The Nation 1894-11-22: Vol 59 Iss 1534

Page 1

q he N ation VOL. LIX—NO. 1534. THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 22, 1894. a PRICE 1o CENTS

HARPER’S ‘Harper & Brothers’ Latest Books MAGAZINE READY TO-MORRO! A Sporting Pilgrimage. Riding to Chapters from Some Unwritten Me- Hounds, Golf, Rowing, Football, Crick moirs. By Anne THackeray Reve DECEMBER. ; et, Club and University Athletics, Stu uthor of * Re f Tennysot dies in English Sport, Past and Pre cin, Br 172 Pages. Now Ready. ; sent. By Caspar W. Wurrney. Illus ——. | trated. Svo, Cloth, Ornamental, 83.50. The Simpletons. A Novel. By Tuomas | Harpy. Part I. With Frontispiece Illustration by W. Harueretyi. The title of this story has been changed | at al. 3 by Mr. Hardy, and, beginning with Th hris ‘ ' ; : F , saad ie aecmatinstuteent. tewill be called eC ristmas Hirelings. A Nc vel. By A Bread and Butter iss. A Sk Hearts Insurgent. | M. E. Brappox. Hlustrated. st Outline By Grorur Pa ‘ Post 8vo, Cloth, Ornamental, 81.25. Sve, Cloth, Ornament Slax The Time of the Lotus. Summer in Japan. By AuFrRep Parsons. With PERS TITTIFE NOI twenty-three Illustrations by the Au TARVER D L522 thor. Show-Places of Paris. Night. By Ri CHARD Harpine Davis. With seven Illustrations by C. D. Grpson. An Agitator. A Story. B) An Arabian Day and Night. A Little Journey in French Africa. By Pouvr- | OTHER RECEN NEY BicEtow. With eight Illustra : tions by FrepERIc REMINGTON. HYPATIA; Or,New Foes with an Old Face. By CHakurs Kixes Evolution of the Country Club. by | ings by Wituiam Martin Jounsox, and Caspar W. Wuirney. With ten Illus. | Volumes. 8vo, Ornamental, Silk Bind trations. Ina Boe. omernnns — 2 “ rate ried haat ene eink meme tae 14 - Ba ee ee Rae RT eRe, Pb ipatiS b, acleatdedine te ne ae “ s r People’ for 18° Wayside Poems. By Wantacrk Brut cil a . — R ra , - Illustrated. Square Svo, Cloth, Orna Lao : ‘ mental, $2.00, 3 Se gt ee ee ert re thor in ito, ¢ Square 32mo, Cloth, Ornamenta The Royal Marine. By Braxven Mar A Kentucky Cardinal. 1) rHEWws. Illustrated. Arcey. | tr i ASA PRR See COATS:

i ' : Taming of the Shrew. Nine Illustra. | Wealth Against Commonwealth. by Portraits in Plaster. &: tions by Epwin A. Appey. Comment} piexpy Demarest Lioyp. Svyo. Clot! ion of Ls ver H by Anprew Lana. . i. lili ta istrations. Large Pape 82.50. aes . rnamental, Uneut Ed Paola in Italy. A Story. By Gerrevne | : Pere: r ' Hatt. With two Illustrations by AL- | Bible Stories row Youxo Prorir. By BERT E, STERNER. | the Right Rev. Hexry C. Porrer, , Josiah weenie, F.2.S. D.D., the Rev. Bishop Jony F. Hurst, 8! History. By Saver Sm D.D., the Rey. Jouy Hart, D.D., and f-He Others. Illus eek Post Svo, Cloth, The Dividing Fence. <A Simpkinsville : Episode. By Ruth McEnery Srvarr. | The Colonel’s Christmas. A Story. By Harrier Prescorr Srorrorp. With four Illustrations by W. H. Hype. TRILBY. The Peddler’s Peril. A Story. By L. B. | A Novel. By Georce pv Maurier, Author of MILLER. . : trations by the Author. Post Svo, 1 Calf, $3.50: Three-quarter Crushed Richard and Robin. A Story. By Ro- | in Press.) Edit de Lure. Qne BERT GRANT. With two Illustrations | early in December. by C. CarLeton. Ornament Who Was Lostand Is Found. A Nov Foo.ball Facts and Figures. A Symp People We Pass. Hl. The Mother; By Mrs. Onipuanr, ith: f ** Sit ium of Expert Opinions on the Game’ Song. AStory. By Juuian Ratpn. | Robert's Fortune,’ * Chronicies « Place i erican thietic ’ With three Illustrations by C. Care Carlingford.” vo, loth, piles TON, Ornamental, $1.50. Poems by W. D. Howes and others. | Wimples and Crisping: Pins. Studi Editorial Departments as usual. 1 the Coitfu nd Ornaments of W — Football. y Warrer Ca e men. By THeopore CuxiLp, Author of With 32 Portraits. l6mo, Cloth, 81.25 Art an riticisn Crown Svo, New and elle Edition, with SUBSCRIPTION, $4.00 A YEAR. loth, Ornamental, Uncut Edges a1 = ipplementary Chapter on the New Booksellersand Postmasters usually receive Su scriptions. Subscriptions sent direct to the pr R 2R lishers should be accompanied by Post-ofice Money Pune by roma R & . OTHE “ Ss, New York. Order or Draft. When no time is specified. Sut scriptions will begin with the current numbe Tr . Ks a aai ¥ AU Dok Postage free to ali subscribers in the United States, toany port of the United Si ion, 2 ida, or Meri Canada, and Merico be sent fo any address on receipt of Ten Cents i llers cill be se ul by the publishera, postage prepaid, f of price. Harper's Catacoave will

Page 2

The Nation. [Vol. 59, No. 1534 The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science, and Art, FOUNDED 1865. [Entered at the New York City Post-Office as second-class maitl-matter.) CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. PE WRiivcccconsscescce ppeveneuen or pibesee und $78 gente ARTICLES : Bene ort on the ateago REEDS » vv nvccsescvancee 876 The Filling S Se of Lia RapeneS shine dun kebecanene 376 nS a1 ccnc sab pebteeeaecuasscensasiocd 877 Secular Aetivitios Oe RE 378 SPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE : Working With Froude on Fraser's Magazine.—I.. 878 EE SIR de deny cncndasrivesschicsevecsceeeceaces 879 CORRESPONDENCE : The Mandate of the Election...................205- The Strike and the Vote Hallucinations ............ ENN 0 i cosenssedepeescnesobaeetasnus Modern Greek and its Pronunciation BOBcicesice slswasevives ccccccesecccccccoccecccccqoc;s SOM Book REVIEWS: NR, 5.5 sc crcabaneepbudsuaesasbeaweee Charles Loring Brace..... Books for Children....... Recent English Poetry 888 Briefe an August Roeckel von Richard Wagner.. 889 Rambles oe Japan without a Guide......... 390 Cicero and the Fall of the : -T Republic....... 891 A Study of Ethicai han Tg it Pastehbersoesennetile 891 The Life and Letters of uM Pt O’Connor.........0.. 891 Histoire de la littérature ROO vccccees cxcce 892 bn .).UlU OO, er rar are City Government in the United States............ 892 OE SE GE rea vcs cnsesvcesctconssazecsve cooee. 303 TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three Dollars per year in advance, postpaid, to any part of the United States or Canada; to foreign coun- tries comprised in the Postal Union, Four Dollars, The date when the subscription eapires is on the Ad- dress- Label of each paper, the change of which to a sub- sequent date becomes a receipt for remittance. No other receipt is sent unless requested. Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter or by check, express order, or postal order, payable to “Publisher of the Nation.” When a change of address is desired, both the old and new addresses should be given. Address THE NATION, Box 794, New York. Publication Office, 208 Broadway. TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Fifteen cents per agate line, each insertion, 14 lines to the inch. Twenty per cent. advance for choice of page, top of column, or cuts. Cuts are not inserted on the first page. A column, $20 each insertion; with choice of page, $24. A page, $60 each insertion; front cover page, $80. Advertisements must be'acceptable in every respect. Copy received until Tuesday, 5 P. M. DISCOUNTS. AMOUNT— $100 within a y. 250 “o ‘ 500 “« “ 750 “ “ 1,000 1,500 “oe “ 2,000 “ ? The NATION is sent free to those who advertise in it, as long as advertisement continues. The EDITION of the NATION this week is 10,100 copies. The Subscription List is always open to the in- psec of advertisers. * Copies of THE Nation | may be procured in ‘hoe at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de l’Opéra, and in London of B. F. Stevens, 4 Trafalgar oe American Newspa : " Agency, 15 King illiam Street, Strand, V London agent for Advertisements, R. J. Bush, 92 Fleet Street, E. C iucdhinal, CALIFORNIA, Los Angeles, West 23d Street. M ARLBOROUGH SCHOOL for GIRLS. Mrs. Gro. A. CASWELL, Principal. CONNECTICUT, New Haven, 56 Hillhouse Avenue. EST END INSTITUTE, %chool for ls. Pre- pares oor any college. Circulars. Early applica- tion necess: Mrs. 8. L. Capy and Miss C. Cc. E. ‘Caby, _ Principals. CONNECTICUT, Pomfret Centre. Sent od T SCHOOL.—A New Church ool for Boys will be opened at Pomfret, Octo- ber 3” = all information, address WILLIAM EP Peck, Head Master. row a Re Waterbury MARGARE T° S DIOCESAN ) Board and Day School for Girls reopens Sept, 1% av. Francis T. Russell, D.D., Rector. Miss ia R. Tiitard, Principal. Educational. Museum of Fine Ar Copley Square, Boston, Mass, SCHOOL OF DRAWING AND PAINTING. Nineteenth year now open. Instruction in drawing from the cast and from life, in painting, modelling, and decorative design, and also in jag | anatomy and wig Principal instruc- tors: W. Benson, C. Tarbell, and Philip Hale (Drawing and Pair ting), Mrs. William Stone (Decora- tive Design), B. L Pratt (Modelling), G. H. Monks, M.D. (Anatomy), and A. K. Cross (Perspective). Pupils are allowed the free use of the galleries of the Museum. For circulars giving detailed information, address iss ELIZABETH LOMB: ARD, Manager. DELAWARE, Wilmington, Franklin Street. HE MISSES HEBB’S ENGL TSH, French, and German Boarding and Day School for young ladies and girls reopens Sept. 24, 1804. Ituinors, Chicago, 708 Chamber of Commerce. FIICAGO COLLEGE OF LA W. Law Department Lake Forest University. Two and three year course. For information, address E. E. BARRETT, LL.B., Secretary. LOUISIANA, New Orleans, 247 Pry tania Street. rs. F. D. BLAKE AND Mrs L. POLK CHAPMAN’S French and English Boarding and Day School for Girls reopens Oct. 1, 1894. Students jcc for college. Ample grounds for outdoor exer- cise. MARYLAND, Baltimore, 122 and 124 W. Franklin St. DGEWORTH BOARDING AND DAY School for Young -aemed will reopen Wednesday, September 26. 32d ves rs. H. P. LEFEBVRE, Principal. MARYLAND, Catonsville. T. TIMOTH Y’S ENGLISH, FRENCH and German School for Young Ladies reopens Sep- tember 20, 1894. Principals: Miss M.C. CARTE ER, Miss S. R. CARTER. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 593 Boylston Street. YAUNCY HALL SCHOOL (School Es- tablished in 1828). For Boys and Girls.—Prepara- tion for the Mass. Institute of Technology is a specialty. Reference is made to the Institute Facult 1G Preparation also for College (with or without Greek) and for business. ow and Physics are taught by laboratory work. MASSACHUSETTS, Bos! OSTON UNI VERSI TY Law School, Address the Dean, Epmounp H. BENNETT, LL.D. MASSACHUSETTS, Cambridg HE CAMBRIDGE SCHOOL for Young Ladies. Mr. ARTHUR GILMAN is the Director. MASSACHUSETTS, Conco: poviehctnnti HOME SCHOOL. —25 BOYS pared for college, scientific school, or business. tages of far: ‘am All t) o caven ily life combined with best mental and physical training. Buildings ~ ef and ac- acres of grou. AMEs S. GARLAND, Principal. cording to latest = MASSACHUSETTS, Plym A R. KNAPP’S HOME SCHOOL FOR Boys—12 Boys. 27th year. H. W. Roya (Harv.), Head Master. Mrs. KNAPP, Principal. MASSACHUSETTS, Worcester, 66 West Street. OHN W. DALZEIL’S PRIVATE School for more. .—Prepares for College or Scientific School. Send for Catalogue. On10, Cincinnati, Mt. Auburn, 31 Bellevue Ave. ISS LUPTON has prepared girls to ass without condition the full Harvard exam!- nation for admission. There are at present e pils from her school at Vassar College, the Cincinnati University, and the Chicago University. PENNSYLVANIA, Germantown, 202, 204, 335 West Chelten Avenue. Z fond MARY E. STEVENS’ BOARD- and Day School.—26th year. “Approved” by B awr College. The B ve awrentrance exa- mina’ sons are held in the school by an ns from Vassar. the College. School certificate admits to A TSS COMEG Y’S AND MISS BELL'S English, French, and eT Boarding-School for young ladies reopens October 1. Students prepared for College. Ample grounds for outdoor exercise. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, 1350 Pine Street. — ANABLE’S BOARDING AND y School for Young Ladies. Established in pon en September 26. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, Chestnut Hill. 1848. RHODE ISLAND, Providence, 26 Cabot Street. ISS MARY C. WHEELER'S PRE- paratory, Collegiate, and Art School reopens Octo- ber 2, 1894. Certificate admits to Brown University, Smith and Wellesle Colleges. College Professors in Collegiate De n ~ studios. Lim ment. Art School prepares for Paris ted number of boarding pupils. EUROPEAN WINTER RESORT. INNSBRUCK, TYROL, AUSTRIA, 1,900 feet above the sea, with dry, bracing climate, CENTRE FOR SLEIGHING EXCURSIONS. Fine University, Hospital, ete. HOTEL TIROL. Open all the year. CARL LANDSEE, Proprietor. Large, airy, sunny rooms; modern conveniences; superior cul- sine. Reduced rates in winter. EXCURSIONS A SPE- CIALTY. Best references. Illustrated pamphlets sent on application. COLGATE ACADEMY. HAMILTON, N. Y. New gymnasium; cottage dormitories, improved course of study; best modern methods. For illustrated Cata- logue, address the Principal. RS. JOHN McGINNIS, Jr.,OF NEW York, has taken an apartment, No. 40 Ave. Vic- tor Hugo, Paris, where she will receive girls of any age, enabling them to have the best advantages there, and will arrange for some travel if desired. Refer- ences required. Inquiries may be made of Mr. Horace White, New York Evening Post. ACADE RIVERVIEW POUGHKEEPSIE. N.Y. 59TH YEAR. Prepares thoroughly for College, the Government Academies, and Business. U.S. Army offi- cer detailed at Riverview by Secretary of War. BISBEE & AMEN, Principals. 7. A GNES’ “SCHOOL, Albany, N. y. —Optional studies. Special advantages in Modern Languages and Music. Gymnasium; 34 teachers. Send for catalogue to Miss E. W. Boyd, Principal. Teachers, etc. LGIERS—AMERICAN PH rherhiecrnie ., age 29, wintering in Algiers, seeks eng: ment either as oa vator or to take charge of patient. Spea French. References. _Dr. W! WILLIAM BEAM, , Hotel Continental, Algiers, Africa, ANSKRIT AND AVESTAN WORK- ing Library for sale at low —. ., Columbia College. — 7 UTORING FOR COLLEGE. G. H. MAYNADIER, A.M., 17 Plympton St., Cambridge, Mass. O STUDENTS OF THE FRENCH Language.—Genders and irregular — taught by Dr. Pick in 2 lessons. Apply 127 E. 10th f ARVARD—Tutoring for Admission.— ; H. H. BroGAn, Ph.D., 858 Main St., Cambridge. HARLES W. STONE, Tutor for Har- vard, 68 Chestnut Street. Bostou. School Agencies. HE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES, 4 Ashburton Place, Boston; 70 Fifth Ave., N. Y.; 106 Wabash Ave., Chicago; 32 oe er Toronto: 803 Twelfth Street, Washington, D. C.; 120% South Spring Street, Los Angeles. Agency Manual free. EVERETT O. Fisk & Co. y MERICAN AND FOREIGN TEACH- ers’ Agency — Professors, Teachers, Tutors, Governesses, etc., to Colleges, Sebools, and Families. Apply to Mrs. M. J. Youna-FutTon, 23 Union Square, New York. HE ALBERT TEACHERS’ AGENCY, 211 Wabash Ave., Chicago.—We are in need of seve- ral Professors for college positions open at the holidays, and of teachers for high-school work. Correspondence solicited. C.J. ALBE RT, , Manager. © HE NEW AMERICAN TEACHERS’ AGENCcY.- Teachers seeking positions and those Wishing a change at an increased salary should address Cc. B. RuaaLes & Co. (Palace Hotel Building), Room C, 237 Vine Street, Cincinnati, O. }NION SCHOOL BUREAU / Supplies teachers for Schools and Colleges. Informs parents of good schools. KERR & Hvyssoon, 2 West 14th St., New York.

Page 3

— ae Tr Nov. 22, 1894] _The Nation.

JUDGE DILLON’S GREAT WORK ON The Laws and Jurisprudence of England and America. A Series of Lectures Delivered Before Yale University on Our Law in Its Old and New Home. By JOHN = as LA..2., Author of Commentartes on the Law of Municipal Corporations > Profe fF Real olumbia College Laz School, formerly C ireuit Ju f th Unit ? States 7 Colum "e Circutt, and Chief- fies of the Su preme Court of the Stat ° 8vo. Cloth. $4.00, net. , first part of “ The Laws and Jurisprudence of England and America,” by Elon. Joun F. Ditton, the eminent author, is a study of Law and Jurisprude nce in general, and the peculiar institutions of England, from which the law of this country has been largely adapted. It inelu a most interesting account of the Inns of Court, with their literary and historical associations, and of Westminster Hall. The later lectures deal with the great living — connected with our own law, such as Legal Education, Trial by Jury, Judicial Tenure, the Or Deve —- lent, and Characteristics of the Common Law, Written Constitutions, s miidhiaton, Las Law, ‘he Law Reports, Judicial Precedents, Codification, and Legal Reform. Probably no law book published during the last quarter of a century has been received with such universal praise and with such expressions of admiration. The great distinction of the ~ author, the interest he has taken in the work, the reforms he advocates, and the tund of anecdotes embodied in these lectures, make the volume one of interest to every judge, to every lawyer, and to every student of the law. - ~ - — 4 Has added much to his already great service to his profession by this noble volume.—Phtladelphia Tymes Every one, whether lawyer, legislator, or layman, will be the better and the wiser for reading it.— Yale | i This is one of the most delightful (we might say with truth the most delightful) legal works which it bas been our good fortune to read Green Bag. Primarily of interest to men of the robe, yet there is afascination about these Yale lectures whi whom good literature appeals.— The Critic. The work combines not only interesting matter, clearly and de ‘ligh tfully expressed in the author's well-known style and showing his re cognized ability, but also is a text-book of value.— Albany Law Journal If a man wants to realize how great is law and its professors, let him read Ju: le Dillon's latest work. No one can peruse that work with out a profound feeling of respect for its brilliant and amiable author.— Rich t Dispate The book ought to find fitting place, not only in every lawyer's, but in every intelligent man’s library. Whether read by a technician or a tyro, the book’s greatest charm lies in the popular treatment of its veldeet ts.—The Outloak h, we are sure, will be felt by all to

The work is worthy of its maker, not only as a splendid contribution to legal history, but also in its strong plea for the historic and philo sophic side of legal study as the means of legal development and progress. Th ie New York Counsellor Although the work was prepared expressly for the legal profession, there is no thoughtful reader w . ar interest. The chapters descriptive of the London Inns of Court are full of curious infor ion.— Boston Trans t The volume is well calculated to enlist the interest of the American |! hand Bar in those broader views of the law which our busy pro- fession so much needs, and which have been rarely put forth in a form at once so attractive and so instructive.— AUSTIN ABBOTT. This book should be placed on the prescribed course of every law student and in every law school. It should be read by every lawyer to whom the profession stands for something beyond a trade. There is no judge on the bench to whom it would not bring aid, comfort, and en- couragement; and few, if any, to whom its careful perusal would not bring instruction.—Lega/ | It is a work which every educated man, whether scholar or layman, will read with delight The heavy paper, the beautiful typography, the digest of each lecture in the table of contents, and of each paragraph on the broad margin of the ] he table of cases and of authors cited, and the full index, combine to make the book one of which its publishers may be proud.—<Am: rn I Register and Review, We find it exceedingly interesting reading; and we doubt not that every one who cares for the great questions of general jurisprudnnce will say the same. It is a matter of great importance that we h: ave presen ted to us, in this very attractive book, the matured opinions of a man so distinguished as Judge Dillon is upon all the great « — stions of jurisprudence and law reform that are now engaging the attention of the best statesmen and lawyers of our time.—American Law Re

—prre t . from his bed. A volume of unique interest, cha- ss style, marked always by earnestness and gravi- 11 There is not a dull line nor a heavy page in the whole volume. It isa book to keep one racterized by the author's sound thinking and vigorous reasoning, e xpressed ty, occasionally by enthusiasm and eloquence, exhi b iting vast research in the fic f ure as well as of law, and forming an invaluable treasury of wisdom and information fit for constant resort and reference as well as for ttainment of a few evenings’ recreative reading. The book is an amazing monument to his scholastic acquirements and research as well as to his professional learning.—IRVING BROWNE. LITTLE, BROWN & COMPANY, Publishers, 254 Washington Street, Boston.

oe AR A RE RL NECROSS ARE co 4 Silene ag cre AORELA yc a Ne Aenea ete AERE SRL ctr ght 0

cnet anne Me 02 ee eae ene ean Bi a ant une PRR Ri eek verge forma ene 1 pps MPS a rd ee. ai eee a Mar ON as ae PO ee Se st ate a

* “aay

Page 4

The Nation. [Vol. 59, No. 1534 HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO’S, NEW BOOKS. ESSAYS AND TRAVEL. Childhood in Literature and Art. With some Observations on Literature for Children. A book of high critical character and interest, study- ing the meaning of the appearance and disappear- ance of childhood as a subject for story, poetry, and art in Greece, Rome, Judea, in the Middle Ages, and in moderntimes. By Horace E. ScuppEr, author of “Men and Letters,” etc. Crown Svo, gilt top, $1,25. In the Dozy Hours,and Other Papers. A book of nearly twenty bright essays, on a large va- riety of subjects, ranging from kittens to parents’ rights, written with delightful humorand charm. By Agnes Repr.ier, author of “ Books and Men,” “ Points of View,” “ Essays in Idleness,” etc. Each of the four books, 16mo, $1.25. Studies in Folk-song and Popular Poetry. A book of essays and popular poems, which will strongly appeal to those who are interested in the fresh literature of primitive thought and feeling. By ALFRED M. WILLIAMS, author of “ Sam Houston,” etc. 12mo, gilt top, $1.50. Master and Men: The Sermon on the Mountain practised on the Plain. A thoughtful book, contrasting current Christianity with that of Christ, and illustrating the Beatitudes by the lives of Moses, Paul, George Fox, General Gordon, and George Macdonald. By Rev. Dr. W. B. WRIGHT, autbor of “ Ancient Cities” and “ The World to Come.” 16mo, $1.25. Occult Japan: The Way of the Gods. A book of great interest on the Shinto faith of Japan, from careful study and personal observation. By PERCIVAL LOWELL, author of “ Noto,” “‘ The Soul of the Far East,” etc. Crown 8vo, $1.50. Pushing to the Front; Or, Success under Difficulties. By OrIson Swett Mar- DEN. With 24 excellent portraits of Famous Persons. Crown 8vo, $1.50 [ Nov. 28.] An Irresistible kind of book, showing by vigorous statement and most abundant and various anecdotes how vi*tory may be gained over obstacles and success achieved by pluck, will, and persistency. It is admira- bly suited for a Holiday gift. Glimpses of Unfamiliar Japan, A work of great interest on the less known portions and customs of Japan. By LAFcADIO HEARN. 2 vols., 8vo, gilt top, $4.00. “A very great book.”—New York Times. The Pearl of India. An informing and very readable book about Ceylon. By M. M. BALLov, author of * Due East,” ‘‘ Due West,” “Due North,’ “Due South,” “Under the Southern Cross,” “ Equatorial America ” “ The New Eldorado,” “ Aztec Land,” ‘The Story of Malta,” etc. Crown 8vo, $1.50. Riverby. A volume of eighteen charming outdoor papers on flowers, eggs, birds, mountains, prairies, and other ap petizing subjects, treated with great freshness and in- sight. By Joun Burrovess, author of “ Wake Robin,” “Signs and Seasons,” etc. 16mo. $1.25. From Blomidon to Smoky, and Other Papers. Very intersting book of nice observation in the Provinces and elsewhere. By the late Frank BoL_es, author of “ Land of the Lingering Snow ” and “At the North of Bearcamp Water.” 16mo, $1.25. A Florida Sketch Book. A charming outdoor book on things observed in Flo- rida. By BRADFORD TorREY, author of “ Birds in the Bush,” “A Rambler’s Lease,” and “The Foot-path Way.” 16mo, 81.25. Sold by al? Booksellers. Sent, postpaid, by MNOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO., Boston. it Last 17th Street, New York. Scribners New Keligious Books THE MESSIAH OF THE GOSPELS By Prof. C A. Briggs. 8vo, $2.00. « ST. PAUL’S CONCEPTION OF CHRISTIANITY. By Alexander B Bruce. 8vo, $2.00. $ PROTESTANT MISSIONS Their Rise and Early Progress. Lec- ae by A. C. Thompson. 12m», THE JOHANNINE THEOLOGY A Study of the Doctrinal Contents of the Gospel and Epistles of the Apostle John. By George B. Ste- vens, Ph.D., D.D. 8vo. $2 00. 4 GENESIS AND SEMITIC TRADITION By Prof. John D. Davis, Ph.D. Illus- trated, 8vo, $1 50. $s DOGMATIC THEOLOGY Vol. Il. Supplement. By W. G. T. Shedd, D D. 8vo, $4.00. CHARLES SCRIBNER’S Prof. Briggs’s new volume has a special value and interest for the Advent season. It takes up the ideals presented in the autbor’s ‘‘ Messianic Prophecy of the Old Testament,” and traces their development in New Testament prophecy. The method and scope of the work are entirely origi- nal, and it is full of fresh statements of the doc- trine of the person and work of Christ as a result of the new point of view that is taken. “Tt will be welcomed by the large constituency which has been gained by Dr. Bruce’s previous volumes, and it is one of his best books. He has the art of stating bis points well, and making them clear and unexceptionable.”— Boston Herald. This new volume by the author of ‘‘ Moravian Missions” presents a clear, concise, and compre- bensive view of Protestant mission work in va- rious quarters of the world, from the period of the Reformation down to 1732. ‘‘We welcome the volume as a clear, unpreju- diced, and thoroughly scholarly interpretation. John’s writings are approached in a spirit of fresh, full, though always reverent inquiry.”— The Outlook. ‘‘ His endeavor is to clear up obscurities in the conclusions proclaimed in Assyriology, to set in a clear light whatever is trustworthy, and to com- pare the story with the Hebrew narrative. The caution of the well-balanced critic is obvious everywhere, and the work does good service in clarifying the subject.”—Congregationalist, “As a defence of the Augustinian theology, Dr. Shedd’s great and laborious work deserves praise for its profound learning and dialectic skill."—N. Y. Tribune. SONS, 153-157 Fifth Ave., N. Y. G. P. Putnam’s Sons, 27 and 20 West 23d St., New York. (RETAIL DEPARTMENT.) SEND FoR LIST OF 100 — WT ALSO Catalogue (No. XI.) of English Books Standard Books (Single volumes and small sets, in every department of literature.) In special leather bindings, suit- able for dainty presents to culti- vated people, at moderate cost. Beside the Bonme Brier Bush. By Ian MACLAREN, 12mo, $1.25. ‘* The book is destined to a great, a long-enduring, and an enviable populart- ms % utt, humor, observation—but his adrstinc- tion ts his gift of temperate yet most mov- ing pathos. In this he ts unsurpassed by He has many qualtties— any living writer.’—Dr. Robertson Nicoll in the British Weekly. DODD, MEAD & COMPANY 149-151 Fifth Ave., cor. 21st St. STUDENTS, AUTHORS, SCIENTISTS. : é a Rae (Including some rare sets and beautiful illustrated volumes), in k Choice > rich bindings, for private libraries ' and for presents. Bibliographic, literary, scientific, and technological work of all descriptions. Correspondents in a'l uni versities and jibraries of Europe and America. Re search and investizat‘on conducted, bioliographic ma- terial collected, trans'ations made,in all branches of literature, science, and technology. INTERNATIONAL BIBLIOGRAPHIC BUREAU, ATLANTIC BUILD'NG, WASHINGTON, D.C,

Page 5

cond Edition, with Answers. $1.80, “« Probably within the limits of the volume no better have been given.” —Athenawum. Advertiser. ENGLISH LANGUAGE, THE ; M.A., Lond. Second Edition. 60 cents, pies.”—Saturday Review. in the highest terms of praise,”’—Scholustic Globe. to 1603. $1.00.

and diagrams By Pact Carus. Pages xvi, 455. Cloth, $3.00. PRIMER OF PHILOSOPHY. By Pati Carts. Pages vi., 232. Cloth, 31.00. DARWIN AND AFTER DARWIN. An Exposi tion of the Darwinian Theory and a Discussion of Post-Darwinian Questions. By Prof. GEORGE JOHN ROMANES, Part I. THE DARWINIAN THEORY. Pages xiv., 460. 125 Illustrations. Cloth $2.00. : Part II. POST-DARWINIAN QUESTIONS. (In pre paration.) To be edited by Prof. LLoyD Morgan. AN EXAMINATION OF WEISTANNISM. By GEORGE JOHN ROMANES. Pages 1x., 271. Cloth, $1.00. THE SCIENCE OF MECHANICS. A Critical and Historical Exposition of Its Principles. By Prof. ERNST MacH. Translated from the second German edition by Tuomas J. McCormack 250 Cuts and Il lustrations. Half Morocco, gilt top, $2.50. POPULAR SCIENTIFIC LECTURES. By Prof ERNsT Macn. (In preparation.) Cloth, $1.50. By TH. Rigor. Autho The Psychology of AStention, rized translations. The Diseases of the Will, Cloth editions, 75e. The Diseases of Pe ~Ahe ss each. In set $1.75, Paper 25c. each. THE LOST MANUSCRIPT. A Novel. By Gus TAVE FREYTAG. Authorized Translation from the six teenth German edition. Two volumes. Extra cloth, gilt top, $4.00 (Thesame in one volume, cloth, $1.00. ‘The translation tas been authorized and seems to be competent and idiomatic, and on both accounts is calculated to give pleasure to readers scrupulous as to copy right and literary merit.”—The Nation. he volumes are a rich contribution to this depart ment of literature, and the publishers have sent out the volumes in elegant form."’"—Chicago Inter-Ocean. THE OPEN COURT. A weekly journal devoted t the Religion of Science. Yearly, $1.00. THE MONIST. A Quarterly Magazine devoted to the Philosophy of Science Yearly, $2.00; single copies Sve. ‘ The Open Court Publishing Company, 324 DEARBORN STREET, CHICAGO.

by which the marvellous structure of scientific astronomy has been built up could “One noticeable feature of the book iathat the more important theorems are earefully Illustrated by worked-out numerical examples, and are so well arranged and clearly written that the volume ought to serve as a good text-book.’—Bombay ETHICS, MANUAL OF. By J. S. Mackenzre,M. A, Its History and Structure. By W. H. Low “A clear, workmanlike history of the English Language done on sound princi “The book is in every way admirable, and {s certainly the clearest, and, within Its compass, the most thorough manual on the history and the gramm: ar of the Engiish language published. We have gone carefully through the book, and can speak of it ENGLISH HISTORY, THE INTERMEDIATE TEXT-BOOK OF. By ©. S FEARENSIDE. M.A., Oxon; aad A. JOHNSON Evans, M.A., “It is written in a bright and attractive style, and displays a fairness and inde pendence of thought which place it high in the Ist of manuals dealing with this

‘The Nation.

M.A. BSe,, and G. H. Bryan, M.A.. Fellow of St. Peter’s College, Cambridge. Se W. H. Low. M.A... Lond TEX T-BOOKS FOR COLLEGES. i ASTRONOMY, ELEMENTARY MATHESIATICAL. By ©. W. C. Bartow, | ENGLISH LITERATURE, THE UNIVERSITY TUTORIAL SERIES. W. B. CLIVE, Publisher, 65 Fifth Avenue, New York. RICHARD SHERRIFF, Manager. THE INTERMEDIATE TENT-BOOK OF Ry A History of English Literature in 3 vols Volume 155s to 1660. Volume LIL., 1660 to L7¥8, 80 cents per vol description of the methods | tator. Fellow of Trinity Col

“This text book of literature is one of the very few that we t car re commend both to teachers and stutents, for here we have ' et at arrangement, well-thought out criticism, and unbDiassed ' shers (wreular. “Correctness and a cautious, critical Judgment mark the wolun ? ‘3 MAGNETISM AND ELECTRICITY, TEXT- BOOK OF. With One Hundn lege, Cambridge. $1.50. : » Diagrams " t ty R STEWART to sel his a most admirable student’s manual.”—Teachers’ Monthly ere y rien ar The Tu me iat “Pan a ae a es “Mr. Mackenzie's book is as nearly perfect as it could be. It covers the whole ae . : field, and for perspicuity and thoroughness leaves nothing to be destred. The pu The author ts evidently familiar with the diMcultics which usually ocour pil who masters it will’ find himself equipped with a sound grasp of the subjec t | Students. The arrangement of calculations and examples at the end of ea apts such as no one book with which we are acquainted has hitherto been equal to must prove extremely useful to students Nature supplying.”—/iterary World. “Mr. Wallace Stewart, in his text book of Magnetism and Electricity, maintains the high level of excellency which,his already published sefence text books possess Literary Opinion “We can heartily recommend it to all who ne sed a text book I yow tems PLATO, PHAEDO. Edited by CS. Fearensipe MA, Oxon, and R C RB KERIN, B.A., London. tional Times. Camb. Volume II., 1485 found carefully explained ROME, HISTORY OF:

** Mason and Hoadley’s System for Beginners.” American or Foreign Fingering. $3.00. “New England Conservatory Method.” pe ase book of piano instruction in this fa mous school. Three parts, each $1.50; complete, $3.00. aualan or Foreign F ingering. MASON’S PIANOFORTE TECHMES.” By Wm Mason and W. SB. Matthews. $2.50. «PETERS’S ELECTRIC PIANO INSTRUCTOR.” Over 300,000 of this standard work soki. $3 00 “Bellak’s Analytical Method” Paper, 75 cents; Boards, $1 oo. ‘* Winner’s Eureka Method.” Price, 75 cents uliefins of new and

standard piano music Oliver Ditson Company. 453-403 Washington St., Boston. | | | C,H. DITSON & OO, N.Y FE. DITSON & CO., Phila

| | SO cents | | “ The introduction ts short, but contains a good analysis of the book, and the ! 7 | notes are precise, clear, and never too long. There {s also an fndex of proper names mainly biographical, a note on the Sophists and a grammatical appendtx Bivca “ This is a careful and scholarly ectit! ” The diMeulties transla “ tn The notes are | ikely to be very usefu Bi tec THE TUTORIAL TO A.D. 14) By A EL Antomows

period.”—The Guardian, + Oxon., and W. F. Masos, M.A. Camb. With Maps. 5 ts “A thoroughly satisfactory compendium of the history of England under the | “Ths Tutorial History of Rome appears to us ¢ de an accura and capal Tudors. The work of a man of very wide and solid reading, with a real grasp of his manual for students, and the book ts written with fuer t and ar ‘ subject, and a mind well furnished and well trained to historical research.”—Daily | papel Chronicle. | ‘The outcome of adequate Knowledge, which has been acqgu as { HORACE, The Epistles. Edited by F. G Pratstowe, M.A., Camb, and | ho it, Ry equal with the latest advances, and infor ~ . « . F. P. SHIPHAM, M.A., London. Introduction, Text, and Notes. 80 cents. | sclentifie spirit.’—Speetator “A well-written Introduction. The notes are voluminous, and explain every SOPHOCLES, ELE > ' ~ulty » text.’— ishers’ Cire ‘ 7 ~ aS SLECTRA. Edited by J. Trowrson, MA, Ca ‘ diffic Pn be pol riot — ular. EP Re : | Haves, M.A.. Camb., Gold Medalist tn Classica. SO cents “ The editors of this issue have done their work with s ntegrity, and com: | “ a a 3 as niinietad ia P . petent knowledge. The arguments of each Epistle are models of ¢ sondensed precis- | on yA — wh ts wanton ts woe .- bn 7 ae re tt ~ ' ; are s —y > making; the notes are full, relevant, pointed, and informing. This eoition ts credit > xt dy 2 aia te t. "Ed: rls. Ate > i — sti pl iene casi able to the editors, and worthily keeps up the standard of scholarship applied to Oto Grady GF Cae ten sshaptaehaptene ate a a toss purpose, cheracteristic of this serviceable series.” —FEdueational News. } ‘The carefully prepared totr: a thor notes which he ’ any e have seen no better e dition of the Epistles of Horace. It is faultless from | Greek text are well worthy of the acit 1 versity t us “ . ees... to end.”"—Teachers’. Aid. { the book belongs.”"— Publishers’ Cir: Complete Descriptive List, embracing Latin and Greek Classics, Translations, The English Language, M } \ mailed free on application, if . A TO ts 7} ppp ch ’ ? »/.y y New and Standard Publications | | oe 4 ( ( Catiuis. | PLAY ; i y f : Sjr.yf ys ad j y THE GOSPEL OF BU.DHA. According to Old 4 THE 4 i ° Paclek Eas ” i - § + Records. By PauL Carus. With table of References , and Parallels, Glossary, and Complete Index. Cloth, j 7 ig \aa) 5 «il C aQi- silt top, $1.50. R ; | — Om our [ tev. Shaku Soyen, the head of the Zen Sect in Japan, AICHal d SOILS Ne W \ el lh " 1 : eee Be NE } . writes: “It pleases me very much to peruse your work, blisl Th oe niet ans ifs j @ 420 CLV LNG) ‘ Ss . ‘The Gospel of Buddha,’ which is happily compiled in Just published The new edition Revised. en ; ; many respects, and I hope, after its completion, you | larged, embodying the latest ideas in teaching 4 a 3) Foti / _ ; ry will be kind enough to let me publish its tre unslation in | New amusements. New annotations. Dr. Mason's Pe alti halt 7 ce our own language. [Iam sure the public will be greatly | famous system of touch and technics. 500.000 of the ry 4 ; ’ Ro cee prove mp s doctrines are un- | old edition sold Price, American or Foreign Fine 9 /207°Sc, Lowe ar RCV? ste ya ecidental author. gering, $3. 00. si ieee iniilistiaciaiiinas ee sa tain THE SOUL OF MAN. With 152 illustrative cuts a we'tmt Riad oem wt ree eeae rao tgeranpemr even to wan 0 OP me neopwee ‘ress eerceenghs ees - “ tlhe prvane anton yn reat Paes pepe ea 1

PAs bs HS NO Orta naRe me = OMEN Go S05 tags J ov norte ten Toles ote Ie Senet tama ae Peer wos mesh A a om

Page 6

vi The Nation. [Vol. 59, No. 1534 MACMILLAN & CO.’S NEW BOOKS. Just Ready: 12mo, “Crimson” cloth, gilt top, $2.25. BY THE EDITOR OF “BOSWELL.” HARVARD COLLEGE BY AN OXONIAN. By Greorck Birkseck Hirt, D.C.L., Pembroke College, Oxford, Editor of ‘* Boswell’s Life of Johnson,’’ Author of ‘“‘ Writers and Readers,” etc. Llustrated with new Frontispiece Portrait in Photogravure of President Eliot, and with Views of the Principal Buildings, etc., including the oldest picture of the College. 12mo, bound in ‘** Crimson ”’ cloth, gilt top, $2.25. The accomplished and scholarly editor of ‘ Boswell’s Johnson,’ Dr. G. Birkbeck Hill, has recorded his impressions of Harvard in a very entertaining volume. Among the topics touched upon are: The Growth of Harvard—‘‘ Fair Harvard ’’— The College Chapel—Fagging and ‘‘ Hazing ’’—Odd Characters—Commencement Day—The Classes—Class Day—The Athletic Craze—Signs and ‘‘ Shingles’—Harvard and Yale—The After-dinner Speeches—The Elective System—The Law School—The Lawrence Scientific School—Radcliffe College—The Library—The Faculty—Oxford and Harvard. By the Author of ‘‘ The Memories of Dean Hole.” More Memories. BEING THOUGHTS ABOUT ENGLAND SPOKEN IN AMERICA. By the Very Rev. 8. Reyno_ps Hoie, Dean of Rochester, author of ‘ Reve- ries,” ** A Book About Roses,” etc. With two Illustrations. 12mo, cloth, gilt top, $2.25. New Book by Frederic Harrison, The Meaning of History and Other Historical Pieces. By Freperic Harrison, author of ‘* The Choice of Books, ete.” Large 12mo, gilt top. $2.25. **A work of remarkable interest and value.”’"—N. Y. Press. ROBERT BROWNING'S WORKS. NEW COMPLETE AND DEFINITIVE EDITION. In Nine Volumes, s12mo, Cloth, in Box, $20.00. THE POETICAL WORKS OF ROBERT BROWNING. New and Complete Edition, including in addition to the matter heretofore included in the sixteen-volume edition, ‘‘Asolando,” together with Bio» graphical and Historical Notes to the whole Poems. 9 vols. 12mo, cloth, gilt top, $2.25 each; the set, in box, $20.00. Jane Austen Illustrated by Hugh Thomson. Pride and Prejudice. By Jang Austen. With Preface by GrorGe Sarntspury, and 100 Illustrations by Huasa THomson. Crown &vo, cloth gilt, or edges uncut, ‘uniform with “Cranford,” ‘‘Shakespeare’s England,’’ *‘ Our Village,” etc. $2.25. sik = an Edition de Luxe, limited, on Hand-made Paper, Super Royal 8vo. .00 net. New Indian Tales, Illustrated by J. Lockwood Kipling. Tales of the Punjab, Told by the People. By Mrs. F. A. Steen, author of ‘‘ The Flower of Forgiveness, and Other Sto- ries,’ ‘‘ Miss Stuart’s Legacy,”’etc. Illustrated by Jonn Lockwoop Kip.LineG, author of ‘‘ Man and Beast in India.” Crown 8vo, cloth gilt, $2.00. CANON FARRAR’S NEW BOOK. PROFUSELY ILLUSTRATED. THE LIFE OF CHRIST AS REPRESENTED IN ART. By FRepERIc W, Farrar, D.D., F.R.S., Archdeacon and Canon of Westminster, author of ‘‘The Life of Christ,” ‘‘Seekers After God,” ete. With numerous Illustrations and Photogravure Frontispiece. 8vo, cloth gilt, gilt top, $6.00. “* The volume is superbly and most liberally illustrated with one hundred and sixty engravings in the text aud twenty-three full-page plates."—The Beacon. “There is a breadth of culture in this book which shows the author tothe best advantage. . . . It is destined to be a favorite volume in the approaching Christmas season.’’—Boston Herald. Fust Published, A Short History of Syriac Literature. By the late Wittiam Wariaat, D.D., Professor of Arabic in the University of Cambridge. Crown, 8vo, cloth. $2.25, net. Second Edition Now Ready. The Religion of the Semites. THE FUNDAMENTAL INSTITUTIONS. By the late W. Ropertson Smirn, M.A., LL.D. Second Edition, Revised and Enlarged by the Author. 8vo. cloth. $4.00, net. Completion of Dr. Swete’s Edition of the Septuagint. The Old Testament in Greek. According to the Septuagint. Edited by Henry B. Swete, D.D., Regius Pro- fessor of Divinity in the University of Cambridge. Vol. II. HOSEA.— IV. MACCABEES. Crown 8vo, cloth, $2.00, net. Cheaper Edition. Now Ready. Labour and the Popular Welfare. By W. H. Mattock, Author of ‘Is Life Worth Living ?” ‘* Social Equality,” ete. New and Cheaper Edition. 12mo, cloth. 90 cents, SELECTIONS FROM THE POEMS OF AUBREY DE VERE. Edited, with a Preface, by GEORGE E. WoopBERRY, Professor of Literaturé, Columbia College. 12mo, gilt top, uniform with ‘ Ballads and arrack-Room Ballads,” ‘‘The Poems of William Watson,” etc., $1.25. “The sympathy of the poet with the ancient Irish spirit must have been fed with patriotic fervor, akin to renewed inspiration, to permit him to render the old lays of his country with such fidelity to their native genius. These poems of Aubrey de Vere—to characterize them largely—are scenes from the life of « hrist in Man; and there is something in them—in their gladness, their luminousness, their :peace—which suggests Fra Angelico, the halo of Christian ° . Art.”"—From the Preface. NEW NOVELS, New Volume of Short Stories. By the late Editor of the Fortnightly Review. Elder Conklin, and Other Stories. By Frank Hargis, late editor of the Fortnightly Review. Crown 8vo, cloth, on 1 25. Tales of Western Life “Frank Harris—a new name in literature—bas written half a dozen stirring stories of Western life. .. . ‘lhe Sheriff and His Partner’ and ‘ The Best Man in Garotte * are worthy of Bret Harte."—Boston Evening Transcript. NEW BOOKS FOR Mrs. Marshall's New Story. Kensington Palace in the Days of Queen Mary II. A Story by Emma MarsHati, Author of “ Winifrede’s Journal,’ ‘‘ Penshurst New Novel, by the Author cf ‘‘A Village Tragedy.” The Vagabonds. By Mrs. MarGaret L. Woops, author of “A Village Tragedy,” ‘‘ Lyrics and Bal- lads,’’ ** Esther Vanhomrigh.”’ Crown 8vo, uniform with *‘ The Raiders" and * The Stickit Minister,’’ $1.50. ‘““A remarkably vigorous and interesting novel, full of true dramatic spirit. site Refreshingly original in style. . . . Its principal personages . . . are per- formers in an English travelling circus.”—N. Y. Times. YOUNG PEOPLE. New Fairy Tale. Maurice; or, The Red Jar, | A Tale of Magic and Adventure for Boys and Girls. By the CounTsss or JER- Oastle,” ete., etc, With Illustrations. Large crown 8vo, cloth. $1.50. | SEY, with Illustrations by Miss Rosie M. M. Pirman. Extra crown 8vo, cloth, $1.50, MACMILLAN & CO., 66 Fifth Avenue, New York. tins cee lalihtil

Page 7

NEW YORK, THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 22, 1894. The Week. THE comments made in some of the newspapers about the withdrawal of gold from the Treasury for the purpose of pay- ing for the new Government bonds are ex- tremely infantile. They are based upon the assumption that the Government ought to be paid in something better than its own demand notes, and that a subscriber to the loan who uses for this purpose the money which the Government itself has forced upon him, is taking an unfair advantage. An- other assumption, equally ill founded, is that the redemption of the Government’s demand notes in gold, although not re- stricted by law to any particular class, is understood to exclude persons who sub- scribe for a Government loan. If this conception were generally entertained it would lead to a premium on gold, great- er or less, and that would be the very condition which the bond issue aims to prevent and avoid. The Govern- ment ought not to set a higher value on any kind of money than on its own legal- tender notes. In point of fact, every sub- scriber to the new loan has the legal right to pay for those bonds with the notes, and it cannot make a _ cent’s difference to the Government whether they are paid with the one or with the other. The new loan has had one good effect, quite unexpectedly. It has opened people’s eyes to the absurdity, the inconveniences, and the costliness of Government note issues, which require the Treasury to provide the ultimate gold reserve of the nation. This is a business function pure- ly. It ought to devolve upon the banks, and would devolve upon them if the Gov- ernment would retire its own notes and simply step out of the way. There is cu- mulative evidence that public opinion is tending toward that conclusion.

It must be considered doubtful if any beneficial financial legislation can be had at the coming short session of Congress, no matter what the President may recom- mend. Whatever measures might be whipped through the House would be al most certain to be asphyxiated in the Se- nate, where silver will still lie a-bleeding. Nor can it be hoped that even the severe surgical operation of November 6 has got the idea into the heads of the silverites that their antics were a prime cause of the country’s disgust, and that it was to guard against a repetition of them that Congress was turned bottom up- wards. With stupidity the gods them- selves contend in vain. Already the At lanta Constitution is urging the passage of a free-coinage law as the sovereign remedy

The Nation. for Democratic ills, and we have no doubt that ‘Silver Dick’? is fully persuaded that he must work all the harder for cheap money in the brief term left of his congressional career. There might be some hope from the Republicans, were it not for the fact that it would never do for them to support a financial law urged bya Democratic President. In times of panic, or for the sake of taunting and dividing the Democrats, such a thing may be done lawfully, but on the eve of coming into power themselves we fear the temptation will be strong to insist that all law-making of that sort must be left over. It is none the less the President’s duty to urge upon Congress needed reforms in our monetary and banking laws, and his initiative will have great weight.

The New York State Bankers’ Associa tion at their session in this city last week endorsed the Baltimore plan of currency reform, and it is now said that the comp- troller of the currency and President Cleveland will refer to it favorably in their next communications to Congress. The only note of discord heard is that of the Populists and silverites. These say that the Baltimore plan is a scheme of bankers, by bankers, for bankers. If that were true, we should consider it high time to take it up, when we consider the dreadful mess that the silverites have made of our currency during the past fifteen years. The bank- ers, during all this time, have remained silent. They have taken no step, except now and then to protest against schemes for depreciating the money standard. At last, after the silver men, Populists, and Coxeyites had done all that they could do, and had brought on a panie which com- pelled even their own sympathizers to vote for stopping silver purchases, the bankers took the subject in their own hands, not to benefit themselves in particular, but to bring order out of chaos. The charge that they are seeking to introduce a new and untried principle into our currency system is made only by ignoramuses. The principle of ** banking on assets" as dis- tinguished from banking on bonds was the distinguishing feature of the best banks we had before the war, and it is safe to say that the /esf ones we had before the war were of unsurpassed excellence. It is the principle of the Scotch system and of the Canadian system, and of the banks of France and Germany.

Never in the history of our politics were so many demagogues laid out in one day as in the elections of a fortnight ago. Hill, Lewelling, Waite, Bland, and Holman are only a small part of the number. In Minnesota. gnatius Donnelly was disposed of—-that State's perennial nuisance, who hoped to become United States Senator through the choice of a fusion Legisla-

ture, and was even beaten as a can didate for the Legislature in his own county, which has always returned him before, no matter with which party he act ed—and he has tried all of them. So, too, Iowa has got rid of its standing nuisance, Weaver, Populist candidate for President in 1882, who was soe badly beaten as a fusion candidate for Congress that he is going to leave the State and abandon politics. The total vote of New Jersey shows that the Democrats of that State hung them selves with neatness and despatch. The Republican vote reveals slight changes from that of I8v2, while the Democratic falls off from 171,000 to 115,000 —or nearly one-third. A fairer comparison would per haps be with the vote of Isao, when the Re publican vote was 114,000 and the Demo cratic 128,000. It is evident that the great Republican majority in the State this year was the work of Democrats. Thousands of them refrained from voting at all, and thousands more voted the Republican ticket. As in New York, the unexpected magnitude of the victory is proving eu barrassing to the Republican bosses. With only a working majority in the Legislature, Boss Sewell would be cer tain to be elected United States Sena tor. <As it is, the almost solid Repub lican Legislature has encouraged other candidates to come forward. It ought to be evident to New Jersey Republicans hat they are now as much on probation as the other party has been for two years past, and that as swift and terrible a pun ishment will be visited upon them for abuse of power as has stricken down their opponents. A resolute effort to rescue the party from Sewell’s clutches would, whether immediately successful or not, be worth many thousands of votes to it in coming elections. he official returns confirm the first re- ports that the Republicans have carried Missouri on the popular vote by a narrow but sufficient margin. This result is im- portant as reversing the precedents of a quarter of a century, for the Republicans have not carried the State on a straight issue between the two parties since Grant’s first election in 1868. The canvass shows that the Republicans won this year through Democratic losses rather than through gains for their own party, the figures for the last two elections comparing as follows: Rep Dem. Pop. Pro. inv2 226,916 268,398 41,213 4,331 1804 229,641 226,547 42,463 3,009 It will be seen that the Republicans have increased their poll by less than 3,000, while the Democrats have lost nearly 42,- 000. But while Democratic absenteeism caused the election of the Republican can- didate for Supreme Court judge, it is a

ow yen regen tw 2 ANCE SSL RRS ter Pat aE spear ye compe

nde mene a bas Ai Lf #1 me

Page 8

STA

great gain for the latter party to carry the State in any way, for the first time in the memory of many voters, because it is al- ways easier to secure the ‘ floating vote ”’ for a party which has once shown that it at least stands some chance of suécess.

The closeness of the contest for the Tennessee governorship has served to show the strength of the sentiment for honest elections in that State. When it first became evident that the Republican candidate had won by a very small ma- jority, there were some intimations that he would be * counted out’? by the Demo- cratic officials who control the returns, but the suggestion was promptly repudiated by everybody of authority in the party. The chairman of the Democratic State committee announced that ‘‘there has not been and will not be the slightest irregu- larity countenanced,’’ and such represent- ative organs as the Nashville American declared that ‘if Evans has been fairly and legally elected, he should be, and no doubt will be, duly inaugurated.’’ In Tennessee, as everywhere else in the South, the senti- ment against election frauds has never been so strong as since the repeal of the federal election laws. Moreover, the fact should not escape notice that, while the Republicans never carried Tennessee on a square issue between the two parties so long as those laws were on the statute- book, they have secured the governorship at the first election after their repeal.

The results of the election in Nebraska and California show the growing inde- pendence of voters. In each State a ma- jority of the ballots cast on the congres- sional issue were for the Republican can- didate, while in each the Republican nomi- nee for Governor failed of election because some thousands of voters in his party who supported the rest of the ticket would not sustain the man whose name stood at the head. The Australian ballot law helps very much in encouraging this spirit of independence. The chairman of the Democratic State central committee in Kentucky frankly acknowledges this ef- fect of the system. ‘The election,’’ he says, ‘* will be a valuable lesson, as well as a warning, to the party. A secret ballot makes voters more independent, and if the party expects even in a sound Democratic State like this to poll its full vote, it must deal fairly and honestly with the voters, and especially in local races must nominate capable and worthy men.”’

There was a most remarkable and grati- fying exhibition of the power of the inde- pendent voter in Cincinnati on Tuesday week. In the national election the Republicans carried the city by an im- mense majority; in the local election, seven days later, the Republican candi- date for judge of the insolvency court was defeated by several thousand majority. This was anew office, created by a bill

The Nation. [Vol. 59 No. 1534

which was ‘‘ sneaked” through the Legis lature in its closing hours, and which was so hastily and _ carelessly drawp as to require its filling by a_ special election, on November 13, at an ex- tra cost of $10,000, instead of on the re- gular day for voting last week. For this place Boss Cox, the ex-saloon-keeper who runs the Republican machine, picked out one Von Seggern, a lawyer of meagre ability, dubious character, and unsavory record, who was declared unfit for the of- fice by an impartial and non-partisan com- mittee of the most eminent members of his profession. The boss relied upon the more than 20,000 majority of last week to pull through his tool, and there were Republican newspapers hide-bound enough to support Cox in his contempt of decency, but the voters rebelled, and Von Suggern was beaten by about 3,000 majority.

Of the three States which recently vot- ed on the question of calling a convention to revise the constitution, one went over- whelmingly for such action; in the second the proposition failed because there was so little popular interest that most voters neglected the matter; and in the third the convention was voted down at the polls, but through fraudulent counting is re- turned as carried. The difficulties of changing the constitution are probably greater in Delaware than in any other State of the Union, since it is requisite that the affirmative vote shall exceed a majority of the highest vote cast for representatives in the Legislature at any one of the three previous general elections. Over and over again this severe require- ment has defeated action, even when a good majority of the votes actually cast were favorable to a convention. But public sentiment at last grew so nearly unani- mous that at the recent election the vote stood 22,842 for to 2,364 against; and al- though only about two-thirds of those who declared themselves for Governor paid any attention to the constitutional question, the affirmative vote largely exceeds the requisite number. In New Hampshire, on the other hand, so little interest was felt in the matter of a new constitution that but few voters recorded themselves either way, and the proposi- tion failed really from inattention. In South Carolina, the Tillmanites favored a convention, but they were outvoted by about 10,000 through the opposition of anti-Tillman Democrats and Republicans; yet the Tillmanites have ‘counted out”’ the opposition, and returned the proposition as carried by about 2,000. This is the most barefaced fraud ever committed, even in South Carolina, and it has ex- cited intense indignation.

There has been a good deal of talk about some sort of testimonial to Dr. Parkhurst, and he richly deserves one. But it ought to be something strictly personal-—books, pictures,’ silver, or furniture. At all

events it ought by no means to be a pub- lic monument set up in the streets, for such a monument would, of course, commemorate our shame as well as his services. It must not be forgotten that he has not delivered us from a foreign ty- rant or oppressor, or from an apparently good ruler who turned out badly after he got into power. He has delivered us from the yoke of men deliberately chosen and rechosen by our own popular vote, after we knew all about them and had seen many specimens of their work. Grant was as well known in 1890 as he is to-day. So was Gilroy in 1892. He had issued from the sheriff’s office in its most corrupt and degraded period, and had in 1890, when appointed commissioner of public works, immediately made Barney Martin, an old grogshop-keeper, who had been indicted for bribery, his deputy. Our oppressors, in short, did not get hold of power by a coup d'état or by force of arms. They got it by the choice of the people. We have honored Grant as much as we have honored any of his prede- cessors, if not more. Therefore Dr. Park- hurst’s testimonial should be something for himself and his family and not for the pub- lic sight-seer. This Tammany hallucination of 1888-’92 will always be an interesting historical episode, but not a thing to com- memorate in brass or marble.

A prominent member of the Hawaiian Government, Mr. Damon, told his fellow- councillors a few weeks ago: ‘‘ If we wait for the United States to give us annexa- tion, we shall have to wait a long time. What is to be done, we must do our- selves.’”’ This doctrjne is now ‘‘ treason ”’ among the Hawaiian extremists. They must have annexation immediately, and there is no use in talking about establishing a government on any other basis. Yet there is evidently a growing conviction among the revolutionists that they must continue to hold their own dog by the ears for some time tocome. This conviction will not be weakened by the growing indifference of the Republicans to poor outraged Hawaii. When the furious Boutelle tries to annex by resolution in the next Congress, he will find Speaker Reed as stubborn and noisy with the gavel as ever Speaker Crisp was.

That the art of war in modern times is more and more reducing itself to the art of finance, we have lately had many facts to remind us afresh. War, in truth, is only another name for financial specula- tion on a great scale. If Japan whips China, she stands to win $200,000,000, which she will exact as ‘tindemnity’’—that is, as a return on her investment. Mili- tary glory continues to be a. fine thing in the eyes of mankind, but, without an ac- companiment of hard cash when all is over, it partakes too much of the nature of a barren ideality. At any rate the finance ministers who have to _ pro- vide the funds for securing the glory,

iG a PRs RRA BK if La eae ac a < ; 4 : i i i 5 ' $ 5 3 i i ,

Page 9

cata cha oan EN a eS vie Se SNe srescisn tesa aR ae keep a sharp eye on the gold which they hope to get along with it, and, if it comes to a choice between the two, are disposed to say with Omar Khayyam, ‘Take the cash and waive the rest.”’ Even such *‘ war scares’ as those caused by the death of the Czar, when it was first seen to be impending, or the threat of complications between France and Eng- land, or the troubles of the French in Madagascar, throw the stock markets into a shiver, and show how war in a commer cial and industrial world is like blood poisoning in the body. When hot-heads begin to talk about the need of fighting off Russian assaults on Afghanistan, the bankers and merchants at once begin to ask who is to provide the $20,000,000 ne cessary to send a British army there, or the $100,000,000 which would be required to keep it there a few months. Down go the stocks until the official assurance comes that there is ** nothing in it.”’ A writer in the Jnvestors’ Review commenting on this intimate connection of finance and war, asks why the ‘swag gering fire-eaters’? can never be got to look on this side of the picture. He truth fully says, anticipating what Lord Rose bery substantially declared the other night at the lord mayor’s banquet, that “the edi tor’s room is often worse than a barrack room for its blatant display of we-can-lick creation, brainless insolence.”* For a na tion that lives by commerce and is owed money by three-quarters of the world, this bloody-bones style of talk is not only contemptible, but dangerous. A great war would promptly ruin half the in vestors in England, and probably cost Great Britain half her empire. The writer in the Periew would be glad to see a Government official stationed behind the chair of every Jingo editor, constantly putting to him the question, ‘* How are you going to pay your income tax of three shillings in the pound with half the banks broken and consols at 80?” But the editor would have a complete answer ready. He would either deny that he ever had any income tax to pay, or would affirm that he could easily make up the difference by the immense profits on his war extras. The only thorough going remedy is the one we have long ad vocated—namely, a law compelling all fighting editors to go at once to the front, and be given as near a view as possible of that “hell of death and destruction “ to which distance lends, in their eyes, such enchantment. Lord Rosebery is *‘ catching it,’? both from the Radicals, the Liberal Unionists, and the Irish. The Irish, who really have his official existence in their hands, are growing more and more impatient over the way in which home rule has apparently been relegated to the rear. Redmond, who commands the Parnellite ten votes, de mands an immediate dissolution on the The Nation. home-rule issue simply and solely, so as to get a plebiscite on it, and ridicules the anti-Parnellites for their willingness to wait till Rosebery ‘*mends’? the House of Lords: and the anti-Parnellites have w Radi cals,on the other hand, led by Labouchere not much to say in defence. T and the Chronie/e, flout him because he is a peer and because he does not appear to have much mind of his own. The Liberal Unionists sneer at him because, although he attacks the House of Lords, he does not say how he is to get rid of it, or what he is going to substitute for it. He probably does not know what had better be done: but what just now seems most probable is a dissolution on the question of the Lords. If he got ‘ta plain popular mandate” to “mend or end ™ the Lords, he could then take some decid edstep in the Commons against them, but hardly otherwise. The step most talked of is a resolution of the Commons declaring themselves the paramount legislative body, , 1 4 but if the Lords chose to disregard this and throw out a Commons bill, would such a bill be accepted by the country as law? Neither party seems to like to face a situation of this sort, and vet it has to be faced if anything is to be done. Mr. Chamberlain has, in the meantime, come forward with some positive measures for the Liberal Union ists, which have been received with general ridicule. Construction is evi dently not his forte, though he did prove a very successful administrator as mayor of Birmingham. A very remarkable episode in parlia mentary government is) appros i crisis in the little colony of Newfound land. One year ago this month, the party in power went to the country on the legal expiration of the Legislatur The chances at the polls were heavily against the ministry and the electoral con test was bitter. But Premier Whiteway and his leutenants, as was afterwards fully proved in court, used the Pul Works Department most effectively to pur chase votes. Written agreements by the ministers awarding road-building con tracts on the promise of political support have since been placed in evidence The ministry won, electing twenty fis inembers out of the total thirty sev Three nths ter the Opposition | ran legal proceedings against t s cessful bribe givers. Evid e Was ove whelming ind a urh othe nla judges were of the mi istry’s ow! party, the twentv-five **Whitewavites.”’ including the pret r himself, were for mally unseated. The Whiteway ministry thereupon resigned, their purpose being to force a general election and secure the re turn of the s tied legislators. This plan failed. The Governor-General, acting under advice from the British ministry, prorogued the Parliament three successive times, and eventually ao} ted the ex treme measure t collecting the customs Q~~ evird revenue without a legislative appropria- tion bill. By these bold expedients, in the face of actual rioting, the bye-elections were put off until the fall, when it was hoped that public sentiment would be thoroughly aroused against the corrup tionists. But the hope has not been justified. The six most important bve elections for the seats of the « } lisqualified members have now been held, and the Whiteway candidates have won by heavi lv increased majorities. The unseated cor ruptionists could not, of course, stand per sonallv for this Parliament; but the plainly avowed plan is to organize a w Whitewav ministry, vote it down by its own support ers, and thus fores 1 genera etectiorn through whi t liprits of ISG ay ull returt As t fore f ti British Government ts publicly entisted against the now victorious Newfoundland party, the outcome will be interesting. M. Nun a Dy . several f a President of the Swiss Confederation, and at present one of the most considerable figures in Switzerland, has lately published in the Bib? othedgue q . his views the working of the referendum ind the initiative. They will note: t! ATO people whoare benton say row i try by transplanting here those political ontrivances, M. D ‘ ules, after ot Serving t! drift f t 1 s f r many vears, that the nservative d racv of Switzerland is in danger f g the moderation which ss ow bee the admiration of Europe, and of taking a plunge into unrest rogy The sole principle of authority t Swiss Government resides in its representative character, and t tat tends i l the while to destrov this transforn legislators into mere ¢ tric buttons for acing the history of polities in his own land,{M. Droz remarks that the referendum * furnished of itself a the people to press. Tra base of operations for demagogv.”* but that only half the mischief could be done by its aid. By it popular whin uld paralyze legislation, but could not itself legislate. So the initiative was devised to change the wooden sword nt One f steel, and now, according to the ex President, “the Government is in a fair way to be pushed aside, in all important matters, and to pass into the hands of political com- “s I nittees."" f- He jrefuses to be comfort ed even bv the recent rejection of the ridiculous law, brought to vote through the initiative, affirming the “right to y. #8 work This only shows, i says, that the Swiss people are not at present in clined to socialism, not that they are op posed to absurd and noxious laws as such. He instances the anti Semitic amendment to the Constitution, voted into the organic law ‘‘amid universal apathy,” asa speci men of the kind of laws which he expects demagogy tosucceed in passing through the initiative. The outlook fills the veteran Swiss statesman with sadness, eee eine = ea NO Pn rene ee Oar PN Sie nee OMIA Ata EI - UT AR lear A ena ve la 5 AO lg ah ~ ee ee ees re Ati ith WELT ee ————. = re Tepe ee nied wee Sint so ae TNT nathastecnsind ns tinialichacataipteriiadpltigale + agligncs D.thelindh Meaty: uiaighdinttes de laaninianiaiigaliag Seine Sree

Page 10

376 The Nation. [Vol. 59, No. 1534 THE REPORT ON THE CHICAGO STRIKE. THE report of the commission appointed by the President to investigate the Chica- go strike has been made public. It is a disappointing, in some respects a very dis- turbing, document. In matters of fact its compilation of statistics will prove useful as a permanent record, though everything recorded was known before; but in its theorizings and recommendations it takes many surprising and dangerous positions. The commission was appointed in pur- suance of a law which provides that where both of the parties to a labor ‘‘difference”’ will not agree to submit it to arbitration, the President may, ‘either upon his own motion or upon the application of one of the parties,’’ name a commission to ‘ ex- amine the causes of the controversy, the conditions accompanying, and the best means of adjusting it.’’ Now, this par- ticular ‘‘ controversy ’’ was already “ ad- justed’’ when the commission went to work. Debs had abdicated, and the Pull- man strikers who had been lured into his organization by an exaggerated idea of his power to bring railway kings to their knees, had gone back to work, and were glad enough to do so. Under these cir- cumstances the duty of the commission would appear to have been simply to col- lect facts about the causes of the strike and the conditions accompanying it. This they, in fact, did, and their account is rea- sonably complete and impartial. But, not content with this, they argue a great deal to show how a controversy that had adjusted itself in a particular way should really have been adjusted in another and radically different way, and wind up with some extraordinary propositions about compulsory arbitration and a permanent United States strike commission. This may not have been going outside of their powers, but it certainly was overstepping the bounds of propriety and prudence. Without stopping over many details of the report that invite criticism, we will direct attention to two vital points in which it seems to us to be both mistaken and mischievous. One is the expression of the conviction that, at the very crisis of our civil war last summer, the Pullman Company and the General Managers’ As- sociation should have consented to ar- bitrate, or at least to the appointment of a committee to see if there was any- thing to be arbitrated. Referring to the firm stand taken by the company and the association, the commission says that it ‘‘is impressed with the belief, by the evi- dence and the attendant circumstances as disclosed, that a different policy would have prevented the loss of life and great loss of property and wages occasioned by the strike.”’ The narrative of events leading up to this conclusion is grossly inadequate and unfair—unconsciously so, no doubt. All the rioting and the plundering and burn- ing are left out—all the terrorism, extend- ing over large sections of the country and affecting millions of citizens, with the need of calling out the troops, State and na- tional; and the impression is given that it was just an ordinary peaceful strike which the implacable Pullman and the _ hard- hearted managers refused to arbitrate. The report gravely recites the efforts of the ‘Civic Federation’ of Chicago, made up of “eminent citizens,” to inter- vene, together with those of the Common Council and the mayor of the city, and notes with a pained air that the ‘“ stereo- typed answer ’’ was returned to them all, as also to Mayor Pingree of Detroit, “himself a large manufacturer,’ though backed up by telegrams from fifty other mayors. Notaword here about the shooting and train-wrecking and blockading, about the distress of travellers and the threat- ened famine in many cities; not a word about the intense excitement throughout the whole country, and the general feeling that the existence of the Government and of society itself was at stake, and that to give in to the strikers at that point or at any point would be a deadly blow to liberty and the rights of property—nothing of this, but only the statement that the com- mission is ‘‘ impressed with the belief” that the company and the managers should have given in. This part of the report is only a traves- ty. What account of the ‘“‘cireumstances accompanying”’ this strike, which was not so much a strike asa social convulsion, can be complete if it leaves out the intense anxiety of the best citizens lest a fatal sur- render of principle should be made? Much has been said about the disagreeable cha- racter of Mr. Pullman and his hard and ty- rannical ways, asofalittledespot. We have nothing to say about all that, but we do affirm that there were hundreds of thou- sands of the best American citizens who rejoiced with great joy at that critical moment that Mr. Pullman was unyielding. They did not care if he was disagreeable personally, or if his firmness was mere stubbornnesss. He could not be too mul- ish or arbitrary for them or the occasion: Americans abroad anxiously scanned the fragmentary despatches and prayed fer- vently that Mr. Pullman would at any rate stand firm. They would have been willing that he should be a thousand times more disagreeable and pig-headed, if ne- cessary, to make him the man to settle that principle of law in this country, then and there. He did settle it, and the coun- try owes him a great debt, whether he is a likable and kindly man or not, and whe- ther the commission is impressed with a belief to the contrary or not. Providence never showed a more tender care for this country than in having an unpleasant man ready for that emergency. The other astonishing position taken by the commission is in favor of compulsory arbitration, binding on the railroads but not binding on the employees. This seems too absurd to be credible, but there it stands in black and white. ‘ Railroads have not the inherent rights of employers engaged in private business,’’? and hence a law can be passed to compel them to pay whatever wages a commission of ar- bitration may fix upon. On the other hand, employees have an “inherent, in- alienable right to work or quit,’? and therefore they cannot be forced to accept wages they do not like. This is the most laborish scheme of compulsory arbitra- tion ever devised, and has about as much chance of being adopted as the heads - I - win - tails- you-lose principle in gambling. We presume the commission was led into its ambitious theorizings and suggestions of remedies for all labor trou- bles out of a desire to magnify its office. It seemed too paltry for men under Govern- ment appointment at $10 a day simply to gather together facts already perfectly well known; so they had to affect the ora- cle and bring out another solution of the labor problem. Luckily, their opinions carry no official weight and will be accept- ed only for what they are worth. One good result of the report will be in- creased hesitation about appointing com- missions to inquire into the origin and causes of ‘‘labor troubles.’? There have been several of these commissions dur- ing the last ten years here, in England, Germany, and France. They have not only never found anything out that every- body did not know already, but have in many cases, through the strong tempta- tion to coddle labor which in these days of democracy besets every public and even semi-public man, done a good deal to aggravate the laborer’s discontent and set class against class. There is hardly any man who is fit to conduct such inquiries unless a judge sitting in a lawsuit. Most investigators are either strongly opposed to all the pretensions of labor, or else their heads are stuffed full of the vague socialistic longings which are already such an affliction to all industry. In either case the report only aggravates the trou- ble. Labor disputes are -generally very simple, and nobody can possibly settle them but the parties to them.| They alone know all the facts, and they have the deepest possible interest in coming to terms. The interference of outsiders, un- less asked for by both sides, ought to be a gross impertinence. Nothing is more needed at this crisis than the practice of treating the working classes as business men fully capable of managing their own affairs, and not as children who are being put upon by their elders, and are to be forgiven if, in their childish rage, they break the furniture and throw the bed- ding out of the windows. THE FILLING OF THE OFFICES. THE question how the Governor and the mayor are to fill the vacancies made by the men who are to “‘go,”’ is one which not unnaturally begins to occupy the public mind. The Governor has about two dozen appointments to make of first-class im- portance, to offices now held by Hill and x= ssi GRRL ORM IR IRESNNES 8 Fore piemee ewe m

Page 11

Pre Sees fers Por ehiSea? hare Nov. 22, 1894] The Nation. Murphy ‘“workers.’”* An outside esti | mate of the candidates for these State of fices would give twenty-five to each. This makes six hundred in all. Give each candidate ten backers and endorsers, and we have a total of 6,000 persons who are deeply interested in the disposition of these places—that is, 6,000 persons who desire them to be filled for other reasons than the good of the community. To all the others. it is a matter of supreme indif ference who fill them, provided the work be well done. Now, the total vote of the State at the last election was about 1,200, 000. Add to this as many women who did not vote but have an equal interest with the men in good government, and we have 2,400,000. Deduct from this the 6,000 office-seekers, and we have 2,394,000. to whom the filling of the offices has no in terest whatever, provided they are well filled. So that those who will beset Gov. Morton to get him to give them a living out of the State treasury without regard to their qualifications are about one four- hundredth part, not of the population, but of the adults of both sexes. There is very little difficulty in filling these offices if fitness only and not claims is to be considered. But it is perhaps asking too much to ask Mr. Morton to fill them for fitness only. Republicans have probably been too long excluded from these State offices to make it possible for any one man to withstand their rush, or totally exclude the consideration of ‘“‘claims.’’ But in considering ‘claims,’ we may fairly ask him to take two things into account. One is the very great change in the position of ‘‘ workers ”’ since the Re publicans were last successful in this State. He must remember in the first place that it was they who in 1885 brought Hill into the governorship by arranging a great Republican abstention in order to “spite the Mugwumps,”’ so that what we have really been doing at the last election, is undoing, by * toil of heart and knees and hands,”’ the mischief wrought in that unhappy year by the Republican managers. In the next place, there has probably never been a Governor elected in this State who could so truly say that he owed no thing to either party. No one is foolish enough to pretend that Morton’s majority of 157,000 came from either party. It came from the honest, sober - minded, industrious people of both parties, who do not care who get the offices, but do desire good government. It would, therefore, be peculiarly unfortunate if he were to listen for one moment to the advice of a man like Platt, who not only had no share whatever in winning the victory, but has been for many years closely identified with the sys tem of corruption which the election of November 6 was intended to overthrow. The Tammany police justices, for instance are largely the result of a‘ deal” of his ir ISS88. , In the last place, it must not be for gotten that the new ballot act has greatly changed the position of the worker in politics. He is no longer entitled to the ' . ° ' consideration he used, and perhaps not unreasonably, to claim. The first es sential of his trade was the publicity of the vote. It was necessary to his business success that the way a man voted should be known to his neighbors, and for this purpose the worker put the ticket into his hands and saw it deposited in the ballot-box. For a service of this kind it was well worth the while for the late Mr. Thorndike Rice to pay the late Mike Cregan $5,000, and it is nothing to the purpose that Mike betrayed him and “tran out” his rival's. tickets. A faithful worker was extremely useful under the old system to both his party and his employer. Under the present law this is no longer possible. No worker can tell how many votes he has influenced, if any, and he is, therefore, not entitled to any office as of right. Let us note, too, that Hill and Murphy have had all the offices for nearly ten years, and have nevertheless sutfered ruinous defeat. The ballot law will undoubtedly be made still more stringent next spring, possibly by the adoption of the Myers machine. This will insure absolute secrecy and fair counting, so that the occupation of the working politician will be completely gone. The result of this will probably reach farther than we now imagine. It will undoubtedly give appointing Officers a much freer hand. It will make ‘‘claims” much more difficult toestablish. Above all, it will restore speaking and writing, or in other words discussion, to their old place in American politics. It will make imposst ble a repetition of Hiil's impudent boast, that ‘‘they had got the brass bands, but he had got the delegates."". It will make nominations by conventions much less valuable because they will give less sure promise of election. Nothing is more en couraging than the uncertainty about re sults which now prevails in thi has been increasing for sor rapidity and unexpectednes majorities pass from one pi does for our politics what the sea. They keep it sweet and They give such an assurance as nothing else can, that what the people desire, of all things, is not party triumphs, but good government. Every one who has followed the course of New York politics is aware that Mr. Thomas Platt has long played a prominent part in it, not as a formulator of ideas or a framer of policies, but as a distributor of patron age and as a controller of the rural legislators throug patronage row k y¥ not what If v Were « alled to say, in fact. who} local bosses had done most tol nany in the itv and ik it lan i, we should say it was Mr. Platt. Consequently, although he is to-day trying to get the re me and *‘confer”’’ with him, he is himself part of the t rto . formed. Why he interests himself in poli tips « 1} } ha ] na wan ¢ hin tics at all, WHY he does not wl e him self to the conduct of his express business, has never been satisfactorily explained But the fact is that for ten vears | has been, we might say, permanently in command of the Repu in party i this State, and constantly engaged gotiations with Tammany in its name. His process has been verv si ny when the Rey ubl Legislature, he has “struck” Ta aris for offices and contracts by threatening hostile legislation or investivatior \ ; : his medium > cans are ina minority, | kes t ‘ nive at Tammany schemes, vote for and keep silent a t t res ract in debate, or in s Vay prevent Opinion fron getting t t Bat Ss pul is alwavs the sat f | any the storm t is wrath with un passed over the prominent Repub r around his ,a ving doubtless to get instruc tions from him. These things are all mysteries which we make no pretence of being able to solve. We eall attention to them as among the most important facts of the hour. If the practice of consulting and deferring to Platt, in fact, cannot be broken up in thé next Legislature, we greatly fear that many the bright hopes of the reformers will not be fulfilled. No reform can be sue cessful in this State which does not reach Platt himself. He is himself a gross abuse, one of the grossest we have to contend with. If it be said that his power of mischief will be destroyed by the fact that Tam Coe A reap le Amd eh ame Pt ae ieM AN « sb ie aretdn ney obec Beret ~ - ened es Phim aa ” RST a Rea

Page 12

378 many has now nothing to bargain with, we answer that the defeat or postponement of a power-of-removal bill would be worth more to Tammany to-day in money alone than anything Platt has ever had to offer. The passing of such a bill means the loss to the organization of a payroll of about $15,000,000 annually, and nothing would be easier than to raise among the Boys a sum,‘ for political purposes,’’ which would keep Platt’s treasury full for a good while, and which he could accept, as Cro- ker has accepted blackmail, without any breach of the law. It is only in case of the passage of such a bill that Tammany cannot ‘“‘trade.’’ As long as it holds the offices, the materials exist for the finest ‘“‘deal’’ Platt has ever made or imagined. We find already that there is a good deal of whispering going on about the probability that no such act will pass, but if it does not pass, the reform effort of the last month will be utterly thrown away. Con- sequently it is not with the devil but with the sinners we have to deal to-day. Platt is certain not to change: death will probably overtake him in the middle of a ‘‘deal.’”?> But we cannot help hoping that the new Republican legisla tors have felt and shared the passionate aspiration for better government, for a more manly and American way of facing political responsibilities, which has carried them into power, and that on this occasion at least, if only for once in their lives, they will try to stand on their own feet. One great ground of hope lies in the changed attitude of the New York 7’ri- bune towards Platt. That paper is, as the party organ, probably the only New York paper which reaches the Republican legis- lators, or has any influence on them; and its exposure of Platt’s methods is all that could be desired and ought to bear fruit. SECULAR ACTIVITIES OF THE CHURCH. One of the warmest discussions of the Episcopal Church Congress in Boston was that on the topic, ‘The Church’s Duty in the Matter of Secular Activities.”’ This ‘an hardly be called a burning question with Episcopalians, since tradition and church polity and the general level of good taste in their denomination have kept them from the temptation to go to such extremes as other churches have fallen into. One of the speakers at the congress exhibited a huge green poster announcing a benefit to be given for a rural church in Massachusetts, and enumerating among the features ‘‘a song and dance sketch,”’ an impersonation of ‘*The Bowery Girls,”’ and a skirt dance. It need not be said that it was not an Episcopal church. At the same time, it is clear from the course of events in England and in this country that even the staid and esthetic Episcopal church feels the running of the strong tide in the ecclesiastical world, and has to face the question of a great expan- sion of the church’s activity on the social The mystic letters P. S. A. are well side. The Nation. [Vol. 59, No. 1534 understood in the Church of England, we believe, and denote a Pleasant Sunday Af- ternoon Association for the promotion of good times and attachment to the church through getting up excursions and bi eycle runs after the morning service, to fetch up somewhere for a sermon (guaran teed to be short) on Ezekiel’s wheels or some such relevant topic. And on this side the water the clubs and brotherhoods and sodalities have wondrously multiplied in the last few years. What other denomina- tions have given in to almost unreservedly —that is, all kinds of social contrivances and organizations to ‘* make it interesting for the young people ’’—has become some thing for the Episcopalians to consider. This is clear from the prominence given the subject in the Boston Congress. What the debate also made clear is, that there iva division of opinion on the question in the Episcopal church, with the weight of Humbers apparently in favor of indefinite ly extending the social side of the church’s work. The chief speaker in opposition was the Rev. W. B. Hale. Two articles of his in the Forum on religious conditions in Massachusetts country towns and in Fall River have marked-him as a man with a keen eye for facts and a_ praiseworthy bluntness of speech. His argument against what he called “‘ the desecration of the church ” through the “‘ crowding sen- sational performances which index its secu- larization,’’ appears to have been vigorously presented and’ to have made a deep im pression. What he would have the church do is to stand before men as ‘‘a great, imposing spiritual fact,’ given up to the proclamation of ‘‘the Gospel of faith, righteousness,and judgment to come,”’ and leaving all this business of libraries and gymnasiums and music-rooms to other and profaner, hands. But is there any hope of this view being now realized? What, in fact, is the rea- son why the church has been driven by circumstances, or led by Providence, as one chooses, into this new attitude towards social pursuits and enjoyments? Looking at the matter dispassionately, it seems clear that it is because the old attitude of sacred aloofness has broken down, in the sense that of itself it can no longer command the support and affection of mankind. It is indeed a fine concep- tion, that of the church asa great, impos- ing spiritual fact, standing apart from the hurlyburly and the coarseness of ordi- nary life; but how if so standing only means an increasing isolation and ineffect- iveness; how if so standing ceases to make it an imposing fact at all? We leave it to those most concerned to say why it is so, but the fact of the loosening hold of the church and church doctrine of the old style on the minds and hearts of men we take to be admitted. It is implied in all such discussions as the one to which we are referring. If this is the case, it becomes simply a question of ordinary human expediency and of a desire to get the most good possi- ble out of a great and venerable institu- tion, what is to be done to restore and in- As far as we can see, there are but two courses open. One is to readjust the doctrine—that to “reconcile science and religion,’’ to re- fine and explain away the old difficulties crease its power. is, which press so heavily on the modern in- tellect. But this isa painful and a dubi- ous process. A brand-new theory of inspi- ration, ora clever dodging through the first chapters of Genesis, is not calculated to make the church a great and imposing fact. Moreover, the operation is at best Sisyphean, for no sooner have you got reli- gion. well reconciled with current science thana new science comes along to compel you to begin the job all over again. The old theology has, in practice, to meet the terrible difficulty of a ‘ we- know-all-that ’ air in the congregations of to-day, while it seems to be the weak- ness of the new theology that it starts more doubts in one sermon than it can lay in two. A preacher in Whitechapel recently hada painful experience of this. He had discoursed on the new view of hell, not asa place of physical suffering, but asa state of sin and alienation from God, the soul itself its own dungeon. Walking out behind some of his hearers, he heard one of them say to another: ‘¢Parson says there be’ant no hell, Dick. Where be you and I to go then?” The new theology had filled them with a fresh sense of homelessness, as if their one sure pro- vision for the future had been suddenly taken away. A much surer as well as a more useful way to restore and preserve the prestige of the church seems to us to lie in develop- ment on the social side. It was never more obvious than it is to-day that the principal strength of the church is as a social insti- tution, and a frank recognition of that fact seems only proper. Certain it is that the newer organizations and observances which tend to make the church less awful and more human have done a great deal to win back to it the indifferent. This being so, it is idle to argue against them. As long as the new methods can do what the old methods aimed to do but failed of achieving, they will surely remain in vogue. Whatever may be their effect on the historic conception of the church or on the doctrine of the church and the effect. on both cannot but be profound—they will be cherished for their excellent practical and reformatory results. And it would be hard to deny that such results are their sufficient jus- tification. WORKING WITH FROUDE ON SERS MAGAZINE.—I. FRA- New York, November, 18!4. NEAR the close of 1863 I was invited by Froude to visit him, in consequence of an arti- cle of mine sent, by Carlyle’s suggestion, to Fraser (‘‘ The Transcendentalists of Concord”), and for eighteen years I enjoyed bis friendship.

Page 13

alah Giese as, re a ae

Nov. 22, 1894]

{ continued writing for Fraser so long as he was its editor. His characteristic liberality was a good deal pressed by my articles during the civil war in America and the period of recon- struction. He was not quite a captive of Car lyle on the negro question; he regarded slavery as an evil, but he had the instinctive dislike of a philosophical historian to revolutionary or militant methods of reform. At the time, many of his views on American questions ap- peared to me merely academic, but I have since often had to reflect on the greater fore- sight with which he apprehended some of the sequela of a reform secured, however inevita- bly, by force. Moreover, Froude was able to quote some of the most eminent abolitionists in America against the policy of * coercing the South,” such sentiments having been freely uttered before the attack on Fort Sumter. In one of his earliest notes to me, Froude says: “T am amazed by the course Motley has taken He once stayed at my house, when the trouble in America was beginning, and completely indoctri nated me into the idea of disunion, which he thought to be the feeling of the North But when I met him after the war had broken out, and spoke of his former sentiments, he almost foamed at the mouth.” Although my political articles were hard for Confederate sympathizers to bear, Froude never changed a sentence himself, and rarely induced me to alter them; and only in one case (‘The New Rebellion in America,” No- vember, 1867) did he print any disclaimer. This was in a footnote saving that the paper expressed ‘‘ the opmions of the extreme Re- publican party; opinions curious and interest ing in themselves, yet not necessarily sound or certain to be verified by fact.” His usage, af ter I had selected a subject relating to the struggle, was to write me some thoughts, strongly put, meaut to restrain my enthu- siasm, which saw the New Jerusalem hovering over America, and waiting to alight when the negro was made a citizen. As all articles in Fraser were anonymous, such restraint was not unfair, and in reading the subjoined ex- tracts from Froude’s notes their practical pur- pose as well as their off-hand character should be remembered: *Tam going to ask you to revise some of the more gushing passages in your Jast five pages. My own intense conviction is that fifty years hence people will look upon the whole emancipation enthusiasm as—like many other enthusiasms—a dream of mad ness. Ido not wish to make my own opinion the absolute rule of what is to appear in Fraser, and still less do I look forward to what will be said of us fifty vears hence; but I do not like to affect a tone of thinking and feeling the precise reverse of the truth.” This note related to an article which appeared in June, 1865, ‘* The Assassination of, President Lincoln.” I had good reason to be grateful for the alterations asked for, as they dimi- nished the stock I had taken in Andrew John son, SO soon to become worthless. As I was a Virginian, both Carlyle and Froude listened to my views about slavery with respect, and Carlyle generally encouraged him to let me have my say in the magazine, though he some- The Nation. 8379

times stormed at me about them afterwards No article was ever refused admission. Pr mising only that Froude never gave the year in his dates, [ continue the extracts, which re- fer to different papers, without interruption “I fear that on the slave questi nearly with Carlyle than with you. At least I look on it, and have all my life looked on it, as a thu

be allowed to wear itself gra tion advances. You cannot tr

old as mankind a: a crime to be put it by f If you do, youare unjust, and the injustice wi x Sout coil upon yourselves) You make wrong into right ment Vases t by treating it unfairly. You are playing once agair sa Mut . on a new stage the old game of Philip the Second | Perience with Seot 1 We and Alva. You cannot be more persuaded of the i 1 it tem, twe ) y wickedness of slavery than they were of the wicked taxpayers grew weary of { \ ness of heresy The universe does not allow on tare . s section of mankind to inflict its views upon another kind and not by s at the point of the sword. If the sword is pressed tt \ into a service beyond the common sense of mankit y ow ‘ ‘ f it will kill the man that uses it, You won't believe un uuly any of this, but you will find it to be so, unless the | Ut > , laws under which we live in this world are suddenly trea y altered. ’ s vs v his Your article suggests so many considerations that l am obliged to pause upon it for a month Either I} must add netes or vou must intr l qualifications. You accuse England of want sympathy. England has no want of sympathy, but ‘ \ England has been taught lessons by painful exper ence, You propose to force the South hence! ‘ ward to govern itself by Northern ideas, and you | 's 't . think that now, after Grant's election, they are « tain to comply. England has for 700 vears been try Cary \ ing to force English ideas upon Ireland, at least as superior in themselves as yours are to the Virg v nians’, Our Catholic Church in the th century was \ ‘ more bloody and cruel to heretics than the Black | Me Code to the negroes We have conquered the i W try fifty times, confiscated the estates, settled 4 , vinces with immigrants, instituted preachers of out t thes ‘ ideas in every parish in the island; and we are now > obliged to confess that we have z wrong way, and were attempting the impossille It Froude not . is curious that the only Englishmen wl lo " \ bring ab . ‘ agree with your Republicans are those whe at = : . loudest the other way abeut Ireland. You may l« sage . * some of sv vs a ‘ right, and you may succeed, but if you do IT shall expect to hear that Congress has successfully \ ° , . pealed the law of gravitation, There is nota single | SGites Were tf ‘ instance in history in which one nat } lek, a . “ \ sa ‘ of a nation, has succeeded by for i ,. | It st } nided ¢ " the unwilling adoption of its own creed, howeve . i bv t x 2 " vA superior that creed may be Wrot we have | Ka. wee intel . _ learnt, ‘is no match for ri but it is ‘ re aE - P — . . mateh for right and power combined “Tf you wish to persuade us, it will mot be by se | “ ways & 3 ting down what vou eall our « iIness t w n ’ Mon R : NWA difference, but by recognizing that we Ww people have reasons for hesitati und distrust by showing why those reasons are t ap, \ \NI Every word you say in this article I can pa we XN SIT from Irish state papers advocating the policy w | has brought us to our present difficulties. TT} ‘4 LIS . st . " ment of arguments, in the sixteenth a sev | | > show us I huss in teenth centuries, was that the only ene . x | ‘ Ws and vt land were the chiefs and the landowners; that | tri and \ w flags a 3 inted w those very chiefs were the rutai Ppress > ack ‘ \ Vea vas peasantry, and ir business was . \ | ; nies : » 5 vi 's* and the stablis = : i . tillers” im the s ed by lis | grants, English laws, an English p CERIN, RR VEG isharmy. What has a ‘ s stnan t tillers preferred pov i A eis that ¢ Sani chiefs to prosperous 1 s > Li s " i gra s imbibed Irish ways N i t izainst us here we a s , woes \ 1 our st tors fee assured it cTOSS i a i " , Pia Vs - oe | among t Souther ‘ es, W a , I 4 at ‘ : the s e Way at ~ ¥ s f i that the . sults 7 . ed Ley i i i i sh 2 Y I , - \ } ” Pea e his ined i e anit . s and se x ‘ " I | it i is \nd now theya N i ae | N _ t ‘ ania > ing al the ironies of Some s $ “s stor President Carnot never for amoment _ 1 bis life felt himself in danger from the - be 2 ' anarchists; if there was a representative Ian sires gees tas ve ” wh tld think that his life was safe and that e sta g we stinaey s re wr what vou ‘ t he had nothing to fear from @ssassins, it Was j " J _ 1 the head of a free and representative govern- iracter and t I pany t alluded ¢ ment, the president of a republic, the bighest } Was written by myself expression of the popular suffrage. Carnot, weit ’ — — clad t ay who was a calm and courageous man, always Pe ee ere pending struggte [state | bore with reluctance and impatience the pre | i ; ‘eermiong ng cautions of the poli tL nder bis government i= ae 2 t \ WAS the i e . | = : j} all the laws passed in the House, good or bad, ; 4 + 4 a) s j . g . < was . < : “ were passed apparently for the benefit. of the , } | can se ss are going exactly WAY We ex working and the suffering classes; socialism You a pelled to keep uj i pervaded the legisiative work, still, Carnot

Page 14

380 The Nation. [Vol. 59, No. 1534 was the chosen victim of the anarchists, of the party which has declared war on the capitalist and the bourgeoisie. Alexander ILI. was, during bis whole reign, thinking of the Nihilists, and, instead of be- coming, like his father, their victim, he died a natural death. Nature did what dynamite or the dagger could not do. Remember under what tragical circumstances he ascended the throne. The cruel death of Alexander II., as- sassinated by the Nihilists, took place on the 13th of March, 1881. Alexander II. had been on the throne for twenty-six years. On the very day of his death he had sent to the Home Office an order to announce in the Official Messenger that he would convoke an assembly entirely composed of the provincial states and of the dumas of the great cities; this would have been the opening of a constitutional era, something like the ‘‘ Assembly of the Nota- bles” which preceded the Convocation of the States-General. Can we wonder that, after the horrible death of Alexander II., his son did not think it possible to give satisfaction to a party which used assassination as one of its means? The times were very threatening ; the Nihilists had accomplices everywhere, even in the army, even in the imperial palaces. One of the witnesses of the first reception which Alexander IJI. gave to the diplomatic corps, M. Melchior de Vogiié, writes: ‘*He received us on the 8th of April, in the palace which was said to be undermined, not far from the tribunal where, on the same day, appeared the assassins of Alexander II. The new monarch wore the long tunic of the Cos- sacks of the Don, which made him look even taller; he addressed a few words to the assem- bled diplomats. Accustomed as we were to the ease, the affable talk of the late Em- peror, our impression was uncertain; a slight embarrassment in the person and the speech betrayed the cruel annoyance of the Czar at his first representation. Through a half-open door connecting with his writing-room, I still see three children’s heads, smiling, curi- ously watching all these unknown strangers. Of these children, now become men, one strug- gles today with an implacable malady, an- other has just placed on his head the heavy crown of Russia.” Alexander III. lived chiefly at his residence at Gatshina, an old and savage castle, built among a forest of fir trees and surrounded with ponds. Gatshina became a sort of for- tress; the Emperor, always shy and timid, liked to live there, away from the noise of St. Petersburg. He worked incessantly, reading the reports of his ministers and putting brief notes to them. He would have no chancellor; the time of the Nesselrodes and Gortchakoffs had passed. He probably did not forgive Gortchakoff for having become a sort of tool in the hands of Bismarck. He had, like all the Slavophiles (and he was a thorough Slavophile at heart), not forgotten that Russian diplo- macy had been completely defeated at the Congress of Berlin. The Russian armies, which, after the terrible fighting before Plev- na, had been carried to the very door of Con- stantinople, had recrossed the Balkans. The Emperor became his own chancellor, and in reality his own minister of foreign affairs. He was a man of few words; he might even be called an enigmatic man; but the develop- ment of events showed by degrees what was the exact character of his policy. His first acts proved clearly that he meant to be an au- tocrat, and that he did not intend to relin- quish any portion of his authority. In one of the first cabinet meetings, the privy councillor Nabokoff read to his colleagues a sort of mani- festo on the part of the Emperor. Loris Meli- koff and Abaza, who had prepared the ukases which Alexander ITI. was on the point of sign- ing when he was murdered, sent their resigna- tions to Gatshina, and Gen. Ignatieff, a tho- rough Russophile, became Minister of the In- terior. In an ukase of the 12th of May the Czar confessed ‘‘ his faith in the strength and legitimacy of his autocratic power” to reés- tablish order in the empire; he hoped to give a new development to the religious and moral sentiments of his people. He began a difficult and laborious war against corruption, which is the plague of the Russian administration. In- augurating a policy of retrenchment, he re- duced the number of offices in the imperial household, he appointed a number of commis- sions for the reform of the administration of the army and the police, and to regulate the condition of the former serfs. There were, when his father died, still three millions of peasants who were unable to pay for the land which had been allotted to them, and who, in consequence, remained under the severe tute- lage of their former lords. They had to ac- quit themselves by degrees towards these mas- ters, by bodily labor. Alexander III. came to their help; by an ukase of the 9th of January, the Government paid the lords, in banknotes, the price of the lands which were in the hands of the emancipated serfs, and they had to re- imburse the State in a number of annuities. They were given all the rights of proprietor- ship from the date of the Ist of January, 1883. Were it only for this boon, it can easily be conceived that among the peasants Alexander III. was looked upon as a saviour and a bene- factor more than an ordinary sovereign. The emancipation of the serfs could hardly have been accomplished otherwise than by the auto- cratic will of the Emperor; the terms of eman- cipation, had they been discussed by chambers necessarily composed of the former masters, could never have been as favorable as those which were adopted. The Emperor felt in many questions the need of his autocratic power; he felt it particularly when he made the liberal ukase in favor of the Old Believers or Starovertzi, of whom there are more than thirteen millions. Though their ceremonies differ but little from those of the Orthodox church, they could not open churches, nor send their children to the schools and aca- demies of the State; in the army, they could not become officers. Alexander III., by a stroke of the pen, put an end to all these disabilities. He chose, among the first objects of his atten- tion, the corruption which existed in all branches of the Russian administration, and which had already been denounced by Pushkin and by all the great Russian writers. This cor- ruption was so great, so universal, that it can be compared only to what exists in the Otto- man Empire. How far this war against the Russian form of backsheesh has been success- ful, it would be difficult to say; but we must nevertheless give credit to the Emperor for bis attempt to cleanse the Augean stables. The Emperor's efforts were naturally directed also towards all measures which tended to put the Russian finances on a stronger basis. In these efforts he was fortunate enough to find much belpin France. Napoleon III. said that France could make war for an idea; France can also make investments for an idea. When Italy joined the Triple Alliance, the French capitalists sold their Italian funds, and made investments in Russia as soon as it was gene- rally believed that Russia was averse to war and would not allow the Triple Alliance to be- come offensive. How this feeling came to become universal, it would be difficult to tell. The genesis of what is called the Franco- Russian alliance was slow; it was like oneof nature’s phenomena—it was born insilenceand darkness. Alexander ITI. said nothing to the Triple Alliance; he said no- thing, at first, to France: it was felt, however, that a great change was taking place in the con- stellations of the political sky. Alexander IIT. was very slow to separate from the old alliance of the three Emperors, the Dreikaiserbund, but he feltearly that Austria had benefited more than Russia from the Turkish war; she had taken Servia and Herzegovina without firing a shot, while Russia could not even prevent Bulgaria from choosing a prince who was, or appeared to be, in the Austrian interests. When Alex- ander allowed the tie of the Dreikaiserbund to become very loose, he had to look about for some declared or at least virtual ally. There was France, all ready, isolated since 1871, and at times even alarmed about herself. It is my belief that there is not, as some people think, any written understanding between France and Russia—anything that can be compared to the diplomatic documents which bear the sig- natures of the sovereignsof Germany, Austria, and Italy. But Alexander III. felt himself slowly drawn towards France by a sort of ir- resistible necessity. With his habitual horror of writing, he avoided as much as he could written engagements; his own will, his own interest, spoke loudly enough. He felt that this sentimental Franco-Russian alliance was a great bar to those who wished to embark Europe in great adventures; he was a peace- maker, and he overcame, in the interest of peace, his natural antipathy for many men. He was also made to believe, after many years, that if there was no stability in the parliamen- tary cabinets of France, if they fell in succes- sion like card-houses, there was nevertheless a certain continuity in French aspirations, likes, and dislikes; he was told that the French army survived all the parliamentary defeats, that it was imbued with a spirit of discipline and of patriotism, which, at a given moment, could make it again a most formidable weapon. And thus it happened that the Franco-Russian alli- ance, after having long been a mere instinct, became a fact, an obvious factor in politics. The happiest moments which Alexander III. spent in his laborious life were probably those which he passed every year in Denmark, with the family of his wife, away from all etiquette, away from the Nihilists. Those who saw him there represent him as the best and simplest of men, fond of animals and of children, a child of nature himself ; in his gigantic frame, the true type of the tender and kindly Rus- sian, not demoralized by Occidental civiliza- tion, full of natural affections and of natural sympathies. Correspondence. THE MANDATE OF THE ELECTION. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: Iam too warm an admirer of the Na- tion to indulge in captious criticism, but in comparing your recent editorial utterances with those on the previous congressional elec- tion, there appears to me a certain inconsist- ency. You will remember that after the election of 1892 you urged upon the President-elect the importance of an early session of Congress for the purpose of revising the tariff; you believ- ing, with many others, that such was the man- date of the people. Why, then, should not aes lives lain ania tdi ea lala aman

Page 15

cease SSR Ae ian ited, ating Vivid ile ai il Nov. 22, 1894] ‘The Nation. President Cleveland call an early session of the recently elected Congress, so that the expres- sion of the popular will be formulated in a tariff act more or less 0 la McKinley? If there was reason for attributing the election of 1802 to a tariff-reform proclivity, is there not equal reason for ascribing the recent tidal wave to a protectionist reaction ? There were few, if any, Republican speakers who participated in the recent campaign, who were not closely identified with McKinleyism. Governor McKinley was greeted with the wildest enthusiasm, and repeatedly nominated for the Presidency at the meetings which he addressed in New York, as well as in other States. Mr. Harrison, who signed the McKin- ley bill, and who has since not wavered in his convictions of its merits, was also warmly re- ceived. If Mr. Reed was apologetic, we must remember that his Presidential bee cannot well hover around the McKinley hive. You intimate in a recent editorial that it was apathy rather than changes in conviction, rebuke to party management rather than loss of faith in party policies, which led to the Re- publican defeat of 1892 and the Democratic rout of 1894. But if this is conclusive, which I question, it does not appear to be more availa- ble as an argument for one election than for another. Under our system of government we are obliged to assume that a majority of voters is competent to decide on all economic, political, and financial questions which may come before them, and that such majority knows what it wants. Should not, therefore, the wishes of an overwhelming majority be promptly complied with ? C. A. W. BALTIMORE, November 15, 1894. [To another correspondent last week we expressed our belief that the Republican majority just elected to the House could not define its mandate. In fact, if ever there was an election in off years which was obscured by mixed issues, that of No- vember 6 was emphatically one. The ne- cessity North and South of getting rid of the Populist incubus, and again of suppress- ing Tammanyism, unquestionably over- ruled national considerations over a large tract. Democratic apathy and abstention, produced either by hatred of corruption or disgust with the mismanagement of the tariff, cannot be interpreted to the advan- tage of the opposite party as a mandate contrary to Democratic principles. The President, grown wiser since 1885, refused to vote for Hill or to utter a single word even to ‘“‘save the party ’’—that would contribute to his success. How absurd to suppose he was thus issuing a ** mandate’ against himself! He knows, and we all know, that his reélection was public ap proval of a tariff-reformer, and that while protectionist views were maintained and protectionist orators applauded in the late ‘anvass, the undoing of the mutilated Wilson bill was not a favorite topic with these gentlemen. In fact, if we reasoned logically from Mr. Reed's argumentation, we should have to regard the election as a second whack at protection—for were we not told ad nauseam that the Democratic party stultified itself by passing a protec tionist measure ? Nor, to meet our cor- respondent’s point about an early session, must we forget that the election of 1892 was a mandate to Mr. Cleveland as the head of a victorious party, for whose fidelity to its principles he more than any one else was responsible. The mandate now, if there be one, may be to the new Congress, but Mr. Cleveland has no re sponsibility for the party consistency of that body.—Epb. Nartion.] THE STRIKE AND THE VOTE. To THE Epitor OF THE NaTION: Srr: Do you not think that in estimating the reasons why so many Democratic voters stayed at home on the last election day, some weight should be given to the resentment felt by mem- bers of the labor-unions all over the country at the action of the President in sending the Unit ed States troops to Chicago during the Pull- man strike? The feeling was and is very bit- ter. [have no meansof measuring its strength, but from what I have heard said, I should con- sider it one element, and a very considerable one, in the West. Good statesmanship is sometimes very poor politics in the narrow sense. Regular troops are especially hateful to our foreign voters. Yours very truly, CHARLES F, JOHNSON. HARTFORD, Conn., Nov. 18, IS@4. HALLUCINATIONS, To THE EpiTor oF THE NaTION: Srr: Permit me, as the spokesman for a number of persons who carefully examined and rejected the evidence about pbantasms of the dying presented in the book called * Phan- tasms of the Living,’ to say that we do not consider the new Census of Hallucinations as satisfactory, nor the conclusion from it legiti- mate; and that our objection is to the commit- tee’s logic. It is true that for any ordinary case one might let the evidence go as sufficient, but, the conclusion being so revolutionary, in our opinion an exacter proof is necessary We object to your assumption that whoever rejects the reasoning of the committee is ne- cessarily a positive disbeliever in the reality of the phantasms. 1, for my part. in my attack on that book, fully admitted that it ought to be regarded as sufficient to silence any poob- poohing of the belief in ghosts. C. S. PEerrce. ARISBF, MILFORD, Pa , November 13, 1894 THE ORIGIN OF BAYOU, To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: The communication of Prof. Wyman in No. 1538 of the Nation, page 361, on ‘the same criticism as the ‘New English Diction- ary’ and the ‘Century’ but too often invite when they pass judgment upon a word with- out fully canvassing the authorities. The In- dian origin of bayow has been known to the writer of this note for some ten years past, and probably to other students of Ameri- can dialect as well. It seems strange that Prof. Wyman, while acquainted with the ety- mologies of Pascagoula, Pensacola, Apalachi- cola, given by Byington and others, should have failed to notice the following passage in the first volume of Dr. A. S. Gatschet’s ‘A Migration Legend of the Creek Indians’ (Phila- American word bayou,” seems open to the | 381 “The full form of the tribal name [i e@., Bayogoula] is Bayuk-okla, or river-tribe, creek or bayou-people; the Cha’hta word for a smaller river, or river forming part of a delta, is biyuk, contr. bOk, and occurs in Boguechito Bok’ humma, ete.” (p. 118 It is in justice to my friend, the distinguished linguist of the Bureau of Ethnology, that I call attention to this, the first scientific state ment of the etymology of this interesting American word. Prof. Wyman’'s independent solution of the etymological problem which the word has presented to many is heartily to be welcomed; but priority lies, Lam fain to be lieve, with Dr. Gatschet. Prof. Hemp! of the University of Michigan, to whom the writer of this note communicated his belief iu the Indian origin of bayou, some time ago, is now engaged upon an investigation of the origin, history, and local distribution of the word, the results of which will no doubt soon be made public A. FP. CHAMBERLAIN CLARK UNSIVERS!Ty, W ESTER, Mass November 16, [sua MODERN GREEK AND ITS PRONUNCIA. TION, To THE Epriror oF Tur Nation Sir: Mr. Gennadios’s article on ** Teaching Greek as a Living Language” has drawn out three letters in the Nafion. Mr. Alden, in his sympathetic letter, showed clearly that he bad caught, to a remarkable degree, the true spirit of modern Greek and its relation to ancient Greek. Tam sorry I cannot say the same for Mr. Lawton, for his letter is most unsympa pathetic; while the distinguished classical scholar, Prof. Goodwin, believes that the ques tion of Greek pronunciation ought to be fonght over, not in the columns of the Nation, but upon the ramparts of Constantinople between the Greeks and the Turks in a deadly combat Blood, not ink, he declares, should decide the question. No one ever suspected so amiable a man of being so sanguinary. Three elements constitute the modern Greek the dialects, the common language (nicknamed Romaic), and the literary one. The dialects are used only in their respective localities; the other two prevail all over Greece, now com- mingling, now struggling for supremacy, and all the time making faces at each other. The common language exists by reaction or rebel- lion against the slavery of grammar, and it willexist just so long asthe literary one exists; if the literary one perishes, the common one will perish too, for want of having some- thing to rebel against. It is well that it is so, for this rivalry bas a salutary influence on both of them, since it restrains the one from reaching too high astyle, the other from reach- ing too low. I dare say such is the case more ; or less with languages every where Mr. Lawton, in calling modern Greek patois, makes the same mistake all foreigners make when they visit the mother country whose language they have studied in cold type with the eye only, without having ever learned it by ear, and hear it spoken for the first time. The common language is genuine Greek or Hellenic only here and there—in forms and syntax—free from the thraldom of grammar. The Greek detests the stiffness of formality in dress and in speech, and for this reason, when he retires to the privacy of his home, he gladly lays aside cuffs, collars, and frills, and in chat- ting with his family and friends he suits his speech to his dress by discarding, metaphori- cally speaking, the grammatical cuffs, collars, delphia, 1884 and frills from many words and phrases. This SS aee o Hh

Page 16

Ney SLE NS Re SO ee ae Etastrentttaire> 0 as toate TDD RANE Some simple, unaffected speech is the informal speech of the people. I used to look upon English, during my first year or so in this country, just as Mr. Lawton looks now upon Greek. From a philological standpoint, English appeared to me to be a monstrosity, the spoken language a patois, and its pronunciation a jargon; but I did not hastily write my immature impressions and send them to a Greek newspaper. Only gra- dually was I forced to change my opinion, and not before the English language reached my understanding through my ear. Then I began to see and appreciate the force, the beauty, and the individuality of the English language, written or spoken. And now, after a residence of nearly twenty years in the United States, I feel that, next te the Greek, nothing in the world is more beautiful than the English lan- guage, literature, and pronunciation. Mr. Lawton’s statements about the literary or journalistic language are absurd. This language is perfectly natural to, and in direct touch with, the people at large. The news- papers’ style follows the popular taste; other- wise, they could not live aday. The different shades in style are due to the individualism of the writers and to the plasticity of the Greek language, ancient and modern. Xenophon’s ‘Anabasis’ is not read in Greek schools; Esop, Lucian, and the ‘Cyropzedia’ are read instead. Yet the journalistic style, reflecting the literary taste of the educated classes, is so high that, if a newspaper were to publish the ‘Anabasis’ in serial form, its readers would read it with such avidity, as contemporary war-news, that they would scarcely stop to notice here and there the few differences in forms and syntax; the style would appear to them a little too Attic, and only the arms of the soldiers would betray the age of the story. The objections to the modern Greek pronun- ciation are due to prejudice. The Greeks are themselves well aware, from inscriptions and allusions in ancient authors, of certain changes in the sound of one or two vowels; but these changes had already been established in the xowh diadrexros (@. e., the Attic dialect, slightly modified, of the Alexandrian period) about the first half of the third century B. c., and in all probability as far back as Demos- thenes, a century earlier. The chief charac- teristic of this pronunciation is the reading by the written signs that mark the accents, which were introduced at the close of the third cen- tury B. Cc. in order to preserve ‘‘ the correct- ness of speech.” Through the living pronun- ciation of the living Greeks lies the road to the life of the Greek classics, for what took Mr. Lawton years of laborious study to enable him to see (if, indeed, he has ever seen and felt) the ‘*throbbing life and beauty” in the pages of Sophocles and Pilato, an educated, native Greek will accomplish at first glance at a classic page. J. P. LEOTSAKOs. 240 S. 1STH St., PHILADELPHIA, Noy, 15, 1894, Notes. Tue Bureau of Education has engaged Mr. Appleton Morgan and Mr. L. L. Lawrence to compile a‘ Directory of American Literary So- cieties,’ which the Bureau will print and dis- tribute. A circular calls for certain data, the reply to which will insure the society a copy of the Directory. 8S. C. Griggs & Co., Chicago, are soon to publish an authorized translation, by E, J. The Nation. [Vol. 59, No. 1534 MacEwan, of Freytag’s ‘The Technique of the Drama.’ A third edition, revised and much expanded, of Dr. Norman Kerr’s ‘Inebriety; or, Nar- comania, its Etiology, Pathology, Treatment and Jurisprudence,’ is at once to be brought out by J. Selwin Vait & Sons. Bb. Westermann & Co, send us the prospectus of a folio book of travels, ‘ Durch Siid-Amerika: Aus der Zeichenmappe eines reisenden Kiinst- lers,’ to be published sumptuously in Hamburg by Louis Bock & Son. The travelling artist is Th. Ohlsen, whose ‘‘ vehicles ” are pencil, char- coal, pen, and india ink. The large scale of this publication permits very broad effects. An assured welcome awaits the Complete Works of J. G. Whittier in a one-volume ‘*Cambridge Edition” (Houghton, Mifflin & Co.), a generous octavo in good type with two columns to the page, uniform with the one. volume Longfellow. Here will be found eve- rything in the seven-volume Riverside E\ i- tion, plus the supplementary collection ‘ At Sundown’ and such poems as have been brought to light inthe just published autho- rized Life of Whittier by Mr. Pickard. Among these are some curiosities, like the bellicose ‘* Song of the Vermonters, 1779,” which served as a quarry for ‘‘ The Yankee Girl,” and some rarities, like the Frémont campaign song, so hard to find in its sheet-music form. Mr. Scudder prefixes a compact and skilful sketch of the poet’s career which his admirers will be glad to read. There are indexes of titles and first lines, and an etched portrait of Whittier in his later period. Mr. William Martin Johnson, who, if we mistake not, illustrated a sumptuous edition of ‘Ben Hur’ for the Messrs. Harper, has em- ployed his talent in a similar manner upon Kingsley’s ‘ Hypatia,’ now issued by the same house in covers of a vivid green silk. His de- signs are partly imaginative of the personages and action of the story, partly emblematic and archeological, and, again, occupy a whole page. or, more commonly, indent the letterpress or haunt the margin or serve as head or tail- pieces. They are delicate and graceful, not al- ways strong, and are drawn in wash or with the pen. We, for our part, can but regard the irregular distribution of these little pictures as @ passing affectation, not truly in harmony with the art of Gutenberg; but they are re markably evey in quality, and lend an air of painstaking and outlay to the edition. Being engraved by process, they exact a shiny page, and this is a toll upon the reader who threads his way through them. We have already spoken sufficiently of M. Masson's ‘ Napoléon chez lui.’ This chronicle of petty details has not failed to be turned into English, by James E, Matthew; J. B. Lippin- cott Co. being the American publishers. The typograpby is needlessly open, and the two volumes might well have been made one. We cannot praise the translation; for example (vol. i., p. 64): ““Ségur, who was already de- voted to Bonaparte, and had joined the hussars as a volunteer in the campaign of 1800 (whose father, among the first to come over, etc.)”; (p. 65): ** but enjoyed their favor for a short time only, having died of illness at the begin- ning of 1816.” Add to this an annoying reten- tion of French phrases: we count ten on p. 133, all in italics. The illustrations of the original are reproduced with this edition. A longer interval was needed to find a trans- lator and an English public for the ‘Memoirs of the Duchesse de Gontaut,’ which touch the Napoleon epoch at its beginning and at its close. They have been translated by Mrs, J. W. Davis, and are likewise in two volumes, illustrated with portraits (Dodd, Mead & Co.). The rendering is noticeably intelligent and idiomatic. The same publishers have resuscitated An- ster’s metrical version of the first part of ‘Faust,’ for the sake of illustrations by Frank M. Gregory. These, in various tints of helio- type, with some vignettes in the text, seldom rise above the level of prettiness, and mostly substitute pose for expression. The volume is attractively made up. So is Tennyson's * Beck- et,’ with the same imprint, but with illustra- tions by F. C. Gordon, whom a feeble play has certainly not inspired. So, for a third, is Dickens’s ‘ Tale of Two Cities’ in two charming little volumes, with designs by Edmund H. Garrett—pen-etchings, full-page and vignette, not powerful, but decorative and unobtrusive, and that is a good deal. The gray cloth bind- ing is tastefully stamped in gold. Lovell, Coryell & Co. have reissued in two presentable volumes, with excellent portraits, Mrs. Oliphant’s ‘Victorian Age of English Lite- rature,’ of which we had our say as an agree- able guide-book a couple of years ago. The impression is a little faint, but the typographic page is handsome, with broad margins for notes. Mutatis mutandis, we need only repeat our comment last summer on G, Montbard’s ‘Among the Moors’ to convey a correct im- pression of this author's ‘ Land of the Sphinx’ (Dodd, Mead & Co.). It has all the defects of taste and style that distinguished his former work, and, in spite of the numerous produc- tions of his pencil, it is not to be preferred to the dryest guide-book, Flippancy is as little in place in Egypt as perhaps in any country in the world, and flippancy is the note of this oc- tavo of 341 pages. Félix Dubois’s ‘ Anarchist Peril’ (London: T. Fisher Unwin) is mainly interesting on account of its collection of anarchist caricatures, which will be of value to the future historian as proof (if proof were wanting) of the very low state of art and intellect in the anarchist press. The fact is that the propaganda would have made much more impression on the world if the anarchists had confined themselves to reform ‘*by deed.” If they bad merely blown people to atoms and assassinated ‘‘ bourgeois” right and left without saying a word, a certain mys- tery would have attached to their perform- ances which would have helped them ; but the publications of their ‘‘doctrines,” the dying speeches of their heroes, and the debased con- dition of intellect revealed by their press, have opened people’s eyes to the real character of the creatures and the motives which recruit their ranks. The amazing thing is that they should ever have had men of education for leaders. Prof. Paul Fredericq of Ghent has supple- mented his recent ‘Onze Historische Volkslie- deren’ with a discourse in French on ‘ La Chan- son Historique en Langue Néerlandaise avant les troubles religieux,’ forming a little brochure of thirty-one pages. He points out the rarity of historical songs prior to the dissemination of printing, when they fell by the wayside and perished, owing to the temporary interest felt in the events which gave them birth. Still, the industry of scholars has resurrected about five hundred of them anterior to the religious troubles of the Low Countries. Of these Prof. Fredericq gives specimens with transiations into French. The most interesting to the gene- ral student are two on the voyage to Spain of Philip the Fair and his Queen Juana to take possession of Castile on the death of Isabella, ner mesh

Page 17

The first of these depicts in quaint terms the cowardice of Philip on being overtaken by a storm in the Channel; the other explains his early death, as caused by poison administered to him ina cup of wine by Juana. While, of course, these effusions have no weight as his torical documents, they are of much interest as embodiments of popular manners and of the currents of popular thought, and their general characteristics are set forth by Prof. Fredericq with his wonted ability. ‘Monsieur Cotillon,’ by Henri Rabusson (Paris: Calmann Lévy), might have been a strong book; the subject-——a sad enough one, the hold of vice on a man—lending itself to serious treatment rather than to the light and airy mode of handling preferred by the author. M. Rabusson has missed his opportunity; per- haps he has not power enough or talent enough to do more than see a good subject—which would be a pity. Judging from the third number, the more se- rious contributors seem’ to be dropping away from the ‘ Yellow Book’ (London: John Lane; Boston: Copeland & Day). James and Dobson, Leighton and Sargent, are conspicuous only by their absence, and the impressionists, literary and artistic, areleft tocarry on the work alone. How long they can do so remains to be seen. Why is it that these gentlemen can seem to tind nothing in life worth representing but the music-hally That institution is even more prominent in this number than in either of its predecessors, and that is saying a great deal ‘The Leaping Ouananiche: W hat it is, where, when, and how to catch it,’ by Eugene McCar- thy (New York: Forest and Stream Publishing Co.), has a self-explanatory title. The facts learned from its perusal are that the ouanani- che (‘leaping ” is not a part of the pame) is a land-locked salmon, that its habitat is confined to Lake St. John and its tributary waters, and that it can be caught during the tishing season, any time after the ice breaks up in the spring This disposes of the ** what,” ‘* where,” and ‘‘when.” The ‘‘how”™ isa more ditlicult mat- ter, and the author would have done better had he left it out altogether. He makes the mistake of trying to tell how to play the fish an art which can be gained only by experi- ence. The ouananiche was but little known to anglers until within a few years. Its gamey qualities are now so thoroughly recognized as to need no advertisement. The book has seve- ral attractive illustrations, and is valuable as revealing a grand country for anglers. ‘The Boy’s Own Guide to Fishing, Tackle- Making, and Fish- Breeding,’ by John Harring- ton Keene (Boston: Lee & Shepard), bas the two virtues of clearness and completeness. it attempts to lead a boy from inartistic sucker-fishing to the essentially manly and artistic sport of trout, bass, and salmon-tfish- ing, and nothing, to the very humblest detail, is forgotten. Theauthor is evidently a thorough sportsman and accomplished fisherman, and his love for his subject makes his book pleasant reading even for a boy who has grown to be a man. Almost any angler, old or young, may learn things from it which he either neve knew or has forgotten, and, if he follows some of its suggestions, may find his increased catch not entirely due to good luck. In Morley Fletcher's translation of Von Kahlden’s ‘Methods of Pathological Histo logy,’ with his own notes (Macmillan), are shown the latest German and the most im- proved English ways of microscopical work with tissues and bacteria. There are no illustra- tions, no pathology, and bo treatment. The reader is supposed to recognize what the ui The Nation. croscope shows him, whence the objects arise, and what they demand. But there are mul- tiple devices for staining and fixing these fac- tors, briefly but clearly expressed, to the great saving of the student's time and energy. On the other hand, Schenk’s * Manual of Bacteri ology’ translated by Dawson (Longmans) is protusely illustrated, although the scale of magnifying is very provokingly seldom noted. It does not treat of histology proper, but is a refreshing contrast in size and perspicuity to treatises that deter by their very volume, Both Dooks are well indexed. Dr. J. W. Downie'’s * Clinical Manual for the Study of Diseases of the Throat’ (Macmillan is a good example of specialty in medicine well developed. The only omission observed is in re ference to the practical question, which is of popular interest, whether the removal of en- larged tonsils injuriously affects the voice According to a recent article in a Russian newspaper, there were published in Russia, not including Finland, during the past year 335, million copies of 10,242 separate works. Of these about three-quarters were published in the Russian language, the remaining quarter being divided between the Polish, Hebrew, German, Lettish, Esthonian, Armenian, ete., in the order named. There was an increase over the preceding vear inthe number of books published in French, Lettish, Armenian, and Polish, a decrease in the others. The largest proportion of books in Russian, a quarter of the whole, were of a religious character In the Jlansische Geschichtsblitter for 18u8 (issued in October, ISt4) there is an instructive essay on ‘** Die Hanse zu Ausgang des Mittelal ters” by Prof. F. Frensdort?, based on records recently published by the Verein fir Han sische Geschichte. He considers the internal organization of the Hanseatic League, its fune tions and privileges, its relations to the Em pire, to the various German principalities, and to foreign Powers. He shows that the League exerted considerable intluence upon the internal government of the citres included in the federation. In 1418 an enactment was made that any city guilty of overthrowing its council or governing body should be excluded from the Hanse; this ordinance was frequent- ly contirmed in the fifteenth ceutury. The in- teresting question whether the federation was a corporation is also examined. The League contended that it was a corpus only as regards the enjoyment of its privileges in various coun- tries, but not a corpus in the sense that the federated cities were individually liable for each other's acts. —The third and fourth volumes of the * His toire Générale, du [Ve siécle A nos jours,’ edited by MM. Lavisse and Rambaud (Paris Armand Colin & Cie.) are entitled respective ly, ‘Formation des Grands Etats” and * Re- naissance et Reforme: Les Nouveaux Mondes,’ and cover the vears 127) 1402, 1492-1559. The tirst wandering of the peoples (the Germanic invasions) was followed by a formative period in which kingdoms were laboriously built up only to topple down, while throughout the land the people slowly segregated into inchoate na- tionalities. After the second wandering (the Crusades), followed in due time a second epoch of px l ed kingdoms which, for the most part, because ‘al development, wherein were found- they were true nations, still exist. These vol umes tell the story of this second period of formation: of its beginning in the feudal state, of its rapiddevelopment under centraliz- ed authority, of the social and religious read- justnents that followed the awakening of in tellectual activity and moral sensibility among all classes. MM. Coville and De Crue write upon the political history of France, MM. Pe tit de Julleville, Mintz, Levasseur, and others upon French literature and art. MM. Bomont and Langlois deal with English histery. M Rambaud writes of Russia and the Ottoman and Mongol empires, M. Cahun of Asia, M Masqueray of Africa. The age of maritime a venture in Portugal is assigned to M. Gallows and M. Moireau writes with endat servatism of the discovery America Ube bibliographies are continued as ial, wit their convenient separation of iments and “livres sources, and recet works research Prof. Wundt’s * Vorlesungen ber M schen und Thierseele published more tha thirty vears ago, can be named with bk. i Weber's articles, with Fechner’s * Psvehophy i sik’ and Helmb s works on sight and ‘ ing as one of the pioneers of that expernpuenta method of study tn psychology which los be come so powerful since In INh) Wundt 1 lished an edition of it with alterations a omissions, which we have wodor nto t lish by Professors Creighton and Titehes Cornell, and published by Mae: ul There is much to be said against tssui an alte edition of a book that has marked a el in the development A scie! \ it of its value as an bist i t, and you fail to make it a genuinely mel work Prof. Bain’s recently published t of his ‘Senses and Intellect’ is a case stmki: ly in point. The translators th work, moreover, tell that t \ av furnish a literal, as dis yuls r a \ bal (s rendet ' aul tex even at tl ‘ ASIONA airy Y These twi tacts i is tt kw some alarm: but happily prov ‘ + Prof. Wundt’s unexar i sint making has practically led him to write a work altogether, in which passages t earlier one have been inserted only where they would still serve; and the translators have not fultilled their awful threat, but have given us English that is quite unbarbarous even though it may at times be slightly heavy. The result is one of the most available text- books for use in colleges which our language now possesses It is needless to say that of the doctrines of the earher work the author has not left many un } +) changed. In particular original explana tion of so many sensations and judgments by ‘unconscious judgment” has of course been wholly abandoned, and mechanism and logi are no longer affirmed to be the same. Many of the results of Wundt's later thinking, as ex pressed at k ngth in his larger books, are here to be found in compendious and popular form and for a reader who wishes to make some ac tinguished Leipzig phi quaintance with the dist losophe r, these lectures are decidedly the most advantageous channel of approac! Archdeacon Farrar’s ‘Life of Christ as Represented in Art’ (Macmillan) is avowed ly written from the ecelesiastical and religious standpoint, bot the artistic. All the old talk about the symbolism and poetry of ar ehaic frescoes from the catacombs; all the gushing enthusiasm for the ‘‘ pure devotional feeling ~ shown in the round-faced, pursy- mouthed saints and angels of the grasping and irreligious Perugino, whom Michelangelo call ed a blockhead of art; all Mr. Ruskin’s elo quent and ingenious readings of deep meaning inte the most theatrical and brutal of Tintoret’s rat ee ae uae y ree

Page 18

at ee GN AS WB Hee SEB Fs ot-aeaeaeaehe” pe 384 The Nation. [Vol. 59. No 1534 scrawling sketches—are brought out again for our edification. All the pilers of words on words who ever darkened counsel on the sub- ject of art are quoted at length. An artist who never painted a cast shadow in his life is thought to have done something wonderful when!he paints figures which cast no shadows, ‘*being angels”; the obviously natural intro- duction of some carpenter's tools in a picture of the Annunciation is made into a mystical allegory; the most pompous and empty compo- sition of the pompous and empty Fra Bartolom- meo is extravagantly lauded, and the common- place Francia is exalted as a great master, while Rembrandt is denied any claim to bea “‘re- ligious painter.” Art, we are told, was simple and dignified in the fifteenth century because the people were reverent and faithful, and it decayed in the sixteenth not because it was ripe, but because the people had ceased to be- lieve. Why cannot these critics see that there is as much ‘‘ sadness” in Botticelli's Venuses as in his Madonnas, and that Perugino was a workman who turned out saints all of a pat- tern to meet the demand? But the interest in everything about art except art is immortal, and of the making of many books there is no end. —Under the name of ‘Le Musée Social,” a somewhat unique industrial institute has late- ly been founded in Paris, by a distinguished French economist and publicist, the Count de Chambrun, who has given for this purpose his fine old family mansion, No. 5 Rue Las-Cases, and an endowment of 200,000 francs. The three ‘“‘présidents d’honneur ” are MM. Jules Simon, Léon Say, and the Count de Chambrun; the active president, or chief of the faculty, being M. Jules Siegfried. According to the first article of its constitution, the object of the Count de Chambrun’s institute is to place freely at the service of the people—by means so varied that only political and religious dis- cussions are specifically excluded—a knowledge of “‘ institutions and social organizations which have for their aim and end the amelioration of the physical and moral condition of the arti- san class.” This new Sorbonne of Work, as it has been called, will offer to craftsmen of high or low degree technical instruction in certain arts, practical ‘‘ advice,” and the latest artis- tic and scientific data affecting their relations to their work or to society. It is proposed to establish workshops, sociological laboratories, a great technical library, museums, etc., and . by means of object-lessons, lectures, confer- ences, conventions, reports, prizes, and medals, tocreate a sort of sociological clearing-house, which may become a national centre of in- struction and of counsel to wage-earners, and a medium for spreading among them a fa- miliarity with sound economic social theories, and of successful industrial experiments, both at home and abroad. The social-economic ex- hibits (documents, models, photographs, de- signs in relief, etc.), which formed so striking a feature of the French display in Paris (1889) and in Chicago (1893), have been given as the nucleus of the Chambrun Museum; the French Government has, by special decree of Presi- dent Casimir-Perier, endorsed La Sociéte du Musée Social as ‘‘an establishment of public usefulness,” and has authorized it to report an- nually to the Minister of Commerce and Indus- try—which authorization goes far towards se- curing in the future a State grant. Although the institute will not open until January, 1895, and its attitude towards its clientéle, as ex- pressed in its constiution, is somewhat pa- tronizing, it seems to us entitled to tabulation as the latest attempt on the par't of scientific philanthropists to direct into safe and helpful channels the formidable power of the modern workman. —Some weeks ago M. Georges Docquois con- voked in the columns of the Paris Journal a ‘*Congrés des Podtes,” to each of whom was addressed the somewhat delicate question; ‘Quel est, selon vous, celui qui, dans la gloire ainsi que dans le respect des jeunes, va rem- placer Leconte de Lisle?’ The inquiry was taken up and carried further in the Plume of October 15 31. No less than one hundred and eighty-nine poets sent in their opinions. The frankest answer, and not the least critical (as regards the inquiry, at any rate), was that of M. Emile Bergerat, who, with a quiet smile, voted for himself. In the general result, Ver- laine came out at the head of the poll by a great majority. He received seventy-seven votes, and there was a great gap between him and José-Maria de Hérédia, who followed with thirty-eight. Then came in their order, Ste- phane Mallarmé (36), Sully-Prudhomme (32), Francois Coppée (26), J. Richepin (21), Léon Dierx (15), Catulle Mendés (14), Henry de Re- gnier (11), and Frédéric Mistral (9). Two names of Americans appear on the list; F. Vielé- Griffin (5, and Stuart Merrill (3). It will be seen that the question, as put, was some- what embarrassing. It suggests a comparison between two poets who stand apart in violent contrast with each other. The characteristic “note” of Leconte de Lisle’s verse, as of his life, was its faultless deportment. That is not the note of Verlaine. His verse, exquisitely musical, is not always faultless if scanned on thumbs and fingers; while his disordered, un- happy life excites other emotions than those of a cool respect. Nothing less than love and pity can the impression fill which his own dual nature and untoward circumstances, as well as vulgar scandal, have stamped upon his brow. And, besides, to many the word ‘‘remplacer,”’ for various and possibly opposite reasons, will seem ill-chosen. At any rate, such satisfaction as is proper may be felt at the prospect which is opened in French literature by the manifee- tation of such a multitude of writers who are, by their own admission, poets. One hundred and eighty-nine of them have been accused of poesy, and have been found reos confitentes! ROPES’S CIVIL WAR. The Story of the Civil War : A Concise Account of the War in the United States of America, between 1861 and 1865. By John Codman Ropes. Part I. G. P. Putnam’s Sons. 8vo, pp. xiv, 274. THE title of Mr. Ropes’s book does not seem to indicate its exact scope. It is not a military history which he has undertaken to write, nor yet a general history of the civil war. He disclaims any purpose to narrate or to consider political matters, yet, with the exception of the first battle of Bull Run, he does not give us more than the barest mention of the en- gagements and military movements of the first year of the great Rebellion. So far as this first volume goes, his intention seems to be to discuss the more important politico-mili- tary situations, together with the personal re- lations of the civil chiefs with their generals on both sides. It is necessary to try thus to measure the author’s aim and purpose, for the reader will otherwise be disappointed in the lack of descriptive detail. Mr. Ropes offers as a formula which may help to clear up the positions of the combat- ants in the great struggle, the statement that the South had universally adopted the theory that the United States was not one nation, but a collection of nations. Apart from the ques- tion of the unanimity of the Southern people in any theory of Union or secession before hostilities began, it will hardly do to say that the South had consciously adopted the doo- trine so formulated. Down to the very last, Southern men professed attachment to the whole country, and patriotism which meant a recognition of the whole country as their own. It would seem to be more accurate to say that they recognized a limited nationality. The world was already familiar with limited mon- archy, and there was no difficulty in recogniz- ing a federal nationality which, although limited by the alleged reserved rights of the federated States, was still in a proper sense a nationality which could draw out the patriotic devotion of a whole people and a true affection for fatherland. When this love was soured and this devotion dead, they were ready for the dissolution which they claimed as a re- served right to be used only in the last ex- tremity. This, which is really the common theory, seems also the more logical. It best accounts for all the facts. It leaves wholly open the question of moral right or wrong, and of the justifiable or unjustifiable conduct of their leaders. It seems to leave the difference between the two sections just where the com- mon sense of the people has been accustomed to put it. The Unionists believed this federal nationality to be indissoluble, the secessionists did not. The situation at Fort Sumter in March and April, 1861, is also subjected to a painstaking analysis which, in general, is sound and in- structive. Ona single point the author seems to be hardly just to Major Anderson. His in- structions were that he should limit himself to the defensive and by no means be the first to shed blood. It was already shown that rein- forcements could not be sent in without a col- lision, and Anderson regarded himself as con- demned to await an actual attack upon his fort. In these circumstances he wrote a pri- vate letter in which he said his ‘policy ” (as he felt ‘‘secure for the present in his strong- hold”) was to preserve the peace ‘“‘in the hope of avoiding bloodshed.” Commenting on this, the author says it lays Major Anderson open to severe censure, because a military man has no right to have a “ policy,” which is a func- tion of Government. This strains the mean- ing of words beyond what is reasonable. Policy means any selected line of conduct, and it seems plain that Anderson regarded this as entirely consistent with his orders. No man in the world was less likely to ignore his orders in choosing the line or “policy” he should follow in loyal subordination to his su- periors. In discussing the conduct of Mr. Lincoln, it is unpleasantly evident that the author is pre- disposed to depreciate him. Criticising the first call for troops, which recited the lawful occasion for such a call in formal statutory language, Mr. Ropes says that it ‘‘is really lu- dicrous in its minimizing the facts of the situa- tion.” It certainly appeared ludicrous to no- body in April, 1861, and its restrained and technical reference to the Rebellion as obstruct- ing the execution of the laws by combinations too powerful to be suppressed by ordinary means, was in accordance not only with good traditional form, but with the public feeling which shrank from official declaration that there was civil war in the land. The delibe- rate understatement of the crisis made the de- claration all the more full of solemn meaning. A SS ORR ve IAS

Page 19

SNA GEN a Oh NE Sl aR Uh Sey Nov. 22, 1894] The Nat ion. In the chapter on ‘‘The Opposing Parties” the statement of the relative military aptitude of Northern and Southern men cannot be ac- cepted as sound. It may be doubted if any nation on earth shows a more even range of characteristics than the United States. If it be admitted that in the South there was a little more quick impulsiveness of temperament, and in the North a little more persistent de- termination of will, we shall have gone quite as far as facts will warrant. By common con- sent of all witnesses, including the foreign officers sent specially to report upon our ar- mies, no better or braver material for soldiers was ever seen. The enthusiasm of the first en- listment was every whit as intense, as high, as ‘* poetic,” north of Mason and Dixon's line as south of it. Northern young men took as kindly to camp life as the Southern youth. There was much in army experience that was “weary” and ‘‘distesteful” to both, but it is wide of the mark to say that the taste for and power to excel in military life was not exhi bited in one section as much as in the other. A like impulse to draw contrasts has misled the author in speaking of the selection of mi- litary leaders. Any man acquainted with the army could have predicted that the two John- stons, Lee, Beauregard, Bragg, and G. W. Smith would have been the first called to im- portant command in the South. The same test of accepted reputation made it certain that Scott would call Halleck, McClellan, McDow- ell, Meigs, and Anderson to his assistance. If Mr. Davis had a personal acquaintance with army men which enabled him to make the selection himself, Mr. Lincoln was at no disad- vantage in selecting upon the suggestion of Winfield Scott. The attempted contrast in this respect will not bear inspection. If Mr. Lincoln called men from civil life to be general officers, so did Mr. Davis ; and what more striking instance was there than the ap- pointment by the latter of Bishop Polk to bea major-general? Neither of them was gifted with prophecy, and therefore neither of them could guarantee the success of their appointees in military commands far larger and more re- sponsible than any man on the western conti- nent had ever held. There were failures on both sides among men of whom everything was expected, and there were great military talents developed where they were not looked for. In what war was it ever otherwise ? Mr. Ropes is, however, very emphatic in his assertion that, with an organized, though small, regular army, ‘‘there was no sort of need of giving to any untried civilian a rank so high that of itself it constituted a constant tempta- tion to intrust him with an important com- mand.” This is a large subject, and its full discussion would need a book as large as the one before us. There were weighty political reasons, which cannot be ignored, for includ- ing in the military organization, in such a great popular uprising, the natural leaders of the people. But asa purely military question it is not so one-sided as our author contends. American history does not exhibit the citizen soldier at a disadvantage. The capture of Louisburg by New England militia under Pep- perell, a civilian, was a capture from regulars. The officers of the Revolutionary war were civilians pitted against regulars. The war of 1812 ended with three pre‘minent reputations, Andrew Jackson, Jacob Brown, and Winfield Scott—the first two militia generals, and all appointed from civil life. If in our civil war Banks and Baker left Congress to fight, so in the English civil war did Cromwell and Hamp- den leave Parliament. The French Revolution was still more striking. There was a standing army of old ‘‘regulars” as well as the ardent young volunteers, and they were opposed to the regular organizations of all Europe. Mili- tary talent sprang fromevery calling and rank, and held its own against the world. Lawyers, doctors, painters, farmers, private soldiers, and stable-boys became generals, and, after a little, marshals of France. All this does not prove that there is no use in military educa- tion, but it should make reasonable men very cautious in asserting that the doors of a par- ticular school open the only way to it. But the proportions of our war were so vast that when every regular officer who remained true to his colors was counted, we had only a small fraction of the number required to com- mand regiments, brigades, and divisions. Many of these were most needed in the staff departments, many lacked the zeal in the cause which the country imperatively demanded, some shrank from responsibility and did not seek volunteer commands when the way was opened to them. Whoever will take the Army Register of 1860-'61, and count the names, will see that it is mere nonsense to talk of organiz- ing anarmy of nearly half a million with only these for the higher offices. The popular de mand accorded with sound policy in giving the army the character of a levée en masse, and letting the shaking together of all classes of men bring to the top those who were fit for their work. Whoever will analyze the rosters of 1864-5 will see that the ‘‘ volunteers” did not suffer by the competition. Another fact to which Mr. Ropes does not give due weight is, that, under existing laws in 1861, the Governors of States sent their con- tingents to the field, under the first call, com pletely organized as brigades and divisions This took the general ofticers of the State mili tia, who had at least more idea of organiza- tion and tactics than most of the people Many of these were continued in the service, the Presidential appointment only confirming the State commission. In this way both But- ler and Banks took the field with Massachu- setts troops by appointment from Gov. An drew, and it is at least gratuitous to sar their employment proved that ‘the President showed but little judgment in his appoint- ments to high command.” Both were men of superior ability, both had led brigades of well- drilled troops in the evolutions of a time of peace, and that was more than could be said at that time of any man who was then or thereafter made a major-general in the regu- lararmy. Not one had ever handled so large a body of troops. What so reasonable, then, as to try them? In 1812 no one could tell in advance that Gen. Hull would weakly sur- render at Detroit, or Brown show courage and ability at Sackett’s Harbor; and what hap pened did not prove that President Madison had “little judgment " in appointing Hull or great sagacity in appointing Brown. Then, a Massachusetts critic should be fair to Banks and Butler. The former had an honorable re- cord in command of a division and a corps, and showed himself a competent officer in his grade. The latter had unquestioned ability in administrative positions in which other officers of his grade were often employed. If neither succeeded in comma nd of an army in the field, what shall we say of the long list with Halleck at the head * The simple truth is, that in 1561 there was no way of telling whether a man was fit to be a general officer but by trying; and, as Sber- man said, those were lucky who didn't get tried too soon. McClellan, in his memoirs, 385 also says it would have been better for him if he bad not bad so prominent a command for another year or two. Let us recollect that this was before the days of army schools more advanced than West Point; when we had no- thing resembling the education which Moltke was drilling into the Prussian army; when there never had been in the regular army a brigade or division camp for evolutions of the line or field manceuvre. The field officers of the regular regiments were nearly all of them too old for active service, and the list of cap tains was that from which the men were chosen who became best known in the civil war. They had gone to West Point, as Grant said, knowing only the ‘three R's, reading, ‘riting, and ‘rithmetic.” They spent four years there in study different from that of other schools in scarce anything but a little engi neering of fortifications. They had personal drill in the companies of the cadet battalion, and in company and regimental tactics. With this they graduated, and, considering the low requirements for entrance, more would have been mere “cram.” The duties of our little company posts on the frontier would increase familiarity with post routine and administra tion, but what was there in this to warrant the assumption that these were the only men to be tried as general officers’ It is notorious that very few had built upon the beginning made in the Academy, or had the opportunity if they had the will to continue industrious study. It was an individual question as to each, what progress he had made, what qualities he had developed, and what he was competent for When these things are candidly weighed, it does not appear so clear that there was a class of * professional solders" who, by virtue of the label, were exclusively fit for command We must conclude, therefore, that the distri- bution of military offices which was then made was not an error of Mr. Lincoln; it was only the adoption ef a method which may be called usual in this country, and which would be repeated if we were again forced to enlarge our army suddenly to ten or twenty times its regular strength. Mr. Ropes regards the Confederate organt- zation with the grades of general and lieuten- ant-general as better than ours. It may well be doubted. Our system provided that when a general officer was specially assigned by the President to a corps or department, he was thereby given precedence over other officers of similar grade not so assigned. It was asif he were their senior. Mr. Ropes is mistaken in saying that this caused ‘loss of esprit de corps andthe general detriment of the service.” Mc- Clellan, Halleck, Buell, Rosecrans, Sherman, Thomas, Schofield, McPherson, bad no other rank but major-general, and no one under them ever questioned their power as commander. It Was as complete and obedience was as hearty as to any Confederate ‘‘ general.”” The system had the very great advantage, that men might be shifted from one duty to another without losing their commissions. Thus, Sherman com- manded a department in 1861; next he went back to a division, later he was promoted to a corps, and reached a department again only at the close of 1863. Later ip the war the Con- federates themselves mooted the question of making their upper grades temporary, in view of the need for greater scope in trying promis- ing men. In the chapter on ‘Plans and Preparations in the West,” after mentioning Gen. Thomas's brilliant little victory at Mill Springs, in January, 1%62, the author severely criticises Mr. Lincoln by saying that ‘‘ for some reason, . idee we ne ah 1 PR na BLN Ny am ae Det zemtreon none, — “ ee Secnes by Steno ie rao ae

Page 20

2 aie ae, ager ae ee SEs ho RA PAR MEAIRLAM erecta ee oe eRe wet ey es Sahat cord 386 The Nation. not capable, in our judgmeut, of any satisfac- tory explanation, Gen. Thomas's name was not even mentioned in the order” issued by the President which congratulated the troops and the country on the event. The order itself gave so satisfactory a reason that one is sur- prised at the criticism. The President’s lan- guage was, ‘“‘he returns thanks to the gallant officers and soldiers who won that victory, and, when official reports have been received, the military skill and personal valor displayed in the battle will be acknowledged and rewarded in a fitting manner.” The country was aching and longing for some gleam of encouragement, and the President hastened to give it on the first despatches. Reference to the journals of the time would show that there were claims that the chief merit belonged to Gen. Schoepf, who had been in command and was reinforced by Thomas, Under such circumstances the President prudently refrained from awarding the honors till official reports were received. Then, he did not forget to give Thomas promo- tion, though the great events of Fort Donelson and Shilob had intervened to make Mill Springs look very small. Mr, Ropes—by a slip, no doubt—conveys the idea that Thomas was not promoted; and one who places Thomas’s coim- mander, Gen. Buell, so high as he does, surely cannot claim that the subordinate should have been promoted over the head of his chief, for executing that chief's orders ! Both were only brigadiers, and the delay of a few weeks in the important campaign then opening was only enough to do justice to Buell and Thomas at once. A chapter is also devoted to the relations of Mr. Lincoln with Gen. McClellan, and here the same readiness to find the President weak and in the wrong confronts us. This is not for the purpose of praising McClellan, for, if we were to bring together the marks of in- competence attributed to him, nothing would be left but the organizing abilities which be- long to an adjutant and inspector-general. When we find, therefore, the President's order for a general movement on the 22d of Febru- ary called ‘‘a curious specimen of puerile im- patience,” we conclude that either we or the author know very little about Mr. Lincoln. * Puerile impatience” is the very last defect of character which we should dream of imput- ing tohim. Through along autumn of beau- tiful weather, an army of fifty thousand Con- federates besieged a hundred and fifty thou- sand equally brave, better drilled, better equipped, better organized troops under Mc- Clellan. Navigation on the Potomac was stopped, as was railway communication with the West. Winter came and McClellan would not give to the commander-in-chief a plan or a definite promise of movement. His own memoirs show that he was indulging in gross- ly insubordinate and contemptuous conduct towards the President. [t was nothing but an almost supernatural patience, in view of the perils of changing commanders at such a time, that accounts for the continuance of such a state of things. It is the province of the exe. cutive of every government known among men to assign to an army its field of opera- tions and to command instant, continuous, and vigorous activity till it beats the enemy or is beaten. The ultimate reasons of war are all political, and political reasons for action in October or January may be cogent and con- clusive. It is for the executive to judge; it is for the geneial to use his talent, and skill, and courage, if he have any, to make such actiona success. It is not for him, to say, We will postpone this war till next year! Mr, Lin- coln’s order was issued only when the patience of Job was exhausted. So, of the President’s order in March, we are told that if Mr. Lincoln ** had been equal to his position as commander-in-chief, he would have issued no such document.” The answer is, that the extraordinary and almost incredi- ble obstacles to action made the order a ne- cessity. The only alternative was to make a change of commanders. Mr. Lincoln was al- ways a more favorable judge of McClellan’s ability than the majority of the public men of the nation. He saw the lack of initiative, courage and enterprise in the general, and hoped that, by assuming himself the responsi- bility for-immediate action, he would make the other qualities useful to the country. But when Mr. Ropes, after stating clearly the triple superiority of McClellan’s forces over the enemy, argues that because he believ- ed the enemy to be twice as strong as the Po- tomac army, he cannot be blamed for acting as if the ‘‘ monstrously exaggerated stories” were true, he seems to get quite beyond any legitimate field for debate. In the history of war there have been not infrequent instances of a bold man making two or three surrender to him by sheer audacity and pretence, but it may be doubted if it was ever before heard of that the ‘‘conduct” of the dupes was exonerat- ed while their ‘‘sagacity’’ was mildly found lacking, This novel departure will hardly be taken seriously. It is matter for deep and sincere regret that so earnest a student of milita*y history as Mr. Ropes should have adopied 4 low estimate of Mr. Lincoln in everything, apparently, but political sagavity. The common sense of the world has put him in the list of the very few who rank as greatest, and this judgment is not contradicted by the conclusions of students who are at once thorough and sympathetic. Thorough criticism is justifying his judgments of the military problems which he had studied. His advice to make the Confederate army the objective—all the more because it was near Washington, where our troops, as he said, could ** board at home ”—was as sound strategy as it was good wit. His warning that ‘‘ going down the bay in search of a field” would only change the place without diminishing obstacles to be overcome, was pure sagacity applied to the situation, which is a prime element of gen- eralship. His judgment in January, 1862, that “if something was not done soon, the bottom would be out of the whole affair,” was sound statesmanship in homely form. It is danger- ous to hurtle against his reputation in any field. CHARLES LORING BRACE. The Life of Charles Loring Brace. Chiefly told in his own Letters. Edited by his Daughter. Charles Scribner’s Sons. 184. It is over-modest of Miss Brace to call her- self the editor simply of her father’s life. The story, it is true, is chiefly told by his own let- ters, but he was not a voluminous correspond- ent; his life was too busy for much letter- writing. The narrative would therefore have been defective were the letters not connected by a stream of commentary and exposition of re- markable clearness and simplicity. It is very rare, in our experience, to meet with a bio- graphy in which the sense of proportion on the part of the biographer has been so steadily maintained, in which there is so little surplus- age and padding. In fact, there is hardly a letter or line too much, One or two letters might well have been omitted, but on the whole [Vol. 59, No. 1534 it is not often that a-daughter working over the life of a distinguished and much honored father has been so successful in keeping up the literary standard, and making the work agree- able reading as well as a faithful record. Mr. Brace’s life may almost be said to be a history of philanthropic effort in the United States. He stepped into the field just as the great anti-slavery struggle which had for thir- ty years absorbed all the humanitarian thought and energy of the country, was drawing to a close. What he says in one of his later letters that he had accomplished, was what he set himself to do thirty-five years before—namely, the establishment as principles of the ‘‘absolute necessity of treating each youthful criminal or outcast as an individual and not one of a crowd; the immense superiority of the bome or family over any institution in reforma- tory and educational influence; the prevention of crime and pauperism by early efforts with children, and the vital importance of breaking up inherited pauperism by putting almshouse ch ldren in separate homes; and, most of all, the immense advantage of ‘placing out’ neg- lected and orphan children in farmers’ fami- hes.” The success which attended his labor, we think we may safely say, surpassed everything which has been attempted in the philanthropic world since Howard made his attack on the old prisons. Thesociety which he built up in New York has not only been the means of transferring tens of thousands of boys from street pauperism and profligacy to comforta- ble homes and lives of usefulness in the West, but bas through schools and through lodging- houses done an immense work of civilization among the youthful poor of both sexes in this city. Moreover, his system has been widely copied, not only in other States in the Union, but in every country in Europe in which or- ganized efforts are made for the rescue of youthful criminals and outcasts. It is not every country which has our ‘‘ West ” for the reception of the waifs and strays of the great cities; but the ‘‘ Newsboys’ Lodging-house ” and the ‘ Girls’ Lodging-house” have furnish- ed to a great many cities in the Old World both an inspiration anda model, All this work, too, begun in 1853, and continued for thirty-five years, was carried on, as we said at the time of his death, ‘with clear insight, perfect sanity of judgment, supreme diligence, and indomitable patience.” When we come to loek at the man behind the work, the thing which has most struck us, in turning over the pages of this Life, is the perfect accuracy of his moral judgments from early youth down to hisdeath. Not the small- est error or aberration ever shows itself in passing on the great movements which he wit- nessed. Indeed, his personal history is a sort of chronicle of the intellectual and moral changes which had come over the world in his day. There was nothing about him more remarkable than his keen intellectual cu- riosity, which seemed well-nigh insatiable. He was bred in the old New England atmosphere of sixty years ago, when orthodox religion, the relation of *‘ the sinner” to God, was the main concern of all thinking people, to whom the abolitionists were profane ‘‘ranters.” But in 1848 hearing Wendell Phillips set his mind at work about slavery, and on this subject he ever afterwards thought right. He ‘*joined the church” in New Haven, as was the custom of the time, but very soon plunged into the speculations about the origin and na- ture of Christianity which have since effected such profound changes, if not in the formal creeds, in the spiritual outlook, of all the churches. For the Fugitive Slave Law he at LPialac at ERI OPT

Page 21

Lach ES oS REC ERR SOT perescrra eter Nov. 22, 1894] The Nation. once conceived an abhorrence which was not shared by his elders at the time, and which he had to defend in a letter to hisfather. Had he had a gift of speech proportionate to his extra- ordinary energy and mental activity, he would have set the country on flre regarding most of the questions of theday. But he was too specu- lative, too candid—one might say—for a popu- lar orator. He had not sufficient positiveness and emphasis of expression to drive home the spoken word. On this point he somewhat de- ceived himself. When the Children’s Aid scheme first took possession of him, he recoiled a little from giving himself up to the work of philanthropy, in the belief that his true function was that of a teacher or preacher, and it was probably this feeling which led to his excursions into the regions of science and history which pro- duced his book on ethnology, the ‘Gesta Christi,’ and the ‘Unknown God.’ His books of travel, owing to his unfailing good hu- mor, his intense optimism, his great energy, his wonderful enjoyment of life, and kindly, sympathetic ways with all classes and condi tions of men, were always interesting and in structive. He went toGermany and lived there for a winter or two, studying the language in the old days when a man could earn a comfort- able subsistence by writing letters about every- day life to the religious weeklies, and when Europe was to most Americans almost a terra incognita. On this occasion he was imprisoned in Hungary by tbe Austrians as a dangerous propagandist, which did him the great service of making him widely known in America. The true spirit of the man came out at this period, too, by the emphatic declaration to a friend who was trying to get him correspondence with the American papers: ‘*l would rather write for the Tribune for five dollars than for the Courier for ten, and won't I have a noble audience, too!’ He was then only twenty-five years old, but ‘‘ bis good Jance thrusted sure.” His letters at this period give this amusing glimpse of the youth of the illustrious professor who now presides over the Englishdepartment at Harvard: ‘' These ideas have been rather forced on me by seeing a good deal lately of a wonderfully witty fellow from Harvard Col- lege, whois studying for a professorship in Got- tingen, and whoassimilates perfectly wherever he is, swears and jokes now in German, wears boots up to his thigh, and dances German stu- dent hornpipes, drinks punch, and sings Ger- man songs to perfection. This fellow, whose name is Child, is visiting two friends of mine.’ ‘*Fugit Euro citius tempus edax rerum,” the professor will probably say on seeing this little reminiscence of long ago. Mr. Brace’s most valuable contributions to contempceranecus literature were undoubtedly his ‘ Dangerous Classes of New York,’ and his society reports. These have a value whichcan- not wear out. His ‘Gesta Christi,’ which is an extremely interesting collection of facts, has the misfortune-to be an addition to the great mass of Christian apologetics, to which the world, rightly or wrongly, pays less and less at tention every year. It has the defect of trying to separate Christianity from the Church, and win it credit by surrendering the Chureb to the enemy. The view which is gaining ground is that all religions, Christianity as well as others, depend for their character on the civili zation of the people who profess them. Chris- tianity during the greater part of its history has been the faith of semi-barbarians, and therefore a cruel, butchering, burning creed. To-day for a similar reason it is humane, | tolerant, and charitable. Nothing but pro- i digious twisting and turning will deliver it from responsibility for the Catholic Church, or give it all the credit for the handful of profes- sors who, even in dark times, have stood for the grace, mercy, and peace of the Founder. It is impossible iu the limits of a brief notice like this to give an adequate idea of the charm of Mr. Brace’s personality, The energy and hopefulness which carried him to success in his philanthropic work played an equally large part in his intercourse with his friends. He had in an eminent degree what the Boston wit called a ‘‘talent for friendship.” His friends were never out of his mind. Their fame and fortune were as dear to him as his own. His interest as to their state of mind touching all the great questions of the time never flagged: and this talent, no less than his great labor in his own field, brought him into cordial rela tions with most of the leading minds of the day, both here andin England. We doubt if a happier man ever lived until the cloud of the great tragedy which always closes even the most successful career, overtook him. He warmed both hands at the fire of life. He was eminently successful in his calling, was much appreciated by his contemporaries, and met the end with a fortitude and serenity which all who knew him expected BOOKS FOR CHILDREN ‘DECATUR AND SOMERS,’ by Miss M. Elliot Sea well (Appletons), is a pleasant story for the young, narrating two of the most touching and heroic passages in the history of our navy, the destruction of the Philadelphia off Tripoli, and the explosion of the /ntrepid. The authoress has not, however, told it in a better way than Maclay tells it in his recent history of the navy, and has not, we think, equalled in pathos o1 interest her own story of ‘ Little Jarvis” Her picture of naval life contains many errors and anachronisms. At the very commencement shi calls and relieves the watch on a frigate whil ‘“‘allhands” are getting the ship underway; her brigs are fitted with bridges, her ships ‘*wear” instead of ‘‘carry™ colors, and her quartermasters and coxswains are not only mixed up in their duties but in their ships Clipper ships did not exist at the beginning of the present century to carry news to Gibral tar, and a ‘“‘soldier’s wind” (p. 34) does not en able a ship to go in any direction she wishes certainly not in the direction from which the wind blows. Historically the incidents are true, though the traditions of the service are that Stewart, Decatur, and Somers were inti mate alike with each other, and that the /n- trepid grounded upon a rock before she was blown up. Miss Seawell will not have written in vain, however, if she make known to the young generation of the present day exploits of the American navy, one of which was cha- racterized by Nelson as “the most bold and daring act of the age.” The last volume of Col. Knox's series, en- titled ‘The Boy Travellers in the Levant Harpers), takes his young tourtsts along the soutbern coast of the Mediterranean to Car thage, and thence to Greece, the Troad, Con- stantipople, Smyrna, and Cyprus, successive y. It provides plenty of information for boys and girls who have a sound digestion for facts and dates and are not too fond of plumcake; it is also well supported in the mat- ter of illustrations by the resources of the Harpers’ establishment. The careft person will not find bimself entirely absolved 1 voung from reviewing Col. Knox's statements; he must not imagine that the escort of a squad of B3S7 soldiers is usually needed in visiting Mara- thon; nor must he invest in Greek bonds on Frank's statement that ‘they are generally well quoted on “change”; nor should he adopt his spelling of Dionysius for the god Dionysus, nor sccept as final his opinion that ‘* a Greek play was a very solemn affair. which, if put on the New York stage and advertised as much as you please, would not pay expenses He may correct this impression by reading Prof. Church's ‘Stories from the Greek Come dians,’ or by consulting some Frenchman who bas heard Mounet-Sully’s Gedipys. We note this sentence as a sample of an occasional dry ness and lack of sympathetic imagination in a book which is sensibly and pleasantly written, but sometimes savers rather strongly of the chide t \ wmplete antidote for Frank's matter-of fact omniscience may be found in * The Story ’ of Alexander, by Robert Steele (Macmillan This bi-tory is delightfullw destitute of fact, and presents only the marvellous and fancifu legends of the Middl \ves, in which Alex ander iS made a son Anectanpabus, King of Egypt hquers Su Ralaan vr is well as Gog and Magog, and visits Je a4 where he is humbly mr ved bw ¢ bishop and the mnavor, attired in worgeous silks from Tartary Fortunately, Bucephalus is retained intact, ind prances throagh the story with all his an cient tascinations The illustrations and the book are very dainty and charn A book full of lively incidents agreeably told s Mrs. ©. V. Jamison’s * Toinette’s Philip’ The Century Co Improbabilities in the plot are plenty, but the children will pass them bv ghtiv., and | free to enjev the pleasant 1 ture of New Orleans life, the tou vf rathe transparent mystery, and, above all, the satis factory ending, where evervbody is made hay py and even the disagreeable people become amiabl ‘The Land of Pluck’ is the apt name which Mrs. Mary en to Holland apd tl! and Duteh his- tory w ea in Sf. N ms mak t st part of thel k so entitled They are written inthe bright. en stvle which Mrs. Dodge always mmands, and are well fitted to rouse an in terest in the manners and history of this admi peopie. In the second part of the book ire gathered a numberof short stories of all sorte a haps th most amusing of these is r \ Garret Adventure.” in which some good, iren th rh? they bad their mo- ther’s permission to make a skating-pond by freezing water on the carret floor. Naturally, the pond refused to ‘stay put * long enough to free and its appearance below stairs sur prised no one more than the mother. ‘The Brownies Around the World’ (‘The Century Co.) isthe title of Mr. Cox's latest ad- lition to the Brownie literature. The ever welcome little beings swarm as usual over the pages, getting themselves into and out of new scrapes, and entertaining their admirers with new antics, while they journey from Arabia to the arctic regions and around the earth’s cir umference to view the world and its wonders, and comment upon them for the edification of com! children To take in at one sitting a whole bookful of Oliver Herford’s ‘Artful Anticks’ (The Cen- tury Co.) would be too much like making a meal out of the caster; but as condiments they are agreeable. It isa satisfaction to find such ld friends as ** The Audacious Kitten,” and ‘* The Artful Ant,” with a host of other clever verses and pictures, preserved in this volume A OC a Sn Rt GPR odie pir dla, 126 0 08 be in Sat «a wap aoe. vs ta heat Pag ey eat Satie Saitama ater masa Si nase ms ey

Page 22

aerate 388 The Nation. [Vol. 59, No. 1534 to please many who would never have found them in the back numbers of St. Nicholas. Two books by Miss A. G. Plympton, ‘ Rags and Velvet Gowns,’ and ‘Penelope Prig’ (Roberts Bros.), are so full of a sort of senti- mental socialism that, in spite of lively flashes of imagination and humor, they are not really good reading for children. Nothing is more likely to make disgusting little prigs than giving children the notion that their simple acts of kindness, which they ought to doasa matter of course, are noble and admirable deeds calling for general applause; or that they will be likely to reform society from the bottom by, for instance, giving away their old toys, or inviting street children to their Thanksgiving dinner. In wholesome contrast are Susan Coolidge’s ‘Not Quite Eighteen’ bright stories (Roberts Bros.). In this oddly named book it is the everyday duties and homely virtues of which the young reader is reminded; and so plea- santly and naturally withal, that the most wary avoider of morals will not be inclined to revolt. The country minister’s daughter who feels restless at home and goes away in search of her mission, is not exactly a new character in fiction, and this is perhaps hinted in the title of ‘Another Girl’s Experience,’ by Leigh Web- ster (Roberts Bros.). This girl, at any rate, finds herself younger than she had supposed when out of reach of her mother’s advice, and finally goes home well content to discover her real mission in brightening her father’s and mother’s hard life, and in helping along her numerous brothers and sisters. Five or six unpretentious tales about her country neighbors, each suggested by some plant brought from one of their gardens, are the ‘ Quiet Stories from an Old Woman’s Gar- den,’ by Alison McLean (F. Warne & Co.). Quiet they are, indeed almost soporific, each with its little morality; but possibly useful for reading aloud where the only object is to make conversation needless, as in those working- parties whose want of short and unexciting stories prompted their writing. That droll and individual designer Mr. P. 8. Newell seemed to us last year to have reached the bounds of his ingenuity in his reversible plates called ‘Topsy-Turvys’ (The Century Co.). The second volume, just issued, proves that we were mistaken, as any one might be who had not gone through a course of stand- ing upon his head. The pew series is rather more clever and audacious, and less transpa- rent, than the first. RECENT ENGLISH POETRY. Ir is now nearly a hundred years since Can- ning’s ‘ Anti-Jacobin’ predicted, as did Heine fifty years later, a transfer to England of what the latter called *‘ the monkey’s skin,” or, in other words, of the levity of the French metro- polis : “O Nurse of Crimes and Fashions ! ee in vain Our colder servile spirits would atta’ How do we ape thee, France! but blundering still Disgrace the pattern by our want of sk The borrow’d step an awkward gait rev 18 As clumsy C—rtn—y mars the verse he steals.” It becomes more and more impossible to keep the run of recent English poetry without re- cognizing the double truth of Canning’s analy- sis and Heine’s prediction. Mr. Hamerton tells us that there is still a perceptible differ- ence between the moral atmosphere of Lon- don and that of Paris; but the transplanted war against ‘‘ the bourgeois virtues” still goes on. The ‘‘Crimes and Fashions” are still borrowed and still spoiled by a clumsiness in the imitation. It will pot be counted as an offence, perhaps, by the readers of Mr. Arthur Clarke Kennedy’s * Erotica’ (London: Gay & Bird) that the author stoops to actual doubles ententes of extreme indecency, but it may be au objection that they have not the French grace and are too much in the C—rtn—y style. The same impression is made when Mr. Percy Pinkerton, in ‘ Adriatica’ (Gay & Bird), cele- brates his wayside amours as frankly, though not as entertainingly, as the hero of a Pigault- Lebrun novel. Mrs. Louise Chandler Moulton has edited, with a preliminary sketch, extracts from the poems of Arthur O'Shaughnessy (Chicago: Stone & Kimball). This young poet, who died in 1881, has been both fortunate and unfortunate in his biographer—fortunate, because of her loyal devotion and artistic ‘sympathy; unfor- tunate, because she is wont to pitch her praise ona key of appreciation which the wares she exhibits do not always quite justify. To be told again and again that the poems are ‘‘di- vinely lovely ” (p. 28), and ‘‘ very lovely” (p. 37), and ‘‘so noble” (p. 37), awakens an expec- tation which is here not quite fulfilled; a little understatement is sometimes safer. Mrs. Moul- ton undoubtedly quotes some remarkable pas- sages, as when she gives us this (p. 40): “The long-hushed eve Glowed purple, and the awed soul of the thunder Lay shud ering in the distance, and the heave Of great unsolaced seas over and under The tremulous earth was heard with them to grieve.” That phrase ‘‘great unsolaced seas’ is Keats- like, yet no finer than single phrases that could easily be culled from transient poets now al- most forgotten, like Alexander Smith and Philip James Bailey. It must be owned that, with much of sweet and honied cadence, the ba- sis of O’Shaughnessy’s strains is repellent, even as he is seen here at his best; it lies among tombs and wehrwolves and fountains of tears. He was really one of the first of the English dé- cadent rhymers. He began to publish in 1870, and his biographer assures us that ‘“‘he was half a Frenchman in his love for and mastery of the French language; and many of his clos- est affiliations were with the younger school of French poets.” This hardly needed to be told us; and ‘this sympathy with the lawless lives of these evil phantoms’’—the men changed to wolves—leaves in the healthy mind the same sense of aversion produced annually hy so many repulsive pictures in the French Salon. With all the care and felicity of these selec- tions, and the external taste and grace of the little volume, we cannot predict for it a place very near to any human heart. It is something, perhaps, if Mr. Richard Le Gallienne, who, amid affectations of his own, has yet protested ere now against that prevail- ing Gallomania with which his name would im- ply some sympathies, should thus frankly link London and Paris together, for purposes of criticism: “ Paris and London, World Flowers twain Wherewith the World Tree blooms again Since Time hath gathered Babylon And withered Rome still withers on. “Sidon and Tyre were such as ye, How bright they shone upon the tree! But Time hath gathered, both are gone, And no man sails to Babylon. “ Ah, London! London! our delight, For thee, too. the eternal night, And Circe Paris hath no charm To stay Time’s unrelenting arm.” ‘This is from ‘ The Second Book of the Rhym- ers’ Club’ (London: Mathews & Lane)—a book by a dozen or more minor poets, mostly Welsh or Irish, and giving a good view of the range of thought and art among a circle of the Lon- don men. On the whole, the exhibit is pro- mising and indicates a little reaction against the French imitation; Mr. W. B. Yeats tak- ing easily the lead in the group, by reason of his marvellous Celtic grasp upon the night- side of mysteries and what he himself calls “The Folk of the Air.” Yet no poem by him in this little volume is so remarkable or haunt- ing as his former drama, ‘‘ The Countess Kath- leen,” or as his little detached and slender volume of Irish legend, ‘The Land of Heart's Desire’ (Chicago: Stone & Kimball), which surpasses all the rest. Although disfigured and blighted in the publishing by one of Mr. Beardsley’s ugliest and most meaningless fron- tispieces, the poem itself is as rare and unique as a witch-hazel blossom; it is of the air airy; a proof that pure fantasy will not perish out of the world while the Celtic races survive. And the manly purity of these poems—the utter freedom from the Gallic smirch—is refreshing when compared with the sickly and jaunty sensualism of Mr. Arthur Symons, who repre- sents the low-water mark of the ‘‘Rhymers’ Club.” : Another illustration of this fine Irish-Eng- lish quality is in the ‘ Cuckoo Songs’ (London: Mathews & Lane) of Katharine (Tynan) Hink- son, known in her maiden days as editor of an exquisite volume of ‘Irish Love Songs,’ full of what she herself christened as a ‘‘ strange love- ly flavor, as of wild bees’ honey.” She contri- buted one or two songs only to that volume, but this later book is full of them ; and there is one called ‘‘ Ivy of Ireland ” (p.81), in memo- ry of Charles Stewart Parnell, so noble and so beautiful as to make the stranger wonder if he who is so reverenced was really the faithless friend and shabby lover that he seemed to us to be. “ Like Cashel or like Muckross, famed in story, Your name shall arch the sky —— the sunset and the sunrise glory mournful and so high. “ All your sad splendor shall the ivy cover Wi h dew and raindrops wet, And ever greener as the years go over, Closer and greener yet.” Another member of the Rhymers’ Club is Mr. Ernest Rhys, well known as an editor, and still remembered in America for a visit he once paid us. It is mistakenly called ‘A Lon- don Rose, and Other Rhymes’ (London: Mathews & Lane)—mistakenly, for the merit of the book lies chiefly in that which is not of London. ‘‘ Welsh Rhymes and Ballads” form the best part of the book ; and this ‘‘ Autobio- graphy” is at least quotable and portable (p. 97): AN AUTOBIOGRAPHY. “Wales England wed; so I was bred. ’Twas merry London gave me breath. I dreamt of love, and fame: I strove. But Ireland taught me love was best: And Irish eyes, and London cries, and streams of Wales may tell the rest. What more than these I asked of Life, I am content to have from Death.” ‘Sagas and Songs of the Norsemen,’ by Al- bany F. Major (London: Nutt), is a rather dis- appointing book. It is a kind of first fruits, we take it, of the ‘* Viking Club,” of which its author is secretary. Every page of this vol- ume shows wealth of material rather feebly used. Charlies Mackay is or was but a third- rate poet, and yet there is in his ‘‘ Sea-King’s Burial,” published fifty years ago, more of Norse vigor and salt sea-foam than in all these more languid attempts; for Mr. Major, even in choosing precisely the same theme in his ‘Burial of the Sea-King” (p. 31), selects a long-drawn measure suited for a philosophical poem rather than a deed of ‘‘derring-do.” Strange to say, Mr. Major is strongest when he leaves his immediate theme and adds a few English ballads; and the closing ‘Fight at Pa Res hp hESC

Page 23

Nov. 22, 1894] The Nation. 38% Senlac,” though too long, is really the best thing in the book. Among recent London translations of poetry : the first place belongs historically to Dr. James Atkinson’s rendering from the Persian of Ni- zami’s *‘ Loves of Laili and Majnin (London: Nutt); for it was first printed nearly sixty years ago in one of those stately volumes of the Oriental Translation Fund which so long ; charmed ingenuous youth with their motto, *¢ Ex Oriente Lux.” The translation itself, now reédited by the Rev. J. A. Atkinson, belongs to that period when readers still enjoyed Hoole’s ‘ Tasso’ and Mickle’s ‘ Lusiad,’ and were not easily surfeited with monotony in heroic couplets. That period has perhaps passed by. Another book of translations is more inte- resting from the autobiographical preface than from anything else it contains; ‘ Anthero de Quental: Sixty-four Sonnets, Englished by Edgar Prestage’ (Nutt). The translator, also known as editor of the ‘ Letters of a Portuguese Nun,’ claims these sonnets as the best in the Portuguese language since Camoens; but when we think how little the sonnets of Camoens himself afford us, as rendered at different times by Strangford, Aubertin, and Higginson, it is evident that this standard is not a high one. But as a personal study, a typical case in the morbid anatomy of the age, the autobio- graphy of this poor fellow, who is ranked by his admirers with Heine and Leopardi—who was called by his friends Sauto Anthero, from his asceticism, and charity, and who, after a lifetime of spinal disease, shot himself at forty- nine in a public square at the Azores—is pro- foundly touching and interesting. An interesting but not very successful ex- periment in translation is the first volume of ‘ Euripides,’ by Arthur S. Way (Macmillan), who has previously rendered the ‘Iliad’ and the ‘Odyssey.’ Its chief novelty of treatment is in translating the choruses (which, of coursa, constitute the chief difficulty) in the modern lyrical or Swinburnian fashion. This Mr. Way has carried out with such spirit and sincerity as must convince the reader that, whatever is the solution of this difficult prob- lem, that which he has adopted is not. Take, for instance, this (p. 69): CHORUS. If she would but come forth where we wait her, If she would but give ear to the sound Of our speech, that her spirit would learn From its fierceness of anger to turn, And her lust for revenge not buru ! O ne’er may my love prove traitor, Never false to my friends be it found. This commonplace jingle suggests a Gilbert ‘ and Sullivan opera rather than the delicate expression and wonderfully adjusted cadences of a Greek chorus. In other cases we revert to ‘* In Memoriam” (p. 109): “One toils with love more strong than death; ret, yet, who knoweth whether he A wise man or a fool shall be To whom he shall bis wealth bequeath ?”’ In a few choruses the version is more vigor- ous and sonorous, but it is at the best some- thing more remote from Euripides than Mr. 5 Newman's ballad-measure from Homer; or it is ; as if the Pyrrbic dance were represented for 4 stage purposes by the latest figure of the Ger- man, with favors. Of minor volumes, Mr. Reginald Fanshawe’s ‘Two Lives’ (Bell) is monotonous, and writ- ten too much on atheory; ‘Quorsum ” the Cry of Human Suffering’ (Rivington) is liable to the same objection, with the addition that it is written in Wordsworthian blank-verse, clearly and conscientiously worked out, however, and readable by ‘a lonely and athletic student,’ rane’s ‘The Kestrel’s Nest, and Other Verses’ (Longmans) is made difficult to read by being composed of the very lightest kind of vers de société, balanced by the dignity of a Greek motto on the titlepage. ‘Windfall and Wa- terdrift’ (G. P. Putnam’s Sons), by the well- known Auberon Herbert, is an example of curious balancing in another way, being a col- lection of short poems of no special interest, and all intended to ‘float’ (in commercial phrase) the announcement, at the end of the volume, of Mr. Herbert's monthly magazine, “The Free Life: Organ of Voluntary Taxa- tion and of the Voluntary State.” It may in- terest some cis-Atlantic readers to know that ‘““Mr. Auberon Herbert will be glad to write to all persons interested in Voluntaryism”— his address being Old House, Ringwood. The announcement seems recent; if he knew how many people in America are eager to write to anybody who will answer them, he probably would not have risked the offer. May Kendall’s ‘Songs from Dreamland’ (Longmans) is not quite light enough for dreams or substantial enough for reality. The same might be said of Julian Sturgis’s ‘ Book of Song’ (Longmans) but for such a touch of bu- man sympathy as in this modernizing of a le- gend (p. 65): A SONG OF PROSERPINE, Her eyes were lights of the morning, Her song of the meadows gay, But the dark man at eventide Had stolen her away— Aw J from tbe sunbright upland Where t e folded sheep are fed, Away from her father’s cottage door, Away from her mother’s bed! And ah, if her mother could see her, Who once was glad of her birth, And hear her leugh in the gaslight glare A laugh of little mirth. ‘Sonnets of the Wingless Hours * (Chicago Stone & Kimball) is the most remarkable of these recent volumes because, while the hun- dred sonnets all owe their immediate origin to one of those cases of lifelong invalidism so com- mon among English authors, they are wholly free from the erotic taint, and are thoroughly simple and noble. The life on a wheeled chair which they reveal is still manly enough to take pleasure in the thought of every truly manly thing—cricket, swimming, skating, fishing; nay, to go beyond the usual English limitation and grant the object of “sport” his little term of life (p. 13): “And yet I think, if ever years awoke My limbs to motion, so that I could stand Again beside a river, rod in hand As Evening spreads his solitary cloak, “That I would leave the little speckled folk Their happy life—thetr marvellous command Of stream’'s wild ways—and break the cruel wand To let them cleave the current at a stroke As I myself once could.” Mr. Lee-Hamilton has been stretched on bis mattress bed for twenty years; he is not sus- tained, as many are, by trust in a Divine Pro- vidence or by faith in a happy immortality but he is, on the other band, above all mere voluptuousness of fancy, all weak selfishness: and one, at least, of his sonnets is worthy, by its nobility of thought and treatment, to hold its own, like Blanco White's one sonnet, in any future collection of English poetry (p. 7%: A FLIGHT FROM GLORY. —. from the parapet of gems an i glow, 2 Angel said, “ O God, the he art KTOWS co ld ( ou these eternal battlements of goid Where all is pure, but cold as virgin snow. Here sobs are never heard; no salt tears flow; Here the re are none to help—nor sic& nor old; No wron ) Gght, no justice to upho wel Grant me Tt 1 leave to live man’s life belo And the a annihilation?” God replied “ Yes,” said the angel “even that dread price; Fore artuly tears are worth eternal night. “ Then, g¢>," said (od. — The Angel opened wide Andrew Lang never better justified his Lon- don sobriquet of ‘‘ the Amateur Genius” thao in his little volume ‘Ban and Arriére Ban (Longmans)—of course the name must be French—in which he has swept together all the fragments of his numerous writing desks, even to a sonnet containing only thirteen lines. It, however, includes his ** Boat Song,” perhaps the prettiest thing he ever wrote, and a few poems on those inexhaustible out-door themes, golf, cricket, and trout fishing. After all, we should not complain of these subjects, even when they are made as Wearisome as Black's perpetual salmon, when we think that they remain the one stronghold for English mental health against the ever invading * Ban and Arriére Ban’ of France. But even here Mr Lang's puny defence is as nothing compared with the stalwart arm of Mr. Norman Gale, well known already by bis ‘A Country Muse,’ and now giving us a whole volume of * Cricket Songs’ (Methuen), so crammed with honest animal life and endless unintelligible techni- calities and ringing rbythm as will charm a vast multitude who know no difference be What spirit of unwholesome décadence but is, so to speak, tween a “lob” anda “ grub bowled out by a strain like this (p A TOMBOY That long leexed « ing, Alice James Phare takes wth the hnson boys A chk n engines could not mak So shrill a notse She's onlv twelve, and so. unfrocket! Beyond her sor s And never maiden longed » A boy to be She puta on gloves and pads to bat And makes young . Good heavens’ How she 4 ile t that teall And how she goes She's tumbled vards outette the crease And is indisputably out Apother innings? Ah, bow strong That cherry pout And alse Bob's Ro, riding roughshed over rules This lorg leawed darling bas her wil! And when she's twenty, | expect She will do so stil Briefe an August Roeckel von Richard Wag ner. Leipzig and New York: Breitkopf & Harte It is well known that Richard Wacner was a great letter-writer, partly owing to the fact that he spent so many years in exile or isola tion, far away from his intimate friends. The letters to his most favored correspondents Liszt, Ublig, Fischer, and F. Heine—have been printed in three volumes, those to the last named, however, being not complete, as it was lately announced that Richard Bertling of Dresden had come into possession of other letters to Heine even more interesting than those already printed. Forty of his letters are to be found in Praeger’s ‘ Wagner as I Knew Him, which has recently come in for much criticism, as it has been shown that the au- thor’s vanity led him to make claims that can not be substantiated, and also because, for some reason or other, the Wagner letters were in the German edition printed not in the ori- ginal but in a retranslation from the English. Mr. S. Chamberlain, however, has since pub- lished a German brochure containing ‘ Wag- ner’s Genuine Letters to Praeger.’ Then there are the eighteen romantic letters to Frau Wille printed in the Deutsche Rundschau, 1887, twelve letters on vivisection to E. von Weber, a considerable number to Carl Heckel in ‘ Die Bihnenfestspiele in Bayreuth,’ and scores of in Emerson's phrase; while Mr. Alfred Coch- His dazzling wings, cased back on Heaven thrice, And plunged fur ever from the walls of Light. single letters printed in the German periodi- Se een 3 ie Toop te 1a rere, 9 dt ag ae = Si eat

Page 24

OLY SP EERE sete ocr se © I OS BE es 390 cals, especially the Berliner Boersen-Courier, which no doubt will be collected into a volume as soon as the list is complete, for new ones are appearing almost every week. The latest contribution to Wagner's episto- lary literature is a collection of twelve letters to August Roeckel, his most intimate friend in Dresden during the time that ‘‘ Tannhiiuser” and ‘‘ Lohengrin” were composed. He himself re- lates, in one of his autobiographic sketches, that in his Dresden solitude almost his only intimate associate was Roeckel, ‘‘ who, in his thorough sympathy with my artistic development, went so far as to Aabandon—as he told me himself— his inclination and ambition to develop and apply his own artistic capacities.” This was literally true. Roeckel had been appointed as- sistant conductor at Dresden in 1843, on the strength of the success of bis opera ‘‘ Farinelli,” yet he was sp overawed by Wagner’s genius that he gave up his intentions of making his way as a composer, in spite of bis rather re- markable musical affiliations; for he was a nephew of Hummel, his wife a cousin of Lort- zing, and his father had been a friend of Bee- thoven, in whose ‘‘ Fidelio” he appeared as Florestan at Vienna in 1806, while subsequent- ly he helped to popularize German opera in London and Paris. Unfortunately, Roeckel’s abandonment of music was followed by his more and more complete absorption in the revolutionary move- ment of the time. He had been in Paris in 1830 during the July Revolution, and the ideas to which he was there subjected continued t» ferment in his mind, and made him one of the leaders in the Dresden uprising. Hugo Dinger, who has written the most detailed and trust- worthy account of the revolutionary period in Wagner's life (‘Wagner’s Geistige Entwicke- lung’) and who had access to official docu- ments, relates that Roeckel ‘‘ was the Mephis- topheles who led Waguer- Faust into the politi- cal witches’ kitchen, and showed him an ideal picture of the future in the mirror of demo- cratic and socialistic ideas. He had taken com- plete possession of the artist. Every day he call- elon his friend and took bim out for a walk, during which be indoctrinated him till he had him completely in his power and drove him forward, over the barricades, to a new life.” Thus it happened that Wagner, who really did not care for politics at all, but merely hoped that a general overthrow would make it possi- ble for him to carry out his revolutionary ar- tistic schemes, became involved in the Dresden rebellion. How far he was personally active in that uprising is still a matter of dispute, and may remain so, unless bis unpublished au- tobiograpby should contain a circumstantial confession. Dinger’s investigation of official documents has shown that the Government did not at first look on Wagner as a very serious rebel, and purposely allowed him ample time to escape before issuing the warrant for his arrest; but subsequeut developments made him liable to the charge of high treason, the penalty of which was death. Roeckel was caught, condemned to be sbot, but finaily im- prisoned at Waldheim, where he remained thirteen years, although he could have secured his release sooner had he not stubbornly re- fused to apologize. Wagner had good reason to dislike a man who had thus led him into mischief which re- sulted in twelve years’ exile from the only country where he could hope to produce his art-works. But there is no trace of reproach in these twelve letters, seven of which were sent to Roeckel while he was still a prisoner. In the first of them, dated Ziirich, August 24, The Nation. 1851, he writes: ‘‘Just as I happened to be at Bordeaux, I saw in a French paper that you and Bakunin were soon to be executed. I wrote a letter in the hope of being in time to bid you farewell. The rumor, however, proved to be false, and the letter which I had sent to Dresden to be forwarded was, under these cir- cumstances, withheld as a matter of course.” There are no other significant allusions to the revolutionary period in these letters, of which, since most of them were sent to a prisoner, it could not have been expected that they would allude to the unfortunate incidents which had made him so. Nor is there any further allu- sion to this period in the five letters written after Roeckel’s release, for Wagner was not in later years fond of stirring up those unplea- sant memories. It cannot be said, indeed, that readers of Wagner’s previously published letters will find anything very new or striking in the present collection, but there are many interesting va- riations of certain ‘“‘leadiug motives” of his life which constantly recur in his letters and other prose writings, as the Leitmotire do in his scores. Here, once more, we find grateful references to Liszt’s sympathy, friendship, and artistic encouragement; commendation of the Persian Hafiz as the greatest of all poets; com- plaints of isolation and lack of appreciation; aversion to artistic work for pecuniary com- pensation; denial that Humboldt was a genius; references to the tremendous influence on him of Schopenhauer at a decisive period in bis life; sneers at Judaism and optimism; excla- mations on the martyrdom of being an artist; reference to artistic creation as the only true enjoyment; pity for King Ludwig in the hands of his political advisers; protests against sepa- rating the ‘‘man” from the ‘artist’; surprise that his operas are becoming popular in spite of the almost invariably wretched perform- ances of them; commendation of solitude, Switzerland, and dogs; invitations and refe- rences to the pleasures of hospitality—and so on. The fourth letter takes up vo less than 26 of the 84 pages, and is on the whole the most important of the collection, because in it Wag- ner replies to certain criticisms of his Nibe- lung poems made by Roeckel, and thus throws some bright side-lights on them. Commenta- tors may be especially advised to read page 37, wherein he justifies the need in a drama of a certain obscurity of motives; and page 41, where he points out the tragic sublimity of the motive which makes Briinnhilde cling to the cursed ripg as the symbol of love. In the same letter he laments the principal impediment in his path—the rarity of good vocalist-actors: ‘* When I think of the performers, I must sigh deeply. Of course I must try to find young artists not yet ruined by our opera- houses; so-called ‘celebrities’ [ have no use for. Then I must see about training these young folks. What [ should prefer would be to keep them together a whole year without letting them appear before the public; then I could meet them daily, train them in their artistic and human capacities, and see them ripen gradually for their task.” Here is another interesting passage from the same letter: ‘Once more I have realized how many things in my poetic ge become clear only through the music. can no longer en- dure to look at the poem without the music. In time | hope to be able to send you this score too [‘* Rheingold”). Here I willonly say that it has become a work united in all its parts; the orchestra has hardly a bar that is not de- veloped from preceding motives.” The sixth letter is metaphysical and melan- [Vol. 59, No. 1534 choly. It was written in London, which makes it additionally foggy; Wagner was una- ble to do anything in that city, and informs his friend that ‘there all capacity for work left me. I meant to complete the score of the ‘Walkiire,’ but lost all inner memory for it, and returned to Ziirich ill.” In London he “avoided making new acquaintances”; he lived fora time, as is well known, with Prae- ger, to whom he refers as that ‘‘dear crazy fellow” (diesen guten nirrischen Menschen). Rambles through Japan without a Guide. By Albert Leftingwell (Albert Tracy). Lon- don: Sampson Low; New York: The Baker & Taylor Co, 1894. As Mr. Chamberlain has amusingly recount- ed, the books of travel on Japan cover almost every possible space of time, from seven weeks, to nine years’ sojourn in that country. The author in hand spent only three months there; but we are willing to go very far in praise of his notes of travel, for, taking them merely as a traveller’s impressions and asa diary of small compass, it is the most realistic, the most en- tertaining, the most trustworthy book of the sort that we have seen. More than this, it is one that the reviewer, as an old resident in the country, has read page by page with an inte- rest which he had not thought possible. In calling it trustwortby, he does not forget that there are minor inaccuracies which, though natural in a traveller, could easily have been avoided; such as the use of ‘ karuma” for ‘*kuruma,” the absurd supposition that the Japanese celebrate the falling of the Bastile (p. 5), the forty-nine Ronin (p. 13), the belief that ‘“‘one in twenty, possibly even one in fifteen, of the persons one meets are either partially or wholly blind,” the use of ‘‘ Mika- do” for ‘*Emperor,” and other errors. But these are not unpardonable. One feature must be specially noticed, The author is remarkably clear-headed in his judg- ments of the national traits. Hebas the readi- ness of sympathy without which a traveller has no right to form judgments of otber peoples. He begins by confessing that he has come ‘to regard Japanese life and manners as a phase of real civilization,” a belief which one or two of us have been trying for some time to hammer into the Philistine mind of the home keeping public. He therefore does not hesitate, when he meets some phase of life which has come in for foreign criticism, to point out, where necessary, how a comparative (not necessarily an absolute) estimate is usually to the credit, not the discredit, of Japan, This is a rare feature in such a book, and we may close by quoting an instance or two, taken at random: *“* Although Buddhism may be an ‘outworn creed,’ it has at least served to prepare for the reception of a better, by creating a population more considerate of each other’s rights and privileges than many another even in the Christian world” (p. vil). ‘It is always unsafe to draw one’s conclu- sions respecting a country from the character of a sea-port population. The ‘ globe-trotter’ who judges Japan from Yokohama is as wise as the Oriental pilgrim who should picture English society from his chance experience in Glasgow or Liverpool, or judge American morality solely by rambles in New York and New Orleans” (p. 8). 7 “+ Squeezing’ is invariably the custom [on the part of guides}. But in China, India, Egypt, Spain, France, Italy (to speak merely ot my own experience), and, I suppose, ever y- where else, the traveller who bargains through an interpreter must always pay more than he need pay alone” (p. 62). ge ‘*A few minutes later we were passing swift- ly through the streets of Tokio (at night).

Page 25

2 ter aes OATES SC Nov. 22. 1894] The Nation. | Nearly all the shops were closed. Not a sound of noisy revelry was to be heard, not a drunk- en man was to be seen. How different will be the streets of London, Paris, or New York, a few hours later this Saturday night. But this is a heathen country, barbarous, uncivilized!” >, 65). « ‘In Japan there is no [social] vice which does not more openly prevail in every great city of Europe or America. The missionary tells you of the Yoshiwara ; he does not know the condition of the streets of Christian Lon- don and Glasgow. Compared with streets of San Francisoo and Liverpool, the Yoshiwara of Tokio or Kioto is the apotheosis of decency. In all my journeys through the highways and by-ways of Japan, I never saw such depths of degradation as I have seen in parts of London and New York” (p. 276). ‘¢The longer I live in Japan, the more I am struck with the innate gentleness of the peo- ple. In practical conformity to the teachings of Jesus Christ, in gentleness, in meekness, in a willingness to bear evil rather than do evil, the Japanese are to-day more really a Chris- tian nation than any people of Europe or America” (p. 114). “The price to this country of internal and external peace for more than two centuries was isolation from Western civilization. But when I think of the bloody annals of European history between 1600 and 1853, of the story of man’s inhumanity to man in England, France, Spain, Germany, Ireland, I am disposed to think that the blessings of absolute peace were not too dearly purchased by Japan. What could Europe have given this country that she did not have? What lessons in the practice of Christian virtues could the despotisms of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries have taught Japan ? No; she was wise to shut her gates. They were opened at a better hour.” Weare to-day coming to respect Japan be- cause she can fight when it is necessary. Let us rather, with more intelligence, accord her respect for the high type of character which she has built up in the past centuries in spite of her isolation from the influence of what we are pleased exclusively to term ‘‘ civilization.” Cicero and the Fall of the Roman Republic. By J. Strachan-Davidson, M.A., Fellow of Balliol College, Oxford. [Heroes of the Na- tions.) G. P. Putnam's Sons. 184. Pp. viii, 446. With illustrations and an index. THIS is a good life of Cicero, and, considering all the difficulties which such a work involves, may be pronounced on the whole the best yet accessible. There has been so much written of late on the fall of the Roman Republic that any great striving after originality would be affectation ; but the author has thought for himself, and draws his own picture of Cicero and his times, without making either a servile copy from other authorities or a fantastic caricature in defiance of them. He draws largely from Cicero’s own works, especially his correspondence, as is inevitable; and the translations are gratifying for their simplicity, at a time when English scholars are much too fond of squeezing every drop of possible mean- ing out of the ancient languages, which are often delicately allusive, and ought to be left so. Especially worthy of commendation is the clear statement of the relations of the different orders in the later Commonwealth—the Nobles and the Knights. Every student of this period would say he knew them; but they are pressed home in this book with great acuteness, parti- cularly where it is pointed out that the Sena- torial nobles never could throw off the class sympathies which drew them to Cewsar and Clodius, and away from Cicero and Pompey, even when the opposite course was dictated by common sense and by personal predilection. It ought also to be brought out that at such a sensitive time, where every circumstance gave a tilt to the balance, Pompey’s insensibility to culture must have been very repulsive to a ruling class who were steeped in refinement The sin of Verres in pillaging the works of art had been the sin of a gentleman: and a man who, being on the spot, would not go to see the wonders of Athens (Mr. Strachan- Davidson mistranslates visenda here) was too much like the Mummii and Marii to hold his own against Cesar in the affections of the Optimates The author believes in Cicero; and he is right. There can be few greater mistakes, either in histor; or in morals, than to maintain that Cicero was either knave or fool in trying to rally all parties in defence of the ancient constitution against such enemies as Lentulus, Cesar, and Antony. Mr. Strachan- Davidson has had the courage as well as the acuteness to hold that Caesar's autocracy was not at al! the beneficent and progressive substitute for effete forms that Mommsen and Froude would per suade us. It was tyranny, in the modern as wellas the ancient sense—directly undermin- ing the spirit as well as destroying the rights of the Romans ; and the oppression was felt at the time by all of the population who were capable of feeling it. When the whole tale of Cicero’s weaknesses—which have been paraded by his detractors, as if there was any secret about them—is told, he comes out a great statesman and a good man; and, as the author says, those who know him best like him best The limits of the book forced the author to pass over much that was interesting, but some omisions seem injudicious. The beautiful inci dent of Cicero’s discovering the tombof Arcbi medes at Syracuse, and his diligence in being ready with his evidence against Verres much witbin the allotted time, are too characteristic to be left out. It is to be regretted that Mr Strachan-Davidson speaks of the triumvir by the fantastic name of ‘‘ Octavian.” No one calls Scipio the Younger ‘*‘ Aemilian.” If he shrinks—as his contemporaries did not—from the name of Caius Cesar, why not simply say Augustus? An engraving of the famous bust is inserted as that of the young Augustus—and so all the world calls it. The illustrations, mostly from Duruy, are neither elegant nor significant enough to add much to the value of the book. A Study of Ethical Principles. By James Seth, Professor of Philosophy in Brown Uni versity. London: Blackwood ; New York Charles Secribner’s Sons. ISM. Pp. xvi + 460. THis book tends to fall between two ideals The author evidently intended to write a text- book, yet hoped (as he says in his preface) to achieve something much more ambitious. In the latter endeavor—namely, to add to the discussion of ethical principles somethipg fresh and permanent—he does not succeed, in our opinion. At most he provides occasional apergus which serve to make his book sugges- tive, while not original. Prof. Seth's whole attempt at constructive work ends in the abyss of * personality.” He gives us not a shadow of a criticism of this Vague concept, and does not seem familiar with the rich details of matter which the ab- normal and analytic work of the last few years has laid out. It is possible we are not ready yet for a doctrine of persopality ; but the phrase ‘* personality is sacred,” and the argu ment for it, *‘ otherwise morality and religion are undermined,” ought to have no place now -without critical justification, at any rate— in treatises which pretend to either scientific exactness or philosophical competence. 2391 There is in the book one point which seems to us to be new: we mean the argument made from an evolutionary standpoint against Mill's qualitative distinction between plea sures; to the effect that only the highly cde- veloped natures would appreciate higher plea sures, and so there would be no sense in com mending such pleasures to the lower natures which need our injunctions most. But does net the moralist in fact encounter just this difficulty * Is he not in constant perplexity as tothe means of interesting lower natures in higher things, whether we call the higher things personal ideals with the eudamonist, pleasures with the hedonist, or laws with the rigorist ° Considered as a text-book, on the other hand, and especially as an historical introduce tion, there is much to commend in Prof, Seth's ‘Study.’ The style is good, though in places hasty, the conneetions of historical system are clearly made out along the traditional lines of the histories of philosophy, and the author does Aristotle justice wherever his name can be brought in Moreover, Mr. Seth tries to build upon recent psvchology; vet be does not succeed very well in making psychology really a part of ethics, as it should be Teachers, nevertheless, will not go far wrong in using tl book for what it is—a sensible, orthodox, clearly wriften exposition ability al ton a per with at least tw t? snow in irrent use We must in closing deprecate the author's excessive injection of the gica atter t the treatment of ethics The sermoniszings found in the last third of the book weaken it distinctly , and is there anv need of devoting one hundred pages to the mmonplaces nm specting virtues like tem] trol, and another hundred out of a total of four hundred to such topics as immortality and theism Of course when a man has some thing new to savy on these topics, they are just the topics on which something new should be said; but when the opinions ld—as thev are in this case ne must grudge th re two hun- dred pages, no matter how well expressed the views may be, or how well supported by hap- pily chosen poetical quotations. Life and Letters of M. P. O'Connor Written and Edited by his daughter Mary Doline O'Connor, New York: Dempsey & Carroll, i883 THE interest of this bulky volume for the gene- ral reader is almost entirely that pertaining to a phase of Southern reconstruction, one of the darkest of a time of fearful gloom. But we have the illustration of this phase in connec- tion with a personality that is attractive by its earnestness, its simplicity, and its warm affec- tions in all the more intimate relations of friendship and domestic life. It would be churlish to object to the effusiveness of a laughter’s admiration for her father’s charac- ter and ability. When, with filial piety, we have the Irish temperament, some latitude of praise must be expected, and to look for any critical estimate would be manifestly absurd. Michael Patrick (Connor was born in Beau- fort, S. C., in 1831, ‘amid the full develop- ment of aslaveholding influence, an atmosphere not favorable to the growth of any character foreign to its tenaciousand exclusive instincts.” But Mr. O'Connor was at least free from the disadvantage of hereditary taint. His father had immigrated only nine years before his birth. He was a sturdy Roman Catholic, at first almost the only one in the community. — a he NUE, IIE or SEAN te aspen ee ee eT ee ee a erly eins dil ee =e ee nem ee nm

Page 26

EAR iaigie sts, co mre Ue incall The son kept the faith, and equally his father's interest in all things Hibernian, and his easy eloquence was in demand for all [Irish anni- versaries and social festivals. He was educat- ed—imperfectly, it would appear—at the Jesuit College at Fordham, N. Y. Admitted to the bar when he was twenty-three years old, his local reputation as an orator was of rapid growth. More than half the volume is given up to his speeches and orations, and they are examples of genuine Irish eloquence—rhetori- cal, emotional, perfervid; its substance glow- ing with a crimson heat even when there is most of solid argument. One can easily con- ceive that, with such a voice as many eulogists ascribe to him, the impression that he made upon a popular assemblage was intense, if not profound. But the circumstances of his ca- reer were not such as to make his political suc- cess commensurate with his natural ability. Elected to the lower house of the General As- sembly in 1858, he opposed the reopening of the slave-trade and the movement towards seces- sion, then fast gathering head. But when South Carolina seceded, ‘‘ finding himself ‘una- ble to stem the current, he bowed to the State’s decree, loyally acquiesced in that which he was powerless to prevent but sincerely re- gretted, and in many of his public utterances cheered them [sic] on to victory.” We read so often of this kind of thing that we cannot help wondering what the course of events would have been if all who were opposed to secession had shown the energy and determi- nation of their opponents. As the war drew to its end, Mr. O’Connor and his family found themselves in Columbia, witnesses of the city’s melancholy fate, but sufferers to no great extent. He immediately accepted the results of the war and, once they were passed, the constitutional amendments ; yet he could not but oppose the policy which made South Carolina ‘‘The Prostrate State” : the deluded negro and the carpet-bagger join- ing hands to keep her in the slough of her im- measurable disgrace. He was an ardent sup- porter of Horace Greeley in 1872, and, in the convention which nominated him, threw him- self with tremendous ardor and effect upon the reactionary position of Senator Bayard. Could his spirit have become general in the Democratic party, the result would have been very different ; but that it would have been more fortunate—only those to whom the un- knowable is an open book can tell us about that. In 1876 he was again eager and hopeful, and correspondingly depressed when the Elec- toral Commission gave the election to Hayes. “The sin of pride and slavery, it would seem,” he wrote, ‘has not yet been sufficient- ly atoned for.” But his Irish blood was up, and he had no patience with Tilden’s easy acquiescence in his fate. The election of Wade Hampton as Governor was a mitigating cir- cumstance, and did much to console him for Tilden’s defeat and his own as a Congressional candidate. In 1878 he was more fortunate and again in 1880, but he was prevented by death from finishing his second term. To no- thing did he give himself more actively in Congress than to a bill for the reimbursement of the colored people who had suffered by the failure of the Freedmen’s Bank. A less femi- nine taste for statistics and hard facts would have made his biography much more valuable; but as it is, when Mr. Rhodes or some other historian comes to the reconstruction period, this will be one of many memoirs that will serve him with some knowledge of the men and the motives which that period involved in its distracting whirl. The Nation. [Vol. 59, No. 1534 Histoire de la Littérature Francaise. Par Gustave Lanson. Paris: Hachette & Cie. IN one stout volume of 1,150 pages, M. Lan- son—whose critical work has won him an honorable place in the ranks of the best con- temporary French writers—gives us the most complete and best-proportioned compendium of French literature yet published. Neither Petit de Julleville’s excellent ‘Legons de Litté¢- rature Francaise,’ Lintilhac’s ‘Littérature Francaise,’ René Doumic’s or Gazier’s works, can stand comparison, as a whole, with M. Lanson’s new book. As for Demogeot, he is decidedly out of date. Two or three points in M. Lanson’s book serve to place it far ahead of its rivals. First, the Middle Ages receive a due share of attention; the labors of the me- dizvalist scholars, led by Gaston Paris, hav- ing been turned to practical account for the benefit of the student. The whole of this period, of such great importance to a proper understanding of the Renaissance, Classic, and Romantic times, is treated with fulness and clearness. Secondly, the nineteenth century is rightly considered by the author as a com- pleted epoch; and a general view of it, occu- pying nearly 250 pages, enables the foreign reader to understand the worth and bearing of the work done by great writers from Mme. de Staél and Chateaubriand down to Renan, Leconte de Lisle, and the chief novelists whose career is practically closed. Thirdly, M. Lan- son, appreciating the general desire felt to know something definite of the contemporary writers actually engaged in the production of literature, has devoted a chapter to the great critics of the day—Brunetiére, Faguet, Lemai- tre, Sarcey—to the latest poets and romancers, to the very latest dramatists. Such informa- tion has hitherto been unattainable save in the pages of critics and reviewers, in newspa- per and magazine articles. Petit de Julle- ville merely names some of these writers in footnotes, Doumic in a paragraph; Liutilhac has a few brief words about some of them; not one of the three has ventured very far. M. Lanson is to be congratulated on his resolute attempt to characterize these men and their work for the benefit of the student. All these merits are important, and add very greatly to the value of the book. But the fun- damental point isthe mode of treatment adopt- ed by the author, and here again one experi- ences satisfaction. M. Lanson has not attempt- ed a scientific history of an art; he has at- tempted and has succeeded in giving a philoso- phical view of French literature. It is no mere dry catalogue of names and dates, of authors and works, filled out with summary appreciations of each, but a systematic, well- linked, well thought-out account of the evolu- tion of literature, of the movement of thought, of the birth, growth, and decadence of the various schools which have been the expression of the successive phases of that evolution. To the mere amateur of literature, as to the earnest student or teacher, this method of presenting the history of French literature will prove of the greatest value for a clear comprehension of that literature as a whole and of the reasons of its influence. Not that this method has not already been put into practice: Nisard’s cele- brated history is an example of it, and Pellis- sier’s work on the nineteenth century is another —Saintsbury’s ‘Shorter History’ may be cited also. But M. Lanson carries it out for every epoch, as is not the case with Nisard or Pellis- sier. It is supplemented by the details which other writers of handbooks of literature have thought suflicient in themselves. The personal note, too, is marked: the book is no mere epitome of opinions of various critics: it is the outcome of knowledge of the works which to- gether make up French literature; and herein M. Lanson is an example of the only true way of studying any literature, namely, by reading the original works first and the criticisms after- wards, Too many people nowadays read the latter only. Well-arranged chronological tables, a full index, an interesting table of contents which summarizes the leading divisions of the work, contribute to the general excellence of the book; and last, and very important, M. Lan- son’s style is such as to make the reading of his history a distinct pleasure. Varieties in Prose. By William Allingham. 3 vols. Longmans, Green & Co. No more agreeable volumes of miscellanies have passed the press in recent years than these reliquic of a gifted and amiable writer. They range widely: sketches of little tours in Eng- land, Wales, Ireland—France at the farthest; historical papers, not too learned to be reada- ble; pieces of artistic and literary criticism; humanly philosophical essays; studies of life and manners—there is something for most tem- peraments except the Gradgrind and the hys- terical. Some of the papers are slight things, others are in dead earnest; but the serious are never heavy, and even the least significant are instinct with the life of an interesting and worthy individuality. Whatever is sound and honest is sure of a good word. Even stupidity is treated with rare patience when it is com- bined with sincerity, and when, we must hasten to add, it does not express itself in church- ‘“‘restoration.” Whatever is mean—above all, whatever is cruel, whether of intent or as part of unfeeling system—evokes warm but unde- clamatory indignation. Wholesome reading for a fussy and attitudinizing decade! We may. spare over-much detail, for many of these papers have appeared in the English magazines or elsewhere and are familiar to our readers; but we cannot pass by ‘The Rambles of Patricius Walker” without a word of appreciation. If the bicycle is to abolish the good old art of walking, as some trium- phantly think, these little sketches of tours on foot may stand as a testimony to our descend- ants. In them they may read with envy how once the contemplative man could take his pleasures at a leisurely pace, not vexing his soul about problems of rapid transit. The sketches are not all first-rate, but none of them is dull and the best of them are charm- ing. Mr. Allingham’s descriptive powers were those of the poet, and, unlike many poets, he was master of a graceful aud unmannered prose style. The ‘‘Irish Sketches” have also a permanent value, and the account of St. Patrick’s Purgatory is doubtless unique. It is not, however, so much for instruction as for refreshment that the reader who pos- sesses these volumes will recur to them, always, we are sure, with gratitude to Mrs. Alling- ham for sending them to press, and to her pub- lishers for putting them up in so attractive a form. City Government in the United States. By Alfred R. Conkling. D. Appleton & Co. 1894, Mr. CONKLING has collected a great deal of useful information with reference to City Government, and gives much good practical advice. The main conclusions to be derived from bis bc ok are (1) that our large cities are

Page 27

Nov. 22, 1894] the worst governed in the world; () that this is not due to bad laws, but to bad men—1. e., to the fact that the class of men who fill the administrative offices is so poor that no amount of good legislation will produce good | government. get good men? And to this the answer is not so easy. According to estimates on which Mr. The question is, How are we to | } solely for fitness. Conkling places reliance, a very large propor- tion of the voters in any community are vena), and if, besides venality, ignorance is also taken into account, we may say that the venal and ignorant, by acting together, would be able to decide almost every municipal election. Of course we console ourselves with the reflection that they do not act together, that some of them vote for one party and some for the other; but there is really more ‘solidarity ” and esprit de corps among them than we are apt to think. It must be remembered, too, that the pre- vention by good election laws of actual bribery at the polls does not ipso facto make a worthy citizen out of the voter who would otherwise have taken money. The ‘ floater” and the ‘‘stove-sitter” will always ‘‘ be voted” rather than vote. We cannot get rid of them, and all we can do is to take away their opportunities as much as possible. A very good way to see in what direction the remedy lies is to ask our- selves what sort of municipal government the venal classes would themselves most enjoy. If they were revising the charter of a city, they would undoubtedly provide for as many elec- English Readings. Just Published: LYLY’S ENDYMION. Edited, with Notes, Bibliography, and Biographical In- troduction, by Grorce P. BAKER, Harvard. 16mo, elxxxix+109 pages. Cloth. Teachers’ price $1.25, postage 8c.; boards 85 cts., postage 7c. a HENRY HOLT & CO., N. Y. Yale Mixture. A GENTLEMAN’S SMOKE. You won’t know the luxury of Pipe-Smoking until you use Yale Mixture.

A two-oz. trial package, postpaid, for 25 cents. MARBURG BROS., The American Tobacco Co , Successor, Baltimore, Md. We buy and ‘sell bills of exchange on and make Cable Transfers of money to of Europe, Australia, and the West Indies: also make collections and issue Commer 5. etters _—— cial and Travellers’ Credits, available in Cre dit. all parts of the world. . Brown Brothers & Co., Bankers, _NO. 59 WAL L STREET. NEW YO YORK. THE LENOX LIBRARY (AND READING ROOS), Fifth Ave. and 70th St., is open every weekday from 10 A.M. to 4 P.M. Exhibition of rare books; two galleries of paintings. Admission free; no tickets required. NY INFORMATION OF WILLIAM 21 James McWilliams of Cainteel, Co. Tyrone, Ire land, last heard from at Risings, Butler Co., Nebraska, in 1880, will be thankfully received by his sister, Mary McWILLIAMS, of Aughnadoy, Co. Tyrone, Ireland.

The tive offices and as frequent elections as possi- Nation. ble. Exactly in the same way the interests of | the honest classes require the concentration of power in the hands of non-elective administra- tive officials, and the appointment of these officials by some one who will select them Ten years of such appoint- ments would solve the question of munici- pal government in any city in the United States. form of the city government of Philadel- phia is perfect,” Mr. Conkling says, ** yet the men now (184) in office are not satisfactory.” The ‘‘men in oftice” make the city govern- |} Knox, T. W. Hosmer, J. K How Thankful Was Bewitched. | nams, ) cents Jesperson, Prof. Otte. Progress in Lancuage with special reference to English. London © Sonnensehels New York : Macmillan. $1.50 Kapp, Gisbert. Electric Transmission of Frergy ith ed., thoroughly revised, D. Van Nostrand Co. §8_) The Lost Army The Merriam ( . Liddon, Rev. BH. P. Clerical Life and Work. Longmans, Green & Co 2. | Morrison, Arthur, Martin Hewitt. Investigator. Har “Under the new ballot charter, the | ment what it is—not the form of the laws which they administer; and the reason why Berlin is better governed than Philadelphia is because the ‘‘ men in office” in Berlin are satis factory. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Amicts, Edmondo de. Holland. 2 vols. Philadelphia Porter & Coates. 5. Bastian, Adolf. Zur Mythologie und Psychologie der Nigritier in Guinea. Berlin: Dietrich Reimer. Bliss, W. R. Side Glimpses from the Colonial esting House. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co. 81.5 Borlaise, Skipp. Stirring Tales of Colonial Ac ave means A Book for Boys. F. Warne & Co. $1.50. Clark, D. K. Tramways; TheirConstructionand Work ing. 2d ed., re-written and greatly enlarged. Lon don: Crosby, Lockwood & Son; New York: D. Van Nostrand Co. $4, Davidson, Thomas. The Education of the Greek Peo He and its Influence on Civilization. (International education Se vee s.] Appletons Edwards, Dr.J.F. Hygiene, with Anatomy and Physi ology. Edw: a P. Slevin. Ford, Mary H. Otto's Insptration. Griggs & Co. $1. Gersticker, F. Germelshausen. Boston: D. C. Heath & Co. 25 cents. Chicago: S. C. LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO.'S NEW BOOKS. Border Ballads With an Introductory Essay by ANDREW LANG and 12 Etchings by O. MURRAY Printed on laid paper, gilt top, half uncut 4to (1854x854), $7.00, 750 copies of this box 200 have been secured for the United States. History of the Commonwealth and Protectorate, 1049-1000 By SAMUEL Rawson GARDINER, M.A., Hon LL.D. Edinburgh, Fellow of Merton Col- lege, Honorary Student of Christ Church, &e. Vol. 1. 1648-1651. 87.00, The Repose of Faith; in View of Present-Day Difficulties By the Rev. ALEXANDER J. Harrrsoy, B.D. Lecturer of the Christian Evidence $ Society, Author of ‘Problems of Christianity and Scepticism.’ Crown Svo. #2.00, Advanced Agricul iture By Henry J. wi EBB, Agricultural College, Aspatria. With illustrations. Crown Svo £2.50.

Sold by all Booksellers. Sent, post} aid, by LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., lS Lasi JOIRkR M t, Nes Pere, The Round Robin Reading Club Offers to indiv lasses a discriminating study of Literature ing literary men and frexiom in the choice

and personal gui T ’ ni r 7 » its System, endorsed Dy

of subject hes for each subject original r specialiate, who criticise pa pers when desired. This direct personal assistance S peculiar the “ Round Robin,” and is of great value i ny study and in general reading. For Parlicula4rs ac dd ines Miss LOUISE STOCKTON, 4215 Chester Avenue, Philadelphia.

schedules |

pers 56 cents Muggleton College: Its Rise and Fall Lond Archi bald Constable & Co. O'Grady, Standish. The Coming of « alt AR mance of the Heroic Age of Ireland Lond Mw thuen & Co Perrot, Prof. Georges, and Chipies, Charles. History of Art in Primitive Greece. Mycentan Art vals London: Chapman & Hall; New York: A A strong & Son. §15. Phyfe, W. HP. Five Th pane rds ten Mispr nounced. Putnama, 75: t Roosevelt, Thelore. The Wis woof the West. \ Hil. The Founding of the Trans Allegheny ’ wealths. 1784-170. Putnams. $Y Schorlemmer, Prof. Carl. The Rise and Dev ‘ of Organte Chemistry. Revised ed. Macn am. S14 Skene, F.M.F. Hidden Depths Rand, McNally « « MO) cents

Sheldon, ¢ oa M. The ruc ifixion of Phitip Strong j Chicago c. MeClurg & Co. 61 Stmonds, A i American Song: A Collect f Rey sentative American Poems. Putt The Demon of Lermontoff. Translates { fro t * | sian London: Rivington, Percival & ¢ | The Golden Fairy Book. Illustrated Applet ‘ . The Student Missionary Enterprise: F. HR. Reve CA $i So Thompson, D. DD. Abraham Lincoln, the First Amertean Hunt & Raton. Wi cents Un Siecle de Modes Fer mit nines, 1 Twa Isvd Quatre Cents Tollettes réprxtdultes en re Yaris Charpentier & Fosquelle; New York » Dyrsen & Pett fer Van Dyke, Prof Cc Text book of History i Painting. Longmans, tir x 4 $! | White, Eliza O. When Moliv Was Six. Boston: Hougt k have been printed, of which | a

ton, Mifflin & Co

Wright, Thomas Life of Dante! Defoe. Randoty 3.75 | Wright, W. A. Sbakspere’s Mux Ado at t Nothing Oxford! clarenden Pre as: New York Maer lar Zimmern, Alice. Methods of Ea at : nited States London > Sonnenschein New \ . Ma milan. $1 Ziwet, Prof. Alexander. An Flen tary 1 at lew Theoretical Mechanics. Part LIL Kinetics. Ma tliat $V.25 7 A y, OWE For Bratn-Workers, the Weak and Debtiitated. Horsford’s Acid Phosphate is without exception the Best Mental 1: and Remedy for relieving and Nervous Exhaustio where the system has become debilitated by disease it acts as vitalizer, both a general tonic and affording sustenance to brain and body. Dr. E. Cornell Esten, Philadelphia, Pa ‘*] have met with the great- est and most satistactory resuits tn 9 Says: Jao } ] Gyspepsia and general derangement of the cerebral and nervous systems, causing debility and exhaustion Descriptive Pamphlet free. Providence, R. 1. Beware of Substitutes and Imitations. Rumford Chemical Work

FOR SALE. St. Nicholas, Vols. 1-19, bound. paeeasendanacane Scientific Am., Vols. 18-69 = cooee OE OO Our Young Folks, Vols. 1-9, bound 10 00 Goldthwalte's Geog. Mag., Vols. 1 5, unbound.. 7 50 H, WILLIAMS, 195 West 10th St., N. Y.

rea A te PN SOON REE eas megan te Sade vine siti LE 0B MI

eo eed io acme setae mst. tty Sain tine <a ng FBR IT st mse “ee ge ~ anew ip-vositinrtet Sere a

Page 28

394. Poems, New and Old. William Roscoe Thayer Author of ‘* The Dawn of Italian Inde- pendence,” etc. Z6mo, gilt top, $1.00. *“ You have always something to say, and you say it distinctly,” wrote the late Matthew Arnold of some of the earlier poems in this volume. “Mr. Thayer does not imitate any of his contempo- raries; he nowhere wrecks himself upon expression; what strikes one most in his verse is the solid good sense upon which it is based.”’—R. H. Stoddard, in New York Mail and Express, “* Waverley Revisited’ is a composition of sustained elevation of feeling and much beauty of expression. The music of the verse is especially charming, and the sincerity of the sentiment is altogether convincing.”— New York Times, “ This Isa volume such as one hardly expects from a young writer to-day in these United States; ... poems of the Orient and of love, although here and there he becomes satiric and occasionally reflective. Fifty years hence ... may be... the first edition of a book written by one whose name will then be a household word.” —Boston Saturday Evening Gazette. “ Forms of expression that attract by spontaneous beauty.”—Boston Beacon, “Has many dainty love songs which will be appre- ciated by any one who loves good poetry.”"—San Fran- etaco Chronicle. “Profoundly touched by modern thought. . . . To Mr. Thayer belongs the honor of a pioneer.”—Christian Register. Sold by all Booksellers, Sent, postpaid, by HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO., Boston. 11 East 17th Street, New York. THE FAMOUS Capt. January Series, And Other Books. By LAURA E. RICHARDS. MARIE—NARCISSA. ,2xo gharmivg new *books from the pen of Lavra E. Ricwarps, companion volumes to ** CaPTAIN January *’ and ‘* MELopy.’’ 16mo, cloth. Each 50c. These two books will unquestionably rank as Mrs. RicHarps's best work so far, andit is perfectly safe to predict that no one who picks either volume up and commences to read will drop it until it has been read to afinish. Over 100,000 copies of this series have been sold already. MELODY, a “eet. or es *‘Had there never been a ‘Captain JANUARY,’ * MELopy * would easily take first place.*\—Boston Times. a ae, / 78th Thousand. One of CAPT. JANUAR * the most charming Idyls of recent times, whose success is something - nomenal i6mo, cloth. boc. SAME. Illustrated nie edition, with half-tone pictures by Frank T Merrill 4to, handsome cloth cover. $1.25. WHEN | WAS YOUR AGE. 4,>r#&t the author's child-life. Fully illustrated. Small 4to, cloth. $1.25. GLIMPSES OF THE FRENCH COURT: Sketches from French history. With a series of portraits in etching and photogravure. Square zmo, cloth $1 50 THE HILDEGARDE SERIES. Sapprising HiLpEGARDE * — “ Hitpre@arpe’s Honipay” and * HILDEGARDE’s Home.” Ech volume illustrated. Three of the brightest girls’ books. 16mo, cloth. Each $1.25. For sale by booksellers generally, or sent by mail, POSTPAID, on receipt of price by the publishers, ESTES & LAURIAT, Boston. The Nation. NEW BOOKS. The Play-Actress. By S. R. Crockett, author of ‘‘ The Raiders,” ‘The Stickit Minister,” etc., etc. 16mo, in the series of ‘‘ Distinctive Stories,” uniform in general style with ‘“‘A Literary Court- ship,” with Frontispiece by McCullough. $1.00. Uniform with the Above: I. SHIPS THAT PASS IN THE NIGHT. By Miss Harraden. II. In VaryinG Moops. By Miss Harraden. Ill. A LitkRaRy CourRTSHIP. By Miss Anna Fuller. IV. PBAK AND PRAIRIE. By Miss Anna Fuller. V. THe Story OF MARGREDEL. By David 8S. Meldrum. VI. ANALTAROFEARTH. By Thymol Monk. VII. Rep Cap anp BLUE Jacket. By Geo. Dunn. Fly Leaves. Verses by CHARLES STUART CALVERLEY. 16mo, full leather, circuit edges, gilt top (in box), $1.50. Anybody who has read (in a foreign edition) “In the Gloaming,” “ First Love,” ‘ Beer,” ‘‘On a Distant Pros- pect (of making a fortune),” “‘ The Schoolma ster,” and all those other memorable verses of the genial, witty, kindly, gentle Calverley, will be glad, we are sure, to meet with them once more in this pretty American edi- tion. More Celtic Fairy Tales. By JosepH Jacoss, President of the English Folklore Society. Illustrated by JOHN BaTTeEN. (Being No. 6 in the ‘‘ Fairy Tales of the Nations” Series.) 8vo, $1.75. “ There are no volumes of fairy literature which one can more heartily commend to young and old than Mr. Jacobs’s.”—Literary World. Previously Published in this Series: No. I. Eneuisa Farry TALES......... $1 75 No. II. Cexutic Farry Taxs...... oso wae No. III. [INpran Farry TALES........ Bg es No. IV. More ENGLISH Farry Taues... 1 75 All the above volumes have been collected by Mr. Jacobs, and contain illustrations from the pen of Mr. Batten, whose work is now so famillar to children on both sides of the Atlantic. About Women: What Men have said. An Every Day Book. Compiled and arranged by ROSE PORTER. 16mo, ornamental cloth covers, $1.00. American Song. A Collection of Representative American Po- ems, with Aualytical and Critical Studies of their Writers Edited by A. B. Simonps. 12mo, cloth, $1.50. The Wind in the Clearing. Poems by RoBERT CAMERON ROGERS. 12mo, cloth, $1.25. Descriptive prospectuses of the “Stories of the Na- tions” and the ** Heroes of the Nations,” and quar- terly “Notes,” giving full descriptions of the sea- son's publications, sent on application. G.P.Putnam’sSons NEW YORK AND LONDON. [Vol. 59 No. 1534 NEW AND ATTRACTIVE BOOKS PUBLISHED BY Joseph Knight Company, No. 196 Summer Street, Boston. The Innocents Abroad; Or. The New Pilgrims’ Progress, by MARK Twain. New Edition. Fully illustrated with thirty photogravure illustrations of scenery, cities, and architecture, visit- ed by the author and his fellow pilgrims on their fa- mous excursion to Europe and the Holy Land fn 1867. 2 vols., crown 8vo, cloth, gilt tops, in cloth box, $5.00, or half levant morocco, gilt, gilt tops, $9 00. Hypatia ; Or, New Foes with an Old Face, by CHARLES KINGSLEY. New Edition. With two photogravure frontispieces and twenty-eight full-page half-tone i'lustrations, and many illustrations in the text. 2 vols.,crown 8vo, cloth, gilt tops, $4.00, or half levant morocco, gilt, gilt tops, $7.50. Lorna Doone. By R. D. BuackmoreE. The only complete illustrated edition. With a wealth of illustration, comprising over two hundred beautiful text illustrations and thirty photogravures from original photographs of Devon and Somerset scenery. 2 volumes, crown 0c- tavo, in green silk or white cloth and cloth jacket, gilt tops, $6.00; or in half levant morocco, gilt tops, $10.00. Some Old Time Beauties. By THomson WILLING. Ten sketches, biographic and literary, of distinguished beauties and ladies of rank of the Georgian Era. Illustrated in photogravure from the original portraits by Sir Joshua Reynolds, Sir Thomas Lawrence, Romney, and Gainsborough, with cover, decorative borders, title-page, half titles, and tail-pieces by the author. One volume, small quarto, size 7x9, bound in cloth, gilt top, with pho- togravure design on side, 83,00. Romance Switzerland. Teutonic Switzerland. By WitiiaM D. McCrackan, M.A., author of “The Rise of the Swiss Republic.” 2 volumes, 32mo, cloth, gilt tops, per set, $1.50. The Same. Illustrated Edition. With twelve photogravure illus- trations of Swiss scenery in each volume. 2 volumes, 82mo, white cloth and china silk. gilt tops,or green cloth, handsome gilt sides, gilt tops, per set, $3.00. A Sentimental Journey Through France and Italy. By LAURENCE STERNE. II- lustrated by Maurice Leloir. Witb twelve full-page photogravures and numerous photo-engravings. One volume, 16mo, daintily bound, cloth, full gilt, gilt top, $1.50. The Abbe Constantin. By Lupovic HAaLevy. Illustrated by Madeleine Lemaire. With eighteen full-page photogravures and eighteen half-tone illustrations. One volume, 16mo. daintily bound, cloth, full gilt, gilt top, $1.50. Pipe and Pouch. The Smoker’s Own Book of Poetry. Compiled by Jo- SEPH KNIGHT. With frontispiece illustration in half- tone. One volume, square 16mo, ornamental cloth binding, gilt top, $1.25; or full Havana colored leath- er, flexible, round corners, gilt edges, 82 50. The Same. Large-paper Edition. Limited to 250 signed coptes. Printed on Van Gelder hand-made paper, with pho- togravure frontispiece from Meissonier’s ‘“ The Smoker.” One volume, 12mo, uncut edges, net, $3.00. This somewhat unique volume of collected verse is the result of many years’ gleaning from a great varie- ty of sources of all the best verse devoted to praise of the weed. It will bea matter of surprise to most read- ers to find how much has been written that is clever and bright on the theme of smoking. From the time of Raleigh and Spenser to the present day, not only the writers of lighter verse, but the more dignified of the poets, have turned aside to sing of what one of the old- est of them called “ The Plant of Great Renown.” A complete illustrated catalogue of our publications mailed free to any address. Our books are for sale by booksellers, or will be sent post or express paid on re- ceipt of price. JOSEPH KNIGHT COMPANY, No. 196 Summer Street, Boston, Aaiee ny Seraaaie Fb. Saget

Page 29

Nov. 22, 1894] A.C. Armstrong & Son’s HOLIDAY BOOKS. JUST PUBLISHED. History of Art in rimitive Greece, MYCENIAN ART. By GEORGES PERROT and CHARLES CHIPIEZ. With 564 Illustrations. Two vols., imperial 8vo, uniform with ‘* /7is- tory of Art in Ancient Eqypt,” “ ITis- tory of Artin Chaldea and Assyria, “History of Art in: Phanicia,” “Iis- tory of Art in Sardinia, Judaa, Sy- ria,and Asia Minor,” “History of Art inPhrygia, Lydia and Caria, Lycia, Persia.” Handsomely bound in cloth, gilt top, $15.50: three-quarter crushed levant morocco, $22.50. This New Work is the sixth in the Series by these distinguished writers on the ‘* History of Ancient Art,’’ the iv previous works having achieved reimcark- able success and being accepted by the Highest Authorities as the Standard Works on the Subjects. This great history is, in many respects the mo tim portant contribution of modeen tines to the literature of artandare)eology. As it progresses its value be comes more and more apparent. The illustrations are admirable as illustrative ar’, and abundant to bring the descriptive text within the comprehension of the ordinary reader, as well as the student. The value of these works to every reader of history, whether of mankind or of what man has produced, consists in the fact that we have here fromaschoar of the first rank (and none holds higher rank than Perrot) the results, in digested form, of the extensive contributions of knowle ige made by Layard, Rawlinson, Loftus, George Smith, Lenormant, Maspero, Oppert,and a host of other distinguished laborers in the fleld. THE COMPLETE WORKS OF Edgar Allan Poe. With a Memoir and an introduction on the Genius of Poe. BY RICHARD H. STODDARD. Messrs. Armstrong & Son have the pleasure of announcing that they have now ready A NEW EDITION of Poe’s Works, in six tastefully printed volumes, to be known as The Fordham Edition. {LLUSTRATIONS.—The Fordham Edition coutains etchings from GIFFORD. CHURCH, PLATT, PENNELL, and other artists, also a portrait on steel of Poe, and a Japan proof illustration of the Cottage at Fordham, made especialiy for this edition, while there are added facsimiles of the first draft of ‘**The Bells,” and a number of facsimile let- ters. The Etchings are printed upon India paper in the best possible manner. BINDING.—The set is bound in an attractive and durable cloth binding, uncut edges, gilt top. Price for the set, in a neat b x, $7.5 Also bound in half calf, extra, at 33 per vol Copies mailed, postpaid, on rece tpt of price, dy A. C. ARMSTRONG & SON, 51 East 10th St. Near Broadway), N.Y. The Nation. England in the Nineteenth | Century By Elizabeth Wormeley Latimer, author of ‘* France in the Nineteenth Century, etc. Handsomely illustrated with twen- ty-seven half-tone portraits of celebrat ed characters. S8vo, $2.50. Readers of Mrs. Latimer’ 8 previo vusly published books, “France in the Nineteenth Ce ntury" ‘and “ Russia and Turkey tn the Ninet-« th Century,” will welccme tois volume. It is written in the same clear, fascinating style, and, like them, will take bigh rank in popular historical Hterature By Marguerite Bouvet, author of ** Sweet William,”’ ** Prince Tip Top,” ete. With illustrations and cover-design by Mar garet and Helen Armstrong. 81.25 This ts a delightful story for adults from the same au thor who has already charmed the thousands who have read her favorite crildren’s stories, “Sweet Willfam,” “ Prince Tip Top,” ete. It ts a fine example of the power to tell a tale of tender love in pure Saxon English . . . Reminiscences of a Portrait . Painter By G. P. A. Healy. With illustrations after the original paintings by Mr. Healy. 12mo, 221 pages. $1.50. “ There is, to use a hackneved expression, not a dull paze in this book. Notonly was Mr. Healy's own life interesting, but, as be has painted more well known people than almost any other recent painter, he has a fund of geminiscence and anecdote to draw upon which is simply extraordinary.”’—Jeannette L. Gilder oe In Bird Land A Book for t Keyser. ‘I have read your book with great p pone You are one of the few who write what they see 1nd do not draw on their imagination, nor on the od ‘books Olive Thorne Milier, in a letter to the Author sird-Lovers. By Leander S. l6mo, 269 pages, $1.25 Tales from the 4E¢ean By Demetrios Bikélas. Translated by Leonard E. Opdycke. With an intro duction by Henry A. Huntington. 31.00. Mr. Bikelas is perhaps the most popula* living author in his own land, and his name is a household wort among all who take an interest in the modern Greeks of these eight tales some are sad, some imbued with a gentle humor, and all are pure and refined in renti ment. Their ¢ speci al value lies in the realistic pictures they paintof Greek life in our own times For sale by booksellers ceneral!l hi ; A. ©, Mc CLU RG A. C. McClurg & Co.'s The Crucifixion of Vil New Hibelis Jewish Tales Translated from the French of Leopold von Sacher Masoch by Harriet Lieber Cohen. Imo, 317 pages, &1.00 These highly entertsiaing prose tdyls -racy piquant spirited—have already attained great France, and thei ir realistic pk tures of Jews mh the good olé times, both in its com'c and serious aspects } will assure them a warm welcome here The Price of Peace A Storv of the Times of Ahab King of Israel. By A. W. Ackerman. &1.25. This book will be found intensely interesting because of the light it throws oa an eventful 1 tt ’ ats rv of the people of I+rae! The interest t« greativ « hanced by the exquisitely pure lowe-stery that ts inter woven with the stircing hist rical ever Philip Strong A Novel. By Charles M. Sheldos st A novel of unusual tnterest and t ~~, t deais with the Cour neoxtern » ‘ 1 aut sees and clearly pres e tit thes w t i way of a man honestly determined to do hts duty live and act as he belleves Christ won frm ity and act Things of the Mind By the Rt. Rev. J. L. Spalding, Bishop of Peoria, author of “Education and iligher Life,’ ete., ete. l2me, 81.00 Bishop Spaldirg t owen fe and w in a delightfully cle ty t} ture, Religton, anc Sana VS Mf ‘ are all too rare, \ » te are r tendency to draw the 1 1 fr t cs things spiritual The Power of an Endless Life book ar ;war Woman in Epigram Flashes of Wit. Wisd . al } Satire fr m the Wor Literature. Compiled by Frederick W. Morton. 1I6mo, $1.00 A book of opinions, guesses, and aphorteams about women, by themselves and by mir The re uit is an interesting. amusing, an? edifving ction of eu terances of the "ben minds on the pest sensi sub jects Mary Abbott in rh icago Herald & CO., CHicaco. LITTELL’S LIVING AGE A Weekly Magazine of FOREIGN PERIODICAL LITERATURE. Giving 3300 Double-Column Octavo Pages of Matter Uncqualled in Quality and Quantity. The Ablest Minds of the Age » rites male Contribute to make this period Encyclopedic in Scope, Character, Completeness, ry elaiseiasieaiitiias INDISPENSABLE TO EVERY READER OF INTELLIGENCE AND LITERARY TASTE. +. ENCES The Thirteen Weekly Issues THE LIVING AGE (Oct... Nov.., Dec. 1Scq), forming an octavo Volume of S24 pages, at iA ba a s Subscrip- tion to any one of the g publications ~plication. Sample iS, 35 Cts. each. i The Cosmopolitan, Domestic Monthly, McClure’s Magazine, Midiand Monthly, Godey's Magazine, or a 6 months subscription to Scribner's Magazine. Published Weekly at $8. © a year, free of postage Add-ess LIFTELL & CO.. 31 To each NEW subscriber remitting $S.co for 1895 will be sent ABSOLUTELY FREE ee Our Day, Christian Nation, S. S. Times, Golden Rule, The Pulpit, Rates for clubbin y with other periodicals sent on dford Street, Boston. sa AN Nigh: Aen OS PAOD ME) ng 00 mecbe i Pomme ee ee. ee eS baeaciicting dalle Frases" taka a ale, sibel OT ene

Page 30

ce Se ee ae

a

The Nation. [Vol. 59, No. 1534

B. WESTERMANN & CO., (LEMCKE & BUECHNER] BooKSELLERS AND IMPORTERS, 812 Broadway, New York. JUST READY. CATALOGUE RAISONNE Of German Belles-Lettres containing the Classics, their contemporaries, and the best modern fiction, with critical notes as to the comparative merits of different editions, as well as the literary standing of the authors and a list of ENGLISH TRANSLATIONS OF GERIIAN BOOKS, being hints for selecting the German Library of a man of culture. sag riptions for Foreign and American Pertodi- cals, UNMOUNTED PHOTOGRAPHS of Ancient aud Modern Works of Art, —— tions of famous paintings, sculpture,and architecture, with views from all parts of the world. Send 15 cents for catalogues of 14,000 subjects. List of World’s Fair Views and Art at the Fair now ready. Lantern slides made to order from any of our subjects. Photograph Mounting in Albums or on cards a specialty. Albums supplied. Soule Photograph Co.. 334 Wash’n St., Boston Pr rincipal Fo mem New York, E. P. Dutton & Co., 31 W. 23d St.; Chicago, M. O’Brien & Son, 208 Wabash Ave.; 5 Philadelphia. J. A MeClees & Co., 1417 7 Chestnut St.

LONDON, PARIS. LEIPZIG. NEW YORK. GUSTAV E. STECHERT, Importer of Books and Periodicals, 810 BROADWAY, NEW YORK.

Large stock of Foreign Books, new as well as rare and acarce, and sets of Periodicals. Subscriptions to Periodicals for 1895 now received. Lowest rates, quick delivery. Send for Catalogue. BRANCHES: London: 30 Wellington Street, Strand, W. C. Paris: 76 Rue de Rennes. Leipzig: 10 Hospital Strasse. JAMES G. BLAINE. We have just secured a small eapaiey of James G. Blaine’s ‘Twenty Yearsin Congress.’ The work is eel plete in two royal octavo volumes of about 700 pages each, printed from new geewowype plates on superfine book paper, bound in fine English muslin, marbled edges. Published by Henry Bill Publishing Co., Nor- wich, Conn. Original price, $750 Our price for the two volumes, $3.50. Mention the Nation. Leary’s Old Bookstore, No. 9 South Ninth St., (First Store below Market St.) PHILADELPHIA. Zf you want FRENCH BOOKS, or books of any description—School Books, Standard Books, Novels, etc.—send to WILLIAM R. JENKINS, Publisher and Importer, 851 and 853 SIXTH AVENUE (48th Street), NEW YORK. Catalogue on application. Importations promptly made. F. W. CHRISTERN, (DYRSEN & PFEIFFER, Suc’rs), 254 Fifth Ave., between 28th and 29th Sts., New York, Importers of Foreign Books; Agents for the leading Paris Publishers, ‘auchnitz’s British Authors, Teub- ner’s Greek and Latin Classics. Catalogues of stock mailed on demand. A large assortment always on hand, and new books received from Paris and Leipzig as soon as issued.

To Librarians, ‘Book- Lovers, and Booksellers. Our NEW CATALOGUE of RARE and CHOICE BOOKS, comprising works on architecture, biography, belles- lettres, the drama, first editions, mays peg rare French books, works of art, etc., -» Will be sent, post- paid, upon request. ¢2™ Attention is called to this valuable collection. BRENTANO’S, 81 Union Square, New York. MEYER BROS. & CO., 18 WEST 24TH ST., NEW YORK. FRENCH BOOKS, FRENCH CALENDARS, AND CHRISTMAS CARDS. Send for our new Catalogue of FINE BOOKS, Bind- ings, Original Drawings, Autographs. _ ie West 24th St. (Madison Square). American Magazines, Newspapers, and Journals The Cosmopolitan @ $1.50 per year. Best magazine issued in America. The Division Visitor, @ 50 cents per year. Best non-partisan and non-sectarian tem remce paper. Ask us to quote on your wants. Men vation. AMERICAN PRINTING AND NEWS Coempanry _1111 ARCH S8T., PHILADELPHIA, P

BAC ACK numbers and sets of all magazines. For x ee state wants to MAGAZINE EXCHANGE, Schoharie, N. Y.

DIRECT IMPORTATIONS. Catalogue, Ten Thousand Subjects, 10c. C. H. DUNTON & CO., 136 BOYLSTON STREET, BOSTON. BOOKS por aa — a : JEN AWAY Paper %cuces AT with every pure phe ole gs 4 LIBERAL quotations. books write for assortment of catalogues D | SCO U NTS aiid sp ecial slips of books at re- Geced prices sent for 1Qc. stamp. F. E. GRANT, Books, 7 West 42d Street. New York. __ Mention this advertiseme nt and rec eive a disc ount, pore Photographs

A catalogue of VALUABLE EN- NT GLISH BOOKS—new and fresh— at half price, and a catalogue of CHOICE OLD BOOKS at greatly FREE reduced prices. Send your address on a postal card. : 801 Washington Street, ESTES & LAURIAT, 355. Singita BOSTON. ARCHITECTURE. A copy of the scarce and beautiful edition of VITRUVIUS Is offered for sale. Folio, vellum, many quaint old full- page and half- page p plates. initial- letters, head and tail- pieces; Como, 1 GEORGE P. HUMPHREY 25 Exchange St., Rochester, N. Y. RARE. | ENGRAVINGS, PORTRAITS phn < For Extra Illustrating. B . Catalogues free on application. ° E. F. BONAVENTURE’S Book Annex, Next to his Art Rooms. 45-47 W. 31st Street, corner Broadway. THE BOOK-LOVER’S ALIMANAC FOR THE YEAR 1895, $3.00. DUPRAT & CO., 349 5TH AVE., N.Y. HE MOST INTERESTING PLACE in New York is PRATT’S BOOKSTORE e — opinion.) 6th Ave, 12th St., N.Y

Ee to foreign Ps: Reatis C Zon ere rlodteals, Tanchnitz British ithors. Catalogues on ap- Plication. CARL soncamnos, 23 School St., Boston.

rd N-AMERICAN IMMIGRATION. — The latest statistics tabulated. By Rena Michaels Atchison. $1.25. CHARLES H. Kerr & Co. Pubs., Chi- cago. H WILLIAMS, 195 WEST 10TH ST., » N. Y.,dealer in Magazines and other periodicals. Sets, volumes, or single numbers.

School Agencies. CHERMERHORN’S TEACHERS’ Agency. A and best known in the U.S. Established 1855. 8 East 14th St., N. Y. HE BRIDGE TEACHERS’ AGEN- cies, 110 Tremont St., Boston, and 211 Wabash Ave., Chicago. Agency Manual free to any address. MERICAN AND FOREIGN TEACH- ers’ Bureau. Miss GRACE POWERS THOMAS, M’g’r, 8 Park Street, Boston, Mass.

/ A az is valuable in proportion to its A 4 Agency influence. If it merely hears of vacancies and tells Th 1 t is something, but if you about them ¢ it is asked to recom- mend a teacher and recom- mends you, ete is more Ours Recommends - BARDEEN, Syracuse, N. Y. G l d’ 1A REFERENCE BOOK Ou S for Editors, General Scientists, Libraries, Illustrated Newspaper Offices, ta Biologists, Chemists, Dictionary Physicians, Dentists, oF Druggists, Lawyers. Medicine, Biology) pemi Quarto, over 1600 pages,

AND Half Morocco, . . Net, $10.00 Half Russie, Thumb Allied Sciences. | Index,...... Net, $12.00 Ba Samples of pages and illustrations free. P. BLAKISTON, SON & CO., 1012 WALNUT STREET, PHILADELPHIA Heath’s UWlodern Language Certs CINQ MARS. By De Vieny. The greatest historical novel of France, W ith elaborate and scholarly introduction and notes, Should be read by all interested in French Litera- ture. Cloth. Introduction prive, 80 cents. D. C. HEATH & CO., Publishers, BOSTON, NEW YORK, CHICAGO. The School Review.® The December number will contain Se full report of the CONFERENCE OF THE NEW GLAND ASSO CIATION OF COLLEGES AND PREPARATORY SCHOOLS, with important addresses by PRES. ELIOT, -~ many others. ol. III. begins January, 1894. New subscribers from that date may receive the December issue free. $1.50 ayear. Address **THE SCHOOL REVIEW,’’ Hamilton, N. Y. LANGUAGES MASTERED in 10 WEEKS Part I. (3 Lessons), either language, sent for 25c MEISTERSCHAFT BUREAU, Boston, Mass. FRENCH, GERMAN, SPANISH, ITALIAN. ig We make a specialty of hunting OLD BOOKS up old books and magazines. We buy large and small libraries for cash. If you want anything in the book line write to us. Monthly list of old, rare, and curious books free. THE PHILADELPHIA BOOK CLEARING-HOUSE, 144 N. 7th St., Philadelphia, Pa. A. KOEHL E R & CO. Foreign Booksel- i lers and Import- ers, 149A Lier wgag 4 Street, Boston, Mass. Subscriptions to Periodicals. egular importations from Leipzig, Paris, London, ¥.., auchnitz British Authors, etc. RARE | PRINTS—AUTOGRAPHS. Catalogues Issued Continuall BOOKS. | W.E. - BENJAMIN. 22 E. 16th St., St., New vew York,

PAPER BY THE POUND and env . Greater quan- tity, lower price than by quire. eee, 2 all grades, — marked, on receipt of Ry WM. R. JENKINS ne stationery, 851-53 Sixth Ave. (48th St.), N. Y. ‘Ge TALOGUE OF 1,900 BRAND NEW items, selected from the Literary Junk Shop of A.S. CLARK, Bookseller, 834 Park Row, N. Y., now ready.

GOLDEN SCEPTRE. PERFECTION FOR THE PIPE. Send 40 cents for 4-0z. sample to SURBRUG, 159 Fulton St., N. Y. City.

ae

Page 31

oe Nov. 2 22, 1 1894] WORKS BY PROFESSOR MARSHALL. The Frog. An Introduction to Auatomy, History, and Embryology. By A. MILNES MARSHALL. Fifth Edition. 1l6mo. Illustrated. $1.25. = Ww ill be extremely useful to all students of biolo- gy- A valuable, clear, and masterful exposi tion. *— Nature. ’ 4 Vertebrate Embryology A Text-Book for Students and Practitioners. By A. MILNES MarsHaut, M.D., D.Sc., M.A., F.R.S. Fully illustrated. 8vo, $6.00. “It iscertainly the best text-book for students’ use and dealing with vertebrate embryology known to mein any language. It is ad: upted in the most satis factory manner to guide practical laboratory work. I admire both the clearness and accuracy of ‘the au thor’s descriptions.” —Charles S. Minot, Professor of Histology and Human Embryology, Harvard Uni versity. “We recommend the work with confidence to students and practitioners. ‘Ihe presentation of the subject is exceedingly clear, and the illustra tions are throughout good.’’— Medical Chronicle A Junior Course of Practical Zoology. By A. MILNES MARSHALL, assisted by C. HERBERT Hurst, Ph.D. Third Edition, Revised. With additional Illustrations. Crown 8vo, 33.50. The work is in plan and execution admirable; memaed the best books if not the very best of its serge ‘~Edinburgh Medical Journal, ‘A most successful and important treatise. The eteeiomn are excellent and the work is presented ina form which demands our grateful acknowledg ment.”’— Nature. G.P.Putnam’sSons 27 and 29 West 23d St., New York. e@ i ar nate) “onstable Ko, Co, LYONS SILKS. Muscovite, Peau de Daim, Gros de Londre, Poult de Sotc Brocades, Chine Taffetas, Motre Miroir, Moire Granite, Moire Antique, Colored Satins. RICH WHITE FABRICS FOR WEDDING GOWNS. Crepes and Crepons for Bridesmaid’s Dresses, Grenadines and Gazes Satin Antique Glace Velvets, Fancy Velvets. Sroadeoay RH 19th ot. NEW YORK. The Nation. he Modependent. NEW YORK. The Leading Religious and Literary Weekly Newspaper of the Wor gens INDEPENDENT maintains a high standard, and furnishes a newspaper un surpassed in the variety, quality, and quantity of the literature it offers, in the representative character of its contributors, and in the breadth, ability, and vigor of its editorial discussions During the past year THE INDEPENDENT has printed 1,050 columns of reading matter, equivalent in octavo volumes to Bancroft’s com plete ‘‘ History of the United States” twice over, With three volumes to spare. It has printed during the same time over 200 original poems, from the pens of the leading American, English, and Canadian poets. It gives a complete religious history of tbe times, in addition to full reports of all impor- tant religious assemblages at home and abroad It prints fresh letters from all mission fields throughout the world. Its yearly subscription is $3.00, or at that rate for any part of a year. Two years, $5.00. Clubs of five, $2.00 each. Specimen copies free THE INDEP! reiastenel as r.9 Box 2787, 7730 fi wifon A a Ver V e Christmas (December) Number OF THE | Pall Mall Magazine Edited by LORD FREDERIC HAMILTON, MP., and SIR DOUGLAS STRAIGHT. PRICE, 25 CENTS. This special number surpasses everything yet achieved by the Pull Mail Magazine. Considerably larged for the occasion, and beautifully printed ont finest paper, it contains contributions from many fn mous authors, and a profusion of un istrations fre leading artists, including several uperb full-page plates. Amongst the special features is a series of colored illustr: tions to a hunting poem entitled * The Fox of the Priory Whin,’’ and _ ** Notable Portraits of the Queen,"’ Edited by Her Majesty at Balmoral Other contributions by H. Riper Ha GARD, Wal TER BESANT, W. WALDORF ASTOF R. 8 HICHENS, GUY BooTHuey, Gen. Lort L. ALDEN, “ Q,"’ HAMILTON AIDE, ete., etc ‘The Faull Mall Magazine marks the high-water of present day magazine achievement. It reserves Us pages for the very best literature the martet can s ply. und m ane score of expense allows nothing to sw pass it, Th otsma m the Christmas N 1893 Editorial Officea—18 Charing Cross Road, London, W.C.; Publishing Offices—London 18 Charing Cross Road, W. ¢C.; New York, The International News Co., New York: Toronto, The Toronto News (¢ Mon treal, The M mtreal News Co. K nage TUNEQUALLED IN New ¥ a 22 and 24k re 48 Sth Ave. near 20th St \ tor 7 Market Space -H. He UPHAM: &-CO- VIEMORIAL > TABLETS ° -IN- BRASS: AND- BRONZE - i j | j | | } | F | 1X HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO.'S NEW BOOKS The Oliver Wendell Holmes ‘Year Book. Selections from Dr. Holmes’s prose and poet ry, for Every na of the Year. With a fine portrait. Attractively bound. 16mo, $1.00 Talk ata Country House. Interesting imaginary co nversatic ns, at an English country house, on famous Eaglish men, English so ‘iety, politics, and literature Assyrian inscriptions, ete Ry Sir Epwarp STRACHEY With a portrait and engraved title pty tien » gril tt Top, S125 Religious Progress. A small book on a large subject treated with admirable learning, rare breadth of view, and a finely tolerant spirit. By A. V. WG. ALLEN, auther of The Continuity of Christian Thought 16n ”) a The Great Refusal : Letters fi ma Dreamer in Gotham A ro mance in which the sentiment ts erished mostly by the *‘dreamet . writes in ad mirab stvle of many interesting things be ides love. By Pa KE. Mor n Blu A Story of Courage: Annals of the Cony f the Visitation at ( I tow ie: ii as «6P al vs La Hi I m and Ros i eeeeees RNE Lia THRO With ilhistra s Y S20 N iv ‘ sty ? ‘ \ ‘ \ ~ , * ~ — \ gin ¥ v ‘ t K is valua aS - x . aa * ar si { t 8 x f tut st Protestants as _— as Cat s, ar a rou! % w i V Hymns and Verses. By Samut LONGF Ww wa, STs s ev. s w's a . , 7 a st . “ . " cerly w ‘ \ . ‘ . ss rat HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO., Boston, 11 East 17th Street, New York. “After reading tits fasct- nating story for girls we wondering whether a new Miss Alcott may not be about to enter the ranks of our writers for voung people. Not since the days of ‘ The Old-lFash- toned Girl’ have we read SHOE Qj tre sh.7 rn Wo rf SONNE, ana vet Lively an a tnite ve esting stor V. stor s fail of i and life id has ty { x ‘ t i The book is re k ts i liv re tou ster’s family and the unsel fish wife ar mother are all tou i with tenderness, ar on t story a charm wh readers of all ages aj says tt Transcript of | Amethe or Girl’s Experience. LEIGH WEBSTER. 4 story for girls. Illustrated by JESSIE MeDermotr. I6mo. Cloth. 1.25, ROBERTS bs, Publishers, RAG DOLLS Settee? nt by mail, Lane d Apply to 107 Market Street. Be thie hem, Pa. pgp ORL AD te CS OS he crite PCR RAN ey AU Tee AS BRM me 2 weer ene, Seite catti PaR able simi ak we yO mine «Whi

Page 32

i ng ld Ta Bi hee os

x The Nation. [Vol. 59, No. 1534

GINN & COMPANY PUBLISH: ETHICAL SERIES. |The Philosophical Review. Under the editorial supervision of Professor E. HERSHEY SNEATH of Yale University. A Bi-mouthly Journal of General Philosophy. The primary object of the series is to facilitate the study of Edited by J.G. Scuurman, Dean of the Sage School of Philoso- the History of Ethics in Colleges. This History will be in the phy and President of Cornell University, and J. E. Creiau- form of a series of small volumes, each devoted to the presenta- ron, Associate Professor of Modern Philosophy in Cornell tion of a representative system of Modern Ethics in selections University. Subscription price, $3.00. Single copy, 75 cents. trom the origiast works. THE PHILOSOPHICAL REVIEW is intended as an organ for the publication of the results of investigation in every ALREADY PUBLISHED: branch of Philosophy. It is made up of original articles, re- THE ETHICS OF HUME views of books, and classified summaries of periodical literature. By Dr. J. H. Hystop of Columbia College. 12mo. Cloth. 275 ators pages. Introductory price, $1.00. i s Leading Articles for November. THE ETHICS OF HEGEL. I. The Consciousness of Moral Obligation, By J. MacBripeSrerrett, D.D., of Columbian University. 12mo. President J. @. Sohurman Cloth. 216 pages. Introductory price, $1.00. II. Hegel’s Conception of Freedom, Professor S. W. Dyde lati f Hume’s Treatise and Inquiry The following Vilumes are in Preparation: aE. Seeemon sas> DD tonics, Romance Languages, Mathematics, istory or H ’ " he pen mae neg — y. Full a and graduate Courses in these departments and in Pbi- CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS, 153-157 Fifth Ave., N.Y. § | andstatuate Coursés in these departments and tn Pat . guages For General Program or Graduate Pamphlet, address Bryn Mawr College, Pa.

ONL NS

a i i ie

Page 33