The Nation 1900-01-18: Vol 70 Iss 1803
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
GENERAL LIBRARY, UNIV. OF Mic™- tAN 10 1S VOL, LXX—NO. 1803. THURSDAY, JANUARY 18, 1900 PRICE 10 CENTS. PUTNAMS NEW BOOKS Theodore Beza ee The Counsellor of the French Re- ormation. By Henry Martyn Bairp, of New York University. Heroes of the Reformation Se- ries, No. 4. Fully illustrated. 12mo, $1.50. It is rather remarkable that this book should be the first biography of Beza in the English language, because Beza played a very prominent part in the Reformation movement; but the fact is he has been overshadowed by Calvin, just as Melanchthon was overshadowed by Luther. It was, however, richly worth while to present in detail the life of such a worthy man and fine scholar. Bismarck And the Foundation of the German Empire. By J. W. Heapwam, M.A., Fellow of Kings College. Heroes of the Nations, No. 25. Fully illustrated. Large 12mo, $1.50. “The work of this author is conspicuously superior to that of other re- cent writers on the subject. His conclusions are thoroughly sound and the book is a vast improvement on all! the volumes thus far printed in Eng- land.” —The Atheneum. Henry Knox (1750-1806.) A Soldier of the Revolution. Ma- jor-General in the Continental Army, Washing- ton’s Chief of Artillery, etc. By Noau Brooks. American Men of Energy. No. 2. Fully Illus- trated. 12mo, $1.50. The author, in his well-known forceful manner, shows that General Knox was a more important figure among the Revolutionary officers than many others who have been more conspicuous in histories. The Midsummer of Italian Art By Frank Preston STEARNS, author of ‘‘ Tinto- retto.” Second edition, revised. [llustrated. 8vo, $2.25. “One of the most genuinely delightful and readable art books. work is a model of sensible art writing.”--New York Times. The Regeneration of the United States By The A Forecast of Its Industrial Evolution. WILLIAM Morton GRINNELL. 12m0, $1.00, The opening chapters of Mr. Grinnell's volume are devoted to a con- sideration of the early history of the United States, with its lofty political ideals reduced to practice, as contrasted with the political and business degeneration which characterized the last half of the nineteenth century. Heredity and Human Progress By W. Duncan McKin, A.M., Ph.D. 12mo, $1.50. An expedient for relieving society of the heavy burden imposed upon it by weaklings and criminals, | | The Stage as a Career A Sketch of the Actor’s Life, its Requirements, Hardships, and Rewards. By P. G. Hupert, Jr. 12mo. $1. Mr. Hubert's experience as a dramatic critic has brought him into close relations with the stage, and he speaks upon the subject with per- sonal knowledge. His volume gives a sketch of the actor's life, its re- quirements, hardships. and rewards. He describes the qualifications and training essential to success, and gives expert opinions from such famous actors as Sir Henry Irving, Lawrence Barrett, Dion Boucicault, Joseph Jefferson, Helen Modjeska, Mary Anderson, and Maggie Mitcheli. Earthwork Out of Tuscany Being Impressions and Translations of Maurice Hewett. New edition, with additional illustra- tions in photogravure. 12mo, net, $2.50. “The book is an original and valuable production, bringing to the in- terpretation of a familiar theme new insight, new feeling, new art. It is delicate, spiritualized work, not the sort that most easily finds favor to- day.’’—New York Tribune. a ‘ s a *,8 First Principles in Politics By WILLIAM SAMUEL LILLY, Honorary Fellow of Peterhouse, Cambridge. 8vo, $2.50. The author has added to his long list of standard works of history this new book, dealing with Politics. He has taken afresh and striking view of his subject, based upon common sense The Wheat Problem Based on remarks made in the Presidential Ad- dress to the British Association at Bristol in 1898; revised by Sir WILLIAM Crookes, with two chap- ters on the future wheat supply of the United States, by C. Woop Davis and the Hon. Joun Hype. Questions of the Day Series. 12mo0, $1.25. This volume is an elaboration of the Presidential address delivered by Sir William Crookes before the British Association for the Advancement of Science. In this address the author pointed out the serious peril await ing wheat eaters who contentedly pursue the present wasteful «ystem of cultivation. Under the present conditions of wheat culture scarcity of wheat is within an appreciable distance, as the wheat-growing lands all over the world are becoming exhausted, and it seems to the author that at some future time—and, in his opinion, at no far distant time--no availa ble wheat land will be left. Exploratio Evangelica A Brief Examination of the Basis and Origin of Christian Belief. By Percy Garpner, author of ‘* New Chapters in Greek History,” etc. 8vo. An attempt to examine the phenomena of the rise of Christianity from | a point of view which is purely historical and lay, although not irreligioux 27 and 29 West 23d St, NEW YORK 24 Bedford Street, Strand, LONDON G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS
Page 2
The Nation. [Vol. 70, No. 1803 The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science, and Art. FOUNDED 1865. [ Entered atthe New York City Post-Office as second- class mail-matter. CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. ED EN oN bbb bo 000 b6ade0 draSévrcaeoy CAspeebauasbess 41 EDITORIAL ARTICLES: Ex Oriente Lux The Bankers and the SEOROney Reform by Social oun “The Mills of SPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE: The Winter Exhibitions..............cceeee. 46 Rébelliau’s Bossuet CORRESPONDENCE: ee Auditing of McKinley hrow Over vind on New Diplom: Our Title to the Philippines Things Athenian NE SID 6 gob ons verecrcvcccecnteseseces’ UD RIOR a cchiccccscenecocenevesses Decision Without Reasons...........-....+- Eo op cken eset csrniehed oarne sen BN isn sah cde des ech cvenneihindcsusdcubeseseekaskose 52 Book REVIEWS: i nO 6. nt haeebis Spee b aes soak 55 Smith's New Trades Gembnstion a 56 emoirs of a Revolutionist...............6.. 57 The F pully 58 A Potion History of Besepe Since 1814.... 58 Under Three Flags in Cuba..........--++.4++ 59 Sextus ‘Empiricus and Greek Scepticism..... 59 A World in a Garden 60 BOoKSs OF THE WEEK........... ...... TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three Dollars per year, in advance, postpaid, to any partof the United States or Canada; to foreign countries comprised in the Postal Union, $4.00. The date when the subscription expires is on the Address-Libel of each paper, the change of which so a subsequent date becomes a receipt for remit- tance. No other receipt is sent unless requested. Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter, or by check, express order, or Hostal Order, payable to “ Publisher of the Na- tion,” When a change of address is desired, both the old and new addresses should be given, Address THE NATION, Box 794. New York. Publication Office, 208 Broadway. TERMS OF ADVERTISING. en cents per agate line, each insertion, 1, lines to the tnch, Twenty per cent. advance for choice of page, or top of column, A column, $20 each insertion; page, $24, A p ige, $60 each insertion; frontcover page, $80. Advertisements must be acceptable in every re- spect, Copy received until Tuesday, 5 P. M. with choice of DISCOUNTS. Time— 4 tnsertions..... é per cent. s Lil tien La 1k “ 26 “ BY i) 62 “ MOUNT— $100 within a» a 500 ad 750 = 1,000 e 1,600 “ 000 The NATION is sent free to those who advertise in a as long. as advartigemens ¢ continues, *,* Copies ‘of the Manon may ‘be stiiie’ in Paris at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de l'Opéra, and in London of B. F. Stevens & Brown, 4 Trafalgar Square, Charing Cross. London agent for advertisements, George M. 8. Horton, Trafalgar Buildings, Trafalgar Square. , Educational CALIFORNIA, NOCH S es; West 23d Stree ARLBOROUGH SCHOOL jor GIRLS GrorGe A. CaswBLL, Principal. DELAwaRE, Wilmington, Franklin Street. ‘HE MISSES HEBB'S Boarding and Day School for Girls. Students are red for Colle; pre ARYLAND, Baltimore, 122 and 124 W. Franklin St. DGEWORTH BOARDING and DAY School for Girls.—37th year will begin September 428, 1899. id . LEFEBVRE, Principal. 88 E.D. HUNTLEY, "Ansoclate Principal. MARYLAND, Catonsville. A. TIMOTHY'S SCHOOL for Girls re- opens Sept, 21, 1899. Prepares for College. Heads of School, Miss M. G. Carter, Miss 8. R. CARTER. MASSACHUSETTS, Bos OSTON UNI VERSI TY Law School. Address the Dean, SAMUEL C, BENNETT. N Ew YORK, Tarrytown-on-Hudson. ACK LEY HALL. v. Theodore C. Williams (lately of All Souls’ church kw York), assisted by Mr. Seaver B. Buck ary.), can receive a few more pupils. Term be- gis “po 8. Number limited this year to ten boys Care- ul preparation for college examinations. Family life in nem he beautiful surroundings. Highest references requ PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, Chestant Hill. RS. COMEG YS’ AND MISS BELL'S BOARDING AND DAY SCHOOL FOR GIRLS. Students prepared for college. ISS ANABLE’S Boarding and Day School for Girls. Established in 1848. pty application. Opens Sept.28. 1350 Pine St., Phila., Pa. SCHOOL OF DRAWING AND PAINTING, MUSEUM psa. oy ase s, B mgpig MASS. Instructors — 1 Ec. TA ARBELL, | F w. BENSON, mae. Wi painting: ne ed PRATT, rr, Modelling; Mi MRS WM wo pooga: 5 RSON, fig ten A. K. — as hen. S Tree use of Museum Galle Poreign Scholarship for men and ~ ll elen Hamblen Scholarship. Ten Free a bo prizes in money. For circulars and terms ad _MISS BLIZABETH LOMBARD, Manager. ‘Cambrides, Massachusetts. A HOME for a few Dene Sept, wishing to study in or near set ADDIE re-opens t. 25th, At sag Highest references. before ‘Apri ist to Miss 8S. W. Fos- dick, 188 rattle dt. Cambridge, Mass. on fur- nished at once upon application. School Agencies. ‘HE FISK TEA CARES ACENCIES, Everett O. Fisk & Co. ‘oprieto: 4 Ashburton Place, Boston. IsoS Pa) Ave. Washington. 156 Fifth Ave., New York. 414 Cent. ay “-Minneapolls. 533 Cooper Bdg. .. Denver. 25 King St 878 Wabash Ave., Chicago. 525 Stime’n Bk. “Te kueles. 420 Parrott Building, San Francisco. LBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY, 4 State St., Albany, N. Y.—Provides schools of all ae with competent teachers, Assists teachers in obtaining positions. HARLAN P. Frenon, Manager. G HERMERHORN Teachers’ Gagoties Teachers for all peepee. orms parents of good sch p meee & Rookwk.LL, 3 El lath 8t., New York. THE PRATT TEACHERS’ AGENCY. WM. 0. PRATT, Mgr., 70 Fifth Ave., New York. Agency. Teachers, etc. Pres D.o f JOHNS HOPKINS, with 7 years’ ence as Professor of English in a small col- Gaevle a better position. Address x. pf Nation. (CHARLE SW. ST ONE, Ti ator for Har- vard, 68 Chestnut Street, Boston. TRANSLATIONS From all the literary lan —o of Europe into Jing lish, German, French, Spanis jan, etc,, by a ver- sity Instructor. (Scientific translations a special ty.) Le ge = references for work done for leading libra- and #. Address O. BR, care of Publisher of The Nation, KIN DERGARTEN SUPPLIES t SCHERMERHORN'’S, 8 East 14th St., N. Y Send for New Catalogue. Travel. on BERMUDA FROST UNKNOWN. MALARIA IMPOSSIBLE. 48 Hours from New York, by Elegant Steamships, Weekly. 5 days’ service during January, February, March, 1900, For Win te West Indies Including Bermuda, Porto Rico and Cuba MADIANA, 3,080 Tons, Jan. 4 and Feb. 3 PRETORIA, 3,300 Tons, Jan.J3 and Feb. 14, Duration of Cruise about 32days. 20 days in the Tro- ie os Pamphlets and full information, 8 to E. OUTERBRIDGE & CO., NY QUEBEC STEAMSHIP sana set by Crp 39 B way, New York N. Y, Juebec, Canada. THOMAS Cork * SON, 261 Broadway, HERN, Secretary. OBERAMMERGAU PASSION PLAY OF 1900 Families and individuals may obtain rooms at the Pension Veit, and seats at the Play will be se- cured for them. An ag application, stating date of arrival, is desirable. Address Frau Johanna Veit, Oberammergau, Bavaria. fers to brews TICHARDSON, | DR. FRANCIS P, SPRAGUE, Boston, Mass. DR. HASKET DERBY, Winter Tour. A piae-Gese pe flor a will sail Jan 20, by North German for — in, ey Greece Tees ty iiviera, - tion), ‘and London, Duration of tri “7 months, Send’ at once for itineraries and references to MRS. M. D. FRAZAR, 72 Globe Building, - + Boston, Mass. THE CRAWFORD TOURS. Oriental parties leave New York February 17 and April {8. Escorted tours to all parts Orient of,,the world. Independent steamship and Pari railway tickets. Special inducements to clubs TiS and societies. Illustrated pitineraries free. and CRAWFORD & FLOYD oes Tremont Passion Building, Boston ; 220 Bro St. Paul Play. Ruilding, New Yo rk City; old “Cl estnut St.. Philade phia; 621 Marquette Building,Chicago, GATES’ MEXICO TOURS. 33 days’ tour by special train de Lue, leaving 4 node? 22d and February 28th. Inclusive charge, covering rai road fare, ae ang-cer, hotels, guides, etc., Boston $340, New York $337, Buffalo $325, Chica: go Wine St. Louie $290, Denver * $280. Optional route via Cuba. Tickets cee to start South at any time. Send for ro am. CHAS. H. GATES, Toledo, Ohio, or W.H. EA » 201 pe 8t., Boston. PARIS AND EUROPE IN 1900. Private ates conducted by Prof, CAMILLE THUR- WANGER, 31 Pierce Building, Boston. Pocket Guide Book ot Paris fr free; , send stamp. The Resorts. EUROPEAN WINTER’ RESORT, INNSBRUCK, TYROL, AUSTRIA. 1,900 feet above the sea, with dry, bracing climate HOTEL TIROL. Open all the year. Modern conveniences. Best references. Illustrated = hlets on application. CARL LANDSEE, Proprietor. A Beautiful Winter Home IN FLORIDA To be Sold to Close an Estate. Send for Booklet. Estate of Bela Hubbard, Detroit, Michigan. We buy and sell bills of oxcpange to LETTERS and make ane Kare | of Money Mr also make eectians and issue Com- CREDIT. mercial and Travellers Credits avail- able in all parts of the world. BROWN BROTHERS & CO. NO. 59 WALL STREET, NEW YORK. TRANSLATIONS AND REPRINTS. Nos. 4, 5,6. 25 cents each. Letters of the Crusaders. 3d Edition. The French mevetution. 2d Edition, Constitutiona! ! Documents. 2d Edition. Oirenlars DEPARTMENT OF peneny, on application, Univ, of Pa., Phil
Page 3
_The Nation. FORTIETH ANNUAL STATEMENT OMeC LTC SNSUTANCEC VO. CEORCE E. IDE, President, NO. 256 BROADWAY, NEW YORK. JANUARY 1ST, 1900. ASSETS. LIABILITIES. ne ee a $3,49.,071.00 Policy Reserve (Per Certificate of Real Eatates os narwet value). --scvcvvcocos SiR gea | New York Insurance Department) pops Collateral Loans Loans to Policy-holders Interest and Rents Due and Accrued Total Admitted Assets INCO — Cash in Banks and Trust Companies...... cere eee enes seen eeeeee Premiums in transit and Deferred Premiums less cost of collection............e. vane ME IN 1899. dante s Soni $1,889, 180.64 POCO SCHOO ESE eOH OT eereseseoce 22,400.00 1,080,247,93 206,714.78 43,600.42 ment Dividends) All Other Liabilities Net Surplus 482. 940.95, Total Payments. Accumulations DISBURSEMENTS Including Death Claims, Matured Endowments and Annuities. : Dividends to Policy-holders..... \ Suvendor Weicesecsus Balance—Excess Income over Disbursements Present Value of all Dividend-Endow (Deferred 626,713.00 106,454.70 1,203,278.42 $11,348,859.12 IN 1899, $1. (46. 887.00 $761,592.68 | 164,714.37 112,001.42 725,243.50 Total BN i die) cogs diva ers en #2.372.130.59 | Total Disbursements and Balance......... £2,572, 190,59 NUMBER OF POLICIES IN ForcE, 26,262, being an increase of.............. a ee re eee een er ee 1,987 AMOUNT OF INSURANCE IN FORCE, $49,258,697.00, being an increase of........ eee $3,684,316.00 PREMIUM INCOME INCREASED $41, 12 for every 31,000 gain in Insurance in Force. RECEIVED FROM PoLicy-HOLDERS since organization (1860)........4.0cecceceee eee eee: $32,887 ,028.95 RETURNED to PoLicy-HOLpERs and now held for their benefit............--20ec ee cece eee eee eee een eeeeees $33,341,452.86 ‘ RESULTS OF THE YEAR 1899. $ PER CENT PER CENT Renee Ti WOURE TROUIIR, 5 6 oscec cn Sess ccaceeedebeveeecee 7.23 | Increase in Insurance in Force 8.08 ss \ New Premium Income,..........+.-..++++++. 6.69 | * Deferred Dividend Fund. , 18.90 “ ‘¢ Renewal Premium Income................... 9.87 | F to Tuas less ar a) $6 wa lO eae 7.48 * Insurance in Force to Insurance Issues mi oe ee 8 10 | Increase in eres ceeeee 4.35 ELLIS W. GLADWIN, Secretary. F. W. CHAPIN, Medica! Director. WM. M. ST. JOHN, Vice-President. WwW. A. MARSHALL, Actuary. WM. G. LOW, Counsel. The Divina Commedia and Canzoniere of Dante Alighieri. ' Translated, with Notes and Studies, by the late E. H. P.umprre, D.D., Dean of Wells. Five volumes, each with Frontispiece and Index of Subject and Names. LIBRARY EDITION. May alot uncut edges. Five vol oe, ing bo STUDENT'S ofothe i iémo. Price, me, - enta. Any volume in the Student's D. C. HEATH & CO., Publishers, Boston. New York. Chicago. London.- CLARENDON PRESS PUBLICATIONS. For sale by all booksellers. Send for Catalogue. OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS, (American Branch) 91 sth Ave., New York. at WM. Le os FRENCH BOOKS “82 Complete Catalogue on Ri. wB A, Readers and Writers have been Waiting for this Up-to-Date, Pull-of-Matter, Moderate-Priced Reference Book, THE STUDENTS’ STANDARD DICTIONARY. AN ABRIDGMENT OF Funk & Wagnalls’ Standard Dictionary Large 8vo, 933 pages, cloth, leather back, net, $2.50; Sheep, $4.00; Indexed, 50c. additional. Contains 60,000 Words and Phrases, and 1,225 Pictorial Illustrations. Sent postpaid on receipt of price by The Baker & Taylor Co. 5 and 7 East 16th St., New York. To recetve the current numbers in a convenient (temporary) form. Sub- stantially made, bound in cloth, with Taz Na- TION stamped on the side in gold. Holds about one volume. Papers easily and neatly adjusted. Sent, postpaid, on re- celpt of 75 cents. LEMCKE & BUECHNER’S The Old Masters UNDER THE TITLE Monoarapbs on Flctists INCLUDES NOW Raphael Holbein Rembrandt Van Dyck Profusely fliustrated $1.50 each. Others in preparation LEMCKE & BUECHNER PUBLISHERS 812 dheutesaniieds New York Tastefully bound Brentanos Edition ooae “STANDAR ERAGLASS —_. ‘L
Page 4
iv The Nation. [Vol. 70, No. 1803 JUST READY The Macmillan Company’s LATEST ISSUES Or Lirerary, Dramatic, PHILOSOPHICAL, AND EccLEsIASTICAL INTEREST Tennyson, Ruskin, Mill Ano Orner Literary Estimates. By FREDERIC HAR- RISON, author of «* The Meaning of History,’’ etc. Cloth, 1z2mo. $2.00 Essays containing a series of systematic estimates of some important and typical influences on modern thought. Among others whose work is discussed are Matthew Arnold, John Addington Symonds, Lamb and Keats, Gibbon, Froude and Freeman. The Drama of Yesterday and To-day By CLEMENT SCOTT. Two volumes. $8.00 An illustrated record of the Victorian drama, full of personal interest. Besides the many anecdotes resulting from the author’s long personal acquaint- ance with the most prominent actors and playwrights, there have been reproduced facsimiles of old playbills, letters, and other documents, with many portraits. Brook Farm. Its Members, Scholars, and Visitors. By LINDSAY SWIFT. Cloth, $1.25. The second volume of the series of ‘‘ Nationat Strupres in American Lerrers,’’ edited by Gzorce E. Woopserry, of which the first volume to appear was T. W. Higginson’s charming book of reminiscences entitled ‘* Old Cambridge. ”’ The Life and Letters of Archbishop Benson Edited by ARTHUR CHRISTOPHER BENSON. With portraits, etc. Two volumes. $8.00 A book of singular interest on both personal and public groun is. ‘« That one cannot help receiving a true impression of a man of intense vigor and decision, of eager life and lively faith, is one of its greatest advantages over the usual biography.’’— The Boston Herald. Lights and Shadows of a Long Episcopate Being Reminiscences and Recollections of the Rt. Rev. HENRY BENJAMIN WHIPPLE, Bishop of Minnesota. With portrait, etc. Second Edition. $5.00 ‘* The volume is unique and most attractive.”’—The Living Church. An Awnnuat BiocrapHicaL Dictionary. Who’s Who, 1900 52d year of issue. 12mo, cloth, $1.75 OF AISTORICAL INTEREST The Story of France By the Hon. Tuomas E, Watson. Vol. If. $2.50. It is of this volume that The Evening Telegraph, Philadelphia, said: ‘‘The public will await it impatiently. the period of the great Revolution, which will naturally be the crown of the entire work. the notice of the world,” Pompeii: Its Life and Art By AUGUST MAU. University of Michigan. Translated by Francis W. Ketsey, Illustrated. $6.00 ret THE FICTION 53D THOUSAND Via Crucis A Romance of the Second Crusade By F,. MARION CRAWFORD, Author of « Corleone,’’ ‘« Casa Braccio,’’ etc., etc. [Illustrated by Louis Logs. Buckram. $1.50 ** For color, emotional intensity, vitality, and individua. action, and charm of style, Mr. Crawford unquestionably exceeds every other living writer Of prose romance,’’— Chicago Inter Ocean. * One of the best if not the very best of his stories. nificent romance,'’— The Independent, A mag- The Favor of Princes By MARK LEE LUTHER. A Novel of Adventure in the time of Louis XV. Cloth, 12mo, $1.50 ** Exceedingly interesting.’'~-Inter Ocean, Chicago. ** A better written and more absorbing book would be hard to find.’’ Boston Budget. Complete in Two Volumes, $5.00. Therein, of course, the author will describe We have every right to expect it to be an exposition which will attract The United Kingdom A Pouiricat History. By GOLDWIN SMITH, author of «*The United States,’’ etc. Two volumes. $420 THE DAY 5 310TH THOUSAND Richard Carvel By WINSTON CHURCHILL, author of «The Celebrity.”’ Illustrated by Cartton T, Cuapman and Matcoim Fraser. Cloth, 1zmo, $1.50 OF ‘* Full of good things . . . The Daily Telegraph, London. ‘* A tremendously good story.’’——-Rewiew of Reviews, interesting, vivid, and picturesque, ’’— ** An enduring piece of work.’’—~The American, Philadelphia. Henry Worthington, Idealist By MARGARET SHERWOOD, author of «*An Experiment in Altruism,’’ ete. A Study of sociological questions. Cloth, 12mo, $1.50 “ Of absorbing interest apart from the problem it contains; certain to arouse wide discussion,’'-—- Tribune, Chicago. THE MACMILLAN COMPANY, 66 Fifth Ave., New York
Page 5
NEW YORK, THURSDAY, JANUARY 18, 1900. The Week. Senator Hoar rendered an important service to the cause of human freedom by the few words of reply which he ut- tered at the conclusion of Senator Beve- ridge’s speech on Tuesday week. Al- though he had announced his purpose to make a set speech on the subject of the debate, he saw the importance of pricking without delay the gas bag that the Indiana Senator had been so long in- flating. This was done neatly and ef- fectively by calling attention to the fact that, in the whole of Mr. address, so carefully prepared and print- ed and distributed before delivery, the words right, justice, duty, and freedom were wholly wanting. He went on to say that ‘“‘practically every statement of fact in Senator Beveridge’s speech was refuted by reports received from Admi- ral Dewey, Gen. Otis, and other official sources.” This was a most sweeping statement, justifiable only by knowledge of the existence of reports from those of- ficers which have not yet been made public. That such documents exist, or that Senator Hoar believes they exist, was made manifest by the resolution of inquiry which he at once introduced, asking for copies of all official communi- cations to or from Aguinaldo or any other person commanding or represent- ing the forces in hostility to the United States in the Philippines. In a subse- quent letter, Senator Hoar makes more definite reference to this unpublished cor- respondence, saying that he has him- self read some of these letters, and that they establish the fact that Aguinaldo is an honest, patriotic, and brave man, and is the chosen leader of the Philip- pine Islands. From other sources the report has gained currency that, at the time when the President sent his pro- clamation to the Filipinos which Gen. Otis altered on account of its incendiary character, peace had been practically se- cured. It has been rumored of late that the naval and military authorities in the Philippines, before the President’s proclamation was received, were on the point of coming to an arrangement with Aguinaldo, by which hostilities would have been avoided altogether. If such are the facts, then the responsibility for all the waste of blood and treasure that has taken place since we bought or took the islands, rests on William McKinley. Beveridge’s Senator Beveridge has received a se- cond lashing from the Republican side of the chamber, and from an unexpected Senator Wolcott took the same quarter. The ‘must hold Manila line of criticism as Mr. Hoar in a rather more picturesque manner. The immoral character of Beveridge’s discourse on the wealth of the Philippines upon which we were to gorge ourselves, was held up to indignant scorn, and his highfalutin rhetoric was riddled with merciless sar- casm. Mr. Wolcott was not wholly free from highfalutin himself, but it was of a better kind that Beveridge’s. He gave his attention also to the pretentious talk about the glory we were to acquire from an honest administration of the Philip- pine government. that all was ridiculous,” he pointing a lot of Indiana politicians in the Philippines and letting the reflected glory of the republic shine across the seas.”” It is true that Mr. Wolcott favors holding the Philippines as a matter of duty, or what he considers to be duty, but of the moral tur- pitude of Beveridge’s plea for pelf was something for which he deserves hearty thanks. ‘With the municipal admitted it said, “to talk of ap- corruption existed, his exposure Senator Beveridge unconsciously put a knife into the very midriff of the Ad- ministration when he declared that we in order thence to “command the trade of China.” Then what has all the boasting been about, in connection with the “open door” in China? Are the diplomatic laurels to be plucked all green from Secretary Hay’s brows? We have been assured over and over again that the Administration, by obtaining an international agreement for equality of trade privileges through- out the whole Chinese Empire, had al- ready commanded the trade of China. Secretary Wilson was glorying in it pub- licly only the other day. England has been congratulating us on our great di- plomatic achievement. No one said word about Manila in the whole busi- ness. But now comes this tall talker of the Wabash and pours despite on the entire affair. If we do not hold Manila, that Chinese trade is for ever gone, he says, which the Administration had just informed us was for ever secured in quite another way. But the Indiana Senator seems to have a certain natural awk- wardness in support of his friends. a The influence of the political “pull” in the relations of the national Govern- ment with the banking business of the country is clearly illustrated in the re- velations regarding the selection, a few months ago, of the Seventh National Bank of this city as the depository of the post-office funds, in place of the Chase National Bank, which had long acted in that capacity. Those interested in bank- ing observed that some changes were Nation. dent. made in the Seventh National Bank last year, the most significant of which was of Perry Heath, First Assistant Posimaster-Gene- ral, and the selection of his t Fietcher S. Heath, as its Vic As these the accession as a director Ss. sprother, President Indianians had never prominent in the banking busine those Tle ath as i at once concluded that he was cay 1Z who knew Perry § ing his political influence, rather n his knowledge or This statutes enable experience as fly been proved Post-office D ment, instead of the Trea: the in kept, and the First cler, has now which its. fund Assistant P ter-General soon took this privilege fre National, which bank and ave it te He director and his brother the the Chase ath was a Viece-P1 Heath bank, William H. Kimball, was perfectly frank bank of Perry 38 The President of the in explaining the matter to a Herald re- porter on Friday. ing: He is quoted as say “It is a case of business competition, and political influence counts. The man who can pull the most wires successfully often wins.” The bearing of all this upon the ques- tion of our expansion policy is plain and important. The spread-eagle orator from Indiana said in the the day, that “the men we send to adminis- ter civilized government in the Philip- pines must be themselves the highest ex- amples of our civilization’; that no one need “fear that our party workers wilil seek to fill these places without regard to fitness’; but that “I know well this most maligned and most valuable class of American citizens, the precinct Gom- mitteemen in the country districts of the republic; and if we truthfully, bravely the tion at the outset, these very politicians will insist most strenuously of all on the highest possible qualifications in the ad- Sen- ator Beveridge, of course, speaks of his. own State. Perry S. Heath is the most prominent Republican party worker in Indiana. He has already shown that he considers it entirely proper for the First Assistant Postmaster-General chairman of a national partisan commit- tee, to “take a week off’ in order to man- age the Republican side of the fight for the control of Kentucky, and to get him- self and his brother into the directorate of a New York bank, with using his place in the department to se- cure favors for that bank. Was anything more ridiculous than the claim that the Perry 8S. Heaths, who insist upon having the offices at home and running them on the basis of the political “pull,” will insist upon model adminis- Senate, other and party workers situa- state ministration of our possessions.” to act as a view to ever
Page 6
42 The Nation. {Vol. 70, No. 1803 tration in managing the government of the Philippines? How to get Cuba annexed to the Unit- ed States with the least amount of trou- ble from the Cubans, and with the small- est apparent violation of the promises made by our Government, is the evident aim of the committee on colonial rela- tions of the Senate, if we may credit a Washington telegram in the Sun. The committee, it says, will visit Cuba to learn from actual observation how much time will be required to bring the isl- and under the influence of American ideas and American methods. The jour- ney will be made in February. The tele- gram continues: “It is evidently the prevailing sentiment among the members of this committee that the annexation of Cuba will ultimately re- sult, and perhaps at no distant day. In the meantime, the Cubans will enjoy that independence promised them in the resolu- tions of Congress which brought on the war with Spain. According to one member of the committee, annexation will be brought about by a perfectly natural process of transition.”’ It is to be hoped that the committee will include in their inquiries the question, how much time will be required to bring American institutions under the influ- ence of Cuban ideas and Cuban methods. Under our form of government political action and reaction are equal. The “pull” which Cuba will have on_ the United States will be, like the pull of the planets on each other, in proportion to her mass. On this subject read the speech delivered by ex-Gov. Boutwell at the anti-imperialist meeting in Washing- ton on Thursday evening. £ The report comes from Washington that Quay’s case and Clark’s case for seats in the Senate are somehow joined together. If they are not joined, they ought to be. Both represent the very worst side of American politics. Quay has been known and read of all men for twenty years. His character has been established ‘‘from way back.” Clark is a new comer, and it appears from the testimony taken in his case that a seat in the Senate from Montana goes to the highest bidder for cash, and is obtaina- ble in no other way. The revelations made in this case are positively sicken- ing. They are as bad as the stories we read of Roman elections in the last days of the republic. It is related, as the acme of corruption at that time, that a deposit was once made of 800 talents to secure the consulship. We should judge that this had been done in Montana to seat Clark, and that 800 more had been deposited to unseat him. ‘Mr. Kasson encounters difficulties in explaining the advantages of the reci- procity treaty with France to the Senate committee on foreign relations, He seems to have made a very painful impression by remarking that in the tariff act of 1897 many of the rates were intentionally made higher than necessary, in order to render it easier to negotiate reciprocity treaties. A number of prominent Con- gressmen are reported to have declared such a statement wholly unwarranted. They are shocked at the idea that Con- gress should have been actuated by such mercenary considerations. Mr. Kasson may have been rather blunt in his lan- guage, but really the tariff act speaks for itself. It provides that, “with a view to secure reciprocal trade,’”’ treaties may be made with foreign countries, which, in consideration of the advantages to the United States of tariff concessions by those countries, shall reduce the” duties that we impose on the importation of some of their products. These treaties are to be made “with a view to the arrange- ment of commercial agreements in which reciprocal and equivalent concession may be secured in favor of the products and manufactures of the United States.” It is preposterous to contend that the rates in our tariff were not determined with reference to this contingency. The peo- ple who settle our tariff duties are not so guileless as to have adopted rates without thinking of the possibility of re- ciprocity treaties. Of course they will oppose any reductions by treaty or legis- lation, but they need not pretend that the tariff was not framed with the pros- pect of “reciprocal and equivalent con- cessions” distinctly in view. The only tenable ground is to assert that the con- cessions to be obtained from France are not ‘“‘equivalent” to those to be made by the United States. The mind of the ordinary protectionist must be painfully confused by the exi- gencies of imperialism. The President’s message bore a startling resemblance to a Cobden Club essay, and the Republican papers are filled with insidious repre- sentations of the benefits of free trade, Beyond question the mainstay of protec- tion in this country has been the belief that the high standard of living attain- ed by American labor was due to the tariff. Protective duties excluded the products of cheap labor and gave the American market to American labor. But here is the New York Tribune publish- ing*views completely subversive of the protectionist faith. It prints an inter- view with a Gen. Stone, who goes so far as to ridicule the cheap-labor argu- ment, to sneer at the tariff, and to insin- uate that free trade with our new con- quests is something required by philan- thropy and the Christian religion. This renegade protectionist, who professes to have “stood by protection to American labor through thick and thin,” says that the argument that “one-half the people in Puerto Rico live on 5 cents a day or less” is convincing only to stupid people. However correct this statement may ap- pear from our point of view, it is evi- dent that a sincere protectionist ought to regard it as highly esoteric doctrine. It is profaning the mysteries to give it publicity. Gen. Stone says that the American workman might like to have an orange, or a banana, or a pineapple, or a good cigar to smoke without paying the price of a Havana. ‘He might even like to have fresh winter vegetables without paying the hothouse price, but he finds that tobacco and vegetables are not worth raising in Puerto Rico, and delicious fruits not even worth picking because of the high tariff here, while American flour, meat, and manufactures are shut out from the island by the tariff which we impose there.” It is certainly doubtful if a paper which prints such underhand attacks on the tariff as this ought to be allowed in a protectionist household. In order to avert a suspension of building operations in Chicago, the labor unions have abandoned many of their ex- travagant demands. Affairs had come to such a pass that builders no longer dared to take contracts, not knowing in what losses future orders of the walk- ing-delegates might involve them. Noi only were they required to employ union labor and to use union material, but that material had to be of home production, regardless of the fact that better goods could be purchased from outside the city at less cost. On top of that, the unions claimed the right to determine the maxi- mum amount of labor which their mem- bers should do in a day, at a price fixed by themselves. It was an attempt to ar- bitrarily provide work for everybody at good wages, and it nearly resulted in throwing all the building trades workers out of employment, By the agreement now made between the unions and the contractors, the latter are free to get their material anywhere, always provid- ed that it is of union production, while the matter of unreasonable restrictions upon the amount of work done, and questions of apprentices, of sympathetic strikes, and of the usurpation of walk- ing-delegates, are to be referred to arbi- tration. The unions retain, among other things, the “right” to fix the wage scale, but they have surrendered much. Even a Labor Trust has limitations, albeit it does not fear the Attorney-General. Louisiana Republicans think that they see in Democratic disaffection over the nomination of Heard for Governor, at the dictation of Gov. Foster, an opportu- nity for something more than a for- lorn-hope campaign. The situation is much the same as in 1896, when a coali- tion of the Republican factions with the Populists nearly overthrew the Demo- crats, and an attempt is making to re- new that coalition. An agreement for united primaries and conventions has 2s ESN RIS I ee Sts et Pe : ef
Page 7
Ar ee egg Ra a Malta aay Ree ye ee HST eee a Jan. 18, 1900] ae been entered into between the Regulars and the Sugar Republicans, the line of division between which factions appears to have been nearly wiped out by the Democratic disfranchisement of the il- literate negroes. With no longer any fear of negro domination in the State, the Sugar Republicans, many of whose leaders are seceders from the Democra- tic party on protection grounds, and who have shown hitherto all the Southern Democrat’s antipathy to the negro in politics, now argue in favor of welcom- ing to the party fold the intelligent ne- groes left on the registry lists. They have surrendered their title to the ap- pellation of “Lily-White Republicans,” the primary call just issued by their committee inviting all Republicans, “without distinction as to race or color.” There are many men of character and standing in this organization, and out of it may perhaps come what some intelli- gent Democrats foresaw in negro dis- franchisement—the creation of a strong opposition party which disaffected Demo- crats may join without losing caste. The reports of the Mazet committee have been so thoroughly discounted in advance that only a languid interest is felt in the full text. The majority, of course, try to unload the full responsi- bility for the present misgovernment of New York city upon Tammany. The character of the administration is fairly summarized when it is styled ‘“‘the most perfect instance of centralized party gov- ernment yet known; government no longer responsible to the people, but to a Dictator; the central power, not the man who sits in the Mayor’s chair, but the man who stands behind it; the powers of government prostituted to protect cri- minals, to demoralize the police, to de- bauch the public conscience, and to turn governmental functions into channels for private gain.” But it is hardly a fair implication to give the impression that “a majority of the voters of Greater New York are satisfied with the present sys- tem, theory, and practice of govern- ment.” The present administration re- presents a minority of the voters. More than 300,000 ballots were cast for Mayor in 1897, of which Van Wyck received only 143,666, or more than 6,000 short of half. The followers of Seth Low, Ben- jamin F. Tracy, and Henry George cast a total of 155,916 votes, and everybody fa- miliar with the facts knows that the hearty support of Low by the Republi- can machine would have elected him. The investigation into the affairs of the State Trust Company has revealed the interesting fact that “Lou” Payn, not a great while ago, borrowed from that institution $435,000. This loan was made to a man against whom judgments had been filed, over and over again, from his early manhood in 1859 down to within less than three years of his appointment The Nation. 43 as Superintendent of Insurance in this be kept from exporting coin by the loss State in 1897. Some of these judgments had not been satisfied when he assumed office. Payn, of course, insists that the securities which he furnished as a basis for this loan were good, but the better they were, the greater the surprise that a man with such a financial record before becoming head of the Insurance Depart- ment early in 1897 should enjoy this high rank among capitalists before the end of 1899. Quite aside from any question of Payn’s character and standing before his appointment by Gov. Black, what im pression must be made upon the pub- lic mind by the discovery that an official occupying such a fiduciary position as that of Insurance Superintendent is en- gaged in great speculative schemes? Mr. Dorman B. Eaton could hardly have made a better disposition of the sums left by him to Harvard and Colum- bia Universities, than by his requirement that they be used in founding professor- ships in the science of government and municipal administration. In this de- partment at Harvard there has for years been a particular weakness, which has not failed to attract attention, and has led students of civics to seek other col- leges for what they could not find in the Cambridge curriculum. There could be no more fitting time than the present to endow a professorship to “vindicate and strengthen” the “great principles upon which our national Constitution is bas- ed,” and to point out “the obligations of the moral law and of patriotic en- deavor in party politics and all official life.’ Nor could any better place be found than a college in the city of New York in which to found a chair to “gather municipal wisdom from the most enlightened cities,” and to make good city government “the ambition and en- deavor of the worthiest citizens.” It is truly gratifying that the influence of a man who, from the purest of motives, devoted his life to the betterment of the governments under which he lived, should continue to be felt in institutions to which the country must look for some of its most ardent reformers and patri- otic citizens. A very desirable reform has at last been adopted by the Government in the matter of the charges of the Assay Office for gold bars. Hereafter these bars will be furnished by the Assay Office at a charge of four cents per $100, instead of ten cents. The charge was raised to ten cents some years ago on the theory that gold might thus be kept in the country. The reasoning of the Treasury officers was that, by making it expensive to ob- tain gold bars, the sordid bankers who wanted to export gold when it was need- ed here would be balked. They would find their miserable profit cut off by the charge for gold bars, while they would | from abrasion which would appear when the coin was melted in foreign mints. This petty expedient for maintaining the solvency of the United States Treasury was on a par with the device anclently resorted to in times of panic in Eng- land, of paying depositors in sixpences. There is nothing better in Adam Smith's writings than the chapter in which he examines the effect of the export duties on specie formerly imposed in Spain, and demonstrates the futility and the posi tive mischief of all such measures. The charge of ten cents per $100 for gold bars no doubt discouraged their export; but coin was exported instead, and the Government was, therefore, put to the expense and waste of coinage, to say no- thing of the charges for transperting bullion and coin between New York and Philadelphia. It raised its charge for a service which cost it very little, and was compelled by its own act to render ser- vices which cost it a good deal. No one pretends that the movement of gold was checked by this paltry measure, and it is hardly necessary to say that it did not increase confidence in the solvency of the Treasury. When a man is found to be taking steps to stave off his obliga- tions, his credit is not improved. We may reasonably expect that the begin- ning of the next century will find the Government permanently relieved from the temptation to resort to such contemp- tible means for maintaining its solvency. The English Government appears to have receded from its first contention that food is contraband of war. That we take to be the meaning of its release of the cargoes of American flour, and its announcement that it will not regard provisions as contraband “unless intend- ed for the enemy.” By the enemy is meant armed opponents in the field. Food for the enemy’s country is another thing. It is legitimate to try to reduce men in arms by cutting off their supplies, but not to starve non-combatants. If such is the scope of the decision arrived at, we regard it as a great gain for inter- national law, and a wise thing for Eng- land. The status of food in time of war has been unsettled, and the present de- liberate action of Great Britain in taking it definitively off the contraband list will go far toward settling universal practice. England’s own interest is transparently against treating provisions as contra- band. Lord Rosebery wrate to the Lon- don Times on December 28, referring to the “disquieting intimations” that the Government was treating food-stuffs aa contraband, and calling for “an authori- tative statement’”’ on the matter of such “supreme importance.” He has now got it, and it is to the effect that England does not propose to take a position which might result in her being starved in case of war with a country owning a first- class navy.
Page 8
44
The Nation.
» [Vol. 70, No. 1803
EX ORIENTE LUX. A flood of light on the Philippine in- trigue is thrown by Admiral Dewey’s re- port to the Navy Department, dated Hong Kong, March 31, 1898. It was pub- lished for the first time on Thursday, having been sent to the Senate by spe- cial request. Dewey, like the careful of- ficer he was, had thoroughly investigated the state of the Spanish defences at Ma- nila, and expressed his confidence that he could reduce them and put the city at his mercy in a single day. He did exact- ly that one month later. It was, of course, strictly in the line of his duty to inform his Government respecting the military situation, and the Navy Depart- ment would have been inexcusable if it had not, at the time it telegraphed Dew- ey, been making up its mind what to do if war broke out. But the significant, the critical part of Dewey’s report is this: “There is every reason to believe that, with Manila taken or even blockad- ed, the rest of the islands would fal! either to the insurgents or ourselves.” Now it is not too much to say that this sweeps completely away the defence of our Philippine adventure which has been made by the President and his most ardent supporters. What is that defence? Why, that when the war began, this Gov- ernment never dreamed of annexing the Philippines. Dewey was sent only to de- stroy the Spanish fleet. That was a per- fectly legitimate operation, as both a blow to the military power of our enemy and a means of protecting our Pacific Coast. But, to the surprise and almost to the consternation of the President, he found that it would not do to recall Dew- ey’s squadron; that he must send troops; that he must take Manila and occupy Lu- zon, and that then, led on strangely by Destiny and Providence, he must, with many misgivings, much against his will, and in obedience only to a lofty sense of national duty, instruct our Paris Com- missioners to demand cession of the whole archipelago. This is no caricature of Mr. McKinley’s account of his Philip- pine stewardship. Read what he said in Boston on February 16, 1899: “The Phi- lippines were intrusted to our hands by the providence of God. It is a trust we have not sought.” In the light of Dewey’s report this now sounds uncommonly like a devout explanation by Ah Sin that the twenty- four packs in his sleeves found their way there providentially. Here was the Commodore of the squadron writing three weeks before war was declared. In answer to inquiries from his Govern- ment, he distinctly foreshadowed the seizure of the whole group. “The rest of the islands would fall either to the insurgents or ourselves.” This was in the hands of the Administration at the very time when it was asserting that the occupation of the islands was a pure afterthought, a dire military necessity unforeseen, an unexpected command of
God. What can we say now of such talk except that it was sheer hypocrisy? There have been many hints and indica- tions before that the annexation of the Philippines was a part of the Adminis- tration programme from the very first. People in the confidence of Admiral Dewey and Assistant Secretary Roose- velt, as he then was, have smiled know- ingly over the theory that nobody ever dreamed of our taking the Philippines. But now we have the first official docu- ment proving that the thing was contem- plated from the beginning. Is it any wonder that when Senator Sewell went to the President and begged him to or- der Dewey to sail away after the bat- tle of Manila Bay, lest complications arise and we be compelled to take over the islands, Mr. McKinley refused to comply? Dewey was there precisely in order to make the islands “fall to our- selves,” and the President knew it. He had a sure inkling of the vast designs of Providence in that matter, pecause he had been acting in the spirit of the old Puritan who said, when some one piously sighed, “Well, God mend all!” “Nay, we must help him to mend it!”*’ Only less important than Dewey’s re- port is the official “Report of Tour through Island of Luzon” made in No- vember, 1898, by two naval officers of Dewey’s squadron, and only now given to the public. Senator Hoar succeeded in extracting this valuable document from the Navy Department, and getting it printed in the Congressional Record. It is endorsed by Admiral Dewey as “the most complete and reliable information obtainable,” and it is no exaggeration to say that it completely snuffs out the speech of Senator Beveridge. These na- val officers, Messrs. Wilcox and Sargent, travelled for six weeks in the interior of Luzon, and discovered such evidences of general intelligence and ‘education, and good order and respect for the law, and patriotic aspiration, that the record is one, we should think, to bring a blush even to the cheek of the superior Lodge, who was again arguing last week that the Filipinos are but a set of savages, who ought to be only too happy to have us come and kill them in a civilized way. What is most encouraging about the whole situation is that light is beginning to dawn. Whenever the cover is taken off the Philippine iniquity, a fresh set of its defenders are struck dumb. Every new document which the Administration can be forced to publish is practically a new exposure of blundering or worse. More official reports are to come. Gen. Otis’s report, which so clearly convicts the President of being the one man re- sponsible for the war with the Filipinos, speaks of naval reports or representa- tions made from Manila in December, 1898. What were they? Was one of them a report from Dewey which, it has been alleged, the President quite disregarded and so floundered into his war? We shall soon know, for the Senate has asked for all the documents in the case, and if the Government does not give them up, its silence will be, like suicide, a confes- sion. In any case, the policy of secrecy and suppression is evidently drawing to its end. It is a most righteous “itch to know things” which the country at pre- sent has regarding these Philippine mys- teries; and the sooner we get to the bot- tom of the affair, the sooner we shall know whether it was Destiny, alias Providence, or an ambitious coterie of plotters at Washington, that got this white elephant of the Orient on our hands.
THE BANKERS AND THE TREASURY. The letters from two prominent bank- ers to the Secretary of the Treasury, which were made public by him last week, are not pleasant reading. Proba- bly no one who knows the authors of these letters would attribute to them any corrupt purpose. In one case the letter amounted merely to a suggestion that a delay in paying over to the Government a fund arising from the Central Pacific Railroad settlement would help the finan- cial situation. It was accompanied with -a statement that the call loans of the City Bank were at the time $56,000,000, and that the rates on the more specula- tive collaterals in Wall Street were high enough to force liquidation. The infe- rence is unavoidable that if the City Bank could retain the deposits of the Government for a week, it would make a large profit from their use. It could lend larger amounts, at very exceptional rates, Moreover, if the President of the bank were assured of this money for a week, while the public knew nothing of it. very profitable operations in stocks were possible. Very likely a public service would be rendered by such action as was suggested. Panic might be checked, fail- ures prevented, the normal and legiti- mate demands of borrowers be met. Nev- ertheless, these good results were to be produced by means that are scarcely de- fensible on any sound theory of govern- ment. The notion that the Secretary of the Treasury is a deus er machina, whose duty it is to relieve hard-pressed debtors and to maintain prices for those who have to unload, ought to be repudiated. Many people remember the unpleasant events under Gen. Grant’s Administra- tion, and we might fairly say that scan- dals have attended the relations of the Treasury with the banks during a large part of the existence of our government. The other letter is simply an illustra- tion of the demoralization resulting from the doctrine of political spoils. It was written in behalf of a bank which was already a Government depository, and which desired to remain such. There was no impropriety in making such a statement, nor in calling attention to the
financial strength of the bank. But the . Sania saa OS P< 5 Sesiheroe reper se
Nes Se R
Page 9
at ae i ES ped 3 DO ek RRS Ne aE aay ih, spa: pi be 4 Jan. 18, 1900] The Nation. 45 letter closed with the intimation that the directors of the bank had rendered great services to the Republican party, and that on that account the bank had claims on the United States Treasury. The natural meaning of these words is that the directors had contributed a great deal of money to the Republican cam- paign fund, and that they expected to be repaid in some fashion and in some degree by favors of the Treasury. Very likely the author of the letter was un- conscious of any impropriety in making such a suggestion. It was not intended as a request for any illegal favors. It was meant to remind the Secretary of the Treasury that in stich matters of dis- cretion as the choice of depositories of public funds, some regard should be had to the party services of bank directors. There is nothing more in this than is involved in the claim which all our poli- ticians believe in, and which most of them openly maintain, that the general Government is to be carried on for the immediate advantage of the managers of the dominant political party. The post- offices are to be filled with Republicans when they come into power. So are the custom-houses, the internal-revenue of- fices, the consulships, the departments in general. Some one must have the office, it is argued, and it is absurd to give it to aman who has done nothing for the suc- cess of the party, when those who have borne the burden and the heat of the day really need to be supported. In pre- cisely the same way it can be argued that, asthe Secretary of the Treasury is obliged to designate certain banks as depositories, it is reasonable that he should choose banks with good Republi- can directors. If there is any profit in these deposits, it ought to go to Repub- lican bankers under a Republican Ad- ministration; and it ought especially to go to such bankers as paid the most mo- ney to put the Republican Administra- tion in power. There is no question of loss to the Government; its deposits are well secured. It is simply a question of favoring Republican bankers who con- tribute to the party revenues, rather than Democratic bankers, or those who make no contributions. Let no one cast a stone against the bankers who wrote these letters unless he is ready to con- demn the spoils system, root and branch. We may profitably recall an episode in the political campaign of 1888. A letter from a Republican Senator was brought to light then, with very impor- tant political results. “If I had my way about it,” said the author of this letter, “I would put the manufacturers of Penn- sylvania under the fire, and fry all the fat out of them.” He also said: “I was solicited to contribute to a protective-ta- riff league, and I replied that... I did not propose myself to contribute money to advance the interests of men who were getting practically the sole benefit, or at least the most directly im- portant benefits, of the tariff laws.’’ This letter opened the eyes of many people to the true nature of protective legisla- tion. Those who are engaged in lines of business the profits of which are af- fected by foreign competition, pay libe- rally to elect Congressmen who will pass laws to protect them against competi- tors. When they have elected their Con- gressmen, they think that they own the Government. They have paid to consti- tute it in a particular way, for their particular pecuniary benefit. All our prominent manufacturers understand this very well, and never think of dis- puting it in private conversation. Bring the subject up, and they are very apt to mention some aggravated case of tariff favoritism. Bankers have until recent- ly been more exempt from this political demoralization, but the exigencies of 1896, when their business became a po- litical issue, were too much for many of them. Yet, in spite of the callousness of so many of our business men, there is a great volume of popular wrath at, and loathing for, the whole system of plutocracy, and had the Democrats a leader of real honesty and ability, he would be a formidable candidate for the Presidency. REFORM BY SOCIAL STIGMA. President Hadley’s address at Denver has been variously reported, and it would be obviously unfair to pin him down to any form of words put into his mouth by a newspaper. There appears to be no doubt, however, that he did in a general way advocate social ostracism as a wea- pon of moral and political reform. In particular he urged social punishments for men whose wealth has been acquired by dishonorable, or at least anti-social, means. ‘When,” said President Hadley, “it is understood that a man who does certain things cannot associate with his fellow-men, it will penetrate deeply into the social organism.’ Social disqualifi- cation, he added, and condemnation by public opinion, together make up the strongest force in the business and poli- tical world. To this we heartily agree. Granted that there were in any given community an austere and high-minded and well- organized and stable social opinion, which could be depended upon to put a stigma ‘upon the man who had heaped up riches by illicit means—especially upon a man who makes politics a mat- ter of buying and selling—no more pow- erful instrument for righteousness could well be imagined. Wealth is sought for social ends. No man would live labo- rious days to acquire money, did he not look upon it as the thing which would throw open to him, or at least to his children, the doors of social enjoyment. To sit down as a social pariah, though cushioned by millions of bank-notes, fs a wretched existence. Many an adven- turer in times past has mournfully asked himself, when lying outside the social breastworks, “Was it for this that I turn- ed such sharp corners, wrecked banks, and burst bubbles of speculation—-only to find myself flung out here?” A man who has reached wealth by “rubs and doub- lings and wrenches” finds himself more miserable than Midas if he cannot make it minister to his social cravings. He can travel, he can buy pictures as he would cotton, books as he would cord- wood, but what can he get out of all this but vanity and vexation of spirit” What he wants is the regard and recog- nition of the best people; and ws thoroughly endorse President Hadley’s contention that, if these could be with held from the shady capitalist, or the man who has fought his way to the top over the ruin of his own character and the wreck of other men’s fortunes, it would be an unequalled power making for righteousness. But, alas, where does this social Rha- damanthus exist? Where can we find this severe, this compact, this sensitive and scrupulous “society,” ready to ostra cise money that smells of blood or is tarnished by social crimes? We wish ws could think that there is such a thing any more in this country—in any appre- ciable force, we mean. Of course, there is a remnant of it in our large cities—a few families in Philadelphia whose glances still freeze the upstart specula tor; an inner circle in New York to se- cure entrance into which a man has to send in some other visiting-card than a certificate of deposit for $10,000,000; an intellectual élite in Boston that pours scorn uponthe manipulators of gas stocks and the deities of the caucus. But is it not the truth that our society as a whole has lost the power of scourging wealth unscrupulously gained, because it has capitulated to wealth as such? As luxury has swept in upon our social life, we have ceased to discriminate too sharply. If lavish living is the sign of social standing, then the man able to squander his thousands on social joys provides his own satisfactory cachet. President Hadley would find it very difficult to get “society” to ostracise the successful gam- blers in finance and politics when, in too many cases, its recognized ‘leaders’ are the very ones who would first have to go. The most we could get in the way of denunciation would be an application of Clough’s “Latest Decalogue”’: ‘Thou shalt not steal; an empty feat When ‘tis so Incrative to cheat." To bring this matter disagreeably home to the bosoms and business of New Yorkers, what social results may we expect to follow from the recent re- velations in the financial and political world? Will anybody “ostracise” the bankers who went on their knees to Platt to get a Government deposit? Will the men who let Payn and Sheehan
Page 10
46 The Nation. [Vol. 70, No. 1803 have enormous loans, with a well-under- stood political attachment, find their fel- lows looking askance at them? Even our political corruptionists we are at last recognizing socially. The moral harm that Gov. Roosevelt and President Low have done by sitting down amicably to breakfast with Platt is incal- culable. He was almost as much of a so- cial outcast as Hill, before these social eminences recognized him as an equal. But the power of discrimination in these matters seems almost gone; and our “society” will soon deserve George Wil- liam Curtis’s burlesque account of the rich noodle in Newport, looking about him.at the ball and saying complacent- ly and innocently, ‘Well, I see all the parvenus are here!”’ The churches have a terrible responsibility in this matter. Who does not remember the Presbyteri- an coquetting with Jay Gould? What Protestant church in this city would re- fuse a present of $50,000 from Platt to support a vested choir? What Catholic church would turn on Croker, bearing gifts, with an indignant, “Thy money perish with thee”? The pious Quay has founded a church in Pennsylvania, and, we do not doubt, would endow a the- ological seminary if necessary. At a certain stage of his career every wealthy corruptionist is said to fairly pine for a theological seminary to take his money, And what do the ecclesiastical—-yes, and the educational—authorities do in such cases except to imitate the old Scotch minister who told the dying skinflint that he could not guarantee that a gift to the church would save his soul, but that “the experiment was well worth trying’? But, when all this is said, we repeat that President Hadley is on the right track. He speaks for the ideal of so- ciety. What society should be is the great moral and reformatory power he alludes to. It should be separate and touch not the unclean thing. It should smite the evil-doer, though he be rich, with open scorn and pass a decree of perpetual banishment against him. We greatly need a quickening of our social sensitiveness, and the best way to in- duce it is to show what a power for good it might be made. Matthew Arnold said there could be no human perfection without society; and it is our business to make society the deadly foe of human imperfection, so that illegitimate wealth shall have the brand of social disquali- fication burned into it, and political tricksters, together with those who strike hands with them and hire them as bravos or panders, shall be made to lie in social outer darkness. “THE MILLS OF GOD.” About 1880 Mr. Joseph Chamberlain was emerging from Birmingham municipal poli- ties, making his appearance in the larger imperial arena, caucus in hand, and calling on the rich to pay ransom to the poor. I was naturally curious about his personality, and I wrote to a friend in England to ask what kind of man he was. My friend con- sulted a high authority, who told him, among other things, that ‘‘Chamberlain was the first politician of the American type that they had had in England, and would give a great deal of trouble.’’ I have been deeply impressed ever since with the acuteness of this observation. What this gentleman meant by the ‘American type’ was undoubtedly the kind of man who considers public questions with his ear to the ground, makes up his mind about them with strict reference to the next election, and changes that mind as he would change clothes, according to the season. It was evident almost from the first year of Cham- berlain’s political career that he was ‘on the make,’”’ as we say in America—not, of course, for money, since he did not need that, but in respect to his personal political fortune. He at once took up the Irish busi- ness, which then seemed the most promising one. Home rule had not yet made its ap- pearance, but the Irish under Parnell were threatening trouble. So they, as well as the poor, became in Chamberlain’s eyes the most wronged of mankind. It was then that he made that famous ‘Poland speech,”’ which bothered him so much afterwards, in which he compared the lot of the unhappy Irish to that of the Poles, ground down, by Russian tyranny. He cast in his lot thoroughly with the Irish, as well as with the poor. It was current gossip in Liberal circles at that time that he wanted to be Irish Secretary, and that it was the bestowal of the place on Lord Frederick Cavendish which implanted in Mr. Chamberlain that dislike of Mr. Gladstone which burned brightly in him long before Home Rule, and satisfied him that this bad old man was not a man for him to tie to. Mr. Chamberlain, however, soon showed himself to be too adroit a poli- tician and too powerful a debater to be ig- nored, and Gladstone had to give him ‘‘some- thing equally as good.’’ This was the presi- dency of the Board of Trade. I remember reading a speech of his at that period re- specting the failure of a shipping bill intro- duced by him, which failure he ascribed to the then wicked Lord Salisbury. I read one later, after he had joined the Conservatives, in which he ascribed it to the doubly wick- ed Mr. Gladstone. I dare say there exists some means of reconciling the two state- ments, but it is not within my reach. Every one remembers how Home Rule carried Mr. Chamberlain over to the Conser- vatives. I was in the House of Commons the night he made his final speech about this atrocious attempt to tear to pieces his beloved empire. His peroration, show- ing how much it all cost him internally, had a falsetto note, which, I observed, excited the smiles of my neighbors in the Speaker's Gallery. But he was now at the goal of his striving. He was in the best society of England, and had no longer any dealings with the wicked old Gladstone or the low Irish, and when the Conservatives should come in, he was sure of something. He got the Colonial Secretaryship. I am recalling these events, not so much for the purpose of discrediting Mr. Cham- berlain as for that of illustrating the moral government of the world. President Lincoln was not wrong in his second mes- sage in pointing out how nations and men are sure to atone some day for great errors or great crimes. Since Peel’s day the Eng- lish Tories have never been content with a statesman of their own order, taken from their own ranks. No one familiar with the character and prejudices and history of English gentlemen would have believed for a moment beforehand that a Jewish literary adventurer, however clever of speech, living by his wits, would have the slightest chance of a political career among them. But Disraeli had a most successful one, and rose so high in English social and political life that he had a narrow escape from being put in ‘orders’? and made Archbishop of Can- terbury. His antics amused them, and his cleverness saved them trouble. Neverthe- less, it seemed unlikely that he would soon have a successor. But he was hardly dead when his successor turned up. For a lite- rary adventurer was substituted a dealer in screws, a powerful debater, with no con- victions to speak of, and a vaulting ambi- tion. Home Rule, which turned so many English heads, and made the most distin- guished public man they have had since Pitt a favorite object of the billingsgate of the upper classes, gave them Chamberlain as their man-of-all-work; and Lord Salis- bury, able as he is, succumbed to him, just as he succumbed to Disraeli. He does not seem to have checked him once in his crazy colonial policy. Who will say now that Providence has not: in this way, dark and mysterious though it be, avenged the famous “wrongs of Ireland’’? Could there be a more grateful topic of conversation, even among the chiefs and ladies bright in “the Halls of Tara,” than the manner in which the great anti- Home-Rule Colonial Secretary had been “euchered’” by a Dutch farmer into a bloody war for which he was not pre- pared, and in which the one “neglected es- tate” that he had undertaken to “culti- vate” proved to be a nest of ten-pound hor- nets? Verily, the mills of God grind slowly, but they grind exceeding small. BE. L. $ THE WINTER EXHIBITIONS. LONDON, January 1, 1900. As I sit down to write, I hear drums in the street below—probably the Volunteers on their way to the Guildhall to be sworn in. I can see nothing, for London is wrap- ped—choked—in a thick, wet, gray fog. There could not be a more melancholy open- ing to the new year. It scarcely seems a moment when Englishmen are likely to spare much thought for pictures, or time for galleries. But it just so happens that the winter exhibitions at the Academy and the New Gallery have seldom been inore inte- resting; the one supplementing the other, ° and both together giving as complete and representative a collection of the Flemish masters as could well be got together in one place, unless the national galleries of the world combined to arrange it. And after all, however absorbing other mat- ters may seem at this crisis, Van Byck and Memling, Rubens and Van Dyck, will live long after Kriiger and Chamberlain, Joubert and Buller, are but names! The idea, of course, originated in the Van Dyck celebrations at Antwerp last summer. The Academy had already been so successful in repeating the Rembrandt show of Amsterdam that the new oppor- tunity for a good winter exhibition was not é 4
Page 11
Jan. 18, 1900] The Nation. 47 to be overlooked; especially as it would be even easier to represent Van Dyck in Lon- don than Rembrandt. All the finest pic- tures at Antwerp, with the exception of the famous “Lord Wharton” that belongs to the Hermitage, came from England, where there were many more, as every one knew, that had not been trusted out of the country. This being decided upon, the directors of the New Gallery were wise enough to make their show an introduc- tion to the Academy, by completing in it the representations of the Flemish school up to the time of Van Dyck, and also a sequel by including a few examples of the English portrait-painters who were Van Dyck’s direct descendants. The work has been done as well as it could be, I fancy, under the conditions. In a loan collection you must take not al- ways what you want, but what you can get. The historical sequence is somewhat interrupted by the great gulf between the Primitives and Rubens, and again between Van Dyck and Reynolds and Gainsborough. But still, it suggests, if it does not fol- low in every stage, the development of Flemish art that led from the early im- mature performances of the old Guildsmen to the masterpieces of the greatest of the Flemings, and then, through their influence, to the portraits of the most distinguished group of painters England can boast. If you turn immediately from the austere, firm, uncompromising realism of the Van Eycks to the elegant, delightfully artificial conventions of Reynolds and Gainsborough, it may seem impossible to believe in any relation between them. But the two ex- hibitions supply many of the connecting links. At the New Gallery the room devoted to the Primitives is most satisfactory—that is, from the historical standpoint. I do not think any pictures suffer as grievously as theirs from being seen, a great number to- gether, in a gallery. These early painters almost always worked for a definite decora- tive purpose. Their Virgins and Christs, their saints and angels, were intended to serve as altar-pieces, to adorn reliquaries, to become a part of church or convent walls. They were never meant to be looked at apart from their surroundings. Did we not realize but yesterday the difference between the decorations of Puvis de Cha- vannes, when they hung in the Champ-de- Mars Salon, and when, afterwards, they were in their place in the building for which they were designed? The early mas- ters lose still more, for in the gallery we are doubly conscious of their imperfections and limitations, it is difficult to judge of the decorative merit of their work, and there is no longer the sentiment of place that can make us forgive and even rejoice in their failures. Take Memling in Bruges, as the most striking example: I, for one, should not like to say how much my pleasure in him there comes from the innumerable as- sociations of the quiet old Hospital, from the impressions of fFromentin passing through the same rooms, from (perhaps) the exaggerated melancholy of Rodenback in his Bruges-la-Morte. But Memling in London, at the New Gallery, away from Bruges and its charm and glamour, becomes but the painter to be catalogued, classified, but a good subject for the ingenuity of the scien- tific critic. The pictures attributed to him yesterday are to-day labelled with some one else’s name; his name to-morrow may be on a dozen pictures never hitherto claim- ed for him. He is a specimen to be studied, as the chemist studies his gases or the doc- tor his microbes. I do not deny that a certain amount of exact classification is an excellent thing, but when it turns art into archmwology, when the art critic adopts the methods of the lite- rary critic whose only interest in Shakspere is to prove that he was Bacon, then I do not see that any good is accomplished. This is particularly true of many of the Primitives, who, to be honest, are not worth all the talk there is about them. Since the pre-Raphael- ites, there has been a sort of superstition that the Primitives were, until the middle of this century, the only painters who went to nature for inspiration, when the truth is, never were painters so hampered by for- mulas imposed upon them. They could, I admit, in matters of detail, work with the realism of the Van Eycks. When, occa- sionally, they escaped from the religious subjects usually demanded from them, they did go to nature, apparently with relief, and, as far as it was possible within their limitations, with quite amazing results. Who can forget that wonderful portrait of Gio- vanni Arnolfini and his wife by Van Eyck in the National Gallery? And here, in the New Gallery, continually, through an open window or beyond the Christ Crucified or the Virgin and Child Enthroned, you look to a charming little landscape, or to the towers and battlements of a medieval town set upon a hill, full of careful observation and dis- tinctly individual in treatment. But in car- rying out a religious motive certain things were expected of them by the patrons for whom they worked, and the consequence is a monotony in design and method that really is the second reason why it is a mistake to see so much of their work together. I have always felt this in the rooms full of Primitives in the great national collection —as must everybody else whose emotions have not been duly manufactured before- hand; and I feel it again in the New Gallery. There are some fine examples of the Van Eycks, Memling, Mabuse, Gheereart David, Van Orley, Quentin Matsys that I long to see back again over the altar or in the chapels or shrines where they originally be- longed. However, as I have said, they have their historical value and importance in the exhibition, in any review of Flemish art; and archaic though they are, with their rich color, their careful draughtsmanship, their technical accomplishment, they seem worthy to prepare the way for Rubens. Of all the masters, Rubens is probably the one who has the most serious disap- pointments in store even for his admirers. His name has become a synonym for splen- dor, for a flamboyant stateliness, for a vo- luptuous beauty, for a vigor, a vitality, sim- ply amazing. The stories, the evidence too, of his facility take your breath away. You know the impression he made upon his contemporary, Velasquez, the influence he had upon his pupil, Van Dyck. But then, Rubens ran a shop, a picture manufactory. His assistants and students produced half, probably more than half, the work turned out in his name. The design may have been his, the painting was theirs. Compare one of his beautiful little sketches with the | finished canvas, and the animation, the life, the soul has gone; only the empty swagger remains. What could be more wearisome than the acres of Rubens in the Louvre, in Munich, even in Antwerp—I mean in the Museum, not in the Cathedral, where, be- fore the “Descent from the Cross,"’ you can only wonder that you ever dared to criti- cise the master’? It is not strange, there- fore, when the most important national galleries do not always show you the real Rubens, that the directors of the New Gallery, borrowing where they could, have succeeded still less well. The big canvases they have collected together are mostly fine theatrical exercises, tremendousiy skil- ful machines, which the cleverest contr!- butor to the Salons could not hope to rival. Of one, the “Daniel in the Lion's Den,”’ belonging to the late Duke of Ha milton, it seems Rubens himself wrote from Antwerp: “Daniel amidst many lions taken from the life—original, the whole by my hand.”’ But this is hard to believe, powerful as is the drawing of the lions. The Daniel, in his excess of terror, is melodramatic, and there is no splendor of composition, no glory of color, as in the “Paris and the “Rape of the Sabine Woman” in the Nation al Gallery. Indeed, were it not for a series of sketches, for his pictures, and for tapes- try and a number of drawings, the stu- dent would have to go promptly from Re- gent Street to Trafalgar Square to remind himself of what good reason there really is for the fame of Rubens. The New Gallery, with the best will in the world, offers but a reminder, useful at the moment, of this greatest of the Flemings, who was Van Dyck’s master. But, if the National Gallery contains some of Rubens’s masterpieces, it is far from do- ing justice to Van Dyck. The large eques- trian Charles is there, and a fine portrait, but little else of note, while the Academy now gives such a chance to study him at his It is hard- ly necessary for me to go very much into detail; it is only a few months since I was writing of Van Dyck in Antwerp, and all best as cannot soon occur again the masterpieces that were there reappear on the walls of Burlington House Here again are the ‘“‘Carew and Killigrew,” the ‘Royal Children,”’ with other pictures from the Queen’s collections; here the Hermitage “Lord Wharton”; here the “Henrietta Pre- senting the Laurel Wreath to Charles,” the “Earl of Arundel,”’ belonging ‘o the Duke of Norfolk, with several versions besides of that most generous of all Van Dyck’s pa- trons; the painter’s portrait of himself in his youth, and the other with a sunflower, still more deliciously affected, of a later And there are pictures not shewn in Antwerp, quite as important. Only the big religious subjects, lent so reluctantly by Belgian convents and churches, are miss- ing, but no work of Van Dyck couid be spar- ed so readily. They illustrate a certain stage in his career; they add nothing to his repu- tation. Altogether, the collection, which in cludesalso a largenumber of interesting and characteristic drawings, is more fully repre- sentative of Van Dyck during his most dis- tinguished periods than was the series at Antwerp. Nevertheless, I find that the Impression If Van Dyck could sometimes show himself the supreme mas period. it makes is the same. ter, in a painting likethe perfect “Carew and Killigrew,"’ for instance, or a dozen others, he was far oftener content—with Rubens to be the accomplished director of a picture
Page 12
48 The Nation. [Vol. 70, No. 1803 manufactory. His “Charles” and his “Arundel” and almost all his portraits of the artists and students and writers of his day prove his delight in the rendering of character when he discovered it in his sit- ters. But probably the expression of strong character was the one thing with which the lords and ladies who crowded to his studio could dispense, and so to him and to his assistants they became charming lay models upon which to drape a gorgeous costume, puppets to pose picturesquely. How lifeless they are, these pretty dukes and earls and marquesses, these great ladies in their silks and laces, with their pet dwarfs or tiger cubs at their sides! Van Dyck—again with Ru- bens—suffers from his own carelessness of his reputation, from his willingness to lend his name to all the work manufactured in his shop. After Van Dyck, in his own country, came the decadence. But in England, the country of his adoption, there followed the growth and flowering of the first great school of English painters. The manner of this growth is not very clearly indicated at the New Gallery, excellent as is the intention. More than a century and several artists of great distinction separated Reynolds and Gainsborough from Van Dyck. The pre- sence of Hobson and Walker, then of Lely and Kneller, who, though influenced by Van Dyck, became in their turn an influence, and of Hogarth, would have helped to bridge over the interval. It might have been wiser to limit the English work, since so little of it is exhibited, to portraits. It is always a pleasure to see the landscapes of Wilson and Constable and such a noble example of Turner as the ‘‘Walton Bridges.’’ But these we owe to a very different influence, and they interrupt, instead of helping, the historical sequence. However, there are se- veral fine Reynoldses, and Gainsboroughs, and Romneys; Reynolds’s ‘Mrs. Nesbitt as Circe,”’ with its forced, artificial, and very superficial allegory, showing how all that was most affected in the conventions of Van Dyck’s latest period survived not only in Lely and Kneller, but in the English por- trait-painters of the very end of the eigh- teenth century. Lawrence and Raeburn, who is but beginning to be appreciated as he should be, carry on the tradition to its de- cadence and final disappearance. For, sure- ly, the inspiration of the few distinguished English portrait-painters of to-day comes not from Flanders, but from France. One or two men have tried to revive the old conventions, which, however, have proved empty and dead in their hands. Until three years ago, with the Leighton exhibition, the Academy showed the Old Masters of many groups and schools, while never before this winter has the New Gal- lery sought to work in harmony with it. But so much has been accomplished by this joining of force, and by this representation of only one school or artist, that it seems to me the Royal Academy and the New Gal- lery have but to continue the present policy to make their winter exhibitions in the fu- ture still more delightful, and profitable too. N. N. REBELLIAU'S BOSSUET. December 25, 1899. PARIS, Bossuet will always remain one of the commanding figures of French literature and a model of style in the French language. There is in language a law of development and a sort of organic growth; Bossuet’s style remains the perfection of the language of the seventeenth century. It belongs to the grand siécle, and cannot be separated from it; and whatever changes time may bring in the formation and expression of ideas, it will be an object of admiration for future generations. M. Alfred Rébelliau has applied himself to a special study of Bossuet’s work, and has just added a valua- ble volume to the excellent collection of ‘‘Les Grands Kerivains Francais’’ of Hachette. It will be read with pleasure, even after the works of Floquet, ‘ftudes sur la vie de Bos- suet,’ ‘Bossuet Précepteur du Dauphin,’ of Gandar, ‘Bossuet Orateur’ and ‘Choix de Sermons de la Jeunesse de Bossuet,’ and the ‘G2uvres Oratoires de Bossuet’ publish- ed by the Abbé Lebarq. Bossuet was born in 1627 at Dijon, at the time when a sort of Catholic revival, under the influence of Francois de Sales and of Bérulle, had begun. In his native province of Burgundy this revival was very marked. Bossuet’s family was of humble origin; his ancestors had been drapers at Seurre, a small town of Burgundy. In 1517, one of them held a municipal office, and abandoned the old sign-board of the Bossuets, a vine with the device, ‘‘Bois boussu est bon,’’ for the arms afterwards borne. The Bossuets became members of the parlements. The father of the illustrious Bishop was Councillor at Metz; he was a strong royalist and an ardent Catholic. Bossuet was educated at the Collége de Navarre in Paris, and left it after the most brilliant examinations. His family had pro- vided him, while still a child, with a canonry at Metz, but in the seventeenth century the obligation of residence admitted of many ex- ceptions. The masters of the Collége de Navarre urged Bossuet to remain with them. He resisted their entreaties, and left for Metz, where he remained seven years, or until he was thirty-two. He arrived in a place which was in a miserable condition. The Spaniards and the Lorrainers were con- stantly devastating the neighborhood. Bos- suet was at once appointed deputy of the chapter in the Municipal Assembly of the three orders, and was chosen to negotiate an armistice with the agents of Condé, who was at the time in the service of Spain. He left Metz in September, 1653, with a drummer to enter the enemy’s lines. He thus imme- diately took his place as a man of action, and such he essentially remained all his life. He was always busy in directing religious com- munities or establishing seminaries. He was an indefatigable preacher. He was naturally eloquent, and his eloquence had always an end. He was also a great reader, and the germ of all his great works can be found in the studies he pursued at Metz and in his earliest sermons. As soon as Louis XIV. became the real ruler of France, he aimed at the utter de- struction of Protestantism in his kingdom. His predecessor, Louis XIII., had made war on it in the field; under Louis XIV. the war was carried on by the theologians. Bossuet en- tered the lists with ardor; his book entitled the ‘Exposition of the Catholic Doctrine on Matters of Controversy,’ composed in 1671 for the instruction of Turenne, of Dangeau, and of the Marquis de Lorges, made an im- mense sensation. In 1678, he was invited by Mademoiselle de Duras, a niece of Turenne, to confer and discuss with Claude, the most famous Protestant minister of the time. This debate recalled the famous discussion of Duplessis-Mornay and Cardinal Du Per- ron under Henri IV. In 1669, Bossuet was named Bishop of Condom, and soon after- wards, in 1670, Louis XIV. chose him as pre- ceptor of the Dauphin. Putting aside ser- mons, controversy, funeral orations, Bossuet gave himself up wholly to his new task; he tried to make a king of France, a Christian king, who should be an honor to France and to Christianity. His pupil, alas, was a most ordinary and mediocre man, but Bossuet’s time was not lost to the world, as his les- sons took the shape of books which have been read by many generations. The son of Louis XIV. and Marie Thé- rése inherited from his mother a sort of heaviness almost amounting to vulgarity. A virtual king, he feared nothing so much as public life and diplomacy. He was brave and good, kind to those who lived with him, but careful to forget all that was taught him; he read only the births, deaths, and marriages in the Gazette de France. He spent whole days lying on his bed at Meu- don, where he buried himself, away from Versailles, a cane in his hand, tapping his boots or playing with his snuff-box. What a pupil for a Bossuet! Bossuet, at least, profited by the education which the Dau- phin received; he entered upon new studies. He was forty-three years old when he be- gan to give lessons to the Dauphin, but he himself learned a great deal. He read He- rodotus, Thucydides, Plato, Polybius, Stra- bo, Homer, Hesiod, Livy, Cicero; he be- came more familiar with the classics. His views on philosophy and policy became enlarged; he even opened the door to Des- cartes, though Descartes was denounced by the Jesuits as an accomplice of Calvin. He studied history in the original documents. His polemical life began in 1673, when appeared the ‘Critical History of the Old Testament,’ by a learned Oratorian, Rich- ard Simon. A friend sent it to Bossuet, who saw in this exegetic work ‘‘a heap of impieties,’” and denounced it to Chan- cellor Le Tellier. After a brief examination of it, orders were given to burn all the copies. Richard Simon treated the text of the Old Testament as an ordinary text, with the curiosity of a critic who means to have everything explained and _ verified. This scientific exegesis was a great novelty at the time, and seemed sacrilegious to Bossuet. Later, in 1680, he was much grieved at the publication of Malebranche’s ‘Traité de la Nature et de la Grace.’’ He wrote on the book ‘‘nova, mira, falsa.” In 1682, Louis XIV.’s policy was the cause of great embarrassment to him. The Pope’s relations with the King of France had be- come very strained. In 1681, Innocent XI. excommunicated vicar-generals appointed directly by the King in two bishoprics, and an extraordinary general assembly of the clergy of France met on this occasion. The King charged Bossuet to make the open- ing speech in this national council. Bossuet was a Gallican, he regarded the King as a holy being, a representative of God on earth, responsible to God alone. He hoped to bring back to Gallicanism the French Protestants, who were always denoun- cing the Ultramontane pretensions. His po- sition was not easy; he wished the Prince to be independent of the Pope, without being himself a lay Pope. He accepted the task which was offered him. Joseph de Maistre
Page 13
Jan. 18, 1900] The Nation. AOD considered Bossuet’s sermon on “The Unity of the Church”’ which he delivered on open- ing the assembly a tour de force. For ten years Bossuet tried to reconcile the su- premacy of the King with the supremacy of the Pope, but the Pope forced the King to capitulate. In 1693, Bossuet had, by order of the King, to compose for another assem- bly a form of retraction of the first De- claration of 1682—a retraction which the vicar-general had to sign in order to receive the papal bulls. Bossuet had other battles to fight, against Jurieu, against Fénelon. The battle with Jurieu was occasioned by the publication of the famous ‘History of the Variations in the Protestant Churches.’ This and the ‘Po- litique Tirée de l’'&criture Sainte’ are the most important of Bossuet’s works, which are still readable and are found in all li- braries. As for his numerous theological pamphlets, written in answer to Fénelon or to the Jansenists, they have lost all their interest for us. In the ‘Politique Tirée de l’Kcriture Sainte’ and in the ‘Histoire des Variations’ we have, so to speak, the nucleus of all the doctrine of Bossuet—one spiritual law, one temporal law. These two works are the studied code of absolute authority. Bossuet found himself at one time in a sort of spiritual negotiation with Leibnitz. He wished to bring about a fusion of the Catholic Church and _ the Protestant churches, as well Lutheran as Calvinistic. A sort of written dialogue began between the great Bishop and the great philosopher. Bossuet insisted upon the necessity of a permanent doctrine and unity of belief. The Catholic doctor said: “‘This was believed yesterday, so it must be believed to-day”; to which the Protestant philosopher an- swered: “What if something else was be- lieved the day before yesterday?” ‘Can you,’”’ asked Bossuet, ‘‘find a way to hinder your Protestant churches from being eter- nally variable?’”’ To which Leibnitz answer- ed in these famous words: “It suits us, Monseigneur, to belong to this moving and eternally variable church.”’ Bossuet’s quarrel with Fénelon reminds one forcibly of Moliére’s verse: “‘Tant de fiel entre-t-il dans l’'Ame des dévots?"’ The very name of ‘‘Quietism’’ is almost forgotten, and we can hardly understand now the violence of the passions excited by the doctrine of Madame Guyon. Fénelon was condemned in Rome, but bore his defeat with admirable dignity; he was perhaps wrong in doctrine, but he struck in the heart of his contemporaries a chord of sentiment and sentimentality which was a sort of revolt against the harshness and se- verity of Bossuet. ‘ Bossuet struggled to the end against what he considered the errors of the time. He preached also to the end, not only in his eathedral church, but in the smallest churches of his diocese. He began to suffer from the stone in 1700; in 1702, he bade good-by, on Easter Day, to his diocese. He continued to work hard in his episcopal pal- ace, writing, correcting proof-sheets. He finished his ‘Meditation on the Gospel,’ his ‘Explanation of Isaiah,’ his ‘Politique Tirée de l’&criture Sainte.’ When he died, on the 12th of April, 1704, Saint-Simon could write of him that “‘he died with his weapons in his hands.”’ Correspondence. THE AUDITING OF M’KINLEY. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: No historian who ever wrote has taken more frequent advantage of his posi- tion to make personal hits at the Adminis- tration of President McKinley than Tacitus, in delineating the imperialism of Rome. If I remember rightly, some of these thrusts have already been brought to the attention of your readers, but not the one which fol- lows. On the death of Augustus, his grandson, Postumus Agrippa, was immediately slain by a centurion detailed for that purpose. (It will be remembered that he was at the time on the island of Planasia, under sen- tence of banishment.) The centurion under- took to report to Tiberius, but was referred to the Senate, Tiberius disclaiming respon- sibility. Thereupon Sallustius Crispus, fear- ing the possible results of his own part in the slaughter, went to Livia, still in many respects the head of the house, as she had been during the last years of Augustus, and warned her that Tiberius should not break the force of his imperial authority by bring- ing everything before the Senate. ‘‘For,”’ he added, “it is a fundamental fact of im- perialism that its accounts will not balance if submitted to more than one auditor.” That fundamental fact seems to be fully appreciated by our modern imperialists, who seem determined to give the people full in- formation on no fact of real importance un- til that information is wrested from them by a pressure which can no longer be safely resisted. W. H. JOHNSON. “THROW OVER BRYAN.” TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sig: Believing that the Nation likes to know facts, I take the liberty of saying just how a sentence in No. 1801 strikes me. The sentence is this: ‘‘Why not throw over Bryan with the free-silver issue?’’ I am a teacher, and take no part in poli- tics except to vote. I want Bryan renominat- ed by the Democrats because I believe that he is opposed to the tariff and to monopolies of all kinds; because I believe that he is not dominated by the influences that rule McKinley and Hanna. You must find us another man before you say, ‘“‘Throw over Bryan.’’—Very respectfully, J. H. TULANE UNIVERSITY, NEW ORLEANS, January 6, 1900. DILLARD. [But we are equally ready to say, “Throw over McKinley with the impe- rial programme.”—Ep. NatTion.] OUR NEW DIPLOMACY. SDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Educated opinion is, I take it, the same in all parts of our country as to the wretchedness of boss rule and the difficulty of overthrowing it because of our lazy good- nature. It does seem a little too bad, how- ever, that those of us who are working in Europe should be hampered by shoddy po- litics in America. Advanced study in classics and in certain forms of art does not, at first sight, seem to be related to the question of To THE the Italian immigrants who arrive in New York, but we here are suffering from an unwillingness on the part of the Italian Gov- ernment to go out of its way to be friendly to representatives of a Italy has recently treme discourtesy. country by whom been treated with ex- The story (which I have from the highest Italian authority) passing of our present immigration part of which was framed, as every one knows, with the sensible intention of preventing pauper begins with the law, aliens from entering the United States When this law was passed, the Italian Gov ernment, in order to assist both her own people and the United States, came to an informal agreement with the authorities at Washington, with office in charge of authorized cials was established on Ellis Island office the immigrants were given which an of At this whatever in accordance Italian information was needed by them, and as sisted to defend themselves from the pa drone. In case question arose as to any im migrant fulfilling the the law, the officials in charge of the office were in a position that requirements of to give our Government in formation could be other way. This took place McKinley was President that worked excellently, and both parties to the acquired in no before Mr elected It was a system agreement derived considerable benefit from it. The dullest what a blessing it immigrants. When President, Mr. head of the Immigration Bureau. the hostility of the trades-unions to foreign immigration, Mr. get the office on Ellis Island abolished, the Italian Government the office must be closed ment to which the office owed its existence had been informal, yet the work done by it perceive to the became the Owing to imagination have been McKinley put at can must Mr. Powderly was Powderly did his best to and was informed that Though the agree had been so satisfactory that the Italian Foreign Office was surprised, and begged earnestly for an adequate explanation of our action. As there was none to give, and as, being at war with Spain, we did not de sire to increase the number of our enemies, the matter was dropped and the office tinued its beneficent work con Lately the affair has been taken up once more, and the Italian Government has been finally told that the office would t« ed, the reason being that other nations were abolish- asking to be allowed to establish similar bureaus, and we cannot give this right to everybody! That other European nations should be demanding this permission is an incontrovertible proof of the excellent ser- vice of the office, but apparently our Wash ington sages think that, like Polycrates, we had best throw some precious possession into the sea. But greater even than the wisdom of our Solons is their courtesy, for thia was the manner of their notification to the [Italian Government. Early in December the Gov ernment here was informed, through the Italian Ambassador in Washington, that the office was to be done away with. The Mar quis Visconti-Venosta, Minister of Foreign Affairs, asked (using the telegraph) that no final action be taken until the authorities at Washington had studied the papers he desired to send them The papers were sent, but the reply received by cable at Rome before their arrival in Washington was that the office would be closed on Janu-
Page 14
ae a a es ee The Nation. [| Vol. 70, No. 1803 ary 1—papers or no papers. The exact lan- guage I am unable to quote, but the abrupt- ness of the decision is evident. The exact feelings of the Italian Foreign Office were left by my Italian informant to my imagina- tion. Up to the present time the Italian press has scarcely commented on the subject, for the Marquis Visconti-Venosta, knowing its supersensitiveness on certain points, has kept the matter dark. One writer has, however, asked if this casé. is to be taken as a sample of our ‘‘new diplomacy.” It is to be hoped that, before the press begins ir- rational attacks either against us or the Italian Foreign Office—attacks which would render the wise settlement of the affair more difficult—the matter will have been recon- sidered at Washington from the point of view of common sense and not that of the next election. RICHARD NORTON. AMERICAN SCHOOL OF CLASSICAL STUDIES, Romer, December 27, 1899. OUR TITLE TO THE PHILIPPINES. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Imperialists speak of the Filipinos as being in a state of insurrection. An insur- gent is one who resists by force constituted authority and attempts by arms to overthrow an established government to which he owes obedience. That the Filipinos, who once were Spanish subjects, became insurgents against Spain by contracting an alliance with the United States, cannot be denied, but resist- ance to the extension of American sovereign- ty over the Philippines is not insurrection, as they have never been subject to the do- minion of the United States. Aguinaldo’s Government was the legitimate successor of the Spanish, and was organized and in con- trol of the islands long before the pretended cession to the United States. As Spain had already lost control of the territory, and the United States had never attempted to exer- cise even military authority (before the trea- ty was signed) outside the limits of Manila, clearly the Filipinos could not be in insur- rection against a power that did not exist. By the terms of the protocol, the United States was to hold Manila pending negotia- tions for the disposition of the Philippines. Of course, any attempt by the United States to extend its authority during the suspension of hostilities might be a breach of the con- ditions of the protocol and a violation of pub- lic faith. The agreement provided that the situation in the Philippines should remain unchanged until a treaty of peace was con- cluded, The mere signing of the treaty by the Commissioners gave it no operative force before the exchange of ratifications. Yet on December 21, 1898, when the treaty had not been ratified and had no more legal force than a blank sheet of paper, and in deflance of the protocol, the President wrote to the Secretary of War: “With the signature of the treaty of peace between the United States and Spain by their respective plenipotentiaries at Paris, on the 10th instant, and as the result of the vic- tories of American arms, the future control, disposition, and government of the Philippine Islands are ceded to the United States. In fulfilment of the rights of sovereignty thus acquired, and the responsible obligations of government thus assumed, the actual occu- pation and administration of the entire group of the Philippine Islands became immediate- ly necessary, and the military government heretofore maintained by the United States in the city, harbor, and bay of Manila is to be extended with all possible dispatch to the whole of the ceded territory.” , The same day a cable order was sent to Otis: “The President directs that you send necessary troops to Iloilo to preserve the peace and protect life and property.” Life and property were then as safe in Iloilo as in Manila. Peace was preserved and life and property protected by bombarding the town. The proclamation was a declaration of war against a people who had been organized and armed by the United States as allies in the war with Spain. It assumed fore- knowledge of the fact that there were Sena- tors who would speak against the treaty, but who would stultify themselves by voting to ratify. It is a well-settled principle of public law that the national character of territory ceded by treaty continues unaltered until the treaty has been executed. As long as it re- mains executory, and there is no delivery of possession, the sovereignty is unchanged. Such a thing as sovereignty without posses- sion cannot be conceived. This would have been the legal effect of the treaty even if Spanish power in the Philippines had not been extinguished and there had been no organized opposition to the transfer of sov- ereignty to the United States. The word cede means to yield or surrender title to some- thing. But Spain had been divested of all title and had nothing to yield or surrender. Twenty millions were simply given as a soothing syrup to console her. There is no analogy between a title ac- quired by private contract and a cession of territory. A citizen may convey property in the adverse possession of another, be- cause the Government is the guarantor of its enjoyment by the grantee if the title of the grantor is good. In such a case the supreme power of the State provides a tri- bunal to try the right and execute its decree. But contracts inter gentes have no such sanction because there is no common politi- cal superior to enforce them. What is called international law is not law jn the municipal sense of law. It is a mere ethical code, not a positive institution. Nations in their intercourse respect it, but there is no civil remedy for a violation of it. Redress must be sought by negotiation, or war. Hall, on International Law, says: ‘‘As interna- tional law is destitute of any judicial or ad- ministrative machinery, it leaves states which think themselves aggrieved and which have exhausted all peaceable methods of obtaining satisfaction, to exact redress for themselves by force.’’ Law is defined by Blackstone as the command of a superior to an inferior. But among sovereigns there is no inferior—all are equals. Hence there can be no such thing as sovereign right without sovereign possession. The cession of Louisiana is a case in point. It was a province of Spain, and by a secret treaty was ceded to France in 1800, but there was no transfer of possession until 1803. In the case of the Fama, 5 C. Robinson 107, Sir William Scott held that the national character of the inhabitants of Louisiana was not changed ipso facto by the treaty, and that Louisiana continued to be Spanish territory until it was actually delivered to France. There was war between England and France, and a vessel cleared from New Orleans with a cargo belonging to a merchant there resident, and was cap- tured on the voyage. It was contended for the captors that, as domicile in war is a test of national character, it was enemy's prop- erty because Louisiana, having been ceded to France, was no longer neutral territory. The case turned upon the nationality of Louisiana. If it was French, the property was liable to condemnation as prize of war. Sir William Scott (Lord Stowell) said: “The present question is a general one re- specting the situation in which the people of a distant settlement are placed by a trea- ty of the state to which they undoubted- ly belong, and by which they are stipulated to be transferred to another Power. The case proceeded for a considerable time with- out dispute as to principle on a mere in- quiry into the fact of possession; under an understanding, as I apprehended, that if possession had not been taken by France, the French character could not be deemed to have attached. The question has, how- ever, now been fully argued as to the prin- ciple of law, whether the treaty did not in itself confer full sovereignty and right of dominion, and whether the inhabitants were not so ceded by that treaty as to become immediately French subjects. The other question of law, how far full sovereignty can be held to have passed by the mere words of the treaty without actual delivery, was in the first stages of this cause not mooted. It is to be ob- served that all corporeal property depends very much upon occupancy. With re- spect to the origin of property this is the sole foundation. So with regard to transfer, it is universally held in all sys- tems of jurisprudence that to consummate the right of property a person must unite the right of the thing with possession. I am of opinion that, on all the several grounds of reason or practice and judicial recognition, until possession was actual- ly taken the inhabitants of New Orleans continued under the former sovereignty of Spain.’”’ Judgment for claimant. : The doctrine of this case was affirmed by the United States Supreme Court in Davis vs. the Police Jury of Concordia, 9 Howard 280. The Court said (p. 292): “The Fama sailed from New Orleans in April, 1803, for Havre de Grace with Span- ish property on board. She was taken on the way by a British cruiser, and her car- go libelled, it being alleged to be enemy’s or French property only upon the ground that Louisiana had been ceded by Spain to France before the Fama sailed. The points stated in the words of Sir William Scott are, whether the treaty did not in it- self confer full sovereignty and right of dominion to France, and whether the in- habitants were not so ceded by that treaty as to become immediately French subjects. The cause was fully argued on both sides by as able counsel as were in that day or since in the admiralty courts of England, The cargo was restored to the Spanish claimant on the ground that the national character of a place agreed to be surren- dered by treaty, but not actually delivered, continues as it was under the character of the ceding country.”’ According to these decisions, even if there had been no contest with the Filipinos until possession had actually been delivered to the United States, their national charac- ter would continue to be the same as when the treaty was signed. But the cession was absolutely void because, at the date of the treaty, Spain did not possess the sove- reignty of the islands, and hence had no power to cede. She had no right to cede what she could not deliver. Spain’s sove- reignty in Louisiana was undisputed, but, in the Philippines, it had been wrested from her by the people she undertook to sell. The Filipinos were in actual control everywhere but in Manila. If the United States ac- quires possession of the Philippines, its title must rest not on cession from Spain, but on the conquest of the Filipinos. We bought nothing from Spain but a hole in the sky.—Respectfully, Jno. 8. Mossy. San Francisco, January 7, 1900.
Page 15
Jan. 18, 1900] The Nation. 1 THINGS ATHENIAN. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: The old Greek adage, that it is not given to every one to visit Corinth, still holds good as regards Athens in modern days. The tide of American travel still flows from Italy past the peninsula of Greece on to Constantinople or to Egypt without touching at Patras or the Peirzus, and the American colony at Athens is not yet so numerous as to be promiscuous. On returning to Athens after an absence of twelve years, one is impressed with the rapid strides the capital of Greece is making towards becoming a handsome city. Private residences as well as public edifices are built of Pentelic marble in part if not throughout, and the neighboring quarries are yielding an ever-increasing profit to the English company that has purchased a large part of the old mountain. The lesser and nearer heights, such as the Hill of the Muses and Lycabettus, are scarified and mu- tilated by the constant demands upon them for building material, and the day is close at hand when their outlines, if not their very existence, will be wiped out, unless the Government puts a stop to this wholesale destruction. The city is also losing its semi-Oriental character and becoming more commonplace. Fustanellas and fezzes are comparatively rare sights, and one must go down into the older portions of the city, near the Tower of the Winds and the Stoa of Attalos, to see and to hear the character- istic sights and sounds of the Athens of twenty years ago. One is surprised to notice so few traces of the effects of the late war with Turkey. Some of the Greeks speak of the affair as a mystery, more look upon it as a stupen- dous political blunder, and all get some comfort from the outcome, which has given to Crete a popular and intelligent Greek prince as Governor. One indirect effect of the late war is especially deplored, and that is public begging, which, before this, was hardly known in Greece. This, doubtless, is a remnant of the public charities that were instituted during the war to care for the refugees who sought shelter in Athens. The Boulé has just begun its session. There is prospect of lively discussion, though the Government party has a good majority. One of the most important questions to come be- fore the Chamber of Deputies is the increase of the supply of water for Athens, which is a growing necessity. There is a curious lawsuit pending on which the whole matter seems to hinge. The late Mr. Syngros, after providing for his family, left the bulk of his property to charitable objects, making a certain benevolent organization his residu- ary legatee, but naming the sum which he expected it to inherit from him. But it turns out that his estate is worth upwards of a million of drachm# more than he had supposed. The widow now sues to have this surplus revert to her, with the understand- ing that, if the courts decide in her favor, she is to present this amount to the Govern- ment for the new water supply. The sum required will be much larger than the amount of this bequest in litigation, but the Government hopes that, with this amount in hand, the needed work can at least be ini- tiated. ‘ Another matter that is likely to agitate the Boulé relates to forming a closer con- nection with the rest of Europe. The most feasible plan is to extend the railway from Larissa in Thessaly to Salonica, and there form a junction with the line from Constan- tinople to Vienna. That communication by rail with Western Europe would be of great advantage to Greece cannot be doubted. The difficulty in the way is the needed conces- sions from Turkey, through whose territory a large part of the proposed road would run. Just now, however, the Sultan is showing a friendly disposition towards Greece, and there is reason to hope that such a conces- sion may be obtained. Then there are questions of constitutional and financial reform to be discussed. To be sure, such questions are always at the front in Greece, but they seem to be unusually ur- gent at present, and it is said that the Min- istry is determined to accomplish something of note in that direction. One of these re- forms is the abolition of the vexatious octroi duty between the Peirzus and Athens. Most of the temporary residents from Northern Europe and America are drawn here by the opportunities for archological study and exploration. There are now five schools for classical and archzological study in Athens, the latest born being the Austrian Institute. They maintain most friendly rela- tions with one another, and all enjoy the hospitable favor of the Greek Government and its officials. The Germans, under the auspices of the Berlin Museum, are digging in Miletus, the Austrians in Ephesus, the English in Crete, and the Americans hope to resume work at Corinth. The British School has recently fallen heir to a library “bonanza.”’ The library of the late Dr. Fin- lay, the historian, containing upwards of 4.000 volumes, has been presented to it. This library is especially rich in books and pam- phiets on the history of Greece during the Byzantine and Frankish periods, and con- tains a number of personal memoirs in ma- nuscript and letters from distinguished men that have never been published. Our American School has entered upon the nineteenth year of its existence. Its twelve students, representing ten different colleges and universities, are at present en- joying the privilege of hearing Dr. Dérpfeld once a week talk, as only he can talk, on the recent excavations about and on the Acro- polis. In addition to the exercise in epigra- phy with Prof. Herbert W. Smyth of Bryn Mawr, they enjoy occasional lectures from Dr. Wilhelm of the Austrian Institute. To this is to be added the weekly visit to the rich collections of sculptures in the museums under the skilful guidance of the Director of our School, Prof. Rufus B. Richardson. If the friends and patrons of the School could see for themselves the enthusiastic work that is done here, they would value still more than they do the helpfulness of this School in training the future teachers of classical studies in our country. The desirableness of putting the School on a permanent financial basis is patent to every one who knows its history and the worth of what it is doing. The time is ripe for the completion of its endowment, which has already made so good a beginning. The excavations at Corinth are at present suspended, partly to await more favorable weather, but also for lack of funds. The last discovery made on that site is the spring of Glauké, not far from the old temple, which, as we have now learned, was not the temple of Poseidon, but of Apollo. It is to be hoped that the appeal of Mr. Richardson in your columns last August for financial aid to resume these interesting explorations wil) not go unheeded. The discoveries made by our School during the past decade at Sicyon, the Herwum, Icaria, and Corinth are ac- knowledged by the leading scholars of Europe to be a great credit to our country, and give American scholarship a position which it has never held before. The work of the Greek Archeological So- ciety on and about the Acropolis is now fin- ished. This is not the place to recount the many important finds that have been made on this site within the past few years. The old rock and its western declivity are now denuded of all Frankish and Turkish addi tions. The Acropolis is again a precinct of sanctuaries, though in ruin, and stands out above the modern city more rugged and se verely beautiful than when disfigured by bastions and of modern construction. The Parthenon has still a scaffolding on its western facade to facilitate the work of placing supports and pieces of architrave and columns where time and bombs and earthquakes had most ruin. It is expected, however, that this needed work of restoration will be completed its approaches were bulwarks wrought in the course of a few months MARTIN L. D'OoGEe ATHENS, December 18, 1809 SUUM CUIQUE. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: Your recent appreciative and discri- minating notice of ‘The Methods and Mate- rials of Literary Criticism’ accidentally mis- states the respective shares of the colla borators in that work. epitome of authorship by chapters be, in general, retained, it should read, “The ory of Criticism, History of Criticism (main- ly by Prof. Scott), Theory of Art (partly by Prof. Gayley), Development of Art, Theory of Literature, Comparative Literature (mainly by Prof. Scott), Theory of Poetry, Historical Study of Poetry, Historical Study of Poetics, and Principles of Versification (mainly by Prof. Gayley).” But it would, in truth, be impossible for the authors themselves to indicate ly the contribution of each to chapters that have been ten years on the stocks; and, In their inability to make more definite appor tionment of their labors, they are of a mind that the best parts of the book were writ ten by both, and the worst by neither. Each is, however, generously disposed to appro- priate whatever credit may be got out of it.—Yours sincerely, THE AUTHORS If your reviewer's exact January, 1900 BIBLE DICTIONARIES. TO THE EpitTorR or THE NATION Sir: What you say about a Bible Diction ary, with special reference to Prof. new book, suggests that there may be known to you some better work which would be adapted for persons ‘‘already wandering in darkness,"’ or at least not “satisfied the Princeton position.” If such a book is on the market, will you not kindly print its title and publisher?—Respectfully, SETH GREET Davis's with January €, 1900 [Our correspondent’s question is some- what vague. If the book wanted is a dic-
Page 16
oe EN ate Pe 52 The Nation. [Vol. 70, No. 1803 tionary of the Bible on about the same scale as that of Prof. Davis (i. e., a sin- gle, moderate-sized volume), wé must re- ply that we know of none that can be recommended with any warmth. On the other hand, two large Bible dictionaries are being published at present, and each has excellent points. Of one of these, Hastings’s ‘Bible Dictionary’ (Edinburgh: T. & T. Clark), two vol- umes out of the four of which it is to consist have appeared. Of the other, the ‘Encyclopedia Biblica,’ edited by Drs. Cheyne and Black (The Macmillan Co.), only one volume has appeared, but it also will consist of four. We shall pub- lish. shortly an extended review of this last. Both books can be heartily*recom- mended. The first will be the more valuable for non-specialists; the second will appeal most to the specialist, but even he will require both. In questions of Biblical theology Hastings easily leads —from Cheyne such matters are practi- cally excluded; in details of exact scho- larship Cheyne is richer. But if what our correspondent wants is not neces- sarily a dictionary of the Bible, but any book which will enable a layman to find his way in the present labyrinth of cri- ticism, and to keep his head through it all, then we would advise him to try Dr. Washington Gladden’s three books, ‘Who Wrote the Bible?’ ‘Seven Puzzling Books,’ and ‘How Much Is Left?’ These are not intended for the student, but for the plain man who cannot be satis- fled with the old formule, yet who wish- es to hold fast to the old truth.—Epb. Na- TION. ] DECISION WITHOUT REASONS. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: The question you put on page 37 of your last issue is answered by the fol- lowing quotation from Mill’s ‘Logic’ (8th ed., N. Y., 1881, p. 144): ‘“‘Almost every one knows Lord Mans- field’s advice to a man of practical good sense, who, being appointed governor of a colony, had to preside in its courts of jus- tice, without previous judicial practice or legal education. The advice was to give his decision boldly, for it would probably be right; but never to venture on assign- ing reasons, for they would almost infalli- bly be wrong.”’ » a DID PLATO ERR? TO THE Epitor or THe NATION: Sir: Prof. White’s note in your issue of the 11th inst., which seems to indicate that Goethe was a victim of the delusion that mistakes the last year of one century for the first year of the next, brings to my recollec- tion a passage about Henrik Steffens in Hansen's ‘Illustreret Dansk Literaturhis- torie.’ The passage runs as follows: “New Year's eve, the 3lst of December, 1800, found him at a court masquerade in Weimar. After midnight Goethe, Schiller, Schelling, and Steffens withdrew from the ball, and in an adjoining room drank cham- pagne to welcome the new year. Goethe was jovial, Schiller held instructive dis- course, Schelling was quiet, and Steffens found joyous entertainment in noting the various effects of the wine upon these great spirits.” This account, if accurate, saves Goethe from the imputation of having thought that there were only ninety-nine years in the eighteenth century.—Yours faithfully, WILLIAM MORTON PAYNE. CuicaGo, January 13, 1900. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: In spite of many provocations, I have so far abstained from writing to any pe- riodical in regard to the beginning of the twentieth or any other century. But Prof. White’s little note in this week’s number of the Nation, which I saw a few hours ago, forces me to say that Schiller as well as Goethe soon gave up the idea of 1800 being the first year of the nineteenth century. The letters exchanged between the two poets during the latter part of that year show that, in the words of Diintzer (‘Life of Schiller’ [translated], page 403), ‘‘The con- federates wished to celebrate the opening of a new century [1801] by theatric festivi- ties for which Schiller was particularly ac- tive.” However, ‘‘the Duke had declared against the Centenary” and ‘Schiller drew back in disgust.” “On the last evening of the year and century they met at the mas- querade got up by the Court. .. . After midnight the two poets, with Schelling and Steffens, retired into the side rooms, and had a pleasant talk over champagne.’’* As to Heine's jest, it is, of course, as well known to Prof. White as to me that the poet did not state, in so many words, that he was born ‘on the first of January,” but “in der Neujahrsnacht Achtzehnhundert,”’ that is to say, as it were, between the 3ist of December and the 1st of January. I should not speak of this in particular if I did not think that Heine got this century joke from the real date of his birthday, January 13, which, turned about, gives 31, so that originally the December day was uppermost in his mind. Hence, the wrong date of his birth, equally familiar to Prof. White, which was formerly found in so many books. While I was writing these lines there reached me (irony of fate!) one of the new German century postal cards with a radiant sun and a big 1900 on it, besides the Ger- mania on the embossed stamp, stamped, “1.1.00 2-3V,”’ that is, freely to quote Heine, “in der Neujahrsnacht Neunzehnhundert.” I need scarcely mention that the authors inform me of their being gathered “das alte Jahr scheiden zu sehen und das neue Jahr- hundert zu empfangen.’”’ Of course, when we give up the 18.. in our correspondence, we have the feeling that a new century begins. But, notwithstanding this, it is acknowledg- ed by the serious writers of Germany (e. g., Brockhaus’s ‘Konversations-lexicon,’ sub “Jahrhundert’’) that the new century be- gins with 1901. On pages 13 and 14 of Kiirschner’s well-known ‘Jahrbuch’ for this year is to be found a reprint from ‘Der Bote aus Thiiringen’ (Schnepfenthal, 1800), entitled, “‘Wenn beginnt das neue Jahr- hundert?’’ This should be sufficient to en- lighten the Pope of Rome and the Emperor of Berlin.—Very truly, E. LESER. BLOOMINGTON, IND., January 18, 1900, ~Compere Diintzer, Goethe’s Life II, 181, note on Schiller’s New Year letter of 1800; also, Karl Helnemann, Goethe, I, 228, and the Schiller bio- graphy by Wychgram. Notes. The Macmillan Company’s spring an- nouncements embrace ‘Democracy and Em- pire,’ by Prof. Franklin H. Giddings; ‘Poli- tics and Administration,’ by Prof. Frank J. Goodnow; a ‘Dictionary of Philosophy and Psychology,’ edited by Prof. J. Mark Bald- win of Princeton; a ‘Cyclopedia of Ameri- can Horticulture,’ by Prof. L. H. Bailey of Cornell; a second series of ‘Studies in Lite- rature,’ by Prof. Lewis E. Gates; ‘Makers of Literature,’ biographical essays by Prof. George E. Woodberry; ‘The Evolution of the English Novel,’ by Prof. Francis H. Stod- dard of New York University; ‘The Men Who Made the Nation,’ by Prof. Edwin E. Sparks; ‘The Golden Horseshoe,’ the story of American expansion, by Stephen Bon- sal; ‘‘Source Readers of American History,”’ volume i., ‘Colonial Children,’ by Prof. Al- bert Bushnell Hart; ‘Extracts from the Sources of English History,’ by Elizabeth K. Kendall of Wellesley; ‘European Travel for Women,’ by Mary Cadwalader Jones; ‘Highways and Byways in Normandy,’ by Percy Dearmer, illustrated by Hugh Thom- son and Joseph Pennell; ‘A History of Gothic Art in England,’ by E. S. Prior; the first volume of a ‘Dictionary of Architec- ture,’ edited by Russell Sturgis; ‘Dante Ga- briel Rossetti,’ an illustrated memorial of his art and life, by H. C. Marillier; ‘The Life of Edward White Benson, Sometime Archbishop of Canterbury,’ by his son Ar- thur Christopher Benson; ‘More Letters of Edward FitzGerald,’ edited by W. Aldis Wright; a ‘Concordance to FitzGerald’s Omar Khayyam,’ by J. R. Tutin; and ‘The Welsh People: Their Origin, Language, and History,’ by Prof. John Rhys. D. Appleton & Co.’s January announce- ments include Maspero’s ‘The Passing of Empires,’ translated by M. L. McClure and edited by Prof. Sayce; the late David A. Wells’s ‘Principles of Taxation’; the fifth volume vf Prof. McMaster’s ‘History of the People of the United States’; and ‘The Com- parative Physiology and Morphology of Ani- mals,’ by Prof. Joseph Le Conte. Harper & Brothers will speedily publish ‘Thackeray’s Hitherto Unidentified Contri- butions to Punch,’ by M. H. Spielmann, in a volume uniform with the recent “Biogra- phical Edition’ of the novelist. ‘Three Men on a Bicycle,’ by Jerome K. Jerome, will be published early in the spring by Dodd, Mead & Co., and Tolstoy’s ‘Re- surrection’ probably before next autumn. The Abbey Press, No. 114 Fifth Avenue, announce ‘Danger Signals for New Century Manhood,’ by Edward A. Tabor. A book will be made, by the Century Com- pany, of Ernest Seton Thompson’s ‘Biogra- phy of a Grizzly,’ already published in their magazine. Henry Frowde will soon issue four vol- umes of classical texts in the projected se- ries “Scriptorum Classicorum Bibliotheca Oxoniensis,’’ viz., Thucydides, edited by H. 8. Jones; Plato, by J, Burnet; Lucretius, by C, Bailey; and Tacitus, by H. Furneaux. ‘Hazell’s Annual for 1900’ (London: Ha- zell, Watson & Viney) will be prized for reference on no account more than for its succinct chronicle of the Transvaal imbro- glio, in its several stages, often with textual quotations from the dispatches. A small map accompanies the article. Useful sum-
Page 17
GS NI a OO A THE SSE TE PERE LES LES LOTTE OE Jan. 18, 1900] The Nation. | — 53 maries, too, are those of the Commissioners’ report on the Newfoundland French treaty shore question, and the report of the Royal Commissions on the licensing laws and lo- cal taxation. Other momentous’ subjects similarly illustrated are the Conference at The Hague, the Venezuelan arbitration, the Dreyfus affair, etc. The Annual is kept re- markably up to date. It notes the ‘‘all-well”’ condition at Ladysmith on December 1, and, under United States, tells of the Samoan agreement, the ‘‘open-door’’ negotiations with other Powers for China, and the death of Vice-President Hobart. The editor, in his preface, lays stress on the extension of the biographies which are one of the features of this publication; but we fail to discover in the American portion any of the new war lights of the past two years. All are eclipsed by Bryan—his wind power proving a better title to fame even than Capt. Ma- han’s sea power. A portrait of President Eliot, etched by a foreign hand not unfaithfully, is the front- ispiece to the ninth issue of the ‘alma- nac of the learned world,’ Minerva (Strass- burg: Karl J. Triibner; New York: Lemcke & Buechner). A very handsome tribute is paid him by the editors, in an apology for deviating from their custom as to the choice of subjects for portraiture (among profes- sors). They speak of the power, authority, and responsibility of American college pre- sidents, among whom Harvard's head is “der hervorragendste und der Fiihrer.’’ The other new feature of this ever grow- ing annual is a list of significant scientific congresses scheduled for the current year. These are arranged alphabetically accord- ing to the place of meeting, Paris being preéminently the common ground, with forty-three congresses (out of some hundred, we believe, appointed there during the Ex- position), while only six are held elsewhere. Sometimes the programme and usually the chief officers are given. It is a pity when a master makes sport for the Philistines. Dr. Green of Prince- ton is a Hebraist such as there are few in thjs country. He has upheld a lost cause with loyalty and ability; but he would have been well advised either not to publish his ‘Introduction to the Text of the Old Testament’ (Charles Scribner’s Sons), or to subject it before publication to an exhaustive revision. As it is, it evidently consists of lectures compiled some considerable time ago and very inadequate- ly brought up to date. It is, presumably, accidental that there is no reference to Dri- ver’s ‘Introduction,’ though his earlier views on some points which were afterwards mo- dified in the ‘Introduction’ are given at length. Yet why the great plan of the Cambridge Septuagint should be ignored; why Tattam should be the latest Coptic scholar mentioned; why the elder Hoffmann (who wrote in 1828!) should be the authori- ty quoted for the history of the Hebrew script; why Gesenius (clarum et venerabile nomen, but undoubtedly antiquated) should often be the leading and only authority— these all be hard questions. The book as it stands is a most grievous mistake. The prospectus of a magazine to be “‘con- ducted on Twentieth Century ideas” by the Press Biographical Company, New York, is before us. Mr. Charles F. Lummis may take a solid satisfaction in putting on his shelf the ele- venth volume of his pictorial monthly Land of Sunshine (Los Angeles), both as one more triumph over the difficulties of establishing such a magazine on the Paci- fic Coast, and for its intrinsic return to his subscribers and readers. Besides the unfailing exhibition of the attractions of the Coast, and the literary articles in prose and verse, and the editor's own frank utter- ances on politics and books, we find in the half-year embraced in this volume a trans- lation (never before made) of the whole of the Viceroy Revilla-Gigedo’s Report on Cal- ifornia, 1768-1793, and the beginning of a translation of Fray Zarate-Salmeron’s Re- lacion concerning the ‘‘New Mexico”’ of his time, 1538-1626. This is the third in the important series of historical sources with which Mr. Lummis has freighted his plea- sure-craft. Nor should we omit to mention his trenchant discussion of our treatment of the Indians, under the caption, ‘“‘My Bro- ther’s Keeper.’’ The note of industry im- plied in all this personal editorial contri- bution is striking indeed. The movement of population in France continues to arouse discussion, and at the annual meeting of the Society of Social Economy, in December, M. Fournier de Flaix presented an elaborate essay on the subject. He attempted to show that the situation was not so grave as was commonly be- lieved, but he was obliged to resort to argu- ments of the most recondite and even ab- surd character. He made the paradoxical statement that, during the nineteenth cen- tury, the population of France had increased more rapidly than at any other period; but this increase occurred almost wholly during the period of repose which followed the cessation of the wars of Napoleon, and since 1871 population has been either stationary or declining. M. Bertillon criticised the es- say severely, but had nothing positive to suggest except the fantastic measures advo- cated by the National Alliance for the In- crease of the French Population. This Al- liance maintains that it is the patriotic duty of every Frenchman to marry and be- get at least three children, and relies, in effect, on a system of bounties for large families. But it must be admitted that in so far as its measures contemplate a reduction of taxes, they are well conceived. There is some evidence that not only the popula- tion but also the wealth of France is de- clining, and unless the burdens of industry are -lessened the decadence may become serious. The introduction of the study of the Rus- sian language in the continuation schools and in one of the gymnasia in Berlin has, of course, a more than purely educational sig- nificance, especially as this new departure coincides very closely with a movement among German manufacturers of machinery towards the establishment of permanent ex- hibitions of their products in Russian trade- centres. The young men availing them- selves of this new opportunity are sons of high military and civil officers, and techni- cal students, discerning in the land beyond the Vistula and the distant regions beyond the Obi a promising field of activity. The instruction is given by the official Rus- sian interpreter at the Prussian courts and offices of state. The linguistic training of young Germans has long been recognized (by English chambers of commerce and other interested parties) as one of the prin- cipal causes of their successful careers in foreign parts, and, in consequence, of the rise of German trade and industry. Our own young men may as well take the hint. The fourth annual meeting of the Ameri can Academy of Political and Social Science will be held in Philadelphia on April 19 and 20, with Corporations and Public Welfare for the general topic—e. g.. governmental control over public-service corporations (gas, street railways, water); the influence of corporations on political life; combina tion of capital as a factor in industria! pro gress; the future of protection The Secretary of the League of Social Service, No. 297 Fourth Avenue, New York will, on application, furnish particulars re garding the proposed “Paris Internationa! Assembly" to be established in connection with the great Exposition. Its main feature, we are told, will be ‘‘the largest application yet conceived of the summer-schoo!l idea,”’ and it will “help bring the right people to the various departments of the Exposition and to the Congresses,"’ and provide the more serious-minded visitors with “expert guidance, rendezvous and information bu- reaus,”’ lecture courses, excursions, and even private hospitality. —In vols. lv.-lviii. of the ‘Jesuit Rela tions’ (Cleveland Burrows Bros. Co.) we receive a premonition of the fact that this great series is drawing to its close The formal Relations, which began in 1632 with LeJeune’s vivid description of his first ef- forts among the Montagnais, end, in vol. Ivi., with the second instalment of Dablon’s Re- lation for 1671-72. Henceforth, we shall see no more of the carefully prepared reports which were either written or edited by the local superior at Quebec, and sent home to the French provincial to be printed at the press of Cramoisy. With the extension of the sphere of Jesuit influence, it has evi- dently become impossible for any one so to coordinate the dispatches from widely se- vered flelds as to give the effect of unity Accordingly, a new practice establishes itself, and the compact Relation of the year gives way to a collection of letters, which, how- ever, as a rule, reaches the printer by the same stages which have been already noted in the case of the Relation itself This change in the form of the reports is coincet- dent with and represents the final broaden ing out of Jesuit missions. The characteris- tic feature of vols. lv.-lviil. (which cover the four years, 1671-1674) is transition from the dominating interest of Iroquois topics to matters connected with the Far West and the Far North. The names of Albanel, Allouez,Jo- liet, and Marquette all suggest new regions which the French were developing at the moment when Dablon sent in the last of the Cramoisy Relations. Of these four explorers, Albanel is probably the least known, and we shall accordingly refer to his journey in the Hudson's Bay country. Dablon says, in edit- ing Albanel’s journal, that ‘the famous bay to which Hutson gave his name,’ had long stirred the curiosity of the French and made them wish to know the land route thither. In 1671 purely geographical motives received an impetus from the report that foreignships had arrived in the bay, and had opened up the peltry trade in regions where all fur-bearing animals abounded. Talon, the Intendant, ac- cordingly thought it his duty to act promptly on behalf of the national interests, and the expedition which started from Tadoussac in August had more than his sanction; it owed its origin to his suggestion. A missionary, Albanel, was put at its head because, from
Page 18
O4. The Nation. [Vol. 70, No. 1803 his intercourse with the Montagnais and At- tikamagues, he could best converse with the northern tribes and explain to them the vir- tues of Onontio, besides the advantages which would result from trading with the French rather than with any other European race. Albanel, after a hard journey, reached Hudson’s Bay only to find the English there before him. His narrative effectively dis- poses of the claim that the French were the first to establish posts on this northern sea. —‘How England Saved Europe’ (Scribners) is the picturesque title of a work in which Dr. W. H. Fitchett rehearses the events of the Great War, 1795-1815. ‘England has saved herself by her exertions, and will, as I trust, save Europe by her example”’; these last public words of Pitt are here forced to furnish both a title and a motto. We have only the first volume before us, but it can easily be seen that the three succeeding parts will also have a military character, and will be written in a spirited way from the British standpoint. ‘‘ ‘I have made war upon you for twenty years.’ Napoleon, with somewhat vague arithmetic, condenses into that brief sentence the chief aim of his great career as a soldier, the whole policy of his Empire. And the satire of history is illus- trated by the fact that these words were spoken as a prisoner in the cabin of a Bri- tish man-of-war, and to a couple of British officers by the greatest military genius the world has known since Hannibal, and who had fought against England as Hannibal fought against Rome; ‘the man of a thou- sand thrones,’ who had made and unmade kings, and entered well-nigh every capital in Europe in turn as a conqueror. His twenty years of war with England had land- ed him there!” There is a certain ring about the allusion to Hannibal which re- minds one forcibly of the most famous para- graph in Dr. Arnold’s ‘History of Rome,’ but we have quoted this passage to disclose the tone which Dr. Fitchett uses. He views the long duel as an epic struggle with a clearly defined Nemesis. From the moment when, ‘‘at half-past six on the morning of February 25, 1793, three battalions of the Guards, equipped for foreign service, were drawn up on the parade-ground in what is now the rear of the Horse Guards,’”’ a great catastrophe was preparing. From the very beginning Dr. Fitchett does not once lose sight of the end. He presents us with the spectacle of Napoleon standing on the deck of the Bellerophon even before he ‘has de- scribed the main conditions of the contest. His first volume extends from the French regicide to the defence of Acre by Sir Sidney Smith. Thus the record is largely one of sea-fights, and the period has already been covered by Capt. Mahan. However, as Dr. Fitchett does not write for specialists, any profit which he may have derived from a study of the “Sea Power” seriesisinthe nature of gain to his audience. Apart from the de- scription of manceuvres at sea, where he can hardly escape following Mahan, he goes at some length into the state of the service, and discloses the spirit of mutiny and dis- affection which existed at the very time when the most brilliant victories were be- ing won. 1797, the year of St. Vincent and Camperdown, witnessed an almost incredibly large number of trials for mutiny and sedi- tion. Dr. Fitchett is sympathetic towards ability wherever he finds it, and his enter- taining style should give him a wide circle of readers. —The late Dr. James Martineau, who died on January 12 in the ninety-fifth year of his age, was easily the first of English Uni- tarians for a period of more than fifty years before his death. Dr. Priestley is the only other of them whose fame is at all likely to rival his in the historical per- spective. Martineau was not a good sec- tarian, and his coreligionists were often grieved because he lent himself so grudg- ingly to their sectarian organization. He was always glad to call himself a Unitarian, but unwilling to connect himself with orga- nizations carrying a theological distinction in their names. On the eightieth anni- versary of his birth, in response to the greetings of the National Conference of English Unitarians, he declared his ‘‘con- viction that the true religious life supplies grounds of sympathy and association deeper and wiser than can be expressed by any doctrinal names or formulas; and that free play can never be given to these spiritual affinities till all stipulation, direct or im- plied, for specified agreement in theological opinion is discarded from the bases of church union.’’ He did not’ hope for the disestablishment of the National Church, but for such reformation of it that it might in- clude all aspects of sincere belief and ear- nest life. His influence was not confined to the Unitarian body. He had many readers and disciples in the National and dissenting churches, and the religious literature of England has had many clear reflections of his thought. A prominent writer in the Reviews for sixty years, contemporary with Carlyle and Newman and Mill and Darwin and Spencer, he had a leading part in all the greater controversies of the time, and the sweep of his learning and the keenness of his dialectic made him an antagonist whose youth nor manhood no man could despise. The most painful episode of his career was his misunderstanding with his sister Har- riet, who enthusiastically adopted the philo- sophical and ethical opinions from which he had turned away. He maintained a rigid silence when assailed by Harriet’s friends until the appearance of Mrs. F. Fenwick Miller’s life of his sister in the ‘‘Famous Women Series.’’ Then the superfluous as- sault upon his mother’s memory elicited from him a sharp rejoinder. Harvard Col- lége gave him the degree of LL.D. in 1872, the University of Leyden the degree of Doc- tor of Theology in 1875, and Edinburgh Uni- versity the degree of D.D. in 1x4. —Mr. Oliveira Lima, Secretary of the Bra- zilian Legation at Washington, has publish- ed a volume (‘Nos Estados Unidos’) of po- litical and social impressions derived from a three years’ sojourn in this country (Leip- zig: Brockhaus.) His eleven chapters must not be judged as a symmetrical essay, for they are composed of articles contributed to the Revista Brazileira and of letters to the Jornal do Commercio. Mr. Lima gives us, therefore, first and current im- pressions, and is not concerned with pro- portion or closeness of texture. His re- view of American writers, for instance, fill- ing some forty pages, devotes seven pages to Mark Twain and sixteen to John Fiske, who has seldom been praised by a more hearty admirer. lLllustrative of his discur- siveness is the occurrence, in the chapter entitled ‘Effects of Immigration,’’ of a sum- mary account of the contents of the Metro- politan Museum of Art in this city. Bos- ton’s Public Library, park system, and his- torical associations are also here touched off, in paragraphs which end with a para- ble of G. W. Steevens’s about a Bostonian’s likening Irish rule in his city to negro elec- toral supremacy at the South. A real- ly pertinent fact, had it been known to Mr. Lima, would have been that the Irish citizens of Boston had far more to do with saving the old State-House from demoli- tion than the blue blood of Beacon Hill. “‘Woman’s Influence” is discussed with but incidental mention of woman’s suffrage, and with no apparent knowledge of the origin of the agitation in favor of it. Similarly, lynching is little dwelt upon in the open- ing chapter on ‘The Negro Problem,” nor is any notice taken of the tendency towards caste separation of the races in the new Southern industrial development. In that constant comparison of the two republics which is one of the writer’s motives for publication, he remarks, on page 52, that such a law as that which prevails at the South, prohibiting intermarriage of white and black, could never be enacted or exe- cuted in Brazil. The peculiar form of crime which incites our Southern lynching, he adds, is not on the increase in Brazil since emancipation; but he stops short of suggesting that the abrogation of our South- ern statutes against intermarriage would perhaps tend to reduce the frequency of the offence so much feared and so savagely avenged. —The latest issue of the Berlin Royal Ethnological Museum’s publications is again brimful of the best scientific matter. The first half of the sixth volume, just out, is taken up entirely with contributions to Mexican archeology made by Dr. Edward Seler. Of his ‘eighteen annual festive pe- riods’’ of ancient Mexico the first section is presented in the last number, his principal authority being Bernardino Sahagun, a Franciscan clergyman who arrived in Mexi- co from Le6én, his natal province, in 1529, and died in 1590. The circumstance that this author wrote but shortly after the con- quest renders his descriptions especially valuable. Sahagun composed the twelve books of his ‘Historia General de las Cosas de Nueva Espafia’ in the Nahuatl language. The two parts of it are now kept in two dif- ferent libraries at Madrid, but the whole also exists in an ancient copy with fine il- lustrations, in part translated into Spanish. This manuscript was recently discovered in the Biblioteca Laurenziana in Florence, Italy, by Zelia Nuttall. What has been hitherto published of Sahagun’s archzolo- gical work gives only a faint idea of the contents and the high value of the whole. The eighteen annual feasts discussed by Dr. Seler are based on the calendar which was common to the Mexican and Maya nations, and counted, to make up the year, eighteen sections of twenty days each. In Mexico a section was called eompoualli, from the word for twenty, and each section had its own name, ceremonies, and sacrifices. In Seler’s article the ceremonies attending every sec- tion are described by prefixing Sahagun’s Nahuatl text, and then adding his own Ger- man translation with extensive comments, by which a full understanding is made pos- sible. ~The subjects discussed in the two other papers of vol. vi., part 1, are of equal interest. One of them, “Pictorial Images of the Mex- VX ——— =
Page 19
| ta 53 bs i Jan. 18, 1900] The Nation. _ 55 ican Annual Celebrations,”’ describes the feasts, ceremonials, pageants, and mummery attending these popular demonstrations, and may be regarded as a sort of abstract or recapitulation of the former article. The accompanying pictures are taken from va- rious Nahuatl codices, but without the gaudy coloring of the originals. ‘Sorcery and Wizards in Ancient Mexico”’’ is the title of another erudite article in the same fas- cicle. For ethnologic science the beliefs and symbolism of witchcraft are always in- structive, and among primitive nations like those of Mexico the practice of medicine (or say of healing) is intimately connected with sorcery and jugglery. As among our northern Indians, the members of the ‘‘fa- culty” belonged to several classes, and for Mexico Dr. Seler establishes four—the medi- cine men (titici), the soothsayers (tlahpou- qué), the jugglers (teireuepanimé), and the wizards or sorcerers proper (nanualtin), who were also forecasters or prophets, rain- makers, and producers of hallucinations. Many of them were doing their best to bene- fit the race, but others, probably the ma- jority, were intent upon inflicting injury upon their fellow-men. SEA-POWER ETHICS. Lessons of the War with Spain, and Other Articles. By Alfred T. Mahan, D.C.L., LL.D., Captain United States Navy, etc. Boston: Little, Brown & Co. Pp. 320. We have here a new volume in which are collected the essays that Captain Ma- han has published in the past year. Five of them make a series which gives the title to the book. The other four treat of subjects more or less closely allied to the imperialist expansion, of which the author is a leading advocate. The essays upon the war with Spain are a very instructive and interesting analysis of the naval ope- rations in the West Indies, and, considered as a discussion of the war as actually con- ducted, could not easily be improved. The author’s professional knowledge and his study of the broader problems of naval stra- tegy give lucid expositions of the recurring critical situations in the Caribbean Sea, while his position as member of the stra- tegy board at Washington makes his ex- planation of the reasons which controlled the naval conflict authoritative. The ef- forts to advocate his imperialist theories are kept subordinate to the historical pre- sentation, and do not challenge much de- bate. In the essay on Distinguishing Quali- ties of Ships of War we find also good professional treatment of the subject, skil- fully adapted to popular comprehension. The other papers may properly be treat- ed as a politician’s partisan advocacy of the imperialism which builds upon conquest the policy of assuming the r6éle of a “great Power,” in the European sense, asserting a potent influence in every world-contro- versy, and taking a hand in every scheme for the spread of empire. The essay on our Relations to our New Dependencies is a statement of principles of government, by a conquering Power, over dependent peoples, for their own good (from the conqueror’s point of view). It is a summary of the policy which Great Britain has evolved from much painful experience, and, if rights of weaker communities to self-government are put among the exploded whimsies of our youth and the discarded “swaddling-clothes” of our infancy, the author’s exhortations to be guided by “beneficence,”” as well as self- interest, do credit to his heart. If we must have despotism, by all means let it be the maternal despotism which Captain Mahan describes. In the essay upon the Peace Conference and the Moral Aspect of War, we reach the discussion of fundamental principles of ethics as the basis of law, whether mu- nicipal or international. As to what the Conference of The Hague actually did, the author expresses a mild approval, when it is limited to the affirmation of the decision “that it is to arbitration men must look for relief [from the evils of war] rather than to partial disarmament, or even to an arrest in the progress of preparations for war’”’ (p. 208). He sees, however, “cause for serious reflection when this most hu- mane impulse is seen to favor methods which, by compulsion, shall vitally impair the moral freedom and the consequent mo- ral responsibility which are the distinguish- ing glory of the rational man and of the sovereign state’’ (p. 209). He seems to have found in the Conference, and in the friendly discussion of the proposals before it, this tendency to put the duty to ar- bitrate international disputes among the agreed principles of international law, so that the conferring Powers consenting thereto might apply to future disputes that moral coercion to arbitrate which is now found in the other agreed principles, such as, for instance, the rule that you shall not slaughter your prisoners. This ten- dency, though it resulted in no action {n the Conference, he finds it his duty to combat vigorously, lest the distinguishing glory of the sovereign state should be eclipsed. The philosophy upon which the contention is based is presented with formidable sea- power. The first postulate laid down is that “‘one of the most unfortunate characteristics of our present age is the disposition to im- pose by legislative enactment—by external compulsion, that is—restrictions of a moral character which are either fundamentally unjust, or at least do not carry with them the moral sense of the community as a whole” (p. 209). The argumentative use of this is to create in the reader a readiness to rebel against legislative control. But in truth no period of the world’s history has been so free from such an “unfortunate cha- racteristic.”’ Never has the tendency been so strong towards local and individual au- tonomy; towards freedom of thought and of action; towards liberty of speech and un- trammelled locomotion; towards easy bonds of allegiance and liberal practice of expa- triation. The postulate is a false assump- tion in fact. The next step is to assert the right and the duty to follow one’s own conscience, in obedience or disobedience to public law. One need have little quarrel with the proposition if enlightened conscience were properly dis- tinguished from ignorant or ill-educated im- pulses; if the anarchical tendency of deny- ing authority were fully weighed; if the ob- ligation to preserve and respect human so- ciety were measured; if the presumptions in favor of law were not casually named, but soberly analyzed. So far from this being done, the author states, as the thing to be “carefully kept in mind,” that it is not the “absolute right or wrong of the particular act, as seen in the clearer light of a later day,”” that justifies men in disobedience “The saving salt which has preserved the healthfulness of the body politic has been the fidelity to conscience, to the faithful, if passionate, arbiter of the moment" (p. 212). To call such hasty, passionate action on the impulse of the moment conscientious, is a simple abuse of language. When a man is face to face with the choice between obedi- ence to law or rebellion against it, passion and haste are the opposites of conscience, and most commonly used to silence its judg ments. By such inversions of the meaning of terms, the absurd logic is easy by which the author concludes that making war for slavery is as conscientious as making war to resist it, and, after a holocaust of human lives and the desolation of half a continent, not only is nobody morally responsible, but the aggressors “‘made no small contribution to the record of fidelity to conscience and to duty which is the highest title of a na tion to honor” (p. 213). To cap the paradox, he affirms, in the same paragraph, his agree- ment with Lincoln that “if slavery is not wrong nothing is wrong.”’ His stunning con- clusion is that the Slave Power would have been wicked not to make the war, because, “be it by action or be it by submission, by action positive or action negative, whatever is not of faith—of conviction—is sin.” He omits to draw the final conclusion which his logic demands, that Nothing is wrong. One would naturally suppose that the con clusion that men and nations may be equal- ly conscientious on either side of the most bloody conflicts, nay, that they would “sin” if they did not fight on the side of the most plain and demonstrable of wrongs, would find its most’ evident corollary in the doctrine of general arbi tration. In such a muddle it would seem wise beyond dispute to submit our differ- ences to disinterested tribunals guided by standards of right which are based upon the assent of the ages, and so escape from the wars that must follow the imaginary dic- tates of a bogus conscience which may ap- prove either side of a conflict between H- berty and slavery, and which decides pas- sionately and on the moment Far from it. The logical stress only nerves the ethi- cal philosopher to the dialectic feat of as- serting that this conscientious judgment that right is wrong makes it wrong, and that “even the material evils of war are less than the moral evil of compliance with wrong” (p. 215). How consoling to the anarchist who threw his bomb into the French As- sembly, and what a noble justification to our compatriot in Sulu who runs amuck that he may win the Moslem paradise! The final word of Jingo philosophy is, ‘‘It is not the accuracy of the decision, but the faithful- ness to conviction, that constitutes the moral worth of an action, national or indivi- dual” (p. 216). The Sulu juramentado is faithful unto death, and Captain Mahan, if consistent, must echo the voice of Allah, Come thou blessed! As is usual in self-deluding fallacies, hav- ing made an absurd definition of conscience, having divorced it from ail criteria of right as recognized by the common judgment of mankind and left it to the impulse of the individual, true or false, strong or weak, wise or foolish, the author now slides back to the common notion of conscience as a God-given judgment In real accord with tun selfish ideals and love to our neighbor. The
Page 20
KAS les ot RT ee eee eb 28 56 The Nation. ' [Vol. 70, No. 1803 “passionate arbiter of the moment” again becomes the diligent searcher of his own bosom, its motives and its standards, and the authority of such a deliberate, altruistic judgment is coolly transferred to the coun- terfeit. ‘‘Between God and man,” he tells us, ‘“‘no other arbiter comes; and if this be so, a pledge beforehand [to arbitrate] is impossible’ (p. 220). He thus reaches the sad conclusion that a treaty agreeing to arbitrate future disputes is contrary to con- science, and, of course, wicked. He is will- ing to concede that there may be some mere interests, not involving conscience, which may be submitted to arbitration; but the door is so wide open to making anything a point of conscience that, even as to past differences, the field of arbitration is too narrow to waste time upon. The ancient, au- thoritative maxim of law, that ‘‘no,one is a rightful judge in his own cause,” is, thus deposed in favor of the truly imperialistic one that everybody is his own sole judge, by divine right. If general war shall follow, the universal conflagration will only illu- mine and bring into stronger relief the moral grandeur of the resistance to coercion even to keep the peace; for compulsory arbitra- tion assumes ‘‘a moral obligation to do or to allow a wrong”’ (p. 224). From such a point of view it is not strange that peace should seem ignoble, and war rise to the dignity of a world’s benefactor. “Step by step, in the past, man has ascend- ed by means of the sword, and his more re- cent gains as well as present conditions show that the time has not yet come to kick down the ladder which has so far served him” (p. 230). We italicize the phrase which so charmingly characterizes the base ingra- titude to War which is a crying sin of the present age. If any of us are so belated in progress as still to hold that the gradus ad Parnassum is found in peaceful education, developing ideas of the true, the beautiful, and the good, leading on to standards of justice heartily respected, and good will to our neighbor spontaneously exercised, we here find our deserved condemnation and correction. Swords, not ideas, are the rungs of the ladder of human progress. We are now taught that it was the sword, and not the vigorous growth of law, of letters, and of free religion, that made the land of Gro- tius the enlightened country it is. It was Philip’s remorseless war upon its advanced notions in intellect and private conscience that was the praiseworthy cause of great good. If we have foolishly supposed that progressive enlightenment was the precedent condition of the high position the Dutch na- tion attained, and the sword was Philip's wicked instrument of oppression, let us hasten to correct our ignorance, If we have imagined that Philip and Alva were foiled, and that noble enlightenment survived in spite of (not by reason of) the Spanish bigot’s war, though the sword was backed by the gibbet, the rack, and the stake, let us recant our misjudgment of the conscientious king, and glorify not only the sword but his other pious instrumentalities. If we have weakly thought that when the Ruler of the Universe ‘‘maketh the wrath of man to praise him,’’ he does not thereby sanctify the wrath and transmute it into holiness, let us confess our error and be humbly thankful that, even at this late day, we have enjoyed the teaching of a professor emeritus of Jingo ethics. In our wicked effort to over- turn the ladder of swords, we have only been ‘kicking against the pricks.” SMITH’S NEW TRADES COMBINATION. The New Trades Combination Movement; Its Principles, Methods, and Progress. By E. J. Smith. With an Introduction by the Rev. J. Carter, M.A., Bursar of Pusey House, Oxford. London: Rivingtons. 1899. During the last-seven or eight years a most significant movement has been making headway in business circles in England, es- pecially in the Midlands, around Birming- ham—a movement which has hitherto hardly attracted in this country all the attention it deserves. A certain Mr. E. J. Smith, evi- dently a man of original and masterful cha-_ racter, who had made his way up to the posi- tion of an employer through all the grades of journeyman, foreman, manager, and travel- ler, has managed to induce almost all the manufacturers in his own line of business, the metallic bedstead trade, to form a close combination of an altogether novel type. So successful has this ‘‘Alliance’’ proved, and so persuasive has been Mr. Smith’s advocacy of his plan as applicable to any industry and a blessing to all concerned, that he has been invited to organize some half-a-dozen others among the smaller trades on the same lines. Now every few months some fresh combina- tion or other is launched under his auspices. All this has not happened without a great amount of opposition from recalcitrant manu- facturers, and also of sweeping and bitter criticism in the public press. The editors of the English Economic Review were quick- sighted enough to perceive the possible sig- nificance of the movement. Mr. Smith was nothing loath to appeal to economists, and contributed a series of articles in explanation of his plan, the first on its general principles, the others on its relation to the workman, to the foreign competitor, and to the consumer, respectively; and it is these articles which have now been collected in a handy little volume, with an introduction by the Rev. John Carter, the able and energetic secre- tary of the Christian Social Union. Mr. Smith is of opinion that the main cause of business distress in all its forms, and of the effort to reduce wages to make up for falling profits, or to ward off bank- ruptey, is to be found in the temptation, to which manufacturers are exposed by the pressure of competition, to sell below cost. He asserts that, absurd as it may seem, a large number of manufacturers have in fact no definite and accurate notion of the cost of producing the articles they deal in. The first principle, therefore, on which he in- sists is the necessity of correctly “taking out costs.’ This is largely a matter for the accountant, though it involves several in- teresting questions to be referred to later. The next step is to induce all the manufac- turers of a particular trade, after following certain commonrules of cost-taking adjusted to the average business, to agree to fix the price of each article by adding a certain definite percentage of profit. So far there is nothing particularly new in the scheme. The cifficulty has always been to hold the members of the association to the agree- ment: it has never seemed possible to get out of them a guarantee payment sufficient- ly large tomake its forfeiture a serious con- sideration. One of the expedients to which aimilar combinations have had recourse in tbis country, namely, a compact with the transportation agencies, is impracticable in England; another, to wit, a system of dis- counts to buyers, is commonly inadequate. Mr. Smith’s invention to overcome the dif- ficulty is nothing more nor less than an open and avowed coalition with the workmen in the trade. He insists that where the men are not already organized they shall be formed into a union, and that the masters shall engage to employ no non-unionists, in return for the agreement of the union to work for no employer not belonging to the Alliance. Accordingly, a manufacturer who breaks away from the Alliance has to reckon, at the very outset, with a strike of his employees. The assistance of the men is not obtained for nothing. The bargain between the two associations of employers and employed contains elaborate provisions for a bonus on wages in proportion to an increase in prices, and for a Joint Conciliation Board to settle all possible matters of dispute. Ac- cording to a late Lord Mayor of Birming- ham, the increase in remuneration has amounted in the bedstead trade to 25 per cent. The general results have been thus summed up in a characteristic speech by Mr. Joseph Chamberlain: “In a trade in which every one, whether workman or employer, was dissatisfied, he has brought contentment. Wages, I believe, have been increased, profits have become larger, and, curious to relate, the demand and the production have increased at the same time. This experiment, I believe, is capable of great development. I understood, when I was last in Bradford, that a great trade in that city has agreed to adopt the principles upon which Mr. Smith has se- cured success. - Iam always glad that a new light should proceed from Bir- mingham.”’ Even the Bedstead Alliance, however, is not yet out of the woods. It is true that the outcry against it would seem to have pro- ceeded, not from the general public, but from the ironmongers and other middlemen who have hitherto been able to play off one manufacturer against another. For moiths there has been talk of the establishment of an opposition factory at Antwerp; but it is probably only talk. Yet it would be strange if a neighborhood so characterized by indi- vidual initiative as the Midlands submitted without a murmur to so singularly complete a system of regulation. And as it is, two manufacturers, one in Birmingham and the other near Manchester, were holding out at the date of our last advices. Without speculating as to the distant fu- ture, it may be recognized that the new movement has hitherto enjoyed a very con- siderable measure of prosperity. Moreover, no one can have moved in English business circles of late, especially in Yorkshire and Lancashire, without realizing that combina- tion is in the air. And as there are many masters who really value trades-unionism, and still more who feel they cannot get rid of it, it is very probable indeed that the early decades of the coming century will witness in England a whole series of at- tempts to create what may be called a ver- tical organization of the industrial field—to harmonize and formally associate all the in- terests in particular industries, from top to bottom, in the face of the rest of the world. We see no reason to question Mr. Smith’s genuine regard for social welfare, and espe- cially for the workingmen; we are ready to allow that the consumers affected by his al- liances have suffered inappreciably; but the CRM esata roa 2
Page 21
Jan. 18, 1900] The Nation. 57 plan is so full of potentialities that he must be patient with us if we insist on its weak point. That weak point is the interest of the consumer. Mr. Smith is perfectly right in saying that the older school of economists paid too exclusive an attention to the con- sumer; he is right in urging that the work- men are themselves consumers. What is even more to the point, he is justified in his contention that in unrestricted competition there is no necessary safeguard for the con- sumer, inasmuch as recent experience goes to show that competition itself tends to the creation of monopoly. But the moral of all this is neither that the consumer can be dis- regarded, nor that the alliance plan is to be condemned. It is rather that the public should be given a good deal more definite in- formation than they have yet received as to the details of the mechanism. What is the way in which the consumer tends to be pro- tected under competitive conditions? It is that when the profits of a particular business are noticeably higher than in other indus- tries, new men and new capital are attracted to it; and if prices continue too high, over- production ensues, and then prices fall. This would be cold comfort in the case of many industries where only large capitals find an opening; but with the Birmingham trades, where businesses are still comparatively small, where there is a great deal of enter- prise and money always on the watch for fresh opportunities, and where exceptional men can still rise from the ranks, it is a solid satisfaction. Will not Mr. Smith con- vince us of the persistence of this salutary check on excessive prices, in the bedstead trade for instance, by telling us the exact financial conditions of membership in his Alliance? Is it easy for a new man to en- ter the association? In order that the equalizing forces of individual enterprise should work at all rapidly, it must be pos- sible to find out what profit is actually be- ing made in the several trades. Will not Mr. Smith tell us what is the ‘fair inte- rest’”’ which must, in his scheme, be reck- oned among costs of production? Will he not tell us how he reckons the ‘wages of management”? which are similarly counted in? Will he not say what is the profit the Alliance adds to the production-cost of each article? As a bedstead-maker, Mr. Smith may hesitate to satisfy our curi- osity; as a social reformer, we are con- vinced it would be his best policy in the long run. Certainly, if combinations con- tinue to flourish, publicity of accounts will be the only alternative to state interfer- ence; and if it is not voluntary, it will be compulsory. Memoirs of a Revolutionist. By P. Kropot- kin. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co. 1899. It may be truly said of Prince Kropotkin’s Memoirs that they offer a better all-round picture of a certain type of Russians in par- ticular, and of the genuine aristocratic so- cialist and anarchist in general, than any other record in existence. The first part of the autobiography is not a whit inferior to Count L. N. Tolstoy’s famous ‘Childhood, Boyhood, Youth,’ in its vivid limning of fa- mily and social life sixty years ago in Rus- sia; indeed, it far surpasses Tolstoy’s work in actual details, though the plucking up his thoughts and feelings by the roots to inspect their state of growth, pre- paratory to replanting and reinspection, is suggested, not minutely recorded as in Tol- stoy’s case. Many people, no doubt, will be shocked at the account of the treatment frequently dealt out to serfs, under the old régime, as intelligent Russians might be shocked at many occurrences during the old slave days in our Southern States; but the instances of good temper, fine feeling, and faithful affection narrated by the author offset the horrors, in that they furnish data for judging the general character of the peasants who (when properly educated) are destined to exercise a decisive influence up- on the world. What is absolutely new is the description of life in the crack military school and the suggestively thorough trainp- ing of Russian officers, which is of interest to foreign nations at present, especially to those which have too hastily taken univer- sal ignorance for granted in that greatly misunderstood empire. The author states, in his prefatory note, that he has added considerably to the ori- ginal text (as it appeared in the Aflantic Monthly, September, 1898-1899), in the parts dealing with his youth and his stay in Si- beria, and especially in the part where he has told the story of his life in Western Europe. Such is the intense interest of the book that it is to be regretted he did not make two volumes, at least, and deal with the two halves of his life in a wholly satisfactory manner. As it is, we should be very glad to have an unstinted quantity of social pic- tures from so clever a pen, while more fulness of psychological study and of practical detail are certainly needed in the socialistic-anarchistic division to en- able the reader to comprehend and pass just judgment upon Prince Kropot- kin’s aims and methods. For example, he mentions that, on his father’s death and his inheritance of a large landed estate, he meditated putting in practice there the so- cialistic theories to which he had already dedicated himself; but, on being warned by’ competent persons that this would be im- possible, he refrained. There the incident ends, so far as we are informed. He does not mention whether he left the estate to be administered on the usual plan, condemned by him, shifting the responsibility to a hired steward, or whether he sold it, and thus shifted the responsibility in a still easier manner; or what he did with the proceeds. Later on, when he records the efforts of him- self and his fellow-anarchists to found a newspaper—an “‘organ’’—he says that their combined funds amounted to about four dol- lars; and he constantly refers to some handicraft exercised by himself (nowhere specified), as a means of livelihood. Inevi- tably, the reader demands: ‘‘What had be- come of your estate? Why did not you re- main in Russia and superintend the welfare of the peasants there resident, as many Raus- sian landed proprietors actually do, even if you were unable to raise them to your level or lower yourself to theirs? And if manual labor is the sole means of salvation, why did you waste your time upon scientific work, however important to the world, however profitable to yourself?’ There are many other questions that occur to the non- anarchist public, which does not clearly un- derstand what aim the anarchists propose to themselves, unless it be to usurp the au- thority of the present powers, and dictate terms themselves in a more arbitrary man- ner. It is a disappointment that Kropotkin has not seized the opportunity to elucidate this point, for it must be conceded that he pos- sesses one incalculable merit over his ijate friend and ally, “Stepniak’’—he is straight- forward and convinced, he carries the tradi- tion of his good birth and breeding into his revolutionary propaganda Stepniak was plausible and convincing, to the uninitiated in Russian affairs. But his books would not bear careful reading, and too frequently con- tradicted in one chapter the specious argu- ments of a preceding chapter, or an ordinary knowledge of chronology sufficed to annihi late his most powerful anecdotes of illustra tion. In conversation he would state a mat ter strongly, with entire conviction, to all ap pearances, and announce plans of future ac tion with the calm confidence of a mathe matical professor. But if his interlocutor happened to understand Russia, her people and problems, and objected, ‘“‘But that is not 80, because,"’ or, “‘You cannot work on that plan, for such and such reasons," Stepniak would yield, frankly and promptly, with 4 smile that was the apotheosis of the child like and bland, with the remark: “No, we cannot; I see that you understand."’ There- upon he would calmly proceed to repeat the manceuvre, as long as the time and the un derstanding (or ignorance) of his interlocu tor permitted Under such circumstances, belief in Stepniak’s sincerity was dif@ecult, to say the least. There is nothing of that sort with Kropotkin. We may trust his sincerity He has proved it; he has abandoned his ad- vantageous social position and revenues in Russia, and done actual labor, unlike some members of the British aristocracy who write socialistic articles and books on hear say knowledge, because the topic is popular, and receive for their amateur efforts—plus their title—excessive payments, which are diverted from the pockets of genuine literary workers toiling for their bread As the best example of a non-introspective but intensely interesting life-story of a high- ly gifted and sincere man, Prince Kropotkin’s volume merits a place in every library, even though it be not very convincing in its so- cialistic doctrines and attempted propaganda Elizabeth Pease Nichol. By Anna M. Stod- dart. With portraits and other illustra tions. London: Dent; New York: E. P. Dutton & Co. Pp. xi, 314 This Life of Mrs. Elizabeth Pease Nicol fitly commences a proposed series, under the editorship of Robert F. Horton, of “Saintly Lives.’’ We read (p. ix) “It was a saying of Jowett, the late Mas ter of Balliol, that more good would be done in the future by writing the lives of men and women who have deserved well of their kind, than by set treatises in theology and morals. The present series aims at be- ing a contribution to such a service.” We agree with the editor in the sugges- tion that Protestants have, in the lives of passing and present humanity, more zeal and higher incentives to purity of thought and action than have other religionista in the lives of those whom, it is supposed, the Deity has been moved to set apart above ordinary conditions of life and death. If to many who knew the late Mrs. Nichol some of Mrs. Stoddart’s chapters may ap pear heavy, and if more personal incidents might have been looked for, it must be al lowed that it would be difficult in print to give any real conception of the richness and
Page 22
STAs 4 B ii # o8 The Nation. * [Vol. 70, No. 1803 loveliness of this Englishwoman’s charac- ter. The reviewer’s endeavor would be even more difficult than the biographer’s. Born in 1807 of the best Quaker blood in England, Miss Pease married in 1853 Prof. Nichol, Astronomer Royal of Scotland. She was widowed in 1860, and survived until 1897. We are given three portraits of her. That which pleases us most is at the age of seventy, showing her still in the plenitude of her powers. Her fea- tures, seventeen years later, in their al- most leonine nobility, might well be tak- en for those of Mr. Gladstone. From Qua- kerism—at its best, as we have said—her mind expanded, mainly under the influence of the anti-slavery movement, to the broad- est Christianity. She was actively engaged in all the liberal philanthropic movements of her time. Either as guests at her fa- ther’s house in Darlington, at her married home in Glasgow, or her final retreat at Huntly Lodge, Edinburgh, or in corre- spondence, there stud the pages before us the names of such men and women as Wil- berforce and Clarkson, George Stephenson, O'Connell, Garrison, Phillips, Thompson, Harriet Martineau, and all the anti-slavery set; Cobden and Bright, W. E. Foster, Glad- stone, John Dillon; Mazzini, Kossuth, and Garibaldi. For American readers, the chief interest in Miss Pease lies in her intimate relations to the American abolitionists, and especially to their leader; and these have been set forth on an ample scale in the Life of Gar- rison, to whom she was in England what Mrs. Chapman was in America. Before his first visit abroad, however, she was al- ready schooled in the cause by assisting her father and his associates in abolishing slavery in the British West Indies, as later in terminating the apprenticeship system imposed by the half-hearted emancipation act of 1833. The methods of agitation and information of the public mind then em- ployed were most sagaciously and industri- ously used for the overthrow of slavery in the United States by casting the moral weight of Great Britain into the _ scale against the power which was on the side of the oppressor. They were equally avail- able on behalf of the natives of India as against the East India Company; or against the corn laws and in support of the Char- tists; against male monopoly of the higher education; against the Contagious Diseases Acts; against cruelty to animals. No hu- mane interest was foreign to her as Miss Pease or Mrs. Nichol, and she brought to each a rare degree of business and executive ability. Her old age was beautiful in the extreme, and, even when sightless, she was all alive to the politics and the philanthropy of the hour, as well as to her numerous friendships on both sides of the Atlantic. A perusal of this biography suggests a consideration of how much the world has lost in the practical abandonment by Qua- kerism—-by British Quakerism, at least—of its most moving peculiarities (which, how- ever, Mrs. Nichol never lost). Apart from church government and forms of worship, and as yet a lingering greater simplicity of social life, there is little now to distin- guish Friends from members of other re- ligious bodies. The scruples have mostly vanished. We have seen the list of a Friend stock-broking firm, one of whose members preaches in meeting, in which shares in taverns, breweries, and theatres are advertised. We are not aware of any collective protest having been made by the Society against the Transvaal war even as war. On the contrary, more strenuous individual testimony against it has been borne by individual members of other bo- dies than by individual Friends. Friends now without objection don the military garb of Deputy-Lieutenants of counties. Entering the civil service and professions, they have lost their old independence of thought and action, and compound for (in the main) abandoning their old humanita- rian réle at home and abroad by princi- pglly devoting themselves to foreign mis- sions, in which sphere they run no chance of endangering personal interests. It was not so when Quakerism gave birth to spirits like Elizabeth Pease Nichol. The Family of William Penn. By Howard M. Jenkins. Philadelphia: The Author. 1899. In this considerable work Mr. Jenkins has collected all that he could gather on the genealogy of the Penn family. He has not undertaken to make it a history of the Penns, for that would have led him far into the rise and position of the Quak- ers in England and the founding and early records of Pennsylvania. Confining himself as he does to the immediate family, he has been obliged to omit much of a more general interest bearing upon the intentions of the colonizers and their relations to state policy. As it is, the record was not a simple one to compile, for authorities have been contradictory, and the loss or absence of important links in the chain of evidence has given occasion to conjec- ture. The name and tradition point to a Welsh origin for the family, but the first authentic records begin with the fourth ge- neration from William Penn, and locate his ancestor in the County of Gloucester. It was Admiral Penn who gave the family prominence, and he would not be so well known but for the many references, com- plimentary and otherwise, given to him and his doings by Pepys. The son of the Ad- miral was William Penn, whose religious experiences and the hardships and reputa- tion gained through them, are too familiar to need summarizing. Mr. Jenkins refutes the story that Penn died insane, but shows him embarrassed in means, in spite of his American principality. His widow was at times hard pushed to obtain so small a sum as ten pounds. Among the original documents printed by Mr. Jenkins are some interesting let- ters of Hannah, the wife of William Penn, They throw light upon the household of the founder, and incidentally point to her strug- gle to obtain the means to meet the cur- rent expenses of her family. Some slaves were included in the estate, and she wrote: “The young Blacks must be dispos’d of to prevent their increasing Charge. I have of- fer’d my Daughter Aubrey one, but she does not care for any. I would, however, have y® likelyest Boy reserv’d, and bred to reading & sobriety as intending him for my self, or one of my children.’’ The worth- less son, William, sought to overthrow his father’s will, and laid claim to the proprie- torship of Pennsylvania, but was defeated in the attempt, and died soon after. His half-brother, Thomas, became priricipal pro- prietor, and held the trust for nearly thir- ty years, although residing in America only nine years. It was his nephew John who was Governor of Pennsylvania when the Revolution caused the collapse of all the Penn interests in the colony, with a loss amounting to nearly $7,500,000, the larger part of which was represented by unsold lands. Pennsylvania voted him a large sum after the peace, and a royal pension was given to him for his loyalty. The early mar- riage of John is lightly touched upon, but not explained, and the family history of the brothers is given. Mr. Jenkins has drawn largely from the manuscripts of the Pennsylvania Historical Society, and has made an interesting com- pilation, of which the general accuracy is very high. The book has many portraits. A Political History of Europe since 1814. By Charles Seignobos. Translation edited by S. M. Macvane. Henry Holt & Co. 1899. Whenever translation renders an impor- tant work accessible to a large audience which would otherwise be deprived of its use, the translator’s services should be swiftly recognized and defined. Prof. Mac- vane says, with studied moderation: “ ‘The Histoire Politique de l’Europe Contempo- raine,’ by Prof. Seignobos, seems to me to merit larger use among people of English speech than it is likely to receive in the original French’’; and, in fact, the book in question is one of very high importance to all who read history, and especially to such as are not engaged in its professional study. If a reader is prevented by circum- stances from making his own investigations, he is a good deal at the mercy of his author, and, accordingly, the latter’s fairness or unfairness becomes of the first consequence. Most of all is this true where recent history is concerned. Now Prof. Seignobos, apart from his splendid store of knowledge, both mediz- val and modern, his skill in putting a state- ment clearly, and his general cleverness, yields to no one in sincerity of tone. Prof. Macvane counts among his author’s various good qualities a ‘‘thorough freedom from na- tional or other prejudice.’’ The praise is just, and carries a special meaning when elicited by a work upon the present sub- ject. For instance, if one were comparing Seignobos with Fyffe in the matter of im- partiality, the Frenchman would be called quite the more.impersonal of the two. Prof. Macvane found the English chapters of the book less satisfactory than the others, but none of their shortcomings can be ascribed to a polemical spirit. Seignobos is learned, accomplished, clear, and the appearance in our language of his ‘Histoire Contempo- raine’ must be a source of satisfaction to others besides college teachers and their classes. The translation, with its index, contains more than 880 pages (or about four-fifths of the number in Fyffe), and is accordingly so long that we are unable to analyze the body of contents; but, with the aid of the author’s preface, we shall try to explain the purpose which the work contemplates. Seignobos begins with a query. Having ad- mitted his rashness in publishing a one-vol- ume history of contemporary Europe, he proceeds: “The question is, not whether this history be worth reading, but whether it can be written.”” An overwhelming sup- ich
Page 23
Jan. 18, 1900] The Nation. ply of material blocks the way, for since vigorous historical method demands the di- rect study of the sources, the conscientious inquirer is brought to a halt. “The life of one man would not be long enough, I do not say to study or to criticise, but to read the official documents of even a single country of Europe.’’ A modern author must yield to practical necessities, and make his attempt under limitations which are none the less strict because inevitable and clear- ly defined. Thus beset, Seignobos falls back on “‘mo- nographs, special histories, and annual pub- lications, all made at first hand.’’ These furnish a solid framework of fact, and, where doubt arises over their accuracy, they can be easily controlled by compari- son and other simple tests. A second diffi- culty, that arising from the citation of au- thorities, is partially met by frequent refer- ence to selected bibliographies. The chap- ters are short, and at the end of each a list of sources and works is given. By avoiding the establishment of disputed facts and the discovery of new ones, the text is still further compressed. Lastly, the author has renounced ‘‘all attempts at full narrative, all descriptions, character-sketches, and anecdotes; such things being nearly always matters of dispute.” We dwell at length upon the method which Seignobos employs because his book is ex- traordinarily useful and its scope should be fully outlined. Erudition, controversy, and picturesqueness he eschews in order to ac- complish one end. ‘‘My aim has been to enable my readers to comprehend the es- sential phenomena of the political life of Europe in the nineteenth century, by ex- plaining the organization of the nations, governments, and parties, the political ques- tions which have arisen in the course of the century, and the solutions they have receiv- ed. T have tried to write an explanatory history.”” Social, intellectual, and artistic phenomena are strictly excluded, andsif any non-political facts are used, it is simply in a context which connects them with po- lities. Seignobos’s ‘Contemporary Europe’ then, a masterly explanation of political movements. It begins at the Congress of Vienna, and reaches a very recent date in the case of each country or of each episode considered. The author not commit himself, hands bound, to any special form of treatment, whether comparative, chrono- logical, or geographical. Throughout the greater part of the work he follows a geo- graphical line of division, beginning with England, ‘which furnished the model of po- litical organization for all Europe,” and ending with “the group of eastern states, Ottoman and Russian, which have longest retained the political forms of the eigh- teenth century.’’ When he wishes to con- sider the material conditions of political life, the state of the Roman Church, and the international parties of revolution, he uses a comparative method. And when he passes the external relations of states under review (¢. g., the System of Metternich, Rivalry between Russia and England, the Nationalist Wars, and the Armed Peace) he observes the order of time. Each pas- sage is carefully wrought, and the com- bination of passages forms a luminous whole. Prof. Macvane is responsible for the quall- ty of the translation, but it will be noticed is, does that on the title-page he speaks of himself as an editor. ‘“‘Most of the actual labor of translation has been done by another."* The English version is correct and smooth, and a good index has been added. Prof. Mac- vane, however, has not limited himself to contributing the He has “freely revised and partly rewritten the chapters on England” because they seemed not quite to equal the remainder of the volume in ex- cellence. We need only say of the changes that they have not reached the of structural alteration, and are an improve- ment upon the original. We have described the character of this treatise so far as possible in its own words and from its own standpoint. Its value is so great because it represents admirable knowledge and discernment, together with skill in the rapid explanation of large ques- tions. For the early stages of university work it is too advanced, but for maturer preface. point undergraduates as well as for adults it must prove an invaluable guide. Under Three Flags in Cuba. By George Clarke Musgrave. Boston: Little, Brown & Co. 1899. This narrative purports to be ‘‘a personal account of the Cuban Insurrection and Spa- nish-American War.” According to his story, the author joined Ruis Rivera’s west- ern army, as a newspaper correspondent, just after Maceo’s death; made his way into the Spanish lines; went familiarly about Havana, attended executions at Cabafias, chatted with Weyler and had some thought of kidnapping him; worked eastward again among the insurgents, meeting Gomez, Gar- cia, and the insurgent Government in Cama- guéy; saw a number of fights; returned to Havana, was imprisoned as a spy, transport- ed to Spain, and released as a British sub- ject in time to witness the Santiago cam- paign. An author with such opportunities should have written a book. Perhaps the seizure of his original manuscript, ‘‘to- gether with three hundred photographs of Weyler’s régime in Cuba and some historical letters that had passed between the Cap- tain-General Premier CAénovas,”’ ac- counts for his failure to do so. Barring his picture of the horrors of a Spanish transport and the common ill-treatment of Spanish conscripts, there is nothing new in the whole volume. is so incoherent that one follows his wander- ings with difficulty; and his personal story is lost in a jungle of hearsay and extraneous matter. Even in what as an eye-witness, the ‘‘journalistic’’ habit dis- torts his vision. The ‘swells of the organ” and ‘“‘the voices of the choir” ‘‘wafted across the bay” from the Cathedral, steal upon the ears of the dying patriots at Cabafias. From Marianao (which he calls ‘‘Mariano’’) just beyond the River Almendares (which he calls ‘“‘Almanares’’), he notes the moon's ‘pure radiance lighting up the distant spires and domes of Havana,”’ resting on ‘‘massive guns” where ‘the great Santa Clara and Vedado batteries loomed grimly in the dis- tance,”’ ‘“‘making them gleam like polished silver,’ etc., etc. This !s a sublimation of hearing and eye-sight—like listening to the choir of Trinity from Columbia Heights, and watching the ferry-slips at Cortlandt Street from Spuyten Duyvil! The book is charac- memorable and Moreover, the writer’s chronology he describes terized throughout by such loose and bom- a >) +S o bastic misstated facts of com mon common use writing, by knowledge, and misspelled names The author claims a part in the rescue of Evange‘ina Cisneros, and b trays in an unconscious note (p. 104) how far the irresponsible vagaries of “yellow journalism"’ may go for mischief Mr Decker, during the winter, formulated a plan to rescue Capt. Dreyfus, which M Hearst wished to effect without causing ternational Maine complications, . but disaster and the war diverted tt unprecedented journalistic enterprise Sertus Empiricus and Greck Scepticiam. Vs Mary Mills Patrick. Cambridge, Ens Deighton, Bell & Co. 1899. The movement called Scepticism—for cannot be called a philosophy—has never |: strong hold of the imaginations of m« There iz in the human being an ingrained love of dogmatizing; and a method which i entirely negative and cffers nothing in plarc« of the belief that it destroys, has little cha: of taking root. The very name of the founder of the sceptic school, Pyrrho, is a secret cf scholarship; for the agnostics of Greece their modern imitators, were n-t represent ed by any figure so commanding as to com pel the attention of the ignorant. Pyrrhoen ism and Pyrrho are mere shadows. What layman off-hand could come within a cen tury of the date of Sextus Empiricus, pe: like haps the greatest of them all? Yet, wit! these two men, Scepticism was much mors than the mental laziness that is often the only basis of agnosticism. When we call a man a sceptic, we imply merely that he does not hold certain ce: ventional beliefs. directed The followers of Pyrrho their reasoning powers to suspe their judgment that they saw both sides « t every question with perfect impartiality bu actually resulted was a state of mental equ'- librium that cannot be distinguished fre: the a@quus of the Stoic dogmat Apathy follows this sort of agnosticism a a} Vt wh sence of dogmatism was their aim; animus by chance, as a shadow follows the body; anid this is the most positive side of a philosophy that that it oral conclusions, had no criterion, and could never was unique in drew no m state the grounds of its negations. To > 2 would be to dogmatize. We fear that Mrs. Patrick's never reach those whose ignorance of Sext Empiricus it He: thesis is admirable for its purpose as a do tor’s dissertation (accepted at Berne in iS%7) volume will intended to dispel is and, as a supplement to Zeller, will be read with interest by students. was a sceptical doctor who lived (probably) at the close of the second century A. D. H spent his life in attacking Stoic degmatism and, in general, all the sciences that have labored to construct. We have ‘“‘Hypotyposes,”’ the public lectures in which he tried to demolish dogmatism, and not the least valuable part of the present work is the translation of these by the authoress There is an interesting chapter on the reia tion of Pyrrhonism and the Scepticism of the Academy. If we had thought that the English of th« President of a college must be above suspi- cion, the writer’s style would be a disiliu sion. On p. 29 we encounter this curiously compounded sentence: “He threw the sponges at the picture that he had used to wipe th« Sextus Empiri men the colors from the painting with.” The fol-
Page 24
eg snif sng eke wr se Ls woes ae ee
& Pe A ¢ - es z a > pipette 2 9-0
60 The Nation.
[Vol. 70, No. 1803
lowing positively defy analysis: ‘‘He states that a philosopher himself is a part cf the discord, and to be judged, rather than being capable of judging” (p. 45); “‘Saisset is cor. rect in saying . . . but it is not correct when we consider” (p. 57). A thesis which is published in book form invites criticism and should at least be free from bad grammar, On p. 82 the phrase Antigonus of Carystius is presumably a slip.
A World in a Garden. By R. Neish. Lon- don: J. M. Dent & Co.; New York: Mac- millan. 1899. It is the hard-won Scotch garden which, in its owner’s esteem, surpasses all others, and the enthusiasm with which this author writes of his brief northern blooms would seem exaggerated to the South, where flow- ers are matter of course the whole year through, and no long winter sleep adds in- tensity to the common joy in spring’s awak- ening. But the ‘world’ held by this garden is more than a collection of vegetable life. Poetry, religion, and philosophy are dis- cussed with the plants, which our author | finds appreciative, perhaps instructive, in- terlocutors; even doting upon the ab- sence of more disputatious human neigh- bors. Why, then, should he seek the audi- ence he professes to scorn, or at least dis- regard? The assumption that his person- ality is of general interest is, of course, necessary to the man who sits duwn to write a personal book; but when we are lea into a garden only to talk about its owner, we feel a little tricked, and inelined to doubt the genuineness of his enthusiasm as a gar- dener, and to wonder if in other circum- stances he might not have unfolded himseif just the same on the text of carpets and furniture. “I have always loved Chippen- dale chairs,’’ tells as much of a man’s cha- racter as, ‘I have always loved lilies’’; and
equally invites the reply, ‘“‘Lucky dog, to have some to love.’’
BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Alden, R. MacD. The Rise of Formal Satire in England. ‘he ae Ginn & Co. Alexander, P. Darwin and Darwinism Pure and mune, Sandan John Bale, Sonus & Daniels- son. 7s. ws A. hy ‘Elementary Chemistry, Macmillan. th Atkinson, P. Power Transmitted by Electricity. London: Crosby, Lockwood & Son; New York: 1). Van Nostrand Co. Austen, Jane. Pride and NEES Persuasion, Emma, Mansfield Park, Sense and Sensibility, Northanger Abbey. [Temple ed. | London: J. M. Dent & Co.; New York: Macmillan, 8 vols. $s. juird, Prof. H. M. Theo. Beza, the Counsellor of the French Reformation. Putnams. $1.50, Balfour, Lady Betty. The History of Lord Lytton’s Indian Administration. Longmans, Green & Co. Barnes, Rev. W. E. The Books of Chronicles. Macmillan, $1. Bascom, J. Growth of Nationality in at United States: A Social Study. Putnams.. $1.25 Benson, A. C. The Life of Edward White, Some- time Archbishop of Canterbury. vols. $8. Bernard, Rev. J. H. The Pastoral Epistles. Mac- millan, 90e, —— Isabella B. The Yangtze Valley and Be- yone Putnams. 2 vols. $ti. Biack, N. Fr. First Reader. Macmillan. sourinot, Sir J. G. Builders of Novia Scotia. <A Historical Review. Toronto: Fhe Copp-Clark Co, Bowman, Isa. The Story of Lewis Carroll. E. P. Dutton & Co, $1. Brown, Prof. W. J. The New Democracy. A Political Study, Macmilian. $2. Bury, Bishop R. de. Philobiblon. New York: Meyer Bros, & Co, $2.50. Charles, Rey. R. H. A Critical History of the Doctrine of a Future Life in Israel, in Judaism, and in Christianity. London: Adam & Charles Black; New York: Macmillan. $5, Chiniquy, Rev. ©, Forty Years in the Church of Christ. Fleming H. Revell Co. $2.5 Cowell, B. The Hungarian Exiles. Eeaduet Samp- son Low, Marston & Co.; Milwaukee: Young Churchman Co. $1. Crookes, Sir W. The Wheat Problem. Lenton: John Murray; New York: Putnams. $1.25 Cruttwell, Maud. Luea Signorelli. London: George Bell & Sons; New York: Macmillan. Dearmer, Mabel. The Book of Penny Toys. “Maae- millan. $2. Densmore, Dr. E. Consumption and Chronic Dis- eases. London: Swan Sonnenschein & Co.; New York: The Stillman Pub. Co. Dresser, H. W. Voices of Freedom and Studies in the Philosophy of Individuality. Putnams. $1.25. Earle, J. Microcosmographie, ndon: J. M. Dent & Co.; New York: Maemillan. 50c. Emerson, E., jr. Pepys's Ghost. Boston: Richard G. Badger & ‘Co. Fernald, * Cc. True Motherhood. Funk & Wag- nalls Co, 60c. Fortescue, J. W. Kr History of the British Army. Macmillan. 2 vols. Headlam, J. W. Bismarck and the New German Empire. Putnams. $1.50.
Macmillan, 2 | | | | } | Hewlett, M. Bag mety 5 out of Tuscany. New ed. London: J. M. Dent & Co.; New York: Putnams, $2.50. Hiatt, C. Henry Irving. London: George Bell & Sons; New York: Macmillan. —_ Violet B. Prisoners of the Tower of Lon- London: J. M. Dent & Co.; New York: on P. Dutton & Co. $2.50. Hutton, C. A. Greek Terracotta Statuettes. Mac- millan. $2.50. Janes, Emily. The English Woman’s Year-Boo . and Directory. London: Adam & Charles Black New York: Macmillan. 50, Jephson, H. The Real French Revolution. Mac- millan. $1.75. King, Prof. F. H. Irrigation and Drainage. Mac- millan. $1.50. Lanciani, Prof. R. The Destruction of Ancient Rome. Macmillan. 2. Letchworth, W. P. Care and Treatment of Epi- leptics. ‘Putnams. _ Letters of Benjamin Jowett, Master of Balliol College. Arranged and Edited by Evelyn Abbott and Lewis Campbell. London: John Murray; New York: E. P. Dutton & Co, 5. Lilly, W. 8... First Principles in Politics. _Lon- don: John Murray; New York: Putnams. $2.50. Maemillan, H. Gleanings in Holy Fields. Mac- millan. $1.50. Main, FE. Cities and Sights of Spain. London: George Bell & Sons; New York: Macmillan. $2. Mason, Rey. A. J. The Five Theological Orations of Gregory of Nazianzus. London: C. J. Clay & Sons; New York: Macmillan. $1.50. Mather, F. J. Chaucer’s Prologue, The Knight's Tale and the Nun’s Priest’s Tale from the Can- terbury Tales. Houghton, Mifflin & Co, 40ce. we gs J. S. Mythology for Moderns. Life Pub. Co, . Meyer, R. M. Die Deutsche Litteratur des Neun- zehnten Jahrhunderts. Berlin: Georg Bondi; New York: Lemecke & Buechner. Montefiore, C. G. The Bible for Home Reading. Macmillan. Parts 1 and 2. $2.50. Murray, D. A. Plane Trigonometry for Colleges and Secondary Schools. Longmans, Green & Co, Nitobé, Inazo. Bushido the Soul of Japan. Phila- delphia: The Leeds & Biddle Co. Norway, A. H Highways and Byways in York- shire. Macmillan. 2. Palmer, Florence U. One Year of Sunday-School Lessons for Young Children. Macmillan. $1. Pattee, Prof. F. L. The Foundations of English Literature, Silver, Burdett & Co. $1.50. OS Frances M. Donna Teresa, Macmillan. vo, Royce, Prof. J. The World and the Individual. Macmillan. $3. Shakespeare, W. Tempest. Cassells. 10c. Shorey, Prof. P. Pope’s The Iliad of Homer. Bos- ton: D. C. Heath & Co. 35c. Shuckburgh, E. S. The Letters of Cicero. Lon- pe ter’ Bell & Sons; New York: Macmillan. Sienkiewicz, H. The Ratghts of the Cross, or Krzyzacy. R. F. Fenno & Co. vols. $2. or a U. L. The Enchanter. Macmillan. Some Things That Trouble Young Manhood. New York: Styles & Cash. The Living Age. Vol. 5. Boston: The Living Age C The Works of Shakespeare. [Eversley ed.] Vol. X. at $1.5 Welton, Prof. The Takia Bases of Education. Macmillan. i.
“A style which can fairly be described as fascinating. . » One of the most important books on music that have ever been published.” —W.J. HENDERSON, Musical Critic of the N. Y. Times. LAVIGNAC’S MUSIC AND MUSICIANS. 2p Eprrion. 504 pp. 8vo, $3.00. Henry Holt & Co., Hew Work BUILDERS OF GREATER BRITAIN. NEW VOLUME. Rajah Brooke. The Englishman as Ruler of an Eastern State. Ky Sir SPENSER St, Jon, G.C.M.G., Au- thor of *‘ Hayti; or, the Black Republic,” etc,, ete, With Portrait and 2 Maps. Crown Svo, $1.50.
LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., 91-93 Fifth Ave., New York. TIFFANY STUDIOS /tlustrated Historical Hookleta aent upon request—(1) Favrile Glass, (2) Lampa and Firturea, (3) Glase Mo- wate, (4) Memorial Windows, (5) Memortai Tablets, (6) Monuments. 333341 POURTH AVBNUB, NEW YORK.
of famous Bought and Sold AUTOGRAPH pe Teons LETTERS WALTER RB. BE a 1125 Broadwa SEND FOR Place” K Lists,
By MINOT J. SAVAGB, D. D. Life Beyond Death Being a review of the World’s Beliefs on the Subject, a consideration of Present Condi- tions of Thought and Feeling, leading to the Question as to Whether it can be De- monstrated as a Fact, Third Impression. 8vo, $1.50. “The book is a sane, wholesome, sunny view of human nature and religious thought, and wheth- er a man is very religious or not he will enjoy reading it, if he is a thinking man. It is a book which will help a great many people, and it ought tu have a wide sale.’’—Washington Times. “This volume is dedicated to the son who was suddenly called last spring from a life of pro- mise and usefulness into the great beyond; and Dr. Savage pours out his soul in the mingled lan- guage of serrow and faith, which puts into his hope the emotional temper of Channing and the intellectual spirit of Parker. It shows the strong inspiration that governs the work, and which ba- lances all the moral, religious, and scientific forces in the world between the claims of scientific method and the ideal of religion. The book un- questionably marks a tremendous reaction against the materialism of the past.'’—Christian Register.
G. P. Putnam’s Sons, 27 AND 29 WEST 23D wa - = NEW bine A Handbook of CUBA, PORTO RICO, HAWAII, and the PHILIPPINE ISLANDS. OUR ISLAND EMPIRE By Cuar.es Morris. With Maps. 12mo, cloth, $1.50. For sale by all booksellers. J. B. LIPPINCOTT COMPANY, Publishers, Phila.
THE FUTURE OF THE AMERICAN NEGRO. By BOOKER T. WASHINGTON. Price, $1.50. “In respect of distinction alike of style, insight, outlook, spirit, and manner, this discussion of ‘The Future of the American Negro,’ by Booker T. Washington, is as — worthy as any book which has ap during the year.”"—Chicago Evening fa t. SMALL, MAYNARD & COMPANY, Boston.
NOW READY. The Natural History of Selborne. By GILBERT WHITE. Edited by Grant ALLEN. With upwards of 200 Illustrations by Epmunp H. New. Containing Photogravure Portraits of Thomas Pennant and Daines Barrington, and some hitherto unpublished Notes Samvuev TayLor CoiE- ripax. Uniform with ‘ Walton’s Angler.” Feap 4to. 568 og Seat in buckram.
JOHN LANE, a51 5th Ave., N.Y. City
|
Page 25
Jan. 18, 1900] The Nation. Vv SCRIBNERS NEWEST BOOKS THE BOOK OF THE YEAR THE LETTERS OF ROBERT LOUIS STEVENSON Edited by Sipney Corvin. Illustrated. 2 vols. 8vo, $5.00, ver. ‘*He was the most delightful of letter writers—-one who seemed to have caught the very flower and perfume of the art and to have carried it to its highest expression. . . Stevenson, it seems to us, mist be regarded as the highest type of the modern letter-writer; the man who will talk with the pen with the same skill and freedom that he shows when speaking face to face, and who can put into such written conversation the charm and fascination of the spoken word. Viewed from this standpoint, Stevenson was indeed a prince of letter-writers.""—Brooklyn Eagle. “ They are, in the first place, saturated with the spirit of literature. . . . It was almost impossible for him to put himself on paper without putting on the same paper the touch of the artist. One is continually aware, in reading these letters, of felicities of style, charming turns of phrase, of the play, variety, and freshness of an artistic mind ; and thes», it is hardty necessary to say. combined with that sense of form which was a passion with Stevenson, are the qualities which make literature. As a piece of literature, this correspondence will long be read."’-The utlook. A TIMELY BOOK ON SOUTH AFRICA ; SIDE LIGHTS ON SOUTH AFRICA By Roy Devereux. With a map. Crown 8vo, $1.75. “The author of ‘Side Lights on South Africa’ is a keen observer, and sets forth her impressions of travel with engaging sprightliness Just the kind of popu'ar survey of existing conditions which deserves a welcome, since it presents useful informatior in terse, agreeable form.” New York Tribune. By E. A. Firz Geratp. With 40 tull-page illustrations (10 in photogravure), and a map. Royal 8vo, $6.00 net. ‘A well-written record of a most arduous piece of exploration, carefully planned and carried out with amazing pluck in the teeth of difficul ties, discouragements, and dangers . . * It is almost appalling to one whose experience of mountain terrors does not range beyond the Alps te read of the risks and hardships cheerfully faced by these intrepid explorers.”’—The Athenwum. AMERICA TO-DAY Observations and Reflections. By Wittiam Arcuer. 12mo, $1.25. “Mr. William Archer's observations and reflections in ‘ America To-Day’ are well worth reading. An Englishman who is not insular, but cos mopo.itan, a sympathizer with the spirit and conditions of American life in many respects, a keen critic of English institutions as well as of others, and a master of an easy and natural style of expression, his book is one of the best studies of our institutions and life which have lately appeared.” The Congregationalist. TO BE PUBLISHED SHORTLY HOW ENGLAND SAVED EUROPE The Story of the Great War, 1793-1815 By W. H. Fircnerr. To be in 4 vols. (Vols. 1, 2, and 3 now ready.) Each vol., illustrated, 1zmo, $2.00. Vor1. From tHe Low Countrizs to Ecypt. Vor, 2. Netson ann Tae STRUGGLE FoR THE SEA Vor. 3. THe CAMPAIGN’ IN THE PeninsuLa. “The work is worthy of the author of * Deeds that Won the Empire’ and ‘ Fights for the Flag.’ Mr. Fitchett gives us in chronological order and with a few connecting links a series of pictures naval and military. By this means the great pageant of the war passes before our eyes as ina moving panorama. This may not be the history required by the student and the politician, but it is exactly the sort of history desired by the mil lion.” — The Spectator. FIFTEEN YEARS’ SPORT AND LIFE In the Hunting Grounds of Western America and British Columbia By W. A. Baitiiz-Grouman., With 77 illustrations from photographs, and 3 maps. 8vo, $5.00, ef. “This is the record of sport enjoyed by the author in visits, extending over fifteen years, to the Pacific slope of North America. Mr. Baillie Grohman is a connoisseur of antlers, and his book is a mine of facts about the wapiti, the moose, the antelope goat, and other splendid game The practical issues of frontier life are touched up throughout the book, which isa matured personal record that will not disappoint readers of the author's earlier works, ‘Tyrol and the Tyrolese,’ ‘Camps in the Rockies,’ etc.""—London Academy. TWO NOTABLE NEW NOVELS IN CONNECTION WITH FOR THE FREEDOM OF THE SEA THE DE WILLOUGHBY CLAIM By Frances Hopcson” Burnett. Third Jarge edition. I1zmo, $1.50. . “Mrs. Burnett has never written better than in this story. She has “ The very name of this noble romance is like a clarion call never nara —— — delicately, more s eee: her | The whole story deals with powerful motives and great deeds. It« tone 08 never n truer, her manner more engaging. 1¢ book gives =. # p ’ on ¢ one the impression of having been written with great and worthy care.” _ 18 elevated, its style vivid and enthralling. It is distinctively one of the — Daily Chronicle. strong books of the year.""— Boston Journal, | By Cyrus Townsenp Brapy, author of ‘For Love of Country.’’ Richly illustrated. 12mo, $1.50. CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS, Publishers
Page 26
S, bam: ? i os (a ea 2 samen eae fith 3 See RRA rk FR ek a § ae chek: 2 : ‘aietm The Nation. [Vol. 70, No. 1803 « Inventory — An itemized list of goods or chattels.” — Wesster’s Dictionary, to the will save hundreds of dollars in time and labor, in the preparation of your Annual Inventory Billing and Tabulating Attachment At a touch the carriage jumps from the last character written to the exact place in the next column, and over any number of columns, thus: 1,000,000.00 #80——"""10 009 3**"3-100, 000.0033 a~1.00 ODOR Tt For sale by all Remington Typewriter dealers WYCKOFF, SEAMANS & BENEDICT, 327 BROADWAY, NEW YORK 2100. 00%~->4,000.00 Winter Underwear. Men’s, Women’s, and Children’s Underwear. Wool, Merino, Camel’s Hair Underwear. Silk and Wool and All Silk Underwear. Swiss Ribbed Underwear. Union Suits. All weights and sizes. Hosiery. Women’s and Children’s Hose. Men’s Half Hose. Golf and Bicycle Hose. Cardigan Jackets. Ladies’ Shetland Wool Knit Spencers. Broadovay Ks 19H st. NEW YORK BOOKS When callin ploane ask for AT MRO ANT. LIBERAL Whenever you need a Boo DISCOUNTS. address MR. GRANT. Before buying books write for quotations. An assortment of catalogues and special slips of books at reduced prices sent for 10-cent stamp. F, B. GRANT, Books, 28W.42p8r, - - + «+ «+ NEW YORK (Mention thin advertisement and receive a discount.) F. W. CHRISTERN (DYRSEN & PFEIFFER, Successors), : bem bay Ave. bet. “oH gut 80th oe, New York. mporters of Fore »ks; Agents for the leadin Paris Publishers; Tauchnita’s British Authors, Teute ner’s Greek and Latin Classics. Catalogues of atock matied on demand, New books received from Paris and Lel a6 800N 48 issued. OOK'S, SECOND HAND AND NEW, Standard and Rare. Books bought. Catalogue Tesued, E. W. Jonweon, 2 BE. 428d 8t., N. Y. DENSMORE Typewriter Light Touch Long Wear A request in person or by letter brings a catalogue. Densmore Typewriter Co., 202, 83> ~ BLLIS & ELVEY, Dealers in Old and Rare Books CATALOGUES of CHOICE BOOKS and ILLUMI. NATED MANUSCRIPTS published periodically. Rare Karly English Literature, Early Printed Books in Black Letter, Ancient Artistic Hookbindings. rare Prints and Auto; roEpe ete. Only fine specimens are dealt with- 20 Cr BOND STREET, LONDON, ENG. JOAN OF ARC. By Francis C. Low .t. $2.00. “ Asa piece of historical biography It is a noble success.””"--Am., Historical Review. HOUGHTON, MIFPLIN & CO. Music Lovers’ Books. Get our Catalogue. L. ©, PAGE & CO Boston, Mass ATALOGUE No. 49 (of second-hand booke and pamphiets), as to contents, is the best I have published. A. 8. CLank, 174 Fulton 8t., New York. Registered 7 vaas Mark. 200 Sets French Hemstitched Table Linen at a full 33¥%3% less than their present market value, at ‘‘The Linen Store.’’ These are truly regal goods in quality, design, and work- manship. (The hemstitching is as beautiful as French hem- stitching usually is.) Napkins are full 27 inches square, the cloths are 2% yards wide, 2%, 3. 3% and 4 yards long, at the uniform price of $20.00 per Set. (Cloth and dozen Napkins. ) They have hitherto been sold in this city at from $27.50 to $37.50 a set. During this month we are offering special values in Table Linen, Bed Linen, Towels. James McCutcheon & Co. 14 West 23d Street, N. Y. Extraordinary Reduction! In order to send out balance of Augusta-Victoria Empress Shoulder-Shawls HANDWOVEN in DECEMBER, the price for a limited time is $5.50 instead of $7.50. Colors remaining: Light green, white, and cherry red. Sent on approval. The Susacuac Weaving Co. BETHLEHEM, PA. -