. On the French side there was complicated discord. On the English side there was no discord which weakened the efficiency of the service; but a mutual dislike, perhaps distrust, destroyed real cordiality of intercourse between Wolfe and Townshend. As early as July, Wolfe snubbed Townshend sharply for inefficiency, and on September 6, a week before the bat- tle, Townshend wrote to his wife: ‘‘Gen. Wolfe’s health is but very bad. His gen- eralship, in my poor opinion—is not a whit better; this only between us.” On the last day of July, Wolfe was re- pulsed with severe loss at Montmorency. On the 22d of August the physical frailty which he shared with Nelson, was increased by fever, and for a week he remained un- able to take personal charge of the opera- tions. It was then (August 29) that he asked the advice of his brigadiers regard- ing future movements. The attack below the city had failed, winter was coming on, and the General’s illness rendered the sit- uation critical. The brigadiers were not slow in expressing their opinion when it was thus asked. They advised against mak- ing any further attempts in the neighbor- hood of Beauport and Montmorency, and recommended an attack on the town from the northern side. The particular distance, however, is not named, and Parkman, with many other writers, has by this means been led into error. What the brigadiers had in mind was an attack to be delivered about twelve miles above the town, as may be gathered from their detailed plan of opera- tions which seems to have been published for the first time in 1901 by Col. Townshend. Such a movement, it will be quickly seen, was something very different from the plan that was executed. Wolfe accepted this sug- gestion at first, and preparations were made accordingly. Then, after reconnoitring for himself, on September 10 he reached a total- ly different conclusion. Instead of going twelve miles above the town, where he would doubtless have been opposed by Bougainville, he decided upon trying a sur- prise and coup de main. That Wolfe won his triumph by his own genius, aided by remarkable good fortune, is apparent in three ways—first, from a passage in the ‘Journal of an Officer of Fraser's Regiment,’ where it is stated that the General reconnoitred the north shore The Nation. _ above the town on July 18, in search for landing-places. He then thought the scheme practicable, and Major Dalling found two or three places where troops could be put ashore. Secondly, the arrangements which had been made early in September for going up the river were suddenly changed. Third- ly, Mr. Doughty has procured from the British Museum copies of letters which put Wolfe's responsibility for the enterprise in the clearest light. On the eve of the battle the three brigadiers sent a letter to the General, wherein they stated that they were in need of further information. “As we do not think ourselves sufficiently in- formed of the several parts which may fall to our share in the execution of the Des- cent you intend to-morrow, we must beg leave to request from you, as distinct Or- ders as the nature of the thing will admit of, particularly as to the place or places we are to attack.” Wolfe replied in the last letters he ever wrote, the one to Monck- ton and the other to Townshend. The for- mer communication, which is considerably the longer, contains some specific informa- tion about the landing and the arrange- ments for the advance. It then concludes: “I had the Honor to inform you to-day that it is my duty to attack the French Army. To the best of my knowledge and abilities I have fixed upon that spot where we can act with the most force, and are most like- ly to succeed. If I am mistaken, I am sor- ry for it, and must be answerable to his Majesty and the public the quences.” Mr. Doughty has outlined impartially, and we should think finally, Wolfe's part in the whole campaign. He has also produced the evidence which settles the most interesting single point in the strategy of the opera- tions before Quebec. For the rest, he de- fends Bougainville from the charge of negli- gence which Parkman, among others, brings against him. He is much more friendly to- wards Montcalm than Casgrain is, and less friendly towards Vaudreuil. He vindicates Townshend from having sought to vilify Wolfe or rob him of his laurels. In the mat- ter of the capitulation he is favorable to the action both of Townshend and of Rame- zay. In each case there is cogent documen- tation, and Mr. Doughty is careful not to outrun his sources. Bougainville’s case is perhaps the most notable. Parkman says: “When Bougainville saw Holmes’s vessels drift down the stream, he did not tax his weary troops to follow them, thinking that they would return as usual with the flood tide.” As a matter of fact, Bougainville was following strict orders which he had received from Vaudreuil and from Montcalm. He had been told to keep touch with Holmes’s vessels and prevent a landing at Cap Rouge or higher up. In compliance with instructions he followed Holmes as far up as Pointe-aux-Trembles. He and his superiors were outgeneralled, but he was not guilty of leaving anything to chance. If there were space, much might be said about the materials which have been col- lected and employed. As it is, we ean hard- ly do more than state that they will be in- dispensable to every future historian of the Seven Years’ War in America. Through the aid of important personages in three countries, Mr. Doughty has been able to procure copies of papers which must have remained beyond the reach of the ordinary investigator, The effort and expense of for conse- 469 bringing together all these documents woul. also in most cases have acted as a powerful deterrent. Besides additions made to the published correspondence of Wolfe, Town- shend, and Bougainville, the cartography of the campaign has been largely supplement- ed by Mr. Doughty's discoveries. “Realiz- ing the importance of studying every avail- able account written by those who took part in the the authors have obtained copies of twenty-three distinct re- events narrated, lations of the siege, and seventeen plans of the battle of the Plains of Abraham, seven of which are in manuscript.’ Besides print- ing unknown and unpublished documents of great value, Mr. Doughty gives us an elab- orate bibliography of the Siege of Quebec, divided into one section of books and pam phiets, and into another of manuscripts With the exception of reading, the mechanical features of these volumes deserve high praise. The first three volumes are profusely illustrated with pho- togravures by Goupl!l and Hyatt, and with collotypes of good quality. The printing is exccllent-—the should think, that has been done in Canada since the celebrat- ed edition of Champlain. Altogether, Mr. Doughty and Mr. Parmelee have good rea- son to be pleased with the outcome of their long labors. eareless proof- best, we NOVELS, MOSTLY OF AMERICAN LIFE The Lady Paramount. By Henry Harland New York: John Lane. The Kentons. By W. D. & Brothers. The 13th District. By Brand Whitlock. In- The Bowen-Merrill Co. By W. L Howells. Harper dianapolis: Drewitt’s Dream Alden. D pleton & Co. The Making of a Statesman. By Joel Chan- dler Harris. McClure, Phillips & Co Ap- The beauty of Mr. Henry Harland’s story, ‘The Lady Paramount,’ is at once obvious and subtle, altogether satisfying. Any one may enjoy it who has an openness to the happy exhilaration that fine weather, gurgling brooks, singing birds, all the fresh loveliness that accompanies the miracle of spring. The simple love story of Susanna, Countess of Sampaolo, all ex- quisitely the senses like music conceived in a spirit of joy, ex- comes with embroidered, charms pressed in elaborate harmonies. This, for the average reader, indifferent to the means by which literary effects are wrought. To the informed and critical the book yields more. It is the work of an accomplished artist whose material is a cosmopolitan experience. It finished expression, not of the art of representing people and things as they are, but as they might be, might beautifully be. Novelists are not very often born in the ranks of a great aristocracy, nor does their breed- ing or experience often lead to a suc- cessful assumption of intimacy with the ex- alted. Of the vulgarities and absurdities into which such assumption may betray them, “Ouida’’ in her heyday was a dread- ful example. On the face of things, Mr. Harland seems to inherit Ouida’s adora- tion for an aristocracy qua aristocracy, to be under the spell of an Old World glory. His men and women (supremely women) exhale perfection, centuries of privilege. is a accumulation of The slow physical na-

Page 20

4°70 The Nation. [Vol. 74, No. 1928 ture he delights in is not fresh from the hand of God, but blooms in a loveliness that testifies to man’s patience, taste, and skill. He is thrall to ancient faiths and policies, more Catholic than the Pope, more royalist than the King. He is reactionary, mystical, sensuous, and not ashamed or apologetic. Yet in all this he, we think, does but seem. His serious and sincere intention is artistic; therefore, he makes deliberate choice of conditions in which beauty,, physical, mental, and moral, may most naturally either have been raised to perfection or degraded to corruption. Let it be said to his credit, both as man and artist, that in ‘The Lady Paramount,’ at all events, he ignores the possible corruption. Having chosen his characters and milieu, he moves under the guidance of the artistic feeling for truth to nature, the artistic sense of measure and proportion. In es- sentials he holds fast to what is simple, common, permanent in human nature; and for the probable influence of given condi- tions on the natural man his perception is very clear and sure. Thus we have Su- sanna, a gay, romantic, generous girl, yet decorous, imperious, and enchanting as good women of great race may well be; Antonio Craford, a common mortal in love, yet making love in a very superior man- ner, which, if not exactly English, is dis- tinguished; Patapouff, at heart a common cat, with the external graces of a thorough- bred. Mr. Harland’s purely literary qualities reflect his cosmopolitan experience. His grace and vividness smack of France, his sensuousness of Italy, his ironical humor of America. The point of view in social relations and the frank carelessness of speech are English. There is no positive indication of the author’s race or nation- ality. Nothing is certain except that he is an artist choosing to write in English, the free, light, slightly exotic English of Mr. Henry James. Against that are a seri- ous artistic intention, a loving and pa- tient cult of beauty, so absolutely, so hope- lessly not English. As Mr. Howells’s well-known theory is that a novel should be a representation, as closely as possible a literal transcript, of pages of real life (for himself. character- istic American life), conformity between his theory and practice is taken as a mat- ter of course. His new novel, ‘The Ken- tons,’ shows us a well-to-do family of Tus- kingum, Ohio, suffering inconvenience and painful agitation because the eldest daugh- ter, Ellen, has chosen to fall in love with an unmitigated detrimental. Ellen, though beautiful, is serious and cultured; there- fore, the “most cultivated young men of Tuskingum"” pass her by, preferring her sister Lottle, who boasts that she is not literary or cultured, and whose reported conversation proves that she does not de- fame herself. So poor Ellen takes up with a journalist named Bittridge, an imperti- nent young man, flippant and shallow, and, worse than all, not very keen about Ellen. The deeply disapproving parents stand helpless before impending calamity. They have made a compact not to cross’ their children in love; thus, Mr. Howells inti- mates, maintaining an American tradition which forbids parents’ trying to prevent a marriage that they know must be disas- trous. Nothing that has ever been written about Americans can surprise other na- tions more than this. Fortune sometimes favors the pusillanimous. Bittridge gets himself talked about with a married wo- man (nothing scandalous, of course); El- len realizes feebly the impropriety of a passion for such a bold buccaneer, and her parents, at last, take courage to carry her off from Tuskingum. When Bittridge, hav- ing pursued them to New York, commits the indiscretion of kissing Ellen, the Ken- tons feel fiercely outraged. The unhappy family sails for Europe, meeting upon the way a young man who, in his lighter mo- ments, is fatally like Bittridge, but au fond serious and good. To him Ellen transfers her bleeding heart, thus permitting her distracted parents to return to their home and their evening game of checkers, At this game, Mrs. Kenton invariably cheats— a fault condoned by her husband, who pre- sumably finds it humorous. There is an analogy between the Kentons’ attitude to- wards their children and their pastime. They perceive no sanctity in a rule; they do not, so to speak, play the game. The interesting points in the story are the failure of culture to improve charac- ter, and the failure of that American pol- icy (if it is an American policy) which prevents a direct and serious exercise of parental authority. The cultured Ellen has neither self-control, nor taste, nor common sense. Has Mr. Howells been asking himself, Whereunto is culture good? And is this the dismal answer? The bold and hectoring Lottie has finer in- stinct and better judgment than Ellen, be- sides being really kinder to ‘‘poppa’”’ and ‘“momma.’’ In drawing Lottie and the parents, Mr. Howells seems to us to have fallen back on observations made twenty years ago. We cannot but think that, in Ohio, parents have broken the American tradition of detachment from their chil- dren’s interests. At all events, in the sit- uation conceived, a modern Lottie would instruct them how to behave, firmly in- sisting that it is the custom of the ‘‘best people” to deal with infatuated Ellens in peremptory fashion. Boyne Kenton’s passion for the young Queen of Holland is an imaginative excursion, suspiciously indicative of the author’s desire to show the awful consequences to republican youth of a surfeit of romantic fiction. The story of Jerome (familiarly Jerry) Garwood of Polk County, Congressional candidate for the Thirteenth District of Illinois, includes a particular description of the methods by which legislators are se- lected, nominated, and conducted to suc- cess or defeat at the polls, and a general criticism of the process and results. Bad as practical politics are supposed to be, no view is too gloomy to lack confirmation in Mr. Whitlock’s narrative, or so bitter as to find reproof in his reflection. Current cen- sure of the republic's government, uttered by ignorant and prejudiced foreigners, is mild as milk in comparison with this de- nunciation, spoken by one, presumably na- tive-born, certainly possessed of all the secrets and mysteries of what he calls the “business of the people’s government.” This rather important business, Mr. Whit- lock declares, is carried on in every State of the Union by a handful of men, all ig- norant, dirty, dishonest, and profane, not in order to promote the people's happi- ness or comfort, but solely for what they, the managers, can get out of it in cash down or in promises to pay—that is, in of- fices (chiefly post-offices), and the salary and influence accruing. It may be arg ed that the Polk County gang was exception- ally wicked, that their candidate was un- usually weak and unscrupulous, even that the author so intimately acquainted with party politics has himself been turned down by the bosses and is taking a shabby re- venge. Such consolatory possibilities, if admitted, cannot banish the conviction that the record of Garwood’s campaigns is a truthful presentation of almost all po- litical campaigns in a country where the people are, by way of flattery, assured that they govern themselves and seldom resen! such an insultingly untruthful statement. Garwood is conducted through three cam- paigns—twice to an inglorious victory, and, at last, to ignominious defeat. His victories are won by his managers, and his defeat by himself, by his vanity, his selfishness, and his short-sighted treachery. The weakness of the book as criticism is in the failure to show any reason why the boss, Jim Ran- kine, should have implicitly trusted a man of only superficial attraction, one plainly without mental energy or shrewdness, or enough moral perception to yield to a de- mand for honor among thieves. In con- structing his story the author has had no trouble. No artificial arrangement could produce such a good dramatic effect as the direct narration of actual events in their actual sequence, moving from local pri- maries through county conventions, stump- ing tours with accompanying brass bands, torchlight processions, and general pande- monium, to the fatal day when the whole nation is given over to what is grandilo- quently described as a “quadrennial trag- edy of personal ambition.’”’ Garwood’s pri- vate history is naturally interwoven with his public one, and in his domestic rela- tions he is saved from complete disaster only because disappointed wives are some- times more forgiving than disappointed of- ficeseekers and angry bosses, and because mothers can always ascribe the infamy of a son to the plots and villanies of envious enemies. The wife and mother, rigidly honest, unsophisticated, trustful, and lov- ing, are very well drawn, without conde- scension or apology. The author knows and loves them as he knows and loves the prairies, to which he gives a few descriptive paragraphs so vivid that one longs for more, if only to relieve the impression that Polk County is thickly dotted with bar- rooms, filled with slovenly, sweating poli- ticians plotting for power, playing poker, drinking, smoking, giving and taking gross personalities as harmless chaff. The cor- rupt speech of these people is enlivened by metaphors. Meaning to betray some one, they threaten to “camp on his trail,” to “go out with their knives’; and no sooner have they elected a candidate than they caution him to ‘‘fix up his fences for a sec- ond term.” The author, speaking in his own person, uses freely an American va- riant of the English language. His people “sense” and ‘‘voice’’ things; they ‘‘flex in every fibre’; and when he wishes to tell us that some delegates had been slow to iden- tify themselves with the winners, he says: “The band wagon had taken them by sur- prise and rolled by too swiftly for them to climb in.” This is reconditely American, and the author’s apparently unconscious use of such metaphor gives a fine touch of gen-

Page 21

June 12, 1902] The Nation. uineness to a novel in every way signifi- cantly American. ‘Drewitt’s Dream,’ by Mr. W. L. Alden, is a gay tale. Ostensibly one of adventure, quite recklessly improbable, its real motive is a discussion of American political methods, or, rather, an explanation and defence from the mouth of a successful boss. Drewitt, the dreamer, a young Eng- lishman on his way home from India, stops over in Greece, on the chance of seeing a battle with the invading Turks. He reaches a town that momentarily expects an attack, and the very night of his arrival the crash of guns is heard, followed by clatter and rush of Greek soldiers, forsaking their posts. A general rout ensues, and Drewitt on horseback is swept along with the mob. He picks up an Englishwoman, whom he instantly loves, and is shot while trying to reach a deserted block-house. Waking in a hospital, he is persuaded that many of the circumstances he narrates are but the fancies of a disordered brain. He, how- ever, reserves a belief in the rescued maiden and her unparalleled beauty. In the hospital he meets Mr. Gallegher of Sallust City, Iowa, whose talk about him- self is both amazing to an Englishman and amusing. He pictures himself as a very honest and moral man, distinctly creditable to his country. Agreeing with the author of ‘The 13th District,’ he says politics is a business, but legitimate and honor- able, and one in which advancement of pri- vate interest is involved with doing one’s duty to the public. The author declares that Mr. Gallegher ‘‘did not possess a par- ticle of the national humor,” but there are many moments when he is infected by Mr. Alden’s humor. ‘‘Nobody,”’ he tells Drewitt “ever offered me a bribe, and nobody ever caught me in a crooked transaction.”’ Pro- ceeding to narrate how, taking advantage of his position as boss, he had made several profitable deals, he winds up: ‘‘No man can find any fault with that; and the fact that I gave up politics just as soon as I had made a fortune, shows that I wasn’t a poll- tician for any ambitious or selfish purpose.” Discoursing, further, on distinctions be- tween bribery and corruption, on thé use- lessness of “reformers,’’ on the duty of attracting to one’s party a strong “religious element,” also a strong ‘‘whiskey element,” Mr. Gallegher triumphantly justifies the system whereby he has become a million- aire, and Sallust City a model of municipal perfection. In disquisition Mr. Gallegher is delightful and in action convincing. Shar- ing Drewitt’s enthusiasm for the lost lady of his dream, he proposes that his yacht Caucus be used for a search expedition. Personally conducting the strange pursuit, he shows the courage, resource, and tact of a born ruler, who, whether we call him despot, or tyrant, or boss, is fit to control the mass of men and even to establish them in a higher condition of happiness. It is, however, difficult to believe that a free republic is his proper sphere. The com- pany on board the Caucus includes persons amusing and remarkable; but, beside Mr. Gallegher, they fade into insignificance. ‘The Making of a Statesman’ tells of an era preceding that of definite recognition of politics as a business. It represents those presumably good old times when a political career, in the South especially, was the privilege of a gentleman, and in- timately connected with oratory embellish- ed by quotations from the classics. Yet Mr. Featherstone, who rose to be a leader in the State of Georgia, and whose public record was most honorable, was, from the beginning, tainted with dishonor. He was more culpable than Mr. Gallegher, because he rose to power by the theft of another man’s brains. The voluntary self-sacrifice of Billy Spence is not probable, but, that being granted, all that follows is natural and pathetic. The remaining tales in the volume sustain Mr. Harris’s reputation for revealing negro character in negro dialect. Aunt Minervy Ann, telling about Misa Puss’s parasol, is a perfect specimen of the immortal ‘‘Mammy.” American Gardens. Edited by Guy Lowell. Boston: Bates & Guild Company. 1902. 112 plates. If any evidence be needed that the for- mal garden has found a ready acceptance among us, it is amply furnished by the re- markable collection of photographs pub- lished under the above name, a collection representative of the best work of an earlier time as well as of the present day. Our ancestors were familiar with the formal manner, and, in a modest way, as befitted a by no means wealthy age, exemplified their skill in the surroundings of many a worthy mansion. Though in most cases sadly changed, quite a number of such old gardens have come down to us. Of several that have been preserved in their original condition, views are given in ‘American Gardens.’ Of all these, the one which seems closest to the state in which it was a cen- tury or more ago, is Washington's garden at Mt. Vernon, the trim box hedges of which, enclosed bythe quiet buildings of the ‘“‘quar- ters,’ give a sense of well-ordered neat- ness very soothing in these days of nervous hurry. But, for a higher quality than mere neatness, for peace and poetry, the old Car- roll garden at Annapelis stands without an equal. Its serene white statues raised on lofty vine-clad pedestals and backed by dense masses of foliage cannot fail to bring to mind one of the finest portions of the Borghese gardens. Few other things within the book show so well as does the view of the Carroll garden the perfection to which nature will bring a simple formal arrange- ment, if this arrangement be wise in the beginning. But it is not to eighteenth-century gar- dens that the book chiefly devotes itself. They make a small part of its contents. Since for nearly a century the for- mal manner has been out of fashion, we find that by far the larger part of the book represents the work of the last ten years. How great is the volume of this work and how high a level much of it has reached, few would suspect who had not closely followed the subject. So many and so excellent are the examples that it is difficult to single out any for special com- ment without doing injustice to a host of others perhaps equally excellent. To put them in categories, however: among the minor gardens few possess a charm equal to those designed by Mr. Wilson Eyre, while among the larger and more elaborate, those by Mr. Charles Platt and by Carrére & Hastings easily occupy the first rank. For the sake of this publication the country has been carefully searched for its finest gardens. Excellent photographs of these, well reproduced, give a most lucid idea of 4°71 the present state of garden design among us. The index has the unusual merit of presenting many sketch-plans showing the points from which the views were taken, and thus enabling one the more clearly to un- derstand the garden's design Mr. Guy Lowell's introduction to the book is an essay on the history of gardening, and a critical consideration of gardening as practised in America. He points out that, owing to the peculiarities of our cli- mate and of our manners and customs, our gardens necessarily differ other countries, and are our needs and surroundings. Nevertheless, the impression left by the book Is, that although we have made very great advances in gar- den design, much that we have done smacks strongly of its foreign source, and that we have by no means established a national type of formal garden. The field is a wide one and the workers In it are alert and intensely Interested. Let us hope that before long they will develop a manner that will speak more clearly of our own time and people. from those of adapted to too Uncle Sam, Trustee. By John Kendrick Bangs. New York: Riggs Publishing Co. 1902. This book purports to give a history of Cuba down to the year 1898, and to record the achievements of the Government main- tained there by this country since that date. The “‘history’’ consists of scraps from books of every description, and may be dismissed at once as a compilation devoid of merit. As to what has been accom- plished in improving the conditions of life in Cuba during the last three years, it is ‘impossible not to deplore that so interest- ing a theme should have fallen into such incompetent hands. The photographs with which the book is adorned show that ma- terial conditions have been much improved under American rule, but the author seems incapable of giving a really intelligent ac- count of the system that has been followed. We know that some $40,000,000 has been col- lected from the taxation of imports, but we are left altogether in the dark as to the wisdom with which it has been expended. The debates in Congress indicate that the economic condition of Cuba is unsatisfac- tory, and it would be interesting to learn whether or not the revenues of the country have been wasted in extravagant improve- ments when they could have been applied to the relief of industry. Instead of facts of this kind, the reader is treated to pages of indiscriminate adula- tion of those officers of our army who have been stationed in Cuba. These gentlemen may well delivered from such friends as Mr. Bangs. They may enjoy ap- preciation without relishing abject syco- phancy, and might well prefer to have their deeds speak for themselves rather than to have them advertised by a too obsequious civilian. There is some attempt at fine writing in the book, but the style is rather slovenly. It is not clear what is meant by the assertion that “the betrayal of their trusts by the convicted men of the Cuban Postal Service is not an unmixed blessing.” More intelligible is the statement that “within a period of eight months, the health of the city of Santiago became quite as salubrious,”’ etc. beg to be

Page 22

4°72 The Nation. [Vol. 74, No. 1928 Finland: Its Public and Private Economy. By N. C. Frederiksen, formerly professor of Political Economy and Finance in the University of Copenhagen. London: Ed- ward Arnold; New York: Longmans, Green & Co. 8vo, pp. 300. In view of the present widespread inter- est in Finland and the Finnish people, an accessible book, dealing with the subject in a serious and at the same time popular manner, is very welcome. Professor Fred- eriksen’s eleven chapters are concern- ed with the civilization, agriculture, forestry, industries, commerce, naviga- tion and fisheries, money and banking, means of communication, exchequer, and civic duties, and, finally, with the Gov- ernment of Finland and its future. On these topics the author has succeeded— with limitations that will be noted further on-—in gathering within a very narrow com- pass a great deal of information which, on the whole, is presented in a readable form. Like the rest of the world, Finland has made rapid material progress during the last century, but it differs from many oth- er countries with a more highly developed parliamentary government in having its finances in a very flourishing condition, the budget balancing with a good surplus, while the state owns valuable assets worth several times more than the inconsiderable public debt, which has, moreover, been wholly incurred for productive purposes. In the matter of private economy the re- sources and industries of the country show a marked development, the rapidity of which will be apparent from the state- ment that the value of the manufactured products, which in 1887 was estimated at 114 million marks ($22,800,000), in 1899 had risepw to about 300,000,000 ($60,000,000). In 1887 each manufacturing plant had on an average eight workmen and an annual out- put valued at 20,000 marks, while in 1898 the same averages were twelve workmen and 36,000 marks. The wages received by the workmen vary for the different trades; they may be said to average about 800 marks a year, to which must be added, in some cases, free house rent and firewood. As several members of a family often are wage-earners, these incomes compare very favorably with those of the agricultural laborers, not excluding the peasant pro- prietors. Finland, like the United States, has vast tracts of public lands, and the lengthy review of the land laws of Finland would, therefore, be of especial interest in this country if it were clearer than, unfortu- nately, is the case. The Government lands of Finland are, according to the author, opened up for settlers on very liberal terms, but what these terms are one may read through the entire chapter without being able to find out. The law “is not unlike the American Homestead Law, which gives grants of land on the condition of cultivating a small part and paying an insignificant fee. It has been decided that these crown lands which are fit for cultivation shall be separated from the forest land, surveyed, mapped out, as- sessed for taxation, and offered to people who wish to settle. The settlers are to have an additional advantage [additional to what?], that for the first fifteen years they are entirely exempt from taxation, and have to pay only half-taxes for the pext five, while they may, perhaps, get this exemption extended to forty years. The taxation is very moderate, being only from two to twelve Finnish penni (4. e., from a farthing to a penny) per hectare.” On the whole, it may be said that the greatest fault of the book is a lack of con- cise statement and statistics. Statistical tables do not make a book readable, but they convey a deal of information to those who are in need of it. From the present book such tables are almost entirely ab- sent. The author, in a kind of prefatory note, thanks Mr. Edward H. Cooper of London for advice and careful codperation in re- spect of his English text. Still greater care might, it seems, have been exercised. The book appears, simultaneously with the English, in a French and a Danish edition. The last was probably the original, and some of the English expressions seem to be due to faulty translation. Thus, on page 25, decisions, in the sentence, ‘‘There are decisions about enforcing this system in the Finnish laws as early as the fourteenth century,” probably stands for “provisions,” the Danish word “bestemmelser” meaning both. Whether the following passage is due to a slovenly translation or slovenly think- ing, may be questioned: “Rye, which was introduced by the Swedes in very early times, superseded barley to some extent in the eighteenth century, and still later it was largely re- placed by oats. In the fourteenth century rye was cultivated only in parts of South- ern Finland. In the eighteenth century it became, however, the most important ma- terial for bread, and is now cultivated as far as the 64th and 65th degrees of lati- tude. In the years subsequent to 1870 the cultivation of rye increased enormously, but later still, after 1887, it gave place to oats,” “Finland contains about 1,100,000 sheep.’’ “The number of sheep owned by the poorer class of peasant is, however, increasing as they grow more prosperous.” “The duty on maize in Finland, as in Sweden, is a great difficulty in the way of keeping and fattening pigs; it is 2 marks 25 penni (about 45 cents) per 100 kilos on all maize coming from other countries than Russia, and to bring it Jrom Russia does not pay so well,” It would, we think, have been more cor- rect to translate the Swedish word gran (Abies excelsa, or rather Picea excelsa) by “spruce,” which is its regular commer- cial name, than by “fir”; the more so as the Swedish word rendered “pine,” fura, is the etymological counterpart of the word “fir,” and also commercially goes by the name of “Scotch fir.”’ It will have been observed from these quotations that the author occasionally brings forward his own opinions about things. In fact, he greatly overdoes this, for his opinions embrace almost the whole field of human knowledge. Some of the opinions seem rather naive: “If we remember the good result of the last budget, as well as the by no means excessive duty now demanded on articles 80 well able to pay duty as alcoholic liquors and tobacco, we find that it would be quite possible to abolish entirely all the other duties. In fact, they are all detrimental to the economic life of the country, and they are causing difficulties at the custom-house,” The author is a thorough admirer of the “Anglo-Saxon.”’ On the very first page of the book we read: ‘‘At present the highest stage of all [civilization] has been reached in England and the United States.” It would be interesting to see if the French edition contains the same statement. Religion in Recent Art: Expository Lectures on Rossetti, Burne-Jones, Watts, Holman Hunt, and Wagner. By P. T. Forsyth. London: Hodder & Stoughton; New York: Edwin S. Gorham. 1902. It is a relief to the conscientious review- er that Mr. Forsyth confesses in his preface that “he trusts much to the ability of the skilful reader to skip,’”’ for it is only by the liberal use of this ability that we have found it possible to read the book at all. To put it frankly, this is almost the most wordy and repetitious book that we have ever seen, and its author shows a truly remarkable ability to spread one small idea over many pages, turning and twist- ing the expression of it, exclaiming and orating, but adding nothing whatever there- to. The system is such that it hardly mat- ters what you skip, for any one sentence on a page is as good as any other to indi- cate the general drift; you may choose one at hazard, with confidence that the others are only slight variations of it, and turn a page or two, lucky if you find anything different at the second dip. Mr. Forsyth’s “religion in art” has no- thing to do with ecclesiastical decoration or Biblical illustration. His thesis is that great art has a spiritual content, regard- less of its formal subject, and that what the artist, consciously or unconsciously, tells you of the soul is his religion. Thus we have Rossetti; or, The Religion of Nat- ural Passion—Burne-Jones; or, The Religion of Preternatural Imagination—Watts; or, The Religion of Supernatural Hope—and Holman Hunt; or, The Religion of Spiritual Faith. In his search for meanings, Mr. Forsyth claims the right to find them whether or no they were intentionally put there by the artist, but he is, naturally, best pleased with the conscious allegorizing and didacticism of Watts and Hunt, and it hardly needs his assurance to convince us that the book would never have been writ- ten but for the opportunity of dealing with these two. The artistic value of Watts’s work we take to be very great, that of Hunt’s work to be relatively small, but each has chosen to confuse the art value of his work With its value as thought, and to rest his claim to serious consideration on what is really of least importance. The allegories of Watts do no harm—they ‘‘will not bite’? more than those of Spenser; but 4 the “thoughts,” in so far as they are defi- nite and translatable into words, might be conveyed in pictures not worth the canvas they were painted on. Mr. Watts chooses to think them all-important, and he is, there- fore, the delight of preachers and expound- ers of meanings, such as Mr. Forsyth, for in this case there can be no doubt that the meanings really were put there with malice prepense. It would, however, be a poor expounder who could not explain more than wag ever said, and Mr. Forsyth manages to find things, even in the pictures of Watts, that can hardly have been intended. We all know the noble “Love and Death,” and its allegory is obvious enough; but see Mr. Forsyth add to it: “And, chief of all,” he says, “a great light falls upon the figures’ back, and we remem- ber that we never see the dawn upon death till it hag gone by; that we get to know our angels when they have left us, and that we mark the sunlight on the graves only when they have well grown green. The source of the light, you further mark, is not

Page 23

June 12, 1902] The Nation. 4°73

in the picture; and so the hope in our latter end is no ray from within our visible frame of things, but from a life and a world be- yond.” And so on. One can only feel helpless, and mildly inquire how else the picture could be lighted—how the shadow was to fall upon Love unless the light were out- side the frame and at the back of the figure of Death, and if we are really to accept the physical necessities of the composition as a new allegory more important than the original one? The book is handsomely printed, and light in the hand, and the eight reproductions are very well done. BOOKS OF THE WEEE. Alden, Mrs, ¢ A Unto the End. Boston : Lothrop Pub. Co. .50. a. F. 8S. What’s What? The Bradley-White habe. A. A. Electrical and Magnetic Calcula- tions. _D Van_Nostrand Co. 50. Banks, Nancy H. Oldfield: A Kentucky Tale of the Last Century. Maewmillan. $1.50. Barr, Robert. A Prince of Good Fellows. Me- Clure, Phillips & Co. Bassett’, Mary E. 8S. Judith’s Garden. Boston: Lothrop Pub. Co. 1.50. —) 9 rhe Path to Rome. Longmans, Green 0. Bevan, E. a The Prometheus Bound of Aes- chylus. London: David Nutt. 5s. Blaisdell, A. F. Life and Health. Ginn & Co. Bolot, Sous-Intendant. Muette. Paris: La Grande Ernest Flammarion. 8 fr. 50. Bourne, H. E. The Teaching of History and Ciy- ics in the Elementary and the Secondary School. Longmans, Green & Co. $1.50. Bowen, B. L. A First Scientific French Reader Boston: D. C. Heath & Co. Brooke-Hunt, Violet. The Story of Westminster Abbey. E. P. Dutton & Co. $2. Brooks, H. 8S. Progression to Immortality A. Wessels Co. 50 cents. Burt, Mary E., and Cable, Lucy L. Don Quixote de la Mancha’ Scribners. 60 cents. Cable, G. W. Bylow Hill. Scribners. $1.25. Carlyle, Thomas. Past and Present. (iemple Classics.) London: J. M, Dent & Co.; New York: Macmillan. 50 cents. Carmichael, Montgomery. The Life of Sir, John William Walshe. E. P. Dutton & Co. Chase, F. H. The Credibility of the Book me the Acts of the Apostles: Being the Hulsean Lec- tures for 1900-1901. 5. Macmillan. 45 R. S."’ Eton Idylls. Oxford, cng.: BR. Blackwell. Is. Davitt, Michael. The Boer Fight for Freedom. Funk & Wagnalls Co. $2.

The most complete and reliable work that ever appeared in the form of a flora of this region.-- Prof. 1. M. Un- derwood of Columbia. BRITTON’S FLORA A Manual of the Flora of the Northern States and Canada. By Director N. L. Brirton of the New York Botanical Garden, 1030 pp. SvO, $2.25 net. Henry Holt & Co., 29° Ww. , 23d St., , New York. 878 Wabash Ave., Chicago. F. W. CHRISTERN (DYRSEN & PFEIFFER, Successors), 429 5th Ave, bet. 35th and 39th Sts.. New York Importers of Foreign Books, Agents for the leading Paris publishers: Tauchnitz’s British authors, Teub- ner’s Greek and Latin Classics. Catalogue of stock matied on demand New books received from Paris and Leipzig as soon as issued. Out-of-Door Books Send for illustrated catalogue of what is probably the most authoritative list of nature books published.

G. G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS, NEW YORK. JUST PUBLISHED—NEW BOOK BY SAMUEL IVES CURTISS A Record of Researches, Discoveries and Studies in Syria, Palestine and the Sinaitic Peninsula. Fully illus'rated, including photographs of points and places which have not appeared tn print Primitive Semitic Religion To-day. Net $2.00

‘LIMITED EDITIONS © of Standard English and French Authors. On receipt of postal card specimens of paper, type, {lustration and binding will be sent KNIGHT & BRO , 150 Fifth Ave., New York.

Dean, Howard. The Iron Hand. Abbey Press, ““Delta.*’ Charades. Oambridge (Mass.): W. Sever & pg $1. Charles Montmorency, J. E. G. de. State Intervention tn English Education. London: C. J. Clay & Sons; New York: Macmillan. $1.50.

BOSTON, MASSACHUSETTS

European and American Plan The BERKELEY HOTEL Boston. John A. Sherlock, Proprietor. Facing on Dermeten, Boylston, and Providence Streets; but one bloc from the far-famed Public Gardens and the same distance from Copley Square, is but two minutes’ waik from the Art Museum and Trinity Church; is directly opposite the Institute of Tec hnology, and but five minutes to all theatres. shops, and the business section Restaurant a la Carte, Dining-Koom, Table a’Hote, Café and Billiard-Room for Gentlemen.

American Traits From the Point of View of a German. By HUGO MUNSTERBERG HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO., Boston and New York

ASK FOR Dean, J. M. he Cross of Christ in Bolo-Land. Morris, Clara. A Pasteboard Crown. Seribners. Fleming H. Revels Co. 1. $1.50 : Douglass. F. A. Col. Harold de Lacey. F. Ten- Muirhead, J. H Philosophy nd Life, and Other nyson Neely Co Fssays. London: Swan Sont senscbein & Co.; Fenn, G. M. Old Gold; or, The Cruise of the |New York: Macmillan. $1.50. . Jason"? a | London: Brnest Nister; New Nature Portraits. Text by the Editor of ‘Country York: E Dutton & Co. $1.50. Life in America.’ Doubleday, Page & C Fick Rs: Das alte Lied vom Zorne Achills. Neumann, Ludwig Der Schwarzwald Leipaig Gottingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht; New York: Velhagen & Klasing; New York: Lemcke Lemeke & Buechner. Buechner ' Flint. C. R.. Hill, J. J., Bridge, J. H.. Dodd, Oman, Charles. A History of the Peninsular War, 8S. C. T., and Thurber, F. B. The Trust: Its Nol. I. Henry Frowde. $4.75 é 300k. Doubleday, Page & Co. $1.25 O'Rell, Max Tween you an’ I Some Litth Fowke, Gerard. Archwological History of Ohio. Problems of Life. Boston: Lothrop Pub. Co. $1.35 Columbus, O.: Ohio State Archwological and His- Ostwald, Wilheim The Principles of Inorganic torical Society. Chemistry Macmillan. $6 Francis, V. E. Advanced French Peeve Compos!l- Page. W The Rebuilding of Old Common tion. American Book Co. 80 cer wealths Doubleday Page & Co. $1 - : Gibbons, W. F. Those Black Btemnena Men, Flem- Pyle, Howard. Some Merry Adventures Kebin ing If. Revell Co, Hood. Seribners. 60 cents Greenough, J. B., and Kittredge, G. L. Select Remains Historical and Literary Connected with Orations and Letters of Cicero. Ginn & Co. the Palatine Counties of Lancaster and Ches Hancock, ge 2 Life at West Point. G. P. ter, vol. 4 New Series Manchester, Eng Putnam's Sons. $1.40. Printed for ‘the Chetham Soctety Headlam, Cecil. The Story of Chartres. (Mediwval Ripley, Cordelia, and Other Poems. Ab- Towns.) Londun: J. M. Dent & Co.; New York: bey Press. : Macmillan. $2. Roberts, C. G. D. Poems. Silver, Burdett & C ll, Grace L. An Unwilling Guest. Philadel- Roberts, ©. G. D The Kindred of the Wild: A phia: American Baptist Publication Society. $1. Book of Animal Life Boston: L. O. Page & Hodgson, F. C. The Early History of Venice Co 2. London: George Allen; New York: E. P. Dut- Rousiers, Paul de. Hambourg et I’ Alle anges cou ton & Co. a temporalne ‘aris: Armand Colin. 3 fr. 50 Holland, Clive. My Japanese Wife. Frederick A Sabatini, Rafael. The Suitors of Yvon: ne G. P Stokes Co, $1.50. Putnam's Sons 1.20 Set Z Heathagten. A. M. Poem of the Cid: Transla- Sandys, Edwyn, and Van Dyke, T. 8. Upland Game tion. Vol. Il. G. P. Putnam’s Sons. $25. Birds. (American Sportsmen's Library.) fac lichester, The Countess of, and Stavordale, Lord millan. $2 : ne Life and Letters of Lady Sarah Lennox, Serious Poems of Thomas Hood (Caxton Re 1745-1826. London: John Murray; New York: prints.) Londen George Newnes: New York: Scribners. $4. _Seribners. $1. = ; ioe Job, H. K. Among the Waterfowl. Doubleday, — i as os a The Red Anvil. Frederick A Page & Co. 35. stokes Co oA . Jordan, D.S S., and Heath, Harold. Animal Forms: — “=~ 2 ‘Pitosophy, Its Scope and Rela- } > ) Li ) Appl & Co. tions acmillan ’ 4 Book of Zodlogy. D. Appleton & Sullivan, T Eh. The Courage of Coaviction. Scrib Keese, W. L. The Siamese Twins, and Other ners 3 5) - , —s Poems. Edwin W. Dayton. “o 7 M kJ agg Mile . n Persia; or Cenye ic i Jovel o ‘phes eight ears in a Serit ~ “ : mene i Se. Bn yg ay 1 s wo sus Parr, R. 8 The Phyasteal Geogr aphy of New ( > Maciebose ” he etters of Monsieur eae de Sauss ’ ” eas: Newr Ween: Mecmien 91.70. aes his Family. London: John Murray; New York Lawrence, W. H. Principles of Architectural FE P. Dutton & Co. $3. neat wees te Perspective. New ed. Boston: Published by the Velfizquez de la Cadena Mariano uevo ‘ 1 3 eclonario de Pronun iaci6n de las Languas Inglesa Linn A. The Story of the Mormons. Mac- y Espafiola, Segunda Parte, New ed. D. Appl — ag on ton & Co. $3.50. ; a? ais: te Marsh, C _— on the Chart. Frederick A. Vendryes, J. Recherches sur I’ Histoire et les Ef Stokes Sot “$1.5 fets de IIntensité Initiale en Latip Paris: ¢ Meade, L. T. The Time of Roses. London: Ernest Klineksieck. 8 fr Nister; New York: E. P. Dutton & Co. $1.50. Walsh, Walter The Religious Lite and Influence Merriman, R. B. Life and Letters of Thomas of Queen Victoria London: Swan Sonne pachein Cromwell. 2 vols. Henry Frowde. $6. & Co.; New York: E. P. Dutton & Co 2.0K). Mets, J. A. Naval Heroes of Holland. Abbey West. A. F. A Latin Grammar for Schools I) Press. $1.50. Appleton & Co. 90 cents. . . . Chickering Pianos] |THE ——® tesey marzano - Author of The Cardinals P . LADY Snuff-Bor (85,009) The OLDEST in AMERICA; . x ° rr 1: 2m ) THE BEST in the WORLD PARAMOUNT :” WRITE CATALOGUE : AALS EEA. 50TH THOVS_AND! e . 2.8 Chickering & Sons The New York Sun: ‘A book full of sunshine and sparkie.” YY Fa nme? Fe 2 TT 2 Ba ae ee “ The wittiescand brightest book of the season.” The London Times: “A fantastic, delightful love-idyll “He is easily first in his own del taht ful line.’

JOHN LANE : NEW YORK

JUST PUBLISHED A History of the Peninsular War with Por- $1.75 In six volumes, Cloth. Vol L For sale by all Booksellers OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS: (AMERICAN BRANCH) 91 and 93 Fifth Avenue, New York. By C. Oman, MLA traits and Maps.

Ib ACK NUMBERS, VOLS. AND SETS of Tue Nation bought and sold A catalogue of | second hand books upon application. AS. CLanm, 174 | Fulton Street, New York OLD BOOKS AND MAGAZINES S28. 5 Get, 'CROWELL’S POETS | 4. J. CRAWFORD, 10th & Pine Streets, St. Louls, Mo

Page 24

4°74 The Nation. [Vol. 74, No. 1928 POSSESSORS, PURCHASERS, or 49,762 HEIRS Wanted. TO THE OWNERS OF THE Copies of the Genuine, Complete, and Authorized Ninth Edition of the ENCYCLOPADIA BRITANNICA imported into the U. S. All persons who have bought or inherited genuine sets of the ENCYCLOPADIA BRITANNICA will learn something very greatly to their advantage if they will at once communicate with us. We do not wish the names and addresses of those persons who bought sets of us, for such names we already have. Nor do we wish the names of those who have bought pirated, garbled, impenfect, and mutilated sets, and we therefore state that the imported and authorized copies bear the imprint on the title-page of Adam & Charles Back, of Edinburgh and London; or Charles Scribner & Sons, of New York; or of Samuel H. Hall, of New York. Undoubtedly many owners of the garbled and imperfect sets will write us for what we are prepared to send you, and in order to secure ourselves against them, we ask you to look on the final page of any one of your volumes, and state in your letter the nam2 and address of the printers which you will find there. We shall then know from that name and address whether the writer has one of the genuine or one of the imperfect and pirated copies. All persons who have the authorized ENCYCLOPADIA BRITANNICA, and will com- municate with us at once, will learn something of great profit to themselves. Address: THE MANAGER, “ THE TIMES”? (LONDON), 225 Fourth Ave., NEW YORK. Financial. THEODORE WETMORE & CO. | REAL ESTATE, COMMERCIAL PAPER, STOCKS, BONDS, AND MORTGAGES. All cities are experiencing sharp advances in estate. Now isthe time to purchase Mirne- apolis real estate. We offer some ver ~ | properties, some of w assessed value. MINNEAPOLIS, MINN, Pulford,How& Company INCORPORATED Investment Bankers, MORTGAGE LOANS, REAL ESTATE AND INSURANCE, : Trust Company Building, | DULUTH, MINN. Book Salesmen Wanted. Successful work will bring large profits. Only men who have had experience and succeeded in selling high-priced books or many-volumed sets need apply. In writing state previous experience, &c. Address: A. B. C., Box 333, Madison Square Branch, New York Post Office. desirable income-bearing ch we will sell for less than A limited number of sets of the ** Encyclopedia Britannica” can be obtained for a first payment of One Dollar, and 21 further Monthly Payments of One Dollar each. The ‘* Encyclopedia Britannica,” the greatest and best work of reference in the world, has never been obtain- able at such prices and on such terms before, and this offer is made now for a limited number of sets and during LAWTON & FERTIG _ Colorado Springs, Colo. a limited period only. Address: W. J. KELLEY, P. O. Box 822, NEW YORK. An experience of twenty-five years in local Realty makes our judgment competent in the safe selection of Six Per Cent. Loans, as well as the wise purchase of city property for in- vestment. An unbroken record of success in the profitable handling of money for a large list of Eastern investors is the best reason for your confidence. for Sale and To Let For Sale at Duluth, Minnesota. One of the Finest School Properties Registered Trade Mark Summer Comfort Unless your undergarments are porous and provide good ventilation, they keep the heat in and add to your dis- comfort on hot days. The Dr. Deimel Underwear made of specially-woven li- nen-mesh (a fabric resem- bling fine fish net), allows a free circulation of air around the body, keeps the skin dry, and gives comfort during the warm weather. Booklet about it or the garments at «The Linen Store.”’ James McCutcheon & Co., 14 West 23d St., New York. SNe Linens Housekeeping Goods FOR COUNTRY HOUSE FURNISHINGS Table Cloths, Napkins, and Doylies. Sheets, Pillowcases, Towels, and Bath Towels. d Spreads, Comfortables, Blankets. Curtain Materials Rugs and Carpets, Mats and Mattings. Droadovay KH 19th ét. NEW YORK, in the Country. Bullding modern and convenient in all {te appoint menta. Burroundings {deal and beautiful. A wide field fora senparstor y achool, and to the right party the price reasonable and terms of payment easy. For information apply to L. MENDENHALL, Duluth, Minn. bi Ray oad ell Lo | of exchange and make Cable transfers of money on Europe LeTreRs Australia, and South Africa» also make CREDIT collections and issue Commercial and . rT Credits available in all parts of é world, International Cheques. Certificates of Deposit. BROWN BROTHERS & CO., NO. 50 WALL STREET, NEW YORK. Reading Case for the Nation, To receive the current numbers in a convenient (temporary) form. Substantially made, bound in cloth, with The Nation stamped on the side in gold, Holds about one volume, Papers easily and neatly adjusted. Sent, postpaid, on receipt of 75 centa.

Page 25