The Nation 1899-08-31: Vol 69 Iss 1783
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
GENERAL LIBRARY, UNIV. OF MICH. a SEP 1 189° e NaStex VOL. LXIX—NO. 1783. THURSDAY, AUGUST 31, 1899. PRICE 10 CENTS. CONSTITUTION OF THE UNITED STATES. A Critical Discussion of Its Genesis, Development, and Interpretation By JOHN RANDOLPH TUCKER, LL.D. Edited by HENRY ST. GEORGE TUCKER, Professor of Constitutional and International Law and Equity, Washington and Lee University. Treated consecutively, section by section, beginning at the preamble and concluding with the amendments, and wherever constructions at variance with those advanced “by the author have been given to any clause by authors or judges, the views of such authors and the opinions of the judges bearing upon the decisions are often given at length. ‘*Prof. Tucker's exposition of the Federal Com- ‘‘It is a monumental work, and it will be immense- pact theory of the Constitution of the United States | ly valuable to all students of the Constitution "— is the most thorough and clear presentation of that sub- | CHarLes W. Dasney, University of Tennessee. ject which has yet been made.’’"—Hon. Simeon E. Ba.p- : ‘*Whether or not the reader agrees with all the WIN, Supreme Court of Errors, State of Connecticut. conclusions of the author, he will feel at every step that he is enjoying the companionship of a great thinker. '"’"— 66 : " Cc ° ° ; A history of the development of the Constitution, | 4,,,,;-¢n Law Review. and a commentary, thorough and lucid, upon the many judicial decisions to which it has given rise.”"— 7he Chi- ; “The work will be of Great value to jurists aad cago Times-Herald legislators.” —Galveston Daily News. ‘In both sections of the country eminent legal ‘*Mr, Tucker is what is called a ‘strict construc- | critics agree that nothing more exhaustive or more pro- tionist,’ and in these times of windy statesmanship and | found has appeared on the subject of the Constitution loose methods, his views are profitable for doctrine, for | of the United States than the publication under re- reproof and guidance.”—Charleston News and Courier. view.” — The Constitution, Atlanta, Ga. Two Volumes, Cloth, $7. 00 net: Sheep, $8.00 net. IMPORTANT NOTICE. We shall have ready early in September a popular edition of Von Holst’s Political and Constitutional History of the United States, complete w. th Index, 8vo, cloth, 8 vols., $12.00. It is the publisher's intention to make this edition most attractive, using good paper, large type, approved portraits for illustrations, and best cloth binding. This edition to be sold in complete sets only. CALLAGHAN & COMPANY, CHICAGO, ILL.
Page 2
The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1783 The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science, and Art. FOUNDED 1865. [Entered at the New York City Post-Office'as second- class mail-matter.]} CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. I IE iain bch oon oxbh e Savadcavctadenectinsstsceves 159 EDITORIAL ARTICLES: ry ws, 4b. 3) ee rece 162 Recognizing Slavery.........0.ssescesecsees 162 Phases of the Negro Problem.............++ 163 Our Own Anti- Dreyfusism ehecoenedrveveeece 164 Americans and German8,..........6e-eseeee 164 SPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE: CORRESPONDENCE: “Our Country, Right. of Wrong’ ..cccsoseove 168 THO BERN WUIPIROS... co cvccccsvcscccvecneces 169 I i incketandceconaces vanbbcncecescskessachunkeveress 169 Book REVIEWS: Tucker's eneiieation of the United States... 172 Reminiscences i Justin McCarthy, M.P.... 173 German Higher Schools ..........ceessesses 174 SE et ce 'ndk-osvevasertesnendesechoenccne 175 *Ar@is : Storia della Repubblica Ateniese..... 176 Siberia and Central Asia.........c0..scce0s 176 BU ERMINE Se caccdottccntsceceneenenese 177 BOOTED OF IRE Wins oi. ce sinin tn Xs cho vin sos dievscncoar’ 177 TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three Dollars per year, in advance, postpaid, to any part of the United States or Canada; to foreign countries comprised in the Postal Union, $4.00. The date when the subscription expires is on the Address-Label of each paper, the change of which to a subsequent date becomes a receipt for remit- tance. No other receipt is sent unless requested. Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless male by registered letter, or by check, express order, or Postal Order, payable to “Publisher of the Na- tion.” When a change of address is desired, both the old and new addresses should be given. Address THE NATION, Box 794, New York. Publication Office, 208 Broadway. TERMS OF ADVERTISING, Fifteen cents per agate line, each insertion, 1), lines to the inch, Twenty per cent. advance for choice of page, or top of column, Cuts are not inserted on the first page. A column, $20 each insertion; with choice of page, $2. A page, $60 each insertion; front-cover page, $80. Advertisements must be acceptable in every re- spect. Copy received until Tuesday, 6 P. M. DISCOUNTS. “4 ‘insertions BO 26 “ 89 « 52 - AmountT— 9100 within @ FEOF. .....sccccsecccoessveees 10 per cent. 250 pe w ” Ser dscedeusipabahoseukpne 12 PP 6500 Oe db eebaenperasedinecensens 15 me wee. opeavacesactapnsas adage . 20 vi Lie Se oo deisenneevenssdecuniaes 265 ” ee = ee See eeebeehvodestehusuaban 80 “ 2,000 ” oi Seeedvakgesmasbencenesese BBy OC The NATION is sent free to those who advertise in it as settndh as advertisement continues. *,* | Catan. of the Nason may be peosiies ye Paris at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de l'Opéra, and in London of B. F. Stevens, 7 Trafalgar Square, Ame- rican Newspaper Agency, 15 King William Street, Strand, W. CO. London agent for advertisements, H. A. Delille, Langham Hotel. - Educational. CALIFORNIA, Los Angeles, West 23d Street. M4 RLBOROUGH SCHOOL for GIRLS. Mrs. GrorGe A. CASWELL, Principal. CanaDa, P. Q., Lennoxville. ISHOP'S COLLEGE SCHOOL. (Es- tablished 1842 } Church School for Boys on lines of English Public Schools. Specially adapted for sons of English residents in America. Bathing, cricket, and healthy country situation. Best New York references, S960 8 a year. H. J. H. Perry, M.A., Headmaster. ConNEOTICOT, Black Hall. : LACK HALL SCHOOL.—A Boarding School for 40 boys. Prepares for any college or for business. Gymnasium, athletic fleld, etc. 24th year be- gins in September. Has, G. BARTLETT. M. A., Prin. DELAWARE, Wilmington, Franklin Street. WE MISSES HEBB’S Boarding and Day School for Girls. Students are prepared for College. DISTRICT oF CoLumBiIa (Chevy Chase P. O., Md.). HEV Y CHASE French and English School for Girls. Suburb of Washington. or. ae eo tango e of the house. OULIGNY, Principal. Miss C. PeTriGREw, Asst. Prin. ILLINoIs, Chicago, 1500-4 Title and Trust Building. HICAGO COLLEGE OF LAW. Law DEPARTMENT OF LAKE FOREST UNIVERSITY. Three-year course leading to degree LL.B. For further information address the Secretary. E. E. BARRETT. MARYLAND, Baltimore, 122 and 124 W. Franklin St YY DGEWORTH BOARDING and DAY a? School for Oe, —87th year will be; 2 September 28, 1899. 34 LEFEBVRE, Princ = Miss E.D . HUNTLEY, Assoc ate Principal. MARYLAND, Catonsville. T. TIMOTH V’S SCHOOL for Girls re- opens Sept 21, 1899. Preparesfor College. Heads of School, Miss M. C: Canran. iss S. R. CARTER, Massacnu SETTS, Boston. OSTON UNIVERSITY Law School. Address the Dean, SaMvUEL C. BENNETT. Massacuvusetts, Duxbury OWDER POINT SCHOOL. —Prepares for Scientific Sci.ool, College, or Business. Indi- vidual teaching. Elementar rh. classes for young boys. Home and outdoor life. Kwapp, 8.B. (M. I. T.). MASSACHUSETTS, South Byfiel UMMER ACADEMY. PRE PARES boys for any College or Scientific School. Special attention is given to English. Trained teach- ers. $500. PERLEY L. Horne, A.M. (Harvard). MASSACHUSETTS, Waban (Newton). ZTNDSOR HALL SCHOOL. A home school for girls. CHARLES H. CLarK, A.M., D.Sc. New JERSEY, Bridgeton. EST FJERSE Y ACADEM Y. Prepares boys for College or Business. A Chris- tian Home and School. Beautiful grounds; steam heat; ymnasium. The health region of New "Jersey. Our oys uniformly do well. Puases W. Lyon, A.M., Principal. New Jersey, Summit, near New York k4 NT PLACE SCHOOL FOR GIRLS. Special attention to College preparation. rs. SawAH WOODMAN PAUL, Prin. Pres. of Board of Directors, HAMILTON W. MaBreE,L.H.D. Norra Carourna, Asheville, 261 Chestnut St. TSS CHAMPION’S HOME AND Day Schoolfor Girls. 14th year begins Sept. 27. Onto, Cincinnati. TSS ARMSTRONG’S SCHOOL FOR Girls, Liddesdale Place, Avondale. Family limit- ed. Circulars sent on application. Onto, Cincinnati, 2648 Bellevue Ave., Mt. Auburn, TSS LUPTON REOPENS HER School Sept. 27. Preparation for college > made a specialty. Pupils from this school too grees during the past year at Vassar College and at the Shicago and Cincinnati Universities. A few boarding pupils are received. OFS SEV PS Walnut Hills, 944-046-048 Morris 8t. EN PARK SCHOOL.—BOARDING all on Day School for Girls. Primary, Preparatory, Collegiate Departments. Higher course in the Lan- guages, Music, and art. F ADAME FREDIN Mied Many F Sarre, { Principals. Onreon, Portia T. HELEN'S “iA LL.—A Boarding and Day School for Girls; will reopen Sept. 15. For cir- culars address Miss ELxawor TeBpetrs, Ph.D., Prin, Penrnsyivania, Chestnut Hill. HESTNUT HILL ACADEMY, A Boarding School for Boys. Illustrated Cata- logues on application. James L. Parrzenson, Head-master. Frducatonal. PEINSYLVANIA, M EDIA MCADEM Y or BOYS AND Youts g Men. 24th Year. Classical, Scientific, En- lish, and Commercial Courses. Thorough reparation or college or business. Careful individua oe Excellent fable. Beautiful location. Circular free. Caas. W. Stuart, Prin. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, Chestnut Hil. RS.COMEG YS’ AND MISS BELL’S SOARDONS AND DAY SCHOOL Will reopen October 2, 1899. Students prepared for college. Virewta, Richmon NIVERSIT Y COLLEGE OF MEDI- CINE. 100 per cen}. made by 68 graduates this summer be- ap 6 differert State Examining Boards. For 88-pageC ee e address J. ALLISON Hop@Es, Proctor. ANDERBILT UNIVERSITY, Nashvilb, Tennessee.—Next session opens Sep- tember 20. Full graduate as well as undergraduate courses. 800 sudents last year. Seven Departments. Fully equipped jaboratories and museums. WILS WILLIAMS, Secretary. M85 ANABLE'S Boarding and Day , School for Girls, Established in 1848. Circular on application. Opens Sept. 28. 1350 Pine St., Phila., Pa. SCHOOL OF DRAWING AND PAINTING. MUSEUM OF FINE ARTS, BOSTON, MASS. — bc opens October 2, 1899. Cc. TARBELL, F. ee BENSON, ‘PHP HALE, Drawin nd eoint in PRA » Mode ling; Wi. si ait Ni, Decorative Design; Ee SON, Anatomy; A. K. Cross, Spameative. Free use of eo Galleries. Paige Foreign Scholarshi Men and Women. Helen Hamblen Scho fer ship. Ten Free Scholarships. Six cen in mo- ceri For circulars and terms addres MISS ELIZABETH LOMBARD. Manager. Dr. Holbrook’s School will reopen Wednesday, September 27, 6 P. M. Yale, Princeton, and Columbia examinations held at the school. Sine Srna, New York. MISS BALDWIN’S SCHOOL FOR GIRLS, BRYN MAWR, PA. Preparatory to Bryn Mawr College. Miss FLORENCE Batpwiy, Principal. Within eight yooee more than ninety pupils have entered Bryn awr College from this school. Diploma given in both General and College-Preparatory Courses. Fine, fire-proof stone building. 25 acres beautiful grounds. For circular. address the Secretary. ACADEMIC CLASSES its. A Boarding and Da ay School. College we reparations gaa advanced courses. Certificate accepted by Smith, sar, Wellesley, and Mt. Holyoke. Artistic maf = Swedish Gymnastics. Music De artment. th year. MARY B. WHITON, A.B., and LOIS A 43 West 47th Street, Ie a tak. FORESTRY SCHOOL, For circular _ vt a Cc. A. SCHENCK, Ph.D., Forester to the Biltmore Estate. MONTCLAIR MILITARY ACADEMY ation fi the ben cote a tific schools ‘or the best colleges, acien C. Psa og . Especiali, iw cordlel ve lations with Prince JouN G. MACVICAR, Head Master. ABBOT ACADEMY Fe" Pv on tg poe ag its 7ist — September 14, 1899, offering Seminary rses of Studies, and a College- atin Be = Address ‘ine Emu.y A, MEANS, For cataboned W . F, Draper. Pensionnat Francais of Vermont Aca- demy and Training School t. 19. F FOR reaceene ae OF rae er bey” ve . hentoc's ns River, near Bellows Falls, . Ags
Page 3
LSE EIT RS 9S hy kh) ita iat Ss ANN POY Aug. 31, 1899] Educational. Lasell Seminary FOR Young Women “In your bce ig and sitting so much more erect; in your general health; in your conversation; in your ay of meeti people; and in innumerable ways could see e benefit you are receiving from +. training aa associations at Lasell. _ All this you must know is very pans to me." This is what a father wrote to his daughter aie her return to school from the Christmas vacation at home. It is unsolicited testimony as to Lasell's success in some important lines. Places are now being taken for the year begin- ning September, 1899. Catalogue free. Cc. C. BRAGDON, Principal. AUBURNDALE, Mass. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 44 St. Botoiph St. The Allen Gymnasium TRAINING SCHOOL FOR TEACHERS. Definite Progressions for symmetry in develop- ment. The result of twenty-one years of practice and study. Two-year Course in Anatomy and Phy- siology, in theory and practical work. Circulars on nm application. MARY E. ALLEN Royal Vic oriaCollege | (McGILL UNIVERSITY, MONTREAL). This residential college for women-students of McWGill University will be opened on 14th Septem- ber next. For terms, etc., apply to the Secretary, McGill College, Montreal. The Detroit School for Boys DETROIT, MICH. Tenth Year begins Sept. 20th. A Home and Day School with Primary, Intermediate, and College Pre- aratory Departments. Full provision for English, odern Languages, Classics, Sciences, Music, Ma- nual Training, Physical Training. Receives boys between the ages of 6 and 18 years. on application. MASSACHUSETTS. CONCORD SCHOOL. “One 0 ¥: the most desirable preparatory schools in New Engiand.”—Wm. T. Harris, f ’ Com’r of Education. A Home as well as a School for the training of Ameri- can boys. Tenth year begins Sept ae To secure places, early application — re re et JAMES “GARLAND, Princ neipal. — Yew York University. eye SS ENCE and UNIVERSITY COLLEGE. For circulars address the Registrar, Washington ‘Square, New York City. THE PHILLIPS EXETER ACADEMY. The 117th year begins Sept. 13, 1899. Eighty Scho- larships awarded to students of high standing. Six im- — buildings added since 1886. For Catalogue and llustrated Su Pement, address HAR Re N P. AMEN, Principal, Exeter) N. H. Comprehends six Schools. The LAW School (with Day and Evening Class- es). Medical Graduate School, | Announcement i Mass. College. | Peda- | gogy, APPL 1ED SCI. | } | | ‘The Nation. Edie nal. HOWARD SEMINAR For GIRLS and | * YOUNG WOMEN | West Bridgewater. Maas, § p, 20, 1899. Terms $350 per year. College -Pre -paratory, and Spec fn courses. Art, Mu- sic, and Elocution. Well-equipped Library and La- boratories, fine Gymnasium. Miss SARAH E, LAUGHTON, Prin. BRADFORD ACADEMY. Founded 1803. For the higher education of young women. Classical and Scientific course of study; also Preparatory and Optional. Year begins Sept. 20, 1899. Miss Ida c. Allen, Prin., Bradford, Mass. ALLEN BROTHERS’ West Newton English and Classical S Family and Home School for both Sexes WEST NEWTON, MASS. Mr. and Mrs. John A. Bellows school. 17th year opens | Academic, | School Agencies. [CHE FISK TEACHERS AGENCIES. a3 Proprietors 4 Asht Washingt i56 Fift g. Minneapolis 730 Cox Kk. Loe Angeice 875 Wahas San Francts Gesany TEACHERS’ AGENC) if. Ui State St Albany, N. ¥ ’r as a of all grades with competent tea Aaniste teachers taining positions Haman I’. Frencn, Manag “CHERMERHORN'’S TEACHER S' » AGENCY Oldest and at k “ the ~ Established 1555 } ith St. N. ¥ THE PRATT TE ACHE RS’ AGENCY. WM. O. PRATT, Mgr.. ) Fifth Ave ,. New York (47th year.) | | ; FOR SALE will reopen their Boarding and Day School for Girls at | 115 Beacon Street, Boston, October 4, 1890. Certificate of Principals admits to Smith and Wellesley Colleges, 38 Nassau | ‘* Dwight NEW YORK /' St. New Method "’ LAW SCHOOL | y York City. /of Instruction. LL.B, {n two years; LL.M. in three years. High stand- ards. Prepares for bar of all States _ Gene for ¢ Catalogue. GEORGE CHASE, Yale Divinity School. A free education in Theology in a great univer- sity. For catalogue, etc.. apply to Prof. B. W. BACON, New Haven, Conn. Dean. Highland Military Academy Worcester, Mass 44th year. A home school. Preparatory of the first grade. Healthful loca tion. Newathietic field. Live teac ane. , Sanat classes Visitor: The Rt. Rev. Wm. Lawren D. Headmaster: JOSEPH AL DE 5 SH AW,AM. RHINELAND—A School for Girls. 72-84 Hooker Avenue, Poughkeepsie, N. Y. For circulars, address CHARLES E. FISH, Principal. Summer address, Cotuit, Mass. Teachers, etc. IBRARIAN.—FOUR YEARS EX- perience in one of largest American libraries—will act as assistant or take charge of town or college libra- ry. References as to scholarship and efficiency fur- nished on aplication to A. K. G., care of the Nation YOUR YEARS’ ACADEMICAL Course, preparatory to Yale, Vassar, etc., reduced to less than one year by private instruction. Pamphlet free. Rev. Wu. WEBER, Belleville, M1. REPARATION FOR COLLEGE BY a tutor of experience (Ph.D. Harv.). A pleasant home provided, with personal oversight, in ¢ ambridge, Highest re ferences. W., care Nation. W4 NTED.—BY EXPERIENCED / lady teacher, with best of references, position In rivate school. French a specialty. Has studied in Paris. Address P. O. Box 367, Plymouth, N. H FEXPERIENCED TUTOR will take _s pupils after September 10th fn Cambridge and Boston. Terms not low. Address * T. L.,” the Nation. 'HARLES W. STONE, Tutor for Har- vard, 68 Chestnut Street, Boston. Carteret School, Short Hills, N. J. Preparation for any College. -rivate Coaching when needed. A course to suit each para 8 need. Constant persona For information and Year-Book address nfluence of headmaster. Physical Training and Military Drill. Gymnasium, Laboratory, Casino. Tennis, Tetherball, Golf. References required from all pupils. ALFRED COLBURN ARNOLD, Headmaster. Maine Coast. A compact tract of 400 acres of innd in one of the most central positions on the malin land of Penobscot Bay. It has nearly four miles of bold rocky shore front, with beaches, coves and beautiful headlands. The land runs to high elevations, and has great topographical variety; pine woodland; meadows and grassy slopes There is a steamboat landing close by with dally service to and from Boston and the West It is within half an hour by steamboat from Isles boro and Castine There are several good farm houses on the property, an tce pond, and a trout brook. Salmon are taken on the shore. The land everywhere commands broad and beautiful views of an archipelago of islands, the broad bay, dia- tant sea, and mountains. The property ts offered for sale as a whole at a low price per acre to settle a joint account Photographs and further details may be obtained of zr MURRAY 28 State HOWE, Trustee, Street, Boston Travel. GOING ABROAD ON A BICYCLE TRIP? Send for “Bicycling Notes for Tourists Abroad,” 10 cents in stamps. The fine new steamers of the LEYLAND LINE Sail every Wednesday BOSTON TO LIVERPOOL. First cabin, winter, $37.50 and up nev. steamer Winifredian, 10,500 tons length, now in service P. O. HOUGHTON & CO., General Agents, 115 State Street, Boston. PARIS in 108. Splendid 570 feet in A word to the wise. Make of steamship and h tel accommodations now, + ‘fai ir rates pe ree ynally conducted parties. THE CRAWFORD it per Home Office 610 Tremont Bullding, Boston: 220 Bre mad way, New York; 1011 Chestnut Street, Philadelphia Summer Resorts. EUROPEAN SUMMER RESORT, INNSBRUCK, TYROL, AUSTRIA. 1,900 feet above the sea, with dry, bracing climate HOTEL TIROL. year Modern conventences Illustrated poms ta on — ation SWITZERLAND .. LAUSANNE. HOTEL RICHE-MONT. First-class hotel with moderate tariff Magnificent view over the lake and mountains. Lift, Large gardens batha, electric light ineveryroom. Patronized by Ame rican families. In winter very reduced pension terme Tariff and pamphieta sent free on application OOPERSTOWN—“OTSEGO HALL,’ small hotel near the lake. Well kept; chotce table; good boating and fishing: 2 golf courses. Now open J; INDERGARTEN SUPPLIES at SCHERMERHORN’S, 3 Fast 14th 8t., N. Send for New Catalogue Open all the ferences teat re We supply all the Publishers’ School Books at Lowest Wholesale Prices. Our Catalogue of the School and College Text-Books of all Publishers, containing Net and Mailing Prices and a Teice graphic Code revised to date, mailed gratis on application to THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO.. Wholesale Books, 5 and 7 E. 16th St., N.Y.
Page 4
The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1783 E:ducational. Johns Hopkins University, BALTIMORE, MARYLAND. TWENTY-FOURTH YEAR. Beginning October 1, 1899. Prestdent: Danret C. Gruman; Dean of the Medi cal School: Wrt1amM OsLER; Dean of the College:- Epwarp H. Grirrin. Instruction. For GRADUATE STUDENTS: (a) In Philosophy and the Arts. (Courses for candidates for the degree of Ph.D.) (b) In Medicine. (Courses for candidates for the degree of M.D.; courses for physicians. ) For UNDERGRADUATES: (c) As candidates for the degree of B.A. (d) As special students. Libraries. 90,000 volumes. 133,000 volumes. 190,000 volumes, University, Peabody Institute, Pratt Library, Laboratories. Directors. Physics. Henry A. Rowland, Chemistry. Tra Remsen, Geology and Mineralogy. William B. Clark. Zodlogy. William K. Brooks. Anatomy. Franklin P. Mall, Physiology. William H. Howell. Pathology and Bacteriology. William H. Welch. Pharmacology. Jokn J. Abel. Physiological Chemistry. John J, Abel. Clinical Medicine. William Osler. Seminaries. Directors. Greek. Basil L. Gildersleeve. Latin. Kirby F. Smith. Sanskrit. Maurice Bloomfield. Semitic. Paul Haupt. German. Henry Wood. Romance. A. Marshall Elliott. English James W. Bright. History. Herbert B. Adama. Sidney Sherwood. Thomas Craig. Joseph S. Ames, Economics. Mathematics. Physics. Undergraduate Courses (leading to B.A.) Groups . Classical (the “ old college course "’). 2. Mathematical-Physical (leading up to Engineering). . Chemical-Biological (leading up to Medicine). 4, Geological-Biological. _ a 5, Latin-Mathematical. . Historical-Political (leading up to Law). 7. Modern Languages. Editors. Simon Newcomb. Tra Remsen. Serial Publications. Mathematics (vol. XXI). Chemistry (vol. XXI). Philology (vol. XX). Basil L, Gildersleeve. History (vol. XVII). Herbert B. Adams, Modern Languages (vol. XIV).A. Marshall Elliott, Biology (vol. IV). William K, Brooks. Assyriology (vol. IV). Paul Haupt. Experimental Medicine (vol. IV), W. H. Welch. Programmes of the Courses offered to graduate students in Philosophy and the Arts, and in the School of Medicine, and also of the Undergraduate or Collegiate Courses, will be sent on application to the Registrar. , f @ WEBSTER'S DICTIONARY Every School and Teacher Should Own Webster’s International Dictionary of ENGLISH, Biography, Geography, Fiction, etc. STANDARD AUTHORITY of the U.S. Supreme Court, all INTERNATIONAL } the State Supreme Courts, the U. S. Government Printing Office, and of nearly all the Schoolbooks. Warmly commended by State Super- intendents of Schools, and other Educators almost without number. Charles W. Eliot, LL. D., President of Harvard University, says :— “The International is a wonderfully compact storehouse of accurate information.” @ WEBSTER'S COLLEGIATE DICTIONARY Next to the International, and Useful for Everybody is Webster’s Collegiate Dictionary This isa NEW BOOK —the latest and largest of the abridgments of the International, It has a sizable vocabulary, complete defini- tions and adequate etymologies. It has over 1500 pages and is richly illustrated. Size 7x 10x25-8 inches. A valuable feature of its appendix is a Glossary of Scottish Words and Phrases, giving as nowhere else the correct pronunciation of the Scottish dialect. Nicholas Murray Butler, Ph.D., Columbia University, New York, says: The Collegiate Dictionary is first class in quality and admirably adapted for everyday use. terse and con e stat WEBSTER’S DICTIONARIES EXCEL in the ease in which the eye finds the word sought; in er - definition; in effective methods of indicating ts of facts and in practical use as working dictionaries. ronunciation; in Specimen oat of woth books with full descriptions will be sent on application, G. & C. MERRIAM CO., Publishers, Springfield, Mass. HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO., Boston, New York, Chicago, WILL SEND ON APPLICATION THEIR NEW ILLUSTRATED EDUCATIONAL CATALOGUE ALSO DESCRIPTIVE CIRCULARS OF JOHN FISKE’S HISTORY OF THE UNITED STATES FOR SCHOOLS. $1.00, net. JOHN FISKE’S CIVIL GOVERNMENT IN THE UNITED STATES. $1.00, net. RIVERSIDE LITERATURE SERIES. Over 150 numbers. Paper and cloth, 15 to 60 cents, net. RIVERSIDE SCHOOL LIBRARY. 50vols. 50, 60, and 70 cents, net. ROLFE’S STUDENTS’ SERIES. teachers, 53 cents each. MODERN CLASSICS. 34 vols. Each, 40 cts., net. TRANSLATIONS FROM CLASSIC AUTHORS. CAMBRIDGE EDITIONS OF POETS. eer i ee OF AMERICAN LITERATURE. $1.00 oe OF BRITISH LITERATURE. aah nee SONG BOOK. Paper and boards, 80 and 40 cents, net. THE HIAWATHA PRIMER. 11 vols. To 40 cents, net. If you wish to learn a foreign language thoroughly in the shortest possible time, use the — . GASPEY-OTTO-SAUERgooxs which have a universal repeentian. The series consists of 100 text books for the study of 15 different lan Complete list free.—French German, Italian, Conversation Grammar $1. 60 each , key 40c. for the authorized edition published by C. A. KOEHLER & CO. 142. 2,Trement St. BOSTON,TIASS. Extensive stock of foreign books, importations, at vensonabie rates; # catalogues on application. panish each. Send Study and Practice of French in School IN THREE PARTS. By L.C.Boname, 258 South 16th St., Philadelphia A carefully graded course, meeting requirements for entrance examination at college tice in conversa- tion and thorou ope aril drill in Pronunctatio and Grammar. From Educat Boston: “A well-made sertes. Teach- ers = a will find the three books helpful and inte- reati FRENCH BOOKS “sas Complete Catalogue on application. ONVERSATIONAL FRENCH: Main- ly for Teachers, and self-tnstruction 8 Liprat- sona now ready at 10 oui each, Any one of me mailed on approval. KE. Rorg, 1186 Pine Bt., Phila. GANOT’S PHYSICS. Fifteenth Edition. Revised and Enlarged. By E. ATKINSON, Ph.D., F.C.S. THE STANDARD AUTHORITY UPON THIS SUBJECT IN THE LARGEST COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES IN THE WORLD. Copiously Illustrated. 1,142 Pages. Price Five Dollars. William Wood & Co., 51 Fifth Avenue, New York. Miudents “ss Se se. Sadar ne mae eter DET ALY Six oe Books Issued Yearly. New Book Every Day. F. TENNYSON NEELY, blishe Pu r, 114 FIFTH AVE., NBW YORK, Manuscripts Promptly Examined.
Page 5
Aug. 31, 1899] The Nation. V SCHOOL, TEXT, AND REFERENCE BOOKS The Latest Series. Lippincott’s Mental Arithmetics. Lippincott’s Elementary Arith- metics. Lippincott’s Practical Arithmetic. Cutter’s New Physiological Series. Beginner’s Physiology. | Intermediate Physiology. 'Morris’s Histories OF THE United States of America, OOMPRISING |Primary, Elementary, Advanced Comprehensive Physiology. | No recent publications have elicited Teachers who want the best text books ——— more flattering testimonials from teach on this important branch of school in- Adopted for exclusive use in all the | ers and school officers than these histo struction should examine this series. They contain new and valuable features. | and West Virginia. Worcester’ S : Dictionary Is the standard authority on all ques- tions of Orthography, Pronunciation, or Definition. The complete series consists of Quarto Dictionary, Public Schools of Virginia, PUBLISHERS OF Sharpless & Phillips’ Natural Philosophy. Sharpless & Phillips’ Astronomy. | Tennessee, | ries, and none praise them more highly | than those who are using them. | Every School Room SHOULD CONTAIN Lippincott’s Gazetteer World. Greene’s Lessons in Chemistry. | Lippincott Biographical Dictionary Bert’s First Steps in Scientific | | Chamsbeas's Encyclopedia. New Pocket Dictionary, a ‘ on hina pret «| Edition. er’s Principle an e 0 whensnagnisdlapersarecaptetey , T . hi Allibone’s Dictionary Authors. New School Dictionary, eacning. ; Comprehensive Dictionary, Carrington’s Patriotic Reader. Worcester’s Quarto Dictionary. Academic Dictionary, Carrington’s Columbian Selec- | Reader's Reference Library. 15 Royal Octavo Dictionary. tions. | vols. Price List and Special Terms for Introduction sent on application. Complete Educational List mailed on request. J. B. LIPPINCOTT COMPANY, Publishers, Philadelphia. HARPER'S: STANDARD TEXTS Phillips-Loomis Mathematical Series. ELEMENTS OF GEOMETRY. By Anprew W. PBSILLIPs, Ph.D., and Irvina Fisner, Ph.D., Professors in Yale University. Crown 8vo, Half leather, $1.75; by mail, $1.92. ELEMENTS OF GEOMETRY. Abridged. Crown 8vo, leather, $1.25; by mail, $1.40. Half PLANE GEOMETRY. Crown 8vo, Cloth, 80 cents; by mail, 90 cents. GEOMETRY OF SPACE. Crown 8vo, Cloth, $1.25; by mail, $1. 36, OBSERVATIONAL GEOMETRY. By Wituiam T. CaMPBELL, Boston Latin School. Post 8vo, Cloth, 80 cents; by mail, 90 cents. ELEMENTS OF TRIGONOMETRY —Plane and Spherical. by AnpREW W. Patties, Ph.D., and WenpELL M. Strona, Ph.D,, Yale University. Crown 8vo, Cloth, 90 cents; by mail, 98 cents. LOGARITHMIC AND TRIGONOMETRIC TABLES. Five place and four-place. By Anprew W. Pauutuips, Ph.D., and Wenpett M. Srrone, Ph.D., Yale University. Crown 8vo, Cloth, $1.00; by mail, $1.08, TRIGONOMETRY AND TABLES. In one volume. 8vo, Half leather, $1.40; by mail, $1.54. Crown Natural Science THE ELEPiENTS OF PHYSICS. By Josern S. Ames, Ph.D., and Henry A. Rowranp, Ph. D., LL.D., Professors of Physics in Johns Hopkins University. (Jn press.) THEORY OF PHYSICS. By Josern S. Ames, Ph. D., Asso ciate Professor of Physics in Johns Hopkins University. Crown 8vo, Cloth, $1.60; by mail, $1.75. A MANUAL OF EXPERIMENTS IN PHYSICS: tory Instruction for College Classes. By Josern S. Ames, Ph.D., Associate Professor of Physics in Johns Hopkins University, and Wituiam J. A. Briss, Associate in Physics in Johns Hopkins University. Crown 8vo, Cloth, $1.80; by mail, $1.95. Labora - INTRODUCTION TO ELESIENTARY PRACTICAL BIOLOGY. A Laboratory Guide for High Schools and College Stu dents. By CHartes Wricutr Dongs, M.S., Professor of Biology, University of Rochester. Crown 8vo, Cloth, $1.80; by mail, $1.95. COMPARATIVE ZOOLOGY, STRUCTURAL AND SYS- TEMATIC. For use in Schools and Colleges. By Jamus Orton, Ph.D. New edition, revised by Cuarites Wricut Dover, M.8., Professor of Biology in the University of Rochester. With 350 illustrations. Crown 8vo, Cloth, $1.80; by mail, $1.96. Special Rates to Teachers and for Introduction. HARPER & BROTHERS, Publishers, FRANKLIN SQUARE, N. Y.
Page 6
The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1783 Physics for High Schools THE MACMILLAN COMPANY Greek History BOTSFORD History of Greece. By GerorGe WILLIs Borts- FORD, Harvard University. 8vo Half Leather Price $1.10 Ten Full-page Maps. Nine Maps in the Text. Eleven Full-page Illustrations. Fifty-eight Illus- trations in the ‘ext. Sources. Topics. Marginal Notes and References. Tables. General History ADAMS European History: An Outline of its Devel- opment. By GrorGe BuRTON ADams, Pro- fessor of History, Yale University. 8vo Half Leather Price $1.40 Ten Full-page Maps. One hundred and twenty- five Illustrations. Sources. Topics for Assigned Studies. Tables of Dates. Marginal Notes. The book can be used, by following the text and tke tepics alone, for a one year’s course of study; and by using the references for additional study it gives a two-year course in Huropean history, the dividing point being at the reign of Charlemagne. and Academies CREW Elements of Physics. For use in Colleges and Secondary Schools. By Henry Crew, Ph.D., Professor of Physics in the North- western University. 12m0 Cloth $1.10 Art in Elementary Schools WILSON Picture Study in Elementary Schools. By L.,L. W. Witson, author of ‘* Nature Study in Klementary Schools,” etc. In four parts, with ninety-four full-page illustrations from famous painters, Cloth 12mo Ready in September There will be two manuals and two correspond- ing primers: the one set for primary grades, and containing fifty-two pictures in each; the other set for grammar grades, with forty-two pictures in each. The pictures used in the manual will be in each cage repeated in the primer. The manuals are designed to aid teachers in im parting to children a true appreciation of, and love for, the paintings by the world’s great masters. Pictures of famous and beautiful paintings are al- ready becoming widely used in elementary schools, and it is proposed to shape a course in picture study which shall carry the pupil through thechief schools of painting. English History COMAN and KENDALL History of England: The Growth of the Eng- lish Nation. By Miss KATHARINE CoMAN and Miss E. K. KENDALL, Wellesley College. 8vo Just Ready Thirty-one Maps. One hundred and twenty-five Illustrations. Sources. Lists of Important Events. Marginal Notes. Tables. American History CHANNING Students’ History of the United States. By EDWARD CHANNING, Harvard University. With Suggestions to Teachers. By ANNA BOYNTON THompson, Zhayer Academy, South Braintree, Mass, 8vo Half Leather Price $1.40 Fifty maps in color and otherwise. One Hun- dred and Twenty-six Illustrations, chiefly portraits. Each chapter is headed by a list of illustrative material of all kinds, and concludes with from two to six pages of —*" questions and topics. Marginal notes throughout. A New German Reader HEWETT A German Reader. Edited with Vocabulary and Notes. By WaTERMAN T. Hewett, Ph.D., Professor of German Language and Literature in Cornell University. 12mo Cloth $1.00 Selections are graded and classified by subjects. Contains 20 that are Elementary, 40 Poetical, 7 His- torical, 2 Complete Prose (Immensee and Auf der Eisenbahn), and 2 Dramatic. Rhetoric and Composition CARPENTER Elements of Rhetoric and English Composi- tion. (First High School Course.) By G.R CARPENTER, Professor of Rhetoric and English Composition in Columbia University . 12mo Cloth 60 Cents. CLEVELAND Letters from Queer and Other Folk. By Heten M. Cievecranp, Part I. A Manual for Teachers. Part II. Reader for Grammar Grades. Part III. Reader for Primary Grades, Cloth 12mo Ready in September. THE MACMILLAN COMPANY, 66 Fifth Avenue, New York BOSTON CHICAGO SAN FRANCISCO
Page 7
The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, AUGUST 31, 1899. The Week. President McKinley was in great form on Friday when he made his speech to the church militant at Ocean Grove. He declared that his policy in the Philip- pines was: “Peace first; then, with charity for all, es- tablish a government of law and order, pro- tecting life, property, and occupation, for the well being of the people—a government in which they shall participate under the stars and stripes.”’ Peace first by means of ten new regi- ments! Gunpowder and ball with chari- ty for all, and the whole gamut of hypocrisy described by Tacitus in words that have rung through the ages, “‘Soli- tudinem faciunt, pacem appellant’— They make a solitude and call it peace. But what would you do? say the would- be missionaries, Methodist and other, who throw the cloak of religion over this welter of blood. We would do what Admiral Dewey recommended in his in- terview in the London Daily News of August 21, viz.: “T have never been in favor of violence to- wards the Filipinos. The islands are at this moment blockaded by a fleet, and war reigns in the interior. This abnormal state of things should cease. I should like to see autonomy first conceded, and then annexa- tion might be talked about. This is my opinion. I should like to see violence at once put a stop to. According to my view, the concession of self-government ought to be the most just and most logical solution.” Those words ought to be printed in letters of gold, and no places would be more fit for their display than the plat- form of the Auditorium at Ocean Grove and the entrance to the White House at Washington city. How rapidly the situation in the Phi- lippines changes from week to week, and always against the policy of sub- jugation, is shown by the news that native mayors, supposed to be in sym- pathy with the Americans, have been put in jail for conspiring to aid the insurgents. One of them, in fact, is said to hold a Colonel’s commission in the Filipino army. Yet it was only two or three months ago that the accept- ace of office by these men was trumpet- ed abroad as a convincing proof of the peaceful spread of American rule. There we were setting up municipal govern- ments. Couldn’t the blind anti-imperial- ists see that the natives hailed our com- ing, and were glad, as soon as protect- ed from the savage Aguinaldo, to accept our beneficent sway? Well, here are these pet mayors of ours risking their lives to work for Philippine indepen- dence. The very men whom President Schurman and the other Philippine Commissioners were pointing to as tri- umphant evidence of the readiness of the better class to welcome American control, are now shown to have been actively recruiting for the Filipino army. It will not do to dismiss them as treacherous scoundrels. They are our own chosen scoundrels, if scoundrels they are; and if they have tricked us and left us a laughing-stock, that only shows into what perils and pitfalls we have walked. It is reported from Washington that Gen. Otis has decided to extend to the Philippines the law excluding the Chi- nese from the United States. What rea- son exists for such action it is difficult to conjecture. Perhaps the intention is to keep the Chinese at home in order that we may deal with them there. But other nations can get at them in China, while if we let them come to the Philip- pines we may secure a monopoly of their trade. All accounts agree that the Chi- nese element is the most tractable that we have to do with, and that it is the most industrious and progressive. Our Government passed the exclusion laws because they were demanded by the people of our Pacific Coast States. The Chinese were pouring in in such num- bers as to excite a fear that they would outnumber the whites, and the laboring class was especially violent in its pro- test against their competition. It is stated that the native Filipinos are also strongly opposed to “Chinese cheap labor,” and one of the diplomatic agents of our Government writes from Manila that the exclusion of the Chinese would aid materially in bringing the war to a close. If our Government is reduced to such expedients as this to aid its mili- tary operations, the situation is indeed desperate. The Chinese have on all ra- tional grounds a better right to be in Manila than we have. Many thousands of them have long been there. They carry on most of the retail trade, and their influence has been described as valuable by Admiral Dewey. To forbid their immigration is not only to insult the Chinese Government, but is plainly injurious to the prosperity of the Philip- pines. It seems incyedible that so doubtful a measure as this should have been adopted for no better reason than the hope of propitiating malcontent Filipinos; but no other explanation is suggested. The expenditure for the army during the last two months is said to amount to $30,000,000, or half a million dollars a day. What Congress appropriated for this purpose was not far from $80,000,000, which will be exhausted, at the present rate of outgo, before next December. It is urged that a good deal of this expendi- ture is on account of contracts that have now been completed. On the other hand, | the army is being rapidly increased, and the additional expenditure will be very considerable. Furthermore, the cost of maintaining troops will necessarily be greater this year than last. Nearly all prices have risen, and in some cases the rise has been very great. Possibly Mr. Root may develop such abilities as a war minister as to expel jobbery from the Department; but the task is formidable. Some fifteen months ago, the Govern ment hired two steamers on the Pacific Coast, worth perhaps, $250,000 apiece, at the rent of $1,000 a day, all operating expenses being assumed in addition. Af- ter twelve months one of these steamers was returned to the owners, but the other is still retained by the Govern- ment, at the same rent. Now that the war is to be prosecuted with renewed vigor, this vessel will probably be kept in service for another year. There is no- thing exceptional in such jobs as this. They are necessary incidents of war, and, if the people disapprove of them, they should demand that the war be stopped. On some accounts we are glad to see that the disbursements are at such a rate as will require application to Congress for enlarged appropriations. They will not be granted with the same haste as in the past, and the attention of the people will be called to the price which they are paying for a very doubt- ful kind of military glory. Quay met in convention at Harrisburg on Thursday and heartily endorsed Quay. He also had a good word to say for his supporter in the White House. Quay declared himself proud of the Pennsylva- nia troops. If they are proud of him, the commonwealth is secure. He renewed his promise to the Cramps of a subsidy for the ships they build. Quay resolved that he was for everything that is good for the State and nation, and especially for himself. That is a faithful summary of the so-called Republican State conven- tion at Harrisburg. All accounts agree that there was never a convention in the State so boss-ridden, with the delegates so listless, with nominations and pledges of future nominations so minutely and tyrannically determined in advance. As the free expression of the mind of the party, or even of that of the Quay goods and chattels who composed the conven- tion, it would be ridiculous to take its action and resolutions. The whole thing was simply designed to show that Quay is supreme boss, his power unimpaired by the revelations of last winter, moral- ly damning as they were. It also was de- signed to show Mr. McKinley that he,
Page 8
160 The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1783 with the “great moral earnestness” which Col. Hay has said is his chief characteristic, has done just right in standing by Quay through thick and thin, in spite of the protests of the mind and conscience of the Republican party in Pennsylvania. “Let them kick, Mr. President,” is what Quay says in effect; “I will furnish you the delegates just the same,” One searches the Pennsylvania plat- form in vain for warm approval of the President’s Philippine policy. It simply promises him support in “the prosecu- tion of the war,” in order that “the su- premacy of the flag may be maintained,” Not a word about the wisdom of taking the islands, or the desirability of keep- ing them. In this respect the Pennsyl- vania Republicans imitate the example of their brethren in Iowa and Kentucky, and even in Ohio. They shy awkwardly at the Philippine issue, and are evident- ly prepared to bolt and run from it, if political safety seems to lie that way. The Ohio Republicans are heartily in favor of “a wise solution” of the Philip- pine problem, and, sotto voce, wish to heaven they knew what it was. The Kentucky Republicans are going to sup- port Mr. McKinley until he establishes “order and progressive government” in the Philippines, but they evidently wish he would be a little quicker about it. So it goes. A President who does not know his own mind has behind him party lead- ers who are afraid of their horses. The demand for iron and steel has so far outstripped the supply that the export of these metals has fallen off and some importations have taken place in lines which are usually abundant at home. Structural iron is in particular demand, but all the mills are filled with orders from four to twelve months ahead. The supply of ore is not equal to the demand. The number of lake vessels fit for carrying ore is likewise deficient. In short, all people seem to want iron at the same time. Now, is not this a favorable time to repeal the duty on iron ore? The revered Dingley put a tax of 40 cents on it, and also on the sea water or other dampness that might be absorbed by it in the course of transit. There is plenty of iron ore in Cuba actually owned by American citizens who cannot get the use of their own property without paying a fine of 40 cents per ton. If this iron ore were obtainable, it would, of course, take the place of some of the manufactured iron which, under the stimulus of the pre- sent excessive demand, comes in from abroad over the top of tke Dingley tariff. The merits of the controversy over the advance in the price of beef are not easily determined. There are so many causes in operation as to make it im- possible to tell the effect of particular ones, and we may add that so many reckless statements of fact are made as to obscure the whole question. It seems to be undisputed, however, that the price of live cattle in the West has materially advanced. At Omaha, for example, steers are selling for a half more than they have brought in recent years. This disposes of the charge that the recent advance of prices in this city is due to the arbitrary action of the great butch- ering companies. They have raised the price of meat because they have to pay more for cattle. On the other hand, it is quite probable that their charges were unreasonably high before, and are still unreasonably high. They are protected against competition, except among them- selves, by the extent and completeness of their organizations. They have per- fected the art of butchering, they have developed the art of utilizing by-pro- ducts, they have created the art of re- frigeration, and they have made an art of transportation. It is obvious that any attempt to compete with such organi- zations must be on a large scale, must be scientifically planned, and must be very ably managed. Considering the increased demand for meat for exportation, the growth of population, and the ability of the people to pay for meat because of their present prosperity, the general tendency of prices, and the probable shortage in the supply of cattle, it seems doubtful if the butchers of this city can succeed in lowering the cost of beef by their proposed combination. The Alaska boundary question rises out of the fog and falls back into it with admired regularity, but fails to cause any excitement on this side of the line. The latest thing heard on the other side was that the Canadian Gov- ernment, despairing of justice from the United States, had resolved to build a railroad on their own territory from some port of their own to the Klondike or to the navigable waters flowing thith- er. This proposal was quite generally acquiesced in by Americans. At all events no objection could be advanced against it. If Canada can afford to build 700 miles of railroad through a barren country, a road which will have to be operated at a heavy loss, all right. Undoubtedly she can afford it, for she has done such things before when she was much poorer than she is now. No- body here will lift a finger to prevent her. Yet it would be a pity to waste s0 much money, and we do not believe that Canada really intends to do so. She already enjoys a right of way across our territory from the head of the Lynn Canal to White Pass. She can send goods in bond from Skagway just as she sends them through Portland, Me., to Montreal, and as we send from Buffalo to Detroit via the Canada Southern Rail- way. In fact, this bonding privilege is all that she needs commercially. Some little delay, due to formalities, is met with in passing the custom-house, but it is not attended with any expense. When the goods arrive at White Pass, they cross the Canadian boundary duty free, of course, while American goods taking the same route are subjected to the Canadian tariff before they can reach the Klondike market. This protective tariff, coupled with the railroad, has al- ready killed the town of Dyea and is fast sapping the life of Skagway. These places, while they were outfitting-posts for travel to the Klondike, did a roaring business, but since the White Pass rail- way has reduced the necessary outfitting to small proportions, the prosperity of the towns on the Lynn Canal has greatly declined, for although goods continue to go through, they do not break bulk; they leave no toll except the wages of freight- handlers. Now, under these circum- stances, while the Canadians are making nearly all the profit out of the Klondike trade, and the towns of Dyea and Skag- way are either dead or decaying, why should there be so much tail-lashing at Ottawa? Why should Premier Laurier talk about arbitration or war or a new railroad to the Klondike, and why should Sir Charles Tupper tell of his deter- mination to stand by the Government to the last extremity? Evidently, because one of them represents the ins and the other the outs of Canadian politics. They are enjoying now all the profit they could obtain by a new railroad—that is, a virtual monopoly of the Klondike trade. They have everything they could desire except the spectacle of their own flag waving over a port on the Lynn Canal. Facts must prevail in the long run, and this convinces us that a settle- ment of the boundary question will be reached ere long without either arbitra- tion or war or a new railroad 700 miles long. The reappearance of M. Labori in the Dreyfus trial, and the mental vigor he has displayed, have already had a con- siderable influence in changing public opinion as to the result of the trial. It is now evident that the assassin fired at the right man, for in disabling Labori he took out of the court-room the one man whom the prosecution stands most in fear of, the one man who knows most about the case, the one upon whom the defence leans with the greatest confi- dence. If Labori’s strength holds out, the tissue of perjury and forgery which the Court of Cassation partly exposed will be riddled to the satisfaction of the lovers of truth throughout the world. Every dodge, every meanness of the prosecuting witnesses has been con- es
Page 9
Aug. 31, 1899] The Nation. 161 fronted by Labori with merciless logic, and with indignation of the contagious sort that must have its effect even upon a prejudiced court-martial. Gen. Mercier is rapidly becoming chief villain of the Dreyfus tragedy, and, | luckily, he is meeting the usual dramatic fate of villains in being exposed and | overwhelmed with confusion. A whole series of his lies and perjuries was thrown to the ground on Saturday by the testimony of Capt. Freystatter, member of a cier, then Minister of War, had illegally submitted evidence in secret to the judges, and whether, in particular, he had included the famous Panizzardi dispatch in a translation which he knew to be incorrect. First Mercier denied having done it at all; then asserted that if Col. Sandherr or some other man now dead had sent in the dispatch along with the other documents of the secret dos- sier, it was in the form which the Foreign Office certified to be correct and which exonerated Dreyfus. now Capt. Freystatter declares that it was precisely the fraudulent translation of the Italian attaché’s dispatch which Gen. Mercier, knowing it to be fraudu- | lent, caused to be read to the judges. This, we suppose, is the basis for the rumor that Mercier himself is to be arrested and court-martialled. His cool audacity did not entirely desert him in the face of Freystitter’s revelations. That officer had said something about Dreyfus having been suspected of selling the secret of the Robin shell. An evi- dent lie! cried Mercier, as the Robin shell was not in use before 1895. Will it be believed that Gen. Mercier himself spoke of the same charge against Drey- fus in his testimony of August 11? There it stands in the Figaro’s steno- graphic report, the “secret de l’obus Robin.” Surely a very shallow as well as a daring villain is this Mercier. The part which French yellow jour- nalism has had in keeping alive the myths and passions and prejudices which are the only real evidence of Dreyfus’s crime, is well brought out by M. Guerlac in his letter in the Tribune of Monday. What with clerical organs | of slander like the Croir, furious anti- | Semite papers such as the Libre Parole, | and the shrieking army-worshipping and foreigner-hating Petit Journal, with its tirculation of more than 1,000,000, the difficulty of making the truth known in France begins to be seen. It is these newspapers, affirms M. Guerlac, which have fooled the majority of the nation. Even the reports of the present trial | they grossly color and pervert. They make out Mercier and Boisdeffre and Gonse national heroes, giving triumph- ant proofs of Dreyfus’s guilt, and repre- the court-martial of 1894. | The issue of veracity was whether Mer- | But | sent Col. Picguart as a sneaking dri- | veller, with his face stamped all over with cowardice and duplicity. Take, for example, the way in which the Petit Journal treated the attempted assassina- tion of Labori. It almost suppressed | mention of the crime, giving to it only | a few casual lines. By way of comment, | it spoke of the atrocious assault as a “regrettable incident,” which “one can- not but condemn, and we do not hesitate to do so”; but then it proceeded to argue that the crime was the very natural re- | tort to the hooting of Mercier by the crowd on the previous Saturday, so that the real responsibility lay with the Drey- fusards! It is against such formidable | engines of mendacity that the mind and conscience of France have to struggle |in their attempt to convert popular opinion. Mr. Chamberlain’s speech about the Transvaal situation on Saturday was disquieting mainly because it showed his impatience and determination to | bring matters speedily to a crisis. He complained that Kriiger was slow and | grudging in all his concessions; that they had to be squeezed out of him like water out of a sponge. What of that? Is that not the usual way of diplomacy? The chief question is whether the con- cessions are actually made or not. There is every reason to think that Kriiger has now conceded all that Sir Alfred Milner demanded. But, as is natural, he wants something in return, and that is, a promise that England will respect the independence of the Trans- vaal. Why should Mr. Chamberlain refuse this? Only three years ago he said it would be “immoral” for England to interfere in-any way with the inde- pendence of the Boers. Oom Paul on his side might complain that Chamberlain’s demands are always rising; that it is impossible to satisfy him. The situation is unquestionably grave, more so through Parliament not being in session; but we still believe that Lord Salisbury will re- strain “pushful Joe,’ and not allow him to plunge Great Britain into a needless war. Meanwhile, both sides are pushing forward their preparations for the final struggle. In view of the complaints made by the British Government of the oppression of its subjects in the Transvaal Republic, it should be observed that only white men’s rights are considered. The na- _ tives of British India are subjects of the Empress Victoria, but they do not have | the rights of English citizens. They have no political rights, and their legal rights are limited. The Legislature of their Indian fellow-subjects from that colony. It has | ! Natal .has taken measures to exclude | levied a capitation | | tax on them, which is quite as oppres- | | sive as the tax levied on the Outlanders | the Dortmund-Ems canal by the Boers. The Dominion of Canada imposes a tax of $50 on every Chinaman that enters that country, British Columbia has lately tried to keep out the Japanese. It seems that the Japanese have been pouring into that province at an alarming rate, with the usual result of furnishing “‘Asiatic cheap labor,” and when they have established themselves they show no disposition to go What is most startling is the fact that the Japanese Government impudence to suggest that, after a cer- tain period of residence, the Japanese in British Columbia should be given the franchise. The Dominion has been obliged to veto the exclusion law of Columbia, and Mr. Joseph Cham berlain is reported to have suggested that the Natal act might be copied. To this the Columbian authorities reply that the Japanese Government would probably regard that as an unfriendly proceeding, and the problem remains un- settled. Evidently the admission of Ja- pan to the status of a civilized Power may have awkward consequences. It implies that the Japanese are on a level with white people, and must be treated like the subjects of the European states. To refuse them the franchise in the Do- minion of Canada, after the claims that Great Britain has made for the Out landers in the Transvaal, may have an air of inconsistency which cannot easily be explained away. and away has had the Government Emperor William has again run against that ridiculous provision of the law which compels him to ask money of a popular assembly. When he opened some three weeks ago, he broadly hinted to the Prussian Diet that he expected a prompt vote of the money necessary to com- plete a system of waterways stretching right across Germany, and connecting the Rhine, the Weser, the Elbe, the Oder, and the Vistula. But the refractory Diet refused the grant by large majori- ties. It was those stout and consistent Protectionists, the Agrarians, who did the mischief. They do not want im- proved internal communications which would simply increase the facilities for bringing in foreign agricultural! products and foreign timber. To them, the opi- nion of a British vice-consul that the Dortmund-Ems canal would be “dis- tinctly favorable to British shipping,” was enough to condemn all such pro- jects. So they braved the wrath of the Emperor, and flatly refused him his money. That potentate is in a fury, and is calling his Cabinet to task for having allowed such a rebuff to fall upon him. But dismissing a Minister or two will not go to the root of the trouble. It ought to be made treason to deny the Emperor any sums he may demand, and the whole Diet should be drowned in’ the canal. Their successors would then be more reasonable. up
Page 10
162 The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1783 THE TRUTH IS NOT IN HIM. Mr. McKinley has broken his long silence on the Philippine question. He has also broken something else, as we shall proceed to show. What he as- serted in his speech at Pittsburgh on Monday is doubtless what he would like to believe to be true, but the facts are otherwise. We shall set forth as dispas- sionately as possible some of Mr. Mc- Kinley’s perversions of the truth. To begin with, he said: “Until the treaty was ratified we had no authority beyond Manila city, bay, and har- bor. We then had no other title to defend, no authority beyond that to maintain. Spain was still in possession of the remainder of the archipelago. Spain had sued for peace. The truce and treaty were not concluded.” Very good; then by what title or authority did William McKinley assert on December 21, 1898, seven weeks be- fore the treaty was ratified, sovereignty over all the Philippine Islands? In his proclamation of that date he declared that “with the signature of the treaty of peace the future control, dis- position, and government of the Philip- pine Islands are ceded to the United States.”” He went on to announce that, “in fulfilment of the rights of sovereign- ty thus acquired,” he proposed to im- mediately occupy and administer “the entire group of the Philippine Islands.’ In other words, what the President now says he could not do legally, he did do. Boasting now that “every step taken was in obedience to the requirements of the Constitution,’ he compels attention to the fact that his proclamation of De- cember 21, 1898, was in flat violation of the Constitution. If he could, as he then asserted, proceed to occupy and adminis- ter the entire group, then his excuse for doing nothing outside of Manila falls to the ground. If, as he now says, it would have been illegal to assert title to the islands before the treaty was ratified, then he is a confessed law-breaker, for such title he did assert. We prefer (to quote his own language) to “leave to others the ungracious task of justifica- tion and eulogy.” Mr. McKinley declared further that his purpose in originally sending troops to Manila was to “emancipate” the na- tives, and that, therefore, they should have been our “firmest friends.” Well, it was not the fault of the Filipinos that eternal friendship was not sworn on the spot. They were for months most profuse in their expressions of gratitude and admiration and attachment. If ever a statesman had an easy task, it was that of consolidating the amity which existed for months at Manila between Filipinos and Americans. But all was turned to bitterness and hatred. Why? Because the Filipinos discovered that, whatever might be the case with Dewey and the other officers on the scene, the tovernment at Washington was insin- cere in its fair words. This is not a matter of opinion. There is an official , document on record which shows how hollow are these later pretences of an in- tention te “emancipate” the Filipinos. As early as June 16, 1898, the Secretary of State, Judge Day, wrote a letter to Consul Pratt in which the real purpose of this Government respecting the na- tives was revealed. Warning the Consul against having any relations with the Filipino leaders, Mr. Day said: “This Government has knownthe Philippine in- surgents only as discontented and rebel- lious subjects of Spain’; and went on: “The United States, in entering upon the occupation of the islands, will expect from the inhabitants 7 that obedience which will be lawfully due from them.” There is the announc- ed purpose of the McKinley Adminis- tration a month and a half after Dewey’s victory—the islands to be seized, the na- tives to be subdued. The President’s most unblushing dis- tortion of the truth was his assertion that it is only “the will of one man” that keeps the Filipinos from submit- ting, and that the insurgents “in no sense represent the sentiment of the people.” This is antecedently incredi- ble, and it also flies in the face of a mass of evidence to the contrary which is simply overwhelming. Not alone news- paper representatives, but army officers and commanders of our ships, report the situation of our troops in the islands as that of besieged men. If ever there was proof that a foreign invasion was dashing itself against a strong and ris- ing national sentiment, we have that proof in the Philippines. Napoleon did not find it more marked in Spain or Russia. In the very newspapers con- taining the President’s speech are dis- patches from a trusted Philippine cor- respondent, saying, “The only friendly natives I found on my southern tour were the Moros [Mr. McKinley’s poly- gamous and _ slaveholding protégés]. Even the non-combatants hate us. In Manila the native feeling against us is growing stronger every day.” And the same day we get the testimony of the Rev. Peter MacQueen, long in the isl- ands as chaplain of the First California volunteers, to the following effect: “There is not aFilipino in the islands that wants the American form of government. There was a time when the conquest of the islands might have been completed with comparatively little bloodshed, and that was immediately after Dewey’s victory. Since that time the policy has been such as to en- courage resistance.” We are content to leave the Presi- dent’s assertions and the facts to con- front each other. But we are heartily glad he has spoken out. He has now committed himself to the policy of sub- jugation. He has staked his political fortunes on the popularity with Ameri- cans of a merciless war upon millions of men of another race, half way round the globe, who resent and repudiate our pretensions to rule over them. Unless the country we have known and loved has suddenly become a cruel nation of conquerors, the ultimate fate of such a President and such a policy cannot be in doubt. RECOGNIZING SLAVERY. The Tribune of Friday morning con- tained an editorial article pointing out that, muddled and scarcely intelligible as a large part of the charter of New York is, the provision that no president of a borough shall have a vote in the Board of Public Improvements except upon matters relating exclusively to his own borough “is absolutely lucid, yields its full meaning at a single glance, and is incapable of supporting the claim based upon it under any torture.” The Tribune adds: “If it can be held to mean that the bo- rough presidents can vote on the water scheme, then the provision making the May- or’s term four years may as well be held to mean that the Mayor’s term is two years or five, and article xiii. of the Federal Consti- tution be construed as permitting slavery to exist in any part of the United States.” On another page the Tribune published the Associated Press dispatch from Manila, which announced that Gen. Bates had returned there from Sulu, having succeeded, ‘“‘after five weeks’ negotiation with much tact,” in securing the signing of an agreement with the Sultan of the Moros. By this agreement American sovereignty over the Moros is recognized, and the United States may occupy and control “such parts of the archipelago as public interest demands.” The Ame- ricans are to continue paying the Sultan the same subsidy which he got from Spain; the Americans are to protect the Moros against foreign imposition; Ame- rican courts are to have jurisdiction, “except between the Moros”; the in- troduction of firearms shall be prohibit- ed, piracy shall be suppressed, and there shall be no persecution on account of re- ligion. “Domestic institutions’ among the Moros are not disturbed. One of these institutions is slavery. Mr. John Fore- man, in his ‘Philippine Islands,’ says on this point: “The Mussulmans (called by the Spaniards Moros) now extend over the whole of Mindanao Island, and the sultanate of Sulu, which comprises Sulu Island and about 149 others, 80 to 90 of which are uninhabited. Slavery exists in a most ample sense. There are slaves by birth, and others by conquest, such as prisoners of war, in- solvent debtors, and those seized by pira- tical expeditions to other islands.” Prof. Dean C. Worcester, now a mem- ber of the Philippine Commission, in his ‘Philippine Islands,’ says: “We soon found that the slave business still flourished in Tawi Tawi. Girls of fifteen years were valued at three cabans (about five bushels) of rice. One was offered to us at Tataiin for three dollars in cash. The proposition was a secret one, for while Don Felipé [the Spanish commander] could not control the Moros on the south coast, he would have no slave-catching or selling about his corner of the island. He told us that the slave-dealers had no difficulty in selling all the able-bodied men they could
Page 11
Aug. 31, 1899] The Nation. capture to the Dutch planters in Borneo—a fact which affords one more illustration of the benefits that civilization sometimes brings to a benighted land!”’ The thirteenth amendment to the Constitution of the United States de- clares that “neither slavery nor involun- tary servitude, except as a punishment for crime, whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.” It is an interest- ing fact that the amendment, as origi- nally introduced by Senator Henderson of Missouri, provided that slavery or involuntary servitude “shall not exist in the United States.” The Judiciary Com- mittee, through its chairman, Senator Trumbull of Illinois, reported it back with a change in the form of the pro- hibition, and the addition, after “the United States,” of the words, “or any place subject to their jurisdiction.” In presenting the revised draft to the Se- nate on the 28th of March, 1864, Mr. Trumbull emphasized this point: “It is a proposition so to amend the Con- stitution of the United States as for ever to prohibit slavery within its jurisdiction.” The United States in 1864 possessed no “place subject to their jurisdiction” outside the bounds of the States, Terri- tories, and District of Columbia, which constituted the Union. A prohibition of slavery “in the United States” would have prevented its existence wherever our government had jurisdiction. But the opposition to the “peculiar institu; tion” was so earnest, and the determina- tion that this government should never again lend any favor to it was so strong, that the Republican leaders decided to cover all possible contingencies in the indefinite future. They therefore so amended the Constitution that if the nation should afterwards, as it did only three years later, acquire Alaska, there should be no danger of slavery existing there, and that in whatever remote cor- ner of the world the flag of the republic should ever wave, the mere fact that the United States held jurisdiction should of itself mean freedom to all the in- habitants. As the Tribune says of the clause in the New York charter regard- ing the voting power of a borough pre- sident in the Board of Public Improve- ments, the language of the amendment “is absolutely lucid, yields its full mean- ing at a single glance.” The idea that the thirteenth amend- ment might be construed as _ permit- ting slavery to exist anywhere that the United States government holds juris- diction rightly seemed to the writer of the Tribune article unthinkable. Yet that is precisely what the McKinley Ad- ministration is doing. The government of the United States is to exercise sove- reignty over the Moros, and at the same time it is to allow the continuance of slavery in this “place subject to their jurisdiction.” The war with Spain was begun “in the cause of humanity,” and | | “for the sake of freeing the oppressed.” The latest development in the train of events which has followed is this pro- position of the McKinley Administra- tion to construe the thirteenth amend- ment as permitting slavery to exist un- der the jurisdiction of the United States. What do the clergy, the religious or- ganizations, the missionary societies think of this? PHASES OF THE NEGRO PROBLEM. During the past week the war in the | Philippines has been thrust somewhat into the background by the news from | the nearer conflict between whites and blacks in the State of Georgia. ten days ago, Henry Delegal, politician of Darien, Ga, made an as- sault on a white woman—or was charged with having made such an assault. Dele- gal was soon arrested. The negroes con- { About | a black | ceived the idea that he was to be lynched | —‘falsely conceived” the idea, the whites say, but not unnaturally, any candid ob- | server must admit. When the Sheriff started on Wednesday to remove Delegal from Darien to Savannah for safe-keep- ing, “the negroes dropped everything to go to his rescue,” and surrounded the jail. ernor for aid, and 200 militiamen were sent from Savannah. rioters were then made by the dozen. Two of Delegal’s sons ‘were badly wanted,” and two white deputy-sheriffs went after them. They apparently sub- mitted to arrest, and then fired upon ‘ : the guilty persons. The Sheriff appealed to the Gov- | Arrests of black | the sheriffs, one of whom was wound- | ed by John Delegal and _ soon while the other was threatened with instant death by a crowd of negroes, and had a narrow escape. Of course, this intensified the excitement. The negroes practically deserted Darien and took to the swamps. They threw out pickets and sent in word that they would not submit to arrest. The whites sent to every convict camp in the State for bloodhounds, dispatched an armed posse on horseback to the scene of the trouble, organized another posse to go by spe- died, cial train, and sent a steamer to Bruns- | wick to bring as many volunteers as could be secured. Early Saturday morn- ing operations began. Every negro found as the white forces advanced was arrested. Women and children, as well as men, were placed under guard to pre- vent information from being carried across the country to the eight cabins which had been the Delegal stronghold. The cabins were searched without result, | | comfort and expenditure are pitched on and then “the swamps were being beaten closely while the soldiers lined out on the bluffs, prepared to send a volley into the negroes as they came before the posse,” when Henry Delegal’s aged mother came out and arranged for his surrender. He was lodged in jail at Darien on Saturday night, and there was at once “a noticeable decrease of negro |a lower scale, 163 talk: the surrender of Delegal and the arrival of additional troops having com- pletely unnerved those in Darien.” On Sunday it was thought prudent to send home some of the troops, while the rest remained in camp until after the special term of court to try Henry Delegal, John Delegal, and thirty-five black But the country is. still alarmed. rioters thoroughly been inte resting the between the two races in the neighbor ing State of Florida. A white politician named Crum was recently postmaster at Peck, Fla., and negro for his clerk. Last week a party of “whitecaps’” violently attacked Crum, whipped him cruelly, and poured carbolic acid upon the lacerated flesh. He is still confined to his bed and suf- fering terribly. The colored deputy has fled from the neighborhood in fear of his life. The Federal Government im- mediately ordered the of the post-office, and offered a reward of $200 each for the apprehension of This caused great indignation among the whites. Two post-office inspectors who went to Peck have not returned. It is reported that the residents will not allow them to and fears for their safety are entertained. The United Dis- trict Attorney, with six deputy marshals from Jacksonville, went to Peck on Sat- urday night with warrants for the ar- rest of sixteen whitecaps, took the town by surprise, and bagged seven without resistance. When they went back on Sunday for the rest, armed guards along the road tried to them, though without success; but armed men since been on the alert throughout the neighborhood, determined to prevent the arrest of any more of their people. The officers sent for reinforcements, and propose to execute the rest of the war- rants at all hazerds. In the State of South Carolina a new aspect of the trouble between whites and blacks has developed. A number of outrages were recently committed upon negroes at Greenwood, 8S. C., by whitecaps. The blacks had committed no crime, and had not tried to hold even so petty an office as a clerkship The only trouble was that they live more cheaply than the whites. It is a region where land-owners rent their holdings largely to tenants. Of course, they want to get the largest possible returns. The small white farmers find that the blacks, whose standards of Meanwhile, there have developments in relations appointed took a discontinuance leave, States stop have ean afford to offer a higher rental, and they are thus pushing the whites out of the most productive land. The whites have consequently taken to whipping the blacks by night, in the hope of frightening them away. Here are three phases of the race problem presented almost simultaneous-
Page 12
164 The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1783 ly in three adjoining States in the “black belt.” Any one of them alone, because typical of conditions that exist widely, would seem alarming enough to engage the most thoughtful Americans. But, in point of fact, few people have time to give them any attention, so engrossed is the nation with the efforts of the Administration to thrust “benevolent assimilation” upon an unwilling race of colored men on the other side of the globe. OUR OWN ANTI-DREYFUSISM. We have been working ourselves up in this country to a fine pitch of virtuous complacency over the Dreyfus case. France seems to us sO wrong, SO possess- ed, so driven by passion and ridden by panic fears, that we cannot but have a better idea of ourselves by comparison. We not only feel vastly superior to Frenchmen, as they display themselves in this affair, but we wish earnestly to manifest to them our moral disapproval. We even talk of morally boycotting them. We will avoid them. We will keep away from their Exposition. Ame- rica will gather up her skirts and, as she passes by disdainfully, let her soiled French sister see what real virtue and moral indignation mean. Now, it is always ungracious to disturb the peace of mind of people thanking God that they are not as other men are; but it is sometimes necessary and salu- tary to do so. Indeed, we have not only Scriptural warrant (which might not be enough), but good Republican precedent, for saying something unpleasant to “‘ho- lier-than-thou” folk; and to our mind there is a good deal of rank Pharisaism and hypocrisy, none the less offensive for being partly unconscious, in the pre- sent attitude of many Americans towards France and the French people. We be- lieve, and are glad and proud to assert, that the instinctive regard of Americans for individual justice, and for the rights of an accused man before the law, would make the Dreyfus tragedy impossible in this country. But we also believe that in some of the deeper-lying passions and motives which account for the horrible injustice done Capt. Dreyfus, we are not so different from the French as we plume ourselves upon being. In fact, if we look closely into the matter, we shall find it too true of many of us that wherein we judge the French we con- demn ourselves. What, in the last analysis, is the rea- son why France has apparently gone maa about Dreyfus? It is because the nation has come to have an insane devotion to the army. In the military power it has come to feel that its strength and safe- ty are bound up. Anything that touches or seems to touch the credit or efficiency of the army drives a Frenchman into a frenzy. The nation is for the army, not the army for the nation; and it is with ’ a fierce energy as of self-preservation that the French rush blindly to crush any one who seems to be attacking the army. It is upon this feeling, almost amounting to mania, that the conspira- tors against Dreyfus have artfully play- ed. But are we wholly innocent of any such national delusion? Have we no public men who exalt the military arm as the nation’s true grandeur? In our execration of the wrongs of Dreyfus, we must not forget that every man among us who asserts might over right, who ad- vances the doctrine that our country’s hope is in the army and navy, and that the Commander-in-Chief can do no wrong, is by so much revealing himself an anti-Dreyfusard. Theodore Roose- velt took occasion in one of his recent speeches to point to the awful exhibi- tion France was making before the civi- lized world. We beg to tell him that it is of just such ideas as his own about the supreme importance of the army, and the glorification of the military life, that France is perishing. Another point in which we at this mo- ment are “deplorably like” the French, is our persistent unwillingness to admit that we have made a mistake. It is safe to say that the judgment of the civilized world is as unanimous in the opinion that our policy in the Philip- pines has been a huge blunder as it is in the opinion that Dreyfus was unjust- ly condemned. We say nothing now of the larger question of expansion—let that be as it may; it is certain that our handling of the situation in the Philip- pines has been one long mistake and misery. But are we going to admit it? Never! Our anti-Dreyfusards are as fierce about it as their French brothers were against revision. We, too, have our chose jugée. If we perhaps did blun- der in our attitude towards the Filipi- nos, our dignity as a nation will not allow us to reconsider and reverse it. No, we say, we have made our de- cision, and it is irrevocable. But this is pure anti-Dreyfusism. Finally, let us look in the French mirror and see if we do not recognize familiar features in the furious outcry with which Picquart and Scheurer-Kest- ner and Pressensé and Bréal and Stap- fer and Seignobos, and the few brave men who dared to tell the French na- tion that a grievous wrong had been done, were pursued by press and public. Is there any analogy between the sneers with which these “intellectuels” were denounced, and the taunt of ‘“doctri- naires’’ which Gov. Roosevelt hurls at our professors and publicists who ask that the country be just and concilia- tory, instead of truculent, in the Philip- pines? Alas, alas, we are all poor mortals, and there is nothing so like an inflated and besotted Frenchman as an inflated and besotted American. We only hope that our moral indignation will not be exported for the use of the absent and foreigners—the two great classes of human beings who are always wrong—to the point of sweeping bare the home market. We think we foresee a large domestic demand for the article in the near future, and advise those who are using up all their reserve stock of horror. and shame in denouncing the anti-Dreyfusites of France, not to put the United States in the humiliating position of being obliged to ask French- men to send us some back when we need it most. AMERICANS AND GERMANS. Whatever tends to promote friendship between the different peoples of the earth is to be welcomed, and Prof. Miin- sterberg’s article in the September num- ber of the Atlantic, entitled “The Ger- mans and the Americans,” is full of friendly professions. For many reasons, however, we apprehend that the article will fail to remove such misunderstand- ings as now exist, even if it does not add to their number. It specifies many parti- culars in which German theories, pre- judices, and habits differ from those of Americans. It explains why Germans who have long been citizens of the United States are a socially isolated class, even if we do not admit that the average German-American stands be- low the level of the average German at home. It advances certain theories and speculations, more or less suggestive and meritorious, concerning the psychologi- cal constitution of Americans, and it would be ungracious to deny that it ac- cords us a generous meed of praise. Nevertheless, the reasoning of the ar- ticle is fallacious. It assumes that what is true of some is true of all. The popu- lation of the United States is made up of many races, and when Prof. Miinster- berg speaks of what Americans believe or like, we have to ask what he means. The Irish Americans have their own feel- ings, and so have the German, the Scan- dinavian, the Russian, the French, the Italian, even the Jewish elements. There are Africans and Asiatics with prejudices of their own, and there are marked dif- ferences between the native Americans of the South and those of the North; nor are the latter to be classed as homoge- neous. Speaking broadly, the people of every race dislike and dread or despise the people of every other race. As Cicero observed, the same word means strang- er and enemy. Granting Prof. Miinster- berg’s sweeping assertion, which is that the two peoples do not like each other, let us ask, What peoples do like each other? Can he name any people that love the Germans? Are the French fond of them? or the Danes? or the Poles? or the Russians * or the English? Do the non-German Austrians love their German fellow-citizens? Do the Bava- rians, even, love the Prussians? and have the Germans any sincere liking for any
Page 13
Aug. 31, 1899] of these peoples that do not like them? Prof. Miinsterberg recounts many dis- similarities between Germans and Ame- ricans which are amply sufficient to arouse dislikes; but any foreigner of equal ability could do the same for his own race. When a distinguished German is presented to one of our leading states- mer and finds him squirting tobacco- juice on the floor, or even- into a spit- toon, he does not like it. Neither does a well-bred Englishman or Frenchman. Tastes differ. It is idle to argue about them, still more idle to imagine that one people will give up its habits to please another. The descendants of the Puri- tans, who are probably the people that Prof. Miinsterberg has in mind when he generalizes about Americans, do not like the ways of Germans, and probably nev- er will. Perhaps, it is better that they never should. They come of an ascetic stock. They seriously think that the Germans have accomplished the desecra- tion of the Sabbath and the subversion of the cause of temperance. They have accepted. their music, with due delibera- tion, but they are not reconciled to their dancing and beer-drinking. But that the American people as a body have any peculiar aversion to the Germans, is not established by anything that Prof. Miin- sterberg advances. It is an altogether different matter when we come to consider Prof. Min- sterberg’s glorification of what he calls Germany, but which is really a medley of political and social misrepresenta- tions. He sneers at the German-Ameri- cans because they protested against the “Anglo-American Alliance,” and entirely ignores the fact that this was by way of protest against imperialism. He is an enthusiastic imperialist, and, no doubt, is disturbed that his fellow-countrymen are unanimously opposed to him; but that is no excuse for not doing justice to their attitude. Equally misleading is his ac- count of Germany. We may concede that “there is no people under the sun with more valuable inner freedom than the Germans.” “Inner” freedom is not easily suppressed, but when we are as- sured that “the German University is the freest place on earth,” we can but stare and gasp. There was a Liberal Member of Parliament named Virchow, who was also not unknown as a profes- sor at the University of Berlin. How did the Government treat him? What sort of treatment did Mommsen receive under Bismarck? What course was taken with Prof. Geffcken when he published the diary of the Crown Prince? How came Georg von Bunsen to be prosecuted? What is the explanation of these recent attacks on professors who have taken the part of the Social Democrats? What of Prof. Delbriick’s fine? Even as regards the outer forms of freedom, Prof. Miinsterberg maintains, Germany is freer than the United States. Comparisons are odious, Many outrage-
The Nation. | ous infractions of liberty take place here, |
and we are at present in no mood for boasting. But that is the very reason why we must protest against other un- founded claims. Prof. Miinsterberg says the right to insult the President is not freedom. That begs the question. Is it freedom when an editor is sent to prison for four months for commenting on the Emperor’s speech at the opening of Par- liament? The numberless prosecutions for lése-majesté are not to be brushed away with a metaphysical definition. Prof. Miinsterberg says that he is a mo- narchist, and calmly assumes that the present revival of medizwval pretensions by the Emperor is monarchy. He is wel- come to his opinion, but until he can si- lence the voices of the German Liberals and of an immense number of German voters, he has no right to make such representations to the American people. Few intelligent Americans have any ob- jection to a constitutional monarchy. It is impossible for us, but we might be better off if we had it. We will not go so far as to say that few intelligent Ger- mans favor the recent developments of imperialism in that country, but we know that a great many do not; and they are by race and position quite as well qualified to speak as Prof. Miinster- berg. Take the case of the German colonies, for instance. “The colonial transmarine development of the German empire is taking away that narrowness of its citi- zens which too much depressed the spirit of individual initiative.”’ .As a matter of fact, two or three thousand Germans a year may be induced to settle in these colonies, after twenty years of Govern- ment support, at a cost to their country- men of about 100,000 marks per colonist. How is individual initiative thereby re- lieved from depression, and how is it re- lated to the disposition of Germans to colonize anywhere rather than under their own flag? Prof. Miinsterberg is delighted with the Spanish war and our new policy of conquest. He says that “an heroic revival is at hand, imperial- ism awakens echoes throughout the land”; and hints that we shall best ap- proximate to the true ideals illustrated in the German Emperor by becoming an aristocracy and putting our govern- ment in charge of a Cesar. That is the theory in the minds of a certain class, in this country, in Germany, and elsewhere. It is the the- ory of reaction, of servility, of despotism. The Titelsucht which is corrupting the German empire goes with it; the ignoble desire to be promoted by the ruling powers into an arbitrary social promi- nence without reference to _ intrinsic worth. Such is not the theory of those Germans and those Americans whose political ideal is liberty, and whose ef- fort is to make free from the op- pression of its rulers. One of the best of men and =<ablest of ; duct of our Government
‘ ~ 165 declared just the con the Span- ish war had put back the cause of Lib- eral progress in the Old World a hundred Bamberger, died that statesmen, before he in years. To put back what Bamberger called the cause of liberal progress is exactly what Prof. Miinsterberg would like to do, and if his ideal is to prevail, Germany will be detested by every Ame rican who loves the constitution estab lished by his fathers. There is eternal hostility between the ideals of freedom and of despotism. If the governments of Germany and the United States are to be free governments, there will need of reconciling Germans and Ameri cans. They will have no disputes over naval superiority, or colonies, or tariffs if not, no likeness between the peoples will prevent conceited and ambitious rulers from quarrelling. be no VAMPIRES AMHERST, August, 1899. Some years ago the writer, accompanied by a friend, was travelling on foot in Greece. One day, after sunset, we reached an isolated farmhouse, situated on the edge of what was then the great Copaic morass, immediately .north of Orchomenus. We had been tramping through Greece for seven we were very footsore, and a long walk had made us unusually tired and hun- gry on that particular day. As ap- proached the house, we were greeted by the barking of a huge, and apparently very sav- age, dog, who made frantic efforts to break his chain in order to gratify his burning cu riosity in regard to the two forlorn travel- lers. Had we known what was to follow, the dog would have inspired us with more re- spect, but we had seen many Grecian curs masquerading as lions, though at beart they were as cowardly as hares. So, trusting to knowledge born of experience with other dogs, we scarcely deigned to the vigorous protests of this savage beast. Ar- rived at the door of the farmhouse, we knocked once and again. Apparently the house had no inmate. But after a time the door opened cautiously, and a burly Al- banian peasant appeared in the doorway extending towards us a pair of tongs in which was held a live coal of fire. The ex- traordinary performance rendered us for the moment speechless with astonishment. The peasant, pale and apparently quivering with terror, stood but for a moment holding the coal of fire towards us. Then, without hav- ing uttered one word, he hastily closed the door in our faces and bolted it with care. This behavior was as inexplicable to us at the time as it is, no doubt, to the reader now. But at any rate one thing was certain the man had given us the strongest as- surance that he regarded our room as better than our company. We were confronted by a condition, not a theory; we were literally worn out; we knew that the nearest village was about five miles distant; it was now dark, and we longed to be housed and fed. So we knocked at the door again, and yet again, but all within was as silent as the grave, in striking contrast with the deep- voiced bellowings of the dog behind weeks; we notice us German | But our friend of the tongs could not be In-
Page 14
166 The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1783 duced to come forth a second time and par- ley with us. Finally, we gave up in despair, and, wandering away past the uproarious cur, we sat down in sadness upon a neigh- boring bank to determine what was to be done under the distressing circumstances. To our great relief, we soon descried a half-grown boy approaching on a donkey, but to our queries as to the possibility of finding lodging for the night in the house he answered with a decided No, stating that he was the only Greek on the premises, and that the inmates were Albanians who were in no wise likely to entertain strangers. “But,”’ said he, pointing to a hut of con- siderable size, ‘“‘there is the dog’s house. You can sleep there if you want to. But they always turn the dog loose at night, and if he finds you, he will eat you up, as sure as fate.’’ Thus saying, he left us to confront an unameliorated condition; the door of the house opened to allow him to enter, but was closed and ostentatiously bolted after him. In the course of our wanderings we had frequently been compelled to spend the night in the open air as best we might, but on former occasions we were not so tired, foot- sore, and hungry as we were on that particu- lar evening. It was, therefore, a real hard- ship to be treated with a rude inhospitality that was wholly inexplicable to us, because, hitherto, we had received not merely hospi- tality, but marked attention even. However, under the circumstances, the only thing left for us to do was to take possession of the dog’s house as the sole protection within our reach against the chilling dews of a Grecian spring night. That dog was some- thing of an aristocrat, and his house was a veritable palace—for a dog; better, indeed, than many houses that are occupied by hu- man beings. Upon entering we found, to our great regret, that the door was off its hinges, and, in spite of anxious effort, we could not adjust it in the pitchy darkness. The dog had been set free, and was now rampant, roaming to and fro and calling for our blood, with deep-mouthed bellowings that gave us concern, as I am free to confess. Taking all things into consideration, we had come to respect the dog, and it was with pain that we realized that we could not debar him from impertinent intrusion upon our privacy. We propped the door up, but, had the power- ful dog so wished, he could have entered without difficulty. In our unarmed condi- tion, therefore, we were not wholly free from anxiety lest he might find an opportunity to eat us, according to the reassuring pro- phecy of the Greek boy. But weariness bore heavily upon us, and, ylelding to necessity, we laid us down, just as we were, in the dust that was ankle deep, and of that peculiar liquid variety produced by the action of innumerable tramplings. The whole night through, the dog never once ceased his search for us; we could hear him now near at hand and now in the distance, but ever making night hideous with his bayings, which did not have for us the soothing, nerve-calming ef- fect upon which Byron dwells. We had been reading that poet as we journeyed through Greece, and we were keenly alive to the irony of the words: ‘“*"Tis sweet to hear the watch-dog's bonest bark Bay deep-mouthed welcome as we draw near home.’’ Fortunately for us, it did not occur to the dog to look for us in his own house, though he often came uncomfortably near, and so we dragged through the weary night with- out a visit from our canine friend, of whom, by this time, we stood in absolute terror. We arose at the peep of day, selecting for our exit a moment when the dog seemed to be baying in the distance, and attempted to gain the open country before he could dis- cover us. Vain delusion, for we had not taken many steps before the dog became aware of that for which he had been search- ing fruitlessly the entire night, and made for us with the speed of the wind. His faithful, all-night hunt deserved to be crowned with success, but he was doomed to disappoint- ment—at the very moment, too, when he had treed his game. Fortunately for us an in- mate of the house was astir even before us, and, throwing himself upon the furious beast as he rushed past, he bore him to the ground and held him there. From the time of St. Paul down to the present day every- body in Greece has been inquisitive. Under the circumstances, the curiosity of our be- nefactor was natural enough, but still it was ridiculous in the extreme to see him lie there on -the furious, struggling, howling dog, and ply us with a host of questions, many of which were wholly irrelevant. When finally he had satisfied his curiosity, he apo- logized for the treatment we had received at the hands of the rude Albanians, and bade us go—in God’s name. We were not slow to obey, nor did we stop to satisfy our own cu- riosity as to how he came to be there in his peculiar garb, for he was stark naked. In Greece the belief in vampires was once widespread, but it has been gradually dying away as education invades the remoter re- cesses of the land. Even in Athens one still sometimes hears: ‘‘May the vampire take you!’’—a curse of diabolical nature. But the belief in vampires is now confined to the lower classes, and perhaps chiefly to the Al- banians, of whom Von Halm relates that they entertain many other absurd superstitions, such as belief in the existence of men with tails—no doubt a reminiscence of the Satyr of classical mythology. Among us most peo- ple have but a vague and indefinite idea in regurd to the vampire, his raison d’étre, his haunts and habits. It seems that after death some people do not rest quietly in their graves, but come forth at night when the moon shines. They live by sucking the blood of men, and return to their tombs at the ap- proach of dawn, after gorging themselves with human blood. There are two kinds of vampires: the blood-sucking and a less ma- lignant variety. It is of the malignant vam- pire that Byron speaks when he writes: “But first, on earth, as vampire sent, Thy corse shall from its tomb be rent: Then ghastly haunt thy native place, And suck the blood of all thy race."’ The less malignant type of vampire amuses itself by playing tricks on people and by frightening them, but otherwise does them no harm. The more malignant vam- pire, on the contrary, is fond of the liver of its victims, whom it attacks in the form of a variety of animals or insects, such as cats, dogs, fleas, spiders, etc. The best evidence that death has been caused by a vampire is the mark of a bite on the nape of the neck, though sudden death of any kind is regarded as its work. The fear of sudden death is said to be very great among the peoples with whom the vampire loves to dwell, for the reason that he who has been killed by a vampire him- self becomes one. Allatius tells us that the vampire is not the soul of the deceased, but an evil spirit which enters the body of the dead person. He says: “The corpse is entered by a demon, which is the source of ruin to unhappy men. For frequently, emerging from the tomb in the form of that body, and roaming about the city and other inhabited places, especially by night, it betfakes itself to any house it fancies, and, after knocking at the door, ad- dresses one of its inmates in a loud tone. If the person answers he is done for. If he does not answer he is safe. In consequence of this, the people of the island of Chios never reply the first time, if any one calls them by night.” Fire is the surest protection against vam- pires. Behold, then, the key to the treat- ment to which we were subjected by the Albanian peasant. The poor creature had mistaken us for vampires. We did not dis- cover this fact until after our return to Athens, when some friends, to whom we recounted our strange adventure, opened our eyes. We had not seen a vampire our- selves, but the Albanian saw two, and trembled. It is a fearful thing to become a vampire, and people whose friends have died are always anxious to gain some certain know- ledge as to the status of. their beloved dead. The question, ‘‘How fares it with the spirit of my dead mother, father, husband, wife?” is a momentous one even to this day. In many places it is still customary to disinter the corpse after it has lain for a year in the grave, in order to solve the question as to whether the soul of the dead be in heaven or hell. I believe that this custom had its origin in the vampire faith, though I am not prepared to say that the vampire superstition is nowadays the con- fessed cause of the exhumation. The con- dition of the bones decides whether or no the spirit is in heaven or hell, but if the body be found in a good state of preserva- tion, with the skin taut like a drum, then the dead person has become a vampire. There are various causes for the change into a vampire after death. Chief among them is excommunication by Holy Mother Church, then great sins of any kind, the curse of parents, dealings with witches and witchcraft, eating the flesh of a lamb that has been killed by a wolf, the springing of a cat or a dog over a corpse before its burial, etc. Accord- ingly, it is easy to see that the clergy are clothed with a fearful power, for with the words, ‘‘Whatsoever ye bind on earth shall be bound in heaven, and whatsoever ye loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven,” in their mouths, they may hold a Damocles sword over the heads of an ignorant and su- perstitious peasantry, and thus wield a pow- er which one shudders to think of, especially if the clergy be unscrupulous and the people faithful and pious. Nay, the days when the clergy availed themselves of this mighty power are almost within our touch. Not only throughout the Middle Ages, but down cer- tainly to the first decades of this century, the vampire played a great réle in the Hast, and the clergy not only did not hesitate to use this excellent means of moulding the ignorant to their will, but took pains to disseminate the belief that excommunicated persons who died without having been absolved from the curse of the Church, became ipso facto vampires after death. The superstition is not to be regarded in the light of a mere myth which the peasantry believed in without having their lives influenced thereby for good or for bad. Nor was the belief confined to the
Page 15
Aug. 31, 1899] peasantry; it had a firm hold on all classes, for we are told by learned and good men not merely that they know of this effect of excommunication by hearsay, but that they can vouch for it personally, because they have seen it with their own eyes. The Church claimed not only the power to excommunicate, but also the right to absolve from the curse pronounced by the ecclesiastical authorities. This absolution might be pronounced at any time, either before or after the death of the excommunicated person. Consequently it was possible for a dead man to remain a vampire for a season, and still get to heaven after a time, provided his friends had money or in- fluence enough to procure for him absolution at the hands of the Church. In Crete the priests were regarded as being very skilful in exorcising the vam- pire. Friday night was the proper time for the ceremony, because on that night the vampire usually remained in his tomb, but occasionally he absented himself even on Friday nights; in that case the exorcism failed, or, in other words, the officiating priest did not feel that he had made money enough out of his victim. When other means of laying the demon failed, the corpse was burned. Tournefort, in his ‘Relation d’un Voyage du Levant’ (i., 131 ff.), gives an amazing account of the laying of a vampire-demon by cremation in the island of Myconos. A quarrelsome peasant had been murdered in the fields. Two days af- ter his burial it was known that he had appeared at night and played tricks on peo- ple. The priests sedulously spread the re- port, for it meant that masses would be said. On the tenth day after burial, solemn mass was said, the body was exhumed, and the heart was cut out by the village butch- er—an operation attended by the escape of such noxious gases that the abundant use of incense was necessary. Every one was crying, ‘‘Vampire, vampire!’’ Some said that the blood was red; the butcher averred that the body was warm, others that the corpse was not stiff when carried out for burial—a sure sign that it was a genuine vampire. The heart of the corpse was burn- ed on the seashore. But all this had no effect on the vampire, who continued his pranks as before; every one had some big tale to tell of his doings. It came, finally, to such a pitch that people abandoned their houses and encamped in the squares, and all were terrified at the approach of night. The priests reaped a rich harvest. All day long men were busy plunging swords into the grave, until a wise Albanian discovered that the hilts of the swords resembled a cross, and of all things the vampire fears the cross most because he can never leave his tomb as long as a cross is on it. He suggested the use of Turkish swords. But all was in vain; the vampire continued his wicked ways; the people were beside them- selves with terror, and so many families emigrated to the neighboring islands that Myconos was threatened with depopula- tion. A great funeral pyre, consisting of wood, pitch, and tar, was erectcd on a jutting promontory of the island, and on it the remnants of the corpse were burned to ashes. The vampire was laid; Myconos had peace, and many ballads were composed in honor of the event. The most available account of the vam- pire is that in Tozer’s ‘Researches in the Highlands of Turkey’ (ii., 80 ff.), where the reader will also find the literature of the subject cited. J. R. 8. STERRETT. ‘The Nation: MEMOIRS OF MME. DE LA FERRONAYS. —Il. PaRis, August 9, 1899. Many are the details which Madame de la Ferronays gives regarding the salons of Paris in the years preceding the Revolution of 1848. She herself began her apprentice- ship as maitresse de maison. ‘“‘M. de la Ferronays desired that I should prepare my- self to become his aid—in the measure which belongs to a woman—on the day when, as we hoped and wished, he should be called by the return of the King to have an employ- ment at Court, or, as he would have much preferred, in diplomacy.’’ Her sister, La Roche-Aymon, and herself lived then in great intimacy, all the agreeable men of their generation and of the older generation came to their house. “In my youth, andI cannot imagine that the fashion has changed in this respect, men paid court to the women; they fell in love or pretended to do so. The liaisons were taken seriously; I could cite women who never consoled themselves for the pain given by a rupture. Between society men and women the question of money did not exist. Our betting with friends ended in ex- changes of neckties, of ribbons, of umbrel- las for canes at the utmost. A young man, in an intimate liaison, which lasted several years, with a lady among my friends, hav- ing dared, on the Ist of January, to offer her she became indignant, and sent it back, asking if he took her for a fille entretenue. -. . . We attached so much importance to not allowing our manners to be similarin the who abounded at the theatre or at supper parties, that we did not admit that the | expenses should be divided among the men to our exclusion; and our friends did not dream of paying for us—we should have considered it a humiliation.” In the year 1847 M. de la Ferronays went to Venice to be presented to the Countess de Chambord. “He did not find Madame pretty; but she had made an effort to please, and had shown herself amiable towards the French, having not yet reached the time when, as she often told me,she felt humiliated before them because of her sterility, and consid- ered that, the more royalist they were, the more they ought to desire her death. The poor Princess, who can perhaps be re- proached with not having had a beneficent influence over her husband, suffered cruel- ly for not having given a Dauphin to the country. Was it her fault? These are nature’s secrets.”’ The Revolution of 1848 was a satisfaction and a sort of revenge for the Legitimist party. Madame de la Ferronays says about it: “The throne of Louise-Philippe, erected by one revolution, was upset by another; but, whatever our sentiments at the time, it was a misfortune for the country. We should not now have to deplore the loss of two provinces; a respectable royal family would not have demoralized France by ex- cess of luxury as the Empire did, and the sterility of Monseigneur [the Count de Chambord] would have given the branch of Bourbon-Orléans a legitimacy which it failed to have, to establish itself on a solid basis. But it is impossible for men to foresee the future; the passions do not rea- son; and by us royalists the fall of the July monarchy was hailed with joy.” The troubles which followed the Revolu- tion, especially the bloody insurrection of June, 1848, against the Constituent Assem- bly, gave great hopes to the Legitimists. “It was the time when, in the shops of Paris, Monseigneur was called ‘Monsieur | Crédit,’ and when, under that name, his por- | traits figured in all the shops. My husband | frequently, 167 was soon to go to Frohsdorf, and in his illusions, of which I partook, he imagined that he would come back with the Prince, to whom he was to carry generals’ uni- forms. When the moment came for his taking the road to Frohsdorf, having carefully shut the doors, we ourselves put these precious uniforms in the trunks that were to take them .o Austria; and while we were thus engaged, M. de la Ferronays said to me "You will see, my dear, that Monseigneur will accept the flag which France brings him, since, to keep his liberty entire, he has never worn a cockade on his hat or his cloth- ing.’ Those we were packing had none.”’ This little incident seems to show that in 1848 the Count de Chambord was not as absolutely hostile to the tricolor flag as he proved to be in 1872, when the Constituent Assembly chosen after the war was on the point of offering him the crown. “During all the years,’ says Madame de la Ferronays, ‘‘anterior to the Coup d’ Etat, ne gotiations were entered into with chiefs of army corps, and money was spent with open hands. MM. Berryer, De Valmy, and the Duke de Noailles always wished to re- tard the moment of action, not seeing that they were compromising success. Large sums were paid to a Marshal of France who was needy and received money from both sides. Every time, and it happened that M. de la Ferronays ar- | rived at Frohsdorf, the Dauphiness, whom a diamond heart which had cost 400 francs, | smallest degree to those of the light ladies | we called the Queen, said to him: ‘Fernand, do bring us a colonel, or nothing will be done." Once, he replied: ‘Madame, I bring you better than a Colonel, a Marshal of France. Marshal Bugeaud asks Monseigneur if, on the day when he calls him in the midst of the army of the Alps, which he | commands, he will be ready to come.’ ‘Im- mediately,’ was the answer. But the Mar- shal imposed delay, and afterwards, for the misfortune of France, turned towards Louis Napoleon.” In 1850 M. de la Ferronays was complete- ly attached to the person of the Count de Chambord, and accompanied him first to Wiesbaden. It was there that the Prince learned the death of Louis-Philippe. He at once ordered a mass to be said, and wish- ed all his household to attend it “It was an order for us all, and I must confess that we were a little astonished to go into mourning for a King whom we had never accepted, and whom we had al- ways considered our most mortal ene- my.”’ The Count de Chambord spent the winter of 1851 at Venice; there was still some hope for the royalist party, and visit- ors were numerous. Among others came M. de Falloux, who had broken with Prince Louis Bonaparte. “M. de Falloux, whose dominant virtue was not frankness, came to Venice to play a sharp game. He wish- ed to diminish the influence of the Duke de Lévis, and to surround the Count with new men, who would accept his leadership.” Venice was full of princes. There were the Duke and the Duchess of Modena, the Duke and Duchess of Parma, the Infant Don Juan and his wife the Infanta Bea- trix, sister of the Count de Chambord. “The sight of the Duke of Parma and of the Infant Don Juan had the effect of put- ting Monseigneur in very bad humor. The Duke of Parma, rather disagreeable to everybody, was particularly so to the French, especially to-those in the family of his brother-in-law, whom he made _ re- sponsible, though they never had anything to do in the matter, for the conditions im- posed on him in his marriage contract, by which he was not allowed to touch the fortune of the Princess, his wife." The father of the Duke of Parma, the Duke of Lucca, had employed in his stables an Englishman called Ward, who entered more and more into his favor, and ended
Page 16
168 The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1783 by becoming the preceptor of his son. .The Revolution of 1849 turned the Duke of Lucca out of his states, and he abdi- cated in favor of his son, whom the death of Marie Louise, according to the terms of the Congress of Vienna, soon called to the throne of Parma. “The Infant Don Juan was not handsome,” says Mme. de la Ferronays, ‘‘and it was difficult to understand the passion which he inspired in the Archduchess Beatrix, who had become very deaf at this period. She was the mother of Don Carlos and of Don Alfonzo. . The poor Infanta be- came afterwards so deaf that the efforts which she made to hear the persons to whom she granted an audience, occasioned nervous attacks. It was a common infirmity with all the members of the house of Austria-Mo- dena.”’ On her return to France, Mme. de la Fer- ronays witnessed the Coup d’Etat of the 2d of December. Paris woke up to the sound of the drums. Gen. Changarnier and other ge- nerals, the Deputies of the Chamber, were thrown into prison. “My husband,” she says, ‘had papers which might have been compromising; he confided them to me to be taken to a safe place, and, on my return to the Faubourg St. Germain, I had the painful pleasure of seeing pass before me Louis Napoleon, acclaimed by the troops which lined the avenue of the Champs-Elysées. It is the only time in my life that I screamed ‘Vive la République!’ a demonstration which had no result, not even to console my heart. rom We were entering the era of sad- ness, even of some apostasies; but the man- ner in which these were received in society restricted their number. In the eve- ning from a balcony at the circus of the Champs-Elysées, we saw carriages, sur- rounded by troops, which took some of the Deputies to Mont Valérien; all the others were taken to Vincennes. Our poor friends and our chiefs were still so full of illusions that, while in certain regions people conceded to the new régime only the essentially Napoleonic duration of a Hun- dred Days, the chiefs advised my husband, who was sent to explain the situation to Monseigneur, to tell him expressly not to move, for there was every reason to believe that the President had only taken power to place it in his hands. Oh, how stupid honest people, intelligent as they may be, can sometimes be!” This is Madame de la Ferronays’s judg- ment of Louis Napoléon: ‘‘The new master of France was feeble and undecided; the will of M. de Morny and of M. Fleury had necessary to lead him to an act of energy. He was a dreamer, a voluptuary, a good man at heart, liked by those who approached him, and having nothing of the terrible man he had the name of being.” Madame de la Ferronays is very severe on the Countess of Teba, who came to France with her mother, Madame de Montijo, and became the Empress of the French. This marriage, she says, ‘‘decided her fate as well as that of France, of which the handsome Spaniard, by her levity, her fri- volity, and her incapacity to conduct the affairs she mixed herself up in, prepared the ruln. She contributed to the irreparable disasters under which our country has sunk.” Courtiers became more rare at Frohs- dorf after the establishment of the Em- pire. “The grand figure of the daughter of Louis XVI. disappeared. For me she left a great void. She had always shown me great kindness. Her life had been that of a saint, and, if her speech was a little brusque, her heart was full of in- dulgence. People were unjust to her in France; they would‘not’ make allowance for been the dreadful memories that confronted her when she reéntered the Tuileries, which she had left on the 10th of August.” Correspondence. “OUR COUNTRY, RIGHT OR WRONG.” TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Srr: For the last two or three months the idea has been growing in this country that, since the war in the Philippines is actually under way, no honorable course is open to us but to force it to a successful termination. Even among those who once most nobly took the side of justice toward the unfortunate islanders, this thought seems to be commending itself. Half- hearted humanitarians quiet an uneasy conscience by pleading the stain to nation- al honor which would result from the slightest retraction in our exorbitant de- mands. But is not our country great and powerful enough to afford to be generous if by that means she can be just? Those who urge the bloody prosecution of an un- just war to save what they are pleased to call our national dignity, would do well to recall the position taken by our English defenders at the time of the Revolution. No hypocritical pride brought them to the low level of sanctioning the continuance of a wrong merely because it had been igno- rantly and foolishly begun. On October 31, 1776, in the House of Com- mons, Mr. Fox boldly and honorably de- clared: “The noble Lord who moved the amend- ment said that we were in the dilemma of conquering or abandoning America. If we are reduced to that, I am for abandoning America.” And this champion of liberty, whom we all honor for his fearless honesty, entered his vote against a bill for raising revenues to maintain the war, “because he could not conscientiously agree to grant any money for so destruct- ive, so ignoble a purpose as the carrying on a war commenced unjustly, and support- ed with no other view than to the extirpa- tion of freedom. This he conceived to be the strict line of conduct to be observed by a member of Parliament.” In November of the same year, Edmund Burke said in the House of Commons: “You simply tell the colonists to lay down their arms, and then you will do just as you please. Could the most cruel con- queror say less? If you had conquered the Devil himself in Hell, could you be less liberal?” And yet this is the identical policy which our Government is now enforcing with fire and sword, while we stand weakly by and say, ‘Let it go on, since we are in ig And the great Chatham, as true a patriot as England ever knew, whose son resigned a commission in the English army rather than fight against liberty, said in the House of Lords, in the second year of the war: “We have tried for unconditional sub- mission; try what can be gained by uncondi- tional redress. This country has been the aggressor. You have made descents upon their coasts; you have burnt their towns, plundered their country, made war upon the inhabitants, confiscated their property, pro- scribed and imprisoned their persons. I do therefore affirm that, instead of exacting unconditional submission from the colonies, we should grant them unconditional re- dress.”’ Again, a few months later, he declared with fervent earnestness: “T would sell the shirt off my back to as- sist in proper measures, properly and wisely conducted; but I would not part with a sin- gle shilling to the present ministers. Their plans are founded in destruction and dis- grace. It is, my Lords, a ruinous and de- structive war; it is full of danger; it teems with disgrace, and must end in ruin. .. . If I were an American, as I am an English- man, while a foreign troop was landed in my country, I would never lay down my arms! Never! Never! Never!” If England, far from feeling herself hu- miliated by such sentiments, coming from men high in official station, looks back to them as the truest patriots of that age, surely we Americans need dread no bitter judgment from posterity if we repeat those chivalrous and humane views. Once before in our brief history our country fell from her lofty place among the nations, and plunged into a cowardly war with a helpless neighbor. Then, as now, the siren’s song of pride corrupted our people. Then, as now, a short-sighted Administra- tion forsook the straight path of moral rec- titude and honored tradition, justifying a war of criminal aggression by the plea that we must not retreat. Then, as now, strong words of remonstrance were raised in Mas- sachusetts, which are full of encouragement for us to-day. Charles Sumner, the ever- eloquent champion of justice, in an address to the people of Boston, on the 4th of Feb- ruary, 1847, exclaimed in righteous wrath: “We are told that the country is engaged in the war, and therefore it must be main- tained, or, as it is sometimes expressed, vigorously prosecuted. In other words, the violation of the Constitution and the out- rage upon justice sink out of sight, and we are urged to the same acts again. By what necromancy do these pass from wrong to right? In what book of morals is it written that what is bad before it is un- dertaken becomes righteous merely from the circumstance that it is commenced? Who on earth is authorized to transmute wrong into right? Whoso admits the un- constitutionality and injustice of the war, and yet sanctions its prosecution, must ap- prove the Heaven-defying sentiment, ‘Our country, right or wrong.’ Can this be the sentiment of Boston? If so, in vain are her children nurtured in the churches of the Pilgrims, in vain fed from the com- mon table of knowledge bountifully sup- plied by our common schools. Who would profess allegiance to wrong? Who would deny allegiance to right? Had this senti- ment been received by our English de- fenders in the war of the Revolution, no fiery tongue of Chatham, Burke, Fox, or Camden would have been heard in our be- half. Their great testimony would have faited. All would have been silenced, while crying that the country, right or wrong, must be carried through the war.” May we not rise above the unreasonable and vicious idea that what we all con- demn in an individual, we may sanction in the state? The just man, when he sees himself in the wrong, is restrained by no shallow pride from desisting, and making amends to the full extent of his ability. Should not a nation do as much? A word from our Government, guaranteeing to this brave and heroic people the blessings of that dearly loved liberty which years of struggle had all but won, would end the carnage in a moment. Can we, in the light of history, honorably refuse so small a sacrifice? 8. August 19, 1899.
Page 17
Aug. 31, 1899] The Nation. 169 THE MIXED FILIPINOS. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: There are more people on the Philip- pine Islands than were in the whole western hemisphere when Columbus discovered Ame- rica. In the latter, moreover, the population was homogeneous throughout, but in our new archipelago the blood of all mankind flows in the veins of its heterogeneous popu- Mr. Miller Christy’s undertaking to write | an exhaustive and authoritative ‘History of ; the Hudson's Bay Company,’ after personal lation. For the white sub-species, you have © Semite, Hamite, European, and Iranic in- gredients; for the yellow, Malay and Chi- nese; for the brown, the Polynesian sup- plies the blood; and for the black sub-spe- cies there are twenty thousand Negritos, or dwarf negroes. Even the American Indian cannot be omitted, for, during two centuries, between 1565 and 1765 about, the Philippines were governed exclusively from Acapulco, Mexico. Concerning the Negritos, Dr. A. B. Mey- er, director of the Royal Ethnographic Mu- seum, Dresden, publishes a timely book of a hundred pages, issued in English by Sten- gel, in Dresden. The text forms two chap- ters of his greater work on Philippine types, jin a research in the archives of England, France, and Canada, and with access to the Compa- ny’s records, has not been affected by the approaching appearance of two other works on the same subject by Beckles Willson and Prof. Bryce of Winnipeg. ‘Through Persia on a Side-Saddle,’ by Ella C. Sykes (Lippincott), a fairly stout volume, is an unpretentious account of the author’s experiences in her travels about Persia and while keeping house for her brother, the first British Consul ap- pointed to the city of Kerman. She writes good-humored, straightforward way, | describing what she saw and did, and wisely | about anything else. printed in folio in 1893. Ethnologists will be | glad to have these chapters in handy form, since not only do they bring to date what is really known of this interesting people, but the author attacks with vigor the un- substantiated theories concerning a negroid substratum in all the Indo-Pacific islands and southeastern Asia promulgated by Qua- trefages and Hamy, endorsed by Flower and Lydecker, and put in general circulation by Keane. O. T. MASON. WasHINGTON, D. C., August 24, 1899. Notes. Miss Lilian Whiting’s ‘Kate Field: A Re- cord’ is on the point of being issued by Little, Brown & Co., Boston. Thomas Whittaker will soon publish ‘My Smoking-Room Companion,’ a _ satirical sketch by William Harvey King, M.D. The Continental Publishing Co. announces ‘A Daughter of Neptune,’ stories of East and West, by William Winslow. Mrs. Mabel Loomis Todd of Amherst has just completed a thorough revision of Dr. Dorman Steele’s text-book, ‘A New De- scriptive Astronomy,’ which is now in the press of the American Book Company. ‘An Autumn Lane, and Other Poems,’ by Will T. Hale, is in the press of Barbee & Smith, Nashville. The Moravian Book Concern (The Come- nius Press), Bethlehem, Pa., will shortly publish ‘Fifty Years Ago,’ by Mary Wiley Staver, a description of a trip to England and the Continent, with illustrations. The Open Court Publishing Co., Chicago, will issue next month ‘Solomon and Solo- monic Literature,’ by Moncure D. Conway; ‘Science and Faith; or, Man as an Animal and Man as a Member of Society,’ by Dr. Paul Topinard; and ‘The Evolution of General Ideas,’ by Th. Ribot, translated by Miss Frances A. Welby. ‘A First Glance at the Birds,’ by Charles A. Keeler, being a general introduction to the study of California birds and an ad- vance portion of a larger work, ‘Bird Notes Afield,’ by the same author, will be brought out at once in pamphlet form by Elder & Shepard, San Francisco. not attempting to give much information The book reads well, and, though containing little in the nature of exciting adventure, will interest those who care for books of travel or for de- scriptions of the part of the East in ques- tion. The fifth part of David W. Hoyt’s ‘Old Families of Salisbury and Amesbury, Mass.’ (Providence) completes the work, and finds room for some additional documents, with additions and corrections and three index- es. An odd erratum pointed out was caused by some one’s misreading a passage in Isaac Estey’s will (Topsfield), ‘‘daughter Sarah I reckon she had her full portion upon her marriage,” making it ‘Sarah Ireland.” The time of the army upheaval in France is propitious for the appearance of Part IL. of ‘A French-English Military Technical Dictionary,’ prepared by Cornélis De Witt Willcox, First Lieutenant of Artillery, U. S. A., and issued from the Adjutant-General’s Office at Washington. The 160 closely print- ed octavo pages, ending with espace, con- trast sharply with the total 118 pages of Barrére’s pocket ‘Dictionary of French and English Military Terms (French-English),’ which was published by Hachette in 1896. Lieut. Willcox’s labor is worthy of all praise. The proof-reading appears to have been very scrupulous. While canaille de D—— will not be found in this vocabulary, bordereau is given, with a number of quali- fications (énonciatif, énumératif, nominatif, etc.). Of coup, 192 different definitions are given. Under école there is a list of the French military schools. Not least interest- ing are the instances of military argot, as bal, ‘extra drill,’ and Dache, ‘hairdresser to the Zouaves (a mythical personage), used in the phrase Allez raconter cela @ Dache, “Go tell that to the marines.’””’ The author gives a list of 129 authorities, which includes 30 of- ficial French publications and 45 lithograph- ed text-books of the Artillery and Engineers School at Fontainebleau. Part 26 of Hatzfeld’s ‘Dictionnaire Gé- néral de la Langue Francaise’ (Paris: Ch. Delagrave) finishes the letter R, and car- ries the letter S to soulever. In this section occur an unusual number of characteristic compounds, such as songe-malice, sot-l'y- laisse, Saint-Simon’s sauve-l’honneur, and one of the newest, saute-ruisseau, a sort of errand-boy (admitted by the Academy in 1878). Sauve-qui-peut takes its alphabetical place, instead of being put under sauver, as the Academy treats it. The same authority from 1718 to 1740 printed sans-souci without the hyphen, which it conceded to sang-froid only in 1798. (A century earlier, it is re- corded,some used the expression sens froid.) Savoir-faire and savoir-vivre were both dep- recated as neologisms in 1671; and while the Academy adopted the former very speedily, in 1674, it turned a cold shoulder on the latter till 1740. Of three significant words the etymology is quite obscure—sobriquet, used in our modern sense in the fifteenth century; sot, and sowche. About four more parts will complete this compact, scholar ly, yet popular dictionary. The gullibility of Quesnay de Beaurepaire, the late President of the Paris Court of Appeals, is a striking example of the mo nomania of suspicion not unknown in actual life and on the comic stage. His fanatic be lief in the guilt of Dreyfus has made him more than once the dupe of tricksters whose wiles any schoolboy of ordinary intelligence would have seen through. Any inte rested in this psychological problem should read ‘Karl et Quesnay de Beaurepaire’ (Pa ris: P. V. Stock). ‘‘Karl’’ is the wag, prot ably a student of the Latin Quarter, after easily making his victim swallow the bait of “irrefragable evidence’ against Dreyfus, exposed his credulity in the Figaro to the laughter of the world. “It was upon the judgment of this man that the liberty, the honor, the lives of a host of unfortunate men and women depended. The fate of hundreds of these was at the mercy of such want of sagacity and common sense.’ And then the question arises: Is it proba- ble that this judge of the highest rank is the only one of his kind? What influence will the discovery of such incapacity have upon the popular respect for the law and its representatives? The tenth volume of the ‘Collections of the one who, Nova Scotia Historical Society’ (Halifax) covers the years 1896-98, and consists of a monograph by T. Watson Smith, D.D., on ‘The Slave in Canada.’ This subject has been all but completely ignored by historians and school-book makers—‘‘Clement, the au thor of the school history accepted by nearly all the provinces, dismisses it in a single sentence’’—so that the present gene ration, even among the well informed, sceptical of the existence of slavery on pro vincial soil. Dr. Smith has been at great pains to establish the fact with such m!i- nuteness that no one will attempt the task again. The courts virtually abolished sla- very long before the British Emancipation Act of 1833 could operate upon it in Cana da, and apprehension as to the effects of this measure related wholly to the trade rela- tions between Canada and the West Indies Of the indemnity for emancipation, “not one solitary dollar found its way into Ca- nadian hands.”’ Dr. Smith has produced not only a permanently valuable book, but a very readable story, which has hitherto been covered up, not from shame, but from for- getfulness. He has few if any cases of ex- treme cruelty to record, and no instance of burning alive or dead. His survey would not have been complete without a chapter on Canada as the American fugitives’ para- dise—a glorious page. While he adda to our knowledge from his side of the line, he bas not fully studied the sources of our Underground Railway history. His caption, “Influence of Canadians on Slavery Else might have been illustrated by the fact that the leader of the moral agitation against slavery in the United States would but for the accident of his parents’ removai to Massachusetts, have been a native of Nova Scotia. is where,”’
Page 18
tO. The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1783 The annual report of the State Geologist of New Jersey for 1898 embraces as an appendix Mr. Gifford Pinchot’s ‘Study of Forest Fires and Wood Production in South- ern New Jersey,’’ a document of 100 pages, copiously illustrated, which will, we are sure, mark the beginning of the final effort to save that district from a scourge whose effects are moral as well as physical. Close- ly allied to this is Mr. C. C. Vermeule’s briefer paper on the pine belt of the same section in connection with water supply, a subject of great moment that cannot be too soon considered. The same authority, whose investigation of the volume of streams in New Jersey and available surface water- supply took rank at once as a standard work, makes here a first attempt to solve the more complex problem of water-supply from wells, which is nevertheless inseparable from that of surface-supply. Mr. Lewis Woolman furnishes his annual record of ar- tesian wells in New Jersey, which is contri- buting so much towards a definition of water-bearing strata not confined to that State alone. Prof. Rollin D. Salisbury sums up, from the practical side, his studies in the surface geology, characterizing the va- rious soils in relation to the underlying formations and to their economic utility. Dr. Kiimmel passes beyond the State limits on the north in order to complete, in Rock- land County, N. Y., his study of the Trias- sic red sandstones and trap rocks. The re- sult is confirmatory rather than novel. The variability in the thickness of the trap sheet is still remarkable, but more difficult to determine accurately. While it is some- times 400 feet above the Hudson River level, at certain points it lies beneath. The Secretary of Agriculture aims to make the Department’s Yearbook for 1899 a summary of what has been done in this country towards scientific agriculture dur- ing the lapsing century, and to distribute 50,000 copies at the Paris Exposition. Mr. Gifford Pinchot of the Division of Forestry accordingly solicits information regarding the efforts of private landowners to apply the principles of forestry economically and conservatively. He will send a card with printed inquiries to any one desirous to as- sist in collecting these statistics. A circular from the committee of fores- try and roadside improvement of the Mas- sachusetts Horticultural Society, Boston, asks about the kind of trees adorning the roadside in any locality, their thriving, objectionableness, etc. Answers are soli- cited before October 1. The Geographical Journal for August opens with Col, J. R. L. Macdonald's ac- count of his explorations in the almost un- known country to the north of Uganda and east of the Nile. The principal geogra- phical result was the discovery that the high and healthy plateau which lies be- tween Lake Victoria and the coast runs far to the northward, though at a reduced altitude. Parts of it were highly cultivat- ed and thickly inhabited, in one district with “a magnificently developed people of great stature’ and “possessing immense herds of cattle, donkeys, sheep, and goats." ‘Bach village or little group of villages has its own chief, but important matters are settled by a council of all the chiefs, and, as there are very strict and recognized rules regarding the settlement of serious disputes, there is no fighting between these numerous settlements.’s Another thing which distinguishes them from most Afri- can tribes is that “marriage is not merely a matter of barter. If the girl objects to marry her suitor, her refusal is absolute and settles the matter.’’ Supplementary to this is an account, by Major H. H. Austin, of a branch expedition which he led to the north of Lake Rudolf, in which he succeed- ed in making a comparatively thorough sur- vey of the western shore. There were evidences of the lake’s westward encroach- ment on the land. ‘At one point,’ he says, “we observed a regular line of trees, extending for a distance of between two and three miles out into the lake.” Prof. A. G. Nathorst summarizes the scientific results of the Swedish Arctic expedition of 1898, and calls attention to the bacterio- logical investigations. In a total of 4,400 gallons of the atmosphere filtered in a score of different localities, the doctor of the expedition ‘did not discover a single bacterium, and only an infinitesimal quan- tity of aspergillus, or mould.” He “further examined the intestinal contents of a num- ber of different animals, but without, ge- nerally speaking, discovering any traces of bacteria.’’ Among the collections brought home were “numerous specimens of red snow and green snow,” besides mam- mals and birds which will, it is hoped, form the nucleus of an Arctic Biological Museum. P. Leendertz, jr., in Noord en Zuid, treats of “The Names of the Months,” a subject of much interest to Dutch and Fle- mish scholars. This was the most vexa- tious problem connected with popularizing the Roman calendar in the Netherlands, which was not accomplished until long after the term of Roman occupation. While the remote German progenitors of the present Netherlanders had not names for all the twelve months, their descendants gradu- ally evolved one hundred and twenty-eight, more than a dozen of which, gleaned from mediwval manuscript almanacs in the Royal Library, have not been given by any other authority. These one hundred and twen- ty-eight examples (of which a careful list is drawn up, with a glossary) are ranged in eight classes, according to derivation from the season, the weather, the occupa- tions of man, the products of nature, the products of industry, the habits of animals, pagan and civic festivals, and church fes- tivals. Some of these are still in use, though not often now found in print. Natu- rally, each month’ received many names, while one name often did duty for more than one month. Not only might many of the above matters occur in more than one month, but the discrepancy between the lunar and the solar year often demanded the insertion of a whole month, which took the name of its predecessor, bringing all the names wrong the next year, and, this not being of rare occurrence, great con- fusion ensued. To remedy this, Charle- magne chose twelve of the names, and tried to have them generally used, but failed. The Church secured greater uni- formity, but only by substituting the La- tin names, which steadily gained ground, despite the efforts of purists and patriots. Why? Grimm says, no doubt rightly, be- cause of ambiguity and clumsiness in the popular names. The timely subject of the decadence of the Latin nations is treated in an article by Prof. Giuseppe Sergi of the University of Rome, in the Nuova Antologia for August 1 (“Come sono decadute le nazioni latine’’). Passing in rapid review the nations of the valley of the Euphrates and Tigris, of Asia Minor, Egypt, and Greece, the writer dwells more at length upon the Roman Em- pire, and winds up with the people of Italy, Spain, and France, in order to show that all of these either have passed away or are threatened with the same fate from one and the same cause, viz., immobility, or the desire to maintain unaltered and intact from foreign influences the civiliza- tion transmitted to them or developed by them. There is but one means by which a nation can resist the progressive impulses from outside without being doomed to ex- tinction, namely, absolute isolation.« It is thus that China has till now continued her national existence, but she belongs to ‘“‘so- cial paleontology,” and now that she has been forced to open her frontiers to out- siders her days seem to be numbered. Cor- ruption, vice, luxury, etc., can be considered only as concomitant causes of the deca- dence of the Roman Empire and of na- tions in general. The Renaissance in Italy could have become a real risorgimento only by repudiation of the Roman tradition, and, together with it, of the morbid aspiration of reviving the Empire; while, in fact, it was not a rinascimento but a rinvecchiamento, destined, as far as the reinvigoration of the nation is concerned, to failure. In modern Italy, Latinity, through the classical school, is still viewed as a continuation of Roman life: a fatal anachronism, a sign of inhi- bition to modern progress. These few points will suffice to show the trend of Prof. Sergi’s essay, and to suggest the ori- ginality of his thesis and arguments. In consequence of the unrestricted sale of alcoholic liquors in France, the number of débits in the country has reached the enormous figure of 424,500, or one to every eighty-five inhabitants. No wonder, there- fore, that the private organizations strug- gling against the evil of alcoholism are coming to be looked upon as insufficient, and that legislative action is resorted to. A measure, aiming at the gradual reduction of the places for the sale of liquor to one for every three hundred inhabitants, was introduced during the last session in the Senate and has found many supporters all over the land. At the same time, the cru- sade against strong drink is being vigorous- ly carried on by numerous temperance s0- cieties, forming together the Union Fran- caise Antialcoolique (6 Rue de Latran, Paris), which publishes a monthly journal under the editorship of Dr. Legrain, the head of the inebriate asylum at Ville- Evrard. In the army and navy the tem- perance movement has also taken root, and much zeal is displayed by teachers and school inspectors in the provinces. From Cahors (the home of Gambetta), e. g., it is reported that there are as many branches of the temperance league as there are schools in the district, and ‘“‘games have been organized so that even hardened drinkers prefer, on Sundays, the bowling- alley in front of the school-house to the tavern.” It is rather curious that wine- growers, i. ¢., those not manufacturing dis- tilled liquors, are looked upon as the stanchest friends of the temperance league. In so-called temperance restaurants li- mited quantities of natural wine are serv-~- ed with the meals, if desired. ‘Total ab-
Page 19
Aug. 31, 1899] The Nation. stinence” has reference to spirituous li- quors. The death of Dr. William Wright has directed attention to the extraordinary growth of the work of the British and Foreign Bible Society, of which he was for more than twenty years the linguistic superintendent. During that time 153 new versions of the Bible, in whole or in part, were added to the Society’s list, which now contains 364 versions in different lan- guages and dialects. This means that the same influence which the English Bible has exerted on the English character and tongue since the days of Wiclif and Tyndale is now being exerted on multitudinous races and tribes. The practical boycott of the Indian coolie and merchant throughout Africa, with the sole exception of British East Africa, is apparently about to lead to the develop- ment on a vast scale of unoccupied land in India. In Assam alone, the province ad- joining Bengal, whose population taxes the utmost food-producing powers of the soil, out of eight and one-half millions of cul- tivable land only one and three-quarter millions are occupied. It is proposed to bring this great region into communication with the congested province by the exten- sion of the Assam-Bengal Railway, the construction of roads and tramways, and the granting of tracts not exceeding 10,- 000 acres for thirty-three years free of taxation to native capitalists, on condi- tion that they clear their grant of forest and jungle. This would create a pro- prietary body, which is contrary to the set- tled policy of the Indian Government, name- ly, to secure the land to the actual tillers of the soil; but the exigencies of the situa- tion may compel the adoption of the scheme. Our correspondent “D. B.’’ calls attention to an error in his interesting letter on the Isle of Man in the Nation of August 3, where one should read £10,000 instead of £10 as the tribute the island annually pays to the Imperial Government. An error of quite as grave significance in a different category arose on p. 136 (No. 1781), when quoting the lines lent by Mrs. Wordsworth to her hus- band. “That inward eye which is the bliss of solitude,” was fatally disfigured by lapse of pen or memory into inner. —Prince Kropotkin continues, in the Sep- tember Atlantic, his lurid narrative in his restrained and considered style. It embraces the assassination of Alexander II., Kropot- kin’s expulsion from Switzerland a few months later, and his subsequent life, first on French soil, later in London, again in France, his arrest under the new extradition treaty between France and Prussia, his im- prisonment at Clairvaux, with his release and return to Lordon in ’86. His estimate of Alexander II. is not ungenerous, but, ex- cepting the prison episode, there is in this instalment of the memoirs more of the in- verted vocabulary peculiar to anarchism, hence more to alienate sympathy, than be- fore. Prof. Hugo Miinsterberg’s article, ‘‘The Germans and the Americans,’”’ we discuss elsewhere. A foregleam of the promised Life of John Murray Forbes by his daughter is af- forded in Mr. Edward Waldo Emerson's agreeable biographical notice of that perfect citizen. Mr. Crothers’s paper on “‘The Mis- sion of Humor,” like Saadi, sits in the sun. Blessed are they, says the Psalmist, who, go- ing through the vale of misery, use it for 171 a well. This article will show them how. The only short story in the magazine is a particularly good one, by Elia Peattie. Is the Contributors’ Club asleep or dead or peradventure on a journey? —The proposed American interoceanic ca- nal is the principal subject of the August number of the National Geographic Magazine (Washington). In a striking article on its commercial aspects, Mr. Joseph Nimmo, jr., formerly Chief of the Bureau of Statistics in the Treasury Department, calls attention to the fact that, though $1,326,176 has been ap- propriated within four years to ascertain the engineering features and cost of con- struction, ‘“‘not one cent has been appro- priated by Congress for the purpose of as- certaining the probable commercial value of the project—i. e., the amount of shipping which would pass through it.’’ Yet section 231 of the Revised Statutes expressly pro- vides for the preparation and submission to Congress of ‘‘full statements of all existing facts tending to show to what extent the general commerce of the country will be promoted” by such works as this. The as- sertion of the advocates of the canal that its commercial necessity is so clear that it needs no investigation, he meets with the fact that it is not the shortest nor most practicable route for the trade of our Atlan- tic seaports with Asia or Australasia. The distance from New York to Manila by the Suez Canal—a sea-level canal, whereas the Nicaragua involves 220 feet of lockage—is 181 miles less than by the Nicaragua Canal. As to the anticipated commerce of the States east of the Rockies with the Pacific States, he holds it impossible to believe that, with the present number of transcon- tinental railroads and the low cost of trans- portation (the average rate being ‘‘about one-third the average of the rates which prevailed thirty years ago’’), any important part of this trade could be diverted to the canal. This conviction is strengthened by the fact that railroad competition has prov- ed almost destructive of river and canal traffic. The commerce with South America is not an appreciable factor, as it is mostly carried on by sailing vessels, and the canal is impracticable for them. In fact, ‘“‘the general trend of the evolution of trans- portation facilities during the last twenty years has been in the direction of reducing the possible tonnage of any American inter- oceanic canal. From a computation based upon all the controlling conditions of the present day, I conclude that not more than 400,000 tons of shipping annually can be confidently expected to pass through any such canal. The receipts from any American interoceanic canal from tolls would there- fore be insufficient to meet the expenses of its maintenance and administration, with nothing for interest on cost of construction, amounting probably to eight million dollars a year.” —Armando Ferrari discusses in the Mi- lan Perseveranza the origin of the sonnet. In time it remounts to the first decades of the thirteenth century. In structure, Bia- dene has shown that it arose from a fusion of a strambotto of eight lines and one of six. This glee form of verse has never ceased to flourish in Sicily. What regicn of Italy was to be credited with the fusion is the chief matter in debate. Ferrara bases an argument on a disputa on love, of which the joint autbors were a Tuscan, Jacopo Mostacci of Pisa; a Neapolitan, the youthful Pier della Vigna of Capua; and a Sicilian, the notary Jacopo da Lentini. The disputa (an imitation of the Provencal) was opened by Mostacci, who had recourse to the strambotto of eight lines, but found the vessel too small for its contents, and so annexed the six-line strambotto. The four- teen, making one body, he passed on to Pier della Vigna, who responded in kind, while Lentini capped their efforts with one of his own, without, however, uniting the two strambotti. Ferrari supposes plausibly that the three friends met at the University of Bologna, then a great seat of learning; and it is notorious that at that epoch Pler della Vigna was a student there. By this clever boxing of the compass Ferrari satisfies many local ambitions. The Sonnet, of Si cilian components, was born in Bologna about 1224; a Pisan called it in being with the aid of two representatives of the southern provinces. Crossing the Apen- nines into Tuscany, it there flowered to perfection under Dante’s care and Pe- trarch’s. What poetic form could be more thoroughly national? ~—With keen regret we record the death at Seal Harbor, Maine, on August 3, of William McCrillis Griswold, son of the late Rufus Wilmot Griswold, but better known as the creator of the “Q. P. In- dexes."" This series embraced the North American Review, Lippincott’s Magazine, the elder Scribner, the Eelectic, Harper's Weekly, some British and some German historical magazines, Essays, etc., and a line of “Q. P. Annuals.’ It was, moreover, initiated with a general index to the Nation (1865-1880, afterwards extended to 1885. with a contemplated and perhaps commen- ced extension to date). Jt was entirely cha- racteristic of Mr. Griswold that he under- took this most useful work, peculiarly use- ful to the editors of the Nation itself, with- out previous consultation with them or any request for support, so that its appearance was a complete surprise. It was but one mark of Mr. Griswold’s attachment to this journal, to which he was a more or less fre- quent contributor, as well as its ever friend- ly critic. The scope of the Index was literary, historical, social, and economic, and left room for one political; and this, entitled ‘A Record of Politics and Poll- ticians in the United States, 1865-1882,’ with occasional references to other sources than the Nation, was subsequently (1883) produced, equally unsolicited and unherald- ed, and has a value quite beyond any prob- able general appreciation of it. Of all Mr. Griswold’s indexes it is proper to say that they bore the strongest marks of the “‘per- sonal equation.” He was his own pub- lisher; his labors could fairly be called disinterested, since the pecuniary return was most precarious; hence, a studied con- densation, with signs and symbols offering no little obstacle to rapid reference. Even some phonetic deformations in line with the so-called reform (applicable last of all to an index) were philanthropically adopted by Mr. Griswold. These eccentricities were reinforced by an imperfect knowledge of the mechanic art of printing. But, all de- ductions made, the Quarterly Periodical Indexes were and will ever remain a great boon to students. —This indexical passion, rather than gift was manifested in other ways—in a com-
Page 20
The Nation. [Vol 69, No. 1783 172 pilation of narratives called ‘ Travel,’ ‘France,’ ‘Germany,’ and ‘Switzerland’ re- spectively, and in Descriptive Lists of No- vels, of much higher and more permanent worth. Here the classification was carried out by countries, and even by sections in the case of the United States; and current criti- cism of each work was cited, according to the editor’s lights or material. In the prose- cution of this task, Mr. Griswold employed and increased his exceptional knowledge of the more or less forgotten periodicals of the day of small things in American let- ters—the period of his father’s literary ac- tivity as journalist and author (to mention but one of his numerous works) of the ‘Poets and Poetry of America.’ Mr. Griswold bore with a rare philosophy the renewed assaults of latter-day admirers of Poe upon his fa- ther’s memory, which Mr. Woodberry’s su- preme biography’ effectually vindicated against the charge of malignity towards the poet. Only a year ago did he publish, not an apologia, but a truthful portrait by in- direction of his father, consisting of the frankest presentation of ‘Passages from the Correspondence and Other Papers of Rufus W. Griswold.’ Our readers can turn to the review in No. 1742 of the Nation to refresh their memory of this very important land- mark in our literary history. It was, un- fortunately, marred by defects in construc- tion, and, being a private venture like all the rest of its author’s, it fell somewhat flat, but no public library can afford to be without it. It was an honorable as well as a pious termination of Mr. Griswold’s la- bors. The death of this not more indefati- gable than modest worker was untimely. He was born in Bangor, Maine, in 1853, and gra- duated at Harvard College in 1875. A wife and children survive him. -Probably the most noteworthy of the many efforts put forth to secure a modifi- cation or revision of the steps recently taken by the Russian Government against the national individuality of the Finns, has been a series of appeals, on the part of the savants, scholars, artists, and other non- political men of prominence in all the lead- ing countries of Europe, addressed to the Czar. It is a singular phenomenon that the movement was spontaneous and independent in these various countries, and in all prac~- tically on the supposition that the Czar himself had not a clear conception of the far-reaching evils of his decree, so that the addresses were virtually appeals “from the Czar poorly informed to the Czar bet- ter informed.”” The German address could circulate only for a short period, but never-~ theless secured 160 signatures from among the brightest minds of the country. Lister’s name heads the English list, while the French bears the names of mary members of the Academy. The Italian address contains an exceptionally long list of prominent names; Austria and Hungary each sent one of their own; the Belgians sent both a Flemish and a French appeal; and in those of Holland, Switzerland, Denmark, Norway, and Sweden the signatures of the leading thinkers and authors are found. It is rare- ly that an international manifestation of this character, without a central impetus, proves so extensive and successful among this class of men. Recently a deputation of prominent scholars and savants assembled in St. Petersburg, and asked for permission to present an address to the Czar, but an audience was refused them. , TUCKER'S CONSTITUTION OF THE UNITED STATES. The Constitution of the United States: A Critical Discussion of its Genesis, Develop- ment, and Interpretation. By John Ran- dolph Tucker, LL.D., late Professor of Constitutional and International Law and Equity in Washington and Lee University. Edited by Henry St. George Tucker, Pro- fessor [in the same chair]. Chicago: Cal- laghan & Co. 1899. Two volumes, octa- vo, pp. xxviii, 1,016. The son of “Randolph Tucker’ has done well in publishing these volumes. Although not quite finished, and never revised by the author, they preserve for us with substan- tial fulness the constitutional views, and the grounds of them, held by one of the best and ablest of modern Virginia statesmen; one who was true to the old doctrines of his State, and who had the opportunity to restate them and attempt their vindication in the light of what has been decided since that great event which is known at the South as “the war between the States.’’ Whoever takes up this book, having known the de- lightful man that wrote it, so full of cha- racter, intellectual energy, and a contagious, irresistible generosity and kindness of na- tur., almost the type of what we think of as best in the old-fashioned gentleman of Virginia, will need no urging to read it. All who knew him must rejoice to see this record of his best and most serious thinking—a book full of interest and instruction. Whether one agrees with the writer’s fun- damental positions or not, and whether or not one finds them in harmony with the later decisions of our Supreme Court, he will, at any rate, agree that they are clearly stated, put with force, and carried out to logical conclusions. And the reader who has been bred on other meat than this will do well to reflect that what he finds here has got to be reckoned with. It may not agree with what our courts are laying down to- day; but the history of our Supreme Court teaches us that the fashion of courts passeth away; what is prevalent in this age may va- nish in the next. This book is not, properly speaking, a law book, a treatise on constitutional law, but rather, what its title imports, a commentary on the Constitution of the United States by a lawyer. We have chapters of political philosophy, followed by textual criticism and exposition and historical explanation; and also a fairly full statement and criticism of the cases. The legal aspect of the subject is not the sole or even the primary one. The author’s fundamental conception of the instrument is seen in such a passage as the following. He has been saying that while the States have the greater number of pow- ers, the Federal Government has “preémi- nence in the reach and majesty of power. But in their essential sovereignty of dominion they are alike and of equal digni- ty.”’ And then he adds (p. 847): “The real question in the comparison of the two classes [of powers] is as to the holders of the respective powers. The Fede- ral Government holds the one class and the State Governments the other class. Back of both is the reserved authority of the States, as delegators of both classes, and as the original source of all powers belonging to both governments. The powers held by the Federal and State Governments are dele- gated to them by the States, as the bodies- politic, with essential sovereignty, from which emanate the functional capacities of each of these governments.” The writer goes on to say that this is de- monstrated by the fact that the Constitution prohibits the States from exercising the pow- ers delegated to the Federal Government. Why prohibit, if it was not necessary? ‘‘An- nul the prohibition by striking out this sec- tion, and these powers would belong to the State governments concurrently with the Fe- deral Government.” This reasoning may seem inadequate, but the style of it is characteris- tic of that method of discussion, refined, in- genious, academic, which our old Northern Federalists used to wonder at. when they first met the Virginia statesmen in Congres- sional debate. The Virginia Federalists had it, and even the judicial opinions of Marshall, the greatest of them all, are full of it. The meaning of the passage above quoted will be elucidated by adding the writer’s explanation of some of these phrases. In an earlier part of the book he describes the ‘‘body-politic” as ‘the corporate unity of the many, bound together in society,” and points out that the “distinction between the body- politic and the Government is fundamental and essential.’’ The former “is not the Government, nor the persons ad- mitted to participate in the functions of Government, but it is the whole body of persons politically associated. . . . A con- stitution . is the act by which the Body-politic constitutes the Government and delegates and limits its powers. . . . The Body-politic is creator; the Government its creature; the Body-politic is principal; the Government its agent. Every Gov- ernment is the delegated agent of some or- ganic Body-politic. . Destroy the Gov- ernment and the Body-politic remains. De- stroy the Government of a State, and the State still stands. But destroy the Government of the United States, and what single Body- politic remains? All that would remain would be the forty-five Bodies-politic—the States.”’ The writer agrees that the fourteenth amendment is a final, authoritative denial of the doctrine of secession, of a legal right to withdraw from the Union; but he holds that the fundamental character of the Union re- mains unchanged, that it is still merely a compact between States whose only bond is the Constitution. There is no ‘merger or fusion”’ of States or people into a new Body- politic. There is only a new ‘‘Government,” discharging certain functions for the States. We are “functionally one’ as to the dele- gated Federal powers, but “organically sepa- rate’ as independent States. Such a theory as contrasted with that simpler view, which time and events seem likely to uphold, viz., that the people of each State have created a new nation by contributing a share of their power to a common stock—-each the same share — must, of course, bear fruit in the interpre- tation of the Constitution. Very different re- sults are reached from such different pre- mises. See; for example, the influence of our author’s fundamental theory in his in- genious argumentation about the legal- tender question (p. 514): “Congress can coin money; the States cannot. And the gold and silver coin struck by Congress becomes legal tender because the States are forbidden to make anything else legal tender. The denial to the States to make anything but gold and silver coin a legal tender indicates that, but for this prohibition, the States might have done so. This prohibition to the States and the grant to Congress result in the conclusion that Congress can make current a coin which is legal tender in the payment of debts, and against which the States cannot discriminate. If this be so, how can bills emitted under the power to eee
Page 21
Aug. 31, 1899] The Nation. 73 1 borrow money, and not as currency, be a legal tender for any debt?” And again (p. 825), in speaking of the prohibition on the States, we read that if | this be put with the clause giving Congress the power to coin money, the clause “would then be as if it read, ‘Congress shall have the power to coin gold and silver | coins, and no State shall make any but these a tender in the payment of debts. esi There is no power given to Con- gress, nor a hint of a power in Congress, to make anything a tender in the payment of debts. It would, therefore, seem to be a sound interpretation of these kindred clauses of the Constitution, that while Con- gress was to be the instrument for put- ting the stamp of currency upon coins of gold and silver, in order to create a circu- lating medium, the States were forbidden to make anything but these coins a tender in the payment of debts, and no power was de- legated to the United States to do so; and therefore, as a medium for the solution of debts between man and man, the tution intended that the gold and silver coin stamped by Congress, as well as foreign coin, to be regulated by Congress, was to be the only medium for the payment of debts under the system established by the Constitution.” And again (p. 516): “If, then, the Constitution has made gold and silver coin the only legal tender, and Congress has power to strike these coins, and this power to coin is denied to the States as well as the power to make any other than these coins a legal tender, it |} on a judge be or be not in pursuance of the Consti- tution—where the repugnancy is not clear and beyoud reasonable doubt—it should re- frain from making the law void in effect by its judgment, lest it should be really repealing a valid law by legislative act, instead of declaring it void by judicial act. The obligation of the Constitution in respect to his judicial func- tions is different from its obligation on a legislator or executive officer. The oath of the judge binds him to support the Constitution as to the prescribed limits of his jurisdiction as a precondition to his discharge of his function in declaring a law to be unconstitutional. His duty to | do the latter depends upon whether his ju- | risdiction extends to it; and, unless it clear- Consti- | would seem to follow that Congress may | coin both metals, and can deny to neither the functions of money. As the States are confined to both, as legal tender, Congress must furnish both.” Even as hard as that the author is willing to squeeze his grapes! When one reads this sort of reasoning, he seems to be living in the days before the war. There is much else that gives a like impression. The Dred Scott case, for example, is cited re- peatedly as if it bad decided what was merely the dictum of two or three judges. It never was the law of the Supreme Court that negroes, merely as such, or even ne- groes the descendants of slaves, were not citizens, capable, merely as such, of litigat- ing in the Federal Courts. Again, the writer puts forward the old doctrine as to the in- ability of Congress to keep slavery out of the Territories, and denies the validity of the reconstruction acts and of any power to hold the rebellious States under military government when they had laid down their arms. Indeed, one finds here most of the main consequences of that highly elaborated theory of our national Constitution which had been worked out at the South of old, under the influence of a parti pris, to pro- tect their local institution of slavery. It is fortunate that these doctrines have now to fight their way and hold their own, if they can, North and South, simply upon their merits. It will probably be found, in this open field of controversy, that they will not fit the facts of the past any better than they will serve the purposes of the future. In arriving at a theoretical conclusion in favor of the judicial power to disregard legislative enactments as unconstitutional, Mr. Tucker adopts the view of Marshall that it is necessarily involved in the idea of a written constitution. He does not advert, any more than Marshall did, to the experience of other countries having such constitutions yet recognizing no such power in the courts. In considering the scope of this power, he says, forcibly and justly: “If the court be in doubt whether a law ly extends to it, in undertaking to decide on the unconstitutionality of a law he may pass the boundaries of his jurisdiction, and exercise the legislative power of repeal; therefore he cannot declare a law void or unconstitutional unless for clear and un- doubted repugnancy. The case is different with the legislator and the executive. ... If he doubts his power .. . he is bound to resolve the doubt against the act, not in favor of it.” It is this point, so often forgotten in impatient comments on perfectly sound and just decisions of our courts, which Cooley has put so well in saying that a member of the Legislature may refuse to vote for a bill on the ground of its uncon- stitutionality, and yet afterwards, when promoted to the bench, be bound to support the same measure, if passed by the Legis- lature against his vote, as being consti- tutional; that is to say, not so clearly unconstitutional that he can disregard the decision of the Legislature, the body charg- ed, in the first instance, with the right and duty to act. As to the construction of these volumes, the main text (874 pages) is divided into four- teen chapters. The formal exposition of the Constitution begins with chapter viii, at page 349. The first seven chapters are made up of an introduction, in which some fundamental principles are worked out and terminology is settled, and of other chapters on the Source of Sovereignty and Power, the Limit of Governmental Pow- ers, the Origin of English Institutions, Ame- rican Constitutional Development, Two Important Compromises in the Constitution, and The Constitution as Modified by the Civil War. The other chapters deal first with the arrangement and interpretation of the instrument, and then take up in turn the legislative department (nearly three hundred pages), the first ten amendments, the executive department, the judicial de- partment, and limitations on the powers of the States. An appendix of some sixty pages contains a variety of illustrative documents, including the Constitution and the Virginia and Kentucky Resolutions of 1798. Although the author had not quite completed his work, the editor has prefer- red to print it as fit stood, without under- taking to supply any omissions. Apparent- ly these were not many. This serious and valuable treatise is pub- lished in a worthy style, handsome and solid. In the excellent preface, the editor, who is, we believe, the author’s son, as well as successor in his chair at the University, tells us that the author, born in 1823, died in February, 1897, and that systematic work on these volumes only be- gan in the autumn of 1895. “He was the son of Henry St. George Tucker, President of the Court of Appeals of Virginia, and grandson of St. George Tucker, also a mem- ber of that court, and who was the author of ‘Tucker's Blackstone,’ the first commen tary on the Constitution of the United States.” Students of political science, of constitutional history, and of constitutional law have reason to be grateful to the editor for the pious care and the good judgment with which he has produced these studies of his distin- guished father. They contain ample evidence of what the editor impressively says “The book is an expression of the views of the author—not merely his intellectual op! nions, but his deep convictions—in the con sistent exercise of which he lived and in the faith of which he died; and neither the dis sent of friendship, nor the storm of pepular indignation, nor yet the of preferment, ever shook his unswerving devo- tion to them.”’ It is proper to mention two or three slight errors. On p. 159 the author says that England the crown has not veto power since 1692. 1707, in refusing her assent to the Scotch Militia Bill. The important case of Hans vr. Louisiana, in both the table of cases and the book itself, is disguised as Ham v. Louisiana In citing Cooley on Constitutional Law, we are not told which of his two books is meant. the ‘Principles’ or the ‘Limitations.’ It may be added that the author, at p. 803, miscon- ceives the case of Gelpcke v. Dubuque; and that here and there, as in the cases of Able- man v. Booth, the Dred Scott case, already mentioned, and the Milligan case, he states inexactly the points decided. But it should also be added that these are trifling things to speak of, in so large a work, which the author had no opportunity to revise. hope political in the Anne exercised it in exercised by Justin McCarthy, M.-P. 1899. There is no form of literature so much in demand to-day as personal and there are probably few people living so well qualified as Mr. McCarthy, both by his experience and his powers of expression, to meet this demand. Beginning life as a news- paper reporter, he had excellent opportunities of seeing and describing some of the great men of his youth. Then he became editor of the Morning Star in the days when it was largely under the personal influence of John Bright and represented the most intelligent liberal opinion of England. Then he somed out as a successful littérateur, which implies a passport to all that is most inte resting in London society; and, finally, he became an active and influential member of Parliament. Such a career would even a retiring person to make many inte- resting acquaintances, though he might frain from describing them; in the Mr. McCarthy, with a sociable disposition and a passion for celebrities of all kinds. such a career made these good-sized volumes quite inevitable. The book has the defects of its writer's qualities. This very geniality, this remarka- ble absence of political bias and personal venom, this fondness for all the celebrated men “who have shaken me by the hand,”’ produces a certain monotony of praise that becomes a trifle wearisome. One is reminded of John Bright's theory that in properly con- structed novels and plays there should be none but good characters. Possibly he was right in believing that such stories would raise the moral standard of readers, but would it be entirely safe to assume that they would continue to be read? Making due al- Reminiscences Harper & Bros. reminiscences, blos- compel re- case of
Page 22
174 The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1783 lowance, however, for this defect, there re- mains so much of the charm that invariably attaches to genuine personal recollections of the great that the book is assured of many interested readers. Mr. McCarthy’s earliest recollection of Gladstone dates back to 1854, in which year he was sent to London to report the Budget speech for a Liverpool paper. He was as- signed to a seat in a remote corner of the gallery and feared that his mission would prove a failure. Great was his relief, there- fore, when he found that the Chancellor of the Exchequer’s wonderful powers of voice and elocution enabled him to catch every syllable. Next to his voice, Mr. McCarthy was most impressed by Gladstone’s eyes, which, like Goethe’s, seemed to have the power of resting on every one in the room at the same time. In later years he, of course, knew Gladstone well, and he says that his face became more and more striking as the years went on, and that it possessed that preéminent quality of distinction that at once compelled the attention of a stranger—a quality, by the way, which he found also in the face of Nathaniel Hawthorne. Of his con- versation, Mr. McCarthy says that he had the happy faculty of drawing out the ideas of his company, and that, in spite of his wide range of knowledge and love of speech, he never produced the Johnsonian effect of a schoolmaster haranguing a class. Mr. McCarthy is a great admirer of Dick- ens. His admiration shows no sign of hav- ing suffered from the reactionary chill that has struck so many of the early votaries, but it breaks out in a new place. He does not, like Andrew Lang, go into fine frenzies over ‘Pickwick’ or Little Nell, but he admits that he is quite unable to do justice to Dickens’s genius for after-dinner speaking. He con- siders him the very best speaker he has ever heard under these conditions, and he brack- ets Lowell and Depew in the second place. On the other hand, he is willing to allow that Dickens’s readings, while inimitable in their way, were at least a fair subject for criticism. To many who heard those read- ings, and can recall the intense disappoint- ment and shattered enthusiasm that follow- ed the author’s interpretation of his own works, this may seem a very moderate ad- mission; but Mr. McCarthy is so pleased with the recollection of the novelist’s hand- shake that it.is perhaps all that could be ex- pected. In connection with Thackeray, Mr. McCarthy revives the old discussion as to whether or not the author was entitled to a place in his own ‘Book of Snobs,’ and de- cides in favor of the negative view. But here again his good nature and loyalty to those who were once his friends seem to warp his judgment. Of so many people does Mr. McCarthy say, “So and so was always described as very disagreeable, but I am bound to say that I found him kind and pleasant’’—or words to that effect—that the reader will be apt to wonder what dire offence Charles Kingsley could have committed that he alone is outside the pale. In all this crowded gallery of portraits only his is painted in decidedly unpleasing colors, and what faint praise is thrown in is clearly of the damning variety. Lord John Rus- sell, on the other hand, is one of Mr. Mc- Carthy’s heroes, in disregard of the po- pular opinion that Lord John was selfish and cold-blooded. That he had a saving sense of humor is well known, and nothing could be neater than his reply to Sir Fran- cis Burdett, who had formerly been a Radical agitator, and was expressing his contempt for the cant of patriotism: ‘‘Yes,”’ said Lord John, ‘‘there is only one thing worse, and that is the recant of patriot- ism.’”’ Mr. McCarthy says that nothing in the nature of a living experience ever car- ried him so far back in time as hearing Lord John casually mention that he had met in Florence the widow of the Young Pretender. But, after all, this is not as startling as it sounds when we remember that the drunken reprobate who had once been known as “Bonnie Prince Charlie’ died in 1788, while his widow lived till 1824. Moreover, in the minds of most readers, the mention of the lady recalls Alfieri rather than the Pretender. Of Cobden and Bright Mr. McCarthy saw a good deal, and in comparing them he very justly says that, while Cobden believed in democracy as such, Bright’s efforts were directed to the accomplishment of certain specific reforms, especially of the suffrage, and that, when these were attained, he virtually became a Conservative. Cobden was disliked in England forty years ago, as such men are disliked in America to-day, because, although he was not a peace-at- any-price man, he thoroughly distrusted a war policy as a means of benefiting man- kind, and he had absolutely no sympathy with the spirit of Jingoism. It was this feeling that actuated him when he told Lord Palmerston that he could not take office under him because he had frequent- ly described him as the worst Foreign Minister England had ever had. ‘‘But,” said Palmerston, “Milner Gibson has often said the very same thing, and he is going to take office.’ ‘Yes,’ replied Cobden blandly, ‘“‘but then I meant it.’’ Of the great public speakers of other days, Mr. McCarthy instances Brougham, whom he heard at the banquet of the So- cial Science Association at Liverpool in 1858, and he describes the curious effect on the company of the sudden appearance on the scene of a very venerable old man, with whom Brougham at once fell into earnest conversation, but who was entire- ly unknown to the rest. It turned out to be Robert Owen, the philanthropist, then in his eighty-seventh year, who had out- lived his generation and seemed like one returned from another world. With many natural disadvantages, Brougham was un- doubtedly one of the greatest orators that ever lived. For sheer force of sustained logical argument he was perhaps equalled by Sir George Lewis, who, Mr. McCar- thy declares, was the only speaker who ever succeeded in completely changing his opinion in regard to tbe subject under discussion. No doubt this sort of con- version is very seldom accomplished be- cause the speeches delivered in legislative bodies are apt to be aimed at the public out- side. Mr. McCarthy has paid several visits to this country, and, being a good-natured per- son, and having been very well received here, he has nothing but pleasant things to say about us—some of which, we hope, are true. We would call attention, however, to one of his statements which is obviously in- correct. He says that greater changes have taken place in the outer aspects of the streets of New York in the last ten years than have taken place in London in the last forty-five years. Possibly this might be true about the comparatively small sections of the two cities that come under the observation of the well-to-do, although the immense changes that have been wrought in London during the longer period by the Embankment, the Holborn Viaduct, and the new avenues leading to Charing Cross seem to make it improbable. But in the last forty-five years great cities have been added to London at every point of the compass, as any one may discover by driving in a hansom from north to south or from east to west; compared with these vast additions, the growth of New York in the last ten years is absolutely insignificant. Of course Mr. McCarthy has known many Americans and tells many American stories —among others, one of Henry Ward Beecher’s reading from the pulpit various letters received by him during the previous week. One of these contained the single word “Fool.” ‘Now,’ said Beecher, ‘I have known many a man write a letter and then forget to sign it, but I never knew a man sign a letter and then forget to write Tie With characteristic good nature, Mr. Mc- Carthy seeks to rehabilitate certain dubious political reputations, such as those of Prince Napoleon and Lord Randolph Churchill. In the case of the Prince he succeeds in showing that he was a free- trader, that he foresaw the rise of Prussia, that he foretold the result of the American Civil War, and that he was utterly opposed to the Emperor’s Mexican’ enterprise. Moreover, it appears that Cavour had a high opinion of the Prince’s statesmanship. Mr. McCarthy’s brief in favor of Randolph Churchill rests largely on a story which certainly shows the possession of humor, It appears that a great lady once spoke to him of the fund being raised for the benefit of the wives of distressed Irish landlords, and said that, though she was entirely in sympathy with the movement, she had not subscribed to the fund. “I see,” said Churchill, ‘‘your sympathy doesn’t take that form.’”’ But it would require more than a good story to establish Lord Ran- dolph’s claim to be a statesman. We have not space to dwell on Mr. Mc- Carthy’s account of George Eliot’s Sunday receptions, his description of the continual controversies between Froude and Freeman, his lifelike pictures of Huxley and Tyndall. Suffice it to say that on these and many other topics he is instructive and entertain- ing, and amiable always. German Higher Schools: The History, Or- ganization, and Methods of Secondary Education in Germany. By James E. Rus- sell, Ph.D. Longmans, Green & Com- pany. 1899. Of all species of extravagant waste, there is none more unpardonable than that which permits one nation to remain in ignorance of the clever and successful methods devised in another for gaining important ends. The enormous product, in the way of scholar- ship, which is brought forth in Germany each year is such a remarkable phenomenon that when any light can be thrown upon its first causes, that light must be received with gratitude by those who wish to see a like brilliant issue in our own country. Mr. Russell’s book is very exhaustive; it is the result of a long study of the subject,
Page 23
Aug. 31, 1899] The Nation. res and, so far as his descriptions can be tested by one’s personal observations, it is re- markably accurate and sound. Every one who is actively interested in the improve- ment of methods of education in this coun- try will give serious study to this volume: we can only say here in general terms that much is accomplished in Germany be- cause much is demanded of the teacher, and of the pupil as well. Education is made a matter of extreme concern in every family; nothing but serious illness is allowed to keep a child away from school for a single day, and no extraneous interests are suf- fered to interfere with his steady prepara- tion of his daily tasks. With this spirit thoroughly ingrained in the family, it be- comes possible for the teacher to ask for and to obtain a very large output of work from the student. It is true that it is not disinterested love of learning on the part of the family which brings about this re- sult; a boy’s career depends so absolutely upon his completing each grade of study at the right moment, and with the right de- gree of success, that the pressure is very strong to see that nothing hinders him upon his way. The obverse of this picture of industry is that there is not enough time for play, and especially not enough con- secutive free time for engaging in the regu- lar athletic sports. But it is possible that athletic sports are less essential to the boy’s well-being than we have hitherto sup- posed in Anglo-Saxon countries; it is pos- sible that the English authority on food and feeding is right in thinking them an excrescence that might well be removed, an effort to work off the ill effects of the Anglo-Saxon diet, over-rich in proteids. Without question, the time which the Ger- man youth gives to music contributes more to making him a civilized human being than many hours of athletics would do; and if it is a question of enduring health, he is far from falling in the rear of his American competitor. It should be remembered that “secondary education’ has not the same signification in Germany as here; its upper end coincides with the end of the second or third year of our college course, as nearly as comparison can be made. We do not associate with the phrase the reading of Sophocles and ®schylus, yet that is covered by it in Ger- many, and yet the boy finishes this portion of his studies at the age of eighteen, as a general rule. Though there is not at all the same fixed relation between age and advancement in school here as there, it may, nevertheless, be safely assumed that the German boy of eighteen is fully two years ahead of the American in acquire- ment. And the character of the instruction which he has received, as a means to the producing of a cultivated human being, may be gathered from this bit of description in the book before us: “J have heard such masters. teach Sophocles in a way to make one uncertain which to admire most, the marvellous beauty, depth of emotion, and ethical content of the tragedy, or the artistic power of the teacher in making every scene pul- sate with life and every sentence speak straight to the hearts of his students. The ethical, the msthetic, and the patriotic blend in one.” Without going into detailed questions of methods, which are for the technical edu- cational journals to discuss, we note some random points of interest. BEducation is compulsory from six to fourteen; it is free from six to nine. The cost of instruction in the gymnasium is from $20 to $30 a year. but there are many bursaries. One-half the expenses of the schools is paid by these tuition fees; the general Government pays only one-sixth of the expenses, but it as- sumes very complete control of the educa- tion furnished. From five to six hours a day are spent in the school-room, and from one to three hours are given to outside study; this latter, however, consists chiefly in working up the exercises of the past day. Instruction goes on with much more effort on the part of the teacher than with us, and what we call the “recitation” is not known either in fact or in name. The modern German teacher has become (thanks to the explicit effort of the Government to this end) a person of much social im- portance; with the military rank which it is now his privilege and his hope to attain, he has gained a distinguished bearing which differentiates him widely from the tradi- tional German pedagogue. The five or six thousand school-teachers who have be- come officers of the Landwehr have made a complete revolution in the status of the teaching profession: ‘‘to have officers of the Reserve in a school is equivalent to saying that there are just so many able disciplinarians, perfect gentlemen, men of high moral character and ambitions in the teaching corps.” If the discipline is fre- quently stern and the teacher apparent- ly unsympathetic, this is not disagreeable to the student; he is himself imbued with the military spirit, and is not averse to having it manifested in the school-room. The German principle for secondary in- struction is that the pupil should not be left to flounder about by himself, but that everything should be made plain to him in the class-room. He is considered to have not yet arrived at the stage of inde- pendent study, and time is not to be wast- ed in beating about the bush. The ability to make an occasional lucky guess is in no wise identical with sustained logical thought. The supervision of pupils is not confined to the school premises, but has to do with their entire life outside of school, nor are parents permitted to have their own way with their children. The school- master is in the possession of professional knowledge, and the whims of over-indul- gent parents are not allowed to interfere with his methods of training. The use of tobacco is altogether prohibited in the lower classes, and upper-classmen may not smoke on the street or in public places. In no subject of study have recent reforms been of such marked success as in the modern languages; they are taught, be- sides, with such scientific method that as great proficiency in Latin can be attained in six years if French is studied first as can otherwise be got in nine. As an indi- cation of the remarkable mastery of foreign tongues that can be secured by good teaching, Mr. Russell relates that he was one day asked to speak to a class of boys in English, and was somewhat afraid that they might not understand him: “Im- agine my surprise when, at the teacher's suggestion, six of these boys in turn re- produced in their own words and in almost faultless English the gist of all that I had said to them.” This was the result of two years of class instruction in English for four hours a week. Japan in Transition Harper & Brothers By Stafford Ransome We can hardly expect literature in the average book about this one reads more like a commercial report than the product of a scholar or polished writer Mr. Ransome is a somewhat narrow-minded Japan, and | civil engineer, whose knowledge of subjects beyond his professional ken rather limited. His style is colloquial, and seems to be his reiteration of pet phrases is rather wearisome. His utter lack of perspective in writing, as a correspondent, on commer cial matters aroused the just indignation of honorable merchants at the treaty ports Now, it is plainly evident that, in expatiat ing on “The Position and Christianity,” he is familiar neither with actual figures easily accessible and collect ed with care and diligence, nor with the native literature or periodical writing. His wild assertion about the “2,000 paid foreign missionaries” in Japan, and his apparently profound ignorance of what Americans in all lines of work have done in Japan, show him as untrustworthy in some parts of his report as his commonplace English is loose and threadbare. Mr. Ransome is on firmer ground when he talks of what he has touched and known. He sees old Japan passing away. New Japan is hardly as yet born, except in the spirit. He describes with briskness and vigor— hastily, also, as if the whole scene would change in a moment—‘“the transition Japan, which is passing through its most critical throes just now.” One must read this book as a correspondent’s news-letter, in which neither background nor perspective is visi- ble. The author, who lived but a few weeks over a year in Japan, has apparently got his ideas wholly from English periodical and other ephemeral literature. He speaks evidently to the club, and to an English public in whose eyes Russia must always be the Satan among the sons of God, his fel- low-imps being the missionaries, who are made responsible (p. 233) even for the troubles in Formosa. The best chapter in the book is that on the new school of the drama. As the Japanese “adopt nothing, but adapt every- thing,” they have borrowed many foreign texts and plots, giving them the proper Japanese background and color, and adapt- ing the words to the native prejudice and palate. The moral standard is discussed with fairness, the author arguing that, to un- derstand or appreciate an alien civiliza- tion, ‘“‘one must begin by making his mind a blank.”” He defends with spirit the com- mercial integrity of the Japanese, or rather explains why the Chinese is reckoned su- peridr, and he sees a steady Improvement among the business men in the island em- pire. In modern industry the weak point is that the educated man devotes himself too exclusively to theory and neglects the practical side. He still fears the ancient traditions, being afraid ‘‘to dirty his hands in acquiring the practice.” Mr. Ransome thinks the power of the Japanese to com- pete with the skilled producers of Europe has been greatly exaggerated. Treating of the effect of war on foreign relations, he says there is no deep-rooted hatred of the Chinaman, despite surface contempt for Chinese methods. There is a good sketch of “politics past and present,’’ and, in treat- ing of “strategic geography,’ the author Prospects of
Page 24
176 The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1783 furnishes a chapter which all military stu- dents will welcome. As a colonizing Pow- er Japan never wanted Hawaii, does not want the Philippines now, has more than enough to do in Formosa, and, with the rise of manufactures, with congestion of population in the cities and denudation of the country—compelling large imports of food—she is likely to need all her people at home for generations to come, and has, strictly speaking, no surplus population. As an ally, Japan is just the country, with just the people, which Great Britain needs. Both nations united can keep out of hos- tilities and compel a coal famine that will stop war. Present-day education is dis- cussed and set forth with intelligence, well selected and arrayed figures, and an excel- lent map. This work is presented in attractive type and binding on good paper. The clear and beautiful half-tone illustrations, over fifty in number, show finely the progress made in machinery, manufactures, the navy and army, modern architecture and engineer- ing, while the charm of female grace and beauty and the makers of New Japan, es- pecially in statesmanship, arms, and science, are not forgotten. The four maps are of high value and deserving of great praise. 'Ardis: Storia della Repubblica Ateniese dalle Origini alle Reforme di Clistene. By Gaetano De Sanctis. Rome: Tipografia Polyglotta della S. C. de Propaganda Fide. 1898. Pp. vii., 364. He who undertakes to write the constitu- tional history of Athens ought to sift care- fully the literature which has accumulated on the subject in recent years, especially since the discovery of Aristotle’s ‘Consti- tution of Athens.’ De Sanctis, however, though a scholar of established reputation, has not taken so serious a view of his duty as an historian. Limiting himself, for the most part, to a few good authorities, he has made free use of their material, often without giving them due credit. As a re- sult of this neglect, the reader is in many instances at a loss to determine whether a given view has originated with the author. Though the work contains some new features and gives evidence of consider- able diligence in research, the soundest pas- sages in it are those which aim at digest- ing the opinions of others. Such is the greater part of chapters i.-iil., which treat of the formation of the Athenian state and of the regal period. Chapter iv., on the decline of the monarchy and the archon- ship, is unsatisfactory. From the mere fact that the word “‘archon” is simpler than the word ‘“‘polemarch,”’ the author con- cludes, against the testimony of Aristo- tle, that the archonship was instituted be- fore the polemarchy. Yet, were we to fol- low the analogy furnished by the two Athe- nian councils, we should reach the oppo- site result, for it is the earlier council which bears the more complex title, Equal- ly slender is the evidence for De Sanctis’s opinion that the thesmothetw# were insti- tuted at the same time with the archonship, or at all events before the polemarchy. It seems better to connect the origin of this office with the rise of the timocracy, which beiongs apparently to the geventh cen- tury B.c. But De Sanctis has no room in his work for the growth of timocracy, though he is aware that Solon did not create that form of government. It seems strange that he should have ignored Busolt’s masterly treatment of this subject. Again, disre- garding a statement of Aristotle that in early Athens the magistrates were appoint- ed by the Council of the Areopagus, he de- clares that from the beginning they were elected by the people, and cites Spartan usage as proof. His failure to grasp the truth of this matter, as Aristotle repre- sents it, leads him to misconceive the whole development of the Athenian constitution before Solon. Athens and Sparta did not advance along parallel lines. The first three sections of Aristotle’s ‘Con- stitution of Athens’ De Sanctis (chapter v.) considers of no historical value—a tissue of “combinations.” But Aristotle’s combina- tions are worthy of consideration; it is not unlikely, too, that he had some slight documentary evidence for the time before Solon. Our author goes with the majority in pronouncing section iv. of the ‘Consti- tution of Athens’ a political forgery of some fifth-century oligarch—a crude mixture of the old and the new—which the simple- minded Aristotle accepted as a constitution of Draco and inserted without hesitation in his history, though it was absolute- ly incongruous with the rest of the work. Blass, who differs from the majori- ty, the author silences with an exclama- tion, and proceeds to support his own view by misinterpretations and by violent emen- dations of the text. There is need of great- er fairness in the treatment of this unfor- tunate section. The title of the seventh chapter, ‘‘The First Written Constitution’—that of Solon (594 B. c.)—strikes the reader as very strange. There is a vast difference between a written constitution, as that of the United States, and an unwritten con- stitution amended by written laws, as that of Athens. The former presupposes an advanced stage of political thought reached in Athens in the latter half of the fifth century B. c. It was not till 411 B. c. that Athens came under a written consti- tution, and then for only a few months. When the author, p. 193, says that the peo- ple, not content with the code of Draco (621 B. c.), demanded a constitution, he as- cribes to them a theoretical knowledge of government which even the Greek philoso- phers did not begin to acquire till nearly two centuries later. Among the surprises afforded by the book is a new date for the conspiracy of Cylon. Till within recent years, all agreed in pla- cing this event between Draco and Solon (621-594 B. c.); Busolt and Wright made it earlier than Draco, and their view has the support of Aristotle’s ‘Constitution of Athens.’ Now De Sanctis (chapter vilii.), following a suggestion of Beloch, declares that it occurred while Pisistratus was in exile (after 560 B. c.). His theory, though interesting, is far-fetched. Connected with this date of Cylon is his opinion (chapter ix.) that Pisistratus instituted the naucra- ries. In this case, he argues that the term ‘“naucrary” had reference to ship-building, and that Athens had no fleet before Pisis- tratus. But the derivation of the word is uncertain, and the laws of Solon referring to this institution prove its existence in bis time. It is hardly possible, as De Sanctis assumes, that the Atthid-writers should have been deceived as to the authorship of these laws. On purely subjective grounds, De Sanctis (chapter x.) places the constitutional re- forms of Cleisthenes before his struggle with Isagoras, and makes these improve- ments the cause rather than the effect of the strife, thus setting aside the testimony of Herodotus and of Aristotle. That Cleis- thenes, the founder of the democracy, should have ever been the head of the aristocratic party is to him an absurd idea. The test of absurdity, however, is unsafe. To one acquainted with practical politics, a summersault such as that which Herodotus ascribes to Cleisthenes seems too com- monplace to raise a suspicion. In conclusion, it may be said that the tendency of De Sanctis is to cut loose from authority and from the recognized canons of historical criticism, and to give free rein to the fancy. It is to be noted further that his originality lies especially in chang- ing the dates of events. Zealously pattern- ing after Beloch, yet lacking the judgment of his master, he falls far short of the standard set by Busolt, who, in the second edition of his ‘Griechische Geschichte,’ has contributed greatly to our knowledge of. early Attic history. Siberia and Oentral Asia. By John W. Bookwalter. Springfield, Ohio. There is so much that is unfair in many popular ideas about Russia, there are so many people ready to believe anything un- favorable to that country, that something dithyrambic on the subject may be useful every now and then as a corrective. Last year, Mr. J. W. Bookwalter travelled rapidly (making all due allowance for the slow- ness of Russian trains) through the re- gions he describes; and the result is a heavy volume containing, besides a large number of not very interesting photographs, an array of descriptions, statistics, and conclusions delivered with a breezy cock- sureness that makes the reader feel no time has been wasted. If the chops and steaks at the railway restaurants were juicy, it showed that the region had a splendid future as pasture-land; again and again a few well-handled figures prove great things; and what use would there be in having a guide through whom people could be interviewed, if what they said, especially when officials, were not accept- ed? Thus the process of acquiring infor- mation was speedy—sweeping in great facts as well as small of history, sociology, and anything else. x! For instance, speaking of the harmless Khirgiz, the writer says: “I am informed that they are yet the same untamed nomads that, under Mundzuk and his successors, as a mongrel Tartar and Mongol horde, swept with such destructive fury nearly 1,600 years ago through the length and breadth of Eu- rope, holding even Rome in terror for se- veral centuries.”” Why bother to look up in some stupid book the accuracy of such striking information? Or, for a more domes- tic detail: “I am also informed that in large cities, like St. Petersburg, where the water is not of the very purest, it is the duty of every householder, during the sum- mer, to place a suitable vessel in front of his house, containing boiled water, for the free use of the passer-by.” Mr. Bookwalter appears to have been at least in Moscow, in July, but he does not mention how many such exaggerated cholera regulations he
Page 25
Aug. 31, 1899] has himself seen signs of. To counteract common accusations that Russia is a bar- barous state, ruled by corrupt and ignorant officials, it is pleasing to hear that “Within certain limits this is perhaps the most secure and the freest country in the Wettd: ...« There is perhaps no nation whose official classes are so well informed, The Nation. if there has been occasion for it this year. The “good road from Kutais to Vladi- kavkaz,”’ distance, path, is in one portion only a bridle- impassable for carriages. The way | from Abbas Tuman to Kutais is fine enough, or who so minutely understand the commer- | cial, industrial, and even the political poli- cies of other nations, and the real working and trend of their institutions. It was, no doubt, this penetratingforesight [the author does not seem to be “informed” in this case] that caused her, long ago, to devise her policy of territorial acquisition, under which she laid aside for future use such vast accessible and contiguous areas of country which to the rest of the world seemed use- less.” Even the passport system in “the freest country in the world’’ finds favor: “Tt is, moreover, an instrument that greatly aids in more thoroughly utilizing all its [the Government’s] sources of energy, and in knitting more effectively together the potencies of national life into a com- pact, mobile whole, leaving no loose ends floating about.’”’ A good deal might be said in regard to this statement about a land that has suf- fered for centuries from the plague of vagrancy, but we do not care to go into the question of Mr. Bookwalter’s beliefs, of his faith that every suggested railway will be built at once (which is very different from the usual experience in the empire of the Czar), of his political reflections, reminding one so often of those of the ordinary Rus- sian traveller one meets. His whole atti- tude is that ‘‘tout est pour le mieux dans la meilleure des Russies possible.’’ It is, however, perhaps worth while to call at- tention to some of the errors of detail in his facts. The standing army of Russia is very large, but it is not ‘1,500,000 to 2,000,000 of men,” nor could she ‘quickly put her- self on a war footing of four or five mil- lions of men, well appointed and equipped.” The assertion that the railway from Kushk is “being quietly extended to Herat,” i. e., in Afghan territory, seems so absurd on the face of it that we ask for more proof than the remark in another place that | “it is hinted.”” The road from Petrovsk to Derbent can hardly be “almost completed,” as last July people were still talking of be- ginning it in a year’s time. Although the Russians have large families, they are not by any means “probably the most prolific race on the face of the globe.”’ ‘The fa- mous” Shamyl (not Schemyl) was not “a Georgian chieftain,’ but a Lesghian, and he “made his last stand in defence of his coun- try’ at Ghunib, far away in Daghestan, not near Tiflis. It is incorrect to say of climb- ing Ararat that “those who visit the sum- mit are provided by the Government, for their protection, with ten or a dozen Cos- sacks from the barracks located at the foot of the mountain, where there are always quartered several regiments of these cele- brated soldiers.’”” Last summer, when a foreigner came to try the ascent, there were only some score of men in these bar- racks (even in winter there are but a few hundred), and at that time no officer or sol- dier In the vicinity had ever attempted to get to the top of the mountain. A party of ten infantrymen and three Cossacks served him as a volunteer escort, at the invitation of the officer commanding a summer camp part way up the mountain, and some such courtesy may have become the custom since, but not “‘one of the wildest and most soli- tary passes in the world,” cautions against brigands always be elabo- rate. So we might go on. book there is a general looseness of state- 177 one expedition that could be considered of |; any moment was that to New Providence to though existing for most of the | | cess was attained, | powder had been shipped away by the seize powder and stores. Only partial suc- for the greater part of the Eng- lish Governor, and Hopkins returned to New | London after engaging a British vessel under nor need the pre- | | ness that followed gave rise In fact, throughout the | conditions that would seem to insure his suc- cess. Yet he failed, and the nths of idle- to an opinion that Hopkins was not the man for the place, mo | and did prove that he lacked organizing abi- ment which makes one hesitate to accept | without further confirmation anything it says. The author would have done wisely to subject citement and fatigue of a long journey” to careful correction at greater leisure. Esek Hopkins, Commander-in-Chief of the Continental Navy, 1775-1778. By Edward Field. Providence. 1898. Portraits. “a work thrown off during the ex- | lity. It may be admitted that many condi | tions favoring success were wanting The Marine Committee of Congress interfered, ordered him on impossible ventures, and, when disappointed, laid the blame on the Mr. Field seeks to defend Hopkins against | certain charges of misconduct while com- | mander of the Continental Navy in the first years of the Revolution. This is not an easy task, for many circumstances contributed to bring to pass the discharge of Hopkins under serious charges. There were personal as well as political reasons for the act, and it is much to Mr. Field's credit that he does not suppress what may tell against Hopkins as a man or as a naval officer. A sea-captain of long standing, in the employ of the Browns of Providence, Hopkins cer- tainly knew how to handle a ship. He had the usual faults of a seaman, and they be- came glaring when he undertook to become a politician. Hasty and intemperate of speech he did not hesitate to break out against those with whom he had served and to whom he had for years given support. He carried his habits into the “navy,” a few small vessels hastily brought together and controlled through the Congress. The local agents of this body were charged by Hopkins with being interested in privateers, of car- ing more for their personal interests than for those of the continent, and of encourag- ing malpractices that their gains might be the greater. He was known to have spoken disrespectfully of the Marine Committee of Congress, though he doubtless uttered only the truth, for the committee gave extraordi- nary orders at extraordinary times, and laid the responsibility of failure on the fleet. He used language more forcible than was neces- sary, thereby shocking the chaplain of the fleet, who did not hesitate to mention the affair to Congress, urging the demands of his own conscience, while overlooking the dangerous example of insubordination among men much discontented and ready to con- spire against their commander. On the other hand, Hopkins enjoyed the warm friendship of John Adams, John Paul Jones, and others not more likely to take up with a sham; and even Knox, himself something of a rough diamond, wrote of him, “Though antiquated in figure, he is shrewd and sensible. I, whom you think not a little enthusiastic, should have taken him for an angel only he swore now and then.”’ The test came in actual service, and here there was much to create doubt of his real abilities. It is hardly possible that Congress really intended to give Hopkins the same re- lative command at sea as Washington held on land, but high rank was given, and the fleet was constituted with some flourish. The | prejudice of an opposite nature Commodore. Money was wanting, and could not be obtained as needed. It was difficult to enlist men, for the higher pay and greater chances of privateering drew into that calling those who might have made a navy. There were jealousies among the officers of the fleet, and discipline was not maintained. Without money, men, or officers, Hopkins blurted out his opinion of men and things, and this was reported to his superiors. Con- gress ordered him to appear before it and ex- plain his conduct, but did not accept his explanation as satisfactory. Later, on the complaints of his own officers, he was sus- pended and dismissed from the Continental service. The charges made were vague, and covered many insinuations that no court would admit to be evidence; yet it cannot be said that Congress was too severe in its judgment. Hopkins, with characteristic tem- per, court-martialled those who had complain- ed of him, and then sued them for libel in the civil courts—a poor remedy for an in- jured reputation, and in this case bringing none. It is difficult to accept the opinion of Mr. Field that Hopkins was sacrificed to the spite of men whose influence was very power- ful, and whose enmity he had incurred by denouncing their guilty practices. Nor could the prejudice against New England so freely expressed in Congress account for the result. Schuyler was kept down by a prejudice of New England against him, and at this time that prejudice was in the ascendant, con- trolling Congress in its decisions on the Northern army. How, then, could a general accomplish all that Mr. Field attributes to it? There was enough in Hopkins’s own acts and character to account fully for what was done, and it Is nothing against him to admit it. His habits were those of sea-captains of the time, and the picture of the interior of a public house in Surinam, reproduced in this volume, tells the whole story. Mr. Field has made an interesting ume, but it could be wished he had printed more of Hopkins’s letters. vol- BOOKS OF THE WEEK. The Archbishop's Un juarge d Mo- Boston: * "age Adams, Oscar F. mont. and Other Stories. Ce Barron, Biwye. Manders. A Tale of Paris. Bos- ton: L. C. Page & Co. Bida, Ale aa Aucassin and Nicolette. Fords, i & Hulbert. anor p Dr. Nikola’s Experiment. Apple- 1. onan Matthew P. Thirty Years of New York Politics. New York: The Author. a Bridgman, R. L. The Master Idea. Boston: Pil- m Press. Beyer Licyd. Lady Blanche’s Salon. F. T. Neely. nudge, B. A. W. Oriental wit ont Wisdom ; The “Laughable St Stories."" From Syriac. Le: 4 Luzac Butler, W = ie Notbt to ewe, and Other Poems. New ed. Ha ae Cadet, Félix. oval Education. Syracuse, N. Y.:
Page 26
178 The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1783 Clark, 8S. H., and Blanchard, F. M. Practical Public Speaking. Scribners. $1. Clement, Clara E. Saints in Art. Boston: L. C. Page & Co. " Ons, Pad B. B. Life Indeed. F. A. Revell Oo. Colmore, G. ‘The Strange Story of Hester Wynne. Appletons. $1. Connell, G, 8. The Old Patroon, and Other Plays. w. H. Young & Co. 40c. Connor, Ralph, Black Rock, A Tale of the Sel- kirks, F. H. Revell Co. $1.25 Crawford, Virginia M. Stories in Foreign Litera- ture. Boston: L. C. Page & Co. $1.75. Curtis, G. W. Prue and I. Harpers. Cyr, Ellen M. Fifth Reader. Boston: Ginn & Co, 80c. Dake, C. R- A Strange Discovery. New York: H. I. Kimball. $1.25. Dawe, Carlton. The Voyage of the “Pulo Way.”’ 1 " R. F, Fenno Co. .25. Dewar, G. A. B. Yild Life in Hampshire High- lands. London: Dent; New York: Macmillan. Dixon, Mary A. The Love Affairs of Margaret Dale. F. T. Neely. Foa, Edouard. After Big Game in Central Africa. C, Black; New York: Macmillan. and Thomas, C. W. A Practical Course in _ Drawing. D. Van Nos- trand Co. -25. Harraman, Curtis G. American Investments Clas- e Author sified. New York: Th \ Herford, Prof. he Works of Shakspere, ; ee 2 Everday. Edition.] Vols. VI. and VII. Macmillan, c 1.50. Herrick, Prof. R., and Damon, L. T. Composition and Rhetoric for Schools. Chicago: Scott, Fores- man & Co. $1. Hillyer, Prof. H. W. Laboratory Manual. Mac- millan. 90c. Hooker, Le Roy. Baldoon. Rand, McNally & Co. Howard, J. R. Patriotic Nuggets. Fords, Howard & Hulbert. Howard, J. R. Educational Nuggets. Fords, How- ard & Hulbert. Hyslop, ant d. H. Scrib- London; A. & Logic and Argument. Knackfuss, H. Rembrandt. [Monographs on Art- ists.] Leipzig: Velhagen & Klasing; New York: Lemcke & Buechner. Knackfuss, A. Van Dyck, [Monographs on orteets. } Leipzig: Velhagen & Klasing; New ork: Lemcke & Buechner. Lentz, Max. Heyse’s L’Arrabiata. American Book Major, G. M. Lays of Chinatown, and Other Verses. New York: H. I, Kimball. $1.25. Pickett, Mrs. Lasalle ©. Pickett and his Men, Atlanta, Ga.: Foote & Davies Co. , Capt. G. W. The Hygiene of the Soldier in the Tropics. Kansas City: Hudson-Kimberly Co. Stephens, R. N. A Gentleman Player. Boston: L. C. Page & Co. $1. Stout, G. F . F. A Manual of Percholosy. London: W. B. Clive; New York: Hinds & Noble. The Mirror of Boston: L. C. Page & . THe. Taso, E. 8. Lobo, Rag and Vixen. Scribners. ic. Warner, G. T. Landmarks in English Industrial London: Blackie & Son; New York Macmillan, $1.60. Perfection. Henry Holt & Co. Atkinson’s Elementary Botany Gro, F, ATKINSON of Cornell. Profusely xxili+444 pp. 12mo, $1.25 net. Nature (London): * This is one of the best little books of its kind it has been our lot to look through fora long time. Pleasantly written, admirably printed and illus- trated, it forms an excellent introduction to the study of the science of botany, and Professor Atkinson Is to be congratulated on the way in which he has fulfilled the task he has set himself.” ad Prof. {llustrated. Barnes’s Plant Life By Prof. Cuas. R. BARNEs of the University of Chi- cago. With about 400 illustrations. 428 pp. 12mo, $1.12 net. Prof. V. M. Spalding of the University of Michigan: “T am Impressed with its comprehensiveness, trust- worthiness, clearness, and simplicity of statement, com- bined with sclentific eogresey and a common-sense adaptation to the needs of students for whom it was prepared. Such a book has been greatly needed, and it 1as at last been written in such a way as to leave no- thing to be desired except teachers who know how to use it, It can hardly fail to materially promote the de- velopment of the right kind of biological work in the secondary schools. The author seems to me to have at- tained his own ideal, and greater praise it would be hardly possible to give.” Holden’s Elementary Astronomy By Epwarp 8. Ho_pgen, sometime Director of Lick Observatory. (American Science Series.) About 400 pp. 12mo (October). This book aims o> peoneee the most significant results of ages of astronomical observation, so as to give wide general views and at the same time a luminous idea of the most important of the special methods of the science. Being designed for beginners, the topics are treated at length with great clearness, Kingsley’s Vertebrate Zodélogy By Prof. J. 8. Kinasiey of Tufts College. 417 pp. SvVo. A new book by the author of “ The Elements of Com- peretive Zoology ” It is very fully illustrated, and can ye used a8 a companion to McMurrich’s “ Invertebrate Morphology.” Martin’s The Human Body Entirely New Edition of the Briefer Course Revised, with Practical Exercises by Pror. Gro, W. Fivz, of Harvard, xiv+408 pp. 12mo, $1.20 net, Prof. Henry B. Ward, of the University of Nebraska: * Martin's has always been a most admirable book from a acientific point of view, and the addition of the ap- pendices, particularly that on demonstrations and ex- periments, will do away with the single objection urged againet the book hitherto.” 29 WEST 23D ST., NEW YORK, THE CAMBRIDGE LITERATURE SERIES Prices, Imperial Paper Covers, Single Numbers.... 12 cts. The usual diseount, Double Numbers.... 18 cts. >» All books sent inan Triple Numbers..... 24 cts. ) quantities, postpald, Peabody’s Laboratory Exercises in Anatomy and Physiology By James E. Peasopy, of the High School for Boys and Girls. New York. x+79 pp. 12mo. Interleaved. 60c. net. Forty-five simple and unobjectionable experiments. Prof. H. C. Bumpus of Brown: “ An exceedingly use- ful and thoroughly up-to-date manual.” Torrey’s Elementary Chemistry By JOSEPH ‘1ORREY, Jr.,of Harvard. 437 pp. 12mo, $1.25 net. A systematic course of instruction accompanied by carefully chosen laboratory work, mainly quantitative in character, suitable for well-equipped schools and ele- mentary college classes. Underwood’s Moulds, Mildews and Mushrooms A guide to the Systematic Study of Fungi and the Mycetozoa and their Literature. By Prof LuctEN M. UNDERWoop of Columbia. Illustrated with ten He- liotype plates, one colored. 236 pp. 12mo, $1.50 net. The chapters cover the Relations of Fungi to other Plants; Reproduction, Constituents, and Habits; Phy- comycetes, Ascomycetes, a Imperfecti, Basidio- mycetes, Fungus Allies; the Study of J ycology in gene- ral and in America; the Geographic Distribution of American Fungi; Methods of Collection and Preserva- tion—Hints for Further Study. There are indexes—I. to Latin Names, II, to Host Plants, III. to Authors and Collectors, LV. General In- dex and Explanation of Terms. Woodhull & Van Arsdale’s Chemical Experiments By Prof. Joun F. Woopavu.t and M. B. VAN ARSDALE, both of Teachers’ College, New York City, 136 pp. i2mo, 60 cents net. An elementary laboratory manual of the chemistry of every-day life, air, water, combustion, bleaching, alka- lies, soaps, etc. Evans’s Algebra for Schools By Gror@e W. Evans of the English High School, Boston, Mass. 433 pp. 12mo, $1.12 net. Aside from a number of novelties, the book is dis- tinguished by two notable features: I. Practical prob- lems form the point of departure at each new turn of the subject; II It contains nearly 3,500 examples, none of which are repeated from other books. Prof. Paul H. Hanus of Harvard: “The author has cer- tainly been successful in presenting the essentials of elementary Algebra in a thoroughly sensible way as to sequence of topics and method of treatment.” 378 WABASH AVE., CHICAGO. UNDER THE EDITORIAL SUPERVISION OF THOMAS HALL, Jr., Harvard University. Books required for admission to College Pricesin Levantine. Sin Numbers.... 25 cts. Se wee) Gleneut. Doubie Numbers.... 30 cts. Triple Numbers..... 40 cts. Books not delivered. CORRESPONDENCE SOLICITED. Publishers, Boston BENJ. H. SANBORN & CO., OOK S.—All Out-of-print Books te pe no matter on what subject. Acknowle the world over as the most expert bookfinders nt. Please state wants, BAKER'S GREAT BOO OP, 14-16 John Bright Street Birmingham, Eng . pence READING.—UNITARIAN LI- terature and printed ser; ing P. 0. Box 272, g ons sent free by address- oncord, Mase, « ‘SLANT. By Mavup WitpsR Goopwin, author of “ White Aprons,” “ Abounds tn bi t, almost epigrammatic sayings and sparkling flashes ° merriment.’ Detroit pg LITTLE, BROWN & CO., Publishers, Boston. Story of the Nations. New Numbers. Fully illustrated. Large 12mo, each $1.50; half leather, each $1.75. No. 53. The West Indies. A History of the Islands of the West Indian Archipelago, to- gether with an Account of their Physical Characteristics, Natural Resources, and Present Condition. By Amos KippDEr FIskg, au. Nos. 54and 55. The Story of the People of England in the 19th Century. By Justin McCartay, M.P. In two volumes. No. 56. The Story of Austria. The Home of the Hapsburg Dynasty, from 1282 to the Present Day. By SypNEY WHITMAN. No, 57. China. By R. K. Doue.as, G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS, 27 & 29 W. 23d St., New York. THE ONLY AUTHENTIC Life of Dewey In OUR THREE ADMIRALS: FARRAGUT, PORTER AND DEWEY By JAMES E. HOMANS, A.M. An accurate account of their ancestries, early lives, and blic services, and the story of their notable achievements and memorable victories which won for them the highest rank in the U. 8. avy. With portraits, illustrations, and maps. Cloth, postpaid, $1.00. JAMES T. WHITE & CO., PUBLISHERS, 5 & 7 East 16th St., New York. IN THE POE CIRCLE. By JOEL BENTON. Some Poe memorabilia, An account of the Poe-Chivers Controversy. Some portraits and facsimiles of MS. Poe and Baudelaire. 12mo, cloth, $1.25. EMERSON AS A POET. By JOEL BENTON. Mr. Benton has recently rewritten and re- vised a former series 0: s and added thereto an article, Emerson’s ter Poems. With a Bibliography and paper. a portrait on Japan t2mo, cloth, $1.25. M. F. MANSFIELD & A. WESSELS, 1135 Broadway, New York. HAKLUYT SOCIETY (President, Sir C.LEMENTs MarkuaM, K.C.B.),—The first two of the publi- cations for 1899, viz.: THE EMBASSY OF SIR THOMAS ROE TO INDIA, 161g—19 (2 vols.), edited | ak Foster, are now being dis- tributed to members by Mr. Quaritch. The annual subscription is one guinea. A new series commences with these volumes. Wii.uiaM Fosrer, Honorary Secretary. Borpean, Hotty Roap, Wanstgeap (England), OOKS, SECOND-HAND AND NE W, Standard and Rare. Books bought. Catalogue lo E. W, Jouneon, 2 E. &t., N. ¥.
Page 27
Aug. 31, 1899] The Nation. Vil JOHN WILEY & SONS. Scientific Publications. Descriptive General Chemistry. A Text-book for Short Course. By 8S. E. Till man, Professor of Chemistry, Mineralogy, and Geology, United States Military Academy. Second edition. First thousand. S8vo, cloth, $3.00. Statistical Methods with Special Reference to Biological Variation. Intended especially for those who are interested in the quantitative study of species and of or- ganic variation. By O. B. Davenport, Instructor in Zodlogy at Harvard University. 135 pages. 16mo, morocco, $1.25. Indicators and Test-papers. Their Source, Preparation, Application, and Tests for Sensitiveness. Designed for the use of Che- mists, Pharmacists, and Students. By Alfred I Cohn, Ph.D. 2mo, cloth, $2.00. October. The Microscopy of Drinking-water. By George C. Whipple, Biologist and Director of Mt. Prospect Laboratory Department of Water Supply, Brooklyn, New York; formerly Biologist of Boston Water-works. Illustrated by figures in Ho eee and 19 full-page half-tones. Svyo, cloth, Physical Chemistry for Beginners. By Dr. Ch. Van Deventer, with an introduction by Prof. J. H. Van't Hoff. Authorized American Fdition from the German Edition. By Bertram B. Boltwood, Ph.D., Instructor in the Sheffield seo. School of Yale University. 12mo, cloth, The Elements of Physical Chemistry. By J. Livingston R. Morgan, Ph.D., of the De partment of Physical Chemistry, Columbia Uni- versity. 12mo, cloth, $2.00. Examination of Water, Chemical and Bacteriological. By William P. Mason, Professor of Chemistry, oa Polytechnic Institute. 12mo, cloth, First Appendix to Dana’s New ‘‘System of Mineralogy.’’ By Edward Salisbury Dana, Professor of Physics and Curator of the Stineral Collection, Yale Uni- versity. Being an account of the progress of this science from the iasue of the sixth edition in 1882 to 1899. Large 8vo, cloth, $1.00. Sewerage. The Designing, Construction, and Maintenance of Sewerage Systems. By A. Prescott Folweil Member American Society of Civil Bngineers. Svo, cloth, $3.00. Sewer Design. By H. N. Ogden, C.E., Associate rican Society of Civil Engineers; Assistant Pro- fessor of Civil Engineering, Cornell University. xi + 234 pages. 12mo, cloth, $2.00. Member Ame- The Elements of Precise Surveying and Geodesy. By Professor Mansfield Merriman. 8vo, cloth, $2.50. 264 pages. Elements of Sanitary Engineering. By Mansfield Merriman, Professor of Civili Fngi- neering in Lehigh University. Svo, cloth, $2.00. 53 EAST TENTH STREET, NEW THREE NOTABLF NEW BOOKS. Heat and Heat-engines. A Study of the Principles which Undertie the Mechanical Engineering of a Power Plant Ry Frederick Remsen Hutton, EM.. Phil). Profes sor of Mechanical Engineering at Columbia Uni versity. 559 pages. Svo, cloth, 8 © Machine Design. Part Il. Strength and Proportion of Machine Parts. By Forest R. Jonea, Professor of Machine Design in the University of Wlaconsin ma pp. Te figures. Svo, cloth, $3.00. Handbook on Testing Materials. For the Constructor, Methods, Machines. and Auxillary Apparatus. By Adolf Martens. Profes sor. Authorized translation and additions by Gus Cc. Henning (M.E., Stevens, 76) 2 vols. Svo cloth, 700 pages and plates. $750. Octob Determination of Radicals in Carbon Compounds. By Dr. H. Meyer, Imperial and Royal University, Prague. Authorized Translation by J. Bishop Tingle, Ph.D., F.C.8., Instructor of Chemistry at the Lewis Institute, Chicag l2mo, cloth $1.00. October Kinematics of Machinery. By John H. Barr, Professor of Machine Design Sibley Oollege, Cornell University Over 2) figures, 250 pages. Svo, cloth. October Modern American School Buildings. Being a Treatise upon, and Designs for, the Con struction of School Buildings ty Warren Rich ard Briggs, F.A.LA With 89 full-page illustra tions, YORK CITY. Svo, cloth, $4.00 Second and Concluding Volume of President Sharpless’s Notable Work. A History of Quaker Government in Pennsylvania. By ISAAC SHARPLESS, LL.D., President of Haverford College. Vol. Il. THE QUAKERS IN THE REVOLUTION. The first part of this work, under the title of ‘A Quaker Experiment in Government,” was published in the Spring of 1898, and met a warm reception from press and public, and a ready sale. the peace principles of the Quakers and the warlike trend of events first reached a crisis. events of the Revolution, and examines its momentous results. enacted in these years, and an important aspect of which is ey in this volume. The work as a whole, while making full use where necessary 0 owes records, of which the archives of the various Friends’ meetings oceup istorian, and a careful survey of such sources of information throws a flood of light upon early anc It carried the narrative from the founding of the Commonwealth down to the year 17%, when the conflict het ween The present volume traces the same conflict through the stormy It is safe to say that no more pregnant or dramatic historical episode can be named than was the labors of earlier historians, is especially the fruit of an extensive examination of ort- the most important pace These constitute in the main a virgin fleld for the middle Pennsylvania history The volumes thus consti tute an important, original and highly interesting contribution to our historical literature, and will be found indispensable to every well furnished library An important and most interesting contribution to Colonial history.—The Out- look, N. ¥ The story is more fairly, succinctly and intelligently told than ever it has been before.— The Public Ledger, Phila. Two volumes, 12mo, with numerous portraits and other illustrations. Volume 1.—A Quaker Experiment in Government, $1.50, $2.g0. PAUPERIZING THE RICH. By ALFRED J. FERRIS. In the short time since it appeared this book has been universally recog- nized by press and critics as opening a new chapter in the discussion between the classes and the masses, and as destined to havea wide influence upon public opinion. PRESS NOTICES A very telling argument.—Springfield Republican. It is not probable that any sortal economic book since Kidd's “ Social Evolution” id worth, or will receive, the attention that * Pauperizing the Rich" deserves for its clear thinking and originality. New York World, A wholesome critique on some conventional ideas both of charity and of justice — Outlook (New York). Deserves the serious attention of economists A very readable, popularly written discussion. tive.—New York Commercial Advertiser. It is an ambitious and radical programme, but the author urges it with an in- It is interesting and at the same time genuity and lo stimulating.— c that are fascinating. burgh Times. A thoroughly fresh and interesting discussion of our social and economic diffi- culties. Chicago Tribune. A fresh and original contribution to political economy.—Syracuse Herald, Cloth, $1.25. 12mo, pp. 432 Hartford Courant. PRESS NOTICES OF VOLUME 1. aY. Volumes sold separately. increasingly sought. Interesting and sugges- offered to the public. ment. . . | Journal of Soctology. Really delightful and yet critically appreciative volume A valuable and permanent contribution to civil and religious history { the cause of better government and purer politics An onutually serviceable work scientific books upon every phase of the labor question A contribution to American history that has a curious timeliness — The Nation, The Independent, WN. ¥ ae Well ae to The American Friend, Phila Cloth, extra, $3.00; Half Morocco, gilt top, $5.00. Volume 11.--The Quakers in the Revolution, $1.50, $2.80. An Indispensable Work of Reference for Librarians, Teachers and Student of Economics, and the General Reader. A HANDBOOK OF LABOR LITERATURE. Compiled by HELEN MAROT. The need of such a work as this, and the place which it must fill been brought to the attention of the compiler in the course of her the founder and librarian of the Free Library of Economics and Political Science, Philadelphia. The constantly increasing volume and complexity of the literature on this subject have made it almost impossible even for spe cialists to keep abreast of its various growths, and have made it a trackless wilderness for the general reader. on for advice upon the subjects well know, it is a branch of inquiry increasingly attracting public attention, and on which intelligent advice is It is as a help to the giving of such advice, and a direct guide to the general reader, that this work has been compiled and is now have work, aa As librarians and others who are called which is PRESS NOTICES. A work which will take rank beside the best bibliographies on German and | French literature in the same field. | Engliish.—Annateof the American Academy of Political and Soctal Sctence, I fail to see how the book could be substantially tmproved except by enlarge: On the whole the work is admirabie.-C Nothing comparable with it has preceded it in 1. Hastixes in American An admirably classified list of the best The Outlook (N. Y.) samo, cloth, $1.00 net. For sale by all booksellers, or will be sent, postpaid, by the publishers, T. S. LEACH & COMPANY, 29 North Seventh Street, Philadelphia.
Page 28
viii The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1783 HE North American Review EDITEDBY GEORGE B.M. HARVEY —_——— SEPTEMBER, 1899. The Agnostic’s Side (Republished ) Robert G. Ingersoll Ingersoll’s Influence The Rev. Henry M. Field, D.D. EX ORIENTE LUX: A Rejoinder Archibald Little The Foreign Service of the United States Francis B. Loomis U. S. Minister to Venezuela Vindication of the Boers A Diplomat Legal Aspect of Trusts Joseph S. Auerbach Progressof Automobilism in France The Marquis de Chasseloup-Laubat American Universities, Edouard Rod The «*America’’ Cup Race The Hon. Charles Russell Aguinaldo’s Case Against the United States A Filipino No. 11 Warren St., New York. PUBLISHED MONTHLY. Single Number, 50c. Per danrscaisis $5. SUPPRESSED IN LONDON. Appreciations «+ Addresses By LORD ROSEBERY. Edited by CHar.es Geake. With Portrait and Exhaustive In- Crown &vo, $1.50. CONTENTS. APPRECIATIONS: Burke; Robert Burns; Wal- lace; Robert Louis Stevenson; Gladstone; London. ADDRESSES: Bookishness and Statesman- ship; The Duty of Public Servants; Our Civil Servants; The Quality of Judgment; The Work of Public Librarians; Parliamen- tary Oratory; The English-Speaking Bro- therhood; Scottish History; Eton; The Hap- py Town Councillor; Sport; Golf, dex, JOHN LANE, 251 5th Ave., N. Y. whe colts opiate ask for —_- LIBERAL Wonllcat you need a Book, DISCOUNTS. address MR. GRANT. Before buying books write for quotations. ment of catalogues and special slips of books at reduced prices sent fur 10 cent stamp. FP. BE. GRANT, Books. 23 W. 42p Sr.. - - - - NEW YORK. (Mention this advertisement and recetve a discount.) An assort- Five Thousand More. Prisoners of Hope By Mary Jounston. 12mo, $1.50. One of the most notable novels of many days, worthy vf unqualified admira- tion.—The Interior, Chicago. Prisoners of Hope An Extraordinary Story to come from the pen of a new writer.—New York Times. Prisoners of Hope Wonderfully dramatic and fascinat- ing.—Charleston News and Courier. Prisoners of Hope Is a very uncommon novel, strong, masterful, true in its historic setting and atmosphere—very well worth being read by every reader of The Nation. Sold by all Booksellers. Sent, postpaid, by HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO., Boston, I | East 17th Street, New ‘York. A Hand-Book of Wrestling. HUGA F. LEONARD, Cloth, profusely illustrated... ................eeeeee $2.00 PE BO Ba iii. cc ctca acessvceciisconstacned “T consider the book not only one of the best ever published on this subject, but I think you have added to the it of valuable books on legitimate sport.”—W. G,. ERSON, Medical Lirector, Yale Uni- versity. “The illustrations are very fine, and the method of presentation of the subject matter is extremely good.” —D. SARGENT, Medical Director, Har- vard Walvavoit. “Tn colleges it will meet a demand long felt, and will be evidence that the art is both ancient and honorable, and one which _—- to develop the human body to its finest form.”—-GKORGE . OLD Gymnasium, Princeton University. Canadian Folk-Life and Folk-Lore. WILLIAM PARKER GREENOUGH. Illustrated, Svo, cloth, $1.50. * Not a dull page in the whole book.”’—Quebec Daily Telegraph. “ Fach chapter isa compound of anecdote, of obser- vation, and of shrewd or amusing reflection. All is elastic, spontaneous, unreserved.’’— The Nation. J. F. TAYLOR & COMPANY, 5 and 7 East 16th St., New York. For Length and Quality of Service the Remington Standard Typewriter defies competition IE. Director of fa Ci enEL, Upholstery. Light weight Tapestries and Silk Drapery Fabrics. Lace Curtains. Figured Muslins, Madras, and Laces for Curtains. Best Scotch Holland and Linen for Window Shades. Proadovey K 19th ot. NEW YORK Beautifully Handwoven BY EXPERT SAXON WEAVERS. The Augusta-Victoria Empress Shoulder Shaw! made of softest wool and silk, 40 inches square with 6 inch fringe, warp silk and woof wool. Rich light green, delicate pink, recherche red, pure white or black. Sent POSTPAID and e miged Enna on receipt of $7.50—check, draft or money order—b The Susacuac Wenn Co., 12 Moravian Church St., Bethlehem, Pa. Old Books, Rare Books, Choice Books, Quaint Books, Typography, Topography. BOOKS ON ALL SUBJECTS. FIRST EDITIONS, ETC. ILLUSTRATED CATALOGUE, pronounced to be the most original and interes ng list issued, pages, 8vo, with 370 apt yr my of Plates, Portraits, and Title-pages, post sree, Co iw (which sum is deducted from the first purchase of 80s:). PICKERING & CHATTO, Antiquarian Booksellers, 66 Haymarket, St. James, London, S. W. To receive the current numbers in a convenient (temporary) form. Sub- stantially made, bound in cloth, with Tug Na- TION stamped on the side in gold. Holds about one volume. Papers easily and neatly adjusted. Sent, postpaid, on re- ceipt of 75 cents. We buy and sell bills of exchange to and mene Cable Transfers of money on Euro, Austrailia, and South Africa; also ma é collections and issue Commercial and vellers’ Credits, available in all parts of the world. BROWN BROTHERS & CO. NO. 59 WALLISTREET, NEW YORK LETTERS CREDIT. F. W. CHRISTERN (DYRSEN & PFEIFFER, Successors), 429 Sth Ave., between 38th and 89th Sts., New York. Importers of Foreign Books; inte for the leadin ng Paris Publishers; Teschaee'e: 8h ES yore sewer? reek and lags ee talo ~ad of stoc tnalied on demand, ie Encentred Leip zig a6 s00n as issued
Page 29
Aug. 31, 1899] —a ‘ ‘ The Nation. Longmans, Green, & Co.’s List Plane and Sch Contniten, By James Howarp Gore, Ph D., Professor of Ma- thematics, Columbian University, Author of “Elements of Geodesy,” ‘‘ History of Geodesy,” etc., etc. Crown 8vo, 220 pages, $1.00. New and Revised Edition with over 500 Exercises. In this book about one-half the matter usually included in text-books on geometry has been omit- ted. This exclusion leaves out all those propositions which are not of practical value, and such as are not of use in applied mathematics. The practical teacher may rest assured that in this treatise there are no breaks in the continuity of reasoning or lack of training in the demonstrative processes. The book prepares for college entrance examinations, and should appeal to all teachers who are in sym- pathy with the movement to shorten the college preparatory curriculum. An Introductory Course in Differen- tial Equations for Students in Classical and Engineering Col- leges. New and Revised Edition. By Dante, A. Mur- RAY, B.A., Ph.D., Formerly Scholar and Fellow of Johns Hopkins University; Instructor in Mathematics in Cornell University. 12mo. 250 pages. $1.90. Plane Trigonometry for Colleges and Secondary Schools, By DanreEL A. Murray, Ph.D., of the Department of Mathematics, Cornell University, Author of “A Course in Differential Equations,” ‘‘A Course in the Integral Calculus.’ (Jn the Press.) This book differs somewhat from other text-books on this branch of mathematics both in the arrange- ment and in the manner of presentation. An Introduction to the Differential and Integral Calculus and Dif- ferential Equations. By F. GuanvitLe Taytor, M.A., B.Sc., Mathe- matical Lecturer at University College, Notting- ham. Crown 8vo, 592 pages, $3.00. This book gives a fairly full treatment of the more elementary parts of the Differential and In- tegral Calculus, together with a shorter treatment of Ordinary Differential Equations. The aim has nm to present each subject in a clear and simple manner and invest them with general interest. Ex- amples of the practical 9 of the subjects have been freely introduced. Mechanics Applied to Engineering. By Joun GoopMAN,Wh.Sch. A.M.1.C.E. M.I.M.E., Professor of Engineering in the Yorkshire Col- lege, Leeds (Victoria University). With 620 Illustrations and numerous Examples. Crown 8vo, 612 pages. Price, $2.00. A Course of Practical Chemistry. By M. M. Partison Murr, M.A. (Three Parts.) Part II. Intermediate. A Course of Volumetric Analysis—Preparations and Reactions of Certain Compounds—Qualitative Analysis of moderately Complex Mixtures—Examination of an Organic Compound for the Elements of which it is com- ea vere Reactions of some Typical rganic Compounds—Detection of certain Or- ganic Acids, Alkaloids, and Cyanides—Determi- nations of some Equivalent Weights and some Molecular Weights — Gravimetric Analyses. Crown 8vo, 244 pages, $1.50. *,* This volume is the second of a systematic course of procteens Chemistry which will consist of three Parts. Part I. ‘‘Elementary,’’ is also ready. Elementary Chemistry. A Manualfor Beginners. By G.S. Newrn, F.1.C., F.C.S. With 108 Illustrations and 254 Experi- ments. Crown 8vo, 302 pages, $0.90. “I believe the book is the best of its kind on the market. The illustrations are attractive, the di- rections for experiments are concise, and the text is intelligently selected and arranged.’’— Dr. Lyman C. NEWELL, State Normai School, Lowell, Mass., and President of the New England Association of Chemistry Teachers. A Text Book of Inorganic Chemis- try. By G. 8S. Newra, F.I.C., F.C.8., Demonstrator in the Royal College of Science, London, etc. With 146 Illustrations. New Edition. Crown 8vo. 682 pages. A SO-pege circular, containing Gonoriptions of text-hooks and works of reference in Chemistry will be sent to any address upon application to the publishers. Address the Publishers, LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., 91-93 Fifth Ave., New York City. D. Van Nostrand Company’s Recent and Forthcoming Publications. A Practical Course in Mechanical Drawing. By Prof. Wm. Fox and Cuanirs W. THomas (College City of New York). 12mo, Cloth, Hlustrated. Price $1.55 Chimney Design and Theory. A Book for Engineers and Architects, contain ing all data relative to Chimney Designing, by Wa. Watiace Curistig. vo, Cloth, Hlustrated Price $3.00 Their Materials and In Press Conductors for Electrical Distribution. Prof. F. A. C. Perrine of Leland Stanford University Manufacture. By Electrical Engineers’ Pocket Book. By Horatio A. Foster. With the collabora tion of eminent specialists. One thousand pages and numerous illustratioas. /n press Engines and Engine Running. A Practical Treatise on the Management of Steam Engines and Boilers for the use of those who desire to pass an examination to take charge of an Engine or Boiler, with many full-page diagrams and illustrations. By Josuva Ross, MF 12mo Cloth, Illustrated. Price $2 50 Manual of the Slide Rule. By F. A. Hatsry of the American Machinist. (No 114, Van Nostrand’s Science Series.) We. Marine Boilers. Tubulous Boilers. Price $7.50. Their Construction and Working. By L. E. Dealing more especially with Bertin, Chief Constructor of French Navy. Svo, Cloth, Illustrated Minerals in Rock Sections. The Practical Rock Sections with the Microscope. Methods of Identifying Minerals in Especially arranged for students in technical and scientific schools. By Lea McIuvane Lugver, Department of Mineralogy, Columbia University.8vo, Cloth, Illustrated. Price $1.50 net. Navigation and Nautical Astronomy. By Prof. J. H. C. Corvin (U.S. Naval Academy). Revised by Commander CHARLES BELKNAP (U. S. Navy I2mo, Cloth, Iustrated Price $3.50. Patents, and How to Make Money Out of Them. By W. 8B. Hurcninson, mem- ber of the New York Bar. 12mo, Cloth. Price $1.25. Petroleum [lotor Cars. By Louis Lockerr. 12mo, Cloth, [llustrated. Price 81.50. Potable Water, and Methods of Detecting Impurities. Ph. B., C .E. (Van No3trand Science: Series No. 61) Price 50 cents. Portland Cement. Cloth, Illustrated. By M. N. Baker, Its manufacture and CuHartes D. Jameson. S8vo, use. By Price, $1.50. Power Transmitted by Electricity and Applied by the Electric Motor, including Electric Railway Construction. By Partie Arkinson, A.M., Ph.D. Second edition, fully and new matter added. 12mo. Cloth, Illustrated. Price $2.00. revised Purification of Sewage. Being a brief account of the scientific principles of Sewage Purification and their practical application. By Sipngey Barwise. 12mo, Cloth. Price, $2.0 Report on the Investigations into the Purification of the Ohio River Water at Semen’ Kentucky. By Georce W. Futier. 4to, Cloth, 480 pages, § full-page plates. Price 10.00 net. Slide Valve Gears. Cut-off Slide Valves. Cloth. Price $1.50. A Practical Manual of By GreorGe H. Hurst, F.C.S. An explanation of the Action and Construction of Plain and By F. A. Havsey of the American Machinist. Seventh edition revised. 12mo, Soaps. soaps. Toilet, and other Price $5.00 the manufacture of Domestic, 8vo, Cloth, 385 pages, 65 illustrations. Small Engines and Boilers. A Manual of concise and specific directions for the construction of small steam engines and boilers of modern types from five horse-power down vw model sizes. By Eosert P. Watson. 12mo0, Cloth, Illustrated. Price $1.25. Standard Polyphase Apparatus and Systems. Electric Company. In Press. Text-Book of Seamanship. or Steam. By M. A. Ovpin of the Genera! The Equipping and Handling of Vessels under Sail For the use of the U.S. Naval Academy. By Rear Admiral 8. B. Luce, U.S.N. Re vised by Lieutenant Benson, U.S. N. With illustrations drawn by Lieutenant 8S. Seasvray, U.S. N 8vo, half leather. 579 pages and 124 plates Price, $10.00 The Character of Crystals. An Introduction to Physical Crystallography. By Prof. ALFrep J. Moses (Columbia University, N. Y.) 8vo, Cloth, Illustrated. Price, nef, $2.00 The Compendious Manual of Qualitative Chemical Analysis of C. W. Exior and F. H. Storer, as revised by W. R. Nicno.s: newly revised by W. B. Lixpsay and F. H. Sromen. Nine- teenth edition, fully illustrated. 12mo, Cloth. Price $1.50 The Electrical Transmission of Energy. A Manual for the Design of Electrical Circuits. By Arruur V. Asporr of the Chicago Telephone Co. Illustrations and % folding plates. Second edition, revised and enlarged. 8vo, Cloth. Price $4.50. Treatise on Photographic Optics. By R. S. Core, M.A. 12mo, Cloth, $2.50. 330 pages. Treatise on Roofs and Bridges. With numerous exercises. By Epwarp A. Bow- ser of Rutgers College. 12mo, Cloth, Illustrated. Price $2.25 net. 23 Murray and 27 Warren Streets, New York.
Page 30
lhe Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1783 NEW BOOKS AND NEW EDITIONS. The Literary Study of the Bible. — The State: A study of the leading forms of literature represented in the | Elements of Historical and Practical Politics. By Wooprow Bible. Revised and Enlarged Edition. By Ricnarp G. Witson, Ph.D., LL.D., Professor of Jurisprudence and Mouton, Ph.D., of the University of Chicago. Cloth, Politics in Princeton University. A new edition, largely 590 pages, $2.00. one and printed from new plates. Cloth. 692 pages. The Essentials of Argumentation. Principles of International Law. A practical manual, with illustrative selections. By Extas J. ; pees : MacEwan, M.A. Cloth. 428 pages. $1.12 A timely and authoritative book, embodying the latest results of discussion and research. By THomas J. LAWRENCE, LL.D., Lecturer on Maritime Law in the Royal Naval English Etymology. Academy, Greenwich. Buckram, 8vo, 666 pages, $3.00. By Dr. Frrepricu Kuiuce of Freiburg, author of ‘‘Etymolo- x gisches Worterbuch der deutschen Sprache,’’ and FREDE- History of English Critical Terms. ricK Lutz, A.M., Professor in Albion College. Clotb, 249 pages, 60 santa: By J. W. Bray, A.M. Cloth, 352 pages, $1.00. Experimental Psychology. The Principles of Composition. Sensation and Perception. A revised edition, with three new A handbook for classwork, by Henry G. Pearson, A. B., Pro- chapters) By Epmunp C. Sanrorp, Ph.D., Assistant fessor in the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, with Professor of Psychology in Clark University. Cloth. an introduetion by Arto Bares. Cloth, 165 pages, 50 cents. Illustrated. 457 pages. $1.50. Organic Education. Physiology, Vol. 35 in Heath’s Pedagogical Library. By Harrier M. | Experimental and Descriptive. By Burt P. Cotton, A.M., Scorr, Principal Normal Training School, Detroit. author of ‘‘Practical Zodlogy.’’ Cloth. 103 illustrations, Cloth. 342 pages. $1.25. many in colors. 443 pages. $1.12. “In conceding to this work the rare quality implied in the relative position The A r den Sh akespea re. ped ee ete atlaker fas te — we pay a high compliment to The following plays are now ready: Hamlet, Macbeth, Julius Cwsar, The Tempest, Coriolanus, As You Like It, Twelfth The : Theory of Equations. Night, Cymbeline, A Midsummer Night's Dream, The | A treatise for college classes. By Samuget Marx Barron, Merchant of Venice, Richard II., Richard III., Henry V., Ph. D., University of the South, Sewanee, Tenn. Cloth. Henry VIII. Cloth, 35 cents each. 210 pages. $1.50. The above are for sale by booksellers, or will be mailed, postpaid, by the publishers, on receipt of price. D. C. HEATH & CO., Publishers, Boston, New York, Chicago. Clarendon Press LNVew Publications. FUST PUBLISHED. VOLUME II. HISTORY OF THE NEW WORLD CALLED AMERICA. By Epwarp Jon Payne, Fellow of University College, Oxford. Crown 8vo, Cloth, Vol. I., $3.00, Vol. IL., $3.50. “It is beyond question a remarkable book. . . . No one who pretends to acquaintance with American Aboriginal conditions, can afford to neglect Mr. Payne’s work, . . . It is a storehouse of information drawn from out-of-the-way sources, quite beyond the reach of any except the most favored students.”—Journal of Education. STUDIES IN DANTE—Second Series. Miscellaneous Essays. By Epwarp Moors, D.D. 8vo, Cloth, $3.10. “ The relation of the present collection of Studies to that which was published three years ago is that of another Series rather than that of a Second Volume. I have endeavored to make them as far as possible independent of one another, since some of the various subjects here treated of may b\ is hoped) have an interest for many who would not care to purchase a volume entirely devoted to a subject so special and technical as ‘the use by Dante of Scriptural and Classical authors.’”—From the Preface. AN INTRODUCTION TO THE FIFTH BOOK OF HOOKER’S TREATISE OF THE LAWS OF ECCLESIASTICAL POLITY. By the Very Rev. Franois Pager, D.D., Dean of Christ Church. Medium 8vo, Cloth, $1.90. For the convenience of purchasers, Vol. IL. of the Three-Volume Edition of Hooker’s Works (Ecclesiastical Polity, Book V.) edited by Drs. Keble, Church, and Paget, is sold separately, price $3.00. MODERN LAND LAW. By Epwarp Jenks, M.A. 8vo, Cloth, $3.75. This book, which is uniform with and on the same lines as Sir William Anson’s well-known work on the Law of Contract, is the result of Mr. Jenks’ many years’ expe- riones as a teacher of ra property Law ; and presents in clear and compact form a comprehensive outline of the subject, which can afterwards be filled in by the study of arger and more technica reatises. SPECIAL ANNOUNCEMENT ! THE OXFORD ENGLISH DICTIONARY. (27° Reissue in Monthly Numbers of 88 pp. Price 90 Cents. A New Ewnezitsy DicrionARY ON HIsTORICAL PRINCIPLES; Founded Mainly on Materials Collected by the Philological Soctety. Edited by Dr. J. A. F.. MURRAY, with the assistance of Many Scholars and Men of Letters. To suit the caftveplence of those who may desire to commence subscrpt:on in instalments for the DICTIONARY, a oe New Issue, beginning with the letter A, was begun on July | last. Already Published: Vols. land II, py Dr. Murray; Vol. III, by Dr. MurRRay and Mr. Brap.igy. In course of publication: Vol. IV, by Mr. Brapugy; Vol. V, by Dr. Mornray. ~*~ The Oxford Dictionaty when completed, will consist of from 12,000 to 18,000 contained in Ten Volumes, Of these Volumes, Three have been issued, and the Fourth and Fifth (of which many Parts and Sections have ap) red) will be completed in 1900, Half of the entire work will thus be finished with ths cantury; ths secon I half (Vols. VI-X) will bs produced more rapidly than the first, so as to reach the end of the alphabet in 1909, It will be pub- lished, as heretofore, in Quarterly Sections, and in Parts and Volumes, at the original price; which was fixed so low that each page costs the purchaser less than a cent—no more than the page of eny other large Dictionary. For Sale by. all Booksellers, Send for Catalogue. OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS, American Branch, 91 and 93 Fifth Ave., New York.