The Nation 1896-07-02: Vol 63 Iss 1618

Page 1

The Nation VOL. bnimacauiiiicolmad 161 8. THURSDAY, ‘JULY 2 2, 1896. PRICE 1 10 CENTS, THE JULY NUMBER OF THE NORTH AMERICAN REVIEW CONTAINS: THE DECLARATION OF INDEPENDENCE IN THE LIGHT OF MODERN CRITICISM. By Moses Coit Tyler, Professor of History in Cornell University. RUSSIA AFTER THE CORONATION, : , Kart BLIND SOME INTERNATIONAL DELUSIONS, . . Tue Rev. Dr F. E. CLaRK, President of the Society of Christian Endeavor THE STEPCHILD OF THE REPUBLIC, ; j ; ; W. E. SMyTHE A COMMON COINAGE FOR ALL NATIONS, . ‘ Tue Hon. C. W. STonE THE TEACHER’S DUTY TO THE PUPIL. By Cardinal Gibbons. THE RIGHT OF PRIVACY, JouN GILMER SPEED CRIMINAL JURISPRUDENCE, ROMAN AND ANGLO. SAXON, THE MEXICAN MINISTER WHY WOMEN SHOULD HAVE THE BALLOT, | Tue Late GENERAL JOHN Gipson, U. S. A. SOUND MONEY THE SAFEGUARD OF LABOR, . Tue Hon. R. B. Manany PETTICOAT GOVERNMENT. Max O’Rell. With Comments by Mrs. Harriet Prescott Spofford and Mrs. Margaret Bottome, President of the International Order of King's Daughters and Sons. STORM TRACKS, : . =) , F. L. OswaLp A PRESIDENT OF NO IMPORTANCE, , Ww. B. McCrackan THE NECESSITY OF LIMITING RAILWAY COMPETITION, . H. T. Newcoms AMERICAN DIPLOMATS IN EUROPE, ; ; fia e CHATFIELD-T AYLOR 50 Cents a Copy; $5.00 a Year. Sold by all Newsdealers. THE NORTH AMERICAN REVIEW, 3 East 14th Street, New York.

Page 2

The Nation. [Vol. 63, No. 1618 The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science, and Art. FOUNDED 1865. [Entered at the New York City Post-Office as second-class maikmatter. CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. TE WRK, 2. oc cccecvtcccsssccscnnnccsccstosnedeseess cooe 1 EDITORIAL ARTICLES: The Issue of the Campaign. ...............ssseeseees 4 The New York Democratic Platform. 4 The Menace to Railroads.............. 5 The Canadian Ele cane parbidevnen dyes prevencedbeiaee 6 SPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE: OR RPUEE ES Tear ee Cer 6 nO THMRINONS OF TBO BLT, 6.00 ccesccdccevccvecsesses 7 CORRESPONDENCE: Minnesota and Sound Money.............ceseceeeees 9 International Arbitration,.............00..5+ oes Jobn Sparks, of Pike’s Expedition. 9 DROID. ciinccndesdngocsscacennecsecesudisncsesseeioececesss 10 Book REVIEWS: MOOI TARP OR OOO «005550000 s000sncr0ee0cc00s0s vacenes 13 The Merrymount Missel... .....ccccccservecccssccss (.. 14 ae = Badge of Gourens. —Maggie —George’s ie Ns coda hanhooteh4ocsdnpoabwensse\casesepenhsiesst Re ne Si ebes bednaanened son anes eee A Fauna of the Moray Basin The Roman See in the Early Church...... Memoirs of an Artist.—Charles Gounod. eee EEE SUE Ms nosy co bdedevercesinctocdcboseces ons DOOR CP TI Wes ocvccctecsecsvcccnsscsenapsccsecce 18 TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three Dollars per year, in advance, postpaid, to any part of the United States or Canada; to foreign coun- tries comprised in the Postal Union, $4 00. The date when the subscription expires is on the Ad- dress Label of each paper, the change of which to a sub- sequent date becomes a receipt for remittance. No other receipt is sent unless requested. Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter, or by check, express order, or postal order, payable to “ Publisher of the Nation,” When a change of address is desired, both the old and new addresses should be given. Address THE NATION, Box 794, New York. Publication Office, 208 Broadway. TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Fifteen cents per agate line, each insertion, 14 lines to the inch. Twenty per cent. advance for choice of page, top of column, or cuts, Cuts are not inserted on the first page. A column, $20 each insertion; with choice of page, $24. A page, $60 each insertion; front-cover page, $80. Adverti. ts must be ptable in every respect. Copy received until Tuesday, 5 P.M. DISCOUNTS. p34 “ “ 750 “ “ 1,000 r 7 1,500 * = 2,000 e ~ The NATION ts sent free to those who advertise in it, as long as advertisement continues. The EDITION of the Nation this week is 9,200 copies. The Subscription List is always open to the in- spection of advertisers. * Copies of the NATION may be procured in "Baris at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de l’Opera, and in oe of Rn F, ct 4 15 uare, American Newspaper Agency, 15 Kin Willings Street, Strand, W.C. er " London agent for Advertisements, R.J. Bush, 92 Fleet Street, E. C. Educational. CALIFORNIA, Belmont. ELMONT SCHOOL FOR BOYS, ~ the foothills, near San Lf meage ay al woe uipped conducted as a fitting school for th colleges = technical schools, It is lighted by 2 beat, cotleg and has every needful educational, sanitary, and recreative = Educational. MASSACHUSETTS, Auburndale (10 miles from Boston). A sees SEMINARY FUR YOUNG Women suggests to parents seeking a good school consideration Of of the Le pte 3 points in its methods: 1st. Its special care of hi Resident urse supervising work, diet, and exercise; d ‘00. pliance. The climate and surroundings o probably unsu: a but it is intended that the school shall be valued more for its educational advantages than for climate and natural beauty, and that it shall stimulate its boys to a better intellectual and spiritual life, and leave them a heri' of pleasant school memo- ries. The Catalogee f oes Pi es raduates, wil views of e Bchool and a oft ed ny ua =o idea of its apirit and and o oft the work it is Rep, A.M. (Harv. i nea Master. FORNIA, Los ‘Angeles, West 23d M4 RLBORO UGH SCHOOL rosy GIRLS. Mrs. GEorRGE A. CASWELL, Principal. CONNECTICUT, Old Lym OX WOOD ‘SCHOOL for Girls. Elective and College poeseretay. Special Ad- vantages in Art and Music. Separate Department for girls under twelve. Mrs. RICHARD SILL GRISWOLD. CONNECTICUT, Ridgefiel HE MISSES PIN TON’ S SCHOOL FOR GIRLS. Will reopen Monday, October 5. ConnEcTicUT, Waterbu Ls MARGARET”. S DIOCESAN Boarding and Day School for Girls reopens Sept. 23, 1896. Twenty-second year. The Rev. Francis T. Rus- sell, D. D., Rector. Miss Mary R. Hillard, Principal. — DELAWARE, ., Wilmington, Franklin § Street. ae MISSES HEBB’S ENGLISH, ench, and German Boarding and Day School for a... rtadies and girls reopens Sept. 24, 1895. DisTRIcT OF COLUMBIA, Washington. é ‘HEV Y CHASE French and English Ronzding a4 Day School for Young Ladies —Half an hour from Washington, D.C., by electric cara. French the language of the house. Reopen s Oct. 1, 1896. Ad- dress Mile. L&a Boutieny, P.O. Station E. ILuno1s, Chicago (Opposite Cook Co. Hospital.) OLLEGE OF PHYSICIANS and SUR- geons of Chicago. Four zoos, graded course. The course of the first two years is ages | laboratory work, of the last two years largely clinical. The equipment of the College includes six-story laboratory and a hos- pital of 125 beds, in which all members of the senior class are assigned to duty and ie practical clinical ex- perience. The course of the College offers exceptional advantages to earnest studen Dr. WM. ALLEN Pusey, 1 108 State St., Secretary. ILLINOIS, Chicago, 479-481 Dearborn Avenue. ts “IRLS’ COLLEGIATE SCHO Twentieth year begins September 23. Prepares for college and gives special courses of stud aa For young ladies and children. Miss R S.Rice,A mn Prins Miss M.E. BEEDY, A.M. 2 ILuino1s, Chicago, 1500-4 Title and Trust Building, ‘“WICAGO COLLEGE OF LAW. Law DEPARTMENT OF LAKE FoREST UNIVERSITY. Two and three-year course. For further information, address the Secretary, BARRETT. MARYLAND, Baltimore, 122 and 124 W. Franklin St. DGEWORTH BOARDING and DAY _« School for ore. my A x ma BVRES September 24th, 1896. Rs. H. Principal. MARYLAND, Baltimore. OLLEGE OF PH YSICIANS AND Surgeons of Baltimore, . Send for a Catalogue. 'HOMAS OPIE, M.D., Dean. MARYLAND, Catonsville. : fet TIMOTHY'S SCHOOL, for Girls reopens September 23, 1896. Prepares for College. Heads of School: Miss M.C. CARTER, Miss S. R. CARTER. MARYLAND, Hagerstown. EE MAR COLLEGE AND Music AND ART CONSERVATORY for Young Women. Finest climate, beautiful grounds, elegant buildings on a hill, experienced faculty. Home com- forts, rare advant ages, reasonable rates non-sectarian. Send for Catalogue.' C. L. KEEDY, President. MASSACHUSETTS, Belm: HE BELMONT SCHOOL (FOUNDED 1889). Private bn Boarding School for Boys. ames for on College. B. F. HARDING, A.M., Headmaster. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 9 Appleton Street. OSTON NORMAL SCHOOL OF GYM- nastics—(Established in 1889 7 the late Mrs. Mary Hemmenway.) Eighth year will begin Sept. 29, Amy Morris Homans, Director. MASSACHUSETTS, Cottage City. ARTHA’S VINEYARD SUMMER Institute. a gg year begins July 13, 1896. Send for 80-page circular. WILLiAM A. Mowry, Pres., Hyde Park, Mass. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston. OSTON UNIVERSITY Law School. Address the Dean. Epmunp H. BENNETT, LL.D. ain good variety, and well cooked; early and long step; a eee furnished by Dr. Sar arvard; bowling alley and Seta Wome no Bos nish the best of teachers, including many specialists; with one hundred and twent; Pupils, a faculty of thirty. Four years’ course; in some things equal to college work; in others, planned rather for home and womanly life. Two studies required and two to be chosen from a list of eight or ten electives. One preparatory year. Spe- cial students admitted if eighteen years or over, or graduates of high schools. 3d. Its homelike air and character. Training in self-covernment; limited number (many declined every fall for lack of room), personal oversight in by wo manners, care of person, room, etc.; comforts not stinte 4th. Its handiwork and other unusual departments. Pioneer school in scientific egpemy | of Cooking, Mil- linery, eet: ete Business Law for Women, fome eee. Swimm Regular expense ter ‘school year $500. For illustrated catalogue, address rutaner 5 | Nation), 7. G. BRAGDON, Principal. MASSACHUSETTS, D OWDER PO iNT SCHOOL, —Prepares for Scientific School, College, or Business. Indi- vidual teaching. Elementary classes for young boys. Home and outdoor life. . B. Knapp, 8.B. (M.1.T.). MASSACHUSETTS, Easthampton. ssc SEMINAR Y.—-Academy r Boys. Prepares for any college orscientific school. ‘Fully equipped laboratories in Chemistry, Phy- sics, and_ Biology for training for Medical Schools. Fifty-sixth year opens September 10, 1896. Ww. GALLAGHER, Ph D., Principal. MASSACHUSETTS, Lowel', OGERS HALL.-A Home School for Girls and Young Women. Certificate admits to Smithand Wellesley Reopens October 1, Terms, $750. References: Mrs Alice Freeman Palmer, Mrs. Frederic T. Greenhalge. For further particulars, address Mrs. E. P. UNDERHILL, M.A., Principal. MASSACHUSETTS, Montval SHLEY HALL OME SCHOOL for —— ladies. Ten miles from Boston. Music, Art, and Languages. Thorough preparation for college. Miss W HiTTEMORE, Principal Montvale, Mass. MASSACHUSETTS, Waban WE WABAN SCHOOL. A Preparatory School for ae. Circulars will be sent on application CHARLES sk. FisH Principal. MASSACHUSETTS, Worcester (“‘ The Academic MY. IGHLAND MILITARY ACAD 4ist year. Best preparation for A ig Profes- sional, or Business Life. Healthful location. Careful selection and supervision of students. Small classes. JOSEPH ALDEN SHAW, A.M., Head Master. MASSACHUSETTS, Worcester, 66 West Street. OHN W. DALZELL’S PRIVATE School for Boys.—Prepares for College or Scientific School. Send for ait MIcHIGAN, Orchard ICHIGAN MILITAR Y ACADEMY. —20th year. Prepares for leading universities Graduates are now in Harvard, Yale, Princeton, Cor nell, and University of Michigan. New gymnasium 50x150 feet. Address COLONEL — Supt. New JERSEY, Engle WIGHT SCHOOL FOR GIRLS. 8th year. Preparation for College. Special courses, *Principals: Miss CREIGHTON, Miss FARRAR. NEw JERSEY, Summit. Near New York. HE KENT PLACE SCHOOL FOR Girls.—Principal, Mrs. Sarah Woodman Paul, late of Wellesley College. Modern methods. College preparation. Home com forts for boardi _e a W. Masig, President. NEw JERSEY, Trenton. UPUY SCHOOL FOR BOYS. ASchool for Boys backward in Studies. Only four boarding boys. Terms, $500 per = ie. ONTANYE, Master. New York, Kingston-on-Hudson. OLDEN HILL SCHOOL FOR BOYS, Classical, Scientific, and English Courses. JOHN M. Cross, A.M., Principal. New York, Newburgh-on-Hudson. IGLAR SCHOOL.—30 Boys.’ If you have a boy, send forapamphiet. Henry W. SIGLAR. New York City MPIRE THEA TRE DRAMATIC SCHOOL.—Associated with Mr.Charles Frohman’s sapue Theatre. Address Mr. NELSON WHEATCROFT, irector. New York Ciry, 80, = wD 84 East 57th Street. M ISS PEEBLES A MISS THOMPSON'S Boarding and Day School for Girls pRRE SAE inn poh aa asl

Page 3

sees 5h TF Soe selina? Ri sc teaa: eh ee Bates TESS July 2, 1896] The Nation. Educational. NEw YorK, Rochester. IVINGSTON PARK SEMINAR Y.— AChurch School for Girls. Prepares for College. 88th year Opens Sept. 17th, 1896. For circulars ad- dress Miss Georaia C. STONE, Principal. NEW YORK, Sing Sing on-Hudson. OUNT PLEASANT MILITARY ACADEMY.—A high grade school for boys. Fits for college and for business. 82d year. Library of 12,000 volumes. Reference, Hon. Joseph H. Choate. pm gaa F. BRUSIE, A.M., ARTHUR T. EMORY, A.B.. Prin- cipals. NEw YorK, Tarrytown on-Hudson. ’ OME INSTITUTE.—A Boarding and Day School for Girls. College preparation. Re- opens Sept. 17. Miss M. W. METCALF, Principal. Onto, Cincinnati. TSS ARMSTRONG’S SCHOOL FOR Girls, Liddesdale Place, Avondale. Family limit- ed. _ Circulars sent on application. PENNSYLVANIA, Mercersburg. ERCERSBURG COLLEGE. A first-class Academy for boys. Prepares for any college tn America, $250. Defies competition. Modern equipment. Scholarships. WILLIAM MANN IRVINE, Ph.D. (Princeton), President. PENNSYLVANIA, Ogontz, YWHELTENHAM MILITARY ACADE- my, on the summit of the Chelten Hills, 2 hours from New York, one-half hour from Philadelphia. Represented by 30 graduates in 6 leading colleges and scientific schools. $600. 26th year. JOHN C, RIcE, Ph.D., Ogontz, Pa. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, Chestnut Hill. RS. COMEGYS’ AND MISS BELL’S BOARDING AND DAY SCHOOL FOR GIRLS will reopen October 1. Students prepared for college. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, 1350 Pine Street, ISS ANABLE’S Boarding and Day School for Young Ladies. Estab. in 1848. Circu- lar on application. TENNESSEE, Nashville. ANDERBILT UNIVERSITY. Next session opens September 16 Full graduate as well as undergraduate courses. Ten Fellowshi for college graduates. Seven departments. Fully equipped laboratories and museums. WIL WILLIAMS, Secretary. Virainia, Amherst P. O, Z ENMORE HIGH SCHOOL.—Prepara- or”, to Higher Collages, West Point,and Annapo- lis. Will open Lo a 16, 1896. Address H. A, STRODE (U. Va.), Principal 4 Virainia, Richmond. ’CABE’S UNIVERSITY SCHOOL. —The thirty-second annual session of this School for Boys begins a 21,1896. Thorough preparation for University of Virginia, Yale, Harvard, US. Military and Naval Academies, and the leading Engineering Schools. Full staff. Boarding department strictly limited. For catalogue, address . GORDON McCaBE, Head Master. VirGInis, Staunton. TAUNTON MILITARY ACADEMY. A Military School for young men and boys, unsur- passed in course of study, thoroughness of equipment, and beauty of location. Handsome illustrated cata- logue on application. FRANCE, Paris. 7. MARGARET'S CHURCH SCHOOL, A French and American Scheol forGirls. French the language of the household. Autumn term opens October 1. Terms, $1 000a year. Address Miss JULIA H.C. Acty, 50 Avenue d’Jéna. = A teacher will conduct pupils from New Yurk to Paris in September. Address, untit Sept. 1, Miss Mary Davy, care Finch, Van Slyck & Young, St. Paul, Minn. HOWARD SEMINARY. A HOME SCHOOL FOR GIRLS, limited to fifty: cer- tificate aimits to colleges; offers thorough academic training with wide choice in electives (including Music, Art, and Languages); advantages for Home Culture; Library, Gymnasium, and Laboratory; location quiet, healthful, accessible; references in all parts of the country, Annual Announcement sent on application. Mr. and Mrs. R. W. GIFFORD, Principals, West Bridgewater, Plymouth Co., Mass. Miss Baldwin's School for Girls, Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania. Preparatory to Bryn Mawr College. Miss FLORENCE BALDWIN, Principal. Within five years more than fifty pupils have entered Bryn Mawr College from this school. Ce-tificate admits to Smith, Vassar, and Welles- ley. Diploma given in both General and College-Pre- Poraters Courses. Fine fireproof stone building. 25 acres utiful grounds. For circular address the Secretary. HE PEEK SKILL MILITARY ACA- ee me ¥. , a trated catalogue. Col. Locate Jnr ing Paes line Educational. NEw ENS LAND C2 NSERVATORY Founded in 1853 by EBEN TOURJEE. Music. Elocution. Modern Languages. Expert instruction from i yy grades to ighest artistic requirements. Oldest, largest, best. rospectus and calendar free. Franklin Square, Boston, lass. School of Drawing and Painting MUSEUM OF FINE ARTS, Copley Square, Boston, Mass. TWENTY-FIRST YEAR. The Fall Term will open Sept. 28, 1896. Instruction in drawing from the cast and from life, in painting and decorative design, and also in artistic anatomy and perspective. Principal instructors: F. W. Benson, E. C. Tarbell, and Philip Hale (Drawing and Painting),Mrs. William Stone (Decorative Design), E.W. Emerson (Anatomy), and A.K. Cross (Perspective). Pu- pils are allowed the free use of the galleries of the Mu- seum. For circulars giving detailed information, ad- dress Miss ELIZABETH LOMBARD, Manager. EUROPEAN SUMMER RESORT. INNSBRUCK, TYROL, AUSTRIA. 1,900 feet above the sea, with dry, bracing climate. CENTRE FOR COACHING TRIPS AND EXCURSIONS OF ALL KINDS. Fine University, Hospital, etc. HOTEL TIROL. Open all the year. CARL LANDSEE, Proprietor.. Large airy, sunny rooms; modern conveniences; superior cui- sine. Reduced rates in winter, Best references, Illus- trated pamphlets sent on application. QUINCY MANSION. The Quincy Mansion School for Girls. Will = at Quincy, Sept. 23. Regular courses; expe- rienced teachers; special attention paid to vocal and instrumental music; certificate admits to college; new school building; ctass-rooms on first floor; stairs few and easy; beautiful grounds—4 acres; view of Boston the harbor,and Massachusetts Bay: rooms high and light; Lyd ana steam heat,electric lights, open plumb- iog; 13 minutes’ ride from Boston. Send for prospectus to Dr. HORACE MANN WILLARD, Wollaston, Mass. THE Hotchkiss School LAKEVILLE, CONN. Prepares for the best colleges and scientific schools. The next year will begin Sept. 16, 1896. EDWARD G. COY, Head Master. CLARK UNIVERSITY, WORCESTER, MASS. SUMMER SCHOOL. Psychology, Biology, Pedagogy, and Anthropology. JULY 13-25. Seven Instructors give daily lectures or demonstra- tions. Ninety-six hours of coordinated work. Adapted teachers of all grades. Dr. G. Stanley Hall and CHILD Stupy a feature. Kindergarten Day, July 20. Address for Programme, LOUIS N. WILSON, Clerk. MORAVIANSEMINARY foWamee BETHLEGEM, PA. (Founded 1749.) For circulars ad- ress J.MAX HARK, D_D., Principal. (Normal Department of Expression and Physical Culture in charge of Lydia J Newcomb.) The Misses Hickok’s Boarding and Day School For Girls, near NEw York Ciry, will reopen October 1. Lectures by Professors in Columbia College. Morristown, New Jersey. Educational. University of Virginia CHARLOTTESVILLE, VA. Letters, Science, Engineering, Law, Medicine, Session begins 15th September. Mild climate. Excellent gymnasium. For catalogues address WM. M. THORNTON, LL.D., Chairman. Manual Training. PREE COURSES for TEACHERS, fitting for both Grammar and High School Work at the SLOYD TRAINING SCHOOL, established by Mrs, Quincy A. Shaw in Boston. Time for each course, October 1 to June 1. Address GUSTAF LARSSON, Principal, 39 North Bennet St., - - Boston, Mass. ST. AUSTIN’S SCHOOL, WEST NEW BRIGHTON, STATEN ISLAND, N. Y. Thirteenth yom. Thorough and successful prepara- tion for all colleges. Military system. Number of boys limited. Sixteen acres of playing flelds. Outdoor exer- cise compulsory. Gymnasium under the directorship of a fully qualified physical instructor. Beautiful grounds. Unbroken health record. For prospectus, address Rev. GEO. E. QUAILE, M.A., Head Master. TWENTY-FIFTH YEAR oF MISS GIBBONS’ SCHOOL FOR GIRLS New York City, 55 West 47th St. Mrs, SARAH H. EMERSON, Principal. Primary and Advanced Classes. Preparation for all Colleges. A few boarding scholars taken. Reopens Sept. 30, 1896. Rockford Collegefor Women Fall Term Opens Wednesday, Sept. 16, 1896. Classical and Science Courses, Excellent Preparatory School. paren = organized departments of Music and Art. Well-equipped Laboratories, Fine Gymnasium, Resident Physician. Memorial Hail enables students to reduce expenses. For cotalogyes, address PHEBE T. SUTLI TA] F, President, Lock Box 10, Rockford, II. Miss Mary E. Stevens College Preparatory Boarding and Day School, 221 West Chelten Ave., Ger- mantown, Philadelphia, Pa. Begins 28th year Sept. 30, with Mrs, J. FrEDERIc Dripps, Principal, Miss Mary E. Srevens, Honorary Principal. Fifteen pupils at Bryn Mawr College, 1896. Standard remains unchanged. THE PHILLIPS EXETER ACADEMY. The 114th year begins September 16, 1896 Eighty Scholarships awarded to students of high standing. For Catalogue and illustrated Supplement, address HARLAN P. AMEN, Principal, Exeter, N. H. PROSPECT HILL SCHOOL FOR GIRLS GREENFIELD, MASS. A thorough education with good home influence. Eztabli: 869. shed 186! Miss Ipa F. Foster, 2 Miss CAROLINE R. CLARK, § THE WALTON-WELLESLEY SCHOOL 2101 and 2103 Spruce Street, Philadelphia. For Girls. Possesses finest private peoperty in city. Boarding and day. 15th year. Academic, College-Pre- paratory,and Musica! Depts. For illus. catalogue and re- ferences, address Dr. and Mrs. JAMES R. DANFORTH. BRADFORD ACADEMY. Founded 1803. For the higher education of young women. Classical and scientific course of study. Also Preparatory and Optional. Year begins Sept. 16, 1896. Apply to da C. Allen, Prin., Bradford, Mass. THE CAMBRIDGE SCHOOL, a select private school for girls. Preparation for col- lege. ong gs not leading to college Comforts of home. r. ARTHUR GILMAN is the Director, Cam- bridge, Mass. T. JOHN’S SCHOOL. MANLIUS, N.Y. Next term begins September 16, 1896. Apply to __ WM. VERBECK. Principals. IRVING INSTITUTE FOR BOYS, Tarrytown-on-Hudson, N. Y. 25 miles from N. Y. City. 4ist year begins in September. Summer term. J. M. FURMAN, A.M., Prin. A AGNES’ SCHOOL, Albany, N. Y.— Under the direction of Bishop Doane. 27th year. Miss ELLEN W. BoD, Principal. © COLLEGIATE INSTITUTE, Fort Edward, N. Y. For Young Women, 39th year Sept. 22. Six courses and Prep., Mus, Art, Elocu., Sten., $350. Jos, E. King, Pres.

Page 4

oe 1 mr A lV The Nation. [Vol. 63, No. 1618 THE DOCTRINE OF FEVER. Dr. Burpon-SaNDERSON, University of Oxford. APPLICATIONS OF ELECTRICITY. Dr. H. Lewis Jones, In Charge of Elect. Dept., DIET AND THERAPEUTICS OF GENBRAL PATHOLOGY OF St. Bartholomew's Hospital. MASSAGE. Dr. Kears.tey MITCHELL, University of Pennsylvania. The spectalist’s knowledge of his chosen subject; instruction by Professors in the best medical schools in the world, and the expe- rience of physicians in the best hospitals in the world, unite in CHILDREN. DIGESTION. Dr. Eustace Sutra, Dr. CoaRLes HENRY RALFE, East London Hospital for Children. London Hospital. DISEASES OF THE STOMACH Dr. LaupER Brunton, Editor of “The Practition- er,” etc., and Others. ' MALARIA. aces «ge gram A PATHOLOGY OF THE BLOOD. Johns Hopkins University. e e Prof. MicHagt Foster, University of Cambridge. PATHOLOGY OF INFECTION. YS em O e 1Cl Drs. KLEIN SMALLPOX. and KanTmack. BY MANY WRITERS. Dr. JoHN Macomste, Supt. Smallpox Hospital, INPLUENZA. EDITED BY : Dr. GoopHart, Guy's Hospital. Dr. J. F. Payne, 8t. Thomas's Hospital, MENTAL DISBASES. Dr. SavaGEe and Others. DISEASES OF THE LUNGS. Dr. Ewart, Dr. Pyg-Smita, De: Bast Reo, T.C. ALLBUTT, M.D., F.R.S., Dr. ARLIDGE, Cambridge. Dr. Kineston Fow er, Dr. Goopmart, and THOMAS CLIFFORD ALLBUTT, M.A,M.D., LL.D., F.R.C.P., F.R.8., F.L. DISEASES OF THE SKIN the University of Cambridge, etc NOW READY. and Others. VOL. 1. PROLEGOMENA AND INFECTIOUS DISEASES. Complete in Five Quarterly Volumes, beginning July, 1896. Medium 8vyo. Price, cloth, UNIFORM WITH THE ABOVE: A SYSTEM OF GYNA:COLOGY. EDITED BY Professor of Physic in the University of and Professor of Cones Medicine in Kings Two Volumes, medium 8vo. Cloth, $5.00 each; Half Russia, $6.00 each. Limehouse, London. Contributing to the F.S A., Regius Professor of Physic in SYSTEM OF GYNAZCOLOGY. Henry GERvIs, Consulting Physician, St. Thomas's Hospital. Epwarp Matins, M.D , Birmingham General Hos- pital. $5.00; half russia, $6.00. Sir W. O. Priest.ey, Consulting Physician, Kings College Hospital. ALEX. SmmpPson, Professor of Midwifery, University of Edinburgh. W. S. PLAYFAIR, M.D., F.R.C.P., Wu. J. Smyzty, Master, Dr. Norman Moore. Sold by subscription only. Rotunda Hospital, A Prospectus of the entire Series will be sent free — to any address on application to Send for Prospectus. THE MACMILLAN COMPANY, Publishers, 66 Fifth Avenue, New York. NOW READY. 470, CLOTH EXTRA, GILT TOP. Price, $18.00. The Fundus Oculi. With an Ophthalmoscopic Atlas, BY W. ADAMS FROST, F.R.C.S, Containing about fifty full-page plates in coler, besides many illustrations in the text. CONTENTS. INTRODUCTION. PART I. PHYSIOLOGICAL VARIATIONS. The Normal Fundus: The Optic Disc; The Retinal Vessels; The Macula Lutea; Developmental Irregularities. PART Il. PATHOLOGICAL CONDITIONS. Affections of the Choroid; Optic Neuritis or Papillitis; Neuro-Retinitis, and Retinitis; Optic Atrophy; Affections of the Vascular System of the Retina; Punctate Conditions of the Fundus; Pigment Changes in the Retina; De- tachment of the Retina. INDEX. NOW READY: the Authorized English Edition in one vol, royal Svo, pb. xxviii, 1208, elegantly bound in buckram, top edges gilt. Price, $10.50. The Histopathology of the Diseases of the Skin. By Dr. P. G. UNNA. Translated from the German with the assistance of the author by Norman Watker, M.D-, F.R.C.P.Ep., assistant physician in dermatology to the Royal Infirmary, Edinburgh. With double coloured plate containing nine- teen illustrations and forty-two additional illustrations in the text. Prof. DUHRING in the AMERICAN JOURNAL OF SCIENCE. “ The work is fresh, and deals with the latest discoveries and observations.” “New paths and fields have not only been staked out, but are occupied by him.” “An unknown territory in the pathology of the skin has been cultivated, and, moreover, on such a comprehensive scale as to dwarf completely all other former attempts by authors in thesame direction.” ‘“ Literature has been greatly enriched by the production of this work, which for many years to come will be regarded as authoritative on the histopathology of the skin. It stands alone; it is unique.’’ “Wecommend the book heartily to dermatologist, histologist, and pathologist— to all investigators in spectal and general pathology, feeling assured that they will find a great deal of matter of intrinsic worth.” THE MACMILLAN COMPANY, Publishers, 66 Fifth Ave., New York.

Page 5

The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, JULY 2, 1896. The Week. Tue Democratic convention in Wiscon- sin on June 23, like that in Minnesota a fortnight earlier, declared in favor of the gold standard and against the free coin- age of silver. As the Republicans in these States had previously taken the same position, both parties in Wisconsin and Minnesota are now committed to the doctrine of sound money that is really sound. The same thing is true of the Re- publicans, who are the dominant party, in North Dakota; the Democrats there have not yet held their convention. These three States constitute that section of the Union where the foreign element is the largest anywhere to be found, the proportion of the population whose pa- rents, one or both, were foreigners, being 73.69 per cent. in Wisconsin, 75.42 per cent. in Minnesota, and 78.98 per cent. in North Dakota. Those persons who think that foreign ignorance is what threatens the stability of American institutions, will do well to contrast the financial history and present position of these three States with the record and attitude of three such States as Kansas, where the foreign element is only 26.78 per cent., Missouri with 24.98 per cent., and Kentucky with but 9.87 per cent. The Democrats of Illinois went wild last week for free silver and free riots. ‘The arbitrary-interference on the part of the federal Government in local af- fairs,’’ they say, ‘‘ by. ignoring the lawful authorities, is not only a violation of the Constitution of the United States, but a crime against free government, and is de- structive of the very foundation of demo- cratic and republican institutions.” This refers to Debs and the great strike and boycott of the American Railway Union. It affirms virtually that if a riot breaks out in any place which stops the running of cars, the movement of interstate com- merce, and of the United States mails, and if the Governor of the State is in sympathy with the rioters and neglects to suppress their unlawful acts, then the President of the United States must do nothing but allow the sioters to have their way. This is Altgeld’s theory of free institutions—freedom to throw trains off the track, to burn loaded cars in the midst of great cities, to kill conductors and engineers if they attempt to perform their duty, and to strangle the trade and commerce of the whole country. Natu- rally the passage of this resolution by the convention is followed by another cordial- ly endorsing the administration of Gov. Altgeld. Illinois would be in a pitiable condition if such a man could be re- elected as her chief magistrate after all that he has done to produce chaos in her principal city. It was right for the con- vention to renominate Altgeld. It is time to find out what sort of people in- habit the State, and whether life and property are really safe there—a question which can be determined in no other way so speedily and surely as by putting his name before the voters for their suffrages once more. Four years ago they did not know the man. Now they know him very well. Mr. Whitney’s absurd New York Demo- cratic platform has been received by the silver Democrats in just the way that might have been expected. It heartens them greatly. If that is the best the De- mocracy of New York can do, the silver- ites may gayly run down their steep place into the sea. For argument, all they need to do is to point to Mr. Whitney’s concessions. He gives the whole case away. All he lacks is the courage of his convictions. Zhat they willsupply in un- limited quantities, with the courage of their ignorance thrown in. He is all very well as a philosopher to point out the way where he dare not go, but they are the men of action who will translate his reasoning into deeds. What the silver Democrats dreaded was an outspoken and uncompromising gold platform from the New York Democracy, with a bolt distinctly threatened. Ifsuch a platform had been put out last April, it would have had a powerful effect in other States. But to wait till the end of June, and then give forth a lot of mushy bimetallism, was the surest way to make New York Demo- crats contemptible in the eyes of the party and the nation. The Democratic nomination for the Pre; sidency will not be made for a week, and the canvass never really opens until some weeks after the last of the conventions. But the fight for control of the next House of Representatives is already on, and, as we have previously said, that body will hold the key to the situation. The Senate, from 1897 to 1899, will surely be controlled by the silverites. With either the nominee of the Chicago convention or McKinley in the White House, we can no longer depend upon the President for pro- tection from the silver madness, as has been the case under Cleveland. The only assurance of salvation will be in the elec- tion of a House of Representatives a ma- jority of which will prevent any conces- sion whatever to silver. The pressure for some concession will be tremendous. If McKinley shall be elected, he will come in pledged to give the country a high tariff. The Senate will ‘‘hold up” any tariff bill until the ransom price is paid in the shape of an agreement to coin more silver dollars, or buy more silver bullion, or coin the seigniorage. What is abso- lutely essential is a majority in the House which cannot be inveigled or bulldozed by the protected interests into a sur- render to the silverites. In order to secure such a majority, the sound-money men must go to work with- out a moment’s delay. Two members of the next House have already been elect- ed—Republicans from Oregon who favor ‘“‘doing something for silver.”” Two Re- publicans have already been nominated in Kansas districts upon silver platforms. Silver Republican newspapers in the West, like the Detroit Tribune, are urg ing the immediate organization of the silver forces to capture the caucuses and secure the nomination of Representatives who will pledge themselves to favor silver legislation. Congressman Aitken of the Sixth Michigan District, a Republican who seeks reélection, declares that he is ‘*bitterly opposed to a single gold stan- dard, and will not tolerate it.”” Republi- can Representatives in other Western States are explaining that the St. Louis platform really commits the party only to opposition to free coinage, and declaring that they will favor other silver legisla- tion if they shall be returned to the next House. Such developments as these show the imperative necessity for equally vigor- ous action on the part of thesound-money men at once. Nominations in a large pro- portion of the districts will be made be- fore the Presidential canvass really opens in September. If the believers in a gold standard postpone work until then, they may find that it is too late to avert the danger of an untrustworthy House of Representatives. All the outgivings from Canton indi- cate that McKinley and his managers will try to make the tariff the issue of the - campaign. ‘ The tariff is the only issue, of course,’’ says the great Hanna, after a conference with the candidate. ‘‘ Tnere is but one issue, and that is the tariff,” says Thomas McDougall, a Cincinnati politician, after a similar conference. ‘The drift of all McKinley’s speeches and conversation thus far,’’ writes Wil- liam E. Curtis, who knows him well, to the Chicago Record, “is towards a re- vival of interest in the tariff, which the national committee will force to the front as an issue in the campaign.”’ It is easy enough to say that the tariff shall be the issue, but how are McKinley, Hanna, and the rest going to make it such? A new tariff can be secured only through a trade with the silver men, like the one in 1890, when Teller & Co. insisted upon the sil- ver-purchase act before they would let

Page 6

The Nation. [Vol. 63, No. 1618 the McKinley bill become a law. So long as this is the case, the financial question must be the chief issue. To say that all the country wants is revenue, and that the Republicans will pass a tariff bill that will give this revenue, will deceive no- body when every one knows that the Senate will never let such a bill through unless another blow shall be dealt at the stability of our currency system. It is right to say, however, that McKinley on Friday made a speech at Canton, in which for the first time he defined his dollar satisfactorily. He said it must be a dollar ‘good for a dollar, not only at home, but in every mart and market- place of the world.” : It is a curious survival of the Blaine campaign that clergymen should have _taken to writing letters to the newspa- pers calling attention to McKinley’s ex- emplary church-going habits. The ob- jections to Blaine were, indeed, of a sort which a good record for church attend- ance would tend to rebut; though it would also be consistent with the theory that he was not only a dishonest man, but a hypocrite as well. But McKinley’s personal character is not called in ques- tion, and testimony as to that can hardly be taken as a conclusive reply to the doubts about him which are really trou- bling people. What they want to know is, if he is the man, by knowledge and conviction and force of character, to take charge of the nation’s finances at a crisis of unexampled gravity. They crave as- surances that a man who endorsed notes up to ten times the amount of his proper- ty will not consider that method a safe one in conducting the business of the Government. They are anxiously trying to find out whether he will resolutely veto a bill for the further purchase of silver and inflation of the currency, and whether he will exhaust every power lodged in the Executive to maintain gold payments before he will see them fail. Really, we must point out to the reverend logicians, it is no answer to say that Mc- Kinley is regularly in his pew on Sunday mornings, or that he does not beat his old mother. The working of the McKinley magic is already visible in business, as all ear- nest thinkers knew it would be, though it is a little hard to follow the process, A surprising falling off in our worsted and cotton imports from England is re- ported for the past four months. This is as it should be. McKinley simply will not have imports. The trembling Bri- tishers know this, and would not, of course, risk their goods in a land where the eye of a McKinley is upon every re- creant American who dares to wear a foreign coat or shirt. To be sure, the falling off appears to have occurred un- der the wicked Wilson tariff, of which the main design was to strengthen England’s ‘*hold ” upon us, but what we would ask is, did it occur until McKinley was ‘‘ sure to be nominated’? ? We rather think not, and we believe a careful comparison of dates would show that the diminution of exports from Bradford was coincident with the visit of the Tribune’s London correspondent to that unhappy city. The manufacturers learned from him that it was all up with them, and that no more of their exports would be received in this country. Then there is the closing of our own cotton mills, threatened on an extensive scale on account of overproduc- tion. At first sight, one would say that McKinley should have stopped this. Can the manufacturers have forgotten to ap- peal to him, instead of simply consulting the market, before ordering the shut- down? He might have told them that their trouble was all due to the cursed Wilson tariff. He might have believed it; but they would not, because they have testified, through their spokesman, Senator Aldrich, that the cotton sche- dules of the Wilson bill were the most scientific and thoroughly protective ever framed. Like talking with Mrs. Tulli- ver, this is all ‘‘ puzzling work,’’ and we fear that the puzzle of it will grow denser from week to week. The London Economist explains why the adoption of the gold plank at St. Louis did not send up the price of Ame- rican securities abroad ‘with a sharp bound.” In the first place, it says, there is not in the resolution a ‘‘a breath of strong conviction,’ and the long dodging and bad record of McKinley had filled foreign investors with fears which the platform alone could not allay. But fur- ther than this, not a hint, not a suspicion of a suggestion, is given in the platform as to the way in which the existing gold standard is to be preserved. President Cleveland, with his heart in the work, has been struggling to do that all through his administration, and by the only me- ‘thod now available. For doing so he has been denounced like a pickpocket by Re- publicans. They now say they are going to maintain the gold standard, but of measures todo it they breathe not a word. Foreign investors, says the Economist, want to see a definite programme of cur- rency reform before they will be prepared to pin their faith and their money to a platform generality. On top of all these doubts come the militant and extravagant policy of the planks relating to foreign affairs, and the general threat to trade involved in the promise of a return to Chinese-wall protection. Thus the gold plank at St. Louis, while it undoubtedly prevented something like a panic which would have resulted from a free-silver or straddling platform, did not positively and efficaciously reassure foreign markets. For the reasons mentioned by the Eco- nomist, ‘‘ they have failed to respond as was expected,” and, it adds, “it can- not be said that their caution is un- justifiable.” Gov. Morton’s selection of ex-Mayor Gilroy as member of the Greater New York Charter Commission, in place of Mr. Fitch, who declined to serve, is a most indefensible act. It would have been difficult to find in this city a more thoroughly unfit man. Certainly none more so could have been found outside the membership of Tammany Hall. Mr. Gilroy is nothing except a Tammany man, and the Governor has no reason for putting him upon the Commission except as a representative of that organi- zation. He is certainly not a representa- tive of the city and its interests, as he has had no training which fits him to be of assistance in evolving a system of government for the proposed great city. The only science of government that he has ever studied is that which Tammany carries out when it is in possession of public office. Everybody knows how Gil- roy executed that as Mayor. He put Scannell the murderer into the Fire De- partment, put Sheehan the Buffalo de- faulter into the Police Department, and obliged Tom Platt by giving Sheehan as associates two Republican Boys, Mike Kerwin and Charlie Murray; made Bar- ney Martin and Joe Koch Police Jus- tices, and Mike Daly Commissioner of Public Works. He has no idea of public offive except to turn it to the personal profit of himself and his political asso- ciates, who are mainly persons of disre- putable character, dissolute and irregu- lar lives, and general ignorance. It is an insult to every reputable man on the Commission to ask him to sit with Gil- roy as an associate. The city of Milwaukee has been the scene of the most extensive application of the boycott ever seen in this country. On the 4th of May the men employed by the company which operates the street- car lines struck for higher pay, which the company refused. The usual con- comitants of such a strike followed for a few days—difficulty in operating the cars until a full force of new men could be secured, with more or less disorder and assaults upon the “scabs.”’ This state of things did not last long, how- ever. Thecompany had soon manned the cars, and its full service was resumed, Then came the novel feature of the strike. The former employees declared a boycott of the cars. Such orders have been issued under similar circumstances in other cities, notably in the great Third Avenue strike in New York a few years ago, but never before were they regarded by more than a small portion of the la- boring element in the community. In Milwaukee, on the other hand, the strik- ers were at first able to make practically the whole population abandon the street- cars, and either patronize the ’busses and

Page 7

Bs D re 4 a July 2, 1896] The Nation. other conveyances which they put on the prinzipal streets, or walk. It is actually true that for days cars would go along routes where they were ordinarily well filled at all times and crowded sometimes, and not average more than one pas- senger a trip, even in the ‘‘rush’”’ hours. Business men, professional men, all classes, were threatened with loss of patronage, law-suits, damages of every sort, if they should ride in the cars. For some time the public was so much dazed that hardly anybody dared to defy the boycott. Gradually, however, most of the people recovered their senses and their courage, resumed patronage of the cars, the ’busses lost their passengers, and at last the managers of the strike ‘declared the boycott ‘‘off,’? having se- cured nothing for themselves out of the strike, and only diminished the power of the company for a long time to pay the higher wages that they sought. * Judge Wright of the Illinois Circuit Court bas declared unconstitutional and void the State law requiring the national flag to be displayed over every school- house. The case vame before him in the form of a motion to quash indictments found against certain school trustees and other officials for failing to execute the law. The Legislature had made such violation of the law a misdemeanor, and therein, so Judge Wright holds, had exceeded its powers. The decision hinged on this point. There was no question of the right of the State to or- der the flag flown on any of its build- ings, at such times and in such a man- ner as it saw fit. The effect of this deci- sion will be to make patriotism, in so far as it consists in flinging the flag to the breeze, optional. This may seem a hor- rid conclusion to some perfervid breth- ren, but, after all, it simply puts patriot- ism in the same category with the other leading virtues. It is perhaps unfortu- nate that we cannot by law compel all citizens to be sober, saving, honest, kind to wife and child, but we cannot; nor can we, if Judge Wright’s exposition of the law is sound, compel them to be pa- triotic. Illinois school-children may in- cur great civic dangers by not being al- lowed to see the flag above their heads. Certainly they will be as much at sea as the rest of us about the great McKinley definition of ‘sound money ”’—that it is something ‘‘ as untarnished as the flag.’’ Still, they may learn in their school his- tories that the flag was very badly tar- nished in the Mexican war, Gen. Grant being witness, and so not lose so much after all. Anyhow they will have to be patriotic, as they will have to be virtu- ous, from an inward spring if at all, and not by act of Legislature. At the meeting of the Tory members of the House of Commons on June 15, when the melancholy announcement was made by Mr. Balfour that not one of his pet and promised bills could be passed, a re- mark was made by the veteran Sir John Mowbray which elicited the only real ap- plause of the afternoon. It was to the effect that he hoped one result of the grand fiasco, as of the experience of the late Liberal Government, would be to teach parties the folly of overloading their legislative programme. In other words, this thing of promising the millen- nium out of hand, and then going on to leave Satan just as visibly unchained as before, is getting to be wearisome. For nothing did Mr. Balfour and Lord Salis- bury and Chamberlain rail more causti- cally at the Liberals than for having un- dertaken so’much more than they could possibly perform. Yet they at once pro- mised three times as much—very natu- rally, having three times the majority. But here is their first session gone to wreck, and all their promises gone to protest. Whether parties will learn wis- dom from the unexampled breakdown, may be doubted, despite Sir John Mow- bray’s pious hopes. Parties are bound to bid against each other for popular sup- port, and the highest bidder seems to carry off the prize. Ifone side promises the millennium, the other must pledge itself to bring in two, with the Golden Age and the Saturnia regna thrown in. Of course the bigger the promises, the bigger the smash when they are unfulfil- led; but the temptation to win votes by the easy process of making promises seems to be too much for mortal politi- cians. The Republican platform, for ex- ample, contains a tremendous array of solemn undertakings to do things that the framers knew would not and could not be done. All they had their eye on was the election, which they hoped to win by promising everything, and then afterwards get up some diversion, like a foreign war, to appease the disgusted and enraged voters. Mr. Balfour’s failure as leader of the House of Commons is partly the fault of his party and more the inevitable result of his temperament. An impossible task was laid on him—the task which Mr. Bright described as that of driving six coaches-and-four abreast through a street where but one at a time could go. Too many and too complex bills were given him, with orders to pass them this ses- sion. The thing could not be done. But the great incapacity is that of Mr. Bal- four’s own mental make-up. He is in- finitely bored by the dreary speech-mak- ing of the House of Commons. Nine hours of it is more than his refined and subtle intellect can endure. He will not sit it out. But the prime requisite in a suc- cessful leader of the House is constant and watchful attendance. Even the cyni- cal Disraeli recognized this fact and was unflaggingly at his post. Mr. Gladstone, up to the very end, especially when the home-rule bill was pending, was always on the Treasury bench, except when he was springing to his feet to controvert some dullard over whom Mr. Balfour would only have groaned inwardly and then gone out. So notoriously slack is his attendance on the House that the fact is frequently thrown in his face. He attempted to reply to Sir William Har- court, the other day, when the Liberal chief turned on him roughly with the question how he could venture to answer a speech he had not heard. Such things are fatal to the discipline of party and the prestige of the leader. As Mr. Lucy says: ‘* The House of Commons is a team that may be successfully driven only by an undeputed coachman always on the box-seat.’? Mr. Balfour’s ability is un- questioned, but the ablest man that ever lived could not succeed in his place un- less he made up his mind to chain him- self to his seat in the House, to suffer fools gladly, and to have the run of busi- ness and debating always accurately in mind. All this is no doubt distasteful to a speculative intellect like Mr. Balfour’s, but then, as the man said about writing a sonnet, it is so easy not to be leader of the House, and the speculative intellect essaying it must take on the air and the methods of the hard-hitting, practical, galley-slave intellect. The Pope’s latest encyclical on Chris- tian unity is a very elaborate argument for Roman supremacy, but how it touches existing conditions and problems it is hard to see. His long and careful de- monstration that the Church of Rome is the most likely centralized and authori- tative exponent of Christian doctrine and practice, will be shed as so much water from the backs of those who, like the Protestants, deny the desirability of hav- ing any such authority at all, or, like the Greek Christians, affirm that Rome has widely departed from the primitive faith. Thus the whole encyclical necessarily has an unpractical air, like a bit of labo- ratory experimentation, with little regard to the hard and ugly facts. The Pope has before made friendly and charitable advances to both the Greek and Angli- can Churches. Nothing resulted in either case except a polite but firm re- fusal to take a step towards that union of Christendom which consists in sub- mission to Rome. After these rebuffs in the practical sphere, it looks as if Leo XIII. had determined at any rate to put on record the reasons he has for believing that he is right. His encycli- cal will make an excellent thesis for use in Catholic seminaries. Those who are already convinced will find it irrefra- gable. It is very learned, very logical (granting the premises quietly assumed), and is argued through with the air of a disinterested and detached philosopher. But the philosopher is, unfortunately, so detached from the facts confronting him that his reasoning cannot be expected to have any practical results.

Page 8

4 The Nation. [Vol. 63, No. 1618 THE ISSUE OF THE CAMPAIGN. Mr. McKintey, in his speech at Canton on Saturday, made an allusion to the money question as one of the issues of the campaign. It came out rather slow- ly, but it came nevertheless, and what he said encourages us to believe that he will say more by and by. He said that it was one of the missions of the Republican party to give the country a dollar which would pass for a dollar in every muarket- place in the world. Now, the only dol- lar that passes for 100 cents in all the markets of the world is the gold dollar. It certainly is the mission of the Repub- lican party to preserve this dollar, and it is equally the mission of the gold dollar to preserve the party, for everybody can see that this is to be the overtopping is- sue of the campaign. The men who are prating about the tariff, and pretending that protection is in danger under sche- dules of duties averaging 42 per cent. ad valorem—a tariff higher than Mr. Mor- rill ever drew in his palmiest days—will not be heard of two months hence, or at all events will not be listened to. Their voices will be completely lost in the 16- to-1 whirlwind. Mr. McKinley’s speech shows a dawning recognition of the kind of campaign that is now beginning. The Sunday papers contained an inter- view with Mr. Whitney in which he ac- knowledges that he does not expect to change the purpose of the silver majori- ty at Chicago. They are too many and too stubborn, he says. They are going to adopt a platform which will disrupt the party because honorable men cannot stand on it. Very true. We have fore- seen that catastrophe to the party for some weeks. Wesay now that it is best for the country that the silver majority should go on and do what they were appoint- ed to do, for if they should turn around at the instance of Mr. Whitney and go against their instructions, the country would put no confidence in their change of heart. People would say that they had been false to their constituents. Moreover, a change on their part would not change their constituents. All the poison of 16 to 1 would be rankling among them as before, and would be more viru- lent than ever by reason of such trea- chery. It would have to be doctored just the same. The delegates to Chicago, in the improbable event of their being lured away by sirens, would simply disappear beneath the waves. Their successors, whether calling themselves Democrats, or Populists, or Teller men, would be in full panoply, if not this year, then next year and thereafter until beaten in fair fight, perhaps more than once. There is still another reason why it is best that the silver majority at Chicago should do what they were appointed to do. If they should turn around and adopt a straddling platform, the sound- money Democrats, or most of them, would then vote their own ticket. The Demo- cratic party would be no safer than it is now, but the sound-money vote would be divided. It-is not impossible in that event that the Democrats might elect enough Congressmen to makea majority, with the aid of the Populists and the Teller Republicans. It is needless to point out the dangers of such a combina- tion. The thing most to be desired is that the sound-money vote of the country should be united on the Presidential ticket, and united on Congressmen wher- ever the silverites are any where near one- half of the total vote. _ Still another reason for wishing the Democrats at Chicago to do what they have been bidden to do is that the. busi- ness of the country will never be on a sound footing as long as the present un- certainty about the money standard con- tinues. Even our esteemed contempora- ries of the McKinley League ought to see this now. They have been telling us that their candidate was the advance agent of prosperity, that he was sure to be nominated and sure to be elected, and that his very name was going to make good times. -Yet business does not im- prove. Last year was bad for trade, but this year is worse. There has been no lack of McKinley to account for the dul- ness. He is nominated. He will proba- bly be elected, but there is just enough doubt about it to leave a shadow on the standard of value, by which credit is im- paired. The banks are putting themselves in condition to meet the worst. Men who have money refuse to lend it because they do not know what they will get back. There is much less talk about the ad- vance agent of prosperity now than there was two months ago. The question what shall be the issue of the campaign, is one which cannot be settled by McKinley, or Hanna, or the Republican national committee. It is settled by the people. The issue of any campaign is that question in which the people are most deeply interested. That question this year is the currency. The free coinage of silver is advocated earnest- ly as the only cure of the hard times. It is a dogma which finds a host of men ready to accept it as the true faith. It will be preached upon every stump in every doubtful State. It will carry such States unless it is met. If the Demo- cratic campaign in such States as Ne- braska, Kansas, Iowa, Illinois, Indiana, and even Ohio, were to be made for free coinage, and the Republicans, instead of meeting these arguments, were to do no- thing but talk high tariff, they would de- serve to lose them, and probably would get their deserts. The time has come for every man who has saved anything, even though it be only ten dollars in a savings bank, to fight for the ownership of it. The de- mand for free-silver coinage is a demand for a division of property. It is even worse than that, for a division might con- ceivably be made without losing any part of the whole, but a division by changing the value of the dollar would involve enormous losses by which nobody would be the gainer. Such losses are taking place now through the interruption of industry, the lack of enterprise, the cur- tailment of credit which everybody feels and for which there is no vieible or as- certainable cause except the threatened change in the measure of values. It is proposed to divide the dollar in two parts, to give one-half to the owner, and have a scramble for the other half with the chance of losing it altogether. This is the vital issue, and the Republican party will win if it has the sense to make its campaign on it. If we could imagine the party to be so stupid as to allow the Democrats to fill the land with free-silver literature and stump speeches, and at- tempt to meet them with tariff arguments (especially McKinley tariff arguments), we would not give much for their chances at the end of the campaign. THE NEW YORK DEMOCRATIC PLAT. FORM. WE had hoped that the efforts of the Eastern delegates to the Chicago con- vention might be effectual in preventing that body from taking a plunge to the silver standard, and that the New York delegates especially would go thither with a weighty declaration of principles —one that should present a very stiff - barrier to the mad rush of the South and West. We have been disappointed, not- withstanding some excellent features that have been incorporated in the plat- form adopted at Saratoga. The first thing in this platform is an appeal to the party faith as revealed unto Thomas Jefferson that ‘‘ the monetary unit must stand on both metals.’ If Jefferson were alive, he would be asto- nished to learn that this was an article of party faith and that he was the author of it. Thesaying came about in this way. Hamilton, the leader of the Federalists, was preparing his report on the establish- ment of a mint. He took facts as he found them—among others the fact that both silver and gold were in use as money throughout the world at ratios differing somewhat in different countries. So he decided that both metals ought to be re- ceived and coined at our mint, at a ratio coinciding as closely as possible with their value in the market. He put this idea in his report, and sent it to Jefferson for his advice and criticism before sending it to Congress. Jefferson read the paper, made certain remarks upon it in writing, and returned it to the author. Among his notes were tha words: ‘‘I agree with you that the monetary unit must stand upon both metals.” In citing the passage the platform-makers at Saratoga omit the words “I agree with you.”” Those words show that it was not the original concep- tion of Jefferson, and that it was not ‘‘a declaration of party faith,’”’ but merely an expression of Jefferson’s concurrence

Page 9

July 2, 1896] The Nation. 5 with his chief political opponént on a matter of business. This misconception or misquotation is not, however, the chief point of objection to the platform. The chief objection is that it confirms the silverites in their present beliefs. When you tell them that party faith requires that ‘‘ the mo- netary unit must stand upon both metals,” they say, ‘‘ That isjust what we are fighting for.”” When you tell them that this article of party faith cannot be realized until something else is done by some other country or countries, they reply that articles of party faith cannot wait for ever for realization; that they have waited twenty years for Europe to come upon Jefferson’s platform; that as often as Europe has been invited to do so, she has declined, and that it is useless to wait longer. If the declaration of party faith is to be kept alive, if it is ever to become a vital principle, it must be put in force by ourselves ; and why not now as well as at any other time ? The next paragraph of the platform is as malapropos as the previous one. It ‘“‘arraigns”’ the Republican party for demonetizing silver’ in 1873. ‘*The ac- tion of a Republican Congress and a Re- publican President,’’ it says, ‘‘deprived silver of its equality with gold for the money and currency of the nation.” ‘¢ Exactly so,’ replies Bland; ‘‘ Exactly so,’””? echoes Tillman; and the words go reverberating through the ranks of the silverites from the Potomac to the Rio Grande and the Columbia. This was ‘the crime of 1873”; we are going to punish it now. ‘From this act,’’ con- tinues the Saratoga platform, “(for which the Democratic party was in no wise re- sponsible), and from the action of other nations following in the same course, it has resulted that silver has greatly de- clined in commercial value, and there now exists a wide departure of the two metals from the coinage standard of value— bringing disturbance to the financial sys- tems of European countries as well as to our own, and awakening there, as here, the earnest apprehension of statesmen and financiers.’’ All of which, besides being a gratuitous assumption, serves to confirm the silver men in their opinion that they are redressing a great wrong, and that if they succeed, they will bring back prosperity instead of plunging the country into a deeper abyss than it has ever known before. The truth is, that no disturbance was produced by the adoption of the single gold standard either in this country or in Europe. On the contrary, the most fre- quent and serious cause of disturbance previously existing was removed, namely, the oscillations due to the changes of market value of the two metals. Great prosperity followed, especially in this country. From 1879 to 1890, with a few brief intervals, due to over-specula- tion, the United States enjoyed a most It was in the last- prosperous career. mentioned year that the Sherman silver act was passed. It was in that year that confidence in the standard of value was first seriously shaken, and from that year to this it has been subjected to frequent shocks, and will continue to be as long as there is a party formidable in numbers threatening to reduce the dollar on which business now rests, to the value of fifty-two or fifty-three cents. The only financial disturbance caused by the demonetization of sitver exists in the ima- ginations of the bimetallist philosophers. The resolution of the Saratoga piat- form which calls for the retirement and cancellation of the greenbacks, while com- mendable in itself, will not cure the mis- chief which has been done by telling the silverites that they are all right except as to the particular method they have adopt- ed for carrying out their views. THE MENACE TO RAILROADS. THERE is probably not a railroad mana- ger in the United States who is not lying awake o’ nights thinking of the results of the free coinage of silver to him and his property and his employees. If he has any gold bonds outstanding (and nearly every one has them), the first question is how he is to get gold to pay his interest if the standard money of the country is silver. Norailroad can live and main- tain solvency if its receipts are in the form of silver and its payments are made in gold. The silver dollar is worth some- where between 50 and 60 cents, vary- ing like a shuttlecock, but not likely to rise above 60 cents for any considerable time. A railroad which bas a million dollars of gold interest to pay must ex- pend nearly 2,000,000 of silver dollars in order to meet this single liability. It is very easy to say, ‘‘ Raise your rates; charge the public $2 freight where you now charge $1; make them pay 4 cents per mile for riding on the cars instead of 2.” The thing cannot be done, or, if done at all, only at the end of a pro- tracted turmoil and struggle during which bankruptcy will overtake every road so situated. This is not all. The gold-interest prob- lem is only a part, and not the largest part, of the green cloud in the railroad horizon premonitory of a cyclone. The cost of labor and materials will rise in proportion to the fall in the value of the money. It must be so because that is the law of money. Men cannot do the same amount of work for a silver dollar that they can for a gold dollar, because it is not worth so much. It will not buy so much. It will not bring in the same amount of flour, meat, clothing, and other commodities. Consequently the railroad employees and material men must have more dollars than they get now for a given amount of labor and supplies. Iron, lumber, coal, oil, and everything else will cost more. But where is the money to come from? The people who are served by the railroads must pay it. But they will resist any advance as long as they can, and, while they are resist- ing, the roads will be unable to pay the increased wages and prices demanded. The President of the Atchison Road pic- tures the situation in its true colors, thus; ‘‘Thereis not a Western railway, with a few exceptions, that does not pay out 70 per cent. of its gross receipts for labor and supplies. The exceptions pay out 60 percent. The mar- gin of profit for capital is very small. If, as the free-silver advocates themselves clai free silver will raise the price of products an labor, the railways will have to raise their charges accordingly. Furthermore, if we are to receive 50 cents in place of $1, the railways will be driven into confusion and bankruptcy. The proposal is to revolutionize the money basis in the face of the world. If it carries, it will be followed instantly by a widespread panic and havoc, blacker and more disastrous than any business calamity that ever swept America. The situation which now confronts railway managers and the managers of great investments and capital is that of awaiting the settlement of this tremendous question and the wiping out of the menace against their property and money.” What is true of the railroads is true of nearly all large business undertakings. Most of them have some debt. Most of them have been brought into existence by borrowing. They have obtained capi- tal cheaply by promising to pay interest and principal in gold. They have bor- rowed gold under contracts to return gold. All such undertakings are exposed to the same hazard as the railroads. There is no difference between them ex- cept that the railroads are a little more in evidence by reason of the daily quota- tion of their securities in the newspapers. Coal mines, gas works, iron works, elec- trical companies, cotton and woollen mills, cities and States that have bonds outstanding, are in the same plight. As we write these lines an official circular comes to us from Utah asking proposals for $200,000 of ‘“‘State of Utah Gold 4 per cent. twenty-year funding bonds, principal and interest payable in United States gold coin.”’ Here’s richness! The delegates of Utah to the St. Louis ‘convention seceded from that body and left the Republican party because a gold- standard platform was adopted, and yet these very men must have taken part in passing the law authorizing this gold loan; or if they did not personally take part in it, must have approved it. The same may be said of their newspapers that are indulging in blackguardism against the gold-bugs and against Wall Street seven days in every week. They are all shocked at the issue of gold bonds by the United States. They insist that when the federal Government borrows money it shall pay the principal and in- terest in silver, or at least reserve the op- tion todoso. Yet when their own State wants to borrow, they print’ the word gold in capital letters on the circulars which they send to the Wall Street sharks, and they never recognize the humor of the situation. The main fact, however, is that every State and municipality that has gold .

Page 10

6 The Nation. [Vol. 63, No. 1618 bonds outstanding will have to increase its taxes if silver becomes the standard, unless it repudiates its debt. Repudia- tion would not be difficult under the cir- cumstances, for a community or people that could authorize all debtors to cheat their creditors out of one-half of their private obligations would not hesitate long to apply the same principle to pub- lic obligations. There would be Till- mans and Altgelds in plenty to point the way. The only class of creditors of the States and cities who would be helpless would be the office-holders. Their ex- penses would rise like those of the rail- road employees, but they could not strike for higher wages. They could no nothing but petition the Legislature for an in- crease of salary, and it would be a long time before they would get it. The em- ployees of the federal Government would be in the same plight, for Uncle Sam must pay out the same kind of money that he takes in. THE CANADIAN ELECTIONS. For the second time only since confede- ration, the Canadian Liberals have car- ried a general election. Steadily beaten since 1878, they have now won not only a victory, which they were expected to do by a narrow margin, but a sweeping vic- tory which leaves the Conservatives dazed. Even in the province of Quebec, where the Government candidates counted upon gaining six seats, the Liberals were al- most everywhere successful. Mr. Wilfred Laurier will be the first French Canadian Premier the country has had, and is as- sured of a good majority in the House over all opposing factions. The two great issues in the campaign which ended on June 23 were the school question, or the religious-school question, and the tariff. Of these the first was doubtless the more important, and cut most sharply through party lines. The controversy is an oid one and has raged mainly about the schools in the province of Manitoba. That province entered the Dominion in 1870, and in 1871 established a system of schools such as exists in other Canadian provinces—that is to say, sepa- rate schools for Protestants and Catholics, under the supervision of a school board composed of two sections, one Catholic and one Protestant, each managing its own schools. So things went on till 1890, when the Protestants, having become largely in the majority through the influx of settlers, abolished the two-headed school board and practically withdrew all public money from the Catholic schools. An appeal was at once taken to the Gov- ernor- General in Council, as provided in the British North America act of 1867, and judgment was finally given in favor of the Roman Catholics in 1895. A reme- dial order was drawn up restoring to the Manitoba Catholics the right to a share in the legislative school grant. The Mani- toba Legislature refused to act upon this order. Thereupon a bill was brought into Parliament to compel the Manitoba Protestant majority to give the Catholics their school money. This bill passed its second reading on the 20th of last March, by a vote of 112 to 94, but was killed by the famous obstruction in committee, after two successive sittings of 129 and 80 hours continuously. In the appeal to the country the Con- servatives made the Manitoba school bill their leading campaign cry. Sir Charles Tupper even carried the war into Mani- toba itself, where he fairly told the elec- tors that the bill would be forced down their throats if he won the day. But it was, of course, in the strong Catholic provinces that he expected to score his gains, and he had the influence of the higher clergy most outspokenly on his side, despite the fact that Mr. Wilfred Laurier is himself a Catholic. In the churches of Quebec and elsewhere Cath- olics were told from the altar that it was their religious duty to support the Con- servatives, and one bishop denounced Laurier as no better than ‘‘a rationalistic Liberal ’’ for having maintained that ‘a Catholic is not required to be a Catholic in public life.” But it appears, from the issue, that thousands of even the priest- ridden French Canadians resented this interference and voted for the Liberals, while, of course, ultra-Protestants must have been detached in great numbers from the Conservative party so openly bidding for priestly support. From the event it is clear that this religious ques- tion, upon which the Conservatives count- ed so much, hurt them severely, both go- ing and coming. The other leading issue was tariff re- form. Mr. Wilfred Laurier is a free- trader and a strong advocate of recipro- city with the United States, though he has frankly said in his speeches that the necessity of raising revenue by customs duties will prevent any radical reduc- tions in the tariff for some time to come. All that he promises is a moderate read- justment of the tariff. But Sir Richard Cartwright, who will probably be finance minister in the new Liberal cabinet, is strongly in favor of unrestricted free trade, and he has been held up as a bogey-man by the Conservatives. The voters, however, do not appear to have been frightened. The truth is, the coun- try has not been prosperous under pro- tection, trade depression having persisted for some years. By the very logic of pro- tection, therefore, which risks the whole case on prosperity, the electors were jus- tified in turning towards free trade. It is somewhat puzzling to see a nation on one side of an imaginary line attributing all its ills to protection, and one on the other side to the lack of protection. But it is a comfort to reflect that there is One who knows all about it—McKinley, of course. On the whole, accordingly, the result of the Canadian elections must be taken as an encouragement to the believers in popular government—which is, of course, the Q. E. D. of all elections. An over- bearing priestcraft has been rebuked, fiscal follies and fallacies shown to have lost a part of their power, and one more pin thrust into Chamberlain’s Imperial Zollverein. The Conservatives made much of this particular inflation of the Colonial Secretary’s, giving the people to understand that Chamberlain was greatly interested in Sir Charles Tupper’s suc- cess. So much the worse for Sir Charles then, said the people, and down went the Zollverein in Canada. Ags far as the re- sult affects the United States, we should say it meant a more cordial policy in ge- neral on the part of the new Government, and in particular an excellent disposition to return to a generous treaty of recipro- city, such as the arrangement of 1854, which was repealed to mutual disadvan- tage and under a good deal of false pre- tence in 1866. JAMESON COMMITTED. Lonpon, June 16, 1896. THERE are a number of men going about the streets here bearing large yellow placards to the effect that a picture entitled ‘‘ Jame- son’s Last Stand,” by R. Caton Woodville, R.A., is now on exbibition. This was proba- bly painted at the height of the Jameson fu- rore last January, for it is doubtful if lau- reates and academicians would find ‘Dr. Jim” a figure so entirely heroic since his commitment for trial yesterday at the close of the police magistrate’s examination at Bow Street; but it would be a mistake to say that interest in the raiders has altogether abated, or that they are much less popular. On June 11 the adjourned session of the ex- amination of the men charged with a violation of the Foreign Enlistment Act by making a raid into a friendly state was brought on at the Bow Street Police Court, before as brilliant and interested an audience as can be imagined. The ‘great crowds” at previous sessions must have stood outside the gates, for at this ses- sion no more could have been accommodated within. To the American mind, Bow Street suggests something vaguely disagreeable and disreputable, like the Old Bailey or the Tombs, yet it is by no means such a bad street; andas the Covent: Garden Opera-house stands just across the way from the police court, there was a curious air of propriety about the ela- borate toilets that filled the commonplace little room where real dramas were acted in the light of day. The ostensible purpose of the examinations was to ascertain whether or not the defend- ants had committed an offence for which they should stand trial. Whatever the Govern- ment’s original intention with regard to the matter may have been, the necessities of the situation have compelled it to a strenuous and successful effort to bring the conspirators to trial; so the many adjournments of the case (which the Opposition called dilatory tactics) now seem quite justified. As this proceeding must inevitably affect the South African question, a slight sketch of it and of the prin- cipal figures in it is perhaps worthy of record. The court-room at Bow Street is small, somewhat dingy, but clean. Across one side of it runs the bench, which is raised above the RT Te ee

Page 11

Ba Care wok ee ta Ni ne ia aaa July 2, 1896] The Nation. level of the floor, railed off from it, with the Judge’s desk in the centre. So many chairs and benches were filled with ladies and gen- tlemen, to his right and left, that both Judge and bar lost something of their usual imposing appearance, especially as both were without wigs and gowns on this occasion. The fifteen defendants filled the whole of the first of the floor benches usually allotted to spectators, but everywhere else the interested and the curious were packed in—ladies and gentlemen in about equal numbers, seated and standing—as many as the bench, the floor, and the aisles could comfortably accommo- date ; and the little room had more the ap- pearance of some academic feast-day than of a court of justice. The visitors were no bet- ter dressed than most of the defendants, to whom they nodded and smiled as lightly as if the whole affair were a splendid joke. With one exception the defendants also seemed to share the same delusion. That exception was Jameson himself, who came, first of the fif- teen, into the room, with a grave face, which showed a full appreciation of the seriousness of the case, and which never lightened for a moment. The others—most of them typical English gentlemen of the fashionable set— took the matter very jauntily ; and, sitting there in their long frock-coats, smooth-cheeked and well-groomed, seemed very unlikely per- sons to have gone rough-riding through a strange country in such a Quixotic adventure as they ended at Doornkop last January. Jameson has an interesting and by no means a bad face, though not as strong as one would expect. His eyes are fine—wide apart and rather pathetic—and he has a good big fore- head, perhaps a little exaggerated by bald- ness, but his mouth and chin do not look un- usually positive. He wears a brown mous- tache, trimmed close, and in age appears to be about forty. His eye is clear and his color good, but fatigue and care were evident from his whole appearance and demeanor. In physique he is thickset and short—quite the least imposing by far of the party; but he has the only intellectual face among them. Henry Frederick White, one of the leaders, is the handsomest of them, a tall, military man, with an air of good breeding and dis- tinction. The Hon. Robert White, the ‘* Bob- by” of the dispatches, is quite vacant-looking, as is also Capt. Coventry. Col. Grey is also handsome, in a way, but heavy; Sir John Willoughby looks intelligent enough, in all conscience, but his face is cynical and repel- lent. The Crown was represented by the Attor- ney-General, Sir Richard Webster, large of stature, déep of voice, and impressive. A le- gion of barristers appeared for the defence, notably Sir Edward Clarke, Sir Frank Lock- wood, and Mr. Gill. The proceedings were very slow, for the depositions of the witnesses were taken by the clerk in narrative form in longhand, to be sworn to and signed then and there; and the delay between question and answer or question and question would have made the most exciting story tame. Never- theless, some of the first day’s stories were exciting in spite of this, particularly the tale of a boyish Dutch lieutenant, who had been under arrest by Jameson’s column and had afterwards taken part in the first skirmish near Kriigersdorp, all of which he described simply and with much dignity. They met him on patrol duty, took his horse away, and disarmed him, and he asked them why they did, ‘‘when no war had been de. clared or anything”; he refused to tell them how many men he had, saying ‘‘ he did notsee how they could expect him to answer such a question.” They finally gave his horse back, and left him behind them on a two hours’ pa- role to stay where he was, at the close of which he joined the Boer forces and reached his battery at Krigergdorp ahead of them, where, he said, ‘‘some of them were killed and we beat them off.” After him came two or three Dutch officials, who produced the two large tin boxes, one black, one yellow, and the now famous lea- ther portfolio, stamped ‘‘ L. 8. J.”—the Pando- ra’s box which Oom Paul opened as a gift of plagues for all his enemies, These were found on the field at Doornkop, the fustian conspira- tors having left them for the heroes of the piece to discover, as naively as if they had been the villains of an ordinary British melo- drama. The proof as to the identity of boxes and contents was slow but interesting; and as paper after paper was put in evidence—letters to ‘dear Bobby” and others, dated in early November and December, full of arrange- ments for an early start; of solicitude for sound horses, mules, and plenty of ammuni- tion; of fears about Foley’s ‘‘blabbing”’ and. the premature disclosure of the plan; of the necessity for ‘drilling all the men inside out” —the little conspirators looked exceedingly foolish, and their leader put his hands over his crimson face and hid it for a long time. The spectators, however, heard the testimony as complacently as if it were all of a highly honorable nature, and seemed quite to miss the point of it. The magistrate had nothing to do, at the close of testimony so convinc- ing and carefully submitted, but to hold the six leaders for trial, under £2,000 bail each, and to discharge their dupes. Jameson, with a generosity that is said to be character- istic of him, and accounts in part for the de- votion he is capable of arousing, offered by counsel to be held alone responsible; but the evidence was so damaging against the Whites, Willoughby, Coventry, and Grey, that the of- fer could not avail them. The defence outlined by Sir Edward Clarke is distinctly a thin one—that the expedition started from Pitsani, outside British jurisdic- tion ; and that, though it was led by an officer in the British service, and recruited and armed on British soil, its place of final departure converts it into a sort of piratical raid from no-man’s land, which should have been pun- ished, if at all, by the Boers; and that it is not an offence of which the British courts are cognizant. No defence on the merits is longer possible; and even the excuse of chivalry and Hotspur thoughtlessness has been perforce abandoned. The Government appear to be acting in good faith, and so far to have proceeded with ability. The future alone can tell what they will do in the ensuing criminal trials, and what effect Jameson’s acquittal or conviction wil] have on the South African situation. Mean- while, the newspapers here grumble at Krii- ger, and even at the necessity of going further with Jameson, for whom they are now clamor. ing for a “fair trial.” The defects in the Boer Government are for ever harped on, and the iniquity of the conspiracy against that Government quite glossed over. One finds daily defences of Cecil Rhodes, open or covert, in the papers; and the street posters show how venial the people consider ‘‘Dr. Jim’s” offence. The truth is, that South Africa holds the im- agination of England, just now, as a sort of El Dorado, which must not be given up to Dutchmen or negroes. The progress of the Matabele war is proclaimed with trumpets; whole pages of the papers are given up to ad- vertisements of mining ventures and Cape in- vestment companies; a popular burlesque takes a head waiter turned millionaire at the Rand for its hero; and Mr. Barney Barnato— who, they say, was once a circus-clown—is now giving a touch of realism to all these fa- bles about the wealth of the Cape by erecting a very ostentatious house facing the Park. What all this will end in, no one knows; but the Jameson affair, a misdemeanor under the act, is at any rate no ordinary misdemeanor. It is already an historical one, and its end is not yet. L. McK. G. THE TRIUMPHS OF LEO XIII. IraLy, June 10, 1896. WHEN the present Pope (who, as chamber- lain after Antonelli’s death, exercised su- preme authority during the conclave) was the virtual head of the anti-Jesuit party, which, without formally renouncing the temporal power of the papacy, yet saw the wisdom of finding some modus vivendi with the civil au- thorities of the new kingdom of Italy, recog- nized as such by all European powers, it was confidently believed that, if elected Pope, he would carry out the intentions of his party. That he intended to do so is certain, but the Jesuits, the Intransigenti, prevailed against him and the moderate party, reinforcing the non-possumus of Pio Nono: and the Vatican, as far as Italy was concerned, was regarded as an enemy to be watched incessantly—not to be specially feared; one whose hostility was decidedly preferable to its friendship. There is no country in the world where religious in- difference amounts to the total oblivion of any religious question as in Italy. During more than forty yédrs’ residence and inti- macy with men of thought and intellect, I have never heard one purely religious discus- sion, and should not know to whom to address the question, ‘‘ What are the central doctrines of the Trinity and the Incarnation ?”—which, according to Mr. Gladstone, ninety-nine pro- fessing Christians out of a hundred believe in. What thoughtful, patriotic Italians dreaded was the dominion which, in exchange for a cessation of hostilities towards the royal au- thorities, would be given to the Church over education. Eighteen years have passed sinve Cardinal Pecci assumed the tiara, and ustensi- bly he has made no progress in this direction. Although the proclamation of universal, gra- tuitous, compulsory lay education has become a dead-letter in Italy, we have not yet heard that instruction in the catechism and attend- ance at mass are compulsory in State schools. Nevertheless, the Pope’s inordinate ambition, tenacity of purpose, persevering energy, vast learning, knowledge of human nature, and tact in dealing with it, have not been spent in vain: he is at the present moment the person most talked of, most looked up to in Europe. This fact, without awakening any really re- ligious emotion or reviving controversial dis- cussions, is one which appeals to that side of the Italian character which is neither its no- blest nor its highest— to national vanity. For some time past, all religious ceremonials have been revived throughout the kingdom. Though not expressly abolished by the law of 1847, religious processions had fallen into to- tal disuse. Prefects were allowed to forbid them if disturbance of the public peace was likely to follow, and they did forbid them; for in the days when the people believed that Ita- lian unity would give them a roof over their

Page 12

8 The Nation. ‘\ [Vol. 63, No. 1618 heads, clothes to their backs, and at least one good meal a day, priests, monks, sacristans, all the confraternity in short, were jeered at and even hissed. I remember, just fourteen years ago, on the very green opposite, a stand- up fight between the populace and the proces- sionists who, for the first time after sixteen years, ventured on a renewal of the cere- mony of transporting the Madonna from her own church to the place where she first ap- peared. In this fray the cross of a valu- able antique image of Christ was injured and broken. Now, on this last 4th of June, in the smallest village hamlet as in the largest city of the peninsula, the Corpus Do- mini procession paraded the streets in all its former grandeur. Even Bologna, the last stronghold of the opposition, celebrated it with extraordinary splendor, and in Rome, for the first time since [taly took possession of her capital, the Corpus Domini was accompa- nied in its triumphal procession by the entire populace. Italy, exclaims the Tribuna, in a bitterly sarcastic article, is transformed intoa cathedral: prostrate yourselves, Freemasons, free-thinkers, misguided patriots, kings, sol- diers, ministers of Italy ; the Church is tri- umpbant. Say the optimists: This means nothing but that our people have an unappeasable appe- tite for feasts and festivals and spectacles of every kind. This is true, but once they be- lieved that liberty would add some enjoyments to their hfe. Now, finding that the theatres, on which millions of the public money has be n expended, and which are maintained at public cost, hold no gratuitous places for them—nay, that often, as in the Politeamo of Palermo, the lowest price for sitting-room is five francs— they take their diversions where they cost them nothing. Leo XIII, therefore, was wise in his generation when he ordered ali the minor and major Churcb ceremonies to be celebrated throughout the land as in the days of yore, reéstablishing rigorous religious cere- monial at the Vatican court. Wiser still was his practical following up of his encyclical on the social question by enjoining on all the confraternities, the Catholic associations and clubs (circoli), the formation of mutual-aid societies, whose members, on contributing a very small monthly sum, are assisted in sick. ness and convalescence, of rural banks where the interest is not usurious, where loans are not granted to favorites, whose cashiers do not decamp with the funds. By these spec- tacular and mundane methods the Church is attracting the people back to its ample bosom. On the other hand, the terror inspired in all the property possessing classes by the spread of theoretical socialism and the practical orga- nization of the ‘* masses” by the leaders, has engendered in the authorities and in the **classes”’ a strong conviction of the necessity of finding a rallying-point whereon to take their stand and organize their forces for de- fence against the encroaching multitudes. You will remember Crispi's speech at Naples, in which, altering Mazzini’s famous formula of ‘God and the People,’’ he proclaimed the necessity of uniting with God and the King for the salvation of the country. Not only the Jesuits, but the entire Catholic Church, and, during his reign, Leo XIIL., have waged emphatic warfare against the Masonic order. The Pope’s encyclical of 1892 was one of the fiercest on record—and for good reason. For many years previous to 1860 the Freemasons, owing here to persecution and there to indifference, had become inert or acted in entirely private groups, of which the most important existed in Sicily and Naples. There were lodges in Calabria, in the Abruzzi, in Emilia, in Leghorn, in Liguria, in Pied- mont, Turin and Venetian Lombardy ; and in Rome existed, in strictest secrecy, the Fabio Massimo Lodge. Their object was chiefly political, the overthrow of existing govern- ments; but they were distinct one from the other, and had no common action. After the liberation of Naples and Sicily, the Dante Alighieri Lodge of Turin, to which most of the members of the old parliamentary Left belonged, set on foot a unitarian movement, founding the first Italian Great Eastern (Grand Oriente), which was accepted and re-. cognized by most of the Italian lodges at Florence in 1864. The supreme council of the: thirty-three, in Palermo, refused to ac- knowledge Masonic unity until Rome should be proclaimed the capital of united Italy, and the Supreme Council of the Thirty-three of Turin also retained its separate authority and was the lodge chiefly recognized by the Masons of other countries. After 1870, owing chiefly to the exertions of the old triumvir of Tuscany (tben Senator Mazzoni), and of Fre- deric Campanella, who, with Aurelio Saffi, was Mazzini's chief continuator, a constituent Masonic assembly was held in Rome in 1862. Most of the lodges adhered, Turin and Pa- lermo still holding aloof, the Thirty-three of Turin insisting on its supremacy as the sole recognized authority of the Masons who held the Scottish rite; but the Great Eastern, es- tablished in Rome, rallied to it the most nume- rous adherents. On the death of Petroni, who succeeded Mazzoni, they elected, as Grand Master of the Order, Adriano Lemmi, who, by the great ascendancy he had acquired through his life of patriotic exertion and his immense expenditure of his honestly earned wealth in patriotic and benevolent purposes, succeeded in procuring the fusion of all the lodges, even of the Supreme Council of Turin. The Assembly presided over by Aurelio Saffi established a sole supreme council of the thirty-three, with its seat in Rome. Lemmi, who remained Grand Master of the Great Eastern in Italy and chief of the Scottish rite, having established the central lodge in the magnificent apartments in the Borghese Pa- lace in Rome, made a tour of all the Italian lodges, delivering really magnificent speeches, in all of which Mazzini’s doctrines were enun- ciated and enforced (Garibaldi and Mazzini were both Freemasons), the moral preached being that all the efforts of martyrs and he- roes would be in vain unless the whole Italian people, redeemed from misery, ignorance, superstition, and crime, should be made par- takers of the benefits of unity and liberty. The Vatican was pointed to as the one enemy of Italian autonomy, of scientific, intellectual, and moral progress everywhere; hence the renewed thunders of the Vatican, and, as all the prominent Liberals of Italy were or be- came Freemasons, the Conservatives (who are mostly professing Catholics) rallied to the Op- position for a long time, covertly and silently. As this great Masonic organization was and is mainly political, though its vast funds are applied to secular education, to benevolent schemes, and to the direct assistance of needy and unfortunate brethren at home and abroad, not only did the Conservatives dread it, but parties, cliques, and ambitious individuals viewed it with increasing jealousy. A vio- lent attack, founded on an old, disproved ca- lumny, was made on the Grand Master by the | press, and even brought into the House of Commons. Adriano Lemmi, after laying be-. fore the Grand Council of the order every fact and document relating to his life and action, resigned. The members of this order, including Carducci, Rizzoli, Ceneri (the first jurisconsult in Italy), and other notabilities, after minute examination and mature discus- sion, declared that there was not a flaw to be found, and entreated him to withdraw his re. signation. He, however, in aletter made pub- lic last year, declared that it had never been his intention, once the discipline, finance, and organization of the Masonic forces were estab- lished on a broad basis, to retain in his own bands the double office of Grand Master of the Great Eastern and that of Grand Moderator of the Scottish rite; that to the latter he in- tended henceforward to dedicate his chief en- ergy, and they must decide upon his successor. Glad tidings of great joy were these to the opponents of Freemasonry, who shrewdly guessed that it would be difficult to find any other man who would devote such exceptional energy and such wealth to the support of the association. As soon, therefore, as Lemmi’s successor, Ernest Nathan, a staunch Mazzi- nian, was elected, the question of demolishing the Masonic society on the plea that it was a secret one, was brought before the House of Commons and the Senate. Tothe anti-Masons in the House Rudini replied that it was his intention to take careful but decisive steps against all secret and subversive associations (** Especially against us,” said the Socialists). In the Upper House Senator Rossi took up the cudgels, observing that societies exist whose aims and members are unknown to the public, which give their united support to ministers who are members of their association, and make equal opposition to those who are not. These were clever tactics, as the Masons were (up to the banking scandals certainly) Cris- pinos, to a man, nor has their support of Ru- dini been much to count on—not because he is not a member of the confraternity, but be- - cause he is a Conservative. Parenso, a Libe- ral Senator and one of the first and staunchest opponents of the African folly, agreed with Rossi as to the uselessness and possible harm of secret societies, but said that if they were to be extirpated, a just and logical Government must commence with the most widespread and deleterious, that of the Jesuits. Rudini repeated the declarations made in the House; he thought that the Freemasons ought to be- come a public association, that no secret so- cieties ought to exist, that the moment had not come when special provisions should be made, but that if necessity and an opportune mo- ment should occur, the Government would not shrink from taking the necessary steps. — e publication of Mr. Gladstone’s letter toner Anglican orders, announced in ost of the papers, is regarded as another great triumph of the reigning pontiff, al- though considerable confusion prevails as to what is meant by the validity of Anglican or- ders. One paper gravely informs us that, in the expectation of a speedy return of the An- glican churches to the bosom of Holy Mother Church, the Pope is anxious to facilitate the return of the prodigals by not insisting on their reordination. The story of the nego- tiations may be briefly summed up. Abouta year since a book maintaining the validity of Anglican orders was laid before the Pope. It showed great erudition and vigor. The Pope ordered the question to be studied with a view to decreeing the validity of the ordinations. The English Catholic bishops at once protest- ed, and brought to the Pope’s notice the fact that the book, written by the Jesuit Berroyer,

Page 13

July 2, 1896] The Nation. 9 had been condemned by the highest authori- ties and consigned to the Index. Cardinal Vaughan went deep into the matter, and sent the theologians Dr. Moyes, Dr. Gayquet, and Father David to Rome to inform the Pope that the decision of the English Catholic clergy was final—nay, that many of the English Ro- manists would be inclined to abjure allegiance should he recognize the Anglican orders. The Pope, who was decidedly compromised by bis expressed approval of Berroyer’s book, sub- mitted the question to the Holy Office, and the cardinals of this congregation also decid- ed against the validity, as did Cardinal Ga- limberti, who had so much influence with the Pope until his recent death. Not choosing to publish with his sanction the decree of the Holy Office, the Pope took the whole question into his own hands, rather to avoid than to reach a decision, and it is the general opi- nion at Rome that the matter will be allowed gradually todrop. When we remember how firmly Archdeacon Manning believed in the validity, held that he was already a priest, and yet was compelled to admit that in the eyes of the real Church he had only been a simple layman, we can understand the sweep- ing condemnation of Cardinal Vaughan, and, while comprehending the extreme anxiety of the high Anglicans for a recognition by Rome of the validity of Anglican orders, we doubt their satisfaction being shared by .the large body of Anglican or Dissenting Protestants. These, while anxious to strengthen the forces of faith and the Church against ‘‘secular- ists and Unitarians,” as Hugh Cecil put it in his bitterly sectarian speech on the Edu- cation bill, are not yet clearly prepared to approve steps which are certainly an advance towards a reunion with Rome. The triumph scored for the Pope lies in the cordial senti- ments of ‘‘ reverence, gratitude, and high ap- preciation” expressed in Mr. Gladstone’s let- ter, which has been transmitted to Cardinal Rampolla, the Pope’s intransigente secretary of state. A far more important triumph will be ob- tained if his Holiness succeeds in inducing Menelik to liberate and restore the Italian prisoners detained in Shoa. The Osservatore Romano of the second inst, announced the de- spatch of a letter from the Pope to the Negus, urging the release of the prisoner. To-day’s papers affirm that Menelik has already con- signed them to Makonnen, who will send them to Zeila, where they will be embarked on English vessels sent to Massowah and thence to Italy. Should the prisoners be restored to their country and their homes, through the intervention of Leo XIII., a sense of the power and might of the Church superior to that of the civil arm will mingle in a very large degree with the joy and gratitude with which the unfortunate victims of the insane African policy will be welcomed by their families and their countrymen. J. W. M. Correspondence. MINNESOTA AND SOUND MONEY. To THE EpiToR OF THE NATION: Sir: In connection with the strong senti- ment in Minnesota in favor of sound money there are some facts which are encouraging. Minnesota has had a campaign of education on the subject of sound finance, and the results show. x: In 1858 the State, by direct vote of the peo- ple, issued railroad bonds to the amount of $2,275,000. The bonds were to be paid to the company at $10,000 per mile, one-half for grading and one-half for completed track. The company, instead of straightforward work, picked out easy places and left all the difficult ones, so that nothing of real value was done, and no consecutive miles of road were finished when they failed, leaving the State nothing to show for its more than two million dollars indebtedness. Times were very hard, the population was small, and for some years nothing could be done. Then the war came on, and Minnesota did her full share for the country besides quelling an Indian out- break within the State. By the time prosperity had returned, a new population had come in—people who knew no- thing about these old bonds except that they represented a railroad swindle. The interest which, by agreement, the railroad company was to take care of, accumulated until in 1881 the whole amount, principal and interest, was $8,400,000. Demagogues were fond of de- nouncing the idea that the State was respon. sible for these bonds, and hardly one man in one hundred could be found who would con- sent to their redemption, much less advocate it. But a champion came who was honest and fearless and persistent, and the sound finan- cial sentiment of Minnesota to-day is his re- ward. When Goy. John §., Pillsbury, in his first message in 1876, advocated the payment of the bonds, to use his own words, ‘‘everybody look- ed black.” This first term was the time of the grasshopper plague. Gov. Pillsbury, by his personal kindness and his efficient aid, travel- ling throughout the State to get information and give assistance, advocating plans for re- lief and carrying out schemes for prevention, won the hearts of the people. But while he was administering to their necessities, he never lost an opportunity to urge them not to dis- grace the State by dishonesty. His business ability, which rescued the University and saved the State large sums in other ways, won him esteem, and he was reélected in spite of his persistent advocacy of the payment of the bonds. But, even in his second term, a measure looking towards payment was over- whelmingly defeated. The stanchest friends of the measure, ex-Govs. Sibley and Marshall and Mr. Horace Thompson—men who felt that they would move out of the State if its credit was dishonored—were now almost ready to give up. Senator Windom and Senator Mc. Millan were openly taunted with representing a repudiating State. But Gov. Pillsbury re- solved to fight it out, and strong friends ral- lied round him. His personal popularity was thrown into the scale, and had great weight, but still a large majority of the people re- garded the bonds as ‘‘a steal,” and could not see that the honor of the State was at stake, no matter how unjust had been the dealings of the railroad company. At last the Legislature was induced to au- thorize a commission part of whose duty it was to pronounce on the legality of the bonds. Perhaps the most discouraging thing in the whole struggle was the fact that one after an- other of the district judges, fearing the unpopu- larity of a decision they knew they must ren- der, declined to serve on this commission. But at last five honest judges were found. Before they could render a decision, the opponents of payment brought action to prevent the re- ference to the commission. This threw the whole question into the Supreme Court, and a straight-out decision was rendered in favor of the validity of the bonds. In the mean- time the holders of the bonds, who knew very well that the State had reason to complain of the value it had received, offered to accept one-half the amount in new bonds. Now came the final tug of war. Mr. Joseph Wheelock, editor of the St. Paul Pioneer Press, then, as now, honest to the core, was, through. out the whole struggle, a tower of strength, and he was ably supported by the Minneapolis Tribune and by nearly all the papers of the two cities. They brought forward every ar- gument that could affect character or interest, and at last, by herculean effort on the part of all the friends of redemption, the Legislature voted to issue the new bonds. This was in the fall of 1881, just before the maturing of the old paper. Gov. Pillsbury, who had now served his third term and declined another, had to work early and late to get the bonds signed before the expiration of his term, for he was succeeded by a man who was not in sympathy with the payment. So, by the skin of the teeth, the measure was carried through. But the glory of it, the prosperity and high financial standing which it gave the State, could be appreciated by all; and that is why Minnesota is sound on the money question to- day. A. L. MINNEAPOLIS, June 24, 1896, INTERNATIONAL ARBITRATION, To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION : Sir: The following passage, which I have just come across in Chateaubriand’s ‘Génie du Christianisme’ (vol. ii., p. 271), would seem to indicate that the idea of an international court of arbitration is not new: ‘* Sil existait, au milieu de l'Europe, un tri- bunal qui juge&t, au nom de Dieu, les nations et les monarques, et qui prévint les guerres et les révolutions, ce tribuaal serait le chef- d’couvre de la politique et le dernier degré de la perfection sociale.” Yours truly, WESLEYAN UNIVERSITY, MIDDLETOWN, Conn., June 26, 1896. L. Oscar Kuagns, JOHN SPARKS, OF PIKE’S EXPEDI- TION. To THE EpIToR OF THE NATION : Sir: In January, 1807, when Capt. Z. M. Pike was struggling to cross the Sangre de Cristo Mountains of present Colorado, several of his party were frost-bitten. Two of them, Jobn Sparks and Thomas Dougherty, were abandoned with frozen feet January 22, as it was impossible for them to proceed further. Pike afterward received, from one or both of these men, some of the small .bones of the feet which had come away with the sphacelus that had set in. These men were rescued eventually, but never rejoined him in his tour through Mexico, and at the close of his book remain unaccounted for, together with five or six others left behind in Mexico. It has al- ways been supposed, no doubt correctly, that nearly or quite all of them regained the United States ; but I have hitherto seen nothing de- finite upon the subject, excepting that the Nation’s reviewer of my edition of Pike’s ‘ Travels’ mentions the finding of the name of one of them on rolls of the War Department subsequent to 1807. But now John Sparks turns up, thoroughly identified by name, by his stumpy feet, and by local tradition of his connection with Pike’s expedition. This in- formation is given me in several letters from

Page 14

10 ‘The Nation. [Vol. 63, No. 1618 Mr. A. H. Wilcox, of C. P. Wilcox & Co., lumber merchants, Frazee, Minn. In 1854 Mr. Wilcox went to Licking County, Ohio, and soon became county surveyor. The name of ‘‘old John Sparks" was then a house- hold word there. Mrs. Wilcox, now a woman of sixty-five years of age, knew him well. She first saw bim when she was a child about eight years old, and had been sent to watch a gap in a fence through which hay was being haul- ed out, to keep the cattle from straying in. She was frightened at his psculiar dress and appearance as he came hobbling along, but was reassured by being told that that was ‘only old John Sparks,” who would hurt no- body. She remembers him as a man of me- dium height, slender and wiry, with remarka- bly piercing eyes, who managed to get along as well as anybody, though both his feet were partly gone; and perfectly recalls the stories that were rife of his adventures with Pike, as well as the general complaint in the neighbor- hood that he killed more than his share of tur- keys and pigeons, in spite of his crippled con- dition. He was a Virginian by birth, and at the time of which I am speaking was a pen- sioner; he used to go regularly to Newark, the county seat, to draw his pension, and in pass- ing would stop over night at her house (her people being also Virginians), but could never be persuaded to go to bed, as he preferred to roll up in a blanket on the porch. When the Mexican war broke out, he was on hand to en- list, but was rejected on account of age and the partial loss of his feet. He was quite une- ducated, and, like many others of his class, was fond of indulging in flights of rhetoric. On the completion of the Sandusky and New- ark Railroad, before it was open to the public, he was given a free ride on the locomotive, and never afterward tired of describing this trip on an “‘ enginuity,’’ which had caused in him a settled conviction that the works of ““nacher” were wonderful, but the works of art “‘wonderfuller.” Mrs. Wilcox remembers his military funeral, as he was buried with the honors of war, and the passing by of the squad of soldiers in uniform, with drum and fife, impressed her mind. This was circa 1850, when he was about seventy years of age. ELLIoTT Cougs. 1726 N Street, WASHINGTON, D.C. LiTfrLE, BRown & Co. have just issued, in advance of completion of Prof. J. B. Thayer’s ‘Preliminary Treatise on Evidence at Com- mon Law,’ Part i., which deals with the ‘‘ De. velopment of Trial by Jury.” Edward Arnold’s announcements for speedy publication include ‘The Cruise of the Ant arctica: A Voyage to the South Polar Regions in 1895,’ by H. J. Bull, and ‘Persia Revisited (1895), by Gen. Sir Thomas Edward Gordon, K.C.LE., etc.—both works provided with il- lustrations and maps. A book on Japan, by W. E. Curtis; ‘The Thlinkets of Southeastern Alaska,’ by Francis Knapp and Reta Louise Child; and (in the fall) ‘ A College Year-book,’ are forthcoming publi- cations of Stone & Kimball. D. Appleton & Co. will bring out ‘ Familiar Trees and their Leaves,’ by F. Schuyler Mat- thews,’ with illustrations, and an American historical romance, ‘Sir Mark: A Tale of the First Capital,’ by Miss Anne Robeson Brown. Ginn & Co. have in press ‘Glaciers of North America,’ by Prof. Israel C. Russell of the University of Michigan. Last year we had a reprint in four handy volumes of Thomas Shelton’s translation of ‘Don Quixote,’ prompted by Mr. Justin Hunt- ly McCarthy, and now Mr. James Fitzmau- rice-Kelly has taken it in hand for Mr. David Nutt’s superb series of Tudor Transla- tions, and half the work is before us, namely, volumes i. and ii. Apart from typography, the two editions differ in the spelling, which is modernized in Mr. McCarthy’s; but Mr. Fitzmaurice-Kelly impliesthat the sources are different also, and avers that he now reprints ‘‘for the first time from the excessively rare edition of 1612,” the editio princeps. Such random comparison as we have made would point to identity, but we will not dispute the present editor, who in a liberal Introduction sketéhes the life of Cervantes, tells what is known of Shelton and of the circumstances of his version, confirms the claim of the Brussels edition of 1607 to be the one used by Shelton, and points out some of his errors of haste or ignorance along with instances of his felicity in truly rendering the original. will prize Shelton in his new dress. On the first page of volume ii. a significant no has been dropped before lesse in the eleventh line of the first paragraph. With the eighth volume Mr. Henry B. Wheatley finishes the editing of ‘The Diary of Samuel Pepys’ proper (London: Bell; New York: Macmillan), with its pathetic ending in view of the condition of the diarist’s eyes, of which he could never ‘‘command the plea. sure.” No other portion of the work more perfectly reveals the man in his private ca- pacity, or presents more curious material for reflection to the moralist. Mr. Wheatley has now in hand a ninth volume, embracing an Introduction; a paper on the London of Pepys’s time; corrections of some of the notes; a corrected pedigree; appendixes; and an ela- borate index. He also intimates that he may annotate hereafter Pepys’s numerous letters. The present volume contains portraits of Monk and of Charles If. The bound volume of the Century from No- vember to April last is not easy to characterize in a few words ; but as the sheets of our topo- graphic atlases are designated by some larger town in the field, this volume might be fixed in time by Prof. Bryce's article on the ‘ Ar- menian Question,” or by Prof. Allan Mar- quand’s illustrated paper on ‘‘The Old Olym.- pic Games” in connection with an editorial article on the New. To be remarked also are J. G. Vibert’s poetic little autobiography and expanded picture-labels for the baker’s-dozen of his paintings here engraved; a story by Kipling ; ‘‘A Midsummer Night,” by Benja- min Kidd, who essays the réle of Thoreau and his imitators. The poetry of the volume is signed by many well-known names, and reaches its high-water mark, we think, in Mr. Woodberry’s lines to his brother-profes sor Jackson. But, altogether, in the case of this magazine as of its rivals nowadays, one echoes Miss Thomas’s desire for ‘‘the era of rich verse again.” Mr. Hamilton, in ‘Across an Ulster Bog’ (Edward Arnold), gives us one of the stories of Irish life, truest to nature of the many we have read of late years. A character such as that of Mr. Duffin is, we trust, an anomaly in even the fiction relating to the Irish Church, and the culmination of the tragedy is too hor- rible. But the delineations of character, the conversations, the tender touches, the de- scriptions of scenery are admirable. The Everybody’ reader will not soon forget Ellen and her father, Miss McFadden, Mary Anne and her dogs. The narrative never drags; we are car- ried on irresistibly from opening to finish. This little book is especially interesting in that it depicts life among the poor of the Protes- tant population of Ulster. But why should these Irish sketches so uniformly be sombre or sad? Surely the sun shines in Ireland as else- where, and life there is not without its bright- ness, its joys, its successes. An abridgment of Mr. H. 8. Salt’s ‘Life of Thoreau’ appears in the ‘“‘ Great Writers” edit- ed by Eric Robertson and Frank T. Marzials (London: Walter Scott; New York: Scrib- ners). It is chiefly noticeable—apart from its readableness—on account of a Thoreau bibli- ography compiled by John P. Anderson of the British Museum. This extends to nine pages and more than two hundred titles—a sufficient proof of the interest of the subject. Mr. Salt’s Life, which appeared, in England only, in a fuller form, six years ago, does not, so far as we perceive, throw any new light on Thoreau. Of course, as an admirer, he strongly objects to Lowell’s view of his hero, and assures the reader that it is alla mistake to suppose that he imitated Emerson or was an egotist. If not an egotist, Mr. Salt should add a new word to the dictionary framed to describe the quality which leads a man to declare that, after living some thirty years on this planet, he has “ yet to hear a word of valuable advice from his elders.” It is not only students of ecclesiastical his- tory who will be benefited by Messrs. Gee and Hardy’s ‘Documents Illustrative of English Church History’ (Macmillan Co.), but all who desire to follow the development of political life in England ; for in the Middle Ages it is impossible to dissociate the sacred and the pro- fane. The Statutes of Mortmain, of Provisors, and of Premunire were acts of statesmanship exercising a wide influence on the community in general, and there were few measures of more importance in the stormy seventeenth century than the Solemn League and Cove- nant, the Five-Mile Act, the Test Act, the Bill of Rights, and the Toleration Act. The one hundred and twenty-four documents here printed are gathered from a wide range of publications, accessible as a whole to few scholars, and it is a real service to sound learning to collect and present them in a handy shape. Many students would have pre- ferred them in the original language, but it is perhaps a prudent concession to the multitude to give them in translations. Both the subject and treatment of Bright- man’s ‘Liturgies, Eastern and Western,’ of which volumei., containing the Eastern Li- turgies, has just been issued (Oxtord: Claren- don Press; New York: Macmillan), are too technical for detailed notice here, but acknow- ledgment is due to the author for the learning and thoroughness with which he has handled his complex theme. Even those not specialists can, however, find interest in the glossaries, where they will learn how many forms the Christian ritual can assume. f The exceptional number of periodic comets renders very acceptable the new and fourth edition of Mr. W. T. Lynn’s ‘Remarkable Comets’ (London: Edward Stanford), it be- ing the only popular monograph on these ex- traordinary bodies. Not only are periodic comets treated, but also those which may be considered remarkable either on account of their brilliant physical appearance, or because of any other circumstance respecting them. The scope of the work is almost purely histori-

Page 15

July 2, 1896] The Nation. 11 cal. The comets connected with the great me- teoric displays are not omitted, nor those in- teresting comets seen on a single occasion only, during total eclipses of the sun—in 1882 in Egypt and in 1893 in Chili. It is somewhat singular, too, although the coincidence has not been remarked, that during two previous eclipses, also at eleven years’ interval (1871 and 1860), comets are thought to have been de- picted in the streamers of the corona. Mr. Lynn touches lightly on the subject of the composition of comets, and concludes his valua- ble treatise with a list of the dates inthe order of the next returns of those periodic comets now expected to reappear. Only one or two of these are likely to exhibit extraordinary brilliancy, such as any comet from the inter- stellar spaces casually encountering the solar system may do. Small as the monograph is, its author has not neglected to provide a brief index. A new ‘Paris Directory’ for 1896 comes to us from the compiler and publisher, Donald Downie, 61 Rue du Faubourg St.-Honoré. It is convenient for the pocket, and consists of a guide for sightseers, with directories of the diplomatic corps and of the residential section (Anglo-American chiefly), and much miscel- laneous information concerning railroads, ho- tels, cafés, etc. The theatres are so exhibited (in perspective, not in plan) that one can read- ily choose his numbered seat A recent issue of the Berlingske Tidende of Copenhagen contains an account of a new en- terprise of the leading Icelandic publisher, ‘Sigurdur Kristjanssop, who is now bringing out a cheap edition of all the Icelandic sagas. The latest issue from the Reykjavik press is a series of biographies of twenty leading Ice- landers, in as many volumes, of which two have already appeared. The subjects of these first two volumes are the historian Jon Espo lin and the poet Magnus Jonsson. The first work consists in part of an autobiography, originally written in Danish, translated and completed by Espolin’s favorite pupil, Gisli Konradsson. An interesting feature is the in- troduction by Dr. Jon Thorkelsson, describing the life of the Icelandic students at the Uni- versity of Copenhagen during the middle of the last century. From the biography it ap- pears that Espolin was born in 1769. After spending three years in Denmark, where he made an unsuccessful attempt to obtain a per- manent official position, he returned to Ice- land and became Syssellmand or judge in various districts of the island. His most im- portant literary work is ‘ Arbekur Islands,’ in thirteen volumes, which treats of the his- tory of Iceland from 1262 to 1832. Besides being the foremost Icelandic historian of modern times, Espolin may be regarded as the father of modern Icelandic prose. Of Magnus Jonsson’s life and works less is known, as he lived in the sixteenth century. Unlike the majority of his fellow-poets, Jonsson was very wealthy, and, both on account of his polite- ness and his sumptuous retinue, he received the surname of the Magnificent. The book contains many contemporary documents which throw light on obscure points. In se- lecting the subjects for the later volumes, an attempt will be made to include prominent Icelanders whose lives are comparatively un- known to ordinary readers. A year ago the Bunker Hill Monument As- sociation held a memorial service in celebra- tion of the hundredth anniversary of the death of Col. William Prescott, who commanded in the battle. The orator of the occasion was Dr. William Everett, and his address has just been printed by the Association. It was when delivered an admirable peace tract, but its worth and timeliness have been vastly aug- mented by the Jingo mania under which we have labored for the past six months. Dr. Everett aptly defends the fitness of his invoca- tion of international peace in a commemora- tion of Bunker Hill by instancing the call of Webster to be orator in 1843, at the dedication of the monument, just after he had concluded the unpopular extradition and boundary trea- ties with England. Dr. Everett’s address was mainly historic, but the weight of it is in his fervid denunciation of war, which may fairly be called prophetic. The seventh Bulletin of the Bureau of Rolls and Library of the Department of State pro- ceeds with the miscellaneous index to the pa- pers of these depositories, in which each item is a précis of the document recorded. We miss here a repetition of the personal name (or other rubric) at the head of a page when a number of items are ‘“‘let in” with a dash. The bulk of the Bulletin, however, consists of ‘‘The Amendments to the Constitution and Ratifications by the Several States,” forming Part iv. of the ‘Documentary History of the Constitution, 1786-1870,’ and concluding vol- ume ii. Capital topographic draftsmanship and a cultivated graphic style distinguish Mr. Bol- ton Coit Brown’s paper, ‘‘ A Trip about the Headwaters of the Middle and South Forks of King’s River,” in the eighth Sierra Club Bul- letin (Academy of Science Building, San Fran- cisco). There is a brief description, with pho- tographic views, of an ascent of Mt. Le Conte, and the other articles convey practical infor- mation for the Sierra mountaineer. In the Scottish Geographical Magazine for June Mr. G. 8. Fort gives an encouraging ac- count of Rhodesia as a grazing and farming country. The want of machinery has pre- vented the development of the extensive gold areas which have been discovered, but he looks forward with confidence to the not dis- tant time when its output of gold “will equal, if not exceed, that from the Rand.” The success of this industry, however, de- pends wholly upon obtaining reliable native labor. In the Transvaal this is becoming in- creasingly difficult on account of the treat- ment of the natives by the Boers. ‘ Mar- riage rights are not recognized. A native Christian woman properly married in the Cape Colony loses all conjugal rights, even the position of wife, as soon as she goes to re- side in the Transvaal.” ‘‘If more than five fa- mnilies settle on any piece of ground, they are broken up, practically, and handed over as slaves to the surrounding farmers.” They are denied the ordinary rights of justice, and ‘‘are abie to buy drink.” Mr. A. Silva White, in a paper on aérial navigation, says that his ten years’ experiences in ballooning show that ‘‘a flying-machine, heavier than the air and capable of withstanding the im- pact of the wind, is the only promising air- ship of the future.” The great difficulty with Mr. Maxim’s aéroplane, he thinks, lies in the fact that there is no ‘‘automatic mechanism which will enable it, without altering its di- rection,” to pass from one air-current into an- other blowing in an opposite direction. Herr Andrée’s project of reaching the North Pole by balloon is characterized ‘‘as foolhardy in the extreme, even suicidal.” The latest statistics of suicide in Germany from 1881 to 1894, published by Georg G. Mayr in the ‘Allgemeiner Statistischer Archiv’ (Tibingen: Laupp), show a startling increase in the number of self-murders during these thirteen years—from 8,987 to 11,112, an in- crease far greater than that of the population during the same period. It is also a curious fact that about four times as many men com- mit suicide as women. This disparity is due, in part at least, to the prevalence of suicide in the rank and file of the army as the result, in most cases, of maltreatment, but cannot be thus wholly accounted for. In England the proportion is somewhat less, being about three men to one woman. Evidently the female sex is either more patient in bearing those ills we have, or less resolute in flying to others that we know not of. The German is reputed to be phlegmatic, and is certainly less vivacious than the Frenchman, but is irascible, and easily loses his self-control on slight provoca- tion. This is especially true of the lower classes. We may add that these statistics do not include unsuccessful attempts at suicide, but only actual deaths. The Prussian Minister of Instruction has re- cently issued a circular stating the conditions on which women can be permitted to attend the lectures in the University of Berlin. In the first place they must obtain permission from the Minister of Instruction, and in their request for this official document must state what studies they intend to pursue and what lectures they wish to attend; they must also give an account of the nature and extent of their preparatory instruction and of their ‘personal relations,” whatever that may mean. After these testimonials have been ex- amined and the certificate of permission se- cured, they are to make application to the professors or tutors directly concerned. The rector’s certificate must be renewed every se- mester, and should always be carried in the pocket, as it may be called for at any time. Only candidates for a degree are provided with the Anmeldungsbuch. These concessions to women indicate no little progress, although necessarily accompanied, in bureaucratic Prussia, with the unwinding of considerable red tape. On May 16 six women took the de- gree of M.D. at the University of Brussels, of whom five were English and one a German from Berlin, who passed her examination ‘* with great distinction.” The coat of mail presented to Joan of Arc by Charles III. has been discovered in the Vatican. Hefore the death of the Maid of Orleans this coat of mail came into the pos- session of the Marquis de Courvel. Later it was brought to Rome, where it remained ap- parently unnoticed among other articles from the Middle Ages, until a descendant of the old marquis, after having obtained the necessary permission, conducted a search with the result noted above. The Norwegian Storthing has passed a bill introduced by Emil Stang, the former Conser- vative prime minister, providing for the ex- ercise of the right of suffrage by Norwegian sailors while on voyages. The measure, which was passed without regard to party feeling, has received the unqualified endorsement of the class it is intended to benefit. —Historical students have awaited with in- terest the appearance of the complete compi- lation of the messages, proclamations, and in- augural addresses of the Presidents from 1789 to 1897, authorized by concurrent resolutions of Congress. The importance of this under- taking was recognized by the editor, Mr. James D. Richardson, Representative from Tennessee, who says: ‘“‘ The utmost effort has been made to make the compilation accurate

Page 16

12 The Nation. [Vol. 63, No. 1618 and exhaustive.” The first volume, 1789-1817, covers the first fourteen Congresses, whose pa- pers are almost inaccessible. It shows that Mr. Richardson has been unfortunate in his assistants, and that the work is badly planned, inaccurate, and incomplete. The arrange- ment is roughly by sessions of Congress, and the papers are arranged chronologically for each session under four sub-headings, viz., Annual, Special, and Veto Messages, and Pro- clamations. To find a given document is very difficult, as the volume of six hundred pages is not indexed. Mr. Richardson announces that from this ‘‘complete compilation” he bas omitted messages nominating persons to office, transmitting treaties, and transmitting re- ports of heads of departments, though in fact he has not rigidly followed this rule. Rou- tine nominations and regular, formal reports might properly be neglected, but the omission of messages relating to treaties, and to special reports of the highest importance, renders the collection incomplete and unsatisfactory. | Moreover, apart from these, some fifty impor- tant messages have been incomprehensibly omitted, for it is only necessary to follow page by page the journals of Congress to make a complete list of the messages. The following schedule illustrates the character and importance of the missing messages: Sep- tember 26, 1789, Rhode Island desires to main- tain friendly relations with the United States ; June 14, 1790, Ratification of constitutional amendments by New Hampshire; June 14, 1790, Similar action by Maryland; December 80, 1793, Affairs with Spain; January 15 and 16, 1794, Relations with France, being the im- portant messages on the Genet incident; Ja- nuary 22, 1794, Relations with Great Britain; March 12, 1794, Relations with Spain; March 25, 1794, American commerce; May 23 and June 4, 1794, Relations with Great Britain; January 12, 1795, On Indian troubles; Febru- ary 29, 1796, Negotiations for a treaty with Spain; June 24, 1797, Relations with Algiers; January 29, 1798, Explanatory article of treaty with Great Britain; June 5 and June 18, 1798, Two important messages on relations with France; December 13, 1799, Relations with Tunis; February 17, 1800, Negotiations with Prussia; December 22, 1800, Confidential in- structions to Envoy to France; December 6, 1804, On public buildings at Washington. To add to this list is needless. —It is to be regretted that, as Mr. Richard. son prints a letter of Louis XVI.’s on Jeffer- son’s quitting the French court, and other extraneous matter relating to Jefferson’s ser- vice in France, he did not print with the message of January 26, 1791, the letter from the French Assembly regarding its three days’ mourning for Benjamin Franklin, as the title of the message conveys no idea of its subject-matter. The letter of Thomas Jeffer- son, President-elect, fixing the time and place 4 for taking the oath of office, is published, but a similar letter of John Adams, laid before the Senate February 9, 1797, is omitted. It is to be hoped that Mr. Richardson will supply the missing messages by errata pages in vol- ume ii. The unsystematic method of compila- tion is indicated by the failure to find Wash- ington’s proclamations of March 1, 1791, and March 1, 1795, until the volume was practi- cally completed, so that they were printed on an errata sheet. Adams’s proclamation of July 16, 1798, convening the Senate in extra session, is omitted, and the proclamation of July 16, 1803, is drawn from a newspaper, as are others, instead of being taken from official publications. Madison’s proclamation of De- cember 22, 1815, in connection with the very important commercial convention with Great Britain (see message of December 23), is also wanting. The excision of the treaty of Ghent from the proclamation of February 18, 1815, emasculates the document. The following messages of President Washington, which are printed as being addressed to the Senate alone, were addressed and sent to both houses of Con- gress, namely, August 7, August 10, September 16, and two of September 29, 1789. Mr. Rich- ardson has incorporated the Declaration of Independence, Articles of Confederation, and the Constitution. The illustrations are typo- graphically unsuited to the volume, and the biographies of the Presidents are unsatisfac- tory. Washington’s grandfather, Lawrence, is said to have come to Virginia in 1657, whereas it was his great-grandfather, John Washington. —In 1889 the Historical Society of Pennsyl- vania authorized the publication of the writ- ings and correspondence of John. Dickinson, “the penman of the Revolution.” The first fruit of this undertaking was Stillé’s ‘Life and Times of Dickinson,’ published in 1891, and reviewed at length in these columns at that time; we now have the first of three vol- umes of the ‘ Writings,’ edited for the Society by Paul Leicester Ford. While the present collection does not claim absolute complete- ness, owing in part to the inability of the editor to obtain access to some of the Dickin- son papers, and in part to his wise decision to exclude broadsides and newspaper pieces whose authorship could not be determined by other evidence than that of style, Mr. Ford assures us that such omissions as there may be are probably of ‘‘small moment,” and “ that the present edition includes all that is essen- tial and important of Dickinson’s works.” As the only other collection of Dickinson’s writ- ings, that compiled by himself and published in 1801, contains less than a third of his works, and is no longer very accessible, the present edition is certain to make a valuable addition tu available material for the study of the pe- riod which it covers. About a third of this first volume is taken up with the speeches and published writings of Dickinson, in connection with the agitation in Pennsylvania, in 1764, for a change in the government of the colony —a movement to which he was vehemently opposed, and against which he fought vigor- ously, but without success. Besides the great speech of May 24, we have Dickinson’s protest against the petition drafted by Franklin and adopted by the Assembly, his scathing ar- raignment of Galloway in an elaborate reply to the latter’s ‘‘pretended speech,” his sa- tirical ‘‘ Receipt to make a Speech,” and his protest against the appointment of Franklin as additional agent of the colony in England. To this last protest Franklin, though on the eve of his departure, felt bound to reply. Dickinson’s rejoinder, closing his side of the controversy, is here printed for the first time. —In the discussion aroused by the Stamp Act, the revenue acts, and other coercive measures Dickinson was a leading participant. He prepared the original draft of the resolu- tions adopted September 21, 1765, by the Pennsylvania Assembly, on the Stamp Act, and the “ Declaration of Rights” and ‘‘ Peti- tion to the King” put forth by the Stamp Act Congress, besides publishing, later in the same year, a short ‘ Address to Friends and Coun- trymen,” and a pamphlet on the ‘‘ Late Regu- lations respecting the British Colonies.” A garbled version of the letter of the Barbados Committee of Correspondence in 1766, in which, by a misprint, or worse, the American colonies were charged with ‘‘ rebellious” in- stead of “present” opposition, gave Dickin- son an occasion for stating more in detail the position of the colonies, and of repelling ac- cusations of disloyalty ; while in 1768 appear- ed the most popular and influential of all his writings up to that time, the ‘‘ Letters of a Farmer.” In the heat of controversy and in- vective over the conduct of Great Britain, there had come to be, as Mr. Ford points out in his introductory note, much confusion of arguments, and not a little difficulty in at- tempting to reconcile perfect independence in taxation and perfect loyalty to the crown ; and the ‘Letters of a Farmer,” with their distinction between ‘‘external” and ‘‘inter- nal” taxation, seemed to point to a common ground upon which all the patriot party could stand, The distinetion was a shadowy one at best, but it undoubtedly served a tem- porary purpose and helped on the cause of union, upon whose necessity Dickinson re- peatedly insisted. As the conflict approach- ed, however, the essential limitations of Dick- inson’s mind, and in particular the curious hesitancy at critical moments which was later to- turn public opinion against him, began to appear, and one is almost forced to believe that he failed to see the natural and inevita- ble outcome of the steps he was doing much to hasten. While urging uncompromising resistance to the aggressions of Great Britain, he insisted upon the adoption of peaceable measures only, declared again and again that the only hope of prosperity for the colonies lay in union with the mother country, and refused to consider the possibility of inde- pendence. So he threw himself into the movement for non-imporiation, and drew up, in 1771, a petition from the Pennsylvania Assembly to the King, while attacking the tea tax in two letters published in 1773, and in 1774 once more reviewing the controversy in four ‘‘ Letters to the Inhabitants of the Bri- tish Colonies.” —Mr. J. P. Gordy, professor of pedagogy at Athens, Ohio, has compiled ‘A History of Political Parties in the United States,’ in three volumes, of which volume one, covering the period from 1787 to 1809, has been issued at Athens by the Ohio Publishing Co., and, according to the preface, the book is written primarily for the teacher ‘‘ who has not had the advantage of a higher education.” The author says: ‘‘ Until normal-school training is required of American teachers, a considera- ble part of their training must be obtained through private study.” The book is there- fore intended for the “thoughtful reader without much previous knowledge of the sub- ject.” Mr. Gordy wishes to concentrate the attention of the unqualified teacher, desirous of learning how to teach history, on ‘‘ those phases of history which it is important for American citizens to know in order that they may perform their duties as American citizens intelligently.”” He also hopes that the book may commend itself to some of ‘‘that large class "—business as well as professional men— who are ‘‘ beginning to realize that the present has its roots in the past.” To judge by the present volume, the book may be read not only by beginners, but by almost anybody, with profit. It is written in a clear and sim- ple style, is entirely non-partisan, and makes the causes of the early party struggles much

Page 17

July 2, 1896] The Naticen-: 18 clearer than many a more elaborate account. We have space but for two criticisms. The exact nature of the relations between the judi- ciary and the legislature might be made plainer. Again, the author seems to think (following Prof. Burgess’s treatise on ‘ Politi- cal Science and Constitutional Law’) that it is only the force of public opinion which, after a law has been, in a given case, held unconsti- tutional, operates to prevent the executive or the legislature from enforcing it in other cases. This is a mistaken view. When a court of last resort holds a statute unconstitu- tional, the effect is to wipe the law off the statute-book, and the moment the judgment is pronounced, any official who attempts further enforcement lays himself open, if he interferes with private rights, to a civil action in which he may be subjected to heavy dama- ges. It is common sense and the fear of the consequences that make people refrain from trying to carry into effect laws once held to be void. The judiciary is, with us, above the legislature as to these matters — not codrdi- nate with it. . MACAN’S HERODOTUS. Herodotus: The Fourth, Fifth, and Sixth Books, with Introduction, Notes, Appendi- ces, and Maps. By Reginald Walter Macan, M.A. Macmillan & Co. Sr1ncE the learned and comprehensive work of Rawlinson, this is undoubtedly the most im- portant English contribution towards a scien- tific study and sympathetic appreciation of the labors of the Father of History. Some good excuse should be offered for the appear- ance of a new edition which expends eight hundred pages on one. third of the history, and we really believe that Mr. Macan has justified himself. Whether he might have spared his readers a hundred or more pages by rigid self- denial and condensation is another question. But there is a luxury in taking plenty of sea- room; and Mr. Macan, if sometimes diffuse, is never tiresome. He uses occasionally hard and strange words which one must search for in the very largest dictionary, or perhaps in an American newspaper; it makes one’s eyes open to see such oddities of expression as ‘‘ gold galore,” ‘‘to sleep six months on end,”’ ‘‘ not but what,” ‘they gat them away,” ‘ contag- mination,” and ‘to penalize,” used by a scholar who dwells not far from the fountain of pure English, which used to flow in Balliol. But at any rate Mr. Macan’s style is strong in itself aud strong in the weight of matter and research which it presents. The special value of his attitude is that, while recognizing most fully the transcendent merits of Herodotus’s narrative and achieve- ment, he also points out with great penetra- tion his numerous defects when judged by modern historical standards, and the sources of these defects. Finally, he sets himself to work to discover, by a searching analysis, the precise historical facts which underlie the vari- ous portions of narrative which he has under- taken to edit. His attitude differs fundament- ally from that of Mr. Sayce, who found but little save abuse for the Egyptian and Persian episodes of the history—who suggests to us a bizarre picture of Herodotus listening open- mouthed to his dragoman and taking notes which he afterwards disarranges, highly gulli- ble yet withal ready to gull his fellow-crea- tures, a “malignant” plunderer of the ideas and observations of his rivals who tries to con- ceal his theft; in short, an arrant liar and rogue, who poses under the mask of honest candor andsimplicity. Mr. Macan does not join the side of the out-and-out sceptics like Sayce and Delbriick. He gives us a picture at once completer, fairer, and more flattering—more like that masterly and most satisfactory de- lineation which M. Hauvette offers with so much learning, measure, and sobriety; a de- lineation which reconciles so completely our spontaneous impression of the character of the man with the peculiarities of the historian. Although not indebted to M. Hauvette, Mr. Macan agrees in general with his point of view. He gives us, in fact, the keenest, the most discriminating, the most exhaustive pre- sentation of the methods and the merits of Herodotus which we have yetseen in English. Even as to that conglomerate of ‘traditions, legends, memories, and imaginations” of which the first three books are composed, where it would be, as he says, a ‘“‘ veritable labor of Psyche to sort and separate the fictitious from the true”—even in these, the least historical of the Histories of Herodotus, when tried by careful and discriminating methods, “‘there re- mains a great deal of almost infinite value for the historian proper, apart from its secondary value as illustrative literature, which the harshest critic cannot deny.” Of the remain- ing six books, “large portions of particular statements may pass unchallenged into the historical order.” ‘* Yet, if the time is gone by when the work could be dismissed ‘ as a pack of lies,’ the time is also gone by when the mere citation of a chapter of Herodotus can be taken as definitive. The historical va- lue of the work varies from volume to volume, from book to book, almost from sentence to sentence.” ~ To discover and to weigh these varying values by a detailed application of the critical method must be the business of the critical historian; it is the object of Mr. Macan’s edi- tion to apply this sifting process in detail to Books iv., v., and vi. The results are con- tained in the elaborate foot-notes of vol. i. and the fourteen dissertations which make up vol. ii. It is not possible here to catalogue the re- sults, but there is no doubt at all that Mr. Macan, by a combination of good sense, keen penetration, and ample learning, has shed a useful and novel light on many important questions. To take a single instance, there is the battle of Marathon. This ancient prob- lem, which has been so often attacked and with such varying solutions, is all the more fascinating because it involves many unknown quantities and so few data that are fixed. In- deed, the data given by Herodotus are so vague and inconsequent that it is possible the great traveller never took the trouble to visit the battle-ground, or to consult the evidence of documents and monuments for information. Dr. Evelyn Abbott professes himself some- what tired of this question and hopeless of any further solution. Instead of discussing it once more, he gives his readers the sources, and leaves them to draw conclusions for them- selves. Mr. Macan is more courageous. He has attacked the question once more, in an ex- cursus which is the largest and most elaborate of his fourteen appendices. It is a choice specimen of his thorougbness and acuteness— perhaps we may add of his prolixity; for he writes as if he had all day and night before him. He permits himself to conjecture the probable value of a possible narrative by Aristotle, nor does he deny himself an allusion to the midges which, as Aristotle affirms, arise from the marshes of Marathon after a wari and pleasant day. But these are the foibles of an enthusiast who is eager to neg- lect nothing that may pertain to histopic. As a matter of fact, Mr. Macan does extract from his exhaustive discussion a reconstruction of the motives and strategy of the battle which is quite plausible, reasonable, and consistent. The outlines of his theory are not novel, but the combination is on the whole novel and satisfactory. The hinge of his theory is this: The Athe- nians finally made the attack because the Per- sians had just begun a forward movement to- ward Athens by land and sea with the inten- tion of assaulting the city, This movement was furthered and timed, to a certain extent (though not started), by the signal of a shield displayed to the Persians by Athenian sympa- thizers dn the Pentelicus or Agrieliki. The Persian cavalry were therefore partly aboard the fleet, partly hors de combat, while the army was marching southward toward the main road to Athens. The Persian line fronted the mountain pass of Avlona whence the Athe- nians issued; their right rested on the ‘‘ Chara- dra,” or water.course, to the north ; their left on the smaller marsh, Brexisa, to the south. This plan, varying in detail from that of Cru- sius, Delbriick, and Busolt, solves equally two main puzzles, or cruces: it accounts for the facility with which the Persians, after the de- feat, got away with most of their fleet ; it ac- counts also for the absence of the cavalry— that harrowing difficulty of all strategic cri- tics. It does not find room or special occasion for the mile long running charge of the Athe- nians which Herodotus mentions with such emphasis, and which has been generally disbe- lieved. In view of certain French military experiments for longer distances, M. Hauvette accepts this charge as a possibility for well- trained athletes, and utilizes the movement in his scheme of the battle (which seems to us pro tanto preferable to Mr. Macan’s) as part of a rapid change of front, executed to face and surprise the Persians. It will be remem- bered that Herodotus first states that Hippias chose the plain of Marathon because ‘‘it was suitable for the manceuvring of cavalry,” and yet, in his account of the battle, absolutely ignores the cavalry, as if they had slipped clean away, or clean out of his mind. It is, in fact, quite likely, as Mr. Macan suggests, that they had slipped out of his mind when he was writing his somewhat misty sketch of the battle. Such forgetfulness seems to us highly unsci- entific ; but Herodotus was neither a soldier nor a scientist. He did not care much—his hearers cared even less—for accurate tactics and topography. He could not have obtained such information from the veterans of Mara- thon, if he had tried. What they and his hear- ers liked best, undoubtedly, was his stories of individual prowess, his epic history of a grand national achievement, his tales of the marvel- lous, and, above all, his moralities. In these tastes Herodotus was like his audience: he holds the mirror up to his own time; he reflects the popular spirit, the superstition, the beliefs of his age, much more exactly than the scientific Thucydides. Thucydides is a modern, a mind of the nineteenth century. He had some in- tellectual comrades (of his own way of think- ing) even in his own age. Yet it is likely that Herodotus has given us a work of greater value than if he had attempted prematurely to apply the method of Thucydides—the mo- dern method—to the complex massof material with which he dealt. The result would have been more sophisticated and less trustworthy. Herodotus has, of course, his standards; he is far from believing everything he hears. He

Page 18

RRA NAIC RIN O RELL AL I 8 RAO A OPN Ht Me ag RI ey . . > " b . Paes 14 The Nation. [Vol. 63, No. 1618 is by no means destitute of the critical faculty, but he applies it unequally and capriciously. ‘A modern critic,” says Mr. Macan, ‘‘ might charge him with a failure of political insight”; and, notwithstanding examples of marked shrewdness and penetration, his rationale of the movements of events “falls far short of the policy and statecraft of the age which he describes and represents.” This statement is probably truer of the politics of the Greek than of the Eastern world of his day. The Orientalism of his motives, the personal whim and caprice which we see in his story of Poly- crates, of Croesus and Cyrus, must certainly have ruled to some extent the fortunes of that Eastern world as they ruled at the court of Haroun al-Rashid, or in the advehtures of Hajji Baba of Ispahan. But there is no deny- ing that Herodotus loved to point to the turns of the wheel of fortune ; he is fond of the deus ex machina. He looks at the world and man- kind through colored glasses; to bim human ‘‘life is a sphere for the realization of divine judgments, and human history a book of fa- bles with a moral.” Hence he is like a novel- ist with a purpose—he writes history with a motive; his dearest delight is to point a moral and adorn a tale. Indeed, that is a main ob- ject in rehearsing the failure of the Persian invasion, and a subsidiary object in a multi- tude of minor episodes—in the story of Croesus and of Miltiades. A most striking and unsuspected instance of these tendencies and of the pitfalls which they offer to the historian has been unearthed by Mr. Macan, aided by a suggestion of Mr. Arnold C. Taylor. Curtius, in sketching the career of Cleisthenes of Sicyon, accepts in detail with a certain amount of confidence the celebrated tale of the wedding of Agariste. It is related by Herodotus with a kind of epic pomp and circumstance, and the gathering of the suitors is an echo, we may think, of some Homeric account of the assembling of the suitors of Helen. The affair, indeed, reminds one of the Hindu custom of “‘swayamvara”’ such as that in which Nala won Damayanti. The story ends, it will be remembered, with the reckless behavior of the Athenian Hippo- cleides, the cleverest and wittiest of the suit- ors, who lost his head at the final banquet, disgusted his prospective father-in-law by his pranks and indecent performances, and ‘*danced away” his marriage. Now the star- tling fact which Mr. Macan’s appendix brings to light is that the parallel of this very legend is contained in one of the Buddhist birth- stories translated by Mr. T. H. Rhys-Davids. In this tale, the king of the birds, the Golden Goose, holds a swayamvara for his daughter to which he assembles all the birds of the Himalaya region, and bids his daughter choose a husband. Her choice rests upon the pea- cock, with his brilliant plumage, whereupon the peacock, proud of the distinction and anxious to display his charms still further, spread his wings and began to dance, exposing himself ‘‘in breach of all modesty.’ The royal Golden Goose is shocked by this indecent exposure and bestows his daughter on his nephew, an exemplary gosling. There is hard- ly the ghost of a chance that this tale travelled to India from Greece, and that the Golden Goose is a metempsychosis of Cleisthenes. All scientific probability points the other way. The Greek story is an historic tradition en- tangled and overgrown with the decorative ivy of a popular fable. Less than two cen- turies were required for this growth and transformation ; and Herodotus simply hand- ¢d down what he heard, dressed up in his own admirable manner. The historic facts are not obliterated, but they are considerably dis- guised. We have here aclear proof of the caution with which the details of Herodotean narra- tive must be sifted, more particularly when it involves folk-lore. The folk-lore is quite pat- ent in the story of Atys, foredoomed to be slain by steel, in the clever thief of the trea- sury of Rhampsinitus, in the ring of Poly- crates, in the beautiful tale of Helen of Therap- ne bestowing the gift of beauty on the future wife of Ariston. All these are still echoed in the ‘Arabian Nights’ or elsewhere, and are themselves melodious echoes of folk-lore older than Herodotus, but crystallized and adorned by his consummate literary art. THE MERRYMOUNT MISSAL. The Altar Book: Containing the Order for the Celebration of the Holy Eucharist ac- cording to the Use of the American Church MDCCCXCII. By Authority. [Boston: The Merrymount Press (D. B. Updike).]} Mr. UPDIKE deserves well of his church for the labor of love which has produced this magnificent volume. The Anglican liturgy, like all its sister Rites, lends itself easily to decorative art. What was accomplished by the missal painter of the Middle Age by creamy parchment and a wealth of color and exqui- site miniature work, Mr. Updike gives us in the measure of our days by the most careful bookmaking and by decoration in black and white. The origin and development of the Eng- lish Prayer-Book make neither a long nor an unfamiliar story. Up tothe time of Edward VI. there was, in the Church of England, no one precise order of celebrating the Eucharist binding upon all churches. In the centuries between the mission of St. Augustine and the beginning of the sixteenth century the origi- nal liturgy, if indeed there were only one, had developed into many and various local “Uses.” These variations, however, were rela- tively slight; they did not touch the structure of the liturgy at all. A liturgy, or Mass—to use @ more convenient technical word which ought to be colorless—has a structure of its own as distinct and as much a matter of rule as the-structure of a symphony is. It is, in fact, a mystical drama, in which is shown symbolically the Life and Passion of Christ. Every liturgy from the very earliest shows this with more or less plainness, though it is perhaps set forth with greater clearness in the later Roman Rite than in some of the earlier ones. These Uses, then, at the beginning of the sixteenth century, divided the Church of England among them. The great Sarum Rite, ‘‘Insignis Ecclesie Sarisburiensis,” seems to have prevailed in the south of Eng- land, and was carried so far as to certain churches in Ireland and in Scotland. In the north of England, the Use of York was followed; west of the Severn, that of Here- ford seems to have been adopted, and, in North Wales, the Use of Bangor. But all these churches appear to have retained pecu- liarities of their own. Maskell shows, for in- stance, that there was an ancient Use of the Cathedral of St. Paul in London, held in high esteem till the year 1414, when the Use of Sarum was substituted. But though this last regulated the order of saying and singing, St. Paul’s is expressly said to have retained its ancient ceremonies and observances as they were from the beginning. These diversities, most interesting as they are from a liturgiological point of view, and giving as they did great scope to beautiful ritual development, met with little favor in the eyes of the Reformers, just as the Roman authorities within the present century dis- liked and have destroyed the Paris rite and many another, and would doubtless be glad to root out thoroughly even the Ambrosian. So the English Reformers were determined that *“*now from henceforth all the whole realm shall have but one Use.” This was said at the time of the setting forth of the first Prayer- Book of Edward VI. in 1549. The revision of the old offices had been going on since 1542. Edward’s First Book may be described, some- what generously, as a severe recension and re- vision (if not a reconstruction) of the Sarum Use. It lost much in point of liturgical beau- ty, and was made awkward by the introduc- tion of much didactic and hortatory matter. For the first time in ecclesiastical history what are practically sermons were introduced into a missal. But the English form was of high excellence, and the Mass itself not substan- tially changed. The Second Book, which ap- peared in 1552, showed more important chan- ges, some of which must be called nothing less than wanton, like the removal of the Gloria in Eecelsis from the beginning to the end of the Mass. This simply destroyed the sequence of the liturgic drama. Some ‘ Ritualists” find, we believe, a certain doctrinal satisfac- tion in the change, but with doctrinal conside- rations we have nothing to do. From the point of view of the liturgiologist it was a great mistake and is a blemish. The other changes in the Second Bock were all in the direction of restriction and narrowness. The book had, however, but a brief existence, for it was superseded within a few months by the revival of the Latin Mass at Mary’s accession, and is interesting chiefly as forming the basis of the restored Prayer-book under Elizabeth in 1559, and, through that, of the later revisions. All these revisions, one after another, down to the last one in America in 1892, have been, on the whole, liturgical improvements. The Anglican liturgy, while not perhaps “‘in- comparable,” save in the stately and beautiful flow of its English speech, is still, no doubt, the best known and best loved by the people who use it of all Christian religious formularies. It is not entirely unlike many a church which may be seen in England, with Saxon or Nor- man arches in its crypt and Gothic archi- tecture of two or three periods appearing in its nave and chancel, with a Renaissance porch, and perhaps a Georgian three-decker blocking up the east end. Time and use have blunted the sense which perceives many of these incongruities. Age has made them ve- nerable in some sort, and has inspired affec- tion for them. Their distant origin even seems to make them blend, as distance blends inhar- monious voices. It may possibly be that what are, when viewed with a severely critical eye, the defects of the Anglican liturgy, have them- selves only added to the devotion with which the Prayer-Book is cherished, and which has enshrined it next to the Bible in the English religious mind. Mr. Updike, then, has had a worthy field in which to display all his ability, his judgment, and his knowledge of his art. He has drawn upon these unsparingly, and, besides, has lav- ished time and pains and money upon the per- fection of his book. Many difficult questions he must have had to consider and settle. Some people, doubtless, would have been glad to see full and minute ritual directions introduced Sm it a UM

Page 19

_July 2, 1896] The Maticn. 15 into the volume, and additional prayers for the priest’s own use, and perhaps Collects, Epis- tles and Gospels for votive masses, and would fain have made the present volume something like Mr. Orby Shipley’s ‘ Ritual of the Altar,’ which was published by Longmans in 1878. Mr. Updike has wisely avoided this snare. His book is exactly and precisely what the Church prescribes, and nothing else. The text follows exactly the Revised Standard Book of Common Prayer of 1892. The most scrupu- lous pains have been taken that the text should be as correct as possible, and the book has the great advantage of being issued ‘‘ by authori- ty.” So far as we know, no other similar missal possesses this. Among those who have collaborated with Mr. Updike, the highest praise is perhaps due to Mr. Bertram Grosve- nor Goodhue, who has not only furnished the elaborate and intricate borders in black and white, but has also designed the initial letters throughout the volume, and the type by which it is printed. The type is most satisfying— clear and round and handsome, suggesting the best sixteenth-century fonts. Mr. Goodhue’s symbolism in his borders and initials has been worked out with much care and is not too re- condite to be easily understood. Most of all, the arrangement and application of the sym- bols deserve notice and praise. The illustra- tions include pictures suitable to the great festivals of the Christian’year and a Crucifix. ion facing the Prayer of Consecration. They are the work of Mr. Anning Bell of Liverpool. These have at least one great merit, which is enough to make them shine in their own genre: they are, with one possible exception, neither sentimental nor weak. The drawings for Eas- ter and for Trinity Sunday are especially to be commended. Only so far as in any, how- ever distant, way they suggest the work of Direr do they give occasion for regret. The musical notation of the book has been in the hands of Sir John Stainer, who in it has fol- lowed Merbecke with praiseworthy closeness. Of his own work there is but little, except a few notes to the Kyrie, and the Summary of the Law; the latter based on the cadences of the Comfortable Words. He adds, also, some notes on a separate sheet with tones for the Collects, Epistles, and Gospels, which will be found useful. The music is printed with the old square notes on a red staff. The book would have been more conve- niently arranged, no doubt, if the Communion Office had been put in the middle of the vol- ume after the Gospel for Easter Even, as is common in missals; but this convenience would have been dearly bought, for it would have prevented the publication of the book “by authority.” The order of the offices in the Standard Book is rigidly fixed. So, too, it would have been a convenience if the Canon, or Prayer of Consecration, had been printed on two pages facing each other, so that no leaf need be turned during its recital. But this would have left no place for the picture of the Crucifixion. The binding of the volume is of pigskin, strong and handsome. The cov- ers might, perhaps, have been with advantage a trifle thicker and the metal clasps stouter. The type of the book has been set under the publisher’s personal supervision at his Merry- mount Press, in Boston, and the printing, in redand black, executed at the De Vinne Press. Mr. Updike has endeavored, as he says, ‘‘to make a volume on ideal principles with satis- factory practical results.” His aim has been nothing short of perfection, and we have tried to judge his book by his own standard. We believe that we haye found all the fault with it that can fairly be found—save one, that the edition consists of only three hundred and fifty copies, and that the book will therefore soon be out of print. The Red Badge of Courage: An Episode of. the American Civil War.—Maggie: A Girl of the Streets. By Stephen Crane. D. Ap- pleton & Co.—George's Mother: By Ste- phen Crane. London and New York: Ed- ward Arnold. 1896. Mr. STEPHEN CRANE is said never to have seen a battle; but his first book, ‘The Red Badge of Courage,’ is made up of the account of one. The success of the story, however, is due, not merely to what Mr. Crane knows of battle-fields, but to what he knows of the hu- man heart. He describes the adventures of a private—a raw recruit—in one of those long engagements, so common in our civil war, and indeed in all modern wars, in which the field of battle is too extensive for those in one part of it to know what is going on elsewhere, and where often a regiment remains in ignorance for some time whether it is victorious or de- feated, where the nature of the country pre- vents hand-to-hand fighting, andacoup d’eil of the whole scene is out of the question. In such an action Mr. Crane's hero plays an ac- tive part. It is what goes on in his mird that we hear of, and his experience is in part so exactly what old soldiers tell young soldiers to expect that Mr. Crane might easily have got it at second-hand. The hero is at first mortally afraid that he is going to be afraid, he then does his duty well enough, but later is seized with a panic and runs away, only to come out a hero again in theend. His panic and flight are managed well; the accidental wound which he luckily gets in running, helps him to a reputation for bravery before he has earned it. When he fights in the end, he fights like a devil, he saves the regimental flag, he is insane with the passion of battle; he is baptized into the brotherhood of those who have been to hell and returned alive. The book is undeniably clever; its vice is over-emphasis. Mr. Crane has not learnt the secret that carnage is itself eloquent, and does not need epithets to make it so. What isa “crimson roar”? Do soldiers hear crimson roars, or do they hear simply roars? If this way of getting expression out of language is allowable, why not extend it to the other senses, and have not only crimson sounds, but purple smells, prehensile views, adhesive mu- sic? Color in language is just now a fashion- able affectation; Mr. Crane’s originality does not lie in falling into it. ‘George’s Mother’ is the story of a degenerate drunkard who breaks his mother’s heart; ‘ Maggie’ is a story of the Bowery, in the “‘ dialect” of ‘‘ Chimmie Fadden.” Taking all three stories together, we should classify Mr. Crane as a rather promising writer of the animalistic school. His types are main- ly human beings of the order which makes us regret the power of literature to portray them. Not merely are they low, but there is little that is interesting in them. We resent the sense that we must at certain points resemble them. Even the old mother is not made pa- thetic in a human way; her son disgusts us so that we have small power of sympathy with her left. Maggieitis impossible to weep over. We can feel only that it is a pity that the gutter is so dirty, and turn in another direc- tion. In short, Mr. Crane’s art is to us very depressing. Of course, there is always the eyushing reply that one who does not love art for the sake of art is a poor devil, not worth writing for. But we do not; we do not even love literature for its own sake. It is only fair to say that what we have called animalism others pronounce wonderful realism. We use the word animalism for the sake of clearness, to denote a species of realism which deals with man considered as an ani- mal, capable of hunger, thirst, lust, cruelty, vanity, fear, sloth, predacity, greed, and other passions and appetites that make him kin to the brutes, but which neglects, so far as pos- sible, any higher qualities which distinguish him from his four-footed relatives, such as humor, thought, reason, aspiration, affection, morality, and religion. Real life is full of the contrasts between these conflicting tendencies, but the object of the animalistic school seems always to make a study of the genus homo which shall recall the menagerie at feeding- time rather than human society. Regeneration : A Reply to Max Nordau. With Introduction by Nicholas Murray Butler. G. P. Putnam’s Sons. Pp. 311. THE anonymous author of this work assures us that Max Nordau’s book has become a nightmare to millions of human beings, that people have been aroused by it from the “lethargy produced by the din of clashing opinions and contradictory systems” (an ill- fitting figure!), and that he knows cases of people of sensitive mind who imagine that, ‘*thanks to this book, their friends will Jook upon them as on the road tolunacy.” It is evident that so much misery is in crying need of being alleviated, and we basten to inform these sufferers that they will find in ‘ Regene- ration’ a perfect remedy for all their ills. The author has set himself the task of reply- ing to the exaggerations of Max Nordau with great detail; one cannot rise from reading his book without being fully convinced that Nor- dau has failed to establish his position, and that his indictment against humanity as being well on the road to lunacy is, to say the least, not proven. The author takes up in turn the attacks which Nordau makes on the pre- Raphaelites, on Ibsen, Tolstoi, and Wagner, and it is safe to say that those timid souls who have felt constrained to give up their admi- ration for these great artists for fear lest they were following after erratic and irre- sponsible will-o’-the-wisps, may now return to their allegiance with recovered peace of mind. It is true that our author does not do all this with the brilliancy which William James de- voted to the same thesis in the pages of the Psy- chological Review, but he does it with perfect effectiveness; and if only the brilliant people were allowed to write, of the making of many books there would soon be an end. The scien- tist, and especially the psychologist, will not make much account of this volume, but then the author has a poor opinion of these mis- guided people anyway, and he had small hope of turning them from the error of their ways. It is true that his idea of just what it is that the scientists believe on various points is some- times rather hazy, as the following sentences will show: ‘* A hundred years ago the scientists would have laughed to scorn any one who had told them that their senses deceived them with re- gard to light, darkness, colors, silence, and sound, and that all these presentations received by our senses were simply movement, or mani- festations of energy.” “Itis not surprising that a scientist by eru- dition (!), and ke cams A an alienist, who by dint of studying the mechanism which connects what some the soul, and others designate

Page 20

16 The Nation. [Vol. 63, No. 1618 as the trinity of the consciousness, the judg- ment, and the will (!), with the body, has per- suaded himself that there is nothing beyond nerves, cells, and the gray matter (!), should look with contempt on the imagination.” One would gladly know who is this enviable scientist who has been able to get at the ‘‘ me- chanism which connects” soul and body, and to study it! “Psychologists are pores to speak of a man’s consciousness, though scarcely two scientific men would agree as to what itis. But this does not prevent them from dividing con- sciousness up into divisions and subdivisions, all with their special names, in order to be able to express their ideas in words.” It must be admitted that this looks like a laudable motive on the part of the psycholo- gist, whatever may be thought of the means which he employs to attain it. But not all scientists are as bad as psychologists: “All scientists are not affected by scientific superstition. . . . Thus, astronomers rare- ly exhibit any such symptoms, while biologists are more apt to do so, and psychologists are more scientifically superstitious than any other class of scientists. It 7 be hazardous to ate explanation of this fact, but may it not be found in the obviousness of outward infinity, and the impalpability of inward in- finity ?” Lest these examples may not be a sufficient indication of what the author is capable of in the way of style, we add one more: ‘Should we find, on the other hand, that the deplorable state rep | the poorer classes— their suffering, their degradation, and their joyless lives, coexisting with large fortunes, and irremediable under present laws and insti- tutions—leads to the conclusion that the altru- istic feelings of the wealthy are useless, and thus prompt among the upper classes selfish- ness and egomania, and the determination to drown their higher emotions in a giddy life, and in the poorer classes to foster destructive tendencies and the desire for revenge, we turn our attention to social remedies.” _ Occasionally even the author himself loses his way in sentences of this kind, and ends with deny where he means to say affirm, or folly where he means tosay wisdom (pp. 105, 67). He has a curious way of saying ego for soul, and “personal responsibility” for a future state of rewards and punishments. He says: ‘It is not the well-meaning, plodding scientist, striv- ing to arrest disease, lessen pain, and dispel superstition, that can bounce us into the belief in personal irresponsibility.” And here isa curious bit of thinking: he believes that in the Franco-German war the victory of the Ger- mans was due to the moral quality of the Ger. man army, while the defeat of the French is to be attributed not to lack of moral qualities, but to bad leadership. But it should not be supposed that the book is all quite as bad as this. There are two sub- ordinate topics, in fact, which the author treats at considerable length, and on which he writes with a good deal of freshness and with a degree of intelligence that would seem to in- dicate an acquaintance at first hand. These are his description of the peculiar character and tone of feeling of the people of Norway, in refuting Nordau’s charge that Ibsen is writing in the air; and his picture of the ave- rage German man in the character of husband of the average German wife. Under this lat- ter head, he points out that the Germans are perfectly sensible to the charm of high-spirit- ed, talented, well dressed, and lively women, and that they are also aware that leisure, ex- emption from hard work, good food, exercise, suitable friends, artistic surroundings, books, a fair amount of pleasure, and considerate treatment are essential to the production of women of this kind. But it is not this kind of woman that they wish to marry—it would clash too widely with the traditional type of a good wife, and would set their whole circle of acquaintances talking ; nor is it the kind of woman that they wish their daughters to de- velop into—they must not have a distinct indi- viduality, or it will go hard with them in the marriage market. Women must eschew ro- mantic ideas, they must practise a demure de- meanor, they must notice the evils that follow upon poverty and be content with a prosper ous though unattractive husband; men seldom marry young, and girls are taught to ask no question about their past, to sacrifice their own ideals of purity, their dreams of love, their future happiness, their healthful youth, upon the altar of Philistine respectability. It is fortunate for the race of human beings that different ideals have prevailed in other coun- tries, and that a different sort of woman has had opportunity for development. The dreari- ness of social intercourse in Germany which results from cutting off half the racefrom the intellectual life is something which it would be difficult to exaggerate. A Fauna of the Moray Basin. By J. A. Harvie-Brown and Thomas E. Buckley. In two volumes. Edinburgh: David Douglas. THE printed title-pages of these volumes bear no dates, the photographic titles both have 1895, and 1896 is stamped on the back of each. The books are technically called small quartos, being deeper but not taller than large octavos. The work forms ostensibly volumes vi. and vii. of a series of local faunas in part by the same authors, and all brought out by the same pub. lisher in similar elegant style. Volume v. deals with the vertebrate fauna of Argyll and the Inner Hebrides, 1892; iv., with the same fauna of the Orkney Islands, 1891; iii., with the birds of Iona and Mull (by the late H. D. Graham), 1890; ii., with the vertebrate fauna of the Outer Hebrides, 1887; i., with the verte- brate fauna of Scotland. The two last are out of print. Each of these works is of mono- graphic character, complete in itself, and in- dependent of the rest; and they collectively form part of a still larger series of books of the same general character, several of which we have already had occasion to notice, always with approbation. Such are Charles St. John’s ‘Natural History and Sport in Moray’ (1882), and his ‘Tour in Sutherlandshire,’ the second edition of which (1884) has a faunal appendix by Harvie-Brown and Buckley; ‘The Caper- caillie in Scotland,’ by Harvie Brown; and Muirhead’s ‘ Birds of Berwickshire.’ Theset of books is distinctively British, but not confined to sport and natural history in those islands, as it includes Gatke’s ‘Heligoland,’ H. C. St. John’s ‘China,’ the Earl of Southesk’s ‘Sas- katchewan,’ and others. The general character of these works is high, with all the appointments of fine manu- facture, and profuse illustration in various styles of art, from thumb-nail sketches in the text to elaborate engravings of compositions from the portfolios of well-known artists, among whom Millais and Keulemans may be named; photogravure is also much used, with striking effect in many cases. The present vol- umes are among the most elegant of the lot, and may fairly be called sumptuous. They show leisurely and experienced authorship, based on great resources in the way of mate- rials, and abundant pecuniary means for effecting the desired result. They are also among the more formal and technical vol- umes of the series, in which scenic effect and the freehandedness of “ outings” are subordi- nated to serious scientific work. Lest ‘‘Moray Basin” may convey no very definite notions to the average American, we may say that it is practically the watershed of Moray Firth in Scotland, and some considera- ble adjoining country lying on the whole northwest of Aberdeen. Sutherland, Ross and Cromarty, Inverness, Nairn, Elgin, and Banff are included in the area to be treated faunally. The greater part of the first volume is occupied with an elaborate physiography of this region, which will abundantly satisfy the cravings of nearly all readers for information in that regard, and probably leave none but some of the most critical special students of the subject anything to require further. The rest of the work is a formal and systematic fauna, in so far as this is represented by verte- brates, carried into great detail. Of its tho- roughness there is no question, and none but a local expert could pretend to criticise it mi- nutely. The authors find in their bailiwick just about one-half of the British mammals— 42 species out of 81. As is invariably the case in works of this nature, birds are the most conspicuous and extensive feature of the lists, and also the subjects most elaborated. Out of 360 to 370 species which the author’ allow to the holy canon of ‘‘ British Birds,” they give 255 a place in these volumes, and sum them up in nine distinct categories, one of which we observe to be a list of 26 species ‘* recorded on insufficient evidence.” Herpetology is at a minimum, only nine species of reptiles and batrachians together being found in the Moray Basin. Fishes would seem to be called for, by the title, for treatment like that accorded to the higher vertebrates, but there is nothing of the sort in either volume; perhaps recent ichthyology is resérved for due recognition hereafter. In place of any recent fish fauna to match the rest of the work, we have a monograph of entirely different and strictly technical character, on the fossil vertebrates, of which fishes constitute the greater number by far, though a few reptiles are included, and the recently extinct mammals (reindeer, elk, ox, beaver, and wolf) are also noted. Dr. Tra- quair’s memoir includes a geological biblio- graphy, and is illustrated with a series of nine special plates of different character from the other illustrations of the work, besides several cuts in the text. This publication is thus highly praiseworthy as far as it goes, but would appear to require several more volumes to meet fully the re- quirements of the extremely comprehensive though curt title. The Roman See in the Early Church, and Other Studies in Church History. By Wil- liam Bright, D.D. London: Longmans, Green & Co. ; THERE is significance in the fact that the Re- gius Professor of Ecclesiastical History at Oxford should devote nearly half the present volume to refuting the Roman theory of the continuous tradition of Papal supremacy as recently set forth by the Rev. Luke Riving- ton. This he accomplishes with abundant learning and acuteness, somewhat marred by occasional obscurity of presentation, but his success or want of success in this is of less ac- count than the fact that he should have deem- ed it worth his while tu undertake the task in the Church Quarterly Review, and then to re- MAEM be ees! ae LM Se oe

Page 21

€ ao “3 4 a ph oe Ps. Sy = ps x PRON Cie oS Se Ae * 3 July 2, 1896] The Nation. iF print his argument enlarged in the present ! volume. Tous the contest between the two champions is chiefly of interest as a manifesta- tion of the curious movement towards Rome on the part of a portion of the Anglican Church, and of the anxiety, if not alarm, which this tendency is producing in the minds of the sturdy adherents of the Edwardian Church. So sagacious a Pontiff as Leo XIII. would scarce have ordered a fresh examina- tion into the old question, decided so long ago, as to the validity of Anglican orders, without an expectation that some concession, in form if not in substance, might result in a ‘‘ bolt” which would strengthen the cause of Catho- licism in England, while Mr. Gladstone’s let- ter to Cardinal Rampolla bears traces of that singular longing for reunion which would seem to justify in some degree the anticipa- tions of the shrewd and far-seeing men who direct the policy of Rome. . To a disinterested onlooker it is suggestive to watch the development of this revival of the medieval conception that the Church must be one, like the seamless garment of Tréves. It is true that, during the ages of semi-barbarism and brute force, there were advantages in the powerful organization which controlled Europe and transmitted, in a spirit- ual disguise, the imperialism of ancient Rome to modern times; but monopoly bears within its bosom the seeds of imevitable evils, and the popular antagonism to ‘‘ trusts” in the com- mercial world shows how instinctive is the ap- preciation of the benefits of competition. The medizeval Church was a trust which controlled salvation and sold it at its own pricein power and wealth, resulting in a worldliness and corruption scarce conceivable by the present generation. There are dreamers who deplore the sundering of the Church in the sixteenth century, and who imagine that abuses could have been reformed from within, on some such basis as that which Erasmus suggested; but, so long as the Holy See retained a mo- nopoly, such a reform could have been only superficial and temporary, as may be seen by the career of Spain, which allowed no intru- sion on the exclusive claims of Catholicism, and consequently was virtually untouched by the Counter-Reformation. Spiritual dissension may be an evil, but it is a less evil than spiritual torpor, and dis- sension at least connotes spiritual vitality. So far from the multiplication of sects being an evidence of error, as Bossuet endeavored to show, it is an evidence of earnest seeking after the truth, and, so long as modern ideas prevent persecution for conscience’ sake, it merely stimulates a healthy competition to advance the kingdom of righteousness. No greater misfortune could befall the Christian world than a restoration of unity under Latin Christianity, and, in this, Latin Christianity itself would be oneof the chief sufferers. For- tunately such reunion is impossible, however much the advanced type of Anglican priests may long for it; and although we cannot look upon the labors of Mr. Bright as a very effi- cient instrumentality in preventing it, they deserve recognition as a sufficient exposition of the hollowness of the claims of the Petrine Church that the Vatican decree is securely rooted in apostolic principles and practice. The other essays in the volume are fair aca- demical discourses, manifesting sufficient ac- quaintance with the subjects discussed, but presenting nothing new. Memoirs of an Artist. By Charles Francis Gounod. Translated by Annette E. Crocker. Chicago : Rand, McNally & Co. Pp. 223. Charles Gounod: Autobiographical Reminis- cences, with Family Letters and Notes on Music. From the French by Hon. W. Hely Hutchinson. Philadelphia: Lippin- cott. Pp. 267. Two translations of Gounod’s autobiographic fragment have appeared almost simultaneous- ly. Both are well done, and while the first- named has the merit of cheapness, the second is more terse and idiomatic, and free from the occasional blunders which occur in the first (pp. 111, 118, 125, 127, 139). Mrs. Crocker’s version contains only the memoirs and a few letters ; Mr. Hutchinson’s includes further let- ters and five articles of Gounod’s on Berlioz, Saint-Saéns, Nature and Art, The Academy of France at Rome, The Artist and Modern Society. Both versions are elegantly printed and bound. The noblest trait of Gounod’s character was his affection for his mother. ‘If I have work- ed any good, by word or deed, during my life, I owe it to my mother,” he says, ‘‘and to her I give praise.” He had reason to adore her, for she was one of the most devoted, self sac- rificing women in the annals of art. Her childhood had been unhappy because of pa- rental dissensions, and, as the family was poor, she began giving piano lessons at the age of eleven. She gradually saved enough money to go from Rouen to Paris (a three days’ trip by coach) once in three months, for a lesson of Adam at the Conservatoire. At twenty- six she married Frangois-Louis Gounod, well known as a painter, a man of talent, but of frail health and a weak will. He took plea- sure in drawing the essentials of a picture— face, expression, etc.—but left the accessories and drudgery to his wife, who luckily also had talent for drawing, and was thus able to finish what he left undone. In 1823 she found her- self a widow with two boys, Charles, aged five, and an older brother of fifteen. The widow now took it upon her to support the family by continuing her husband’s drawing. class as well as her music lessons, but found ere long that she was overtaxing her strength, whereupon she dropped the former and con- fined herself to music lessons, to which she devoted twelve hours a day. Charles Gounod also had to make his choice between music and painting. His talent for both was about the same. He remembered how, asa boy, he used to lie on the floor draw- ing eyes, noses, and mouths with a white crayon on a varnished blackboard, and he had no doubt that if his father had lived he would have become a painter too; this opinion must have been confirmed when no less an authority than Ingres, after seeing some of his amateur sketches at Rome, told him he might have se- cured the grand pria de Rome for painting as easily as for music. The fates had decided in favor of music, luckily, for France needed another good composer much more than an- other good painter. His mother used to be proud when, as an infant, he could give musi- cal hints to grown-up girls, and she lived to see him give many other proofs of his talent, including the winning of the Roman prize at the second trial; yet she had her misgivings as to a musical career, and did not live to witness his first lasting success, the opera ‘‘ Faust.” As holder of the Roman prize, Gounod was obliged to spend two years in Rome. That city was at first a great disappointment. ‘ In- stead of the city of my dreams, majestic and imposing, full of ancient temples, antique monuments, and picturesque ruins, I saw a mere provincial town, vulgar, characterless, and, in most places, very dirty.” In course of time he not only became reconciled, but enthusiastic, and when he left, after overstay- ing his time several months, tears rolled down his cheeks. This feeling, however, was based - entirely on artistic and social considerations, for musically Rome had little to offer to the talented young composer except a chance to become familiar with the works of Pales- trina. As it is almost impossible to eradi- cate from the American mind the impression that Italy was and is the musical centre of the universe, it is worth while to quote a few of Gounod’s remarks: **As regarded religious music, the Sistine Chapel in the Vatican was the only place where it was possible to hear anything decent, to say nothing of its being instructive. What they called music in the other churches was enough to make one shiver. Except in the Sistine Chapel, and in that called the ‘Ca- non’s Chapel’ in St. Peter’s, the music was not merely worthless, it was vile. It is hard to imagine how such a chamber of horrors could ever have come to be offered up to the glory of God within those sacred walls. All the shabbiest tinsel and trappings of secular music passed across the trestles of this reli- gious masquerade. So no wonder I never tried it twice.” Equally unsatisfactory he found the opera, the only other field of music cultivated by the Italians. Bellini, Donizetti, and Mercadante made up the repertory, and ‘‘ the performan- ces were very inferior to those at the Théa- tre Italien in Paris. The stage ma- nagement, too, was often literally grotesque.” Consequently Gounod went to the opera sel- dom, finding it more profitable to stay at home and study the scores of Rossini, Gluck, Lulli, and especially his beloved Mozart, whose ‘*Don Juan” remained always his favorite opera. Mozart and Bach were his idols, and ‘* Mozart,” he says, ‘‘ bears the same relation to Palestrina and Bach as the New Testament bears to the Old, in Holy Writ.” When he reached Vienna, Gounod found a very different musical atmosphere—good ope- ras, good singers, and ‘‘that universal diffu- sion of musical knowledge which is such a de- lightful and peculiar feature in Germany.” In Leipzig he was most cordially received by Mendelssohn, who called a special meeting of the famous Gewandhaus orchestra to play his Scotch symphony for him, and who comment- ed on a passage of the ‘Dies Irae” which Gounod had composed in Vienna—‘' My boy, that might have been written by Cherubini.” The last forty pages of the Memoirs are de- voted chiefly to an account of Gounod’s early efforts as an opera composer, up to ‘‘ Faust,” which had been in his mind nearly twenty years before it appeared on the stage. Here the autobiography breaks off suddenly, prob- ably for the reason that there were episodes in Gounod’s later life which he did not care to dwell on. Of the essays appended to Mr. Hutchinson’s version all contain some good things, besides a considerable amount of de- clamation and ‘fine writing.” The best are those on Berlioz, whom Gounod calls ‘‘one of the greatest emotional influences of my youth,” and on Saint-Saéns, to whom he pays this tribute: “ He has an enormous power of assimilation. He can write you a work in any style you choose—Rossini’s, Verdi’s, Schumann’s, Wag- ner’s. He knows them all thoroughly—the surest safeguard, it may be, against his imi- tating any. He never suffers trom that bug- bear of the chicken-hearted, the dread of not

Page 22

18 The Nation. [Vol. 63, No. 1618 making his effect. He never exaggerates; thus he is never far-fetched, nor violent, nor over-emphatic,” Notes of the Night, and Other Outdoor Sketches. By Charles Conrad Abbott, M.D. The Century Co. 1896. SomE nature-lovers tell us of the dawn and of the twilight, and the sunlit hours we may know for ourselves ; but it has been Dr, Ab- bott’s ambition to learn what goes on at every moment of the entire day, nor has he discrimi- nated between the seasons. There is nothing absolute, and on the darkest night something may be seen, although the images are distorted and magnified. Neither does perfect silence ever prevail, for multitudes of living things have nocturnal pursuits, and even those whose chief business is by day are wakeful, and re- cognize the moon or the aurora with inarticu- late comments. Perhaps they, like men, suf- fer from mysterious terrors when darkness deepens, realizing how helpless they are with- out the sense of sight. We think of night as dark and damp and chilly ; but, as Dr. Abbott reminds us, there are moonlit nights when nearly the whole world can be seen in dif- ferent attire from that of the day, and when the air is warm anddry. The stories of his nocturnal rambles are very pleasantly told, and they open a new field of travel, more ac- cessible than central Africa or the Arctic zone, and almost as little trod. “Notes of the Night” is the longest and most original of the essays collected here, the others following more conventional lines. In style they remind us of Thoreau, whom Dr. Abbott highly appreciates and defends against unsympathetic critics. We need, he main- tains, ‘‘an infusion of intellect into the lower strata of man’s activities’; and ‘‘the intel- lectuality that Emerson deplored as dissipated was put to the very highest of uses, that of making the lower or simpler things of life shine out in their proper light.” We need not pass upon this point, but only remark that while Thoreau’s style is richer in literary al- lusion and in profounder thought, Dr. Abbott keeps somewhat closer to nature—is, in the technical sense, more of a naturalist. His book is daintily printed and bound, and is to be considered by those who are getting to- gether their vacation reading. ° The author’s modest hope, that it contains some “ profitable reflections readably expressed,” is certainly justified. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. A Stumbler in Wide Shoes. Henry Holt & Co. Koldrewood, Rolf. Old Melbourne Memories. 2d ed. Macmillan. $1 75. Bunner, H.C. Jersey Street and Jersey Lane. Scrib- ners. $1.25. Clarke, George. The Education of Children at Rome. Macmillan. 75c. Cockburn, Rev. G. John Chinaman: His Ways and Notions. Edinburgh: J. Gardner Hitt. bey. Hungerford’s Daught Chicago: C. H. Kerr 0. Cooper, J. F, The Sea-Lions; or, The Lost Sealers, (Mohawk Edition.] Putnams. $1.25. Cossins, George. Isban-Israel: A South African Story. London: La | & Bird. Cowperthwalt, J. H. Money, Silver, and Finance. 3d American News Co 25c. Crane, Stephen. Geprge’s Mother. Edward Arnold. Crane, Stephen. Maggie: A Girl of the Streets. Apple- tol Crashaw, Prof. W. H. The Interpretation of Litera- ture. Macmillan. $1. Denormandie, M. Notes et Souvenirs. 3ded. Paris: Léon a Dickens, Charlies. Christmas Stories. Macmillan. $1. Dougall, I. The MadonnaofaDay. Appletons. $1. Farnell, L. R. The Cults of the Greek States. Vols. I. ana Ii. ‘Oxford: Clarendon Press; New York: Mac- millan. ‘ Farnbam, A. W. The Oswego Normal Method of Teach- in, Seontaeng. Syracuse: C. W. een. 50c. Fowler, R. L. The Law of Charitable Uses, Trusts, and Donations. New York: Diossy Law Book Co. Francke, Prof. Kuno. Social Forces in German Litera- ture. Henry Holt & Co. $2. Gollancz, israel. Julius Cesar. Timon of Athens. (The Temple Shakspere.] London: Dent; New York: Macmillan. Each 45c. Gregory, J.W. The Great Rift Valley: Being the Narra- tive of a Journey to Mount Kenya and tobe Baringo. Lon‘on: Murray; New York: Scribners. $7.50. Gréville, Henry. Perdue. W.R Jenkins. 60c. Aleimweh, Jean. Droit de Conquéte et Plébiscite. Paris: Colin & Cie. . W. Gerhard’s Sacred ogy ~ gee periences. T. Y. Crowell & Co. . as Prot Heinrich. Miscellaneous Papers. Macmil- an. 25. Herwegh, Marcel. Briefe von und an George Herwegh. 1848. Munich: Albert Langen. Hewett, Prof. W. T. Poems of Uhland. Macmillan. Hinsdale, Prof. B. A. Teaching the Language-Arts. Appletons. $1. ogan, Louise E. How to Feed Children. Philadelphia: J.B. Lippincott Co. $1. Holmes, Mrs. Basil. The London Burial Grounds, Macmillan. 50. Martin, E. A. The Story of a Piece of Coal. Appleton. The Works of Max Beerbohm. Scribners. $1.25. Wheatley, H. B. The Diary of Samuel Pepys. Vol. VIII. London: Bell; New York: Macmillan. $1.50. D., and Reeve, J. K. Bible Boys and Girls. Boston: Lothrop Publishing Co. $1. Woodward, G. A. Diary of 2 Seomaer™ Girl. Buf- c. Oe 8 Wright, Rev. C. H.H. A Primer of Roman Catholi- cism: F.H. Revell Co. 40c. FUST PUBLISHED. Gillet sEuclideanGeometry By J. A. GILLET, Professor in the New York Normal College. 12mo, half roan, $1.25 net. This book is “‘ Euclidean” in that it reverts to queelz geometrical methods of proof. It attempts no literal reproductions of Euclid’s demonstrations or of his pro- positions, but does aim at absolute faithfulness to his spirit. Evenin tne crucial chapter on proportion, a strictly geometrical treatment is maintained, without, it is believed, complicating the subject for beginners, and certainly with a clear gain in logicat —. Metrical applications and illustrations of geometri cal truths are interspersed with unusual freedom, but are always 80 managed as to keep clear and sharp the radical distinction between the methods of pure geometry and those of pure algebra. Exercises (‘‘ originals ’’) are made an integral part of the logical development of the subject; that is, they include theorems and prob.ems which are ordinarily found in the regular series, and thus, by devoting the upil’s inventive energies to these instead of to merely ncidentai “ originals,’’ he secures the necessary power at a smaller expenditure of time. Besides these exer- cises, which it is assumed all pupils do, there are nu- merous Others of the supplementary sort for additional drill or for particularly apt students. RECENTLY PUBLISHED. Gillet’s Algebra. 12mo. Halfroan. $1.35 net. : J. B. Coit, Professor tn Boston University: “I am pisesee to see that the author has had the purpose to utroduce the student to the reason for the methods of Algebra, and to avoid teaching that which must be u: learned when the student moves on into higher studies,” E L. Richards, Professor in Yale University: “If I pot > papaetmea Algebra I should certainly give it a J G. E-till, Master in Hotchkiss School, Lakeville Conn.: “ It impresses me ee, so far as I have bad time to examine it. e order in which the subjects are taken up is the most rational of any Alge- bra witn which I am familiar.” Cnarles A. Pitkin, Thayer Academy, So. Braintree, Mass.:; “Tam poeanen wito the arrangement of it, an in general with the explanations, some of whicna are particularly good.” John E. Clare, Professor in Yale University: “ It co- vers the ground requisite to prepare candidates for Sheff: ld, and the study of the subject can be — it—an | tape Wom pon hes appreciate. see severai features in it-which I wo ladly speak of in detail if I had more leisure.” — & William A. Francis, Phillips Academy, Exeter, N.H,: I find many things in it to admire, especially the shortening of algebraic processes.” sj James Lee Love, Instructor in Harvard University: It is unusually good in its arrangement and choice of material, as well as in clearness of definition and ex- planation.” Arthur Lathum Baker, Professor in Universit: samen A “It rd - ap epesend gory! in My m4 y up te in man, e ways practical teacher can appreciate.” “ sie cectan HENRY HOLT & CO.,N. Y. JUST PUBLISHED. THE GOSPEL OF EXPERIENCE; Or, The Witness of Human Life to the Truth of Revelation. Being the Boyle Lectures for 1895. By the Rev. W. C. E. NEwBo tt, M.A., Canon and Chancellor of St. Paul’s Cathedral, Select Preacher before the University of Oxford, 1894-5, and Examining Chaplain to the Lord Bishop of Ely. Crown 8vo, $1.50. LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., gz and 97 Fifth Avenue, New York Books of To-day and Belinda’ Supt. The Best Monthly Review of English Books for American Readers. Annual Subscription 3s., 6d., post free. HATCHARDS, Booksellers to the Queen, 187 PiccaDILLy, LonDoN The Forum JULY, 1896. Jefferson and His Party To-day, Hon. WILLIAM E. RUSSELL The Presidential Outlook, PAUL LEROY-BEAULIEU Editor, “L’ Economiste francais’’ Reasons for an Immediate Arbitration Treat: with England, President CHARLES W, ELIOT Mr. Cleveland’s Second Administration, GEORGE WALTON GREEN Baron de Hirsch........ Hon. OSCAR S. STRAUS Theodore Roosevelt as a Historian, . P. TRENT Professor of History and English, University yp RY Cardinal Manning, Anglican and Roman, The Venerable Dr. C. C. TIFFANY, D.D. Archdeacon of the Diocese of New York Substitutes for the Saloon, FRANCIS G. PEABODY Professor of Social Science, Harvard University. Is There Another Life?....... -GOLDWIN SMITH President Angell’s Quarter-Centennial, MARTIN L. D’OOGE Dean of the Dept. of Literature, Science, and arts, University of Michigan Moltke and His Generalship, J. von VERDY du VERNOIS Ea-Prussian Minister of War The Forum Publishing Co., NEW YORK. 25centsaCopy. .. . $3.00a Year. YALE MIXTURE. The choicest tobacco made, and pre-eminently a gentleman’s smoke. Marburg Bros., The American Tobacco Co., Successor, Baltimore, Md.

Page 23

«

July 2, 1896] The Nation.

Vv

Teachers, etc. pr X Pan? TUTORING for September Examinations.—New requirements in English. Representatives in Harvard, Yale, Columbia, Cornell, and,other Colleges. Advantages of city and country. Dr. C. H. J. Dovaias, 815 Marcy Ave., Brooklyn, N. Y. HARVARD PH.D., who has studied abroad, with five years’ experience as a teacher of Latin and Greek in an tern university,desires a col- lege position as teacher of Greek. ress . H., care of Nation, HARLES W. STONE, Tutor for Har- vard, 68 Chestnut Street, Boston.

School Agencies. HE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES, EVERETT O. Fisk & Co., Proprietors. 4 Ashburton Place. Boston. 70 Fifth Ave., N. Y. 355 Wabash Ave., Chicago. 1242 12th St..Wash’gton. 420 Cent. Bdg., Minneapolis. 728 Cooper Bdg., Denver. 107 K. & P, Bdg., Kaneas City. 25 King St., Toronto. 525 Stims’n BK., Los Angeles. Agency Manual free. LBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY, 24 State St., Albany, N. Y.—Provides schools of all grades with competent teachers. Assists teachers in obtaining positions. Correspondence fs invited. ARLAN P, FRENCH, Manager.

R COLLEGE POSITIONS IN THE WEST, Apply to ALBERT & CLARK, Pullman Building, Chicago.

MERICAN AND FOREIGN TEACH- ers’ Bureau. Miss Grace Powers THoMAsS, M’g’r, 8 Park Street, Boston, Mass. CHERMERHORN’S TEACHERS’ Agency. Oldest and best known in the U. S. Established 1855. 3 East 14th 8t, N. Y.

find good places through GooD TEACH ERS the New American Teac ers’ Agency (The C. B. Ruggles Co.), Offices 1257 Euclid Avenue, Cleveland, and Room 47, Wiggins Block, Cin- cinnati. This agency is widely known, conscientious, and earnest. High-grade Teachers, Principals, —— intendents, Governesses, Draughtsmen, Chemists, Must- cians, Electricians,and Engineers approve of its direct and solid recommendation. Send for circulars. AN AGENCY = ea in proportion to its ence. If it merely hear: of vacancies and tells TH AT is something, but if it is Ss a. ‘ asked to recommend a acher and recommends you, that is more. Ours RECOMMENDS. C. W. BARDEEN, Syracuse, N. Y. THE WINCHELL TEACHERS’ AGENCY is the leading agency for higher positions. 50 Brom. fleld Street, Boston; 262 Wabash Ave., Chicago

LR — —— The Continent of America, By JOHN BOYD THACHER (Just issued),is an important historical work relating to the discovery and naming of America. It contains manyfacsimile reproductions of heretofore inaccessible rarities, including a series of fourteen maps showing geographical knowledge of America from.1478 to 1570. Only 250 copies elegantly printed on finest pa- per. $25.00. For full descriptive circular, address WILLI1M EVART3 BENJAMIN, Publisher, 10 West 22d Street, New York City.

JUST PUBLISHED, COMENIUS’S THE SCHOOL OF INFANCY. Edited by WILL 8. Munrok. Cloth, 116 pages. $1.00. D.C. HEATH & CO., Boston, New York, Chicago.

K INDERGARTEN supPLiEs at SCHERMERHORN’S, 3 East 14th Street, N. Y. Send for new Catalogue. A TION.—FIRST 60 VOLS., unbound, ee in every particular, for sale. No reasona _ refused. Address ANx1ous WIDow, care of the la

. Subscriptions to Foreign Pe- Fi. orezgn Books. rlodicals, Tauchnits british authors. Catalogues on ap- Plication. CARL SCHOENHOF, 23 School St., Boston. H. WILLIAMS, 25 EAST 10TH ST., N.Y., dealer in Magazines and other Periodicals. Sets, volumes, or single numbers.

B ACK numbers and setsof all magazines. For Fico state wants to AMERICAN MAGAZINE EXCHANGE, De Menil Building, St. Louis, Mo. A ZoGk4A ee LETTERS OF CELEB- WALTER ROMEYN onan 287 ath eee N. Yaw Complete Index to Littell’s Living Ape, to the end of 1895. E. Rota, 1135 Pine St., Phila.

R SALE by A. S. CLARK, 174 Fulton Street, New York,

American Ancestry, 10 Vols..............0s0e0.08+ $40 00 Bunker—Long Island Genealogies................ 400 Renton—History of Herkimer Co., N. Y... <9 Bible of Pope Clement VIIL, 1592................ 45 00 Cooper—Townsend Edition, odd volumes, each. 3 50

Carroll—History of S. C. Nae ee eer Dikeman—Brooklyn, N. Y. Compendium......... 5 00 De V POMEL s cccevssncecseccecescs «-- .2 50 RE 10 00

of Long Island... ... 2000 eee 10 00 —Treasury Report, 1795... 25 00 Set, 91 vols 49 N.C. 2 vols eee eran a cinducensands sss 10 0 Gazetteer of Vt. Vol. 4..... 4 80

ED Sc ccccdutudataws 4 00 Surg.-Gen.’s Office. 17 vols.... 50 00 Sc eeeth OkGdKa akabtetoundeneseuce 00 00 € Bock Amer. Revolution. 3 vols. 10 00 of New York (City).... 6 00 arcoy—Across South America 4 vols Morgan—Consanguinity and Affinity Nation. Set, 60 vols.. - Ormsby Genealogy. ...

Pickering—Races of M ae sie | en amsey—Annals of Tennesseeé..............-...+. 400 Ramsey—History of South Carolina. 2vols.... 14 16 Record of Massachusetts, Vols. 1861-’65. 2 vols. 6 50 Riley & Howard—Insect Life. 4 vols............. 10 00 Ruttenber—History of Newburgh, N. Y.......... 7 50 Stiles—Brooklyn. 8 vols., large paper............ 12 00 Same—On smaller paper.............-..+ jen: Se Squier & Davis—Ancient Monuments .... 20 00 Thompson’s Long Island, N. Y. 2 vols 30 00 Tuomey—Geology of 8. C.......-........ 12 00 y of S.C Warriner—Sands St. Church, Brooklyn, Webb—Reminiecences vf Gen. Webb Wood's Long Island. 4to edition....... Wilson—Memorial Hist. N. ¥Y. City. 4v RARE AMERICANA. BURTON’S GENTLEMAN’S MAGAZINE. Acomplete set of this rarest of American Periodicals, edited by WILLIAM E BuRTON and EpGaR ALLAN POE. 7 vols., royal 8vo, half leather. Philadelphia, 1837-1840. It is almost impossible to complete a set now. Only $50.00. Usually priced at $75.00. HAZARD'S REGISTER OF PENNSYLVANIA. De- voted to the preservation of facts and documents. and every kind of useful informatton respecting the State of Pennsylvania. 16 vols., newly bound in 8 vols, half blue morocco, $40.00. AMERICAN ALMANAC, 1880-1861. 32 vols., bound in 16, half morocco, $20.V0. SPOFFORD’S AMERICAN ALMANAC. 8 vols., red cloth, $12.00. YE OLDE BOOKE MART, 133 N. 13th St., Philadelphia, Pa. LEMCKE & BUECHNER, Booksellers and Importers, 812 Broadway, ... .» New York,

Book-buyers can save themselves much trouble and save money by sending all orders for both FOREIGN AND AMERICAN BOOKS toour firm, prepared to furnish all books, wherever published, promptly and at lowest rates.

Rev. W. H. Furness, D.D. Imperial Pneseqnerane, with Autograpb. Print 12x15, on paper 19x24. For sale by F. GUTEKUNST, 712 Arch St., Philadelphia, Pa.

RECENTLY PUBLISHED IN FRENCH FRENCH VERBS, REGULAR AND IRREGULAR. ne be yy P. DuCRoquET. The arrangement of this k on the French verbs ts very simple, and with it one ought to be able to conjugate them thoroughly in a few lessons. A series of 31 questions for arill work is given at the end of the book, and as wela few examination papers of various universities. 12mo, cloth, 47 pages, 35 cents. ATHALIE. By JEAN Racine. With a Blography, Biblical Refer ences, and 7 a Notes in Engiish, by C. Fon- TAINE, B.L., L D., Director of French in the Washing- ton hools. No. 6, Classiques Francais. The best of Racine’s works. Racine called “Athalie” a tragedy founded on the H»ly Scripture. 12mo paper, 111 pages, 25 cents. Complete catalogue on application. For sale by all book- sellers, or postpaid on receipt of price by the publisher WILLIAMR. JENKINS 851 and 853 Sixth Ave. (48th St.), New York. LIBRARIES We solicit correspondence with book-buyers for private and other Libraries, and desire to submit —— on proposed lists. Our topically arranged brary List (mailed gratis on application) will be found useful by those selecting titles. THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO., WHOLESALE BOOKS, 5 and 7 East Sixteenth St., New York. A NEW ERA IN BOOKSELLING. BRENTANO’S, 31 Union Square, announce an impor- tantchange of policy. Hereafter they will sell books at SWE*“PING REDUCTIONS from PUBLISHERS’ PRICE. Bookbuyers will thus be afforded the opportunity to purchase from an unrivalled stock of Classic,Standard, and Current Literature, at PRICES as LOW as prevail ANYWHERE, with the added advantage of prompt and intelligent service. ALL the BOOKS of THE DAY at LOWEST PRICES. Foreign Books. Mail orders reccive spec’al attention. Send for Brentano’s Monthly L'‘st of New Books. Free on a. BRENTANO’S, Publishers, Booksellers, Stationers, Newsdealers, 31 Union Square, New York. _F. W. CHRISTERN (DYRSEN & PFEIFFER, Successors), 254 Fifth Ave., between 28th and 29th Sts..New York, Importers of Foreign Books: Agents for the leading Paris Publishers; Tauchnitz’s British Authors, Teub- ner’s Greek and Latin Classics. Catalogues of stock mailed on demand. New books received from Paris and Leipzig as soon as issued. MEYER BROS. & CO., 1127 Broadway, near 25th St. Now on Exhibition the Largest Collection of EUROPEAN POSTERS Ever Seen in this Country. Posters for sale Catalogue 10 Cents. Aamission, 25 cents. Open Evenings. _ Cioe tremant St Gawmnce FOREIGN BOOKS —— Corner West St.), N, b {mportations from Eu repe. Catalogues on application.

WASHINGTON’S ADDRESSES _ tothe American Churches Washington’s letters to the various religious bodies which congratulated bim upon bis election have been gathered into an OLD SOUTH LEAFLET, No. 65, which possesses unusual value The fourteen letters—to the Roman Catholics, Jews, Quakers, Baptists, etc.—are a notable revelation of Washington’s religious breadth, and emphasize the duty of fraternity between the different religious bodies in the coun- try. They area great rebuke to bigotry and persecution, and should be widely circulated. Price, 5 cts. acopy; $4.00 ahundred. Send for complete lists. DIRECTORS OF OLD SOUTH WORK, at this time. Old South Meeting House, Boston.

*“\TO ONE who smokes the ‘ARCADIA MIXTURE’ would ever attempt to describe its delights.” —J. M. Barrig, in ‘‘My Lady Nicotine.” Samples sent for 25 cents. THE SURBRUG CO., Makers, 37 Dey St., N. Y.

Page 24

vi1 The Nation. [Vol. 63, No. 1618 NEW-PUBLICATIONS The Monist. pincsopny, sctence and Philosophy, Science, and Religion. Yearly, $2.00. Single Numbers, 50 cents. Contents for July, 1896. Vol. VI., No. 4. The Holiness of. Instinct, Prof. Woops Busnes; Philosophical ?'erminology and its History, Prof. DOLF EUCKEN; On the Origin and Import of me ‘dea of Causality, prof. F. JopL; Science and Faith. ——— to Man as a Member of Society, Dr. ‘OPT The Problem of Good and Evil, Eprror Literary Corres; ndence—France—LUCIEN ARREAT. Book Reviews; Periudicals. ON GERMINAL SELECTION AS A SOURCE OF DEFINITE VARIATION. By Prof. AvGusT WEISMANN. Pages, xii, 61. Price, 25 cents. The present ore is oe joteet development o of Dr. Weismann’s theo He seeks by his doctrine of germinal re to 2 ee the neces- sary character of ¥ t retaining Darwin's theory of ons. Ww! natural selection. ariations are shown to be terminate, but without th Laks ese Lamarckian pr The Preface Wels. nae 8 views 0 on B ecleatifn pn pnd biological t Tethod. and the me Aaa sketches the history and the present discussion on selection and variation. (Just published. ) PRIMARY FACTORS OF ORGANIC EVOLUTION. By Prof. E, D. Copz. ag mey eed 121. Pages, 550. Tables, Bibliography, and Inde. A handbook of the Neo- pont theory of grole. tion, by one of its foremost representatives. Places special stress on the evidence drawn from the field of paleontology, especially in the United States. (Just published.) A work of unusual ality, such as Prof. Cope’s, ch tat is oom to criticism; but it t together, as he has cine 3 & ee environ- in eonscious- ness, the efficient factors of o rock ution. The — oa finds the arguments inconclusive, but d how can read the on book without | admiring the @ intimate knowledge of — Fons the great powers of generalization which it PRIMER OF PHILOSOPHY. A popaler exposition of the Septementel potions of . Second — tion. Pages, vi, 232. Cloth, $1 00. Paper, 25 cen THE OPEN COURT F PUBLISHING CO. 324 DEARBORN STREET, CHICAGO. WALTER BAKER & CO, uur. Established Dorchester, ae, 1780. Breakfast Cocoa Always ask for Walter Baker & Co.'s Breakfast Cocoa Made at DORCHESTER, MASS, It bears their Trade Mark “ La Belle Chocolatiere ” on every can. Beware of Imitations. Ready To-day. The Law of Real Property As applied between Vendor and Purchaser in Modern Conveyancing, or Estates in Fee and their Transfer by Deed. By LronarpD A. JonEs, Esq., Author of Treatises on Mortgages, Chattel Mort- gages, Liens, Corporate Bonds and Mort- gages, Pledges and Collateral Securi- ties, and Forms in Conveyancing. 2 Yols., 8vo, containing upwards of 900 pageseach. $12.00 net. These volumes deal with that part of the subject of Real Property relating to ordinary Conveyancing. The leading purpose in the preparation of this work has been to state correctly and fully the law of to-day, and to state it with such completeness as to make the work valuable to the courts and to prac- tising lawyers. The parts of the subject that present the most difficulties and give rise to the most litigation are discussed with the greatest care and fullness of illustration. The cases cited are very numerous, and have been cited after examination for their value. Sold by Law Booksellers. Sent, postpaid by HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO., Boston, 11 East 17th Street, New York. Practical Popular. Scientifically Exact. A-JOUR ALORHOR | ANDS AVE-ART ANDROWESTRY a CIANUARY t-1596- Indispensable to all who love gardens or the literature of gardens; to all who own country places or take pleasure in rural scenery; to all who desire a broader knowledge of trees, shrubs, fruits, and flowers. GARDEN AND Forest stands for the protection of our forests, for the pre- servation of natural beauty, for a purer taste in the design and decoration of pub- lic and private grounds, and is universally pronounced the best horticultural journal ever published for Americans. “ Wise, intelligent, entertaining.”—Harper’s Weekly. “ Rich variety of remarkable engravings.”’—N. Y. Post. “ Winning, delightful, and accurate.”—N. Y. Tribune. “A compendium of new information.’”’—N. Y. Herald, Beautifully Illustrated. Weekly. $4 00a year. Specimen copy free on application. Garden and Forest Publishing Co. Tribune Building, NEW YORK. ce MBIA BICYCLES you see THEM EVERY WHERE [Popl MEG. CO. HAPIFORD CONN] William Lloyd Garrison, 1805-1879. The Story of his Life told by his Children. Illustrated with over 40 portraits, views, etc. 4vols., 8vo, gilt top, $8.00 net. This important work (till recently published by the Century Company) has been reduced in price from $12 00 to $8.00, a remarkably low price for what is unquestionably one of the handsomest products ofthe American press. “A biography of almost world-wide importance. - . It will bea standard work of reference, ’— Charleston News and Courier. ‘*In fact, Southern history is not complete with- out this work.’"’"—Atlanta Constitution. “It is, for the anti-slavery record, final; and the service done to our nation history is as great as that toa father’s memory. Its one eminent trait, however, is its justice.”—Atlantic Monthly. ‘A masterpiece of m-dern historical biography. . . . Tocall the work a mine of information would be to oom a false impression; it is rather a well- arranged library in which attendant hands are al- pee present to point the way to the exact thing anted ly, the work, while as in- structive ‘as the driest manual, is as interesting as a romance."—Boston Advertiser. ¢,* For sale oes At id, on recetpt o, r ~ by the Publishers, tial HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO., Boston AND New YORK. We buy and sell bills of exchange on Letter S and make Cable Transfers of money - of Kurope, Australia, and the West In i make collections and issue Commer. Credit. cial and Travellers’ Credits, available in all parts of the world. Brown Brothers & Co., Bankers. NO. 59 WALL STREET, NEW YORK. DESERT (P. 0., SEAL HARBOR). MT. ished houses $175, $250, $350, $500. Hot-water baths, open fires. W: M. GRIswoLp, Cambridge, Mass. GOLDEN eee tb: PERFECTION FOR THE PIPE. Send 40 cents for 4-oz. sample to SURBRUG, 159 Fulton St., N. Y. City. Tie RP Set, Sh eae :