The Nation 1899-08-10: Vol 69 Iss 1780
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
VOL. LXIX—NO. 1780. THURSDAY, AUGUST 10, 1899. PRICE 10 CENTS. Popular Books—For Summer Reading Snow on the Headlight. A Story of the Great Burlington Strike. By Cy Warman. 12me, Cloth, $1.2! “ Books by Cy Warman are always appreciated by a large circle of attentive readers, who enjoy his forceful style and original line of work.” — Albany Times-Union. “Told with all the freshness and vividness of an eye-witness.""—Philadelphia Call. “Cy Warman is the story-teller of the calling of railroading."’—-Chicago Times-Herald. Idylls of the Sea. By FRANK T. BULLEN, author of ‘‘ The Cruise of the Cachalot,” etc. 12mo. Cloth, $1.25. “ It is a delightful and stimulating book that will hold the attention of every lover of the sea.""— Brooklyn Eagle. * It is not to be wondered at that Mr. Kipling wrote to this author, ‘It’s a new world that you have opened the door to." Chicago Tribune A Double Thread. By ELLEN THORNEYCROFT FOWLER, author of ‘‘Concerning Isabel Carnaby,” ete. 12mo. Cloth, $1.50. “*Even more gay, clever, and bright than ‘Concerning Isabel Carnaby.’ The characters are created by one who evidently knows all the vari ations of human nature, and who is as shrewd as she is keenly observant.’’—Boston Herald, The Mormon Prophet. By Lity DovuGALL, author of ** The Mermaid,” ‘‘ The Madonna of a Day,” and ‘‘The Zeit-Geist.” 12mo. Cloth, $1.50. “A striking story. . . . Immensely interesting and diverting, and as a romance it certainly has a unique power.” — Boston Herald A Duet, with an Occasional Chorus. By A. Conan DOYLE, author of ‘‘ Uncle Bernac,” ‘‘ Brigadier Gerard,” ‘‘ Rodney Stone,” etc. Uniform with other books by Dr. Doyle. 12mo. Cloth, $1.50. . ‘“‘Charming is the one werd to describe this volume adequately. Dy. Doyle’s crisp style and his rare wit and refined humor, utilized with cheerful art that is perfect of its kind, fill these chapters with joy and gladness for the reader.""— Philadelphia Press. A Herald of the West. A ee of 1811—1815. By J. A. ALTSHELER, author of ‘* A Soldier of Manhattan” and ‘‘The Sun of Saratoga.” 12mo. Cloth, “A portion of our history that has not before been successfully embodied in fiction. . . . Extremely well written, condensed, vivid, pic- turesque, and there is continual action. . . . A rattling good story, and unrivalled in fiction for its presentation of the American feeling toward England during our second conflict.”"— Boston Herald. e Windyhaugh. A Novel. By Granam TRAVERS, author of ‘‘Mona Maclean, Medical Student,” ‘-Fellow Travellers,” ete. 12mo0. Cloth, $1.50. ‘*The author draws her characters with the clever strokes of the successful artist, and the life of her heroine is, in and of Itself, so immensely interesting that the story never for u moment palls. . . . Aside from its moral and intellectual’charm, ‘ Windyhaugh’ is brightly written, and has that keen sense of enjoyment which belongs to any genuine delineation of life.""—Boston Herald. APPLETONS’ GUIDE-BOOKS. Kept fresh and accurate by frequent revision. Appletons’ General Guide to the United States. Morocco, $2.50. (Part I., separately, cloth, 75 cents. Part I[., cloth, 75 cents ) Appletons’ Guide-Book to Alaska. Appletons’ Canadian Guide-Book. By Miss E. R. Scrpmore. Flexible cloth, $1 00. By Caarzes G. D. Roperts. Flexible cloth, $1.00, These books are for sale by all booksellers, or they will be sent by mail on receipt of price, by the publishers. D. APPLETON AND COMPANY, 72 Fifth Avenue, New York. ee Teter et ie oo ae
Page 2
4 The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1780 The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science, and Art. FOUNDED 1865. [Entered at the New York City Post-Office as second- class mail-matter.] CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. THEM WEEE... cescoccccccsvcccvcccstcvecccesngecesenes 101 EDITORIAL ARTICLES: The Needs of Imperialism.........6..0eec008 104 The Shipping-Subsidies Plot...........e000. 104 Expelling Human Nature,........s.seeeeeee 105 Foreign ade of Great Britain.........+... 106 SPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE: The Pronch Betlget oo. evccccccscsesosevesse 106 Washington's Visit to Barbados in 1751..... 107 CORRESPONDENCE: The Secondary Schools and the Colleges..... 108 BI, cc kccs bus capescacncsinets save cercspnugusoaebons 109 Book REVIEWS: Travels and Politics in the Near East...... 112 Fisher's Mediwval Empire............. ee The Break-up of China ........seeeee08 The Great Lord Burghle ti bape ebb cnhehacess ss 116 The Real Hawaii.—The Making of Hawaii,— Se Per rrr oe hier e ee 116 The Social History of Flatbush.—History of The Town of Flushing 1 Through Nature to God.... ek TEROOS OF TONG i o.5k bri soos pbecheoeuee Irish Life and Character.............eeeee8 119 TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three Dollars per year, in advance, postpaid, to any part of the United States or Canada; to foreign countries comprised in the Postal Union, $1.00. The date when the subscription expires is on the Address-Label of each paper, the change of which to a subsequent date becomes a receipt for remit- tance. No uther receipt is sent unless requested. Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter, or by check, express order, or Postal Order, payable to ‘Publisher of the Na- tion.” When a change of address is desired, both the old and new addresses should be given, Address THE NATION, Box 794, New York. - Publication Office, 208 Broadway. TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Fifteen cents per agate line, each insertion, 1, lines to the inch. ‘Twenty per cent, advance for choice of page or top of column, Cuts are not inserted on the first page. A column, $9 each insertion; with choice of page, $2h. A page, $60 each insertion; front-cover page, $80. Advertisements must be acceptable in every re- apect, Copy received until Tuesday, 5 P. M. DISCOUNTS. Time GO POBOPOGD, coccdsiivevestssosevesssianesses 5 per cent. ra ori gabon sentestespahialevastestiia 4 3 18 we. Ca sbaevebidenrebetsconseteouebe 4 26 Se puategebeesesbeseoneberecdionsen 15 1 BY Oe vamb spn cabhuesavtasscsnsapennane 20 ” 2 © | Gecbagveeseutsesanvennviacntvees 25 se Amount— $100 within a YOON. .cceeeceeeneeesereerense 10 per cent, 250 of 7 ve . 12 = 00 “ Ld “ 760 . o “ 1,000 IR a se 1,600 it) Ld 80 cd 2,000 moi sins 83% “ The NATION ia sent free to those who advertise in it as long as advertisement continues, *,* Copies of the Nation may be procured in Paris at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de l’Opéra, and in London of B. F, Stevens, 7 Trafalgar Square, Ame- rican Newspaper Agency, 15 King William Street, Strand, W. C. London agent for advertisements, H. A. Delille, Langham Hotel. ’ k:ducational. CaLiFornta, Los Angeles, West 23d Street. (4k440K0 UGH SCHOOL for GIRLS. Mrs. GrorGeE A. CaswELL. Principal. CANADA, P. LA nnoxville. Bese S COLLEGE SCHOOL. (Es- tablished 1842 h Church School for Boys on lines of eatin Public Be ools. Specially adap for sons of English r n America. Bathing, cricket, and peaishy Jon gat pwd Dy Best New York references. $280 H. J. H. Perry, M.A.. Headmaster DELAWARE, Wilmington, Franklin Street. WE MISSES HEBB’S Boarding and Day School for Girls. Students are prepared for College. DISTRICT OF C7 a (Chevy Chase P. O., Md.). HEV Y CHAS. french and Soden School for oe pate of Washington. French ‘ne e eagee eof the h Mil ULIGNY, Principe Miss’ C. PETTIGREW, Asst. ILLINOIS, Chicago, 1500-4 Title and Trust Building. VIICAGO COLLEGE OF LAW. Law DEPARTMENT OF LAKE ForEST UNIVERSITY. Three-year course leading to degree LL.B, he further information address the Secretary. E E. BARRETT. MARYLAND, . Baltimore, 122 and 124 W. Franklin St. DGEWORTH BOARDING and DAY _« School for Girls.—87th year will begin September 28, 189y. Mrs. H. P. Leresvre, Principal. Miss E. D. Hunriey, Associate Principal. MARYLAND, Catonsville. ¥ 7. TIMOTHY'S SCHOOL for Girls re- xJ opens Sept 21, 1899. Prepares for College. Heads of School, Miss M. C. CARTER. liss S. R. Carti ER. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston. OSTON UNIVERSITY pee School, Address the Dean, SaMvEL C. BENNETT. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 66 Marlborough St. {; LASSICAL SCHOOL FOR GIRLS. Boarding and Day School. Certificate accepted by Smith, Vassar, and Wellesley. 8. Arice BRown and AMELIA L. Owen Principals. MASSACHUSETTS, Danvers rs. TLLARDHALL SCHOOL for GIRLS. Twelfth year. Mrs. 8. M. D. MBEBRILL, Principal. MAssacnusEtrs, Duxbury OWDER POINT SCHOOL. —Prepares for Scientific School, College, or Business. Indi- vidual teaching. Flementary: classes for ite me Home and outdoor life Kwapp, 8.B Educational. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, Chestnut Hill. APS oe COMEG Ys". “AND. MISS BELLS AND DAY SCHOO RLS. Will reopen October 2, 1899. Students prepared for college. es RuopeE IsLanp, Providence. FrRIENDS SCHOOL Founded in 1784. Excellent FOR BOTH SEXES. home. Students from 18 States. All oes. a work in English, Science, ics, Music, id . Address AveusTInE Jones, LL.B. ReIN1A, Richm CABE'S (DA. Y ‘AND BOARDING) ersity piper Univ The thirty-fifth annual ses- goa of this eehaes ig BSS I - ee “1808. oro} re on for Un very Harvart dS PMit emies. : ben meng — cad “i the tending Ba gineer! "fteed. For Ld 4 vs ORDON McCaBE. Heat Mae fe Virermta, Richmond NIVERSITY ‘COLLEGE OF MEDI- 100 per cent. made by oe abeaies this summer be- = 6 eesiy he mood Examinia ng Boards. or Catalo Br J. ALLISON Hopess, Procter. JSS ANABLE'S Boardin ng and Day School for Girls. Established in 1848. Cirealar ¢a application. Opens Sept. 28. 1350 Pine St., Phila., Pa. SCHOOL OF DRAWING. AND PAINTING. S, BOSTON, M MUSEUM OF FINE oo Year Opens phe B 2. 1399. Instructors—E. C. TARBELL, F. aA BENSON, PHILIP HALE, Dra rawing an Pain B. L. PRATT, elling; A ONE, Decorative Design; W. EMERSON, Anatomy; A. K. Galleries, ‘Pal reign Scholarship tor alleries. ge Fo olars ‘or en and Women. Helen finunbicn Scholar- holarships. Six Ml ees in mo- oer 4 circulars and terms MISS ELIZABETH LOMBARD. Manager. MISS BALDWIN’S SCHOOL FOR GIRLS, BRYN MAWR, PA. Preparatory to Bryn Mawr College. Miss Firorence Baipwiy, Principal. Within eight ears more than ninety pupils have entered Bryn a" College from this school. Diploma given in General and College-Preparatory urses. yn fire-proof stone building. 25 acres beautiful RS. wi. e MASSACHUSETTS, East Hampton. ILLISTON SEMINARY Prepares boys for any college or scientific school. Library. Enyeteel. chemical), biological laboratories; ry etc. New athletic field with \4-mile track. tember, 1899. JosePH H. SawYER, M.A., Principal. Mrssourt, St. Louis. 39th Year. 22 Professors. OREST PARK UNIVERSITY FOR Women. ee na ay Course. oo of Music, E. R. cree irector; robty Fellows, J Parisi, Violin. Pi ore Elocution, Art. Board tuition, $265 to ss 80. dress for Catal logue, Mrs. ANNA SNEED CarrRns, President. New JERSEY, Bridgeton. EST ¥ERSE Y ACADEMY. Prepares pore ~— _— or Business. A Chris- tian Home Hew School. ul grounds; steam heat; ee. The heaith go of New Jersey. Our oys uniformly do w Paar ie W. Lyon. A.M., Principal. New York Or POERIA ights, 160 Joralemon St. HE KATHERINE L. MALTBY Home and School. a of Coemane and Special Stu- dents and Young Ladies wishing to d the wiater | the enjoyment of the Art and Musical advantages of New York City. Eleventh year. Onto, Cincinnati. ISS ARMSTRONG'S SCHOOL FOR Girls, Liddesdale Place, Avondale. Family limit- ed. Circulars sent on application. Onto, Cincinnati, Walnut Hills, 944-946-048 Morris St. DEN PARK SCHOOL.—BOARDING and Day School for Girls. Primary, Preparatory, Collegiate Departments. Higher course in the Lan- guages, Music, and art. 1 see Wie Mises Mary F. SMITH, { Prinetpals. OrngGon, Portland, 7. HELEN'S HALL.—A Boarding and Day School for Giris; will reopen Sept. 15. For cir- culars address Miss KLgaNnor Teppetts, Ph.D, 6 PENNSYLVANIA, Chestnut Hill. 'HESTNUT HILL ACADEMY. : A Boarding School for Boys. Illustrated Cata- logues on application, James L. Patterson. Head-master, PENNSYLVANIA, M SOIA aoe Y arc 8 YS AND oung Men ear, cal, petentine, ih, 8 nd rset for caf nt table. Brginea, © Gara atlon. w. ruse, A gr ds. For circular. address the Secretary. aes Dr. Holbrook’s School will reopen Wednesday, September 27, 6 P. M. ze agape onaias and Columbia examinations held at the Sine Srna, New York. . ACADEMIC CLASSES its. A Bossfing and gent Dee oe Sapo. Bin = ee remit, and advances h, Vas- Wellesley, yan Mt. Holyoke beep oid Military, jor. 10th a a SALEM, MASS., 2 Chestnut Street. MISS A. C. DRAPER'S SCHOOL. unior, Classical, and General Courses. The Princi wht pave afew girls as members of her family. Re! tages of its M Boston, make it an ideal place for education. FORESTRY SCHOOL, At Biltmore, N. C. For circular and range wd : ae Forester to the Biltmore Estate. FRIENDS’ ACADEMY. LOCUST VALLEY, N. Y. Thoro education and guarded moral training. 8 Oy atone oe eer WILLITS. Bec’y, round Mr. and Mrs. John A. Bellows reopen their Boarding and Day School for Girls at ne oon Street, Boston, October 4, 1899. Certificate of Principals admits to Smith and Wellesley Colleges. Pensionnat Francais of Vermont Aca- demy and Training School FOR TEACHERS Bd EEG aoa Mee ie Saxton's ies. caus Sie:
Page 3
Aug. 10, 1899] The Nation. Educational. LASELL SEMINARY FOR YOUNG WOMEN, AUBURNDALE, MASS. Finely equipped with Studio, Gymnasium, Swim- ming Tank, Scientific Cooking Rooms and Labora- tory; possessing all the comforts and elegancies of a first-class home, with a beautiful dining-room, superior table and service; situated in one of the most delightful suburbs of Boston, within easy access to the best concerts, lectures, and other advantages of a large and refined city; employing a large and competent board of instructors. Send early for catalogue. Students are now re- gistering for next fall. Choice of room is in the order of application. Address C. C. BRAGDON, Principal. THE H. THANE MILLER SCHOOL FOR GIRLS. (Mt. Auburn Institute. Established 1856.) School of Language, Literature, History, and Art. Three courses leading to graduation with diploma. Col- ege pesparatien. Elective courses of study. Teachers all col uates. Preparation for foreign travel. Family fim im ted in namber. Ad Mrs. H. THANE MILLER, Lenox Place, Avondale, Cincinnati, 0. Crinity College. Forty-fifth year opens September 6th. Largest endowment of any College in the South. Superior climate. Send for Cata- logue to PRESIDENT KILGO, Durbam, N. C. The Detroit School for Boys DETROIT, MICH. Tenth Year begins Sept. 20th. A Home and Day School with Primary, Intermediate, and Coll ty Pre- peer ceperenenee. Full provision for glish, odern Languag Classics, Sciences, Music, Ma- nual Training, Pagal Training. Receives boys between t and 18 years, Announcement on sac Be + ~4 OBERLIN, OHIO. Kindergarten Training School. Two years’ course. Special facilities for Post- gracias | work, Lectures in re pany : OB Ornitholo- rof ge Isarte, Music, and A essors of lin Colle; Free use of college library. Send for catalog. ddress B. EMELINE MONTGOMERY, Principal. MASSACHUSETTS. CONCORD SCHOOL. **One of the most yt e; ratory achools tn New Ergiand.”—Wwm. T. Harris, FC Com’r of Education. A Home as well as a School for ee training of Ameri- «an boys. Tenth year be; oy Se ne . To secure places, early application should JA MES 8. GARLAND, Principal. s e The American Institute of Phrenology, President, Mrs. CHARLOTTE FOWLER WELL, incorporated under the State of New York gow. opens its next session on September 5th of th tes (1899). For pects us send (free on applica- on” 2 the SECRET! RY, care “. Fowler & Wells 27 East 2ist Street, New ¥ ALLEN josie West Newton English and Classical School. Family and Homey School for both Sexes. (47th year.) WEST NEWTON, MASS. NEW YORK Ste — 1 Hs - New * LAW SCHOOL (y¥ick City. lof Insteannen. LL.B. in two for ber s 3 pr sod 7 bet years, High stand- end for Catalogu GEORGE CHASE, Dean. s e Yale Divinity School. A free education in ‘wag a in a great univer- sity. For e, etc gd Prof. B. W. BACO ew Haven, Conn. po yen Miltary Pere og WN Hon. cat A Live teach claenes, e Rt. Rev, Wm. Lawrence, eadmaster; JOS eorenes LP, SHAW, AM. sea aaa ok School for Girls. 7a-84 Hooker Avenue, Poughkeepsie, N. Y. For etoetiow, abaions ¢ tego gt Principal. Edvicudiiiial Royal Victoria Colleee (McGILL UNIVERSITY, MONTREAL). This residential college for women-students of McGill University will be opened on lith Septem- ber next. For terms, etc., apply to the Secretary, McGill College, Montreal. Massac HUSETTS, CAMBRIDGE. HARVARD UNIVERSITY. AUsTIN SCHOLARSHIPS FOR TEACHERS. Eight Scholarships, each with an annual value of $250, to be awarded for one year to superin- tendents of schools, and to teachers in secondary schools and in onege. who have been recently in service and intend return to service. For full faformation and for application blanks apply to the Corresponding Secretary, 2 University Hall, Cambridge, Mass. Yew York University. Comprehends six Schools. The LAW School (with Day and Evening Class- es). Medical College. Graduate School, Peda- gogy, APPLIED SCI- ENCE and UNIVERSITY COLLEGE. For circulars address the Registrar. Washington Square, New York C ity. ABBOT ACADEMY For Young Ladies, Andover, Mass. ee Begins its 7ist aE. September 14, 1809, ‘offering three Seminary Courses of Studies, and a College- fitting Course. Address Miss Emity A. MEANs, Principal. For catalogue, W. F. DRAPER. MONTCLAIR MILITARY ACADEM } MONTCLAIR, N. J. Preparation for the best colleges, acientific schools, gor ernment academies, or business. Especially cordiai re lations with Princeton, JOHN G. MAC VICAR, Head Master. ~ Rogers Hall School For wos Certificate admits to College. Apply to Mrs. E. P. UNDERHILL Lowell. Mass. Miss GIBSON’S FAMILY and DAY SCHOOL for Girls, 2037 DeLancey Place, Phila., Pa. 28th year. Fall term begins Sept. 28, 99. C olege Preparatory. BOYS CARED FOR. —~MORAL, MENTAL, eee Physical advan- tages not secured elsewhere. Circula JUHN H. WALSH, Great Beariagten, Mass. pete - ae —s Educational MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 44 St. Botolph St. The Allen Gymnasium TRAINING SCHOOL FOR TEACHERS. Definite Pregressions for symmetry in develop ment The resalt of twenty-one years of | t and study Two-year Course in Anat iy and Phy siology, in theory and practical work ‘ ms on application MARY |} ALLEN BLACK HALL SCHOOL & ‘eoar'eg =! >. boys Prepares f any college or for business yg im, athlet ete, 24th year begios In Septem be Caas. G. Bartierr, M.A, Prin. Black Hall, ¢ Teachers, etc. IBRARIAN.—FOUR YEARS’ EX « perience in one of largest American libraries—will act as assistant or take charge of town or college libra ry. References as to scholarship and efficiency fur nished on application to A. K.G _ care of the Nation TOUR YEARS' ACADEMICAL Course, preparatory to Yale, Vassar, ete., reduced to leas than one year by private instruction Pamphilet free Rev. Wau. Wenner, Believilie, Ll Ee NGLISH Composition.— Teachers, Clergy 4 men, Writers, Clubwomen. Systematte course by | mail. Harvard method. Free trial. Certificate given ’ MSS. criticised. Ws. H, Hawkins, Cambridge, Mase ' "| Gees W. STONE, Tutor for Har vard, 68 Chestnut Street, Boston School Agenctes. WE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES. Everert ©. Fisk & Co., Proprietors 4 Ashburton Place, Roston. 1505 Pa. 4ve., Washington 156 Fifth Ave., New Lork. 4i4 Cent. Bag, Minneapolis 730 Cooper Bdg , Denver 525 Stimae'n bk, Los \ngeles 378 Wabash Ave., Chicago. 825 M’ket St.,.San Franctaco LBANY TEACHERS’ AGE. NCY, 24 State St., Albany, N. ¥.—Provides schools of all grades with competent teachers. Assists teachers in obtaining positions. HARLAN P, Frencn, Manager CHERMERHORN'S TEACHERS' AGEN( Oldest and best known In the U. 8, Ratablished 1855 SE. 14th 8t., N.Y Carteret School, Short Hills, N. J. Preparation for any College. Private Coaching when needed. A course to suit each ease need. Constant, persona For information and Year-Book address influence of headmaster. Physical Training and Military Drill. Gymnasium, Laboratory, Casino, Tennis, Tetherball, Golf References required from all pupils. ALFRED COLBURN ARNOLD, Headmaster. _ Che Spectator. The Proprietors who in 1861 purchased the Spectator have since that date conducted It themselves. They are therefore e camped from many influences which press severely on the inde ¥ ndence of journalism. and have from t the first made tions, irrespective, not only of opposition from without, their chief object to say out what they believe to be trat 1 in theology, politics, and soctal ques but of the opinion of thelr own supporte re. Their object is to reflect the opinion of cult vated Liberals; but in the matter of the American War they fought againet the mass of the very class they are trying | to represent, and were finally acknowledged by them to have been in the right The news o the current wee without missing the life or import of the events, is compressed into an animated narrative, which the laziest or buslest may read, The Spectator contains a list of all Books published during the week (not under one shitting to price e), with the names of the publishers and the prices attached, a feature which will greatly increase ite value to booksellers, librarians, literary institutions, and private gentlemen. The SPECTATOR is on sale regularly at Messrs. Damrell & Upham’s, 283 Washington St . Boston, Mass.; The International News Co., 83 and 5 Duane St , New York; Messrs Sroatane’ 8, Union Square, New York; The Subscri ption News Co., 47 Dey St.. New York, and 77 Clark St., Chie ago, and The Harold A. Wilson Co., Ltd., 35 King St., West Toronto, C ‘anada, where single copies can be obtained, and subscriptions are received. SUBSCRIPTION, Payasue tx Apvance, $7.50 A YEAR. steele ce alddgsd 1 bide xan Street, Strand, London, England. | SOUND-DEADENING in FLOORS and PARTITIONS Every one who has suffered the annoyances and embarrassments of buildings in He lined the floors with which every sound is heard from one room to another will appreciate Rudyard Kipling’s relief at curing the trouble in his house, through which ‘‘every sound rang like a gong. Cabot’s Sheathing and Deafening ‘‘Quilt,”’ and now says, ‘‘I have found it invaluable as a deadener of noise.” Sample and circulars sent on appiication. SAMUEL CABOT, Sole Manufacturer, 79 Kilby Street, Boston, Mass. Agents at all Central Points. SEE eR RE EEA LS MORAL TN eam
Page 4
iv The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1780 NEW AND FORTHCOMING BOOKS WENTWORTH’S PLANE AND SOLID GEOMETRY Revised. By G. A. WentwortH. Half miorocco. 466 pages. $1.25. WENTWORTH’S PLANE GEOMETRY Revised. By G. A. Wentworts. Half morocco. 256 pages. 75 cents. WENTWORTH’S SOLID GEOMETRY Revised. By G. A. WentwortH. Half morocco. 210 pages. 75 cents. -DAVIS’S PHYSICAL GEOGRAPHY By Wiuu1aM M. Davis, Professor of Physical Geography in Harvard Uni- versity, assisted by WitL1am H, Snyper, Master in Science in Worcester Academy. 428 pages. Illustrated. $1.25. BEMAN AND SMITH'S NEW PLANE AND SOLID GEOMETRY By Woosatrr W. Beman, Professor of Mathematics in the University of Michigan, and Davin E. Smirx, Principal of the State Normal School at Brockport, N. Y. Half leather. 382 pages. $1.25. CAIRNS’S INTRODUCTION TO RHETORIC By Wituram B. Carrns, Instructor in English in the University of Wis- consin. 272 pages. 90 cents. SPEER’S ADVANCED ARITHMETIC By Witu1aM W. Speer, Assistant Superintendent of Schools, Chicago, Ill. CYR’S FIFTH READER By Even M. Cyr. 482 pages. 70 cents. SECOND YEAR ‘LATIN PART 1. Miscellaneous Selections of Easy Latin PART I]. Selections from Cezesar’s Gallic War EDITED BY Professor J. B. GREENOUGH of Harvard University, B. L. D’OOGE, Professor of Latin and Greek in Michigan State Normal College, Ypsilanti, and M. GRANT DANIELL, formerly Principal of Chauncy- Hall School, Boston. Descriptive Circulars of all our books sent, postpaid, on application. GINN & COMPANY, Publishers, BOSTON. _ NEW YORK. CHICAGO. LONDON. LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO.’S NEW BOOKS (AMERICAN CITIZEN SERIES.) OUTLINE OF PRACTICAL SOCIOLOGY: With Special Reference to American Conditions. By CARROLL D. WriGut, United States Commissioner of Labor; Lec- turer in the Catholic University of Aaerica; Author of ‘ Indus- trial Evolution of the United States,” ‘* Statistics of the City of Boston,” *‘ Reports of the Chief of the Massachusetts Bureau of Statistics of Labor,” *‘ Reports of the United States Commission- er of Labor,” etc. Crown 8vo, with 12 maps and diagrams, 464 pages, $2 00, COMMON SENSE IN EDUCATION. By P, A. Barnett, M.A., H.M., Assistant Inspector of Training Col- leges and Examiner in Practical Teaching for the Cambridge oe Syndicate; formerly Principal of the Isleworth Training College for Schoolmasters. Crown 8vo, $1.50. A SHORT HISTORY OF THE PROGRESS OF SCI. ENTIFIC CHEMISTRY IN OUR OWN TIMES. By WiuitaAM A, TILDEN, D.8c., Lond ; D,8Se., Dub.; F.R 8.; Fellow of the University of London; Professor of Chemistry in the Royal College of Science, London, Crown 8vo, $1.50. PSYCHOLOGY IN THE SCHOOLROOM. By T. F. G. Dexter, B.A., B.Sc, and A. H. Garuick. B.A., author of ‘A New Manual of Method.” 421 pages, crown 8vo, $1.50, “This is a remarkable book; nothing like it has before appeared. It is a comprehensive manual of psychology and agogy, of methods and devices. It is a rare combination of scholarly knowledge o A pa , of a pedago- gical professor's view of applied psychology and of a training teacher's sug- gestions to young girls about to teach their first school.” —Journal of Education, Boston. MASTERS OF MEDICINE, A New Series of Monographs Edited by Ernest Hart. D.C.L., Editor of the British Medical Journal. Each with Photogravure Frontispiece. Crown 8vo, cloth, $1 25. CLAUDE BERNARD. By Sir MicHakE. Foster, K.C.B., M.A., MD., D.C.L.. etc. Secre- tary of the Royal Society of London, Professor of Physiology in . the University of Cambridge. With Portrait, 250 Pages, $1.25. Just Ready. PASSAGES FROM THE DIARIES OF MRS. PHILIP LYBBE POWYS OF HARDWICK HOUSE, OXON. A. D. 1756 to 1808. Edited by Emity J. CLIMENSON. With a Portrait. 8vo, Pp. x.-399; With Pedigrees of the Lybbe and the Powys Families, gilt top, $5.00. *,* These extracts from the diaries and travelling journals of Mrs. Philip Lybbe Powys present such an accurate picture of life, manners, and customs of the upper ¢ of the period that I feel they cannot fail to interest the - general reader, containing as they do such’ interesting anecdotes of royalty and other notable people, descriptions of country seats, places, towns, manu- factures, amusements, and general habits of the period which now form his- tory.—Extract from Editor's Preface, STONEWALL JACKSON AND THE CIVIL WAR. By Lieut,-Col. G. F. R. HanpERson, Professor of Military Art and History, the Staff College; Author of the ‘ Battle of Spicheren,” ‘* A Tactical Study,” and ‘*The Campaign of Fredericksburg.” With 2 Portraits and 83 Maps and Plans. SECOND EDITION. : With an Introduction y Ft Marshal the Right Hon. Viscount - Wo .se.ry, K.P., .B., G.C.M.G., &c., &c., Commander. in- Chief. 2 vols., 8vo, $10.00, AMERICAN | LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., Publishers, 91-93 Fifth Ave., New York.
Page 5
NEW YORK, THURSDAY, AUGUST 10, 1899. The Week. j The Republicans of Iowa, in their State Convention on Wednesday of last week, pronounced an encomium on the Gold Democrats. “As Republicans,” they said, “we make recognition of the loyalty and exalted patriotism of the Sound-Money Vemocrats, and men of all parties, who put aside partisanship in order to maintain the good faith of the nation, and, in resistance to the Chicago platform and its candidate, to secure the welfare of the people.” Signs are not wanting in other quarters that the atti- tude of the Democrats who supported Palmer and Buckner in 1896, and of those who voted directly for McKinley in order to make their votes “count double” against Bryan, is becoming a matter of much interest among the Re- publicans. In proportion as the latter grow uneasy respecting their position on expansion and the war in the Philip- pines, they are inclined to fall back on the Gold Standard and make that issue once more the chief stone of the corner. On the other hand, the Bryanites, think- ing that they see victory within reach on other issues than that of “16 to 1,” are taking steps to win the Gold Demo- crats back to their old allegiance. Fortunately for such an effort, as re- gards domestic policy, the things which the McKinley Administration is most concerned about have been those most calculated to offend its Democratic and independent allies. It passed a most offensive tariff bill, the details of which gave rise to the suspicion that it was part of a preélection bargain for which cash had been paid into the campaign fund. In the interest of spoilsmen, it reversed the policy of civil-service re- form—in defiance and contradiction of its own national platform—a_ policy which had received the sanction and support of every other Administration, Republican or Democratic, for fifteen years. Moreover, as regards the one issue which led the Gold Democrats and the Independents to give their aid to the Republicans directly or indirectly (the establishment of the gold stan- dard), they have as yet done nothing, and it is still uncertain what they will do if anything. It is true that they have not hitherto had control of the Senate. They could not have passed any measure through that branch of Congress, but, in fact, they did not make any attempt to pass anything, not even the slight mea- sures looking to the maintenance of the gold standard which President Mc- Kinley himself recommended. They The Nation. gave no sign of interest in the subject until it dawned upon them a few months ago that they might want the votes of their gold allies next year, es- pecially since their policy of expansion and war against the Filipinos had not been an unmixed success. Added to these acts of omission and commission, which are sins in the eyes of nearly all of their allies of 1896, they are now talking of a new ship-subsidy bill, to enable another lot of rich men to get their hands into the public treasury. Such a measure would alone repel four- fifths of the Palmer and Buckner Demo- crats and of the Independents who sup- ported McKinley in 1896. The Iowa Republican platform dodg- es the whole question of civil-service reform and of the President’s action re- garding it. It does not commend Mr. McKinley’s “backward step,” as did the Kentucky Republican platform, but sim- ply ignores the subject, while holding him up in general terms as a pattern of wisdom and discretion. This was the easier in Iowa because the Republican politicians of that State have never pro- fessed much interest in the reform, and nothing was said about it in the resolu- tions adopted when Gov. Shaw was first nominated. The real struggle for the platform-makers will come in such States as Massachusetts, where hereto- fore there has been sincere support of the reform. In the convention of 1897, for instance, the Massachusetts Republi- cans congratulated the country upon the fact that “we see a Republican President, under severe pressure for place, not merely maintaining, but wisely extend- ing, the merit system in our civil ser- vice.” What shall be said in 1899, when the same President has yielded to this “pressure” and dealt a staggering blow at the merit system? The embarrass- ment of this situation is going to in- crease as the time for the Republican national convention of next year ap- proaches. Heretofore, ever since the ci- vil-service act of 1883 was passed, the Republican party has declared its belief in the reform, advocated the extension of its scope, “pointed with pride’ to the record of the party in championing the merit system, and “viewed with alarm” the prospect of intrusting it to the hos- tile hands of the Democrats. What is going to be done in 19007 It will be ri- diculous to promise support of the re- form and extension of its operations if the candidate for President shall be the man who has let down the bars in 1899. It will not do to endorse the backward step. It will be humiliating to ignore the question. Gen. Alger’s victorious home-coming must have made the air at Lake Cham- plain seem decidedly chillier to the Pre- sident. There was, of course, a good deal of the “favorite son” and “distin- guished citizen” in the enthusiasm at Detroit. This proud and jealous local sentiment is something that we in East- ern cities find it hard to comprehend. In the West, citizens of all parties and creeds will turn out to do honor to a fel- low-townsman who has won distinction of any kind—most of all, political dis- tinction. But while pride of locality un- doubtedly had much todo withthe demon- strations over Alger, resentment at Pre- sident McKinley’s subterranean way of getting rid of his Secretary of War, when he found it inconvenient any longer to carry him, was also clearly ablaze in all the proceedings. It was not only Gov. Pingree who spoke of the President's “insult to the State,” and of the “con- spiracy” to which he had lent himself. The Mayor of Detroit referred pointedly to the fact that the great outpouring of the people signified their “love of jus- tice and fair play.” Who had been guilty of injustice and underhand methods? Why, of course, the gentleman in the White House who had weakly yielded to “slander.” With all Michigan cheering Alger, and prominent Republicans send- ing checks to the reception committee as an expression of their “contempt for McKinley,” the bewildered sojourner at Lake Champlain must have asked where the political profit he expected to reap from dismissing Alger is coming in. One of the many faults in the ad- ministration of the War Department to which Mr. Alger made no reference in his public apologia, he quietly corrected on the very eve of his retirement. We refer to his rehabilitation of the Inspec- tor-General’s department. This had been all torn to pieces during the war. Though presided over by one of the most accomplished officers in the army, his functions and powers were so cur- tailed that his work was practically re- duced to a nullity. The testimony given before the War Investigating Commis- sion showed how this essential service— army inspection—had been broken down and ruined by Alger’s orders affecting it. To this fact were partly due the enormous scandals of the military camps and the transporis from Santiago. Now, Inspector-General Breckinridge has se- cured a restoration of the department to its old status and usefulness, with the distinct understanding, in addition, that army transports shall be subject to his inspection. It was gravely stated in the official bulletin announcing the change, that it was owing to “the exigencies of the war” that “certain duties” had been taken away from the Ingpector-General’s m
Page 6
102 ‘The Nation. . [Vol. 69, No. 1780 department which were now given it again. This is an excuse which con- demns. When, if not during the exigen- cies of war, is the safeguard of rigid inspection most necessary ? Light is gradually dawning on the Tallulah lynching case. According to the latest information, Dr. Hodge, for assaulting whom five Italians were lynched by the inhabitants of the town, was able to walk home from the scene of the assault, and has not been good enough to die in consequence of his wounds. It is pretty well established, also, that three of the five men lynched were Italian subjects, and, therefore, en- titled to whatever protection the king- dom of Italy can give them. The pro- vocation to the lynching and the justifi- eation of it are supplied in a rather remarkable article in the Daily States, which is styled the “official journal of the city of New Orleans,” from which it appears that the doctor’s assailants ought to be thankful that they were not burned alive. The States not only de- fends the lynching, but defies the federal Government, and tells Italy to “go to hell.” The language it employs must raise the inquiry in all civilized com- munities, what kind of catastrophe a State or community which tolerates such ideas, expressed in such brutal terms, is rushing forward to. That Gov. Candler of Georgia can ex- press sound ideas on the subject of lynching was shown early last week, when he issued an appeal to the people of the State, declaring that they ‘‘must away with the mob; must reénthrone the law.”’ In this proclamation he urged all officers of the State to do their duty in bringing to justice violators of the law, ‘“‘whether it be the negro who com- mits rape, or the white man who kills him for his crime”; all lawyers to exert their influence in discountenancing mob rule, and aiding the courts in bringing accused parties to speedy trial; and all good men to coéperate with the officers of the law in their efforts to prevent crime and suppress mob violence. Two days later the Governor showed that he can act as well as hecan write. A negro who had attempted a criminal assault in Coweta County, and had been lodged in jail, was in danger of being lynched. The Governor instructed the Sheriff to organize a posse, arm his men, and pro- tect the prisoner at all hazards; when the excitement continued to increase, he ordered out a company of militia; finally he went himself to the scene of trouble, took personal command of the situation, and brought the prisoner under a strong guard to Atlanta, where there is no danger of violence. If every Governor will treat every case of threatened lynch- ing in this fashion, the practice will soon be effectually checked. The censor at Manila ought to keep from the natives the statement which Gov. Bradley of Kentucky has just is- sued, explaining why he does not main- tain order in the mountain regions of that State. The substance of it all is that the executive cannot accomplish anything under existing laws to put an end to the terrible feuds which prevail, and that the legislators will not pass any laws which would be more effective. This is one of the most extraordinary confessions ever put forth by the head of a community which professes to be civilized. Kentucky is one of the oldest States in the Union, but its Governor ad- mits that he is powerless to stop the reign of lawlessness over whole counties. Outsiders may not be qualified to de- cide whether Gov. Bradley is right or wrong in saying that he has done all that any executive could do under the conditions which exist, but every Ameri- can must feel a sense of shame when such a revelation is made as to any por- tion of the Union, at a time when our nation has sallied forth to “enforce law and order” in distant parts of the world. No wonder that the Manila censor- ship refused to let through the dispatch which came on Tuesday by way of Horg Kong. It records one of the most shameful horrors of our shameful war in the Philippines. A town of which the residents supposed they were under a guarantee of American protection, was suddenly shelled without warning by the commander of one of our gunboats. One child was killed, buildings were destroy- ed, and the terrified inhabitants fled to the hills, doubtless with new love for their American liberators. Such an act —the shelling of an unfortified town without notice—is contrary to the laws of war. If we were making war against a civilized nation, the civilized world would exclaim in horror at our barbar- ism in doing such things. But as it is only “niggers” whom we are trying to assimilate, no protests will be heard. But why are no steps taken to end such atrocities? The dispatch says “the au- thorities express great regret” at the occurrence. But why did they try to keep from us all knowledge of it? And what is the Christian gentleman at Point Bluff doing to put an end to a situ- ation which is bringing disgrace upon the American name and civilization? To say that American citizens feel di- rect personal responsibility for the ad- mistration of the affairs of Samoa would be so grotesque a perversion of the truth as to bring a smile to the face of the most serious expansionist. Taking the country through, it is doubtful if half of its inhabitants know anything of Sa- moa but its name, and most of the re- mainder could not find it on the map if they cared enough about the matter to look. Lovers of Stevenson alone, we might say, have any understanding of the nature of the controversies in which our Government has taken part, and they certainly feel no responsibility for the slaughter of the natives committed by our forces. Outside of Stevenson’s readers, we should be surprised to learn that a hundred American citizens could be found who would conscientiously as- sert that they knew enough about Sa- moan affairs to favor any measure for which they could be held responsible. The whole business is in the hands of Government officials, and they are un- moved by public opinion, because there is and can be no intelligent public opinion in so great a country as this, concerning such remote and insignificant affairs. Hence, it would be idle to comment on the new agreement determining the des- tinies of the Samoans, although we may at least express our satisfaction that they have consented to stop fighting, and to accept the rulers set over them by England, Germany, and the United States. The decision of Secretary Gage to re- sume the issue of gold certificates in denominations of $20 and upwards will meet with general approval. Perhaps this step ought to have been taken ear- lier, but it would be superfluous to dis- cuss such a question now. The law, ever since 1863, has authorized and directed the Secretary to receive deposits of gold coin in the Treasury, to give certificates of deposit in exchange therefor, and to hold the gold for the redemption of the certificates on demand. An amendment of this law, passed in 1882, provided that whenever the gold in the Treasury, held for the redemption of greenbacks, should fall below the sum of $100,000,000, the Secretary should suspend the issue of such gold certificates. In 1893 this con- tingency came to pass. The greenback- redemption fund was reduced below that sum, and Secretary Carlisle suspended the issue of certificates. A little later, in consequence of a public loan, the gold in the Treasury rose above $100,000,000, and the Secretary resumed the issue of cer- tificates, but when it again fell below the limit, he again suspended the issue and did not resume it during his term of office. The amount of paper currency is limit- ed by law, but the available gold is limit- ed only by the products which we have to sell and which foreigners want to buy. It is fortunate that we have the means of converting gold in any amount into a convenient form of paper currency. Very likely we shali see few of the new gold certificates in circulation, but they can be used for bank reserves, and all the greenbacks now held for that pur- pose can be liberated and sent anywhere to facilitate the movement of the crops. It would be more convenient if the law
Page 7
Aug. 10, 1899] The Nation. 103 allowed the issue of gold certificates of the denomination of $10, but there must outside of bank vaults. The Bank of England issues no notes of less denomi- | nation than 325, yet its circulation is nearly $250,000,000 at the present time. The gold certificates of the Treasury, the issuance of which it is now proposed to resume, are of very nearly the same nature as Bank of England notes. These notes, although identical in form, are of two different kinds as regards their origin. There is an issue of about £16,000,000 sterling against Government securities held by the Bank, and about double that amount against gold deposit- ed by private persons. The amount of its issues of this second class is without limit. It is required by law to issue its notes for gold, either coin or bullion, in any amount, not merely to all Eng- lishmen, but to all persons who bring it. It is not required, as our Treasury is, to keep this gold on hand at all times to redeem the notes with. The general solvency of the Bank is the only security for the depositor. A deficit of $8,506,000 is reported by the Treasury for the month of July. But the existence of a deficit is less re- markable than the fact that the deficit is the smallest recorded in July during the last five years. Interest and pen- sion payments, during that month, are almost always sufficiently in excess of other months to create an excess of federal expenditure. But last month’s excess not only is nearly $22,000,000 smaller than that of the month of July, 1898, but falls two to five million dollars below the same month in either 1897 or 1896. So far as concerns the public finances, this improvement is matter for congratulation, especially since it fore- shadows a surplus for the autumn months, after the Treasury’s heavy mid- summer dues are paid. But, as usually happens when the Treasury’s position alters, there arises at once the possi- bility of embarrassment in the money market. During July, notwithstanding the general déficit in public revenue, the Treasury drew something like $8,000,000 net in cash from the New York bank reserves—this at a time when the banks’ percentage of reserve to liabilities was the lowest in six years. Apparently, the Government will have even larger auto- matic power to draw away and lock up cash a month or two hence, when all the country’s circulation will be needed for the autumn trade. The official Tammany rejoinder to the revelations made by the ex-magnates of Tammany Hall, Sheehan and Crimmins, is that they are both “sore-heads.”’ Shee- han was deposed from the position of head distributor of plunder—therefore planted him. Crimmins used to be the | favored Tammany contractor; now the be a large field for notes of $20, even | business goes to other firms: hence his | sudden discovery of the monstrous con- duct of Tammany in organizing com- panies to control all city contracts. This | May all be true, and yet all that Sheehan ; and Crimmins allege may be true also. A sore head is no bar to truth-telling; in fact, it is one of the greatest pro- vocatives to speaking truth known to man. Many a politician has displayed, | along with a sore head, a mind working with uncommon lucidity.and frankness. Sore-headedness has even been known to stir unsuspected dregs of conscience in some men. It really ought to take the place of wine in the proverb about “veritas.” The real question is not whe- ther Sheehan is a disgruntled politician, but whether his detailed and specific statement of Croker’s attitude and ac- tions during the mayoraity campaign of 1897 is accurate. There is much corro- borative evidence to show that it is. Croker had been “out of politics” for three years. He came back from Eu- rope in 1897 to look the ground over and see if it was worth his while to set up again as Tammany boss. For some weeks the prospect was not inviting, and he continued to talk of himself as a permanently retired statesman, and spoke of Sheehan as the leader of Tam- many Hall. But suddenly there came a change. Croker asserted his dictator- ship. The time was, as Sheehan ex- plains, shortly before the election, “when it seemed certain that Van Wyck would be elected.” Why was it certain, and why did Croker so confidently take the helm? Sheehan did not explain this, but everybody knows what made the Tam- many outlook roseate. It was Platt and his tool Tracy, in their control of the Republican organization and their re- fusal to endorse Mr. Low’s nomination. Boss Platt said, by actions, what his indiscreet lieutenant, Lauterbach, actu- ally blurted out in words, that he would much prefer Croker to Low. It was the political situation thus created by Platt which filled Croker’s head with visions of fresh power and wealth. But he still needed one thing more; he need- ed funds. That he got money for the campaign in enormous quantities is cer- tain; and most people can give a shrewd guess who furnished it. One of Mr. Moss’s questions expressed the general suspicion. He asked if the Metropolitan Company had not subscribed $750,000 or so to the Tammany campaign fund. If it did not, the mystery of its since acting as if it “owned” the city, and getting for nothing privileges in the streets worth millions prospectively, is deeper and darker than ever. . But from one corporation or another—probably from several—Croker got his huge corruption | fund, and then the battle was over. Platt his bitterness against the man who sup- i held the stirrup, corporations desirous of buying illegal privileges from the city gave a boost, and there was Croker in the saddle again. Horgan & Slattery have filed a peti- tion in bankruptcy, in order to get rid of liabilities to the amount of $191,392. The most interesting thing brought out in the proceedings is the statement that “the firm has had no place of business during the last six months.” This covers the period of its greatest activity and largest success in getting work from the municipal authorities; the period in which, by their own admission, Horgan & Slattery have become “the peers of any architects in the United States.” This was the last touch needed to com- plete the wonderful picture of Tam- many architecture—the revelation that the official architects of the city have no office except “the Club,” where they meet the heads of departments in the evening and receive orders from “old friends,” like Commissioner of Correc- tion Lantry, who agree with their view that they are “peers.” Newspaper reporting fairly wreaked itself upon the first day’s proceedings in the new Dreyfus trial, and did its best to turn its simple yet intense dramatic interest into melodrama. The exag- gerated emphasis given to every acces- sory—the columns about the way Drey- fus looked, whether his voice and bear- ing were those of an innocent man, and all that sort of reporter’s supernatural | insight—only serve to show how little that was new or striking came to light on Monday. Clearing away all the fine writing, what appears is that not a par- ticle of fresh evidence against Dreyfus has yet been produced to take the place of the discredited mass of forgery and perjury used to condemn him before; and that his own testimony, on cross- examination, was clear and straightfor- ward and apparently conclusive as against every old charge and new in- sinuation. The court is now sitting be- hind closed doors for a few days to con- sider the famous “secret dossier.” This was pretty thoroughly riddled before the Court of Cassation, according to the Figaro’s reports of the sessions of that tribunal, and shown to be little more than a gigantic mare’s nest. But so many diplomatic mysteries are supposed to be among its addled eggs that the court feels bound to look at them in se- cret. After that, the prosecutor will produce what evidence he has against Dreyfus, if he has any. For that we must wait with as open minds as pos- sible, though: the former case against the unfortunate officer was such a com- pound of malice and credulity and false swearing and irregularity, and has been so thoroughly broken down, that any fresh proofs offered will necessarily be under strong suspicion from the start. NG ES NE SA NEBR IT FR a iv
Page 8
104 The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1780 THE NEEDS OF IMPERIALISM. One of the commonest arguments in favor of imperialism represents the United States as a great nation, destin- ed to play a large part in the world’s history, and therefore under moral obli- gations to extend to the utmost its in- fluence and power. Much stress is put upon the necessary abandonment of our policy of “isolation,” whose continuance, it is said, is quite inconsistent with our acknowledged importance in the world’s eye. We have passed out of infancy and youth into manhood. In population and wealth we are become great. Our peo- ple buy, sell, and get gain in every quar- ter of the globe. More significant still, other nations are getting in the way of consulting us, or seeking for our support, or inviting us to take a hand in their games. All these things, we are told, show unmistakably that we are a “world power” and “international force’; by which is always meant that we are to go into the business of acquiring colo- nies and dependencies and join with Great Britain or Russia in partitioning China. Unquestionably, argument of this sort, appealing primarily to the imagination, has a subtle fascination for many peo- ple, especially for such as rarely think much of consequences and results. It should not be forgotten, however, that, in politics as well as in private concerns, those who would do things in a large way must have a large type of mind. Nothing can be clearer than that, if we are to go in for imperialism on the scale marked out for us by enthusiastic advo- cates of that policy, we ought, in the interest of consistency, if nothing more, to make some radical changes in our political and governmental methods. We cannot go on in the happy-go-lucky way that has so often characterized us, over- looking abuses, shutting our eyes to pa- tent evils and defects, and good-natured- ly putting up with conditions we are too lazy or indifferent to remedy, and yet expect success in a field strewn with difficulties and dangers, and in which the competition of training and acute- ness is intensely keen. We cannot step out into what is invitingly called a large place, and maintain ourselves there, without conducting our affairs in a cor- respondingly broad way. Al whatever point an imperial policy is examined, there stands forth this ne- cessity of a broad view. Take the civil service, for example. For an imperial administration, a clean and sound civil service, inaccessible to ence, comes near to being of wisdom. We need also. tem of finance, beyond the demagogues, and remote the ‘‘is- sues” of a Presidential campaign. We need a renovated and reorganized diplo- matic and consular service, Further, we have got to devise a form of govern- ment for our colonies or dependencies. There can be no question that at this point the difficulties are many and serious; but there can also be no ques- tion of our duty to build for the future. May we confidently hope that the large view will prevail here? Or have we to fear progress along selfish and narrow lines? Are we to see Hawaii, Porto Rico, and the Philippines organized and manipulated in the interest of the do- minant party in the United States, or with an eye solely to their healthy and prosperous development through coming generations? Shall we industriously seek for knowledge of local needs and condi- tions, on which to base our action, or go ahead on the theory that an Ameri- can Congress can succeed at anything it chooses to turn its hand to? Shall we open their trade freely to all nations, or keep up the Spanish scourge of protec- tive tariffs and. discriminating duties? Shall we give away valuable franchises and concessions to men with a “pull,” or administer them in the interest of local needs? Shall we send to the isl- ands as our Official representatives men of character and experience, chosen for their business ability and administrative capacity, or shall McKinley telephone to Platt or Hanna or Quay whenever a colonial governor is to be apppinted, in order to get the approval of some power- ful American boss? These are real problems of imperial- ism, as the question presents itself to- day to the people of the United States. There can be no doubt as to the course most in accord with the American spirit, or most certain to win on the narrow- er ground of party policy. From the beginning, material success in this country has been the result of skilful and far-seeing adaptation of means to ends. We have never gone ahead blindly, fol- lowing the ways of our fathers, attack- ing material difficulties and obstacles in pursuit of a vague and uncertain end. Our pr us development has been the result SM satin thought and per- sistent effort, working always towards a definite end; and we can hope for similar results in our political life only as we set about the work in the same ‘spirit. As a matter of party policy, too, it is the broad view that will win. Po- litical parties are now on trial before the country on this issue of imperialism. They are expected to declare and defend their policy towards our new posses- sions; and the party in power must be prepared to show its faith by its works. The party that temporizes with the situ- ation, or allows inefficiency and corrup- tion to get a foothold in the colonial ad- ministration, has nothing before.it but repudiation and defeat, It 48. worth while remembering, also, that what we have called the broad view is the only one which will win approval in the judgment of the world. We have had to take a good deal of disparage- ment at the hands of European critics. They have sneered at our culture, con- demned our political morality, taunted us on our devotion to money-getting, and reminded us of our remoteness and our youth. They are now watching to see how we succeed in managing colo- nies and playing the game of “world politics.” ‘We may depend upon it, therefore, that, to a considerable de- gree, our standing as a nation is at stake, and that failure in our new under- takings will go far, with many, to justify the worst that has been said about us. If we feel called to build an empire, surely we have here at once the op- portunity and the duty of ridding our- selves, once for all, of the spirit. of local- ism and indifference so often character- istic of our political life, and placing our whole system of policy and administra- tion on solid and permanent founda- tions, broad and deep, in every way worthy of the best we think and know. THE SHIPPING-SUBSIDIES PLOT. One of the curiosities of the Iowa Re- publican platform last week was a vaguely worded plank in favor of “‘legis- lation” (i. e., subsidies) for American shipping. The strange thing about it was that it had to be explained that this plank was adopted by “special request’ of Senator Allison. No wonder the Iowa farmers wished to wash their hands of a job put up in the interest of shipbuild- ers and shipowners on the Atlantic and Pacific coasts. Not only has the ship- ping-subsidies bill (which failed in the last Congress only because Speaker Reed put his heavy foot upon it) all the marks of a job, but all the circumstances attend- ing it justify us in describing it as a plot. The “special request” of Senator Al- lison simply shows that he is in it. What was the shipping-subsidy bill? It was a bill enabling shipowners and shipbuilders to enter into twenty-year contracts with the Government. The consideration for the Government was a certain vague right to take over steam- ers in. case of war. This naval-reserve feature of the bill proved utterly worth- less in the Spanish war; the Government found that it had to buy ships on their owners’ terms, just as if no such stipu- lation existed. For the party of the se- cond part the consideration was a bounty out of the national Treasury. What the total would amount to was variously estimated. The majority re- port put it at $3,000,000 a year; the mi- nority at $8,000,000. It was a question how many 8 would take advantage of the act. But what was not disputed was that the bounty would amount year- ly to about 8 per cert. of the cost of a 14-knot steamer, and to 10 per cent. in the case of a 20-knot steamer. In other words, the International Naviga- tion Company, for example, would get from the Government in twenty years
Page 9
Aug. 10, 1899] The Nation. 105 twice the original cost of each of its fast steamers! And it would get it by a hard-and-fast contract, which no subse- quent Congress could annul without seeming to repudiate a legal debt. It is that modest proposal which Senator Allison specially requested the Iowa farmers to tax themselves to carry out. The bill was certainly an extraordi- nary example of effrontery. As the mi- nority report on it in the House assert- ed: “The bill is in almost the exact form and grants to a penny the bounties de- manded by the gentlemen who are to re- ceive them.” But what is the evidence that the bill was not only brazen, but in pursuance of a corrupt agreement? Only circumstantial evidence, of course, but very significant. It has been openly as- serted, by David Lubin, for instance, who has talked with Mr. McKinley about his project of really protecting farmers by an export bounty, that Mark Hanna threw over the farmers, and promised the shipowners legislation in return for campaign contributions. If this were the case, and if the shipowners had been pursuing Hanna to make him pay up, the course of events could not have been different from what it has been. In the first place, Hanna made the Presi- dent come out for ship-subsidies in his message to Congress. Then he pulled the wires to get Republican conventions introduced the bill. He put his own name on it, as the hall-mark of a regu- lar Republican job. In the Senate re- port he actually apologized for not hav- ing lived up to his bargain and intro- duced the bill in the previous session. “The war prevented it,” he said. But he pointed out that he had brought for- ward the bill “at the earliest practica- ble moment” in last winter’s session. But Hanna did not get up early enough ‘among his | lieved that it can pass the next House, to endorse the scheme. Then he himself | | attention and that of all conservative to take in Speaker Reed, and his bill died. The plan is now to move heaven and earth to pass it in the next Con- gress. We are not going to argue the subsidy question with the Hanna syndicate. Something is to be said on both sides, undoubtedly. England and Germany pay subsidies, and have an expanding merchant marine. France pays $10,000,- 000 a year in bounties, and her tonnage is steadily decreasing. That fact is fa- tal to the argument that big bounties will create big fleets. Moreover, the lapse of time has put the seal of ab- surdity on much of the reasoning set forth by the Hannaites. What they said could not be done without subsidies, is done — solvitur ambulando. American ship-yards were never so prosperous as at this moment. They have orders to keep them busy for from one to three years. American ships’ plates are sold to Belfast at a profit. These are some of the facts which would enter into a se- rious discussion; but no serious discus- sion with the Hanna plotters is called | contributed by Gov. Sayers of Texas to | the current number of the North Ameri- | name of being an able man, as well as | an honest one, and he was regarded as | for. They know no argument except | greed, and the opportunity unblushing- ly to fasten themselves like leeches upon the national Treasury during this their brief day of power. Not to the front of brass of the Ohio Senator does the appeal lie, but to sober Republicans, to the farmer Republicans of the West, to Speaker Henderson, and to all who would be alarmed to see their party lend itself to such a selfish scheme of rich men. Look at the admissions of | the President of the International Navi- gation Company. He did not deny that his business was profitable at present. “We madke some money at the end of the year. We are enabled to live at | present.” Then what did he want of a bounty? To pay a “dividend to our stockholders.” Only about $50,000,000 of | Government money in twenty years did this retiring man ask for to distribute company’s stockholders. Talk about Trusts! Talk about rich men | using the Government for private gains! | The shipping-subsidies bill is a master- piece of selfish greed, compared with which the worst monopoly alive looks like a children’s aid society. To pass it would go far to justify the worst that any agitator has said of the Govern- ment’s being sold body and soul to the Hanna syndicate. It is not to be be- | with its narrow Republican majority. Speaker Henderson cannot desire to | have his term turned into an orgy ot | extravagance and corruption. But his Republicans cannot be called too early or too sharply to the shameless and dan- gerous nature of the shipping-subsidies plot. Senator Allison’s special request that the Republican party execute it is only a special request that it commit suicide. EXPELLING HUMAN NATURE. The article on Anti-Trust Legislation can Review is extremely disappointing. When in Congress Mr. Sayers had the a sound lawyer. But his present contri- bution to the solution of the most im- portant problem in our internal policy | brings us no further light. He gives a | summary of the provisions of the Texas statute, but he does not attempt to offer the slightest proof that great combina- tions of capital are theoretically perni- cious, or are, as a matter of fact, in- jurious. He asserts that such combina- tions are encouraged by protective- duties, which no one disputes; but he also maintains that they are caused by the existence of the gold standard of values, which will be generally thought absurd. His condemnation of the | “Trust” as “arrogant, unscrupulous, and | is justified only hypothetically. | says, “the cost of production and distri- |; as can be imagined. merciless in the exercise of its powers,” “If,” he bution is being reduced to the minimum; if the output is being so regulated as not to exceed a given quantity, and its sell- ing price determined by the Trust ex- clusively; if the small dealers are being put under duress as to those from whom and as to what they may buy, and as to how they may sell; if individual effort be no longer able to compete successfully with corporate power and corporate ad- vantage; if young and weak industries | are being strangled to death and the | establishment of new enterprises pre- | vented,” legislation is at fault, and the State of Texas will do what it can to cor- rect its errors. As to part of this hypothesis, it may be said at once that the reduction of the cost of production and distribution of goods is almost as pure a blessing It is synonymous with economic progress, and the inci- | dental sufferings of a few lindividuals | are offset by the improved!condition of mankind. Whether or no the price of "anything is “determined by the Trust | exclusively” we are not informed, but, if | $0, the public can hardly complain un- | less the price fixed is unreasonable. Our railroads fix the rates for transportation, but it would be hard to make out that they are often unreasonably high. The Standard Oil Company is the typical “Trust,” but it is quite obvious that the competition of electricity and gas pre- vents any “exclusive determination” by it of the price of oil. All that remains of Gov. Sayers’s hypothetical indict- ment is that individuals cannot compete with corporations, that feeble industries are strangled, and that small! dealers are put under duress as to their buying and selling. The difficulty encountered by individuals, however, in contending against great corporations is a result of the accumulation of capital, not of the existence of “Trusts.” The only sub- stantial accusation relates to the duress under which small dealers do their buy- ing and selling. That such grievances exist, however, and that they ought not to, we may ad- mit, but there are some patent reasons why it is vain to legislate against them. The Texas law forbids every human be- ing to agree with any other on the price of anything whatsoever, to sell any- thing below its cost of production with the intent to get the advantage of a com- petitor, or to deal in anything that has been produced by any one or sold by any one in violation of these restraints. Such a law is totally incompatible with present economic conditions. It might possibly be enforced in one of the vil- lage communities in India described by Sir Henry Maine. Some hundreds of years ago legislation of this kind was thought desirable in the interests of ' the trade-guilds of Europe. But in those = -
Page 10
106 The Nation. [ Vol. 69, No. 1780 ages the aim was to prevent competition, while Gov. Sayers asserts that his aim is to encourage competition. His theory of trade is that every one must ignore the existence of competitors. The grocer must not reduce the selling price of his wares because he finds the grocer across the street is selling cheaper than he. The natural consequence of such a step on his part would be to injure his com- petitor, and the law presumes that a man intends the natural consequences of his acts. But it is by precisely such reduc- tions of price that the régime of com- petition is maintained. Smith observes that Jones is selling groceries at prices that return him large profits. Smith thinks that he may as well share in these gains, and he sets up a shop where he sells at lower prices than Jones in order to get Jones’s customers to trade with him. He has no animosity towards Jones, but in legal diction he intends to injure him, and no doubt he does injure him. Jones has to lower his prices and content himself with smaller gains. Smith and Jones may be actu- ated by the meanest motives. They hard- ly pretend to be acting from any disin- terested concern for the interests of the public; but the public is on the whole benefited by their competition. To attempt to change all this is to at- tempt to expel human nature from daily life. In the city of Cleveland a great many thousand people are engaged in a general boycott. They come squarely within the purview of the Texas statute. They are conspiring to injure men en- gaged in legitimate business. Yet these very people are doubtless to a man in favor of “anti-Trust” laws. They favor them because they think they will ap- ply to other people, and not to them- selves. But the very difficulty with such laws is that, unless they are applied uni- versally, they are unjust and conse- quently ineffective. For this reason they cannot be partially enforced, and if the attempt were made to enforce them uni- versally it would fail, unless human nature underwent a sudden change. That it has undergone such a change in Texas is altogether improbable, and it is safe to predict that Gov. Sayers’s statute will produce nothing but confusion, corrup- tion, partiality, and injustice. FOREIGN TRADE OF GREAT BRITAIN, For many years the fact that the ex- ports of Great Britain have been of much less value than the imports has given concern to numerous writers. The mer- cantile theory, although long since ex- ploded, still influences the views of busi- ness men, and much of the language of trade implies that the theory is valid. A more serious cause for apprehension has recently been discovered in the de- cline of these exports as compared with the exports of other countries. It has been maintained that this decline indi- cated that the glory was departing from English commerce, that the supremacy of English manufactures was threatened, and that the country was on the verge of commercial decay. The industrial progress of Germany and the brilliant achievements of the United States have created genuine alarm, and if the pros- perity of these countries endangers that of England, the situation may well be regarded as critical. There are many reasons, however, why it is unnecessary for Englishmen to worry over the state of the commerce of their country. In spite of the fact that the balance of trade has long been against them, they have succeeded in prospering to a wonderful degree, and there are no tangible evidences that the relative decline of their export trade is arresting their prosperity. Nor, if we take a broad view of the situation, is there any reason to ‘hold that such a decline should even in theory be disas- trous. The accumulation of capital in England has for more than two genera- tions been prodigious. Under the influ- ence of internal peace, freedom of trade, moderate taxation, and the development of the mechanical arts, wealth has in- creased with leaps and bounds. Even in the beginning of this century Col. Tor- rens wrote that England had acquired “a species of property, a vested interest, in the industrial products of all the regions of the earth,” and this process of ac- quisition has been steadily going on ever since. Until quite recently, it has been on the whole a peaceful process. As Mill said, industry rather than war was the natural growth of power and impor- tance to Great Britain. Trade did not follow the flag, but preceded it, and it flourished more before the Jingo period than it has done since. And if anything shall ruin British commerce, it will more likely be the new policy of sustaining it by immense military expenditure than anything else. For, as is pointed out by a writer in the Contemporary Review, the possessions of Englishmen are largely in the hands of foreigners. In 1865 an article, at- tributed to Mill, called attention to the rise in the rate of interest that had taken place, and showed that it was due to the investment of English capital in other countries. This process was re- garded as not a temporary movement, but a permanent tendency. It was due to “fundamental and permanent changes in the relation of the aggregate of Eng- lish capital and foreign demand.” Mill held that this outflow of English capital was the principal means by which the decline of profits in England had been arrested. He declared that “the mere continuance of the present annual in- crease of capital, if no circumstance oc- curred to counteract its effect, would suffice in a small number of years to re- duce the rate of net profit to 1 per cent.” England depended no longer upon the fertility of her own soil to keep up her rate of profit, but on the soil of the whole world. The fleets that her abun- dant capital enabled her to construct brought to her shores the food products of the remotest regions, and at little greater cost than the expense of produc- tion in those countries. Just as the dwellers in great cities now enjoy the produce of the farms at as low rates as dwellers in the country,so the people of England are cheaply fed by the peo- ple of the rest of the world. The simple explanation of this is that Englishmen own, literally or metaphori- cally, the land and the instruments of production everywhere to such an ex- tent that they may be said not to need to work so hard as formerly for a Mving. London is crowded with companies whose business lies in other lands: land companies, mining companies, mortgage companies, railway companies, water companies, gas companies, etc. Austra- lia is perhaps owned more by residents of England than by its own inhabitants. Canada is in a literal sense a British pos- session. The United States has been for years a favorite field for English capital- ists. Their money has built many of our railways and is invested in many of our factories. The amount of British capital invested in Argentina has been estimated as high as £200,000,000. The securities of every government ‘on the face of the earth are held in London. Taking British investments in India and Australia and Canada, and adding to them the sums invested in foreign countries, we see that the revenue regu- larly coming from abroad to people liv- ing in the British Isles must he enor- mous. It might well be thought that their exports represent merely new in- vestments of their capital in other coun- tries, and that if they ceased altogether the income of the existing possessions would be sufficient to keep them in pros- perity. Some Englishmen pull long faces at the sums which they say are paid to foreigners for butter and meat and grain. But, as the writer in the Contemporary says, it is the foreigner who is paying his rents and the inte- rest on his mortgages in the shape of these commodities. If, as this writer conjectures, the value of the property of the inhabitants of the British Isles ly- ing beyond their own confines is £5,- 000,000,000, they may contemplate some decline of their exports without uneasi- ness. eee THE FRENCH BUDGET. PARIS, July 26, 1899. The French budget was long kept below the sum of two milliards (2,000 millions of francs); when it attained that sum, M. Thiers is said to have told the Chamber: “Bid it good-by; you will never see it again.” He was right; the sum of two mil- lMards rose gradually to three, and now we can bid an eternal adieu to this last sum.
Page 11
Aug. 10, 1899] The reign of Louis-Philippe was the gold- en age of our finances; it was an era of economy, and at the same time of useful expenditure; it was the period of the first development of railways, of many indus- trial enterprises, of the creation of im- portant banks. The Revolution of 1848 brought about an interruption of this pros- perity; the Second Empire had very flourish- ing finances again, but spent very large sums in wars. It was a period of great finan- cial extravagance, but also of great indus- trial developments. In 1869, the last: normal year of the imperial régime, the ordinary expenses of the state amounted to 1,737 mil- lions of francs. In 1870 came the war. Its consequences, in a financial point of view, were disastrous. France had to pay to Germany, for the ransom of the occupied provinces, a sum of five thousand millions. The money was found and placed in the hands of the Ger- mans with a celerity which seemed in- credible at the time. The secret of it lay in the fact that France was then a very large holder of foreign securities, which were sold, chiefly in London; and the ran- som was paid by instalments. Many French people were flattered in their mis- fortune by the thought of the great wealth of France, forgetting that France had to issue a loan of five thousand millions. This was simply added to the long list of her debts; it has not yet been paid. After what may be called the liquidation of the war of 1870, when its permanent effect was felt in the finances of the nation, in 1894 the total of the ordinary expenses had risen to the sum of 2,623 millions of francs. The difference between this and the last budget of the Second Empire was there- fore no less than 886 millions of francs; and this yearly sum may be considered as the result of the unfortunate war of 1870. As long as the Constituent Chamber was in session at Versailles, there was a great ery for the reform of the finances, for re- trenchment in every department, for a di- minution in the number of office-holders. For all administrative matters the influ- ence of M. Thiers was excellent; he was a good financier if he was not always a good statesman and a good economist. But France had to reorganize her army, and this involved enormous expenses, which have never been interrupted to this time. When the question of the form of govern- ment was finally settled, the consequences of a democratic and republican government were felt by degrees in the financial sense. If the Republicans had preserved the scrutin de liste, or vote by general ticket, which is a party rather than a personal ballot, these consequences might perhaps have been delayed; but, with the present system of the scrutin d’arrondissement, the Deputy becomes a sort of local agent for a very small division of France, and he can secure his reélection only by gifts of all sorts to his arrondissement and to all per- sonal and local interests. As a whole, the Chamber speaks invariably for retrench- ment, while every one of its members is working incessantly for some object which represents directly or indirectly an addition to the budget of expenditure. This tendency is one of the great evile of a democracy; general considerations have to give way to private interests, The increase in the num- ber of offices and office-holders is one of the effects of the omnipotence of Parlia- The Nation | lations. agen at ment. Each Deputy, in order to keep his | seat, is obliged to provide offices for some of his influential electors, his sons, his re- As soon as a law is passed for the protection of labor, of children, or for any other democratic object, a number of inspectors are appointed with a view to se- curing the execution of the law. The Cham- | ber has a complete initiative in the matter | of expenses, and every member can ask for a new credit. This omnipotence is destruc- tive of all budgets prepared by the adminis- tration. M. Thiers made, after the war, a pro- vision of 200 millions a year for the sink- ing-fund; and for a few years this sum was deducted from the 2,623 millions of the | budget of 1874. The 200 millions has been reduced in 1899 to 95. The difference is 105 millions, and, if we take note of it, we find that the real difference between the two budgets of 1874 and 1899 amounts not to 851 millions, but to this sum augmented by 105—that is to say, 956 millions, nearly a milliard. This melancholy comparison will all the more strike a financier because the rate of in- terest has greatly changed since 1874. M. Thiers issued the great war loan in five per cents; in 1883 the French rentes were converted from 5 to 4% per cent.; in 1894 the conversion was continued, and the state | | frances; now gives its creditors only 3% instead of 4%. These successive conversions have al- | | Defence issued in London the loan of 250,- | 000,000 which goes lowed the state to effect a saving of no less than 108 millions a year, adding which to the sum of 956 millions we arrive at a grand total of 1,064 millions. This is really the augmentation which has taken place in the ordinary expenses in the course of twenty-five years; the French budget of expenses has increased regularly by. 42 mil- lion francs a year. This progression is truly alarming, all the more so because it is constant and regu- lar. France, rich as she is, will be able to bear such a burden long, especially as the popu- | lation is nearly stationary. The enormous taxation, which is a consequence of the growing expenses, weighs heavily on the earning power of the nation; it is an ob- stacle to the industrial development, as is clearly shown by the amount of French ex- ports from year to year. In 1874 France exported 3,701 millions of goods of all sorts; in 1899 she exported only 3,503 millions, a difference of 198 millions. These figures compare unfavorably with similar figures in England, Germany, Belgium, and the Unit- ed Stated. I said above that the number of office- holders, of public functionaries, is alarmingly on the increase. ber, but it is proportionate to the amount of pensions paid by the state to those who have | left the public service on account of age. This, in 1869, at the end of the Empire, amounted to 85 millions; in the budget of 1899 it comes in for 237 millions, an augmen- tation of 152 millions. It can, therefore, be fairly said that the number of pensions has tripled under the Republic. France has made and is making enormous | sacrifices for her army and navy. The Cham- bers, since 1870, have invariably voted al! the credits necessary for this increase. Our army, the active and the territorial included, and the reserves, would amount, in time of war, to nearly four millions of men. Such a war instrument, in the opinion of the | for its mobilization; | too costly. ' | expenses of the national defence in the war | Government of the National | expenses of a new war, | bring all its forces into action, it | be necessary to find from twenty to thirty | millions of francs a day. | tiv trul re, 1 ht to I : Many people ask themselves whether | tle gare Sin reg , ae I have not their exact num- | 107 best judges, would be too unwieldy, notwith- standing all the efforts which might be made it would certainly be It has been calculated that the of 1870-1871 amounted to millions a day; the army then numbered at its maxi- mum 600,000 men, reckoning in this number all the levies made in the provinces by the Defence. The with the present dimensions of the French army, would be much higher; they would rise perhaps to twenty, perhaps to thirty millions a day It is frightful to think of such outlays if the war lasted any length of time. A national loan, to an enormous amount, would imme- diately become necessary; it would undoubt- edly be subscribed, but at what rate of in- terest? That depends upon many circum- stances, and particularly upon the credit of France at the moment war is declared. Those who have not abandoned the idea of re- venge and of the reconquest of Alsace-Lor- raine, ought, therefore, to take the greatest care of the credit of the country; but this preoccupation does not seem to have much weight with the Chambers, and they allow the debt of France to grow alarming proportions. In 1870 the funded debt and the redeem- able debt amounted to about 13 milliards of and it was not without some diffi. culty that the Government of the National ten to the most in France under .the name of the Morgan loan. The Bank of France was obliged to lend about 700,000,000 to the State. At present, the public debt of France reaches nearly 35 milliards of francs. In case of war, in order to main- tain the country on a war footing, and to would Such a perspec- our legislators with the necessity of fund- ing as much as possible of the present debt, of avoiding all unnecessary expenses, of practising seriously a policy of retrench- | ment, of refusing to create new offices, and of leaving to private efforts and enterprise as much as can be taken away from the work of the state. We hear, on the con- trary, constantly of plans for the manage- ment of the railroads by the state, or of the mines, which are now worked by private companies. The Socialist school would, if it could, suppress all private enterprises, and make the country an immense state establishment. It is safe to assert that no system could be more ruinous, and at the same time more destructive of those indi- vidual forces in which must lle, on the whole, the strength of a civilized and pro- gressive state. Democracy is costly enough, but what would not Socialism be? WASHINGTON’S VISIT TO BARBADOS IN 1751. GEORGETOWN, BRITISH GUIANA, July, 1899. “No, sir, I don’t believe George Washing- ton ever visited Barbados!” Such was the declaration recently made, in all candor, by an American gentleman to a British colonist | who had referred to the only journey Wash- ington ever took outside of that country of which he became the Father. It is, however, a fact that, as the companion of his invalid ee ee
Page 12
108 The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1780 elder brother, Lawrence, then in a rapid consumption, George Washington sailed from Virginia on the 28th of September, 1751; ar- rived at Barbados on or about the 3d of No- vember, and sailed thence, on his return to Virginia, on board the Industry, on the 22d of December. His passage, each way, was a rough one, and prolonged to five weeks. The methodical young Virginian kept a Diary during his trip, extracts from which were published by Jared Sparks, in his ‘Writings of George Washington’ (vol. ii., pp. 424 to 426). On their arrival at Bridgetown, the capital of Barbados, the Virginia brothers would in ordinary course take up their quarters at a tavern, which in those days took the place of a hotel. A hundred and fifty years ago, however, as in our own time, the people of Barbados were much given to hospitality; or, to use Washington’s own words, ‘‘Hospi- tality and a genteel behaviour are shown to every gentleman stranger by the gentleman inhabitants.” Accordingly, there is this en- try in the Diary, on the 4th of November: “This morning received a card from Major Clarke, welcoming us to Barbadoes, with an invitation to breakfast and dine with him. We went—myself with some reluctance, as the small-pox was in the family. We were received in the most kind and friendly man- ner by him. .. . After drinking tea we were again invited to Mr. Carter’s, and de- sired to make his house ours till we could provide lodgings agreeable to our wishes, which offer we accepted.” The “reluctance” to accept Major Clarke’s invitation, on account of the presence of smallpox in the family, was justified by sub- sequent events. The Major Clarke who wel- comed the Washingtons, and who showed them much attention during their stay in the island, was Major Gedney Clarke, who for years filled the post of Collector of Customs at Barbados, and was a member of Council. He and his family were much concerned in the colonizing of Demerara, then under the Dutch, but now forming a part of British Guiana. On the 5th, Dr. Hilary, ‘an eminent physi- cian recommended by Major Clarke,’’ passed a favorable opinion upon Lawrence’s case. In the cool of the evening, accompanied by Mr. Carter, the brothers rode out to seek lodgings in the country, as the doctor ad- vised. They “were perfectly enraptured with the beautiful prospects which every side presented to their view—the fields of cane, corn, fruit-trees, etc., in a delightful green."" They were, however, unsuccessful in their search for lodgings. On the 7th, they dined again at Major Clarke’s, where they met the Surveyor-General and the judges. After dinner, which in those days was taken early in the afternoon, the whole party went with the Washingtons on a hunt for lodgings, this time with success. “We pitched on the house of Captain Croftan, commander of James’s Fort. He was desired to come to town next day to propose his terms.” On the 8th, Captain Croftan made known his terms, which were fifteen pounds a month, exclusive of liquor and washing, “which we find ourselves.” Washington's frugal mind characterized these terms as “extravagantly dear.’’ Lawrence was, never- theless, obliged to accept them. The brothers moved into their quarters that evening. Of the prospect from their residence, the Diary records: ‘It is very pleasantly situated near the sea, and about a mile from town. The prospect is extensive by land and pleasant by sea, as we command a view of Carlyle Bay and the shipping.” Carlisle Bay is the har- bor of Bridgetown. Again, on the Sth, came “a card” from Major Clarke, inviting the brothers to dinner on the 10th, this time as the guests of the Beefsteak and Tripe Club, which was to meet at Judge Maynard’s. This club was insti- tuted by Major Clarke himself, and met at the houses of the several members. The entry in the Diary on the 10th of November will give some idea of the heartiness of the welcome accorded to their Virginia visitors by the Barbadians with whom they became acquainted. It runs as follows: “We were genteelly received by Judge Maynard and his lady, and agreeably enter- tained by the company. They have a meeting every Saturday, this being Judge Maynard’s day. After dinner there was the greatest collection of fruits set on the table, that I have yet seen—the granadilla, sapadilla, pomegranate, sweet orange, water-lemon, forbidden fruit, apples, guavas, etc., etc. We received invitations from every gentle- man there. Mr. Warren. desired Major Clarke to show us the way to his house. Mr. Hacket insisted on our coming Saturday next to his, it being his day to treat with beef- steak and tripe. But, above all, the invita- tion of Mr. Maynard was most kind and friendly. He desired, and even insisted, as well as his lady, on our coming to spend some weeks with him, and promised nothing should be wanting to make our stay agree- able. My brother promised he would accept the invitation as soon as he should be a lit- tle disengaged from the doctors.” On the 15th, Washington was “treated with a ticket to see the play of George Barnwell acted.” Of the acting he observes that “‘the character of Barnwell and several others were said to be well performed.” On the 17th of the month, the future hero was “strongly attacked with the small-pox,” which had probably been incubating since his first visit to Major Clarke’s. Until the 12th of December his illness kept him within doors. Dr. Lanahan was constant in his at- tendance upon the patient,and Major Clarke’s family visited him in his illness, and “‘con- tributed all they could in sending him the necessaries which the disorder required.” As soon as he was able to get abroad, Washing- ton called upon the Clarkes, to thank them for their kindness. Leaving his brother Law- rence at Barbados, whence the invalid two months afterwards sailed for Bermuda, vain- ly seeking for better health, Washington sailed out of Carlisle Bay at midday on the 224 of December, 1751. Washington wrote down the general im- pressions he had received on his visit to Bar- bados, as well of the people as of the coun- try. Of the physical features of the island, the young land-surveyor noted: “There are several singular risings in this island one above another, so that scarcely any part is deprived of a beautiful prospect, both of sea and land; and, what is contrary to observation in other countries, each eleva- tion is better than the next below.” Of the fruits he found many delicious, but none pleased his taste so well as the pine. His practised eye led him to note that “‘the earth in most parts is extremely rich, and as black as our richest marsh meadows.” After instancing the productiveness of the soil, he philosophizes thus: “How wonderful that such people should be in debt, and not be able to indulge them- selves in all the luxuries as well as necessa- ries of life. Yet so it happens. Hstates are often alienated for debts. How persons com- ing to estates of two, three, and four hundred acres (which are the largest), can want, is to me most wonde Pg Of the conditions of the inhabitants he ob- served that there were few who might be called middling people. ‘They are very rich or very poor, for by a law of the island every gentleman is obliged to keep a white person for every ten acres, capable of acting in the militia, and consequently the persons so kept cannot but be very poor.”” Washington’s sol- dierly eye noted the bearing of the militia. He held them to be “‘well-disciplined.”” More- over, there were large intrenchments cast up wherever it was possible to land, and ‘‘as na- ture has greatly assisted, the island may not improperly be said to be‘one entire fortifica- tion.” Thoughtful and grave, far beyond his years, the young colonist from North Ame- rica, then only in his twentieth year, pla- ced on record his observation that the isl- anders of Barbados had a political griev- ance. His words ran: “They are, however, very unhappy in re- gard to their officers’ fees, which are not paid by any law. They complain particular- ly of the provost-marshal, or Sheriff-General of the island, patented at home and rented at eight hundred pounds a year. Hvery other officer is exorbitant in his demands.” The friendly relations that existed be- tween the colonists of North America and those of the West Indian islands is well exemplified by the kindness with which the Washingtons were received, when they vi- sited Barbados. How close were the con- nections subsisting between the Virginians and the Barbadians may be gathered from the fact that no less than thirty-three per- sons in Virginia are named among the sub- scribers to the Rev. Griffith Hughes’s ‘Na- tural History of Barbados,’ which was pub- lished in London in 1750, the year before Washington’s visit. Among those subscrib- ers were Lord Fairfax, and the Honorables William Fairfax, John Robinson (President of the Council), William Newton, and the Rev. William Dawson, D.D. (President of William and Mary College); Cols. Carter, Burwell, Thornton, Fitz-Hugh, Fry, Bever- ley, Lunden Carter, Blande, Braxton, Carter Burwell, and George Lee; Majors Danger- field, Monroe, and Wayener; Thomas Nel- son, James Reid, Beverley Whiting, Stephen - Dewey, Edward Pendleton, Lumford Lomax, and John Lee. Some idea of the where- abouts of Major Clarke’s house may be gath- ered from a statement in the ‘Natural His- tory of Barbados’ (p. 6). Referring to the position of the Indian Bridge, which in the early days crossed the stream that ran into Carlisle Bay, Hughes says: “The above- mentioned Bridge was placed over that part of the creek, or narrow neck of the Bay, which divides Major Gidney Clark’s House from Colonel John Fairchild’s.’”’ It should be an easy matter to trace the position of Capt. Croftan’s house by an examination of the records in the Colonial Secretary’s Of- fice, at Bridgetown. Of the numerous Ame- ricans who now take holiday trips to the West Indies, perchance some may have the inclination to locate the spot where Wash- ington dwelt when he sojourned in Barbados. Correspondence. THE SECONDARY SCHOOLS AND THE COLLEGES. To THe EprTtoR oF THE NATION: Sir: The comments which I wish to make
Page 13
Aug. 10, 1899] The Nation. 109 upon the recent report on historical teach- | knowledge of the great landmarks of the ing are with reference to some of its most general features; I feel, therefore, that there will be no injustice in making them before I have examined the report itself. School men have known for some time what, in general, would be its conclusions. In so far as they are likely to meet with general approval, they are of a rather obvious cha- racter. Secondary school men must often in their hearts pray to be delivered from their friends. Our good champions, the colle- gians, have done much for us, but it is a question whether the limit of their service is not now nearly reached. When we re- flect that we cannot possibly accept all the authoritative views of all the authorities, perhaps courage may be plucked up to assert a somewhat more manly independence in the discussion and settlement of problems purely internal in character. It has for a long time been agreed, in a general way, that the studies below col- lege grade should not substantially differ in the case of young men intending to enter college and in that of those who will not do so. The evident conclusion from this agree- ment is that secondary curricula must be planned with reference chiefly to previous, not subsequent, work, and that the aim of these secondary curricula is to complement and supplement the elementary study. The pressure on the part of the college men becomes, however, increasingly heavy upon the secondary school, and an emphasis is placed upon the term preparatory which is, in my judgment, highly mischievous. The dilemma is often presented to the secondary school of sacrificing, either really or ap- parently, one of its two classes of students. There would be something grotesque in the spectacle of a conscientious and not too intelligent school principal sitting down with the final judgment of the specialists in each department and endeavoring to con- struct a school programme. The historians have just insisted upon four full years for them; Greek demands three; Latin five or six; Science insists upon three or four; the mathematicians have never contemplat- ed any reduction in the time allotted to them; French and German are insisting upon not less than four years, and English is equally grasping. Each department, with the possible exception of Greek, insists that every student shall take all of its work. There is a ridiculous aspect to all this, but there is also a more serious one. Is it too much to ask from our men of widest culture and deepest insight that they shall steadily hold in view all interests and all needs? Or must we resign ourselves to mere partisanship even here? Similarly, in the judgment of the writer, the wholesale condemnation of the year course in general history shares in this quality of partisanship and partial survey. It can scarcely be open to question that, for many students and in many cases, the single-year course in general history, plus some work in American history, is the best that can be planned. Let our college friends spend some energy in giving us the best possible text-books for this work, and we will ask no more. It is true that such a course finds little space in private acade- mies, or in the course of students who willen- ter college; in our public high schools, how- ever, a thorough study of outlines and some world’s progress are all that thousands of young people may hope for. Shall we serve their interests well if we inform them tho- roughly as to the constitution of Cleisthenes and leave them quite ignorant as to Cal- vin and Chaucer and William the Silent? I am, sir, yours very truly, FREDERICK WHITTON. MICHIGAN MILrrary Acapgmy, August 4, 1899 Notes. Doubleday & McClure Co.'s fall list of publications includes a translation, by R. C. Long, of Jean de Bloch’s ‘The Future of War,’ to which is accredited the idea of the Peace Congress at The Hague; ‘Misceila- nies,’ by the late Henry George, and his Life by his son and namesake; ‘Nancy Hanks,’ the story of Abraham Lincoln’s mother, by Caroline Hanks Hitchcock, and a Life of Lincoln by Ida M. Tarbell; ‘Heroes of Our Early Wars,’ by the Rev. Cyrus Townsend Brady; “The Boys’ Book of Invention,’ by Ray S. Baker; ‘Tales of the Telegraph,’ by Jasper Ewing Brady; ‘Nature’s Garden,’ an aid-‘to our knowledge of wild flowers, by Neltje Blanchan; ‘Sketches in Egypt,’ by Charles Dana Gibson; and a Kipling Kalen- dar for 1900. In connection with J. M. Dent & Co., this firm will undertake a ‘‘Temple Edition” of Dickens in forty volumes—good news to all who know the meaning of this trademark. The Century Co.’s ‘““Thumb-nail”’ series will be continued with ‘Rip Van Winkle and the Legend of Sleepy Hollow,’ with an introduc- tion by Joseph Jefferson; and the ‘Medita- tions of Marcus Aurelius,’ newly translated by Benjamin E. Smith. They announce, too, ‘Maximilian in Mexico,’ by Mrs. Sarah Yorke Stevenson. Prince Kropotkin’s ‘Reminiscences of My Life’; ‘The American in Holland,’ by the Rev. W. E. Griffis; ‘A Dividend to Labor,’ by the Rev. N. P. Gilman; ‘How Much is Left of the Old Doctrines?’ by the Rev. Washington Gladden; and ‘The Little Fig- Tree Stories,’ by Mary Hallock Foote, are in the press of Houghton, Mifflin & Co. Ginn & Co. have in preparation ‘An Intro- duction to the Methods and Materials of Literary Criticism,’ by Profs. Charles Mills Gayley and Fred Newton Scott, of which two volumes will be ready next fall; and ‘Ways of Wood Folk,’ by William J. Long. ‘On General Thomas’s Staff,’ a story for the young, by Byron A. Dunn, is in the press of A. C. McClurg & Co., Chicago. The tenth volume of the sixth series of the Massachusetts Historical Society’s se- lections is unequally divided between an index to that series and a selection from Sir William Pepperrell’s papers in the So- cilety’s possession (by gift of Dr. Jeremy Belknap). These documents, which centre about the siege of Louisbourg, have been freely availed of by historians, but have only partially been printed. This is espe- clally true of the private letters which make up the bulk of the present reprint, and which satisfy all reasonable curiosity as to a military and naval enterprise of great significance in our colonial history. Two plans accompany the papers, which have been judiciously annotated. An ap- pendix contains a roster of the troops en- gaged. Mr. Cecil Headlam has added to the “Me. diwval Towns” series (Macmillan) a volume on ‘Nuremberg’ which well deserves its place beside Mr. Cook's ‘Rouen.’ Compar- ing the two books, we find evidence of deeper historical research in ‘Rouen’ and a greater regard for the needs of the tourist in ‘Nuremberg.’ The municipal and artistic activities of Nuremberg were both so strongly marked that they afford a rich store of topics to the author and of, inte rests to the traveller. Probably no town in Germany outside the great capitals is more frequented by Americans than the red-roofed city on the Pegnitz, and few per sons are fortified with the local knowledge which will enable them to neglect in safety this sketch of its origin, progress, and lead ing citizens. Commendation now as always must be given the beautiful drawings of Miss Helen James. They adorn any volume which they illustrate. ‘Alfred the Great: Containing Chapters on his Life and Times’ (London: Adam & Charles Black; New York: Macmillan) is a high-class advertisement of the national! commemoration which will be held in 1901. The editor, Mr. Alfred Bowker, Mayor of Winchester, frankly points in his preface to a circular of solicitation which is given at the end; and the circular, in turn, asks for subscriptions to the fund of £30,000 which is being started by the Lord Mayor of London. “The International Committee organizing this Commemoration have con- sidered it very advisable that a publication should be issued with a view to diffusing as widely as possible public knowledge of the King’s life and work. This being the sole object, it became essential that the book should not be costly, but within the reach of all. Therefore, it was aiso neces- sary to restrict its scope; numerous sub- jects and possible illustrations of interest have been left for a full and complete bio- graphy of the great king.” The volume contains eight essays written by contri- butors who are all prominent in English let- ters: Sir Walter Besant, Frederic Harri- son, the Bishop of Bristol, Charles Oman, Sir Clements Markham, Professor Earle, Sir Frederick Pollock, and the Rev. W. J. Loftie. On the cover is a reproduction in colors of King Alfred’s Jewel. Her Majesty has accepted the dedication, and the Poet Laureate furnishes a poem, entitled, “The Spotless King,”’ which, among other cha- racteristic lines, contains this one: “and none are truly great that are not good.” The articles are all creditable to their au- thors, and show that, though the work is intended for the unlearned public, the bust- ness of composition has been taken se- riously. We have found two papers parti- cularly good, viz., Professor Earle’s on “King Alfred as a Writer,” and Sir Fred- erick Pollock’s on “English Law before the Conquest.” By reason of its purpose and of its own merits, the book should be wide- ly spread. Those interested in the tendencies of eco- nomic thought of the last twenty-five years will welcome Mr. C. W. Macfarlane’s ‘Value and Distribution’ (J. B. Lippincott Co.). To many the “new economics” has been identi- fied with the negative critical work of tbe Historical School; great emphasis on ‘‘induc- tion” as opposed to “deduction”; and a weak- ness for “ethical” applications. That there is a mass of constructive work, some of
Page 14
110 The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1780 which is embodied in the publications of the Austrian group, much more of it scattered through various magazines and journals, is not so generally recognized, because no effort had been made to bring it together as a co- herent whole. To give permanence to this scattered work, and to bring it, as well as that of the Austrian economists, into some sort of co-relation with the work of the so- called orthodox school of economists, is one of the purposes of the present volume. ‘‘Eth- ics’”’ is avoided, and, in the problem of Dis- tribution, the question of equity of the dis- tribution of wealth has been consciously and purposely avoided, the author confining him- self to a purely theoretic study of the laws of Distribution. In his criticism of the modern economists, as well as in the statement of his own position, Mr. Macfarlane shows his grasp of ‘economic theory, and has made a valuable contribution to economic literature. Coming from outside the academic circle, the book is significant of the attitude of mind of the educated business man, and points to a more sympathetic relation between the University and the world of affairs. It is hard to see what reason there is for the existence of Dr. E. C. S. Gibson’s com- mentary on Job (‘The Book of Job,’ Macmil- lan), except it be that the series to which it belongs (Oxford Commentaries, edited by Walter Lock, D.D., Ireland Professor of the Exegesis of Holy Scripture) stood in need of something of the kind. The pity is that the kind is so poor, and it is to be hoped that the succeeding volumes of the series will reach a higher level. This instalment makes no contribution to its subject; it fails to see the problems involved, and thus cannot even present the solutions of others. The series as a whole, according to the prefatory note of the general editor, is to be “less elemen- tary than the Cambridge Bible for Schools, less critical than the International Critical Commentary, less didactic than the Exposi- tor’s Bible.” The latter two minuses are easy of attainment, and are abundantly at- tained in this volume; with regard to the first, no one would ever choose this book in place of the golden little commentary by Da- vidson in the Cambridge Bible. We cannot see that it is less elementary, except for two or three pages on the versions, and Dr. Gib- son certainly makes no approach to David- son’s exegetical tact and learning. Further, though much has been accomplished since Davidson's little book appeared, there are here few or no signs of advance. The almost solyed problem of the original prose legend of Job and of the folk-tale about him meets with no allusion, and though there are refer- ences to the contributions of Budde, not the slightest account is taken of his last recon- struction—fantastic, it may be, but epoch- marking. Finally, so far as the present volume is concerned, the only advantage which this series has over the Cambridge Bible is that it uses the Revised and not the Authorized Version as a basis. It would be & cause for thankfulness if the Cambridge Bible would follow this most reasonable ex- ample, In ‘Through Armenia on Horseback’ (BE. P. Dutton & Co.), the Rey. George H. Hep- worth, sent out by the N. Y, Herald to look into the Armenian massacres, describes his journey of investigation. As he had such full permission from the Sultan that he was even provided with an escort of Turk- ish officials, we canhot help fearing that many unpleasant facts may have been kept out of his way, and we are not reassured by his manner of operating or by many of his comments, which suggest that one of Mr. Hepworth’s characteristics is a certain naiveté not exactly suited to the difficult and delicate task he had in hand. His re- fiections are at times almost childishly com- monplace, his style is generally trivial, and his rather lumbering attempts at gayety are apt to be exasperating. On the other hand, if not keen in detection nor profound in insight, he did not shut his eyes to ob- vious truths, however painful, or allow him- self to be led away by the specious expla- nations of those who had been personally kind to him. Thus, although he travelled with specially appointed companions, and was hospitably entertained by the local of- ficials, he did his best to hear what he could of the Armenian question from the other side also, and it is that other side which convinced him. If he tries to explain the massacres, he does not attempt to pal- liate them. His conclusions are pessimis- tic enough. He believes that the future of the Armenians is hopeless, and meanwhile they are in continual danger of fresh slaughter; that the Turks are incapable of reform; that “I cannot name the root of the difficulty, but I feel sure that it is political rather than religious, and that not all the Powers of Europe can make Turkey other than it is, a moribund nation with a fatal disease for which there is no known re- medy.”’ ‘De l’Influence Francaise sur 1’Esprit Public en Roumanie: Les Origines,’ by Pom- piliu Eliade (Paris: Leroux), is a study of the intellectual awakening of Rumania at the end of the eighteenth and the beginning of the nineteenth centuries. The author, a native who has studied in Paris, ascribes this awakening almost entirely to the direct or indirect influence of France, whether in the form of the enlightenment of the “‘philo- sophes,” the ideas of the great Revolution, or the stirring glories of Napoleon; whether brought in by wanderers and émigrés, or in- troduced as a fashion in literature and so- ciety by Greeks or Russians. He exagge- rates, perhaps, the share of French influ- ence in all this, but not, we think, to any great extent. Writing soberly and care- fully, he has given us in accessible form an account of the forces that have aided in transforming a barbarous Oriental depen- dency into a small but interesting modern state, proud of its Latin language and the descent it claims from the Romans, and in intellectual as well as political community with the rest of the civilized world. ‘Les Colonies pendant la Révolution,’ by M. Léon Deschamps (Paris: Perrin), is a continuation of his ‘Histoire de la Question Coloniale en France,’ publish- ed in 1891. He now explains the co- lonial policy of the Constituent Assem- bly, telling only enough of the story of the troubles in tke colonies’ to make his explanations clear. This is the first time the subject has been studied ade- quately in the documents themselves. In his introduction, the author has furnished an excellent bibliography of all the sources he has used. The most curious phase of his subject is the long conflict in the legis- lative conscience between “philanthropy and 5 per cent.’’—in other words, between the principles of 1789 and the old colonial sys- tem; particularly, the ambitions, jealousies, and interests to be served by the main- tenance of the privileged position of the planters. It is diverting, as well as in- structive, to observe the shifts to which men like Barnave were put to satisfy these planters, and, at the same time, to show a proper regard for the Declaration of Rights. They solved their problem by de- ciding that such noble principles were not suitable for export to the colonies. Their changing and hesitant attitude upon the status of the mulattoes and free negroes, due largely to the agitations promoted by the Hétel Massiac, was responsible, thinks M. Deschamps, for the worst mischiefs in the West Indies. With this exception he criticises favorably the scheme of control devised by the Constituent, believing it far ahead of any system then in existence. Among the numberless articles on the “Affaire’’ with which the Paris newspapers regale their readers every day of the week, there are not a few which aim at some- thing higher than to satisfy curiosity or to nurture party and race animosity. Such a comparative study of the administration of military justice in the principal states of the Continent, for instance, as recently ap- peared in the Matin, raises the hope that the great harm done by the whole Dreyfus affair may, in the course of time, be in a measure neutralized by profitable lessons. The writer in the Matin shows that in Germany, Austria-Hungary, and Italy mi- litary courts are never exclusively com- posed of soldiers, but always in part of professional jurists of experience and high standing. In France, on the contrary, no such safeguard exists. A little treatise, ‘Die richtige Aussprache des Musterdeutschen,’ by Dr. E. Dannheis- ser (Heidelberg: J. Gross), is to be recom- mended to the many earnest students of German in this country who are striving, often with an excessive scrupulosity, after the best pronunciation. It is brief, simple, and practical, and may be advantageously used by itself or in connection with any German grammar. The Nineteenth Century has an article on the International Council of Women, by the Countess of Aberdeen, and the Fortnightly discusses the same subject by the pens of Gilbert Parker and of Mrs. Sewall. Nature also reports the proceedings of the scien- tific section of the same congress, which was presided over by Mrs. Ayrton, astro- nomy being represented by Mile. Klumpke, head of one of the departments at the Paris Observatory, geology by Miss Raisin of Bed- ford College, chemistry by Miss Dorothy Marshall of Girton College, bacteriology by Mrs. Percy Frankland, and botany and zodlogy by Miss Ethel Sargent. Miss Ayrton, in the course of her interesting and able address, pointed out that there is an im- portant outlet for the work of women at the present time in the manufacture of electrical instruments, the demand for them being so great that manufacturers are not able to cope with it. The various papers contributed are stated to have been worthy both of their subjects and their authors. M. Camille Flammarion contributes to the July number of the Revue des Revues an article apparently called forth by state- ments published in many French and for- eign papers, to the effect that this eminent scientist has retracted what he former- ly published on matters of physical re- search and occultism. He declares such as- sertions to be erroneous, and announces
Page 15
Aug. 10, 1899] The Nation. j 111 that he has nearly ready for publication a work entitled ‘L’Inconnu,’ which will be devoted largely to a scientific analysis of occult phenomena. The article reports a large number of cases which are certainly curicus and, to M. Flammarion, seem suffi- ciently interesting and authentic to deserve serious consideration. | “Night Walk” and Herford’s delicious verses The publisher of the Imperial Free Eco- | nomic Society of St. Petersburg informs his subscribers that the issue for December, 1898, has been hindered by the Government | censor, but will be sent out as soon as the prohibition has been set aside. The word “free” in the name of the society does not seem appropriate. The preparation for the celebration in 1900, on a grand scale, of the five hun- | edi ® of the P Cc SS as an ag dredth anniversary of the birth of Guten- | y ae ee eat of berg, is being energetically pushed by the | authorities at Mainz. The scientific ‘Fest- schrift' will contain contributions on Gut- enberg and the art of printing, from the on the Mole. —In the Atlantic Mr. Riis and Mr. Bur- rougbs are met again, but indoors. The former writes of “The Tenant,”’ and avows his persuasion that the trades-union label and the colonization of the Jew, whether as a farmer or in manufacturing colonies (ex- periments already promisingly initiated in | New Jersey), are to be the sweat-shop’s Strongest antidote. Mr. Burroughs preaches agreeably against preaching in art. Mr. H. D. Sedgwick, jr., rallies his affections and quotations about Macaulay with a zeal which proves that his scorn of Thackeray did not | proceed from the pride of the un-Philistine. Dr. Cunningham writes somewhat half-heart- | disarmament, but hopefully of “changes in political aims and ambitions” as ‘‘doing away with the occasions of international conflict,” | such skeleton texts—misleading enough In their bones—intelligible to them —Prof. Hartmann regards the undertaking as by no means hopeless. The bigoted Mus- lims of the towns wil! bave little to say to it; but the far less bigoted peasants who, under English rule, are leading a quiet and prosperous life and learning things about and from the unbeliever, will be won over much more easily. The Jews, too, and Coptic Christians will accept it. Curiously enough, he thinks that the Bedawi and semi-Beda- wi floating population can be reached with comparative ease. They, as opposed to the Fellahin, are fanatical Muslims, but their religion is not bound up with a written tradition to the extent that holds of the population of the towns. But, for their | use, the alphabet will need to be extended, | and characters added to represent sounds | and calls attention to the dangers arising | from best specialists of Germany and elsewhere, | and will be an international document of permanent value, edited by Prof. Dr. Velke; while a more popular volume, with especial reference to the history of printing in Mainz, is being prepared by Dr. Bockenheimer. Academic festivities, banquets, processions, concerts, public games and plays, and the like, will constitute the chief portion of the public exercises. The Ger- man Emperor and the Duke of Hesse will take part in the exercises. -——The “Midsummer Holiday Number” of the Century appropriately devotes itself to out-of-door interests. Those who stay in cities may follow Jacob Riis and Police Board President Roosevelt on a Feast Day Pilgrim- age through New York’s ‘‘Little Italy.” The lover of wild nature may listen to the birds about Mr. Burroughs’s cabin in the woods, the traveller may drink tea all along the Yangtse-Kiang with Eliza Scidmore, visit the Churches of Auvergne with Mrs. Van Rensselaer as guide, live the life of a no- madic Lapp with Jonas Stadling, or, if desirous of a more stirring vacation, may invade India with Alexander the Great under the leadership of Prof. Wheeler. Well-timed, too, for midsummer use are an account of the Kirksville tornado by Mr. Musick, an eye-and-ear witness; Prof. Abbe’s brief de- liverance on tornadoes, with its appeal for “untouched”’ photographs; short articles on ‘Powerful Electrical Discharges,’’ by Prof. Trowbridge, on “‘The Protection of Electri- cal Apparatus against Lightning,’’ by Alex- ander Wurts, and on ‘“‘Needless Alarm during Thunder-Storms,”’ by Alexander McCabe. An interesting account, by Marion Haskell, of “Negro Spirituals,”’ or religious songs com- posed by negroes, and Paul Leicester Ford's paper on ‘“‘The Many-Sided Franklin,”’ make further agreeable August reading. Most striking, if least agreeable, in the account of Franklin’s diversified thrift is the evidence of his traffic in indentured servants and slaves, through the medium of his newspa- per. Two short papers by Major-Gen. Wood and General Manager Howard furnish ex- perts’ views on administrative and industrial matters in Cuba. Mr. Crawford's novel pro- ceeds at leisurely pace. ‘The Transit of Glo- ria Mundy” is the sincerest of all tributes to Kipling-and-Dooiey, the latest American hybrid. The poetry is of a midsummer cali- bre; the trail of the languid hammock is over “national vanity’ and “irresponsible meddlers,’”’ whether individuals or sections of a community, “who try to jerk the reins of government at a critical period.” | prevention of strife, he concludes, is the key historical | to immunity from concern as to ways of al- laying it; and he points to England as lead- | ing the way by showing “a genuine unwill- ingness to take offence.” Prince Kropotkin’s tenth paper brings him out of prison into England; tells of his connection with the International Workingmen’s Association, of the work of that body, including its division after the war of 1870—a division brought about by the “conflict between the Latin spirit and the German Geist.’’ He shows por- traits of several of his fellow-workers, and a particularly interesting one of Turgeneff. “His Brother’s Brother’ is the late Mr. John Holmes, and T. W. Higginson bestows on the reader a brief glimpse of that rare spirit. —In the March number of the Zeitschrift fiir Assyriologie appears a most interesting paper by Prof. Martin Hartmann of Berlin on the efforts being made to raise the spok- en dialect of Egypt to a written language, and to advocate for its expression the mo- difled Latin alphabet invented by Spitta and used by him in his invaluable ‘Grammatik des Vulgardialectes von Aegypten.’ We have already noticed this movement, which emanates from Florence (The Landi Press), New York, and Cairo, and the present ar- ticle shows with what energy it is being carried on and what chances of success it has. The need is clear. In Egypt, as in all Arabic-speaking countries, there are at least two languages. The one, written after a fashion by educated men and spoken in sermons and on public occasions of weight, attempts to reproduce classical Arabic; the other is the spoken language of the peo- ple, and is beginning to appear in different forms of popular literature—plays, songs, jests, etc. For the first, the Arabic charac- ter is a fairly adequate medium; to the ex- pression of the second, that character, with its lack of vowels and hampering traditions of classical forms, is utterly unequal. Yet the only chance of spreading education in the mass of the people is through the tongue which they speak; and how hopeless it is to attempt that with the Arabic alphabet, will be felt at once by any Arabist who will at- tack one of the modern plays of Othman Gelal so written. European students of old Arabic require to be equipped with elaborate it all if we except Meredith’s fantastic | transliterations and translations to make The | heard only in the desert. This opinion is of the greatest weight, for few Arabists know the local conditions of Egypt and Syria so well as Prof. Hartmann. And his subject has evidently touched him with enthusiasm; he looks for the movement to spread beyond Egypt, and he especially hails it as a‘veri- table deliverance for those non-Arabic- speaking peoples who use the Arabic charac- ter. This last comes close to us; at least it is not so far below our national horizon as it was a year ago. Our wretched complica- tions in the Philippines have brought us face to face with a Muslim population not speaking Arabic, yet using the Arabic script. To deliver them from that would mean almost as much as to deliver them from ourselves. —Harper & Bros. present us, under title of ‘The Letters of Captain Dreyfus to his Wife,’ a translation of the collection which appeared in the French as ‘Lettres d'un Innocent,’ and which Zola solemnly adjured Prime Minister Brisson to read in the com- pany of his wife and children, and then say whether their author was not a martyr. They are undoubtedly moving, and, at this time, their publication cannot but increase the public sympathy for Dreyfus that has now become so strong even in France. Ex- cept as documents in a cause célébre, how- ever, they will not be likely to have any permanent value—they are at too painful and too monotonous. Even as docu- ments they have limitations, as they were written for official scrutiny, and tell little or nothing of the prisoner's life. They are filled with his protestations of innocence, his loyalty to the army and to France that had so foully wronged him, and a continual urging on his wife to clear his honor. Drey- fus’s enemies, of course, say that this is all posing; his partisans, that it is all since- rity, and increases the presumption in his favor. With the latter view we concur. But it is curious to note his frequently ex- pressed belief that there was a real traitor, somewhere, for whom he had been mis- taken, and whose discovery was as essential as his own vindication—whereas, out of all the confused evidence so far published, proof of definite acts of treason be- tween French officers and an enemy country seems alone wanting, while of domestic forgery, plotting, and general scoundrelism there is no end. The Dreyfus case long ago assumed an im- portance in French history so pro- found that the man about whom these pas- sions were raging sank to an abstraction. once
Page 16
ees en A! Xs OMEN OT Pe tea 112 The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1780 This book restores the personal element to the drama; and to the picture it gives of the victim’s tortured spirit should have been added the photograph in Harper’s Weekly of his wasted figure ascending the gangplank of the Sfaz. —Unless we happen to stumble upon Me- zhov’s bibliography with the titles of more than twenty thousand books and articles on Siberia, we hardly think of that country as one which has been much written about. However, with its recent rapid development, and the more frequent visits of western tra- vellers, the available literature on the sub- ject is becoming copious. ‘En Sibérie’ (Paris: Colin), by Jules Legras, is the tale of a journey along the usual route from Eu- rope to the Pacific at Vladivostok, with a few side excursions; but the author, in spite of his modest disclaimer in the pre- face (in spite, too, of a little too much per- sonal narrative), has given us more than the notes of a mere globe-trotter. He was charged with an official mission by the French Government to investigate the co- lonization of the territory he went through, and, although he has reserved the results of his labors for a later, more serious work, the present one contains not a little inte- resting information. The general impression we get from it corresponds with the one we had previously obtained from travel and from books. Siberia is a country with a ra- ther unattractive history and character of its own, but its conditions and population are being rapidly changed beyond recogni- tion by the flocd of newcomers pouring into it, as well as by the opening up of its re- sources. Although it presents many obsta- cles of different sorts, its possibilities of de- velopment seem almost unlimited. As for the central government and local officials, they appear at one moment the indispensa- ble agents of civilization and progress, at another as doing their best to hinder them. Mr. Legras writes with great frankness about what he saw and what, thanks to his knowledge of Russian due to a previous vi- sit in the empire, he heard and understood as well as saw. His opinion of the Siberi- ans is not complimentary; he finds them lazy, selfish, unlovable, and particularly un- truthful. “If I put aside the friends who gave me faithful information, I could count on my fingers the men I have not caught in the act of flagrant deceit. Oh! the offensive and useless flood of lies. They lie behind my back, not suspecting that a mirror is betraying the impostor; they lie when by me, not suspecting that I have an acute sense of hearing and catch asides; they lie in my presence, not suspecting that in my hands are written proofs of their duplicity. They lie with najiveté, with subtlety, or with cynicism, as the case may be; they He with a caress of their eyes and of their hand.” ~—At the opening meeting of the Interna- tional Conference of Hybridization, held under the auspices of the Royal Horticul- tural Society, at. Chiswick, Dr. Maxwell Masters gave an address on the artificial hybridization of plants. This was first prac- tised in the early part of the eighteenth cen- tury by Thomas Fairchild, one of whose de- scendants was present as an American dele- gate. Fairchild produced a cross between a sweet-william and a carnation pink which is still cultivated. Reference was made to the singular prejudice against the practice, hybridists being accused of “contravening the laws of Providence.” This objection was met by Dean Herbert, who, having found in the Pyrenees a narcissus growing be- tween two narcissi of similar character, proved it to be a hybrid. He produced a similar one, and asked why he should be blamed for doing what nature had done. Still, this remarkable prejudice persisted to such an extent that florists, rather than exhibit plants as hybrids, described those raised in their own nurseries as coming from “‘the Cape,’ or elsewhere. Another objection to hybridization on the part of some botanists is that it upsets their ‘“‘sys- tems” and creates confusion as to species and genera. There was a time when “spe- cies’ was considered a sacrosanct thing, but the researches of Darwin and others have changed all that, and no definite line of demarcation between species, genera, or varieties can be drawn. Dr. Masters be- lieves that the experiments of hybridists are not only advancing science, but adding to the welfare of humanity. H. J. Webber of the United States Department of Agri- culture described, at the second meeting, some attempts to produce a hardier variety of orange, that would be less likely than the Florida orange to be cut off by frost. Experiments have been made to produce hybrids between the American orange and the Japanese, which begins to flower just as the blossoms of the cultivated kind are disappearing. It is hoped to produce a va- riety which will be retarded a little in flow- ering, and thus escape the spring frosts. Experiments are also making with the Tangerine orange, to effect a combination of its loose rind with the superior qualities of the American orange. Limes, lemons, and pineapples have been the subjects of experiments in bybridization, and the De- partment is trying to improve cotton by means of hybrids between the upland and the Sea Island kinds. TRAVELS AND POLITICS IN THE NEAR BAST. Travels and Politics in the Near East. By William Miller. Frederick A. Stokes Co. 1899. The affairs of southeastern Europe have had a fascination for Mr. Miller, which found expression in his excellent work, entitled ‘The Balkans,’ in the “Story of the Nations” series, already reviewed in these columns. That complex. of peoples and states whose shifting composition eludes the grasp and dazzles the eye of the observer, has found the closest of students in Mr. Miller, who has habituated himself to regard each feature in this bewildering panorama according to its intrinsic quality, eschewing the time-honored standpoint of the Englishman intent solely on unravelling the mysteries of the Eastern question -with reference to the future pros- pects of Britain. Extensive journeys through the picturesque regions that constitute the mighty Ottoman Empire of old, combined with a vast amount of reading and inter- course with public men of various nation- alities, have familiarized the author in a rare degree with this mosaic of the Near Bast, and, while waiting for the kaleidoscope to make another turn, he has given the public the benefit of his observations in a very charming volume of more than 600 octavo pages. Of the fourteen chapters into which the book is divided, Bosnia (with Herzegovina) and Greece each claim two, and one is allot- ted to each of the following subjects: Istria and Dalmatia, Montenegro, the Sanjak of Novibazar, the Albanian Coast and Corfu, Crete under the “Concert,’’ Samos, Mace- donia, Stambul, Bulgaria, and “The Great Powers in the Near East.”” The kingdoms of Servia and Rumania, it will be seen, are not specifically dealt with in these pages, but the former enters largely into the treatment of political and economic topics, and the lat- ter is naturally not overlooked in the dis- cussion of the Balkan question as a whole. Mr. Miller made four visits to the Balkan countries between 1894 and 1898, in three of which he was accompanied by his wife, and he extended his journeys into Asia Minor. Nothing appears to have escaped the ubiqui- tous range of his observation. He is equally master of his pen, whether depicting the wondrous charms of the Dalmatian coastland, or descanting upon the advantages of new and prospective railway lines, or portraying racial peculiarities. Mr. Miller surveys his chosen domain with an impartial eye, not being an enthusias- tic admirer, as he says in his preface, of any one Balkan race fo the exclu- sion of all others. His pleasure at the release of Bulgaria from the Turkish yoke does not make him blind to the vices which stand in the way of her political advancement, nor does his detestation of the Turk as a ruler prevent him from appre- ciating his virtues as a man. The country whose condition has most favorably impressed our author is Bosnia (or, more properly, Bosnia and Herzegovina), which he styles the “‘model Balkan state.’’ The twenty years of Austro-Hungarian occupation have wrought a complete transformation here. From the position of asemi-mediwval Turkish province, groaning under oppression and rent by re- ligious animosities (the Slavic Bosniaks are among the most zealous of Mussulmans), Bosnia has suddenly emerged into the light of civilization and become a well-ordered, prosperous, and contented country. As an illustration of the rate at which it is being modernized, we need do no more than refer to the statement on page 153, to the effect that the excursion trains running from Sara- yevo to a neighboring pleasure resort have a special van for bicycles alongside of a car reserved for Mussulman women. The descrip- tion which Mr. Miller gives of this lovely borderland between West and East opens up a delightful vista to the tourist in quest of _ virgin soil Boundless praise is lavished upon Baron KaAllay for his efficient adminis- tration of this region, and upon his charming wife, who has so zealously seconded his efforts. Bosnia’s little neighbor, Montenegro, to whom nature seems to have denied every- thing save her rocky fastnesses, is, in Mr. Miller’s eye, a land not without signs of promise. He has faith in her simple and sturdy, though rude, mountain folk, who for five centuries have bidden defiance to the Crescent ranks; and he is above all im- pressed with the sagacity and patriotic vir- tues, not to say shrewdness, of Prince Nicholas, ‘‘even by the admission of his se- verest -critics, the ablest of Balkan sove- reigns.” This “patriarchal autocrat,’ who -‘most emphatically knows on which side his bread is buttered,” and who has seen himself and his little principality sud- denly exalted through the marriage of his
Page 17
Aug. 10, 1899] The Nation. 118 daughter to the future King of Italy, is winning distinguished laurels as a Slav poet. Montenegro is advancing on the path of progress, a hilly road to travel, up which she is being helped by both Russia and Austria. The former extends a kind of godmotherly care over the tiny state, in which her calculating eye fondly sees an advance post of Muscovy on the Adriatic. Much less refreshing than his account of Bosnia and Montenegro is the picture dition of Bulgaria, a country resurrected from a bondage of five hundred years, and bidden by the Powers to move forward with the eyes of the world fastened upon her. This peasant state par eacellence, as the author calls her, has run through a mad course of political evolution since its new machinery was set in motion. Already the theory of public spoils, the clean sweep, railroad jobbery, and all the concomitants of a representative system which has no roots in the past, have become firmly in- trenched, while the methods and expedients of the executive power, as depicted by the unprejudiced pen of Mr. Miller, are worthy | people. | the concluding chapter we read: which Mr. Miller draws of the political con- | cles in the journals while hawking them about in the streets. Mr. Miller’s journeyings in the dominions | of the Sultan have convinced him that the | Turkish government is utterly and hope- lessly rotten. He has nothing to say, in- deed, against the character of the Turkish “The plain Turk of the country districts,” he would have us know, “is hon- est enough; upen that all are agreed.” In “No one can help admiring the devotion of the true Mussulman to his religion, a devotion which puts to shame many Christians. F He points Sut, sometimes with no little justice, that the simple life of the East is better than the degraded existence of many of our great cities.”” But the author finds no words of condemnation too severe for the official class (whose sins, he ad- mits, belongrather to the system than to the man) and the methods pursued by the cen- tral Government. “The secret-service fund amounts to £2,000,000 a year, and from six hundred to seven hundred reports are sent | in by spies to the Sultan every day.” of the Spanish republics of the South. No | wonder that, after inhaling the perfumes of the far-famed rose-gardens of Kazanlik, sixty ounces of whose distilled fragrance sells for a hundred pounds sterling, Mr. Miller cannot help exclaiming, “If only Bul- garia had no politics, that curse of the small Balkan States!”” It is some consola- tion to be told that Prince Ferdinand, that accomplished trimmer, is thoroughly un- popular with his subjects. In Servia, as well as in Bulgaria, parliamentary elections have been “reduced to a farce.” It is a strange irony of history that a people so long held in bondage as the Bul- garians should have such “fantastic no- tions of its own dignity” as our author had occasion to observe. The question of do- mestic servants, he tells us, is “far more In refreshing contrast to the pages de- voted to Turkish maladministration is an account of a visit to Brusa, in Asia Minor, the capital of Sultan Orkhan, in the early | days of the Ottoman Empire, which, ac- | one oasis in this gran diserto, cording to Mr. Miller himself, is at least “an ex- cellent example of what Turkey might be under a wise government.” Speaking of the | approach to this place from the Sea of Marmora, he remarks: be in Southern Europe. “Here you might On either side a rich and fertile land stretches out before | you, a land of wine and olives, cultivated | by a bright and cheerful peasantry, who greet the train as it slowly turns and turns on its way up the hillside.” Brusa, through the energetic foresight of its governor, es- | caped the horrors of the Armenian massa- acute in Bulgaria than even in London.” | “The natives are so independent that it is All thoughtful people whom Mr. Miller met during his stay in that country “agreed in pointing out the danger of over-education for Bulgaria,” the threatened result (the same as in the case of Greece, according to the writer) being “the growth of a class of professional politicians from among the briefless lawyers, hungry doctors, and dis- contented teachers produced by the Bul- garian schools.” With regard to the ame- nities of travel, the “Bulgarian Switzer- land” is anything but a tourists’ paradise. The peasant innkeepers are “honesty it- self,” but they have nothing to offer in the way of food or cleanly comfort. The effect of new political conditions, however, and of the establishment of railroad routes is visible in Sofia and Philippopolis, . which have blossomed out into modern cities. The author was in Greece at the time of the recent war, and the chapters devoted to that kingdom, conceived in perhaps too jour- nalistic a vein, will to many readers prove the most interesting part of the book. He presents us with a pretty picture of the reign of the spoils system at Athens. There is no country in the world, according to Mr. Mil- ler, in which politics have such a fascination cres. Mr. Miller enters into a minute analysis | of the Macedonian question, “perhaps the difficult to engage them to work for wages.” | most dangerous problem which the states- | men of Europe will have to face in the near future.” Servia, Bulgaria, and Greece are each waiting to pounce down upon this re- | gion, which presents a labyrinthine jumble | | of nationalities. There is also a Ru- manian propaganda, based on the presence of a considerable Ruman, or Wallach, ele- ment in the Macedonian population; and any settlement. The idea that a solution might still be found in the rehabilitation of Turkey, a Turkey regenerated by reforms, is dismissed after due consideration as an idle dream. “Of all the futile nostrums,” says our author, “prescribed for the salvation of Turkey, that of ‘reforms’ is the worst."" He sees po unravelment of this tangle until Austria-Hungary and Russia step for ward and cut the Gordian knot. Russia will! not rest until she obtains possession of Con stantinople, and she will have to share the spoils with Austria by allowing her to reach down to Salonica and establish herself on the AZgean. This, the only conceivable solu- tion in the author's eyes, is not put forward as by any means a satisfactory consumma tion, nor does he pretend to see how it is to come about. The inspiring spectacle pre sented by Bosnia and Herzegovina at the present time has completely won Mr. Miller over to Austria-Hungary, but the prospect of Russia established on the Bosphorus, intent awful upon the benevolent assimilation of the neighboring peoples, is to him far from a cheerful one. Not that he is in special dread of Russian power in the Levant-—that fear, he admits, has been mini mized by the hold that England has secured upon Egypt—but, to Mr. Miller, Russia is Russia still, and he doubts (page 507) whe- ther the substitution of Russian for Turkish rule on the Bosphorus would be an advan- tage to the people governed. He does not think that Rumania would help Russia a se- cond time in her march towards Constanti- nople, the Bessarabian steal of 1878 never having been forgiven; and as for Bulgaria, although Prince Ferdinand has thrown him- self into the arms of the Czar, he has not succeeded in making his subjects overcome the avergion which the outrageous intermed- dling of Russia in their affairs has excited Altogether the picture drawn by our author, who is no pessimist, of the political condition and prospects of the Near East not a bright one to contemplate. Mr. Miller is convinced that the Ottoman Empire is doomed, but to say that its down- fall is necessarily close at hand he believes would be a rash assertion. Europe will not plunge lightly into the seething vortex of the Balkan East; and, while the problems of the Far East and of Africa engage the Powers, no one can tell how long the death- agony of the Turk may be prolonged. The is | author hopes fervently that the great state even the Albanians appear to have started a separate organization in the region, a people who have hitherto been “content to remain subjects of a Power which did not interfere with their ‘legitimate’ occupation of cutting each other’s and their neighbors’ throats.” ‘ In the chapter entitled “‘The Great Powers in the Near East,” which is the concluding section of the volume, Mr. Miller discusses in | a vigorous but dispassionate manner the pos- sibilities in the way of a settlement of the affairs of the Balkan Peninsula. He con- fesses that he has been weaned from the be- lief expressed in his recently published his- tory, that a Balkan confederation might be a solution of the great problem that so per- sistently-confronts Europe. His travels and talks haye persuaded him that political rival- | ries and jealousies preclude such a consum- for the common people as fn Greece. The | Athenians are still.the Athenians of old in their eagerness to hear what is going on. The very newsboys devour the political arti- } mation. The Serb has no love for the Bul- garian, the Bulgarian’ has no faith in the Ruman, and Greece is centred on herself. | whose destinies are bound up with those of the Balkan Peninsula may survive the perils that threaten its dissolution. He considers that no greater catastrophe could befall Europe than the dismemberment of the Austro-Hungarian Monarchy. Mr. Miller denounces in unstinted terms the apathy which the English nation has displayed in recent years with respect to the course of events in the Sultan's do- minions and the conditions affecting British trade in those regions. He is not afraid to let the world know that all respect for the British flag in the Levant is at an end. “Orientals,” he says, “despise people who talk and do not act, and the threats of- fered to the Sultan, followed by absolute in- action, have enormously damaged our pres- tige in the Near East.” The supineness of | the British in the matter of their commer clal interests is contrasted with the activity of the Germans, who. appear to be ousting their competitors on every side. Mr. Mil- Albania is a stumbling-block in the way of | ler is shocked, it is true, at the strange
Page 18
prarent °8}e — Sa ere a 114 The Nation. [ Vol. 69, No. 1780 lengths to which Germany is willing to go in her eagerness to gobble up the Turkish market, and he speaks of the Kaiser as “‘a commercial traveller whose journeys are utilized for the propagation of German trade.”’ The volume is profusely illustrated with reproductions of photographs, but we regret to say that they reflect but little credit on the half-tone process. There is a compre- hensive folding map on the generous scale of twenty-five miles to the inch. The reader who does not familiarize himself with the short table of phonetic values in the pre- face and keep the equivalents constantly in mind, will stumble hopelessly over the pro- nunciation of the proper names. Our fa- miliar ‘Maritza,’ for example, figures as ‘“‘Marica.’’ We shall take leave of this valuable book by pointing out a slip on page 365, where the capture of Salonica by Tancred is stated to have occurred seven centuries ago instead of eight. FISHER’S MEDIAZZVAL EMPIRE. The Medieval Empire. By Herbert Fisher. 2 vols. Macmillan Co. 1898. ; Among the many good things in this im- portant work, one of the best is a charac- terization of the discrepancies which ex- isted between the soi-disant Roman Em- pire of the Middle Ages and genuine classi- cal Romanism. Mr. Fisher is not con- tent with recalling, in his first sentence, Voltaire’s celebrated saying that the Empire was well named save in the three respects of being neither Holy, nor Roman, nor an Empire. In his concluding remarks he re- turns to the same idea, except that this time he is regarding the medizwval instead of the eighteenth-century state: “The Saxon king of a rude race of pea- sants is required to conserve and to appre- ciate a conception of government moulded by the genius of the Latin races in a climate of Roman law and Roman religion, and sa- turated with the spirit of Roman autocracy, that last and most refined distillation of the aristocratic pride of a great city. A bar- barian, living in a condition of affable equal- ity with his fellow-tribesmen, is asked to posture as the descendant of Augustus, the masterful and subtle, as the coequal of those Greek rulers for whose elaborate court Constantine Porphyrogenitus wrote his massive and curious book upon ceremo- nies. Yet the difference between the courts of Constantinople and Tribur was as great as that between the court of Versailles, as it was known to the Duc de Luynes, and the Highland home of Fergus M’Ivor, as Sir Walter Scott describes it in ‘Waverley’; and the idea of the Roman Empire as it was printed upon the Saxon brain of the tenth century, no more reflects the ancient classica! conception than the Venus of Bot- ticelli in the Uffizi Gallery renders the spirit of ancient Hellenic art.” Hventually the Hohenstauffen emperors grasped the autocratic, imperial idea, but that was only after Romanism, in an eccle- siastical solution, had been filtered through medimwval society for centuries, after legal studies had revived at Bologna, and after a close connection between Germany and Italy had been established, Apart from an opening chapter on the “Survival of the Imperial Idea,’’ Mr. Fish- er’s essay deals with the period between Otto I. and Frederick Il, Had he entered at large upon the subject of Charlemagne’s empire, it is possible that he would have found something truly Roman in the impe- rial progresses and in the institution of missi dominici. But beginning, as he really does, with the rise of Saxon power and the restoration of 962, he must perforce deal with pure Teutonism masquerading in a Roman domino, until he reaches those sov- ereigns who cared more for Italian politics than they did for the broils of their own “yellow Germany.’’ Altogether, the great- er part of these two volumes is devoted to German affairs, though in the last 150 pages the Italian element is duly accentuated. Coming rather more to detail, we can best indicate the scope of Mr. Fisher’s treatise by comparing it with Bryce’s ‘Holy Roman Empire,’ because the latter book now holds the field in English, and is thoroughly well known to all historical students. In purpose there is not nearly so much conflict between the two as one might suppose from merely glancing at Mr. Fisher’s title. Being very evidently a man of sense, the later histo- rian recognizes that nothing is to be gained by writing, after Bryce, a general sketch of the imperial theory and its results. He fills in for a single, clearly defined era (and that the distinctively medisval one), the outlines which Bryce has rapidly but firmly traced. To secure clearness he treats Ger- many and Italy separately, considering Ger- many in its imperial aspects first. Here he begins by examining the state of the coun- try at the outset of the tenth century, and then, excluding Lotharingia and Burgundy, proceeds to “the problem created by the affinities and antagonisms of the four German races, with a view to discovering how far these an- tagonisms and affinities tended to obstruct and further the imperial mission. It then seemed best to consider the resources and work of the empire in Germany, its influ- ence on law, on administration, on consti- tutional and financial growth; and, in or- der to exhibit its work in proper propor- tions, and to throw additional light upon the causes of its downfall, chapters are add- ed upon the German nobility, upon the ex- pansion of Germany, and upon the German Church.”’ Reaching in his second part Italian af- fairs, Mr. Fisher dwells chiefly upon im- perial legislation and administration, upon “the relations of the emperors with the city of Rome,” and upon ‘‘the reciprocal influence of German and Italian culture.” In this brief epitome we have enumerated almost every leading topic which he pre- sents, for each chapter is a special, self- contained study, and might have been print- ed in the English Historical Review with- out creating in one’s mind a sense of in- completeness. Yet while each is a sepa- rate essay, the union of parts is so skil- fully effected that a reader of the whole work need not complain of abruptness in transition. At only two points does Mr. Fisher invade Bryce’s frontier, namely, in his opening chapter on the imperial idea, and in his chapter on the city of Rome. Nor can he be said ever to echo his dis- tinguished predecessor. The praise which is due independent research, independent reflection, and strong writing, can and must be freely accorded to Mr. Fisher. It may seem that we make a purely ar- bitrary division when we set the chapters of this work which relate to Germany over against those which relate to Italy. If we do so it is because the former portion Is, in- our judgment, the better of the two. In so far as he is indebted to modern au- thors—and. his acknowledgments are ge- nerous—Mr. Fisher depends largely upon Germans even where his subjects are Ita- lian. There can be, of course, no possible objection to this procedure when a just balance is preserved between original sources and recent literature. We have gathered, perhaps too hastily, that Mr. Fisher’s familiarity with German Quellen is greater than with Italian. That he should use Ficker’s ‘Forschungen’ for his account of Italian administration, Grego- rovius for his chapter on Rome, and Gas- pary for his notice of early Italian lite- rature, is no more surprising than that he should rely on Schréder and Stobbe for Ger- man law, on Reizler for Bavaria, and on Giesebrecht for the mediwval empire at large. But our impression is incorrect if he has not devoted more attention to Pertz’s M. G. H. et al. than to Muratori’s R. I. 8. et al. Whereas at times we have felt a passage in the Italian division to be comparatively thin, we have found Mr. Fish- er’s disquisition on German subjects at once solid and mature. Among German topics, those which have been approached most seriously are impe- rial legislation, the imperial court, and im- perial finance. It is not too much to infer from an allusion at the end of the intro- duction that Maitland’s stimulating writ- ings directed Mr. Fisher’s' attention towards problems of mediwval law and administration. Wherever the influence of that great scholar takes root, it speedily becomes fruitful of thoroughness and of new ideas. We cannot better indicate the character of the three chapters named above, than by saying that they are worthy products of the Maitland school, or, in other words, that they are accurate and sugges- tive. A clear instance of the Cambridge professor’s influence is furnished by Mr. Fisher’s study of the law of inheritance as associated with the imperial court. We make no hint of undue subservience. The influence exercised is of that kind which an unusual scholar and thinker must always have over the most independent minds. Such subjects as legislation and finance do not admit of picturesque or animated treatment, but the theme with which the first volume closes, viz., ‘“‘The Empire and German Nobility,” does. Here Mr. Fish- er introduces several graphic touches, and indicts the medieval proceres in severe though justly deserved terms. The ano- nymous biographer of the Emperor Henry IV., in an epigram worthy of Tacitus, thus satirizes the freebooting barons whom a state of enforced peace had brought to penury: “Mira res, nec minus. ridicula; alii injurias suas injuriis vindicant, im- perator suas pace vindicabat.” It may well be doubted whether this particular Em- peror maintained the public security thus perfectly, but beyond question what the medieval noble of Germany most loathed was the strong hand which did justice and preserved order. Von Raumer’s valiant and disinterested princes are for the most part figments of a fanciful or patriotic im- agination, while Mr, Fisher’s charges of scandalous selfishness are alike clear and damaging. “The German nobility possessed a perfect genius for disobedience and treachery. They would ally themselves with Bohemians and Slavs, with Danes and Italians, as it might serve their turn. Restrained by no con- siderations of patriotism, softened by no tincture of culture, swayed by rudimentary passions, simple, violent, and gross, they would neglect all the higher calls of citi-
Page 19
Aug. 10, 1899] The Nation. 115 zenship to serve their greedy ends. Only occasionally a great cause swayed them, and, fired with the pride of race or bowed to the mastery of a gorgeous dream, they spent their lives nobly in the arid highlands of Asia Minor, or in the maiarious paradise | of Italy, yet the thickest strand of their existence was woven with cruelty, and per- | fidy, and vice; and when the mailed heroes of Germany rode off to the Crusade, the monk and the peasant breathed a sigh of relief, and tranquillity returned to the land.”’ We have a small list of errors to bring against Mr. Fisher, although in reading his pages we have observed few serious mis- statements of fact. letter of Stephen to Charles Martel in 752” appears, “letters suth as Stephen III. wrote to Charles Martel.’’ Doubtless in both these cases Pippin was intended for Charles Martel. Vol. i., p. 35, and again on p. 51, the date 842 is assigned to the Treaty of Verdun, on what authority we cannot imagine, for it seems very decisive- ly settled that the Strassburg Oaths were sworn in 842 and the great partition of territory arranged in 843. Vol. i., p. 70: here once more a chronological slip ap- pears, in the case of a Merovingian sove- reign—‘The Frankish king Chlotaire III. (620-660).”” On pp. 101-2, vol. i., occurs a somewhat amusing error. “It might have been expected that the royal hold over Saxony would be relaxed as soon as a non- Saxon dynasty came to the throne. But it must be remembered that Conrad the Se- cond, the first king of the Franconian house, was the great-grandson of the daughter of Otto the Third, and that he, like his predecessor, confirmed the Saxon law upon his accession.’’ Vol. i., p. 136: a double mistake occurs in the account of the imperial election which took place on the death of Henry V.—‘‘The Franconians murmured at the appointment of a Saxon, and attempted to substitute Conrad, the cousin of the late Emperor.”’ Probably Mr. Fisher, when writing thus, had Frederick of Swabia in mind, not his younger brother, the future Emperor Conrad III.; but both of these important persons were sons of Agnes, the sister of Henry V. A few lines further on, the date of Conrad III.’s ac- cession is given 1139 instead of 1138, con- trary to the date correctly assigned in the chronological table of popes and emperors which is placed at the end of the first vol- ume. A further instance of discrepancy between text and table is furnished on the same page, 1126 appearing in the text and 1125 in the table for the death of Henry V. Vol. ii., p. 127: “Gregory the Great deposed an emperor, and struck hard at the two most ingrained abuses of German clerical life, simony and marriage.’’ The title in question is applied to Gregory I., not to Gregory VII. Vol. ii., p. 255: The line “Ahi serva Italia, di dolore ostello,"’ and the two lines immediately following it, are no part of “Sordello’s cry to Dante,” but an interjection of the poet’s own, as may be seen from the succeeding tercet: “Quell’ anima gentil fu cos! presta,’’ etc. Vol, ii., p. 269: cates for itself some legendary connection with the ancient world. Padua shows the tomb of Antinor, Milan the statue of Her- cules, Fiesole looks back to Catiline.”” The case of Catiline and Fiesole rests on quite a different basis from the other two cited. Finally, we quote a passage, vol. li., p. 271, “Not a city but fabri- | | which seems to us quite singular. By way of illustrating the bitterness of the thir- teenth-century sirvente, Mr. Fisher makes an extremely apt reference: **Barons of Lombardy and Rome and Apulia, And Tuscans and Romagnese and men of the March, Florence the flower which renews itself, Call you to her court. For she wishes to make herself Tuscans Now that she has conquered the Germans and the Siennese by force."’ Mr. King of the “So,” Fisher comments, ‘“‘sung Guit- | tone d’Arezzo after the Florentine victory | at Monteaperto in 1260, with all his rough Vol. i., p. 24, “the first | vigor.” Waiving the point that Mr. Fish- ; ‘ , ; ving er’s spelling of the battle is not one which s spoken of, and again on p. e phrase Dante approves (vide Inf. xxxii., 81, ed. Witte), his reference to the ‘Florentine victory’ removes the sting from the sirvente, leaving his quotation flat as de- canted Apollinaris. This is not an ordinary slip, and we find difficulty in imagining how it crept into the text. It is a reviewer's duty to register the errors which he observes, otherwise we should not have mentioned these, for Mr. Fisher’s erudition and ability have im- pressed themselves upon us much more strongly than shortcomings of any kind whatever. Were this ‘‘a product of Ame- rican scholarship’’ we could avow the fact proudly, nor should less grudging praise be accorded a work which shows the present vigor of historical studies at Oxford. The Break-up of China. By Lord Charles Beresford. Harper & Brothers. Ever since 1860, when a few thousand Eng- lish and French troops exposed the military helplessness of China, but more particularly since 1894, when Japan annihilated the only real soldiers China had, the Middle King- dom has given strong evidences of approach- ing dissolution. The signs multiply hourly that the ‘‘boneless giant’’ is more of a car- cass than a body capable of self-protection. The eagles are flying from every land, and the symptoms found within, or the signs ema- nating from, the subject are all those of the moribund. Rebellions and disorders, an empty treasury,and approaching bankruptcy; utter lack of menta] initiative on the part of China’s statesmen, who cannot see what is coming; the concessions, loans, leases, and gifts of land under pressure of war-ships and armies; the fastening upon the national vitals by aliens who claim the land on which they have settled as virtual portions of distant sovereignties in Europe; the inabili- ty to purge out internal morbidness, or to shake off blood-sucking parasites, are all proofs of the hopelessness of the recovery of “the sick man in the Far East.’’ China, at least the China hitherto known to history, has apparently run her race. Yet Lord Charles Beresford, whom we all re- member as the dashing naval commander at Alexandria, and who has seen Egypt be- come a virtual British dependency, did not go to China to be in at the death. Indeed, between title and text of his book there is paradox, if not contradiction. He be- lieves, or professes to believe, that China can be saved and kept a unit. He went out as a representative of the Associated Cham- bers of Commerce of Great Britain, in an entirely unofficial character, to learn the actual situation in China. He arrived at Hong Kong September 30, 1898, and remain- ed in China until January 9 of this pre- sent year, visiting every place where British communities reside. He convened meetings and discussed the whole situation, asking and answering questions. He interviewed the leading magistrates, seeing six out of the eight viceroys of the great provinces. He entered the precincts of the Tsung-li- Yamen, where he sat at the table with a body of men who are probably the most profoundly erudite, and the most densely ignorant, of all the so-called statesmen in the world. With the exception of three military mobs termed “‘armies,"’ he inspect- ed the armed forces of China, and himself put the troops through various movements. He visited every fort and arsenal with one exception, all the naval and military schools, the ships of both Chinese fleets, and the one dock-yard which China possesses. On his way home he passed leisurely through Japan and the United States, to which he devotes some chapters. Between the Bri- tish merchant who says “Speak out,” and the British financier who says “Speak gently,” Lord Beresford has uttered the truth as he believed it, frankly and with- out reserve. From the first to the last page, he urges that the policy of Great Britain should be that of the “open door." He contends vigorously always against the so-called “‘spheres of influence.”’ Lord Beresford’s report makes a book of nearly five hundred pages of thick paper, with large print. He does not conceal his meaning and desire for an Anglo-American alliance. In the bright and gay stamp, upon the yellow binding, of the Stars and Stripes and the Union Jack, these two emblems stand staff to staff, with the yellow flag of China beneath, on which a four-legged, five-toed, red-bellied dragon is trying to swallow a red sun. Whether that sun-ball will be most easily digested if marked ‘‘open door,” or “spheres of influence,”’ remains to be seen, for China’s dragon at present seems to be blind. Besides a voluminous appendix of reports of the various meetings in China, an index, and two portraits of the author, there are two maps, one showing the water- ways and trade routes of China, and the other the proposed or completed railways, the location of beds of iron, coal, and mine- rals, with tables of the area and popula- tion of the provinces. 3 The report is in the brisk, straightforward language of a sailor and man of affairs. In his power to make commercial, trade, and statistical matters interesting, the author reminds us of Mr. Gladstone. The abundant information given is of the first order of value to one who would know the actual China of to-day. British commerce, once the only occupant of the field, has now to face competition and adverse political influences, yet sixty-four per cent. of the foreign trade of China still remains under the British flag. The merchants, as individuals and as- sociated in Chambers of Commerce, were 4 unit in urging that the “open-door’’ policy ought to be maintained, and that it was the only one that would save the integrity of the Empire. On the other hand, when the author tells us about the Chinese and their rulers, and gives the results of his inqui- ries and inspections, we have a most piti- ful and monotonous -story of corruption, weakness, wastefulness, and inability to know the real needs of the nation, to read the signs of the times, or to understand the dangers, both internal and external. There is an apparent paralysis of the power of initiative. All foreigners agree with the author that China’s first requisite is a good
Page 20
ye anes Rinse Roa eee ee : e 116 The Nation. [ Vol. 69, No. 1780 police system for maintaining domestic tran- quillity. Then must follow a reorganization of the military and naval forces to protect the country from foreign enemies. To show the difference between Japan, which, as to proportions of population and area of domain, is as a pigmy, but which in unity of purpose is an athlete, and China, which, though a giant, is a helpless hulk, Japan, with a population of 42,000,000, had a foreign trade last year of $444,000,000, while China’s foreign trade was only $495,000,000. Yet the Chinese mandarins are still drawing large sums from the treasury to feed, clothe, and equip “armies” which are chiefly on paper, being in actual existence little more than skeletons. For dress parade and in- spection, coolies are hired by the day to fill up the ranks. In the arsenals, equipped with costly machinery, the mandarins will have their way. They manufacture jingals in- stead of artillery of the latest model. The infantry are armed with rifles of a dozen different patterns. The use of bows and ar- rows is not only still warmly commended, but is in actual practice by soldiers who are expected to fight men with rifles that can kill at two thousand yards. In a word, it seems almost impossible for the average mandarin to rise out of the ruts of a thou- sand years. While Lord Beresford intelligently urges the open-door policy—on which Lord Salis- bury seems to have turned his back since the book was put in type—as the cure for the old Empire’s troubles, he does not tell us how the Chinese character is to be made over or the tide of corruption stemmed. Who, or what, is to open the eyes of the Chinese, or give them moral stimulus or the power of mental initiative? We need a book that will satisfactorily answer that question. This, certainly, is the fact, that in Japan the man of letters was also a sol- dier. Furthermore, while the central idea in Chinese ethics is filial piety, that of the Japanese is loyalty. The Japanese are more than a race, they form a nation. That the Chinese do is more than doubtful. It is possible for China to become self-re- formed, but with only her ethical syster, from which the tap-root of aspiration was cut ages ago, it is hard to see how her regeneration can come, either under the “open-door” or the “spheres of influence.” Something more than politics must save her. The Great Lord Burghley: A Study in Bliza- bethan Statecraft. By Martin A. 8S. Hume. Longmans, Green & Co. 1898. The present Bishop of Oxford says jocu- larly, in the preface to a volume of col- lected addresses, that he cannot imagine why he is printing them unless it may be because he has grown addicted to the read- ing of proof-sheets. Major Hume, too, must have had his share of revising proofs during the past three years, for in that time he has published five or six historical books. These we have welcomed with real pleasure, both for their mastery of Elizabethan and Spa- nish subjects and for the liveliness with which they are written. Nor would we bint that their author is now producing litera- ture at too fast a pace. If we mention his prolific energy here, it is for the sake of drawing a comparison between the present biography and his other numerous works. We should probably go beyond the mark were we to call Burghley one of Major Hume’s heroes, but he holds the Eliza- bethan statesman in marked respect, and devotes to him the most elaborate study which, so far as we have seen, has yet is- sued from his pen. One cannot deal with Burghley on a small scale. The materials which he left his bio- graphers are enormous, and if Nares erred on the one side in producing a series of quartos which weighs sixty pounds, the shortcomings of the epitomist are almost equally glaring, though they may not be so ludicrous. According to the scale of mo- dern memoirs—e. g., Lord Selborne’s auto- biography—the 500 octavo pages of Major Hume are indeed but a moderate book. For one surrounded as he has long been by the ample records of Burghley's time, verbal restraint must be difficult, even with a fresh remembrance of Macaulay's satire against the Brobdingnagian propensities of Dr. Nares. Considering that among the Lansdowne MSS. at the British Museum there are 122 folio volumes of Burghley’s papers, and that Lord Salisbury’s collection at Hatfield comprises 30,000 documents, any sketch of the man’s career which can be contained in one volume is reasonably compact. Just as a life of Sir Robert Peel means interminable Hansard, a life of Lord Burghley means interminable dis- patches. The clearness which is characteristic of Major Hume’s literary style is also no- ticeable in what he says concerning his attitude towards Burghley. He regards Elizabeth’s Lord Treasurer neither as a “demigod,” nor as a statesman of the high- est class, nor as a high ethical example. He even professes that our modern moral standards are out of place in judging the acts of Tudor politicians. It was during Burghley’s age that the majority of the English nation “cheerfully changed their faith four times in a generation to please their rulers,” and therefore it would be “absurd to hold up to especial obloquy a rainister for having persecuted at one time a religion which at another time he pro- fessed. The final triumph of England in that struggle of giants was won by states- men who, like their mistress, owed as much to what we should now call their fail- ings as they did to their virtues. Their. vacillation and tergiversation in the face of rigid and stolid opponents were main elements of their success. Cecil was by far the most honest and patriotic of them, but he, too, was a man of his age, and must be judged from its standpoint—not from that of to-day.” For purposes of this review, the domestic relations and even the social qualities of Burghley are largely negligible, but apropos of the vast wealth which he accumulated and of his other canny traits, we must cite Mr. Hume’s estimate of his egotism when viewed side by side with his public duty. It is, that country came before family. ‘The first cause he served was that of the State, the second was William Cecil and his house. Through a long life of ceaseless toil and rigid self-con- trol, these were the mainsprings of his activi- ty and devotion.” Moreover, we should em- phasize the sense of personal dignity which, at a time of almost universal pilfering and blackmail, kept him above suspicion of brib- of public questions, he showed the disinte- rested temper of a jurist, and under other circumstances he might readily have deve- loped into a great judge. As a royal councillor, Major Hume consi- ders that Burghley checked much of Bliza- beth’s flightiness and created in her mind a salutary confidence. ‘When passion or per- suasion led her into a dangerous course, as they frequently did, she knew that Cecil, sa- gacious, and steady as a rock, would advise her honestly.” At the outset he had become a member of the advanced Protestant party surrounding Somerset, and though only by wariness he escaped his first patron’s fall, and was often forced in later days to trim his sails, he clung to Protestantism for what it meant politically. On the other hand he dreaded France, however governed—even by the Béarnais—and inclined towards a Spanish connection whenever the religious issues which were respectively typified by the Eng- lish and Spanish governments could be forced into the background. Historically, Burghley’s attitude towards France and Spain is very interesting, for it was not merely a personal fancy, or a pre- judice which he had derived from his sur- roundings. He had inherited it as a tradition of statecraft from the early years of the fif- teenth century, when England and Burgundy were arrayed against France and Scotland. Burgundy and Spain becoming connected by marriage, the latter assumed in Burghley’s eyes the place of recognized ally. The ran- cor of Philip II. against Protestantism, and. his position at the head of Roman Catholic Powers, made him a difficult person to nego- tiate with, but Burghley was always looking in the direction of a rapprochement. Just as Richelieu in the next generation sided with the Protestant princes of Germany while put- ting down the Huguenots at home, so the English statesman would by preference have sided with Spain against France while re- pressing Romanist activity in his own island. Major Hume quotes a saying of De Beau- mont, the French Ambassador in 1598, that Burghley still heads ‘all the old councillors of the Queen who have true English hearts; that is to say, who are enemies of the welfare and repose of France.” As usual, we have only words of commen- dation for Major Hume’s sound learning and entertaining style. We must, however, con- fess to some amusement at a passage in which he strikes a balance between divine and human elements of control in ‘mundane affairs: ‘“‘How England should emerge from the welter of the old tides and the new, de- pended to some extent upon providential cir- cumstances, but more largely still upon the personal characteristics of those who guided her national policy and that of her competi- tors.”” But this graceful concession to Pro- vidence*of a recognized though subordinate réle.opens up questions which it is no part of our function to discuss here. The Real Hawaii. By Lucien Young. Dou- bleday & McClure Co. 1899. The Making of Hawaii. By William Fre- mont Blackman. Macmillan. 1899. Hawati Nei. By Mabel Clare Craft. San Francisco: William Doxey. 1899. Perhaps the most innocent way of ex- ploiting our conquests is to write books about them. Even if the books contain much that is untrue, no great harm is done, for the fate of the countries is settled; while there is a faint hope that if the truth concerning them becomes generally known, their condition may be ameliorated. Doubt- less the American public has grown a little Aired of Hawaji, having had the affairs of
Page 21
Aug. 10, 1899] that region thrust upon its attention for some years; but as these affairs remain unsettled, we must still welcome informa- | tion, and the three books before us furnish a good deal of it. Each has its purpose— | one to prove that the revolution was justi- fied, one that present conditions are the result of evolution, and one to arouse pity for the fate of the race that once possessed the islands. historical matter of sufficient authenticity, | and many descriptions of persons and places and travels and customs. Mr. Young is more elaborate, Mr. Blackman more philosophi- cal, Miss Craft more imaginative; but all have written well. Mr. Young, who is an officer in our navy, participated in the original revolution, and defends it with much show of righteous in- dignation. His reasons are the wickedness of the Hawaiian people and their rulers, the practical ownership of the islands by foreigners, the diabolical designs of Great Britain, and the strategical advantages of the post. He tells us that while England maintains a seeming friendship towards the United States, “it is a moral certainty that the near future will draw Great Britain and the countries of Europe, by mutuality of interest, into an antagonism to the Unit- ed States.”” Great Britain is preparing to treat us “as her greatest foe.’’ She has drawn a chain of hostile ports around us, and the only missing link is Hawaii. Hence Hawaii “is second in importance to no other single point on the earth’s surface.” Its importance “is no more a matter of opinion than is a geometrical axiom. It is a primal, incontrovertible fact.’’ This wis- dom has of course not been hidden from the Britishers, and their insidious schemes are fully exposed by Lieut. Young. It is plain enough that if we look through his glasses, our country was not safe until the Ameri- can flag was hoisted over the Government offices in Honolulu. Prof. Blackman’s work is a study of so- cial, political, and moral development, or, we might say, decadence. The natives have been, after a fashion, Christianized, and after a like fashion civilized. The result is that most of them are dead and the rest are dying. They are almost universally licentious and diseased. Their place has been taken by a mongrel population, and the hope of the region lies, according to this writer, in the immigration of Teutons, who shall eventually find the tropics as favorable for their de elopment as the tem- perate zones. Meanwhile Hawaii is ruled by a slaveholding aristocracy, who fatten on the products of Asiatic bondmen. It is vain to deny that slavery has been re- established under the American flag, al- though probably in a mild form. Whether the relations between masters and contract laborers are better than between our plant- ers and their slaves, is an unsettled ques- tion. Prof. Blackman takes a hopeful view of the situation, but the evidence that he presents hardly supports it. At all events, his account of the islands and their people is remarkably free from bias and is marked by sobriety of statement. Miss Craft’s contribution is in some re- spects more superficial than the others, her book being made up largely of letters written to American journals at the time of the revolution. Nevertheless, she has the insight that comes from living on inti- mate terms with the natives, and it is »too feeble to resist. All, however, include much | The Nation. ! impossible not to share her sympathy with | the western part of Long Island only after | them. They mourn the extinction of their | own government, but they are not of the stuff of which rebels are made. They have Craft, whose arraignment of the missionary rulers is severe, but they are too few and A large part of her | book is devoted to description of a some- what flowery, and occasionally poetical, character—not bad of its kind. Altogether, | by a perusal of these three books one may much to complain of, according to Miss | ' a war, gained validity in its eastern part by the force of events at an earlier date The little village, when only two years old, was drawn into the dispute through a claim made by the agent of Lord Stirling, under a grant from the Plymouth The agent, proclaiming himself Governor of Long Company ' Island, was promptly disposed of by Stuyve- |; sant, who sent him as a prisoner to plead | his case in Holland. | feel that he has a sufficient knowledge of | the conditions, past and present, which the history of the Hawaiian Islands has been and will be shaped. The Social History of Flatbush. By Gertrude Lefferts Vanderbilt. D. Appleton & Co. 1899. History of the Town of Flushing. By Henry D. Waller. Flushing: T. H. Ridenour. 1899. From the heights of Prospect Park in Brooklyn one looks down on the hamlet of to the ocean, and so hidden among embow- ering trees and shrubs that its pretty ancient name, Midwood, seems more fitting than its modern one—a corruption of two Dutch words, signifying level and forest. Midwood was one of the five little groups of farms clustered about the western point of Long Island, settled by colonists from Holland, who followed in the track of Hendrik Hud- son, and chose for their home the fertile soil of Seawanhaka, opposite the Island of Man- hattan. among the waves to seek new homes to be hewn out of the heart of a forest wilderness. Under the government and authority of the States-General, they bought their lands in fair bargain from peaceable Indian neigh- bors, and devoted themselves to diligent agriculture; the palisadoes required by law to be built around their houses kzing needed more for protection against small wild beasts than against savages. These five towns re- mained intensely Dutch, little disturbed by the streams of alien immigration mingling with the ancient stock which flowed so co- piously among their neighbors of Manhat- tan. The author of the ‘Social History’ finds | little to record in the short and simple an- nals of Flatbush except the tranquil progress of a pure domestic life, carefully nurtured by religion and common-school education. She draws with filial tenderness the picture of thrift and probity, and collects with faith- ful and minute detail such descriptions of the ways and lives of the inhabitants, their architecture, implements, dress, and cus- toms, as compose a veritable museum of relics, reviving the memory of a civilization only two centuries old, yet ancient to us of this day. About a score of miles eastward from Mid- wood, the town of Flushing, originally Vlis- singen, was established on the north shore of Long Island in 1645, under a patent granted by Gov. Kieft of New Netherlands. In its position, its original settlement, and its varied history, Flushing presents a strong contrast to its quieter neighbor. Though the source of its title and the form of its government were derived from Holland, not a Dutch name is to be found among the crigi- nal patentees, who were all English. The claim of English dominion, established over Descendants of sailors and soldiers, | they left the turmoil of a struggle for life | under | The town was involved, too, in the quarrel between Connecticut and New Amsterdam over the boundary which had been settled in 1650 by an agreement, called the Hartford Treaty, which Holland ratified, though the English disregarded it continuing their encroachments both on the | mainland and among the Long Island towns Flatbush, placed on a plain sloping gently | Some of these even petitioned the Hartford colony to cast over them the “Scurts of your government and protecktion.” For a time, however, the quarrelling provinces agreed to exercise no authority over the Long Isi- and towns, leaving them in an anomalous state of quasi-independence. They formed themselves into a “Combination” under the guidance of one Capt. Scott, an English adventurer. Both provinces soon set upon this unlucky chief, who was banished, and a sort of peace continued until the Dutch rule came to an end. Among so sturdy and restless a community as that of Flushing, of course religious dis- turbances were likely to be as rife as poli- tical troubles were. Their first settled min- ister of the Gospel was Francis Doughty, the true type of an ecclesiastical adventurer, an Episcopalian silenced as a Nonconform- ist, who emigrated to Taunton, preached the heretical doctrine that Abraham’s children ought to have been baptized, and was banished from Rhode Island. Thence he came, for liberty of conscience’ sake, to Newtown, where he attempted to set himself up as a patroon, and was at last forced by Stuyvesant on the reluctant inhabitants of Fiushing, | among whom he remained till his church was | closed for seditious preaching against the authorities, and he himself took refuge in Virginia. The most interesting chapter in the reli- gious history of Flushing is that which re- lates to the Quakers, who came first to the town in 1657. They were regarded by Stuy- vesant as ‘‘a heretical and abominable sect,” and severe puuvishment was inflicted on all who harbored them. This persecution called forth from the leading inhabitants a vigorous and noble remonstrance, followed by the ar- rest and imprisonment of many of its sign- ers. Ultimately, the subject came under the cognizance of the Directors in Holland, who administered to Governor Stuyvesant that stern rebuke, famous in history, which ended for ever this single attempt at persecution known to New Amsterdam. It should be remem- bered, to the honor of this peculiar people, that they were the first among the colonists to confess the iniquity of slavery. The sub- ject, first discussed at the annual meeting of Friends at Philadelphia in 1693, was con- sidered at many of the meetings of the Flush- ing Quakers. An address published by one of their number, William Burling, in 1718, is one of the first productions of anti-slavery literature in this country. Mr. Waller's volume is an unpretentious compilation of historic facts, without any attempt at teaching philosophy by example, and is enlivened by curious anecdotes and biographical sketches of several men of note
Page 22
a : i | 4 i : 118 The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1780 given by Flushing to the service of the State and nation, both before and since the Revo- lution. Attention is irresistibly drawn to the contrast between the annals of the Hollanders in New York and those of their kindred, the Boers, who emigrated under like auspices and about the same period to the wilds of Afri- ca. Yielding to the course of events, the Dutch in this hemisphere blended insensibly with the conquering race, lending to the union their own peculiar virtues and quali- ties. The African colonists from the first resisted and to this day resist the spirit of the age. Agriculturists always, they were compelled by their position between savage enemies and civilized aggressors to become also hunters and warriors. Driven ceaseless- ly backward by the rising tides of commerce and conquest, they were forced by the Eng- lish first westward from Cape Colony into Griqualand, thence, after stern resistance, into the region watered by the Orange River; and, at last, with obstinate resolution taking up another exodus, they trekked their long and painful way, with flocks and fami- lies, towards the heart of the continent, across the River Vaal. In the midst of this haven of rest a new danger suddenly arose, The discovery of gold inundated their chosen home with floods of alien and unquiet adven- turers. True to the spirit of the age, these demand a share in the government, which would speedily grow into its control. The Boers, firm and stubborn as ever, persist in being an anachronism and an anomaly among the peoples of the earth. They stand at bay. Through Nature to God. By John Fiske. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co. 1899. To watchers of the tides and currents of thought, just now setting decidedly against rationalism, the later turn of Mr. Fiske’s philosophy is an interesting phenomenon, and none the less so where his argument seems insufficient. The present little vol- ume, continuing the line of thought of the ‘Idea of God,’ has three disconnected parts, entitled, ‘The Mystery of Evil,’ “The Cos- mic Roots of Love and Self-Sacrifice,” and “The Everlasting Reality of Religion.” Mr. Fiske’s solution of the problem of evil is the familiar one, that evil is only relative, and that it is absurd to suppose good to exist without a correlative and reacting evil. Hardly more than a hint is afforded of how this thought is to be followed out, although it was developed at large more than a generation ago in James’s ‘Sub- stance and Shadow.’ In the second part, the author endeavors to show that “the cosmic process exists purely for the sake of moral ends’’—quite too serious a proposi- tion for so light a book. He has much to say of the prolonged infancy of man; but he does not attempt to refute the alleged facts that have again recently been put forth and tabulated, to show that the dura- tion of man’s infancy is related to the length of his natural life in the same way as that of all other mammals, We re- mark, too, the lack of any clear distinction between cerebral evolution taking place strictly by natural selection (the more cun- ning and, to some extent, the more good- natured individuals averaging in the long run the larger families) and intellectual development under the influence of tradi- tion, which variations at birth can influence only so far as those individuals who are congenitally suited to accepting establish- ed customs, are likely to produce more nu- merous progeny than those who are con- genitally ill adapted to the traditional ideals. If a “cause,” in the sense of an active body of sentiments, can be damaged by an argumentative defence that seems at first sound, but is sure at last to be found worthless, then-it may be doubted whether the third part of Mr. Fiske’s book is likely to do religion more good or more harm. The nature of his .reasoning is sufficiently shown by the following sentences: “Now if the relation thus established in the morning twilight of Man’s existence be- tween the Human Soul and a world invisible and immaterial, is a relation of which only the subjective term is real and the objec- tive term is non-existent, then, I say, it is something utterly without precedeat in the whole history of creation. All the analo- gies of Evolution, so far as we have yet been able to decipher it, are overwhelmingly against any such supposition. To suppose that, during countless ages, from the sea- weed up to Man, the progress of life was achieved through adjustments to external realities, but that then the method was all at once changed, and, throughout a vast province of evolution, the end was secur- ed through adjustments to eternal non- realities, is to do sheer violence to logic and to common sense, Qr, to vary the form of statement, since every adjustment where- by any creature sustains life may be called a true step, and every maladjustment whereby life ig wrecked may be called a false step; if we are asked to believe that Nature, after having, throughout the whole round of her inferior products, achieved re- sults through the accumulation of all true steps and pitiless rejection of all false steps, suddenly changed her method and, in the case of her highest product, began achieving results through the accumulation of false steps—I say we are entitled to re- sent such a suggestion as an insult to our understandings. All the analogies of Na- ture fairly shout against the assumption.” There is much more of this, But it is mere reiteration. Every reader will see how all this heat and “shouting” contrasts with Mr. Fiske’s quiet way of pushing his reasons when he sees their force clearly, instead of only feeling something, he knows not quite what. To say that ‘the analogies of Evolu- tion are overwhelmingly against any such supposition” is quite the reverse of the truth. According to accepted ideas of evo- lution, species do not become adapted to their environment in so far as that environment enjoys abstract “reality” (if that means any- thing), but only in so far as that environ- ment affects the continued propagation of the species. Correct notions about ways of get- ting food and the like are developed because the species would die out if they were not. But Mr. Fiske will not be able to point to a single idea which evolution has rendered true in any other sense than that it is favor- able to the continuance of the species. He himself, in his second sentence above, de- fines a ‘‘true’”’ step as an ‘‘adjustmert where- by any creature sustains life’—which is ap- proximately, though not accurately, a good definition for the purposes of evolutionary philosophy. But, in that sense, the develop- ment of a whelly erroneous conception of the sun or moon, or of another life, or of anything else which in some respects cannot really influence the species, may be a ‘‘true step,’ provided it be stimulating or tend to sustain life. If Mr. Fiske would content himself with saying that Truth, in any other sense than that of a valuable adjustment, is unattainable, if not inconceivable (as his Pragmatist friends, James and Peirce, con- tend), his reasoning would be considerably amended. There are several passages in the book which remind us that Mr. Fiske is not a tho- rough-going evolutionist, but is a follower of Spencer, who holds that Evolution and Devo- lution ceaselessly alternate under the in- fluence of an immutable law that knows no growth, no cause, no reason; so that not evo- lution, but immutability, according to his ac- count of the matter, is the general charac- teristic of the universe. The Races of Hurope: A Sociological Study. By William Z. Ripley, Ph.D. With Sup- plementary Bibliography of the Anthropo- logy and Ethnology of Europe. Two vols. D. Appleton & Co. 1899. Dr. Ripley’s book impresses one at sight as the result of great labor and painstaking. You need not be an ethnologist to discover that the author, the artist, and the publisher have done their best. The race and type portraits are most of them in front and side- face, to enforce the text. The graphic charts and maps of cephalic index, stature, color, etc., compiled from a hundred heterogeneous sources, are brought to a common, intelli- gible standard. The author says that most of these are the handiwork of his wife, so we take off our hat to her for the most in- teresting parts of the volume, which not only illustrate the text, but brilliantly illuminate it. The bibliographic supplement is both a collection of book titles and an alphabetic list of topics, under each of which the perti- nent authors are given in chronological order. The Boston Public Library, with commend- able generosity, has brought the books toge- ther at Dr. Ripley’s behest. Any student past fifty will miss the name of almost every author at whose feet he sat thirty years ago. Putting aside society, language, indus- tries, fine arts, and religions as function- al only, Dr. Ripley devotes himself to the term race, meaning blood, as applied to Eu- rope, insisting always that the study can- not be divorced from the environment, in the fullest meaning of that term. Races of Wurope and the map of Europe—that is the text. Head-form holds the first place as a characteristic of race; after that come color in the skin, the hair, and the eyes, and stature. On this basis it is inferred that there were three races in Europe, all se- condary or derivative. By race the author does not, with Deniker, mean the biologi- cal groups now peopling Europe; much less does he hold the view of Agassiz regarding fixed types. As an evolutionist he holds that races are only ideals, inseparable branches of a common stem. The three ideal, funda- mental races of Hurope are: 1. Teutonic, a variety of the Cro-Magnon man, with long head and face, light hair, blue eyes, tall stature, and narrow, aqui- line nose. Also called Homo Europseus, the Nordic, Kymric, Germanic, and Reihengra- ber race, (2.) Alpine (Celtic speech, Hallstatt cul- ture, Asiatic affinities). With round, broad head, light chestnut hair, hazel-gray eyes, medium stature; broad and heavy nose. Also called Homo Alpinus, Lappanoid, Occidental, Aveyron, Dissentis, Sarmatian, Celto-Slavic race. Lineal descendants of the lake-dwell- ers, (8.) Mediterranean, earliest, with long head and face, dark brown or black hair, dark eyes, medium stature and broad nose.
Page 23
Aug. 10, 1899] ‘The Nati ion. 119 Also called Homo Mediterranensis, Atlanto- Mediterranean, Ibero-insular, Ligurian, Ibe- rian race. In France all three races occur—the Al- pine in isolation, the long-headed in the open, the Teutonic latest and most ener- getic. Remnants of the Cro-Magnon race still survive in the Dordogne valley. The Basques are not a physical type, but have been evolved from the Mediterranean by iso- lation and inbreeding. The Scandinavians had no early stone age. They are one with the Lithuanians, Finns, and Teutons, having an Alpine substratum. Germany differs lit- tle from France in race, being Teuton in the north and Alpine in the south. If they only knew it, they have no need of strife. Even the withering suggestion that the Prus- sians are nothing but Finns, anyhow, loses its force when you know that the Finnish | head is’ as long as the Teuton’s. originally peopled by Ligurian long-heads; the present Umbrian type is an overflow of the Alpine Celt. The Etruscans came upon the Umbrians as a mixture of Alpine and Tyrrhenian. Beyond the Pyrenees, Africa! The Spa- niard is Mediterranean, allied with Africa from the earliest prehistoric period. Switzer- land is the home of the broad-headed Al- pine descendants of the lake-dwellers, with long heads in the highlands and the valleys. Holland is Teuton in its highways and Al- pine in its byways. the long head as the prevailing type, but the round-barrow man was round-headed, whe- | ther Celt or not. The Russians are mixed of long-headed Teuton, Finn, and Lithua- niau, Lappish Mongol-Tartar, and Slav; these last are fundamentally Alpine, and entered Russia from the southwest. The Jews have changed head-form in the historic period; nine-tenths of them being now short-headed. They are not a race, or a language, or a nation—they are a people. The Greeks were anciently long-headed, but the author has some excellent words about their present melancholy condition between the two brachycephalic millstones. Turks are physically allied to Mongols, and Italy was | The British Isles have | — apart. and seven-eighths Alpine. In the Caucasus the Iranian long-headed brunet is in rivalry with the Armenian short-head. Asia Minor is Mediterranean and Iranian at bottom, overlaid with Armenoid, Hittite and Turk. A brief discussion of the later stone pe- riod and earlier iron and bronze period | brings the author in his closing chapters to the serious consideration of race and en- vironment in relation to the critical problems of modern life. Hereditary forces, both na- | tural and selective, are allowed their just | share in moulding men and manners, but, |} with much force, environmental pressure, | both physiographic and human, is here ac- | corded a large place in the programme. | The chapters on urban selection and acclima- tization cannot fail to awaken the liveliest interest just now. It is only fair to Dr. are in Europe only to keep the dogs of war The Magyar is one-eighth Finnic | | | | Ripley to say that he professes only to have | | codrdinated a vast mass of material, and that he himself often balks before jumping to onclusions which the data do not now justi- } | c } | pete co) Trish Life and Character. By Michael Mac- Donagh. Thomas Whittaker. 1899. Pp. viii. 382. . The title of this volume is misleading. What is offered us is not a grave study of Irish life and character: it is an anthology—admirable, the best that has yetappeared—of Irish humor, repartee, and sarcasm, bulls, colloqualisms, | and oddities; a collection such as might be | | made concerning most countries or peoples. | | In no country and with no people, least of all | in Ireland, do such constitute the staple of | life, or are they a conclusive indication of real life and character. It is a misfortune for any people not fully masters of their own to be too much dwelt upon. ‘“‘Nigger min- | strelsy” has worked harm to the negro, as the Irishman of the music-halls has Ireland. that the humorous side of their lives has not thus been exploited; it will be well for the Filipinos if theirs be not. to HENRY HOLT & CO., 29 W. 23d St., NEW YORK; 378 Wabash Av., CHICAGO HAVE JUST PUBLISHED: Daniels’s Elements of Public Finance Including the Monetary System of the United States. By Prof Winturop More Danrers of Princeton. 373 pp. 12mo, $1.50 net. A handy manual for general reader or student, describ- ing the actual system in the United States, with some exposition and criticism of our monetary system. The author’s standpoint is in the main conservative, favor- ing proportional as against progressive taxation and corporate initiative (under legal restriction) as against public ownership of most urban monopolies. CLARENDON PRESS PUBLICATIONS. For sale by ali booksellers. Send for Catalogue. OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS, (American Branch) 91 5th Ave., New York. Manuscripts A New Book Every Day. Promptly F. TENNYSON NEELY, Examined. ee 114 PIFTH AVE., NEW YORK, Six Million Books issued Yearty. HEROES OF THE REFORMATION. Fully illustrated. Each, 12mo, cloth, $1.50. Nearly Ready. DESIDERIUS ERASMUS (1467-1536), the Humanist in the Service of the Reformation. By EPHRAIM EMER- TON, Ph.D., Professor of Ecclesiastical! History, Harvard University. Professor Emerton has laid the general public under a heavy obligation by produc- ing a very carefully and, at the same time, brilliantly written study on the prince of the Humanists of the XVI. centdry. His book will prove its superiority to the other English books on Erasmus, when compared to them, by reason of its sanity and tho- roughness. PREVIOUSLY ISSUED: Martin Luther por ng THe HERO oF THE REFORMATI'N. By Henry Eyster Ja- cobs, D.D., LL D. Philip Melanchthon (1497-1560), tHe Pro TESTANT PRECEPTOR OF GERMANY. By James William Richard, D.D Send for Prospectus of the Heroes of the Reforma- tion Serves. v vi G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS, New York and London, destiny, when this side of their lives comes | It is well for the people of India | | ject. | footnotes | Irishmen and the rest of the world, These considerations aside, Mr. MacDo- pagh has well executed his task, and his |} book may be taken as a standard on the sub- It would have been interesting if in or appendix he had the sources whence his examples were culled; and an index would have laid his readers un- der additional obligations. Very many of his staple old friends must bear in mind the extent to which the ben trovato prevaiis. The world would be a leas pleasant place than it is if anecdotes, of speech, and travellers’ tales were passed on in the truthful nudity of their origin, if reproduced by phonograph. We have no desire to throw the cold water of explanation or criticism over some of the author's most amusing passages. We must, however, pro- test against the thin end of the wedge of po- litical controversy occasionally introduced, as where it is hinted that differences between North and South of Ireland, and between stated pieces are One flowers as are due principally to racial characteristics rather than to history and environment. The au thor’s remarks on the reproduction of Irish dialect in writing are admirable, and should be taken to heart by all who purpose making incursions, verbal or written, in that fleld Upon one important point we must differ, and our experience has been longer and perhaps wider than Mr. MacDonagh’s—that is, the go- neral joyousness of Irish life, and the ness of character of the average We believe that Irish life, famine, open Irishman. at least since the is upon the whole more sombre than that of neighboring English-speaking peo- ples; and, as to openness of character, it is amyth. There is a mauraise honte, a cav tion, even a suspicion (all the result of cir- cumstance) in Irish intercourse, little pre- valent elsewhere. The Irishman is appa- rently at first easier to become acquaint- ; ed with and apparently open; but he | guards his inner life, his thoughts, his real opinions, to a degree unknown among people who have had full control of their own fate. Taking this beok for what it really is, we can unhesitatingly recommend it. Maine Coast. FOR SALE.—A compact tract of 400 acres of land in one of the most central positions on the main land of Penobscot Bay. It has nearly four miles of bold rocky shore front, with beaches. cove« and beautiful headlands. The land runs to bigh elevations, and has great topographical variety; pine woodland; meadows and grassy slopes There is a steamboat landing close by with dally service to and from Boston and the West It is within half an hour by steamboat from Isles boro and Castine. There are several good farm houses on the property, an ice pond, and a trout brook. Salmon are taken on the shore. The land everywhere commands broad and beautiful views of an archipelago of islands, the broad bay, dis. tant sea, and mountains. The property la offered for sale as a whole at a low price per acre to settle a joint account, Photographs and further details may be obtained of J. MURRAY HOWE, 28 State Trustee, Street, Boston The Story of Gésta Berling By SELMA LAGERLOF Translated from the Swediah by Pauline Bancroft Flack. 12mo, cloth extra, $1.95 A veritable epic.” London Daily Telegraph. LITTLE, BROWN & CO.. Publishers, Boston. kK DERGARTEN SUPPLIES at SCHERNERRORE'S, 8 od 14th &., N. ¥. nd for New Catalogue 00K'S, SECOND. HAN. DAND NE W, Standard aud . Books bona. Cataiogue issued. E. W. Jounson, 2 E. 42d &t., i |
Page 24
120 The Nation. [ Vol. 69, No. 1780 COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY STUDIES IN HISTORY, ECONOMICS, AND PUBLIC LAW. Facutty oF Po.iticaL ScIENCE OF COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY. VOL. X., No. 3. Centralized Administration of Liquor Laws in the American Commonwealths. By CLEMENT MOORE LACEY SITES, Ph.D., Sometime Fellow in Constitutional Law. Price, paper, $1.00. The above, bound up with HALL’S Sym the Formation of the Union, forms Vol. X. thetic Strikes and Lockouts and BATES’ Rhode Island and rice, paper, $3.00; cloth, $3.50 VOL. XI. The Growth of Cities in the Nineteenth Century: A Study in Statistics. By ADNA FERRIN WEBER, Ph.D., Sometime University Fellow in Economics and Social Science in Columbia University, Deputy Commissioner of Labor Statistics in New York State. For further information apply to Prof. EDWIN R. A. SELIGMAN, __Cotumbia University. Price, paper, $3.50 net; cloth, $4.00 net. Orders filled by THE MACMILLAN COMPANY, New York. NEW NOVEL BY W. J. LOCKE I D IDOLS L, S Price, $1.50, “One of the best novels a d this ye N. Y. World, June. ba 1899. JOHN LANE, 251 Fifth Avenue, New York. God’s War. By WILSON VANCE. ‘There is more real war in this war story than in any one I have read."’ —Murat Halstead. Cloth, 12mo. One Dollar. We issue over six million books yearly. Averaging more than a book a day. Manu- scripts promptly examined. F. TENNYSON NEELY PUBLISHER, 114 Fifth Avenue, New York. THE BLICKENSDERFER TYPEWRITERS No. 5, $35. No. 7, $50. Are Guaranteed the Best. Ask for New Catetoges of Desks and Up-to-date Office Devices. Blickensderfer Mfg. Co. 325 BROADWAY, N.Y. F. W. CHRISTERN (DYRSEN & PFEIFFER, Successors), 429 Sth Ave., between 38th and 80th Sts., New York. Importers of Foreign Books; Aponte for the leading Paris Publishers; Tauchnitz’s British Authors, Teubner’s Greek and Latin Classics. Catalogues of stock mafied m Paris and Leip- on demand. New. books received zig a8 soon as issued. Readers and Writers have aoe Waiting for this O= a Full-of Matter, Moderate-Priced Reference Book, THE STUDENTS’ STANDARD DICTIONARY. ‘ AN ABRIDGMENT OF nae Funk & Wagnalls’ Standard Dictionary Large 8vo, 933 pages, cloth, leather back, net, $2.50; Sheep, $4.00; Indexed, 50c. additional, Contains 60,000 Words and Phrases, and 1,225 Pictorial IMlustrations. Sent postpaid on receipt of price by The Baker & Taylor Co. 53 and 7 East 16th St., New York. An Elementary French Grammar. By CHARLES P. DU CROQUET. Author of “‘ Francais par la Conversation,” ‘‘ French Verbs in a Few Lessons,” etc., etc. This elementary French Grammar is practical for the pe dag as well as for the adult student, and can be mastered by the latter in a ee sant time. Reading can be commenced after Pa’ I. has been learned. Second Edition, revised. 12mo, cloth, 250 pages (including a complete Vocabulary )e Price, 75 cents. Complete catalogue on application. Forsale by all book- sellers, or postpaid on receipt of price by the publisher, WILLIAMR. JENKINS 8511 and 853 6th Ave. (cor. 48th St.), New York. Old Books. Rare Books, Choice Books, Quaint Books, Typography, Topography. BOOKS ON ALL SUBJECTS. FIRST EDITIONS, ETC. ILLUSTRATED CATALOGUE, pronounced to be arg most original ano interes ng list issued, 364 pages, 8vo, with 870 Reproductions of Plates, Portraits, and Title-pages, pest bisa -_ sum is deducted from the first purchase of PICKERING & CHATTO, Antiquarian Booksellers, 66 Haymarket, St. James, London, s. w. s BOOKS When calling please ask for rere wieesian =e need a Book DISCOUNT address MR. GRANT. Before ah od books write for quotations. An assort- ment of catalogues and — slips of books at reduced prices sent fur 10 cent stamp. FP. BE, GRANT, Books. 23 W. 42p Sr. ~ NEW YORK. (Mention this ‘advertinement and receive a discount.) dg! S.—All Ont-efs “5 Books supplied, matter on what sub pooktnders — ‘over as the ag P Tate Jon n Bright Mata ngbam, T BOOKS He A Handsome Gobelin is no doubt the ne plus ultra of the weaver’s art, yet our beautiful, stylish and always useful Augusta-Victoria Empress Shoulder-Shawils are cer- tainly also exquisitely handwoven (about 40 inches square, with 6 inch fringe) by expert Saxon weavers at Bethlehem. Colors white, light green, pink, distingué¢ red, and black. When ordering kindly remember to mention color des'‘red. Sent postpaid and registered on receipt of $7.50. THE SUSACUAC WEAVING CO., BETHLEHEM, PA. Travel. GOING ABROAD ON A BICYCLE TRIP? Send for ‘Bicycling Notes for Tourists Abroad,” 10 cents in stamps. The fine new steamers of the LEYLAND LINE Sail every Wednesday. BOSTON TO LIVERPOOL. First cabin, wen er, $37; 88 and up. Splendid new steamer Winifredian, 10,500 tons, 570 feet in length, now in pha F. 0. HOUGHTON & CO., General Agents, 11g State Street, Boston. DRESDEN, GERMANY. _ Pension Kretzschmer-Schadewell. Friiulein Schadewell, prveriotans of Pension Kretzsch- mer, removes in tember to 4 Lindenau-Platz. New house, conveniently situated. with southern exposure. Equipped with modern a: appointments; lift. Address un- til Gapoember, 15 Riickn: PARIS in 1900. A word to the wise. Make sure of steamship and ho- tel accommodations now, at fair rates, in_ personally conducted _ parties. THE. ‘CRAWFORD TOU Home Office 610 Tremont Building, Boston; 220 Broadway, New York; 1011 Chestnut Street, Philadelphia. EUROPEAN TRAVEL. THE MISSES WELDON, he a their 9th Annual Class. Young Ladies’ Forei Restricted; highest re- ferences. Address THE MOORINGS, Tour HAVEN, Pa. Summer Resorts. EUROPEAN SUMMER RESORT, INNSBRUCK, TYROL, AUSTRIA. 1,900 feet above the sea, with dry, bracing climate. HOTEL TIROL. Open all the year. Modern conveniences. Best re- ferences. Illustrated pomapeiens on application. ‘ARL LANDSER, Proprietor. SWITZERLAND yotAUSANNE. mOoTet. RICHE-MONT. First-class hotel with moderate tariff. Large gurdons. ag cent view over the lake and gene Lift, baths, electric i ineveryroom. Patronized 4 Ame: rican families. In winter ve ry reduced pension term Tariff and peunphiets sent fred. on application. OPERSTOWN—“OTSEGO HALL,” small hotel near the lake. Well kept; choice table; good boating and fishing: 2 golf courses. Now open. and LETTERS ™ CREDIT. : Travellers’ ie and is available in ~~ of the world. BROWN BROTHERS & CO. NO. 59WALL STREET, NEW YORK. Study and Practice of French in School IN THREE PARTS. By L.c. Some, 258 South 16th St., Philadelphia A carefully graded course een Pract juirements for entrance exaitination at coll tice in conversa- Pron tion and Grammar. tion and thorough drill in m Boston: AW il-made series. Teach- ers and pupl will find the ‘three’ books helpful and inte- resting.” HAY FEVER Is NATOREre MERU. A French discovery, recommended by —— aye, eens. psec teens ir iia to perfect health, ore a far comical Go $85 Pith Ave., New York.
Page 25
. ‘ ‘ - e - > . « . 6 ‘ : : ra ~ ‘ : ; 8 a - - 6 . e 4 4 \ - 7 \ A - 7 7 - a \ . ' ; ‘ ‘ " . . - bs 7 i ‘ ° . . . . \ . . = coy y* 5 ‘ ; ° 7 x 2 } 7 t * 7 2 2 F = : ° o + \ y « 7 g pe be tas eoetee— : ’ = J A - . ; \ - \ . . ai 7 ‘ 2 7 7 o - y 1 : ene s ‘ ’ 7 a a . . ° ° » « : ‘ ° . : a ° i) - = & . . | 7 2 : . ‘i ‘ " , ° . . - - ° : — - * 6 » . . . : . ‘ | a Ps te . : -. . 3 « f 4 , : 7 ; = al ; \ . ! + . . ’ € +