The Nation 1899-12-07: Vol 69 Iss 1797
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
GENERAL LIBRARY, wiv. OF MICH. VOL. LXIX—NO. 1797. THURSDAY, DECEMBER 7, 1899. ilies. chute SPOR rerereaererekerectererkz FOUR SUCCESSFUL BOOKS. “The Work of the Greatest Literary Interest of the Year.” Che Letters of Robert Louis Stevenson Edited by Two Volumes Illustrated by SIDNEY COLVIN 8v0, $5.00 net GUERIN ann PEIXOTTO ‘« There is but one great letter-writer in the English tongue who may be ranked with Stevenson in this class; , to follow personal predilection we should call Stevenson, indeed, the greatest letter-writer in the English language. : The soul of the-man shines out clear and strong, and a more charming, buoyant, brave, glad soul we have rarely seen.’’—New York Commercial Advertiser.
SLOr@X
A Holiday Book to Remember. Fisherman's Duck. By HENRY VAN DYKE, With 13 full-page illustrations by prominent artists. Crown 800, $2.00. *«Dr. van Dyke has brought from the brooks and the woods a fresh and genuine note into our literature—a note in which one hears the fall of water, the stir of leaves, and the sound of men moving and speaking. The twelve chapters which make up this book of stories and sketches have a delightful breeziness of spirit and a sincere lite- rarycharm. . . . In these chapters Dr. van Dyke makes courage, cheerfulness, kindness, and loyalty more credible and winning.’’— The Outlook.
“ The Christmas Book of the Year.” santa Claus’s ‘Partner. By THOMAS NELSON PAGE. Richly illustrated in colors by W. Glackens, 12m0, $1.50. «« A charming and dainty Christmas story. . . . The book is a new and triumphant proof of Mr. Page’s powers both as an artist of tender sentiment and as an adept in the delineation of character. The story abounds in touches of exquisite feeling.”’—-Chicago Tribune. ‘It is a lovely story, beautiful in conception and beautiful in execution; and the publishers have made a charming, old-fashioned book of it.’’—The Outlook.
“ 4 Book Noble and Ennobling.” In Connection with The De Willoughby Claim. 12mo, $1.50. By FRANCES HODGSON BURNETT 12mo, $1.50 ««Mrs. Burnett’s delineation of character is masterly, showing a large comprehension of humanity, sympathies broad and deep, reverence for the soul of man, under whatever garb or guise. . . . Her characters are master- pieces of creation, and their range is a wide one. She has created a distinctly unique character. We are happier and better for knowing Tom De Willoughby. He deserves a place beside those other heroes of unselfishness, Wil- liam Dobbin and Thomas Newcome. . . . A book not only a literary event, but noble and ennobling,’’— New York Times Saturday Review. CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS, ,f@@ier ROKOVSKLSE SKOOL OKOROKOd OXE
N ® a Cd i od os ® BE it aS Cd Sc 4 oR cd ‘ ise a cd i Cd of ed Ne 8 A ie ag BKOVvekcGere@<Orexk Oe FOKOTOeK Oz.
Page 2
The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1797 The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science, and Art. FOUNDED 1865. [Entered at the New York City Post-Office as second- class mail-matter.]| CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. EDITORIAL ARTICLES: Secretary ye are ara 420 The ‘New Di lomacy”” ‘uid WAP sevcvnsces 421 Training for Citizenship ...........0.s00+5 422 The Future of the Small College .......... 422 SPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE: The Villart Testimonial .....+.-seseeaecees 423 Hugo’s “Things Seen,’’—II. ..........+++.. 425 CORRESPONDENCE: A Prophecy Recalled .......ccsscssescvcces 426 Why valies CHicumenical? ......sscceeseess A26 The Suffix al a Place-Names.... 427 Goethe Frranalatio TTPO ee re 427 Beget in pas eel pr ee 427 TOTO ons sickdevaccotssscctcchouwe besaaconvsesensenabas 428 Book REVIEWS: Rhodes’s United States .........ccceeeeeee 430 Recent Books On MuBic ......esecessesees 432 Recent Compilations of Poetry ..........-. 433 The Expansion of Western Ideals and *' World’s Peace.—The New Pacific ..... 433 Scotland’s Ruined Abbeys ....-.--++++s05+ 434 BOOKS OF THE WERK......... secccccvcccesccvcccscccs 435 TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three Dollars per year, in advance, postpaid, to any part of the United States or Canada; to foreign countries comprised in the Postal Union, $4.00. The date when the subscription expires is on the Address-Label of each paper, the change of which to a subsequent date becomes a receipt for remit- tance. No other receipt is sent unless requested, Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter, or by check, express or Postal Order, payable to “Publisher of the Na- tion.” When a change of address is desired, both the old and new addresses should be given. Address THE NATION, Box 794, New York. Publication Office, 208 Broadway. TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Fifteen cents per agate line, each insertion, 1, lines to the inch. Twenty per cent. advance for choice of page, or top of column. A column, $20 each insertion; with choice of page, $24. A page. $60 each insertion; front-cover page, $80. Advertisements must be acceptable in every re- spect, Copy received until Tuesday, 5 P. M. DISCOUNTS. The NATION is sent free to those who advertise in it as long as advertisement continues. *.* Copies of the Nation may be procured in Pacis at Brentano's, 17 Avenue ie l'Opéra, ng ates in London of B. F. Stevens, 7 Trafalgar Square, rican Newspaper Agenoy, 15 King William bareet, Strand, W. C. London agent for advertisements, George M. 8. Horton, Trafalgar Buildings, Trafalgar Square. nat CALIFORNIA, ies, West 23d Stree MAkiBCKOe UGH SCHOOL for GIRL. Ss Mrs. Groros A, CaswELL, Principal, DELAWARE, 5 EBB eo Street. ‘HE MISSES HEB pte Fae and ney School ve Girls. Students are prepared for DistTRIcT oF COLUMBIA. et Columbia Heights, 1225 Princeton r.and Mrs. OTTO TORNE Y SIMON will receive into their home five young ladies wishing to study music or languages, and to have the advantage | of a winter in Washi ngton. MARYLAND, , Baltimore, 1 122 and 124 24 W.I Franklin St. DGE WORTH BOARDING and DAY genoa for Girls.—87th year will woste September 28, 1899. Mrs, H. P. LEFEBVRE, Principal Miss E. D. HuntLey, Associate Principal. MARYLAND, Catonsville. T. TIMOTHY § SCHOOL for Girls re- opens Sept. si, 1899. Freee res for Coneee. wanes of School, Miss M. C. . CARTER, Miss 8. R. CaRTE Massacuvusetts, Boston. OSTON UNIVERSITY Law School. Address the Dean, SAMUEL C. BENNETT. MASSACHUSETTS, Duxbury OWDER POINT SCHOOL. —Prepares for Scientific School, College, or Business. Indi- vidual teaching. Elementary classes et ore T be 8. Home and outdoor life. F. B. Knapp, S T) PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, Chestnut Hill. M?*s. COMEG YS AND MISS BELL’S BOARDING AND DAY SCHOOL FOR GIRLS. Students prepared for college. ISS ANABLE’S Boarding and Day 8. School for Girls. Established in 1 Circular “4 1350 Pine 8t., Phila., Pa. application. Opens Sept. 28, SCHOOL OF DRAWING AND PAINTING, MUSEUM OF FINE ARTS, oy th MASS. 2th Year ns Octobe I potrueiere—o- Cc. PHILIP HALE, PRATT, Modellin tive Desi gn; EB. W. EME SON. STONE, Doce ‘ A. K. CROSS, ve. Free use of Museum Galle- ries, Paige oreign Scholarship for men and women, Helen Hamblen ee Ten Free pone porate Hens Six prizes in money. or circulars an MISS ELIZABETH LOMBARD, Manager. School Agenctes. ‘WE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES, Everett 0. yeen, & Co., Proprietors. 4 Ashburton Place, Boston. . Ave., Washington. 166 Fifth Ave., New York. tid Cent. Bdg. —_ee se Cooper Bdg. » Denver. 25 King 8t., 878 Wabash roe ,Chicago, 525 Stine'n’ Bk. 8 Angeles. 420 Parrott Building, San Francisco. LBANY TEACHERS AGENCY. all Soaken wine aah a eticcshuie* kaa Piro iashons in obtaining positions. ” HARLAN P. FReNCH, Aon iseeaee. CHERMERHORN'S TEACHERS’ AGENCY. Oldest and bent wh in the U.S. Established 1855. . 14th 8t., N. Y. THE PRATT TEACHERS’ AGENCY. wM. 0. PRATT, Mgr., 70 Fifth Ave., New York. Teachers, ete. ( H4ahes W, whe gf Z utor for Har- ar me Readers and Writers have beef Waiting for this Pp Pull-of-Matter, Mode Reference Book, THE STUDENTS’ STANDARD DICTIONARY. | ~ AN ABRIDGMENT OF Funk & Wagnalls’ Standard Dictionary Large 8vo, 989 pages, cloth, leather back, net, $2.50; Sheep, $4.00; Indexed, 50c. additional. Contains 60,000 Words and Phrases, and 1,225 Pictorial IMustrations. Gent goctpat dh Fedlibet of rice’ by The Baker & Taylor Co. 8 and 7 East 16th St., New York. Travel. GOING ABROAD on a bicycle trip? Send for “Bicye Notes for Tourists ‘Abroad. 10 cents in Stamps. Splendid new steamers LEYLAND LINE BOSTON TO LIVERPOOL. irst cabin, winter, $40 and up. Steamer Winifredian, 10,500 tons, 8 feet in length, now in service, others’ bui ~* i Applications received now for berths in 1900 F. 0. HOUGHTON & CO., General Agents, 11g State Street, Boston. Winter Tour. A_ high-class private will sail Jan 20, by North German av Line, for Southern rey t, oe. Fe y, the Riviera, Paris (Exposi- tion), ‘and Lon Duration of trip, four months, at once = itineraries and erences to MRS. M. D. FRAZAR, 72 Globe Building, - ° Boston, Mass. THE CRAWFORD TOURS. Oriental parties leave New York peermeey y 2 April 16 Barony Naps ai | 7) wor ndependent steams an Orient railway tickets. § Pal taducempents hubs and socteties. Il ay ae itineraries free. and CRAWFORD & FLOYD, 609-610 Tremont Passion Building, Boston; 70 "broadway, St. Paul Play. Building, New York Cit: 1 Chestnut St., Pail adelphia; 631 1 Marois) Butlding Chicago” 3 = Egypt and Palestine. A leisurely tour, sailing in February. Paris Exposi- tion on our return. Address H. W. DUNNING, Ph.D., Room 106, Congregational House, Boston, Mass. PARIS AND EUROPE IN 1900. Private parties conducted by Prof. CAMILLE THUR- WANGER, 31 Pierce aoe Boston. Pocket Guide Book of Paris free; send sta: EUROPEAN WINTER RESORT, INNSBRUCK, TYROL, AUSTRIA. 1,900 feet above the sea, with dry, bracing climate. HOTEL TIROL. the year. Modern con aounsenens Lone oe Open ail f aeees. Illustrated phiets on : si GAR DSE a DRESDEN, GERMANY. Pension Kretzschmer-Schadewell. Friulein ee BS a ge a of Pension Kretzschmer, has Lindenau-Platz, New house, eonvenitetier etunied, with southern pees: "Equipped w with modern appointments; We buy and sell bills of exchange to LETTERS and make Cable Transfers of Money on Europe, Australia, and -e h Africa; — make collections and reial and Travellers’ brie availa- ble in all parts of the world BROWN BROTHERS &CO. No. 59 WALL STREET. NEW YORK. CREDIT, TWO STANDARD WORKS OF REFERENCE. Lippincott’s Pronouncing Dictionary of Biography and Mythology. Lippincott’s Gazetteer of the World. New Revised Edition. Write for circulars. For sale by all booksellers. J. B. LIPPINCOTT COMPANY, Publishers, Phila. Study and Practice of French in School IN THREE PARTS. By L. C. Boname,2s8 South 16th St.,Philadelphia A carefully graded course, m ite for entrance examination at college. - tion and thoro' From , Boston: “A well . Teach- po c 4 aon will “and the three books helpful and inte- TRANSLATIONS . a. REPRINTS. Vol. IV., No. 1. 20 cents. The Early Cristian Ps i Persecutions, et g RS, T NT OF HISTORY, PR une of CHOOL piled SALE. rey with pea oe Gia Heist al tere on iberal tere KINDERGARTEN SUPPLIES at SCHERMERHORN'S, 8 East 1th 8... Y. a ro re
Page 3
Dec. 7, 1899] A Delightful Series of Holiday Books. The Beacon Biographies Edited by M. A. DeWOLFE HOWE The following volumes are now ready: JOHN BROWN FREDERICK DOUGLASS | By JOSEPH EDGAR CHAMBERLIN By CHARLES W. CHESNUTT PHILLIPS BROOKS NATHANIEL HAWTHORNE ’ By THE EDITOR By MRS. JAMES T. FIELDS THOMAS PAINE _ sy ELLery sepGwick AARON BURR ROBERT E. LEE By HENRY CHILDS MERWIN By W. P. TRENT ' DAVID G. FARRAGUT JAMES RUSSELL LOWELL By JAMES BARNES By EDWARD EVERETT HALE, JR. DANIEL WEBSTER _ By NORMAN HAPGOOD Among those in preparation are JOHN JAMES AUDUBON BENJAMIN FRANKLIN By JOHN BURROUGHS By LINDSAY SWIFT EDWIN BOOTH ULYSSES S. GRANT By CHARLES TOWNSEND COPELAND By OWEN WISTER JAMES FENIMORE COOPER SAM HOUSTON By W. B. SHUBRICK CLYMER By SARAH BARNWELL ELLIOTT STEPHEN DECATUR THOMAS JEFFERSON By CYRUS TOWNSEND BRADY By THOMAS E. WATSON ALEXANDER HAMILTON By JAMEs SCHOULER HE BEACON BIOGRAPHIES were issued to meet what in the opinion of the Editor and the Publishers was a + distinct need in American literature—a series of brief, well written, readable and authoritative biographies of eminent Americans, to include, in the end, all whose lives were notably distinctive or typical. In respect of manufacture, the Publishers have tried to make a set of ‘‘little books’’ which should surpass anything of the sort hitherto attempted in this country in all points of style and workmanlike thoroughness. Each volume measures 3%x51¢ inches, and is thus of a size to go handily into the pocket. The cover (in blind and gold on limp blue cloth) is by Mr. Bertram Grosvenor Goodhue, who has done also the standing title-page for the series, which has been engraved on copper. The frontispiece portrait which accompanies each is in photogravure. The paper has heen selected with great care, and the type used is a new face specially cut. ; The notices of the Beacon Biographies in the reviews have been complimentary to a high degree. Thus the Bos j ton Herald says: ‘‘There is neither romanticism nor realism in the treatment; the effort is always toward the sanest, fairest, soundest reality.’’ ‘‘As carefully prepared, °” says the New York 7'imzs, ‘‘as if they were so many imperial uartos.’’ ‘‘The form of these little volumes,’’ according to the Nation, ‘‘and the general tastefulness of the get-up are electable.’’ ‘‘They do more than languidly interest,’’ says the Outlook; ‘‘they interest vividly; and their instruction is surprisingly comprehensive.’’ And the Churchman extends ‘‘a hearty welcome to this useful little series which tr bring many who shrink from attempting long volumes to better knowledge of the men who have impressed their personality on the history of their country or the character of their countrymen. ’’ Price, 75 cents a Volume, in Limp Cloth; $1.00, Bound in Blue Lambskin. Small, Maynard & Company Publishers—Boston. Pein BR Aan cneanaee tey neem
Page 4
The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1797 SEESSSESESESEESE ESE SEE SEEEESEELHESEE ESE EELESELELEELELELESLEEEEELELELELELELEL EEL ELELEE EEE EE SEELEEEESESELELEEELELELELEEES Putnam’s New ‘Books. A Prisoner of the Khaleefa Twelve Years’ Captivity at Omdurman, By CHARLES NEUFELD. Illustrated with 36 photographs taken by the author. Second Edition. 8vo, $4.00. ‘Mr. Neufeld has at any rate furnished us with a most thrilling and interesting volume, which will be read far and wide’ by vast numbers of our countrymen, over whom the mys- teries and tragic history of the Soudan have exercised an almost antique fascination.’’—-THE SPEAKER. Romance of the Feudal Chateaux By ELIZABETH W. CHAMPNEY. With 40 photogravure and other illustrations. 8vo, $3.50. (Ready next week.) Mrs, Champney has chosen a few of the Feudal Chateaux as typical. She writes sympa- thetically concerning the ruins of these chateaux and the traditions which cling to them. Some of these traditions were told to her by simple people on the spot; others she has derived from the old chronicles. Life Beyond Death Being a review of the World’s Beliefs on the Subject, a consideration of Present Conditions of Thought and Feeling, Leading to the Question as to Whether it can be Demonstrated as a Fact. By MINOT J. SAVAGE, D.D. 8vo, $1.50. CONTENTS: Primitive Ideas—Ethnic Beliefsa—The Old Testamentand Immortality—Paul’s Doctrine of Death and the Other Life—Jesus and Immortality—The Other World and the Middle Ages—Protestant Be- lief Concerning Death and the Life Beyond—The Agnostic Reaction— The Spiritualistic Reaction—The World’s Condition and Needs as to Belief in Immortality—Probabilities Which Fall Short of Demonstra- tion—The Society for Psychical Research and the Immortal Life—Pos- sible Conditions of Another Life—Some Hints as to Personal Experi- ences and Opinions No problem sesses more interest for men than that contained in the question asked centuries ago, “If a man die, shall he live again?’’ The orthodox Christian lieves it to be the gift of God through the atoning sacrifice of Christ. Others seek a scientific demon- stration. To the former class Dr. Savage’s volume will not appee) nee book will be welcomed as a valuable contribution to the knowl tion. but to the latter group edge on this great ques- The volume includes a consideration of the work of the Society for Psychical Research and also an appendix giving some of the author’s own personal experiences in this line. Dr. Savage holds, as a provisional hypothesis, that continued existence is demonstrated, and that there have been at least some well-authenticated communications from persons in the other life. Bacteria Especially as they are related to the economy of nature, to industrial processes, and to the public health. By GEORGE NEWMAN, M.D.. F.B.8., etc.. Demonstrator of Bacteriology in King’s College, London. Science Series No.6. With 24 micro- photographs of actual organisms and over 70 other illustrations. 12mo, $2.00 Professor Newman's volume is not a record of original work, nor is it a text-book for the laboratory, but it is of a less technical nature, being an attempt to set forth a popu- lar scientific statement of our present knowledge of bacteria. 4 The oe pr Sey of biology to life and its problems has in recent years been nowhere more marked than in the realm of bacteriology. ‘Turn where we wili, we shall find the work of the unseen hosts of bacteria daily claiming more and more attention from practical people and there can be no doubt as to the advantage of a wider dissemination of the ascertain facts concerning them. As the world learns its intimate relation to science and the inter- dependence between its life and scientific truth, it may be expected more heartily to support science. Previously Published in the Science Series: 1—The Study of Man. By A.C. HADDON. Illustrated. $2 00. 2—The Groundwork of Science. By ST. GEORGE MIVART. $1.75. 3—Rivers of North America.— By ISRAEL C. RUSSELL. Illustrated. $2.00. 4—Earth Sculpture. By JAMES GEIKIE. Illustrated. $200. 5—Volcanoes—By T. G. BONNEY. Illustrated. $2.00. The Religion of Israel to the Exile By Karu Bunppks, of the University of Strassburg, Germany. Fourth Series in the Course of American Lectures on the History of Religions, 1898-99. 12mo, $1.50. Previously Issued in the Series: Buddhism.—Its History anp Literature. By T. W. RHYS-DAVIDS. 12mo. $1.50. ‘As a clear and concise exposition of the subject Prof. Rhys-Davids’s book is unsur- passed, . . . The clearness and condensation of the work are remarkable, and it is doubtful if any exposition of the Buddhist doctrines has ever been made in English so satisfactory as this. . . . The book is an admirable hand-book of Buddhism, written from a point of view at once scholarly and unprejudiced, and will take a creditable place among books of its class.’’--PIONEER PRESS, St. Paul. 2.—-Primitive Religions.—Reticions or Priwitive Proptes, By DANIEL G. BRINTON, 1%mo. $1.50, “That this volume will have a strong interest for the student of religious th observance goes without saying. The scholarship and ht and calm and an a hod of Dr. Brinton’s mind, and his reputation as an authority on anteropolog?, archeology, and comparative mythology, ensure as much.’’—~PHILADELPHIA BULLETIN. 3.—Jewish Religious Life After the Exile. By REV. T, K, CHEYNE. 12mo. $1.50 ; ‘Few men are as well qualified as Canon Cheyne to discuss the Jewish literature and life of the period covered by this course, . . . exceedingly interesting and instructive.’’ ~INDEPENDENT. The Eve of the Reformation in Great Britain. By FRANCIS AIDAN GASQUET. 8vo $3,50. A study of the religious life and thought of the English people during the period im- mediately preceding the rejection by Henry VIII, of the jurisdiction of Rome. * 4" Send for our New Illustrated Holiday Catalogue of 48 pages. G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS, 27 & 29 w. asp st., New York. RFFSFSFSSSSSSSISSSS HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO.’S Holiday Books BACKLOG STUDIES By CHARLES DUDLEY WARNER. Holiday Edi- tion, With 12- illustrations. and 13 head- pieces by EDMUND H. GARRETT. 12mo, $2.00, THE MARBLE FAUN By NATHANIEL HAWTHORNE. Roman Edition. Illustrated with 48 fine pictures of famous sculptures, paintings, and historical locali- ties. 2 vols. 16mo, gilt top, $3.00. THE TENT ON THE BEACH By JOHN G. WHITTIER. Holiday Edition. With rubricated initials and 12 full-page illustra- tions by CHARLES H. and Marcia O. Woop- BURY. 12mo, $1.50. LOVELINESS A Story. By ELIZABETH STUART PHELPS. With illustrations. Square 12mo, attract- ively bound, $1.00. THE STORY OF JESUS CHRIST By ELIZABETH STUART PHELPS. 24 fine il- lustrations, $2.00. ott. peculiarly suitable and beautiful Christmas THE OTHER FELLOW By F. HOPKINSON SMITH. Illustrated. 12mo, $1.50. Eleven short stories told with the dash and dramatic effect, and the practised skill of his other volumes, and finely illustrated. PLANTATION PAGEANTS Another of the delightful Thimblefinger books. By JOEL CHANDLER HARRIS, author of Uncle Remus. Fully illustrated by E. BOYD SMITH. Square 8vo, $2.00. AN UNKNOWN PATRIOT = S. CHILD, Illustrated. Crown 8vo, An absorbing story of the “Secret Service” in Connecticut during the Revolution. THE WIFE OF HIS YOUTH AND OTHER STORIES By CHARLES W. CHESNUTT, author of “ The Conjure Wonian.”’ Illustrated. Crown 8vo, $1.50. A PRETTY TORY A Story of the Revolution. By JEANIE GOULD LINCOLN. Illustrated. 12mo, $1.50. UNDER THE CACTUS FLAG A Story of Life in Mexico. By NORA ARCHI- BALD SMITH. With 8 illustrations. 16mo, $1.25. A charming book for girls. By SARAH ORNE EWETT. With decorative cover and illus- rations. Square 12mo, $1.00. | DOROTHY AND HER FRIENDS A delightful continuation of “Dorothy Deane,”’ by ELLEN OLNEY Kirk. With a de- corative cover and illustrations. 16mo, $1.25. Sold by all booksellers, Sent, postpaid, by HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO., Boston, 11 East 17th Street, New York. & , eo
Page 5
Dec. 7, 1899] The Nation. bg JOHN LANE’S NEW PUBLICATIONS. Some Illustrated Gift Books. THE GOLDEN AGE. | THE NATURAL HISTORY OF SELBORNE. By Gilbert White. Edited by Grant Alien. With upwards of 200 Tiustrations by Fd mund H. New Covtalning Photogravure ‘ortralts of Thomas Pennant and By Kenneth Grahame, Daines Barrington; “ White's Fellow Naturalists,” “ White's Obsers rations o Author of “ Dream Days,” “Pagan Papers,” Nature,” and Poems; with some hitherto unpublished Notes by Samuel Taylor c. Cc oleridge Uniform with “ Walton's Angier.” Feap. 4to. 565 p nae s, bound Ney Illustrated Edition. With 18 full in buckram. $7.50. llustrations, numerous Tail-pi 8, i Stover Design by Maxfield Parrien.” En. ONE HUNDRED FABLES OF LA FONTAINE. With i100 f tirely reset in old-faced type by the Univer- page Iilustrations, Title Page, Frontispiece, and Cover De sign by Pes y J sity Press. Feap. 4to. Handsomely bound in nooner Uniform with “ One Hundred Fables of .fsop pric -t “) cloth, gilt top, in a box, $2 50 Feap. 4to. Cloth. $1.50 Chicago T:mea- Herald: “ One of the most J ! tue Re Sleepir attractive books that will be offered to holl- BLUEREARD S PICTURE BOOK. j h. —— so pene y overa to day book-buyers.” Beauty, and Babies’ Own Alphabet omple i Me PY gether with collective titles, end ponere, decorative cloth cover, and new! The Outlook; “ The volume is a treasure.” written preface by Walter Crane. ri N. Y. Mailand Express: “ If ever book de- served beautiful illustrations and a hand OUTSIDE THE GARDEN. By Helen Milman Mra. Caldwell some dress it is Mr. Grahame’s wondrously Crofton). With 24 full-page fllustrations and a Cover Design by Edmund H delicate interpretation of child life and the New. Crown Svo. Art Linen. $1.50. = ~ RA =. anreany a classic—the HE SUN: F i T I By E l classic of its kind—a book that none wh v n seek unadulterated pleasure on the arid path THE OTHER SIDE OF T = ry anes. y . y of life can afford to neglect, a pearl beyond Sharp. With 8 hays Lpage Illustrations and a Cover Design by Nellie rice. These be strong words of praise, and Syrett. Feap. d4to. $1 P REDUCED FACSIMILE OF TITLE-PAGE still we remain Mr. Grahame’s debtors.” GULLIVER’ S TRAVELS, With Illustrations and a cover design by JACK OF ALL TRADES. A Book of Nons2nse Verses. Herbert Cole. $1.50 By J. J. Bell. witn Illustrations and cover by Charles Robi Uniform with “ The New Noah’s Ark.” Feap. 4to. $1. bo. siden? nesameamcnes gy ~~ g Ari e j ovat. .25. With 14 Illustrations and Cover by POETRY. FICTION ESSAYS, &c. ay — Phillips. By John Buchan. By Lord Rosebery. PAOLO AND FRANCESCA. A LOST LADY OF OLD YEARS. | APPRECIATIONS AND ADDRESSES. bs A Play. $1.25. ? Slee An Historical Romance. $1.50. Second Editi on. $1.50 ‘By John Oliver Hobbes. JOHN BURNET OF BARNES. $1.50. ee ieee tee tee ; OSBERN AND URSYNE. Grey WEATHER. $1.50. By Richard Le Gallienne. IAM A Drama in Three Acts, $1.25. By Richard Le Gallienne. * RUDYARD KIPLING, By Matthew Arnold. THE WORSHIPPER OF THE IMAGE. | tnd a Portrait of Mr. Kipling from a Wenslent hy POEMS. A Tragic Fairy Tale. $1.25. Ropert Brypen. Crown vo. 61.25 (January With an Introduction by A.C, Benson Illustrated. $2.50 ; By Thomas Cobb. By Stephen Gwynn. Warn. THE JUDGMENT OF HELEN. $1.50 THE DECAY OF SENSIBILITY, _A Book of Verses. Feap. vo. $1.25. coe ore AND OTasR ESSAYS. By Wilfred Scawen Blunt. : SATAN ABSOLVED. By Frank Mathew. By Edmond Holmes. a CSA : oe vure i ge ONE QUEEN TRIUM rRAet. WH AT IS POETRY? mar Khay’am. DEFENDER OF THE FAITH. $1.50. An Essay. 61.25 susaY'ae OF OMAR KHAY’ AM. Tue SPANISH WINE. $1.25. By S. R. Maitland. a Preface by Dr-Gannerr OBO LED stas, By Herbert Flowerdew. THE REFORMATION IN ENGLAND. By Winifred Lucas. : THE REALIST. With an introduction by she Bev A. W. Hurroy,M.A FUGITIVES. Poems. A Modern Romance. $1.50. = $1.25 A CELIBATE’s WIFE. $1.50. . } RSE ee. * a ~ By J. F. Muirhead. By Robert Stephen Hawker By William J. Locke, THE LAND OF CONTRASTS. (of Morwenstow). The WHITE DOVE. $1.50. on’s View o neric Sin. Secone THE COMPLETE POETICAL WORKS. DeRELicrs. 2d Edition, $1.50. HO "eaition. “50. With Portrait. $2.00. Ipots. 2d Edition. $1.50. : — By Sir F. A. Swettenham, K.C. M.G. THE TUORILEUIOM. CATINUM lll. By Ella Napier Lefroy. THE REAL MALAY : PEN PICTURES. Celebrated Passages, mostly from English Poets, ren- THE MAN’S CAUSE. — dered inte Lain tind wa $100. By Charles Waldstein. No. IV. By Vanda Wathen-Bartlett. THE EXPANSION OF WESTERN ENGLISH ELEGIES. HEART’S DESIRE. IDEALS AND THE WORLD’S PEACE. By J. C. Bartry. $1.50. $1.50. $1.50. NOW READY. PRICE SIX DOLLARS NET. THE ANGLO-SAXON REVIEW. VOLUME IL. A QUARTERLY MISCELLANY. Edited by LADY RANDOLPH SPENCER CHURCHILL. The Contributors ree the Duchess of Devonshire, Lord Lovat, the Earl of Crewe, Mr. Brook Adams, Professor Sylvanus P. Thompson, Elien Thorneyeroft unseat Be onlin ete. The Illustrations include photogravure portraits of Queen Elizabeth, William “The Silent,” George Spencer, fourth Duke of Marlborough, and Dorothy idney, Countess of Sunderland. The Binding of tone Two is of Leather, elaborately and richly decorated In gold. from adesign by the great French binder, Dexome, 1770-1780. It lea pete Patera = beautiful specimen of Derome’s work, acceptable alike to the connoisseur and to the general lover of fine bindings. ANNUAL SUBSCRIPTION, $24.00 NET. An Illustrated List of New Books Sent Pree on Application. JOHN LANE, NO. 251 FIFTH AVENUE, NEW YORK CITY
Page 6
vi The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1797 THE CLARENDON PRESS. JUST PUBLISHED Italy and Her Invaders By THomas Hopoexin, D.C.L. Volume VIL, Frankish Invasions; Volume VIIL., The Frankish Empire. With Maps and Iilustra- tions. Demy 8yv0, cloth, $6.00, From THe AuTHor’s PREFACE. These two volumes complete the author's history of Italy and her In- vaders. The work has occupied his leisure for the greater part of twenty-five years. In accordance with the original design and the title of the work, the story of the invading nation is treated as oany oe that of ‘the invaded land, and the reader will consequently find the ear ly chapters of the Seventh Vol- ume almost exclusively occupied with Frankish affairs. Afterwards the nar- rative concerns itself with two leading events, the foundation of the temporal power of the Pope and the proclamation of Charles as Emperor of Rome. Two of the Saxon Chronicles Paralle)], with supplementary extracts from the others. A revised text. Edited, with introduction, notes, appendices. and glossary, by CHARLEs ‘PLUMMER, M.A.. on the basis of an edition by John arle, M.A. Vol. II, Introduction, notes, and index. Crown 8vo, half leather, $3.10. Great Britain and Hanover Some Aspects of the Personal Union. Being the Ford Lectures de- livered in the University of Oxford, Hilary Term, 1899. By —- WILLIAM Warp, Litt.D. Crown 8vo, paper boards, A Handbook of Anatomy for Art Students By ARTHUR THomson, M.A., M.B. Second Edition, with new Illus- trations in the Text and ‘additional Full-page Plates. Demy 8vo, buckram, $5.00. Studies in Dante Second Series, Miscellaneous Essays. By Epwarp Moors, D.D. 8vo, cloth, $3.10. “ The relation of the collection of Studies to that which was pub | ree rs is Bint of another Sriog rather than that of & sosond volume. ve v one another, since some of the various su Seer hoped have an interest for many who woul not care to entirely devoted to a subject so special and technical as use by Dante of Scriptural and Classical authors.”—From the Preface. Marathi Proverbs waa and Translated by the Rev. A. MANWARING. 8vo, cloth, UST PUBLISHED. VOLUME If. ‘History of the New World Called America By Epwarp Joun Payne, Fellow of University College, Oxford. Crown 8vo, Cloth, Vol. I., $3.00, Vol. IL., $3.50. “Itis Sis baron _—_— a cennadtdaibe book. . No one to acquaintance bo: condi Mr. Payne’s work. is of-the-way sources, quite beyond the reach of any except the most favored students.”’"—Journal of Education, Also Published by Henry Frowde: Selected Poems, Old and New By ANNIE MATHESON. Crown, 8vo. Cloth, 75c. This volume, besides a portrait and preface under difference—contains nearly ott some chosen wit from the Author's works already ed, or reprinted f rom periodicals, while a few, includin — porieern For r Dreyfus” and * The Christmas Child,’ have not appeared poems are under ‘London Poems,’ ‘For Diverse Voices,’ In Serious Mood ’ ‘Sonnets,’ ‘From Earliest Poems,’ ‘Hymns for Children,’ ‘ Translations, > &e. pleading for unity th great care For Sale by all Booksellers, Send for Catalogue. OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS, American Branch, 91 and 93 Fifth Avenue, New York. NEW ILLUSTRATED CABINET EDITIONS Charles Reade’s Works. This edition is printed from a handsome set of plates on a fine English finish deckle-edge paper. illustrated with about 80 photogravures and etchings by Frank T. Merrill and others. tionably the best edition that has ever been put upon the market. Complete set, 16 vols., cloth, gilt tops -°- . ° It will be The edition is unques- The works will be sold in sets or separately. $24.00 Bulwer-Lytton’s Works. This edition is printed on a fine laid deckle-edge paper from a practically new set of p’ates. It will be illustrated with 125 photogravures and etchings by such well-known artists as W. L. Taylor, F. T. Merrill, Frede- rick Dielman, W. St. John Harper, E. H, Garrett, Charles Copeland, etc. The works will be sold in sets or separately. edition of Bulwer ever issued. Complete set, 25 vols., cloth, gilt tops . . ° The edition will be the finest cabinet Shakespeare's Works, 12 vols,, cloth, gilt top $18.00 George Bilot’s Works, 24 * “6 “ 36.00 Victor Hugo's Works, 16 * “ 24.00 Wm. H. Prescott’s Works, 16 vols., cloth, gilt top 24.00 $37.50 W. M, Thackeray’s Works, 20 vols., cloth, 29 top $30.00 Charles Dickens's Works, 30 “ “ 45.00 John Ruskin’s Works, 26 * “6 “ 39.00 Scott's Waverley Novels, 48 “ “ “ 72.00 For sale by all booksellers, or sent, express paid, upon receipt of price by the publishers. Special catalogue of Illustrated Cabinet Editions sent postpaid upon application. DANA Est & COMPANY, Publishers, Boston. Please mention Taz Nation in writing to advertisers.
Page 7
Dec. 7, 1899] The Nation. vii New Publications Through Unexplored Asia By William Jameson Reid, who is a member of the Royal Geographical Society of London, and who has spent several years in exploring China and Thibet. Itis a stirring story of travel and ex- ploration, and gives in the most careful manner an excellent idea of the habits of the various tribes of peopie met with, besides many inte- resting and instructive hitherto unknown facts about this great unexplored region. Illustrated with sixteen fine full-page half-tones from wash drawings by L. J. Bridgman. Also numerous text cuts, besides maps and plans of the coun- try through which Mr. Reid passed. Royal 8vo, handsome cover design, gilt tops, $4.50 Adventures in East Africa By M. French Sheldon. A stirring account of the adventures of a plucky American woman in the wilds of East Africa. Besides twenty-six full- page illustrations the book contains nearly 325 text cuts, and is bound in a handsome cover. Royal 8vo, gilt tops, $2.50 John Ruskin, Social Reformer By J. A. Hobson. An excellent and most thorough exposition of John Ruskin’s social teaching. 12mo, cloth, gilt tops. $1.50 The main part of this book is devoted to a state- ment and a vindication of Mr. Ruskin’s claim to have placed Political Economy upon a sounder scientific and ethical foundation than it had hither. to possessed, and to have built upon that founda- tion an ideal of a prosperous human society. The work is a valuable contribution to Ruskin litera- ture and social science. It cannot fail to be of immense value, not only to the sociological stu- dent, but also to those whose reading hours are limited, but who are seeking instruction on so- = questions.—A. W. Wishart, in Trenton Adver- r. For sale by all booksellers, or sent postpaid on receipt of price by the publishers. DANA ESTES & CO., Boston A BOOK THAT WILL'SAVE YOU MONEY IN MAKING YOUR CHRISTMAS PURCHASES, OUR 21ST ANNUAL HOLIDAY CATA- LOGUE OF CHOICE NEW ENG- LISH AND AMERICAN BOOKS BOOK FREE sat ss" ars ot ELEGANT BINDINGS, NOW READY. THE LARGEST WE HAVE EVER ISSUED AND CONTAINS THE BEST BARGAINS EVER OFFERED TO BOOK BUYERS. A COPY FREE, BY SENDING YOUR ADDRESS ON A POSTAL CARD TO Chas. E. Lauriat Co., Svcsmemi2 Boston Mention The Nation. XMAS POREION BOOKS. Assortment of Germa and nish books i "handsome bindings peuttable dren. Superior assortment of refs ne 1900 CALENDARS 1 tour’ Tangua ee New Year cards in the above books for the at lowest rates. C. A. KOBHLER & CO., 149 A Tremont St. (Lawrence Bullding) BOSTON, \ S Sy S Y Vbdhbebohohoeheseeg THE SELECTING OF Christmas Books is always one of the difficall problems confronting the holiday shopper. To have a few good books definitely in mind would sabe mach embarrassment on entering a book-store. A Half-Dozen Attractive Volumes appealing to different tastes, carefully made, illustrated, and suitable for gifts, will be found in DODD, MEAD & CO.’S LIST. 4 My Study Fre. Illustrated. By Hamilton Wright Mabie. Cloth. $2.50 The drawings in this handsome volume (over 60 in all) are the work of the artists Maud and Genevieve Cowles, already famous through their illustration of the “ House of Seven Gables,” published last season. Their work shows a remarkably fine feeling for nature and a delicacy of imagination unsurpassed by any of their fellow-draughtemen. Poems of Cabin and Field By Paul Laurence Dunbar. Cloth, $1.50 The best dialect poems of this well-known writer, illustrated with photographs taken by the Students’ Camera Club at Hampton School, Va., and with many decorations by Alice C. Morse. Like Mr. Dunbar's poetry, these illustrations give evidence of a delicate appreciation of nature and character, and a sense of humor withal, such as is seldom found in similar work from any source. Great Pictures Described by Great Writers Edited by Esther Singleton. Cloth. $2.00 Uniform with ‘‘ Turrets, Towers and Temples.’’ Miss Singleton has given, in connection with a reproduction in an excellent manner of fifty or sixty masterpieces by the great painters, a Sencnietiote of the several pictures from the masters of literature. For example: Raphael's Sistine Madonna is described by Hans Andersen; Botticelli’s Birth of Venus by Walter Pater; Guido's Portrait of Bea- trice Cenci by Shelley; Rubens’ Descent from the Cross by Sir Joshua Reynolds; Tin toret’s Paradise by Ruskin; Paul Potter's Bull by Thackeray. Holland and the Hollanders By David S, Meldrum. Cloth, $2.00 While quite different from De Amicis's charming sketch, it is likely to supersede it. Without being statistical, it is full of exact and comprehensive information, not only about the country in its ordinary as but its people and institutions, with which Mr. Meldrum has a most intimate acquaintance. . Fanice Meredith. tastrated By Paul Leicester Ford. 2 vols. Cloth, $5.00 The holiday edition of this popular novel has been profusely illustrated by Howard Pyle and his pupils, and with a number of interesting facsimile reproductions of old Prints. It is beautifully bound and printed ; also gilt tops and deckle edges. The two volumes are neatly boxed. Switzerland Legends of Cloth, $1.50 By H. A. Guerber. This volume is bound in uniform style with the other books by the same author, “ Stories of Wagner Operas,” etc. It is illustrated with 20 full-page photographs of fa- mous Swiss Scenes and has a frontispiece in colors. The folk-lore tales of Switzerland have never before been collected in popular form. These books can be seen in all the principal bookstores, or will be sent by the publishers, carefully packed, lo any address in America on receipt of the published price. DODD, MEAD & CO., Publishers, New York. v sd v vy v a Y
Page 8
Vili The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1797 THE MACMILLAN COMPANY'S NEW HOLIDAY PUBLICATIONS. Christmas Fiction and Poetry. BY F. MARION CRAWFORD VIA CRUCIS. A RoMANCE OF THE Sgconp Crusape. 5th Edition. Iliustrated. With illus- trations from drawings by Lovis Logs. Buckram, $1.50. A valuable study of a period as historically important as picturesque. As history, a picture of great brilliancy, vivid with enormous contrasts, Asastory, full of exciting episodes, of the simple passions, deep and strong. Re ” An exquisite romance . LITTLE NOVELS OF ITALY. By MAURICE HEWLETT, author of “ The Forest Lovers,” etc. Cloth, $4.g0. “A singularly romantic collection of short sto- ries . full of the thrill and penetration of a thrilling, tender story.”—Times Sat. YOUNG of Jennico.” By EGERTON CASTLE, Illustrated by A. B, WENZELL. Fourth Edition. Cloth, $1.50. SARACINESCA. Illustrated by Orson LowxLL. Two volumes, Sateen, $5.00. Mr. Lowell’s charming drawings for ‘‘The Choir Invisible,” published a year ago, helped to make it one of the season's most successful holiday edi- tions “The story is exquisitely told and is the author's highest achievement as yet in the realm of fiction.” —The Boston Traveller, “The plot is a masterly one, bringing at almost every page a fresh sur- prise, keeping the reader in suspense to the very end."—New York Times. APRIL. THE FAVOR OF PRINCES. By MARK LEE LUTHER, author of “ The Livery author of of Honour,” ete. Cloth, $1.g0. A story of the glittering days of Louis XV., of Mme. de Pompadour, the Duc de Choiseul, and other historical characters famous in the history of that “The Pride the author's acute imagination.”—The Herald, Boston. In Its 245th thousand, RICHARD CARVEL. By WINSTON CHURCHILL, author of “The Ce- lebrity: An Episode.” Illustrated by Matcotm Fraser. Cloth, $1.50. “The book altogether is delightful.”—The Eve- ning Telegraph, Philadelphia. ‘“‘A drama of mingled passion and mirth, of laughter and tears, and chivalry.”—The Evening Transcript, Boston. MY LADY AND ALLAN DARKE, By CHARLES DONNELL GIBSON. Cloth, $1.g0. A wonderful story very cleverly developed, keep- ing its mystery unsolved to the very end. brilliant court. A Capital Historical Novel. SOLDIER RIGDALE. How He SalLep tn THE “‘ MAYFLOWER,” anp How He Servep Mixes SrTanpisH. By BEULAH MARIE DIX, author of “ Hugh Gwyeth.” Illustrated by Reainatp Birca. Cloth, $1.50. “A vivid picture . - doubly valuable for the genuine note of sympathy which it strikes.”— B Herald. WILD EDEN. A Volume of Verse. By GEORGE EDWARD WOODBERRY, author of “ Heart of Man,” ‘‘ The North Shore Watch,” etc. 16mo, cloth, $1.25. The characteristic quality of Prof. Woodberry’s verse will secure for this new volume a welcome from all those who care for poetry. NATURE PICTURES BY AMERICAN POETS. Edited, with introduction, by Anniz Russet, Marsie. Crown 8vo, cloth, 1.25. A collection of scenes and songs of nature which lovers of the best Ame- rican literature will find valuable and stimulating, The New Standard Works. FOR THE LOVER OF POETRY. LORD TENNYSON’S LIFE AND WORKS New editivn in ten volumes, Fully illustrated with portraits, facsimiles, etc. 12mo, Sateen, gilt tops, $20.00. Sold only in sets. This is the only complete library edition of Tennyson published in this eountry. The Memoir by the present Lord Tennyson is now for the first time issued in a style uniform with the poetical works. Each volume contains a photogravure frontispiece and other illustrations. BISHOP WHIPPLE’S MEMORIES. LIGHTS AND SHADOWS OF A LONG EPISCOPATE. Being Reminiscences and Recollections of the Rr. Rev. Henry BENJAMIN HIPPLE, D.D., LL.D., Bishop of Minnesota, with portraits and other illustrations. Cloth, 8vo, $g.00. “Of varied and absorbing interest.”— The Churchman. ‘* Unconscious, informal, conversational.” — Outlook, FOR THE STUDENT OF POLITICS AND THOSE WHO ENJOY POPULAR BIOGRAPHIES. THE UNITED KINGDOM: A POLITICAL HISTORY. By Go _pwin Sarrn, D.C.L., author of ‘'The United States,” etc. Two vol- umes. Crown 8vo, cloth, $4.00. ABRAHAM LINCOLN: THE MAN OFTHE PEOPLE. By Norman Hapaoop, author of “ Literary Statesmen and Others,” etc. Il- lustrated from portraits and facsimiles. Half leather, $2.00. In these volumes the author follows the political development of the Of the earlier work The Nation said: “It is a literary English-speaking race. masterpiece as readable as a novel.” go ne, “Something which I believe is going to live.”—Hamiiton W. Masie. ‘‘ Never surpassed in vividness, compactness, and lifelike reality.” —Chica- FOR THE STUDENT OF ART AND ANTIQUITIES. POMPEII: ITS LIFE AND ART. By AUGUST MAU. Translated by Francis W. Kevsey, Professor of Latin in the University of Michigan. Illustrated with ten full- photo- gravures and plans and about 200 half-tone illus- trations, drawings, and plans in the text Cloth, $6.00, net. Not an English edition of one of Dr. Mau's standard works, buta new book designed to an- swer questions which are constantly asked about the remains of the ancient city. DEVELOPMENT AND CHARAC- TER OF GOTHIC ARCHITEC- TURE. By Cartes Hersert Moors, Second edition wholly rewritten, with many new illustrations. 8v0, $4.80 net. “Those who have found the first edition of Mr. Moore's work valuable will find it still more impor- tant to possess the second.”—The Nation. LETTERS FRO/ JAPAN. A RECORD OF MODERN LIFE IN THEISLAND EMPIRE. By Mrs. HUGH FRASER, author of * Palladia,” etc. In two volumes. With over ~ illustrations. 8vo. Cloth extra, gilt tops, 7-59. ** Every one of her letters is a valuable contribu- tion to our knowl of the Japanese. The illus- trations are as f ting as letter-press.”— TAterature. FOR THE STUDENT OF SPECIAL PERIODS OR PHASES OF HISTORY. THE ROMAN HISTORY OF APPIAN OF ALEXANDRIA, Translated from the Greek by Horace Wurrs, LL.D. Two vols. $3.00 net. “A long desired addition to English literature.” The Outlook. THE STORY OF FRANCE. From tar Earuiest Times TO THE ConsULATE OF NapoLeon Bonaparte. By the Hon. Taomas E- Watson, The complete work, in two vols., $g-00, “Intensely interesting.”"—-Boston Budget. THE DIARY OF SAMUEL PEPYS. Edited with Notes, etc., by Henry B, Waeatiey F.8. A. Sets in nine volumes, $13.50, net. The only complete edition of one of the most im- ortant “ sources" of English history. The best booksellers throughout the United States have these books in stock for sale or examination, THE MACMILLAN COMPANY, Publishers, New York.
Page 9
The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, DECEMBER 7, 1899. The Week. The opening of the Fifty-sixth Con- gress is noteworthy for the fact that each branch is controlled by the party which carried the country in the last Presidential election. How extraordi- nary such a state of things is, appears only when one runs over the record of administrations, to find that, with the exception of a dozen years after 1860, when the representation of the South was either suspended or abnormal, there has been no case since Jackson’s day when the Executive sent his message to a Congress, chosen midway in the term, which had both a Senate and a House with a majority of his party. In 1895 Cleveland met a House which was over- whelmingly in opposition; in 1891 Harri- son had the same experience; in 1887, whilethe Democrats had, contrary to pre- cedent, retained the lower branch in the middle of Cleveland’s first term, the Republicans still controlled the Senate; in 1883 Arthur addressed a House which was Democratic by a great majority; in 1879 Hayes found Senate as well as House opposed to him; and in 1875 a “tidal-wave” for the Democrats had swept the House from the Republicans, for the first time since 1861. Before the civil war, as during the past quarter of a century, it had become the rule that a political reaction against the party which had carried a Presidential elec- tion, came two years later, and pre- vented the unquestioned control by that party of both branches of the Congress sitting during the last half of a term. Nothing could more forcibly illustrate the utter demoralization of the Demo- cratic party through its surrender to Bryanism than the simple statement of these facts in our political history dur- ing the past sixty years. Another noteworthy fact is, that, for the first time within the experience of this generation, a new Speaker having to be chosen (the old Speaker being in- eligible), there has not been a con- test for the nomination in the caucus of the dominant party, with “headquarters” for rival candidates and all the other ac- cessories of a political contest. Reed, Crisp, Carlisle, Keifer, Randall, Kerr, Blaine, Colfax, Grow—to run back no further than 1861—all had to make a fight for the place when they first se- cured it. The singular feature of Mr. Henderson’s choice by his party is the fact that it was made so clearly several months before the meeting of the House that everybody accepted the situation. Sectional considerations helped the can- vass of the lowa member somewhat, as there was a general feeling in the West that the office ought now to go to that side of the Alleghanies, after having been held by Eastern and Southern mem- bers ever since 1869, except during Kei- fer’s incumbency and Kerr’s still shorter period; but Mr. Henderson found warm support in the East last summer, as had Mr. Reed in the West when McKinley sought the place ten years ago. For the first time in the nation’s history this high position, now universally consider- ed the second office in power under our government, has gone to a State west of the Mississippi. The important feature of the opening proceedings at the national capitol was the attitude of the House toward the Re- presentative-elect from Utah. By a vast majority it assumed the position that, if anybody charges that a Representative- elect is ineligible, he shall not be ad- mitted to a seat until the point thus raised shall have been examined by a committee, and the House shall have acted upon its report. It is a mistaken and a dangerous position. There is an attempt to strengthen it by reciting that the charge in the case of Roberts “is made through a member of the House, on -his responsibility as such member, and on the basis, as he asserts, of pub- lic records, affidavits, and papers evi- dencing such ineligibility.” But the fact remains that an attempt is made to keep a man out of a seat to which he has as strong a claim upon his credentials as any other Representative, on mere alle- gations. The interesting question in the Senate whether Quay will get his seat upon the basis of the Governor’s appointment, came to the front at once. The me- morial against his admission, signed by many members of the Pennsylvania Le- gislature, is a strong document. Besides showing clearly Quay’s weakness in the Legislature, where on the last ballot for Senator he received only 93 votes, against 85 for a second candidate, and 69 for a third, it cites the provision of the State Constitution, which Gov. Stone has disregarded, that “in case of a vacancy in the office of United States Senator of this commonwealth, in a recess between sessions, the Governor shall convene the two houses, by proclamation on notice not exceeding sixty days, to fill the same.” It also puts forcibly the argu- ment that, if the Senate recognizes the right of a Governor to make a tempora- ry appointment when a term expires while a Legislature is in session, “it will inevitably result that efforts will be made by the executives of the States to gather round themselves a small band of adherents who, holding the balance of power, and preventing an election by the Legislature, will deliberately throw into the hands of a Governor the pre- rogative with which the Constitution of the United States has invested the seve- ral Legislatures.” The Senate has so of- ten decided against the Governor’s right to appoint in such cases as this, and by so great a majority when the question was last raised in a case from Oregon last year, that a reversal of its attitude does not seem possible. But Quay’s friends profess confidence that he will pull through, and the public does not feel that confidence in the force of pre- cedents with the Senate in these days which was once entertained. The President’s long review of affairs in the Philippines adds nothing to our knowledge of the past; and as for the future, he distinctly refrains from mak- ing any recommendations until “peace shall be restored.”” Yet, while professing to leave the whole thing to Congress. he asserts that the islands “cannot be abandoned” by us, and goes out of his way to argue against the plan of giving the natives an independent government under an American protectorate. There is not a hint of intending to secure the consent of the governed, though, of course, the President assumes that the majority of the Filipinos are ready and anxious to have him come and bless them by force. It must have been hu- miliating to a Republican President to have to admit, as Mr. McKinley does, that our flag is now flying over slaves in the Sulu Islands; but he thinks to save himself by saying that the agree- ment with the Sultan “is not to be deemed in any way to authorize or give the consent of the United States to the existence of slavery.” It is there, under the shelter of our flag; but if we only ignore it hard enough, why, for all cam- paign and oratorical purposes, it ceases to exist. The message is not nearly so explicit in regard to Cuba as was Secretary Root’s report. It is, in fact, strangely bi-vocal in this part. Referring to the joint resolution binding us to withdraw from Cuba, the President affirms that “the pledge” contained in it “is of the highest honorable obligation and must be sacredly kept.” He also speaks of the possibility of a future convention of the Cuban people to establish an “inde- pendent government.” But he else- where intimates that the ties which are to bind “the new Cuba” to the United States may be “organic” (that is, of course, by annexation), and long puts OE item ot Ne sapimonpemy more = te ec nae 7s cud ema gre gorece 8. SEO POO A ARIE lt
Page 10
418 The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1797 off the day of self-government by the as- sertion that “our mission is not to be fulfilled by turning adrift any loosely framed commonwealth to face the vicissitudes which too often attend weak- er states, whose natural wealth and abundant resources are offset by the in- congruities of their political organiza- and the recurring occasions for internal rivalries to sap their strength and dissipate their energies.” We fear that despondent Cubans and exultant annexationists alike will read those words and say, with the Irishman, that they are “so ambiguous that only one construction can be put upon them.” tion, The President returns this year to the consideration of civil-service reform as a necessary topic in his message, hav- ing omitted all reference to it last year. tie now defends his famous “backward on the familiar lines followed by Secretary Gage, and claims that it has re- sulted in improving the service, adding: “It is believed that the merit system has been greatly strengthened and its perma- nence assured.” By whom is this be- Certainly not by the authors and champions of the system. In regard to the establishment of a reform civil service in our Spanish inheritance, he “It will be my constant aim in the administration of government in our new possessions to make fitness, charac- ter, and merit essential to appointment to office, and to give to the capable and deserving inhabitants preference in ap- pointments.” Let us hope that this pledge will be worth more when the time for performance comes, than the Presi- dent's fervid pledges before he entered upon his duties have proved to be in re- gard to our home service. step” lieved? pays: The clause of the proposed House cur- rency bill which substitutes a tax of one- fifth of one per cent. on bank capital in place of one per cent. on circulation can- not be considered a desirable change. National-bank capital is taxed too heay- ily now, under State and municipal sys- tems. As compared with other forms of moneyed investment it is largely over- taxed, and this bill would handicap it still more. Note issues are a proper sub- ject of taxation, although one per cent. per annum is too heavy. If the Senate shall reject this part of the House bill altogether, it will be no cause for re- Connected with the banknote question is a project for refunding the outstanding national debt into bonds having a long time to run, and bearing interest at 2% per cent. The 4s of 1907 constitute one-half of the bonded debt They will be due in eight years, and if paid will take that much away from the national-bank holdings. The national- gret. bank circulation will be lessened one-half | by that means, It is proposed to renew these bonds at 24% per cent., mainly for ’ the purpose of keeping the banknotes alive, but partly, we presume, to fur- nish a commission on the refunding job. This is, perhaps, tie most dangerous po- litical issue that could be thrust into the bill. It would raise the question wheth- er the people ought to pay interest on the national debt longer than is actually necessary, in order to accommodate the banks. Such a project cannot be sus- tained in the forum of economics or of morals. A 4 per cent. bond running eight years will carry 32 per cent. inter- est. A 2% per cent. bond running 13 years will carry 32% per cent. interest. Therefore, the Government, if able to pay its 4 per cent. debt in 1907, could not afford to extend it now at 2% per cent. beyond 1912. Any longer time than that would be an imposition on the taxpay- ers, which they would be likely to re- sent, or at all events ought to. Secretary Long calls attention again to the fact that the officers and men of the North: Atlantic squadron have so far gone not merely without reward, but ab- solutely without recognition, by Congress for their services in the Spanish war. The nominations for promotion made by the President were not acted upon. Through the promotion of others, seve- ral of the officers of Sampson’s fleet are relatively worse off than they would have been had there been no war. Congress has not even voted them thanks. This, at least, it should now do, urges ‘Mr. Long. He does not explain the extraor- dinary omission, but everybody knows the cause of it. A personal intrigue of the meanest sort, with a degrading ad- mixture of “‘politics,” is the only reason why this appearance of ungrateful ne- glect has been exhibited by Congress. The Secretary takes up none of these de- plorable quarrels, but, in his renewed- tribute to the “precision, brilliancy, and vigor” of the blockade of Santiago, he shows that he knows where the credit is due. We may add that striking tes- .timony to the same effect is to be found in the telegrams which passed between Admiral Cervera and Gen. Blanco. Cer- vera told the doubting General in the plainest terms that it was impossible for him to escape from Sampson’s grip of steel, and when, after the rush to ruin on July 3, Blanco intimated that the squadron might have fared better if it had gone out at night, Cervera an- swered that in that case its destruction would have been but the speedier and more complete. Senator Foraker of Ohio has published a long statement to show how the finan- cial plank in the Republican platform of 1896 came to be adopted. Mr. For- aker was the chairman of the commit- tee on resolutions at the St. Louis con- vention, and he says that he has preserv- ed the records of the committee, includ- ing every scrap of paper that was pre- sented to or considered by the commit- tee. The avowed purpose of the state- ment is to teach Mr. H. H. Kohlsaat of Chicago to know his place, and to show that the claim made for him of the au- thorship of the said financial plank is unwarranted and false. The immediate occasion of Mr. Foraker’s writing is an article in the Metropolitan Magazine for September by William Eugene Lewis, in which it is affirmed that Mr. Kohlsaat drafted the gold plank of the Republican platform of 1896. Mr. Foraker says that he has seen this statement, or the sub- stance of it,in print several times, and that since Mr. Kohlsaat, although having a newspaper at his command, has not seen fit to deny it, he (Kohtsaat) has perhaps come to believe it himself. So it is time to enlighten him as well as other people. Hence the long and ra- ther tedious article which Mr. Foraker supplies to the press, and which goes to show that Mr. Kohlsaat had very little or nothing to do with the plank in ques- tion, unless he wrote the so-called Rich- ards-Hanna resolutions, which were adopted only in part, and that part not very important. Shortly after the adjournment of the St. Louis convention, and while the au- thorship of the financial plank of the platform was under discussion, Mr. E. A. Angell of Cleveland, Ohio, wrote to the New York Evening Post an account of the origin of that plank which was pub- lished in its issue of June 29. The writ- ing of it was not known to Mr. Kohlsaat, nor was the author of it known to him, yet he immediately addressed a letter to the editor of the Hvening Post, saying that it was a true aecount except in some unimportant particulars, which he speci- fied. Mr. Angell’s statement was in sub- stance the following: On Friday, June 12, a number of gentlemen, among whom were Mr. Henry C. Payne of Wisconsin, ex-Gov. Merriam of Minnesota, ex-Gov. Proctor of Vermont, and Mr. H. H. Kohl- saat of Chicago, spent the entire day in a room at the Southern Hotel, discuss- ing the phraseology of a financial plank which had been brought to St. Louis by Mr. Myron T. Herrick of Ohio, one of Mr. McKinley’s intimate friends. This plank was worked over and reduced to shape in words differing very slightly from the form in which it now stands in the plat- ‘form, and it contained the words “the existing gold standard should be pre- served.” The only change made subse- quently, as regards this sentence, was the substitution of the word “must” for “should.” The other changes were of little consequence, but were on the whole improvements. On Monday this plank was submitted by Gov. Merriam to Sena- tor Lodge, Thomas C. Platt, and a few others, and was approved by them with some slight modifications, and on Tues-
Page 11
} Dec. 7, 1899] The Nation. day, June 16, it was telegraphed to Mr. McKinley by Mr. Herrick, and approved by him, and was adopted by Mr. Fora- ker’s committee and by the conven- tion. This was the substance of Mr. Angell’s communication to the Hvening Post, which Mr. Kohlsaat in writing en- dorsed and reaffirmed. Mr. Angell, as it were in anticipation of Foraker’s pre- sent communication, added these words: “It will be noted that the plank proposed by Gov. McKinley’s adherents and personal friends contains the words ‘existing gold standard.’ It will also be observed that this plank was framed and agreed to by them before Mr. Platt, or Senator Lodge, or Mr. Lauterbach had arrived to teach our people the elements of finance, and before the great light had illumined Gov. Fora- ker’s mind. It possibly has not escaped the attention of our Eastern friends that this distinguished apostle of the gold standard announced himself last January, after his election as Senator, as in favor of the re- storation of the free coinage of silver.” The sworn statement of election ex- penditures which has been filed by the Ohio Republican State committee is an unusually interesting document. It re- presents the total outlay as reaching only $91,000, which will cause a smile in more quarters than one. The amount disbursed includes the committee’s note for $20,000, which was discounted at the savings banks and trust company with which the treasurer of the committee is connected. According to the filed return, Senator Hanna did not contribute any- thing, but Col. Dick, chairman of the committee, assured the reporters who questioned him on the subject, that the “Senator did his duty nobly, and it is presumed that he will pay off the note.” That is a new way of making a cam- paign contribution without having the amount revealed in the sworn return of the committee. Another item which is missing in the Ohio return is the amount received from postmasters and other fe- deral employees throughout the United States in response to the begging circu- lars of the finance committee. It is set down in the return that Gen. Horace Porter, Ambassador to France, contri- buted $500; Powell Clayton, Minister to Mexico, $250; Francis B. Loomis, Min- ister to Venezuela, $200; and Senator Foraker, $250, but no sum, individual or lump, is mentioned as’ coming from mi- nor members of the federal service, Surely all those begging letters were not sent in vain. The movement for the wholesale dis- franchisement of the negroes in Georgia has utterly collapsed. The committee on constitutional amendments in the lower branch of the Legislature reported fa- vorably upon the scheme to establish a new test, by which nobody should be a competent voter unless he not only could read and write any paragraph of the Constitution, but could understand and give a reasonable interpretation of it— , except that any man who was entitled to vote in January, 1867, or the lineal de. scendant of any such man, might vote, even if he did not possess the educa- tional qualification. This would enable white election officials under the forms | of law to deny the suffrage to almost every black man in the State. The in- justice of the proposition was so obvi- ous and gross that it could never stand discussion. When it came up in House on November 28, the chairman of the very committee which by a majority | of our most familiar the | vote had reported it favorably, opposed | its passage as unwise, and the only per- son to say a word for it was its intro- ducer, a member of no special influence. But two joined him when the roll was called, while 137 mem- bers voted against the bill. The net re- sult of the agitation is fortunate, as it has shown that the spirit of fair play is dominant in Georgia when an attempt is made to draw the race line. More- over, other States are likely to be de- terred by it from imitating Mississippi. representatives A very interesting analysis of the city budget for 1900 has been made by Mr. P. T. Sherman, the lonely reform mem- ber of the New York Board of Aldermen. He shows that chief among the “fun la- mental advantages of consolidation” has been an annual increase, during the first three years of the enlarged city’s career, of about $22,000,000 in municipal expen- diture. He finds in all departments in- creased salaried forces, and many dupli- cated and unnecessary salaries, and esti- mates the amount of money paid out yearly in useless salaries at fully $7,000,- 000. He is doubtless well within the limits in this estimate, for nearly every department of our government has con- verted itself into a little city govern- ment of its own, with all kinds of subor- dinates, advisers, special clerks, special counsel, confidential stenographers, and other paraphernalia of administration, all at the public expense. Mr. Sherman is quite right in saying that this $7,000,- 000 “is really used to pay workers for Tammany; for the officials who draw these salaries, having no work to do for the city except to draw their salaries, can readily spend their time in political work for their organization.” The plethoric condition of the Tam- many treasury is revealed with -great freedom by Mr. Croker and his asso- ciates. They raise $60,000 with per- fect ease for the purchase of the Par- nell homestead in Ireland, an act which the Lord Mayor of Dublin says will make the name of Mr. Croker beloved for ever in all the homes of Ireland. They are now proposing to take hold of the Dewey Arch fund and carry that through to complete success. Whence comes all this wealth? What is Mr. Croker living on? How does it happen that he can sail for Europe, for several | citizens on |} name is signed in all lists of notables, | en nm ee months of idleness and comfortable liv ing, amid the cheers of a creat host of admirers, and with no anxiety whatever about paying his bills These are que tions which at one time might have ex | cited mild curiosity t f the people, but nobody bothers himself about them now. Mr. Croker has bk institution Vi accept him and his government, which he says publicly that he runs for his personal benefit, as a matter of course He serves on our committees of eminent great public occasions, his | and he rides in our processions and ac- cepts gratefully the homage of the pe ple. Through habit, we have come to accept him, as we come to accept every- thing else. He is, in fact, the chief of those “fundamental adv intages of con solidation” which our new charter gave us. Ever since the Sun declared ita in- dependence of Typographical Union No. 6 the officers and agents of the union have been bombarding the merchants of New York with letters and circulars threatening them with loss of trade and other injury if they that newspaper. They have also done every- advertise in thing in their power to prevent news- dealers and newsboys from selling the Sun. They have picketed the newspa- per office and its branch offices, its pa- trons, its agents, its advertisers, and its sympathizers. All the machinery of the boycott has been brought in requisition to cripple and break down the paper; and all because the Sun hired such men as it chose to do its work. The particu- lar facts which led to the boycott are all comprehended in a single sentence The Sun insisted on managing its own affairs, and the Typographical Union ob jected. Hence the boycott and the pick- eting which have been running on for a period of three months. The the boycotters fair notice that it would appeal to the law for protection. It show- ed, by citations from similar cases that had passed through the courts, that boy- cotting is an unlawful conspiracy, pun- ishable by fine and imprisonment; but, of course, the boycotters did not desist on that account. In due time the Sun's case came to a hearing in the Supreme Court, and on Friday an injunction was granted by Judge Bookstaver against the officers and agents of Typographical Union No. 6, restraining them from all the acts complained of, such as sending threatening letters and other advertisers, news- dealers and picketing the Sun's offices, intimidating its employees, or otherwise injuring its: business, its property, and its property rights. The injunction is as sweeping as the boycott itself. It now remains to be seen whe- ther the law as pronounced by the courts can be enforced in New York. Sun gave merchants intimidating newsboys, to
Page 12
420 The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1797 SECRETARY ROOT’S REPORT. It is a satisfaction to read Mr. Root’s annual report as Secretary of War, for one thing because it is evidently the work of a trained mind, of real grasp and power, going straight to the point, in the spirit of the sound advice of Bish- op Blomfield: ‘When you come to a man of business, keep to your business, finish your business, and go about your business.” We can only sigh as we think what Mr. Root might have done had he been in Gen. Alger’s place from the beginning. . The sections relating to army reor- ganization are of the highest importance. We shall discuss them presently. But what will most instantly command at- tention is the Secretary’s discussion of the questions of insular government forced upon us by the war with Spain. These come necessarily at present with- in the purview of the War Department. Besides, it was understood, when Mr. Root took office, that his legal abilities were especially sought, for the aid they might give the President in making re- commendations to Congress of legisla- tion in execution of the Treaty of Paris. Of Mr. Root’s proposals we must say that, given the circumstances, they are enlightened and honorable. In regard to Cuba, the Secretary’s trumpet gives no uncertain sound. ‘We shall,” he flatly says, “transfer to the Cuban govern- ment the control now held by us in trust for the people of Cuba.” “The revenues of the island of Cuba have been treated as a trust fund for which the United States was accountable to the people of Cuba, and the accounts have been so kept that this department will be ready to account for all money received, when- ever the proper time comes.” These words will be received with joy by the Cubans, and will alone be as valuable in calming agitation in the island as two regiments of soldiers. Mr. Root is much more explicit and emphatic in this offi cial utterance of his than the President has ever been; but it must be that the subordinate now speaks with the assent of the chief, and that we are by so much nearer to keeping faith with the Cubans. Military control must be for some time continued, the Secretary believes, but the islanders will not mind that; they will rather welcome it if along with it goes the distinct promise and prepara- tion of independence in the end. For the rest, Secretary Root urges that our temporary military occupation of Cuba be made to minister as directly as pos- sible to the physical and moral recupe- ration of the people, along the lines now so successfully followed. He also recom- mends that Congress should, during the period of our control, grant to Cuban exporters fully as favorable terms as to their competitors in the West Indies. In his general discussion of the kind of government to be given the islands ceded to us by Spain, Mr. Root strikes the right note by saying at the start that “it is our unquestioned duty to make the interests of the people over whom we assert sovereignty the first and controlling consideration in all le- gislation and administration which con- cerns them.” This will excite the sneers of the speculators and the office-seekers, who snuff the spoils from afar, but it must be made the watchword of Admi- nistration and Congress alike, if we are not to fall off our “glory-crowned heights” into a pit of falseness and failure, to the derision of all mankind. In regard to Porto Rico, for which Mr. Root sketches out a somewhat elaborate scheme of territorial government, he says, with unmistakable clearness of in- tent, that “it will be necessary that some cardinal rule shall be adopted and rigidly followed regarding appointment to office.” What this rule should be, he describes in cold-blooded terms, cal- culated to send chills down the spine of every Charley in Ohio: “Wherever a Porto Rican can be found capable and willing to perform official duties he should be selected, and the aim should be to include in the civil service of the island no greater number of Americans from the United States than are necessary for the introduction of the methods of administra- tion in which Americans have been trained and Porto Ricans have not. “Wherever it is necessary to employ Americans, except in the chief offices, a system of civil-service examination should be provided, under which requests from the Governor of Porto Rico for suitable per- sons to be appointed may be filled.” Into the legal and constitutional ques- tions involved in such a plan of gov- ernment we need not now enter. Con- gress and the courts will have their fill of them before they get through. Though Mr. Root thinks that the Porto Ricans have no constitutional right to demand uniformity of tariff laws, he strongly urges, as a measure of policy and justice, that “the customs duties between Porto Rico and the United States be removed.” This is a grave question, the discussion of which in its constitutional and fiscal aspects must be postponed. The radical and able recommendations for the improvement of the army include a general war college, corresponding to similar institutions in Europe; staff corps to consist of officers temporarily and not permanently detailed; promo- tions for merit and by selection instead of for seniority only; close relations with the navy and the National Guard, and, generally, a careful preparation for war in time of peace. In regard to these proposed changes, he says, what has fre- quently been pointed out in these col- umns, that they will accomplish “results which are provided for in every conside- rable army in the world, and which un- der our organization are not the busi- ness of anybody in particular.” ° There can be no difference of opinion as to the necessity of the creation of a general war college, or general staff, af- ter our experience in the war with Spain. A similar organization furnishes the eyes, ears,and brains of every Con- tinental military body, and has every- where been the most favored and che- rished corps since the one at Berlin, under the guidance of Moltke, raised Prussia to the front rank of military na- tions, and made possible the overwhelm- ing defeats of the Austrians in 1866 and of the French in 1870-1871. Its absence here rendered the United States unfit to carry on so puny a war as that in Cuba without extravagance, inefficiency, and intolerable scandals, together with needless suffering and loss of life: Given an efficient general staff, and there will be a competent body at hand to make graduation from West Point not, as is so often the case, the end of an of- ficer’s professional education, but mere- ly the beginning of a life-long study of the science of war and the art of han- dling as large bodies of troops as may be got together in this country. Given trained staff officers, and there can be mapped out long before the outbreak of war every foreseeable detail, from the plan of campaign and the selection of generals down to the purchase of shoes in Massachusetts and canned fruit in California. If the perfection of the Ger- man system is fortunately impossible in this republic, it is none the less possible to map out complete plans which would produce similar results to those accom- plished by the navy in 1898. And all this may be done, as Mr. Root points out, with comparatively liftle expense, and “without any revolutionary interference with the general scheme of organiza- tion,” except that, in our opinion, the existing staff corps must be abolished or consolidated. In regard to the latter, Mr. Root again takes’ advanced ground. His adoption of the principle that the staff corps, wheth- er executive or supply, should be made up of officers temporarily detailed from the line, instead of being appointed to them for life, or until retirement for age, will cause much unhappiness in certain Washington military circles. We can- not improve upon Mr. Root’s statement that— “Nothing can be more important than that the officers of the army shall feel that their rise in rank depends upon what they do; that ability, intellectual activity, faith- ful performance of duty, and gallant con- duct are more certain claims to preferment than social or political influence. A system of promotions which is divorced from the efficiency record is not merely unjust, but it destroys ambition and checks the effort of the army.” The Secretary’s proposal that officers shall be promoted not only because of becoming seniors in their grades as is done now, but also because of gallantry or special ability or merit, is again merely the adoption of a principle in force in all foreign armies. Its value to the army will depend upon the jus- tice with which the merit system is ap- plied, and the absence of political or Beg ad eee
Page 13
Sq ROR RL patter Stele its ioe RAS ade ti rien, ht tenes: Dec. 7, 1899] The N ation. personal favoritism. It is amply suffi- cient at this time to point out that, had such a method been in use in this coun- try during the last ten years, Gen. Shaf- ter would not have commanded the Fifth Army Corps at Santiago, Gen. Brooke would have had no opportunity to blun- der in Porto Rico and Cuba, and, in all probability, Gen. Otis would never have commanded more than a brigade, if as much. The friction between the mili- tary and naval officers during Gen. Otis’s tour of command in the Philip- pines would alone justify Mr. Root’s plea for a close alliance between the two services, did not the country’s long coast lines make such a union a tacti- cal necessity. ; For decades past most of our army ex- penditures have been wasteful, and therefore inexcusable, because with them there has been purchased a very inferior military machine. If the Secretary's views and plans prevail in Congress, the people will at least get what they pay for—a modern, capable, and efficiently administered army. THE “NEW DIPLOMACY” AND WAR. Mr. James Bryce has rendered a great service to the public in printing, as a “Prefatory Note” to the third edition of his ‘Impressions of South Africa,’ an ab- solutely impartial, clear, and succinct narrative of the events in the Transvaal since 1895, which have resulted in the present war. The situation, as he de- scribes it, which existed in the Trans- vaal, in the Orange Free State, and in Cape Colony, was one of complete friend - liness between the Dutch and English races. There was good feeling towards Great Britain in all three; in Cape Co- lony and in the Orange Free State, pro- gress and enlightenment, and a growing town population. The people of the Transvaal were much more conservative, pig-headed, and ignorant. They were to- tally unable, through want of knowledge, to provide for the proper government of the great horde of foreigners which their newly discovered gold mines had invited to their territory. It is to this incompetence, rather than to malice, and to the retention of the administration by the older men, that Mr. Bryce as- cribes most of the grievances of which the Uitlanders complained. But to set this off, there was, according to him, a growing younger party, among the burghers, which, already containing the moral and intellectual influence of the country, perceived that the actual state of things could not continue, and was ready to join the Uitlanders in agitating for sweeping changes. Consequently, the sorrows of the Uitlanders were on their face temporary; property was se- cured, and the complaints of disability were not greater or, more serious than mining adventurers in new countries usually have to make. This promising state of thinga was all changed by the Jameson raid, which nobody attempts tc defend, but about which many have lied. It was due to the haste and greed of the capitalists who were engaged in exploit- ing the country under the superintend- ence of Mr. Rhodes. After that, the Boers naturally be- came very suspicious. They could not be persuaded that the British had not de- signs on their independence. These sus- picions were strengthened by the atti- tude assumed by Mr. Chamberlain. In- stead of heing patient, conciliatory, and indulgent in dealing with an ignorant but well-meaning population, who were well known to be ready to sacrifice everything for their tndependence, he suddenly became querulous, exacting. and haughty. He grew more and more deeply impressed with the wrongs of the Uitlanders. He could not see, what every other rational man saw, the prob- ability that these wrongs would be made transitory by the rapid growth of the new mining population, by the rise of the young burgher party, and by the dis- appearance from the scene, in the course of nature, of Kriiger and the old Dutch oligarchs. These facts made it plain that, even if the Uitlanders had to suffer, they would not have to suffer long. Tho poor old Boers, who trekked so brave- ly and fought so valiantly, were Mestined surely, in the ordinary course of nature and through the mere spread of civiliza- tion and wealth, to disappear from the scene, and leave the soil, which they had bedewed so plentifully with their blood, to the potent forces of the coming time. Mr. Chamberlain even went so far as to raise new points in the negotiations which ensued, and, when he found that the mention of “suzerainty” inflamed and frightened the Boers, instead of keeping it out of sight and belittling its importance, he enlarged its meaning, and gave out that it meant not merely, as Mr. Bryce says it really meant, the right to control foreign relafions, but the right to interfere in domestic concerns, which was the very thing the Boers had dread- ed and foretold. Mr. Chamberlain’s position in England was at that time peculiar. In London, in June last, before the controversy had en- tered on its acute stage, there were but few who denied that he was bent on war. There were many who told you that he must have war or he would be ruined. The earlier schemes with which he entered office, such as the treatment of the colonies as “neglected estates,” and the creation of the Zollverein to include them and the mother country, and the plans for the elevation of the poor and the comfort of old men, had come to nothing to speak of, In the twinkling of an eye the great English Radical became wholly possessed by the sorrows of the emigrant miners in South Africa, and the saving of the British Empire from the hellish designs of 70,000 421 Dutch farmers in the Transvaal. Most of his dispatches and speeches bristied with taunts and threats. It soon became very evident that his mission was not settlement, but provocation. We do not recall, except Bismarck’s challenge to the French in 1870, a similarly diabolic réie as having been played Wy any mod- ern statesman. From the month of May on, the “new diplomacy” was in full play. Every 4-4 patch, instead of being kept, as in the old diplomacy, in the Minister's desk un- til called for by Parliament, was laid before the public with a Chamberlain gloss. The services of the press in in- flaming the people with news of the ab- solute necessity of conquering the Boers, were eagerly enlisted. In London, edi- tors are even more impressionable by official recognition than they are here. Consequently, a few of the more infiu- ential found themselves welcome once a week or so, at the Colonial Office, to talk over the affairs of South Africa with the great statesman himeelf, to hear fresh revelations of Kriiger’s duplicity and malice, and British official rejoicing over the progress of the imperial movement in America. The resulting harangues in the prese and the growing excitement of the pub- lic naturally enabled Mr. Chamberlain to hold his own against the peace-loring members of the Cabinet, though they well understood his character and de. signs. The Jingoes became every day more audacious, began to break up pub- lic meetings, and howls “Rule Britannia” at the music-halls and in the streets. The voices of the men of light and lead- ing, like John Morley, Sir William Har- court, James Bryce, and Bishop Percival, had harder work in making themselves heard. Nevertheless, the party of peace made progress, owing to thé Colonial Secretary’s inability to put om paper what his demands were, or what his u!- timatum, if he went to war, would be; for every war has to be preceded by an ultimatum. This was the trouble which stared the Right Hon. Joseph in the face. He had an easy time enough while he was declaiming, but sooner or later he would have to formulate reasons why the Boers had to be killed for doing, or not doing, certain things. At this criti- cal moment of his career, Kriiger came to his rescue by his deplorable ul- timatum, and Mr. Chamberlain was able to laugh at those who asked what Ais ultimatum would be, somewhat as the confidence man laughs at you when you fail to find on him the watch which you think he has stolen from you. We have here a perfect picture of the working of the “new diplomacy”—the need of war to distract public attention, felt by a de- magogue or party in trouble; the selec- tion of some weak foreign antagonist for a quarrel; the making of insulting de- mands on him; the conduct of negotia- tions with him about these demands in
Page 14
The 422 public before people excited almost to frenzy already by a subsidized or ca- joled press; the steady provocation of about capita! and labor, currency and finance, and the fundamental conditions | of healthy political society. Some would the enemy till he does something to si- | adopt all three suggestions at once, and | lence completely the voices of reason, | so alter the curriculum of school and justice, and mercy, and the conversion of the successful demagogue into a first- class national hero. TRAINING FOR CITIZENSHIP. Every little while the press gives us an account of some new discussion of the well-worn question of “training for citizenship.” The subject is one of the most common, if not one of the most hackneyed, in the whole field of educa- tional debate. It is “standing matter” on the programmes of teachers’ conven- tions and young men’s congresses. It is sure to crop out in every college pre- sident’s inaugural address, and is rarely absent from baccalaureate sermons and commencement speeches. No education- al journal would be complete without more or less extended reference to the subject at least four times a year. Wherever students, young or old, or men for the time being educationally inclined, are gatbered together, there is this per- ennial question in their midst. It is very significant that, with all the wealth of rhetoric and good intention lavished upon it, it should still hold its place, and rarely fail, when vigorously and incisive- ly presented, to arouse the interest and enthusiasm of an audience, The story may be old, with repetitious phrase and familiar illustration in the telling of it; but somehow it does not seem to lose its charm, It ia interesting to note the more im- portant elements of which training for citizenship is commonly thought to con- sist. Surely it is not for want of pana- ceas that the body politic continues to be diseased. One writer or speaker, for ex- ample, urges a broader and more tho- rough study of history, particularly American history. At the root of most public sin les ignorance—ignorance of the course of human progress, of the critical moments and pivotal points in the development of civilization, of the steps by which our country has come to be what ft Is. It can but clarify the vi- sion and strengthen the hands of an hon- est, but fll-informed, Democrat to study the ives of Jefferson and Jackson, just as ft can but set right every honest Re- publican to know the political princi- ples of Hamilton and the extraordinary career of Lincoin. Another writer urges a more general study of “civil govern- ment” in schools, and would have every child become acquainted with the admin- istrative machinery, local, state, and na- tional, that so he may come to realize his duties and responsibilities as a cit!- zen. Still another would have political economy and sociology taught in gram- mar and high schools, and give boys and girls, from early life, correct hotions college as to make place for the studies bearing most directly on what they in- sist is the chief business of life. ° It will not escape notice that each of these suggestions—and they are the ones most frequently urged—purposes to at- tain civic goodness by increasing the citizen's stock of information. Now, it cannot be denied that information on every one of the points mentioned, and many others, is highly desirable; nor can there be any doubt that ignorance is often an effective bar to the satisfactory performance of political duty. It ought to be apparent, however, without much argument, that knowledge and right con- duct are not quite the same thing, and are not always even found together. Were all men as righteous as they are well informed, the dawn of the millenni- um might ere this have been discerned. On the contrary, some of the greatest rascals in American politics have been men of intellectual attainments and va- ried accomplishments. There has never been a visionary project launched, or a scheme for getting around some consti- tutional prohibition or legal safeguard set on foot, which has not drawn to its support men of marked intellectual strength. In our own day, we have seen men of information and cultivated tastes swearing allegiance to the economic va- garies of Mr. Bryan, and apologizing for the scandalous invasion of the civil service by President McKinley. Know- ledge, in short, is only the accumulated stores of the human mind, and may or may not determine, in the right direc- tion, opinion and conduct. In the same way, what we have in mind when we talk about “good citi- zenship” is not necessarily furthered by exceptional familiarity with the details of government and administration. It is not so much ignorance of adminis- trative methods, as the employment of those methods for corrupt and selfish ends, that stamps our politics with evil. The experts who “run” the political ‘‘ma- chine” are perfectly acquainted with all ite parts, but they are hardly the men we should like to have instructing our children in the duties of citizenship. We fancy that Mr. Platt could give an ex- tremely interesting and informing course of lectures on “practical politics’; but we do not think of Mr. Platt as a good citizen. Mr. Hanna could doubtless dis- course most instructively on the conduct of Presidential campaigns, but we do not think of Mr. Hanna as primarily a good citizen. President McKinley could great- ly enlighten us on the obligations of the executive to enforce thelaws of the land; but we should hesitate to select Presi- dent McKinley as a type of the good citizen. The patent fact of the matter Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1797 is that knowledge, in and of itself, car- ries no necessary power for good, and does not prevent those who know the most about government from governing us the worst. What we need, over and above a knowledge of historic fact, is a certain moral touch, a critical appreciation of measures and men, a kindling enthusi- asm for a proper conduct of affairs. It is useless to inform ourselves of the ways of the fathers, under the impres- sion that we are thereby training our- selves for citizenship, unless we also grasp the ideals toward which the fathers worked, and light up with our own imagination the picture of govern- ment as they meant it to be. It is use- less to delve among administrative de- tails, unless we gather some sense of ob- ligation to keep them from perversion. It is useless to master the laws of cur- rency and finance, if, in practical life, we are to be swayed about by every wind of doctrine. We must have the frank and conscious judgment as to the moral worth of things, as well as know- ledge of the things themselves. Such is not, we are aware, the universal view. Moral instruction of any sort has prac- tically disappeared from the public schools, and our learned historians are shy of getting beyond a careful narration of events. But good citizenship has as its foundation, not only knowledge, but patriotism-—,it is patriotism in action; and patriotism is a moral ideal as well as a mass of facts. Matthew ‘Arnold de- fined religion as morality touched with emotion; we may define patriotism as knowledge touched with imagination. It is the passion for cleanness and purity In politics, the hunger and thirst for righteousness in public life, that is to secure for us good citizens and good government, if anything can; and it is this, added to knowledge, that holds for us the promise of the future, as it is our safety here and now. THE FUTURE OF THE SMALL COL- LEGE. If one were asked to name the moat important development in higher edu- cation in this country during the present generation, the answer would, undoubt- edly, instance the rise of the universi- ties. Starting from a condition in which professional instruction was on a low plane, and graduate instruction almost unknown, the whole structure of the American university now familiar to us, with its professional and graduate schools, its libraries, laboratories, and museums, and its large and highly or- ganized teaching and administrative corps, has grown by leaps and bounds, and, for the most part, before our own eyes. Each year finds the student less dependent than formerly upon European institutions for the:training which his particular business in life demands,
Page 15
Dec. 7, 1899] ‘The Nation. while in many directions the facilities for scholarly attainment and research are already distinctly superior to any offered abroad. To be sure, we have learned, sometimes by painful experi- ence, that it takes a good deal of money to “run” a university, and certainly none of our greater institutions has as yet anywhere near as ample funds as it could profitably use; but the money seems likely to be forthcoming, in larger and stronger flow, to the continual and rapid enhancement of every facility and opportunity now enjoyed. It is a serious question what effect this development of the university is likely to have upon the immediate future of the so-called small college. The small college has filled a peculiar place in American society. Located, often, out- side of the larger centres of population, and drawing its students from a limited geographical or social area, it has offer- ed a type of education which, useful as a foundation for more advanced study, has served also to perpetuate much of educational tradition and custom. Such a college. as a rule, has comparatively small financial resources; its faculty are rarely great scholars; and its social ad- vantages are inconsiderable. Yet, im- portant and indispensable as the work of the small college has been, and praise- “worthy as are those who have unselfish- ly labored in its behalf, it is fairly open to question whether the future of high- er education in the United States does not now rest with the university. The university is undeniably the great force to-day in educational councils, and quite the most conspicuous figure in the public eye. Its superior wealth enables it to offer facilities for instruction with which no college can compete. It is steadily attracting to its service the ablest men in all departments, until no college can now hope to retain long a professor who makes a name for. him- self. There can be little doubt but that undergraduate instruction in the univer- sity—the instruction which comes direct- ly into competition with the college—is of a superior sort, better in quality and greater in variety and amount than any college can offer. There is a more eager and enthusiastic intellectual life, a clear- er view of the worth of sound learning, a closer contact with scholarly instruc- tors, and a richer and a healthier so- cial atmosphere. These are things with which the small college cannot compete; and if there be added to them the attrac- tive force of numbers—the inevitable tendency of the largest institutions to grow the fastest—it becomes a question of pressing and vital concern whether the college must not before long become either a preparatory school on the one hand, or a university on the other, or, failing either, close its doors. The action most likely, we think, to bring matters to a head, would be the re- duction of the undergraduate course in the university from four to three years. So long as the first degree can be ob- tained anywhere only after the same length of time, institutions of widely different grade can continue to flourish side by side. But the dropping of a year by a few leading universities would bring the small colleges face to face with a problem whose solution might well in- volve, not only their standing in the educational world, but their very exist- ence as well. The contingency is not re- mote. Harvard has for some time had the matter of a three years’ course under consideration; and what Harvard does to-day, most institutions are likely to be doing ten years from now. The increas- ing tendency to make the undergraduate course a prerequisite for admission to the professional school, the late age at which the graduate of the professional school now enters upon his work in the world, and the superior meaning of the baccalaureate degree now as compared with its traditional significance, are ar- guments strongly urged in favor of the change. It will not escape notice, also, that a number of universities already practically shorten the undergraduate} course by allowing the fourth year to be! spent in the professional or graduate} school. As to the wisdom or propriety of the proposed change, we do not now express any opinion. What we wish to call attention to is the fact that such a change, if once brought about, cannot fail to put the small college in jeopardy. When the degree of Bachelor of Arts can be had at Harvard or Yale, for example, in three years, how long will any New England college be able to hold its stu- dents for four? No loyalty to an honor- able past could long avail against the opportunity of saving a whole year in the preparation for bread-winning. Once the change of which we have been speaking shall have come about, the path of the college, if it is to main- tain itself under the new competition, would seem to be reasonably clear. The college must, in the first place, reduce its own course to three years. It may do this promptly, or it may delay until the operation is necessary in order to save its life; but that it must do it, sooner or later, is obvious. In the sec- ond place, the undergraduate course in the college must be made fully equal, in scope and value, to the undergraduate course in the university. At present such equality is far from obtaining. A number of the leading universities now rate the average college course as the equivalent of but from two to three years of their own; that is to say, the graduate of the college is admitted to the junior or senior class in the university, while the acknowledged superiority of university work might very likely be a sufficient warrant for bestowing the first degree at the end of three years instead of four; but it may well be doubted whether public opinion would tolerate a 423 corresponding “degradation” of the de- gree on the part of the college. Some- how or other, the college must raise the standard of its work, at the same time that it is cutting down the time of its course. The crucial question ts whether this can be done. Something, no doubt, can, without much difficulty, be accomplished. The intellectual standards of most col- leges are not very rigorous, and might well be stiffened. The college cannot, of course, lower its standard of admis- sion; to do that would be to lose much of what has been won by a generation of strenuous effort. Whether, however, the college, placed between the efficient high school and the powerful university, can continue to hold its own, and still offer an education worth rewarding with a degree, is the question whose serious consideration cannot long be evaded. Yet nothing can be clearer than that un- less the college can so hold its own, its days, at least in its present form, are numbered. It may become a high-grade preparatory school, sending its pupils, unadorned with a degree, to such profes- sional careers as may still be open to them; or it may in some way affiliate with the university and take over some of the work of elementary instruction now done by the latter. But it cannot hope to retain its present independent and honorable status, or exert a large in- fluence in educational affairs, unless it is able to convince the critical public of the soundness and adequacy of its work. — RT THE VILLARI TESTIMONIAL. FLORENCE, November 17, 1899. Ceremonies such as those just terminated in the hall of the University college at Pisa are so common in England and in America that they excite little curiosity, but in Italy it is extremely rare that an individual, un- less he be a popular soldier or statesman, gets honored in his lifetime. Therefore, when last year it was announced that the colleagues and admirers of Pasquale Vil- lari intended to commemorate him in his capacity of teacher of youth during the last forty years, and that the form proposed was to be a foundation for assisting future stu- dents to pursue their historical studies, there was considerable doubt whether suffi- cient funds could be raised for this Fonda- zione Villari to insure the sum of four or five hundred dollars, which suffices for the modest requirements of real students in Italy, who are as frugal as the Scotch when really bent on study, and on study only. One thousand pounds sterling was the most the sanguine friends expected to ralse, but an English admirer, Col. Gilman, opened the ball with one hundred pounds; admirers from England, Scotland, the United Srates, contributed with hearty good will, while the subscription list contains the name of al- mest every man of note and culture in Italy; his Majesty King Humbert closing the list with $1,000 and a genial tele- gram duly read and appreciated by the crowded audience of scholars, professors, friends, and admirers, gathered from all parts of the country, together with a num-
Page 16
424 ber of illustrious foreigners. The presence of Augusto Conti, the well-known Catholic philosopher, and one of the chief and most ardent promoters of the testimonial, is a proof of the esteem in which Villari is held by all classes of patriots, whatever be the difference in their political and reli- gious opinions. Augusto Conti was the standard-bearer in the famous battalion of professors and students who signalized Tus- can valor on the bloody field of Curtatone in i848, where so many of their numbers feli dead or wounded on the field. As he was unable to read his speech, owing to fail- ing eyesight, it was read for him by Prof. Raini, and one paragraph is worthy of quo- tation, as it touchés on the part of Villari’s varied and laborious work which seems to us his highest claim to the gratitude of his countrymen: “You, the active benefactor of the work- ing classes, have toiled with fraternal, I might say paternal, solicitude, not to arouse evil passions and to promise imaginary equality among them, but to secure just wages, to elevate their morality and dignity. This is well known to the Tuscan straw- plaiters; to the Sicilian toilers in the sul- phur mines; to the dwellers in caves and cellars of your native city, and now to the poor navvies in the excavations of the Sim- pion tunnel, about whom you have written with so much wisdom and kindness, spar- ing neither long journeys nor sojourn in order to ascertain the real facts and pro- pose ameliorations in their hard lot.’ (A touching telegram came from these grateful toilers, or rather from the band known as the Salesiana.) The Professor himself, while naturally em- barrassed at having to listen to such various and warm praise from all sides, seemed in excellent health and spirits, and was ex- ceedingly happy in his speech of thanks, saying that criticism had become so entire- ly a second nature with him that he felt sure he could write a better book than any yet published if devoted to a criticism of his own writings. He attributed the “unmerit- ed honor” paid to him to various fortuitous circumstances: the choice of Florence for his historical studies—Florence, the beloved of the civilized world, which appeared as an electric spark in the night of the Middle Ages, illuminating the world and determin- ing the character of the new Italy; the re- sult of such studies proving that the great- est and strongest nations are those wherein society is justest, most honest, which give the highest proofs of social justice, the one solid basis of all civilization. This convic- tion it was which led him to a study of the social conditions of Italy, to the denuncia- tion of many and gross injustices which abound. This, he said (and alas with what truth!), arouses sympathy, but little more. People read your descriptions of the poor wretches tolling in the Roman Campagna throughout a long day without earning enough to satisfy their hunger, and say, “What a beautiful article!’’—simply that and nothing more. The remainder of his speech was devoted to his beloved Institute, to his colleagues, and, above all, to his scholars, who had presented him with a capital portrait paint- ed “to the life.” Villari dwelt lov- ingly on many promising students cut off in their prime, on the pleasure of meeting old scholars now engaged in tuition in the different provinces, and always gratefully affectionate, His tribute to Aygusto Conti was duly appreciated by all. As the Dean of the Institute, he spoke of his science and The Nation. [ Vol. 69, No. 1797 love of country, not forgetting his defence of the flag confided to him by the University battalion, and was greeted with such hearty applause as must have delighted his English wife and perfect helpmate, Linda, daughter of the fine old radical member for Brighton, James White, and the perfect translator into English of her husband’s historical works on Savonarola and Machiavelli. Their one son, bright and very English looking, Gino, was also present, and will certainly carry through life a pleasant memory of the day, not forgetting that the unusual tribute paid to his father was due quite as much to his sterling courage and honesty, to his generous, unostentatious,and disinterest- ed character, as to his real merit as his- torian and well-done work as a professor. The subscriptions, amounting to 43,000 lire (about $8,500), are, by Villari’s own desire, to be administered by a Commission com- posed of the presidents of the faculty of letters and of the Istituto Storico Italiano in Rome; of a representative of the Accademia dei Lincei and of the Accademia della Crusca,with one other professor of history. The Commission is to meet every three years, and decide what special branch of history shall be chosen for the candidates for the fellowship, which will be eagerly competed for by graduates from all the uni- versities and superior institutes, women laureates (who are now increasingly nume- rous) included. As a historian, Pasquale Villari needs no introduction to the readers of the Nation; as Senator, Minister of Public Instruction, member of the Superior College of Public Instruction, to which he is elected when- ever the rules permit, he is as well known in Italy. Born in Naples in 1827, he has given a capital sketch of public instruction there in his preface to the works of his col- lege friend, Luigi La Vista,and of his beloved master, De Sanctis, “the last of the pur- ists.” After the fatal 15th of May, 1849, when his friend of friends, La Vista, was shot to death at his side by one of the Swiss Guards of King Bomba, he came to Florence and commenced his historical pub- lications with an introduction to the His- tory of Italy, followed up by a study of Ce- sare Beccaria; an essay on the origin and progress of the philosophy of history; a cri- tical essay on the biographers of Savonarola, who had always attracted his sympathy, but concerning whom he found, from his re- searches in the Florentine archives, that he knew next to nothing. It is character- istic of the man’s honesty that he burnt his already prepared manuscript and set to work afresh, publishing his now well-known work only in 1860, after he had been appointed Professor of History in the University of Pisa by the Minister Ridolfi in 1859, and later to the post he still occupies in the Istituto di Studj Superiori, founded by Ri- casoli, Peruzzi, and other valiant Floren- tines, but which owes its rank as a real and first-class university more to Villari than to any one else, In 1860 he returned to Naples, and was appreciated at his true worth by Dr. Agos- tino Bertani, Garibaldi’s alter ego for the time being, who, even more than to political affairs, devoted his attention to the horri- ble sanitary conditions of the city and the appalling misery and degradation of the poorest classes. The idea of the disembow- elling of Naples was originally Bertani’s, as the reports which he drew up and which have been published since his death amply prove. He chose Villari as the representa- tive of the dictator Government in Turin, and, though the latter declined the office, he drew up the instructions for the office, which were approved and signed by Garibaldi with- out a single alteration. During the time Villari spent in Naples, he first became ac- quainted with the actual state of the popu- lation; but when Garibaldi handed over the liberated province to the King, the govern- ments which succeeded one after the other took no thought for the welfare of the in- habitants, but simply of subjecting the south to the north. Villari returned to his Institute, but could not long refrain from mooting the subject which often saddened him in the midst of his scholars and literary studies. In October, 1861, he wrote a letter to the ultra-moderate newspaper, the Perseveranza of Milan, on the Camorra of Naples, in- sisting that it was a duty of all in autho- rity to do their utmost for its suppression, because of its material oppression and moral degradation of the very poorest classes. He showed that it was of no use to arrest the camorristi and send them to the common prisons to which all their friends and accomplices had access, and recommend- ed the rigorous punishment of the chiefs, who should be confined in penitentiaries, while their victims should be encouraged to resist their requisitions to the utmost. But the sixties were not years propitious for the study of social questions. With Venice to be freed and the French to be dislodged from Rome, the political question occupied the minds of all. Bertani, after the Men- tana episode, demanded an official inquiry into the conditions of the peasant classes, and Villari was one of the few moderates who seconded him. As a rule, the wealthy classes of all nations object to the raising of the social spectre, and when Villari’s “Lettere Meridionali’ appeared in the chief organ of the Moderate party, the Opinione, he was assailed on all sides by the members of his own party for his revelations, or, as some of them said, his ‘fictitious nar- rations’’; indeed, many of them maintained that the “fondaci” (or barns), where the miserable denizens of the slums are hud- died together like sardines in a barrel, were his invention pure and simple. He was told that he knew nothing of the misery of other cities—of Vienna, Berlin, New York, not to speak of London. So to Lon- don he went, and saw by night and by day the worst quarters and the vilest alleys that the most courageous policeman could show him; visited the lodging-houses, the dens of the opium-eaters; and, returning, affirmed ‘‘on his honor’ that the poor of Naples were infinitely more wretched than the very poorest of London. But of this, his persistent and exhaustive work, we have already spoken in the Nation, where also have appeared extracts from his many pamphlets on social questions. What marks out Villari from his colleagues who started in the race is that he remains alone to do battle for the unhappy millions who cannot help themselves. Once it was the proud vaunt of the Liberals that they had initiated a series of social remedies, but, with the death of Bertani, of Saffi, and their fellow-workers, nothing has been done, no- thing attempted for their benefit, and, therefore, it is no wonder if the entire working population and now numbers of
Page 17
Dec. 7, 1899] The | Nat ion . the peasants have enrolled themselves un- der the banners of the Socialists—the Col- lectivists, as they style themselves—who succeed in persuading them that, if they will but fill the city and provincial councils with their members, and send them to the national Parliament, very soon the face of the country will be socially transformed and general prosperity and plenty prevail. That Villari does not subscribe to this be- lief goes without saying. What he insists on is, that things are going from bad to worse, and that the old dilemma repeats it- self, ‘‘Reform or revolution.’”’ He has but just returned from his inspection of the Simplon excavation, and we shall soon have the result of his observations. Even as we write comes the last number of the Nuova Antologia, with the first of a series of his articles, entitled ‘‘New Problems,’’ where we find such sentences as, “A corrupt Italy has no right to existence.” ‘The truth is, that, after the first heroic enthusiasm fad- ed away, the North, which for so long gov- erned Italy, lost its faith in the force of justice and virtue, and failed in courage to do its duty at any cost. Had it not so failed it would have moralized both North and South, and promoted the true welfare of the whole country.” Then, recurring to the sad old theme, he continues: “Every time that I return to Naples, I think of the hundred millions of lire des- tined for the amelioration of the city from a sanitary point of view, and above and be- fore all for the housing of the poor. And when I look at the Rettifilo (the quarter of Naples built on the site of the old slums), with its new, lofty, sumptuous palaces, and then turn my eyes downwards to the right and left, and see the old filth, the old cor- ruption; when I remember that numbers of the old hovels were pulled down without a single habitation being built for the really poorest, as has been proved over and ovet again; when I see how those utterly des- titute are worse off than ever, because they have been compelled to huddle together in ever-increasing numbers in the hovels that have been left still standing; when I think of the depredations committed and the mon- ey wasted, it seems to me that many of the people driving by in their carriages ought to be sent to the galleys.” J. W. M. HUGO’S “THINGS SEEN.”—II. PaRIs, November 6, 1899. The sentiments which Victor Hugo first entertained towards Louis Napoleon were far from hostile. The President showed him many attentions, of which he was sensible. Still, he said as early as February, 1849: “With the best intentions in the world and a certain very visible measure of in- telligence and aptitude, I am afraid Louis Bonaparte will succumb beneath his task. For him, France, the century, the new spirit, the instincts proper to the soil and to the time, are so many sealed books. He views without comprehending the agita- tions of the human mind, Paris, events, men, things, ideas. He belongs to that ignorant class called princes, and to that category of foreigners who are called emigrants. To those who examine him carefully, he has the air of a patient rather than of a gov- ernor. He has nothing of the Bonaparte either in his face or in his manner; he probably does not belong to them. People remember the easy ways of Queen Hor- tense.”’ On the 5th of December, 1850, Jerome Bo- naparte met Hugo at the French Theatre, at a representation of “Adrienne Lecou- vreur,”’ and complained bitterly to him of his nephew. ‘Louis is mad,’ said he. “He has no confidence in his friends, and gives | 4A25 himself up to his family. He distrusts his femily, and allows himself to be garroted by the old royalist parties. I was better received, after my return to France, by Louis Philippe at the Tuileries than I am now at the EBlysée by my nephew.” And so the old King of Westphalia went on, telling Victor Hugo that the presidency of the Republic had first been offered to him- self by Fould, in the name of Thiers, Molé, Berryer, and Marshal Bugeaud. Molé, ac- cording to Fould, considered Louis a mere idiot. Thiers saw in him (Jerome) a figure- head; he alone could succeed and beat Ca- vaignac. He had refused, saying that he was an invalid, Louis was young. Now, Louis had forgotten all this, and would not see his cousin Napoleon, who had taken up his defence. After having thus reproached the President, ‘the King of Westphalia paused a moment and then said: ‘And do you know, Monsieur Victor Hugo, what he answered me?’ ‘You will see.” Nobody can see inside that man.” This curious passage reminded me of an answer Louis Napoleon, then Emperor, is said to have made once to his cousin Napoleon, who had a violent tem- per, and who incessantly visited him with demands and reproaches: ‘“‘You have no- thing, nothing of Napoleon.” “I beg your pardon, I have his family.” : Victor Hugo has interesting portraits dis- tributed here and there in his ‘Choses Vues.’ To begin with the court of Louis Philippe, where he was so often received as a Peer of France, he says of the Duchess of Or- leans: “She is a rare woman, of great mind and great sense. I do not believe that she is completely appreciated at the Tuileries. The King, however, holds her in high esteem and often converses very particularly with her. He often gives her his arm in the evening to take her from the family draw- ing-room to her apartment.” The Duchess, speaking to Victor Hugo of her son, the Count de Paris (February 26, 1844), said to him: “My son is not what you call an amiable child. He is not one of those pretty lit- tle prodigies who do honor to their mo- ther, and of whom one says, How witty! what grace! He has a good heart, I know; he has some wit, I believe; but nobody knows it and believes it except myself. He is timid, shy, silent, easily put out. What will he be? I don’t know. Often, at his age, a child in his position understands that he ought to please, and begins, small as he is, to play a part. My child hides himself in my gown and looks down. Such as he is, I love him, and I even prefer him. I prefer a savage to a comedian.” The Count de Paris remained always of a grave and mild nature; his timidity di- minished with age, without ever completely disappearing. He had a certain depth of thought and sentiment which was inherited from his mother. Victor Hugo tells amus- ing stories about the princes, especially about the Prince de Joinville, who was, in his youth, very boyish. ‘‘What annoys most these poor princes is to receive people and to speak to them ceremoniously. This obli- gation recurs nearly every day. They call it—for there is a language of princes—do- ing the function. The Duke de Montpensier is the only one who always does it with grace. One day the Duchess d'Orléans ask- ed him why; he answered: ‘It amuses me.’ He is twenty years old [1847].’" The Prince de Joinville was very early affected with deafness. “He loves France and all that touches her. As he cannot speak at his ease, he becomes concentrated at times ahd bitter. However, he spoke more than once, and worthily. They did not listen to him or hear him. He asked me once: ‘What are they saying about me? It is they who are deaf.’”’ ‘“‘The Prince has not, like the late lamented Duc 4’Orléans, the princely coquetry which is such a victorious grace He likes to please individuals."’ This is a very just remark on the part of Victor Hu go, as there never was any banality in the Prince de Joinville. The judgments which Victor Hugo passed on the statesmen whom he knew are gene rally very severe. Royer-Collard seems to have inspired him with a respect he did not often feel. There is an interesting con- versation with him reported verbatim (1843) Royer-Collard was a Legitimist; he had played a very great and honorabie part in the Chambers of the Restoration, and did not serve the Government of July. “ ‘But, sir,’ said Victor Hugo to him, ‘there was in the Revolution of July a foun- dation of right which you could not deny: you were not among those who could pro test against it.’ ‘Neither did I,’ answered Royer-Collard. ‘I do not blame those who acted differently from me. Each man has his conscience, and in political matters there are many ways of being honest. Peo- ple have the honesty which results from the light there is in them.’ After a moment of silence, Royer-Collardadded: ‘Well! Charles X. also was honest. He was an honest king, and, whatever may have been said, he fell only by his own fault. Historians may arrange this as they like, but it is so It was Charles X. who upset Charles X. People have said that he was badly ad- vised. They have pretended that he con- sulted the Cardinal de la Fare, M. de Latil, M. de Polignac. . . . Would to heaven he had done so. All those who sur- rounded the King, those who were called the courtiers, were wiser than he.’ And, after a moment of silence, he added, with the sad smile which he often wore during this conversation: ‘Wiser—that is to say, less mad.’ ”’ It was the belief of Royer-Collard that Charles X. never really took advice. He was the same man in his old age that he was as Count d’Artois. The only quality which he praised in a man was immutability. He said often that since the Revolution there had been but two men, M. de La Fayette and himself. He esteemed La Fayette. Royer- Collard knew the King well, as he had al- ways been a royalist. The King saw him from time to time, and always showed him much courtesy and kindness. It was Royer- Collard who had to take to the King the address of the Chamber which preceded the Revolution of 1830. ‘I might say,’’ he said, “that on that day I read the Revolution in his eyes."” The King read the answer which he had already prepared. He manifested no anger. The answer had been carefully word- ed and several times modified; but the King had made up his mind, and, three months af- terwards, appeared the famous Ordinances which caused the Revolution. In the chambers in which he sat-—the House of Peers, the National Assembly of 1848—Victor Hugo amused himself by mak- ing sketches of his most important col- leagues. These sketches sometimes border on caricatures, but are generally very true to life. He describes very well Odilon Bar- rot, the solemn and ponderous orator; M. Dufaure, with his provincial and nasal ac- cent, ‘a mind so clear that it becomes at times luminous, a slow and cold eloquence, but sure, solid, and calmly push- ing difficulties aside. M. Dufaure ‘ ; i f
Page 18
The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1797 is an honest and grave man, who has held power without greatness, . . . who has figured at the tribune without glamour, but with authority.’’ Gen. Changarnier “has the look of an old academician, as Marshal Soult has the look of an old archbishop. . . . He has a long and dry body, a soft speech, a gracious and artificial air, a wig like Pas- quier’s, and a smile like Brifaut’s. Withal, he is a determined man, bold, expeditious, but two-faced and dark.’’ His portrait of Thiers is interesting: “M. Thiers will treat men, ideas, and re- volutionary events with parliamentary rou- tine. He plays his old game of constitution- al distinctions in the presence of an abyss and of the terrible uprisings of the chime- rical and unexpected. He does. not understand the transformation of every- thing; he sees some resemblance between the times in which we are and the times when he governed, and that is enough for him. These resemblances in fact exist, but there is something colossal and monstrous mixed up with them. M. Thiers does not suspect it and goes his way. He has spent bis life in caressing cats and taming them with all sorts of feline manners. Now he wants to continue, and he does not perceive that the beasts have grown enormously, and that what he has now about him are tigers. A singular spectacle, this little man trying to caress with his little hand the roaring head of a revolution.” This was written after 1848; perhaps Hugo would have written a little differently in 1871, after the Commune. The portrait ends with these severe lines: ‘I have always felt for this celebrated statesman, this eminent orator, this mediocre writer, this narrow and small heart, an indescribable sentiment of admiration, aversion, and contempt.” There is a charming conversation between Victor Hugo and Béranger, in November, 1847. Béranger compliments Hugo on being able to dominate his popularity; he is him- self the slave of his own popularity. ‘“‘What a slavery! You know, their reform banquets [it was the time of the agitation for electoral reform] bore me to death. I make excuses, so as not to go: ‘I am old, I have a poor digestion, I don’t dine out any more, I cannot travel,’ etc. ‘You owe it to us! A man like you must give us this pledge,’ etc. And I must put on a good face, and smile. You know, it is simply the life of the old court buffoon. To amuse the Prince, to amuse the people, is the same thing. What difference is there be- tween the poet who follows the court and the poet who follows the crowd? Marot in the sixteenth century, Béranger in the nine- teenth century. I hate popularity.”’ While talking thus, they arrived at the Rue Mazarine, at the door of the Institute, where Hugo was going. It was Academy day. ‘'‘Are you going in?’ said Hugo. ‘Oh, no, not that. That is for you,’ and he went rapidly away.” The account which Victor Hugo gives of his last visit to the dying Balzac is very graphic and touching; but ‘Choses Vues’ is full of such fragments and impressions, scattered in the two volumes in a curious disorder. The vistas which Hugo opens here and there on the theatrical world are not the least interesting: he takes us behind the and shows us Mademoiselle Mars (who first played the part of Dofia Sol. in ‘“Hernani’), Rachel, Mademoiselle Georges, in their real life, away from the stage. The volume which has just appeared ends with a long list of all the people with whom Hugo came in contact, high and low, great and small. scenes, “ft have sometimes had in my hand the white and gloved hand which is above and the large black hand whiclr is below, and I ' Kansas, have recognized that there is but one man. After all this passed before me, I perceived that Humanity has a synonymous word, Equality, and that there is under heaven one thing only before which we ought to bow, namely, genius; and one thing before which we ought to kneel, namely, goodness."’ Correspondence. A PROPHECY RECALLED. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: You may recollect how, in February of this year, I objected to your remark that Mr. McKinley was doing this or that to catch ‘‘delegates,’’ upon the ground that his nomination in 1900 was already a foregone conclusion; and my additional remark that his reélection was also certain, because the Democrats could not get rid of either Bryan or of free silver. As to the nomination of the two old candidates I suppose there is now no doubt in anybody’s mind, and there should be just as littleof McKinley’s success. It is idle to speculate about the meaning of the vote for Nash, Jones, and McLean in Ohio, for there is the rest of the Republi- can ticket, below the Governor, which won, if by a small, yet by a substantive, majority. Whatever opposition to the President’s poli- cy in the Phflippines has been developed must collapse when the war is ended, as it substantially is now; for the American loss in blood and treasure was the main ground of that opposition, not the wrong done to the Filipinos. The Democrats have reco- vered only one of the McKinley States of 1896, namely, Maryland, and that only by putting up three pronounced gold-standard men as their candidates, among them the (to the Bryan crowd) unspeakable Isidore Rayner. On national issues Maryland is still good for a Republican majority of thirty taousand. Kentucky may fall into the Bry- an column; but the twenty-one electors of South Dakota, Wyoming, and Washington are a good set-off. Times are flush; that means success to the party in power. As I said in February, all questions before the American people should be weighed and discussed in the light of McKinley’s cer- tainty of success next November, as far as there can be any certainty in political events eleven months off. Respectfully, LovIsvILLE, Ky., December 8, 1899. L. N. D. WHY CALLED CECUMENICAL? To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Early in the summer each member of the American Board’s European Turkey Mis- sion received a circular letter addressing him as “Dear Friend,’ and inviting him to attend the ‘“‘Gicumenical Conference on For- eign Missions,"’ to be held in New York next April. The mission was also urged to make a good showing in the Missionary Exhibit, and one of its members was appointed to take the responsibility of preparing its con- tribution thereto. But, a few days ago, this member receiv- ed the following communication, dated Sep- tember 2: “Since writing you requesting codperation in connection with the Missionary Exhibit, I learn that the General Committee of the Conference have decided that work done in Europe is not to be represented at the com- ing Conference, either on the platform or in the Missionary Exhibit. Hence I will not trouble you to aid us as formerly re- quested.” The foregoing implies that members of the European Turkey Mission will have the same standing in the Conference as citizens of New York or Boston—who are not Sec- retaries of Mission Boards. Aside from the obvious inference that European Turkey is as highly Christianized as the respected communities mentioned, it will be interest- ing to trace out some other logical results of the General Committee’s decision. Aside from its other work, the European Turkey Mission is trying to do something for Albania, the country along the east shore of the Adriatic. This is one of the wildest and most uncivilized countries in the world. It can hardly be said to have a lite- rature, while it is practically impossible to- day to obtain permission from the Govern- ment to print Albanian books. The first school for girls ever conducted in the Albanian vernacular was opened by our mission, while the only boys’ school in the same vernacular (opened by the people because of having our school be- hind which to hide it) has just been closed by the Governor-General of the district. Were I a Japanese, a Hindu, or a Chinese, it would give me “de dry grins’’ to have my nation rated behind the Albanians in educa- tion, where the managers of the Conference seem to place it. Again, I am confident that the gentlemen of the General Committee would travel much more safely through almost any part of China, Japan, or Zululand than they would through the heart of Albania. Recently I was speaking of bicycles with a wealthy Al- banian. Said he: “What good would a bi- cycle do me? I couldn’t ride it with my rifle on my shoulder and one hand on my revolver!’’ He added that on arriving at Monastir—the terminus of the railway—he should telegraph to his home at El Bassan, and a band of fifteen armed retainers would come out on the road two days’ journey to meet and escort him home. The great na- tural abilities of the Albanians, failing of development in legitimate channels, find vent in feuds, lawlessness, and bloodshed. Two days since, a friend mentioned a good- sized Albanian city which he said no foreign consul has ever visited, because none could go there without a guard of from seventy to one hundred soldiers. Is there any such city in Japan? Why, then, should the more civilized country be represented in the Con- ference as a mission field, and the less civilized country shut out? Because the latter, forsooth, is in Europe! The reductio ad absurdum of the Commit- tee’s position appears in Constantinople. The American College for Girls may be rep- resented in the conference because it is in Asia, while Robert College may not because it is in Europe. A missionary to the Arme- nians in Scutari has a standing in the Con- ference, while one to the Armenians of old Stambul has not. Dr. Greene, if present, may speak of the work which he does on the Asiatic side, but must not mention that which he does in Pera! The dictionaries define “a@cumenical” as “general, universal, pertaining to the habita- ble world.” May one venture to ask, then, in what sense the coming Conference will be @cumenical? Says the circular: “The Sec- retaries extend a cordial invitation to all
Page 19
Dec. 7, 1899] The Nation. 427 the Protestant missionaries to unevangelized | peoples. ern churches are not included, and the Con- ference will not be ecumenical in the sense of embracing all who bear the name of Christians. Naturally, one would conclude, then, that the intention is to make it Pro- testantly cecumenical. But no, the Pro- testant missions to the unevangelized peo- ples of European Turkey, Bulgaria, Austria, Spain, etc., are ruled out. This is bewil- dering to the plain man who has been ac- customed to accept as authoritative the de- finitions of the leading dictionaries, and Evidently the Roman and East- | | posed to record tribal settlements. 1889 Mr. W. H. Stevenson, in reviewing Prof Earle’s work, went much further: *Kemble’s gd delusion,” he ** natu- tally brings to mind another of his extrava- gances—the list of local names in -ing sup- He was Says, | well aware that this suffix had other mean- ings besides the patronymic, but this did not suggest to him any caution. Prof. Earle has done good service by pointing out in his notes that -ing is sometimes merely the equivalent of the genitive singular. It has | in some cases merely a possessive signifi- e ' makes him wonder whether the managers | of the Conference have not lost the jewel consistency down some knot-hole. It is not hard to find a reason for the Committee’s decision to exclude all work done in Europe. It would be highly incon- gruous to have represented as mission-fields stanch Protestant countries like Denmark and Sweden, by admitting to the Conference those who are engaged in persuading the people of such countries to leave the Luthe- ran or other Protestant churches for the Methodist, Baptist, etc. But even the Chi- nese long since discovered that it is not ne- pig. The object could easily have been at- tained by ruling out of the Conference all work done in communities commonly known as Protestant. This would have been con- sistent, and would have made the Confer- ence cecumenical as touches the Protestant world. The members of the General Committee are intelligent men who understand the use of words. Honesty requires of them either to make their Conference ecumenical in the widest and real sense by inviting the Ro- man and Greek churches to participate, or to make it ecumenical in the sense of embracing all Protestant missions in non-Protestant lands, or to drop the high-sounding misnomer which they have selected for the proposed gathering. Is it necessary to crown all the shams of the cen- tury with a sham-ccumenical conference on foreign missions? Very respectfully yours, EDWARD B. HASKELL, Missionary of the American Board. SaLONICA, EUROPEAN TURKEY, October 11, 1899. THE -ING SUFFIX IN ENGLISH PLACE- NAMES. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: In your review of Round’s ‘Commune of London’ a statement is made which needs a slight modification. The reviewer says: “In all the discussion which has raged around the English ‘village community’ and manor, no doubt has ever been cast on the assertion of Kemble that -ing in English place-names had a ‘patronymic’ signifi- cance.”’ From this the reader would infer that, up to the present time, scholars have not hesi- tated ‘‘to deduce a clan settlement’ from every -ing suffix and to accept without ques- tion Kemble’s lists. This is far from true. Prof. Earle, in his ‘Land Charters and Saxonic Documents,’ page 454, called atten- tion eleven years ago to the fact that the patronymic use of -ing was only one special application of a form that differed little in its original sense from a genitive case. In cation even where used in the genitive plural form -inga, whilst in other cases it is merely a pet or diminutive suffix to a personal name.’ (English Historical Review, April, 1889, p. 356.) Your reviewer is doubtless quite aware of this expression of doubt, but I do not think that the average reader would infer it from his words. The truth is that no student of this subject to-day pretends to accept all Kemble’s place-names as representing clan or kin settlements. I do not understand that Mr. Round has more than eliminate from the lists a large number of names which mean something else. The important point is, that he has still left many genuine -ings, and this fact is sufficient, even without done | other evidence, to warrant the assumption cessary to burn down your hut to roast your | ! that in the main the land was settled by communities. has had a theory on the subject, has, how- to plenty of room for war-bands, and chieftains, and individual allotments. Prof. Maitland expressed him- self very cautiously, but conclusively, when he said two years ago, in ‘Domesday Book Beyond,’ “Originally, the men who settle down in a village likely to be kinsmen. Some phrases in the Continental folk laws, and some perhaps of our English place-names, point in this (p. 349). What Mr. Round has discovered will not modify this opinion. We are in this, as in so many other par- ticulars, greatly indebted to Mr. Round for reaching a more hitherto there has been only doubt; but the point upon which I wou'd lay stress is, that the doubt has existed before. Your reviewer has given, it may be, that slight twist to his comment and quotation which has made his statements to the unini- tiated not a little misleading. CHARLES M. ANDREWS. Bryn Mawr CoLueae, December 2, 1899. No one in recent years, who ever, failed leave and are direction” certain conclusion where unconsciously GOETHE TRANSLATIONS. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir’ Prof. Kuno Francke of Harvard, in his interesting article in the November Atlantic upon ‘‘Goethe’s Message to Ame- rica,”’ quotes Goethe’s poem, “Bins und Alles,” and adds, in a footnote: “So far as I know, this wonderful poem has never been translated into English; and it seems indeed untranslatable.” In that important early work, “Specimens of Foreign Standard Lite- rature, edited by George Ripley, the third volume was entitled ‘Select Minor Poems, translated from the German of Goethe and Schiller. With Notes by John 8S. Dwight’ (Boston. 1829). This book contains ten of the most striking poems from the rubric “Gott und Welt,” and includes the above poem. They were ali translated by John 8. Dwight except “Dauer im Wechsel,” which was rendered by N. L. Frothingham, and “Urworte: Orphisch,” by James Freeman Clarke. The translation seems to me made | with rare | teeler, felicity foundly significant of Goethe's view o ture, and shows the influences sophy of both Schelling an him. The entire volume of these early transla- tions is of great interest, and of the philo- d Spinoza upon contains con- tributions, in addition to those above men tioned, by George Bancroft, William H Channing, Frederic H. Hedge, S. M. Fuller, G. W. Haven, Charles T. Brooks, and C. P Cranch. A monograph upon the relation of New England thought to German literature and philosophy at this period would be of great value. Wweeus CORNELL UNtversiry, December 2, HEWETT isvu BEGET IN ELIZABETHAN ENGLISH TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Mr. Sidney Lee, in his recently pub- lished biography of Shakspere, discusses in appendix v., p. 390, the relation of Thomas Thorpe and “W. H.” to the first edition of Shakspere’s Sonnets. He recapitulates in substance a theory that has long been held by careful Shakspere scholars in regard to the identity of the mysterious “W. H.,.” along with some fresh and interesting de- tails about Thomas Thorpe’s publishing ca reer. He explains Thorpe's use of the word ‘begetter’’ in the phrase, ‘the onlie beget- ter of the ensuing sonnets,” as being due to a habit of grandiloquence which led the publisher to use the word with an artificial of “obtain,’’ “acquire,’’ though says later that the word is not unfrequentiy employed in Elizabethan English in this at- tenuated sense (it really the word), and adds a quotation from Dekker’s ‘“‘Satiro-Mastix.”’ If the read- er will turn to the words beget and begetter in the New English Dictionary, he that though this meaning of quire”’ sense he is original sense of the will see “obtain,” “ac- is there set down for the words, the illustrative quotations are not entirely con- vincing. Shakspere’s temperance,”’ “acquire and beget a in “Hamlet,’’ ILI., tii., 8, would point to the fact that beget had some dif- ferent meaning from that of the acquire al- ready used probably ferred to some efiect which the actor was to produce on his audience. The other quo- tations are even less convincing; the last one under beyelter, from the Pali Mall Ga- zette, dDeing obviously a mere imitation of the Shaksperian quotation. But the assump- tion that Thorpe did not use the word “in an exact sense’’ to explain the relation in which “W. H."’ stood to the Sonnets is en- tirely unnecessary, for the quotations given by the New English Dictionary confuse two distinct usages of this word beget in Eliza- bethan English. First, as to begetter=“obtainer,” “‘pro- curer.”"” In Sewel's ‘Dutch and English Dictionary’ (I quote from the second edi- tion, Amsterdam, 1708), p. 41 of the first part, we have beget glossed not only by teelen, voortbrengen, but also by gewinnen, verkrygen (verkrygen in the second part ts Silossed “obtain,” “get,” “acquire,” and ge- winnen is there glossed ‘gain,’ ‘‘get’’); getter is glossed not only by cen Teeler, aan- toorttecler, but also by which is the sense Thorpe used it in. Simi- larly, begetting is glossed verkryging. He begot is glossed hy gewaan (i. ¢., he acquir- ed), and begotten is glossed by gewonnen (ac- quired) and werkreegen (obtained). In ‘Skinner’s ‘Etymologicon Lingu# An- by Hamlet, and re- be - verkryger,
Page 20
The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1797 glicanz,’ 1671, after beget stands the gloss In the Cambridge ‘Phraseologia Generalis’ (1681) we have “beget or pro- glossed parere, parare. These re- ferences show clearly, coming, as they do, from independent sources, that beget and hegetter in the seventeenth century were commonly used in the sense of ‘acquire,’ “obtain,” “procure.’’ Thorpe, therefore, in the phrase “onlie begetter’’ is using a na- tural and ordinary form of expression, and not a figurative or stilted one. Beget has another shade of meaning which has not, I think, been sharply defined by the New English Dictionary. The Cam- bridge Phrase Book, just cited, has a number of quotations to illustrate beget in the sense of conciliare. These will throw light on some of the theological quotations in the Dictionery, and aptly explain Hamlet’s usage of the word as well as our modern usage of it in the idiom ‘“‘to beget confidence.’’ In the Phrase-Book we have: “To beget, procure, or make friendship; conciliare amicitiam; to beget or procure men’s favour, and good obtimere. cure”’ liking to ones self, conciliare sibi animos hominum ; to beget or procure credit, favour, etc., to himself, conciliare fidem, gratiam, &c., sibi ; to beget or procure peace amongst any, conciliare pacem inter aliquos; to beget or procure sleep, rest, &c., conciliare somnum, quietem, &e."’ Reading this conciliare meaning into Ham- ict’s advice to the players, we have a deeper and more far-reaching principle of dramatic art than that the usual interpretation of gives us: “Wrest the in- your passion into a _ selif- control that will win over your audience share your power, and thus give the strength of your acting smoothness— the ease of strong power.” MaRK H. LIDDELL. UNIVERSITY OF Texas, November 25, 1899. words of his tensity to Notes. ‘Sir Walter Scott,’ a new biography, by James Hay, is in the press of A. S. Barnes & Co. &. P. Dutton & Co. will publish immedi- ately ‘Lewis Carroll and the Real Alice in Wonderland,’ personal reminiscences by Miss Isa Bowman. Eider & Shepard, San Francisco, announce for this week ‘Moods, and Other Verses,’ by Dr. Edward Robinson Taylor, translator of the Sonnets of Hérédia. We learn that Siebert’s ‘Underground Railroad from Slavery to Freedom’ (Mac- millan) has already reached a second edi- tion. Resuming our notice of reprints, we have to tell of John H. Ingram's edition of Poe's Works in four volumes (London: Black; New York: Macmillan), now brought out as a “Standard Edition.’ The books are beautifully printed and well adapted for the hand, and the blue cloth binding’ is tastefully stamped. Mr. Ingram’s prefa- tory memoir is still open to animadversion, especially since the publication of the Griswold Letters; but no one need ask for a better presentation of the writings them- selves, quite apart from the very moderate price. From the same cis-Atlantic house we have Mr. Marion Crawford's ‘Sgracinesca,’ in two volumes of elegant typography, with illustrations by Mr. Orson Lowell, in which the novelist must be deemed equally for- tunate. Both the wash and the pen-draw- ings are skilful and decorative, and much thought has evidently gone into them. Mr. Crawford, in a new preface, tells us that the exclusive world of ‘Saracinesca’ has been already invaded by the march of mo- dern ideas and events, and has mingled with the majority, so that he is inclined to re- commend his pages as much for the history as for the human interest contained in them. The Siddal Edition of Dante G. Ros- setti’s works, charming little volumes, pro- ceeds with his early and late product, the translation of Dante’s ‘New Life,’ of which the verse is a standing test of Rossetti’s theory of translation, as it more than once involves the rendering of the simple by the obscure (London: Ellis & Elvey). As usual, his brother furnishes a _ prefatory note, and a graceful frontispiece is from the brush of Arthur Bilis. Herbert Cole sup- plies the pretext for another issue of ‘Gul- liver’s Travels’ (John Lane), and is to be praised for the general quality of his de- signs; but, as is often witnessed in the case of pen-and-ink draughtsmen, his smaller drawings—vignettes, head and tail-pieces— are much superior to the larger, in which, strange to say, he often omits the scale (e. g., in depicting individual Lilliputians). As a whole, however, Mr. Cole has kept his embellishments in harmony with the old- style typography, and the result is a very pretty book. Harmonious, tco, are the adornments of the luxurious edition of Mr. Hamilton W. Mabie’s ‘My Study Fire’ (Dodd, Mead & Co.); but here, to our think- ing, the two ladies, Maude Alice and Gene- vieve Cowles, who designed them have suc- ceeded better in the larger series—charac- ter sketches, interior groups, landscapes. They are all praiseworthy, however. and can but be acceptable to Mr. Mabie’s admirers. Miss Larned’s ‘Historic Gleanings in Windham County, Conn.’ (Providence, R. L: Preston & Rounds Co.) is, as might have been expected of the historian of that coun- ty, a substantial addition to knowledge. If the characters here celebrated are minor and subordinate, one at least, Major James Fitch, cut no inconsiderable swath in his day, and, somewhat as an equal, engaged the attention of the colonial Legislatures of both Connecticut and Massachusetts. The Rev. Joseph Howe, another well-forgotten name, made his mark in college instruction and in pulpit eloquence, and his too brief career is deservedly remembered. The chapter, “A Life’s Record,” is a notice- ably artistic handling of a typical Connect- icut Yankee diary, 1777-1843. Miss Lar- ned’s humor is at its best in this case, and has easy play by virtue of her famillarity with the annals and the genealogy of her especial province. A neighboring antiquarian, Mr. John Os- borne Austin of Providence, author of the remarkable ‘Genealogical Dictionary of Rhode Island,’ puts forth, in a volume of “modest dimensions, ‘The Journal of William Jefferay, Gentleman’ (Providence: The Author). This is an original and really in- genious imagining of “a diary that migkt have been,”’ based on the materials at hand in the Dictionary Just named. The diarist is an actual personage, whose gravestone may be seen in the old cemetery at Newport, and he is depicted to the life by Mr. Aus- tin, both individually and as a part of the (chiefly Rhode Island) community, from 1623 to 1675. Some of the entries are purely ge- nealogical, others convey the leading his- torical incidents of the colony, as may be seen in the index under the rubric ‘‘Massa- chusetts oppressions’’; for variety’s sake, some excursions by land and water ce in- vented, and the food, the occupations, and manners and customs of the people are shown in a natural fashion. The stories told at the Seven Club are the least ef- fective of Mr. Austin’s diversions. His ex- periment is much to be commended. ‘Personal Reminiscences of the Anti-Sla- very and Other Reforms and Reformers,’ by the late Aaron M. Powell (Plainfield, N. J.: Anna Rice Powell) is an unfinished fragment of autobiography, whose chief in- terest lies in the simple story of the au- thor’s enlistment in the abolition cause. He took the field as a lecture agent in 1854; had his share of being mobbed, notably at Syracuse in January, 1861, a ticklish period for the abolitionists everywhere; was pre- sent at the hoisting of the flag over Fort Sumter in April, 1865. On the division of the abolitionists in that year over a con- tinuance of the organization, he sided with Wendell Phillips and the pros, and was made editor of the Anti-Slavery Standard. His subsequent reformatory labors were mainly in behalf of temperance; but pri- sons and peace and social purity also large- ly occupied him, and drew him many times across the Atlantic as delegate to con- gresses. His reminiscences add but lit- tle to our knowledge of his eminent coadjutors. He reports the mild-mannered Stephen Foster, who had a genius for get- ting into hot water, as contending “that he really had very small combativeness, but that what he had was very active.” After hearing Gladstone, John Bright, John Morley, and Lord Rosebery speak, Mr. Powell still gave the palm for oratory to Mr. Phillips. Lucretia Mott, at her hos- pitable board, he shows, during the pe- riod of the dessert, relieving her maids by drying with her own hands the plates of the earlier courses which had been re- moved and washed; ‘‘meanwhile bearing her full share with her guests in the most engaging table-talk.’’ Numerous portraits and facsimiles further make this volume a useful contribution to anti-slavery litera- ture, as well as a memorial of a most excel- lent man. ‘Famous Actresses of the Day in Ame- rica’ (Boston: L. C. Page & Co.), a series of sketches by Lewis C. Strang, differs from the general run of books of the cha- racter in being well written, but resembles them in being prepared chiefly for the- atrical consumption. The biographical part of it, apparently, has been compiled with considerable care, and has been verified, it is said, in many cases by reference to the subjects themselves; but the critical opinions, both those which are original and those which are culled from various sources, are, in the vast majority of cases, far too complimentary to inspire confidence. It will be surprising to most persons familiar with the present condition of the stage to hear that no less than thirty-one of our actresses are “famous.” The defi- ciency in the sense of proportion which per- mitted the use of this word in the title, is apparent in almost all the notices. The fact is, that Mr. Strang has ascribed fame to almost every actress who has ever had
Page 21
Dec 7, 1899] The Nat ion. her name printed in large letters upon a theatrical poster, and to some others of whose very existence the average New York playgoer is probably still in ignor- ance. That he has been able to quote glow- ing eulegies about all of them is a melan- choly demonstration of the true value of current journalistic criticism. Some of the praise is “‘craftily qualified,’’ as Cassio says, with adverse comment, but not sufficient- ly so to destroy the pleasant flavor of adulation. As to the proportion observ- ed, it may be stated that more space is devoted to Mrs. Fiske than to Ada Rehan or Helena Modjeska. The book, however, is agreeable in style, and is illustrated plenti- fully with attractive photographs. The second volume of the publications of the Alabama Historical Society (Carrollton, Ala.) is one more evidence of an awakening of historical studies in the South. Mono- graphs on the early roads, on the begin- nings of public education, and on war in- cidents are interesting, but the most valua- ble parts of the volume are the statistical tables, prepared by the secretary of the Society, Mr. Thomas M. Owen. Among these are a list of the sessions of the Gene- ral Assembly, statistics of each county, and bibliographical notes at the end of each ar- ticle. Tatum’s topographical notes on the Alabama River, made in 1814, are also of high interest, and are now published for the first time. Mr. T. A. Coghlan, the well-known statis- tician of New South Wales, has prepared a monograph on child-birth in that colony. While much of it merely confirms the ex- perience of other countries, there is estab-, lished an actual decline in the birth-rate within the last twenty years. In a new community this is not the rule,-and Mr. Coghlan sees important effects for the colo- ny. “Taking Australia as a whole, and in- cluding New Zealand, the fall in the birth- rate is such that there are 47,000 births less than would have occurred under the rates prevailing as late as ten years ago.”’ New Zealand complains that there are not enough children to fill the schools, and the same condition is to be found in Victoria, as the number of children under ten years of age is less than in 1891. The law for- mulated by Galton, on material supplied by Korési, governing the number of parents to whom children wil] be born during a year after marriage, is disproved by the Aus- tralian statistics. It is possible that Mr. Coghlan’s conclusions may be modified by fuller statistics, covering a longer period of time, but he has made a very sugges- tive study of the material at his command. The essay is issued through the Government Printer at Sydney. The returns of the foreign trade of the United Kingdom for 1898 have been publish- ed, and the form of five years’ figures has been retained by Mr. Pittar. This makes it possible to see at a glance the changes in quantity or direction of trade in any one article, and makes the volume a veri- table encyclopedia of the world’s commerce. Another feature may be noted, viz., that these figures have never been under sus- picion, as the Board of Trade has not for a half-century been manipulated in favor of any commercial theory or political policy. We wish we could say as much for our Treasury Bureau of Statistics. The expedition of Mr. H. J. Mackinder of Oxford to Mount Kenya, in East Africa, adds materially to our knowledge of this interesting region. It consisted of six Eu- ropeans, including two Alpine guides, a na- tural-history collector, and % taxidermist, and its scientific results are a large num- ber of observations on the topography of the region, the discovery of ten new glaciers (making fifteen in all), large and representative collections of the fauna and flora, as well as geological specimens. In an interview recorded in the London Times the leader describes the Meranga country through which he passed as an “informal republic. There are no chiefs or kings, and the government is in the hands of a Shauri, or council of elders, of whom there are about fifty. Two or three of the elders are recognized as_ leaders. Practically the whole country was under cultivation. There were large banana plantations on all the shambas, and hundreds of acres were under maize, while sweet potatoes, beans, and sugar-cane grew in abundance. The roads were good, and in some places were actually fenced, wearing in places the aspect of an English country lane, with the addition of tropical plants and flowers.” The present accessibility of the interior of East Africa is illustrated by the fact that the expedition left England on June 8, and the return journey, after the successful as- cent of the mountain, was begun on Sep- tember 21, and Mr. Mackinder was in Lon- don on October 30, twenty-eight days after reaching the Uganda railway. Macmillan Company will issue on January 1 a new magazine, the International Monthly, the first number containing articles by Edouard Rod, Prof. N. S. Shaler, Prof. J. T Trowbridge, Norman Hapgood, and Charles de Kay. The Century Magazine promises copious extracts from the entire journal of Dr. O’Meara at St. Helena, only partly drawn upon for his account of Napoleon in cap- tivity. The Paris Temps, referring to a recent important auction sale in Munich, finds new proof of the growing prosperity of Germany in the flourishing condition of the market for works of art in that country. The sale in question is that of the private collection of the late Dr. Martin Schubart, consisting of valuable paintings and various other rare objects of art. (We called attention to this interesting collection in a note of August 4, 1898, little expecting that it would so soon be brought under the auctioneer’s hammer.) From the Miinchener Neueste Nachrichten we learn that one of the finest canvases. Hobbema’s ‘‘Water Mill,” was bought for the Dresden Gallery for 86,000 marks, while Ru- bens’s “Diana Bathing’’ was knocked down to J. Béhler of Munich for 126,000 marks, Metsu’s ‘“‘Lady and Gentleman at the Spinet” and Gerard Douw’s ‘‘Housekeeper’’ to Sedelmayer of Paris at 45,000 and 37,000 marks, respectively, and Rembrandt’s ‘‘Por- trait of an Old Man” to Celnaghi of Lon- don at 31,000 marks; the latter also buying two portraits by Amberger (of Augsburg) for 51,000 marks. More than fifty collectors, dealers, and directors of galleries from with*® out having been attracted by the auction, the bidding was lively throughout the sale. But the majority of buyers were Germans, and the 7'emps accounts for the good prices obtained, even for second and third-rate ob- jects, by the increasing number, in Germany, of amateurs of moderate means, a class not existing in France, 429 —The growth of patriotic societies in this country is shown by the portentous size of the Year-Book of the Sons of the Revolu- tion in New York, a quarto volume of near- ly 700 pages. Composed as it is of lists of members, and of ancestors and descendants, the general impression left ts one of self- glorification. The claims for consideration are often so slight as to be grotesque. and the wish to make much out of little and magnify the services of all whom acci dent involved in the Revolution is too ma- nifest to be pleasant. Some short and ra ther perfunctory biographies are given as samples of an intended series, but they make indifferent reading, and are neither his- tory nor biography. Why do not the Sons aid the Historical Society to publish the Revo lutionary manuscripts deposited in its store? That would be serviceable, and would re duce some of the pretensions loudly made. In reading over the long list of pri- vates and non-commissioned officers mep tioned in the Year-Book, some names are found owners did not figure creditably in the service. The punishment of 500 lashes or less, and dismissal from the army, were frequently given to offenders Then, too, how few really know about their ancestors. Read Washington's opinions of his general officers, and bear in mind that he was cool and just in his judgments. There were many fine characters and reputations in the army, but to claim preéminence for all is carrying the matter to an extreme. 80 whose very —Of like description is the report of the Daughters of the American Revolution, 1890-97, printed at Government expense, and containing many illustrations of plates and monuments raised by the Society. It was a bit of favoritism which saddled the print- ing of these reports on the country, and the Daughters are not backward in advertising their claims to recognition. To preserve interesting buildings is laudable, and pri- vate effort can do this better than the Gov- ernment of a State or of the nation. The old redoubt at Fort Pitt was certainly worth preserving, and the monument to Mary Washington was a fitting expression of the regard for historic characters. Lesser events and places are commemorated by tablets placed on houses or sunk in stones. And in placing these, the different societies have shown little discrimination. The very profusion is bewildering, and every house and rock of any age or weight promises to have a tablet. Nor is this the only form of activity. Prizes are offered for historical essays; pilgrimages are made to historic spots. “Each chapter possesses a gavel made of some historic material. Almost all have their charters framed in woods con- nected with some famous event. Many have made the exhibition of historic heirlooms a specially instructive part of their work,’’ and so on. The old-time historian, who verified his facts, will be overwhelmed with the mass of legend, tradition, and curios ga- thered by the Daughters, and it will be dif- ficult to sift what is offered. The Daugh- ters and Sons cannot do better than to fol- low the excellent example set by the Co- lonial Dames, who are raising the best of mementos by publishing the Letters to Washington written during the colonial period. —Prof. William MacDonald's ‘Select Char- ters and Other Documents Illustrative of American History’ (Macmillan) seems to take its title from the Bishop of Oxford's
Page 22
430 The Wation. | Vol. 69, No. 1797 celebrated collection of English constitu- tional documents. American history, of course, affords ample material for a volume similar in scope to that of Dr. Stubbs, al- though his handbook ends at the beginning of the thirteenth century. Among points of difference between Prof. MacDonald’s man- ner of editing and that which his predeces- sor pursued, the following ones may be mentioned. Prof. MacDonald writes no ge- neral introduction, his prefaces are briefer than those which Stubbs supplied, and in connection with each passage he gives a paragraph of bibliographical references. The period covered is 1606-1775, the series begin- ning with the first charter of Virginia and ending with the Prohibitory Act. One would expect to find in such a book as this many pieces taken from the seventeenth century, when all the most important colonies gained constitutional status, and so it is. For the period which lies before the peace of Rys- wick, Prof. MacDonald is much more detail- ed than for the years 1697-1768. He gives eighty documents in all, and of these only eight are allotted to the sixty-six years which we have last indicated. ‘Indeed, he almost scampers from the Peace of Ryswick to the end of the Seven Years’ War. With the Peace of Paris he again becomes detail- and traces distinctly each principal] atage of the rupture between the colonies and the mother country. Twenty-six docu- ments relating to the last twelve years of the colonial era do not, however, constitute an undue proportion when one considers the interests at stake. Prof. MacDonald shows good judgment in his selections, and his book should materially assist the teaching of American history in colleges which are unfortunate enough to lack large libraries, More than this, it will be a great conve- nience everywhere. ed, ~Historians and heralds have long puz- zied over the meaning of FERT, the motto of the House of Savoy. When Amadeus VI., the Green Count, founded the Order of the Most Holy Annunciation, in 1362, he gave this motto to it, and the mysterious word still appears, separating pairs of true-lov- er’s knots, on the collar of that order. We say ‘‘word,”’ but as the form F. BH. R. T. was early used, it came to be taken for granted that the four letters were the ini- tials of four words. Accordingly, various phrases have been suggested. Jortitudo Ljius Rhodum Tenuit (His fortitude held Khodes) had many upholders; but when it was discovered that the defence of Rhodes against the Turks by Amadeus V. occurred in 1315, whereas the motto is found on the tomb of Thomas I., who died in 1233, they were silenced. Of another guess, l'e- dere Et Retigione Tenemur (We are bound by covenant and religion), which appears as the legend of a comparatively late coin, we may remark that it seems too evidently an attempt to invent a phrase whose initials should compose the required word. Mrappez, Entrez, Rompez Tout, a version popular in describes the bold methods of the Counts in acquiring new possessions, but is neither philologically nor historically possi- ble. During the middle of this century, when Italy was struggling for her indepen- dence, patriots gave the motto a prophetic significance by assuming that the letters stood for Fiat Emanuel Rea Tuus. Such are some of the more or less fanciful solutions. Now we learn from the Milan Perseveranza of November 3 that Count Massimino di Savoy, Ceva has published a monograph in which he reads the riddle in a new fashion. It was not uncommon, he says, for the first word of a well-known line or sentence to serve as the motto of a noble house: FE egi, for example, is so used, instead of the whole phrase, Exegi Monumentum Aere Perennius. With this clue, let us seek a line in which FERT is the keyword. Know- ing that Virgil was the most quoted author in medieval times, we turn to the ‘Avneid,’ and quickly come on the passage: ‘‘Talibus orabat, talisque miserrima fletus FERTque refertque soror: sed nullis ille movetur Fletibus, aut voces ullas tractabilis au- dit’’ (iv., 437-439). —This is ingenious, but ingenuity should go on and show, if it could, how this quo- tation applies to a Count of Savoy of the thirteenth century, or earlier. What has the description of Dido’s sister, carrying again and again to stony-hearted A®neas the story of Dido’s woe, what has this to do with Count Thomas or his predecessors? We are told that other families—the French Bussay, the Spanish Agreda—have this very motto, and that a Spanish town has it; but we fail to see that these facts are conclusive. Neither is the further state- ment that, for the marriage of Charles Emanuel I. with Catherine of Spain, in 1590, a medal was struck, on which appears the longer quotation, FERTQUE RE- FERTQUE. We do not feel, therefore, that Count di Ceva’s solution is ‘final. We. be- lieve, rather, that in these matters the sim- plest interpretation is the likeliest; and that it is more probable that a warrior no- ble of 1230 chose FERT for its common meaning, ‘“‘He bears’ or ‘‘He endures’’—a soldierly motto—than for any intricate allu- sion bound up in it. In any case, it is in- teresting that the oldest reigning House in Europe should have forgotten for six cen- turies what its watchword means—a strik- ing instance of the way in which tradition may be interrupted. —The seventh volume of the ‘“Ver- sailles Historical Series’’ (Boston: Hardy, Pratt & Co.) consists of selections from the correspondence of the Princess Pa- latine, the Duchess of Burgundy, and Mme. de Maintenon, arranged and trans- lated by the editor. Very judicious care is shown in the choice of extracts, for the purpose of presenting to their readers the salient traits of character and disposi- tion in these three contemporaries of ex- alted birth or station, and likewise of il- lustrating the points discussed in Sainte- Beuve’s prefatory essays to each division. The portraits thus offer an interesting and piquant contrast. Madame, Princess Pala- tine, and mother of the Regent, appears in these pages perfectly undisguised, out- spoken even to violence in her expression of private hatred and race prejudice, and, per- haps because of this very arrogance of her rank, better fitted to receive the adulation of a Resideng than to play a strictly subordi- nate part in the throng of a splendid court. And yet it is amusing to note, in spite of this pride, the bourgeois element of her early training in her lifelong sighings after the somewhat substantial dishes of her na- tive land, with corresponding contempt for the flimsy achievements of French cooks. The frankness ‘of her speech, amounting in some cases to positive coarseness, is en- tirely in keeping with this materiality of bodily habit, and is faithfully rendered by the translator. In the letters of the Duchess of Burgundy, little more can be found than the natural affection of a girl for her parents, with the flutterings of a very charming social butterfly. As for Mme. de Maintenon’s correspondence, the speci- mens here given deal chiefly with her edu- cational work at Saint Cyr, her private let- ters being for the most part restricted in this instance to a few confidential communi- cations with Mme. de Glapion and the Prin- cesse des Ursins, the latter of whom was evidently a cherished kindred spirit. The tone of imperious patronage which forms the running accompaniment of these epis- tles helps to explain the persistent, ran-— corous hatred expressed by the German Princess Palatine for the parvenue morga- natic spouse of Louis XIV. If it was the editor’s object to emphasize Mme. de Maintenon’s love of domination, ill-con- cealed under her constant exhortations to modesty, that: object has been completely attained. It must be added that through- out this volume Miss Wormeley’s transla- tions are both minutely accurate and freer from Gallicisms than in the preceding vol- umes of the series. RHODES’S UNITED STATES. History of the United States from the Com- promise of 1850. By James Ford Rhodes. Vol. IV., 1862-1864. Harper & Brothers. 8vo, pp. xv, 557, with maps. The two and a half years from the spring of 1862 to the reélection of Lincoln in the autumn of 1864 measure the agonizing pe- riod of the civil war, when the belligerents were straining their strength to the ut- most, and when other nations, watching the stubborn struggle, might be pardoned if their forecast of the result was in accord- ance with their interests and sympathies. The wrestlers often seemed to be in dead- lock, with little apparent change of posi- tion or of chance, each stiffened into iron and grimly waiting for some indication of the other’s exhaustion. The weeks and months passed in a monotony of indecisive military campaigns, and an equal monotony of legislative and executive activity in sup- plying the waste of war in blood and in treasure. Foreign policy was, on the one hand, a strenuous effort by the Davis Gov- ernment to induce England and France to intervene, and on the other Mr. Lincoin's wise diplomacy to ward off or postpone such intervention. Everybody was waiting in painful suspense for some evidence of: deci- sive superiority in the field which should be a basis of intelligent judgment as to the end. This painful and troubled period Mr. Rhodes treats in his fourth volume, and as we are now familiar with his method of re- constructing each critical situation from a broad array of contemporaneous testimony, we find ourselves following with unflagging interest his strong synthesis of current facts, actions, and opinions, which make vivid the actual life of the time. We breathe the atmosphere of the period itself, and share the doubts, the fears, and the deep solicitude of the actors in it. We realize how hard it was to foresee consequences, and at how great a risk every decision of responsible leaders had to be made. We are charitable towards their ‘doubts and their hesitation, and admire the faith and
Page 23
Dec. 7, 1899] The Nation. 431 courage that inspired their patient, un- flinching efforts. The historian so well pre- serves his own balance of judicial calmness, and his full knowledge of all the facts which should temper and modify our judgment is so well at his command, that we easily yield to his interpretation of events even against our own predilections. Our con- sciousness of this effect upon ourselves goes far to make us believe that we have here something very near to what time will prove to be the accepted story of the na- tion’s great struggle for self-preservation. As everything turned upon military suc- cess, the campaigns of McClellan and Hal- leck, of Pope, Burnside, and Buell, of Meade, Rosecrans, and Grant, occupy us most, until the victories of Vicksburg and Missionary Ridge had developed a general-in-chief to whom the Administration and the country could commit the leadership of our armies, with a confident trust that there would be unresting activity and a steady progress towards a final triumph. When the period of experiment with generals not equal to the gigantic task is over, the historian feels that he may broaden his sketch of mili- tary affairs and give them much less space in the narrative. ; An excellent analysis of the Peninsular campaign justifies Mr. Rhodes’s conclusion that it ‘“‘was a failure, and the chief cause of its failure may be ascribed to McClellan,”’ who was proved to be ‘‘not equal to the po- sition of Commander-in-Chief” (p. 49). Hal- leck’s reputation for military knowledge and his successes in the West made him the na- tural, almost the inevitable, choice of the Administration for the general command. It was soon discovered, however, that he lacked the combative energy necessary to the command in the field, and he subsided into the position of Chief-of-Staff to the President and made it a bureau office in Washington. The recall of the Army of the Potomac from Harrison’s Landing on the James was ordered unwillingly, and Mr. Rhodes fairly states the case in saying that ‘‘the decision was a choice of evils made on the side of safety, a natural result of the balancing of chances, in which the poor promise of the future of McClellan’s failures in the past outweighed the many disadvantages of his withdrawal” (p. 104). The vexed question of the removal of McClellan from command Mr. Rhodes finds hard of solution, but sums up its consideration by saying, ‘“‘It is not su:prising that he was relieved, but it is no less true that his removal was a mistake”’ (p. 188). It is almost impossible in such a case to avoid a judgment after the fact, and full weight is not given, perhaps, to the actual opinion of the ablest patriots then in public life. The judgment supported by the common assent of Mr. Lincoln, his Cabi- net, the ablest Governors of States, and the leading Union men in the Senate and House of Representatives, cannot justly be said to be so contrary to sound reasons which were then within their reach that one may now affirm that they ought to have known bet- ter. The question was not whether McClel- lan could keep his army from destruction or rout after defeat, or maintain a cautious defence. The Union could not be restored in that way. The whole of McClellan's ca- reer made the authorities conclude that the cause would not triumph by his military leadership. To continue him in command was to give it up, and if it were to be given | , to try a change, and keep trying till the fit | tract, and the up, the sooner the better, and less costly. They concluded that the only other way was leader was found. If they ought to have known that Burnside was unfit by reason of his lack of self-confidence, and Hooker by reason of his excess of it, why ought they not to have known McClellan’s deficien- cies also before he was tried? We are coustantly brought back to the simple truth which all military history teaches, that for the highest qualities of generalship there is absolutely no sure test except actual trial in the field. Mr. Lincoln had to do what all other rulers have done, to take the most promising of subordinate rank for the chief place. His frank admission that he did so with great fears that the successors would not do better (which Mr. Rhodes quotes, p. 189), did not absolve him from acting, but Was a necessary condition of action. And here, in the larger sense, the event proved him right, for the time and the man came at last. Our author does justice to Mr. Lincoln's diligent study of the problem before him with the aid of theoretic books on the mili- tary art and of practical discussion with his military advisers. Such study, to his wonderfully clear intellect and practical sa- gacity, was so profitable that already, in the spring of 1863, he was “now the best of counsellors in the relation of the civil commander-in-chief to his officers of tech- nical training and experience” (p. 271). The point was reached where officers in the field could feel that the President's judgment of their work was soundly critical and appre- ciative as well as discriminating. The pro- cess of selection went on more rapidly and surely. The capture of Vicksburg and the victory of Gettysburg marked the end of the period of doubt and the beginning of that rational hope, ripening into confidence, which was to grow into assurance in an- other year. In the conduct of our foreign affairs dur- ing the critical period, the attitude of Eng- land was what gave most concern, and this was not because England was most dis- posed to be unfriendly, for she was not. France, already committed to the enterprise of establishing a monarchy in Mexico on the ruins of Juarez’s republic, knew well that a humiliating retreat could be prevent- ed only by the permanent disruption of our Union. Louis Napoleon was therefore the instigator of all hostile movements, con- stantly repeating his desire to intervene decisively in our conflict whenever England would consent to join him. This was so well understood that our State Department did not waste much effort in argument with the French Emperor. Seeing clearly that the true way to restrain France was to dis- suade England from yielding to Napoleon's seductions, the diplomatic campaign was fought out in London with rare ability by Mr. Adams. It was a curious result of this, that the chafing with the more friendly of the two Powers was the more painful and irritating, because the more active contro- versy went on with her. Even in the matter of the Confederate cruisers, the controversy over their build- ing and fitting out was with England in- stead of France, though England was less willing to permit their construction. France offered much greater encouragement and even active coéperation. But French ship- yards could not compete with the English | in the rapid and efficient construction of | such ships, and so the Lairds took the con- burden of maintaining the neutrality laws was upon the English Min- istry. Mr. Rhodes has had the very great ad- vantage of access to Mr. Adams's MS. diary, and has thus been able to trace th: ourse of the English Government and the ebb and flow of English sentiment with a clearness and fulness which would have beer posai ble without the use of so important an original document. This helps him to fix the exact date and the circumstances in which some of the most significant of Earl Russell's dispatches were written, and to throw a bright light upon the motives of the English Secretary and his colleagues He has found it a grateful task to unravel the intricacies of a correspondence in which letters crossed each other on the way, and took thus a tinge of meaning which did not properly belong to them. We can go gladly and heartily with him when, in summing up the evidence, he reaches the conclusion “that Russell deserves applause for his methodical straightforwardness and his honest purpose in this affair [of the iron- clad rams], where action was hedged about with difficulties, owing to the evasion of the true ownership and to the force of the prece- dent made by the narrow and doubtful con- struction of the in the of the Alexandra’ (p. The escape of the Alabama had shown that something more than a leisurely and per- functory enforcement of the neutrality laws was necessary if Great Britain was to escape responsibility for statute 381). case the destruction of Ame- rican commerce, and Lord Russell was deep- ly chagrined at the evident lack of carnest- ness in the action of the law officers and others in that His seizure of the rams was in spite of the sympathies of sub- ordinates and their wilful blindness to evi- case. dence. It was a vigorous assumption of responsibility on his part, all the more worthy of remembrance because Palmerston, the Prime Minister, was so open in his sympathy with the Confede- rate Government that he would have con- tinued to shut his eyes to the peril in which he was putting the relations of the two countries. By the summer of 1864, however, all the English officials saw new light, and we had no more cause to complain of the inefficiency of their statutes. Mr. Rhodes’s judicial quality is well shown in his remind- er that a modern nation is the corporate constituency which elects its Legislature and practically chooses its Ministry. The enlargement of the franchise in England since our civil war has brought into politi- cal control classes other than those which governed the state in the sixties, and while those who then gave shape to English policy were hostile to our national cause, the new yoters were almost unanimously friendly to us and now give the tone to British policy and governmental conduct. wide “Tf there still remain an American Jingo who wishes to retaliate, when the bided time comes, for the depredations of the Confederate cruisers, the cynical ill-will of Palmerston, the speech of Gladstone, the leaders in the Times and the Saturday Re- view, he must remember that the England which arouses his indignation has passed away” (p. 260). Our home politics depended, of course, upon the questions involved in the conduct of the war. The acknowledgment of the
Page 24
432 The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1797 independence of the Confederacy could not be made an open issue between parties, and the opposition was ostensibly based on criticism of the measures of the Administra- tion. Within the Union party the most radical seemed to lead, and in the middle of his term Mr. Lincoln appeared to be almost without hearty support. It is a curi- ous fact that among Congressmen, especially, there was no ability to see the practical wis- dom and solid abilities which lay behind his awkward form and manners, and personal contempt for him may be said to have been the ruling fashion in Washington. His pa- pers and public letters, full of shrewdest judgment and most taking argument, would seem to have been read by the people at large, but not by their representatives. Mr. Rhodes brings out the courage and the con- servatism of his policy, his delays that were never timid but only a calculated waiting for the fit time to come, his refusal to allow his hand to be forced in the matter of emancipation, and his action at last in accordance with a deliberately fixed purpose. His methods of dealing with men were also peculiarly his own, whether he were dealing with Greeley as assumed spokesman for “twenty millions,’’ or with Pendleton’s com- mittee protesting against Vallandigham’s trial. He was very patient with his military officers so long as they kept persistently at work, and was unwearied in giving them the means of success. Inaction he deeply felt was certain ruin, and this he could not tole- rate. Yet he did not supersede a dilatory general till he had given him fair warning and had tested his capacity for energetic initiative. The steadily growing activity of our armies was good proof of the advantage and the necessity for the unfaltering activity he asked of them, and the attendant suc- cesses completed the demonstration. The results were so far seen in 1864 that oppo- sition to his renomination melted away, and the strength of his hold on the hearts of the people was such that even the names of Chase, Wade, and Davis proved vain to conjure with. He was reélected by an al- most unanimous Electoral College, and by a popular vote large encugh, as Mr. Rhodes reminds us, to give in Congress ‘the re- quisite majority of two-thirds for the con- amendment abolishing slavery” stitutional (po. 5388). On the vexed question of arbitrary arrests and the suspension of newspapers, our au- thor takes strong ground, going so far in summing up as to conclude “‘that all of this extra-judicial procedure was inexpedient, unnecessary, and wrong; that the offenders should have been prosecuted according to law, or, if their offences were not indict- able, permitted to go free’’ (p. 234). Few thoughtful people will now deny that the power of arrest under the suspension of the habeas corpus was abused, while many will probably hesitate to go the whole length of giving the executive in a time of civil war no discretion in seizing and holding persons suspected of being spies or agents of the enemy, or otherwise actively engaged in giving him “ald and comfort.’’ The mat- ter was complicated by the fact that in some communities, such as Baltimore or Washington itself, ordinary juries would certainly contain some sympathizers with the rebellion who would prevent conviction, no matter how clear the evidence. It was also unfortunately true that, in similar communities, courts could not be relied upon to administer the law, and inferior judges were in some instances cynically daring in the protection of bounty-jumpers and deserters. The constitutional provision for the suspension of habeas corpus in time of insurrection is itself the clearest re- cognition of the existence of conditions un- der which exceptional powers must be exer- cised if the government is to be preserved. All nations in all times have seen this, and no stronger reason for sedulously avoiding war can be found than the persistent truth of the old maxim, Silent leges inter arma. The ‘Records regarding Prisoners of War,’ etc., now coming from the Government printing-house, will give the means of a scientific study of this subject which has before been almost impossible. The act re- garding suspension of habeas corpus of 1862 did not attempt to deprive the Executive of exceptional powers in this respect; it only provided means for securing reason- ably prompt action or the release of sus- pected persons. Of it Mr. Rhodes says that, “had it been strictly observed, no lasting hardship, nothing but transient injustice, would henceforward have been done’’ (p. 236); and we may add that, in peace as well as in war, it will always be true that the administration of justice will involve tran- sient injustice to persons accused on rea- sonable suspicion who may yet be finally acquitted. When the war was over, the Su- preme Court in the Milligan case declared void his trial by a military commission for organizing an armed insurrection in Indiana in aid of the rebellion; but we cannot forget that, while the war was flagrant, the same court refused to apply the same doctrine to Vallandigham’s case. In holding to the stronger doctrine of limitation of executive war-powers, Mr. Rhodes touches neatly the real reason why the loyal people of the country sustained the President in his action and were not disturbed by the cry of usurpation: “That he had assumed unwarranted pow- ers might be true; but that he had done this with regret, that he was no Cesar or Napo- leon, and sought no self-aggrandizement, that he had in his own loyal and unselfish nature a check to the excessive use of ab- solute power, was then almost as clear to his friends and opponents as it is now to the student of his character and acts” (p. 171). The period covered by this volume was one in which the natural expression of the people’s prayer was, ‘‘Out of the depths have I cried unto thee!”’ In the rest of the work the historian will have the more cheerful task of telling the story of the reéstablishment of the Union, to the won- der and admiration of the world. But even in this sober-tinted narrative, Mr. Rhodes has sometimes brightened his pages with quotations from the classics and from the poets, the aptness of which has the en- livening effect of wit. The definite clear- ness of judgment and the right-minded fair- ness of criticism shown in each chapter sup- port our earlier judgment that the whole book will be a trustworthy guide and a friendly companion in our study of the time, as indispensable to those whose ca- nons of political Judgments may differ from the author’s as to those who fully accord with him, petnre nanennareerens RECENT BOOKS ON MUSIC. The National Music of America, and Its Sources. By Louis C. Elson. Boston: L. C. Page & Co. Famous Violinists of To-day and Yesterday. By Henry C. Lahee. Boston: L. C. Page & Co. A Guide to the Opera. By Esther Singleton. Dodd, Mead & Co. The Standard Opera-Glass. By Charles An- nesley. Brentanos. Stars of the Opera. By Mabel Wagnalls. Funk & Wagnalls. Faworite Songs and Hymns. Edited by J. P. McCaskey. Harpers. The Academic Hymnal. G. Schirmer. Unlike most European countries, white America has no genuine folk-songs—melo- dies that seem to grow up spontaneously like wild flowers, belonging to no one in particular. The nearest approach to real folk music is found in the songs of Stephen Foster, who was not uninfluenced by the music of the negroes as heard at camp- meetings and elsewhere. Under these cir- cumstances one feels surprised, on first opening Mr. Elson’s book, to find that he has succeeded in writing more than three hun- dred pages on his chosen subject. The first three of his chapters are, however, devoted to Puritans, Pilgrims, and psalm-singers, and the fourth discourses at considerable length and with many interesting details on European national songs. Nearly thirty pages are devoted to “Yankee Doodle’ and the various theories of its origin.. Mr. Elson quotes Richard Grant White’s assertion that this tune ‘‘cam scarcely be regarded as be- ing properly music,” but fails to add his own condemnation of it, which is to be re- gretted. It is true that, as he says, the “patriot” cares very little for the musician who tells him that the air which pleases him is very trashy music. “It represents the land he loves, and that is enough. Many a man thinks he is being thrilled by music when he is really being moved by memories.”’ Herein lies the philosophy of the subject; it is our misfortune that most of our “‘pa- triotic memories’ should be bound up with such rubbish—imported rubbish, too. ‘The Star-Spangled Banner” alone is worthy of the honor bestowed on it, and that seems to have been originally an English drinking song. If Mr. Elson has not cleared up all the problems relating to our national music, it is not because of a lack of judgment or industry. His book, -which is written in his usual entertaining style, free from pedantry and posing, will be welcomed by thousands who seek information heretofore scattered in hundreds of places. Of books on violinists and violins there are many, yet none of them is as up-to-date as Mr Lahee’s, which combines history and biography in a chatty way, and does not en- cumber its pages with pedantic piles of use- less knowledge about players of whom no- thing but the name remains, and in whom no one is any longer interested. Among the great violinists there have been some—like Paganini and Ole Bull—whose life affords many elements of romance, and whose story will be written many times more, Mr. Lahee has also a chapter on famous quartets. Per- haps the most useful section of his book is that on women as violinists, which brings us up to those two gifted players, Miss Maud Powell and Miss Leonora Jackson, of whom the latter is to make her début in her native America in a few weeks. Another class of books for which the de-
Page 25
Dec. 7, 1899] The Nation. 4338 mand must be great, judging by the supply, is guides to the opera. Esther Singleton is very much mistaken when she declares in her preface that theré is no work that exactly covers her field. There are at least two—Upton’s ‘Standard Operas’ and ‘The Standard Opera-Glass,’ by Charles Annes- ley—which cover that field more satisfac- torily than her book does. The last-named contains the plots of 123 operas, while the ‘Guide to the Opera’ has only 29. . These, no doubt, are well chosen, except in the case of Donizetti’s ‘Don Pasquale,’ which is no longer in the current repertory any- where. But the author of the ‘Guide’ has not the gift of condensing a libretto into an entertaining story, and her comments are often crude and useless. It helps no one to an understanding of an opera to be told that in a certain place a minor chord is “preceded by a chord of the diminished seventh in F minor’; that in another place “the strings give us pearly shakes in the lower parts; flute, oboe, clarionet, and bas- soon sounding the upper part’; or that “the flutes reveal the erdour of Tristan.” The portraits of thirteen famous operatic artists adorn the volume. The fact that Annesley’s ‘Standard Opera- Glass’ has reached its fifteenth edition in- dicates its utility. The present edition, which bears the imprint of Brentano, is not so convenient as its predecessors for slipping in the overcoat pocket, yet it is not too large to be taken along, and it has, what the others lacked, a “‘prelude’” by Mr. James G. Huneker, who discourses inte- | restingly on the vitality of operas and other topics. What gives additional value to this volume is the brief historic remarks which precede the tersely told story of each opera. It is the best book of its kind. Opera appeals to all sorts of persons, from those who go to study the interweav- ings of leading motives to those who sim- ply take pleasure in hearing popular works and seeing famous singers. The latter class will find entertainment in ‘The Stars of the Opera,’ by Mabel Wagnalls, who, by the way, was introduced to a New York audi- ence as a pianist at a Theodore Thomas concert. There is no food for thought or historic information in her volume, but sim- ply gossip; which gossip, to be sure, will be utilized by future biographers of great singers. The table of contents tells the whole story: An interview with Marcella Sembrich; “Semiramide”’; a call on Emma Eames; “Faust”; ‘Werther’; ‘“Calvé and ‘Carmen’’’; “Carmen”; “Hamlet”; a talk with Lillian Nordica; “Lohengrin”; ‘Aida’; “The Huguenots”; an hour with Lilli Leh- mann; ‘Melba, the Australian Nightingale,” etc. There are also seventeen portraits, mostly in costume. In ‘Favorite Songs and Hymns,’ Mr. Mc- Caskey has brought between two covers 450 songs and hymns, the best of which had ap- peared previously in the eight volumes of the ‘Franklin Square Song Collection,’ while others are new. The selections are, on the whole, judicious, and there is no lack of variety, from Balfe and Foster to Verdi and Rubinstein. The ‘Academic Hymnal’ is intended specially for use in college chapels, being a collection of hymns and chants with tunes harmonized for men’s voices and in unison, whereas the harmoniza- tions in the hymnals generally used in col- lege chapels are for mixed voices, and therefore useless for men’s voices. Eight well-known American musicians aided the compiler. RECENT COMPILATIONS OF POETRY. The London Spectator has lately declared that “serious study of the great English poets” is “far more general” in America than in England. There is this year, in this country, an unusual harvest of books of selected poetry; but the only one of these which justifies the Spectator’s remark is ‘A Book of Seventeenth Century Lyrics,’ selected and edited with an introducion by Prof. Felix E. Schelling of the University of Pennsylvania, aided, as he says, by those two high authorities, Dr. Horace Howard Furness and Professor Kittredge of Har- vard. It forms one of the Athenw#um Press Series (Boston: Ginn & Co.), and in all re- spects—selection, editorship, commentary, and annotation—it comes very near perfec- tion. If it errs on the side of limitation in regard to its notes, this is surely on the right side, since our books of selections, for schools especially, grow more and more minute and even elementary in this respect. Perhaps this is not the defect of Mr. Henry S. Pancoast’s ‘Standard English Poems’ (Holt), but there is a marked ele- ment of commonplace in its criticism and sometimes of inflation in the phrases em- ployed, as where he speaks of “‘the tremen- dous vogue”’ (p. 696) of Byron,and describes Wordsworth’s life as “‘idyllically peaceful.” It is curious, too, to find him (p. 729) treat- ing Browning as still holding a question- able position in English verse, and still more curious to find him construing his range, “Spenser to Tennyson,” so as to in- clude, alone of living authors, Rudyard Kip- ling. Less critically pretentious, but selected and arranged with very uncommon felicity, is ‘The Listening Child: A Selection from the Stores of English Verse, Made for the Youngest Readers and Hearers,’ by Lucy W. Thacher (Macmillan). It contains many poems not commonly to be found in books intended for children, and in this shows unmistakable indications of a mo- ther’s experience, since the poems which give most delight to imaginative children are apt to be those supposed by their pro- saic elders to be a little too old for their comprehension. ‘The Kings’ Lyrics’ (Russell), selected and arranged by FitzRoy Carrington, con- tains lyrics of James the First and Charles the First, together with Drayton’s “Ballad of Agincourt.” This is a charming little book to the eye, enriched by many por- traits of poets. The necessary omissions are discreetly made, here and there, and it would be difficult to find a prettier present for a young person of poetic taste. The only criticism to be justly made on it is that modern spelling has been adopted in part of the extracts, but not in all; and this discrimination seems not quite justified. Mr. Howard 8. Ruddy’s ‘Book Lovers’ Verse; being Songs of Books and Bookmen Compiled from English and American Au- thors’ is perhaps the fullest collection of this kind, yet inspires, like its predeces- sors in the same line, but a languid inte- rest. ‘The Best Short Poems of the Nineteenth Century,’ compiled by William 8. Lord (Chi- cago: Revell), is a rather dingily printed little book, put together on what strikes us as being a very poor plan. “Two hundred representative literary people” were recent- ly asked for a list of twenty-five of the best short poems (limited to fifty lines) written in the English language in the nineteenth century. The twenty-five poems receiving the highest number of votes are here print- ed in the order of the ballots received, namely: Holmes’s “Chambered Nautilus,” Tennyson's “Bugle Song” and “Crossing the Bar,” Mrs. Howe’s ‘“Battle-Hymn,”’ Browning's “‘Lost Leader,” Keats's “Chap- man’s Homer” and “Grecian Urn,” Words- worth’s “Phantom of Delight” and “The World Is Too Much with Us,” Mrs. Brown- ing’s “‘A Musical Instrument,” Bourdillon's “Light,” Bryant’s “To a Water-Fowl,” and so on. There would doubtless be a certain interest in such a list, even were the vote taken among any chance roomful of intelli- gent persons; but the fatal defect of the ballot as described in this book is, that the “representative literary people’ have abso- lutely no vouchers except in the judgment of Mr. William 8. Lord himself, whose name is new to us and is not to be found even in that refuge of literary hospitality, ‘Who's Who in America.’ We intend no disrespect to him in pointing out that we cannot tell whether his literary jury included the best- known authors of the country or only his immediate acquaintances. The list of twen- ty-five leading poems selected would indi- cate an intelligent body of jurymen; yet when we take into view not merely these chosen winners, but also the supplementary list of poems suggested ty the various judges, that fell short of success in the com- petition, the result is not quite so satisfac- tory; since these certainly indicate a great deal of commonplace material. On the whole, it is a disappointment to find our- selves called upon, first to receive the ver- dict from the jury, and then to judge of the jury only by its verdict. ‘For Love’s Sweet Sake: Selected Poems of Love in all Moods’ (Boston: Lee & She- pard) is edited by Mr. G. Hembert Westley, and has some of the very worst faults that such a collection can have. There is, as frequently happens, a mixture of the choice and commonplace, but the evil is especially enhanced by taking many poems to pieces and printing only a verse, or a line or two, here and there. We doubt the right even of publishers to give the short poems of Longfellow, for instance, to be cut into bits and served up in fragments, as happens to his “Endymion,” of which about half is printed (p. 51) under the name, “How Love Comes.” In one case (on page 39) three lines are taken from Tennyson’s ‘Fa- tima’” and published without any acknow- ledgment, as a part of a poem by some anonymous author. The illustrations of the book have the same second-rate quality which marks its literary structure. The Eapansion of Western Ideale and the World's Peace. By Charles Waldstein. John Lane. 1899. The New Pacific. By Hubert Howe Ban- croft. New York: The Bancroft Com- pany. 1900. The right of conquest is in modern times defended in various ways. For some the good old rule sufficeth—that they should take who have the power and they should keep who can. The consciences of others are too queasy to accept this simple piaa, ee ae
Page 26
434 The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1797 and much casuistry has been recently em- ployed in explaining the propriety of doing evil that good may come, and how the end justifies the means. The task is, at this stage of the development of ethics, not without difficulty, and it seems logically indispensable to apply some rules of mo- rality different from those commonly ac- cepted. This Mr. Waldstein has attempted to do. He has, perhaps unwittingly, gone back to Aristotle, who made his system of ethics apply to the Greeks, the Barbarians being excluded. According to Mr. Wald- stein, the “English-speaking nations’’—he rejects the term Anglo-Saxon for good and sufficient reasons—occupy the position as- signed by Aristotle to the Greeks, and taken later by the Romans and the Turks. As Aristotle held that Barbarians were slaves by nature, so Mr. Waldstein thinks that dark-colored people are intended to be subjects of the white races, or such of them as speak the English language. This discrimination between the whites is justified by the imaginary confessions of the most virtuous of the Germans, Rus- sians, French, Spanish, and Italians. These worthy people, if they were quite frank, would say what they at heart believe, that the cause of civilization would be furthered more by the expansion of the English- speaking peoples than “by that of Russia or any other of the Continental nations or grouping of these.” In fact, “‘a conscien- tious Russian” has stated this to Mr. Wald- stein, and several of the distinguished men with whom he is intimate have at least implied it. It only remains to convince the English-speaking peoples of their own superiority to the rest of the world and the responsibilities which it involves. Mr. Waldstein is pained to find that many worthy people in this country cling to the- ories of equal rights and impartial justice which blind them to the virtues attendant on the use of the English language. These misguided persons are condescendingly as- sured by Mr. Waldstein that it is disloyal for them to “counteract the success of American arms’’ in such a war as is now carried on by the Government. They are told that they are guilty of “nefarious abuse” of the term self-government when they say that the Filipinos should have it. Those who maintain that we ought to cor- rect the abuses with which our political eystem reeks, are informed that ‘inquiries into local corruption tend ultimately to de- base rather than to elevate the national conscience.” And finally the administra- tion of colonies is to purify and elevate the politicians; for the spirit which: moved the “yellow journalists” to call the Ameri- cans to arms against Spain “gave a new lease of life to the national morality of the American people.” It is a relief to turn from this Pecksniff- jan theory of national ethics to Mr. Ban- croft'’s frank avowal of what the ‘“Expan- sion of Western Ideals” really means. We shall let him state at some length the prin- ciples on which conquest is justified: “It has come to be a doctrine of orthodox civilization that it is right, humane, and just ‘or a people of culture and nominally good morals to take in hand the affairs of any weaker people of low intelligence occu- pying lands which the stronger nation would like to possess; that in law and equity it is not proper for savage or half- savage races to take up the room on this earth which can better be filled by better people, and that therefore any nation strong enough at once to conquer the weak- er nation, and at the same time hold at bay or mollify its covetous compeers, may honorably seize upon and Oversee, manage, manipulate, and govern the persons, prop- erty, and country of another whenever a plausible pretext can be found for so doing. As it is the destiny of all savage peoples to give place to civilization, so these half or wholly savage islanders must be content to have their affairs managed by those strong- er and more intelligent than they. Thus we see the importance to us and to civilization of the tropical islands which have recently fallen to us, and which with wise manage- ment and proper care will become useful and profitable.” It would be interesting to inquire what the results to human society would be if individuals as well as nations were to act on these principles of morality. We all know people much inferior to ourselves who do not improve their opportunities, and whose possessions would be much better ad- ministered by us than by them. That, how- ever, is an inquiry which is not pursued by the defenders of conquest, for reasons which are obvious. Concerning Mr. Bancroft’s work, we need only add that it is of pro- digious bulk, and that the most of it is too diffuse to be readable. There are some speculations concerning the future deve- lopment of the Pacific States and their trade with the East which are occasionally suggestive. A few chapters about notable voyages, celebrated pirates, etc., furnish padding, which, in view of the size of the book, might have been dispensed with. Nor do we understand why a long account of the recent war should be thought necessary in treating of the ‘‘New Pacific.” Scotland’s Ruined Abbeys. By Howard Cros- by Butler, A.M., sometime Lecturer on Architecture in Princeton University, and Fellow of the American School of Classical Studies in Rome. With Illustrations by the Author. Macmillan. 1899. This volume is the production of an enthu- siast who is also a sincere and diligent stu- dent. Its shortcomings, then, are naturally of two kinds only—first, limitation, because research in the way of using the spade and of careful comparison of what excavation reveals is a thing almost unknown in Great Britain; second, a popular tone, because the choice has been deliberate not to attempt the careful, half-technical descriptions of Mac- gibbon and Ross in their important book al- ready reviewed in these columns, but to de- scribe for less advanced students what should impress the intelligent observer. It is, however, with a little pang of regret that oné notes the evident love of the writer for the picturesqueness of ruined and of ivy~ grown walls and piers. It puzzles the ap- preciative reader that Mr. Butler should find it possible to say that the ruined window of the refectory at Dryburgh finds its effect enhanced by ‘“‘a rich growth of ivy covering the bareness of the ruined wall and gable.” The true lover of ancient architecture should regret every leaf of ivy that besets and that helps in the rapidly advancing destruction of these precious ruins; he should watch his chance to cut the plants up by the roots rather than his chance to praise them. So much of protest must be allowed to the lover of architecture as opposed to the lover of the picturesque, as Sir Walter Scott and bis followers understood it. That protest having been made, there is nothing but praise left for the book before us. Twenty abbeys, including the well-known remains at Melrose and Dryburgh and the far northern and seldom visited Beauly and Kinloss—together with three in that savage region of Gallo- way, close to the English border and yet so wild that the masters of the present school of Scotch romance find there a wilderness in which any strange outrage may be sup- posed possible—all these have received the loving visit and have been the subject of the patient study of our author. His drawings are numerous, and he has deserved the thanks of every student by his recollection of the need of general plans. Such plans are disagreeable to make when they are of ruins only—when the practised hand and the train- ed eye have to stop for lack of trustworthy treatises, and can only put in a line of wretched dots to show where the artist fully believes the nave or the cloister wall was carried on. Such work as that is vexation itself, and the student who will master his impatience and make the plans honestly, as material is allowed him, and stop where the stone walls disappear, is one who deserves well of his kind. Of the other drawings it cannot be said that they are altogether de- lightful. In some cases, as in the picture on page 279, the perspective is certainly at fault. In this case the nave is made vastly too long; so, on page 249, the view of Dun- drennan is so treated that the transept wall ‘seems curved. Let those who have no experi- ence of the difficulty of avoiding these de- fects in their work be loud in their denuncia- tion of such errors. It is only a past master in out-of-door drawing that will know how to avoid them always. The drawings show a sincere love of the architecture, both in mass and in detail, a sense of stony so- lidity and of crumbling ruin each in its pro- per place, and a love of that tracery and sculpture which remains nearly intact. As to the tone and character of the text, It can well be judged by a careful reading of the chapter on Dunfermline. Some ac- count is given of the foundation of the church by Malcolm Canmore and his wife, Margaret of England; and the question as to how much of the existing nave is of their building and how much is of the time of David I, is very properly discussed without final decision being reached. The architec- tural character of the building is treated in a simple and easily comprehended fashion; the connection of Robert the Bruce with the building and the disapearance of his structures at the time of the Protestant Re- formation are handled in the right spirit, and the recent discovery of Robert’s tomb, coffin, shroud, and body cut through the breast for the extraction of the heart, as is described in the ancient legends—all this, with the preposterous way in which the newly com- pleted structures were compelled to dohonor to King Robert, is as well urged as possi- ble. The reader who understands what may be done and what cannot be done with twenty pages of large print from which must be deducted the space taken up by five large cuts, will understand that what most travellers need and will ask for will of ne- cessity prevent the use of space for more minute archsological examination. And as this chapter is, so are others—perhaps all. The book can be read at home with perfect satisfaction and content as if it were an unusually intelligent novel, and it could be read in your Scottish inn at morning, and at night with renewed sense of what the day's work is to be and has been.
Page 27
Dec. 7, 1899] The Nation. 435 BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Archer, W. ike, Reading! Seribners. 1.25. a . How to Tea it. Arnold, me Go 6 Avenel, Vicowte G. d écanisme de la Vie Paris: ee.” Colts & Ole. 4 fr. Barnes, J. Drake and His Yeomen. Amelia E. Was It Right to Forgive? H. 8. Stone & Co. oe. hae ai Barr, rom aening ust. Boston: L. O. vols. a C. Magna Charta and Other — esters of England’ Philadelphia: W. J. nO. t, Vanda W. Heart's Desire. John Lane. Blunt 8. Satan Absolved. John Lane. $1.25. Booth: bby. G ve Made Manifest. H. 8. Stone nat , C rT. For Freedom of the Sea. Scribners. Buchan, J Grey Weather. John Lane, $1.50. a Prof. + Religion of Israel to the Exile. nams. e Life and Death of Mr. Badman. Beayes, 3 : Be iy rak Lively City 0’ h.§ i e e! Stokes Co. $1.50. Carrington, H. B. Washington the Soldier. ners. Carter, F. Katooticut. R. H. Russell. Cary, Elizabeth L. Browning, Poet and Man: A Survey. Putnams. $3.75. Cennini, Cennino, The Art of the ona Masters. Translated b Christiana J. Herringham. Lon- don: Geo len; New York: F. P, Harper. $2. Champion, E. Tn troducticn aux Essais bs — t . : Armand Colin & Cie. 3 f 8. mk — Relation to Mind. urchill, Winston O. e River Wess An His- torical Account of the uest of the Soudan. Lo ans, Green & Co. vo Letters from Queer and 1 and 3 and Teacher's Ma- Macmillan. aN, 85, ~ ity, Lands. Flaming H. Revell Co. “tn nlisaione one alph. The * Pilot: A Tale of the Peotkilie” Fleming H "Revell Co. 26. wt M. racinesca. Illustrated by Orson Lowell. Macmillans. 2 vols. a Cripps, ee oe = Pate. ae: John ’ ° a e. urray; New Yor ee oh Mt, Dent & Orowes Beethoven Oo. ; 5 New York: KE. P: Dutton & : Go, etice of Sat-itenaee name ".% Motalen totes Archibald Constable & New York: / $1.60. ck, G. Red Rag of Ritual. Frederick arne & oo. '$ $1.50. ligg. F. A. Scrib- 60c. A Santor’ s Experience Dawson, A. J. The 1. ‘ aon Story of Ronald Kestrel. D. — A. La Tulipe Noire. American Book Child Life in Colonial Days. A. . Earle, Alice M. Macmillan. a ) . His Betemne, and Other Stories. The Cen mtury Co. 1.25. wy owt, 4 . Bi; and Jeune ry stem of Instruction Qualitative patysie. New York: The Authors. ro. J. A Century of Science, and Other Es- ys. Houghton iffin & Co. §2. FitsGerald lama u-Absal and Bird Parlia- ment. Trinit Ed. } Boston : L. OC. Page & Co. Fitz Gerald, The Highest Andes. Scribners, Fitamaurice-Kelly, J. Don xote de la Mancha. = pare te. London: David Nutt; New York: P. Putnam’s Sons. ocsen, Edith H. A Oorner of the West. D, Ap- pleton & Co. $1. Green, W. H. General Introduction to the old Testament. Sypmnees. $1.50. Grisebach T. A. Hoffman's S&mtliche Weems. elas “Max Hesse. 4 vols. Harden T. E. Financial New York: A History. yy York: The Author, Vol. I. $1.50. Macmillan Co, artey. L. R. Francis Lieber. The Hawt “ J. Archibald Malmaison. Funk & . The Two Books on the Water Supply of the ‘City of Rome of Benga - Julius Frontinus. on: Dana Estes & Co. $6.50. Hobbes, J. O. Osbern and Ursyne: A Drama, in three acts. John Lane, $1.25. —, & S. The Family of the Sun. D. Apple- Hopkins The Power of Womanhood. E. P, oe Co. $1.25. sy Julia W. Reminiscences. Houghton, Mif- n & Oo, 50. ae: R. jr., and Shastovent, B. The Birds of Rhode M inda The Auth ae. npere, * Maud, and Peck, 8. M. The Golf Girl, tokes Co. 25. $1. =. iy. The Baldwin Primer. American Book Livingston, L. S. American Book-Prices Current. Dodd, Mead 10. Long, W. *H. Naval Yarns of Sea Fights oe Wrecks, Pirates and Privateers. London: ; New York: F. P. Harper. . $1.50 The Frederick The Four-Masted Cat-Boat. ~~ of Yadasara. uae H. W. My Study Fire. Dodd, Mead & Oo. uecirther, RB & Pe Old Book and the Old Faith. FE. B. t & Co. $1.50, A Physician's Study of the Alco- Madden, Dr. J. hol Question. Milwaukee: Owen & Weihbrecht Co. M H. ©. Aaron Barr. Rea Blogra- Small, Maynard & Co. ; of Greek Idyls. Houghton, + & he Life and Letters of Sir Joho werett Millais. F. A. Stokes Co. 2 Vols. 10. Phillipe Mrs. L. South African tions. Longmans, Green & Co. Pick, Dr. E » Santen on Memory Culture. EL ik p Kellogg. Surgery. A Treatise for Stu- aye Practitinnes Loogmans, Green & Plummer, C, Two of the Saxon Chronicles Parailel, with Su menta Extracts from the Others Henry Frowde. Vol. 2. 128. 4d. Point and Pillow Lace. _ By A. M. 8. Lendon: John M New York: E. P. Dutton & Go. Poll, M. “Materials for German P 3 e an bee « t Heary Holt & Oo. Val 3 Sc. tee ee Daisy H. ion Fane m. The Re of a Turkish Hartm. Macmillan. $1: ND = ay M. Suédois et Norvégiens chez eux Reid, W. J. Through Unexplored Asia. Boston: Dana Estes & Co Ribot, Th. The Evolution of General Ideas —_ Kegan Paul, Trench, Triiboer & Co.; : Open Court ‘Pub. Co. $1.25. Rose Island. H. Lon- Ont Russell e @ 8. Stone & Co Smith, Rev. A. H. Village Life in Caine: A Stuay in Sociology. tow we Re . Revell Co. §2. Stern, Menco. Geschichten vom Rhein. American Book Co. " Stockton, F. R. The Squirrel Inn; The Merry Chanter. The Late Mrs. Null. 2 vols. Scrib ners, Stringer, A. J. The Loom of Destiny. Boston: — oe werd & >. . 1.2. tuart t c oO and a and Oth Stories. The Century Co. $1.25 — orett, om. Stories of Maine American So Thackeray, F St. J., and Stone, F. D. Florile- ium Latinum: Translations into Latin Verse rom Pre-Victorian Poets. John Lane. 2 The George Meredith Birthday Book. By D. M. London; Archibald Constable & Co.; New York: E. P. Dutton & Oo. $1.25. The International Annual of fe graphic Bulletin. Vol. 12. . thony & Co. Vogel, Th. Goethes Selbstzeugnisse sur Religion, vasat'€ B. G. See icomte E. de. Le Rappel des Ombrea. Tavis: Armand Solin & Cle. 8 fr. SO. » Bishop H. B. Li hte and Shadows of a Episcopate. Macmi Wightman, F. PP. Little Leather Breeches, and Other Southern Rhymes. F. Taylor & Oo. §2. Woolf, M. A. ae of Ton Life in a Great City. Putnams. Anthony's E. & H. ‘¢ The chief organ of serious educa- tional thought in America.’’—7he Dial. DECEMBER EDUCATIONAL REVIEW pi Ke Professor NICHOLAS MURRAY BUTLER. : Commercial Education, by Charles W. Eliot ; AReligi ome Instruction in Education, by Nicholas Mar- er; Impressions of American Education (I) by David 8 Salmon” The C Vg mpg of a National nt Gollan og Se und J. Jam lations of School 1 by Robert Eilts, "Jenes; History in the Elementary ‘Be ool, by Julia A. King. Discussions: Is there “a new revival”? by Jefferson . Kershner; Paul Janet, by Adolph Cohn. REVIEWS. EDITORIALS 35c. per number. $3.00 per year. 10 numbers. HENRY HOLT & CO., READY SOON: The Yangtze Valley and Beyond An Account of Journeys in Central and West- ern China. By ISABELLAL BIRD (Mrs Bishop), author of ‘* Unbeaten Tracks in Japan,” etc With 116 9" and a map. 2 vols., 8 vo, per set, $6.00 Miss Bird is one of the most remarkable write . Her famous book on Japan, published in ere ne considered one of the most satisfactory works on the subject. G. P. Putnam’s Sons, 27 and 29 West 23d St., New York. | The Story of a 1 Modest Great Man earned the name of great. . . | Letters oink: Becoilectians entail, PIE aici JOHN MURRAY FORBES Edited by his daughter, With Portraits. 2 vols. 8vo, $6.00 SARAH F. HUGHES “One who had more greatness in him than many who have . His daughter’s biography of him deserves to be numbered among the best which this century has produced,” says The ee of London. HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO., Boston | 11 East 17th Street, New York The Prince’s Story Book Being Historical Stories Collected out of English Romantic Literature in Illustra- tion of the Reigns of English Monarchs from the Conquest to Victoria. Edited, with an introduction, by Ggzorcr Lav- RENCE GOMMBE. Illustrated. Crown 8vo, cloth extra, gilt top, $2.00. LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., PUBLISHERS. 91-93 Fifth Ave., New York. OXFORD MAPS. BY PROF. H. 8. OSBORN, LL.D. Palestine, These maps cover all Biblical Geography ,contain all recent Egypt and Sinai, discoveries, and are accepted . "s Travels. ) authority. Can be seen over large rooms. Special terms for the maps as a set. Oxford Map Publishers, Oxford, Ohio. FRENCH BOOKS “zs 1S AND ADMIRANDA DESCRIPTIS GUIANA: Printed in Nuremberg in 1509, with [a rare book. Offers ta | P. - apmwarket. London, England
Page 28
436 The Nation. (Vol. 69, No. 1797 Some Wlustrated holiday Publications of L. C. Page and Company, Boston = ART LOVERS’ SERIES SAINTSINART in Art,’’ ete. FRENCH. every way worth CLAR ERSKINE ny ene Madonna in A great masters. _ maints in Birt. By Crans En. y : SKINE CLEMENT, author of ‘‘Angels [> Christ in Hirt, By Joszex Lewis i Each 1 vol., 12mo, deckle-edge flat back, with ‘silk head-ba ond ‘ebnatits cover, per vol. .... oe The same, three-quarters levant, morocco, WOR s.0kadennvnae eae These are the two new volumes in the very successful ‘‘Art Lovers’ Series,’’ and are in y of being added to the series so well ; Seveney 3 known by ‘‘The eee eee eee eeeee Each volume is illustrated with thirty-three full-page seeneneannene from paintings by the This series of six volumes is boxed as a set if desired, or three 2-volume sets in flat boxes, as follows: ‘‘The Madonna in Art’’ and ‘‘Ohild Life io “art, " “Angels in Art’’ and “Saints in Art,’’ “Christ in Art’’ and ‘‘Love in Art. ‘Angels in Art,’’ ete, MUSIC LOVERS’ SERIES THE NATIONAL MUSIC OF AME- RICA AND ITS SOURCES. By Louis C, Exson, Author of ‘‘Great Composers and their Work." With illustrations in photogravure and re- ——— of numerous rare scores, yol., crown 16mo, cloth ornamental. ..$1.50 i yol., crown 16mo, three-quarters mo- SOO orccee ser asicnvvetscnseccsdenes This volume describes the quaint music of the Pilgrims and Puritans and the beginni of music study in America. It gives the origin of all our most important national songs, and the historical events intertwined with their use, terday.’’ Boxed as a set if desired. These are the two new volumes in our successful ‘‘Music Lovers’ Series begun last year with “‘Great Composers and Their Work,” and ‘‘Famous Singers of To-day and Yes- FAMOUS VIOLINISTS OF TO-DAY AND YESTERDAY. By Henry C. LaHEE. Author of ‘Famous oe gen bingy Yesterday.’’ Illustrat ag ten full Pam photogravures. 1 vol., crown 16mo, cloth ornamental..... $1.50 1 vol., crown 16mo, three-quarters moroc- 3.50 GOs sak ehh wt KR ESOS SEE Seed reeked «ahs A sketch of the celebrated violin virtuoso, from early times to the present day, together with an account of the development of the various schools of instrumentation. STAGE LOVERS’ SERIES FAMOUS ACTRESSES OF THE DAY 1n America. By Lewis C. STRANG, Illustrated with eventy. -five full-page plates in photogravure and balf-tone. 1 vel., crown 16mo, cloth decorative.... $1.50 1 vol,, crown 16mo, three-quarters a ‘‘Famous Actresses of the Day in America” contains accounts of Maude Adams, Ada Rehan, Juila Mastows, Viola Allen, Mrs. Les- lle Carter, Julla Arthur Olga Nethersole, Annie Russell, Maxine Elliott, and all the more prominent women on the American stage. if desl These books contain not only carefully compiled biographical sketches of the players, and complete lets of the im o— characters that they have impersonated, but also just and tenpartial estimates of their work in the leading roles of their repertoires. Boxed as a set FAMOUS ACTORS OF THE DAY iv America. By Lewis C. STRANG. Illustrated with twenty-five full-page plates in photogravure and half-tone. Each 1 vol., crown 16mo, cloth decorative, 1 vol., crown 16mo, three-quarters mo- WONG: cs vr on kc th aso cet oubiauns fact *‘Famous Actors of the in America” escribes the careers and art of the minent American actors, including Somes Herne, Richard Mansfield, Nat, C. Goodwin, James H. Hackett, William’ H. y Ay Robert Mantell, and KE. H. Sothern. TRAVEL LOVERS’ SERIES THE UNCHANGING EAST; or ‘PRAVELS AND TROUBLES IN THE Onient. By Ropert Barr, author of ‘‘ Princess Tekla,’’ etc. Piustrated with eighty - two full - ge pistes, frony photographs specially selec red y the + uthor. 2 vola., crown 16mo, cloth decorative. . ig Three-quarters levant moroced,,.... eee F OLD WORLD MEMORIES. By Epwarp Lowe TEMPLE. : ’ With eighty phot vure and half-tone -illus- trations, Selkle cage fit top. top, Set backs 2 vols,, crown 16mo, clo "sh Three-quarters evant moroceo. ee eeeeeees An jatoroatt qitecticn of essays and oes sketches through both Har haunts a af-the-way Mhaees at” ot he "Old Wi World. For sale at all book-stores, or sent, delivery prepaid by the publishers, on receipt of the price, SEND FOR OUR ILLUSTRATED HOLIDAY CATALOGUE, AS THE ABOVE BOOKS ARE ONLY A SELECTION OF OUR NEW HOLIDAY PUBLICATIONS. New Holiday Books. My New Curate. A Story: Gathered from the Stray Leaves of an Old Diary by the Rev. P. A. SHeenan, P. P., Doneraile (Dio- cese of Cloyne). Author of “Geoffrey Austin: Student,” “The Triumph of Failure,” etc. With numerous illustra- tions. 12mo. Cloth, gilt top, $1.50. The Secret of Fougereuse. A Romance of the XVth Century. From the French, by Louise Imocen GuUINEY. With illustrations by Chase Emerson and Louis Meynell. 1zmo. Cloth, or- namental, $1.25. “It is a fine piece of work . . . vivid in its rendering of the conditions and the spirit of the time, full of movement and incident, impressive in its contrasts of noble anc — ‘ristian character with that of the base intrigue:, and withal thoroughly entertaining from first to last.’’—Congregational- Jerome Savonarola. A Sketch. By Rev. J. L. O’Netm, O. P. 1zmo. Cloth, profusely illustrated, net, $1.00, “This ‘sketch’ is an excellent piece of writing. It is compact, full, clear, and consecutive, por- traying the character and work of the man in most glowing colors.”—Troy Budget. Marlier, Callanan & Co. 173 Tremont St., Boston. Experimental. For the purpose of showing what effect prices have on sales, we are putting on the market an edition of “Von Holst’s Con- stitutional and Political History of the United States,” at less than one-half the regular price. Best English cloth, gilt tops, large type, good paper, complete, 8 volumes, $12.00 net. “A work which every student must needs possess in its entirety.".—New York Evening Post. For sale by all booksellers. CALLAGHAN & COMPANY, Chicago. Lark Classics, » ha enon illustrations by Ro- bert Edgren. Oblong, 12mo. Fine yr nl paper; handsome cover Price 75c. Par with THE SIGN OF THE two wares colors $1.50 onl edition of ea es on ivo! - per with two water-colors 50a bath de tare with 14 waset — 100 copies , 8 esha nc 0 co pes only 8. Vols. an THE PURPLE COW. Illustrations by Gelett Also “IDLE HOURSIN A LIBRARY.” By Pro- fessor W. H, Hudson. The Doxey Book Company, 3 Hardie Place, San Francisco.
Page 29
Dec. 7, 1899] The N ation. ix Holiday Books | VEN Ga V/A LWA Dickey | Downy The Autobiography of a Bird *& FF SF By Vrrernia 8S. Patterson. 192 pages. Price, 60 cents Containing numerous beautiful colored pictures and black and white sketches of birds. A story of a bobolink told by himself, witty, instructive, ori- ginal; withal a — protest against the whole- sale slaughter of song and other birds. “What ‘Black Beauty’ may have done for the co race, Virginia S. Patterson’s charmingly told ‘Dickey Downy’ may assuredly do for bird life.’’—Boston Globe. A Wind Flower By CAROLINE ATWATER MASON, author of ‘*A Minister of the World,’’ ‘‘A Quiet King,’’ etc. 290 pages, beautifully bound. Price, $1.00 The delightful romance of a little ae oe who becomes enamoured of a high-church clergyman, A thread of religious discussion, which weaves it- self in unobtrusively, places the book on a higher plane than that of a mere story. “Worthy of a place among the year’s best fic- tion.’’—Chicago Tribune. The Ward Hill Books WARD HILL AT WESTON WARD HILL THE SENIOR WARD HILL AT COLLEGE By EVERETT T. TOMLINSON. illustrated, averaging 300 pages. Price, $1.25 Per Volume A series of boys’ books eqeally as entertaining and somewhat similar to ‘‘Tom Brown at Rugby. The experiences told of have all been taken from real life. The baseball and football games have really occurred. Of ‘‘Ward Hill at College,’’ The Chicago Chroni- ele says: ‘‘A wholesome, helpful story in every way.’’ AMERICAN BAPTIST PUBLICATION SOCIETY, 1420 Chestnut St., Philadelphia. NEW YORK. BOSTON. CHICAGO. ST. LOUIS. DALLAS. ATLANTA. Autograph Letters Excellently FAMOUS PERSONS Bought and Sold by Walter R. Benjamin, 1125 Broadway, New York City. Send for price lists. Bosasis SECOND HAND AND NEW, - Sta sau ndard Rare. Books bought. Catalogue ed. —, Ww. ‘joumsom, 2 H424 &t., N.Y. ‘ATALOGUE No. 49 (of second-hand books and pamphlets), as to contents, is the best I have published. A.S. CLARK, 174 Fulton 8t., New York Published Every Saturday and giving about 3500 pages a year Science and Art Politics, Discovery Fiction and Poetry FREE. THE LIVING AGE EACH WEEKLY NUMBER contains without abridgment, the most interesting and important contributions to the periodicals of Great Britain and the Continent. ALL DEPARTMENTS of knowledge and discussion which in- of the terest intelligent readers, with fiction and poetry. World’s Best | ORIGINAL TRANSLATIONS of striking articles from Conti Literature nental sources are made expressly for the magazine by abitinn its own staff of translators. | A SHORT STORY and an instalment of a Serial Story will appear in each issue. A MONTHLY SUPPLEMENT presents readings from the most important new books, editorial notes on books and au thors, and a list of the books of the month. Published Weekly at $6.00 a year. Single numbers 15 cents. Biography Literary Criticism A REMARKABLE OFFER. NEW SUBSCRIBERS to THE LIVING AGE may receive with it THE REVIEW OF REVIEWS or PUBLIC OPINION for only $6.75 a year; or for $7.2 HARPER'S MONTHLY or SCRIBNER’S MAGAZINE, or any other $3.00 periodical published inthe U. S. This offer is good only to absolutely NEW SUBSCRIBERS to THE LIVING AGE. To all New Subscribers to THE LIVING AGE for the year 1900, remitting before Jan. 1, the weekly numbers of 1899 issued after receipt of their subscription, will be sent PREE. THE LIVING AGE CO., P. 0. Box 5206, Boston. Novels on India Paper NEW CENTURY LIBRARY TO BE ISSUED MONTHLY Charles Dickens’s Novels Complete in about 1s Volumes Now ready (2 vols.), THE PICKWICK PAPERS and NICHOLAS NICKLEBY. These volumes are printed on the thinnest printing paper in the world; yet it is perfectly opaque and very strong. The type is long primer, and the printing is clear, so that reading it is a delight. Convenient for the pocket, only 644 by 414 inches and extremely light. ‘** One of the most remarkable feats of modern book-making.'’— The Churchman. Uniform with above Wrm. M. Thackeray’s Works Now Ready, ‘Vanity Fair.’’ PRICE, CLOTH, GILT TOP, $1.00 per volume. For sale by all booksellers, or sent postpaid on receipt of price. THOS. NELSON & SONS, Publishers, 37 East 18th St., New York .WEBSTER'S INTERNATIONAL DICTIONARY In its Various Attractive Bindings it Makes the CHOICEST GIFT FOR CHRISTMAS. What better, wiser, or more acceptable gift could be made than a copy of the International? It is a vast storehouse of valuable information arranged in a convenient form for hand, eye, and mind. It is more _— -_ than any other lexicon in the world. It should be in every usehold. We also publish Webster’s Collegiate with a Valuable Pronouncing Glossary of Scottish Words and Phrases, etc. ? ee GET| ihild asgortment of catalogues at reduced prices sent for 10-cent stamp. (Mention Uda Gdvertisement and receive a discount.) conta, | west ORANE F. W. CHRISTERN DISCOUNTS. | "sddressIR. GRANT.” | (DYRSEN & PFEIFFER, Successors), uotations. An Before buying books write for and slips of books 429 Sth Ave., bet. and 30th Sts., New York. Importers of Foreign 5 Aponte fer the leadiog Pari ; itish uw Teul ” rye es Catalogues i ie . B. GRANT, Books 90 W. conor : NEW YORK.
Page 30
x The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1797 TIFFANY Favrile Glass FOR GIFTS FAVRILE GLASS, made by special processes under the personal supervision of MR. LOUIS C. TIFFANY exclu-. sively in our own furnaces, is now as favorably known in Eng- land and on the Continent as in America. A wide range of selec- tion is afforded by the large num- ber of objects made in FA VRILE GLASS alone and in combina- tion with metal, at prices from one dollar to five hundred dollars or more: Some are here given: Vases Powder Boxes Bowls Perfume Bottles Plaques Fewel Boxes Table Glass Handkerchief Boxes Finger Bowls Cigar Fars Ice Plates Picture Lights Fruit Plates Candlesticks Olive Plates Cigar Lamps Sorbet Glasses Desk and Reading Salt-Cellars Lights Gas Fixtures Electric Fixtures Portable Lamps Standing Lamps Hanging Lanterns Decanters Liqueur Sets Tea Stands Tea Screens Cracker Fars Rose ‘Fars Lamp, Electric and Vinaigrettes Candle Shades Salts Bottles and Globes Ink Stands Fardinieres Paper Window Transpa- Weights rencies TIFFANY STUDIOS (TIFFANY GLASS & DECORATING CO.) Illustrated Historical Booklets sent upon request— (1) Favrile Glass, (2) Lamps and Fixtures, (3) Glass Mosaic, (4) Memorial Windows, (5) Me- morial Tablets, (6) Monuments. 333-341 Fourth Ave., New York Noe Gloves. Fowne’s, Dent’s, and Courvoisier’s Gloves. Riding, Driving, and Evening Dress Gloves. Umbrellas. Martin’s Umbrellas. Lap Robes. Rich Furs. Broadway K 1 90h st. NEW YORK FATIGUE Is Not Necessary to Good Work. THE DENSMORE TYPEWRITER does good work and does it easily. ‘ s ball bearings in the type bars partly account or A request in person or by letter brings a cata- logue, Densmore Typewriter Co., 316 Broadway, New York. Brentano's Edition THE STANDAR OPERAGLASS finn bears Music: L, ELLIS & ELVEY, CATALOGUES of CHOICE BOOKS and ILLUMI- NATED MANUSCRIPTS published iy. Brack Letler and RE BOND STRELT’ LONDON ENG. OOKS.—AH# Out-of-print Books supplied, no matter on what sub, world over as the tempore: ne 1218 Sonn Bright Sirect, REIS ohitAR BOGxSHOF , Registered Trade Mark, For Holiday Gifts Table Cloths and. Napkins Put up in Boxes bearing the Seal of “The Linen Store.” The most notable produc- tions in design and workman- ship of Irish, Scotch, Barnsley, Flemish, French, German, and Austrian manufacturers. Cloths to suit any table. We quote for a popular size. Cloth, 2x2% yards, with 1 doz Din- ner Napkins to match, at $4-75, 5-75, 6.75, 7-75, 8.50, 10.00, 12.00, 15.00, 16.50, 18.00, 20.50, and upwards. James McCutcheon &Co. 14 West 23d St., New York. A Pittsburg Gentleman, living on Wallingford St. in that city, writes in reference to The Augusta-Vic- toria Empress Shoulder Shawls: ‘‘My wife and daughter were so much pleased with the shawl that they have decided to have a second one. Of all the shawis I have seen I must say The Augusta-Vic- toria are the finest that have come to my notice, and I advise every gentleman to buy one for his wife and daughter.’’ Have you ordered one? They are hand-woven, about 40 inches square, with 6-inch fringe, warp silk, woof wool, in light green, delicate pink, recherché red, light white or black color. Postpaid and registered for $7.50. THE SUSACUAC WEAVING CO., BETHLEHEM, PA. lue, stylish yellow,