The Nation 1897-05-13: Vol 64 Iss 1663
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
f 4 he Nat VOL. LXIV—NO, 1663. THURSDAY, MAY 13, 1897. PRICE 10 CENTS. D.APPLETON AND COMPANY'S Cyprian: His Life, his Times, his Work. By Epwarp WuirtE Benson, D.D., D.C.L., late Arch- bishop of Canterbury. With an Introduc- tion by the Right Rev. Henry C. PotTer D.D., LL D., D.C L., Bishop of New York. 8vo. Cloth. Canon Gore has said that he does not believe there is so much theological or moral illumination to be gained from any study outside Holy Scripture as from the great theologians who are called the ‘*Fathers.”. Dr. Benson speaks of Cyprian as ‘‘a powerful and fas:inating personality,” who left a theory of the Church's life which is still ‘‘a living theory.” Bishop Potter writes: ‘‘Cyprian beheld Christendom vexed by questions which were not new when he came to Carthage, and which are as vital in their interest and as far-reaching in their importance now as then.” Bird-Life. A Guide to the Study of our Common Birds. By Frank M. CHAPMAN, Assistant Cura” tor of Mammalogy and Ornithology, Ame rican Museum of Natural History, author of ‘*‘ Handbook of Birds of Eastern North America.” With 75 full-page Plates and numerous Text Drawings by Ernzgst Sr- TON THOMPSON. 12mo. Cloth. $1.75 This book is designed for the use of those who would become familiar with our common birds in their haunts, learn of their migrations and how they are performed, their nests and the causes which influence their construction, the significance of birds’ colors, the forms and uses of their wings, tails, feet, and bills, and the relation between their structure and habits. In Brook and Bayou; Or, Life in the Still Waters. By CLaRa Kern Bay.Liss. A new volume in Apple- tons’ Home Reading Book Series. Illus. trated. 12mo. Cloth. 60 cents, net. In this volume the author introduces her readers to some of the interesting inhabitants of the micro- scopic world by the aid of numerous plates and full descriptive text. The account of the evolution of these minute creatures and their struggle for ex- istence is given in a remarkably entertaining way, and makes the book as fascinating as a novel. History for Young Readers. | England. By Frances E. Cooke. 16mo. Cloth. 60 cents. The purpose of this book is to present to young readers, in simple language, a clear conception of the origin and growth of the English nation, giving special attention to events that affect the social and educational affairs of the people, and the General Grant. By General James GRANT WILSON. A new volume in the Great Commanders Series. With Portrait, Illustrations, and Maps. 12mo. Cloth, $1 50. The author's acquaintance with General Grant began at Cairo, Ill., in 1861, and continued for near- ly a quarter of a century. In addition to this the author has had the advantage of consulting a war diary containing many interesting conversations ‘and incidents of his service under General Grant in the Vicksburg campaign andelsewhere. The proofs have been read by a member of General Grant's family. Among the valuable papers included are lettersfrom Generals Franklin, Reynolds, Long- street. and French; a most important correspond- ence with the Hon. E. B. Washburne, covering the four years of the war, and reproductions of the “Unconditional Surrender” letter, the appoint- ment as Lieutenant-General signed by Lincoln, and other valuable papers. The illustrations include the medal struck to commemorate the dedication of the tomb on April 27, 1897. In Joyful Russia. By Joun A. Locan, Jr. With 50 full page Tilustrations in colors and black and white. Sm 8vo. Cloth, $3.50, A peculiarly delightful book of travel and sight- seeing, describing the splendid ceremonies at the coronation of the Czar, and also picturing Russian social life in Moscow and in the country. Mr. Logan’s credentials gave him special facilities for seeing everything best worth seeing, and his intro- ductions enabled him to acquaint himself with various phases of life which the average traveler does not see. Numerous admirable illustrations reproduce notable buildings; street scenes, portraits of important personages and genre subjects as well as the pageantry of the coronation. Beauty and Art. By ALDAM HraTon. 12mo. Cloth. $1 75 The purpose of this book is to treat fully of evolution in art, especially in those minor arts where the stages of evolution are not to be dis- cerned so readily. “The'book may be read to advantage by any one de- sirous of cultivating a refined taste in choosing beau- tiful things for the ordinary ete oa of his daiiy life. Thevolume will be welcome to everyone who seeks trustworthy.and intelligent guidance in the matters of taste with which it is occupied ”—The n. The Third Violet. By STEPHEN CRANE, author of ‘‘The Red Badge of Courage,” ‘The Little Regi- ment,” ‘Maggie,’ etc. 12mo. Cloth, $100. ~ Mr. Crane’s new novel is a fresh and delightful study of artist life in the city and the country. The theme is worked out with the author's characteris- tic originality and force, and with much natural humor. In subject the book is altogether different from any of its predecessors, and the author's marked success proves his breadth and the versa- The Story of Oliver Twist. Cundensed for Home and School Reading, by Etta Boyce Krrx. A new volume in Appleton’s Home-Reading Book Series. 12mo. Cloth. 60 cents net. Mrs. Kirk preserves the author’s language, with slight modifications, and has eliminated only such passages as are not essential to the continuity of the narrative, but preferably omitted for young readers. In its present form it is a wholesome and entertain- ing beok for school use as well as for home circles. His Fortunate Grace. By Mrs. GERTRUDE ATHERTON, author of ‘*Before the Gringo Came,” “A Whirl Asunder,” ete. 16mo. Cloth, $1.00. Mrs. Atherton is at her best in this vigorous and graphic story. of an international alliance. Her theme is modern social life in New York and its relations to the titled foreigner in quest of an American wife. The Beautiful Miss Brooke By “Z. Z.,” author of ‘The World anda Man,” etc. 16mo. Cloth, $1.00. A clever and entertaining story. The theme is handled lightly, the conversations are vivacious and real, and the glimpse of certain phases of life in London and in Paris ateliers possesses actuality and interest. LATEST ISSUES IN Appleton’s Town and Country Library. Each, 12mo. Paper, 50 cents; cloth, $1.00. The Sun of Saratoga. By J. A. ALTSHELER. This new American historical romance will meet with immediate favor because it is preéminently readable and entertaining. The hero plays no small part in the campaign which resulted in Bur- goyne’s surrender and his adventures, grave and humorous, are pictured in a way which will insure the author a large following. The Beautiful White Devil. By Guy Boorusy, author of ‘‘Dr. Nikola,” ‘*A4 Bid for Fortune,” ‘‘ The Marriage of Esther,” etc. This thrilling romance of the China Sea abounds in picturesque scenes and stirring situacions. It will be found to be a most entertaining story of adventure. A Galahad of the Creeks. By S. Leverr Yeats, author of ‘‘ The Honour of Savelli,” etc. Mr. Yeats’s new novel offers a picturesque and dramatic study of exciting episodes of Indian life in addition to the working out of the special motive from which the title is drawn. In addition to this admirable romance, another story is included in struggles that the nation has passed through. tility of his great talent. the volume. For sale by all hooksellers, or will be sent by mail on receipt ao price by the a D. APPLETON AND COMPANY, 72 Fifth Avenue, New York.
Page 2
os Sete a} ri or ayo See ee bance The Nation. [Vol. 64, No. 1663 The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science, and Art. FOUNDED 1865. {Entered at the New York City Post-Office as second- class mail-matter.] CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. THE WEEK ......00000+ scccecescccecs Soscesdecedocess . 349 EpITvoRIAL ARTICLES : Confessed Failure of 1 apace The Pauper Labor of A ° The Currency Danger. SPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE : More about Greek ExcavationS............+..-+++. B54 Napoleon at Elba ..........seececeeceseceecsceensees 855 CORRESPONDENCE : Protection and the acpi sappesrcnt socsveceedcss OOO A New Party.. + e0u evens vecicsen ness) OO History Re ating itseit.. ececscbecsocssotoecs GOD Indentu = ohh aa secceneccccccesccvcsseses COO Brant and Rabelais ........cccsecscoscscccvcccccsccce 356 The Antiquity of o eperunaa” Rinses eekbensehsabane 856 Philology at a Venture.. dhwabeSnicdt bens en eee HOTBB .0ccccccccccsveccscrcccccccsccccseesccccescsecccce 358 Book Reviews! The Steer a Perr rir | ee Raters pececcce cseceees BBQ Hi tor — Criticism » -. 363 The Mount........... . 864 The on Te . 364 ts The Story of the Pilgrim Fathers. Municipal Problems.............+ Pbilip cat Alexander of Macedon ee NE SEND gon 50s p500 Sen ccncncecceesoosess A Book of Sopaniees Books OF THE WEEK .... TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three Dollars per year, in advance, postpaid, to any part of the United States or Canada; to foreign countries comprised in the Postal Union, $4.00. The date when the subscription expires is on the Address-Label of each paper, the change of which to a subsequent date becomes a receipt for remittance. No other receipt is sent unless requested. Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by régistered letter, or by check, express order, or postal order, payable to ‘‘ Publisher of the Nation.” When a change of address is desired, both the old and new addresses should be given. Address THE NATION, Box 794, New York. Publication Office, 208 Broadway. TERMS OF ADVERTISING, Fifteen cents per agate line, each insertion, 14 lines to the inch. Twenty per cent. advance for choice of e, to of column, or cuts. Cuts are not ineertel. Om the jirst page. A column, $20 each insertion; with choice of page, $24. A page, $60 each insertion; front-cover page, $80. Advertisements must be acceptable in every respect. Copy received until Tuesday, 5 Pp. M. DISCOUNTS. TIME— The NATION is ent Apa to those ea advertise in it as long as the advertisement continues. The EDITION of the Nation this week is 9,400 copies. The Subscription List is always open to the inspection of advertisers. * Copies of the NaTION may be procured in "Paris at Brentano’s, 17 Avenue de l’Opéra, and in gest of Ps . Stevens, 4 Trafalgar uare, American ewsy Agency, 15 Kin eae ers an awe G gency, g pegs ae $a R.J. Bush, Fleet Street, E * 4 Educational CALIFORNIA, Los Angeles, West 2 (48 20K00CH SCHOOL f ye GIRLS. Mrs. GrorGE A. CASWELL, Principal. CONNECTICUT, Clinton UNTRY HOME, PERSONAL CARE, good school. wey receive three boys for SCHOOL YEAR or SUMMER VACATION. Twenty-two years’ experience with boys. JosEPH H. Sperry, A. Assistant Principal Morgan School. CoNNECTICUT, W: Se MARGARE 7S DIOCESAN Piney spa pry meet Se Gre ore tem Francia ia Tr Russell I DD. Rector. Miss Mary R. Hil- n, Franklin Street. HE TT SSES 5 WEBI S Boarding and Day School for Girls will reopen September 24. District oF CoLuMBIA, Washington. 5 YWEVY CHASE French and English School for Girls. Suburb of Washington. French the language of the house. Fripctonl, Mile. L. M. Bounieny. Assistant Principal, Miss C. Perticgrew. P. O. Station E, Washington, D. C Educational. School of Drawing and Painting MUSEUM OF FINE ARTS, Copley Square, Boston, Mass. TWENTY-SECOND YEAR WILL OPEN OCT. 4, Instruction in drawing from the cast and from life, in painting and decorative design, and also in artistic ea A — perspective. rincipal in- structors, F. W. E. C. Tarbell, and Philip Hale (Drawing 7 “Palating), Mrs. William Stone (Decorative Design), E ettve) Emerson (Anatomy). and A. K. Cross (Pers: Pupils are allowed the free use of the ga Micrice ae the Museum. Yor ear et detailed information, address ABETH LOMBARD, Manager. University of Michigan. SUMMER SCHOOL. July 7—August 18. Courses will be offered in all leading Academic studies; also in Law, Engineering, Bacteriology, Histology, and Photography. For full announce- ment apply to Secretary, JAMES H. WADE, Ann Arbor, Mich. ILLINoIs, Chicago, 1500-4 Title and Trust Building. ‘WICAGO COLLEGE OF LA We / DEPARTMENT OF LAKE FOREST University. and three-year course. For further information, odtnant the Secretary, E. E. BARRETT. TAGE WO Baltimore, 122 and 124 W. Franklin 8t 'DGE RTH BOARDING and DAY School pee Girls —35th year will begin September 23, 1897. Mrs. H. P. LEFEBVRE, Principa Miss E. D. HUNTLEY, Associate Principal ARYLAND, Catonsville. T. TIMOTHY: S SCHOOL for Girls re- September 23, 1896. Prepares for College. Heads’ bf ‘School: Miss M. CG. Carrer, Miss S. R. CARTER. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 9 Appleton Street. Bre TON NORMAL SCHOOL of House- hold Arts, established by the late Mrs. Mary HE- under the nameof Boston NorMAL SCHOOL OF COOxEny. will reopen sae 29. Adaress the Director, Miss Amy Morris Homans. MassACHUSETTs, Bi OSTON UNI VERSI TY Law School, Address the Dean, Epmunp H. BENNETT, LL.D. MASSACHUSETTS Duxbury. OWDER POINT SCHOOL. —Prepares for Scientific School, College, or business. Indi- vidual teaching. Elementary classes 4 i oun boys. Home and outdoor life. F. B. Knapp, S. T.). MASSACHUSETTS, Lowell. focgsss HALL (Opposite Rogers Fort Hill Park). A Home —_- for Girls and Young Wo- men. Certificate admits to , Vassar, Wellesley, and Wells. Reopens eer ’30. Terms, $750. For further particulars address the Principal, Mrs. E. P. UNDERHILL, M.A. Onto, Cincinnati. TSS ARMSTRONG S SCHOOL FOR Girls, Liddesdale Place, Avondale. Family limit- ed. Circulars sent on application PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, Chestnut Hill. RS. COMEG YS’ AND MISS BELL’ S BOARDING AND DAY SCHOOL FOR GIRLS will reopen October 1. Students prepared for college, PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, 1850 Pine Street, ISS ANABLE’S Boarding and Day School for Young Ladies. Estab. in 1848. Circu- lar on application. The Annie Brown School. BOARDING AND DAY SCHOOL FOR GIRLS. Primary, preparatory, academic, and musical de- partments. Preparation for college. Special courses. 711-713-715 717 Fifth Avenue, N. Y. Mrs. FRANCES FISHER WOO Resident A New York Ciry, 80, $2, 84 East 57th Street. The Peebles and Thompson School For Boarding and Day Pupils, Miss D. E. Merrill, Miss L. A. Beymes, Bre. S. S. Van Laer, Principals and Prop etors, will open October 4 ST. AGNES SCHOOL. Under the Gievetien: of Bishop Doane. Pre tion for all colleges. 8 al Studies and Courses 0 Pa lege a. 8) | Oe a in Music and Art. mna- BOYD, Prin., Albany, Sey THE CAMBRIDGE SCHOOL. A Select School for Girls. Comforts of home. Mr. ARTHUR GILMAN is the Director. CAMBRIDGE, MASS. HARVARD UNIVERSITY EXAMINATION FOR ADMISSION Will be held in New York, in the Y. M. C. A. Build- ing, 23d St., cor. 4th Ave., June 29. July 1, 2,3. The terms of admission, fees, expenses, and privileges in any or all Departments of the Universitv may be learned from Descriptive Pamphlets, which may be had on application to the Corresponding Secre- tary, Harvard University, Cambridge, Mass. RADCLIFFE COLLEGE. CANDIDATES FOR ADMISSION and other women who wish to take the Harvard Examinations in New York, will be examined under the supervision of the New York Local Committee, provided they give written notice of their inten- tion to the Sren ey of Radcliffe College. Cam- bridge, Mass., by JUNE 10. For further informa- tion, applv to the Secretary of the Local Commit- . Mrs. H. A. Davis, 170 West 77th St., New York. New York University. SUMMER COURSES. Third session July 5-August 18. Twenty-nine courses in Mathematics, Science, Languages, and Pedagogy. A delightful suburban locality in New York city. For announcement apply to the Secretary, CHAS. B. BLISS, University Heights, New York City. Miss Baldwin's School for Girls, BRYN MAWR, PA. Preparatory to Bryn Mawr College. Miss Florence Baldwin, Principal. Within six Mia more than sixty pupils have entered Bryn awr College from this school. Certificate = ts Prepa A Hine fire-proof stone building. "S acres beautiful grounds. For circular, address the Secretary. MANUAL TRAINING. FPREE COURSES for TEACHERS, ting for both Grammar and High School Work. at the SLOYD —* SCHOOL, established by Mrs. Quincy aw. Time for each course, October 1 to June 1. Address GUSTAF LARSSON, Principal, 39 North Bennet St., . Boston, Mass. SUMMER SCHOOL FOR GIRLS. A Summer Term of WINDSOR HALL SCHOOL begins July 6. Parents intending tospend the summer abroad may leave their daughters in the care of experienced teachers, in 2! beeae ul country village ten miles from Boston. HHARLES H. CLARK. Waban, Mass. HE SAUVEUR SUMMER SCHOOL of Languages, at Amherst College, Mass. Twenty- second Session—Jul. ik rad 4 ad 13. For programme, address Miss F. we haw, Amherst, Mass. Fer par- ticulars “ circulars tL. Sauveur’s Works, address Dr. L. SAUYEUR, 4613 Ellis Ave., Chicago, Ill. M4 RIENFELD SUMMER CAMP for. d august’ Sal year). For chroulers, address. ™ Dec. a RD HENDERSON, Chestnut t Hill, Pa. UMMER COACHING SCHOOL. Pei Smeale Lary ces Se Hg i 12 Fast 47th § St., N.Y, City.
Page 3
May 13, 1897] The Nation. Educational. Cortina Method | Oyun chrols Awarded First Prize Columbian Exposition. SPANISH. IN 20 LESSONS, FRENCH. cloth, each, ENGLISH. $1.50. FRENCH specimen copies of Books I. and Il., 30c. Other text jane imported Spanish Books. Send 5c. for catalogue. Cortuna academy of Languages, R. D. Cortina, M.A., Prin. Originator of the adaptation of the Phonograpn to the teaching of languages, 44 West 34th St,, N. Y. SUMMER LAW LECTURES, UNIVERSITY OF VIRGINIA, July 1 to Aug. 31, L3¥7. Course includes 36 lectures by Mr: Justice marian of U.S. — Court, For cata- logue, address LILE, Dean. “Charlottesville, Va. Summer School at Nantucket. Connected with Harvard School, 568 5th Avenue For circular and other information, ‘apply to WILLIaM FREELAND, 5638 5th Ave, N.Y. Teachers, etc. NINSTRUCTOR IN THE MASSA- chusetts Institute of Technology and graduate of the Jonns Hopkins University (A.B. ana Ph.D.), who has spent two summers in travel in Europe, de- sires to tutor during the coming summer. Mathema- tics aspecialty. Address N., care .ation. SPECIALIST IN HISTORY and the Classics, A.M., seed ni 7, with post-graduate train- ing at Harvard, and fro r years’ successful teaching experience in present place, wants positon in coliege or preparatory 7 Address Henry K. Rowe, New London, N. H. GRADUATE OF HARVARD UNI- versity, who is an instructor of mathematics in one of the leading technical institutions, desires to tutor during the summer. Address GRaDUATE, care of Nation, HARVARD M.A. an, aged 25, with teaching experience (col- lege), Wants a position to teach Laiin and Greek in a privace or preparatory school or college. Very best references. adaress b., ation office. V/A ANTED — Teaching, Coaching, or Tu- toring. United States cistory ana Latin spe- cialties. ELIZABETH M. AsH, B.A (ener ‘8 College of Balto.), 1804; m.a. (University or Pa.), Address E. m, ASH, 2136 Bolton Ave., Ghiganese, Md. VERY SUCCESSFUL TEACHER, having given up his position for the special study of Greek and German abroad, is open for an engage- ment. Would also teach Latin or History. Best refer- ences. Pu.D., care or the Natron tron. ORRE SPONDEN: CE DESTRED CON- cerning either the establishment of a girls’ school —tne direction of the studies of a — of girls—or part- nership in a girls’ school. Aadre _ Miss IsaBeLLa’ WHITE, Butler, Pa. by ades with competent teachers. School Agencies. HE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES, Everett O. Fisk & Co., Props., 4 Ashburt’n Pl., Bos- ton; 70 5th Ave,. N. Y.; $55 Wabash Ave,, Chicago; 1242 12th St., Wash.; 420 Cent, paae Min’apolis; 72 8 Cooper Bdg., Denver; 107K. , Kansas Cit ty; 25 oe Toronto; 525 Stims’n ok. ae iaeees Ag'cy Man. LBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY, 24 State St., Albany, N. Y.—Provides schools of Assists teachers P. FRENCH, Manager. obtaming positions. HARLAN R COLLEGE POST; a7 ONS Apply to ALBERT & ire Pullen Building, Chicago. CESEMEEACE S TEACHERS’ ency. Oldest and best _ in the U. 8. “Bata ished 1855, 8 East 14th St., N. Y. Tours. EUROPE. PRIVATE PARTIES. —fouitsapecta service in travel—careful and _ thorough sight-seein 11th season. Special party for Southern route May 29. Mrs. M. D. FRAZAR, 70 Globe Building, Boston, Mass. BICYCLING IN GREAT BRITAIN. A physician of bag meg in the care of boys will take a small nn meee England and Scotland dur- net July and Aug’ efers by LL . to Dr. David wy, Gheoves, Bos- ton; Dr. F. C. Shattuck, Boston Edward a D.D., Boston. Address E. C, STOWELL, M 602 Beacon 8t., Besken. UNICH, GERMANY. — PENSION NORDLAND. Schellingstrasse 10, I (near Lud- wigstr.). Very central. Comfortable and refined home for ladies and families. Terms moderate. American and English references. New Ideal European Recreation AND BICYCLE TOUR FOR YOUNG AND OLD. Sail- tng last week in June. 70 days. $425. H. J. BOOS, Mass. INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY, BOsTON. dress Miss BARBOUR, 81 Co. Eu rop poe Heights, Brooklyn, N.Y. ACATION TRIP TO EUROPE. Specially planned for rest and recreation. Terms most reasonable. For full particulars, address Prof. H. B. RICHARDSON, Amherst, Mass. Two vacancies, Small part - sailing in June. 9th EUROPEAN BICYCLE TOUR. All expenses, 70 days. $420. z. H. SMITH, 218 Woodward Ave., Detroit, Mich. GR AY’ S = a aes. Rev. FRANCIS A. GRaY, reakos, N. H. SPE CIA LI ST IN LATIN, Ph.D, five years’ experience, three years in pre- sent Pest desires a chair of Latin for coming year in = college in Eastern or Middle States. Aadress ., care Nation. SITION WANTED.—A COLLEGE Graduate, who has had experience in all branches of Library work, would like to change to another Li- brary. The best of references givea. Address LIBRa- RY POSITION, office of the watiun, New York City. OF. J]. M. ROVIRA, practical teacher “ Spanish, French, Italian, and Latin Languages to = petvane family, is the man that you need. Address 831 Cottage Lane, | Dallas, Tex. SPECIALIST IN LA TIN OF SE- ven years’ experience in academy and college, D. of Corneil University, desires a co lege osition. Excellent references. Address E. t., care lation, SUCCESSFUL Teacher and Coach, of seven years’ experience in and for Eastern uni. versities (graduate of two, Ph.D.), will take a few pu- pils for thesummer. Address H. ‘2 Aatton office. IBRARIAN OF UNIVERSITY LI- brary, = years’ experience, seeks another posi- tion. Addres “ LIBRARIAN,” care Nation. ( w4eins W. STONE, Tutor for Har- vard. 68 Chestnut Street, Boston. School Agencies. AN Agency fiuence: ir it merely hears of ve- cancies and teils that is something, but if itis asked to you about them recommend a teacher and rec- CW. BARDEEN, Syracuse, WY RECOMMENAS BEST AND CHEAPEST TOURS. SAIL EUROPE. June. Will pay 2.000 Fr. to getting dozen.tourists. INTERNATIONAL einansans BA New Diuretic, TRADE MARK REGISTERED. mic Cereal, and irritable Duoettee Emolitent, attractive, palatable. Unsurp hole range of ’ PAMPHLET JAD KING QAMPLE FREE. Cartvalled in A Ask Dealera, or (Write to Farwel n, N. Y.,U.S.4, We buy and sejl bills of exchange on Letters and taal Cable Transfers of money to f Europe, Australia, and South Africa; also ° make collections and issue Commercial Credit and Travellers’ Credits, available in all parts of the world. BROWN BROTHERS & CO. NO. 59 WALL STREET, NEW YORK. Moench) Constable Koco MensFurnishings STEAMER RUGS, Carriage and Lap Robes, Pajamas, Bath Robes, Might Shirts, Dress Shirts, Collars & Cuffs, Smoking Jackets, Flannel Travelling Shirts. NECK WEAR. Linen and Si'k Handkerchiefs. GLOVES. Driving and Riding Gloves. UMBRELLAS. | Ad 19th ot. NEW YORK. Country Cottages harmonize with nature and fit into the landscape if stained with the soft moss- green, bark-brown,and silver gray shades of Cabot’s Creosote Shingle Stains which cost 50% less and look 100% better | than paint. Stained | w les and color-studies sent free on application. SAMUEL CABOT, 71 Kilby St., Boston, Mass | AGENTS aT ALL CENTRAL POINTS. _—— — - 5 as may not be worthy to smoke the ‘ARCADIA " MEXFURE” —J. M. B—, in ‘* My Lady Nicotine.” Send 25 cents for sample to THE SURBRUG CO., 37 Dey Street, N. Y. City.
Page 4
aha sae ener ar col Pie Peaches a * iv The Nation. [Vol. 64, No. 1663 Macmillan’s New School Text-Books ARITHMETIC The Public School Arithmetic By J. A. McLellan, President of Ontario Nor- mal College, Toronto, Canada, and A. PF. Ames, Superintendent of Schools, Riverside, III. Fust Ready. Send for Specimen Pages. ALGEBRA Hall and Knight’s Elementary Algebra Second American Edition. Revised by Frank L. Sevenoak. 16mo, half leather, $1.10 xez. BOTANY Setchell’s Laboratory Practice for Beginners in Botany. . By Wm. A. Setchell, Professor of Botany in the University of California, formerly instruc- tor in Yale University. Cloth, 16mo, 90 cents net, ‘*Botany, with many other of the sciences, must be more readily taught by the laboratory method, and this book is the best of its kind that I have seen.”—HERBERT R, Morty, Gilbert School, Winsted, Ct. DRAWING Hallowell’s Elementary Drawing A Series of Practical Papers for Beginners. Written and Illustrated by Elisabeth Moore Hallowell. in the Press. ENGLISH Brooke’s English Literature By Stopford A. Brooke, M.A. Revised through- out and greatly enlarged. Cloth, 16mo, 90 cents ret. ‘*T think itis just what we have been needing—a con- cise résumé of the subject. The book has already been placed in the hands of our English classes.”—Prof. HYDE APPLETON, Swarthmore College. Carpenter’s Elements of Grammar By George R. Carpenter, Professor of Rheto- ric and English Composition in Columbia Uni- versity. Nearly Ready. Send for Specimen Pages. Lewis’s A First Book in Writing English : By Edwin Herbert Lewis, Ph.D., Associate Professor of English in Lewis Institute and in the University of Chicago, author of ‘* The History of the English Paragraph.” Nearly Ready. Send for Specimen Pages. oy GEOLOGY Tarr’s Elementary Geology By Ralph S. Tarr, B.S., F.G,S.A., Professor of Dynamic Geology and Physical Geography in the Cornell University. Crown 8vo, half leather, pp. xxx+499. Price, $1.40 et. HISTORY American History Told by Contempo- raries Edited by Albert Bushnell Hart, Professor of History in Harvard University. Vol. I. Eraof Colonization. (1492-1689.) Ready in May. Vol. II. Building of the Republic. (1689-1783.) Ready in 1897. Vol. III. National Expansion. (1783-1845.) Jn Prepa- ration. Vol. IV. Welding of the Nation. (1846-1896.) In Pre- paration. The Set of Four Volumes, $7.00. Each Volume Sold Separately, Price $2.00. In Preparation, PHYSICAL GEOGRAPHY Tarr’s First Book of Physical Geogra= phy By Ralph S. Tarr, B.S., F.G.S.A., Professor of Dynamic Geology and Physical Geography in the Cornell University, author of ‘*‘ Elemen- tary Geology,” ‘‘ Elementary Physical Geog- raphy.” This book will consist of about 350 pages, fully illus- trated, in which the general] subject of physical geography will be treated from as simple a standpoint as possible. The effort will be to treat every subject without assum- ing any knowledge that students in the last year of the grammar or the first year of the high school should not have obtained. It will be still less advanced than the ‘‘EKlementary Physical Geography,” but will be charac- terized by some of the features which have especially recommended this to the schools. ; Fust Ready. Send for Specimen Pages. PHYSICS Nichols’s The Outlines of Physics An Elementary Text-Book. By Edward L. Nichols, Professor of Physics in Cornell Uni- versity. 12mo, cloth, pp. xi+452. $1.40 mez. ‘“*The work is a valuable contribution to the text- books of physics. Iam very much pleased with the man- ner and method of treatment, and also the mechanical execution.”—Prof. J. W. GorE, University of North Carolina, PHYSIOLOGY Foster and Shore’s Physiology for Beginners By Michael Foster, M.D., F.R.S., Professor of Physiology in the University of Cambridge, and Lewis E. Shore, M.A., M.D. With full Illustrations. New edition, 16mo, cloth, pp. 252. Price, 75 cents mez. NEW YORK 66 Fifth Avenue THE MACMILLAN COMPANY CHICAGO The Auditorium Building SAN FRANCISCO 327-331 Sansome Street
Page 5
The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, MAY 13, 1897. The Week. By a vote of 43 to26, or, counting pairs, 52 to 31, the arbitration treaty was de- feated in the Senate on May 5. Fifteen of the opposition are put down as com- ing from Kansas, Tennessee, North Ca- rolina, Montana, Virginia, North Dako- ta, Idaho, Arkansas, Nevada, Texas, Alabaina, South Dakota, and Utah— States representing about a fifth of the whole population of the United States. Twenty-five out of the whole thirty-one were advocates of the free coinage of silver. There was no division on party lines whatever. The vote on the other side, which shows the Senate as stand- ing five to three in favor of arbitration, was equally significant. It represented almost the whole character and intelli- gence of the country, whether we count by communities or men. To say nothing of New England or the Middle States, wherever throughout the United States the Senator acted as the representative of public as opposed to private interests, wherever he voted free from the dicta- tion of a ring or machine and was an intelligent man, his vote was given for the treaty. The exceptions only em- phasize this. If Quay and Penrose both voted, as the list shows, against the treaty, we need no explanation of the fact. In other words, an analysis of the vote shows that even in the Senate the general sentiment of the body reflected very fairly the sentiment of the coun- try. The Senate was five to three in fa- vor of the treaty, and if the Constitu- tion allowed treaties to be ratified by a majority vote, we should to-day be con- gratulating one another over a great victory. bs Mr. Dingley has but just recovered the power of speech. Colleagues and friends hastened to him, as soon as the Senate bill was reported, exclaiming: “Bless thee, Bottom, thou art translated!” But the chairman of the ways and means committee insisted that he must not com- ment on his translated bill until he had had time to examine it and so to remark upon it “intelligently.” Yet it did not require a high order of intelligence nor prolonged thought, to see that the Senate committee had, in effect, told Mr. Dingley that his estimates of reve- nue were all moonshine; that his tax on books and art was an indefensible bar- barism; that his retroactive clause was a mere bogey with all the stuffing let out of it; that his reciprocity proposals were ludicrous. No such damaging re- flection has ever been made on a chair- man of the ways and means committee | by a committee of his own party in the | Senate. Mr. Dingley now says the bill reported is not the one that will pass, and that he does not accept the estimate of revenue from it. Speaker Reed rushed the tariff bill | through the: House pell-mell, in order that the Senate might the more quickly dispose of it. The announcement is now made that the fact that the bill really had no consideration in the House will contribute largely to the duration of the time that will be devoted to it in the Se- nate. While Mr. Reed may “thank God the House is not a deliberative body,” its neglect in this respect must be re- paired at the other end of the capitol. The members of the House themselves insist upon such repair. Many of the amendments made to the Dingley bill by the Senate committee were proposed by Representatives, and inserted by the committee upon their request, after Mr. Reed had denied them an opportunity to bring forward their suggestions in the House. A good authority expresses the opinion that, notwithstanding the nu- merous and radical changes made by the Senate committee, the bill in its present form is more acceptable to most mem- bers of the House than when it left that body. In other words, the Reed system of legislation has now reached the point where Representatives pass bills which they do not favor, with the expectation that the Senate will amend them so as to make them meet the views of the House. In putting a duty on hides the Senate committee has done what the House wanted to do, but was not allowed to do. Western Republican Representa- tives are already organizing to retain the duty in the bill, if it passes the Senate. Thus it is almost certain that, if there is to be any tariff bill at all, it will tax imported hides, for the first time in twenty-five years. Such a tax would have been put in the McKinley bill if Lodge and other New England Representatives had not served formal notice that they would defeat the whole bill if the tax were left in. Then the tax was taken out of the bill, although McKinley’s report explained why the committee had decided to tax hides. Re- minded of these facts the other day in the House, Mr. Dingley said that “later investigations” had persuaded the Mc- Kinley committee that the tax would not benefit the farmer. The later inves- tigations meant, of course, the Lodge ultimatum, and also the following let- ter: ‘“‘WASHINGTON, April 10, 1890. “DEAR MR. MCKINLEY: It is a great mistake to take hides from the free list, where they have been for so many years. It is a slap in the face to the South Ameri- cans with whom we are trying to enlarge our trade. It will benefit the farmer by add- | ing 5 to 8 per cent. to the price of his chil- dren’s shoes. It will yield a profit to the butcher only-—the last man that needs it. The movement is injudicious from begin- ning to end—in every form and phase. Pray stop it before it sees light. Such move- ments as this for protection wili protect the Republican party into a speedy retirement. “Yours hastily, JAMES G. BLAINE.” It is a bitter dose for the New England Republicans, but can they deny that the Rocky Mountain Republicans are sim- ply repeating the lessons taught them by New England? The view taken by the wool-growers’ tariff committee of pending legislation is that it makes no difference to the con- sumers of woollen goods how high the duties are, and that the only interest worth considering is that of the pro- ducers of wool. If the duties on wool and woollens are prohibitory, nobody is harmed. The public must in that case buy of the home manufacturer, and the latter must buy his raw material of the American wool-grower. So everybody ought to be satisfied. If under this sys- tem of thorough-going protection it be- comes necessary to tax the washerwo- man’s cup of tea for purposes of reve- nue, she is not likely to understand it, and therefore not likely to complain. This is a very plausible scheme, but it overlooks the fact that there is a limit to the purchasing power of the consumer of woollens. The theory of the high- tariff crowd, so far as they indulge in theories, is that the gains of the wool- grower are diffused through the com- munity, so that everybody is able to pay a dollar for what formerly cost him only fifty cents. This theory is rejected, for the present at all events, by the carpet- manufacturers. They say that if the Senate committee’s wool schedule passes, the public will not be able to buy the same number of yards of carpet that they have bought heretofore, and conse- quently that some of the mills must close. This is contrary to the declared intention of Mr. McKinley during the campaign. His aim was to opem mills and factories, not to shut them up. There is the duty on hides, too. Nobody believes that that will open any new tanneries, or boot and shoe factories, or harness shops. The men who operate them say that the contrary effect will be produced. So it seems that the dif- fusion theory—the theory that if A makes money out of the tariff, all of A’s customers will be prosperous—is not be- lieved in by all of its former votaries. The Chicago Times-Herald learns through its Washington office that speculations in the stock of the sugar-
Page 6
8 | ; Recs t} $3 SFR SET SS Fe NL J ~sesseildetnesenctirinteicnteccernances taaeainstaemes ange ee | The Nation. [Vol. 64, No. 1663 refining company took place last week in the office of one broker which netted a profit of $30,000, and that the custom- ers of this broker were three United States Senators. This is so surprising- ly like the charges brought, and in part proved, against certain Senators when the Gorman-Brice sugar tariff was be- fore the Senate three years ago, that the public will be very likely to put the worst possible construction on any facts, or even surmises, that find their way in- to the columns of the press. It might be supposed that at this juncture, when one of the witnesses of the last investigation is under sentence of imprisonment for refusing to testify, and when his counsel are seeking vainly for his pardon on the ground of ignorance of the law, there would be considerable hesitation to en- ter into such speculations. But that would be an unwarranted supposition. Any Senator who has incurred this risk once and come off with anything short of expulsion would not hesitate a second time. If the country has anything more to learn from such disclosures,it should be this, that the tariff system is rotten. Any system which makes all the busi- ness of the country a game of grab, where Senators and Representatives are besought, by day and by night, to put money into the pockets of A, B, and C by changes in the schedules, will draw Senators and Representatives themselves into the vortex. While voting to enrich the Sugar Trust some of them will put their hands in the sugar. The Senate, on Thursday, with charac- teristic sneers at “scientific gentlemen from Harvard College,” voted to suspend President Cleveland’s proclamation of February 22, setting aside several mil- lions of acres of public timber land as a national forest reservation. Mr. Wilson of Washington said that his people were going to have the timber, “law or no law,” and the Academy of Sciences might whistle for its pains. Alarming rumors are afloat about President Mc- Kinley’s readiness to give the miners and sheep men and timber-thieves un-° limited access to this precious part of the national domain. The case is un- doubtedly one for establishing some sort of regtlation or control of the territory set aside, so that trees may be properly cut, and mineral deposits and land suitable for agriculture opened for pre- emption; but to undo the whole work of forest reservation at a stroke seems too monstrous even for the Senate. The reckless action was taken under the form of an amendment to the sundry civil bill, with which it normally had no more to do than with the consular and diplomatic bill. But the Senate voted that the amendment was in order, and so of course it was. We are glad to observe that Vice-President Hobart took occasion to declare the practice of thus passing on points of order an exceeding- ly bad one. This may be an intimation that he means, when the occasion comes, to assert the rights of a presiding officer without too much reverence for the musty, fusty Christophers of the Senate. The tenor of the present Cuban de- bate in the Senate is significant, when one remembers the heroics of last win- ter. Even the sensational press aban- dons the once flaming subject, for fresh crimes and scandals new. Why this great change? Are the Spaniards no longer cruel? Do our hearts no more throb for Cuban liberty? As far as the situation in the island goes, there is as much to call for our intervention as there ever was. Is it mere fickleness on our part that makes us now tired of the Cuban business, as we had before tired of the Hawaiian, the Venezuelan, and the other businesses? A better explana- tion is, we think, to be found in the ex- traordinary weight in all matters of in- ternational law and international rela- tions which a President at the beginning of his term exercises as compared with one at the end of his term. The latter, as every Senator knows, is more than likely to be “all wrong” in his law, des- picable in his policy, and bent on hu- miliating the country. An incoming Pre- sident, on the contrary, is almost in- variably sound in his law, firm and dig- nified in his policy, and resolute in up- holding the country’s honor. This strik- ing difference is not at all impaired by the fact that both incoming and outgo- ing Presidents think and act precisely alike on the given question. The whole thing is a good deal of a puzzle to our more thoughtful constitutional writers. They naturally dismiss as irrelevant the fact that the incoming President has a lot of offices to give out, while the re- tiring President had bestowed all his. Speaker Reed has succeeded, through the power which he exercises by his control over the committees yet to be appointed, in getting the Republican members of the House almost unani- mously to approve his policy of doing nothing in the lower branch of Con- gress. But he cannot be very well pleas- ed with the treatment of this conclusion by the Republican party throughout the country. Many organs content them- selves with a silence which hardly con- ceals their disapproval, but not a few important newspapers are outspoken in their condemnation of Mr. Reed’s po- sition. On the very eve of the vote sus- taining his do-nothing policy which the Speaker forced the other day, both the Tribune and the Times-Herald of Chicago earnestly demanded that the House should pursue the opposite course. “Let Congress Go to Work,” was the title of @ leading editoria} article in the Times> Herald, which complained that the House had already “dawdled away a so- lid month of the public time”; declared that, if this policy was intended to make the Senate ashamed of itself for its unreasonable procrastination and re- missness, “it has utterly failed in its object”; and called upon Mr. Reed to “appoint your committees, and let the House go to work.” Under the very si- milar caption, “The House Should Get to Work,” an article in the Tribune maintained that “further inactivity on the part of the House of Representatives is inexcusable’; predicted that “the country will be profoundly dissatisfied if the House remains idle till midsummer and then adjourns after disposing of the Senate amendments to the tariff bill’; and insisted that “Speaker Reed should announce his committees and let the members get to work.” Both the Tribune and the Times-Herald specify two sub- jects regarding which the House should take action without the slightest delay. One is currency reform, the other is bankruptcy legislation, in which the whole business community is deeply in- terested. The question of consular fees at Lon- don and Liverpool has come up again, and it is understood that the President has been asked to revoke the order on the subject made by the last administra- tion. This, if done, will inure to the benefit of his cousin, William Mc- Kinley Osborne, to whom he gave the London consulship, and of James Boyle, the appointee at Liverpool. The ground suggested for the revocation is a legal one, that under the Revised Statutes all consular officers are entitled to fees for the consular signature to commercial documents. The section of the Revised Statutes referred to says, it is true, no- thing whatever about fees, but au- thorizes consuls, before certifying in- voices, to require “satisfactory evidence, either by the.oath of the person present- ing such invoices or otherwise, that such invoices are correct and true,” and adds: “In the exercise of the discretion here- by given, the consular officers shall be governed by such general or special re- gulations or instructions as may from time to time be established or given by the Secretary of State.” Under this pro- vision, it was for years understood that merchants in London and Liverpool could not make their evidence satisfac- tory without paying something for it to the consul, and in consequence it was also understood that the Liverpool office was worth at least $10,000 a year and the London office $25,000. This comfort- able arrangement, which applied to one or two other ports also, was broken up by the hypocritical Cleveland and Olney, who, under pretence of what they and those like them call “reform,” issued an order abolishing the system, thus, as the precious pair claimed, relieving shippers
Page 7
May 13, 1897] The Nation. 8351 and trade of a burden of some $50,000 a year. Gov. Black shows that he is a level- headed man by declining to affix a memorandum to the New York charter giving his reasons for signing it. ' No sensible man in his position could pur- sue any other course. “Act and keep your mouth shut,” is the only policy. Why waste time in giving reasons which will deceive nobody? Everybody knows why he signed the charter. He did it because Platt wished him to. He made proper recognition of the real author and promoter of the charter when he sent the pen with which he signed it to Platt. Whom else could he have sent it to with so much propriety? Platt is not a citizen of New York, but he has shown himself to be more powerful than all its citizens combined, and this pen is a fit symbol of his power. Every time he looks at it he can chuckle over the de- lightful way in which the Governor per- forms his duties as agent. Black’s me- thods are very similar to those of the legislative agents, though possibly a lit- tle more liberal. He always grants hear- ings to the opponents of Platt govern- mental measures, gives them ‘“‘a song and dance,” and then acts precisely as he intended to do from the beginning, with- out dignifying their protests with a word of notice. That is the delicious humor of the system, you see. It is so amusing, you know, to see these reformers guing through their “song and dance” “2 if we really had an old-fashioned system of constitutional governme™. in operation. The poor things do noi vrzalize that all this has been changed. The people of the future great city of New York cannot begin too soon to realize that a task of unprecedented magnitude has been imposed upon them. They are to set in motion on January 1 of next year the most colossal system of municipal government that this coun- try has ever seen. They are to elect in November, six months hence, a Mayor who is to have virtually unrestricted control in the selection of the men who are to administer this new government. The city over which he is to rule will have a larger population than the en- tire United States had when our nation- al government was formed, will have an annual budget of at least $75,000,000, or twenty-five times the size of that which the national government had when it began its career, and an aggregate of property so far in excess of that which the original thirteen States possessed as to defy comparison. What the municipal salary roll will aggregate no man can say now, but some idea may be formed of it from emoluments attached to the chief appointments which the new Mayor will have to make within six months after entering upon his duties, and which amount to nearly $250,000. Each of these heads of departments will have subordinates, in many cases aggregating large numbers. If the new civil-service law which the Governor has forced through the Legislature shall become law, the new heads of depart- ments will have it in their power to make a “clean sweep” of the entire mu- nicipal service. The occupation of Pharsalos and Volo by the Turks has been the military event of the week, and this has forced Greece to a modus condescendi and has enabled the Powers to intervene for a- cessation of hostilities, which will be as welcome to the victors as to the van- quished. It will be pretty to watch France and Germany determining to- gether what indemnity the loser shall pay, fixing the period of Turkish occu- pation of Thessaly, and perhaps shifting to the Turkish side of the frontier some petty Alsace-Lorraine. To separate Crete from Turkey under the guise of autonomy, and to devise means of re- imbursing Turkey out of the doubly bankrupt finances of Greece, will furnish another amusing act in this tragi-com- edy. The moral inquiry, “What is all this worth?” as to the fearful destruc- tion of life and property now drawing to a close, the terror and the misery pre- cipitated upon Christians and Moham- medans alike, may be left to some Bri- tish historian to answer. In any settlement which the Powers can now effect, one fact forces itself upon the attention, and that is that the Turks occupy a totally different position from that which they have hitherto held. Before the present troubles began, the Sultan was actually imploring Lord Salisbury to be “easy” with him, and he would most certainly be good in fu- ture, while Lord Salisbury was warning him in a public speech in London of his impending doom if he did not mend his ways. He has not mended his ways, but he has, with the aid or connivance of the Powers, including England, since obtained some very notable advantages. He has settled the Armenian question by massacring the Armenians; he has mobilized a powerful army, well officer- ed, armed, and equipped; he has suc- ceeded in getting the Powers to neu- tralize Crete, which was ready for an- nexation to Greece, and has been allow- ed to invade and conquer one of the principal Greek provinces, which he now holds, while demanding a war indemni- ty, or territory—and all this in the face of the promises of Europe recorded in the Berlin Treaty for twenty years. Lord Salisbury made a speech on Thursday at the annual meeting of the Primrose League, in which he defended the action of the Powers towards Greece. He said that the Treaty of Paris, made at the close of the Crimean war, bound them to respect the “integrity” of Tur- key; that they now formed a “federa- tion,” the object of which was the pre- servation of the peace of Europe; that the war between Greece and Turkey was a local affair, and that ali danger of a general war had passed away, i. e., through the action of the concerted Powers. The latter part of this state- ment is pure prediction, intended to re- assure England; but the first part is a serious perversion of historical facts. Literally, it is true that the Powers in 1856 promised to respect the integrity of Turkey, but the fact is that the history of Europe from that time to this is the history of the collapse of Turkey .and dismemberment of its territory under the supervision of these same Powers; while to call the Concert a Federation is really the artful application of a term which does not describe it. The Concert has nothing federal about it, for there is no agreement at the bottom of it to which any one can appeal, and it is not inconsistent with secret arrangements and treaties between the parties to it, totally inconsistent with the preserva- tion of peace. Moreover, the Treaty of Paris was substantially superseded in 1878 by the Treaty of Berlin, and it is in the latter instrument that the present obligations of England towards Crete and the Christians are to be found. The serious difficulties in the way of Australian federation, if not its impend- ing failure, reported a week ago, were, in fact, foreshadowed from the very opening of the convention to draft a federal constitution. This body met at Adelaide on March 22, and, while unani- mously in favor of the principle of federation, found itself at once divided on almost all questions of detail. The sharpest clash came just where it did in our own convention of 1787, on the question of the equality of the smaller States in the upper house. A subordi- nate part of this controversy involved the right of the upper house to amend money bills sent to it by the lower. This right was stoutly asserted by the delegates from Tasmania, West Austra- lia, and the smaller States generally. However, a majority of two votes finally decided, early in April, that the upper house should not have the right to amend money bills, as the United States Senate has, but should follow the prac- tice of the House of Lords. Thereupon the West Australian delegates with- drew, saying that if the larger colonies were not willing to make this concession to the smaller, they would have to fede- rate bythemselves. Compromise may yet do in the Adelaide convention what it accomplished in the Philadelphia con- vention; but the present outlook does not promise it, a
Page 8
t i ' i 4 / i sels 352 The Nation. [Vol. 64, No. 1663 CONFESSED FAILURE OF PRO- TECTION. The week which has elapsed since the Senate tariff bill was reported and pub- lished discovers the Republiean press and party in confusion. Counsels are di- vided; even the familiar old prophecies that “all will come out right in the end,” with a reunited party, are put forward with unwonted timidity. It would be hard to recall a condition of party be- wilderment and alarm at the work of its own leaders equal to that in which the Republicans now find themselves. Like the nursery artist, the party looks at its drawing of a tariff bill, and is frightened at the ogre which its own hands have made. The reason for this trepidation and looking every man at his neighbor in wild surmise does not lie in any given schedule Of the Senate bill. New England looks hard at the tax on hides, but that is only a minor grievance, after all. The sugar schedule is confessed by the Tribune to be much more favorable to the Sugar Trust than was the Wilson bill, which it denounced on that score; but this might be mended or endured. But what can- not be mended or endured is the con- fession by the Senate committee that the whole Republican system of protection has broken down; that the policy for which the party has fought, in victory and defeat, for twenty years, has now, in the hour of victory, to be abandoned as a failure. That is the true significance of the Senate bill and of the Republican per- turbation in view of it. Enemies of pro- tection have said that it was an anti- quated and outgrown policy; but now its friends acknowledge it. Opponents of protective taxes have asserted that not enough money could be got from them to pay the expenses of the Government; at last friends of protective taxes are forced to admit it. The proposed tax on tea,’with the increased taxes on beer and tobacco, in a bill drawn by a Republican committee, with their hands free, is a standing confession that the protective system, as we have known it, has passed away. It would be cruel, as it would be need- less, to go back to the debates of 1888 and 1890 to show what the historic Re- publican position on this question really is. Everybody knows that taxes for revenue were to be avoided like the pest —any tax, in fact, that any American citizen had to pay was to be shunned religiously. Breakfast - tables and tea- tables, too, were to be unvexed by the presence of the tax-gatherer. Internal- revenue taxes were to be reduced and eventually abolished altogether, and ample revenue for the Government, at the same time with full protection to American labor, provided by a high pro- tective tariff. We say it is not necessary to go back six years to prove this to be the Republican policy; it is necessary to go back only two months. In Presi- dent McKinley’s inaugural address he distinctly said that “every form of di- rect taxation except in time of war” was to be avoided, affirming that “the country is clearly opposed to any need- less additions to the subjects of internal taxation, and is committed .. . to the system of tariff taxation.” The comment of the Republican Senate, eight weeks later, is a tax on tea and higher taxes on beer and tobacco. And Mr. McKinley’s newspaper friends say he is pleased with this Senate bill, largely because it promises to raise the needed revenue! The man who really prophesied what the new tariff bill would be was not Mr. McKinley, but Mr. Carlisle. In his last annual report, discussing calmly the fis- cal situation, he laid down the principles to which the Senate committee has re- luctantly come. He distinctly informed Congress and the country that, if the present scale of public expenditure is to be kept up, “it will be necessary to re- sort to taxation upon various kinds of importations heretofore exempted sim- ply because they were not included within the scope of the protective theo- ry.” He added, with a brusque disre- gard of the opinions which Mr. McKin- ley was complacently to express in his inaugural, “it is evident that new ob- jects of taxation must be included in our tariff schedules, or the attempt to secure the usual proportion of revenue from customs must be abandoned.” The Se- nate bill was framed as if in exact and conscious fulfilment of these predictions. It is a great triumph for Mr. Carlisle, as a lucid reasoner on finance, but the real victors are the laws of trade, the progress of industry and invention, the growth of the country. Whatever may be said of protection theoretically or historically, it is obsolete as far as the United States is concerned. A _ tariff which will at once bring in revenue and make high prices for manufacturers is no longer a possibility. This truth is now publicly confessed by the greatest tariff experts in the Republican party. After weeks of wrestling with the prob- lem, they have had to turn to revenue duties. They tacitly come over to the position of their adversaries, and say that the hocus-pocus of keeping out im- ports and at the same time collecting revenue on them is now too transparent a trick to be tried again. If the Trea- sury really must have money, reve- nue taxes must be laid, and even Ameri- cans, tenderly reared as they have been in the belief that they need pay no fede- ral taxes, must begin to go down into their pockets. This is a tremendous party rightabout, but it has now been made. With Republican leaders thus openly converted, in fact if not in creed, to the doctrine of taxation for revenue, it ought not to be so difficult to give a little more rationality to our taxing methods. Why, in fact, might not Congress drop the whole protective humbug, as it has dropped a part of it? Why might not the revenue features of the Senate bill be made law, and the rest of the tariff left as it is? Messrs. Allison and Aldrich practically confess that Master Dingley has been trifling with the laws of trade and has got badly hurt; why should they want to write themselves down silly boys like him? THE PAUPER LABOR OF ASIA. For a long period of time the very ba- sis of the plea for a protective tariff was the competition in manufactures from England. The advocates of a high ta- riff never wearied of describing the “pauper” labor of England, and the ne- cessity of protective duties here to pre- vent labor in the United States from fall- ing to the same level of wages—to them one of indescribable misery and extreme poverty. Even within a few years an account of the hand nail-makers in the iron district was circulated as a cam- paign document, and was regarded by protectionists as the best evidence of what “free trade” in England had done for the workingmen. But the picture of women hammering out the nails was recognized as a phase of campaign argu- ment which was rapidly passing away. The pauper-labor argument went the path of the “British gold” argument and the forged extracts from English papers. The question of labor cost is now dis- cussed from a more scientific standpoint, and the fallacy of basing conclusions up- on money wages has been exposed. Ex- perience has demonstrated that high wages in the United States mean high productive ability, and when American manufactures meet similar foreign pro- ducts in neutral markets, and control those markets, the theory of the protec- tionist falls. The view that high money wages mean high cost of manufacture dies hard. As the exporter of manufactures, England was looked upon as the country most to be feared. When Continental nations began to manufacture on so large a scale as to provide a surplus for export, the “pauper labor of Europe” became the bugaboo, and the wages of the Con- tinent, much lower in money than the wages of England, were quoted by high- tariff stump-orators. For some years the sums of money received weekly by the glassmakers of Belgium, the ribbon- makers of France, and the textile-work- ers of Germany have done yeoman ser- vice in bolstering up the demands of our manufacturers that duties should be maintained because of our “high-priced and dear labor.” It was useless to re- peat that money wages did not express labor cost, or that England would long since have been driven from the field by this “pauper” labor of Europe if the ar-
Page 9
May 13, 1597| The Nation. T guments of the protectionists were true. tomers for our products than the United Any sort of a table was prepared, show- ing a remarkable difference in money wages, and this table, without comment or explanation, was looked upon as un- States is for theirs. While failing to see any immediate danger from this Asiatic competition, we | are obliged to recognize the use likely answerable proof of what the protection- | ists asserted. - Signs of another change of base are now visible. Continental Europe may still serve to frighten a few who have not been enlightened, and even English wages are quoted occasionally as a me- morial of the good old days when such an argument was accepted without ques- tion. But neither of these excites the same horror that it once did, and the pauper labor of Asia is now the scare- crow. Manufacturers passed before the committee of ways and means and urged duties that would protect them and the labor they employed from the products of China and Japan, of British India, and the East Indies. The harrowing condition of labor in those parts was dwelt upon with almost morbid horror, and any wages—a few cents a day — were nained as representing the earn- ings of these peoples. Textile fibres grown by “pauper labor or labor paid in the most niggardly manner’; chemi- cals, made or to be made in China, with labor at starvation wages; machinery and machine products, the outcome of Japanese ingenuity in applying their ri- diculously cheap labor to copying Ame- rican inventions and trademarks—these are a few of the matters brought before the committee. One and all spoke of the impending (for there was always an atmosphere of futurity in the condi- tions they described) influx of Eastern copies of Western manufactures, and one and all saw in a nearly prohibitive tariff the safety of the infant industries of the United States. This scare over the possible competi- tion in the East has grown in recent years, and now threatens to become an actual factor in tariff legislation in this country. For our part, a study of the commerce between the United States and Asia fails to discover any evidence of this competition. In the last five years our imports from China have gained $1,600,000; but this increase is almost entirely to be found in the single item of raw silk. In the same period the im- ports from British India and the British East Indies decreased $4,400,000, and not a single item of manufactures shows a larger import in the year 1896 than in that of 1892. With Japan, the country most to be feared in manufactures, our imports have gained $1,800,000 in five years, and in manufactures of silk, flax, and hemp there has been a small in- crease; yet it is an increase too small to weigh in the supply of such a market as the United States. Our exports to Japan have gained $4,300,000 in five years, to China $1,300,000, and to British India have lost $400,000. On the face of the returns these countries are better cus- | explicit enough, yet Gov. Griggs says | that the election dispelled the black | cloud of Bryanism, and that the Demo- | erats who voted for McKinley should to be made of it in fixing tariff duties. | | riously argue, except in an after-dinner The tariff of 1883 was determined by a fear of European competition. An ave- | rage duty of 45 per cent. was regarded as | good protection against the Continent | of Europe as well as England; against | the machine products of Great Britain, France, and Germany, as well as against the house industries of Russia and Aus- tria. If that rate was required against Europe, what rate will be demanded against Asia? THE CURRENCY DANGER. The Governor of New Jersey, in his speech last week at the dinner to Am- bassador Porter, denied that Sound- ask for nothing more. Probably the Governor would not se- speech, that a popular election makes legislative enactment unnecessary. The only chance the people have at a law is to vote that it shall be made or repealed. Their suffrages can neither make nor unmake it. Legislatures and Congress- es obtain, or ought to obtain, guidance in law-making from an expression of the popular will; but the specific laws | to execute the popular will have to be passed in legislative halls; they do not Money Democrats had any just cause of | | of the country for four years, whether complaint in“the dawdling and do-no- thing policy of the present Congress as respects currency reform. They were | not deceived, he asserted, and have al- ready got what was promised them— salvation from Bryanism.” ‘What do we care now,” “the black cloud of | went on Gov. Griggs, “if gold goes out | or comes in? For four years the coun- try is saved, its financial honor is saved. We are in no danger, for even if any- thing happens to our President, there is another hand to take the nation’s helm and hold it steadfast.” Gov. Griggs was himself among the foremost to invite and acknowledge the coéperation of Sound-Money Democrats in the election of McKinley. He knows how many of them must have contri- buted in Democratic New Jersey towards the majority of 81,000 which McKinley obtained in that State. But he ought also to know that they were promised, and voted in order to obtain, not only an escape from the silver standard, but the secure establishment of the gold standard. This was not merely the logic of the campaign and the burden of in- numerable speeches; it was the express pledge of the party platform and can- didate. The platform specifically recog- nized the need of legislative enactment to “maintain inviolably” the gold stan- dard, and solemnly bound the party to “favor all measures” designed to do so. No promise made to the Sound-Money Democrats which has not already been | fulfilled? What, then, did President Mc- | Kinley mean in his inaugural address by saying that it is “necessary to devise a system” to remedy the “constant em- barrassment to the Government” caused by ‘the several forms of our paper money”? Why did he say that “our financial system needs revision,” and that our money should “be put upon an enduring basis, not subject to easy at- | tack, nor its stability to doubt or dis- pute’? Here are promises and pledges emerge magically from the ballot-boxes. The absurdity of having to argue this with a man of Gov. Griggs’s intelligence only shows how he forsook his intelli- gence when he declared that the vote of last November saved the financial honor anything is done to reform the currency or not. Reverse the case. Suppose Bryan had won. Would he and the silverites have fallen back on the popular majori- ty and said nothing more was neces- sary? Would they have attempted to still popular clamor by saying that Pre- sident Bryan’s heart was true to silver, and that, even if anything happened to him, there was glorious Sewall ready to keep the helm steadfast? Everybody knows that nothing of the kind would have been the case. Bryan specifically asked for the election of a Congress to give him the laws that would be needed to put the country on a silver basis. He knew that a popular election, however overwhelming the verdict it pronounced, would go for nothing unless that verdict were written into law. But, putting one side all talk about party obligations and promises made to Sound-Money Democrats, what are the facts? Is our currency system rational and secure, or is it not? Gov. Griggs’s own argument implies that it is not. He rests all our hopes on the fidelity of the President or Vice-President. That is to say, all depends upon the Execu- tive; the law is wavering and uncertain. Another President might wreck all un- der color of the very laws which enabled President Cleveland to save the nation from dishonor. No country is safe in such a condition as that. No financial system can inspire anything but dis- trust when it is so at the mercy of a changing Executive. Law and statute are for the express purpose of removing such vital interests from control by the personal caprice of any public officer. Our present condition is one of unstable equilibrium. That is what alarms tue country, as well as exasperates Demo- crats who think themselves tricked. Positive financial legislation is needed. It must be speedily undertaken, if at all. | To wait for the regular session is to wait
Page 10
i St ee ey rr eng apn ieraeconnapeing mae gpeme= 3854 The Nation. [Vol. 64, No. 1663 in vain. To wait for the next Congress is to wait for a Congress that will be hostile. When is President McKinley going to tell Congress that he, at least, will no longer consent to dangerous delay? MORE ABOUT GREEK EXCAVATIONS. ATHENS, April 10, 1897. THE Greek Archeological Society was founded in 1837. In 1896 it was reorganized with the Crown Prince Constantine as presi- dent, and with most of the native-born archeologists by profession in control of the machine. The society has ever gained its money from a lottery, which for years sald 150,000 tickets, four times a year, at two drachmas a ticket. In 1895 the number of lottery tickets was raised to 225,000. This number is sold out at each drawing, ana, after the premiums have been paid, the so- cigty finds itself in possession of 268,000 drachmas a year wherewith to conduct ex- cavations, pay salaries of officials, and care for antiquities in general throughout the kingdom. The society has done noble work with the money thus gained, as the Acropo- lis, Epidaurus, Eleusis, and many other places prove conclusively. This year, too, excavations have been conducted in various places in Greece. Some of them I mentioned in a recent letter to the Nation; others I mention below, basing my account on the Praktika for 1896 by Kabbadias. The excavation of Eleusis was continued. The object this year was to investigate the southern court of the temple and the south- ern slope of the Acropolis. But, owing to the great depth of the débris with which this region is covered, the excavations were not completed, though they continued from June to October. Some facts in regard to the architecture of the Bouleuterion have been gained. The corridor by the southern gate of the temple was completely excavated, with the result that the inscription C. I. A. iv., 2, 1054, which contains the specifications of a build- ing to be erected on the spot, does not agree with what was actually found. The building, therefore, was never begun. Very few pieces of sculpture and inscriptions were found. But, in atonement for this lack, the excavator came upon a rich and unique collection of vases of the geometrical or linear style. These treasures were found in an ancient cemetery outside the temple- precinct. It was a fortunate circumstance that this cemetery had never been over- hauled in antiquity or in modern times, and for that reason its contents are of immense importance for the study of the art of the period to which they belong. Excavations were made in Myceng in- side the Acropolis. In some places the earth to be removed was forty feet deep, and, when removed, a wealth of labyrinthine walls of houses stood revealed. The un- tutored visitor stands dazed before this mass of walls, whose purpose perhaps no one will ever be able to divine. Many of them form rooms, with walls thirty feet high, but with no doorways whatever. The complete exca- vation of the Acropolis of Mycenz will be accomplished this year, when Tsountas will undertake a description of the entire cita-- del, giving plans and photographs. Out- side the Acropolis walls, eight new tombs were found and added to the large list al- ready uncovered by Tsountas. Being far from the Acropolis, these tombs belonged to poorer families, and therefore yielded few objects of interest. Seven of them are rock- cut tombs, but the eighth is a beehive or vaulted tomb in an excellent state of preser- vation and of great importance architectu- rally. It contained three graves, each cov- ered with large stone slabs, but unfortunate- ly the graves had been robbed in antiquity. Tsountas thinks, though he gives no rea- son for the surmise, that the robbers were members of the family to which the tomb belonged—a case that is not without a parallel at Mycenz. On the floor of this tomb were found numerous objects, among others, certain small plaques of glass paste bearing animal-headed daimones standing round a tripod or an altar and carrying vases in their hands. These plaques are important for the insight they give us of religion in Greece in the most archaic times. This is the first instance of animal-headed daimones on ornaments of glass. They also prove that glass was made here in the Mycenzan period. Among the finds on the Acropolis itself may be mentioned an archaic inscription on bronze, a piece of sculpture representing an animal-headed daimon subduing two lions, and lastly, the head of a woman 0.17m. high. This head has colored hair, eyes, ears, and mouth; it is further adorned with four orna- ments painted on the forehead, the cheeks, and the chin—a fact which seems to prove that in earliest Mycenzwan times it was customary to paint or tattoo the body. I have elsewhere pointed out the astonishing parallelism between the dress of the My- cenzan female and that of the squaws of the Mojave Indians. This matter of paint- ing or tattooing the body furnishes still an- other parallel. Because of its size and workmanship, this unique head is of the utmost importance for the history of My- cenzan and of Greek art in general. The excavations that were begun at Epi- daurus in 1881 were continued throughout this year also. The Stadium was uncovered, and the Hippodrome was found at a distance of about a quarter of an hour from thg tem- ple of Asklepios. The ruins that have been uncovered up to this time extend over an immense territory, and are the despair of the traveller who is foolish enough to at- tempt to see Epidaurus and return to Nau- plia the same day—a thing that most men do, owing to the difficulty of securing en- tertainment at Ligouris. But, in spite of the vastness of the uncovered area, a large out- lying territory still remains to be unearthed, though probably it contains only the sub- structures of private houses. Fortunately Epidaurus is not deeply covered, as is the case, for instance, at Corinth, where the excavations will be very costly, owing to the fact that the wicked old city is buried beneath twenty or thirty, sometimes even forty feet of dirt. But in this very fact lies our best-founded hope of discovering some- thing in spite of Mummius and others who helped to cover Corinth with such a shroud of earth. Near Amarousion, on the old road to Pentele, a large mound had long excited curiosity. The mound is forty-six metres in diameter by eight in height at present, though originally it was much higher. The mound was partially excavated in 1890, when many large rectangular blocks were found at varying heights, but the excavations were abandoned too soon, and the purpose of the mound remained a mystery until the recent excavations, ‘which have proved that the tumulus was a vast family tomb. A trench was driven through the mound, in the centre of which a base built of the colossal stones mentioned above was found. Originally this base pierced the tumulus to its summit and was crowned by some imposing memorial of the dead. Earth was heaped systematically around this central structure in layers that can be distinguished easily to-day. Some slight excavations were made at the Amphiareum, and at Lykosoura, but without noteworthy results. At Daphne, Signore Novo, a Venetian artist, has been busy the entire year in an attempt to patch up and preserve the mo- saics of the monastery. The tomb of Marathon has been rebuilt or restored to the condition it was in before it was excavated. The great iron fence around the Dionysiac Theatre has been finished; the stone blocks have been piled up, and the excavated dirt has been put back in many places. The re- gion about the Asklepieion will be treated in a similar way this year. An iron fence will enclose the Odeion of Herodes Atticus and extend around to the Acropolis. Similar fences have been erected around the Stoa and the old market, at great cost. Measures have also been taken to preserve the ruins at Orchomenos. In addition to the Ephemeris Archeologike, the Archsological Society has undertaken the publication of three other works: Lol- ling’s Catalogue of the Epigraphical Mu- seum, which will be a gadsend to many peo- ple; a periodical under the title of Monu- ments of Greece (Mvnucia ris ‘EAAdéos), to contain phototypes of the most important works of art, accompanied by short expla- natory texts; and lastly Caweran’s topo- graphical and architectural plans of the ex- cavations on the Acropolis from 1885 to 1891. For many years past, visitors to Athens have been distressed to see the hills around Athens ruthlessly blasted away and destroy- ed in order to furnish the city with building material and with lime. The Frog’s Mouth has been uterly ruined; Lycabettos has been hopelessly disfigured; the same is true of the Mouseion hill and the old city of the Kranaans south of the Pnyx. It will delight every one to know that this vandalism will proceed no further, thanks to a law that re- cently passed the Parliament. Unhappily, the law came thirty years too late, for the huge gaping holes that have been made in these classic hills can never be refilled; the ghastly sores are too deep for healing by any medicaments that man may apply. It will interest a wide circle in America to know just what the Archwological Society has expended on excavations and in the care of the antiquities during the past year: Seaffolding for Parthenon repairs...... Drs. 84.622 Mosaics at Daphne.........sseceeseees 18.314 Excavations at Epidaurus............. 8.603 Excavations at Mycemae.........see0% 9.898 Excavations at Eleusis....... eccdecese 5.616 Excavations at North Slope Acropolis.. 12.295 Excavations at Outer Ceramicus...... 3.172 Excavations at Dipylon Mound..... ° -783 Excavations at Amarousi Mound...... -966 Excavations at Amphiareum........... 127 Excavations at Lykosoura....... eceee 217 Excavations at Stoa of Attalus...... ; .564 Fence around Theatre of Dionysos.... 20.122 Fence around Stoa..........ceeseseeee 5.878 Fence around Old Market........ceseee 15.829 Purchases for Museum.....cccccccccce 5,000
Page 11
May 13, 1897] The Nation. 355 This does not take into account the ex- | penditures for the various publications and for salaries. The sums above speak for | themselves; for .impoverished Greece they | are colossal; they should put America to shame and induce our moneyed men to give | at least one million dollars for the excava- tion of Corinth, for it will take fully that much to do the work thoroughly, and to publish the results worthily and fittingly. J. R. S. STERRETT. NAPOLEON AT ELBA. Paris, April 18, 1897. No one, says the proverb, is a great man to his valet. It may be said, also, that the great man has somewhat to lose, if you study him when he is fallen from power. The light through which we view him is not the same; he is not so muchchanged as are those who observe him. The philosopher can see the same man in the Hermit of Friedrichs- ruhe and in the powerful Iron Chancellor who so long kept Europe under his influ- ence; but the general public is not made up of philosophers. The official editors of the ‘Correspondence of Napoleon I.,’ which was published in many volumes by order of Na- poleon III., at the imperial printing-office, took care to pass lightly over the period of the Emperor’s sojourn in the island of Elba. They published only one hundred and four- teen letters of that period, which was fol- lowed by the dramatic Hundred Days. They used either the originals, which were com- municated to them by Gen. Henry Ber- trand, or some well-authenticated letters which were written under Napoleon’s dicta- tion and preserved in the library of the Louvre. The register of these last letters was preceded by a note in these terms: “This register of the letters and orders dictated by the Emperor for the administra- tion of the island and of his guard was writ- ten by me, his secretary, under his dicta- tion. Paris, March 20, 1847. RATHBERY.” The original text of this register, preserved at the Louvre, was destroyed in the fire of 1871. Curiously enough, a copy of it was pre- served and is now at Carcassonne. This copy was made for M. Cornet Reyrusse (son- in-law of Peyrusse, a faithful servant and treasurer of Napoleon), who intended to write a history of the Emperor at Elba. This manuscript of Carcassonne (which bears the number 260 in the catalogue of the manuscripts of the Carcassonne Library) is 4 a volume of one hundred and fiftypages. M. Cornet Peyrusse died before having even be- gun the history of the Elba period; and the register has now been published by M. Léon Pélissier, a professor in the University of Montpellier. The volume has for its title, ‘The Register of the Island of Elba: Letters and Inedited Orders of Napoleon I. (28 mai, 1814-22 février, 1815). The editors of the voluminous correspond- ence of Napoleon I. did not think it necessary to publish all the letters which M. Pélissier now publishes. They were not only afraid to increase too much a collection which con- tains no less than 20,000 pieces; they tried to | establish a certain proportion between the number of the documents and the importance of the period to which they refer. The choice, sometimes arbitrary, of the commis- sion which published the correspondence was, however, not always inspired by such con- siderations. “Other motives,” says M. Pélissier, ‘“‘some- times guided it. It was thought necessary to keep for Napoleon the heroic and super- human attitude which the memorial of Saint Helena gave him, and to allow his letters to | represent him as he wished to be painted. It was thought necessary to show him, as it were, with the aureola of the admiration and devotion of his guard and of the troops of the | island of Elba. Consequently the letters re- lative to the revolts of his grenadiers and to their punishment were almost all put aside. The reign of Napoleon at Elba was to have been an era of perfect happiness for the in- habitants of the island chosen as a residence by Napoleon ‘in consideration of the mild- ness of their character and of the goodness of the climate’ (such were the expressions of Napoleon in a letter written by him to General Dalesme, and the good people of the island themselves really thought for a while that Napoleon had come voluntarily, with a view to taking a little repose among them). The letters concerning the severe repression of a popular tumult at Capgliveri, other letters relating to the indebtedness incurred in the island and left unpaid, were not published, as well as many others which pertained to vulgar details, the table of the officers, the distribution of linen jn the household, etc., etc.” It is evident that, after his great cam- paign in France, his abdication at Fon- tainebleau, his journey to Saint-Tropez, through Provence, when his life was con- stantly in danger, Napoleon might have sunk in Elba into a state of complete apa- thy. He left a world behind him—not only a material world, but a world of emotions, of perils, of gigantic plans; and he sank into the state of a landed proprietor, of a small farmer, unseen, unknown. Yet such was the elasticity of his nature, he was so essentially a man of action, that he took as good care of the small guard which had been left to him as he had ever done of the “Grande Armée”’; he preoccupied himself as much with the needs of the small island of Elba as he had ever done with the needs of France and the immense provinces which he had added to ancient France. He was as autocratic in Elba as he had been in Paris. Nothing was done or could be done without direct orders from him. M. Pélissier is un- just when he says that the prosperity of the island never interested Napoleon; his publication shows that the Emperor initiat- ed many measures of public interest, sani- tary measures, erection of fountains, plant- ing of trees along the road, water-works, etc.; he made plans for the opening of schools, for drawing and for sculpture, for a polytechnic school. His activity was extraordinary. We see him looking into the finances of every com- mune, of the hospital of Porto Ferrajo, or- ganizing a police, a gendarmerie, a small army, a navy, the defences of the coast: opening roads, building bridges over tor- rents. His administration in Elba is imbued with the same spirit as it was in France. “In whatever situation fortune may place me,”’ be had once said to the Treasurer Peyrusse, “I will never tolerate any fripon- nerie.”’ It is true, he said once, “We are here no longer in Paris’; still, he keeps up his old habits, the respect of form, of registration, of control. M. Pélissier says of him: “Sous l’autocrate, le bureaucrate”; and adds that his letters reveal ‘“‘the revival, with extraordinary vital intensity, of the officier d’administration in the generalissimo. So long as Napoleon could apply himself to great affairs, so long as he could leave to his subordinates the care of details, it might be thought that with him the genius of social organization, like the genius of war, was pure and detached from all mean- ness. But here, when fate had reduced him to administer petty affairs himself, one is surprised and frightened at seeing, under the mask of Cesar growing fat, the petty soul of a riz-pain-sel [such is the familiar name given in the French army by the sol- diers to the officers of the supplies depart- ment—intendance]}.”” Napoleon knew better than M. Pélissier that there are no petty details in the organization of an army, that. the smallest differences in the expenses of a soldier are multiplied by thousands and very soon by millions; that the efficiency of an army depends upon these. details. He had found, after the Directory, not only the mili- tary administration of France, but its civil administration, in a state of hopeless dis- order and chaos; he introduced order every- where, showed the greatest severity to those who squandered or stole the public money; he organized the inorganic masses which had been freed by the French Revolution. He could not help doing at Elba, where he was still a sovereign, what he had always done. The stage had changed, the actor was the same. It seems to me that M. Pélissier also takes a narrow view of his subject when he says: “Lower still in his heart there survives the soldier of fortune; the Corsican gentilldtre, the thin and underfed young man for whom the trade of arms was at first only a mode of bread-winning and the means for obtain- ing a pension. Aroused from his unheard-of dream of fifteen years (and it seems impossible that, during these fifteen years, he should not have had at times the sensation that all this was unreal, that normal life was in suspense for him), the captain of artillery of the siege of Toulon re- turing to common life, to a legal situation, could congratulate himself on having found for his old age an assured and peaceful exis- tence. In his conversations, his letters, one feels, amidst a thousandother feelings, along with the bitterness of a fallen soveretgn, the proprietor’s feeling of plenitude. He wishes to make his retreat as comfortable as he can and to secure the highest possible in- come... . He shows a true bourgeois passion for building. He must above all as- sure his finances; his first care is to verify his resources, to make his budget, to lay his hand on all the revenues of the domain —salt, mines, woods, taxes.’ I can see in this disposition of Napoleon, as well as in his habit of controlling all the expenses of his household, only the re- sult of acquired habits of economy and order; I cannot help thinking that the extraordinary activity of Napoleon at Elba and the interest shown in the minutest af- fairs of the island served him as a veil to cover the project which he was forming of a return to France. M. Pélissier is not of this mind; he does not admit any premedi- tation for the famous return from Elba. “The letters,’ he says, “do not allow us to suppose this premeditation. It is not be- cause the absence of political letters author- izes this negative conclusion, for from the fact that there is no trace of them in this register of Rathery, it would be imprudent as well as foolish to conclude that no such letters were written, by him as well as by others. It is rather the multiplicity of business letters, the infinite detail of internal questions, which force us to this negative conclusion.” M. Pélissier believes that Napoleon was resigned to his fate; he cannot think that this mass of administrative papers served as a mask to cover a long conspiracy. We know that the French agents at Leg- horn and on the coast towns of Italy kept the French Government as well as M. de Talleyrand at Vienna informed of the small-
Page 12
mitre WENN eos ee 356 The Nation. [Vol. 64, No. 1663 est incidents relative to Napoleon, while he. was at Elba, of all the movements of his family, of all the visits which he received; but Napoleon had shown on his return from Egypt that he knew how to prepare in se- cret a coup d’état, and had kept all parties and all men in the dark about his real in- tentions before the 18th Brumaire. M. Pé- lissier publishes himself in his volume three letters which show clearly that Napoleon had secret relations with the Continent: one relates to a journey in Tuscany of Countess Walewska, who had remained faithful to him since the days of Poland; in another letter, we see that Napoleon tries to send dispatches in a Neapolitan ship; in another, he invites Col. Mallet to advise the grenadiers who go back to France from Elba to send notes to their comrades re- maining at Elba ‘‘on the state of the pub- lic mind.’’ Napoleon’s resolution was taken only after the visit of Fleury de Chabou- lon; but we believe that the project of a re- turn to France was constantly in his mind. He watched events on the Continent with the most eager interest and the trans- formation of public opinion in France, after the return of the Bourbons. Even on his way to the coast of Provence, after he had been forced to abdicate, he had conversation with the foreign officers who accompanied him and saw him embark, which proved that he was not resigned and had not said his last word in history. Correspondence. PROTECTION AND THE MONROE DOC- TRINE. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Has it ever occurred to the distin- guished Jingo from Massachusetts, or to any of his colleagues, that our protective tariff is at the bottom of all our trouble with the Monroe Doctrine? Of course, England and the other greedy Powers eagerly swallow all the fat business opportunities which this generous nation of ours allows them to seize. So long as we leave any ripe plums growing on the outside of our Chinese wall, just so long will those hungry Powers come all the way across the Atlantic to gather them. What’s the use of the Monroe Doctrine, anyway, if we can’t get the Pan-American products over our own fence? We might as well let Europe in outright; then she would not have so many ignorant emigrants to flood off on us. But, no! the glorious Doctrine must be maintained—and so must protection. We need only increase our navy to a point where we shall no longer be obliged to sub- mit every petty claim against us to arbitra tion, but shall be able to prescribe that me- thod of settlement to all other nations. Our home securities, to be sure, may fluctuate more or less under continuous doses of war scare; but then they represent protected in- dustries, and must expect to take a bitter pill now and then; perhaps some day it will produce nausea, and Congress will see the errors of its way. With the Chinese wall removed, the gun- boats could withdraw to make way for our merchants, who would quietly proceed to drive out those European hucksters from the South American market. JOHN ALDEN LEE. MILTON, Mass., May 3, 1897. A NEW PARTY. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: The inquiry, “Why Not a New Party?” in this week’s Nation, has often INDENTURED SERVANTS. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: My mother, now seventy-six years | old, tells me that she very frequently heard suggested itself to the writer, and must have | done so to many others who find no political | resting-place in any of the parties now ex- isting. Certainly the need of a new party is as great as it was when the Republican party was founded. The manner of its founding suggests the method to be pur- sued to-day. Let the Democrats who voted for Palmer break with the present Demo- cratic party, and call for a convention of those citizens everywhere who favor the principles of the Indianapolis platform. There must be many everywhere who would join a real party of ideas. 7. GD. HISTORY REPEATING ITSELF. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: I have never known an implied pre- diction of coming events so completely veri- fied in so short a time as in the letter of “W. J. S.,” in the Nation of March 18, on “The Motive of Greek Intervention.” He says, among other things: “The result was the blockade of the Pei- reus, which closed the agitation and per- mitted the Ministry to resign, with a flam- ing appeal to the nation, saying what it would have done if the Powers had not stopped it; the fact:being that the Turkish General had his orders to cross the frontier if the provocation lasted another day, and march on Athens, which he would have done with no serious difficulty, since the Greek army lacked organization and even the shad- ow of discipline. Tricoupis came to power just in time to save Greece from a disaster, but, as the ranters of Athens said, only to prevent Greece from going to Constantino- ple. The Turks would have been in Athens in less than two weeks, there being on the frontier 40,000 men, many of whom were veterans of the Bulgarian war.” Here, then, we have in the statement of | what would have been in 1886, a fairly ac- curate description of what has been in 1897. The American people may now see what “W. J. S.”’ saw in advance, that the occupation of Crete and the war with Turkey, were not brought about by an intelligent, self-re- strained, determined people, but by the Jin- goes, the politicians, the editors, and the idle inflammatory material of the Grecian cities. The Ministers yielded because otherwise they would have “‘to go’; the King yielded be- cause he thought war safer than revolution. The result, of course, is that the brave and heroic have poured out their blood and laid down their lives for the cause of the Jingoes; that the innocent inhabitants of village and country are subjected to the ravages of war; that the Jingo element is laying the blame upon the monarchy, and trying to set up a republic to keep the Turks out of Athens, and valorously insulting the wife and daugh- ters of the King when they appear in the streets. Personal bravery, love of country, hatred | | expected “epilogus,” see Laberius, p. 286 of the oppressor are priceless elements in national. character. These the Greeks have. But these are not all the elements needful to make a great people or, in the present | age, to wage a successful war. A successful | war, to-day, may be defined to be “‘a terri- ble product of industrial and scientific pre- paration.”” This the Jingo does not know. He may be defined to be ‘a survival of medieval ignorance.’’ Cc. C. N. WASHINGTON, May, 1897. her mother (living in the Cumberland Val- ley, Pa.) refer to the practice, as rather a common thing, of very respectable people, in the early days of immigration, contract- ing with a ship’s captain to have him “sell their time” in America for a sum suf- ficient to repay him for the amount of their passage-money from Great Britain. One or another of the well-to-do farmers in their vicinity would be spoken of as children of “Redemptionists,””’ and not at all to their discredit. They simply worked their pas sage, only doing their work after landing instead of en route. Schoolmasters might well have been among them. T. E. C. BRANT AND RABELAIS. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Srr: Your reviewer of Virgile Rossel’s ‘Histoire des Relations Littéraires entre la France et l’Allemagne’ (April 22) states that “there is, according to our author [i. e., Rossel], a likelihood that closer investi- gation will reveal traces of Brant’s ‘Ship of Fools’ and ‘Till Eulenspiegel’ in Rabelais.” This fact has been proved beyond doubt, at least in regard to Brant and Rabelais, cf. Louis Spach, Bulletin de la Société littéraire de Strassbourg, 1862, 1.38; Siipfle, ‘Geschichte des deutschen Cultureinflusses auf Frank- reich,’ I, 31 ff. In Brant, chapter 108, das schluraffenschiff (the fool’s trip to Mont- flascun) (‘all port durchsuchen wir und gstad’’) undoubtedly was the source of Ra- belais’s voyage to the Holy Flasc (Publ. of the Mod. Lang. Assoc. of America, 1893, p. 4, note 2: Rabelais and Hrasmus). Very respectfully, HERMANN SCHOENFELD. THE ANTIQUITY OF “WELLERISMS.” TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Your correspondent “W. H. B.’’ cites a passage from Petronius as the earliest ex- ample of a “‘Wellerism,”’ or rapampocdéxypua, to use the terminology of ancient rhetori- cians. An exact parallel is, however, found in an author who antedates Petronius by more than three centuries. Readers of Theocritus will recall the de- lightful scene in the ‘‘Adoniazuse,’’ where the two Syracusan women, accompanied by their maids, after considerable jostling, final- ly force their way through the dense crowd and into the “concert hall,’’ where a cele- brated prima donna was “advertised’’ to sing the ‘‘Adonis.” At this point, Praxinoa remarks: ‘*’Evdou maga.” 6 trav wdv elm’ amoxAgtas (‘ They’re all in,’? said the man, as he locked out his bride). For similar instances of proverbial ex- pressions, followed by a ridiculous and un- Ribb., Lucilius, fragm. 458 L., and especially M. Haupt, Opuscula II:, pp. 400 ff., and Hoefer, ‘Wie das Volk spricht,’ 1856. Yours respectfully, ALFRED GUDEMAN. PHILADELPHIA, April 30, 1897. PHILOLOGY AT A VENTURE. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Among the contents of Dialect Notes,
Page 13
May 13. 1897] The Nation. 357 Part IX., lately published, figures an article entitled ‘British vs. American English,” which, to the editor of that journal and his | which, in 1893, I entered into at length, I | may be excused for repeating the summing colleagues, is ‘‘very welcome,” and, in their | opinion, “can be regarded as authoritative as to English usage.’’ The writer of it is Mr. Evacustes A. Phipson, of Birmingham, England. The point whether Mr. Phipson’s deliver- ances are as they have been estimated will receive illustration in the sequel. If, how- ever, their author is qualified to determine what, in others, is prescriptively reputable English, it is unexpected that he should, himself, now and then deviate from such | ty,’ as Mr. Lowell says. | your statement is correct? English in a manner the most marked. For instance, in his significant judgment that his fellow-countrymen are ‘absurd in ex- cluding from genteel language the useful word ‘belly,’ substituting for it the misno- mer ‘stomach,’ ” the proletarian equivalent of “‘the language of gentle life’’ is seen to have his practical countenance; and, accord- ingly, we must take it for granted that the only consensus regarding it which is to be consulted with a view to guidance, since it cannot have escaped his attention, is dis- carded by him on principle. That, in Eng- land, at the present day, the expression gen- teel is mainly a peculium of the underbred— of those with whom wives are ladies, and of those, who, in their own sphere, are known as gents, donas, and the like—is a position which none but the ill-informed are likely to controvert. And not only as above, presumably under provincial influence, does the Birmingham critic exemplify, in the article of «esthetic predilections, what, tested by the accredited touchstone, ranks as vulgarity. ‘There is,’’ he says, ‘“‘no more need to mention the fore- name after the title Sir or Rev. than after Mr. and Lord. Why always say ‘Sir Charles Dilke’?”’ ‘‘Need,’”’ in the matter, and the answer to his “Why,” are sufficiently ob- vious. Acquaintance with established eti- quette being presupposed, observance of it, where not clashing wth scruples of con- science, is generally felt to be of the nature of a duty. In particular, it is not instinc- tively that one can come by such a fact as that “the Rev. Smith” and “Sir Dilke’’ are peculiarities of phraseology which, to per- sons of refinement or good taste, at once distinguish, as being alien to themselves, those who employ or would tolerate them. Summarily, it is impossible to misinterpret the bearing, as. towards the rulings of the great centre of English culture, of one who can speak of the ‘‘ ‘polite,’ or, rather,cockney, language” and of ‘“‘the London simper.”’ Before we reach the bottom of his first page, we meet with what follows: “The word guess may be found, used in precisely the American sense, in nearly every page of Chaucer, and is not quite ob- solete in England even now, but may occa- sionally be heard, in remote rural districts, employed in the Chaucerian sense. More- over, it is, certainly, more correct than the usual British substitutes, fancy, imagine, suspect, to say nothing of the commonest of all, expect, which is positively ungram- matical, unless referring to future events.” Mention having been premised of writers on this side of the Atlantic, Mr. J. R. Low- ell, as formerly quoted by me in these pages, remarks: “I have never seen any passage adduced [from them] where guess was used as the Yankee uses it.’’ Nor, I am confident, has any one else. Of the dis- cussion relative to the question in hand, | | | | up: “The true state of the case regarding the verb guess in America is, that, while it is employed there, rather than its practical synonyms, much more frequently than in England, it not seldom, especially in the Eastern States, ‘implies a confident certain- ‘Are you sure that ‘Yes, I guess I am.’ ‘Bein’ the mercury is at zero, I guess it is pretty cold.’ ‘I must start now for Bos- ton; and I guess I shall.’ Here are genuine Americanisms, reminding a dweller in East Anglia of the expletival ‘That du fare to rain right tidy,’ ‘How do yow fare to be, mate?’ ” Incidentally, not without entertaining a very original notion of grammaticalness can Mr. Phipson say what he says about expect. Is it syntax that the Scotch “I will come just now” transgresses? Hapect, for suspect, is, at present, a blunder; and yet, possibly, it may by and by become classical. If it vio- lates grammar, we must bracket with it dese- crate, which, quadrating with Latin, would be convertible with consecrate, if not also with deify, devote, prescribe. As respects the English of America, so as respects that of England, the critic’s infor- mation is often glaringly at fault. ‘The diction [sic] of a French Canadian,’ he re- marks, “in its misplacing of the aspirate, strongly reminds one of the brogue of our southeastern counties.’’ In all parts of this country, a little of the extreme north and east excepted, is the cacoépy which he no- tices prevalent among the common people. According to him, furthermore, “‘it is becom- ing the fashion,” here, “‘to sound the #¢ in often, pestle, and the word lieutenant as spelled,” and to say ‘“’umble, ’erb, ’eroic, *istoric, ’abitual, ’umorous, ’armonious;” the truth being that most of these pronunci- ations have long been more or less cus- tomary, and that none of them are now recognized by good society, metropolitan or other. ‘’Otel,”” the omission of which is indicated above, stands by itself, in that the h of hotel, though not heard after an, is al- ways heard elsewhere. - Once more, the subject being still the aspi- rate, we have the assertion that it “‘is never wrongly sounded, in England, in an unac- cented syllable; so it is utterly erroneous to represent an Englishman as talking of Hamerica, though he may say I ham.” Rather, it is to unaccented or sub-accented syllables that, in speaking, the aspirate is, here, most commonly prefixed amiss, es- pecially to mark emphasis. Would not heddication and helevation come-from the same mouth as heddicate and helevate? Hard- ly can one have travelled much about England to find anything strange in haltera- tion, hanimation, howdacious, hemploy, hen- gineer, henjoy, heapress, hingenious, hin- struct, hobligation, hoperation, huncertain, hundrinkable, and so on; and why should Englishmen print such forms, as they have been doing since the time of Fielding, if they are only fancies? A good number more of gratuitous statements, kindred to those just animadverted on, are, in the interest of brevity, left uncastigated. Tokens that Mr. Phipson, in posing as a philologist, has mistaken his function are | | thickly strewn. On his credit, “‘it has lately | become the fashion to write | carpet’ for ‘on the (table) cloth’ (the same | ‘on the werd, tapis, in French, standing for both).” Again, ‘‘to wantonly introduce such confu- sions as . elect for choose (as ‘he elected to go’), and assurance for insurance, is to deliberately mar the richness and har- mony of the language.” On the carpet was used by Sir Roger L’Es- trange in 1687; it occurs in The Entertainer, published in 1718; and no more to our fore- fathers, at any period since, was it a novelty than it is to us. When it first appeared, it exactly corresponded to the French phrase sur le tapis; carpet, from the fourteenth century till the reign of George II., having meant both what it now means and also “table-cloth.” The Oxford Dictionary takes its carpet to have been, originally, that ‘‘of the council-table.”” As little as other things are the age and the history of an expression to be dogmatized about on conjecture mas- querading as knowledge. To come to the verb elect, one would ask in vain what “confusion” is occasioned by making it intransitive. And the critic’s “wantonly” and ‘introduce’ betray equal dreaminess with his ‘“‘confusion.”” From the era of Lord Bacon forward, the intransitive elect has been a formal substitute, with jurists, for choose; and, so far forth, it re- sembles the modern condone, for forgive or overlook. Colebrooke, the great Orientalist, has it repeatedly in his 7’reatise on Obliga- tions and Contracts, issued in the year 1818. And it early became popularized. Lord Or- rery, in the days of the Commonwealth and just after, was especially fond of it. I have marked twenty-six instances of it in his Parthenissa alone. As untechnical, it has had the sanction, in recent years, of Lord Strangford, Prof. de Morgan, John Stuart Mill, Cardinal Manning, and many others. Here, again, the Ozford Dictionary would have been inspected advantageously. In passing, a reviewer in the Guardian news- paper of August 23, 1871, p. 1023, dealing with a book “placed in the year 1829,”’ ob- serves: ‘“‘At that time we are sure that horrid Americanism ‘elected to do a thing’ had never come in.’”’ Almost as a matter of course, an ordinary Englishman does not hesitate to impeach, ‘“‘hitty-missy,’” as a “horrid Americanism,’ anything in his mother-tongue that seems to him objection- able. Touching assurance—that, it is presumed, which is the object of asswrance-companies— the essayist writes much at random. In the Ozford Dictionary, which quotes “the price of assurance” under the date of 1622, there is the subjoined observation by Dr. Murray: “Technically, the present usage is to dif- ferentiate life-assurance and fire- and ma- rine-insurance; though, as will be seen from the quotations, assurance was the original term in reference to marine risks.” From among Mr. Phipson’s numerous pla- cits, here follow a few specimens, as express- ed by himself, or in substance, with brief comments. Goods-train and luggage-train are stated to be confined, in England, to the diction of men and to that of women, respectively. This distinction is one of narrowly limited currency. Drawers, to denote a “female garment’’—the restriction is unwarranted— is called a “barbaric [sic] word.’”’ One would like to know why it is barbarous. ‘Pail is, properly, a utensil with one handle at the | side, and is erroneous, if used as synony- Understood as thus de- fined, it is a localism. Rooster and slut, in- | stanced as samples of “‘American fastidious- are living English provincialisms, Cute, glimpsed, | mous with bucket.” | ness,” | and are of long standing.
Page 14
358 The Nation. [Vol. 64, No. 1663 pshaw, faucet, rarely ever, maybe, with the adverb any, mad, for angry, and ’most, for almost, “‘are, I believe, peculiar to Ameri- ca, or nearly so.”’ All of them, good and bad alike, are common enough here. Is “the dove returned not again any more” false English? ‘‘The American usage is de- cidedly the more correct in around for round (adverb).”” On what conceivable ground is it ‘‘more correct’? Condemnation is arbitrarily awarded to ‘than whom, for than who, to a degree, for to a high degree, quite so, for just so’; as if the first locution were not supported by the highest authori- ty, while the other two are respectable col- loquialisms. ‘He ignored the question is only correct [correct only], if he could not answer it’’; a rare and obsolete use be- ing thus preferred to one of universal ac- ceptance. And here my choice of citations must end. Let us now come to the winding-up of the critic’s prolusion: “If speakers and writers would take the trouble to consider a little, in the light of common sense, whether or not the words or phrases they use are correct, instead of merely following vulgar usage, regardless of whether it is right or wrong, the most fla- grant inconsistencies and solecisms in our language would soon disappear.” This may be accepted, when those who would improve English by inspiration pro- duce testimonials certifying that they are veritably inspired. Pending, however, the production of such vouchers, and the saving of labor therefrom resulting, a scholarly ap- prehension and a reasoned appreciation of linguistic conventionalities are indispensable preliminaries to tenable proposals for set- ting them aside. These wanting, ‘“‘the light of common sense” is only an ignis-fatuus to the would-be reformer of speech. Again, as to “‘vulgar usage,” inasmuch as it is, ad- mittedly, sometimes “right,” established usage is, of course, intended by it; and we have had to do, all along, with a professed exhibition of the established usage of both England and America. “It is,” however, “impossible for any man who has not lived in a country to be an authority on the usage there’; an axiom which the editor of Dia- lect Notes pertinently adduces, by way of preface to the plentiful array of misrepre- sentations of Americanisms pointed out by him in Mr. Phipson’s essay. Forestalled, partially, by the editor, I have but slightly concerned myself with particulars akin to such as he has specified, having chiefly kept to a selection of those of another category, namely, those evincing, on the part of their enunciator, an imperfect familiarity with what is, or what has been, recognized as standard English in its old home. The gene- ral qualifications of the Birmingham critic for engaging in our vernacular philology the reader, after turning to Dialect Notes, is now in a position to appraise. That our language is largely open to ad- verse criticism is confessed on all hands. But equally the exposure of its blemishes and practicable suggestions for their re- moval necessitate comprehensive and serious study. Dilettantism, with its little budget of quisquilious jottings, would, if prudent, indulge in some pursuit of a different de- scription. F. H. MARLESFORD, ENGLAND, March 11, 1897. Notes. MACMILLAN Co. have in press ‘Burns and his Times as gathered from his Poems,’ by J. O. Mitchell, LL.D.; a volume supplemen- tary to the Oxford Chaucer and uniform with that edition in six volumes (1894), to | be entitled ‘Chaucerian and Other Pieces,’ edited from numerous MSS. by the Rev. W. W. Skeat; and ‘Elementary Drawing,’ a se- ries of practical papers for beginners, by Elizabeth Moore Hallowell. ‘Latest Excavations in Nippur,’ edited by Prof. Dr. H. V. Hilprecht after the recent researches of Dr. J. H. Haynes in Babylonia, will be published by John D. Wattles & Co., Philadelphia, under the auspices of the De- partment of Archeology and Paleontology of the University of Pennsylvania. Mr. Gladstone’s new series of ‘Gleanings from Past Years’ (1879-1897) will bear the imprint, in this country, of Charles Scrib- ner’s Sons. Further announcements by G. P. Putnam’s Sons are ‘ Evolution and Religion; or, Faith as a Part of a Complete Cosmic System,’ by John Bascom; ‘ Bases of Religious Belief, Historic and Ideal,’ by Prof. Charles Mellen Tyler of Cornell; ‘The Occasional Address, its Literature and Composition,’ by Prof. Lorenzo Sears of Brown; ‘ Corporation Fi- nance,’ by Thomas L. Greene, Auditor of the Manhattan Trust Co.; ‘Nullification and Secession,’ during the first century of the Republic, by Edward Payson Powell, D.D.; and ‘ Personal Recollections of the War of the Rebellion,’ edited by Gen. James Grant Wilson and Dr. T. M. Coan for one series, and by A. Noel Blakeman for a second. ‘A Garden of Romance,’ “a collection of the best short stories of all ages and coun- tries,’’ edited by Ernest Rhys, will be issued in handsome form this month by the New Amsterdam Book Co. In the autumn the A. D. F. Randolph Co.- expect to publish ‘ Handbooks for Practical Workers in Church and Philanthropy,’ by Prof. Samuel Macauley Jackson. Mark Twain’s latest travels round the world are to furnish a new ‘Innocents Abroad,’ to appear in the autumn through the American Publishing Co., Hartford, but by subscription only. Prof. Morris Jastrow, jr.’s, ‘Religion of Babylonia and Assyria’ is nearly ready to be published by Ginn & Co. Bates & Guild, Boston, have in prepara- tion ‘The Municipal Buildings of the City of Boston Designed and Erected by Edmund M. Wheelwright, City Architect 1891-95,’ com- piled and edited by Francis W. Chandler, Professor of Architecture in the Massachu- setts Institute of Technology. The work will be illustrated with photographs, plans, working drawings, notes on construction, cost, etc., of more than eighty buildings, of which school-houses form a large propor- tion. De Wolfe, Fiske & Co. will shortly bring out ‘Samuel Sewall and the World He Lived In,’ by N. H. Chamberlain, with portraits and other illustrations. Among the gathering reprints on our ta- ble we can mention a new edition of ‘John Halifax, Gentleman,’ on which the Harpers have bestowed much care in presswork and binding, and which has been modestly illus- trated by Hugh Riviere, largely from the actual scene of the story. It makes a very pretty book. Attractive, likewise, is Dodd, Mead & Co.’s new dress for Mr. Edmund Gosse’s ‘Seventeenth Century Studies.’ It is a third edition, to which the author adds a fresh preface, intimating that his early judgments of 1883 have suffered some modi- fications, but not such as to call for a work- ing over; and he has done well to procure. an index, which greatly enhances the worth of this collection of studies of the lesser literary lights of the period under review. In an appendix Mr. Gosse prints an inter- esting extract from a letter of Lowell’s ex- plaining the structure of the Commemora- tion Ode by its having been intended for public recitation. Mr. Gosse had denied its Pindaric legitimacy. An older work, Bry- ant’s metrical version of the ‘Iliad,’ is now issued in a single volume by Houghton, Mif- flin & Co. as a students’ edition. The manu- facture has purposely been made inexpen- sive, but the presswork is clear and the binding tasteful. The same firm has en- larged its “Riverside Literature Series” with Grimm’s Tales, Bunyan’s ‘Pilgrim’s Progress,’ ‘‘Macbeth,’”’ and Carlyle’s Essay on Burns. The brown linen covers of this series call for especial commendation. Mr. Oscar Fay Adams’s ‘Story of Jane Austen’s Life’ was already a well-made book in 1891, with its index and bibliography; now the author is able to carry out his original plan of illustrating his biography with portraits and views, and this improved edition has been published by Lee & Shepard, Boston. The last portrait in the series is that of the genial nephew and first biographer of Jane Austen, the Rev. J. E. Austen-Leigh. We conclude with the little pocket-piece, Fletch- er’s “Two Noble Kinsmen,” in, the Dent- Macmillan ‘“‘Temple Dramatists.”” The lite- rary apparatus is furnished by Dr. C. H. Herford. Full of apt description and poetical sug- gestion is Col. T. W. Higginson’s book of summer sketches named, from its first es- say, ‘The Procession of the Flowers’ (Long- mans, Green & Co.). The orderly march of this yearly parade Mr. Higginson delights to watch while welcoming the special gifts of-each season. Even in the bare winter woods he sees a peculiar propriety, and speaks with approval of the thoroughness of Dame Nature’s annual housecleaning. This variable lady’s many moods and toilets find keen appreciation in his pages, which also charm by their reproducing for the reader, in some degree, the pleasure that its author feels in ‘‘all out-doors.” A botanist might find here and there a trifling error, as when hepatica triloba is called an annual, but an easy, every-day familiarity with common plants and birds is shown in all the es- says. It would be a pity, indeed, if all our botany were Latin names, but Mr. Higgin- son’s plea for the moderate use of Latin will be appreciated by every one who has tried to scrape an acquaintance with our native flowers. When half-a-dozen distinct plants of widely separated orders have the same English name, and others, common enough, have no English name, we must be pedantic or unintelligible if we speak of them. Following very rapidly upon the appear- ance of Messrs. Thatcher & Schwill’s larger work on the Middle Ages comes an abridg- ment by the senior author (‘A Short His- tory of Medizval Europe’; Charles Scrib- ner’s Sons). It commends itself especially to the pupils of high and preparatory schools. It is marked by the same general
Page 15
May 13, 1897] The Nation. 359 characteristics noticed in the larger book— a comprehensiveness of plan, a studied sen- tentiousness of style, an avoidance of all personal element in the movement of events. In.the hands of a skilful teacher it would be better than nothing; in those of an unskill- nothing. In other words, while it has no glaring faults, it does not rise by any vir- tue of its own above the level of the usual text-book. The ‘History of Iron,’ by Dr. Ludwig Beck, is apparently approaching completion. The first volume of this valuable work, second edition appearing in 1891, contained | the history of this industry from the earliest times to the end of the Middle Ages. the second volume there was an account of its development during the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. The third volume, of which the sixth quarterly part has just appeared, is wholly devoted to the eigh- teenth century, the plan of the author be- ing to give first a general account of the different processes of extracting the ore and of its manufacture then in vogue, and after- wards to describe their application in the different European countries. One of the most entertaining occupations man can take up is that of the discovery (Paris: Calmann Lévy), is marked by the same traits which distinguish his other works: the same voluptuous languor, the same love of color and vague form, the same absence of virility, of vigor, of healthy | thought, the same cloying sweetness of sen- ed teacher it would be almost worse than | sation and impression, the same helpless view of the problems of life and death which disgusts or exasperates once its fleeting charm has evaporated. There are. beautiful descriptions in ‘Ramuntcho’—one expects to find such in Loti’s pages; there are suave and passionate passages of love in youth | and sad strains such as he has accustomed which was published originally in 1884, a | In | of unsuspected genius, and one of the rich- est fields he can work is contemporary literature, applying himself especially to the study of authors who have had their mo- ment of vogue in a more or less restricted | circle of admirers. which Maurice Le Blond has addressed him- se]f in his ‘Essai sur le Naturisme’ (Paris: Mercure de France). He reveals to an ex- pectant public that romanticism is dead; that realism and naturalism have followed | it to the grave, and that symbolism has shared their fate. What is certain to be news to many is that the new and most recent literary school is that of ‘‘Naturism’’; the dropping of the syllable ‘“‘al’’ makes all the difference. “Naturism” is an “art of humanity,” simpler and more naive than pre-Raphaelitism and symbolism. As for the revealer and expounder of this nebulous doctrine, he is called Saint-Georges de Bouhélier, and, though scarce twenty years of age, is a Sage and a great Poet. The capitals are important. The Mercure de France, whose mission in this lower and intensely ignorant world of ours is to enlighten a benighted public on the rare merit of small potatoes, sends forth, in addition to Le Blond’s essay, a vol- ume by Victor Charbonnel, ‘Les Mystiques dans la littérature présente.’ This book has more value to the student of literature at the present day, although it also is con- ceived and written in a spirit of well-nigh unbounded admiration for mediocre writers. It is scarcely possible to evoke much en- ‘ thusiasm for Paul Desjardins,Des Esseintes, the Sar Péladan, or the “‘great Hello.” Vil- liers de l’Isle Adam had parts and talent, but even posterity is not likely to place him in the first rank of writers, any more than Mallarmé, Schuré, Rod, or Viélé-Griffin. Of these, Rod is easily the best, and yet even he cannot be said to have done more as yet than express a not infrequent gentle melan- choly and regret. His last novel, ‘La-haut,’ is worth reading, but it is not a great work nor within measurable distance of great- ness. Pierre Loti’s latest novel, ‘Ramuntcho’ This is the task to | us to in his former novels; but there is also that same feeling of puerile discouragement and of weak despair in the presence of events, that washed-out emotionality and theatrical yearning after a lost faith, that have marked this author’s work and have recommended him so highly to certain tem- peraments. Hachette & Co. have just published two additional volumes in their series of mono- graphs of great French writers: ‘Malherbe,’ by the Duc de Broglie, and ‘Beaumarchais,’ by M. André Hallays. Two more widely different authors it would be somewhat dif- ficult to select, and the two volumes appear to reflect precisely the character of the two men. The ‘Beaumarchais’ is interesting and bright from the first page to the last; the volume on ‘Malherbe’ is almost uniformly heavy and disappointing. The Duc de Bro- glie has taken great pains to make his work readable and to give as lifelike a portrait of his author as he could, but the formalism of Malherbe has proved teo much for him. On the other hand, M. Hallays has given us one of the brightest and truest portraits of Beaumarchais which we possess, and this without exhibiting undue partiality for the subject of his brilliant study. He puts the witty author of the Memoirs, of the “Barber of Seville,”’ and of the ‘“‘Marriage of Figaro” in his real light, with all his faults as well as all his qualities justly and fairlyset forth. His style has much of the vivacity of Beau- marchais himself, and the result is one of the most readable and entertaining of books, in which honest criticism and the sense of responsibility are ever present. In a second and revised edition of the Rev. J. H. Pettee’s ‘A Census of Christian Chari- ties in Japan’ (Okayama), the author shows that the foreigners and missionaries have established the following institutions: Theo- logical seminaries, 14, with 216 students; 32 boys’ schools, with 2,239 pupils; women’s training schools, 10, with 238 inmates; 50 girls’ schools, with 2,748 pupils; 14 kinder- gartens, with 526 children; 184 day or night schools for the poor, with 9,241 pupils in at- tendance; 39 orphan asylums, with 2,686 in- mates; 15 homes for the destitute, with 335 pensionaries; and 31 hospitals—a total of 333 benevolent institutions, which benefit 15,448 persons. Ten pages of detailed information cover only the Protestant work, but Roman and Greek Catholic statistics are included in the totals. We also note the publication by a Japanese bookseller (2 chome, Ginza, Tokyo) of ‘A Mirror of Christian Names,’ giving name and address of over 1,000 native and foreign workers, 754 churches and preaching stations, 208 religious and benevo- lent native institutions, and of 30 periodicals, all Christian, though of various forms. The Boston Book Co. began last month a Bulletin of Bibliography, which is frankly a private commercial medium for this house and its customers, yet possesses features which librarians at least must prize. For example, Miss Ethelyn D. M. Tucker, of the Amherst College Library, contributes the first instalment of a list of books that ori- ginally appeared in periodicals. This in- formation practically doubles a library’s re- sources for the works named—and they are by no means all novels; witness Agassiz’s ‘Method of Study in Natural History,’ Mat- thew Arnold’s ‘Study of Celtic Literature,’ Bagehot’s ‘Constitution of Great Britain,’ etc. Miss Mary W. Plummer describes anew the Petrarchan and Icelandic collections of Prof. Willard Fiske at Florence. There is also an editorial article on the Dingley duty on books and works of art. The Bulletin has no subscription price. Part i., No. 2, of the Lower Norfolk County (Va.) Antiquary, edited by Edward W. James, and for sale by George M. West, Richmond, reproduces the resolution of a hustings court at Norfolk. on July 31, 1835, instructing the Mayor to re- quest the Postmaster to withhold delivery to free negroes and other colored persons of the Human Rights, the Emancipator, “and other incendiary papers published in the Northern States,’ and alleged to have been addressed to that dangerous element of the Southern population. —The Atlantic for May opens with two articles under a common heading, ‘ The Problems of Rural New England,” by Philip Morgan and Alvan F. Sanborn. The first is called ‘‘ A Remote Village’’ and the se- cond ‘“‘A Farming Community’; neither makes it very clear what are the problems referred to, except, perhaps, that Mr. Mor- gan raises the question whether New Eng- land character “has not entered upon a long and gradual course of sure decay.” It is a queer community which he describes, possibly (from the very slight indication given of its situation) a New Hampshire village. Most of the touches of description are strong of the soil: ‘The prevailing tone in Asher Dill’s store, and in the vil- lage generally, is a humorous one—a tone of irony and of good-natured sarcasm; in fact, to be humorous, and es- pecially to be good at repartee, is the one intellectual ambition of the community.” The nearest railroad station is ten miles away; the office in the tavern is the plea- santest social centre in the village, though some people prefer the gathering-place round the stove in Asher Dill’s store, where there are more “ happenings,” as, for in- stance, when poverty-stricken Jake Her- ring (Almiry Herring’s husband) shuffles up to the counter, and, after buying medi- cine for his dying wife, finds he has not cash about him “ just then” to pay for it, upon which Asher replies without hesita- tion, ‘“‘ That’s all right’—Asher being a good-natured man, and ready, very likely, to furnish the coffin, too—the selectmen, possibly, in the end, finding the money. Nobody has much ambition, or, indeed, any expectation of ever materially bettering his condition; but nobody is so poor or busy that he cannot afford to take a day off for fishing or shooting. The inhabitants are not specially moral (though there is no bar- room in the tavern), and the number of il- legitimate births is said to be large—so large that there is a tariff of $400 per child which custom fixes as decently obligatory upon the putative father. Away from the
Page 16
ape ate tg erry weaat e+ 3ed = 8360 The Nation. [Vol. 64, No. 1663 village, on a lonely farm, is an estab- lishment for the illegal sale of liquor, the resort of scapegraces and the scene of degrading orgies. There is no stealing, and there is no standard of manners; bathing, for the sake of cleanliness, is rare, and slovenliness in dress the habit of the community. Mr. Sanborn notices the fact, characteristic of all New England village life, that there are apt to be a number of queer characters, who have travelled out into the world, and come back with a his- tory of some kind, which’ suffices them for experience, and gives a little eccentric re- lief from the unmodified village type. He does not mention the village drunkard, who in some localities is an important charac- ter. Lowell, if we remember right, some- where records the decease of one, adding, ‘““We don’t know how we shall be able to supply his place.’”” We must not forget the marked passion for equality, which has really obliterated all the social traditions of the earlier New England. Prof. Gilder- sleeve’s ‘“‘My Sixty Days in Greece” reaches its third number, and we may also call attention to Lafcadio Hearn’s ‘“ Trip to Izumo” as worth reading. His account of the impression produced by the restrain- ed irony of a Japanese war-song is a deli- cate essay in musico-literary analysis. —Undergraduate life at Harvard is de- scribed in Scribner’s by Edward S. Martin in an illustrated article. He points out seve- ral of the contrasts which exist between the old and new Harvard, i..e¢., between the University as it was before the intro- duction of the elective system and as it is now; the main cause of the differences ly- ing in the facts that the college is twice as large as it was twenty years ago, and that the introduction of the elective system has broken up the solidarity of the class, as it used to exist, men being grouped now, not by the proscrustean associations of that time-honored institution, but by those of their chosen studies and tastes and friend- ships. Not much is said in the article about studies, the writer evidently enter- taining a little of the old feeling that if a man studies at college, the less he says about it the better. There is plenty of evi- dence in the article that the moral at- mosphere of undergraduate life is not very different from what it used to be in the remote preélective days. The spirit of Harvard, we learn, still “makes for vera- city, for a high sense of honor, and for good manners’’—and it cannot make for better things, though the graduate with gray hairs may hardly be able to restrain a smile as he remembers that he too, in his youth, forgot during most of his college ca- reer that it ought to have made also for a zeal for learning. A companion article, without illustrations, on ‘‘Harvard College in the Seventies,” by Robert Grant, confirms many of the impressions made by Mr. Mar- tin. It has more literary value, and the literary skill with which Mr. Grant man- ages to give the effect of remoteness in time to what happened twenty-odd years ago is very noticeable. The minatory let- ter from a sophomore to a freshman ending “Sie semper stultibus” is what would be calledin French an historical undergraduate “document.” —-The most novel and original illustrated articles in the Century are on kite-flying, by J. B. Millet and Hugh D. Wise, U. S. A., and photographing from kites by William A. Eddy. Kite-flying, like everything else, has become scientific, and one may, after gazing at the queer machines which are now often seen floating in mid-air above New York, find solid satisfaction in learning from these pages that the adult kite-flyer is becoming an expert investigator into the internal movements of air currents, a thorough knowledge of which is to-day the basis for the future art of aerial locomotion. The war-tap in the magazines begins to run ratherdry. The ‘“‘Chapter of Secret History,” by Gen. Schofield, relating to the withdrawal of the French from Mexico, contains an amusing story of Seward, whose instruc- tions to Gen. Schofield were, ‘“‘I want you to get your legs under Napoleon’s mahogany, and tell him he must get out of Mexico.” —Harper’s principal illustrated articles are John Corbin’s ‘“‘Two Undescribed Por- traits of Shakespeare,’”’ which contains mat- ter for both illumination and contention; Poultney Bigelow’s seventh instalment of “White Man’s Africa,” with some naive Af- rican folk-lore; and Dr. Henry Smith Wil- liams’s ‘“‘Geological Progress of the Cen- tury.”” Mr. George W. Smalley writes about “English Country-House Life” as it, appears to a visitor, and tells the story of the Duke of Wellington’s guest, who consulted another as to “how much he should give the game- keeper.””’ He was advised to give him no- thing at all. ‘“‘But do you give nothing?” said the first guest. ‘Oh, I shall give him a five-pound note. But then, I shall be asked here again, and you never will.’’ Mr. Smalley imparts a good deal of information to American visitors, and his aim is evidently to produce the impression that the English country-house is the home of kindness and hospitality; but he in some degree fails— partly, perhaps, because he has in his mind’s eye the raw visitor who knows little of any country save his own, and at home has not had a very effective social start. He is much struck by the fact that the visitor need not expect on the part of the host any great effort at ‘‘putting himself out’’; and this is no doubt true. The host who carved for you, sat with you, ‘drew you’”’ on your favorite topics, welcomed you to “Liberty Hall,”’ and sped the parting guest by seeing you half-way home, is as extinct as the dodo. The English host nowadays best reflects the new, as he once best reflected the antique, method. —The réle of the librarians in this country as critics of literature and arbiters of lite- rary reputation is growingly apparent. ‘Poole’s Index to Periodical Literature’ is of necessity selective, and the selection from each periodical embraced in the Index ap- pertains to the particular librarian or li- brary assistant specially charged with the care of that periodical. In most cases the name of the author is ascertained and ap- pended to the title, and so the aristocracy of current letters is called into being. Writers in this way come to be known for their range of subjects and interests; their weight is suggested by frequency of titles; editors and publishers will naturally apply to them for further work in their lines; the youth who resort in great numbers to the Index for aid in debate, will look up to them as authorities. Not satisfied with this control at once of fame and of research, the asso- ciated librarians got up a list of works re- commendable for a library of five thousand volumes, and available also for any one building up a private library or for the casual purchaser, They now undertake an an- nual estimate of the year’s literary product in the shape of books, assigned in classes to judges among themselves. Again, of last year's issue, 489 were culled out as “‘lead- ing’ by Mr. Melvil Dewey, the well-known Director of the Public Libraries Division of the University of the State of New York, and “submitted to the librarians of the State and others to obtain an expression of opinion respecting the best fifty books .. . to be added to a village library.’’ The result has just been printed at Albany, and as the 300 books named which fell short are re- corded along with the fifty which led off, a pretty generous advertisement is given to a considerable number of authors, both old and new. —It is obvious that the object of the selec- tion, to suit a village library, militated against pure criticism. Lecky, Froude, Grove, Rae, Hamerton, Mahaffy, Lubbock, Bonney, Suily, Pater, Hugo, Sinckiewicz, Maspero, are well-known foreign authors left ‘‘outside the breastworks,’’ while the same fate overtook Marcou (‘Life of Agas- siz’), McMaster (‘With the Fathers’), Francke (‘Social Forces in German Literature’), A. L. Lowell (‘Governments and Parties in Conti- nental Europe’), Putnam (‘Books and their Makers during the Middle Ages’), Mrs. Na- varro (‘A Few Memories’), Sturgis (‘Euro- pean Architecture’), C. W. Whitney (‘On Snow-Shoes to the Barren Grounds’), Hos- mer (‘Thomas Hutchinson’), Shinn (‘Story of the Mine’), Channing and Hart (‘Guide to the Study of American History’)—to mention but a part of the American works which any village library might rejoice to have, and which are not too expensive to be thought of. Equally significant is it that in fiction the popular idols of the hour—Barrie, Crock- ett, Kipling, and Watson—crowd out those of yesterday: Besant, Black, Crawford, How- ells, James, Phelps-Ward, Wilkins, ete. It is also clear that preference was given to works relating to current political and so- cial topics, as, Armenia, Nicaragua Canal, Transvaal, strikes, to popular science, edu- cation, domestic arts, bicycling, etc. For this reason, again, the collection could not embrace the intrinsically best or permanent- ly important; and the fifty may be likened to the envied forty of the French Academy in being a company of which it is no discredit not to be a member. —Vol xxiv., and the last but one, of the present series of B. F. Stevens’s ‘Facsi- miles of Manuscripts relating to America, 1773-1783’ (London), does not require, owing to the homogeneity of its contents, so ex- tended a notice as we have usually accorded to preceding issues of this admirable under- taking. Most of the papers herein contained are addressed to Lord Dartmouth, and upon them Mr. Stevens has discoursed helpfully in his preface to the Dartmouth manuscripts recently published in the Fourteenth Report, Appendix, Part 10, of the Historical Manu- scripts Commission. A letter from Dartmouth to Thomas Cushing—the only one by him in this volume—confirms the opinion that Dart- mouth was an “amiable, pious man,” and, as a statesman, more honorable than as- tute. He will be remembered, if remem- bered at all, as the friend of the Countess of Huntingdon and her thought-of successor, rather than as Secretary of American ¢
Page 17
‘ May 13 1807] The Nation. 3861 * Affairs and Lord of the Privy Seal. Most of the letters are from Richard Oswald, Am- brose Serle, and Joseph Galloway. Serle wrote with accuracy and candox, while Gal- loway seems to have had a faculty for be- lieving what he wished to believe, and, though zealous, must often have been mis- leading in his copious information. Mr. Stevens has pointed out elsewhere that the person to whom was written the unad- dressed letter by Thomas Jefferson, dated August 25, 1775 (No. 2038), was John Ran- dolph. The first document (No. 2024) is the famous “Little Red Book,” or ‘“‘Account of Money issued for His Majesty’s Secret and Special Service,” from 1769 to 1782. Here we may learn that more than £360,000 was paid out from 1775 to 1783 to ‘American Officers and Others who have suffered on Ac- count of their Attachment to his Majesty’s Government,’ the ‘‘others’’ possessing the maininterestforus. To this American fundit was good policy to subscribe on the part of those who wished the King’s favor. Few documents in the whole collection have so vital an“interest as this ‘Little Red Book’’; but how happens it that this and other docu- ments of a public nature remain in private hands and not among the Archives of Great Britain? THE STORY OF THE BALKANS. The Story of the Balkans: Roumania, Bul- garia, Servia, and Montenegro. By Wil- liam Miller. [Story of the Nations Series.] G. P. Putnam’s Sons. 1896. WHEN the forces of Sultan Orkhan first obtained a foothold on the European side of the Dardanelles, in the middle of the four- teenth century, Servia was at the zenith of her power under her able Czar, Stephen Du- shan. He was master of Bosnia, Albania, and Thessaly, and aspired to the dominion of the Balkan peninsula. Seven centuries had elapsed since the warlike Serbs had set- tled in the region of the Save. The Bulga- rians had been established for about an equal period in the Balkan country. They had early become amalgamated with the Slavs, whom they had subdued, and had laid aside their Turanian speech for a Slavic tongue. Conquered by the Greeks of Constantinople early in the eleventh century, they had emancipated themselves before the close of the twelfth and founded a new kingdom. Beyond the Danube, in the region which had been the prey of the Petchenegs and Ku- mans, two Romanic principalities had re- cently arisen, Wallachia and Moldavia. Greece was partitioned among petty Latin Powers, and the Empire of Constantinople had been reduced to less than what the Turks possess of the Balkan Peninsula at the present day. The untimely death of Stephen Dushan paved the way to Ottoman invasion. Adrianople fell in 1361 and be- came the capital of the Sultans. The vic- tory of Amurath at Kossovo in 1389 crush- ed the power of Servia, and revealed the nature of the foe with which southeast- ern Europe had henceforth to cope. Bul- garia was speedily conquered by Bajazet, and the prince of Wallachia became his vas- sal. The fall of Constantinople was followed by the incorporation of Servia, Bosnia, and Greece with the Ottoman Empire. Albania, after holding out desperately under Scander- beg, succumbed after the death of that hero. Moldavia, at first successful in her resist- ance, was soon forced to acknowledge the overlordship of the Sultan. Only Monte- negro, the little fragment that was left from the wreck of the Servian kingdom, could not | | be effectually subdued in her mountain fast- | nesses. Hungarian heroism availed to check | the onward tide only as long as John Hun- | yadi and Matthias Corvinus lived. The vic- tory of Solyman at Mohdcs in 1526 broke up | the Magyar realm, and the crescent was planted on the walls of Buda. After the disaster at Lepanto in 1571, the power of Turkey steadily declined, but for more than a century she retained firm hold of her conquests, to which in 1669 she still was able to add the island of Crete. With the defeat before Vienna in 1683 began the dissolution of the Turkish realm. Austria, Poland, Venice, and Russia undertook to batter down the mighty edifice reared by the Mohammeds and Solymans. In 1791 Austria closed her accounts with the Porte and left to Russia the réle of dismemberer of the Ot- toman Empire. The rising of the Serbs un- der Kara George in 1804 inaugurated a new phase in the process of dissolution. In the volume before us, Mr. Miller pre- sents the history of three peoples on whom the Turkish yoke formerly rested, and of a fourth whose career has been that of a tiny state successfully struggling through long ages to keep itself above the tide which en- gulfed its more powerful neighbors. The annals of these four peoples may truly be said to be inscribed in blood. We think it a pity that Mr. Miller did not see fit to round off his task by the addition of a chapter or two on Albania and Bosnia; but, as it stands, the work is a most valuable accession to the “Story of the Nations,” and fills a broad gap in English historical literature. It is about equally divided between the four countries whose history is told. The author carries us back to the times of the ancient Greeks afd Romans, and traces in skilful outlines the revolutions which have resulted in the mod- ern mosaic of the Balkan Peninsula. With regard to the origin of that newest of Euro- pean nations, the Rumans, or Wallachs, Mr. Miller is not willing to accept the theory, advanced in recent times, according to which Dacia was altogether deromanized by the successive occupations of barbarous peoples, the Romanic element being subsequently re- stored by the influx of a rustic folk who had been dwelling south of the Danube and had preserved a corrupt Latin speech. The emergence of this great Romanic island on the ethnographic map of Europe remains a most interesting riddle. The beginnings of the Ruman principalities in the thirteenth century are shadowy enough, and yet as early as 1475 we find Stephen the Great of Moldavia bidding defiance to the conqueror of Constantinople. The Rumans, who are a prolific race of peasants, at present number nine or ten millions, of whom only about one- half dwell within the limits of Rumania, the bulk of the remainder inhabiting Transyl- vania, Bukowina, and Bessarabia. A peculiar feature of Ottoman domination has been the small extent to which the con- querors settled in the countries which they subdued. The Turk, true to his Asiatic ori- gin, has evinced little desire to stray far from the sight of the Black Sea and the Dardanelles. A century and a half of Otto- man sway in Hungary hardly left a vestige behind it, and the Sultan permitted his Ru- man vassals to close their gates against his The Turkish con- Mohammedan subjects, quest of the Balkan Peninsula nowhere meant the uprooting of the conquered in- habitants from the soil. Nor was forcible conversion to Islam part of the policy of op- pression practised. Numbers of Bulgarians and Bosniaks, however, were induced by the prospect of bettering their condition to em- brace Mohammedanism, and the bulk of the Albanians became Moslems. Mr. Miller deals with Turkish misrule, the misrule which has especially marked the decline of Ottoman power, in no stinted terms of denunciation. A brilliant exception among provincial gov- ernors was Midhat Pasha, whose adminis- tration of Bulgaria from 1864 to 1867 is awarded an eloquent eulogy. Russia does not receive very gentle treatment at the im- partial hands of our author, who vividly portrays the insidious and grasping part she was played in connection with the Bulgaria which she has freed. He expresses unbound- ed admiration for the heroic qualities of Alexander of Battenberg, “fone of the most romantic figures in the history of our time,” but admits that he was “lamentably deficient in the arts of a statesman.” Of Prince Nicholas of Montenegro, with whom Mr. Mil- ler would appear to be on terms of personal friendship, and whose portrait is the frontis- piece to the volume, he says: ‘Whoever would see benevolent despotism in full work- ing order had better go to Montenegro.” “Tt has truly been said,’’ continues Mr. Miller, “that the Montenegrin is the exact opposite of the Bulgarian. Put both in a drawing-room, and the Montenegrin, who has never bowed his neck to a foreign mas- ter, will look and behave like a gentleman, while the Bulgarian, but lately set free from the Turkish bondage, will look and behave like a boor. But put the two upon a waste plot of ground, and the Bulgarian will con- vert it into a garden of roses, while the Montenegrin will look on.” The disruption of the Turkish realm in Europe has not brought Russia closer to Constantinople than she was at the begin- ning of the century. Her frontiers are still where they were in 1812, when her bounda- ries were advanced to the River Pruth. Nor has she obtained a hold on the affec- tions of the peoples who owe their libera- tion more or less to her efforts. She alie- nated the Rumanians, whose gallantry be- fore Plevna deserved a better reward, by forcing them to an exchange of territory which was galling to their national pride. Bulgaria, after the infamous treatment which she received at the hands of her Mus- covite guardian, has barely been won over to a state of cold allegiance. The Greeks have every reason to dread Russia as a bar- rier to the realization of their dream of a new Byzantine Empire. But when the time for action arrives, Russia will have means at her command wherewith to attach the states of Greek Christendom, Greece perhaps excepted, to her banner. It is only at the hands of Russia that Rumania can hope to receive the investiture of that extensive do- main, peopled mainly by Wallachs, which constitutes the southeastern part of Austria- Hungary. To the Servians Russia can hold forth the vision of a greater Servia, to em- brace Bosnia and Croatia-Slavonia, as the price of her codperation in a grand on- slaught upon the Austro-Hungarian mo- narchy. She can bribe the Bulgarians by , offering to revive the greater Bulgaria of Montenegro is bound to her Austria- San Stefano. by the strongest ties of gratitude.
Page 18
862. The Nation. [Vol. 64, No. 1663 Hungary is not in a position to bid against Russia. She may hand Bosnia over to Ser- via, to which that region naturally belongs, but this is much less than Russia can offer, and a greater Servia on her borders is a menace to Hungary, whose Croat subjects, of the same blood as the Serbs, would fret still more than they have done in the past under Magyar domination. To Rumania Austria can offer nothing unless it be the evanescent prospect of recovering Bessara- bia in the event of the repetition of Russia’s discomfiture in the Crimean war. With re- gard to Bulgaria, she could perhaps hold forth inducements equal to Russia’s in or- der to gain her over, and a stronger Bulga- ria would in fact be a support to the Haps- burg throne, involving as it would a weak- er Servia by reason of the enmity between Serbs and Bulgarians. Not one of the Bal- kan countries is naturally drawn towards Austria; to Russia they are all bound by the ties of a common church. But it is Russian Panslavism, and not the danger of Hapsburg aggression, that rests as a cloud upon the future of the Balkan region. The recent history of the Balkan Peninsu- la is presented by Mr. Miller in a very spirited and effective manner. He confines himself strictly to narrative, and refrains from discussing the present situation with reference to the possibilities of the near fu- ture. In his preface he emphasizes the benefits that would result from a Balkan confederation as a safeguard of peace. In dealing with medizval history the author occasionally shows a pardonable lack of close familiarity with the shifting scenes on the margin of his panorama. Thus, con- siderably more is known of the Patzina- kitai (Petchenegs) than the reader would infer from the statement on page 31, this Turanian people figuring rather conspicu- ously in early Russian annals. Mr. Miller’s style is animated and vigorous throughout, but now and then lapses into a somewhat journalistic vein. The defective orthography of foreign names is a decided blemish on these attractive pages. We find, for exam- ple, Marica, Tirgovischtea, Mirtschea, Kesc- kho, Garashanine, and other unpardonable spellings, in many cases representing Ger- man transliteration. Onthemapof the Balkan States such memorable battlefields as the Shipka Pass and Slivnitza should not be conspicuous by their absence. The illustra- tions are neither numerous nor striking, and the small maps inserted in the text are decidedly poor. INSTINCT. Habit and Instinct. By C. Lloyd Morgan, F.G.S. London and New York: Edward Arnold. 1896. Pp. 351. Die Spiele der Thiere. Von Karl Groos. Jena: Fischer. 1896. Pp. xvi, 359. PROF. MORGAN’sS ‘Habit and Instinct’ adds another to his series of works, now three in number, dealing- with comparative psycho- logy. The reader is impressed anew with the prime quality which he has learned to expect in this author’s writing: great lucidi- ty, secured at gnce by a simple style, long reflection, and a certain persistence in mak- ing his point tell. Combined with this is a balance and caution which invites the read- er’s confidence, and legves the impression that the writer, even in the theoretical parts of his subject, can always be trusted. At the same time we find that the work goes over many of the same topics as the earlier books, repeats some of the same instances, even repeats itself more than is necessary, and, while the net gain is great—the book is one of the most important in the recent lite- rature of the problem of instinct—yet both the observations and the discussions could have been put into much less space at half the price. The volume will tend in some de- gree to supersede the one on ‘Animal Life and Intelligence,’ since the author has now reached points of view on the most impor- tant subjects, such as the relation of instinct and intelligence, the inheritance of acquired characters, imitation, etc., which render it impossible for workers to quote the earlier work as representing Prof. Morgan’s entire views. As to the essential teachings of the present book, we have space to give only their most important bearings in connection with recent discussion. Among recent publications on this side of the water Prof. Morgan makes use of the observations of Prof. Wesley Mills of Montreal on the instincts and habits of young animals, and the experiments and conclusions of Prof. Mark Baldwin of Prince- ton reported in his work on ‘Mental Deve- lopment in the Child.’ It will be remember- ed that Prof. Morgan, in a course of Lowell lectures in Boston last year, dwelt on the results of detailed experiments carried out by him with young birds, artificially hatched and reared under constant observation. The early chapters in ‘Habit and Instinct’ con- tain these experiments carried still further. The substantial result is in agreement with those of Mills, and goes to show that many of the actions of young fowl which have been considered quite instinctive—as the experi- ments of Spalding and others seemed to show —are really a mixture of congenital tenden- cy and acquired habit. Some of these activi- ties are of vital importance, such as drink- ing, fleeing from constant enemies (as the hawk), appreciating and acting upon exact spacial relationships, etc. Such _ results, found also in the examination of trustworthy reports of animals, as those of Hudson in the ‘Naturalist in La Plata,’ lead Prof. Morgan to his most important conclusions. Briefly stated, they are somewhat like’this: First, this imperfection of instinct, even in things vital to the organism, emphasizes the intelligent and imitative learning pro- cesses of young animals. These learning processes keep them alive by supplementing their congenital activities and structural ca- pacities. This conclusion gives new impor- tance to the psychological side. Second, the further question arises as to the sort of things which young animals learn and how they come to learn them. Upon this, again, observations throw light. The fact appears that there are certain relatively constant functions and activities handed down from generation to generation in ani- mal families and communities, as has been theoretically insisted on by Wallace, and re- cently confirmed by the observations of Hudson, under the term “tradition,” and Baldwin, who calls the individual’s learning of tradition ‘“‘social heredity.” And, third, the question of the method St organic evo- lution has some light shed upon it, in Prof. Morgan’s opinion, by the relation between these learning processes of the animals and natural selection. Prof. Morgan here deve- lops (chap. xiv.) a suggestion which has also beep put forth, as Morgan points out, by Prof. Baldwin, and independently reached by Prof. H. F. Osborn of Columbia University, namely, that by learning intel- ligently and imitatively to do things which are essential, certain animals are screened from the operation of natural selection, and so hand on their capacities to future gene- rations, while the race accumulates further congenital variations in the same directions (what Morgan calls “‘coincident variations’’). Thus evolution takes the direction marked out in the first instance by the individual’s learning. All these writers agree that this suggestion neutralizes in great measure the current arguments for the inheritance of ac- quired characters, since if evolution is di- rected in any case in the channels of the ac- quired characters in the way suggested, it becomes unnecessary to suppose, in the ab- sence of evidence in favor of it, that the same characters are also directly inherited. It may be noted that among others Mr. A. R. Wallace, in a recent review of this book in the journal Natural Science, welcomes this suggestion. Possibly our readers will be most interest- ed in certain positions regarding “Human Evolution” which Prof. Morgan reaches (in chap. xv.) on the basis of the observations and conclusions already briefiy set forth. He seems well justified in drawing them in view of the foundation laid in his other chapters. His main contention is that, even in the animal world, the method of learning by the individual—i. ¢., imitation, associa- tion, profiting by experiences of pleasure and pain—is essentially different, and the progress which is secured through it is es- sentially different, from natural selection and the progress secured through it. In the former, consciousness becomes ‘“‘efficient,”’ at least in a sense. It is not clear to us just how much this means from a philo- sophical point of view—this “efficiency” of consciousness, in the mind of Prof. Morgan; but it is yet clear that in the case of man, where social heredity comes to replace phy- sical heredity as the means of handing on the mass of tradition and race acquisition, consciousness, whatever it is able to do, has the field largely to itself. In human evolu- tion, therefore, we are not under the law of natural selection alone, operating upon fortuitous variations. We are rather under the law of conscious selection accumulating and progressing through social and intelli- gent handing down. Natural selection weeds out the worst on a large scale; conscious selection picks out the best individuals, the best actions, arrangements, beliefs, etc. This is the way the author and some of those whom he quotes would reconstruct the relation of biology to social evolution; and the position seems to be fruitful enough. Readers at all versed in recent biological discussion may remember the sort of fatal- istic results which the new neo-Darwinian theories of human evolution were supposed to bring. If the discipline and the dissipation of parents have little or no effect upon their children, we are asked, where is the place of social reform and the motive to in- dividual training? The answer to this comes through the line of teachings brought to- gether in this book. The individual is not born with a physical heritage made better or worse by his father, but into a social heritage which takes its character from the set of conditions which the father also lived in and contributed to. We all make these conditions better or worse, and we
Page 19
May 13, 1897] The Nation. 363 all profit by them for better or for worse, in a new and truer sense. The individual is redeemed from the capricious and acci- dental effects of single lives lived for good | or ill, but he inherits socially the larger in- | fluences which make the social environ- ment what it is, and which represent a continuous social movement. We cannot dwell- upon the special ques- tion which Prof. Morgan discusses with his usual clearness and force—such as_ the relation of instinct to acquired habit, the function of sexual selection, the details of the specific habits of mammals and birds. These discussions may, however, be brought | to the attention of both biologists and psy- | chologists. . In conclusion, we may notice em- phatically the contrast between this book | and the work of those recent writers who deal with the same large questions of heredi- ty, degeneracy, race-progress, etc., having only scented biology from afar and having learned their anthropology from Lombroso and Nordau. Groos’s ‘Die Spiele der Thiere’ goes well with the work just spoken of. The author sets himself to examine the plays of ani- mals, collecting all the facts hitherto re- ported, and interpfeting them in a general theory of play, and its function in the eco- nomy of animal and mental life. Hereaches an instinct theory of play as against its tra- ditional opposite—the “‘surplus energy” the- ory held for so long by Mr. Spencer and his followers. Herr Groos shows himself a competent critic, and, moreover, an able constructive thinker. He finds that the plays of animals are a necessary preparation for their strenuous life. Play exercises their capacities of both mind and body, while they are immature and when failure does not bring fatal consequences, and so gives the practice and aids the development which are essential for adult life. On this basis the literature of animal life is ran- sacked; cases of play and pseudo-play are brought together, all with a very high fer- tility of resource and ability of interpreta- tion. Prof. Groos also signalizes, as Prof. Mor- gan does, the learning processes of young animals, and the imperfection of instincts. He likewise lays great stress on imitation, finding that imitation acts to enable the animal to dispense with fixed complete in- stincts, and so allows a species to acquire the generalized ways of action in which in- telligence predominates. His foundation as regards heredity is similar, also, in that he discards use-inheritance utterly, thinking that play both results from and carries on the operation of natural selection, which is sufficient. He does not take over his con- clusions into human life, however, reserving all that for another volume, to be called pected with interest. Prof. Groos, finally, makes interesting ap- plications of his theory of the psychology of play to ewesthetics. but the reader will find it only one of the many suggestive and fruitful positions taken up by the author in a book which should be read by all who are interested in the larger problems of the evolution of instinct. History and Criticism. By H. Schiitz Wil- son. London: T. Fisher Unwin. 1896. — ONE’s first impression on opening these es- says is that Mr. Wilson’s taste is in part gruesome, in part bizarre. When the Con- ciergerie and Bianca Capello are followed up by ‘Wallenstein’ and the second part of “Faust,” one begins to shake off sloth and to prepare for an exciting time. If circum~ stantial detail, together with an unlimited supply of strong adjectives, can make the reader “creep,” he will not be disappointed. | Bulwer Lytton’s ‘House and the Brain’ palls beside the gore which is shed more freely than ink in these pages. Mr. Wilson writes history and criticism from the standpoint of the Quarterly Re- view, to which we gather from a prefatory note, he is a contributor. The ‘Annual Re- gister’ for 1793-94 discusses the events of the | Terror with the same animus, though with | a less copious vocabulary. We can best show how earnest our author is by quoting a few of his phrases. Of Robespierre: ‘‘We admit a feeling of exultation as we stood in the dreary little cell in which the inhuman and incarnadined fiend was left to face the prospect of that horrid death which he had inflicted on so many thousands.”” Of the Queen: “After she had been dethroned, Marie Antoinette became most truly queen- ly. She was thirty-eight whea she was done to death. She had been sublimed and rapt to truest heroism.” Of her trial: ‘‘Only two painters are good enough for such a theme and such a picture, and they are Millais or the imagination.” Of Egalité : “That purple pustule on the cheek of royalty.”” Marie Antoinette is trou- bled by “haggard dreads,’’ just as Bianca Capello a little later on is troubled by “a haggard horror.” In short, Mr. Wilson seeks to adapt his language to the occasion. When he is dealing with Danton, Robespierre, and Marat he has no trouble in making ‘‘the pu- nishment fit the crime.” While his essay on the Conciergerie is oc- cupied with a_ specific recital of ghastly deeds, the comparison of Carlyle and Taine gives our author an _ opportunity to arraign the Revolution on more general grounds. Taine’s contempt for the chief personages of the National Convention is heartily reéchoed, and Carlyle is scored for neglecting to denounce the atrocities with vehemence. Mr. Wilson evidently admires the Scotchman’s “great warm heart,” but | will not stay his pen on that account. Some ‘Die Spiele der Menschen,’ which will be ex- | mitigation of the offence is found in compa- rative ignorance, and some in preconceived theories; still, Carlyle’s ‘‘passionate pictur- | esqueness, his graphic grip, and his most The essence of play-con- | sciousness in animals is a sense of self-illu- | sion or of conscious Schein. This is also | the root of conscious esthetic experience, as he says in agreement with Hartmann. So, in the animal plays we have the lower stages of esthetic consciousness present. Interest- ing cases are found in the male’s show of bright color to the female bird, and in the charm which the male fowl exercises through his evolutions in the presence of his mate, etc, We cannot follow this in detail, fervent emphasis” are found wanting when brought to the touchstone of the “truest philosophy.” To “the vivid and masterly picture painted by M. Taine of that inhuman Revolution” the palm is awarded. We shall be at no pains to exalt Carlyle or to decry Taine, and we would praise Mr. Wilson for his careful examination of their books. At the same time, we think that in making strictures on Carlyle he has over- looked one of the gravest artistic charges that cap be brought egeinst him. He ob- trudes himself between the reader and the subject in a gratuitous way. The French Revolution is a movement so colossal, so titanic, that one does not wish to see even a Chelsea philosopher in the foreground. The future historian (for Taine, with all his learning, stops short of exhausting the sub- ject) will do well to keep himself sedulous- ly in the background, and to create the im- pression that destiny is marshalling events. How can any one man’s symmetrical theo- ries pretend to estimate and account for the proportions of good and evil involved ? Here, too, as in the case of pure criticism, it is one’s business to ‘‘keep out of the way and let humanity decide.’”’ We certainly cannot allow that Mr. Wilson has got to the root of the matter when he sums up in the following strain: “The great distinguishing feature of the Revolution is that it plucked the muzzle from all restraint; that it enfranchised all vanity and vice; that it would, but for that revulsion of outraged humanity which sick- ened at last of the sorry spectacle of rivers of innocent blood, have ruined France. The latest and ripest fruit of the French Re- volution is, perhaps, the godless anarchist and bomb-thrower of the distracted hour in which I now write.” We are somewhat amused to note that though Mr. Wilson is unwilling to admit local conditions in extenuation of Danton’s share in the September massacres, he is ready to view Bianca Capello in the light of the late Renascence. ‘Bianca was a product and a portent of her land, her Church, her day; and we must judge her always with reference to the Italy of the 16th century. It became a ‘question whether Ferdinando should kill Bianca, or Bianca kill Ferdinan- do.”” If one takes up with the “product” theory, he should nail his colors to the mast and be consistent throughout. A graver complaint is that Mr. Wilson accepts with- out question the tittle-tattle of Florence about Cosimo I. and his sons. We should gather from his statements that Garzia be- yond doubt murdered his brother Giovanni. “The slayer of his brother went to his father to plead for pardon, but Cosimo, in the very presence of the youth’s mother, Eleonora di Toledo, stabbed Don Garzia to death; and the Duchess, the miserable wit- ness of this second crime, died of grief.’’ The fact is that this whole story is prob- ably a piece of moonshine. Symonds, no lenient critic of the age, repudiates it un- hesitatingly: ‘There is little doubt that all three deaths were natural; and Cellini’s in- terrupted account of the occurrences very materially confirms this view.’”’ It is only fair to the public that an author should in- dicate in such disputed cases the nature of his sources. Mr. Wilson’s antithetical con- clusion will not save him from censure if he despises the essentials of sound historical writing: .“Fair and yet foul, lovely and yet repellent, is the picture which we ultimate- ly paint in our imaginations of the beauti- ful and winning, if tempted and wicked, Bianca Capello.” Besides the essays already mentioned, this volume includes articles on Calderon and Goethe, and on Goethe and Carlyle. We have several little items against the printer —for instance, ‘‘Courthon” for Couthon. ‘‘Marsiellaise’’ for Marseillaise, and ‘‘Mer- lin, De Thionville,” ‘Goethe and Garlyle” is a headline which is sure to catch the eye of every one except the proof-reader. When Mr, Wilson calle Mme, Roland the Egeria
Page 20
364 The Nation. [ Vol. 64, No. 1063 of the Girondins, should he not put the phrase in quotation marks? He places the number of the September executioners at 300; the official number is 178. A worse slip is the naive acceptance of Lamartine’s story of the Girondists’ ‘‘Last Supper.” In short, this book ‘bears evidence of some reading and of some literary aptitude, marred by turgid language, absence of the sifting process, and a slight lack of balance. Its component essays were in their day good average magazine articles. When arranged in book form under the title ‘History and Criticism,’ they show off to less advantage. Had Mr. Wilson selected a modest caption, he would not have appeared so distinctly over-parted. The Mount: Narrative of a Visit to the Site of a Gaulish City on Mont Beuvray, with a Description of the Neighboring City of Autun. By Philip Gilbert Hamerton. Bos- ton: Roberts Bros. 1897. THREE-QUARTERS of this little book is de- voted to an interesting mountain called Mont Beuvray, or Le Beuvray, which is a few miles west of Autun. This mountain rises twenty-five hundred feet above the sea and more than two thousand feet above the plain of Autun, and yet, upon the summit and the sloping sides near the top, there ex- ist the remains of a fortified town four miles or more incircuit, and well filled with the ves- tiges of small hut-like dwellings of pre-Ro- man Gauls. For twenty-five years explora- tions have been carried on, slowly and sys- tematically, under the direction of an anti- quarian whose name is given in full in Joanne’s Guide and Napoleon’s ‘History of Cesar.’ This gentleman, Mr. Bulliot, is the hero of Mr. Hamerton’s tale, in which he ap- pears as The Antiquary, though his name is mentioned when the story is half told. The account of the dwellings, half-subterranean and with but little provision for light and air, and of the work-shops in which were wrought the admired Gaulish enamelling and bronze work, of which specimens begun, half completed and wholly completed were found, is interesting, though much too slight and too brief. The general character of the great ramparts is also well explained—their vast size, their position, now lost among the trees which have grown upon their sloping sides, but cannot grow where a hard road forms the uppermost surface, and their con- dition of grassy slopes where the forest is not. A very curious error, however, marks the detailed description. The recognized manner of construction of the Gaulish walls is well known from Czsar’s ‘Commentaries’ (Book VII. of the Gallic War, chap. xxiii.). This description has been entirely confirmed by the diggings at Mont Beuvray, at Bourges, and elsewhere. A book not more uncommon than Napoleon’s ‘Julius Cesar’ gives a quite accurate plate of the system in connection with the defences of Avari- cum. Mr. Hamerton, referring to these au- thorities, has yet misunderstood completely how the timbers were placed. He thinks there was an extensive system of vertical posts, and a glance at the plate in Napo- leon’s book shows how he made the error: he simply took the ground plan for an eleva- tion, and supposed the construction to be that of a scaffolding of uprights and hori- zontals. This town on Mont Beuvray was probably the Bibracte which Cesar calls much the largest and richest oppidum of the Aldui. The neighboring city of Autun, which is known to have been the Roman Augusto- dunum, is thought by many to have been Bibracte; but we quite agree with Mr. Bul- liot and his imperial patron and pupil, and with his more recent pupil, Hamerton, in finding Bibracte in the newly discovered hill fortress. The mountain is a _ fascinating place, covered in part with a noble forest, and having detached chestnut trees of great beauty near the top. A score of splendid springs of pure water are found on it. It is ascended by many ancient Gaulish roads, and near one of these, and close to the sum- mit, Mr. Bulliot has his mountain encamp- ment, where Mr. Hamerton often visited him. The natural beauties of the mountain, the superb views from the summit, and the romantic beauty of the site itself, are all delightfully treated. The second part of the book, only sixty pages long, is devoted to a description of the ancient city of Autun, its churches and more ancient remains, as well as its present ap- pearance. There are few cities so rich in architectural antiquities, and these few pages, small and in large print, afford but little opportunity for analysis or even de- scription. The essay is, however, most at- tractive, and capable of serving as a partial introduction to the study of the artistic side of architecture. The Physiocrats: Six Lectures on the French Economisies of the 18th Century. By Hen- ry Higgs. Macmillan Co. 1897. Pp. x. 158. THE development of economic thought has suffered much from the faulty exposition of important principles. Ricardo has received his commonest interpretation in the dicta of McCulloch; Malthus has found his largest clientéle through the pages of J. S. Mill, and Quesnay has been most often refuted by readers of ‘The Wealth of Nations.’ In the last ten years, partial correction has come in the extraordinary growth of interest in and study of the history of economic the- ories and systems. Thus, a striking phase of current economic discussion is the so- called “rehabilitation of Ricardo.’’ Pr. Bonar has placed within reach a masterly inter- pretation of Malthusianism, and the careful investigations of a group of distinguished European scholars have made clear the real significance of the doctrines of the French economists of the eighteenth century. The brilliant studies of Oncken and Bauer, of Schelle and Hasbach, in the field last in- dicated—the doctrines of the physiocratic writers—have brought into prominence the surprising and discreditable absence of any English treatment of this important chap- ter of economic theory. With a general re- eognition of strong physiocratic influence upon the beginnings of the science, with the original texts inaccessible to the ordinary student, and with the most superficial treat- ment in the stock manuals, this long-con- tinued neglect is extraordinary. Reasonable assurance that an adequate study in English of the Physiocrats is with- in sight comes in the attractive little vol- ume given us by Mr. Henry Higgs, well known in economic circles as the scholarly editor of Cantillon’s Essai and as Secretary of the British Economic Association and joint editor of the Heonomic Journal. It contains six lectures delivered before the recently established London School of Eco- nomics, in May and June of last year, sup- plemented by adequate notes and a useful list of authorities. The book is avowedly a mere introductory study, and conforms in method of treatment to the elementary pur- pose for which it was designed; but the most exacting reader turns the last page with the comforting sense of prospective release, in this particular field, from “‘the tyranny of un- read books,” and with the no less absolute conviction that lack of occasion and not of capacity has prevented Mr. Higgs from giv- ing in the present connection a definitive ex- position of physiocratic thought and influ- ence. The genesis of the physiocratic school can be traced with some precision. The wretched economic condition of France un- der the ancien régime evoked the criticism in succession of Boisguillebert, Vauban, Me- lon, and the fuller exposition of Cantillon. Mirabeau’s ‘L’Ami des Hommes,’ essential- ly a commentary upon Cantillon’s Essai, fell into the hands of Quesnay, then Madame de Pompadour’s physician at the French court, and led to a meeting of the two men. From this interview in July, 1757, Mr. Higgs dates the schoel of the Physiocrats. The growth of the school, the important principles of physiocratic philosophy, and the personality of its chief exponents—Ques- nay, Mirabeau, Dupont de Nemours, and Mercier de la Riviére—are characterized in bold, clear outline. John Stuart Mill de- scribed the Ricardian theory of rent as the pons asinorum of economic science; but a longer retrospect must surely award the distinction to Quesnay’s ‘Tableau Econo- mique.’ Few students who have grappled with the-elusive ‘‘zig-zag’’ have failed to derive keen satisfaction from the statement recorded by Francis Horner, himself in de- spairing pursuit of the clue, as made by Lauderdale, ‘‘that he had repeatedly left the study of the ‘Tableau Economique’ cursing himself for a blockhead.’”’ Mr. Higgs’s in- terpretation (pp. 38-39) is simple and intel- ligible, and divests the chart of its terrors, even to the veriest tyro. Symmetry in treatment is gained by the consideration in successive chapters of the activities, the opponents, and the influences of the Physiocrats. Here the scholarship, industry, and skill of the author leave little to be desired. Inclusion of Turgot’s ‘Ré- flexions’ in chapter iv. (‘Activities’), rather than in iii. (‘Doctrines’), seems an unwise cession of essence to form. Adam Smith is surely to be classed as opposed to as well as influenced by physiocratic thought, and some consideration is demanded of the influence of the school upon American publicists, nota- bly upon Franklin and Jefferson, and upon American political thought, manifest even in the framing of the Constitution. Mr. Higgs has realized a want in econo- mic literature, felt long and painfully. If he has not entirely filled it, he has given the amplest assurance of his fitness to do so. The Story of the Pilgrim Fathers, 1606-1623 A.D.; as Told by Themselves, their Friends, and their Enemies. Edited from the Origi- nal Texts, by Edward Arber, F.S.A. Lon- don: Ward & Downey; Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co. 1897. Pp. x, 634. PrRoF. ARBER is so well known by reason of his republication of tracts by Knox and Udall, and other rare pieces of the Tudor
Page 21
May 13, 1897] The Nation. 865 and Stuart periods; by his ‘Introductory Sketch of the Martin Marprelate Contro- versy’; by his ‘English Garner’; and espe- cially by his ‘Transcript of the Registers of the Company of Stationers of London,’ that it was with decided prepossessions in its favor that we took up the volume under consideration. Nor has this expectation been disappointed. We can, indeed, assent only in a modified degree to the author’s asser- tion that “the Pilgrim Story must, after the appearance of this Volume, assume a some- what different aspect from that which it has hitherto had.’’ The discovery which seems most, to have surprised Prof. Arber, namely, that the Pilgrim church felt an increasing affection for the ‘‘Church of their fathers— the persecuting Bishops apart,” is certainly not novel to American students of the writ- ings of Robinson; on the other hand, Prof. Arber, probably with much justice, attaches greater weight than have American investi- gators heretofore to the charges of moral rgttenness brought by White and Lawne against the character of several of the leaders of the London-Amsterdam church, to escape from contact with which organi- zation the Pilgrims transferred themselves from Amsterdam to Leyden. But though little really essential to the main out- line of the Pilgrim story seems to us to be altered by Prof. Arber’s volume, he has brought to light a good many facts of much interest, and his treatment of this well- worked theme throughout is fresh and sug- gestive. It deserves the author’s descrip- tion as “in one sense . . a resetting of old material; in another, the production of new facts.’’ The volume under review, as its title im- plies, is essentially made up of extracts, drawn necessarily in the main from familiar sources; .but Prof. Arber has evidently gleaned the less accessible literature of the Pilgrim movement with equal painstaking, while his own comments are constantly in- terspersed and give flavor, and largely value, to the work. In opposition to the opinion that has widely obtained by reason of Na- thaniel Morton’s designation of the year 1602 as the date of the formation of the Pilgrim Church, Prof. Arber holds that the congregations of Scrooby and of Gainsbo- rough originated about 1606, and that each was largely independent of the other. He demonstrates that John Smyth, through whose activity the Gainsborough congrega- tion was organized, was still a minister of the Church of England, being a “lecturer” at Lincoln, as late as March, 1605; and could not, therefore, have reavhed the full Sepa- ratist position, to which he came after nine months of struggle, till after that date. Moreover, the author identifies this erratic Separatist leader with the John Smith who graduated M.A. at Cambridge in 1593; in. stead of finding in him, as the late Dr. Henry M. Dexter did, the like-named recipient of a similar degree in 1579. It is rather to Clyfton and Brewster that Prof. Arber traces the beginnings of the Pilgrim Church; both men laboring, though in different ways, within the Establishment for years before openly separating from it, and having John Robinson as their associate from about 1604. The author thus epitomizes his conclusions: “So, going back to the ultimate facts, we say that the. Pilgrim Movement originated in the Rectory and Church of Babworth, in Nottinghamshire; and that it was mainly a Nottinghamshire Movement. The West Rid- ing of Yorkshire was not in it; except as Austerfield was the home of Governor W. Bradford: but he, during the period now under review, was merely a child growing to youthhood. Lincolnshire, through the Congregation at Gainsborough, temporarily furthered the Movement during the years 1606-1608; but this was merely an accidental help, occasioned by the coming to that town of the Rev. John Smyth. In the main, Nottinghamshire men founded the Pilgrim Church.” Contrary to the usually received opinion, moreover, Prof. Arber gives strong reasons for believing that Smyth and his Gains- borough congregation, instead of emigrating to Amsterdam in 1606, did not greatly, if at all, precede the Scrooby emigration thither. As late as November, 1607, Smyth and his flock seem still to have been at Gains- borough. The time limits within which the Pilgrim exodus Hollandward must fall, the author places at October, 1607, and August, 1608. But probably the portion of Prof. Arber’s volume to which the reader already some- what familiar with the Pilgrim story will most readily turn, is his account of the activities of what he aptly calls the “Pilgrim press” at Leyden, and of the troubles which its publication, for circulation in England, of books unlicensed in that kingdom brought to the “‘sleeping partner’ in the enterprise, Thomas Brewer, and would have brought to the “working partner,’”’ Elder William Brew- ster, had he not succeeded in hiding from the officials and employees of the English Government. ‘‘For more than a year before he left Delfshaven,”” Brewster ‘“‘was a hunted man”; and the letters exchanged between Sir Dudley Carleton, English Ambassador to Holland, and Sir Robert Naunton, the Eng- lish Secretary of State, which the author reprints to the number of twenty-nine, show how eagerly this pursuit was followed. Prof. Arber is able to present a list of fifteen volumes, most of them such as could not have been printed in England, which may justly be regarded as the product of this press between October, 1616, and June, 1619. Characteristic of the author’s suggestive comments is his observation regarding Brad- ford’s statement that the Speedwell was “bought and fitted in Holland”: “Now it was those members of the Leyden Church who were responsible for this fit- ting of the Speedwell, that were the proxi- mate causes of most of the troubles on the voyage out, and of many of the deaths at Plymouth in New England, in the course of the following Spring. For they overmasted the vessel, and, by so doing, strained her hull while sailing. Then that cunning ras- cal, Captain Reynolds, finding this out, all that he had to do was to clap on all possi- ble sail, and so to make the hull, as Robert Cushman tells us it was, ‘[as] leaky as a sieve.’ For this fatuous and supreme error of judgment in business matters, and all that came of it, the Leyden Church alone were responsible. No one in England had anything to do with it.” A valuable and novel document presented by the author is the statement of claims growing out of the robbery by the French of the Fortune, in January, 1622, on her re- turn voyage from Plymouth, and of the loss thereby, among other things of value, of a “letter written by [William Bradford] the Governor of our Colony in New England, containing a general relation of all matters there.”” The author intimates that a second volume, tracing the fortunes of the Pilgrims in a similar manner to 1628 or 1630, is pro- jected. We trust that he may be able to carry out his purpose. Municipal Problems. By Frank J. Goodnow. New York: Published for the Columbia University Press by the Macmillan Co. 1897. TuIs book gives evidence of much thought as well as scholarship, and it deserves the attention of those interested in the govern- ment of our cities. Prof. Goodnow has already pointed out some of the most ob- jectionable features of the systems preva- lent in this country, and he here restates his position more at length, and with some constructive suggestions. His fundamental objection to the American method of mu- nicipal government is that it results in the city’s. being governed by the State Legisla- ture. The bad results of this arrangement are so notorious in the case of New York city as to need only an allusion. In Prof. Goodnow’s opinion they are bad everywhere. For in his view—and his book is but a de- velopment of this view—a city ought to legislate for itself. The taxing power and the power of appropriating money are legis- lative in character. There should be deli- beration and publicity in determining how money should be raised and how it should be spent, thus giving public opinion a chance to make itself felt. Hence he disapproves of the policy of suppressing city councils and putting their powers in the hands of the Mayor. He urges, with much force, that this policy has resulted in transferring the functions of the city legislature to the State Legislature, and not to the city executive. It has also resulted in the creation of boards of commissioners by the State Legislature which are independent of any municipal au- thority. Moreover, it proceeds on a theory which Prof. Goodnow dislikes—the theory that the city is a business corporation. He holds it an organ of government, and infers that its members should be those to whom the law of the land gives the ultimate de- termination of governmental policy. It is primarily an organ for local government, secondarily an agent of State government. Its local concerns should be controlled by a council, its State agency should be regu- lated by a permanent board of administra- tive supervision representing the State Gov- ernment. Its council should content itself with debate and resolution, accepting no emolument, and abstaining from administra- tion.. That should be attended to by boards of unpaid members appointed by the Mayor for indefinite terms and removable by him, which should have under their direction per- manent subordinates of tried capacity. This theory is pleasing in appearance, and, under different circumstances from those which prevail in this country, it might be successfully applied. In fact, it is in essen- tiais the theory adopted in England, al- though the modifications are important. But the objections to it are serious. It ignores the real difficulties in the way-of good gov- ernment, it proceeds on false analogies, and it makes incorrect assumptions. To present these criticisms in detail, we notice, in the first place, that Prof. Goodnow barely al- ludes to the fact that foreign cities are not governed by universal suffrage. It is this system of government, however, that ren- ders the government of our large cities so difficult, and this fact makes the example of foreign municipalities inapplicable. We must, like Montesquieu, recognize the spirit of laws, and remember that Prussia is a military aristocracy, almost a despotism, and that England is still governed by its aris-
Page 22
3866 The Nation. [Vol. 64, No. 1663 tocracy. The ‘‘spoils system’”’ has not arisen under these governments, while it is the most important feature in our politics. With childlike faith, Prof. Goodnow tells us that this evil will not long remain with us, so great has been the growth of the civil-ser- vice reform movement. We should be glad to be able to share this confidence, but it is at least premature to construct a system the efficiency of which depends, as Prof. Good- now acknowledges, on the establishment of the principles of selection of officers for me- rit and of permanency of tenure in the place of party considerations. To establish these principles would mean deprivation of occu- pation and of income to the whole tribe of politicians, and it is idle to suppose that they can be displaced without a far more desperate struggle than has yet taken place, We must take issue, further, with the as- sertion that the government of a city is not essentially a matter of business. By way of confession and avoidance we may say that even if it is not, a mayor can discharge legislative functions better than a board of aldermen. Prof. Goodnow wholly disregards the fact that these boards have always in this country been inefficient or corrupt, or both. They have been representative bodies only in name. They have represented the spirit of party or the spirit of plunder. They have not represented intelligence; they have borne the name of legislatures, but have not discharged their theoretic functions. To say that their deliberations have been se- rious discussions of matters of public policy is absurd. They have been influenced by public opinion only when they have been de- terred from particularly outrageous mea- sures by angry protests. They are essen- tially irresponsible to the people, for they are responsible primarily to the party mana- gers who have placed them in office. The mayor, on the other hand, ‘may be quite as competent for deliberation as a board of aldermen. He is in position to be influenced’ by the best and most intelligent public opinion. He need not act until he has been informed by public-spirited citizens of what, in their judgment, the general wel- fare demands. To this public opinion he is responsible, and, being an individual, he cannot escape responsibility. It may be urged that our mayors, when given great powers, as in Brooklyn, have disappointed public expectations. Even if this be conced- ed, it can hardly be maintained that they have done worse than our common councils. The experiment has not been fairly tried, and in any case it gives reformers a more advantageous position than they can possi- bly enjoy otherwise. It is easier to compel the nomination of a decent man for mayor than to compel the nomination of a number of decent men for aldermen. The majority must rule in the council; and the desires of a majority of the citizens can be quite as well carried out by a single functionary as by a majority of the board of aldermen. 5 But, in the true sense, the municipality is a business corporation. Prof.Goodnow main- tains that the city is not concerned to make a profit; that, as Mr. Matthews, ex-Mayor of Boston, says, ‘‘Municipal corporations are or- ganized not to make money, but to spend it.” But the important thing is that they should spend it on business principles, and not wastefully and corruptly, as they are prone to do. The methods of expenditure are the most essential feature. Prof. Goodnow ad- mits this to a certain extent, but he does not recognize its fundamental importance. Not a few municipalities have been bankrupted by bad business management, and this pos- sibility is so serious as to make good busi- ness management the first thing to be sought for in municipal reform. If that can be se- cured, the properly governmental functions will easily be provided. In our view, boards of aldermen have in this country proved themselves unfit for the discharge of these functions, and nothing but disappointment will come from the policy of increasing their powers. They will be chiefly composed of men incapable of taking wise and broad views of municipal development, and inte- rested primarily in partisan and selfish ends. If this be true, and if the State Legislatures retain their present character, it will be im- possible to keep the administration of city affairs out of the hands of politicians. We cannot, therefore, accept Prof. Goodnow’s theories; but we must thank him for the able and suggestive way in which he has presented them, and we commend his book to the careful consideration of all thoughtful citizens, and. Philip and Al of Macedon: Two Es- says in Biography. By David G. Hogarth, M.A., Fellow of Magdalen College, Ox- ford. Charles Scribner’s Sons. 1897. THIS work wears a luxurious dress—excel- lent paper and type, elegant illustrations from coins and medals—and is written in a style flashing with brilliantly colored words. The theme is in itself interesting: Philip the maker of a nation, and Alexander the architect of an empire; but Hogarth has added to it a new interest, and has brought us closer to the personality of these two men than perhaps any other modern writer. He mentions only the telling facts, pursues only the main line of events; and, thus avoiding detail, gives us a remarkably per- spicuous narrative of the rise of Philip’s kingdom and Alexander’s empire. Such a method has its limitations. Though fur- nishing plenty of footnote citations of sources, the author speaks to the cultivated public rather than to the scholar. He rarely discusses unsettled questions; hg meets dis- agreeable views with the summary judg- ment of “not proven,’ though he never seriously attempts to prove his own views. Also, the author followsthetoo common prac- tice of exalting hisown subject by depreciating everything that comes into rivalry with it. Arbela is to him “the most famous fight of antiquity.”’ He shows little intimate ac- quaintance with the history of the various Greek States outside of Macedon, or of their social, moral, and political condition in the period of which he writes. He is not merely unsafe in his treatment of these, but posi- tively unfair toward Philip’s and Alexan- der’s enemies. Philip and Alexander treat- ed Thebes brutally; Hogarth follows their example. His characterization of the The- bans as an invading Eastern race, like the Ottoman Turks, is without scientific sup- port, and his whole tirade against Thebes is what we might expect of a violent parti- san of Philip and Alexander. Without ade- quate knowledge of the condition of Athens in the fourth century, Mr. Hogarth has much to say of Athenian degradation, in justification of Philip’s policy toward Ath- ens. This theory of Athenian degradation, to which Hogarth clings, has been success- fully assailed by Holm, a calm-tempered historian. The author’s view that Philip, in his dealings with Athens, was controlled by a purely sentimental respect for her past glory, is a mere illusion. Philip appreciated Athens’s power of resistance, and the im- portance of her political relations with Greece, more thoroughly than is possible for any one who assumes that at that time her citizens were publicly and privately in the last stage of moral decay. Especially interesting in the second essay is the author’s treatment of the gradual development of Alexander’s mind and cha- racter under the influence of his Asiatic ex- periences. But the attempt to justify Alex- ander’s policy of claiming divinity, and de- manding worship of Greeks and Asiatics alike, is a failure. It was unwise in Alexan- der to try to degrade the Greeks to the level of Orientals for the sake of building up a homogeneous empire. As to the place of Philip and Alexander in history, Hogarth has little to say, and that not new. Indeed, the novelty of the work in general is not in its facts and ideas, but rather in its un- troubled narrative, its striking phrases, its expressive epithets, and its clear delinea- tion of the great characters of the epoch under treatment. Travel and Big Game. By Percy Selous and H. A. Bryden. Longmans, Green & Co. Ir is a monotonous fact that the narratives of hunters of large game are mainly records of merciless slaughter. Now and again, however, a sportsman who tells of his ad- ventures in this field, is a valuable contri- butor in the domain of zodlogy or ornitho- logy, a forcible and entertaining writer, a lover of the picturesque, and endowed with judicious self-restraint when confronted with an abundance of game. The authors of the book under notice, we regret to say, do not belong to this class. To ‘Travel and Big Game’ Mr. Selous contributes eleven chapters and Mr. Bryden two—not volun- tarily, as appears from his protest in the Atheneum of April 24. The first-named promptly prejudices his case by stating that, upon arrival at Rio Janeiro, he was “fortu- nate enough, to participate in a genuine slave-hunt.” He gives a brief account of the affair, written in a matter-of-course fashion, as if it were a cheerful episode of domestic life. The unfortunate negro was followed by mounted men with bloodhounds. He found refuge in a tree, to escape being torn to pieces by the dogs. He was dis- lodged and terribly flogged, then, ‘‘tottering and bleeding, he was driven back towards the city like a bullock.” Mr. Selous ex- plains that, had he not been present, the fugitive would have received much more se- vere punishment. In the chapter devoted to “Hunting and Trapping in Canada,” he describes a deer-trap used by a companion and himself. It is made of slabs of wood, and, when the deer is caught, “‘the slabs close on its shins and snap them like match- wood. . . . It matters not if the whole concern is dragged out, for the movable frames are studded with short nails, which clutch the firmer the more the animal pulls.” One may imagine the sufferings of a deer entangled in such a contrivance. There is nothing in this book that lifts it above a commonplace record of killing and maiming; nothing to arouse the interest of the general reader, and nothing told the
Page 23
May 13. 1897] The Nation. 3867 sportsman that has not been imparted to him long since in a much more lucid and at- tractive manner. A Book of Scoundrels. By Charles Whibley. The Macmillan Co. 1897. Ir all the world loves a lover, what is its feeling about scoundrels in literature? Cer- tainly, however we may reprobate, not one wholly devoid of sympathy. It is, in fact, the fascination which crime and wickedness possess that makes publications about them dangerous; but Mr. Whibley seems to us to mistake the sources of this feeling. When we find a boy absorbed in the biographies of Sixteen-String Jack, Jack Sheppard, Car- touche, or Vidocq, it does not necessarily prove that the boy is thrilled with criminal emulation. What these stories have in com- mon with better books is adventure; they are full of danger, of combat, of hairbreadth escapes, of love-affairs, of surprises—in other words, of the materials of romance. But Mr. Whibley seems to think that the characters of the scoundrels are interesting, which is exactly the reverse of the fact. In- terest is never long compatible with disgust. He gives us not only the old stories, but elaborate parallels, in the manner of Plu- tarch, between Moll Cutpurse and Jonathan Wild, between Gilderoy and Sixteen-String Jack, between Sheppard and Cartouche. These, of course, are so grotesque as to be laughable. Indeed, the whole book, with its pseudo-humorous mimicry of a serious lite- rary and biographical style, is decidedly queer literature. The account given of the Abbé Bruneau, ‘‘the man in the gray suit,” is better, as it preserves the record of a very remarkable case which attracted attention a short time ago, and serves to show, if proof is needed, that our age produces types of scoundrelism quite as remarkable as, and no less repulsive than, those which have pre- ceded them. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Baker, M. N. Manual of Sparta Water-Works. 1897. ‘‘Engineering News’ Baring Gould, 8S. Life of a Bonaparte. Lond som: Methuen & Co.; New York: Truslove & Comba Barnes, James. A Loyal Traitor: A Story of the War of a. Harpers. n Birdseye, F. The Greater New York Charter. Baker, Voorhis & Co. Boardman, Rev. G. D. The Problem of Jesus. aay” A. J. Rowland. 50c. Boo rs. Ballington. k Up and Hope. Branded. pee . Each 25c. Branden, D. O’K. Heart- ‘Tones, and Other Poems. Buffalo: Peter Paul Book Co. 25. Bryant, W. C. The Iliad of Homer. Two vol- a in one. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co Catlin, H. G. Yellow Pine Basin: au Story of a Prospector. G. Hi. Richmond & C $1.2: Connell, N. The Fool and His Heart’ G. H. itichniond & Co. Craik, Mrs. Jobn Halifax, Gentleman. Harpers. Creeyey, Caroline A. Flowers of Field, Hill, and Swamp. 50. Dana, Francis. Taceoes of the Gawmish. A Novel. Harpers. $1.25. Dawson, A. J. Middle Greyness. John Lane. Dowden, Prof. Edward. The French Revolution and English Literature. Scribners. 25. Farrar, Rev. F. W. The Bible, its eaning and Supremacy. Longmans, Green & Co. Ford, P. L. The W ritings of Thomas Jefferson. Vol, VIII. 1801-1806. utnams. Foster, D. 8S. Spanish Castles by the Rhine. Henry Holt & Co. T5ec. Freeman, E. A. Sketches of Travel in Normandy and Maine. Macmillan, q Gospel of the Stars; or V onders of Astrology. New York: The Eskdale Press Handy, W. M. Baakies Syatems of the World. Chicago: C. H. r & Co Hay. BH. H. ‘Frumpets and Shawms. Philadel- phia: Arnold & (¢ $1.50. Johnston, Prof. H. “Ww. Latin Manuscripts: An Elementary Introduction. Chicago: Scott, Fores- - $2.25. Knanff, C. W. Doctor Tucker, Priest-Musician. Randolph. $1.50. Koch, T. W. Dante in America: A Historical and Bibliogra yhieal Study. Boston: Ginn & Co. Liipke, Robert. The Elements of Electro-Chem- istry Treated Experimentally. London: H. Gre- vel & Co.; Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott Co. “arene Prof. R. Galdés’s Dofia Perfecta. Boston: Ginn & Co. Mason, E. T. Lyrical and Dosmatic Poems ha lected from Browning. Henry Holt & Co. Matthews, Major Washington. Navaho Legends. Boston: Hougutoa Mifflin & McKean, May F. Ruth the Gleaner, Philadel- phia: Ba sat Publication Society —~ F.. Phyllis and Philistia. Cassell Pub- * BOe. ishing Co -Climbing. Athletic Sports. [The Out- of-Door Library.] Scribners. Each $1.50. 1 Mmm Fag tt! lord: Murray Historical Princt trusttully— Deo II.). orem Foister a! te ha a Press; Murray, Prof. Gilbert. “A Bieter” of milan. Greek ae Fae ~*~ $1.50. D. ntroductory Course in Differen- tia 1 at Hquations, © Longmats, Green & Co. $1.90. Myrick, Herbert. Sugar: A New ant Profitable Industry. New York: Orange Judd Co. Neville-Rolfe, E. Naples in the Nineties. Lon- don: A.,& ©. Black; New York: Macmillan. Newman, J. H. The Devotions of Bishop An- drewes. Translated from the Greek. G. H. Righwens *, Co. Nicolls, J. The Railway Builder: A Hand- book Pe, Estimating the Cost of American Rail- ie 4 Construction and Equipment. Philadelphia: Lippincott Co. Pages Choisies de Jules Claretie. Paris: A. Colin & Cie Peilico, Silvio. Francesca da Rimini. Cambridge, Mass.; C. W. Sever. Piatt, J. J. Odes in Otte, and Other Poems. Cin- cinnati: Robert. Clarke Co. — =e 2 eo » un Pape Philosophe. Paris: Lero Robert. Sau a. The Eternal Enigma: A Page from the Life of Yvette Guilbert. Jodge Pu lishing Co. Savage, R. H. ‘ie Schamyl’s Wooing. Rand, MeNally & Co, Siecke, Prof. Ernst. * Die Urreligion der Indoger- manen. Berlin: Mayer & Miiller. Sloane, Prof. W. M. Life of Napoleon Bona- parte. Vol III. Century ‘0. Stebbins, Sarah B. Was it He? G. W. Dilling- » we, Thanet, or eo The Missionary Sheriff. Har- Thatcher, O. J. A Short History of Medieval Europe. Scribners. $1.25. = Encyclopedia of Sport. Part I. Putnams. Theiss, J. W. Gepfliicht am Wege: Lieder und Gedichte. St. Louis: Louis Lange Publishing Co. The House of Dreams. Dodd, Mead & Co. -25. “The Living Age.’’ Jan.-March, 1897. Boston: “Living Age’’ Co. Thomson, A. C. The Outgoing Turk: Impressions of a Journey Through the Western Balkans. London: Heinemann Thwaites, R. G. The Jesuit Relations. Vol VI. Quebec: 1633-1634. Cleveland: Burrows Bros. Twain, Mark. Bow to a a Story, and Other Essays. Ha |S gg Tyler, Prof. M. c. he Literary History of the 783 TI. 1763- ‘American Revolution. 1763-1783. Vol 1776. Putnams. $3. Urtext und Ubersetzungen der Binet in_tibersicht- licher Darstellung. Ree Hinrichs. Voorhees, J. Tale of Modern Theatrical Bohemia Adams Pres Wells, Ya G. Thirty Strange Stories. Edward Wiedemann, Prof. Alfred. Religie of the An- cient Egyptians. London: Grevel & Co.; New York: Putnams. $3.75. Wilkins, Frances. A Microscopic Hypnotist. G. bf i ty 50c. Willard, F. B. A Pretty Bandit. New York: The Eskdale Mh . Yonge, Charlotte M. The Pilgrimage of the Ben Beriah. jo nenlt $1.25. W ashington: Byron Henry Holt & Co.’s New Books TO BE PUBLISHED SATURDAY: SKETCHES IN LAVENDER, BLUE AND GREEN. Tales and “ Character Scapes.” By Jerome K. Jerome, author of “ Three Men in a Boat,” “The Diary of a Pilgrimage,” etc. With 10 full-page illustrations and 30 in the text. 12mo, $1.25. In the three years since “John Ingerfleld,” Mr. Jerome’s last book, appeared, he has written some well-liked plays, and in this volume he shows a marked advance in dramatic force and rapidity of movement. While his prevailing tone is gay, several of the tales, however, have a strong emotional in SVENGALI’S DIARY. rest FUST PUBLISHED. IN PLAIN AIR. A novel of New England to-day. By ELIzaABETH LYMAN CABOT. 12mo, $1.25. The Christian Register: “ Naturally told and decidedly interesting. a picture drawn from life.’’ - One feels quite sure that it is TWO NEW VOLUMES IN THE BUCKRAM SERIES. SPANISH CASTLES BY THE RHINE. A Triptychal Yarn. By DAvip SkaAaTs Foster. With 12 full-page illustrations. 18mo, 75 cents. The grotesque adventures of three lively and very up-to-date Yankees among the scenes of medizval ro- mance. The book displays a good knowledge of German character, as well as a petty skill at burlesque. THE WHITE HECATOMB AND OTHER STORIES. By Wu. Cuas. ScuLLY (uniform with his Kafir Stories). With frontispiece. 18mo, 75 cents. These stories, without any paziving for effect, are as frankly horrible as Poe’s. They are rapid and simple and their plots remarkable. Temes said of “ Kafir Stories”: ‘* He writes of South Africa with the sure knowledge, the sympathy, and almost with the vigor that Mr. Kipling bestows upon his Hindu stories,” and the ton Transcript called it “ a desperately strong little book.” SOME QUESTIONS OF GOOD ENGLISH. Examined in controversies with Dr. Fitzedward Hall. By oe OLMSTEAD WILLIAMS (author of Our Dic- tionaries and Other English Language Topics). 12mo, $1.7 : . THE FERN COLLECTOR’S HANDBOOK AND HERBARIUII. 72 plates, mostly life-size, with a botanical guide. By Miss S. F. Price. 4to, $2.25. ion:—" Seventy-two excellent figures of our native forse are given, for bag tary part with a suffi- eient distinctness to make their identification mere child’s play. and Mr. Schuyler Matthews have rendered good service in their botanical sketches, and we must ask them for more.’ 29_W. 23D ST., NEW YORK. Yale Mixture. A GENTLEMAN’S SMOKE. You won’t know the luxury of Pipe-Smoking until you use Yaie Mixture. A two-oz. trial package, postpaid, for 25 cts. MARBURG BROS., The American Tobacco Co., Successor, Baltimore, Md. A NEW WORK BY DEAN FARRAR. The Bible: ITS MEANING AND SUPREMACY By F. W. FARRAR, D.D., F.R.S., Dean of Canterbury. Large crown 8vo, gilt top, pp. 376, $2.00. LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., 91-93 Fifth Avenue, New York.
Page 24
The Nation. soda 32 feo [Vol. 64, No. 1663 Dodd, Mead & Company HAVE NEARLY READY: LADY BURTON The Romance of Isabel, Lady Burton. The story of her life. Told in part by herself, and in part by W. H. Wilkins. In two vols., 8vo, cloth, gilt tops. With photogravure and other portraits, aud numerous illustrations. Two vols., $7.50. This book is the life ‘story of one of the most in- teresting and picturesque personalities of our time sabel, tton, the wife of the famous Orientalist fad explorer. Lady Burton was as re- markable a character as a woman as Sir Richard m wasasaman. The tale of her romantic love and marriage, and her unique devotion to her husband, is here told with many new facts. Her exciting ‘travels and adventures in Soutn America, the Syrian Desert, the Holy Land, Arabia, Egypt, India, and elsewhere are recounted. The truth about her burning of ‘‘The Scented Garden”? is told, and her real motives given. _ MISS TOOLEY The Personal Life of Queen Victoria. By Miss TooLey. Illustrated. Cloth, $2.00. At this time, when the Queen’s jubilee is excitin such general attention, an account of the persona! life of the Queen will, it is thought, be of interest to the American public. Miss ber J is thoroughly qualified to treat of this phase of the Queen’s life with anthority and interest, having been in a posi- tion to know intimately the life of the Queen at Windsor and while travelling abroad. M. MAETERLINCK The Treasure of the Humble. MAETERLINCK. 12mo, cloth, $1.75, With M. Maeterlinck as a dramatist the world is well acquainted. His latest volume, however, pre- sents him in the character of a philosopher and an testhetician. ‘‘ The Treasure of the Humble” con- tains his present ideas on a variety of subjects— Mystic Morality, Women, the Inner Beauty, the Deeper Life, the Awakening of the Soul—all ap- proached from the view-point of a supersensuous, mystical child of the last half of the 19th century. RECENTLY PUBLISHED. MRS. CLIFFORD The Dominant Note, and Other Stories. By Mrs. W. K. Ciirrorp, author of The Love ,Letters of a Worldly Woman, Aunt Anne, etc. 12mo, $1.25. EDMUND GOSSE Seventeenth-Century Studies. By Ed- MUND GossE, author of Critical Kit Kats, etc. 12mo, cloth, $1 50. By M. Also by Edmund Gosse : Critical Kit Kats. 12mo, cloth, $1 50. From Shakespeare to Pope. 12mo, cloth, $1.25. ‘ MAX PEMBERTON Christine of the Hills, By Max Premper- TON, author of A Puritan’s Wife, Lit- tle Huguenot, An Impregnable City, etc. 12mo, cloth, $1 25. AN EMINENT ENGLISH AUTHOR The House of Dreams, 160, cloth, $1.25. By an eminent English writer whose name is for the present withheld. BEATRICE HARRADEN Hilda Strafford. A California Story. By BEATRICE HARRADEN, author of Ships That Pass in the Night. Withillustra- tions by Eric Pape. 12mo, cloth, $1.25. Dodd, Mead & Company, Fifth Ave. and Twenty-first St. NEW YORK. he Yale Review Contents for May, 1897. Limits of Constitutional Law. Mr. Taacaer of the New York Bar. The Farmer and Taxation. Professor C.S. WaLK- ER of the Amherst Agricultural College. The Rationale of Congressional Extravagance. Mr. Rotto Oapsen ef the New York Evening Post. Street Railways and their Relation to the Pub- lic. Mr. C. E. Curtis of New Haven. Public Baths; or the Gospel of Cleanliness. Dr. W. H. Totman of the New York Association for Improving the Condition of the Poor. Editorial Notes on the English Licensing System; The New Economic Magazines; Insurance against Loss of Work in Switzerland ; Prices in Silver Countries; Wages in Silver Countries; Price Movements and Interest in India. Book Reviews: Baden-Powell’s Village Communi- ties in India; Keasbey’s Nicaragua Canal; Kerr’s U. S. Senate; Thiébault’s Memoirs; Andrews’s Development of Modern Europe. THomas = $3.00 75 Yearly Subscription, - = Single Number, - = - Tuttle, Morehouse k Taylor, PUBLISHERS, NEW HAVEN, NEW BOOKS. Corporation Finance. A Study of the Principles and Methods of the Management of the Finances of Corporations in the United States, with special reference to the valuation of corporation securities. By THomas L, GreEenzE, Auditor of the Manhattan Trust Co. 8vo, $1.25. Life of Abby Hopper Gib- bons. Told chiefly through her Correspondence. Edited by her daugheer, Satan Hopper Emerson. Illustrated. Two volumes, 12mo, per set, $3 00. CONN. Fugitive Lines. By H. J. StockaRD. 12mo, $1.00. G.P. PUTNAM’S SONS NEW YORK AND LONDON. Poems. Professor Cope’s Portrait. A fine portrait of the late Professor E. D. COPE has been published by GUTBKUNST. Itisof large size, suitable for framing, and is a speaking like- ness, being not only a beautiful specimen of photo- graphy, but a life-like portrait of the great scien- ist. CREST VIEW SANITARIUM, Greenwich, Conn. An ideal home for health and re- creation seekers. Beqetite), scene ve aqpeestble; moderate rates. M. HITCHCOCK, M KIN DERGARTEN SsuPPLIES at SCHERMERHORN’S, 8 East 14th Street, N. Y. Send for new Catalogue. CATALOGUE NO. 4 NOW READY. Americana, Masala ig, Trae, Ste. Mailed upon appli- cation. PHREY, Dedham, Maee, Safety from Sewer Gas and Damp. *T had as Hef they would put ratsbane in my mouth as offer to stop it pan re _ Many readers of the Nation live where it is impossible to hire good mechanics; hence they are at the mercy of the ordinary plumber, whom an inscrutable Providence permits to tamper with the sanitary arrangements of even the finest houses. The dire results of such meddling are known to all. I have been called to scores of places from Beverly Farms, Mass., to the heart of Geor- gia, to supplement or correct the work of the local plumber, builder, or architect. There are many things besides plumbing which I look after, and which seriously affect health. My fees are modest, and often save doctors’ bills. Write for particulars. CHAS. F. WINGATE, Sanitary Engineer and Inspector of Houses, 119 Pearl Street, Hanover Square, NEW YORK. French and German BOOKS. The latest French and German Books Are promptly imported and kept for sale. All Standard Works continually in stock. Write for new list of late Fiction. BRENTANO’S, 31 Union Square, New York. LIBRARIES Library Catalogue Mailed Free. LISTS PRICED GRATIS. THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO., Wholesale Books, 5 & 7 East 16th St., New York. ELLIS & ELVEY, Dealers in Old and Rare Books CAT om OF CHOICE BOOKS AND ILLUMI- 'D MANUSCRIPTS published periodically. ro mera glish Literature, Early Printed Books in pee yes aeaent Artistic Bookbindings,rare Prints » and Autogrens 8,etc. Only fine specimens are dealt with. 'W BOND STREET, LONDON, W. F. W. CHRISTERN (DYRSEN & PFEIFFER, Successors), 429 | Ave., bet. 38th and 39th ge East Side, N. Y¥., Importers of Forei Books; Agents for the leading Paris Publishers; Tanchalte'e British authors, Teubner’s Greek and Latin Clas- sics. Catalogues of stock mailed on demand. New books received from Paris and Leipzig as soon as issued. FRENCH BOOKS “2s, s23Rcn Complete Catalogue on application. gs TALOGUE NO. 44 OF BOOKS AND Panes, isting v9 Amerioe in ete character but in the main lew York. America, no’ S. CLARK, 174 Fulton St, UTOGRAPH AND BOOK-PLA TE Collectors! Send for sample of “ The Coll rr.” ALTER ROMEYN BENJAMIN, 1125 Broadway, N. Y. City. FLLIAMS, 25 EAST IOTH ST., Dealer in ~ Fn other Pi cals. PE hh je numbers a OLD BOOKS, suits zo usr. 2N. St., St. Louis, Mo.