The Nation 1899-07-20: Vol 69 Iss 1777
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
VOL. LXIX—NO. 1777. THURSDAY, - JULY 20, — Summer Resorts. Special Inducements to Summer Resorts. GOLFERS IN JULY « Mount Pleasant House, — WHITE MOUNTAINS. The Links have been put in the finest condition for season of 1899. Few Golf Courses in the world exceed the Mount Pleasant in natural | interest or in perfection of improvement. A feature is the caddy service supplied by a force of active, intelligent academy and college boys. Dark room, with complete outfit for use of amateur or professional photographers. Mount Pleasant House is luxurious in every ap- pointment, and has special Post-office, Telegraph, cae eenaee Telephone, and Railroad Ticket e hotel. Theoush Parigr Pow Sleepin rte ongvies from pa Port rlin Montreal to shotel grounds, ere Trains he grounds twice daily for ascent of Mt. Washington, directly 5 ‘front My, the hotel THE OPEN OBSERVATION-OARS again run through the Pass of the White Mountains. Pas- - ers to Mount Pleasdnt House from Portland from Boston, via North Conway, will enjoy this unique rail ride from Bartlett to Mount Plea- cast, 8 miles of it from Bemis to Crawford Notch, far Pleasant, Presidential Peaks just across de in America uc. No rail compares with th his. noosu Rocky Mountains, Bicycle Path to Crawford Notch. Bridle Trail to the Summit of the Rosebrook Range. Birch Rock Spring Water. Mount Pleasant Dairy Mi!k. White Mountain Air. ANDERSON & PRICE, Managers, Also of Hotel Ormond, Florida. EUROPEAN SUMMER RESORT, INNSBRUCK, TYROL, AUSTRIA. 1,900 feet above the sea, with dry, bracing climate. HOTEL TIROL. Ra haa . pate of exchange to and Africa? Ege svaijabie in al poate the world, BROWN BROTHERS & CO. NO. SOWALL STREET, NEW YORK. ’ tsened Mount Pleasant House, N. H. SWITZERLAN D st eeien. HOTEL RICHE-MONT. First-class hotel with moderate tariff. Large gardens. Magnificent view over the lake and mountains. Lift, baths, electric light Ineveryroom. Patrontzed by Ame- rican families. In winter very reduced pension termns. Tariff and ee sent free on application. EAUMARIS HOTEL, MUSKOKA NG cee Sa seh ac aig Rent for booklet ieee Prowsk, Pro OOPERS STO WwN—"0 TSEGO HA LL,’ % small hotel near the lake. Well kept; choice tabie; good eauncnadan and —_—- 2 golf courses. Now open. DOORS. SECOND-HAND AND NEW, Standard and greg. Rooks bought Ps a E . dounsom, 2 E. 424 & high up on the Mountain-slde, with the valley | low, and three miles from the Notch to Mount commanding the grandest view of the | the valley Ammo | east of the | PRICE 10 CENTS. "Beautifully tienes BY EXPERT SAXON WEAVERS. - The Augusta-Victoria Empress Shoulder Shaw! made of softest wool and sifk, 40 inches square with 6 inch fringe, warp silk and woof wool, Rich light green, delicate pink, recherche red, pure white or black. Sent POSTPAID and REGISTERED on receipt of | $7.50—check, draft or money order—by |The Susacuac Weaving Co., 12 Moravian Church St., Bethichem, Pa. New Volume of Poems by the Author of ‘“‘“ADMIRALS ALL THE ISLAND RACE. By HENRY NEWBOLT. Crown 8vo, $1.00. The London Daily Chronicle says: “It con tains nothing better than the best things in ‘Admirals All,’ for the excellent reason that these things were perfect in their kind and eould not be bettered.” JOHN LANE, 140 Fifth Avenue, New York. HAY FEVER js xature’s remeny Perfectly simple and scientific. Dry-air tnbalation A vegetable compound, antiseptic and anti-spasmodic tn action. A French discovery; recommended by Dr Forné of the Pasteur Institute, and many of the most distinguished physicians of France for use in the hosp!- tals and public schools. Full information gladly sent Inhaler and bottie of Gomeno! may be obtained through your druggtst, or by mall, prepaid, for one dollar BARD CHEMICAL COo., 51-57 Franklin St., 765 Fifth Ave., N. Y. esi Travel. GOING ABROAD ON A BICYCLE TRIP? Send for “Bicycling Notes for Tourists Abroad,” 10 cents in stamps. The fine new steamers of the LEYLAND LINE Sail every Wednesday. BOSTON TO LIVERPOOL. First cabin, winter, $37. mg and up. Splendid new steamer Winifredian, 10,500 tons, 570 feet in | length, now in service. F. O. HOUGHTON & CO., General Agents, 11g State Street, Boston. PARIS in 1900. A word tote rae. Make ome of senmehte and > tel accomm tions now, at rT rates, ynally | conducted parties. THE CHA WFORD TOURK B10. Tre mont Building, Boston; 220 _rectuns. New York; 1011 Chestnut Street, Philadelph } —_—— EUROPEAN TRAVEL. THE MISSES WELDO® wae thetr @th Annual Clase- Young Ladies’ Fore ricted, highest re | ferences. Address B MOORINGS. Loon HMavew, Pa
Page 2
The Nation.
[Vol. 69, No. 1777
The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literamarny Science, and Art. FOUNDED 1865. [@ntered at the New York City Post-Office as second- class mail-matter.]}
CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. DRE TR bi bik vhs eh iweistevccsakabictisisegeussten 41 EDITORIAL ARTICLES: te irnce ot RO. 6.0 0060c8ewk sdusiee 44
Wes @ “Backward Step’’.....scesccecses 44 Heapousibilit of Lawyers as Citizens....... 45 Courts and Combinations...........0..e-e08 46 BORON. GRE BRON serkcccccceccearbtanavis 6 46 SPECIAL Conemanematioans A BpBets MAGGIORE. cs Kc ccrdicccrvocccosssadece 47 A Milanese Are ‘Foundat BOR. < ovo ntn2sd viveve 49 Poisoning in the Seventeenth Century....... 50 CORRESPONDENCE: Democratic Agitation against Trusts........ 51 Keeping Our Own Door Olean.............. 61 Ruskin and Millala .....c.ccccccsevedscccee 52 PB vc bicscccssenvashuscvshesensavesavconpeoaseceter 52 Boox REvixrws: WHO OE VECGIMER bak i occ deccegracecpedecege 54 Vondel’s Lacifer 55 Benn’s Philosophy of Greece 56 James Russell tows 57 European History 58 The Genesis and Dissolution of the Faculty GB BOOED. ne ccc tccppesesesacassvcetoces Selections from the Manuscripts of Lady Lotion Stuart ...crecseccccsvccccvecsccese DOORE UP. THR. WBE. ois ccsccdscvcadedevovecesusvnece 60
TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three Dollars per year, in advance, postpaid, to any part of the United States or Canada; to foreign countries comprised in the Postal Union, $4.00. The date when the subscription expires is on the Address-Label of each paper, the change of which to a subsequent date becomes a receipt for remit- tance. No other receipt is sent unless requested. Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter, or by check, express order, or Postal Order, payable to ‘‘Publisher of the Na- tion.” When a change of address is desired, both the old and new addresses should be given. Address THE NATION, Box 794, New York. Publication Office, 208 Broadway.
TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Fifteen cents per agate line, each insertion, 1, lines to the inch, Twenty per cent. advance for choice of page or top of column. Cuts are not inserted on the first page. A column, $20 each insertion; with choice of page, $24. A page, $60 each insertion; front-cover page, $80. Advertisements must be acceptable in every re- spect. Copy vessiued until Tuesday, 6 P. M.
DISCOUNTS.
Amu $100 within BHOR, vcccccccreseevocsrocsecs 10 per cent. 250 i igh, ” 600 ad “ 760 cl “ “ a 000 “ “ o “ 1,500 Sipe eee -»» 80 Md $000 wo - puveucnsneenapnenenesaces 83% “
The NATION ia sent free to those who advertise tn it as tong as advertisement S comeenem eeepc enne -—- oe eee *,* * Copies of the Natron may be oil in Paris at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de l'Opéra, and in London of B, F. Stevens, 7 Trafalgar Square, Ame- rican Newspaper Agency, 15 King William Street, Strand, W. C London aaa for advertisements, H. A. Delille, Langham Hotel. ,
Educational. CaL‘FrorNrIA, Los Angeles, West 23d Street. M ARLBOROUGH SCHOOL for GIRLS. Mrs. Grores A. CaswkLL, Principal.
CanaDa, P. Q. TSHOP'S COLLEGE “SCHOOL. (és- tablished 1842 ) Church School for Boys on lines of English Public Schools. Specially adap for sons of English residents in America, weaning cricket, = healthy country situation. Best N ork referen $280 a year. H. J. H. Perry, +4 x
DeLawakk, Wilmington, Franklin Street. WE MISSES HEBB'S Boarding and Day School for Girls. Students are prepared for College.
District oF CoLumBra (Chevy Chase P. O., Md.). HEV Y CHASE french and English School for Girls. Suburb of Washington. 7 34 o sagen e of the house. ULIGNY, hig = am. Mine’ C. PETTIGREW, Asst.
ILurvors, Chicago, 1500-4 Title and Trust Building. YICAGO COLLEGE OF LAW. Law DEPARTMENT OF LAKE FoREST UNIVERSITY. Three-year course leading to degree LL.B. For further information address the Secretary. E. E. BARRETT.
MARYLAND, Baltimore, 122 and 124 W. Franklin St. DGEWORTH BOARDING and DAY School for oy". —87th year will beatin September 28, 1899. oe P. Leresves, Princ anes ~4 3 D. HUNTLEY, Associate er
MARYLAND, Catonsville. T. TIMOTHY'S SCHOOL for Girls re- opens Sept 21, 1899. Preparesfor College. Heads of School, Miss M. *C. CaRTER, Miss S. R. CARTER.
MASSACHUSETTS, Boston. OSTON UNIVERSITY Law School. Address the Dean, AMUEL C. BENNETT.
MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 66 Marlborough St. ‘LASSICAL SCHOOL FOR GIRLS. Boarding and Day School. Certificate accepted by Smith, Vassar, and Wellesley. 8. Auice Brown and ‘Anata L. OWEx, Principals. Massacuvusetts, Cambridge, 9 Channing Street, HE LEE SCHOOL FOR GIRLS. Miss M, L. Ke.vy, Principal.
MASSACHUSETTS, Danvers I i} JILLARDHALL SCHOOL for GIRLS. Twelfth year. Mrs. 8. M. D. MEBRILL, Principal.
Massacuvsetts, Duxb OWDER POINT SCHOOL. —Prepares for Scientific_School , College, of, Business. Indi- vidual teaching. Elementa 4 4 classes for young 5 a Home and outdoor life. F Kwapp, 8.B. (M Massscuvusetts, South Byfield. UMMER ACADEM Y.—PREPARES boys for any College or Scientific School. Special attention is given to English. Trained teach- ers. $500. Perey L. Horne, A.M. (Harvard).
Missour!, St. Louis. 30th Year. 22 Professors. REST PARK UNIVERSITY FOR Women. ierooger, Di College Course. ws, Folce Music, E. R. Kr areckes: rry Fellows, ice; ariel Violin. ape Elocution, Art. Boa and tuition, $265 to $3 80. Address for Cata logue, rs. ANNA SNEED Carrns, President.
New HampsuHireE, Plymouth OLDERNESS SCHOOL. — Thorough preparation for College and Scientific School. Holderness boys are standing well at Trinity, Dart- n, Harvard, Wesleyan, West Point. Bend mouth, Princeto for catalogue to’ Rev. LORIN x M.A., t. Rev. W. W. NiiEs, President of Trustees,
New York, Sing Sing. R. HOLBROOK *'S SCHOOL will reopen Wednesday, September 27, at 6 P. M-
New York, U RS. PIA TT" S SCHOOL.—The next school year begins Thursday, Sept 22, 1898.
orTu CAROLINA, Red ORTH CAROLINA MILITARY Anna —— rants and for celege ‘atid we Polnt or th- ful climate. Address C. A. Suort, Prin,
Onto, Cincinnati ISS ARMSTRONG'S SCHOOL FOR Girls, Liddesdale Place Avensals. Family limit- ed, Circulars sent on application Educational. SS HELE y's Ss “TALL. —A Boarding and L Aewe yt ned Girls; Will reopen Sept. 15. For cir- eulars iss ELEANOR TEBBETTS, Ph.D., Prin.
PENNSYLVANIA, Bethle EHIGH PREPARA TOR Y TOOL Lis 900 aloga ae various col ae ieee ae io raha Ba PENNSYLVANTA, Chestnut Hill. ‘HESTNUT HILL ACADEMY. A Boarding School for Boys. Illustrated Cata- logues on application. James L. PatrEerson, Head-master.
PENNSYLVANIA, Med EDIA ACADEM ted or BOYS AND , Scientific, = Thoro Careful indivi ua! on. table. Beautiful location. Circular . Cuas. W. STUART, Excellen
PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, Chestnut H RS. COMEG YS’ AND MISS BELL'S BOARDING AND DAY SCHOOL FOR GIRLS. Will reopen October 2, 1899. Students prepared for college. Virermia, Richm CcCABE’S (DA. y ‘AND BOARDING) University School. The thirty-fifth annua’ sion of this school for bo: Sept. 25th, isee. Freee aPamic ta cat eet r e e leading eering Schools. Full staff. o partments strletly limited. For catalogue ORDON McoCaBe, Head Master.
Virerta, Richmond. NIVERSIT Y COLLEGE OF MEDI- cine.—310 mene med last a ees 56 in Faculty. E. Seee Pe a Ererts Be compalecry extres; Besord dete carta bet Cf. a appt can ore last North ing, Bo Board, 1 (17 appli- cants), and before all . ay d Pharmacy ards eq as good ans For 88-page Catalogue, address Dr. J. ALLISON Hopes, Proctor. ISS ANABLE'S Boardin, Ks and Day School for Girls. Established in 1848. Cireular on application. Opens Sept. 28. 1350 Pine St., Phila., Pa. SCE HOOL, wor DRAWING. AND PAINTING. S, BOSTON, MASS. ear Opens Os wien eee Haus -
F. ‘aed scat Sates! Pinatomys ve. se hate ated ay dose oar shi ceri 4 circulars we i add MISS ELIZABETH corm adreat Manager. MISS BALDWIN’S SCHOOL FOR GIRLS, BRYN MAWR, PA. Preparatory to Bryn Mawr College. plisre CRossS,
Miss FLorence Bautpwin, Principal. Within eight ears more than ninety pupils have entered : wr College from this school. shou: Fine, fire- both General and e building. 3 a0 A Noten tiful ne oare ui! grounds. For circular, ad Secretary. ACADEMIC CLASSES nis. A Boarding and ade Resting ed Pal tates Sees evant
, Wellesley, and Mt. Holyoke. Artistic, Mili and Swedish Gyinaaatioe Music ent. 1oth pear. Ad West 27th Street, New York.
FORESTRY SCHOOL, For circular — information ote = Cc. A. SCH » Ph.D., Forester to the Estate.
MONTCLAIR MILITAR y ACADEMY Ay bay LE ete Vhs ag Aa a OHN @. wAcvicaR. Head Master.
Onto, Cincinnati, Walnut Hills, 044-046-048 Morris DEN PARK SCHOOL,—BOA RDING and Day School Ld Girls, Primary, Preparatory, Steak edn eer an Higher course in the MaDAME Frepry, Mise Many F. Surru, } Principals.
ABBOT ACADEMY °°" Yenne lstisss, Rares fire eee, oa ie
Page 3
July 20, 1899] The Nation. Educational. Edaetient: Lasell Seminary Ryyvq| Vicioria College cme: yee very gra is what a father wrote to ughter after to school from Christmas vacation testimony as to Lasell’s ant lines. Lig ms are taken for nnd year begin- ning September, er, 1809. Catalogue f c. c. onsen, Principal. AUBURNDALE, Mass Trinity College.) Forty-fifth year opens September 6th. Largest endowment of any College in the South. Superior climate. Send for Cata- logue to PRESIDENT KILGO, —_— N. C. ROANOK COLLEGE Salem, Virginia. ourses for Degrees with Electives. Library of one Workin Ae me Healthful moun- location. Six Churches no bar-rooms. Very moderate expenses. Aid Scholarships. Students from North and South. 47th Session begins Sepr. 18, Catalogue with views free. Address JULIUS D. DREHER, President. Mr. and Mrs. John A. Bellows will reopen their Boarding and Day School for Girls at 115 Beacon Street, Boston, October 4, 1899. Certificate of Principals admits to Smith and Wellesley Colleges. BRADFORD ACADEMY. Founded 1803. For the higher education of young perm oe Classical and Scientific course of study; tory and Optional. Year begins Sept. 30800. oo. Mise ny and Opt Prin., Bradford, Maas. For GIRLS and HOWARD SEMINARY Youna women b shy @ Bridgewater, Mass. i7th year opens ius” Te Terms $350 RF Academie, Seki ob seeraterd* am apd Spec Art, Mu- sic, and Elocution. Well- eanipped a Leary and La- , fine Gymnasiu Miss SARAH E. LAUGHTON, Prin. Pensionnat Francais of Vermont Aca- demy and Training School FOR TEACHERS OF FRENCH begins Sept. 19. For circulars address Rev. L. C .A., oF Mrs. L. C. ROUX, Sexton's’ River, near Ballon Falis, Vt. ANDERBILT UNIVERSITY, Nashville, Tennessee.—Next session opens Sep- tember 20. Full graduate as weil as undergraduate courses. 800 students last year. Seven Departments. Fully equipped laboratories and museums. WILS WILLIAMS, Secretary. THE PHILLIPS EXETER ACADEMY. a. me. PF begins Sept. 18, 1899. Eighty Scho- ed to students Mot high standing. Six im- portant buildings added since a For Catalogue and llustrated Su romest, addre: HARLAN AMEN, ‘Principal, Exeter, N. H. WwW , Mass. or eye Military Aateany a ee school. first grade. Healthful loca- ag tie Bela. t pe. —— _ Small classes. jOsRPH PH ALDEN 6 SHAW, A.M. ALLEN BROTHERS’ West Newton English and Classical School. Family and Home School for both Sexes. (47th year.) WEST NEWTON, MASS. tion. News Visitor: Th Miss GIBSON’S FAMILY at DAY SCHOOL for Giris, 2087 Loy ey Pa, 28th year. Fall term begins Sept. 28, '99. — Proparetery. PALLS (N, Y.) en’ Ouro he ee a a ag (McGILL UNIVERSITY, MONTREAL). This residential college for women-students of McGill University will be opened on 14th Septem- ber next. For terms, etc., apply to the Secretary, McGill College, Montreal. Yale Divinity School. A free education in bg Ayok in a great univer- sity. Foo ete f. BW BACO! New Haven, Conn. -MORAL, MENTAL, BOYS CARED FOR.- rg Physical advan tages not - ured elsewhere. Circu JOHN H. WALSH, Great , ae Mass. Teachers, etc. IBRARIAN.—FOUR YEARS’ EX- perience in one of largest American libraries——will act as assistant or take charge of town or college libra- ry. References as to scholarship and efficiency fur- nished on | application to A. _K. G.. care of the Nation. OUR YEARS’ ACADEMICAL Course, preparatory to Yale, Vassar, etc., reduced to less than one year by private instruction. Pamphlet free Rey. Wu. WE Belle ville, Ill. ANTED—AN ENGAGEMENT AS a specialist in Classics and Sarina. Lecture Courses in French Literature. Addre SLrEa,7 730 L “mn Avenue, € "Cieveland, Ohio, HARLE S Ww. STON. E, Tutor for Har- vard, 68 Cheatnut Street, Boston. School Agencies. TI ‘HE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES. | Everett 0. Fisk & Co., Proprietors. 4 Ashburton Place, Boston. 1505 Pa! Ave., Washington. 156 Fifth Ave., New York, 414 Cent. Bag. Minneapolis. 730 we, Bdg.,Denver. 525 s8time’n Bk, Los Angeles 378 Wabash Ave., Chicago. 825 M’ket8t. San Francisco LBANY TEACHERS AGENCY, 24 State St., Albany, N. Y.—Provides schools of | all grades with c ompetent teachers. Assists teachers in onteintng positions. HARLAN P. Frenon, Manager. why SS Sa RHORN’S TEACHE eS GENCY. Oldest and a. yy in the U. Retablished 1855. l4th St., N. a THE PRATT TEACHERS’ AGENCY. WM. O. PRATT, Mgr., 70 Fifth Ave., New York. is valuavle in proportion to Ite ip An Agency fluence. If it merely hears of va- cancies and tells that is sometiing, but if itis a-ked to ae about them recommen a teacher and rec- —- | | the most CW BARDEEN, Syracuse, LY. Recommends ELLIS & ELVEY, Dealers in Old and Rare bKeoks. CATALOGUES of CHOICE BOOKS and ieee. NATED La pet bd 5 paniohes periodical Rare Early English Lite’ re, Early Printed i Black Letter, Ancient Artistic Bookbiading:, rare Prints and Ante i ete. Onl fine epecimens are dealt with. BOND STREET, LONDON, E Study and Practice of French in School IN THREE PARTS. By L.C.Boname, 258 South 16th St., Philadelphia A carefully graded course, meeting requirements for entrance exainination at college ge. Practice in conversa- tion and thorough drill in Pronunciation and Grammar. From Education, Boston: “A well-made series. Teach- ers and 1 ame will find the three books helpful and inte- FRENCH BOOKS “Zsee=="* Cc somplete Catalogue on application. OOKS.—All Out-of-print Books su plied, | no matter on what subject. Acknow the world —. . the most ex kfinders extant. Please ante. BAK gg BOOKSHOP, 141 16. John) “pright Street Birmingham, E1 England. KIN DERGARTEN SUPPLIES a at bees rt 57 S Rast i4sb 8t., N.Y. for New ogue. | thing but Best Known Keown as the Best emington Standard Typewriter WYCKOFF, SEAMANS & BENEDICT, 327 Broadway, New York. Old Books. Rare Books, Choice Books, Quaint Books, Typography, Topography. BOOKS ON ALL SUBJECTS. FIRST EDITIONS, ETC. ILLUSTRATED CATALOGUE, pronounced to be ginal and interesting list issued, 364 pages, 8vo, with 370 Reproductions of Plates, Portraits, and Title- pages, post free, | — sum is deducted from the first purchase of } PICKERING & cnATYS, Antiquarian Booksellers, 66 Haymarket, St. James, London, S. W. - LIBRARIES. We ony ply Public, Private, School, College, and Club Lit wreries with all current Books promptly and —~° It ia our specialty We deal in no oks. Our Monthly Bulletin of all the publishers’ new, noteworthy, and popular tooks mailed on application. The Baker & Taylor Co. 5 and 7 East 16th honti New York. CLAREN DON PRESS PUBLICATIONS. For sale by ald booksellers. Send for Catalogue. OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS, (American Branch) 91 5th Ave., New York. Soule’s Synonymes. Howison's revised and enlarged edition. Now more indispensable to the writer than ever. Crown 4vo, cleth, $2.00; half leather, $2.%. | LITTLE, BROWN & CO., Publishers, Boston.
Page 4
iv The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1777 NEW, BOOKS MACMILLAN COMPANY JUST READY The Government of Municipalities Tue GREAT MUNICIPAL PROBLEMS STATED AND PRACTICAL METHODS SUGGESTED IN AID OF THEIR SOLUTION, By the Hon. Dorman B, Eaton, formerly Commissioner of the United States Civil Service. 8vo, Cloth, $4.00 net. The author has treated the subject theoretically in reference to American constitutions and the relations of the city to the State, and practically in the light of the experiences of both American and European cities. th the actual and the true relations of political parties to city government are set forth; thus it is shown by what means parties have gained an unjus- tiflable control of American cities. HISTORY, TRAVEL, AND DESCRIPTION. The Making of Hawaii The Philippines and Roundabout A Srupy mm Soom. Evo.vrion. By Major G. J. YounaHusBaANnD. Cloth, $2.50 By Prof. W1.L14aM Fremont BLackman, Yale University. Cloth, $2.00 Written in a dashing style that is very taking; it supplements Prof. Wor- A careful study, clear and concise, of the social, political, and moral de- | cester’s book, written ore the recent troubles, so as to give a most com- velopment of the Hawaiian people. plete account of the past and present of the ielanda Letters from Japan ge Simply By Mrs. Hueu Fraser, author of “ Palladia.” etc. A Record of Modern captivating.”’ Profusely Mlustrated, Two Volumes, 8vo, $7.50. Life in the —EVENING Post, ‘Exquisite word-pictures . . . altogether delightful.”—Chicago Tribune. Island Empire. ** Really hc Head pen-pictures . . . diversified by delightful character sketches.""—Boston ip Evening Transcript. The History of South Carolina By Epwarp MoCrapy, President of the Historical Society of South Carolina. Member of the Bar of Charleston, S. C. Vol. 1. Under the Proprietary Government, 1670-1719. Vol. Il. Under the Royal Government, 1719-1775. “The work as a whole is one which cannot be considered as belonging to one State alone, but as a part of and an important contribution to the nation's history.”—Journal of the Southern Historical Association. Source Book of American History Sid2 Lights on American History Edited for Schools and Brgtene by ALBERT BusHNELL Harr, Ph.D., Professor | By Henry W. Exson, A.M., Lecturer of the American Society for the Exten- of History in Harvard University. With Practical Introductions. Illus- sion of University Lhaorag * 16mo, Cloth. Price, 7g cents trated by Facsimiles, etc. 12mo, Cloth. Price, 60 cents net. NATIONAL Periop BEFORE THE CiviL WAR. State Trials—Political and Social Selected and Edited by H. L. SrepHen. 2 Vols., 12mo, Cloth, $2.00 net. Illustrated with some famous Portraits. These trials embrace those of Raleigh, Charles I., Regicides, Colonel Turner, Suffolk Witches, Alice Lisle, Lord Russell, Earl of Warwick, Spencer Cowper, Goodere, etc. NEW BOOKS FOR THE STUDENT OF SOCIOLOGY, PHILOSOPHY, ETC. From Comte to Benjamin Kidd Naturalism and Agnosticism THE APPEAL TO BIOLOGY OR EVOLUTION FOR HUMAN GUIDANCE, By James Warp, M.A., LL.D., Fellow of Trinity College and Professor of By Ropent Macgintoss, D.D., Author of “‘ Christ and the sehen Mental Philosophy, University of Cambridge. 12mo, cloth, $1.50 Historical and critical—a sketch of the growth of the evolutionary systems This volume contains the much-talked-of Gifford Lectures delivered by of ethics, and a study of their claims to authority. Professor Ward in 1895-1896. 2 vols., 12mo, $4.00 net. Ethics and Revelation By Henry 8, Nasu, E.. -c opal Theological School, Cambridge, Author of “‘ Genesis of the Social Conscience.” Cloth, 1amo, $1.50 * This is a grea{. bcok. It is a poem in prose, felicitous and forcible. Every word of the six lectures should be read by thoughtful men of the day, ministers and laymen, * lievers and sceptics.” —Joun H. Vincent. The Physical Nature of the Child AND HOW TO STUDY IT By Sruartr H. Rows, Ph.D., Supervising Principal of the Lovell District, New Haven, Conn.; formerly Professor of Pedagogy and Director of Practice in the State Normal School at Mankato, Minn. A masterly study of the child's physical basis for é; Cloth Educational Aims and Educational Values By Pau. H, Hanus, Assistant Professor of the History and Art of Teaching, Harvard University. — Cloth, 1amo, $1.00 A series of Essays on Coutemporary Educational Problems for laymen as well as for professional students and teachers. Tue Season’s Best Fiction _ SEVENTH EDITION ON THE PRESS. 35th THOUSAND Published June 1, By Winston Churchill. Richard Carvel § Authorof TheCelebrity. Cloth, $1.50 “ It has seldom if ever been surpassed by an American romance,”’—Chi- | “A pure romance of the most captivating and alluring order,"'--Boston cago Tribune. “The book altogether is a delightful one, abounding in powerful scenes,""—The Evening Telegraph, Philadelphia. The Custom of the Country: Tales of New Japan By Mrs. Hven Frassr, author of “ Letters from Japan,” ete, Just ready. Her letters from Japan are described as “simply captivating.” Cloth, $1.50 THE MACMILLAN COMPANY, Publishers, NEW YORK. , 8vo, $1.00 9 aan teres Pe ee SS i a oa
Page 5
tas : The Nation. NEW YORE, THURSDAY, JULY 20, 1899. The Week. In unconcealed consternation, our Im- perialists at Washington and through- out the country discovered on Monday that their policy of suppression and de- ceit is a melancholy ruin. The exposure by the newspaper correspondents at Ma- nila of the fraud which has been de- liberately practised upon the American people, is the most terrible blow which President McKinley has received. For to him it comes back. This futile war in the Philippines is his war. If his underlings have acted like knaves or fools, they are still his underlings, chosen by him, kept in office by him, directed in all things by him. Attempt to dodge responsibility as he may, the American people know where to fix and fasten it. If they have been tricked into thinking this war on the Filipinos anything but a criminal blunder, if they have been steadily deceived as to its causes and course and ‘1e prospect of its speedy termination, \. lliam McKin- ley is the man to be held ultimately re- sponsible. Politically, that is the most momentous inference to be drawn from the collapse of imperialistic lying, brought about by the united action of the American correspondents in Manila. There is really no surprise about the re- velations. They came in a dramatic way, and will shock the country, but they only confirm indications which have been accumulating for many weeks. Private letters, talks with returned cor- respondents and volunteer officers and men, and information obtained from na- val officers, all have pointed to the fact that official deception had been practised on a monstrous scale. As for Gen. Otis, we think of him mainly as an unlucky subordinate blun- deringly carrying out his orders. There can be no doubt where he got his inspi- ration to secrecy and deception. The phrases of his which the correspondents quote—that certain facts “would alarm the people at home,” or would “have the people of the United States hy the ears” —show that he was acting not as a gene- ral but as a politician. That is, he was taking the White House view that this is “a Republican war,” and must be con- ducted not so as to win battles but to win votes. In this, Gen. Otis no doubt thought he was just as faithfully serv- ing his master at Washington as he was by telegraphing the manifest absurdity the other day, that only the encourage- ment derived from anti-imperialists in America prevented the Filipinos from surrendering. That there was no mili- tary reason for the censorship is proved beyond all dispute by the correspond- ents, who show that the very statements of fact which Gen. Otis would not per- mit them to telegraph to this country, lest somehow the news get to the ears of the Filipinos, were printed in news- papers in Manila which freely circulated among the insurgents. It is clear enough that Gen. Otis was acting in all this matter of the censorship from puli- tical motives, under political instructions from Washington. This is the main rea- son why the exposure leaves him, as a mere general, in so ridiculous a position. Gen. Funston, who is frequently al- luded to as the “Roosevelt of the Philip- pine war,” and who is undoubtedly the popular hero of that war, is credited with sentiments about it which are extremely likely to be regarded as “treasonable” at Washington. Mr. Wild- man, our Consul at Hong Kong, repre- sents him as saying, in a statement of his views, that there “should be a little less gunpowder and more diplomacy” in our Philippine policy; that a “little di- plomacy at this time would go a long way towards settling the trouble and bringing peace and prosperity to these unfortunate islands”; that, strange as it may seem, he is “almost a peace-at- any-price man”; that “when life and property can be saved, it is almost crime not to follow that rule, whatever may be the circumstances arguing against it,” and that, though he is a Republican he is an anti-expansionist, but not a bitter one. His view of the future pos- sibilities of the islands seems to touch upon some of the hidden forces which are behind this extraordinary “war for humanity”: “Big syndicates and capitalists will be greatly benefited by the retention of these islands, but, outside a few exceptional in- dividual cases, I can see no advantage in their possession by the United States. The islands are so thickly populated and labor so cheap, there certainly is no inducement for the American laborer.’’ Secretary Wilson of the Department of Agriculture confirms this view of syndi- cates and capitalists by his glowing pic- ture of Old Glory floating over the butter cans of the Pacific Coast, which the Fili- pinos will buy by thousands after they have been subdued. Washington confirms, albeit with a lit- tle shame, the statement from Manila that this Government is going to sub- sidize the Sultan of Sulu. Not only that, it is going to make him a little present of $10,000, or so, to start with, just to put him in a good humor. This is a good deal of a novelty in the way of republi- can government, but the State Depart- ment officials put on a grave face and say that here is a shining proof of our sincerity in promising to give the Phi- lippines self-government. The dear pub- lic, how it does like to be humbugged, If it swallows this! Anybody who reads Foreman or Worcester can see for him- self the kind of “self-government” which the island of Sulu enjoys under its Sul- tan. It is the regular system of Mo- hammedan absolutism. The plain truth is, that the Administration has its hands so uncomfortably full in Luzon that it is appalled at the idea of having to fight in Sulu also. So it comes down with the dust, and tells the Sultan to do whatever he pleases in the way of oppression and arbitrary rule if he will only fly the American flag. Tue report comes from Boston that the Republican machine in Massachu- setts will oppose the reélection of Sena- tor Hoar because he is not in harmony with the Administration on the subject of the Philippines, and because he (Hoar) is reckoned an anti-Imperialist. It seems to us that it would be wiser for the ma- chinists to wait and see what the Mc- Kinley policy is, before throwing Senator Hoar overboard. It may prove that Mc- Kinley is in harmony with Hoar. Such a vacillating person is liable to turn up anywhere at any time. It would be most embarrassing if Senator Hoar and all the Massachusetts Republicans who agree with him were read out of the party for anti-Imperialism, and at the last moment McKinley himself should turn around and become an anti-Im- perialist also. However that may be, Senator Hoar cannot change his posi- tion. He has won a crown of exceeding glory by upholding the Declaration of Independence as a document of world- wide truth, applicable to all people strug- gling for liberty. whether white or black, whether the Malay or Caucasian, whe- ther of the New World or of the Old. If Massachusetts throws him overboard for this reason, the dishonor will be great, but it will be all her own. Unwitting confession of wrong-doing is often more conclusive than open beat- ing of the breast and acknowledging one’s self a miserable sinner, and this is what we are now getting from the Ad- ministration. Its virtuous declaration that all the commissions for the volun- teer army are to be given strictly for merit, is indirectly the plainest kind of admission that its different course last year was all wrong. One of its thick- and-thin defenders has a dim perception of the awkwardness of praising the new departure, and inserts a solemn explana- tion that to laud the new method fs not to admit that the old method was ne- farious. But if the old way of handing
Page 6
42 The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1777 over commissions to a “pull” or a purse was commendable, why abandon it? That is what the politicians are asking who are now overrunning the White House in search of military appoint- ments, If their demands must be re- fused this year, as calculated to injure the army, why were they not refused last year for the same reason? If a stern sense of duty compels the Presi- dent to appoint only experienced and capable officers now, where was his sense of duty last year? The baleful effect of President Mc- Kinley’s act in removing 10,000 offices from the merit system at the instance of the spoilsmen finds a fresh illustra- tion in the resolutions adopted by the Republican State convention of Ken- tucky on Thursday. The politicians there assembled hailed the new order with de- light. They so far forgot themselves that they repudiated that part of their own national platform which relates to civil-service reform, although it is bind- ing on the party until repealed or until a new platform is adopted. They for- got, also, that Mr. McKinley, or at all events his Secretary of the Treasury, adheres to the St. Louis platform, and maintains that the recent executive or- der is not in conflict with it. These tri- fling incongruities were not noticed by the Kentucky politicians. They went to the heart of the matter at once, and passed two resolutions on the subject, viz.: ‘“‘We reaffirm our adherence to principles and to policies proclaimed by the last na- tional Republican convention, except as to the civil service. ‘We commend the present amendment of civil-service rules by the President, and de- clare our belief that further modifications of existing civil-service legislation may be made with advantage to the public service.” For the purpose of contrast, we reprint the clause of the last Republican na- tional platform, which the party in Kentucky now repudiates in express terms: “The civil-service law was placed on the statute book by the Republican party, which has always sustained it, and we renew our repeated declarations that it shall be tho- roughly and honestly enforced, and extended wherever practicable.” An edifying controversy sprang up last week in New Hampshire, when Senator Chandler and Senator Gallinger appear- ed on opposite sides in a prosecution of the latter for levying contributions on federal office-holders for campaign pur- poses. This is a violation of the civil- service law, and ex-Governor Busiel took the initiative in calling Gallinger to ac- count for it. Gallinger thought that Chandler had inspired this movement against him, and he asked in the preli- minary investigation whether that was not the fact. When it came Chandler’s turn to testify, he said that he had with- drawn from membership of the cam- paign committees of his State on account of the passage of the civil-service law, and had advised Gallinger to do the same, and that when he found that Gal- linger was assessing federal office-hold- ers he left the committee rooms alto- gether. This was very becoming on the part of Chandler, and we set it down to his credit that, although not a friend of the civil-service law, he would not open- ly violate it or countenance its violation by remaining in the company of those who were levying assessments on office- holders. The real significance of the row be- tween these worthies is the neglect and contempt into which the whole civil- service law has fallen under the present Administration. As we have repeatedly shown, the system had been honey- combed, through unrebuked violations of the law, long before Mr. McKinley threw off the mask in his order turning over 10,000 offices to the spoilsmen. It is well known that case after case of flagrant disregard of the civil-service law and regulations has been brought to the attention of the President, who has effusively thanked and flattered his informants, and then done precisely no- thing to bring the offenders to justice. With the Chief Magistrate thus con- senting to see the law made a mockery, what wonder that senatorial bosses like Gallinger should go back unblushingly to the old system of blackmailing fede- ral employees? The violation of the law in New Hampshire wes notorious. A copy of the assessing circular, with Se- nator Gallinger’s name on it, was pro- duced. Now such assessments are cri- minal. A statute of the United States so declares, and provides a penalty of $500 for each offence. It is a statute, moreover, which was enforced under President Arthur, and offenders con- victed. A vigilant Executive, eager to put down this form of crime against the United States as well as all others, would long ago have instructed the United States District Attorney to look into the matter and see that the law was respected and enforced. But Mr. McKinley has been so busy sending greetings to the Christian Endeavor Convention that he has had no time to attend to his sworn duty. The importers of Swiss embroideries, in their proceedings to test the law un- der which Appraiser Wakeman acted in his harassing movements against them, drew out some facts of importance last week. One was, that the Collector of the Port did not, of his own motion, or- der a reappraisement of the goods; that he was satisfied with the first appraise- ment, but that he was instructed by Mr. Howell, the Assistant Secretary of the Treasury, to order such reappraisement. The law does not authorize the Assist- ant Secretary, or anybody except the Collector, to order the reappraisement of goods that have once been pass- ed. The question which the Board of General Appraisers have now to pass upon is, whether the Treasury Depart- ment is vested with such general powers of oversight that it can contravene or supplement the mandate of the law re- lating to the importation of merchandise in such a way as to inflict losses upon merchants for which they have -no re- medy. We trust that this question may be brought before the courts, and that it may be made known whether there is any limit to the persecution of that portion of the community whose busi- hess supplies the Government with two- thirds of its revenue. The republic of Mexico desires to con- solidate its debt in a 5 percent. gold bond to the amount of about $110,000,000, of which about $25,000,000 has been al- lotted by the contracting syndicate to the United States and Holland. The re- mainder goes to England and Germany. The loan has been underwritten by the syndicate of which the American branch is the house of J. P. Morgan & Co. The amount allotted to this country is small, but it has some significance in the fact that it is the first introduction of foreign government. loans to this market. It may have a further significance as being the first step of the republic of Mexico towards the gold standard. Mexico has the double standard in law, but the sin- gle silver standard in fact. All her reve- nues are collected in silver, and all her obligations are paid in that metal except such as are made specifically payable in London or Berlin. We shall hope to hear from our silver doctrinaires on this subject in due time. Senator Jones of Nevada might well devote a cou- ple of days to it, and Mr. Charles A. Towne of Minnesota might prove to the satisfaction of himself and George Fred Williams that the gold standard can never be adopted in Mexico even if her people and rulers desire it. The American-China Development Company is one of the evidences of the superabundance of capital in the United States for domestic use. The surplus which has been accumulating since our own Western territory was supplied with rather more railway mileage than was needful, must and will find an outlet. China presents a field that is inviting in the sense that it is a country of large resources as yet undeveloped. It is not yet known publicly what kind of a charter the American company has ob- tained for a railway from Han-Kow to Canton, or what, if any, obstacles have been put in the way of its realization by the Chinese authorities. It is report- ed from Washington, however, that Min- ister Conger has been instructed to use his good offices and influence to secure the effectual carrying out of the contract,
Page 7
July 20, 1899] The Nation. and the securing of other privileges of trade and investment in the Celestial Empire, but not to take joint action with any other Power in such a way as to form an international engagement. To this there can be no objection. That a large increase in importations of foreign goods follows a year of ex- traordinary domestic prosperity and pro- | fit has often been manifested in our history. It is not surprising, therefore, that imports for the fiscal year 1899, as last week’s statement shows, have in- creased $81,027,000 over 1898. Neverthe- less, the total importations of the year are smaller by far than those of any year in the decade past except 1898 and 1894. Two explanations are advanced for this remarkable result. Now and then, some belated protectionist will point with pride to the Dingley law as the cause of our relatively slow recourse to foreign markets. But this explanation can be easily blown away. Of the eighty-one millions increase in importations, seven- ty-two millions came from dutiable goods. In the similar trade year, 1880, under a similar tariff, imports increas- ed no less than $222,000,000, or nearly three times their present increase. Fur- thermore, the folly of talking of pro- tectionist barriers when our own manu- facturers were invading the foreign mar- kets, is so plain that he who runs may read. The simple fact, proved as con- clusively by our export trade as by our imports, is that American capital and American ingenuity have so far broken the fetters of protection that we no longer depend on foreign markets to meet an increasing home demand. This year, it is the foreign markets, even for manufactured iron goods, which depend on us to make good their shortage. Last May’s report, which showed for the eleven months an increase of $45,000,000 in imports of raw material for the use of our own exporting manufacturers, gives a hint at the great industrial change which has been in progress. What is most likely to strike the read- er’s attention, in the foreign trade state- ment for the fiscalyear ending with June, is the fact that the total export trade virtually shows no decrease whatever from the fiscal year 1898. Such a result would hardly have been predicted, a year ago, by any experienced. observer. The corner in wheat had then collapsed. Ex- portation of cereals from the United States had fallen to barely half the monthly average of May and June. The European famine and the European alarm over a possible blockade of wheat supplies were both ended. Europe, through its urgent purchases of our wheat in May and June, had raised its Own storehouse reserves nearly four- teen million bushels beyond their total of the year before, and this great in- crease in the supply at hand came at the | known in English p | moment when European farmers, for the | first time in three years, were reaping ; an abundant grain harvest. A heavy de- crease, both in quantity and in value, of agricultural exports from the United States was thus inevitable. Since agri- cultural shipments had made nearly 70 per cent. of the total American exports in the fiscal year 1898, it was natural to expect a rapid decrease in our export trade. As a matter of fact, agricultural! exports in the fiscal year just ended were less by nearly $86,000,000 than in the fiscal year 1898. But what had not been reck- oned on by the commercial prophets was the sudden development of a world-wide famine in iron, which, like the wheat famine of 1897 and 1898, was by far most acutely felt in Europe. The result was an increase in our steel and iron shipments for eleven months, shown by the May report (the latest classified summary available), exceeding by $21,- 000,000 those of the similar period in 1898. Simultaneously, the foreign de- mand for other commodities of manu- facture expanded rapidly, and the in- crease during the fiscal year, in all man- ufactured goods, can hardly have fallen short of $50,000,000. A similar increase in the foreign demand for products of the mines raised the total exports al- most to the level of 1898. When the Tammany rank and file grasp the full meaning and effect of the new rules and regulations which the State Civil-Service Commissioners have prepared for this city, they will not only agree with ex-Senator Plunkitt about the “civil-service curse,” but will, unconsciously, of course, parody the ex- clamation of Shylock by saying the “curse never fell upon Tammany till now”! The State Commissioners have eliminated most of the concessions which they made in the conference with the City Commissioners, greatly redu- cing the number of places which are to be exempt from competitive examina- tions, and placing in the competitive class many which have hitherto not been there. They have also taken from the appointing powers the right to set aside persons heading the eligible lists and to substitute others for them, and have in- serted such perfectly fiendish require- ments as that causes for removal must be filed, and that sworn certification must be made that an office-holder has actually done the work for which he is paid a salary, before he can get his mo- ney. There will be groans and writhings in Tammany when this “curse” falls, and the feeling towards Mayor Van Wyck, who made it possible, is not likely to be kindly. An acute English statesman said long ago that Mr. Chamberlain was the near- est approach to an American politician | occurrences will not make that opinion seem less just. There was the revelation in Parliament the other day that Cham- berlain owned stock in the Niger Com- | pany, just bought up by the Government. He confessed a certain indelicacy in the | situation, but indignantly repelled any suspicion of official impropriety. Yet it is matter of public notoriety that he vi- sited with severe denunciation anoth- er public officer for doing the same thing But he jauntily puts this all aside in a manner that is not only American but Blaineish, which is, of course, another way of saying “intensely American.”” And he has a true American agility in slip- ping away when “cornered.” Thus, in the debate a little while ago on the In- dian sugar duties, Sir Henry Fowler produced a formal opinion by Mr. Cham- berlain, both as public man and as eco- nomist, flatly opposed to the course which he is now eagerly advocating. But did this trouble the Colonial Secretary? Not in the least. Why rake up his old speeches? Whatever he may have said in the past, this is what he says now, and honorable gentlemen who differ with him had better look out or they will lose their seats. Truly, the sincerest flattery—by imitation—of the ways of the American politician. English war preparations go on, but it is difficult to see how there can ,\be a war with the Transvaal. Mr. Chamberlain thinks that President Kriiger’s conces- sions respecting the franchise for the Outlanders are tricky and may be illu- sory in practice; but the Prime Minister of the Cape declares, on the contrary, that they are generous and satisfactory. This must have great weight with Eng- lish public opinion. Though the Gov- ernment is plainly determined to be ready for the war, if war must come, yet it just as plainly expects a peaceful solu- tion. One curious item in the war mea- sures is the announcement that the Eng- lish troops are supplied with the Dum- Dum bullet. This shattering missile has been defended as necessary for use against savages, and on that ground alone the English delegates at The Hague voted that it might be used in war. A civilized soldier, when he gets a small-calibre steel bullet through his diaphragm, knows enough to stop right where he is. But Zulus and Dervishes and Pathans rather like being made a sieve of in that way, and come rushing on as before. Hence the necessity of a ball that will “stop” them when it hits. But how about the Boers? Is the use of the Dum-Dum against them intended as an insulting suggestion that they are no better than savages? Or will they take it as a tribute to their prowess? It seems a very doubtful form of com- pliment, as well as, we must say, a very doubtful proof of England’s desire to make war “humane.”
Page 8
4 The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1777 THE SILENCE OF M’KINLEY. Among the great men to whom the President’s adulators compare him, sim- ply by way of showing what a composite picture of greatness he is, we often see the name of Lincoln. That patient and humor-supported man, having gone where envy is extinguished, will not feel outraged by the comparison; and his admirers can afford to smile at it as he might have done. But they may, how- ever, even granting the asserted likeness, reluctantly point out some differences. Perhaps the chief one, which instantly turns the comparison into contrast, is to be found in Lincoln’s habit of freely informing the country of his plans and policies; of frankly and in person an- swering criticism; of pursuing, in short, the method of reagonable publicity. It is said that the President resembles Lincoln in carefully watching the de- velopment of public opinion, and never getting too far in advance of it. Mc- Kinley’s friends proudly accept the de- scription of him as a man with “his ear to the ground.” It shows how like Lin- coln he is. Well, if it is true that Lin- coln listened, it is also true that he gave people something to listen to. His pub- lic utterances were as frequent as they were frank. One has only to run over the index to Hay and Nicolay to see how numerous are the letters which Lin- coln wrote and published to explain and defend his policy. His letter to Greeley of 1862; his letter concerning Vallandig- ham’s arrest and imprisonment; his great letter to the Illinois Republicans in 1863—‘The Father of Waters again goes unvexed to the sea’—all are specimens. It was Lincoln’s habit, at strategic moments and under adverse criticism, to throw out these letters of his which were truly half-battles. He not only followed but formed public sen- timent. Now no one could reasonably ask Mr. McKinley to write letters worthy of be- ing named the same day with those of Abraham Lincoln, one of the greatest masters of style that ever lived. Any man living might well shrink from that comparison. But if the President cannot be expected to put pen to paper and rout his opponents as Lincoln did, he can at least be expected to say something. It will not do for him to fall back on the dignity of his office as a justifica- tion of his silence. Lincoln did not make the same office undignified by his way of speaking out in person. In critical times like these, when so many questions of domestic and foreign policy are hotly debated, it is the duty of the President to take the people into his confidence; it is their right to know what he thinks and means to do. But where Lincoln was ready and willing to tell what he thought and intended, McKinley wraps himself in silence as in a garment. Take the civil-service order. Expert reformers agree with expert spoilsmen that it is a step not only backward, but downward—not only off the platform, but into the mud. Various half-hearted and inconsistent explanations have been at- tempted by McKinley’s subordinates,but he himself remains dumb. Why does he not come forward in person to defend the order, if it can be defended? A special duty to do so is laid upon him. He has not always been so voiceless about civil-service reform. He spoke and voted for it in Congress. He com- mitted himself to it explicitly in his let- ter of acceptance. Yet thousands of his friends and supporters are sorrowfully saying that his acts have eaten his words. Can any one imagine Lincoln remaining silent under such circum- stances? Is it “dignity” on McKinley’s part, or is it confusion of face and un- certainty and dismay? He may be sure that as long as he says nothing, people will think the worst. As to his Philippine policy, the case is even more flagrant. All the light the President has given us on that subject is but darkness intensified. His brief references to it in his message to Con- gress, his studiously non - committal speech in Boston, and his car-platform platitudes in the South are all we have to go upon, and they do not get us for- ward one inch. What Mr. McKinley is now doing in the Philippines, what he means to do, the country does not know. His angriest defenders do not agree in their statements of his policy. Is he going to kill the Filipinos with kindness or with bullets? Is he going to buy up Aguinaldo as he has undertaken to buy up the Sultan of Sulu? Is his policy peace or a sword? The country is left in blank ignorance about all this. The oracles are dumb. McKinley lies with his ear glued to the ground, but not one stroke does he himself give to con- vey a vibration to the ears of others, This persistent and astonishing silence of the chosen leader of the people, when so great a crisis is upon us, is susceptible of various explanations. We think the most plausible one is that the President does not speak because he has nothing to say. This was Sydney Smith’s ex- planation of the taciturnity of English- men; they kept still because there was nothing in their heads. If Mr. McKinley cannot defend his civil-service order, no doubt his true plan is silence, and mighty little of that, as the Irish magis- trate said. If he has no Philippine policy except one of drift, he is wise to keep close-mouthed, and, like Hotspur’s wife, refuse to utter what he does not know. His silence is a good deal of a puzzle if he is a second Lincoln; but there is a theory of portentous and solemn silence which an increasing num- ber of people are saying exactly fits Mc- Kinley’s case. It is laid down in Shak- spere: “O my Antonio, I do know of these That therefore only are reputed wise For saying nothing, when, I am very sure, If they should speak, would almost damn those ears Which, hearing them, would call their brothers fools.’’ IT WAS A “BACKWARD STEP.” In one respect it is to be regretted that proof of the inaccuracy of Secretary Gage’s defence of President McKinley’s recent civil-service order is so abundant. It swells the answer which the. Secre- tary of the Civil-Service Reform League makes, to such a volume as greatly to reduce the number of persons who would naturally be inclined to read it. Yet every word of it is well worth reading, for there is scarcely a sentence in it which does not contain an item of proof that the President has violated his most solemn pledges, and that the worst of- fender in breaking down the law is Sec- retary Gage himself. Whoever else may be fitted to speak as an authority on civil-service reform, Mr. Gage clearly is not. He has been one of the worst ene- mies, if not the very worst enemy, the cause has had in official life since the original law was enacted In formulating his evidence that the President’s order is a “backward step,” and does restore to the spoilsmen a large number of places which had been taken from them, Mr. McAneny has very wisely put the proceedings of the Trea- sury Department first. Secretary Gage invited this distinction when he made himself the champion of the President’s course; but if he had not done so, the record of his department so far eclipses all others in assault upon the system that it is thereby entitled tu first place in the assembling of the proof. Whatever else he may read, or omit to read, we entreat every one in- terested in good government to peruse carefully the passages in Mr. McAneny’s reply which relate to the conduct of the Treasury Department. Mr. McAneny shows, in the first place, that Secretary Gage, when he entered upon office, foun: the Internal Revenue Service wholly subject to civil-service rules; that he began, long before the recent order was issued, to permit such violations of the law as freed a large portion of the service from these rules, and that at present the entire service has been restored to spoils politics. When it is remembered that, under our new internal-revenue laws, the chief portion of the income of the Government, aggregating no less than $276,000,000 during the year end- ing July i, is collected through -thia branch of the service, the full meanng of this betrayal becomes apparent. In the second place, Mr. McAneny shows how, under the guise of war-emer- gency appointments, the rules have been broken down so completely, by one piece of hostile legislation after another, that all appointments, in both the Treasury and War Departments, are now made without competitive examination. Ail temporary appointments, of which there
Page 9
July 20, 1899] ‘The Nation. have been a great many, have been made | permanent by the President’s order. In instance after instance where the law was violated, Secretary Gage, though re- quested to interfere and assert his au- thority to enforce the law, has declined to do so. The mass of evidence against him is overwhelming, and furnishes melancholy reading for reformers who thought they had a champion of the first order in Mr. Gage when he was made Secretary. The original charge of the Civil-Ser- vice-Reform League, that the President’s order withdraws fully 10,000 places from the classified service, is shown by offi- tial records to be strictly accurate. Equally conclusive proof is advanced in support of the League’s other charges Temporary appointments are shown to have been made permanent, and persons appointed after passing one of the lowe1 grades of competitive examination ar« being transferred, after a “‘pass’’ exami- nation only, to higher grades. “The effect of this practice,’ as Mr. McAneny says, “is likely to be that the higher grades, in time, will be placed on a vir- tually non-competitive basis’’—that is, the whole system will be overthrown. This destructive process will be assisted by the other provision of the President’s order which permits the reinstatement, at the discretion of department offi- cials, of persons who have been removed from the service for any stated reason. This opens the door for the return of incompetent and unfit men, and no- body who knows anything about poli- | tics will question that the opportunity will be fully improved. We have given only a cursory and in- complete outline of Mr. McAneny’s re- ply. He devotes small space, and very properly so, to Secretary Gage’s ingenu- ous contention that the opportunities which the President’s order gives for evasion of the law: will not be improved because the Administration does not in- tend to use them. If the power was not intended for use, why was it conferred? | RESPONSIBILITY public judgment about it will be un- availing. OF. LAWYERS CITIZENS. The recent meeting of the Bar Asso- ciation of Pennsylvania was in several ways of unusual importance. Mr. Horn- AS blower’s address was itself worthy of | public attention, and the fact that he was heartily applauded for defending the po- litical ideals which have distinguished our country, is extremely encouraging to the truly patriotic. To the mass of the people the Constitution is but a meaning- less name. To most of the educated it is a technical term, which they can perhaps define, but do not comprehend. To law- yers, however, such an instrument is full of the profoundest significance. They know what wonderful! skill, what patient thought, what prolonged labor, were em- ployed in its fabrication, and they alone can fully appreciate the prodigious bless- ings that have resulted from its exist- ence. stand the mischief that will follow from disregarding it, and they, more than any other class, can effectively protest against its violation. They are called on They are in position to under- | | Indiana, and as citizens to use their professional skill | in the public interest, just as doctors | are called on for similar exertions in times of pestilence. The more they up- lift their voices, like Mr. Hornblower, | the sooner will sane counsels be listened | to by our politicians. As an illustration of what can be done | | in the way of procuring better laws by combined and persistent professional ac- tion, the report of the committee on uni- form legislation may be referred to. It is now about eight years since this mat- ter was seriously taken up by the pro- | fession, and in many of the States Com- missioners have been appointed whose | conferences have had very substantial Has it not always been the chief aim of | every spoilsman to “beat the law,” if he | | systematize the acknowledgment and execution of written instruments, the | could? Is it not a fact that every oppor- tunity to “beat” it which the new order affords is already being improved? And this is not the worst aspect of the situation at Washington. Mr. McAneny declares that, for the first time since the National Civil-Service Commission was created, access to its records has been refused to him, because he wished to find there proof of the Administration's bad faith. This fact, coupled with the spectacle of a Civil-Service Commission- er, appointed by President McKinley, de- fending publicly this “backward step,” results. to recognize the importance of enacting laws with some reference to those al- ready existing in neighboring communi- ties. Bills have been perfected which sealing of deeds, the execution of wills, and the law of negotiable paper. Some states have already adopted these bills, | and, the way having been broken, other shows clearly enough what the friendly | | Court and Client in Criminal Cases.” He | professions of the Administration to- wards the reform are worth. The first step towards the overthrow of the entire system has been taken, and all efforts to disguise the crime or confuse the 4 States will more easily be induced to fol- low. Here, we may fairly say, we have genuine reforms due to a recognition by | more on celerity than severity. 45 description of crime he attributed large- ly to the feeling of impatience with le- gal delay, and distrust of the enforce- ment of justice. “Men not criminals themselves in intent refuse to wait for the law, and commit crime in the name and for the purpose of justice.” The number of homicides in the country at large is appalling. figures exist, but those which are pre- sented may be reduced one-half and the result is still frightful. Judge Parker of the United States District Court, Arkan- sas, states that from 1890 to 1895, in- clusive, there were nearly 44,000 homi- cides in the United States, while in the same period there were 723 legal exe- cutions and 1,118 lynchings. The At- torney-General has reported to Congress that in a single year there were 10,500 homicides, 100 convictions of murder by the courts, and 240 executions by ille- gal agencies. Judge Hillyer of Georgia declares that in 1896 there were more men murdered than fell at Gettysburg. Many States are comparatively free from this stain of bloodshed, but in Ohio, and Illinois there have been episodes that indicate the existence of dangerous tendencies. As one cause of this deplorable blot on our civilization, Justice Mitchell did not hesitate to assign the inexcusable delays of the law. It has long been recognized that the efficacy of punish- ment as a deterrent from crime depends Lawyers are always present in our legislatures and they can generally shape laws as they desire. In the administration of justice they have almost complete con- trol. Were they to devote themselves to accelerating the course of justice, they would be successful. Lawyers are often unjustly blamed, as individuals, for de- lay in bringing cases to trial. But for delays and hindrances and obstructions No very trustworthy | in the course of the trial and afterwards, Legislatures have been brought | lawyers of their responsibility as mem- bers of our society. This illustration serves to give addi- tional force to the address of Justice Mitchell of the Supreme Court of Penn- sylvania. His theme was “Fidelity to referred to the alarming increase of crimes committed, not by the criminal classes, but against them, which go un- | of justice. der the general name of lynch law. This | Judge Mitchell said, counsel must accept the heaviest responsibility. They have a duty to the court as well as to the client. “Counsel represents the prisoner to de- fend his rights. In so doing he is bound to exercise competent learning, and to be faithful, vigilant, and resolute. But he is at the same time an officer of the court, part of the system which the law provides for the preservation of indivi- dual rights in the administration of jus- tice, and bound by his official oath to fidelity as well to the court as to the client.” While individual lawyers were to blame for abuse of their position, Jus- tice Mitchell held that the criminal law was full of umreasonable technicalities. Under the sanguinary code of an earlier day, these technical devices protected the interests of humanity, but under our milder laws they merely defeat the enda “The bar must take care that it shall not fail of its proper share tn the right establishment of a new order
Page 10
46 The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1777 of things, lest a whirlwind of popular impatience and distrust shall sweep away not only the hurtful obstructions, but with them some barriers that are true safeguards of innocence.” These are wise words. They are addressed to those who are peculiarly responsible for the preservation of life and property from violence. If there is to be any re- form, it must be carried through by law- yers. If lynching is to be checked, it must be by means of such reform. The profession is called on to act, both by its own members and by the laity. As they have shown what they can accom- plish in other directions, let them now direct their efforts to this end. It may be called a “parochial” question; but 10,000 homicides a year is a phenomenon large enough to demand serious conside- ration. COURTS AND COMBINATIONS. The signs are abundant that the politicians of both parties will declare war against what they call “Trusts.” The term “Trust” has established itself in the political vocabulary, and lack of significance will not displace it. It is a substitute for the “money power,” a term which has done service for so many years that it may be regarded as worn out. The “money power” was the great bugbear during the early part of the century; and when Jackson was carry- ing on war against the Bank, the fury of the demagogues over the diabolical malignities of wealthy corporations ex- ceeded the present display. The real ob- ject of attack then was accumulated wealth, and that is the object now. Cor- porations are denounced, but it is, of course, the men composing the corpora- tions and owning their wealth that are really guilty, and they are capable of oppressing the people severally as well as by combination. The obstacles which the demagogues will encounter when they undertake to legislate against combinations of capi- taliste are set forth in a judgment ’re- cently pronounced by the Court of Er- rors of New Jersey. A number of con- cerns engaged in making pottery in that State were bought and their works car- ried on by a corporation; a condition of the purchase being that the men bought out should not engage in the pottery business again within fifty years, except in a few remote States and Territories. Having received their money, some of these men proceeded to establish new potteries, and to compete actively with the larger corporation. On application by the latter, the Court of Errors held that the operation of the new potteries by these men should be enjoined. Their only justification for refusing to be bound by their contract was that such a contract was contrary to public po- licy, and the Court of Errors held that it was not. For, in the first place, it was shown that a contract by the vendor of a busi- ness and its good-will that he will not compete with the purchaser, although a contract in restraint of trade, is not op- posed to public policy when it is not ab- solute, and is reasonably required for the protection of the purchaser in his enjoyment of the business purchased. On any other principle, the good-will of a business would have no market value. No one could afford to pay any- thing for it if the seller could at once resume it. As Sir George Jessel said: “If there is one thing which more than another public policy requires, it is that men of full age and competent under- standing shall have the utmost liberty of contract, and that their contracts, when entered into freely and voluntarily, shall be held sacred and shall be en- forced by courts of justice.” In other words, freedom of contract is more im- portant than almost anything else. To allow a person to enter into a contract. obtain the benefits of it, and then re- pudiate his obligations under it, is, as another English judge has said, “prima facie, at all events, contrary to the in- terests of any and every country.” And so our Federal Courts have held that the burden is on him who would avoid a contract because it is against public policy. Unless the Legislature is pre- pared to enact that no sale of the good- will of a business shall be valid, it can- not enact that no agreement not to com- pete in business shall be valid; or rather if it enacts the latter rule, this involves the former one. Furthermore, if a man may lawfully buy the good-will of one business, how shall he be prevented from buying that of two? And if he may go so far, why may he not go further, and finally ac- quire all the concerns engaged in a par- ticular indusiry? In the New Jersey case, it was urged that the five potter- ies bought were the only ones in the country making what is called sanitary ware, which has become one of the ne- cessaries of life, and that the intention of the purchaser was to obtain a mo- nopoly. Shall the Legislature then enact that no one shall buy all the factories making a certain necessary thing? Or shall it be lawful to buy all but one or all but 10 per cent. of them? And shall it forbid the purchaser of a part to have any interest in the remainder? Or shall there be unlimited freedom of purchase if the purchaser does not intend a mo- nopoly? And who is to tell, and how, whether he does or not? According to the New Jersey court, “the contracts in question were not intended to withdraw, and do not appear to have withdrawn, from work a single workman in that in- dustry. They restrain a coniparatively small number of capitalists, who had previously employed their capital in such manufacture, from continuing to do so. The entire capital of the country, except theirs, is free to be employed in the manufacture.” There was no proof that the public would suffer under such a consolidation as was effected. The situation had no peculiarity be- cause a corporation did what an indi- vidual might do. The New Jersey law authorizes a corporation to buy the stock of another corporation. If such pur- chases are prohibited, as has been else- where done, individuals may make the purchase, and organize a corporation afterwards to carry on the business. What the demagogues must do, if they wish to prevent the carrying on of busi- ness by combinations, is to forbid not only corporations but also firms and in- dividuals from agreeing to carry on any industry. Unless this is done, indivi- duals will direct the policy of competing corporations by controlling their stock. Such management may be inconvenient and expensive, but it is possible. The cost of production would be increased, and the public would have to pay a part at least of the increased cost of products. Perhaps we shall try the experiment, but it is doubtful if the public will like the results of the policy after it is adopted. All coéperation involves combination, and it is not yet the fashion to denounce coéperation. Combination on a great scale is the consequence of doing busi- ness on a great scale. It results from the great accumulation of wealth in mo- dern times. Our governments can do much to hinder the accumulation of wealth, and thus limit combinations. We have yet to see how they can otherwise prevent them; nor is it easy to frame a statute against great combinations with- out including small ones. TAXES AND INTEREST. It was laid down as a maxim by Adam Smith, that wherever a great deal can be made by the use of money, a great deal will commonly be given for the use of it; and that wherever little can be made by it, less will commonly be given for it. Hence it may be inferred, in a rough way, that profits vary with the rate of interest. Accepting this rule, we cannot fail to be impressed with the decline that has taken place in the rate of profit in this country within the last twenty-five or thirty years. Before 1873, seven per cent. was a common rate for money loaned on bond and mortgage in the city of New York, and a not uncom- mon rate for railroad mortgages. Five per cent. was a rate hardly thought of even by persons and corporations en- joying the best credit. As money was freely borrowed at those rates, it would follow that the average rate of profit was from 12 to 15 per cent., taking the country at large. In many lines of busi- ness, and in certain parts of the country, the rate was higher than this; but in the older and richer regions this rate was probably not generally exceeded,
Page 11
i a rs July 20, 1899] The Nation. At the present moment, the rate of interest is little, if any, more than one- half what it was in 1870. A great deal of money is loaned at 3 per cent., and many very large issues of 34 per cent. bonds are quoted above par. Frequently the rates for call loans are even lower, and the lending capacity of the country seems to be unlimited. Under these cir- cumstances we know, @ priori, that the rate of profit must fall. Competition set- tles that. If money can be borrowed at 3 or 4 per cent., there are plenty of alert men who will borrow it and undersell those who are trying to maintain the old-fashioned rate of profit. Whether profits of 6 or 7 per cent. are sufficient to content the ordinary business man cannot as yet be accurately determined; but under present conditions the ave- rage rate of profit cannot long be main- tained above that figure. The firm or corporation that can earn, year in and year out, 7 per cent. on its capital, is doing as well as can be expected, Such a decline in the rate of profit has necessarily many important economic, as well as social, results. One of these is the extinction of business enterprises having small capitals. Their earnings are not enough to pay the wages of management in addition to the wages of labor. Another result, no doubt, is the combination of business concerns. The steadily falling rate of profit compels at- tention to economies, and in the office ex- penses and the cost of marketing goods very great economies have been effected. Such economies enable particular con- cerns to maintain for atime a high rate of profit; but such success can be, in most cases, only temporary. By the aid of protective duties, patents, and other conditions favoring monopoly, many en- terprises will doubtless long continue to pay very high profits on the capital orl- ginally invested, but even they will be unable to maintain such profits indefi- nitely. Such being the return of capital, the amount demanded by the tax-gatherer becomes a very important subject of consideration. _Here we find no such tendency as is seen in the case of inte- rest and profits. Taxes have very gene- rally increased. The indirect taxes col- lected by the United States authorities have been enlarged in number and in rate. The direct taxes levied in the States and municipalities, while not generally much higher in rate, are dou- ble what they were, if we compare them with the rate of interest. It is this fact to which public attention should be di- rected, for it is never referred to. Little dependence can be placed on the census statistics, but we know from other sources the condition of affairs in most of our cities, In some few cases, and those not unimportant, the valuation of property has not been raised in the pro- portion in which its real value has been enhanced; but as a general rule assess- ments have kept pace with the advance in values, and in some cases have sur- passed it. Hence, it may fairly be said that even if the nominal rate of taxa- tion were the same as formerly, the ac- tual burden would be twice what it was. | In other words, the taxes levied on ac: cumulated property are as high as ever, while the revenue derived from such property is only one-half what it was. Such an increase of the burden of gov- ernment cannot be regarded without alarm. It is, of course, to be remem- bered that many things are done by the State that were formerly not done. There have been great improvements in streets and parks, in water and light, in public buildings, in police, and in education. Such improvements, however, could have been made and could be maintained for much less than they cost. The manner in which our rulers spend the taxes in all large communities has long been a scandal. Every one knows the condition of affairs in Illinois, in Pennsylvania, and in New York. In our own State many millions of dollars have been wast- ed within a few years, under the pre- tence of improving the canals. The evi- dence is overwhelming that our rulers spend the taxes badly, and the increase of taxation must therefore be regarded as an economic evil. Little further fall in the rate of interest can be anticipated, and if the increase in taxatign is not ar- rested, the prosperity of the country can- not continue. At least we must be pre- pared for a material reduction in the rate at which wealth and population have heretofore increased. A MODERN MASQUE. LONDON, July 1, 1899. The Art Workers’ Guild is little known, even by name, to the outside world, but it is probably the most genuine society of ar- tists in London. It includes men who prac- tise every art and every craft, from the | painter and sculptor to the basket-maker and metal-worker, from the illustrator and architect to the painter and designer. It finds a place for artists as entirely opposed in intention and method as Sir Edward Poynter and Mr. Sargent, as Mr. Walter Crane and Sir L. Alma-Tadema; in a word, so far from imitating the foolish exclusive- ness of the Royal Academy, it aims at be- ing as representative as possible, and at encouraging a practical union of all the arts. It has its headquarters at Clifford's Inn, one of the picturesque old inns of court just off Fleet Street, where the mem- bers are understood to meet and talk, speak- ing their minds with a freedom that would be alarming to the seeker after Academic honors. But such is the Guild’s rare talent for keeping its own affairs to itself that, beyond this, little can be said of it with authority. Its performance of a Masque at the Guildhall this week is its first appear- ance before the public. Why it should have decided to make a public appearance at all, may not be easy to explain. But perhaps the example of the balls and processions arranged, from time immemorial almost, by the artists of Paris and Munich, together with the know- ledge of the Guild's ability to rival them, had something to do with it; or perhaps it was simply the desire to create a beautiful pageant. If the Masque was the form in which this desire was eventually expressed, it was probably because no other manner of pageant is so essentially English, and gives such a chance to the invention and fancy of every kind of artist and craftsman. In the days of the famous masques, the spec- tacle was always the great thing. While the legitimate boards were still as bare and unadorned as the Elizabethan Stage So- ciety loves to show them, the Masque was as splendid and gorgeous and lovely as the artist, with a royal or princely purse at his command, could make it. Ben Jonson might write for the theatre, too, but it was only for the Masque that the services of Inigo Jones were in request, and this calling-in of the artist was its special dis- tinction. The theatre gradually borrowed the gorgeousness but left out the artist, and in the gaudy glitter of Drury Lane, in the showy pretentiousness of the Lyceum and Her Majesty’s, most people to-day have forgotten that there is no reason in the world why the picture on the stage should not be as beautiful, as dignified, as har- monious as the picture on canvas. There have been two or three revivals of the Masque during the present century, but the object then was rather to borrow the pretty, artificial old fashion of celebrating a royal event than to take advantage of a delightful form of pictorial expression. The Art Workers, on the contrary, have been interested above all in the pictorial possibilities. What they wanted to revive was, not Ben Jonson's, but Inigo Jones's share in the pageant. But, of course, there had to be a play, or dramatic allegory, as motive for the pic- ture, and this they undertook to write them- selves, for the Masque was to be from begin- ning to end their own creation. If they may not be able to boast a Milton, there are two among their number, Mr. Selwyn Image and Mr. Henry Wilson, who write admirable verse, and three or four others, Mr. Waiter Crane, Mr. Christopher Whall, Mr. C, R. Ashbee, Mr. Harrison Townsend, who can | at least versify fluently. The regret is that William Morris, for many years an active member, and for one the Master, of the Guild, did net live long enough to join in the work, for he could have made it worthy to rank as a poem with the Masques of Tudor and Stuart days. However, as it was, “Beauty's Awakening’ answered its pur- pose excellently. The princess of the fairy tale was transformed into the Spirit of All Things Beautiful, the redemption of London was the joyous result of the kiss of the Prince in his new role as the good Knight Trueheart; and, if this seems very naive, tt must be remembered that not even Milton in “Comus” ventured upon a subtle or intricate plot. As the pageant slowly took shape, as the scheme for it, that originated about a year ago, was more and more developed, it was realized, no less to the astonishment of the Art Workers than of any one else, what a big thing had been undertaken. Big as it was, however, professional assistance was called in only for the music, composed by Mr. Malcolm Lawson--though at the per- formance it was a member of the Guild, Mr. Belcher, an architect, who led the orchestra
Page 12
48 The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1777 —and for the stage management, as it was found absolutely indispensable to have some one who could devote the necessary time and attention to every rehearsal, and also to the proper drilling of the dancers. But it was a more serious matter when it became evident that the scheme had outgrown the limits of the Guild’s own hall in Clifford’s Inn, where it was first intended that the Masque should be given. The new version of the old story meant many dancers and group- ings and processions; it meant, besides, from a hundred and fifty to two hundred per- formers. In Clifford’s Inn hall was scarcely more space than for a stage of the re- quired size. It was useless to think of the ordinary theatre with its tinsel and gilding and sham; a more discordant frame could not be imagined. But, with nothing less than a stroke of genius, the Art Workers deter- mined to ask the Lord Mayor to lend them the Guildhall. There is no more beautiful or statelier hall in London; it is in the very midst of the richest and most commercial part of a town where, according to some authorities, the Spirit of All Things Beauti- ful sleeps her soundest. Moreover, it is the scene of the most impressive and magnificent official pageants still left in the world, though, it must be confessed, the actors in these are apt to look rather sheepish and ashamed of themselves. Somehow, it is hard to say just how, but largely through the intervention of Mr. Merwyn Macartney, the Master of the Guild, the Lord Mayor and the Corporation were induced to consent, and though, afterwards, the County Council, by the imposition of tedious and vexatious re- strictions, did its best to prevent the Guild’s profiting by the generosity of the City, in the end the Guildhall was delivered over to the carpenter for the great part of ome week, and to the performers for the greater part of the next. And, indeed, this has proved but another of numerous occasions when the City refuses to justify its reputa- tion for outer barbarianism. I think most people, when they came away from the finest pageant seen in London for many a long day, must have felt, with me, that the County Council, for all its pretensions as a refining influence and a promoter of art, can still take a lesson or two from the much- abused Corporaticn. The stage, set up at that end of the Guild- hall over which Gog and Magog preside, was the triumph of the Masque. It was designed by Mr. Henry Wilson, an architect of whom the world will be sure to hear more in the future, and it was as little as possible like the usual big, bare stage, with its flimsy scenery and stale devices—it was a ‘“‘lordly pleasure-house” rather, a Palace of Art, its architecture as stately and sumptuous a set- ting for the groups and figures that passed across it, as the arcades and terraces of Ve- ronese are for his painted courts and cere- monies. Wide steps led up from the audience to a great central portal, flanked on either side by graceful columns, gray and cool in color, harmonizing with the surrounding stone-work. Above the great golden arch, above the spreading colonnades, towering to the mysterious roof, was a majestic vague veil of blue, over it no meaningless ara- besques, no bedraggled flowers, but only one single silver figure keeping guard in the cen- tre. The solemn, the immense mystery of the proscenium concentrated the eye on the stage; nor was there in the detail and orna- ment any of the tawdry prettiness or glar- ing tinsel, so dear to the professional stage decorator, to distract it. At the back of the stage were three rounded arches, filled as low as the capitals with a dull gold lattice; and every capital—the de- sign of Mr. Wilson, carried out by Mr. Stir- ling Lee and Mr. Murphy—was delicately sculptured, and painted in green and red and the same dull gold, giving just the right notes of color. Hangings, like rare tapes- tries, fell between the columns at the sides. A drop-curtain, for certain scenes, represent- ed, very conventionally, a wood; for others, it rose, showing the three arches, with, beyond, the hedge of flowers and briers that must enclose the palace of every Sleeping Beauty, and that was replaced for the last scene of all by “arras green and blue.”” Nothing could have been simpler, nothing more imposing. When the stage was dimly lit, and you looked through the Romanesque portal to where the gold of lattice and capitals glowed in the tender gloom, it was like looking into one of the shadowy chapels of St. Mark’s, somebody said to me. Mystery is essential to all great art, we have been told. It was the element of mystery Mr. Wilson introduced in his stage that was one reason of his success, nor was the importance of this quality undervalued in the arrangement and action of the seve- ral scenes. On the professional stage there is always either a uniform illumination or a uniform darkness, or else a sudden, abrupt flash upon one figure. Gradation of light and shade is not understood by the pro- fessional managers. But the Art Workers knew its value in a picture, and their sole idea was to produce pictures. Bvery cos- tume, down to the most minute ornament, the most trivial detail, had been designed by one or another among their number; every emblem borne by the different cha- racters, every chair set upon the stage, was their work; and yet they never hesitated to subordinate the beauty of the various parts, when necessary, to make a perfect whole. There were no footlights; but why should there have been? There are no foot- lights in a picture. The illumination came from the sides, it seemed to issue myste- riously from the clustered columns. Some critics have found fault with this, as is natural, for critics have a way of damn- ing everything they do not understand be- cause it is new te them. But in the crude glare to which the conventions of the thea- tre have accustomed us, the daintiest or most splendid color-schemes would inevitably lose. When, after the Prolocutor, who, in his red and black robes and laurel wreath of gold, introduced every scene, had made his first announcement, and the curtains were drawn, and at the back of the stage, below the golden lattice, the Sleeping Beau- ty, with her Seven Lamps grouped about her, was seen in a soft pale green light, it was in very truth like an enchanted palace. And when, into the midst of these ‘‘perfect forms in perfect rest,’’ the Fallen Leaves of the Forest—children in russet and green and gold and scarlet—were blown by the Four Winds and sent whirling and swirling in a rhythmical flight, to the strange, old, wind-like music of Mr. Arnold Dolmetsch and his orchestra, now they were but dim, shadowy shapes, as if clouds were sweeping across the unseen sky, now they shone forth radiantly, as if in a sudden gleam of sunshine, so gay that a little butterfly, with orange-streaked wings, came fluttering down the stage. The management of the light was masterly, both from the sym- bolical and pictorial standpoint. Without it, the dance would have been charming, for the dresses designed by Mr. Louis Davis were very pretty and graceful, and Mr. Arnold Dolmetsch and his musicians, in their antique costumes, with their curious old instruments, grouped at the foot of the steps, were as picturesque. But the play of light made it more than charming—as exquisite a poem as the dance of the nymphs in Corot’s glades. I was sitting at the far end of the hall; the audience was in all but complete darkness, out of which loomed up the gray walls of the ancient building and the ghostly monuments of Pitt and Wellington; and the stage in the distance, with its shifting lights and shadows and its dancing leaves, was as unreal, as fantastic as a Midsummer Night’s Dream. There was another lovely picture when the Knight Trueheart in his glittering ar- mor slept in a mystical forest that made one think of Meriin and Vivian in the wild woods of Broceliande; and again when, armed by Fortitude and Hope, he met and slew the horrid dragon Aschemon, and vanquished the whole tribe of modern de- mons, as uncouth as the “‘monstrous rout” of Comus. These demotis, Jerrybuiltas, Slumdum, and the others, held their own high revels in the dusky twilight best adapted to such an evil crew. But it was when the drop-curtain was raised and the palace within once more revealed, that the tichest and most sumptuous scenes follow- ed, that some of the most marvellous ef- fects were rendered. At the bidding of Clio, the Muse of History, the Fair Cities of the World with their attendants, passed, as in a vision, by the couch of the Sleeping Beauty, whose sway they had once owned. Each of these groups was composed by a member of the Guild, each was as histori- cally accurate as pictorially it was splen- did, and, in several, well-known artists themselves figured—Mr. Walter Crane as Direr in the train of Nuremberg; Mr. Pomeroy, the sculptor, as Phidias, with Athens; Mr. Stannus, the architect, as Ti- tian, with Venice; Mr. Hughes, as his own St. Louis, with Paris. Miss May Morris, who, in her severe white draperies, might have stepped down from some old Byzantine mo- saic, led the way as St. Helena, for By- zantium. Each group appeared beyond the arcade, paused a moment by the Sleeping Beauty and her unlit Lamps, then passed out into the full light of the stage to be lost slowly in the shadows of the colon- nades. I have never seen anything like this on the stage before; it reminded me of the effect in certain pictures, in the “Night Watch,” for instance, with the few figures brilliant in the centre, and the others gradually disappearing, merged into the mysterious glooms and distances. And the arrangement of the scene pointed to another mistake made on the ordinary spectacular stage, for it was shown clearly that it is less by numbers and crowding that grandeur and splendor are to be sug- gested than by two or three figures well placed. Thebes, with her single attendant, Rameses II., in simple white draperies, seemed to fill the stage far more effective- ly than the endless battalions of a Drury Lane spectacle. One by one, the Cities passed separate-
Page 13
July 20, 1899] 1e ly, to the dramatically appropriate melody of Mr. Lawson’s music, and then, in long procession, they passed again: lotus-bear- ing Thebes; Athens, with, for insignia, a Venus held aloft; Rome, with globe of power; Byzantium, with cross and scroll | of the law; Florence, lily-laden, scatter- ing flowers in her path, accompanied by two of her greatest sons, Dante and Ci- mabue; Venice (jewels her burden), large and resplendent as the women of Giorgione and Tintoretto, a Doge and Titian in her guard of honor; Nuremberg and her crafts- men “born of Toil and Liberty,’ with whom it was only in keeping that Mr. Walter Crane should enroll himself; Paris, with St. Louis, Joan of Arc, and the Three Graces to explain her greatness and her charm; Oxford, with her band of students. And when, at the kiss of Trueheart, the spirit of All Things Beautiful awoke, and the lights burned once more in her Seven Lamps, London at last, like the Lady in Comus, was set free from the demons, and took her place with the Fair Cities; Labor and Invention, Freedom and Com- merce waiting upon her. The Five Senses, gay and many-hued as a garden of flow- | ers, celebrated their deliverance in a joy- ful dance, and all the performers, Fallen Leaves and Demons and Fair Cities, join- ed in a triumphal procession. The stage now was one great blaze of light, and so was the hall, and the music burst into a stirring march, and in and out among the columns, even down the steps where the Prolocutor stood, and in and out among the audience, just as the performers in the old Masques marched through the streets of Whitehall with all London looking on, the procession passed, a winding line of rich, iridescent color. The pageants that Car- paccio watched, that Veronese painted, were not more gorgeous. I know that as a revival the Masque has an historic interest. I know that to many the ethical intention of the allegory has seemed a recommendation. But its impor- tance really, the one thing that distinguished it from other revivals and moral allegories, was its pictorial beauty. There may have been defects, here and there a slightly dis- cordant note may have been struck. In the course of time it might have been still fur- ther perfected—indeed, the fourth perform- ance, in many ways, was an improvement upon the first. But it is useless to search for defects when they were overshadowed by so much beauty. If any lesson was taught it was that, on a finely built stage, in a care- fully graduated light, with the costumes and groups and movements designed by the art- ist, pictures may be composed as great as those of the greatest painter; that the crude conventions of the theatre are as inartistic as they are needless. And this lesson, if les- son you can call it, was taught by the Art Workers solely and entirely for their own amusement. Only the four performances were given: three for the public that chose to pay and so help to meet expenses, one for the Lord Mayor and the Corporation, who certainly deserved it, and who are so used to be themselves the performers in the Guildhall spectacles that they must have found it a strange experience to take part as lookers-on. Nor will the Masque be repeat- ed. But I do not believe the true Art Worker | ever grudges time and trouble to create a | thing of beauty even if merely for a day. | N. N. a} Nation. A MILANESE ART FOUNDATION. ANDERMATT, June 29, 1899. Municipal ardor has been, during the en- tire course of Italian history, the source of most of the good, as it has been of most of the evil, that has befallen the Peninsula. | Town no longer meets town on the field of | battle, but rivalry is not dead. It finds | less bloody outlets. On the cruder side it has become a race to outdo each other in the number and noisiness of electric trains run- ning through broad, new streets, lined with hideous blocks. But the same rivalry leads to endless pride in the past, to exultation in its artistic achievement, and—in rarer instances—to a sincere desire to preserve the artistic patrimony. Here also we en- counter a nobler and a less noble tendency. The same spirit has led towns to admire their own artists beyond all bounds of con- sidered criticism, and has inspired such foundations as the Querini-Stampalia at Venice, the Filangieri at Naples, the Gal- liera at Genoa, the Carrara-Lochis-Morell! at Bergamo, and, best of all, the Poldi- Pezzoli at Milan. Where energy abounds, everything is pos- sible. Milan, which led in tramways—it should be added that they have been ‘“‘muni- cipalized,”” and are the best and cheapest in Europe—is now leading in the recovery and intelligent arrangement of its art trea- sures. Milan was the home of Morelii and is still the home of the scarcely less emi- nent Signor Frizzoni, and of that alchemist in the restitution of begrimed and ruined pictures to their original state of perfec- tion, Signor Cavenaghi. At his studio you find old and young of the best and most cultivated society, come to see the paint- ings received for restoration, and to watch the scrupulous magician at work. There also congregate the amateurs and students from all over Europe who happen to be passing through Milan. The interest in art aroused by these meetings has happily pass- ed from words to deeds. It has led to the saving from demolition, and to the restora- tion, of the Castle of Milan, which bids fair, when completed, to be one of the most de- lightful and artistically instructive sights in Italy. It has induced a number of Milan- ese gentlemen to give their best energies to the proper installation of the works of art already collected. On some other occasion I hope to speak of the various treasures which Signor Vittadini is arranging in the Castle. Here I will say a few words about the Poldi-Pezzoli Museum which MM. Friz- zoni, Boito, and Noseda have just ordered anew. It was the private collection of the Milan- ese patrician, Cav. Poldi-Pezzoli, which he left to the town, adding an endowment for further purchases. The collection consists of bronzes, ivories, enamels, arms, tapes- tries, and pictures by the old Italian mas- ters. All is interesting and of a high quali- ty, but it is the pictures which give this museum its now almost world-wide fame. The other treasures are there by way of relief. It lacks but little of being an ideal show. There is not too much, and almost nothing of the sort of stuff which, instead of being discreetly hid away where the devout and forgiving eye of the archmologist alone shal! see it, is too often flauntingly displayed to the puzzled or jeering gaze of the tourist or scoffer. You could spend a morning there | AD in rooms not too large, among masterpieces not too overwhelming, amidst works of art which hate each other's company It is in many Ways a model that our col- do not lectors should study, and it will perhaps decide them not to leave their acquisitions to those monster storehouses where one perhaps may study, but scarcely ever en- joy, a work of art, but to endow them as separate small foundations containing only such objects as will give refined and ele- vated pleasure. Unhappily, Cav. Poldi-Pezzoli combined with his passion for what was best in the art of the past a taste naturally bad in the art of the The carvings, the stained glass, the one or two pieces of modern statuary which still disfigure what was once the Cavaliere’s private apart ment, fervently away The greatest eyesore was a huge bed, a night- mare of skilled and odious modern carving which filled one entire room. This has been banished by the new arrangement, and the paintings and other works of art have been put in better light, and in euch wise that they shall produce the greatest sensuous and esthetic present. wood wishes one harmony. One entire room is given up to the paint ers of the Milanese school. I regret that among them neither Foppa, nor Borgo- gnone, nor even Bramantino is to be seen—none, in short, of the heroic or grandly decorative artists of the Quattro- cento, but only the later brood whose pret tiness renders them popular, and value Milanese critics (Morelli was a Mi- lanese) have succeeded in raising far be- yond their deserts, but who impress me as more or less empty echoes of Leonardo, mirroring his smile, catching much of his technique, but possessing neither his sov- ereign sense for form, his command action, nor his deep insight into the human beart. The best of these followers was Beltraffo, who is represented by two Ma- donnas, the one beautiful in color, and re- flecting more than a little of Leonardo's gracious, mysterious beauty; the other, a recent acquisition, badly drawn, hard, and whose of bricky. Here also is Solario’s master- piece, the famous “Ecce Homo,” in senti- ment on the very edge of the Bolognese abyss, but technically a masterpiece of oil painting. Luini appears with a ‘Mar- riage of St. Catherine,” one of his least glassy and vapid works. Even Cesare da Sesto is here somewhat less distasteful than usual. To him Signor Frizzoni now ascribes a small chromo-like version of Leonardo's “Madonna with St. Anne,” but with St. Anne left out—a picture which bears some such relation to Leonardo as an abbreviated arrangement for an cordion might have to a Beethoven sym- phony. Finally, Leonardo's assistant, Am brogio da Predis, author of the “Vierge aux Rochers” in the National Gallery, dis- plays his not mean talents in a stately profile of an elderly gentleman. One of the very loveliest portraits ever painted in Italy hangs here. It is the likeness of herself in all the charm of young woman hood, with not a little of a great lady's elegance and grace, by Sofonishba Apgus- sola of Cremona, one of the few women who have left their mark on art. Heiress of Brescian and Venetian traditions, she spent much of her life at the of Spain, and lived on into the seventeenth century, becoming in extreme old age an ac- Court
Page 14
50 The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1777 Egeria to the happy young Van Dyck at Genoa. I shall mention but one picture of the Veronese school. It represents Samson stretched out on a bench in the foreground of a romantic, joyous landscape. He is sound asleep, and Delilah, in the bravery of all her beauty, sits by listlessly shear- ing his hair, while her paramour kneels watching. If this work of glowing deep color, quiet lyrical feeling, and exquisite arrangement of masses did not bear the forged signature of Carpaccio, it surely would pass for Giorgione’s. Few pictures have more right to this title, and indeed a far inferior work in the Uffizi by the same hand bore it until the other day. The real author is Michele da Verona, a third-rate painter usually, but at times lucky. The painters of Venice and her subject States have a well-lit room all to them- selves. There you see first and foremost a Madonna by Montagna, a canvas of his lat- est years, dark but comely in color, and of intimate feeling. Around him are grouped the rugged, patriarchal masters of the Vene- tian Quattrocento. The heroic Montagna, majestic in form, in color mighty, is here with two splendid figures, a St. Paul and a St. Jerome, parts, doubtless, of some scat- tered polyptych. Cima shows the head of a female saint, done in his last years, when his porcelain-like surfaces were more than ever enamelled and transparent. Crivelli has two tiny pictures; in the one a St. Sebastian, in the other a St. Francis kneeling at the feet of the Man of Sorrows— tiny pictures, and precise, yet done in his unrivalled large decorative style. The un- equal but grand Bonsignori is represented by at least three works. The bust of a female saint with pearls on her forehead and loose yellow hair is of radiant beauty—unhappily not altogether original. Better preserved and more rugged are the bust in profile of an old man, and another bust, full face, of a Venetian senator. Neither Giovanni Bellini nor Alvise Vivarini is to be seen here, al- though pictures bear these names. The Ve- nice of the sixteenth century is represented by an indifferent Holy Family of Lotto’s de- cline. On the other hand, the eighteenth century can boast of little or nothing to sur- pass the small Guardi recently bought, a view across the lagoon to the Lido, a deli- cate study in opalescent effect of sky and sea, diaphanous, evanescent, yet intense- ly real and intensely poetical—a prophecy of Whistler, if ever there was one. Tuscany has sent few pictures to this de- light?ul show, but all are interesting, and one at least of the highest order. The deep and intense but slovenly Pietro Lorenzetti is here with an unusually lovely Madonna and angels, replete with the ardor of Tre- cento Siena. Here Pietro makes his nearest approach to his brother, the great Ambrogio, but there is yet a gulf between them. The earliest of the Florentines at the Poldi- Pezzoll is Pesellino, one of the most gifted of Tuscan artists, rousing among his towns- folk the highest expectations, but dying in his prime—a Florentine Giorgione. His work here is a smallish Pieta, so close in form and color to Filippo Lippi that it took the piercing eye of Dr. Bode to see that It was not Lippi's but Pesellino’s. There is yet another panel which at first glance (or if one saw a photograph only and not the original) one might be tempted to ascribe to Pesellino. It is a lunette of but a span long, containing an Annunciation. The com- position was certainly Pesellino’s, but the color and the technique are of two genera- tions later. It is probably a copy after a lost original by Pesellino, made by Alber- tinelli or perhaps Sogliani. It is charming and interesting nevertheless. Albertinelli himself is represented by one of his most at- tractive and successful achievements, a small triptych of dainty finish and jewel- like color, both due to Flemish influence. Two panels are ascribed to Botticelli. One, a Pieta, is an unhappy caricature of the mas- ter’s style, such, however, as pleases those who, caring little for his art and much for the emotions he depicts, find these emotions emphasized enough for rapid comprehension. The Madonna is much prettier now than when it left Sandro's hand, but is still his work. I have properly left to the last the choicest morsel of the collection. It is the most famous of all the profiles of women attribut- ed to Piero dei Franceschi. So famous is it that if at Milan you ask for a post-card you run the chance of receiving one with its reproduction on the back. You see against the sky the bust, in profile to the left, of a young woman, robust yet refined, simple yet elegant, with no self-consciousness—I need scarcely add, no grain of affectation. Artis- tically, the supreme charm of this work is in the outlines, firm and sinuous, leaving but little for the modelling to fill in. The tone tends to blondness, the gracefully coiffed hair is almost straw-colored, the sky is pale blue, the dress is of brocade, with a dazzling pattern. Few if any works of art have, like this bust, united critics and di- vided connoisseurs. All agree about its qua- lity, but each has his own attribution. I have mine. I would ascribe it to Verrocchio in his earlier years. This is not the place to give my reasons. This much I may say, that while the resemblance between this work, both in quality and technique, to certain others by Verrocchio is great, you need only look at the bust of Battista Sforza in the Uffizi or the frescoes at Arezzo to see that it is not by Piero dei Franceschi; you need only look at the altar-piece in the Uffizi also to see that it Is not by Domenico Veneziano; you need but look at the profile in the Hainauer collection at Berlin to see that it is not by Pollajuolo. By whom, then, can it be? Sure- ly not by Baldovinetti. Yet it certainly is Florentine, and my conclusion is that the painter of this marvellous profile was aut Verrocchius aut—discipulus. B. BERENSON. POISONING IN THE SEVENTEENTH CENTURY, PaRIs, June 26, 1899. The seventeenth century remains in our imagination as the culminating point of all the elegance and greatness of France. We call it le grand siécle, and Louis XIV. is le grand roi. If we would form a better opi- nion of our own time, in contrast with past ages, and see the shadows behind the glar- ing light of the seventeenth century, we can do no better than to read a work just pub- lished on the ‘Drama of the Poisons,’ by M. Funck-Brentano. This elaborate work is very fully documented, if I me» be allowed to use a modern expression applied to all historical works which are considered worth reading. M. Funck-Brentano has plunged into the Archives of the Bastille in the Archives of the Prefecture of Police, where all the pa- pers concerning the “affaire”’ of the poisons are preserved; he has found in the Library of Rouen the papers concerning Le Voisin, one of the women who made a trade of fur- nishing poison. The trial of the Marchioness de Brinvilliers, who was one of the chief poisoners, is still remembered. Her rank has given her an historic notoriety; but she was only one among a number of men and women who used poison freely in the seven- teenth century. There were regular associa- tions of alchemists, magicians, sorcerers, poisoners. When the Lieutenant of Police, La Reynie, first penetrated this world of crime, he was so moved that he wrote: ‘‘Hu- man life has become a matter of trade; poi- soning is the great remedy in all family em- barrassments; impiety, sacrilege, abomina- tions are common practices in Paris, in the country, in the provinces.” The belief in sorcery was still popular in the seventeenth century. Jean Bodin, the illustrious author of ‘Six Books on the Re- public,’ wrote a treatise called ‘Demonoma- nia, or a Treatise on Sorcerers.’ His definition of the sorcerer is this: A person who, by diabolical and forbidden means, attempts to obtain something. “Sorcerers, men and wo- men, formed a sort of vast association; they had traditional secrets, formulas, habits, ceremonies, generally cf the most infamous, impious, and indecent character.” They had their own mass, called the black mass. They were doctors and chemists. They revealed the future, they found hid- den treasure; they were alchemists, and tried to discover the philosopher’s stone for converting all metals into gold. The woman called Le Voisin was a typical specimen of the sorceress of the seventeenth century, very different from the more an- cient sorceress described by Michelet. She earned annually as much as 400,000 francs; she had many lovers, and gave dinners. Among her lovers was the executioner of Paris, André Guillaume, who beheaded Mme. de Brinvilliers. Le Voisin was a mere char- latan; she delivered her oracles to persons of all ranks in a splendid gown, and with a mantle covered with golden eagles. She was a real believer in alchemy. She was also a doctor, like all sorceresses, and had re- ceipts for every malady. She was known to help abortive practices, and once, in a mo- ment of sincerity, she confessed having burned or interred in her garden the bodies of more than 2,500 children, prematurely born. Curiously enough, she insisted upon these children being baptized. The crimes of this horrible creature were such that the Lieutenant of Police was appalled by the confession of them. One can easily imagine the stupor of Louis XIV. when they were revealed to him. A special commission was appointed to investigate what was called the affair of the poisons. This commission is known in history under the name of the “chambre ardente.” The arrests were made by lettre de cachet. Four hundred and forty-two persons appear- ed before the special commission, and two hundred and eighteen persons were kept in prison. Thirty-six prisoners were condemn- ed to death and executed, five were con- demned to the gallows, twenty-three were banished. The most guilty prisoners had ac- complices in very high places. Madame de Dreux, the wife of a member of the Parle- ment, is a type of these accomplices. She was in love with M. de Richelieu, and em-
Page 15
July 20, 1899] The Nation. 51 ployed the services of one of the sorceresses brought before the chambre ardente. She wished to be relieved by poison of her own husband, and by sorcery of Madame de Richelieu. She was accused of having her- self poisoned some people—one of her lovers among the number. She was a cousin of two members of the special commission, and she received a mere admonition. ‘“‘M. de Dreux and his entire family,’’ writes Madame de Sévigné, ‘“‘went to get her at the Chambre de l’Arsenal. . . It was a joy and a triumph, and she was embraced by all her family and friends. M. de Richelieu has done wonders in all this affair.’"” What seems in- credible is, that, after having left the prison of Vincennes, Madame de Dreux resorted again to a sorceress, named Joly, and got from her powders for poisoning a person whom M. de Richelieu ‘‘considered.’”’ ‘To be sure,’’ says M. Funck-Brentano, ‘“‘the woman Joly having been arrested and having made revelations, a new warrant was issued against Madame de Dreux; but she was advised of it and fled.” Madame de Dreux was condemned to banishment, but the King allowed her to remain in France, on condition that she would live with her husband in Paris. The wife of President Laféron was also implicated in the trial; she got powders from the woman Le Voisin, and her husband died soon after. She too was condemned to banishment. Madame de Poulaillon was, by lettre de cachet, shut up in a house of detention, the Pénitentes of Angers. The declarations of the venders of poison before the chambre ardente were of such gra- vity that Louis XIV. gave special orders that they should be kept secret. The name of Madame de Montespan, the King’s favorite, was pronounced. Her ambition was ex- treme; she had made great efforts to sup- plant Mademoiselle de la Valliére, and by de- grees had established her empire over the King. Her favor lasted fourteen years, and she had no less than seven children by Louis XIV., the eldest being the Duke du Maine; the eldest daughter, Mademoiselle de Nantes, married the Duc de Bourbon; another daugh- ter, Mademoiselle de Blois, married the Duke d’Orléans. Marguerite Le Voisin, the daugh- ter, declared before the judges that Madame de Montespan paid frequent visits to her mother, whenever she feared a diminu- tion of the King’s good graces, and a rival; her mother then had recourse tosome priests, who said special masses and gave her phil- ters for the King, in the form of powders. When Marguerite Le Voisin made this depo- sition, her mother had been burned on the scaffold several months before. Many historians have thought that if the sorceresses tried to compromise people in high positions, it was in the hope of saving their own lives; but Le Voisin never pronounced the name of Mme. de Montespan, perhaps because she feared the terrible punishment of the regicides. The relations of Mme. de Montespan with the sorceress seem to have begun in 1667, when the King first turned his eyes towards her. “In 1667,” writes M. Funck-Brentano, ‘we find her in the Rue de la Tannerie, in com- pany with the magician Lesage and the Abbé Mariette, a priest of Saint-Sévérin. - + In a little chamber stood an altar. Mariette, in sacerdotal vestments, pro- nounced incantations. Lesage sang the Veni Creator, then Mariette read a chapter of the Gospel over the head of Madame de Montespan kneeling before him, and re- cited conjurations aaaiuat Louise de la Val- liére. She said (the very words sin te in one of the interrogatories of ‘I beg that the friendship of the cone — of Monseigneur the Dauphin may be con- tinued to me, that the Queen may be barren, that the King may leave his bed and his table for me, that I may obtain from him all that I ask for myself and my relations, . that I may be called to the councils of the King, and that, his friendship increasing still more, the King | may leave La Valliére, and that, the Queen | being repudiated, I may marry the King.’”’ In 1688, Mariette and Lesage had the impudence to recommence their incanta- tions at court, in the Chateau of St. Ger- main. It was in this very year that Ma- dame de Montespan took the place of La Valliére; in 1669, she had the first of her seven children by Louis XIV. Mariette and Lesage had made the acquaintance of Madame de Montespan by means of Le Voisin, who several times gave powders to the favorite. She fell so low as to enter into communication also with a certain Abbé Guibourg, who said the black mass. The ceremony took place near Monthéry, in a house which still exists, called Ville- bousin. It is difficult to go into the de- tails of this infamous black mass, and dif- ficult to believe that Madame de Monte- span took in it the part ascribed to her in some depositions. Can we believe that a second black mass was said for her at Saint-Denis, a third at Paris? We cannot forget that the evidence of such _ wit- nesses as appeared in the affair of the poisons had but little value; at the same time, there is some truth in the old pro- verb, “There is no fire without some smoke.” It is certain, also, that at various times Madame de Montespan lost her hold on Louis XIV.; that the King had fits of devoutness, and was on the point of se- parating from her; that once a separa- tion really took place for a month. Must we believe that Madame de Montespan, frantic with fear, full of superstitious no- tions, really addressed herself to criminal women like Le Voisin and others? It is curious to follow in Madame de Sé- vigné’s correspondence the ups and downs of the favor of Madame de Montespan, whom she calls Quanto or Quantova; and to com- pare her dates with the dates given in the trial of the poisons. In one letter she writes (September 2, 1676): ‘‘The vision of Madame de Soubise [for whom the King had a short caprice] has passed like lightning; every- thing is arranged. Quanto, the other day, at the play, had her head familiarly on the shoulder of her friend; this affection meant: ‘I am better than ever.’ ’’ On the 11th of September things are changed. ‘Everybody believes that the star of Madame de Monte- span is waning. There are tears, natural sor- rows, affected gayeties; well, my dear, every- thing comes to an end; some tremble, the rest are glad; some desire immutability, the others a change in the play.”” The anxieties of Madame de Montespan became greater when she saw the King take a growing in- terest in Madame de Maintenon; the gov- erness threatened to become the mistress. Were new black masses said at this junc- ture? Did Madame de Montespan, wounded in her pride and ambition, take diabolical means to get rid of a rival? The deposi- tions of the Abbé Guibourg are truly ter- rible; but I must repeat that the testimony of such people as he can be accepted only with great hesitation. Louis XIV. took the royal part in this ter- | | | i rible affair; he did not allow the mother of several of his children to be disgraced He had much affection for these children, and gave them a sort of legitimacy. Without going into further details, I will only say that M. Funck-Brentano’s book is weil worth reading throughout. It throws a lurid light on the substructure of the splendid edifice of the most brilliant age of France. Correspondence. DEMOCRATIC AGITATION AGAINST TRUSTS. To THE EpItoR OF THE NATION: Sir: In your discussion of Prof. W. J Ashley’s suggestions for legally safe-guard- ing “just prices” and “reasonable wages” against the work of Trusts, you touch on the disposition of legislators to demand high wages for workingmen, and on the difficul- ty of marketing product at the prices which these wages make necessary. Might you not have said, much more generally, that there are the same objections to the present agi- tation against Trusts as to protectionism? Before the Trust question can come to a vote by the whole American people it must be recognized that, on very important points, the current denunciation of the Trust sys- tem clashes with the ancient Democratic faith, We who have held out for cheap- ness of the necessaries of life, can we be heard to complain of the Trusts that they have cut out redundant expenses of pro- duction, or that they have shut down ill- conditioned enterprises which never could have lived but for the bonus protection gave them? Whether the Trusts can compensate the public for the destruction of industrial in- dependence and its brood of virtues; wheth- er, in the nature of things, the Trust tends more to the effacement of the individual than does the ordinary corporation; what protection “life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness” must have against consolidated industry—these inquiries, comprised in the social side of the Trust question, are tre- mendously important; but they are quite distinct from that economic side of the ques- tion about which Democrats (if they foi- low the present recognized spokesmen of their party) and other believers in free trade may well be brought into confusion. BEeNJ. CARTER. Wasninotor, D. C., July 17, 1800 KEEPING OUR OWN DOOR CLEAN. To THE EpiTroR or THE NATION: Sin: What a prophet Emerson would be were he only living in this age, when in- dividual self-assertion seems to be weaken- ing in the knees. These words were true in 1865; they are true to-day. Says he, in ‘Social Aims’: “The young men in America at this mo- ment take little thought of what men in England are thinking or doing. This is the point which decides the welfare of a people; which way does it look? If to any other people, it is not well with them. If occupied in its own affairs and thoughts and men, with a heat which excludes almost the no- tice of any other people, . . they are sublime; and we know that in this abstrac- tion they are executing excellent work. Amidst the calamities which war has brought on our country, this one benefit has accrued —that our eyes are withdrawn from Eng-
Page 16
H2 [Vol. 69, No. 1777 land, withdrawn from France, and look homeward. We have come to feel that ‘by ourselves our safety must be bought’; to know the vast resources of the continent, the good will that is in the people, their convic- tion of the great moral advantages of free- dom, social equality, education, and religious culture, and the determination to hold these fast, and, by them, to hold fast the country and penetrate every square mile of it with this American civilization.”’ Yours truly, GEORGE L. REES. 4116 BaLTrmMorE AvENU E, PHILADELPHIA, July 11, 1899. RUSKIN AND MILLAIS. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: In a review of Mr. W. M. Rossetti’s ‘Preraphaelitism’ in the Nation of June 8, headed “‘A New Light on Ruskin,” occurs the following passage, apropos of Ruskin’s alleged public ignoring of Ford Madox Brown: “Add to this the other known fact {the italics are mine] that Ruskin could never see any merit in the work of Millais after their personal quarrel, and we are led to think that while he was right in think- ing himself ‘very resentful,’ he was singu- larly wrong in considering himself ‘just.’ ’’ Will you allow me in fairness to place before your readers the following known facts which tell the other way? In ‘The Art of Englard’ (1883) Ruskin speaks of Millais’s ‘“‘Caller Herrin’ as “‘that most noble picture of Millais, a picture which, as a piece of art, I should myself put highest of all yet produced by the Pre-Ra- phaelite School.” And, in a smali octavo pam- phlet, entitled ‘Notes on the Principal Pic- tures of Sir John Everett Millais, exhibited at the Grosvenor Gallery, 1886, with original and selected criticisms by John Ruskin, D.C.L., LL.D.’ (William Reeves, 185 Fleet Street, E.C.), there are, in addition to the quotations of Ruskin’s earlier criticisms, a series of occasional notes, in small capitals, signed “J. R., 1886,” at the foot of the pages on which the titles of the pictures referred to appear. Among these are the following: “The North-West Passage’ (1874): “I have not seen this picture, but it must be a glorious one, judging merely from the col- oured print.” “For the Squire’ (1882): ‘‘One of the most deep and pathetic renderings of expression ameet the painter’s great work of this “The Ornithologist’’ (1885): “I have never seen any work of modern art with more de- light and admiration than this.’’ And the catalogue concludes with the fol- lowing sentence: “Looking back now on the painter’s ca- reer, crowned as it has lately been by some of the best pieces of free-hand painting in the world, I am disposed to regret his never having given expression to his power of animal painting, wholly unrivalled in its kind, than any of the shortcomings of his actual work. J. R., 1886." Trusting 1 have said enough to somewhat modify this “‘New" light which ever beats about the throne of genius, I am, sir, yours obediently, JAMES TROTTER. CRICKLEWOGD., LONDON, N. W., June 80, 1699. [There is an obvious hiatus in the last of the above extracts, but we cannot lay our hands on the volume from which it is taken.—Ep. Nation.] y) The Nation. Notes. ‘Pupils of Peter the Great,’ by R. Nisbet Bain; ‘Napoleon’s Invasion of Russia,’ by Hereford B. George; ‘With Nansen in the North,’ by Lieut. Hjalmar Johansen; and ‘Gypsy Folk Tales,’ by Francis H. Groome, are in the press of the New Amsterdam Co. E. P. Dutton & Co. will shortly publish ‘Robert Raikes: The Man and his Work,’ namely, the founding of the Sunday-school in the last century. Dean Farrar supplies an introduction. Ginn & Co. have in preparation ‘Twelve English Poets,’ condensed biographies, by Blanche Wilder Bellamy. Almost ready is ‘The United States Army and Navy, 1776-1899,’ told for the former sec- tion by Lieut.-Col. A. L. Wagner, U. S. A., and for the latter by Commander J. D. Jer- rold Kelley, U. S. N., and published by the Werner Co., Akron, O. There will be nearly fifty illustrations. ‘Our Conquests in the Pacific’ (Frederick A. Stokes Co.) consists of Oscar King Da- vis’s special correspondence from Manila to the New York Sun. It is written in choice jovrnalese, and with small regard to the difference between the “reporter”? and the historian, but it has a measurable value among the documents of the war. The il- _ustrations are very good. Another chronicle of a newspaper cor- respondent is ‘Kuba und der Krieg’ (New York: Chrrles Wildermann), by Joseph Herrings, who went out to the island for the New York Staatszeitung, and here re- publishes his letters with some revision. His special claim to consideration is, that he was the only German correspondent who participated in the Santiago campaign from beginning to end. He does not confine him- self tc his observations, witness his chap- ter on Weyler’s reign of terror. There are numerous pen-and-ink sketches in the body of the text, which will serve. Helene Richter’s ‘Percy Bysshe Shelley,’ a volume of 640 pages, recently issued by Emil Felber in Weimar, is by far the best life of the English poet in the German language. It is no mere compilation from other works on the subject, but is based throughout on a careful and critical study of original sources. Even those who are familiar with the standard biographies and literary histories by Dowden, Gosse, Saints- bury, Todhunter, Brandes, and Engel, will find new points of view in this book, and may have their opinions considerably mo- dified by reading it. The influences of the poet’s domestic, social, and intellectual en- vironment on the early development of his character, and thus in some degree on the predetermination of his career, are clearly traced. The result is a finished portrait of the ‘“‘Real Shelley.” The Prussian ‘Pedagogical Society’’ has just published some interesting statistics showing that the provinces in which the law compelling all children to attend the public schools is most rigidly enforced, have the smallest percentage of criminals. Thus, in West Prussia, there are 1,926 criminals to 100,000 inhabitants, but in Hohenzollern only 761. The statistics also show that the im- provement of the schools and greater strict- ness in obligatory attendance have every- where been followed by a perceptible dimi- nution of crime. For a long ttme Swiss parents have car- ried on a system of intercantonal inter- change of children during the summer vaca- tions for educational purposes. Thus, a fa- mily in Lucerne would send their children to Lausanne or Lugano and receive in return children of a family in one of those places. By this arrangement the children would ac- quire in a short time a practical knowledge of German, French, and Italian. It is now proposed to extend this plan, which has worked so well in trilingual Switzerland, to the principal eountries of Europe, and espe- cially to England, France, and Germany. By this method the children will easily learn not only to speak foreign languages, but also to form a more just estimate of foreign peo- ples. Curiously enough, this larger move- ment appears to have originated in Denmark. A very interesting collection of Arabic proverbs, 205 in all, collected by L. Bauer, a resident of Jerusalem, is published in the latest number of the Zeitschrift des Deutschen Palaestina-Vereins (vol. xxi., p. 129). It is not the first of the kind printed in this journal, which, in the course of its 19th volume, published a fine list from the pen of the daughter of the famous architect, Conrad Schick, for fifty years the leading archeological authority i the city of Je- rusalem. But Bauer’s list is entirely new material gathered by himself from the lips of the people in Jerusalem and Palestine in general, and shows that not a few excellent proverbs, sayings, etc., have escaped pre- vious collectors. The list contains quite a number that reproduce in modern shape some of the proverbial sayings found in the Scrip- tures, sometimes, too, almost in the words of the sacred writers; but the bulk consists of the practical wisdom of these people, put usually in metrical or alliterative form, and many of them agreeing in sentiment with the proverbs and sayings of modern and other ancient nations. In this respect the collection contains some good material for comparative ethnological study. Probably one-haif or even a larger percentage could be paralleled, if not in English alone, in modern tongues in general. Bauer has pub- lished also the transliteration of the Arabic, and thus enables the non-Arabist in a mea- sure to feel the beauty of form that cha- racterizes this proverbial wisdom in the ori- ginal. Mr. D. C. Heath, the well-known Boston publisher, has lately acquired the library of children’s books and educational works is- sued by Newbery in London from 1740 to 1800, and brought together by Mr. Charles Welsh when he was writing the biography of John Newbery, founder of the famous publishing-house which, for nearly 150 years, was at the corner of St. Paul’s church- yard, London. Besides a number of chap- books for children, several battledores (the successors of the horn-books), some rare primers, a thoroughly representative collec- tion of fiction for children and of early toy books, there are in the collection first edi- tions of Goldsmith’s ‘Vicar of Wakefield,’ ‘The Traveller,’ and ‘The Deserted Village,’ and of other works by Goldsmith and Dr. Johnson. The special feature of the Boston Public library Bulletin for July is a list of some 100 books and magazine articles on the Dreyfus affair. They are all in French and English, with the exception of a single Ger- man romance. The Nicaragua Canal route is the prin- cipal subject of the National Geographic
Page 17
July 20, 1899] The Nation. St 3 Magazine (Washington) for July. The geo- logic history of the region is told by C. W. Hayes, one phase of which is that prob- ably “during early Tertiary time the waters of the Atlantic and Pacific had free inter- communication across this portion of the isthmus.’”’ A popular account of Nicaragua and the different isthmian routes projected during the last fifty years is given by A. P. Davis, with some important facts in re- gard to the hydrography or the region. There are several interesting illustrations and two useful maps. The Russian petroleum trade in 1898 is the first subject treated in the Consular Re- ports for June, especial attention being given to the residuum or oil fuel, the con- sumption and price of which increased over the previous year. Notwithstanding an in- crease of output of all products at Baku of about 200,000,000 gallons in a total of nearly 2,000,000,000, the average daily output per well has fallen from 225 gallons in 1896 to 199 in 1898,which would apparently indicatea permanent weakening of the wells. There is a short account of commercial education in Antwerp,! one feature of which is the be- stowal of ten travelling scholarships of three years’ duration with an annual in- come of $1,000; a list of the kind of goods most in demand in the Philippines; and considerable information in regard to the tea-trade of Formosa. Railroad building is being pushed with great activity in nearly all parts of the Russian empire. 1,500 miles of road were completed last year, and there are 7,000 miles in process of construction, while the building of 2,000 miles more has recently been authorized. Among the important cities already or soon to be reached by the lo- motive are Archangel, Kars on the Trans- caucasian line, Tashkent on the Transcas- pian, and Irkutsk on the Trans-Siberian line. An important railway project, both from a commercial and a political point of view, is the continuation of the Anatolian Railway from Angora via Diarbekr and Mosul to Bagdad. The necessary capital is to be fur- nished by Germans through an arrangement recently concluded between the Deutsche and Ottoman Banks. The country which would be opened up is rich in natural re- sources, and most of it was formerly dense- ly populated. Russia, however, officially ob- jects to this route because it comes so near to the frontier and the Russian sphere of interest. This seems to be factious, as the distance to the frontier is about 200 miles; but there can be little doubt that much trade would be diverted from Russia to Ger- many, and German interests would become paramount in a region where Russia has hitherto been without a rival. The popular interest of Germans in schemes for imperial expansion was still further shown at the recent meeting of the Colonial Society at Berlin. This society, numbering 30,000 members, publishes a jour- nal, arranges lectures, gives information to emigrants, subscribes towards the cost of commercial and mining expeditions, offers prizes to colonial planters, etc. Among its expenses for last year are grants towards the transport of a steamer to Lake Tan- ganyika, the German School at Apia, the publication of works on New Guinea, vari- ous periodicals, and to individual students of African and Australasian languages. It has also had considerable success in finding wives for German settlers in southwest Af- rica and elsewhere. The prominent subjects discussed at the meeting in question was the construction of a railway through German East Africa from the coast to the lakes, an expedition to Lake Chad from Cameroon, and the German regulation of the river Hoang-ho. The development of their colonial posses- sions is a subject which is now engaging the attention of many intelligent French- men. One of the latest manifestations of this is the formation of a Ligue Coloniale de la Jeunesse, which has for its object “‘the familiarizing its members with the study of colonial questions by means of lectures and the formation of a library."’ A depart- ment of colonial agriculture has been add- ed to the National College of Agriculture at Montpellier, and the League hopes to found a travelling scholarship in connection with it, as well as to aid the graduates in finding situations in the colonies. —Lady Randolph Spencer Churchill’s new venture, ‘The Anglo-Saxon Review: A Quar- terly Miscellany’ (John Lane), is appropriate- ly named, considering the Anglo-American alliance symbolized by the editor; and the main title would have been very taking for a real review. But “Miscellany” it is, rather than Review, even if we find in the contents a paper on “Wireless Telegraphy,”’ by Prof. Oliver Lodge; another, on “Some Consequen- ces of the Last Treaty of Paris,’’ by White- law Reid; a third, on “The Sudan,” by Sir Rudolf Slatin, etc. A short story, ““The Great Condition,” by Henry James, is followed by a sketch of the Life of Lady Mary Wortley Montagu, by Elizabeth Robins; and this concludes the cisatlantic collaberation. The Miscellany, Annual, Keepsake, or Friend- ship’s Garland of other days appears in sun- dry portraits, as of Lady Mary above; of Sir Robert Peel, to whom Lord Rosebery de- votes the most solid article; of the Queen (Onslow Ford’s bust); of Washington (Stu- art’s full-length); of Anne of Austria, the Countess of Pembroke, the Duchess of De- vonshire, by Rubens, Marc Gheeraerts, and Reynolds respectively. The luxurious quali- ty of paper and print offers another feature of resemblance to the Keepsake, and finally the volume is bound and very elegantly stamped with a design borrowed from a copy of André Thevet’s ‘Les Vrais Pourtraits’ (Paris, 1584), formerly in the possession of James I., as Mr. Cyril Davenport, F.S.A., explains. This binding will not be repeated, so that each number of the ‘Review’ will have its own character externally. The total product is evidently for the élite; and while a portion of it furnishes food for thought and possibly for comment, the ‘Review’ altogether is bibliographical bric-A-brac, and calls for description rather than criticism. As book- making, it can be praised without reserve. —A slight examination of ‘Who's Who in America: A Biographical Dictionary of Liv- ing Men and Women of the United States, 1899-1900’ (Chicago: A. N. Marquis & Co.) shows that it is in good hands. The editor is John W. Leonard, and his preface must conciliate every right-minded reader. The work is patterned after the English exemplar bearing the same title (“Who's Who’), but with retrenchment in two particulars: no mention is made of club membership, or of “recreations’’ or avocations, curious and in- teresting as these are in the English work, and likely to have a practical use for pur- veyors for special tastes. The address, how ever, is given wherever possible, or in thr vast majority of cases; and this feature Is one of the strongest recommendations of ‘Who's Who,” English and American alike The inclusiveness of the dictionary is the first thing to be challenged, and here we have some arbitrary ecr-oficio admissions Congressmen, Governors, United States Judges, National Academicians, heads of un! versities and colleges, etc.; all praiseworthy Moreover, “special effort has been made to include all living American authors of books of more than ephemeral value,” and if one observes marked differences in the length of the very condensed notices, ten to one it is because of the bibilography A prope: latitude has been displayed in making up : company which could not be expected to b« on one level of talent or character, and few will question Croker’s title to a place beside Dr. Parkhurst, Grover Cleveland, and Carl Schurz, for example. The editor amusingly relates his trials in trying to keep out the insignificant or the merely promising, and especially those who wished to buy their way in. No one will accuse him or his pub- lishers of having yielded to this temptation. In a list of thirty names chosen at random we have found but four not represented, and of these, two at least may have declined to be taken in, while the merit of a third, though real, is inconspicuous. The accuracy of the biographical sketches (mostly auto- biographica]) is, so far as we have tested it, admirable. Quite exceptional is such a de formation (under: W. J. Stillman) as “Fran cisco Criski’’ for Francesco Crispi. There are sore cross-references from maiden to married name and from pseudonym to true name. Very interesting are the preliminary statistics as to sectional origin of the 8,602 men and women, more than 20 per cent. be- ing natives of New England. A necrology from January 1, 1895, will also be found very convenient. —From Cromwell to Wellington: Twelve Soldiers’ (Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott Co.) is a volume of biographical sketches written for popular use by men who have received a Staff College training. The edi- tor, Mr. Spenser Wilkinson, has in one or two cases acted as the collaborator of his contributors, but ordinarily the authors are past or active officers of the British army We give the list of subjects in full: Cromwell, Marlborough, Peterborough, Wolfe, Clive, Coot, Heathfield, Abercromby, Lake, Baird, Moore, Wellington. A super- ficial analysis of these names shows that a large proportion of the generals in ques- tion gained distinction in India, while al- most all of them were at one time oranother engaged against the French. A valuable fea- ture of the book—indeed, the feature which is most likely to attract wide notice-—-ts an introduction by Lord Roberts, containing brief appreciations of the leading command- ers dealt with in the body of the work Cromwell and Marlborough are particularly singled out by him for praise and illustra- tion, though most of the others receive a word’of comment. Lord Roberts also has something to say on each of several topics connected with the art of war, ¢. g., the ad- vantage of fortified lines and fortified towns, the necessity of most careful equipment, the influence of sea-power on military his- tory, the organic connection between army and navy, and the typical characteristics of a good general. He ascribes to the success-
Page 18
54 The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1777 ful fighter exactly those qualities which win success in other occupations. ‘In addition to military knowledge and experience, there must be good judgment,sound common sense, tenacity of purpose, quickness of perception, promptitude of decision, aud, above all, an infinite capacity for taking pains. The officer who is fortunate enough to be intrusted with a comma.d in the field should be prepared at all points and ready to face all contingencies. He should follow Cesar's example, of whom Lucan wrote: ‘Nil actum reputans, dum quid superesset agendum.’ ”’ These words from a mere writer of books might seem commonplace, but with ‘‘Ro- berts, F.M.,” after them, they represent mature conviction and wide experience. The several essays have been carefully prepared, and the book puts professional criticism at the service of a public which usually goes to civilians for its knowledge of military ope- rations. —We described last week a simple but beautiful device in which all the colors of the rainbow (and hence all the colors of a natural scene) are produced for the eye of the observer out of a screen of glass on which there is no trace of color printed, but only groups of lines, of three different de- grees of fineness to correspond to the three physical constituents of white and colored lights (physical, because physiologically the fundamental color sensations are four in number). Another device has lately been put on the market which is in some sense the reverse of this: a picture which is printed in bright red and green is looked at through a pair of spectacles consisting of a plain piece of red glass for one eye and of green glass for the other. To the surprise of the observer, all color disappears, and the scene is shown in plain black and white, but with the perfect effect of stereoscopic relief. The explanation is plainly this: the two halves of an ordinary stereoscopic picture, instead of being brought into approximate coinci- dence by means of lenses, are printed nearly overlapping each other, but one in red ink and the other in green. Through the red glass of the spectacles the green picture be- comes sharply black, and the red picture becomes so faint as to be overlooked in com- parison; so through the green glass the close- ly contiguous red picture is black, and the other is inconspicuous. The result is the same as if the right eye looked a little more around to the right of the objects represent- ed, and the left eye a little more. around to the left of them; but this is exactly what constitutes the vision of solidity in real life, and the poor eyes, knowing no better, think that they have before them a scene in three dimensions. The ordinary stereoscope is a clumsy affair, and besides one has got tired of it; this process, in which the observer has nothing to do but to put on his red and green glasses, ought to have an impor- tant future before it. It is quite conceivable that it should lend itself to the purposes of serious art in a way in which the other method (it is hard to say why) has never done. As a means for the representation of solid diagrams for the purposes of scientific illustration, it cannot fall to be very useful. The method lends itself perfectly, of course, to the representation of pictures in the solid for a large audience, and in fact it is in this: form that it has been utilized already for some time in Germany. —'Finland’s Rights and the Czar’s Mani- festo of February 15, 1899,’ is the title of , a timely pamphlet just published at Hel- singfors in Finnish and Russian, giving a succinct history of the political constitu- tion of Finland since its incorporation into Russia after the peace of Frederikshamn in 1809, and the several crises through which it has passed during the present cen- tury. Every Czar, from Alexander I. to Nicholas II., has, on his accession to the throne, sworn to uphold the constitution of Finland, and as yet not one of them has violated his oath. But there has always been at the Russian court a crafty and unscrupulous clique of reactionists, who have endeavored to deprive the Finns of their political rights and privileges under the pretext of making the whole empire homogeneous in its organization and insti- tutions. One would suppose that this pro- cess of ‘“‘benevolent assimilation’’ might be accomplished most easily and effectually by granting a constitution to Russia instead of subverting that of Finland. Such a change, however, would have defeated the real pur- pose of the “imperialistic’’ cabal. Al- though Alexander I.-and Nicholas I. were wholly different in character as individuals and sovereigns, they pursued the same just policy towards Finland, whose constitution they recognized as the fundamental law of the land. When the latter succeeded to the throne in December, 1825, he was urged to withhold this recognition, but indignantly rejected the evil counsel. Two years later the Governor of Finland, Zakrewski, on ac- count of some i'legal act which he had com- mitted, came into collision with the local authorities, and in the heat of the ensu- ing controversy exclaimed: “I am your law.” Nicholas I. rebuked him for this ar- rogant assumption, and uttered the words, which Nicholas II. should heed: ‘No, not even I, the Czar, am Finland’s law.”’ As re- gards the manifesto issued by the present Czar, it not only imposes heavier military burdens on the Finns, but also does so without the consent of the Diet and there- fore in direct violation of the constitution of Finland. Against this measure the Diet, in a recent session, has firmly protested. —The general statistics of Social Demo- eracy have lately been compiled and publish- ed by Dr. Lung, a prominent representative and agitator in Denmark. In his own land he credits this party with 90,000 adherents, while in Norway the political organization reports 11,600 members, and in Sweden the party societies have 40,000 followers, and the workingmen’s societies, holding Socialistic principles, 60,000. In England the political organizations have a membership of about 25,000, and the trades-unions 1,600,000, not all of whom, however, can be regarded as Social Democratic votes. In 1898 Belgium reported 534,000 votes, and France, in the same year, reported 1,000,000 for the four Socialistic schools. In Austria, under the new law, some 600,000 Social Democratic votes were cast, and in Hungary, where labor organiza- tions of a political character are forbidden, the membership of the party is computed at 200,000. In Italy, in the elections of 1897, the number of votes cast was 137,000, and in Switzerland 56,000. Spain, in 1898, gave 20,-, 000, and Holland 15,000 votes to this party. In Germany the party is the strongest, the votesiat the:last ‘Parliamentary elections be- ing 2)107)000. Im the course of a very thoughtful article in the Christliche Welt (No. 22) of Leipzig, a leading and influential organ of advanced religious and ethical thought in Germany, a well-known authority on Social problems, Paul Géhre, who has made a practical study of the problem by living and laboring with his own hands for months among the workingmen, discusses the remarkable progress which the peace idea has made in Germany in recent decades, notwithstanding the militarism in official cir- cles; and among the factors which have contributed most towards this end, he counts Social Democracy, thus assigning to this agitation a mission in modern civilization rarely accorded to it. After speaking of the Czar’s project and ideal, he adds: “But still more powerful in this direction has been the Czar’s most bitter enemy, namely, the Social Democracy of Germany. This party in 1898 cast about 2,500,000 votes, and accordingly has between four and five million adherents in Germany alone. And these four or five million the party has made into uncondi- tional enemies of war and adherents of peace.”’ WISE OF VIRGINIA. The Life of Henry A. Wise of Virginia: 1806-1876. By his grandson, the late Bar- ton H. Wise. Macmillan Co. 8vo, pp. xiii, 434. Governor Wise was a picturesque figure in the politics of the country from Jackson’s second term to the outbreak of the civil war. Lank and thin, with deep-set, piercing eyes, low, broad forehead, light hair worn long behind the ears, a large mouth, with thin lips and square chin, care- less in attire, an inveterate tobacco-chewer, chewing faster as he got excited with speak- ing, bold of speech, blurting out the pass- ing thought or feeling with little reference to conventionalities, he was a typical example of the Southern politician of that genera- tion as people knew him ir the cartoons of the time. But he had intellectual qualities which sustained and justified the interest his personal appearance excited. With re- markable fluency of speech, his ideas were always striking and apt to be novel. His standpoint was always his own, his opinions independent, his utterance of them trenchant and even fierce, though often enlivened by a native humor and a keen wit. His reso- nant voice was equal to the demands of the greatest crowds in the open air, and to the habit of talking by the half-day and renewing the speech after dinner. He was a native of the “Eastern Shore” in Virginia, and, in his congressional career, ‘Wise of Accomack” represented that sandy peninsula between the ocean and the Chesa- peake, peopled by small farmers and oyster- men, whose luxuries were the canvasback ducks and “tarrapin’’ that abounded in the tide-water creeks. A few parsons, doctors, and attorneys were the leaders of the com- munity, and the petty disputes of such a people were the material on which the young lawyer practised his logic and his wit, and plumed his wings for the higher flights from the stump which were to carry him into the national arena at Washington. After graduating at Washington College in western Pennsylvania, he studied law under Judge Tucker of Winchester in the Shenandoah valley, and, except a brief ex- periment in Tennessee, his home, during all his congressional career, was on the “bay side” of the peninsula, He was in an uncom- monly complete sense the product of his na- tive province, ip its virtues and its weak-
Page 19
July 20, 1899] The Nation. 55 nesses. His domestic life was pure and happy, and he was always frank in confess- ing the good influence of the womanly re- finement and piety which presided there. He avoided intemperance and gambling. He was a slaveholder, though slaves were comparatively few about him, and the few had a comparatively easy time in the small farming of the region. He adopted, however, the cardinal principle of the slaveholder’s creed, that, slaves being property, any re- striction which was not applied to all other | should not be invoked as a remedy except in the extreme case of the invasion of fun- damental and essential rights of a State or section. His refinement of doctrine was too subtle | for most Virginians, and when the Con- | federacy was organized and made overt | secession party because the | met war with war. war on the national forts, he joined the Government | contrived and directed a military raid upon Harper’s Ferry armory and arsenal, with- | property, everywhere, was a wrong against | the South. The Missouri Compromise was such a wrong. The exclusion of slavery from the Territories was such a denial of South- ern rights as to justify revolution. The anti- slavery movement was an impudent and senseless fanaticism. With his fashion of extreme statement, his gift of trenchant sarcasm, and habit of flerce denunciation, ‘system of slavery, and was looked upon at the North as the Hotspur of the fire-eaters. Wise’s relations as Governor to John Brown's invasion of Virginia and to Brown’s execution made him, to Northern men, the out any pretence of lawful authority, and | avowedly for the purpose of routing the | Union members of the State convention by | the uncontrollable excitement following the renewal of Patrick Henry's famous cry, | “Our brethren are already in the field.”” His political and personal prominence brought | him a commission as Brigadier-General in | the Southern army, but, despite his energy | he became a recognized champion of the | and personal courage, his impatience of true | military subordination and his combative- | ness for his opinions prevented him from embodiment of the Southern idea in 1859 and | 1860, almost as fully and typically as Jef- ferson Davis was during the civil war. The quality of Brown’s act which filled the ima- gination of Northern men was the heroic self-sacrifice for the enfranchisement of the slave. The total inadequacy of means to the end, the misjudgment of all probabilities, the illusions amounting to insanity, were all overshadowed by the sublimity of the man’s devotion to the most unselfish of purposes. To Wise, as the representative Southern man, Brown was the incarnation of aggres- sive abolitionism, and his raid the manifest demonstration of Northern hostility upon which years had been spent in Southern dec- lamation. If there were illusions on both sides, there were also curious foreshadow- ings of the real struggle and its influences on the combatants. In the presence of Brown’s patience under his wounds and physical suffering, the glib denunciation we had been so familiar with in Wise’s speeches disappeared, and he stood in sympathetic re- spect by the pallet of his prisoner, ques- tioning him with the courtesy due to a recognized peer and no vulgar outlaw. In Brown’s amazing self-control, his unfalter- ing purpose, his cool courage, his inde- peadence of factitious excitement or ner- vous exaltation, there was the premonition of the qualities of the Northern soldiery, which, when marshalled into armies under leaders worthy of the host, were to shatter the vain dreams of easy Southern victory. It is no slight evidence of Wise’s real man- hood that, when he came face to face with such an opponent, he anticipated the sim- plicity of demeanor, the absence of false pride and pretence, the frank cordiality, and the honest respect and confidence which marked the meetings of Grant and Lee, Johnston and Sherman, six years later when the great struggle had been fought out. Wise always denied that he was a seces- sionist, and advocated fighting within the Union, in the last resort, by the right of re- volution against what, from his ultra views of slavery, he declared would be an intolera- ble oppression—4. ¢., the enforcement of the Republican doctrine that there should be no more new slave States. In short, it was the old doctrine of nulification of obnoxious laws by force, with the limitation that it achieving any great results. He was, be- sides, too old to learn a new business re- quiring special adaptation for any real suc- cess in it. He proved his willingness to pay with his person for the advocacy of war; but, for influence upon the progress of events, he probably might better have con- tinued in civil life, where he was an ac- knowledged leader. When failure and surrender came, he was depressed and saddened beyond real recovery at the failure of the revolution he had great- ly helped to begin; but he soon saw and frankly declared that the end of slavery would prove a providential blessing to the South. At the beginning of 1866, in a letter to Fernando Wood, he said: “The main difference, that of slavery, has been determined for ever vi concitata belli. I am convinced that it could never have been settled in any other way, and that for that reason the war itself was providential; it was God’s war, and who on earth dares gainsay it?’ (p. 385). Again, six years later, he wrote to a friend, expressing his gratitude to the colored people for quiet orderliness during the war, and adding, “I would not enslave them or their children again if I could, and I could not if I would. I therefore heartily adopt as well as acqui- esce in the Fifteenth Amendment of the Con- stitution of the United States’ (p. 396). Such words may well be inscribed over against the denunciations of Garrison and Quincy Adams he had uttered in the flerce controversy of his earlier years, as proof how great a revolution the armed conflict of the war made in opi- nion and feeling as well as in power. His oratorical gift, by which he had led his people, had a good deal of genuine feel- ing, of imagination and fancy, and a natural taste for orotund phrases and balanced sen- tences. His facundity showed itself in his varied forms of setting the same thought, turning it over and over with new ver- biage, till he was sure it had made its full impression on his auditors, who had learned to enjoy and admire his fluency. He prefer- red to appeal to the nobler motives, and there was rarely anything low in his speech- es, though he often clinched the effect of a half-poetic passage by some homely compari- son which would relieve the attentics and bring his hearers into rapport with him:by a hearty laugh. It is hard to show the charac- ter of such speaking by a brief quotation, but one may get a tolerably fair idea of his man- ner from the following passage from a cam- | It is even said that he | paign speech in 1855, in which he was calling his people away from the seductions of the “Know-Nothings,” by offering the better Is- sue of internal improvements and the deve- lopment of commerce, mining, and manufac- tures, reproaching Virginians for their un- thrifty reliance upon poor farming alone. If he had marked the effect of slavery in this, the lesson would have been complete. “On Chesapeake Bay, from the mouth of | the Rappahannock to the capes of the Chesa- peake, you have roadsteads and harbors sufficient to float the navies of the world. From the River of Swans, on whose mar gin we are, down to the line of North Caro- lina, you have the Potomac, the Rappahan- nock, the Piankatank, from Mobjack Bay to James River and the Elizabeth River- meeting in the most beautiful sheet water of all the seas of the earth. You have the bowels of your western moun- tains rich in iron, in copper, in coal, in salt, in gypsum, and the very earth is rich in oil which makes the rivers inflame. You have the line of the Alleghany, that beau- tiful blue ridge which stands, placed there by the Almighty, not to obstruct the way of the people to market, but placed there in the very bounty of Providence to milk the clouds, to make the sweet springs which are the sources of your rivers. And at the head of every stream is the waterfall mur muring the music of your power. And yet commerce has long ago spread her sails and sailed away from you; you have not as ail of yet dug more than coal eaough to warm yourselves at your own hearths; you have set no tilt-hammer of Vulcan to strike blows worthy of gods in the iron foundries You have not yet spun more than the coarse cotton to clothe your own slaves. You have | had no commerce, no mining, no manu- facturers; you have relied alone on the single power of agriculture—and such agri- culture! Your sedge patches outshine the sun Your inattention to your only source of wealth has scarred the very bosom of mo- ther earth. Instead of having to feed cat- tle on a thousand hills, you have had to chase the stump-tailed steer through the sedge patches to procure a tough beef- steak.”’ Mr. Barton Haxall Wise, the biographer, was a young man, full of promise, who made his grandfather's life a study of filial de- votion, and died with the first proof-sheets of the book upon his table. His tempe rate judgments, his calm discriminations. his control of family pride, his broad po- litical views, his literary instincts and hap- py power of expression, are remarkable in a young man’s first and sole literary venture of importance. He has reared an honor- able monument to himself as well as to his progenitor. These circumstances make us indebted to his uncle John S. Wise for an introductory sketch of the author, full of interest as well as of affectionate and ap- preciative feeling. VONDEL’S LUCIFER. Vondel’s Lucifer. Translated from the Dutch by Leonard Charles van Noppen. New York: Continental Publishing Co. Dutch literature has always been strangely neglected in England and America. Few scholars have concerned themselves with it, and even the untiring pen of the professional translator has—except for a few novels-— left it undisturbed. If proof were needed for what everybody acknowledges, a single plece of evidence would suffice: Mr. van Noppen’s translation of ‘Lucifer’ is the first English version of any of Vondel’s dramas or longer poems. The fact is sufficiently curi- ous, however one looks at it; for the ‘Luct- fer’ is not only the supreme masterpiece of Dutch poetry, but is beyond question one of
Page 20
56 ‘The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1777 ——————— the very great things in the universal litera- ture of the last three centuries. Almost in- credibly strange; however, is such neglect of this particular piece when one remembers how much it has been talked about of late years as the possible source of ‘Paradise Lost,’ or, at all events, as a work well known to Milton and systematically ransacked by him for its stores of thought and imagery. Upon the intricacies of the ‘‘Milton-Vondel debate” we have no intention of entering at this time. Too much and too little has al- ready been written on this interesting but not very important question; too much, if one has regard to the narrow range which the discussion has taken and the fallacies that have attended it; too little, in view of the crying need of a thorough examination of the Biblical epic material before Milton. Such an examination would, beyond a doubt, resu!t in the cancellation of most of the parallels between the Dutch and the Eng- lish poet which the partisan zeal of Mr. Ed- mundson has accumulated. Meantime, it is to be hoped that every student of Milton will read Mr. van Noppen’s ‘Lucifer,’ and so convince himself that the differences between the Dutch drama and the Hnglish epic are fundamental in plan, conception, and con- duct. The wonder is, indeed, not that we may detect a resemblance here and there, but that—given an identical body of Scriptural and patristic material—two great poems so very dissimilar should have been produced at nearly the same moment. That Milton had some acquaintance with Vondel’s tra- gedy is not improbable. That it was in any sense a controlling influence in the composi- tion of the ‘Paradise Lost’ we find it im- possible to believe. On this point we are glad to be at one with so ardent a Vondel- fan as Mr. van Noppen himself, who is con- vinced “that a critical and impartial com- parison of the two masterpieces will neither detract from the glory of Milton nor dim the grandeur of Vondel.’’ Be that as it may, the real interest which attaches to the great Dutch drama is independent of all such ques- tions. Whether it is studied as a work of art or as an expression of national life and character in a fervid time, it will be found equally absorbing and impressive. The controlling motive of the tragedy is the wounded pride of Lucifer. It is not mere ambition that leads him to revolt. It is his knowledge of the Creation, and of the ulti- mate destiny of the Son of Man: “God hath decreed, Even from eternity, that man shall high Exalted be, even o'er the angel world, Ye shall behold the eternal Word above, When clad in flesh and bone, anointed Lord And Chief and Judge, mete justice to the hosts Of spirits, to angels and to men alike, From His high seat, in His unshadowed realm."’ Nor is his feeling merely that of unworthy envy. He tries to belleve—he even succeeds in persuading himself—that in this proposed exaltation of humanity God is disgracing the angels and proving false to the divine na- ture. Thus the revolt in heaven commands, in some measure, our «sympathy, as the al- most sincere, though infatuated, asser- tion of a mistaken principle of loyalty to an ill-conceived ideal. The character of Lu- eifer is further complicated by a kind of weakness quite consistent with his position as a tragic hero. Like Macbeth, he needs a tempter, and this role is played by Belzebub, without the influence of whose subtle and disaffected nature one feels that the decisive step might not have been taken after all. Hence the fourth act, which is mostly occu- pied with Rafael’s sublimely futile attempt to win Lucifer to repent before it is too late, has all the suspense of a mighty crisis, despite our knowledge of what is to come. It may well be doubted if the intensity of this mo- ment is surpassed by anything in ‘Paradise Lost.’ With the beginning of the fifth act, how- ever, the hand of the artist begins to falter. The ‘Lucifer,’ we must remember, was meant for the stage, and indeed had actually been twice performed before the clergy succeeded in suppressing it. Stage battles are never im- pressive, and, in the present case, a coram populo presentation of the strife in heaven would have been wildly impossible. Hence the poet was forced to confine himself to nar- rative declamation. But this is not all. The act falls into two distinct parts. In the first, Uriel describes the triumph of Michael over the host of Lucifer; in the second, the Temp- tation, and the Fall of Man, are reported by Gabriel, and the whole ends with a choral prophecy of the ‘“‘Seed of the woman that shall bruise the Serpent’s head.”” The interest of the act is divided; essential unity is sac- rificed to the formal unities and to the exigencies of the theatre. The poet at- tempted the impossible, and failed. Magnis tamen ecacidit ausis! We must turn from the drama itself to Mr. van Noppen’s version. Vondel is not an easy author to translate. His vocabulary is rich and varied, and his command of metre is no less extraordinary than his diction. The dia- logue of the tragedy is in rhyming Alex- andrines, and the choral songs move in com- plex lyric measures. To reproduce the pre- cise effect in English is quite impossible; to approximate it would tax the powers or a great poet. Yet, despite these difficulties, Mr. van Noppen has produced something more than a merely creditable version. He has succeeded—we scarcely know how—in giving a pretty good idea of the power and beauty of the original. Wisely refusing to essay the English Alexandrine, he has put the body of the play into respectable blank verse. At its best, this is correct, and not unmusical, as in the following extract: “Yea, e’er we yield, these empyrean vaults, Proud in their towering masonry, shall burst With all their airy arches and dissolve Before our eyes; this huge and joint-racked Earth, Like a misshapen monster, lifeless lie; This wondrous universe to chaos fall, And to its primal desolation change. Who dares, who dares defy great Lucifer?’’ At its worst, to be sure, Mr. van Noppen’s verses are pretty bad: ***O Adam,’ thunders God, ‘where art thou hid?’ ‘Forgive me, Lord; I flee thy countenance, Naked and all ashamed.’ ‘Who taught thee thus,’ Asks God, ‘thy shame and nakedness to know? Didst dare profane thy lips with the forbidden Fruit?’ ‘Aye, my bride, my wife, alas! did tempt.’ She says, “The wily Serpent hath deceived Me with this lure.’ Thus each the charge denies Of being the cause of their sad wretchedness.”’ Such verses as these remind us of the mock-Wordsworthian, “A Mr. Wilkinson, a clergyman,” but luckily there are not 80 very many of them. In the choruses the translator has adhered to the original me- tres, and, though it would be folly to claim for his English odes all the high qualities of their originals—a claim which Mr. van Nop- pen would be the last to make—it is not too much to say that here too a difficult task has been performed with a good measure of succeis. Throughout, the translator has treated his author with commendable reverence. He has dove his best to stick to his text, often sacrificing smoothness rather than resort to paraphrase. The closeness and accuracy of his version are alike remarkable. Er- rors occur, but they are not numerous. The worst, perhaps, is the translation (p. 345) of “Zij weken geen gestarnte in eendracht noch in peis’” by: “They would not, as now, Awake the stars from their harmonious peace."’ The famous astronomical figure in the speech of the Chorus immediately preceding this passage is also misunderstood and erroneous- ly rendered. Again, inthe same act, the point of Belial’s retort to the Chorus (“‘De vader leer’ het kind hem volgen op zijn spoor’’) seems to be missed; at all events the ren- dering is vague and weak. But such slips are infrequent and do not impair the gene- ral excellence of Mr. van Noppen’s work. Besides the translation, the volume con- tains an introduction by Prof. W. H. Car- penter, a note on ‘Vondel and his Lucifer,’ by Prof. Kalff, the highest Dutch authority, and a Life of Vondel and a critique of the tragedy by Mr. van Noppen himself. A table of Mr. Edmundson’s “parallels between Von- del and Milton’ adds to the value of the work, The book is illustrated by John Aarts, and is printed with unusual sumptuousness. BENN’S PHILOSOPHY OF GREECH. The Philosophy of Greece; Considered in Relation to the Character and History of its People. By Alfred William Benn. Lon- don: Grant Richards. Mr. Alfred Benn is known to a small circle of appreciative readers as a frequent con- tributor to the Academy, and as the author of a suggestive and readable work on ‘The Greek Philosophers’ which has never re- ceived the recognition that it deserves. Mr. Benn’s attitude is that of the scholarly and philosophic amateur. He can follow the lat- est researches of the Germans, and, if need be, control their use of the sources; he writes eloquently, and evidently from per- sonal knowledge, of the great poets and phi- losophers of Greece; but he undertakes no minute erudite investigations. His aim is rather to portray brilliantly the larger move- ments of Greek life and thought, to general- ize their tendencies, and to set them forth in relation to the thought of the modern world. -His special distinction is that he unites to a very sufficient scholarship and a fluent style a genuine sympathy with physi- cal science and the modern scientific point of view. Too often the student of Greek philosophy, in the selection of a guide, is ° compelled to choose between a belated Hege- lian out of touch with modern thought and a rampant Baconian ignorant of Greek. In his new work, ‘The Philosophy of Greece,’ Mr. Benn, while restating some of his earlier ideas, is chiefly occupied with the interpretation of the general movement of Greek philosophy regarded as an expression of the character and history of the Greek people. The suggestion of this method came to him from Prof. Knight of St. Andrews, who thought that the entire history of phi- losophy ought to be rewritten from this point of view as a “philosophy of the nations.” But, as Mr. Benn would himself admit, the idea is in the air. The most popular teach- ers of philosophy in this country are in- clined to treat the history of philosophy in this way. That is to say, they dissociate it from the direct study of ultimate psycho- Sa iiat Te Nate. :
Page 21
= te % & B ee 4 & SBS RE Riemann o.. ERR tes ee: Rae aie: £3 July 20, 1899] The Nation. 57 logical and metaphysical questions, and make of it a sort of sublimated philosophy of his- tory. They are never weary of repeating — that there is nothing absolute in the phi- losophy of an individual or of a nation. It is in each case determined by character and circumstance. The picturesqueness of this method of treatment cannot be denied. Broad, * ingenious generalizations relating the entire | social, economic, and artistic life of a people to the abstract utterances of its metaphysical philosophers are interesting in themselves, and are eagerly welcomed by the student as a substitute for the toilsome determination of the precise meanings of difficult texts. But interest and picturesqueness of this kind may be purchased too dear. One may admit abstractly that all products of Greek civiliza- tion must be connected by fine-spun threads of relation with each other, with the qualities of the Greek genius and the conditions of Greek life—one may grant all this and yet distrust the ability of the mo- dern student to unravel so tangled a web. ‘God in History’ proved to be “Bunsen in History,”’ and similarly subtle laws of cor- relation between disparate phenomena may turn out, under the critical microscope, to be only accidental associations in the mind of the theorist, or at best ingenious fancies rendered plausible by the pseudo-inductive accumulation of citations wrested from their context, and unconsciously colored by the preconceptions of the generalizer. So, while we have read Mr. Benn’s book with great interest, our more specific criti- cism must take the form of dissent from pro- positions that seem to us either unverifiable or wholly fantastic. It may have been a spe- cial characteristic of the Greek mind to set up 4 sharp antithesis and then bridge it over by the insertion of transitional links—though we suspect that a clever writer would un- dertake to show us thesis, antithesis, and transitional mediation everywhere. But we can hardly take seriously the citation, as il- lustrations of this law of the fact, that “‘the ‘Tliad’ was built up by the insertion of transi- tional links between the opening and the conclusion’’; that ‘‘so also the Olympian the- ology was organized on a mediatorial basis, Apollo, once an independent god, being re- garded solely as the interpreter of Zeus’’; that similarly the Greek mind developed ge- ometry out of Egyptian mensuration by in- terpolating a series of steps between the sub- ject of the conclusion and the predicate; and lastly that Aristophanes pitches on the clouds | as the goddesses of physical inquiry because they are the mediators between earth and sky. “Know thyself’ was undoubtedly a fundamental precept of Greek ethical reflec- tion, but it is going very far afield to say that, even in the worst times, self-knowledge still asserted itself as an advantage in the struggle for existence, since Thucydides tells us that inferior wits came off best in the dis- sensions at Corcyra because, recognizing their own inferiority in intrigue, they struck at once. There is doubtless some connection between climate, social environment, politics, and philosophy; but Mr. Benn cannot really know that Heraclitus sprang from the union of the sombre enthusiasm fostered by the re- ligion of Diana of the Ephesians with the lu- minous, orderly genius of Ionia; or that the | home-staying Ionians took their speculative | bias from meteorology and physiology because © “they were occupied as such people are with | the weather and the care of their health,” whereas the Italiate Ionians, having travelled afar, generalized the idea of space. The pre- Socratic cosmologists were perhaps aristo- crats, as Plato certainly was, but it is not i ) | ! a safe inference that “it was in consonance | with aristocratic tradition that they disdain- ed to explain their theories by argument,” or | possess""—4. ¢., | that the negative result of the minor Socra- | | tic dialogues is due to Plato’s desire to dis- credit induction, for which he had an aristo- cratic dislike. And it surely is overstepping | both the evidence and the modesty of nature | | to denounce Empedocles as a ‘‘vegetarian ter- rorist,”” “a hal&Semitized thaumaturgist reared on a reeking hotbed of salvationist su- | perstition.” These be hard words. We may take more seriously Mr. Benn’s interesting chapter on the opposition be- tween the humanists and the naturalists among the Greek sophists, though here too we think that both he and Gomperz, whom in part he follows, strain the evidence. The antithesis between nature and law or con- vention held a large place in the thinking ef the time. Democritus distinguishes the solid reality of the atoms from the conven- tional and relative reality of the secondary qualities of sense-perception. The conven- tional or natural origin of language was hotly debated. In ethics, too, nature was appealed to for more moral ends ag author of the “higher law,” and for antinomian or immoral purposes in protest against the artificiality of the moral conventions that seek to fetter the free play of human pas- sion and appetite. But Mr. Benn goes further than this, and attempts to assign the thinkers of the time to two distinct schools, the humanists and the naturalists; and here we think he goes beyond the evidence. Hippias is not classified by the casual remark attributed to him in the ‘Protagoras’ that the distinguished company assembled at the house of Callias are friends by nature and not by the artificial conven- tions of society. And to say that this is a “pregnant principle’ from which “the fate- ful triad liberty, equality, and fraternity was afterwards destined to be developed,” is sheer buncombe. Hippias’s self-sufficiency was a very different thing from that of the Cynics and Stoics. His was a vainglorious many-sidedness, theirs a philosophic limi- tation of desires. Prodicus taught naturai Philosophy—a genuine Sophist dabbled in everything; but his show course was the fifty-drachma lecture course on synonyms, which, by the way, Plato does not treat with bitter satire, but with playful per- siflage. Both Prodicus and Hippias seem to have been luxurious and self-indulgent rather than stoical in their habits of life, and Aristophanes’s gibes at the pale-faced starveling disciples of Socrates are singular evidence for the proposition that “plain living and high thinking’ was the motto of the ‘“‘physiocratic school.”’ The evidence for the classification of Pro- tagoras and Gorgias as partisans of véyos is equally defective. In the “Theetetus,’ Protagoras actually illustrates ethical cul- ture by gardening—the Georgics of the mind, in Bacon’s phrase. Gorgias’s disciples in the ‘Gorgias’ appeal to nature. And Mr. Benn merely illustrates the danger of us- ing Jowett without control when he quotes the remark of Agathon in the ‘Symposium’ that “where there is voluntary agreement, there, as the laws which are the lords of the city say, is justice.” If he had look- ed at Shelley’s version, not to speak of the original, he would have found the simple statement, quite Innocent of genera! philosophical significance: “and that which every [any] one voluntarily concedes to an- other, the laws, which are the kings of the republic, decree that it is just for him to our laws ratify voluntary agreements. But it is impossible to pursue this theme further here. The attempt in this and al- milar cases to erect elaborate structures of hypothesis on an insufficient foundation of evidence, is a natural result of the profes- sional preoccupation of thousands of acute minds with the classics. It may advance knowledge in the end; meanwhile, it dis tracts attention from the main object of classical studies — disinterested contem plation and enjoyment of the beautiful and the significant. Quwu’est-ce que cela prouve! cannot be the watchword of the highest classical scholarship, James Russell Lowell. By Edward Everett Hale, jr. [‘The Beacon Biographies.] Bos- ton: Small, Maynard & Co. This compact and well-printed little book has a double interest for the attentive reader, as being at once a bit of literary criticism and an example of literary heredity. It is not of- ten that a father and son, bearing the same baptismal names, publish within six months two separate books on precisely the samv subject. This being the fact, the first point of interest will naturally He in seeing how far they duplicate each other. In this search, the reader will readily find some points of style in common—a certain agreeable and conversational, not to say chatty, air; a to- lerable readiness in forming and expressing offhand opinions; a few familiar catchwords, such as “all the same” and “any way’; and an occasional slovenliness of sentences, show- ing either haste in writing or absence of re- vision. The chances are, for instance, that if one of the pupils of Mr. E. E. Hale, jr., at Union College had inserted in a thesis such a sentence as this—‘‘He seemed to be as gift- ed as an occasional author as he was as a poet or essayist” (p. 106)—the reviewing of- ficer might have pointed out that one smali monosyllable was rather overworked in the passage. And, finally, another hereditary trait is seen in a habit of stepping aside for little collateral axioms, such as this (p. 110): “The great pleasures of the old are unsel- fish. When a man passes seventy, if not be- fore, he is apt to take his greatest pleasure in the happiness of those about him.” This is a view which, however agreeable, is not always confirmed, we fancy, by the old age of artists, authors, or politicians. What is noticeable, however, beyond these evidences of heredity is a marked divergence from all inherited qualities in the sub- stantial structure ‘of the book, which is, as a whole, condensed instead of discursive, methodical and not scattering, analytic rather than gossipy. This is to be placed to the cre- dit of the new generation. Something is aiso due to the evident plan of the new series of biographies, which seems to be more essen- tially historic than blographic. The subject of the book, very clearly, is Lowell the au- thor and the public man, not Lowell as that rather complex human phenomenon which he actually was. In this last aspect there may perhaps be a little source of disappoint- ment to the reader. Few works, taking Low- ell as their subject, have added less to our knowledge of that curious and rather fasci-
Page 22
¥ Be q 58 The Nation. [Vol. 69, No. 1777 nating commingling of elements which show- ed itself in him, and which was indeed a life- long puzzle to himself. The value of the book is in its discussion of Lowell as a force in the literature and society which were tak- ing form about him; and this value is quite disproportioned to the size of the book. It is really the first word on the subject from the next generation—the first answer to that “Appeal to an Impartial Posterity’’ which every author unconsciously makes, though only Madame Roland gave it that high- sounding title. Herein it fitly keeps the pro- mise contained in the prospectus of this se- ries, to deal with “‘those Americans whose personalities have impressed themselves most deeply on the character and history of their country’’; and therefore deserves high praise. Such praise does. not imply, by any means, that we always agree with the author's as- sumptions or views, but only that we re- cognize them as frankly and clearly put. Here we see again the advantage that may be gained by a single step in the right direc- tion, It detaches from all responsibility for the opinions of one’s grandfather. With all the growing and generous interest of the Rev. Dr. Hale in the cause of freedom, he never could quite shake himself free from the shadow of the eminent editor, Nathan Hale, in his old-time contest with the new-born heresy, abolitionism. Taking one step more, Mr. E. E. Hale, jr., stands forth free from that hereditary shadow. True, we cannot al- ways understand just what he means by some of his phrases, even on this point, as where he says that the reader can see what a claim the anti-slavery movement made on the poets of its time “‘by glancing at the earlier poems of Whittier and Holmes’ (p. 21). We can recall no allusion to the subject in Holmes’s early poems beyond a trivial squib, as where, in his account of the very hot day, he speaks of “the abolition men and maids’ as tanned by it to the color of their friends; but if this seems to Mr. Hale a sufficient basis for his phrase, we have no objection to it. Nor can we quite comprehend the contrast here made between Lowell and Whittier when he says: ‘‘Whittier’s poems have each some blow at slavery; Lowell thought rather of free- dom.”’ This seems to us an exaggerated dis- tinction, At the Garrisonian or “disunion’’ conventions which Lowell habitually attend- ed, the actual negro slave was much more in evidence than at the ‘“‘political’’ anti-sla- very meetings which Whittier frequented; and Lowell was really thrown more in contact with leading colored men, such as Douglass and Remond, than Whittier was. It did not take the Mexican war to make Lowell an abolitionist. Yet even here the point taken is a fair one, if a little overstrained, and perhaps really touches a difference in the training or temperament of the two men, Here and there we find opinions from which we should dissent, in other directions. Mr. Hale says (p. 31) that Lowell “was not in those earlier years a very popular poet,” whereas the phrase of Willis, “the best- launched poet of his time,’ seems more in accordance with the general testimony of contemporaries. No doubt magazines were few and prices low, but when Lowell had, within a year or two of the publication of his first volume, an offer from Graham's Magazine to print a poem every month at $120 a year, it meant a recognition such as few young poets win so easily. Again, when Mr. Hale says: “Lowell's scholarship was not the scholarship of to-day’ (p. 41), he speaks what is a matter of course; yet it is also true that when Lowell's interleaved copy of Wercester’s Dictionary came to light, through an auction store, and was bought by the Cambridge Public Library, its scanti- ly filled pages won at once, as we happen to know, the most cordial appreciation of their quality from the most eminent English scholars among the Harvard professors. Again, we demur a little at the rather sweeping remark (p. 37) about ‘“‘the scho- larship of our own time, which is not only very unpoetic, but on the.whole very much opposed to poetry”; and we doubt if the English examination papers at any of our leading universities would quite justify this imputation; at Mr. Hale’s alma mater they certainly would not. Doubtless, tastes vary at different periods, and perhaps the stan- dards which recognize the leadership of Kipling would seem to many less valid than those which recognized the leadership of Browning. This would at any rate be our own point of view, but we cannot agree with Mr. Hale’s inferences from the fact-- if, indeed, this be the kind of fact from which his inferences are drawn. Least of all should we agree with one of his most important dicta, the announcement that the twenty-five essays in ‘Among My Books’ and ‘My Study Windows’ will ‘‘prob- ably last longer than anything else of Low- ell’s’” (p. 83). Even supposing, which is probable, that this assertion is meant to refer to prose alone, how could Mr. Hale have al- lowed himself seriously to add, ‘‘What he wrote subsequently has never had any such acceptance and never will be so widely known” (p. 83)? We should gay, on the other hand, that the Address on Democracy had both won more “acceptance’’ and be- come more “widely known” than anything he had previously written; indeed, that it took its place as distinctly at the head of Lowell’s prose work as did the ‘“Commemo- ration Ode’’ at the head of his poetry. We cannot, therefore, concede to Mr. Hale the very greatest felicity in critical opin- ion, while admitting that some of the points he makes—as, that Lowell has now passed into the position of a classic rather than of an immediate propelling force (p. viii); that the period when he came forward was one in which literature held a greater relative prominence than now (p. 11); that he was, more than any other, “the repre- sentative American man of letters of his day” (p. 111)—-seem to us to be exceedingly well put, and to furnish a good preparation for the next generation’s study of Lowell. Huropean History. An Outline of its De- velopment. By George Burton Adams. With maps and illustrations. The Macmil- lan Co. 1899. This book, which is designed for the use of higher schools and of colleges, possesses many excellent features apd may be called without hesitation a suceess, Prof, Adams avoids most of the shortcomings which one expects to meet with in manuals (¢. g., dul- ness, distorted proportions, lack of sugges- tion), and has many merits of his own which we shall presently specify. Speaking at large, we must give the volume our hearty approval, and express the hope that it may be widely established as a text- book. When one analyzes the contents, a con- siderable range of subject-matter ia obser- vable. Besides the text proper, there are bibliographical tables and particular biblio- graphical references to the various sub- jects considered, a paragraph of ‘‘topics’’ at the end of each chapter, presumably for questioning purposes; ‘‘topics for studies in review,” placed at the end of each main period; and a-table of important dates for review, sometimes given synoptically in parallel columns. In addition to these di- versified attractions must be mentioned nu- merous illustrations and maps. Thus the au- thor presents a great deal of apparatus out- side his plain narrative, all of which, how- ever, is intended to supplement, emphasize, or embellish the text itself. Here lurks the danger of providing too much machi- nery, which has, however, been escaped by a close regard to the correlation of parts. In spite of the various elements which it presents to the eye, the work cannot be accused of lacking unity. We are unable to tell what degree of trust Prof. Adams places in the apparatus which we have just described. Personally, we think that most of it will prove useful, and the bibliographies are indispensable. But the chief virtue of the treatise does not consist therein. A large proportion of the persons who have written outlines or sketches of European history are merely compilers, and not in any fit sense of the term historians. By process of abridging they have won a certain “base authority from others’ books,’”’ and have managed to fill up a fixed quota of pages. General his- tory has, probably, suffered more from writers of this kind than limited periods and separate countries have done. On the other hand, Prof. Adams has studied sys- tematically; he can, through a comparative knowledge, estimate the character of epochs and nations; and therefore he mo- dels a shapely, organic whole. He is a pro- fessional who knows where to go for the best information, and how to employ it when brought together. Next after the writer’s competence, we must rank in the list of strong points the remarkable pains which he has taken with his bibliographies. They are really admira- ble, and so conjoined with the text that the full measure of their value is secured. Fol- lowing the table of contents is placed a page which contains the titles of such books in French, German, and English ag the teacher will probably require for general reference, and special bibliographies stand at the head of every leading subdivision. These are all rendered the more practical by comprising the publisher’s name and the cost price of the volume. Page by page, too, as the text proceeds, the student will find in the margin some standard authority for every leading topic which is taken up, and, whatever the book in question may be, precise passages from it are recommended— which is something quite different from a nebulous allusion to the whole work. Adams the justice of a discriminating ex-
Page 23
July 20, 1899] The Nation. 59 cated with perfect accuracy, and numerous misprints occur; e. g., Maestsicht for Maés- tricht, Landshul for Landshut, Nerwinde for Neerwinden, Manheim for Mannheim, Le- gnago for Legnano, etc. Secondly, Prof. Adams’s style, although clear and compact, does not reach quite the same level with his ideas and information. Finally, the love of generalization now and then carries him too far. For instance, on p. 168 this state- ment occurs: “The territories of Charle- magne were, by the year 800, practically those of the old Roman Empire in the West.” But the Western Empire at the time of the final division between Arcadius and Honorius included the provinces of Africa, Spain, and Britain, besides Sardinia | and what we may call by their later name the Two Sicilies, none of which (save the small strip of the Spanish March) Charle- magne controlled. Of course Prof. Adams knows the comparative extent of the two empires as well as possible, but here, and in several other cases, his fondness for symmetrical formulas carries him a littie beyond the mark. Our strictures, however, are quite insig- nificant when weighed with our commenda- tion of this well-designed and carefully finished text-book. The Genesis and Dissolution of the Faculty of Speech: A Clinical and Psychological Study of Aphasia. By Joseph Collins, M.D., etc. Macmillan Co. 1898. Pp. 426. The study of the speech-faculty has long been a fascinating one, even for the layman, and this excellent and critical treatise, to which was awarded in 1897 the Alvarenza prize of the College of Physicians of Phila- delphia, deserves to be widely read. Every cultivated man knows something of the plan on which the brain is built; and the chance of extending that knowledge by gaining a closer sight of the inner working of the mar- vellous speech-function is one not to be ne- glected. The language-faculty seems, on the one hand, the antechamber to the mysteri- ous temple of thought, while, on the other, the study of the mechanism on which it is based lets one see, with almost diagrammatic clearness, a portion of the scheme by which the brain seeks to gain its ends. It is less than four decades since Broca published the remarkable observations that appeared at first to place the whole function of speech in a small portion of the frontal lobe, a little in advance of what is now known to be the primary centre for the movements of the organs of articulation. Nearly ten years later came the remarkable discoveries by Fritsch and Hitzig of Ger- many, and Ferrier of England, which opened the flood-gates of research with regard to cerebral localization in general; and soon afterwards Wernicke published his little pamphlet which made it clear that Broca’s area was concerned only with speech in a narrower sense, and that the convolutions of the temporal lobe in which the higher functions of hearing were represented, were an equally important part of the ‘“‘zone of language.”” With this admirable paper the its disturbances were surely laid. It is Interesting to note that the tendency has shown itself, both in the study of the cerebral localization in general, and in that of the speech function in particular, to re- cognize more and more plainly the fron band that ties together different sorts of func- tions which seemed at first sight Independ- ent. The physiologist Goltz has been the strong and often much misappreciated advo- cate of this doctrine as regards the general functions of the brain, and Dr. Collins ranges himself squarely with those who adopt the eame conception for the language-function. As in the child the growing power of utter- ance leans upon the ear and upon the “inner hearing,”’ so even in the adult the areas corresponding to the organs of speech and organs of hearing remain so closely depend- ent one on the other that neither can be damaged without the activity of both being impaired. It was Wernicke’s essay that first made clear the character of speech disturb- ance resulting from an injury of that part of the brain in which sounds are first in- terpreted as symbols of thought, showing that while the person with such an injury could still speak, his power of controlling his words was lacking. Dr. Collins aptly compares this condition to that of an engine running off by itself with the throttle-valve wide open. Speech may at first pour in an unregulated flood, but after a time even ut- terance will practically cease, as the engine stops when its fuel is exhausted. It must be observed that, in the modern conception of the conditions at stake, which is not likely to be materially changed, the centre con- cerned with the interpretation of sounds as words stands in much the same relation to the peripheral organs of hearing that Broca’s convolution occupies for the organs of ay- ticulation, and the “‘angular gyrus,’’ a por- tion of the brain situated near that part which is devoted to primary visual percep- tions for the function of sight. An injury of these centres does not cause a person to be- come blind or deaf or paralyzed as to his organs of speech, and not until these centres or the tracts uniting them (to- gether making up the “zone of language’’) are damaged is a person properly speaking aphasic. He may be unable to speak, but he still has the higher mental use of words. It is customary to say—and this is Collins's mode of expression—that these centres are “storehouses,” as it were, for ‘‘memories”’ of the special sensations of motion, and sound, and sight necessary for the use and comprehension of speech. In other words, these sensations enter there into combina- tions which clothe them with new signifi- cance. The curve of the vibrations which are set up in these portions of the sounding- board of the brain is no longer a simple but a compound curve. From this point onward the processes which underlie words are no longer symbols of motion and sensation alone, but rather symbols of thought. The conception of the brain as “storing up’’ me- mories is, however, misleading. Each re- sponsive thrill of the brain stands for itself alone, though it differs from each that pre- ceded and from each that follows it. The memory of the past is reproduced only in so far as it forms an integral part and posses- sion of the present. It would, of course, be impossible to dis- cuss here the many important questions exa- | mined in this book, such as those, for exam- foundations of the doctrines of speech and | ple, relating to the fascinating subject of dis- turbances of language-function correlated to visual impairments of different sorts. It may be mentioned in passing that the au- thor is one of those who with good reason disbelieve in the existence of a specialized “‘writing-centre.” On the other hand, he seems to sanction the psychological theo- ries of Flechsig, though they have been in some respects pretty thoroughly dis- credited. Many points in the doctrine of aphasia are of course still obscure. Among them are those relating to the curicus functional disorders of speech, as seen in fatigue and in migraine. The side on which the book is relatively lacking is the psychological side; had this been more fully developed, the keen suggestions of Hugh- lings Jackson, somewhat old though they now are, would have found a larger place. Still, every chapter is full of interesting matter and contains little to find fault with. Dr. Collins’s style is clear and good, ex- cept for a somewhat fanciful straining after unusual terms. They are indeed sometimes better than the old ones, but they distract the attention to a degree that their intrinsic me- rit does not always make up for. Selections from the Manuscripts of Lady Louisa Stuart. Harper & Brothers. 1899. Lady Louisa Stuart was the daughter of John, Earl of Bute, the prime minister and favorite of George III. Born in 1757, while George II. was still on the throne, her life of nearly a century extended to 1851, the year in which Napoleon III. overthrew the French Republic. With her natural gifts of observation and expression, and the ad- vantages of high position and long life, she could have become one of the most delight- ful memoirists of her time had she so chosen: but she was shy of appearing in print, and these interesting papers were written only for a family circle. Her account of John, Duke of Argyll, and of some of his family is very entertaining. All readers of Scott will rememberthe stately Duke who befriends Jeanie Deans, but Scott gives no glimpse of the peculiarities of his character. An eccentric streak (perhaps due to the “‘Tollemache blood’’) seems to have run through that branch of the Campbells. Few things are odder than his second mar- riage. This great and splendid nobleman, who might have aspired to a royal alliance, fell madly in love with a poor, homely, un- educated girl, with the manners of a dairy- maid, who was not the least in love with him. Jenny Warburton, daughter of a country Squire, was one of the maids of honor at the court of Queen Anne, where she was the laughing-stock of her companions for her blunt speech and constant blunders. When the great and admired Duke returned from the Continent, Jenny, like all the rest, thought him a very great man. So one day at dinner, when her companions called on each other for toasts, simple Jenny, instead of naming some bishop or octogenarian ge- neral, proposed the Duke of Argyll. Shrieks of laughter greeted this announcement; the Duke must at once be told of the conquest he had made—or no, such an honor would make him too proud—until poor Jenny left the table in tears. At a ball that evening the Duke of Shrewsbury told the joke to Argyll, who had been quite unaware of Jen- ny’s existence, but now feit bound to show | her some little attention by way of consola- | tion. The result was a perfect infatuation on the part of the Duke, who soon came to look upon Jenny as the paragon of her sex, and, though he could not then offer her marriage (his separated wife being aitill alive), he spent a portion of every day in
Page 24
60
The Nation.
[ Vol. 69, No. 1777
her company. When his Duchess died, every- body supposed that Argyll would drop Jen- ny and seek an exalted alliance; but no, he flew to his Jane,whom heconsiderednot only the most virtuous, but the most beautiful, witty, and altogether fascinating of women. Nor did time nor matrimonial experience damp this ardor; he “remained throughout life a faithful, doating, adoring lover,’’ while his Jane, who had no spark of ro- mance in her cool and placid nature, loved him ‘‘as much as she had the faculty of lov- ing anything.” But all the queerness of the Tollemache blood concentrated itself in his youngest daughter, Lady Mary, afterwards Lady Mary Coke, a kind of lia Lelia (‘‘nec vir nec femina, nec virgo nec uxor’) among women, whose extraordinary vagaries and ex- periences would make an admirable novel if we had a Thackeray to write it. Let- ters to and from Sir Walter Scott and
others increase the interest of this ap- petizing book.
Seige ~ THE WEEK. Balfour, iggy pes Ser of the Musi- cal Bow OE + Sg Types. : Olarendon Press; New York: Henry — , W. T. Observational ae Har- Holt, ‘Mina. The Sat A Novel. F. Neely. Edward. Modern Land Law. Outen Cla- ew York: Henry K vitch, Prince Bojidar. Enchanted In- dia. Harpers. $1.75. Vance, Wilson. God's War. F. T. Neely.
‘Interesting and valuable... . Not unworthy the attention of sert- ous students.’’—SPRINGFIELD RE- PUBLICAN. ‘*There is much humor in the book.’’ —LITERATURE. THE HOOLIGAN NIGHTS An Actual Criminals Remintacences. Edited by Cuia- REKORB ROOK. iH $1.25. HENRY HOLT & CGO., 29 W. 28D ST., NEW YORK.
‘* One of the most creditable novels of the year.”—N. Y. Trisune. Children of the Mist. By Eden Phillpotts. pages, $1.50.
8vo, 556 “If I were to name the best novel I have read, I should un- hesitatingly put down ‘Children of the Mist.’ It is fresh, and original, and powerful.’’—Edward Fuller, Literary Editor of Providence Journal. “‘ One of the most consistently and thoroughly worked-out nov- els that have appeared fur long time past.’’—London Post. “The book leaves a pleasant and cheerful impression. It is a work of notable vigor.’ —The Outlook. G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS, _ New York and London. NEW BOOK BY MAX MULLER. The Six Systems of Indian Philosophy. By the Right Hon. F. Max MOuuER, K.M., ween n — of the French lustitute. vo, “No one will read this valuable and enlightening vol-
ume without admiring the Hindoo | ang which the book enables them to comprehend. ew mater!- ally enriches the long series of boot aby which ite a author has brought home to English-« peoples the intel- lectual treasures of ancient India, oat cannot bu’ ly stimulate the rapidly growing interest in ite ‘capject. pidly LONGMANS, GREEN, & C0., 91-93 Fifth Ave., New York. Prisoners of Hope By MARY JOHNSTON. 12mo, $1.50.
advanced steadily in rary charm have become more New Orleans, in the following p of its popularity: «« Those who have not yet read Mary Jqhnston’s «Prisoners of Hope’ have missed the enjoyment of a charming bit of contem- porancous fiction, and have deprived them- selves of a pleasure only occasionally vouch- safed them in these days of abundant lite- rary trash. ‘*Miss Johnston has selected for the scene of her sprightly tale the Virginia of old colonial days, and few writers have given us a more delightful picture of the period, nor better drawn, in light and shade, the exclusive society of the time.
Sold by all Booksellers. HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO., Boston; 11 East 17th St., New York. ISS JOHNSTON'S novel of Colonial Virginia has
popularity as its uncommon power, historic imagination, clear discrimination of character, its most interesting love story, and its lite- widely known. Zhe States, of aragraphs indicates the sources «<The aristocratic refinement of the state- ly mansions in which the action moves at times, the culture of its lords and masters, the beauty and grace of its maids and mis- tresses, are presented with a deftness of skill that distinguishes the finished artist; yet when the thread of the tale winds in among the rougher path of insurrection and bloody strife, there is not wanting tbat vividness of description that thrills and enchains. «« The tale is of interest rarely so well sustained, One moves into it fascinated ° from the beginning. It is notably strong in description. ”’ Sent, postpaid, by
influence freed himself from the petty tastelessness of in its perfect truth and beauty. He was one of the
As we have already pointed out, no book lover ca: series, which now ready the volumes on RAPHA volume, profusely illustrated, $1.
who only lived forty-six years (1497-1543), was one of the most precocious geniuses of history—appearing as an able painter at the age of fourteen—and was among the few masters of 5 a —— — =o the decided used it with perfect independence. As is pointed out in the volume om a TOLBEIN’ in Knackfuse’s admirable MONOGRAPHS ON ARTISTS, #olbein was sass teins ee ceed = his deautiful and distinct coloring has — attained Dy gay other Northern painter side of Hol character is ial | RAPHAEL wens gliog p’e omc is expocis ily empha HOLBEIN | $1.50 upon recent authorities, and {itustrated us ane care $1.50 and discrimination. English by Campa. Dopason, —_ British Museum. Others will be published shortly. Each LEMCKE & BUECHNER, Publishers, 812 Broadway, New York. of around him, and conceived the human figure first masters of ot heen historical painting, and
afford to be without the volumes o, 2s EL on HOLBEIN, admirably tra
F. W. CHRISTERN (DYRSEN & PFEIFFER, Successors), 429 Sth Ave,, between 88th and 89th Sts., New York. [mporters of Foreign nite uA nts for the Pa Pubiiepers: Ty ey Auth pk ‘eu Greek and :
on demand. Wow beat Kobe: recel ived tems Paris and
zig as soon as issued.
BOOKS When calling ask for LIBERAL, Whenever you need a peek, einer anata ea notations. Ant asso pon aad sent Ly mp gimy 0 cent sta! — redneed P. B. GRANT, Books 28W.42p8r., - NEW Ue thia ‘advertisement ana recewe a deen