The Nation 1899-06-29: Vol 68 Iss 1774
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
The Na Gi rhe UNIV. VOL. LXVIII—NO. 1774. THURSDAY, JUNE 29, 1899. PRICE. 10 C E N’ rs. Summer Resorts. Special Inducements to Summer Resorts. GOLFERS IN JULY a Mount Pleasant, WHITE MOUNTAINS. The Links have been put in the finest condition for season of 1899. Few Golf Courses in the world exceed the Mount Pleasant in natural interest or in perfection of improvement. A feature is the caddy service supplied by a force of active, intelligent academy and college boys. Dark room, with complete outfit for use of amateur or professional photographers. Mount Pleasant House is luxurious in every ap- pointment, and has special Post-office, Telegraph, offices in’ the oo and Railroad Ticket ffices 1 te Through Parlor or Sleepi ytag Cnr service from Bos- ton, Foon wy oy New York icago, Burlington, and Montreal to hotel grourds. Traine leave the grounds twice daily for ascent of Mt. Washington, eiirectly in f~ oat of the hotel THE OPEN OBSERVATION-CARS again run through the Pass of the White Mountains. Pas- sengers to Mount Pleasant House from Portland and from Boston, via North Conway, will enjoy this unique rail ride from hg oy t to Mount Plea- sant, 8 miles of it from Bemis to Crawford Notch, being high up on the Mountain-side, with the Valley far below, and three miles from the Notch to Mount Pleasant, commanding the grandest view of the Presidential Peaks just across the valley Ammo- noosuc. No rail ride in America, east of the Rocky Mountains, compares with this. Bicycle Path to Crawford Notch. Bridle Trail to the Summit of the Rosebrook Range. Birch Rock Spring Water. Mount Pleasant Dairy Milk. White Mountain Air. ANDERSON & PRICE, Managers, Also of Hotel Ormond, Florida. Mount Pleasant House, N. H. THE BARTLETT COTTAGES, FISHER’S ISLAND, N. Y. Seven miles ee ge from yew, benden, See : _ bane furnished cottages for house or w y eep' ng, bing and drainage strictly sant lambing circular mailed on ‘Applicat. ake. BERKSHIRE HILLS. The ples gate and Cottages, Great Barrington, Mass. home, ¥ located in the vil. re Ras een dy od guests. ‘o SMALL, Proprietor. EAUMARIS HOTEL, MUSKOKA KE, ONT ARID eens A! —1,000 ‘eet above ever. ting, bathing. ger‘ sea, Nah ee Prowse, Proprieto EUROPEAN SUMMER RESORT, INNSBRUCK, TYROL, AUSTRIA. 1.900 feet above the sea, with dry, bracing climate. HOTEL TIROL. Open all the year. Modern conveniences. Best re- ferences. Illustrated a on application LANDSEE, Proprietor. Summer ar rc MALOJA Se from June 19 to the end September. Vory first- clase hotel. Sanitary ar rangements of the most im- proved description. Position 6,000 feet above sea-level, in the aw ietu- resque scene pper Fn adine Engadine. Divine a service in the churches belonging to the hotel. Golf 144 mile, lawn-tennis, fishing in the Lake of Sils, mountain ex- ( SWITZERLAND) cursions, carriage and coach service. Many natural curt- Osities; glaciers, waterfalls, giacier mills; wonderful Al- pine flora. Please write or telegraph to the Manager, (Za. 1815. g.) I. F. WALTHER. Telegraph and Post-Office, MALOJA KURSAAL. Ocean Breezes Are apt to be atrifle cool. A light wrap at such times is most welcome. The Augusta. Victoria Empress Shoulder Shaw! is delightfully com- fortable and stylish. Entirely hand- woven from pure wool and silk— 40 inches square, with 6-inch fringe —in white, rich light green, delicate pink, recherché red, or black. Sent postpaid and registered for $7.50. Money refunded if not satisfactory. THE SUSACUAC WEAVING CO., 12 Moravian Church St., Bethlehem, Pa. DRESDEN, GERMANY. Pension Kretzschmer-Schadewell. Friulein nary ay proprietress of Pension Kretzach- mer, removes in September to 4 Lindenau-Platz. New house, conveniently situated, with southern exposure. paupeee with modern sgpetatnente, lift. Address un- til September, 15 Ricknitz-Strasse Travel. GOING ABROAD ON A BICYCLE TRIP? Send for “ Bicycling Notes for Tourists Abroad,” 10 cents in stamps. fine new steamers of the LEYLAND LINE Sail every Wednesday. BOSTON TO LIVERPOOL. First cabin, qo: $37.50 and up. Splendid new steamer Winifredian, 10,500 tons, 570 feet in me now in service. . HOUGHTON & CO., General Agents, 11g State Street, Boston. SWITZERLAND osAUSAnNe; First-class hotel with moderate tariff. enn ificent view over the lake end moun Litt, Tariff and pamphlets sent free’ on ep (C QOFBRSTO WN—“OTSEGO HALL,” s mall hotel near the lake. Well kept; choice table; good boating and fishing; 2 golf courses. Now open. Ee - —~———— PARIS in 1900. A word to the wise. Baaine supe of ssonmadiitp and ho- tel accommodations nme fp personally conducted perties TH THE CR fe CRAWFORD Ti TOU RBS, 610 Tre- mont Bulld way, New York; 1011 Chestnut Sere Philadelphia EUROPEAN TRAVEL. with their 9th Annual Class. THE MISSES WELDON Young Ladies’ Fo Tour, Restricted; highest re- ferences. Address MOORINGS. Loox laven, Pa. JUN 30 1899
Page 2
eee Cae The Nation. [Vol. 68, No. 1774 The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science, and Art. FOUNDED 1865. mini angen CALIFORNIA, es, West 23d Street. M4 RLBORO UGHS SCHOOL for —— Mrs. Groner A. CaswELL. Princi CanaDa, P. 7 Lennoxville. ISHOP’S COLLEGE SCHOOL. (Es- tablished 1842 ) Church School for Boys on lines of English Public Schools. Specially adap’ for sons of English residents in America. Bathing. cricket, and healthy country situation. Best New 7 references, $280 a year. H. J. H. Perry, M.A., Headmaster. [Entered at the New York City Post-Office as d class mail-matter. } CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. Sa is sans choetace oo.co00 cb iceneccbibssecks tonas 487 EDITORIAL ARTIOLES: Aid and Comfort to the Enemy.............. 490 Feomest Pelitias .. nw ccccevccccevecoctesesecse Political Issues Changing............sseee. 491 The Interoceanic Oanal..........+-eececeece 492 Spectral CORRESPONDENCE: An Interesting Exhibition.............see00+ 492 Cn ND cb dessus costatonntivaneee 493 CORRESPONDENCE: Foreigners at the University of Paris........ 495 DROUIN vis asuin ounekssbievecchaddns coms scaknnwdeseaabebs 495 Book REVIEWS: Caras WAGG bok vive pcccrcctwccvase 497 Marshall's Instinct and Reason............. 499 Ratzel’s History of Mankind..............+. ee rrr er eee 501 A_ Literary nga A of Ireland’ ‘rrom’ "the e Earliest Times to Present Day......... 1 Bittlography of E of Eienirent -Century Art and SEU SOO sn 0 56.0.0 50.0 Ch Aged beesteees 502 VOOR icc etn cde vive vecbdee p4eaanvebeanad 503 he haere ee re 503 Under the African Sun...........sceeeccees B04 DOO WO THEE WI a ann vide cdc venscadesinresabanens 505 TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three Dollars per year, in advance, postpaid, to any part of the United States or Canada; to foreign countries comprised in the Postal Union, $4.00. The date when the subscription expires is on the Address-Label of each paper, the change of which to a subsequent date becomes a receipt for remit- tance. No other receipt is sent unless requested. Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter, or by check, express order, or Postal Order, payable to “Publisher of the Na- tion.” When a change of address is desired, both the old and new addresses should be given. Address THE NATION, Box 794, New York. Publication Office, 208 Broadway. TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Fifteen cents per agate line, each insertion, 1; lines to the inch. Twenty per cent. advance for choice of page or top of column. Outs are not inserted on the first page. A column, $20 each insertion; with choice of page, $2/,. A page, $60 each insertion; front-cover page, $80. Advertisements must be acceptable in every re- spect, Copy received until Tuesday, 6 P. M,. DISCOUNTS. “too within eer as cent. o “ 760 oe ats $0 " 1,000 eA We ey 1600 % « $0 2,000 06 “ 83%“ The NATION ie sent free to those who advertise in it as — as advertisement continues, *,* cnees of the Nation may be procured in Paris at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de l’Opéra, and in London of B. F. Stevens, 7 Square, Ame- rican Newspaper Agency, 15 King William Street, Strand, W. 0. London agent for advertisements, H. A. Delille, Langham Hotel. : Devcawarkg, Wilmington, Franklin 8t. bd AISSES HEBB'S vey Body Day School for Girls. Students are Fe for DisTRiot oF CoLumBIA (Chevy Chase P. O., Md.). HEV Y CHASE French and English School for Gee. Sa of ashington. Frenc ene ls e of the Mile. L. Rees Prinetpal. Miss C. Perrigrew. Assist. Prin ILLrinors, Chicago, 1500-4 Title and Trust Building. YICAGO COLLEGE OF LAW. BB ad DEPARTMENT OF LAKE Forest UNIVERSITY. ree-year course leading to degree LL.B. For further ffcenietion address the Secretary. E E. Barrett. MARYLAND, Baltimore, 122 and 124 W. Franklin St. DGE WORTH BOARDING and DAY School for Girls.—37th year will Puneipat September 28, 1899. Mrs. H. P. Leresvre, Pri Miss E. D. HunTLeYy, ‘Associate Principal. MARYLAND, Catonsville. S% TIMOTHY'S SCHOOL for Girls re- opens September 21, 1899. ch oy for College. Heads of School, Miss M. C. Carrer, Miss S. R. CARTER. MASSACHUSETTS, B OSTON UNI VERSI TY Law School. Address the Dean, SamMvuEL C. BENNETT. MASSACHUSETTS, ton, 66 Marlborough St. ‘LASSICAL SCHOOL FOR GIRLS. Boarding and Day School. Certificate accepted by Smith, Vassar, and Wellesley. 8. ALioz BRowN and AMELIA L. OwEn, Principals. MassacuuseETts, Cambridge, 9 IRE Street. WE LEE SCHOOL POR G LS. atest ia, Chestnut Hill. RS COMEG BCYS' A 4) VD MISS BELL'S BOARDING amp DAY SCHOOL Will Leg October 2, 1899. Students prepared for college. & IsLAND, Providence, yy RIENDS SCHOOL FOR BOTH puree. Mk mney 5 in 1784. Excellent home. es ee tates. All denominations. Thorough work Engiiahe Science, Classics, Music and Art. Address AvevstiIne Jonzs, LL.B. Virerta, Richmon NIVERSIT Y COLLEGE OF MEDI- cine.—310 a last year; 56 in Faculty. $300 for 4 years; no c ulsory extras; W ee ve be ore last on nia Medical xamining Board, 94.6% (36 appli- ); before last North Carolina Board, 100% (17 appli- SSG; Spaces. Ver tape eae aiaies rds. For a > as antes — Dr. J. ALLISON Hopes, Proctor. ISS ANABLE’S Boarding and Day School for Girls. Established in 1848, Circulars on application. Opeus Sept. 27. 1350 Pine St., Phila., Pa SCHOOL OF DRAWING AND PAINTIN ING. MUSEUM OF FINE ARTS, BOSTON, eth Four Opens October Instructors—E. T | a pt al PHILIP HALE , Drawing and MRS. W ly STONE, Decorative Design E. ON, Anatomy; A. K. CROSS, Perspective. Free use of Museum Galleries. Paige pereign Sehotare hip for Men and wromes. Helen Hambien Scholar- shi 1D. aug 2S Free po goes ed prizes in mo- reulars an rms a Miss ELIZABETH LOMBARD, Manager. BOSTON, MASS. Roxbury Latin School. (Founded in 1645.) WM. C. COLLAR, Headmaster. Prepares for Harvard. the aa educational advan- tages. Refined home in Oe Admiral Winslow House.” JAMES D ORM. . D.D., gi t of the aaeneee Address O. M. FARNHAM., Roxbury. Mass Miss M. L. Benge Princip MASSACHUSETTS, Duxbury. P2 WDER POINT SCH OOL —Prepares for Scientific School, College, or Business. Indi- vidual teaching. Elements classes for young boys. Home and outdoor life. . B. KNAPP, SB Ont is) MASSACHUSETTS, East Ham ghLleT ON SEMINAR Y Prepares ys for any college or scientific school. Library. f 4 oO themteal, biological ype hy me cymaseiem, etc. New athletic field haf gp am ns Sep- tember, 1899. Josepu H rele aw Prine cipal. Missouri, St. Louis. 39th Year. 22 Professors. REST PARK UNIVERSITY wth Women. ion ne College Course, Coll Music, ¥; R. Kr mig arry eg “Foc Parisi, Violin. Pipe Elocution, Art. and n. tuition, $265 to $280. ddcess for ll Mrs, ANNA SNEED CaIRNs, President. New Hampsarre, P! OLDERNESS SCHOOL. — Thorough preparation for Pete and Scientific Sopest. olderness boys are made well at Trinity, Dart mouth, Princeton, Harvard, Wesleyan, West Point. Send for igatalo e to’ Rey. Login Wenster, M. A., Rector. Ww. NIvzs, President of Trustees, New Yorks, Si Rk. HOLBRO K's "S SCHOOL will reopen Wednesday, September 27, at 6 P. M. New York, Utica. RS. PIATT’S SCHOOL,—The next school year begins Thursday, Sept. 22. 1898. Onto, Cinct LSS ARM STRONG'S SCHOOL FOR Girls, Liddesdate Place, ervetals, Family limit- Circulars sent on application Onto, Cincinnati, Walnut Hills, 944-946-948 Morris St. DEN PARK SCHCOL.—BOARDING and Day School asd Girls. Merman f Preparatory, Collegiate in the Lan- guages, Music, and ir Mise Many F Burra, { Principals. PewnsyLvania, Bethl BAICH PRE PARATO TORY SCHOOL hd fer on men mi Hpiaco al ach ook I sion, PENNSYLVANIA, lent table. EDIA MCADEMY or BOYS AND zopes Bee. , Scien Rrcitoe Ee in Cas. Oe Pia, MISS BALDWIN’S SCHOOL FOR GIRLS, BRYN MAWR, PA. Preparatory to Bryn Mawr College. Miss FLorENcE Batpwiy, Principal. Within eight ears more than ninety pupils have entered Bryn Mawr College from this school. a given in in both General and College-Pre tory Fine, fire-proof stone building. acres beautiful grounds. For circular, address the Secretary. ACADEMIC CLASSES airts. A Boarding and Day School. College preparation and advanced courses. Certificate acce by Smith, Vas- sar, pp nee and Mt. Holyoke. Artistic, Military, and wey B: WALTON AH, and LOIS A: BANGS, an ” 43 West 47th Street, wan York. FORESTRY SCHOOL, At Biltmore, N. C. rian: a SCHENCK, Ph Bote SALEM, MASS., 2 Chestnut Street. wip A. C. DRAPER'S SCHOOL. Junior, Classical, and General Courses. The Fypnctoal will oe a few girls as members of her fami! lem’s situation, the ad Veatages © of its Museum, the in- yore of its citizens in histo om and art, and its ncarness. to Boston, make it an ideal place for education. ABBOT ACADEMY '** Young Ladies, Vist tember 1 init, a ame (eta Cana nt gee Course. ype ino us beg E Means, pal. For catalogue, W. F. Draper. Mr and Mrs. John A. Bellows will reopen their Boarding and Day Schoo! for Girls at 115 Beacon Street, Boston, October 4, 1899. Certificate of Principals admits to Smith and Wellesley Colleges, ALLEN BROTHERS’ West Newton English and Classical School. Family and Bom, eee & both Sexes. (47th year.) iN, MASS. Highland Military Academy ,¥, rome re a oH ae i om recenmmery eT. tl aaa
Page 3
ARERR as ie at ole Tee June 29, 1899] The Nation. A New Harkness Complete Latin Grammar, $1.25 Short Latin Grammar, - .80 Practical, clear, and concise. Special attention paid to syntax, the subjunctive, etc. Harper and d Gallup’ s Cicero’s Orations and Letters $1.30 The Orations are those generally required by colleges throughout the country. The Letters were selected with special reference to their {fit- ness in sight translation. Eight Books for Graded Schools Five Books for Ungraded Schools The most attractive series of readers ever pub- lished. McMaster’s School History of the United States $1.00 Special attention paid to the industrial deve- lopment of the country since 1815. th aw YORK CINCINNATI | logical treatment. NEWEST AND BEST ‘TEXT-BOOKS | Geometry Revolutionized Irish’s Qualitative By the Publication of Milne’s Plane Geometry, - $0.75 and Milne’s Plane and Solid Geometry, * > = 1.25 Issued on May 3ist after several years’ prepa. | ration. Unrivalled ag teaching books, The first successful combination of the of inventional and concrete geometry with rigid structive questions, undemonstrated theorems, and unsolved problems, numerous enough for the needs of any class. CAMERON’S DE GONCOURT SELECTIONS, mbes VIGNE’S LETTERS, - - .40 _ RANKE’S KAISERWAHL KARL’S V;; a a in ” +35 ROGERS’S FRENCH SIGHT READING, «..=..« .© 40 FRANCOIS’S INTRODUCTORY FRENCH PROSE COMPOSI- 7 «5s @. & .25 For special information regarding these and many other superior books, write to AMERICAN BOOK COMPANY, | ATLANTA BOSTON CHICAGO omitted. valuable features | Contains large number of in- | - $1.25 | | SYMS’S MADAME DE Sé&- Baldwin’s School Readers Natural Geographies school geographies having corresponding maps drawn on the same scale, and showing correctly | the relative size of countries. and collateral reading. lll Analysis for Secondary Schools $0.50 A simple but complete half-year’s work. AN | obscure and complicated reactions have been Large number of suggestive questions. Milne’s Arithmetics Elements, $0.30 Standard, -65 Probably the most successful series of arithme- | tics published in this country during the last | | twenty-five years, Milne’s Grammar School Algebra, | $0.50 | Published June 12 | Elementary, $0.60 Advanced, 1.25 Man in his relation to the Earth. The only Laboratory work PORTLAND, ORE. || Educational. Rogers Hall School al Girls. Certificate admits to College. Apply Mrs. E. P. UNDERHILL, Lowell,. Mass The Four Weeks’ Summer Course of French of the Pensionnat Francais of Vermont Academy. {sth Reaston eae J a For circulars, address Rey. L. C. ROUX, Saxton’s River, near Ballons Falls, Vt. G LENS PALLS (N. Y.) ACADEMY. One of the oldest and best fitting schools in country. D.C. FARR. Ph.D., Principal. Teachers, etc. WOMAN OF LIBERAL EDUCA- tion and culture, at presenta teacher, wishes to evote herself to the care of three or four children in her own home, training them in the manifoid require- ments of modern life and in some of the old-fashioned virtues as well. Address Ph.D., care of the Nation. IBRARIAN.—FOUR YEARS’ EX- ence in one of largest American libraries—will act as assistant or take charge of town or college libra- ry. References as to scholarship and efficiency fur- nished on application to A, K. G., care of the OUR YEARS' ACADEMICAL Course, preparatory to Yale, Vassar, etc., reduced less than one year by private instruction. Pamphlet free. Rev. Wu. W Belleville, Ti. 'HARLES W. STONE, Tutor for Har- vend, 60 Gennes Street, Bosten. TO RENT FOR A SCHOOL. | A_ beautiful house of 14 oye and bath. All modern conveniences; a Pema shade bit convenient to R.R. ion and elec rie ee 7 —. ~— Boston, Pn ne goer fs 66 “state St., pgp. te ton, Mash” AA cna sen PARTNER ( Male) WANTED — Girls’ School, eng established, between New York C., 466 Weat 149th 8t., N. ¥. itooin 7, School Agencies. HE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES. Everett O. Fisk & Co., Proprietors. Ashburton Place, Boston. 1595 Pa. Ave. , Washington. 56 Fifth Ave., New York. 414 Cent. Bd , Minneapolis 30 Cooper Bdg. » Denver. 525 Stims’n ie. ,Los Angeles ‘ 4 q: 878 Wabash Ave., Chicago. 825 M’ket 8t., San Francisco LBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY, 24 State St., Albany, N. Y.—Provides schools of all grades with competent teachers, Assists hers in obtaining positions. Han.an P. FRencu, anager. CHERMERHORN'’ & TEACHERS AGENCY. Oldest and best known in the U. Established 1855. % E. 14th 8t., N. y. is valuable in proportion 'to its m- An Agency fluence. If it erely of va- cancies and tells that' is somethin ner if itiparked to you = voy: bs - nag ne and ree- ommen tis more. re cw BARDEEN, Syracuse. N.Y. ‘Recomumpends nT = = — ~~ Readers and Se hove Oe been Waiting for this Full of-[atter, Modorate-Priced Refe Book, THE STUDENTS’ STANDARD DICTIONARY. AN ABRIDGMENT OF Funk & Wagnalls’ Standard Dictionary Large ove, 933 pages, cloth, leather beck, t, $2.50: Sheep, $4.00; Indexed, 50c. addit Contains 60,000 Words and: rases, and 1,225 Pictorial Illus ns. Sent postpaid on receipt of price by The Baker & Taylor Co. calamistis yr ana KINDERGARTEN: RN’S, 8 apt 14th Bt, N. 4 CLARENDON PRESS PUBLICATIONS. For sale by all booksellers. Send for Catalogue. OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS, (American Branch) 91 sth Ave., New York. PUBLICATIONS IN FRENCH. "| comge-Preparatery French Grammar. By CHARLES P, DU CROQUET. Fourth Edition, revised. Grammar exercises and reading, followed by Examination Papers. A practical French Grammar. Its arrangement ie quite new. The rules concerning a subject have been carefully arranged in one lesson, and can easily be learned in a few moments. 12mo, half leather, 284 pages. Price $1.25. “It is indeed the best book for the majority of our classes | have ever seen, and I shall introduce [t fmme- diately.’’—Prof. A. E. Gainer, Canton, Ubio. Complete Sy on oor we p —— ae by al! book- sellers, or postpaid on receipt of price b e publisher. WILLIAM R. JENKINS 851 and 853 6th Ave. (cor. 48th St.), New York. Study and Practice of French in School IN THREE PARTS. By L.C. Boname, 258 South 16th St., Philadeiphia A carefully ed course, meeting requirements for entrance examination at college. Practice in conversa oe and thorough drill in Pronunciation and Grammar. pin Education, Boston: “A well-made series. Teach- ers and pupiis will find the three books heipful and inte- rest ONVERSATIONAL FRENCH, Deux- feme Livraison, just out, Price a cents, or wiil be mafied on @ val any address b Dwakp Korn, 1135 Pine St., Philada. Bintan SECOND-HAND AND NEW, Standard sn fW Jonsson, 2 4a St.
Page 4
lv The Nation. [Vol. 68, No. 1774 SCRIBNERS NEV BOOKS WHAT SHALL WE THINK OF CHRISTIANITY? By Prof. WILLIAM NEWTON CLARKE of Colgate University Author of ‘‘An Outline of Christian Theology.” 12mo, $1.00 Contents: I. The Christian People.—II. The Christian Doctrine.—III. The Christian Power. | this very unusual book, which is a remarkable contribution to the literature of its subject, both in its style and subject-matter, Dr. Clarke examines the historical development and present condition of the three great contributions which Christ has made to the mora! wealth and welfare of humanity—the Christian People, the Christian Doctrine, and jthe Coristian Power. Thus the book deals in a broad manner with the great essentials of Christianity, and because of the author’s catholicity and broad-minded treat- ment of his subject, it will prove helpful and stimulating to thoughtful persons of all denominations, i Pham is characterized by the same simple, clear, and spiritual treatment which marked the author's ‘‘ Outline of Christian eology. ‘* Eight admirably written stories.” —New York Times. THE GREATER INCLINATION By EDITH WHARTON Second Edition. 12mo, $5.50 66 [F we were to single out one book from those that have been published this season as exhibiting in the highest degree that rare cre- ative power called literary genius, we should name ‘ The Greater Inclination,’ by Mrs. Edith Wharton. And not only has Mrs. Wharton brought to these stories a remarkable power of insight and imagination, but the phase of life in America which she has chosen for treatment may be said to be altogether new in her hands.”—The Bookman. 66 is a book of wonderful delicacy and power both, but of cultured power. In workmanship it stands among the masterpieces of modern Anglo-Saxon fiction--finished, yet embracing some of the great problems of life, delicate, thoughtful, and a monument ¢° the possibilities of the language in the hands of a master."—New York Mail and Express. ACROSS THE CAMPUS A Story of College Life. Lamo, $1.50, By CAROLINE M. FULLER ae M's FULLER has done college life and college women a real service by writing this pleasant and breezy book. Girls’ books are all too few, and for one which does not preach nor prose, which is full to the brim of mirth, and has no morbidness, there is always a place ready and waiting.”—Literature. ‘6 S te picture of the social life of the college, which is called Harland in the story, but which is Smith in reality, and of the per- sonal relations of the girls, is painted with great spirit and enthusiasm. The author succeeds in conveying a vivid sense of the atmosphere and feeling of the place. It is a book that would fiil a girl with a longing to go to college, and recail a thousand de- lightful memories to a woman who had been through college.”—Brooklyn Life. TWO OUTDOOR BOOKS HOW TO KNOW THE FERNS A GUIDE TO THY NAMES, HAUNTS, AND HABITS OF OUR NATIVE FERNS. By FRANCES THEODORA PARSONS With 144 Illustrations by Marion Satterlee and Alice J. Smith. Crown 8vo. $1.50 net. 66 RS. PARSONS ought to be proud of the large number of followers—one is tempted to say imitators—that she has made, There are weber books to the number of a dozen which have been written on lines so similar to those which characterize ‘ How to Know the Wild Flowers’ that they amount to an infringement of intellectual copyright. But our author still keeps at the head of the procession, nor can anybody take away from her the title to priority which she holds. To many grateful Americans, young and old, she is the Columbus who pioneered the way for them to a new world of loving intimacy with the flowers and the erns.”—Brooklyn Times. ’ 66 ATIEE a delightful introductory chapter on ‘Ferns as a Hobby,’ the author goes on to the explanation of terms, to the fertili- zation, development, and fructification of ferns, the notable fern families, and the description of individual ferns. The illus- trations, by camere and pencil, are numerous and exceedingly fine, completing a book that must prove a lasting delight to all nature lovers,”-—-Boston Evening Transcript. HOW TO KNOW THE WILD FLOWERS A GUIDE TO THE WAMES, HAUNTS, AND HABITS OF OUR COMMON WILD FLOWERS. With 156 illustrations by Marion Satterlee. Forty-third Thousand, Revised and Enlarged. Crown 8vo, $1.75 met. 4¢ {VERY flower-lover who has spent weary hours puzzling over a botanical key ia the effort to name unknown plants will wel- come this satisfactory book, which stands ready to lead him to the desired knowledge by a royal road,”—The Nation, CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS, 153-157 Fith Ave, Mew York DESL NI SIO LLL LE LOL. PION LL ENO SO EE TR I Ea SOLE Ep Ee SS OR 5 a et eg TUN URef t A TIET OR ne me cee es Ree Batsee Bh C860: Hoa LE 2 PRR LRN TESS AAS TT
Page 5
ORIN RSFOTRY SINS: AEE PAN REIN ES ae ate Sea ae BRD ako asain Dae ata Bae ye ee SRR NARA ME STN FIN mr ir é £ k § Z : Vg NEW YORE, THURSDAY, JUNE 29, 1899. | The ie The opportunists of the McKinley Ad ministration will receive a severe shock from the picture of the situation in the Philippines which Dr. McQueston, $f Gen. Otis’s staff, brings nome with him. He says it will require a force of 100,000 to 150,000 soldiers to subdue and hold the islands; that unless thousands of troops be sent at once to the aid of those now there, our forces will be driven back into Manila during the next few months; that our men simply cannpt stand the climate during the rainy sea- son; that fifty per cent. of them will »e incapacitated by sickness; that the ter- ritory hitherto overrun will have to be abandoned, and that Manila will be in a state of siege again. As to the temper and feeling of our soldiers, he says: “The volunteers all want to return honie, and I hardly think that the plan to enlist three skeleton regiments from the volunteers now in the Philippines will be a success. The men enlisted ito fight for their country, and they are not the kind of men who want to stay and fight an insurrection for money jor for the fun of fighting.” These are rot the words of a despised private soldier, or of a non-patriotic anti-imperialist, but of a member of the staff of the Com- manding General, who has served as tihe Health Officer at Manila. It is barely possible that they may even cause Alger and Corbin to think that the situatfon in the Philippines is serious. : There is talk in Washington of a new department of the Government and! a new member of the cabinet, to be called the Secretary of the Colonies. It is said that Cuba, Porto Rico, and the Philip- pines cannot always remain unter charge of army officers, that the War Department is overburdened already, that the mere financial administration of the islands is sufficient to engross the whole time of a cabinet officer, and, final- ly, that if a Department of the Colonies is created, it is probable that R. P. Por- ter will be made the first Sec of it. All this reads very much like a plan to introduce the spoils system into the islands at the earliest possible ment. Certainly nobody could be found better fitted for carrying out that sch than the ex-Director of the Census. discussion of a Department of the ries. A colony is a subject coun be ruled by the mother or mistress try by her appointees, her governors, pro- en — consuls, harmosts, satraps, they may be called. A Territory jis for the most part a self-governing district, which may look forward to a time, near or remote, when it will become an| equal partner, and help to govern the mother country, in proportion to its numbers. Congress must decide which of thepe two forms of government is to be first ap- plied to the “colonies.” If they are to be reckoned as Territories, we shaj] need no new cabinet officer to look after! them, or to see that the spoils of office ave pro- perly apportioned to our most reliable “heelers,” as the census patronage/is and has been. Meanwhile, the duty of jcount- ing and taking care of the revenue of the islands will remain in charge off army officers, and will, no doubt, be wéil and honestly discharged, even though: Alger continues in charge of the War Ijepart- ment. 4 From the entire indifference’ with which the public has treated Commis- sioner R. P. Porter’s contention that ex- posure of commissary scandals is spoil- ing our foreign trade, we should infer either that the public does not ‘elieve in condoning a flagrant wrong for a pe- cuniary advantage, or else that ‘t does not trust Mr. Porter’s statements about the exports. In either case, we suspect that the public’s judgment would he war- ranted. Mr. Porter’s allegation was that “the various meat investigatiors, and the political capital which has been made out of them by American newspa- pers, have done our interests more in- jury” in European eyes than all for- eign influences put together. This was an assertion as to what has tctually happened. But Mr. Porter grew some- what more cautious as he approached nearer to official statistics, finally con- tenting himself with predicting a possi- ble loss to the meat-export trade of $20,000,000 to $25,000,000 per annum.” This caution was well advised, for the detailed returns of the Federal Bureau of Statistics for May inform the American public that our export of canned beef last month increased 647,000 : pounds over 1898, and our export of fresh beef 6,033,000 pounds, and that the total pre- served beef exports in May were the largest for any corresponding period in our history. It is possible that ¢ven the foreign consumer may have grasped the fact that the “Eagan brand” of contract army beef was something contrived ex- clusively for the army, and not available in the export market. Senator Foraker is much of the time in a frame of mind towards McKin- ley Administration which es him to say what he thinks without; he- sitation or reserve. He is panpictlarty or whatever ready to do this just now, because the old factional troubles among the Re- publicans of Ohio, In which he has so long been involved, are raging afresh, and the dominant Hanna wing is doing its best to “down” him. It is not sur- prising, therefore, that Mr. Foraker should have tojd an interviewer on Thursday that “we seem to have a hard- er job on our hands in the Philippines than we anticipated”; and that, although Congress will provide the means if more men and money are wanted, “the war is not popular.” The truly loyal organs of the Administration will, as in duty bound, sneer at the Ohio Senator for talking in this strgin; but we doubt if even the most gerdent advocate of the expansion policy will venture to con- trovert his position by trying to prove that the war really is popular. One remark of Senator Foraker’s ex- presses a feeling which is steadily grow- ing among close observers. “I don't be- lieve,” he says; “the newspapers aye getting all the news received at the War Department, but I know nothing of it personally.” There is no doubt that our imitation of the Spanish system of sup- pressing facts, {hrough a censorship of the press, is constantly being carried further. Nearly two months ago the Hong Kong Duily Press contained a statement from|the American, published at Manila, saying that its readers had complained because it did not give more news, and “rechived that “many cable- grams are received from the United States, but are |suppressed by the press censor,” these {two illustrations being cited: “On Friday a portion of one of our cablegrams/ was suppressed, and yes- terday one entire dispatch was censor- ed, this office receiving nothing but the words: ‘Ameri¢an, Manila, from Hong Kong; text stjppressed by press cen- sor.’” A fortnight ago the Philadelphia Times published a special dispatch from Hong Kong, saying that the censorship at Manila had‘ become so strict that a meeting of the correspondents there had been called to protest against the action of the United |States military authort- ties. The representative of the Times reported that ‘jnothing is allowed to be sent out on meng which affect the Administration] at Washington; and un- less dispatches! are rosy and optimistic, they are not aljowed to go.” He further declared that, although there was great anxiety on the} part of the volunteers to return home, the censor suppresses every mention of the fact, and that he also forbids any reference to the terrible suf- ferings from the heat, while “our men drop like sheep from the overpowering influence of sun’s rays.” It is an interesting qug fon how long the Ame- j { } ; ! H : Pesce enue: es yan aia en" ony 5 Moe) A Fema anenprampere «swe Ds nereeess sre esa ba orar pan Hien -esttrnesps tnerensss aaa Ponte. Pores
Page 6
’ He policy. 488 The Nation. [ Vol. 68, No. 1774 rican people will endure the same policy of suppression and deceit which they used to pity the Spaniards for tolerating a year and a half ago. A more impudent performance than the appearance of Gen. Russell A. Alger as a candidate for the United States Senate from Michigan on a platform ot opposition to Trusts could not be imagined. He was himself one of the chief organizers of a most odious Trust, and the Supreme Court of his own State held that the enterprise in which he thus engaged was unlawful and against pub- About seventeen years ago the Diamond Match Company was orga- nized by Gen. Alger and some other busi- ness men, with a view to controlling the manufacture and sale of friction-matches in the United States and Canada. The object sought to be attained was boldly ‘avowed. The articles of agreement pro- vided for the aggregation of an enor- mous amount of capital, sufficient to buy up and absorb all of that kind of busi- ness done in this country and in the Dominion, and to prevent any other per- son or corporation from engaging in or carrying on the business, thereby pre- venting all competition in the sale of matches. Not only did this object plain- ly appear in the organization of the Trust, but it was openly admitted by Gen. Alger himself. A law-suit grew out of the proceedings taken, to which he was a party, and here is his confession. in response to a question from his coun- sel: “Question. It appears that during the years 1881 and 1882 large sums of money were expended to keep men out of the match business, remove competition, buy machinery and patents, and in some in- stances purchase other match factories. I will ask you to state the reasons, if there are any, why these sums should not be treated as an expense of the business and charged off from this account? ‘‘Answer. Because the prices of matches were kept up to correspond, 80 as to pa these expenses and make large dividends above what could have been made had those factories been in the market to com- pete with the business,”’ The case finally reached the Supreme Court of Michigan, and its decision was filed on the 15th of November, 1889. The judgment of the court went to the heart of the matter. Chief Justice Sherwood, who wrote the decision, began by saying that no one could read the contract in question and fail to discover that con- siderations of public policy were largely involved. He then set forth the facts regarding the organization and operation of the Diamond Match Company, declar- ing that “the sole object of the corpora- tion is to make money by having it in its power to raise the price of the arti- cle, or diminish the quantity to be made and used, at its pleasure.” Both the sup- ply of the article and its price were made to depend upon the action of about a half-dozen individuals, “to satisfy their cupidity and avarice.” The article thus brought under the control of a few ava- riclous men is one in necessary and daily use by almost every individual in the country. “It is difficult,” said the Chief Justice, “to conceive of a monopoly which can affect a greater number of people, or one more extensive in its ef- fect on the country, than that of the Dia- mond Match Company.” The contract in the case then pending was to aid that company in carrying out its purposes, and the court was asked to enforce the contract. This it flatly refused to do, for the reasons quoted above. Director Merriam of theCensus Bureau has been trying to delude the public by the pretence that all applicants for places must undergo an examination which will test their ability as fully as any inquiry into their qualifications which the Civil- Service Commission would have made, if these positions had been brought un- der the rules. But only a very simple person could be taken in by such a pre- tence. If the spoilsmen had desired the honest application of the competitive system, they would have turned over this work to the Commission; whereas long experience of the “pass” examina- tion has shown that it is always a de- lusion and a snare. This old truth is now being freshly demonstrated again. A sample illustration of the way that a spoilsman’s examination works is given by the Baltimore News. An applicant whose home is not a thousand miles from Baltimore, after having passed what he was told by the officials was a highly creditable examination for one of the higher positions in the bureau, was advised by them to go and see his Congressman, who in turn referred him to the “executive” (the Baltimore equi- valent of the New York “district lead- er”) of the applicant’s ward! One of the worst effects of the Presi- dent’s recent “ backward step” in the matter of civil-service reform is the encouragement which it has given to the revival of the spoils spirit every- where. During the first two years of his administration Mr. McKinley reappoint- ed efficient Democratic postmasters, upon the expiration of their terms, in more than one Massachusetts town, and the feeling was growing throughout the. State that, when the incumbent of such an office had served to the general satis- faction of the community, politics should not stand in the way of his retention. Easthampton, a business and education- al centre in one of the western counties; should have been added to the list of places where this sound principle had been accepted. Four years ago Mr. Cleveland appointed a postmaster who has proved so efficient that his reappoint- ment was asked for in a very strong pe- titioh, representing a large majority of the voters, and nearly all the business interests, including all the manufacto- ries, Williston Seminary, the banks, and almost all of the merchants. But, since the bars have been taken down in the classified service by the President’s re- cent order, the Republican politicians ap- parently feel that it will not do to let a Democrat stay in any place from which he can be ousted, and word has reached Easthampton that a Republican must be picked out for an office which nine- tenths of those most concerned prefer to see the Democratic incumbent retain. A striking illustration of the folly of the rule that there must be a change in the postmastership of every town whenever there is a change of parties in the national administration at Wash- ington, was afforded by a recent. inci- dent in the United States District Court for Connecticut. At East Hartland @ man named Hayes had been arrest- ed for the embezzlement of about $345 while he was postmaster of that town, and was indicted by the grand jury. A lawyer appeared in his defence, but all that he could do was to plead for a mitigation of punishment, on this ground: “It was a great mistake that the man was ever appointed, but as Hayes was about the only one who had voted the Democratic ticket in Hartland for some time, he supposed that some one had to be appointed postmaster there, when the change of administra- tion came, but he considered it a mis- fortune for Hayes that he had ever been selected.” The District Attorney con- ceded that Hayes was a very ignorant man, and Judge Townsend said that he felt sorry for him, as he sentenced him to six months’ imprisonment. The Bourbon Democracy of Kentucky have adopted a pro-silver and anti-im- perialist platform, and have nominated William J. Bryan for President. Neither the head nor the tail of the platform is ¥ery energetic in tone. The plea for sil- ver is almost apologetic. The war with Spain is commer‘ded and endorsed, but the Administration’s course in the Phi- lippines is declared to be contrary to the spirit of republican institutions. The convention finally nominated J. C. 8. Blackburn for Senator of the United States in place of Mr. Lindsay, the pre- sent member. Mr. Lindsay was a sup- porter of Palmer and Buckner in the campaign of 1896. Kentucky, under nor- mal conditions, is overwhelmingly De- mocratic, and will no doubt prove to be such at the coming election. Her in- fluence upon the Democracy of other States has never been great, and is not likely to be important this year. The Silver Republican party of Iowa has given up the ghost. The attack
Page 7
June 29, 1899] The Nation. A89 which destroyed what little life remain- ed, was dealt by a provision in the new ballot law which will prevent so weak an organization from placing a ticket on the ballot next fall; but it would have been almost impossible to keep any breath in its body if there had been no such difficulty. The Silver Republicans counted for so little in the campaign of 1896 that the other elements in the op- position to the dominant party have not thought it worth while to pay much at- tention to them since then. The Popu- lists in some States will find it almost as hard to keep up their separate or- ganization, since the Bryanized Demo- cracy has so generally accepted their principles. Bryanism has become so close an approach to Populism that there is not much excuse for keeping up the fiction of a difference. Indeed, the chief reason in most cases why anybody tries to maintain the separate organization is the hope of the men who run it that they may fare better, in the way of nominations, when the two parties “fuse” on a ticket than if they fell in be- hind the regular Democrats. Prof. McVey of the University of Minnesota, in a note contributed to the Journal of Political Economy on the sub- ject of Trusts and the tariff, says that there are some combinations so depend- ent on the tariff that the repeal of the protective duties would destroy both the combination and the industry. He in- stances the Tin-Plate combine as one of this sort, and gives figures to show how the tariff works in this case. The Tin- Plate Trust was formed last Decemb with a capital of $50,000,000. The sell- ing price of tin-plate in Liverpool $2.30 per box. The cost of production i this country is $2.75, and the tariff is $1.62 per box, or 70 per cent. ad valore Since the formation of the Trust t price has been raised to $3.80 per box, which is about the Liverpool price wi the duty added. In other words, the Trust prevents the consumer from gej- ting the benefit of domestic competiti in the manufacture of tin-plate, and tlje _ tariff enables the Trust to accompli this object. There has been considerable chuckling among the high-tariff gentily over the success of the tin-plate industily in this country, but in the presence $f these facts and figures the less we h from them the better. There never w any doubt that by paying 70 per cent. more for tin-plate than it is worth inja free market we could have it produced at home. Nor was there much doubt thht the makers would combine to preveht domestic competition just as soon as the consumers began to derive any benefit from it. The reported placing of orders for 184,- 000 tons of steel rails for Russia at the Carnegie works, to be delivered during the next twenty-six months, is fresh evidence of the fact that the United States has become the centre of the world’s iron and steel production. It may be worth mentioning that nine years ago Mr. Edward Atkinson con- tributed to the Manufacturers’ Record of Baltimore a paper predicting this result as something to be looked for at an early date, i. e., that the United States would soon distance all . ‘er countries in the production of iron. He also quoted an earlier prediction of the same tenor from Abram S. Hewitt, dated as far back aa 1855. Both were true prophets, and their words have come true sooner, per- haps, than they expected. Great Britain, hitherto the largest producer of iron and steel among the nations, is now handi- capped by the growing cost of her raw material. She is compelled to import the best qualities of iron ore from Spain and Sweden, and, what is still more se- rious, she has reached her maximum output of coal; that is, she has reached the point where a larger demand for coal cannot be supplied without a ma- terial advance in price. This is a criti- cal situation for her iron industry, if not for all of her industries that de- pend upon coal. At present the world’s demand for iron and steel has outrun the supply, and while this condition lasts the competition of the United States will be little felt. But when the situation changes, the advantages which we pos- sess in raw material will begin to tell against the English furnaces, and can be met only by economies of detail or by the sad alternative of lower wages to laborers. The outward movement of gold ought not to attract any attention, and does not, except among those who deal in foreign exchange and those who have bills to pay abroad. It is easily explain- ed by a number of patent facts, which are commonly overlooked. One of! these is the gold production of the United States, which is going on all the time at the rate of $5,000,000 per month. [n ad- dition to this is the production df the Klondike mines, nearly all of which comes to our refineries and assay pffices. The amount of Klondike gold coming in is not known, but it is a pretty! large sum, and is evidently increasing.; It is not to be supposed that we can find use for all that we produce, plus all that we take in from the North. It is either possible nor desirable that we shodld re- tain an excess of gold, any more than of grain, or cotton, or pig-iron. Moteover the outward movement has not yet reached the amount of the paymen{| made to Spain for the Philippines. Still an- other line of drainage not usually ob- served is the war in the Philippines: which is costing about $3,000,000 per month. This works against our balance of trade just like the payment of the $20,900,000 to Spain. Several months of the war will cost us more than the original price of the islands. The $3,000,000 sent to pay the Cuban army must be taken into the reckoning, also, together with the sup- port of our own military forces there and in Porto Rico. Altogether the won- der is that the gold-export movement did not begin sooner and reach a larger amount. The establishment of Australian fede- ration is a matter of world-wide concern, and the result of the vote on this ques- tion in New South Wales on June 20 is therefore of the first importance. The idea of such a union among the British colonies in that part of the world has been discussed for a dozen years, but New South Wales, the codéperation of which was most essential, seemed dis- posed for some time to hang back. The late election, however, resulted in an overwhelming majority in favor of fede- ration. South Australia has previously voted the same way; Victoria will cer- tainly follow suit at its election next month, and Tasmania whenever the vote shall be taken; while Queensland, which has been hostile to the scheme, is not likely to stay out jalone very long. Even if the latter colony shall vote against it next September, the other four will go ahead and start the Federation, under a Constitution which bears some strong re- semblances to that of the United States. Such a omestide is a sign of healthy progress in the fanification of interests among colonies Which have much to gain from closer ties. The arrival of|the bubonic piague in Egypt in the corse of its westwardly advance from (China towards Europe is a disquieting |fact, inasmuch as the latest scientific |testimony is to the effect that the disease, having once ob- tained a feothold! cannot be stamped out by summary me4qsures, but will prevail so long as it has} material to feed upon. Alexandria is myjch cleaner now than it was before the days of the English occu- pation, but it is still an Oriental city, and, with the plague within its borders, more or less of|a menace to all ports with which it is in communication. That the pest can be prevented from spread- ing to Europe is most improbable, that it may cross the Atlantic or Pacific is quite within the limits of possibility; but fortunately if is now practically cer- tain that it can} be controlled and de- feated by pro sanitary precautions. This seems to He about the only point in connection with it upon which all the scientists are agreed, after several years of anxious observation in China and in India. As to the cure of the malady, Science has not jadvanced yet much be- yond the experimental stage. The Rus- sian Dr. Haffkin claims a certain degree of success for preliminary inoculation by his process. [doe ncomantans sets Amar maine ena esata = sma toma ao 2 acca nae ibaa Lad
Page 8
490 The Nation. [Vol. 68, No 1774 AID AND COMFORT TO THE ENEMY. The speech made by Mr. Barrett, late Minister from the United States to Siam, at the Chamber of Commerce in Boston, was in some respects commendable. So far as it dealt with the commerce of the East, it was at least more moderate in its estimates than some others that have been made. Mr. Barrett, however, as- signed no substantial reason for the great increase of trade which he ex- pected, and his estimates must be re- garded as largely conjectural. It is not his figures that appear to us deserving of attention, but the political principles that he enunciates. He thinks that the only hope of this country, so far as gaining the trade of the Far East is concerned, is in our maintaining our sovereignty perpetually over the Philippine Islands, and he implies that those who protest against our subjugating their inhabi- tants are traitors. He declared that all our generals and most of our privates agree that the anti-imperialist move- ment has given unlimited aid, comfort, and encouragement to the forces of the Filipinos. More specifically, he stated that ‘the most encouraging influence for the Filipinos in fighting us, and hence the most unfortunate one for «ur sol- diers and sailors to combat against, was the spreading of the sentiment and ideas through the ranks of the Filipino army and among the masses of the natives that our occupation of the islands was unwarranted, the war unprovoked, our army and navy unsupported by our peo- ple, and our country about to demand the withdrawal of our forces from the islands, the hauling down of the flag, and our complete and ignominious with- drawal from our responsibilities.” Mr. Barrett further declared that Sena- tor Hoar’s speech roused great hopes of freedom among the Filipinos, and that he did all that he could to prevent copies of the speech from being dis- tributed among them, This is in accord- ance with the principles of the censor- ship which has been established under our military rule, and Mr. Barrett’s whole speech is based on the assumption that it is the duty of Americans who believe that we are engaged in a war of “criminal aggression” to deny their be- lief, or at least hold their tongues. This assumption has no place in the theory of free government, It belongs to des- potism, and the naiveté with which Mr. Barrett adopts it shows how extensive is the demoralization produced by war. But how consistent is his own prac- tice with his censure of those who will not be silent at this time? We find in the July number of the Review of Reviews an article from his pen on the Philippine situation, in which he represents Agui- naldu as the idolized popular leader, who had returned to his country “under. the protection. of the.ships of a nation called. America, Which had gore toowar. with se Spain and would give them freedom and independence at once.” The “impression went abroad among thé masses of the people that Aguinaldo had arrived to es- tablish an independent government, and that the Americans”’would assist him.” The people flocked to him in such num- bers that he had contributions of large sums of money, unlimited supplies of food, and more soldiers than he could arm. The “people were educated to be- lieve that they were to have absolute independence.” Within a few months, Aguinaldo organized a government which “developed into a much more ela- borate affair than its most ardent sup- porters had originally expected.” By the middle of October, 1898, says Mr. Barrett, “He had assembled at Malolos a congress of 100 men who would compare in beha- vior, manner, dress, and education with the average men of the better classes of other Asiatic nations, possibly including the Ja- panese. These men, whose sessions I re- peatedly attended, conducted themselves with great decorum, and showed a know- ledge of debate and parliamentary law that would not compare unfavorably with the Japanese Parliament. The’ executive por- tion of the Government was made up of a ministry of bright men who seemed to un- derstand their respective positions. Each general division was subdivided with refer- ence to practical work. There was a large force of under-secretaries and clerks, who appeared to be kept very busy with routine labor.”’ Does that sound like the description of an assemblage of savages, cr of an as- semblage of intelligent men, who knew what they wanted—knew their rights, and were bound to maintain them? And now read what Mr. Barrett says of the army which Aguinaldo collected: “The army, however, of Aguinaldo was the marvel of his achievements. He had over twenty regiments of comparatively well-or- ganized, well-drilled, and well-dressed sol- diers, carrying modern rifles and ammuni- tion. I saw many of these regiments execut- ing not only regimental, but battalion and company drill, with a precision that aston- ished me. Certainly as far as dress was concerned, the comparison with the uniform of our soldiers was favorable to the Fi- lipinos. They were officered largely, except in the higher positions, with young men who were ambitious to win honors and were not merely show fighters. The people in all the different towns took great pride in this army. Nearly every family had a father, son, or cousin in it. Wherever they went, they roused enthusiasm for the Filipino cause. The impression made upon the in- habitants of the interior by such displays can be readily appreciated. Aguinaldo and his principal lieutenants also made frequent visits to the principal towns, and were re- ceived with the same earnestness that we show in greeting a successful President.’ We submit that when Mr. Barrett pub- lishes facts like these, he does more to discredit the war which we are carrying forward in the Philippines than all the utterances of the anti-imperialists, and all the soldiers’ letters combined, can do. He makes an effort to show that Aguinaldo is culpable because, when he found that the Americans were not going to withdraw and leave the Filipinos to rule their own country, he concealed the fact from his followers. He also en- deavors to show that while our forces maintained “most agreeable relations” with Aguinaldo when he first returned, Admiral Dewey was “careful to avoid formal recognition.” But Mr. Barrett knows very well that there is other evi- dence on this point which establishes be- yond dispute that Aguinaldo and his fol- lowers were led to believe that they would be helped by the Americans to es- tablish their own independence. There is the official dispatch of Admiral Dewey himself, sent to the Secretary of the Navy on June 27, 1898: “Aguinaldo, insurgent leader, with thir- teen of his staff, arrived May 19, by permis- sion, on the Nashan. . . . I have given him to understand that I consider insurgents as friends, being opposed to a common ene- my. He has gone to attend a meeting of in- surgent leaders for the purpose of forming civil government. ... In my _ opinion, these people are far superior in their intelli- gence and more capable of self-government than the natives of Cuba, and I am familiar with both races.” A few weeks later, Gen. Thomas M. Anderson, commanding the United States troops at Cavité, wrote to Aguinaldo: “T would like to have your Excellency’s advice and coéperation, as you are best acquainted with the resources of the country.” Three weeks later, still in su- preme command, he asked Aguinaldo for assistance in transportation of American troops, “as it is to fight in the cause of your people.” That previous to this time our consular officials, Wildman, Consul-General at Hong Kong, Pratt, Consul-General at Singapore, and Wil- liams, Consul at Manila, gave Aguinaldo the strongest reasons for believing that the American Government would help him to secure the independence of the Filipinos, is an established fact, the de- tails of which are too familiar to need repetition. But what matters it how he and his fellow-patriots got the idea that we were to help them to fight for their independence? If they are fighting for it, what kind of an American is he who cannot sympathize with them? And if our sympathy depends upon their con- dition of savagery or the reverse, is not Mr. Barrett fostering the very “trea- son” he deprecates? HONEST POLITICS. It would be interesting to learn exact- ly who is meant to be influenced by the defences of the recent civil-service order which have been put forth, We know what the Civil-Service Commission thinks of it; we. know what every one who has struggled for the reform thinks of it. They have no doubt concerning the pur- pose of the order, nor concerning its con- struction, nor concerning its operation. The assertion that the order is really calculated to promote the cause of re- form, in the opinion of all these per- sons, merely adds the sin of hypocrisy to the guilt of bad faith. It is certainly im- probable, on its face, that an order de- vised by men who have never interested themselves in reforming the service should be meant, to advance the reform,
Page 9
June 29, 1899] rf $ ‘The Nation, 491 when no one who has been interested in the reform suggested or desired such an order. We may lay it down quite po- sitively that whoever was grieved or dis- gusted or angered by the issuing of the order has not had his feeling altered by the defences offered for it. There is abundant evidence, also, that these defences are equally worthless in the view of those who are opposed to reform. The Ohio politicians may have exulted a little prematurely, and per- haps injudiciously; but they exulted sin- cerely and they show no signs of dis- appointment. They are doubtless indif- ferent to explanations of the new order, provided they get the offices, and they have no doubt that they will get them. The editor of a New Hampshire journal, the Mirror and Farmer, of Manchester, perhaps as influential a Republican organ as any in Northern New Eng- land, dismisses all the talk of the Pre- sident’s being in favor of keeping the offices out of the hands of the politi- cians as cant. He says very frankly that it is wasting space to contend that the} President’s order “taking from 5,000 to 10,000 Federal offices out of the classified service and putting them in the list of spoils squares with the St. Louis platform, or with the Presideat’s letter of acceptance, because every intelligen person who is interested in the subjec knows to the contrary.” The order, h maintains, is right, because it restore to the politicians a large number of of fices that should never have been take away from them, and he concludes wit the pointed question: ‘““‘Why not stan up and say so, instead of asking peopl to believe what they all know it i not?” This honest politician takes the groun that as the Democratic officeholders ar performing their duties faithfully an satisfactorily, it would be an outrage t remove them “for cause.” There is n cause for removing them, except tha they opposed McKinley’s election in 189 and will oppose his reélection in 1900 Barring their politics, they are wel enough; but there are plenty of Republi cans who can step into their places an perform their duties just as efficiently No doubt President McKinley declare that he stood on the St. Louis platform and that platform promised to defen and extend the merit system. But, i the first place, “the adoption of th civil-service plank at St. Louis was perfunctory performance, intended, lik the declaration in favor of internation bimetallism, to catch or hold a few vote of which it was supposed there would b¢ great need.” The promise was a ba one, and is better broken than kep The President “has become convinced that the Republicans did not mean what they said when, at St. Louis, they poll} parroted the usual promise to defend an extend the civil-service rules, in accord ance with the wishes of the profession reformers, and he has corrected the wis. take. He has made it possible to bounce several thousand Democrats who are’ {lo- ing well enough, and give their placey to as raany Republicans who will do t as well. This is the plain truth, and: po- thing is to be gained by having it itis. stated by cabinet officers or any “one else.” *} It is difficult not to be convince¢ | by these statements. They are evidently sincere, they express the feeling of Host of the Republican soliticians, and they are intrinsically probable. No one tan deny that there are thousands of offices in which the pay is more than the ’ger- vices are worth—in which, indeed,)'the services are of no market value, —* has often been pointed out, in whi¢h a child could do all that is required dt a man. Such offices are created by poli- ticians for the purpose of filling them with politicians, and to suppose that they will relinquish them without! !the most desperate resistance is to suppose that they are willing to commit politi- cal suicide. Such offices are created to be made “spoils,”’ and it is time fot} re- formers to enlarge their scheme, sq as to provide for the abolition of useless offices and the compensation of em- ployees on business principles, as well as for examinations and permanent tenure. Until this is done, the di- nary citizen will cling to the tradi- tional view that a public office is jone in which the pay is much higher} in proportion to the work done, th a private position; and while that lew prevails, the “spoils” theory will endure. The New Hampshire editor has stated the case fairly and honestly. The jRe- publican politicians talked of civil+ser- vice reform only to gain votes, and now that they think they do not need these votes, they cease their pretences. hat may be ca!led dishonest politics from! one point of view, but it is honest politics as showing reformers just how they have been treated, and just what they may ex- pect from the Republican party. | | i POLITICAL ISSUES CHANGING. Mr. 8. BE. Morss, editor of the Indiana- polis Sentinel, is credited with holding the view that the financial plank ia the Democratic platform of 1896 ought, not to form the dominant issue in the ¢am- paign of next year, and that if it does the party will be beaten. Accomding to an interview which has been ‘pub- lished in some of the Western news- papers, Mr. Morss thinks that the issues will be “anti-Trust, anti-militarism, ex- pansion, and tariff reform.” With these he thinks that the Democrats would have good prospects of success. It is reported that the ancient and moss-grown Demo- cracy of Indiana are much agitated by this outgiving, and that some of the more venerable members of the party talk of starting a new paper in opposi- ! j | ry | ! i tion to the Sentinel—-a project which may be carried into effect when the United States adopts free jcoinage at the ratio of 16 to 1 without! the consent of any other nation, but nét before. Undoubtedly Mr.} Morss, in the inter- view attributed to) him, represents the present drift and tqndency of the Demo- cratic party. On jthe other hand, we observe a tendénes among the Republi- cans to put the Bene issue forward as the chief one the next campaign. Such must be the meaning of the sudden and praiseworthy zeal of their leading organs in favor of a law declaring all Government obligations payable in gold, and the reported determination of the Senate Finance Committee to promote the passage of such a measure next win- ter. If such a bill is reported at the next session, it will constitute a chal- lenge to the Democrats to make the campaign on the ipsues of 1896. It will serve the twofold purpose of putting the Democrats in a dilemma, and of side- tracking the issues of imperialism and civil-service debauchery which now be- cloud the Republi¢an horizon not a lit- tle. The question, bs shall be the issues of next year, canhot be determined er cathedra this year.| Whatever shall prove to be the subjects @f most immediate na- tional concern then—whatever be the questions making ithe sharpest divisions in the public conscience—will be the political issues. Neither Mr. McKinley nor Mr. Bryan, nejther editor Morss nor Senator Hanna, cn stop the flowing of the tide of opinion. The tide will carry the platform-makers along with it, and they will be studying, when the time comes, not how they may stem it, but how they can make the best use of it and derive the mdést advantage from it. It is easy to say [wh will not be the uppermost consideration next year. Mr. Morss is right in jsaying that it will be useless to expect t@ change our monetary standard while t Republicans control the Senate. As they have secured a ma- jority for at leasti six years to come, it will be simply a waste of powder for the Democrats to put the silver issue in front. All that they could expect in the most favorable evpnt would be a change to bimetallism of some kind, national or international, pe the year 1907. That is too distant and too problematical to engage present fe No enthusiasm can be enlisted in a contingency so re- mote. The situation; is greatly changed since the fight for free coinage was going on in the seventies and eighties. Then the Republicans professed to be as good silver meh as the Democrats. If the Democrats hered the Bland bill, the Republicans fathered the Sherman bill, which “did more for silver” than the former measyre. If the Democrats were for free coinage by separate ac- tion of the United States, the Republi- | | i ; | ; stain tn A ltd
Page 10
492 The Nation. [Vol. 68, No. 1774 cans favored the same end by interna- tional agreement, which was safer. And so the ignis fatuus was always dancing in front of us, apparently within reach, but just beyond our grasp. Now, how- ever, the situation is wholly different. The Republicans are no longer pretend- ing to favor silver. They no longer fa- vor an international conference to “re- habilitate” it, although they would join one if it were called by some other na- tion of the first rank, as it will not be. The prospect being as it is for six years to comé, the most sanguine bi- metallist must be under depression of spirits. The inspiration of hope is wanting. Even Mr. A. J. Warner, who may be called, since the death of Mr. Bland, the veteran of flat money, is said to take a despairing view of the bi- metallic future. It is certain that Mr. Bryan is not upholding the cause with his usual vigor. He has two words to say about Trusts where he says one about silver. He has said that he con- siders the money question only one branch of the Trust question. Very likely Mr. Morss did not give utterance to his views without some assurance that they would be agreeable, or not disagreeable, to Mr. Bryan. All that can be said now is that the Democratic party is drifting away from the financial plank of the Chicago platform, and that the campaign of next year will most probably be fought on the other issues which Mr. Morss has indicated. THE INTEROCEANIC CANAL. The problems of an interoceanic canal form the text of an instructive article in the June number of the Political Science Quarterly, by George L. Rives. Mr. Rives considers dll the questions in- volved, but gives most attention to an exposition of the legal ones which are raised by the demand for “a canal un- der American control.”’” This phrase has been repeated so often that it has come to be accepted by many as a self- evident proposition, yet it ignores seve- ral important considerations, and among others these: (1) the Clayton-Bulwer treaty with England, in which we agreed that we would never acquire or exer- cise such control; (2) the consent of Nicaragua, Costa Rica, Colombia, or whatever countries the canal passes through; (3) the means necessary to make such control permanent and effec- tive, and the cost of the same. What is meant by “American control” of an interoceanic canal? It does not mean exclusive right to use the canal. Nobody has ever suggested that idea. Every calculation that has ever been made respecting the cost and the revenue of the canal has been based upon the largest possible traffic. It has been as- sumed that all nations will use it on equal terms, and that the tolls will be made low enough to attract not only the commerce that now goes around the Horn, but a large share of that which crosses the continent by rail, and some part of that which now goes via Suez. Neither Great Britain nor any other country could consent to discriminating tolls on an interoceanic canal. The Clayton-Bulwer treaty was framed pri- marily to prevent such discrimination. Moreover, Nicaragua has treaties with most of the nations of the Old World guaranteeing them equal rights of pas- sage through any canal that may be made through its territory. Great Bri- tain may consent to the abrogation of the Clayton-Bulwer treaty, but only on condition that the canal tolls shall be as low to her ships, her subjects, and her goods as to those of any competi- tor. Neither France nor Germany could consent to be put at a disadvantage commercially in respect of tolls, since discrimination against them would be tantamount to exclusion from the canal altogether. . If the Suez Canal had never been neutralized by treaty, if it belonged solely to England in such a way that she could do what she liked with it, she could never adopt discriminating tolls on it without finding herself at war with the whole world. We may assume, then, that “American control” does not mean the exclusive right to use the canal commercially, nor the right to give our own people an ad- vantage over others. There is only one other thing that it can mean, and that is the right to pass our war-ships through it in time of war, and to prevent the enemy from doing so. Obviously, these rights can be exercised in time of war only on condition that we are strong enough on the line of the canal, and at both ends of it, to fight off the adver- sary. The right to pass the Oregon through the canal last year (if there had been a canal) would have been of no worth unless we had been able to gua- rantee that no harm would be done to her or to the canal itself while she was making the transit, and that she would not meet a superior enemy when she emerged from it. Mr. Rives thinks that without such guarantee Capt. Clark would have preferred to take his chances by the Straits of Magellan. A _ very small amount of dynamite would suffice to disable a lock and to imprison any and all ships that might be passing through. Of course the enemy would make the utmost efforts to cripple the canal unless he were restrained by treaty from doing so. Therefore, American control, in Mr, Rives’s opinion, requires continuous military occupation of the country through which the canal passes, supple- mented and sustained by paramount na- val strength, situated in close proximity to the Atlantic terminus. This is main- ly a question of cost, but it is not with- out its moral aspects. How are we to acquire the right to occupy the country in question? Such occupation is not likely to be granted peacefully. It is not likely that Nicaragua, for example, will surrender her sovereignty unless com- pelled by arms. Are we to invade her if she declines to do so? Would any large number of the American people justify such a step? There may be some persons so addled by the catchwords “American control,” ‘Monroe Doctrine,” etc., that they would see nothing wrong in our seizing any Central American country that denies or questions Mr. Ol- ney’s doctrine that our fiat has the force of law on this continent; but it is not probable that we shall resort to such measures unless we have better reasons for doing so than have been advanced as yet. The conclusion that the readers of Mr. Rives’s article will draw from it is that an international guarantee of the neu- trality of the canal is much better and a great deal cheaper than any guarantee of our own. With an international guarantee, the only protection needed would be that of an ordinary police force, whereas our sole guarantee would require effective military control of the entire line, and effective naval control of the termini. The former would prob- ably imply 30,000 men either on the isthmus or within hailing distance. The latter would be an indeterminate quan- tity. It might require us to have the largest navy in the world as a perma- nent addition to the national budget. It might. involve us in a larger expense than all the saving which the canal could bring to our commerce. Mr. Rives takes the Panama Canal into his reckoning, and holds it to be the President’s duty to give that enterprise the same impartial consideration as the Nicaragua. His article is interesting in all its phases, and, while his treatment of the subject cannot be considered ex- actly novel, it is so clear and complete that it must have considerable influence on current opinion and discussion. AN INTERESTING EXHIBITION. LONDON, June, 1899. The International Society of Painters, Sculptors, and Uravers, as it calls itself, having its headquarters at Knightsbridge, began its career a year ago, and yet already it is felt that if it will but persevere, if the small public that can appreciate it will but give it the necessary support, it must prove a more formidable power for the Royal Academy to reckon with than any number of Royal Commissions and big books of denunciation. Not that it was started in opposition. The object of the Grosvenor Gallery was, practically, to rival the Acade- my, to represent all the outside forces, to provide a shelter (and a befitting one) for distinguished, or interesting, or promising artists who found the doors of Burlington House shut against them. But the Interna- tional was formed by a little group of men, with Mr. Whistler as their ‘President, not to revolutionize or reform or represent or rival anything, but simply because it was
Page 11
June 29, 1899] The Nation. amusing to try, by means of discriminate in- vitation and selection, of intelligent hanging and arranging, to make a show that would prove a pleasure, and not a torture, to all ! who visited it. And it so happens that no- thing is so badly needed at the present moment as just such a show. The-necessity of cover-. ing an enormous wall space has put a pre-| mium on incompetency. The lowering of the} exhibition standard has encouraged the ama-: teurs. And in the dreadful medley that isthe! result, good work is lost sight of. It gra-! dually disappears, for the self-respecting ar-| tist hesitates to dishonor his pictures by! submitting them to so humiliating a test. Against this evil the International Ex-| hibition proves a triumphant protest, and it! is because I think the evil so serious,; though not half well enough realized, that! I dwell on the general character of the; show rather than on individual contribu-: tions to it. All the pictures hung may not: be masterpieces, to be sure, but at least: they are treated as if each were worthy of! consideration—and, indeed, if it were not,; why should it have been accepted? The! walls, of a good gray-green, make a plea- sant neutral background, the light is tom) pered by a canopy, and the pictures, in-! stead of being jumbled up into a mere mo-; saic of frames, hang never more than two; deep, while around each is the little space as important to a painting as the margi of white paper is to a page of text. If th ‘ result is that room can be spared for not: quite two hundred and fifty pictures, so much the more reason have we to be thank- ful. It is quality that counts, not quantity: Another advantage is that these compara- tively few are, more or less, in sympathy; at all events, different methods and styleg are never allowed to conflict, to kill each other. When discord is thus avoided, whet every canvas is duly respected, genius does not run the danger of disappearing for the moment, or of suffering from its neighbors{ the honest endeavor or experiment is mr at its very best. Such careful arrangemen immediately gives dignity and harmony t the walls. The collection can be looked at, not only comfortably, but with absolute en} joyment. Of course, it may be said that thé system of inviting contributors must lead to injustice, that the most perfect com: mittee is sure to have its prejudices an preferences, that some good men are boun to be left out. But still, in the end, the system, no matter how much abused, would be productive of less evil than the Aca} demy’s plan of considering any and ile thing any and every man, woman, or chili may choose to submit. The more ey an there is in obtaining admission into an ex hibition, the better it must be for that ex- hibition, : But it is not necessary to theorize when we have the International as a practical example of how the system works. I not count the New Gallery, where the same rule is supposed to prevail, for there, thou there is a committee made up partly af artists, I doubt very much if they are the ruling force. Besides, they are mostly Acg- demicians, with, pcesumably, Academical axes to grind. The tomparison may he made more reasonably between the Intes national and the Academy. It is a ver few weeks since { wrete that the success¢ at this year’s Academy could be reduced to two small pictures—a portrait and a lan¢ scape. And now, if I turn to the younger + & as ’ eo mee ee, eeerewes ee institution? At once, I am confronted by a difficulty. I find in the four or five rooms— there are sixteen galleries at Burlington House—more good, more interesting work than I can mention without my letter dwin- dling into a mere catalogue, and I f=d also some extremely distinguished work. Here you have a President who not only is useful as a figurehead, but is a painter accepted by all other painters as a master. It would matter little at the Academy, one way or the other, if Sir Edward Poynter did or did not exhibit. Mr. Whistler's appearance at the International is an event of the greatest artistic importance—especially as three of the six paintings he contributes have never been shown to the public before. One is a little nude, the other two are por- traits—small ovals: “‘Violet and Rose, Car- men qui rit,” and “Rose and Gold, the Little Lady Sophie of Soho’’—both very love- ly harmonies of color, full of the elegance and reticence which always make so many of the canvases hung near Mr. Whistler's seem but tentative, experimental, uncertain. It is to be noted, too, that Mr. Whistler's in- fluence develops an appreciation of these very qualities in his pupils. Not very far from his group of pictures is a study of a head, ‘‘%Stude de la Semaine,” by Miss Inez Bate, who, the catalogue explains, is ‘‘Mas- siére de l’Académie Carmen, Eléve de Whis- tler,” and its sober restraint, its dignity, lend it a distinction you do not look for in a student’s work. How often, I wonder, would one’s attention be called to the “‘Week’s Study”’ by an Academy student, if it were hung at Burlington House? The same difference that exists between the presidents of the two institutions fs as striking’ when it ccmes to the rank and file. At the International the trouble is ta dis- cover, not the successes, but the failures: But let me quote Mr. R. A. M. Stevenson gn the subject: ‘“‘While the first impression at the Aca- demy is appalling, the first sight of this place is inviting and delightful; while one takes some time to find out that there are good works at Burlington House, one admits only slowly and reluctantly that there are bad pictures at the International.” And he adds that ‘‘perhaps bad may be a rather strong word, since the International does not go as far down as the Academy.” But, really, it has been amusing, in reading the criticisms in the London papers, to see how the various critics have dispcsed of this majority of good work, to which the usual London show has not accustomed them. One or two have been content to consider only the pictures of the group represented by Re- noir, Pissarro, Monet, Sisley, who, it has been said, must be discounted in reckoning the actual forces and prospects of the Society, though I cannot understand why, since they are unquestionably among the forces that have made a large proportion of the ex- hibitors what they are. In some cases in- terest has been concentrated chiefly upon the Glasgow men; very naturally, as this is the one gallery in London where Mr. Guthrie, Mr. Walton, Mr. Lavery, Mr. Paterson, and the others are received and recognized and honored. I cannot help feeling that their accomplishment has not yet justified the great expectations they aroused j#everal years since, but their work is never common- piece, and their contipual endeavor to de- velop style above all else prevents their tumbling into the trivialities of the Acade- my or wrecking themselves on the sham re- vivals and archaic affectations of the more notoriety-seeker. Nor have they ceased to concern themselves with the decorative qua- lity of a canvas, so jthat you may be sure of some definite design, some well-thought- out arrangement of dolor, even in the por- trait or landscape ij which you are most keenly conscious of} their indifference to tones and values. Then, again, the important fact may be the presence of Miss Begux, who made such a sensation last year, dnd Mr. Chase, who, in London, has hithert¢ been known only by reputation, and I thihk he might have sent pictures that would jfustain that reputation more brilliantly. Orj the chief attracticn is the work of the Scapdinavians, Kroyer and Thaulow; of the Gerthans, Stuck and Klimt; of the Italians, Mancini and Fragiacomo; of the Dutchman, Jameg Maris, or of the indi- vidual painters independent of any group- Muhrman, Mark Fisher, McLure Hamilton, for too many years resident in England to be identified entirely with the Americans— or Couture, or Sandys, or Walter Crane, or Greiffenhagen; and sp I might go on through a long list. But I hpve said enough to give an idea of what manuer of painting, or paint- er, is to be looked fom at the International. The prints and drawings are still more dis- tinguished as a collection, and they are as admirably hung as the black-and-white work at the Academy 4 chucked carelessly to- gether. The men of! the sixties are given a place, and for me this mingling of the older with the younger g¢nerations is immensely helpful. There are/studies by the English Alfred Stevens, the tte of the Welling- ton Monument at St! Paul's, and by the Ger- man Menzel. A room—a white room—is set apart for Mr. Whigtler’s etchings, among them two beautiful jlittle iimpressions of the Jubilee Naval Review, now seen for the first time. There are seyeral of Mr. Cole’s wood engravings after the English masters, al- ready published in the Century; color prints by Mr. Oppler and |Mr. Nicholson; etchings by Herr Klinger, Mr. Pennell, Mr. Strang; Mr. Sullivan’s series of drawings to illustrate “Sartor Resartus."” But, again, | am in dan- ger of cataloguing. | Ali I have space to say is that the average in the black-and-white section is higher than in any other, and that the sculpture, if there is not much of it, is excellent, while it includes one of M. Rodin's most perfect little grcups. Altogether, the radicals, who are sb eager to put a stop to all exhibitions because both Salon and Aca- demy have failed the artist, could not do better than visit thé International, and from it borrow a far simpler solution for the most serious artistic problem of the day. N. N. SAN GIMIGNANO. | FLORENCE, May, 1899. Now if it were not for the recent flecting gleam of popular isterest in which the little Tuscan town of gan Gimignano has been basking on account! of the Dante celebration there, I should p bly never set down for publication a word!about the place. Nor do I intend to descri the goings on at the aforesaid celebration, firstly, because I was not present, and, secondly, because, as near as I can make out,'it was like most celebra- tions—speeches, dinners, processions, and band-concerts, Neither can I speak learned- ly of the surprisingiy numerous and interest- ing frescoes in the local churches, by Benoz- zo Gozzoli, Ghirlandajo, and ether worth- 8 PAST 0h mA Db-s-« 3 aedeow need cena oe eteaatier, 3 : § > 7
Page 12
494 The Nation. [Vol. 68, No. 1774 ies. What, indeed, remains to be men- tioned? Little, it is true; but there is always a pleasure in chronicling the obscure, if worthy, and bringing to light hidden trea- sures of even small price. The town, up to the present time, has been known to the elect only, and from the elect did I get my cue to go and stay there. So, as a mere matter of noblease oblige, I should be extremely shy of “giving away a good thing’ were it not for the celebration above mentioned, which has attracted such comparatively general atten- tion to the town among tourists that I might as weli raise my voice to tell them what San Gimignano is like when they are not there, and when no band-concerts are in progress. What, then, is the mystic attraction of San Gimignano? Well, it is a mediwval town. Here, in seething modern Italy, only seven iniles from the railroad, under the shadow of Florence, that great cradle of the new life of which the ending century has been so glo- riously full, San Gimignano stands stolidly unmoved, essentially as it stood before that new life was conceived of. It was more on account of the local color of the place than of its somewhat slender connection with Dante— he spoke here in favor of the Tuscan League in 1800, not, as erroneously calculated, in 1299—that the town was selected as the stage for the recent cavalcades, speechify- ings, and so on. And as a stage, the setting is certainly appropriate. The centre is occu- pied most properly among a sober and clean- ly folk by the town well, which, with that perversity almost proverbial in wells, oocu- ples nearly the highest land in town. If you will stand on the steps and peer over the curb into the capacious depths, you will get the keynote of the town; for the inner edge of that solid stone curb is like nothing so much as a blunt-toothed comb. Uncounted generations of bucket-~-opes sliding over its surface have worn the a continuous fringe of grooves, so deep that in some you can hide two fingers. Turn and walk around the square, being careful not to step on the crock- ery and other small wares laid on the pave- ment for sale. The houses, you see, have rarely remained true to their original inten- tions. Doors have been made into windows, arches bricked up, and then other arches opened under them, to be perhaps superseded after all by a modern lintel. There are bits of fine old Siena brick and terracotta work over some of the more pretentious windows; a sturdy Romanesque chapel front of the ele- venth century serves as a wall to the stable- yard; and dozens of other tracks of the whirligig of time are obvious. Indeed, it is said that the town is mentioned as far back as 921, In the middie part of the town plen- tiful traces exist of a wall of the twelfth century. In the sixteenth century a much more ex- tensive wall was constructed, and this wall, with its round bastions, its machicolated gates, and its embrasures for the primi- tive cannon with which it was at inter- vals defended, still remains in almost perfect preservation. Outside of it the town, with true medimval caution, has steadfastly refused to expand. Within it the highest point is occupied by the Rocca, or citadel, now for the most part a blooming garden. In the aimless streets that plough through the solid masonry of the town like deep crooked stone gutters, the pack-horse is still the characteristic beast of burden. The mail comes up from Poggibonsi, when it does come, in a shambling old curricle. Fur- ther than the telegraph office, electricity in any form has never penetrated. I think at “Tl Leon Bianco’ I once saw a newspaper, but I forget of how many weeks back. The policeman sleeps undisturbed on the café bench. A bicycle tourist is a seven days’ wonder. In fact, I am ready to back my thesis against all comers, that San Gimi- gnano is a thoroughgoing medisval town. And what of the inhabitants in a media- val town? I wish I could truthfully say that medieval costume is still worn. But, alas, to return to our stage metaphor, instead of the ‘legitimate’ doublet and hose, coif and farthingale, a distressingly iow-comedy style is prevalent; loud checked suit, pan- cake derby, and baggy green umbrella be- ing proper festive attire. Since their disas- trous playing at politics in the Middle Ages, resulting in loss of independence, dis- mantling of the fortifications, and a forced fealty to Florence, the inhabitants have to a remarkable degree minded their own bu- siness and cultivated self-dependence. Only once was I approached by a beggar (and this, mind you, in Italy) during my stay— of course, saving and excepting the children, who follow a visitor as if he were a kind of modern Midas. Almost every trade is prac- tised in this isolated little community. The women twirl the distaff in the streets, and on the grass outside the walls bleach the narrow linen web that comes from the hand-looms clapping in the doorways. Dyed yarn hangs on the walls to dry. The cobbler, the harness-maker, the mason, the carpen- ter, the painter, the coppersmith, the pot- ter, and all the rest of them can be seen intermittently at work. For nobody works very hard at San Gimignano. Why should they? Things were pretty well finished up there some time ago. Only the very old men and women are really active. Most of the able-bodied men lounge on the piazza and hold deep self-communings as to the advisa- bility of doing anything to-day. It seems to take till about sixty-five to learn the value of time here. The types of face are not un- pleasing—the women round-cheeked and cheery, brown-haired, taller and more at- tractive than the Sienese; the men spare, keen-faced, taciturn, pipe in mouth, and hands in pockets, looking not unlike New England fishermen ashore. Until the olive-picking and wine-making season comes round, life is almost station- ary. What need to go far for anything? Following her self-centred policy, the town is well provided, not only with trades, but with public buildings. There is the cathe- dral, a stone barn without, within miserably painted above its uncouth capitals in imita- tion of Sienese striped marble, yet enshrin- ing the famous chapel of Fina, the invalid girl saint, whose simple death at the age of fifteen is beautifully illustrated on the walls by Ghirlandajo in some of his finest frescoes. There are the inevitable barracks, where a fresh section of that national scorpion, the Itaiian army, is quartered every six months. There is the hotel (as it loves to style it- self), in an ancient “palace,” where the in- frequent visitor may wajch the antics of his coming dinner as the geese chase the rabbits round the courtyard, or admire the sign- board, the ancient coat-of-arms of the town, a white lion on a shield half red, half gold. There is a mysterious factory that makes something very noisily in the sleepy late af- ternoon. There is even a theatre, shamelessly converted out of the ancient and venerable hall of the Council. There is a collection of pictures from suppressed monasteries and the like, in the upper chamber of the town- hall. There is a monastery, not sup- pressed, among towering cypresses in the valley. There is an orphan school that is al- Ways open, and a public library that is al- ways shut. There are parish churches, bald and early, but full of mural work by Be- nozzo Gozzoli and other great names. There is a large hospital and a small penitentiary. What would you? Are we not a complete little community at San Gimignano? But above all there are the towers. Con- cerning them it appears, as nearly as I can make out, that at some misty date in the early struggles between Guelph and Ghibel- line, or the two local families of Ardingelli and Salvucci, one of the haughty nobles built him a large square tower some three stories high, lighted by graceful arched win- dows and finished with a corbelled parapet. This was altogether too much for the leader of the opposition, whc promptly built a taller tower and capped it with a belfry. ‘‘Un- bearable!” cried every one, and forthwith the tower-building fever seized the town. Towers sprang up intall directions, all on the same square plan and with the same characteristics. Height being the sole con- sideration, any stone was used, mostly an ugly gray slate; no time or money was wasted on decoration, or even windows, save a few light-slits; there was no attempt at finishing the top—you merely stopped construction with a certain course, ready to go on again if the tower across the street grew taller than yours. One builder was so thoughtless as to run a set of corbels round the top of his tower; but behold, ‘a neighbor’s overtopped his, and he had to add another story, leaving the corbels foolishly sticking out below it. Church and state became equally infected. The town hall had been finished, a fine piece of early Gothic, but the Council built a large tower next it, thereby blocking the side street, which had to be led through an arch in the base. The cathedral chapter laid their heads together, and, under the name of a cam- . panile, ran up a perfect monstrosity. One desperate slave to family pride erected twin towers only a few yards apart. Man with- out a tower was but a thing of naught in- deed. At last affairs got to such a pitch that the authorities interfered. A maximum height of towers, a sort of early building law, was fixed, beyond which no private person could go. Then the craze subsided and the town came to its senses again. But what a looking town! Everywhere within the limits of the early walls, in the heart of the town, ugly tall towers and ugly short towers and ugly stumps of towers gibber senselessly at the firmament above them. Viewed from a distance, the town resembles some manufacturing centre, bristling with great chimneys of odd shapes. Only recently one of the loftiest towers was pulled down as dangerous, and similar precautions seem to have been often taken before. And they are now little more than ruins. Just when this craze occurred I don’t think any one quite knows, but it is alluded to in a proverb of highly respectable antiquity; and in the town hall you may see Gozzolli's picture of Saint Gimignano himself, painted years before Columbus was heard of, holding a model of the town, of which the towers form about nine-tenths of the buildings. Similarly, in Domenico Ghirlandajo’s fres-
Page 13
June 29, 1899] The Nation. | 405 coes in the cathedral, groups of towers are used for unmistakable local ‘‘color’’; and on the top of one we see a large bush already grown, as on an ancient ruin. By day they slowly splinter and crumble away under sun and wind and frost, of no more use now than they were to their pride-devoured build- ers. By night, from their pinnacles, the owls hoot derisively at each other, like haunting spirits of the disdainful nobles of the murky old days that saw their rise, and the moon plays strange mocking tricks with them. And as you end your stay in this corner of the Old World, and drive back to the New again, through the vineyards of the valiey, you will turn for a last glimpse of the strange forgotten town, crawling uncertainly along its hilltop like some Rip Van Winkle who has lost his way, and all the poetry within you will be drowned in a flood of laughter at the inexpressibly futile and ludicrous ap- pearance of the towers of San Gimignano. S. F. B. Correspondence. FOREIGNERS AT THE UNIVERSITY OF PARIS. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Will you please allow me to rectify an omission in my letter on Americans at the University of Paris? Besides the Comité de Patronage des Etudiants Etrangers, I should have mentioned another information- giving body, created especially to supply the needs of American students, namely, the Comité Franco-Américain, whose secretary, M. Henry Bréal, No. 70 Rue d’Assas, Paris, holds himself ready to answer all questions that may be addressed to him regarding stu- dies in any of the French universities. American students, before or after arriv- ing in Paris, may obtain from him informa- tion not merely on academic subjects, but also on the practical questions of expenses, lodgings, etc. M. Bréal has just published, in the name of the Comité Franco-Américain, a pam- phlet (in English), of about 140 pages, 8vo, entitled ‘The Universities of France: A Guide for American Students,’ containing very full information regarding organiza- tion, requirements for admission and gra- duation, and courses of study. This pam- phlet may be had gratis on application ei- ther to him or to W. T. Harris, Esq., U. 8. Commissioner of Education, Washington, D. C.—Yours very truly, W. 8. PARIS, June 15, 1899. Notes. Henry Holt & Co. announce Krausse’s ‘Russia in Asia,’ and ‘Adrian Rome: a Con- temporary Portrait,’ by Ernest Dowson and Arthur Moore. ‘Thirty Years of New York Politics—-Up to Date,’ by Matthew P. Breen, will short- ly be published by the author, at No, 71 Broadway, New York. Macmillan Co. will publish ‘ Insects, their Structure and Life,’ a primer of ento- mology, by Prof. George H. Carpenter; ‘State Trials, Political and Social,’ in two volumes, by H. L. Stephen of the Inner Temple; and, somewhat later, ‘The Govern- ment of Municipalities,” by Dorman B. Eaton. , The Scientific Publishing Co. of this city have nearly ready the seventh issue of “The Mineral Industry: Its Statistics, Technology and Trade in the United States and Other Countries to the End of 1898,’ edited by Richard P. Rothwell. The Hudson-Kimberley Co. of Kansas City will publish immediately ‘The House of Dreams, and Other Pcems,’ by William Grif- fith. In August, Brown & Co., Boston, will have ready ‘A Kipling Primer,’ a bibliography by Frederick Lawrence Knowles, with a criti- cal appreciation of Kipling’s works and an | alphabetical index to the plots of all the sto- ries and ballads; and ‘The King and Queen of Mollebusch, or, The Indispensables,’ trans- lated from the German of Georg Ebers by Mary J. Safford, with full-page illustra- tions. The third volume of the Clarke papers, edited for the Royal Historical Society by Mr. Charles H. Firth, who, with Mr. Raw- son Gardiner, shares the seventeenth century as his own, in matters historical, is in the press. It will contain many important pa- pers relating to the West Indies. A fac- simile will also be given in this volume of a very curious colored caricature of Rich- ard Cromwell, on horseback, with the head of an owl. Mr. Rodway, author of ‘ia the Guiana Forest,’ of the ‘History of British Gui- ana,’ and of ‘The West Indies and the Spa- nish Main,’ in the “Story of the Nations” series, is now on a visit to England, hav- ing obtained leave of absence for six months from his duties of librarian and assistant secretary to the Royal Agricultural and Commercial Society of British Guiana. From the more serious subjects of history and natural science Mr. Rodway has recently turned to novel-writing. His ‘In the Wilds of Guiana,’ just out, formas one of Mr. Fish- er Unwin’s “Over-Sea” series. Mr. Rod- way took to England manuscripts which will no doubt find their way into the pub- lishers’ bands. Dr. Telting, sub-director of Archives at The Hague, is at present in the West Indies on official business. The West Indian Re- cords preserved at The Hague having all been properly arranged, catalogued, and {n- dexed, the Dutch Government has decided that the Records remaining in Dutch Guiana and in Curacoa shall be similarly treated. It is on this mission that Dr. Telting is now engaged. He arrived in Paramaribo, the capital of Dutch Guiana, early in May, and, assisted by a staff of clerks from the several departments, he took in hand the documents preserved in the law courts, in the jury, and in the office of the Secretary of | Colony. Thinking he might learn thing from the officials of British ——_ as to the preservation of documents from! the ravages of insects, Dr. Telting paid a shi visit to Georgetown, Demerara, where every facility for inquiry was given him by @pv- ernor Sir Walter Sendall. Neither in British nor in Dutch Guiana, however, has yet disclosed the vermifuge that oe serve papers from the various pests | de- stroy books and manuscripts alike. A completing his labors in Dutch Guiana,; Dr. Telting will proceed to Curacoa, to arrange the Public Records of that historical isiand, of which Stuyvesant, the famous Govetnor of New York, was at one time Lieutenant Governor. Returning'to Europe by way of New York, Dr. Telting will renew acquaint- ance with Prof. Burr $f Cornell, with whom he formed agreeable jations at the time the latter was work at The Hague in connection with Presigent Cleveland's Vene- zuelan Boundary Co ssion. The Messrs. Putnam: have become the pub- lishers of the second edition of Miner Bruce’s ‘Alaska,’ whith we noticed on its appearance three years ago, and have much improved its dress. The author has revised and enlarged his work; and given it a needed index. There is a chapter on the boundary dispute, one for tourists in search of the picturesque, and one of practical suggestions to prospectors in the) Klondike. The illus- trations are numeroug and serviceable, and there are several maps. Macmillan’s taking jlittle “Pocket Bnglish Classics” proceed with ‘Milton's Comus, Ly- cidas, and Other Poenjs,’ and Byron's ‘Childe Harold,’ both edited Andrew J. George. FitzGerald’s Omar jp for a third time given the imprint of Thoma B. Mosher, Portland, Me., now in a “Vest}Pocket Bdition,” long and narrow as befits:the designation. The binding is very dainty, and the printing to match. Mr. Dole, never weary of his sub- ject, furnishes a brie{ preface. Volumes ix. and i of Mr. Charles F. Lummis’s monthly md of Sunshine are replete with information and entertainment not wholly confined to California. In “The Bones of Mitla’’ the} editor presents some of the architectural nse of early Mexi- can civilization, andjthere are short illus- trated articles on Hajwaii and Manila, while Joaquin Miller describes “Life in a Klon- dike Cabin,” from pérsonal experience. In volume ix. is relate@ by several hands the memorable ascent of the Enchanted Mesa by Mr. Lummis, hig little daughter, Pre- sident Jordan and wife, and others, who easily discovered prpofs of former abor!i- ginal occupancy. Tie pictures of scenery, population, natural | products (¢. g., the largest tree in the worid), private and pub- lic dwellings and thej like, will interest any one. Those who go deeper will be most struck by the bold and independent tone of the editorial writing, especially on public topics. This is not aj common characteristic of the press, on the where; but courage Pacific Coast or else- has @ permanent berth in the office of the ljand of Sunshine. A short but admifable preface, contain- ing a brief biography of Amalie Skram, the author of ‘Professg¢r Hieronimus’ (John Lane), and statement of her position among Scandinavian realis of to-day, arouses further interest in t story to succeed it by means of -he following quotation from Bjérnson: “It is,” says, ‘‘the first time that a great author, in full possession of ber mental powers, has had the opportunity of making such a study. Seeking quiet and treatment for a/nervous affection, Fru Skram, of her own) free will, became an inmate of a lunatic lum. Thus she had a chance of studying jone of those specialists in mental disease who are too apt to mis- take rebelliousness for a sign of mental derangement. Of thiq doctor, of the patients, the nurses, her whole environment, she gives a picture so vivid, of such absorbing interest, that it can vie with the most thrilling rom: nce.” i and absorbing it I certainly is. We fpllow the fate of the heroine with feverish solicitude, and pity the husband hypnoti into the general be- t : } ' : ee aaeneeti :
Page 14
496 The Nation. [Vol. 68, No. 1774 lief in her insanity, but it is the horror, and not the romance, of the situation which thrills us. A mixture of domineering con- ceit, untruthfulness, and subtle cruelty en- ables the professor to secure and retain his patients; nurses and doctors alike come under his spell. The treatment and hope- less struggles of the sane to escape are portrayed in ghastly detail; and this dra- matic piece of writing of a high order will doubtless serve as a weapon for those who distrust the despotic power of asylums. Baker, Voorhis & Co. of this city are the publishers of a valuable compendium of the ‘United States Interr 1l-Revenue Laws Now in Force,’ by Mark Ash and William Ash. The volume is accompanied by notes in- dicating the derivatory statutes, references to judicial decisions, regulations, rules, and circulars of departments, and is supple- mented by a voluminous appendix contain- ing laws of a general nature and miscel- laneous provisions applicable to the admin- istration of the internal-revenue laws. The book is made necessary by the enactment of the war-revenue law of 1898, and is intended to cover everything. Taking as a basis the last official compilation of the Commissioner of Internal Revenue in 1894, the authors have endeavored to ‘‘compre-— hend in one volume all the express law.” The compilation is conveniently arranged for purposes of reference. ‘Cases on American Constitutional Law,’ edited by Carl Evans Boyd (Chicago: Cal- laghan & Co.), is a compilation of some hundred and fifty or more abridged cases. The author, in his preface, disclaims any intention of attempting to rival the well- known collection of Prof. J. B. Thayer, but has aimed at bringing together within the compass of a single volume a_ sufficient number of the leading decisions of the Su- preme Court of the United States to form the basis of a university course on Con- stitutional Law. The cases are taken from the reporters verbatim, except that ‘‘cer- tain parts, particularly statements of facts, have been shortened, and matter not necessary to the elucidation of the con- stitutional question involved has been omit- ted.” ‘The Conflict of Laws in the Province of Quebec’ is the title of a little book by Prof. K. Lafleur of McGill University (Montreal: C. Theoret). This is, it seems, the first attempt made ‘to collect and systematize the rules for solving conflicts of laws de- rivable from our codes, statutes, and juris- prudence.’’ Many circumstances contribute to make the study of the conflict of laws in Quebec specially interesting--among others the fact that the province, while retaining French law as the foundation of its juris- prudence, has not (following the modern French rule) made civil status and the law of persons dependent on nationality, but has, on the contrary, adhered to the rule of the old French law, which is the same as that of the English law—that such ques- tions must be decided with reference to domicile. The volume is a _ convenient handbook, and has a geod collection of CASES. The Weidmann publishing-house of Berlin has commenced a series of translations of Greek tragedies by the well-known profes- sor, Ulrich von Wilamowitz-Moellendorff, of the University of Serlin. These translations have already been published in the learned editions of this scholar, and are here repro- duced in the hope of reaching readers who would not naturally turn to a critical and more costly edition of an Attic tragedian. Besides the translation, which is invariably a masterpiece of literary art, each volume is furnished with an introduction of which it is the highest praise to say that it is cha- racteristic of the author. Taken all in all, these volumes form no inconsiderable con- tribution not only to the literature of the classics, but also to German literature. The tragedies thus far published are the ‘‘Cidi- pus Rex” of Sophocles and the “Hippolytus,”’ “Hercules Furens,’’ and ‘‘Supplices’’ of Bu- ripides. American teachers of the classics, both in secondary schools and in colleges, will find much that is interesting and profitable in Dr. P. Dettweiler’s articles on Latin and Greek instruction (‘“Didaktik und Methodik des griechischen und des lateinischen Unter- richts’’) which originally formed a part of Baumeister’s recent ‘Handbuch der Erzie- hungs- und Unterrichtslehre’ (Munich: Beck), and are now obtainable in separate editions. Dr. Dettweiler, who is an Oberschulrat in Darmstadt, writes from long experience as a teacher, and from thorough knowledge of the extant literature of the subject to which his notes furnish an _ excellent bibliographical guide. The general por- tions of each treatise, dealing with the development, value, and principles of classi- cal instruction, are, of course, of as great value here as in Germany; on the other hand, the particular considerations of teaching in the higher classes of the Gymnasia, while not at once and in toto applicable to our system, contain much that is of very great worth in regard to choice of authors to be read and methods of instruction. Lippincott’s Magazine will,in its July num- ber, make a new departure in outward dress and in collaboration, and announces the sole literary remains of the author of ‘David Ha- rum,’ “a long short-story, entitled “The Teller.’ ” ; In the June number of the Library Jour- nal, Mr. John Thomson, of the Free Library of Philadelphia, reports on his endeavor ‘“‘to procure a hand list of incunabula (limiting the date to books printed prior to 1501) own- ed by colleges, libraries, and private owners in America’’—this by way of contribution to the Gutenberg quincentenary celebration at Mainz. Already, he says, from five sources only he has got track of more than 1,500 volumes. He desires from any possessor of “fifteeners’”’ a description embracing author, full title, date of publication and place (or press), and bibliographical reference (as to Hain or Panzer). In the same number may be found Mr. J. P. Edmond’s account of his simple method of cataloguing fifteenth-cen- tury books. We read in the Florence Nazione that on June 3 the Duchess Bnrichetta Caetani di Sermoneta contributed $5,060 towards thefund for the perpetual Dante lectureship in Fle- rence. This fund, by the resolve of the local executive committee of the Italian Dante So- ciety, had been named for Duke Michelange- lo di Sermoneta of Rome, her late husband, a devoted student of Dante and eminent com- mentator. The Dante Hall in Or San Michele is to be furbished up and restored to its ort- ginal condition by November next; and for the seating of it the Duchess offered 600 lire, and our countryman, Prof. Willard Fiske, 200. The same paper contains the subscrip- tion-list for the scholastic foundation to ce- lebrate the fortieth year of Prof. Pasquale Villari’s ‘‘fecondo e glorioso”’ instruction. The twenty-first annual report of Mr. W. E. Foster of the Providence Public Library dwells largely on the new building now ap- proaching completion. An interesting feature of the work of the year is the establishment of a system of “home libraries,”’ consisting of “‘little cabinets, of attractive design,” filled with good reading, and placed in the needy portions of the city. The decrease in the number of books circulated is amply ac- counted for by the increase of newspaper and periodical reading occasioned by the war with Spain. It is interesting to note that the per- centage of fiction circulated was 60.60, his- tory coming next. The total number of books in the library at the end of the year was 86,235. From the annual report of the Suez Canal Company it appears that the receipts for 1898 were $17,581,200, or nearly.two and a half millions more than the previous year, and the largest on record,-though the number of vessels (3,503 of 9,238,000 tons burden) was slightly less than in 1892, when the ships numbered 3,552. England sent 2,295 vessels, Germany 356, France 221, Holland 193, Aus- tria 85, Italy 74, Turkey 54, Spain 49, Rus- sia 48, Norway 47, Japan 46, Egypt 10, Den- mark 8, America 4 (there were 3 last year), China 4, Portugal 3, Sweden 2, Greece 2, Rumania 1, and Argentina 1. Of the 219,- 000 passengers, a considerable majority were soldiers—English 34,000, Russian 23,000, Tur- kish 23,000, French 14,000, Spanish 10,000, Italian 5,000, and Dutch 3,000—figures of much historical significance. At the last congress of the Sociétés Sa- vantes, the Abbé Marsan read before the historical geography section a paper upon a project for communication between the At- lantic and Pacific Oceans by Nicaragua lake presented in 1785-1786 to Florida-Blanca, Minister of Foreign Affairs to Charles III. of Spain, by Count Louis Hector d2 Ségur, commandant of the castle of Péronne. The route suggested was “‘by the channel of the San Juan and Lakes Nicaragua and Lindiri.” The manuscript of this memoir has been found in the archives of the chateau of Ar- reau. Dr. Horace Howard Furness was given the honorary degree of Doctor in Letters by Cambridge (Eng.) Uniyersity on June 13. The Public Orator, Dr. Sandys, had his word of praise for Dr. Furness’s eminent Shak- sperian labors—‘‘virum et nobis et Britan- norum poetze summo conjunctissimum’’—but also did not forget his father, that sound abo- litionist, the late Rev. William H. Furness, D.D., “rerum divinarum interpretis hu- manissimi, Afrorum libertatis per vitam lon- gam vindicis acerrimi.’’ —A return to the, British Parliament of proceedings in county courts under the Workmen’s Compensation Act of 1897 covers only three ful! months of the law’s activity, but gives some interesting figures. The act provides that the amount of compensation may be settled by agreement, in which case it does not necessarily become a matter of court record. Failing agreement, two forms of arbitration are provided—first, an in- formal arbitration by a single arbitrator chosen by the parties; or, second, a formal arbitration before a county court judge, or an arbitrator appointed by the judge and acting under court rules. The number of cases recorded was 130, of which 104 were settled by the judge’s award, 8 by an arbi-
Page 15
June 29, 1899] The Nation. 497 trators’ award, and 18 by acceptance of money paid into court. The plaintiff won in 101 suits and lost in 29. In 38 cases compen- sation was given on account of death, the average award being £200. There were 53 cases of injury in which a weekly sum was granted—16 for total and 37 for partial inca- ‘pacity. The average sum for partial inca- pacity was 12s. 10d. a week; for total, lis. 4d. “It appears somewhat remarkable that the average payment for total incapacity should be less than that for partial inca- pacity. Probably the explanation is that par- tial incapacity usually means temporary in- capacity, and that, in cases of temporary in- capacity, even where the employer disputes his liability, he does not object, if he pays at all, to pay the full amount allowed under the act, i. e., half wages. On the other hand, the cases of total incapacity include a larger proportion of cases of perma- nent disablement in which a smaller allow- ance than the maximum under the act is awarded.”’ —These figures present a strong contrast to the returns under the Employers’ Liability Act of 1880. Of the $81 cases treated under this act in 1898, 596 were in employments to which the Workmen’s Compensation Act now applies. The average|amount of damages in case of death was, under the act of 1880, only £85 6s., compared with £200 under the act of 1897. Solicitors’ costs under the earlier law averaged £22 14s., and under the later only £11 is. It is known that only a small part of the claims come before the courts, as damages are usually given without ques- tion. If the rate of injury and death in Ger- many held for England and Wales, the num- ber of cases would number at least 120,000, and probably more. Considerably less than one per cent. of the cases, therefore, come before the judge or arbitrator,'and the lar- ger share of those do not arise from a dis- puted payment, but are to settle the question of the person to whom the payment should be made. ‘In some of the largest and most populous industrial districts, where nume- rous accidents must certainly have occurred in the employments coming within the act, not a single litigated case under the new act had, up to the 3ist of December, been taken to the county court and decided, either by the judge or arbitrators. Thus, there was not one case from the mining districts of Durham, Consett, and Bishop Auckland, with a popu- lation of 312,000, nor from South Staffordshire, with a population of 575,000, nor from Ply- mouth and South Devon, with a population of 480,000, nor from Cornwall, with a popula- tion of 314,000. In Bristol, with a population of 355,000, there was only one case, and only two in the circuit which includes Hali- fax, Huddersfield, and Dewsbury, and has a population of 582,000.” -—The contributors to Prof. Petit de Julle- ville’s seventh volume of the ‘Histoire de la Langue et de la Littérature Francaise’ (Paris: Colin) have kept the tacit promise of their work on the eighteenth century by giving, in their treatment of the Romantic period (1800-1850), a very generous attention to writers of clerical and reactionary opi- nions, namely, Chauteaubriand, Joaeph de Maistre—and even Ballanche. Lammenais, Guizot, and Henri Martin hardly come off so well, although their respective writings are fully and fairly analyzed. As regards the principles of the Romantic school in poetry, one is pleased at finding neither violence nor 3 ox in the exposition of them given ere; but many readers will doubtless be urprised at the systematic disparagemeyit bt Hugo's tragedies, which have been cox- emptuously lumped with the work of Dumas ére, and summarily disposed of as “mela- ramas,”’ By following a similar line of az'- ment, it would not be difficult to squeeze Le Cid’ into the same category. Among he novelists, George Sand and Balzac na- urally hold the foremost places. In the ase of the latter, however, certain details f criticism leave something to be desir«d. f the great novelist’s predilection for the uartier Saint-Germain is indicative of:'a mewhat “snobbish” turn of mind (frém hich some of his successors have not né- ained entirely free), is it also true that his ortraits of aristocratic society in the thir- ies are alone wanting in delicacy and tagt? urely, not here only is Balzac’s representa- ion of human character deficient. Much the ost interesting chapters are those devoted o a review of criticism (Emile Faguet), to ithe literary relations between France aad her neighbors (Joseph Texte), and to the nterdependence of letters and art (Sam#el Rocheblave), during the singularly active riod covered by this volume. M. Fagust, treating his subject in more academic style than is his wont, appears at his best in ¢s- timating the value and influence of Sainie- Beuve’s criticism; and in view of the sly underrating which the memory of the inimit- able causeur has of late years experiencad, M. Faguet’s judicious discussion produres the effect of a rehabilitation. The most ae- rious lack of this issue is in the matter, of bibliography, to which but very superficial attention has been given. It is enough: to state that the division on Musset contains no reference whatever to Paul Lindau’s jle- servedly popular monograph. a | —The unsettling of time-honored custoins and old lines of demarcation of educaticgal institutions, in consequence of the _-je- velopment of new domains of knowledge jin- to full-grown sciences, has been experie i everywhere. Just now, the universities and higher technical schools of Germany are an gaged in a serious intellectual boundary dis- pute, which is complicated by such side issues as the graduates’ status in society and the State. The distinction attaching: to ‘tihe Doctor’s title has led the modern hth Hochschule to covet the right to confer this degree, hitherto reserved to the sive alone. If the degree of “doctor of natu sciences” is granted by certain universities, why should not a four years’ course ati a technical Hochschule, followed by ‘a rigorosum and a thesis, lead to a doctor rerum tcchnicarum? Champions of the older institutions do not object to the title, but, they contend, it ought to emanate from|the only genuine source of doctors’ diplorhas, i. ¢., the university. Others, however, hold that the titles of architect, engineer, etc’, if properly guarded by law, would render | the new species of doctor unnecessary. The grave question is under debate, and, to judge by the amount of thought bestowed upon it by the press and other authorities, is in no danger of being settled with unbecoming haste. 1; GORHAM’S STANTON. Life and Public Services of Edwin M. - ton. By George C. Gorham. With r- traits, maps, and facsimiles of im: t letters. 2 vols., 8vo, pp. 456, 50°. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & (o. There has long been a good deal of cu- riosity to know whetler Stanton’s private papers contained much faterial which would throw new light upon the history of the civil! war and the reconstru¢tion period that fol- lowed. The publication of the Life by Mr. Gorham seems to provp that his career was public in a more complete sense than that of most men, and that there were, with him, almost none of those jprivate intimacies in which statesmen take confidential friends behind the scenes and reveal their inmost opinions of the men with whom they are acting, and the hidden; springs of events in which they have a ; The man and his work were one; and may be said to have had very little life tside of his official duties. With this impression, at least, we close these volumes, jn the preparation of which the author is pposed to have had fullest use of whatev private papers Mr. Stanton left. ° This air of complete! absorption impressed all who met bim duriag the years when he was at the head of the War Department. His face rarely changed from the fixed serious- ness, tinged with ness, which was its habitual expression. ‘His eyes gazed ab- stractedly beyond his Visitor, and his words were uttered in a quiet monotone, with very little motion of iips;or facial expression. This might be varied py flashes of intensity or of imperiousness, ‘but almost never by relaxation into ease of manner or the genial trifles of conversation which smooth the flow of public business. Eyen his approval came as a kindof official bengdiction, through which might break at any moment a notice to quit. The portrait in Mr. Gorham’s second volume gives with faithfulness the expression of his countenance habitual in his periods of best health, but it was incensified too often by lines which marked a morbid condition of his nerves, and the look of weariness in the eyes as of those who are overdone by watching. As a lawyer the same quality of intensity had marked his work: making him a vehe- ment advocate who saw his case in the light of partisanship for his client. To take sides and to be militant in doing so was a neces- sity of his nature. It was easy for Lincoln to be judicial and to rid himself absolutely of partiality and predilection; but for Stanton this was not possible—at least not until the heat of the fray had plenty of time to cool. Stanton, although #ftoutly for the Union, had been flerce in his opposition to the Re- publican party, and continued denunciatory of Lincoln and all. his works down to the very day of his own appointment to the War Department. Mr. Gorham says that no man of note had been “more lavish of expressions of dislike for the President himself than had Mr. Stanton.” There seems to be no good reason for doubting that McClellan's asser- tions and illustrations in his ‘Own Story’ regarding the violent contemptuousness of Mr. Stanton’s language in conversations with himself in the fall of 1861, are substantially true. Mr. Gorham makes no effort to ex- plain the incongruousness in the sudden transition from this attitude to that of cor- dial and harmonious work under the Presi- dent. The great desire to be of use to the country is hardly a sufficient solution. As Secretary he must work in strict and con- fidential subordination to Lincoln, while vio- lent repulsion and contempt would destroy the necessary basis of successful codperation. ’ y . i
Page 16
498 The Nation. [Vol. 68, No. 1774 There is evidence that Stanton underwent a conversion scarcely less sudden and striking than the most marked of religious trans- formations. Mr. Lincoln’s biographers agree in stating that a feeling of strong personal dislike had followed the association of Lincoln and Stan- ten as lawyers in the McCormick and Manny reaper case tried in the United States Circuit Court at Cincinnati in 1857. They, with Mr. Harding of Philadelphia, a leading lawyer in patent cases, were coun- sel for Manny. By common consent Mr. Harding was to present the arguments upon the mechanical questions, but, in the ar- rangement of the arguments upon the law, Mr. Lincoln was made to feel that he had been ridden over roughshod by Stanton and discourteously crowded out of his place in the argument. There are differences in the stories as to the details, but Mr. Herndon seems to be conclusive authority for the fact that, on Lincoln’s return home, he felt the ill-treatment keenly. Accident had, be- sides, made him aware of rude personal ex- pressions by Stanton, such as men meeting Lincoin for the first time were apt to use and smart with shame after- ward when they learned what manner of man they had tried to look down upon. As the one in the wrong, Stanton’s dislike naturally became vindictive and even violent when, in so short a time, Lincoln be- came a great figure in the nation and was made President, Stanton opposing with might and main. Mr. Harding, being often in Cincinnati af- ter the civil war, told the sequel to Chan- ning Richards, late the United States At- torney there, who is the authority for it, and an indisputable authority to all who knew him. Harding had been admitted to Mr. Lincoln’s friendship, and the latter knew his chagrin at being in any degree connected with the painful incident. He was in Wash- ington at the time President Lincoln was considering the appointment of a new Sec- retary of War, and, with a tact amounting to genius, Mr. Lincoln made him the mes- senger to Mr. Stanton, to say that he was invited, as an earnest War Democrat, whose ability and honesty were well known, to take the War Department, and give the country confidence in the integrity and intelligence of its vast expenditures and in the unparti- san aims of the Administration in its con- duct. The choice of the messenger made personal explanations superfluous. That Mr. Harding came with the invitation told the story without a word more. Stanton re- ceived it as a man stunned and incredulous. After a long pause, in which the tumult of his feelings could be seen in his face, he broke out, “Do you tell me, Harding, that Mr. Lincoln sent this message to me?” As- sured that it was so,’ with streaming eyes he said, “Tell him that such magnanimity will make me work with him as man was never served!” It goes without saying that so impetuous a nature would become radical in the struggle, once he was committed to it, and that whoever else might complain of arrogance in dealing with him, after such a renewal of relations Mr. Lincoln's leader- ship was easily safe, though it was sure to be kind and considerate. In dealing with Mr. Stanton’s change of at- titude toward General McClellan, Mr. Gor- ham makes a very full analysis of the dispatches and letters which passed between the War Department and the headquarters of the Army of the Potomac. First came the rectification of Stanton’s former sup- porition that there had been niggardliness in supplying the army and in fitting it out for a campaign. Next was the disproof of the General’s imaginary obstacles, and of delays by reason of any hostility to him personally, or desire on the part of President or Con- gress to thwart him. This was inevitably followed by Stanton’s discovery that the con- stitutional irresolution of McClellan was the sole cause of his tardiness in marching against the enemy, prompting him to ex- aggerate the forces opposed to him, and making a vigorously aggressive campaign an impossibility for him. The conviction that the General was a failure as a fleld- commander naturally led such a Secretary to vigorous efforts to remove him from com- mand. The biographer shows that Stanton was quick and ardent in recognition and praise of all who struck hard at the enemy, and was intolerant only of timidity and in- action. McClellan had to take the same judgment as the rest, and the vindication of Lincoln and his Secretary is found in the earnest and unswerving approbation they gave to the officers who were finally de- veloped, and who proved their ability to lead our armies to victory. With Lincoln’s death began a series of complications in our history which showed that the balance-wheel was gone and the engine racing in a way that threatened wreck and ruin. In the treatment of the convention between Generals Sherman and Johnston for the surrender of the Confede- rate armies, Stanton’s impulsiveness ran away with his judgment. It is impossible to think of Mr. Lincoln as permitting the course taken by the Secretary, had he been living. The panic following the assassination and the attempt to murder Mr. Seward also is the best excuse for the total misjudgment of Sherman’s real meaning and of the situa- tion created by the negotiations. It was a matter to be handled delicately and thought- fully, not coarsely and impulsively. Silence and confidential instructions to the General would have brought accord, and saved pub- lic excitement at a time when the calming of the public mind was the plainest dictate of prudence. Yet the manifesto published was of the class which provoke and accom- pany revolutions. Sherman felt it to be a travesty of what he had done, and was made to believe that it was published with intent to destroy his reputation. Mr. Gor- ham, however, writes of it as an advocate holding a brief for Mr. Stanton, and is able to see no flaw in his judgment or conduct. He rings the changes on the General’s “ad- mission of his ‘folly in embracing in a mili- tary convention any civil matters,’’’ when the folly, as Sherman viewed it, was in falling to assume that the politicians would refuse consent to any plan not conceived by themselves. In the very letter quoted, he said, “I still believe the Government of the United States has made a mistake.”’ In like manner, Mr. Gorham’s denial that Stan- ton’s manifesto implied that Sherman was violating known instructions given by Lin- coln to Grant, is contrary to the natural meaning of the document, and that which was, in fact, given it at the time. So, the influence on Sherman of his recent confer- ence with Lincoln himself is ignored, as ie the extraordinary change in circumstances when Johnston declared he had power to surrender at once all the scattered forces of the Confederacy, and prevent that lingering guerilia warfare which had been the great apprehension of our military men when the larger armies should be surrendered. Scarce- ly ingenuous is Mr. Gorham’s use of John Sherman’s letter to Stanton as “testimony that he was sure Mr. Stanton would not allow his brother, the General, to be un- justly dealt with,’”’ when the whole letter was a diplomatic effort to soften Stanton’s antagonism, and was based on his feeling that “gross injustice has been done General Sherman.” The armistice had been expressly made pending the submission of proposals to the Government, and to publish violent condemnation of them at the very momen‘ the rejection was sent, days in advanve of its reaching Sherman, is so gross a~breach of established rules in civilized administration that nothing but an existing panic can palli- ate it, and it was inevitable that Sherman should feel outraged. The only fair treat- ment of the subject at this distance in time is to admit, on the one hand, that Sherman’s sketch of terms was defective and could not be accepted as it stood, and, on the other, that Stanton’s course was under the impulse of undue excitement, and his publication a grave mistake. The same fault of temperament marks the whole of Stanton’s dealings with President Johnson after he had determined to side with Congress in the deplorable quarrel over the reconstruction question. That one of the President’s cabinet should stay in his confi- dential office for the very purpose of thwart- ing the Administration, and should make his knowledge, thus confidentially obtained, the means of drafting a bill to be passed by Con- gress to prevent the President, as Command- er-in-Chief, from directing his generals in their administration of what the bill itself declared to be a military government in the conquered territory, shocks intelligent people now by the mere statement. That the same officer, after condemning the Tenure-of-office Act as unjustifiable invasion of the exe- cutive rights and responsibilities, should himself use its provisions to defy the execu- tive, when his resignation was requested, and afterward his removal announced, is a gross inconsistency accounted for only by the blindness created by passion. Mr. Gorham makes elaborate argument in defence of Stanton, forgetting that those who then ap- proved his action because it furthered their partisan aims learned, with so hot a parti- san as Mr. Blaine, to say at last, “If it had been President Johnson’s good fortune to go down to posterity on this single issue with Congress, he might confidently have antici- pated the verdict of history in his favor.” The quotations which the biographer makes from letters of approval by distinguished men to Mr. Stanton at the time, need to be supplemented by the votes of Congress re- pealing the act almost as soon as Mr. John- son left the President’s chair. Its character as a revolutionary measure was thus confess- ed, and judicious friends of Mr. Stanton wish he had followed the example of Mr. Denni- son, Mr. Speed, and Mr. Harlan, in quietly retiring when they found themselves out of harmony with their chief, as all other cabi- net officers have done before and since. Mr. Stanton’s final official act was as in- consequent as the others of this irrational period of our politics. His party was nearly solid in favor of the impeachment of Mr, Johnson, and was still unanimous in con- demnation of what was uprderstood to be the
Page 17
June 29, 1899] The Nation. A499 Administration policy, That the impeach- ment lacked one vote of a two-thirds majo- rity in the Senate did not affect the existing antagonism between the departments of the government, or the duty (if duty it was) of Mr. Stanton to stick to the War Office as a partisan of Congress. Yet he immediately re- signed, giving as his reason that the failure to impeach was a failure to sustain the for- mer resolution of the Senate that the President had no power to remove him and designate a Secretary ad interim. It is, however, a cu- rious fact that the vote for impeachment was exactly the same as the vote for the resolu- tion against removal, namely, thirty-five. In this latest step, as in the others, the bio- grapher resents with great fulness what was the current party defence of Mr. Stanton at the time, but does not indicate the calmer judgment of the same party, which came with the sober second thought when the in- toxication of partisan) zeal had passed off. Here again Mr. Gorham would have done well to reflect upon Mr. Blaine’s conclusion that “the sober reflection of later years has persuaded many who favored impeachment, that it was not justifiable on the charges made, and that its success would have re- sulted in greater injury to free institutions than Andrew Johnson fn his utmost endeavor was able to inflict.” The true view of Mr. Stanton’s character seems to be, that, with) great intellectual abi- lities and high ideals, his impulsive nature made him exceptionally liable to the mis- takes of intense partisanship. So long as he was under the influence of Lincoln’s calmly practical and eminently sane judgment, his honesty and his great powers made him one of the most useful of public officers; but when left without that leadership, his eccen- tricities led him into many and great errors. Tke two large volumes of this biography come short of being historically valuable be- cause they do not get beyond the limits of the thought and action of the period of poli- tical storm and stress, and give us no help in correcting the misjudgments inseparable from such a time. MARSHALL’S INSTINCT AND REASON. Instinct and Reason, By Henry Rutgers Marsball. The Macmillan Co, 1898. Under this title Mr. all essays to fur- nish us with a psychology of religion. Its last words, printed in| capitals, are, ‘‘Be re- ligious.’”” Why? Because analysis shows it is in the highost degree desirable. Very well; most of us already feel that keenly enough. The difficulty is that the first step towards ‘being religious is te believe; and not only do the minds of most men nowadays not readily believe, but, bad as it is to be de- prived of religion, it is unquestionably still worse to cook up a factitious, unfounded, and consequently unstable belief. True, Mr. Mar- shall persuades us that religion is an in- stinct, and, therefore, not a faith. But, like other instincts, the moment it is broken down in the particular form in which it has taken root in us, it is ept to evaporate alto- gether, or, at any , to retain little vita- lity. Thus, the book, in its practical up- shoi, leaves us just where the majority of thinking men are already. Those who deem religion to be altogether banefui, had better avoid it if they do not want to change their minds. There are not|many sentences in the volume as pro-religigus as the following) which serves at once to illustrate Mr. Mar- hall’s attitude and his way of constructing period: “We note also the existence of a continu- us and partially effective opposition to ra- fonalism by the established Christian urch; an opposition which seemed exceed- gly perverse to the Church’s opponents at he time, which appears extremely repre- ensible to the body of thinkers to-day, but hich, I am convinced, will not seem nearly ill-timed nor so disgraceful to those who k back from the standpoint which will be ttained in the future, however much they deplore, as we all must do, the form Which this opposition took and the methods émployed to attain its ends.” It is certainly true that rationalism has peen slowly declining. Since nineteenth- gqentury science has taught us how truth be- ¢qomes established, since Darwinian ideas fave been applied to the history of mind, gince Hegel’s analysis of self-consciousness has been illustrated in studies of childhood, gnd since the phenomena of sub-conscious ind have become known, the pretensions of dividual reason to solve the great problems ave been at a discount. Yet, after all, it our nature to reason, and we have to ake the best of it. Progress never has ome from the religious spirit, and never ill, as Mr. Marshall acknowledges; so that lhe whole question is how far we are to Ty tionalism, and at what point to check it. r. Marshall’s doctrinaire anti-rationaligm rather amusing, considering that his whole k is rationalism undiluted with one soma ord dictated by authority or prejudice, jor ven instinct, as such. Ali that he con- ributes to the solution of that question |is n argument to show that it is rational ‘to ay great respect to our instincts, especia'ly hose of the broader kinds, We fancy one J.J. ousseau said something like this, without ing looked upon as the champion of un- eason. The author’s method of philosophizing is eartily in the spirit of the times. He re- ies implicitly and utterly upon a line (of bvolutionary argument which may be sound ind is decidedly fashionable. He assumes ‘as unquestionable that every instinct must gubserve, or have formerly subserved, some fsa need, and even sometimes seems o speak as if every tendency to reaction ust benefit, or have benefited, the single pell as well as the whole organism. While ue risks everything on such reasonings, he fnakes considerable general admissions as to he insufficiency of the evolutionary philo- hophy, going in some respects further than vhere was any need of doing. Thus, he grants to Mr. B. I. Gilman that “Darwinism” eaves the whole question of origins un- ouched. Darwinism, in the proper sense of he word, of course does so; but that a pure- y evolutionary philosophy can trace its way rom a starting-point that logically demands ho explanation back of it, is shown by {he instances of Aristotelianism and Hegelign- sm, both of which philosophies are pis lonary and set out (or may set out) from cojn- ete actual indeterminacy. Equally needl d still more important is the confess that the idea of “progress’’ is purely reja- ive to our own ideals. If there be in ga- ure a universal tendency in any definite Bi- rection, no matter what, that universal ten- — will determine ideals; and therefi ny such tendency would be a progress puye- y objective. i For reasons that appear decidedly feeble, Mr. Marshall concludes that there is sorme- thing psychical—in his phrase a ety somewhat'’—to which he gives the name of mentality, in all action whatsoever. The reasons for believing that the rudiments of mind are much more widely distributed than we can positively make them out are strong enough; but to select “action” (whatever that may mean) from among all the objective ele- ments of the universe of phenomena as de- fining the limits of mind, is a very different inference. It may be doubted whether a concept so vague and confused as a ‘psychic somewhat” can be of any service at all in philosophy. It would seem to be the busi- ness of the metaphysician to discriminate be- tween the radically unlike elements of psy- choses, and to find good reasons, as soon as he is able, for identifying these with differ- ent elements of phenomena objectively ob- served. One of the psychic somiewhats would appear to be immediate consciousness, or feeling; but there is little or no reason to opine that this is at all proportionate to the amount of motion of its subject, or to any- thing else of that sort which the word “action” may denote. Consciousness is de- fined by Mr. Marshall as “the fleld of inat- tention.”” We may grant that this remark tis founded on a true psychological observation, without admitting that attention and inat- tention differ otherwise than in degree, or that there is any threshold, or Schwelle, be- tween them. pallroone 6 as a definition of consciousness, the preposition simply re- stricts that word to a particular kind of self- consciousness. Consequently, when the author applies the definition to the criticism of James and others, he simply misses their meaning. Mr. Marshall reposes; too confidently upon what he calls “mental and physical parallel- ism’’—a monistic theory familiar enough in its outlines, though somewhat modified by the author—as against the traditional doc- trine of a soul. To hold to a substantial soul is neither more nor léss than to hold that mind and body really react. Action cannot take place without reaction, even if it can be so conceived, which may be doubted; for what would “action” mean without reaction? Yet the only considerable objections that Mr. Marshall brings against the theory of the soul are, first, that the action cannot be exclusively of mind on matter, and secondly, that it cannot be exclusively of matter on mind. The whole question is one of fact, and must await positive scientific observa- tions for its settlement. Comparing it with other mysteries which have eventually been cleared up in that way—with that of the chemical constitution of the stars, that of the Trojan War, that} of whether diseases are entities, that of méteorites, etc.-we re- mark that in those cases the facts were found to have little regard for the fine nega- tive theories; and the simple idea of a soul seems to be rather more like nature’s ha- bitual answers to experimental questions than is any highly metaphysical hypothesis of mind-stuff and the like. Perhaps we may ultimately find that mind and matter are of the same general natuge, and yet that there is a real mutual reaction between body and soul. : We could not undertake to do justice here to Mr. Marshall's very:elaborate main argu- ment. It seems to be jessential to his posi- tion to maintain a natural classification of instincts into those which conduce to the preservation of the individual, those which go to the propagation of offspring, those which support social ~ and finally religion, which checks the tendency to reason--or to t
Page 18
SOO The Nation. } [Vol. 68, No. 1774 eccentricity, which is much the same thing, from Mr. Marshall’s standpoint. Reason he holds to be conterminous with choice, and as broad as our psychic life, and not at all restricted to the more superficial conscious- ness. Here, of course, he must expect strong dissent. The work concludes with two strong chapters, antagonizing hedonistic and utili- tarian ethics. RATZEL’'S HISTORY OF MANKIND. The History of Mankind. By Prof. Friedrich Ratzel. Translated by A. J. Butler, M.A. With introduction by E. B. Tylor, F.R.S. Colored plates, maps and illustrations. Vol. iii., pp. 599. The Macmillan Co. 1898. In this the concluding volume of a most comprehensive work, we have a descrip- tion of the manners and customs, arts and industries, religion, form of government and personal appearance of the tribes that live in the western and central parts of Africa, together with a short and satisfactory ac- count of “the cultured races of the Old World,”’ under which head are included the Egyptians, Berbers, etc., of Africa and the Mongols, Arabs, etc., of Asia. In a sepa- rate chapter the racial history of the modern Europeans is briefly told. Of course in an investigation of this cha- racter, ranging as it does from people in a low stage of barbarism to those that may be justly termed civilized, all attempts at generalizations except upon the broadest pos- sible lines are futile. Great similarity, no doubt, runs through each one of the several groups, just as it exists everywhere be- tween peoples in the same stage of develop- ment; but the differences in bodily con- formation and in almost every other aspect of life are so numerous and so marked that no seale of progress hitherto invented seems elastic enough to include them all. Even among tribes and nations belonging to the same generic stock, and living in close proximity to each other, apparently upon the same plane of culture, this statement is believed to hold good; and it is this fact which makes it incumbent upon any one en- Kaging in an investigation of the present nature to deal with each people separate- ly and in more or less detail. Such a me- thed of treatment, no doubt, has disad- vantages, in so far as it involves an amount ef repetition that soon becomes wearisome, and yet, on the other hand, it gives pro- mise of greater accuracy, and, when based on competent authorities and accompanied by a suitable index, it makes the work in- valuable for purposes of reference. This fact our author recognizes, and accordingly he has spared no labor in the preparation of a history in which, as people after peo- ple pass before us, we can study their cha- racteristics and note the points jin which they agree or disagree, be it in physique or culture. Naturally enough, in a panorama of this kind, it is the differences that are chiefly in evidence. They are sometimes individual, oftener, perhaps, tribal, but in either event they are not infrequently of such a nature as te call for an explanation; and it is in answer to this demand that our author is led to ascribe them, in part, to the admixture that has everywhere taken place between people who not only lead different lives, but who may belong to different races and be in different stages of development. From the earliest antiquity, and ail along the line of contact between the light and dark races, of “between herdsmen and till- ers of the soil,” as our author more ac- curately describes them, this process has been going on; and so numerous are these crosses, and so varied the elements of which they are composed, that it is probably safe to assert that to-day there is no such thing known as a pure race, or a civiliza- tion untouched by outside influences. In Asia, for example, the southward march of Aryans, Mongols, etc., has made a hotch- potch cf the peoples of India and their culture; while in Africa the Arabs and other Semites, in the course of successive invasions, have left their impress every- where. Even in the heart of the Sudan and among the negroes of the Congo basin, the evidence of this is seen in the spread ef Islam, in the prevalence of certain in- dustries, especially the manufacture of iron, as well as in the agriculture and in the physical peculiarities of different tribes. Only in comparatively recent times and within certain limits has a stop been put to these wholesale irruptions and their long line of consequences. The Mongols, for instance, instead of hanging like a cloud over Eastern Europe, have been so effectual- ly bridled by Russia and China that they are no longer a menace to their neighbors; and in Afriga the same is true of the tribes that have suddenly, and much to their sur- prise, found themselves within the ‘sphere of influence’’ of some European Power. Only in the west-central portion of the continent, and outside of these “spheres,’’ does the progress of the Fulbe warn us of the exist- ence of regions in which the contest still rages much as it has always done. Of the effects of this admixture it is impossible to speak in general terms with any degree of accuracy, for the reason that they are not uniform. The pasto- ral races were not always successful in their invasions; and even when they were, they not only did not always de- stroy the civilization they found in exist- ence, or absorb the people whom they sub- jected, but sometimes, as in the case of Rome, they ended by adopting the civili- zation they are supposed to have destroyed, and were themselves absorbed by the people whom they subdued. Moreover, it is possi- ble that those of us who hold that man is largely the creature of his environment, may ascribe the retrogression that has followed hard upon the irruption of a tribe of no- mads upon their settled neighbors, to natu- ral causes, rather than to the deteriorating effect of any admixture of races. Certainly, if we are to judge from the progress made in southern Spain during the seven or eight centuries that it was under Musiem rule, we should be justified in concluding that the re- lapse into pastoral life in portions of west- ern Asia and northern Africa was due to the destruction of the forests, the exhaustion of the soll, or the drying up of the water supply, quite as much as it was to anything that the Arab may have done or left undone, But enough of such generalizations. They contain nothing new, and our excuse for in- dulging in them is to be found in the fact that they embody, in an indefinite sort of way, conclusions which it would be impos- sible otherwise to set forth without trespass- ing upon the reader’s patience. As a rule, these conclusions may be said to be unob- jectionable, though there are times when they are believed to be premature. Thus, for example, while there can be no doubt of the existence of Semitic influence in Africa from the date of the Hyksos invasion (some 2000 B. Cc.) down to present times, and from the Mediterranean to the southern extremity of the continent, yet it is by no means sure (pp. 161 et seq.) that the earliest Egyptian civili- zation followed that in western Asia, and was borrowed from it. All that can be safely asserted is that the case is still unde- cided. We may also add, though the mat- ter is hardly germane, that the proof of “‘ the derivation of the old American civilizations from Asia,’’ which was to be forthcoming in Ratzel’s second volume, is not satisfactory. Resemblances there are—any number of them —in the manners and customs of the people of the two continents, just as there are be- tween our Indians and the barbarous tribes of Africa, or the people of Great Britain in the time of Cesar; but this does not prove derivation. And if it did, there is no reason why the argument is not as applicable in the one case as in the other, unless the facility of intercommunication via Bering Strait should be taken as the determining factor in the problem. Indeed, it is so re- garded by our author, and if the configura- tion of the earth is the same to-day that it was ages ago, he may be right. It is a bad rule, however, that will not work both ways, and we must not forget that, leaving out of consideration the continent which, it is said, once united Europe, Iceland, and America, there can be no doubt that the Northmen were in Greenland, and, in all probability, upon the mainland of North America, some hundreds of years before “Columbus sailed the waters blue.” In conclusion, there are one or two con- siderations that have such a direct bearing upon the political conditions prevailing in our country to-day,that we bespeak for them careful attention. And, first of all, we have the statement, p. 558, based upon an investi- gation into the origin and distribution of the Aryan races, that “the fair Aryans,” from whom we are graciously supposed to have “descended, ‘do not acclimatize them- selves in hot countries.’’ This, it is said, is the ‘“‘teaching of history’’; it is endorsed by one who speaks with authority, and while it is not new, it contains a truth which should “give us pause” before we are enticed: any further in a career that not only leads to the extension of our rule over tropi¢al re- gions, but includes the assimilation, benevo- lent or otherwise, of alien races. Turning now to the ever present negro problem, we are told (i., p. 18) that it would be possible to forecast “‘the effect of culture u race distinctions if we could say to-day, with approximate certainty, what will , in the course of generations, of the 12,000,000 of negro slaves who have within the last thirty years been freed in America, and who will, in the enjoyment of freedom the most modern acquisitions of culture, have multiplied to 100,000,000."" Of the probability of such an increase there cannot, we i e, be much doubt in view of the statem (ii., p. 326) that ‘“‘their numbers in No Ame- rica increase faster than those of most prosperous white population.” Moreover, it is borne out by the fact that (ii., p. 257) “whole islands, as San Domingo Ja- maica, have fallen to the share of the ne- groes; several States of the Union, weil as Nicaragua, show negro majorities, and in )Brazil all. classes are permeated by ne- ‘gro element.’*' To some of us this
Page 19
} i | j | June 29, 1899], The Nation poor eerie OE 501 is not very encouraging, and yet, in spite of it, and of the “harm|that has resulted, and is still, no doubt, in|a yet greater measure in reserve for future ages, owing to the pre- sence of 8,000,000 of |negroes in the United States,” our author hopeful, for the rea- son that experience shown that ‘culture is not injurious to the negroes,” and be- cause ‘they have not wholly unlearned the work which they d learnt.” Regarded from an economic point of view, this opi- nion is well founded,| for it is admitted (ii., p. 322) that “the Southern States, in which those 'wko were formerly slaves form 50 per cent. of the inhahitants,’’ have been less injured than was feayed by the abolition of this our author does not venture in his effort to forecast the fu- ture; and we are accordingly left .with the political portion of the problem unsolved, unless; perchance, th@ story, as here told, of the Turks (p.552) in Europe,the Arabs (vols. ii. and iii. passim) i sians and Chinese ( in Asia, should be that they have not ful t in we appear . a way| by which a h can made to live political equality. Africa, and the Rus- ii., pp. 150, etc., etc.) ken as an indication mn any more success- have been in finding her and a lower race together upon terms of Longinus on the Sublime. By W. Rhys Ro- berts. Cambridge ( g.): University Press; New! York: Macmillan. 1899. The author of the tract “On the Sublime” is, in a sense, the Matthew Arnold of Greek Literature. Matthew Arnold, however, lived in a period that was masterpieces of Eng ingularly productive of lish, and as he wrote for an audience that was eager to appreciate and echo his definitions, he could seldom sin- cerely pose as one crying aloud in the desert. “When I reflect on the age in which Longinus lived,” wro nal,’ ‘fan age which te Gibbon in his ‘Jour- produced scarcely any other writer worthy of the attention of pos- terity;| when real learning was almost extinct, philosophy sunk down to the quibbles of grammarians and the ty, I heart amazed that f Syria, and at tricks of mountebanks, at such a period, in the the court of an East- and “ Empire desojated by every calami- ern monarch, Longipus should produce a work worthy of the best and freest days of Athens.” Tt was not till nea this entry that the t the treatise to Longi by scholars. Ina 1 whith MSS. attributed the } ginus, was mortified Italian indicated “Dionysius author. Last of ali i ly half a century after itional ascription of was fairly challenged 8 the learned world, had taken for granted that all the book to Dionysius Lon- by the discovery by the scholar Amati that a Vatican MS. or Longinus”’ as the t was found that a MS. at Florence had th@ frank title ‘“Anony- mous.’? ments, slender weight one Without entering into the argu- which are chiefly negative and of way or the other, we msy sum up the controversy by saying that the q was tion at issue is whether the work tten by a aaa writer, pre- sumably Longinus, or by a first-century cri- tic o Dion: the Augusta period, possibly one iberts has stated both rness, and leaves the ty that must darken nus does not depend historical interest, on a fninister of Zenobia, the Queen of pis city, Palmyra, her instructor in Greek ls- ters, and her chief adviser in the heroic Fe- sistance she made to the Emperor Aureligh. Aurelian, when he took Palmyra, put h- inus to death. Longinus is known to hgye a an excellent critic, and we have some fragments of his writings—hardly enough, however, to make a comparison with the present treatise of much value for the qubs- tion of authorship. But Longinus owes true lustre to the long-undisputed autho ' ip of the work “On the Sublime,” and, unless mew evidence comes to back his claims, a ge- neration hence, when the modern phrase ‘auctor mepi ious” shall have completely ousted the old title, the name and repute of Longinus will have very slight significance for literature. For the sake of brevity, we shall ourselves refer here to the author of the treatise under his traditional name. The English word “sublime” is, of course, a wholly inadequate rendering of the Greek spos. It is to be regretted that Mr. Roberts did not take the opportunity of this new and important edition to introduce a more satisfactory rendering. “Ywos is easier to de- iscribe than to define, and probably there is no single English word that would repro- duce it. John Hall’s seventeenth-century translation was entitled “Of the Height of loquence,”’ which comes nearer the original han the unhappy “Gallicism,” as Dr. John- m would have called it, now in use. But perhaps there is no phrase current in modern criticism that so nearly represents Longi- nus’s idea of the word iyos as Matthew Arnold’s “the grand style.”” For both critics, the secret of a grand or elevated style is ethical; in both, the study of literature is ‘closely allied to the study of morals. “What fact,”” wrote Longinus, “was before the eyes of those superhuman writers who, aiming at everything that was highest in composition, contemned an all-pervading ac- curacy? This besides many other things, that Nature has appointed us men to be no base nor ignoble animals; but when she ush- ers us into life and into the vast universe as into some great assembly, to be, as it were, spectators of the mighty whole and jthe keenest aspirants for honour, forthwith she implants in our souls the unconquerable ‘love of whatever is elevated and more di- ivine than we.” “Yyos is, in short, the “high seriousness that comes from absolute sincerity.” As Matthew Arnold relied on illustration ra- ther than on definition to convey his idea of a “tonic’’ passage, so Longinus, with the un- erring good taste that has made his criti- cisms of permanent value, illustrates his maxims from the whole range of Greek li- terature. He was a Greco-Roman sophist in the technical sense, but he never yielded to the Sophistic weakness of treating of minor and inferior authors on the same plane as the heroes of poetry. Like a nineteenth- century critic encouraging a reaction against the eighteenth-century manner, Longinus in- sists that the faultless productions of a Lysias or of an Alexandrian poet are not to be preferred to the work of a truly great writer like Homer whom it is possible to catch nodding. Greek literature in its decadence produced two critics of importance, Dionysius of Hali- carnassus and Longinus. The latter ranks with Plato and Aristotle as the third of the three greatest critics of Greece. Longinus has not the rigidly analytical spirit of Aris- totle; he is a critic of the intuitive type of He was that famous Plato, with an enthusiasm that was troubled i by no philosophical arriére pensdée. He has the enormous advantage over his predeces- sors of not being confined to a single litera- ture. We possess only » third of his treatise; but no century, from ithe earliest times to the beginning of our bora, is unrepresented in his quotations. Te is a catholic taste that can draw on Sappho, Moses, and Ci- c-ro in a breath. After illustrating from Ii- ferature the loftiest expressions of the divi- nity of the gods, Longinus adds: “Similarly, the legislator of the Jaws, no ordinary man, having formed and expressed a worthy con- ception of the might of the godhead, writes at the very beginning of his laws, ‘God said’ —what? ‘Let there be light, and there was light; let there be land, and there was land.’"" Mommsen, who thought that the treatise was written in the early days of the Empire by an unknown author, was led by this passage to suggest that he was a Hel- lenized Jew. Here is a Greek critic, then, who has some acquaintance with Latin, and even with Hebrew literature. We owe to his wide range of quotation several passages from Greek literature that are nowhere else pre- served, and, most impprtant of all, that fa- mous ode of Sappho—"‘not one passion but a congress of passipns’’—which Catullus translated. As Mr. Roberts points out, Lon- ginus has not given js any of those great classical definitions that light up the ‘Poetics’ of Aristotle, yet if we had to judge of all the glory that was Greek literature from only one or the other, it is the enthusiast Longinus from whom we should gain the clearer and wider confeption. The treatise has been much neglected by English editors. Mr.| Havell’s translation, published in 1890, did much to encourage the study of Longin S among general stu- dents of the history of criticism. Mr. Ro- berts has now given us a critical edition of the text with a parallel translation, a valu- able introduction and; appéndices, which, if they do not embody any new matter, present with admirable clearpess all the previous work done on the essay. We wish he had included the fragments of the historical Longinus for the convenience of those who wish to compare the styles. The post-classi- cal Greek of Longinus has no great beauty to lose in translation;-a fact which greatly simplifies the translator's task. Mr. Roberts's version is in excellent English, and, gene- raily speaking, his remderings of the quota- tions are good; it is upfortunate that, of all the bad translations of the Sappho ode, he should have chosen that of the late John Ad- dington Symonds; he ‘might, however, have taken Gladstone's, whizh is one degree worse. H A Literary History of Ireland from the Ear- liest Times to the Piesent Day. By Doug- las Hyde, LL.D., M.R.I1.A. London: T. Fisher Unwin; New |York: Scribners. 1899. Pp. xviii, 654. After all that has m said and done, there are fewless sentimenta} peopie than the Irish. There are few more inclined to mauvaise honte, more apt to be movediby the sneers of those above them; few less; disposed to let a ray of sentiment (on all hut the religious ques- tion) stand in the way of their individual progress. They ed through the penal and ascendancy 4d sufficient national peculiarities in la e, dress, and music through which to exhfbit distinctive national traits and customs asi honorable as those so jealously guarded by Seotch and Welsh. { | |
Page 20
The Nation. 5OR Their object has been to obliterate rather than to conserve distinctive national life, and of late years Irishmen have had to deplore the peasantry beating their children who lisped Irish in districts to which came Con- tinental savanta to study the Irish branch, purest preserved and philologically most im- portant of the tongue once common over Western Europe and the British Isles. In 1825 a German who travelled in Ireland cal- culated that out of a population of seven mil- lions, four millions spoke Irish “als ihre Muttersprache.” The census of 1891 show- ed that while 750,000 were still bilingual, but 66,000 spoke Irish only. There has of late years been a vigorous effort, likely to be at- tended with some measure of success, to pre- serve and extend the use of Irish, not to the exclusion of English, but as educational and enlightening, tending to self-respect and breadth of mind among the Irish people. Dr. Hyde, fully qualified as a scholar and philologist, has been foremost in this move- ment. In the work before us we have the outcome of his deeper studies in the history of the language and its literature. The last chapter is an appeal for its preservation as a spoken tongue. The appearance of this book has been long looked forward to. In breadth of view and erudition anticipations have been justified. The style is, however, somewhat ponderous. While no collection of books relating to Ireland will be complete without it, it will be kept rather for refer- ence than for reading. Most of the old cy- cles of story related are familiar to those conversant with the subject and who are like- ly to purchase the book. For such they might have been curtailed. For those fresh to the subject they are not made sufficiently inte- resting. Dr. Hyde has not Dr. Joyce’s fa- culty for popularizing knowledge on Gaelic subjects. This does not, however, take from the great and essential value of the book. We only regret that our space will not permit of a full exposition of the contents. Dr. Hyde cites the authority of German and French scholars for the belief that there are still in existence 133 Irish MSS. copied before 1600, and that the total literature produced by the Irish before the seventeenth century and still existing would fill 1,000 octavo vol- umes. There is in the Royal Irish Academy alone a large body of MS. “pieces,” from quatrains to long poems and epic sagas. Dr. Hyde refers to the correspondence of genea- logies and thecorrect noting of eclipses: ‘‘The Annais of Ulster, annals which treat of Ire- land and Irish history from about the year 444, but of which the written copy dates only from the fifteenth century, contain from the _ year 496 to 884 as many as eighteen records of eclipses and comets which agree exact- ly, even to the day and hour, with the cal- culations of modern astronomers.” Again: “‘We may, then, take it, without any credu- lity on our part, that Irish history as drawn from native sources may be very well relied upon from about the middle of the fourth century.” The Irish alphabet, still in use, was no doubt borrowed from the Romanized Britons. The general use of letters is to be attributed to the early Christian missionaries. Ogham is essentially an Irish system of writing to be found only where Irish settlements or Irish influence extended. Some of the Ogham pillars “are gravestones of peo- ple who died so late as the year 600, but what proportion of them, if any, date from before the Christian era, it is yet impossible to tell.’"” We have no specimens of Irish manuscript written in Irish before the eighth century; we have Latin probably of the fifth or sixth. The extent to which the Irish people, up to the catastrophe of the famine, and before the anti-Gaelic influence of the Government schools had worked, and even since and still, have preserved a taste for and recollection of the old literature, bears out Dr. Hyde’s insistence concerning the extent of literary culture among the native Irish. Concerning the effective bene- ficial influence of that literature and of the great Irish schools upon national. apart from individual character we retain our doubts. After ail the bombast and glories of the ancient Sagas, Ireland was helpless to pre- vent the Danish and Norman invasions. She cherished no national ideal. The contests between the heroes and the clans of Ulster and Leinster and Meath and Connaught and Munster that form the staple of so much of Dr. Hyde’s narratives, are sickeningly repro- duced in the factions and rivalries of the present day. Literary interest there is, but circumscribed. Large admission is made by Dr. Hyde when, discussing the curious and involved Irish metres, concerning which he gives us so much interesting information, he says: “This may help to place mucb of our poetry in another light, for its beauty depends less upon the intrinsic substance of the thought than the external elegance of the framework.”’ To all but a comparatively nar- row circle, ancient Irish poetry can be known but through translations. If through such, that is lost upon which its beauty mainly de- pends, it cannot be expected that it will arouse much general enthusiasm. Seeing that Dr. Hyde appreciates the Irish alphabet as a “peculiarly beautiful’ modi- fication of the Roman, he gives no reason for not using it in this volume. The language is difficult enough of pronunciation in its own dress—doubly so in the cumbrousness of Roman lettering. The peculiar pronuncia- tion of the dotted consonants in Irish is not fully expressed by the alternative addition, where Roman letters are used, of the letter h after the consonant. This valuable work is the outcome of Dr. Hyde’s enthusiasm for the preservation’ of Irish as a spoken lan- guage. We do not understand why in its pages he thinks well to present it to his readers in foreign garb. The dominant thought with which we lay aside this ‘Literary History’ is of the solace which native literature and song must have been to the Irish through ages when bereft of almost everything else. Bibliography of Highteenth-Century Art and Illustrated Books: Being a Guide to Collec- tors of Illustrated Works in English and French of the Period. By J. Lewine. With thirty-five plates giving specimens of the work of the artists of the time. London: Sampson Low, Marston & Co.; New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons. $25.00. The title of this book is to be understood as the bibliography of art books and il- lustrated books. It would not be strictly ac- curate to say that it is a bibliography of eighteenth-century art, in view of the fact that it does not deal with books which treat of that art. Where no mention is made of the very numerous French writers of our own timo who have devoted themselves largely to elucidating the art of the eighteenth century, the title should, perhaps, suggest as much. [Vol 68, No. 1774 Even if it did offer such suggestion, it be hard to understand the phrases of the|pre- face. It appears that our author thinks |that vogue and so deservedly coveted by the teur.”” There is one book devoted to “ students of that important and c branch of art are unanimous in praise. book is Henry Cohen’s ‘Guide de ]’Amateur,’ which, whether in its fourth edition, now fifteen years old, or in its fifth edition as revised and enlarged by Baron Portalis, is as useful and as satisfactory as a book of the kind can be. This one bibliography covers nearly all the French half (which is lly more than half) of Mr. Lewine’s work, and to this has been added a very great number of monographs on different artists, also the French school, together with the eral treatises of the brothers De Goncourt, ¢ele- brated for their thoroughness and their ¢om- plete presentation of the subject. The biblio- graphy by Cohen and Portalis is devot strictly to books with illustrations Mr. Lewine’s; and, as suggested above, was little for the English author to to copy or restate what was contained in; but the other works referred to adorner of palaces and churches, as well as the beautifier of books. On the other hand, the English compiler has gone a little farther afield than have the Frenchmen in that he has added to his list certain books which could not peoperiy be called livres d vignette, namely, such as! cér- tain collections of costumes, and a book on garden architecture, which, though books on kindred subjects are certainly included in Cohen and Portalis, are not to be found there. Still, it is for the English part of the collection that one will eagerly buy the present volume. There were very few books published in England and illustrated in the dainty French way with prints from (@eli- cately engraved plates, but there were the vigorous caricatures of Rowlandson and the realistic grotesques of Hogarth. There were the half-English publications known der the name of Count Hamilton. There were numberless volumes with a portrait or| two in each, and there were the archzological books which, from the beginning of} the century to its close, were produced in g- land in some abundance. It would be in- teresting task to make a classified list of the different subjects covered by the ks named in this volume. One would be |glad to know how many were French and | how many English, how many are ill held together by a thread of commo: eation, as in the numerous “Galleri many are books of archsological study. maker of such a list will be amused different departments which he has to for himself, and into which his list be divided. It was a surprise, when heading “Songs,” beginning at the: that page, was carried on and. contin repeated for three pages more. actually forty separate titles of song- all illustrated sufficiently to become the
Page 21
| 4 | June 29, 1899] The Nation. 508 | i | jects of Mr. Lewine’s studies. Our student will find, also, in this book about English and French books some. works which are neither English nor French, such as Treitz- saurwein’s ‘Weis Kunig,’ which seems to be entered in its original form because there was to be entered a French issue of it, and Gessner’s writings in five volumes, needed apparently for the same reason. The eighteenth century deserves especial attention from those who would know how much of good and valuable art is possible to times which are admittedly less strenuous, less significant, less in earnest about their fine art. The exact value of such art as that of Watteau and that of Reynolds, when compared with the more serious and, there- fore, greater art of earlier times, is dif- ficult to fix even in one’s mind; and of pro- portionate difficulty is the appraisement of the minor arts of the same epoch—the prints in these illustrated books, as well as the delicately modelled and exquisitely chased metal work of ornamental design, and the charming paintings above door, window, and mantel. The curious; mixture of reality and stagey affectation which marks the figure- drawing of the period, and the defects in the drawing itself—jnot so much defects in knowledge as jn care and _ serious purpose, and mingled with a_ singular dexterity and swifthess of execution—all this is worthy of the most serious obser- vation of the student of fine art, and the explanation of it is Ta task for the wisest and most perspicacigus critic. The books we already have, have opened up the French side of this art very |thoroughly and admir- ably, and we have tp expect more and yet more of the present generation of students; but the English side] of it has hardly been done as yet; so far ap that is concerned, the statements of Mr. LeWwine’s preface are cor- rect. Voloanoes : Their Structure and Significance. By T. G. Bonney,| D.Sc., LL.D., F.R.S., Professor of Geolagy at University Col- lege, London. G. FP. Putnam’s Sons. 1899. 8vo, |pp. xiv, 332. Volcanoes were phe ena to be at among the first natural antively observed by ci- vi man. The e ence of Vesuvius, Vul- cano, iand other ve or extinct eruptive centres in the midst of the Roman Empire led to continuous and minute observations upon many characteristics| of volcanoes. Nume- have been written of volcanic activi- ng the problems ag a itself upon Prof. Bonney, the author the work now before us, for in his preface e remarks: ‘Were it not that Nature some- times supplies new materials, there would be little excuse for another book on Volcanoes.” It seems, then, perfectly fair to examine his ibook upon this basis. The plan of it, as expressed in its chapter headings, sounds very fair, and seems to pro- mise a well-thought-out scheme for the pre- sentation of the subject. “The Life History of Volcanoes,” “‘The Dissection of Volca- jnoes,” and the like, convey the idea of a very systematic treatment of the materials, but examination proves that the system is not followed out to any great extent. The book is very largely a compilation of long quota- tions, descriptive of certain volcanoes, and thrown together without much regard for the scheme of its table of contents. In the first chapter, on the Life History, we find presented sketches of various kinds of volcanoes, with bits of the history of many vents; and, altogether, the reader will -gain some idea of what is considered the normal sequence of events about a volcanic centre, but it will be in spite of, rather than owing to, the order of presentation. Under the “Dissection of Volcanoes” one encounters a jumble of descriptions of volcanic mountains in all stages of decay. A long discussion of crater lakes appears here, and shorter ones of fissure eruptions and laccolithic intrusions. It is much more the internal structure of vol- canoes than the dissection which is dwelt upon in this chapter. It is, no doubt, a diffi- cult task to explain the chemical and mine- ralogical classification of igneous rocks to a lay reader, but no good can result from at- tempts to make the matter simple by mis- statement. Prof. Bonney gives a crude ex- planation of some of the principal rock groups omitting others equally important—and then indicates thenomenclatureof each group after this style: ‘Then the holocrystalline forms are called Diorite; the semicrystalline, Porphyrite; the glassy, Andesite.” It is true that he explains that he does not use these adjectives in their natural sense and as they are used by petrographers, but he leaves it yery obscure what he does wish to express. The description of the structural forms of Ia- vas, including all their physical aspects, is elear and comprehensive. The chapter on ‘“‘The Geological History of Volcanoes” is not a general discussion of the subject indicated, put a kind of abstract of the works of Sir Archibald Geikie and Prof. Judd upon the extinct volcanoes of Great Britain, with many points concerning which there is still a marked difference of opinion. In the following chapter, on ‘The Distribution of Volcanoes,”’ there is a brief statement in regard to the active or not } extinct volcanoes of the world, outside of Great Britain. This enumeration and con- cise characterization of known volcanoes) is one of the most valuable portions of the book. | The final chapter, on ‘The Theories of Volcanoes,” vividly illustrates the difficulty of analyzing such an abstruse subject for the untechnical reader when it must be admitted at every turn that we are ignorant as | to essential facts, and have but little basis. ‘or assumptions. The conclusion reached is/ Hee one familiar from earlier summaries, that o- understand the physics and the chemistry surface volcanic phenomena fairly well, | have little real knowledge of the 4 a causes of volcanic action, including the gin of the magma and the force propelling it to the surface. j It seems, then, that ‘Prof. Bonney‘s treat- ment of the older materials is not conspicu- ously successful. He has rearranged the descriptions of many Well-known volcanoes to be found in earlier |treatises, but without much reference to the apparent plan of his own work. As to the few materials supplied . him by nature, it is probable that the greater number of those who! take up this volume will already have read the same or much fuller accounts of Krakatoa, Bandaisan, etc.; at least that is true of America’s readers. The style of the work seems somewhat open to criticism. The attempt to popularize leads in many places to a rather colloquial form, often mistakenly thought to be the same thing as simpli¢ity and directness of statement. The latter: is far more difficult, and correspondingly more effective, as a rule. History of the World: From the Earliest Historical Time to the Year 1898. By Edgar Sanderson, M.A. With Maps. (The Concise Knowledge Library.) D. Appleton & Co. 1898. A publisher’s note ¢oncerning the Ameri- can edition of this book faces the title- page, and in it attention is called to the fact that Mr. Sanderson's ‘History of the World,’ as prepared for the United States, reaches the close of!the war with Spain. This apparently incidental statement may be used to bring out! the character of the volume. A history of the Spanish war, using that term in any proper sense, cannot yet be written, but much knowledge about the late contest is easily available, and that is all which is required for the purposes of the present series. {ndeed, had Mr. San- derson written his account of the Pelo- ponnesian War in 404 B. c., or his account of the Lutheran Refprmation in 1546, his pages on those subjects might well have borne a strong resemblance to the ones which we have just been reading. His comments and deductions would have been somewhat different, but the proportion of these to hard relentless facts is so small that the general appearance of the work would not have been profoundly affected thereby. Comparing Mr. Sandersou’s outlines of universal history with other similar sketch- es which have recently appeared, we find its chief value in the portions relating to the obscurer regions of: the world—to those, we mean, which hgve had a relatively small share in the progress of civilization, and are, ‘therefore, passed over by most writers as too insignificant for mention. Thus, for instance,'in the case of the ancient world, Lydia, Phrygia, and Bactria appear; and in that jot the modern, Siam, Burmab, the Sudan, Abyssinia, Central America, and A Roughly speak- ing, a fifth of the tents is occupied with information which, , besides being ordi- narily omitted from; manuals, is likely to render intelligent readers of the newspa- pers direct assistancp. On the whole, Mr. Sanderson has mad hie choice of topics judiciously, and shows that he has a com- petent store of historical information. There are a few standard authors to whom he is rather amusingly indebted, for example, Macaulay and Bryce., Besides quoting from and referring to them often, he more than once paraphrases thhir words without ex-
Page 22
5OA : The Nation. [Vol. 68, No. 1 press recognition, ¢. g., from Macaulay on p. 431, and from Bryce on p. 214. In one or two other respects he is decidedly amus- ing. What the sentences are like in which he gives the modern student mnemonic assistance by coupling some matter of con- temporary note with an ancient fact or circumstance, may be gathered from the following illustrations: P. 209, “‘A seven days’ desperate battle at the place; north of Cadiz, called Xeres de la Frontera, fa- miliar to us from the district’s wine called ‘sherry,’ ended in the total defeat of the Goths.” P. 332, “We must now relate the origin of one of the most flourishing minor states of the world, the Swiss republic, which, in the nineteenth century, became a chief resort for European and American tourists and derives therefrom a large in- crease of wealth for her people.’’ Another diverting feature is the shower of adjec- tives which, doubtiess for the sake of con- ciseness,. Mr. Sanderson lets fall upon rulers and other great personages, e. g., p. 476, “The worthless, witty, clever Charles II. reigned from 1660-1685."" And facing this, at the beginning of the next paragraph, p. 477, “James IT. (1685-1688), cruel, faithless, stupid, hard-hearted despot as he was, had a short term of power, according to the prediction of his shrewd brother Charles.’ Finally, we doubt whether such an ex-parte statement as the following is appropriate in a “concise knowledge’’ series. Referring to the Anglo-Russian difficulty of 1885 in Afghanistan, Mr. Sanderson says: “The act was a deliberate insult to Great Britain, and should have been followed by an immediate declaration of war. Mr. Gladstone, how- ever, was Prime Minister, and Lord Gren- ville was Foreign Secretary, and the mat- ter was settled by ‘explanations.’ ” Some slips must always occur in an ex- tensive work of reference, and we have noted a considerable number here, though not enough, by any means, to fix ‘a stigma of incorrectness upon the whole narrative, We mention some of them partly because they are typical and partly that they may be placed upon the list of corrigenda. P. 168: The impression is conveyed that Decius de- cisively repelled the Goths. On the con- trary, he was slain in the battle of Forum Treborrii, where the Goths overwhelmed his legions. P. 182: Pope Leo the Great had not been concerned in meeting any Vandal in- vasion before 449. P. 183: The leader of the Franks to whom Pope Gregory III. appealed against the Lombards was Charles Martel, not Pepin the Short. P. 190: Clovis’s vic- tory over the Alamanni (Ziilpich) was fought near Strassburg, not Cologne. P. 217: Ro- ger Guiscard, rather than Robert, should be credited +:.th achievements in Sicily against the Saracens. P. 245: Besides some doubt- ful statements regarding the early condition of Florence, the minting of the florin is as- eribed to the eleventh century instead of to 1252. P. 274: 1166 is not the date of Strong- bow's first victories in Ireland. P. 279: The essence of the communes (Cambrai, Beau- vais, Noyon, etc.) is missed in the sentence, ‘Former serfs who had been hereditary own- ers of portions of land had, in like manner, organized communes or parishes."” P. 289: It is implied wrongly that in 1158 Milan yielded to Barbarossa without a struggle. P. 296: The Cathedral of Florence was not a Medicean work. P. 330: There is no good evi- dence to show that the Emperor Henry VII. was poisoned in 1313, although the assertion is often repeated on weak authority. P. 334: The battle of Nafels was fought in canton Glarus, not Schwyz. P. 424: The notice of St. Bartholomew hardly represents the best recent investigations. P. 623: Admiral Jarvis was not “victor over the French” in the battle of Cape St. Vincent. P. 720: The first Canadian printing-press was established in 1759, not 1764. Despite these strictures, we must term Mr. Sanderson’s book a useful, we in the main a very correct, one. Under the African Sun: A Description of Native Races in Uganda, Sporting Adven- tures, and Other Experiences. By W. J. Ansorge. With 134 illustrations from pho- tographs by the author, and two colored plates. Longmans, Green & Co. 1899. 8vo, pp. xiv, 355. Uganda is the most interesting of tropi- eal African countries. Its unique position makes it the true heart of the continent. Situated at the sources of the Nile, exactly half way between the Cape and the Medi- terranean and the proposed meeting-point of the Nile and Bechuana railways, it is in close touch with the Indian Ocean by a rail- way nearly completed. Before another de- cade closes, it may be in direct communica- tion with the Atlantic by a railway bridging the two or three hundred miles to the navi- gable waters of the Congo. Though appa- rently possessed of no mineral wealth, its soil is extraordinarily fertile—cotton and sugar growing wild—and it has an equa- ble climate in whieh neither the heat nor the cold is excessive. The inhabi- tants, more than any other pure ne- groes, resemble the Japanese in their in- telligence and their feudal form of govern- ment, while their eagerness to learn is shown by their nascent literature and native press. Their strength of character and self- reliance are attested by their history since Stanley’s memorable visit in 1875; and though wars, religious persecutions, and re- bellions have devastated the led and re- duced its population, yet now it is confi- dently hoped that an era of peace and pros- perity has dawned, and that there is an ap- proaching near fulfilment of the prophecy that Uganda will become a second India. The author of this latest contribution to the literature of the country, as Government medical officer during the last four years, was stationed in different parts of the Pro- tectorate, thereby gaining an exceptional knowledge of the country and the people. His book is not a connected narrative, but a serigs of detached sketches and descriptions of incidents and personal experiences with men|and beasts. It seems almost as if Dr. Ansorge had first arranged his pictures ac- cording to subjects, and then in writing fol- lowed their suggestions. There is an ad- van in this method in that each picture becomes individual and significant, and the impression of much which is described in the |text is heightened. Beginning with Zanzibar and the caravan road to the lake, our jauthor tells something of each district throligh which he passed or in which he was stationed, and of the different tribes with} which he had dealings, closing with stories of his hunting adventures with big game, and brief accounts of some of the smaller mammals, reptiles, and insects. His most) enjoyable station, if not the most in- ng, was at Fovira on the Nile, where, amid lovely scenery, surrounded by id and peaceable natives, he led an almost idyllic life. Far different were his experi- ences at another post at the outbr the Sudanese mutiny. Fortunately his |men remained loyal, not, however, without ing some alarming demonstrations. He mends the Sudanese for their soldierly q ties of obedience and courage, and for excellent service up to this time in guarding the frontiers of the Protectorate. Of intelligence he gives this illustration: “The men have to be their own tailors, and it is astonishing what neat white juni- forms they can produce. The thread |they obtain by unravelling a long, narrow strip of ‘americani’ cotton-cloth, or, more jeco- nomically, by spinning it for themselves out of cotton from the nearest cotton plant” He tells little of the deplorable, been granted to meet Government exp ture, and that the British nation has a er hold than ever of the Uganda Prot¢cto- rate.” Dr. Ansorge is an interested and careful observer, and scattered through his bpoks are numerous descriptions, illustrated |fre- quently by well-chosen pictures, . of charac- teristic native types, saioms, and dwell- ings. These diffe:Womet!mes in an extragrdi- nary and inexplicable way: for instance, the traveller passes immediately from the absolutely nude savages in Kavirondo into Usoga, ‘“‘where not even the youngest walk about uncovered.”” The children show at a very early age an intelligence and capacity which seem of great promise for the ultimate elevation of the race. On the northwest shore of Lake Albert, among the , & magnificent black bull, becoming excited, put a whole village, including Dr. Ansorge’s followers, to flight, and was on the point of charging him: “Fortunately some one had hurriedly jse for the bull's keeper, a .ix-year-old n little urchin. He came on the scene, before the bull was aware—switch!—ga long lithe reed wand. The effect was m cal. The bull became most humble, . laughter of the hundreds. who, a few min before, had fled eet oke in every rection.” people. On the Nile and on the wes shore of Lake Albert, the iatter were sweet-potato crops that there was a of food. “In such a struggle for existe he says, ‘“‘the hippo is locally extermi description of his various collections by {é ferent authorities inserted at the end o:
Page 23
June 29, 1899] Hf The min BOOKS OF |THE WEEK. Ba 8. W. Graded Work and Arithme.'c. Fifth Book. American Book/ Co. The Strong Arm. Frederick A. Stokes Barr, R. Bayer, C. J. Studies of Life and its Variations. 8. Sein vie vulseaing Oo, $1.25. n Tennyson es ee, L. Ridan the Devil, and cee tories. oor on: T. Netaacnes Unwin; ‘Philadelphia: Lippin- Bosanquet, B. The Philosophical Theory of the partes eacoul BySrnstierne BY ra enr ms rmson: eUritical Studies. Machaitlan $2.50. wn,’ Anna R. A Chamepebien Comedy. D. Appleton & Co. dl Bruce, |M. Alaska: .Itg History and Resources, Gold Fields, Routes, ahd Survey. 2d ed. G. P- Putnam’s Sons. \ Byron, Lord. a e Harold's Pilgrimage." Mac- Capes, B. 0. iS Winter’s Fire. Doubleday & Mc- Chamiase, Adelbert von.) The ae yon History of Peter Schlemihl. ht em Ginn & Colerid H. The “ of Past i ree. ge, E. m Poetry. Vol. IL London Murray; New York: os Cornwa lis, K K* e Conquest of Mexico and Peru. New ¢d.' New Tyee: all Street Daily Investi- r. Cornwa}lis, K. The War for the Union. New York: Wall Street Daily Investigator. Oragin,| Belle 8S. Our [nsect Friends and Foes. + ee a woh Sons. | $1.75. Crowell E. The Young Volunteer: A Record of the Tox riences of a Private Soldier. F. Tennyson Neely. Curtis. /D. A. meer Luck. Poker Stories from the New York Sun. —— ). Ewart, K. Dorothea. tosimo de’ Medici. Mac- an. FitzGerald, E. Rubéiyfit of Omar Khayyam. Vest Pocket Rat tion. ontland, Me.: omas B. Guerben, H S. The Stary of the Great Republic. American Book Co. 2 Hanus. ‘Prof. P. H. Educational Aims and Educa- tional; Values. Macmillan Harben; W. N. The Carruthers. Affair. F. Tenny- son Neely. nm ic} = = Ss. 4 i as t + Harrison, Mrs. ar Ps. Nsee FE Bmore, 8." Spee and Other Tales. & Co. roe Hart, Prof. A. B. Source Book of American His- tory. emillan Co. Pa Heilprin, eae A. Alaska and the Klondike. ». A oa S Co. $1.75. 4 in Tnes, Kuba und der Krieg. New. York: beliateeee, briteheock. Mary E. Two Women in the Klondite. Putnams. $3. ollopeter, Dr. hes an” Fever and i. & =, sont Co. hiladeiphia: P. Bi Son vg R. n the Birds’ Highway. The. ton: Stuait ‘wotnct & Co, apis Haurés, J. Action Soctaltste. lére Série: Socialisme et I’ Ense am ogg a Socialiame\| les come Paris: rGeorges Bel ; ree ® A, &; ast oa Sreasnt, na pridge: Dultereity Press; New York: Maemi ipling. | R. yom Sea to Sea. 2 vols. Doubled y lure Co, $2. Kipling, R. Departmental Ditties, — Ballads 4 arrack-Room Ballads. Doubled & M Co. $1. 50 Kruell, Portfoilo of National Portraits. New York . H. Russell. $1 Lewes, G. H. The Life of Robesplerre. New ei London: Chapman & Hall; New York: Scribaé¢ts. 5 | jLummis, C. F. The Land of Sunshine: Te x. Ts zine of California and the West. Vol. IX Angeles. Cal. Macaulay, T. B. Warren Hastings. Cassell).'& Co. lve. f MacDonagh, M. Irish Life and Character. ;?d Thomas Whitaker. $1.75. a Mackern, and es . Bad pay of the Green (A' Book nadles’ Golf). : r- rence & Bullen; Philadel hia: Lippincott. $12 MeCrady, E. History of th Carolina under 3 Royal one, 1719-1776. Macmillan. McDougall, Rev. The Conversion of the Mao sryeeeyess: Srubaten Board of Publicat $1.25, Miller, Olive T. The First Book of Birds. Bostun: Houghton, Mifflin & Co. $1. f Milton’s Comus, Lycidas, ete. Macmillan xo. 25e. Minckwitz, R. A. The Twelfth Book of Homef's Odyssey. Boston: Ginn & Co. 40c. F by “Beez Moliére’s Le etinie Boston: D. ©. Heath & Co. 30e. us. ton: —_ MimMiin & “i Munroe, K. Shine rrili: A Sea Island Ranger. Boston: Lothrop Publishing Oo. $1.25. Newsholme, Arthur. ics tist 3d 5 York: Macmi Peaee Flotie W son Neely. nr abusson, Henry Les | Praistre. Paris: Lévy. —~ Clarence. Dent; New York: ib: as af Walter. Kenf Scott, ate Walter. The sell & Co. Ive. Shakspere, Ww. Vote Macmillan. $L& ments of Vital on: Sonnenschein; cw e les of March. F. Teany- Chiméres de Mare le a Hooligan 95 Henry Betrothed. i 2 vols. oy 4 Classion | Landon : ch Sie. ment. American Book Lady of the Lake. Cas- | Eversley Edition. Vol. Sidney, Margaret. The ‘Sortes Polly Pepper Told Boston: Lothrop Pubijshin Stephens, W. W. we. Longmans, Green Stern, 8. t be ie Goring People M. + BR ‘Hetorich ong. genannt otiees. Lebensgeschichte. Henry Holt & Co, $1.2 siuiy ‘ot oe Mistees in the Stheols. Macmillan. Sc, The a Denturz gazine. Century Nov., 1808—April, 1899. The Persion Policy of the United States: Political and Commercial. ere: American Aca- demy of Political and 8 oral Discourses of Elizabeth Carter. 2 ¥ London: Dent; New Yo Vivekananda, Vedanta, Science. ‘ctetus. Translated y EZ ed. Baker & Taylor 0. Ward, Prof. J. Naturalfm and Agnosticism. 2 vols. Macmillan. Wentworth, G. A. Plane Geometry. Revised ed. Boston: Ginn & Co. What Women Can Earn. Wherry, Albinia. Greek Frederick A. Stokes Co, uipture, with —g Ay g. London: Dent: New York: Scribners Wirth, A. Geschichte schurei. Bonn a. Rh.: Worthington, Elizabeth 8. Dodge Publishing Co. i A Naw MoDERN-|LANGUAGE SERIES. i | JUST PUBLISHED. Johann Heinrich Jung’s genannt Stilling Lebensgeschichte. Eine Wphrhafte Geschichte von thm selbst erziihlt. Zum hundert und fiinfzigsten Geburtage Goethe’s im Auszuge herausgegeben mit Worterbuch von Siemon M. STERN, Director of Stern’s School of Languages of New York City. xxvi+2B4 pp. 12mo, $1.20, net. This gutobiography is Bo of interesting intimate glimpse# of the author’s frjend Goethe. RREVIOUSLY PUBLISHED. STERN’S FIRST LESSONS IN GERMAN. 292 pe. 2mo. $1.00 net. STERN’S AUS DEUTSCHEN MEISTERWER- KEN | Niebelungen, Gudrun, Parcival, Tristan und poids.) vith vocabulary. xxvii.+225 pp. muna $1.20 $ & STieRN' GRAMMAIRE PRAN- slst LESSONS IN $1.00. Se meas e a? Breen ENCH. 321 pp. 2 0. HENRY HOLT & CO.,N. Y. SECOND EDITION NOW REAIY. e: THE LIFE’ | OF WILLIAM MORRIS By J. W. MackaiL, M.A, Fellow of Balliol College, Oxtord. With 6 Portraits in Pno- togravure and 16 full page Illustrations: by E. H. New, ete. 2 vols., 8vo, Vol. I, pp xvi,—375 ; Vol. IL., pp. viii, — 364, #7 50 abt. LONGMANS, GREEN, & C0. 91-93 Fifth Ave., New York. E "By ANNIE PAYSON CALL. Power Through Repose. | As a Matter of Course. Price, $1.00 each. LITTLE, BROWN & CO., Boston. the first} made it their chi¢f object to say out what the ticns, irrespective, not only of eppostiion res prem without, is to reflect the opinion of cult mass of the ve of oye they pre re ayes to represent. and we The hews of the cu rrent w is compressed {nto an @ without}missing the life or + rt of the events. The tor contains|a oe all Books published dy names gf the publishers ind the — attached, a featul librariags, literary institutions, and private gentlemen. Tha SPECTATOR isj on sale regularly at Messrs Mass.; The In News Co., 83 and 85 Duane New Yprk; The News Harold!A. Wilson Co., -, 385 King St., West and suljscriptions are SPECTATOR, LID., 1 Wellington |: vated Liberals; but in the i finally acknowledged by them to have been in the G4 i be Spectator. The (Proprietors who in 1861 purchased the Spectator } therefore exempted from many influences which press sev ave since that date conducted it themselves. The jare erely on the independence of jJournaliam, and have f pPelieve to be truth in theology, politics, and_social it of the opinion of their own ~~ Their object matter of the American War they fought against’ tong imated narrative, which the laziest or busiest may fing the week (not under one shilling¥n price), with: ns which will greatly increase its value to bookseljers, FOR SUMMER READING. é “A atrong, fine story of great promise.””—Hangier P. Pages, 230. Cloth and gilt. For sale by all boo ENJ. H.| SANBORN & A ROMANCE OF FIS IERMAN’S ISLAND. Damrell & Upham’s, 283 Washi St., pha ngton Boston, . New York; Messrs. ’s, Union on 8q Co., 47 Dey St Hew York, and 77 Clark St., —— "The obtained, —————_—+4§ —— lers, or sent, postpaid, on receipt of price, $1.00. CO., Publishers, Boston. ' | ibiriens und der Mand- arl Georgi. 1 _ to Cook Husbands, re i j + Two Women in the Klondike. The Story of a J Alaska. By Mary large folding map trations from photogt $3.00. The volume presenta to the Gold-Fields of Hitchcock. With a | Alaska and 105 Illvs- aphs. 8&vo, 500 pages, the record of a jour- ney undertaken in og oH of 1898 to the gold fields of Alaska and is written in a is full of interesting i rs. Hitchcock's jour- ivacious manner and idents. nal is a faithful na of her experience, igh a G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS, New York and London. Hay Feve e: ITS SUCC ESSFU L TREATMENT. By W. H. HOLLOPETER, M.D. The success of this bool Enlarged Se has made necessary an nd Edition (JUST READY), which bears witness to tle value of the method of tre~ Handsome clot nt. Price, $1.00 net. Will be sent, postpaiil, on receipt of price. P. BLAKISTON’S SON & CO., Publishers, Philadelphia. Royal Acade In 5 Parts. Price, 40 cen’ Complete set, 1888 to 1 CASSELL & CO 7 AND 9 WEST: y Pictures, each, or one vol., $3.00 price on application. ANY, Limited, ST., NEW YORK.
Page 24
504 The Nation. j [Vol. 68, No. 1 press recognition, e. g., from Macaulay on p. 431, and from Bryce on p. 214. In one or two other respects he is decidedly amus- ing. What the sentences are like in which he gives the modern student mnemonic assistance by coupling some matter of con- temporary note with an ancient fact or circumstance, may be gathered from the following illustrations: P. 209, “A seven days’ desperate battle at the place, north of Cadiz, called Xeres de la Frontera, fa- miliar to us from the district’s wine calted ‘sherry,’ ended in the total defeat of the Goths.” P. 332, ‘We must now relate the origin of one of the most flourishing minor states of the world, the Swiss republic, which, in the nineteenth century, became a chief resort for European and American tourists and derives therefrom a large in- crease of wealth for her people.’’ Another diverting feature is the shower of adjec- tives which, doubtless for the sake of con- ciseness,.Mr. Sanderson lets fall upon rulers and other great personages, e. g., p. 476, “The worthless, witty, clever Charles II. reigned from 1660-1685." And facing this, at the beginning of the next paragraph, p. 477, “James II. (1685-1688), cruel, faithless, stupid, hard-hearted despot as he was, had a short term of power, according to the prediction of his shrewd brother Charles.” Finally, we doubt whether such an ex-parte statement as the following is appropriate in a “concise knowledge” series. Referring to the Anglo-Russian difficulty of 1885 in Afghanistan, Mr. Sanderson says: “‘The act was a deliberate insult to Great Britain, and should have been followed by an immediate declaration of war. Mr. Gladstone, how- ever, was Prime Minister, and Lord Gren- ville was Foreign Secretary, and the mat- ter was settled by ‘explanations.’ ”’ Some slips must always occur in an ex- tensive work of reference, and we have noted a considerable number here, though not enough, by any means, to fix a stigma of incorrectness upon the whole narrative, We mention some of them partly because they are typical and partly that they may be placed upon the list of corrigenda. P. 168: The impression is conveyed that Decius de- cisively repelled the Goths. On the con- trary, he was slain in the battle of Forum Treborrii, where the Goths overwhelmed his legions. P. 182: Pope Leo the Great had not been concerned in meeting any Vandal in- vasion before 449. P. 188: The leader of the Franks to whom Pope Gregory III. appealed against the Lombards was Charles Martel, not Pepin the Short, P. 190: Clovis’s vic- tory over the Alamanni (Ziilpich) was fought near Strassburg, not Cologne. P. 217: Ro- ger Guiecard, rather than Robert, should be credited with achievements in Sicily against the Saracens. P. 245: Besides some doubt- ful statements regarding the early condition of Florence, the minting of the florin is as- cribed to the eleventh century instead of to 1262. P., 274: 1166 is not the date of Strong- bow's first victories in Ireland. P. 279: The essence of the communes (Cambrai, Beau- vais, Noyon, etc.) is missed in the sentence, ‘Former serfs who had been hereditary own- ers of portions of Jand had, in like manner, organized communes or parishes.” P. 289: It is implied wrongly that in 1158 Milan yielded to Barbarossa without a struggle. P. 296: The Cathedral of Florence was not a Medicean work. P, 330: There is no good evi- dence to show that the Emperor Henry VII. was poisoned in 1313, although the assertion is dften repeated on weak authority. P. 334: battle of Niafels was fought in canton s, not Schwyz. P. 424: The notice of recent investigations. P. Jaryis was not “victor over the French” in the|battle of Cape St. Vincent. P. 720: The first Canadian printing-press was established in 1759, not 1764. Dpspite these strictures, we must term Mr. Sanierson’s book a useful, and in the main a very correct, one. * Under the African Sun: A Description of tive Races in Uganda, Sporting Adven- tures, and Other Experiences. By W. J. sorge. With 134 illustrations from pho- graphs by the author, and two colored ates. ‘Longmans, Green & Co. 1899. 8vo, pp. xiv, 355. ganda is the most interesting of tropi- cal| African countries. Its unique position makes it the true heart of the continent. Situated at the sources of the Nile, exactly half way between the Cape and the Medi- terranean and the proposed meeting-point of the Nile and Bechuana railways, it is in cloge touch with the Indian Ocean by a rail- way nearly completed. Before another de- cad@ closes, it may be in direct communica- tion with the Atlantic by a : vilway bridging the |two or three hundred miles to the navi- gable waters of the Congo. Though appa- renjly possessed of no mineral wealth, its soil) is extraordinarily fertile—cotton and sugar growing wild—and it has an equa- ble | climate in whieh neither the heat nor| the cold is excessive. The inhabi- tanfs, more than any other pure ne- gro¢s, resemble the Japanese in their in- telligence and their feudal form of govern- mert, while their eagerness to learn is shown by their nascent literature and native pregs. Their strength of character and self- reliance are attested by their history since Stailey’s memorable visit in 1875; and thoygh wars, religious persecutions, and re- belljons have devastated the land and re- ducdd its population, yet now it is confi- dently hoped that an era of peace and pros- els has dawned, and that there is an ap- prodching near fulfilment of the prophecy that] Uganda will become a second India. The author of this latest contribution to the Jiterature of the country, as Government medical officer during the last four years, was|stationed in differeat parts of the Pro- tectorate, thereby gaining an exceptional knowledge of the country and the people. His jbook is not a connected narrative, but a seri¢s of detached sketches and descriptions of ihcidents and personal experiences with men| and beasts. It seems almost as if Dr. Ansorge had first arranged his pictures ac- cording to supjects, and then in writing fol- lowdd their suggestions. There is' an ad- vantage in this method in that each picture becomes individual and significant, and the imptession of much which is described in the | text is heightened. Beginning with Zangibar and the caravan road to the lake, our jauthor telis something of each district through which he passed or in which he was} stationed, and of the different tribes with which he had dealings, closing with stor of his hunting adventures with big os > a gamp, and brief accounts of some of the ler mammals, reptiles, and insects. His most enjoyable station, if not the most in- ng, was at Fovira on the Nile, where, amid lovely scenery, surrounded by and peaceable ives, he led an al idyllic life. Far different were his e ences at another jpost at the outb the Sudanese mutiny. Fortunately his/men remained loyal, , however, without ing some alarming demonstrations. He mends the Sudanese for their soldierly qnali- ties of obedience and courage, and for excellent service up to this time in gua the frontiers of Protectorate. Of intelligence he gives this illustration: “The men have |to be their own and it is astonishing what neat white forms they can produce. The thread obtain by unravelling a long, narrow of ‘americani’ cotton-cloth, or, more nomically, by spinning it for themselv of cotton from the| nearest cotton plantj He tells little of the deplorable, because preventable, mutiny beyond his personal] ex- periences, but he hints at one of the causes, insufficient pay, in the remark that its jout- come is “that a more liberal allowance) has been granted to meet Government exp@ndi- ture, and that the British nation has a firm. er hold than ever of the Uganda Prot¢cto- rate.” i Dr. Ansorge is an interested and cateful observer, and tered through his are numerous descriptions, illustrated re quently by well-chosen pictures, of rac- teristic native t , customs, and dwell- ings. These differ sometimes in an extraprdt- nary and inexplicable way: for instqnce, the traveller passes immediately from| the absolutely nude savages in Kavirondo |into Usoga, “where not! even the youngest about uncovered.” The children show very early age an intelligence and ca which seem of great promise for the ult elevation of the race. On the nort shore of Lake Albert, among the Lu mificent black bull, becoming ex put a whole village, including Dr. Ansorge’s followers, to flight, and was on the point of charging him: “Fortunately some one had hurriedly for the bull's keeper, a .ix-year-old little urchin. He came on the scene, before the bull was aware—switch! the brute a whack’ across the flank wi long lithe reed wand. The effect was eal. The bull , most humble, .|. . and it fairly gallo off, amid the jeers) and laughter of the hundreds who, a few before, had fled helter-skelter in eve’ rection.” The author’s hunting was done main provide food, or, as in the case of the and hippopotami, for the protection o people. On the Nile and on the w shore of Lake Albert, the latter w numerous and destructive to the corn sweet-potato crops that there was a of food. “In such a struggle for exis he says, “the hippo is locally extermi or the villagers must migrate to a regi favored by these animals.’ He is an e siastic student of natural history, and birds, some are new to science, and of only one or two other specimens are and of butterflies, moths, and beetles has “succeeded in adding more than fifty species to science.” The illustrations, are reproductions of his own photo 4 are exceptionally good, and add much interest and value of the work. It regret to say, however, without either or index,
Page 25
29, 1899] The Nation _505
BOOKS OF |THE WEEK. ee 5. W. Graded Work and Arithmetic. Fifth American Book} Co. The Strong 4rm. Frederick A. Stokes C. J. Studies of Life and its Variations. 8. Oaiivie A ng Co. $1.2. b . Tennyson Nee! -. Devil, and Other Stories. Londén: T. Fisher Unjin; Philadelphia: Lippin- qhet, B. The Piitlosophical Theory of the Brandey, G. Henrik Ibspn, BjSrnstjerne BjSrnson: efaittan, 50. itan Comedy. D. Co. $1. Alaska: _ Its History and Eonar, Gold Fields, Routes, G. P. and Survey. 2d ed
Putngm’s Sons. $2) ra, Lord. Childe Harold’s Pilgrimage. Mac- millah Co. 4 Capes, At a Winterjs Fire. Doubleday & Mc- ureiCo. $1.25. Chamispo, Adelbert von Wonderful History of Peter Schlemihl. R Ginn & Co. 35c. Coleridge, E. H, Works of Lord Byron. Poetry. Vol. Il. London: Murray; New York: Scribpers. $2. Cornwajlis, K. The Conquest of Mexico and Peru. ard bd. New York: Wall Street Daily Investi- gator Cornwajllis The ar for the Union. New York; Wall Street D ly oe: Cragin,; Belle 8S. Our [Insect Friends and Foes. G. Putnam’s Sons. Crowell, J. The Y ung Volunteer: A Reseed of the muapersenees a Private Soldier. Tennyson Neely. Curtis.;D. A. eer ck. Poker Stories from the New York Sun. tano’s. $1,¢ osimo de’ Medici. nll K. Dorothea. Mac- m FitzGeta of Omar Khayyfim. Vest ‘ocket eee Parting Me.: omas B Tr. 25¢c. Guerber, H. S._ The Stgry of the Great Republic. Amerjecan Book Co. Macaulay, a
a Harrison, Mrs, Burt Emers ane Other Tales. ese = 8. Stone part Prof. A. B. Source Book of Americar Wis- * $1.75. Kuba und der Krieg. New Yark: Shas. Widermann. Hitchcock. Mary E, Two Women in the Kiendine. Putnams. $3. Holo ter, Dr. W. C. -Fever and its Sa | fal atment. 5 oa. hiladelphia: P. B ‘ ton’s Son & Co Howe, R. H. m the Birds’ wena Small ‘etna & Co, Liao, J. Action Soctaliste. Série: ie. ‘Soclallame “ Socialisine et I’ es | les Peuples. Phd ia ay a hge Roane, Prof. Man st a Oum- H. t Present. a Uutvereity Press; New York: Maemiltan. xipling, R. From Sea to Sea. 2 vols. Doubleday McClure Co. $ 0 net. —f-— Will be sent, postpail P. BLAKISTON Publisiers, |Philadeiphia.
1, on receipt of price. NS SON & CO., a tn
Complete set, 1888 to 1 CASSELL & CO 7 AND 9 WEST i
Royal ncaneny Pictures, In 5 Parts. Price, 40 genbe each, or one vol., $3.00 , price on application. ANY, Limited, ST., NEW YORK.
Page 26
506 The Nation: [Vol. 68, No, 1 THE North American Review EDITED BY GEORGE B.M. HARVEY JULY, 1899 A Channel Passage, 1855, ALGERNON C. SWINBURNE EX ORIENTE LUX!) Prince E. A Plea for a Russo- OOKHTOMSKY American Under- VLADIMIR standing HOLMSTREM ‘‘Americanism,” True and False, The Rev. WILLIAM BARRY, D.D. Universal Peace, Baroness BERTHA VON SUTTNER England and the Transvaal, SYDNEY BROOKS Our Public Schools—A Reply, Mrs, SCHUYLER VAN RENSSELAER The Government of Greater New York, BIRD & COLER, Comptroller of the City of New York Pig Iron and Prosperity, GEORGE H. HULL The Logic of Our Position in Cuba, AN OFFICER OF THE ARMY OF OCCUPATION The Tercentenary of Velasquez, CHARLES WHIBLEY The War with Spain—III., Major-Gen, NELSON A MILES, Commanding the United States Army Golf, from a St. Andrews Point of View, ANDREW LANG ee NEW YORK: No. 11 Warren Street. Single Numbers, soc. Per Annum, $5 PUBLISHED MONTHLY APPLETONS’ pular Science Monthly. JULY, 1899. P ThejRace Problem in the United States. By KER T, WASHINGTON. Gives the mature views of one of the leading rep- tatives of the n race on the causes of the P nt unhappy rela on eeowre ree eee and lacks in the South, and offers as metiods of education and social intercourse which will gid in doing away with the mutual antagonism. eahts a about Universities. By WiLLiam Kerra pecially with reference to the true value of the brsity and the way in which the university graduate can do the most both for ey at large the advancement of his alma mater. tific Method and its seg niga to the ble. By the Rev. Davin Spracvue essay on the higher criticism, aD ago out its propriety and —_ value en conducted y scientific sp The oon y of the Klondike Gold Fields. rofessor ANGELO Herprin. Illustrated. A bso of the physical geography and oa gy o —= never nate gm om mma inp y a num f Tecrations and @ new pir ep met the gold. regions, showing the position of the most profitable of the stake tty Pavey Use of Acetylene, By Epwarp Renovr. Il- strated. punprsbenstve article describing the new we int both scientifically and comme y. al value to the country householder or fiotsl. ppr who is looking about with reference to ing methods, and who naturally wants a “ittle mation other than that furnished by the sell- gents of the various appliances. Antiquity of Man in North America. By q ES a Asporr. Illustrated. ussion as to the probable date at which man merica,. Dr. Abbott takes — is much more remote of our geologists at present believe. A per of Illustrations add interest to the article. erarticles: The Little Brook; White Whales nfinement; Some Things unusual with Plants; Pre we ep Colors of Flowers; Folklore of lleghanies; Origin of “Ancient Hindu Astro- ;; and sketch (with frontispiece portrait) of am Keith Brooks. Editor's Table; Scientific Books; Fragments. 50 cents a number; $5.00 a year. D. APPLETON & COSPIPANY, 72 Fifth Avenue, New York. oe a When —_ r pieare ask for LIBERAL Pei ou need a Book, DISCOUNTS. enever you GRANT. Before buying books, write for quotations. An assort- ment of catal es and special slips of books at re- duced prices sent for 10 cent stamp. F. E. GRANT, Books. 28 W.42p8r.. - NEW YORE. (Mention this advertisement and receive @ discount.) Old Books, Rare Books, Choice Books, Quaint Books, Typography, Topography. BOOKS ON ALL SUBJECTS. FIRST EDITIONS, ETC. 1 LUST R ATES CATs GATOS BS Frompnneed to bx to 4 we es, pas i 4 Heproduetfont ons of Pla is deducted from the fir rst sh ted Mon of “gy mun PICKERING & CHATTO, Antiquarian Booksellers, 66 Haymarket, St. James, London, 8S. W. THE NEW and WONDERFUL ZEISS IMPORTED AND SOLD BY THEODORE MUNDORFF, Optician, 1167 Brsedway, N. Y. Send for circular, F. W. CHRISTERN (DYRSEN & PFEIFFER, Successors), 429 5th yee between coon ont 30th Sts., New York. im ~pY for t the lead ae pabl Ler ye Teubner e t Fo: ‘oreign Boo urls Publishers: Tauchaita' br pad Lames sal talogtes ‘om Paris and Leip- prere ‘| BLLIS & ELVEY, PE pe r bak and Rare Beoks, CAT. Sof CHOICE BOOKS and ILLUMI. NA Dm MANUSCR RIPTS jodicall 7 ae Literat Serica, ings, rare Prints arta. nikPEeRE Te JOAN OF ARC. By Francois C. Lowgtt. $2.00. “ Asa piece of historical biography it is a noble success.”"—-Am. Historical Review. HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO. B*e OxS. All Out-of. int Book su Hod, world over as the ban poe: € Plense, state, wants "BA ‘ES oN : 14-16 John Bright Street, Birmingham, Best Known Known as the Best emingto Standard Typewrit WYCKOFF, SEAMANS & BENEDICT, 327 aie oe New York. Save Your E yes KEEP YOUR GLASSES CLEAN. Send for kage of our prepared (absorbent) Polishing Poser for cleaning eye-glasses, etc. 10 cents silver per package; 3 for 25¢. Calumet Chemical Co., Box A, Blue Island, Ill. New Volume of Poems by the Author of “ADMIRALS Pj THE ISLAND RACE. By HENRY NEWBOLT. Crown 8vo, $1.00. The London Daily Evebag od ey “It con- nothing better than the best things tains ‘Admirals All,’ Ba the excellent reason these things w fect in their kind could not be better JOHN LANE, 140 Fifth Avenue, New York. THE BLICKENSDERFER TYPEWRITERS No. 5, $35. No. 7, $50. Are Guaranteed the Best. Ask for New ogee °° of Desks and Up-to-date Blickensderfer Mfg. Co. 325 BROADWAY, N. Y. ° calor. : | BROWN peehdaon & NO, 59 WALL STREET, NEW YORK. | make ¢ Rag bel Sitio of