The Nation 1897-11-04: Vol 65 Iss 1688
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
The Nation
oe THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 4, 1897. , TU orm CENTS.
VOL. LXV—NO. 1688. - SCRIBNERS’ NEWEST BOOKS OLD CREOLE DAYS. | By GEORGE W. CABLE With 8 full-page Illustrations and 14 head and tail pieces by ALBERT HERTER, all reproduced in photogravure, and with an original cover design by the same artist. Svo, $6.00. A few copies still left of the Special Limited Edition on Japan paper. Each $12.00 net. || This edition of Mr. Cable's masterpiece is a most remarkable achievement. Mr. Herter’s illustrations, while charmingly in key with the stories. 4 are exquisite in their firmness, grace, and feeling. Indeed, they have probably never been equalled in these qualities by any American illustrator 4 The volume. with its wide margins, fine paper, and beautiful printing, really marks an epoch in the act of bookmaking on this side of the water, and forms an ideal gift-book. It is as unique in its mechanical perfection as the stories themselves are in our literature. q THE FIRST CHRISTMAS TREE. | By HENRY VAN DYKE : With full-page illustrations by Howarp PyLs, reproduced in photogravure, decorative borders, illuminated title, and a striking cover design. S8vo, $1 50. Dr. Van Dyke is here in his happiest vein, for his keen feeling for nature and his deep religious sense have combined to render this story, dealing cn hate Penn E | as it does with the transition to Christianity from primitive savagery, vivid and moving in the extreme. The illustrations by Mr. Howarnt Pyle are 4 noteworthy examples of that artist's sterling and satisfactory work, and of his ability, by conscientious attention to minutia, to depict realistically : scenes of a bygone age. > i SECOND EDITION NOW READY OF THIS COUNTRY OF OURS. _ By BENJAMIN HARRISON, Bx-President of the United States 12mo, $1.50. “The purpose of the book is to give a better knowledge of things that have been too near and familiar to be well known. I hope it may also tend to promote an intell:gent patriotism and a faithful discharge of the duties of citizenship.’'—AvTuor’s Prerace i ConTENTS: The Constitution—The Congress—The President—The State Department—The Treasury Department— Departments of g War and Justice—The Post Office Department—The Navy Department—Departments of the Interior and Agriculture—Independent q | Boards and Commissions--The Judiciary. “ Nowhere could there be found a volume better adapted to popular uses than this compendium of one of the wisest of our Presidents... . ‘With an | ardent love forour country’ he approaches his task, and the tone of his book is, forall his business-like handling of business matters, pecullarty patriotic. | sane. and especially young Americans, will find abundant timely instruction in these pages... . These chapters . . . possess a permanent value.” —New ork Tribu e. 4 | SONG BIRDS AND WATERFOWL. TWO VOLUMES IN THE CAMEO EDITION. e | By H. E. Parknurst. With 18 full-page illustrations by Louis By HENRY VAN DYKE. Agassiz Fuertes. 12mo, $1.50 net, Each with frontispiece etching, attractively bound in green and | The nies hae shanty shown in ~ Bird's Calenian” ae, the gold, 16mo, $1.23. | amateur ornithologist need not go far afield to pursue his study of our | Lietgte Wi ‘ ispiece b — : —— beh — bye he tells of the land and water rt eat | pina illustrations, which are fresh evidences of this artist’s great pth et ot hf et pT ny A wag on is The Poetry of Tennyson. With an etched portrait by Gustav Mercter. | THE STEVENSON SONG BOOK. Epucunp Crarence Stepman has declared of this work: , ee : “oN . Verses from ‘A Child’s Garden,” by RoBperT Lovis STEVENSON; | jying coe eee the suth oF bas added an Introduction and | with music by various composers. (A companion volume to | a thoughtful essay on “In Memoriam. the ‘* Field-de Koven Song Book ”’ published last year.) Large 4 | 8vo, $2.00. MRS. KNOLLYS, AND OTHER STORIES. ‘* A handsome volume containing twenty of Stevenson’s most lyrical } By F. J. Strwson (J. S. of Dale”). Author of ‘‘Guerndale,” songs. set to music by such composers as Reginald de Koven, Dr. C. Vil- ‘First Harvests,” ‘‘King Noanett,” etc. 12mo, $1.50. I] liers Stanford, W. W. Gilchrist, Homer N. Bartlett, C. B. Hawley, Arthur There ic & flavor about Mr. Gtimece'’s clerics thet teal his ows. Foote, and C. W. Chadwick. " ~ ; 4 1} : , ’ = “ First Harvests,”’ that fascinating tale of ‘‘ The Residuary Legatee,”’ with || Already Published. The Field-de Koven Song Book. Verses by EUGENE | jts inimitable desoument, “Querndale,” “ The Crime of Henry Vane,”
1} Firetp. Music by Reatnacp peg Koven and others. Large Svo, $2.00. “In the Three Zones."* ete., could have been written by no one but “J. 8S. 1] of Dale,” and the present volume contains some of his best work, includ- |] ST. IVES ing two new stories. Being the Adventures of a French Prisoner in England. (Se- TWO NEW VOLUMES IN THE “IVORY SERIES.” cond Edition.) By RoBEert LOUIS STEVENSON. 12mo, $1.50. “St, Ives is a tale of action in the author's most buoyant style, and | Literary Love Letters and Other Stories. By Ronert HER-
|| there is a vigor yet light-heartedness, a continuous grasp of the interest RICK, author of .** The Man Who Wins.” 16mo, 75 cents. | and sympathy throughout, which is truly fascinating. Mr. Herrick’s present volume, ormaning ng age stories, ex _— E 1} . abundantly the qualities which have already won him distinction is | THE TORMENTOR. stories are potable alike for their admirable literary quality and their | By BENJAMIN Swirt. 12mo, $1.50, vivid presentation of the subtler phases ef mind and character. | A new and equally dramatic story by the author of ‘* Nancy Noon.” A ROMANCE IN TRANSIT. | Fifth Edition, Nancy Noon, 12mo, $1.50. By FRaNncts LYNDE. 16mo, 75 cents. AMERICAN NOBILITY. 4 most clever and entertaining railway story of a railway man, who ; knows from the inside all the conditions whereof he writes By PIERRE DE CouLevain. A Novel. 12mo, $1.50.
1 The burning question of ‘international’ marriages has never been TAKEN BY SIEGE. [f| SPRee ee ay Seren ee Eene eeeye A Novel. By Jeannette L. Gruper, Editor of The Critic. 12 $1.25. | SELECTED POEMS. on i Miss Gilder, the well-known editor of The Oritic. has here written a | By GeorGE MEREDITH. Arranged by the author and including | captivating love story. The scene is laid in New York City, and, the all his most popular works. With portrait. 12mo, #1.75. principal character being connected with The Dawn, while the heroine is + an opera singer, the book contains ee and faithful stage. “Not since Shakespeare has England produced a man with so extraordi wee studies of life in a newspaper office and upon nary a gift of poetic expression.”"—J. Zangwili, in Pall Mali Magazine. CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS, 153-157 Fifth Avenue, New York
a eee ae es
Page 2
wee os The adbvia. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science, and Art. FOUNDED 1865 ‘Entered at the New York City Post-Office as second- class mail-matter |
CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. nn ones en keke dbndenvess cnsnsccssenssscsscccenae 347 EDITORIAL ARTICLES; ae er 350 Ex-Minister Taylor Om Cuba........ccccsccsccccccee 350 ER Sie bnicn Ga ceeks* n00d 5.00 ssb0s5%senssenek 851 SPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE: The Scandinavian Exhibition at Stockholm...... 852 Fagnies’s Father Joseph .....cccesscccsccccccccsces 853 CORRESPONDENCE: High School and College. BE BUNT. occrcvccspeccves Not German, but American.. ; PE I EIIOOD 6.0 6icc~<ccctoasesenscesedvestssve 355
Book REVIEWS: Bacon’s American Christianity are
Land Power and Sea Power...............eeees.e0e 360 BPEPG GU THURGOOD 2... ,00005s0cceess ssoceecese 361 Studies in Psychical Research..................... 62 Sweet Revenge.—Hell fer Sartain.—From the Land OF The BROW POAPiS..........ccosccsccceeces 363 The Brontés: Fact and Fiction....................5 363 I TE IE 5 oes oink d sckccapsevthesasdvaseesd 364
TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION, Three Dollars per year, in advance, postpaid, to any part of the United States or Canada; to foreign countries comprised in the Postal Union, $4.00. The date when the subscription expires is on the Address-Label of each paper, the change of which to a subsequent date becomes a receipt for remittance. No other receipt is sent unless requested. Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter, or by cheek, express order, or postal order, payable to “Publisher of the Nation.” When a change of address is desired, both the old and new addresses should be given. Address THE NATION, Box 794, New York. Publication Office, 208 Broadway.
TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Fifteen cents per agate line, each insertion, 14lines to the inch. Twenty per cent. advance for choice of page, top of column, or cuts. Cuts are not inserted on the first page. . A column, $20 each insertion; with choice of page. 24. A page, $60 each insertion; front-cover page, $80. Advertisements must be acceptable in every respect, Copy received until Tuesday, 5 p. M.
DISCOUNTS. E— G CNBOTRONS. ccccsesosecvcessevccsacs 5 per cent. 8 “ ia a § i 12 o 24 “ ; 15° $6 89 ved 20 os 52 ” 25 - AMOUNT— = w ithin A VOATceeeceeeressereeeeeee 10 per cent. « “ i ssesesseeceenmneabane Tie 750 = MEO CO TT 20 - 1,000 si M LSaeea ee kbbahe ke bannael 25 vi 1,500 ve “ os bephensheuebe osscee OO - 2 000 a eT ee eR 833% “* The NATION is sent free to those who advertise in it as long as the advertisement continues. The EDITION of the Nation this week is 9,200 copies. The Subscription List is always open to the inspection of advertisers. *,* Copies of the NATION may be procured in Paris at Brentano’s, 17 Avenue de l’Opéra, oe in — of B. F. Stevens, 4 Trafalgar quare, American Newspaper Agency, 15 Kin William Street, Strand, W. — . London agent for advertisements, R.J. Bush,
Fleet Street, E. C. _The N ation. [Vol. 65, No. 1688
I: “a adintal CALIFORNIA, Los Angeles, West 23d St ARLBOROUGH SCHOOL for GIRLS. LVL 7 Mrs. GEORGE A. CASWELL, Principal. — Mary LAND, Baltimore, cor. Carey and Lanvale Sts, HAFTESBURY COLLEGE OF EX- pression.—Six months’ session. Enrolment the Ist of each month, Winter term Nov. to April, inclusive. Handsome 1!) lustrated catalogue. Miss ALIC E May You SE, President. — MARYLAND, Baltimore, 122 and 124 W. Franklin St, fies. FEWORTH BOARDING and DAY School for mite. m4 year will begin September 23, 1897. Mrs ?, LEFEBVRE, Principal. Miss A b: HUNTLEY, Associate Principal
MARYLAND, Catonsville. : 3 TIMOTHY'S SCHOOL for Girls re- opens September 23, 1896. Prepares for College. Sends of School: Miss M. C. CARTER, Miss S. R. CARTER
Massacnuserts, & Boston OSTON UNIVERSITY Law School. Address the Dean, EpMunp H. BENNETT, LL.D.
~ MASSACHUSETTS, Concord, ONCORD SCHOOL. Prepares for College, Scientific School, and Busi- ness. Individualinstruction Elementary classes. Non sectarian. JaMES S. GARLAND, Principal.
MASSACHUSETTS Duxbury OWDER POINT SCHOOL. — Prepares for Scientific School, College, or business. Indi- vidual teaching. Elementary classes for young boys Home and outdoor life. F. B. Knapp, S.B. (M.I T.).
New York City, 126 and 128 East 17th Street. Uptown Piaro School, 239 Lenox Avenue HE NATIONAL CONSERVATORY OF MUSIC OF AMERICA.—Dr. Antonin Dvorak, Director. Admission ¢aily Retad parrioulars, address ‘Ske RETARY. ‘New YorK City, 537 riftn Ave enue. MM: SS M. D. HUGER Boarding and Day School for Girls.
NEW YORK, Utica. RS PIATT’'S SCHOOL FOR GIRLS. —The next school year begins Thursday, Septem- er 23, 1897. Applications should be made early. Outo, Cincinnati, 2643 Bellevue Ave, Mt. Auburn. ISS LUPTON’S SCHOOL reopened Sept. 29. Thorough preparation is given for college. The number of boarding pupils is limited, Circulars are sent on application.
Onto, Cincinnati. V TSS ARMSTRONG’S SCHOOL FOR i Girls, Liddesdale Place, Avondale. Family limit- ed. Circulars sent on application. sa ‘PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, Chestnut Hill. RS. COMEG YS’ AND MISS BELL’S BOARDING AND DAY SCHOOL FOR GIRLS will reopen October 1. Students prepared forcollege.
FRANCE, Paris. T. MARGARET’S FRENCH AND English School for Girls. Household French, with American oversight. Pupils met at Havre or Cher- bourg. Address Miss AcLy, 50 Avenue d’Jéna. ISS ANABLE’S Boarding and Day School fcr Girls. Established in 1848. Circular pA application. | Cpensteps. 27.1350 Pine St., Phila., Pa.
School of Drawing and Painting, MUSEUM OF FINE ARTS, Copley Square, Boston, Mass. THE TWENTY-SECOND YEAR NCW OPEN. Inetraction in drawing from the cast — from life, age and decorative design, and also -. ‘artiste anatomy and pers ctive. Principal F. W. Benso . Se reel, and Paip: Viale (Drawing and. Painting) Wil- liam Stone oy ae’ Design), E. A _ oe (Anatomy), and A. K. Cross (Perspective). Pupils are allowed the free use of the galleries of the Museum. For circulars giving detailed informa- tion, address MISS ELIZABETH LOMBARD, Manager. CEDARCROFT SCHOOL. In the Higtionte 3 the Hudson. Number limited to ten. Combines home life with careful indi- vee trainin, a . HUSE, M.A., Principal, Cornwall, N. Y. ST. AGNES SCHOOL Under the poy of Bishop Doane. Prepara- tion for all Col ial Studies and Courses of College hoe Special 8 advanta, in music and Alb do a ELLEN W. BOYD, Prin., any, THE CAMBRIDGE SCHOOL. A Select School for Girls. Comforts of Home. Mr. ARTHUR GILMAN is the Director. CAMBRIDGE, MASS.
f:ducational. Western Reserve University Includes ADE. SERY COLLEGE (for men); COL- LEGE FOR WOMEN; GRADUATE SCHOOL FOR MEN AND WOMEN. degrees of A.M., Ph.D.; LAW SCHOOL (three years); MEDICAL SCHOOL (four years): DENTAL SCHOOL (three years). CHARLES F. THWING, President. Cleveland, O.
School Agencies. HE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES. EVERETT O. Fisk & Co., Proprietors. 4 Ashburton Place, Boston 1242 12th St., Washington. 70 Fifth Ave., New York. 44 Cent. Bdg , Minneapolis 378 Wabash Ave., Chicago. 730 C ooper dg., Denver. a King St., ‘Toronto. 525 came" n Bk. .Los Angeles LBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY. 24 State St., Albany, N. Y.—Provides schools of all grades with competent teachers. Assists teachers in obtaining positions. HARLAN P. FRENCH, Manager.
R COLLEGE EOS TIONS "ES Apply to ALBERT & y is eae Building, Chicago.
CGHERMERHORN’S TEACHERS Agency. Oldest and best known in the U.S Established 1855. 3 E. 14th St., N. ¥.
Teachers, ete. F pd AN IDEAL WINTER CLIMATE, a home (and tuition also if desired) for three or four young ladies under the age of seventeen. The house is near Kenilworth Inn, and convenient to Asheville and Biltmore. References exchanged. Address Box 861, Bitnore, Buncombe Co , North Carolina. 1D XPERIENCED TEACHER, Graduate _z of Vienna University, desires position as tutor. Prepares for any college. Also French and German aeteny. Highest eereremoes. L. V.C, care Hatton.
(™ ARLES W. STONE, Tutor Son Har- vard, 68 Chestnut Street, Boston.
Tours. EUROPEAN WINTER RESORT. INNSBRUCK, TYROL, AUSTRIA. 1,900 feet above the sea, with dry, bracing climate. CENTRE FOR SLEIGHING EXCURSIONS. Fine University Hospital, etc. HOTEL TIROL. .Open all the year. CARL LANDSEE, Proprietor. Large, airy, sunny rooms; modern conveniences; superior cul- sine. Reduced rates in winter. Best references. Illus trated pamphlets sent on application. ~ BUROPEAN BICYCLE TOUR. | Allexpenses. 70 days. $420. C. H. SMITH, 218 Woodward Avenue, Detroit, Mich. MIND CULTURE —how to think, read, study and ob- serve —an idea-systematizer — the greatest work of modern times— WHEREWITHAL It is called a “seven- word, seven-minute method of education, ” has “the beauty of sim- plicity.” One prominent instructor says, “It’s 400 years ahead of time.” New ideas—none of the hackneyed, confusing present day methods. Applying to any conceivé able ques- tion from every conceivable point of view. Citizens’ edition, handsomely bound, $1.00. Descriptive circ ular free. School edition, reduced price in quantities. THE WHEREWITHAL BOOK co., Bourse Building. Philadelphia, Pa.
TRADE MARK REGISTENEDD
ee ee ee
j $ @ $ Pf i sbi s ari Cre PRR RAE Ee
Page 3
PACER BE, tebe REY MMOS AAO DIP era. © ak ied dae ca Ni Se Seleabpsnacnataenasae ls ‘ € Nov. 4 ! 1897) The Nation. NOW READY The November Book-Buyer TEN CENTS The Reader and the Novelist. Hamerton’s ** Quest of Happiness.” Broadway in Worcestershire. A Tragedy of Torment, The Author of ‘‘ The Tormentor.”’ Also numerous other illustrations. Hamilton W. Mabie, CONTENTS INCLUDE: A NEW PORTRAIT OF THACKERAY........ An Essay......... A Review.... Illustrated. pee A Review of ‘‘ The Tormentor”’. Wm. With Portrait A Bibliography of Nathaniel Hawthorne. Ernest Peixotto and His Work. Illustrated... .... James B. Carrington The Literary News in England. Iilustrated............. J. M. Bulloch IRN Ge BN ooo os crew cass aseeiawsmnricveennsnictes E. D. North The Rambler: Literary News and Comment. Henrik Ibsen, H. G. Wells, Gelett Burgess, Signed Reviews of New Books, by Louise Imogen Guiney, Brand Frank Dempster Sherman, M, A. De Wolfe Howe, Richard Burton, Mary Tracy Earle, pawedtes Frontispiece Marguerite Merington BE. lL. Burlingame Gilder Lyon Phe Ips We nleu Jeannette R. M. Part Il....... G M. Williamson With Portraits of Mark Twain, Edward Potthast, and others. r Matthews, Nathan Haskell Dole, and others. * ON ALL NEWS STANDS CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS, Publishers APPLETON’ S Popular Science Monthly. NOVEMBER, 1897. Semon’s Scientific Researches Prof. E. P. Evans. Illustrated. An account of Dr. Semon’s exhaustive study of the natural history of this strangely isolated conti nent, of especial interest because of the occurrence there of living specimens of mammals, birds, fishes, and reptiles, which are found elsewhere only as fossils. The British Asso:iation at Toronto. S. MARTIN. A general account of this important event, in- cluding descriptions of the personalities of some of the many illustrious men who attended, and acom- parison of the tone of this gathering of scientists and that of our own scientific association. Principles of Taxation.—The Existing Methods of faxation. Hon. Davip A. WELLs. Consists mainly of a consideration of the history and present status of the taxation of personal prop- erty, showing the way in which it encourages crime, and in the end defeats its own purpose. Archeology and the Antiquity of Man. Sir J. Evass, President B A. A. 8S. for 1897-98, His address at the Toronto meeting of the British in Australia. Prof. D. THREE NEW BOOKS! A GIFT BOOK FOR AMATEUR PHOTOGRAPHERS, Sunlight and Shadow. Edited by W. IL. Lixcotn Apams. Illustrated by more than 100 exquisite Half Tones from Orig: nal Photographs from Nature. 4to, cloth, deco- rated, full gilt, in a box, $2.50. The season's most useful and beautiful book for those who use cameras. To aid the reader to advance in pictorial photography, the foremost artists treat the following subjects: The Choice of Subject, Land- scape Without Figures, Landscape With Figures, Poregrounds, The Sky, Outdoor Portraits and Groups, The Hand Camera, Instantaneous Photo- graphy, Winter Photography, Marines, Photo graphy at —— Lighting in P.rtraiture Photo- graphing Children, Artin Grouping. The abun dant illustrations are very beautiful examples of the perfection which has been reached in making and printing from half-tone plates A Colonial Witch. Being a Study of the Black Art in the Colony of Connecticut. By Frank Samvect CHIvp, author of “An Old New England jown,” ** The Colonial Parson of New England,” ete. 12mo, cloth, gilt top. $1.23 The author ts a ripe scholar in colonial history, and has gi iven special a to the psycholo e of the witchcraft delusi His treatment of th | theme takes the form of a well sustained and tas- } cinating narrative |} of town and court record Association for the Advancement of Science. A | strong presentation of the claims of archeology as an exact science, and a brief inquiry into the an- tiquity of man on the earth. An Experiment in Citizen Training. Wuiyirrep Buck. A description of what is known as ** Junior Good Government Club,"’ No. 1, which has now been in existence about four years, and offers some in- structive results for the social economist Other articles: The Racial Geography of Europe —X, Germany; Expert Testimony in the Bering-Sea Controversy; Burs and Beggar's Ticks; and Artificial Perfumes; (with portrait). Editor's Table: Scientific Literature; Fragments of Science; Notes. Ske ch of Carl Vogt 50 cents a number, $5.00 a year, D. APPLETON AND COMPANY, 72 Fifth Avenue, New York. JK INDERGARTEN SUPPLIES Mr. Child has made large use is, private journals and public documents in the historic setting of the narrative. Fabius, the Roman. | Or, HOW THE CHURCH BECAME MILITANT. | By Rev. Dr SLip esc a the Natural | E. Frres Brrr rated, gilt top, $1 50. This stirring st vividly how I2mo, cloth, deco ry of the Roman Emp ire tells the Ch ristians and jer Fabius s leader- oppress nd cruelty of Maxen- obtained “elvil am tous nt verty under d l nd adventure runs quick and exciting action of the story tius, g | At all Bookst res, or sent, poefpaid, on receipt of the at SCHERMERHORN’S, 3 East 14th Street, N.Y. j Send for new Catalogue. price. THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO., Publishers, 5 and 7 East Sixteenth St,, New York, I etters We buy and sell Dills of exchange to ih ““ end make Cable transfers of money on of Europe, Austratia. and South Africa; also make col’c Hons and issue Commercial *redi it and Travellers’ Credits, available in all parts of the world. BROWN BROTHERS & CO. NO. 58 WALL STREET, NEW YORE. adel —a te N EW BOOKS. Some Colonial anit And Their Stories. By Marion HARLAND. Withb 86 Illustrations. Svo, gilt top, 8.00 In this volume the author tells the stories of some Colonial Homesteads. in a names have be come household words. The dex ie charmingly written, and is embellished b no A. number of illustrations very carefully selected and engraved Among the homesteads presented are: Brandon, Westover, Shirley. Marshall House, Cliveden iChew House), Morrie House, Van Cortlandt Manor House, Oak Hill (the home of the Livingstous), Philipse Manor House, Jamel House (Fort Wash ington), Smith House (Sharon, Conn). Pierce Home stead, Parson Willianis'’s House, Varina (Poca hontas), Jamestown, and Willa msburgh Reminiscences of an Old Westchester Homestead. By CHARLES PRyYER, Member N. Y. Historical Society, Fellow N. ¥. Geographical So- ciety, ete. 12mo, gilt top, $1.25. To the lover of ghost stories and local legends this littl volume makes trresiatible appeal. It ts an entertaining book, and will add a charm te many Westchester scenes. Modern English Prose Writers. By FRANK PRESTON STEARNS, author of ““Con- cord and Appledore,” ‘* The Midsummer Italian Art,” ete. Svo. Elementary Jane By Rickarp Pryce. No. Library. 36 in the Hudson I2mo, @1.00; paper, 4) cents. The Colloquy. Conversation about the Order of Things and Final Good, Held in the Chapel of the Blessed St. John. Summarized in Verse. By Jostag Avaustts Skitz. Svo, gilt top, $1.75. The Poem of the Cid. The National Epic of Spain. Edited, with Notes, by ARcHER M. Huntineton. In three super-royal octavo volumes, printed on hand made paper, containing nume- ous photogravure [ilastrations, and bound in vellum. Vol IL. is devoted to the fac- simile of the original text, this being fol- lowed line by line and page for page; Vol. Il. contains Notes and Variants; Vol. IIT. consists of a careful and as nearly as pos- sible literal translation. The edition is limited to 100 sets, the first volume of which is now ready. Price per volume to subscribers, $25.00 net. A Young Scholar’s Letters. Being a Memoir of ByRoN CALDWELL SMITH. Edited by D. O. KeLLoGG. With Por- trait. Svo, $1.75. The letters are a revelation.'’’—[Chap Book. A spirit of purity and fire.""—[Providence Jour- nal. High ideale and penetrating intelligence.’’— Indianapolis Journal. We are reminded of Amiel.’ W orld —[{Boston Literary *,.* Votes on New Books, a quarterly bulletin, ana cir culara of ‘ Colonial Homeatcads” sent on application. G.P. PUTNAM’S SONS 27 & 29 West 23d St., New York.
Page 4
[Vol. 65, No. 1688 iv The Nation. EW AND FORTHCOMING BOOKS Specimens of the Pre-Shaksperean Drama. With an Introduction, Notes, and a Glossary. By JoHn M. Man ty, Profes- sorof the English Language in Brown University. In three volumes. Vol. I. just ready. Atheneum Press Series. Poems of William Wordsworth. Chosen and Edited, with Introduction and Notes, by Epwarp DowpeEn, Professor of English Literature in the University of Dublin, Clark Lec- turer in English Literature, Trinity College, Cambridge. 522 pages. For introduction, $1.25. Atheneum Press Series. School Edition of Homer’s Odyssey, Edited, with Introduction, Commentary, and Vocabulary, by B. PERRIN and T. D. Seymoor, Professors of Greek in Yale University. Eight Books, with Vocabulary. Square 12mo. Half morocco. $51 pages. For introduction, $1.50. Four Books, with Vocabulary. Square 12mo. Half morocco. 248 pages. For introduction, $1.25. A Practical Physiology. A Text-Book for High School, Academy, and Normal School Classes. By Avert F. Biaispevy, M.D., author of * Blaisdell’s Series of Phy- siologies.”’ Fully illustrated. 448 pages. For introduction, $1.20. Elements of Chemistry. By R. P. Witttiams, in charge of the Chemical Department of the English High School, Boston. 412 pages. For introduction, $1.10. The Sociological Theories of Gabriel Tarde. By Gustavo Tosti. Reprint from The Political Seience Quarterly, Vol. XII., No. 3. Paper, 23 pages. Price, 15 cents. The War of the Theatres. sd Josiag H. Penniman, Assistant Professor of English Literature in the niversity of Penn. Boards. 168 pages. Price, $1.00. Publications of the University of Pennsylvania. Cicero: Selected Letters. Edited, with Introduction and Notes, by Frank F. Assotr, Professor of _— in the University of Chicago. For introduction, $1.25. College ‘atin Series. Physical Experiments. A Manual and Note Book by AtFrep P. Gage, author of “ Principles of Physics,’ ete. Boards. 97 pages. For introduction, 35 cents. The Living Substance As Such, and as Organism. By GwenpoLen Foutke ANDREWS. Sup- plement to Journal of Morphology, Vol. XII, No. 2. Paper. 176 pages. Cloth, $1.50; Paper, $1.25. Famous Problems of Elementary Geometry. By W. W. Beman, Professor of Mathematics in the University of Michi: an, and Davip E. Smirs, Professor of Mathematics in Michigan State: Normal College. 80 pages. For introduction, 50 cents. Maldon and Brunnanburh. Two Old English Songs of Battle, edited by CuarLes Lanaty Crow; Pro» fessor of Teutonic Languages in Weatherford College, Texas. 47 pages, For introduction, 60 cents. Library of Anglo-Saxen Poetry, Vol. IV. Studies and Notes in Philology and Literature. Vol. V. Child Memorial Volume. Paper, 282 pages. Carlyle’s Essay on Burns. Edited, with Notes, by CHarRLes Lange Hanson, Teacher of English im Durfee High School, Fall River, Mass. Annotated English Classics. Webster’s Speeches. Reply to Hayne. The Constitution and the Union, Boards. 156 pagesi. For introduction, 30 cents. Annotated English Classics. Descriptive Circulars of all our Books sent, postpaid, to any address. Correspondence cordially invited. GINN & COMPANY, Publishers, BOSTON. NEW YORK. CHICAGO. _ ATLANTA. LONDON.. LONGMANS, GREEN, VOLUME II. JUST PUBLISHED. HISTORY OF THE COMMONWEALTH AND PRO- TECTORATE, 1649-1660. Vol. I., 1649-1651. With fourteen Maps. 8vo, $7.00. Vol. II., 1651-1654. With seven Maps. 8vo, $7.00. Just Ready. THE DIARY OF MASTER WILLIAM SILENCE. A Study of Shakespeare and Blizabethan Sport. By the Right Hon. D. H. Mappen, Vice-Chancellor of the University of Dublin, With illustrations. 8vo, gilt top, $4 00. POPULAR READINGS IN SCIENCE. By Joun Gat, M.A., LL.B. Late Professor of Mathematics and Physics, Canning College, Lucknow, and Davip RoBERTSON, M.A., LL.B., B.Sc., formerly one of the Assistant Masters, University College School, London. Third Edition. Crown 8vo, $1.50. A TEXT-BOOK OF GENERAL BOTANY. By CarRLTon C. Curtis, A.M., Ph.D., Tutor in Botany in Columbia University. With 87 Illustrations. Large 8vo, cloth, pp. viii-360, $3.00, net, *,* An introduction to the study of Botany by the laboratory method. The book is divided into four chapters: I. Anatomy of the Plant Body. II. Plant Physiology. III. Systematic Botany and Plant Morphology. IV. Paleontology. Following the discussion of each subject explicit direc- tions for laboratory work are given, and the plants best illustrating each topic are indicated, as well as the principal books of reference. The figures are all newly drawn. & CO.’S NEW BOOKS THE PINK FAIRY BOOK, Edited by ANDREW LANG. With 34 plates and 35 illustrations in the text by H. J. Forp. Crown 8vo, cloth, oraamental gilt edges, $2.00. THE ADVENTURES OF THREE BOLD BABES: Hector, Honoria, and Alisander. A Story in Pictures. By Rosa- MOND PRAEGER. With 24 colored plates and 24 outline pictures. Oblong 4to, $1.50. HERE THEY ARE. More Stories. By James F. SuLutivan, Author of “The Flame Fiower,” etc. With nearly 100 illustrations by the Author. Crown 8vo, pp. x-350, cloth, ornamental, gilt top, $1.50. Contents: The Blue Eyed Fly—The Blue Thing with White Dots —The Land of the Givers away—Snit—George the Usurper—Nobody the Intruder. LIBRARY OF HISTORICAL NOVELS AND ROMANCES, Edited by LAWRENCE GOMME. HAROLD: Lord Lytton’s ‘‘Harold, the Last of the Saxon Kings.’” Large Crown 8vo, $1.50. WILLIAM I.: Macfarlane’s ‘‘Camp of Refuge.’ Large Crown 8vo,. $1.50. *,* Other volumes in Preparation. MEMORIES AND FANCIES: SUFFOLK TALES AND OTHBR STORIES. Fairy Legends, Poems, . Miscellaneous Articles. By the late Lapy CAMILLA GuRDON, Author of “Suffolk Folk Lore.” Crowa 8vo, $1.75. Sold by booksellers. Sent, postpaid, on receipt of price. LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., Publishers, 91-93 Fifth Ave. New York. TR PR RR Naa PEE AE cE 6 salah De nigra a Apaberste Si xt
Page 5
2 LODE MRP id feat dl Rea hah A SE TR a BOLE A REI td SS ani err se aD BOS oes matin sd: The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 4, 1897. The Week. The reaction throughout the country against Republicanism, as represented by the McKinley Administration and the tariff legislation passed at the extra ses- sion of Congress, proved overwhelming on Tuesday. The tide which transform- ed a plurality of 268,469 for McKinley in this State last year into one of about 60,000 for the Democratic candidate for the Court of Appeals bench this year, swept on into Ohio, where it almost, if not quite, wiped out the Republican plu- rality on the State ticket and rendered the Legislature almost a tie, as against 110 Republicans and 28 Democrats in the last body; while Iowa, which gave Mc- Kinley more than 65,000 plurality last year, and has always gone Republican in State elections except on the prohibition issue, was saved by a narrow margin. McKinleyism in the White House and Dingleyism in Congress combined are proving even more disastrous to the Re- publican party than McKinleyism in Congress seven years ago. Platt has “saved his organization” at the most stupendous price ever paid by a political leader. He has turned over Greater New York, with its enormous patronage and $75,000,000 of annual ex- penditure, to the Democratic party for four years; he has lost the State irre- vocably, converting a plurality of 268,- 000 for McKinley and one of 212,000 for Black, into a Democratic plurality of 60,- 000. He has nearly if not quite lost control of the Assembly, and hence of the Legislature. What prospect is there, in view of these results, that the Repub- licans can elect a Governor next year, or can carry the State for a Republican candidate for the Presidency in 1900? Greater New York, with its 3.500,000 of: people ani its 567,000 voters, will henceforth be the most tremendous Democratic stronghold this or any other State has ever seen. To secure this in- valuable Democratic advantage, the Re- publican boss “jammed” the new char- ter through the Legislature, and then “jammed” the enlarged city into the possession of Tammany Hall by run- ning Tracy for Mayor—‘to save the organization.’”’ Was ever a great politi- cal party in the hands of a more extra- ordinary “leader” than this? And what a triumph for that leader that he should be able to get 100,000 Republicans to help him carry his policy into execu- tion. The new Municipal Assembly will be an overwhelmingly Tammany body in both branches. There will be only a handful of Republicans in either house, so that, as an element of the new city government, this local legislature will work harmoniously with the other branches of Croker’s administration. The character of the Tammany member- ship is about as poor as could be ima- gined, falling quite uniformly to the level of our worst Boards of Tammany Aldermen. Fortunately this new body has very little real power, but it has, nevertheless, large confusing powers in many directions, and opportunities for general jobbery which are not likely to be neglected. If it were composed of the most intelligent elements of our popula- tion, this local legislature would be at best a virtually useless body, but it would be harmless. As it is, time alone will show how great a capacity for mis- chief may be lurking within it. The bigger the Greater New York and the more difficult of organization the more comic the way the charter was passed. It was passed as never before was passed the organic law of a civilized community. We predicted incessantly while it was under consideration, that there would happen, at the first election exactly what has happened—the passage of this new municipality, with its roads and parks to make, its bridges and tunnels to build, its streets to asphalt, its municipal buildings to erect on an enormous scale, and its $75,000,000 of revenue to administer, into the hands of Tammany. The calm with which Platt and his men seemed to contem- plate this last spring, satisfied us, and most other intelligent observers, that he had some sort of understanding with the other side, and that it was a matter o! indifference to him personally which side won, if he once got the charter to work. What we did not anticipate was that he would find it so easy to rally to his aid 100,000 Republicans in this city and a man of Gen. Tracy's standing to obey his orders and serve his purposes Most of these Republicans are undoubt edly honest men, but the extent to which their devotion to “the party’ carries them, and the readiness of Gen Tracy to sacrifice the good name of an honorable career for an “intuential” practice at the bar, are things for which we certainly were not prepared. The novelty of such phenomena in human experience naturally justifies the belief ;} held by many that they are not wholly due to human agencies. Mr. Low's final address to the voters, like all of his campaign utterances, was a model of its kind. We have never had in any campaign, city, State, or national, a candidate who has confined himself in all his speeches and addresses so com- pletely to the matter in hand as Mr Low has. The simple issue of free and honest government by the people has been the subject upon which he has dwelt to the exclusion of all others. In his final appeal this was the only sub ject pressed upon the voters’ attention Speaking of the Citizens’ Union, he said: “(1.) It stands for local self-government for a government of the city by the people of the city, and in the interests of the city It opposes the government of the city by the machine of any party “(2.) It stands for the right of the people to nominate their own candidates, as wel! as to vote for them. It opposes the dicta tion by one man, through his party machine of nominations for public office, trrespective of the popular wish. “(3.) It stands for the responsibility of public officers to the people, and it opposes the claim of the machines to use the gov ernment of the city in their own inte rests.” No man Was appealed to on the ground partisanship, but all citizens were asked to give their support to candi of dates who were pledged only to supply the city with good government. In order to see what an advance this kind of final appeal is, we have only to contrast it with that which Gen. Tracy put out addressed to the partisan prejudices of Republicans, begging them to stand by their party first of all, and to do their utmost to get possession of the city for the Republican party; Tracy being fully aware that every Republican who listen ed to him and followed his advice would be giving his vote in favor of turning the city over to Croker for four years In a public speech last week Mr. John Brooks Leavitt made certain charges against T. C. Platt in connection with the New York Life Insurance Company, which the cashier of that company promptly denied. The latter admitted, however, the payment of ‘$30,000 or more,” not to Mr. Platt, but to, or on aceount of, the late John F. Smyth, then State Superintendent of Insurance, in connection with an examination of the assets of that and other insurance companies. The cashier thinks that in all probability this is the origin of Mr. Leavitt's story We think that it is more easily traceable to the passage of the bill by the Legislature, some years ago, by which the life-insurance com- panies were relieved of the payment of about $750,000 in back taxes which was decided by the Court of Appeals to be due to the State. The late Gen. B. H. Bristow resigned his position as trus- tee of the New York Life Insurance Company because he could not get any satisfactory explanation from the late President Beers of a payment of $30,- 000 or more from the company’s trea-
Page 6
348 sury about that time. So he informed some of his friends. We do not affirm that this money went to Albany, nor do we think that Mr. Beers put it in his own pocket, nor do we imagine that. it disappeared by magical conjuration. We are well convinced, however, that its disappearance is typical of many similar payments made before and since by corporations in this city to secure what they call “protection,” which keep party bosses in power and enable them to buy members of the Legislature and to hurry the republic to destruction by corrupting the instrumentalities of gov- ernment, The funeral of Henry George was a striking demonstration of the popular attachment that has grown up in this community towards a man of high pur- pose, single-mindedness, and devotion to what he conceived to be his duty. As one of the speakers said, Henry George might have filled important offices, he might have made money, he might have achieved most of the things that are accounted success in this world. He had all the qualifications that make up the equipment of the successful politi- cian—all except one. He could not crook the pregnant hinges of the knee that thrift might follow fawning. It was im- possible for him to deliver any other message than the one he did deliver. As another speaker at the funeral said, the people there assembled were in part those who accepted Mr. George’s teach- ings, in part those who accepted some of his teachings and rejected others, and in part those who accepted none but re- jected all of them. Yet the whole vast assemblage within the hall and the vast- er one without were drawn together by profound respect for a gifted man who followed his convictions and turned not to the right hand or to the left, who car- ried no muck-rake to draw place or pro- fit to himself, but held fast to the truth as he understood it, leaving results to the ordering of Providence. So much of Mr. George’s life and work was given to the single-tax theory and the land question that scant attention has been drawn to other labors which, to our mind, were more important. He was a friend of peace. When the fight- ing element of the community was so stirred by President Cleveland’s Vene- zuelan message, the voice of Henry George was among the first and most potent to rebuke it. When, at a later period, the arbitration treaty with Eng- land became a public issue, he gave it the warmest welcome. He hated war with a holy hatred, and he hated the preparations for war, because he be- lieved that, in our case, if not every- where, they tended to bring on war. He believed that the burdens of war, both in blood and treasure, fall mainly on the ee CAS The Nation. working classes, and this was an addi- tional reason for his detestation of it. Here again he delivered his message be- cause he could not do otherwise. He was a free-trader out-and-out. He knew that protection was a tax on labor, that what was given to one by that system was taken from another, that there was no law, and could be none, to compel the beneficiaries of the tariff to divide with their operatives, still less to divide with other people; and hence that the sys- tem was part delusion and part fraud. And so he spoke and wrote, producing one book that is among the best ever written in English on that subject. In all that it fell to Henry George to do there was a scrupulous morality and fidelity to the interests of his fellows. Mr. Dingley’s deficit for October was only $9,300,000, and November leads off handsomely with a shortage of $530,000 for the first day. These deficits, be it remembered, occur in the face of ex- penditures visibly “held up.” Mr. Gage, that is to say, very properly exercises his discretion in the matter of certain payments which are authorized, but not strictly compulsory at a fixed date. The bill will have to be settled in the end, but it is comforting to hold it back until the promised surplus revenue is in hand. But that Dingley millennium will have to hurry up; one third the fis- cal year is gone, and the deficit is $38,- 000,000. Secretary Gage’s “plan” for reforming the currency has met with little but an eloquent silence. This may be due in part to the absorption of the public in pending elections. But we fear a deeper reason is the despairing feeling of the business community that Congress will be indisposed to touch the currency with the tip of a finger, and that the Ad- ministration has not the stomach for a fight on the subject. Mr. Gage is, of course, committed, and will no doubt make a strong and urgent report; but what will the President do? It is gene- rally agreed that, as at present minded, he will make only a perfunctory recom- mendation—something like Mr. Harri- son’s allusion in his message to Secre- tary Windom’s report: ‘‘Here is the re- port of the Secretary of the Treasury, which I hope you will read carefully and try to understand; Heaven knows, I don’t understand it!” But Mr. Mc- Kinley has a better reason for faltering zeal in the cause of currency reform. As he explained last March, the first thing was to raise a sufficient revenue; after that would come currency reform. Now as a matter of fact he is not with- in $38,000,000 of sufficient revenue; so how can he be consistently asked to go on with currency reform? But we hardly Jook to see him put this argu- ment ip & message to Congress. [Vol. 65, No. 168 News comes from Honolulu that the dispute with Japan over immigration is all but settled. It is also stated that the Japanese Minister to the United States, now on leave of absence in Tokio, will be replaced at Washington by another envoy. This is to be a rebuke to Minister Hoshi for taking so high a tone with Secretary Sherman about Japan’s interest in our annexation of Hawaii. But this, we must think, is a very mis- taken view for annexationists to hold. If everything is such plain sailing now, if nobody objects in the slightest de- gree to our taking the islands, it at once becomes doubtful if we want them. The general feeling in the country is that it is probably a highly foolish thing to annex Hawaii; but, if anybody says we mustn’t, we’ll do it though it were twice as foolish. So we think a better theo- ry of the Japanese Minister’s recall would be that he had fallen under dis- pleasure for having assured Secretary Sherman that Japan had no idea of annexing the islands herself. That was a fearful blunder; everybody knows that Japan wants the islands; therefore, we must have them. Annexation strate- gy seems to be flagging. The form of autonomy which Spain is now prepared to grant Cuba is but vaguely outlined as yet in the accounts of it given to the press. But there is no reason to suppose that it allows any such measure of home rule as Canada, for example, enjoys. Either by power lodged in the Governor-General, or by a veto reserved to the Spanish Cortes, a sure check on local control will be retained by the Spanish Government. Moreover, it is to be remembered that autonomy, even if freely granted and frankly accepted, would not solve the whole problem, which is so largely one of finance. Cuba, even if her industries were not ruined, could not bear the erushing burden of taxation which would be sure to be laid upon her after the war. Discontent and the outbreak of another rebellion would be almost certain to follow. But the great trouble with any scheme of autonomy is that it comes too late to satisfy either the Cubans or the American Congress. The insurgents take the offer of home rule as a confession of weakness, and say it will merely make them redouble their efforts to secure independence, which is now more than ever their goal. And it is difficult to believe that Congress can be kept from some kind of pro-Cu- ban vote early in December. In its tem- per lies Mr. McKinley’s real perplexity. But until Congress meets, it is promised that he shall do nothing. The English bimetallists are not at all discouraged by the bursting of the Wolcott bubble. They issue an address pointing out the great victory they have siitchenab i
Page 7
Seciidineguixe it achat ee eee iret reg bial crane asa CeO ihe Pe Nov. 4, 1897] The Nation. won by having “attention called” so prominently to the subject of interna- tional bimetallism. This is like Pad- dy’s consolation when the pig crashed through the window and got away; at any rate he knew the size of the cratur now. Yes, attention has been called to international bimetallism; also ridicule and contempt. All the world sees it ly- ing dead in Downing Street. But, as the English Bimetallic League says, the slaughter has attracted great “atten- tion,” and the funeral will be attended by many mourners. Chief among these should be the “brainy” Balfour. The idea, said one of his admirers just the day before the fatal blow was struck— the idea of Balfour’s staying in a cabi- net which would do bimetallism to death! But there he stays just like a less divine being. Perhaps it is only to make his mourning official. No one doubts that it is heartfelt. While earnest protests are raised against the further immigration of “cheap labor” from Europe, it is note- worthy that recourse must constantly be had to such labor, even in a State like Massachusetts, where the movement for restriction has been very strong. Many pieces of “State road” are being made in different parts of Massachu- setts; and even in rural towns, where foreigners are almost unknown, it has often been necessary to employ Italians sent thither from the large cities. The same thing is true even of the smaller cities. A new street-railroad is being constructed in North Adams, and when the company began work, it brought in a gang of Italians. The Central Labor Union at once raised a “howl” about the injustice thus done the poor work- ingmen of the city, whereupon the com- pany explained that it had imported the outsiders only because it could not find the men that it needed in the city. A firm which has the contract for a job of street paving has had the same difficulty, and it has actually been compelled to advertise in the local papers in order to get a sufficient force. The employers say that there is not a man idle in the city who wants to work, though there are not a few who are idle but will not work. The utter breakdown of prohibition in New Hampshire is now confessed, even by its most earnest advocates. Testi- mony to the fact which is of the highest importance was furnished at the con- vention of Baptists in Manchester a fortnight ago. The whole subject of temperance was discussed at length, and the result was the adoption of resolu- tions which declare that “we view with consternation the influence of the saloon in our State, and regard it as a nuisance which ought to be suppressed”; and that “we note with great sorrow the open violations of the prohibitory law in our cities and towns with the evident per- mission of our commissioners, mayors, and police officials.” Nobody attempted to deny that this statement as to the wholesale violation of the law was en- tirely true, and if it is true, it would seem as though the most ardent pro- hibitionists must soon see the folly of keeping on the statute-book a law which cannot be enforced, and which results in “free rum.” The killing of a promising young Georgian, who was a student at the State University, as the result of a game of football at Atlanta on Saturday, has led to the announcement by the Chan- cellor that no more playing of the game will be allowed in that institution. The announcement commands general ap- proval in the State, and many members of the Legislature favor the passage of a law to the same effect applying to all. A similar prohibition of the game by the principal of a high school in Milwaukee, because of the serious injuries suffered by several members of the eleven in a recent game, is to be noted, together with an admirable deliverance on the subject from Mr. Charles Quarles, Presi- dent of the Milwaukee School Board, who favors action by the board that will make this prohibition general. It is re- freshing to find an educational authority who appreciates that boys are “presum- ably sent to school for mental training,’ and who is not deceived by the cant about physical training into favoring a game which has a “hospital list’ as an invariable accompaniment in every in- stitution where it is played. So, too, it is encouraging to hear the president of a school board laying down the sound but now generally forgotten principle, that the authorities in charge of an educa- tional institution “have no business to countenance, and so encourage, danger- ous sports.” There is nothing like agreement among the authorities as to what con- stitutes “slugging”’ in football, or as to what extent slugging on the part of uni- versity students should be condemn- ed. This is not to be wondered at. It will be remembered that a Yale profes- sor three years ago, in a book on the science, held that “personal encounters of some sort seem absolutely necessary to the education of young men, especial- ly men of the strongest character.” At what point does a “personal encounter” between players of rival teams cease to be “roughness,” which is held by ex- perts to be as permissible as it is ne- cessary, and become “slugging,” for which President Harper of the Univer- sity of Chicago has announced that the offender “will be dropped from the team and University at one and the same time"? This is just now a burping question ip Syracuse and Colgate Uni: 349 versities. In a recent game between elevens representing these institutions it is alleged that “Syracuse players in- tentionally ‘tackled’ Colgate men who did not have the ball, contrary to the rules of the game, and seemed to slug as if trained in the ring instead of on the gridiron”; that “the Syracuse full- back, while being forced back with the ball by Colgate men, lost his self-control and deliberately punched one of the Col gate men in the eye’; that “naturally Colgate men retaliated”; and that finally “the players all lost self-control and some of the spectators tried to quiet them.” It is further affirmed that “Sy racuse men were heard to speak laud ingly of players who slugged, and in condemnation of the action of President Harper of Chicago in reference to such actions.” The London Economist, commenting on the rumor that Lord Salisbury had resigned, advises him to give up one of his offices, that of Foreign Secretary, on the ground that, whether true or false, there is a strong popular impres- sion that in that office he has failed On the other hand, it advises him to keep the Premiership, on the ground that he has great mental powers and high rank and is a favorite of the Tory party. The truth is that Lord Salisbury, like Mr. Balfour and many others, owes his reputation for all sorts of ability. simply to his being an anti-Home- Ruler. Previous to Gladstone's attempt at Irish home rule, and especially after the Berlin treaty flasco, there was no general impression of his ability what- ever. His meek succumbing to Disraeli, whom he hated and despised, his clumsy device of a secret understanding with the Russian Minister, and then astound- ing denial of its existence, and the whole hodgepodge called “‘peace with honor,” gave the country the idea of want both of capacity and of good faith, and made Mr. Goschen’s declaration that he was not prepared “to give Lord Salis- bury a blank check” in foreign affairs, seem a very good reductio ad absurdum. When Gladstone took office in 1886, Lord Salisbury had, in the public eye, failed or was incompetent, and Mr. Bal- four, though sixteen years in the House of Commons, had never been heard of. Lord Salisbury has never said or writ- ten anything to give an impression of mental power. He has published no- thing, and made no sort of literary dis- play, except smart and cynical articles in the Saturday Review. Both he and Mr. Balfour, to say the blunt truth, owe all their eminence. to the wild alarm excited in England by the Home Rule bill, and to their social position. They rode into power and fame on the crest of this wave, and they have been found out in two years, Lord Salisbury by his diplomatic failure and Mr. Ba); four by his bimetallism.
Page 8
— THE ROOT OF THE MATTER. Nothing more dramatie has occurred in our political history than the reap- pearance in the canvass of Henry George, after many years of seclusion and apparent failure, to reaffirm his doctrines and resuscitate his fame by an early and sudden death. Never was it more true than of him, that, being dead, he yet speaketh; for we do not be- lieve it is an exaggeration to say that his death has given twice the force to his words they would have had had he lived. For we may fairly conclude that had he lived he would have been de- feated at the polls, and his peculiar doc- trines would again have shared his poli- tical eclipse. But he took himself at once out of the category of preachers of hopeless opinions by his vigorous at- tack on the root of our city evils. Most other orators treated Croker’s and Platt’s badness as the cause of our woes. He said: “The trouble lies deeper. These men do only what all bosses have done, levy blackmail on people whom they can attack through venal legislatures. If I am elected, you need not expect me to reform our taxation or reduce car fares. These things are beyond my powers, I know, but you may count on my bring- ing these rogues to justice. This I can do and will do.” This talk rang through the city like a trumpet call, and stirred up the masses as no other speaking had done, and then came his death, impress- ing people like a heroic sacrifice for the public good. Considering everything, the speculation which followed on the effect of his death on the canvass was droll, if anything connected with such a tragedy could be droll, for Croker and Platt both maintained that those whom he had roused would at once go over to the causes which he hated and to the men whom he denounced. Mr. George’s stern and energetic pre- sentation of Platt and Croker as cri- minals to be punished was in a certain sense a new idea. Most of our other ora- tors had given it the go-by, and treated “Mr.”’ Platt and “Mr.” Croker simply as over-ambitious political opponents, who merited nothing more than defeat at the polls. George shook the handcuffs and striped jackets before their eyes, and pointed them out to his followers as dou- ble-dyed criminals, whose condign pun- ishment he would, if elected, consider his first and most solemn duty. The moral law, for the first time in city poli- tics, we May say, spoke through him to the masses. There was no mincing, no allowances, no courtesy, no compliments or qualification, such as have been show- ered on some other city thieves and re- probates; nothing but the Ten Com- mandments in their naked majesty. For this we honor his memory. The causa causans, as the philosophers say, of Platt and Croker both, is the cor- porations which supply them with money. Could we stop corporation contributions, The Natiom. [Vol. 65. No. 1688 these two men would sink into utter in- significance. They owe all their im- portance to the money they are able to dispense. How they spend it and where they get it is well known, and has been frequently pointed out. No one, not even Quigg or Lauterbach, pretends that, if Platt had not this money, his doings and sayings would have the slightest importance. He has none of the quali- ties of a popular leader. He is not elo- quent, or witty, or wise, or magnetic. Low cunning he has in abundance, but even a band of thieves would not enlist under him on this account. His appear- ance simply as a candidate for command would set a band of brigands in a roar. He is what he is simply because he holds the bag. Take the bag from him, and an enthusiastic canvass against him would become supremely ridiculous. It is to be observed, in confirmation of all this, that whichever boss is able to command the city money, as a rule, also commands the Legislature. The Legislature goes with the city much as a Waterbury watch goes with a suit of ready-made clothing, or a chromo with a year’s subscription. The corporations give money to both bosses, but they al- ways give most to the one which has won the last city election. It was the general impression that Platt had shared in the victory of Strong—that is, that it was to him the credit of the Strong vic- tory would accrue—that enabled him to get together such a collection of venal eattle as made him Senator over Mr. Choate.. 'The legislators obey the ‘Old Man” for-precisely the same reason for which the porter obeys him at No. 49 Broadway. They know they would lose their places if they did not obey him. When Tammany won the city, Croker stepped into the boss-ship at Albany without the smallest question in any quarter. He soon had the Legislature, and his Sulzer, and the usual gang of mercenaries ready to pass laws without discussion, on telegraphic orders, almost as a matter of course, and all because he then carried the bag, not because he was an orator, or statesman, or influen- tial in any good or moral sense. Now, where did the bag come from? It came from the corporations. No bag, no boss. Could we stop the bag, we might still have bosses, but they would be bosses like Daniel Webster, or Silas Wright, or William H. Seward, or Low, or Hewitt, who would be followed and obeyed because they were loved and ad- mired, or were considered wise counsel- lors, or had become great party leaders through force of eloquence or political skill. Therefore, we say unhesitatingly that unless a victory at the polls were soon followed by fresh legislation mak- ing the payment of money by corpora- tions to any one, for political purposes, a penal offence, entailing a few years of stern penitentiary, and making the pay- ment of money to candidates for the Legislature by any one, or its receipt by any one, also a penitentiary offence, we should have the boss back again in a very short time. The great aggregations of money known as “corporations” are a new thing in the modern world. The extravagant use of money in elections is also a comparatively new thing in America. Both of them were unknown to the men who in our constitutions laid the foundation of our polity. Neither of them has been adequately dealt with, or dealt with at all in our legislation. There has, therefore, grown up rapidly that curious creation of mixed bribery and blackmail known as “the boss.”” He must be dealt with by law speedily if he is not to ruin our government, and the corporations must be expelled from polities if they are not to rule us wholly through a new form of government, which would be the meanest and basest contrivanee devised by man since he began to live in society. BEX-MINISTER TAYLOR ON CUBA. Mr. Hannis Taylor, our Minister to Spain under President Cleveland, pub- lishes in the North American Review for November an article on the Cuban ques- tion which is important in both source and substance. It might be thought in- delicate for Mr. Taylor to write about Spain as he does soon after leaving Madrid. He himself seems to feel that his article is open to the suspicion of being thought undiplomatic, but excuses his writing it on the ground of its being his “duty to lay before my countrymen my humble testimony on the whole sub- ject.”” We never were, in this country, great sticklers for diplomatic propriety, and Mr. Taylor need fear little censure on that score—especially when he comes forward not as an idle gossip, but as a slave of duty. For the rest, it must be said that his high standing as man and scholar, and his opportunity: for study- ing Spanish politics at first hand for four years, lend him an authority in the matter in question to which few can pre tend. Mr. Taylor’s analysis of the causes of the Cuban rebellion agrees with that made by intelligent Spaniards. It is a rebellion based on economic reasons and inflamed by misgovernment. The prosperity of Cuba depends upon two great staple products—sugar and to- bacco—and these have been at the mercy of foreign tariffs and the benighted legislation of the Spanish Cortes. It is not necessary to go over the details. The present revolution started, it is con- fessed by Spaniards, in industrial dis- content and misery, and its aim is pri- marily to secure commercial indepen- dence; political independence is subordi- nate, but goes with it. This is a familiar story, but the point to which Mr.Taylor speaks with peculiar weight is the ability of Spanish states- Se iat A TR ae tages SNOT An Se eis ao aaa hare Np
Page 9
Laclede a ed eset i Schou nha Ki Nov. 4, 1897] men either to grasp the real problem of Cuban government or to solve it. Here he is emphatically despondent, but not more so, we believe, than the facts warrant. As he says, the idea of colonial autonomy, in the English sense, of local control of local affairs, is an idea which has never yet got lodgment in a Spanish head. The Government now talks about granting Cuba home rule, but really does not mean it, because it does not even understand what home rule is. Nor do the Spanish people as a whole, who would think of a Cuban Parliament, with the powers, say, of the Canadian Parlia- ment, as equivalent only to surrender- ed Spanish sovereignty. Mr. Taylor says, and doubtless with truth, that Spaniards would rather lose the island by force of arms than make it a grant of liberal self-government. The dis- placement of Gen. Weyler by Gen. Blan- co will make no real difference. Reforms and an extension of local. government may be promised; but any form of au- tonomy conceded by Spain would be hollow because neither Spanish Govern- ment nor people understand what au- tonomy really means. If it were grant- ed in name, it would be only in the way in which the Bourbons granted the Charter—not that they had the least idea of living up to it, or thinking that any- body would suppose they would. So far Mr. Taylor on the causes of the rebellion and the impotence of the Spanish Government to heal the Cuban sore. In these matters he writes as one with authority. What he says of the duty of the United States, what he ad- vises Congress to do, what he predicts as the result of his advice if it is taken --all these things must be accepted for what they are worth. Yet it cannot be denied that they will be apt to have great weight with the country and with Congress. What Mr. Taylor hopes to see is, he says: “The prompt adoption by Congress, upon its reassembling, of a joint resolution, em- bodying three clear and definite proposi- tions: The first, asserting our right and duty, not only to ourselves, but to humanity, by virtue of the universally recognized doc- trine of intervention, as well as by virtue of the Monroe Doctrine, to put an end to the dreadful conflict so long raging in Cu- ba, because it involves not only the con- stant disturbance of our internal peace, but also the destruction of great commer- cial and property interests of our citizens: the second, asserting that, after enduring patiently all such evils incident to fifteen years of war in Cuba out of the last twen- ty-nine, the Government of the United States has offered in vain its friendly offices as peacemaker to Spain, in hope of aiding her, without offence to her susceptibilities, in bringing to a close a strife so destructive to the material interests of both countries: the third, declaring that the Government of the United States, in view of Spain’s refusal to accept such friendly and respectful me- diation, has now resolved to exercise upon its own responsibility its entire moral in- fluence, to the end that the war in Cuba may be brought to a speedy close, provided Spain fails to accomplish that result in a reasonable time, to be clearly indicated.” Mr. Taylor thinks that the passage of such a resolution could not be “justly regarded” by Spain as a casus helli; The Nation. but this is surely to presume upon Spain’s weakness. She may be weak, but she is as proud as ever. In fact, there is reason to believe that, as in the case of a decayed noble family, she clings to the last remnants of her former great- ness with a pride that is all the fiercer for her enfeeblement. This at least is certain, that Spain would prefer to lose Cuba as the result of a war with the United States rather -than surrender the island to the insurgents unaided. So it would be the height of folly for Congress to pass such resolutions as Mr. Taylor urges, without seeing that they lead directly to war with Spain, and without preparing for such a war. Our duty is our duty, whatever the result; but we must not flatter ourselves that we can discharge it with light hearts on account of “sunk Spain’s prolonged death-agony.” COLLEGE ENGLISH, The Harvard Committee on Composi- tion and Rhetoric have made their final report to the Board of Overseers, on “College English’’—that is, on the Eng- lish of the voung men who present themselves for entrance to the college. The three previous reports were devoted mainly to the revelations made as to the quality of this English by the freshmen’'s examination papers and themes. They reflected, many thought, too severely on the want of proper previous training in the preparatory schools which these pa- pers and themes seemed to indicate. Many teachers resented warmly the con- clusions of the committee, and some doubted whether there was any sufficient basis for them in fact. The committee then sought to meet these objections by the publication of specimens of the compositions on which they had com- mented. These specimens were, as a rule, deplorable, but still the use made of them was unsatisfactory to the school- masters, who had many ways of ac- counting for their badness without ac- cepting the blame for their own schools Much of this blame was thrown on the practice of testing English by translations from the Greek and Latin, inasmuch as this really imposed on the student the necessity of showing skill in the use of two languages, when he was nominally called on for proficien- cy only in one. The committee acknow- ledged that there was some force in this excuse, but the fact still remained that the English of the freshmen was so very poor that the college had been compelled to establish a course called “English A,” in which to teach the rudiments of Eng- lish composition so as to fit the young men to profit by the remainder of the The committee accord- ingly determined to try to get to the root of the trouble in another way, by addressing queries to the young men and Harvard and its 1? so, coiuerce course. women in annexes, 351 touching the preparation in English they had received in their respective schools. They received 1,308 answers, on which the report before us is based. These an- swers have been bound together, and have been deposited in the college li brary, where they will probably afford a useful means of comparison to some future generation. One hundred and fif- ty-eight of them have been printed in an appendix to the report. They will well repay the perusal of all who are interested in methods of education. Many of the facts one gathers from them are worth more than a passing no- tice. One, however, of which they make no mention, and, perhaps, the most for- midable, is the hindrance the teacher of English in America receives from the belief of both parents and children, that they know English well enough. Very many of the parents and of the boys who go to college, have found that the kind of English they speak and write has served their purpose through life and they, therefore, are not deeply im pressed with the necessity of better Eng lish for their children. Speaking or writing bad English does not discredit a man or woman here socially, as speak- ing or writing the language of the coun try badly would in England or France in most American towns success in life would furnish an ample answer to cri ticisms on one’s speech or letters; in Europe it would only make the want of education more annoying For some- what similar reasons, the boy is not apt to carry the teacher's corrections far out of the school-room. He rushes back to his playmates and repeats joyously with them the solecisms against which the schoolmaster has just warned him. But this is not the difficulty which comes out most prominently in the an- In fact, it hardly comes out at all, and many teachers’ own practice is too faulty for them to plead it. The thing in which nearly the whole body of the students seem to agree as their chief hindrance to acquiring skill in English composition at school, is want of practice They all, or nearly all, say that the main reason why their themes and composi- tions did them so little good was that so little time was given to them. Once a week or twice a week only, were they swers. called on to write English correctly at school. Next after this comes the fu- tility of much of the instruction—the reading and memorizing ot classic and imperfectly understood English authors, and the listening to exhortations about method, and the cor English bad for the occasion. style” and made In fact, much of the instruction, considering that it was furnished to mere boys, appears to have been, according to the report, of e\ traordinary absurdity. The courses of the schools seem to be largely courses in | terature given to persons who have The teach- rection of sentences still to learn the language.
Page 10
352 The Nation. [Vol. 65, No. 1688 ing of the proper use of the language, therefore, has been left to the college, which ought to be able to give all its powers and time to the teaching of lite- rature. Next to want of practice in the schools, there is nothing about which there is so much unanimity as the ex- cellence of this college instruction. Har- vard ‘English A” isthe subject of general praise, and not a few gratefully acknow- ledge the help they have received from it in making up the deficiencies with which they entered, showing that the same method, and especially the same attention to frequent practice, would have produced similar results earlier. What is probably most surprising in all this discussion is that the supreme importance of practice, in learning to do anything well, with which everybody is familiar in nearly every pursuit in life, has not made more impression on teachers of English. To ride or row, to play billiards, or fence, or make speeches, or make music, practice is well known to be the essential condi tion of excellence. But a raw boy, who most of his time talks slang with slangy playmates, is expected to ac- quire a ready and correct use of-the greatest instrument of human expres- sion, through which one rises from an Australian savage to Plato or Shak- spere, by two or three hours of drill and attention a week, in most of which he is called on to talk about things of which he has only a vague or hazy understanding. Even more sur- prising than this is the small impression which seems to be made on the mind of teachers by the difficulty of learning to speak a foreign modern language. Most teachers have tried to learn to speak French, or German, or Italian. No man who has ever tried it has failed to find that he might read any one of these lan- guages for years, and study the gram- mar, and yet be unable to write a de- cent letter in it or carry on a conversa- tion respectably. If he were asked the reason, he would almost invariably re- ply that it was want of “practice”—that is, that to speak fluently or write cor- rectly, he must do it every day, must live in the country so as to be obliged to do it, or live with some one with whom he spoke it incessantly, in order to make any progress. That this patent fact, with which everybody is familiar, has not had more influence on school instruc- tion in English is very surprising. The English of youths does not greatly dif- fer from any language in the mouth of a foreigner. Many meanings of words, turns of expression, and idiomatic ways of saying things are all strange to him, and he has to cure himself of his faults of expression, exactly as a foreigner would, by frequent repetition and con- tinuous attention. Another matter to which the report calls attention is the tendency of the sort of instruction given by the schools to lead young persons to suppose that what they are being taught is to make literature, not simply to use English easily and correctly. All theme and essay writing has this tendency in a cer- tain degree, but when it is literature that is being studied, it is difficult to avoid it. The desire and ambition of most young people who try to write or speak is to be eloquent or make a mark of some kind. The letters in this collection from the Radcliffe students show how strong this tendency is among women. The answers are not plain statements of fact. They are adorned with flowers of rhetoric, with playful illustrations, with striking analogies and reductions to absurdity. Newspaper reporters, as all editors know, labor under the same difficulty. They cannot bear to narrate or describe simply. They love to give the story literary form or ornamenta- tion, and the result is often that the ac- count of a small accident or offence be- comes a large structure of fabulous mat- ter, resting on a small basis of fact. In some papers the story is stripped of these accidents, but they are most- ly let pass to save trouble, and the re- sult is the prevailing want of confi- dence in newspaper descriptions. This matter is more important than it seems, for there can be little doubt that the value of truthfulness would be greatly enhanced if the earliest lessons in Eng- lish were lessons in the importance of seeing things as they are, and telling simply what happened. THE SCANDINAVIAN EXHIBITION AT STOCKHOLM. STOCKHOLM, October 5, 1897. The Stockholm Exposition of Scandinavian Industries was closed on the 3d of October. Every one who visited it must have hesi- tated which to admire most—the modesty of the people who could conceive and carry out with such perfect taste so striking a display of their handiwork, and yet make so little parade and noise about it, or the wonderful perfection to which they have brought such of the arts as they have long practised. One is also surprised at the ability and skill with which they are adopt- ing and adapting to their special require- ments and to their natural products every advance made by others in technical science. Stockholm is itself an example of a city possessing beautiful natural features, im- proved by art, as well as of a community which, under a good civil government, dis- plays the virtues of social order; among which not the least are uniform urbanity and courtesy. Built on a group of islands and on the mainland, where the shores of Lake Maelar contract to discharge its fresh waters, with the rush of the Rhone at Gene- va, into an inlet of the Baltic, Stock- helm greets the eye at every turn with graceful bridges and _ substantial stone quays lined with shipping, ferries flitting hither and thither, handsome stone build- ings, and, as a background, forest-clad hills. Nor is the delight of the eye vitiated by of- fence to the nose, for in-door and out the most perfect cleanliness prevails. Even the air is not polluted with coal smoke, as wood is the domestic fuel. And, in contrast to the capital of Norway, whether it be due to the Géteborg liquor law or not, a drunken man or woman is rarely seen. Altogether, Stockholm is one of the most charming cities on earth. On one of the promontories to the south of the city, reached by a horse-car line and by ferry-boats from every section of the city, were laid out the grounds and erected the exhibition buildings. No attempt was made to imitate Chicago, nor was the world in- vited to display its wares. Russia, on ac- count of her geographical relations to the peninsula, was asked to participate and ac- cepted; otherwise it was an exclusively Scandinavian exhibition, and therefore of so moderate a size that the visitor was not be- wildered and wearied to death in trying to drag his heavy limbs through mile after mile of gallery, with the horrible dread ever haunting him of being twitted when he reached home of having omitted to see some trifle or other which his more inquisitive neighbor therefore considered the best worth seeing in the whole show. It is devoutly to be hoped that the forthcoming Paris Ex- position will be the last of those stupen- dous world-shows which have gradually grown so unwieldy as to be beyond the com- pass of the average human understanding and the limit of human physical endurance, Those stimuli to industry and skill which exhibitions doubtless are should be confined, either, like this,to the natural and industrial products of one section of the world, or to one group only of the objects and aims of human industry. The setting of the exhibition was simple and in admirable taste. The grounds were laid out with a profusion of flowers, which the spirit that presides over the weather beneficently preserved from frost till the very last day—but only till then. None of the larger buildings was conspicuous for peculiarity of design except that devoted to the industrial arts, over whose large en- trance hall there towered a triple dome flanked by four towers occupied by as many elevators and capped by observation-galle- ries. There was a flavor of Muscovite ar- chitecture about the building, though it fol- lowed closely no recognized style. Struc- turally it was notable, for it was the largest wooden building in the world—a forest of 34,000 trees having been felled for its erec- tion. There was, of course, an Old Stock- holm, whose walls were defended by genu- ine old culverins, and whose portcullis was guarded by men in leathern jerkins and armed with veritable old cross-bows. The rooms and kitchen of the castle were stock- ed with furniture, ornaments, and utensils of the actual age of the building reproduced. The Midway was represented by a very modest puppet-show. On the other hand, the pavilions erected by private firms were numerically on a par with and artistically superior to those of Chicago. The promi- nent feature, in fact, of the whole exhibi- tion was the high average excellence of everything displayed, and the supreme per- fection of certain classes of manufacture. As might be expected, Sweden made a most impressive display of her iron and steel industry, and she did it in a measure to em- phasize the chief characteristic which all her ironmasters aim at, viz., quality before quantity. There were not immense piles of iron and steel ingots, nor huge structures of pipes and bars, but models in glass of all Sat ies
Page 11
iti Seva aien: Ol aaa Shae eee ie Nov. 4, 1897] The Nation. isa her principal mines, collections of her ores beautifully displayed, and samples of the im- mense variety of articles she manufactures out of them. For though Sweden is now exporting from two alone of her newer mines about two million tons annually of ore of high percentage in iron, but otherwise of in- ferior quality, she reserves for her own manufacture her purest and choicest ores. Out of these she makes, with wood and char- coal as fuel, such iron and steel as no other country attempts to compete with her in manufacturing, and which brings so high a price that she cannot, for instance, afford to waste it upon rails, tor she lays down imported iron on the very roads which de- pend for freight on her own steel mills. The best seamless tubes, which, when drawn, are marvels of lightness and strength, can be made only of Swedish iron, and are im- ported by American makers, to be returned to Sweden itself as finished bicycles. From Sweden also come the finest watch springs. In making the raw material for such articles no trouble or expense is spared to insure uniformity and excellence; and as the high- est quality can be secured only by the use of wood as fuel, the iron companies are of necessity lumbering companies. Hence the manufacture of sawn timber and of wood- pulp and paper have grown up as subsidiary industries to the iron trade, and pulp and paper formed part of their exhibits. But the use of wood as fuel necessarily limits the iron production, which, judged by the Ame- rican standard, is despicably smali. One of Mr. Carnegie’s Duquesne blast furnaces makes as much iron in six weeks as the total annual output of the largest concern in Sweden—say 30,000 tons. But if all the Carnegie blast furnaces had to be fed with charcoal and the reheating furnaces with wood gas, the Pennsylvanian forests would be swept away in about a twelvemonth to sup- ply him alone. Extensive as the Swedish forests are, and large as are the timbered domains which each large iron company owns, restriction to the use of wood as fuel will continue to make her production small. As it is, her splendid steel industry would speedily come to an untimely end did not her provident iron and steel companies plant as well as cut, and allow neither root nor branch to go to waste. In this they teach us a lesson. Would that we were not so slow in learning it. The large iron companies own several hun- dred thousand acres of timber land apiece. They plant a tree for every one they cut; but they do not wait for the sapling to grow into a tree of giant size before felling it. It is found more profitable to cut it when from eight to ten inches thick at the butt. There is, therefore, no large timber in Sweden. Then, when cut, the best is shipped to the company’s paper mills; the rest is made partly into charcoal for use in the com- pany’s blast furnace, or sawn into boards and dimension lumber at its own mills for domestic use or foreign shipment. But not a grain of sawdust is allowed to escape into the streams, nor a splinter permitted to go to waste. Everything that will burn is thrown ‘into the gas producer, and is made into pure gaseous fuel, free from the slight- est trace of sulphur, to be burnt in the steel works; for there the faintest breath of coal gas would leave a stain. sedulous care with which these manufactur- ers collect every portion of what we call waste, but they call riches, is the fact that | As proof of the } i | i salmon still run up the rivers where falls and rapids turn a score of sawmills; for Sweden and Norway have the advantage of possessing boundless water power. Very lit- tle fuel is therefore consumed in generating power. Only one large iron company is so situated as to be deficient in water for its total needs. As both steel and paper-making demand such heavy expenditure of power, and as these two industries, though so un- like, have thus become almost essentially dependent on one another, Sweden's large and rapid rivers are as much an element of her prosperity as her forests. To the initiated the structure of pigs, in- gots, and bars of iron and steel exhibited by all the Swedish steel companies was proof sufficient of the admirable quality of their wares; but to the mind and eyes of the un- initiated such a ribbon of steel as that exhibited by the Sandvik Iron Company carried a much more convincing conception of what can be done with the metal when of the highest quality. Up and down and round about the walls of the pavilion there was twined a single 8-inch wide band of steel, cold rolled, 2,354 feet long and weigh- ing 1,146 pounds. Two large exhibits made by two cream- separating machine companies explained the success of another of Sweden's great indus- tries. Milking cows and making butter do not appeal to the imagination like mining ores and making pig-iron apd blowing it up into steel in Bessemer converters amid a blaze of sparks before which a discharge of rockets is dim; but to the people at large the humbler occupation is of as great, if not greater, moment than the more brilliant, for Sweden's export of the produce of her dairies about equals in value that of her furnaces, and her butter is as invariably good as her steel. It is not to the credit of England and Ireland that England should be her best customer. For the excellence, variety, and novelty of the terracotta, faience, and porcelain exhibits, Denmark perhaps should be ac- corded the prize over Sweden; and in the manufacture of enamelled jewelry Norway excels Sweden and aims at even rivalling Russia, especially in articles of transparent enamel. But there was a branch of domestic industry in which Sweden had, at least in the exhibition, no competitor—that of home- woven woollen goods. A large stone build- ing with a wooden annex was devoted to the display of Sweden's educational and sanitary instruction and methods, among which the Swedish-movement cure in active But the most interesting to a foreigner was the large section of the building appropriated to the Swedish provinces for the hand-made tools, utensils, carved wood, and textile fabrics manufactured by the peasantry. The rather too brilliant aprons and petticoats, which are conspicuous in the costumes of the women, did not lead us to expect such artistic subjection and perfect blending of color and such harmony of design as were dis- played in the rugs, curtains, and portiéres which came from every section of the coun- try except from the extreme north. In finish and beauty of pattern, if not in weight and thickness, they would compare with like fabrics of the East. Every cottage has its operation was the most attractive. loom, and nearly every Swedish country- woman is more or less expert in handling it. Certain very beautiful native patterns, transmitted as traditions, are reproduced in them for domestic service; but of late years this skill in weaving, for the practice of which the long winters give ample time and opportunity, has been encouraged and directed into new channels by an associa- tion of patriotic women in Stockholm, the “Friends of the Handicraftsman."" Promising girls are taught the higher branches of the art of weaving in a central school, from which teachers are sent to the small pro- vincial towns and villages, where, for a trifling sum, instruction ts given to the peasant women in short courses of techni- cal teaching. Thus their inherited skill and natural proclivities receive fresh impetus and are directed by new motives. The dan- ger, of course, lies in a tendency towards imitation, in the corresponding loss of ori- ginality, and a too great departure from the patterns and designs which are the ex- pression of the native mind and taste. But the result, so far as it could be judged of from the provincial exhibits in this northern museum, would lead us to expect that, if this wonderful taste should be judiciousiy cultivated and industriously practised, the products of the looms of the Swedish peasant women will be sought the world over by those who appreciate the beautiful and are willing to pay for it, for their work is by no means cheap. The motto of Sweden, as we have already said, is, “Quality, not quantity,” and for quality you must pay J. Dovenas FAGNIEZ’S FATHER JOSEPH Paris, October 21, 1897. Politics extends its influence even into the quiet domain of literature and of his- tory. The Franco- Russian alliance has given great notoriety to the name of our present Minister of Foreign Affairs. It was prepared by his predecessors, but he has been so fortunate as to be the instrument of the final consummation; he accompanied President Faure to Russia, and played his part in the Olympus of Emperors, Grand Dukes, and Grand Duchesses. M. Hanotaux is a scholar, he was at the Ecole des Chartes ; he entered the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, not in the political division, but merely in the division of the Archives. He made himself so useful, however, he showed such a perfect acquaint- ance with diplomatic documents, that he rose rapidly, and became one of the im- portant officials of the department. He en- tered for a little while the Chamber of Deputies, but, not being an orator, he made little mark there, and he abandoned his post of Deputy to resume his former duties. The constitution allows the President to choose » e his Ministers outside of the Chamber; he never uses this prerogative except for three ministries—of War, of the Navy, of Foreign Affairs. M of Foreign Affairs, is not a Deputy. Hanotaux, who is now Minister His rapid promotion is explainable by his great knowledge of the diplomatic traditions of the Quai d'Orsay, and by the support which he has consequently received from all those who belong to what is called at the Quai d'Orsay “la carriére."" M. Hanotaux never speaks extemporaneously, but when a question is put to him he can always pre- pare a declaration written with the caution and the mixture of vagueness and precision which are considered necessary in diplomacy. Long before he thought of entering upon his high functions, he prepared himself for the laborious task of writing the life of one of
Page 12
354 The Nation. (Vol. 65 No. 1688 the greatest ministers—of Richelieu. Riche- lieu’s correspondence was published a few years ago under the editorship of M. Avenel; but there is still in the Archives of our For- eign Office a mountain of what are called the “Richelieu papers.’’ M. Hanotaux has stu- died carefully all these documents, and is laying the foundation of a very exhaustive biography of the minister of Louis XIII. He has already published two volumes on Riche- lieu, but they take the reader only to the beginning of Richelieu’s first ministry. The Cardinal had an acolyte, a cola- borer, who was familiarly known as the ‘* Eminence grise.’’ Father Joseph remained in the background, but he played a very important part, as is well shown in the work of M. Gustave Fagniez, published in two huge octave volumes, ‘Le Pére Jo- seph et Richelieu.’ Francois Le Clere du Tremblay was born in Paris on the 4th of November, 1577. He was the eldest son of a councillor of the King, first president at the requétes of the Palais, who belonged to one of the old parlementary families, cer- tion of whose members were often employed in diplomacy. Francois Le Clere pursued his studies at the University of Paris, The Ligue had divided France into two camps, and the University of Paris had fallen into a state of great disorder. “Indifference to science, brutality of manners—these fruits of civil war had ruined the studies and the discipline.”” At the age of seventeen Francois Le Clere entered an ‘‘académie,”” a sort of military school, where he made the acquaintance of the great Duke Henri de Rohan, with whom he had afterwards so much to do. He felt very early a religious calling, made the acquaintance of Bérulle, and, after some struggles between his affection for his mother and his vocation, in 1599 he entered the -novitiate of the Capuchins of Orléans. In entering the order of St. Francis, Father Joseph had chosen the institute which was most in harmony with his aspirations. A life of contemplation was not intended for him. He was a man of action; he was made for proselytism, ready to start wher- ever he was called by imperative duties, mixing with the people; he had the soul of an apostle. In 1613 he was appointed Pro- vincial of Touraine, and this dignity gave him occasion to play an important part in the civil wars and commotions of the mi- nority of Louis XIV. The confusion of these wars involved not only the individual aims of the great noblemen, Condé, Mayenne, Bouillon, ete., but also a struggle between the civil and religious powers, between the Church and the State. It was the ambition of the Church to govern the State and to have a cardinal in the ministry. The Duke de Luynes, the favorite of Louis XIII., was the natural enemy ‘of the Queen Mother, who was in the hands of the priests, and who made the fortune of Richelieu. Condé, the father of the Great Condé, was looked upon at first as the natural leader of what might be called the lay cause, the cause of the State. He could have rallied round him the Parlement, which was strongly opposed to the predominance of the Church over the State, the bourgeoisie, the Protestants. Father Joseph was employed to turn him away from the cause which his ancestors had de- fended, even with arms in hand; he fright- ened him with a Gallican schism, and finally | obtained from him a complete submission. Father Joseph had engaged in a double crusade—against the Protestants of France and against the Turks for the reconquest of the Holy Land. We find him by the side of the King in his campaigns against the Protestants of Béarn. “In the campaign of Poitou, Jesuits and Capuchins mingled with the soldiers to encourage them and hear their confession; the expedition had something of the nature of a crusade. At Saumur, it was in the chapel of Notre-Dame des Ardiliers that Louis XIII. held his final council of war, and received the Communion wth all his re- tinue; he left this revered sanctuary, where Father Joseph felt the first movement which would make him the founder of the Calvary, more excited against the Huguenots. A spirit of fanaticism had entered the army; officers and soldiers mutilate the books of the Protestant Governor, Duplessy-Mornay. From Saumur the army goes to Be Thouars, where the Duke de la Trémoille opens the gates and where our Capuchin founds a convent of his order.” This extract gives an idea of the work of Father Joseph. The details of these civil wars are only too well known. Father Jo- seph's efforts against the Turks are less fa- miliar, It may be sald that his whole life was filled with the desire to see the Holy Land torn from the hands of the Mussul- mans. He founded a congregation whose spiritual merits were intended to obtain the deliverance of the Christians of the East; he tried to unite in the same view all the Christian nations of Europe. It is rather painful to think that, since the seventeenth century, the question which preoccupied Fa- ther Joseph has not made a step in advance. The Eastern question was reopened this year, and what has been the result? Turkey has been placed again, by the action of what calls itself the European Concert, among the great Powers, and the Sultan is more powerful now than he was a year ago. “From the day,’’ says M. Fagniez, ‘when the conquest of Constantinople by the Turks, the last wave of the barbarian invasions, inaugurated modern times, to the day when Father Joseph tried to interest the Powers in his projects, Nurope seemed to have no- thing more in common with that Christian Republic of the Middle Ages which still kept the mark of the Roman and Carolingian unity, which revered its representatives in the Pope and in the Emperor, and which was led to the crusades by a common faith.”’ With slight alteration, might not this phrase apply to the year 1897? It can even be said that the feeling of Christian solidarity is much weaker now than it was in the time of Father Joseph. ‘‘The destruction of the Ottoman fleet at Lepanto, the general repro- bation provoked by the alliance of the most Christian Kings with the Sultans, the pro- jects which Sully attributes to Henri IV., numerous writings prove that the divisions of Christendom did not make it forget the solidarity of its members nor the danger of Islamism.” Father Joseph found a chief for the cru- sade in the person of the Duke de Nevers. Charles de Gonzague was the grandson of Margaret Paleologus of Montferrat; his fa- ther was an Italian, Louis de Gonzague, his mother a German, Henrietta of Cleves; he was an ardent Catholic, a man of chivalrous courage and of great ambition. The Duke had made war against the Turks and been wounded in the siege of Buda; the Greeks chose him as a leader in the revolt of one of the provinces of Morea, Maina, a strip of | land which was protected by mountains against the Turks. Father Joseph threw himself with great ardor into this movement of the Greeks. The Duke de Nevers pre- pared an expedition to Morea; his agents visited the bishops and the most important men in Macedonia, Servia, Albania, Dalma- tia, and Croatia. Many promises were made them, but always subordinate to the adhe- sion and participation of the King of France. The complications of the civil wars in France were a great obstacle. Nevers had to take care first of his government of Cham- pagne in France. In 1617 the Duke founded in France the self-styled Order of the Chris- tian Militia, an order similar in some re- spects to that of Malta. It is impossible to enter here into the details of all the efforts made by Nevers in France and in Austria to organize a crusade against the Turks. Alas! the ships which Charles de Gonzague had constructed for the crusade, instead of showing to the Crescent the Christians united under the Cross, served only against the French Huguenots, who perished mise- rably in our civil wars. M. Fagniez, in his elaborate work, gives innumerable particulars about the missions which were organized by Father Joseph in France to obtain a Catholic re- vival in the provinces where the Protestant faith was still dominant. Father Joseph’s spiritual work extended all over Europe, including England, over the East~Asia Mi- nor, Persia, Egypt, Abyssinia, Morocco. The originality of his character is shown in his dual réle of missionary and of diplomat. His spiritual work was helped by his tem- poral work. A man of the world, he could be employed in any diplomatic mission, and he became, in fact, the most powerful in- strument and sometimes the instigator and inspirer of Richelieu, when the great Cardi- nal had to conduct a mighty struggle between France and the powerful House of Austria. While we must greatly commend M. Gustave Fagniez’s work, which has added so much new material to history, we cannot help re- marking the fatiguing confusion which con- stantly interrupts the natural succession of events—a confusion which arises from the dual character of Father Joseph. The reader will often lose himself in it, and it at times becomes almost inextricable. Correspondence. HIGH SCHOOL AND COLLEGE. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: In view of the introduction of the high-school system into New York, the fol- lowing facts may not be uninteresting con- cerning the new classical course in the Girls’ High school in Philadelphia. The course is intended as a thorough prepara- tion for college and runs through four years. It was organized four years ago, but its suecess was not fully evident until this fall, when the first students completely prepared by the High School entered Bryn Mawr College, which, owing to its proximity, is chosen by most of those intending to go to college. The course was, in fact, mapped with the Bryn Mawr requirements:in view, and was most carefully supervised and gone over by Miss Thomas, the President of Bryn Mawr, in conjunction with Dr. Edward Brooks, the Superintendent of Public Edu- cation in Philadelphia. At the time the course was organized, eg aarti a |
Page 13
ee a IN Dae needa iain wii! Rie TEs Nr ahead Nov. 4, 1897] The Nation. 355 the trustees of Bryn Mawr established eight scholarships, of the value of $400 each, to be awarded annually to those students of the school who passed the Bryn Mawr entrance examinations most successfully. The first year of the course is devoted main- ly to grounding in Latin and algebra; five tours weekly are given to each branch, the | remaining time being taken up by four hours of English, four of French, and one of physiology. The second year is still largely Latin and mathematics, five hours of Cesar, two of Latin prose composition. five of plane geometry; two hours being de- voted to English, five to French, and four to German. The third year, five hours a week are spent on Cicero, three on Latin prose and sight reading (the Bryn Mawr language examinations are now entirely at sight). two hours on English, five on French and German, and five on a mathematical re- view. The fourth year’s course is elective, and those students who do not wish to en- ter college have the privilege of transferring to the general course preparatory to entering the normal schools. If elected, the fourth year consists of four hours of English, three ' y of physics or some natural science, five Vir- gil, three Latin prose and sight reading, five German, and five history of Greece and Rome. It has, moreover, recently been de- cided to admit sufficient Greek to pass a col- legiate entrance examination—that is, Greek prose and sight reading in Xenophon and Homer. The Greek may be taken instead of either German or French, the requirement being to present three languages in the matriculation examinations. The six students who came up for matri- culation at Bryn Mawr this fall from the graduating class at the High School were of extremely high standing in the list of the entrance examinations, one of them being first of 250 girls who took the examinations coming from all parts of the country. Her average was 88, the highest ever obtained in the Bryn Mawr entrance examinations. The other five girls passed, one clear of con- ditions, two with but one-half a condition, two with but one. The course is complete in itself, and no preparatory work whatever is done in the grammar schools before entering the High School. The girls enter by application for examination, and the number of applicants this fall was unprecedented. Dr. Brooks Says that the success of this classical course, and the splendid records made in the Bryn Mawr entrance examinations by the stu- dents referred to above, are largely respon- sible for the unusually great number of ap- plications coming from private schools. H. BRYN Mawn, October 25, 1897. AN ETYMOLOGY. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: Every one who has made the tour of Switzerland will have read in his Baedeker the altogether unlikely stories that seek to | connect the rugged mountain near Lucerne. Mount Pilatus, with the name of that worthy Biblical character, Pontius Pilatus. He will soon learn from experience (after it is vointed out to him in the guide-book) the value of the cap of cloud that hovers over Mount Pilatus as a local signal-service sta- tion In the summer of 1896 my colleague in the law department, Prof. Charles E. Graves. | was in Lucerne, and, looking up at Pilatus with its cap of cloud, he translated the phe- nomenon into Latin: mons pilleatus, “‘the capped mountain.”’ This seems to me a most alluring explanation of the name; and if we may suppose that pilleatus was connected by the inhabitants at an early period with the name of Pilate, which must have been well known to even the lowest of them through the medium of Mother Church, all phonetic questions and difficulties will be avoid- ed.—Yours truly, . Epwin W. Fay. WASHINGTON aND Lek UNIVBRSITY, LEXINGTON, Va., October 2o, 1807. NOT GERMAN, BUT AMERICAN. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: John Morley, in his recent Romanes lecture, refers to my book, ‘Machiavelli and the Elizabethan Drama’ (kindly noticed in the Nation of March 25), as “the work of a German writer.” Will you kindly rectify the error and state that the author is an American, who wrote his book in London and Heidelberg for the degree of Ph.D. in the latter place, and is at present instructor in Germanic philology at Adelbert College, Western Reserve University? The book was printed in Weimar and recently review- ed'at length by Prof. Emil Képpel of Strass- burg in the last number of the Hnglische Studien.—Respectfully, EpWARD MEYER. 844 Logan AVE, CLEVELAND, O#10, October 24, 1897. PINES AND SPRUCES. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: In the “Physical Chart of the North Polar Regions’’ accompanying Nansen's ‘Farthest North,’ the northern tree limits of the species of spruce, Picea alba and Picea nigra, are carefully outlined: but these trees are called in the chart “white and biack pines.”” Elsewhere in the chart the Picea obovata is called a “‘pine.”’ Is there any authority for this nomencla- ture? It wilt certainly be very misleading to the average reader, if he is not familiar with botanical names, and he will be led to believe that pines are found very far north of their real limits. Incidentally, let me Suggest that the lack of description of the northern limits of the poplars and willows leaves out a most interesting feature that should be added to the chart, if the chart pretends to be instructive about tree lines. The willows probably occur farther north than any other trees. Rost. T. MORRIs. No. 49 W. 39TH St., New York, October 23, 18¥7. {Pinus formerly included certain ge- nera which have been separated from it. Among these is the genus which our cor- respondent cites above as’ Picea. The species of Picea are properly called spruces; to call them pines would per- petuate the idea, now generally aban doned, that there are no generic dis tinctions between pines and = spruces. True pines do not reach as far north as the spruces. Willows occur very far north, and are there prostrate, dwarfed shrubs. Ep. Nation. Notes. The Century Co.'s November list embraces Bryce’s ‘Impressions of South Africa’; ‘Ja va, the Garden of the East,” by Eliza Ruha- mah Scidmore: ‘The Story of Marie Antoi- nette,, by Anna L. Bicknell; ‘Forty-six Years in the Army,’ by Gen. Schofleld; and James Whitcomb Riley’s ‘Rubd&éiyat of Doc Sifers,’ a long story in verse of a country doctor. Macmillan Co. will soon publish “The Early History of the Hebrews,’ by Prof. A. H Sayce; and, in the course of the winter. ‘The General Manager's Story: Oldtime Re miniscences of Railroading in the United States." They have also in hand ‘Old Eng lish Love Songs,’ selected by Hamilton W Mabie, with illustrations by George Whar ton Edwards; ‘Practical Ethics,” by Henry Sidgwick; and ‘The Making of Abbotsford Incidents in Scottish History,’ by the Hon Mrs. Maxwell Scott, Sir Walter's grand daughter From D. Appleton & Co. we are to have ‘Marriage Customs of all Countries, by the Rey. H. N. Hutchinson; ‘English Litera ture,’ by Edmund Gosse; ‘Baboo Hurry Rungsho Jabdberjee, B.A.’ by PF. Anstey a new edition of F. M. Chapman's ‘Bint Life’ with seventy-five facsimile colored plates; a new edition of Alfred R Conkling 's ‘City Government in the United States,’ with a chapter on Greater New York; and a@ new uniform edition of Gilbert Parker's novels Thomas Whittaker has nearly ready a new (the seventh) edition, revised and enlarged to cover the past quarter of a century, of Dr. McConnell’s ‘History of the American Episcopal Church.’ T. Y¥. Crowell & Co. have arranged wit! ex-President Cleveland to publish imme diately his address entitled “The Self-Mac Man in American Life.’ This will be added to the “What Is Worth While Series.”’ The ‘Life of Napoleon Bonaparte,’ by S Baring-Gould (London: Methuen & Co.; New York: Truslove & Comba), is a folio of some six hundred pages, illustrated with photo- gravures from historical paintings and engraved reproductions of portraits, me dals, drawings from statues and statuettes, caricatures, etc.,. almost without end, and in elegant form. The text is a compilation of what bears particularly upon the develop ment of character in Napoleon, professedly restricting the story of his military career to an outline only. The whole is woven to gether with literary skill, making an anec- dotal life of the hero of remarkable fulness, comprising nearly everything that has been told of him by his contemporaries. The view taken of Napoleon's character is the severe one—what may be called the stan- dard English view—corrected by the investi- gations and publications of the present gene- ration, and reinforced by the judgment of such authorities as Lanfrey and Taine. The noted | gigantic power of the man in intellect and will is fully recognized, but the meanness, selfishness, untruth, unscrupulousness, and immorality are unsparingly exhibited and fix the general tone of the picture. Ernest Ingersoll’s ‘Wild Neighbors: Out door Studies in the United States’ (Macmil- lan) is for the most part a new use of ma terials which have appeared in various ma- | gazines and newspapers, with such revision and amplification as fugitive pieces are apt } to receive when collected in book form.
Page 14
asta The Nation. [Vol. 65, No. 1688 Mr. Ingersoll 1s no new hand at the busi- ness of what may be called interviewing natural history for the purpose of making readable stories; he always writes pleasant- ly, and his recent connection with one of the large dictionaries now before the pub- lic has widened his zodlogical horizon, be- sides strengthening his knack of being ac- curate as far as he goes. The merely “jour- nalistic’’ element is therefore less evident than it used to be in his writings, with corresponding gain. He has become a more careful and reliable writer, but none the less entertaining. His chapters called ‘The Ser-* vice of Tails’ and ‘The Skunk, Calmly Considered,” are among the best in this book, and all the defects of his qualities will not prevent many a reader from en- joying the whole of the articles. It is good popular natural history, written with an easy, perhaps free-and-easy, swing. The il- lustrations do not help us much, and seem somewhat anachronistic in these days when fine work is so readily and inexpensively procurable, being mostly technical cuts made from Baird’s plates of 1857. The best of the lot, to our eye, is not in the book at all, but stamped in low relief on the cover, around the back of which the cougar’s tail curls so fearfully. The whole appearance of the volume is elegant. Mr. Edwin H. Higley’s ‘Greek Prose Com- position’ (Ginn & Co.) deserves mention be- cause it carries out consistently the plan of a series of progressive exercises, consist- ing of short narratives based on passages of the ‘Anabasis’ and the ‘Hellenica.’ The vo- cabulary and grammatical notes are care- fully prepared and judicious. The plan is, of course, not new; it has long been prac- tised by thorough teachers—it is followed in certain German manuals to which Mr. Hig- ley refers, and it is illustrated in the re- cent supplement to Dr. Allinson’s useful ‘Prose Composition.’ But Mr. Higley’s book furnishes new and useful apparatus for prac- tice in the higher forms of preparatory schools, and perhaps also in the freshman year at college. At the same time, it pro- vides a corrective for the lax knowledge of syntax and vocabulary which is often in- duced nowadays by too exclusive practice in reading at sight. The Pamphlet holds its historical position in Germany, and nothing is quite equal to it as a source of information on the ques- tions of the day and the more hidden cur- rents of contemporary civilization. Such publications as Count von Hoensbroek’s ‘Re- ligion oder Aberglaube? Ein Beitrag zur Charakteristik des Ultramontanismus’ (Ber- lin: Walther) will make most readers stare with amazement at the amount of super- stition of the crudest kind still prevalent among a large portion of one of the most civilized nations of the world. The author, a former pupil of the Jesuits, holds Ultra- montanism and Jesuitism responsible for the perpetuation of the worst supersti- tions among the people. He furnishes abun- dant evidence of the credence and support given by the Ultramontane press and by high Chureh dignitaries to the notorious, preposterous, and scandalous ‘“‘revelations’’ concerning freemasonry by the mysterious Diana Vaughan and by Leo Taxil, the latter (since April, 1897) a self-confessed impostor; he also dwells at length upon the teachings of the Church concerning demonology and Satanism. Among the most astounding pro- ductions of modern divines are the ‘Purga- tory’ and ‘Hell’ of J. Bautz, docent at the Academy of Minster (1883), from which quotations are given. ‘Der Katholizismus als Princip des Fort- schritts,’ by Dr. Herman Schell, Professor of Apologetics and formerly rector of the Uni- versity of Wiirzburg (fifth edition, Wiirz- burg: Gébel), discusses, from the point of view of a somewhat liberal German Catholic, the question why Catholics have been rele- gated to such an inferior position in modern intellectual and social life. This fact, re- cognized and investigated years ago by Car- dinal Manning (see Purcell’s ‘Life’), is no longer denied. Recent German school sta- tistics, for example, show that, in round numbers, out of 10,000 Protestants 53 are found on the benches of the Gymnasia or Realschulen,,while for the Catholics the pro- portion is only 32. The Israelites leave both the other confessions far behind, 332 out of every 10,000 attending secondary schools. Dr. Schell’s views have called forth nume- rous replies and critiques, from his core- ligionists as well as from Protestants and from those sharing neither faith. The most extreme liberal standpoint is occupied by Dr. Emil Wabrendorp in ‘Katholizismus als Fortschrittsprincip? Mit einem offenen Briefe an Prof. Dr. H. Schell’ (Bamberg: Handels-Druckerei). The proportionally large number of Se- mites seeking a higher education is also referred to by M. Anatole Leroy-Beaulieu in ‘L’Antisémitisme’ (Paris: Calmann Lévy), in which the statement is made that com- plaints are not infrequently heard from Christian boys and parents in France of the numerous triumphs won by Jewish scho- lars in the lycées. The little volume is a stenographic report (including the ill-na- tured and ill-mannered interruptions in- dulged in by part of the audience) of an ad- dress given before the Catholic Institute. It is a vigorous arraignment of the doctrines, methods, and polemical procedure of the anti-Semites. A good thing has been done by the Hin- richs publishing-house in Leipzig—alike for the work of which it forms a part and for the Biblical student—by reprinting in a separate volume, 8vo, pp. 240, the articles on the original text of the Bible and its translations prepared for the third edition of the ‘Realencyklopadie fiir protestantische Theologie und Kirche.’ This volume gives the fullest and latest information about the Bible and more than a score of its transla- tions, by a dozen such scholars as Buhl, Von Gebhardt, Berger, Dalman, Gregory, Nestle, Pritorius, and others, whose names are a sufficient guarantee for the trust- worthiness of their articles. The third and final volume of ‘Moltke’s Militirische Korrespondenz,’ just issued by Mittler & Sohn, Berlin, contains valuable contributions to the history of the Franco- German war from the suspension of hos- tilities in the spring of 1871 to the complete evacuation of French territory by the Ger- man troops on September 13, 1878. Nothing could be more admirable than the combina- tion of tact and energy shown by the great strategist during the peace negotiations, which were complicated by the ascendency of the mob and the temporary supremacy of the Commune in Paris. The value of Moltke’s correspondence is greatly enhanced by the fact that no full, official history of this period has as yet been published. The first full and accurate statistics of losses in life and property caused by the Franco-German war, the active operations of which lasted about six months, have been recently published by Signor Bodio, Director- General of the Italian Statistical Bureau. France lost 136,000 men, of whom 80,000 were either killed or died of wounds received in battle, 36,000 died of disease in France, and 20,000 died as prisoners of war in Germany. There were also 477,400 men rendered unfit for. service during the war, namely, 138,000 by wounds in battle, 11,400 by wounds and other injuries on the march, and 328,000 by disease, privation, exposure, and similar causes. The losses of the Germans, as com- piled by Bodio from official and thoroughly authentic reports, were 17,255 men killed in battle and 21,023 deceased in ambulances and hospitals, making a total loss of 38,278 by death. The loss of the French was there- fore 97,722 more than that of the Germans. The losses of France in money, so far as they can be estimated, were 2,387 millions of francs for military expenditure, 5,743 millions for war indemnity, 1,156 millions for loans and premiums, 207 millions for public works necessitated by war, 605 millions for com- pensation to private individuals, 2,034 mil- lions fer losses incurred by the state through diminution of revenue, etc., and 535 millions for losses incurred by the communes and re- imbursed by the state, making a sum total of 12,667 millions of francs. This amount does not include the incalculable damage done to agriculture, commerce, and the various branches of industry and the permanent loss of revenue from Alsace and Lorraine. As to victorious Germany, the war indem- nity of 5,743 million francs by no means made good the material losses suffered by that country. We commend these figures to the serious consideration of our Jingoes. In the sixteenth annual report of the Bu- reau of American Ethnology, just published, is a paper by Mufiiz and McGee on ‘‘Primi- tive Trephining in Peru,’ giving evidence that this operation as there practised rep- resents a stage in the ‘‘gradual transition from thaumaturgic manipulation into empi- ric surgery.”” Cosmos Mindeleff describes the “Cliff Ruins of Canyon de Chelley, Arizona,” and concludes that the cliff-dwellers were Indians and not a distinct people. ‘Day Symbols of the Maya Year,’’ by Cyrus Tho- mas, is a discussion of the origin and sig- nificance of the names given to the twenty days of the Mexican month. J. Walter Fewkes describes the “Tusayan Snake Ce- remonies,’’ which he believes have two main purposes, the making of rain and the growth of corn, ophiolatry having little or nothing to do with them. The papers are illustrated, the views of the cliff-dwellings being especially interesting. The California Academy of Sciences has begun publication of its Proceedings in three sections, devoted to Botany, Geology, and Zodlogy respectively. In the first num- ber of the zodlogical series, Gustav Eisen writes upon ‘‘Plasmocytes,’’ a hitherto un- described element in the blood of certain batrachians. ‘‘Submerged Valleys of the Coast of California,” by George Davidson, and “Scientific Names of Latin and Greek Derivation,’”’ by Walter Miller, are among the other papers in the seven numbers al- ready issued. A geological description of Pachuca, in which the physiography, general geology, mines, metallurgy, and other features of the subject are treated by different writers, is BEAN PR LIE TEN ON >
Page 15
FMD RA Ib BIDEN Ow Be Bale 5 PPE Se Nov. 4, 1897] The Nation. 857 contained in the latest Boletin of the Geo- logical Institute of Mexico. It is illustrat- ed by numerous half-tones and some excel- lent contour maps. The Geographical Journal for October opens with an interesting account, by Lieut. Van- deleur, of the recent expedition against the Fulas of Nupe and Ilorin in the basin of the Niger. ‘A Journey in Southwestern Patagonia” is mainly occupied with a de- scription of the physical features of a re- gion in which “five years ago no single white man was living,’’ but where now “the open land is largely occupied’’ by settlers from “England, Scotland, the Falkland Isl- ands, or Australia.’”” R. T. Giinther, hold- ing an Oxford University geographical stu- dentship, gives the results of investiga- tions of the Phlegrwan Fields, near Naples, made in order to determine the quantity of voleanic matter erupted and the relative ages of the crater-slopes and the volcanoes themselves. Each of these papers is ac- companied by numerous illustrations and maps. We have noticed several discrepan- cies between the spelling of names in the text and upon the map of the first paper, as, Egbon, Jakpana, and Lokicha in the text, Egbom, Jakpara, and Lokitsha on the map. The reopening of the medical school for women in St. Petersburg on September 23 may be regarded as an event of historical as well as of educational significance. This institution was founded in 1872 by Count Milyutin, the well-known Liberal Minister of War under Alexander II. With the ac- cession of Alexander III., and partly in consequence of the assassination of his fa- ther, a violent reaction set in, which effect- ually checked the reformatory movements already begun, and in 1882 suppressed the medical school for women as ‘‘a hot-bed of nihilism,” notwithstanding the earnest ef- forts of its founder to save it. The revival of the school is regarded as a good omen and is hailed as a decisive proof of progress both in education and in politics. Women are now admitted to the Univer- sity of Vienna as matriculated students un- der the following conditions: (1) They must be Austrian subjects; (2) they must be eigh- teen years of age; (3) they must have pass- ed an abiturient or final examination in an Austrian gymnasium or in some foreign gymnasium of equal standing. The first of these conditions is thoroughly provincial and preposterous, and will doubtless soon be set aside. Women may be admitted as hearers provided they have finished suc- cessfully the courses of instruction pre- scribed in normal schools for girls or in some other school of equal rank. If they enter, they must attend at least ten lec- tures a week in some department of the phi- losophical faculty. The number of women already registered for the winter semester is thirteen, of whom eleven are hearers and two matriculates. Four of them takecourses in mathematics, four in philosophy, two in physics, two in history and Germanistic stu- dies, and one in natural science, including zoology, botany, and mineralogy. The session of the Icelandic Althing that has just closed gave promise at one time of settling the question of a revision of the Constitution, with which every session for the past sixteen years has been engaged. In place of the usual radical proposal, a mo- derate measure was introduced, which in- cluded, however, one of the essential fea- » tures of home rule—an independent resi- dent minister for Iceland, in place of the present Danish Minister, who combines with Icelandic affairs the Department of Justice. Although the bill failed to pass the lower house in a form that made it possible for the upper house to accept it, there seems to be every prospect that a new election will be called, and that the advocates of this moderate measure will receive the sup- port of the people. The death of the Danish historian Adolf Ditley Jorgensen, which occurred in Copen- hagen on October 5, is naturally connected with that of our own historian Justin Win- sor. Nor is the association suggested mere- ly by the accident of their dying in the same month. There was much in the per- sonal character and in the nature of the work of the two men to suggest a compari- son. Like Winsor, this Danish scholar was a patient and conscientious student of his- torical sources, omitting nothing that could contribute to a fuller understanding of the subject under discussion. As Keeper of the Public Records he brought order out of chaos, and thus more than any other one person determined modern historical me- thods in Denmark. He was also the author of a number of articles, monographs, and independent works, all of which are charac- terized by thoroughness and originality. At first his attention was directed to the ear- lier periods in connection with the develop- ment of the Scandinavian Church, laws, folk songs, heraldry, etc. Owing to the fact that he was a Schleswiger by birth, he was spe- cially interested in the Schleswig- Holstein question, about which he published several monographs. Of great value as _ original studies are his biographies of Georg Zoega, Thorwaldsen's early friend in Rome, the poet Johannes Evald, and the statesman Peter Schumacher Griffenfeld. He was also known as the author of popular historical works. At the time of his death, Jorgensen was en- gaged on the great History of Denmark (‘Det Danske Riges Historie’), of which he was one of the editors. Admirers of Ian Maclaren should be well pleased with the Kalendar for 1898 which bears Dr. Watson's nom de plume (Dodd, Mead & Co.). It consists of a dozen folio rubricated leaves loosely bound with corded silk, each having a decorative border and a vignette pertinent to Dr. Watson's writings These are drawn upon for a daily text, with marginal readings of greater length duly credited to the respective works. The de- signer, Mr. William Snelling Hadaway, is to be praised in the main, especially in his village and house sketches; but his skill is not equal to mountain delineation with strokes that tell, every one. Other calen- dars before us for the coming year are from R. H. Russell, No. 9 Rose Street—one, the “Sports and Seasons Calendar,’ with large co- lored plates by several hands,and mostly cle- ver and taking; the other, Mr. E. W. Kem- ble’s “Coon Calendar,’ in which this art- ist’s mastery of the negro physiognomy is kept more in check than in some of his slighter efforts. —The declaration of the faculty of the Karlsruhe Polytechnic School in favor of the Gymnasia, as compared with the Ober- Realschulen, as preparatory schools for high- er technical institutions, is truly surprising. In spite of many points of inferiority in our secondary schools, we have reason to con- gratulate ourselves on not being hampered in our development by quite such numerous and formidable historical legacies and pre- judices—so arduous is the task which has been forced upon the Germans in adapting certain of their educational institutions to modern requirements. Prof. Schittler of Brunswick shows (in No. 5 of the Péda- gogisches Archiv for 1897) that the above decision was made mainly in view of the less advantageous position, social and offi- cial, of engineers, architects, etc., in com- parison with those professions for which a gymnasial preparation is required. In fact, the Karlsruhe faculty admit that their de- liberations might have resulted differently were the Government willing to accept the Realschule diploma also for the admission of candidates to other than technical branches, such at least as the higher administration of the finances, the positions of higher teachers of mathematics and the sciences, and the medical profession. It cannot be, and is not, claimed that these schools do not furnish the higher technical tnstitu- tions with well-prepared students. On the contrary, it is found that the first year's lectures, adapted for graduates of the Gym- nasia, are too elementary for those coming from the Realgymnasia and Ober-Realschu- len. At the Technische Hochschule of Stutt- gart the regular courses for the graduates of these three classes of schools, in the or- der named, are arranged for nine, eight, and seven semesters respectively, requiring two whole semesters more work of Gymnasium graduates than of those who have com- pleted the course at the Realschule —The session of the Académie des in- scriptions et Belles-Lettres held on October 1 was of somewhat exceptional interest. M. Max Collignon presented to the Academy the photograph of a funerary group in lime- stone which is preserved in the Graeco-Ro- man museum at Alexandria. The monu- ment, the figures of which are larger than life, represents a veiled woman seated in an ttitude of mourning near a young girl who is standing. It is a new example of the of which the so-called Penelope of the Vatican is a well-known specimen, which abounded in the fourth century in Greek cemeteries. This type of the draped woman is closely analogous to that of the figures of women which appear on Attic steles of the fourth century, and recalls in certain respects the style of the school of Skopas. The Alexandrian group, executed in Egypt by a Greek artist con- temporary with the first Ptolemys, is an interesting document for the history of Greeo-Egyptian sculpture. It shows how, at the beginning of the Alexandrian evolu- tion, the influence of types that were strict- ly Greek sti imposed itself on the art of Hellenized Egypt. M. Salomon Reinach fol- lowed M. Collignon with a paper entitled “Une Image de la Vesta Romaine,’ based upon a passage in the ‘Fasti’ of Ovid which has hitherto escaped notice. Ovid says that there existed at Alba statuettes of the god- dess Vesta veiling her face with her two hands. This gesture, anterior to the influ- ences of Hellenic art, was probably borrow- ed from the old wooden statue of Vesta which stood among the twelve Roman gods in the Forum. It occurs also in the hitherto unexplained altar of Mavilly in the Cdte- d@’Or. This altar, on which the twelve Roman gods figure, seems to reproduce the archaic images of the Forum. The singular gesture of the goddess who covers her eyes with statues, funerary
Page 16
358 N The at1ion. [Vol. 05, No. 1688 her hands, was not understood even by the ancients themselves. M. Reinach explains it by the special function of Vesta as goddess of the hearth: she is protecting her eyes from the smoke. There was a god of the hearth among the Latins called Ceculus, a name which the ancients explained by his half-closed eyes. The god shut his eyes, as the goddess covers hers, to keep the smoke out of them. M. Reinach added that up to now no image of the Roman Vesta has been found, and spoke strongly of the importance of the Mavilly altar, which presents to us this very ancient type for the first time. ~—Maurice Courant, the eminent French scholar in Chinese and Korean, has recently completed his magnificent ‘Bibliographie Coréenne’ (Paris: Ernest Leroux), in three quarto volumes of about 500 pages each. It gives in Chinese, Japanese, Roman, and Korean letters the names of all the books known to have been published in the Land of Morning Calm, from early medizval times until a. D. 1890, with description and analysis of the more important ones. Be- sides a luminous and very interesting intro- duction, there is a concluding chapter sur- veying the whole field. The occasional re- productions of old maps, tables, and dia- grams are also very welcome to the student of Korean history. After a knowledge of this scholarly work of M. Courant, and fa- miliarity with the history of book-making in the once hermit kingdom, it will be dif- ficult to believe that printing with movable types is a purely European invention. Hun- dreds of years before the use of “‘living’’ type was known to Gutenberg or to Koster, the Koreans used it for printing their books, a good collection of which is now in the British Museum. M. Courant (who is inter- preter to the French Legation in Tokyo) thus concludes his survey of the fruits of intellect in the peninsula: “The perspicuity of the Korean mind ap- pears in the fine printing of the books, in the perfection of the alphabet, the simplest which exists, in the conception of movable types, which it was the first to think of. Korea’s part in the civilization of the far East has been considerable; if the situation had been analogous to that in Europe, Korean ideas and inventions would have stirred all the neighboring countries, but the barriers raised by pride were higher, and respect for the past imposed immobility. Korea had no dealings with foreigners but to be pillaged and enslaved; she has lived within herself; her inventions have not gone beyond her frontiers.”’ —In a recent lecture, Dr. Carl Ranke, who two years ago joined Dr. Hans Meyer's ex- pedition for the exploration of Central Bra- zil, spoke of having paid particular atten- tion to the senses of the Indians, especially their sight. He noticed, as others before him had done, that an Indian can see many things that Europeans cannot; he can foi- low the course of a fish in turbulent waters and hit it with his arrow; he can spy an animal in a thicket that to our eyes seems impenetrable; he can see in the ground and the grass, and follow them, tracks of man and animals that to us are invisible, and so forth. The psychology of our fathers dis- posed of these phenomena bluntly by de- claring off-hand that savages had sharper senses than we have. But Dr. Ranke ex- amined the eyes of some of these Indians and found, to his surprise, that there was hardly any difference between their direct powers of sight and ours. What enables them to observe thosé phenomena which elude us is their superior practice and fa- cility in accommodating the vision to dif- ferent distances. Dr. Ranke holds that this focussing facility is of much greater impor- tance than has heretofore been believed. Moreover, he thinks that what gives the In- dians another practical advantage over us in the intercourse with nature is that they are not accustomed to look at a landscape as a whole, as we are, but give their undi- vided attention to a particular detail. Ranke also declares that the short-sightedness so prevalent in civilized countries is not a dis- ease or a failing, but a salutary adaptation of the eyes to conditions of life that re- quire constant work at close range. BACON’S AMERICAN CHRISTIANITY. A History of American Christianity. By Leonard Woolsey Bacon. New York: The Christian Iiterature Company. 1297. Published in connection with a series of American Church Histories, Dr. Bacon's book is an attempt to sum up in a single volume the course of events which have been described in the preceding separate volumes, each treating of a particular church. It is a bright and entertaining summary of the general religious history of the United States and the outlying parts, written in a vigorous and slashing style, the homeliness of which, at times, is carried far, as where it is written of Whitefield that “Belcher, the royal governor, fairly slobbered over him, with tears, embraces, and kisses.’’ We do not seem to find much in the book that could not have been gathered easily from the other volumes of the series, and, as com- pared with those, it is necessarily thin and vague to such an extent that those who have read the other volumes in order will wonder what reason this one has to exist. But in none of the other volumes has the writer been so much in evidence; and his tone, so confident and positive, is, if sometimes disagreeable, frequently amusing and always enlivening. Considered as a whole, the temper of the book is catholic and irenical. There runs through it a sentiment of regret in view of the divisions of the evangelical churches and the waste of meeting-houses and minis- ters in the smaller towns and villages. .There is more than the desire, there is the dis- position, to treat the different churches fairly, both as regards their doctrines, their purposes, and their mutual affinities and op- positions. Nor is this fairness confined to the evangelical churches. Unitarians and Universalists may feel that scanty justice has been done their respective churches in so far as they are very summarily dis- missed, but the confession is ample that the moral quality of either sect has falsified all the predictions of their first opponents. The writer quotes his father, Dr. Leonard Bacon, ‘“‘one of the most strenuous of the early disputants’’ opposing liberal opinions, as saying of the Unitarians ‘‘that it seemed as if their exclusive contemplation of Jesus Christ in his human character as the exam- ple for our imitation had wrought in them an exceptional beauty and Christ-likeness of living.’ This was, however, ill-considered praise, seeing that the early Unitarian con- templation of Jesus Christ was not exclu- sively that of his human character. It has become so now. So venerable a joke as that about the difference between Unitarians and Universalists is not improved by the re- moval of its sting. The true reading is, that Universalists think God too good to damn them, while Unitarians think they are too good to be damned. Dr. Bacon has it, “that the Universalist holds that God is too good to damn a man; the Unitarian holds that men are too good to be damned’’—which may be a truer statement than the other, but has not its humorous application. Dr. Bacon is clearly of the opinion that much was lost to either party by the sepa- ration of the orthodox and liberal Congre- gationalists, questioning if the orthodox party ‘‘would have been worse off if Chan- ning and his friends had continued to be recognized as the liberal wing of its clergy,’’ and if the Unitarians ‘‘would not have been a great deal better off if they had remained in connection with a strong and conserva- tive right wing, which might counterbalance the exorbitant leftward flights of their more impatient and erratic spirits.’’ It is when he comes to these “impatient and erratic spirits’’ that the strain upon Dr. Bacon’s catholicity is greater than he can bear. Thus we read of Emerson: ‘“‘Without any formal demission of the mi- nistry he retired to his literary seclu- sion at Concord, from which he brought forth in books and lectures the oracular ut- terances which caught more and more the ear of a wide public, and in which, in casual- seeming parentheses and obiter dicta, Chris- tianity and all practical religion were con- demned by sly innuendo and half-respectful allusion, by which he might, ‘without sneer- ing, teach the rest to sneer.’ ”’ This is the kind of thing which is best criticised by merely quoting it. Few will recognize in it the Emerson of their ac- quaintance, especially where the writer whose main haunt was “the supremacy of ethics,” is denounced as an enemy of “‘prac- tical religion.”” We also read of his ‘gay and Skimpolesque reply’’ to a criticism of his Divinity School address of 1838 as ‘‘an illustration of that flippancy with which he chose to toy in a literary way- with mo- mentous questions.’’ The page devoted to Theodore Parker is, if possible, more awry in its perspective than that devoted to Emerson. We are told that “he liked ‘to make people’s flesh crawl,’’’ and _ that, “Even in his advocacy of social and public reforms, which was strenuous and sincere, he delighted so to urge his cause as to in- flame prejudice and opposition against it.’ Here is a manifest contradiction in terms and an accusation singularly false, Parker having often kept himself in the background in furtherance of some public end. In the same connection .we have a statement which is a tissue of mistakes and misrepresenta- tions. It is as follows: “The immediate reaction of the Unitarian clergy from the statements of his [Parker's] sermon, in 1841, on ‘The Transient and Per- manent in Christianity,’ in which the su- pernatural was boldly discarded from his belief, was so general and so earnest as to give occasion to Channing’s exclamation, ‘Now we have a Unitarian orthodoxy!’ ”’ Now, so far was Parker in that epoch- making sermon from boldly discarding. the supernatural that Channing wrote regret- ting that he did not give some clear expres- sion to his belief in the miracles, adding, “His silence under such circumstances makes me fear that he does not believe them.’’ The fact is that he did believe them at that time as historical events, but as belonging to the “transient” part of Christianity, which got from them no “permanent” sup- port. Channing’s ‘‘Now we have a Unita-
Page 17
Nov. 4. 1897] The Nation. 359 rian orthedoxy’’ was no cry of satisfaction over the Unitarian uprising against Par- ker, but an expression of regret. Unitarian- ism, he said, “began as a protest against the rejection of reason—against mental slavery. It pledged itself to progress as its life and end; but it has gradual- ly grown stationary, and now we have a Unitarian orthodoxy.” He also wrote of Parker: “I trust the account of attempts to put him down is in the main a fiction. Let the full heart pour itself forth.” From the fact that Dr. Bacon passes di- rectly from his account of Parker to some reflections on the relation of the church to slavery, it may be inferred that he was not unaware that Parker had a part to play in this, though mention of it he has none. There is no aspect of the history of American Christianity of which Dr. Bacon writes with so much feeling and passion as of its relation to slavery. He does not make of it a subject by itself, but returns to it from time to time at different stages of his narrative. The general thesis he maintains is, that the conduct of the churches in their concern with slavery was wonderfully fine and brave. There were, of course, individu- al exceptions, and the whole body of the Southern churches finally pronounced for slavery as a divine institution in the most decisive manner. But, even here, if the manes of the proslavery preachers of the South are not well satisfied with the tribute that is paid to them, they must be exorbi- tant in their demands. For example: ‘‘There seems no reason to doubt the entire sin- cerity with which the Southern church, in all its sects, had consecrated itself with re- ligious devotion to the maintenance of that btorrible and inhuman form of slavery which had drawn upon itself the condemnation of the civilized world.””’ This devout persua- sion of the Southern churches that their ‘peculiar mission’’ was to “conserve the in- stitution of slavery,’’ as declared by the Southern Presbyterians, is contrasted sharp- ly, as well it may be, with the almost uni- versal anti-slavery sentiment of the South- ern churches before 1833, as seen from Dr. Bacon’s mount of vision. In the eighteenth century a few instances are given of cleri- cal opposition to slavery, and we are assured that “They are simply expressions of the universal judgment of those whose atten- tion had been seriously fixed upon the sub- ject.”” But it was in the decade following the adoption of the Missouri Compromise that the American church won its proudest laurels as an anti-slavery organization. “The persistent attempt to represent this period as one of prevailing apathy and iner- tia on the subject of slavery is a very fla- grant falsification of history.’’ Was it not the common practice to take the Fourth of July for an antf-slavery holiday in some New England towns, in Boston several of the churches uniting in a common service? Strangely enough, and yet not so strangely, all things considered, the American Co- lonization - Society is barely mentioned among the anti-slavery forces of the time. This may be because Dr. Bacon, to vary a phrase of Eugénie de Guérin, has a pain in his father’s side whenever reference is made to that misshapen darling of his fa- ther’s heart. Indeed, there is a suggestion of paying off old scores in the whole treat- ment of the slavery question, and especially of those who showed the pretensions of the Colonizationists to be utterly fallacious and often insincere. But, if we concede that the few scattered instances of anti-slavery preaching from 1820 to 1830 establish the prevalence of a widespread anti-slavery sentiment in the churches, it becomes all the harder to ac- count for “the Southern apostasy’ which Dr. Bacon dates from the year 1833. “Such was the swift progress of this innovation that in a few years, we might almost say months, it had become, not only prevalent, but violently and exclusively dominant in the church of the Southern States, with the partial exception of Kentucky and Tennes- see.” How to account for this sudden change is a problem to which Dr. Bacon ap- plies himself with easy confidence. He is not of those who feel that ‘‘the furious vi- tuperations of a small but very noisy fac- tion of anti-slavery men” are sufficient of themselves to explain the moral revolution, though they were an important factor in the charge. Panic terror, caused by the Nat Turner insurrection of 1831, was the most important. Such an explanation, if valid, would prove the utter unreality of the much vaunted anti-slavery sentiment of the preceding period. It takes no account, ex- cept a casual mention of the cotton-gin, of the causes which operated in the South to make slavery popular and divine. It does not make plain why ‘‘the strange and swift- ly spreading moral epidemic’’ was not con- fined to the South. “A deep passion of honest patriotism’’ is set down as the main reason for this; then, too, there was ‘worthy solicitude lest the bonds of intercourse be- tween the churches North and South should be ruptured.”’ ‘“‘Withal, there was a spreading and deep- ening and most reasonable disgust at the reckless ranting of a little knot of anti- slavery men, having their headquarters at Boston, who, exulting in therr irresponsi- bility, scattered loosely appeals to men’s vindictive passions, and filled the unwilling air with clamors against church and minis- try and Bible and law and government, de- nounced as ‘pro-slavery’ all who declined to accept their measures or their persons, and, arrogating to themselves exclusively the name of abolitionist, made that name, so long a title of honor, to be universally odious.”’ - There is a foot-note to this railing accu- sation which assures us that the story of Mr. Garrison’s life, ‘‘as told by his family and friends, is a monstrous falsification,” and that ‘‘one of the best sources of au- thentic material for this chapter of history is ‘James G. Birney and his Times.""" No mention, however, is made of the fact that, in the history of the anti-slavery conflict no expression is more classical than Bir- ney’s dgnunciation of the American church as “the bulwark of slavery."" The most un- assailable position will probably be found somewhere between this extreme and that of Dr. Bacon’s eloquent encomium. It would be a pleasure to follow Dr. Bacon into other parts of the wide field over which he careers so joyously, nis trumpet giving no uncertain sound, to whatever onset we are called. The majority of his conclusions would be found sensible and just, especially where principles are involved. Dealing with persons, he is more apt to swing violently to one side or the other, to praise or blame too much. There are points at which the fuller treatment of Walker's ‘Congregation- al Christianity." Allen’s ‘Jonathan Edwards,’ and Tiffany's ‘Episcopal Church’ is essential to a good understanding of the course of events. In conclusion there is some discus- sion of the problem of Christian unity, not without reflections more or less caustic on the absurdities in which this problem has been involved. Dr. Bacon does not think that a quadrilateral! of four tremendous sects would be an improvement on the 143 enume- rated in the eleventh United States Census. It is a sign of the times deserving notice that any unionof Christians not including the Ro- man Catholics is deprecated by this New England Congregationalist as an unworthy end; and it is another that the Chicago Parliament of Religions is hailed as pre- eminently a triumph of the most wholesome and beneficent forces working in the body of religion as the history of an eventful cen tury draws onward to its close MR. LODGE'S ESSAYS. Certain Accepted Heroes, and Other Essays in Literature and Politics. By Henry Ca- bot Lodge. Harper & Brothers. 1897 This volume contains essays of two dif- ferent sorts. If, in ignorance of their au thorship, we were to confine our attention to those of a literary. critical, and historical character, we should be inclined to pro- nounce them the work of a clever but some- what audacious beginner, determined at all hazards to attract the public attention Published anonymously, they would have attracted notice and aroused some wonder as to their authorship, on account of a vein of boyish sophistry running through them, re- markable less often for its plausibility than its transparency. In his essay on “Certain Accepted Heroes,”” Mr. Lodge holds up to contempt the literary tradition which makes heroes of Achilles and other classical cha- racters, whom he demonstrates to have been in reality bullies, blackguards. and cowards In “The Last Plantagenet” his thesis is that Richard Ill. deserves our admiration as a statesman, and that “in the supreme mo- ment’ we sympathize with him and not with his critics and opponents, such as “the respectable Richmond.” In “Shakespeare's Americanisms” the argument is pressed with such vigor that it results in seeming to prove that there is no such thing as cor- rect usage in language. In “English Elec- tions’’ Mr. Lodge maintains that less money is spent on elections here than in England. The reader will find, however, that the verified statistics given relate only to Eng- lish elections, and that the author's proof is made by his own unsupported assertion that the expenditure in one eountry is “just about the amount” actually spent in the other. If the ideas and theories which have inspired these essays are not original, their method is very much so; the style is clear, and were they the ventures of an unknown tyro, many a puzzled reader would cer- tainly exclaim, “Well, well! What next?” But Mr. Lodge is no young and unknown man. He is one of the Massachusetts Sena- tors, a man of mature age, and a successor of Webster and Choate. The volume con- tains other essays than those just men- tioned, which set forth his views on graver matters connected with the commonweal. The book, therefore, muat be taken on one side as a literary excursus by a public man of a rather old sort, and, for the re- maining essays, as a statement by a Senator representing one of the most important com- munities in the Union of his opinions on some of the leading questions of the day, deni baa ee a a
Page 18
360 The Nation. [Vol. 65, No. 1688 especially higher education and foreign af- fairs. In these lies the real interest of the book. They are public declarations by a public man, designed to illuminate and throw into strong relief, not merely the author’s view of certain public questions, but his estimate of his own career, position, and relation to them. Mr. Lodge is a graduate of Harvard, yet in public life he is known as a beneficiary and defender of ‘‘machine’’ politics, as a protectionist, and as a Jingo. Though con- nected by birth, training, and social life with all the interests and ideas in the com- munity he represents for which his Uni- versity stands, his career is that of a strict party man, dependent for place on the con- tinued favor of that quasi corporation one of the main functions of which is to stifle independence of thought and action, such as a university is designed to foster. In the world to which Mr. Lodge naturally belongs he has, through this circumstance, as he has advanced in power, become gradually less and less at home, until it is mainly by non-political means, such as literature or social life may afford, that he is able to maintain his connection with it. He 1s, at the same time, one of a small band who reconcile themselves to this situation by cul- tivating the conviction that only by this sacrifice can they benefit their fellow-men and country according to the designs of Providence. This conviction it is which en- ables them to claim whatever good they ac- complish as their own; the evil that ensues they attribute to the necessity to their high aims of constant codperation with baser natures. A liberally educated man in such a situation, turning essayist and pub- licist, would be likely to betray in some way a sensitiveness to the criticism which his attitude must naturally call forth, and such sensiliveness Mr. Lodge does show. Indeed, these essays may be described as a covert apologia; any one who desires to understand them must put himself, as far as possible, in the author’s position, and bear in mind the powerful impulses to self-exculpation of some sort which alone can explain much of what he says. The essay on “A Liberal Education’ was originally an address, delivered before the Phi Beta Kappa Society at Harvard in 1894. It was reported at the time to have caused surprise among the members of that learned society—why, it is difficult to see, for it is exactly what might have been expected by them from the source from which it came. Though not so in form, it is in substance a defence by the author of himself in the guise of an attack on a body whom he de- scribes as critics of America and Ameri- can institutions. This is a well-known rhe- torical device, and its value depends wholly on the skill with which it is used. Of this the reader will judge for himself. A good illustration of the way in which he employs this weapon is found in the statement that the ‘‘national self-assertion’’ of Jefferson Brick and Elijah Pogram was “‘infinitely bet- ter’’ than ‘“‘the opposite spirit, which turns disdainfully even from the glories of na- ture because they are American and not foreign, and which looks scornfully at the Sierras because they are not the Alps.” What he desires to do evidently is to divert the attention of the hearer from the charge brought against himseif of being the spokes- man of the ideas of Brick’and Pogram, and to arouse jndignation agsipst the person making the charge, to whom he accordingly imputes a character and motives of the most odious kind. The whole essay is full of re- marks about the superiority of Performance to Criticism, which would be rather myste- rious without this key. He talks about the work of criticism as if he thought that the true object of a liberal education was to teach the young to do something or other without any critical inquiry into the nature of the means to be employed—a manifest im- possibility; and his statement that it was not Criticism that won the battle of New Or- leans, though true, does not throw much light on his drift. What he really means here is not that criticism in itself is bad (the whole essay being a. criticism of the present management of Harvard and of his audience, that Would be out of the question), but that it is bad when directed against himself. The moment that this is under- stood, the obscurer passages of the essay be- come perfectly clear. They should be com- pared with some of those in the essay on Richard III., through which the idea seems to run that if the author can show that the critics of the accepted villain of early Eng- lish history were mistaken, his own are probably at fault. The chain of reasoning is: Richard III. was criticised as a villain; the facts now show that his critics were wrong, and that he was a statesman; I too have been criticised; this shows that my critics are wrong, and that I am a states- man. Directly connected with Mr. Lodge’s sen- sitiveness to criticism is another character- istic trait. He evidently in his own mind personifies his country as himself. This sub- stitution of the Ego for the non-Ego throws an enormous amount of light on his method of reasoning in politics. When he wishes to investigate a question of public policy, he is obliged to examine it only so far as to en- able him to detect what view of it suits him; the view in question is at once im- puted to ‘‘America.’’ Whenever he wishes to tell us what America thinks, he tells us what he thinks himself; the ‘‘true American”’ is really no other than the author. Con- versely, to be anti- or un-American is to criticise the ‘author. In the same way, of course, “‘the people’? means Mr. Lodge; any one who wants to know their aims, hopes, fears, and desires can very easily ascertain them by ascertaining those set forth in this book. When he denounces as too “abun- dant’”’’ the current criticism of America, what he means is that his own critics are too abundant; when he warns the Phi Beta Kappa that the great danger of the time is that they will undervalue ‘‘their coun- try,”” what he has in mind is the @anger that they will undervalue him. This pa- triotic identification runs through the essay on what he calls “Our Foreign Policy.’’ In it he advances the proposition, which no one is likely to dispute, that the United States has a distinct historical foreign policy. He then describes a Jingo foreign policy of his own, calls it ‘‘ours,” and pronounces it to be the true American policy; the inference being that no true American is at liberty to criticise him for stating it. The fact that public men, whether in Church or State, gradually come to identify themselves with what they represent, is well known, but we have never met with so remarkable an instance of it as in Mr. Lodge’s book. -Were his subordination to himself of the State more veiled, it would be ! rhetorically more effective, but it seems to spring from an uncontrollable tendency. The author has gone far beyond ‘‘ L’Etat c’est moi,”’ and identifies with himself not merely the United States, but a whole hemisphere. It is on the truth of this implied premise that his conclusions really depend. If he is right, the future of the western half of the world is bound up in his own, and it is na- tural enough that he should think his for- eign policy more important than that of Washington, and should seize the opportuni- ty afforded by the invitation of his Univer- sity to lecture it on its hostility to and ig- norance of the true American view of the higher education. In the end we see very plainly how Mr. Lodge’s critical is connected with his political position. A statesman’s powcr must rest on the support of those who think him a patriot, and not on the favor of those to whom what he calls a patriot is nothing more than a bully or an egotist. LAND POWER AND SEA POWER. The Effect of Maritime Command on Land Campaigns since Waterloo. By Major C. E. Callwell, R.A. With Maps and Plans. Charles Scribner’s Sons. Pp. 380. Mejor Callwell’s book is in the nature of a supplement to Captain Mahan’s brilliant work on the influence of the Sea Power. Taking up events where Mahan dropped them, at the fall of Napoleon, an outline is given of the wars waged since that time in which naval power played a part. It is not strange that military men should feel the impulse to continue the story, though the effect of doing so may not turn out to be quite what is intended. It may be questioned whether Captain Mahan was not as wise in choosing the limit of his work as he was able in its presentation. He covered the period of the great naval wars when sailing ships were at the height of their glory and romance, when the old seaman- ship fascinated the imagination, and when great fleets rivalled land armies in the hosts of combatants engaged. Left where Mahan left it, the effect was a most stirring one, and the reader was persuasively induced to leap to the conclusion that great peoples should rival each other in building great navies as sedulcusly as they have run the race of turning ordinary standing armies into armed nations. When, however, the argument is applied to a long list of great and petty conflicts of modern times, the in- tellectual process results in a certain amount of disillusion. We find ourselves returning to the older opinion that, for nearly all the nations of the world, a navy is only ancil- lary to the army, with a partial and excep- tional role to play; that Continental Powers have not been unwise in avoiding the enor- mous burdens which the building of great fleets would add to their budgets; and that it is doubtful if any nation can be at once a great land and sea power. There is a limit to the expenditure for military pur- poses which even the richest nation can make. There is also a limit to the extent to which it can saddle the cost of its present armaments and wars upon posterity. More than one European Power is perilously near the brink of insolvency, and the gravest question which living statesmen have to meet is this ef the extent to which public debts can be increased if the necessity shall arise to meet the cost of a great war. Eyerybody knows that this consideration ig deve
Page 19
neni detteaca a iAkeee ceebe bist sie: AP a ee Nov. 4, 1897] The Nation. 3861 perhaps the most potent in preserving the general peace, even at the cost of many a sacrifice of national pride and interest. Before yielding to the impulse to try to rival Great Britain upon the ocean, states- men of other countries will carefully analyze the asserted influence of dominant sea power on land operations. Major Callwell’s book, by the very extent of its claims, tends, as we have said, to weaken the effect of the more plausible general argument which Captain Mahan had so well put. He claims for naval armaments the credit of success when their work has been the convoy of provisions as much as if they had won a battle between fleets. An improvised flotil- la on a river or a gathering of private arm- ed vessels in the ASgean Sea helps the theory as well as the formal array of iron- clads. It is hard to say why the laying of a common pontoon bridge or using a flat- boat ferry may not be called a naval ope- ration and be cited also to show the influ- ence of sea power upon land operations. There is a certain degree of truth in all this, but the truth is not found in the implied conclusion that great navies are a necessity to modern nations. We are led to discrimi- nate, and to separate the operations of war which call for fleets from those in which some inferior or temporary use of water transportation may be useful. The uses of these last are interesting, but it is not worth while to claim that they show the advantage a great nation has in being dominant in sea power. To “rule the waves’’ properly means to be superior in organized squadrons of ships-of- war, as Great Britain now for some genera- tions has been. What would be the con- sequence of France, Germany, or Russia trying to excel her in this respect? If done at all, it must be thoroughly done. Half measures are worse than none. If the naval supremacy is to be taken from England, her rival must be prepared to beat her in number of ships and in their fighting ef- ficiency at all times and places. Napoleon, by combining the fleets of France and Spain, succeeded in sending to sea more ships and guns than England could give Nelson, but Trafalgar proved that this was not enough. The fact is, it is doubtful if any of the great Continental peoples of Europe takes kindly to the sea. Then England herself is the best proof that even the richest nation cannot stand the strain of trying to lead in armaments toth by land ard sea. It was only the other day that the Spectator said that England frankly disclaims the wish or the ability to land on a foreign shore an army large enough to be seriously formidable to a pow- erful neighbor. Her naval power is in chief measure a defensive power. The old name of ‘‘wooden walls’”’ truly showed that it grew out of her insular position originally,and has progressed by the action and reaction of her colonial policy. Because she was strong on the ocean, she successfully planted colonies when others failed; and because she nourish- ed many and distant colonies, her fleets were incréased and made stronger and stronger. So long as wars are waged, domi- nance in ships will be a necessity of Brit- ish policy, and whoever would rival her in it must calculate upon going beyond not only all she has hitherto done, but all that her wealth would make possible in a further ptruggle for Jeadersbip. She now acts op the policy of being able to put in commis- sion a heavier naval armament than any two of her possible rivals could do. She thus provides for any probable combination against her, for it would be a very strange conjuncture of European affairs in which she could not find one ally out of three great Powers. This condition of things is fortunately one that tends powerfully to preserve the peace of the world. The dominance of the seas is not an end in itself, but a means to an end. The great peaceful mercantile com- merce of the world, and leadership in it, are of capital importance to the richest commercial nation of the Old World. She could greatly annoy any opponent, but a conquest such as France inflicted upon Prus- sia at Jena, or Germany upon France at Sedan, is wholly beyond her power. She knows this so well that it never enters in- to her plans. It was the combination of all Europe against Napoleon's unbridled ambi- tion that made a Waterloo possible, and there is little danger of the rise of such an- other conqueror. But it is not only true that a great naval power cannot afford to be also the organizer of vast land armies: there is a limit soon reached in the possibilities of transporting armies to distant shores. Even when Eng- land and France united in the invasion of the Crimea, the army that fought at the Alma bore no proportion to the military strength of Russia. Russia's fatal weakness was that she had aspired to be a naval power, and had just fleet enough at Sebastopol to com- mit her to fighting the duel out at that re- mote outpost. Had she been without it, and tolled on her adversaries into the steppes of southern Russia, a very different story of that war might have been written. It was the point of honor to protect her few ships and dock-yards in the Black Sea that proved her ruin. A great naval power may land a comparatively small army almost where it will, but when the small army advances into the interior, it meets a large one and retreats to the cover of its ships or is cap- tured. The boot is then on the other foot, and the theme of an entertaining book would be the importance of land power to the ultimate success of naval incursions. History, then, seems fairly to teach the comfortable doctrine that it is not given to a colonizing nation to be at once a great sea and land power, and that this natural determination of the direction of its ener- gies tends to preserve the peace of the world by making commerce its supreme material interest, as well as by making it unable to rival a Continental power in the concen- trated weight of military strength upon the land. Under these circumstances, in spite of the most taking of Jingo essays, practical statesmen in Continental nations will con- clude that they find no call to exhaust their exchequer in chase of the will-o'-the-wisp called Dominance of the Sea Power. In his general outline of recent military history Major Callwell is clear and interest- ing, with one exception, which will go far with American readers to discredit the whole work. The sketch of our civil war is written from the standpoint of the pre- judice and very imperfect knowledge of 1866, and must be regarded as a burlesque in its characterization of men and of events. A serious writer owes it to himself to keep more abreast with the progress of investi- gation sad discussion. Bertrand du Guesclin: His Life and Times. By Enoch Vine Stoddard, A.M., M.D. Il- lustrated. G. P. Putnam's Sons. 1897. It is an observation of Henri Martin that when the Middle Ages were regarded as all alike, Bertrand du Guesclin was erected into a type of the chivalrous knight. The truth is, on the contrary, that his influence tended to destroy the French chivalry of his day, and to substitute for the hero of the tournament the professional captain of Renaissance times. His manners from childhood re- sembled those of, let us say, Bayard little mors than the manners of Father Damien (depicted by Stevenson in his open letter to the Rev. C. M. Hyde) resembled those of the conventional “plaster saint." He dis- concerted his parents by extraordinary roughness of demeanor and peasant tenden- cles. Among the great men of France, he was second only to Mirabeau in plainness of feature. He was not a native of the fle de France. He had an apparently falling cause to support. With such long odds against him, the degree of his force, deter mination, and bravery can be measured only by a detailed examination of what he a complished for himself and his country. He did more than win the Constable's sword, in spite of court opposition, and wield it with distinction under circumstances which would have taxed the address of Turenne. He was one of the chief agencies in the achieve ment of French nationality; and ever since the process of consolidation has been un derstood, his countrymen have assigned him a place next and close to Joan of Arc among the worthies of the Hundred Years’ War Dr. Stoddard's sketch of Du Guesclin’s career is, with the exception of a short chapter on social conditions in the four- teenth century, occupied with its hero's own undertakings, to the exclusiong of political issues in their wider sense. Its avowed aim is to disentangle the Constable from “the influences of an inadequate estimate of the. actual social and political conditions of his time, and from the false conceptions of character which naturally arise from the distance in time between the living present and remote past, as well as from the distortion produced by the roseate mists of a romantic atmosphere which envelop it.” For our own part, we should be disposed to leave aside this somewhat indistinct definition of purpose to say that Dr. Stod- dard has prepared for popular use a nar- rative that combines sufficiency of bio- graphical information with a full measure of biographical sympathy The writer seems to us to belong to a class which we only wish were larger—the class of men who, without being trained historians, are moved by the events of distant centuries to under- take some special study in them. The in- terests of history suffer when historical read- ing is held to be the property of a close cor- poration. The amateur may fall into an oc- easional slip which in the professional writer would be heinous, without incurring quite the same censure. One is only gratified that his tastes lie in the right direction. We state our impression that Dr. Stoddard is a volunteer historian, because, without ha- bitual inaccuracy, he once in a while errs in a fashion that marks him off from stu- dents who have served an apprenticeship. For instance, on the last page of the preface he styles Cuvelhier, one of his chief authori- ties, a Troubadour, and then more cor- rectly, in the first line of chapter i., a Trou- vere, But s determining proof of inexpert-
Page 20
362 The Nation. [Vol. 65, No. 1688 ence is the following account of the Jac- querie: “The occurrence at this time of what is known as the ‘Insurrection of the Jacquerie’ introduced a startling element into affairs. This was an uprising aimed against the no- bility, and was led by one Jacques Bon- homme (James Goodman). This insurrec- tion was mainly participated in by the lowest and most ignorant orders of society. The ravages committed were not confined to any class, but were equally violent and destructive among all conditions of society. Like all movements of a similar character by an ignorant populace, the effort was a failure, and those concerned in it were dis- persed by the organized effort of the intel- ligent classes. Its end was hastened by its excesses, which united the better elements of society in suppressing it.’’ In a critical age this identification of the proverbial Jacques Bonhomme (‘Jacques Bonhomme a bon dos, il souffre tout’’) with an individual leader, illustrates the process by which folklore is begotten and extended. In comparison with this mistake, Dr. Stod- dard’s failure to dilate satisfactorily on the peasant revolt is less glaring. Among other marks of the novice in setting forth French history, we may mention an arbi- trary use of accents, or, rather, their omis- sion from many vowels with which they be- long if French forms are not to be frankly discarded. The modern biographer has only to present facts in dealing with Du Guesclin. He has few judgments to revise. One seldom en- counters a case where the opinion of con- temporaries has endured till now without greater modification. As with Joan of Arc, the sources are full and the literature ex- cellent. Dr. Stoddard has ‘fortified himself by careful reference to the chief authorities. and if we have treated some features of his work rather slightingly, we can commend its main outlines with heartiness. Probably the most impértant consideration which he urges is that Du Guesclin was far from be- ing a mere leader of coups de main, and a champion against such knights as Sir Thomas Canterbury and Sir William Bram- bourg. He was a strategist superior in tac- tical skill to the best of the English, even superior to the veteran Sir John Chandos. “Common sense, not aphorisms drawn from the tournament, guided his campaigns. He would fight if necessary, but was just as ready to reach his goal by craft as by hard blows.”’ Yet how terrible he was in person, the vogue of his proud battle-cry shows. “Notre Dame, Guesclin’’ almost drove ‘‘St. Denis’ out of the field. In specifying what seem to us Dr. Stod- dard’s best chapters, we should give praise to his account of the reverses which Du Guesclin suffered, especially Auray and Navarrete. In both cases where conspicu- ous failure fell to his lot, his judgment had been overruled, and the large ransoms im- mediately raised to redeem him prove how indispensable he had made himself to his employers, whether French or Spanish. THe fourteenth century comes in for more copi- ous abuse than any other medizval period, and is usually made to suffer by comparison with the age immediately preceding it. So regularly is it decried that one is tempted to plead a little in its behalf. Its love of splendor and luxury did more for the re- vival of literature and the arts than any amount of scholastic philosophy had been able to effect; it suffered untold misery from pestilence; it revealed marked democratic sentiments; and, finally, it furnished a small quota of notable men. Among these Du Guesclin looms up well, and the three hun- dred pages which Dr. Stoddard devotes to him are none too prolix. Studies in Psychical Research. By Frank Podmore, M.A. G. P. Putnam’s Sons. 1897. 8vo, pp. 458. This pleasant volume may be recommend- ed to those who desire to inform themselves concerning the progress of psychical re- search since the publication of ‘Phantasms of the Living.’ It must be acknowledged that in the meantime the reasons for be- lieving in something which may vaguely be called telepathy have been considerably strengthened. This has, in part, been due to the influence of facts already in print before that publication, but which had not yet been sufficiently digested even by those who knew them best. Among the corrobo- rations the first to be mentioned is the en- larged census of hallucinations. It is true that this did not strictly conform in its scheme to the logical requisita—so much so as to bring its authors in some quarters under suspicion of dreading to meet the facts face to face; and, in consequence of its defects, the new census leads to no decisive conclusion. Yet it was certainly an im- provement upon the first one, and did con- tribute something to the evidence for te- lepathy. But that which has strengthened the case much more has been the multitude of experiments, mostly unreported, which have been undertaken of late years. Almost everybody, roughly speaking, who has been interested in the subject, has made such ex- periments for himself. These experiments, too, have often been .conducted with a mea- sure of good sense, not in mechanical routine (which is as unfavorable to any other men- tal phenomena than those of fatigue as can be), but with some appreciation of the style in which telepathy, granting it to be a real action, appears as a matter of fact to ope- rate. The results of the best of these ex- periments have usually afforded what ap- pear to be indications, though extremely slight ones, of some tendency to something like telepathy. Now it was precisely such very slight phenomena, occurring with a cer- tain frequency, that were wanting a dozen years ago to bridge the chasm between the ordinary course of nature and the apparently supernatural. In the third place, the de- cade has not been altogether barren of strik- ing phenomena suggesting telepathy, which, though less probative than the more ordinary results just mentioned, yet, as being open to experimental tests, are infinitely more so than all the ghost stories that ever were told. The striking phenomena can amount to nothing until they are welded into con- tinuity with ordinary experience. Finally, the very simple mechanical philosophy which was in high vogue still a dozen years since, though it had already been weakened by physical investigations, has now suffered se- rious dilapidations. It is now doubtful whether the conservation of energy can be regarded as the original and ultimately fundamental law that lies hidden beneath the corner-stone of the universe. The hypothesis which it behooves science provisionally to adopt is not in every case the most probable theory. One source of pleasure in reading Mr. Podmore’s present book is that, from begin- ning to end, there is scarcely a decided flaw in his inductive reasoning. He judges of a conclusion, not by his inclination to think one way or the other, nor by any rule of thumb, but by the necessities of the case. The general plan of the book is to proceed from beliefs which the author refutes or only partially accepts, first to those which seem to him undeniable, and finally to those which try his faith. The first chapter sketches the history of the movement in psychical research. The second, upon “Spiritualism as a Popular Movement,” shows the extravagant hardihood of the cre- dulity of the spiritualists of the last gene- ration. The next chapter criticises the experiments of Thury and Gasparin, of Dr. Hare, of Lord Lindsay, of Crookes, of Stain- ton Moses, and of Zéllner. The next chapter shows how the more severe investigations of the Society for Psychical Research re- futed apparent phenomena of like descrip- tion, sometimes identical. Chapter v. ex- plodes Poltergeists. Chapter vi. shows how the Society exposed Madame Blavatsky’s fraud. It concludes with these words: “Of the later history of the Theosophical movement, and of the revelations made by Mr. Edward Garrett in ‘Isis Very Much Un- veiled,’ it is not necessary to speak here. And it would be rash to prophesy even now —notwithstanding all the damning evidence of fraud, notwithstanding the loss of the unique personality of the foundress—that the movement is near dissolution. To most men who have given themselves over to a false belief, there comes a time when the ears are deaf and the eyes are closed and the heart is hardened, so that they will not be- lieve even the testimony of the false pro- phet against himself. For are there not, as we have seen, black magicians and other powers of darkness who may transform themselves into the likeness of angels of light? With such men and against such a contention, argument is no longer even pos- sible. Discipiantur.”’ With chapter vii. the constructive part of the book begins. Experimental Thought Transference is rightly taken up first, since it must form the logical basis of the whole doctrine of telepathy. The results of the experiments are very slender, and any one series is quite inconclusive. The circum- stance that two minds of the same level liv- ing constantly together will, under given circumstances, be apt to notice nearly the same sequence of ideas, is left out of ac- count. But then, on the other hand, were such phenomena more than just discernible in the long run, they would stand in flat contradiction to the ordinary course of ex- perience. Their slightness is thus negative evidence of the veraciousness of the effects. Telepathic hallucinations are next taken up. What the judicious reader will think of this chapter will naturally and logically de- pend upon the impression made upon him by the direct experiments. If these, upon the whole, can be considered as establishing telepathy as a real phenomenon, however slight it may ordinarily be, this conviction will be drawn upon to explain the highly in- tensified phenomena narrated in this chap- ter. In regard to hallucinations, it is to be remembered that while most men never have them at all, many others have so lively a visualizing power that they may be said to live amidst hallucinations all their lives. Others, such as many painters and chess- players, have ordinarily no hallucinations about ordinary things, yet habitually behold as real the imaginary objects concerning which their brains are chiefly exercised. It is probably mostly among men of this in- termediate class that visions of dear friends occur at times when their hearts are ex- cited, whether through ordinary or telepa-
Page 21
Nov. 4, 1897] The Nation. — thic channels. Ghosts are next considered, and strong reasons are shown for believing them to be merely hallucinations. Haunted houses is the next topic. Nothing is said about the great number of houses which are inhabited or frequented by tramps and squatters. In the first case mentioned in this chapter, a Miss Laurence was going up stairs: “When she reached the second-floor land- ing, she saw a cotton skirt, of a lilac shade and indefinite pattern, disappearing round the bend of the stairs leading to the top floor. Supposing it to be the housemaid, she called to her; and the housemaid appeared from a door close to her on the second floor. The only other servant was the cook, who was down stairs. Miss Laurence told the housemaid of her experience, and the housemaid replied, ‘Oh, that’s nothing, miss; I often see a skirt go round that corner.’ "’ Now is it natural the housemaid should think that ‘‘nothing,’’ unless she knew it was a natural appearance? It was a house in Hyde Park Place; and intruders into city bouses generally pass from one to another by the roofs. It often happens. The author next considers Premonitions and Previsions. Here we meet with a num- ber of stories marked by all the general characters of those relating to telepathic hallucinations. But the difference is, that these are not backed up, as those were, by experiments. Nobody has experimented upon premonitions and previsions, simply because the ordinary course of life has too thorough- ly prejudiced everybody against any such thing. Yet it is hard to say how prophecy runs more counter to experience than does telepathy. It is, however, interesting to see that Mr. Podmore draws back before pre- vision, and wishes to consider this class of events as chance coincidences. The next chapter, upon Secondary Con- sciousness, which has no obvious connection with psychical research, seems to be insert- ed merely as an introduction to the final chapter, which relates to Impersonation, Ob- session, and Clairvoyance. It is the clair- voyance which particularly belongs to the questions here considered. As these phe- nomena, real or fraudulent, stand at pres- ent, they are too isolated to be brought un- der the dominion of science until further re- search shall discover other phenomena bridging the gap. Sweet Revenge: A Romance of the Civil War. By F. A. Mitchel. Harpers. Heil fer Sartain. By John Fox, jr. pers. From the Land of the Snow Pearls: Tales from Puget Sound. By Ella Higginson. Macmillan Co. Har- Perennial as the pension list, the war romance appeals not less directly to the for- bearance of the public. But the purest pa- triotism must find it difficult to justify the increase, at this late day, of both these burdensome results of our civil conflict. In its construction the war romance follows simple and unvarying lines. The hero, whose hurts are healed by the maiden of fiercest Southern sympathies, reveals his connection with the Northern army and his | undying passion for herself. She flouts and insults him. The two armies mancuvre in the background. There is much mutual saving of life on the part of the lovers, and the curtain falls on a union of prob- lematic happiness. ‘Sweet Revenge’ de- parts in no important particular from the accepted traditions, but some uniqueness may be allowed to its scenes of guerilla war- fare, which are of a diverting improbability. The author's military titles afford, together with his book, satisfactory proof that with him the sword was mightier than the pen. The well-sung Southern mountaineer has found in Mr. John Fox his latest and not least competent chronicler. Under a title of rather unjustifiable luridness, Mr. Fox presents ten sketches of life in that Cum- berland Gap which he knows so well. Slight in form, they afford no opportunity for the display of constructive skill, but in accurate reproduction of dialect and custom, in swift and successful characterization, they leave little to be desired. ‘“Courtin’ on Cutshin” is ‘‘courting as she is wrought”’ along many a creek and in many a cove of the Southern Appalachians. The mountain white has al- ready undergone apotheosis and vilification in turn; that he is a man who can see a joke, who can even originate one, has been left for Mr. Fox to bring out. Other re- sources than those of dialect are shown in the effective English of “The Purple Rho- dodendron.’’ The theme is a pretty one, and the flower may serve Virginia lovers as a test of devotion; but any one who has seen its acres of bloom mantling the shoulders of Roan or Craggy in North Carolina, will be inclined to doubt its entire fitness for the réle of American edeiweiss. The Puget- Sounders are unmistakably people of like passions with ourselves; their remoteness is merely geographical. Nothing is more clearly revealed in Miss Higgin- son’s book than their affinity with New Englanders—Miss Wilkins’s New England- ers. Theirs is surely the land whither have strayed the wandering and derelict lovers of Miss Wilkins’s widows and maids. The New England fibre has somewhat coarsened, the dialect roughened, as indi- cated on Miss Higginson’s page; but the Christmas cranberry-sauce still casts its heart-softening radiance over family re- unions in the valley of the Willamette. The people of the West have recently shown symptoms of a revolt against their dialect writers. The uncouth representations of their speech—the ‘“‘choos,”” “yuhs,”’ and “hunh unhs,”’ which affront the eye more than the ear, they have suffered in silence. But Nebraska has risen up to protest against Octave Thanet'’s imputation that “Ma” is the ordinary filial utterance with- in her borders. “Ma” is, however, a pleas- ing and decorous form of address compared with that in vogue with the Puget-Sounders. Can a people poetic enough to speak of their mountains as Snow Pearls profane the pa- rental relation by the hideous monosylla- ble ‘“‘Maw’'? The question is not one with which a stranger may safely intermeddle Higginson evidently shares George Moore’s recently expressed conviction that “the sadness of life is the joy of art."” Most of her stories ‘vail themselves out in minor cadences-—the deserted maiden, the jilted lover, the ingrate child. Something too much of this, one is tempted to cry out in the presence of these numerous and familiar It no slight proof the author’s skill that she has been able to with much interest her rather motives sons Miss sorrows is of invest so trite The Brontés: Fact and Fiction. By Angus Dodd, Mead & Co ton; New York xil, 187. This important addition to Bronté litera ture derives its value, not from fresh in- formation conveyed as to the Bronté fami- ly, but from its able exposition of fiction claiming to be truth, and from the light it throws upon the life and writings of the author of ‘Jane Eyre.’ It consists of two essays. The second, the longer——“‘A Crop of Bronté Myths’’—is an expansion of one which had already appeared in the Wes? minster Review. It deals with Dr. William Wright's book. Few that read it will agree “that the facts set forth carry complete conviction with that those ‘The in Ireland’ will henceforth merely treasure it for what it of the curiosities of nineteenth-century literature." The general acclaim with which this book by Dr. Wright was received, and the several through which it has passed, must now be held as a warning to critics and the pulNic to let no name, no apparent honesty of pur pose, or protestations of care in the collee 1897 hat will them, and who possess Brontés is-—-one editions tion of materials by an author, dull vigi lance in the comparison and testing of state ments and dates and nice weighing of like lihoods and possibilities, If the the first—‘Fresh Light on Bronté Biography.” a charmingly candid and intelligent oft writing—is essentially constructive. It deals with Mr. Mackay entitles “Charlotte Secret’’- the ap pearance of Mr. Shorter's book, written with the sanction and assistance of Mr. Nichol renders it desirable to explain. Mr. Shorter’s views regarding inferences to be drawn from passages in Charlotte’s life are well sum med up by Mr. Mackay “The story not true; but if it were true, it would be dis creditable.” Mr. Mackay has gone far to es- tablish his thesis that “‘The story is proba- bly true, but if true is not discreditable’; and, with him, while feeling for and under- standing Charlotte Bronté the more, we love and esteem her none the less. second essay ts destructive piece what Bronté's a secret which as is “Charlotte Bronté’s writings have proved a palimpsest, and scholars have from time to time hinted of the older sentences they could discern beneath the present characters. More recently there have been signs that hints are to be replaced by innuendoes, and I have therefore endeavored to restore the whole of the old text as far as it is still de- cipherable. It turns out to be a tragedy which for human interest equals anything in the novels, and which cannot but render those who peruse it wiser and stronger. Its central figure is Charlotte herself, as noble and brave a heroine as any which her ima- gination created. We see an acute sensitive- ness which attracts our pity, wedded to a dauntiess fortitude which compels our ad miration. We see her sore wounded in her affections, but unconquerable in her will. The discovery of the secret of her life does not degrade the noble figure we know so well: it adds to it a pathetic significance.” This is as thoughtful an essay as has come into our hands for some time. We light upon sentences such as the following: “It is needful te remember that persons of strong intellect are apt to vindicate their right to freedom of thought by adopting some other ’ opinions than those offered by their environ- ment.” “He taught her the sweet and tran- quil pleasures of an affection which is al- most more precious than love.’”’ “‘The flame, it would scem, had already passed on her, and left behind nothing that was inflamma- ble.” Respecting Anne Bronté’s genius we M. Mackay, B.A. London: Serviss & Pa- read: “Upon those bright twin stars [Char-
Page 22
364 lotte and Emily] many telescopes are turn- ed, and then there swims into the beholder’s view this third, mild shining star of the tenth magnitude, which otherwise would have remained invisible.’’ While in no de- gree concerned to defend the character of Bramwell Bronté, we cannot take Mr. Mackay’s view that his letter to Hartley Coleridge, which appears on page 120 of Mr. Shorter’s book, exhibits him as ‘capable of the worst which has been imputed to him.’’ We unhesitatingly recommend this little book. BOOKS OF THE WEEK James. The Republic of Plato. Cam- University Press; New York: Macmillan. 1.2 AC ams, W. I. L. Sunlight and age For Pho- Adam, bridge: tographers. peer & Taylor Co 6 Adcock, A. St. J. East End Idylls. London: New York: M. F. Manstield. James eM, 1.25, Aldrich, T. B. Prose and Poetical Works. vols, Dogzen: Houghton, Mifflin & Co. fe Algse d A Treatise on the Law in lation oP aint and the 2 of Corporations. | Bey, Little, Brown & C Allen, Prof. A. V. G., Christian Institutions. Scribners. $2.50. Among the Dunes. F. T. Neely. 50c. Andrews, Mrs. Gwendolen IF. The Living Sub- stance as Such, and as Organism. Boston: Ginn Asbjérnsen, P. C. a y * ‘ales from the Far North. A. C. Armstron m. $2. Austin, O. P. National Affairs for the Appletons. 75c. Bacon, E. M. Chronic ak of Tarrytown and Sleepy Hollow, Putnams. $1.2% Baker, Rev. C. R, Prayers for the Christian Year. Whittaker. ie Barlow, Jane. Irish Idylls. Dodd, Mead & Co. Prof. W. W., and Smith, Prof. D. E. Elementary Geometry. Bjérnson, B. Captain Mansara, Problems in Mother’s Hands, Macmillan. $1.25, Burdick, Prof. F. M. The Law of Sales of Per- sonal Property. Boston: Little, Brown Co. Chambers, The Mystery of Choice. Ap- Baker & Taylor pletons. $1.25. SS. A Colonial Witch. Paul Travers’s Adventures. Chicago: nele Sam's Secrets: A Story of Youth of the Nation, Beman, Famous Boston: Ginn & Co. and Child, F. . $1.25. Clover, 8. T. Way & Williams. $1.25. Conkling, A. R. eS Government in the United States. 3d ed., revise Appletons. $1. Connery, T. B, That. "Noble Mexican, F. T. Neely. 25c. Conway, Prof. R, S. The Italic Dialects. 2 vols. Cambridge: University Press; New York: Mac- millan. $7. Coz, Mme. V. le. Sans Mari. Paris: Colin & Cie. Cromarty, Deas. When Hearts Are Young. Lon- don: James Bowden; New York: M. F. Mans- field. $1. °
The Nation. Dakin, Dr. W. R. A Handbook of Midwifery. Longmans, Green & Co. $4.50. Dawson, A. Fs God’s Foundling. Appletons. $1, Dilworth, J. B. Free Banking a Natural Right Centinnatel’ Publishing Co. $1. Dole, Rev. F. The Coming People. T. Y. porowell & 6s. si, eee eanee The Children House. Dodd, Mead & Co. ry at Sherburne Drake, 8. A. On Plymouth’ Rock. : : ‘Shep a foe: ; y Boston: Lee & stébanez, Joaquin n Drama Nuevo. = * Jenkins, 5c." ces Eve, G. W. Decorative Heraldry. London: Bell; New York: Macmill ap. -50. Fisher, Prof. Irving. A Brief Introduction to the Infinitesimal Calculus. Macmillan. 75c. Fletcher, Horace. Happiness as Found in Fore- thought minus Fearthought. Chicago: H. 8S. Stone & Co. Ford, Mary, History of Rome. Whittaker. 75c. [ome in Homespun. Boston: Lee & Shepard. $1.50 Fouqué, F. de la M. Undine. Macmillan. $2. Fuchs, Julius. Kritik der Tonwerke. Leipzlg: Frie- drich a ae ge Gates, Prof. L. E. Selections from the Prose Writings of Matthew Arnold. Henry Holt & Co. Gordon, ee Co Eat Not Thy Heart. Chicago: H. on Ston 0. Prof. C. L. Maldon and Brunnanburh: Two “Old English Songs of Battle. Boston: Ginn & Hardy, Mrs. A. S. The Hall of Shells. Appletons, ® | Hennessy, R. B. Tales of the Heart. Meyer Bros. Hill, C. T. Fighting a Fire. Century Co. $1.50. Hird, Dennis. In Search of a Religion. Putnams. A. Holbrook De. M. L. Stirpiculture. New York: . Holbrook & Co. a.%, , Washington. Astoria. [Tacoma Edition.] 2 vols. Putnam James, Henry. ‘What Maisie Knew. Chicago: H, S. Stone & Oo. James, Rev. Fleming. The Message and the Mes- sengers. Whittaker. $1.25. ..< Maurus. Peter the Priest. R. F. Fenno & Lanciani, Prof. Rodolfo. The Ruins and Exca- vations of Ancient Kome. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co, e Pink Fairy Book. Longmans, Le Gallienne, Richard. If I Were God. T. Y. Crowell & Co. 50c. Madden, D. H. The Diary of Master William Silence: A Study of Shakspere = of Blizabeth- n Sport. Longmans, Green & Magee. L. J. Songs after Work. A. D. F. Ran- dolph_ & Co. Manac¢ine, Marie de. Sleep: its Physiology, Patho- logy, Higgiene, and Psyc ology ndon: Walter ee York: Scribne von "$1.25. Nall, W. G. Elementary Latin-English Diction- ary. Macmillan, $1. Nicholson, William. An Alphabet. R. H. Rugsell. William Blackwood and His Sons: helr Magazine and Friends. 2 vols. Seribners. Op Bite, ouiver, Pacific Shores. Boston: Lee & epard " Palmer, Prof. ms H. — in English, ec Early ee pions Wills of aerancls P . i well & : % Pelletreau he War of fia ‘Theatres. olin ant Mrs. 8. Suffolk am Voor 1703. Penniman, Prof. ‘ Boston: Ginn & Co
__[Wol. 55, No. 1688 — R. R. Common-Law Pleading: Its History a is a Boston: Little, Brown & Co. Peters, Rev. M. ©. The Great Hereafter. New York: J. A. Wilmore & Co. . ? of a Bachelor. J. 8. Ogilvie Publishing E. Free to Serve: 4 gtk of Colonial w York. Boston: Copelan Rem, Clinton. 300. me fianelphine J. B. Lippincott Co. Ryan, e Red Crescent: Adventures of an ‘English ore at Plevna and roum. 1877-78. Scribners. Sabatier, Auguste. Outlines of a Philosophy of Religion based Oa Psychology and History. James Pott & Co. Schmid, itis m Congreve: Sein Leben und : W. Braumiiller. Re ner, D. a seine Lustspiele. Leip Shakespeare (William). rom the British Museum Catalogue SA ve Books. London: William Clowes & Sherman, F. D. Little-Folk Lyrics. Pessteated. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co. 50. Sidney, Margaret. Paronsio Pepper. ae Lo- throp Publ ons Co. $1.50. 7. G. G. . oo "* No. 1 to No. 80. Vol.’ I Scxipners , 3 + In the Permanent Way. Macmil- an. 50. Stories from the Arabian Nights. ton, Mifflin & Co. , Sullivan, J. F. The Flame-Flower, Stories. London: Dent; Philadelphia: Boston: Hough- ape Other . B. Lip- pincott Co. $1.50. Swett, Sophie. Pom 5 Tibaring of ’Scutney. Bos- ton: Lothrop Publishing Co. $1.25. Tchertkoff, v adimir, Christian sia. London: Brotherhood Publ - ag oe The Ian Maclaren Calendar. Doan, ead & Co. 1. re Ian Maclaren Year-Book. Dodd, Mead & Co. The Love Affairs of Some Famous Men. F. A. Stokes Co. The Maiden and Married Life « Had Powell Martyrdom in Rus- 25e. Afterwards Mistress Milton), the Sequel hereto, Deborah's De ss. Lond ion: Nimmo; New York: Scribners. The New Era Union. bo Chas. The Roger Witiate Calendar. Wchieteet _ Osborne Austi The Stevenson ‘Song. -Book. Scribners. $2. i Story of an Irish Sept. London: J. M. Dent The © Mead ne Franeels Rabelais. 5 vols. Phila- Tannen, Brot “3 xin i ent. Visible and Invisible. yacraltan 1.60.5 Poetry of of Tennyson. [Ca- Vernois, Gen. J. von Verdy = “With the Royal Headquarters in 1870-71. Vol im. pa a Ward, James. Historic Ornament: Treatise on Waring, Gol -E Whip and Spur. Doubleday fons Boston: Houghton, meo Edition.] Scribners. London: Kegan Paul, Trench, Triibner & Co.; Decorative Art and Architectural Ornament. vite C dD, _ a Boy. Co. Miffli farner, Rev. ot The Facts and the Faith. Whittaker. Waters, Stanley. The Story of Ab. A Tale of the Time of ser Cave Men. Chicago: Way & Williams. White, Prof. H. A. Robert E. Lee, and the South- ern Confederacy. [Heroes of the Nations.] Put- nams. 50. Wilcox, D. F. z Study of City Government. Macmillan. $1.50
“T have been a subscriber forthe REVIEW since it started, and hope to continue—well, not until it ends, but until I go out of education and teaching.”’—Sup’t Wil S. Monroe, Westficid, Mass. NOVEMBER EDUCATIONAL REVIEW. Edited by Prof. NICHOLAS MURRAY Columbia. ARTICLES: Educational Movements ia England, by Sir Joshua Fitch; A New Scnool in a New Neighborhood, by Frederic L. gt Lines of Child-Study for the Teacher, by G. W. A. Luckey; Bible Study, by John W. Hali; Hoginnings of an Education Society, by Walter Channing; Present Status of the Elective System in American Colleges, by Albert Perry Brigham; and English oe a in the Illinois High Schools, by Daniel K Discussions: The Problem of Praetice- Pvmpry by Seerley, Theodore B. Noss; The Dark Side of the Pe ture, F. R. Morrison, REVIEWS. BUTLER of EDITORIAL $3 per year (monthly, excepting July and August). 35 cents per copy. Contents, Vils. I..XUI, free. HENRY HOLT & CO., 29 W. 23d St., New York; 378 Wabash Ave., Chicago.
Dr. aeate SANATORY UNDERWEAR AS USED BY Dr. Nansen on his famous Arctic sledge journey. “The result of all this experimenting was that I made up my mind to keep to my woollen clothes, which would give free outlet to the perspiration. Jo- hansen followed my example, and on the upper part of our bodies we each had two Jaeger Undershirts next the skin, etc., etc.”—" Farthest North,” Vol. IL, p. 115 This Applies to You. Jaeger Underwear allows the skin to breathe freely, at the same time absorbing its exhala- tions, leaving the body dry and warm. Gives the greatest warmth with the least weight. Send for Illustrated Catalogue, Main Retail Store: Branches: 16 WEST 23D ST.,| 166 Broadway, New York. 248 W. 125th St
YALE MIXTURE. The choicest tobacco made, and preeminently * a gentleman’s smoke. Marburg Bros., The American Tobacco Co., Successor, Baltimore, Md.
HATCHARDS. This is the favorite BOOKSTORI, and for 100 years the resort of the smartest people in London. It is visited and patronized by all who love books. London is the great market for books, and all the best as well as the cheap- est editions can be had by writing here. Special collections formed, and fuller information sup- plied than from any other house. Books, both old and new, and relating to any subject, can readily be supplied, at very moderate prices. Agents for Clubs, Libraries, and all private collectors. W. 187 PiccapiLLy, Lonpon,
ALL LOVERS OF ‘THE FIVE LITTLE PEPPERS” WILL WELCOME Phronsie Pepper, the “ Last of the Five Little Peppers,” by Margaret Sidney, $1.50. Now ‘eas Overruled, i $1.50, is having a great sale. Ask for these new Lothrop books at * -_ booksellers: The Ready;Rangers, by Kirk Munroe, $1.25; Camp and Trail, by Isabel Hornibrook, $1.50; Tom Pickering of ’Scutney, by Sophie Swett, si. 25; The Great Island, by Willis Boyd Allen, 75 cents. Send for Catalogue to LOTHROP PUBLISHING COMPANY, 92 Pearl Street, Boston.
Page 23
Nov. 4, 1897] The Nation. VW Standard Typewriter’s New Models draw old friends closer and attract new ones, by the power of inherent merit and unfailing service. WYCKOFF, SEAMANS & BENEDICT 327 Broadway, New York Second Edition PRIVATE LIBRARY WHAT WE DO KNOW WHAT WE DON’T KNOW WHAT WE OUGHT TO KNOW ABOUT OUR BOOKS Kiet ARTHUR L. HUMPHREYS 1 Vol., Crown Quarto, Cloth, Uncut, $1.50 J. W. BOUTON 10 West 2°TH St., NEW YORK ‘OVERNMENT PUBLICATIONS. JY Wecan usually supply any wanted on short no tice. Correspondence invited. : W. H. LOWDERMILK & Co., Washington, D. C, AGAZINE OF AMERICAN HISTO- ry. Asetin numbers; clean, unused. A S. CLARK, 174 Fulton Street, New York. WILLIAMS, 25 EAST 10TH ST., N. Y., Dea er in Magazines and other Periodi- ts, volumes, or single numbers, Old South Leaflets on the Anti-Slavery Struggle Eight leaflets relating to the Anti-Slavery Struggle have just been to the series of Old South Leaflets. constituting Nos. 78-85 of The new leaflets are as follows: A Reprint of the First Number of The Liberator; Wendell Phillips’s Eulogy of Garrison; Theodore Parker’s Address on the Dangers from Slavery; Whittier’s Account of the Anti Slavery Convention of 1833: Mrs. Stowe’s Story : Sumner’s Speech on the Crime against Kansas; Words of John Brown, and the First Lincoln and Douglas These eight leaflets are bound together in a neat volume in r covers, with an introduction giving complete lists of all the South Leaflets and Lectures since 1883, and sold for 35 cents. Accompanied as all the leaflets are with careful references to the best books, nothing could be a better guide for clubs and classes making a study of the Anti-Slavery Struggle. sold for 5 cents a copy, or $4 00 per hundred. Send for complete list. DIRECTORS OF THE OLD SOUTH WORK, Old South Meeting-House, Boston. Mass. ay not be worthy to smoke the ‘ARCADIA MIXTURE.” —J. M. B—, in ** My Lady Nicotine.” Send 25 cents for sample to THE SURBRUG CO., 37 Dey Street, N. Y. City. (And all Booksellers). of * Uncle Tom's Cabin” The Old South Leaflets are “you m Publications in French Attention is called to the following series of re- — as of value to the student as well as o the general reader of French. ROMANS CHOISIS. 12mo, peper, 60 cents; cloth, 85 cents. No. 21. NANON. By Georee Saxp. With Intro- duction and Explanatory English Notes by B D. Woodward, Ph.D., Instructor in the Romance Languages at Columbia College. 431 pages No. 22. LE PETIT CHOSE. By ALrHonse Dav- pet. With Explanatory Notes in English by C. Fontaine, B.L.. L.D., Director of French in Washington's High Schools. ° Complete catalogue on application. For sale by all book- sellers, or postpaid on receipt of price by the publisher WILLIAM R.JENKINS 851 and 853 Sixth Ave. (48th St.), New York. Old and Rare Books. FIRST EDITIONS, etc., ete., FOR SALE, AN ILLUSTRATED CATALOGUE OF. PART 2. with Seventy-one Reproductions of Plates. Titie-pages, etc., etc. Works relating to the Civil War and Cromwell, Coaching, Cookery, Costume, Queen Elizabeth, Freemasonry, Gardening. Books chiefly first editions, by Charles Cotton, Abraham Cow- ley, William Cowper, Daniel Defoe, Charles Dickens, Dr. John Donne, Michael Drayton, John Dryden, Thomas Durfey, John Evelyn, Henry Fielding. FIRST EDITIONS of books fllustrated by George and Robert Cruikshank, Richard Doyle, and Harry Furniss, and a large collection of cu- rious Facetie. Part 2. 8vo, 74 pages, post free, 1s. PICKERING & CHATTO, 66 HAYMARKET, LONDON, 8. W. French and German BOOKS The Latest French and German Books Are promptly imported and kept for sale. All Standard Works continually in Stock, Write for New List of Late Fiction. BRENTANO’S, 31 Union Square, New York. ELLIS & ELVEY, DEALERS IN OLD AND RARE BOOKS, PRINTS. AND AUTOGRAPHS Catalogue 87 Just Published, tucluding the Valuable Library of Rare Books upon Music formed by the late JOHN BISHOP of Chelt*nham. 29 New Bond Street, London, England. FW. CHRISTERN (DYRSEN & PFEIFFER, Successors), 429 5th Ave., between 38th and 39th Sts., New York, Importers of Foreign Books: Agents for the leading Paris Publishers; Tauchnitz’s British Authors. Teub ner’s Greek and Latin Classics. Catalogues of stock mailed on demand. New books received from Paris and Leipzig as soon as issued. OL D BOO KS, sesp eTaMP FOR LIST. PSS A. J. CRAWFORD, 312 N. 7th St., St. Louis, Mo. READY NOVEMBER 10. Old Virginia and Her Neighbours. By JOHN Fiske $4.00. These volumes cover the settlement and growth of Virginia, Maryland, the Carolinas, and Georgia nearly tothe Revolution, [tis a most interesting story, aod bas never before been. told with the critical insight, the philoso. phic gr+sp. and the distinct literary charm with which it is here told by Mr. Fiske. Walden. By Henry D. Tooreav. /oliday Ruition, A very interesting edition of Thoreau's most characteristic book. with an Lotro- duction by Braprorp Torrey, aod W full-page photegravure Lustrations, in- cluding Walden Views, Concord Views, Portraits, etc. 2 vols , 12ma, &5.00, 2 vols., crown Svo, gilt top, —_——— HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO., Boston, 11 East 17th St., New York. EXEEITIDILILIZILILITIIIIIN : BY LLOYD MIFFLIN. = 4 Asexquisite as Landor or Matthew Ar + nold, or Sheliey at his best.—Hosten Tran. ba script. A glorious imagimation. A new ix Poet.—Richard Henry NSloddard The . Pastrike a high note.—J vy Warner. Most meritorious work, m its way, ever }@ done by an American —E. Ro Champlin 4 An unusual versatility and width ot Rd i senee —N. ¥, Sun. Very notable for im. & agination, acertain sublimity of thought MM Mand diction and for perfected art.—Pu mund C. Stedman —Beautifully illus | trated.— Baston Glots : A HANDSOME GIFT BOOK. Pictures ey . by T. MORAN, N. A. | ESTES & LAURIAT, Boston, Re and all Booksellers, - - - $1.50, > LS PSPSPS SSIS IP IP PSI OSS POSSE. SEX WORSHIP. An Exposition of the Phallic Origin of Religion. By CLIFFORD HOWARD. A work of rare and curious information concern- 7 te ing the ancient worsh of the pro reative powers Its purpose is t strate that the various re lig s faiths of the wo have had a common origin, and are founded upon this universal primi- tive form of worship, as practised by the early Hebrews, Assyrians, Hindoos. Greeks, r theological beliefs have and that all of our most impertant church embems and religious festivals ‘as the cross, altar, and wine, the celebration of Christmas and Easter) were originally of sexual significance, and antedate the Christian era many hundreds of years “A remarkaMe book.""—[Allecheny Record “‘Many strange beliefs and stranger customs are touched upon in this work.’ Brookiyn Eagle i2mo, cloth, $1.25 net. Limited edition. Sent, postpaid, on receipt of price CLIFFORD HOWARD, Publisher, P. 0. Box 633, Washington, D. C. Monthly Cumulative Index to Periodicals. Indexes subjects, authors, titles, book reviews, and portraits. Specimen copy free PUBLIC LIBRARY, Cleveland, Ohio. London Weekly Circular of Rare, Choice, and Curious English Books from well-known libra- ries sold in London this season. Sent gratis on ap- plication by H. W. Hagemann, 160 5th Ave ,N.Y. AUTOGRAPH LETTERS OF CELE B- 4 RITIES and ROOK-PLATES. Send for Catalogue. Water Romweyse Bexsamis 1125 Broadway, N.Y. City
Page 24
The N ation. [Vol. 65, No. 1688 " PUBLISHE! ED NOVEMBER» 5 LITERATURE A Weekly Gazette of Literary Criticism, Comment, and Chronicle Price, 10 Cents a Copy; $4.00 a Year. VIE admirable distinctness and singleness of purpose that mark this new periodical Jind expression in its title. Literature, and literature alone, ts to be tts theme. The aim of its publishers will be to make tt essentially the organ of the literar ry Classes in the widest sense of the term, impartial and authoritative in tts literary criticism, and a comprehensive and | trustworthy medium of literary tntelligence. An earnest and an honest attempt will be made || to deal with the best literature of every country on its liter ary merits alone, without prejudice, wethout national prepossessions. To E nglish and to American works a certain prominence — well almost tnevitably be given; but this natural preference will not exclude reviews of the | more important of the volumes tssuing from the publishing centres on the continent of Eu- | vope. Lt ts hoped that every important work may be reviewed within three weeks after its || publication. | Though Literature well consist mainly of reviews of books, tt will invite correspon- dence on and will ttse /f deal with any literary subject of permanent or of current interest to the writing, publishing, or reading world. The selection of Mr. H. D. TRAILL as editor of Literature /finds cts warrant in the broad critical faculty and masculine sanity of judgment which characterize that well- known writer. Mr. BARRETT WENDELL, Assistant Professor of English at Harvard College, well contribute weekly a letter upon topics of literary interest tn America. bain) & ee bk erecta New York ee lL DODD, MEAD & COMPANY eo Announce The 9th 1,000 Constable KCo. DARIEL: Oriental Rugs. A ROMANCE OF SURREY. By R. D. BLACKMORE, au- Punjaub, Persian, Oushak. thor of ‘*LORNA DOONE.’’ Illustrated. 12mo, cloth, $1.75. Large and medium sizes for Libraries and Dining-Rooms. Antique Rugs The 9th 1,000 in fine variety. THE POTTER’S WHEEL || Carpets. By IAN MACLAREN, author of «The Mind of the Mas- || Wilton, Axminster, Brussels. ter,’’ etc. 12mo, cloth, $1.25. The 14th 1,000 IN KEDAR’S TENTS. A Novel. By HENRY SETON MERRIMAN, author of ‘* The Sowers.’’ 12mo, cloth, $1.25. AT AL SOURSRLAONS. STUDY AND PRACTICE OF FRENCH DODD, MEAD & COMPANY, Publishers, N.Y. IN SCHOOL. In Thtee Parts. Special designs and estimates prepared on request. Droadoay AS 19th ot. NEW YORK. By L. C. Boname, Philadelphia, 258 South 16th St. Natural Method on a New Plan, with thorough drill in Pronunciation and Essentials of Grammar.