The Nation 1897-10-07: Vol 65 Iss 1684
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
The N ation : VOL. LXV—NO. 1684. THURSDAY, OCTOBER 7 , 1897. PRICE 1o CENTS CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS PUBLISH OCTOBER 9: Laz, THIS COUNTRY OF OURS. ore By BENJAMIN HARRISON, Ex-President of the United States. I2mo, $1.50. ty, | * The purpose of the book is to give a better knowledge of things that have been too near and familiar to be well known. J 6 Fe tena || to promote an intelligent patriotism and a faithful discharge of the duties of citizenship.’—AvTMoR’s PREFACE 1] CONTENTS: The Constitution—The Congress—The President—The State Department—The Treasury Department— Depa. nts of || War and Justice—The Post Office Department—The Navy Department—Departments of the laterior and Agriculture—Indefendent Boards and Commissions—The Judiciary. | This is essentially a unique volume. In it General Harrison has described, so simply and directly that the most uninformed person cannot | fail of enlightenment, the way in which this vast country of oursis governed. The various departments of our National Gowerament, with thel |; functions and their individual peculiarities, are thus characterized and described by an author who has himself occupied the chief place aad the most || responsible position in this tremendous and complex machinery ; and the result is a book which for the first time presents an adequate view of a sub || ject that is of prime interest to every American. 1 i} THE TORMENTOR. LITERARY LOVE LETTERS AND OTHER | By BENJAMIN SwIFT, author of ‘‘ Nancy Noon.” 12mo, $1.50. STORIES. ; A successor to that remarkable and much discussed novel “Nancy | By Ropert HERRICK, author of ‘The Man Who Wins.” (/: ; | Noon” will be received with intense interest, and ‘‘ The Tormentor”’ will Series.) l6mo, 75 cents. | be found quite as original a story, both in its substance and in the telling. Mr Herrick’s present volume, containing seven short stories, exhibits ementeany Sn qnanene which have already won him distinction His | It is even more powerful in the serious and intense feeling that the author stories are notable alike for their admirable literary quality and their expresses in such an individual way. vivid presentation of the subtler phases of mind and character TAKEN BY SIEGE, THE SUB-CONSCIOUS SELF, | A Novel. By JEANNETTE L. GILpDER, Editor of The Critic. and Its Relation to Education and Health 12mo, $1 25. i. By Lovuts WALDsTEIN. i2mo, $1 25. Miss Gilder, the well-kuown editor of The Critic, has here written a : uatigenpe ‘ : : Dr. Waldstein is an investigator at first hand of pave te phenomena captivating love story. The scene is laid in New York city, and, the prin- | and he has here explained many of them as due to the underlying self, of cipal character being connected with The Dawn, while the heroine Is an | Whose impressions the memory retains no conscious recor 7 He goes on | | i opera singer, the book contains especially interesting and faithful studies | } to show how important a factor these impressions are in the pr *bliems of : ’ education and of mental and physical health that confront all thoughtful of life in a newspaper office and upon the stage. people. ee NEWEST PUBLICATIONS. Second Edition of Robert Louis Stevenson's Great Romance, | ST. IVES. Being the Adventures of a French Prisoner in England. i2mo, $1.30 “St. Ives’* is a tale of action in the author's most buoyant style, and there is a vigor yet light-heartedness, a continuous grasp of the interest and sympathy throughout, which is truly fascinating. One hardly realizes the mastery and art of it all at the time, so absorbing is the story, but ‘ Stevenson's inimitable and characteristic style is in evidence on every page, and the scenes and charactersare as vivid as anything he ever wrote Unlike so many of the author's books, the present tale is intertwined with a romantic and spirited love-story. The advance orders having already exhausted one large edition, a second is now ready. ~ 7’ wt } | VASARI’S LIVES OF THE PAINTERS. ! AMERICAN NOBILITY. || By Grorcio Vasari. Edited and annotated in the light of recent A Novel. By Pierre pe CouLevarn. 12mo, $1.50. i i| discoveries by E. H. and E. W. Biashfield and A. A. Hopkins. | | . 1} Library Edition. 4 vols., 8vo, $8 00, Ss ’ ; | “ Vasari’s ‘ Lives’ are something more than one of the most useful contri. | THE BIBLE AND Is l AM; } || butions to the data 0’ art criticism. They are also literature. . . . Read with Or, The Influence of the Old and New agg poor nonaes on } the Religion t || the assistance of such notes as the presen* editors have provided, he ts not an | of Mohammed. Being the Ety Lectures fi vor.) By B | authority invatidate 1, but a classic purged of the tll «fects of time eet satagemeemsicatt rer : “tM ciures ISY/6 3 : Z iH] is just because he is nt aca temic that Vasari is immorcal; it is because he gives | HENRY PRESERVED SMitH, DD. 12mo, $1. ? 4 us at first hand a vivid picture of the art amid watch he lived that he carries . j : conviction, and, with conviction, a peculiar delight.”—N. ¥. Tridune. A HISTORY OF CHRISTI ANITY IN THE APOS- : ; ENGLISH LANDS, LETTERS, AND KINGS. TOLIC AGE. : || The Later Georges to Queen Victoria. By DonaLp G. Mitcaett ! By AntHUR C. McGirrert, D D., Ph D , Professor of Church His- j (“Ik Marvei”), 12mo, $1 50. tory, Union Theological Seminary, New York. Crown 8vo, ‘ 2Wnet (International Theological Library.) : j PREVIOUS VOLUMES. Each, $1.50 —— a ee an : || English Lands, Letters, and Kings. From Celt to Tudor } THE HISTORY OF THE LADY BETTY STAIR. By Moutiy ELLior SEAWELL. Illustrated by Thule de Thulstrup. In an original bindiag similar to ‘‘ The Sprightly Romance of SELECTED PUEMS. Marsac.” 12mo, $1.25 English Lands, Letters, and Kings. From Elizabeth to Anne. English Lands, Letters, and Kings. Queen Anne and the Georges. The set, 4 volumes in a box, $6.00. tn By Gaonas MEREDITH. Arranged by the author and including CATHERINE SCHUYLER : a 38m 12 L.7 4 “Not cince ia ceeeeanpunes eatrety oe pried iets } By Mary Gay HCMPSREYS (Women of Colonial and Revolu- , nary & gift of poetic expresatoa.”—[. Zasowmt. tn Pali Mall Magazine. | tionary Times.) With photogravure portrait. 19m, $1 25. ' | CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS, 153+157, Fifth Avenue, New York ——_--—_—
Page 2
eed pet > The Nation. [ Vol. 65, No. 1684 The N ray A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science, and Art. FOUNDED 1865. [Entered at the New York City Post-Office as second- class mail-matter.] CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. THE WBE .ccsccccecs cccsesosecccessccccsvescesescoes 269 EDITORIAL ARTICLES : Annexation, Hawalian Style.........-..eeeeeeeeeee 272 BEE, OPT GP COO TOP ccs cen vccccsesccccsscccersee 272 The Iowa Campalgn...........sssseeceseeeeeeeereees BUD Na cb b bincssscncversconcrocestakpvcesen 274 SPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE: Yellowstone Park in 1897... .........cceeceeceeeeee 298 CORRESPONDENCE : Judge Parker and the National Democrats....... 277 Oregon Plants..... webenerenescecdeeveressnssgcesqees 278 yer 278 PO so vcdvpupnctinnbiscssephsrcescckesa¥exneecaevebneres 278 Book REVIEWS: NEN iu canecnpccncuneonscssncsesansoveenne® 281 The Indian Village Community... ............00000+ 283 A EROCy Of CGF OWRD TIMES... 00000-cccrcecccsecens 284 ON 5 500 hcnb csc s¥005dsnseneneovescedentaccas 284 ea ee nas iene van 285 I cs essa rca ses ccae sent obese tte sence seeniwe 285 The Voyage of the Mayflower. . ee bo, eer err 286 With the Trade MN douassneceusssekdcpsencnenste 286 DOCKED OF THR WE ioc cescscsncsccvseccevencensecsess 287 TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three Dollars per year, in advance, postpaid, to any part of the United States or Canada; to foreign countries comprised in the Postal Union, $4.00. The date when the subscription expires is on the Address-Label of each paper, the change of which to a@ subsequent date becomes a receipt for remittance. No other receipt is sent unless requested. Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless male by registered letter, or by check, express order, or postal order, payable to ‘* Publisher of the Nation.” When a change of address is desired, both the old and new addresses should be given. Address THE NATION, Box 794, New York. Publication Office, 208 Broadway. TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Fifteen cents per agate line, each insertion, 14 lines to the inch. Twenty per cent. advance for choice of page, top of column, or cuts. Cuts are not inserted on the first page. A column, $20 each insertion; with choice of page, $24. A page, $60 each insertion; front-cover page, $80. Advertisements must be acceptable in every respect. Copy received until Tuesday, 5 Pp. M. DISCOUNTS. TImE— : insertions bea npebhy Saaehe bRAek bauhWhewas 4 per cent. 13 S “geenbebabsbebenpeabessenes? all 12 wi 26 fT Reieayasuuneksubud aabeneasncet i5* 2 39 es Cobewenweabe bens bhecsebesaaanee 20 ba mM - Say biaeneecoaeeneadenebeasaee 25 * “p10 ywithia DOOR. o ncicccccnctsiscccoesn 10 per cent. 250 “ae ove coos a sn br “ “ ti 750 “ “ “ 1,000 xd ws “ 1,500 ~ va - 2,000 e - “ The NATION is sent free to those who advertise in it as long as the advertisement continues. The EDITION of the Natian this week is 9,200 copies. The Subscription List is always open to the inspection of advertisers. *,* Copies of the NATION may be procured fn Paris at Brentano’s, 17 Avenue de l’Opéra, and in a wd F. Stevens, 4 Trafalgar uare, American News r Agency, 15 Kin Willian Street, Strand, PY. we sd London agent for advertisements, R.J. Bush, Fleet Street, E. C. E:ducational. CALIFORNIA, Belmont. (In the foothills near San Francisco ) ELMONT SCHOOL for Boys hopes to deserve the confidence of Eastern as well as of Western parents by surrounding its boys with as stimu- lating an intellectual, spiritual, and physical jife as is found in the best Eastern schools, and by offering a home which in beauty of sprrounoings and fineness of climate for sustained work no Eastern school can hope toequal. It should give to its beys a healthful impulse towards good thinking and good living, and leave with them a heritage of pleasant and helpful memories, The catalogue, containing views of the school and a record of the colleges and technical schools entered by its graduates, will help to give an idea of its spirit and the work it is doing - REID, A. M. (Harvard), | Head | Master. acne Los Angeles, West 23d St. A ff AkLBORO UGH SCHOOL for GIRLS. Mrs. GEORGE A. CASWELL, Principal. CONNECTICUT Hartford, 714 Asylum Ave. ISS F B. BURBANK’S FAMILY School for young girls. Ninth year. Number limited. Kegular and special courses. Home life cheerful and wholesome. DISTRICT OF CoLUMBIA, Wasbington. LISS SCHOOL OF ELECTRICITY. The only institution teaching practical electrical engineering exclusively. Laboratory equipment ex- cellent. Courses open October 1. _ Catalogue on | application. DISTRICT OF CoLumBra, Washington. HEVY CHASE French and English School for Girls. Suburb of Washington. a the language of the house. ‘oo ¥ Mile. L. M. Boutieny. Assistant Principal, Miss C. PETTIGREW. s. Oo Stat tion E, _Washington, D. Cc ILLINOIS, Chicago, 479-481 Dearborn Avenue. “IRLS'’ COLLEGIA TE SCHOVUL.—22D T year begins Sept. 22 For Young Ladies and Chil- — a 4 anes Gg a ag pa courses of study. 88 REBECCA Ick, A.M.,? Miss Mary E. Bexpy, A.M, ieee MARYLAND, Baltimore, cor. Carey and Lanvale Sts. HAFTESBURY COLLEGE OF EX- pression.—Six months’ session. Enrolment the Ist of each month, Winter term Nov. to April, inclusive. Handsome ilustrated catalogue. ie Miss s ALICE May Y YOUSE, | President. MARYLAND, Baltimore, 122 and 124 W. Franklin St. DGEWURTH BOARDING and DAY School for Girls.—35th year will begin September 23, 1897. Mrs. H. P. LEFEBVRE, Principa Misa E. D. HUNTLEY, Associate Principal ss MARYLAND, Catonsville. Byte TIMOTH ¥'S SCHOOL Sor Girls re- ns September 23, 1896. Pre ag for p nee ng Heads « of ‘School: Miss M. 6. CaRTER, CARTER. MASSACHUSETTS, Belmont. HE BELMONT SCHOOL. Founded 1889. Incorporated 1897. An Episcopal Church Boarding School for Boys, pre- paratory for College or Scientific School. For terms, etc., address B. F, Harpine, A.M., Head Master. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 9 Appleton Street. OSTUN NORMAL SCHOOL of House- hold Arts, established by the late Mrs Mary Hk- MENWAY, under the name of Boston NORMAL SCHOOL OF COOKERY, will reopen Sept. 29. Adaress the Director, Miss AMY Morris Homans. xi " MASSACHUSETTS, Boston. OSTON UNIVERSITY Law School. Address the Dean, EpMunD H. BENNETT, LL.D. MASSACHUSETTS, Concord. ONCORD SCHOOL. Prepares for College, Scientific School, and Bus!- ness. Individualinstruction Elementary classes. Non- sectarian. JaMES S. GARLAND, Principal. MASSACHUSETTS Duxbury OWDER POINT SCHOOL.— Prepares for Scientific School, College, or business. Indi- vidual teaching. Elementary classes for By a Home and ou oor life. F. B. Knapp, 8. fr NEW YORK, Mount Vernon, 25 minutes from - Y. HE MISSES LOCK WOUD'S COLLE- giate School for Girls. 12th year College-Prepa ratory and — Courses. Certificate admits to Vas- sar and Wellesley. Home attractive. French spoken Instruction Srscugh. Only earnest students desired. Terms moderate New York City, 43 West 47th Street. CADEMIC CLASSES FOR GIRLS. College Preparation in a College-Preparatory School. Certificate admits to Smith, Vassar, and Wellesley. Special coaching to supply deficiencies. Residence from Monday to Friday arranged. Mary B. WHITON, A.B., and Lois A. BANGS. New YorK City, 126 and 128 East 17th Street. HE NALIONAL CONSERVATOR} OF MUSIC OF AMERICA.—Dr. Antonin Dvorak, Director. Annual Entrance Examinations begin Sep tember 15. For particulars, address SECRETARY. Educational. New York City, 537 Fifth Avenue. ISS M. D. HUGER, Boarding and Day School for Girls. New York, Utica. RS. PLATT’ S SCHOOL FOR GIRLS. ~The next school year begins Thursday, Septem- er 23, 1897. - Applications § should be made early. OnI0, Cincinnati, 2648 Bellevue Ave , Mt. Auburn. TSS LUPTON’S SCHOOL reopened Sept. 29. Thorough preparation is given for college. The number of boarding pupils is limited, Circulars are sent on application. OuI0, Cincinnati. TSS ARMSTRONG'’S SCHOOL FOR Girls, Liddesdale Place, Avondale. Family limit- ed. “ Circulars sent on application PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, Chestnut Hill. RS. COMEG YS’ AND MISS BELL'S BOARDING AND DAY SCHOOL FOR GIRLS will reopen October 1. Students prepared forcollege. FRANCE, Parts. T. MARGARET'S FRENCH AND English School for Girls. Household French, with American —. Pupils met at Havre or ‘Cher- bourg. Address Miss Acty, 50 Avenue d’Jéna. TSS ANABLE’S Boarding and Day l School for Girls. Established in 1848, Circular on application, Opens Sept. 27. 1350 Pine St., Phila., Pa. School of Drawing and Painting, MUSEUM OF FINE ARTS, Copley Square, Boston. Mass. THE TWENTY-SECOND YEAR OPENS OCT. 4, 1897. Instruction in drawing from the cast and from =. > ainting and a om, pee fee n artistic enetaes a rs iv instructors: F. w. Benso e Cc. Tar ga. and Philip Hale Fe rawing and ’ painting) Wil- liam Stone ( ecorative, Design), E. wt Emerson (Anatomy), and A Perspective). Pupils are allowed the free ka. of the eilerien of the ge For circulars giving detailed informa- on, address MISS ELIZABETH LOMBARD, Manager. MILITARY 8LtEGE Chester, Pa. 36th year begins Sept. 15 Civil Engineering (C.£.),Chemistry (B.S.), ‘Arts (A. B.). Also Thorough Preparatory ‘Courses. Infantry, ‘Atiliery and Cavalry Dri “A Military School of t _ highest order.”* 4 De r Repartment R t. » Presi: eat. 5 Catalogues of Cui? Western Reserve University Includes ADELBERT COLLEGE (for men); COL- LEGE FOR WOMEN; GRADUATE “oN L FOR MEN AND WOMEN, degrees of A.M., ae WwW SCHOOL (three years); MEDICAL SCHOOL (four years): DENT L SCHOOL (three years). CHARLES F. AT WING. President, Cleveland, O. BRADFORD ACADEMY. Founded 1803. For the higher education of young women. Classical and Scientific course of study; also eae ms | and Optional. Year begins Sept. 15, 1897. Miss Ida C. Allen, Prin., Bradfo . Mass. CEDARCROFT SCHOOL. In the Highlands of the Hudson. Number limited to tes. . Combines home life with careful individual inin a ol HUSE, M.A., Principal, Cornwall, N. Y. A SCHOOL THAT IS A HOME. LheVermont Episcopal Institute, Burlington, Vt. On the shore of Lake Champlain, prepares thirty boys for college or for business, and gives the care and training of a refined home. $40 way York refer- ences. H. H. KOSS, A. M., Principal. THE HOTCHKISS SCHOOL Lakeville, Conn. Bao gd ar - best colle; tab gepiae ar 0 a am EDWARD eC CoY, Pitead Master. ST. AGN ES SCHOOL Under the direction of Bishop Doane. Prepara- of Colle ~y stands 8 7 1 ~ Be Ce ‘and ege u ala Art. Gyignestum, Miss ELLE NW B OYD, Prin., any, a ~ ‘THE CAMBRIDGE SCHOOL. A ag School for Comforts of Home. Girls. Mr. ARTHUR GILMAN is the Director. CAMBRIDGE, MASS. Mrs. M. F.WALTON, 79%; 9242" ees beng me School and Practice School. hoa on Sab Le SED LARD ah ENT Bi ah 82 SE
Page 3
x a as ae sng nd ge rea BSL RO BOR So SpE RN Sgn tees oop Oct. 7, 1897] The Nation. School Agencies. Y hoes FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES. Everett O Fisk & Co., Proprietors. 4 Ashburton Place, Boston. 1242 12th 8t., Washington. 70 Fifth Ave., New York. 414Cent. Bag . Minneapolis 378 Wabash Ave., Chicago. 730 Cooper a. Denver. 25 King St., Toronto. 525 Stims’n Bk.,Los Angeles LBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY. 24 State St., Albany, N. Y.—Provides schools of all grades with competent teachers. Assists teachers in obtaining positions. HarLan P. Frencu, Manager. R COLLEGE POSITIONS IN THE WEST, Apply to ALBERT & CLARK, Pullman Building, Chicago. CHER MERHORN'S TEACHERS Agency. Oldest and best known in the U.S. tablished 1855. 8 E, 14th St., N. Y. Teachers, etc. RENCH IN A PARISIAN FAMILY. An educated French family, consisting of a wid- owed mother and a son and daughter who are com- pleting their studies, offers ahome to not more than three or four Americans at moderate terms. Highest references. Address MADAME DE MaTUSKA, 53 Avenue de Neuilly, Paris. HARLES W. STONE, Tutor for Har- vard, 68 Chestnut Street, Boston. 7 ours. EUROPEAN WINTER RESORT. INNSBRUCK, TYROL, AUSTRIA. 1,900 feet above the sea. with dry, bracing climate. CENTRE FOR SLEIGHING EXCURSIONS. Fine University, Hospital, etc. HOTEL TIROL. Open all the year. Cart LANDSEE. Proprietor. Large, airy, sunny rooms; modern conveniences; superior cul- sine. Reduced rates in winter. Best references. [lus trated pamphiets sent on application EUROPEAN BICYCLE TOUR. Allexpenses, 70 days. $420. C. H. SMITH, 218 Woodward Avenue, Detroit, Mich Letters We buy and sell bills of exchange so and make Cable Transfers of money on of Europe, Australia, and South Africa; alto : make collections and issue Commercial Credit and Travellers’ Credits, available in all * parts of the world. a ae CREST VIEW SANITARIUM, Greenwich, Conn. An ideal home for health and re- creation seekers. Beautiful scenery; very accessible; moderate rates. H. M. HITCHCOCK, M.D. Old South Leaflets on the Anti-Slavery Struggle Eight leaflets relating to the Anti-Slavery Struggle have just been added to the series of Old South Leaflets. constituting Nos. 78-85 of the series. The new leaflets are as follows: A Reprint of the First Number of The Liberator; Wendell Phillips’s Eulogy of Garrison; Theodore Parker's Address on the Dangers from Slavery: Whittier’s Account of the Anti Slavery Convention of 1833; Mrs. Stowe’s Story of “Uncle Tom’s Cabin”; Sumner’s Speech on the Crime against Kansas; Words of John Brown, and the First Lincoln and Douglas Debate. These eight leaflets are bound together in aneat volume in poet covers, with an introduction giving complete lists of all the Old South Leaflets and Lectures since 1883, and sold for 35 cents Accompanied as all the leaflets are with careful references to the best books, nothing could be a better guide for clubs and classes making a study of the Anti-Slavery Struggle. The Old South Leaflets are sold for 5 cents a copy, or $4 00 per hundred. Send for complete list. DIRECTORS OF THE OLD SOUTH WORK, Old South Meeting-House, Beston. Mass. “6 TOU may not be worthy to smoke the Noenol Constable Ko. Upholstery. Broche Damasks, Wool Tapestries, and Drapery Fabrics. Drapery Designs Specially Prepared and Executed. iY ? ? Jvoadevauy AS 19th dt. Z NEW YORK. INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ETHICS OCTOBER NUMBER. NANSEN. LESLIE STEruen, London. CITIZENSHI+. PE. Matueson, New Colleze, Oxford. PROFESSOR JOWETT. Epwarp Carrp, Balliol Col lege, Oxferd THE RELATION OF PESSIMISM TO ULTIMATE PHI LOSOPHY, F.C. 8. ScHr__er, Cornell University. OUR SOCIAL AND ETHICAL SULIDARITY. Epmcxp MONTGOMERY, Hempstead, Texas. SOME OF THE LEADING IDEAS OF — S POSI Vist MELLON. Edinbu THE HISTORY AND SPIRIT OF CHINESE ETBIcS ELJIRO NAKAMURA, Tos yo, Japan. DISCUSSIONS AND BOOK REVIEWS PHILADELPHIA: INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ETHICS, 1305 Arch Street. SINGLE NUMBER, 65 CTS. YEARLY, $2.50. (Trade Mark Registered.) and little starch—whb Nutritious and pal acidity and flatulence, ghest degree Unrt- ; FREE Watertown, N.¥. ARCADIA MIXTURE.” —J. M. B—, sie My Lady Nicotine Send 25 cents for sample to THE SURBRUG CO., 37 Dey Street, N. Y. City. ECOLE LIBRE DES SCIENCES POLITIQUES 27, Rue Saint-Guillaume, a PARIS (Vingt-seplieme annee 1SQ7-18Q8) L—DIRECTEUR: M. Bmile BOUTMY, membre de I'institut, membre du Conseil supérieur de instruction publique IL.—COMITE DE PERFECTIONNEMENT MM. BOULANGER, sénateur, premier président de la Cour des Comptes: CAMBON., gouvrerneur géné ral de |’ Algérie; Baron de CUURCEL, sénateour ambassadeur de France A Londres; PLOURENS, député, ancien ministre; GLASSON, de I'Insti tut, professeur A la Faculté de Droit; NANO. TAUX, ministre des Affaires étrangéres: JANET, de I'Instatut; LAPERRIBRE, vice président du Conseil d Etat: P. LEROV-BEAULIEL., de IIa stitut; MAGNIN, vice-président du Sénat. gou- verneur dela Banque de France: NISARD, dire teur des Affaires politiques au Ministdre des Af faires &trangéres: RAMBAUD, ministre de I'In struction publique; A. RIBOT, député, ancien président du Conseil des ministres 1IL—CORPS ENSEIGNANT MM. LEVASSEUR, de !lostitut; Albert SOREL. de Académie francaise: H GAIDOZ. directeur Al'Ecole des Hautes Etudes; LYON-CAEN, de l'Institut, professeur A la Faculté de Droit: RE- NAUCT, professeur A la Faculté de Proit FUNCK-BRENTANO; Anatole LEROY- BEAL LIEU. de linstitut: Albert VANDAL, del Aca démie franoaise; Andre LEBON, dépurd mi: tre des Colonies; Charles BE NOIST, J r L. Ach. professeur au Collage de Fracce; Gebriel ALIX: LEVASSEUR DE PRECOURT.) maitre dex rm quétes benoraire au Conseil d' Etat, DUNOY ER. ancien conseiller d’ Etat CHEYSSON, | Pspercteus général des Ponts et Chaussées; DE FOvVitt E de Vinstitut, directeur de ladministration des Monnaies et Médaitles; Rene ale oy de Tos tut. ancien inspecteur des é pances “2 AR- NAUNE, directeur au Mia stare ae nance: BOULANGER, conse: 7 ndaine » Cour des Com ptes COURTIN LAF t AlN, TINT teurs des Finances: SLVE STUE. en direc teur des Affaires civiles au Tonkin ~* TABLEAU en DES Cou ~~ Hist ¢ pe de 17890 ts? Histoire constitutionneile de Tk mye et des Etats Unis, des s ics Histoire diplomat que de U Burope, de 1718 4 Histoire politique de T Rurope pead t les g derni san $ I haus s Pte? . ee stiONs dit es et t ‘i 2 isie Orienfa Organisat ; ti x ~Irees treugrapmir t EY ! ¢ € ’ emne » et statist raga ef ? sat ’ i wires pate des posses $ ses dD les a mint ’ f t™ wsateonet ma esa raat } a +, Péter . Léqg stati nue ef Droit 7 Légisiation ‘ sa Econom: ti lis pues Ry TED socia - sia ¢ Hy €3 gue et grands wo I Finances f Bis tet $ La mrmCTa t ef i {faire yu Comme te et slation douanirre R -ENSI IGNE MENTS GENERAUX L' Enseigneme nt del Fe le des Sciences P Nitiques est le couronnement naturel de toute éducation lib¢ rale. Chacune de ses grandes divisions constitue €B Outre ube preparation compl: te aux carrieres a’ Etat et aux examens ov concours qui en ouvrent | Pentrée Diplomatie, Conseil d Etat. Cours des ; Comptes, Daapeet tion des Finances), et A des postes dinitiative ou de contréle dans les grandes entre | prises privées Les 4léves sont admis sans examens, avec l'agré ment du Directeur et du Conseil de I Ecole; ils n'ont A justifier d'aucu: grade universitaire L’enseignement comprend un ensemble de cours répartis en deux années, mats L durée des études peut étre étendue a trois ans diplome est dé | liwré, en fin d’études, aux éleves qui ont subi avec succes les examens. ANNEE SCOLAIRE 1897-1898.—L année sco laire commencera le 8 novembre 1897 et finira le 6 juin I8@8. On s‘inscrira au Secrétariat a partir du 3 novembre 1807. Inscription d’ensemble donnant entrée A tous Jes cours et conférences réguliers et complémentaires et 4 la Bibliothéque (environ 25,000 volumes et 160 revues et journaux frangais et étrangers) ; Par ANn&e: 300 fr. Brochure speciale donne des renseigne ments detailies sur l'organisation de l’ Ecole et ur lescarrieres aux auelles elie prepare , S’adresser a VECOLE, 27, Rue Saint- Guillaume, PARIS. & : 3 jubiigeanle Fig Sasendinduae ee eee
Page 4
lv The Nation. [Vol. 65, No. 1684 GINN & COMPANY’S LATEST BOOKS Poems of William Wordsworth. Just Ready. Chosen and Edited, with Introduction and Notes, by Epwarp DowpeEn, Professor of English Literature in the University of Dublin, Clark Lec- turer in English Literature, Trinity College, Cambridge. 12mo. Cloth. 522 pages. Science of Discourse. By Arno_p Tompxins, Professor of Pedagogy in the University of Illi- nois. 12mo. Cloth. 353 pages. For introduction, $1 00. Physical Experiments. A Manual and Note Book by ALFrep P. GaGe, author of * Principles of Physics,” ete. 12mo. Boards. 97 pages. For introduction, 35 cents. Flowers and Their Friends. By MarGaret W. Mokvey. author of ‘ Seed-Babies,”’ ‘‘A Few Familiar Flowers,” ete. Boards. 255 pages. For introduction, 50 cents. Exercises in Greek Composition. By Epwin H. Hiavey, Master at Groton School. 12mo. Cloth. 170 pages. For introduction, $1.00. German Orthography and Phonology. A Treatise with a Word-List. Part I. By Gzorae Hemp, Professor of English Philology and General Linguistics in the University of Michi gan. 12mo. Cloth. 264 pages. For introduction, $2.00. School Edition of Homer’s Odyssey, Edited, with Introduction, Commentary, and Vocabulary, by B. Perrin and T. D. Szymocr, Professors of Greek in Yale University. Eight Books, with Vocabulary. Square 12mo. Half moroeco. 351 pages. For introduction, $1.50. Four Books, with Vocabulary. Square 12mo. Half moroeco. 248 pages. For introduction, $1.25. A Practical Physiology. A Text-Book for High School, Academy, and Normal School Classes. By ALBERT F. BuaispeLti, M.D., author of ‘ Blaisdell’s Series of Phy- siologies.”” Cloth. Fully illustrated. 448 pages. For introduction, $1.20. Elements of Chemistry. By R. P. Witu1ams, in charge of the Chemical Department of the English High School, Boston. Cloth. 412 pages. For introduction, $1.10. The Student’s American History. A Text-Book for High Schools and Colleges. By D. H. Montgomery, author of ‘‘The Leading Facts of History Se- ries.”’ Illustrated. Cloth. 523+1v pages. For introduction, $1.40. Higher Arithmetic. By W. W. Beman, Professor of Mathematics in the University of Michi- gan, and D. E. Smira, Professor of Mathematics in the Michigan State Normal College. Cloth. 193 pages. For introduction, 80 cents. Descriptive Circulars of all our Books sent, postpaid, to any address, Correspondence cordially invited. GINN & COMPANY, Publishers, BOSTON. NEW YORK. _ CHICAGO. ATLANTA. _ LONDON. _ LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO.’S NEW BOOKS. NEW ROMANCE BY WILLIAM MORRIS. THE WATER OF THE WONDROUS ISLES. By Wiiu1aM Morris. Large crown 8vo, buckram, pp. x-+-553, $2.50. BUILDERS OF GREAT BRITAIN. Edited by H. F. Witson, M.A. A set of volumes illustrating the growth and expansion of the Queen's Empire, as shown in the lives of the soldiers and governors who have played the chief parts. Each volume will contain the t est portrait obtainable of its subject, anda map showing his special contributions to the Imperial Edifice. 1. SIR WALTER RALEIGH; The British Dominion of the West. By MartTIN A/S. Hume. Crown 8vo, with Portrait. and 2 Maps, 450 pages, $1.50. 2. SIR THOMAS MAITLAND; The Masters of the Mediterranean. By WALTER FREWEN LORD. [In the Press. *.* Other volumes in preparation. NEW BOOK BY GEORGE MACDONALD, LL.D. RAMPOLLI: Growths from a Long-Planted Root: Being Translations, New and Old, chiefly from the German; along with A Year's Diary of an Old Soul. By GEORGE MACDONALD, LL.D. Crown 8vo, $1.75. NEW NOVEL BY EDNA LYALL. WAYFARING MEN. By the author of ‘‘ Donovan,” ‘*We Two,” ‘ Doreen,” etc. Crown 8vo, cloth, ornamental, $1.50. “Miss Lyall’s novel is one of unflagging interest, written in that clear, virile style, with its gentle humor and dramatic effectiveness, that readers well know and appreciate. ‘ Wayfaring Men’ is a literary tonic to be .warmly welcomed and cheerfully commended as an antidote to much of the unhealthy, morbid, and enervating fiction of the day.” Press, Phiiadeiphia. : NEW BOOK BY ANDREW LANG. A BOOK OF DREAMS AND GHOSTS. By ANDREW LaNnG. Crown 8vo, Cloth, ornamental, gilt edges, $2.00. *,* Previous works on this subject have been remarkably lax in the matter of evidence. In this book original sources are always investigated, and some manuscripts have been discovered and made use of. Thus, one celebrated Aus- tralian story of ‘* Fisher’s Ghost” is here told from the judge's notes at the trial and from the newspaper report of the day. A manuscript by Mr. Wynd. ham, who knew the seer of the Duke of Buckingham’s father’s ghost, and was in his society at the time, is reproduced. All contemporary evidence for Lord Lyttelton’s ghosts is analyzed, and Williams's dream of Mr. Perceval’s mur- der is given in the dreamer’s own words. The Ricketts and Wesley ghosts are similarly treated. A number of modern stories at first-hand are produced, some by the permission of the Society for Psychical Research. Icelandic, Chi- nese, and Highland Ghosts are criticised. THE EXPOSITORY PARAGRAPH AND SENTENCE. An Elementary Manual of Composition. By CHARLES SEARS BaLpwIn, A.M., Ph.D., Instructor in Rhetoric in Yale University. 18mo, 50 cents. “A olear, vigorous, and systematic method of treatment, copiously illustrated by examples, which have every advantage of novelty, and of judicious selections from standard writers.’’—A. L. Bouton, Rutgers Preparatory School, New Bruns- wick, N. J. HISTORY OF THE COMMONWEALTH AND PRO- TECTORATE, 1649-1660. By SamMvuEL Rawson GARDINER, D.C.L., LL.D. Vol. II., 1651-1654. With maps. 8vo, $7.00. THE ELEMENTS OF COTTON SPINNING. By Joun Morris and F. WILKINSON. With a Preface by Sir B. A. Dosson, C.E., M.1.C.E. Crown 8vo, $2.50 net. cid by booksellers. Sent, postpaid, om receipt of price. LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., Publishers, 91-93 Fifth Ave., New York. ; i § a * v4 * 4 A bbinissnissci PERT At Mies tinct a es EB a
Page 5
i i Pon Mo eae Nit Set RM AERO Boi ee an aaa Atel étyide scssnlll pwikatis DAIS RAS The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, OCTOBER 7, 1897. The Week. The Monetary Commission, of which ex-Senator Edmunds is chairman, has organized itself in three sub-committees and prepared a list of questions upon which it has solicited the opinions of business and professional men. The list has been sent especially to those who have given attention to the subject in hand and have acquired reputation as instructors therein. It was found im- possible within the limited time, and with the means at the disposal of the Commission, to go about the country, hiring rooms and taking testimony like an investigating committee of Congress. Nor is it certain that the best results would be achieved by such means, since all the facts that are needed are within reach at Washington city and are pre- sumably in possession of the members already. A roving commission would be likely to accumulate a great amount of lumber which it could not use, since everybody who has a plan of his own for straightening out the national finances would insist upon being heard orally. Few Americans are without such a plan, and in that fact lies the main difficulty. If questions of public finance were left solely to those who understand them, as is the case in most civilized countries, there would be no monetary question now and no need of a monetary commission. The present Commission does well, therefore, not to expose itself to personal contact with all the cranks who would like to give a public airing to their respective systems. To the three sub-committees are as- signed the three branches of the main subject, viz.: (1) metallic currency; (2) demand obligations of the Government; (8) banking. The first has to deal with the standard of value—to decide whe- ther it shall be gold, or silver, or what is commonly called the double standard, but is really the alternate standard. This will necessarily include the ques- tion whether international bimetallism is practicable. The second deals with the outstanding paper greenbacks and Treasury notes of the United States, but not necessarily with the silver certifi- cates—these being merely warehouse re- ceipts for silver dollars held on storage by the Government. As the Government has promised to keep the dollars at par with gold, the certificates will be at par as long as the promise is fulfilled. The third sub-committee deals with bank is- sues only, but this question is the most complicated of all, and upon its right so- lution depends the success of the whole investigation. The degradation in which Bryanism has involved the Democratic party of the nation could not be more vividly il- lustrated than by the contrast between the State convention in Massachusetts on Tuesday week, which nominated George Fred Williams for Governor, and the gathering of National Democrats which made William Everett a candidate for the same office on Thursday. Wil- liams is a perfect type of the harum- scarum men who have come into control of the “regular” organization; and the noisy convention, which required the in- tervention of the police to save it from riot, fitly represented the lawless ten- dencies which Bryanism develops. On the other hand, the gathering of Na- tional Democrats included a large num- ber of the men who helped William E. Russeli to his three elections as Gover- nor, and it nominated in William Eve- rett a candidate for the same position who would adorn the office. Dr. Everett’s address of acceptance and Moorfield Storey’s speech as chairman of the convention fully vindicated the policy of those Democrats who cannot support Bryanism and who are equally opposed to modern Republicanism. The Republican State convention, which was sandwiched in between the other two, had nothing to do except to renominate the full ticket of State officials now in place. Gov. Wolcott has made an ex- cellent executive, and his reélection is, of course, assured. The platform on which he stands says the first good word for Mr. McKinley’s attitude towards the civil-service law which has yet come from a Republican convention in any State, commending him for, “under severe pressure for place, not merely maintaining, but wisely extending, the merit system in our civil service.” It was, however, unworthy of the gold sentiment of the Bay State to praise him also for “instituting an honest search for honest bimetallism, which an international agreement alone can ef- fect,’ when there is not an intelligent man in the State but recognizes the humbug of the roving Wolcott-Steven- son-Paine commission. The significance of the nomination of Gen. Tracy against Seth Low—in fact, the significance of the whole anti-Low movement in the RepuLlican machine— lies in the fact that the corporations which hold city franchises of one kind and another do not want Seth Low, or any man of that stamp, for Mayor. These | and other corporations furnish money to the Republican boss to pay for what they call “protection,”’ and the boss distributes it among the politicians who SSS === petuating machine, and is the greatest menace to free institutions that exists anywhere in the world to-day. The ma- nagers of these corporations say that they must be protected against “strik- ers” in the Legislature, and that they must buy protection where it can be had. The only question with them is whether it will cost more to buy off the strikers after the Legislature meets or before it is elected. They have tried both ways, and they find the latter cheaper, more reliable, and less trouble some. “Protection,” it should be re marked, means anything that they feel the need of. As long as they and the boss are the only ones concerned in defining the word, it may mean what- ever they please. If they simply want to be let alone, that is protection. If they want something they do not now possess, or have grabbed it without an- thority and have been caught red-hand ed, then protection has one meaning to the public, but another meaning to the grabbers. If they want something that they cannot grab, but which they think they ought to have, then protection has a still different meaning. The “Henry George movement” took shape on Friday evening, when his ac ceptance of the nomination for Mayor was received by the Bryan Democrats in convention assembled. Whatever this movement may prove to be in point of numbers, every vote that it musters will be taken from the Tammany ticket. Not one will come from the Gold Democrats, not one from the Republicans, not one from the Citizens’ Union. The move- ment will, therefore, be welcomed by all the other parties except, possibly, the Platt machine, which will find its chances of a post-election deal with Croker dwindling in proportion as Tammany’s voting strength is drawn away by the George movement. In a four-cornered fight Mr. Low’s chances are decidedly the best. Few more amazing things have oc- curred in New York city politics than the sudden appearance of ex-Mayor Grace and Francis M. Scott as parties to a disreputable ‘“deal’’ with Tammany Hall. We use the term disreputable ad- visedly, for, if the plan which they un- dertook had succeeded, it would have involved the delivery in a body of the local oganization of the National or Sound-Money Democracy to Tammany Hall as the price of a Supreme Court Judge nomination for Mr. Scott. That this was the proposition is not our as- sertion, but that of Mr. Scott’s political associates, and it is also his own vir- control the nominating conventions. | tual admission. Its success was thwart- This makes a self-working, self-per- ed by the refusal of the honest and self- t & 3 t : ——— ee ee nah gett dite
Page 6
27O respecting men in the organization to submit to such a base betrayal. If Tam- many had nominated a decent municipal ticket, the proposal might have been de fended on reasonable party grounds, but, coming as it does on the heels of Van Wyck’s nomination, there is absolutely nothing to say for it. It will fail, we have no doubt, utterly and overwhelm- ingly, when the organization reassem- bles this week. The Brooklyn section of the National Democracy has taken the only course which, as reputable men, the members of the party everywhere can take —that is, to declare in favor of Mr. Low. What excuse is there for delay? We know what Tammany proposes and we know what Platt proposes. We know also what Mr. Low stands for. Either the National Democracy is in favor of honest government or it is against it, and the member of it who desires more time in which to make up his mind is seeking something quite other than non- partisan government. It is not the least of the encouraging elements in the situation in this city that Tammany will be virtually without advocacy of its cause in the local press, provided, of course, that the old Tam- many Nun does not return to its first love when it shall be forced to the al- ternative of doing that or favoring honest government. No newspaper of any character or influence is in favor of the restoration of Croker and Sheehan, and this absence of support will be a serious loss in the campaign. In fact, we begin to see already how great a change has been wrought in public sen- timent during the past few years in regard to municipal government. It is a much more difficult thing now than it ever was before for a newspaper or a politician of character or a citizen of repute to take sides with Tammany Hall, especially when Tammany Hall does not think it necessary to put on an appearance of decency. As the cam- paign advances, we shall have more evi- dence of this kind, for every day’s dis- cussion will make the issue clearer. It is not conceivable that there is in the enlargec city a majority of voters who are willing, when the choice is laid so plainly before them, to select the worst possible kind of government in place of | the best The Pennsylvania courts continue to annul laws passed by the Legislature on the ground of their obvious unconstitu- tionality. The last act thus overthrown was a particularly flagrant attempt to tamper with the ballot law. It provided that the name of any candidate should not appear more than once upon the ballot to be voted at any election. practical effect of such a restriction, as has already been illustrated, would be to prevent the Democrats of Philadel- phia from putting their, judicial candi- | The Nation. [Vol. 65, No. 1684 dates on their ticket because the Re- tempting, however, to prevent the Mc- | Kinley Administration from reopening publicans had been before them in no- minating the same men, and to debar | the Democrats of Schuylkill from reno- minating and having on their ticket a judge of their own party because the Republicans had renominated him first. The absurdity and injustice of such a provision are obvious, and it is most fortunate that the courts find it as ob- the question by appealing to the Su- | preme Court if it should elect to do so. The matter was left in such shape that if Mr. McKinley’s Attorney-General does nothing, the sum of $46,000,000 will pre- | sently drop into the Treasury, and the ' Government will be relieved of some- noxious to the Constitution as it is to | common sense and fair play. Senator Morrill begins the publication in the Forum of some “Notable Letters” which he has received from public men. | He includes a few written on the tariff | in 1860-'62 by Henry C. Carey. The ta- riff of those days was of pre-historic simplicity and moderation, compared with the tariff as we now know it, but even then one thing was needed which is needed now. ‘Nothing less than a dictater,”’ wrote Mr. Carey in 1860, “‘is required for making a really good tariff. Would to Heaven you or I could fill the place for a week!”’ The tariff-dictators have greatly increased and multiplied since those idyllic days. Not all of them are in Congress—many do their dic- tating by telegraph, many on manufac- turers’ letter-heads, some from Wall Street. Latest developments, however, look as if even the dictator would have to yield to the thimble-rigger in tariff- making. Mr. Nimmo informs us that “as much true Americanism” was put into section 22 of the Dingley bill as is to be found “in all the other sections of the act combined.” Yet this true Ameri- canism was not put into the bill by a dictator, but by a midnight trick, a jug- gler legislator. Thus a new era in ta- riffs opens before us. We still need a dictator to make Congress vote, but we need also a head trickster to manipu- late in secret the bill which Congress passes without knowing what it is. The interest which moves the Govern- ment to let the decree of foreclosure in the Union Pacific Railroad case, which has been entered in the United States Circuit Court, stand undisturbed, lies in the fact that the Government needs the money. it makes a difference of nearly $46,000,000 in a pinch whether the decree of foreclosure is allowed to stand or whether an appeal is taken. Consider- ing the dreadful botch, or series of botches, which Congress has made in its attempts to deal with this problem, it must be regarded as a piece of extra- | ordinary good luck to the present Ad- | ministration that its predecessor took | the responsibility of coming to a settle- The | | ment with the insolvent company. In- stead of leaving matters to drift, there- by prolonging litigation and multiplying lawyers’ fees and other expenses, and perhaps dismembering the property al- together, the terms of a decree’ of fore- closure were agreed upon, without at- thing which has been a nuisance to it for a great many years. Moreover, Con- gress will be relieved of a problem which it has shown itself incapable of solving, and the country will be spared a future torrent of words from Senator Morgan of Alabama. If Neal Dow, who died on Saturday at a great age, had died thirty or thirty- five years ago, he might have departed with the comforting conviction that he had discovered the most effective way to repress the liquor traffic. For some time after “the Maine law” went into operation, it was possible for a sanguine believer in the policy of State prohibi- tion to claim that legislation would cure the evil. For many years past, however, the veteran champion of this system has been forced to admit that the law was openly violated in the cities and large towns, and that each new Legislature must pass some more rigorous statute on the subject, only to find that this had failed as badly as its predecessors. The fact is now confessed by all candid resi- dents that prohibition as a State mea- sure is an utter failure, and that Maine would be far better off with a local- option system, under which towns op- posed to the liquor traffic could forbid it, and those where it flourishes would impose a proper tax or license fee. Advocates of Hawaiian annexation are much relieved to hear that the Sugar Trust has withdrawn its opposition to the treaty. Just how the thing has been arranged is not clear; but simultaneous- ly in Honolulu and San Francisco it is announced that, somehow, Spreckels has been “squared,” the island planters have been let into the “deal,’’ and now all is clear sailing. If this is so, we shall ex- pect the Senate to return at once to its high moral plane in discussing annexa- tion. There was, for a time, a mercena- ry tinge to the debate, which must have pained Senators—there was much talk of the selfish opposition of beet-sugar growers and sugar refiners, and hints that there would be something substan- tial “in it” for certain Western Senators if they could beat the treaty. It is well if all this is now removed from the de- bate, and if it can again dwell upon the lofty morality of 3,000 aiiens giving away the territory and sovereignty of 47,000 natives and residents. We are glad also to see that Senator Morgan is already in the field with the argument from high naval strategy. He knows now beyond a peradventure just how Ail sal shes Ppa je Sree ie ane a Aceh OF eRe er aee
Page 7
@ Sec cee piacere ai wt 5 Sa Pe ioe i aan ite 3 Oct. 7, 1897] the great circles and the radii cut the Hawaiian islands, for he has been there himself and had his foot right on the intersection. Those who expect any great change in the Cuban situation from the accession of a Liberal ministry in Spain would do well to recall certain facts. One is that the present Cuban rebellion broke out under a Liberal Prime Minister—under Sagasta himself—and that he was doing his best to put it down with a nard hand when he fell from power in 1895. An- other is that the “reforms” for Cuba again promised are not likely to appease discontent now, after two years’ fight- ing, any more than they did when first offered by Sagasta three years ago, be- fore there had been any fighting at all. Nothing showed more clearly the refrac- tory nature of this insurrection than the fact that it broke out right on the heels of a vote by the Cortes of the largest measure of self-government ever offered by Spain to a colony. Since then even more extensive concessions in the line of home rule have been proposed by the Conservative Government, but have had no effect in diminishing the intensity or cruelty of the war in Cuba. That sore, evidently, cannot now be poulticed by a grant of autonomy. Furthermore, the change of political leadership in Spain cannot have altered the policy which Mr. McKinley and his advisers have deter- mined upon in respect to Cuba. That policy, whatever it is, was deliberately adopted weeks ago, and Gen. Woodford’s instructions were framed, not for this Prime Minister or the other, not for Conservative or Liberal government as such. They cannot be changed, as, in- deed, it is announced from Washington that they will not be, by Sagasta’s re- turn to power. While the new Spanish cabinet has not the names of some of the abler Liberals who it was supposed would have portfolios, it seems to be strong at the critical points. The new Minister for Foreign Affairs is not, it is true, a man known for commanding ability, but in any case Sagasta would have to be his own Minister for Foreign Affairs, as CAa- novas was before him. But his Minister for the Colonies, Sefior Moret, who will have to look after the vexing details of Cuban and Philippine affairs. is a Liberal of distinguished services and great influence. Both he and Sagasta have lately exposed themselves to the charge of being unpatriotic by severely criticising the policy of the Conserva- | tives in foreign affairs, and by assert- ing that, despite the official reports. matters were going badly in Cuba and the Philippines. How truly do such ut- terances look to a change of policy, now that the Liberals are in power? Or did er? That the latter was the case, to a | The Nation. considerable extent at least, Spaniards themselves, when talking not for publi- cation, will not deny. But the greatest difficulties in the way of a real change of policy respecting Cuba are, of course, the pride of the Spanish people, and the fatal inertia of the administrative and military machine. A correspondent of the London Times makes some illuminating comments on Gov. Smith’s proposal to use the permis- sion given in the act of 1844 to the Bank of England to hold part of its reserve in silver. He shows from Sir Robert Peel's speeches when introducing the bill in 1844, and in amending it in 1848, that what Peel had in mind was the possi- bility at that time of liquidating obli- gations to France profitably in silver, owing to the fact that, under the French bimetallic law, silver was now and then overvalued in Paris. Peel wished the Bank ot England, in short, to be able to get the benefit of this whenever it happened. Another reason Peel as- signed was, that it might be well to have a stock of silver ready for shipment to | the East, especially India. Of course, this is now totally unnecessary. Deal- ers stand ready at a hundred points to ship silver by telegraph to anybody who is foolish enough to want more of it. In fact, it would appear that Mr. Smith never took the trouble to look up the original reason of the permission to keep some silver in reserve. The con- ditions have totally changed. There is no profit to be made on the Continent | by sending silver over. If anybody now sees silver coming to him instead of gold, he tries to make his escape, and the Bank’s keeping it in reserve is about as necessary as keeping copper and iron would be. The Greeks find the treaty concluded by the Powers, over their heads, fixing the amount of damages they have to pay for the fun of making war on the Turks, and creating foreign control of their finances, too much for their sto- machs. On its submission to the Boulé not for ratification, but for approval confidence in the ministry was refused by a vote of 90 to 30, and Mr. Ralli’s re- signation followed. The treaty has made the situation a little better than it was, but not much. The money has still to be paid, and the Turk has agreed to leave Thessaly a month after he gets; . = ‘ a Ss * : | ing South Germans. The choice of Nu- it. But if anything about the Turk can | be learnt from experience, he will not | leave Thessaly. He was bound far more solemnly than he is now-——for he had to face Gladstone and Bismarck—in 1881 to give Thessaly to Greece, and he agreed to do so; but he did not do so until Gladstone got ready to use force. There is no Gladstone now, or Bismarck either, and if the Turk leaves Thessaly they simply indicate a wish to gain pow- | i until somebody threatens or attacks him, he will do what he has never done 271 before. Turkish territory has never been ceded except under the guns of a conqueror, and we greatly fear the Greeks may pay their money long be- fore they get Thessaly. The Sultan is sure to find some excuse for not evacu- ating, and he will then wait to see whe- ther he is going to be compelled; but who will undertake the job of compel ling him? Jingoes have done much mis- chief in their day, but we doubt if any where else they have brought so much ruin on a community as they have brought on Greece. When the Powers met to consider the case of Crete, au tonomy and the withdrawal of the Turk ish garrison would doubtless have come before long, and then annexation to Greece would probably have soon fol lowed, for nobody would have interfered to prevent it. But the Athenian Jingves felt that, without a war, the national character would run down. So, like true Jingoes, without stopping for a moment to count the cost, they rushed into the field, and were broken like spray on the bayonets of the silent and resolute Ot tomans. The crisis is pitiful and it is not over. The prosecution of the Frankfort Zeitung for lese-mejeste in criticising the course of Emperor William is one of the most daring steps yet taken in the cam- paign for the suppression of free speech in Germany. It may be Bismarck’s turn next, or that of his personal organ, the Hamburg Nachrichten; they have cer tainly made some dangerous suggestions lately that the Emperor was not abso- lutely all-wise and infallible. But it is gratifying to observe that the German people are not going to lie down tied hand and foot and gagged under the boot-heels of their swashbuckling Kai- ser. The sharper the policy of repres- sion, the more ominous the rumblings in all parts of the empire. All observ- ers agree that political unrest in Ger- many is reaching a dangerous pitch. Prof. Rheinhold cf the University ot Ber lin lately said with truth: “Things have come to such a pass that almost every body in Germany belongs to the Opposi- tion.’ All this is, of course, water for the mill of the Social Democrats. But the Liberals, too, are beginning to bestir themselves. They lately held a meeting at Nuremberz, where the liberalism of the North, led by Richter, struck hands with the discontented and almost revolt- remberg for the place of gathering was significant, as was explained by one of the speakers, Herr Schmidt, a member of the Reichstag. He said Nuremberg showed, some centuries ago, how vengeance is taken upon robber barons In that good fight it was not the peasant but the lord who was crushed to powder In the city hall, where lately banqueted a company of princes, one reads the inscrip- tion: ‘Suprema lex salus populi.” Let us adopt this motto, for the council of Nurem- berg. which caused it to be placed there, was itself also an authority by divine right!’ ; : aA PDE PLACE TS San lin noapimnleiiie So a et a
Page 8
272 The Nation. [Vol. 65, No. 1684 ANNEXATION, HAWAIIAN STYLE We have received the full press report of the proceedings of the Hawaiian Se- nate on September § and 9 in ratifying the treaty of annexation. An impartial summary of the reports, speeches, and acts should be of interest to Americans, whose pert in annexing remains to be played. It will at least help to dispel some illusions. The Hawaiian Senate was summoned in extra session on September 8, for the sole and express purpose of ratifying the treaty. On September 6 a mass-meet- ing of anti-annexationists was held in Honolulu, and adopted resolutions, of which the more important were the fol- lowing: “Whereas, The native Hawaiians and a large majority of the people of the Hawai- ian Islands have been in direct opposition to the annexation of Hawaii to the United States of America; and, ‘‘Whereas, The native Hawaiians and a large majority of the people of these islands have fully believed in the independence and free autonomy of these islands and in the continuation of the government of Hawaii as of a free and independent country gov- erned by and under its own laws; therefore, be it “Resolved, We, who in mass-meeting as- sembled on the 6th day of September, A. D. 1897, at the city of Honolulu aforesaid, for ourselves, and for and on behalf of the peo- ple of Hawaii, as well as for the large ma- jority of the people of the Hawaiian Islands, earnestly protest against the annexation of Hawaii to the United States of America in any form or shape.” The next day, September 7, a com- mittee of fifteen, mostly natives, waited upon the President and cabinet to lay this protest before him. President Dole said he was sorry the resolutions had not been brought to him “several days ago,” for then he “might have had more time to think about it.”” As it was, there was the Senate called to meet the next day, and the “time for con- sideration was very short.” The Gov- ernment was there “to look after the rights of the people,” and it was certain- ly “right for the people to express their views.” Then he shook hands cordially with the committee, and, after the At- torney-General had said how glad he was, too, to “have the people express their views,” that part of annexation was safely and satisfactorily over. The natives, nevertheless, lodged their protest with the Senate committee on foreign relations. But that body pointed out in a special report that the protest was evidently intended to prevent the President and cabinet from giving their approval to the treaty. The President and cabinet had, however, already ap- proved the treaty, so that the protest was evidently not in order. Besides, the committee were “firmly and sincerely of the opinion that, in refusing to ratify the treaty, we would not be acting for the benefit more especially of the native Hawaiians.” It was clear, therefore, that the natives were protesting “on the grounds of sentiment,” ,and the only thing to do with their protest was to lay it on the table, which was done by unanimous vote. Then came up the main report of the committee advocating ratification. This was argued for on the explicit ground that ‘‘the experiences of recent years have shown that, under the changed conditions which have resulted from cir- cumstances beyond human control, good government cannot be permanently maintained in these islands without aid or assistance from without.” Further- more, the committee was convinced that from “the benefits received’”’ and ‘to be received,’ the United States was the government to which ‘‘we must turn for assistance of every kind.” It had been through the “agency of Anglo-Saxon civilization” that “progressive institu- tions’ had been established in Hawaii, and it was “for the benefit of all’’ that these institutions should be maintained. In the debate on the report, Senator Brown said that he had long’ been against annexation, but latterly had “grown satisfied that the salvation of the country and the people was to be obtained through annexation.” More- over, in addition to salvation, “pros- perity” was to be obtained, and there- fore he was prepared to vote for ratifi- cation “with pleasure.” Senator Mc- Candless followed, asserting that annex- ation was a “vital necessity,” and that the Hawaiians opposed it “through mere sentiment,’ most strangely not giving a thought ‘“‘to the prosperity which will be theirs.”” Senator Schmidt also said he favored the treaty, and then the debate was about to close; further remarks might have excited the fear in Speaker Reed’s bosom that the Hawaiian Senate is a deliberative assembly. But an un- timely interruption came from Minister Damon of the Finance Department. He rose and said: “T understand that the adoption of the report of the committee carries with it all the views expressed therein, and these views naturally will be made public through the press of the United States. As a Hawaiian, one who has been identified with the gov- ernment since its inception, I cannot agree with the committee in saying that good government cannot be maintained in the Hawaiian Islands unless we have support from without. In that expression we are tacitly admitting that we are unfit to be- come a part of the great republic across the sea. In view of the events of the past four years, in view of the support given the Gov- ernment by men of all classes at the time when its safety was threatened, and in view of the fact that the Government of Hawaii has grown steadily stronger since its forma- tion, and in view of the reports that have been sent abroad as to the strength of our position, I say that in the adoption of that clause of the report we would be stultifying ourselves. I believe it unwise to endorse that part of the report. It is one of the statements so often made in the opposition press, and the one which our friends have so strenuously denied in our behalf.’’ In a similar vein spoke the Attorney- General and the Minister of Foreign Affairs. But they were roughly put down by the impatient Senators. Senator Baldwin said: “Things have been get- ting worse here on the islands for the past few years, and that is what has made me an annexationist.” Senator Brown remarked: “The Minister of Fi- nance is wrong; no form of government. monarchical or republican, can thrive under that flag [the Hawaiian], and for that reason, I say, we want the United States to take us.” There being “no other remarks,” the motion to ratify was put and carried unanimously. The situation was described the next day by the Hawaiian Gazette, the faith- ful organ of the missionaries and of an- nexation, in language which we com- mend to the attention of our ardent an- nexationists. Of “the native,” the (a- cette says that he “looks with simple, . childlike thought, dazed and perhaps wondering at it [annexation], as if it were a strange, mysterious act.” The part-Hawaiians, ‘innocent victims of the contact, almost criminal, of the stronger and weaker races,” naturally “take a wider vision.” They hear “the rough voices of the aggressive race coming over the sea’; this makes them “pa- thetic.”” The Chinese look upon annex- ation as bringing them “further humilia- tions.” The Japanese see in it something which will “cripple their commerce, and prevent their freedom of travel and resi- dence.” “The intelligent Portuguese” think annexation will give them “a large share in the local government.” The “few remaining missionaries see in it the wheels of the juggernaut of modern progress passing over the little autono- my which they labored to create and preserve.” The only thoroughly satisfied element of the population is, ’ according to the Gazette, ‘the recent An- glo-Saxon”’; and he is satisfied because he sees in annexation “a firmer footing for the god of the world, gold,” and be- cause he beholds “a writing over every mountain and valley side, ‘Good Busi- ness Chances Here.’ ”’ The only comment we have to make at present on this story of annexation, Hawaiian style, is that this “republic” which now offers itself to the United States, “unfit” and “stultified’’ in the language of its own Minister of Finance, is, on the face of it, a sham republic, a confessed fraud and failure. Less than 3,000 of the “recent Anglo-Saxon” are pretending to have a right, and are brutally exercising it, to dispose of the lives and fortunes of 25,000 Japanese, 24,000 Chinese, 15,000 Portuguese, 40,000 Hawaiians. And they are doing it un- der the proud device, “Good Business Chances Here”! MR. NORTH ON THE TARIFF. A very remarkable explanation and defence of the Dingley tariff law is that which is published by Mr. S. N. D. North, Secretary of the Wool Manufac- turers’ Association. Mr. North served as Secretary of the Senate committee on finance during the preparation of the Senate bill in the last session of Con- gress, so that his views and utterances we ersbweiaiasiNspaat eS est dati Baie s: Bae SE ee Meteor AERP
Page 9
SARA MATTED RENNES UR mje. Dele tac ALGAAS pa abe! Petia ccs i BEARER, ae AER EE a Oct. 7, 1897] oo — — may be regarded as semi-official and as expressing the general sense of the com- mittee. Further, as a good and even extreme protectionist, Mr. North may be looked to for a defence of the protec- tive features of the new tariff law, a task for which his experience with the committee eminently fitted him. We cannot do better than to summarize his article, generally using his own words. The feature of the Dingley tariff which chietly distinguishes it from prior tariffs is its “especial care” for the crude pro- ducts. Hence the duties on foods, fibres, minerals, crude substances of any and every sort. The farmer has received a good share of the good things. ‘There was nothing asked in behalf of the farmer, in the way of increased rates, which was not given to him.” And after reading Mr. North’s article we con- clude that nothing in the form of pro- tection asked by the manufacturers was denied. Everywhere the demands met with favor, and duties of prohibition were granted in many cases. ‘The silk schedule is particularly severe in its ap- plication to the very light fabrics of Japanese origin which have recently so troubled our domestic manufacturers. They will have no trouble from them hereafter.” In the cotton schedule there was a contest over the duties on yarns, the manufacturers of finer fabrics claiming that they could not obtain the necessary yarns in this country. They wished mo- derate duties on the higher counts; but “the spinners insisted that they can and will make all numbers required; and they finally had their way about it.’”” So in the textile fibre schedule a like dif- ference of opinion arose. The manufac- turers of linens, who are in a position to know, declare that there can be found in this country no flax suitable for spin- ning the yarns required for the linen- thread industry. On the other hand, individuals and associations in great numbers “renewed their promises of 1890 that they can and will, under ade- quate protection, raise as fine a fibre as comes from any part of the world.” The higher duties on the raw fibres would have led to increased rates on manufactured linens; but a further in- crease was made on the plea that the “extraordinary increase of cotton mills in the South has resulted in a produc- tion of cotton cloth that exceeds the con- suming powers of the people’; and, to | save themselves, a few New England mills were experimenting upon linens. Hence the duties on fine linen yarns | were lowered and those on linen cloths | were raised—a different policy from that pursued in cotton yarns. Mr. North doubts whether adequate results will follow. Linen mills will not be built, but cotton looms will be superseded by linen looms. But “it is a well-known fact that even in the countries where the linen manufacture has flourished for The Nation. centuries, it shows a steady tendency to decline. Linen feels the stress of the closer and closer competition of cotton, just as the wool manufacturer feels it.” As to burlaps, Mr. North makes a curious admission. “If Dundee can make burlaps in competition with Cal- cutta, and without any duty, the United States can make them in competition with both, under a protection sufficient to cover the difference in labor-cost.” Mr. North might explain why his doc- trine of labor-cost works only in regard to the United States, and not in the com- petition of Dundee with Calcutta. The duties on ramie fabrics are “a recogni- tion of the birth of a new textile indus- try’’--somewhat prematurely, it may be thought. Naturally, it is with the woollen sche- dule that Mr. North is most explicit. The manufacturers, he states, asked less, and have received less, protection from Congress in comparison with the other industries. They were in favor of free wool, and had derived great and peculiar advantages from the repeal of the wool duties by the law of 1894; but they were overborne by the demands of wool- growing States. In fact, the extravagant expectations of this wool-growing inte- rest to exact prohibitory duties on for- eign wools were defeated only by the belief that such duties wouid ‘“ship- wreck” the cause of protection. As it is, the wool-growers have secured higher all-round rates than had been given them by either house, acting separately. With a tinge of sarcasm, Mr. North adds: “It is due to their special repre- sentatives in both houses of Congress to say that the interests of the wool-grow- ers were cared for with consummate ability from first to last.” As to the rates on raw wools, they are “relatively higher than those of the Mc- Kinley law at the time of its passage, and higher, in their ad-valorem equiva- lents, than under any previous tariff in our history.”’ The carpet-manufacturers especially have made a fortunate escape, as their interests at one time were se- riously threatened through the unrea- sonable demands of the wool-growers. Can it be that the eminent leader of the wool-growers, Judge Lawrence, is in- tended when Mr. North speaks of the “constant presence in Washington of professional mischief-makers, seeking to curry favor with wool-growers for busi- ness purposes, who devoted their time to the dissemination of misleading and false information on this subject’’? Nor was it by rates of duty only that the manufacturers claim to have suf- fered. Since 1867 the classification of wools has been by “blood” and not by use. Now the symmetry of that classi- fication has been destroyed, and some wools, without a trace of merino blood. have been transferred from the carpet to the clothing class. This was done to appease the claims of the growers that i ' i 273 carpet-wools were used in higher manu- factures, to the exclusion of the better and more expensive grades. The duties on waste, shoddy, rags, and flocks “were all fixed in the interests of the wool-growers, and the mannfacturers had nothing whatever to say about them.” Yet these many changes have produced a scheme of duties satisfactory neither to wool-growers nor to manufac. turers. The latter are disposed to make the best of the situation, and look for- ward hopefully to the future. It is not stated whether carpet-wools will be raised in this country under the new rates—a point of some importance. In the past they have not, and it is hardly possible the sheep will change their coats to conform to tariff rates It would be interesting to follow Mr North in his detailed study of the wool- len schedule, but too much space would be required to make the matter intelli- gible. This may be said, that in few cases have the consumer's interests been considered, and in nearly every item the highest attainable rate of duty has bean imposed. If the wool-grower seems in- satiate, the wool-manufacturer has been amply compensated for the new wool duties, and does not appear in any more moderate light than the grower It is with complacency that Mr. North views the results, and expresses his belief that “it will be found in practical operation to be the mast perfect woollen schedule which has ever been enacted.” When to high rates of duty is added a pro- vision authorizing appraisers to take the market value of the goods in the United States as a basis of value—the home as distinguished from the foreign value it does seem as if the manufacturer had reason to be satisfied. It is another example of the ingrati- tude of republics that, after this defence of the wool schedule of the Dingley ta- riff. Judge Lawrence, the First Consul of the Ohio wool-growers, publishes a let- ter protesting against the appointqent of Mr. North as superintendent of the census, and saying, too, that “President McKinley cannot afford to make an ap- pointment so objectionable to wool- growers.” This means that,if he does appoint Mr. North, the wool-growers will Knife him on the first opportunity. THE IOWA CAMPATGN. lf a modern Diogenes were seeking a man among the Republican leaders the present year, he would have a trouble- ; some search, but his diligence would not be wholly in vain. One such would be found in the person of Mr. Leslie M. Shaw, Republican candidate for Gov- | ernor of Iowa. This gentleman has de- |clared himself for the gold standard | without any ifs or buts. Not only so, but he has made the most effective speech for the gold standard that has been made this year in this or any other ne eA OR ETS AEST 4 YON eee oe 2 at pencemnd
Page 10
Q74 country. We can recall nothing in the literature of the subject more convinc- ing than his speech at Red Oak on Sa- turday week. In the discussions of the money question which have been so profuse and diffuse during the past quar- ter of a century, there has been an in- tense craving for simplicity and clear- ness of exposition, and the most success- ful writers, speakers, and pamphleteers have been those who have succeeded best in bringing these subjects to the comprehension of untrained minds. In this endeavor Mr. Shaw has succeeded so well that we must conclude not only that he has a perfect understanding of the rather abstruse subject in hand, but that his reasoning powers in general are of a high order. We shall give our read- ers a few examples of Mr. Shaw's quali- ty. That one of the hardest things to de- fine is a standard of value we have seen by many ineffectual attempts to define it. Perhaps the most dismal of all was that of the Supreme Court of the United States in the legal-tender cases, where we were told by the mouth of Mr. Justice Strong that there is no such thing as a standard of value, but that ‘‘value is an ideal thing.”” Mr. Shaw thinks different- ly, and he puts his opinion in the con- densed paragraph which follows: “What is meant by a money standard? As we have seen, each standard coin is worth the material of which it is composed. By gold standard is simply meant that the value of our dollar is determined in a de- finite amount of gold, and not in a certain amount of silver, or copper, or brass, or iron, or lead. There is no reason why a United States dollar has its present pur- chasing power except the fact that the standard dollar contains a fixed amount of gold. Had the framers of our monetary sys- tem seen fit to put 12.9 grains of standard gold in a dollar, the purchasing price would be one-half of what it is now. The word dollar divorced from its associations means nothing. We come to know its value when we associate it with its purchasing power, and its purchasing power is determined by the value of the material of which the stan- dard dollar is composed.” Mr. Shaw had previously referred to tHe silver dollars and shown how they were kept at par by the limitation of their quantity and by the action of the Treasury, paying a high compliment to the ex-Secretary, Mr. Carlisle, for his public declaration that he would redeem the silver dollar in gold if it should be necessary in order to prevent its depre- ciation. In connection with this, Mr. Shaw came perilously near to the line of Mugwumpery, saying that he had no sympathy with that school of politics which denounces everything that the op- position does, whether good or bad, and | supports everything that its own party does, whatever its evil effect. The assertion often made in our po- | litical campaigns, that there is not gold enough to do the world’s business, finds an equally brief, complete, and convinc- ing answer in Mr. Shaw’s speech,. to wit: “How much gold is needed to do our busi- ness’? Just enough for convenience in mea- The Nation. suring and determining the value of our cur- rency; enough for redemption purposes and enough to accommodate those who desire to hoard it. How many fifty-pound standard weights, such as is used on the large class of scales for weighing stock and produce, is it necessary to have? They are used to balance the scales and to keep the pound and ton from fluctuating. Just enough of these weights are essential to accommodate the business. Your cattle will weigh no more if the weighmaster have two or a dozen of these standard weights than if he has one. It is essential that he have one, and that this one is of the same weight as those in the market where you bought your cattle. If this weight fluctuates you will not be safe in buying cattle in one town and selling them in another.’’ Equally clear and cogent was Mr. Shaw’s refutation of the oft-repeated charge that the banks have an interest in making money scarce in order to op- press debtors and obtain high rates of interest. He showed that exactly the opposite condition was essential to the prosperity of a bank, because plenty of money implies large deposits. If its pro- fits depended on its own capital, it could make more money for itself by not be- ing a bank. A bank is obliged to keep 25 per cent. of its capital unused in its own vaults, whereas an ordinary money- lender can make all of his capital earn interest all the time. In order to be on as good a footing as a private money- lender a bank must have deposits—the more the better. But deposits always shrink when money is scarce. The shrinking of the deposits is the very thing that makes a tight money market. Therefore, the banks have no motive to make money scarce, even if they could do so. In his broad view of the philosophy of life Mr. Shaw is equally strong and sin- cere. Compare, for instance, the follow- ing paragraph with the blatherings of Bryan, Watson, and Coxey: ‘All that any party, or any standard, or any legislation can do is to see to it that every man has an open field and a fair fight. It cannot exempt him from the fight. Fight he must, and the best that the Government can do is to see to it that no one strikes below the belt. From the beginning of time to the present and to the end of time those who earn and save will have, and those who refuse to earn or fail to save will come in empty. We look at our child in the cradle, or our boy coming to manhood, and tremble at the consciousness that he must go into this relentless conflict, where every man is selfish, and win or lose, on his own merits. To the utmost of its ability let the Government protect him and see that he has fair play. While we do all this, we must demand that he enter the ring, put on the gloves, and stand up like a man.” In such wholesome ideas as these, when they find expression in the mouths of candidates for high office, rests the se- curity for free institutions. We wel- come Mr. Shaw’s speech as a sign of courage in a State where that quality is much needed. BLACKSTONF.—I. To the ordinary reader old books are un- known books, and he may, if he choose, find in them the charm of novelty. It is at any rate worth while occasionally to take up some work which has instructed or charmed [Vol. 65, No. 1684 our forefathers, and, reading it in the free- and-easy spirit which we apply to the pub- lications of to-day, try to estimate its real worth. Of few books does this remark hold more true than of ‘Blackstone’s Commen- taries.’ They are known by name to every one; they have supplied to successive gene- rations the current truisms or platitudes on the subject of the English Constitution; portions of the ‘Commentaries’ are read by every student of English law, and ‘Black- stone’s Commentaries’ constitute the one law-book which has become a part of the literature of the English people. Yet it is common knowledge that the Commentator does not now command anything like the veneration which at one time surrounded him. It is an ordinary and in one sense a true saying that we need a new ‘Commen- taries on the Law of England’; and though you will with difficulty find a modern work on the history or the theory of English law in which Blackstone’s name is not men- tioned, his most ardent admirers must con- fess that the references to the ‘Commen- taries’ more often take the form of criticism than of eulogy, and that of recent times jurists and historians are apt to treat Black- stone mainly as the propounder of legal fal- lacies or the perverter of legal history. But the criticism or detraction of to-day is still overbalanced by the appreciation of a former generation. The admiration of Mansfield, of Burke, and of Gibbon cannot go for nothing, and none but the rashest of critics will ven- ture to disdain an author who is never mentioned otherwise than with profound re- spect by Story, and whose work, it is said, first aroused the enthusiasm for law in the mind of Kent. It is, then, no waste of time if we attempt to fix Blackstone’s true posi- tion in the English world of letters. How does it happen that Blackstone is now depreciated, not to say underrated? A partial answer to this inquiry is found in the statement, which is true though para- doxical, that the real Blackstone is rarely real even by professional lawyers. The practical utility of his work, and the reputa- tion which it at once achieved, have detract- ed from Blackstone’s permanent fame. The original book, which derives half its charm from its literary perfection, has of necessity become obsolete as a statement of existing law. Hence it has been edited and re- edited, and altered and realtered, till it has been, as a work of letters, completely spoil- ed, and the students who think themselves to be reading Blackstone are in reality read- ing a treatise about as like the original ‘Commentaries’ as would be an edition of Gibbon’s ‘Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire’ which should have been not only edited but to a great extent rewritten, first by Milman and then by Merivale, and then should have been overloaded with an in- finity of notes added by authors of very in- ferior quality. We may, indeed, say that, mm England at any rate, Blackstone’s ‘Com- mentaries’ have been transformed into Ste- phen’s ‘Commentaries,’ and that this trans- formation has been a public calamity; it has spoiled the work of two men of equal but of very dissimilar genius. Serjeant Stepher did not possess the literary gifts of Black- stone, the Commentator was deficient in the lucid precision and the logical acumen of his editor. The literary beauty of the ‘Commen- taries’ vanished under the attempt to import into them a precise statement of the whole law of England which Blackstone never in- ata ere Se ener a Ratt Oe } ia j =f x i IE ETS I aa P Nite iP MBE DE
Page 11
i ' ? ote Het et Beate
ae
PWS bin Saab leatasenia bps shiihedaas Boss Shivion ee Dit a aE Oct. 7, 1897]
tended to provide for the students to whom he addressed his lectures, while the time and power spent by Serjeant Stephen on the rewriting of the celebrated ‘Commentaries’ might, if more happily employed, have sup- plied us with such a logical analysis of the law of England as could bave been produced by the author of the celebrated ‘Treatise on Pleading,’ and could, in his day at least, have been produced by no one else. The first step to be taken by any one who wishes to appreciate Blackstone’s genius is to read the ‘Commentaries’ as Blackstone wrote them, and, if possible, to read them unencumbered even by the notes of subsequent editors. But even when the ‘Commentaries’ are studied in their original shape, it will soon become apparent to a candid reader that Blackstone’s fame has suffered from his own defects or peculiarities. He is not an original thinker; his constitutional dogmas, for example, are taken from Locke and Montesquieu, and are not improved in the borrowing. He is not a subtle logician. His knowledge of Roman Law, to which he not infrequently refers, is superficial and not particularly accurate. He is a well-informed and competent English lawyer, but he does not rank among the writers, such as Coke, who may be cited as ‘authorities’; he is said not to have raised his reputation by his decisions as a judge, and since his time there have lived many lawyers and judges who have surpassed him both in legal learn- ing and in logical acumen. His style, which excited the admiration of his contemporaries, and which would have been commended by Johnson, does not happen to suit the taste of to-day, though it must be left an open question whether it be Blackstone’s style or modern taste which is at fault. His gene- ral way, moreover, of looking at the world. his dignified and complacent optimism, is strangely opposed to the sentiment ro less of modern democrats than of modern con- servatives. We are divided from Blackstone by the gulf of the French Revolution; and whoever wishes to measure the width and nature of this division cannot better attain his object than by investigating the differ- ence between the tone of Blackstone and the tone of every modern writer on politics or sociology. The main cause, however, of the compara- tive discredit into which the ‘Commentaries’ have fallen is that Blackstone, from his very celebrity no less than from some of his defects, became the object of attack to two different and opposed schools of think- ers. To the Benthamites, Blackstone was from the first an object of detestation. Bentham, | indeed, heard the lectures which formed the | bases of the ‘Commentaries,’ but he must soon have detected that he was opposed to his teacher both in his methods and in his aims. The celebrated ‘Fragment on Gov- ernment’ is the boldest and most trenchant critique ever published by a young man on the doctrines propounded by a writer of the highest reputation, which were accepted as profound truths by the educated world of the day; and though the ‘Fragment on Government’ is itself open to criticism. it contains one of those attacks which were completely successful. It is easy enough to see that Bentham is by no means a critic, and that a logician might perhaps devise a defence for some of Blackstone's positions; but it is impossible to read the ‘Fragment’ without arriving at two conclu fair
The Nation. sions: first, that Blackstone is a lax, not to say an inaccurate, thinker, and next that in Bentham he has met with a controversialist of tenfold his own power. Few are the men who would not have come off second-best in a controversy with Jeremy Bentham when in the full vigor of his youth, but assuredly no writer of real talent was likely to suffer a more complete defeat than did Blackstone at the hands of such an anta- gonist. It was not, however, the logical weakness of Blackstone’s positions which impelled Bentham to assault them. What aroused his indignation was the Commentator’s peculiar form of optimism. Bentham was a born re- former. Utilitarianism was to him a living and inspiring faith. From youth to old age he labored at the removal of actual and palpable abuses. He was much more than a mere denouncer of wrong; he was a pa- tentee of devices for the improvement of society. But before his reforms could be adopted it was necessary to convince the world of the need for reformation. Now Blackstone, though a man of benevolence, was by nature and conviction an apologist for and admirer of things as they were. With complete sincerity he held that the British Constitution was not only by far the best of existing polities, but also as nearly perfect as could be any commonwealth. His work is from beginning to end either a eulogy or an apology. He grants that the Constitution or the law may have slight flaws, but they are flaws which, in the eyes of an adorer, either approach to or are the price of beauties. He mitigates even the defects which his judgment disap- proves. He has something to say in favor of the scheme which excludes brothers of half blood from inheriting from one another He dislikes the peine forte et dure, but he contrives to make it necessary appear an abuse of little consequence down his wife is, it is hinted by Blackstone & man who has an fondness for the Common and a jealous suspicion of the Civil Law. Here grim pleasantry and the ‘Commentaries’ always over a bottle of port. But, however this may be, their author sttod right in Bentham’s path. “Blackstonism,” if one may coin the word, was the sworn foe of ‘“‘Benthamism,”’ and the whole tribe of Benthamites strove not in vain, to discredit a writer who em- bodied all the prejudices which delayed the triumph of the Utilitarian creed. Utilitarianism has be it added, was both a necessary and a no ble work-—-and Benthamism has ceased to be a living force. for the time at least, been destroyed by enthusiasts for the historical method. But the decline in the authority of Benthamism has not re the fame of Blackstone, the his- torical school of thinkers have looked unfa- Blackstone. They have done very to the skill with he has blended the history of law with the exposition of legal doctrines, and they have extreme severity historical mis- conceptions which were rather the common mistakes of Blackstone's generation than his of course, excessive we a vein of that written may suspect recall the legend were done its work—which Its influence has vived for vorably upon scanty justice which noted with own peculiar errors. It cannot, be disputed that. if tested by a high stan- } often found deficient in his- He is deeply onnection between lary rical knowledge or insight close English institutions and feudalism; but
The ruffian who knocks | 275 feudalism is to him a mere name for bar barism, just as Romanism and the authority of the Pope are in his eyes nothing but names for superstition and priestly arro gance. His historical views or conjectures are often at fault. He knows that the landholders of England swore allegiance to William at his great court at Salisbury be misunderstands the whole effect of the ceremony, and uses language which suggests that the Conqueror introduced the feudal system into England at the very moment when William prevented the full develop ment in England of the feudal system Blackstone, again, has studied with care the history of copyholds, but the Black stonian theory of the origin of the maaor but has been pronounced by later untenable; and all that in its defence is, that the which have been propounded in more recent times are also open to grave objections. He is convinced that the English Constitution existed in his own the re of “‘a gradual restoration of that an investigators to be can be said rival theories as it time, is sult cient constitution, whereof our Saxon fore fathers had by the policy, the Norman.” must be partl) ferce, of been unjustly deprived and partly by the No view of English progres« admitted, be eould, it more op posed to the facts of history; but before we condemn Blackstone too severely, we ought to remember that this faith in what has been termed retrogressive progress ha belief by on: his of Montesquieu been cherished as a pious of the most distinguished of English tcrians. Under the influence he is too apt to look upon the English Con as a fabric designed and built uy stitution by the wisdom of our ancestors. It is here Blackstone's true son of the eighteenth century. H we touch upon weakness. He is a the sentiments or judges the past by prin ciples of his own day, and exhibits an un historical attitude of mind. Hence he in no way anticipates the reaction in favor of me diwval institutions and mediwval modes of thought. He therefore never alludes to the Middle Ages without using language which grates upon the feelings of writers imbued sentimental mediwvalism of th nineteenth century. They are far lees of fended by Blackstone's definite historical er ors, many of which are, after all, than by his general tone of mind in other words with the vers venial, He was an old Whig, or, of the a strong Conservative time of George the Third. He because he did not share the enthusiasm for which the religion of the eighteenth century. He hardly obtain toleration from the modern devotees of the imbued was detestable to Bentham reform was can was historical method because he with the principles and the prejudices of the eighteenth and not of the nineteenth cen- tury. Whoever will weigh carefully the words in which Blackstone concludes hi Commentaries,’ will understand why it ts full reformers of that he has never received justice at the hands of time or of the historians of to-day his own the Of a constitution,” he writes, ‘“‘so wisely contrived, so strongly raised, and so high lv finished, it is hard to speak with that praise which is justly and severely its due the thorough and attentive contemplation of it will furnish its best panegyric. It hath been the endeavour of these commentaries however the execution may have succeeded, to examine its solid foundations, to mark out its extensive plan, to explain the use distribution of its parts, and, from the coneurrence of those several harmonious an Ethanatesie tare RRR CaRHn< Mah Cen eibaaedaes ante
Page 12
— The Nation. [Vol. 65, No. 1684 parts, to demonstrate the elegant propor- tion of the whole. We have taken occasion to admire at every turn the noble monu- ments of ancient simplicity, and the more curious refinements of modern art. Nor have its faults been concealed from view— for faults it has—lest we should be tempted to think it of more than human structure; defects, chiefly arising from the decays of time, or the rage of unskilful improvements in later ages. To sustain, to repair, to beautify this noble pile, is a charge entrust- ed principally to the nobility, and such gen- tlemen of the kingdom as are delegated by their country to Parliament. The pro- tection of THE LIBERTY OF BRITAIN is a duty which they owe to themselves, who enjoy it; to their ancestors, who transmitted it down; and to their posterity, who will claim at their hands this, the best birthright and noblest inheritance of mankind.” YELLOWSTONE PARK IN 1897. September, 1897. Capt. Anderson, who was Superintendent of the Yellowstone Park from 1891 to 1896, pointed out in his last report to the Secre- tary of the Interior that the total number of persons who visited the Park in 1895 was only 2,588. He attributed this to financial depression, the tendency of Americans to spend their summers in Europe, their gene- ral ignorance as to the wonders of their own country, and also, in part, to the long rail- road journeys necessary to reach them. The present Superintendent, Col. Young, will be able to note a great improvement in the tourist business for 1897. About 9,000 sight- seers were taken through the Park this sea- son. Many of these, it is true, were Chris- tian Endeavorers, and others who availed themselves of the cheap rates offered all travellers to the Pacific Coast and back in July and August. There were so many of these that at one time the agents had to stop selling Park tickets for ten days be- cause the stages and hotels had all they could possibly attend to. Yet the officials believe that this Pacific Coast excursion does not account for all the increase, and that the travel through the Park will continue to be much larger than heretofore. Having spent the last three weeks in the Park, long after all the Christian Endeavorers and others had passed through it, I have come to the same conclusion. Favored by fine weather, the travel remained large to the last days, many of the belated tourists be- ing eminent Englishmen—among them Lord Lister and Lord Kelvin (Sir William Thom- son)—from the meeting of the British Asso- ciation at Toronto; and to judge by their comments, they will help to popularize our wonderland abroad. No one desires to make a Coney Island of the Yellowstone Park, yet there is no reason why it should not be seen by 50,000 or even 100,000 tourists every summer. Capt. Anderson overlooked the main reason why the Park travel has increased so slowly; namely, the disposition of the transporta- tion and hotel companies to arrange mat- ters to suit themselves instead of to suit the tourists. The situation has been, and is to this day, positively amazing, not to say outrageous. When an educated person hears the name Yellowstone, what image arises in his mind? The picture of a geyser, in every case. True, the Park is famed also for its beautifully colored Grand Cafion, its picturesque lake at an altitude of 7,741 feet, its extensive forests, high mountains, and numerous trout-brooks; but there are trout-brooks as good, forests’ much finer, mountains much grander, lakes quite as pic- turesque, elsewhere, while the Yellowstone Cafion, though unique in its coloring, has only one-third the depth of the Grand Cafion of the Colorado in Arizona, and is corre- spondingly inferior in sublimity. But in its geysers the Park has afi attraction in which only two countries in the whole world—Ice- land and New Zealand—compete with it, without equalling it. It is to see these gey- sers in particular that ninety-nine out of a hundred tourists visit the Park; yet, by the present arrangement, they are exceptionally lucky if they catch a glimpse of the finest of them, and many go home in consequence disappointed of their main object. Let me explain how the matter is managed at pre- sent. In the Upper Basin there are about thirty superb geysers, all differing from each other in appearance and the manner of their erup- tion. It is to see these geysers that the tour- ists—supposing they live at the East—have come twothousand miles, have expended hun- dreds of dollars since leaving home, and have undertaken a five days’ dusty stage ride. And having got there, what arrangements do they find for seeing them? A large hotel, with com- fortable rooms, overlooking the whole Basin so that they can watch for an eruption and hasten down to see it close by—a_ hotel where they can spend a day or two, or a week, so as to make sure of enjoying the wonderful phenomena they have come so far to see? That is what every uninformed person would erpect to find there. But what is there in reality? A small wooden shanty in which a poor lunch is served, while as for rooms, not one is to be had for love or money. But where do the tourists stay while they remain to admire the geysers? Stay? Foolish question! They do not stay at all. The stage gives them four or five hours, during which a hurried guide takes them hurriedly across the Basin, and if some of the geysers happen to play while they are being ‘‘done,’”’ the tourists are lucky. And after this short visit, part of which is given up to the aforesaid lunch, the tourists are hurried—on, of course? Oh no! Back ten miles to the Fountain Hotel, and next morn- ing they have to get up at six and for the third time traverse those ten miles between the Lower and Upper Basins! And all this time the geysers they came so far to see may be playing merrily, unseen. To be perfectly fair, it must be said that the transportation company is not to blame for this state of affairs. Indeed, it would be only too glad to dispense with two of the three trips between the two Basins. The hotel company is the culprit. A number of years ago it had a building at the Upper Basin, which was burnt down as soon as com- pleted and has not been rebuilt. Why? Heaven only knows. The managers say their business has not been sufficiently profitable to allow the rebuilding of that hotel. But why were funds available for the fine build- ings at the Lake and the Fountain—the Fountain, in particular, which, if things were properly arranged, would be a mere lunch station? Why not tear down the Foun- tain Hotel and rebuild it at the Upper Basin? Something must be done soon. Congress ought to compel the company to build that hotel. It would be the company’s gain as well as the tourists’. At present many of the latter are disappointed, declare that the geysers (which they have not seen) are a fraud and a delusion, and on returning ad- vise their friends to avoid the Park. I heard not a few comments of that sort during the three days I spent at the Upper Basin. Until the hotel company desists from its penny-wise policy, the public should patron- ize the opposition company. I did not know until I arrived at Livingston that there has - been, for two years, a new way of traversing the Park, by the same route, but upon an entirely different and much more rational plan. Mr. Wylie of Bozeman has secured permission to erect permanent camps at various places in the Park, and to take tour- ists through on his own wagons. He has large tents, divided into compartments and equipped with stoves for cold nights. The food is plain but good, in the ‘‘home-made” style. Mr. Wylie charges $5 a day for trans- portation, lodging, and meals, and instead of rushing tourists through, as the stages do, in five days and a half, he gives seven days to the trip, allowing two nights at the Upper Basin and two at the Grand Cafion. Tourists who prefer the comforts of a hotel may still make use of Wylie’s camp at the Upper Basin, where they may stay as long as they please, taking their chances of be- ing carried on to the next station by the other company, though these chances are not as good as they might be. The provoking capriciousness of the gey- sers may be inferred from the fact that the Grand, as the corporal on guard informed me, had not played from July 2 to September 2, whereas in the week we were there it played four or five times. It seems, unfortu- nately, that the biggest ones (always except- ing Old Faithful) are becoming more and more capricious and indolent. The prevalent theory is that they have been injured by being secretly ‘‘soaped’’—that is, by having soap thrown into the cones to bring on an eruption. This soaping is strictly forbidden, and rightly so, as it cannot be well to have any substance thrown into a geyser. I have, however, noticed a curious circumstance, which seems to have escaped the attention of the experts, as a more plausible explanation of the apparent misbehavior of the big gey- sers. Right by the side of the Bee Hive there is a new geyser, only a few years old. It is called the Cascade, because its waters overflow directly into the river, forming a cascade in their descent over the bank. It is a pretty sight, but it does not atone for the quiescent Bee Hive from which, I believe, it takes away its ammunition—its steam and water—by its eruptions, which occur every twenty minutes. In the same way, the Splendid has ceased to play since the forma- tion, by its side, of the Daisy, which plays every two hours. The Giant, Grant, and others seem to be similarly drained by re- cent formations adjoining them and acting as safety-valves. Geologists use centuries as yard-sticks where we use years, and they discountenance the idea that the Yellowstone geysers will cease to gush in the not very distant future. Mr. Arnold Hague could find no diminution in the intensity of their action since they have been subject to care- ful observation. I have myself, however, noted some changes at Mammoth Hot Springs and the Upper Basin in the interval of ten years since last I was there; and in an apparently sober description of that basin written in 1842 (‘Life in the Rocky Moun- tains’) occur expressions like ‘“‘loud explo- sions and sulphurous vapors,’”’ ‘‘tremendous noises,” “hollow, unearthly rumbling under the rock on which I stood,’’ which indicate cee line aaa aie 2a ONE ere
Page 13
pein cint FARA et Oct. 7, 1897] The Nation. 277 more violent action half a century ago than can now be witnessed. If the geysers are decreasing in grandeur, | there is the more reason why arrangements | should be made at once to have these won- ders as accessible as possible. A steam rail- way would be an atrocity: it would endanger the forests and frighten away the game: but an electric trolley would not be open to the same objections. The power could be secured cheaply and invisibly from the falls and rapids; it would do away with dust and discomfort, and it would enable tourists to devote one-fourth of their week in the Park to travel and three-fourths to sight- seeing, instead of three-fourths of the time to travel and only one-fourth to sight-seeing, as at present. Capt. Runcie of San Fran- cisco, who has lately made the tour of the Park with Col. Young, estimates that an electric road would cost between $1,500,000 and $2,060,000. As the expenses for annual repairs would be heavy too, owing to winter storms and snow pressure, it is not likely that our embarrassed Government could be induced to build such a road. But private | capitalists have offered to assume the risk, and I see no reason why they should not be allowed to do so. An electric car could make the whole circuit of the Park (about 150 miles) in seven or eight hours: visitors, therefore, could spend a week there, with only an hour of daily travel. It must be distinctly understood that the great sights of the Park are separated by wearisome stretches of commonplace scenery which no- ning, when the setting sun illumines the fine mountain ranges that surround it. Capt. Waters, too, gives you a chance to sail across this lake, at an elevation a thou- sand feet higher than the top of Mount Washington, from the bay called the Thumb across to the admirable Lake Hotel, stopping on the way at Dot Island, where the Captain keeps for the entertainment of his passen- gers some elk, antelope, mountain sheep, and five superb buffaloes. grand historic game preserve where Ame- rica's characteristic fauna might be saved from utter extermination. It is only within a few years, however, that a serious attempt has been made to enforce the law. For a | ' time the keepers were practically in league with the poachers, and Col. Young has come | to the conclusion that it is not enough to enforce the law, but that additional legisla- tion is imperatively needed if the game is to be effectively preserved. The present forest reserve, east and south of the Park rroper, is so only by Presidential proclama- | pro} y DJ tion, and an act of Congress is needed before the superintendent has the power to punish properly those who disobey his ordinances Nor is this enough. The Colonel is convine- ed that the southern boundary of the Park should be extended down to Jackson's Lake | and the Three Tetons. That region is a fa- body would ever visit for their own sake— | chiefly dense forests, not of large, noble healthy firs and pines, as in Oregon and California, but of puny, starved trees, thin as lead pencils, and looking as if afflicted with some skin disease; the disagreeable impression being heightened by the dense tangle of dead and fallen trunks at their roots. They are extremely useful as conser- vators of the vast river-system arising among the Park mountains, since they re- tard evaporation by several weeks: but scenically they need distance to lend en- chantment to the view. Capt. Chittenden says in his book on the Yellowstone Park that in 1892 a vote was obtained from the tourists of that season as to the desirability of having an electric road through the Park, vorite autumn resortof the Park animals, and dozens of camping parties go there in Sep- tember and slaughter them by wholesale. | It is useless to stop up a leak in a bucket ; on one side if you allow the water to es- and that ‘“‘the result was a majority of more | than five to one against it... He does not state who took the census and who those tourists were. One thing that struck me on my trip through the Park was that there seems to be a regular conspiracy against the Lake Hotel. Yet I found that hotel by far the best of all. more commodious, tasteful, and homelike than any of the others, and the meals fifty per cent. better, though the source of sup- plies is the same for all. We remained in it eight days, and daily blessed the manager, the caterer, the cook, and the very attentive waiter girls, so superior to the colored waiters at most of the other hotels. For literary work I know no place equal to it in America, except the Californian Lake Tahoe. The tourists who allow themselves to be: persuaded that it is not worth while to take in the lake make a great mistake. The stage company saves a day by taking them from the Fountain Hotel direct to the Cafion Hotel, but the tourists lose some of the finest sights in the Park. There is not in all the Americas a more picturesque lake than the Yellowstone, especially in the eve- cape on the other. The State of Wyoming would probably not object to this enlarge- ment of the Park, because it will make it a real breeding-place, the overflow of which will in future restock that State. Ten miles more or less is a mere bagatelle to a giant State like Wyoming. The Park is as big as the State of Connecticut, yet it seems but a microscopic corner of Wyoming Col. Young has been lately promoted, and, in the due course of military events, he should join his regiment It is to be sin- cerely hoped, however, that a way may be found to preserve him to the Park. He is just the man needed there. Of course he has made enemies by strictly enforcing laws that had heretofore generally been current on paper only; but such enemies are a com- pliment to him. “‘Every one.” he remarked to me one day, ‘“‘agrees that the laws are all right, buthe fancies Av ought to be an excep- tion to the rule. For instance. I allow no dogs to run loose on the Park roads, be- cause_they scare away the wild animals which visitors are eager to see. Campers have been in the habit of putting their dogs in a wagon on passing a guard-house, and letting them run as soon as out of sight. I ordered a few of these dogs to be shot, and that had a salutary effect. I allow no excep- tions whatever. Another day one of my high- est officers came to meand asked to have his borse released. It had been taken in because contrary to law, it had been turned joose to graze. I informed the officer that he could have his horse as soon as he had paid the fine, adding that I did not turn loose my horses From others | have heard similar stories about the Colonel. and they have convinced me that he is the right man in the right place j Since dogs were suppressed in the Park tourists have had ample opportunity to see deer, coyotes, squirrels, birds, and other animals along the roads and near the stations. The most interesting illustration of the rapidity with which wild animals can be tamed when firearms are banished is afforded by the scene that can be witnessed at the Fountain Hotel every evening. It is customary there at six P. M. to dump the kitchen garbage at a place a hundred yards | behind the hotel. The bears soon found it As everybody knows, the Yellowstone Park | was reserved not only as a scenic wonder- | land, but with the intention of making it a | out, and every evening from half a dozen to a dozen (once there were sixteen) now come down from the woods for their supper. There they are—black bears, a few cinnamons. oc- } casionally even a grizzly—quietly munching the bones and fruit peelings, while a dozen or two of the hotel guests look on ten yanis away. One soon gets used to the scene: some men feed the bears apples out of the hand and we ourselves adapted our habits so soon to the situation that when we met a bear in the woods afterward we paid no more at tention to him than if he had been a dog In reality these bears are harmless animals unless wantonly provoked. Col. Young has come to the conclusion that the cevotes ought to be thinned out, as they have be gun hunting deer in packs. The bears, too he thinks are getting superabundant, and he advocates catching some and distributing them to museums. He has made a begin ning by sending a dozen cubs—with some pelicans, squirrels, geese, porcupines, et to Washington Col. Young has also been obliged to forbid fishing in some parts of the Park, for the benefit of future visiters. as the sport is not as geod as it used to be Eastern readers find it dificult to believe the story that there is a place here where you can catch a trout in the lake and coek it in a hot spring without taking it off the hook or changing your position l have known Europeans who simply refuse to be lieve this tale. Yet, as a matter of sober fact, there are at least a dozen such places in the Park. Several of them are at the Upper Geyser Basin. along the Firehole River. At one of these, just above the lower foot-bridge, you can not only cook a trout, but cook him in three ways—steam him, boil him in the water, or bake him on the HENRY T. FINCK hot rocks Correspondence. JUDGE VARKER AND THE NATIONAL DEMOCRATS To THE Eprttor OF THE NATION Sir: Your criticism on the action of the county committee of the National Demo- cratic party in endorsing the nomination of Judge Parker strikes me as entirely just As 1 wrote to one of the party leaders in New York. it seems to me that a consistent voter would really feel more inclined to support a Republican who had voted for Mr. Cleveland and was not ashamed of it, than a Democrat who considered it necessary to come out and assure ‘“‘my dear Danforth” and the “sincere friends of Mr. Bryan’’ that he stood by their ticket last fall. If Judge Parker had remained silent, his cause would have been in no way compromised. Frankly, however. it was really not so much the con- sideration with me that he voted for Mr Bryan as was the apparent fact that he is
Page 14
278 The Nation. [Vol. 65, No. 1684 “chummy” with a man of such shady repu- tation as he of Madison Square Bank fame. Beyond these facts the necessity of pre- serving the autonomy of the party in this state should have had weight with the com- | mittee. The National Democratic organiza- tion of New York is entitled to no respect if it is not held to be on a much higher plane than that controlled by Messrs. Hill, Dan- forth, Murphy, Sheehan & Co. Inasmuch as the party holds its position now solely on account of the votes polled for Mr. Wheeler in 1894, when he was nominated as a protest against the candidacy of Hill, it would seem absolutely necessary to keep free from alliance with the people above named. If the National Democrats should, by fus- ing, lose their place on the ballot at the election next year, it would mean that there would remain practically no agency through | : . which independent sentiment could be ex- | S¥bjects who are held to abstinence from be glad to listen to argument from the other side.—Very truly yours, ISABEL F. HAPpGcoop. New York, October 4, 1897. [The word is some four years old in its cant application, and was originally applied to the body of voters, not quite homogeneous but mainly Catholic, who had previously been irreconcilably op- posed to the republican form of govern- ment in France, but who were at last led to abandon their opposition to it and accept it as definitive. The Pope was thought to have been influential in this “rallying” to the republic of its former enemies; and if he were to exercise the | same influence in Italy and release the | consciences of King Humbert’s Catholic pressed. The present outrageous law placed on the statute-book by Raines, requiring at least fifty signatures in every county in the State in order to make an independent nomi- nation for State officers, would prevent any action by the people, and leave us entirely at the mercy of the corrupt machines con- trolled respectively by Mr. Platt and Mr. Hill. For this reason it is to be hoped that the ‘“‘Ship’’ Democracy will keep in the mid- dle of the road and go ahead, following its own lofty ideals, and avoid combinations with politics by the injunction, “Né elettori né eletti’” (so long as the Pope is de- prived of his temporal sovereignty), there would be added to the electorate not a mass of independents, of Mug- wumps, surely, but of Catholic partisan | voters seeking to promote the cause of religion and the papacy as best they | might under the Savoy monarchy, accept- other organizations whose only aim seems to be to secure spoils.—Yours truly, EDMUND H. TITCHENER. BINGHAMTON, N,. Y,. October 4, IS7. OREGON PLANTS. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: I am obliged to your Chicago corre- spondent for his rectification of my doubt- less antiquated nomenclature of the Oregon He may be interested to yellow “bear's-food’’—the Symplocarpus Kamschaticus of Bongart .(Lysichiton of Schott, and Dracontium of others)—at least in British Columbia and plants mentioned. know that the Alaska, when bruised, has a very distinct | pungent than It far mephitic odor, though less that of our Eastern skunk-cabbage. exceeds the latter in size; I have measured | a single leaf four feet long, two feet wide, and with the leaf-stalk four inches in diame- ter.—Respectfully yours, ws 2 BD. OCTORER 2, IS?7, ‘RALLIES. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: Your critic (Nation, September 30) ed as legitimate and final.—Ep. Nation. | Notes. Longmans, Green & Co.’s autumn an- nouncements include ‘The Liberty and Free Soil Parties in the Northwest,’ by Theodore C. Smith, Ph.D., and ‘A Bibliography of Bri- |} tish Municipal History,’ by Charles Gross, Ph.D.—new volumes in the Harvard Histori- cal Series; ‘The Life of Stonewall Jackson,’ by Lieut.-Col. G. F. Henderson, York and Lancashire Regiment, in two volumes; the fourth and concluding volume of Dr. Lid- don’s ‘Life of Edward Bouverie Pusey, D.D.’; ‘The Life of Chauncy Maples, D.D., Bishop of Likoma (British Central Africa),’ by his sister, Ellen Maples; ‘Drake and the Tudor Navy,’ by Julian Corbett; the second volume of Gardiner’s ‘History of the Commonwealth and the Protectorate’; further volumes in the ‘Builders of Great Britain’’ series; a | select ‘‘Library of Historical Novels and Ro- characterizes my translation of ralliés into | “Mugwumps” as ‘‘well-meant but perverse and misleading.’ Permit me to say that that translation was furnished to me by a French diplomat, long a resiaent of Ame- rica, and as well acquainted with the Eng- lish-American language and politics as he is with his own. He told me that the word and the thing exactly matched in both countries. He is, also, a friend of Baron Coubertin, the author of the book in ques- tion. On the whole, I am inclined to be- lieve that “Rallié: Mugwump” will prove mances,”’ edited by Lawrence Gomme, and arranged chronologically according to sove- | reigns, each with an introduction; ‘The Wa- | ter of the Wondrous Isles,’ a prose romance by William Morris; ‘Suffolk Tales and Other Stories,’ by the late Camilla Gurdon; ‘Early , Italian Love Stories,’ edited and retold by | Una Taylor; ‘The Diary of Master William | Silence: A Study of Shakspere and of Eliza- bethan Sport,’ by the Right Hon. D. H. Mad- den, Vice-Chancellor of the University of whole set of delightful and enlightening ex- Dublin; ‘The Queen’s Hounds, and Stag- | Hunting Recollections,’ by Lord Ribbesdale, Master of the Buckhounds, 1892-'95; ‘Racing Pierre de | a valuable addition to the ‘Dictionnaire de | la Langue Verte’ not be translated literally with impunity!) of your readers. But, nevertheless, I should : . } (which title, also, may and Chasing,’ by Alfred E. T. Watson; ‘A Book of Dreams and Ghosts,’ ‘The Pink Fairy Book,’ and ‘Wordsworth’—first of a new series of selections from the poets—by Andrew Lang; an entirely new edition of ‘The Spectator,’ in eight volumes, crown oc- tavo, edited by George A. Aitken; Rameau’s Nephew,’ from the French of Diderot, by Sylvia Margaret Hill: tions, new and old, from the German by ‘Rampolli,’ transla- | | George Macdonald; the first volume of a | ‘History of Intellectual Development on the Lines of Modern Evolution,’ by John Beattie | Crozier; ‘The Origin and Growth of Plato's Logic,’ by Prof. W. Lutoslawski of the Uni- ' versity of Kazan; ‘Teaching and Organiza- tion,’ with special reference to secondary schools; and ‘Parables for School and Home,’ brief readings in applied morals, by Wendell P. Garrison, with pictorial il- lustrations. Harper & Bros. will shortly publish ‘The Personal Equation,’ essays chiefly in literary criticism, by Prof. Harry Thurston Peck of Columbia University. A Life of Prof. Henry Drummond, by George Adam Smith, will bear the imprint of the Doubleday, McClure Co. Thomas Whittaker announces ‘Potters, their Arts and Crafts,’ by John C. L. Sparkes of the South Kensington Museum, and Walter Gandy. The American Book Co. will publish ‘A New Astronomy for Beginners,’ by Prof. David P. Todd of Amherst. A. C. McClurg & Co., Chicago, have in press ‘Stories from Italy,’ by Miss G. S. Godkin, and ‘A Little House in Pimlico,’ tales for children by Miss Marguerite Bou- vet. ‘Buddhism and its Christian Critics,’ by | Dr. Paul Carus, will be issued next month by the Open Court Publishing Co. | The Catholic Art Publishing Co. of Phil- | adelphia has in press ‘Angels of the Bat- tlefield,’ a history of the labors of the Catho- | lie sisterhoods in our late civil war. Cary’s translation of the ‘Divine Comedy,’ first issued in 1812, has held its own with remarkable success in both England and America. Here it has been published at least three times, as early as 1822 and as late as 1889, and there have been many re- printings of these editions. The continued popularity of the version has led Thomas Y. Crowell & Co. to provide a new edition of it, prepared by Prof. L. Oscar Kuhns. Included with it is Rossetti’s translation of the ‘New Life,’ which has also recently ap- peared in two American editions. Prof. Kuhrs contributes a short introduction to the volume and a new set of notes to the ‘Di- Rossetti’s notes are retained, | though others are added. Prof. Norton’s translation of the ‘New Life’ excepted, Rossetti’s is that best known, and Cary’s version of the ‘Divine Comedy,’ whatever may be its defects, remains the easiest of all to understand. The reprint, therefore, is likely to meet with some measure of popular favor, particularly as it is illustrated and as Prof. Kuhns’s introduction and _ notes. though not impeccable, are interesting and sensible. An ideal popular commentary, in- deed, for students of the poem could be made by combining Prof. Kuhns’s plan with that of Longfellow—that is, by adding to simple comments on difficult passages a vine Comedy.’ tracts from contemporary historians and chroniclers. Hopelessly commonplace is ‘The Age of Milton,’ by the Rev. J. H. B. Masterman (Macmillan), to which is prefixed a rather aimless introduction by Mr. J. Bass Mul- linger. The volume can hardly be said to ' be up to the comparatively easy standard of its three predecessors in the same series | It lacks quality and illumination; its style is without order and grace; its literary criti- cism, while cautious and generally orthodox,
Page 15
— LORNA = ROCA He Oct. 7, 1897] is marred by frequent touches of banality; and it shows very little of that power of generalizing its subject so necessary for a primer or handbook which aspires to be any- thing more than a mere list of names and biographical facts and bibliographical memo- randa. We have noticed errata which injure the trustworthiness of the work as a school- book or book of reference at pages 35, 81, 111, 127, 128, 129, 146, 160, 212, and 214. ‘A First Book in Writing English,’ by E. H. Lewis (Macmillan), deserves notice, among recent contributions to the renascent art of the teaching of English prose composition, for its careful attention to the practical and i The Nation. conclusion. The translation is smooth, | though occasionally ungrammatical,and mar- red by a tiresome misuse of the present tense. The geology of Java forms the subject of a sumptuous report in French by R. D. M. Verbeek and R. Fennema, published at Amsterdam by the Dutch Government. A general description of the island is suc- ceeded by an account of the geology of each | of its twenty-two divisions or residences, pedagogic aspects of the subject. If the | | containing a geological map in twenty-six writing of English is to be taught as an art, the teaching and practice of it must not be deferred until too late in the student's course. It requires skill, however, and fe- licity of choice to eliminate the rhetorical abstractions and the dogmatisms from the more advanced text-books, and to present to the student in the secondary grades the heart of the matter in simple, practical, and yet attractive form. This, we think, Dr. Lewis has fairly succeeded in doing. As a guide-book to the senior university of the English-speaking world, Mr. Wells’s charmingly illustrated little book on ‘Oxford and its Colleges’ (London: Methuen) de- serves a word of hearty commendation. Its method is mainly historical: a succinct ac- count of the buildings of the various in- stitutions described is followed by a sketch of their history and a mention of the cele- brities that issued (or in some cases were propelled) from them. Needless to say, Mr. Wells's scholarship is excellent; he is tho- roughly at home with his ground and his authorities, and generally succeeds in con- veying a pleasing impression while skilfully keeping clear of sore points. And yet he not infrequently succeeds in gratifying his own and his readers’ sense of humor in his selections from the storied past, and alto- gether manages to infuse into his tale not a little of the fascination of his theme. It is interesting to note (p. 301) how in the end the sense of the poverty of modern Oxford conquers its pride, and extorts from Mr. Wells an allusion to the deathless fame which Oxford has the power to bestow upon a generous emulator of the noble benefac- tors of the past. The little war in Lombock of two years ago is described in ‘With the Dutch in the East,’ by Capt. Cool (London: Luzac & Co.). The author has written for his countrymen an impartial account of events with which they are in the main familiar, and which excited them much at the time, being to them thrilling as well as important. The object of the translation is less evident, for the work has not sufficient literary merit to make it easy reading. It is prolix, full of overwhelmingly long Malay names, and its artless rhetoric provokes a smile in the stranger unwarmed by the glow of Dutch | monograph would have been an added boon; patriotism. Still, the long chapter on “Our | Knowledge of the Country and its People” contains a good deal of information, and the one about ‘“‘The Attack’’ on the Dutch quar- ters at night is even exciting. The invading army, which was divided up at the time, narrowly escaped annihilation, and the im- pression left on the reader is that gross incompetency was shown—an impression not entirely effaced by the later successful opera- tions: indeed, the author’s own criticisms however mildly expressed, point to the same including the neighboring island of Madura. A special feature of the work is a memoir on the fossil foraminifera of Dutch India, with eleven lithographic plates. There are numerous illustrations, and a superb atlas sheets, as well as more than twenty addi- tional maps. In ‘Les Origines de la Monnaie considé- | rées au point de vue économique et histo- | rique’ (Paris: Firmin-Didot), M. Ernest | Babelon, curator of the department of coins | in the Biblioth@éque Nationale, traces with | adequate knowledge and with admirable | clearness the actual development of money | by the spontaneous action of individuals seeking each to better his own industrial situation. No plainer refutation will be found of the pernicious notions that money | originated in human convention, legal or | extra-legal, and that its purchasing power | depends on a law of legal tender, than that | which M. Babelon has given: and his re- | futation is net the less effective because he | advances little theory of his own, but sim- ply so marshals his facts that the candid reader is forced, as it were against his will, to the saine conclusions which the author has reached. M. Babelon’s book will be | welcome to all readers who appreciate the superiority of an historical treatment to an a-priori treatment of the subject of money. From Lemcke & Buechner we have speci- men numbers of the artist monographs (‘Kiinstler-Monographien’) for some time in course of publication by the resourceful | Leipzig house of Velhagen & Klasing. The text of these thin, profusely illustrated oc- tavos in limp bindings proceeds from several | hands; but the editor, H. Knackfuss, is the author of three of the five before us, viz.. Ru- bens, with 122 illustrations, Hans Holbein the Younger, with 151, and Franz Hals. with 40. | Ernst Steinmann treats of Botticelli, with the aid of 90 illustrations, including those | for Dante's ‘Divine Comedy’ and the newly | discovered “Pallas and Centaur.’" Perhaps | the most famous book-illustrator of Ger- many, Chodowiecki, falls to Ludwig Kaem- | merer, who can display no fewer than 204 | examples of the often tiny vignettes of this | masterly delineator of contemporary man- | ners. The Holbein and the Botticelli offer | the greatest pictorial interest, but in all | these cases it is a great boon to have such | extensive memoranda of the work of the | artist commemorated. An index to each | but only in the Botticelli .s there so much i as a table of the paintings described. The moderate price, two to three marks apiece, would still bear, we think, the cost of a | key to the contents j “Certain Aboriginal Mounds of the Geor- gia Coast" is the title of a memoir by Cla- | rence B. Moore in the latest number of the | Journal of the Academy of Natural Sciences | | of Philadelphia. It is the result of an exa- | mination of more than fifty mounds be- ' tween Fairview, Camden County, and Skid- 279 daway Island, Chatham County. The con- | struction of the mounds, the human remains | contained in them, together with the uten- sils and implements of copper, stone, shell, or earthernware, are minutely described. Evidences of both incineration and inhu- mation were found. Cremated remains were placed in cinerary urns, and large clay jare were used for the burial of infants and some- times of adults. A pecullar custom, com- mon in Florida, was observed to some ex- tent in Georgia. The bottoms of vessels in which the dead were placed were perforated, either at the time of manufacture or af- terwards. Skeletons were most frequently found with the knees and chin drawn well together. The author's conclusions are that the Georgia mounds are ‘“‘relics of a race il} supplied with stone, almost without copper, but given to the manufacture of earthen- ware.’ The race differed from the abori- gines of Florida in their methods of mound building and in their mortuary custome, | Practising cremation to a much greater ex- tent. The Geographical Journal for September opens with an account, by Col. J. K. Trot- ter, of an expedition to the source of the Niger by the French and English commis. sion for determining the boundary between French Guinea and Sierra Leone. It is il , and a map In the continuation of his Prof. Milne treats mainly of the curious testimony to lustrated by reproductions of photographs paper on sub-oceanic chan these changes by the telegraph cables Among the pictures of fractured cables is one showing a cable grown round with coral. Other articles are upon the physiographical features of the Lakes Nyasa and Tangan yika districts, the Roman roads of Morocco, and Mr. Keltie'’s presidential address before the geographical section of the British As- ' | sociatior In it he dwells upon the future work of geographers. which consists not ; only in exploring the still unknown parts of the earth, but also in the study of ocean- ography, and the relations between man and his geographical environmegt Capt Cleeve contributes an interesting ‘‘aide-mé. moire to a comparison of certain geographi- eal distances." Taking as a unit the dis- tance from Land's End to Shetland Islands, 7>0 miles, he shows it to be a remarkable | standard of measurement by a table of some hundred instances selected from all parts of the world The Scottish Geographical Magazine for | September contains, in addition to the ad- dress of Mr. Keltie, a very interesting ac. count of the investigations of Dr. Niiesch on the prehistoric remains at Schweizersbild, near Schaffhausen, by Prof. James Geikie. There is something very touching in the de- scription of the Neolithic interments discov- ered, ten of which were children. ‘The great care with which the graves have been | constructed, and the presence of the orna- | ments and other valuable objects [shells and finely finished flint implements] placed | beside his dead little ones, show how strong was Neolithic man’s family affection. The new-born infants were laid each within the right arm of its mother, while with the left arm stretched across her breast the latter seemed to hold the little one fast.” M. Eugéne Ritter, whose work on the youth of J. J. Rousseau was reviewed in these columns last year, publishes in the Reruc des Deux Mondes for September 1 some further researches on the history of Serene oe Ske ache bagedeeet nea eae oad one (IRE L aeNAEOE Niint CIT oe BRIT EO FH Bhs RAR padaaned
Page 16
280 that ever problematic character. New light is thrown on the relations between Rous- seau and M. de Montaigu, the French Am- bassador at Venice, so harshly treated in the ‘Confessions’ for his dilatoriness in paying his secretary's salary. The latter was not let into the secret of the financial difficulties in which his superior found himself in con- sequence of the maladministration of public affairs under Louis XV. Thérése Le Vas- seur, it appears from M. Ritter’s pages, did not deserve all the contempt which has been heaped upon her by many writers; her ig- norance and illiteracy, however, were as- tonishing. To point out estimable traits, hitherto not sufficiently noticed, in Rous- seau’s character, as M. Ritter is able to do, must be especially gratifying. The article deserves to be read by those desirous to do justice to the memory of Jean Jacques and to understand more fully the causes of his influence. Dr. Hans Reusch, Director of the Geologi- cal Survey of Norway, has been appointed for the year 1897-’98 to the Sturgis Hooper professorship of geology at Harvard Uni- versity, this position having been vacant since the death of Prof. J. D. Whitney a year ago. Prof. Reusch will lecture during the first half-year on vulcanism and erup- tive rocks, earthquakes, and movements of the earth's crust. In the second half-year he will treat of the geology of Northern Europe and its relation to general geology. The third meeting of each week will be given to seminary work. In the spring, Prof. Reusch proposes to take part with the other instructors of the geological depart- ment in practical study in the field. -The Boston committee in charge of the Shaw monument wind up their trust in an elegant volume detailing the inception, com- pletion, and unveiling (1865-1897) of the memorial (Houghton, Miffin & Co.). No- thing could better typify the transition pe- riod—far from being yet ended—from op- pression to justice than the speeches of Major Higginson, Prof. William James, and Booker Washington. Major Higginson has tc apologize to Southern susceptibilities for his historical retrospect, and wofully to mis- represent the abolitionists, the subsoil—or, rather, considering his parentage—the very soil out of which Col. Shaw grew. Prof. James speaks in the humane and elevated tone of the national conscience on the sub- ject of slavery, and does not omit to point out the civic evils that have flowed from a just war. Finally, Booker Washington, on behalf of his color—emancipated, but social- ly ostracised, both North and South—shows in brief but well-chosen words the incom- pleteness of the edifice erected on the ruins ef slavery, the lack of ‘‘the full measure of the fruit of Fort Wagner and all that this iShaw] monument stands for’; the duty also of completing it, and the mode in which the freedmen are to enforce their manhood claims by moral and intellectual training. As we close the volume, news comes that the School Board of Alton, Ill., is forcibly ex- cluding colored children from the common schools—even those named after Lovejoy and Lincoln. Shades of the martyrs! —In a very neat little volume, with illus- trations, Mrs. Fairchild has printed a limit- ed edition of the Journals of John Linklaen, agent of the Holland Land Company, de- scribing his travels in,Pennsylvania, New York, and Vermont in 1791 and 1792. The The Nation. blunt and unimaginative voyager notes down in the simplest manner whatever meets his eye, and the result is very readable, and of interest as a rough presentation of the times. His special interest was shown for the maple-sugar industry in Pennsylvania. The industry was primitive, for, in place of the extensive works, buildings, and work- men he expected to see, he found a ruined hut, barely accessible because of the bram- bles, a couple of ‘“‘chaldrons’’ and some other scattered utensils, but no workers. Five gallons of sap was required to make one pound of sugar. While noting the occur- rence of the ‘‘mapple” tree, he was not blind to other economic features. The lie and quality of the land, the price per acre, and the yield of wheat and maize, the plans of new roads or vroposed canals, and the own- ership of the land were of interest, as the region through which he passed was held in large parcels and as speculative ventures. This did not prevent squatters ‘‘who have come to settle themselves with no other rights than those of nature.’’ The inchoate condition of the country is well shown by the difficulties of travel—‘‘mud up to the horses’ belly’—which effectually prevented any trading of goods. —Apart from the religious communities encountered, Linklaen met other social cu- riosities. The Oneida Indians were on a reservation,-and carefully protected by law from any contracts with the white settlers. “Tilling the earth is burdensome to them, so that often they allow Americans to settle on & work their lands provided they give them 1-3 or half the yield. Even their grist- mill is managed on this footing by an American.’”’ There he heard the ‘universal Friend,’ a woman from Rhode Island, who claimed to be an apostle of Christ, but he found her to deal in ‘‘a quantity of vain words without sense or reason.’”” The gene- ral impression made by these notes is that wood-life at that time was one of great deprivation and almost wretchedness. It is well to have such an unvarnished record of the curiously mixed life in these new set-~ tlements. One detail needs explanation. In expressing values Mrs. Fairchild has used the symbol for the apothecary’s ounce. As a rule it stands alone with the figure, but on p. 74 we find it intercalated between ‘2-6’ and “‘sterling.’’ It is reasonable to suppose it is only a shilling mark, and in this we are confirmed by an entry on p. 116. The note to Mr. Root on p. 74 is clearly wrong, for the local money is used unless the name of another State is added. This was the universal practice at that time. —At the recent Congress of Orientalists in Paris M. Salomon Reinach read a paper upon the representation of female nudity in Mediterranean prehistoric art. The ge- neral subject of early undraped statues of women is one to which M. Reinach has given much time and study. About twoyears ago he read before the Académie des In- scriptions, and afterwards published in the Rerue Archéologique, what may fairly be called a convincing paper, disproving the generally received theory that nudity in classic art is ultimately derived from a Babylonian source, the image of the goddess Istar. There was no nude divinity in the Babylonian pantheon. When Istar appears as a goddess, she is represented clothed and in armor; when she is disrobed, it is for her humiliation, her descent into hell. On the [Vol. 65, No. 1684 other hand, there have been found in the Archipelago and at Troy, dating from about 1200 B. c., statuettes of nude women, and one was also found in a tumulus in Thrace. Similar figures of life-size existed at the same period in the Greek islands, and some of these may bave been carried off by a Babylonian conqueror and so have become objects of worship. It was, then, according to M. Reinach, from prehistoric Greece that the type of nude divinities passed into Babylonia, coming back centuries later through Pheenicia to historic Greece, and so to Rome. In his paper before the Orien- talists M. Reinach brought new support to his theories from the art found in the ca- verns of the south of France, which is of the same type as that of the borders of the Archipelago. An instance that is at once quite new and _ highly corroborative was brought forward by M. Reinach in the very curious statuette discovered ten years ago in a grotto of Mentone, and acquired in 1895 by the Museum of Saint-Germain. This figurine appears to date from the end of the paleolithic period—that is, perhaps some €,006 years before the Christian era. The statuette was shown to the meeting by M. Reinach. The Débats describes it as being “aux formes bizarres, aux saillies exagé- 1ées,’’ and adds, with a certain conscious or unconscious humor, “‘c’est une ceuvre réa- liste, d’un art tout spontané.”’ —Michelangelo literature, already so volu- minous, is on the point of receiving a con- siderable addition. Michelangelo’s own let- ters have already been given to the world; they are to be supplemented by a collection of about eight hundred letters written to bim which have been kept among the archives of the Casa Buonarroti in the via Ghibellina in Florence. The Casa Buonar- roti belonged to Michelangelo (although he never lived in it), and remained in the pos- session of his heirs until the year 1858. In 1620 the house was put in order and deco- rated, and became a sort of museum of sketches and casts, drawings, plans, and autographs of the master, to which his family added from time to time such let- ters addressed to him as they could find or procure. By a will dated June 11, 1856, the last descendant of Michelangelo, the Count Cosimo Buonarroti, bequeathed the building and its contents to the city of Florence, and a corporation was formed to take charge of it. This corporation has ad- ministered its charge so well that the Casa has been from the very first self-supporting. In the will of Count Cosimo Buonarroti there were several hampering restrictions, the most annoying of which was one that for- bade the publication of any of the manu- scripts or other papers which the house con- tained. For a number of years these re- strictions were observed; the first breach that was made in them occurring in Gothi’s Life of Michelangelo, published in Florence in 1875, at the time of the celebration of the quadricentenary anniversary of the great man’s birth. In this volume appeared some letters of his correspondents, and at a little later date Milanesi published thirty-six let- ters written to Michelangelo by Sebastian del Piombo between the years 1520 and 1533. The two scholars made no mystery of the fact that the originals of these letters were in the archives of the Casa. Others have followed them, but, in all, hardly more than sixty letters have so far appeared. The corporation has now swept all restrictions Ry malt Coed: Fee a at 3 i i einen Lnc Breen Se
Page 17
sigtitiien a eieliiiell oe oo ee os ia ae Maca Ae
3 2 ete MMM Ratan aa AN
Oct. 7, 1897]
aside, and the whole eight hundred letters are to be printed. The learned Commen- datore G. Biagi, head of the Laurentian Li- brary, is charged with their publication. The letters cover the period between the years 1506 and 1564, and their writers are many and of the most widely separated con- ditions in life, down to the humble scal- pellini. Michelangelo counted many ascal- pellini among his friends, and it is said that these letters will throw much light on the so- cial condition of this interesting classof men. RECENT NOVELS. The Christian: A Story. By Hall Caine. D. Appleton & Co. The Martian. By George Du Maurier. Har- per & Brothers. Uncle Bernac. By A. Conan Doyle. D. Ap- pleton & Co. The Secret of Saint Florel. By John Ber- wick. Macmillan Co. Constantine. By George Horton. Chicago: Way & Williams. Susan’s Escort and Others. By Edward Ev- erett Hale. Harper & Brothers. The White Hecatomb, and Other Stories. By William Charles Scully. Henry Holt & Co. Love & Company (Limited). By John Wern- berny and Another. J. Selwin Tait & Co. Arnaud’s Masterpiece: A Romance of the Pyrenees. By Walter Cranston Larned. Charles Scribner’s Sons. Since the fashion set in for using a prob- lem in morals as the heart of a romantic legend, Mr. Hall Caine has been one of our most effective novelists. For the develop- ment of moral conflict leading to a sombre or terrible catastrophe, correct instinct has led him to choose rather primitive, sim- ple people, in whom an excess of emotion over reason is probable and not discredita- ble. Such people move naturally through a drama which takes the full romantic license in action and sentiment, with only enough restraint to escape the absurdity and senti- mentality of melodrama. Perhaps the es- cape from the worst dangers which beset an excitable, imaginative temperament, ap- plied to the discussion in prose fiction of the soul’s temptations, has been due more to the sincerity and passion thrown into the strife, and to Mr. Caine’s intuition for phases and fine shades, than to the very slight technical restraints. In his latest novel, ‘The Christian,’ the ever-threatening calamity has overtaken him. He has tackled a problem in morals which affects the whole world, not exclu- sively a small group of Manxmen, and the problem is greater than he is, even as the world is bigger than the Isle of Man. The
subject, instead of lending itself willingly | to the romantic, dramatic method, | stands aside, rigid, unmalleable, refusing absolutely to he dragged or driven into har- mony. The majesty of the redemption of the world declines association with scene, situation, climax, and silently contrasts its true self with Mr. Caine’s artificial and vio- lent presentation. In one of those explanatory notes through which authors try to deliver readers from the consequences of their natural-born stu- pidity, Mr. Caine says: “In presenting the thought which is the motive of ‘The Chris- tian’ my desire has been to depict, however | The Nation. imperfectly, the types of mind and character. of creed and culture, of social effort and re- ligious purpose, which I think I see in thelife of England and America."’ By the im- perfect light of our own wits we take the | thought to be that the world is far gone in | sin, particularly in the sin of lust, and is in sore need of a redeemer. A just inference from the book, and one sustained by the title, is that Mr. Caine has desired to do more than record observations, and has wished to denounce sin and to depict the character of a redeemer, despised and re- jected of men, through the medium of a readable novel which may be con- verted into an actable play. It was said of old that we cannot serve God and Mammon, and Mr. Caine’s, experi- ment offers no reason for a_ reversal of that judgment. But, putting aside a per- haps base suspicion, and looking for reasons of failure more particular than a disparity between the man and the work, the motive and the method, the most conspicuous are the conception of the character of a possi- ble redeemer, and the author’s predilection in favor of one sort of sinner. For the rdéle of redeemer it would be hard for a person not a novelist to think of any one less fitted than John Storm. He is not supposed to be a primitive person, picturesquely governed by emotion, but a man of good birth, wide education and travel, prompted to devote himself to Christ by observation of universal injustice to and oppression of the weak by the strong. It is fair to assume that such a man would possess an intellect to be used for guidance, but John Storm rarely displays a glimmer of reason. He has no singleness or stability of purpose. The command, ‘Know thyself,”’ is, by reason of his mind- lessness, nothing but a stumbling-block. He has no sense of personal responsibility, for he refers his actions, good or bad, to the influence of God or the Devil. He pursues a mad career to a miserable end, never quite sure that he has really been blown about like thistle-down by passion for a woman; passion taking base forms, jealous, suspicious, insulting to its object. Whatever he does, whether he enters a monastery or leaves it, throws himself into a furious cru- sade against lust, drink, and hypocrisy, or spends weeks in solitary prayer and penance, the inspiring motive is always the young woman with the great mimetic talent and awful name—Glory Quayle In his relations with Glory, he is con- spicuously lacking in the first of Christian
virtues—charity st thought of her is that she is ana though frivolous, worldling, and (which is also his commonest), that she is the mistress of an amiable and rich young man named Drake. When her genuine love for him proves in- adequate to his demand that ‘she shall fol-
low him to his London slums, he never thinks of compromise, going away from Lon- jon and leading a decent, quiet, Christian life in a country parish, but proposes that she shall de ate herself to lepers, to whom, » s death, he at ted, and has a
expect her cooperation Bitterly appointed by her rejection of this inhu- proposal. he rushes back to the monas- tery, previously abandoned, and takes the vows of chastity, poverty, and obedience. Af- terwards he tries to kill her, but kisses her instead, and ends by marrying her, literally with his last breath. Storm may represent
281 | one of the kinds of culture which Mr. Caine thinks he sees, but it is not a kind which it is possible to admire or respect, or even greatly to sympathize with; it is not a kind of which a possible Christ or even a sincere and useful Christian is made. His failure to achieve any kind of good is not the failure } } } of a great nature misunderstood, scorned and persecuted by those whom he loved and would have saved. John Storm failed be- cause he never Knew exactly what he wanted or how to take it, and because he was ir resolute and violent and passionately pre judiced; because, in fact, he was almost al ways in the wrong The career of Glory Quayle makes a the- atrically effective contrast to John Storm's, and is reminiscent of many careers described by unpretentious, frivolous novelists She is a nice enough girl, with a shockingly as tificial epistolary style, but for which and an easy-going tolerance of wicked lords and their vulgar mistresses, she would be nicer Her long patience with Storm's harshness and insults, her passionate pity for his de lusions and belief in his goodness, and her final renunciation of all for him are not } exaggerated testimony to the strength of an i blossoming f alfection soWn in childhood an in the wonderful beauty of a first love i it were not for that last thrilling scene in the slums with the dying Christian and the great actress for centre, the clergyman to the right, the Prime Minister waving a li- cense from Lambeth to the left, and a back
ground of bedraggled femal
could imagine Glory permanently forsaking the stage and devoting herself to the tedium of good works: but her eagerness for this climax betokens a theatrical instinct too vi gorous to be buried in the graves of a dozen lovers Mr. Caine’s treatment of the sin of the world is a deplorable exhibition of senti- mentality, and his criticism of institutions such as hospitals and the Anglican Church is harshly censorious Apparently the only sinners worthy of tenderness and charity are prostitutes. This view, of course, nar- rows any scheme of redemption, and is un impressive but it gives great opportunity for violent rhetoric, and is sure of applause from the gallery. The most serious aspect of the sentimental treatment of seduction
and prostitution is that it is more likely to increase than to diminish their practice. All women are not doves any more than all men are birds of prey. The social law which makes unchastity a shame for the woman only is unjust and oppressive, but, like most rigorous social laws, its roots are deep down in human nature, and it restrains rather than encourages immorality No wailing of hysterical humanitarians or rhetoric of sen- <imental novelists will ever cast the burden of shame on men, but these methods may undermine the sense of shame instinctive in women of all classes, and thus set stronger instincts free for unrestrained indulgence Girls like Polly Love, for whom our sym- pathy is urgently invited, and of whom there are at least several in every community, can never be saved or reformed by being told that they are irresponsible victims of man’s depravity, but this is an excellent way to encourage the vanity and frivolity which make them the easy victims of the Lord Robert Ures prowling about to devour. If Mr. Caine has a sincere desire to help both men and women to abstain from sins
of the flesh, the road he must take is dull 1 ne ta: And aegnenns
Page 18
2Q282 (Vol. 65 No. 1684 The N at and tedious and discouraging; an obscure and silent road, where electric light shineth not and the sounding brass and tinkling cymbal are never heard. The three books written by Mr. Du Maurier have so many points of likeness that reading or thinking about one recalls vividly the one before and the one before that. The passion for physical beauty never ebbs; the view of men and manners con- tinues frank, gay, and tolerant, and the imagination hovers about the incredible— particularly about successive incarnations of the soul and magnetic influence. In each the author is the most conspicuous charac- ter, and draws himself with an untram- melled vivacity which leaves little to specu- lation or future biographers. Of the three ‘Peter Ibbetson’ is the best story, and has the most literary value—using that phrase to mean the closest adherence to a central idea, coherent form, and a style that in many passages has the refinement and repose of all literature that becomes classic. In ‘Tril- by’ the story is feeble, of secondary impor- tance, the form correspondingly loose, and the style the freest that ever skipped with a smile and a wink into the formal kingdom of letters—a spontaneous, colhoquial, volatile style, making every one intimate with one of the kindest, cleverest, and wittiest of men. One cannot imagine gloom so deep as to prove impenetrable by that buoyant, diverting spirit, and insensible to that hap- py manner. We cannot be grateful enough to the man who, at a time when novels were harder and drearier than the existence of any one mortal could ever be and con- tinue, gave us such a fillip as ‘Trilby.’ As an expression of Du Maurier’s lovable nature, ‘The Martian’ is a supplement to ‘Trilby.’ We learn a little that is new about his feelings and experiences, and we feel all the old charm over again. Though we may not believe in the incomparable beauty, virtues, talents, and graces of Barty, Leah, and all the galaxy, we know that he be- lieved, and our delight in him is unim- paired. As fiction is a representative art, it must make us believe, or fall short of good. Many people found a difficulty in accept- ing Trilby as a real girl, living, or ever having lived. Her praise was too ecstati- cally chanted and there were glaring dis- crepancies. The laudation of Barty, Leah, and the rest is riotous, too superlative; it excites suspicion, criticism, scepticism; its insistence and iteration bore us. Our im- perfection perhaps resents so much perfec- tion. The Lady from Mars, whose magnetic influence made Josselin ‘‘the greatest lite- rary genius this century has produced,” is purely fantastic. She is not a perfect in- vention, like the dream situation in ‘Peter Ibbetson.’ Her presence and performance are much remoter from the actual and pos- sible than is Svengali, with his magnetism and magic. Her account of herself is a wild, unconvincing fabrication, and there is even a farcical suggestion in her trick of mak- ing Barty ‘feel the North.” Putting this trick, reminiscent of Captain Cuttle, to- gether with the lively ironies of her letters and personal narrative, one suspects that Du Maurier wrote her up for his own amuse- ment, caring little whether she and her do- ings should appear probable or not. He was not, thank, Heaven! a serious novelist. He served no apprenticeship, and in none of his books, except the first, is there the slightest indication of his having paid any attention to the conventions or technicalities of novel-writing. Therefore the way to enjoy his books without any “ifs” or “‘buts’” is to forget that they are called novels, and to regard them as descriptions of a most interesting life and as wonder- fully expressive revelations of a man of happy outlook, whose sympathies were as wide as was his exceptional power of ob- servation, and who gave unstintingly his heart and head and hand for the pleasure of us all. Mr. Conan 1 yle’s Uncle Bernac is an irreproachable villain. His skin is of the texture and tint of parchment; his expres- sion sinister, his coat snuff-colored. He speaks in sibilant whispers menacing as a serpent’s hiss, and is always on the winning side. A participator in the vilest crimes of the French Revolution, he chased into exile a noble family, with which he was closely connected by marriage, taking to himself the confiscated estates and revenues. When it came to pass that every man’s for- tune depended on Napoleon’s, none was more devoted to the risen star than Uncle Bernac. Mr. Doyle deals with him as the Emperor’s spy, a traitor and coward; a miserable, de- graded wretch, who deservedly comes to a bad end. The adventure which introduces young Louis de Laval to his delectable uncle makes a spirited opening—so spirited that the subsequent adventures are dull by con- trast. Louis has not enough dash for a hero, but is a modest young man, whose good judgment shines in the reflection that Na- poleon is the most interesting figure of this memoir. Napoleon stands very solidly on his feet. By a careful combination of fact and legend and by a clever selection of scenes, Mr. Doyle has contrived a lively and comprehensible picture of a character made up of contradictions and extremes, great and trivial, worshipful and detestable, sub- lime and ridiculous, always above or below common men. The vitality and compres- sion of this sketch of the awful Boney imply careful preparatory study and display great literary skill. Beside it the tale of Louis de Laval’s love and Uncle Bernac’s iniqui- ties is a flat, perfunctory performance. It is to be hoped that the author of the ‘Secret of Saint Florel’ means never to write another tale of mystery and adventure. Painful beyond endurance, and futile with- out hope, would be his effort to find any first-rate mystery or horror which he has not already used for all it is worth. Spendthrift, too, of scene as of incident, the Arctic Circle alone remains to him, for the awful occur- rences leading up to this secret exhaust the tropics and the temperate zones. The whole wide range of human character is, however, still at his service, for, with his super- abundance of more inxmediately striking material, he has wisely held his psychic ob- servations and theories severely in reserve. Descriptions of the beauty of the Isles of Greece and of the ways not exclusively beautiful of their modern inhabitants make the most readable chapters of ‘Constantine.’ The figure of Constantine, wronged and de- frauded from his birth, driven to madness by injustice and betrayal, is rather a tragic conception, but the author has not the power to keep up to such a high mark. He shows to more advantage in common characters and ordinary incidents; his domestic scenes, quarrels, reconciliations, and the every-day family intercourse being done with unusual point and truth. In the rather curious preface to his volume of tales, Dr. Hale enters a plea of justifica- tion for the practice of telling stories which may appear to be true. He says that there are critics who hold that an author is suc- cessful only when no one can imagine his stories to be true. He does not like or ap- prove of these critics. Yet his first tale, “Susan's Escort,’’ and several others in the volume, are nothing if not sops thrown with intent to placate. They are quite trium- phantly improbable, and base indeed are these critics should they fail to proclaim Dr. Hale as another Barty Josselin among authors. To the critics who do not make a canon of improbability, the merit of Dr. Hale’s work, including this volume, is in the healthy moral tone, the practical energy and common sense, the word of good cheer aptly and heartily spoken to humble, ob- scure pilgrims on the monotonous by-ways of life. His success in America comes large- ly from his habit of addressing the American people, not the English or any other nation, in their own language, which is not exactly English, but (we hasten to say) not inferior to English or any other as a medium for the communication of ideas. He does not speak down to any class or up to any, but is al- ways imperturbably on a level with all. He is one of the last of a band of American writers spiritually attached to the idea of human equality; and so long as his stories express that spirit, and are read and liked because of its presence, the opinion of critics of form and word makes very little differ- ence. ‘The White Hecatomb, and Other Stories’ are as well and carefully written as the author’s earlier volume, entitled ‘Kafir Stories.” Among South African savages and Boers the horrible with hideous accessories is probably very much in evidence. Mr. Scully seems to find it without any trouble. and though he lifts it sometimes to tragedy, the sordid and squalid atmosphere will not vanish at his bidding. In following the pas- sions and actions of savages black and dirty, with unpronounceable names begin- ning with two consonants, the point of satiety is soon reached. About the middle of the volume there is a sketch entitled “Derelicts.”” The reason for its being just there is not plain, since it has nothing to do with negroes, Boers, or Malays. Its sub- ject is extremely painful, and none of the pain is spared in the treatment. The Dere- liets and their madness of sorrow eat and drink and sleep with you and refuse to be banished for many days, so nothing need be said about the writer’s force and power. Several times the experiment of writing a story in collaboration has been tried by men and women. The little tale entitled ‘Love & Company (Limited)’ is a pleasant and successful venture of that sort. The compact made in the beginning is a situa- tion so full of peril of sensuality or vul- garity that the authors’ management of it is a quite surprising exhibition of good taste. The only indiscretion is Miss Morris’s mistaking Mr. Horton's feet fer the massive legs of her ancestral mahogany and per- sisting in the mistake through a long din- ner. As this episode and the emotions of the participators are described with perfect gravity, there is a deficiency in the sense of humor, not otherwise conspicuous, and also a momentary yielding to temptations which had best be sternly resisted in the interes! of polite letters. The man’s and the wo- man's point of view are clearly distinguisha- ble throughout, the style neat and befitting- A chit aici es a —o ha SSE Neg ai DE ee aba te. - ef “ Eee ng cee a ; 3 MRA .
Page 19
ie os aie ‘ ° ACU eee Der ce eed ae RCRA eo Oct. 7, 1897] ly light, and the manner noticeably good- tempered and well-bred. ‘Arnaud’s Masterpiece’ is more a suc cession of pictures than a coherent romance. The majesty of mountains, the freshness and fragrance of forests, the splendor of 1oppy fields, are more vividly present to the | author than are human passion either of | love and gratification, or of love and re- nunciation. The young monk and the out- lawed Cagots and the beautiful Angela are like the figures of indifferent landscapes mistakenly believed to add interest to the scene. There is much more effort, hard conscientious work put into the people and incidents than into the descriptions of scene, but the heart and soul have disdained guid ince and thrown themselves into the adora- tion of external beauty. THE INDIAN VILLAGE COMMUNITY. The Indian Village Community, chiefly on the basis of the Revenue-Settle- ment Records and District Manuals. By B. H. Baden-Powell, M.A., C.ILE. Long- mans, Green & Co. It may seriously be questioned whether ‘the comparative method,”’ which our fathers were so proud of having first applied to the history of society, has done more good than harm. It has helped to lift history out of mere antiquarianism; it has led to the for- mulation of sweeping generalizations, which have appeared to bring masses of tedious facts under easy control of the scientific imagination; it has helped to bridge over the chasm between ‘“‘science’’ and _ the studies concerned with human society by facilitating the utterance of the current shibboleth of “evolution.”’ But it is now be- coming apparent that some of these generalizations were of the kind that the academic slang of the English Cambridge calls ‘“‘hasty.’’ They are now being, of neces- sity, either abandoned or profoundly modi- fied; but meantime they have done a world of mischief. Men have, consciously or un- consciously, gone out for more than a gene- ration to seek new illustrations for con- clusions already assumed; they have often had eyes only for what, consciously or un- consciously, they wanted to see; and it has not been altogether a gain that has given us, in the place of the plodding and unspecula- tive scholar, the brilliant and pseudo-scienti- fic essayist. One amusing, were it not irritating, result of the recent confidence in certain results of the comparative method we are reminded of by Mr. Baden-Powell’s welcome book on India. This is the way in which, as soon asa generalization, covering all the peoples of the earth, or perhaps only the ‘“‘Aryan’’ peo- ples, begins to be called in question in its application to one particular people, there is a tendency to overbear criticism by an appeal to what it is alleged has been proved elsewhere. That, in apparently similar | sequences of phenomena, a gap in one series | should be provisionally supplied from an- other; that language which is obscure in the documents of one people should be interpret- ed by its significance (when it is clearly the same formulas that appear) in the docu- ments of another—this is all very proper But to be of any value, the appeal should be from the dubious to the certain: when it is from the dubious to the equally dubious, it is only waste of time. Yet there has been The Nation. something like this in someof the recent dis- cussions concerning the origin of property in land. It was taught preity generally un- til quite recently that all peoples, or at any rate all Aryan peoples, had gone through a stage in which the ‘‘ownership” of the soil was vested in a village community. This idea was probably of German origin and originally applied to Germany only. Then the generalization was extended to England | and, about the same time, to the vast area of Hindustan. A decade or so of populariz- ation followed. When by and by the critical process began, and doubts were raised as to whether the proposition was true in its bearing upon England, nothing was more natural than to refer the inquirer to the example of Germany. Was it its truth as to Germany that was next called in question, the sceptic couid be referred to India. And it was not long before in India itself the critics of the theory there were referred back—by those, of course, who had not fol- lowed the course of the discussion in Eu- rope—to what was still regarded as ascer- tained fact with regard to Germany. So that actually four years after the appearance of his own magnificent work, ‘The Land Sys- tems of British India,’ which ought to have placed the whole discussion on a new foot- ing, Mr. Baden-Powell is obliged to recog- nize that some of his readers will ‘“‘be dis- posed to regard the Indian case as neces- sarily concluded by a general verdict on the European evidence as to archaic common ownérship of land’’; and it is with the air of one who asks a favor that he “submits that, under the circumstances of doubt that exist as to the European phenomena, the Indian case may with advantage be dealt with on its own merits” (p. 5). For more than twenty years almost all those who in Europe or America have had occasion, in the course of their study of the history of institutions, to pay any attention to the Indian village, have had recourse to Sir Henry Maine's ‘Village Communities in the East and West’; while observers in In- dia itself, called upon, in the course of their official duty, to draw up an account of con- ditions immediately before them, have been apt to see them through the spectacles of the same book. But Maine’s work owed much of its authority to the reputation gained by its predecessor, ‘Ancient Law,’ to which it is in truth far inferior; his own range of observation had been curiously limited; and since his time there has been a vast accumu- lation of fresh evidence in the way of gov- ernment gazetteers and Settlement records, which makes it absolutely impossible any longer to be satisfied with “the abstract and unified conception of the village’’ suggested by his writings. Mr. Baden-Powell has done us the great service, in the substantial vol- ume closely packed with matter now before us, to bring all this material together. He attempts, and that with no small success, to disentangle its main ~esults and dovetail them into one another, with a perception of their value which is the result at once of his own Indian experience and of his ac- | quaintance with recent English discussion By far the larger part of the volume is taken up with an exposition of existing con ditions of land-tenure and land cultivation, and of the geographical and ethnological considerations which have to be taken into account. He points out that there are two of village-tenure at very different present in existence In the one, known as 288 the Raiyatwart village, the iand-owners are themselves cultivators, and own their land each in severalty; so that “the group of holdings in no sense forms a proprietary unit.” This form is characteristic of more than two-thirds of India. In the other, call ed by the author the joint or shared village, there is something which may in a sense be called a common ownership; but this com- mon ownership is that of a “landlord es tate’’—‘‘the growth of some individual over- lordship, or some settlement of conquering clans or’ expansion of families with thelr own notions of equal rights’’ among them selves, ‘‘and of superiority to inferior races who have usually been allowed to con tinue as rent-paying cultivators of the soll He then shows that the Raiyatwari form prevails in those parts of India which have been least affected by invasion. Finally after an elaborate examination of the rem nants of tribal organization still to be foun: in the Punjaub and other provinces. he sets forth tentatively his own conclusions. These are that ‘“‘the right to land grows out of twi ideas; one being that a special claim arises to any object, or to a plot of land, by virtus of the labor and skill expended in makine it useful or profitable; the other, that a claim arises from conquest or superie might’’ ¢p. 400). Of these the first. if ws are to call anything “primitive,” would seem best to deserve that title. All the evidence of early law and of the actual practice of “aboriginal” races leads to the conclusion that ‘‘the early tribesman, under sanction of custom, appropriated his fleld orhis share of the tribal land, as he would appropriat: atree tomakeacanoeora plough.” This claim or appropriation was perfectly compatible with the existence of a certatn tribal contro! or better (for it was rather a division of a tribe that held together than a tribe itself) of a certain control by the cian. both as thin and those withow against those wi Neither the vague sense of clan-right nor the stronger sense of individual appropriation can be termed “property” without creating misapprehensions. Left to itself, however the development ran steadily in the direc- tion of what we can call individual property, is seen to-day in the Raiyatwari village; unless above the body of originally owning ultivators was imposed, by some one of the score of ways in which such things took place in India, a landlord or group of land- lords claiming superiority of race. And in that case a body of non-cultivating joint proprietors might make its appearance, usu- ally as the result of certain customs regard ing family property. In no case does the self-governing village group of cultivating »wners of Maine’s hypothesis make its ap pearance as a distinct stage in agrarian history. The discussion cannot be regarded as losed. We are still only at the beginning of our analysis of the tribe and the clan and the lesson of past controversies is that we should not be in a hurry to suppose we know just what “tribal conditions’’ are. In the overwhelming mass of particu lars brought together by Mr. Baden-Powell from provinces so far apart as Mysore and Cashmir, Assam and Sindh, there is abun- dant opportunity for differences of interpre were or tation. It is perhaps ungrateful to say that there is still room for a statement from Mr Baden-Powell’s pen of the farger results of his studies, set forth in untechnical language, for the benefit of the general ADE? en AE, METER: TORO ain
Page 20
284 reader. His volumes are fruitful in in | struction to all who will take a little trou- | ble; still, they present a severe aspect. But | nothing can lessen our admiration for his learning, his thoroughness, his caution, and his intellectual candor. The book is a very considerable achievement. A History of Our Own Times, from 1880 to the Diamond Jubilee. By Justin McCar- thy, M.P. Illustrated. Harper & Bros. 1897. Mr. McCarthy’s first two volumes appeared in 1878. His object in writing them, as ex- plained in his present preface, was to sup- ply the “young student”’ with something he could not elsewhere get. Now that the book has been completed by bringing it down to the current year, its chief distinction un- doubtedly is that there is no other work of the sort covering the same ground. It is a convenient book of reference for. any one who wants to get a rapid résumé of an incident or episode, a brief account of a ca- reer, or a party struggle, as one might get it more laboriously from the newspapers of the day; but more than this we cannot say. Mr. McCarthy is not so much an historian as a ready writer, who has a reporter’s gift for seizing upon the striking features of what is going on, and a turn for narration which the young student will be apt to value more than the old one. It would, indeed, be apparent without the preface that the author had had a youthful audience in mind throughout. His history, especially in this volume, reads sometimes like the story told by the good grandfather, after his retirement from active life, to the young folks at home. It is good for the young to héar it, and they may derive much profit from it, but we do not generally call it history. The volume is an uneven piece of workmanship. Of course there are chapters in which any mature man will find something to interest him, but we cannot help being irritated by a tone which continually suggests that, had the author made up his mind at the outset to write a Child’s History of the Reign of Queen Victoria, we should have had a better book. Occasionally Mr. McCarthy's method of treatment produces the effect of positive in- accuracy; as, for instance, in his account of the Venezuela dispute, in which he makes Canning urge the Monroe Doctrine on Mon- roe as a means of preventing ‘‘the fallen dynasties’’ of Europe from establishing themselves ‘‘on the shores of either Ame- rica,’’ and makes the Doctrine itself simply a declaration ‘‘that the United States could not regard with approval any attempt on the part of a foreign Power to set up a monarchy on American soil against the wish of the people who occupied that part of the country.’’ We doubt if this would be accept- ed by any Monroe Doctrine publicist. We never heard that the Doctrine was directed specially against ‘‘fallen’’ European dynas- ties, and the implication that a local vote would authorize the establishment of a for- eign monarchy on American soil contrary to our wishes, could commend it to no true pa- triot. The only safe plan is to quote the Doctrine. Still, the author gives us the general drift of the dispute, and we know of no subject on which more excuses may be made for a slight lapse from accu- racy. Another defect which the grown-up read- The Nation. er will notice, although, for purposes of | reference, it adds to the value of the book, is the extraordinary importance attached by the author to what we may call the necro- | logical side of history. We have not count- | ed to see how many of the pages are taken up with what a journalist would call ‘‘obi- tuaries,’’ but it is a considerable part of the book. Chapter v. is called “On Fame’s Eternal Beadroll’’ (the titles of the chapters are more adapted to a work of fiction than to a history), and contains critical notices of George Eliot, Lord Stratford de Redcliffe, Sir Alexander Cockburn, Lord Hampton, Carlyle, Dean Stanley, Archbishop McHale, George Borrow, J. H. Burton, Trelawney, Grenville Murray, James Spedding, Mrs. C. S. Hall, W. R. Greg, Edward Miall, E. A. Sothern, and Disraeli. Chapter xiv. is call- ed “Only a Death Roll,’’ and it is twenty-six pages long. Chapter xx., ‘‘Death—and Dyna- mite,’’ ushers another batch of distinguish- ed men to the shades; but this method of disposing of the dramatis persone of history sadly interferes with the march of events. No doubt such biographical notices help us to understand the times, but masses of post- mortem notices, arranged one after another without any connection with the rest of the book, cannot but suggest to the reader a biographical dictionary. One peculiarity the book has which is not common in works of this sort. As a gene- ral rule the historian endeavors to efface himself, and tell his story so that the read- er shall seem to hear only the voice of His- tory herself. If we want to know about Gibbon, or Macaulay, or Motley, we must seek for knowledge elsewhere than in the ‘Decline and Fall,’ the ‘History of England,’ or the ‘Rise of the Dutch Republic.’ In fact, in reading these works the reader's curiosi- ty is greatly aroused to know more of the author. In Mr. McCarthy's case, on the con- trary, the author puts himself with such naive good-will into his pages that at the end we know quite as much about him as about the history, and are quite satisfied on the point as to which so many historians leave us curious. We would undertake to prove by the internal evidence afforded by this volume that the author is of a most excellent, but somewhat superficial disposi- tion, sympathetic, humane, averse to do- mineering imposition of his will or his opi- nions upon others, and absolutely devoid of originality. He tells us his opinion of others’ opinions in such a way as to let us see that he has few of his own, except on one point, that of Ireland’s nationality, and even this seems to be rather a feeling or sentiment than a belief. He has acted with a party, and with a faction inside that party, for so long a time that, if he ever had the germs of criginal power, they have withered and shrivelled up for want of use. History is to him really a tale or drama which he personi- fies as a struggle between the Liberal party, or party of progress, and the Tories, or par- ty of reaction; everything that happens is an episode in this struggle, and the struggle itself chiefly important, at leastin these lat- ter days, as bearing on the Irish question, the real nature and position of which Mr. | McCarthy seems quite incompetent to de- scribe except as a sort of tale of wrong and liberation. If the reader can find out from Mr. McCarthy, for instance, what the author means by “Home Rule,” it is more than we have been able to do. There is a great deal, too, about land-law reform, but there [Vol. 65, No. 1684 is no clear account anywhere of what it has accomplished. Much of the reign of Queen Victoria has been a great party struggle for freedom; the whole of it, considered as a narrative, is | full of entertainment, but we fear that even | | admirers must admit that in this last vol- ume the capacities of the story have often been injured in the treatment. The best things in it are the accounts of the Brad- laugh episode, the Gladstone-Austria im- broglio, and the description of the career of the leader of the “Fourth Party,’ though whether Mr. McCarthy does not attribute to Lord Randolph Churchill a too serious quali- ty, we are much inclined to doubt. It is a pity that the author, in preserving one of his jokes, should not have mentioned what eminent pair of statesmen Lord Randolph had the hardihood to call ‘‘Marshall and Snelgrove.”’ Art and Life, and the Building and Decora- tion of Cities: A Series of Lectures by Members of the Arts and Crafts Exhibi- tion Society, delivered at the Fifth Exhi- bition of the Society in 1896. London: Rivington, Percival & Co. 1897. This new volume by members of the so- ciety whose long name appears in the title consists of five lectures, and therein differs markedly from its predecessor of 1893, in which a large number of short papers were bound up. It differs also from that volume in not having a long preface by William Morris. He has gone, and it does not yet appear who will replace him as the admitted chief of the Association. The first address begins with praise of Morris which must seem to many extravagant, as it is certainly unbounded. The word ‘“‘great’’ used in the largest sense, as it is here, and the state- ment that Morris was ‘‘too great to criti- cise, to judge,’’ would be so extravagant as to destroy any respect we might otherwise feel for the author of this address but for the fact that Morris had died on the opening day of the exhibition, October 3, 1896, and that such a circumstance as this might well excuse the undue enthusiasm. The first lecture is by T. J. Cobden San- derson, best known to Americans as a book- binder who has given minute and delicate handicraft and considerable power of design to the production of costly bindings. His address is an attempt to define and explain Art as orderly and seemly living, moral grandeur, noble individuality, and noble communal existence. The reader is partly prepared, by this, to find the noble intention accepted as the great result; to find little said of works of fine art or of the way they have been brought into being, but much of the fraternal and emotional spirit which fancies more than it can realize. ‘I imagine,’’ says Mr. Sanderson, ‘‘all men to be potentially artists.” Those of us who know that the vast majority of men are not artists at all, in the sense that they have not the perceptive faculties nor the power of artistic expression which are needed to make an artist, will set Mr. Sanderson down as an amiable dreamer. And yet he is more than that, as is proved by the admirable remark (p. 7), ‘Art has its origin in craft, and craft in the needs of life.” The second lecture, “Of Beautiful Cities,” is by W. R. Lethaby, one of the two authors of an admirable work on the Church of Sancta Sophia, at Constantinople, and author ee
Page 21
eee a Sa SAS eis aioe Swed: Wit Nisa SN Oct. 7, 1897] of an extremely useful and sensible book on architectural lead-work, as well as a book less easy to characterize, ‘Architecture, Mysticism and Myth,’ published in 1892. This lecture, much longer than the first, is largely descriptive. The author’s attempt has been to set before the modern reader, accustomed to ugly London, unorganized London, accidental and unadorned London, the beauty of the ancient and the medigwval city, as Athens and Jerusalem, Rome and Constantinople, thirteenth-century Paris and fourteenth-century London. Although this seems a somewhat ancient and time-worn subject for a lecture, and although there are those among our intelligent students of art who think, or who at least say, that the old commonplaces of good advice and sound criticism should be left to slumber, as hav- ing been said so often that they have lost their force, there is nevertheless enough to supply each new generation with the old advice and the old information, re- shaped for the new age. The difficulty of treating in an intelligent way the huge mo- dern city is as great now as it was thirty years ago; for, indeed, the cities and the reason communities which create them, grow faster | than our knowledge of how to handle this terrible problem possibly can. Walter Crane’s paper, “Of the Decoration of Public Buildings,’’ is less important, yet contains interesting hints in the course of description of some modern buildings and some modern mural paintings. Reginald Blomfield, one of the joint authors of that most valuable little book, ‘The Formal Gar den in England,’ gives the fourth address, “Of Public Spaces, Parks and Gardens,”’ and it is full of common sense. It seems that he and Mr. Lethaby must have put their heads together, so neatly does the fourth of these lectures carry on and develop the thoughts offered in the second. What “landscape architecture,’’ as our modern phrase is, can do for cities and towns is extraordinarily well suggested in this really valuable paper. Finally, Halsey Ricardo has treated “Of Color in the Architecture of Cities.’’ Here there is more difficulty, for no living man has seen color used successfully in external architecture in city or in country, and no one can imagine it except as the use of flower gardens may furnish color. Mr. Ri- cardo seems to perceive that the flower gar- den is his great chance, and attempts to translate the effect of flower gardens in city squares. John Checkley; or, The Evolution of Reli- gious Tolerance in Massachusetts. By the Rev. Edmund F. Slafter, D.D. Two vols Boston. 1897. (The Prince Society.) It is a distinct misfortune to the cause of literature that the publications of such book clubs as the Prince Society do not more often come out into the open and take the chances of life. As a matter of fact, they too seldom fall under the usual harrow of criticism, and, however great their merit, remain in the seclusion of private hands or on the shelves of a few large institutions They seem to enjoy the right of asylum rather than the privileges of a tested repu- tation. Dr. Slafter’s ‘John Checkley’ touches with a scholar’s care and with a partisan though not ill-natured severity upon an im- portant phase of New England history; but since his work in no sense enters the of literary competition, it may fairly claim lists | | | scandalous libel.’ The Nation. the indulgence of an undertaking which does not seek to be weighed on its merits. In all candor, however, there arises a reasona- ble doubt whether, if the accomplished edi- tor had subjected himself to the require- ments of the open market, he would have allowed himself so much freedom and so lit- tle restraint and compactness, more parti- cularly in the memoir of his subject. The ‘persecution’ of John Checkley in Boston during the early twenties of the last century is not a well-remembered incident. Checkley was by birth a New Englander, Oxford-bred, a non-juror, and a devoted pre- pagandist of the Establishment in the colo- His citadel was a small book-shop just opposite what is now the Old State- house; from this admirable site for any sort of enterprise he projected weapons calculat- ed to hurt, In the shape, mostly, of reprints of forensics by English divines. The hea- ordnance was Charles Leslie's ‘Short and Easy Method with the Delists’; but Checkley did not fail to discharge a few lighter shafts of his own fashioning. For these various assaults upon the bulwarked faith of later Puritanism, Checkley was made to appear at the Court of Sessions, and, on appeal, at the Superior Court of Judicature and Assize. Before a court of which Samuel Sewall was Chief Justice, a protagonist of that black beast Episcopacy come off worsted, and Checkley fined £50 for publishing and selling a ‘false and Nothing could have been more strict than the adherence of the prose- cution to the observance of law, but the spi- rit of liberty was on Checkley’s side and not on theirs, and he, who at the time show- ed more than anything else a predilection for getting into trouble, remains in memory a martyr to intolerance. Some years later, not without opposition, he received orders in the Church of England, and ended his days as rector of King’s Church, now St. John’s, in Providence, Rhode Island, ever a haven against intolerance (though some would except the year of our Lord 1897) But with his trial ends the public career ot Checkley; at most he was an incident and not an epoch of our earlier days a nies. viest was sure to was It is easier to share Dr. Slafter’s uncon- cealed indignation at Checkley’s persecu- tion than to follow his admiration for Check- That the Boston bookseller was persistent and courageous is undenia- ble; but neither his letters nor his printed remains proclaim him the rich scholar and man of conspicuous parts that his apolo- gist so readily discerns. It is from a modern point of view that Dr. Slafter sees his hero ley’s abilities. loom so large. The story, however, ie a clear illustration of the determination of New England to resist any ecclesiastical encroachments, great or small. There was intolerance, but, as on Checkley’s side, there was no want of good courage. Dr. Slafter has discharged a volley at the already well- assailed Puritau. but. as we have not un- pleasantly meant to say, from behind the That socie- ty’s reputation for making a handsome book is again sustained. It ever, that Benjamin Colm as Coleman, and Peter e! Perhaps the editor these familiar names; otherwise such errors are the more to be regretted in a work not raniparts of the Prince Society is to be noticed, how- h’s name is given hacher's as Thatch- has new light on subject to revision Slafter's “Bibliography of the in America Relating to Episoo- 285 pacy, 1719-1774," in volume il., students will have cause to be grateful The subject, which ts to increase in interest, receives an impulse from so excellent an array of titles ; Vontaigue, and Other Essays. Carlyle. Now first collected word by S. R. Crockett J. B. Lippincott Co. 1897 By Thomas With Fore- Philadelphia No one who raises himself out of obdscu- rity and narrow means by the sole use of his pen escapes the experience of hack work Afterwards, when independence and recog- the author is glad to forget his incunabula. Dr. Johnson's dis- inclination to be reminded of his Street performances is nition come, successful Grub notorious, and Car poor of his Encyclopedia.” He to republish them; lyle had a opinion articles in Brewster's never cared and Froude’s judgment conveyed in a footnote, was probably a re flection of his master’s final feeling on the subject. The sketches in question, he says ‘are little more than exercises A pub lisher now rises up to dispute this censure by reprinting in collected form some seven teen essays written in 1821, and paid for by those checks of Sir David Brewster which Ecclefechan in by true filial of Carlyle’s made their way to susvested piety In the own adverse criticism it must has the intro- he th le Oy the led to bibliographical instinct which the adve of Mr , reverence for the present although concluding words Crockett's duction breathe young This early work, hav prophet undisclosed ing been rescued from the ‘“‘densely-piled double-columned débris of the ‘Edinburgh Encyclopedia,” may now stand printed plain ¥ man's for the even these The fate of just ob- and fair on an né shelf who, sake of the full-fed herd, firstlings of the flock.”’ loves livion has overtaken other articles of equal or greater merit which were contributed to ho 29 > , . tay the same compendium, much would have thought and we very doubt whether any one it worth his pains to unearth such forgotten this not an that collects ephemerides with the same typographical care it bestows But are apa- this scheme we papers were age postage-stamps and _ reprints on masterpieces while we particular in dismissing Carlyle’s early when they pre- once are sented to us, without at least a word of omment The author of ‘Sartor,’ writing in stilted eighteenth-century phrase, presents the spectacle of Pegasus attached to a plough, or, perhaps, more fitly, to a_ threshing- the through the azure of his own disquisition, with hanical trudge on the moving gangway of the ‘Encyclop@#dia’: ‘“‘The fire- baptized soul, long so scathed and thunder- riven, here freedom ; which feeling is its Baphometic baptism: the cita- le] of its whole kingdom it has thus gained and will inexpugnable; outwards from which the remaining domi- indeed without hard battering, will doubtless by degrees be conquered and pacificated.”” And over against this a sen- tence from the ‘Encyclopedia’ notice of Mungo Park’s life: ‘‘The evils of an African journey were distant in place, and becoming more distant in time, while the disquietudes hin Contrast the action of easy steed as he wanders at will ase me feels its own assault keep nions, not of his present situation had the painful quality of presence and reality, and he
Page 22
286 turned from them with disgust to contem- plate the more exalted prospects which ima- gination delighted to picture in the scene of his former adventures.’’ Carlyle struck his own gait in ten years from the time he be- gan to publish. A wider vocabulary and a more etymological use of words are the first signs of difference between him and the or- dinary digester of facts. There is no evi- dence of a special desire to avoid trite ex- pressions or constructions. With the length of his composition prescribed, the youth of twenty-six went through his books of refer- ence, arranged an intelligible abstract, and delivered goods of an expected size and quality. The field being an easy one to work, the essays were turned out with very considerable rapidity. The subjects are either men or districts. Arranged alphabetically, they extend from M to P; from Montaigne to William Pitt, the Younger. Carlyle was fortunate in hav- ing worthies only to portray, and the chief interest of the series springs from its reve- lation of his attitude towards the Great Man. By itself his constant praise may seem commonplace. Considered in the light of his teaching it is significant. His reputa- tion having suffered somewhat from reac- tion, we are prone to forget the extent of his contemporary influence. One finds the zerm of that stimulating effect he had on young men in his early enthusiasm for Mon- tesquieu, Necker, Nelson, and the Pitts. The article on Nelson ends as follows: ‘“‘The pe- riod is advancing when the naval supe- riority which he completed will pass away; but Nelson’s name will always occupy a section in the history of the world, and be pronounced, wherever it is understood, as that of a Hero.” One requires but a modicum of biographi- cal knowledge to perceive that these notices are incomplete. The modern editor of a good encyclopedia would demand more spe- cialized information than Carlyle then pos- sessed on the majority of his themes. The omission of notable facts and considera- tions, the misspelling of names, etc., fits in well with the general air of an abridgment. School manuals of literary criticism have a way of comparing Macaulay and Carlyle. The former shows off to advantage if one puts his contributions to the ‘Encyclopedia Britannica’ beside the latter’s contributions to the ‘Edinburgh Encyclopedia.’ To be sure, Macaulay wrote for his friend Adam Black in the fulness of his powers, and treated subjects with which he had long been conversant, while Carlyle is at the dis- udvantage of immaturity and unfavorable circumstances. But regarded intrinsically, there is no comparison. Macaulay’s sketches are models of their kind. A forward stu- dent in the Harvard Graduate School might hope to equal those of Carlyle. One notes particularly the extent to which his opi- nions on the French Revolution changed. Under Necker, Nelson, and William Pitt he has occasion to touch upon its principles and personages. Of Necker’s decline in popularity after his return from Basel, he says: ‘‘With the most earnest desire to act uprightly and honourably, he soon found it impossible to unite an attention to the real interests of the State with the favor of an excited and ignorant mob, perpetually mis- led by wicked agitators, yet drunk with its new-found power, and indulging the most chimerical expectations from the actual pos- ture of affairs,"’ 7 The Nation. We can discover no reasons for the re- publication of these articles other than sen- timental regard for everything that Carlyle did, and the bibliographical desire to pre- sent his writings in their entirety. The Voyage of the Mayflower, Penned and Pictured by Blanche McManus. New York: E. R. Herrick & Co. 1897. Pp. viii, 72. In these days of wide-extended, if often superficial, interest in our colonial begin- nings, it is not surprising that effort is made to present our early history with the maxi- mum of external attractiveness. Such a vol- ume, designed, one would suppose, for a fashionable drawing-room table, rather than the shelf of a student of New England his- tory, is the one before us. The author and illustrator declares her purpose to be ‘‘that even, to those who are interested beyond the limits of these few pages, will be presented a new view of the susceptibility of artistic treatment and ensemble of historical briefs relating to any subject likely to prove of general or widespread interest.’’ With the two-fold intent thus indicated, in which we may presume the artistic is the stronger motive, the author’s pencil has ornamented a brief narrative of the Pilgrim movement from the flight into Holland to the arrival of the Charity at Plymouth in 1624. The sketches which fill the upper third of every page are effectively decorative in black and white, borrowing their motive from sugges- tions of the text below. To the whole the skill of the printer has given an attractive setting. The accompanying text is of the slightest, and would scarcely call for comment did not the “Apologia’’ prefixed speak of it as “terse but authoritative,’’ and claim the volume as not merely “original in its incep- tion,’’ but ‘correct in fact.’’ Certainly such an assertion is far too pretentious unless reference be had only to the broad general outlines of the familiar story. The author, for instance, in referring to the Pilgrim church, speaks of William Brewster as ‘‘or- dained their pastor’; certainly his well- known title of “ruling-elder’’ might have put her on her guard. She represents the Sepa- ratists as already fled to Holland in 1575 under Robert Browne—an event which did not take place till 1581. It is surprising to read of the Pilgrims at Leyden that ‘‘their church received no further recruits from England and was not increased by proselytes from Holland,’’ when one recalls —to mention no others—how a member of such later distinction as Edward Winslow joined them in 1617. Nor is the author more accurate in reproducing as familiar a series of names as those of the signers of the Compact and of the Mayflower’s passengers. Besides an indiscriminate application of the then significant title ‘‘Mr.’’ to all the signers except three, the more striking because William Bradford is left (in company with John Alden) without such distinction, there are several omissions in the list of emi- grants, while Desire Minter masquerades as Winter, John and Francis Billington as Bellwright, and John Turner’s son is enter- ed as his wife. A similar want of accuracy leads the author to date the introduction of cattle into Plymouth 1622, rather than 1624; and one queries whether she could have realized the immense amount of labor that would have been involved had the statement been true that the Mayflower was “towed [| Vol. 65, No. 1084 over to her anchorage for the winter,” 4. ¢., from Provincetown to Plymouth harbor. It is no less surprising to find Peregrine White described as a “daughter to William and Susan White’’—a change of sex which a glance at any competent compendium of Pilgrim history would have avoided. Mercy Warren. By Alice Brown. [Women of Colonial and Revolutionary Times.] With Portrait. Charles Scribner’s Sons. This book has been called out, in large measure, by the immensely increased inte- rest in past times aroused by the eagerness to join the so-called ‘‘patriotic-historical” societies. It is an attempt, enthusiastic and industrious, to bring before us in vivid outline one of the most prominent women of the first generation of American inde- pendence—matron, poet, historian, contro- versialist. The attempt is but partly suc- cessful. The lack of materials is admitted. Mrs. Warren’s voluminous correspondence ran insatiably into moral and political apho- risms instead of personal incidents, and her biographer confesses that she has laid on the details of the picture pretty thick from her general information about the age. She has io ‘‘suppose”’ and ‘‘fancy’’ a good deal. Apparently Miss Brewn’s object is to make the present generation more familiar with their great-grandmothers, and draw away the sort of stiff lustre that surrounds them, like saints in early Tuscan pictures. To effect this object, she writes in a strange style, a sort of cross between Stanley Wey- man and a Washington correspondent, al- ternately gushing over the sentiment in Mrs. Warren’s life, and making fun of its quaint solemnities. We are particularly introduced to misplaced capitals and false spellings in her letters, as if we could ap- preciate her character any better from see- ing her MS. printed in a way no printer of her time would have let it pass. As a result, Mrs. Warren appears in these pages not so much in her own character, as the prima donna of a modern play, acted by very modern performers, and enlivened by modern gags. The biographer seems to have gauged very correctly the value of Mrs. Warren’s litera- ry compositions; but these cannot have either their merits or their faults appre- ciated without a much more thorough know- ledge of eighteenth-century writers than this book shows. Pope is mentioned; but no knowledge is betrayed that the lines which Mrs. Warren puts as a prologue on the title- page of ‘‘The Group” are taken from one of bis best-known satires. Addison’s ‘‘Cato”’ is never even mentioned; yet it continued to be a special favorite in American house- holds as long as Mrs. Warren lived, and suggested the name Marcia, which resem- bled Mercy only by accident. Several times Mrs. Warren is called Mercy Otis War- ren. Is there any evidence that this prac- tice of preserving the maiden name existed at all in her lifetime? We have seen John Adams's wife called in modern writing Abi- gail Smith Adams; but she never wrote her name so herself. In those days, as in Eng- land now, a married woman dropped her own name when she took her husband’s. With the Trade Winds. A Jaunt in Venezue- la and the West Indies. By Ira Nelson Morris. G. P. Putnam’s Sons. 1897. The author of this little volume, whose eS Ti
Page 23
Oct. 7, 1897] preface describes it as a ‘‘desultory account” of his observations during a recent winter tour, is, to judge by the frontispiece, a young man, but he has avoided the fault, common among young observers of men and manners, of being too critical. He sticks throughout to description, and, tracing his footsteps through that part of the region traversed with which we are most familiar, we find him a pleasant, if somewhat imma- ture, travelling companion. There are, as he says in his preface, so few books in Eng- lish about the northern part of South Ame- rica that every new one is of interest. We note one or two points which have struck us. Mr. Morris found the harbor of La Guayra no longer an open roadstead, the great breakwater so long projected having been finally built. He notices that ‘one of the greatest disadvantages the present government has to contend with is the ex- istence of contracts and agreements entered into by the previous ruler, Guzman Blanco, with various corporations and syndicates, which are thoroughly impracticable.’’ This, however, is a chronic difficulty in Venezue- la. Caracas is evidently improving, for our traveller can speak of his ‘comfortable quarters at the Grand Hotel,’”’ and he in- sists, with Mr. R. H. Davis, on that capital being ‘‘the Paris of South America.’”’ Ame- rican interests he declares to be ‘‘steadily growing’ in Venezuela, but gives no proof. He makes the surprising statement that the people of Venezuela ‘‘do not seem to know what we would call a good horse,’’ the fact being that what we call a good horse is of The Nation. a totally different breed from theirs, and cannot be acclimated, certainly not without great difficulty. His account of the behavior of the sefioritas leads to the inference that the habits of South America are changing faster than we supposed. Can it be that they sit in the windows, directly on the street, “arrayed in becoming toilets, observ- ing the passers-by aml chatting with their friends’? In our time they were not visi- ble, though they might have been observing the passers-by from behind the shutters. Elsewhere Mr. Morris says that on Thurs- day evenings, when the band plays in the Plaza, the sefioritas ‘respond to their suit- ors,"" “‘coquettishly wandering in the sha- dows.”’ He explains this by saying that “North American customs’ have been intro- duced into Caracas; but we believe he has been misled, owing to the fact that Spanish- American customs are in this respect pecu- liar. Sefloritas are to be met with, no doubt, in the Plaza in the evening, because it is a common meeting-place for every one, but the mother or chaperone of the young lady takes pretty good care that she shall not wander off into the shadows. Such at least was the case consule Blanco BOOKS OF THE WEFK Allen, F. H. Hotere’ Diary. Boston: Houghton Mifflin & Co. $1.2 American Newspaper “annual, ISv7. Philadelphia N. W Ayer & Son Armour, Margaret The Fall of the Nibelungs London: Dent; New York: Macmillan. $2.50 Boswell, James. The Life of Johnson. {Temple Classics.}] Vol. 3. London: Dent; New York Macmillan. 50c Cargill, J. F. The Chicago: Big-Horn Treasure. $1.25. A. C. McClurg & Co. 287 Dollivet, Louts. Sale Juif! Paris: A Colin & Ole Farrow, +h. E. The Missing Prince. Dodd, Mead & Co 1.& Filon, alennte. The English ~y x een John Milne; New York: Dodd, Mead & Co. George, 4 Coleridge's * oo tent AK ae Reston: D. C. Heath & Co. & Hocking, Joseph. The Birthright, Dedd, Mead & Co. 1.25 Hume, M. A. S. Philip Il. of Spain. Macmillan Hietere. c. W. The Story of Language. Chicago: A CC. MeClurg & Co. $1.50 Kipling, Radvard en tury Co. $1.50. Lee, Sidney lMectionary of National eee Vol. Lil, Shearman-—Smirke. Macmillan TS Macdonald, George. Salted with whe: A Story of a Minister. Thadd, Mead & Co Mathew, Frank. A Child In the Teuste John Lane, $1 MeKay, Angus M. Dodd, Mead & Co. Monvel, RBoutet de Century Co : Munroe, Kirk hers $1.25 Nicoll, W. R. James Macdonell, Mead & Co. $2.75 Oberholtzer, EB. P. The New Man Levytype Co. $1 Pearson, H. G. Freshman PD. C. Heath & Co. We Penney, W. E Saliede ‘of Yankee Land Crowell & Co $1& Robdinser, CH vane Cavatic T. Neely Podmore, Frank. Studies in Pay hical Researc? Putnams. $2 Sargent, Lieut H. The Campaign of Marengo Cc hieago: A. C. McClurg & Co. $1.50 ouler Prof James Constitutional Studies State aml Federal, Dodd, Mead & Coe $1.40 Shelley, H. C. The Ayrshire Homes and Haunte of Rurns. Putnams. $1.23 Smith, G. B The United States of Colonization Tkald, Mead Smythe. Alfred. Van Hoff; or American Publishers Corporation “Captains Courageous."’ The Brontés: Fact and Fiction $1. Joan Illustrated of Are Rowte. Serid Dodd, Philadelptia $38 With Crockett and Journalist Boston: = ¥ Com position ~ _ H Se (The Rew & 4 $i & The New Faust $i Annee Spenser, Fdmund. The Faerie Queene. Ilustrat ed..2 vols. Londen: Dent; New York: Macmil lan. $18 Stickney, Albert State Control of Trade and Commerce by National or State Authority. Ra . Veorhis & Co. $3.25 Tompkins, Prof. Arnold. The Sctence of Discourse Reston: Ginn & Co Tyler, Prof. M. C. The Literary History of the American Revolation, Vol. IL. 177617838. Put- names. $3 Winternit M The Mantranpat wr, The Praver Rook of the Apastambing { Anecdota Oxonten sia Oxford Clare mion Press; New York: Hea ry Frowde “The leading educational journal of the country.”— Congregattonalist. “No teacher of any grade can possibly afford to go without reading it.’ —The Dial. OCTOBER EDUCATIONAL REVIEW. ARTICLES —Classification and Instruction in Rural Schools, by Wm. Harris; The New Harvard E-- trance Requirements, by Albert Bushnell Hart; The Scope of the Science of Education. bv J. J. Findlay; Present-Day.Problems in the Education of Women, by Marion Talbot; The Spirit of the Practice School, by Wilhelm Rein; Some Aspects of Drawing. by M.V. O’Shea, and On Teaching Argumentation, by G. J. Smith. REVIEWS. EDITORIAL $3 per year (monthly, excepting July and August). 35 cents acopu. Contents, Vels. I. XUIL., free. HENRY HOLT & CO., 20 W. 23d St, New York; Laced Wabesh 4 Ave , Chic ago. HATCHARDS. This is the favorite BOOKSTORE, and for 100 years the resort of the smartest people in London. It is visited and patronized by all who love books. London is the great market for books, and all the best as well as the cheap- est editions can be had by writing here. Special collections formed, and fuller information sup- plied than from any other house. Books, both old and new, and relating to any subject, can readily be supplied, at very moderate prices. Agents for Clubs, Libraries, and all private collectors. 187 PICCADILLY, _Lonpon, W. London Weekly Circular of Rare. Choice. and Curious English Books from well-known libra- ries sold in ee this season. Sent gratis ne . Hagemann, 160 Sth Ave., N plication by H. W ROBERT E. LEE AND THE SOUTHERN CONFEDERACY. 1807-1870. By HENRY ALEXANDER WHITE, M A., Pb.D., Professor of History inv the Washington and Lee University. No. 22 in the ‘*Heroes of the Nations Series.’ Fully illustrated. Large 12mo, cloth, $1 50; half leather, gilt top, $1.75. Caer Coxtests: Birth — Family — Education Marriage—Secession and Slavery—The Crisis of 1861—In Command of the Forces in West Virginia —The Seven Days’ Battles in Defence of Richmond (1862)—The Campaign in Maryland—The Capture of Harper's Ferry—The Battle of Fredericksburg The Campaigns of Gettysburg, Petersburg. and Appomattox—Lee as President of the Washington College. Prof. White's biography of the great Contede- rate general is written from a Southern stand- point. His work will, however, appeal to all, whether north or south of “Mason and Dixon's Line, as the record of an American whose no- bility of character and soldierly qualities are un- questioned. G.P. PUTNAM’S SONS | NEW YORK AND LONDON. Dr. Jaeger’ S Sanitary Underwear Fits ph erp Ma toes, all weig possible Aerck W This means for vou the greatest com omen fort you have ever expertenced per fect freedom of limb, and the best fit possible for your dresses M This means for you Warmth, Cemfoert, CM eaten. Boys and Girls ' the fear of taking cold. Babi This means for them freedom from es . » Ie and cold, and assures happiness Sead for Lllustrated Catalogue to the mother MAIN RETAIL STORE Branches ‘or you It means the delicious enjoyment of outdoor sporte without 16 W. 23d St., 166 Broadway. New York. 248 W. 125th St. Reading for Recreation Should not be confined to light literature. Busy people who want rest for mind and body need something worth thinking about The German-Roman Year in the Chautauqua Reading Circle offers an interesting plan. More than 250,000 readers have been enrolled in the Circle. Send for full information to JOHN H. VINCENT, 26 Genessce St., Buffalo, N.Y. ALE MIXTURE. The choicest tobacco made, and preeminently a gentleman's smoke. Marburg Bros., The American Tobacco Co., Successor, Baltimore, Md.
Page 24
288 APPLETON’ Ss Popular Science Monthly. OCTOBER, 1897. Franklin's Kite Experiments with Modern Appa- ratus. ALEXANDER McAopix. Illustrated. A reproduction of Franklin's epoch-making ex- periments by means of modern apparatus, and a discussion of the kite as an instrument for meteo rological investigation. Science at the University of Chicago. Prof FREDERICK Stark. Illustrated. Describes and pictures the men and buildings de voted to the teaching of science in the newest of our great universities. The Psychology of Belief. W. B. Parker. An interesting and instructive discussion of this curious trait of the human mind, which might almost be called an instinct. FPree-Hand Drawing in Education. H. G. Fitz. Illustrated. Shows the importance of this subject when pro- perlv taught, and its absolute uselessness as ordi- narily presented to the child. A Decade in Federal Railway Regulation. H. T. NEWCOMB. Shows how futile the famous interstate commerce law has been in checking the evils which led to its passage, and points out its radical defects. Early American Chemical Societies. H.C. Bo.Ton. A brief historical sketch of the origins and aims of what were practically the first scientific societies in this country. Other articles: The Racial Geography of Europe IX, Italy; Some Unrecognized Laws of Nature; The Idea of Murder among Men ani Animals; Prin- cipals of Taxation—XI, Present Methods; The Eco- nomic Value of Animals; and Sketch (with Por- trait) of Louis Figuier, astronomer. Editor’s Table; Scientific Literature; Fragments of Science; Notes. 50 cents a number; $5.00 a year, D. APPLETON AND COMPANY, 72 Fifth Avenue, New York. William Lloyd Garrison, 1805-1879. The Story of his Life told by his Children. Illustrated with over 40 portraits, views, etc. 4 vols., 8vo, gilt top, $8.00 net. This important work (till recently published by the Century Company) has been reduced in price from $12 00 to $8.00, a remarkably low price for what is unquestionably one of the handsomest products ofthe American press. *\ A biography of almost world wide importance. It will be a standard work of reference "— Charle ston News and Courier. ‘*In fact, Southern history is not complete with- out this work.’’—Atlanta Const.tution. ‘It is, forthe anti slavery record, final; and the service done to our national history is as great as that toa father’s memory. Its one eminent trait, however, is its justice.”— Atlantic Monthly. *A masterpiece of m dern historical eon eB | To call the work a mine of information would be to convey a false impression; it is rather a well- arranged library in which attendant hands are al- ways present to point the way to the exact thing wanted . . . Finally, the work, while as in- structive as the driest manual, is as interesting as a romance.*'— Boston Advertiser. *,* For sale by bo pksellers. Sent, postpaid, on receipt of price by the Publishers, HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN BOSTON AND New YORK. & CO., | | | | | | | | ‘Lhe Nation. [Vol. 65, No. 1684 FALL ANNOUNCEMENTS THE OPEN COURT PUBLISHING CO. DARW'N AND AFTER DARWIN AN EXPOSITION OF THE DARWINIAN THEO- RY, AND A DISCUSSION OF POST-DARWIN- IAN QUESTIONS. By the late GEORGE JOHN ROMANES, M.A., LL.D.,. F.R.S., Honorary Fel- low ¢ ae and Caius College, Cambridge. PART III. POST-DARWINIAN UESTIONS., ISOLATION AND PHYSIOLOGICAL SELEC- TION. Pages 181. 8vo. Price $1.00. With Por- trait of Mr. G. T. Gulick. ‘The best single volume (Part I.) on the general subject that has appeared since Darwin's time.’’— American Naturalist. BUDDHISM AND ITS CHRISTIAN CRITICS. By DR. PAUL CARUS. 8vo. Pages, circa, 300. Price, $1.25. POPULAR SCIENTIFIC LECTURES. By ERNST MACH, Professor in the University of Vienna. Second Edition, revised and greatly enlarged. S8vo. Prges 380. 48 Cuts. Price, | $1.00 net. “Has scarcely a rival in the whole realm of popular scientific writing.’’—[ Boston Traveller. MARTIN LUTHER. By GUSTAV FREYTAG. &vo. Pp. 133. Paper covers; ‘Religion of Science Library’’ edition. Price, 25 cents. Illustrated Cloth Edition, large S8vo. $1.00. “Gustav Freytag has made the history of the great reformer as interesting as a novel.’’—[New Orleans Picayune. THE MONIST (A Quarterly Magazine). Devoted to the Philosophy of Science. CON‘ ENTS FOR OCTOBER. 1897. THE REALITIES OF EXPERIENCE. By Prof. | ©. Lloyd Morgan, Bristol, Eng ON ISOLATION IN ORGANIC EVOLUTION. A | Posthumous Essay. By the late George John | Romanes. ON THE ORIGIN OF ok sna By Prof. Th. Eimer, Tubingen, Germa MAN AS A MEMBER OF ‘SOCIETY. Dr. Paul | Topinard, Paris, France PROF tate S. MAX MPL LER'’S THEORY OF THE SELF. By Dr. Paul Carus. ON SENSATIONS OF ORIENTATION, By Prof. Ernst Mach, Vienna, Austria. ia CORRESPONDENCE, BOOK RE- VS, ete. Single Copies, 50 cents. Annually, $2.00; in the U, 2; 0, @; 6a. CONTENTS of OCTOBER OPEN COURT Devoted to the Religion of Science and the Science of Religion. FRONTISPIECE: Johann Wolfgang von Goethe. Municipal Life in New Zealand. By the Hon. Sir Robert Stout, K.C.M.G., and Ex-Premier of New Zealand. History of the People of Israel, From the Begin- ning to the Destruction of Jerusalem. Fourth Ar- ticle. Solomon.—The Division of the Kingdom. By Dr. C. H. Cornhill, Professor of Theology in the University of Konigsberg. The Mission Ruins of California. By J. M. Secanland. he Personality of God. Correspondence between Pere Hyacinthe Loyson and Dr. Paul Carus. Biographical Sketch of Goethe. Miscellaneous. Book Reviews, Notes, etc. Every issue contains as a frontispiece a portrait of a distinguished thinker and writer in the field of philosophy and religion. Illustrated. “Monthly. Single Copies, 10 cents. Annually, $1.00. Chicago: The Open Court Publishing Company, 324 DEARBORN ST. Sex Worship: AN EXPOSITION OF THE PHALLIC ORIGIN OF RELIGION. By CLIFFORD HowarbD. A work of rare atd curious information concerning the ancient worship of the procre- ative powers, and demonstrating that the va. rious religious faiths of the world have had a common origin, and are founded upon this universal primitive mode of worship. “A remarkable book.”—dllegheny Record. “Many strange beliefs and stranger customs are touchediupen in this work ’—Brookiyn Eagle. “a volume whose contents will surprise most peo ple.”—Inaianapolis Sentinel. 12mo, cloth, $1.25 net. Limited Edition. Sent, postpaid, on receipt of price. CLIFFORD HOWARD,’ Publisher, P, 0. Box 633, Washington, D.C. Publications i in French. Attention is called to the following series of re- prints, as of great value to the student as well as to the general reader of French. Romans Choisis. 12mo, paper, 60 cents; cloth, 85 cents. No. 17. SANS FAMILLE. Par Hector Ma.or Abr dged and arranged for school use by Prof. P. Berey, B.L,LD. 430 pages. No. 18. COSIA. By Axpre MicHe, Duranp. 165 pages. Complete catalogue on application. For sale by all book- sellers, or postpaid on receipt of price by the publisher, William R. Jenkins 851 and 853 Sixth Ave. (48th St.), New York. Old and Rare Books. FIRST EDITIONS, etc., ete., FOR SALE, AN ILLUSTRATED CATALOGUE OF. PART 2, with | Seventy-one Reproductions of Plates. Titie-pages, etc., ete. Works relating to the Civil War and | Cromwell, Coaching, Cookery, Costume, Queen | Elizabeth, Freemasonry, Gardening. Books chiefly first editions, by Charles Cotton, Abraham Cow- ley, William Cowper, Daniel Defoe, Charles Dickens, Dr. John Donne, Michael Drayton, John Dryden, Thomas Durfey, Jobn Evelyn, Henry Fielding. FIRST EDITIONS of books illustrated ' by George and Robert Cruikshank, Richard Doyle, and Harry Furniss, and a large collection of cu- rious Facetiw. Part 2. 8vo, 74 pages, post free, 1s. PICKERING & CHATTO, 66 HAYMARKET, LONDON, _S. \ a FE; lua and a BOOKS | | The Latest French and German Books Are promptly imported and kept for sale. All Standard Works continually in Stock, Write for New List of Late Fiction. BRENTANO’S, 31 Union Square, New York. LIBRARIES. Library Catalogue Mailed Free. LISTS PRICED GRATIS. THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO., Wholesele Books, 5 & 7 East 16th St., New York. F. W. CHRISTERN (DYRSEN & PFEIFFER, Successors), 429 5th Ave., between 28th and 29th Sts., New York, Importers of Foreign Books: Agents for the leading Paris Publishers; Tauchnitz’s British Authors. Teub ner’s Greek and Latin Classics. Catalogues of stock mailed on demand. New books received from Paris and Leipzig as soon as issued. WILLIAMS, 25 EAST 10TH ST., « N. Y., Dea er in Magazines and other Periodi- _ Sets, volumes, or single num bers. AGAZINE OF AMERICAN HISTO- ry. Asetin numbers; clean, unused. $75. A.S. CLARE, 174 Fulton § Street, New York. UTOGRAPH LETTERS OF CELEB- RITIES and BOOK-PLATES, Send for Catalogue. WALTER ROMEYN BENJAMIN, 1125 Broadway, N. Y. City. KIN DERGARTEN supPLiEs at SCHERMERHORN’S, 3 East 14th Street, N. Y. Send for new Catalogue. Reading Case for the Nation, To receive the current numbers in a convenient (temporary) form. Substantially made, bound in cloth,with The Nation stamped on the side in gold. Holds about one volume. Papers easily and neatly | adjusted. Sent, postpaid, on receipt of 75 cents # ¥ Si EB Spencers Kin ROR mepasetntReRS Say _— re ee hee in eng YR RIOR At
Page 25
ihe Oct. 7, 1897] The Nation. Vv ee THE WORMELEY EDITION. LA COMEDIE HUMAINE HONORE DE BALZAC. Translated by Katharine Prescott Wormeley. TRANSLATION. By the most competent liv- ing trausiator of Balzac, preserving all the original flavor, vigor, and delicacy of the original. ILLUSTRATIONS. Seven in each volume, on vellum plate paper, with replicas on India paper. Made by twenty of the best French artists for this edition only, reproduced in Goupil-gravure. PAPER. Best Dutch, hand-made, light, soft, exioie, each sheet with special water-mark, ‘*H, de B.” BINDING. Polished linen buckram, better than leather, gilt top, deckle edges, back titles forming complete index. PRICE. 250 sets only, 40 volumes each, royal octavo. $500 per volume. Subscriptions received for complete sets only. DESCRIPTIVE VOLUME. With each set, without charge, 0/uud to match, contain- ing half-tone portraits of the twenty ar- tists, Miss Wormeley’s ‘‘Arrangement of the English and French Titles.” Sugges- tions on the order in which to read Balzac. The complete set is ready for immediate de- livery on very favorable terms. Quick application should be made for the few remaining sets of this magnificent work. Circulars and full information free of the publishers ROBERTS BROTHERS, 3 Somerset St., Boston, Mass. NEW YORK: 156 Fifth Avenue. CHICAGO: [icDonnell Bros., 279 Dearborn St, MIND CULTURE how to think, read, study and ob- serve —an tdea- systematizger — the greatest work of modern times— WHEREWITHAL It is called a “seven-word, seven-minute method of education, ” has ‘the beauty of sim- plicity.”” One prominent instructor says, “It’s 400 years ahead of time.”” New ideas—none of the hackneyed, confusing present day methods. Applying to any conceivable ques- tion from every conceivable point of view. Citizens’ edition, handsomely bound, $1.00. Descriptive circular free. School edition, reduced price in quantities. THE WHEREWITHAL BOOK CO., Bourse Building. Philadelphia, Pa. HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO.’S NEW BOOKS Tre Revolt of a Daughter. A thoroughly interesting and charm- ingly written love story, by ELLEN OLNEY Kirk, author of “The Story of Margaret Kent,” ‘‘ Ciphers,”’ *‘ Walford,” ‘“‘A Lesson in Love,” etc. 16mo, $1.25. aron in the Wildwoods. A delightfui new Thimblefinger story of Aaron while a ‘ runaway,” by JoEL CHAN- DLER Harris, author of * Little Mr. Thim- blefinger and his Queer Country,” ‘“‘ Mr. Rab- bit at Home,” ‘“‘The Story of Aaron,” etc. With 24 full-page illustrations by OLIVER HERFORD. Square 8vo, 22.00. A Browning Courtship. and Other Stories. A group of charming short stories, by ELiza ORNE WHITE, author of ‘* Winterborough,” “The Coming of Theodora,” ‘* When Molly was Six,” “A Little Girl of Long Ago,” ete. 16mo, $1.25. Hawthorne's First Diary. With an Account of its Discovery and Loss. By SamMvuEL T. PicKarb, author of ‘Tbe Life of John Greenleaf Whittier.” With four illustrations of scenes in Raymond, Maine, frequented by Hawthorne when a boy. Imo, $1.00. Sold by all Booksellers. Sent, postpaid, by HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO., Boston. 11 East 17th Street, New York. To receive the current numbers tn a convent ent (temporary) form Substantially made, boundin cloth, with Tre NATION stamped on the side in gold. Holds about ene volume. Papers easily and neatly ad justed. Sent, postpaid, on receipt of 75 cents ‘The Workers’”’ THE TRUTH ABoUT THE Laportnc-MAN COLLEGE GRADUATE y WHO BECAME A DAY LA- BORER TO LEARN THE LIFE OF THE STORY OF HIS TWO TELLS YEARS’ THE WORKINGMAN \CTUAL EXPERIENCES IN . Scribners’ Magazine NEW BOOKS. Robert E. Lee, And the Southern Confederacy. 1867 1870 By Henry ALExaNDER Ware, M.A, Ph.D., Professor of History in the Wash- ington and Lee University. No Win the Heroes of the Nations Series. Fulty illus trated. Large Imo, cloth, $1.50; half leather, gilt top, $1.75. Prof. White's biography of the great Confederate General is written from a Southern standpomt His work will, however, appeal to all, whether north or south of Mason's and Dixon's line, as the record of an American whose nobility of character and soldierly qualities are unquestioned. Ulysses S. Grant And the Period of National Preservation and Reconstruction, 1822188). By WiItLitaw Conant Cuurcn, Lt. Col. U. S. Vols, author of * Life of Jotn Ericsson.” No 21 in the Heroes of the Nations Series. Fully illustrated. Large 12 no, cloth, $1.50; half leather, gilt top, $1 75 “Itis written by an expert tactician, whose know ledge of the technical problems which Grant solved in such a masterly way has enabied him to write « work which will satisfy those who are seeking for a brief, succinct statement of the eawsential faces in the career of the greatest general of ar Civil War The work ts tllustrated with maps and portraits that add to its value aad attractiveness.’ Ne Vugre gationalist Pratt Portraits. Sketched in a New England Suburb. by ANNA FULLER. New holiday edition, with 18 illustrations by GEORGE SLOANE. Svo, gilt top, $2.00. One of the richest and most worthy contributions to American literature of the past decade vith a = positively photographie imned the porfratts of Pratt by nan nature.” — Rox H BY THE SAME AUTHOR A Venetian June aud A Literary Courtship. New holiday edition, with numerous illus tration, Thetwo vols., as a set, in a box, #2 The Fall of the Sparrow. By M. C. Batrovr. No. 25 in the Hudson Library, I6mo, $1 00; paper, 50 cts. John Marmaduke. A Romance of the English Iavasion of Ire- land in 1649. By Samvce. HARDEN CuURCR, author of “Life of Oliver Cromweil.” Third Edition. Llustrated. Imo, $1 2 The author has produced a thoroughly interest ing storv, abounding in stirring scenes, whicn force themselves on the aftention of his read ra, and peopled with a sufficiency of clear-drawn, vivid, life like characters, the lovelie-t of whom, the heroine, Catharine Dillon, ts an unforgetable woman,"’~ ¥. Mati and Express Life of Abby Hopper Gibbons. Told chiefly through her correspondence. Edited by her daughter, Saran Hooper EMERSON. Illustrated. [Two volumes, l2mo, per set, $3.00 “In the ‘Life of Abby Hopper Gibbons’ a loving laughter presenta to ua the story of a noble woman who played an important part in an important time, and who left the impress of her remarkable character on every one who came within her influence.”’— Home ind Ciud Life, Boston Journals of John Lincklaen, Agent of the Holland Land Company. Travels in the Years 1791 and 1792 in Pennsylvania, New York, and Vermont. With a Biogra. graphical Sketch and Notes. By HELEN LINCKLAEN FAIRCHILD, With illustrations and maps. Limited edition of five hundred copies printed from type. Svo, $2 50. “This book fis of value to students of our national develo,ment, but especialiy of our development in the three sta.es mentioned.”"— Tne Outlook, G. P. PUTNAIT’S SONS 27 & 29 West 23d St., New York. e
Page 26
‘The Nation. [Vol. 65, No. 1684 ‘APPLETON’ Ss. Popular Science Monthly. OCTOBER, 1897. Pranklin’s Kite Experiments with Modern Appa- ratus, ALEXANDER McAopig. Illustrated. A reproduction of Franklin's epoch-making ex- periments by means cf modern apparatus. and a discussion of the kite as an instrument for meteo rological investigation. Science at the University of Chicego. Prof FREDERICK Starr. Illustrated. Describes and pictures the men and buildings de voted to the teaching of science in the newest of our great universities. The Psychology of Belief. W. B. Parker. An interesting and instructive discussion of this curious trait of the human mind, which might almost be called an instinct. Pree-Hand Drawing in Education. H. G. Fitz. Illustrated. Shows the importance of this subject when pro- perly taught, and its absolute uselessness as ordi- narily presented to the child. A Decade in Federal Railway Regulation. H. T. NEWCOMB. Shows how futile the famous interstate commerce law has been in checking the evils which led to its passage, and points out its radical defects. Early American Chemical Societies. H.C. Bourton. A brief historical sketch of the origins and aims of what were practically the first scieatific societies in this country. Other articles: The Racial Geography of Europe -IX, Italy; Some Unrecognized Laws of Nature; The Idea of Murder among Men andj Animals; Prin- cipals of Taxation—XI, Present Methods; The Eco- nomic Value of Animals; and Sketch (with Por- trait) of Louis Figuier, astronomer. Editor's Table; Scientific Literature; Fragments of Science; Notes. s 50 cents a number; $5.00 a year, D. APPLETON AND COMPANY, 72 Fifth Avenue, New York. William Lloyd Garrison, 1805-1879. The Story of his Life told by his Children. Illustrated with over 40 portraits, views, etc. 4 vols., 8vo, gilt top, $8.00 net. This important work (till recently published by the Century Company) has been reduced in price from $12 00 to $8.00, a remarkably low price for what is unquestionably one of the handsomest products ofthe American press. * A biography of almost world wide importance. . . It will bea standard work of reference "— Charle. ston News and Courier. ‘*In fact, Southern history is not complete with- out this work.’’—Atlanta Const.tution. ‘It is, forthe anti slavery record, final; and the service done to our national history is as great as that toa father’s memory. Its one eminent trait, however, is its justice.."".—Atlantic Monthly. ‘*A masterpiece of m dern historical biograpby. To call the work a mine of information would be to convey a false impression; it is rather a well- arranged library in which attendant hands are al- ways present to point the way to the exact thing wanted Finally, the work, while as in- structive as the driest manual, is as interesting as a romance.*’— Boston Advertiser. *,* For sale by bo -ksellers. Sent, postpaid, on receipt of price by the Publishers, HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN BosTON AND New YORK. & CO., FALL ANNOUNCEMENTS THE OPEN COURT I PUBLISHING CO. DARW'N AND AFTER DARWIN AN EXPOSITION OF THE DARWINIAN THEO- RY, AND A DISCUSSION OF POST-DARWIN- IAN QUESTIONS. By the late GEORGE JOHN ROMANES, M.A., LL.D.,. F.R.S., Honorary Fel- low of Gonville and Caius College, Cambridge. PART III, POST-DARWINIAN QUESTIONS. ISOLATION AND PHYSIOLOGICAL SELEC- TION. Pages 181. S8vo. Price $1.00. With Por- trait of Mr. G. T. Gulick. “The best single volume (Part I.) on the general subject that has appeared since Darwin's time.’’— American Naturalist. BUDDHISM AND ITS CHRISTIAN CRITICS. jy DR. PAUL CARUS. 8vo. Pages, circa, 300. Price, $1.25. POPULAR SCIENTIFIC LECTURES. By ERNST MACH, Professor in the University of Vienna. Second Edition, revised and greatly enlarged. S8vo. Pdges 380. 48 Cuts. Price, $1.00 net. “Has scarcely a rival in the whole realm of popular scientifie writing.’’—-[Boston Traveller. MARTIN LUTHER. By GUSTAV FREYTAG. 8&vo. Pp. 133. Paper covers; ‘‘Religion of Science Library’’ edition. Price, 25 cents. Illustrated Cloth Edition, large Svo. $1.00. “Gustav Freytag has made the history of the reat reformer as interesting as a novel.’’-—-[ New Jrleans Picayune. THE MONIST (A Quarterly Magazine). Devoted to the Philosophy of Science. CON'ENTS FOR OCTOBER, 1897. THE REALITIES OF EXPERIENCE. By Prof. ©. Lloyd Morgan, Bristol, Eng. ON ISOLATION IN ORGANIC EVOLUTION. A Posthumous Essay. By the late George John Romanes. ON THE ORIGIN OF ares By Prof. Th. Eimer, Tubingen, German MAN AS A MEMBER OF ‘SOCIETY. Dr. Paul Topinard, Paris, France. PROFESSOR S. MAX MPLLER'S THEORY OF THE SELF. By Dr. Paul Ca ON SENSATIONS OF ORIE NTATION. By Prof. Ernst Mach, Vienna, Austri wa oa CORRES PONDENCE, BOOK RE- IEWS, ete Single Copies , 50 cents. Annually, $2.00; in the 0. Ff, U., Se ad. CONTENTS of OCTOBER OPEN COURT Devoted to the Religion of Science and the Science of Religion. FRONTISPIECE: Johann Wolfgang von Goethe. Municipal Life in New Zealand. By the Hon. Sir Robert Stout, K.C.M.G., and Ex-Premier of New Zealand. History of the People of Israel, From the Begin- ning to the Destruction of Jerusalem. Fourth Ar- ticle. Solomon.—The Division of the Kingdom. By Dr. C. H. Cornhill, Professor of Theology in the University of Konigsberg. The Mission Ruins of California. Illustrated. By J. M. Scanland. The Personality of God. Correspondence between Pere Hyacinthe Loyson and Dr. Paul Carus. Riographical Ske ‘tch of Goethe. Scieteliaisoene. Book Reviews, Notes, etc. Every issue contains as a frontispiece a portrait of a distinguished thinker and writer in the field of philosophy and religion. Monthly. Single Copies, 10 cents, Annually, $1.00. Chicago: The Open Court Publishing Company, 324 DEARBORN ST. Sex Worship: AN EXPOSITION OF THE PHALLIC ORIGIN OF RELIGION. By CLIFFORD HOWARD. A work of rare avd curious information concerning the ancient worship of the procre- ative powers, and demonstrating that the va. rious religious faiths of the world have hada common origin, and are founded upon this universal primitive mode of worship. “a remarkable book.” —dllegheny Record. “Many strange beliefs and stranger customs are touchediupon in this work "’—Brookiyn Eagle. “a volume whose contents will surprise most peo ple.”—Inaianapolis Sentinel. 12mo, cloth, $1.25 net. Limited Edition. Sent, postpaid, on receipt of price. CLIFFORD HOWARD,’ Publisher, P. 0. Box 633, Washington, D.C. Publications in French. Attention is called to the following series of re- prints, as of great value to the student as well as to the general reader of French. Romans Choisis. 12mo, paper, 60 cents; cloth, 85 cents. No, 17. SANS FAMILLE. Par Hector Ma.or Abr dged and arranged for school use by Prof. P. Bercy, B.L,LD. 430 pages. No. 18. COSIA. By Anxpre MicHeL Duranp. 165 pages. 7 Complete catalogue on application. For sale by all book- sellers, or postpaid on receipt of price by the publisher, William R. Jenkins 851 and 853 Sixth Ave. (48th St.), New York. Old and Rare Books. FIRST EDITIONS, etc., ete., FOR SALE, AN ILLUSTRATED CATALOGUE OF, PART 2, with | Seventy-one Reproductions of Plates. Titie-pages, ete., ete. Works relating to the Civil War and Cromwell, Coaching, Cookery, Costume, Queen | Elizabeth, Freemasonry, Gardening. Books chiefly first editions, by Charles Cotton, Abraham Cow- | ley, William Cowper, Daniel Defoe, Charles Dickens, Dr. John Donne, Michael Drayton, John Dryden, Thomas Durfey, Jobn Evelyn, Henry Fielding. FIRST EDITIONS of books illustrated by George and Robert Cruikshank, Richard Doyie, and Harry Furniss, and a large collection of cu- rious Facetiw. Part 2. 8vo, 74 pages, post free, 1s. PICKERING & CHATTO, 66 HAYMARKET, LONDON, _S. W. FE neil and German BOOKS The Latest French and German Books Are promptly imported and kept for sale. All Standard Works continually in Stock, Write for New List of Late Fiction. BRENTANO’S 31 Union Square, New York. LIBRARIES. Library Catalogue Mailed Free. LISTS PRICED GRATIS. THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO., Wholesele Books, 5 & 7 East 16th St., New York. FW. CHRISTERN (DYRSEN & PFEIFFER, Successors), 429 5th Ave., between 28th and 29th Sts., New York, Importers of Foreign Books: Agents for the leading Paris Publishers; Tauchnitz’s British Authors. Teub ner’s Greek and Latin Classics. Catalogues of stock mailed on demand. New books received from Paris and Leipzig as soon as issued. WILLIAMS, 25 EAST 10TH ST., « N. Y., Dea er in Magazines and other Periodi- als. Sets, volumes, or single num bers. Mer secant OF AMERICAN HISTO- & ry. Asetin numbers; clean, unused. $75. A. S. CLARK, 174 Fulton § Street, New York. UTOGRAPH LETTERS OF CELEB- RITIES and BOOK-PLATES. Send for Catalogue. WALTER ROMEYN BEeNnJAMIN, 1125 Broadway, N. Y. City. KIN DERGARTEN suPPLIEs at SCHERMERHORN’S, 8 East es Street, N. Y. Send for new Catalogu Reading Case for the Nation, To receive the current numbers in a convenient (temporary) form. Substantially made, bound in eloth,with The Nation stamped on the side in gold. | Holds about one volume. Papers easily and neatly adjusted. Sent, postpaid, on receipt of 75 cents \ | : ee
Page 27
tte. a apc sae Shactat Cab pallid oon ite WI os io! ARs Si ie, | Ob een, ; - = St em Oct. 7, 1897] The Nation. Vv THE WORMELEY EDITION. LA COMEDIE HUMAINE HONORE DE BALZAC. Translated by Katharine Prescott Wormeleyv. TRANSLATION. By the most competent liv- ing trausiator of Balzac, preserving all the original flavor, vigor, and delicacy of the original. ILLUSTRATIONS. Seven in each volume, on vellum plate paper, with replicas on India paper. Made by twenty of the best French artists for this edition only, reproduced in Goupil-gravure. PAPER. Best Dutch, hand-made, light, soft, exivie, each sheet with special water-mark, ‘*H, de B.” BINDING. Polished linen buckram, better than leather, gilt top, deckle edges, back titles forming complete index. PRICE. 250 sets only, 40 volumes each, royal octavo. $500 per volume. Subscriptions received for complete sets only. DESCRIPTIVE VOLUME. With each set, without charge, 0.uud to match, contain- ing half-tone portraits of the twenty ar- tists, Miss Wormeley’s ‘Arrangement of the English and French Titles.” Sugges- tions on the order in which to read Balzac. The complete set is ready for immediate de- livery on very favorable terms, Quick application should be made for the few remaining sets of this magnificent work. Circulars and full information free of the publishers ROBERTS BROTHERS, 3 Somerset St., Boston, Mass. NEW YORK: 156 Fifth Avenue. CHICAGO: [icDonnell Bros., 279 Dearborn St, MIND CULTURE —how to think, read, study and ob- serve —an idea-systematizer — the greatest work of modern times— WHEREWITHAL It is called a “seven-word, seven-minute method of education, ” has ‘the beauty of sim- plicity.”” One prominent instructor says, “It’s 400 years ahead of time.”” New ideas—none of the hackneyed, confusing present day methods. Applying to any conceivable ques- tion from every conceivable point of view. Citizens’ edition, handsomely bound, $1.00. Descriptive circular free. School edition, reduced price in quantities. THE WHEREWITHAL BOOK CO., | Bourse Building. Philadelphia, Pa. HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO.’S NEW BOOKS Tre Revolt of a Daughter. A thoroughly interesting and charm- ingly written love story, by ELLEN OLNEY Kirk, author of “The Story of Margaret Kent,” “ Ciphers,"’ “‘ Walford,” ‘“‘A Lesson in Love,” etc. 16mo, $1.25. aron in the Wildwoods. A delightfui new Thimblefinger story of Aaron while a ‘‘ runaway,” by JOEL CHAN- DLER HARRIS, author of * Little Mr. Thim- blefinger and his Queer Country,” ‘‘ Mr. Rab- bit at Home,” ‘‘The Story of Aaron,” etc. With 24 full-page illustrations by OLIVER HERFORD. Square 8vo, $2.00, A Browning Courtship, and Other Stories. A group of charming short stories, by ELIza ORNE WHITE, author of ‘** Winterborough,” “The Coming of Theodora,” ‘** When Molly was Six,” “A Little Girl of Long Ago,” etc. 16mo, $1.25. Fyawthorne’s First Diary. With an Account of its Discovery and Loss. By SamMvugeL T. PicKarpb, author of ‘Tbe Life of John Greenleaf Whittier.” With four illustrations of scenes in Raymond, Maine, frequented by Hawthorne when a boy. Ifmo, $1.00. Sold by all Booksellers. Sent, postpaid, by HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO., Boston. 11 East 17th Street, New York. To receive the current numbers in a conven! ent (temporary) form Substantially made, bound in cloth, with THe NATION stamped on the side in gold. Holds about one volume. Papers easily and neatly ad justed. Sent, postpaid, on receipt of 75 cents ‘“The Workers’’ THE TRUTH ABoUT THE LABoRING-MaAN + HE WI BORER TO LIFE OF THE STORY OF HIS TWO TELLS YEARS’ A COLLEGE GRADUATE 1 BECAME A DAY LaA- LEARN THE THE WORKINGMAN CTUAL ENPERIENCES IN Scribners’ Magazine NEW BOOKS. Robert E. Lee, And the Southern Confederacy, 1867-1870. By Henry ALExaNDER Ware, M.A., Ph.D., Professor of History in the Wash- ington and Lee University. No 2 in the Heroes of the Nations Series. Fulty illus- trated. Large mo, cloth, $1.50; half leather, gilt top, $1.75. Prof. White's biography of the great Confederate General is written from a Southern standpoimt His work will, however, appeal to all, whether north or south of Mason's and Dixon's line, as the record of an American whose nobility of character and soldieriy qualities are unquestioned. Ulysses S. Grant And the Period of National Preservation and Reconstruction, I822-I88). By Wirt.tam Conant Caurcn, Lt. Col. U. S. Vols, author of * Life of John Ericsson.” Noa 21 in the Heroes of the Nations Series. Fully illustrated. Large 12 mo, cloth, $1.50; half leather, gilt top, $1 75 “Itis written by an expert tactician, whose know ledge of the technical problems which Grant soiwed in such @ masteriy way bas enabled him to write a work which wll satiafy those who are seeking for a brief, succinct statement of the essential faces In the career of the greatest general of ur Civili War The work Is tHastrated with maps aud portraits that add to its value aod attractiveness.” Me Cvagre gationalst. Pratt Portraits. Sketched in a New England Suburb. By ANNA FULLER. New holiday edition, with 18 illustrations by GEORGE SLOANE. Svo, gilt top, $2.00, “One of the richest and most worthy contributions to Amertvan literature of the past decade With a positively photographic tole skilful writer has imned the portraits of this New England family Pratt by name, and so thoroughly New England by nature.” — Rochester Hera:d BY THE SAME AUTHOR A Venetian June and A Literary Courtship. New holiday edition, with numerous illus trations Thetwo vols. as a set. ina box, PY The Fall of the Sparrow. By M. C. Batrovr. No. 25 in the Hudson Library. I6mo, $1.00; paper, 50 cts John Marmaduke. A Romance of the English lavasion of Ire- land in 1649. By Samvue. HARDEN CHURCH, author of ‘Life of Oliver Cromwell.” Third Edition. Llustrated. I2mo, $1 25 The author has produced a thoroughly interest ing storv, abounding in stirring scenes, whicn force themselves on the attention of his read ra, and peopled with a suffictency of cleardrawn, vivid, life like characters, the loveliest of whom, the heroine, Catharine Dillon, ts an unforgetable woman,’’-N ¥. Mati and Express Life of Abby Hopper Gibbons. Told chiefly through her correspondence. Edited by her daughter, Saran Hooper EMERSON, Lllustrated. [wo volumes. 12mo, per set, $3.00. “In the ‘Life of Abby Hopper Gibbons’ a loving daughter presenta to us the story of a noble woman who played an important partin an important time, and who left the tmpress of her remarkable character on every one who came within her influence.”— Home and Clud Life, Boaton Journals of John Lincklaen, Agent of the Holland Land Company. Travels in the Years 1791 and \792 in Pennsylvania, New York, and Vermont. With a Biogra- graphical Sketch and Notes. By HELEN LINCKLAEN FAIRCHILD. With illustrations and maps. Limited edition of five hundred copies printed from type. Svo, $2 50. “ This book fs of value to students of our national develo, ment, but especially of our development in the three states mentioned.”’— Tne Outlook G. P. PUTNAIT’S SONS 27 & 29 West 23d St., New York. Tree te ery pea marge
Page 28
The Nation.
[Vol. 65, No. 1684
Now Ready. Published by the Century Co,
Pictures by Howard Pyle. ‘*T do not recall any American novel of a semi-historical cha- racter which is at once so intricate in its disclosures of manners and men, so courageous in dealing purely with historic figures, and so full of vitality, variety, and charm.”—HAMILTON W. MABIE. If ‘‘Hugh Wynne” is not the long-sought great American novel, it at least comes closer to it than any novel of the decade.— The Outiook. THE DAYS OF JEANNE D’ARC. By Mary HARTWELL CATHERWOOD, Author of ‘* The Romance of Dollard,” etc. STIRRING romance in which the Warrior Saint of France is the principal figure. The author has made aclose study of the life and times of the Maid of Domremy, and she has reproduced the spirit of the age with fidelity and picturesque effect. 12mo, 280 pages. With frontispiece, Cloth, $1.50, A Story of the Grand Banks. ‘*The most vivid picture of the sea toilers of New England which this generation has known,”— Boston Journal. 12mo, cloth, 300 pages; Illustrated by Taber. Dr. S. Weir Mitchell’s Novel of the American Revolution. “HUGH WYNNE, FREE QUAKER” In two vols., small r2mo, $2.00. ‘‘T am almost tempted to say that with the exception of Coo- per’s Spy it is the only successful Revolutionary novel that I know, It is more than a merely interesting and powerful book, for it has in it the elemant of permanence.” —THEO. ROOSEVELT. A singularly complete and attractive picture of American life in the last century.—London Daily News. AMERICAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO CIVILIZATION. By CHARLES W. E ttrort, LL.D., President of Harvard University. COLLECTION of papers by President Eliot, devoted to ques- tions of great moment: ‘‘The Working of the American De- mocracy,” ‘‘ Equality in a Republic,” ‘One Remedy for Municipal Misgovernment,” ‘Present Disadvantages of Rich Men,” ete. 8vo, 300 pages. Cloth, $2 00.
Rudyard Kipling’s First American Novel. “CAPTAINS COURAGEOUS” $1.50. ‘**Kipling’s powers of description are brought into play and are here seen at their best.”— Post Express, Rochester.
AN ARTIST’S LETTERS FROM JAPAN. By Joun La FaRGE. R. LA FARGE is an artist well kaown for his rich and ex- quisite color and for certain famous compositions in stained glass. Mr. La Farge'’s perk yeoraces J is as vivid as the work of his brush. With many beautiful illustrations by the author. In rich binding, 300 pages, price $4.00. DE AMICITIA. By Marcus TULLIvs CICERO. S these Thumb-Nail books are largely used for gifts, the present volume most appropriately consists of Cicero’s essay on Friend- ship. The translation is by Benjamin E Smith. Size 5x3 inches, about 175 pages. Colored frontispiece. Bound in full leather, rich- ly stamped. Price, $1.00. FIGHTING A FIRE. By CHARLES THAXTER HILL. GRAPHIC and interesting picture of the perils, the hardships, and the almost daily heroism of a fireman’s life, telling how the fire department of a great city is organized, how the firemen are trained, etc. The author is thoroughly familiar with the New York Fire Department. 12mo, about 270 pages. With 30 pictures by the author. Cloth, $1.50
UP THE MATTERHORN IN A BOAT. By MaRIon MANVILLE POPE. AN extravaganza of an up-to-date character. Full of rollicking humor and yet written in such a realistic style as to preserve the interest throughout. 16mo, about 225 pages. Illustrations by George Wright. Cloth back and paper sides, richly ornamented. Price, $1.25. Two New Issues in: the “ Thumb-Nail Series.” A CHRISTMAS CAROL. By CHARLES DICKENS. NEW issue in the attractive ‘‘Thumb-Nail Series.” A dainty and appropriate form for this classic and one that will appeal to every reader. Size 5'4x3 inches, about 250 pages. With colored frontispiece by Charles M. Relyea. Bound in full leather, richly stamped. Price, $1.00. Books for Boys and Girls. MISS NINA BARROW. By FRANCES COURTENAY BAYLOR. STRONG story for girls by the author of ‘‘On Both Sides,” etc. The heroine is a little girl who always had her own way, and the author tells what came of this lack of training. It is a story of character-building, and exerts a helpful and stimulating influence. 12mo, about 275 pages. Frontispiece by Reginald Birch. Cloth, price, $1.25. A RECENT GREAT SUCCESS. ISSUED SEPT. 24th THE CENTURY BOOK OF THE AMERICAN REVOLUTION. BY ELBRIDGE S. BROOKS. With Preface by Chauncey M. Depew. The Story of the Pilgrimage of a Party of Young People to the Battle-fields of the Revolution More than Two Hundred Illustrations. A Complete Panorama of the War. Price $1.50.
Sold by all booksellers, or sent postpaid, by
THE CENTURY CO., ‘Union Square, New York.
<-ctenn: eieyeceiee s YS