The Nation 1902-01-30: Vol 74 Iss 1909
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
+ RENEE RONG ARETE RR spares Se hi VOL. LXXIV—NO. 1909. THURSDAY, JANU ARY 30, 1902. JOHN WILEY @ SONS’ Scientific Publications Power and Power Transmission A work designed for elementary instruction in Colleges and Manual Training Schools. By E. W. Kerr, M.E., Assistant Professor of Me- chanica! Engineering, A. & M. College of Tex- oy xii+356 pages. 264 pages. 8vo. Cloth, 2.00, Insects Injurious to Staple Crops By E. DwieHt SanperRson, B.S8.Agr., En- tomologist. Delaware College Agricultural Ex- periment Station; Associate Professor of Zo- ology, Delaware College. 12mo, x +295 pages, 162 figures, including many half-tones. Cloth, $1.50. Cast Iron A Record of Original Kesearch. By WIL- LIAM J. Keep, Member American Society of Mechanical Engineers, and of its Committee on Standard Tests and Methods of Testing Ma- terials, etc., etc. 8vo, xiii + 225 pages, 117 figures. Cloth, $2.50. Mechanics of Engineering Vol. I. Kinematics, Statics, Kinetics, Statics of Rigid Bodies and of Elastic Solids. By A. Jay DuBois, C.E., Ph.D., Professor of Civil Engineering in the Sheffield Scientific School of Yale University. Small 4to, xxxv +634 pages, upwards of 500 figures. Cloth, $7.50. Velocity Diagrams Their Construction and Their Uses, Ad- dressed to all those interested in Mechanism. By Professor C.W. MaccorpD, Stevens Institute. Svo. iii+116 pages. 83 figures. Cloth, $1.50. The Cost of Food A Study in Dietaries. By ELLEN H. Ricu- akbs, Instructor in Sanitary Chemistry, Mas- sachusetts Institute of Technology. 12mo, v+161 pages. Cloth, $1.00. Order through your bookseller, or copies will be forwarded postpaid by the publishers on th receipt of the retail price. JOHN WILEY @ SONS, 43 and 45 E. 19th St. NEW YORK CITY. The Collected Poems of WILLIAM WATSON With Photogravure Portrait. 12mo. Price $z.50 net. THE LONDON SPECTATOR: “ Here is true gold of puetry—the ‘authentic airs’ of Parnassus. he chief, thé dominant characteristic of Mr. Watson’s peatry is felicity—and felicity not merely of word and phrase, but of thought. He is not only happy in language, but In the ideas which he presents and interprets.” JOHN LANE, Publisher, 67 5th Ave.,N.Y. CLOWES’ « THE ROYAL NAVY.” Vol. VL, with President Roose velt’s “* war of 1812,” now ready. Royal 8vo, $6.50 ne LITTLE, BROWN & CO., i | | ENZYMES OF THE CARBOHYDRATES. | dases. Handbook on Sanitation A Manual of Theoretical and Practical Sani Pn by GeorGe M. Price, M.D., Medical Sanitary Inspector, Department of Health, New York City. 12mo. xii+317 pages. 31 figures. Cloth, $1.50 net. College Algebra A text-book for Technical Schools and Col leges. By LEONARD EvGENE Dickson, Ph.D., Assistant Professor of Mathematics in the University of Chicago. Treating cnly the subjects usually given in the college course in Algebra, with a more de tailed treatment of the more difficult topics, vii+214 pages. Small 8vo. Cloth, $1.50 net, Architectural Engineering With Especial Reference to High Building Construction, including Many Examples of Prominent Office Buildings. by JOSEPH KEN DALL FREITAG, B.8., C.E., Associate Member American Society of Civil Engineers ; Author | of ‘The Fireproofing of Steel Buildings.” Second edition, rewritten. 8vo, xiv + 407 pages, 196 figures, including half-tones. Cloth 3.50. A Treatise on os By Henry T. Inst. C.E., LL.D., F.R.S.C., Professor of ¢ Lawl Engineering and | Applied Mechanics, McGill University, Mon- treal. Second edition, rewritten. Svo, xviii + 582 pages, 339 figures. Cloth, $5.00. Bovey, Enzymes and their Applications By Dr. JEAN Errront, Professor in the New University in Brussels and Director of the Fermentation Institute. English transla tion by Samuel C. Prescott, S.B., Instructor in Industrial Biology, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Boston. Volume [,, Tue | The Oxi Cloth, $3.00. 8vO, xi+ 322 pages. BOOKS When calling picose ask for AT MiR. GRANT. LIBERAL Whenever you need a book DISCOUNTS. address Mr. Grant. | Before buying books write for quotationa An as sortment of catalogues and special slips of books at re duced prices sent for 10 cent stamp P. E. ae Books. 23 W. 42p Sr. NEW YORK (Mention this advertisement and receive a discount.) 4NY BOOKS, OLD OR NEW, SUP yy plied to out-of-town residenta Questions an ewered. Orders promptly filled. Libera! discounts. I. BayLigzs, 415 Putnam Ave. (Brooklyn), New York City. OLD BOOKS AND MAGAZINES | S578. °°, Cet. A. J. CRAWFORD, 10th & Pine Streets, 5t. Louis, Mo L061. ar “G re _ dja GENERAL LIBRAYY UNIV. OF Mik JAN 31 | , Me PRICE TEN CENTS. rican critts British and Am pronouncing The House With the Green Shutters 4n uncommonly strong and im pressive piece of fiction, and in heralding its author GEORGE DOUGLAS Sa new master of literature. Second editio s McCLURE, PHILLIPS & CO. New York F. W. CHRISTERN (DYRSEN & PFEIFFER, Successors), 420 5th Ave. bet SSth and 80th &ta.. New York Importers of Foreign Books, Agenta for the leading Paris publishers; Tauchnoitz's British authors, Ter ner’s Greek and Latin Classics. Catalogues of « mafied on demand. New books received from Part Leipzig as soon as issued Send for * Travel. GOING ABROAD on a BICYCLE [RIP ? Bicycling Notes for Tourists Abroad LEYLAND LINE upwards, depending « Sailing Regularly Boston—Liverpool -—London $40, $45, * Devonian,” mmense new steamers. First Cabin m steamer Feb. 5; *Cestrian.”’ Feb. 12; ** Winifredian,”’ Feb 26; “Iberian,”’ to London Feb. 7; * Caledoniar to London Feb. 25 Kingstonian to London March ?7. P. O. HOUGHTON & CO., Gen'l Agts., 11g State Street, Boston. cade — Land, and Egypt. Pre f.C. THURW ANGER, $5 « Building, Bost European and American Pian The BERKELEY HOTEL Boston. John A. Sherlock, Proprietor. Facing on Berkeley, Boylston Streets: but one block from Gardens and the same distance from Copley Square; is but two minutes’ walk from the Museum and Tri nity ‘ pong a dir the Inatitute of Techno logy nd | to all theatres, shope, and t aaine eatle Restaurant @ la Carte ‘Dink Room, Table d' Hote, Café and Bililard Room f r Gentiemer and Prov dene the far-fained P f
Page 2
il The Nation. [ Vol. 74, No. 1909 The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science, and Art. FOUNDED 1865. Entered atthe New York City Post-office as second- class mail-matter. CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER, By Pes cbevedciabinessconcsduannscieveudénbeneeess 81 EDITORIAL ARTICLES: ee DOE. 6 6a 65 60000000000 s0eenee 84 The Senate as Treaty-Maker................ M Voderal Clearing-HouseS. ...cccccccccccccses 85 Book Collectors and Others....... sateevaness 86 SPECIAL CORBESPONDENCE: NE. cc eenenhshbesss veNiebesebeaa0onnne 87 ED eee CO wince esos cceerencvevess 88 Old Masters at the Royal Academy.......... 89 CORRESPONDENCE: German and American Schools............... 91 Chinese Exclusion ........ evehS Shee ney eesee 91 The Alaskan Boundary...........scceeeceees 91 ED ND wn 60:60. 02.90:00900500005s 008 92 MINES ks scncbcvaceeesieesssneevbasbeucdenesexvcecece ces 92 Book REVIEWS: Furness's Twelfth Night South Carolina in the Revolution............ 96 The Musical Basis of Verse................. 97 EE | cneh Ge bhG K4b05 60a wo Sebo widwd eee 98 i OD. scot e nbs sake duee senses 99 The Welsh Wars of Edward I............... 99 OUR OP WE FE ois iasneereceivsssscisecasasces 100 TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three Dollars per year, in advance, postpaid, to any part of the United States or Canada; to foreign countries comprised in the Postal Union, $4.00. The date when the subscription expires is on the address label of each paper, the change of which to a subsequent date becomes a receipt for remit- tance, No other receipt ts sent unless requested. Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter, or by check, express order, or Postal Order, payable to ‘* Publisher of the Nation."’ When a change of address is desired, both the old and new addresses should be given. Address THE NATION, Box794, New York. Publication Office, 208 Broadway. TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Fifteen cents per agate line, each insertion : 1, lines to the inch, Twenty per cent, advance for choice of page, or top of column, A column, $20 each insertion; with choice of page, $2h. A page, $60 each insertion; front-cover page, $30. Advertisements must be acceptable in every re- spect, Copy reecived unttl Tuesday, 5 P. M. Discounta upon application, DISCOUNTS. 4 Insertions ‘6 per cent, ‘ 0 “ 13 oF 12g“ 24 re . 15 sat ne sid 20 ee 52 - 25 - AMOUNT $100 within a year 10 per cent. 250 es pid Fa lu ” 500 sl 28 1h Lal 760 - = . 20 wi 1,000 “ * 25 wd 1,500 “a = .. 30 ” 2,000 “ ? -. B34 The NATION is sent free to those who advertise in it as long as advertisement continues, *,* Copies of the Nation may be procured in Paris at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de l'Opéra, and in London of B. F. Stevens & Brown, Trafalgar Square, Charing Cross. Educational. DELAWARE, Wilmington, Ss Street. ‘HE MISSES HEBB’S Boarding and Day Schoo! for Girls. Students are prepared for college. MARYLAND, Baltimore, 122 and 124 W. Franklin St. DGEWORTH BOARDING and DAY “0 oer for Cee) pod will begin September , 1901. Mrs H. P. LEFEBVRE, Miss E. D. HUNTLEY, { Principals. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston. OSTON UNIVERSITY Law School. Address the Dean. SaMUEL C. BENNETT. TSS “ANABLE' S Boarding and Day School for Girls. Established in 1848. Circular on sich Opens Sept. 36. 1350 Pine St., Phila., Pa, HARVARD UN UNIVERSITY. The lannenee Scientific School Offers professional courses leading to the degree of 8.B. in Civil, Mechanical, and Electrical En- gineering; Mining and Metallurgy; Architecture; Landscape Architecture; Chemistry: Geology; Bi- ology; Anatomy, Physiology, and Hygiene (as a preparation for medical schools); Science for Teach- ers, and a Course in General Science. Graduates of colleges may be admitted to advanced standing without examination. For information, address J. L. Love, Secretary, 16 University Hall, Cam- bridge, Mass. N. 8. SHALER, Dean. Royal Victoria College, McGILL UNIVERSITY, MONTREAL. A residential College for the Women Students of McGlil Untversity. For conditions of entrance, schol- arships, -ourses, degrees, terms of residence, and other particulars, address THE WARDEN, Royal Victoria College, Montreal. waenn SCHOOL FOR BOYS) WABAN J. H. Pruussury, M.A., Prin : WINDSOR HALL FOR GIRLS | Masa. ANNA M. Goopnow, B,A., Assoc. Prin. School Agencies. I bla FISK TEACHERS AGENCIES. Everett O. Fisk & Co., Proprietors. 4 Ashburton Place, Boston. 1505 Pa. Ave., Washington. 156 Fifth Ave., New York. 414 Cent.Bldg., Minneapolis, 538 Cooper Bldg., Denver. 890 Third 8t., Portland. 203 Mich. Blvd., Chicago. 525 Stimson Bloc k, Los Angeles. Hyde Bik., Spokane. 420 Parrots Bidg., San wrenenten. LBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY, 81 Chapel St., Albany, N. Y.—Provides schools of all grades with competent teachers. Assists teachers in obtaining positions. Rents and sells School Property. HARLAN P. ‘Faunos, Prope etor. ‘CHER: MERHORN Teachers Agency. Recommends best schools, tutors, governesses. Joun C. ROCKWELL, Megr., 3 E. 14th 8t., N.Y. WRINCIPAL L, F. GRIFFIN of the Frye School, Trinity Court, Boston, has room for smother boy in his own family. Address immediately. Ghe TIMES AND YOUNG MEN By Dr. Josiah Strong z2mo, cloth, 75 cts. “What our young men chiefly need to- day is not good advice on this or that subject, but the right view of the world and the right attitude toward life. In gaining and keeping this your book can- not fail to help them.’—Pres. W. H. P. Faunce, Brown University. THE BAKER& TAYLOR CO., New York “Old Father Gander.” Every child sho: 4 have it. ‘os PAGE & CO., Boston, Maasg for many years, under all conditions, by countless users, the Remington Typewriter has been tried and tested, and its Superior merits proved, Wyckoff, Seamans and Benedict New York A Course in Invertebrate Zoology. A Guide to the Dissection and Comparative Study of Invertebrate Animals. By Henry 8. Pratt, Professor of Biology in Haverford College, Pa., and Instructor in Com- Poe vt Anatomy at the Marine Biological La- yoratory at Cold Spring Harbor, Long Island. For Introduction, $1.25. GINN & COMPANY, Publishers Boston, New York, Chicago, London. Back Nunibers of “The Nation, In response to frequent inquiries from subscribers: An incomplete set of THE NATION has little or no mar- ket value. Partial sets, bound and unbound, are always obtainable (usually lacking the earliest volumes), and do not command high rates. The bindings generally count for nothing, owing to great diversity of styles. Vol- ume I. has readily brought $10 and upward when com- plete, bound or unbound, but will bring very little in proportion if a single number is missing. Volumes II. and III. are also scarce, but not so high-priced as the first. Complete sets, both bound and unbound, have sold for $100, with tolerably quick bidders, and have an increas- {ng value year by year. Single numbers not more than a year old can usually be supplied by the publishers at 10 cents each. For num- bers more than a year old purchasers are referred to Mr- J. W. Christopher, 47 Dey St., or Mr. A. S. Clark, 174 Fulton St., New York. The publishers no longer undertake to buy or sell numbers or volumes more than a year old, and can only recommend sellers or purchasers to negotiate with a dealer or to advertise in Tuk NATION. {Publication was begun July 1, 1865, Vol. I. compris- ing the last half year. Two volumes per year have since been issued, Vol. LX XIII. comprising the last half year of 1901.) Financial. Send for our List of In- High-Grade Securities. come-bearing Securities. Mailed on request. E. H.GAY & CO., 131 Devonshire St., Boston, and 1 Nassau St., New York. iat pasate ot #28 AEN aa A?
Page 3
: : Jan. 30, 1902] Financial. We Own and Offer, Subject to Sale, $10,000 City of Duluth, Minnesota, 4 Per Cent. Gold Refunding Bonds. Dated May 1, 1901. Due May 1, 1931. Denomination 3 ,000. Legality has been a D aceed by Chas. B. Wood, Esq., of Chicago. Price $103.50, and interest nets 3.80 per cent. PVLFORD, HOW @ CO., Trust Co. Building, Duluth, Minn. LAWTON & FERTIG Colorado Springs, Colo. An experience of twenty-five years in local Realty makes our judgment competent in the safe selection of Six Per Cent. Loans, as well as the wise purchase of city property for in- vestment. An unbroken record of success in the profitable handling of moaey for a large list of Eastern investors is the best reason for your confidence. CRUTCHER & WELSH have formany years demonstrated toa large clientele that money was to be made in Kansas City Real Estate if it be conservatively selected and administered. Every facility for the care of non-resident estates. Property wisely purchased now is certain of steady advance. Our purpose is to serve faithfully and efticiently a few more Eastern clients. We are an essential part of the bis- tory of KANSAS CITY, MO. FOR RENT. The most PROMINENTLY LOCATED retail store in MILWAUKEE, WIS. This store is now being refitted, and correspondence is solicited BENJ. M. WEIL’S SONS & CO, Real Estate Agents and Brokers, Chamber of Commerce Bldg., Milwaukee, Wis. SAFE MARGINS for the most EXACTING INVESTOR! My life has been devoted to the study of property values in Minneapolis. Am ina position to give you the benefit of expertness in placing investments where both security and fair percentage may be relied upon. An opportunity is solicited of presenting facts which in- vestors everywhere ought to know about Theodore Wetmore & Co., MINNEAPOLIS, MINN. ‘AN OPPORTUNITY. Would you consider an opportunity to secure a per manent annual income by investing your surplus capl talin such sums as you might desire? If, moreover, you were afforded perfect security and the assurance of More than the average interest or dividends, would you invest ? If 80, we la ask you tolnvestigate the proposition offered by the Isthmus Plantation Association of Mexico. Ay Partie ulars will be mailed you upon reque - KENDALL, Gen’! Agent, 414-417 First Nation- al Sion Building, Milwaukee, Wis. We buy and sell bills of exchange and LETTERS make Cable transfers of money on Europe, qn. — Africa; also make collections and issue Commercial and CREDIT. ‘Traveliers’ Credits available in all parts of the world. International Cheques, Certificates of Deposit. BROWN BROTHERS & CO., NO. 50 WALL STREET, NEW YORK The Nation. — ied The February Atlantic Monthly Three Months of President Roosevelt HENRY LOOMIS NELSON The Second Mayoralty Election in Greater New York EDWARD M. SHEPARD PART I. of a Two-Part Story, “Only an Episode,” by Eugenia Brooks Frothingham, and fourteen other contributions, including essays, short stories, book reviews, and poems. For Sale Go-day Ewverywhere poe AN EDUCATIONAL DIRECTORY I.—The NATION stands alone in its field. It has the largest cir- culation of any literary and political journal published in this country, going to all the principal libraries and reading-rooms, and into thousands of families. I1.—The circulation is chiefly among the thinking and well-to-do classes—lawyers, physicians, bankers, and other professional men—and in the homes of cultivated people, where the edu- cation of children is a matter of careful consideration. I11.—The School List in the NATION has been a representative one for many years. It includes cards of most of the promi- nent educational institutions everywhere, during the season of school advertising, and a considerable number are biabeiiaad in the paper throughout the year. IV.—The rate is reasonable, and discounts are made on continuous insertions, of which most of the school advertisers avail them- selves. School advertisements are printed in a uniform typography, with the address in the first line, classification being made by States, alpha- betically, unless especially ordered displayed. Advertising rates, 15 cents an agate line each insertion, with the following discounts: 5 per cent. on 4 insertions, 10 per cent, on 8 in- sertions, 12 % per cent. on 13 insertions, 15 per cent. on 26 insertions, 20 per cent, On 39 insertions, 25 per cent. on §2 insertions. The Nation is sent free while advertisement continues. Orders may be forwarded through any responsible advertising agency, or directly to THE NATION, 206 to 210 Broadway, N. Y.
Page 4
1V The Nation. [Vol. 74, No. 1909 Ghee MACMILLAN COMPANY HAS FUST PUBLISHED She CARE ¥ DESTITUTE, NEGLECTED AND DELIN- QUENT CHILDREN By HOMER FOLKS, Superintendent of the Children’s Aid Society of Penn- sylvania, 1890-1893; Secretary of the State Charities Aid Association of New York, 1893-1902; General Secretary of the National Conference of Charities and Correction, 1901-1902; Commissioner of Public Charities of the City of New York, 1902, Cloth, 16mo, $1.00 zet. ( Postage, 10 cents. ) The first volume to appear in a new Series of works on “American Philanthropy of the Nineteenth Century.” The book covers succinctly the solution of private and public institutions for children, of placing- out in families, temporary homes, protection of neglected children, and the education of delinquents, with a chapter on present tendencies in “ child-saving” work. EXPERIMENTAL SOCIOLOGY Descriptive and Analytical: Delinquents By FRANCES A. KELLOR, Graduate Student in the University of Chicago. Cloth, Crown 8vo, $2.00 ne7. ( Postage, 15 cents. ) A book which presents a new method in sociological study and new data as to whites and blacks ‘not only as to criminality, but as to social conditions. Constructive work of value to sociologists and educational theory. THE THEORY OF PROSPERITY By SIMON N. PATTEN, Ph.D., Professor of Political Economy in the University of Pennsylvania, author of “The Development of English Thought.” Cloth, $1.25 et. ( Postage, 11 cents. ) This work unites the discussion of economic theory and evolutionary doctrines as they never have been focused before; a practical book in the best sense. THE COLLEGE STUDENT and his PROBLEMS By JAMES H. CANFIELD, LL.D., Librarian of Columbia University. Cloth, 16mo, $1.00 ze. ( Postage, 8 cents. ) Helpful, witty advice drawn from a long experience as Secretary and President of the National Educational Asso- ciation, Professor of History, University of Kansas, Chancellor of the University of Nebraska, President of the Ohio State University, and at Columbia University. Short, admirably written, sound, and wise, it is pertinent to most interests of student life. THE SECOND GENERATION By JAMES WEBER LINN. Cloth, $1.50 rhe story of an old hate bequeathed by father to son; of how the latter is by it forced into a course against his niture and his hopes of happiness; a vivid story of newspaper life in Chicago. Frankly a novel whose chief interest is romantic, but drawn from active every-day life. Books published at NET prices are sold by booksellers everywhere at the advertised NET prices. When delivered from the publishers, carriage, either postage or expressage, is an extra charge. Send for the new announcement list of THE MACMILLAN COMPANY 66 Fifth Avenue, New York ANY ae
Page 5
“a oh RAs GAS The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, JANUARY 30, 1902 The Week. It is President Schurman who is now guilty of inflaming the Filipino mind by his recent insistence that the only honorable course for this country is to give independence to the _ islanders. Hitherto it has been Mr. Bryan, or Mr. Hoar, or the Boston Anti-Imperialists, or the independent newspapers who did such deadly work by standing up for the rights of the Filipinos. But now Mr. Schurman, President of the first Philippine Commission, and versed in Philippine affairs, is really undoing all the splendid service of the troops and inciting the natives to fresh resistance by his doctrine, enunciated last week in Boston, that, if we went to war for any other than an altruistic purpose, we laid ourselves open to the charge of man- slaughter. Gen. Wheaton, the acting commander in the islands, is reported to have said that in the Philippines men have been sent to prison for such re- marks as those of President Schurman. The latter does well to retort: “If that be true, it is the saddest and most discouraging truth that has come to us for a long time from the Philippines. Without freedom of speech, civil government will never win the support of the Filipinos.’’ The question cannot be settled even tem- porarily by choking and smothering. Ex- perience has abundantly shown that no government has ever yet been wise enough to pick the doctrine, or set of doctrines, that can safely be suppressed. Attempted suppression will only make opposition the fiercer. If this counsel for independence “be of men, it will come to naught; but if it be of God, ye cannot overthrow it, lest haply ye be found even to fight against God.” The New York Sun considers Presi- dent Schurman to have misinterpreted. the language employed in President Roosevelt’s message, which, it says, was not “a declaration in favor of scuttle at any future time, a prediction of the lowering of the American flag by and by, or of the abandonment of the sovereign- ty acquired by the treaty of Paris.” We agree that the President’s language might have been more explicit, yet we cannot see that Mr. Schurman enlarged its meaning or put an unwarranted con- struction upon it. What is the “great burden” that we are to be relieved of when the natives show the power of gov- erning themselves? It must be the bur- den of governing the islands. The President could not have had in his mind the burden of killing the inhabi- tants, burning their villages, destroying their food, and subjecting to torture those who refuse to give up their guns. That is indeed a great and sorrowful burden, but it is not the one the Presi- dent had in mind. Is there any other tneaning to be put upon his The only alternative is to suppose that he meant to express the hope that the time would come when we might stand in the same relation to the Philippines in which Great Britain stands in refer- ence to Canada. But if he had meant that, he Canada adheres to Great Britain not by compul- sion, but by choice. If the Filipinos were attached to us in that way, nobody would speak of them as a burden, to be relieved of as soon as possible. would have said so. Announcement made on Friday that the treaty by which Denmark cedes her West India States had been signed at last. was United As the dispatch puts it: “This con- summation of protracted negotiations, which will put the United States in pos- session of the strategic key of the Carib- bean, and relieve Denmark of a steady drain on her resources, came unexpect- edly after the hope had abandoned.” But islands to the Tribune's almost been it appears from the same dispatch that several steps are to be taken before the ‘‘consummation” is fully consummated. There are. still wanting, on this side of the water, rati- fication by the Senate, and an appropria- tion of $4,500,000 by the House; on the other side, ratification by the Danish Rigsdag; and, midway, the assent of a majority of the people of the islands, by popular vote. Whether all the people are to vote, or only the whites, is not stated. This is a matter of some im- portance, since they are mostly blacks and mulattoes. Thirty-five years ago the saddling of these islands upon the United States was as nearly consummat- ed as it is now, but the Senate declined at that time to “relieve Denmark of a steady drain on her resources” by assum- ing the burden ourselves. Shortly after the Seward-Rassloff treaty was rejected, the island of St. Thomas was so ter- ribly shaken by an earthquake that the harbor was practically abandoned as a commercial entrepét, and the shipping which formerly centred there took re- fuge at Barbados. It is a serious question which the Sen- ate now has to pass upon. Shall we ac- quire another group of islands, to be either neglected or treated in the same way that we treat the inhabitants of the Philippines, Porto Rico, and Cuba? The latter is, to all intents and pur- poses, one of our possessions, and may therefore serve as a kind of beacon-light to show us what we should avoid. The words? | leading question of our national policy to-day is whether we shall allow Cuban sugar to be imported at lower duty than those of the The whole question is Next to What of duty on the sugar and other products of the Danish rates of Dingley tariff agitated by tha question it in importance the question, shall be the rates Philippines? If we acquire the Islands, the question will be What rates of duty shall we impose up on the sugar of Santa Cruz? The other islands, it should be remarked, have no products, or none to be exported to the United States that the belonging to us Ultimately, we products of all will be admitted free may as sume islands ee duty. This is what the sugar-plant ers of Santa Cruz count upon. This is what our beet-sugar men will have to reckon upon. But that is not all. This is the first step toward other West In The prompt us to dian annexations which same reasons Danish possessions apply to any and all oth take the ers, of the burden of which any Euro pean Power wishes to be relieved rhe Those for which we are now asked to give $4,500 islands are desperately poor 000 of good money would not be accept ed as a free gift if the Senators upon the visit them in person who have to vote treaty should They will simply bring us new responsibilities and new expenses. Every argument that caused the rejection of the Seward treaty in 1867 remains in full force to-day, while that station in the one argument in favor of it we were without any naval those waters—has ceased to have force since we have acquired Porto Rico. Evidence is accumulating that some thing will be done speedily by Congress for the relief of Cuba, by a reduction of the duties on sugar grown on that The greatest apparent obstacle step hitherto has supposed need of making an equal re island. to such a been the duction to all countries with which we treaty ‘“‘most favored nation” have relations embracing the clause Investi gations of the subject made by high au that clause does thorities lead to the conclusion the “most favored nation” not apply to a country bearing the rela- tions to us that Cuba bears at the pres- ent time. Mr. Frank D. Pavey has pre pared a brief in behalf of the Chamber of Commerce of the island of Cuba, in which he that, “during the military occupation of Cuba by the Unit- maintains ed States, Cuban products have the same international status as American ucts.” At first sight strikes the reader as a surprise, but ii has the support of Chief Justice Mar- shall and of the Englisn Admiralty ' Courts. In the case decided by Marshall, prod this proposition
Page 6
a ship carrying sugar, grown on the Danish island of Santa Cruz, and owned by a Danish subject, was captured dur- ing the war of 1812 by an American privateer and brought into an American port as a prize of war, on the ground that Santa Cruz had been captured, and was then actually held, by Great Britain. The court held that the sugar was law- ful prize, saying that, “although acqui- sitions made during war are not consid- ered permanent until confirmed by treaty, yet to every commercial and belligerent purpose they are considered part of the domain of the conqueror, so long as he retains the possession and government of them. The island of Santa Cruz, after its capitulation, re- mained a British island until it was re- stored to Denmark.” An opinion of Prof. J. B. Moore of Co- lumbia University runs the same way. As quoted in the morning press, he says that when the reciprocity treaty between the United States and Hawaii was con- cluded in 1875, Germany acknowledged in a treaty that the ‘‘most favored na- tion’ clause could not be invoked to se- cure the admission by us of German su- gar free, since ‘‘the relations of proximi- ty and other considerations’ were not the same. The conditions which operat- ed in the case of Hawaii, Professor Moore contends, “exist in the case of Cuba with a force and completeness not to be found iy any other country not under the titu- lar sovereignty of the United States.” His general conclusion is, that the ‘‘most favored nation” clause does not stand in the way of the mutual reduction of du- ties on trade with Cuba. There is, per- haps, no higher authority in this coun- try than the gentleman who gives this opinion. The hearings before the Committee on Ways and Means on the Cuban sugar question were enlivened on January 22 by a colloquy between Mr. Richardson and Gen. Grosvenor. In the course of a statement made by Mr. Oxnard, the rep- resentative of the beet-sugar interests, the latter referred to Mr. H. O. Have- meyer and the Sugar Trust as the par- ties behind the movement for a reduc- tion of the duties on Cuban sugar. Mr. Richardson asked whether he meant to say that President Roosevelt had been moved by the Sugar Trust to recom- mend such reduction. That Mr. Rich- ardson'’s arrow went to the mark was proved by the start which it gave to Gen. Grosvenor, who “denounced such pro- ceedings,” and made the point of order that Mr. Richardson was trying to lead the witness (Oxnard) to attack the Pres- ident of the United States. Mr. Rich- ardson calmly replied that he had no such intention, and that he was seeking the truth. Then Mr. Oxnard disclaimed any intention to reflect upon the Presi- dent. So the net purport of his state- The Nation. ment was that the Sugar Trust had “put up the job” of reciprocity with Cuba, but that the President of the United States, from whom the movement de- rived its principal force and impetus, was as innocent as a lamb. The result of this tilt in the Committee was very damaging to the opponents of the mea- sure for the relief of Cuba. Another heavy blow was struck by ex- President Cleveland in a letter to Mr. A. B. Farquhar of York, Pa. Mr. Far- quhar had asked him for an ex- pression of his views on the subject of Cuban reciprocity. The latter replied that he considered the arguments of the beet-sugar men in opposition to the peti- tion of the Cubans fallacious, mistaken, and misleading, but that the question “involves considerations of morality and conscience higher and more command- ing than all others”; adding, “The obligations arising from these con- siderations cannot be better or more forci- biy defined than was done by President Roosevelt in his message to Congress, nor better emphasized than has been done by Secretary Root; and yet Congress’ waits, while we occasionally hear of concessions which rich sugar interests might approve in behalf of trembling Cuba. I do not be- lieve that nations, any more than individu- als, can safely violate the rules of honesty and fair dealing.’”’ We hold strongly to the belief that, if President Roosevelt shall, in this case, emulate the firmness and _per- sistence with which Mr. Cleveland, in 1893, pushed the bill to repeal the Sher- man Act, the measure for Cuban reci- procity which he and Secretary Root have so admirably presented to Congress will be passed in time to afford the need- ed relief. Unfortunate Mr. Hepburn held back his speech of January 9 on the Nicara- gua Canal Bill from the Congressional Record for ten days; but if he hoped to revise it into a less ridiculous conflict with the facts subsequently developed, he found the task impossible. He could not take back his high praise of the Canal Commission. There was Admiral Walker at the head of it, a man ‘most admirably fitted by his reading, his ex- perience, his industry, his fidelity to duty.” The report of the Commission was “well considered,” and was in favor of the Nicaragua route. For what more did the House wish to wait? ‘“‘We have their report’; let not the House be fur- ther beguiled about the possibilities of Panama. But, alas, before this appeal got into type, “we have their report’ unanimously in favor of Panama; ‘‘ad- mirably fitted’’ Admiral Walker, with his known fidelity to duty, signing with the rest. Any one but Hepburn s0 caught would look foolish; so would any House caught voting under his dictation. But the intrepid Congressman coolly an- nounces that while facts may alter, his opinion based on them will remain the [Vol. 74, No. 1909 same, and that there is nothing in the revised report of the Commission to “lead to any abandonment of efforts in behalf of the Nicaragua route.” Rumors that there will be no canal legislation at all during this session of Congress have at least this foundation in fact, that exorbitant demands by Colombia or Nicaragua and Costa Rica may so disgust and chill Congress that it will vote no money at all for the present. The truth seems to be that the Central American countries concerned think they see a glittering prize all ready for their seizing. They have their eyes upon the surplus in our Treasury, and are simply figuring out how much of it they may get, to place it where they know it wiil do the most good. We understand that even the apparent check to their hopes has not made the Nicaraguan authorities a whit less ex- igent in their financial demands. If Co- lombia, as is reported, thinks that this country is now bound to take the Pan- ama canal, and that she may therefore ask any sum she pleases for rental of the necessary territory, she will get a most rude awakening. All depends now upon a reasonable proposal by the Co- lombian Government. It should not forget that there are many men in Con- gress opposed to paying anything what- ever for right of way. It is apparent that the provisions for general subsidy in the pending Frye bill are introduced for amendment, and that various specially objectionable fea- tures of former bills have been tempo- rarily withheld for the purpose of al- iaying Republican opposition. But, in spite of this, the new bill as it stands shows the essential injustice of any sys- tem of general ship subsidy; that is, the injustice of any subsidy except such as is paid for the purpose of calling into Leing new means of communication to specified foreign ports, to which such mneans are now lacking, and where they could not exist without Government aid. Among the iniquities of the pending bill is the fact that nothing in it will prevent an empty ship from collecting a full subsidy. This will interest those who are contending that the bill will operate to increase our commerce, and who allow that subsidies should be paid only in proportion to the cargo carried. Then there is the same old provision about vessels owned by corporations; that is, if the corporation is formed in this country, the stock may really be owned by foreigners, and the subsidy paid out of American taxes may all go as dividends to foreigners. There is no provision in the bill which will secure the establishment of any new means of communication, or will prevent the Gov- ernment funds from going as a bonus to increase the dividends of those al- Seriya es,
Page 7
Jan. even though they provide no increased facikities for the public. There is no adequate guarantee that the subsidy will not eventually be given to foreign-built ships whenever Americans consider it for their interest to buy these ships and to obtain a special American registry for them, as has so frequently been done in the past by the companies which are pressing this bill. Senator Nelson’s bill to establish Department of Commerce has passed the Senate with comparatively little opposi- tion. On Wednesday week that body received a letter from Mr. Gompers, President of the American Federa- tion of Labor, protesting against the transfer of the Bureau of Labor to the charge of the new Secretary. The trouble is the old one of “‘saving my or- der.” Nobody objects to the establish- ment of a Department of Commerce, but nobody wants to see his particular in- terests incorporated into a_ general scheme of organization, even if such scheme would conduce to the _ public good. Mr. Gompers puts his objection bluntly. The Bureau of Labor, he says, was organized at the request of the la- bor interests of the country, in the hope that it might ultimately become one of the executive departments of the Gov- ernment, with a Secretary of Labor in the Cabinet. If it should be incorpo- rated into any other, the “interests of labor” would be “minimized.” In the end the new department was dubbed “of Commerce and Labor.” <A tendency of quite another sort was displayed by Senator Quarles’s defeated amendment vesting the new Secretary with power to supervise the collection of statistics on commercial subjects made by the other departments of the Government. a a Interviews with the officers of several national banks in New York indicate that there is general opposition to Rep- resentative Lloyd’s bill permitting na- tional banking associations make loans upon real-estate security. Al- though the bill limits the amount of ad- vances on real estate to 25 per cent. of he total loans of any bank, those who have been consulted are practically unanimous in condemning the plan, be- cause real-estate security is not a quick asset. This, however, is not the only objection to real-estate loans. There is always a question about even the ulti- mate value of the property offered as se- curity, and it often happens that banks find it necessary in times of depression to take over the real estate on which they have made loans, in order to pro- tect themselves against the loss which would result if the property were sud- denly thrown on the market. The fact is that no such extension of activity as the making of real-estate loans should to |
The Nation. be granted to any commercial bank least of all to those which hold the re serves of the country, and may be called upon at any moment to furnish the rent funds needed to meet idden mands for cash Furt! M \. B Hepburn points out, tl S t large inland cities are often quite as important factors in n a ng tl solvency of the country as are those of New York, since our system of reserve | cities places in their hands the balances | of the surrounding country The na tional system must be made more at tractive to capital, not by weakening the legitimate restrictions tl have been thrown about the busine inking under it, but by removing t iInneces sary ones which prevent tl nks from using their credit by note The continued decline 1 th iational bank currency and the withdrawals of deposited bonds from the Treasury indi cate with renewed force the necessity of taking measures for revenue reduction Secretary's Gage’s policy in keeping the surplus down by means of bond purchas- es is effective enough as a temporary measure, but it results in raising the price of the bonds, and making it more profitable for the banks to sell them than to use them as a basis for circula- tion. It not merely raises the price of the outstanding bonds, but, should it continue, will take all the purchasable bonds out of the market The national debt is now $105,000,000 less than dur- ing the summer of 1899. During Janu ary alone, purchases of bonds by the Treasury have amounted to a par value $3,734,160, $5,285,371 for the of requiring an expenditure of payment of principal and premiums. tighten the market i cline in offers of bonds from nearly $12,000,000 than Moreover, How the bond-purchases s shown he d the Treasury November to January by t - to in $4,000,000 during the d which stood at $328,845,067 in September less bond-secured circulation, last, will have been reduced to $317,500, 000 at the end of March, and there is no apparent reason why the decline should Evi- way, stop at the last-mentioned figure. dently find consistently with the safety of the note- Congress must some holders, to take off the shackles from the national-banking system. Some exceedingly interesting testi
mony regarding last year’s Northwestern | railway deals was submitted on Satur- day at Chicago. We imagine that the | public mind will be chiefly impressed by Mr. Harriman’s testimony as to the uss of the Union Pacific’s credit in the op eration. This witness had stated that, South- to day, neither the Union Pacific ern Pacific. nor Oregon Short Line owns any Northern Pacific stock. This was, of course, not news, the trans the stock hay fer of Northern Securities Company settlement of last autumn Succeeding inquiries established three points: first, that the rich corporation, the Oregon Short Line, vhich bought the Northern Pacific stock at a figure ‘several times larger than its own ipital m had to borrow the money for the pure ist econd that it pparently did 1 $78,000,000 1 owe rth of stock for investment, but for strategic purposes; and, third, that cor- porations which make 1 purchases are quite at liberty ») sell out again to iny boe As he pury rf t pur chase was, M Ha ma illeged, “to | est o the U1 1 Pacif ! ave- ues already open to it,’ nd to levelop |} an opinion that vere ng enough | to contr traffic in ou vn territory.” | The s Mr. Harriman testified, has I d w out le »t Union Pa- eit Com} nm ¢ 5 { oper- ation resulted more agreeably than the | Read R 's by no means d m ‘ i } l ‘ are h } iat the I il ( W d t nk 2 over S I if ‘ I | il and credit. Mr. Harrin i his stra- eglie purp ind rel t th tock vithout loss t ny. But who O guarantee that the next exy t of e kind in the railway wv 1 will have the ime endins The New Jerse Rey i have hosen 5 Unite re) Sel ii! } who would ne ‘ eard of in pul ‘ ] ‘ but f< ' ' | ‘ ysl ness care ‘ ( Mr John | Drye 1 if cessful, but o he most iat 1s a eu logists | h iniz mn he has been a gene We have tl inot elected to the Sena my ‘ 3 rich We know no if gainst Mr Dryden, and sit h t un doubted energ j ne capacity may pre ot . y . t ie t . what we say is, that, byt | ple of ¢ State and | he ¢ i ge, his election will be regarde simpl | more step in the com clalizing of t} | Ser iff Of ! ( I i } + tet j | | to ate and «¢ nd | known; Whether he t ! his capa I hat t } , ta the 1 : t} ‘ } com pe ‘ {y \ ne Gene (; ‘ Senat il tra He j t killed aw ind ay ! had é ‘ Ie ‘ f ve 1 } ‘ tinct ‘| t hat it n 3 mone B hie ¢ whose one t F to ft vealtl We cannot re d | buspic is event ing been part of the! ¢ 83
Page 8
84. AN INDEFENSIBLE ACT. On January 8 Senator Lodge intro- duced a bill “temporarily to provide for the administration of civil govern- ment in the Philippines.’”’ One object of this measure, which does not establish a new form of government, is to con- firm the action of President McKinley ‘'n appointing the present Philippine Commission, and “to approve the acts of ihe Commission up to this time.” In view of the latter purpose, it would be well for the American people, and also for Congress, to know something more about the legislative acts of the Com- mission, particularly as Secretary Root has hoped that “the work of the Com- mission will receive the approval which it merits.” This work he declared to be praiseworthy “for its high quality of constructive ability, its wise adaptation to the ends desirable to be accomplished, and its faithful adherence to the princi- ples controlling our own Government.” That this praise should apply to a large part, or even the greater part, of the work of the Philippine Commission may very well be. There is one achieve- ment of the Commission in its charac- ter as sole legislature in the Philippines, however, which should receive only con- demnation from Congress and the Amer- ican public. This is a statute which be- came the law of the Philippine Islands on November 4, 1901, and which is verbose- ly entitled “An Act defining the crimes of treason, insurrection, sedition, con- epiracies to commit such crimes, sedi- tious utterances whether written or spoken, the formation of secret politi- cal societies, the administering or tak- ing of oaths to commit crimes or to prevent the discovering of the same, and the violation of oaths of allegiance, and prescribing the punishment therefor.” It is on its face a measure to assist the military in forcing the sovereignty of the United States down the throats of the Filipinos, and to prevent them from continuing their struggle for indepen- dence. Like all similar acts in all lands, it is of an essentially despotic character. Its first section prescribes the penalty of death or imprisonment at hard labor for not less than five years, with a fine of not less than $10,000, for the crime of treason-—that is, levying war or ad- hering to the enemies of the United States or the Philippine Government. In this it parallels the statutes of the ('nited States. But in Section 5 the law goes beyond anything now upon the statute-book of the United States, and defines as sedition the infliction of any act of “hate or revenge” upon any offi- cial of the Government, or, “if with a political or social object,’ upon indi- viduals, or any class of individuals. These crimes it punishes by a fine of not over $5,000 and imprisonment for not more than ten years. Conspiracy to The Nation. [Vol. 74, No. 1909 commit the crime of sedition carries with it a punishment of not more than five years in prison and of not more than $1,000 fine. Going a step further, the taking of an oath to engage in a seditious project, or to bind one to fail to reveal any unlawful combination, is punished by the last-named penalty, as is the action of one who merely at tempts to induce a person to take such an oath. But the climax of this extra- ordinary law is to be found in the fol- lowing sections: “Sec. 8. Every person who shall _ ut- ter seditious words or speeches, write, pub- lish, or circulate scurrilous libels against the Government of the United States or the Insular Government of the Philippine Isl- ands, or which tend to disturb or obstruct any lawful officer in executing his office, or which tend to instigate others to cabal or meet together for unlawful purposes, or which suggest or incite rebellious con- spiracies or riots, or which tend to stir up the people against the lawful authori- ties or to disturb the peace of the com- munity, the safety and order of the Gov- ernment, or who shall knowingly conceal such evil practices, shall be punished by a fine not exceeding $2,000 or by imprison- ment not exceeding two years, or both, in the discretion of the court. “Sec. 10. Until it has been officially proclaimed that a state of war or insurrec- tion against the authority or sovereignty of the United States no longer exists in the Philippine Islands, it shall be unlawful for any person to advocate orally or by writing or printing, or like methods, the independence of the Philippine Islands or their separation from the United States, whether by peaceable or forcible means, or to print, publish, or circulate any handbill, newspaper, or other publication, advocat- ing such independence or separation. Any person violating the provisions of this sec- tion shall be punished by a fine of not ex- ceeding $2,000 and imprisonment not ex- ceeding one year.” Plainly, the proper title for this act should have been “A Bill to Put an End to Freedom of Speech and the Liberty of the Press in the Philippines, and to Create a Nation of Spies and Infeorm- ers”; for such is the purport of the provisions cited, and such will be the inevitable results of the law if it should be rigidly enforced. When it was be- fore the Commission, some of the friend- ly Filipinos, and also Sefior Buencamino, who represented the Federal party, pro- tested against it on the ground that it would undo the beneficial effect of the benevolent speeches of members of the Commission when they firstarrived in the Philippines. The Manila Times did not hesitate to tell the truth about the act. “There is no loophole left by it by which any man who is disaffected towards the Government in these islands, and so ex- presses himself by word or act, can es- cape. Even the secret knowledge of covert workings against the sovereign power in these islands is sufficient to make one culpable and amenable to the new law.” Evidently the new Liberty which typi- fles the United States abroad should fling away the torch of enlightenment for the bayonet, since her mission in the Philippines is plainly not to encourage men to be free, but to think only what her armed representatives deem wise. One of these, according to Representa- tive Gaines, has declared the Constitu- tion of the United States “a d in- cendiary document”! In what way such a policy as this Philippine one differs from the oppression of Russia in Fin- land, or that of Turkey in Armenia, it would be very interesting to know. Was there any law of King George the Third as arbitrary or as hard upon his Amer- ican colonists as this when they revolt- ed? We know of none. And yet Mr. Root would have us believe that the Commission, in all its acts, has “faith- fully adhered to the principles control- ling our own Government.” Only once in its history has this Republic turned to such an extreme law, and that in 1798, when the famous Alien and Sedition Acts were passed, only to be repealed within a few years. ‘Let us not estab- lish a tyranny,” protested Alexander Hamilton, whose own party was passing these acts. Is it not a tyranny which the Philippine Commission has estab- lished by its sedition act? Theodore Roosevelt recently named three characteristics or attainments as the necessary equipment of any man fitted to do useful work in our body poli- tic. One of these he defined as “‘some knowledge of history.’”’ It would seem as if the members of the Philippine Commission were wilfully ignorant of some of the most tragic pages in modern history. For if they were familiar with the struggles for liberty of men under the tyranny of despots or under foreign oppression, they would know full well the futility of trying to overawe men’s minds and spirits by threats of prison bars. The dungeons of Russia, the con- vict hovels of Siberia, the prison stock- ade on the island of Guam, all attest this truth. THE SENATE AS TREATY-MAKER. The ups and downs of the treaty with Denmark for the sale to us of St. Thom- as. which is at last before the Senate fcr its approval, throw an_ instruc- tive light upon the theories of Senator Lodge respecting the treaty-making pow- ers of the Senate. He holds, in his Scribner article, that the Senate must be consulted in the framing, as well as in the ratification, of treaties. Of course ii needs a negotiator, since the Senate cannot directly deal with foreign gov- ernments, but there stands the Secretary of State ready to carry out the Sena- torial behests. Let him first find out what Senators want, then let him nego- tiate. Ratification will follow as a mat- ter of course. Such is the Lodgian view. The Danish instance, however, shows that, whatever may be said of the Consti- tutional questions involved, the practical application of these notions would make an end of all negotiation. The treaty with Denmark has been hanging fire for a year or two. There has evidently been a great deal of diplomatic give-and- ASPET ES Cty 12 wisi
Page 9
Jan. 30, 1902] eke in connection with it. The Danish Government wants to know what com- mercial and political rights its West Indian subjects would have under the American flag. It is also thought to have insisted that they be allowed to vote on the question of American an- nexation. the Senate on each of all questions arising in his correspondence before he dares to put pen to paper? one such But must Secretary Hay poll | Must he consult, not his chief, the Presi- | dent, not his colleagues of the Cabinet, | but ninety Senators? We hear of a plébiscite in St. Thomas. But Lodge would have a plébiscite in the Senate this or any other particular could be passed upon by our Secretary of State. If Mr. Hay were to conduct his department with the proper fear of Lodge before his eyes, he would have to keep foreign ambassadors waiting till he had called the roll of the Senate. This would not be very dignified, and it cer- tainly would bring diplomatic business to a standstill. Diplomacy is at best a leisurely affair; this plan would make it a veritable Dead March. By the time that a Secretary had laboriously sound- ed the opinions of ninety Senators, a new Senate might come in, and the work would be all to do over again. Treaties could not be framed on such terms. No self-respecting man would consent to make himself, while nominally in charge of our foreign relations, in real- ity nothing but the errand-boy of the Senate, to deliver its messages to other countries. What Senator Lodge really proves, in his magazine article, is something which nobody ever namely, the Constitutional power of the Senate to ac- cept or reject a treaty made by the Ex- ecutive. In this is implied the to amend a treaty, if the Senate ing to run the risk of defeating by. To the of truth, Senator Lodge comes forward with a great array of learning and eloquence. With triumphant he what no man disputes, and wreaks him- self upon a platitude with the enthusi- asm of a Tupper. He thinks, of course, to slip into his Constitutional argument the inference that the to ratify means the right to be consulted before- hand as to the thing to be ratified. Of course, an may rt that right, if it can find a Secretary and a President weak enough to yield; but that it is fairly to be deduced f1 the grant of power made in the Constitution, is another story. Even if the | good, the consequences would be so dis before questioned power is will- it there- obvious ae Lois assertion logic establishes powel arrogant Senate asst om were iaW astrous, and would so make an end of American diplomacy, that the practice ought not to be adopted. Lodge himself sees this, that the Senate refrained,” as a rule, from exercising its “right negotiate treaties. He is not very happy in the little lec- Indeed, even and observes has “‘wisely to | | | The Nation. ture which he reads Lord Lansdowne | Minister’s Constitution. accept that American the Lansdowne's Hay-Pauncefote upon ignorance of refusal to the treaty as amended by the Senate, Lodge thinks due to entire ‘“‘misapprehension”’ of the Senate’s rights in the premises Sut if the Senator had the ble to the British ign tary's minute the treaty, that there no unwarrantable action by taken trou- read Fore Secre- on he would discovered ref any have was erence to the Senate. It was only because the | American Ambassador laid the Senate amendments before the British Govern ment that the latter took notice of them. A Was nd true, that these changes perfectly Lord Lansdowne pointed out, what | had been proposed without any previous | Brit He added, moreover, that the had pressed to Lord Pauncefote not only its attempt to see if they would meet ish views. American Government before ex complete satisfaction with the treaty as it originally stood, but its of the conciliatory disposition shown by her Majesty’s Government.” Here we “appreciation | get a vivid glimpse of the humiliations | which the Lodge idea of treaty-making | the of would would American President and Secretary State the nation itself. It give us the inevitable air of not knowing our own mind Our negotiators would be without authority Our by the Senate heap upon and two days running. treaties would be waste paper be- fore the ink on them was dry. We agree with Lodge that the Senate would indeed be to refrain shadowy right which would lead direct- “wise” from exercising a ly to such lamentable results. Lodge’s precedents are not in point, that a President may consult the Senate in advance if he of Senator Lodge argues with splendid power. He cites the example of Washington going the in with an treaty. Senate except as they show chooses. This, also, is one those undisputed propositions which Senate Of practically into person In- the Privy dian then the cret, course, Council, and President could meet with it in if he wished. So he can seek know its mind now, doubt, before taking any given The Wash- ington case, if we remember aright, was a se- to no action. the one described in Maclay’s ‘Journal, was when the first President rebuked the Senate for defeating his plan. It was | then, as Maclay wrote, that “if the Father of his Country could ever be thought to look angry, he looked angrily | at me.” If that glance of wrath were to be seen in the Senate of to-day, we sus- pect that it would be directed towards the seat of the junior Senator from Mas sachusetts, on hearing his contention that the Senate possesses the power to negotiate treaties, and may exert it whenever it sees fit. FEDERAL CLEARING-HOUSES. A bill was introduced in the House on » £& SS. the 7th inst. by Mr. Pugsley of New York, to provide for a more elastic cur ney the National Bank Act sup plies. This has long been a desideratum to the securing of which many minds have been working. Everybody who un derstands our present ystem knows that our inknote ‘ t adjust itself to the mand f Phe demand for mone n the comm ‘ | centres, where business is transacted mostly by bank checks, is met prompt ly and easily by the discount of comme cial paper, taking the form of deposits. rhe proceeds of tl d sunt are cre t ea by the banker in the istomer's pas k as a deposit, and the custom diaws his checks against the same, ex ictly as though he had deposited there an equal amount of gold When we peak of an elastic curt we mean system by which banknotes may be is- sued as promptly and readily as bank chee} so that when the customer's pa per is discounted he can draw th money in banknotes, if he chooses to do So It nay be asked, What prevents lim from doing so now? In a single case he could do so, but if a large number of cases should ¢ upon the bank simul taneously, its cash reserve would soon be exhausted, and it would be compelled to stop discounting. If it could issue its credit in the form of its own notes, it could safely discount much paper in that form as in th form of deposits. The reason why the bank cannot respond to the demand f notes as readily to the demand f checks is, that the law requires the s« curity of United States bonds befor notes can be ed This fact not onl makes the currency inelast but make i‘ dependent upon the bond market. A demand for bonds for other pur} i than those of banknote ( contra the circulation, even in the face of a demand for more circulat The iat ter process is going on n The Gov ernment itself is a buyer of its ow bonds. It bids up the pr It offer a temptation to the banks to retire the circulation and sell their bonds, in or de: to pocket the premium The la allows not more than $3,000,000 of ba notes to be retired each month This is the rate at which the withdrawa is now going on But for this limita tion the retirement would be more rapid The bill introduced by Mr. Pugst embodie the ideas pr ted Mr iheodore Gilman in hi ok on ‘Fed eral Clearing-Ho It go upon the theory that, if tl ( iring- houses of the country would unite in guaranteeing the goodne and prompt redemption o hanknotes the assets of the } uing banks a ecurity and uniting their capital and credit to this end h notes would be absolutels ife, and the ecurity of Government bonds might be dispensed with The bill has two ends i ‘
Page 10
to provide a safe and elastic note issue. If the object of the bill could be car- ried out and the banks of the country be grouped into national clearing-house associations of sufficient size, there is no doubt that notes issued upon the com- bined responsibility of these associations would be perfectly secure. The second ob- ject is to relieve the business interests from the embarrassment and actual dam- age done by the constant absorption of money by the Treasury and by its with- drawal from the channels of circulation as customs and internal revenue are col- lected—this to be done upon a security satisfactory to the Secretary of the Treasury. The provisions of the act are vague, cumbersome, and unwieldy. It would be simpler to let the Secretary de- posit with the individual banks in his discretion, upon furnished by them to his satisfaction, and to pay in- terest upon such It would be safe to deposit with the associated banks of any clearing-house district without se- curity, but it would be exceedingly diffi- cult to determine the method of doing this, and no one bank would be dispos- ed to become security for the others. The same criticism applies to circulating notes. The strong banks would refuse to be responsible for the note issues of the weaker ones. Section 13 of the bill proposes to tax all clearing-houses that do not come into the system one-one- hundredth of 1 per cent. on all of their exchanges. This we fancy, will get very little support in Con- gress, yet without the application of force it is not likely that the banks will adopt the proposed plan. security deposits. forcing process, efficacy which possess is The great virtue and clearing-house that they are not incorporated bodies. They are under no supervision or constraint, and in times of crisis they can do what is deemed to be wise and necessary to meet the situation, unham- pered and unrestrained. Under a law like the Pugsley bill these associations would be relegated to the status of reg- ular corporations, governed by law, in- terpreted and administered primarily at the Comptroller’s office. We might very likely have an incumbent in that office who would not be able so to grasp the situation in a time of crisis as to meet the clearing- house incorporated, they would be subject to injunction and mandamus, and the speculative interests in the Street might judicial processes to prevent of enforce action asso- associations emergency. Besides, if associations were interpose or otherwise embarrass such an ciation for other purpose than a speculative one. Such speculation would naturally be on the bear side. The crux of the no matter lies in the question, Will clearing-houses which have the financial strength to command the confidence of the country consent to assume the duties and respon- sibilities assigned to them? Until some those The Nation. [Vol. 74, No. 1909 evidence is presented that they would do so, it is needless to consider the de- tails of the measure. BOOK COLLECTORS AND OTHERS. For some weeks past the dispatches have been full of sensational purchases of works of art—a half million paid for such a Raphael, and a cool million of- fered for a Titian. To-day we are bid be- lieve that the entire Borghese collec- tion is to become the property of one of our countrymen, and the rather dubi- ous rumor is at least taken seriously enough in England to arouse against the sale vigorous protest “in behalf of the civilized world’’—excluding, natural- ly, the Americas. The collectors who buy Raphaels and Titians and gaileries en bloc might be called the “strong-arm” men of the fraternity. They have in their unlimited wealth an unfailing ar- gument, and they may easily dispensa with the guile which is the most salient characteristic of the true collector. It is this fact which, while their conquests are viewed with a kind of fearful ad- miration, puts them generally out of the pale. The collector’s instinct is like genius, iu that it is based upon an infinite ca- pacity for taking pains. It is this which has brought much ridicule upon the craft. And, in fact, money values do come to depend upon the infinitely lit- tle. At a book sale the other day a first edition, 1846, of Hawthorne’s ‘Mosses from an Old Manse’ was sold. The book generally is of no great rarity, fetching ten dollars, or thereabouts. But the copy in question was “in the original paper covers as issued,” and the fact that no one had taken the pains to bind the two volumes properly was responsi- ble for a price of $170. In the same sale a first edition of Emerson was commended because its paper label was in perfect condition; a crack, a finger- mark, a dog-ear, or a torn corner would notably have lessened the value of the, copy. It might be said that these dis- criminations are often based on reason. One would rather have a clean copy of a book than a soiled, a fair white margin than a page cropped to the headlines. A margin, too, isa pleasing thing around a print, and early states of a famous etching are often preferable, on artistic grounds, to impressions from the finish- ed plate. But these considerations do not explain sufficiently the startling caprices of collecting values—as_ the fact that Thackeray first editions, neat- ly bound, may be had for a song, while the same volume in its original serial parts, with the advertising pages and the ugly yellow-paper covers, may be worth a, missionary’s ransom; that we pay in banknotes for every centimetre of ex- tra height of a rare Elzevir, and must cover every sixteenth of an inch of mar- gin about a Rembrandt print with gold. What is really paid for in every in- stance is simple rarity. The unique copy or impression is the ideal for the en- lightened collector; and the anecdote which relates how a famous bibliophile pleaded with an associate for a certain book, raised his offer to an irresistible price, and then threw the book into the fire with the taunt, “Now my copy is unique,’ expresses the spirit in which many collections are made. A kind of madness Dibdin called it, and yet a mad- ness which is fully justified of its chil- dren; for the supply of collectors is un- failing, that of desirable objects ever less. This makes a collection which has been shrewdly assembled with due regard to condition and _ specu- lative value one of the very best investments. And it must be said that very little collecting is free from this taint of commercialism. The books. in a great private library are usually too valuable to be used, even if the collector, which rarely happens, is a reader also. His prints are of a kind too precious to be framed, his china too good for house- hold use. What is he but, on the one hand, a dealer for probable or possible resale, or, on the other, an irrational idealist, in the pursuit not of the beau- tiful, but simply of the rare? But the anti-social nature of collec- tors—their neglect of wife and family for the rare example, their disingenuous wiles for catching the unwary dealer or the ignorant owner—have been fully exposed by members of the craft; and since collectors glory in these things, the severe moralist finds their case be- yond the power of rebuke to reach or of warning to stay. It should be said, how- ever, that there is a kind of collector who is free from this reproach. Dealers do not favor him, or even admit that he is a collector at all, though they de- pend largely upon his enthusiasm for their support. He is unknown to the famous salesrooms, but a familiar fig- ure at the book-stalls and smaller shops. This collector buys the books which he loves in the form in which he loves to read them. He buys cheap, and often wastes his money, but he satis- fies his soul. His attitude towards books is a sentimental one. He is not wise about margins, and labels, or even about editions; but he loves the smell of old Russia; he knows, with Charles Lamb, that Beaumont and Fletcher never taste so good as when taken in folio; or he may have an _ in- vincible prejudice against reading Chaucer except in black-letter. He val- ues books for their human associations, for all the homely signs of use, the scribbled “valde absurdum est” on a margin, or the signature of a former owner which defaces a title-page. Only this kind of collector, after all, knows the real luxury of possession. His books, when he is beyond using them, may cut but a sorry figure in the
Page 11
Jan. 30, 1902] salesroom, and his heirs and assigns may resent the thriftlessness which was willing to amass such merely personal treasures as are negotiable only at an appalling discount; but he himself should have the pardon of him who has loved greatly. We should not fail to admire the minute special knowledge, the painstaking sagacity, and the fanati- cism in the quest exhibited by the great collectors of whom history takes ac- count. But we do well, also, to praise the obscure and disinterested who loves his possessions for their own sake; and we may well suspect a defini- tion so rigorous as to exclude from the line of collectors Charles Lamb, who loved old books with a kind of passion, and Sir Walter Scott, who made Abbots- ford a veritable museum of which, apart from their personal asso- ciations, were of pitifully slight value. collector objects HAVANA. December, 1901. Though means the oldest seat of Spanish power in Cuba—it is, indeed, the sixth in order of the places from which the island was governed from the days of Columbus to Blanco—its fame, its population so far those of all other cities in the Antilles and all round the Caribbean Sea, whether’ Spanish, French, or English, that the visitor ap- proaches it with high expectations of find- ing a place with a dignity of aspect and a richness of interest corresponding to its history and its importance. In some re- spects he is disappointed. Of architectural beauty there is very little. The Cathedral, from which some of the remains of Colum- bus were recently carried back to Spain, is a heavy building, not very large and not very handsome, though the interior, being dignified and well-proportioned, is rather better than the dull exterior leads one to expect. It is not even very old, though the decayed aspect of the coralline limestone of which it is built gives it an air of an- tiquity. Neither has any other church any considerable merit. There are no striking towers, and but little of that rich orna- mentation on the facade or on the door- ways which gives a character to many of the churches of Spanish America. The military edifices are not much better. Morro Castle, of whose situation I shall presently say something, is modern, a good specimen of the fortification work of the eighteenth century repaired some seventy years ago, but destitute of beauty or even of picturesque character. The older fort- ress, on the west side of the entrance to the harbor, is remarkable from its massive solidity, its low gateways, and immensely thick walls enclosing gloomy dungeons, but is equally without architectural merit. Some of the palaces of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries have handsome inter- nal courtyards—patios, as the Spaniards call them—with rows of good columns and stately staircases; but very few of these show any street front worthy of Here and there one finds pretty bits Havana is by no those of Gen commerce, and its exceeded note. of iron work, but the streets are generally devoid of such architectural features as give
The charm to the cities of Spain, Portugal, and Italy. In the older part of Havana, close to the Nation. fort, the thoroughfares, straight, as in all Spanish colonial towns, are narrow and the houses high, and there are sometimes ar- cades of pillars sometimes drawn This part has therefore a kind of picturesque- ness, enhanced by the along them, awnings from side to side. occasional occur- rence of small plazas or open spaces, and by the effects of light and shade which one gets in narrow streets with a strong sun and brilliant sky overhead. In the newer parts the streets are wider and probably healthier, but they are form in the style of building, with little or nothing on even more uni- which the eye cares to rest One gets the impression of a city in which there was neither an aristocracy desiring itself by houses, nor a body of merchants their their substance in decorating their dwell- to assert raising stately town proud of municipality, and willing to spend mediwval Italy or of the Hanseatic and free imperial This remembers ing-places as the merchants of cities in Germany were wont to do. is natural enough when one that Havana never had either a territorial or a commercial aristocracy. It strange, considering how rich the Church was in Cuba, that neither bishops seems toman nor convents should have devoted more of their revenues to the erection of imposing or ornate ecclesiastical edifices, such as are found in other parts of America, as, for instance, in Mexico some Spanish Thus there is really comparatively little to see in this famous capital of the Antilles. So far as architecture is concerned, a fore- noon’s walk is sufficient to show the tourist all he is likely to care for. But if the student of architecture experi- ences some disappointment, if the historian finds comparatively little which can aid his imagination to reconstruct the earlier an- nals of Spanish rule, if the tume and the aspects of social lif: lover of cos- notes less that is peculiar than he expected, there is, nevertheless, a measure both of beauty and of attractiveness in Havana It re- calls some of the famous cities of the Mediterranean in the brilliance of its light and the striking features of its situation It stands on the west side of an inlet of the sea, two to three miles long and les This is the haven which gives its name to the than half a mile wide at its mouth. city, and which affords a perfectly safe and good anchorage with a depth of water suf- Atlantic liners, yet for all the vessels that use, or are likely to use, the port. The older part , fictent, if not for the very largest of the town stands on nearly level ground alcng the The rising ground further back, and has spread harbor. newer part is on northward so as to face the sea outside the harbor, while the suburbs stretch still further along the north coast and inland over the acclivities of wooded hills to the west Thus, as the visitor approache in a ship, he sees a mass of white building backed by verdure above the bright blue waters, usually (in winter) crisping under the northerly breeze Ou the Morro Castle stands rising on a gentle slope further side of the harbor entrance ipon a high, rocky cape against which the waves are always foam ing, while a little further up the inlet the picturesque walls, now half pinkish-white
i} il of tl old sath of Cabasa W ‘ g ff The bay h shipping, and at its head g ! 1 hed by he I DaAcK, yund re that the 5 mosques at : i it) the 1 ( ! Hi at ¢ ‘ ple N t ‘ ! the City Bott i illed the Parque ¢ l Pra i wid ivel | thwest ur filled w i n if | Snowe © th groves ! | i ) } } ’ wt y \ e bay and the osed, M Ca for ‘ } ‘ WN } r j r iOy i I G Ii and Rio J lia ‘a the trang f i 1 ur
Page 12
The Nation. [Vol. 74, No. 1909 costume among the women than he has been led to expect. The mantilla is not general; nor do the dresses generally show much of the grace and picturesqueness one associates with Spanish countries. Among the younger women there are many good figures as well as fine eyes; but Cadiz in the Old World and Baltimore in the New have a much higher proportion of hand- some faces. Neither men nor women give the impression of a vigorous race; and, in- deed, the most industrious and intelligent element in the population (excluding Americans, Germans, and Englishmen—the two latter not numerous) is that which has come lately from old Spain, and especially from the northern provinces—Catalonia, Asturias, Galicia, and the Basque districts. Between them and the native Cubans there seems to be now no ill-feeling, and a good deal of the commerce of the city is already in their hands, or is passing to them. That the commercial activity of Havana depends upon the general prosperity of Cuba, and especially upon the agricultural development of the island and the construc- tion of railways through it, goes without saying. At present the uncertainty of the political future checks new enterprises and keeps everything in suspense. It is, there- fore, the less surprising that there is a want of bustle in the streets, and that the shipping in the harbor is not very nu- merous. Among that shipping there still stands out of the water one ghastly skele- ton. It is the wreck of the Maine, which no one is in any danger of failing to re- member. THE REAL CHAUDIERE. NEW YORK, January, 1902. When I read Gilbert Parker’s ‘Right of Way’ by instalments, I wondered where his Chaudiére might be, for I knew the real Chaudiére some half-century ago, and his picture of the people and their manners bore no resemblance to the reality. I am relieved to learn, from the preface to the book, that the Chaudiére of the story had no existence, except in the author’s imagi- nation. The actual Chaudiére and its peo- ple remain in my recollection as an idyll of primitive purity and simplicity. The Chaudiére River heads near’ the height of land between Maine and _ the Province of Quebec, and its waters almost interlock with those of the Kennebec. It was, therefore, from the earliest days—long before Arnold led his troops through it—a waterway between Quebec and the New Eng- land for, though turbulent for some distance above its mouth, where it leaps by its picturesque falls into the St. Lawrence, the upper stretches of the river are 80 slightly ruffled that the Indians and the Canadian voyageurs could paddle their colonies; canoes, with only one portage, for about forty miles. The fertile valley through which it flows in this section of its course was, early in the eighteenth century, par- celled out as selgnories of twelve miles by twelve miles in extent to French immigrants of note. And as the land was rich, it was soon taken up by tenants, many of whose descendants still occupy the farms of their forefathers; for the seignorial tenure of land encouraged permanency of occupation. The tenant paid the seigneur only a trifling an- nual rent of one or two sous per acre, and the farm and its improvements descended on the same terms to the tenant’s heirs. But if he sold his holding to a stranger, the seigneur was entitled to lods et ventes, or a commission, amounting to a large share of the price. Transfers were, therefore, costly and rare, and generation after gen- eration of the same family occupied the same land, cutting it up, however, into strips, as heirs multiplied who refused to emigrate from the parish, until the attenu- ated farms became too small to supply even the slender wants of the simple folk who cultivated them. Some sixty years ago, in the bed of one of the streams flowing into the Chaudiére through the Parish of Saint Francois, a girl picked up a curious stone, which was rec- ognized to be a nugget of gold. But the discovery, though noted by Capt. Badderley in the Transactions of the Literary and His- torical Society some years afterward, cre- ated no excitement. California and its gold had not loomed up to inflame the imag- ination of the world; and, to the primitive folk of the Chaudiére Valley, the discovery of a nugget was of less moment than the birth of a baby. It had been better for my father’s purse had he been as impassive as his countrymen, but he first joined a few other enterprising spirits in buying from the seigneur the right to work the aurife- rous gravels, and, the company failing, he then undertook alone the unprofitable task. And thus it came about that I spent two pleasant summers among the gentle, courte- ous habitants of the Chaudiére Valley. My job was to superintend some gravel workings on a small stream called after the family who owned the lana at its mouth, the Deplante. The farm, of ample width orig- inally, had been subdivided among three branches of the family. One eked out a liv- ing by blacksmithing, another had some skill as a carpenter; my host, as the head of the Deplantes, disdained other occupation than farming, which, however, he practised, not in person, but through the members of his family. These consisted of a wizen but shrewd old woman, the wife, who was profuse in her professions, and refused to name any price for her hospitality, but, if her ‘‘ce que vous voulez’’ was not responded to as liberally as she expected, left no doubt in your mind that you had been guilty of disgraceful meanness. It was well she had some business capacity and ambition, for her husband had none. He dreamed and slept his life away in the barn. Some of the hay was always sticking in his shaggy, tawny shock of hair. He was the infidel of the village. He never went to mass, but his heretical notions were not very clear, and he recognized the force of public opinion sufficiently to wisely shut them up in his own muddled brain—except to an admitted heretic. They really consisted of little else than an admiration for a shadowy Voltaire, who he said was ‘tun grand homme. Il a écrit soixante-dix volumes, monsieur.”’ His indolence was inherited by his eldest son Olivier, but the younger son, Francois Xa- vier, was an active but rather disagreeably pushing youth, who ultimately broke up the ancestral home; for, years afterwards, when I drove up the Chaudiére, the old people had died, the girls had married, the boys had flitted, and the place knew the Deplantes The other members of the family The eldest, Euphrosyne, a no more. were four girls. good-natured, strapping girl, did most of the outside work; Pélagie was the wit of the family; Ellen was a pale-faced, light-haired beauty, who seldom or never spoiled ber complexion by field work, but was the fami!- ly seamstress; and Marie, a bright little girl, was at the village school. She subsequently was sent to the Ursuline Con- vent in Quebec to complete her education, by fitting herself to become the village schoolmistress in turn. There were four of us, all in search of gold dust in the bed of the Deplante stream, who wished to board with the De- plantes; but the house contained only two big rooms and the garret. The outer room was the kitchen and living-room, with its big fireplace and its deal table and home- made chairs, whose bottoms were woven out of the underbark of the cedar. The wrought-iron lamp, of the exact shape of those used by the old Romans, filled with tallow, in which a wick was immersed, and which hung from a notched stick secured to the ceiling, gave a dingy light for the short space of evening between suppertime and bedtime, for the family engaged in no lite- rary pursuits. The inner room contained four huge bedsteads, one in each corner, so high that agility or a ladder was required to enter them. What members of the fam- ily occupied them when we were not there, we had, of course, no means of knowing. When we were there, the old couple and the girls climbed into the garret, the boys slept in the barn. But to sleep four in a room, even though each occupied a separate bed, was not consistent with our habits; so we suggested that partitions might, with- out much cost, be thrown up. The mere mention of a change in the architecture of the old wooden house threw the old man into a panic. It was the only occasion in our acquaintance when we observed the slightest disturbance in the placidity of the poor old fellow’s temper. His great- grandfather had built the house, and to touch it was a profanity. He could not—he dare not. But, as the alternative was our leaving, the cupidity of the old lady over- came the old man’s scruples, and the par- titions were knocked up. I have since then felt that we committed a crime, for I fear we broke into and helped to break down a simple mode of life without any parallel on our busy, skeptical, self-seeking con- tinent. The family lived almost exclusively on bread and milk. A can of milk covered with a luscious layer of cream was placed before each. Pancakes, so light that they almost tossed themselves, made with no stint of eggs, and occasionally a little fat pork, varied the simple diet. But we want- ed butter. In the rich meadows along the Chaudiére a herd of their cows fed, and milk and cream there was galore, but but- ter had never been made, and there was no churn in the house. I recall well how Euphrosyne beat up the rich cream into a substitute for butter in a bowl, using her hand as a beater. It was not nice, and it soon turned sour; but, rather than intro- duce the innovation of a churn, they pre- ferred buying butter at the store. Besides the cows, they kept sheep, whose fleece supplied the family loom, on which the girls, during the long winter months, wove the étoffe du pays for the men’s clothing, the striped stuff for their own petticoats, and the blankets for the beds. The fleece was spun at home, after being carded at
Page 13
Jan. 30, 1902] the seigneur’s mill on shares, for, as a condition of the old seignorial grants, a carding and a flour mill had to be run by these representatives of the old feudal lords, for the convenience of their ten- ants and their own profit. Then there was a patch of flax, beautiful in the flowering season, and in the autumn the flax-beaters were brought out on the banks of the stream, in whose waters the flax stems had been steeped, and the merry clack, clack of the wooden bar was mingled with the happy laughter of the girls, as they pre- pared the fibre to be made by themselves into the family linen and sheeting. It was not until the beginning of the eighteenth century that the selfish colonial laws of old France—more exacting even than the com- mercial laws of England—allowed the Canadian-French habitant to begin this self-supporting existence. Ever since then they have added little to the revenue de- rived either from the customs of his Sacred Majesty of France or the British Crown. Nevertheless, once in a year there was a trading expedition made by some member of the Deplante family to Quebec. The two-wheeled cart was loaded with a few eggs and turkeys and like salable articles, and with provender for the pony and for one of the boys and one of the girls; and the journey of fifty miles to Quebec and fifty miles back was made by easy stages. Every evening the traders camped by the roadside, and, on the evening before they reached Quebec, stopped just beyond Point Levis, so as to take the earliest ferry- boat and secure a good position in the line of market carts, from which the thrifty housewife still buys on market days her provisions—for the huckster is forbidden to purchase from the farmer until after the householder has had his or her first choice. The few dollars’ worth of poultry and maple sugar sold, the important event of the year followed—the expenditure of pari of the proceeds in a cotton dress or two, for mass on Sundays; some trifling articles of finery, a little green tea, and some simple remedies. The journey back and the pleasant return home completed the one excitement of the year. It was a very moral village. With a view to excite early marriages, the boys and girls were encouraged by the priest to meet freely, but at discreet distance. Swinging was the fad, and a huge wooden structure stood before our cottage. The boys might swing the girls, but the lads and the lasses must not swing together. Danc- ing was not forbidden, but round dances were strictly prohibited. On Sunday after- noon the young men assembled by dozens at our house, each arriving with his own horse and cart, which lined the fence around the meadow between the house and the main road; and then the din of laughter and song, and the dense smoke of acrid, home-grown tobacco, made Sunday after- ndon less pleasant to us boarders than to the happy, noisy crowds on the other side of the partition. The principal personages of the parish were the notary and the priest, but of the two the priest stood supremely highest in the regards of the people. The parish priest of the Province of Quebec is not only the spiritual guide of his parishioners, but the adviser to whom they look for coun- sel in matters of this world, for medical assistance when the doctor is not nigh, and The Nation. for consolation in every time of trouble. No clergy in the world stand in as close and intimate relation to their flocks, with- out being in familiar contact with them, as the French priests of Quebec. The [Irish priest is socially even nearer to his people than the Canadian curé, but this very so- ciability detracts somewhat from his influ- ence and the sacredness in which his per- son and his office are held. One day the children returned from looking al- most solemn. A tavern had been opened in the parish against the From the pulpit he had anathematized the tavern-keeper as the destroyer of public morals. He had forbidden his parishioners to patronize the evil den, and threatened that, unless it was closed, he would call down fire from heaven and consume it. His congregation believed in his power to do so, and he, convinced that he was doing heaven’s work, believed that heaven would mass curé’s protest. help him. We were very good friends, the priest and myself. I had given him an Italian copy of one of Raphael’s Madonnas for an altarpiece. The last time Il saw him was under the following rather peculiar cumstances. It was several years after I had lived in the Deplante family. My fa- ther's concession of the gold-field had near- ly expired when rumor reached Quebec that a wonderful strike had been made by a company of four habitants, who had taken out a license to work on halves. I found the stream on which the rich bar had been discovered a-ive with gold-seekers; but I found also that, unless I reduced the royalty to a more reasonable propor- tion, very little would be paid. So I noti- fied the diggers that I would accept one- fourth instead of one-half. Small quanti- ties of gold dust were turned in by stray miners, but the lucky four appeared with two and a half pounds of gold, which they claimed was the resu't of their work with tin pans in the bed of the stream for ten days. I willingly accepted the gold, and believed their stai.ements. But it soon came to my hearing that the returns they made far short of their luck, so I can- celled their license. The following day the four men met me, and, as a preliminary, wished an assurance that I would still ac- cept one-fourth instead of demanding one- ha!f. This, of course, I gave, and in the evening they arrived at the hotel with a big mustard-bottle full of dust and nug- gets. They had washed a pound of gold for ten consecutive days out of the bed of the stream, and they weighed me out the bal- ance of two and a half pounds. Not unreasonably, they asked for just a little back, the more so as, in not making a true accounting at first, they assured me they had acted with the consent of the curé. So next day I called on my friend the priest, and received a characteristic ex- planation. After the extraordinary find, the four habitants called on his Reverence, told him the truth, and asked, as a matte: ot conscience, whether they might not con- temporarily the full extent of their good fortune, inasmuch as a revelaiion of such unusual wealth might assist the con- cessionaire in selling to the Yankees, and the Yankees might cancel their license. The advent of the Yankee from this point view mattered little to the priest, but the Yankee as the embodiment of heresy, vice, cir- were cea) of and worldliness mattered much to his Rev- erence, and he fell in with their views provided they pledged themselves to ak ultimately an honest return But, on my canceliing their Heense, they returned to the presbytére and lail the case again be fore his Reveierce. They said they were willing to pay at once, as the love of the gold might grow on them, and, when the season cloced, they might be reluctant to part with it; moreover, they might die sud dently, aud what would happen {ff they t world with stolen gold {: ed intu the next their possession?—a question the pric could not undertake to answer satisfacto rily. They thought, therefore, that unles his Reverence objected, they had better ease their conscience and their pockets at once—a holy resolve, to which his Rever ence beartily assented It was with this pleasant incident that I ended my inter course with the simple, sincere folk of th« Chaudiére Valley. I have seen it since from the but I the has changed the habits of its than it the aspects country. J. DOUGLAS railroad cars, fear railroad pe ople more of the has altered OLD MASTERS AT ACADEMY. THE ROYAL LONDON, January 6, 1902 The Royal Academy once more justifies its existence by the excellence of its win- ter exhibition. After the two memorial shows by Leighton and Millais, the fine Rembrandt and Van Dyck collections, and last year’s unfortunate display of half a century of British art, it has returned to the usual miscellaneous series of Old Mas ters. There have been winters when the great masterpieces have been more numerous and more remarkable, winters when a wiser r¢ straint has been put upon numbers. Indeed, nothing is gained by the two extra galleries added this year to the usual five. But there are many pictures notable for one reason o: another, while there is a special exhibition within the exhibition of paintings and drawings by Claude—the first time, to my knowledge, that due honor has been paid in England to the great French landscape painter. Of the further on Claudes I shall To turn to the re speak at length t of the col all old ma ters and every school and country are rep- lection is to find that almost resented, with one ast hing ion there is no English work ont except none of the Sir Joshuas and Gainsboroughs, the Constabl and Turners, hitherto so prominent Th series begins with a sufficient select Italian Primitives to afford employment the Morellian Already labels are being juggled with, and new “attributions” made But really in this section is little to give pleasure to the artist save a small “Virgin and Child with Angels,’ conventional in de- sign, but very lovely in its harmony of gold and rose, catalogued as a Benozzo Gozzoli, and then immediately handed over to ap un known, unnamed Sienese painter, as if it mattered; and two most beautiful cassone fronts by Pesellino—the story of David and Goliath told as naively as possible, event succeeding event with no interval in the composition on the long panel, but with splendor of color, a rhythmical swing in the design, decidedly uncommon in the work of the Primitives the most famous picture included is, per- Coming down a little later
Page 14
90 The Nation. [Vol. 74, No. 1909 haps, the Colonna Raphael, with its well- established pedigree and record of adven- ture. It is the altarpiece which Raphael painted for the nuns of St. Anthony of Pa- dua at Perugia—an early altarpiece. Sold by them in an hour of need, it passed from owner to owner, from town to town, from country to country, resting for a while in Rome with the Colonna family, whose name ever since has clung to it, until, finally, after having been thought not worth a place in the Louvre and the National Gal- lery, and not worth looking at while it was sheltered at South Kensington, it has fallen into the hands of Mr. Pierpont Morgan, and in England loud lament is heard be- cause it seems destined, with many another celebrated ‘old master,’’ to leave Europe for America. But, save for the magic which the name of Raphael still has for the world at large, save for its well-authenticated his- tory, the picture is without great merit. In composition it recalls somewhat the Ansidei Madonna—that seventy thousand pounds blunder of a Liberal Government. The Virgin, holding the Child in her lap, sits on the con- ventional throne with the correct canopy and elaborate decoration; on either side are arranged the conventional saints in saintly halos and draperies—on the left St. Catherine and St. Peter, on the right St. Rosalia and St. Paul, and, almost in front, the little St. John. They have the pretty insipidity, they pose with the self- consciousness, characteristic of Raphael's saints, and Perugino would have designed for them a more beautiful and spacious landscape as background. Above, in the lunette, is God the Father, with two at- tendant angels in a Peruginesque group. But the most interesting thing in connec- tion with the picture in its present quarters is the fact that all the panels of the predella (with the exception of one said to have already preceded the picture itself ‘to America) are included in the exhibition the first time, probably, they have been gathered together since the poor nuns in Perugia had to part with them. But the Academy, with its accustomed unintelli- gence, has seen fit to leave the panels in the first room, and hang the picture in the third—for no better reason, apparently, than because it is rather against precedent on these occasions to hang both small and large works in the third gallery. Probably, if the Raphael had been the only picture lent by Mr. Morgan, the out- ery over America’s gradual acquisition of the old masters would be, for the moment anyway, less loud. But he lends four others—on the choice of three he is not to be congratulated—-and it is not so long since every one was talking of his purchase of Gainsborough’s ‘Duchess,’ which no- body envies him, and the beautiful Fra- gonard series, which every gallery and mu- seum must want to dispute with him. Of his paintings at the Academy, by far the finest is a landscape by Rembrandt-—a wood, the light falling on an open glade in the foreground, and, beyond, the mys- tery and infinite depths of the forest, little figures disappearing into the shadowy dis- tance; above, a clear sky—a_ landscape charged with romance. A portrait of the “Cardinal Ferdinand,’’ by Rubens, and a “Lady and Little Girl,’ by Van Dyck, are fairly characteristic examples, if not the most distinguished of the two great Flem- ish masters. But I do nét think Mr. Pier- pont Morgan—or America—is to be -con- gratulated on the Titian, a large Holy Family, as cold in color and commonplace in sentiment as any picture I have ever seen labelled with the name of Titian. Few other paintings, until the Claudes are reached, need detain one in a general notice of so miscellaneous a gathering. In previous shows I have seen nobler portraits by Rembrandt and Franz Hals, more ex- quisite examples of Terburg, more sump- tuous color by the Venetians. Great names are everywhere in the Catalogue, great work is far more rare on the walls. If I except the sketches for Titian’s ‘‘Last Sup- per,”’ painted for Philip II., and now at the Escorial, and for Tintoretto’s ‘Marriage Feast’ in the Sacristy of the Salute, Venice; if I except a silvery-gray landscape by Murillo—a surprise, to me at least, be- cause it has such charm and is the only landscape by the Spanish sentimentalist I have seen, but how cheerfully would I ex- change it for any number of his Immaculate Conceptions and Assumptions; if I except a blue and white glimpse of Venice by Guardi, a delicate study of tender whites and grays, “Grace Before Meat,”’ by Char- din, and, it may be, a few others here and there, the one picture of any special note is the “Finished Sketch,”’ as it is describ- ed in the catalogue, of ‘‘Las Menifias,’”’ by Velasquez. Though not, within my mem- ory, exhibited publicly before, the picture is well known. It belongs to Mr. Ralph Bankes of Kingston Lacy, and in reproduc- tion can be seen in the late R. A. M. Ste- venson’s ‘Essay on Velasquez.’ The first thing that strikes one in the composition is the absence of the reflec- tion of the King and Queen in the far mirror. One feels still more keenly the sharpness of detail everywhere, but es- pecially in the pictures on the walls and the upright canvas in the foreground. The figures of the little Infanta, with her maids of honor, her dwarfs and other attendants, and of Velasquez are exactly as in the picture at the Prado, and the central group is put in with something of the breadth and freedom of the master, though the faces do not suggest his touch. But figures and detail are not enveloped in the magical at- mosphere that is the beauty of the larger finished work; something has gone from those “fields of vibrating space,”’ that ‘“‘vast shadowed top” of surely the most won- derful room ever painted. For my part, I believe the ‘‘sketch’’ to be a copy, though I cannot understand why a copyist should have omitted such an important feature as the reflected figures in the mirror. Even as I write, I am assured by a critic who thinks himself an authority and has not yet be- come a dealer, that it is a copy, probably by Del Mazo, and I fancy most lovers of Velasquez will come to the same conclu- sion without waiting to hear the critic’s arguments. The Claudes alone would make a delight- ful exhibition. They are lent by several different owners and collectors. The prin- cipal paintings come from the Duke of Westminster, Lady Wantage, the Earl of Yarborough, Sir Frederick Cook, the Mar- quis of Lansdowne; the drawings, chiefly from the King, Mr. Heseltine, Mr. George Salting, Mr. Knowles, About half the pictures I could willingly have omitted. The others show Claude as the great master he really was. His reputation has been somewhat overshadowed in England by the fame of Turner. Ruskin could not exalt the Englishman of the nineteenth century save at the expense of the Frenchman of the seventeenth. The very fact that Turner himself invited comparison by hanging cer- tain of his landscapes for all time by the side of Claude’s, made most people come to the conclusion that Turner must stand the test triumphantly. But he does not, and there are no pictures of Turner’s any- where as perfect as two or three in the present collection. In main features they may be alike. Claude delighted always in wide, rich landscape, in noble groups of trees, stately architecture, tranquil stretch- es of water, the silver light of noonday, the golden glow of evening. He preferred the well-balanced composition to the bit of Nature chosen at haphazard and copied in all its crudeness. And for this reason his work is sometimes thought cold and conventional and monotonous. But what variety there is, even if motive and mate- rial are so often the same! How different the light that falls so serenely on the wind- ing river, the low hills, and distant castle in the “Shepherd Playing on his Pipe,” and the golden glow with its dramatic fervor in the splendid ‘‘Landscape” from Grosve- nor House, though in both it is the hour of sunset! How different the architectural stateliness of one or more “Seaports,” and the Watteaulike daintiness and. charm of “La Récompense du Village’! And though an unmistakable Claude, where is there anything like ‘‘The Enchanted Castle,” lent by Lady Wantage, with its exquisite cool light, its tranquil space of sea where the white sails hover, its mountains fading into blue haze against the pale distant sky, its Arcadian peace and calm! It is not only the variety of Claude that impresses you after a careful study of all these pictures; it is even more their modern feeling and tendency. For a while, he was looked upon as the slave of conventions, one of the powers of evil to be warred with in the general revolt against the academies and traditions. But I think R. A. M. Stevenson was right when he bracketed Claude with Velasquez and Rembrandt as the first of the moderns. He it was who, in landscape, first revealed the true beauty of light. The paiut- er of to-day may have learned much about the scientific qualities and effects of light, but he has seldom understood as well as Claude its serenity, its splendor, its po- etry. Claude, again, was artist enough to know that the sun could shine with the same charm on an impressive classical landscape as on the cabbage-patch at his door; he was not afraid of beauty. And as, in that lovely village dance I have just referred to, he seemed to anticipate Watteau, so there are many passages in many pictures to which you may trace the inspiration of Corot and the Romanticists, who, however romantic in name, had the Frenchman’s instinctive love of harmony and order, and were unwill- ing to leave the composition of the simplest landscape to take care of itself. Certainly, I have come ,away from the Academy con- vinced not only that Claude was the great master in his own time, but that from his work is derived much that is greatest in modern landscape, I have seen, perhaps, finer drawings by Claude in Florence. But still, many in the
Page 15
Jan. 30, 1902] long series shown are of undoubted inter- est and value, and the chance to compare them with the pictures for which in some cases they are the notes and suggestions, should prove of immense advantage to the student. They are chiefly in sepia, bistre, and pen-and-ink. Many are sketches of places; of Rome, which he knew so well; of Civita Vecchia and Genoa, which he must have known better than is generally sup- posed. For at Civita Vecchia, more particu- larly, the tourist may still see, if he eyes, the stately piles of architecture, the broad quays, with their curving steps de- scending to the water’s edge, the towers, the tall shipping, the splendor of light in the evening where the channel leads west- ward, that occur in so many of Claude’s pic- tures oz seaports. Other drawings are stud- ies for paintings, always distinguished by the same fine sense of composition and love of graceful form, and sometimes, in ar- rangement, to the very groups of dancing nymphs, curiously suggestive of Corot. Al- together, I do not remember anywhere a finer exhibition of Claude, and it is fortunate that the Academy, after the horrors it per- petuates in the summer, should, in the win- has ter, give one some reason to be thankful for its existence. N. N. ( ‘orrespondence. GERMAN AND AMERICAN SCHOOLS. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: Without wishing in a general to deny the soundness of Professor Miin- sterberg’s, and his reviewer's, position in regard to American school education, I should like, with your kind permission, to present a few phases of the subject neglect of which might confirm some of our most earnest critics in their, as it seems to me rather one-sided view. First of all, as a matter of fact, the elec- tive system has not become an important feature in the schools of this country below the high school. The so-called introduction way of the “kindergarten spirit and meth- ods” into the primary grades has oc- casionally been carried to excess. by well-meaning cranks, but its influence upon primary education has been, on the whole, beneficial, in so far as it has helped to discard many useless for- malities and mechanical devices in teach- ing and discipline. In the primary and grammar grades the pupils are held to pre- scribed courses of study, and in the high schools the seiection of studies is not with- out restriction. It really amounts to a choice among several courses’ which, mutatis mutandis, differ from each other very much like the curricula in the four or five kinds of secondary schools in Ger- many. It is doubtful whether a complete Separation of pupils pursuing different courses, by assigning to each section a spe cial building and a separate corps of teach- ers, would be advantageous if it were fea- sible. In referring to the superior scholarship of German teachers, one should always bear in mind that the vast majority of German children do not enjoy the instruction of such scholars as constitute the ing force in the gymnasia and the other secondary schools of a high grade teach- Among The Nation. the 85,000 membersof the Deutscher Lehrer verein, for example, there are few univer If we could strike age of scholarship of the teachers of all grades in Germany and compare it with the scholarship of the average American teach- sity graduates. the aver- on the Ger- the by American er, the advantage would still be man but there wide difference of conditions Miinsterberg. As public school combines the various classes side, would not appear assumed Professor the of German schools (gymnasium, realschule, ete., down to the volkKsschule), it is not fair to compare its teaching for with that of the erations been enjoying, more the ernment It differs fron gymnasium alone, which has for gen than any other institution, fostering care of the Gov- our high school more extended course of not only by its but its exclusive function a study, also by a fitting school for the University. I had my early boyhood none but university grad Like Professor Miinsterberg, from uates for instructors. For two years pre vious to my entering the gymnasium, I, to gether with one other boy, was taught by a young theologian taken into the family as a private tutor. I never had any fault to find with him on my own score, and it did not occur to me till many years afte! that the other boy’s nervous system and to some extent, his life were ruined by that man’s pedagogy and the mistaken sense of duty of an ambitious, well-mean ing father. The theologian endeavored to pound Latin and Greek into the little fel low, and the father upheld him in the at tempt. They had none of the indulgence of American father and teachers (The mother and an aunt entreated the con cientious tutor to desist from using the Spanish reed; he promised, but did not keep his promise.) I have since been able to recall a number of similar cases among my comrades at the gymnasium less for tunate than myself. One boy, I remember, whose case was a hopeless one, left the gymnasium early, after a severe tussle with an irascible teacher. He is now Com merzienrat and the head of one of the largest banking firms in Hanover. That my experi ence in this respect is not exceptional, and that the present conditions in the German schools, though improved, are not alto gether changed, I infer from the reports of others and from the manner in which some recent German novelists have treated the school question. On the other hand, I am firmly convinced, from what I have seen of American ‘‘schoolma’ams,’’ that many of them (college graduate of course, and good scholars in our modest sense of th word) could have taught those boy who were not dunces—almost anything, not ex- cepting Latin and Greek. This letter has grown to such length that I must leave it to those of your readers who are interested in the matter to draw their own inferences from the above state ments. Allow me only to say, in conclud ing, that there eems to me good reasor for hoping that, as the Germans are grad ually transforming their inherited educa tional ystem into one ¢ le inife and rigid requirement o the people o the United States may evolve out of the as yet somewhat chaotic present condi- tions a system of popular instruction and education of their own, not yielding in thoroughne and efficiency o any, but 91 the fuller recognition of the many-sidedness of human the man and of leading to hu nature multiplicity of Virtue ways and happiness That Professor Miinsterberg {s contributing his generous share to the realization of such hope. nobody can effectually gainsay A. LaDEMAN YrstLantTr, Mien ‘ ar ) iv CHINE EXCLUSION To THE Epiror or Tur Nation Sir: One would think, to here unanimous in but I the judge by the that the favor of hewspaper out Pacific Chinese press whole Coast was exclusion, can assure you that such is The nuch in not the hands of case by any means fact Is, the hewspapers are pretty I the Typographical Union, and it is as much as their going to press is worth to print anything intmical to the so-called cause of Labor; this so called cause being nothing else than a concerted effort to raise the price of labor and arbitrarily prevent any one else fron cutting it This is legitimate enough it carried on on legitimate lines, but it show the assurance of its upholders when, as was actually the case the other day tn a con ference over a labor dispute, they actually have the face to claim from employers the recognition of unionism to the entire ex clusion of non-unionism, on the ground that the union enables them to raise wages! Sentiment from this quarter, like the sen timent of the consumer of high-protection articles, is not volced much; nevertheles there is much unspoken protest which will come to a point some day The salmon canners are at their wits’ end to get Chi nese labor, and the serious hampering of this industry is imminent Then, many farmers and land-owners would be glad to clear up and cultivate what is now wast land, but they cannot possibly do so on the basis of the “high standard of living that is demanded for the whole working class Last, but not least, the humble home-keeper lives in daily terror lest she find herself without help of any kind. Whit« help has always been ur but now Ch nese is just as much so, and unless an average good Chinese cook can get $35 or o per month, he clears out and goes el wher What is to be the result it is dificult to ee, but there is no question that the Coast is being very much kept back by tl searcity of ordinary labor and a large ized vote of thanks will be orthcomins to any agency in the E that will hely us to get a fair-sized dose of the “Yellow Peril W. J. B I One ‘ ' THE ALASKA BOU> ARY To & Ep THE N te) ~ [ j ~~ ot} ' that ger nen who opose to it t publ 0 t mear 1 f 0 i na nal re ha f nie h | t h i } tre nad hall q ) he P }¢« I Il gq g cla rt j ion ‘ t ain fr t | por i I AD | iu [ ‘ \ 1 ter signed Arthur Johnso
Page 16
92 The Nation. [Vol. 74, No. 1909 of St. Petersburg made in 1825 has been fully set forth by the writer in 1889; and more recently, from a study of the unpub- lished documents, the Hon. John W. Foster has given an account of the negotiations which led up to it, the object insisted upon by Russia and finally conceded by Great Britain, and other details. This statement has not been and cannot successfully be at- tacked on the score of accuracy and fair- ness. To this inquirers should be referred, as neither your space nor my time per- mits of an extended restatement here. The so-called ‘‘claims of Canada’ arose from the fact that the exclusion of Great Britain from the sea between Skagway and Port Simpson, which was the effect of the treaty, has become inconvenient to Canada now that the hinterland of the Northwest Territory is being developed. This led some ill-informed individuals to propose an interpretation of the treaty, aided by some obscurity in its terms, which interpretation, to obtain plausibility, re- quires (1) the total ignoring of the his- tory of the treaty, written and _ carto- graphic, and of the mutual action of the parties to it after it had been signed; (2) that, when the treaty says Portland Chan- nel, it must be assumed not to mean Port- land Channel; (3) that when the treaty purports to convey a continuous strip of coast (lisiére de céte) it must be assum- ed to mean broken patches of coast inter- rupted by foreign territory; (4) that when the treaty directs that a line shall follow the sinuosities of the coast (paralléle aur sinuosités de la céte) it shall be inter- preted as meaning that the line shall be drawn disregarding these sinuosities. What, we may ask, is the value of any treaty if it be subject to such interpre- tations? I believe I am correct in stating that the British Government has never officially adopted these propositions, though colonial politicians have used them for their own purposes; and, by constant reiter- ation, it is probable that many well-mean- ing but ill-informed persons may finally come to believe, in defiance of the real facts, that there is something reasonable and even equitable in these hypothetic in- terpretations. In addition to hypotheses, Mr. Johnson is guilty of direct error in several instances when it would be inferred he had the treaty before him. He says that a clause in the treaty ‘grants to Great Britain the right to ‘free navigation’ of all these in- lets,’’ and asks, “Of what use would thig be did she not own their upper reaches?” The truth is thatthe treaty grants this priv- tlege for a term of ten years. If she “owned the upper reaches’ of the inlets, she could hardly have been excluded from them at any time. With regard to the name Port- land Channel, or inlet, its history is short, definite, and precise, and the contrary as- sumption is utterly baseless, Its location and character were settled by Vancouver, who first mapped it, and have never been in doubt since. Mr. Johnson also states that there is a clause in the treaty ‘‘which ex- pressly denies prescriptive rights to either party.” This is untrue. The only clause which gives even a color of plausibility to such a statement is one in which the con- tracting parties agree not to make settle- ments in each other's territory. In pursu- ance of this, Russia made a settlement on one of the Gravina islands within a few miles of Portland Inlet and the British post of Fort Simpson, and her right to do so was never questioned. When the Hudson Bay Company tried to erect a post surreptitious- ly on Wrangell Island, they were ignomini- ously driven away by Russian naval forces. But, we are asked, why are you not will- ing to arbitrate this question if the case is so clear? In the first place, we may well wait until these preposterous hypotheses are officially adopted by Great Britain be- fore we consider arbitration as in question at all. Secondly, arbitration, unfortunately for the world’s peace, has not of late up- held the ideal character with which it was formerly endowed. The result of the Dela- goa Bay arbitration has been fitly de- scribed as an international scandal. The United States, secure in the possession of her rights, may well wait until they are at- tacked in good faith by more redoubtable adversaries than colonial Jingoes. Wm. H. DALL. WASHINGTON, January 27, 1902, PURCHASABLE FAME. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: I have just seen the representa- tive of a Boston firm engaged in the pub- lication of a so-called history of one of our universities. He wished me, as a graduate of the university in question, to furnish a sketch of my life and my photo- graph for reproduction, which, he repre- sented, would be highly desirable to the completeness of the work. The history is to be edited by two well-known graduates, and a long list assured me that many prom- inent graduates have already furnished similar biographical! material. It soon turned out, however, that I was to be in- cluded in the great work only if I sub- scribed to it in two volumes, at $15 each. The ‘‘scheme”’ is an old one, often used in the publication of county histories and the like, and it can be ‘‘worked’’ anywhere because the essential humanvanityis every- where present. The large scale on which it can be attempted is shown by the an- nouncement of a history of the “One Hun- dred and Fifty First Families of the Unit- ed States,’’ admission to which costs fif- teen hundred dollars. But it is humiliat- ing to find that such methods can be applied to one of our great universities. a mG, oP, Iruaca, N. Y., January 25, 1902. Notes. Dodd, Mead & Co. will shortly begin pub- lication of a new monthly magazine, the Bibliographer, edited by Paul Leicester Ford. It will be freely illustrated with photographic facsimiles of rare _ books, MSS., ete. During July, August, and Sep- tember the issue will regularly be suspend- ed. The same publishers announce the sec- ond volume of Austin Dobson’s ‘Miscel- lanies’; a new volume of Essays by Mau- rice Maeterlinck; the Autobiography of Sir Walter Besant; and ‘Paul Kelver,’ a tale by Jerome K. Jerome. Francis P. Harper will publish next month ‘The American Fur Trade and the Far West: A History of the Pioneer Trad- ing-Posts and Early Fur Companies of the Missouri Valley and the Rocky Mountains, and of the Overland Commerce with Santa Fé,’ by Capt. Hiram Martin Chittendex. Mr. Frank Stockton’s new novel, in the press of D. Appleton & Co., is entitled ‘Kate Bonnet: The Romance of a Pirate’s Daughter.’ Ginn & Co. will soon issue ‘Analytical Psychology,’ by Prof. Lightner Witmer, and ‘Northern Europe,’ in the Youth’s Com- panion series. ‘Melomaniacs,’ by James Huneker, and Paulsen’s ‘Immanuel Kant, his Life and Doctrine,’ translated by G. E. Creighton and Albert Lefevre, are promised by Charles Scribner’s Sons. The Dodge Publishing Co., No. 40 West Thirteenth Street, have nearly ready ‘Favo- rite Songs of Love,’ and ‘For Every Music Lover, or How to Know Music,’ by Auber- tine Woodward Moore. It is enough to say of ‘Who’s Who for 1902’ (Macmillan) that it is more inclusive of men and women of the time by 200 pages than last year’s issue—the present being the fifty-fourth. As is well known, this most convenient directory no longer confines itself to British or Anglo-Saxon person- ages, but has a universal outlook. Its main value, however, is still British above all. In the American portion we might have expected to find our two governors of dependencies, Gen. Leonard Wood and Gov. Taft. Mrs, Ady’s ‘Sacharissa’ has needed less than a decade to pass from its second to a third edition (E. P. Dutton & Co.). No revision has apparently been found neces- sary, and we shall add nothing to our com- ments on this work offered in 1894. It is handsomely made, and has four historic portraits, beginning with Dorothy Sidney herself, and ending with Algernon Sidney. Extremely attractive is the little two- volume edition of Bunyan’s ‘Pilgrim’s Pro- gress’ bearing George Newnes’s London im- print (New York: Scribners). The print is admirably clear, the binding in pliant leather; and Mr. Edmund J. Sullivan’s full- page pen designs are often ornamental and generally effective. In the pocket ‘“‘Temple Classics’’ of Dent- Macmillan we have now Perrault’s ‘Tales of Passed Times,’ with twelve illustra- tions by Charles Robinson, one in color. The series has been eked out from the Prince de Beaumont and from Mme. d’Aul- noy. Dr. Edward Everett Hale’s ‘In His Name’ has been translated into French by Mary Prince Sauveur, with the author’s sanc- tion (New York: William R. Jenkins), and is offered as a text-book for schools. Sir Richard Burton might well have pray- ed to be delivered from his friends. The process of publishing the rakings of his desk-drawers goes merrily on; it is called showing respect to his memory, and bring- ing home to his countrymen what they have lost in him. His memory stands fast, and will stand fast, and his work was well done when he died. But*the ‘‘literary ex- ecutors” continue their antics and refuse to let his ashes rest. If the custom spreads, the eighteenth-century Curll will have found successors, and his new terror added to death will be revived. This last instal- ment, ‘Wanderings in Three Continents,’ edited by W. H. Wilkins (Dodd, Mead & Co.), consists of some eight lectures and essays, descriptive, in a more or less popu-
Page 17
Jan. 30, 1902] lar fashion, of his principal expeditions, which were read before different geographi- cal and scientific societies. They contain nothing which is not more fully and pic- turesquely given in his previously published books. The latest of the Yale Bicentennial publi- cations consists of a series of critical and historical essays by members of the Theo- logical Faculty, originally read before the Semitic and Biblical Club (‘Biblical and Semitic Studies,’ Charles Scribner's Sons). These are average club papers. Among them is a radical article by Professor Cur- tis on the nature and origin of the tribes of Israel; others are on the growth and de- velopment of Israelitish law, oral and writ- ten, by Professors Kent and Sanders; on the Old Testament conception of sin as in- terpreted and developed in Rabbinic litera- ture, by Professor Porter; on the trans- figuration, with a good statement of dif- ferent theories as to it, by Dr. Moulton; on the argument of Stephen’s speech in Acts, by Professor Bacon. To these is added, somewhat incongruously, a translation by Professor Torrey of part of the ‘Futuh Misr’ of Ibn Abd al-Hakam, narrating the Mo- hammedan conquest of Egypt and North Africa. All of these papers do credit to Yale University, but no one stands out as a peculiarly significant contribution to its subject. It is to be hoped that Professor Torrey is preparing for publication a com- plete translation of Ibn Abd al-Hakam. ‘Old Times in Dixie Land,’ by Mrs. Caro- line E. Merrick (New York: The Grafton Press), is a discursive account of life in the Southern Confederacy during the war time, by a woman who was to the manor born, and who knew the alternations of pros- perity and poverty which constituted the unwritten tragedy of Southern life in those revolutionary days. The story is of varied interest and value. There are many pathe- tic scenes, and some personalities of origi- nal humor in its pages; and there are also frequent excursions into fields of family experience, and moralizings, which are of more concern to personal friends than to the reading public. “The New Mexico’’ is described in the National Geographic Magazine for January by Mr. John W. Foster, who has just been the guest of the nation. He contrasts the condition of isolation, bankruptcy, and so- cial disorder which prevailed in 1873, when he first went there as United States Min- ister, with its great prosperity in every respect under the wise and beneficent rule of President Diaz. Its railroad devel- opment, the improvement of its ports, the great canal by which the valley of Mexico is drained, the finances, foreign relations, and commerce are particularly dwelt upon. Mr. only lightly upon a most important part of his subject, the in- nearly Foster touches creasing absorption by citizens of this country of the various manufactures and tracts of refer of large Nor mining industries, and the most fertile land. to the growth of an anti-foreign sentiment, which recent visitors have noticed, and which they hold to future. A number of interesting illustra- accompany the We remark also a Map of Signal-Corps Telegraph Lines and Cables” in the Phil- hamlet the does he other be ominous of the tions article, “Progress ippines, on which is every town or known by the War Department. Jesuits or reported to No better proof of the The Nation. activity of the officials of the Signal Office is needed than the fact that, in three years, 7,000 miles of wire has been strung in the islands, penetrating into nearly all corners of the archipelago. The Geographical Journal for January opens with an account of the Uganda pro- tectorate, by Sir Harry Johnston, in which there is much information as to the scat- tered native races, their origin and lan- guage Among some of these occur curi- ously varied human types, as, for instance, in the same cluster of Andorobo there will little black side with handsome youths Sir Harry of part of the lake innumerable look like a belt which on its outer side is gray- be “hideous prognathous 7 dwarfs side by of almost European features."’ the great especially of the the haunt of ‘Seen from awells on beauty land, Hannington, and mountain flamingoes. above, they white, then becomes white in the middle, inner ring of the The for this is that all the birds on the outer edge of the are the young in their imma- plumage, those in the middle of the belt are full-grown birds that have not ac- quired the full beauty of the adult, while along the inner edge are old birds in the full beauty of a plumage which ranges from and possesses an most exquisite rose tint. reason semicircle ture pale blush-pink to scarlet crimson.’’ In his description of the exploration of the Ru- wenzori range of snow-mountains, there is a useful summary of the vegetation, in which remarkable feet eighteen are some features, as lobelias twenty and more in height, thick on tree trunks at a height of 12,000 feet. The Rev. Dr. Zwemer tells of three journeys in north- ern Oman in Arabia, in which he refers to and mosses inches the great civilizing influence of British trade on the fanatical inhabitants of the so- culled Pirate Coast With but a_ single companion he traversed the coast and cressed the peninsula, being received every- where with genial hospitality. Col. G. E. Church gives a summary of an exploration of the Paraguay, made by t Government to determine whether it offers a navigable route to the Atlantic. There little doubt that steamers drawing three feet of water can ascend the river at all seasons to the Bo- upper Bolivian order of seems livian frontier. The easiest and most di- rect route, however, is by the Amazon, Which Col. Church thinks will eventually take to foreign markets the wonderful nat- ural wealth of the heart of South America Among the illustrations of this number are some cinematograph pictures of the Severn Dr. Cornish numerous bore, taken by Vaughan An interesting discovery is announced by Prof. F. R. von Petermann’'s Witteilungen, number 12, of a copy of Martin Waldseemiiller’s the Wieser, in world-chart of America 1507 in which name is first given to the Western Hemisphere, together with a copy of his Carta Marina of 1517, in a pri- vate library in Wirtemberg. After scribing the charts, of which he is about to publish facsimiles, Prof. von Wieser la- ments that de- Waldseemiiller’s true claim to fame, “the extraordinarily widespread and permanent chart of 1507 upon the development of the true concep- tion of the world’s form,”’ influence of his should have been by this mere upon the “relict so completely overshadowed Other Lake name-giving. articles are question, Is Tanganyika a 93 sea’’? upon Baratta's earthquake map of Italy, and an inquiry as to the distance at which land A large the termed is visible at sea convention of the directors of so-called “‘Reform”" gymnasiums, also the tem, held in Cassel, was a revelation of the “Frankfort and Altona” sys this movement in the The lk schools is their “lateinloser also the strength of German educational world ading character istic of these Unterbau,”” and innovation that ingle Eighty-four institutions wer fewer studies are taken in a year and these finished if possible these present, of which there are now thirty-sevy representatives of en scattered over Germany established new ones being The has been able to compel recognition on all hands At the Phi lological Convention, the Rector of the plo this kind excellent impres every year new scheme Strassburg National neer institution of (that at Frankfort) made an sion by his dispassionate presentation of the “Reform” principles At the Cassel meet ing the Government was for the first time officially represented. The movement has evidently become a fixed fact in secondary school discipline in Germany Modesty almost restrains us from men tioning an article in the London Publishers Circular of January 11, very flattering to the Nation as a journal of the cla to which it belongs The praise, however, both precedes and follows a reproach of “anti-English bias’’ on the political side seemingly not without some reference to our indisposition to approve of the war it South Africa. This bias, moreover, is de tected in our recent review (No. 1904) of Miss Meakin's ‘Ribbon of Iron’—an a count of the Siberian Railway-—in which we alleged aggression on the part of the Chi nese in the outbreak at Blagovestchensk on July 14, 1900, for which they suffered so nzied Rus Publishers hands of the fr terribly at the But the might sians. editor of the Circular have read a similar state in the letter of our special corre Prof. G. Frederick Wright of published in the ment pon dent, Oberlin Nation of September 2 1900, who came the scene when th sill did the ed the peaceful and upon Amur “fairly black’’ with Chine bodies He committed by was slaughter he de harmonious not j istify the Russians, but crit relation existing between the Cossacks and the Chi nese up to the moment when the Chinese fort at Aygun “began, without warning, to fire upon passing steamboats and pre ently on Blagovestchensk itself; and con tended that every appearance argued against Russian intention to disturb the relations Following his series of Mr. Hart jury a presentation of Stuart's portrait portrai men, begins in the February (Ce has chosen for a beginning the portrait of Wa Philadelphia men He painted by Stuart ia William Senator from Pennsylvania from 1795 to 184i Although from it, Mr each hington 1795. for singham made some half-dozeu Hart intentional Stuart copies points out th these show some variaticr leaving the original a distinct type, as con pared with the commonly known “Stuart Washington.”’ In the paper following M: Hart’s, and describing a visit to Mount Vernon by the Niemcewicz t Is to find the diary a conversation Polish peet Pole with recording ‘in hi Mrs. Washingtos interesting
Page 18
[Vol. 74, No. 1909 = on “the small likeness that there is between the General and his portraits.’’ Mr. Daniel H Burnham of the Commission for the Im- provement of Washington city introduces briefly a series of papers on the past and prospective improvements of the capital, giving high credit to the Columbian Expo- sition for teaching the country the great truth of the need of a comprehensive de- sign and plan for the improvement of cities in their entirety. The first paper is by Charles Moore, clerk of the Senate Com- mittee on the District of Columbia, and its most promising feature is its evidence of the growing tendency of officials in power to do nothing involving the improvement of the city, except on consultation with the com- mission of experts authorized a year ago, consisting of Daniel H. Burnham, Charles F. McKim, Augustus St. Gaudens, and Fred- erick Law Olmsted, jr. The tendency to civic improvements elsewhere is represented by papers on the recent alterations in the Chicago River and on the Cathedral of St. John the Divine, in New York. The first subject is treated from the standpoint of utility rather than beauty, but the sary results of Chicago’s new drainage sys- tem have removed such a mass of positive ugliness that the contrast may almost de- ceive one into regarding the present condi- tion as one of positive beauty. neces- —While the Century gives particular at- tention to the contemplated improvements in the Federal] capital, Francis E. Leupp contributes to NScribner’s a glowing tribute to the picturesque character of the city as it is. He has not only thoroughly ‘‘covered the ground,’ but has even witnessed a Washington sunrise from the summit of the Monument, and his paper is certainly convincing as to the wealth of fragmentary beauty which the new Park Commission is to weld into a harmonious whole. William Jarvis gives a brief account of the young sculptor Paul Troubetzkoy, whose work has attracted much attention during the past decade. The question as to what nation deserves the credit of his work is of con- He was born at Intra, Lago Maggiore, of a Russian father and an American claimed by the Italians, though he has no Italian blood and his characteristics as an artist do not link him with any Italian sculptor. Still further in the line of art, Russell Sturgis gives a brief description of the collection of etchings, lithographs, photographs of paint- ings and drawings, and miscellaneous prints recently presented to the New York Pub- siderable interest. mother, and is lic Library by Samuel Putnam Avery—in all, 17,775 separate prints, and about 500 books. Important papers of immediate pub- lic interest are Mr. Vanderlip’s second arti- cle on “Commercial Invasion’’ of Eu- rope, and a twenty-five-page article on the proposed Isthmian Ship-Canal, profusely illustrated, by William H. Burr of the Ca- nal Commission. our Though there may be differences of among and as to the value of a particular interpreta- of history, both that activities exceedingly important part in shaping national policy. The most significant example in recent years of how opinion economists historians tion agree economic play an an economic change can affect great nation- al interests is to be found in the develop- ment of synthetic indigo. In Neience (Janu- ary 3) is to be found an account of a paper The Nation. read by Arthur C. Green before the Chem- ical Section of the British Association, at the Glasgow meeting, last summer. Mr. Green gives an accurate account of the present status of the coal-tar industry, and incidentally of the whole chemical] industry, which is of interest to us in view of the new trade relations of Germany and the United States. Artificial indigo first saw the light of day as far back as 1870, though the synthesis was really completed only in 1878. For a score of years synthetic indigo was simply a laboratory curiosity; but in 1898, the Badische Anilin und Soda Fabrik brought it on the market, and it was a com- mercial fact. To-day, Germany has control of the English color industry, is no longer dependent upon England for raw material, and threatens the natural indigo industry, whose destruction would mean a loss to In- dia of nearly $15,000,000 annually. The Baden company alone can produce enough artificial indigo to supply the world’s con- sumption. —-The Indian planters have only begun to bestir themselves. Against the prevailing low prices the only suggestion had been to increase the output; but now they are talk- ing of encouragement to scientific research, and appealing to the Government of Bengal for aid. Some have gone so far as to sug- gest ‘“‘Americanizing’”’ the industry by com- bining the interests in Behar and even in the whole of India. But the army of re- search chemists engaged in the splendid laboratories of the European coal-tar color factories have a great start on the one or two chemists studying the means of im- proving the cultivation and manufacture of natural indigo. While scientific methods may be applied to the cultivation and ex- traction of the indigo-plant, the ever-deli- cate financial relations of the great de- pendency and the United Kingdom will be subjected to an additional strain. Mr. Green is convinced that a scientific revival is wanted in England, and that the gloomy condition of the color industry is due to the short-sightedness, ignorance, and want of enterprise of the English manufacturer. The control of the industry has passed into the hands of men who have no knowledge and absolutely no appreciation of thescience upon which their business rests, and, con- cerned only with getting the ultimate amount of present profit, have discouraged all scientific investigations as waste of time and money. Speaking of the establishmenf of technica] schools, Mr. Green is not very confident of their “until the public can be completely disabused of the that a two of technical pumped school- effectiveness fallacy training into an ignorant boy will produce a better works-chemist than a university course of scientific study laid upon the foundation of a good general education.” year or -Menelik et Nous,’ by Hugues Le Roux (Paris: Lamm), was written at the request of the Negus, who invited the French au- thor to visit Addis-Ababa, and to prepare a volume on Abyssinia after a journey from one end of it to the other accompanied by a small troop of Abyssinians selected from the Emperor's best soldiers to act as guides and Roux relates his exper!- ences as political envoy, his observations as an explorer and discoverer of new re- gions from a geographical and commercial standpoint, his experiences as a _ hunter, escort. Le and his sensations as a romancier. -The book is illustrated from photographs taken by himself on the journey. It is d!vid- ed into five parts: ‘‘The Cross-roads of Aden,” ‘The Route to Addis-Ababa,” “Guest of the Emperor,” ‘‘Toward the Blue Nile,” ‘France and Abyssinia.” It de- scribes various audiences, both public and private, with Menelik, gives accounts of life and customs among all classes in Abys- sinia, and reports the expedition to a hith- erto unexplored part of the Blue Nile, whose course Mr. Le Roux was able to de- termine definitely. The fifty-two days of caravan were enlivened by elephant hunts, the pursuit of lions, leopards, rhinoceroses, and hippopotamuses, and a _ brusque en- counter with the most savage negroes of Africa. As M. Le Roux was given permis- sion by Menelik to visit the gold mines an@ placers of the west, his caravan was join- ed on its way by gold-seekers. Two of these were seized and cut to pieces by the Shankallas, whose chiefs the French ex- plorer led in captivity to the Emperor. The book contains a definite statement of the mining and agricultural resources of Abys- sinia, and it closes with these words con- cerning the future: “It is no prophecy that I place at the end of this volume, but a logical conclusion drawn from facts I have myself observed. Before a railroad is com- pleted from Caire to the Cape—a highway of ambition and conquest across Africa~ there will be a great commercial route or- fered to the kindly activity of all. From the cross-roads of the Red Sea, its tri- umphal course will have been opened by Menelik and us.”’ —In view of the recent death of the Amir of Afghanistan and the political situation which has now developed, the republication of Dr. J. A. Gray’s ‘At the Court of the Amir: A Narrative’ (Macmillan Co.) is certainly timely. Dr. Gray was surgeon to the Amir for some years, and gives in his book a very vivid account of his experiences and impressions at the Afghan court. In it he has used the letters which he had writ- ten home, and has made, apparently, little change in them or addition to them. As a consequence, his book has the liveli- ness of epistolary first-hand, snapshot ef- fects, but has also many trivialities and some most exasperating lacunas. It is evi- dent that Dr. Gray made no systematic at- tempt to study and understand the Afghans or to enter into their life. He was always dependent upon an interpreter, and to that his troubles, which were many, seem to have been almost entirely due. He was also of a phenomenal uncuriousness when he met anything that he did not at once understand: “I don’t know why,” occurs again and again. Yet, with all that, the picture which he gives us is of an insistent truthfulness. If he was not a trained Orientalist and could never possibly have become one, he was a trained physician, and saw everything with the precise physi- cian’s eye. He had, too, a liking for the registering of little details, and these are so accurate that it is possible for the student of the East to reconstruct from them mat- ters of which Dr. Gray himself, in all prob- ability, never dreamed. On himself and the happenings of his life he lavishes a minute- ness and liking which have the true Bos- wellian charm. The humors of the mediciner-at-large in partibus infidelium
Page 19
30, 1902] yan were always present with him; he enjoy- ed them to the full, and his reader cannot help enjoying them with him. The gusto with which he describes makeshift opera- tions and terrific doses is irrepressible. He is evidently a man of great resource and a skilled and experienced physician, and so can afford to tell tales of his own mishaps and failures. His book is taining in the highest degree and more than entertaining; but the pity is that he could enter- never bring himself to learn Persian, and so shake free of the whole rabble of interpreters, backbiters, and spies. If he had, the Amir might have been alive to-day, and the Central Asian crisis further in the future. —Tadamasa Hayashi was the Commis- sary-General for the Empire of Japan at the Paris Exposition of 1900. He is to be confounded with the Baron Tadasu Hayashi, who is Minister from Japan to Great Britain; nor yet with Toshio Hayashi, also residing in London. He was the founder of a Paris importing house which, in the hands of his successors, has done much to acquaint Europe with the higher and less- known arts of ancient Japan; but it is some years since he has been actively en- gaged in that commercial served him, however, to form a great col- lection of Japanese art treasures; and it was under his direction that was prepared a great folio dealing less with what shown within the Japanese enclosures of the Exhibition than with the whole field of Japanese cultivation and Japanese thought, as embodied in their plastic and graphic arts. It is, of course, in this book that any Oriental or non-European nation has spoken its mind as to its own fine art in any such way that the West could un- derstand it. Here, in French, is set forth the view which able and highly instructed Japanese take of their national arts for a period of 1,200 years or more. Its pages are thickly sown with text il- lustrations, and there are, in addition, about not enterprise. It was alone decent eighty full-page plates, some containing two and some a greater number of sep- arate pieces of fine art. <A note to the reader is signed by Mr. Hayashi; and the preface, signed by the Director-General of the Imperial Museums of Japan, Baron Riyuitci Kuki, announces that a man known to European students of the East, Kakuzo Okakura, first planned the work, and that he, abandoning it, turned it over to others, whose names are given in detail; also, that the translation into French has been done by Emmanuel Tranquois. This is a book of permanent rank, a book of reference to which we shall go as to the founda- tions of anything to be written hereafter on Oriental art. It will be interesting, as time is afforded, to compare the statements of this work with the disagreements among Western writers as to the epoch and as to the relative importance of this and that branch of Japanese fine art. —In addition to the above-named book, now a year old, we will mention a first vol- ume or first part of an illustrated catalogue describing the collection of Hayashi’s collection, which it that he is going to sell the part of it Tadamasa appears (or at least represented by this volume) at auction, in Paris, at the close of the month. Its nature is, of course, that of a full and very intelligent present
The Nation. sale-catalogue, with minute descriptions of the pieces exhibited, and, so far, it would have but a limited interest to those who have not the pieces before them. It con- tains, however, a photo- graphic plates, representing so many pieces of Japanese art, and of so many different kinds, that these, taken with the full de- scriptions of the text, find and to compare, will serve as a handbook for the beginner and as a check to the opinions and the conclusions of the more advanced stu- dent. Another volume the lection of announced, but no nor large number of easy to covering col- illustrated books is date for its for the sale of those objects. is set appearance, FURNESS’S TWELFTH NIGHT. A New Edition of Edited by Horace Howard Furness. Variorum Shakspere Vol XIII. Twelfth Night. Philadelphia: Lippincott. The thirteenth volume of Dr. Furness’s great Variorum lies before us, and a de- lightful book it is. “Twelfth Night,”’ to be sure, is “good enough without notes,’’ but notes are necessary evils, and the history of Sbkaksperian annotation has almost become must have, and Shakspere grammars and lexicons, ‘metric’; to join the cry of those who jeer at commen- a specialty by itself. Variorums we ard treatises on nor are we ready tators. The dullest of them may stumble upon an idea, and there is still much in these dramas which resists explanation When the whole body of pertinent and im- pertinent scholia is collected and sifted and set forth by ascholar of Dr. Furness’s learn- ing and accomplishments, it might seem only becoming to accept the gift in reverential gratitude, acknowledge it courteously, and Say no more. But every fresh volume of this series tempts to extended comment. The mere toil of the editor, prodigious as ic is, is the smallest part of the wonder. The skill with which he arranges his un- wieldy material seems to increase with every year, and still rever flag. The present volume is not mere- ly a record of what or failed to more admirable his spirits his predecessors have full their done, do; it is of origina! contributions, varying in value with the circumstances, but joyous to read, and instinct with the Shakspere. Clearly it been a stant delight to Dr. Furness to edit “Twelfth Night,’’ and he permits his readers to share We are in the uncommon phenomenon—a Variorum exhilarates. Dr. his gentle scorn for keenest appreciation of has con- his pleasure. presence of an that Furness is resolutely consistent in de- termine the dates of Shakspere’s plays. All of his prefaces give utterance to “We who have free those who care to or most this feeling. souls,’’ he says, “and, as far as the plays themselves are concerned, care as little for the hour when Shakspere wrote them as for the quality of his ink... .’’ This is going pretty far. But, after all, tke italicized imply a the extreme position. themselves words that we have virtual abandonment of “As far as the plays quotha? Let individual play,”’ and one may give (craftily qualified) assent. We have all been worried by those Shaksperian are concerned,” it read ‘‘as far as the chronologists who insist on times and sea sons to the exclusion of everything else will who not suffer us to read ‘‘Hamlet”’ or
95 “Henry IV."" without obtruding upon us a cumbrous machinery of groups and periods Yet surely it is also admissible to contem as the work of Shakspere no less than as hisworks; and for such the dates isindispensable. Dr plate the dramas as a kind of whole study consideration of Furness apologizes for the repetition necessitated by his plan of making each volume complete in itself it is not to be avoided, for the most part, but no one would object to his omitting, in sub- sequent volumes, this particular bit of per- There trine in Romans xiv. 23 to sacrificial scruples The text of “Twelfth Night” is unusually free from corruption. So indeed, that Dr. the duty of registering quarto variants, draws a long breath, and express sonal opinion. is good sound doec- and it limite! is not accurate {s it, Furness, discharged from countless es his satisfaction at the absence of all au thorities save the First Folio. On occasion we adverted to the {Increas this matter of text, that has marked successive volumes of the “Othello,” published abandoned his plan text, and reprinted the Folio letter for letter, eloquently justify- ing his procedure in his preface. Since the apparatus criticus is the reader’s eye, and since the editor express- doubtful reading occurs, no objection can be urged to his method, and it another have ing conservatism, in ‘New Variorum.’ In in 1886, Dr. of constituting a Furness always before es his own opinion whenever a has obvious advan- tages for such an edition Oceasionally, however, Dr. Furness carries his respect for the venerable too far, and defends a manifest error. In the present volume though there is the that ters fling at showing still a prefatory delicately put, but he regards them as vicious intromit quartos, we detect a slightly lessened regard the healthy reactioa a too The druldiec mist that enshrouds the “true original cop Condell’s for Folio, in from exclusive reverence. ig and multitude of ies’ of Heminge title-page their Folio worship is a form of religion that is not quite free from superstitious taint. Among the Baconians, indeed, it a kind of melancholy madness The care which Dr. Furness has be on the text, despite the fact that he chosen to reprint the Folio, is shown in a striking example is Capell’'s “excellent excellent Indeed, and too covers a sins has grown to be towed has thousand places. A commendation of (p. 168) seldom heeded; his comma” Dr. Furness isthe first editor to do justice to Capell. He even emendations himself. A tempting one is the 171) Toby to Sir Andrew, whose ‘weak treble suggests transference of a speech (p from Sir one seems to recognize—‘‘and yet we know not.”’ On the other hand, a subtle but in- conclusive defence of the Follo may be seen 186, where it and not. Another instance faith in the Folio is the “with adorations, fertile tears” as a plete with an worked doctrine of the ‘‘pause at p is a question oetweesa and of exces sive defence of com- verse, appeal to tae over- that makes up to the ear for the loss of a metric foot.’ Whatever may be said of this doctrin: in the main, the present passage, with its lyrical richness, is no place for its appli- cation. Pope's emendation “wth fertile tears” is not only a metrical necessity; {ft is stylistically will keep inevitable and its place in defiance of even Dr. Furn: ‘ persuasive note. On the other hand, Theo
Page 20
The Nation. [Vol. 74, No. 1909 96 bald’s unnecessary (though not improbable) emendation of out for on’t (p. 232) is ap- proved as something ‘‘demanded.” It is hard indeed to hold the balance in such cases. Be it remembered, however, that in general Dr. Furness has an uncommonly steacy hand. Some of the editor’s remarks are ex- tremely subtle. ‘‘Unless the master were the man” (p. 92) gives occasion to one of these, which is so pretty that we dismiss it with great reluctance in favor of the more obvious interpretation. A felicitous gloss, and certainly correct, is that on “sives a very echo to the seat where love is thron’d’”’ (p. 138). Per contra, the point of Sir Andrew's “Jezebel,” applied to Mal- volio, is lost (p. 161). For reader, 1n the last line of the notes but one, read writer. This is not a misprint, but an injustice; let it be rectified, if the heavens fall or the plates have to be cut. Now and then, Dr. Furness’s humor will puzzle foreigners, whu may take it in dead earnest—as where he says that ‘“‘firago seems far more expressive than the tame virago; there is in it a sug- gestion of fire, fury, fiend, ferocious, all combined” (p. 240). It is impossible to criticise the work in detail, nor is such criticism required. A few matters in which we disagree with the editor, or in which we detect slight omis- sions, may now be specified. Most of them trifles, and, were they all important, they would count for nothing in compari- son with the excellence of the whole. Sir Toby's song, “‘O the twelfe day of Decem- ber,” is still left unidentified. Is it not, in all probability, the historical ballad of ‘‘Musselburgh Field,’”’ preserved in the Per- cy MS., and beginning— are “On the tenth day of December, And the fourth yeere of King Edwards raigne’’? In the note on ay-word and nay-word (p. 129) we miss a reference to Dr. C. P. G. Scott’s admirable monograph. The miss is more seriously felt in the case of cockney (p. 251). (p. 152) which re- stricts to poisoners the punishment of boil- ing to death, is quoted with approval, but there is much lore on the subject collected by Robertson in his ‘Mate- rials for the History of Thomas Becket.’ On “Jolly Robin” (p. 266) a quotation from Chaucer's ‘Troilus’? would have been in or- der, and a reference to Professor Fitigel’s ‘Neuenglisches Lesebuch’ would have clear- ed up the subject still farther. It is not quite certain that jig is from giga, ‘“‘a sort of fiddle’ (p. 51). “But in its orig- inal meaning, namely, out-take, or except” (p. 77) seems to Imply a misapprehension of the history of the word, but the refer- ence to Abbott's ‘Shakespcarean Grammar’ Grey's note it is incomplete; mends matters. How a, for he, could be “reduced to a mere aspirate” 1s not quite obvious (p. 77). The suggestion that to “our American minds” a squash ‘‘can be only a large melon” will certainly disturb Dr. agricultural readers. Boys who steal squashes thinking them melons Furness's are immemorial objects of rural wit. Is “a dry jest’ a “stupid” one (p. 42)? Hard- ly; any more than “a dry blow” is a dull stroke. At p, 62 a reference would -have been in place: ‘Montaigne has two stories” is pretty vague. We venture to doubt the supposed pun on collars and colors (p. 61), with “of course” by no less an authority than Dr. Aldis Wright and backed with a reference by Dr. fur- though asserted ness. One wonders to see the editor ob- jecting tautology to the usual and inevi- table explanation of‘‘Good my mouse of vir- tue’’ (p. 68)—as if idiom and humor shud- dered at tautology (a word to conjure with!). Dr. Furness’s perception of Shak- spere’s humor is extremely delicate, but here it seems to be at fault. One passage, which Dr. Furness calls ‘dark,’ is not hard: “Words are very rascals since bonds disgraced them.” In the old days, a man’s word was as good as his bond—or, rather, a word was sufficient, and hence bonds were never heard of. The introduction of bonds, then, was a plain discrediting of words. It is odd that Dr. Furness should have missed this; the notes that he prints are truly, as he himself declares, far from illuminat- ing, and his own suggestion will hardly meet with acceptance. But enough of this. It is small business and may seem ungracious. We yield to none in our admiration for Dr. Furnesss achievement. Our ‘‘excepts before except- ed’’ must be taken merely as a proof of the interest with which we have read the vol- ume. May there soon be another! SOUTH CAROLINA IN THE REVOLU- TION. The History of South Carolina in the Revolution, 1775-1780. By Edward Mc- Crady. Macmillan. 1901. Pp. xxxiii, 899. The third volume of Mr. McCrady’s elab- orate history, our notice of which has been far too long delayed, is chiefly remarkable, aside from its detailed account of military operations, for its exposition of the atti- tude of South Carolina towards the mother country during the Revolution, and of the slow and reluctant growth of the idea of in- dependence. To the majority of South Caro- linians, vigorous resistance to the course of Great Britain not only did not mean political separation, but did not for a long time preciude the possibility of reconcilia- tion. The ‘‘Association’’ organized by the Provincial Congress in June, 1775, became practically a revolutionary Government, and, through a system of committees with indefinite powers, began an aggressive en- forcement of the agreement. The address of the Congress to the new Governor, Lord William Campbell, a few days later, de- ciared the desire of the people for reconciliation, though preparations for milli, tary defence continued, and consignments of powder were seized. But the power of the general committee to punish non-sub- scribers to the Association ‘‘according to sound policy’’ was soon arbitrarily exer- cised, with the result of replacing the des- potism of King and Parliament by the despotism of a self-appointed committee, representing but a small fraction of the people of the province, with no support in the interior, and with the opposition of many of the most prominent and influential men of Charleston and the low country. The Council itself was divided into mod- erates and extremists, the one hopeful of reconciliation, the other bent upon war. The Germans in the interior, with little knowledge of the merits or facts of the dispute with England, living a freer life than they had ever enjoyed before, and, having no use for either stamps or tea, were not disposed to join the Revolution- ary party; and the same sentiment obtained among the Scotch Presbyterians. The mer- chants and planters in Charleston were as a rule opposed to war. But although the grievances of South Carolina were differ- ent in character from those of Massachu- setts, and different, also, in onerousness, the radical leaders, like Drayton, Middle- ton, and Gadsden, pushed with vigor and address the advantage already gained, took possession of the political machinery, and did their utmost to force the colony into war. In September the Governor, whose prompt action at the beginning might have defeated the movement, withdrew to a sioop-of-war in the harbor, provincial troops took possession of Fort Johnson, and Charleston was fortified. How far the movement was from representing any majority of opinion was shown by the nu- merous acts of violence perpetrated by the Revolutionary party, and the narrow ma- jorities by which its measures were pass- ed. A military demonstration in the back-country brought on, in November, the first bloodshed, and the opposition in that section was ruthlessly put down. The same general feeling of regard for England which denied popular support to these proceedings, made the idea of inde- pendence also of slow growth. When Gads- den declared for it, in February, 1776, the declaration came, as Drayton expressed it later, like an explosion of thunder to the members of the Provincial Congress who heard it, and called forth a warm reproof from John Rutledge, who asserted his will- ingness ‘‘to ride post by day and night to Philadelphia, to assist in reuniting Great Britain and America” (p. 109). Even the resolution for the establishment of an in- dependent government was carried by a House in which less than two-fifths of the members, apparently, were present, while the fact that the proposed government did not represent the whole province, but only the low country, made its influence di- visive. The choice of John Rutledge for President—as the official who replaced the old Governor was now to be called—was most fortunate, his natural conservatism and firm stand against separation from Eng- land enabling him to act as a bulwark for the people against the precipitate conduct of the radical leaders. A little later, Chief Justice Drayton, in his charge to the grand jury at Charleston, followed Gadsden’s ex- ample, and declared for independence, but neither his indictment of Great Britain nor his argument in support of it was such as to appeal strongly to the people of South Carolina. In his bill of grievances, as Mr. McCrady says: “There was nothing which particularly affected their colony but the general charge that Parliament claimed the right to bind the colonies in all cases whatsoever. And in regard to this, no one in South Carolina, not even Gadsden, had ever denied its right to bind them, except in the matter of tax- ation. Then, in the matter of tax- ation, it was open to the friends of the royal Government to refer the Chief Justice to his own Letters of Freemen, in 1769, in which he had strenuously maintain-: ed this right of Parliament in that particu- lar. . . . It is singular, too, that, in justifying the great step, the Chief Justice does not allude to the real grievances of this colony. He does not point out how the native colonists had been superseded and set aside by the officials of the Board of Trade for the placemen who hung around the throne for recognition and reward for questionable service rendered. He does not point out to the people of the Up Country
Page 21
Jan. 30, 1902] The Nation. 97 that it was the wilful neglect and corrupt conduct of that Board in England which had deprived them of courts for the pun- ishment of crime and the maintenance of justice. In the stead of al} this, he appeals to them to declare themselves in- dependent of England because New Eng- land’s fishing trade had been interfered with, and because the Legislature of New York had been suspended, the charter of Massachusetts altered, and the Roman Catholic religion recognized in Quebec. But what had the Scotch-Irish Presbyterians who, with the Bible containing their own version of the Psalms, were enjoying the liberty of conscience in the country they were wresting from the Indians, to do with all that? Were they, for the sake of the New England fishermen and the Canadian Protestants, to go into a war and expose themselves to the inroads of the Indians, and to set up a government on the coast which was not yet prepared to abandon the Church of England as a church of State? ; The Chief Justice had nothing to say to the people of the Up Country, ex- plaining why they should fight for repre- sentation in the Parliament in England at the bidding of a body in which they had had no representation at home” (pp. 119-122). With South Carolina, as with the country at large, it was the logic of events rather than of argument that urged the colonies to independence. Yet even here the re- luctance of South Carolina was strikingly exhibited. The representatives of the State in Congress signed the Declaration “with grave misgivings” (p. 175). Not until July 9 did they write to President Rutledge, and even then they referred to the matter only incidentally. Their reluctance but reflected the hesitation and uncertainty at home, where there were few families in the low country but were divided on the question. The same reluctance to admit independence as final, while still resisting the coercive policy of the Crown, was strong in 1778, when the terms offered by the peace com- missioners would, Mr. McCrady thinks, have been gladly accepted by a majority of the people of the State. Upon the rejection by Congress of the offer of conciliation, and the departure of the commissioners in November, 1778, the British moved upon the South. The flour- ishing trade of South Carolina and Georgia favored by the interval of peace, the active commerce with France and consequent op- position to the French alliance, the im- portance of Charleston as ‘‘the storehouse of merchandise and the retreat of priva- teers,’”’ combined to make these States an inviting object of attack, while the re- moteness of the region from the previous centre of hostilities, and in particular the defenceless condition of Georgia, promised an easy victory. The military operations that followed are traced by Mr. McCrady in great detail and with not a little adverse criticism. He points out that, from the beginning of the war, the prevailing mili- tary theory had intrusted the defence of the country to a regular army, notwith- standing that a regular army was one of the institutions which the colonies generally feared; and the consequent neglect of the militia left without defence any section in which a_ sufficient force of Continental troops could not be maintained. Moreover, although the regular army was open to all who would probably have served in the militia—a point to which we think Mr. Mc- Crady does not give sufficient weight—the service soon deteriorated, and the ranks came to be mainly filled, not with patriots such as those who fought at Bunker Hill, but with hired soldiers who fought for pay, and who often served as readily under British as under American commanders. Mr. McCrady has no condemnation for Washington, but he points out that when, in May, 1779, Washington declared to Gouverneur Morris his inability to respond to calls for help from ‘particular States” without sacrificing ‘‘the most obvious prin- ciples of military prosperity,’’ South Car- olina was left to take care of itself; and it did in fact meet the British attack mainly with its own forces. The conspicuous fact about the British operations in South Carolina was their suc- cess. The sentiment of Charleston was shown during the first siege, when it sought neutrality for the remainder of the war. The capture of the town was shortly fol- lowed by the submission of virtually the entire State. In June, 1780, “there was not a Continental officer or soldier in the fieid.” Clinton wrote to Lord George Germain, “I may venture to assert that there are few men in South Carolina who are not either our prisoners or in arms with us’ (p. 533). The revolutionary party was broken up, and only John Rutledge remained, clothed with full powers to keep alive, if only in his own person, the State Government. ‘There can be little doubt,’ says Mr. McCrady, “that at this time wise rulers might, with care and moderation, have reéstablished the royal authority,’ and reconciled South Carolina to the Crown (p. 535). The widespread belief “that in order to secure the independence of the others Con- gress had determined to. sacrifice the Southern States,’’ was a further powerful inducement to submission. Mr. McCrady seems to be convinced that the belief was well founded, and that the resolution of Congress denouncing the report as “‘insid- ious and utterly void of foundation” was a case of protesting too much; and he fur- ther adduces the testimony of Luzerne and Duane. The time was unquestionably a critical one, but the conduct of Clinton, Cornwallis, and Lord Rawdon proved ulti- mately to be the salvation of the Union so far as the South was concerned. When Clinton, in June, 1780, issued his proclama- tion, restoring to all the rights and duties of citizens and inhabitants such of the peo- ple of the province as were prisoners on parole, but declaring that all such persons “who should afterward neglect to return to their allegiance and a due submission to his Majesty’s Government should be consid- ered as enemies and rebels to the same, and be treated accordingly” (p. 554), he fixed the turning-point in the contest. The cruelties of Tarleton and the outrageous conduct of the British troops were not easily to be forgotten, while the attack upon the Scotch-Irish, who heretofore had taken no active part in the war, “converted the neutrals in the State into im- placable enemies.” And, with the war spir- it no longer confined to a class, but ani- mating the whole people, the “heroic pe- riod,’”’ as Mr. McCrady calls it, began. We have no space to follow Mr. McCrady through the four hundred pages in which he traces, with minute detail, the first months of the partisan warfare that ensued. No other writer has examined this phase of the Revolution with such painstaking care, or shown so clearly the place in the struggle of the new leaders who come upon the field. The narrative ends with 1780, the remaining years of the Revolutionary period being re- served for a fourth volume. The emphasis which is put in the present volume on the services of Marion, Sumter, and the other popular military leaders, and the intima tion in the closing paragraph that treatment of Greene's career will not be en tirely in the spirit of eulogy, that the remainder of the story which Mr McCrady is telling with such success may soon be made public the makes us hope spirit and THE MUSICAL BASIS OF VERSE The Musical Basis of Verse. By J. P ney. Longmans, Green & Co. Dab The title of this book is somewhat mis leading; we expect to read a succinct mono graph on those features of music which un derlie the structure of verse, find a discursive treatise upon poetry in general. A great deal indeed is said about music, but it is rather the enthusiastic as- sertion of the author’s belief in its basic relation to verse any that such an affinity exists. Still anywhere definitely expounded the natur: and extent of the relationship between the two kindred arts. Hitherto no satisfactory book on poetics has appeared in English. They have va riously exhibited grave defects—imperfect grasp of the subject, incomplete analysis disregard of previous investigations, hasty whereas we than cogent proof less is composition, unsystematic presentation, or, worst of all, a false and pretentious affec tation of system. Those most recently pub- lished have generally labored under the in- cubus of a preconceived idea, and have striven to wrench from the facts a confir- mation of a beloved hypothesis rather than to build up a theory out of usages of verse writers. Most have altogether exaggerated the importance of musical knowledge as an aid in explaining the difficulties of English versification. Many wasted much space and effort in a tedious application of the historical method where it is not at all needed have This fresh attempt we took up with much interest, but do not find it in any respect an improvement upon its Each and all of the faults of its predecessors might be found in it by meticulous eriti- cism, such as we do not propose; and other grave manifest to the most The bulk of the book is made up of examples culled from the poets, and of passages quoted from an astonishingly forerunners. defects are cursory perusal. the critt small the matter is in the author's own words. This in itself is not necessarily a weakness; but, in the excerpts as well as in her own ut- terances, the often if not usually to mistake assertion for argument, and asseveration for demonstration. See, for instance, the footnote on page 81, and the second paragraph of page 52. In the footnote told “I have shown”: on page 52 we find the merest implication, not even a clear statement. is referred to on proportion of author seems we are The same matter page 77, but with the airiest assumption in place of proof. What the author wishes regarded as true, Is accepted unhesitatingly; and what not appeal to her, is cavalierly dismissed The first chapter, on the relation be- tween music and verse, extends to fifteen pages. It may be summed up in one of its own sentences: does “If we glance down the vistas of history and examine the evidences, we shall perceive one fact, that the two
Page 22
98 The Nation. [Vol. 74, No. 1909 arts of music and poetry have always waxed and waned together.” It hardly needs so much space to set this forth, and it seems quite obvious that all arts to- gether flourish amid fostering circum- stances, and languish under unfavorable conditions. The second chapter offers a system of nota- tion for scanning verse. Some of the charac- ters used in writing music are employed to denote the syllables of poetry. Here, if anywhere in the book, we expect the justifi- cation of its title, and do not find it. What we find is almost precisely the system of scansion used by Schmidt in his well-known ‘Rhythmik und Metrik,’ the English trans- lation of which is readily accessible to any one. The crotchets and quavers which the author uses are clumsier than the familiar long and short marks of the classic scan- sion—they take up more room; but it is impossible to discover any difference in their meaning, or anything recommending them over the customary characters. It is a pity that each new writer on versification finds it necessary to invent a new system of notation and terminology. It would seem that even a hasty examination of ex- isting works must save a great deal of mental exertion. The author appears to have thought out, individually, a system practically identical with Schmidt’s, in the ideas it sets forth, and manifestly inferior to it in the notation used to express them. Again, in the same chapter, we find a new terminology. The terms “rising” and ‘‘fall- ing’’ as applied to rhythm are fairly well established, and are used by most writers on the subject. What is there to gain by calling the rising measures “strict,” the falling measures ‘‘with direct attack,’ and those wavering between the two, or hard to assign to either, ‘‘free,’’ as is done on page 47? The tendency to elaborate a new no- menclature and terminology appears very often throughout the book, and seems a source of confusion rather than of clear- ness. Especially do we fail to perceive what is gained by denoting as “primary rhythm” what Sidney Lanier (in his ‘Sci- ence of English Verse,’ pages 71, 77) calls “secondary rhythm."’ It would seem that the terms used by an admired pioneer ought to suit an enthusiastic disciple. Consider- ing the matter for ourselves, it appears to us that Lanier’s terms are far better than this author’s innovation. The remaining chapters are so unsys- tematic that no detailed criticism is pos- sible. The author sets out, to all appear- ance, to weigh and value the metrical struc- ture of a quotation or of a poem. The up- shot often is the praise of poor metrifica- tion because of the excellent presentation of the subject, or because of beauties in the imagery. Quite often really good lines are condemned because of the defects, not of the verse structure, but of the matter or diction. The word “vibration” is abused throughout the book to a painful degree (see pages 17, 69, 61, 63, 88, 95, 97, 98, 133, 242). Some of the judgments put forth seem risky, to say the least; some very in- dividual, some one-sided. For instance: “Wordsworth, too, though In a very much less degree, was defective of ear’’ (p. 63). “Neither Wordsworth, Coleridge, nor Bm- erson was a metric artist of a high order’ (p. 71). ‘We perceive this to be the favorite metre of Scott, Byron, Wordsworth, and others, which was mentioned on page 70 as being motion” monotonous and without much (p. 151). Such utterances as these shake one’s faith in the author’s capacity for the task attempted, and make implicit confidence in the book’s conclusions quite impossible. If we grant for the time being the assump- tions upon which rests the system of scan- sion used by the author, we find that it is applied for the most part consistently, and that the passages it undertakes to analyze are mostly well understood in re- spect to their movement when considered as verse. The notation, too, expresses the author’s ideas fairly well. Some of the ex- cerpts, however, are manifestly miscompre- hended, and the system is mercilessly ap- plied as a Procrustean bed to those which, using the author’s own nomenclature, begin in a 8-beat rhythm and change to a 2-beat rhythm later. The author denies that this ever occurs, and relentlessly scans uni- formly a quotation from ‘‘Christabel” (p. 42) and Shakspere’s “Come away, come away, death” (p. 45). Enough of strictures; the book is certain- ly a failure, but we honor its aim. While no good manual on this subject exists, praise is assuredly due to any one who at- tempts what is plainly a desideratum. Al- though we feel that this volume cannot serve as a safe guide for ambitious begin- ners, striving to learn how to write English verse, cannot make for itself a place as a book of reference for mature students of English poetry; although we believe it may in some cases’ balk and _ mislead callow aspirants for the poet’s bays, befog and becloud earnest’ searchers after the verities of English versi- fication, yet we find more good in the book’s purpose than evil in its execution. It can neither direct the student nor il- luminate the scholar; still, it can hardly fail to stimulate either. In reading it, we feel continually baffled by the shapeless jumble of snap-judgments, unsupported statements, and undeveloped quotations. The constantly recurring criticism of the poetic quality rather than of the versifica- tion in the excerpts from the poets is irri- tating. Yet the book, indirectly rather than directly, stimulates a reader to further thought. The author fails to grasp her subject fully, to express what she grasps, or to set forth the musical basis of verse, is loose and vague to a de gree, fails to convince, to comprehend what she feels, but (and here is the saving clause), while there is an astonishing amount of miscomprehension in the book, there is an amazing amount of right feel- ing. Hardly any one will need this book on oft-sought shelves; almost anybody at all interested in the subject will be the bet- ter for one perusal. The book has a good index. Hypolympia; or, The Gods in the Island: An Ironic Fantasy. By Edmund Gosse. Dodd, Mead & Co. 1901. Mr. Gosse’s ‘Hypolympia’ is a graceful plece of high-toned foolery. The sources of his inspiration, and the tradition which has been his guidance, are not far to seek. Heine’s ‘Gods in Exile,’ the Dialogues of Leopardi, Dr. Garnett’s ‘The Twilight of the Gods,’ Pater’s ‘Apollo in Picardy,’ are some of the literature of which one is reminded in reading ‘Hypolympia.’ The likeness, how- ever, is never very close. Mr. Gosse rarely approaches either the satiric pungency or the poetic beauty of his masters. But his work is none the less admirable in its kind; the prose is graceful, the verse melodious, the irony pleasant and timely, and the diffi- cult tone of ironic fantasy well sustained. The fable is the oid one of the wandering of the Olympian deities after the Gétter- démmerung in the South. The scene is ‘“‘an island, hitherto inhabited by Lutherans, in a remote but temperate province of North- ern Europe.” The time is early in the twentieth century. The scene opens upon the entrance of Aphrodite, out of breath, in her new mortality, and Eros. They are anxious and distressed, and but little com- forted by Pallas, who, entering later, seeks to hearten them by a sight of the strange opal-like jewel of Pandora, which has been commended to her by the oracles as a charm against the woes of Olympus. Pallas herself is quite content and calm, for, as goddess of wisdom, she ponders on the vi- cissitude of things, and so is enabled to be herself even on a ‘“‘beechwood peak in the cold sea.”” To them enters Zeus, per- haps the best conceived of all the dra- matis persone. The nerves of the Cloud- compeller are unstrung, and he is in a mood of garrulous irritability. After Zeus, the other gods appear upon the scene one by one, quite to the end of the pageant. The action of the piece from this point is too fantastical and various to be retold. The special ironic manner which Mr. Gosse has adopted is nowhere seen to better advantage than in the conversation between Pheebus and Pan. Phebus is the poet and idealist of the party on the island, and, for the most part, talks verse; but, in his in- terview with Pan, a very materialistically minded person, he talks good prose. The conversation is concluded by Phebus, who is made to remark pregnantly: “I con- gratulate you, Pan, upon your tempera- ment, and I recommend to you a further pursuit of the attainable.’’ Another notable episode is that in which Zeus is made to pose as a fatuous patron and critic of mod- ern poetry, and the current vein of poetic “symbolism” delightfully derided. The nodus of the fantasy, in so far as it exhibits such a thing, consists in the slow reconcilement of the deities to their mor- tal condition. This end is furthered by the subtle influence of Pandora’s opal-like jewel, which creates in them a mood of “wistful cheerfulness.” But the chief agency is the philosophical admonitions of ®sculapius, who points out that mortality is really the root of true pleasure, that without the chance of satiety there can be no satisfaction, that the art of right living is “to keep the supports and alleviations of your labor about you as skilfully as you can, and, in the fuss and business of the little episodes of climbing, to forget as long and as fully as may be the final and absolutely unavoidable plunge.” So suc- cessful is AUsculapius that at last even Nike cries out: ‘Ah! I see, I think I part- ly see. The element of real victory was absent where no defeat could be. ... And it may be present even where no final conquest can ensue.” So far Mr. Gosse differs from most others who have handled the theme, in making his fantasy tend toward optimism. But at the very last he goes back to the tradition, and so enforces his irony. Suddenly Iris ap-
Page 23
Jan. 30, 1902] The Nation. pears with miraculous ships to convey the gods and goddesses back to their earlier homeandtheirimmortality. They forget their newly acquired philosophy, and, with Olym- pian jubilation, prepare to embark. Just as they go off, it is discovered that Hermes has given away, to a mortal maid, the opal- like jewel, the begetter of ‘‘wistful cheer- iness.” But Pallas assures them: “It is of no moment. It would be an inconspicuous ornament in that blaze of the heart’s beau- ty to which the white ships are about to carry us.” It will be seen that, while the conception of the work is light and fantastical, it is not devoid of serious criticism of life. It contains, of course, nothing conclusive, but it will furnish reading stimulating as well as pleasant to one wth a taste for the peculiar genre. Old-Time Gardens, Newly Set Forth. By Alice Morse Earle. A Book of the Sweet o’ the Year. Pp. xviii, 489. 204 illustra- tions. The Macmillan Co. 1901. What a pleasant surprise to some people must be this book about ‘Old-Time Gar- dens.’ Many had expected to find in it a superabundance of sentiment falling into sentimentality. Some had looked for a book made, as it were, to order and with an evident effort; some for little real know- ledge and the lack of it none too well con- cealed. A half hour’s reading is enough to convince the most skeptical that it has none of these failings. Sentiment it has, to be sure, but this is kept well within bounds, as if there were somewhere in the author’s mind a sense of humor sure to give warning before the brink of sentimentality was reached. Knowledge there is, and of a very real kind—knowledge that has been many years agrowing, consciously and un- consciously. And as for the book’s being made to order, it comes straight from the heart, and from a kindly heart at that. Mrs. Earle had the good fortune as a child to pass her summers in an old-time garden. There she laid in great store of knowledge of the ways of children among flowers, a store that she is now able to draw upon at will and in most delightful fashion, so that one of her best chapters is about child- hood in a garden. Her forebears, too, for generations, seem to have been garden- lovers, so that her sympathy with growing things may well be an inherited trait. Her love of gardens and the interest in colo- nial life and manners which her earlier books have manifested, are in this one most fortunately joined, so that she has here given us a fund of information about the old-time American garden and the things that grew in it, the like of which cannot be found elsewhere. The real colonial garden that has been well maintained, and has come down to us without change from the days before the Revolution, is a hard thing to find. A few exist, but for the most part our old gar- dens, notably those of the South, have been permitted to fall into decay and have lost their former charm of primness. Oth- ers have been so changed by “landscape artists,” ignorant of the laws that gov- erned their planning and out of sympathy with their well-ordered reticence, that their original form may hardly be discovered. Of such as are left in a condition reminiscent of their best time, Mrs. Earle has suc- 99 ceeded in finding the best. Photographs | tional development with the development of and descriptions of them she gives us; but the thing that lent them their distinctive character—their plan—is missing. Sketches of such plans, even though small and rough, would have made all clearer than many words. Here and there, however, the plan is so clearly defined by neatly trimmed bex- edging that the photograph serves in place of a plan. But it is not on the side of garden de- that Mrs. Earle shows her strength and knowledge. They appear when she speaks of flowers. With them she is at home, and about them she discourses in a pleasant way that puts the reader on good terms with himself. With flowers old and new the book is chiefly concerned, and some of its most entertaining parts deal with the introduction of our garden favorites into this country. What flowers the Dutch brought with them, what the Swedes, and what the Pilgrim Fathers—such things are curiously sought out from ancient sources and here down with minuteness and fidelity. To convey an idea of the exact scope of the book is not easy, but some nction of its varied contents may be had from the fact that its twenty-two chap- ters cover subjects as widely separated as front door-yards, the gardens of the poets, sun-dials, and the herb garden. Country Life and House and Garden have set such a high standard in the reproduc- tien of garden photographs that it is much to be regretted that the publishers have nct treated the book as well as it deserved in this particular. The photographs, as- with great care and difficulty, have been turned into half-tones of doubtful quality, and printed in a fashion that would do no credit to a first-class news- paper. With few exceptions they are gray and often vague or lacking in detail—not in the purposeful way in which the skil- ful photographer gives vagueness, but in the way that carelessness in the press- room and unsuitability in the paper give it. sign set sembled, doubtless, The Welsh Wars of Edward I.: A Contribu- tion to Medieval Military History, Based on Original Documents. By John E. Mor- ris, M.A. Oxford: Clarendon Press; New York: Henry Frowde. 1901. The Welsh campaigns of Edward I. are described by Mr. Morris in great fulness of detail, but also in such a manner as gives them general significance for the mediwval- ist. In other words, this book is more than a narrative of fighting in the Welsh marches; it is an essay on certain impor- tant aspects of warfare during the Middle Ages. Furthermore, it is closely related to the Constitutional history of England. The time was one when the paid soldier was taking the place of the simple feudatory, and when the money which military opera- tions demanded under this new condition could be secured only by a confirmation of the charters. Moreover, the sovereign was the “greatest of the Plantagenets,” the chief Constitutional king of that wonderful age, the thirteenth century. Considering space alone, Mr. Morris keeps the local or topographical element prominent, but he does so merely for the sake of thorough- ness, that he may by precise demonstration establish certain views concerning military operations and the interlacing of Constitu- war. In different this exhaustive study recalls the writings of Round, Clark, and Oman, beside the best of which it titled by its quality to stand it relies upon the Exchequer ac counts now preserved in the Record Office, although it draws much from the pipe, the patent, and the close rolls. Compared with the definite statements of such sources, the accounts given by best of the chroniclers like Hemingburgh, Trivet, and Wykes of Osney seem vague and misleading but occasionally they yield a valuable pas- sage, as, the description by Trivet of Warwick's victory over the Welsh near Conway in 1295. Mr. Morris has taken infinite pains with his preparation, and his results are so clearly stated that his labor seems wasted. ways {a en For its data largely even the for instance, none of The groundwork is furnished in large part by a statistical analysis of the army. Edwardian Every one knows how misleading mediwval statements are regarding num bers, when once the modest limit of three Unfortunately, {t fs not possible to discover, search figures is passed however diligent rs the actually or how they were equip ped, or in what order they fought, but the pay-rolls furnish accurate figures, they what were in every case, may be, forces so far as g0, and much may be gleaned from material contained in the ‘Parliamentary Writs.’ Thus a basis of inference is « tablished, and important conclusions, both negative and positive, may be drawn. One of them is that the normal strength of an Edwardian force towards the close of the reign is about 2,000 horse and 10,000 foot another, that ‘‘the and 60,000 foot of Bannockburn is the mer est legend of the 40,000 horse poetic figment."’ Mr. Morris is particularly interested the history of the long-bow. in had the been trained who riddled and turned the ranks of the French chival ry at Crécy and Poitiers? The usual an swer to such a question points in the dire: tion of the Scottish wars, and fixes chiefly Hiow English archers upon the battle of Falkirk Mr. Morris carries the evolution back one stage and connects it with the Welsh wars. “It is clear that the earliest foot, partly spear men, partly bow-armed, were drawn alike from the Welsh ‘friendlies’ of marcher lord ships and from the border counties between Lancashire and Gloucestershire, while the men of nearly all the other English cou: ties had yet to be trained in the Scotti Another matter which Mr. keeps well in view is the intermingling of with the emergence of an infantry force. systematic methods 1 wars.” Morris bowmen cavalry and gradual Edward's the feudal to also anticipated transformation of war from the the modern type. These campaigns must, perforce, be re garded from the English standpoint, be cause little information concerning the equipment and projects of the Welsh can be secured “We know hardly anything of Llewelyn’s men. Their tactics were of the guerrilla type. They avoided pitched battles, sought cover in the forests and mountains, and loved to pounce upon con- voys. They were very active and difficul' to reach. Their chief weapon was a long spear, and one doubts if the Welsh « north ever practised archery.’ They fought stubbornly, but, after they were once beat
Page 24
100 The Nation. [Vol. 74, No. 1909 en, the marches became an excellent re- cruiting ground for the English kings. The Welsh entered into the Hundred Years’ War with the same eagerness which the Scot- tish clansmen showed in the Seven Years’ War. Despite the later rising under Glyndwr, large numbers of men from the west side of the marches were serving against the French in the fourteenth cen- tury. Apart from his account of the campaigns themselves, Mr. Morris discusses the rela- tions of England and Wales during the Norman period, the organization of the Ed- wardian army, the custom of the march, and events leading from the Welsh wars. Altogether, this is a work of solid scholar- ship and lasting value. BOOKS OF THE WEEK Allen, Grant. County and Town in England. Lon- don: Grant Richards; New York: E. P. Dutton & Co, $1.50. Amherst, Lord, of Hackney, and Thomson, Basil. The Discovery of the Solomon Islands by Alvaro de Mendafia in 1568. 2 vols. London: The Hakluyt Society. Baker, M. N. Municipal Engineering and ote tion. (The Citizen’s Library.) Macmillan. $1.25 Ball, W. E. St. Paul and the Roman Law. Edin- burgh: T. & T. Clark; New York: Scribners. $1.50. Barnum, Francis. Grammatical a of the Inbult Language. Boston: Ginn & $5. Barton Se Sketch of Semitic Drie: Social and incligivus. Macmillan. Bell, Mrs. Arthur. Lives and Legends of the Evangelists, Apostles, and Other Early Saints. — Gocege Bell & Sons; New York: Macmil- an Bolton, Gambler. The Animals of the Bible. London: George Newnes; New York: Scribners. cen Bunyan, John. The Pilgrim’s Progress. 2 parts. i George Newnes; New York: Scribners. $2. cautiela, J. H. The College Student and his Prob- lems. Macmillan. Carr, ©. 8. A Preacher Preaching et Himself. Columbus (Ohio): Light of Truth Pub. Cartwright, Julia. Sacharissa: Some ant of Dorothy Sydney, Countess of a Third ed. E. P. Dutton & Co. $2.50 Cumming, A. N. Public- House Reform. London: Swan Sonnenschein & Co.; New York: Scribners. $1. Dodge, H. N. Christus Victor: A Student’s Reverie. G. P. Putnam's Sons. Ellicott, J. M. The Hite of John Ancrum Wins- low, Rear-Admiral, United States Navy. G. P. Putnam’s Sons. $2.50. Fleming, W. H. Shakespeare’s Plots. G. P. Putnam's Sons. $1.80. Fistenes, B. and B. F. A be ee 4 of Architecture on the Comparative Method. New ed. on: B. T, Batsford; New York: Scribners. $7.50. Gray 'W. C. Musings by Campfire and Wayside. Ficcsine H. Revell Co. 50. Holme, Charles. Modern esigns in Semeraty and Fans. The International Studio, $1.7 Hurll, Estelle M. Correggio. Houghton, S cigsin & Co. 75 cents. Lemcke, Ernest E. Creation—Recreation: Poems. Orange (N. J.): Privately printed. Levi, Moritz. Manzoni’s I Promessi Sposi. Silver. Burdett & Co. lle: P. The Pastoral Epistles. bs ey moske for Tpitie taegine t Minbareh: id T. Clar New_York: Scribners. 75 ¢ Love Poems of Sir John Suckling. (Lover's Li- a John Lane. 50 cents. Lum J. R. The Acts of the Apostles. yond Cauntiriace Bible for Schools and Colleges.) - gen ©. J. Clay & Sons; New York: Macmillan. Menpes, Dorothy. —_ : A Record in Colour. London: Adam & Charles Black; New York: Macmillan. a. Morris, Mowbra Tales of the Spanish Main. Nichols, F. M. Britton. Washington: John Byrne Macmillan. & Co. O’Connor, J. A. The Converted Catholic, Vol. xviii. James A. O'Connor. Parker, E. H. John Chinaman, and a Few Others. London: John Murray; New York: E. P. Dutton & Co, $2.50. Pietsch, Ludwig Herkomer. (Ktinstler-Mono- Son Laipuig: Velhagen & Klasing; New Lemeke & Buechner. 4 marks. Piolet, B. Les Missions Catholiqt _ 7 enapaiote au kIxe Siécle. Paris: Armand Russell, C. E. Such Stuff as ng yj en lis: The Bowen-Merrill Co. Schiifer, E. A. Directions for Class Work iu oo Physiology. Longmans, Green & Oo. a, & A. What is Shakespeare? Macmil- an Sladen, Douglas. In ed 2 vols. London: Sands & Co.; New York: E. P, Dutton & Co. “——_ G. W. Old Testament as i London: Methuen, & Co.; New York: E. Dutton & Wherry! Albinia. Stories of the Tuscan Artists. London: J. M. Dent & Co.; New York: E. P. Dutton & Co. $4. The Nation’s Judgment: ‘* Few poems, plays, novels, pictures, statues or fictitious characters that children—or most of their parents—of our day are likely to inquire about will be missed here. Mr. Gea 8 judgment seems unusually sound . . . will be welcome and useful,” says the Natio . of Champlin’s Young Folks’ Cyclopaedia of LITERATURE AND ART With 270 illustrations. 604 pp., 8vo, $2.50. Brief accounts of the great books, buildings, statues, pictures, operas, etc., etc. {?"llustrated circular of Champlin’s ‘ Young Folks’ Cyclopaedias " and his other books free. Henry Holt & Co., New York Count Hannibal STANLEY J. WEYMAN Author of “ A Gentleman of France.” Crown 8vo, Cloth, $1.50. LONGMANS.GREEN, &Co. 93 Fifth Avenue, New York. STUDIES IN HISTORY AND JURISPRUDENCE BY JAMES W. BRYCE, D.C.L. Author of The American Commonwealth,” 8vo, cloth, $3.50 net. OXPORD UNIVERSITY PRESS: AMERICAN BRANCH 91 and 93 Pifth Avenue, New York. RARE PRINTS, XVI. & XVII. Century Armor, Old Delft Ware, etc. Hlustrated Catalogues sunt free on application. HENRY T. COATES & CO., 1222 Chestnut Street, Philadelphia, oenold) Constable Ka. Upholstery. Curtain Materials, Tapestries, and Furniture Coverings Cretonnes. Printed Tuscan Linens, Glazed Chintzes. Swiss Muslin and Lace Curtains, with lace frilled edge, made to any size desired, Bedspreads to match. Window Shades. Venetian Festooned, Opaque, and Transparent. King’s Scotch Holland Window Shades to Order. Mattresses, Bolsters, and Pillows. Hotel and Yacht Work a Specialty. Estimates on application, Droadevay KH 19th ot. NEW YORK. Book Editor Wanted. An important position as manuscript reader and book editor in a prominent New York publishing house is vacant. The position commands a good salary, and requires a man of judgment and ex- perience, who must reside in New York. Address, giving age, qualifications, and experience, PUB- LISHER, Box 50, Madison Sqr. Branch P.-O., New York City. THE LIFE OF Prince Otto von Bismarck by Frank Preston Stearns With frontispiece. 8vo, cloth, gilt top, $3.50. LIMITED EDITIONS of Standard English and Prench Authors. On receipt of postal card a gee of paper, type, Mustratoe, ged inding will be se KN T & BROWN, 150 ritth Ave , New York. Embroidered Swisses at “The Linen Store.” The Swiss Muslins are _ still among the most popular of the sheer fabrics for summer and evening wear. Some of the newest designs show large figures, such as the bow-knot and stripe, bow-knot and medallion, and vine and dot combinations. One very attrac- tive pattern is composed of grad- uated fleur-de-lis arranged in the form of circles. Also polka dots in all sizes, in- cluding white on black, black dots on white and on the ecru or linen shade. A great variety of color combi- nations is represented. 30 in. wide, 50c. to 1.00 yard. 44 “6 “ $1.00 “ 2.00 “ Our stock of wash fabrics includes an un- usually as collection of linen, cotton and silk materials for waists, suitings and gowns, Mail orders have prompt attention. ‘‘ The Linen Store.” James McCutcheon & Co., 14 West 23d St., New York.
Page 25
Pn 145 a”? , s i ’ y oH “Gy, bs [ee = = = — “Vey VOL. LXXIV—NO. 1910. THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 6, 1902 My “ICE TEN CENTS READY SATURDAY THROUGH SCIENCE TO FAITH By NEWMAN SMYTH Author of **The Place of Death in Evolution.’’ ra UR inherited religious faiths,” says Dr. Smyth in bis preface, ‘‘cannot maintain their power, and they ought not to survive, if they fail to accept fully nature’s answer to the latest appeal of our science, and if they do not search diligently for the true interpretation of new disclosures of life.” The author addresses especially the general reader. $1.50 met (Postage 16 cents) PHILOSOPHY OF CONDUCT A Treatise of the Facts, Principles and Ideals of Ethics By GEORGE TRUMBULL LADD Professor of Philosophy at Yale University. I. The Moral Self. II. The Virtuous Lite. III. The Nature of the Right. $3.50 net (Postage 20 cents) PEN AND INK: Papers on Subjects of More or Less Importance By BRANDER MATTHEWS, Author of “ Parts of Speech,’ et ie essays appeal directly to those interested in various aspects of literature as an art; and in this new and enlarged edition th appeal is strengthened by the inclusion of other papers on allied topics. $1.25 nerf (Postage 10 cents) JUSG PUBLISHED THE APOSTLES’ CREED Its Origin, Its Purpose, and Its Historical Interpretation By ARTHUR CUSHMAN McGIFFERT, Washburn Professor of Church History in the Union Theolegical Seminary CRITICAL study, destined to command attention and provoke discussion. Its publication has been deferred to the present time 41 because the author had reached conclusions at variance with many modern scholars which he did not wish to publish until he could give reasons for them in detail. $1.25 mer (Postage 13 cents) PRESIDENT PHILIPPINE AFFAIRS 1 SCHURMAN’S A Pretrospect and an Qutlook COMPLETE survey of the Philippine situation, past and present, in its diplomatic, military, covernmenta ADDRESS A commercial, and ecclesiastical aspects, and a forecast of the ultimate destiny of the Islands, which, it is contended, cannot be colonialism or statehood and must be the development of Philippine nationality with independence when the Filipinos want and are fit for independence. IN FULL 60 cents nef (Postage 6 cents) CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS, New York
Page 26
100 The Nation. [Vol. 74, No. 1909 en, the marches became an excellent re- cruiting ground for the English kings. The Welsh entered into the Hundred Years’ War with the same eagerness which the Scot- tish clansmen showed in the Seven Years’ War. Despite the later rising under Glyndwr, large numbers of men from the west side of the marches were serving against the French in the fourteenth cen- tury. Apart from his account of the campaigns themselves, Mr. Morris discusses the rela- tions of England and Wales during the Norman period, the organization of the Ed- wardian army, the custom of the march, and events leading from the Welsh wars. Altogether, this is a work of solid scholar- ship and lasting value. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. County and Town in pogieet. Lon- Allen, Grant, New York . Dutton & don: Sy Richards; Co, Amherst, Lord, of Hackney, and Thomson, Basil. The Discovery of the Solomon Islands by Alvaro de Mendafia in 1568. 2 vols. London: The Hakluyt Society. Baker, M. N. Municipal Engineering and Sanita- tion. (The Citizen’s Library.) Macmillan. $1.25. Ball, W. BE. St. Paul and the Roman Law. Edin- burgh: T. & T. Clark; New York: Scribners. $1.50. Barnum, Francis. iggy oy Fundamentals of the Inbuit Langu guage. Boston: Ginn & Co. $5. Barton, G. A. A Sketch of Semitic Origine. Social and Religious. Macmillan. $3. Bell, Mrs. Arthur. Lives and Legends of the Evangelists, Apeetios, and Other rly Saints. panseg: George Bell & Sons; New York: Macmil- an J Bolton, Gambler. The Animals of the Bible. London: George Newnes; New York: Scribners 75 cents. Bunyan, John. The Pilgrim’s Progress. 2 parts. oy ae George Newnes; New York: Scribners. Canfield, J. H. The College Student and his Prob- lems. — an. Carr, C. A Preacher Preaching to Himself. atas ‘(Qhio): Light of Truth Pub. Co, Cartwright, Julia. Sacharissa me Account of Dorothy Sydney, Countess of Gathevieed. Third ed. E. P. Dutton & 2.50. A. N. Publie- House Reform. London: Oumming, nnenschein & Co.; New York: Scribners. 1. & Dodge, H. N. Christus hasan A Student’s Reverie. G. P. Putnam’s Sons Ellicott, J. M. The Life of John Ancrum Wins- low, Rear-Admiral, told States Navy. G. P. Putnam’s Sons. $2. Shiaicespeare's Plots. Fleming, W. H. G.. -P; Putnam’s Sons. re B. and B. F. A History of Architecture on the Comparative Method. New ed. om: B. . Batsforc: New York: Scribners. $7.50 Gray, ‘Ww. usings by Campfire and Wayside. Fleming H. Revell Co. $1.50. Holme, Charles. Modern esigns in Jewellery and Fans. The International Studio. 1.75. Hurll, Estelle M. Correggio. Houghton, Mifflin & Co. 75 cents. Lemcke, Ernest E. Creation—Recreation: Poems. Orange (N. J.): Privately printed. Levi, Moritz. Manzoni’s I Promessi Sposi. Silver. Burdett & Co. Lilley P. The Pastoral Epistles. (Hand-Books for Bibie Classes.) Biipbarab: . i ye New_York: Scribners. 75 ce Love Poems of Sir John cabtine. Leas i John Lane. 50 cents. The Acts b the Apostles. Clark; (Lover's Li- Lumby, J. R. a Cambridge — for Schools and Colleges.) oe Sm J. Clay & Sons; New York: Macmillan. Menpes, Dessay. Japan: A Record in Colour. London: Adam harles Black; New York: Macmillan. Morris, ule Tales of the Spanish Main. Macmillan eo . M. Britton. Washington: John Byrne & Co. O’Connor, J. A. The Converted Catholic, Vol. xviii. James A. O'Connor. Parker, E. H. John Chinaman, and a Few Others. London: B50. Murray; New York: E. P. Dutton vw ——— Ludwig. Herkomer. (Ktinstler-Mono- on + a Velhagen & Klasing; New Lemcke & Buechner. 4 marks. Piolet, B. au Kike Siacie. s Missions Catholiqu o- naan Paris: Armand Russell, C. E. Such Stuff as roto lis: The Bowen-Merrill Co. Schifer, E. A. Directions for Class Work iu Practical Physiology. Longmans, Green & Oo. en, 3 A. What ig Shakespeare? Macmil- Sladen, Douglas. In sneer. 2 vols. London: nds & Co.; New York: E. P, Dutton & Co. 20. — G. W. Old Testament History. London: Methuen & Co.; New York: BE. P. Dutton & "eatin Co. $1.50. Wherry, Albinia. Stories of the Tuscan Artists. London: J. M. Dent & Co.; New York: E. P. Dutton & Co. $4. The Nation’s Judgment: ‘Few poems, plays, novels, pictures, statues or fictitious characters that children—or most of their parents—of our day are likely to inquire about will be missed here. Mr. ne 8 judgment seems unusually sound will welcome and useful,” says the Natio . of Champlin’s Young Folks’ Cyclopaedia of LITERATURE AND ART With 270 illustrations. 604 pp., 8vo, $2.50. Brief accounts of the great books, buildings, statues, pictures, operas, etc., etc. tr" Illustrated circular of Champlin’s ‘* Young Folks’ Cyclopaedias " and his other books free. Henry Holt & Co., New York Count Hannibal y STANLEY J. WEYMAN Author of “ A Gentleman of France.” Crown 8vo, Cloth, $1.50. LONGMANS,.GREEN,&CO. 93 Fifth Avenue, New York. STUDIES IN HISTORY AND JURISPRUDENCE BY JAMES Ww. BRYCE, D.C.L. Author of The American Commonwealth,” 8vo, cloth, $3.50 net. OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS: AMERICAN BRANCH 91 and 93 Pifth Avenue, New York, RARE PRINTS, XVI. & XVII. Century Armor, Old Delft Ware, etc. Illustrated Catalogues sent free on application. HENRY T. COATES & CO., 1222 Chestnut Street, Philadelphia. ‘ oenolo Constidile KaCo. Upholstery. Curtain Materials, Tapestries, and Furniture Coverings Cretonnes. Printed Tuscan Linens. Glazed Chintzes. Swiss Muslin and Lace Curtains, with lace frilled edge, made to any size desired. Bedspreads to match. Window Shades. Venetian Festooned, Opaque, and Transparent. King’s Scotch Holland Window Shades to Order. Mattresses, Bolsters, and Pillows. Hotel and Yacht Work a Specialty. Estimates on application. Sroadevay K 1 9th ét. NEW YORK. Book Editor Wanted. An important position as manuscript reader and book editor in a prominent New York publishing house is vacant. The position commands a good salary, and requires a man of judgment and ex- perience, who must reside in New York. Address, giving age, qualifications, and experience, PUB- LISHER, Box 50, Madison Sqr. Branch P.-O., New York City. THE LIFE OF Prince Otto von Bismarck by Frank Preston Stearns With frontispiece. 8vo, cloth, em top, $3.50. ‘LIMITED EDITIONS. of Standard English and French Authors. On receipt of outa card specimens of paper, type, linetraon, and binding will be sent. KNIGHT & BROWN, 150 Fifth Ave , New York. Embroidered Swisses at “The Linen Store.” The Swiss Muslins are still among the most popular of the Sheer fabrics for summer and evening wear. Some of the newest designs Show large figures, such as the bow-knot an stripe, bow-knot and medallion, and vine and dot combinations. One very attrac- tive pattern is composed of grad- uated fleur-de-lis arranged in the form of circles. Also polka dots in all sizes, in- cluding white on black, black dots on white and on the ecru or linen shade. A great variety of color combi- nations is represented. 30 in. wide, 50c. to 1.00 yard. 44 $1.00 « 200 « Our stock of wash fabrics includes an un- usually men collection of linen, cotton and silk materials for waists, suitings and gowns, Mail orders have prompt attention. «The Linen Store.”’ James McCutcheon & Co., 14 West 23d St., New York.