The Nation 1899-06-15: Vol 68 Iss 1772

Page 1

UNIV. OF MICH. ati VOL, LxvIII-No. 1772. THURSDAY, JUNE 15, 1899. PRICE 10 CENTS. SOME IMPORTANT NEW BOOKS. Alaska and the Klondike. _ Uncle Sam’s Soldiers. By. O. P. Austin, Chief of the Bureau of Statistics, Treasury Department ; Author of ‘‘ Uncle Sam's Secrets.” Appletons’ Home- ¥ Reading Books. Tilustrated. 12mo0. Cloth, 75 cents net ‘The purpose of the story, like that of the earlier one of the series, is instruction, ee eee — Ba geen — —— work, the distribution supplies, modern arms, , ammunition, coast ete., and especially modern of th Tis sory, which purports to be the exarienrs of ro boys rersing on ianhood who, corr with the armies in Gaba generation or load them to value whose experiences in the civil war would some account of the developments in war methods since that time. A History of Bohemian Literature. ‘3 |. By Count Lérzow. A new volume in the of the World Series, edited by Edmund Guese. 12mo, Cloth, $1.50. J The autho ample knc 2* of the Mant z Sia Lar en ans eee ego Oe poe paymeer erty ed am —— — an cnet ing with the oa of Jokn $3 Seeeeeajeckt tae dovelopenans of Webeskian proce tn the cixtecein egusace’ icy ceaaet A History of. the American Nation. ESE Se Se ee eee. ing “The Story of the British Race. By Jouw oe eee “The Story of Bilectricity.” A new volume in the Library of Useful Stories. Illustrated. | shar rere ash ty restns pens terse cod meer oo Ban per * 7 STUDY. By Wruasax Z. Rirus Aesitant iA ern aan ee Se cae ie, Sea eT let ll booksellers, or they will be sent by mail on receipt of price, by the publishers. ‘4 PPLETON AND COMPANY,

Page 2

The Nation. [Vol 68, No. 19772 The. M . Nation. 4 WEEKLY JOURNAL — ro Politics, Literature, Science, and Art. FOUNDED 1865. [Entered at the New York City Post-Office as second class matl-matter.| CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. Ra ines ewvinennccsntnnbccdceusneiminsonounces 447 EprrortaL ARTICLES: — i iopert ——— 453 SrxictaL CORRESPONDENCE: Bee eS i ee ComRESPONDENOE: and Expansion .....sccsecsess $e Ap Boglishinas J The Oscitant Proof-Reader ........eeseess 456 sss 456 ——— sab sorgh HP TERS BASE HER i ot Goi ind Goidene 200002002505 ies Siiilis WE RMON 5c ss e'ou ticccces sec censon 464 J Rousseau and the Cosmopolitan it TATQPACUTS 0 ccccccccccccenscccse 464 I SE DEINE. ccccvevcenictvevscsdeesees 464 A J 465 BOOKS OF THE WEEK, .. 2... 000 cccevceesescccseonscencs 465 Tiree veceteed Suestan, 6.7: 1. DISCOUNTS. The NATION te — those who adwertise in it as long as advertisement continues. Sei ne at Brentano's, . of B. F. —3* serena HEV Y CHASE (Chevy Chase P. 0., Md.). — 122 and 1 A St. Dek OARDING ond DAY — 1809. Associate —— TiMOTH | * "SCHOOL for Girls re. — Gib Oone. — VERSITY Low School. CTASSICAL SCHOOL F FOR Gi. ZS. — —8 sot Ye own, Princtpals. — — L Exuxy, Principal. tor ——— POIN — — — a em | CHOOL. —Prepares 91 a Drawing and Painting. _, MUSEUM OF FINE ARTS, BOSTON, MAS& agth Your Opens October 2, 1899. Clark University SUMMER SCHOOL, WORCESTER, MASS., Rie 13-26, 1899. Puc Gukvcae — Languages "(AT AMHERST COLLEGE, MASS., . July — 18. fo See Bev. Davip Led and circulars Dr. i. SAUVEUR, 263 Dearborn Av. , Chicago, ii. — — — — cone ite ILDERN. pre SCHOOL Wednesday, September 97, 6 P.M. MEE. Pie Pra EES SCHOOL,—The. next} a begins Thursday, Sept. 22. 1898. TSS ARMST; NES SC: SCHOOL FOR — sensi. Pty te PRNNSTLv. Bethiehem. MISS BALDWIN'S SCHOOL POR ‘GIRLS, BRYN MAWR, PA. HARVARD wanicat SCHOOL. Summer Course in EXPERIMENTAL PHYSIOLOGY. For information address The Dean 688 Boylston St., Boston, Mass. FORESTRY SCHOOL,

Page 3

June 15, 1899] The Nation. Educational. The Four Weeks’ Guommer Course of French of the Pensionnat Francais SiR: PRE Ee —— — Teachers, etc. WOMAN OF LIBERAL EDUCA- ged ——— — IBRARIAN.—FOUR YEARS’ EX- perience in one of le American libraries—wil act ag/neaistant oF take ol ——— scholarship and on spplication to A. KG. care of the The Spectator. have since that date cond ———— S fap aarti is to the pR awe gy oe | Sateen 8— —— — ————— — —— —— — ⏑ brarians. ATOR regularly — taeeein, Sammeal te Catania, Oy etiaan D. Mam; The tnt — Ceo., 33 Saud 86 Duane St New York; Moser. ——— Union 5* Harold A. 'Witeos Cov kids 8 King St, Went Roroato, Canada, where single copiea con outained, and subscriptions are received. SUBSCRIPTION, Payvasie or Apvanos, $7.50 A YBAR. HOLB MONOGRAPHS ON ‘ON ARTISTS, Hy i fi wie ony cious genio he 4 Sg Ga Sag Se North who evidenced "the. decked pointed out in "te a Be on HO "4. — Holbein wns the one among the of his attained by any othor Northern painter. This . j OUR YEARS’ ACADEMICAL RAPHAEL | side of Holbein? — —— —noeeen MB he FB tinier Nene, Oh, BORnSaE $1.50 upen recent authorities, and illustrated with care $1.g0 Pamphlet free. v. We. Waaen ue and discrimination. cartes pee hace alvondy painted eat, 0 beet Oe AEE oak BOL DEIN Sot So cone &S ‘HAR * pare —* on Cae ee English by Canramii, Doooson, of the British Museum. Others wil be shortly. Back j LEMCKE & BUECHNER, Publishers, 812 Broadway, New York. School Agencies. HE FISK TEA ACHERS' AGENCIES. | pessers and Writers have been Waiting for this Ready about July 1st. —— iene Fe, Ave. »» Washington. | Pull of-flatter, Moderate-Priced Reference Book, ae poses THE sTubeNTs’ | Statistical Methods ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY, | STANDARD DICTIONARY. | cheney pase nie cher * schools of AN ABRIDGMENT OF WITH SPECIAL REFERENCE TO —— —— TEACHERS’ icy. 0 ert end Hest Rees oe ie 5-8: 1855, * 8 E. 14th 8t., An valuable in proportion to its 1n- ——— ——— tiful 7 mifles Boston. Excellent neigh- Fg ae ie Bo |, 66 State St., Room 7, , Mass. ¢ ——— porte anh JON-BOOK fOB- — — CLARENDON PRESS ‘PUBLICATIONS. Tor sale by all — Send for Catalogue. (American Branch) 91 sth Ave., New York. Fook & Wagnalls’ Standard Dictionary . cl leather 2.50: Large Ove ose pages ee . Son back, net, $: — 60,000 Words and Phrases, and 1,225 Pictorial Illustrations. BIOLOGICAL VARIATION. By C. B. DAVENPORT, Instructor in Zoology at Harvard University. This work is intended for Zo- Se — —— species and of 3! Figures. 16mo, morecco, 135 pages. Price, $1.25. APPENDIX TO DANA'S dint petal onivecliglid erliite The Baker & TaylorCo. _§ & 7 East Sixteenth St., New York. PUBLICATIONS IN FRENCH. Verbes Francais Deman- dant des Prepositions. | New “System of Mineralogy” — FRANCIS J. * DARR. ig | 37 EDWARD SALISBURY DANA, designed ar the use — Sr Professor of Physics Shel con amt Minera! eae esas lame, cloth, 13g pages. Price go cents. — Cores RATS eee er hisses ———— PUBLISHED BY WILLIAMR. JENKINS | JOHN WILEY & SONS 6gt and 8g3 6th Ave. (cor. 48th St.), New York. —** = Bo Rake 53 East 10th St., New York City. JOAN OF ARC. —— ©. Lovxra. $2.00. “ Asa plece of historical biography it ts noble success.”—Am, Historical Review. MOUGHTON, MIFPLIN & CO.

Page 4

iv | The Nation. [Vol. 68, No. 1772 NEW AND — ee WENTWORTH’S PLANE GEOMETRY. Revised Edition. By G. A. Wawrworrn. 96 pages. 75 cents. KITTREDGE AND ARNOLD'S ENGLISH LANGUAGE AND GRAMMAR. By Goreme L. Krrrrazper, Professor ot ae, in Harvard University, TARBELL’S LESSONS IN LANGUAGE. pores’ Seay By Horace 8. Tarse.., Superintendent of Schools, BEMAN AND SMITH’S NEW PLANE AND SOLID GEOMETRY. Woosarea Smee: Exctemor of Mathematics in the: Untesas Mlohigan, aed Davin Sure, Principal of the State Normal crinak boeeek of at SPEER’S ADVANCED ARITHMETIC. By Wuitsu W. Spzer, Assistant Superintendent of Schools, Chicago, Ill. CAIRNS’S INTRODUCTION TO RHETORIC. By Vaaau B. Carns, Instructor in English in the University of Wis- STEINER’S INSTITUTIONS AND CIVIL GOVERN- MENT OF MARYLAND. of ‘the Enoch Pratt oh eK nagar? / , Johns Hopkins University. 6 CYR’S FIFTH READER. By Ex.en M. Cyr, author of Cyr's Readers. gt iyo — DAVIS'S PHYSICAL — rane —— M. sada by Wasa Dah, Master OVID. — 2* R. Ds. Eatin ond Grok School Cine, — —* = ODYSSEY, BOOK XII. Eéited by Ricnarp A. Mincxwirz, of the Greek and Latin wea Bieh School, Kanune Clty Me 1 Latin and Greek School LA GRAMMAIRE. sistant Trotemor of Romance Languages inthe Univeraty one Wi cdaen Intomelionas EL SI DE LAS NINAS. oor LF Gp Rocae. a be 2, B.S. Bean, Sateuoier te Frene> SIR BEVIS. ° Richard Jefferies. Edited Exiza Josermmme Keiixy. 129 pages. — Classics for C onde”? HOLLAND’S CLAY MODELLING. taint coco ay Age North Bennett Street in Harvard Uni- in Worcester 8. Prart, As- of Iilincis. @& Indvatrial School, Boston. Descriptive Circulars of all our books sent, postpaid, on application. GINN & COMPANY, Publishers, BOSTON. NEW YORK. CHICAGO, LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO.’S NEW BOOKS Just Issued. 8vo. Price $4.50. MY INNER LIFE. Being a Chapter in Personal Evolution and Autobiography. By JOHN BEATTIE CROZIER, — Author of “ History of Intellectual Development," “Civilization and Pro- gress,” etc.. PRESS NOTICES. “I believe Mr. Crosier has done his a and lasting service hich we ave of bis Sebtors. He has thee ait of visioa.™ —— “A sv cent sein — tg exerdioe, if he dows not already exercee, influence." — a og mast 19 moet interesting autobiography of the is that told Mr. J. ne one to tha that Life,’ a and tive incline one Ee Soon tole tae ena philosopher.’ — — — certainly ia, although he may never have written © us to NEW TESTAMENT CHURCHMANSHIP AND THE PRINCIPLES UPON WHICH IT WAS FOUNDED By the Right Rev. Henny Yarzes SATTERLEE, D.D., Bishop of Washington. Crown 8vo, $1.50. The aim of this book is to show that Baptism, the Eucharist, the Visi- forth in the New Testament as inseparably rection and Ascension; that both Romanism and Protestantism, by stop- Ping at the Crucifixion and losing the true meaning of the Resurrection and Ascension, have failed to realize the relationship of the Glorified Christ to His Church and have thus fallen below the level of New Testament Church- manship. TRUE LIMITS OF RITUAL IN THE CHURCH. Edited by the Rev. Ropert Lurxiarzp, D.D., — — ‘Stroud Green. Crown vo, $1.50. | MANUAL OF THE PRINCIPLES OF PRACTICAL COOKERY. By E. KE. Mas, Head Teacher of Oooksry in the Liverpool Training Bchool of Uookery. pie esalts actus THE POETICAL WORKS OF WILLIAM MORRIS. — THE TALE OF BEOWULF, SOFMETIME KING OF ‘THE FOLK OF THE WEDERGBATS. ods — — — ——— — “995 Fifth Avenue, New York, + ,#

Page 5

The Nation. NEW YORE, THURSDAY, JUNE 15, 1899. The Week. The more the President's betrayal of civil-service reform is defended, the worse it looks, both for him and for his apologists. Poor Mr. Gage is rapidly adopting the melancholy hypocrisies of the spolismen. Unable to break the force of the damaging attacks of veteran re- formers like Mr. BE. P. Wheeler, he fails back on that hoary old shibboleth of the looters, that he is in entire sympathy with the merit system, but that he is no “bigot” about reform, and desires above all things to make it “practical.” This is the precise defence of the drunken temperance lecturer. He was a prohibi- tionist, he told the astonished deacon who found him embracing the lamp-post, but not a bigoted one. Unluckily for Mr. Gage, on the same morning that his dodging reply to Mr. Wheeler appears, Senator Hanna comes along to upset the ' whole apple-cart by brutally declaring that the President’s order was intended to get rid of the appointees whom Cleve- land “saddled upon the Republican party.” This makes it needless for Mr. Gage further to hurt his own reputation by writing more whitewashing letters. It was not simply the pledge which Mr. McKinley made to the people of the country generally that the President broke when he issued his recent order, but a further personal promise which he made to one of the leading civil- service reformers of the country. Mr. William D. Foulke of Indiana testifies that when he called at the White House with other reformers a year ago, and af- ter the President had spoken of the ne- cessity of excluding some places from the operation of the rules, he (Foulke) said that they hoped that,if he did this, he would at the same time include in the classified service some other places, at least equal in number and importance to those excepted, so that it would appear in the order itself that no backward step was taken; and that the President an- swered that he “intended to include a great many more places than those which were excepted.” But despite this promise, not a single office was included in the order when it finally came, and, naturally enough, to Mr. Foulke “the failure to include these places seems to be more surprising than the exceptions actually made.” By the way, speaking of this evidence from Indiana to Mr. Mc- sent situation call for the revival by Mr. would be no “backward step” in this matter? The civil-service order has stripped the mask from the President. We see him now in his true character. He is the same man who, as Governor of Ohio, spoke the clergy and philanthropists fair, but turned over the charitable institutions of the State to the spoils- men as no Democratic Governor had ever dared to do. He is the man who said he was against Hawaiian annexa- tion, but put it through; against a war with Spain, but allowed a group of Con- gressmen to “hold a stop-watch” on him till he brought it on; against taking the Philippines, but took them. In all, his method has been one and the same—to start with a mind absolutely blank of conviction, and a will wholly without the power of initiative; to say little ex- cept to agree heartily with both sides; to put off decision till the last moment, but finally to go with the crowd. The only satisfaction—and we confess it is a melancholy one—to be got out of the ex- hibition of himself which the President has made in this violation of personal and party pledges, is that his adulators will hereafter be dispensed from their nauseous task. If crawling on their bel- lies before him no longer deceives the public, they may fairly beg off from the job. “No Civil Service for Hershey.” Such is the head-line over a dispatch from Harrisburg, Pa., and the story which this dispatch tells is one that is duplicated from many another place in every part of the country where there is an im- portant federal office. Hershey is Col- lector of Internal Revenue at the capital of Pennsylvania. When he succeeded to the office by Quay’s appointment (his commission being signed by William Mc- Kinley as the Senator’s clerk), he found a number of gaugers and storekeepers who had been appointed during the Cleveland administration. Hershey want- ed their places for henchmen of Quay, but they were honest and efficient, so that there was no ground for their re- moval, and even if they had been re- moved, the men who wanted the of- fices would not be likely to pase the competitive examination required. But within forty-eight hours after the Pre- sident issued his order turning over these places to the spoilsmen, Hershey had turned out three of these Democrats and instalied three Quay workers, and the rest will have to go as soon as it can be decided whose claims for their places are strongest. An element of truth there undoubted- ly is in all the rumors about friction between the members of the Philippine Commission, given now as a reason for President Schurman’s early home-com- ing. The trouble has been not in the personnel of the Commission, but in its contradictory instructions. President McKinley has bidden both warriors and peace-makers a hearty godspeed. Otis was to push things, while Schurman was to soothe and conciliate the natives. No such combination of peace and war was ever known before, and it is no wonder that the wires from Manila have been kept hot with inquiries which poli- cy was to prevail, peace or war. Mc- Kinley, with characteristic large-mind- edness, has ordered both policies to pre- vail. He strongly approves of Otis and tells him to go on with his killing, but just as strongly approves of Schurman and urges him to go on waving the olive branch. If this looks like a policy of drift and muddle, the moral is that it is well to have an Executive who can make up his mind. The President's orders to Otis and Schurman, as we gather them from results, must have been modelled upon the famous softening down of tho Ten Commandments: “Thou shalt not kill, but need’st not strive Officiously to keep alive.” The Tribune’s Washington correspond- ent is doing excellent work in exposing the topheavy, job-ridden organization of the War Department. We do not know if the Administration will consider it- self “knifed” by such articles in such a paper, but we do know that = knife was never more clearly called for. A simple comparison of records shows how ab- surdly overgrown the Department is. The Secretary may not have known how to organize victory, but he did know how to organize a bureau stuffed with fa- vorites and incompetents. In 1863, with a million men in arms, Secretary Stan- ton was able to do all the work of his office with a clerical force of 665 men. But the numbers had grown to 1,366 in 1897, when the entire military establish- ment amounted to only 29,000 men. How the war “emergency” enabled Alger to swell the rolls still further, and with questionable legality, the Tribune's cor-

Page 6

448 The Nation. — [Vol. 68; No. 1772 the political and commercial importance of those islands. Before commenting on‘ his speech, it is well to glance at a for- mer utterance of his on the subject of our policy in the Philippines. On the 12th of January last, in a speech before the Shanghai Chamber of Commerce, he said: ‘“‘May I humbly go on record as declaring that it would be far better for the United States to treat this leader [Aguinaldo} and his people with caution and consideration, eventually obtaining the end to be desired without serious loss of life and great ex- pense, rather than peremptorily demand his absolute surrender, be forced into a most unhappy conflict which would, from its gue- rilla nature, mean the loss of hundreds of good lives, the expenditure of large sums of money, and, saddest and worst of all, the de- velopment of a feeling of hatred and revenge towards Americans among eight millions of subject natives which the kind treatment of a hundred years cannot remove?” The unhappy conflict against which Mr. Barrett warned the authorities at Ma- nila and at Washington has taken place and is still in progress. It has entailed the loss of hundreds of good lives, and the expenditure of large sums of money, -and undoubtedly it has provoked a feel- ing of hatred and revenge which will outlast the present generation. Now Mr. Barrett says that if he were asked what was the great signal result of the last war with Spain, and which has amply repaid us for all the diffi- culties brought upon us by our assump- tion of sovereignty over the Philippines, it is simply this: “That it has suddenly and unexpectedly made us the first Pow- er in the Pacific.” It is this which com- pensates us not only for all the Ameri- can blood shed in Cuba, but also for all that has been, or is yet to be, spilled in the Philippines. Now, what is meant by being the first Power in the Pacific? It. means having the power to kill the largest number of men, burn the largest number of cities, and destroy the largest amount of property in a given time. This is what every speaker and every hearer of such words understands by them. Sometimes the phrase ts varied a little, as, for example, when the news- papers of Paris talk about making the Mediterranean a French lake. That means having the power to sweep off, destroy, or drive out all other naval forces. Two questions properly follow Mr. Barrett's assumption. One is whe- ther the acquirement of the power to do the most killing, burning, and destroying in @ given time in the Pacific Ocean can be considered an advantage to the American people. The other is whether this power came to us by reason of the war with Spain and the seizure of the Philippines. If both of these questions must be answered in the negative, then Mr. Barrett appears to us to have de- teriorated as a teacher since he addreass- ed the Shanghai Chamber of Commerce last January. The kind of war that is now going on 4 fied in the Philippines’ was described by a French writer, André Bellesort, in 1897. His article in the Revue des Deux Mondes telling what he saw there, when the Spaniards were trying to conquer a peo- ple fighting for their liberty, is repub- lished in Littell’s Living Age. The Spa- nish officers with whom he talked said that they saw no probable end to the in- surrection; that even if they succeeded in buying Aguinaldo, the whole thing would break out again in three months, and that if they would not buy him, Spain would eventually be exhausted; that European soldiers could not stand the climate, and that they were in a very bad strait. ‘The spectacle of these men, whose courage is unimpeachable, strand- ed there, and spent with fatigue and homesickness, was heartrending.” In short, these Spanish soldiers were un- dergoing the same tortures that ours are suffering now, and for the same cause— i. e.; in order to subjugate a free people. A lieutenant-colonel entertained M. Bellesort with tales of his skirmishes with the insurgents, expressing his hearty detestation of a campaign of snares and ambuscades. They were per- petually harassed, he said, by invisible foes, who never. would stand up to a fair fight. The insurgents knew to a man how many soldiers were operating against them, but the Spaniards never knew whether there were five, or ten, or a hundred thousand men opposed to them. Moreover, the Filipinos were brave men. They would dance and brandish their bolos at the very muzzles of the Spanish guns. Neither pain nor the fear of annihilation could daunt them. These are the kind of men that we send the flower. of American youth, descendants of Revolutionary sires, to kill and be killed by. Oh, Liberty, how many crimes are committed in thy name! A telegram from Washington says that a private cablegram from Admiral Dew- ey to a friend in that city expresses his unwillingness to accept the donation of a home, but adds that he would be glaa to have any money collected for his benefit used in the establishment of a soldiers’ and sailors’ home. It is added that the committee having charge of the fund will continue their collections, and that when the sum originally intended to be raised has been secured; a decision will be made as to its disposition. This is equivalent to an abandonment of the undertaking. The sums contributed daily had fallen so low that the project had almost passed out of the public mind. In order to give it a fresh start; a plan was proposed of asking the National Banks of the country to pledge them- selve for the moderate ‘sum of $25 each. | ggg amen ——— is the Treasury Department; it’ was may be the alternative charity proposed, such a project does not meet the inten- tions of the original donors. The whole scheme was nonsensical, and, to use a ‘much-abused word, un-American. Buy- ing houses for military and naval heroes is not wholly without precedent in our country, but such donations have been extremely rare and have never been be- stowed upon the winner of only one fight, however meritorious he may have proved himself to be. Admiral Dewey has shown all the qualities of naval greatness that his limited: sphere of ac- tion permitted, but that sphere was not sufficiently wide to call for a public sub- scription. Even if it had been wider, Ad- miral Dewey is not the man to accept gratuities on account of it. One of the pleasing little assumptions of Imperialists has been that’the main thing is to seize territory, and that the settling and civilizing will attend to it- self. The theory has already had a good deal of a shock in our experience in the Philippines. We have the islands fast enough, but if there were any good way to let them go, how gladly would we do it. But for this deepening conviction that the United States is now completely stocked up with tropic islands, we should ‘have undoubtedly heard a great outcry over the acquisition of the Carolines and the remaining Ladrones by Germany. As it is, no one peeps. Last summer our most predatory religious papers were calling upon the President to have a war-ship “call” at the Carolines, so as to help along American missions there by seizing the land; but now they see them taken by Germany without a mur- mur. We know more about civilizing Pacific islands now, even if we are not so happy. Yet experience unrolled an ample page before us to read in, if we had not been so intensely patriotic and filled with the new wine of Destiny that we could not stop to learn from the ven- tures of other nations. An English of- ficial has been writing from Africa to describe the condition of things in the region for the possession of which France and England were on the point of going to war. Speaking of the terri- tory between Leopoldsville and Lake Tanganyika, he says that “perpetual war reigns.” Almost every garrison on the Congo has a “punitive expedition” on hand all the time. “The zone of safety, or even so-called civilization, does not exceed a mile back from the river. To venture even a mile from the river would

Page 7

June 15, 1899] The Nation. 449 the support of the State’s delegation to some candidate whose friends in the Se- nate would in return help Quay in his struggle to be seated upon the appoint- ment of the Governor. Moreover, Quay. like Platt, wanted a man in the Speak- er’s chair who would feel under obliga- tion to the bosses, and who could be depended upon to recognize that obliga- tion whenever they should “put on the screws.” Incidentally, he hoped to get the clerkship of the House for a personal follower. But, as things have turned out, Gen. Henderson gets the place with- out any help from Quay, and there has been no chance even to trade the clerk- ship for the support of the Pennsylvania delegation. Gen. Henderson is so strong a partisan that he will not stand out stubbornly against any policy upon which the Re- publican Representatives in Congress shail agree. His instincts and tenden- cies, however, have been so plainly manifested in the past as to indicate that he will not push forward the cause of im- perialism. So recently as last winter he declared that “I look with aversion upon increasing the regular army of my coun- try,” that “I have the gravest doubts of the wisdom of this country taking the Philippine Islands, to govern them as United States territory’; and, further, “If you ask me would I enforce a. govern- ment upon the Filipinos against their will, I answer, ‘No.’” It is reassuring to have a Speaker who, upon the testimony of so good a civil-service reformer as Representative McCall of Boston, “has been outspoken for civil-service reform when it showed little signs of popularity in the House.” On another important is- sue Gen. Henderson has earned from the same good judge the commendation that “he is sound upon the money question.” The new Speaker has ‘progressive ideas in matters outside the ordinary range of legislation. He was an earnest cham- pion of the movement to establish a free - library in Washington, and he was active in securing the passage of the law to prevent prize-fighting in the Terri- tories and the District of Columbia, de- fending the severity of the punishment proposed—imprisonment from one to five years—by saying that it was “the judg- ment of the best people in America that severe penalties should be enforced to break up this practice.” That the affair at Coney Island on Friday evening was a genuine prize-fight is universally admitted. It closed with the defeated contestant insensible in the ring—completely “knocked out,” Chief Devery’ sat close by during the contest, bit in no’ way interfered with it, nor did he express any disapproval of its violent _ ending, Before he started for tlie ncene, he ‘favored the public with a frank ex- promign.-0t: hig yiews, “The law * plain,” he said. “It is meant to allow younger men to familiarize themselves with the manly art. We are living under a liberal government, and it wiil be libe- ral as long as I am here.” There is no doubt whatever about the “liberality” of our present police dispensation of law. The Mazet inquiry has shown that to us, though it was perfectly well known be- fore. Few things are more universally obvious than a “wide-open” city. De- very’s view of prize-fights is identical with Capt. Price’s view of “dives” and “hells,” expressed on the witness stand: “There should be such places in all large cities.” They are needed for the educa- tion of our youth in the manly and kin- dred arts. They are part of our “liberal government” as administered by Croker and his kind. What more appropriate under such a government than prize- fights at regular intervals? Who op- poses prize-fights any way? Why, no- body except reformers, and the people of the city have decided, by the kindly assistance of Platt and Tracy, that Cro- kerism is preferable to reform rule. It is an interesting coincidence that the same year should witness the cleans- ing of the pest hole in Cuba which has been the chief source of yellow-fever in- fection in this country, and the taking of the first step along the road of thor- ough-going sanitary reform in the city of the United States which has always done most to spread the disease after it secured a lodgment. Havana has bred the pest by the shameful neglect of the fundamental rules of public health under Spanish rule, and New Orleans has cul- tivated the epidemic by a neglect only less discreditable. It seems incredible that in this country a city of over a quarter of a million inhabitants, at the close of the nineteenth century, could be without a system of drainage and sewer- age, but such is the condition of New Or- leans to-day. Last week an election was held to decide whether the property- holders of the city would vote a special tax of two mills per annum, above the ordinary State and city taxes, to be le- vied for forty-three years, to raise the necessary. funds to drain and sewer the city, and to provide’ municipal water- works. The agitation had been under way for nearly a year, and at first the re- formers were not sanguine of success, but a combination of public-spirited men and women carried on a campaign of education which finally converted al- most everybody of either sex, women taxpayers having the right to vote on such questions in Louisiana, The whole country is to be congratulated on this result, as it means that within a few years New Orleans will stand among the most progressive eities in point of public health, and that the United States will no longer maintain in one of its chief ports a breeding-place for epidemic diseases, The upset of the Dupuy Ministry looks like fresh evidence of the frivolity that bas made a sport of cabinets and parties in France during the past ten years, yet it was time for M. Dupuy to depart. He had taken the position that although Dreyfus had been convicted on false tes- timony, yet the chiefs of the French army, who were responsible for all the injustice that had been done, should not be prosecuted or disturbed. This was an impossible position. It was impoasi- ble to say that Dreyfus was innocent and that Mercier and Boisdeffre were in- nocent also. The Republican party of France, which had committed itself to a new trial for the prisoner of Devii's Is!l- and, could not stop short with that. It must go on to the logical consequences of so grave a decision. It must finieh the job by trying not merely Esterhazy and Du Paty de Clam, but the men in higher places above them. It was this necessity which drove a sufficient number of the supporters of President Ioubet over to the opposition when the vote was taken on the resolution, which was practically a vote of want of confidence. Unsettled questions have no pity for the repose of prime ministers. The great interest taken by the Prus- sian royal family in the recent congress at Berlin for the prevention of tuber- “culosis, and the message which Queen Victoria sent to it, expressing her warm approval and blessing, have been re- ferred to by European correspondents as striking proof of the attention now given to disease problems. But it would be strange indeed if, after the revelations which have been made in recent years regarding the ravages of the deadly tu- bercule bacillus, sovereigns did not take an interest in the war which medical men have declared against it. If by the invasion of some savage horde more than 70,000 men, women, and children were killed in one year in Great Britain alone, it would be considered the para- mount duty of the Queen and Parliament to give every minute of their time to the extermination of the invaders; all the more if it were certain that the same number would be killed every year fol- lowing by the same enemy. Why, then, should not some attention be given to the enemy that slays those 70,000, even though that enemy be invisible and so small that hundreds of him could find place on the point of a needle? Germany has at present about 1,300,000 sufferers from phthisis, according to the estimate of Prof. Leyden, and 170,000 die annual- ly from this disease. In fifteen years the United States. lost over 2,000,000 by tuberculous diseases; and from figures carefully compiled for years it is known that one person in seven or eight dies in America-and Europe of tuberculosis, a preventable disease if we but knew, a curable disease, no doubt, when we kaow more.

Page 8

450 The Nation. [Vol. 68, No. 1772 PARLIAMENTARY GOVERNMENT. The editors and statesmen who, hav- ing relegated the Declaration of Inde- pendence to obscurity, are now insinuat- ing that a different kind of Constitution would be a good thing, may well ponder the observations of Prof. A. V. Dicey in an article in the June number of the Harvard Law Review, It was early point- ed out, when the acquisition of the Phi- lippines was under discussion, that the form of government prevailing in the United States was, in some important respects, ill adapted to imperialistic schemes. As long as the treaty with Spain lacked final ratification, however, discussion of this question was tabooed as academic; but now that the thing is done, and old men have seen visions while young men have dreamed dreams, the matter is up again. So representa- tive a paper as the Boston Herald has lately, in a leading editorial, announced its conviction that a parliamentary sys- tem is what we need, and that the soon- er we get it the better off we shall be. It seems to be assumed, without argu- ment, that the English system is the only one that will help us out of our difficulties. Prof. Dicey, whose authority on the subject will not be disputed, gets at the matter from an unexpected quar- ter by raising the question, Will the form of parliamentary government be perma- nent? The prevailing belief in the superiori- ty and permanence of the parliamentary type of government rests mainly upon two grounds—the success of the system in Great Britain, and its spread through- out the world. Of the truth of both these facts there can, of course, be no doubt. Whatever may be thought of her policy or her methods, no one can deny that England is, in the judgment of the world, an extraordinarily successful na- tion. Moreover, with the exception of the United States, every great Power having a constitutional form of govern- ment has followed, more or less closely, the English model. It is not the facts, however, but the inferences hastily drawn from them, that Prof. Dicey calls in question. Has the situation; lie asks, the significance cothmonly attributed to it, after all? Is Great’ Britain prosperous because she has a Parliament and a re- sponsible ministry; and are her compe- titors prosperous, also, in proportion as they have: imitated her? Is the parlia- mentary syetem an essential characteris- tic of a civilized or progressive state? On this point Prof. Dicey’s observa- tions are worth considering. To begin with, as he points out, the constitutional history of Wngland ig quite exceptional. Physically detactied the continent of Europe, its insular position has been its political salvation. It is difficult to believe that a people compelfed by their geographical situation to maintain large standing armies as a protection against powerful and hostfle neighbors, could ever have developed the free institu- tions which go to make up political liberty, but to which a military force at the command of the sovereign is a constant menace. Furthermore, while the parliamentary system in England has been the product of long and slow growth, its adoption by other countries has been very recent. Much of the form of the English Constitution was settled under Edward I., who died in 1307; but until the outbreak of the French Revo- lution, in 1789, the system remained, in general, the exclusive possession of Great Britain, and not until after the middle of the present century did it become practically universal in Europe. But why its spread? Largely, Prof. Dicey thinks, because the patent success of England has made it fashionable, and partly because nations, after a revolu- tion, are prone to indulge in political imitation. It is the fashion to have a Parliament, a Ministry, and an Opposi- tion. Countries as unlike as Canada and Japan have copied the virtues and the weaknesses of the system. But it is largely a fashion, after all, and, like “style” and “good form” in other things, is petted and praised while in vogue, and liable to be discarded when its no- velty has worn away. But there are deeper grounds of doubt. “Faith in Parliaments,” says Prof. Dicey, “has undergone an eclipse; in proportion as the area of representative government has extended, so the moral authority and prestige of. representative government have diminished.” The faith in the saving power of parliamentary institutions, so manifest during the first half of this century, has given way to séepticism and distrust. Seventy-five years ago the people’s dearest interests were cheerfully intrusted to the wisdom of a legislative assembly; to-day, we frame constitutions of portentous detail, denounce the party system, and clamor for the referendum and proportional rep- resentation. The fathers fought for rep- resentative government as the only guarantee of civil and political liberty; the sons cry out that the blessings are small and the evils very great. Parlia- ments are no longer a novelty, nor are their proceedings secret, and the com- bination of frequency and publicity has worked to their discredit. The severest criticism of parliament- ary government, however, comes from the acknowledged failure of parliaments to do successfully the work now de- manded of them. For destructive work they are well fitted. The abolition of feudal privileges and class distinctions, the demolition of governmental forms and legal codes, and the punishment of enemies and traitors, are operations which representative assemblies have shown much skill in performing. But the legislation demanded at the pre- sent day is essentially constructive; and it is here that parliaments and con- gresses alike have thus far earned small measure of gratitude. The reason, as has often been shown, lies in the in- herent unfitness of a large and miscel- laneous body of men for the perform- ance of work primarily demanding knowledge, experience, and skill. The protection of property, the assurance of personal rights, and the uplifting of the masses of the people, are the tasks of modern parliaments; they are also the tasks that no parliament has yet per- formed in any but a bungling way. Prof. Dicey modestly suggests that his reflections have speculative rather than practical interest; but their significance for us in this country is not altogether remote. Parliamentary government has through centuries become part and parcel of the whole political habit of mind of the English people; but it is not part and parce! of ours, nor have we, historically, any suihcient preparation for it. Seriously to advocate such a change is to demand a form, trusting to luck to give us the substance later on. The whole argument, indeed, rests on the assumption that henceforth we are to do as England does, which is sheer nonsense. If we set out to become an empire, we may very likely have to fur- ther amend our Constitution to bring that about; but until we have secured purity in elections, a sound civil service, and a President who will keep his word, we can anticipate no greater success from a parliamentary form of govern- ment than we can have whenever we will from the government we now possess. TRUE EMPIRE-BUILDERS. Mr. ‘ohn Morley, in his speech to a Liberal Association on May 25, said that we heard a good deal nowadays about empire-builders, but that we did not always discriminate the true ones from the sham. “Is the only empire-builder,” he asked, ‘the man who goes into Africa or anywhere else, makes a syndicate, takes land from the natives, kills them if they object, acquires a new patch on the map and colors it ” Mr. Mor- ley proceeded to answer his own ques- tion by speaking of Cobden and Bright and those who worked with them to ex- tend English commerce and to spread abroad in the earth the arts of peace, as the men who really laid the founda- tion of the present British empire. There is a very simple and conclu- sive test which can be applied to this matter, in this country as well as in England. Who pays the cost of em- pire? Whatever else is true of Imperial-

Page 9

June 15, 1899] The Nation. 451 gularity. Where does the money come from? Not from new territéry annexed or colonies or protectorates; they are a drain on the Treasury, not feeders. It is the home industry that is taxed to pay for enterprises abroad. It is the impost upon foreign trade and upon domestic commerce, the tax on merchant and banker, upon manufacturers and corpo- rations, which alone enable the Govern- ment to pay its sailors and soldiers and ministers and consuls and special agents of expansion. Empire is founded on taxation, and therefore the men in any country who build up its wealth, extend its commerce, develop its indus- tries, carry on its business, are the true artificers of its imperial power. It is perfectly true, then, as Mr. Mor- ley said, that the statesmen who struck off the shackles from English trade con- tributed more to make the British em- pire strong and enduring than any gene- ral or explorer or annexer of them all. In like manner is it true of the United States that we are not to look for our real empire-builders to Congress or cabi- net, to army or navy, but to our work- shops and counting-rooms, ships and railways, and wheat and cotton fields, inventors and captains of . industry. There are the sources of our wealth, and what is more, the sources of our national prestige. Who are the men who to-day are doing most to impress the world with the potency of this nation? Not our Admirals or Generals, least of all our Congress, but the manufacturers who are snatching away from all com- petitors contracts for bridges and steel rails in Egypt and India, and who are selling locomotives in England and ships’ plates in Scotland. These are the men who, by their enterprise and skill, are making Europe “sit up” as it re- cognizes the commercial giant across the sea, Here we have suggested to us the pro- per way for the United States to “take her place among the nations.” Accord- ing to our upstart Imperialists, this phrase means going in for a lot of unde- sirable territory inhabited by undesira- ble people, keeping them in order, and entering in general upon a course of in- ternational swagger and quarrelsome- ness. This is very like the parvenu’s idea of the pleasure of being rich—to get drunk often and to make a beast of himself. But to take our place among the nations to show them what organized industry cag do, what diffused intelli- gence can make a people capable of, what invention and education and hu- mane reforms can achieve—this is a very cheap thing in the eyes of our Washing- ton vulgarians, who reckon up national power by guns and colonial syndicates and conquered peoples; but it is, never- theless, the true patriotic ideal to work and live for. : Ancther overlooked element in impe- rial strength is peace. In the mouth of c’est la paix,” was tricky and insincere, yet there is a great truth in it. Nothing is more remarkable in the long reign of Victoria, under whom the British em- pire has grown to be what it is, than the Queen’s ardent and constant desire and labor for peace. Some one has late- ly unearthed a sermon preached in St. Paul’s by Sydney Smith, at the time of her Majesty’s accession, in which oc- curred the following passage: “A second great object which I hope will be impressed upon the mind of this Royal lady, is a rooted horror of war—an earnest and passionate desire to keep her people in a state of profound peace. The greatest curse which can be entailed upon mankind is a state of war. All the atrocious crimes committed in years of peace—all that is spent in peace by the secret corruption or by the thoughtless extravagance of nations, rare mere trifles compared with the gigantic evils which stalk over the world in a state of war. . . I would say to that Royal child, Worship God by loving peace—it is not your humanity to pity a beggar by giv- ing him food or raiment—I can do that; that is the charity of the humble and un- known—widen you your heart for the more expanded miseries of mankind—pity the mothers of the peasantry who see their sons torn away from their families—pity your poor subjects crowded into hospitals, and calling in their last breath upon their distant country and their young Queen. Py Extinguish in your heart the fiend- ish love of military glory, from which your sex does not necessarily exempt you, and to which the wickedness of flatterers may urge you. Say upon your death-bed, ‘I have made few orphans in my reign; I have made few widows: my object has been peace. I have used all the weight of my character, and all the power of my situa- tion, to check the irascible passions of mankind, and to turn them to the arts of honest industry; this has been the Chris- tianity of my throne and this the gospel of my sceptre.’ ”’ This reads almost like unconscious prophecy—a sketch of the real policy the Queen has steadily pursued. She and her Ministers are to-day ruling an em- pire vastly greater than that of 1837, but they know that peace is essential to its continuance in unabated strength, and so the more England’s might grows in their hands, the more they strive to make its every display peaceful. Indus- try and commerce and peace—these three are the great empire-builders, and the greatest of these is peace. BIMETALLISM ABROAD. The Gold-Standard Defence Associa- tion of Great Britain has issued a pam- phlet giving a summary of the bime- tallic controversy to date. The last chapter supplies information concerning the present views and doings of the bi- metallists in England, derived from the testimony of Lord Aldenham and M# Robert Barclay, the President of the Bi- metallic League and the chairman of its executive committee. Both of these gen- tlemen consider the subject still alive. Both of them think, however, that the battle ought to be fought hereafter on a basis of a ratio of 22 to 1 between silver and gold instead of 15% or 16 to 1, and, what is still more singular, they think that the United States would coéperate Napoleon III, the phrase, “L’Empire in that plan. Theonly evidence offered is a personal letter from Secretary Hay to Lord Aldenham (published some time ago) in which the writer says: “Our cabinet, like your own, is considerably divided in opinion upon the question of practical bimetallism. Neither the President nor a majority of my col- leagues have in the least changed or modified the views which they held last year in regard to the great desirability of an international agreement on the subject.” He added that the Govern- ment of the United States was “open to consider the question of the ratio,” and that he had no doubt that France was equally so, but that the present Government of the United States would not initiate new negotiations. This let- ter was evidently intended to shelve the question, but it appears to have conveyed to the minds of Lord Aldenham and his colleagues the notion that, if England herself would initiate new negotiations, the United States would assent to a ratio of 22 to 1. The magic of this ratio is that it would make the metallic value of the rupee equal to is. 4d., or the price which the Government of India seeks to maintain for it. Hence these tears of joy. The pamphlet of the Gold-Standard Defence Association then considers the attitude of the Democratic party of the United States on the subject, holding that this country is the most important factor of the bimetallic movement, if there is still such a movement. It pre- sents evidence on the one side showing that silver as a political issue among us is dead, and on the other that it is still alive. It leans, however, to the opi- nion that, if not dead, silver has ceased | to be the dominant issue, and hence that the English bimetallists are deluded if they expect help from the United States in the near future. This is a safe conclusion, and it may be added that if the English bimetallists are “banking” on the conception that Mr. Bryan and his supporters will join them in favoring the ratio of 22 to 1, they are vastly mistaken. They do not understand the force of catchwords tn American politics,,The words 16 to 1 have grown up with the present gene- ration of gilverites. Very few, indeed, know what they mean, or what any ratio means. Hence their suspicions will be aroused by any attempt to substitute new words in place of them. To introduce such a change it would be necessary to explain to the masses, first, what is meant by 16 to 1, and then what is the significance of the charge, and why it is deemed advisable. No large proportion of them could ever be brought to a clear understanding of the reason; but if it could be made plain to them that the “dollar of the fathers” was to be sacri- ficed in order to meet the views of the Hindoos, a howl of derision would be heard from one end of the land to the

Page 10

452 f The Nation. [Vol. 68, No. 1772 other. Not even Bryan could hold his party together on such a platform. The truth is, that the life has entirely gone out of silver as a political issue in this country. All the talk that is now heard of it is a formality. It is uttered for the sake of appearances and to keep up a pretence of consistency. This is especially true of Bryan’s talk. He prates about silver in order to keep him- self in evidence as a candidate for the nomination, but there is no heart in what he says. The Democratic hoi polloi are for Bryan, not because he is for sil- ver, but because he was their standard- bearer in 1896, their hero and martyr. Mr. Bryan himself does not put silver in the foremost place in his speeches and magazine articles, but he introduces just enough of it to keep the campaign of 1896, and himself as the central figure in it, before the people. He does not mean that*the old platform shall be forgotten, but neither does he mean that the cam- paign of 1900 shall be fought on that is- sue. He knows that a repetition of the campaign of 1896 would be another de- feat for him, because the silver issue is not the one which people are now think- ing and talking about. What the chief issue may be is not yet certain. It may be Imperialism, it may be Trusts, it may be McKinley’s surrender to the spoilsmen, but it cannot be silver, for the reason that fresh interest cannot be pumped into it. : As regards international bimetallism, neither Bryan nor his party ever took any interest in it, or cared anything about it. They never contributed: any votes or influence to the promotion of it. They have always looked at it askance. They have considered it a mancuvre of the Republicans when hard pressed, a trick adopted to gain time and stave off a decision. For this reason, in their platform of 1896, they cut themselves loose from all such devices, and demand- ed free aud unlimited coinage of silver “without waiting for the aid or consent of any other nation.” If English bi- metallists are looking to the Bryanites for aid and comfort in the future, they are relying on a party which never had any sympathy with them in the past, and would consider the ratio of 22 to 1 as a laughing-stock if not an impiety. The pamphlet of the Gold-Standard Defence Association gives a résumé of the bimetallic movement on the conti- nent of Europe since the collapse of the Wolcott Commission. The silver propa- ganda existed in only three countries, France, Germany, and Belgium, No new steps have been taken, and only one meeting has been held since the failure of the Wolcott negotiation. On the 18th of December, 1897, the German Bimetal- lic League held a meeting and passed a resolution saying that while the opposi- tion of the English bankers might delay bimetallism, it could not be permanent- ly prevented. In France M. Méline made a speech of no particular impor- tance, and since then the question has been allowed to slumber. GREAT BRITAIN AND THE TRANS- VAAL, The breaking off of the negotiations between Sir Alfred Milner and President Kriiger, with the admission that they were fruitless and will not be resumed, is taken in England as a very serious event. Such it undoubtedly is, though the hot-heads who are jumping to the conclusion that it means war are likely to be disappointed. Lord Salisbury has found a way out of more than one seem- ingly hopeless diplomatic impasse, and it will be strange indeed if he does not de- vise some means of peaceable adjustment of the Transvaal difficulty. Yet the Bri- tish Government is bound to do some- thing. Mr. Chamberlain has gone too far to retreat. He has taken the posi- tion that the situation of thousands of British subjects resident in the Trans- vaal is intolerable, and if renewed di- plomatic pressure does not induce the Boer authorities to make it tolerable, force will be resorted to in the end. There can be no doubt about that. As to the points at issue between the two countries, a fair outside judgment would be that the Boers are technically right on all, but morally wrong on all. In strict legality, and by the hard-and- fast terms of the London Convention and international law, we do not see that Mr. Chamberlain has any case. He is es- topped, in the first place, from asserting any right to interfere with the internal government of the Transvaal. Whatever ‘verbal disputes may be raised over the precise terms of the London Convention of 1884, the broad fact remains that Lord Derby, in an official English interpreta- tion of that convention, explicitly de- clared that under it the Boer Govern- ment would be “left free to govern the country without interference.” The only reservation was that any treaty nego- tiated by the Transvaal with a foreign state “shall not have effect without the approval of the Queen.” But Mr. Chamberlain argues, or at any rate his friends argue, that England, by the very fact of enjoying a suzerainty over the Transvaal, has the legal right to demand, on behalf of British resi- dents, a redress of grievances. This is an unsound argument, It is like a farm- er insisting that because a neighbor has no right to cut a road through his land without his consent, therefore he is en- titled to compel his neighbor to repair a barn or drain a pond. On the bare to pay you $20, or whatever you please to demand. Kriiger is as strenuous as Shylock in pointing to the letter of his bond and the law, and is legally in an even more impregnable position, since there is no likelihood of any Portia ar- riving on the scene. On one point—the dynamite monopoly —Mr. Chamberlain has openly maintain- ed in the House of Commons that tho Boer Government has been guilty of a breach of the London Convention. He bases this contention upon the clause guaranteeing that there shall be no in- terference with the commerce of British subjects in the Transvaal. But the point is strained. The dynamite monopoly does, not discriminate against the Brit- ish as such. In effect it hurts them, but it, is not a measure specifically di- rected against them as Englishmen. A heavy tax on beer, or on the mineral water which the unlucky dwellers in Johannesburg are compelled to drink to escape being poisoned, would bear hard on the English, yet it could not be held to be a breach of the Convention. In fact, though Mr. Chamberlain assert- ed that the law officers of the crown sustained him in his contention, the weight of legal opinion is decidedly against it. Kriiger has not been asleep. He has solicited the opinion of eight distinguished international lawyers—one of them Prof. Westlake of Cambridge— and all are unanimous in holding that he is quite within his legal rights, so far as the dynamite monopoly is concerned. So he is, undoubtedly, in the other burning question of the naturalization laws of the Transvaal Republic. These are out- rageous and oppressive, yet the legal competence of the Boer Government to enact them cannot be questioned. Yet with narrow legal right on his side, as respects every point in dispute, President Kriiger and his Government are taking a position which cannot be morally maintained. As Mr. Balfour said last week, the Boers are denying “the elementary rights of civilization.” The grievances of the foreign residents of the Transvaal are great. They have a large part of the property, and pay much more than half the taxes, of the coun- try, and yet are left almost absolutely without representation in the Govern- ment. Full citizenship can now be ac- quired, we believe, only after a residence of fourteen years, and even then under onerous and humiliating conditions, The inhabitants of Johannesifurg are not even allowed a voice in municipal af- fairs. The city is wretchedly governed, is, in fact, a “death-trap”; yet the dwell- ers in it have no way of exerting politi- cal power to bring about a sanitary re- form and remove a constant peril to life. To all appeals and remonstrances, the stolid Boers return a Papal non-possu- mus, or a Tweedian “What are you go- ing to do about it?” and go on taxing

Page 11

June 15, 1899] The Nation. 453 er victims, and forbidding them the right even to educate their children as they would. Now this, all must agree, is a situation to which an end should be put in some way. By urging upon Kriiger and upon the world, as it is evident from Mr. Balfour’s speech that the Eng- lish Government means to do, the duty of having some regard to natural human rights, as against technical legal power, it will be in a position to secure general sympathy and support if, later, it has to extort by force what should have been yielded to reason and the larger justice. HEINRICH KIEPERT. Last year, when Heinrich Kiepert cele- brated his eightieth birthday, his friends and former pupils, as well as geographers who had come under his wide-reaching in- fluence, presented him, in characteristic .German fashion, with a stately volume, a Festschrift, to which each had contributed an article on some subject near to the heart of the aged and beloved scholar. But even then Kiepert had so far succumbed to the maladies arising from extreme old age that he could take but little part in the festi- vities held in his honor, and now he has passed away, having failed to round out his eighty-one years. Kiepert was a born worker, and in con- sequence the range of his knowledge be- came marvellously wide. His devotion to truth was abso and he was fired by an unflagging usiasm for his science which nothing | t death could quench. Now that death has claimed him, his passing leaves a peculiar gap in the ranks of the devotees of the science of geography, which at present none may fill— certainly not as the master filled his post. He was a tho- roughly rounded geographer; there was ab- solutely no corner of the globe, however remote, about which he could not give every detail known to science up to date. In so far, he will have successors. But Kiepert was more: he was an archeological geo- grapher, if the term be allowed, and as such he stood alone and wunapproachable. As archzological geographer, Asia Minor was his hobby, his pet, his peculiar delight, upon which he expended much time in a variety of ways. He made journeys in Asia Minor at four different periods of- his life, the last falling in his seventieth year (1888). The simple statement that he had collected every scrap of knowledge that bears upon Asia Minor, however sweeping it may seem, has a much wider implication than most + readers will imagine. Of course Kicpert had at his fingers’ and his pencil’s ends Greek and Roman literature relating to Asia Minor; of course he was thoroughly at home in the mighty ‘Acta Sanctorum,’ the ‘Acta Conciliorum,’ the mass of Greek and Latin inscriptions which are profitable for geography, not to mention such minor things as the Byzantine lists, Hierocles, the Itineraries, and all that modern travellers of European nationalities have had to say upon the subject. But after he had learn- ed all that down to the bottom, and had drained from all these sources every frag- ment of knowledge in a measure unattairi- ed before by any man, he found that needed much more of which he knew no . thing as yet, much that was sealed to him. ‘ * He determined to unseal the sealed. This involved the learning of modern Greek, Turkish, and Arabic, in order to find out what the writings in those languages might have to tell him in regard to the geogra- phy of his beloved Asia Minor, and to this task he set himself, and set himself suc- cessfully. By this means he became pos- sessed of a kind of knowledge unattainable by the average geographer. For instance, he knew what the Turkish archives, Turkish lists, and Turkish so-called maps could tell him. This knowledge he used not only in his cartographic work, but also to con- trol the vagaries of ignorant but well-mean- ing travellers. The present writer’s road- notes on Asiatic topography have a host of marginal annotations by Kiepert, whose ac- curate information made him able to say (to choose two out of many instances): “No, this is incorrect; you have wrongly heard Allah when the word spoken was Ala,” or, “The Turkish lists do not bear you out.” His knowledge was not held as a hidden treasure; he had much, and he gave freely. ‘He had gained it, however, in order to add to it, and though he gave freely, he was but sowing the seed, and he expected some return in kind for every geographical gift. No one ambitious of exploring remote and unfamiliar corners ever applied to him for an up-to-date map of the region without getting one that included every known de- tail; for at once the untiring worker betook himself to that mighty table in the big room in the Lindenstrasse, and in due time the traveller had his trusty guide. But much of this sort of work brought no return to Kiepert, for selfish, thoughtless, or lazy men failed to make those additions to knowledge which the master had finally hoped for—fail- ed often to make any report to him; and the otherwise so genial man was full of bitter- ness in speaking of such cases. But when some return, however imperfect, was made to him, then every single word was weighed with the greatest care, and every single compass-bearing was made to do its part, in shaping the mighty map ypon the mighty table. He shirked no toil in utilizing for science the returns thus made, and when one traveller entered the aforementioned big room, he was greeted with the words: ‘Ach, mein Heber, theuerer Herr, Ihr Journal hat mir so ziemlich ein Vierteljahrchen meines Lebens gekostet.”” As they stand in print, these words might be regarded as reproach- ful; but as they came from his mouth they conveyed to the mind of the hearer the great- est compliment, and in hot haste the good wife was summoned to come and help wel- come the man who had robbed him of three months of his life. And warmly affectionate the welcome was. What Kiepert has done for Asia Minor cannot be measured; he has done everything, and much that goes under the name of other men is in the end Kiepert’s. When he be- gan to study the country, its geography was where Ritter had left it; with the exception of the seaboard, which might be reached by Eurdpean ships, it was practically an un- known land, whereas now there are few re- gions that have not been explored and mapped, and this state of affairs is due in greatest measure to Kiepert, either directly or indirectly. As a member of the Central- Direction of the Imperial German Archeo- logical Institute, he has been the immediate and inspiring cause of many of the recent explorations, just as he was the indirect cause of much that was done in the pre- ceding decades. The purpose of this note is to emphasize one phase of his manifold nature; to praise him is really impertinence. An outline of his life and a list of his works may be found in any encyclopa@dia. FRANCISQUE SARCEY. Paris, June 1, 1899. The death of Francisque Sarcey, the theat- rical critic of the Temps, has been quite an event, and has for a few days distracted the public mind from the too famous and en- grossing affaire Dreyfus. Parisians have al- ways been passionately fond of the theatre, and this taste is universal; you will find it in all classes of society. It is even more strong- ly marked in the people and in the small bourgeoisie than among the wealthy classes and the aristocracy. With the small bour- geoisie the theatre replaces all the amuse- ments of society. Our shopkeepers, after having worked all day, delight in going with their wives to some restaurant, and, after a good dinner, hearing a good play. Without having had any classical education, they ac- quire a sort of taste, not of the highest sort, to be sure, but still sufficiently accurate and refined. They have their favorites, their likes and dislikes; they are, as a rule, very indulgent, and never show their discontent by hissing, notwithstanding the old rule of Boi- leau: “C’est un droit qu'a la porte on achéte en en- trant.” Francisque Sarcey may be said to have been the idol of this numerous theatrical public, chiefly compesed of the French bour- geoisie. He had himself received a very high culture, having been a distinguished pupil of our Normal School; but he was essential- ly what we call a bourgeois, a word of dificult definition, which connotes some of the best attributes of the French mind— common sense, poise, judgment—as well as some defects, such as a certain want of imagination, of exaltation, of enthusiasm. The intellectual ideal of the bourgeois of the Francisque Sarcey type is a combination of Epicurean wisdom, of the gayety of Rabe- lais, of the moral sanity of Moliére, of the clever and witty rationalism of Voltaire. Francisque Sarcey received at the Normal School the solid education which forms our best Latinists; but the Normal School forms very few Hellenists—the idealism of Greece is wanting in its pupils. They are all more or less Romans, and their literary produc- tions, full of substance and of logic, are lack- ing in grace and imagination. It would be difficult to find more finished types of the state of mind and intellect which I am at- tempting to describe than Francisque Sarcey and Edmond About. These men were to- gether at the Normal School and became very intimate friends. Sarcey was eminently a “Ciassic’’ (such was the name given to those who stood by the ancients, by Boileau, Racine, Corneille, Moliére, the great writers of the grand siécic).

Page 12

454 The Nation. : [Vol. 68, No. 1772 The French Theatre, which is a state in- stitution, governed by the famous decree signed by Napoleon at Moscow, is naturally devoted to the Classics, and their plays form the “repertory.” It was impossible that modern plays should not from time to time be played at the French Theatre, especially as, after 1830, there came a succession of dramatists who formed a very remarkable phalanx. Sarcey did not oppose, on the con- trary, he gave great encouragement to, the modern school of dramatists; but he insisted all his life long on the necessity of con- tinuing to play the “repertory.”” He main- tained that Racine, Corneille, and Moliére should always be played for the débuts of new actors and new actresses at the French Theatre, and that they should never be al- lowed to appear in modern parts before hav- ing shown themselves at home in the great plays of our best classic authors. This was, in his eyes, a necessary discipline. He had, of course, some difficulty in defending his ground against the new artists, who find it so much easier to play modern and amusing parts than to give their full value to the beauties of a literature which is not exactly the representation of modern life and the echo of modern sentiments. It is, however, to the credit of Sarcey that he succeeded in imposing on the French Theatre a discipline which has greatly contributed to make it the mode] theatre of our time. He was not so fortunate in other points. He made a perpetual crusade against the ex- aggeration of the importance given in the modern theatre to what we cail the mise en ecéne—that is to say, the scenery and all its accessories. He maintained that this exces- sive devotion to purely material details was not favorable to real art; that the interest of a drama or of a comedy was to be found in the dialogue, in the development of a situation and of characters, and that the at- tention of the spectator was not to be ab- sorbed by a show of furniture, of costumes, of palaces, of fine rooms. In the Middle Ages, in the great mysteries which were played before the people, the scenery was of the simplest. There were great boards behind the actors, on which were written in big letters: ‘‘This is Jerusalem,” or, ‘This is Constantinople.”” The tragedies of Corneille and Racine did not require much scenery; fidelity to the old rules of Aristotle’s three unities implied unity of place during the five acts of a tragedy. The actors played all their parts in the costume of their own time. We can now hardly imagine Phédre or Iphi- génte in powder, with silk gowns and hoop- petticoats, or Auguetue and Nero in the dress of the courtiéra Who came to applaud them; but there is very little doubt that the spectators of the seventeenth century felt as keenly the beauties of the tragedies of Racine and Corneille as we ourselves do. The antique world which is shown to us is, after all, also a conventional world; the Greeks of the time of Pericles, the Ro- mans of the time of Augustus, would prob- ably not recognize themselves at our French Theatre, careful as we may be of our scenery. One of the reproaches which Sarcey di- rected against the exaggerated care we now take of the scenery, is the long time re- quired for the arrangement of the stage he- tween the different acts—an interval so long that modern representations become a real fatigue in Paris, lasting as a rule as late as midnight, so that the worn-out spectators cannot be in their beds before half-past twelve or one o'clock. The best part of Sarcey’s life was spent at the time of the great triumphs of Augier, of Meilhac, of Sardou, of Alexandre Dumas the younger, of Pailleron. He had the plea- sure of witnessing and of fostering the tri- umph of a dramatic school which realized his conception of art: the study of life, the observation of the play of human passions, presented to the public by classical methods. By this I mean that the development of the plays of these dramatists is methodical, that there is a certain unity in them, that all the incidents converge towards a definite object. The analyses which Sarcey made of the dra- mas of these authors are marvellous when you consider that they were always written the day after their first representation; their clearness, their lucidity, their criticism can-" not be suffitiently praised. They were al- ways written con amore even when the critic felt tive necessity of being severe. He was often severe towards Sardou. Though he ad- mired the infinite cleverness of this extra- ordinary metteur en scéne and the ease with which he found his way out of the most complicated plots, he could never quite for- give his excessive preoccupation with the scenery, the dress of his personages—the picturesque part of the drama—which, in his opinion, became too great a distraction for the public and absorbed too much of the at- tention of the author himself. Sarcey had a great partiality for Meilhac, and always took pains to find even in his farces some elements of high comedy. Meil- hac was essentially a Parisian; his work may be compared to a glass of champagne— there will soon be little left of it, but it gave much pleasure to the generations who understood all its allusions and criticisms. How long will the works of these writers be played? I remember a feuilleton of Sarcey’s in which he prophesied that two plays only were sure to remain in the “repertory,” to take rank among the classics, the “Gendre de ‘Monsieur Poirier” and the “Demi-Monde,” ‘because they both struck a new chord and dealt with passions which are permanent in the human heart. Sarcey was much surprised and perplexed when he had to give an opinion on the pro- duction of a new theatrical school which affected to ignore or to despise all the rules of the past. The ‘“‘ThéAtre Libre” was founded by an actor of great talent, named Antoine. It did not pretend to anything ex- cept to give the public what the disciples of the new method (or rather want of method) called des tranches de vie, slices of life. No real drama, no real plot, no complications, no intrigue, nothing but dramatic photo- graphs, something in the style of a living cinématograph, in which people not only move but talk. It is undeniable that this “Free Theatre” has had its utility; it ac- took the trouble to follow, night after night, the representations of the new school, and, when there was a pearl on the dunghill, he was honest enough to pick it out. , It would be interesting to show the influ- ence which the Thé@tre Libre has had on the new dramatists, such as Donnay, Hervieu, and the rest—Sarcey did not attempt to deny it. The present school of our begt drama- tists is decidedly purely realistic; it is also pessimistic, and deals by preference with so- cial subjects. It does not adopt the old motto, “‘Castigat ridendo mores”; it is mark- ed by a certain sadness, even in its gayety. Sarcey encouraged its efforts, though he was himself of a robust, healthy, and cheerful disposition. He will not be replaced, in my opinion, for many years to come, as a the- atrical critic. He thought he had a mission, and he fulfilled it with an earnestness and a zeal beyond praise. THIS YHBAR’S SALONS. Paris, May 1, 1899. It is impossible to come away from the latest Salons without feeling just a trifle depressed and discouraged. One thinks of the immense activity during the last hundred years, one remembers the endless movements and schools and revolutions that have come and gone since the National Assembly of 1791 made an end for evermore to the old tyranny of the Academy; and then, in the face of this spring’s exhibitions, one can- not help asking to what purpose has been all this agitation, all this energy, ali this striving, all this struggling. A few thousand artists may exhibit in the place of the few hundred of a century ago, but the greatness of art depends not in the least upon numbers. Indeed, it is one of the most melancholy features of this huge col- lection that such acres of canvas and paper, such a wilderness of plaster and marble and bronze, should yield such an absurdly small crop of good, or interesting, or even irritatingly bad work. Now that the two Salons, as last year, are sheltered under the single vast roof of the Palais des Machines, one is more than ever impressed by the still is the fact that, as one makes one’s way through the labyrinth of galleries, there should be so little to arrest or hold the at- tention. There is much that is workman-

Page 13

June 15, 1899] The Nation. 455 tiny canvases, more than two; and the pic- tures that are thus more easily seen are dis- tinctly better worth seeing. I can imagine that any one who visited the Salon for the first time would be positively amazed at the high level of accomplishment attained; but to all those familiar with the artiats and their work there are signs, if not of exhaus- tion, certainly of fatigue. Naturally, the loss of Puvis de Chavannes is very seriously feit. His large decorative panels may not always have been of equal merit, but they were never entirely without charm, distinction, and, above all, the repose that could not but prove a relief in the midst of the sensations of the year. And his absence is the more keenly realized because in their place now hangs only the little portrait, simple, sombre, reticent, that he painted of his wife when she was still the Princesse Cantacuzéne, while the large decorative work by other artists seemg to violate every canon of his artistic creed. It comes as something of a shock to find Du- bufe consecrating. to his memory a canvas of gigantic scale, on which the dead master sits, with appropriate sadness, among nonde- script symbolical figures in emerald green draperies and violet wings, color and design both as completely out of sympathy with his aims and methods as well could be. Nor do I see much hope of his mantle as decorator falling upon the shoulders of those who evince most desire to wear it—upon either Anquetin or Boutet de Monvel, for example. There is astonishing vigor and force in a big allegorical ‘“‘Battle’” by Anquetin, a mass of men and horses with impossible arching manes, wrestling and grappling together in deadly combat, but so violent, so confused, you can but regret the misdirected energy of a painter of whose power there can be no question. I see that a French critic makes much of the fact that the work was done in some forty days, but the merit of a picture has absolutely nothing to do with the time and labor bestowed upon it. As for Boutet de Monvel, he has apparently taken one of the small colored illustrations from his ‘Jeanne d’Arc,’ enlarged it, and given pre- cisely the same composition in colossal pro- portions, but worked out with the minuteness and elaboration of the old illuminator. Bril- liant reds and yellows and purples that were amusing on the printed page of a small book become offensive and glaring when made to cover vast spaces. The decoration is for the church at Domremy, which is so dark, I am told (I have never been there), that ex- aggerated brilliancy is absolutely neces- sary, if the decoration is to produce its effect. This may be so, though I doubt it, and, in case, I think it a mis- not venture to answer for it until I saw the ceiling in place, nor do I feel that I can ap- preciate the panels he exhibits with it in their present surroundings. These are some of the most striking works, principally, if I except the Besnards, because of their size. To turn to smaller canvases is to find men like Carriére, Aman-Jean, Lher- mitte, Picard, Raffaéili, Gandara, and Blanche repeating more or less the same subjects or same designs or same effects we have had from, them in the past: M. Carriére becom- ing more vague, more mystical, more tragic than ever, though his theme may be one in itself so joyous as the morning greeting be- tween mother and children; M. Aman-Jean’s refinement, for the moment threatening to dwindle into feebleness. Then M. Simon, once so promising, grows more photographic in his portrait groups with every year; M. Cottet, once so original, is degenerating into a mere slave of his mannerisms. With re- gret, one discovers that Mr. Whistler sends nothing; nor is there anything by. Mr. Sar- gent or Mr. Dannat. Mr. McLure Hamilton has but two little portraite—characteristic and accomplished—in the place of the group of several he exhibited last spring. And Mr. Alexander’s ingenuity seems to be failing him, for his favorite model appears upon but one canvas, there twisted in a new and grace- ful curve over a violoncello. Even the sen- sationalists have come to an end of their re- sources. M. Jean Béraud’s hitherto fertile invention has carried him no further than a theatre rehearsal, and this year, at any rate, he must retire before M. Jean Veber, whose rather loathsome fight between two naked women, with hideous old hags for on- lookers, fascinates the crowd; and also be- fore M. De Groux, M. Louis Legrand, and M. Piot, who, each in his way, makes a bid for notoriety by madness of method, a perfect saturnalia of paint. The religious picture, too, is disappearing. M. Dagnan-Bouveret, recently the most enthusiastic exponent of the Scriptures, now confines himself to a portrait, and it is chiefly M. Carolus-Duran who keeps up the tradition by a Crucifixion, melodramatic, bituminous, ineffective. Real- ly the best and most genuine work comes from the landscape painters—from M. Cazin and his follower, M. Billotte, from Ménard, Griveau, Mouillé, and several others, more or less strong, whose canvases reveal a curi- ous romantic tendency. The reign of Real- ism, of Naturalism, of Plein-airieme, of Im- pressionism, is clearly at an end—that is, for the present generation. In the section of drawings and prints, I am conscious of the same fatigue, the same exhaustion. I looked in vain for the old gayety of experiment, the old triumphant solution of new problems. Men like M. Hel- leu, M. Florian, M. Renouard are not rep- resented. Fine woodcuts and wood-engrav- ings, some printed in color, are still sent by M. Lepére, color etchings by M. Raffaél- li, color lithographs by M. Gottlob and M. Heidbrinck, remarkably clever etchings by M. Louis Legrand; but the greater number of exhibitors are content to copy or imi- tate men already acknowledged as masters. Perhaps it should be noted that many art- ists are beginning to show the sketches and studies for their pictures, a capital plan, helping one, as it does, to understand their aims and intentions. But interest cen- tres chiefly about a roomful of drawings by M. Cazin, as refined and individual as his paintings, wonderful little studies of towns —a street or a place charmingly sugsest- ed—or else of the quiet, uneventful sketches of field or open country, where he so of- ten seeks his inspiration, or of women and children; studies these that make one wish he had not devoted himself so exclusively to landscape. The drawings are mostly in chalk or pencil on white paper, sometimes on gray paper, when they borrow some- thing of the tranquil, tender color of his twilights and his moonlit nights. There is never very much sculpture in the Champ-de-Mars Salon, but what there is, usually, is good. This year the greatest success is scored by Mr. Saint-Gaudens with his “General Sherman.” In its quiet dignity, it impresses one, the moment one’s eyes fall upon it, after passing, as one must to reach it, all the flamboyant, rest- less, contorted, posing statues of the other or Champs-Elysées Salon. There is so much character, so much authority, in the gaunt, spare figure, erect and alert in the saddle. The cloak, flying back in the wind, gives just the right suggestion of movement, though [ understand that Mr. Saint-Gau- dens means to modify it slightly, thinking that, as it is, it detracts somewhat from the fine sobriety and reticence of the whole composition. It is interesting to find an- other American, one hitherto known only as a painter, making his appearance as a sculptor: Mr. McLure Hamilton, whose bust of his mother is so able, so expressive in its simple severity, one might think it the work of the master sculptor, rather than the apprentice. M. Rodin, probably to his own great satisfaction, has not created the excitement of a year ago. The now famous “Balzac” is succeeded by a life-size “Eve” in bronze—an Eve after the fall, sad and ashamed, her arms crossed over her breast, her head bent low. It is beautifully con- ceived, full of emotion, subtle and strong in the modelling, but it seems to me that M. Rodin never succeeds quite perfectly in his larger designs. I like better the small, spirited bust of M. Falguiére which he is also showing. One wonders if the exhibition of this bust is not M. Rodin’s way of explaining to the public that he does not in the least resent the fact that the commission for the Balzac monument has been handed over to M. Fal- guiére. The new Balzac is, for me at all events, what the French would call the clouw of the Champs-Bilysées Salon. M. Rodin’s Balzac was so indisputable a failure, and yet, at the same time, so fascinating, so exasperating because it came so near being the work of genius he meant it to be, that it is inevitable curiosity should mingle with one’s desire to see the attempt of the man who has had the temerity to come after him, and so challenge comparison. M. Falguiére, evidently, has been overwhelmed by the de- licacy of his position, and, as if convinced that imitation is really the sincerest form of flattery, has made his Balsac as much like M. Rodin’s as a sculptor of so opposite a temperament could. The new Balzac sits, where last year he stood, his hands no long- er concealed, but crossed comfortably and inelegantly over bis knees; he wears the same indefinite garment, partly dressing-

Page 14

456 The Nation. * [Vol. 68, No, 1772 too, I think, has lost a fine opportunity. To him has been intrusted the statue of De Lesseps to be set up at the entrance of the Suez Canal, and he has imagined nothing nobler and more dignified than a man—no doubt the portrait is irreproachable—in a dress-suit, one hand holding the map of the canal, the other outstretched in the most conventional and theatrical of gestures. If, for the rest of this exhibition, though the larger of the two, I have left myself but little space, I have done so intentionally. There is little to be said that has not been said before many times. Again one is confronted with the enormous canvases, the big machines, meant to capture by sheer force the attention they could not claim by merit alone. M. Jean-Paul Laurens is al- ways an exception. His large histori- cal compositions are designed for a de- finite purpose. This year he shows a ceil- ing for a public building in Toulouse, scho- larly, but, with its persistent reds, less re- strained and sober in color than usual. Of the others, even M. Tattegrain, who once knew how to put a picture together, is beginning to sacrifice everythinr to the gruesomeness of his details, so that, in his ‘‘Saint-Quentin pris d’assaut,’’ the eye wanders aimlessly from group to gtoup, from figure to figure, as ina “yelléw” jour- nalist’s picturesque report, never by chance taking in the effect of the dramatit scene as a whole; and, unfortunately for the paint- er, a picture of this kind is forgotten as promptly as the printed report. The work that tells, in the only fashion an artist should care to have it tell, is found rather in the melancholy gray landscapes of M. Pointelin, who may keep on for ever paint- ing the wide, desolate moorland, the long barren hills he loves, but who does it with such feeling for the poetry of light and air that they have all the variety of Na- ture herself; in the stately, formal com- positions of M. Harpignies; in the little idylis of M. Fantin-Latour. These are, as they have been so often before, the few good things that reconcile one to such a waste of paint. I thought, too, that the work of a few American exhibitors—a delight- ful little Dutch baby by Mr. MacEwen, the well-drawn cattle by Mr, Bisbing, the low- toned pastorals by Mr. Truesdell—were, in their refinement, pleasant contrasts to the typical Salon picture. The seas of Mr. Boggs and the tulips of Mr. Hitchcock also stand out with something like distinction. The prints and drawings here have al- ways been dull and unimportant compar- ed to the series at the Champ-de-Mars, and now, with M..Fantin-Latour and M. Wiliette both absent, they are more for- lorn than ever; an occasional innovation in the shape of an experiment in color, a sin- gle lithograph by M. Dillon,.two or three worth noting by M. Huvey, and M. Leleu, and the wood-engravings by Mr. Wolf are not quite enough to compensate one for wading through such a large collection of indifferent interest. Perhaps I ought to add that in both Salons more and more attention is being paid to the purely decorative arts, and that in the New Salon a prominent and dis- tinguished place is given to Mr. Tiffany's glass, which is also, by the way, being shown just now in London. N. N, Oorrespondence. TEMPERANCE AND EXPANSION. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: The United States having emerged from the smoke of the Spanish war, with Cuba, Porto Rico, and the Philippines more or less attached to her, it is pertinent to ask what effect these new and (to the United States) strange relations will have on the temperance question. Our inquiry need not take us far afield. Expansion means forcible subjection of the countries over which our self-appointed au- thority extends; forcible subjection means the maintenance of a large army, and, not- withstanding the plain prohibition of Con- gress, the beer canteen, according to the opinion of the Attorney-General (an opinion } fearfully and wonderfully made), is allowed to attach itself like a leech to our army under a pretext of the shallowest and empti- est sort. It is not necessary to picture here the evils that follow in its wake. The mere fact that the best and most experienced of- ficers of the army, such men as Gen, Miles, Gen. Shafter, and Gen. Brooke, are stoutly opposed to the canteen, is sufficient to con- demn it in the eyes of the average layman. Yet this curse bids fair to be a permanent adjunct. to our army, and therefore to our new idol, expansion. But there is another and quite as atrocious a way in which expansion is affecting tem- perance.. One of the chief pretences with which we have apologized for the shooting down of the Filipinos in cold blood is that we intend to convert them from barbarism and to make them moral and upright. Never- theless, during the American occupation of the Philippines, between three hundred and four hundred saloons have been established in Manila alone. It seems incredible that such a revolting condition can be possible, and yet so undeniable is the fact that our comic papers have begun to picture the bar- room and the free-lunch counter as the sort of American free institutions that we shall give the Filipinos. The worst of the matter is, that there is no promise of improvement for the future. Our uniform treatment of the Indians in sup- plying them with ‘“fire-water,’’ contrary to treaty stipulations and to the instincts of morality and humanity, and the recent re- peal of the prohibition law in Alaska, augur badly for the needed relief. HENRY FREDRICKS. PHILADELPHIA, June 10, 1899. AN ENGLISHMAN IN RUSSIA. To THE EpIToR or THE NATION: Sir: Prof. Kittredge has directed my at- tention to a postscript of William Smith’s letter of the 15th of May, 1572, sent from Yaroslav in Russia to his brother James Wodcoke in Kent, contained in Thomas Wright's ‘Queen Elizabeth and her Times,’ vol. 1, p. 422. It runs as follows: “Brate Yakobe be possaldie pregottoul Sake. wroties : \ — —— o. DP ya Shotombite wt casein tartare Woke se walle _ thorized onna ys doute mina golli te take. boudes mina brate : sch WILLIAM june In a footnote the editor says: “This post- his friends in Kent.” In this statement he is, however, mistaken, for the postscript was meant as a confidential note to his brother, as the translation of it will soon show us. Ever after the discovery of Russia by the English in 1553, English merchants and their agents and military adventurers resided in Russia. Mention of this fact is made in Smith’s letter, by which we are also in- formed that his brother had been there be- fore: ‘“‘This country of Unsland [mistake for Rusland] is greatly changed since you were here, and things goeth not so convenient with Englishmen as it hathe done.“ During their long sojourn in Russia, many English- men acquired a speaking knowledge of the Russian language, and to one of them we owe the earliest collection of Russian bal- lads in existence, made in 1618. To this mat- ter I shall return at some future time. The passage given above is written in Russian. After making various allowances for mis- prints, incorrect readings of the editor, and superficial knowledge of the language of the writer himself, we get the following intelli- gible translation: “Brother James: Please procure for me a wife, one that is pretty and young, against the time of my return home, and please make my obeisance to Barbara Wood, and tell her to wait for me. If you succeed in doing this for me, you will be unto death the brother—Of your brother, “WILLIAM SMITHE.” This pretty sixteenth-century romance of which we get a glimpse through the Russian language is probably unique in English his- tory. It would be interesting to know whe- ther Smith ever was united to his lady-love. LEO WIENER. CAMBRIDGE, Mass., June 7, 1899. THE OSCITANT PROOF-READER. To THE EDITOR oF THE NATION: Str: Not many more amusing misprints are likely to be found than one in Saints- bury’s ‘Short History of English Literature’ (1898, p. 262), where the well-known line of Sidney’s first Sonnet is quoted: * ——— my nurse to me, look in thy heart and W. H. B. Notes. Dodd, Mead & Co. will shortly publish the only authorized edition of the: early novels of Henry Seton Merriman, which ‘have been re- vised, condensed, and in part rewritten. They have nearly ready the ‘Autobiography of Mrs. Oliphant.’ |}. Henry Holt & Co. announce ‘The Hooligan Nights,’ reminiscences of Alf. Hooligan, thief and counterfeiter, edited by Clarence Rook, a London journalist. D. Appleton & Co., The Century Co., and the Doubleday & McClure Co, are to pub- lish in conjunction the fifteen-volume edi- tion of Kipling’s works, which is to be marketed by the Book Department of the script was no doubt intended to astonish all

Page 15

June 15, 1899] The Nation. 45% magazine story of Mrs. Charlotte Perkins Stetson; and ‘On the Birds’ Highway,’ by Reginald Heber Howe, jr.—coast bird-studies from Maine to Maryland, with some 60 il- lustrations. ‘The Martial Graves of Our Fallen Heroes in Santiago de Cuba,’ by Dr. Henry C. McCook, will shortly be issued by George W. Jacobs & Co., Philadelphia, with photographs, charts, and maps. William Ellis Jones, No. 5 South Twelfth Street, Richmond, Va., invites subscriptions to the ‘Word-Book of Virginia Fo!k-Speech,’ by Dr. B. W. Green of Warwick. Only 300 copies will be printed. A new work on ‘Embroidery,’ by Lewis F. Day and Miss Mary Buckle, will be brought out in London by B, T. Botsford, and in New York by the Messrs. Scribner. The latest volume in the new edition of the writings of the late John Addington Symonds is the fourth appearance of his ‘Introduction to the Study of Dante’ (London: Black; New York: Macmillan). Mr. Brett’s ‘Cumulative Index to a Selected List of Periodicals’ for 1898 (Cleveland: The Helman-Taylor Co.} forms the third annual volume of this important key to “authors, subjects, titles, reviews, portraits’’—the last item not the least. We need only add that the periodicals here indexed number one hun- dred, and that especial paitis have been taken to make the year’s necrology complete. Mr. John Coleman Adams’s ‘Nature Studies in Berkshire [Mass.]’ (Putnams) will not se- cure him the literary rank of Burroughs, Bradford Torrey, or Thoreau, and his text pales in quality beside the photogravure il- lustration of Mr. Arthur Scott, his colaborer in the making of a handsome volume. These views are all charming and characteristic, and unusually successful in catching cloud effects. Mr. R. P. Porter confesses to the haste with which his ‘Industrial Cuba’ (Putnams) has been compiled. Yet as a record of in- formation, as distinct from the author’s opi- nions (some of which seem to have been even more hastily put together than his facts), the book is of considerable value. The existing Cuban tariff printed in full, the account of internal taxes and of the ap- portionment of public revenue, with the chapters on sanitation and transportation, furnish the best portion of Mr. Porter’s sta- tistical exhibit. ‘ There is unaffected modesty in Burr McIn- tosh’s title, ‘The Little I Saw of Cuba’ (F. Tennyson Neely), and the author, a newspaper correspondent, wholeft the island as ayellow- fever convalescent, makes no pretensions of any kind. His journalistic style is not com- mendable, but his observations with the Rough Riders are a respectable contribution to the material for that history of the San- tiago campaign which has yet to be written. Mr. McIntosh leaves us in no doubt as to his likes and dislikes, and among the latter he, with a mind devoid of sectionalism, includes equally Gen. Shafter and Gen. Wheeler. His own photographic views give a better idea of the country than most we have met with, and much enhance the value of a narrative ot some hardship and personal disappointment. F. Anstey’s ‘Love among the Lions’ (D. Ap- pleton & Co.) is clearly by the author of ‘The Tinted Venus,’ is characteristically ingenious in concealing the plot, aad is brief enough not to weary. If it adds nothing tothe au- thor’s reputation for humorous extravaganza, it cannot fail toprovoke a smile in thereader. The Jewish Publication Society of Ameri- -the dialects of to-day. ca, Philadelphia, is ably carrying on the task of popularizing Judaism and keeping its best spirit alive. It has issued some books of high scientific value, such as the translation of Graetz, Schechter’s ‘Studies in Judaism,’ and Dembitz’s ‘Jewish Services,’ along with others of much lighter weight which need not be particularized. Their last publication, Abrahams's ‘Jewish Literature’ (275 pages, in- cluding an excellent double-columned index of twelve pages), takes medium rank. It is an introductory sketch of Jewish literature from the Mishna to Mendelssohn, and is brightly written, clear, and accurate. Of course, the treatment is of the slightest— within such limits none other were possible— but the arrangement is good; each of the twenty-five chapters has a pointed heading and closes with a little English bibliography guiding to further study. The references to Arabic thought and literature might be more exact, but that lies off the writer’s track, and, besides, there are few Eps'ish books in which such references even syproach exact- ness. His little book fairly accomplishes its claim, and will take a useful place in the strange but just and healthy Jewish renais- sance which is upon us. Volume ix. of the Harvard Studies in Clas- sical Philology (Boston: Ginn & Co.) is largely devoted to the memory of the two great and well-beloved teachers whom Har- vard lost in the summer of 1897. The me- moir of Prof. George M. Lane is written by his former pupil and literary executor, Prof. Morris H. Morgan, while that of Prof. Frede- ric D. Allen is the work of his colleague and friend, Prof. Greenough. The two memoirs, which are accompanied by excellent portraits, together with a number of posthumous papers, now furnished with revisory notes, make this volume of the Studies of particular interest to many classical students. The in- fluence of Prof. W. M. Lindsay of Oxford, who was an instructor at Harvard in 1898, is shown in a series of seven studies in Plautus, mostly the work of his American pupils. Other articles are ‘‘Hidden Verses in Livy,’’ by M. H. Morgan, and the “‘Nonius Glosses”’ of the laie J. H. Onions, with note by Prof. Lind- say; while the last two-score pages of the volume are taken up with a careful and pains- taking analysis of the ‘‘Versification of Latin Metrical Inscriptions except Saturnians and Dactylics’—the work cf Prof. A. W. Hodg- man of the Ohio State University. Karl Dieterich’s ‘Untersuchungen zur Geschichte der griechischen Sprache von der hellenistischen Zeit bis zum 10. Jahrhundert nach Chr.’ (Leipzig: Teubner) is a late ad- dition to the constantly increasing list of German studies dealing with the history of the Greek language. This work has special reference to such inscriptions, papyri, and manuscripts as have come down to us from the period 300 B. c.-1,000 a. D., and deals especially with the xow4 or Greek of the Hellenistic period, and its relation to The connection of ancient with modern Greek, a language long despised by philologians, has now been as- sured by the works of such scholars as Krumbacher, Hatzidakis, and Thumb, whom Dieterich follows; and future investigations into the Greek of any period can hardly be made without some reference to the modern Gemeinsprache and dialects. The importance of modern Greek as a development of the ancient, and the fact that it is able to throw light on many difficulties of ancient Greek investigation, explains the extraordinary ac- ‘ tivities of German scholars in this direction during the last decade. Mr. Charles F. Lummis is about to print in his Land of Sunshine (Los Angeles, Cal.) an accurate translation of the Viceroy Revilla Gigedo’s report on California, the clearest and closest summary of Pacific Coast affairs and explorations from San Blas to Nutka, 1767-1793, that we possess. It has not been printed heretofore in English. It will run for about four months in the maga- zine. A map of the theatre of military opera- tions in Luzon, on a scale of nearly three miles to the inch, prepared under the direc- tion of the Military Information Division, is the special feature of the National Geogra- phic Magazine (Washington) for June. Com. H. Webster, U. S. N., contributes a reada- ble account of the Samoans, accompanied by illustrations, in which, referring to their singular hospitality, he says that ‘‘travel- ling parties can go from end to end of the group without expense for food or lodging, and the official ‘Large House,’ maintained by each village, is seldom vacant. This pe- culiar institution is provided by contribu- tions from every family in the place. One of the results of this type of hospitality is that the Samoan has beccme a great tra- veller. Large parties, resembling our ‘tour- ists,” band together and go from town to town and from island to island.” The Sa- moan {@ fond of games of skill, especially of a kind of quoits and of cricket. So strong a hold has the latter game taken upon the na- tives that it was no uncommon experience to find a village “utterly deserted by its in- habitants, for the entire population would be in a neighboring clearing, watching or tak- ing part’ in the game. It is not surprising to learn from another writer that the Sa- mean is averse to labor, and that those who have attempted agricultural pursuits in the islands have been compelled to import la- borers. The rates of wages are “$1 per day for laborers, or $10 per month with food; mechanics from $3 to $5 per day; clerks, $50 per month and board, and bookkeepers $100 per month and board. There are now con- stantly from 1,000 to 1,500 foreign laborers in the islands.” The editor makes a short statement in regard to the work of the Na- tional Geographic Society and its organ, which has afforded an opportunity for the publicaticn, in a popular form, of informa- tion that might otherwise have iain buried in voluminous reports. The Society has now 1,100 active and 500 corresponding members, and a special effort is being made to increase its membership, in order, among other things, to enlarge the magazine and to add to its attractiveness and value, The Annales de Géographie tor May con- tains an interesting description of a type of a primitive house as shown in the stone structures of southern Italy, known locally as trulli, casetle, and specchic. The trullo, or bee-hive house, is a small hut built of “dried” stones laid without cement, coy- ered with a cupola of the same material. The casella consists of several trulli joined together. The specchie are large truncated stone cones, and were no doubt originally intended for watch towers. Few of buildings, except possibly some of trullo not only as also the dryest and tations. There are

Page 16

458 The Nation. [Vol. 68, No. 1772 and a map showing the distribution of the different classes of these buildings, born of a land known in classic days as “‘petrosa Apulia.” There is also an illustrated de- scription of the irrigation works now ‘in process of construction at Assuan and As- siut on the Nile. At the former place at the time of the writer’s visit (February, 1899) there were 6,000 laborers employed, of whom 600 were Italians, the remainder na- tives. Referring to the common idea that in Egypt all things are immovable and unchangeable, he says that ‘“‘it seems to us, on the contrary, that in few countries are modifications, economic, geographic, and his- toric, at the present time so profound and so rapid.’ Pure science is represented in this number by an article on the geo- graphy of plants, founded on a recently pub- lished work, by A. F. W. Schimper, on ‘Plant Geography on a Physiological Basis.‘ In Petermann’s Mitteilumgen, number four, is the first part of an elaborate study, by Paul Langhans, of the distribution of Ger- mans and Czechs in northern Bohemia. In eight districts examined, a comparison of the census of 1880 with that of 1890 shows that in two districts the Germans, in six the Czechs, have increased. A. Gaedertz con- tinues his account of his preliminary survey in the province of Shantung in the inte- rests of the proposed German railway. He gives some figures showing the great com- mercial activity which prevails, and the pre- sent cost of transportation of the principal products, raw silk, cotton, coal, plaited straw, tobacco, vegetables, and fruit “‘in great quantities and-of good quality.” ‘You may make a canal or a railway with- out the consent of a people, but you cannot make a system of justice,” said Sir John Scott in a recent address in which he ex- plained the methods whereby he, as judicial adviser to the Khedive, obtained this consent. Acting on the principle that, in judicial re- form, “better men, not new measures,” were -Gemanded, he began by making provision for the education of Egyptians in Occidental law- Succeeding steps were the removal of hope- lessly incompetent and corrupt judges, and the replacing the seven tribunals in which seve- ral judges sat, with numerous single-judge courts placed in all parts of the country, over which a strict supervision is held. The re- sult is that cheap and prompt justice is brought within easy reach of every peasant. ‘There are fewer crimes in Egypt than there are in England in proportion to the popula- tion’; but when they are committed, the criminals, whatever their rank or position, are tried by the native judges, who show an independence amazing from the Oriental point of view. ‘One of the richest and most influential men in Lower Bgypt’ and a prince, cousin of the Khedive, have been sen- tenced recently by native judges to a convict prison, the one for forgery, the other for as- " gault. Sir John sums up his work in these closing words: ‘‘I found in 1890 a set of na- tive tribunals that were struggling for ex- istence. I leavo behind me a set of national tribunals which will, I trust, be the back- bone of the country for all time.” The proverbial excellence of the Prussian system of popular education is once more dis- proved by recent debates in the Landtag. The scarcity of agricultural labor during cer- tain seasons has led the landowners of the Eastern provinces to urge the passage of a law by which the time and duration of school sessions shall be made to depend more large- ly than heretofore upon “local conditions.” In the course of the debate it was shown that there are large districts in Pomerania where the children attend school only during the early morning hours between 5:30 and 9:30. Half-day schools are common in other places. In the province of Posen the dearth of teachers is such that a thousand positions are vacant, and there are schools in which two hundred children, or more, are under the charge of a single teacher! Elsewhere, chil- dren under nine years of age are not admit- ted to school for lack of room. (See the Padagogische Zeitung, May 11, 1899.) It is surprising that in Mecklenburg, which. in the number of pupils intrusted to one teacher does not exceed fifty, about one-half of the average in Prussia, while even in Saxony, probably the most advanced of all German States in matters of popular education, the average number of children to one teacher is seventy-three. It is evident that the effi- ciency of the school depends largely upon this proportion. —The report of Mr. Douglas Brymner on the Canadian Archives (Ottawa) once more calls attention to our Government’s neglect of the manuscript sources of American his- tory in Europe. The Library of Congress, where transcripts should be found, has never expended a dollar to obtain them. The Penn- sylvania Historical Society, under Mr. Stone’s direction, has done more than any other soci- ety in this good work. The field is practical- ly unworked, however many partial attempts to make an impression may be pointed out, Mr. Brymner has not only systematically taken transcripts of all that the Records Of- fice in England could afford, but he now an- rounces the arrival of copies made in Paris, extending from 1575 to 1767. Instead of Wash- ington being the centre of historical research in the British and French records, Ottawa offers a far richer opportunity, and one that cannot be offset by the Library of Congress for many years. The existence of these de- | posits serves to attract original material, as | the deposit with Mr. Brymer of papers re- lating to Bougainville proves. The expense of obtaining the transcripts is not heavy; and were a few of the larger libraries to com- bine, it would be one of the best undertak- ings for advancing the study of history at a very low cost. No one who has had occasion to write of colonial matters has failed to feel the need of such records, The delay and ex- pense of applying direct to London are prohi- bitory to individual effort; but a codperative plan would be simple and effective. —In his report for 1899, Mr. Brymner co- vers the records of Upper and Lower Canada during the Dalhousie and Maitland régimes. Certain documents, of especial interest, are printed in full as an introduction, among them being a hitherto unknown letter of Gen. Wolfe. He wrote, in June, 1759, in a tone of irritation at being ordered to Halifax to serve under the orders of one who had just been promoted over his head: “Rather than receive orders in the government of an offi- cer younger than myself (though a very worthy man) I should certainly have desired leave to resign my commission; for as I neither ask nor expect any favor, so I never intend to submit to any ill usage whatso- ever.” The disputes between Lord Dalhousie ; political matters is so far behind Prussia; nopoly of offices by a few families, there was always an opportunity for recrimination. The social and political vicissitudes cf Judge Wil-. lis are touched upon—a disturbing influence as marked as the matter of Mrs. Baton in Jackson’s day. One wormnan’s differences with another woman threatened the very policy of the state. The history of the land compa- nies in Lower Canada is very interesting, as they repeated some of the earlier experiences of our States in dealing with their Western lands; while the “naturalization question” arising from the election to the Assembly and rejection by the Crown of Barnabas Bidwell, an allen, fitly brings the report to a close. This resulted in an alteration in the law, but not in a satisfactory settlement of the ques- tion.. Mr. Brymner’s editing shows care, and this new volume is one more excellent pro- duct of his office. —Mr. A. H. Garland’s legal reminiscences (‘Experience in the Supreme Court of the United States, with some Reflections and Suggestion as to that Tribunal,’ Washington: John Byrne & Co.) are chiefly remarkable for their modesty. Most people of his dis- tinction would have made a couple of octavo volumes out of himself, while here we have only a hundred small pages. They are read- able, and here and there the author makes a good point, as where he observes, of the late Justice bradley, that it is doubtful if any man ever sat on the bench of the Su- preme Court who knew ‘“‘more law and more sorts of law than he.” A good story of Roscoe Conkling and ‘Matt’? Carpenter is given. Conkling, with a record of a case coming on at once in court in his hands, ap- plies to Carpenter for light on a point about which he says he is “troubled,” and asks what he, Carpenter, would do about it. Car- penter’s reply is, ‘Why, I wouldemploy a good lawyer.” Mr. Garland gives a long list of cases in which he was engaged in the Supreme Court, but the one which will perhaps cause his name to be longest remembered was He parte Garland, in which, as he somewhat grotesquely puts it, “the right of lawyers against legislative encroachments” was vin- dicated. So conspicuous at the time did this judgment make him that Ew parte became a sort of Christian name for him, as Ad in- terim did for another character of the Re- construction period. —The apotheosis of wood-engraving appears in ‘The Portfolio of National Portraits,’ just issued by R. H. Russell of this city. These portraits (India proofs, signed by the artist) are all on the grand scale, and are all from the same graver; but this latter circumstance would, we ventusze to say, never be inferred by one ignorant of the fact. It is a point of greatness on which we have had more than once occasion to insist in the case of Mr. Gustav Kruell’s work (for it is his which is in question), that it is absolutely devoid of technical mannerism; varying partly with the subject and partly with the artist's growth in mastery. The Sherman and the Grant are illustrations of the first, the two Lincolns of the second cause of this indivi- dual treatment. On the whole, the develop- as compared with the earlier prints. Mr. Royal Cortissoz, who supplies an introduc- tion, and a judicious comment on each print, rightly dwells on the immense qualities of portrait, surpassed by no other of character,

Page 17

June 15, 1899] The Nation. 459 or asa tour de force of the graver, which in the background simulates painting and in the general relief the plastic art. Of all, this portrait seems to us most alive. Besides those already enumerated are heads of Web- ster,Garrison,and Lee—the marvellous Web- ster substantially finished in seven days, and calculated to stand the test of seven centu- ries; the Lee, the latest in the line, and nobly treated, with a sort of arboreal background contrasting with the repose of the person, These seven characters belong to a storm-and- stress period almost forgotten were it not for the pension-budget, and are felicitously grouped. The proofs and letter-press are en- closed in a noticeably elegant carton, and may be so preserved, or the portraits may be framed by the happy possessor. —The second volume of Prof. Friedrich’s ‘Ignaz von Déllinger’ (Munich: Beck) de- scribes Déllinger’s eventful career from the beginning of the reactionary régime of the Bavarian Minister Abel in 1837 to the disso- lution of the revolutionary Frankfort Par- Hament in 1849. A queer occurrence, as viewed in the light of later events, was the removal of Prof. Kaiser from the theological faculty of the Munich University in 1841, be- cause he taught the doctrine of papal infal- libility, declaring the Pope to be the source from which Holy Writ derives its authority, and the absolute sovereign of the reasoning faculties and the laws of thought. He even stated that the successor of St. Peter might be “‘personaliy an unbeliever, a blasphemer, and a heretic,”” yet in his official capacity, as “the organ of Jesus Christ,’’ he would be, in all his utterances and decisions, unerring and inerrable. This idea was then denounce‘ by the highest dignitaries of the Church as “a crazy notion” and “an abominable heresy,” and the genial and tolerant Gérres tried to excuse it by characterizing Kaiser as “somewhat crack-brained” (etwas rappe- lig im Gehirn). Thirty years later this tenet, which had been censured by the bishop as the centre of a “‘whole snarl of false doc- ‘frines,”” was made a “dogma of the Church,” whichall good Catholics were bound to accept on pain of excommunication. It is no won- der that a serious scholar like Déllinger, who had seen the evolution of the system and its culmination in the Vatican deérees, should refuse to turn a somersault in the arena of dogmatics at the command of the master of the ring. He was honest even in his errors, and intellectual high-vaulting either for place or pelf was not in his line. One of the most interesting chapters is that on the Tractarian Movement in England and Déllin- ger’s relations to it:' As a Catholic, he na- turally rejoiced in the conversion of promi- nent Englishmen, and each case of this kind was celebrated with enthusiasm by the Gér- resverein in Munich. Subsequently theso conversions were a matter of deep regret to him, since they served to strengthen the specifically Romish and Jesuitical element in the Catholic Church and contributed essen- tially to the victory of ‘‘curialism” in 1870. Indeed, Manning began to inveigh against Dollinger even beford the Vatican Council, and afterwards denounced him with extreme bitterness because he failed to recognize an “fmpulse of supernatural grace’’ in the de- eree of papal infallibility. The account of the Lola Montez episode, and of the row which “her foot of marvellous beauty of form” kicked up in church and state as well as in . aeademic circles, is only another contribution to the history of the foibles and follies of the house of Wittelsbach. As a member of the Frankfort Parliament, Déllinger was far more liberal than the majority of the Conserva- tives, with whom he naturally associated, and never sacrificed his personal convictions to party fealty. He was an ardent advocate of German unity and a German national church, but soon saw that the time had not come for the realization of these ideals. THAYER ON EVIDENCE. A Preliminary Treatise on Evidence at the Common Law. By James Bradley Thayer. Bostoa: Little, Brown & Co. 1898. When a book covers so much ground as this, and is the result of so many years’ pa- tient research, it is often ‘difficult to review it at all. Not only must many of its interest- ing features be passed over in silence for want of space, but as to those selected for discussion, the candid critic must disavow competency to do much more than to give a slight idea of the scheme of the book, and to recommend careful study and com- parison of it with the work of the author’s predecessors. Prof. Thayer’s studies have already attracted wide attention, and pro- mise to attract more; his book is the only investigation of the subject by a lawyer and writer on law of the first rank since the appearance of Stephen’s Digest, and it deals with the law of evidence in a manner to most American and English lawyers wholly new—a treatment which may be said to combine the historical, the ration- alistic, and the legal methods. As to the au- thority of the author, it is so thoroughly re- cognized on both sides of the Atlantic that it is only necessary to say that he has made the subject his own. To our generation he speaks as the master of it. The idea which underlies the whole book is that what we call the “Law of Evidence” is an historical product of jury trial, or, at any rate, a product of causes of which the, development of jury trial was among the’ effects. Hence, the first four chapters deal with jury trial and its predecessors; ¢. g., trial by oath, ordeal, and battle. These chapters were published two years ago, in advance of the rest of the book, and reviewed by us at the time. (See the Nation, No. 1624.) It is unnecessary here to do more than call attention to the fact of this historical founda- tion; the remaining chapters now published are most important for their bringing pro- minently into view the rationalistic aspect of the law of evidence. In reading them, one of the things which force themselves continually upon the attention is the oppo- sition between the probative system adopted by the common law and the logical laws of proof, which, being laws of the human mind, not only underlie, but continually come into conflict with it. Among the matters which are discussed by Mr. Thayer in a way to arouse the liveliest interest, are “Law ‘and Fact in Jury Trials,” “Legal Reasoning’ as applied to the ascertainment of facts, “Judi- cial Notice,” “Presumptions,”’ “The Burden of Proof,” the “Parol Evidence” and the “Best Evidence” rules. A superstition which the author's re- searches tend to destroy is one embodied in the maxim, Ad questionem facti non reapon- dent fudices, ed questionem juries non reagon- dent juratores. This lies at the very threshold of the subject, for all matters of evidence are matters of fact; and if it Be really true that all matters of fact must be passed upon by the jury, and all matters of law by the court, we have at least an important guide to the Law of Evidence. But research shows not merely that there is no hard-and-fast line to-day, but that there never was one. Not only do ail general verdicts of a jury, such as the very common one of “Not guilty,” in- volve a conclusion of law (p. 253), but the courts settle and always have settled many questions of fact for themselves. “Was the deed that was put forward ‘rased’ or not? If a party claimed the right to de- fend himself as a maimed person, was it really mayhem? Was a person who pre- sented himself and claimed to be a minor. really under age? A stream of questions as to the reality, the rei veritas, the fact, of what was alleged before the justices was constantly pouring In. A prisoner, for ex- ample, had confessed; on being brought into court, he declared that it was by duress of his jailer. Was this so? To find this out, the justice took the short cut of sending for several of the fellow-prisoners and the jailer. and questioning them all in the prisoner's presence, and he found that it was not true. This, again, is just as it is to-day. Courts pass upon a vast number of questions of fact that do not get on the record or form any part of the issue. Courts existed before juries; juries only came in to perform their own special office; and the courts have al- ways continued to retain a multitude of functions which they exercised before ever juries were heard of, in ascertaining whe ther disputed things be true. In other words, there is not, and never was, any such thing in jury trials as an allotment of all questions of fact to the jury.” (P. 184.) A conspicuous illustration of questions of fact disposed of habitually by courts is found in the construction of writings (p. 203). Rules of construction and interpretation which a court lays down to a jury are, of course, matters of law; but when a judge tells the jury that a particular clause in a contract has a particular meaning, he is disposing of what is in reality a question of fact. If every question of fact went to the jury, what the parties meant by the words they have used would certainly go to them, yet in many cases the court takes it upon itself to. say what they meant, and will not tole- rate the introduction of evidence as to in- tention, even though the result be to give the contract a meaning very different from what the parties are likely to have intended. We are consequently driven to the conclu- sion that when it is sald that such and such a question is a question of “law,” It may merely mean that it is a question which the court will dispose of, even though it be a question of fact. In other words, any question disposed of by the court is a ques- tion of law, though it be really a matter of fact; any question disposed of by the jury is a matter of fact, though it really involve a question of law. But, unless our aim is to perpetuate a gross confusion of language, we ought rather to speak of “questions for the court” and “questions for the jury.” The superstition that all questions of fact must go to the jury, and that all questions of law are for the court, crossing the Atlantic, attract- ed the, attention of those pseudo-law-re- formers who were engaged for a whole ge- neration in undermining the authority of judges, as an anti-popular branch of gov- In their minds it became con- verted into the doctrine that the judge ought to have no right to indicate to the jury even his own view of the facts, and, as a result, statutes have been widely passed in our States prohibiting judges from any opinion as to the facts, and f their function to a mere statement of Hi

Page 18

460 The Nation. [Vol. 68, No. 1772 testimony and the law. This is not trial by jury at all, but a new and bastard species unknown to our ancestors, and, fortunately, still repudiated by the Federal Courts, in which the judge retains much more than in State Courts his ancient power and influ- ence (p. 188, note 2). What is the “Law of Evidence’? The an- swer to this question, according to the au- thor’s view, is contained in four very in- teresting chapters, on ‘‘Legal Reasoning,” “Judicial Notice,” ‘‘Presumptions,”’ and ‘‘The Burden of Proof.” If they do not answer the question finally to the satisfaction of all, they certainly throw a flood of light upon it. To the practising lawyer, the law of evidence at any time means only the sum of rules governing the admission and exclusion of evidence in courts of justice. In our system, wherever jury trial exists, nothing is evi- dence which the court of last resort decides it was error to admit as such; anything is evidence which (admitted by the trial court} is held by the court of last resort to have been properly submitted to the jury. The main question here is perhaps less what is the law of evidence than what are the principles which have governed, and do govern, the development of our law of evidence. At any rate, in these chapters the author shows in a striking way that a great part of what our text- writers are forced to discuss under the head of Evidence should logically come under that of legal reasoning. For instance, there is the subject of judicial notice. Not all mat- ters of fact need to be proved. Of matters of common notoriety, courts take notice without proof. That the sun rises in the east, that night succeeds day, that alcoholic li- quors, taken in excess, produce intoxication, that ice is frozen water, thet fire burns and that cold freezes, are matters which no court requires to be proved. Yet all this is given as part of the ‘Law of Evidence.” Accord- ing to Mr. Thayer, the doctrine of judicial notice has no special connection with evi- dence, but belongs ‘‘wherever the process of reasoning has a place, and that is every- where.”’ A very great proportion of the cases involving judicial notice arise upon some question of pleading, or the construction of a written instrument, or the interpretation of conduct. In short, the function of ‘‘taking judicial notice’ of notorious facts is a part of the process of reasoning ad hoc. Then why, it may be asked, not agree at once that it is so? -Probably because it may come up as a question of evidence. In the course of a trial, it may become a question whether a fact is notorious or must be proved. The judge decides that it ig notorious, and an exception is taken. The court of last resort decides that the trial judge is right, and we have at once a new so-called “rule of evidence,’ that the particular matter in question is notori- ous, and that courts must take judicial notice of it. This rule is now part of the law of evidence, no matter how absurd it may seem, and in future editions of Greenleaf the case must be cited, Such is one of the results of our system; but it is nevertheless unques- tionably tre that the law of judicial notice pervades the whole corpus juris, existed long before the common law or jury trial was ever heard of, and would even survive our law of evidence itself. In the same way Prof. Thayer shows that presumptions and the burden of proof rather to the domain of legal reasoning than i to that of the Law of Evidence. Presump- tions are only probabilities resting on ex- perience, or public policy, invoked to supply a lack of facts; the burden of proof is only either (a) the principle that the actor must sustain his case by a preponderance of proof, or (b) the burden which rests on one side or the other, at a given stage in the case, of go- ing forward with evidence. All this has no- thing to do with the Law of Evidence. It is part of the ratiocinative machinery of judi- cial inquiry. In a correct view, then, the Law of Evi- dence means something much more restrict- ed than it does in the ordinary text- book. It relates merely to ‘‘matter of fact offered to a judicial tribunal as the basis of inference to another matter of fact” (page 888). It “prescribed the manner of present- ing evidence,” e. g., by requiring that it be given in open court, by deposition, etc.; it “fixes the qualifications and the privileges of witnesses, and the mode of examining them,” and chiefly it determines; as among proba- tive matters, ‘‘what classes of things shall not be received’ at all—this function of ex- clusion from the consideration of the jury being the characteristic one of our Law of Evidence (p. 264). The distinction which Mr. Thayer has drawn between the principles of legal rea- soning and the Law of Evidence is destined to have very wide-reaching effects on the study and development of the whole sub- ject. As will be perceived, it is in some im- portant respects at variance with the sys- tem of Stephen. That author made the foundation of his Digest the canon of rele- vancy—the principle that all the facts in issue, and relevant to the issue, and no others, may be proved. Now, relevancy, in a rational system, has no special relation to evidence. It is a matter of logic. We do not i uce evidence irrelevant to the issue, for the same reason that a judge does not introduce irrelevant remarks in an opinion— because it has no bearing on the matter in hand; and hence the canon of relevancy is not a test, especially as we know, as a mat- ter of fact, that numerous relevant things are every day excluded, such as hearsay, res inter alios acta, opinions, and evidence of character. Outside of the domain of jury trial these things may all be relevant and probative; how can their being ruled out be reconciled with Stephen's canon of rele- vancy? On Icoking into his Digest it will be found that he has effected a reconciliation by a very extraordinary and characteristic legal tour de force: he introduces two kinds of relevancy—logical and legal relevancy, When he finds that evidence, though logi- cally relevant, is, by a rule of law, excluded from the consideration of the jury, he says it is “deemed to be irrelevant.” When some- thing is admitted which is logically irrele- vant, he says that it is ‘‘decmed to be rele- vant to the issue, whether it is or is not relevant thereto.” What was needed to disentangle this metaphysical juggle (which, by the way, relevancy is a logical matter lying at the foundation of any system of trial, or proof, or reasoning. It is a law of the human mind, not of the common law. The true way to state the matter is therefore this: Apart from legal rule, anything which is relevant to the object of the inquiry—i. ¢., to guilt, ownership, liability for breach of contract— would be admissible, provided it had a pro- bative character. To be probative, however, as to a particular issue, it must be rele- vant to that jssue. A fact, to be probative, must have a tendency to induce a belief in some other fact. A fall in the mercury proves a fall in temperature. Evidence of the fall in the mercury, at sea, is relevant to an inquiry as to whether we are approach- ing an iceberg, but not to an inquiry as to our rate of speed. . Now,in a judicial inquiry in which the decision of the matter at is- sue is submitted to a jury, numerous things naturally probative and relevant are exclud- ed, for reasons which are connected with the historical development of jury trial, just as other things are excluded on grounds of public policy; e. g., cumula- tive evidence is excluded after a time ut sit finis litium. But it is these rules of exclu- sion which constitute the bulk of our Law of Evidence. Yet, as jury trial becomes for ordinary busi- ness Jess and less important, these artificial rules are gradually encroached upon by ex- ceptions, and we seem to be slowly getting away from the mechanical system of the past two hundred years (the Law of Evidence is mainly the product of the present cen- tury, as may be seen by turning to Black- stone, who devotes only a page or two to it), and there is a tendency to admit more and more all proof logically bearing on the matter in hand for what it is worth. Our Law of Evidence grows, mainly, as Mr. Thayer shows, because the bill of exceptions and writ of error enable a litigant to carry up to the tribunal of last resort, after a trial by jury, almost any sort of question which may suggest itself in the guise of a ques- tion as to the admissibility of evidence. This, however, is no essential part of our com- mon-law probative system, and has been done away with to an enormous extent in England. In a final chapter the author dis- cusses “The Present and Future of the Law of Evidence,” showing that he thinks that, as a rule, the decision of the trial court as to the admission of evidence ought to be final, unless a clear case of abuse or de- nial of justice can be made out. At present the object of the system seems to be as nearly as possible to make more and more complex a piece of machinery for the multi- plication of unnecessary trials, in order that the Law of Evidence may increase in vol- ume and incomprehensibility. In our effort to explaia we have said too little about the interest of the book, which to a lawyer, or student of the law, may fairly be called absorbing. No one can mas- ter its contents without feeling that he has been admitted to a share in a profound and original learning, which has pervaded and transfused an old subject with change seems to have taken ourselves and in what _we have. examin- ing. The mystery is a mystery no longer; we have the key at last. ate =e ees _ LETTERS OF DRAN swirt, Unpudsished: Letters of Dean stu navies

Page 19

June 15, 1899] The Nation. 461

by George Birkbeck Hill, D.C.L., LL.D. New York: Frederick A. Stokes Co. These letters of Swift to Knightley Chet- wode were formerly placed in the hands of John Forster, to be used in his biography of the Dean; but Forster’s untimely death be- fore he had reached the period which they cover prevented their publication. Forster, in his preface, refers to them as “the richest addition to the correspondence of the most masterly of English letter-writers”; but, though certainly interesting, they hardly justify that description. Still, there is so much that is mysterious and enigmatical about Swift, and so much in these letters that is characteristic of the man, that their publication is very welcome. The editor has affixed to each letter copious notes explana- tory of the circumstances and allusions, which are a model of intelligent and faithful editing. — Knightley Chetwode was an Irish gentle- man of ancient family and good estate, whose acquaintance Swift made soon after bis retirement to Ireland; and as they agreed in profound discontent with the existing state of things, and in hatred of the Whigs, the} soon became great friends, and so con- tinued for about seventeen years (1714-1731), when they squabbled and the correspondence seems to have come to an end. Swift, un- fortunately for himself, and for others be- sides himself, had been poisoned by his resi- dence in London and the flattery of the great. His natural arrogance and self-esteem had been pampered almost to the verge of insanity. In his mind’s eye he saw himself a bishop, perhaps a primate, moulding the councils of cabinets and guiding the affairs of a nation. The Whigs having faiied to re- ward him as he thought he deserved, he went over to the Tories, who flattered him to the top of his bent; and the foot of the rainbow seemed but a few paces ahead when the death of the Queen and accession of the house of Brunswick shattered all his hopes, and sent him to his Irish deanery to rage against the Whigs and his ill fortunes, to hate Walpole and the Government, to hate Ireland, its climate, and its people, and gra- dually to stretch his very energetic powers of hatred and scorn until they included the whole human race. The earlier of these letters deal mostly with troubles with his choristers, his horses, and his servants.. It has taken him six weeks to get rid of “a great cat’ left behind by his predecessor, an animal of such unexampled noisomeness that he believes her to be a Whig. He is also afflicted with an ugly old housekeeper, whom ‘“‘the ladies” (Stella and Mrs. Dingley), on the score of the proprie- ties, will not let him exchange for a good- looking one. Moreover, he is bothered with debt, having to pay £1,000 for the residence, the first fruits, and the patent, The pres- sure of these debts and other heavy ex- penses no doubt increased his natural bent towards parsimony, so that in his later years we note a singular conflict between stingi- ness and generosity. < In 17156 he writes more about public af- fairs. He is suspected of Jacobitism, and there are rumors of proceedings against him. He is evidently uneasy, and at one’ time seems to have been thinking of the possible expediency of flight. Though he kept clear of dewnright treason, yet he had much syin- pathy. with the Jacobite party, and had many friends in ite ranks, Of the Duke of Ormond, Whe: was impeached, he wrote to Pope, You

know . . . how dear the Duke of Ormond is to me. Do you imagine I can be easy while their enemies are endeavoring to take off their heads?” Yet thisdaffection does not hinder him from writing to Chetwode: ‘“Yes- terday’s post brought us an account that the Duke of Ormond is voted to be impeached for high treason. You see the plot thickens. I know not the present disposition of the people of England; but I do not find myself disposed to be sorry at this news.” He solves a case of conscience for his cor- respondent, who was a Jacobite in heart, and who did not see how he could remain faith- ful to his principles, and yet abjure the Pre- tender and swear that he held George I. to be the lawful sovereign. Swift tells him, first, that private men are not to decide upon ti- tles to crowns; secondly, that “lawful” means “according to the law that now is,”’ and, ‘‘as the law stands, none has title to the crown put the present possessor.” Therefore, the most irreconcilable Jacobite could take the oaths with an easy conscience, for, as the law stood, George was the lawful King and James an unlawful pretender. The Vicar of Bray could have been no more dexterous casuist. There are no letters between 1715 and 1718, and but two in the latter year. There is also a wide gap in Swift’s collected cor- respondence at this time. Probably this was due to the bad state of his health, as he has been complaining of deafness and vertigo. The correspondence is resumed in 1721. He is troubling himself little about public af- fairs, but is planting elms in the cathedral churchyard, and exasperating his flock by re- moving ancient tofiibstones. His deafness is increasing, and he can converse with none but “trebles and counter-tenors,” whose high voices he can hear. His partly genuine and partly assumed cynicism and hardness of heart are so predominant in much of his work that it is pleasant to come across a touch of tenderness. He writes on March 13, 1721-2, “I have the best servant in the world dying in the house, which quite disconcerts me. He was the first good one I ever had, and i am sure will be the last. I know few greater losses in life.” This faithful servant was buried in the cathedral, and “his grate- ful master’’ commemorated his modest worth in an epitaph. In 1720 Swift had laid aside the indifference with which he had for years professed to re- gard all matters of state policy, and had come out in the new part of a champion of the Irish people. But by the Irish people Swift always means the Protestant Irish and those of English descent. For the Catholic Irish population he had not the slightest sympathy, wand indeed regarded them chiefly as vermin. The Protestant Irish, however, were at least worthy of his contempt. But in Irish affairs he now saw an opportunity for attacking the Whigs and the Whig ministry. The oppres- sion of Ireland by iniquitous’ legislation had been a grievance of long standing, and it had been steadily aggravated during Anne’s reign by a succession of laws expreasly designed to destroy Irish manufactures. But of late years @ policy had been adopted of building up an English party in Ireland, whose per- sistent endeavor should be to make Ireland more completely subservient, and to destroy every vestige of national feeling. This policy met with strong opposition among the Pro- testants themselves; old enemies were recon- ciled in the sight of a common danger, and there was a movement tending to the formation of an Irish party, Swift seized the opportu. nity to deal a blow at the Whigs, and enter- ed the arena as an Irish patriot in his anony- mous ‘Proposal for the Universal Use of Irish Manufactures,’ in which he urged union tn hostility to England and a rigid non-impor- tation policy. In the fall of 1724 Swift, after writing about pears, peaches, and cherry-brandy, drops in a casual way the remark, ‘There is a Draper very popular, but what is that to me?” This is of course an allusion to the famous “Drapier’s Letters,” which had begun to make a stir. The affair of Wood's patent was the very fulcrum he needed for the lever which was to shake the ministry. The injury to Irish manufactures was an old grievance; but here was something entirely new which might be invested with any terrors. Ireland was suffering from a scarcity of small coin- age, which lack entailed great hardship and loss upon the poor. A bertain Wood had un- dertaken to furnish a supply of copper coin, if given a patent. The profit which a token coinage always yields would in this case go to Wood, and not to the English ex- chequer; but to the Irish people this could make no particle of difference. Nor did it make any difference to them how fine the copper in the coinage was, so long as the is- sue was limited to a reasonable quantity, and the coins not a legal-tender for large sums. It is true that Wood bought his patent with a bribe to the Duchess of Kendall; but that was a loss to Wood or to the English ex- chequer, not to Ireland. In fact, as we can now see, Wood’s coinage would really have been of advantage to Ireland, and no doubt Swift knew that very well. It would be out of place here to comment at length on thé Drapier’s Letters, which ought to be republished as the perfect rade- mecum of a demagogue. All the arte of the sophist, all the devices by which a credulous people can be deluded, are here displayed in perfection, from insinuations, suppressions, assumptions of false premises, bold denials of fact, down to downright lying and self- contradiction. The Drapier declared that the coins were of vile metal; that while twelve English pence contained eleven-pence worth of pure copper, twenty-four of Wood's half-pence contained only one penny's worth —both extravagant falsehoods. Sir Isaac Newton, Master of the Mint, testified that Wood's coinage was as fine as the English; but Swift contemptuously ignores this, goes on assuring the people that it is mere dross, and then makes the amazing assertion that Wood purposely makes his half-pence bad, so that he can counterfeit them himself! Why he should want to do this, and how he could do it if he wanted, Swift (knowing his public) does not trouble himself to ex- plain. He over and over warns the shop- keepers that they will all be ruined, as they will be forced to exchange their goo4 wares for this worthless trash; and then, turning to the workingmen, coolly tells them that they will be ruined also, as their wages will be paid in worthless trash which no shopkeeper will take! It took the audacity of a Swift to put forward such an argu- ment, and the genius of a Swift to see that the people would believe both statements. He triumphed; the ministry yielded, the patent was withdrawn, and Swift was the most popular man in [reland. The letters following are much occypied with Swift’s increasing infirmities, and with the domestic troubles of Chetwode, who Is

about to separate from his wife. In one

* * a 4 a 3

Page 20

462 The Nation, of 1726, in answer to some inquiry his cor- respondent had made about the poem ‘‘Ca- denus and Vanessa,”” Swift says that he “for- gets what is in it,” that “it was a task performed on a frolick among some ladies,” and “a private humorsome thing,” and adds: “She it was addressed to died some time ago.” He is annoyed that people talk about “such a trifle,” but their conduct “only gives me the ungrateful task of re- flecting on the baseness of mankind.” Many besides Swift have reflected on human base- ness when they have read the piteous story of Vanessa. In 1781 ill-feeling sprang up between Swift and Chetwode, it is not clear from what cause, as some of the letters of this period have been suppressed or destroyed. Swift writes with supercilious contempt, to which Chetwode sharply replies, and thus “the friendly correspondence which had spread over so many years, is brought to a close with mocks and gibes.”” Such is the editor's conclusion, but the present reviewer will venture to express a doubt whether this was really the close, and whether the quarrel was not made up after all. In the letter on p. 247, which is inserted in 1781, just before the quarrel, Chetwode deplores Swift’s long and severe lameness, and gives him advice about it. Now Swift, we know from the published correspondence, was lame from a severe strain during almost the whole year 1732, but not, so far as we know, in 1781; and the editor confesses that he does not know how to account for the discrepancy. But this letter of Chetwode’s is undated, nor is there a word in it which might not have been written in 1732. Where, then, is the difficulty of supposing that, after the falling-out of 1731, there was some sort of a reconciliation, and that then this letter was written? Indeed, there is a sort of guard- ed politeness in it, and apparent fear of being misunderstood, which would be natural under those circumstances. On the vexed question of Swift’s mar- riage, these letters throw no light. Wher he has occasion to speak of marriage, it is in the character of a bachelor, as in Letter 53, where he says, “Those who have been married may form juster ideas of that es- tate than I can pretend to do.” The edi- tor seems to be one of those who (rightly, the present reviewer thinks) disbelieve it. He calls attention to the fact that, in Swift’s written prayers for Stella’s very, no word seems to indicate any cl relation than that of strong friendship and regard. This fact would have great weight if we could accept these’ prayers as the spon- taneous outpourings of the writer's heart, and not as manuscripts to be printed some day. The book is enriched with interesting por- traits and views, and is almost wholly free from typographical errors, though ‘“Pem- sall” for “Perusall’ on p. 1, may puzzle some readers. -serious correspondence—from making him tive of Bishop Tomline and more detailed than Lord Rosebery’s sketch—something, even, which should prove more generally adequate than Lord Stanhope’s ‘Life.’ But now, on its publication, the new book is seen to be little more than a series of loose- ly connected chapters, with large gape be- tween, and not in the least comprehensive. Thus Pitt still remains without his long- expected and final biography, much to the regret of Tories and other ardent admirers. With this view we feel a certain degree of sympathy, for Lord Ashbourne could have rendered useful service by going thoroughly over the whole ground, and by reason of his personal connections he was in an excellent position to do so. Still, there is no just rea- son why he should be assailed for the ill performance of a task which apparently he never undertook. He.produces a large num- ber of new documents—family and political letters in the main—and illustrates certain phases of Pitt’s career more fully than has been done before. He cannot be said to have wrought anything monumental; but within the self-appointed limits he is rea- sonably successful, and should not be pounced upon for failure to execute what was no part of his design. The papers hitherto unpublished which Lord Ashbourne now brings forward are derived from privatemuniment rooms rather than from the national archives, and,as being less acces- sible than public property, lend a special value to the volume wherein they are contained, During twenty-five years Pitt was in close and constant correspondence with the chief families of England, and, owing to his official eminence, the letters would be carefully pre- served. Perhaps the most important collec- tion of Pitt holographs which still remains in private hands belongs to Mr. Ernest Pretyman, M.P., a great-grandson of Pitt’s tutor at Cambridge. Dr. Pretyman is better known under his later name of Tomline. Pitt appointed him Bishop of Lincoln, and was de- terred only by the royal negative—after a Archbishop of Canterbury. Perhaps no one stood closer to the Prime Minister than Tomline, aud although his own account of Pitt is a failure, he possessed and handed down a splendid set of documents. The late Lord Bolton and the present Lord Stanhope also furnished Lord Ashbourne with impor- tant and unpublished MSS. The proportion of documents to comment is 80 great that Lord Ashbourne stands midway between the independent historian and the editor. He begins with a sketch of Pitt’s early years (which is chiefly significant as illustrating the devotion of both his parents) and then plunges into the midst of Irish af- i i He ieehett y s been impugned; but impartial not deny that he was influenced by true eReS onl 3 ‘ legislative conception, which took form and found its way into the statute-book. When the controversies arising from the execution of the measure are broached, Lord Ash- bourne drops into a subdued strain, and ad- mits that Pitt’s “warmest admirer, in con- sidering his career after the Union, has to use much more the language of explanation than of eulogy.” The last sixty-six pages form an epilogue dealing with the increase of cares and the failing health which weighed Pitt down in his last days. Of his career as a peace minister and reformer before 1793 nothing is said, nor of his part in the Revolutionary and Napoleonic contest. His relations with Ireland, wis family ties, and his personal friendships are the sole subjects which Lord Ashbourne cares to consider. Beyond any doubt whatever, the rarest and most striking chapter of the book is that entitled “‘Pitt’s One Love Story.” Pitt was systematically prepared by his father for political life. He regularly subordinated personal pleasures to the public service, whether in Parliament or in the Cabinet; never in modern times has a man belonged more exclusively to the state. Accordingly, when an authentic version of his fondness | for Eleenor Eden is for the first time given, it cannot fail to awaken curiosity. Rumors and fragments of the story have been given before. On the word of Lady Hester Stan- hope, the affair nearly broke Pitt’s heart, but most readers will agree with Lord Rosebery —“Lady Hester’s statements do not impress me with conviction.” Putting by the ques- tion of sincerity, she cannot rank as an au- ployed, and raised to the peerage. Although she was by eighteen years the younger of

Page 21

The Nation. 463 “Indeed, my dear lord, I did not bring to the step I have taken without as far as I am able, again and again considered every point which must finally govern my conduct. I should deceive you and every one concerned, as well as my- fk if I flattered with the hope that such an interval as you suggest would remove the obstacles I have felt or vary the ground of my opinion.” In all the mechanical respects of paper, binding, and illustration, this volume is worthy of its distinguished subject. History of the Pennsylvania Railroad Com- pony. With Plan of Organization, Por- traits of Officials,and Biographical Sketches. By William Bender Wilson. Illustrated. 2 vols., 8vo, pp. 418, 321. Philadelphia: H. T. Coates & Co. The history of the Pennsylvania Railroad Company includes the interesting story of the transition from canals to railways. EXvery- body knows that canals were generally built and operated by the State, and were pre- eminently the “public works’ during the twenty years following the completion of De Witt Clinton’s great achievement in New York. Few are aware that Pennsylvania, in her enterprising effort to maintain the com- mercial supremacy which Philadelphia then held, not only built her canal as far as pos- sible up both slopes of the Alleghanies, on the head-waters of the Juniata and the Cone- burgh. The general route of the canal was also that of the ei ze Hi i ‘ i bei] Ht it in railways soon followed, and the Pennsyl- vania trunk line was an accomplished fact. In the piping times of the war between Andrew Jackson and Nicholas Biddle and the boom which collapsed in the panic of 1837- 38, the political management of canal and railroad building quickly developed all the methods of plunder which have ever since marked such control. Favoritism in con- tracts, political appointments of incompetent and corrupt officers, unthrifty and dishonest conduct of business, a special bag at the pay- master’s table in which the political assess- ments of employees were openly placed—all were in full operation, and make it easy to understand why State control stood no chance in competition with the discipline, energy, economy, and wisdom which the private cor- poration brought to its task. For several years the railroads, both State and private, allowed the use of the track to shippers and transportation companies who furnished their own cars and horse-power, as canal shippers had their own boats and horses; tonnage tolls and passenger tolls being the only revenue of the road itself. Then the Company put on its locomotives as the in- creasing business demanded unity of control and power of carrying out complicated sche- dules for running trains. Last came the ownership of all rolling-stock by the Com- pany, with the exception of sleeping-cars and codperative fast-freight lines. It is both cu- rious and instructive that, in the later-con- tests between railroads and the “Granger” laws in the West, the effort was made to force the renewal of the crude methods of the canal and horse tramway, and to allow any shipper to furnish his own car and de- mand its hauling at a fixed rate. The writer of the book before us is the son of Thomas L. Wilson, who was Secretary of the old Board of Canal Commissioners, and has received from his father a valuable etore of information and anecdotes concern- ing the experimental period of railway ma- nagement, with incidents relating to the ear- ly surveys and construction. He himself en- tered the service of the Company in 1855 as a telegraph operator. The simple narrative of facts in the extension of the Pennsylvania system and the absorption of one small road after another, under the business principle that unity in the management of natural branches and feeders is a condition of suc- cess for thd trunk line, is a most telling les- son in railway policy. The power and profit of union, the loss and bankruptcy coming of multiplicity of small and rival lines, are developed, not by argument but by history, and the history should be studied carefully by everybody who would form intelligent opi- time woodcuts of towns and scenes in the early forties, compared with recent photo- graphs. Picturesque scenery on the line is reproduced in half-tone, as is the large gal- lery of portraits in the second volume. The Book of Golf and Golfers. By Horace G. Hutchinson. Longmans, Green & Co. 1899. The object of this book is not exactly to give elementary instructicn. This has al- ready been done by Mr. Hutchinson and many others, to so great an extent that it seoms impossible that anything can remain to be sald that can be of service to man, woman, or child. The author’s idea is to call in the aid of modern photography, and, by presenting pictures of a number of lead- ing experts caught in the act of making strokes, assist inferior players to imitate the methods of the masters. The result is a book that cannot fail to be interesting to golfers because of the personal element to be found in the descriptions of the players photographed, but we are entirely sceptical as to its educational value. In fact, it is a question whether the standard of play has been improved in the very slightest degree by the recent extraordinary production of golf literature. That the standard is con- stantly advancing, both here and elsewhere, is beyond doubt, and is proved conclusively by the marked improvement in scores; but we believe that this improvement is due to the increasing number of players rather than to the teachings of the books. However this may be, the subject of golf has become one of absorbing interest to a great number of readers, and in the present volume these readers will find the conclusions of experts based on last year’s tournaments, and will note that in some respects these differ from the earlier wisdom of the Badminton book. The most obvious inference to be drawn from an examination of this gallery of por- traits is againat teaching golf by books, for the reason that in golf all rules of procedure must yield to individual pecu- Marities. The individual is everything and “orthodoxy” nothing. Take, for instance, the vital question of ‘he stance for driving. Most of the books agree that the player should stand with the ball about midway between his feet. But what do we fiud to be fact is, that no two individuals are built ex- actly alike, and, as success at golf is the re- The chapter on “Golf in the United States,” contributed by Mr. Whigham, refers to one point which is of great importance in con- sidering the future of the game in this coun- try. .In England and Scotland it is the “poor man’s game,” but here it is a very ex- pensive amusement. The cost of obtaining

Page 22

464 The Nation. [Vol. 68, No. 1772 matter of expense is one of the most seri- Idylts of the Sea. By Frank T. Bullen. D. Appleton & Co. 1899. An American or British deep-water sailor- man of the old school had attained to the limit of fearlessness. Training and asso- ciation made him self-reliant and resource- ful, and the imminent perils and privations that he was called upon to face at sea taught him to meet with philosophical equanimity the vicissitudes of fortune. Moreover, it was impossible for him to take himself seriously, for-speech and fist were vigorously employ- ed to impress upon him the quality of com- plete insignificance. Mr. Bullen, the author of ‘Idylls of the Sea,’ was trained in this school, for he commenced his nautical career as a sailor before the mast in square-rigged ships. In launching, however, his two vol- umes that treat of ocean life, he betrays sin- gular timidity; for each is prefaced with a letter of praise and commendation by a writ- er of distinction (the ‘Cruise of the Cachalot’ by one from Rudyard Kipling, and the book under notice by another from J. St. Loe Strachey). These entirely unnecessary do- cuments convey the impression that Mr. Bullen, under their shield, is seeking pro- tection from adverse criticism, There is no need of this, for Mr. Bullen is strong enough to stand upon his own merits, especially in his latest venture, which is a distinct ad- ‘Vance upon its predecessor. In ‘Idylls of the Sea’ he avoids the snares of geographical inaccuracy and “Yankee” vernacular, in which he became hopelessly entangled in his first volume, and confines himself with success to short, condensed tales of various phases of life upon the sea. Some of them have a quality reminiscent of Maupassant; notably that one called “The Passing of Peter.” The author is weak when he endows in- habitants of the waters of the ocean with the power of speech. The “Idyll” called “A True Shark Story”’ opens with the soliloquy of a mother shark who deplores a temporary scarcity of provisions for herself and the young to which she is giving transportation in her gullet. In this emergency a pilot-fish, who addresses her as “partner,”’ informs her in colloquial English that ‘‘there’s a lump of fat pork almost as big as your head hanging over that ship's stern.” This is welcome news, and, under guidance of the pilot, the shark approaches, turns on her back, and swallows the bait along with a hook attached to a line by which she is hauled to the deck of the vessel. The Captain, who is a hu- mane man, gives orders that she shall not be taken aboard. “‘Just sprit’sle yard him 'n let him go agen,” he pleasantly remarks; where- upon a piece of scantling, pointed at both ends and about four feet long, is got from the carpenter. This the sailors drive through her jaws from side to side. Another wedge-shaped piece is driven through her snout; the wide pectoral fins are amputated, and the shark is cut loose from the hook and returned to the sea. The result of the “‘sprit’sle”’ treatment was that the fish was unable to control its movements, or to get its head below the sur- face of the water; consequently it died slow- ly of exhaustion. One of the passengers on the ship, described as a “‘gentle-faced man,” was moved by the performance “to mutter” “What abominable cruelty!” The assembled mariners regarded him with pity and won- dered “‘at his lack of sporting instincts.” All of Mr. Bullen’s “Idylls”’ must not be judged by the specimen quoted. Most of them are fine examples of dramatic and de- scriptive writing. ‘‘The Cruise of the Daisy” is distinguished in that particular. All of them, with the exception of “A True Shark Story,” are worthy of high commendation. “Studies on Marine Natural History’ form the second part of the Idylla.“ They are full of interest. The third section is made up of a collection called ‘‘Other Sketches,” one of which, entitled ‘‘Truth about the Merchant Service,” is opportune in these days when the manning of the ever-growing fleets of bat- tle-ships in England by native seamen is a matter that is giving considerable concern to the naval authorities. The “Truth’’ applies with equal force to a deficiency that confronts our own service. Jean-Jacques Rousseau and the Cosmopolitan Spirit in Literature. By Joseph Texte. Translated by J. W. Matthews. London: Duckworth & Co.; New York: Macmillan. Among the many recent works or com- parative literary criticism, few hold so high a place as this volume by M. Joseph Texte, in so far as fulness of treatment, breadth and accuracy of insight, and sustained in- terest are concerned. Its purpose is to set forth the literary relations established be- tween the two leading productive nations of the last century by their respective repre- senthtive writers, and, while demonstrating the steady growth of the cosmopolitan idea, to suggest criteria which assist one in the difficult task of distinguishing between cheap or direct borrowing on the one hand, and that form of literary indebtedness pro- duced by generous international sympathies or the subtler influence of affinity in genius. According to M. Texte, the initial process in this vital transformation of literary concep- tions was the direct outcome of the revoca- tion of the Edict of Nantes, which dispersed no less than four hundred thousand French exiles, chiefly over northern Europe, and transferred energy and independence of thought to more favorable conditions of ac- tivity. Several international reviews, pub- lished for the moat part in Holland, trans- mitted to France the foreign impressions of taire. But it is to Rousseau, who combined the ,genius of the Latin and the Germanic race, that we must ascribe the principal share in this broadening of literary interest aroused in himself by the tendencies and products of English thought; for with him as with others, the conception of world-lite- rature began with the realization that other nations besides his own had written worthi- ly and well. Tracing Rousseau’s sympathies to thelr origin in the widespread Angliv- mania of his age and to the initial impulse of Muralt, the critic dwells at much TT displays itself in angry and rebellious con- tempt. For precisely the same reason, we may well doubt whether Rousseau could ever have been brought to understand the endur- ing worth of Fielding, whom, as M. ‘Texte significantly admits, he nowhere mentions (p. 228). As to the causes contributiig to the rapid than apostolic vehemence with which Jean Jacques never failed to express himself on the subject of the moment; in verification of which we need but turn to the amaz- ing success of ‘Emile,’ with its violent para- doxes, and the ready acceptance, even by those whose interests it attacked, of the hazy humanitarianiem of the ‘Contrat So- cial.” Is it not because of this power of passionately insisting on what he feels for the time being that Rousseau, like Burke, looms up so large in the history of eigh- teenth-century thought? M. Texte proceeds to show how Rousseau's defiance of restrictive literary canons affect- ed the method of criticism by directing at- tention not to standards, but to feeling, thus insuring the ultimate triumph of lyrical im- pulse and expression by the Romantic school led off by Chateaubriand. But the more di- rect inheritor of the “exotic” spirit, the transmitter of cosmopolitan influence, was unquestionably Mme. de Staél, who thus shares with her great fellow-countryman the credit of stirring up the lethargic provin- ciality which the survivors of French clas- sicism vainly strove to preserve. With this denationalizing of the literary point of view M. Texte is obviously in hearty sympathy, though in no part cf his treatise does he attempt a full discussion of the ssthetic postulates involved. His readers will, with- out exception, hope that he may at some time take up this great task. Of his present truly admirable work a reviewer can hardly speak with only moderate pre::3 It is true that the principal positions and con- clusions contained in this volume are for the. most part granted without much dis- pute by competent authorities on French literature, notably by M. Brunetiare, the effect of whose comparative teaching is clearly discernible, as well as amply acknow- ledged by his erstwhile pupil; but it sel- dom happens that studies in international literary criticism reveal researches at once : 1 *

Page 23

June 15, 1899] The Nation. _ 465 ligious system, which errs, if at all, on the side of charity, and a short account of the native races, introduce his main theme, the missionary, political, moral, and religious character of the recent Mohammedan con- quests. Some observations follow on the change wrought in the African by his con- version as shown by a few typical examples, with a forecast of the future, in which the author contends that Islam as a civilizing agency in Central Africa and the Sudan must inevitably yield to Christianity and com- merce as represented by the potent railway. With his general conclusion that whatever good Mohammedanism may have accom- plished in elevating the native has been far outweighed by the frightful evil which has accompanied its progress, we are in com- plete and hearty accord. But with some of his statements we find it difficult wholly to agree; as, for instance, when, in reference to the claim made by some writers that Mo- hammedanism is the “great total-abstinence society of Central Africa,’’ he says that “the Arabs themselves are the chief importers of intoxicating spirits inte Africa.” Is this true on the West Coast, where the liquor traffic is at its height? We doubt if it is just to say that the principal occupation of the Arab is slave-trading. He was first and always a trader, and obtained slaves because they were necessary to carry his wares, ¢hiefly ivory, to market. With the advent of the railway he will cease to be either’ slave- trader or slave-holder, but he wily remain a zealous follower of the Prophet: Dr. Atterbury, in his reliance on the statements of older travellers, seems to lose sight of the changed conditions of the pre- sent time, when an Egyptian pasha can be tried for having a recently captured slave in his household. He looks forward to the “inevitable conflict of Christianity with Is- lam,” but to us it seems more probable that the day is not far distant when, as in India, so in Africa, under a strong and righteous government, pagan, Mohammedan, and Chris- tian will live in peace together. A Texas Ranger. By N. A. Jennings. Scrib- ners. In the days of Reconstruction, the Texas Rangers were divided into six companies, and to them was intrusted the task of clearing the western part of the State of the swarm of bandits who made a com- fortable livelihood by plunder and inciden- tal murder on both sides of the border. As some three thousand of them had actually been outlawed by the State, there was work in pienty to be done. The Rangers were equal to it. With absolute indifference to death, they attacked the ruffians wherever and whenever they met them. After a se- ries of bloody encounters, the organized bands were disrupted, and the Rangers ran the thieves to earth or drove them from the State. Their method of procedure was as summary as that of a vigilance commit- tee. If the outlaws were in force, their pur- suers would shoot at sight; if there were but few of them, a Ranger’s first duty was to “get the drop’ on his man, his next to lodge him in the nearest jail. The pursued habitually attempted to save themselves by escaping to Mexico, and the Rio Grande became the despair of the Rangers. Mr. Jennings tells how his troop of thirty men, vexed past endurance, and hoping that the United States troops would back them up, actually crossed the river on one occasion, and attacked ten times their number of cat- tle-thieves at a Mexican ranche. Unhap- pily for the Rangers, and very fortunately for the United States, the military autho- rities refused to risk a war with Mexico. Throughout his lively narrative Mr. Jen- nings has many pretty “tall” stories to tell, but, like a judicious historian, he tells the “tallest” of them on the authority of others. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Arnold-Forster, H. O. A History of England. Cas- Bang, J. K. The Dreamers. A Clud. Harpers. Bioundelle-Burton, John. Fortune's My Foe. Ap- —— —13 2 Dictionary of Dainty Break- — Rov. F. P. 8. eee oo S a Meg Clark Re wen * of —— v. nee, Dinwidate be Conditions Elson, cee we ot Lights on y History. Macmillan. me Garland, Hamlin. The Trail of the Goldseekers Macmillan. Pe Gibson, Rev. E. C. 3. The Book of Job. [Oxford ( ries.) acmillan, $1.25. Be. 8. RH Our Ga London: Dent; New a. Loulsa Stuart. Selec- tions from her Man ts. Ha a 333 te Make Money Get ot Fier, an —— 42 practical Agriculture. Apple- Jordan, Prof. D. 8, Imperial Democracy. Appile- Lawton, X. go 2 Rudyard Kipling the Artist. New — fist hen Wheeler, A. L. Latin Prose — £ — Remintecences. 2 vols. Har. Norris, W. E. Giles Ingilby. Philadelphia: Drexel ur. Cromwell's Ove. A B8tory of the — A Story le to Otrtnoed. ‘arpers. * Charlotte P. a Yellow Wall Paper. Boston: Small, pfazserd & Co. She. Ty — jastes. New ed. London: avid N Vanderbiit — Gertrude L. The Social History of Flatbush. Appletons. — H. G. When the Sleeper Wakes. Harpers. * the Har- 1, Maynard & and Other JUST PUBLISHED. THES HOOLIGAN NIGHTS. ee seeeere OF ’ — 253 HENRY HOLT & CO.,N. Y. Typography, Topography. BOOKS ON ALL SUBJECTS. FIRST EDITIONS, ETC. — and nto Brees Sine — ig deducted from the fret PICKERING & CHATTO, TRANSE ATION AND REPRINTS. days. 20 cents. VOL. VI. WO. 8. The Early Germans. pny, Sg rer town — } ‘Out. of Ponsayivenia, Philads., Pa. President Hadley’s Economics. An Account of the Relations between Pri- vate Property and Public Welfare. By ARTHUR TWINING HADLBY, President of Yale University, 8vo, $2.50, net. The work is now used in classes in Yale, Princeton, Harvard, Ambherst, Dartmouth, Bowdoin, Vanderbilt, Bucknel, Bates, Le- land Stanford, University of Oregon, Uni- versity of California, etc. “The author has done his work s: He is —— — ERG — terpretation.” Am, yc aga nar Plates, |G, P. PUTNAM’S SONS, | © New York and London. TO READERS OF ERE: POET (First Edition). There are a few mistakes, grammatical and typo- graphical, that appear in my book, in spite of great watchfulness on my part, for which I beg — GABRIEL BOUDO . By ANNIE PAYSON CALL. Power Through Repose. As a Matter of Course. Price, $1.00 each. LITTLE, BROWN & CO., Boston. F, W. CHRISTERN (DYRSEN & PFEIFFER, Successors), 420 th Ave,, between 38th and 20th Sts,, New York. 55 —— Greek on zig as soon as ‘*Monopoly bids fair in a short time to hola in its fre? all American industries, Already it includes more than half of the — capital of this country.” Municipal Monopolies By Epwarp W. Bemis, Jonn R. Commons, Frank Parsons, M. N. Baxer, F. A. C. Peraing, Max West. 12mo, cloth, Appen- dix, Index, $2.00. (Vol. XVL, Crowell’s Library of Esonomics and Politics ) “To writers and thinkers on municipal problema the volume is almost indispensable.” — Cutiook. “Probably no more timely work has in this generation. The facta and — — these seven are those which thousands are in- + beg or; and uni “An ex —— valuable and oS te? —222 to the some of the grea’ pak wee Fy perill dangers that ger chee people.” the progress or For sale by boshestiers, im. On receipt of Tuomas Y, Crowe & Co., New York and Boston. Royal Academy Pictures, 1899. In 5 Parts. Price, 40 cents each, or vee rvol., $3.00 . Complete set, 1884 to 1806, price on application. CASSELL & COMPANY, Limited, 7 AND 9 WEST iSTH ST., NEW YORK. Biante SECOND-HAND AND NEW,

Page 24

466 Summer Resorts. Hotel wat MALO JA — — *5 ber, Vi first- class * Sanitary ar —— the most im- Position feet above most Engadine = (SWITZERLAND) (Za. 1815. g.) I. F. WALTHER. Telegraph and Post-Office, MALOJA KURSAAL. THE BARTLETT COTTAGES, PISHER’S ISLAND, N. Y. Seven miles seaward from New London, Conn. sont Bi cottages for “nousekoeping, or with attendance. — and ge strictly sant _ Tlustrated elrcular matled on Lpplicat ‘on. EUROPEAN SUMMER RESORT, INNSBRUCK, TYROL, AUSTRIA. 1,900 feet above the sea, with dry, bracing climate. HOTEL TIROL. Open all_ the year. Modern conveniences. Best re ferences. Illustrated — on application. LAUSANNE. Lannsee, Proprietor. SWITZERLAN D noree RICHE-MONT. lass hotel with moderate tariff. M Mea Soo view over the lake * moun baths, electric rican families. very Tariff and pamphiets cons, free on application. EAUMARIS HOTEL, MUSKOKA LAKE, ONTARIO, CANADA.—1,000 feet above No hay fever. Golf, fishing, boating, bathing. Send for ‘booklet. Epwarp Prowsg, Proprietor. OPERSTOWN—“OTSEGO HALL," small hotel near the lake. Well kept; choice table; good boating and fishing; 2 golf courses. Now open. Travel. PARIS in 1900. A word to the wise. 2* pare Lt gy a 4 and ho- vel accommodations now, rates, in sonally conducted parties. THE | GRawrOonD moat Bullding, reste Phitadelph Broadway, Wee Forks ool Chestaut Street, Phi elphia. EUROPEAN TRAVEL. RS WELDON, with thetr oth Annual Class ian wt tes’ Tour ou Ladies’ ferences. py Be oo THE MOORINGS, AVE, Pa. and call } bille ot to and ‘era of m' quay of ite i Travellers’ Great available in all of the world, Bs — BROWN BROTHERS &CO. NO, 60 WALL STREET, NEW YORK. Hay Fever. ITS SUCCESSFUL TREATMENT. By W. H. HOLLOPETER, M.D. The success of this book has made necessary an Enlarged Second Edition (JUST READY), which bears witness to the value of the method of treatment. Handsome cloth. Price, $1.00 net. Will be sent, postpaid, on receipt of price. P. BLAKISTON’S SON & CO., Publishers, Philadelphia, Underwear. — and Warnerꝰs nderwear. Ladies’ and Children’s Underwear, Merino, Silk, and Lisle Thread Underwear, Swiss Ribbed Union Suits. Hosiery. Ladies’ and Children’s Plain Ribbed and Open- Work Lisle Thread and Silk Hosiery. Men’s Half- Hose, Golf and Bicycle Hosiery. Proaidovay A 19Hb — NEW YORK Out of Doors Summer evenings a shoulder shawl many times becomes a necessity to women lightly dressed. The Augusta- Victoria Empress Shoulder Shawl, entire- ly handwoven from pure wool and silk, is luxuriously soft and com- fortable. Colors—white, rich light green, delicate pink, recherché red or black. Sent postpaid and regis- tered for $7.50. In ordering state color desired and address The Susacuac Weaving Co. 12 Moravian Church St., Bethichem, Pa. Works * Remington Standard Typewriter ] WYCKOFF, SEAMANS & BENEDICT, 327 Broadway, New York. THE NEW and WONDERFUL ZEISS FIELD-GLASSES|| _1167 Broadway, N.Y, Bend for eireaior,_| Underwear for (iolfers It is not extravagant to say that a golfer’s equipment is not complete—not such as to ren- der the game most enjoyablé— unless he or she wears Deimel Linen-Mesh Underwear It is not to be supposed that this statement can be appreciat- ed by those who know nothing of the fabric—have not worn it; but ask any one who has, or send for a pamphlet and sam- ples of the goods. “THE LINEN STORE.” James McCutcheon & Co. 14 West 23d St., New: York. New Volume of the Author of Li) D. Ls iS Pg THE ISLAND RACE. By HENRY NEWBOLT. 140 Fifth Avenue, New York. | re BLICKENSDERFER

Page 25

rey