The Nation 1897-11-11: Vol 65 Iss 1689
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
SON: eR NT VOL. LXV—NO. 1689. The Nation THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 11, 1897. PRICE 1o CENTS. D. Appleton and Company’s New Books. nite Sarah Grand’s New Novel, “mn READY ON FRIDAY. Ny, THE BETH BOOK. ™, By SARAH GRAND, Author of «* The Heavenly Twins.” ““* The Beth Book’ is distinctly a notable achievement in fiction. 12MO, CLOTH, $1.50. ‘The Christian’ and * The Beth Book ' will be the two English oovels to attract the most attention and widest discussion this year.""— Philadelphia Press This is the life history of the heroine, Beth. Since the publication of ‘‘The Heavenly Twins,’ Madame Grand has been at work upon this novel, which will be her most important literary undertaking. The new novel trages the development of a woman of genius from ber birth to her marriage, and afterward. It is a most subtle and extraordinary study of a woman's psychological evolution, while as a story if is cha- racterized by an abundance of delightful humor and incident. No book of recent years has been written with more care. With remarkable fidelity and a singularly graphic power of expression the author depicts the attitude of the child toward the outer world and toward ber pa. rents, the effects of increasing knowledge upon the young girl, the married life, the acquaintance with a larger world, the attitude of men toward women, and the position of women in modern society. Questions of intimate consequence are treated with courage and dignity. Her novel is a book of serious import which will furnish abundant reason for thought and discussion, The closing chapters suggest an effective contrast between the attitudes of Englishmen and Americans toward women. MISS MONTRESOR'S NEW NOVEL. At the Cross-Roads. By F. F. Montrésor, author of ‘Into the Highways and Hedges,” ‘‘ False Coin or True?” ‘*The One who Looked On,” etc 16mo Cloth, $1.50. **Miss Montrésor has the skill in writing of Olive Schreiner and Miss Harraden, added to the fullness of knowledge of life which is a chief factor in the Success of George Eliot and Mrs. Humphry Ward. She is very minute in her analysis of life, and hardly ever strikes an obviously false note. As I cannot understand how a woman of her age and gentle upbringing could have become personally ac- quainted with the multifold aspects of life which she describes so faithfully, I am compelled to put it down to the sheer instinct of a great writer. . . There is as much strength in this book as in a dozen ordinary successful novels.’’—London Litera- ry World. “The story is a delightful one. I commend it to all my readers who like a strong, cheerful, beauti- ful story. It is one of the truly n®&able books of the season.’’— Cincinnati Commercial Tridune. Miss Providence. By DoroTHEA GERARD, author of “A Spot- less Reputatioa,” ‘‘An Arranged Mar- riage,” ‘‘The Rich Miss Riddell,” ete. No. 229, Town and Country Library. 12mo. Cloth, $1.00; paper, 50 cents _ This accomplished writer is so well estab lished in the favor of readers of fiction that it is only necessary to announce her new novel, which deals in large part with English coun- try life. The story is full of interest, and is certain to increase the author’s popularity. R. W. CHAMBERS’S NEW BOOK, The Mystery of Choice. By R. W. CHAMBERS, author of ‘The Moon- maker,” ‘* The Red Republic,” ete. 16mo. Cloth, special binding, $1 25. “Probably Mr. Robert Chambers is to-day the most promising American writer of fiction of his | j | age. . . ‘The Mystery of Choice’ reveals his | most delightful qualities at their best. Imagination he has first of all, and it is of a fine quality; constant action he achieves without ap parent effort; naturalness, vividness, the power of description, and especially local color, come to him like delight in one of those glorious mornings Industrial Freedom. By Davip Maca@reGor Means. With an In- troduction by the Hon. Davin A. Weis 12mo. Cloth, $1.50. Mr. Means deals frankly and directly with questions which are now uppermost in the public mind. Ina fairand candid manner he discusses the present relations of labor and capital, the efficacy of legislation in dealing with economics, the resuits of interference with the natural laws of trade, the advisa- bility of restricting the accumulation of | wealth, the rights and wrongs of corpora- when distance seems annihilated."’--Bos‘on Herald, | ‘Mr. Chambers’s perception of color and the pic- turesque, often phrased in a few short but felici- tous sentences, is purely artistic, while the easy. graphie vigor of his style when he is at his best Is essentially literary."’"—Phiiadelphia Press. Baboo Hurry Bungsho Jabberiee, B.A. By F. ANSTEY, author of ‘‘ Vice Versa,” ‘‘ The Giant's Robe,” ‘The Tinted Venus,” etc. Illustrated. I2mo. Cloth, $1.50. In this irresistibly amusing picture of the ed- ucated Babooin England Mr. Anstey’s delight- ful bumor finds its happiest expression. The impossible language of Jabberjee, bis extra- ordinary adventures in the streets and shops | of London, and on railways, his ridiculous so- and his exhibition of legal acumen in the | courts, are perfect in their ingenious absurdi- ty, and make up achronicle which will be laughed over and quoted by many a reader. tions, and kindred topics. His arguments de- serve the attention of those sincerely benevo- lent persons who have been led to give sup- port to socialistic remedies because of their sympathy with the poor. Many considera- tions are prevented showing that these reme- dies tend to aggravate the evils which they are advertised to cure. APPLETON’S HOME-READING BOOKS. Two New Volumes. Uncle Robert's Visit. The Third Volume in Uncle Robert's Geographies By Francis W. Parker lilustrated 12mo, cloth, 5v cents net These books of Colonel Parker, if read by the school children, and especially by the older youth who have left school, will suggest a great variety of ways in which real mental growth and increase f practical power may be obtained. The reading, so far as possible, should be accompanied by per- sonal observation, investigation, and experiment Harold’s First Discoveries. ; : | The first volume in Nature-Study Readers. By cial mischances, bis déiuf as a sportsman, | ‘ J. W. Troreer. 12mo. Cloth, 30 cents net The firat of a progressive and graded series of books for the study of natural objects that present themselves to children in their ordinary surround ings and occupations, and that are generally within their reach. For sale by all booksellers, or will be sent by mail on receipt of price by the publishers. D. APPLETON AND COMPANY, 72 Fifth Avenue, New York. ee oath o> phage bi wae 3 oon see * gr 0 — 8 QAP MEDI A, ee eas wate Poe ¢ — pet i + Sat a RG be Ra Ma th Base ~ NE INR tt Sy INL TRO cee IR PE pI ~ ae
Page 2
11 The Nation. [Vol. 65, No. 1689 The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science, and Art. FOUNDED 1865. [Entered at the New York City Post-Office as second- class mail-matter. | CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. WS WE ii vecsccnnisepcccsseviacvoutscnigersesseaseuay 865 EDITORIAL ARTICLES; The Revolt Against Bossism ........csceeeseesseens The Tariff and the City.......... Secretary Gage’s Plan............ The Lost Art of Letter-Writing... SPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE: Who Are the People of Asia Minor ?.............. 871 The Rawlinson MSS. in the Bodleian Library.—I. 372 CORRESPONDENCE: The Agricultural Demand for More Money....... 874 Penny Wise, Pound Foolish. 875 The Thorvaldsen Museum... 875 Pe Ns scnsccnuubeiencnces . 376 PR bhneus kciay dnb peens civesesesekecnescotwiatensee 376 Book REVIEWS: The Life of Alfred Tennyson. ..........sscesssecees 879 BOE AN EEN 6.6.5 suc swnsien son ceiceetanscobatee 381 WD ins 45 kcat dal nada naducuccabchsbowseounnerssueorte 382 Pe SRR EE POON sis ccccseneceenss: Ke ensavedrek $82 The Scholar and the State.............cscessccceees 383 Rar ree 383 PE OF TIE FVM ice sins: Swdbnnsiedscveserssavveus 883 TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three Dollars per year, in advance, postpaid, to any part of the United States or Canada; to foreign countries comprised in the Postal Union, $4.00. The date when the subscription expires is on the Address-Label of each paper, the change of which to a subsequent date becomes a receipt for remittance. No other receipt is sent unless requested. Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter, or by check, express order, or postal order, payable to “Publisher of the Nation.” When a change of address is desired, both the old and new addresses should be given. Address THE NATION, Box 794, New York. Publication Office, 208 Broadway. TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Fifteen cents per agate line, each insertion, 14 lines to the inch. Twenty per cent. advance for choice of page, top of column, or cuts. Cuts are not inserted on the first page. A column, $20 each insertion; with choice of page. $24 i page, $60 each insertion; front-cover page, $80. Advertisements must be acceptable in every respect, Copy received until Tuesday, 5 P. M. DISCOUNTS. TIME— ‘ insertions TC ee Te eT eT ET 5 per cent. a: 3: - ceppaadamaeee> = 24 si éPenbbceidd eb SsesRavERSeeeS 15° o 89 WT ToT er re 20 =e 52 - 25 - AMOUNT— 500i 750 =‘ 1,000 * 1,500 * 2 000 wind The NATION is wien e to those who advertise in it as long as the advertisement continues. The EDITION of the Nation this week is 9,200 copies. The Subscription List is always open to the inspection of advertisers. *,* Copies of the NATION may be procured in Paris at Brentano’s, 17 Avenue de l’Opéra, and in London of B. F. Stevens, 4 Trafalgar Square, American New ‘S70 ets 15 King William Street, Strand, W. C. London agent for advertisements, R.J. Bush, Fleet Street, E. C. E:ducational. CALIFORNIA, Los Angeles, West 23d Street. ARLBUROUGH SCHOOL for GIRLS. Mrs. GEoRGE A. CASWELL, Principal. MARYLAND, Baltimore, 122 and 124 W. Franklin St. S‘DGEWORTH BOARDING and DAY _« School bee Girls —35th year will begin September 23, 1897. rs. H. P. LEFEBVRE, Principal. Miss E. D. Hunt.ey, Associate Principal. MARYLAND, Catonsville. *s TIMOTHY'S SCHOOL for Girls re- pens September 23, 1896. Pre ageres for College. Heads. Df School: Miss M.C. CARTER, Miss S. R. CARTER. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, OSTON UNIVERSITY Law School. Aanoeens soo Dean MUND H. BENNETT, LL.D. Massacuvusetts, Brookline, P. O. Box 79. OME FOR GIRL STUDENTS IN Boston.—A Parisian lad aioe many years a teach- erof French. in Boston and offeri ng the most unexcep tionable references, and now living in her own newly- furnished home in the most attractive suburb of Bos ton, 30 minutes by electric car from City Hall, can re- ceive afew young ladies and young men as boarders who wish to visit Boston for special study. MASSACHUSETTS, Concord. ONCORD SCHOOL. Prepares for College, Scientific School, and Bust- ness. Individual instruction. Elementary classes. Non-sectarian, James S. GARLAND, Principal. MASSACHUSETTS, Duxbury. WDER POINT SCHOOL. —Prepares for Scientific School, College, or business. Indi- vidual teaching. Elementary classes for young boys. Home and outdoor life. é F. B. Knaep, 8.B. (M1. 1. T.). New YORK oer. 126 and 128 East 17th Street. Uptown Piano School, 239 Lenox Avenue. HE NA TIONAL CONSERVATORY OF MUSIC OF AMERICA.—Dr. Antonin Dvorak, Directer. Admission daily. For particulars, address SECRETARY. New York City, 537 Fifth Avenue. TSS M.D. HUGER, Boarding and Day School for Girls. NEw York, Utica. . RS. PIATT’S SCHOOL FOR GIRLS. —The next school year begins Thursday, Septem- ber 23, 1897. Applications should be made early. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, Chestnut Hill. RS. COMEG YS’ AND MISS BELL’S BOARDING AND DAY SCHOOL FOR GIRLS will reopen October 1. Students prepared for college. FRANCE, Paris. T. MARGARET’S FRENCH AND English School for Girls. Household French, with American oversight. Pupils met at Havre or Cher- bourg. Address Miss ACLY, 50 Avenue de Jéna. TSS ANABLE’S Boarding and Day School for Girls. Established in 1848. Circular on application. Opens Sept. 27. 1850 Pine St., Phila, Pa School of Drawing and Painting, MUSEUM OF FINE ARTS, Copley Square, Boston, Mass. THE TWENTY-SECOND YEAR NOW OPEN. Instruction in drawing from the cast and from life, in painting and decorative design, and also in ‘artictic enatemy _. pers are Principal instructors: F. -——— , and Philip Hale Be a. znd * Painting) Wil- liam Stone ( pone = ), E. "amas (Anatomy), and "rose Perspective). Pupils are allowed the “tit ane the galleries of the gg For cireulare giving detailed informa- on, a MISS S$ PLIZABETH LOMBARD, Manager. ngl coe egand OF MUSIC ( Founded 1853 by Dr. E. Tourjée) G. W. CHADWICK, Musical Director PROSPECTUS FREE. Address FRANK W. HALE, General Mor., Franklin Sq., Boston Western Reserve University Includes ADELBERT COLLEGE (for men); COL- LEGE FOR WOMEN ; GRADUATE SCHOOL FOR MEN AND WOMEN, degrees of A.M., Ph.D.; LAW SCHOOL (three years); MEDICAL ScHOOi, (four years): DEN HOOL (three years). CHARLES ¥ WING Predident, — oe oO. CEDARCROFT SCHOOL. In the Highlands of the Hudson. Number limited o ten. Combines home life with careful indi- mal trast USE, M.A., Principal, Cornwall, N. Y. t be Educational. Cortina Method § 23"u2 2 schools Awarded First Prize Columbian Exposition. SPANISH. IN 20 LESSONS, FRENCH. cloth, each, ENGLISH. $1.50. FRENCH specimen copies of Books I. and II., 30c. Other text and imported Spanish Books. Cortina Academy of Languages, Originators of the Phonograph in teaching languages, 44 W. 34th St., N.Y. ST. AGNES SCHOOL Under the direction of —_— Doane. Prepara- tion for all Colleges. 8 tudies and Courses of College Study. Speci pe A es in music and Art. Gymnasium. iss ELLEN W. BOYD, Prin., Albany, N. Y. THE CAMBRIDGE SCHOOL. A Fetooe. School for Girls. Comforts of Home. HUR GILMAN is the Director. TOAMBRIDGE, MASS. School Agencies. HE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES. EVERETT O. Fisk & Co., Proprietors. ‘ Savers Place, Boston. 1242 12t St., Washington. Fifth Ave., New York. 414Cent Bdg., — 378 Wabash Ave, Chicago. 730 Cooper r Bdg. Denver. 25 King St., Toronto. 525 Stims’n Bk Los Angeles LBANY TEA 1CHERS" AGENCY, 24 State St.. Albany, N. Y —Provides schools of all grades with competent teachers. Assists teachers in obtaining positions. HARLAN P. FRENCH, Manager. OR COLLEGE rab he TIONS IN THE W. apply to ALBERT & CLARK, Pulman Building, Chicago. CHERMERHORN’ S TEA CHERS’ ency Oldest and best known in the U.S. Estab ished 1855. 8E. 14th St, N. Zz Teachers, etc. NAN IDEAL WINTER CLIMATE, a home (and tuition also if desired) for three or four young ladies under the age of seventeen. The house is near Kenilworth Inn, and convenient to Asheville and Biltmore. References exchanged. Address Box $61, Biltmore, Buncombe Co, North Carolina. ‘bye W. STONE, Tutor ~~ Har- vard, 68 Chestnut Street, Boston. Tours. » EUROPEAN WINTER’ RESORT. INNSBRUCK, TYROL, AUSTRIA. 1,900 feet above the sea, with dry, bracing climate. CENTRE FOR SLEIGHING EXCURSIONS. Fine University, Hospital, etc. HOTEL TIROL. Open all the year. CARL LANDSEE, Proprietor. Large, airy, sunny rooms; modern conveniences; superior cul- sine. Reduced rates in winter. Best references. Illus- trated pamphlets sent on application. EUROPEAN BICYCLE TOUR. Allexpenses. 70 days. $420. C. H. SMITH, 218 Woodward Avenue, Detroit, Mich. The Society to Encourage Studies at Home. A Memortal Volume of this Society, with a Sketch of MiSS ANNA ELIOT TICKNOR, is just published Price $1.00. postpaid; to former members of the Society, 50 cents. Allorders should be addressed to the ANNA TICE- NOR LIBRARY, Trinity Court, Station B, Boston. L. B. Heywoop, Librarian. We buy and sell bills of exchange to Letters and make Cable Transfers of money on f Europe, Australia, and South Africa; also 0 make col'ections and issue Commercial C dit and Travellers’ Credits, available in all redit. parts of the world. BROWN BROTHERS & CO. NO. 59 WALL STREET, NEW YORK. KINDERGARTEN SUPPLIES at SCHERMERHAORN’S, 3 East 14th Street, N Y. Send for new Catalogue. Mebane Sa any ed CISL ei i Gan MOAR EME? pe ils eg ei
Page 3
DE ANE CRE Sikes a 34: aah MER a RES Shea TR Ee Nov. 11, 1897] The Nation. a —s ae ; HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & COMPANY’S NEW BOOKS Old Virginia and her Neighbours BY JOHN FISKE Two volumes, crown octavo, gilt top, $4.00. ment and growth of Virginia, “Maryland, the Carolinas, and Georgia nearly to It is a most interesting story, and has never Before been told with the critical insight, the philosophic grasp, and the distinct literary charm with which it is here told by Mr. Fiske. The Critical Period of American History, 1'783-1'789 BY JOHN FISKE Illustrated Edition. With about 170 Illustrations, comprising Portraits, Maps, Facsimiles, Contemporary Views, P rints, and other Historical Materials. Sho. half calf, gilt top, or half polished morocco, $6.25. This volume is illustrated in the same style as the “American Revolution,” published last year. the Rev olution. $4.00 ; Idrich’s Works Complete Poetical and Prose Works of THoMAS BAILEY ALDRICH. New Riverside Edition, thoroughly re- vised by the author. (So/d only in sets.) Poems in 2 vols., 12mo, with portrait, $3.00; Prose Works in 6 vols., 12mo, with another portrait, $9.00. Complete Works, 8 vols., r2mo, $12.00. Large-Paper Edition, limited to 250 copies, $32.00 a set, set. This is an entirely new and complete edition of Mr. Aldrich’s admirable Poems, Novels, Short Stories, and Travel Sketches. All have been carefully re- vised, and the edition presents in unusu- ally attractive form these delightful writ- ings. ondola Days A charming book on Venice and its attractions, by F. HOPKINSON SMITH, author of “Tom Grogan,” “ Colonel Carter of Cartersville,” etc. With illus- trations by the author. 12mo, $1.50. These volumes cover the settle- alden By Henry D. THoREAv. folt- day Edition. A very interesting edition of Thoreau’s most characteristic book, with an Introduction by BRADFORD TORREY, and 30 full-page photogravure Illustrations, including Walden Views, Concord Views, Portraits, etc. 2 vols., I12mo, $5.00. Seven Puzzling Bible Books By WASHINGTON GLADDEN, D. D. $1.25. Illuminating lectures on certam books of the Bible which in various ways puzzle their readers, — Judges, Esther, Job, Ecclesiastes, The Song of Songs, Daniel, and Jonah. The Juggler By CHARLES EGBERT CRADDOCK (Mary N. Murfree). 16mo, $1.25. “The Juggler” is gne of the most dramatic and powerful novels Miss Mur- free has yet written. SOLD BY ALL BOOKSELLERS. SENT, POSTPAID, BY L HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO., BOSTON; 11 E. 17th ST., N.Y. Remington Standard Cypewriter does, and always has done, the Best Work for the longest time, with the least effort on the part of the opera- tor, and the least expense to the owner. New Models now better than ever before Wyckoff, Seamans & Benedict, 327 Broadway, New York. Old and Rare Books. ILLUSTRATED CATALOGUE OF. PART 2, Seventy one Reproductions of Plates, Title-pages, etc., etc. well, beth, Works relating to the Oivil War and Crom- Coaching, Cookery, Costume, Queen Eliza- Freemasonry, Gardening. Books chiefly first editions, by Charles Cotton, Abraham Cowley, William Cowper, Daniel Defoe, Charles Dickens, Dr. John Donne, Michael Drayton, John Dryden, | Thomas Durfey, John Evelyn, Henry Fielding. FIRST EDITIONS of books illustrated by George and Robert Cruikshank, Richard Doyle, and Harry Furniss, and a large collection of curious Facetiz. Part 2. Svo, 74 pages, post free, 1s. PICKERING & CHATTO, 66 HAYMARKET, LONDON, S. W. ELLIS & ELVEY, DEALERS IN OLD AND RARE BOOKS, PRINTS, AND AUTOGRAPHS Siomne 5 Sy Soenot, maiating the Valuable oO are Books upon Musi r by th JOHN BISHOP of Chelt-nham. ne /** 29 New Bond Street, London, England. London Weekly Circular of Rare, Choice, Curious English Books from well-known iiwres ries sold in ou this season. Sent tis on plication by H. W . Hagemann, 160 Sth Ave NY. F. W. CHRISTERN | (DYRSEN & PFEIFFER, Successors), FIRST EDITIONS, etc., etc., FOR SALE, AN 429 5th Ave., between SSth and S9th Sts, New York, w #h | Importers of Foreign Books: Agents for the leading Paris Publishers; Tauchnitz’s British Authors, Teub ner’s Greek and Latin Classics. Catalogues of stock |} mailed on demand. New books received from Paris | and and Leipzig as SOOn as issued. | STUDY AND PRACTICE OF FRENCH IN SCHOOL. In Three Parts. By L. C. Boname, Philadelphia, 258 South 1 6th St. Natural Method on a New Plan, with thorough drill in Pronunciation Pronunciation and Essentials « ot Grammar FRENCH BOOKS" S382" Complete Catalogue 07 mm 4, senold d/o Comsill Cc K( 0, Men’s Wear. Shirts, Pajamas, Night Robes, Neckwear, Smoking Jackets. Gloves Riding and Driving Gloves, Umbrellas, Carri: iye Robes. ne. ? ? Jroadway Ad 19th St. NEW YORK. “OVERN Mi ENT PUBLICATIONS, 7 We can usually an any wanted on short no tice. ¢ reer wmndence invited. 1424-4 F Street. Low DERMILK & Co., Washington, D.C LP AGAzine OF AMERICAN HISTO- ry. Asetin numbers; clean, unused. §75. A S. CLARK, 174 Fulton Street, New York. "lay WILLIAMS, 25 EAST 10TH ST., e N. Y., Dea’er in Magazines and other Pertiodi cals. Seta, volumes, or single numbers. GOLDEN SCEPI E. ~ PERFECTION FOR THE PIPE. Send 4) cents for 4-oz. sample to SURBRUG, 159 Fulton St., N. Y. City. ARNO UIE te enact Send. “4 BR PNR eet Aer apes A IRE 8 wt ate Dae © CS tls aniatitcads ’ 27 Oe Wace 7 See ee ead ; ram, aml
Page 4
lv The Nation. [Vol. 65, No. 1689 The Macmillan Company’s New Books. THE LIFE OF ALFRED, LORD TENNYSON. By His Son. Two Volumes. Cloth, $10.00 net. The First Edition was published October 12. The Second Edition was published October 23. The Third Edition was ready November 10. This, the most famous biography since Lock- “Two salient points strike the reader of this “The chief worth of the book, of course, is its hart’s Life of Scott, comprises many hitherto memoir. One is that it is uniformly fascinating, minute and illuminating portrayal of Tennyson unpublished poems, letters, and the personal re- so rich in anecdote and marginalia as to hold the himself. Its value is only less for the glimpses collections of old friends, such as Professor Tyn- doll. Wc. humour de Vere. te. Lacker Gane attention with the power of a novel. In the next Reeds ae aes mene “KY, sr place it has been put together with consummate it a biography that is likely to be more than the Palgrave, ete. it affords of other men of his time. Both make The portraits and views illustrating it are uncom- tact, if not with academic art, . . . It is faultless book of one year, or of two.”—The Evening monly fine, in its dignity.”’—The Tribune, New York. Transcript, Boston. ‘Easily the biography, not only of the year, but of the decade,” —The New York Times. BIOGRAPHIES OF UNUSUAL INTEREST. THE LETTERS OF ELIZABETH BARRETT BROWNING. Two Volumes. Crown 8vo. Price, $4.00, Edited by Freperic G. KENYON. Simple, natural letters, telling of the mature life of an observant woman, a poet, who was thrown among some of the most interesting people and stir- ring events of her time. THE STORY OF GLADSTONE’S LIFE. By Justin McCartay, M.P., author of ‘‘A History of Our Own Times,”’ ‘‘ The Four Georges,’’ etc. Fully Illustrated. Cloth, 8vo, $6.00. The story of Mr. Gladstone’s life is of necessity, because of the prominent sitions which he held during so many years, to some degree a History of ngland for those decades. The Old Santa Fé Trail. By Col. Henry Inman, late of the U.S. Army. With eight full-page Pho- togravures from sketches by FrepEeRIc REMINGTON, besides numerous ini- The Story of a tials, tailpieces, etc.,in which appear views of points of special interest : along the trail, portraits of famous government scouts, trappers, Indians, Great Highway. ete. There is also a Map of the Trail and a portrait of Col. Inman. The Cloth, Extra, Medium Octavo. Price, $3.50. book is full of thrilling stories of Indian fighting, of the Mexican War, and ef hunting. Old English Love Songs. With an Introduction by HamiLton W. Masiz, by whom also the selection is made. A COMPANION TO Cloth, Price $2.00. Limited Large-paper Edition, $5.00. Old English Ballads Published last season, on which the Nation com- mented: ‘‘A most charming book, of the very best Old English and Scotch ballads.” Both volumes are illustrated and decorated by GEoRGE WHARTON EDWARDS. F. Marion Crawford’s New Italian Novel: CORLEONE. ‘*The mere ‘ story’ is of absorbing interest, and possesses the transcendent merit that even a biasé or veteran reviewer is altogether unable to foresee the Completing the conclusion. . . . Our author has created one of the strongest situations where- Two Volumes, Saracinesca Series. with we are acquainted, either in the novel or the drama. . . . "\—The Book- Cloth, Price, $2.00. man, IN THE PERMANENT WAY. Snort Stories oF LIFE IN INDIA. By Frora Annik Steg, author of “On the Face of the Waters,” ‘The Flower of Forgiveness,”’ etc. Cloth, 12mo, $1.50. ‘* Mrs. Steel does not introduce us to, but into her characters. We do not look at them. but with them. We think their thoughts, suffer with them, and are merry with them. We know them from the inside, not the outside.’’— The New York Sun, YANKEE SHIPS AND YANKEE SAILORS. TALEs oF 1812. By JAMES BARNES. Cloth, Crown 8vo, $1.50. A lively series of sketthes of the troublesome times of 1812; a good means of arousing interest in the history of the war in which the sailor played so great a part, therefore a valuable addition to any library consulted by young people. Singing Verses for Children. With Music and Illustrations in Color. Verses by Lydia Avery Coonley. Illustrations and colored borders by Auice KeLLoge TyLter. Music by Freperic W. Root, Eveanor Smita, Jesste L Gaynor, and Frank H. ATKINSON, JR The verses are simple and natural, full of the pleasures of child. life, outdoor Songs and Music with Pic- or indoor, bright, and varied. The music is admirably suited to the verses. “One of the most imaginative and exquisite publications of this or any other season. It is poetry, music, and fine art all in one.”'—The Inter Ocean, ed. Cloth, Ato, $2.00 net. tures and Decorative Borders Chicago. Every Page Specially Design- Citizen Bird. SCENES FROM BIRD LIFE IN PLAIN LANGUAGE FOR BEGINNERS. By Mase. Osaoop Wriaut, author of * Birderaft,” etc., ete.. and Dr. ELLIoTT Coves, author of ** Birds of North America.” Cloth. 12mo, $1.50, net. “There is no other book in existence so well fitted for arousing and direct ing the interest that all children of any sensibility feel toward the birds.”’— Chicago Tribune Wild Neighbors. OUTDOOR STUDIES IN THE UNITED STATES. By Ernest INGERSOLL, author of ‘Friends Worth Knowing,’ ‘‘ Country Cousins," ete. Fully illustrated. 12mo, cloth, price $1.50. “The book is full of curious information, and no reader, however well up in natural history, will lay down the book without having learned something from it.”’—Boston Transcript. Send for the Illustrated Christmas Catalogue issued by THE MACMILLAN COMPANY, 66 Fifth Ave., New York. Seite RCRA ARR Se SRT pag ie on SESH ATE
Page 5
Aapaaei he chdna ect Albis dig eas acetate, Sc aS a nasi se ie POTD SPEER TE. fist Se 25 Sea er i ak a a Se. The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 11, 1897. The Week. Spain is naturally incensed at the ar- ticles, interviews, and letters of ex-Mi- nister Taylor, but no international ap- peal lies to the sense of propriet¥ of a private citizen. If Mr. Taylor thinks it fitting to go on speaking of what came to his knowledge through his official po- sition, no power on earth can stop him as long as the newspapers are agape for his views. All that Mr. McKinley needs to say to Spain is that this is a free country, and that he has no more con- trol over Mr. Hannis Taylor, now that this gentleman is out of office, than he has over the Ohio election. He might add, however, an appeal to the forbear- ance of Spain on the ground that she knows how it is herself. She has the spoils system in as great perfection as we have it. With a change in the Span- ish Administration, the public service has to undergo upheaval just as with us. There is no permanent diplomatic ser- vice in Spain any more than in the United States. The new cabinet has to give up all its time, there as here, to office-seekers. The boss system, as Mr. Lowell found out, is as flourishing in Spain as in our own proud republic. Even Gen. Weyler’s recall, over which so much fuss has been made, seems to have been more the seizure of good places for original Sagasta men than anything else. In fact, Mr. McKinley might make out a powerful argument that the two countries ought to be good friends, as both have, under different forms, the same idea of destroying con- tinuity in the public service, and of gracefully stretching out their necks for the bosses’ heels. The severe shaking of Wall Street on Friday by unfounded rumors of war with Spain was a prelude of the shaking that all business interests would receive if those rumors should be confirmed. Wall Street is only a barometer that serves to forewarn the public of disturb- ances in the upper regions before they manifest themselves in tempest and tor- nado. We do not believe that there is any foundation for these rumors. Mr. Hannis Taylor’s indiscretions may prob- ably be explained by a personal desire not to be forgotten by the political par- ty to which he and Senator Morgan, the leading: Democratic Jingo, belong. It is not likely that the Administration would choose a shirt-sleeves statesman of the opposite party for its mouthpiece. More- over, there has been a decline in Jingo- ism perceptible to the journalistic sense during the past three months. Even the World, valiant organ of Cuba Libre as it has been, perceives the change. The coming together of Congress, we are sorry to say, is viewed with alarm by all business interests; that is, by the order- ly, industrious, God-fearing portion of the community. If a vote could be taken by this class of citizens on the question whether there should be any meeting of Congress during the coming twelve- month, it would be decided in the nega- tive by so large a majority that the af- firmative would not be worth counting; and among the reasons for not wanting a session would be the fear lest some wanton outbreak of foreign embroilment should take place in consequence. But, says some one, no such thing can hap- pen if the President stands firm. That is true. Congress has the power to de- clare war, but Congress is not likely to declare war without some aggressive act on the part of Spain. There has been no such act, and there is no likelihood of it. If there were any such act for which prompt reparation could not be obtained, then the responsibilities of war would not 1est upon the conscience of the nation. The case would wear a very different aspect from that of a war in which we were the aggressors. The question, therefore, which agitates Wall Street is whether President McKinley has the firmness to prevent those steps leading up to war which lie within his own discretion. That his private in- clinations are strongly for peace, and that the Jingo sentiment in the country is not so strong as it was some months ago, are facts upon which good hopes may rest. Friends of Hawaiian annexation in Washington now report a new reason for the President's anxiety that the treaty be speedily ratified. He wants it safely out of the way before the Cuban business gets acute. That is to say, two ugly foreign complications are better than one. Hawaiian annexation, if it stood alone, is confessedly a subject re- quiring the closest study and the full- est debate; but if it can possibly get in the way of our going to war with Spain, why, agree to it at once and in the dark. This is a marked change, be it noted, from what was said last May to be the President's idea of the rela- tions of the Hawaiian question to the Cuban question. Then he was going shrewdly to head off the Cuban Jingoes by drawing the Hawaiian herring across the trail. There was bound to be some kind of annexation, some kind of Jin- go explosion, some occupation for the navy and naval editors; so how fine and sly it would be to divert all the bottled Jingo fury towards the Sandwich Isi- ands, with only 100,000 aliens unfit for self-government, and so save us from tak- ing in Cuba with her 1,500,000 unfit a'lens. But it appears now to have been found out, even in Washington, that Jingo ap- petite grows by what it feeds on, and at present the argument is that we must hurry up and bolt Hawaii in order the sooner to set our teeth to Cuba. We are glad to read that in the new negotiations for a treaty of arbitration vetween England and the United States care will be taken at Washington not to “press the subject unduly.” We all know that undue pressure was what killed the other treaty. If the people had not been so eager and unanimous in expressing their desire for its rati- fication, the Senate might have agreed to it. As Senator Hoar explained, when churches and colleges and boards of trade and chambers of commerce and State Legislatures began petitioning the Senate to ratify, the cause was at once lost; there was nothing for a self-re- specting Senate to do but refuse to rati- fy. This fatal error, it is gratifying to be assured, will not be repeated. The new treaty will be devised in a casual, nonchalant way, turned over to the Se- nate with an indifferent air, with as- surances that the people are taking no interest in it whatever, and then, by not being unduly pressed, it may stand a chance of being ratified. It is cer tain that thereafter. at any rate, the people will take no interest in it what- ever. Cornelius N. Bliss, after several days of silent meditation, is able to remark about the Tammany victory: “It is simply what might be expected from a division in the ranks of the people who won the victory last year. This is all there is about it. When it became impossible to make a unicn of forces opposed to Tam- many, defeat was inevitable. As to respon- sibility, every man will have to decide that for himself. We hope that before another election takes place we will be able to get these divided forces together.” Has Mr. Bliss decided for himself what his responsibility is? And if so, is his sense of it likely to prevent him, when the time for another city election ar- rives, from again using all his influence to delude 100,000 Republicans into an alliance with a “rotten” machine, and into the support of a hopeless candidate who is put in the field by a boss “who deliberately acts so as to make it im- possible for self-respecting men to be allied with him even for a good pur- pose’? Is Mr. Bliss a “self-respecting man,” or did he perform the “impossi- ble’ when he joined forces with Platt for the purpose of defeating Mr. Low and putting Tammany in possession of the city for four years? An entertain- ing rumor comes from Washington that : : f 8 RII a MeN aber nn sone Al - i “oot meme te geet” DAE an Rar ee OE Png edn ape gg Sen rere
Page 6
366 The Nation. [Vol. 65, No. 1689 President McKinley is so disgusted with the result of our election that he will not bestow any more New York patron- age on Platt. He has ample cause for disgust, but he should visit his wrath mainly upon himself and Secretary Bliss. He did what he could to aid Platt by giving him the Brooklyn ap- pointments at the very moment when the Brooklyn Republican organization was halting between Platt and Low, and he allowed Mr. Bliss to give the impres- sion that the national Administration was on Platt’s side by coming here to speak for Tracy. The fact that there is a large anti- Tammany majority in this city now jumps into our eyes, through figures, as it has never jumped before. We have always believed and maintained that it existed, but never before has there been a movement like the Low movement to bring out the fact mathematically. Here it is mathematically: SE: cctgoseens 148,585 Van Wyck .... 228,688 errs 101,571 ee 19,864 270,020 For a beginning of an entirely new SYS; tem of nomination, and for a canvass conducted largely by inexperienced ama- teurs, we hold that the Low vote of 148,585 is splendid and full of hope. There is great ground for encourage- ment, too, in the fact that Gen. Tracy’s Republican vote was lower than it has ever been for any Republican candidate in the old New York since the Wicked Gibbs ran for the mayoralty in 1884. Gibbs polled 44,000 votes in a much smaller electorate in 1884; Roosevelt polled 60,000 in 1886; Erhardt polled 73,- 000 in 1888; Tracy only 55,000 in 1897. This shows that an impression may be made on the Republican column by steady effort. Four years is a long time to wait, undoubtedly, for another attack on Tammany, but in those four years Tammany will be furnishing us with plenty of ammunition, and Republicans will be seeing and thinking, and the Citizens’ Union will be learning how to fight. The great hindrance to all continuous and persistent reform agitations in Ame- rica hitherto, except the anti-slavery agitation, has been the national ten- dency to sit down quietly under accom- plished facts, to accept defeat with a laugh, say it “‘will all come out right in the end,” and turn attention to some- thing else. The readiness of the press, after opposing a candidate tooth and nail for good reason, to congratulate him on his victory, and promise to sup- port him if he is good, is a comic illus- tration of the same thing. There is a little trace of it in Mr. Low’s pledging to “the new Mayor and his associates the coéperation of all my supporters in any effort they may make’to administer the government of the city in the interest of the people.” All talk like this, however courtecius it may seem, takes the heart out of a steady and continuous criticism and opposition. If there be the smallest probability that Mr. Van Wyck and his associates will do anything of the kind, two-thirds of our talk about Tammany in the late canvass was pure campaign “ouff.”” We fought and have lost on the theory that there was no such prob- ability; that Van Wyck’s associates would be the old gang as we know them, and that ‘‘the administration of the government of the city in the interest of the people” would be the last thing they would think of. Croker and Van Wyck have both discarded any such idea, in their talk with the reporters since the election. Our duty to the new govern- ment is not to “codperate,” because we do not know in what we should have to coéperate, but to watch, and criticise. and expose, and defend the people whom Tammany may annoy or persecute, and see that its majorities do not affect the imagination of the courts; above all, keep alive the opposition, if not in the character of patriots, in that of civilized men who refuse to live quietly under the rule of barbarians and thieves. When Mr. Croker, speaking in that authoritative voice which he always uses in his deliverances as the King of New York, says that “we have plain, practi- cal men in Tammany Hall; the men that we need at the head of the departments will be found in Tammany Hall without drawing upon the Citizens’ Union,” who are the men that he has in mind? There has been no time since Tweed’s day when the number of really respectable Democrats in Tammany Hall was so small as it is to-day. How many such were among the Tammany orators in the late campaign, or even appeared on the Tammany platform at its meetings? The leading orators were Tom Grady, Birdie Gardiner, and Sulzer. Not a Democrat of first-rate character and ability ap- peared as Tammany’s champion any- where. This being the case, who are the “plain, practical men” with whom Mayor Van Wyck is to fill the forty great positions which will be at his dis- posal on January 1, and the thirty or more minor ones? There is nobody in Tammany except the old gang—Gilroy, the Martins, Grady, Scannell, Koch, and the rest. They are all there, and they are all determined to have places. If Van Wyck were a man of great strength of character and of high purpose, he would be incapable of successful resist- ance to the “pressure” of his associates. Even if he wished to put fit men in the forty chief offices, where is he going to find them among his followers? Croker says he will not be allowed to go out- side for material, and if he is not the 16a] Mayor, he speaks as if he consider- ed himself so. Full returns of the Iowa election show again that courage pays in politics. Mr. Shaw, the Republican candidate for Governor, got his nomination against the opposition of the party machine, and then made his campaign as the open and avowed champion of the gold standard. The opposition succeeded in combining the Bryan Democracy, Silver Republi- cans, and Populists pretty successful- ly on one ticket, and induced many Gold Democrats to support this ticket by the claim that the contest was purely a State one. Nevertheless, Mr. Shaw polled a vote far larger that was ever secured by a State ticket, and his plu- rality over the fusion ticket is fully 30,000, or larger than the record for the Republican candidate over the combined Democratic and Populist vote since the silver issue came up. The contrast be- tween Iowa and Pennsylvania, where the Quay ticket was left in a minority this year, tells a story which even the dullest politician cannot fail to com- prehend. The lower branch of the Georgia Le- gislature voted last week in favor of making the birthday of Jefferson Davis a legal holiday in that State. But any fearful soul at the North who may fancy that such a vote signifies devotion to “the lost cause” ought to be reassured when he learns that during the same week the Board of Supervisors of War- ren County, Miss., which includes Vicks- burg, the chief city of Jefferson Davis’s own State, adopted unanimously resolu- tions declaring it “the deliberate opinion of this board that the entire subject of quarantine against yellow fever and other infectious diseases of foreign ori- gin ought to be under the paramount control of the United States; the ex- perience of the present system and spread of yellow fever this year fur- nishing conclusive evidence that the se- veral independent Boards of Health of the States bordering on the Gulf of Mexico cannot be safely relied upon to prevent the introduction and spread of infectious and contagious diseases.” When this official expression of prefer- ence for federal control of quarantine is endorsed by so representative a Mis- sissippi newspaper as the Vicksburg Herald, which says that it “strikes a keynote that is commended to every county and municipality in the lower valley,’’ the most timorous can dismiss all apprehension as to a revival of “the State-rights heresy.” Mr. Edward Atkinson has published a small pamphlet to prove a thesis which he has heretofore maintained in refer- ence to the silver question, namely, that some of the largest mines in the world are now worked in such a way that the silver produced by them is merely a bye- product—the other ores yielding enough profit to make it worth while to work Sabi SRE ci cae IRE
Page 7
~ tomary method of crediting the bye-pro-
2 alesis, Pai BE Salat
Nov. 11, 1897]
The Nation. 3867
them, even if no silver at all were pro- duced. Among these are the Broken Hill Proprietary of New South Wales and the Anaconda of the United States. When Mr. Atkinson first advanced this state- ment it was questioned by a writer in the Financial News of London, who in- sisted that the cost of operation ought to be charged to all the metals produced, and that if this rule were followed, it would be found that the cost of silver to the Broken Hill Company for the year 1896 was 221%4d., or 45 cents, per ounce. Mr. Atkinson now proves that the cost of all silver produced by this company from 1891 to 1896, according to the cus- ducts to the cost of the principal pro- duct, namely, silver, has been less than 25 cents, or 12% pence, per ounce. Also, that the copper production of the Ana- conda mine in Montana, in the last fiscal year, ending June 30, 1897, yielded a profit over and above all charges of every name and nature, without regard to the silver production. Also, that in that year of low prices the sale of the largest silver product ever made at that mine in one year—namely, 6,057,067 ounces fine—yielded $3,881,551.75 in gold; the whole of this sum received for silver bullion being in addition to the profits upon copper. As the Anaconda property has been sold to an English syndicate, it follows that the largest share of the silver production of the world, something more than one-half, is now centred in London, that the silver so produced is a clean profit to the own- ers, the cost of operation being nearly all borne by other products of the same mines, and that the principal seat of bimetallism as a money-making ven- ture is in London, and not in Colorado or in any other part of the United States.
Sir Michael Hicks-Beach, the English Chancellor of the Exchequer, has been addressing his constituents on various topics, and naturally enough touched on the recent bimetallic flurry in the Bank of England. He said, among many other things: “The letter of the Governor of the Bank of England caused great excitement in the City of London. There is a reasonable, aye, and to my mind a very proper and wise, feeling in the City of London, in favor of the maintenance to as great an extent as pos- sible of the gold reserve in the Bank of England. I do not think there can be a question, I think even I might put it now
to my bimetallist friends who may happen to be present, that if we have a gold stan- dard we must have an adequate stock of gold; and, that being so, I am quite sure that neither the Government of this coun- try nor the Bank of England ought for a moment to consent to anything that would prejudicially affect the amount of our stock of gold in this country, either in reserve or in circulation among the people.” Now this shows twothings. One is, that the talk of bimetallic philosophers, though Sir Michael treats it respectfully —too respectfully, we think—produced no effect until the Governor of the | Bank of England wrote a letter; se- condly, that the minute he wrote the letter, it ‘caused great excitement in the City ef London.” In other words. the minute it appeared that these silly spe- culators meant business, the business world rose in arms. He might have added that the minute the business world rose in arms, the Cabinet squelch- ed the bimetallists, inside and outside, and all said “‘gold.’’ Now this once more confirms what we have been saying for the last two years to the American bi- metallists who have been running over to England to get comfort from Mr. Bal- four, and Mr. Moreton Frewen, and Mr. Gibbs, and so forth, and then hurrying home to tell their bimetallic brethren here that England was on the edge of bimetallism: ‘‘When you arrive in Eng- land, do not go to the Treasury in Downing Street to see Mr. Balfour, or to the library of any bimetallic philoso- pher. Take your gripsack and go straight to the City.” A letter which John Bright wrote in 1884 about imperial federation has late- ly been given to the press. In it he spoke of the project of bringing colo- nial members into Parliament as “ab- surd,” and went on: “These ideas of ‘federation’ between Eng- land and her colonies are equally visionary and valueless. What is intended by ‘federa- tion’ I do not know. But surely trade is meant, and surely free trade—not a Cana- dian or a Victorian tariff. We now give the colonies everything: we buy almost all they have to sell, and levy no duty on their ex- ports—none for protection. What can we do more? If they want a nearer alliance with us, they can give up their tariffs: we can give them nothing more. Our people are all friends of the colonies, but common sense in dealing with our brethren in distant re- gions is worth far more than the feeble sen- timent which some dreamers seem anxious to encourage.” For a Little Englander, this was a re- markable forecast of all that has really happened. Canada has simply given up her tariff, as against England, and the Jubilee-makers could not contain them- selves for joy. But a little of John Bright’s common sense would have shown them that a trade arrangement for common profit was all there was in it.
The Powers have at last pulled them- selves together and named a Governor of Crete. He is a Col. Schaefer of the Duchy of Luxemburg. Coming from a small and neutral state; he is expected to arouse no jealousies among the Powers; and the only question is how the Sultan will take hic nomination. His appointment is, in fact, announced as only “provisional,” but the Powers think that it ought not to be a “diffi- cult task” to induce the Sultan to con- sent to it. If he does not, there are their Admirals still on the spot, there will be “energetic action,” and so on. | He that sitteth in the Yildiz Kiosk shall laugh at all this. He will believe in energetic action when he sees it, and
will snap his fingers at all the Admi- rals in the world until they begin to turn their guns his way. Thus far the Admirals have done nothing but bom- bard Christians and help the English Liberals carry parliamentary elections Another Conservative seat was lost in a bye-election on Thursday.
The continuous turmoil and rioting in the Austrian Parliament has, no doubt, causes in the sharp racial divisions which have long made the problem of Austrian government so difficult; but the inability of the presiding officer to keep order betrays 3 defect in the rules and parliamentary practice which Aus tria seems to share with France. The President of the Reichsrath, as of the French Chamber, appears to have no re- source except to ring his bell, or say “Sh!” cr, as a last vesort, to dissolve the sitting. No representative bocy in England or America is so left at the merey of unscrupulous brawlers, A ser- reant-at-arms, or some equivalent func tionary. is at hand to suppress or re move them. Vienna, so long reputed the politest court in Europe, may have thought itself beyond the need of such protection against disgraceful riot in its Parliament; but the flerce struggle of races has evidently broken through the ordinary restraints of decency. A writer in the last Rerwe des Dewr Mondes, com- menting upon the extraordinary diversi- ty and the extraordinary jealousy of the different nationalities in the empire, says that if local factions could have their way, we should soon be reading of the Austro-Hungario-Bohemian monar- chy, or even, we may add, of the Austro- Hungario-Bohemio-Croatian monarchy. Protection in Germany is like pro- tection everywhere else. “Der Bund der Industriellen” (The League of Industrial Workers) met in Berlin on October 3 and 4. One of the most prominent mat- ters under discussion was the importa- tion of American bicycles, which has grown from $1,898,012 in 1896 to $7,- 000,323 in 1897. The German bicycles are clumsy and heavy wheels, which even the German cyclists, loyal as they are to German industries, will evidently not buy. The natural inference that most people would draw from this marked preference for the American article is that it is better than the German at the same price, and that the German makers should change the designs and improve the workmanship of their wheels. But instead of reading this lesson to the manufacturers, the League calls on the Government to raise the duty on Ameri- can wheels because it is lower than that which the United States and some other countries impose. Certainly a high im- port duty laid by a large exporting com- munity like the American is an anoma- ly; but it is not confined to the bicycle trade nor to Germany, BRO fet SY Ohi et q 8 F i rf Sonhig hs ee) sins ei + BB Ties nae Pag LAS POR IONE S LS TERE nantes Net APM LINE EME SPEIER "ledges Pe ny i at’ —< a - oe GALE. SLES IOLA EEE EE INE EATS A TEI maton
Page 8
The Nation. [Vol. 65, No. 1689 — VHE REVOLT AGAINST BOSSISM. The most striking feature of the re- cent elections, as their results become clearer with fuller returns, is seen to be the tremendous revolt against bossism wherever it was in issue. Among the few States where contests took place were four which had each its boss well known to the country at large, and every one of these four bosses encountered a revolt so strong as to show that public sentiment was the same, North and South, East and West. Platt controlled the Republican party in a State which gave the Republican candidate for President 268,469 plurality over Bryan last year, and chose an As- sembly with 114 Republicans out of 159 members. This year the Republican candidate for Chief Judge of the Court of Appeals, whom he named through his State committee, is beaten hy about 70,000 plurality, and the opposition se- cures ynore than half of the next Assem- bly, while his personal nominee for May- or of the Greater New York gets only two-thirds as many votes as the candi- date of the Citizens’ Union. Instead of having a majority of seventy-eizght mem- bers in the Assembly,as was the case last winter, Mr. Platt will be short of any majority whatever this winter. What is especially bad for him is the fact that the balance of power in the new Assem- bly will be held by a handful of mem- bers who have been elected because they were avowec opponents of his system of government. These members believe that the government belcngs to the people rather than to Platt. and they have had the impudence to hold a conference and pledge themselves to act upon that be- lief. Of course, men suffering under a hallucination like this will not consent to go to Platt every Sunday for orders; and the consequence will be that his system of government will have to be abandoned. Just how many of these members will be found acting for the people when the Legislature meets, cannot be pre- dicted now; but that there will be enough of them to prevent Platt from organizing the Assembly unless he makes an open alliance with Tammany members, there appears to be no doubt whatever. Several of them, notably Messrs. Laimbeer and Weekes of this city, are men of such force of character and of such high purpose that any at- tempt to swerve them from the course they have entered upon will be futile. They are not unlikely to have allies from other parts of the State than Brooklyn, for dissatisfaction with the results ot Platt’s leadership is very prevalent and strong above the Bronx as well as below it. And it would be surprising if this were not the case. The party has lost everything in the election. It has lost control of the Legislature this year, and has thrown away, irrevocably all hope of electing a Governor next year or a United States Senator in 1899, or of carrying the State for a Republican Fre- sidential candidate in 1900. There is not a Republican politician in the State who believes for a moment that there is any chance that his party, during the next four years, will be able to poll above the Bronx a Republican majority which will be large enough to overcome the Demo- cratic majority of Greater New York. In Ohio, Hanna was the absolute dic- tator of the Republican organization, and sought the endorsement of the peo- ple as a candidate for the United States Senate. The last Legislature contained 110 Republicans and 28 Democrats on joint ballot. The best that is now claim- ed is a majority of five for the Republi- cans on joint ballot, three of which come from counties where changes of from 15 to 45 votes would have elected the De- mocratic candidates and given that par- ty an unquestioned majority of the Le- gislature. Except for the feeling that Hanna represented an endorsement of the McKinley Administration which Mc- Kinley’s own State could not afford to refuse only eight months after his inau- guration, he would evidently have been beaten. Even as it is, his success is not assured, as more than one Republican member-elect is personally opposed to the boss. Gorman has been the commander of the Democratic organization in Mary- land for twenty years. During the latter part of this period his rule has been des- potic. Eight years ago he signalized his power in the way that most delights a boss, by having a subservient Legisla- ture give the other United States sena- torship to a man who was simply his “Me Too.” Two years ago this tool was repudiated, a Democratic State prefer- ring a Republican in his stead. This year the same Democratic State again elects a Republican Legislature to fill the senatorship which Gorman has held, as the only way of getting rid of the boss himself. Quay controls the Republican organi- zation in Pennsylvania so openly that, when the last Legislature was in ses- sion, the Republican majority made no secret of the fact that it did nothing without orders from the boss. He named his men for the State ticket without the slightest difficulty, and President Mc- Kinley improved the opportunity to show that the national Administration favored him by naming a disreputable henchman of his as consul during the campaign, against the earnest protest of leading business men of Philadelphia, who furnished evidence of his gross corruption as a legislator. But the re- turns show that the Quay candidate for State Treasurer fell considerably short of a majority at the polls, the Demo- cratic vote combined with that cast for an Independent Republican and a Pro- hibitionist who appealed even more strongly to the independent element, ag- gregating 377,203, against 371,053 for Quay’s man. The plain-spoken clergy- man who ran as a nominal Prohibition- ist, but really as an anti-machine candil- date, though without any effective or- ganization or campaign fund, polled 117,430 votes, or nearly a third as many as Quay’s man. In its way the blow dealt bossism in Pennsylvania was as stinging as in either of the other States. Never before has bossism presented itself so offensively as this year. In the past there has been more or less pretence of reserve. This year the bosses threw off all disguise. They declared that bossism is the ideal perfection of government in a democracy. Hanna summed up their creed in these orders to his subjects a few days before the election: “Every Republican should remember his duty. It doesn’t make any difference about persons, or if the candidate don’t suit you exactly. The Republican organization must have the same discipline as we had in the regular army, when the boys in blue march- ed with their gallant leaders. As Chairman of the Republican national committee, I have the right to command, and you must stand by me in the dual position I now occupy. It doesn't matter whether you like my per- sonality or not. I have no patience with the man who bolts his party because he is not satisfied with the candidate. If you ex- pect business men to take part in politics and come among you, it is your duty to sub- mit to the discipline of the party.” It is well for the country that boss- ism has thus been carried to its logical conclusion. The great thing is to have the Quays and Hannas and Gormans and Platts come out into the open, where the people can get at them. The late elections show that the strongest boss cannot long survive the firing which he thus invites. THE TARIFF AND THE CITY. When we come to hunt up the remoter causes of the difficulty of setting up de- cent government in this city, the first obstacle that confronts us is the fanati- cal devotion of a considerable body of Republicans to their own party—a devo- tion which in its outward man.festa:ions more nearly resembles the devotion of religious men to a church, two hundred years ago, than anything else in mo- dern times. That is to say, it can hardly be shaken by argument or by any exhi- bition of consequences. We know of no political or economical considerations which would have any effect on it; and as to its influence on the city, Republi- cans say simply, as the martyrs said about Christianity, “Perish the city pro- vided the Republican party be saved.” In fact, support of the Republican party seems to be an awful duty, the “stern daughter of the voice of God,” to be dis- charged though the sky should fall. Now, what is the explanation of this extraordinary phenomenon? Well, it is far simpler than it seems. The term “Republican party” does not really mean a party in the ordinary sense of the term, with a body of political doctrine we
Page 9
Nov. 11, 1897]
The Nation. 369
of its own and a set of distinctly de- fined aims. As a party it does not dif- fer much, if at all, from the Democratic party, barring the recent adhesion of the Democratic party to silver. To all outward appearance, the Republican at- titude towards all questions except the tariff—its view of public office, of for- eign policy, and of taxation—appears to be substantially that held by the De- mocrats. The tariff apart, there is no difficulty for an honest man in passing from one party to the other. He might any day doubt to which party he belong- ed, as far as opinions are concerned. Even as regards silver, enough Demo- crats to enable it to elect its President had no difficulty in acting with the Re- publican party last year. We are thus driven by a process of pure reasoning to the conclusion that the proper name of the Republican par- ty, the distinctive aim which would best describe it, is the Tariff party. Its dis- tinguishing trait is devotion to the tariff. This is the one thing which differen- tiates a respectable, intelligent Republi- can from a respectable and intelligent man of any other sect or creed. It is by this trait we know him, just as an early Christian was known by his refusal to sacrifice to the gods. It was by requiring him to burn incense to Jupiter or Apollo that the cruel Romans found him out. In like manner a Republican would be found out by requiring him to curse the tariff, or say it was a bad thing for the country. He would sacrifice himself. his aged mother, or loving wife, or innocent children, or the city of his birth, sooner than do this. The Republican party is the party which has the tariff in charge. To weaken it for any purpose is to put the tariff in peril. To join forces with the Democrats or Mugwumps for any purpose, is to weaken it; therefore ‘“vot- ing straight” becomes the most solemn and sacred of all political duties. We shall not consider this so very ex- traordinary as it seems at first sight if we remember that we have now been living under a high tariff for thirty years; that during that period an enor- mous amount, practically an incalcula- ble amount, of money has been invest- ed under it in every species of manu- facture; that a generation has grown up under it who either owed, or believed they owed, their subsistence or their comfort to it. It has naturally become linked in their imagination with every- thing good and“‘American” in the world The mental process by which this takes place is one of the most familiar in the history of the human mind. All old institutions—the old British Constitu- tion, the old French monarchy, the old Catholic Church, tbe Inquisition even— got support in this way from large bodies of persons who had been born and prospered under them. If the tariff had failed to induce large bodies of per- sons in this country to look on it as /ties of the Government.
the source of their own comfort and suc- cess in life and of American prosperity, it could not have lasted very long. As a matter of fact, it has become identified in the eyes of such persons with prop- erty and order. To attack it is, as Sheil said of the enemies of Catholicism, to “furnish help to those miserable men who are the enemies of human hope, the apostles of desolation and despair.” Its safety become; a concern so weighty as to make all other interests seem trifling. It seems silly to talk about city govern- ment, Tammany, plunder, or dirt, with men who you know cherish, in their se- cret hearts, dark designs againgt the wool and cotton duties, and the duties on knitted goods and other textiles, and who would, if they could, take the duty off steel. It seems like discussing al- terations in church ritual with a shame- less infidel. It sounds fantastical, we know, anc yet it is our solemn conviction, that the march of political progress has for thir- ty years at least been arrested in Ame- rica by this tariff fanaticism; by the erection among us of something sacro- sanct which we cannot alter or dispense with, and the safety of which must not be endangered by any other change whatever. It is in reality the substitu- tion for theocracy of a form of govern- ment closely resembling it. The tariff is, in the eyes of the Platt Republicans in New York, somewhat in the position of the Koran in the eyes of good Mus- sulmans at Constantinople. No matter what beneficial change you propose in the government of the latter city, two ebjections to it at once arise. The first is that it comes from a Giaour (Mug- wump or Democrat); the second is that, there being no mention of it in the Sa- cred Law, it would probably endanger the true faith if adopted. Better dirt and poverty, ruined bridges, venal courts, and a declining state, than that the Prophet’s idea of a political commu- nity should be departed from. Many of our people would sooner see everything that used to constitute American great- ness and glory depart from us, than even endanger the chance of levying 60 per cent. on all the instruments and re- | sults of civilization. In their sad and softened fancy they would be reconciled to seeing the republic perish if in its last moments the appraisers and gaugers and inspectors were still busy on the wharves, and the giddy travellers from foreign ports were still mulcted on their silks and their gewgaws It is an odd
these to be redeemed and cancelled are the greenbacks and the Treasury notes of 1890, amounting to $460,000,000. That these are a menace to the Government's credit and to general prosperity the Secretary shows in an unanswerable way. He esiimates the losses suffered by business interests in consequence of the doubt thrown on the Government's in- tention and ability to keep the currency at par with gold during the past four years at a greater sum than the out- standing paper, including the silver cer- tificates, viz., $900,000,000. We think that this is an underestimate, but all persons of sense will agree that the losses have been enormous. The purchase of silver alone has been a direct and dead loss to the Government of $460,000,000—i. ¢., more than one-half of the total loss estimated by Mr. Gage to have been in- curred since 1893. It may be cuntended that the condition is now fairly satis- factory, as gold is flowing towards the Treasury, not away from it. Mr Gage gives a more ready assent to this proposition than we should be inclined to do, but he shows that present condi- ions cannot be expected to last for ever. ‘ircumstances will not always be in our ‘avor. A change fur the worse may come at any time. It is the statesman’s duty to foresee such changes and to provide rgainst them. Mr. Gage’s plan for meeting future idverse conditions is evidently based upon the idea that Congress cannot be prevailed upon now to take radical ac- tion, but may be induced to take steps that shall minimize the evils of which we have had recent experience. So while endorsing the proposition ad- vanced by so many of his predecessurs in office, that the demand notes of the Government ought to be paid and can- celled, his specific propositions come somewhat short of this. In other words, his remedy does not correspond to his diagnosis. Perhaps if his plan had been prepared in the light of the recent eiec- tions he might have adhered more close- ly to first principles. These elections teach, in our opinion, one lesson, viz., | that the Republican party may be beaten political ideal, belonging rather to the | is great and Mohammed is his prophet.
SECRETARY GAGE’'S PLAN, The plan of currency reform presented by Secretary Gage for the consideration of the cabinet begins with a strong ar- gument for retiring the demand liabili- The first of
in 1898 and 1900 even if it reforms the currency meanwhile, but that it will surely be beaten if it does not. There- fore, we may indulge the hope that Secretary Gage will even yet adopt the more radical measure which his cabi- net paper shows that he favors, and which his utterances as a private citi- zen have aforetime more explicitly fifteenth century than to ours; but God | promines Turning now to the specific plan, we remark that he recommends that the business of supplying a currency to the country be separated from the ordinary | business of the Treasury by the creation | of a department or division of issue and redemption. To this division he would transfer $125,000,000 of gold and $200,- 000,000 of greenbacks, the latter to be Te eg Cee ie ae 2 i j a phe = etme cee DSA aie Beye arene ee wo pode IO EN: SoA OREM I OT: iGO tp Pie ila ED AGRI Oe Bet fo pes ct < 2 : - < *
Page 10
370 The Nation. [Vol. 65, No. 1689 issued only in exchange for gold. This will be not exactly equivalent for re- demption purposes to $325,000,000 of gold, but it will be an immense gain over the present condition of things. The sum of $325,000,000 gold would ex- ercise a more powerful influence on the imagination of the public than the same sum composed partly of gold and partly of greenbacks, but the withdrawal of $200,000,000 of the latter from the chan- nels of circulation would diminish by so much the demand upon the Treasury for gold, and would have nearly the same effect as though the whole mass were gold. How are these greenbacks to be ob- tained? By refunding the national bonded debt in a new gold bond bearing 2% per cent. interest, and allowing the national banks to deposit greenbacks instead of bonds, to the amount of $200,000,000, in the Treasury to secure their circulation, these green backs to be subsequently con- verted into the new bonds and held for account of the banks. This seems like a roundabout way of selling the new bonds to the banks for greenbacks to the amount named and allowing them to issue circulation against them at par. We think that the simpler way would be preferable, because more easily under- stood, and hence more likely to be ac- ceptable to Congress. The kernel of this refunding plan, however, is the proposal to insert the word gold where we now use the word coin. This change would enable the Government to save about $15,000,000 per annum in the way of in- terest, but it is so opposed to the con- gressional way of looking at things that we doubt if it could be carried into the forms of law. The average Congressman wants to pay $15,000,000 extra to the bondholders in exchange for the privi- lege of saying coin instead of gold, when in practice the two words mean the same thing. Secretary Gage proposes no radical change in the banking system except that he would authorize the national banks which have deposited bonds or Government notes to the amount of 50 per cent. of their capital, to issue notes to that amount and 25 per cent. more, the latter to be issued against their ge- neral assets, the Government to be re- sponsible for the notes and to have a first lien on the assets for its own se- curity. To this he would add a tax of 2 per cent. per annum on the unsecured circulation, to be kept as a safety fund for all of such outstanding unsecured circulation. This has some features in common with the so-called Baltimore plan. It bears a closer resemblance to Secretary Carlisle’s plan, in which de- posited security was required to the amount of $30 instead of $50, against $75 of notes. The Baltimore plan re- quires no deposited security, but a 5 per cent. safety fund. We shall consider this part of Secretary Gage’s plan at greater length hereafter. Meanwhile we express our preference for the more radical measure of taking the Govern- ment out of the currency-issuing busi- ness altogether by the retirement of all cf its legal-tender paper, believing as we do that business can never be on a sound bottom so long as the question of redeeming our paper in gold is essen- tially a political one, depending on the chance of a majority of voters being in favor of such redemption. THE LOST ART OF LETTER. = WRITING. “Nobody writes letters,’ sneered Cecil Rhodes before the parliamentary com- mission. He meant, of course, no public man—especially no Imperial statesman like himself, at one moment dictating the fate of the Matabele to his type- writer, the next orderimg a raid on a friendly state in stock-broker’s cipher. But what he asserted of his ilk, others declare mournfully to be the case with all the world. Even professional writers no longer write letters. An edition of eighteenth-century letter-writers is an- nounced as a reprint in a kind of litera- ture that is now a lost art in English. Even from the land of Madame de Sé- vigné comes the plaint that the epis- tolary style is no more practised. In fact, so universal is the conviction that the art of letter-writing has gone out that no one stops to question the fact; all the dispute is over the explanations of the fact. These are various. Cheap postage has wrought the ruin, say some. When you knew that your correspondent would have to pay a shilling or eighteen pence for your letter, you were in duty bound to give him at least his money’s worth. Now the writer pays the charges him- self, has to expend but two cents, and thinks any curt stupidity will do. This doctrine of the cheap postage making the cheap letter will not, we fear, satisfy the truly ingenuous inquirer. He will point out the fact that if, in the eigh- teenth century, postage was at a high rate, the frank was common, and that some of the most delightful letters in the language were written under frank. Costing nothing did not make them worth nothing. On the other hand, if wits have not cheapened as postage has, why should we not jump at the oppor- tunity to shower lively letters on all our friends when it can be done at so little cost? It really looks as if the trouble were to be located in the skull rather than in the pocket. Well, but there are our demoralizing and dissipating mental habits. We live in such a whirl that we have no time to write. And oh yes, there is the dif- fusion of popular knowledge, the daily and periodical press—really, you know, with so much thought at everybody’s disposal, it would be very like an im- pertinence for a man to sit down to com- pose an instructive or amusing letter. The fact is the telegraph has killed let- ters. “I telegraph, therefore I am,” has, as a witty French writer says, taken the place of the Cartesian “Cogito, ergo sum.” It we have not a telegraph blank or a code handy, we instinctively make our letters as short and cryptographic as possible. But even this explanation does not pierce to the centre. Here are but ways of thought-saving in the busi- ness of life; why should they leave us with less thought to bestow on the &s- thetics of life? Does a copy of a weekly paper, even of our own, so fill the soul’s thirst for literary joys that a witty letter from a brilliant friend would seem a great falling off by comparison? To a candid judgment the common literature of the day leaves plenty of room for the uncommon literature of good letters, in- stead of putting a fatal extinguisher on them. If we perforce telegraph more than our ancestors, it does not follow that we should less enjoy a letter full of wise amenity and flashing insight—if we could only get some one to write it to us. As for the growing tendency of lite- rary men to make their letters mere business scratches or formal notes of thanks, the reason for this is more evi- dent. Literature is now more of a busi- ness, the one thing a man does, if he does it well; and, as Mérimée says, a man must be rather stupid who does only one thing. ‘‘How ,can I write let- ters,” cried Victor Hugo, “when I have proofs to correct, and calls to receive, and big books to write, and business af- fairs to look after?” Then there is a subtler force at work. Why waste on a friend what would easily make salable “copy”? Dr. Holmes jokingly remarked on the improbability of an author’s squandering in conversation or in a let- ter what he could get $50 for from a publisher; anid he himself certainly did little such squandering in his letters. Apart from this, there is a feeling that a writer who has put his best into his books can have little but remnants to offer in private. “A letter!” exclaimed Gautier, when a friend urged him to correspond; ‘would you ask a carpenter to send you some shavings?” A hint here in passing. Literary re- pute may in the long run depend more upon a man’s letters than upon his books. M. René Doumic has lately said that Mérimée’s volumes of letters are really carrying better than his other works. Mrs. Carlyle published nothing, but look at her letters. Edward Fitz- Gerald persisted in the pride of printing no books except privately. but he went on writing letters to all the best of his time, which are among the raciest ever penned. The rule is not invariable: Tennyson appears to have been an in- ferior letter-writer; Matthew Arnold was dull enough in his letters. But it
Page 11
Nov. 11, 1897] The Nation. 871 may well be that many an author filled with longing to join the choir invisible of the immortal dead would be given a much more prominent part in that post- humous chorus if he would suppress his books and wreak himself on letters. Letters lend theniselves so much more easily to preserving—or to burning! All this brings us to what might have been said earlier, that explanations why letter-writing is a lost art are unsatis- factory, because letter-writing is not a lost ait. Some of the names already cited show that it at least did not go out with the eighteenth century—with shilling postage and the monthly News- Letter. Mrs. Browning’s letters, only now published, bring the succession near our own day, and Moftlcy’s, and Lowell’s profuse flinging about cf his inental largess, nearer still. Who can doubt that when Gladstone's biography comes to be published. we shall see a noble series of letters spanning almost the en- tire century? The long and tiresome letter, its back broken with the weight of humdrum it attempts to carry, may have gone, and a good riddance it is. But the letter, as yet the choicest vehi- cle (conversation being impossible) for the conveying of undress thought be- tween equal minds; the letter, as the safe receptacle for the incisive com- ment and the witty fling that cannot be spoken or printed; the letter, in which friend strikes out the spark from friend as iron sharpeneth iron, in which con- fidences are shared, judgments exchang- ed, the form and impress of the age given record—that this is an art no longer cultivated by the discerning, we, for our part, flatly refuse to believe. f / WHO ARE THE PEOPLE OF ASIA MINOR? AMHERST, Mass., October, 1897. However much it may deserve such honor, Asia Minor has not. yet been invaded by the tourist, for, in fact, the country is little known to the world at large. We of the West labor under the belief that Moslem fanaticism makes travel in that country dan- gerous to the life or limb of the venturesome traveller. Ever since the time of the Cru- saders, the impression has been traditional that the Moslem in general and the Turk in particular are professional cutthroats, who ask for no higher enjoyment than the op- portunity to carve up a Christian dog of a giaour every day. The assertion, therefore, that the Turk, and certainly the peasant Turk, is preéminently a man of peace, is not likely to find favor in any quarter just at this juncture, since for some years past the world has been horrified by the accounts of awful deeds of murder and rapine com- mitted by the Turks upon the Arme- nians. Recent events in Thessaly have | not served to efface this impression. And yet, for all that, it is a _ fact that the Turkish peasant is peace-loving and averse to bloodshed. He is merciful to | a fault, and his false mercy makes him in- capable of putting a suffering animal of | nesting on every house in a Turkish village. Even hawks, which in other countries are so careful to avoid contact with man, build their nests under the eaves of Turkish houses. An experience among the Turks that extended over several years has given me no cause for entertaining an unkindly opinion of them. But still every one who has had to deal for any length of time with the people who call themselves Osmanli (for the word Turk is unknown to them except as a term applied to a stupid fool) notices that they betray a twofold character, in which flerceness, cruelty, and official corruptness intermingle strangely with gentleness, kind- ness, and goodness. Few attempt to explain the phenomenon. The inhabitants of Asia Minor do not rep- resent a homogeneous population, nor even an aggregation of peoples of kindred stock. On the contrary, that unfortunate country is peopled by a number of tribes which are without racial, and originally without lin- guistic, affinity. This is a fact that was noted long ago by Strabo, though the Ro- man sway and the spread of Christianity both tended to obliterate those racial dif- ferences which originally prevented inter- course and intermarriage between neighbor- ing village communities. But not oaly was this process of the obliteration of racial dis- tinctions stopped with the advent of the Turks in 1070, but the distinctions were em- phasized, and new tribes have come in to add to the racial chaos. A rapid survey of these new tribes will show that they consist of Turks, Turcomans, Avshars, Yuruks, Circassians, Kurds, not to speak of the old Greeks and Armenians, nor of the Tatars, Noghai, Ansarieh, Ye- zidi, and Jacobites, which, with the excep- tion of the Tatars, are found only along the southeastern fringe of Asia Minor and in Syria and Mesopotamia. The Osmanli Turks themselves exhibit a variety of types, though for our purposes they may be divided into two classes: the dwellers in cities and the dwellers in villages, the former class representing the official and governing class. The Turcomans are of kindred stock with the Ottoman Turks, but differ from them in this that they are still wholly nomadic; the Osmanli have long since become residents in fixed abodes, but for all that even the urban populations have not wholly aban- doned nomadic habits. The spirit of the thing still lives, for not only do the vil- lagers abandon their villages for the Yaila during the heated season, but even the great officials of Stambul are in a mild way true to the nomadic instincts of the conquering shepherds. During the summer the traveller will see the harems of the wealthy city gen- tlemen encamped in tents along the entire line of the railway from Constantinople to Nicomedia. The Turcomans also fall into two classes: the orthodox and the hetero- dox Turecomans. The latter, called Ki- zil-Bash (Red Heads), are heartily detested by the Ottoman Turks. Like most nomads, the Turcomans are very hospitable, and rarely accept money for their rude but kind- ly hospitality. The Avshars came originally from Persia; they, too, are nomadic, though they are beginning to adopt the settled habit. They are found chiefly in the moun- tainous regions of the Antitaurus, where I came into constant contact with them. They | are sturdy, courageous, and hospitable. The j any kind out of its misery. Storks cannot | abide the Greeks, but they are found quietly | as Mongolians, while others think them a Yuruks, also nomads, dwell chiefly in moun- tainous regions, and by some are regarded race akin to the Gypsies. They are said to have no religion whatever, and to practise incestuous marriage; but I am not compe- tent to speak either of their religion or of their racial affinities. They are inoffensive, but are universally despised. The Circassians are Moslem refugees from Russia; they are now found all over the peninsula, and even in Syria and Mesopota- mia. They are feared and detested by all alike as thieves and cutthroats. I came into frequent and intimate contact with them, even in the wildest districts of the Antitav- rus, but I was everywhere received with welcome and a lavish hospitality. My Asi- atic friends told me that my immunity was due to the fact that my chief servant was a Circassian, flerce-looking enough, but in re- ality the mildest of men. But however that may be, and as an offset to the universal hatred felt for the Circassians, I have no evil to speak of -them; certainly it was re- freshing to accept the royal hospitality of a Circassian village, with its cleanliness, thrift, and providence, after the filth, lice, and other vermin of the Turkish villages. Like the Circassians, the Kunis are our own brothers, racially speaking; their lan- guage is a dialect of the Persian. Outside of Kurdistan and Armenia they are nomada, and are found in numbers in Catalonia northern Cappadocia, and Galatia. They are a murderous set of filthy villains, who, with the exception of the nomads (in whose tents I have been entertained handsomely), have not even the primitive virtue of hospitality. History has nothing good to relate of them from the time when the Ten Thousand forced a passage through their country, down to the time when they became the butchers of the Armenians. The only time in all my travels in Asia when for a half-hour I thought that Atropos was about to use her shears, was in a Kurdish village in Cata- lonia, not far from the Euphrates. These, then, are the new elements brought in by the Turkish conquest to complicate the racial problem. None of them practise intercourse or intermarriage, and ail of them except the Cirtassians are nomadic. For years the central government has been trying to abolish nomadic life in Asia Mi- nor, and from time to time an order is sent out to the provisional governors to confiscate the costly and serviceable black hair tents of the nomads. But little is accomplished thereby except untold misery among the poor nomads, who, in spite of the loss of their tents, simply will not settle down into fixed villages, but live beneath wretched bowers of brush and leaves until with time their women have woven new tents. Recent events have made it unnecessary to speak of the Greeks and Armenians in Asia Minor. I may say, though, that Greek and Armenian merchants, especially men of the latter na- tionality, are found throughout the penin- sula, while in Cappadocia and Pontus Greek- speaking communities are common. The inhabitants of Asia Minor have never at any period been a homogeneous popula- tion; they have never been an independent, sovereign people. From the dawn of his- tory they have been subject to foreign rule, if we may except such kingdoms as those of Midas, Gordius, Croesus, etc., foreign dy- nasties which themselves soon succumbed to more forceful foreign dynasties. At the open- ing of history the Asiatics were a wealthy people; in fact, commerce was invented by them, and to a late date the “Lydian mar- Sr ie nee ee : 4; i baronree maser , Pe See eng RC NER BIG) Gs NE! he NOB SY WSO ad Laden tieteane onal 7
Page 12
372 kets’’ were well known. Indeed, it may not be controverted that, although the people of Asia Minor were never independent, and, therefore, presumably, never capable of self- government, yet they were ever prosperous and rich whenever they were living under a strong, paternal government that, even in a half-hearted way, secured the individ- ual in the peaceful enjoyment of his earn- ings. Even in Roman times their wealth was proverbial, and a Roman proconsul or proprator wished for no greater stroke of luck than to be appointed to a post in Asia Minor for a season. The pickings were fine, and the post was as good as the own- ership of a mint. But under the ignorant and rapacious government of the conquering shepherds, who were quick enough to seize the pickings, but incapable of improving or exploiting their conquered property, the peo- ple of Asia Minor have become familiar with a depth of poverty unknown before in the history of that still fertile land. And herein lies the kernel of my con- tention, which is that the Moslem peasantry in the villages of Asia Minor are not Turks at all, but simply the lineal descendants of the old aboriginal inhabitants, with their traditional exclusiveness, that was originally based on racial differences; with their tra- ditional and inherited inability to assert their independence and govern themselves, being driven, now as ever, by interloping taskmasters. Throughout all history their very long-suffering gentleness, stolidity, and honesty have made them a peculiarly facile prey to robber officials, and this character they maintain to the present day. There Is no more fruitful field for the ethnologist than Asia Minor, and ethnology has much to tell us about the problems which that curious complex of nationalities propounds to us; but still there is much evidence to prove that, as the years have rolled on, the aboriginal people of Asia Minor have re- peatedly changed their language and their religion. Whatever may have been their primitive worship, they certainly accepted from the Hittites the worship of the Chal- dean Istar, and we may infer from the analo- gy of their subsequent history that they also adopted the Hittite language, at least in central Asia Minor. At the bidding of the Phrygians, the successors of the Hittites, a large portion of them changed their lan- guage again. But if it be said that this is partly conjectural, it is at all events cer- tain that they readily exchanged their lan- guage and their worship of the great Asia- tic goddess of fecundity for the Greek lan- guage and the galaxy of Olympian deities, to whom they transferred many of the cha- racteristic features of their old religion. In its turn this religion was readily supplanted by the state religion of Rome, that univer- sal, all-embracing cult known as the wor- ship of the Roman emperors. They accepted Christianity just as readily, and though they clung to it for a thousand years, yet the Turks, by opening to them all the privileges and honcrs that were the right of the con- quering race, found little difficulty in induc- ing the rural population to embrace Islam and adopt the language of their shepherd conquerors. At first all these various changes were slow of progress, and in the change to the Greek language, for instance, we have many traces of a struggle long kept up. In the case of the last change thé process had been going on for several centuries before the The Nation. fall of Constantinople, at which time {ft had been virtually completed. As might be ex- pected of densely ignorant people, they have utterly forgotten this change of language and religion, and they would be swift to re- sent the imputation that they are not Os- manli Turks, but simply the same patient, good-hearted, and stolid people whose fore- fathers dwelt in the land thousands of years before ever the Turks were heard of. It was in this way that the whole Christian popu- lation of Asia Minor became Moslems, with the exception of comparatively few districts and villages. So true is this that scholars have even claimed that it is still possible to differentiate the nationalities that occupy different localities in Asia Minor, and here- in is a great field for the ethnologist. Who ever heard of 4 blonde and blue-eyed Turk? And yet there are such men in Galatia to- day, men who stoutly claim that they are Ottoman Turks, whereas in point of fact they are almost certainly the lineal de- scendants of the old Gauls, or Galatians, as the Greeks called them. They might even be called French Turks. This peasartry, which has accepted Islam and the Turkish language—and, when the tide turns that way, will quite as readily re- accept Christianity—is still in the main an Aryan race, now ruled by a handful of offi- cials, the hybrid remnant of the shepherd horde that conquered the peninsula. If this be true, we begin to understand the reasors for that two-fold character of the Turk which bas Leen commented upon so fre- quently. Mongrels have ever had a bad name. The peasant is not a mongrel; he is, therefore, honest, sturdy, peace-loving, long- suffering, and slow to anger, whereas the official or ruling Turk, who is at all events the traditional representative of the blue- blood of the conquerors, is exactly the op- posite. Indeed, the Turkish peasant is op- pressed and plundered by the official Turk quite as unmercifully as is the Christian subject; the only difference, so far as I could discover, being that the Christian has to pay a war capitation tax in lieu of service in the field, and in so far he is better off than the Moslem, his turn-coat brother. This ruling class is itself not of pure Turkish ori- gin, for intermarriage with women of every conceivable stock, from Ethiopia to Circas- sia, and from 1070 a. D. down to the pre- sent day, has brought about the virtual ex- tinction of Turkish blood. The Padishah himself cau make no claim to purity of blood; he is more Circassian, more Greek even, than Turk. The purest Turkish blood is found only in the tents of the Turcomans and in Turkistan. If the ruling class are not Turks any long- er, no more are the peasants, for they. never were Turks. While the conquerors might, and always did, take wives from the con- quered natives, the principle did not work both ways. But it may be claimed that, af- ter the original status of the peasantry had been forgotten by master and subject alike, then the aboriginal inhabitants, now turned Moslem, might marry Turkish women. True, they might; but if there is one social feature that forces itself upon the attention of the traveller more than another, it is the as- tonishing exclusiveness prevalent in Turk- ish communities as regards neighboring communities. The peasants live and die within the territory of their own villages, having neither intercourse nor intermar- riage with neighboring villages. They get [Vol. 65, No. 1689 their sole glimpse of the world when they go off to the army. Indeed, the traveller who seeks for topographical information is often exasperated to find in village A a total ignorance prevailing in regard to village B, only ten miles distant. This exclusiveness is as old as Strabo certainly, and it goes to prove that recial differences, though long since forgotten, are traditicnally still ex- istent, and prevent intermarriage between villages. All of which argues strongly for the theory that the peasants are not a homo- geneous race—that is, are not Turks. In- breeding prevails, and intermarriage be- tween the ruling class and the ruled was limited to the period before the final adjust- ment of interests and the definite settlement of the ruling class in fixed abodes. It is still true that the harems of the wealthy class of officials and the gentry are stocked with beauties of any and every extraction. But there is a sorrowful absence of beautiful or even handsome women in the homes of the villagers. Amongst the nomads one often sees women who are splendid animals, splen- did breeders, who might readily find hous- ing in the harems of the great, but cen- turies of grinding drudgery have driven comeliness from the face and the person of the peasant woman, who is, therefore, rare- ly a candidate for harem honors. So that if an intermingling of blood still goes on, it is wholly one-sided. Intermarriage may take women from the village to be wives or con- cubines to the wealthy in the cities, but it brings po women to the village to break the traditional exclusiveness of the non-Turkish villagers. The Turkish peasant, while a faithful Mos- lem, is no fanatic, under ordinary circum- stances at least. In fact, according to his poor lights, he is very liberal-minded. On a hot summer’s day without any hesitation he will quarter a foreign giaour in the mosque, because that is the coolest place in the vil- lage. This liberal-mindedness is very pro- nounced in comparison with the fanaticism say of the Persians, who account a mosque defiled if entered by a Christian or a pig. However, the non-Turkish peasant can be a fighter, and-if his religion be insulted or he be prodded on to fanaticism by the superior or ruling class, he will defend himself until he is cut to pieces. His stolidity and his religion make him an excellent soldier, but, until further light be given me, 1 shall con- tinue to believe that the non-Turkish pca- sant had no share in the Armeniun mas- sacres. J. R. S. STERRETT. THE RAWLINSON MSS. IN THE BOD- LEIAN LIBRARY.—I. LONDON, October, 1897. Once upon a time a party of Americans who were on a visit to Oxford were being shown over one of the beautiful colleges for which that ancient city is famous. As the visitors were walking on one side of the quadrangle, a window was suddenly thrown up on the opposite side. ‘‘Oh, my! are these ruins inhabited?’ exclaimed an American belle who was one of the party. In much the same way would American students be surprised if they knew what vast numbers of unpublished documents that tell of per- sons and things American during the colo- nial period are preserved in the various college libraries of the University, and, above all, in the Bodleian. As regards the contents of Sir Thomas Bodley’s fane of ‘ Bd 4 i 2 : 3 « Ee a Ne seer eae
Page 13
srameesion oon ser epeeerer ene eR serene rerreneresertee et Nov. 11, 1897] Nation. The 8373 learning, the authorities of the Library and the Syndics of the Clarendon Press have, by the printing of admirably prepared cata- logues, done their best to bring their hoard of manuscript treasures within the ken of historical students. But, whether it is that the prices at which the catalogues are published are not ‘‘popular,’’ or that re- viewers do not find catalogues a sufficiently tempting subject for review, it is a fact that the treasures of the Bodleian are not known far and wide as they ought to be. In manu- scripts the Bodleian ranks as a very good second to the British Museum in numbers; and in the rarity of some classes of docu- ments, such as Oriental MSS., the Bodleian surpasses the great National Library of the United Kingdom. It is practicable, at present, to deal with but a single class of MSS. in Oxford’s prin- cipal library, and with an individual col- lection of that one class. With the help of the catalogue published by the Clarendon Press, and its admirable index, it is easy to bring before the eyes of readers of the Na- tion the contents of the manuscripts in the Rawlinson Collection. Subjoined will be found a list which, while it does not pre- tend to include every document, supplies particulars of most of those that relate to the colonial period of American history. Some talk of individuals—of simple colon- ists, or of clergymen, or of Governors or other officials. Others tell of towns, or dis- tricts, or of whole colonies. Administra- tion, civil, military, or ecclesiastical, is de- scribed. In fact, the documents noted sup- ply materials that cannot but throw fresh light on the personal and public transactions of the colonial period. Many, relating to the West Indies, have not been noted in the list subjoined. The Rawlinson Collection includes a vast number of manuscripts besides those relat- ing to America. It was bequeathed to the Bodleian Library by Richard Rawlinson, who died in 1755. The son of a wealthy Lord Mayor of London, Rawlinson was himself a non-juring bishop. His life was mainly de- voted to the collecting of books, manu- scripts, seals, and curiosities. Some of his books, and most of his manuscripts and other collections, were, by his will, left to the Bodleian. The estimable collector was a bit of a crank, as is shown by certain re- strictions he imposed upon some of his en- dowments. By his will, natives of Scotland, of Ireland, or of the Plantations could not fill particular offices endowed by him. Le- gislation, however, has annulled those re- strictions. All libraries of repute should possess the admirable catalogues issued by the Claren- don Press, and especially that of the Raw- linson Collection of MSS., which is sold at the price of ten dollars, but, to students, is worth its weight in gold. Inquirers living in the United States can there learn of the materials for history awaiting employment. It is not necessary to cross the Atlantic to get copies of the documents, for there are persons in Oxford who, for a modest charge, will make all transcriptions required. ‘ ‘ D. D. ALLEN, Samuel, proprietor of the colony of New Hampshire: v. Vaughan, Major Will Orders of Privy Council, etc., on an appeal in Allen v. Waldron, 1701-8 (¢ pi-s), C. 379, &—12 List of papers rela'ing to his pretended title to | New Hampshire, C. 128. 6. ALLETT, Rev. Thomas’ Bond to go as chaplain to Virginia; 2 Apr. 1718, B. 376. 141 AMERICA Notes of grants to planters in Virginia, New- foundland, ete.; t-mo Jac 1. B. 309. 169%. Ecclesiastical papers, C. 933; Papers of Corpor for prop. of Gosp. in N. Ragland; 1649 56, C. 934. Act for promoting the Gosp. inN Engl. 1649 (printed), +b. 1. Letter from the Commrs. of the Colonies to the Corp. for prop of Gosp , ib 40. Account of goods supplied to the Commrs. by the Corp.: 1651-2, 16. 44, 48, 50. Adventures of a Frenchman amongst the In- dians, especially the Iroquois; 1652-1665, A. 329. Instructions for the commander of an expedition against the Dutch settlements in the Manhat- toes: 165-. A 36. 109. * A orief narration of the English mghts to the borthero parts of America"; 1656, A. 38. 707. The market prices of provisions in Old and New England compared, A. 185. 263. Commission of Ch. IL. appointing a Council for the American Plantations; 30 July, 1670, A. 25. 140. Instructio s for the Council, *> 145, 150. Accounts of conferences between Indian Sachems from Canada und the Commissioners for In dian affairs at Albany; June and July, 1700, A. 272. 98, 100. Draft of a clause in an Act for preserving the pine forests, C. 983. 159°. A Bishop desired; 1720. C. 933. 135. Petition from a Bishop of London to the Crown respecting the powers of bis c mmissaries and the mainte- naoce of ministers, C. 933. 163. Notice of a let- ter from the Bp of London to the clergy of New England; 1724. C. 151. 170. Engraved map of part of N. America, C. 281. (end). Clergy in America; see the miscellaneous papers of op John Robinson, passim. ANNE (Queen) Allowances to Colonial Clergy. Forrign Chaplains, &c.. C 933 164. ARCHDALE, Jonv, Governor of Carolina Questions respectiog Carolina addressed to him, B. 243. 12 Army. Reasons why clothing for the soldiers at New York should be made up in England, A. 238. 110. Warrants for Payment for the company serving at Newfoundland; 16 June. 1705, A. 238, 180. ARNOLD, Sion, a pirate. Copy of a pass granted to him by the governor of New Jersey; 12 Aug. 1699, A 272. 56 (see 75). AsuBy, John, Capt. of H.M.S. the Rose. Instruc tions for bim on being sent with land forces to Virginia; 20 Nov. 1676 (c pe), A. 214. 108. Abstract of bis journal ia the Rose, A 185, 299 ASPINWALL. William. Boston. New England. Spe culum chronologicum; a chronology of the Scrip- tures; 1652. B. 156. Astwoop, Juhn, New Engiand. Signature; 1652, C 934. 41. 45. Atwoop, W.. Chief Justice of New York. Letters to J Champante; 172-9. A. 272. 161, 243. BALLANTINE, John. Certificate that he is Clerk of the Peace, co. Suffolk, prov. Massachusetts; 1720, C. 128. 23. Baron, Rev. Robert. Bond that he will goas chap lain to Maryland; %3 June, 1714. B. 376. 8 Bassk, col Jeremiah. guvernor of New Jersey: v Coote Rich , E. of Bellamont. Letter to E. of Bellamont, gov. of New York; 17 June, 1698 (c py), A. W 7. to Capt. Naofan, lieut. gov. of New York; 30 May, 1699 (copy), 10. 35. Pass granted toa pirate (cows). ib. 56 (vee 75). Appointmeot of a committee of the H. of Representatives of N. York to con- sider a petition from him; 12 Feb. 16998, +d S80. Basss or Bass, Jeremiah, Secr. of Prov. of New Jersey. Signature; 1713, C. &33. 91. Bayarb, or Byard, colonel Nicholas: v. New York Creates disturbances at Now York; 172, A. 272 142. 151 His case to be heard before the Queen in Coun- cil; Sv Apr. 17u2, ab. 157 Bett, T. Journal of the work of fortifying St. John’s, Newfouodiand; 1697, C. 873 Rex sett. Richard, Governor of Virginia. Letter from R Bennettaud S Math to Thurloe, respect ing Maryland: 10 Oct. 1656. A. 43. 87. Objections against Lord Baltimore's pategt for Maryland, ecc., 4. 93. 97. Order to bim from Cromweil to forbear disturbing Lord Baltimure’s colony in Maryland; 12 Jan. 164; with a further letter thereupon (copies), 1. 101,108. Resolution of the Council of Virginia upon the foregoing orter; 38 Juna, 1655, 1) 105. Breviat of the proceedings of Lord Baltimore, 1d. 107. Bostos. New England. Order of the Council allow ing Capt. Gookin to publish to the people pro- posals for transplantation to Jamaica; 7 Mar 1655 6, A. 38. 267. —s-_ Letter from the Govervor, ete.. of N E to Cromweil. on the foregoing pro- posal; 23 Oct. 1656, A 43. 135 Brasast, Henr . Comptroller of the customs of North Carolina. Letter to Rod. Mackenzie; 3 Aug, 1699. A. 312. 2, Brapstrert, Simon, New England. Signature 1652. C O34. 41. 45. Burise. Peter. Boston. New England. Representa tion from the Council of State to the Spanish amb in bis behalf; 19 Sept. 1653 Let, and transl., A. 6. 323, 322 [v. aud nomine in lad, supra). Burrs, Laurenc’ de. Bond that he will go to Vir gina as chaplain; 2 June, 172), B IT6 WS Carve rt, Family of. Notice of pedigree and arms; 1679, B. 74. 3° Camppact. Duncan, New York. Bill of exchange payable to him, drawn by the gov. of N. York; 1700, A. 272 109. Letter to J. Champante; § Dec 1701, #, 134. CAROLINA. Draught of the forts, B. M3 15. An act for the better ordering of slaves; 1701, C 155. 273. An act fcr enlisting trusty slaves 170K, 9d, B79 Questions relative to emigration there, by Freach refugees. C. 984 217. BS q estions respecting the province. on behalf of an intending body of Lutberan settlers: 176. B. 43 12 Represen'ation of eccles. affairs in South Caro lina; 1713, C. 48 Admiralty proceedings in South Carolina about the ship © Ludlow; 1717, C. && Testimonial from 8 members of the French chureh at Charlestown to their minister P L' Escot, on bis leaving them; 14 March, ITIS-9, B. 376. 1M. Cuampanre. John. junior, Agent for the Province of New York. Papers c Hlected bv bim relating tothe province of New York; 187.1715, A wy Appointed agent for the province; 108, i>. 6 Re appointed agent; ITIA. +b. 273. Persons recom mended by him for the Council of New York id. 2. Petition to Will LLL. for nay ment of the Earl of Bellamont's salary, o> 288, 3R Petition to Q. Anne in behalf of Capt. Nanfan. 15 300, Appointment as receiver of the Earl of Port- land's rents; 1714, A. Be). 79 Letter to Capt. Nanfan; 10 Apr. 170%, A. 272. 201 Letters to Col. A. de Peyster; 1707.10, #b. 237, MS, WT. ——— to Roger Mompesson; 1707 10, tb. 239, 240, 245, Bs? —— to Adolphus Phi- lips, 1707 10, #b. 245°, BWV. ——— to his sister Kate: & Dec, 1708. A. 238. 117 — to Messrs Staats and Governeur; Nov. 1700—Nov. 1710. A 22. VS? NT, Woe, Wo. —— to John Collins, 1b. 246, 260 —— to Col. R. Hunter; 25 Feb.- Nov. 1710, ib. 20. Wil - to Rob. Wallers: 8 Now. 1710, #). 256°. ——— to Franc. Harrison; 9 Nov. 1710, 2b. 257%. ——~— to Jac. Regd®r; 1710-11, dd, 248", 256, 22. ——— unaddressed; 5 July, 1711, ib. 24. ——— to Capt. Lawson; 8 May, 1715, A. 238. 131. Comptor. Henry (Bishop of London). Draught of Commission to a Commissary in America; 1697 C. 933. 7 Contry, Peregrine, rector of Middle Neck, Maryland App ioted commissary of the Bp. of London; 1697, C. 933. 7. Cornecticvr. Petition to Charles Il for a renewal of the parent of the colony, A. 175. 109. 176. 113. Coote. Kicbard, Lord Coloony, first Earl of Bella- mont. Grant to him and others of al! captures of pirate vessels, etc.. made by capt. W. Kidd in America; 27 May 1697, A. 241 251 Conferences with sume Mohawk Indians respect ing land in New York; 1698, A. 272. 16, 18 Order thereupon. ib. 28. Extract from a letter from him to the Commissioners for Trade re- specting Col. Basse’s proceedings in New Jer- sey. and Every the pirate: 1 July 1608, ib, 22. Instructions 10 Thos. “ eaver appointed agent in England for New York and for the earl's private affairs. 7b. 26. Instructions for Capt. Nanfan as lieut. gov. of New York; 2 May, ENTER Es ARM TS Ce me SPO cy wate st com PRES aren ee cee nt tee Lena | e en
Page 14
The Nation. [Vol. 65, No. 1689 B74 1699, ib, 32. Letter to John Champante; 6 Sept. 1699, ib. 60. Letters to the Commissioners of Trade on the affairs of New York; 1699 1700 (cc pies), ib. 62, 69, 75, 76, 102. Billsof exchange drawn by him on Sir John Stanley; Nov. 1700, ib. 108, 9. Reasons for suspending col. Thos. Willet from the Council, ib. 288. Petition (by his agent J. Champante) to Will. III for arrears of his salary, 1b. 298, 302. Notes of points urged by his counsel in justification of his claim of jurisdiction over East New Jersey, ib. 298. Complaints by Lord Cornbury of his mal-ad- ministration at N. York, C. 984. 133°, et seqq. Coxe, Dr. Daniel. Conveyance of land in Carolina or Florida from him to French Protestant re- fugees ; 1698 (copy), A. 271. 26. Grant to lord Maltravers, on which Coxe claimed in Norfolk co., Virginia ; (copy), ib. 30. ‘ Description of the province of New Jersey ; with proposals for the sale of his lands and rights therein, ete., C. 128. 39-47, Sketch for the government of a colony first called the New Empire, drawn up for him, A. 305. 2. Lived in Charles Square, Hoxton, C. 441. 42. CRANFIELD, Edward. Commission from Chas. II. to be governor of New-Hampshire (copy, unfinished), C, 379. 14. Devaware, North America. Memorial from the people of Sussex county to the Bp. of London for a minister, C. 933. 169. Dieces, Edward, governor of Virginia. Letter to Cromwell ; 29 June, 1655, A. 27. 783 (see 43. 105). Letter to him from Cromwell ; 8 Oct., 1655 (copy), A. 261. 55°, Dubey, Colonel, Gov. of New Hampshire. Letter to the Council of Trade; 23 July, 1702 (copy), C. 128 14, 16. Eager, Thomas. Bond that he will go as chaplain to New England ; 23 Apr., 1712, B. 376. 15. SNDECOTT, Thomas, governor of New England. Sig- nature ; 1656, A. 43. 125. Fountalne, Peter, B.A., Dublin, son of Rev. James Fountaine. Certificate of his birth and baptism in 1691, B. 376. 86. Testimonial for orders from the archbishop of Dublin ; 1715, 7b. 88, 89. Note of his ordination in 1718 as chaplain for Virginia, B. 376. 104. Fox, Francis. Examination concerning a plot against the Protector; June, 1654, A. 15. 624. Order for his transportation to Barbadoes; 18 May, 1655, A. 26.206. Embarked 31 May, 1655, A. 67. 275. Frenca Protestants. Account of relief afforded in England to refugees, in 1700-'01, and of their settlement in Virginia, A. 271. 7-38. FRANKLIN, William, Boston, New England. Order from Cromwell to the Commissioners of Customs in his favour; 6 July, 1655 (copy), A. 261. 50. Goruerson, Major Daniel. Letter to Matthew Prior; 15 Sept. 1663, A. 175. 114. Covenant with Col. J. Scott for the quiet posses sion of land in Long Island; 11 July, 1662 (copy), A. 175, 128. Other instruments between Gother- son and Scott respecting the same estate; 1662-3, ib. 131 7. GoTHERSON, Dorothea Scott, widow of Daniel. Peti- tion to the King respecting some dealings with col. J. Scott for land in Long Island, A. 175. 112, Informations respecting her case, (6. 119, 126. Indenture with col. F. Lovelace constituting him her attorney for the management of her Long Island estate; 2 Nov. 1667, 1b. 139. Letter to Tho- mas Lovelace, ib. 140. —— to Francis Lovelace; 15 June, 1669, 7b. 144. Answers to 13 questions from Pepys concerning Scott and her dealings with him, ib, 147. Copy of the questions, A. 194. 125°. Gray, Samuel. Receipt for 201. granted on his go ing as chaplain to Virginia; 3 Dec. 1689, A. 306. 73 Harison, Francis, New York; v. Champante, John, jun. Letter to J. Champante; 5 Oct. 1710, A. 272. 255. Hooper, John, clerk to the Corp. for Prop. of Gosp. in N. England; ». Cludd, Edward. Letter: 1652 (copy), C. 984. 16. Howarp, Henry Frederick, lord Maltravers, after- wards Earl of Arundel. Copy of a grant to him of the co. of Norfolk in Virginia; 22 Jan, 1637, A. 271. 30. Hupson’s Bay. Observations on the effects of cold at Hudson's Bay in 1741, 2, A. 344. Hudson's Bay Company Charter of incorporation; 2 May, 1670, A. 295, 26. Copies of seven statements and replies on the part of the English Company and the French Com- pany of Canada,with reference to their conflict- ing claims ; c. 1687, F'r., B. 250. 33° 53>, Hunter, Colonel Robert. Appointed Governor of New York; 1709, A. 272. 245, 6. Described in the Tatler, no. 69, under the name of Eboracensis, ib. 245°. Letter to J. Champante ; 23 July, 1715, ib. 275. Hype, Edward, lord Corubury, afierw. third E. of Clarendon; gov. of New York. Proceedings against Capt. J. Nanfan of N. York ; 1702-5, A. 272. 83. Complaints against his government, ib. 159, 161. Suspends three members of Coun- cil; 9 June, 1702, ib. 163. Order prohibiting the departure of the Countess of Bellamont and Capt. John Nanfan; 5 Oct. 1702 (copy), ib. 171. Extract from a letter from him to the Com- missioners of Trade; 12 Dec. 1702, ib 174. Let- ter to the same, on Lady Bellamont’s accounts; 7 Oct. 1703 scopy), ib. 194. Warrant for arrest of Capt. Nanfan; 19 May, 1703 (copy), ib. 204. No- tice of an official report on his letters touching the accounts of the Earl of Bellamont and Capt. Nanfan; 1706, A. 289. 188. Letter to Bp. Compton respecting affairs at New York; 1702 (imperf.), C. 984. 183. Letters to Bp. Robinson ; 1712-1719, A. 286. 177. B. 376. 169. Jounson, Zachary, i. e. H. Manning, q. v. JoHNSTON, ——, Commissary of Bp. of London in S. Carolina. Representation of eccles. affairs in S Carolina; 1713, C. 943. Jounstoy, Gideon Bond to go as Chaplain to S. Carolina ; 1714, C. 393. 67. Kipp, Capt. William, a pirate; v. Coote, Rich E., of Bellamont. Runs away with a French ship in 1689, from St. Christopher's, A. 270. 1. Depositions at New York respecting him; 1699, A. 272, 47. 48, 52. Orders of the Council of New York with refer- ence to him; Aug. 1699, 7b. 58,59. Claim in the Court of Admiralty on the part of some Persian merchants to goods seized from Kidd and con- demned as pirates’ goods, B. 383. 548-545. Lawson, Deodat, minister at Boston, New England. Diatribe de sessione Christi ad dextram Dei, C. 879. Letter to Jer. Dummer and Henry Newman ; Lond., 24 Dec. 1714, C. 128. 12. L'Escor, Paul, French minister at Charlestown: v. Carolina. Recommended for ordination for the French church at Dover; 1719, B. 376, 171.. Certificate of examination, ib. 172”. Leverett, Capt. John, Governor of Massachusetts. Letters to Cromwell; 1654, A. 16. 52. 18.58. Let- ters to Capt. John Scott ; 1663, A. 175. 110, 113. Loa-BooKS AND JOURNALS OF VOYAGES. The Leavett to Virginia ; 1698-9, C. 872. 1. Two voyages in the Bristow to Virginia ; 1699-1701, C. 872. 42, 76. The John to Virginia, etc. ; 1700-1, C. 965. 21. The Harrison to Virginia ; 1701-2, C. 967, 45. Lovevacg, Col. Francis, Governor of New York: v. Gotherson, D. Prior,M. Wren, M. Indenture, constituting him attorney for the ma nagementof Mis. D. Gotherson’s estate in Long Island; 2 Nov. 1667, A. 175. 139. Lovevace, Thomas: v. Gotherson, D. Letter to Pepys; 15 July 1680, A. 173.184. Petition to the duke of York, ib. 185. Account of his losses in the colony of New York, ib. 186. Let- ters of recommendation from Pepys on his tehalf; 1680, A. 194, 185°-187°, Information re- specting Mrs. Gotherson’s case; 12 July, 1680. A. 175. 119. LupLow, Robert, New England. C, 934. 41, 45. Signature ; 1652, Correspondence. AGRICULTURAL DEMAND FOR MORE MONEY. THE To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Srr: I have been a subscriber to the Nation so long—more than fifteen years, I think—and a constant reader more than | Tate is about 1 per cent. a month. twenty-five years, ever since I was a school- boy, that, for many reasons, though I have not the honor of your personal acquaint- ance, I regard you as my stanch friend. More particularly is this true, as I have all these years considered the Nation as the best of American journals, and when in doubt, or when difficult political, financial, or other questions were before the minds of the people, have always deferred to it, and invariably found it correct, and unquestion- ed by fair minds in its positions. In the last Presidential canvass it was masterful. If I am not right politically, financially, and in other ways, you are most to blame for it, as you have, through the columns of the Nation, been my teacher. Now can I interest you somewhat, through me, in my immediate section of the country in a financial way? We are needing money to do business. Many farmers have money locked up in the bank-vaults; they really do not know what to do with it; but there is not, by any means, enough of that, even if they knew how to lend it, to supply the needs of the community, which is a com- paratively new one, and as a farming sec- tion is very fertile, and is destined to be, in the near future, one of the foremost agri- cultural regions in the country. It now yields per acre, in its yet primitive de- velopment and crude culture, from twenty to forty-five bushels of wheat and from fifty to seventy-five bushels of corn, and other cereals and crops of the middle tempe- rate zone in the same high proportion. Fruits, berries of all kinds as fine as any- where, all kinds of stock, can be raised and fattened here as profitably as anywhere. We have land that will grow grapes as fine as any in Steuben County, New York, or any- where in the grape region. No stones, or gravel, or sand to contend with. The soil on the undulating surfaces is a rich dark loam, and underlying it a firm yellow clay that holds the fertilizers and prevents their waste. The level or “bottom’’ lands are a deep alluvial deposit, inexhaustible and easily drained. We are sixteen to twenty miles from the Mississippi River, whose waters can at no time come any nearer, be- cause of the bluffs and hills between us and the river near its bank. Even the crops raised to fertilize the soil, peas and red clover, pay as well when har- vested in their use and sale as the other crops. So there is always a profitable in- ducement to keep the soil in good tilth. This section is getting better every year; no such thing now as failure in crops; in- variably plenty to spare to pay any debts contracted, over and above the needs of the community. Can you put me in communication with parties who would lend money in this sec- tion? I can easily show any one there is absolute safety; no community could be bet- ter in paying debts. Money lends here at 8 and 10 per cent. per annum, and the bank The legal rate is 6 per cent. No question about the land titles. The people are as frugal, industrious, and law-abiding as anywhere in the Union. I never knew any trouble about enforcing a mortgage debt. I cannot call to mind any foreclosure on land if the party kept his health; and there is no healthier section anywhere. I have seen this country from Minnesota to Mississippi and Missouri to Massachu- setts, and no section I have seen can surpass
Page 15
Nov. 11, 1897] The Nation. 875 this in the ease and certainty of acquiring a competency. So there can be no doubt about meeting, with regularity, any mort- gage debt or interest. This, like all new countries, with great agricultural advan- tages, needs capital to develop it rapidly. The silver craze is subsiding, never to trou- ble us again in our day, and the people in these parts are now ready to go to business, thanks to the thorough campaign of educa- tion. The editor of a periodical such as the Nation is, can have a great influence wher- ever he may choose to exercise it. I should be highly gratified if you could be interest- ed in our section. Lend your influence in binding us by financial links to the great city; it has a plethora of capital; we need some of it. A. M. Hancock, Attorney. UNION CiTy, TENN., November 4, 189%. [All that Mr. Hancock says about the condition of his part of the country is undoubtedly true. But his ideas about banks and their functions seem to in- dicate that he has not, in common with a large number of others even here, sufficiently considered the subject. Banks are enterprises started everywhere all over the world, since the close of the Middle Ages, for the purpose of making money, just like opening a dry-goods store or a restaurant. They make this money by using the money of depositors, in conjunction with their own, for the purpose of discounting bills, and buying securities for the purpose of selling them again at a profit. But it has been found by long experience that they can- not safely lend money without security, and that the security they lend on must be realizable immediately,in case the loan is not paid at maturity. Consequently banks of discount do not lend money on land, because the security is not realiz- able at once, and may not be realizable for years. For this reason farmers in all countries have long been clamorous for banks, and have never yet been suc- cessful in getting them, because the only security they can offer is land which cannot be sold, and cattle which may disappear, and crops which may fail. This question has long been known in France, and made a great deal of rumpus under the name of “crédit agri- cole.” Every now and then there is a proposal both there and here, that the Government should be compelled to es- tablish country banks at the public ex- pense, and lend money to all citizens without security. What the farmer needs, even more than money, as a sil- ver statesman remarked some years ago, is “collateral.” Now, business men will establish banks in no place where there is no collateral. In vain you tell them about the prosperity and produc- tiveness of your region. They will cold- ly answer, “Have you plenty of collate- ral? Are there among you plenty of men to borrow, whose credit is such that they will be sure to pay on the | day named, or who can put up securi- ties which we can sell at a moment's | notice?” Mr. Hancock may be assured that if this is true of his region, he will find any number of men to estab- lish a bank. The sole reason why banks do not exist in any locality is that the number of borrowers who have credit and collateral is not large enough to make them pay. Bankers are not phil- anthropists. Show them, not that you would like a bank, but that a bank in your neighborhood can make money by the ordinary banking business, and a bank you will have, without any intro- duction or inquiry from us. An effort, and a very successful one, has been made in Italy, and is being made in Ireland by Mr. Plunkett, the member for South Dublin, to meet this difficulty of ‘“crédit agricole,” or farmers’ banks, by starting codperative banks, which substitute moral for col- lateral security. A certain number of farmers, who “have money locked up in the bank vaults,” form an associa- tion which jointly is probably able to borrow some more capital, as an in- vestment, if they need it. They start a bank and make loans to their neigh- bors, but each borrower's application is considered Ly the whole corporation with reference to what they know of his character. He has to tell what he wants the money for, and it has to be a pro- ductive enterprise, and his business and moral character have to be such as to convince the bank that he will keep his engagements. In this way a farmer of good character who wants money for business purposes, and has shown him- self capable, rarely fails to get it. But it is not a regular banking business, for the bank does not lend to anybody whom it does not know well. We do not see any other way in which farmers’ banks can be established, and we advise our correspondent to write to Mr. Ho- race E. Plunkett, 104a Mount Street, London, for his experience and docu- ments. A good many such banks are working successfully in Ireland.— Ep. NATION. | PENNY WISE, POUND FOOLISH. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: The price cotton is selling for is a great disappointment to the South. It was not anticipated, as consumption and produc- tion were close on each other's heels, and the stock on hand was of extremely meagre proportions. Judged in the light of past experience, it looked as if the crop would bring two cents per pound more than it is now bringing. However, tn the factors that formerly fixed the price of cotton, one ele- ment differs now, and to this difference, in | the estimation of many, is due the low price now ruling. The difference consists in the way the bulk of the cotton crop is now marketed as compared with the method in vogue seven or eight years ago. Formerly the crop was |; marketed through the cotton factor in the ; cities of the South. Now it is done largely | through the local buyer at the “‘cross-roads” depot. The advent of the local buyer was hailed with great rejoicing. The farmer could then sel] direct to the “spinner buyer.” The cotton factor would be eliminated as a useless expense, and the one-half cent per pound cost of marketing saved. In the light of recent events it looks as if the farmer had to a considerable extent accomplished his purpose of saving the two and one-half dollars in commissions and charges, and lost ten dollars per bale in the value of his cotton; a delightful bit of rural financiering. Formerly the crop was concentrated in the large cotton centres with cotton factors. It was in strong and comparatively few hands. The higher the price of cotton, the better it was for both factor and grower. Factors having control of the spot cotton, declines in price could often be successfully resisted and advances in values maintained. How different the conditions now! The cotton Is scattered in the hands of many, many thou- sand cotton-farmers, each marketing his cot- ton alone and without reference to the other; in the hands of parties mainly who are in debt and must sell their cotton to pay the country merchant's store-bill The thousands of little railroad stations each has its little local buyer. Each coun try buyer is a force continually acting to lower the price of cotton. He is either en- deavoring to get the farmer to accept the extremely low bid of the shrewd spinner at a price that will net the buyer twenty-five or fifty cents a bale, or he is flooding the dif- ferent markets with telegraphic offers, wild- ly endeavoring to pluck orders from his al- most innumerable competitors. The number of offers aione causes the amount of cotton offered to be largely magnified. In many in- stances the local buyer is impecunious, and has adopted cotton-buying after having fail- ed in every other line. This has, however, not prevented him this year from selling ahead thousands of bales of spot cotton, which it would be impossible for him to de- liver were the market to advance. He can readily do this, as he has nothing to lose; and if the market goes his way, as it has done, he is so much the gainer. During the present crop the price has been put down notch by notch by the enor- mous offers of spot cotton by these local buyers, in spite of the fact that the size of the crep is purely prospective and the actual movement is smaller than with the crop last year, a crop which, although a large one, lacked three hundred thousand bales of sup- plying consumptive requirements. That cotton should bring the best possi- ble price is a matter of national concern. Many schemes have been proposed for mar- keting the crop, but, on account of the large area of territory involved and the number of parties in interest, nothing feasible has been proposed. Laissez-faire must be trust- ed to bring a solution of the problem. W. COLLIER ESTEs. Mewrnis, TENW., October 26, 1897. THE THORVALDSEN MUSEUM. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: A recent number of the Berlingske Tidende of Copenhagen contains a communi- cation that should be of interest to Ameri- can art lovers and technicians. It is sent out by a committee, of which the architect, F. Meldahl, is the chairman, to which has been intrusted the restoration of the deco- rations on the outer walls of the Thorvald- sen Museum. These pictures were executed : © by ui si i See tata a ee eS ea, ee ees
Page 16
376 The Nation. [Vol. 65 No 1689 at the time the building was erected, a few years after the death of the sculptor, and represent the most important events of his life. For a number of years it has been felt that some steps would have to be taken to prevent the obliteration of the colors, and in order to reach the best results this commit- tee calls upon technical experts throughout the world to offer suggestions. All persons able and willing to assist in this important undertaking are requested to communicate with the committee under the address, “‘The Thorvaldsen Museum, Copenhagen, Den- mark.”’ Prompt attention will be paid to all such communications, and any required in- formation as to the present condition of the decorations and the manner of their original production will be freely given. Yours respectfully, DANIEL KILHAM DODGE. UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS, November 6, 1897. MONS PILATUS. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: In the Nation of November 4, 1897, Mr. Edwin W. Fay, of the Washington and Lee University, gives us an etymology of Mount Pilatus on the Vierwaldstatter See, deriving the name from mons pilleatus. This etymology has long been known to and ac- cepted by scholars: it is to be found in any reliable book on “Deutsche Volksetymolo- gie’’ of recent years. Thus, in Andresen’s ‘Ueber Deutsche Volksetymologie’ (Heil- bronn, a.-N., 1883), p. 27: “Der Berg Pilatus in der Schweiz heisst nicht nach dem be- kannten rémischen Landpfleger, obgleich die Sage sich auf ihn bezieht, sondern ist der Pilvatus (der Behutete).” Early com- mentators derived the word from pila, often used to denote a mountain-pass; scholars are now agreed, however, that it is from pileus, a hat, referring to the mighty cap of clouds which usually covers its bald sum- mit completely. Hence the old French coup- = “Quand Pilate a mis son chapeau, Le temps sera serein et beau.”’ The Germans have another name for this same mountain, namely, ‘‘Frakmont,”’ from mons fractus, indicating its rugged and broken aspect. There is an interesting arti- cle in Bentley's Afiscellany, i., 608, on the above-mentioned mountain. Respectfully, EDWARD MEYER. WESTERN RESERVE UNIVERSITY, CLEVELAND, OHIO, November 6, 2897. Notes. The lectures which Prof. T. K. Cheyne of Oxford is now delivering in this coun- try at various colleges and _ elsewhere, on ‘Religious Life and Thought among the Ancient Hebrews in Post-Exilic Days,’ will form the third volume in the series already begun with Prof. Rhys-Davids’s ‘Buddhism’ and Prof. Brin- ton’s ‘Religions of Primitive Peoples.’ The publishers will be G. P. Putnam’s Sons. ‘The Story of Gladstone's Life,’ by Justin McCarthy, and ‘The Social Mind and Educa- tion,’ by George E. Vincent of the University of Chicago, are in the press of Macmillan Co. Fleming H. Revell Company will shortly publish, in connection with John Murray, London, ‘Korea and her Neighbors,’ by Mrs. Isabella Bird Bishop, with numerous photo- graphic illustrations and two new maps. ‘In Tune with the Infinite,’ by Ralph Wal- do Trine, is to be issued by T. Y. Crowell & Co. The Whitaker & Ray Company, San Fran- cisco, will have ready next month the Com- plete Poetical Works of Joaquin Miller in one large volume. Smith, Elder & Co., London, are just bringing out ‘The Autobiography of Arthur Young,’ with selections from his correspon- dence, by Miss Betkam-Edwards. Two por- traits and many unpublished letters en- hance the value of this work. George Redway’s autumn list includes ‘Reminiscences’ of Miss Betham-Edwards; a new translation of Voltaire’s ‘Candide,’ with introduction and notes by Walter Jerrold and sixty-two vignettes by Adrien Moreau— in a limited edition; ‘The Morality of Mar- riage, and Other Essays on the Status and Destiny of Woman,’ by Mrs. Mona Caird; and ‘The Story of Our English Towns,’ by P. H. Ditchfield. The fifth edition of Prof. Saintsbury’s ‘Short History of French Literature,’ to be soon issued by H. Frowde for the Clarendon Press, is marked by thorough revision, es- pecially in the section on the nineteenth century. Those interested in the history of the exploration of Australia in the first half of the seventeenth century, and of the do- ings of the Dutch East India Company of that time, will be glad to learn that the long-promised work upon Tasman may be confidently expected to appear early in 1898. The recently discovered Journal of Tas- man’s discovery of Van Diemen's Land and New Zcaland, in 1642-43, signed by Tas- man himself, with fifty-three drawings and charts, will be reproduced by photolithogra- phy. A word-for-word translation of the Journal into English will be given, and of the letters of instructions for the voyages of 1642 and 1644. It has been revised by Mr. Coote of the British Museum, an ex- pert in cartography. Tasman’s own obser- vations with the compass will be given. A very valuable memoir of the Life and La- bors of Tasman will be supplied by Pro- fessor J. E. Heeres, who possesses excep- tional knowledge of the colonial archives at The Hague. Four large reproductions of charts of Tasman’s exploratory voyages in 1634, 1639, and 1642-44 will form part of the work, which Muller & Co. of Amster- dam will publish. Those who desire a copy of this luxurious work can have it on pay- ment of £6 sterling. In recognition of his valuable historical work, Mr. George McCall Theal, LL.D., historiographer to the Government of Cape Colony, has been elected by the Council of the Royal Colonial Institute, London, to be an honorary fellow of that society. Dr Theal’s ‘History of South Africa’ is a stan- dard work. Its author has been for many years settled in South Africa, but is at present in London, charged by the Cape Government with the duty of scanning the records of the British Museum and the Pub- lic Record Office for papers illustrative .of the history of South Africa. The extent to which the Colonial Government has been amassing papers connected with that part of the world may be gathered from the fact that between five hundred and six hundred volumes of copies of old records have been sent from The Hague alone to the Cape. Dr. Theal is a native of the Dominion of Cana- da, whither his family, who were loyalists, removed from the United States, and it is more than two hundred years since their progenitor removed from England to North America. Little more need be said of the four- volume edition of Rousseau’s ‘Confessions,’ published in London by Gibbings & Co. and in Thiladelphia by Lippincott, than that it is handy in form and well printed. It is a patchwork upon the anonymous English ver- sion of a hundred years ago, and so far an improvement; but no translation will supply the peculiar charm of the original, in which the style is in the highest sense the man. A few illustrations (besides a portrait) have been inserted, reductions from the ten-year-old designs of Maurice Leloir; and there is an index of names which is passable. But an analytic index is the boon which a not indolent editor might have earned gratitude for, and we ought at least to have had a table of contents. There yet remains to be made an edition of the French, annotated from all the other biographical sources of this author, and even then for the true character we should have to go also to the correspondence. The ‘Works of Rabelais’ have nothing in- trinsically in common with the foregoing, but are issued by the same publishers in five volumes, following the version of Sir Thomas Urquhart and Peter Motteux, and have the same merit as specimens of book- making. ‘Shakespeare’s London,’ by T. Fairman Ordish (Macmillan), appears to be the intro- ductory volume to a new series, to be en- titled “The Temple Shakespeare Manuals.” Its scope is rather less than might be in- ferred from the title, embracing little more than a somewhat rambling attempt to ex- plain the background of the scenes in Shak- spere’s plays which are laid in London. A few, but far too few, illustrations add to the interest of the book. An outline map of old London is especially needed. Attention dis- proportionate for a “Manual” is given to recent theories of the allegory of contem- porary life and politics in Shakspere’s plays. In style and arrangement the book is nei- ther sufficiently lucid nor sufficiently enter- taining to be altogether successful. The student may more profitably consult the pertinent chapters in the larger works of recent date on the London of old, by Wheat- ley, Loftie, or Besant, or even the original descriptions in Stow or Harrison. The fall trade is bringing out the usual number of picture-books. First in order of time and easily first in order of merit is Boutet de Monvel’s ‘Joan of Arc’ (The Cen- tury Company), the quality of which should not be judged from the black-and-white re- productions that have appeared from time to time in the Century Magazine. This art- ist’s style is essentially decorative, and his line is but a skeleton for his color. What seems, in black and white, the ultra sim- plicity and almost affected naiveté of his drawing, reveals itself in the colored prints as the appropriate boundary of his exquisite- ly selected and balanced tones and colors; and the result, though between the covers of a book, is truly mural and even monu- mental. It is interesting to compare some of these drawings with the treatment of simi- lar themes by Mr. Abbey in his “Holy Grail’ series in the Boston Public Library, and to remark how the American artist, notwith- standing his ability and the great merits of vidios
Page 17
Nov. 11, 1897] The Nation. 3877 his work, remains, conversely to his French confrére, the illustrator of books, even when painting vast compositions upon the walls of a noble building. The story of Joan is simply told for children in the accompany- ing text by M. Boutet de Monvel him- self. ‘An Alphabet,’ by William Nicholson (R. H. Russell), introduces to the American pub- lic an artist of a very different type, whose portrait of the Queen, in a style similar to a these drawings, had a great vogue in Eng- 4 land during the Jubilee celebration. Mr. F. Nicholson affects the manner of rude early wood-engraving in which outline, Nght and shade, and local color are all indicated by and merged into fat, flat blacks. The crudi- ty of contrast is then overcome by the use of broad tones of brown or gray over the whole surface, and there is an occasional note of red or blue to enliven the somewhat sombre pages. These twenty-six drawings, from the ‘‘Artist’’ at the beginning to the “‘Xylographer” and the ‘‘Zodlogist’’ at the end, vary much in quality, some of them being richly decorative and some almosi stupid; but the coloring, in its deadened, Whistlerian key, is nearly always good. The “Flower Girl’ and the ‘‘Trumpeter’’ may be mentioned as two of the best, and the “Ur- chin’’ as one of the least interesting, of the series. Judged by a short experience in one family, the book is remarkably and some- what unexpectedly successful in its appeal to children—especially to very young chil- dren. From the same publisher comes another work, whose appeal is to the elders, or at least to ‘“‘boys” rather than to ‘‘children’’— 2 a collection of ‘Drawings by Frederic Rem- 5 ington.’ In a short note “Concerning the Contents’’ Mr. Owen Wister eloquently sets forth the truth to life of Mr. Remington's cowboys and soldiers and Indians, and this may be accepted as expert testimony on the Saati SMR gaa ee OR matter. We confess ourselves unable to discern in a ‘Phil May’s Graphic Pictures’ (Routledge) the merit that has been found by many in that artist’s work. His drawing is undoubt- edly accurate, but to us it seems neither humorous nor beautiful, but simply common- place, while his manner is inflexible and lacking in charm. The Macmillan Company are the New York agents for ‘Portrait Miniatures,’ by George C. Williamson, Litt.D., the latest addition to the ‘Connoisseur Series,"" published by George Bell & Sons, London. The book, be- sides some hints to “the amateur collector,” contains a history of miniature painting in England from Holbein (1531) to Sir William Ross (1860), and a briefer account of foreign miniaturists and of the present revival of miniature art in England. Naturally there is no mention of American work of to-day, some of which is of excellent quality. The book contains very good collotypes, process cuts, and woodcuts of more than a hundred and eighty well-chosen miniatures; and an examination of them throws light on the cu- ‘ rious difference between merit and reputa- tion. Holbein and Cooper are indeed great names as well as great artists, but Cosway, whose name dominates the eighteenth cen- tury, and who may almost be cailed the miniaturist par egecllence in popular opi- nion, is, as an artist, vastly inferior to such less-known contemporaries as George Engle- heart, Ozias Humphrey, or William Grimal- di. The sub-title is ‘“‘A Handbook for Col- lectors,”” and the work should prove useful in that capacity. The Century Co. have reproduced in book form Mr. La Farge’s delightful ‘Artist's Let- ters from Japan,’ with the original illus- trations that appeared with them when they were running in the Magazine. The letters gain in interest, read consecutively, but they are still somewhat desultory, and the book is not one for the searcher for informa- tion. Mr. La Farge writes always as the artist, more interested in colors than in facts, and much of what he has written is an attempted record of visual impressions, charmingly done, but not always quite suc- cessful in reproducing the thing seen to an- other’s eyes. There is always a subtle and flexible style, and there is a good deal of philosophizing and suggestive criticism by the way, some of which is of real value. Part of the chapter on “Japanese Architecture,” which deals with the whole question of right and wrong methods in art and what art is, may be especially recommended as wholesome and stimulating reading for stu- dents of art, and even for many profession- al artists who may be in danger of forget- ting the truths Mr. La Farge teaches. They are truths which have been attempted to be enforced again and again in these columns, though with less distinction of manner, and Mr. La Farge is almost as good as Fromen- tin in his treatment of them. More than this it would be difficult to say. Mr. F.C. Selous, the well-known African sportsman and traveller, puts a low esti- mate on the agricultural value of Rhodes- ia in the Scottish Geographical Magazine for October. The superficial area of that part above the fever-belt (4,000 feet) and accordingly adapted to European coloniza- tion, is approximately 26,500 square miles; but, whatever the fertility of the soil, the cost of transport to Europe will prevent the cultivation of any agricultural product for export. The two great evils under which the country is suffering at present are the rinderpest, which has practically destroyed all the cattle and large game, and the lo- custs, which for seven years have made agriculture well-nigh impossible. These evils Mr. Selous believes to be temporary and not likely to recur for many years, possibly centuries. A useful orographical map adds to the value of the article. Prof W. M. Davis of Harvard University dis- cusses the relations of the winds to ocean currents. His conclusions are that the “‘sur- face currents are ruled by the winds,”’ but that the movement of the deep water is probably due to oceanic convection. This is followed by an account, by Prof. R. E Dodge of this city, of what bas been done recently to improve the teacning of geogra- phy in our schools. The water on the Banks of Newfoundland is the subject of an article by Dr. G. Schott in Petermann's Mittcilungen, No. 9, which is accompanied by an interesting se- ries of six maps shewing the direction of the warm and cold currents, the tempera- ture of the surface water in February and in August, the extent of the floating ice, the percentage of fogs. and the steamer- routes from January to July and from July to January. Other articles are a physical description of Tierra del Fuego by Dr. O. Nordenskjéld, with a map, and the conclu- sion of Dr. Fischer's investigations into the geological development of Italy. Medica] journals are countless as leaves in this country, but the rapid growth of interest in pure science in recent years has at last made necessary (in the opinion of its promoters) the foundation of an Amert- can journal devoted solely to Physiology. The first number of the proposed journal will appear in January; the editors will be Bowditch of Bosten, Chittenden of New Haven, Howell of Baltimore, Lee of New York, Loeb of Chicago, Lombard of Ann Arbor, and Dr. V. I. Porter, No. 688 Boylston Street, Boston, to whom the subscription price of five dollars should be sent. The Monist has begun its eighth year with a very engaging list of contributors, past and future. This journal, which is devoted to the discussion of the fundamental prias- ciples of scientific inquiry, fills a most use- ful office, and is an instance of how much can be done by the devotion of a single in- dividual, if he is an editor, to add to the amount of intellectual work which ts brought to the light In a given country. Dr. Paul Carus is deserving of the earnest sup- port and encouragement of those who be- lieve in furthering intellectual pursuits. The October number of the Monist reprints Prof. Eimer’s Leyden address on Ortho- genesis, by which he means definite evolu- tion occasioned by organic growth. Prof. Mach expresses his adhesion to the view that the ear, which, in its several parts, is now known to be the organ for orlentation as well as for hearing, had the former of these two functions for its original one, and that even so high up in the animal aecale as in fishes, hearing, as a distinct sensation- quality, does not exist. In the face of the agitation which has been carried on by well-meaning persons who have succeeded in making instruction regarding alcoholism compulsory in seve- ral States, it Is extremely desirable that the physiologists ron Fach should tell us dis- tinctly just what sclence has to say re- garding the deleterious effects of alcohol in small quantities, and to what extent the ar- gument in favor of total abstinence can be made sound. Children are peculiarly keen at detecting any forcing of the note in the incentives which are put before them to- wards virtues of any sort, and there is an intellectual honesty which it is of more im- portance to propagate than abstention from alcoholism. It is therefore a matter of im- portance that the Committee of Fifty has commissioned Prof. Hodge of Clark Univer- sity to make a thorough study of the sub- ject. Prof. Hodge's discoveries regarding the immediate and marked effect of alcohol on nerve cells have made it natural to re- gard him as an expert on the subject. The Quarterly Statement for October of the Palestine Exploration Fund contains the final report on the excavations at Jeru- salem by Dr. Bliss, and a description of por- tions of the great mosque at Damascus by Mr. Dickie and Mr. R. P. Spiers, illustrated by numerous drawings to scale. This build- ing, which was nearly destroyed by fire in 1893, is now being slowly restored. Col. Goldsmid makes an interesting statement as to the increased number and improved con- dition of the Jews in Palestine. ‘Where there were three little needy colonies [in 1883] there are now over a hundred, some of which are nearly self-supporting, and the output of wine in the Jewish colonies is something enormous at the present time.” Seven years ago we called attention to the merits of Gottfried Keller as a story- teller, and it is with interest that we note 4 igh yk) online PEGE ee AMT CCAM, 8 eggattinn 5 NRE Hed SO, omen po ar 7
Page 18
—.. ; [Vol. 65, No. 1689 the appearance of one of his best-known tales in the Ogtober-December number of Poect-Lore. The editor, however, is in error in accepting, and confirming, the statement of Cosmopolis that no translation of his work had ever appeared in English. The same tale, which is here given in an abridged form, was published in the ventury, a high- class weekly of New York, in the issues for August 23 to September 13, 1860. In 1885 a three-part tale, “The Flag of the Seven Upright Ones,”’ appeared in Outing. The Society of Natural and Economical Sciences of Palermo has resumed the publi- eation of its (Giornale, six years having elapsed since the appearance of volume 20. The twenty-first volume contains seven papers, including a continuation of Gam- mellaro’s account of fossils from the Sosio valley. —If any settlement of the Bacon-Shak- spere question were possible, Mr. John Fiske’s entertaining ‘Forty Years of Bacon- Shakspere Folly’ inthecurrent Atlantic would dispose of it. The difficulty is, as any one can see who reads the history of this curious narrative of delusion, that the gift of weigh- ing literary evidence is not coextensive with that of reading and writing, nor even with that of a very high degree of general educa- tion. One of the oddest facts in the story is that one of the books produced to prove the case for Bacon was written by a judge who was also a lecturer on evidence; yet he would probably have passed on the ques- tion (had it come before him judicially) with perfect sanity, because, in that case, he would have felt forced to allow himself to be governed by the weight of authority, which is all one way. Outside the articles in this number which may be regarded as instalments of books, one of the most valu- able papers is F. J. Stimson’s ‘‘Democracy and the Laboring Man.’ He shows that during the last ten years some 1,639 laws have been passed in the varioug States and Territories affecting laboring interests. Of these, 114 specific statutes have been de- clared unconstitutional, while ‘‘of the forty- three lines of action in which legislation has been essayed, the constitutionality of no less than twenty-three is, mildly speaking, in doubt.”” If we assumed that each court decision was right, and would be followed in other States, 56 per cent. of the whole legislation would turn out invalid. This cannot be presumed, especially as the courts of all the States do not take the same view of the same law. But, according to any test, an immense proportion of the legisla- tion has been upset. If we inquire on what ground, the answer is in nine cases out of ten that the Legislature has attempted to give the laborer special privileges, or to interfere with his actions, or the actions of employers, in his peculiar interest. Hence these statutes, when they have not been set aside as interfering with rights of contract or property, have been nullified by the courts as invasions of individual liberty; all this activity of the Legislature representing tyranny against which we have to struggle as our ancestors struggled against the ty- ranny of their day. A more shocking ex- posure of the modern Legislature has never been made. The invasions of liberty which it describes stand, the reader will notice, not so much for that tyranny of the ma- jority which Socialism would introduce, pro- vided the majority favor it,.as for the cer- rupt influence over the legislative body of a special class. Nine-tenths of the laws would probably never have commanded a majority vote of the electorate had the ques- tion been thoroughly canvassed. —The Century for November prints the report of an interview extraordinary with the Sultan of Turkey, by Hon. A. W. Ter- rell, late United States Minister at Con- stantinople. It is virtually a communica- tion from the Sultan to the American pub- lic. There is nothing in it of much im- portance or novelty, except some signifi- cant evidence that Mr. Terrell knew that the later Armenian massacres were to be set on foot some time before they actu- ally occurred. He quotes from a letter of his written in December, 1895 (U. S. For. Rel., Pt. II.), in which he declared that as early as August of that year he had been convinced that “the so-called reforms would, when announced, be followed by a massacre of Armenians.’’ He was led to this con- clusion, he says, by reflection on the Ku- klux outrages in the South at the close of our war, following upon “enforced reforms,” but he evidently had better warrant for his foresight than this, because he says that it was “‘known here that at least one of the Powers would not consent to the use of force to make the reforms proposed for the benefit of the Armenian race effective.” And so, in advance of the massacres, he “demanded and obtained,’’ on October 21, “telegraphic orders to every civil and mili- tary chief in the Ottoman Empire to protect American missionaries.’’ Abdul wishes it to be known that he does not “have it in his nature to be wilfully cruel.’’ ‘‘Thus,”’ says Mr. Terrell naively, ‘does this iso- lated ruler, who is regarded by very many persons as a throned assassin, give ut- terance to the noblest sentiments.’’ An ar- ticle on Mrs. Julia Margaret Cameron, by V. Cc. Scott O’Connor, gives some interesting reproductions of her famous photographic portraits. The heroic ‘‘Story of Chitral’ is told in all its details by Charles Lowe. —In Harper’s an illustrated article by Richard Harding Davis gives an amusing and at the same time sad account of the Greek soldiery. “The New Japan’ is the subject of an intelligent but not very in- forming article by Toru Hoshi, Japanese Minister at Washington. If Japan is to become one of the family of nations, the questions which need to be answered are not merely historical or diplomatic, but legal; and on the most elementary questions of common right the article throws no light. We are reminded that Japan has a ‘“‘consti- tutional’ form of government, and that in 1899, by virtue of the recent treaties, for the first time in history an Oriental nation will be received by Christian Powers on a foot- ing of perfect equality. So far as the rela- tions of the United States with Japan are concerned, the treaty, which was negotiated during Mr. Cleveland’s second term, bears out the statement of the article. Ex-terri- toriality goes by the board, and for the protection of Americans in Japan we are to look in future to the Japanese Govern- ment, exactly as in the case of Americans in England we look to the English. George Wharton Edwards gives an il- lustrated account of ‘“‘The Pardon of Sainte- Anne d’Auray in Brittany,” a festival which for the day revives or perpetuates the old Catholic peasant world in that out- of-the-way corner. Primitive Brittany is not so accessible in reality as it looks on the map, and on most days of the year the local costume is little worn; but on the oc- easion of a Pardon the scene is bright with color, and while the ceremonial is Catholic, there are certain accessories, especially the sacred fountain or spring and the sur- rounding sylvan-terraced hillsides, which take the spectator back to still more primi- tive times and worship, before there was any Catholic religion or French language. —William Allen White, in Scribner's, gives an account of “The Business of a Wheat Farm,” which exhibits by text and illustrations the present condition of agri- culture in the far Northwest. What will strike everybody is the picture of Adam’s occupation turned into a modern industry carried on ona great scale with capital, ma- chinery, and the complete subordination of the original husbandman to the conditions of a new economical cosmos. In fact, in the process the original husbandman, farmer, agricultural laborer, and peasant, attached to the glebe, for life if not by inheritance. has disappeared, and in his place we have a quantity of ‘“‘hands,’’ hired for the plough- ing or the reaping, who may for the occa- sion camp on the territory which embraces the ‘‘farm,’”’ but who have very little more vital connection with it than the hands of a factory or a railroad with their particular mill or line. Perhaps the most curious thing in the article is that the author evi- dently thinks the present system not ne- cessarily final. The average farm in the Red River valley is a property of 7,000 acres, but as the land has been taken up the price has increased, and this is a temptation to sell. ‘‘Hence one finds the large farms gradually crumbling.’’ But the fact that the work is so extensively done by machinery, one would think, would tend to a régime of large farms, in the long run, in that part of the world, more strong- ly than any rise in value could tend to break them up. “No Continuing City,” by Blanche Willis Howard, is a painfully cle- ver story, which recalls the pathos of a si- tuation made familiar by Dickens, but now not much in use by writers of fiction. Wil- liam B. Bigelow has an article which is worth examination on ‘‘The Country Church in America.’” It has many illustrations of typical churches. As for exterior design, the writer comes to the conclusion that “there is no peculiarly American church architecture.”’ The characteristically Ame- rican churches of an earlier day, such as the New England meeting-house, are rapid- ly disappearing before a species of art too eclectic to be called national. —Blue Hill Observatory, near Boston, founded in 1885 by Mr. A. Lawrence Rotch, and liberally maintained by him ever since, has given more attention to cloud study than any other institution in the United States. Personal estimates during the day, and automatic photography of the stars at night, have furnished a long record of local cloudiness. Certain high and uniform cloud strata are measured at night by the light reflected upon them from cities; the angle is found which the illumination makes with the horizon, and, the distance of the city being known, the right-angled triangle is solved. Lower clouds are studied by kites bearing self-recerding instruments. Cirrus is judged to be, on an average, about 29,000 feet high, but is sometimes found as bigh rarer
Page 19
Ee Pc ATE Pare LES ND Ling se aati ca seihertoce Ok, 2 inh AE ROSA DS Nov. 11, 1897] The Nation. 3879 as 49,900. Cumulus, on the other hand, is often less than a mile above the earth, al- though thunder-shower clouds sometimes reach into the cirrus region. Nimbus (rain cloud) is but 2,300 feet in altitude. The velocities at which these various clouds move are also very different. Generally the high cirrus travels about eighty-nine miles an hour, but in winter this speed occasion- ally rises to the surprising rate of 230 miles, the entire atmosphere moving twice as fast in winter as in summer; and at altitudes be- tween two and nine miles an almost con- tinuous westerly current of great speed pre- vails. Changes in barometric pressure, air temperature, and humidity with height are even more important in the science of the weather, and these are now most accurately found by elevating delicate instruments by means of large and powerful kites. With winds varying from fourteen to forty miles an hour, about 130 records have been made, many times at heights exceeding a mile. At such elevations both cold and warm waves are shown abruptly, and long before they are felt below; and in fair weather the days are damp, the nights dry—the reverse of surface conditions. So the upper air is now sounded by devices similar to those of Lord Kelvin in reaching abysmal depths of the ocean, and within the past three weeks the observers at Blue Hill have secured perfect records at vertical heights exceeding two miles, or rather more than 11,000 feet. —An interesting instance of the elusive- ness of scientific researches is furnished in a paper by Sir William and Lady Hug- gins, recently presented before the Royal Society and since published in full. It had long been known that certain two lines of the spectrum of calcium were remarkably conspicuous in the chromosphere and pro- minences of the sun, appearing when the other lines were hardly visible at all. To account for this it had been suggested that the lines did not belong to calcium, but to some hitherto undetected impurity (as argon in nitrogen), or else that calcium was itself (after the hypothesis of Lockyer) a com- pound substance, and that it became disso- ciated at certain temperatures. But the ob- servations of the above-named investigators have shown that it is solely a question of the density at which the calcium gas is exa- mined, and they have produced in their la- boratory, and photographed, a spectrum of calcium in which other lines are almost en- tirely wanting. The discovery may prove to be one of great importance, because the calcium spectrum in its different phases can very likely be used as a criterion of the density of stellar atmospheres. Why density should be the quality to play so important a part, it is difficult to understand. —Don Pascual de Gaydngos died in Lon- don on the 4th of October, in his eighty- ninth year. Those familiar with the his- | torian Prescott’s works will remember the frequent acknowledgments made by that au- thor to Don Pascual, who collected materials that were used in the writing of the histories of ‘The Conquest of Mexico’ and ‘The Con- quest of Peru.’ Don Pascual’s life-work was, in fact, to a great extent the collecting, | the calendaring, and the indexing of histori- cal manuscripts, and in these labors he was employed, not only by private individuals, | but by the authorities of the British Muse- | um as well. For the latter he prepared the | valuable calendars of the Spanish manu- scripts in the Museum, which cover nearly 3,000 pages of letter-press. Before his en- gagement with Prescott, he had already been employed by an American gentleman who was collecting documents relating to the history of the United States. Among the private undertakings Don Pascual carried out was that for a wealthy London wine- merchant named Cosens, who believed that fresh light might be thrown upon the life of Shakspere by documents preserved in Spain. To this end Gaydngos copied a vast number of papers from’ the archives of Spain, among them the dispatches of the Count of Gondomar, when Ambassador in London. When Mr. Cosens died, his heirs, who did not set much store upon the collec- tions, put them out to sale, when the British Government secured a portion at a great bargain. American students will find them in the Public Record Office, London, beautifully calendared and indexed. I. is from this col- lection that Major Martin Hume has drawn some of the fresh details that appear in his recent ‘Life of Sir Walter Ralegh.’ GayAngos translated into Spanish Ticknor’s ‘History of Spanish Literature.’ Among his other works was ‘La Gran Conquista de Ultramar,’ and a translation into English for the Hakluyt Society of ‘The Fifth Letter of Cortes to the Smperor Charles V.’ His death was the re- sult of being knocked down in the street by a horse. THE LIFE OF ALFRED TENNYSON. Alfred Lord Tennyson: A Memoir. By his Son. In two volumes. The Macmillan Co. 1897. No biography has for many years past been expected with so much curiosity and interest as this one. Tennyson was (unless an exception is to be made for Ruskin, who has been silent for many years) the last great literary man who used the English tongue. There is not now, either in Great Britain or in America, any poet high even in the second rank, and no prose-writer in the first rank. Tennyson had, moreover, so outlived all his eminent contemporaries (ex- cept Mr. Gladstone) as to have become a somewhat strange and mysterious figure | to the new generation in both countries No one remembered him as a young man No one could recall the impression which his early poems made. To everybody he had been already famous from the time when they first began to care about poetry poet's son, the present Lord Tennyson, has performed his task with great skill, judg- ment, and taste. There is hardly anything inserted which a fastidious critic could wish removed—one or two of the letters from the Queen are perhaps the only exception; and while the domestic life of the poet is given fully enough to make it real to the reader, five-sixths of the two thick volumes is de- voted to tracing the development and illus- trating the working of his poetic faculty Tennyson's life was not an eventful one and almost the only dates that stand out like milestones along it are those that mark the publication of his greater works. He was born in 1809, that famous year which, besides Mendelssohn and Dr. Oliver Wen- dell Holmes, ushered into the world Abra- ham Lincoln, Charles Darwin, and W. E Gladstone. His father was a Lincolnshire clergyman, a man of marked character and a considerable scholar; and the poet would seem to have drawn his intellectual gifts more from his father than from his mother for the latter is described as a woman of singular sweetness and gentleness rather than of any conspicuous talent. Both he and his brothers “‘lispedin numbers.”’ Charles and Alfred published their first volume of verse when the elder was only eighteen and the younger (Alfred) only seventeen, and, strange to say, they obtained one hundred dollars for it from a local bookseller. At nineteen Alfred went to Trintty College Cambridge, but left it before taking his degree, being recalled by his father’s weak health. Of his life there less is told than one could have wished for. The university at that time contained a group of men } more distinguished than either it or Oxford i . i; has since seen, eight or nine of whom at- tained deserved and permanent fame, and | Tennyson was looked upon by them all as J Besides, he led an extremely secluded life, | hated publicity, hated even to be seen by | passers-by when he took his twilight walks | on the down above his house at Freshwater, so that less was known regarding his ap- | i pearance, character, and habits than in the | | prove his gift before he was twenty-five. The volume entitled ‘Poems, Chiefly Lyri- case of any other person who approached him in eminence. These two volumes, if they do not fully satisfy the curiosity of those indiscreet peo- ple who want to know everything about the great, give quite as much as needs to be known by those who desire to connect a poet’s life with his verse. and to under- stand the conditions under which his genius worked. In general, a near relative makes a bad biographer, because he can seldom see his subject in due perspective, and because he—and still more she—cannot becomingly set forth a comment on those flaws which go to make the truth of the picture even where they are mere foils to surpassing excellence. Despite these difficulties, the the most brilliant genius among them: Ar- thur Hallam as the most winning and gra cious personality. A tender reciprocal de- votion united these two from the first. But though most of the group continued to maintain their friendship with one another, it does not appear that Tennyson was much affected in character or opinions by any one except Arthur Hallam. His own indi- viduality was too strong to be moulded by others, and maintained its own well-mark- ed lines through the whole of his career. From boyhood, or at any rate certainly from his college years, he had felt poetry to be his vocation. Though his private means were slender, he seems never to have thought of entering any profession. Poetry, like music and painting, is an art in which the special gift makes itself very early felt, and it may be doubted if any one has ever attained high excellence in it who did not eal,” which he published in 1830, when twen- ty-one, was enough to prove his gift to be real; that published in 1832 (including “Oenone,”’ “The Lotos Eaters,’ ‘““‘The Lady of Shalott,”’ “The Palace of Art,”’ and ““The Dream of Fair Women") placed him at once at the head of all the poets of his generation, and contains some work which he never after- wards surpassed. Looking back after more than sixty years, one is amazed that the ex- traordinary merit of these poems should not have been immediately recognized by cul- tivated people, as it was by the little Cam- bridge group. But nearly twenty years were to elapse before Tennyson's appointment 4s Se is SP,
Page 20
380 The Nation. [Vol. 65, No. 1089 Poet Laureate, after the death of Words- worth in 1850, made his name familiar to the general public in England; and his American popularity came still later. In 18387 or 1838 he became engaged to Miss Emily Sellwood, but it was not till 1850 that his circumstances permitted him to marly. His wife was a woman of singular 1efinement and charm, and their wedded life was one of unclouded happiness. In 1845 Sir Robert Peel had advised the Queen to grant Tennyson a pension of £200 a year; and with- in the four following years the sale of his poems had so far increased that it became possible for bim to maintain a household. After 1850 his income from his books steadi- ly increased, and from 1860 onwards he had no need to think about money. In 1853 he went to live at Farringford, near Fresh- water in the Isle of Wight, and in 1868 he built a house at Aldworth on the top of Blackdown, a4 lofty hill near Haslemere in Surrey, and thereafter spent his time be- tween these two country-seats, with occa- sional short trips to the continent of Eu- rope. He died in October, 1892, having en- joyed good physical health through nearly his whole life, and retained his intellectual powers to the last. His latest volume of poems was published in the year of his death, at the age of eighty-three—an almost un- paralleled instance of the prolongation of poetical power into extreme old age, for of the other great poets who have passed three- score and ten, which indeed not many have done; Sophocles is perhaps the only one who, according to the famous anecdote about the “Oedipus Coloneus,’’ retained his gift in all its fulness. There are not many letters of the poet’s in this Life, for of the earlier ones few seem to have been preserved, and in his later years he wrote extremely few. Those print- ed are admirable, and more helpful to a com- prehension of his character than the Re- miniscences printed in the appendix. Of these reminiscence articles, those written by Mr. Myers, the Duke of Argyll, and the late Mr. Jowett are interesting, hut two others are injured by the intrusion of the writer's personality, and one of these two, that by the late Mr. Tyndall, adds so little that it might with advantage be omitted in future editions. On the other hand, all that the biographer himself records—conversations with friends and opinions delivered by his father (such as the criticisms on Milton) —is admirably given, and makes us wish for even more of the same kind. Of the per- sonal recollections happily introduced here and there through the book we have found those contributed by Edward FitzGerald and Aubrey de Vere, together with Mr. Sidg- wick’s remarks on the impression produced by “in Memoriam,’ the most _ interest- ing. As already observed, it is in the history of the poet’s mind and opinions, in the expla- nation of his modes of working and his self- criticism, that the chief interest of such a Life as this is to found. The biographer has most wisely devoted great pains to this branch of his task, giving us so much mat- ter that is both new and instructive as to make it hard to select any parts for special notice. Four topics have, however, struck us as of eminent and peculiar interest. One is the opinions Tennyson held on religion. Another is his method of composition. A third is the origin of the several chief poems, #. ¢., the conception or suggestion whence each sprang. A fourth is the poet’s own judgment and taste in poetry. The religious sense—that is to say, the impulse to look to and turn to a higher power—was strong in Tennyson from his childhood; and though he early divested himself of the dogmatic forms in which Christianity had been taught to him, he clung all his life to the belief not only in the existence of a Deity, but in the divine government of the world. His mind was incessantly occupied, from early manhood onwards, by the problems which the ad- vance of physical science had raised. in the days between 1833 and 1845, when he was composing at intervals (and at first with no thought of publishing them) the poems afterwards entitled ‘In Memoriam,” he had already begun to muse on these problems, ond nothing in this Life is more Interest- ing than the account given of the way his mind played round them, dramatizing the various moods through which he passed and the phases of doubt or hope that succes- sively emerged. Somewhat later, he began to study metaphysics more regularly than before, and to read a good many scientific books. Neither of these influences altered the settled tendency of his mind. In old age he seemed more than ever concerned at the growing scepticism of the age. It cast a shadow over many hours, yet his own convictions did not falter. There are few of his later poems in which his disquiet at the decline of faith and his own belief in the power and guiding hand of a personal Deity are not indicated. Being a man of very simple tastes, lov- ing nature and quiet, indifferent to so- called sport and the other dull amusements of his social class, averse to city life, ani not drawn to any kind of practical work, because he felt that his own gifts lay in a different direction, he was able to devote the whole of his time to reading and think- ing and musing. The gift of vergjfication came so naturally to him that to reflect meant almost necessarily to compose verses, and this spontaneous fertility would have been dangerous but for the extreme fasti- diousness of his taste. He criticised his own work as closely, and with almost as much detachment, us the work of another, constantly rejecting what he had composed, recasting it, or polishing it to a higher finish. No other great modern bas taken so much pains to revise his work in new editions, so that many of the best-known poems are now, in the later issues, very dif- ferent from what they were in the earlier ones. It was a habit—it was, indeed, al- most an instinct—with him, when some im- pression or thought flashed into his mind, to turn it at once into verse, and often to write down and lay aside the line or lines which he had thus struck off, keeping them till some fit occasion should arise for using them. One remarkable instance is given (vol. i., p. 218) of three magnificent lines in ‘“‘Vi- vien”’ which were thus composed at a visit to the caves of Ballybunnion on the west coast of Ireland, composed in 1842 and in- corporated in “Vivien” fifteen years af- terwards. These two volumes contain a good many hitherto unpublished poems— some never used because they were alterna- tive versions of poems published; some be- cause their author thought them scarcely good enough. Their quality approves the poet’s judgment, for none among them reaches the level of his best work; yet many have the charm of graceful thought and melodious rhythm, and a few may deserve to be included in future editions of the ‘Opera Omnia.’ One of the finest, which well deserves to be so included, consists of some stanzas (given on p. 120 of vol. 1.) written for the ‘‘Palace of Art.” Of the many interesting facts stated re- garding the growth and development of the larger poems, we have space to note one only. ‘‘Maud,” which Tennyson himself al- ways rated highly, and which it always pleased him to find any one genuinely ap- preciate, grew out of a single poem, that which begins— “O that 'twere sible, After long grief and pain,"’ and was, so to speak, written back from that piece, which (it will be remembered) comes near the end of the book. There is in the Life a short but instructive analysis of “Maud” from Tennyson’s cwn pen, intended by him to correct some of the common mis- understandings of the poem. A curious ac- count, too long to be abridged here, is given of the way in which the Arthurian Legend had occupied his thoughts from early youth, and of the various ways in which he had proposed to handle it. Of all his poems, none embodies so much of his philosophy of human life as the “‘Idylls of the King,” and none shows more strikingly the change that passed on his poetical style. Lastly, this biography contains a large number of critical dicta, most, and the best, of them by Tennyson himself, some others by the friends who surrounded him. Ths bard’s own preferences are clearly marked. Besides Shakspere, whom he regarded as an almost superbuman intellect, he honored Milton most among English poets; next to him Wordsworth and Keats. “There is something of the innermost soul of poetry in almost everything he [Keats] wrote.” He used to say in early life that he doubted if he should ever do anything as good as Keats's “St. Agaes’s Eve.”” Among the older singers, he especially loved Homer, Virgil, and Dante, and never ceased reading them. Byron he put comparatively low, calling him ‘“‘end- lessly clever, but not an artist or thinker in the higher sense.’”’ Among American poets he held Edgar Poe to be, “taking his poetry and prose together, the most original American genius’’ However, the value of these literary judgments lies so largely in the quotations which illustrate them that they suffer by detachment from their con- text. The lover of poetry will find these volumes rich both in the ligbt they throw on the workings of an intensely poetical mind, and in the profusion of acute critical observations scattered through them. There is hardly a page in which one fails to find something that deserves to be remembered. One is struck all through the book by the way in which Tennyson’s poetry was his life. He thought of nothing else; or, rather, all that he thought of turned itself into matter for poetry. He needed nothing else to occupy his mind and time. Whether he travelled or read, whether he smoked alone in his upper chamber or wandered at night beneath the stars, he was always absorbing impressions which he turned as naturally and instinctively into musical verse as a plant breathes carbonic acid and turns it into vascular tissue. The fertility of his genius and the ease with which he composed would have been formidable enemies to ex- cellence. But he was happily no less an
Page 21
SARA hai Be a eee Nov. 11, 1897] The Nation. 881 artist than an inventor, and his power of self-criticism was joined to a noble diligence in seeking to bring all the work he put forth as near to perfection as he could bring it The reader, who feels in every page that this biography is written with the reverence as well as the intimate knowledge of a son. may, perhaps, ask what were the shadows on a character which is here presented in so favorable a light, and may distrust the picture because it does not show the sha- dows. Ii he does this he will err. Against the many noble qualities which Tennyson's career showed him to possess, there are really no serious defects to be set. He was so direct in manner as sometimes to appear brusque, and, therefore, rather formidable to strangers. He was all his life over-sensi- tive to criticism to an extent extraordinary in one who had reached a position of sucb undisputed preéminence. But he was not vain, though, like Dante and Wordsworth, he knew when he had done a thing well and was not afraid to say so; nor was he jealous, for no one was more ready to ac- knowledge the excellence of other men’s work, no one more free from petty spites and hinted disparagements. He was up- right, simple, honest, truthful, affectionate, a hater of injustice and cruelty, a friend to all good causes, a man who lived his life in the spirit of his own poetry, and retained, all through, the uninterrupted love and re- spect of those who had known him in his youth. There is nothing in the picture of this life, so full of tranquil dignity, more beautiful than the friendship which united him to three of the greatest of his lite- rary compeers, Thomas Carlyle, Robert Browning, and Edward FitzGerald; nor do any records of those three men’s lives set them in a more attractive light than what we find here as to their relations with Ten- nyson. The friendship of Browning and Tennyson, as we have it here set forth, de- serves to take its place beside the friend- ships of Virgil and Horace, of Goethe and Schiller, of Wordsworth, Coleridge, and Southey. Such instances show how far from being generally true is the judgment expressed in the familiar phrase, genus irri- tabile ratum. There was a strong dash of melancholy in Tennyson’s character, which produced in him mecods of depression faith- fully reflected in his poetry. But apart from this, and from the two great sorrows of his life, the death of Arthur Hallam in 1833 and the death of bis son Lionel in 1886, his life was serene, as should be the life of a great artist, consecrated to the work in which he excels, honored in his own time, and destined to the crown of undying fame. TWO BOOKS ON SPAIN. Across the Country of the Little King. By William Bement Lent. Bonnell, Silver & Co. In Northern Spain. By Hans Gadow. Lon- don: Adam & Charles Black. Mr. Lent’s title is not such as to prepos- sess one in favor of a book; nor is the preju- dice created by it removed by its contents, which are in harmony with the title. It is possible to write a book on the most beaten paths in Spain and yet find plenty of new things to say. Mr. Lent follows these paths, but he saw only what the most com monplace ‘‘personally conducted’’ tourist would notice, and his style is that of the most rambling domestic letter-writer. Even in a private letter one would hardly look for such literary slovenliness as that which makes the author run on from p. 30 to p. 38 without a break or a paragraph. The volume is adorned with a dozen illustra- tions. A very different sort of book is Mr. Ga- dow’s. It takes us into mountainous regions of Spain of which the ordinary tourist does not even know the existence, and where Spanish life may be studied in its unadul- terated medieval backwardness. Once Mr. Gadow took a peasant companion to Riafio, where the latter for the first time saw a te- legraph wire. “The guardia at once ventured to explain the meaning and working of the telegraph. ‘If I want to speak to my chief in Madrid, I go into that house to the postmaster. He makes click (accompanied by manual de- monstration), click, click, and they have my message in Madrid.’ ‘Then the wire must be hollow?’ ‘No, you stupid, it is done by electricity.’ Poor Miguel, he did not even say, ‘Oh, I see,’ but shook his head and thought Riaflo was a very queer place.”’ Among the curiosities carried off by our author was the shoulder-blade of a cow which he found hanging inside a shop, and which had been used for writing down me- moranda—an Arabic practice only recently superseded by the use of slates. All the older people in the mountains, from Galicia to the Basque provinces, had learned to do their sums upon such Awesas (a word spe- cially coined from hueso, bone). Medieval also, cr rather Oriental, was the custom Mr. Gadow found prevalent in the schools of teaching children their lessons by mak- ing them repeat sentences over and over again in chorus until the sound (though perhaps not the sense) had become familiar to them. Postal affairs, again, he found in a more primitive condition than even in the cities of southern Spain. A letter address- ed to John Smith, Esq., is quite as apt to be put in the pigeon-hole marked J. or E. as that marked S.; so Smith has one chance in three of getting his letter when he asks for it. Once, at Potes, the author came across a letter addressed to a gentleman living in a town near Santander. He asked why it had not been sent to that place, to which it was addressed. The answer was, “That man is a compatrieta of yours, a for- eigner, at least, is he not? Well, numbers of strangers come to Potes, and he is as likely to turn up here as at Cabezon.”’ Even at San Sebastian, Mr. Gadow was once com- pelled to seek the assistance of the consul to compel the postmaster to disgorge a let- ter for him which he knew must be there. On the other hand, these primitive moun- taineers have learned the use of modern dynamite to help them fell their hard gnarl- ed trees which it takes days to bring down with an axe. The Government, in view of recent anarchist plots. has forbidden the sale of dynamite, and in the cities it would be dangerous to ask for it; but in the coun- try you can get as much as you please. The men carry the cartridges about in their pockets, and one day Mr. Gadow was horri- fied to find that his muleteer had secreted two of the red sausage-like sticks in his (the master’s) saddle-bags! In one respect these Spanish peasants were even found to be ahead of the rest of the world. They have learned to make cocks hatch eggs and look after the chickens, while the hen, be- ing at liberty, can and does lay more eggs than she would if hampered by her mater- nal duties. The trick is performed in this way: They carefully pluck the feathers off the rooster’s under-side, and the bare skin is then irritated with nettles until inflam- mation sets in. The cock soon finds that the pain caused by this cruel process is mi- tigated by warmth and softness, and this makes him willing and eager, although for purely selfish reasons, to hatch a brood and let the little chicks sit under him. It is even said that he emits the hen’s cluck- ing sound, but this on dif was not verified by the author. Spain, like California, is in the popular mind associated chiefly with oranges and other products of warm climates; but, like California, it has every possible variety of climate and scenery. Who has ever heard of the Deva pass? Mr. Gadow says of it “There is not a pass anywhere else in Eu rope to which this one yields the palm in grandeur and extent. Certain valleys in Norway ... are flanked by higher moun- tains, and others in Switzerland are perhaps as grand, but here we have a pass about thirteen miles in length, every few yards of which bring new surprises of never-flag- ging sublimity.”’ On the range near Ovie- do, he says, ‘“‘in the previous winter snow fell insuch masses that it reached to the roofs and the people were obliged to dig tunnels from their doors into the roads." In such regions the chamois are apt to be at home our author repeatedly hunted them, and his experiences, graphically related, will interest sportsmen. The beaters demand only forty cents a day and find their own food. But not all these mountaineers are so modest in their demands. One day Mr Gadow gave a boy a copper for catching some insects. The next day a maiden, who looked like a milliner, came in with a whole bandbox full of beetles, grasshoppers, and flies. To get rid of her he offered her a peseta (sixteen cents), but she flared up and wanted at least a dollar. “There are so and so many bichos in the box; you gave twenty centimos to my brother for less than one dozen; this makes one duro, and that without the box."” When he told her to take her box and insects away, she grew vicious and wanted to be paid at least for the in sects that had escaped into the room! The natives of this part of Spain are by no means as polite as they are in the south. In Andalusia, an attempt to browbeat or to rebuke would be fatal—politeness alone makes an impression there; whereas ‘‘our sad experience has taught us that if you want anything at all from a Galician, be he a miserable shopkeeper in the Sierras, or be he agent of a line of transatlantic steam- ers, you must ‘go for him’ from the begin- ning; make yourself as disagreeable as pos- sible." But these are not true Spaniards; their language, at least, is more like Portu- guese than like Castilian. With all their rude manners, the humblest of the mountain pea- sants are apt to be very sensitive in regard to a supposed slight. One day, noticing that his beaters had only bread and cheese with them, the author cut his piece of ham in two and with a “Catch!"’ threw it over. “Neither of them caught it. They only looked astonished, and, with a bitter smile, one of them remarked, ‘As at a dog!’”’ The Spanish language, with its charming diminutives, lends itself admirably to fine distinctions in the matter of etiquette and address—a reproach, for instance. To call a man a burro, a donkey, plain and simple, PO
Page 22
— The Nation. [Vol. 65, No. 1689 would be resented as an insult. Burrico, or little donkey, is comparatively inoffen- sive; but to convert the thing into pleasant chaff, you must call him un gran burrico, a big little donkey. Another advantage of the Spanish language is pointed out on p. 67: “It is wonderful how well the Spanish language is suited for shouting and for com- munication acrossenormous distances. Many a time have we beheld two natives asking for and receiving information at a distance which would effectually bar any understand- ing in English, German, or other eminently consonantal idiom. Anda 4 la derecha is bound to’carry further than ‘Go to the right.’ ”’ Something might be said for plantation long-distance English in the mouths of the Southern blacks. Mr. Gadow had his kodak with him, and his volume is illustrated with ninety pic- tures. The appendix contains over fifty pages of valuable notes on the fauna and flora of northern Spain; but why an author who otherwise shows such good taste should have padded his volume needlessly with a forty-page condensed history of Spain, passes comprehension. Varia. By Agnes Repplier. Houghton, Mifflin & Co. 1897. Two essays out of the nine included in this collection—‘“Little Pharisees in Fic- tion” and ‘Prom the Reader’s Standpoint”’ —have already had a month's immortality in the magazines, and are here reprinted with their fellows. The latter essay in- sists on the obvious right of the reader to choose what he shall read, and of the writ- er what he shall write, in spite of Mr. Ham- lin Garland and the critics. We have met with the same contention in much the same language in an earlier volume of Miss Rep- plier’s essays, entitled ‘Our Friends, the Books.’ The touch of Miss Repplier’s hand is as light as ever, her sparkling gayety has its wonted edge, her method of composition has not changed. It is in respect of this last that she chiefly fails to live up to her nick- name, ‘Little Miss Lang.’’ Amiable flip- pancy, light-hearted irresponsibility, and a neat gift of expression she certainly has in common with the author of ‘Essays in Lit- tle.’ But Andrew Lang’s fine carelessness of manner is as a glove under which you feel the hard metal of solid classical at- tainments—the scholarship that shows it- self in the turn of a phrase, a half-quota- tion, an allusion that may be wholly lost on the uninitiated reader. It is the secret of Andrew Lang’s irritating charm. The re- sults of Miss Repplier’s great literary in- dustry lie on the surface. You can—and what is worse, you must—track out step by step the special course of reading pursued for each essay. For Miss Repplier, essay- writing is still an entertaining little game,in which you take a score or so of quotations from authors too little read, and, having shuffled them, stop the gaps with sparkling comment of your own. Miss Repplier ma- nages the transitions with considerable skill, but the skill is too obvious to be art. The general effect of such an array of authori- ties is of all sail and no anchor. Yet we are convinced that Miss Repplier has chosen the literary type that best “sets her ge- nius.”’ It is a sad pity that one whom Na- ture cut out for an essayist should spoil herself in the making. There is a well-in- vented story of Pindar which we commend to Miss Repplier. Korinna the poetess had reproved him for neglecting to use myths in his odes. Pindar took the hint, and his next poem fairly bristled with mythology. Whereupon Korinna said, with asmile, ‘‘One should sow with the hand and not with the whole sack.”’ It is perhaps because it is necessarily free from quotations bearing the label of Dr. Johnson or the Ettrick Shepherd that the essay entitled “The Féte de Gayant’” is one of the most pleasing of the nine. In this tale of Miss Repplier’s experiencesof French towns, and especially the town of Douai, en féte, there is such charming humor that one can almost forgive that slipshod use of the present tensé in narrative which is one of the mint-marks of a lady’s composition. “Old Wine and New’”’ is a spirited defence of the infusion of ‘‘mere literature’ into history in defiance of Prof. Seeley’s warning to histori- ans to keep to “blue-books and other sta- tistics.” In ‘‘The Deathless Diary,’’ Miss Repplier, in the course of copious quotations from diary-keepers ranging from Pepys and John Evelyn to Maurice de Guérin, thus apostrophizes “those who hunger and thirst after the glories of the printed page’’: “O writers of dull verse and duller prose, quit the well-worked field of fiction, the arid waste of sonnets and sad poems, and chronicle in little leather-covered books the incidents which tell their wondrous tale of resistless and inevitable change. Write of electric motors, of bicycles, of peace socie- ties, of hospitals for pussy-cats, of women’s clubs and colleges, of the price of food and house rent, of hotel bills, of new fashions in dress and furniture, of gay dinners, of extension lectures, of municipal corruption and reform. These things do not in- terest us profoundly now, being part of our daily surroundings; but the generations that are to come will read of them with min- gled envy and derision—envy because we have done so little, derision because we think we have done so much”’ (p. 47). This excellent advice would be well timed if there were the smallest chance that the writers thus exhorted would recognize them- selves in Miss Repplier’s category of ‘‘those who have nothing to say which anybody wants to listen to now.” “The Eternal Feminine” is a carefully supported refutation of the popular fallacy that the “new woman” has innovated on her great-grandmother, We are not sure that the ‘new woman’’ will feel flattered by the implication that, like other paradoxes of this generation, she will become a plati- tude of the next, but Miss Repplier’s evi- dence certainly goes to show that the mis- understood pioneers of female progress need only wait for two or three generations to be- come proverbs for domestic industry and true womanliness. Miss Repplier’s English is terse and epigrammatic as usual, but she should remember that colloquialism is a dangerous instrument to play with. Ima- gine Andrew Lang’s using such a phrase as “By the time I got that far back” (p. 186)! A loose construction of which Miss Repplier is too fond is illustrated by ‘‘So old we shall have mastered’ (p. 185). In ‘“‘Lady Somer- set’ (p. 1381) we imagine that we meet Lady Henry Somerset in her customary American disguise. The Italians of To-Day. From the French of René Bazin. Translated by William Mar- chant. Henry Holt & Co. 1897. This book is not, as the title suggests, a complete study of contemporary Italians. It is just a group of sketches and notes of travel by an exceptionally clever observer; yet in its own class it is quite an ideal book for cultivated readers whose tastes are not particularly specialized. It contains four short articles, various in character and treatment, on North Italy, Rome and the Campagna, Naples, and a “‘corner of Sicily’ —this last mainly an account of an expedi- tion to Atna in eruption. Mr. Bazin writes in an easy, simple, off- hand style, with a Parisian’s true sense of measure, and never fails to be interesting. There is not a dull page in the whole book. With perfect tact the author passes from de- scription to dialogue, from dialogue to sta- tistics, from statistics to personal observa- tion and acute comment, never dwelling on any point so long as to weary the reader, yet never giving the impression of frivolity. Kindly sympathy, rare freedom from pre- judice, good judgment in the choice of sub- jects, are joined to a catholic interest in everything worthy of an educated curiosity. In the north of Italy he discusses literature and politics; in Rome he inquires into the history of the recent financial disasters and the ancient problem of the Roman Campa- gna; Naples suggests to him the appropriate subjects of pauperism and the “‘jettatura,” while the south of Italy brings up the diffi- cult question of underpaid labor and conse- quent emigration. His fairness and readi- ness to hear both sides of every question, and his patience in unearthing valuable in- formation, are everywhere conspicuous, while his powers of observation, and his delicacy in speaking of those Italians from whom or about whom he learned so much, are worthy of all praise. His own comments and reflections would lose too much by being quoted apart from the mass of facts upon which theyare based; but their judiciousness may be judged of by the following on Italy’s army and navy ex- penditures. ‘‘An armed Italy,’’ says the au- thor, ‘“‘an Italy which exhausts itself in armaments, is far from being of no ac- count; but an Italy frugal and careful would be a formidable Power.” We must allow ourselves also to give one specimen of Mr. Bazin’s humor. One of the great landowners of the Roman Campagna has been talking to him at a fashionable club, after a drive in that dangerous region, and assuring him that there has been great exaggeration as to the malaria. The author continues: “He stopped just here, without considering the connection of ideas. ‘Garcon,’ he cried, ‘a glass of vermouth and some quinine! and, waiter! a good deal of quinine!’ ’’ Mr. Bazin is not always impeccably accu- rate. When. for example, he tells us (p. 61) that ‘‘open any secular journal, the least re- ligious possible, and you will see in the almanac [read ‘calendar’] of the day, ‘Ave Maria, Morning 5h. 15, Ave Maria, Evening, bh. 22,’”’ he is falsely generalizing for all Italy from what he saw in one district, and that, too, in ignorance of the fact that what he quotes as an evidence of religiousness is merely an indirect way of announcing the hours of sunrise and sunset somewhere about the middle of March. Morecurious than such slips as this is the great multitude of blunders in the relatively little Italian quot- ed or used. This might well give a reader pause, were it not that French is so uni- versally spoken in Italy as to make it possi- ble for a traveller to know the country fair-
Page 23
vA bey Si seis ease Iai RRS Seta Aha Ree AINE TIPS Nov. 11, 1897] The Nation. 3883 ly well without being proficient in Italian. Here is a list, with corrections in brackets, for the use of readers who may not be Italian scholars. P. 11, mama (mamma); p. 18, spé- rito (the verse requires spirto); p. 20, Teatro dal (del) Verme; p. 36, Palazzo della Con- siglia (del Consiglio, but the proper name of that palace in Vicenza is “la Basilica Palla- diana’); p. 47, junta di vigilenza (giunta di vigilanza); p. 53, paese voldostani (poesie Valdostane); p. 117, vicotta (ricotta); p. 133, bonefica (bonifica); p. 183, passegiata (pas- seggiata); pp. 185, 191, 194, resanimento (ri- sanamento); p. 188, brasero (braciere); p. 189, donne di male affari (mal’affari); p. 197, lustroscarpe (lustrascarpe); p. 204, innoma- bile (innominabile); p. 215, bracciani (brac- cianti). On p. 172, in ‘“‘Fa la spia, ma fala bene,” the form fala may be dialectic for the Tuscan falla; but the translation, in- stead of “She plays the spy, but plays it well,”’ should be, ‘‘Play the spy, but play it well’’—which proverbial saying is one of several curious phrase-names quoted as giv- en by the herdsmen of the Campagna to the buffalo cows and their calves. On page 220, “tempo di Sicila (Sicilia), tempo femineo”’ means not ‘‘woman’s weather,’ but ‘‘femi- nine weather,” in allusion to the ‘‘mutabile semper femina.’’ On p. 205 Matilda Serao is called Mathilda Serrao, though the name is properly given in other places. The translator and the printers must share the responsibility for Solférino (Solferino), p. 20, 66; Rudini (Rudini), p. 26; Messenian (for a native of Messina), p. 72; consomme (consommé), Catana (Catania), p. 228; For- tune (for the proper name Fortuné), and a few other obvious misprints. The transla- tion is in the main remarkably good, though we have met with a few lapses. Thus, on p. 33, 4,350,000 tons of charcoal should, of course, be pit-coal; and p. 183, where the vines are said to “run over the ground on green and red arches,’ we should read “‘in’’ (French “en’’) for ‘‘on’’; the vines them- selves making the arches with their leaves and fruit. On p. 187 “‘a slice of infected air” should be merely “‘evil-smelling’”’ or ‘‘malo- dorous”’ air—that being the ordinary mean- ing of the French word infect. Mr. Mar- chant misuses the rare and technical word “quiritarian” in the sense of ‘‘belonging to the Quirites,” and falls into the common error of making Italians use ‘‘Signor’’ (not followed by a proper name) instead of “Signore,’’ which alone is correct as a form of address. The book has a sufficient index and will well repay a perusal. The Scholar and the State, and Other Ora- tions and Addresses. By Henry Codman Potter, D.D., LL.D., Bishop of New York. The Century Co. 1897. Bishop Potter modestly tells us that the publication of this volume was not due to any suggestion of his; but he need not feel that such a suggestion would have been presumptuous. The papers have all a strong, clear tone that will be everywhere welcome and helpful. They are addressed in some cases to the clergy, but in the main they appeal to all conscientious citizens, and their burden is the increasing importance of our | public duties. Such appeals are easily made | in general terms, in which case they are equally inoffensive and_ ineffective. To frame them so that particular acts shall be advised without arousing party spirit. is a difficult task; but Bishop Potter knows how to be outspoken without being arrogant, and how to be earnest and tactful at the same time. “There are two dangers to which religious teachers, or those holding ecclesiastical of- fice, are liable,’’ Bishop Potter observes in his preface. One is a danger of omission, the other of commission. Some of the clergy abstain from all active intervention in the secular life of the community; others ob- trude themselves in such a way as to seem to forget that, “in its ‘highest aspect, the Kingdom of their Master is not of this world.’"” Educated men in general are prone to sin in the former way, and perhaps the second error is often a sign of a lack of culture. But there is a middle course, well described: by Bishop Potter in the paper en- titled ‘“‘The Scholar and the State,’’ which is not so impracticable, perhaps, as our educated class is inclined to suppose. We may call it the elevation of public opinion by constant appeals to lofty motives. Men are so constituted as to approve virtues that they cannot bring themselves to practise, and the power of the most successful un- principled politicians may be undermined by the steady influence of purer standards. It is slow work to educate a whole people, but we have the work to do, and such ex- hortations as Bishop Potter's should cheer the faint-hearted. Siam on the Meinam. By Maxwell Sommer- ville. Philadelphia: Lippincott. 1897. We judge from the preface of the above work that the writer intended it to be “a popular notice” for the use of travellers in Siam. With obvious lack of sympathy for this idea, the publishers have given us a volume with such heavy paper and binding that it is a weariness to the hands, and would increase the charge for overweight in a trunk, but it would look well as a “gift book”’ on the parlor table, where its pretty yellow covers would not show the dust. Those who read it through will find that they can do so in a few hours. The larger half of the book consists of a hasty descrip- tion of what the author saw in Bangkok and farther up the river; there are nine pages on the hotel, a page and a half on the museum, and so on; then follows a chapter on Buddhism, and then three stories “‘as an original means of illustrating phases in Siamese life and customs combined with the history of the Meinam and of the peo- ple of the northern province.” The first and only important one of these, where the scene is laid in the seventeenth century, is illustrated by photographs (!) of the princi- pal characters. The other two together do not fill ten largely printed pages or illus- trate anything at all. As for the style, though occasionally vivid, it is stilted and irritating, besides being confused and at times ungrammatical. We should not have expected, at the present day, a professor in a well-known Northern university to speak of a theatre as “a tem- ple, where, through Thespian sources, men are trying to obtain all the enjoyment pos- sible.” Is it to show that he knows the French words for library and umbrella that | Prof. Sommerville inserts them in a work on Siam? If his largest dictionary gives him authority for “consentaneity,” “inquietude,” “he was desolate,” and “her potential pa- rents,” is that why he puts them in his “popular notice’? Finally, we must pro- . + test against the taste which inserts in such a book two photographs of a “dead body being eaten by vultures”; the second, par- ticularly, is disgusting. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Arnold, Sarah L., and Gilbert C. B. Stepping- Stones to Literature. A First Reader. A Se cond Reader. Boston: Silver, Burdett & Co Barr, Mrs. Amelia FE The King’s Highway Dodd, Mead & Co. $1.25 r Blackmore, R. D. Dartel. Dodd, Mead & Co $1.75. Blanchan, Neltje. Bird Neighbors. Fifty Colored Plates. Doubleday & McClure Go. $2 Brewer, D. The Pew to the Pulpit. F. H Revell Co. 5c. Bromby, C. H. Dante's A Question of the Water and of the Land. London: David Nutt Buckley, Rev. J. M. A History of Methodism in the United States. 2 vols. Harpers $5 ury, R. G. The Philetua of Plato. Cambridge: University Press; New York: Macmillan. $3 Chambers, R. W. Lorraine: A Ronmace. Harpers 1.25. Chatfleld-Taylor, H. C. The Vice of Fools, Chi eago: H. 8. Stone & Co. Charleton, R. J. Nethertyke: A Tale of the “‘Forty-Five."" Edward Arnold. $1.50 Clough, Blanche A A Memoir of Anne Jemima Clough. Edward Arnold. §3.50 Cowley, A. E., and Neubauer, Ad. Beclestastious XXXIX. 15, to XLIX. 11 Translated from the Original Hebrew. Oxford: Clarendon Press: New York: H. Frowde Crawford, F. M. Corleone. 2 vols Macmillan Davenport, W. E. Poetical Sermons, tncluding the Ballad of Plymouth Cbharch Putname SO Edgren, Prof. H. Hjalmar. A Rrief Itallan Gram mar. W. R. Jenkins. 0c. Gardiner, S. R. History of the Commonwealth and Protectorate, 1649-1680. Vol. il 11-10 Longmans, Green & Co. §7 Howard, Rlanche W Seven on the Highwar Roston: Houghton, Miffin & Co. $1.25 : Hunt, Violet. Unktet. Unkind! Harpers. $1 35 Huntington, Archer M. Poem of the Cid. Text Reprinted from the Madrid MS. Vol. I. Put names. $25 Huntington, Faye. His Firat Charge Roston Lothrop Publishing Co. $1.25 Hurl), Estelle M @ Madonna in Art. Roston . C, Page & Co Julleville, Prof. L. P. de. Histoire de la Langue et de la Littérature Francaise. Tome IV. tix septidéme Siecle. Premiére Partie. (1401-1680 ) Paris: A. Colin & Cle Logeas. Prof. Emile. The Early Life of William ordeworth. 1770-1788. Seribmere. £8 Let Us Follow Him, and Other Stortes. Ry the Author of ‘Quo Vadis." R. F. Fenno & Co. 31.25 Mann. Mary B. The Cedar Star. R. FP. Fenno & Co. $1.25. Marchesi, Mathilde. Marchest and Music: Pas sages from the Life of a Famous Singing-Teach- er. Harpers. 2.50 Mason, A. . Lawrence Clavering Dodd, Mead & Co. $1.25 Mayer, Hy. The Autobiography of a Monkey. RK H. Russell. $1.35 McCarthy, Justin H. The French Revolution. Vo! ll. Harpers. $1.50 Moorman, F. W. Fletcher's The Faithful Shep herdess. [Temple Dramatists.] London: Dent; New York: Macmillan. 45¢ Murray, J. A A New English Dictionary Folsty—Frankish. (Vol. IV.) Oxford: Clarendon Press; New York: H. Frowde Ogilvie, J. N. The Presbyterian Churches. F. H Revell Co. 40 Perce, W. R. Genesis and Modern Science. James Pott & Co $1.50 Perry, Prof. Blias. “Little Masterpieces"’ of Haw- thorne and Irving. Doubleday & McClure Co Peters, Rev. J. P es or, Explorations and Adventures on the uphrates rol 1. Put nams. $2.50 Seitz, J. A The Colloqnr: Conversations about the Order of Things and Final Good. Putnams $1.75 Stearns, F. P. Modern English Prose Writers Putnams. $1.50 Stokoe. Rev. T. H Old Testament History for Schools Part Ill Oxford: Clarendon Press; New York: H_ Frowde Tomlinson. FE. T. Guarding the Rorder. [War of 1812 series.} Boston: Lee & Chopard. $1.50. Train. Elizabeth P. A Queen of Hearts. Phila- delphia: J. B. Léppincett Co. $1.25 Trask. Mrs. Katrina. Jonn Leighton. jr. Harpers 1.25. Toon Panl Throngh the Invisible: A Love Story. Continental Publishing Co. TSe¢ Upton. Florence K. Little Hearts. George Rout- edge & Sons Waller, Prof A. D Animal Electricity. Long- mans, Green & Co, $1.50 Welle H. G. The Invisible Man: A Grotesque Romance. Edward Amold, 75c White. Prof. Greenongh. Memoir of the Right Reverend Nicholas Hammer Cobbs, Bishop of Alabama. James Pott & Co. $1 Whitehouse. H. R. The Sacrifice of a Throne: An Acconnt of Amadens of Spain. Bonnell, Silver & Ca %. Wilkins. Mary E. Once Upon a_ Time. and Other »Child-Verses. Boston: Lothrop Publishing Co. $1. Wilkinson, W. C The Epic of Paul. Funk & Wagnalls Co. $2 Willson, Reckles. The Tenth Island: Being Some Account of Newfoundland. London: Grant Rich- Winmorth, Freda. The Epic of Sounds. An Ele- mentary Interpretation of Wagner's Nibelungen Ring. Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott Co. $1.25. Woodward. G. A. Verse Vagaries. Buffalo: Cham- berlin Press. Wundt, Prof. Wilhelm. The Facts of. the Moral Tite London: Sonnenschein; New York: Mac- millan. .
Page 24
384 The Nation. [Vol. 65, No. 1689 HENRY HOLT & CO., NEW YORK AND CHICAGO, HAVE JUST PUBLISHED: SAINTE-BEUVE: SEVEN OF THE CAUSERIES DU LUNDI. Edited by Prof. G.M. Harper of Princeton. li+ 176 pp. 16mo, 75c net. CONTENTS: Qu’est-ce qu’un Classique, Grande ue de la Prose, Pen:ées de Pascal, La Fontaine, Les Mé- moire de Saint Simon, Madame de Maintenon, La Duehesse de Bourgogne. ANOTHE? BOOK EDITED BY PROF HARPER. HUGO’S HERNANI. xli+126 pp. 12mo, 70c. net. Prof. E. F. Wheeler of Northwestern Universtiy, Evanston, lll: “t have never seen a clearer presenta i of the points needed iu a critical study of ths play PREVIOUSLY PUBLISHED. BEVIER’S FRENCH GRAMMAR. With exercises by THomas Loaig. 341 pp. 12mo. $1.00 net. Now being used by classes in Johns Hopkins, University of Michigan, Cornelt, etc. ete. NEW BOOKS. Anarchism. A Criticism and History of the Anarchist Theory. By E. V. ZENKER. 12mo, $1.50. “The fullest and best account of anarchism ever published. . . . A most powerful and trenchant criticism.’’—[London Book Gazette. The American College in American Life. By CHARLES F, THWING, President of West- ern Reserve University, author of ‘‘Ame- rican Colleges,” etc. 12mo, gilt top, $1.50 Chief Contents: Its Increasing Power—Certain Great Results—Its Influence over and through In- dividuals—Its Influence Illustrated in the Three Oldest Colleges—Certain Adjustments of Its Ethi- cal and Religious Forces to its Intellectual—The ar emcee Cost of its Education—Its Power in the “uture, American Ideals, And Other Essays, Social and Political. By THEODORE ROOSEVELT, author of ‘‘ The Harvard, Winning of the West,” etc. 12mo, gilt top, $1 50 CHIEF CONTENTS:—American Ideals—True Americanism—The Manly Virtues and Practical Politics—The College Graduate and Public Life— Phases of State Legislation—Machine Politics in New York City — Administering the New York Police Foree—The Monroe Doctrine—Social Evolu- tion—The Law of Civilization and Decay. “These papers are of sterling merit, and well worthy of perusal. . . . Mr. Roosevelt writes in a direct and forcible manner, and shows a broad and intelligent comprehension of the attitude of the citizen towards the problem of municipal gov- ernment.’’—[Detroit Free Press. G.P. PUTNAM’S SONS 27 & 29 West 23d St., New York. © Yale Mixture. A GENTLEMAN’S SMOKE. You won’t know the luxury of Pipe-Smoking until you use Yale Mixture. A two-oz. trial package, postpaid, for 25 cts. MARBURG BROS., ) The American Tobacco Co., Successor, Baltimore, Md. LOLOL LOL LOD LI I Id ed ded ed ed JUST READY. BY THE EDITOR OF *LITERATURE.”’ The New Fiction: AND OTHER Essays ON LITERARY SUBJECTS. By H. D. TRarLu, author of ‘‘ The New Lucian,” ‘‘The Life of Sir John Frank- lin,” etc. 1 vol., crown 8vo, $2 00. “Mr. Traill’s volume of criticisms is ten times more entertaining to any one who cares about literature than ninety | vd cent. of moderately successful novels.” —Paui Mau Gazette. Shakspere The Plays and Poems of William Shakspere. In one volume. Set in large, new type, and printed on thin opaque Bible paper. Holiday Edition. Limp morocco, red un- der gold, $5.00; Victorian levant, polished, $7.50. The Finest One-Volume Edition of Shakspere made. This unique edition of Shakspere’s Works in fine bindings oniy, will be welcomed everywhere. Ite dis- tinetive features are clear cut, new type, large and reatable, printed on Bible paper, reducing the weight and bulk of the work.and making it a volume that = be ; ro without fatigue either on the part of eye or hand. FIFTEENTH EDITION, Death—and Afterwards With Portrait. By Sir Epwin ARNOLD. Re- printed by authority. Cloth, 60 cents. “ The matchless literary touch of Sir Edwin Arnold er this essay on every page.”—The Independent, Remit by check, stamps, or money order. New Amsterdam Book Co. Publishers of High-class Literature, 156 5TH AVE.,COR. 20TH STREET, N, Y. CITY. Some Colonial Homesteads And Their Stories. By MARION HARLAND. With 86 Illustra- tions. 8vo, gilt top, $3.00. The author of ‘‘Some Colonial Homesteads and Their Stories’ has studied patiently and lovingly the traditions and historical associations that clus- ter about the old family estates founded by notable colonists of the original thirteen States. How rich and varied is this lore none can comprehend who have not, like her, visited the storied homes in per- son and bad access to the family archives of each. Every house hasits romance. The loves, the feuds, the tempers, the sports, and the tragedies revealed by such research are here interwoven with descrip- tions of the houses as we may see them rege and faithful pen- pictures of the worthies who built and lived in them when the history of our country was in making. The book is charmingly written, and is embellish- ed by a large number of illustrations, very care- fully selected and engraved. Among the home- steads presented are: Brandon, Westover, Shirley, Marshall House, Cliveden (Chew House), Morris House, Van Cortlandt Manor House, Oak Hill (The Home of the Livingstons), Philipse Manor House, Jume! House (Fort Washington), Smith House (Sha- ron, Conn.), Pierce Homestead, Parson Williams's House, Varina (Pocahontas), Jamestown, and Wil- liamsburg. G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS, 27 & 29 W. 23d St., N.Y. BOOKS When wine, | pease ask for AT Whenever you need . book, ress Mr. Grant. LIBERAL — mates books ——_ ~~ a assortment o: D ISCOUNTS one logues and special slips of books at reduced prices, sent for 10-cent stamp. F. E. GRANT, Books, 23 West 42d St., . . . New York. Mention this advertisement and receive a discount, Dr. Jaeger’s SANATORY UNDERWEAR AS USED BY Dr. Nansen on his famous Arctic sledge journey. “The result of all this experimenting was that I made up my mind to keep to my woollen clothes, which would give free outlet to the perspiration. Jo- hansen followed my example, and on the upper part of our bodies we each had two Jaeger Undershirts next the skin, etc., etc.”—“ Farthest North,” Vol. IL, p. 115. This Applies to You. Jaeger Underwear allows the skin to breathe freely, at the same time absorbing its exhala- tions, leaving the body dry and warm. Gives the greatest warmth with the least weight. Send for Illustrated Catalogue, Main Retail Store: Branches: 16 WEST 23D ST., | 166 Broadway, New York. 248 W. 125th St Mr. Lang’s New Series of Selections from the Poets. FIRST VOLUME JUST READY. WORDSWORTH. Edited by ANDREW LANG. With Photogravure Frontispiece of Rydal Mount, 16 Illustrations, and numerous Initial Lettera by Alfred Parsons, A.R.A. Crown 8vo, cloth extra, gilt edges, $2.00. Sold by Booksellers. Sent, postpaid, by LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., g1-93 Fifth Avenue, New York. Second Edition PRIVATE LIBRARY WHAT WE DO KNOW WHAT WE DON’T KNOW WHAT WE OUGHT TO KNOW ABOUTL OUR BOOKS BY ARTHUR L. HUMPHREYS 1 Vol., Crown Quarto, Cloth, Uncut, $1.50 J. W. BOUTON (And all Booksellers). 10 West 2:Tta S8St., NEw YORK Now Ready French and German BOOKS. The Latest French and German Books Are promptly imported and kept for sale. All Standard Works continually in Stock, Write for New List of Late Fiction. BRENTANO’S, 31 Union Square, New York. LIBRARIES. Library Catalogue Mailed Free. LISTS PRICED GRATIS. THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO., Wholesele Books, 5 & 7 East 16th St., New York,