The Nation 1897-04-29: Vol 64 Iss 1661

Page 1

Vh N t VOL. LXIV—NO. 1661. THURSDAY, APRIL 29, 1897. PRICE 10 CENTS. THE MAY NUMBER OF THE NortH AMERICAN REVIE CONTAINS: HENRY DRUMMOND. By Ian Maclaren. SHOULD IMMIGRATION BE RESTRICTED? , Z S. G. CROSWELL RECENT ACHIEVEMENTS IN MOUNTAINEERING, A Sir W. M. Conway EVOLUTION OF THE NAVAL OFFICER,. : ApMIRAL P. H. Cotoms, R.N. EXERCISE AND LONGEVITY, . ; ; ; Proressor D. A. SARGENT PROGRESS OF THE UNITED STATES. 1.—THE NEW ENGLAND STATES. By M. G. Mulhall, F.S.S. THE DINGLEY TARIFF BILL, : : Tue How. R. P. Porter PLANS AND PURPOSES OF RUSSIA, . ; . W. F. Mason McCarty CHEAP TRANSPORTATION IN THE UNITED STATES, , J. A. Latcua THE MODERN GREEK AS A FIGHTING MAN, . Proressor B. I. WHEELER SECRET SOCIETIES IN AMERICA, . : W. S. Harwoop * A CONSTITUTIONAL MISFIT. By Professor Goldwin Smith. PROGRESSIVE INHERITANCE TAXES, : Max West THE FOURTH OF JULY AND BALLOT REFORM, tin Rev. A. B. Rrxer, D.D. MISTAKES ABOUT JUDICIAL PROCEDURE IN MEXICO, Tue Mexican MINISTER 50 Cents a Copy; $5.00 a Year. Sold by all Newsdealers. THE NORTH AMERICAN REVIEW, 291 Fifth Avenue, New York.

Page 2

(See eres aN eS aR aft Sie ste le Ne PM 2K HES SP ee MO A i, eg RLS CR ON. ST Ad aan mee —s =. The Nation. [ Vol. 64, No. 1661 The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science, and Art. FOUNDED 1865. [ Butered at .he New York City Post-Office as second-class mail-matter. | CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. EDITORIAL ARTICLES: The Reform Club Dinner. . The Treasury Order..... The Civil-Service Decisi A New Experiment in Socialism SPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE ; The American Oriental Society’s Meeting........ 816 A Visit to the Convent of Meteora in Thessaly... . 317 The Spade Before the Sword ............+ceeeeeeees 318 CORRESPONDENCE : School Holidays Less—and More __....... The Antiquity of Welleri Lines by T'nomas Paine. Whittier and the ‘ Narrative of James WOCMD cececcccccecsccccovecccesscosovessvccectssevesocee 821 Book REVIEWS Foote’s Annals of King’s Chapel...............s005 824 Landacane in Poetry..........ccoccesscccccecccccces R26 Genius an‘ Deve eration.. seaseedecvencenss $26 eee Oe ee errr 827 Tepical No‘es on American AUtHOPS...........+++ 327 ID GO hiv von cases casscnensensccncdaccsessocs 827 BOOKS OF THE WEEK .......++++++ encevcevescoecesess 828 TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three Dollars per year, in advance, postpaid, to any part of the United States or Canada; to foreign coun- tries comprised in che Postal Unton, 84 (0. The date when the subscription expires is on the Ad- dress-Label of each paper, the change of which to a sub- sequent date becomes a receipt for remittance. No other receipt is sent unless requested, Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter,or by check, exvress order, or postal erder, payandle to “Publisher of the Nation.” Whena change of address ts desired, both the old and new addresses should be given. Address THE NATION, Box 794, New York, Publication Office, 208 Broadway. TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Fifteen cents per agate line, each insertion, 14 lines to the inch. Twenty per cent. advance for chotce of page, top of column, or cuts, Cuts are not inserted on the first page. Acolumn, $20 each tnsertion; with chotce of page, $24. A page, $40 each insertion; front-cover page, $80. Advertisements must be acceptable in every respect. Copy received until Tuesday, 5 P. M. DISCOUNTS. MOU $100 y within a oe nbSguhyseacekesunnp ian 10 per cent. 250 os eS id 500 “ “ 750 i = The NATION ts sent free to who advertise in ét as long as the advertisement continues. The ED1i1ON of the Natton this week is 11,900 coptes. The Subscription List ts always open to the tn- spection of advertisers. *,* Copies of the NATION may be procured in Paris at Brentano’s, 17 Avenue de PrOpéra, and in London of B. F. Stevens, 4 Trafalgar = ra American Newspaper Agency, 15 King illiam Street, Strand, W. London agent for advertisements, R.J. Bush, Fleet Street, E. C. E:ducational. LIFORNIA, Los Angeles, West 2 ARLBOROUGH SCHOOL fi omy GIRLS. Mrs, GrorGs. A. CASWELL Principal. Connecticut, Waterbu: T. MARGARE ak DIOCESAN Boarding and Day School for Girla. Spring term opens April 7, eg Twenty-second year. The Rev. rancis Russell, D.D., Rector. Miss Mary R. Hil- lard, Principal. waRE, Wilmington, Franklin Street. HE MISSES HEBBS Boarding and Day School for Girls will reopen September 24. ILuno1s, Chicago, 1500-4 Title and Trust Building. YICAGO COLLEGE OF LAW, Law DEPARTMENT OF LAKE ForEST UNIVERSITY. Two and three-year course. For yeast information, address the Secretary, . E. BARRETT. MARYLAND, Catonsville, T. TIMOTH Y’S SCHOOL for Girls re pens September 23, 1896. Prepares for College. Heads. Of School: Miss M. G. CarTER, Miss S R. CARTER. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 9 Appleton Street. OSTUN NORMAL SCHOOL of House hold Arts, established by the late Mrs Mary Hz- MENWAY, under the name of Boston NonMaL SCHOOL OF COOKERY, will reopen Sept. Be Adaress the Director, iss AMY Morris Homans. MassacuuseEtts, B OSTON UN. IVERSITY Law School. Address the Dean EpMUND H. BENNetr, LL.D. MASSACHUSETTS Duxbu! P*% WDER POINT SCHOOL. — — Prepares for: Scientific School, Conese, or business. Indb vidual teaching. Elementary classes f. r cere & boys. Home and outdoor life. b. Ksapp, 8. MASSACHUSETTS, Waban, 10 miles from Boston. INDSOR HALL SCHOOL Prepares girls for Radcliffe and other Colleges. Studies elective in other courses. Comfortable home. Dr. CHARLES H. CLARE, Principal. CHIGAN, Orchard A ICHIGAN nda TTAR Y ACADEMY. —20th year. ares for leading universities. Graduates are now it arvard, Yale, Princeton, Com nell, and University of Michwan New g:mnasium 50x150 feet. Address COLONEL Rogers, Suot. PENNSYLVaNl4s, Philadelphia, 1350 Pine S'reet, Mir ANABLE’S Boarding and Day School for Young Ladies. Estab. in 1848. Circu- lar on annileation T. AGNES’ SCHUOL, Albany, N. Y.— Under the eeeeten of Bishop Doane. 27th vear. ELLEN W. Koyp, Principal. School of Drawing and Painting MUSEUM OF FINE ARTS, Copley Square, Boston, Mass. TWENTY-FIRST YEAR. NOW OPEN. Instruction in drawing from the cast and from life, in painting and decorative design, and also in artistic anatomy and perspective Principal instructors, F. W. Benson, E C Tarbetl, and Philip Hale Grewaes ona Painting). Dirs. Wiliam Stone (Decorative Design), E. Emerson (Anatomy),and A. K Cross ‘/Perspective) pils are allowed the free use of the galleries of the Mu seum. For circulars firing detailed taformation, ad- dress Mis- EL’ TH LOMB «RD. manager. New York University. SUMMER COURSES. Third session July 5-August 13. Twenty ninecourses in Mathematics, Science, Languages, and Pedagogy. A delightful suburban locality in New York city. For announcement apply to the Secretary, CHAS. B. BLISS, University Heights, New York City. Miss Baldwin S School for Girls, RYN MAW PRE. to. Bryn ae College. Miss FLORENCE BALDWIN, Principal. Within six years more than sixty pupils have entered Bryn Mawr Col- lege from this senool. Certificate admits to Smita, Vassar, and We lesley. D ploma given in both General and College Preparatory Courses, Fine, fire-proof stove building. 25 acres beautiful grounds. For cir- cular, andr s the Secretary Ht SAUVEUR SUMMER SCHVOL of Languag:s at Amherst College, Mass. Twenty- second Sersioo—July 5 to August 13 $ bor prog. — address Miss F. M. Henshaw, Amherst, Mass. r par- ticulars end circulars of L Sauveur’s Works, aateles Dr. L. Savveur, 4613 Ellis Ave., Chicago, Lil. THE CAMBRIDGE SCHOOL. A Select School for Girls. Comforts of home. Mr. ARTHOR GILMAN is the eae tor. CAMBRIDGE, MASS. Educational. University of Michigan. SUMMER SCHOOL. July 7—August 18. Courses will be offered in all leading Academic stu- dies; also in Law, Eayineering, Ract-riology, Histolo- gy,and Photography. For full announcement apply to Secretary, JAMES H. WADE, ANN ARBOR, MICH. Cortina Method | S329; SPANISH. FRENCH. ENGLISH. IN 20 LESSONS, cloth, each, $1.50. FRENCH ee copies of Books I. and Il., 30c. Other TEXT-BOOKS. Send 5c. Cortina Academy of Languages, 44 West sath St,, N. Y. MANUAL TRAINING. FPREE COURSES for TEAC “ERS, fitting for both Grammar and High School Work. at the SLOYD ac I SCHOOL, established by Mrs. Quincy aw Time for each course, October 1 to June 1. Address GUSTAF LARSSON, Prin. ipal. 39 North Bennet St., - «= Boston, Mass. NEw YORK Cry, 30, 32, 84 East 57th Street. The Peebles and Thompson School For Boarding and Day Pupils, Miss D. E. Merrill, Miss L. A. Bushee, Mrs. S. S. Van Laer, Princivals and Provr'etors, will open October 4 ARIENFELD SUMMER CAMP for Bovs is held am ng the nearer a during July and be iy (2d year). Forcirculars, a s r. C, HANFORD HENDERSON, Chestnut Hill, Pa. Teachers, etc. NINSTRUCTOR IN THE MASSA- chusetts Institute -f Technology and graduate of the Jonns Hopkins University (4.B and Ph.D. 7. who has spent two summers in travel io Europe, de- sires to tuto; during tre coming summer. Mathema- tics aspecialty. Address N., care vation. TUDENT OF GERMANIC PHILO- logy and Literature, four years’ postgraduate study abroat, oes year’s experience, seeks college position Addre FLW.F,4 Nettelbeck St., BERLIN, GERMANY. HARVARD M.A. Man, aged 25, with teaching experierce (col- lege), wants a position to teach La in and Greek in a priva e or preparatury school or college. Very best references. aduress B., Nation office. ANTED - Teaching, Coaching, or Tu- toring. ? nited States History and Latin spe- cialties, E.IzaABETH M Ash, BA (Women's v vilege of Serene 1894; M.A (University of Pa. Address E. M: ASH, 2136 Bolton Ave., J apo Md. CB og utedbell IN LATIN, h.D , five years’ experience, three years in pre- sent place, desires a chair of Latin for coming year in small college in Eastern or Middle States. Aadress PHD, care Nation, VERY SUCCESSFUL TEACHER, baving given up bis position for the special study of Greek and German abroa4, is — for an engage- ment. Would also teach Latin or History. Best refer- ences. Pu.D., care of the Nation. intending to travel in Harvard Graduate, Europe during the sum- mer vacation, wishes to take with him a young lad, over whom be will .assume careful supervision; good ref. rences. Address HARVARD, care of the Nation. SPECIALIST IV LATIN OF SE- ven years’ experience in academy and college; Ph.D. of Correll University, desires a cultege position. Excetlent references. Address £ K., care cf Nation, F. KRAFFT, EXPERT TUTOR. We refer toa few of the best New York fam- _—. whose sons we have prepared for college. Ad- dress 38 East 49th St., New York City. big togid W, STONE, Tutor for Har. vard, 68 Chestnut Street, Boston.

Page 3

April 29, 1897] The Nation. | Charles Scribner’s Sons’ Newest by keen, incisive, suggestive treatment. INDUCTIVE LOGIC. By JOHN GRIER HIBBEN, Ph.D., Assistant Professor of Logic in Princeton University. 12mo, 346 pages, $1.50. President Wm De W. Hyde, Bowdoin College; “ Professor Hibben has res- cued tne subject from the eptarglements with discarded psych logy and false met*physics ta Which 't was left by Milt and sain; grounded itia a sound and rationat philosophy; pr sented it iu aiear and attractive style; and brought his numerous illustrations up to date.” THE POWER OF THOUGHT. What It Is and What It Does. By Joan DouGLAs STERRETT. With an Introduction by Professor J. Mark Baldwin, of Princeton University. 12mo, $1.75. Frtract from Professor Baldwin's Introduction: “In manv respects a time!y and valuable work .. . Mr. Sterrett see ns to hav- dove what many psvchologisis would like 10 be able to do, i.¢., write a book which interests || pe-ple generally wit out repelling them by scientific terms and phrases unfa || Mitiar to the :ay m’nd; aad »t the same time, not to falt imto that otner pit of || popu ar *ctentific writers, the condemnavion of having cheapened science by | Works in Mental and Moral Science 1 READY MAY 2a. 1 THE PHILOSOPHY OF KNOWLEDGE. By GEORGE TRUMBULL Lapp, Professor of Philosophy ia Yale University. 8vo. $4 00. | Dr. Latd's wide reputation in the field of psychology and philosoohy gives much interest to anything new from his talented pen. In the present case an ad- | ditiopal attraccion is give» by tbe fact that he is the pioneer American author on the subject chosep. As always, his discussion is marked by deep thinking, and | | A deservedly popular earlier work of Dr, Ladd's is his PRIMER OF PSYCHOLOGY. By GEORGE TRUMBULL LaDD, Professor of Philosophy in Yale University. An elem¢ntary text-book for high schocls and academies, recently adopted as a text-book ia Brooklyn, N. Y.: Utica, N. Y.; Buffalo. N. Y.; Binghamton, N Y.; Middiebor» Mass ; Kbhod- Island State Normal Scho +l, Kan-as Normal College New Hampsaire State Normal School, Los angeles s.ate Normal Scavol, Wel- lesley Coilege, University of Toroato, and in the sixth edition, within one year after publication. 12m0, 224 pages, $1.00 net. Sixth edition. HISTORY OF PHILOSOPHY. By ALFRED WEBER, Professor in the University of Strasbourg. Trausiated by Frank [nuilly, Ph D., Professor of Philosophy in the University of Misso.urt, from the Fifth French E tition, re- vised and enlargei. With Bioliography. 8vo, $2.50 net. Professor WILLIAM JamEs: “ From its size, its clearness, its prop rtion, it Is adaoted b tter for an ordinary college text-book than any extant geaeral His- tory of Philosophy.”’ ELEMENTS OF PSYCHOLOGY. By GrorGse GRooM ROBERTSON, late Greek Professor University College, London. Ett-ed from Notes of the Lectures delivered at the College, 1870-1592 By C. A. Foley Rnys Davids. [Uni- versity Series.] 12mo, $1.00 net. ELEMENTS OF GENERAL PHILOSOPHY. watering it. SCHOPENHAUER’S SYSTEM IN ITS PHILOSOPHICAL SIGNIFICANCE, By WILLIAM CALDWELL, Professor of Moral and Social Philosophy in Northwestern University. 8vo, $3 00 net. A most interesting statement of the true significance of Schopenhauer's philosophy in the light of mouern thought and research. Davids, peare 870, $2 00 net, By GEORGE GROOM KOBERTSON. delivered at the Coll-ge. 1870-172, (Uaiversity Serie-.] l2mo, $1 25 net. These two volumes have been compiled from notes taken by the students of Dr Rovertson, and in a way ave a Me norial to that “reat ceacher, ume they tak - their plat- in the University Series b educational value they bave, and will be foucd :0« duction to psych lugy and.also to pny by way of psychology. Nu other two manuals 50 adaptcd have yet ap- Elite i from Notes of the Lectures By C. A. Foley Ruys- Av che sane r. asou of the excep.ioval rd nos merely an ia‘ro- hilosophy, buc an meroduction to pri ose- AN INTRODUCTION TO SOCIOLOGY. By ARTHUR FAIRBANKS, Ph.D, Instructor in Yale Uaiversity. Prof. JEROwE H RAYMOND. Uatversity of Wisconsin, writes: “Ihave gotte1 more help from your book than any book that I have read within a year. Every teacher and student of sociology will feel personally grateful to you fur waat you aave doa? aad the way in whica you nave doae it.” CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS, 153-157 Fifth Avenue, New York. School Agencies. HE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES, EVERETT O. Fisk & Co., Props., 4 Ashburt’n PI., Bos ton; 70 5th Ave. N. Y ; 355 Wabash Ave., Chicago; 1242 12th St., Wash.; 420 Cent Bdg, Min’apolis; 728 Cooper Bdg., Denver; 107 K. & P Bdg , Kansas City; 25 King St., Toronto; 525 Scims’n Bk., Los Angeles. Ag cy Man free. LBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY, 24 State St., Albany, N. Y.—Provides schools of all grades with competent teachers. Assists teachers in obtaming positions. HARLAN P. FRENCH, Manager. R COLLEGE POSITIONS IN THE WEST, Apply to ALBERT & CLARK, Pullman Building, Chicago. CHERMERHORN’S.TEACHERS' Agency. Oldest and best known in the U.S, Established 1855, 8 East 14th St., N. Y. An A enc is valuable in proportion to its in- 4 y fluence. If it merely hears of va- cancies and tells that is something, butif itis asked to you about them recommend a teacher and rec- ommends von, that is more. Ours C. W. BARDEEN, Syracuse, N.Y, RECOMMENAS The result of ye Bread Flour whi Write to Farw4l] & Rhine Watestown, N. Y.,U 8.4. CREST VIEW SANITARIUM, Greenwich, Conn. An ideal home for health and re- creation seekers. Beautiful scenery; very accessible; moderate rates. a. M. HITCHCOCK, M.D. We buy and sell bills of exchange on Letters and make Cable Transfere of money to of Europe, Australia, and South Africa; also make collections and issue Commercial Credit and Travellers’ Credits, available in all parts of the world. BROWN BROTHERS & CO. ___B0. 50 WALL SFREST. NEW YORE. KIN DERGARTEN SUPPLIES at SCHERMERHORN’S. 8 East 14th Street, N. Y. Send for new Catalogue. 6 OU may not be worthy to smoke the ‘ARCADIA’ MIXTURE.” —J. M. B—, in ‘‘ My lady Nicotine.” Send 25 cents for sample to THE SURBRUG CO.. 37 Dev Street. N. Y. City. BURR’S LIBRARY INDEX. FOR INDEXING SUBJECTS, TO AID THE STUDENT, SCHOLAR CLERGYMAN EDITOR AUTHOR, TEACHER, AND aLL LOVERS OF pOOK © staat PHYSICIAN, All Words and Names are indexed by te first TWO letters, with nearly 400 divisions of the Alphabet printed in Toumbholes cut in the edges ofgne leaves Opened iastantly at any combination Write for Descriptive Circular and price. THE BURR {INDEX CO., Sole Manufacturers, y the use of one hand! An index toinformation for immediate or future use. HARTFORD, CONN. Tours. EUROPE. PRIVATE PA RTI ES,—Comprehensive routes— special service in travel—careful and thorough sixzbt seeing. llth season. Special party for Southern route May 2Y. Mrs. M. D. PFRAZAR, 70 Globe Building, Boston. Mass. BICYCLING IN GREAT BRITAIN. A physician of experience in the care of boys will take a smat! parcy through Englaud and Scotiand dur- ing July and August ef-rs by permission to Dr. David W_ Cheever, Ros ton; Dr. F C Shattuck, Boston; Kdward E. Hale, D.v, Boston Address EK. C, STOWELL, MD, 502 Beacon St , Boston. BICYCLE TOUR TO EUROPE. 70 DAYS, $375. Address for circular, H. B. HIEGEL Arcanum, oO. H ’ To Europe. (9th sea- Kimball’s Tours [o®"fore, Sth sew sails June 23. Moderate price, comprehensive route. Address EDWIN C. KIMBALL, 56 Summer St., Boston, Mass. m1 UNICH,. GERMAN Y.— PENSION NORDLAND. Schellingstrasse 10, I (near Lud- wigstr.). Very central Comfortable ana refined home fur ladies and famities. Terms moderate. American and English references. ANNUAL SUMMER TOURS. Few va- EUROPE. capeies ia select and small party per- sonally conducted by trof CAMILLE THURWANGER, now forming 381 Pierce Building, Boston. ACATION1R.P LVUEURUPEL,CON- ducted oy an experienced chaperon. Will sail from New Yor Apply for programine to Miss SARAH NAGEL, Hotel Altamonr, Baitimore, Md. ACATION TRIP TO EUROPE. Specially planned for rest and recreation. Terms most reasonable. For full particulars, aduress Prof. H. B. RicHaRpDsos, amherst, Mass. EUROPEAN BICYCLE TOUR. Allexpenses, 70 days. $120. C. H. SMITA, 2'8 Woedward Ave Detroit, Mich. EUROPE. pe tu bEsT AND CHEarbsr 1t0URs. 3alL June. Will pay 2000 Fr. to rson ton, getting dozen tourists. INTERNATIONAL PRESS,

Page 4

+ Nene ee nen oe eee re Sis —— sg oof rhb amg a al se oc oc pe cage patie dir gles eT nd 2 RS, PMS KER Fi iv The Nation. [Vol. 64, No. 1661 The Macmillan Company’s Latest Text-Books The Outlines of Physics. By EDWARD L. NICHOLS, Professor of Physics in Cornell University. Cloth, 8vo. Price, $1.40 net. Problems and Questions in Physics. By CHARLES P. MATTHEWS. M.E., Associate Prufessor of Electrica Kngineering, Purdue University, . And JOHN SHEARER, B.S., Instructor in Physics wn Cornell-University. 8vo, cloth. Price, $1.60 net. The Elements of Physics. By EDWARD L. NICHOLS, B.S., Ph.D., Professor of Physics in Cornell University, And WILLIAM S. FRANKLIN, M.S., - Professor of Phytics and Electrical Engineering at the Iowa Agricultural College, Ames, Iowa. Complete in Three Volumes, each $1.50. Volume I., Mechanics and Heat. Volume Il., Electricity and M’>gnetism. Volume IIl., Light and Sound. Elements of Theoretical Physics. By Dr. C. CHRISTIANSEN, Professor of Physics in the Un-versity of C.penhagen. Translated into English by W. F. MAGIE, Ph.D., Pr fessor cf Physics in Princeton University. 8v0, cloth, pp. xiii+389. Price, $3.25 net. Qualitative Chemical Analysis. Witb Explanatory Notes. By ARTHUR A. NOYES, Ph D., Assistant Professor of Chemistry in the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Third Revised and Enlarged Edition. 8vo, cloth, pp. 89. Price, $1.25 net. Mathematical Theory of Electricity and Magnetism. By Professor A. G. WEBSTER, Of Clark University. Worcester, Mass. _ Cloth. 8vo. Price, $3.50 net. An Introductory Course to Quantitative Chemical Analysis. With Explanatory Notes and Stoichiometrical Problems. By HENRY P. TALBOT, Ph.D., Associate Professor of Analytical Chemistry in the Mass. Inst. of Technology. 8vo, cloth, pp. 125. Price, $1.50 net. Laboratory Practice for Beginners in Botany. By WILLIAM A. SETCHEBLL, Ph.D., Professor of Botany in the University of California. 16mo, cloth. Price, 90 cents net. ‘Tam very much pleased with the book. It is far the best that I have seen, and [shall take pleasure in recommending its introduction next fall.”— Ciara A. Pease, Hartfurd High School. An Introduction to Geology. By WILLIAM B. SCOTT, Blair Professor of Geology and Paleontology in Princeton University. Crown 8vo, cloth. Price, $1.90 net. Elementary Geology. By RALPH S. TARR, BS., F.G.SA., Professor of Dynamic Geology and Physical Geography in Cornell University. Crown 8vo, half leather. Price, $1.40 net. f . The Theory of Socialization. A Syllabus of Sociological Principles for the Use of College and University Classes. By Professor FRANKLIN HENRY GIDUINGS, M.A., Of Columbia University, New York. 8vo, paper. Price, 60 cents net. Experimental Morphology. By CHARLES BENEDICT DAVENPORT, Ph.D., Instructor in Zoélogy in Harvard University. Part I. Effect of Chemical and Physical Agents upon Protoplasm. 8vo, cloth. Price $2.60 net. The Development of the Frog’s Egg, An Introduction to Experimental Embryology. By THOMAS HUNT MORGAN, Ph.D., B.S., M.S., Professor of Biology at Bryn Mawr College. Cloth, 8vo. Price, $1.60 net. The Century Science Series. Edited by Sir HENRY E. ROSCOE, D.C.L., P.R.S., MP. 16mo, cloth, $1.25 per volume. Charles Darwin and the Origin of Species. By Epwarp B. PovuLton, M.A., F.R.S. The Herschels and Modern Astronomy. By Acnrs M. CvierKke, Author of “A Popular History of Astronomy during the 19th Century,” etc. John Dalton and the Rise of Modern Chemistry. By Sir Henry E. Roscox, F.R.S. Justus von Liebig, His Life and Work (1803-1873). By W. A. SnEastong, F. I. C., Lecturer on Chemistry in Clifton College. Major Rennell, F. R. S., and the Rise of English Geography. By Creme.ts R. MarxnaM, C.B., F.R.S., President of the Royal Geogra- phical Society. Charles Lyell and Modern Geology. By Rev. Prorsssor T. G. Bonxuy, F.R.S. Clerk Maxwell and Modern Physics. By R. T. GuazeBrook, F.R.S., rellow of Trinity College, Camoridge. Humphry Davy, Poet and Philosopher. By T. E. ToHorrs. F.R.S., Principal Caemist of the Government Laboratories. IN PREPARATION. Michael Faraday, His Life and Work. By Prof. Sirvanus P. THompson, F.RS. Pasteur, His Life and Work. By M. Armanp Rorresr, M.D. : Hermann von Helmholtz. By A. W. Ricker, F.R.S. THE MACMILLAN COMPANY. NEW YORK: 66 Fifth Avenues. CHICAGO: The Auditorium. SAN FRANCISCO: 327-331 Sansome Street.

Page 5

The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, APRIL. 29, 1897. The Week. WE have been asked to state exactly what are the differences between the Dingley bill and the present (Wilson) tariff in regard to the duties on books. It will perhaps be helpful to include the McKinley tariff also in the comparison, and to begin with that, since it is the first of the three in point of time. The differences are found in the free list of the several measures, and are as follows: M’KINLEY. (1.) Books, ete., more than 20 years old, free. (2.) Books, etc., in other lan- guages than Eng- lish, and books for the blind, free. (3.) Books, etc., for colleges and societies, not ex- ceeding two co- pies to each, free. (4.) Books as household and professional ef- r fects of persons returning from abroad, free. (5.) Books for WILSON. (1.) Same, plus works of origi- nal scientific re- search. (2.) Same. (3.) Same. (4.) Same. (5.) Same. DINGLEY. (1.) 25 percent. (2.) 25 per cent. (3.) Free, ex- cept such as are made in the U.S. (4.) 25 per cent., unless included in the $100 wortb exempted for personal bag- gage. (5.) Free. the use of the United States and Library of Congress, free. Nothing illustrates the reactionary and medizval character of the Dingley bill more strikingly than this tax on know- ledge, which, according to the author of it, was adopted, not for reyenue and not even for protection, but to save trouble for custom-house inspectors. Those hard- worked people can be required to count the number of threads in a square inch of cotton or linen cloth, and the number of tufts of bristles in a tooth-brush, to mea- sure the ‘‘lines’’ of pearl buttons, to make intricate and prolonged chemical tests every day, in order to arrive at the dutiable value of a thousand different ar- ticles of commerce. No wonder they are tired, poor things! when they have made all these experiments, and have no strength left to tell whether a book is more than twenty years old, or whether it is printed in a foreign language, or whether it is imported for an educational institution, a public library, or a philo- sophical society. Mr. Dingley has discovered that the blessings of a tariff cannot be felt before the bill becomes law, nor ‘‘even imme- diately afterwards.’’ How long, then, have we to wait? At least a year after the passage of the bill—that is Mr. Dingley’s present position. He sorrow- fully points out that “ practically a year’s stock of goods will have been brought into the country from abroad before the tariff bill becomes a law.’’ Prosperity cannot come until “time is given for the absorption of the enormous amounts of foreign goods now being forced upon the market.”” That time he fixes at a year or thereabouts after enactment. But when will enactment come? By July 1, Mr. Dingley ‘‘ hopes.” Granting that, what will Mr. Dingley have accomplished? Why, he himself told us in his report: ‘* It is easy to see how a delay in the enact- ment of the bill to July 1, for example, would easily take from the Treasury $15,- 000,000 of revenue, and turn it into the pockets of speculators importing wool, sugar, etc.’? That looks like a slice of prosperity—for the speculators. But Mr. Dingley sings another tune at the end of April from the one he favored us with in the middle of March. Then the bill was to be law by May 1; now by July 1, he ‘*hopes.”? But the better opinion is that Aygust 1 will be an early date. It may be much later. ‘With “ prosperity ’’ thus confessedly adjourned till August-Octo- ber, 1898, what becomes of the congres- sional election in that year? What be- comes of President McKinley’s aesertion that we can approach the problem of a high tariff ‘‘calmly and patriotically, without fearing its effect upon an early election ’’? The intention of the opposition to the Republican party in Congress regarding the tariff bill is becoming perfectly clear. The Populist and Independent Silver Senators, who hold the balance of power in the upper branch, will help to make it as bad as possible, and then let it pass, for reasons thus stated by the Washing- ton correspondent of the American Wool and Cotton Reporter: ‘*Tt may be said that recent events make it almost certain that a bill will pass. The Populist and Independent Silver Senators have practically made up their minds that a protective tariff policy shall be put in execu- tion. Their theory is, that the policy will prove a failure, and that the country will turn in eager haste to their policy of free silver coinage in the next elections. They propose to permit a protective bill to go upon the statute books by withholding their votes from both sides upon the final vote on the bill, if it is apparent that the Republicans have a ma- jority sufficient for passing the bill. Popu- list votes will be contributed in the necessary number if Republican votes are insufficient.” The Democrats will vote against the bill, but both Senator Jones of Arkansas and Representative Bailey of Texas, their leaders in tha two branches, virtually ad- mit the satisfaction with which they will view its passage from the political point of view. Nota few Republicans in Con- gress share the conviction of the whole opposition that the bill is certain to pro- duce a tremendous reaction in the next elections, but they seem helpless to resist the current which is sweeping their party to destruction. The Democratic members of the finance committee of the Senate will not agree to the proposition of their Republican col- leagues to allow the tariff bill to be re- ported direct to the Senate without being discussed by the full committee. In this they are only doing the duty for which they were put on the committee. Ifa majority of a committee may prepare a bill in secret, and the minority then with- draw and agree that it shall be reported without their looking into it, or consider- ing whether it is bad or good, or what sort of a measure they would themselves recommend, there is obviously no reason for their being on the committee at all. The true way would be for the party in control to make the committees consist only of its own members. The object of party representation on committees is not mere fairness, but that thorough prepa- ration shall be made for debate. This is possible only if measures are properly canvassed by both sides in advance. What the Republicans propose is a very good preparation for “jamming through,” not for debate. We do not, for our part, understand how any self-respecting mem- ber of a legislative body can agree to let the majority of a committee of which he is a member report a bill secretly pre- pared, and which he has had no opportu- nity to discuss in committee. President McKinley’s four appoint- ments of New Yorkers last week illustrate perfectly his conception of executive duty in the filling of federal offices. For the most important post-office in the country he selects Cornelius Van Cott of this city; for Third Assistant Postmaster- General, John A, Merritt of Lockport; for Internal-Revenue Collector in the First District, Frank R. Moore of Brook- lyn ; and for Postmaster at Elmira, Mel- vin M. Conkling. Of these four, Van Cott, Merritt, and Conkling have always been faithful supporters of the Platt machine, and they were picked out for these offices by the ‘‘ Government” of the State, the President of the United States merely recording the Senator’s will; while Moore was pushed for the collectorship by the anti-Platt element and the ‘‘ original McKinley men.’? Hav- ing bagged the two most important places, as well as the Elmira office, the Senator can afford to let his opponents have the unimportant collectorship, while the original McKinleyites secure as much recognition as they are entitled to by their proportional numbers. If one were to seek the man best qualified to make an efficient postmaster of the metropolis, Mr. Van Cott would not be chosen. He

Page 6

tg: vt ia caaine tomate ptr Se eee ee esti sfinermet etter taster seat Naa eA i SE 2 RATES RE RK Se AE PAIN EY MORALE ee oe se APeta Sybai cee = rae) — | 312 The Nation. [Vol. 64, No. 1661 is a thorough going spoilsman in theory, but happily he was prevented from put- ting his principles in practice during his first term, as he will also be again now, by the obstacles of the civil-service law. The announcement that Bellamy Storer of Cincinnati is to be Minister to Bel- gium, instead of First Assistant Secre- tary of State, records the formal surren- der of the appointing power by the Presi- dent to the Senate. Mr. Storer aspired to the place in the State Department, for which he is excellently qualified; Secre- tary Sherman would have been glad to see him occupy it; Mr. McKinley him- self earnestly desired to name him for that office. But the President had begun by notifying the Republican Senators that he would make no nomination to which a Senator from the State affected might object. Senator Foraker has been on bad terms with Mr. Storer, and serv- ed notice that he would not have him in the State Department. The President meekly yielded, but asked the dictator if he would object to giving Mr. Storer some other office. Mr. Foraker said that Mr. Storer might be sent out of the country with his permission, and he ac- cordingly goes to Belgium. At the same time senatorial consent was given in ad- vance to the nomination of a Canton neighbor of McKinley’s, Mr. Day, to the place in the State Department. The practical significance of this selection is that the President will run the State Department through his next friend; Secretary Sherman being nothing more than a figurehead. The first assistant- secretaryship/has been filled with dis- tinction by Mr. Rockhill, who reached the position by deserved promotions. Mr. Day is not known to the country at large. He has twice been given a seat upon the bench, in the Common Pleas Court of Ohio and the United States District Court, and it is to be hoped that he has the judicial mind which our for- eign relations so imperatively require just now. The first intimation of any sort as to the policy of the Administration regarding Hawaii comes in the appointment of a Jingo and annexationist as United States * Minister. Young Sewall showed himself unfit for responsibility by his conduct while Consul-General to the Samoan Islands; he is a shifty character, having changed from Democrat to Republican after Mr. Cleveland refused him an office in his second Administration; he is an ardent advocate of the policy of annex- ing Hawaii; and he is capable of making quite as much trouble as the other Maine man who tried torush the islands into the Union under Harrison. However, new complications have arisen since that day, regarding the sugar question, which in- volve the pending tariff bill, the beet- sugar people in this country being now opposed to annexation as they are to re- ciprocity with Hawaii; and new influences may thus enter into the decision of the question now. That the mission of Messrs. Wolcott, Paine, and Stevenson is destined to fail- ure is sufficiently indicated by the Lon- don Times, which says that the fad of bimetallism rises and falls in England in inverse ratio with the state of trade. When business is good, people do not want bimetallism. When it is bad, they begin to complain about the currency. ‘* Trade, happily, is good at present,’’ it says, ‘‘and Mr. Wolcott will find sympa- thy with his views correspondingly lan- guid.’’ The prospect on the Continent is no better. It adds: ‘Neither France nor Germany, in spite of official coquettings with the bimetallist Agra- rians, has any reason for discontent with her existing monetary system, nor is Russia, who quite recently established the gold standard, at all likely to entertain proposals for unset- tling all that she has just deliberately settled. That the greatest commercial nation of the Far East has also established a gold standard is a fact by no means without importance in European calculations,” The Zimes concludes by saying that, at all events, President McKinley “ will be able to point to its labors as redeem- ing his election promises, and to their failure as showing that if America wants free silver, she must procure it for her- self at her own risk.”’ That is just where the Bryanites will ‘‘come in.’’ When the Wolcott-Paine-Stevenson Com- mission returns empty-handed, the Popo- crats will exclaim with one accord: ‘* We told you so—now give us 16 to 1 by inde- pendent action.” The personal financial motive for their support of the free-coinage movement bas always been plain enough in the cases of the silver-mine owners who were so prominent in the campaign of last year. The recent failure of the Globe Savings Bank in Chicago is re- vealing an equally strong personal finan- cial motive for desiring the monetary convulsion which the free coinage policy would have precipitated, on the pari of ex-Gov. Altgeld of Illinois, the chief ad- vocate of Bryanism in the central West. It appears that Altgeld had borrowed heavily from the bank through his in- fluence over Spalding, the man who con- trolled the institution and who finally wrecked it; and when it closed its doors, more than $32,000 due it, directly and indirectly, from the Governor had been charged up to profit and loss by the bank examiner, Altgeld isa man of so much ability that he is a dangerous demagogue, and it is therefore fortunate that his ut- ter untrustworthiness should have been so conclusively demonstrated. The scan- dal of his connection with the ruin of this savings-bank is something from which he can hardly recover, - When it was announced last November that McKinley had received nearly 300,000 more votes than Bryan in Pennsylvania, the idea that the State might be doubtful in the election a year Jater would have seemed too absurd for consideration. Yet one Republican newspaper after another is now serving notice that if the Logisla- ture goes on to the end in the way that it has pursued thus far—and everybody ex- pects that it will—the party may be beaten in the contest over the State treasurership next fall. The Republicans have twice in State conventions explicitly promised radical reform measures, and public sen- timent is especially set upon one such measure for the payment of interest on State deposits in the banks. At present, millions of dollars are placed in favored banks which pay nothing for the privi- lege, while $120,000 a year ought to be re- ceived. A feint has been made of intro- ducing and pushing bills to reform this abuse, but things have already been so arranged that these bills will fail. The most encouraging feature of the situation is a report that the Republican Business Men’s League may nominate an independ- ent candidate for State Treasurer on the platform of interest on State deposits, with the expectation of thus defeating the Quay nominee and electing a Democrat. The distinguishing characteristic of the Legislature which finished its work at Albany on Saturday was its open hos- tility to the Constitution of the State. Its chief acts were aimed directly at the spirit, if not the letter, of the Constitu- tion, for purposes of destruction. Nearly every previous Legislature, no matter how bad its general character, has done a few things which were in the public in- terest, some of them conspicuously so. It is impossible to find any measure of large importance in the list of new laws left by the present body of which this can be said. The decent public opinion of the State has been disregarded more completely than ever before; not only have its demands passed unheeded, but its protests have been overridden with defiant contempt. The most conspicuous acts passed were the charter for Greater New York, the civil-service looting bill, and the Raines liquor-law amendments. In the consideration and passage of these both local public sentiment and the Con- stitution were defied. When the new Constitution was placed before the people for adoption in 1894, no two provisions of it received more cordial approval than those relating to home rule for cities and civil-service reform. The convention which drafted it had a large Republican majority, and the instrument was recom- mended to the people by that majority in a formal address, explaining its provi- sions. The Republican platform of that year commended it, and so did Republi- can organizations generally. The provi- sion which required the submission to

Page 7

April 29, 1897] The Nation. 313 mayors of all legislation affecting their cities was regarded as one of the most important recognitions of the home-rule idea for cities that had ever been em- bedded in the fundamental law. That on civil-service reform was dwelt upon in the address of the Republican mem- bers of the convention as a most valuable step in the direction of the extension of the competitive system to the entire ser- vice of the State. Yet a Republican” Le- gislature has done its utmost to destroy both provisions. Gov. Black has consented to give the opponents of his civil service looting bill a hearing before he signs it, and we have no doubt that they will make the most of the opportunity. That he intends to sign it in the end, there is little doubt, for he is the author of it, and its passage through the Legislature was due entirely to the pressure which he exerted person- ally in its support. He differs from the other members of the Platt party in be- ing willing to pay a little attention to the respectable elements of the population. Platt, Payn, Raines, and their kind do not consider it necessary longer even to ‘* pander a little to the moral sense of the community.’’ They ignore it entirely, believing that they can keep in power in spite of its opposition. The Governor’s way is to listen to it politely and disre- gard its opinions and requests. This me- thod of procedure must fill the ‘tried and true” Platt men with disgust, but, so long as the Governor does their work in the end, they are probably content. The New York Senate passed last week the Dudley inheritance-tax bill, which had already passed the Assembly. This bill provides, in substance, that whenever there is an inheritance tax of 5 per cent. and the value of the estate exceeds $500,- 000, an additional tax shall be imposed on the entire personal estate so taxable, at the accumulating rate of 1 per cent. for each additional $250,000, except that if the entire estate exceeds $3,000,000, it shall be subject to taxation only at the aggregate rate of 15 per cent.; and that if the tax is 1 per cent., and the estate exceeds $1,000,000, an additional tax shall be imposed on the entire personal estate so taxable at the accumulating rate of one-half of 1 per cent. for each additional $250,000 or major fraction thereof up to $2,500,000, and 1 per cent. on the entire personal estate for each additional $254.- 000 or major fraction thereof above §2,- 500,000, except that if tha entire estate exceeds $4,000,000, it shall be subjert to taxation under this section on!; ai the aggregate rate of 10 per cent. A well- known man, supposed all his life to be very rich, died in New Ycrk the other day, and it appeared that his estate amounted to only $1,000. There may, of course, be no connection between the fact and the pendency of this bill. What is wanted most of all in the Po- lice Board at this time is a man with such intimate knowledge of police admi- nistration, such intimate knowledge of Commissioner Parker’s peculiarities and performances, and such integrity of cha- racter that he cannot be either cajoled or deluded into allowing Parker’s schemes for turning the Police Department over to the control of the Platt- Lauterbach machine to succeed. That Mr. Moss, Mayor Strong’s appointee to succeed Mr. Roosevelt, has all these qualifications, is acmitted by everybody. Lauterbach ad- mits it, and so does Platt’s personal or- gan, and so do all the other open and se- cret opponents of rea) police reform, both in and out of the press. They all bewail the fatuity of the Mayor in making an appointment which destroys all hope of ‘*harmony”’ in the Police Board. What would harmony in the board mean now? Simply union in favor of ras- cally administration. No honest man can be harmonious with Parker and Grant. They have been for months con- spiring to thwart the efforts of Messrs. Roosevelt and Andrews to remove the po- lice force permanently from the reach of partisan politics of all kinds. Nothing but the ‘‘ crankiness”’ and ‘‘ impractica- bility ’? of Roosevelt and Andrews has prevented their success. When Roose- velt went out, they stood two to one in favor of success, and they immediately endeavored to grasp it by trying to get possession of the presidency of the board by a trick. The honesty of their own chief clerk alone defeated them. Mr, Moss’s appointment putsa permanent bar to success in that direction hereafter. Ever since the system of prohibition in Iowa was so modified as to permit the sale of liquor under the so-called mulct law, where a petition is signed by 50 per cent. of the voters in cities and 65 per cent. in counties, the State has presented the anomalous spectacle of allowing a thing to be sold the manufacture of which was forbidden. Theabsurdity of outlaw- ing breweries and distilleries in Iowa while permitting the admission of: their pro- ducts from other States was sufficiently obvious, but it has taken years of agita- tion to put anend toit. At last the Le- gislature has passed a law allowing manu- facture under certain conditions, the mea- sure barely squeezing through the upper branch by the votes of the seven Demo- crats and nineteen of the Republicans, while twenty-four of the dominant party stood out against it. The petition feature of the mulct law is maintained, and 50 or 65 per cent. of the voters, as the case may be, must sign a request for the establish- ment of the business before it can be es- tablished. There are all sorts of pecu- liarities about liquor legislation in Iowa. While the mulct law allows the sale in a city of over 5,000 inhabitants without re-. gard to the sentiment of the county at large, a city of less than 5,000 people has been unable to legalize it unless 65 per cent. of all the voters in the county peti- tion for it. An amendment has just been adopted which is aimed at this inconsis- tency, but which still falls far short of introducing majority rule; it allows the sale in any town of from 2,500 to 5,000 people, without regard to the rest of the county, but requires a petition signed by 80 per cent. of the voters in the town. The ratification of the treaty between Mexico and England fixing the bounda- ries of the British possession of Belize has been strangely overlooked by our most sensitive and jealous patriots. The treaty actually gives England a few more roods of sacred American soil than she had been occupying. Merely to state this horrible fact should be enough. What would Monroe say to this? What does Morgan say? What Lodge? It is the latter, in fact, bettering Monroe, whose own pet doctrine is flagrantly violated. When the Venezuela wrangle was pending, President Cleveland was weak enough to admit that if Venezuela would amicably agree to give up to England a part of the territory in dispute, we should have nothing more to say. Lodge sternly interposed. This was a fatal yielding of the true principle, which was, that nota foot of American soil (whether swamp or sand-bank) should be given toa European Power, whether its owner wanted to give it or not. We simply could not permit it in our sovereign Pan-Americaxism. That is the Lodge Doctrine which Mexico has now openly flouted. The military operations on the Thessa- lian border during the week have ended in something like a debacle for the Greeks, who have been driven out of Tyrnavos and Larissu, and have fallen back on Pharsalos, leaving Volo uncovered except by the fleet. In Epirus nothing seems to have been achieved except the unchain- ing of Albanian mutineers to terrorize the whole community, while the destruc- tive descent of the Greek war-ships on the coast of the Gulf of Salonica has not in the least embarrassed Edhem Pasha’s command or checked his steady and vic- torious advance. The Greek Government has been forced to change its commanders under fire. Athens is in a state of ex- citement which bodes ill to the dynasty, whose choice lay between succumbing to the mob before or after a duel with Tur- key. The Providence which has saved Italy in similar straits seems wanting to Greece, and her only assurance is that the frontier fruitlessly defended and now overrun will not be permanently pushed southward, the Powers in concert having already declared their intention to main- tain the territorial status quo, whatever vhe fortuneof war. Fortherest, Delyan- nis’s light-heartedness appears destined to reap the same harvest as Ollivier’s.

Page 8

on sense! | ag ee Pee are Oe en ee eo a ne ee ee, ees aS mp . 314 The Nation. [Vol. 64, No. 1661 THE REFORM CLUB DINNER. Tuer speeches made by the Gold Demo- crats on Saturday evening differed from ordinary political speeches in one vital re- spect—that what was said was all true. This was the reason, apart from the in- herent merits of the speeches themselves, which were very great, why they were re- ceived with such spontaneous applause. Every one who listened to them knew that the speakers were not bidding for office, not providing clap-trap and bun- combe for popular consumption, nor do- ing anything but stating in plain lan- guage their real convictions about public affairs. The force of what was said was increased by the fact that these convic- tions were both deep and of long stand- ing, and that the men who announced their determination to stand by them had ‘sustained within six months, without flinching, the most tremendous defeat recorded in the history of American par- ties. The cheers which greeted what they said were cheers which meant that the language of truth, resolution, and courage was refreshing and inspiriting to ears wearied with party jargon and lies, Even Luther’s old words, with which Mr. Cleveland concluded his speech, ‘* Here we stand. We cannot do otherwise,” did not seem forced or out of place. When we examine what was said at the dinner we find plenty of proof that the real Democrats fully understand the situation in which they are placed, and that they are prepared to take and are now taking those steps by which alone they can re- cover the control of the following led away by Bryan, and also attract to their sup- port--for this is equally essential—the in- dependent vote which for twelve years supported Mr.Cleveland, and which by the extraordinary events of last summer was driven into a wholly unnatural alliance with protection. These steps are, in sum and substance, the creation of an active opposition to the party now in control, not merely out of Congress. where .‘‘ or- ganization,’’ however thorough, can have effect only upon elections many months away, but in the Senate itself, where the battle is now going on, and where alone can either a sound-currency system make its way into law, or the protective system be broken up or at least exposed to public execration. Hitherto, since the present Congress convened, the difficulty of those who, like ourselves, have desired tc sup- port the ideas of the Indianapolis con- vention, has been that there have been no public men in Congress standing by them. An opposition, to be effective, must not merely declare its principles; it must fight for them, compel their debate, enlist popular support. No better opportunity could possibly be afforded than by the pending tariff. On the showing of its own advocates the tariff is not needed; it is imperilling all business, and arousing the most violent opposition among the manufacturers and exporters. Yet in the House nobody appeared to lead the De- mocrats but a semi-Populist whose most important political act, to judge by the amount of space devoted to it in the press, was his refusal to wear a dress-coat at the White House, and who openly advised his followers to let the tariff go through, because it would bring them into power again. We doubt if, in the long history of the struggle for freedom of trade, such a thing was ever heard before. It must be remembered that those who attack protec- tion, can never acquiesce in a protective tariff without deserting those whom they have promised to defend from injustice. That a man undertaking to lead revenue reformers should welcome a protective tariff because it was so bad, would be laughable were it not shocking. As Mr. Shepard said on Saturday, the most se- rious thing we have to contend with is ‘*the profound contempt with which offi- cial and political life has come to regard public sentiment.”’ There are signs, and this Reform Club dinner is one, that in the Senate this paralysis will disappear, and that some men will show the country the differ- ence between a mob and a party. Se- nator Caffery’s speech, one of the best made at the dinner, was that of a man who thoroughly understood the situa- tion, and had no sympathy with a do- nothing policy. What he said about the possibility of dividing the Republicans was both true and important: ‘ There are some Republicans who do not believe in erecting the ‘ Chinese wall’ so high as both to keep out foreign imports and to keep in domestic manufactures. These forces ought to, and may, unite with Gold Democrats for the weal of a com- mon country, whose prosperity lies so close to their hearts.’”’ This foresha- dows, no doubt, the plan of bringing forward a genuine revenue bill, and offer- ing it as a substitute for the Dingley measure. ‘‘ You say you want $50,000,000 or $60,000,000 revenue, and offer us a measure which will upset half the estab- lished business of the country, that you may pay your political debts. We offer you a revenue measure with taxes laid on half-a-dozen articles. Everybody knows that it is feasible. What have you got to say?’’ Can any one doubt that oppo- sition of this sort would win support both in and outside Congress? Secretary Carlisle, in his speech, gave the new project for international bimetal- lism a solid and settling blow. What he said was that the plan for a new con- ference had no chance of succeeding, and that it would be a bad thing if it did suc- ceed. It was an attempt to make two things equal to each other by law when they were not equa! in fact ; and this, he said, could not be done by any group of nations, however strong financially, or however numerous. This belief has not, so far as we have observed, been avowed in any political speech before. It has been the private possession of doctrinaires in this country. There has been a uni- versal consensus among politicians that in order to make 50 cents equal to a dol- lar it was only necessary to get England, France, and Germany to unite with us io calling them equal. Mr. Carlisle has now repudiated that notion in vigorous terms. THE TREASURY ORDER. THE debate in the Senate on the Trea- sury order instructing collectors to delay ‘*liquidations ’’ of goods imported after April 1 was a curiosity in its way. We do not mean that it brought forward any new arguments, for what was said on both sides had been said already out- side the Senate; but because it was, we believe, the first recorded debate of its kind in the history of the world—the first debate on the question of the le- gality of an order issued by the Exe- cutive of a free government, managed | under representative forms, designed to fasten a lien upon all goods entering the country, and taxed under an existing tariff, for the purpose of making them subject to an additional tax to any amount that the Legislature may at any future time impose. It cannot too often be repedted that this is what the retro- active scheme means. People are con- fused about it, because they think that the scheme does nothing but make the Dingley duties, so called, retroactive. This is a total mistake. There are no Dingley duties. The Dingley bill is of no more force and effect in the United States until it becomes a law than any one of the two thousand other bills intro- duced intd Congress and not yet passed. The scheme is based on the proposition that Congress may at any future time levy additional duties on goods which have come into the country and been once taxed already in accordance with existing law. The brand now fastened upop import- ed goods by the red ink of the Treasury, and by retention of the samples for identi- fication, cannot be obliterated. The pre- sent Dingley bill may never pass; the regular session of Congress may begin next December with a new Dingley bill with a new retroactive clause, and that bill may in its turn be defeated; or the present clause may be struck out by the Senate, and the bill passed without it. No matter what is done, the operations under the Treasury order will remain for ever as notice to the world of a claim of the right to increase the taxes on goods already taxed, when and to what extent Congress pleases. For there is no limit of any sort, either in time or in amount of tax. The second tax may be laid on two months or two years hence ; the retroac- tive duty may be prohibitive, though the article is now absolutely free. In the case of such goods, of course, the execu- tion of the scheme would be tantamount to confiscation, That such a scheme should not only be

Page 9

April 29, 1897] The Nation. 815 broached, but be actually put, so far as possible, into operation, is an entirely new thing. France and Germany have de- veloped elaborate protective systems, but they never thought of it. It never oc- curred to the English protectionists under Pitt or Peel, and, so far as we know, no- body in Asia, Africa, or what the politi- cians call ‘‘the isles of the sea’’ ever dreamed of it. It is the contribution of Dingley and Grosvenor to the science of taxation, and therefore, as we say, a de- bate on it is a memorable and important event. The first thing to be noticed about the debate is that Mr. Morrill, who conducted it on the Republican side, did not bring forward a scintilla of proof that the scheme was legal. But he did offer one contribution of real value to the discus- sion. He said that the only thing he regretted about the Dingley bill was that it was not ‘sufficiently retroactive,’ be- cause it did not go back to 1894, and ‘‘cover not only this tariff bill, but the law which has been in operation for the last three years’’; that is, that it did not threaten retroactive duties on articles im- ported three years ago. He did not fail, of course, to suggest that the retroac- tive clause would be struck out of the bill by the Senate, but as a mere matter of favor; notice that the Government adheres to the principle of retroactive duties has been given through the Trea- sury order. So far as the executive de- partment of the Government can go, it has adopted the principle, and whether the Senate strikes out the House clause does not affect this fact at all. Indeed, Mr. Gage may well contend, when asked how he can issue an illegal order, that there is nothing illegal in it if the princi- ple of retroactive duties is sound. Not only this, but he might go further, and contend that, if sound, there ought to be such an order permanently in force. A country which adopts the retroactive principle should in fairness notify all the world of it, and keep them notified. Viewed in this light the Treasury order is nothing more than an act of kindness to the importer, for it says in effect: ‘¢The authorities who have just passed a tariff through the House maintain that hereafter any goods passing through the custom-house may be taxed additionally, wherever they may be found; it, is only fair to let you know in advance that im- porting is a dangerous business. All at- tempts to pay duties hereafter will be ‘tentative,’ and if you ask me how much you will finally have to pay, all I can say is that I don’t know.” To make the scheme complete, there might be a per- manent order, and a permanent retro- active statute, under which a board, or perhaps the President, should levy retro- active taxes from time to time on previ- ous imports at such figures as they might deem advisable. We have little doubt that if the pro- tectionists had a tremendous majority in the Senate, asithey have in the House, the temper of legislation is such that they would jam through the retroactive clause. Importers are paying little atten- tion to it, because its very monstrosity prevents the possibility of its getting through an evenly divided Senate. But it is the ripe fruit of protection, and when we hear an old man like Mr. Morrill, very near his last breath, sighing that he can- not make the country pluck and eat it, we see in a curious way how the long practice of protection distorts the mind and blunts the conscience. Tue facts in the civil-service case just decided by the New York Court of Ap- peals were the following: In 1895 eleven appointments were made to various posi- tions in the Brooklyn civil service without competitive examination. At the time of their appointment, the new Constitution, requiring that appointments and promo- tions in the civil service of the State, or civil divisions of it including cities and villages, shall be made ‘according to merit and fitness, to be ascertained, so far as practicable, by examinations,which, so far as practicable, shall be competitive; for the enforcement of this section ’”’ (Const., N. Y., art. 5, s. 9), had gone into effect. The civil-service ‘system estab- lished by statute at the time of the adop- tion of this amendment in the State and in the cities was based on the principle (the same as that of the federal service) that all offices were to be classified as competitive or non-competitive, and that, within the limits of the classified service, all heads of departments must make ap- pointments from those certified as having passed the competitive examinations es- tablished by the various civil-service boards. In cities, the mayors were to classify. ‘‘ Confidential’’ positions were excluded from competition on the ground that it was in the nature of things impos- sible to subject candidates for them to a competitive test, and in Brooklyn Mr. Seth Low when mayor had made the class known as Schedule A a non-compe- titive class. The mayors who succeeded him, Messrs. Schieren and Wurster, the present incumbent, made some changes, the result of which was that the eleven appointments involved in the case came under this head. The present action was brought by taxpayers of Brooklyn on the ground that the eleven appointees were illegally appointed without competi- tive examination, whereas such an exa- mination would have been “ practicable,” and was therefore required by the Consti- tution and the statute. An injunction was asked to restrain the payment of salaries. whole civil-service system—the appoint- ment of the examiners, the method of examination, and the determination of THE CIVIL-SERVICE DECISION. laws shall be made to provide The Court of Appeals holds that the qualifications of the applicants—is left entirely to the Legislature. ‘* As to the machinery necessary for the conducting of a competitive examination, its execu- tion to that extent is dependent upon the statute.’’ The court says, apparently to make all this plain, that if an éxecutive fficer should now undertake to hold ex- aminations on his own account it would ‘* nullify the civil-service law,” leaving it to be inferred that by a new statute pre- cisely this system might be introduced. The court also holds that the only question before it is whether the Brook- lyn classification is legal, and this ques- tion turns wholly on whether it was ‘* practicable ” to have applied the com- petitive system to the eleven appointees. Under these circumstances it might have been supposed that the court would then proceed to inquire into the duties of the eleven appointees, and to decide in each case whether a competitive examination would have been practicable. But, while laying it down as a general rule that where the duties of the position are not merely clerical, but ‘‘such as especially devolved upon the head of the office, which, by reason of his numerous duties, he was compelled to delegate to others, the performance of which required skill, judgment, trust, and confidence, and in- volved the responsibility of the officers of the municipality,’’ the position must be treated as confidential, and consequently non-competitive, the court has carefully avoided determining ‘‘the respective claims of the eleven appointees.’’ On the contrary, the court says in substance: The mayor has determined this question, and we shall not review his action. It must be assumed, until the cpntrary ap- pears, that when he says a position is , confidential and that it is not practicable to bring it within the competitive class, his classification is correct. If the may- or acts improperly, he may be compelled by direct proceedings, as by mandamus, and perhaps certiorari, to classify pro- perly. In all this the court reversed the decision below, which was that it was ‘* practicable ”’ to apply a competitive ex- amination, and that therefore the ap- pointments were wholly illegal. The upshot of the decision is, in the first place, that the courts cannot any longer be relied upon to enforce the con- stitutional amendment for us. The view taken by all the best judges of both po- litical parties in the courts below and in the Court of Appeals itself has been brushed aside by a party majority of one, and we are told that hereafter the classi- fication of offices as competitive or non- competitive made by mayors or governors is final, unless we can show at the end of a litigation that they are wrong; in which case the classification, and probably the litigation, will begin over again. This is a very different thing from a summary process to prevent an officer wrongly ap- pointed without competition from acting. In the second place, the court has gone

Page 10

316 The Nation. [Vol. 64, No. 1661 out of its way to declare that the Legis- lature bas complete control of the one vital matter, the machinery of the exami- nations. A competitive civil service rests entirely on the system by which the ap- pointment is vested in the mayor, Gover- nor, or head of department, while the ex- aininations are conducted by persons not controlled by him. All other machinery isasham. To do away with this system and introduce other machinery—a pass system, or a hocus-pocus of competition under the control of the person who ap- points—is the object of the present attack by the enemies of the system. The de- cision of the Court of Appeals will great- ly raise their hopes, for it says, in words that might almost have been dictated by the Governor, the “starch”? in ‘civil service”’ is in the statute, not in the Constitution; take it out of that, and you can do what you like. In achieving this triumph, the ene- mies of civil-service reform have had to get an apparently partisan construction of the Constitution, unsupported by the weight of judicial authority. Judges Haight, Bartlett, Martin, and Vann, all Republicans, bave overruled Judges Gray, Andrews, and O’Brien, and all the Judges of the Appellate Division, as well as the trial Judge, on a point so sim- ple that a child can understand it, and which may be thus stated: When the Constitution says that no man shall be appointed to office except by competi- tion, if competition is ‘‘practicable,’”’ the courts, and not the Legislature, or the Governor, or the mayors. are to decide whether it is practicable, in view of the duties which the officer has to perform, No doubt,the Judges who held this would also hold that the competition must be genuine, and nota sham. Now the ene- mies of the reform have got a construc- tion which enables mayors and Legisla- ture and Governor to make a sham of the whole thing. Thé people of this State have too much at stake in the matter to permit them to let it rest here. A NEW EXPERIMENT IN SOCIALISM. A RECENT number of the Réforme Sociale contains an instructive and entertaining ac- count of an experiment in codperation made by Belgian socialists. This enterprise is car- ried on at Ghent under the title Vooruié (for- ward), and is described by its leader, Edward Anseele, as ‘‘a citadel, established by the So- cialists, whence they bombard the bourgeois class with bread and butter and potatoes.” The plan of the enterprise was first conceived by two members of the ‘ International,” who had found it desirable to absent themselves for a time from their own country, and who had learned the importance of maintaining the so- cialistic propaganda by more practical agen- cies than debating clubs. They saw many coéperative societies in existence among work- men, and the idea occurred to them that if they could capture some of these, the dissemination of socialistic theories might be greatly facili- tated. After two or three failures they final- ly succeeded, not, indeed, in capturing a co- operative bakery, but in splitting its member- ship, and, with a seceding element numbering 150, they began operations as a professedly socialistic business concern. As a business enterprise the society has achieved great success. M. Anseele is evi- dently a man of much capacity, and he has adopted precisely the methods which have been developed in this country by the ‘‘de- partment stores,” together with some of those attributed to our industria] monopolies. In- stead of advertising in hostile sheets, he has his own daily socialistic newspaper. He maintains a café, on whose walls appears the appropriate motto, ‘‘The stomach of the la- boring man is the savings bank of society.” A pharmacy has been established, and fol. lowed by two others. More recent additions are a shoe-shop, a coal-yard, and, finally, a grand store on the department plan, adorned with medallions of Marx, Fourier, and Owen. For a sign there is inscribed on the front of this building, ‘‘The union of the workingmen is the peace of the world,” and above it floats the red flag. A still later addition is a large hall for festive purposes. Meanwhile the mem- bership has grown within the last ten years from 2,342 to 5,911. Nor has the original business languished, the number of loaves of bread baked having increased from 1,500,000 to 4,500,000. The total of receipts is now nearly 2,000,000 francs yearly, and, after ap-- plying over 18 per cent. in dividends -to mem- bers, a surplus of about 4 per cent. is carried forward. As a socialistic enterprise, however, it can- not be said that this society is successful. It is simply a codperative department store and manufactory, with some ornamental addi- tions. It violates the fundamentat principle of socialism by adopting the present wages system in paying its employees. They do not share in the profits unless they become mem- bers—which, indeed, they seem to be under some compulsion to do.. It violates the prin- ciple of the ‘‘truck” acts, by requiring its workmen to buy their bread at its bakery, and it exacts more than eight hours’ work a day in several of its departments. It pays good wages, but this is partly due to the fact that payment by the piece is to some extent adopted. Severe penalties for bad workman- ship are also imposed. So far as the work- men are concerned, therefore, they seem to be as much victims of the capitalistic régime as if their employers did not belong to the Socialistic party. The despotic tendeucies of socialism, how- ever, are very well illustrated in the case of the members of this society. M. Anseele is practically an autocrat. There is a board of tive directors elected for five years, one retir- ing annually, which is nominally supreme, but really dominated by the manager. Any workman sound in the faith of socialism may become a member by paying a small fee. When he becomes a member he is obliged to buy every week a certain number of bread- tickets, paying for them in cash, at the mar- ket price, and receiving a daily supply of bread. There is a dividend or rebate, not paid in cash, but in ‘‘store orders.” So on other purchases a discount is allowed, but it is always to be ‘‘ taken out in trade.” There is an obligatory subscription to the fund for providing medical assistance, which entitles the subscriber to such aid, as well as to a cer- tain number of loaves of bread, in case of ill- ness. There seems to be no way of withdraw- ing from the enterprise except by abandoning what has been invested in it, and all profits made in it must be reinvested. Such an en- terprise can hardly failto succeed under com- petent management, or to collapse if badly administered. Hitherto the management has been able, and the operating expenses have been low. M. Anseele is contented with power, and does not demand the pecuniary value of his services. The great increase of membership, however, is largely due to the fact that the society is really a branch of the Socialistic party in Ghent. To belong to it is an evidence of fideli- ty to the party; to keep out of it indicates lukewarmuess, if not treachery. M. Anseele has recently become active in political life, and it is not improbable that the business of Vooruit will suffer for it. We are struggling in this country to make municipal administra- tion a business matter; the Socialists of Ghent are introducing partisanship into baking bread and selling groceries. They are tread- ing a well-worn path, and if they proceed they will add another lesson to those already furnished by experience concerning the wis- dom of not conducting business affairs under the influence of party spirit. THE AMERICAN ORIENTAL SOCIETY’S MEETING. BALTIMORE, April 24, 1897. For this, its one hundred and eighth meet- ing, the Society is the guest of the Johns Hop- kins University. The President of the Uni- versity, Mr. Gilman, is also our presiding officer, the worthy successor, by virtue of long and varied service, of John Pickering (our founder), of Edward Robinson, Salis- bury, Woolsey, Hadley, S. Wells Wil- liams, and Whitney—surely a line of notable incumbents. For our tourneys—grammatical, antiquarian, historical, literary, text-critical, and what not—the home team consisted of Profs. Bloomfield, Haupt, and Bright, led on by Prof. Gildersleeve, whose name has stood upon our lists for forty years save one, and next to that of Mr. Gilman, in alphabetic and other harmony, as is most meet. The Uni- versity of Pennsylvania sent us Prof. Jas- trow. From Columbia came Gottheil and Jackson. Yale was represented by Oertel and Sanders in person; while Hopkins, not yet re- turned from India, sent us papers. Toy and Lanman came from Harvard; Price from Chi- cago; Moore from Andover. Of especial in- terest was the part taken by the Catholic University of America, which was most ably represented by the Rev. Prof. Hyvernat of Washington. And itis highly significant that the museums were not without their delegates —Adler of the United States National, and Arnold of the Metropolitan. The unity of purpose of museum, public library, and of university is fast coming to practical recogni- tion. The meeting began on Thursday and con- tinued till today; but on Wednesday eve- ning, by way of preparative, the committee appointed to promote the Historical Study of Religions held its session, and took steps for organizing within the Oriental Society a sec- tion for the Study of Religions. This organi- zation was effected in due course on Friday, with Prof. Jastrow as Secretary. In like manner a Classical Section existed from 1849- 91 under Beck, Hadley, and Goodwin, until the flourishing Philological Association caused it to lapse into happy desuetude. A like re- sult is to be hoped for in case of the Religions Section. In this connection it may be an-

Page 11

April 29, 1897] The Nation. 317 nounced that the services of Canon Cheyne of Oxford have been secured for 1897-98, for the third series of American lectures on the His- tory of Religions ‘the first was the course up- on Buddhism given by Rhys Davids of Lon- don), and that Prof. Budde of Strassburg is to give the series of the winter of 1898-99. These discourses are held in the principal cities of the Atlantic seaboard. The businesssession was set for Friday morn- ing, and began with the presentation of corre- spondence, by Prof. Lanman. From this, one or two items may be mentioned. Dr. Sergius Oldenburg of St. Petersburg writes that Pe- trofsky, the Russian Consul-General in Kash gar, has brought back two birch-bark manu- scripts in Kharoshthi characters, by far the oldest Indian manuscripts known. Oldenburg believes that they are to be referred to the first century before or after Christ. He is going to publish complete facsimiles of both manuscripts, and hopes to have them ready for the International Congress at Paris next autumn. He has also begun a Buddhistic se ries of publications, which promises to be of great value. Among the works undertaken is the ‘Abhidharma Kosha Vyakhya,’ whose importance has been recognized since the days of Eugene Burnouf. Dr. Stein writes from his camp, Mohand Marg, in the Hima- layas of Kashmir. Hehad been commissioned by the Kashmir Durbar to translate into Eng- lish the history of Kashmir, which had been edited by him in Sanskrit. He is the hard- worked principal of the Government Oriental College at Lahore, and says: ‘‘In order to work undisturbed, I came straight up to this plateau, some 11,000 feet above the sea, where I have not seen a white face for the last three months. In this delightful Alpine solitude I could work all day long without feeling tired; and thus had two days ago the satisfaction of getting to the end of my task.” The history is to be published by Constable & Co. in London. The Society has sustained serious losses by death during the year, but none that will be more directly and keenly felt than that of Prof. Isaac H. Hall of the Metropolitan Muse- um of Art. He was a man of remarkable at- tainments in Greek, especially New Testament Greek, in Syriac, and in the subject of Cypri- ote inscriptions and antiquities. His capacity for work, his conscientiousness and accuracy, were marvellous. The late Prof. Josiah D. Whitney, the eminent geologist of Harvard, had been a constant and sympathizing helper of the Society since 1857. Dr. Oliver Crane, who died last winter, was formerly a mission. ary at Aintab and Aleppo. In three separate and quite recent instances, the widow or the sister of a deceased member has expressed the wish to continue that member’s subscriptions. The. coincidence is curious and pleasantly sig- nificant. The fact of most importance in the business chronicles of the Society is doubtless the new departure in the publication of the Journal, which was ordered by the directors a year ago. Since then it has been issued promptly as a periodical, in well-bound volumes of about two hundred pages each, under the edi- torship of Profs. Lanman and Moore. The report of the treasurer, Mr. Warren of Cam- bridge, showed that our expenditures are now very considerably beyond our income. To the end, however, that the new experiment might be fairly tried, the directors ordered that no change in the manner of issue be made for the coming year. Nearly forty promising new members were added to our list. Prof. Haupt was authorized to attempt to make better publishing arrangements for the Journal in Europe, and several of our administrative officers are to undertake to raise a moderate publication fund, and are sanguine in their hope of success. No changes of note were made in the board of officers, except that Pre- sident Harper of the University of Chicago and Prof. Francis Brown of Union Theolo- gical Seminary were elected to fill a couple of vacancies on the boardof directors. The name of Prof. Lanman, at his request, was dropped from the board of editors, thus leaving Prof. Moore of Andover to carry on alone the work of that board. In accordance with a vote of the Society, a memorial was prepared to be presented to the finance committee of the Senate and to the Speaker of the House, urging that the classi- fications and duties which concern books in foreign languages and works of art be permit- ted to remain unchanged as they are in the present tariff law. Over fifty papers were presented, and they were of surprising variety and interest. Per- haps the one fact which is most full of hope and encouragement for the future of the So- ciety is this, that the young men, the pupils-of those who are now bearing the burden and heat of the day, are coming forward with real and valuable contributions to knowledge. If the purpose of the University is not to teach -facts, but rather to train men to do, then cer tainly here is evidence that that purpose is be- ing measurably attained. Among the papers of the older men, criticism of the Bible held an important place. I wish that the flippant critics of the results of the ‘‘ highercriticism ” could see the way in which those results are obtained, the reverent attitude of mind, the absolute fairness of judgment and temper with which truth is sought,: without preconceived opinion. Prof. Hyvernat’s discourse on the Coptic versions of the Bible made it plain that we may associate light with Egypt, and not darkness only. Mr. Grimm presented the re sults of a most interesting study of a class of tags er additions to the Psalms, which occur especially in Psalms whose ending originally contained some expression of bad omen. A striking example of this is seen in the twenty- second verse of the thirty-fourth Psalm. Prof. Haupt naturally had a number of chips from bis busy workshop, where the publication of the Polychrome Bible is now in progress. Such was his essay upon the amplificative plural in Hebrew, wherein he established a principle by which many familiar passages may be made to yield far better sense. His colleague, Prof. Bloomfield, presented an es- say upon the ‘ Gopatha Brahmana,’ which evi- dently grew out of his studies upon the litera- ture of the ‘ Atharva Veda.’ His stately vol- ume containing translations from that Veda, and forming a part of Max Miiller’s ‘Sacred Books of the East,’ was laid before the Socie- ty by President Gilman. Dr. Reisner of Har- vard is now at work publishing a second volume of the Assyrian inscriptions of the Museum at Berlin, under a commission of the authori- ties of that Museum. As an incidental result of these labors, he presented a paper upon the old Babylonian system of weights and mea- sures, the preliminary publication of which, by the Berlin Academy, has already elicited most favorable comment from the highest au- thorities. Prof. Hopkins sends us a paper to prove that the bulk of the Hymns of the ‘ Rig- Veda’ originated in the district that lies south of Amballa. His arguments are based upon travel and observation and upon the inter- pretation of the ancient books. Prof. Jackson presented interesting notes upon play within play (as in ‘‘ Hamlet”) in the Sanskrit drama, and an elaborate essay on the Archangels in Zoroastrianism. Prof. Oertel brought out some results of bis studies in the Brahmana literature, to which he has long been devoted. Prof. Bloomfield’s pupil, Mr. Ness, gave orally a creditable contribution to the exegesis of the Vedas; and Mr. Lovejoy, a pupil of Prof. Lanman, sent on an able dis- cussion of several fundamental points in Bud- dhist philosophy which have recently engaged the attention of leading Buddhist scholars, especially Mr. Warren of Cambridge and M. Senart of the French Academy. The value of organization appeared in the action of the Society in the matter of a pro- posed catalogue of Egyptian papyri and monuments in this country, undertaken, at the instance of the Department of State, on behalf of the Egyptian Government; and again, also, in Prof. Gottheil’s report of sub- stantial progress in the work of cataloguing the Oriental manuscripts in America. Most of the papers were of course too technical for mention here; a notable exception was Prof. Henry Preserved Smith’s argument to show that Mohammed’s impulse was received from Christian rather than from Jewish sources. And a paper on the etymology of Baal-bek suggested the jocose query as to light on the origin of Bal-timore. Your readers will at all events appreciate a new etymology of Bos- ton which has just been propounded by a Buddhist priest, newly arrived from Ceylon tq convert us. Bo is the Ceylonese for Bodhi, and appears in the familiar combination Bo- tree, the tree under which The Enlightened One (Buddha) attained Enlightenment (Bo- dhi); and ston is nothing more than stan, fami- liar to us in many Oriental names, Hindu- stan, Afghan-i-stan, Land of the Hindus, the Afghans, and soon. Bo-ston is therefore lite- rally ‘The Land of Enlightenment.’ The social aspects of the meeting were sim- ple, as was fitting, and so altogether delight- ful. It is hoped that the next meeting may be held at the University of Chicago in Easter week, 1898. A VISIT TO THE CONVENT OF METEO- RA IN THESSALY. Norwicu, Conn., April 17, 1897. On Wednesday, August 30, 1871, I made ar- rangements to leave Larissa, in Thessaly, for a visit to the convents of Meteora, those most inaccessible of all monastic retreats in the world. I hired an old carriage, one of the few in Larissa, to take me to Triccala. We set off at five P.M. As we proceeded westward, the mountains, Ossa and Olympus, on the eastern border of the great Thessalian plain, loomed up in constantly more impressive grandeur, and rose, purple and grand, in the last rays of the sun. All through the vight we traversed the Pelasgian plain, and arrived before daylight at Triccala, anciently known as Tricca, and revered as one of the oldest shrines of A’sculapius. The modern Thessalians are a somewhat in- ferior race, who were described to me by a rich Greek of Larissa as xrynvwdes dvOpwra, ‘‘ beastly fellows.” Their degradation is due in part to their patriotism. They joined heartily in-the national struggle for inde- pendence, which for them, since they were excluded from the modern Greek kingdom, bere no fruit, and they have taken part in the numerous insurrections which have been

Page 12

= prin hm “er 318 The Nation. [Vol. 64, No. 1661 stirred up since the Greek Revolution, and have had Thessaly as their theatre. These successive outbreaks, insufficiently support- ed, have been easily stamped out, and the wretched patriots who supported them have been severely punished. The result has been that the more enterprising Greeks have emi- grated, and that those who remain are an ab- ject, spiritless race. The population of Thes. saly, about 500,000, is almost solidly Greek, about 10 per cent. only being Mohammedan. At the time of my visit, the landholders were generally Turks, and the Christian landhold ers,found it necessary to pay various annoy- ing and burdensome tributes to secure the privilege of cultivating their lands in peace. Now, Thessaly, as far as the River Peneius, but not including Mount Olympus, is Greek territory. i I visited the Turkish governor, who, as I was about to enter the defiles of Mount Pin- dus, furnished me with a zaptieh, or mounted policeman. I also called on the Greek arch- bishop, who gave me a letter to the abbot of the convents. I myself rode on horseback. Our road ascended gradually and lay in the direction due north, passing many beautiful springs which gushed forth abundantly from the ground on either side. We soon arrived at Kalabaka, and beheld the first of the monasteries, perched on a high rock to the right. As we drew nearer to these curious rocks, I observed more carefully their forma- tion. They are a conglomerate, and look as if they had bubbled out of the earth, stiffen- ing as they rose. The separate pinnacles, which number some twenty in all, were each once the seat of a monastery, or, at least, of a monastic cell. These pinnacies or needles rise from a bed of rock of similar formation with themselves, both being bluish in color, extremely hard, and holding many small stones imbedded in their substance. The mo- nasteries crowning these natural columns (like so many St. Simeon Stylites on their pillars) are called collectively 7a Meréwpa, ‘raised aloft,” and no name could be more appro. riate. The chief monastery, called properly the Convent of the Transfiguration (rijs Meraop- ddcews), receives also the name ra Meréwpa, Convent of Meteora. We approached the base of the rock column on which it stands, I in advance of my zaptieh, whose horse had the misfortune to catch his hoof in one of the holes of the hard conglomerate over which we were travelling. When the intelligent creature found that the hoof was held fast, he stood perfectly still until his master succeeded in releasing it. I saw a couple of ropes dangling in air, a hundred feet from the earth. I call- ed, and, when heads appeared above, I pro- duced and held up my letter of introduction, whereupon the smaller cord, used for hauling up packages, was lowered and the letter was thus sent up. The abbot was away, and the three monks could none of them read the letter, but they concluded, from the seal and from the fact that the stranger was attended by a zaptieh, that he was a person of impor- tance, and presently they let down the larger rope with a monk, enclosed in a net, at its lower end. As soon as he had been extricated from the net, he spread it flat upon the rock and bade me sit down, cross-legged, upon it. Then he gathered the outside edges carefully together, putting each mesh around the border over the great hook, and shouted to those above to heave away at the windlass. I felt a curious sensation of being squeezed together, and then rose gradually in the air, whirling around from the twist of the cable, as I ascended. The height was about two hundred feet. Arrived at the top, one of the monks, who worked the windlass, gave me a push, aod, as I came back on the return-swing, well within his reach, he dragged me in, and —the other letting go the windlass—I was deposited on the floor of the monastery. Then I was released from the net and began to look about me. At first, I was left much to myself, for the three brothers at the mo- nastery were ignorant in the extreme, and could do little more for me than to send at once a man with a horse to bring back the ab- bot, who had gone a distance of three or four hours away, on business for the monastery. I went first to the church, a structure dat- ing, perhaps, from the thirteenth century, of the most regular Byzantine type. Finally, I went out upon the beautiful grassy level which, terminated on every side by the per- pendicular rock-walls, surrounds the monas- tery. The entire elevation was not less than two thousand feet above the great Thessalian plain which I had been traversing from Laris- sa. This surface was dotted over with deli- cate blue flowers, and the view in every direc- tion, upon the mighty range of Pindus behind, and over the broad plain in front, was beauti- ful in the afternoon light. When evening fell and I returned to the convent, the monks gave me a frugal supper, and arranged my bed in a spacious room where many a guest had been entertained before—among others, John Catacouzenos, Emperor of Constantino ple, who came to this convent, was hauled up in a basket, and ended his days here as a monk. When I awoke the next morning, the pleasant tones of a cultured voice fell on my ear, and I found that the abbot had arrived. His story was that he was a native of Thessa- ly, but had lived for fifteen years at Constan- tinople as a monk attached to the Patriarch ate, or palace of the Patriarch. He had gain- ed the confidence of Gregory, the cecumenical Patriarch, who had sent him to Meteora, trust- ing to his ability to disentangle the monaste- ries from the debt which burdened them. Speaking more particularly of these debts, he described the methods of the Christian money-lenders. A banker of Larissa, with whom I myself had become pretty well ac- quainted, had lent the convents money, one hundred and thirty Turkish pounds, at thirty pounds yearly interest, payable in quarterly instalments. 7. e., at a trifle less than 25 per cent. To clear off such claims as these, the in- come of all the farms owned by the monaste- ries, save one, had been pledged for five years, and upon that one farm the abbot and his asso- ciates were living with the greatest possible economy. But, the five years expired, the monastery would enter again upon tie control of its property, and, it was expected, in an- other five years would be out of debt. As we continued our conversation, the ab- bot spoke of the loneliness of the place—how, not long after he arrived, he had fallen sick simply from solitude. He left me by theopen window, and there I continued sitting, breath- ing in the soft, cool morning air, watching the mists rising from the great Thessalian plain, enjoying the astonishing calm. Soon he returned, and then he conducted me about, showing me the capacious vaults for storage, the enormous earthen jars for oil, the great wine-butts, the huge cisterns, all witnessing to the scale on which the convent had once been carried on. As a memorial of comparatively recent outrage, he showed me a bullet-hole in the floor, which witnessed to the murder of an abbot during the Greek Revolution. Among the interesting things which it does not seem worth while to describe were the vestments and the drinking-cups which had been used by the Emperor, John Catacouzenos, while a monk in the convent. There was a title-deed of property, devised by one of the Palzologi (Emperors), with the signature in bold, large letters, Ta\aoddyos, as distinct as if written to- day. There were editions of the Greek Fathers and of the Greek classics, with a slight sprin- kling of other books. I do not think it necessary to describe my visit to a second of these curious monasteries, that of Barlaam, and I will only note, in clos- ing, the one overwhelming impression which I have carried away from these singular re- treats, and never lost. This is the strange, unearthly stillness of these almost inaccessible rock-retreats. There is no note of bird there, no rustling of falling leaf, no trickling of wa- ter. The quiet is like that of death ; of a kind, according to the temperament of the man, to calm him or to drive him into insanity. , R. P. K. THE SPADE BEFORE THE SWORD. ATHENS, April, 1897. GREECE is no longer the land of dead issues. For some time past it has been so much alive as to attract the attention of the world; but the questions that have attracted mankind are questions of the living present, not those of a far-distant past. The human interest of real living issues appeals to the human heart of the busy workaday world. And yet there isa remnant which, while feeling keenly the mo- mentous nature of the living issues, is still large enough of soul to be interested in the humanity of the past. It is to such that these lines are addressed. In spite of the fact that recent political events in Greece have been unfavorable to archeological pursuits, yet there was a time this winter when excavations were being car- ried on at five different places in Athens. The British School excavated for the gymna- sium called the Cynosarges on the left bank of the Ilissus, in the neighborhood of the road to Sunium. The excavations were undertaken at this point at the suggestion of Dérpfeld, the topographical ferret. Leaving out of consideration the inevitable graves, the exca- vations brought to light the scanty remains of a Greek and of a Roman building. In view of the purpose for which the excavations were undertaken, it was quite natural that the one should be named the Cynosarges and the other the Gymnasium of Hadrian, but it is ques- tionable whether these theses can be success- fully maintained. _ The excavations conducted by the Gree Archeological Society on the northwestern and northern slopes of the Acropolis have been fruitful of results. The excavations were begun in the depression or lower ground be- tween the Areopagus and the Acropolis, where the foundations of a large Byzantine church were discovered. When the excavations reached the so-called grotto of Pan, inscrip- tions were found on marble plaques that were intended for insertion in the face of the rock. These inscriptions make it clear that this is | the grotto of Apollo, and not that of Pan, as has been believed universally up to this time. Certain passages in the ‘Ion’ of Euripides (283 ff. 936) have received needed and satis- factory elucidation by this discovery. East of this grotto of Apollo were found two other

Page 13

April 29, 1897] The Nation. 819 caves, or rather one labyrinth-like cave, which is regarded as the cave of Pan, because it is in every way suited for the clandestine meeting of Apollo and Creousa, a meeting so momentous for the yet unborn Ionic race. It may be noted that Apollo and Pan were asso- ciated in a similar manner at Ly kosoura alsc. East of these caves, steps leading up to the wall of the Acropolis were discovered; they are the external continuation of the steps found in 1885 inside the walls of the Acropolis. These are the steps by which the Arrephori descended by night during the celebration of the Panathenaic festival, and they are likewise the steps by which the Persians entered the Acropolis. These excavations have but fairly begun, and great discoveries are still to be looked for. The ground occupied by the houses of the Anaphivte squatters on the northern slopes of the Acropolis will be boyght by the Arche dlogical Society, although of course it belongs already to the Government. The squatters, eighty families in all, have resisted successfully for twenty years all efforts of the Government to dispossess them, so that the Society is forced to purchase the houses. They will be demolished in time in order that exca- vations can be made down to the natural rock. The excavated dirt will be replaced along the entire northern slope wherever no ancient buildings are found. The German School has made excavations at the western foot of the Areopagus in the hope of discovering the theatre of Agrippa, the temple of Ares, and the orchestra in which once stcod the statues of Harmodius and Aristogeiton, all of which, according to Pausanias, lay between the Greek Agora (as contradistinguished from the Roman Agora) and the Enneakrounos. Now the Greek Agora lay to the east of the so-called Theseion; Doérpfeld thinks, as is well known, that the Enneakrounos has been definitely located, so that the discovery of the intermediate build- ings can be only a question of time and dig- ging. The excavations for this winter were confiaed to trial trenches, and were without result so far as the topographical questions were concerned. Excavations in the ancient cemetery near the Dipylon prove that the hillock which lies to the south of the Hagia Trias is an artificial mound, the different layers being quite evi- dent. The original graves, five in number, lie upon the hard pan at the bottom of the tumulus, and show distinct traces of fire- burial. As the tumulus grew, other (unincine- rated) bodies were buried in it, so that a verti- cal section reveals graves at varying depths. The five graves are the oldest in the ancient cemetery at this place, and go back to the be. ginning of the fifth century; the other graves in the tumulus belong to the fourth century. Vases of various kinds and gold ornaments were foundinthe upper graves of the tumulus, only a portion of which has been excavated as yet; but the excavations will be continued. The underground aqueduct that carries off the water of the Eridanos will be cut by these ex- cavations, and this may give a pretext for en- deavoring to discover accurately the sources of this abundant water. Excavations conducted in the outer Cerami- cus northwest of the Dipylon have led to the discovery of the ancient road from the Dipy- lon to the Academy, the road of public tombs and of the torch-race contests from the altar of Eros in the Academy to the altar of Ante- ros in the inner Ceramicus. Only a small portion of the road has been uncovered; it is paved and is about eleven metres wide, as Livy says, ut pediti equitique hostium libe- rum spatium proeberet. Theline of the road being thus fixed, we may yet live to see the plan of the tombs of Pericles, Thrasybulus, and of the many Athenians who were accord- ed a sumptuous burial because of their andra- gathy, in that they had died for their country. A sanctuary of Artemis may also be looked for, as well as a statue of Dionysus Eleuthe- reus and xoana of Ariste and Calliste. These excavations have produced inscriptions that add two more names to the list of archons of the third century. A sixth excavation was that for the founda- tion of a large house on Sophocles Street, not far from the National Bank. A portion of the city walls appeared at a depth of about twelve feet. The arch logical year was opened by a dis- covery made by Mr. Smitb, Director of the British School at Athens. While passing through Patras on his way to Athens, Mr. Smith’s attention was called to a marble statue which had been found but a short time previ- ously. A mere glance served to reveal the astonishing fact that the statue was another replica of the Parthenos of Phidias—a replica, too, which in many respects is the best extant. M. Dragoumes accidentally discovered on Salamis the tumulus or polyandrion of the Corinthians who fell in the battle of Salamis. The discovery was made by means of an in- scription in the old Corinthian alphabet and the Doric dialect. The greater part of the inscription has been worn away, but for- tunately the most of the first line is preserved almost intact, and this line presents us with the exact and unatticized text of a part of the celebrated epigram which Simonides of Ceos composed for the tomb of the Corinthian dead. Corinthian Epsilon, Koppa, San, and the old forms of all the letters occur, though Vau is absent. The discovery is of intense interest for the philologist, the arch >logist, and the historian. The old letters recall vividly the pretensions of the Corinthians after the bat- tle, and their squabbles with Themistocles in the council of war before the battle. It is hoped that the relative isolation of the polyan- drion may bave spared it from many consecu- tive plunderings, and that excavations may reveal other things equal in interest with the discovery of the epigram of Simonides and of the tumulus itself. Some years ago three ‘ ostraka” were dis- covered (C, I. A. iv. 2 569-71), one of which was cast against Megacles, the uncle of Peri- cles and grandfather of Alcibiades, and the other two against Xanthippus, the father of Pericles. The lately discovered work of Aris- totle tells us that these were the first Athe- nians to be ostracized. It was surprising that samples of precisely the very oldest ostraka should have been found, and they were of es- pecial interest also because they showed us how that any piece of broken pottery was used for the purpose. The name Scherbenge richt has been fully justified both by these three ostraka, and also by a fourth which was cast against Themistocles at the time when Aristeides was banished. This ostrakon was found during the recent German excavations at the western foot of the Areopagus. It is apparently a fragment from the rim of a vase. This vote against Themistocles was hastily scratched in the black enamel with a sharp- pointed instrument, as seems clear from the fact that the brittle enamel was rudely splin- tered away, leaving jagged the lines of the letters. All of these ostraka bear simply the name of the person to be ostracized and that of his father; thatagainst Megacles, however, bears in addition the deme from which he hailed. Of late, considerable discussion has been aroused with regard to the bronze statue of Delphi which M. Homolle has identified as that of Hiero, and perhaps correctly. Butin a@ paper read before the Parnassos recently, Svoronos disputes Homolle’s identification, and undertakes to prove that the statue is that of Battos, the founder of Cyrene, a hero be- sung of Pindar. Svoronos’s chief argument is based on a passage in Pausanius (10, 15, 3), in which that wortby tells us that the Cyrenzans dedicated at Delphi a statue of Battos in a chariot; that the charioteer was Cyrene, while in the chariot stood Battos being crowned by Libya; that the group was a work of Amphi- on of Cnossos, son of Akestor. Svoronos ad- duced many arguments to prove his thesis. He thinks that Cyrenzan coins of the period have as type the Battos group of Ampbion, and he has restored the Delphian group in accordance with these coins. Thereis a certain dissym- metry in the face of the bronzo statue of Del- phi, especially about the mouth. Now Battos was paralyzed and astammr rer, and Svoronos argues that this dissymmetry was intended to indicate that fact. Svoronos tries to prove, furthermore, that the inscription on the base of the statue was composed by none other than Pindar himself. The thesis of Svoronos was very convincing at the first blush, be- cause many things seemed to speak for it, though it is certain that many other things speak against it. Ata recent meeting of the French School, M. Homolle attempted to re- fute the arguments of Svoronos, and, as many think, successfully. But the end is not yet, lis sub judice est, and the ball started rolling by Svoronos has gained sufficient momentum to excite discussion in archzological circles for some time to come. A most important discavery was made re- cently at Hagios Basileios, a village at the foot of Mt. Citbzron in a nook of the Corinthian Gulf. Remains of ancient ship houses are still visible in the sea, and the spot is regarded by the Greek archzologists as the seaport of an- , cient Platez. A fisherman, while busied with his nets at this spot, discovered in the sea a bronze statue of about half life size. Appar- ently the fisherman was unusually stupid, for, being ignorant of the value of the statue, he sold it for a song to some peasants, who took it to Thebes. They were told that its value was immeasurable. Fearing, therefore, that the Government might take it from them, they hid it and denied its existence, but never- theless stories of the great discovery reached Athens. An Ephor posted off to Thebes, found the peasants, and, with the help of the police, succeeded in wresting the treasure from the hands of its owners. The Ephor also visit- ed the place where the statue was found, and succeeded in discovering a pedestal bearing the inscription rd Morddovos iepdv. It is, how- ever, not yet certain that the statue represents Poseidon. No doubt the question will be set- tled when the base is cleansed completely, for as yet only the first line has been read. The head resembles much that of the traditional Zeus of Olympia. The thinner parts of the body of the statue have been destroyed by time and by ages of immersion in the salt sea. But, in strange contrast therewith, the head is well preserved, even the hairs of the bead and beard being quite distinct. The head is mostly gilded and is crowned by around gilded headband. It is regarded as a splendid speci- men of the archaic art of the sixth century

Page 14

‘The Mation. ~ [Vol. 64, No. 1661 before Christ ; according to Greek arcbzolo- gists, equal, if not superior, to the bronze Hiero found at Delphi by the French. Unfor- tunately, the badly oxidized statue is in many pieces, but, as the arms, legs, and a great part of the torso were found, it cau be joined to- gether successfully, though many gaps will be left. The statue is now in the Museum at Athens, and is exposed to public view even before the needed repairs bave been made. It may interest many to know that the bat- tlefield of Chzroneia, and the village in which Plutarch played as a child, is now the property of an American lady. The story of the lion of Cheroneia is unutterably sad. Erected originally to commemorate the valor, not the victory, of those who fought for and lost the cause of Grecian freedom on the fate- fraught field of Chzroneia, the grim.visaged lion defied man and time for more than two millennia. But, for the past seventy years of the enlightened nineteenth century, it has lain in broken dishonor, with its upturned face, defiant still despite the ages, making mute appeal to heaven. At last, however, an attempt is to be made to rescue from further ruin and decay a monument so venerable, so sad, and therefore so inspiring and so holy. The Archeological Society has determined to restore the lion and to reérect it on the field over which it has stood sentry for these de- cades of centuries, the while the wicked world wagged on, while empire after empire rose and fell, while new religions, aye, and new nations, undreamed of in the days when first the lion was erected, sprang and flourished for age on age, only to melt away and be no more as time grew old and ripe. J. R. S. STERRETT. Correspondence. SCHOOL HOLIDAYS. To THE EpiToR OF THE NATION: Sir: Thé communication in your issue of the 15th inst. does not locate the responsibility for the ratio of school holidays and working- days ; and no doubt most thoughtless persons consider this ratio one of the blisses of teach- ing. Of course, the fact is; schools have prac- tically nothing to do with defining holidays, as every effort of their despair abundantly proves. Parents and children every year go earlier to the country and return later to town, not even going and returning in con. cert, but with irregular individual caprice, thus discounting by confusion the days or weeks left for the remnant of their fellows. Three or four months of unproductiveness is more than millionaires allow themselves; yet schoolmasters are supposed in some way to glory in so much enforced idleness, which would indeed be intolerable but for the pecu- liar exhaustions of their. work. In acceptance. of the inevitable, teachers would gladly acquiesce in any long vacation that would secure immunity from Tuesday and Thursday holidays that mean the loss of Monday and Friday; but authorities that appoint anniversary celebrations or special ceremonials think of everything else except the interests of schools, and our few weeks continue to be vitiated, our labors to be wast- ed, our results to be condemned, our exactions increased, and our felicities exaggerated. No one of these holidays is as significant as the break of momentum is detrimental, and no teacher wants the break, while, on the other hand, the special theory of the celebration is ignored by the boy in his general conception of a holiday, so that he suffers a great loss with no gain. With Saturdays and Sundays as re- gular reliefs, he needs no holiday during the year: in any case, if he needs some, he cannot stand all—a form of the horse-tail argument that advocates of new holidays overlook. No mechanic, artist, or professional man works under such disadvantages ; even strikes are less precarious and whimsical ; and none of these laborers is condemned as a matter of course for deficiencies deliberately provided for him by others. Yet colleges and the pub- lic do thus mock and condemn the most inno- cent of their servants.— Yours truly, CASKIE HaRRISON. BROOKLY?Y, April 17, 1897. -LESS—AND MORE. To THE EpDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir : Accept one hearty Amen, please, to the suggestion that Homer be postponed until college or university days. This is not, in- deed, an absolutely novel heresy. So loyala psir of Grecians as Prof. Seymour and Dr. Keep have discussed it, pro and con, once at least, before a convention of teachers. My own radicalism goes a longish step far- ther. Our vernacular speech, carrying the historic English literature from Caedmon to Kipling, must soon come to its self-evident rights as the chief object in all required lin- guistic study. One language on our Teutonic side and one from the Romance group may fairly be called essential, if only to form the basis of conscious comparison for English. German has, of course, no rival for the for- mer choice. Even a Philhellene must con- cede, though regretfully, that Latin is the other indispensable. Our boys must go to college younger ; what they undertake in school at all must be more adequately mastered; we can’t make indefati- gable book worms of them, as the German gym- nasium may; daily athletics, long idle va. cations, nonchalant _parents, the reluctant schoolboy himself, are here to stay—all this must be conceded, too. Girls’ colleges, starting in these last de- cades, have not attempted to enforce the Greek entrance requirement. Already many ancient gates swing open, however grudging- ly, to masculine youth without the magic se- same of rtirrw. We may as well yield the Thermopyle we never really won. Greek, pursued reluctantly for three or even four years, by boys with no linguistic gift or taste, to be abandoned at the earliest possible mo- ment, is forgotten with incredible prompt- ness, leaving a vague stain upon the memory, nowise worth the time and toil and tears it has cost. ‘* Two languages besides English” should be the minimum demand, as the ordinary high school or academy graduate passes easily, albeit on probation, into college. Both insti- tutions should encourage the attempt to ac- complish the mastery of a third, at least, whenever a child, or group of children, shall have the capacity and the time. (The Eoglish classification into ‘‘ pass’ and ‘‘honor” men is worth considering.) Whether that third language be Greek, or French, or Italian may be determined by the needs of the pupil, or, still oftener, by the fitness of the teacher. The cynical critic is still in full cry after the ‘‘illiterate””. school-graduate, especially the unhappy Harvard Freshman. Neverthe- less, several of us have felt, for some time, that perhaps all preparatory schools might well imitate the ancient Lydians, and let their boys surfeit themselves for a full year with athletics only, if meantime the instructors could be ‘rounded up” in the universities, and taught to begin, seriously, making the ac- quaintance of one language apiece! How many of us have tried to know what we pretend to teach? What proportion of our instructors in ‘‘ Latin,” for instance, ever saw a fragment of Ennius, an epigram of Martial, a tragedy of Seneca? Who will write a synop- sis in a thousand words of Quintilian’s ideal of education? Nay, how many will hear with- out terror that their class will read, next montb, not the ‘Archias’ but the ‘Murena,’ the Civil War in preference to the Gallic, the ninth book of the ‘Aneid’ instead of the fourth? We teach ‘‘reading at sight”; how many would dare read for the first time with their class an average chapter of Gellius or letter of Pliny? Asto an actual manuscript or inscription, it might or might not occur to us at first glance that it is in the language which we teach. This sweeping characteriza- tion is unfair to many devoted and diligent specialists. Still, the composite portrait will be recognized. The average youth (or maid) comes, armed with a fresh B.A., to teach Greek and Latin, perhaps a goodly leash of other accomplish- ments, when he has no special preparation at all, has never devoted himself for a month ex- clusively toany onestudy. Heneeds atleasta year to make the acquaintance of one language and of its literature as an organic whole be- fore he can introduce beginners to it intel- ligently. I propose, in all earnest, that we ‘give a rest,” at least in vacation, to the much-maligned urchin, and hunt—ourselves! Wm. C. Lawron. BROOKLYN, April 21, 1897. THE ANTIQUITY OF WELLERISMS. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: I observe in the papers a discussion about the origin of that peculiar form of hu- morous comparison used by Dickens in his ‘ Pickwick Papers’ and for a while wearisome- ly popular under the title of ‘‘ Wellerisms.” It may interest somé of your readers to know that it can claim a very respectableantiquity. Tu the ‘Satiricon’ of Petronius (a work writ- ten in the first century), one of the guests at a supper is complaining of the hardness of the times and general miserableness of things, and another offers consolation: ‘‘ Don’t talk in that way: such is life. What we have not to day, we may have to-morrow. ‘Now it is so, and now it is so,’ as the countryman said who had lost a spotted pig.” (Modo sic, modo sic, in- quit rusticus: varium porcum perdiderat.) . ; W. H. B. LINES BY THOMAS PAINE, To THE EpIToR OF THE NATION: Srr: On the fly-leaf of a copy of ‘Common Sense’ purchased at a book sale in this coun- try, the following lines are written, I believe by Thomas Paine: “ON THE KING’S ILLNESS, 1789. See the vengeance of Heaven! America cries, George loses his senses, North loses his eyes: When they strove to enslave us, all Europe will find That the tyrant was mad, and his Minister blind!” It will be remembered that Paine was in London at this time, 1789, and that the King’s

Page 15

April 29, 1897] 'The Nation. B21 insanity occurred about the same time as the blindness of Lord North, who died in 1792. MoncvureE D. Conway. Lonpon, April 10, 1897. WHITTIER AND THE ‘NARRATIVE OF JAMES WILLIAMS.’ _To THE EpiTor OF THE NATION: S1r: So much interest has recently centred upon the little book here named that perhaps a few additional ‘facts in the case” may pos sess sufficient importance to prove acceptable. These facts are obtained from recently ac- quired files of the anti-slavery journals, the Emancipator and the Liberator, the numbers of which for 1838 give much prominence to James Williams and his ‘ Narrative,’ and dis pel any doubts surrounding Whittier’s connec. tion with the tale. In the Emancipator for January 25, 1838, appears for the first time the announcement: “James Williams—the fugitive slave. An au- thentic narrative of this slave—now a FREEMAN— self-emancipated—is in the pressand will be speedi- ly published, and we venture to say that no work more interesting has been published since the be- ginning of the Anti-Slavery discussion. It will be a narrative of facts, illustrating the cruelties and blasphemies connected with slavery. The names of persons connected with James will be printed at length, together with a portrait of the fugitive, so that the statements can be verified or contradicted. The story has been taken down from the lips of James, by J. G. Whittier, by whom the work will be prepared for the press. Pages 130, 18mo.” The issue of the paper for February 18 con- tains a list of ‘‘ books recently published, and for sale at the Anti-Slavery office, 143 Nassau Street, New York.” First on this list is: “Narrative of James Williams, an American Slave; who was for several years a driver on a cot- ton plantation in Alabama—by John G. Whittier. Published by the American Anti Slavery Society, and for sale at their office, No. 143 Nassau St., 18mo, pp. 108; price 18%4 cts. single, $14 per hun- dred.”’ (It will ba noted that the announcement be- fore publication specified pp. 130 ; that after, pp. 108—a reduction in size which might have been caused by the omission of intended intro- ductory matter.) This announcement was re- printed in subsequent issues of the journal. In the Emancipator for April 19 appears an extract from the Alabama Beacon of March, 29 (denouncing the Narrative as “a foul fester of falsehood”), appended to which is an edi- torial rejoinder of the Emancipator, contain- ing the statement : ‘The book was not written by ‘some peddling Yankee preacher,’ as is suggested by your corre- spondent, but by Joan G. WHITTIER, whose name is beyond the impeachment of mercenary motives. Neither is the ‘ copyright secu-ed,’ as the same cor- respondent may know by the absence of certificate on the back of the title-page.” The issue for May 3 contains a catalogue of anti-slavery publications, among other titles in which appears : ‘Williams, James. A most interesting and af- fecting narrative of an American Slave, taken from his own lips by John G. Whittier. 18mo, pp. 108. Price 25 cents single: $17 per hundred”; and io another column of the catalogue is announced : ‘Narrative James Williams, in sheets $1.00 per hundred in any quantity.” The latter announcement proves that a let- ter to the editor (Rev. Joshua Leavitt), which appeared in the issue for April 12, suggesting that the narrative be ‘‘ published on a sheet and sold by the thousand—by the tens of thou. sands, by the hundreds of thousands,” was acted upon, and that an edition in broadside, or some such form, may be looked for by the earnest collector. After May 3 the catalogue feature of the Emancipator is omitted, and, except some comment from correspondents, no reference to James Williams appears again until August 16, when an editorial headed ‘* James Williams” states : “The Alabama Beacon of July 26, published at the county seat of Greene County, brings us a letter written by Mr. Lewis Tappan to the editor, with a number of certificates from Alabama and Virginia, calculated to discredit the narrative of James Wil- liams. Mr. Tappan is at present out of town, but the matter will be looked into without delay. And in the meantime, as the committee have no object or interest but in the truth, our publishing agent has stopped the sale of the book.”’ The issue for August 23 contains a brief editorial note on the subject, aud that for Au- gust 30 enters extensively into the controver- sy, ten columns being devoted to the state- ment, entitled ‘‘ Alabama Beacon versus James Williams,’’ prepared by James G. Bir- ney and Lewis Tappan. The opening para- graph states that ‘‘ the narrative was prepared and published under the direction of the execu- tive committee of the American Anti-Slavery Society, in the latter part of the winter,” and refers to “the regular narrative, in which the narrator him- self was the principal actor, and to most of the par- ticulars of which he could himself testify. The narrative was accompanied by a prefato- ry essay, in which numerous well-authenticated facts connected with American slavery were brought togetber and presented in such a manner as to force the belief that the picture exhibited in the narrative, if not drawn from life, was certainly true to nature. The narrative was sent gratuitously to all the members of Congress soon after it was published. In the slave States it has had some, though a limited, circulation.” The “‘ statement” embraces extensive articles from the Alabama Beacon, and letters from several residents of the localities named in the narrative, which contradicted the charges con- tained in the book. A further rejoinder (the tone of which would seem to imply that the sale of the publication was resumed) by the Anti-Slavery Society appsars in the issue for September 20, discrediting the statements ad- vanced by the Alabama Beacon, and the let- ters quoted. This is followed by an editorial note: “Credibility of James Williams. Friend Whit- tier, who is not over credulous and is certainly honest, gives his present judgment of the matter in these terms: ‘We have examined the Southern testimony, and while we candidly admit that it has created a doubt in our mind of the accuracy, in some minute particulars, of the statement made by the fugitive to several gentlemen in this State [{Whit- tier was at the time editor of the Pennsylvania Freeman) and in New York (and which was writ- ten down from his lips by ourself), we are still dis- posed to give credit in the main to his narrative.” The catalogue of anti-slavery publications is resumed in the Emancipator for September 28, but omits mention of the narrative, which is noticed for the last time in the issue for Oc- tober 25, in the art’cle headed ‘Statement authorized by the Executive Committee.” In this article the committee expresses its con- viction that the contradictions advanced by the Alabama Beacon are correct; that the statements made by the ex slave ‘‘ are wholly false, and therefore they [the members of the committee] cannot with propriety ask for the confidence of the community in any of the statements contained in the narrative”; end- ing with the resolution: ‘‘ That the said spe- cial committee prepare, as soon as may’ be, a statement in relation to said narrative, to be inserted in the Emancipator, and that the publishing agent be directed to discontinue the sale of the work.” The Liberator for March 9 contains, over the signature ‘‘ Memento,”’ its first notice of the book. The same issue announces that “‘I. Knapp, 25 Cornhill, is agent for all the publi- cations of the American Anti-Slavery So- ciety.” An extract from the Narrative of James Williams appears in thé number for March 16, followed, in the issue for March 30, by the announcement: ‘Narrative of an American Slave! Narrative of James Williams, an American Slave; who was for several years a driver on a cotton plantation in Alabama. Published and sold by Isaac Knapp at 25 Cornhill—price, bound, 25 cents; paper covers, 18%4 cents.”” Appended is an extract from the editor’s pre- face to the work, and this: ‘‘ Note. The reader is referred to John G. Whittier of Ames bury, Mass., [and others],” the note being copied from front cover of the book, with date appended, ‘‘ Mar. 30.” The advertisement is repeated in the issues for April 6, 13, 20; May 11, 25; June 22, 29; July 13, 27; August 10, 17; September 7, 21; October 5, 19. The dates of New York and Boston an- nouncements will be noted as determining the place of publication of the first edition, also that of Isaac Knapp’s appointment as agent of the American Anti-Slavery Society’s pub- lications, and the different styles in which the issue bearing the Boston imprint was sup- plied. The editor of the Liberator (William Lloyd Garrison) would seem to have adopted an at- titude of extreme caution towards the Narra- tive, and to have held aloof from the contro- versy as to the truth or falsehood of the slave’s story, merely reprinting, without com- ment, in the Liberator for September 28, an extract from the Emancipator (expressing confidence in the Narrative), and copying (also without comment), in the Liberator for No- vember 2, the ‘‘ authorized statement” of the Emancipator, October 25, already referred to; after which date no further allusion is made to James Williams. These facts prove conclusively that Whit- tier’s connection with the publication was, in 1838, almost as generally known asif his name as author or editor had appeared on the titile- page. P. K. Fouey. Notes. Miss IsaBEL F. HapGoop has completed a Prayer-book for the Russo-Greek Church, and has submitted the MS. to the Holy Synod of Russia for criticism. Bishop Nicholas (Aleu- tian Islands and Alaska), the Russian Prelate for America, heartily approves of the under- taking, and stands sponsor for the book with the Holy Synod. The subject is vast and complicated, as no complete service, even of the customary Mass, Matins, and Vespers, exists in Russia. Miss Hapgood has, however, constructed a series of services from the enor- mous material in the ecclesiastical books (a complete set of which Bishop Nicholas pre- sented to her, with his blessing), which any one can follow—even persons unfamiliar with

Page 16

322 The Nation. [Vol. 64, No. 1661 liturgies. The plan of the book includes a condensed but complete compendium of eccle- siastical usages and symbolism, the latter be- ing also indicated in such a manner that it can be grasped as the service proceeds. The Eastern Church has long needed such a practi- cal book, for the use of visitors to Russia, to Greece, to the churches of that rite in the Eu- ropean capitals and in this country, where considerable congregations exist at many points. Rev. William R. Huntington, D.D., of Grace Church in this city is the American revisor and corrector of the liturgical lan- guage in the volume. Ginn & Co., Boston, are soon to publish the first part of a work on ‘German Orthography and Phonology,’ by Prof. George Hempl of the University of Michigan. The second part, consisting of an alphabetical list of the diffi- cult words of the language, with spelling and pronunciation phonetically transcribed, is in preparation. A.S. Barnes & Co. are to publish ‘The An- nals of Switzerland,’ by Miss Julia M. Cotton, and ‘ The History of the Waldenses,’ by Mme. Sophia Bompiani. A remodelled series of the year-book ‘ Who's Who?’ is announced by Macmillan Co. Universal history in monographs is the na- ture of a new undertaking by the great book- making house of Velhagen & Klasing in Biele- feld (New York: Lemcke & Buechner). The first number, dealing with the Medici, will be from the pet of Prof. Dr. Eduard Heyck. to be followed by Queen Elizabeth, by Prof. Dr. Erich Marcks, Kaiser Maximilian I , by Prof. Dr. Heyck, the Crusades, the Hohenstaufen, etc., down to Napoleon [., Freiherr vom Stein, Kaiser Wilhelm I., Bismarck, etc: The series will be admirably illustratéd, and will be sold separately. Few who are fond of the older Italian lité- rature have not, at one time or another, che- rished a mad ambition to translate Giovanni Villani’s chronicle into the easy, good-natured English it deserves. But even if the task were dong, and properly done, the version would search long for a publisher, and, if pub- lished would claim scantattention. It is bet ter to be content with the selections from the first pine boi1ks which have been translated, ** for the use of students of Dante and others,” by Rose E. Selfe, under the supervision of Philip H. Wicksted (London: Archibald Con- stable; New York: Macmillan Co.). The ex- tracts chosen are chicfly those which illus- trate passages in Dante's various works, and marginalia give the appropriate refer- ences. The greatest good, however, that “*students of Dante and others” will acquire from the volume may perhaps be a keener feeling for the somewhat complacent Floren- tine spirit, as unconsciously depicted by this calm chronicler of party feuds and * boss” rule, whose Guelph judgment held that Dante ‘delighted to denounca and cry out after the manner of the poets, perhaps in certain places more than was fitting; but may be his exile was the cause of this.” The translation is excellent. The press of the University of Chicago issues a very elaborate monograph by Prof. John W. Million, entitled ‘State Aid to Rail- ways in Missouri.’ By way of introduction the author reviews the experiments made by most of our States in ‘internal improve- ments” and other business enterprises, the results being, with hardly an exception, dis astrous. ‘‘ There is nota single case,” he says, ‘tin the whole list of the States attempting the construction or the assistance in the con- struction of public works between 1825 and 1840 in which there is evidence of command- ing administrative ability. In the case of al- most all there:is an absence of what can be called immaculate honesty.” Although Mis- souri did not fairly begin her experiments un- tilthe middle of the century, the experience of other States had no lessons for her states- men. Afterspending many millions in various railroad enterprises, the State found the charges iutolerable, and sold out its interests at a very heavy loss. The loss, it seems, was much increased by the venality of legislators; and in this case, as well as others, incompetency and corruption proved to be obstacles fatal to the success of governmental ventures in the field of business. Prof. Million has done his work with great care, and has furnished a valuable body of evidence on this sub- ject. Paul Bourget’s last book, ‘ Recommence- ments’ (Paris : Lemerre), contains somes very strong work indeed. It is a collection of ten tales, every one of which is admirably told, with a surer and deeper art than the author has yet exhibited. Several of the charac- teristic traits of M. Bourget reappear ; the old love of rank, society, wealth, and the luxuries of modern civilization has not abandoned bim, but the profoundly human interest he has im- parted to his characters and to the scenes he describes compensates for this slight snobbish- ness. Four of the tales especially commend themselves by the sense of power: ‘Le David,” ‘‘Saida,” ‘*L’Adoration des Mages,” and ‘‘ Pendant la bataille.” Now that Adolphe Jullien’s ‘‘Le Romantisme et l’éliteur Renduel” has been published in book form by Charpentier & Fasquelle, one can enjoy to the full the recollections of the man who came into such close and intimate contact with all the great writers of that once famous and influential school. Something of what made the enthusiasm of the bygone Ro- mantic days may be gathered from the remi- niscences of Renduel which M. Jullien has so interestingly woven together. The illustra- tions, consisting of reproductions of portraits, caricatures, and facsimiles of autographs, add considerably to the interest and value of the book. Mosapp's ‘ Charlotte von Schiller’ is the first book to present in brief and attractive form the life and character of Schiller’s wife. The two extensive works published years ago un- der the direction of ber daughter, Frau. von Gleichen, offer biographical material in abun- dance, but they can hardly be called biogra- phies. Fulda’s book of 1878 is so lacking in historical arrangement, and there is so little distinction between the essential and the un- essential in his treatment, that a well-propor- tioned idea of Charlotte’s life can scarcely be secured from it. Mosapp puts into his book only that which really has to do with her life and character, and therefore Schiller’s work aud life are mentioned only when he directly contributed to her development. Although the book is of rather a popular nature, it is based on scientific principles, and, where con- venient, the story is told in Charlotte's own words, taken from her correspondence. The book is dedicated to King Wilhelm II. of Wiir- temberg as a token of appreciation of his in- terest in establishing the Swabian Schiller Society some two years ago, and for his en- couragement in the founding of the Schiller museum and archive at Marbach. The re- mains of the poet's wife lie in the graveyard at Bonn instead of at her husband's side asshe so much desired. Their sole descendant is a ‘ great-grandson, Alexander Schiller von Glei- chen- Russwurm. A singularly indigested compilation is the ‘Literary Year-book ’ just adventured in London by George Allen (New York : Dodd, Mead & Co,). Frank admission is made of a change of purposs to which much of the con- fusion may be attributed, but which cannot account for a sketch, with portrait, of Mr. G. S. Street, being deliberately intercalated in a list of literary clubs, learned societies and in- stitutions, page 110 ending with the Oriental Translation Fund, p 111 being a bastard title, and the list proceeding again with the Oxford and Cambridge Club on p. 115. This is the very madness of bookmaking. The explana- tion appears to be that the editor aimed to secure readability for a reference book. The value of this annus! lies almost solely in its directories—of British authors, public libra- ries, literary clubs as aforesaid, publishers, booksellers, etc. The literary articles are slight. A number of the dii minores of lite- rature of the present hour are pictured and briefly biographized. The portrait of the poet W. B. Yeats, by his father, puts the photo- graphs tothe blusb. A list of eight errata is inserted. We can add two more: * At” for As, on p. vi., and ‘‘sold up” (!) for sealed up, on p. 60 (of the Guildhall Library). Mrs. Caroline H. Dall has reprinted in a little brochure (Boston: Roberts Bros) her two-year-old lecture on “Transcendentalism in New England,” which was firat published in the Journal of Speculative Philosophy. Like all that Mrs. Dall writes, it is lively and interest- ing reading. She embraces in her survey Anne Hutchinson and Margaret Fuller, and is mostly concerned, in her intimate sketches of individual lights, to give credit of priority to Dr. F. H. Hedge in paving the way for the Concord group, for Brook Farm, etc. Of Al- cott she writes impatiently. McClure’s Magazine for May opens with an article on Mr. G.C. Cox, the photographer, who holds a place apart not only in this city, but in the profession generally. Mis3Tarbell's text is exemplified by numerous portraits of celebrities, but none of these speaks as much for the skill of Mr. Cox as the succeeding por- trait of President Cleveland (we believe, the very latest before he laid down the cares of office), which stands at the head of Carl Schurz’s notable review of his administrative career. The ordinary machine made photo- graph of commerce after the same face bears no relation to Mr. Cox’s rare psychologic se- lection. Mr. Schurz’s story will be novel to most of us because a short memory is an Ame- rican characteristic. It is not mere eulogy. A reduced facsimile of Alexander Selkirk’s will is the curiosity of the April number of the New England Historical and Genealogical Register. The body of it is aprinted form. It bears date December 12, 1720,and the pay-book of H.M. 8S. Weymouth shows that this ‘‘ mas- ter’s mate” died just a year later, December 12, 1721. Mr. Henry ¥. Waters, continuing to move in that other-world of decedents and testators which must sometimes seem to him the only real existence, deals, in his ‘‘Genealo- gical Gleanings in England,” with connections of Banks, Bates, Burroughs, Foote, Vassall— to mention a part. Dr. John Ward Dean, in a modest paragraph, commemorates his edi- torial direction of the Register for just one- half the fifty and a half years of its issuance. We read on p. 227 that Mr. Eban Putnam of Salem, Mass., proposes to print abstracts of the probate records of that county, giving every name occurring in the wills and settle-

Page 17

April 29, 1897] The Nation. 323 ments of estates to the close of the eighteenth century. But he must be assured of fifty subscriptions in advance, at five dollars each. Bibliographica (London: Kegan Paul; New York: Scribners) closes its third volume and its career in a worthy manner. Sir E. Maunde Thompson compares the block book ‘Biblia Pauperum’ with an antecedent MS. whose miniatures in theme are in close agreement with the woodcuts, This article is finely illustrated. Mr, Andrew Lang, fresh from Pickle, the Spy, discourses on ‘‘Late Ja- cobite Tracts,” while Mr. Robert Edmund Graves describes the nuggets of the Isham eol-. lection of rare Elizabethan and other English works, which has in part been acquired by the British Museum. Elaborate and authori- tative, and richly exemplified, is Mr. Alfred W. Pollard's ‘Illustrations in French Books of Hours, 1486-1500.” Not to be overlooked, decidedly, are the Addenda to former articles. A general index tothe three volumes follows the Epilogue. The effect of alcohol on mountain-climbers is discussed by Dr. Otto Snell in No. 3 of the Mittheilungen des Deutschen und Oester- reichischen Alpenvereins. Last autumn he had a card in the same publication request ing climbers to forward their personal expe- riences and views to him. He received sixty communications, thirty-seven of which, or 62 per cent., condemn the use of liquors, wine, or beer as an impediment rather than an aid. Twelve are for a moderate use of wine, but pronounce against brandy and beer. Three be- lieve in taking brandy along, to be used, how- ever, not as a stimulant, but in case of need as a medicine or to mix with glacier-water. Only five of the sixty expressed their beliet that alcoholic drinks are beneficial or harm- less toclimbers. The general conclusion drawn by Dr. Snell from these answers is that while in exceptional cases alcohol may be harmless, or possibly useful, as a rule great moderation is desirable, while the majority of experts are for total abstinence until after the climb is over, and some even strongly urge abstinence, or great moderation, on the day before the expedition. One of the correspondents ex- pressed his conviction that the bottled drinks taken along by climbers benefit no one but the tavera-keepers from whom they buy them. The Chronik der Christlichen Welt prints statistical tables from which it gathers the surprising information that the number of theological students in the German universi- ties has decreased from 4,527 in 1890 to 2,956 in 1896, or more than one-third. The decrease occurred at all the evangelical faculties ex- cepting those of Griefswald and Erlangen, and it is more noticeable in North than in South Germany. It is considered the more remarkable in view of the fact that within recent years the income of the clergy has been materially increased. The Frankfurter Zei- tung is inclined in large part to attribute the growing disinclination of young men to study theology to the attempts made, especially in North Germany, to crush the tendency to ap. ply scientific methods to the study of religious questions. We notice the advent of the Japan Times, a six-page daily and weekly newspaper found- ed by Japanese enterprise wholly, though a foreign editor will be employed. It is printed wholly in English, and will have colored sup- plements and pay particular attention to those things Japanese which are most in the eye of foreigners. Paper, print, and proof-reading in this first issue are unexceptionable. We note many features of interest, including an an- nouncement of a translation into Japanese of Capt Mahan’s ‘The Influence of Sea-Power upon History.’ (The Times office is No. 5 Uchisaiwai-cho, Tokyo.) The Buddhist magazine, Hansei Zasshi, vol. xii., No. 2, in English, besides fine illustra- tions of scenery and a picture of the late dowager empress, contains an interesting ar- ticle showing the original text of a Chinese Buddhist sutra containing the word Messiah and in the same phonetization as that (mi-shi- ho) upon the famous Nestorian tablet, the au. thenticity of which has been established by such scholars as Legge and Pauthier. In 1895 $180,000 was given by the Legisla- ture of Wisconsin to erect a fire-proof edifice exclusively for safeguarding the collections of the State Historical Society, now amounting to 100,000 volumes and as many pamphlets, with manuscripts yet more rare and priceless. This structure has been building ever since, on ample grounds, and adapted architecturally to be made threefold larger so as to include the University Library under the same roof. This projected extension, which it was believed must be deferred for a decade, is to become an accomplished fact immediately. The Legisia- ture has just now laid a tax for this purpose which will yield $420,000. It has also raised the annual appropriation in aid of the society from five to fifteen thousand dollars. While the death of Christian Ludvig Ed- vard Lembcke, which occurred March 20, is of primary interest to students of Danish lite- rature, it is not without significance to lovers of our own poetry through his admirable translations of Shakspere and Byron. Lemb- cke was born in Copenhagen June 15, 1815. After passing both the theological and the philological examinations he became a teacher, and from 1850 till 1864 he was assistant rector of the famous Latin School at Haderslev in Schleswig. He was one of the most enthu- siastic ‘‘ Scandinavians” and National Libe- rals of that time, and his zeal for the Danish cause in Southern Jutland led to his dismissal from his post. His best-known poem, which is also one of the most popular and charac- teristic of the Danish national songs, ‘* Vort Modersmaal er dejligt” (Our Mother. tongue is Lovely), isa warm expression of his patriot- ism. The translation of Shakspere was un- dertaken chiefly in order to occupy his mind after the exile from Schleswig. It was pub- lished in 1865-72, and immediately won recog- nition as the standard Danish version. It is evidently largely based on the translation of Foersom and Wulff of twenty years before. Although often lacking the vigor and spirit of the original, especially in the later tragedies, it is with few exceptions correct and without exception poetical. Lembcke’s versions of Byron are said to be remarkably happy. Itis of interest to note that a third edition of the Shakspere, in nine volumes, with numerous illustrations by Hans Tegner, was announced at the beginning of the year, the first part having appeared shortly before the transla- tor’s death. A correspondent writes: ‘‘ You cannot follow the Greek struggles with more zest than I do, for I claim to have shared in the first war for liberation. The United States could do no- thing as a Government, but our people did much to feed and clothe the rebels. Pattern suits were sentabout New England, and some came to my native village, one of which fitted me, not yet in my teens; so I was dressed in fez, fustinella, leggings, etc., and sent toevery house in the village—an ambulatory adver- tisement, much ridiculed by boys and girls, ‘but which brought all their mothers together in sewing-circles and turned out a hundred garments which warmed as many Greeks shivering in nakedness, and brought the blessing of those ready to perish on Yankee sewing-women. When first at Athens in ’68 I had many a favor in acknowledgment of my boyish service.” —Sir Martin Conway’s account of his last summer’s expedition to Spitzbergen is given in the April number of the Geographical Journal. To the lay reader the results donot seem commensurate with the hardships and dangers encountered from glaciers, bogs, in- numerable streams, and ‘‘ vile” weather. The chief interest in the exploration seemed to lie in the fact that the island gives ‘‘one of the very best examples in the world of the pro- cesses of mountain and valley manufacture.” From the examination of the glaciers, there is some reason to believe that the climate is ame- liorating. A tourists’ inn, it may be added, has been opened at Advent Point on the west coast. Lieut. Vandeleur tells of various ex- peditions made by him in Uganda and the ad- jacent countries. The most interesting was one down the Nile, during which he landed at several of the old stations of Emin Pasha. There were few signs remaining of the Egyp- tian occupation, nor did there appear to be any Dervishes in the ‘“‘uninviting” country. Under the British rule, however, Uganda is progressing rapidly. The population is in- creasing largely. ‘‘A regular post has been established, which the chiefs avail themselves of to write to each other,” and a silver cur- rency is taking the place of cowries and beads. A description of the work of the commission for laying down the southern boundary of Afghanistan, by Capt. McMahon, contains some vivid pictures of the borderland of In- dia and its great deserts of moving sand, parts of which were anciently inhabited by a dense population, as is attested by the numerous re- mains of cities and canals. The line passed over an extraordinary earthquake crack, ‘‘ as clearly defined as a deep railway cutting,” which was surveyed for 120 miles. Besides numerous illustrations, each of these articles is accompanied by admirable maps, There is to be noted a lack of uniformity in the spell- ing of the geographical names in the text and on the maps, and it is accordingly difficult to determine which is the correct form, as, for instance, Hinloopen or Hinlopen, and Kobuk or Kohuk. A suggestive paper, by A. W. Andrews, discusses the teaching of geography in relation to history. —In perusing volume v. of Cosmopolis, in- cluding the numbers for the first three months of the second year of its existence (January- March, 1897), we are impressed with the suc- cess which has attended this venturesome un- dertaking. To enlist for a single review such an array of first-class writers, representing the principal currents of modern literature and three different nations, was no small feat. This once accomplished, the rest may have been comparatively plain sailing. Still, the codrdination and adjustment of so large a number of articles, from eighteen to twenty- two in each number, is fraught with difficul- ties to overcome and dangers to be avoided. The average length of fifteen pages for each contribution, conditioned by the nearly uni- form size (300 pp.) of each issue, is seldom ex- ceeded by any of the writers; and this mea- sure strikes us as a judicious-one if the aim be to keep clear both of the Scylla of scrappi- ness and the Charybdis of heaviness—relative

Page 18

B24 The Nation. [Vol. 64, No. 1661 terms, to be sure, but not absolutely indefi- nite. While none of the articles are ponder- ous, nearly all of them are sufficiently serious ; even such genial discourse as Max Miiller’s ‘‘ Literary Recollections” contains so much of interest about literary celebrities of the last ‘fifty years, and is interspersed with so many reflections and judgments, that at least every student or lover of English literature will feel repaid for reading the articles. But we must not begin to single out individual names when nearly all belong to the foremost novelists, critics, historians, politicians, etc., of Eng- land, France, and Germany. The utility of such an international and trilingual review will not for a moment be questioned by any one who has occasional half-hours to spare for orienting himself, or keeping up his interest in the literary, political, artistic, and scienti- fic movements of the time, and who, in so do- ing, likes to enjoy the flavor of the soil on which he happens to be moving. The pub- lisher (T. Fisher Unwin) has now arranged for a monthly supplement in Russian, and an- nounces for the near future similar supple- ments in Dutch, Scandinavian, and Italian, all of which can be procured separately. —On April 14 the Zodlogical Station at Na- ples celebrated the twenty-fifth anniversary of its foundation, and the Frankfurter Zei- tung of March 24 and 25 anticipated this event by giving a bird’s eye view of the work done by that important aquarium and bio- logical laboratory, which has served as a model to numerous similar institutions that have since sprung up in various parts of Eu- rope and America as wellasin Japan. It was at a time when the scientific experts were still hotly debating the numerous questions suggested by Darwin’s theories, that it oc- curred to Dr. Anton Dohrn to found, some- where on the Mediterranean, a laboratory where marine animals might be studied at home, as it were ; his belief being that the sea furnished the most valuable specimens for biological /research. He had considerable means of his own, and he added to them the profits of his public aquarium at ‘Naples These, however, did not suffice for carrying out his comprehensive plans, and he therefore appealed to the governments and universities of various countries for assistance. Naples gave him a convenient location, while the Mi. nistry of Agriculture at Rome contributed $8,000 and an annual subvention of $500. The German Government recognized the value of the Zodlogical Station in 1880 by voting to contribute $7,500 a year, which sum was in 1890 increased to $10,000. These funds are augmented by means of an ingenious arrange- ment with various states and universities by which, in return for $500 a year, any one can secure a ‘‘table” in the laboratory with all the privileges and conveniences it affords. Germany and her universities have 10 tables, Italy 9, Austria and Russia 2 each, Holland, Belgium, Hungary, Switzerland, Rumania, Bulgaria, 1 each, while others are held by the universities of Oxford, Cambridge, Columbia, the British Association, Smithsonian Insti tution, etc. The only state that ever gave up its table was Spain, which no longer felt able to pay for it. —The means for securing material for all these students are as ingenious as the financial arrangements. Two small steamboats are in the service of the Zodlogical Station, and $1,500 is yearly paid to the Naples fishermen at large, who have instructions to bring to t the laboratory such contents of their nets as are not utilized in the markets. Not only do the managers in this way secure abundant specimens for use in the laboratory, but ar- rangements have been made for forwarding specimens to biologists in all parts of Europe, this being another source of income. The in- stitution employs 11 officials and 30 assistants, and the number of students is about 40 in winter, 20 in summer. As certain animals are available only at certain seasons, experi- menters are informed beforehand as to the time when they should come to Naples; and so great is the supply of specimens in the aquarium that a student need not be de layedan hour in getting to work. Theexpense of maintaining the aquarium is great, and there are other ways in which the exchequer is depleted, especially by the literary depart- ment. In 1876 the Station commenced the publication of an exhaustive work on the fauna and flora of the Gulf of Naples. There are now twenty-four volumes, the prepara. tion of some of which took a decade and cost over $4,000 apiece. Two other publications are issued by the institute, one (now in its eleventh volume) being entitled Mittheilun- gen aus der Zoologischen Station in Neapel, while the other, Zoologischer Jahresbericht, is an ambitious and extremely useful attempt to catalogue the scientific publications of Ger. many, France, Italy, and England. —In view of the persistent efforts in behalf of the amelioration of the state of women in Germany, it does not seem that the present unfavorable conditions can last many years longer. The periodical press, exclusively or in part devoted to the woman’s cause, continues its work with unabated activity. Such pa- pers as Die Frauenbewegung (Berlin), the or- gan of a dozen associations in different parts of Germany and Switzerland; Neue Bahnen (Leipzig), the official organ of the General Women’s Union; Die Gleichheit (Stuttgart), devoted to the cause of the women of the la- boring classes—with all the warmth flowing from sincere sympathy for the oppressed, and with the stern determination springing from faith in the ultimate triumph of socialism ; Die Frau (Berlin), amonthly edited by Helene Lange and representing the interests of women in the most catholic spirit—these*and others do not allow a single phase of the woman question to escape their attention. That the Social Democrats are stanch supporters of “equal rights” for women is well known. Pastor Naumann of Frankfort, the famous Christian Socialist, also comes to the aid of the subjected sex with occasional articles in the columns of Die Hilfe (Berlin), the weekly founded by him some three years ago and of which he is still a leader-writer. A multi- tude of pamphlets, appearing steadily at short intervals, are mostly concerned with the problem in its bearings upon the middle and higher classes, and the relation between these and the lower strata. Thus, E. von der Deck- en, in ‘ Die gebildete Frau und die neue Zeit’ (Géttingen: Vandenhoeck), writes in the some: what conservative spirit of a modern Chris- tian gentlewoman on the duties which exist- ing social conditions impose upon the women of the higher classes. ‘ Die Ausnahmestellung Deutschlands in Sachen des Frauenstudiume,’ by Eliza Ichenhaeuser (Berlin: Walther), dis- poses easily and effectually of some of the most recent enemies of university education for wo- men: Prof. Platter and Prof. Dr. Albert—the latter, a distinguished Viennese surgeon, hav- ing previously been met in a manful way by oneof his own pupils, Dr. M. Kronfeld, in ‘Die Frauen und die Medicin’ (Vienna: Konegen). Prof. Dr. O. Lassar deserves recognition as a propagandist among the commercial and in- dustrial classes, before representatives of which, in Berlin, he delivered an address’ on ‘Das medicinische Studium der Frau’ (Berlin: Karger), treating thesubject from the general human standpoint. FOOTE’S ANNALS OF KING’S CHAPEL. Annals of King’s Chapel. From the Puritan Age of New England to the Present Day; By Henry Wilder Foote. Vol. II. Boston: Little, Brown & Co. 1896. Ir is now fifteen years since the first volume of Mr. Foote’s Annals was reviewed in these columns. The second volume fully maintains the interest of its predecessor, notwithstanding the fact that, owing to Mr. Foote’s death in 1889, its form and arrangement have depended much on other hands than his. Mr. Henry H. Edes has proved a careful and judicious edi- tor, availing himself of what was best in the mountain of material amassed by Mr. Foote and of the assistance of several competent and sympathetic workers, notably Dr. A. P. Pea- body and Dr. Joseph Henry Allen. Mr. Foote’s classmate and friend, Mr. Winslow Warren, has an appreciative chapter on Mr. Foote’s ministry—a pathetic addition to the book as Mr. Foote intended it. On the other hand, it falls short of his intention through omitting a chapter on the Unitarian Movement, and a ‘¢ List of the Parishioners who were not Pro- prietors of Pews,” for which he had made some preparation. But Mr. Edes found the inclusion of this task too formidable. In re- gard to the Unitarian Movement he does well to suggest that Dr. Allen’s ‘Historical Sketch of the Unitarian Movement since the Refor- mation’ has done away with the necessity for the chapter which Mr. Foote intended and the editor has omitted. It is generally as true of happy churches as of happy peoples that they have no annals — at least, none that make interesting reading. The history of King’s Chapel was not a happy one during the period of sixty years, from its founding by Sir Edmund Andros in 1686 to the resignation of the Bishop’s commissary, the Kev. Roger Price, in 1747—a period covered by Mr. Foote’s first volume; and the humorous interest of that volume inhered very largely in the unhappiness of the Episcopal Church in a Puritan community, and in the strained re- lations which habitually subsisted between the rectors of the church and their people and their assistant ministers. In this volume we have 150 years of almost unbroken felicity in the relations of the chief ministers and people, while the relations of the parish to the ‘‘ King’s Lecturer” were a continual source of friction and annoyance to all who were concerned. But while these infelicities were discounted much more easily after 1746 than before, there were, as time went on, other elements involved in the situation that made superfluous the Ne- mesis which dogs the steps of the too happy. For the one revolution of the early period, which overthrew Sir Edmund Andros, we have two revolutions in the present volume to - make things sufficiently unhappy and to keep up the interest—the first (1776) robbing King’s Chapel of its prestige as the Chapel Royal of Great Britain in New England, and the second (1784) eliminating from the prayer-book of the Chapel its Trinitarian elements and convert- ing its congregation into the first Unitarian Society in the United States.

Page 19

April 29, 1897] The Nation. 325 But it would be most unjust to these annals to create the impression that their interest de- pends entirely on the two revolutions which affected so profoundly the fortunes of King’s Chapel. The quiet, uneventful ministries of Drs. F. W. P. Greenwood and Ephraim Pea- body are reported in a way that will be very agreeable to those who love to ‘follow the things that make for peace” as well as wars and fightings. Then, too, there is much all the way along for those who care for the de- velopment of ecclesiastical manners and reli- gious opinions and social character. Many, we are confident, will find in the social aspects of these annals their most entertaining and in- structive quality, especially as these aspects are associated with the personality of many celebrated people. It was much easier to be celebrated, or at least conspicuous, in a Boston of 12,000 people than in a Boston forty timesas large. Then the individual was not so swal- lowed up as now in the great multitude. Hard- ly can it be possible that the men and women of our generation will be memorialized as pa- tiently and tenderly as those who live again for us in Mr. Foote’s attractive page. Some of the most interesting passages are those which bring us into a vivid intimacy with such men as Govs. Shirley and Pownall and Bernard, such citizens as Sir Harry Frankland and Dr. Silvester Gardner and his son John, the Mi- nots and the Bulfinches, and Col. Joseph May. Col. May was the tutelary musical genius of the Chapel and the most intimate friend of Dr. Freeman, but is even more distinguished as the father of Samuel J. May of anti slavery fame. At the conclusion of the son's college course his father addressed him somewhat formally, and concluded: “If you have not improved your advantages, or should be here- after slothful, I thank God that I have not property to leave you that will hold you up in a place among men where you will not deserve tostand.” The good words were never mocked by the son’s charaeter at any stage of his career. Agnes Surriage, the wife of Sir Har- ry Frankland, is described in glowing terms, and by consulting the ‘‘ Plan of Pews,” oppo- site p. 588, the curious may discover the very pew in whichshe sat and listened to Mr. Caner’s painful preaching. There is also a fine pic- ture of Sir Harry’s house, the most sumptuous dwelling of the colonial city. The book is rich in portraits and other illustrations, some architectural details being introduced very happily as head and tail pieces. Of the por- traits, that of Sumner is as superbin youthful vigor as that of Dr. Walker is unsatisfactory in its senility. There was no falling off in the distinction of a congregation which could boast such a statesman as Sumner and such a poet as Holmes. Charles Sprague also, ‘‘ the banker poet,” was a parishioner, but the circumstance which suggested his loveliest poem, ‘‘Gay, guiltless pair,” was, unfortu- nately for the Chapel, not associated with its history. The present volume opens with the induc- tion of the Rev. Henry Caner to the ministry of the Chapel in 1746. His rectorate ended only with the general exodus of the Royalists in 1776. The most fortunate event of his mi- nistry was the building of a new church, a worthy example of the Renaissance architec- ture of the eighteenth century, happily pre- served till now, though menaced terribly by fire and the more cruel rage of modern im- provement: The movement for a new church began in 1748, very shortly after Mr. Caner’s installation, the circumstances of which had something of Puritan detachment from Eng. lish models. He was chosen by the congrega- tion, not imposed by the English bishop ; and though the King’s Lecturer began with im- agining himself the superior functionary, he was very quickly disabused and given to know that the congregation held him in inferior respect. Gov. Shirley led off the subscription for the new church with £100 sterlivg, and Sir Harry Frankland with half as much. Peter Faneuil outdid the Governor, subscribing £200, though at the time he was building Faneuil Halland Market asa free giftto the town. The death of Faneuil called a halt, and there was even much difficulty and litigation in extract- ing the amount of his subscription from his brother Benjamin. Many of the original sub- scribers added liberally to their original sub- scriptions before the completion of the work, and there were supplementary subscribers, Sir William Pepperell’s being the most famous name upon the list. Though still far from com- pletion, the building was occupied in 1754, In 1758 it had cost £7,405 sterling, a goodly sum when every dollar went much further than it does at present, The new church required a new organ, and Mr. Foote argues plausibly enough for the validity of the tradition that it was selected by an organist of the rarest com- petency, Handel himself. It has had various vicissitudes, but even now there is something more remaining of it than the case. The crown and mitres which ornamented it before the Revolution, and went into banishment simultaneously with the rector, have been put back where they belong. There are many interesting side-lights on he story from the political history of the times. One of these, if it should not be called a shadow, came from the death of Gov. Shir- ley’s son with Braddock in his miserable de- feat. Another came from the death of that young reprobate, Frederick Prince of Wales, in 1751. It cost the chapel £88 to mourn for him properly, and Mr. Caner a good deal of ingenuity in describing ‘‘the well attemper’d majesty and familiarity which are said to have adorn’d this prince’s character.” On the death of George II., his virtues were somewhat ob- scured by the splendor of the rising sun, King George the Third, and still there was enough said about ‘‘ the Glories of his Reign, the Wis- dom of his Counsels,” and so on. It was not long before the ‘region cloud” began to mask the new effulgence. Chapter xvi. of these annals, the fourth in the present volume, is entitled ‘‘The Gathering Storm.” Gov. Pownall, who succeeded Shirley in 1757, was called a ‘‘fribble” by Samuel Adams, and it isconceded by our annalist that he ‘‘ did not adorn thechurch as his predecessor had done”; but he divined the situation with remarkable perspicacity, and had he remained, Samuel Adams might have found his occupation gone. In 1783 we find him writing of American in- dependence ina fashion which smacks more of Thomas Paine than of a royal Governor: ‘I look upon it as a dispensation of Providence, under which the world for [the] future shall, in its polity, be established on and governed by a new system, according to the laws of na- ture and the rights of man.” Bernard, his suc- cessor, was a much better churchman but a much worse Governor, though even his church- manship was not above suspicion, four he was “no bigot.” Instead of riding from Roxbury into Boston, he often attended the nearest Con- gregational church, that in Brookline, where the length of the sermons had ‘‘a leaning to the side of mercy.” He struck the keynote of his whole administration when, in his first ad- dress to the Assembly, he spoke of the bless- ings derived by the colonies from ‘‘ their sub- jection to Great Britain”—a phrase which was deliberately varied to ‘their relation” in the formal reply to his address. In 1763 we find Mr. Caner referring to the “turbulent and unruly temper ” of the times. Gov. Hutch- inson was not connected with King’s Chapel, but with ‘the Brick Church at the North End.” Nevertheless, his relations to the Chapel were of the friendliest character, and his poli- tical temper was that of the majority of the congregation. The last service in the Chapel, before the war broke out, was on September 18, 1774, ‘* before General Gage & his officers & avery numerous & polite assembly, from the text ‘Be kindly affectioned one toward another in brotherly love.’” But the sickness of the time was beyond the healing power of texts or sermons, though to aggravate it they could still do much. Hutchinson wrote in his History that ‘‘ the people had been persuaded that their religion as well as their liberties was in danger.” We have here the subject of chapter xvii., ‘‘ Epis- copacy and the Mayhew Controversy.” It is one of the most instructive chapters in the book. It is refreshing and consoling as well as instructive, so much more liberal was the scope of partisan denunciation then tban now, so much more full and rich the vocabulary of clerical vituperation. The controversy was begun in 1763 and ended in 1765. It was opened and closed by East Apthorp, the Epis- copal missionary at Cambridge. Formally its subject was the corporate right of the Society for the Propagation of the Gospel in Foreign Parts to use its funds for anything but the conversion of the Indian. Practically it took a wider range, and covered the whole question of the relation of the colonies to the English Church. John Adams went straight to the heart of the matter when he said, ‘‘If Parliament could tax us, they could establish the Church of England here, with all its creeds, articles, tests, ceremonies, and tythes, and prohibit all other churches as conventicles and schism-shops.”” Mayhew, minister of the West Churchin Boston, was the ablest of the contro- versialists in opposition to Episcopacy. He found himself ‘‘not wounded, but bespatter- ed” by the enemy, and sometimes bespat- tered with such filth as one finds on p. 266, too dirty to transcribe. The honors in this regard, however, were pretty evenly divided, the lesser lights outshining their superiors in the brilliancy of their controversial con- ceits. The number of inhabitants remaining in Boston in February, 1776, is given as only 2,719. Mr. Caner left for Halifax March 10, with seventeen other Episcopal clergymen of Boston and vicinity, when the King’s troops marched out and Washington came in. Mr. Caner’s warning was so brief that he had to leave his books and furniture behind. The rector of Trinity Church was an ardent Loyal- ist, and his assistant was making ready to fol- low him to Halifax when Dr. Eliot of the New North Church prevailed on him to stay and look out for the spiritual interests of the Epis- copalians remaining in the city. The assist- ant wes the Rev. Samuel (afterwards Bishop) Parker, and the forlorn remnant of the King’s Chapel congregation waited on his ministry. Of seventy-three pews in King’s Chapel thirty had been occupied by Loyalists and forty-three by those of the Revolutionary party. The con- gregation of the Old South held their services in it for about five years, their own church having been spoiled for their occupancy by the British soldiery. The amenities of this posture

Page 20

236 The Nation. [Vol. 64, No. 1661 of affairs were in pleasing contrast with the Mayhew controversy. In 1781, measures were set on foot for the re- sumption of their own services in the Chapel by the remnant of its former congregation. The first gentleman approached was Mr. Thomas Fitch Oliver of Salem, then a lay reader, and he was warned that the theology of the Society was ‘‘Calvinism a little tem- pered.” Thenegotiation failed, but from this intimation it would seem that Mr. Freeman, whose own Calvinism must have been “‘a little tempered” from the start, did not come to a people wholly adverse to his opinions. Acting as lay reader for a few months, in April, 1783, Mr. Freeman was chosen pastor of the church. Very soon after, his doubts concern- ing the Trinity led him to omit all references ‘to that doctrine in the liturgy. His method was quite different from that of the Congrega- tionalist ‘silent brotherhood.” He preached a course of sermons setting forth the change in his opinions in the most explicit manner. He requested a change in the liturgy con- formable to the omissions he had made. His request was granted by a vote of twenty yeas to seven nays. An amusing feature of the new prayer-book was a series of doxologies, writ- ten by Joel Barlow, subsequently of infidel reputation. In becoming Unitarian, the church did not at first imagine that it had ceased to be Episco- palian. Mr. Freeman first sought ordination from Bishop Seabury of Connecticut, who was still receiving the half-pay of a British chap- lain. The Bishop consulted his clergy, and they advised Mr. Freeman ‘‘to go home, to read, to alter his opinions, and then to re- turn.” He next tried Dr. Provoost, Bishop- elect of New York, who approved the altered liturgy, but could not act at once. Weary of delay, the Society resolved to ordain their minister themselves, and did so November 18, 1787. This business was the subject of some controversy, but the affairs of the Episco- palians generally at that time were in a fluid. state. A few strong men would have carried them over bodily to the theological position of King’s Chapel. Nothing could mark more clearly the naive uncertainty of the King’s Chapel Society as to its ecclesiastical stand- ing than a vote passed in 1808, when Mr. Cary was ordained as Mr. Freeman’s assistant, to the effect that, if at any time they could pro- cure for him Episcopal ordination, they wouid do so. Landscape in Poetry, from Homer to Tenny- son. By Francis Turner Palgrave. Mac- millan Co, 1897. In this volume of 300 pages the late Professor 4 of Poetry in the University of Oxford has fol- lowed the example of his predecessors in that chair, M. Arnold (1857-67) and J. C. Shairp (1877-85), in publishing his Oxford lectures (delivered during 1895), In the March number of Cosmopolis, Max Miller, in his gentle re- miniscences, expressed the hope that these lectures would soon appear. “They are full of most valuable informa. tion, and would prove very useful to many as a book of reference. I have known no one better informed on English poe than my friend Palgrave. I owe him a great deal, particularly in my early Oxford days. For it was he who revised my first attempts at writing in English. He is now one of the very few friends left who remember my first appearance ir Oxford in 1846, and who were chiefly instrumental in retaining my services for.a university which has proved a true Alma Mater to me during all my life.” One realizes how deeply the University Ex- tension movement has struck root at Oxford when the Professor of Poetry announces that, in his University lectures, extension students have been “specially kept in view.” It is to them, in fact, that the book will chiefly ap- peal, and Mr. Palgrave pays no very high compliment to the scholarship of the candi- dates in the “‘ English Honour School” when he recommends these essays to their attention. Matthew Arnold, in one of his letters, ex- pressed the wish that ‘“‘a somewhat consider- able body of Greek and Latin literature should be so rendered as to make it accessible to readers anxious for some familiarity with the literature of those great languages, which they have studied but little.” Mr. Palgrave’s aim was to review the treatment of landscape in Greek and Latin, Hebrew, early Italian, Cel- tic, Anglo-Saxon, and English poetry ; and, in the narrow space that he allowed himself, he could devote only about e fifth of the work to the Greek and Latin poets, so that Ar- nold’s wish is only partially realized. Mr. Palgrave is no essayist. It would be vain to expect, in these chapters, the wit, the style, the charm and effectiveness of Arnold’s ‘ Cel- tic Literature’ or ‘Art of Translating Ho- mer.’ But the tact and appreciation that have made the ‘Golden Treasury of Lyrics’ ‘a monument of a nation’s strength,” have been exercised in the choice of these quota- tions to which Mr. Palgrave’s commentary serves as a thread. There are ‘“‘nine and sixty ways” of han- dling nature, and Arnold has indicated four of them—the conventional, the faithful (which, to invert Beethoven’s motto, is mehr Malerei als Ausdruck der Empfindung), the Greek, and the magical. He never hinted that chro- nology could be imported into this classifica- tion. Mr. Palgrave, on the other hand, tries to show that man’s attitude to nature, in lite rature, has had a development more or less chronological, though his four periods, as he admits, constantly overlap. According to this treatment, the first step in the poetry of land- scape is taken by Homer, with whom nature is the background of human life, though, as con. stautly in the classical poets, there is the added element of personification, according to which the god, in Pater’s phrase, might, at any moment, “slip out of the bark of the olive tree.” This is the ‘Greek way,” taken from one side; but Mr. Palgrave will meet the classical scholar half-way who objects that this does not go far towards summing up the Greek and Roman attitude to nature. The view of C. W. Cope, which had some vogue forty years ago, that the Greek feeling for landscape was entirely utilitarian, is justly ignored to-day. The weakness of Mr. Pal- grave’s method is due to the fact that no great poet has contented himself with one way of handling nature, nor, at any period of literary history, has one method held the field. ‘‘ There is nothing in Wordsworth more real,’’ says Mr. Lang, “more full of the incommunicable sense of nature, . . than the Theocritean poem of the Fisherman’s Dream.” Thisis only one of the many instances that will occur to the scholar of the modern attitude, latent or plainly expressed, in classical poetry. Hebrew poetry, with its sense of God’s law in every natural appearance, is here classed apart ; yet one remenfbers how, even for the ‘‘ classical” eighteenth-century English poets, especially for Thomson and Akenside, the seasons were “but the varied God.” Thirdly, we have the whole field of medieval literature, with Ro- mance, Celtic (from which Mr. Arnold derived the ‘‘magical way”), and Teutonic (from which Wordsworth drew that ‘‘Germanic goodness, docility, and fidelity to nature,” which made him perceive in ‘“‘one impulse from a vernal wood” a whole extension movement and a complete ethical code). ‘‘ Fourthly, knowledge of nature becomes intimacy.” Mr. Palgrave’s handling of Shelley under this head is hardly sympathetic, but the chapter on his friend Tennyson leaves little to be desired. In the case of the Greek, Latin, and Italian quotations the original text is given in foot- notes—a great advantage for the scholar, who will never be satisfied with another's transla- tion, however faithful. The chapter on early Italian poetry will interest students of Dante; that on Celtic and Gaelic poetry should be read along with Arnold’s lecture. We think that, in the chapter on the eighteenth centu- ry, more should have been said as to the sur- vival. even in the day of Dryden and Pope, of a sympathetic handling of nature by the minor English poets. Mr. Palgrave’s work is not final for any period, but it is sure to at- tract many readers. We are surprised that he does not mention Biese, whose exhaustive treatises, ‘‘ Die Entwickelung des Naturge- fihls bei den Griechen [1882], bei den Rémern [1884], im Mittelalter und in der Neuzeit [1888],” are by far the most important works on this subject. Butcher’s excellent essay, ‘The Dawn of Romanticism in Greek Poetry,’ should have been cited. The English through- out is careless and, here and there, startlingly incorrect. On page 152, note, for Davies read Daniel. Genius and Degeneration. By Dr. William Hirsch. Translated from the second Ger- man edition. D. Appleton & Co. 1896, Pp. vi, 333. ~ THIS volume was announced as an answer to that of Nordau. It is, in fact, a much more serious and valuable work than Nor- dau’s, and a good deal more than a refuta- tion. The writer, after treating the two topics of the title independently, goes on (with more spirit, possibly, than the subject deserves) to show the fallacies of his contem- porary. As to the independent treatment, the read- er will find it calm, competent, and convine- ing. It is the patient product of a specialist in mental pathology; and although it takes un- necessary space in places to prove the evident, and goes to unnecessary pains to disprove the absurd, yet that is a good fault in a work which is to reach the general reader. For example, there is the question as to how really great men can have the sense-illusions which it seems they do have and still be con- sidered sane. It would seem to be evident that any great variation in central brain-pro- cesses, whatever be its direction, whether to- ward unusual endowment or toward defect, would tend to include some variation in the sense-functions. There is no more reason for thinking the illusions of Goethe a pathologi- cal symptom than for considering as such the increased vaso-motor activity due to the ex- citement of hard thinking, simply on the ground that insane patients have violent changes in blood-pressure. And the same may be said in reference to the sort of symp- tomatic or diagnostic evidence on which the argument of Lombroso, Nordau & Co. ge- nerally rests. A certain symptom is liable to be present in a certain case; hence, wher- ever this symptom or something like it is pre- sent, there is the identical disease. To pro- ceed on such a diagnostic in daily life would be

Page 21

April 29, 1897] The Nation. B27 to kill ourselves off to save the doctor’s bills; or, what is worse, to do so to prove a theory of medicine. Asa matter of fact, we do not wear on our exterior a catalogue of symptoms which can be read off with such ease. Dr. Hirsch, however, takes this problem and others like it very seriously, and certainly de- serves credit for patience. As to his positive views, he develops them on both the topics—Genius and Degeneration —separately. Genius he thinks cannot be psychologically defined, because it has no con- stant psychological differentia ; there are ge- niuses and geniuses, and the discussion as to what constitutes a man a genius is beside the mark, for the disputant may be considering some other sort of genius. There is a good deal of truth in this, from the point of view of popular usage. Andit is needful to say it, since the discussions of genius are made semi- popular usually even by the psychologists, who yield to the temptation to show, in one topic at least, that their science is not dry. The objective, uncolored, is usually dry; yet it ig just the aim of exact science to be object- ive and uncolored. In this matter of genius, the psychologist should have a meaning for the word—if he use it at all—and the drier the meaning the better. Furthermore, Nor- dau and the rest may be better met on their own ground. The greatest of all the world’s geniuses, even in popular confession, are the men who work revolutions in thought, not those who strike a spark from this particular anvil or that in our human workshop. And “ the law of variations, which holds as well of mental endowment as of biological equip- ment, accounts well enough for the wealth of contrast which such men show in the details of their mental constitution. Besides, while our author mentions the weakness of the use made of statistics by these quasi-scientists, he does not adequately explain their utter inca- pacity in this direction. In the matter of degeneracy, Hirsch takes a very wide view, finding degeneracy ‘‘ to em- brace all cases of defective development of the psychical organ.” ‘‘Degenerates are mental monstrosities.” This would be accepted prob- ably by very few competent judges. The de- finition of degeneracy in terms of down-hill heredity, of run-out blood and used-up stock, is the most current and the best, since it falls in line with the usage and theories of the biologists. But in the matter of diagnosis in apy particular case—this so-called genius or that—it matters not what the definition of degeneracy be. For Hirsch’s point holds, that in any case we cannot distinguish, merely from diagnosis of symptoms, whether a parti- cular defect arises from heredity, disturbances of development, alcoholism, or what not. His critical banter of Nordau along this line is very entertaining. Dr. Hirsch enlivens his work with many literary allusions, and gives us a chapter which we hardly had a right to expect: a chapter nominally on the question of Richard Wagner’s supposed insanity, but really in- cluding a detailed study of Wagner’s drama. tic compositions. This is very instructive as showing the appreciation of a medical man for musical genius—and its limitations—but the inclusion of it in such a work looks like “stuffing.” It will enhance the value of the book, however, for the popular reader, and give him information for which he should be seeking. On the whole, the work is healthy reading on morbid topics. The sections on education and genius and on the dangers to society from all the common talk about de- generation, sexual pathology, spiritism, tele- pathy, etc.—seeing that it tends to loosen the general criteria of reality in intellectual and moral things, and lessen their binding force— are most strongly to be commended. Dahomé, Niger, Touareg: Récit de voyage. Par le Commandant Toutée. Paris: A. Colin & Cie. 1897. Map. Pp. xxi, 370. 12mo. THE activity of the French in developing and extending their West African possessions has a fresh illustration in the above work. The account of the preparations for the mission and the march through Dahomey is dull; but as soon as the unexplored Bariba country is entered, a keen interest is awakened in the picturesque narrative of the aushor’s recep- tion by the kinglets of the various villages through which he passed, and of the manner in which he made treaties with them. In February, 1895, seven weeks after leaving the coast, he reached the Niger in latitude 9° 30’, where he founded a post and built boats for the ascent of the river. For some eight hun- dred miles he made his way up the stream un- til he came into the region under French influ- ence. The obstacles to navigation from the numerous rapids he holds to have been greatly exaggerated by the few Europeans who have seen them. The country bordering the river in this part of its course, which had been de- scribed as largely desert, he found very fertile and highly cultivated in regions where the in- habitants were not exposed to the raids of the Touaregs. The only time when the expedi- tion was obliged to fight was when it en- countered an attack from these marauders, who keep a country larger than Egypt and with apparently greater resources practically a desolate wilderness. M. Toutée takes frequent occasion to criti- cise the action of the Royal Niger Company towards French explorers, but he gracefully acknowledges the hospitality with which its officials treated him on his passage down the river. In a sober estimate of the value to France of the newly acquired territory, he says that he detected no signs of mineral wealth in it, and, though its soil is undoubted- ly very rich, yet the climate renders white colonization impossible. He believes that the true policy is to allow the natives themselves to develop their land by defending them from the raids of the slave-hunting Mohammedans of the south and east, and from the Touaregs of the north. In his story the Commandant manifests a kindly and sympathetic feeling for the natives, as well as great tact in deal. ing with them. He justly prides himself on the peaceful character of his mission, with the single exception noted above, and there can be no doubt that the gold medal of the Société de Géographie bestowed upon him was well de- served. There is a map of the route followed by the expedition. Topical Notes on American Authors. By Lucy Tappan. Boston, Silver, Burdett & Co. WE cannot commend this work for either its plan or its execution. We are told in the preface that it is “the outgrowth of several years’ teaching in the Gloucester [Mass.] High School.” One would suppose that the com- piler of a text-book on this subject would have read the preface to ‘The Scarlet Let- ter’; and that a resident of Gloucester would have sufficient local knowledge to see how far from the truth is the statement that Hawthorne’s surveyorship was ‘‘at the time of Salem's importance as a seaport.” Some of Miss Tappan’s facts are so novel that it would be interesting to know her authority— for example, that Samuel J. Tilden was a classmate of Emerson; nor is it easy to see how the latter can ‘‘now” make Concord ‘the Delphi of New England.” Of Thoreau we are told that ‘‘he never left Concord ex- cept for a lecturing tour or a pedestrian ex- cursion,” though remarks on the next page show the incorrectness of this statement. Of Longfellow we learn that he abandoned the law for journalism, but no hint is given as to where or when he practised either. Ccoper is said, correctly, to have written political novels, but, of the six mentioned as such, only two have anything to do with politics, while three show by their titles that they deal with medieval Europe. In the chapter on Poe we find two con- tributions to original knowledge, viz., that his parents were married in Boston, and that it was during his editorship of the Messenger that Mitchell’s ‘Reveries’ were published therein. As this author was only fourteen when Poe ceased to be editor, his precocity was almost equal to that of Tilden, who, born in 1814, is represented as belonging to the Har- vard class of 1821. In one other respect, how- ever, this chapter is remarkable : where dif- ferent authorities claim different employ- ments for Poe at a particular date, Miss Tap- pan avoids the necessity of a discussion by narrating both without a hint that oneexcludes the other. Thus, before 1878, Poe’s biogra- phers, on his authority, said that in 1827 he started for Greece and was seen in St. Peters- burg; in 1884 Mr. Woodberry discovered that during this time he wasin the army. In this compendium we have both versions, given without reference or authority, as successive events. The Children. By Alice Meynell. New York: John Lane. IN this series of brief essays Mrs. Meynell very vividly contrasts the modern belief that child- hood is a beauty and not a defect, with the me- dizevalidea that children were limbs of Satan, to be regenerated by sternness, and filled with wisdom and religion while still in infancy. John Evelyn’s child, at five, had ‘* got by heart almost the entire vocabulary of Latin and French primitives and words, could make copngruous syntax, turn English into Latin, and vice versa, construe and prove what he read, and did the government and use of relatives, verbs, subtantives, ellipses, and many figures and tropes, and made a considera- ble progress in Comenius’s ‘ Janua,’ and had a strong passion for Greek.” This child died—but the system of education based on the theory that a child was mentally and morally on a par with the instructor last- ed well down to the middle of this century. Perhaps Mrs. Meynell goes to the other ex- treme in her appreciation. She presents us sublimated children, without suggestion of bad temper, greediness, or cruelty. She notes only their fine eyebrows and faultless color; their cold cheeks in midwinter; and their un- conscious elegances of sentiment, language, and behavior—in short, she writes of them from a point of view wholly zsthetic. The book is full of pleasant anecdotes, such as “the saying of a little boy who admired his much younger sister, and thought her for- ward for her age: ‘I wish people knew just how old she is, mother, then they would know

Page 22

The Nation. [Vol. 64, No. 1661 she is onward. They can see she is pretty, but they can’t know she is such a onward baby.’” Mrs. Meynell writes a little too con- sciously, but she often conveys a trite observa- tion in very graceful phraseology : ‘‘ It is not true—thoughit is generally said—that a young child’s senses are quick. This is one of the unverified ideas that commend themselves, one knows not why. . . . Noteven ama- teur conjuring does so baffle the slow turning of a child's mind as does a little intricacy of grammar.” ‘It is the sweet and entire for- giveness of children, who ask pity for their sorrows from those who have caused them, who do not perceive that they are wronged, who never dream that they are forgiving, and who make no bargain for apologies—it is this that men and women are urged to learn of a child.” The book is well printed; but, for the first essay of a new press, as it is advertised to be, it shows a lack of careful proof-reading that is not a little surprising. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. American Baptist Year-Book. 1897. Philadelphia: Baptist Publication Society. Ballard, H. H. Re-Open Sesame; Bhymed Acros- ties. "Boston: L. C. Page & Co. Carlyle, Thomas. conse and Hero- Worship. Th French Revolution, 3 vols, Cromwell’s tiers and Speeches, Vol. I. (Centenary Edition.] Seribners. France, Lewis B. Pine Valley. T. Y. Crowell & Gibbins, H. de B. Industry in England: Histori- cal Outlines. pores. Harper, Prof. Augier's La Pierre de Touche. Boston: Ferry & Co. Kpowies, F- Cap and Gown. Second Series. & Co. $1.25. rvations of a Bachelor. F. & Co. es of Phystes: An Parkperet, ‘Talks. ‘to Young. ten, “Talks to Young, Women. The Century Co. h $1. Robbins, Algebra Reviews. Boston: Ginn & Smeaton ery ee ibe Tented Smollett. [Famous Scots The i Series.) 8 ee of the Age: Their Cause and = Ultimate Aim. Putnams. $1.25. A Vintage of Verse. San Fran- Urmy, Clare’ cisco: William Doxey. Van Rensselaer, Mrs. Sc uyler, One Man Who Was Content, e n Watts - C. Chronicles of a Kentucky Settle- ment. Putnams. $2. Wendt, F. W. Ocean Sketches. New York: Colo- nial ‘Book Winesten, Anne H. Martha Washington. Scrib- Whiton, J. M. Resspsiderations and Reinforce- ments. Whittaker. 50c. HENRY HOLT & CQ.S New and Standard Works on Science, Philosophy, Economics. Etc. Descriptive Catalogue free on application to 29 W. 23d St, New York. 1896 EDITIONS OF MARTIN’S THE HUMAN BODY. ADVANCED COURSE. 685 pp., $2.50 net. Prof. G. W. Fite, Harvard University: “It occupies a place in the literature of physiclogy which no other book I know of can take. Prof. Henry B. Ward, Univ. of Nebraska: “I regard it as the best book on the market, and at per. edition is in detail an undoubted advance on the fi (Briefer Course. $1.20 net. Course. 75c. net.) SEDGEWICK and WILSON’S BIOLOGY Sri BIOLOGY Enlarged. 231 pp., 8vo, Prof. E. O. Jordan, University of Chicage: ‘‘ The desir- ability of a general introductory course dealing with pr ogg vital phenomena is everywhere now recognized. This book, by virtue of its discriminating treatment of the most important biological data, is an — supplement to the work of the Jabora- BESSEY’S BOTANY. peace COURSE. 356 pp., 12mo, $1.12 net. Prof. John M. Tyler, Amherst College: “‘The plan of the ook. ry excellent and it is exceedingly well exe- cuted. The new edition is a great improvement over even the old one.” (Advanced Course. $2.20 net.) WALKER’S POLITICAL ECOMOMY. ADVANCED pe pa 587 pp. 8vo. revised and enlarged, $2.00 Prof. John B. Clark, 7 College: “Not excelled . pA any, that is within reach of English speaking stu- en BRIEFER COURSE. 415 pp _ 12m0, $1.20 net. ELEMENTARY COURSE. 823 pp., 12mo, $1.00 Prof. I. W. Jenks, Cornell University: chapters, ¢.g., those on Rent and Profits,the author has con teanty Le his own work in his more ela- boupte treati Wm. V. Tones. Prin. High School Dept. State Normal College, Albany, N. Y.: “ Presented with unusual clear- ness and selenite’ ae and, at the same time, in a very interesting mann ‘By the Same cess ya International Bimetal- lism, $1.25. Wages, $2. Money, $2. Money, . Trade and Industry, $1.25. RESISEN’S CHEMISTRY. ADVANCED COURSE. 827 pp., 8vo, $2.80 net. BRIEFER COURSE entirety new edition, 1883). 435 pp., 12mo, $1.12 net. E.R. Whitney, Instructor in the Binghamton (N. Y.) High School: * In addition to the highly scientific method of procedure, the book is enhanced by being a work of literary excellence. Tne work of a master in science and in English.” ELEMENTARY COURSE. 272 pp., 80c. net. LABORATORY MANUAL. 196 pp., 12mo, 40c. net. (Togo with Elementary Course.) REMSEN & RANDALL’S CHEMICAL EXPE- RIMENTS., 158 pp., 12mo, 50c. net. (To go with Briefer Course.) > “In some PERKINS’ OUTLINES OF ELECTRICI- TY AND MAGNETISM By CHARLEs A. PERKINS of the University of Ten- nessee. 277 pp., 12mo, $1.10 ne Prof. A. A. — Ohto Crcbeseing : “It comes nearest to meeting my ideal of an elementary text on the principles of electricity and m: nevism of al) the books now published on that subject." PIERCE’S PROBLEMS IN ELEMEN- TARY PHYSICS. = E. DANA PIeRceE of the Bewtiies School, Lake- lle,Conn. 194 pp , 12mo, 60c. net. Prof. S. W. Stratton of Untversity of aw: ya! shall recommend its use whenever possible HERTWIGQ’S ZOOLOGY. The General Principles. Translated ee: geet. G. W. a of Brown. 226 pp., 8vo, $1.60 n ‘orbes, Director Ill. State Labora =o ral Batorg: “The most comprehensible, readable, and critical summary of the matn generalizations of zodlo- ical sclence now, accessible to our students in the glish language.’ BOLLES’ COMMERCIAL LAW. By Dr. ALBERT 8. BOLLEs, Lecturer in the Univer- sity of Pa. 344 pp., 16mo, $1.00 net. “ Fitted for popular instruction and information ; it avoids technicalities as much as possible. Important court decisions are cited as the necessity arises.”— Review of Reviews. JAMES’ PSYCHOLOGY. ADVANCED COURSE. Two Volumes, 8vo, 689,704 pp. The set, $4 80 net. The Nation: “It is probably safe to say that it is the most important contribution that has been made to the subject for many 7 jm ertainly it is pond of the most weighty productions of American thoug! BRIEFER COURSE. 478 pp., 12mo, $1. 60 nc J. M. Taylor, Pres. of Vassar Colicge: “ This retains the brightness and great interest of the original. m on FERN COLLECTOR’S HAND- 4 Herbarium. By Miss 8S. F. Price. $2. .- plates, mostly life. size, with blank pages in vaio to press ferns, and a guide. KERNER’S NATURAL HISTORY OF PLANTS. With over 1,000 illustrations. IV. Parts. $15 net. Boston Transcript: “A monumental work.” BEAL’S GRASSES OF NORTH AME- RICA Vol.I. 457 pp., 12mo, $250, Vol. II.707 pp., $5, ag INVERTEBRATE MORPHOLOGY. By Prof. J. P. McMurricu of the University of Cin- cinnati. New and Cheaper Edition. 661 pp., $3 net. CAIRNS’ QUANTITATIVE ANALYSIS. By F.A.Catrns. Much enlarged by Dr. E. Waller. oon, 417 pp, $2.00 net. BOOKS FROM THE LIBRARY OF lMaj.-Gen.Wm.T. Sherman, with other purchases of Scarce and Desirable Works, all at moderate prices, are to be found on the May catalogue of FRANCIS P. HARPER, 17 East 16th Street, New York. THE OXFORD IAPS. By Prof. H. S. OSBORN, LL.D. Palestine, Egypt, Western Asia, St. Paul's Travels, Covering all Biblical Geography. Accepted authority among students. Address OXFORD MAP PUBLISHERS, OXFORD, OHIO. . ; Mixture. | A GENTLEMAN’S SMOKE. ns won’t know the lux “Smoking until you use ar A two-oz. trial package, postpaid, for 25 cts. MARBURG BROS., The American Tobacco Co., Successor, Baltimore, Ma. of ale Wells’s Mathematical Series. The Students’ Series of English Classics. 34 Volumes Ready. The Students’ Series of Latin Classics. 22 Volumes Ready. Our Catalogue of School and College Text-Booke sent on application. Correspondence cordially invited. Leach, Shewell & Sanborn New York. Boston. Chicago. NEW EDITION. ELEMENTS OF ASTRONOIIY. By Sir R. S. Batu, LL.D., F.R.S., Andrews Professor of Astronomy in the ‘University of Dublin, Royal Astronomer of Ireland. -With 136 Wood-cuts. (TExT-BooKs OF Scrence.) Thoroughly revised. 12mo. $2. LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., PUBLISHERS, 91-93 Fifth Avenue, New York. ATTENTION! 7th REG. N. Y. S. N. G, I a Bwintca’s Hist. ¢o the , 501 » BVO, ions, ra N. Y., '86, for factions and ‘Promin $8; and Reco Events in the History of of the 7th, by i + omy Sergeant (John Mason), 206 a8 CL van, Bookseller, 174 Paion Sb We West | way, N OLD, BOOKS, > swe ros ure J. CRAWFORD. 312 N. 7th 8t., St. Louis, Mo, BACK Jnocstate wants to Aunaicsy Macazirs EXCHANGE, Building, St. Louis, Mo.

Page 23

April 29, 1897] The Nation.

NEW BOOKS AND RECENT EDITIONS.

SCIENCE. Introduction to Botany. A practical book on the laboratory plan. By V. M. Spatoine, Professor of Botany, Univ. of Michigan. a MEE wie vandascushtnncxncdacsaduds suds dadarsengatactcctesaascerhs cetues Practical Methods in Micrascony. Gives detailed methods that lead to successful results. ~ U. H. Cuark, A.M. Illustrated. oan pages...... Evia ghedketudvabetdOetroneksuxeccqeeswtens Jdevbasonnes<an) ces Laboratory Manual in Biadiditucy Biology. For inductive study. By E. R. Boyer, Lecturer in Biology, Univ. of Chicago. 4 Physical Laboratory Manual. Covers college-entrance re- quirements. By H. N. Caure, author of “ Practical Physics.” Illustrated. NOR cx caus Aeaetakedintsturesstchebendce denvieverenccncakunnekuat’ .80 Whiting’s Physical Measurement. Intended for colleges and high schools. preparing students for civil, mechanical. and electrical en- gineeriog. surveying. astronomical work, chemical analysis, physical in- vestigation, and other branches of art and science in which accurate mea surements are required. Parts I.-IV. in one vol. 1242 pages........ $3.75 Whiting’s [Mathematical and Physical Tables. With oye. BRCIONE,. TAC PARE. PRIOR. bcc ciccccicccctussccevcccecscessevecscecs Inorganic Chemistry. Dascriptive and Qualitative. By James H. Smeparo. Illustrated. 397 pagesS.......cscceceseccsseecers $1.12 Remsen’s Organic Chemistry. An introduction to the study of the compounds of carbon. For all students of pure chemistry or of its application to the arts, medicine, etc. 374 PageS........-csereeeeees $1.20 A Short History of Chemistry. By F. P. VenaBLz, ~ Dp. Prof. of Chemistry. Univ. of N.C. 171 pages........c.sesseceeeeceens Colton’s Practical Zoology. A clear exposition of the aon as a whole by the careful study of typical animals. A laboratory manual prepared on the pla: of helping the student to help himself. Cloth, 196 DO bv edeccotade ofan cuNesdteggsacacdse eeeevont sss abevensnesssenvebes -80 Crosby’s Common [linerals and Rocks. Contains descriptions and tests of ali the common varieties. Lilustrated. Cloth, 200 pages. .60 Shaler’s First Book in Geology. A text- aioe with all the

interest of astory. Cloth, 272 pages.......ccsccscccccsocsccssecsece $1.00

Roberts’s Development and Present Aspects of Stereo- Chemistry. A contribution to chemical theory. 160 pages........ $1.00 Laboratory Course in Physiological Psychology. By E. C. S.yForp. Assistant Professor of Psycnology in Clark University. Part T. Cloth. 188 pages..........0. Sachin Nddusuwksascvadaydcceancusceesacesses -90 The Psychology of Childhood. By Frepertckx Tracy, Lec- turer in Philos »phy in the University of Toronto, with Lntroductioa by Presi- dent G. Srax~ey Hatt. Cioth, 183 pages.........cscceccceccccccee-cce 90 Manual of Empirical Psychology. An authorized translation from the German of Dr.G@ A. Linpner, by President CoaRLes De Garmo of Swarthmore ee COOG,. BIS POGOG. is 56 oho 5 Socscicdccvesocses 1.00 Apperception: A Monograph on Paychology and Pedagogy. By Dr. Kart Lange. Translated by members of the Herbart Club. and edited by CUHarLes De Gaumo, President of Swarthmore College. Cloth, SEW DOG va vacazevncs secdexcddddqucutiavacthedanveetbeccuuneseesasaeede 1.00 Psychology Applied to Education. By Gisrrec Compayrre. Translated by Wm H. Payne, Chancellor of the University of Nashville. READ MUNN Ax ccbunisdimaucchenadetshacuddrcakectnenduauveveeedegyeds -90 Habit in Education. An essay in pedagogical psychology. Translated from the German of Rapestocg, by F A. Caspar, with an In- troduction by President @. Stantey Hatt of Clark University. Cloth, 124 -75 The Connection of Thought and Memory. By Herman T. LUKENS, Honorary Fellow in Psychotogy in Clack University. — on Dorpfeld’ 8 * Denken und Gedachtnis,.” Cioth. 169 pp........eeeeeeee 1.00 Principles of Political Economy. By Cuaarves Gipz, Professor in the Univ. of Montpellier, France. With Intro- duction by J. B. Cuark, Professor in Colunbia College. 598 pages. $2.00. Prof. E. A. Ross. Leland Stanford Univ. : “Beyond a doubt the best text- book for advanced classes in Political Economy that [ have seen in English.” Prof W. I Hutt, Swarthmore College : ** I have used several text-books in Economics in my classes and am famiiiar with numerous others. | have no hesitation in expressing my opinion that Gide’s is superior to ail others,”

Send for Catalogue, announcing many other new books in this department. D. C. HEATH & CO., Publishers, Boston, New York, Chicago.

JOHN WILEY & SONS.

Some Recent Publications on Physics, Chemistry, and Applied Science.

Descreptive Circulars sent upon application. Anthony, Brackett, and Magie—Text-Book of PI Ss eck peewee REN ogee waa teta ate 8vo, $4 00 Crehore and Squier—Experiments with a New Polarizing Photo-Chronograph........ 8vo, 3 00 Morgan—The Theory of Solutions and its Re- ss ces keuee Tie Soule cx deena ve ...12mo, 1 00 Helm-—Morgan — Principles of Mathematical EN ores ovate eek tdek es 12mo, 1 50 Gill—Gas and Fuel Analysis............ 12mo, 1 25 Mason—Water Supply................... 8vo, 5 00 Adriance—Laboratory Calculations...... 12mo, 1 25 Austen—Notes for Chemical Students....12mo, 1 50 Wilson—Cyanide Processes........ .12mo, 1 50 Spencer — Sugar Manufacturers’ Handbook, 12mo, Wilson—Manual of Irrigation Engineering .8vo, 2 00 4 00

Fuertes—Water and Public Health..... i2mo, $1 50 Hazen—The Filtration of Public Water Sup- a See nee ee er ie ee rare et Pee 8vo, 2 00 Robinson—Principles of Mechanism...... 8vo, .3 00 Ricketts and Miller—Notes on Assaying. .8vo, 3 00 Merrill—Stones for Building and Decoration, 8vo, 5 00 Hutton — Mechanical Engineering of Power Plants....... PP Ep ee EL 8vo, 5 00 Johnson — Materials of Cemmdies Besos 8vo, 6 00 Westermaier-Schneider—General Botany 8vo, 2 00 Du Bois—Stresses in Framed Structures. .4to, 10 09 Brush and Penfield—Determinative Mineralo- SEE ETE Pre eT ere Re ery .....-8v0, 3 50 Chester - the Names of seein 8vo, 3 00

JOHN WILEY & SONS, 53

East Tenth St., New York.

Page 24

mnt psu The Nation. OFFICE OF THE H Atlantic Mutual} INSURANCE COMPANY, New York, January 21, 1897. The Trustees, in conformity with the Charter of the Company, submit the following State- ment of its affairs on the p1st of December, 1896: Premiums op Marine Risks from Ist January, 1896, to 3ist December. 1896, $2,596,788 89 Premiums on Policies not marked off Ist January, 18V6....... ......eceeeeeees 1,109,275 00 Total Marine Premiums................++ $3,706,063 89 Premiums marked off from Ist January, 1896, to 3ist December,1896........... $2,658,108 58 Losses paid during the same period............ $1,249,999 01 Returns of Pre- miums and , Expenses. ...$446,420 25 The Company has the following Assets, viz.: United States and City of New York Stock; City Banks and other Stocks ... $7,226,305 00 Loans secured by 8 ocks and otherwise. 1,930,000 00 Real Estate and Claims due the Compa- WP; GRURMRNESE OE. oc crccdccsevcesvscnsacce 1,137,621 97 Premium Notes and Bills Receivable.... 843 596 96 SION TR AE is nse ocnenisccsncscccncvencs 175,229 25 ARBOR, 0 ccvcnncscccvcesnssccceessecscoes $11,312,753 18 Six per cent, interest on the outstanding certificates of profits will be paid to the holders thereof, or their legal representatives, on and after Tuesday,the second of February next. The outstanding certificates of the issue of 1891 will be redeemed and paid to the holders thereof, or their legal representatives, on and after Tuesday, the second of February next, from which date all interest thereon will cease. The certificates to be produced at the time of payment, and cancelled. A dividend of FORTY PER CENT. ts declared on the net earned premiums of the Company for the year end- ing 31st December, 1896, for which certificates will be issued on and after Tuesday, the fourth of May next. By order of the Board, J. H. CHAPMAN, Secretary. TRUSTEES, W.H.H. Moore, Lawrence Turnure,Joseph Agostini, A. A. Raven, John L. Riker, Vernon H. Brown, Jos. H. Chapman, C, A. Hand, Leander N.Lovell, James Low, John D. Hewlett, Everett Frazar, Jas. G. DeForest, Gustav Amsinck, Wm. B. Boulton, William Degroot, N.Denton Smith, Geo. W. Quintard, Wiliam H. Webb, Chas. H. Marshall, Paul L. Thebaud, Horace Gray, Chas D.Leverich, George Coppell, C.de Thomsen, Edw’d Floyd-Jones, Gustav H.Schwab Chas P. Burdett, George H. Macy, Francis M. Bacon. Henry E.Hawley, Waldron P. Brown. Wm. E. Dodge, Anson W. Hard, W. H. H. MOORE, President. A. A. RAVEN, Vice-President. F, A. PARSONS, 2d Vice-President. French and German BOOKS. The latest French and German Books Are promptly imported and kept for sale. All Standard Works continually in stock, Write for new list of late Fiction. BRENTANO’S, 31 Union Square, New York. Old and Rare Books. CATALOGUE NO. 8 Just issued, sent on application. THE BOOKSTALL, Harry Falkenau, Prop., 101 Madison St., Chicago. UTOGRAPH AND BOOK-PLATE Collectors: Send for sample of “ The Collector.” ALTRR Romeve Bensamin. .195 Broadway, N V. Cite WILLIAMS, 25 EASTI10TH ST., N. Y., Dealer in M ines and - cals, Bets, volumes, or single numbers. nee Noenol) Constable Koo, ~WOOLENS FOR MEN’S WEAR. English Trouserings, English and Scotch Suitings, Venetians, Covert Coatings, Unfinished Worsteds. Spring Overcoatings. Whipcords for Riding Breeches. Bicycle and Golf Suitings. GLOVES. Men’s Driving, Riding and Street Gloves. UMBRELLAS. Proodevary LK ‘ 9th ot. NEW YORK. House at Buy Ridge | BR Fowler & Hough, Archth NY. | ~ e | Prim Paint || may do for clapboards, but its opaque coming spoils the artistic effect of shin- gles. | Cabot’s Creosote | Shingle Stains | color the shingles (in soft, velvety moss- green, bark-browpn, and silver-gray tones) without hiding the wood grain, and each sbingle looks as if it grew that color. 50 % cheaper than paint. || Statned-wood ples and color studies sent on | | request. | |, SAMUEL CABOT, Sole Manufacturer, 71 Kilby St.. Boston, Mass. AGENTS AT ALL CENTRAL POINTS. ELLIS & ELVEY, Dealers in Old and Rare Books. CATALOGUES OF CHOICE BOOKS AND ILLUMI- NATED MANUSCRIPTS published periodically. Rare Early English Literature, Early Printed books in sudautagenphecre Only aneepenmeaete ecw “OS NEW BOND SUREET, LONDON, We” F. W. CHRISTERN (DYRSEN & PFEIFFER, Successors), 254 Sth Ave., between 28th and 29th Sts , New York, Importers of Fure Books: Agents for the leading Pars rublishers; Tauchnitz’s British Authors, Teub- ner’s Greek and Latin Classics. Catalogues of stock on demand. New books received from Paris and Leipzig as soon ag issued. “ Scientific Kite-Flying,”’ described by three experts. A Chapter Seas of Secret ee os through History, by the Dolomites,” by Gen. Schofeld. Col. Geo. E. Waring. — “ “A Suburban Family = Country Greece.” Place,” ones illus. “ Crete, the Island of Discord.” Stories, Etc., Ete. = AMERICAN COLONIAL TRACTS MONTHLY NUMBER ONE May 1897 DISCOURSE CONCERNING THE DESIGNED ESTABLISHMENT OF A NEW COLONY TO THE SOUTH OF CAROLINA, IN THE MOST DELIGHT- FUL COUNTRY OF THE UNIVERSE, BY SIR ROBERT MOUNTGOMRY, BARONET, LONDON, 1717. PRICE 25 CENTS $3.00 A YEAR. Published by GEORGE P HUMPHREY ROCHESTER N Y LIBRARIES Library Catalogue Mailed Free. LISTS PRICED GRATIS. THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO., Wholesale Books, 5 & 7 East 16th St., New Vork. FRENCH BOOKS “es: 3 icn. i NEW YORK Complete Catalogue on arovlicatton / = 100 000 VOLUMRS IN STOCK mast = Send Son pusnlogae No. 119. OC ) Ww r-adyv. E JOSEPH McDONOUGH, 63 and 66 State Street, ALBANY, N. Y.

Page 25

_ April 29, 1897] The Nation. vii Houghton, Mifflin & Company’ s N E Ww B O O K S he Wisdom of Fools By Mrs. DELAND, author of ‘John Ward, Preacher,” ‘ Sidney,” ‘‘Philip and His Wife,” ‘‘Mr. Tommy Dove,” ‘“*The Old Garden,” etc. 16mo, $1.25. A book of four striking stories dealing with situations and problems of great and imme- diate interest. They are marked by the strong good sense, the resolute purpose to straighten out some of the tangles of life, and the fine humor and literary felicity which character- ize all of Mrs. Deland’s stories. iss Archer Archer By Ciara LovuIsE BURNHAM, author of ‘*The Wise Woman,” ‘Sweet Clover,” ** Tbe Mistress of Beech Knoll,” ‘‘ Next Door,” ete. 16mo, $1.25. Mrs. Burnham’s large circle of readers will gladlv welcome this new and thoroughly in- teresting story. Tbe scene is partly on the coast of Maine, partly at an old ‘ before the- war’ homestead in Virginia. Some chapters take in Fortress Monroe, Hygeia H«tel, and Washington. emories of Hawthorne A delightful book, by his daughter, RosE HAWTHORNE LATHRuP. With a new portrait of Hawthorne. Crown 8vo, gilt top, $2.00. Transatlantic Chate- laine A NOVEL. By HELEN CHOATE PRINCE, author of ‘‘The Story of Christine Roche- fort.” Second Edition. 16mo, $1.25. he Spirit of an Illinois Town, and The Little Renault Two Stories by MARY HARTWELL CATHER- woop, author of ‘‘The Lady of Fort St. John,” ‘‘The Chase of St. Castin,” ‘Old Kaskaskia,” etc. 16mo, $1.25. The Day of His Youth A NOVEL. By ALIice Brown, author of ‘‘Meadow Grass,” ‘‘ By Oak and Thorn,” ete. 16mo, $1.00. Sold by Booksellers. Sent, postpaid, by HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO. BOSTON 11 East 17th Street, New York A COMMAND OF FRENCH, GERMAN, SPANISH, Acqu red by practising according to HOW TO THINK IN FRENCH, $1. eee TO THINK IN GERM MAN . $1. OW TO THINK Iv SPANISH, °51 50. By Prof. me... F. KROEH of Stevens Teetiyute of Techno- logy, Hoboken, N. J For class-room or self- instruction. At your bookseller’s or from the Author. of New Yo vy James B ARGAIN. Grant Wil x4 Ato, aggregating 2.729 panes, 22 full- cage asta 64 full: page engravings, 1 $ maps, 1,149 illustrations in text. A brand new set for - (Published at $30). A.S. GuaRK. 174 Fulton St.. Sete re, Edited of im City THE NEW AND ENLARGED EDITION OF Johnsons Universal Cyclopaedia Covers the whole round of Science, Literature, Art, History, Politics, Philosophy, Theology, Medicine. Law, &c., under about 50,000 titles, and is at once Scholarly, Authoritative, and Up-to- Date, because (1) Each DEPARTMENT was in charge of aSPECIAL EDITOR, recognized every where as an Authority; and (2) The articles were written for it by eminent Scholars and Specialists who signa their names to their articles. The information thus given is not only the result of the latest re- search, investigation, and discovery; it is authoritative. The object throughout has been to provide a Trustworthy Work of Reference, suited to the scholar, the professional man, the school-teacher, the business man, and the home. There were THIRTY SIX of these DEPARTMENT EDITORS, and nearly three thou- sand contributors. It contains 7,264 extra royal octavo pages, 130 colored Maps, including plans of the chief citics of North America and Europe, and over 3,000 Engravings, and is printed from new and larger type than that used in former editions. Dr. WILuiaM T. Harris, U. 8S. Commissioner of Education. says “ The new edition [of Johnson’s Cyclopedia is a decided advance in cyclopzedia making,” and *dds: “A se of this work ought to be fouad in the bands o every teacoer, and the pupils ought to be taught how to use 1.’ President D.C. Gruman of Johns Hopkins University says: ., Thoroughness is its marked characteristic. American scholarship may be proud of this achievement. JOHN FISKE says: “I believe it to be incomparably the best cyclopzedia in the English language.” Prest. BanJsMIN ANDREWS of Browao University says it “is a work of the highest character, accurate, of wide range, and up to date. Itis one of the best works, if not the very best extant, for reacy reference upon great topica, pet and present, of human knowledge and interest. Many of its articies are the best that caa be consulted tn English, or in any language.” THE INDEPENDENT says that “in the best sense it is an American work developed on a distinct plan of its own, and every ar.icie written independently for it it a OuTLOOK says: “It is the best boo« of its kind for general use in the American home, office, and ra THe Eprror oF Boog N >T&s says that “n> similar book ever published ta this cou *try equals the new John- ag in meth Ss aad none wa; ever pubiished superior t» it in detail; all taosa now on the market are infinite- y inferior to it.’ Send a Fvvatentes and eae Pages. D. APPLETON & COMPANY, 72 Fifth Ave., New York. ‘TWO N OTABLE SUCCESSES - By BEATRICE HARRADEN. Hilda Strafford. A California Story. By Beatrice Har- RADEN, author of ‘‘ Ships that Pass in the Night.” With Illustrations by Eric Pape. 12mo, cloth, $1.25. This is the first novel Miss Harraden has writ- ten since her memorable “Ships that Pass in the Night.” It is a story of Californian Life. By PAUL L. FORD. The Great‘K.& A.’ Train Robbery By PavuL LEICESTER ForD, author of “The Honorable Peter Stirling,” ‘* The Story of an Untold Love,” etc., ete. } 12mo, cloth, with frontispiece, $1 25. A novel that is admirable reading, for it issure to rouse the interest of the most listless reader, and to keep him on tenter-hooks to the happy Miss Harraden, ouring ending, when all the | her sojourn in the West, my3tery and complica has been much impress- tions are satisfactorily 5 t ed by the homesickness settled. The story is t of those who have entitled The Great” K. 1 000 sought to create a new & A.” Train Robbery. It ft 000 9 nian ranches. The for- ing up of the K. & A. lcrn feeling that over train has no parallel in takes the exile; the quickened sense of remem- all railroad history. The story is admirably bered joys, intensified by the imagination amid told, and the exciting incidents that follow the loneliness of the life; the self-sacrificing toil the “hold-up” move almost as rapidly as an of years—out of materiais like these Miss Harra- express train. It is bound to be widely and ap- home and fairer pros- is, of course, a tale of pects out on the Califor- the West, and the hold- den bas con+tructed a tragic tale of vivid power preciatively read. iI and fresh interest. 1| | The above Books are for sale by all Booksellers, or will be sent, on receipt of their retail price, by the Publishers, _Dodd, Mead & Pay 149-151 Firra Ave. | NEW YORK.

Page 26

Tae Se eke SU SNE SE Se eS ea ATE va *t viii | The Nation. [Vol. 64, No. 1661 | | | THE PUBLISHERS OF LIPPINCOTT’S MAGAZINE ARE OFFERING TO THE PUBLIC THAT INVALUABLE REFERENCE LIBRARY, CHAMBERS’s ENCYCLOPAEDIA (1897 Edition), In connection with the magazine. The first payment of one dollar secures the complete set at once, together with the Magazine for twelve months. You pay the balance practically at your leisure, as it only takes about 10 cents a day. Through this liberal offer you have the opportunity of placing in your home a most popular Magazine of recognized high rank, and an Encyclopedia of superior merit. This 1897 Edition ““THE LATEST AND BEST, THE STANDARD BOOK OF REFERENCE WHEREVER THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE IS KNOWN.” ve ce wi =z is the only genuine . de CHAMBERS’S = LEE ENCYCLOPAEDIA, \ and is now sold exclusively by =H : AMBER amar a ZAZA ze i eY GiamacrstiCuy z cr cworchticeeatiien for Wun T vou AMBER CHANGER Cpe Paes: subscription. | wou | VOL.IVAT Vor : 1 WV. we eva at be VOLYnLT vo i | Sry be ws. fi. f OLX Vot.x. % Mh eats cs Wein R . \ > t ‘ mon 7 e7 | $ 1.00 | atl —_ NEW Eoin ep * 7 zs RGU Sere eros Oe Oe ie eae ee ae) Secures the Set “4 — — —_ 4 | : = —= ~ 7 ADs BINDINGS ARE tz EXTRA CLOTH, HALF LEATHER, WHAT EVERY ONE NEE RCA TO KNOW - BO On See FULL LEATHER. MAY BE FOUND WITHIN ITS COVERS. a TH I Ss G RE AT WORK consists of ten large octavo volumes, containing over 30,000 Articles, about 100 Double-Page Colored Maps ve and Charts (up-to-date), 250 Full-Page Engravings, 3,500 Superior Illustrations in the Text, 17,600 Columns of Reading Matter, about 9,000 Pages, and 11,000,000 Words. Over 1,000 Scholarly Contributors. International in Character. Thoroughly revised by English and American editors up to date of printing. The entire range of human knowledge is comprehended in its scope. Its subjects embrace THE ARTS, BIOGRAPHY, HISTORY, GEOGRAPHY, MECHANICAL ARTS, NATURAL HISTORY, THEOLOGY, ARCHITECTURE, SCIENCE, ASTRONOMY, LAW, MEDICINE, CHEMISTRY, ELEC- TRICITY, EXPLORATION, Efc., ETC. ‘ i ’ No steps backward, but a long step forward has been the aim of the editors and publishers of th's New Edition. IT I S TH E BE ST. All subjects are easily found, information ise easily ascertained, and the meaning is easily understood. 205 eaten COMPREHENSIVENESS, Smspuicity, Accuracy, aND ExceLuesce have been the aim of the editors. Mere verbiage is scrupulously avoided. When twelve words are sufficient to describe an article, twelve words only are used; if a whole chapter is neces- sary, a whole chapter is given. THIS WORK adequately treats scientific or otber subjects of a high nature, and likewise contains the practical knowledge generally sought for. BEAR IN MIND these volumes are mechanically perfect, and are beautifully printed from new plates on asuperior quality of book paper, clear new type, handsomely and durably bound, stamped in pure gold leaf, and, in a word, bear throughout the marks of artistic bookmaking. SHOWING HOW L ATE IT Is New York World.—‘ It is one of the most valuable works of reference ot e in existence.”’ : New York School Journal.—‘ The scholarly character of the new edi- A few of the many new subjects to be found ia this EDITION: Roentgen. McKinley and Hobart. Electrocution adopted by Ohio, July 1, 1896. Dr. Nansen. Cuban Revolution. Horseless Carriage. The New Greater Republic of Central America Rudyard Kipling. recognized by Prest. Cleveland, Dec. 23, 1896. The X-Rays. Etc., Etc. tion is apparent to all, placing the work ia the highest rank ” London Daily Chron cle.—‘* We have. cousulted it constantly, with in- creasing admiration for its uniform accuracy.” Glasgow Mail.—" It is a thoroughly practical book, suited to the wants of the great mass of readers, and itis easy of reference. To go for some particular fact to certain pretentious works is | ke searching in the pro- verbial haystack for a needle ; in Chambers’s we get the facts at once.” THIS IS OUR OFFER. On the first payment of $1.00, the entire set of 10 beautiful volumes, bound in Extra Cloth, will be forwarded at once, the balance to be paid at the rate of $3.00 monthly for thirteen months, or about 10 cents a day. The work will be supplied in fine Half Leather for $2.00 first payment, and $4 00 in twelve monthly payments. At the time of making your first payment please desigaate the kind of binding you desire, and indicate how you wish the volumes shipped. Charges for delivery must be paid by thesubscriber. Remember, the complete set is sent you when the first payment is received, and you therefore have the use and benefit of the volumes during the time you are paying for them. LIPPINCOTT’S MAGAZINE, 715-717 Market St., Philadelphia, Pa.