The Nation 1894-10-25: Vol 59 Iss 1530

Page 1

‘The Nation | ; hy VOL. LIX—NO. 1530. THURSDAY, OCTOBER 25, 1894. "ee os» PRICE 10 CENTS Jay” Pee Y é Je Oa Up Harper’s Magazine | Harper & Brothers’ NOVEMBER. LATEST BOOKS. 166 Pages. Now Ready. seas Trilby. A Nov The Sea-Robbers of New York. By THomas A. Jan- ae Peter viER. With 5 Illustrations by Howarp Pye. — — Au — : ’ (Righty-titth A Painter’s Impressions of Rajpootana. By Evw:n | Portraits in Plaster. Lorp Weeks. With 14 Illustrations by the Author. RENCE Hurron. W per 8vo, Cloth, Ornan The Cossack as Cowboy, Soldier, and Citizen, By | pi) a6 oo PouLTNEY BicgeLow. With rr Illustrations by Fre- ee DERIC REMINGTON,

| Wealth against Commonwealth. | MAREST Lioyp. Svo, Cloth, $2.5 A Sister of the Annunciation. A Story. By Mar- Wimples and Crisping Pins. GUERITE MERINGTON. fure and Ornaments \\ | At the Capital of the Young Republic. By Henry | Cuitp, Author t 2 Art Loomis Netson, With 5 Illustrations by T. pt ‘THULSTRUP, sire of Be auty, mental, Uncut Edges a | Sir Robert’s Fortune. On the Trail of the Wild Turkey. By Cuartrs D.!|) pHanr. Post Svo. Cloth. oy LANIER, With 4g Illustrations by A. B. Frosr. & SROEEAONS UY The Boy Travellers in the Levant. People We Pass: II. The Lineman’s Wedding. }\ wo Youth piveded page saan M Jutran RaAvpu. With 3 Illustrations by Ciirrorp | CARLETON, The Golden House. A Story. By Cuartes Dupiry, S¥o. © WARNER. (Conclusion.) With 6 Illustrations by | English Literature. W. TT. SMEDLEY. | for Se M.A., The Interlude. A Story. By Grace KINo. C Graham’s Voice. A Story. By Ewan Macrpnerson, A Little English Gallery. NEY. With Portrait. 1 The Religion of the Sioux. By Lieut. Wittam H. | the Series © Har er’s A WassELL, U.S. A. With 5 Illustrations. /U 9 “is Bible Stories for Young reaps Jonathan Holt’s « Third.’””, A Story. By Joan Garp- Henry ©. Porrer, DD, t NER, HRs! Others. Full-page Illustration. By Grorcr pu Maurier. $1.00. Hightané Cous sin h ae Editor’s Drawer. With Introductory Story by THo 4 = t NELSON PAGE. mental, $1.75. Editor’s Study. By Cuarries Dupiey Warner. ‘ : On Cloud Mountain. A \ Literary Notes. By Laurence Hurroy. -ne-Ciser Poet < ne aaron eee eee Published by HARPER & BROTHERS, NEW YORK. Booksellers and Postmasters usually tions sent direct to the publ ishers should he acm panted y Postofie The ahor i ef? eale by tll booksellers, or will be sent by the pu Va mey Order or Draft 1h. y tin is sper et vdaecrypt as will Aegin yahers. pasface prepaid wert of the United States, Canada, or Meri wot ; | } paid | with the caednd Waaia tak Fostaes o ali aubacribers in the | ted States, i receipt price “Hanre ER's CATALOGUE will he sent to any addreas Canada, and Me.rice

prenrigntne reeves anaes eae wane en OR ae TE eet NAP SA NO BEL ALAN NIT MAE

Page 2

ret ee The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science, and Art, FOUNDED 1 (Entered at the New York City Post-Office as second-class mail-matter. CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. THE WEEE... ccccccccccccccccccccccccescece ovecveseeses 295 EpiroriaL ARTICLES : The Test OF Meperiemes. .....cccccccccsevecccccss seve 208 Private and Public Morality....................005. 298 Mr. Mortan’s COMCRMAD..........sccccccecee coove 209 NT >. Tear er 300 EE EN 055 os wecweccecsociecensess 301 James Anthony Froude, ..........0.sccceeeeseeeenes 802 SPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE : Carducel at San Marino...............-sseeceeeseees 303 Some Continental Libraries............c.sscseseeees 305 CORRESPONDENCE : EE oct sunk nccn5evenevongnieonoengococsesesecenacanes 306 Romaic and Greek.........cceccessoccs sevccsecvees 806 sik sede diesen osdtnesbeseveninessncccs acseens sovsves BOO Book REVIEWS: I COR HE. oo ceccccescesccecccevescssnvenses 809 SP Ne COG MIOUTOIB snc ovcccvccccvecsvecensscs 810 Life and Letters of Erasmus ...............sseeseees 812 Essays on Historical Chemistry....... ... .-. 312 Chinese Characteristics............ . 813 Diary of Anna Green Winslow Witnesses to the Unseen.......... ‘ RO SR TN Wes vk wo kn cococcrccsencvensescevesess 314 TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three Dollars per year in advance, postpaid, to any part of the United States or Canada; to foreign coun- tries comprised in the Postal Union, Four Dollars. The date when the subscription exptresis on the Ad- dress- Label of each paper, the change of which to a sub- sequent date becomes a receipt for remittance. No other receipt is sent unless requested. Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter or by check, express order, or postal order, payable to “Publisher of the NaTION.” Whera change of address is desired, both the old and new addresses should be given. Address THE NATION, Box 794, New York. Publication Office, 208 Broadway. TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Fifteen cents per agate line, each insertion, 14 lines to the inch. Twenty per cent. advance for choice of page, top of column, or cuts. Cuts are not inserted on the first page. A column, $20 each insertion; with choice of page, $24. A page, $60 each insertion; front cover page, $80. Advertisements must be acceptable in every respect. Copy received until Tuesday, 5 P. M. Discounts on application. The NATION is sent free to those who advertise in it, as long as advertisement continues. The EDITION of the NATION this week ts 9,250 copies. The Subscription List is always open to the in- spection of advertisers. To ‘ilewiats: ‘Book: Lovers, “and Booksellers. Our NEW CATALOGUE of RARE and CHOICE BOOK8, comprising works on architecture, biography, belles- lettres, the drama, first editions, Shakespeariana, rare French books, works of art, etc., etc., will be sent, post paid, upon request. we Attention is called to this Vv pinainte collection, BRENTANO 81 Daten ‘Square. New York. R. RE ENGRAVINGS, PORTRAITS For Extra Illustrating. Bi )( KS we Catalogues free on application. E. F. BONAVENTURE’S Book Annex, Next to his Art Rooms, 5-47 W. 31st Street, corner Broadway. ie TOLTAIRE'S ‘P hilosophic al Dictionary, Voltaire’s ‘ Novels,’ Buchner’s * Force and Matter’ Montesquieu’s ‘Spirit of Laws PRATT, 6th Ave., 12th St. N. Y. ( “4 TALOGUE OF 1,900 BRAND NEW - items selected from the Literary Junk Shop of . 8. CLARK, Bookseller, 34 Park Row, N. Y., now ready. Hs WILLIAMS, 195 WEST 10TH aT. N. Y., dealer in Magazines and other periodicals. Sets, volumes, or single numbers. The Nation. Educ ational. CaLrroryiA, Los Angeles, West 23d Street. ARLBOROUGH SCHOOL for GIRLS. Mrs. Gro. A. Caswait, Pejncipal. Connscricur, New Haven, 56 Hillhouse ‘Avenue. EST END INSTITUTE. §chool for pares for any college. Circulars. Early appl ca- tion 2 yh e ADY and Miss C. E. Capy, Principals. CoNNEcTICUT, Pomfret Centre. MFRET SCHOOL.—A New Church School for Boys will be pened at Pomfret, Octo- ber 3. For all information, addre: Witttam E. Prec, Head Master. ConnecTicuT, Pomfret Centre. HE MISSES VINTON’'S SCHOOL for Girls will reopen Thursday, Sept. 27. Num- ber limited. Connecticut, Waterbury. ‘7. MARGARET'S DIOCESAN Dooeaes and Day ®chool for Girls reopens Sept, 19, The Rev. Francis T. Russell, M.A., Rector. Miss as R. Hillard, Principal. DELAWARE, Wilmington, Franklin Street. HE MISSES HEBBS ENGLISH, rench, and German Boarding and Day School for young ladies and girls reopens Sept. 24, 1804. ILLtnors, Chicago, 708 Chamber 1 Commer YIICAGO COLLEGE OF LA Law Department Lake Forest U + and three year —, For information. address E. E. BARRETT, LL.B., Secretary. ~ LOUISIANA, New Orleans, 247 Pry tania Street. M: F.D. BLAKE AND Mrs L. POLK CHAPMAN’S French and - Boarding and Day School for Girls reopens Oct 1, 1894. Students —— for college. Ample grounds for outdoor exer- cise. Two MARYLAND, Baltimore, 122 and 124 W. Franklin St. Jr BGEWOR TH BOARDINGAND DAY _« School for Young Ladies will reopen Wednesday, September 26. 32d year. Mrs. H. P. enlaces Principal. “MARYLAND, Catonsville. T. TIMOTHY'S ENGLISH, FRENCH ‘ and German School for Young Ladies reopens Sep- tember 20, 1894. Principals: Miss M.C. CARTER, Miss S. R. CARTER. MASSACHUSETTS, Roston, 503 Boylston Street. YAUNCY HALL SCHOOL (School Es- tablished in 1828). For Boys and Girls.—Prepara- tion for the Mass. Institute of Technology ts a specialty. Reference is made to the Institute Faculty. Preparation also for College (with or without Greek) and for business — and Physics are taught by laboratory we Massacnusetts. Bos Be TON UN TER. SITY Law School, Address the Dean, MASSACHUSETTS, Cambridge. EDNUED H. "BENNETT, LL.D. HE CAMBRIDGE SCHOOL for Young Ladies. Mr. ARTHUR GILMAN Is the Director. MASSACHUSETTS, Concord. p ONCORD HOME SCHOOL.—25 BOYS repared for college, sctentific school, or business. All the advantages of family life combined with best mental and physical training. Buildings new and ac- cording to latest models. 75 acres of ground, JAMES S. GARLAND, Principal. MASSACHUSETTS, Duxbury. IWDER POINT SCHOOL. Prepares for Massachusetts Institute of Technolo- gy, Harvard, or Business. Elementary classes for young boys. Laboratories. Individual teaching. Exceptional advantages for home and outdoor life. Fifty bors. F. B. Knapp, S.B. MASSACHUSETTS, Plymouth \ R. KNAPP'S HO. VE SCHOOL FOR J Boys—12 Boys. 27th year. H. W. Royat (Harv.). Head Master Mrs. Knapp, Principal. MASSACHUSETTS, Springfi ny R. AND MRS, VOHN McDUFFIE’'S School for Girls. Formerly Miss How ard’s. ss MASSACHUSETTS, Worcester, 66 West Street. JOHN W. DALZELLS PRIVATE «/ School for Boys —Prepares for College or Scientific School. Send for Catalogue. New York City, 43 West 47th St. lv 7SS WHITON and MISS BANGS— ( English and Classical School. Native teachers in Modern Languages. Certificate admits to Smith, Vassar, and Wellesley. Special care in home and school given to little girls. Gymnasium, New York Crry, 22 East 54th Street. HE MISSES GRINNETLL’S DAY SCHOOL FOR GIRLS reo Kindergarten October 10. Fifteent ns October 4. year. ie vol. ye a 1530 z ver nina NEw YorK CITY, Tist St., at West End Ave. ZAN NORMAN INST.—Founded 1857. Mme. VAN NORMAN, Mrs. J. L. MaTTHEWs, Principal. Vice-Principal. New York City, 55 West 47th Street. Vy TSS GIBBONS’ SCHOOL FOR GIRLS an —Mrs. SARAH H. EMERSON, Prine aot. A few board- ing pupils taken. Reopens Oc tober 3 New York, Uti \ GMD ad Br TT” ‘s SCHOOL FOR GIRLS. —The next school year begins ne Sept. 20, 15894. soe ations should be made early. “Norta AROLINA, Asheville. DAVENSCROFT SCHOOL—PREPA R- atory Boarding and Day School for Boys. Head Master, RONALD McDONALD, B.A. (Oxford), son of George MacDonald. Ounto0, Cincinnati. ] 7SS ARMSTRONG'S SCHOOL FOR LV Girls, Liddesdale Place, Avondale. Family limit- ed. Circulars sent on application. PENNSYLVANIA, Bryn Mawr. TSS BALDWIN’S DAY, BOARDING, and COLLEGE PREPARATO- RY SCHOOL’ FOR GIRLS reopens Sept. 26, 1894. Ad- dress iss FLORENCE BALDWIN. PENNSYLV4NIA, Lancaster Co., Lititz INDEN HALL SEMINARY .« Founded 1794. A Moravian School for Girls and Young Women, with Post Graduate Department. Care- ful supervision, liberal course, and rational methods, Scholars received at any time, For circulars apply to CHARLES B, SHULTZ, D.D., Principal. PENNSYLV ANIA, Germantow n, 202, 204, 3835 West Chelten Avenue. ’ , = S MARY E. STEVENS’ BOARD.- ng and Day School —26th year. “Approved” by on lawr College. The Bryn Mawr entrance exa- minations are held in the school by an examiner from nd College. School certificate admits to Vassar PENNSYLVANIA, Philadetphia, Chestnut Hill. V TSS COMEG Y’S AND MISS BELL'S l English, French, and German Boarding-School for young ladies reopens October 1, Students prepared for College. Ample grounds for outdoor exercise. Xy 1848. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, 1350 Pine Street. TSS ANABLE’S BOARDING AND Day School for Young Ladies. Established in Opens September 26. RHODE ISLAND, Providence, 26 Cabot Street. A iso BARY CC. WHEELER § PRE- paratory, CoNegiate, and Art Schoolr eopens Octo- ber 2, 1894. Certifie ate admits to Brown University, Smith and Wellesley Colleges. College Professors in Collegiate Department. Art School prepares for Paris studios. L imite 1 numbe rof boarding pupils. “| Museum of Fine Ar Copley Square, Boston, Mass, SCHOOL OF DRAWING AND PAINTING. Nineteenth year now open. Instruction in drawing from the cast and from life, in painting, modelling, and decorative design, and also in artistic anatomy and poaercaice. Principal instruc- tors: F. W. Benson, Tarbell, and Philip Hale (Drawing and Pair ting), Mrs. William pene > tive Design), B. L Pratt (Modelling), G. H. Monks, M.D. (Anatomy), and A. K. Cross (Perspective). Pu allowed the free use of the galleries of the Museum, For circulars giving detailed information, address iss au 1Z senna LOMBARD, Manager. COLGATE ACADEMY. HAMILTON, N. Y. New gymnasium; cottage dormitories, improved course of study; best modern methods, For illustrated Cata- logue, address the Principal. | RS. JOHN McGINNIS, Jr., OF NEW l York, bas taken an apartment, No. 40 Ave. Vic- tor Hugo, Paris, where she will receive girls of any age, enabling them to have the best advantages there, and will arrange for some travel if desire Refer- ences required. Inquiries may be made of Mr. Horace White, New York Evening Post. ACADEMY, RIVERVIEW POUGHKEEPSIE. N. Y 59TH YEAR Prepares thorougtly for ot ok the Government Academies, and Business. U.S. Army offi. cer detailed at Rivervie 4 by Secretary of War. BISBEE & AMEN, , Principals. — (IRE UL. AR Se of Be st Schools, with pre free to parents. Teachers supplied for Colleges and Schools without charge. KERR & Hvyssoon, _UNION SCHOOL BUREAU, 2 W. 14th St.. ‘N. ¥. OCK WOOD HOUSE.—Home for 6 boys, « GREYSTONE.—For younger boys. “Preparation for College. Family influences. Refined surroundings. #vmnasium ALFRED COLBURN ARNOLD. Short Hills, N J.

Page 3

Oct. 25. 1894]

kdiu aia, EUROPEAN WINTER RESORT. INNSBRUCK, TYROL, AUSTRIA. 1,900 feet above the sea, with dry, bracing climate. CENTRE FOR EXCURSIONS. Fine University, Hospital, ete. HOTEL TIROL. Open all the year. CaRL LANDSEE, Proprietor. Large, airy, sunny rooms; modern conveniences; superior cui sine. Reduced rates in winter, EXCURSIONS A SPE CIALTY. Bestreferences. Illustrated pamphlets sent on application. Teachers, ete. LADY RESIDING IN ENGLAND who has lived several years in America, wishes to act as companion and courier to ladies or children who are to be on the continent during the coming winter. Would act as governess if desired. Address M. A. Y., 69 Trinity — Margate, England. Refers to Dr. Vincent Y. Bowditch, 719 Boylston St., asain Mass. ] JANTED.—A GENTLEMAN WITH some capital, to assoctate himsel* with the pre sent master (who cannot endure the labor) and take the city of more of a preparatory school in a delight ful Fy | of more than 100,000 inhabitants. Address K. C. B., care of Robt. McMichael 7th and Alabama } Toh maarenepene, | Ind. WO YOUNG 2 ADIES DE SIRI / the educational advantages of Boston can bid a home in a private family by applying to Miss WaLLrey, 78 Huntington Avenue, Boston, Mass. Highest refer ences required.

HE PRINCIPAL OF A WELL- known Day School for Boys, preparatory for col lege, in New York State, wishes to receive into his family two boys of school age to care for in every way for the year or longer. H., care Nation 7 UTORING FOR COLLEGE. G. H. MAYNaDIER, A.M, 17 Plympton St., Cambridge, Mass.

(*s RLES W. STONE Tut r for Har- vard, 68 Chestnut Street, Bostou. School Agencies. HE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES 4 Ashburton Place, Beston; 70 Fifth Ave., N. Y.; 106 Wabash Ave., Chicago; 32 Church Street, Toronto; 803 Tweifth Street, Washington, D. C.; 120% South Spring Street, Los Angeles. Agency Manual free. EVERETT O. Fisk & Co, MERICAN AND FOR: 1G N TE. CH- 21 ers’ Agency sup iplie $s Professors, Teachers, he Ts, Governesses, etc., to Colleges Setools, and Families. Apply to :

Mrs. M. J. VYouNG-FULTON, 23 Union Square, New York. HE ALBERT TEACHERS’ AGENCY, 211 Wabash Ave., Chicago, recommends best teach ers toemployers free of charge. Are filling hundreds of high-class positions this se —7 n. Correspondence solicite ds ALBERT, Manager.

HE NE W AMERICAN TEACHERS AGENCY.- Teac hers seeking id sitions and those sea ac hange at an increased salary should address .B. RUGGLES & Co. (Palace Hotel Building), Room C, 237 Vine Street, Cincinnati, O. MERICAN AND FOREIGN P> sors, tutors, governesses, teachers, etc., Supplied to colleges, schools, and families. Miriam CoYRIEwk, 150 Sth Ave., cor. 20th St., N. ¥ CHERMERHORN’S TEACHERS’ Agency. Oldest and best known in the U.S _ Established 1855. 3 East 14th St., N.Y. HE BRIDGE TEACHERS’ AGEN- cies, 110 Tremont St., Boston, and 211 Wabhast Ave., Chicago. Agency Manual free to any address. MERICAN AND FOREIGN TEACH- Ph ers’ Bureau. Miss GRaAcE POWERS THomas, M’g'r 3 Park Street, Boston, Mass.

is valuable in proportion to its . Y, ’ - An . 1¢ CNC J influence. If it merely hears vacancies ‘and tells is something you about them Tha itis asked to recom mend a teacher and recom sr neessesic mends you, that is more Ours Re COMMEHAS C W. BARDEEN, Syracuse, N. Y

Histew y Pp. Dartmouth College AND THE TOWN OF HANOVER, N.H, by ! RICK CHASE. Voi I. To the outbreak East rath St

} }

The —so ne ae Nation. G. P. PUTNAM’S SON HAVE NOW READY: The Sketch=book of Geoffrey Crayon, Gent. By WASHINGTON IRVING. The Van Tassel Edition, uniform in general style wit w H lay Editions of ** The Alhambra,” ‘*Granada,” and ** Knickerbocker.” Two vol printed from new type, with artistically designed borders, and 32 Ulustratious from desicns by Rackham, Barraud, Church, Rix, and Van Deusen. Cloth extra, $6.00, three quartet levant, $12.00. One bundred numbered copies will be printed, with proofs of the plates Japan paper. Half leather, gilt tops, Roxburgh style, $15.06 The Story of the Civil War.

A Concise Account of the War in the United States of America between INdL and Ine hiv JOHN CopMAN Ropes, author of ** The Army Under Pope,’ ‘The First Napo t To be complete in three parts, printed in three octavo volumes. Each part will be in itself and will be sold separately. Part I. Narrative of Events to the Opening of the Campaign of Is With wisps Svo, $1.50 we - Cicero, AND THE FALL OF THE ROMAN REPUBLIC. By J. Lo Strachan Davipsoxn, MOA Fellow of Balliol College, Oxford. (Being No. X. of the ** Heroes of the Nations ” Series Large 12mo, illustrated, cloth, $1 50; half leather, gilt top, $1.75 “Tt isa valuable addition to this splendi 1 series of biograp! it in suitable dress, excellent paper, clean, large ‘ype and have lighted it w lustre . : : t terially to its attractiveness and value, both for students and the general rea The Story of Venice, From the Earliest Times to the Fall of the Republi By ALETHEA Wr No 4 ‘Story of the Nations” Series.) Imo, cloth, fully illustrated, #1 50, halt ul top, $1.75, (Sept. 10 ‘This book isone of the most intensely interesting a . ‘ y ss uve occurred during the present year. The Story Ve . ya before been written Ne Haven ste

The Ariel Shakespeare.

Each play is in a separate volume, 34,5 inches, and about a half inch int sness fortable bulk for the pocket. ge page is printed from a new f f br r tv} text is complete and unabridged, A ied. arly as possible as the author wrote it, a forms to the latest scholarly editions. As illustrations, the charming des s by RANK HowarRbD (first published in 1833), tive hundred in all, have been effectively rept making a series of delicate outline plates. Now complete in 40 5 mes, and iss styles : A Garnet cloth, each, 40 cents; per set, 40 v ‘umes, in box, SIH. B.—Full leather, gilt top, each (in a box), 75 cents; per set, 40 volumes, in box, C.—40 volumes bound in 20, cloth, in box, per set (sold in sets only), $ D.—40 volumes bound in 20, half calf extra, gilt top t t S35.00

The best handy-volume ed \ x ¢ “ < — The Egy ptian Book of r the Dead. The most ancient and the most important t wt re texts of an it Exzvot Edited with introdu *‘tlon, a complete t raustlat apters on its history symbolism, ete, ete., by CHARLES H.S Daves a f N stra tions from the Turin and the Louvre Papy ~ Zz i

Gods. Large 4to, cloth, $5.00 About W omen: What Men have said. An Every-Day Book. Compiled and arranged by Roser | ornamental cloth covers, $1.0 ’ Napoleon. By ALEXANDER Dumas. Translated fromthe French by Joun B. LARNER m th, $1 The Arti fici ial Mother. A Marital Fantasy. By WG. H.P. With six Ill ations by Van Deusen. l6mo, cloth, $1.00 ‘It is a quaint little story, and bristles with genuine wit The book i¢ handsomely bound and iilus ated i 2 r w stinguishes ss < s i ver ikingly bound a stra \ f NEARLY READY, The Play-Actress. By S. R. Crockett, author of *‘The Raiders.” “The Stickit Minister,” etc., etc. 16mo, in sa neral style as \ Literary Courtship.” with Frontispiece by MeCullough, 21.00 i iv N * Story f the Nations ind the ** Heroes of the Nationa’ and quar t \ = the season's publications, sent on application 27 and 29 West 23d St., New York City. P. PUTNAMS SONS,

foes yo nt Ae mga

UR do en eos wee oe maa

aes le Ay Ny ON

a a ee Se a PR tei

Page 4

MACMILLAN & Co.’s New. Books. iv The Nation. [Vol. 59. No. 1530 NEARLY READY. WITH NUMEROUS ILLUSTRATIONS. BY THE VEN, ARCHDEACON FARRAR, The Life of Christ as Represented in Art. By Freperic W. Farrar, D.D., F.R.S, Archdeacon and Canon of Westminster, author of ‘‘The Life of Christ,” ‘‘Seekers After God,” ete. With numerous Illustrations and Frontispiece. 8vo, cloth, gilt, $6.00. New Book by Frederic Harrison. The Meaning of History and Other Historical Pieces. By Freperic Harrison, author of ‘* The Choice of Books, ete.’ 12mo, Just Ready. A Constitutional History of the House of Lords, By Luke Owen Pike of the Public Record Office. Rvo, cloth. $4.0v, net. IN THE PRESS. NEW, REVISED, AND ENLARGED EDITION. SOURCES OF THE CONSTITUTION OF THE UNITED STATES. Considered in Relation to Colonial and English History. By C. ELLIS Strvens, LL.D., D.C.L., F.S.A. (Edin.). New, Revised, and Enlarged idition. With new Appendices. 12mo, cloth, $1.50, net. “There are few, even among educated Americans, who will not find this volume a means of profitable thought ahd suggestion. Mr. Stevens is a pro found student, and his opinions are entitled to respectful attention. His notes are selected from a wide range of literature, and are extremely helpful in the elucidation of difficult points.”"—The Beacon. THE CAMBRIDGE HISTORICAL SERIES. New Edition in Zz Volumes. General Editor, G. W. ProraEro, M.A., Professor of History in the University Life of Swift. of Edinburgh. By Henry Crark, C B., editor of ** English Prose Selections,’ ete. With Por- traits, New edition in 2 volumes, uniform with the works of John Morley The Revolutionary and Napoleonic Era, 25 Matthew Arnold, etc., Crown 8vo, cloth, $3.00. 1789-1815. By J. H. Rose, M.A. With Maps and Plans. Crown 8vo, $1.25, net. Now Ready. Vol. 1, Large Crown 8vo, $2.50. Translation of PROF. HOLM’S Standard Work, GREEK HISTORY, from its ORIGIN to the DESTRUCTION of the INDEPENDENCE of the GREEK PEOPLE. By Apo_r Hotm. Authorized Translation. In 4 vols. Now Ready—Vol. I.—To the End of the Sixth Century B. C. Large crown 8vo, $2.50. Translation of Prof. ERMAWN’S Great Work on EGYPTIAN ANTIQUITIES. LIFE IN ANCIENT EGYPT. Described by ADoLF ERMAN. Translated by H. M. Trrarp. With 400 Illustrations and 12 Plates. Super-royal Svo, 36.00. ‘‘ A skilful translation of a well known and esteemed German work, which treats of Egyptian antiquities in the light of modern discoveries, and thereby supplies a recognized English want.’’—London Times. New Book by Sir Fohn Lubbock. Ilustrated by Hugh Thontson. The Use of Life. Old English Songs. From Various Sources. With Illustrations by HugH Tromson, and an Introduc- By the Rt. Hon. Sir Jon Lussock, Bart., M P., author of ‘The Beauties of tion by Austin Dosson. Uniform with ‘* The Vicar of Wakefield,” ** Cran- Nature,” ‘* The Pleasures of Life,” ete. Crown 8vo, cloth, $1.25. ford,’’ ete. 12mo, cloth, gilt, or edges uncut, $2 00. NEW BOOK BY MR. WILLIAM WINTER. THE LIFE AND ART OF JOSEPH JEFFERSON. Together with some Account of his Ancestry, and of the Jefferson Family of Actors. By WILLIAM WINTER, author of ‘“ The Life ani Art of Edwin Booth,” ‘‘Shakespeare’s England,” etc. With Frontispiece and Photogravure Plates and other Illustrations. 12mo, cloth, gilt, #2.25. Uniform with William Winter's ‘‘ Life and Art of Edwin Booth,” published last year. Also an edition printed throughout on English hand-made plate paper. Limited to 200 copies. In box, $6.00, nef. NEW NOVELS. JUST PUBLISHED, A NEW BOOK BY THE AUTHOR OF “\SARACINESCA,” ETC. LOVE IN IDLENESS. A Tale of Bar Harbour. By F. Marton CRAwForn, author of ‘Katharine Lauderdale,” ‘‘Saracinesca,” ‘“‘A Roman Singer,” ete. With Illustrations reproduced from drawings and photographs. Crown 8vo, cloth, gilt, $2.00. New Volume of Short Stortes. | A New Novel by Mrs. M. L. Woods, Elder Conklin, and Other Stories. | The Vagabonds. By Frank Harais. Crown Bvo0, cloth, $1 25. | By Maraarer L. Woops, author of “A Village Tragedy,” ‘* Esther Vanhom- Tales of Western Life. | righ,” ete. 12mo, cloth, $1.50 xT, A pathetic story of circus life. The Novels of Ivan Turgenev. Translated from the Russian by Constance Garnett. In 7 vols. New Novel by the Author of ‘‘ Wheat and Tares.” Vol. Hl. A HOUSE OF GENTLEFOLK Si ibylla: Already Published: Vol. I. RUDIN. y Imo, cloth, gilt top. Price, $1.25 each, A Novel. By Sir H. CunnincHam. 12mo, cloth, $1 25. MACMILLAN & CO., 66 Fifth Avenue, New York. : bi serps: i

Page 5

Ex-SpEAKER REED’s significant failur his campaign speeches to endorse mand of the McKinlevites for a rest tion of the high tariff had prepared t} public for his interview at Ann Arbor last week, in which he declared that would not necessarily follow that the 1 turn of the Republican party to power 189% would mean the reénactment I the McKinley law.”’ and that he did not thir the party would make that an issue, conditions had changed materia the last few years, and there was roo for many modifications. Mr. Reed even went a step further, and admitted that the rates in the MeKinley law were mark ed up higher than he expected when he appointed the committee on ways and means. In taking this position the ex Speaker only anticipates the mass of his party. It is clear enough to any careful observer that there never was any popular demand for so extreme a measure as Me Kinley framed, and that no party could now do a more unpopular thing than to pledge itself to a restoration of a policy which the people rejected so ¢ mphatica ly in 1890 and again in 1892. McKinley, of course, tries desperately hard to hold on to the old issue, for it is all he has to offer as a candidate for the next Presidential nomi nation of his party: but he will find him- self more and more lonesome. MclWWinley, Harrison, and Reed evade a discussion of the income tax in their speeches, and even the Republicar Ss of Massachusetts dodged the qu stior their platform. But Senator Hoar bas at | ast broken the silence of Republic orators on this issue, and in a _ recent speech summed up forcibly the ol : to the policy. He declared his cor that it was never intended by the framers of the Constitution that resort sl The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, OCTOBER 25, 1894 Mir. Whe: r! ¢ yo ee ow AO GON OER CR LI Nh TEE tt oN 9 LM Be Remon

Page 6

296 The Nation. [Vol. 59, No. 1530 the fact that Tammany is right in re- garding the governorship as the critical point in the fight, and that any one who votes for Hill in any sort of combination practically votes against Strong. The substitution of Grant for Straus is the substitution of a man who is popular with the Tammany masses for a man who is not. It does not change the situa- tion in the least. The regular Tammany voter is not much affected by the charac- ter of the candidate, though there may be somewhat of a revolt this year on account of the police exposures. As far as the outside world was concerned, Straus was a better candidate than Grant, inasmuch as he had no record except as a_ park commissioner, whereas people have had four years’ experience of Grant in the may- oralty. It was he who began the process of handing the city offices over to the thugs and thieves who now fill them; and he car- ried it on steadily during his two terms. As fast as the offices fell vacant he filled them with criminals and semi-criminals, in the usual Tammany style. Gilroy has only carried Grant’s processes a few steps fur- ther. It has been reported that Grant re- fused to appoint Scannell, the murderer, to the Fire Department, which may be true; but if so, this was the only Tam- many atrocity from which he recoiled. In fact, it may be said that Grant was the first to display that open contempt for the opinion of the moral and religious public, in the choice of public officers, which has finally brought Tammany to its present straits. Up to his time, mayors had always had a general regard for de- cency in this matter. Grant showed at once that he had none. In truth, his own success in getting into the mayoralty fur- nished some excuse for his course. Tam- many had never before ventured to put up a candidate of his kinda young *‘ sport ”’ of unknown occupation and liquor-dealing antecedents. He is said to have accepted the present nomination very reluctantly, but the voters can, and we believe will, now effectually close his political career. The unanimity and vigor with which the press of the city, without a reputable exception, exposes the real character of ‘*Hughey’’ Grant and his candidacy must be acause of dismay in Tammany Hall. Nothing like it has been seen in the city since the last days of the Tweed ring. It means, of course, that public sentiment against Tammany is so overpowering that it is carrying everything before it. The true nature of Tammany rule has been so clearly revealed that few persons with any pretence to character care to be associated with it, or to be making excuses for it. The efforts of Mr. Grant to tone down ap- pearances somewhat by forcing Wissig, ** Silver Dollar’? Smith, and “‘ Paddy” Diy- ver into temporary retirement, excite only ridicule. The charge against Wissig is that he is ‘** foul-mouthed,” but in that he is -Martin or no exception among Tammany men. No respectable person could remain where a body of Wigwam men were assembled discussing political or other quéstions. Their language is habitually indecent, for it is the language of the bar-room and the gutter. Why should Wissig go and ** Dry Dollar’? Sullivan be spared? In what respect is Divver worse than ‘ Barney ”’ ‘*Tom’? Grady? Does any- body suppose that in the free intercourse of Tammany society the language of these men is any less *‘ foul’? than Wissig’s? Is the habitual, unrestrained language of “Hughey ’’ Grant any refined? Everybody who has heard Tammany he- roes of the highest rank talk, knows that whenever they seek to be vigorous they are always blasphemous and filthy. more Apropos of the recent discharge of 800 men from confinement on Blackwell’s Isl- and, which Mr. Goff discovered the other day, certain testimony forming a part of the Fassett committee’s investigation of 1890 becomes important. The coun- sel of the committee, Mr. Ivins, was interrogating Mr. H. H. Porter, pre- sident of the Board of Public Chari- ties and Correction, and he had as- certained from the witness that the law authorized the granting of discharges to certain prisoners by the concurrent action of the committing magistrate and the commissioners, but that in practice the commissioners never took any pains to examine cases, but always granted the discharge on the certificate of the magis- trate. Then these questions and answers followed : * Q,. I find, by going over such statistics as I have, that the discharges are usually 100 per cent. more in the month of October than they are in any other month in the year. A. J guess you and I understand that, *Q,. We understand it. but I want the com- mittee to understand it. Why is it, Mr. Porter? A. Well, I don’t know; they discharge them. *Q. The police justices discharge them ? A. Yea, sit. . . When these men say, ‘Commissioner, won't you let me out 7? Tsay, ‘What for ?? They say, * Well, I want to vote; I want to register”... **Q. In other words. to help elect officers to make appropriations to support them in future on the island? A. Unfortunately, that, I sup- pose, is the basis.” There are so many grotesque features of what passes for government in New York coming out every day that this one may perhaps seem to be of little consequence, but it harmonizes well with the green- goods business, the blackmailing, clubbing, and bar-room brawls. The fight between ‘** Paddy ’’ Divver and Tekulsky on Thursday owes its importance to the fact that it was a conflict between a Magistrate and a Jurist. ‘* Paddy”? is, as we know, a judicial officer, and Tekulsky served as a Tammany member in the Constitutional Convention. Tekulsky is, therefore, a jurist--a Tammany liquor- jurist, it is true, but still a jurist. Fisti- cuffs between Magistrates and Jurists have been rare in history, which makes this one an _ interesting phenomenon. The accounts of the origin of the quarrel, as in all such cases, are confused. The Magistrate maintains a dignified silence, and the Jurist’s story is doubtless colored by prejudice and passion. Charges of cheating seem to have been freely ex- changed, and finally, the Jurist hit the Magistrate on the nose and drew his judi- cial blood, besides tearing his clothes. Recorder Smyth will have the deepest sympathy of the community over this un- fortunate occurrence. That a man whom he has known so long and has esteemed so highly as Divver, should, while occupying a high judicial position, have been hit on the nose by another Jurist belonging to the same “organization,” might well depress a man of sensibilities much less fine than the recorder’s. Moreover, as we do not yet know how many friends like Paddy the recorder may have in dif- ferent departments of the city service, we can well imagine his looking in the papers every morning with bated breath to see what calamities have overtaken the others. When they hit each other, or when they are called before the Lexow committee, he must experience a painful sense of the aw- ful uncertainties of Tammany life. At their recent session the California State Grange spent a day in discussion of the ‘Lubin scheme.’’ This scheme pro- poses to have the Government pay at least a part of the cost of transporting staple farm products to market. It has been pushed with tireless energy, and seems to suit many farmers. The Grange adopted, as an entering wedge, a resolution demand- ing “protection for American staples,’’ and “that this be done by the Government paying a percentage of the cost of sea- transportation to foreign ports.’’ This proposition now goes to the National Grange, and it would not be surprising to see it adopted there. The history of this first Lubin plank in California is as fol- lows: It was rejected by the Populists last May; it was accepted in full by the Re- publican convention last June; it was re- jected by the Democratic convention in August. The Lubinites then began a ‘‘cam- paign of education’? among the granges and farmers’ alliances, and here they carried everything with a rush. The strength of Lubinism is in the claim that it is a legiti- mate and necessary extension of Republi- ‘an protection doctrines. Its acceptance by the Republican State convention is well worth the attention of some future historian of the rise and fall of the high- protection idea in America. In California, where there are almost no manufacturers, and where the whole community has been very heavily taxed by McKinleyism, this sort of notion is made a party issue in hope of obtaining the farmer vote. Train robbery has become so frequent that no one would be particularly sur-

Page 7

Oct. 25, 1894] prised to read any day in the newspapers of a ‘** hold-up’? between New York and Albany. The recent robbery at Quan tico, Va.. was within a few miles of Alex ey andria. some lonely spots, and it does not make Every railroad in the country has much difference whether they are in a thickly settled country or not. can hide as easily in New York city as in Robbers the sage-brush country beyond the Rocky Mountains, perhaps more so. Something must be done to deliver society from this pest, but what to do is not so clear. Perhaps more than one measure is necessary. It has that Congress should pass an amendment to been proposed the interstate-commerce act putting these cases under the jurisdiction of the federal courts. We see no objection to that if it can be that the federal courts would be more efficient in dealing with the cases. shown Another proposal is that the express companies should carry hea vier safes, or safes that cannot be opened that they should carry money only on day trains. The latter plan is not The delay would be more costly to the public than the extra guards. Whatever this extra expense may be, the public must pay it in extra charges except by the station agents, or feasible on long routes. expense of for carriage. One thing is certain: there must be better enforcement of law all around. The form of disease called Coxey ism, Which had such a run last spring, and which took the form of seizing rail road trains and levying contributions on through wealers *’ passed, was almost certain to de velop into train robbery if allowed to pass unchecked. towns which the ‘common The commonwealers came to consider themselves a superior class of citizens who had somehow lost their right to three meals a day and their beer and If the States through which they passed had enforced the vagrant laws against them and put them to work at Coxey’s favorite enterprise of making good roads, the number of train-robbers would now be smaller than it is. tobacco.

Ohio has been so severely and so justly criticised in the past for the brutality shown to negro criminals that a change for the better should not go without recog nition. There cases Within as many vears where colored have been two or three men accused of serious offences were taken from the authorities and lynched by mobs of “respectable” white citizens, and each time Gov. McKinley has weakly lament ed that he could do nothing about it. serious In one cause a attempt Was made by the judicial department of th: Government to secure punishment of the lynchers, but public sentiment did not sustain the courts and nothing came of the proceedings. It had thus begun t look as though any rged wit! negro ¢

a serious crime was liable to be hanged off-hand by a mob in a State which has long been conspicu us for the severity of The its lectures to the South lynch law. usual treatment of a « was threatened at of the mob by the trooy Ohioans at last realiz which has been brought reign of law. The whol fered from the practice the evidence that there is they are profiting by thei ter in virtually and substituting a local taxing system. element in the State, mi drawn into the Republi slavery issue and retaine of that organization to cial issues which followe when the party great proportion of tl publicans deserted it, a voters was doubtless more than make the

abandoning smal on the ‘olored Washington house last week, and the killing of three rs, Indic e the Upon t! evils ere c ‘ute : cliseredit ICI ¢ monwealth, and are resolved to restore Nation. the offender nurt hat “Oh e North has suf . of condoning lynching in that State, and will welcome to be a reform r action ias The Iowa Republicans already find that Wil prohibith ption and saloon There is a large st of w can par “dl by Ul! CGrerman hich ty on } vards the fi 1 the w al e German nd this Class large enough

Was the e stand nan But took up prohibition, a Re t Lf majorities by which a Democrat was twice elected Gov of But the prompt calling out of the military in the case wl the of tt income tax provis sof ft vt riff law expressly s} ify ard thre value of all personal property acquired by gift or inheritance “* as sul t to the tax

Bank f this ‘ an atte pt w \ by w t i } sifor s t iriti t i iple S t? { Ser ‘ \ F . [3 ‘ im \ 1 1 Mr. ( ‘ t \ ‘ ‘ { : Phe try che k i fr Erp rart t balance . lr} , .’ ‘ 25 imeunt ret tional-bank Nev that t} bank < ‘ a ‘ ' ‘ ’ ins s wi \ rods } Lat ] Hy , J i ‘4 ‘ A _— s is : ! t t X} ~ ~ iitferer \ ~ \ t rned Py - } + ‘ ‘ i ‘ M a t Ss ss s irpr Siu results aseertained | 2 thod \ Arye trv t k kept for four 1 ths ‘ verage daily | f S101.000, The i nt of tl f ks deposit i WAS Si. rif . - t i nt f Sw.09 was \ I) rt e the ‘ f tod 4 , st Ly \ vi f but STO. Thes ft ‘ natter Was gross profit t the bank of $9.40, from Ww to pay the cost of clerical force and t t xk penses necessary to handle s ins KS, aS W is npensation for the bank’s guarantee. Another concert ad @ YTross averay iv balance of over SOO. t bank fora vear, which would apparently be a profitable account, but in realitv, owing to a large number of ut-of- town checks which required from four to six days for collection, the account showed large overdrafts each month. The books indeed showed a nominal balance, but the firm drew their money before the bank had time to receive the funds from the « ks deposited. Such investigations Thi + letails as this are to be commended

ernor. Now that prohibition has be dropped, these Germans feel at liberty t return to their old party. The Dy crats might have kept them if the party had behaved better in) State as w as in national affairs, but, as it is bonds are easily severed. One Gert newspaper which has long | 1 cratic recently announced its support of the Republicans, and the tide w! sets in that direction everywhere by virtue of general causes will be swollen in lowa by the removal of the prohibition issue. The Massachusetts Supreme Court last week sustained the constitutionality ofa law passed by a recent Legislature which i poses a taxof Sd percent. upon collat g cles and successions in a ses wl t estate. after the payment of debts, reaches $10,000. Two questions were raised t discussion one, whether the privilege of transmitting and receiving property by will is a **commodity t t aning of the State Constitut . t s the Legislature t \ xeis sucl eases: and the other, whet! the pr posed tax is ‘treasonal All seven of t justices sat upon the case. and six of then decide both points in the affirmative, hold ing phatically that t tax is within the power of the Legislat that it is not ppress ! t i that the ex empt f estates v¥ 210,000 in value is not unreasonable. New York, Pennsvlvania, ) several other States have si } . + ‘ t ‘ Is it Ww a 1 nos f r = x t \ taxat vi ss sily enfor seems to be growing t g t the try Indeed, even if subject to correction. a ee eee

ed

Re AS AINA vee

LON MRE repens Se het neee

Page 8

298 The Nation. [Vol. 59, No. 1530 THE TEST OF EXPERIENCE. THE Democratic Congress during the ex- tra session beginning in August, 1893, and the regular session opening in December, passed three measures of the first impor- tance—measures which constitute land- marks in legislation. The first was the repeal of the Sherman silver-purchase act; the second, the removal from the statute- book of the federal-election laws; and the third, the passage of a tariff bill which, despite all its faults, goes so far in putting raw materials on the free list and reducing duties on other articles as to constitute a new departure. The test of experience is now being ap- plied to each of these measures. There was long and. hot discussion as to the ef- fect of repealing the Sherman act. A year has passed since the step was taken, and the country has had abundant opportunity to make up its mind as to the result. The benefits are so clear and unmistakable that the silver craze which led to the pas- sage of the Sherman act has sensibly di- minished, and the danger of free coinage, towards which this act was proclaimed by its friends as being ‘‘a long yet prudent step,’? has now disappeared. Experience has already vindicated this feature of De- mocratic policy. The repeal of the federal-election laws involved a point of fundamental difference between the two parties. Those laws had been originally passed by the Republicans, against the opposition of the Democrats, as a feature of the reconstruction policy toward the South; and the Harrison Ad- ministration urged more extreme legisla- tion in the same sectional direction as an embodiment of Republican ideas. The Democrats condemned the principle of such legislation as utterly wrong, and made its repeal one of their first achieve- ments after securing control of all branches of the Government. The political campaign of the present year has sufficed to justify the wisdom of Democratic policy in this matter. The opponents of federal-election laws always claimed that the repeal of this legislation would be a long step in the direction of better elections at the South; that, once relieved from the annoying complications incident to outside interference in the matter, public sentiment in that part of the country would demand fair play so emphatically as to compél honest elections and to cause a normal division among voters, instead of the old and mischievous color line; in short, that the surest way to obtain in the South such political methods’ as prevail in the North was to put the South on an equality with the North, and turn over the responsibility everywhere to the people. The elections already held in Southern States this year, and the campaigns now in progress there, have fully vindicated these claims. Never has there been so close an approach to ‘a free ballot and a fair count.’”? Never have there been such ear- nest demands from leading newspapers and representative citizens that whatever cheating in elections still prevails must be suppressed. Never have the negroes voted so freely and found their ballots so much sought for by factions among the whites. Never has there been so marked a divi- sion of opinion among the whites, and so great a readiness to disregard the old race line as unnecessary, now that hostile legis- lation has been abolished. Candid Re- publican newspapers at the North are al- ready admitting that political conditions at the South are now healthier than at any previous time since the negroes were enfranchised, and that the repeal of the federal-election laws has contributed powerfully to this improvement. The shrewd framers of Republican platforms have dropped the old sectional issue as a matter which is settled. Experience has already vindicated this feature of Demo- cratic policy also. The question of high tariff or low tariff, like the sectional issue, has been fought over by the two parties for many years. Prosperity and ruin were predicted as the consequences of the proposed change by its advocates and opponents. Each party professed itself willing to abide by the test of experience. A small element among the Democrats long delayed all action towards redeeming party pledges, and finally pre- vented the passage of a symmetrical mea- sure; but, notwithstanding all obstacles, what is essentially a low - tariff bill at last became a law. So long did the ‘‘con- servatives’’ in the Senate postpone final action that only about two months will elapse between the time when the law went upon the statute-book and election day. Even this brief period, however, will have been long enough to afford conclusive indi- ‘ations of the manner in which the law will work. There is already an evident im- provement in the industrial situation. Mills which have been closed are opening. Ma- nufactories which have been working on short time are returning to full hours. Mc- Kinley, in his repetition of his ‘* calamity wail,’’ has to look sharp, or he may find, as at Ionia, Mich., last week, that a banner hangs before him announcing that ‘‘our factories are running twelve hours a day as a result of the Wilson bill.’’ The _presi- dent of the Pennsylvania Railroad express- es the opinion that the improvement al- ready observed in manufacturing is sure to extend gradually but steadily to all other departments of business. A more hopeful feeling pervades the whole com- munity, and the prophets of ruin are be- coming bores on whom busy people cannot afford to waste their time. Experience promises to vindicate this feature of Demo- cratic policy as abundantly as in the case of the other two. Impatience with Democratic follies and weaknesses has blinded the country to a sense of the real services which a Demo- cratic Administration has rendered. The repeal of the silver-purchase act, the re- moval from the statute-book of the fede- ral-election laws, and the passage of a low-tariff measure for the first time in forty years, are great achievements. Each and all are acts which can stand that cru- cial test of legislation—the test of expe- rience. Witharecord containing so much of good, it is inconceivably stupid that the Democrats should put up a ticket in the most important State of the Union which seems especially contrived to drive away from the party the independent voters who hold the balance of power. PRIVATE AND PUBLIC MORALITY. Amona the curious consequences which the political situation in this State has produced, none is more curious than the disposition which has been shown in certain quarters to make a_ dis- tinction between Hill’s personal and_ po- litical character in the matter of honesty. Several gentlemen with a fair reputation for acuteness have made ex- press reservations as to his ‘‘ personal in- tegrity,’’ while passing the severest con- demnation on his conduct as a_ politician. They have, in fact, propounded, as if it were a generally accepted commonplace, the theory that a man may be a notorious rogue in his dealings with public affairs while remaining quite virtuous in his atti- tude towards money. Several gentlemen of eminence have given us to understand that Hill, though a very tricky and dis- honest politician, is really an upright man. If this were possible, it would be a terrible thing for the state, and in fact for human society. No social organization could long resist the unchecked political rascality of its “best people’; for if men could be po- litical rascals without damage to their pri- vate reputations, there would soon be very few patriots left among us. But it is not possible. There is no foun- dation for this theory either in our expe- rience of human nature or in the history of civilized states. Man is not so.con- stituted that he can be untruthful and unscrupulous in dealing with one set of facts or one department of conduct, and faithful, just, and true with regard to another. Human character is one. It is not cut up into departments, in some of which conscience has jurisdiction, and in others self-interest only. Falsus in uno, falsus in omnibus, is a maxim founded on long observation of the race. There may be certain’ wicked- nesses of which even the wickedest man would not be guilty, to which, for some reason or another, he is not tempted, but it is not open to any one to say he is sure not to commit them. The probabi- lity on which the world has to rely in dealing with him is, that he will commit them. Hungry Joe might be cashier of a bank for twenty years without robbing it, but the directors who em- ployed him would be considered insane. If they said, ** Oh, he has never robbed a bank: he only robs farmers,’’ they would be laughed at. In fact, reputation rests on human belief in the unity of charac See sista PS See ons

Page 9

Oct. 25, 1894] ter. No one in the ordinary affairs of life trusts people who are partially honest —that is, honest about some things and knavish about others. It is only in politics that one hears of this curious distinction. The way to judge a man is to observe how he behaves in the presence of any- thing which he strongly desires—it makes no difference what it is. His methods in getting hold of one thing are sure to be his methods when he turns his atten tion to something else. Nearly all the great political knaves of history whose do- ings have been exposed, have been as weak about money, if they were needy, as about other things; which is quite natu ral, money being the most prominent ob ject of human desire and the cause of nearly all crime. When Hill found he need ed $30,000, he did not hesitate a moment about getting some of it out of contractors in the public service. The sole reason, in fact,for supposing that any man whois po litically corrupt does not steal public money is that it is very difficult to find him out. A man’s jobbing about offices has to be more or less public, but his pecuniary thefts are in their nature secret or easily covered up. Nearly three hundred citizens of the best standing and of various callings have signed a solemn declaration that they be lieve Hill to have been guilty, on divers occasions, of ‘fraudulent’? and = ‘dis honest ’’ practices, of having robbed (** looted ’’) municipalities, of having de fied the laws of the State and the mandates of the courts, of having * out raged common decency,’”’ and of having used the appointing power to put dis reputable persons in public office as a reward for disreputable services. The description they give of him, in fact, connotes lying, concealment, deception, lawbreaking, and the use of the public money to reward criminals or semi-crimi nals. Whether he has ever pocketed pub lic money himself unlawfully, they do not know, but the account they give of him, if true, warrants the belief that he would pocket it if he got a chance of doing so without exposing himself to punishment, or that he has done so if the temptation has ever come in his way. The only good thing they can consistently aver of him now is that he has not been found out. And let us add here that the distinction between appointing to office and keeping in office a man who, you know, will steal, and stealing yourself, is too futile for seri ous examination. Hill is, in fact, according to both friends and foes, the worst man any political party in America has ever offered for popular suffrage. If bad men have been previously set up, their supporters have at least had the grace to deny their badness. In his 7 case the charges against him are admitte aoe ul by the men who are going to vote for him. This is a new and startling departure in American politics, and its prompt repres sion is the solemn duty not only of Repub- licans or Democrats, but of good and pa The Nation. triotic men of all parties. The fietion that David B. Hill has kept pure and good while Governor and Senator Hill were mis behaving, is too thin to impose on anybody. It was remarked to the German prince bishop who defended his atrocities on the ground that he committed them as a prince and not as a bishop- ** When the devil gets hold of the prince, what will become of the bishop?’ So also we may ask, What will become of the upright David when the cheating and lying Senator and Governor are getting their due? VR. MORTON'S COACHMAN For the first time, unless we are greatly mistaken, since the writ of habeas corpus was introduced into Anglo-Saxon juris prudence, a judge last week in this city found that a man brought before him un der it was unlawfully deprived of his liberty, and yet remanded him to the cus tody of his captor. The writ of habeas corpus, it must be remembered, is not intended to enable the court simply to inquire whether the prisoner likes to be in jail, or whether he would like to get out, or how he came to get into jail. Its object is and always has been to enable him to regain his liberty, if he has been illegally deprived of it: and if a court finds that he has been illegally deprived of it, it has always been held to be its duty to discharge him But Howard, Mr. Morton's coachman, was brought before Judge Lacombe last week ona writ of habeas corpus, and showed thai although he was detained ut tract-labor act. it really did not a because it specially excepts domestic set vants,”’ and there was no dispute about his being a domestic servant. His captors hunt ed him up in his employer's house, found him engaged in the duties of a domesth servant. and, we believe. although they have had the poor man in custody two three weeks, have never denied that Was adomestic servant. Moreover, when brought before Judge Lacombe, the judge found that he wes a domestic servant, and therefore the contract-labor act did 1 affect him in any way It was, as regards him, as if it had never been passed, He was more affected by it than Mr. Morten, or any native-born citi zen. Why, then, did not the judge dis charge hit Ti 4 sVW r t t a> pues tion reveals an extraordinary state of things The ntract-labor act empowers the secretary of the treasury to seize and de port, at any time within one year after their arri who may have tm ¢ vi it of the Ww, that is, W ay ve e over nder contracts mai the other side of ti e water I ie ot et of the act is to importat of the swarm d other half-savage pea eastern Europe, whom the rers and miners had f bringing over to avoid paying American laborers the high wages provided for in the tariff. We may add that we think it is good policy for the United States to shut t heir doors, as a rule, to All peo who cannot pay their own way But. in the interest f ci fico tself. ex cepth ns have bye i nt t Ive mad To exclud irtists, tea s i , sicilans, clergy ect rs. and d mestic servants r anv class of persons who are likely to contribute to t tur . of the untry, or the ease and wits f far \ ifs W ld be = s me ba barism. Domestic servants in part ‘ veri great! bers verv Vea 4 ios popes t { tlie ifest want f \ er in f 1) t vants ire raingiv } f vo ene text fev the act, and t¢ s we ( rt, inter , ’ preting th t ad}y is ride t} it ( ' Ox int , x , } ‘lasses aise So fara 3 0 But Congress left t vecutior f tl} act to the secretary iz , . . it vruve hi thre P wh { " } ror iliens wil 8 t > have v ited t \ t ing t this ‘ ‘ ins . @ wit! t veu { t riva But f ‘ f Serv +‘) i K af Xe ae +) mowers il } ‘ ‘ , ¢ , ' t \ \ Sax nt 1 Sos } \ s ~ t \ t? fs WwW ~ ; s vict s al S s the “ ve ft an acti f } ves Wot gv oft k } a pr Court has te ; lyment Nis Ek t ¢ Unit States 142 1 S.. oo) wl iv ow stand 1 side f waiter 1 ( s fi Ws An alien immigrant pr fed from land g by any such officer, « ting authority to so under an act of Congress, and thereby =fY ned of his bertv, Is doubtless entitied toa writ of habeas corpus to ascertain wheth restraint is lawful. And Congress may, f it sees fit.authorize the courts to investigate scertuin the facts on which the right to dey s But, on the other hand, the detert ation of those facts y be in rusted by Congress to executive officers; and such a erse.as in all others in which a stat ite gives a discretionary power to an officer, to be exercised by h upon his own opinion of certain facts. he is made the sole and ex isive judge of the existence of those facts; ino other tribunal, unless expressly autho- rized by law to do so.is at liberty to reexamine r controvert the sufficiency of the evidence acted It is not within the pro- judi iary to order that foreigners » never been nat iralized or acquired ile or residence within the United ever been admitted into the coun- o law. shall be permitted to en- tion to the constitutional and ln lL mensures of the legislative and execu tive branches of the national Government. As " the decisions of ‘ xecutive or officers acting within powers expressiv conferred by Congress are due pro cess of law.’ And further * That the provisions of Article V.of Amend- ments United States Constitution, ‘no person shall be deprived of life. liberty or proper tv without due process of law, do not ipply toaun alien immigrant who has not ac ,uired a domicile, because, so far as he is con cerned, any examination into his right to en ees ar EOE we oe mens oe oot ee

Page 10

300 The Nation. [Vol. 59, No. 1530 come here by such executive officer as Congress may select( without appeal to the courts), is ‘due process of law.’ ”’ It will be seen that this allows the man the habeas corpus—it cannot deprive him of that under the Constitution—but it makes it worthless by depriving the judge of power to act on it. The great writ of liberty becomes, under this inquiry, a ridiculous examination of the reason of the man’s imprisonment, by a tribunal which can do nothing for him. Judge Lacombe had to follow the decision in the recent proceeding. And now see how it works, how soon its monstrosity is demonstrated. In the middle of an exciting political campaign, the secretary. of the treasury allows his subordinates to seek out, in the house of a prominent political candi- date who has filled the office of Vice- President of the United States, one of his ‘‘domestic servants,’’ to whom the law had no application, to arrest him, cart him about the country as a prison- er, and deny the right of the courts to liberate him, although there is no pre- tence that he is legally held. As a legal correspondent of the Hvening Post has well pointed out, under this ruling of the Supreme Court, the secretary is so far raised above the law that he might real- ly seize on a native-born political oppo- nent, pronounce him an alien immigrant, and deport him. This seems an extra- vagant supposition, but the law fully warrants it, and it would not greatly sur- pass in absurdity the treatment of How- ard the coachman, who, as far as the contract-labor law is concerned, stands exactly in the position of a native-born citizen. Nothing can prove better the strength of the principles to which the Democratic party is wedded than its continued strength and vitality in spite of the acts and opinions of many of its leading men. THE BALTIMORE PLAN. TuHE Baltimore plan of currency reform has met with a very favorable reception from the press. The Columbia (S. C.) State regards it as a sign of progress toa rational and fair solution of the money question, and says: ‘* As the scheme has been unanimously en- dorsed by a body so conservative and so influ- ential as the American Bankers’ Association, and will be pressed by it upon the attention of Congress, we may be sure that some legisla- tion on this line will be had at the next session. Indeed, it must be had. Jt is the only possible alternative to a swamping flood of bad money. But the friends of State banks must see to it that it is amended so as to be all that it pur- ports to be, and to give in truth the elastic and sufficient currency of home issue which is re- quired.”’ Quite true. It is the only alternative to a swamping flood of bad money. It should be added that it is the cheapest possible plan. Instead of buying silver at sixty- three cents per ounce, or whatever the price may be, the currency will be sup- plied at a cost of next to nothing. This does not mean that we can all of us pick up money in the street. If we could do so, it would be worth nothing. We shall have to pay one hundred cents’ worth of our goods or labor for every dollar, whether it be silver or banknotes; but in the for- mer case society as a whole must begin by paying out fifty cents for the material of which the dollar is composed, while in the other case it pays only a small fraction of acent. This is true whether the silver is obtained by Government purchase or by free coinage. The cost of mining and smelting, which is not less than sixty-three cents per ounce (the equivalent of fifty cents per dollar), must be paid by the com- munity which uses the dollars. It seems something like a paradox to say that the money which costs nothing is better than that which costs 50 per cent. of its face value, but it is true, because the bank- notes represent 100 cents in bank assets. The banknotes are swapping tickets. The Baltimore plan, as Mr. Hepburn tersely said, is a plan for swapping well-known credit for less-known credit. All trade is exchange. A bank is a machine of ex- change, and banknotes and bank-checks are simply two parts of the same machine. The Columbia State, while endorsing the Baltimore plan, criticises some of the de- tails. It says that ‘if the Canadian banks safely issue notes up to the full amount of their unimpaired capital, there is no good reason why banks in the United States should be limited in their issues of notes to 50 per cent. of their capital in or- dinary times, and 75 per cent. in times of emergency.’’? There is some force in this suggestion; but in making a change in the banking system of a country, it is best not to attempt too much at once. If we err at all, let us err on the side of safety. Moreover, Mr. Homer, who was selected to bring the Baltimore plan before the convention, presented statistics showing that, under the old system before the war, there had never been a time when the banks were able to keep out circula- tion to the extent of more than 50 per cent. of their capital, under the conditions of specie payment and free competition. Of course we do not expect any other condi- tions. The average of such circulation before the war was only 44 per cent. of the capital, while in Massachusetts (in 1859) it was 29 per cent., and in Louisiana only 26 per cent. In the latter State there was no restriction on bank circulation, and in the former there was practically none. The New Orleans Times-Democrat and the Nashville American heartily endorse the Baltimore plan. The former, after re- citing the details of the proposed measure, says: “The plan will give that elasticity to the currency the lack of which has been painfully felt in all times of money stringency, and es- pecially so in the dreadful year 1893. This elas- ticity is to be obtained through the 25 per cent. issue referred to in the plan as the emergency circulation; and this emergen- cy circulation will be taxed so severely that it will never be thought of but when real necessity arises. Thus are both safety and elasticity secured by the propositions of the Baltimore plan. which, from its simplicity and the splendid endorsements of all the bankers as wellas of the present comptroller of the currency and of his last predecessor, is almost certain to receive the favorable consideration of Congress.” The Boston Advertiser objects that the plan sacrifices the depositor to the note- holder by giving the latter a first lien on the bank’s assets. The criticism is thus stated : “It is the depositor in the national banks who is likely to find the chief cause of complaint against the proposed Baltimore scheme. It would hardly be fair to him to say, as President Curtis does, that he * would be as well cared for’ under the Baltimore plan ‘as he now is,’ for the reason that under the proposed system the currency issued by the bank would come in as the first lien upon the bank’s capital, while the depositor would have to be satisfied with what remained after the currency was redeemed,”’ It is one of the a be’s of banking science that the note-holder shall have a first lien on the assets of a failed bank. That is one of the provisions of the national banking law now. If the country should get into another desperate war, so that the bonds held for banknote security should sink to forty cents on the dollar, as they did in 1864, and a national bank should fail, then. section 5230 of the Revised Statutes would become operative at once. It says that ‘‘ for any deficiency in the pro- ceeds of all the bonds of an association when thus sold, to reimburse to the United States the amount expended in paying circulating notes of the association, the United States shall have a_para- mount lien upon all its assets,” etc. This principle is affirmed in the State con- stitutions of New York, Indiana, Michi- gan, Iowa, Minnesota, Kansas, and Ala- bama, and in the banking laws of several other States, including Massachusetts. It would become at once operative in those States if the federal tax on State banknotes were repealed. The only serious objection that has been raised to the Baltimore plan is that it does not provide for the retirement of the Government notes now outstanding. ‘Tt does not go far enough,’’ say these objectors. The criticism is certainly a respectable one, and, if the Baltimore plan were offered as the last word on the subject of monetary legislation in the United States, would be a very weighty one. But, as a circular issued by Messrs. Hambleton & Co. of Baltimore since the adjournment of the convention says, ‘it is not claimed that the plan is per- fect, but it is a long step in the direc- tion of a sound currency.”’ We are of the opinion that all Government notes circu- lating as money ought to be withdrawn. We think that they are inconsistent alike with sound principles of money and with sound principles of government. Never- theless, we do not consider it wise to put for ward a plan for withdrawing them now. Public sentiment is not ripe for it, but the Baltimore plan, if adopted by Congress, will be a long step in that direction

Page 11

Oct. 25, 1894] The Nation. 301 because it will introduce elasticity into the currency pro tanto, and will make the next step easier. What we want now is to get back to sound principles, and especially to the principle that banknotes should be based upon credit and not upon Government bonds. The bond-security system is as hard as iron. It is harder, in fact, than a deposit of gold coin, dollar for dollar, would be, because it requires $114 of in vested capital to get $90 of banknotes. This system does undoubtedly make notes secure, but it does this at the expense of all other qualities. The Baltimore plan will make them equally secure, while adding flexibility to the system. One fact, easily lost sight of, should be steadily borne in mind. If a bank is not required to put up $114 in Government bonds for every $90 of notes, the $114 is not lost. It does not cease to be part and parcel of the bank’s assets. It is just as available (and more so) for the redemption of banknotes as in the other case, pro vided the bank is well managed. ‘* Ah,” says some objector, ‘‘that is just the point; the bond-security system provides against bad management.’”? But bad manage ment of banks is now a known quantity. We have had thirty-one years’ experience to guide our steps. We know just what provision is needed to make it good. We can accumulate a fund for this purpose by general contribution. But that is not all. The comptroller’s office at Washington exists in part to pre vent bad banking. So long as $114 worth of bonds is lodged in the Treasury against $90 of banknotes, the comptroller can per form his duties in a perfunctory way. The Government, his master, is secure in any case. Nobody will suffer from a bank failure except the depositors, and they are smart enough to look out for themselves, or ought to be. The comptroller’s office likes to take things easy. It does not differ in this respect from other human institutions. If the bond security is taken away, then the comptroller’s office and the bank exam iners all over the country have a _ special incentive to vigilance. They have aspur to prick the sides of their intent. Bank ex aminations will be more frequent and more thorough, and depositors be better pro tected than they are now. The question has been asked why the Government should be responsible for the redemption of banknotes, as the Baltimore plan provides. Evidently in order to preserve the absolute good credit which banknotes now enjoy. This is an inestimable public advantage. If the plan contemplated a possible loss to the Government, it would be open to objection, but it first secures the Government by the proceeds of a tax on all the participating banks. This being done, it isno detriment to the Government to guarantee the notes, as it does under the present system, while it is an immense service to the people that they are under no necessity to inquire whether a bank note will be as good to-morrow as it is to- day, or as good in Texas as it is in Maine or Oregon. EDUCATION IN: ENGLAND. Nor since the Forster education act came into operation in 1871 has there been such widespread interest in a school-board elec tion as attaches to that of the London board, which will take place at the end of November. In the metropolis the election of the board is overshadowing the elec tions of the County Council and of the forty new district councils organized un der the parish and district councils act, which are to take place about the same time ; while outside London it is arousing a national interest. Already the election has been the occasion of as many manifes toes as a parliamentary general election, of numerous resolutions at the conferences of the churches, and of scores of sermons from provincial ‘as well as metropolitan pulpits. It is needless to add that all this interest centres about a religious contro versy. Party politics seldom plays much part in school-board elections. From the peculiar character of the elementary schoo! system, most of the conflicts are waged over sectarian questions. England is con sequently accustomed to such controver sies over the administration of elementary education laws; but, as has been stated, heretofore there has never been a school board election which has aroused so much national interest. It is hardly possible to appreciate the significance of the election, and of the na tional issues attending it, without bearing in mind how Parliament left the religious question when the settlement of 1870 was made. At that time Parliament was not establishing an entirely new school sys tem. It wasimproving and extending, some people would say patching up, a system which had then been in existence for sixty years, which had been built up partly by the Church ef England, and partly by an unsectarian organization which, like the church, had received large financial aid from the Government in carrying out its educational work. It was not disposed to disregard the systems it then found in ex istence, nor to decree that a system of uni versal school boards should be created. It aimed at continuing the existing schools, and provided for the establishment of school boards only in those places where the existing schools obviously did not meet the needs of the locality. It continued its annual grants to the schools which in the past had been supported by these grants and by private subscriptions, and further provided that schools under boards should be maintained partly by similar Govern ment grants and partly by local taxes levied by the boards. The managers of the voluntary schools, as the older schools were named, were empowered to continue whatever religious teaching they had been giving. The unsectarian schools, of course, had given no sectarian teaching. In the church schools the doctrines of the Church of England had always been taught. Th: church continued this teaching under the act of IS70; the only difference being that, under the operation of what is known as the conscience clause, parents were em powered to withdraw their children if thes objected to their being present when the doctrines of the Church of England were being taught, and the education depart ment in London directed arrangements i: the time tables in each school to facilitate these withdrawals. So far as concerns the voluntary schools this was the way in which the religion question was settled in IS70 As regants the board schools, it was left to eac! board to determine whether it would give Bible teaching or not All the act stipu lated was that no religious catechism religious formulary, distinctive of any par ticular denomination, should be taught There are now considerably more than 2.000 school boards Oniv by 91 has Bib teaching been ruled out When the first London school boand was organized in IS7L, it at once decided in favor of Bible teaching, and drew up a rule under which the instruction should be given. ‘The Bible.’ this rule set out “shall be read, and there shall be given such explanation and such instruction therefron in the principles of the Christian religion and morality as are suited to the capaci ties of children: provided always that in such explanation and instruction the pro visions of the act in sections vil. and xiv. [conscience clause and Cowper Tem ple clause} be strix iy observed both in letter and = spirit."". The Cowper-Temple clause is the one which forbids the dis tinctive teaching of any particular de nomination. Among the members of the London School Board who took part in drawing up this rule in 1871 were the late W.H. Smith, who was afterwards leader of the House of Commons, the late Sir Charles Reed. the late Samuel Morley, both of whom were prominent members of the House of Commons, Lord Harrowby, Lord Lawrence, Dr. Angus, and Dr. Rigg. On the London board the opposing par ties are now known as the Clericals and the Progressives. Although the Clerical party, which is not in sympathy with the education acts, and is always watchful of the interests of the voluntary schools, has been gaining strength since about 1885, it was not until 1893 that any attempt was made to alter the rule adopted in 1871. The first intimation that the rule of IS71 was in danger was a letter in the fruardian, the foremost organ of the Church of England. It was published in November, 1892, written by one of the cleri cal members of the board, and set forth the complaint that some of the teachers of the board schools were neglecting to teach the doctrine of the Trinity. The very next week a conflict began among the members of the school board which, with intermis sions for vacations, was continued until the 15th of March of this year. It was waged about a proposed circular to

Page 12

302 The Nation. [Vol. 59, No. 1530 be issued to the teachers in respect of the manner in which Bible instruction should be given. The unsectarian mem bers of the board opposed it. Deputations of citizens attended before the board, peti- tioning it to leave matters as they were; nearly all the. London daily newspapers, in- cluding most of the Tory papers, which are usually on the side of the Church of England, urged the board to halt. It wasall to no use. On the 15th of March, by a vote of 26 to 21, the board adopted the now famous circular, and it was _ is- sued to the teachers. It is a long docu- ment, but the substance of it, so far as the present controversy is concerned, is embodied in a paragraph which sets out that the principles of the Christian re- ligion, as understood by the board, in- clude ‘a belief in God the Father, as our Creator, in God the Son, as our Re- deemer, and in God the Holy Ghost, as our Sanctifier.’’ The Nonconformists oppose the circular on the ground that it is a reflection on the previous practice of the teachers; that it implies the imposition of religious tests for teachers, which is contrary to the spirit of modern education and likely to lower the standard of efficiency in the teaching staff; and that it endangers the spirit of the compromise of 1871, which has worked satisfactorily and commanded the confi- dence of the rate-payers. The teach- ers also object to it on the ground that it imposes a religious test. Al- though the board has distinctly stated that it will be left to a teacher to decide whether or not he will give Bible in- struction in the spirit of the circular, the teachers insist that in reality this option does not amount to = any- thing. They urge that ‘a teacher who will conform will be more useful than one who will not, and in the end the former will have his reward in better pay and quicker promotion ’’; and, further, ‘ that a new kind of dissent will be started, and that the school-board Nonconformists will find themselves practically drifting out of the swim of professional advancement.”’ Nearly half of the 7,000 teachers em- ployed by the London board have peti- tioned for the withdrawal of the circular, and their petition has become the ques- tion on which the school - board elec- tion is being fought. Since the begin- ning of the autumn a vigorous cam- paign has been conducted in behalf of candidates pledged to immediate with- drawal of the circular. The Clerical party, however, are active too; and although they are without the support of the Con- servative press, so much so that the Guardian has declared that if the electorate returns the present majority to power, it will do so in the teeth of an almost unanimous opposition from the press, the Clericals are sanguine that the electors will endorse the circular. The electors may not actually endorse the cir- cular, but they will probably again return a Clerical majority to the board, and for this reason: the Clerical party have al- ways posed as the party of economy, andasa matter of fact the school-board rate has been a trifle lower since they controlled the board. The unsectarian party insist that any savings which the last two boards have effected are due to a policy of starv- ing the schools. This may be true. Some of the schools may be understaffed, but the well-to-do London rate-payer does not send his children to the board schools. He is opposed to the progressive idea which dominates the unsectarian party. He dislikes some of the candidates who have fastened themselves on the progressive movement; and while he will not go to the trouble of thinking out the right or wrong of the Trinitarian controversy, he may very possibly give his votes for the candi- dates of the Clericals. JAMES ANTHONY FROUDE. THE death of Mr. Froude, after a literary career of varied industry for almost half a century, ends a life which, in its interests, its emotions, and its activities, in more ways than one reflects the strange transition through which England has been passing during this century. He was one of the very few survi- vors of that extraordinary group of young men who, over fifty years ago at Oxford, illustrated in the sphere of religion the power of the all- pervading spell of the Romantic spirit in its revolt against the rationalism, the common sense, and the placid self-content of the eigh- teenth century, which found their shapes in the utilitarian liberalism of the day. He was born in Dartington rectory, Totness, Devon- shire, April 23, 1818. His childhood was spent in typically English surroundings of the olden time. His father was archdeacon of Totness, and exercised also the functions of a civil magistrate. He was remembered in after years by his son as ‘‘a continually busy, use- ful man of the world, a learned and cultivated antiquary, and an accomplished artist.” Of his early training Froude wrote : ‘‘Our spirit- ual lessons did not go beyond the catechism. We were told that our business in life was to work and to make an honorable position for ourselves. About doctrine, Evangelical or Catholic, I do not think that in my early boy- hood I ever heard a single word, in church or out of it.’ He went to Oxford while the me- mory of his brother, Hurrell Froude, one of the most brilliant of the Tractarian group, was still fresh. He had already ‘‘swallowed such antidotes to Catholicism ” as would be derived from a careful reading of Gibbon, and he was fortified against scepticism by Paley and Gro- tius; but as yet he had little notion of the Evangelical wing of the church. ‘ Pilgrim’s Progress,’ even, he never read until he was grown up. At Oxford he seemed to the friends of his brother to be ‘‘ keeping the party and the Movement at arm’s length.” Mozley tells us that ‘‘his habits and amusements were soli- tary,” and that ‘‘he combined in a rare de- gree self-confidence, imagination, and inquiry.” Froude listened to Newman’s sermons with deep interest, read Hume carefully, and found himself in great perplexity. His confidence in his Oxford teachers was put to a severe strain shortly after graduation by a visit to the family of an Evangelical clergyman in Ireland, where he found Chris- tianity to be *‘ part of the atmosphere which we breathed.” He saw there the genuine fruits of the Reformation which he had been taught at Oxford ‘‘to hate as rebellion.” His reverence for the reformers revived. ‘ Fact itself was speaking for them. . . . Modern history resumed its traditionary aspect.” When he returned to Oxford in 1842, as Fellow of Ex- eter, he had learned ‘that equally good men could take different views in theology, and Newmanism had ceased to have an exclusive interest for him.” Feeling unsettled in his views, he ‘‘read hard in modern history and literature,” including Carlyle, Goethe, Les- sing, Neander, and Schleiermacher. He ap- proached modern science through ‘The Ves- tiges of the Natural History of Creation.’ ‘As I had perceived before,” he says, ‘‘ that Evangeli- cals could be as saintlike as Catholics, so now I found that men of the bighest gifts could differ from both by whole diameters in the interpreta- tion of the same phenomena.” He then discov- ered that the Catholic revival in Oxford was but part of the general movement of reaction in Europe. At this time he was invited by Newman to contribute to the ‘ Lives of English Saints.’ His reading for this purpose took him into a world where ‘the order of nature seems only to have existed to give holy men an opportunity of showing their superiority to material conditions.” After writing one life he ‘‘ had to retreat from his occupation.” But ‘the excursion among the will-o’-the- wisps of the spiritual morasses” did not leave him as it found him. ‘I had-been taught by Newman that there was no difference in kind between the saints’ miracles and the miracles of the Bible.” The alternative prob- ability now forced itself upon him—‘ that all supernatural stories were legendary, wherever found”; and he met the issue with courage although not with composure. His distress drew from him a cry of pain, and in the mournful reflections of ‘The Nemesis of Faith,’ 1848, he revealed to the world his men- tal struggles. The work was widely read, and received the censure of the Oxford authorities. In later years Froude referred to it as ‘‘something written not wisely, in which heterodoxy was flavored with sentimentalism.” To this sor- rowing Werther how like a dash of cold water must have come Carlyle’s gruff comment that ‘*he should burn his own smoke and not trou- ble other people’s nostrils with it.” The evi- dence of Froude’s courage is to be found in his actions rather than his words. ‘‘I found myself unfitted for a clergyman’s position [he was in deacon’s orders], and I abandoned it. I did not leave the church. I withdrew into the position of a lay member, in which I have ever since remained. I gave up my fellow- ship, and I gave up my profession with the loss of my existing means of maintenance and with the sacrifice of my future prospects.” He became acquainted with Carlyle in 1849, although not intimately so until 1860. His relationship to Carlyle is the key to his intel- lectuallife In 1884 he wrote: ‘‘I had, from the time I became acquainted with his writings, looked upon him as my own guide and master—so absolutely that I could have said: Malim errare cum Platone quam cum aliis bene sentire; or, in Goethe’s words, which I did indeed often repeat to myself: Mit dei- nem Meister zu irren ist dein Gewinn. The practice of submission to the authority of one whom one recognizes as greater than one’s self outweighs the chance of occasional mis- take.” After all his struggles he was to take a position toward Carlyle essentially the same as that of Newman toward the church, so per- locity Nei a sepeighacne uaa

Page 13

Sas Te vadiog still was the spirit of the Oxford Move- ment in the air he breathed. Froude now turned to literature for support, and became a frequent contributor to the Westminster Re- view and to Frazer's Magazine, of which he later became the editor. The first two volumes of his ‘ History of England’ appeared in 1856, and he was occupied with this work for the next sixteen vears. His first visit to the United States, in 1872, partook of the nature of a political mission. He delivered lectures to enlighten Americans on the Irish question. Later he travelled in South Africa, Australia, and the West Indies. He was deeply interested in the preservation of the empire, and lamented the apathy of the home Government in regard to the welfare of the colonies, whose value he placed in the opportunities they offered for the expansion of the British people. His narratives of these voyages abound in glowing descriptions of nature, and melancholy reflections on the state of politics in democracies. Like Car- lyle, he was drawn to strong men, to the he roes; and his biographies of Luther, Bunyan, and Carlyle, of Becket, Caesar, and Beacons- field, are among the most successful and cha- racteristic productions of his pen. Several vol- umes of essays, by the great range of their subjects and the never-failing interest impart- ed to them, bear testimony to the versatility of his mind. A volume of Oxford lectures on the Life and Letters of Erasmus is his latest publication, fresh from the press. In 1892 Froude was appointed Regius Pro- fessor of Modern History at Oxford, an ho- nor which it has been customary to bestow upon men who would adorn the position. Ac- tual teaching or lecturing forms a relatively small part of a Regius professor’s duties, which lie rather in the field of research and author- ship. Froude’s views of history differed wide- ly from those of Stubbs and Freeman and his immediate predecessors, for with him the emotional and intellectual life of the indivi- dual was the dominant interest, while for them it was rather the political life of men in the mass, the life of nationalities and of institutions. Freeman, too, had for years been a relentless critic of his work, and had gone so far in one of his published lec- tures as to hold up Froude, in a thinly dis- guised description, in cutting terms, as an example of all that was objectionable in his- torical writing. Not unnaturally, lively pro- test was heard against the appointment. Yet Froude deserved the distinction better than three-quarters of his predecessors. For him the main value of history was not scientific but ethical. “It is a voice for ever sound- ing across the centuries the laws of right and wrong. Justice and truth alone endure and live. Injustice and falsehood may be long-lived, but doomsday comes at last to them in French revolutions and other terrible ways.” Another lesson is, that ‘we should draw no horoscopes; that we should expect little, for what we expect will not come to pass. Revolutions, reformations —those vast movements into which heroes and saints have flung themselves, in the belief that they were the dawn of the millennium—have not borne the fruit which they looked for Millenniums are still far away.” History should be true to life; it can only approxi mate truth to past fact. ‘If the drama is the grandest when the action is the least expli- cable by laws, because then it best resembles life, then history will be the grandest also un- der the same conditions.” ‘For the mere hard purposes of history, ‘the ‘Iliad’ and the The Nat ion. ‘Odyssey are the most effective books ever written.” ‘ Wherever possible, let us not be told about this man or that. Let us hear the man himself speak, let us see him act, and let us be left to form our own opinions about him.” ‘* The supreme excellence of the Eliza bethan literature is in its purety objective character; and the most perfect English his tory which exists is to be found, in my opi- nion, in the historical plays of Shakspere. Shakspere’s object was to exhibit as faithfully as he could the exact character of the great actors ip the national drama—the circumstances which surround them, and the motives, internal and external, by which they were influenced. To know this is to know all.” **Nosuch directness of insight, no such breadth of sympathy, has since been applied to the writing of English history.” Froude considered a ‘constructive philoso- phy of history impossible as yet; for a long time to come study must be confined to analysis.” He ‘objected to all historical theories as cal culated to vitiate the observation of facts with- out which such speculations are not worth the paper they are written upon.” ‘* Neither his tory nor any other knowledge can be obtained except by scientific methods.” He was uuder no illusions in regard to himself. Three years ago he wrote: *‘ For the rest, 1 do not pretend to impartiality. In every conclusion which we form, in every conviction which is forced upon us, there is still a subjective ele- ment. . . . For myself I can say that I have discriminated with such faculty as I pos sess. I have kept back nothing. I have con sciously distorted nothing which conflicts with my own views. I have accepted what seems sufficiently proved. I have rejected what | can find no support for save in hearsay or pre- judice.” Froude wrote history as he conceived it with a power rarely equalled. His pages pulse with life. But though be drew from sources of the highest value, many of them never before utilized, he lacked a sound critical method of dealing with them. Ip this respect his later volumes show a marked improvement over the earlier ones. Unbiassed perception seems at times to have been simply beyond his powers; the facts of his own narrative he often saw as no one else saw them. Objective description he professed to aim at, but rarely attained, for he approached his material too much in the spirit of an artist. In his pictures the shadows are too deep and the lights are too richly glow- ing. A sentimentalist by nature, he was defi- cient in sobriety and poise of Judgment, and he lacked the patience for accuracy in details He had little interest in modern social or po litical science, and to the reader of the present day one of the most serious deficiencies of his work is its failure to give adequate attention to the constitutional and economic aspects of the period. Yet, after all deductions, the ‘History’ remains an imposing contribution to our knowledge of what its author believed **the greatest achievement in English history, the ‘breaking the bands of Rome’ and the es- tablishment of spiritual independence”; and even when for the student it shall have been displaced by the work of some one more large ly endowed with the indispensable qualifica tions of an historian, it will still have an enduring position in the literature of the Eng lish peo} le CARDUcCCI AT SAN MARINO Mount Titan, September 30, 184 3O3 diploma of citizenship by the Regents of the Republic of San Marino: yesterday the hope, long deferred, of visiting this microscop fuge of liberty in the Old World was fulfilled and with Giosué Carducci, his daughter, a the well known writer and professor of history Bertoliai, after a four hours’ drive from Ri mini in pouring rain, we alighted at the gate of the fifteen hundred vear-old citv, hungry drenched, yet merry, chinbed the steep ascent making the old walls ring with shouts of * Viva la repubblica, viva la libertA urious ly surprised that no s/ i intimated silence no carbineer presented handcuffs, On the bot ders of the Italian provinces of Emilia and the Marches, overlooking the fertile, populous plain surrounding Rimini, 7 15 metres above the level of the sea, on the summit of Mount Titan, are three rocks, the / At the fo of these is built the citv; lower down, the Bor go-—the entire territory not exceeding 30 ki metres in circumference, with about 4008) im habitants dispersed im hamlets and villages which the chief are Serravalle, Tre Caste Monte Giardino, Faitar Lhe government of the republic is carried on by a council of sixty citizens elected for life from all classes in equal proportions 20) nobles burghers, WO pea sants Every six months tt usellors ne minate 12 of their members, then by ballot of these are selected to [ t Vier { . or Capitan Read the dutv f these Re gents being to cause tl aWs be execut and to preside over the meetings of the cout cil The ceremony of the instalment of tl new Regents, who, after their six months’ ter of power, cannot be reclected for three vears is performed with eat solemnity. and this year the opening of the new Town Hall is ar event in the annals of the repu ence the invitati to Giosu rducei Hence the invitation ( Card deliver the inaugural address which is just concluded, to which no summary nor even literal translation can do justi The fiftee: centuries of history st it clear and con cise; the poet's passionate love of liberty, of justice, of work, of truth, and honesty shines iz to the kev note dominating the whole—the belief in a di forth refulgent ; vet this is nethir vine idea; the worship of the God befor: whom Washington bent his uncrowned head the God who held converse with Mazzini ‘that hale and healthy soul in the fortress of Savona, and led him thence, Italy’s Ezekiel, to the capitol. * Carducei with Crispi to Ca nossa,” say the silly tattlers; but Carducci has bern long meditating a protest against the mean, debasing materialism preached by the men who, while safe in their own domains, egg on the anarchist assassius to their doom In a reunion of frends in a garden six months since, he sa d quite simply, ‘I believe in God”; and went on unfolding his thoughts, hopes, and visions ; denouncing at the same time the accursed lie enthroned on the Vatican which bas made Italy an unbeliever in the eternal truth. Just then he received the invitation from Tonnini, the regent of San Marino who died last month; and during August and Sep- tember, up in the mountains above Son- drio, he embodied his idea in the address just delivered. The author of the Hymn to Satan, who invited the Italians to bury the old God under the ruins of Roman Catholicism, who prophesied the reign of reason on the throne of extinct creeds, is guilty of no inconsistency in now proclaiming his belief in the unseen, in the divine, in the eternal. He is what Mazzini was—‘ta believer, not a Christian. Neither the *‘Semitic God” nor the God of TEN years ago we were presented with the whom the Pope poses as vicegerent on earth is Pe Ne a | abate ena pisenhtans Se cs MOP ste « - OLA OE EEE BIG MR A TOE OR LTE RN A NN 5 A

Page 14

304 The Nation. [Vol. 59, No. 1530 the God of the Apostle of Italian Unity or of Italy’s divinest poet. But here he must speak for himself, give his own explanation of the motives that led him to avow the necessity of a‘‘return to the lofty ideals which inspired our Italian Renaissance.” . “Tseorn a policy of opportunism The priests of science—I mean those who use science as a profes- sion, a privilege, an instrument, a refuge; who prate of science even as the monks of the last century prated of faith—may believe and preach that the eanaille need a god: even as the marquises of the eighteenth century affirmed that religion was for their valets. .I say that such science is no excuse in my eyes Itisa mime that trips out of books and ywrofessorial chairs on to stilts, and, while selling ove-philters, furtively hands over the keys of the house to the barbarians who assail hearts and heads. I say that the bestial dissoluteness which dares open- ly to boast that civilization consists in corrupting and being corrupted, rages not so much among the people as por the so-called directing (governing) classes, the authors of those latter-day scandals that have given Rome the aspect of a den of thieves, of a brothel house of souls, with Doric or Ionic columns if you please, with the Pantheon and the Colosseum for bac und, and with an awning of gray sophis- tical babble for the protection of infamy. Will God redress all this ? What will the idea of God be for us Italians, and whither will it lead us’ I do not as sume the rdle of prophet, philosopher, or charlatan; hence I neither predict, nor preach, nor indicate— Fata viam invenient. Yet I do affirm that life is a battle of duty, not a pleasure trip, that otherwise there exists not liberty, nor fatherland, nor even a state Yet while I affirm God with Mazzini, not a hair of my head dreams of reconciliation with the Vatican. Long ago Macchiavelli wrote : ‘Owing to the culpable example of the court, this province has lost all devotion, all religion. . . Thus we Italians, with the church and with the priests, are constrained to become impious and to live without religion.’ All this was true even after 1815, Further, I believe that a real return of Italy to her high ideals if this be possible, would not be for the advantage o the Catholic Church, such as she now is ; but | also believe profoundly and affirm that the Italian people is not of its own nature atheist or sceptical, void of virtue, void of faith. This is an insult which the Germans have hurled at us since long ago, and our base ignorance has accepted the insult as a brevet of originality, and is flattered by it Knaves! Our great men are named Dante, Columbus, Michel- angelo, Galileo, Vico, Mazzini; and all of these thought and worked out what is most noble, most lofty, most worthy in the life of man and in the history of the world. But enough! let us speak of other things.’ I should say that this passage is taken from the preface to the inaugural discourse—a preface intended for Italy rather than for the simple, honest citizens of S. Marino. Carduc- ci’s real speech began with an augury to the sons and children yet unborn for the durabili- ty and prosperity of the glorious, happy little republic whose fifteen centuries of life mingle with the hopes of the future. “From the heights of Mount Titan we look down on the glorious cities in the plain—Etruscan Raven- na, Gallic Rimini, Doric Ancona. Rimini retains the bridge of Augustus, Ancona Trajan’s Arch, Ra- venta the ashes of the sons of Theodosius; yet we turn from these trophies of the alternate grandeur and decay of the Roman Empire to seek with loving veneration the altar of the new life of Italy in the tomb of Dante. From these elements, from the seeds wafted upwards on the wings of changeful fate, germinated on this rock this exquisite flower of liberty. . . . When the Roman world decay- ed, God willed that humble Latin folk should re- create that which is the soul, the primordial form of government among the Italic peoples in the hamlet and borough, the castle and the commune, free one and all. yned to premature decay by the tyran- ny of faction, by the ignominy of foreign rule, the republics of Italy vanished in their youth; in the glorious fatigues of our Renaissance, and now in the face of all our peoples united for the first time in the single, eternal name of Italy, God willed and wills that the republic of San Marino remain at once a memory, a witness, an admonition. “God, I said, citizens; for in a good republic it is still permitted to be not ashamed of God, nay, it is ots and from him, optimus maximus, to take initiative and auspices even as did not only the chiefs of our communes, but also our ancestors of Rome the great and of Greece the beautiful Old hatred for a pestiferous tyrannic superstition, new pride of superficial observers who rely too much on victories over external nature, have, as it were, diseducated the Latin races from the divine idea: but neither sacerdotal infamy nor sophistical arro- gance can exclude God from history: God the lofti- est vision to which the peoples in the strength of their youth aspire—God the sun of sublime souls and of ardent hearts—like the planetary sun through the fabled constellations, passes through the forms of all religions, sole and universal God of nations.” Carducci’s discourse, which I ought to have said was entitled ‘‘La libertad perpetua di San Marino,” after the exordium, compendiated with scrupulous exactness and poetic fervor the entire history of the little commune from the hour when Marino, an Italian stonecutter hail- ing from the Dalmatian shores, received, ac- cording to the legend, from the patrona Feli- cissima the gift of the mountain where he lived and worked and built a tiny temple dedicated to Jesus of Nazareth. Here gathered fisher- men, peasants, and poor men oppressed who would not bend the knee to Cesar, and with them Marino lived, working, praying, and sing- ing the Psalms of David,.a simple ‘‘ deacon” of the Christian community, all enjoying the greatest of human treasures, ‘‘ the dignity of work, the freedom of belief.” The heroic re- sistance to oppression, the rejection of Napo- leon’s tempting offer of enlarged territory, the constancy with which the little republic withstood the insidious offers of the bishops of Montefeltro, of the Malatesta, of Valentino, of the Farnese, were set in high relief. The words attributed to Marino, ‘‘Relinquo vos liberos ab utroque homine” (I leave you free from the one and the other man), could not ‘have been spoken by Marino—the Roman con- ception of Christianity in the fourth century could not have realized the barbaric idea of the double feudalism of Empire and of Church; but those words ring out the truth of the tenth and eleventh centuries, when the first (un- known) biographer of Marino recorded his life and deeds. The city grew up really free ‘‘ from the one and the other,” from Emperor and Pope, from lord and bishop. Alone she held her ground as a republic, without the favor or permission of Cesar or of Peter, by the na- tural course of events, the hereditary tradi- tion of her people. So sbe maintained the an- cient liberty forfeited elsewhere, her people living, praying, and working round the tomb of her good founder. Hence that which Aris- totle called tsonomia and deemed necessary in a perfect republic, that which the French Revo- lution sanctioned in the formula ‘ equality of all before the law,” grew up in San Marino, a spontaneous emanation of the will of simple men, The last, most glorious record of the repub- lic bears date of July 31, 1849: ‘* When a self-styled great te crushed with- out conquering the heroic republic of Joseph Maz- zini, then this little republic of San Marino protect- ed ip Garibaldi the supreme efforts of Italic virtue militant. Hither came the hero, preceded by Fran- cesco Nullo, the brave of braves, and by Ugo Bassi, the martyr monk. Ancient and modern Italy knock- ed at thy gates, O good republic. * Two armies pur- sue and surround me,’ said the hero, * My soldiers are exhausted with hunger and fatigue. Give me bread and a little repose forthem. Here we will lay down our arms; here the war for Italian independ- ence shall cease.’ And you and your fathers, face to face with the on-pressing een gave bread and rest and consolation to the hunted, vanquished bro- thers; gave the viaticum to the fugitives, and sped them on their way; and the shadow of the republic saved the hero to preside over Italy's happier desti- nies. Blessed be thou for all time, San Marino, by all Italian hearts which live and shall live for liberty and the fatherland. And you, O citizens, inscribe on the gate of your = the date of July 31, 1849, and on one side the words of Garibaldito his soldiers on that day, * Return to your homes, but remember that Italy must not remain in servitude and shame,’ and on the other the words he addressed to you when brighter days had dawned: * Ever shall I remember the generous hospitality of San Marino in that hour of supreme misfortune for me and for Italy.’ **O republic imbued with the noble spirit of his- tory even in thy day of small things! as in the twi- light of ancient Rome thou wast chosen to preserve the ashes of Italian liberty scattered to the winds, so in the resurrection of Rome to other destinies thou wert again chosen to save the new fortunes of Italy. All honor to thee, ancient, virtuous, gene- rous, trusting republic; honor to thee! And mayst thou live eternal with the life and glory of Italy.” The people, gathered in their beautiful new town hall, who had listened with wrapt at- tention to the discourse, which lasted an hour, burst into wild applause as the poet’s clarion voice rang out the final words, and tears rolled down the cheeks of the Regent Belluzzi, the friend of Mazziniand Garibaldi, who now, in his eighty-seventh year, as the closing act of his term of power, had to declare the new Gov- ment building formally opened—touched to the heart by Carducci’s glowing tribute to his beloved and well-served republic. A gem, in- deed, is the new palace, “designed, built, and decorated as in the times of our fathers ’—that is, in the style of the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries—so that, looking up to it from the piazza, you can fancy yourself in Florence gazing at the Bargello or the Palazzo Vecchio. From the belfry tower the underlying panora- ma baffles description. The hills and moun- tains, streams and rivers that surround and cross the widespread plain have each a re- cord of their own. There is Tassona, where Garibaldi made his last stand against the Austrians before seeking refuge in San Ma- rino. Down there Cesenatico, where his hopes of reaching Venice were baffled, where Ani- ta, who refused his entreaties to remain with the hospitable Sammarinese, died in his arms; and while we are gazing and listen- ing comes up to he presented an old, old veteran, Nicola Zani by name, who, at the risk of hisown life, after Anita’s death, guided Gari- baldi through forests and by steep paths across the mountains into safety. But the summons comes to “attend the banquet,” a simple ge- nial feast, where the chief toasts are for the old Regents, Carducci, and the sovereigns of United Italy. Telegrams are sent by the Re- gents to Crispi and the King, and promptly Umberto I. answers back: ‘IT thank your Excellencies, and the Queen thanks you, for the sentiments you express in the name of the most serene Republic of San Marino inaugurat- ing the new palace of the Government. I am glad that the busts of my august consort and myself at- test to the Republic my sincere affection, which I inherit from the King my father. Joining in your joy to-day, I indulge in fervent hopes for the pros- — of the — records are pure, century- old glories of Ita After the banquet there is a grand rep- resentation at the theatre, where Angelo Ma- sini and Lena Bordato bring down the house with applause; then a brilliant veglione, and the lads and lasses dance merrily till six in the morning of the Ist of October, that day of days in 1860 when Garibaldi telegraphed from the Volturno, ‘Victory along all the line.” At eleven the old Regents and the new assemble in the church erected on the old site where Marino built his little sacello temple, and where his bones repose. The militia are there in their simple, beautiful uniform, and Conso- lo, the great violinist, intones his new grand hymn composed for the occasion. After the short mass, all repair to the Government Build- ing, where Belluzzi the noble, Marcuccithe-pea- sant, Regents take their seats for aya time on the dais. Our host, Prof. Mari Fattori, delivers an eloquent, erudite address, expound- ing his theme, ‘‘ Bonz leges boni mores, boni mores bone leges,” to which all present listen attentively—Carducci with frank appreciation. Then the new Regents, the noble Regent for the city and the peasant (this time a school- master) for the Borgo, take the oath. Next the old Regents proceed to take off their white and pale blue collars, insignia of office, and place them on the necks of the new, deposit in a cof- fer the huge keys of the city gates of the Bor- go, the prison, and the treasury, and hand the coffer to their successors, who now take their seats on the dais, whence the old Regents de- scend and become simple citizens once more. The ceremony is ended; the military bands play the march of San Marino and Garibaldi’s hymn, while the old and new Regents, the con-

Page 15

= Oct. 25. 1894] The Nation. suls, and dignitaries, officers, priests, and p o- ple march in a pouring rain, halt at the old palace while the band plays, and then disperse to their several homes and their various occu- pations. The consular body put on a fine appearance —the French consul in splendid array ; the Austrian consul in a simple uniform; the Italian consul wearing among other decorations a medal given him by Garibaldi for military valor during the siege of Rome; Prof. Malago- la, consul of Bologna, a talented writer, as se- rious and active in the interests of this tiny republic as though he represented the United States of America. In honor of the occasion the republic has printed 100,000 beautiful post- cards and postage stamps of one lira, half a lira, and twenty-five centesimi, which, by for- mal arrangement, are to pass current for ten days only. And now, alas, we must bid farewell to this peaceful, prosperous, hard-working, happy community, where $2,000 covers all expenses of state and commune, where dazii (imposts) are unknown, ‘stone, corn, and wine” supply- ing the wants of the good inhabitants, who can yet boast splendid elementary schools, a gym- nasium, a lyceum, and numerous youths who hold professorships in the educational institu- tions of the great fatherland, as they call our Italy. ‘‘ Viva la repubblica! Viva la liberta!” May San Marino live for ever, ‘‘a memory, a witness, an admonition.” J. W. M. SOME CONTINENTAL LIBRARIES. VENICE, September, 1804. THE older libraries of the Continent remind one of some prehistoric tool of which the use has been forgotten. The American scholar, wandering among the shelves courting burial under the dust of ages, gloats over the MS. treasures, the folioed archives, the work of early printers and engravers, and makes sad comparison with the meagre collections of his own land. He is apt to forget that, except for a few erudites like himself, these hoards might as well be buried with that of the Nibelungs. A sealed book in more senses than one they are to the mass of even intelligent people. A knowledge of cursives and uncials, an ac quaintance with parchment and purpie dyes, is needed to make them either attractive or significant. Is there, perhaps, a younger generation of libraries growing up alongside of these hoary ancestors, a generation alive to its own work, not resting on old achievements? It is this question which I have set myself to investi- gate, as circumstances permit. The statistics of public libraries on the Continent may be had in German in Griisel’s edition of Petz- holdt’s ‘ Grundziige der Bibliothekslehre,’ or in Reyer’s ‘Entwickelung und Organisation der Volksbibliotheken,’ published early this year at Leipzig. The subject is attracting increased attention in Germany and in Italy, and the profession in both countries has followed our example in establishing schools or courses in library science for the training of those who wish and are qualified to enter upon the libra- rian’s career. The Italian school is in Milan, the most modern of Italian cities, under the auspices of the Biblioteca Nazionale of Brera, while in Germany a course in library science is given at the University of Gottingen. Of neither of these can I as yet speak from per- sonal knowledge, though I hope to be able to do so later. The chief librarian at Gottingen, Prof. Kar] Dziatzko, well and favorably known to librarians through his work on cataloguing, is in charge of the German course, and writes me as follows in regard to it 7 give every week a few hours of lecture, in which I endeavor above all to stimulate to independent work in the subject under discus- sion; I give besides exercises in which the stu- dents take part. Moreover, Lallow some of the members who share in the bibliographical exer- cises to learn the practical service of the li- brary in all departments. As a rule. the course lasts a year, but can of course be finish- ed sooner with a less solid foundation. . My lectures begin about the last of October. I shall give two hours per week on the history of printing and of books since the Reformation. The cost for the entire winter term is ten marks I give also, gratis. an hour’s exercise per week in the reading of Latin MSS.” An eminent American librarian expressed to me not long ago a doubt if the deliberate teaching of bibliography and kindred branches could ever be of more than superticial value; years of work in a good collection under scho- larly superiors seeming to him a better kind of training and one more likely to evolve genuine scholarship. It was a discouraging opinion, since it would necessarily follow that libra rians like himself must continue to be hamper ed by assistants needing years of experimen- tal education in order to make them valuable The Germans seem to be of a different mind, judging from the work outlined by Prof. Dziatzko; and if their previous success in un- dertaking and carrying on difficult pieces of work be a criterion, we may expect them to send out not the perfected iibrarian, but stu- dents knowing the rudiments of bibliography and furnished with guides and landmarks for future study, their interest and ambition al- ready aroused to the work of investigation in their chosen field. It is not to be denied thar, because of the larger and richer collections here and the greater number of learned libra rians to serve as instructors, such courses have a much greater chance of success than with us in the United States. Finding, when in Bayreuth, from my bit of a guide-book, that there wasa public library in the city, I betook myself to it on the one day and during the two bours in the week when it was reported open for the use of the 80,000 in habitants. Experience had taught me that, as regards books, supply excites demand, and | did not therefore expect to find myself at the end of a queue of citizens reaching out through the courtyard into the street, on account of the restricted time for drawing books. Onthe contrary, I was scarcely surprised to find my- self and one other person, a man reading a newspaper, the only visitors. My arrival seemed to excite the curiosity of the other visitor as well as of the libre to see that they wondere 1; If Was east 3 n earth had brought me there. Nothing could have ex ceeded the courtesy shown me, however, whet I stated that I should like to see the library and to draw a book. With the ordinary town- eans to explain its system of working, to give the figures of its etc.: here it le troubled that he could produce no MSS., illuminated or contaifi otherwise, except a small vellum-bound praver- book in Arabic, used, or af least owned, by the last Catholic Margrave of Bayreuth. There was also a Lucas Kranach portrait, which he took from its box and dusted before exhibiting it ; and these to him seemed to constitute the sole claim of the library to rank and respect He had not even a Wagner manuscript, though the printed works stood on the shelves, BOS with numerous pamphiets—and this was really apitv. One thing, however, had always beet kept in mind—possibly, there may be a law regard to it: the local journals had been care fully bound each vear, and that much of local history secured I learned that about two hundred volumes were purchased yearly, and that about th same putmber of persons drew books. although as the librarian was quick to remind nie a i ‘“*book ” sometimes consisting of several v umes, the circulation was really larger tha appeared from his records. Books were a lowed out for four weeks ata tu and evet in case the reader was engaged in scholarly 1 searches, as long as a Wear, provid course, no one else called for them A wi set, such as Shakspere'’s plays, might go out at once, at the librarian’s discretion. One could easily see the convenience of this arrangement for certain students, who like to retire wit their booty to some convenient hole. there ¢ enjoy it in quiet; but for others, who prefer to mouse about among the shelwes, choosing their favorite nutriment, and 7 ator into a chair to devour it, the absence of rea ipg-room and reference ! n must bea creat drawback When it came to the que a book, there was not the s test sitat although Bayreuth was fu f strangers signed my name to a printed receipt, the facts of the transaction were placed upon a sort of day book under the headings, Dat Pla book). Title, Borrower, Date of Return. ar the for s were ove! The lest returning the book raised a dithculty, siz I should have left the city before the mext day of opening At first the lhbrarian evidently thought he might call for it at my lodgings ut he was rector ina gymnasium and proba bly bad ne time to spare, and he finally asked me to bring or send it to his house This I promised to doe, and in a drizzling rain, though the walk was a long one, rather than cause a moment's anxiety to ig contidence in my honesty. At parting he offered mea me who had shown such gratifvit printed catalogue of the hbrary. and when | seeing a posted notice of the price, suggested payment, he waved it away, saying, with a humorous twinkle in his eve," Pitts ait ¢ yen!” and 1 enjoved the ke f a woman's presuming to be a hbrarian quite as much as he The publi brarv t Nuornb y Was per according to the local guide book r tw hours on three davs in the week, but this proved to be for sight-seers who wished to see } the archives and the library treasures and cu rios. To the citizens it was open from eight A. M. to five P. M. on these days, though this we had to discover for ourselves. It occupies, as sO maby German libraries seem to do, an old monastery building rendered useless for its original purpose by the Reformation. The walls in several of the rooms show traces of frescoes, though whitewash has almost suc- ceeded in effacing them. If, however, these were no better than the onesthatare left, no- thing has been lost to the art-world, except possibly from the historic point of view. The building stands next the Rathhaus, and encloses a square court-yard as full of quaint carved surprises as most Nurnberg structures of an- cient date. On the ground floor, in the damp- ness and mouldiness of which, strange to say, the library’s choicest MSS. are kept, we were shown about in the usual perfunctory way, and in return emitted the usual perfunctory Ohs ! and Ahs! of the sight-seer. Convinced ws ee ee ee Sh a agony

Page 16

Paty #6 3 Sa 2 Ae eae The Nation. [Vol. 59, No. 1530 306 that the citizens must have something to read besides these musty folios, we declined to be dismissed when the tour was finished, and asked for the public library. ‘‘The place where books are given out ’” ‘ Yes, yes, that is what we want.” ‘‘ That is up stairs, then,” replied the attendant, and we followed him across the court-yard, realizing from his de- meanor that we had asked an almost unheard- of thing. The librarian with one assistant was busy with his records, while a student was poring over some maps in the same room. The attendant went before us to prefer our re- quest, and we were most hospitably treated, and informed that we might see the library throughout and draw books also during our week’s stay. Here, however, as in Bayreuth, the idea of a woman being interested in li- braries seeméd to afford polite amusement to the library officials, which we thought was per- haps a fair return for our obligation. There was a tiny reading-room in this old library in which one might be inspired to all sorts of medizval dreams if one had time to sit in it, and plenty of imagination. The ceilings are groined, and the walls frescoed with monks and saints, while the windows are of thick circular pieces of colored glass set in iron. We asked how many books were added each year, and were told pensively, ‘‘ Not many —we have only 1,500 marks for books.”” About four hundred borrowers used the library, the guide added. There was, as in Bayreuth, no formality in regard to taking the: books want- ed, beyond the signing of a receipt and the giving of our address. No limit was set to the number of books, nor time prescribed for re- turning them, though it was known that we were merely tourists at a hotel and that our stay was to be brief. Lest this recital of pri- vileges should be misleading, I must say that we were accompanied by a professional letter of introduction, yet such is the apparent confi- dence of the Germans in one’s honesty and good intentions that I think we might have ob- tained the same privileges withdut any voucher for our character. When the time came to return the books, we had not quite finished one of them, yet the fol- lowing day was that of our departure and a day when the library was not open. What could be done? We laid the matter before the libra- rian, who at once proved to us that nothing could be easier than the solution of this prob- Jem, by directing that the book be returned by means of a Dienstmann (messenger) or through the hotel porter after our departure. After this and the Bayreuth experiences, I be- gan to ask myself if the iron-clad rules of many of our libraries in regard to non-residents might not be modified to advantage in the di- rection of a little more confidence in human nature. The value to the tourist even of studying or reading the history or literature appropriate to his place of sojourn may be easily recognized by the librarian who turns tourist for the nonce, and finds himself on the outside of the barrier erected by general con- sent between books and the people. Mary W. PLUMMER. Correspondence. DETAIL. To THE EpIToR oF THE NaTION: Sir: The use of this verb and substantive, in the senses, ‘ to select as an ofticer or soldier for a division, brigade, regiment, or battalion,’ and ‘a selecting of officers or soldiers from the rosters,’ evidently began in the United States. These definitions appear in ‘ Webster's Diction- ary,’ 1828, and I know of no other examples so early. Webster, however, cites Law of Massa- chusetts as his authority for the sense of the verb. Will some correspondent of the Nation kindly send me at once a dated quotation for the word from this source (my postal address is Dr. Murray, Oxford, England)? The sense does not seem to have been much known in England before the American civil war. It is much to be regretted that American dic- tionaries are so lamentably deficient in deal- ing with the history of words and senses of American origin, and that they leave it to Englishmen to do this work. J. A. H. MURRAY. OxForD, October 8, 1894, ROMAIC AND GREEK. To THE EpItTorR OF THE NATION: Sir: The paper of M. Gennadios in tbe Oc- tober Forum is essentially identical with many predecessors. Its doctrine is just what every Greek who can obtain a hearing in the Occident feels it his patriotic duty to preach. Mr. Alden’s letter in your issue of yesterday is also fairly representative of what nearly every Philhellene feels, at a certain stage in his contact with the modern land, folk, and speech. Silence would probably be better strategy than any retort. A fairly uniform pronunciation of classic Greek, not very re- mote from the best attainable, has been secured in America. The natural force of con- servatism will long be its best protector. But ‘‘Die Wahrheit ist auch gut Ding!” Modern Romaic, as actually spoken by the Greek people, and as it may be read in their popular songs, comic papers, etc., is a phone- tically debased patois, or group of patois, bear- ing about the same relation to classic Greck that the Neapolitan dialect does to literary Latin. That is, the words are mostly trace- able to Hellenic roots; the spirit of the speech is modern. It is as analytical as, and hardly more highly inflected than, Plattdeutsch. It has no important literature. It is a great pity Koraes and his friends did not introduce a rationally phonetic spelling, like that of Italian. Romaic has the same five vowel sounds as the latter; but the dead lum- ber of seven vowels, seven (or ten) ‘“diph- thongs,” two breathings, three accents, etc., are part of a pedantic attempt to back this patois off towards Xenophontic Greek. The newspaper Greek, which we are told to talk, has quite an Hellenic appearance to the eye. It is sufficiently artificial to be a foreign speech to the Athenian himself. It is not the tongue in which he makes love, or quarrels, or chats with his wife, children, and friends. I once asked a Greek gentleman how one ought to say, ‘*T cannot leave the room.” He answered carefully, ‘‘ Aéy dvvayat va éFéAdw éx Tod Swuatiov.” I laughed, and queried, ‘‘ Yes—very elegant! And how do you really say it? ‘t Well, we say: ‘ Aév qumopa va piyw and thy Kapapay.?”” We must choose a mild example to be understood at all; but ‘‘Then imbord naffigo apotingga- meran” is, surety, a less close survival than is, e. g., ‘* Non posso uscire dalla camera.” The evolution of ‘‘then” from ov is described by the modern Greek as ot = oidéy = Sev = then; i.e, A=A+B=B=b! A typical equation. But even this elegant journalistic Greek has no trace of optative, infinitive, or av; no true future or perfect, no dative (save in very “ high style”). It.is an easy language to acquire, but not a pleasant one, for those who really know their Platonic Greek. To the amazement of many of us, the con- viction has been uttered recently from the walls of Alma Mater herself, that we must eventually decide to make this modern patois our stepping-stone to the classical speech! That Prof. Goodwin, in particular, can feel any inte- rest in a Greek which lacks all the elements just mentioned, seems strange. The essential ques- tion, however, is one which M. Gennadios keeps quite in the background, The thing really worth fighting over is the problem of Greek pronunciation. All unprejudiced scho- lars who have studied inscriptions, with their numberless variations in spelling from one city, generation, or even stone, to the next, know the ancients had a rational, and ap- proximately phonetic, orthography. Now— to pass over such niceties as a fricative 6 and 6, the use of v in the value of our v and f, the treatment of rough and smooth breathings as alike meaningless—the Romaic method would require us to pronounce three vowels and four diphthongs all alike ee (viz, nev ec ve on). The indicative, subjunctive, and optative of any regular verb become identical, e. g., Aveus Avns Avos are all lee-ees. jets and duets are utter- ed precisely alike in each case. Or, again, fs (Latin sis), is (vis), &s (sus), eis (in), ofs (Quibus), fs (cujus), and a dozen words besides, all be- come ees! Etc., ad infinitum. The language of Sophocles and of Plato is still full of throbbing life and beauty for any who have the perception and the persistency needed to attain to its enjoyment. It is still, I say, alive; but through Romaic phonetics lies the road to death, indeed. All this pedantry in Greece has been a mis- fortune to speech and people. It has substi- tuted an artificial and unreal thing fora truly national and natural development. Real Ro- maic contains much interesting material for the professional philologist—e. g., the mixed aorist form (like eiza) is found both in Homer and Herodotus and in Romaic. Such things are sometimes wonderful survivals, sometimes chance revivals. One remarkable power of distinction has been developed, not enjoyed by classic Greek or any well-known modern speech. The distinction between imperfect and aorist, €. J. étpwyov (I was eating, used to eat, etc.) and édayov (I ate then) can be made in the fu- ture also—sa tpdyw, da dayo, What a pity this interesting modern speech should wish to mas- querade in borrowed plumes. Perhaps you will permit me, having already encroached on your space too far, to refer to an article published a decade ago (Atlantic Monthly, September, 1885, pp. 399 ff., ‘ An- cient and Modern Greek”) for a fuller, though necessarily untechnical, discussion of these questions. Wm. C. LawrTon. OCTOBER 12, 1894. Notes. MacMILLAN & Co. have undertaken to pub- lish a series of works edited by a well-known Jewish scholar, and embraced under the gene- ral title of ‘‘The Jewish Library.” No topics are yet announced. They have also in course of publication ‘The Souvenirs of the Prince de Joinville.’ Fleming H. Revell Co. are on the point of bringing out ‘ Before He is Twenty ; Phases of the Boy Question Considered,’ by Mrs. Frances &. $s hg x .

Page 17

Oct. 25 1894] Hodgson Burnett, Mrs. Burton Harrison, Mrs. Lyman Abbott, and other writers. A reprint of Alexander S, Withers’s ‘ Chro- nicles of Border Warfare,’ a history of the white settlement of northwestern Virginia, first published in 1831, is announced by Ro- bert Clarke Co., Cincinnati. Mr. Reuben G. Thwaites, secretary of the Wisconsin Histori cal Society, will edit this limited edition, which will not be stereotyped. A. C. McClurg & Co. have in preparation ‘England in the 19th Century,’ by Mrs. Eliza- beth W. Latimer, and ‘Woman in Epigram,’ compiled by Frederick W. Morton. J. B. Lippincott’s fall publications will em- brace Masson's ‘ Napoleon at Home’ and ‘ Na- poleon and the Women of his Court,’ and Waliszewski’s ‘Around a Throne (Catherine IL. of Russia)’; ‘Henry of Navarre and the Reli- gious Wars,’ by Edward T. Blair; ‘ Lives of the Astronomers,’ by Robert S. Ball; ‘ Pen and Pencil Sketches, by Henry Stacy Marks; ‘ Books and Plays,’ by Allan Monkhouse; ‘ The Autobiography of a Boy,’ by G. S. Street; William Hazlitt’s ‘Liber Amoris’; Mme. de Staél’s ‘Corinne’; the Translations of Thomas Carlyle, in three volumes; the Works of Sterne in six; and ‘Early English Ballads,’ chosen by R. Brimley Johnson, in four volumes. Burrows Bros. Co., Cleveland, will issue a ‘Narrative of Events in France from the Landing of Napoleon, March 1, 1815, to the Restoration of Louis XVIII.,’ by Helen Maria Williams; and a new edition, with an index, of Martha Walker Freer’s ‘Life of Marguerite of Navarre.’ ‘The Gospel of Buddha, according to Old Records,’ told by Paul Carus, is to be brought out by the Open Court Publishing Co., Chica- go, and B. Westermann & Co., New York. Ginn & Co. will have ready next month ‘ An Introduction to the Verse of Terence,’ by Her- man W. Hayley of Harvard; and in December ‘A GermanScientific Reader,’ by Prof. G. The odore Dippold of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. The Bookman for October makes several in- teresting announcements. The late Walter Pater, it appears, has left behind him a con- siderable number of unpublished essays, which will be prepared for the press by his friend, Mr. C. L. Shadwell, the translator of Dante. The first volume to be issued will be a series of Greek studies, to be followed by another of the same general character as ‘Imaginary Portraits.’ Pater’s unfinished ‘Gaston de La- tour’ will also be republished. Mr. Aubrey Beardsley, we are told, is not content with his successes in one branch of art—though they would seem to have been such as to suffice a more ambitious man who was also more self- critical—and is trying his hand at writing. Mr. John Lane will shortly publish a volume of his with a long title which begins, ‘The Story of Venus and Tannhiuser.’ Other forthcoming books are A. H. Millar's ‘ Fife: Pictorial and Historical,’ a comprehensive county history, co- piously illustrated (Messrs. Westwood of Cu- par), and the édition de luxe of ‘The Faerie Queen,’ to be published by Mr. George Allen and illustrated by Mr. Walter Crane. This edition will come out in eighteen monthly parts, large post quarto, and one thousand copies will be printed. The text will follow as closely as is practicable the quartos of 1590 and 1596. We have received from J. B. Lippincott Co, a new edition of Thiers’s ‘ History of the Con- sulate and the Empire of France under Napo- leon,’ in twelve volumes, and the first two vol- umes out of five of the same author's * History The Nation. of the French Revolution.” This revival we owe, of course, to the present rubbing up of the Napoleonic legend. Both issues are uni- form in typography and binding, which are of the very best, and both are illustrated; and the larger work has an index of 7H pages. We can and need say no more to commend them to the attention of librarians and book-lovers; but we may hereafter improve the occasion to speak a little to their contents. Other reprints of the week have been, first, Mr. Justin McCarthy’s ‘ History of Gur Own Times,” extended to date by Mr. G. Mercer Adam, who gives four chapters to events since Mr. Gladstone entered upon his second minis- try in 1880, and a fresh literary survey, from which Edward FitzGerald is conspicudusly ab- sent. Mr. Adam's piecing is not a match for the original cloth in any aspect, but the two volumes, which are issued by Lovell, Coryell & Co., have of course gained in value for re ference, especially as the index has been made anew and numerous portraits have been in serted. From T. Y. Crowell & Co. we have Sir Walter Scott’s Poetical Works in two vol umes, with double-columned page, not to be remarked for beauty: and a two-volume edi tion of Boswell’s Life of Johnson, more at tractive typographically, and neatly bound, as is the Scott. The altogether charming Dent-Macmillan Shakspere goes on with ** As You Like It” and ‘The Taming of the Shrew.” Lastly, we will mention a reissue of Dr. Holmes’s poem ‘The Last Leaf, in the form illustrated by George Wharton Edwards and F. Hopkinson Smith (Houghton, Mifflin & Co.). The suggestion is obvious; but the pub lishers are able to prefix a facsimile of a letter of the genial author written July 12, 184, re lating to this edition, and speaking of himself as ‘‘one of the very last of the leaves which still cling to the bough of life that budded in the spring of the nineteenth century.” “It was,” he says, ‘‘with a smile on my lips that | wrote” the verses with which the melancholy Lincoln nursed his bruised affections. Under the title of ‘ Studies in Folk-song and Popular Poetry’ (Houghton, Mifflin & Co.),Mr. Alfred M. Williams has printed a number of essays, some of which had already appeared as magazine or newspaper articles. ‘* Studies” is a misnomer, The papers are intelligent and appreciative, well-written, usually well-in formed; they show rather wide literary sym pathies and some critical power; but they are not monographs or investigations. Thev range in subject from ‘* English and Scottish Popular Ballads” to *‘ Folk-songs of the Civil War” nor could any range be less contined, for what the author calls (by another misnomer) ‘the folk-songs” of the war have littl in com mon with genuine folk-song. The chapter on sailors’ *‘ shanties” is entertaining, but t does not come tomuch. Those on Breten | a of Poitou, Hungary, ete., consist in large part is, songs of tranglated specimens. The selections are made with uniform good taste, but they are rendered with very various degrees of felicity. The sketch of William Thom, the weaver-poet, is delicately written and full of melancholy in- terest. As a whole, the book is good reading for a leisure hour and will win the author new friends Baedeker’s ‘Canada’ New York: Scribners is a companion of his ‘ United States,” which met with such instant favor. It has been edited by the same skilful compiler, Mr. J. F Muirhead, who has again drawn for as- sistance on the best talent. It is introduced by chapters on the Constitution of Canada by Dr. Boudinot, on geography and geology by Dr. Dawson, and on sports and pastimes by Messrs. Fuller and Chambers. With these are coupled the chief dates in Canadian history anda bibliography. The maps and plans are abundant, and include New York and vieimiuty the Saguenay River, the Rocky Mountains Park of Canada, the coast of British Columbia and Alaska, the chief cities, et New found land, which comes within the scope of this guide-book, is mapped only in nnection with the continent The text is flattery, and is not primarily concerned w patriotism or national vanity On both s of the line the book will be we ed and trusted. The monograph on Thomas Gainsb by Walter Armstrong, which makes up tl September number of the = Macm lan), isa satisfactory piece of work and veys a good idea of the aracter and art the peppery rival of cool Sir Joshua. Gains borough had little literary e and few friendships with literary m and has, there fore, not been embalmed in English lteratur as has Reynolds, whose nan sa house word; but he Was an artist to t finwer-ends and his achievement seems to us a finer ar rarer kind than Revnolds’s ow? Hiow lovely and distinguished bis best work i is w shown by several of tl illustrat ~ WwW are excellent, and convey as mu as black and white can of the works of a st A correspondent in ¢ fay Writes t under date of October U5 ln vour last tss Vour reviewer speculates upon the reas the title of * Lives of Twelve Bad Men Does it not, obviously, refer back t Livesof Tw Good Men. by Dean Burgon, a book ntAin- ing short histories of a doven Oxford worthies, which was published in INSs The article of greatest popular interest the © hica f tetober is Mr J. Theodore Bent’s a nt of his recent expe- dition to the Hadramut in southern Arabia, This isa singular vallev running for a hundred miiles nearly parallel to the ast, and on the average about that distance from it. and inha bited by intenselv fanatical Bedouins and cense and myrrh, no European has succeeded in reaching it till last vear, Mr. Bent’s party being the second. The name means in the Himvyaritic language ‘ valley of death, which ‘in Hebrew form corresponds exactly to that of Hazarmaveth of the tenth chapter of Gene- sis.” It is a fact, interesting especially to Bib- lical students, that the most sacred places in the vallev are the primitive tombs of the le- gendary prophets Saleh and Hud (or Eber, a synonymous term), names which will be found in Genesis in close connection with that of the valley. The appearance of the valley from the arid plateau is very remarkable. It con. . tains some fine and lofty palaces, rich in carv- ing. and ruins of great antiquity, somewhat si- miilar to those found in Seuth Africa, and ex- hibiting a few Himyaritic inscriptions. The jealousy of some of the tribes, however, pre vented any thorough exploration, which Mr. Rent reserves for a second expedition. Dr. Gregory describes the physical geography of British East Africa, and extracts are given from the journal of Captain Larsen kept dur ing the voyage of the Norwegian whaler Jason to the Antarctic regions last winter. The un- usual absence of ice enabled him to trace fora considerable distance south the hitherto unex plored coast of Grabam Land. When farthest south less cold, fog, and snow were encounter- ed than farther north ; a

Page 18

aye SEN So STROSS to, 1 Sa aaa 308 The Nation. [Vol. 59, No. 1530 A rather dry account of Corsica, compact with information, scientific and historical, is contributed by Mr. R. Richardson to the Scot- tish Geographical Magazine for October. The island is suffering at preseut from the repeal in 1888 of the commercial treaty between France and Italy. This has closed its sole market, Italy, as the French do not use the Corsican pine for shipbuilding, nor do they endeavor to develop the considerable mineral wealth of Corsica. Since at least half of the island is covered with forests, the author sug- gests that it would be greatly to the advan- tage of the Corsicans if this portion should be turned into a game preserve. There is an ad- mirable map, showing the forests, the ore- beds, the roads, and even the paths. Mr. E. Durand-Gréville has an interesting essay on ‘‘ Les grains et les orages” (squalls and thunder-storms) in a recent number of the Annales du Bureau Central Météorologique de France, in which he shows the essential con- nection of these two classes of disturbances, when occurring in fully developed form. His work confirms the conclusions of various ear- lier students, and extends them to fuller state- ment and illustration, particularly in connec- tion with a thunder-storm squall that swept over northwestern Europe on April 27, 1890. Its path and progress and the peculiar in- flexion of the isobaric lines at the place of its occurrence are well illustrated. Supplementary to the list of geographical lantern slides prepared for use in the Cam- bridge public schools by Prof. W. M. Davis, a standard list of cloud photographs and lantern slides has been made up from the collections in thé Harvard geographical laboratory by Mr. R. DeC. Ward, assistant in meteorology. There are twenty-eight numbers in the list, which is published, with explanatory notes, inthe Ame- rican Meteorological Journal for July. The prints or slides may be obtained of E. E. Howell, 612 Seventeenth Street, Washington, who also acts as agent for the geographical slides. We read in the Bollettino of the National Central Library of Florence, for September 15, of the steps being taken abroad to carry out the proposal made at Chicago last year of a so- ciety for the autotype reproduction of ‘‘non- tourist” manuscripts—i. e., such MSS. as can- not be loaned out of the library. The proposer, Otto Hartwig, director of the University Libra- ry at Halle, has set in motion W. N. du Rieu, director of the University Library at Leyden, by designating this library as the seat of the proposed organization. Leading librarians have been consulted as to the practical details of operation and maintenance, and an agree- ment is likely to be reached in the course of the present year. —Macmillan & Co. have just published, in two neat volumes, a cheap but well-printed edition of Chaucer's ‘Canterbury Tales,’ pre- pared by Mr. A. W. Pollard. The text follows the Ellesmere MS. in the main, departing from it only under compulsion. The notes, which are at the bottom of the page, have no pretensions to originality or research. They aim to convey such information, in the way of glosses and the clearing up of allusions, as is absolutely necessary to the everyday reader, and in this they are tolerably successful. By a strange error of editorial judgment, these purely practical notes are encumbered with a considerable number of various readings. If variants are in place at all in an edition of this kind—which we doubt, excgpt so far as they are necessary to record departures from the manu- script chosen as the basis of the text~they should, in mercy to the reader, be kept by themselves. The preliminary matter is con- fined to arambling ‘Introduction ” of about thirty pages, which is pleasantly enough writ- ten, but in no way distinguished. The second volume has a brief glossary, which omits refer- ences. Altogether, the edition is not one to be greeted with much enthusiasm, so far as the editor’s work is concerned; but publishers and printer have done their part well, and the volumes are undeniably handy. —The good example which the Bishop of Oxford, Dr. Stubbs (then Regius Professor of Modern History at Oxford), set as long ago as 1870, fh the publication of a convenient collection of original documents for the use of historical students, is at last being fol- lowed by other English scholars. Mr. S. R. Gardiner has recently produced a volume of ‘Constitutional Documents of the Puritan Revolution, 1628-1660’ ; and now Mr. Prothero of King’s College, Cambridge, has supplied us with a companion volume for the preceding period, in his ‘ Select Statutes and Other Con- stitutional Documents Illustrative of the Reigns of Elizabeth and James I.’ (Oxford : Clarendon Press; New York: Macmillan). It is a careful and scholarly piece of work, including a considerable number of official papers very necessary for an under- standing of the period, but hitherto unprinted; and it is preceded by a long, judicious, and dignified introduction. Such a book will be very useful to students of every kind, and it will be especially handy for the purposes of teaching. It is the last thought, however, that somewhat diminishes our satisfaction. The one thing lacking in the book—as in Dr. Stubbs’s ‘Select Charters’—is an account of the sources from which the documents and excerpts are drawn, though most of them are easily accessible in a good library. Such an account would not only have enabled readers the better to appreciate the significance of the passages set before them, but would have sug- gested to at least a few of them that it was not so very difficult to go to the sources for themselves. German historians may have made too much of their ‘‘Quellen” and “ Lit- teratur”; English historians, partly under the influence of the belles-lettristic spirit, partly, asin this case, from a certain school- masterly temper, have certainly made too little of them. The main thing, it may be answered, is that students should understand the period itself, and a few documents care- fully considered may do more to this end than hundreds hastily turned over. This is true, and we would by no means imply that the German method is in all respects the best. And yet it does seem a pity in various ways that men should be able to study history fora couple of years at a great university and dis- tinguish themselves in the examinations, with- out its ever being suggested to them to go to the library shelves and take down the Statutes of the Realm or the Federa. We can hardly be surprised at the little original work that has hitherto come out of the History Schools in Oxford and Cambridge, excellent as their services to England have been in other ways. —M. A. Rebitre publishes as a separate brochure a part of his forthcoming book on ‘ Mathematics and Mathematicians,’ under the title ‘Les Femmes dans la Science’ (Paris: Librairie Nony). By “science” he means, however, only mathematical science. He gives an interesting account, not quite too French, of Hypatia, Madame du ChAtelet, Agnesi, Sophie Germain, Mrs. Somerville, and, great- est of them all, Kovalevsky. In regard to Sophie Germain, he quotes this sentence from Navier apropos of one of her works: ‘‘I ap- preciate as it deserves a memoir so remarkable that few men can read it, and that only one woman could have written it.” He suggests that an epigraph prefixed to one of Poinsot’s books, ‘‘Sophiz germana mathesis,”’ contained an allusion to the fair mathematician. In this connection we may call attention to the fact that the second instalment of Kovalevsky’s ‘Souvenirs d’Enfance,’ which is now ap- pearing in the Rerue de Paris, is a human document of very unusual interest. The cen- tral figure of the picture of life on a Russian estate, so far, is not the mathematician bher- self, but her sister—a remarkable character, whose development is depicted with great dramatic force. —The extent to which therapeutic experi- ments in hypnotic suggestion are exciting the attention of physicians and awakening the interest of the generat public, may be inferred from the fact that during the past year more than a hundred books and brochures, especially devoted to the discussion of this subject, have been published. One of the most valuable of these is the small volume just issued by Bong in Berlin, entitled ‘Die Bedeutung der hyp- notischen Suggestion als Heilmittel.’ The au- thor, Dr. J. Grossmann, editor of the Zeit- schrift fiir Hypnotismus, prints communica- tions from thirty of the most eminent profess- ors and physicians of Europe, giving the re- sults of their experience in the application of hypnotic suggestion to the healing of disease. Thus Van Ceden and Van Reuterghem of Am- sterdam report that from May 5, 1887, to June 30, 1893, in the institution under their charge, 1,098 patients were subjected to this treat- ment; of these 28.28 per cent. were entirely cured, 23.69 per cent. permanently improved, 21.02 per cent. slightly bettered, 17.81 per cent. unaffected, and in 9.18 per cent. of the cases the results are unknown. Dr. Wetterstrand of Stockholm has used this method of medical treatment in 7,000, and Dr. Bernheim of Nancy in 12,000 cases, and both express themselves strongly in favor of it. In- deed, Dr. Bernheim does not hesitate to declare that the study of hypnotic sugges- tion should be made obligatory in all medical schools, and that nowadays a physician who ignores the psychical element in disease, and has no knowledge of the part it plays in pa- thogeny and therapeutics, is no better than a horse-doctor, and should confine himself to ve- terinary practice. Another important point brought out by Dr. Krafft-Ebing of Vienna is the influence of ‘‘ autosuggestion ” in the pro- duction of disease. The number of ailments and morbid conditions of this kind that have their origin in the nervous system and are in- dicated by pains, paralysis, and other symp- toms of bysterical, hypocbondriac, and neuras- thenic affections, is astonishing. Although not merely imaginary complaints, they cease with the removal of the ‘‘ autosuggestive cause,” which may be effected by any change of scene banishing it from the thoughts or by heterosuggestion (Fyremdsuggestion) on the part of a physician, who may impart it ver- bally or in the disguise of a dose of medicine. In obstinate cases, in which the autosuggestion is firmly intrenched in mental imbecility, su- perstition, morbid appetites and passions, in- veterate habits, or abnormities of character, recourse must be had to hypnotism. That the

Page 19

Oct. 25, 1894} The Nation. great majority of mankind are capable of be- ing hypnotized is shown by the experiments of Dr. Freiherr von Schrenk-Notzing of Mu- nich on 8,705 persons of different nationalities, of whom only 6 per cent. proved to be entirely unsusceptible. SKEAT’S CHAUCER.—I. The Complete Works of Geoffrey Chaucer. Edited from numerous manuscripts, by the Rev. Walter W. Skeat, Litt.D., LL.D., ete. Oxford: At the Clarendon Press; New York: Macmillan. 184. Vols. L.-IV. THE appearance of Chaucer's complete works in an edition prepared by so distinguished a scholar as Prof. Skeat may, without exaggera- tion, be called an event of much consequence in the annals of English literature. Chaucer has now been popular, with one or two inter- vals of comparative neglect, for quite five hun- dred years, and his popularity (we are not speaking of mere bookshelf reputation) is steadily growing ; yet there has been no issue of his complete works since 1721. All later editions omit the Boethius and the ‘ Astro- labe.’ Apart from the mere question of abso- lute completeness, however, Prof. Skeat’s vol- umes mark a date in our literary history. Chaucer's poems have been printed over and over again in this century, but in editions for which even their publishers would scarcely claim more than a stop gap importance. The widely circulated Aldine edition is handy in form, and contains Sir Harris Nicolas’s indis- pensable ‘: Life”; but it has no notes, and its text is often grotesquely bad. ‘ Bell’s Chaucer’ was patched up afresh some years ago, and has maintained itself by dint of being inex- pensive and annotated; it too has a poor text, and its notes are not first-rate. The Riverside edition is by its plan restricted to very brief notes, almost exclusively glossarial. Vol- umes of selections intended for educational purposes are beside the question. The pre- sent edition, then, is the first which under- takes to furnish a critical text, founded on serious study of the manuscripts, and to pro- vide all necessary literary and philological ap- paratus. It would be superfluous to descant on Prof. Skeat’s qualifications for this task. His com- mand of Middle English, his long experience in editing manuscripts, hislearning and acuteness, his stupendous industry, and, finally, the na- ture and extent of his special Chaucerian scho- larship, are known wherever our language is studied. The announcement of such a work from such a hand roused very particular ex- pectancy, and its steady progress is matter for congratulation. The four volumes thus far published contain all Chaucer’s writings. The fifth volume will contain notes on the ‘Canter- bury Tales,’ together with ‘‘all necessary helps for the study of Chaucer, such as remarks on the pronunciation, grammar, and scansion ™ the sixth and last volume will furnish the glossary and the index to the whole set. In the present notice we shall confine ourselves to the first three volumes, deferring, for obvious rea- sons, our observations on the fourth, which contains the text of the Canterbury Tales with an introduction ‘on the manuscripts, until the appearance of the fifth volume The annalistic ‘‘Life of Chaucer.” which stands at the head of the edition. is, in its kind, admirable. Written concisely and with creat care, it gives, within the compass of sixty pages, everything known about the poet, with full foot-note references to documents and au- thorities. For Chaucer's birth Mr. Skeat al- lows 1330 and 1340 as possible termini, but opines that shortly before 1340 * fits best with all the facts”—a highly probable conclusion. He sticks to his belief that Chaucer met Pe- trarch in Italy in L873, refusing to admit the ambiguous and nugatory character of the evi- dence; but he does not much fortify his case by arguing that Chaucer could hardly have gota copy of Petrarch’s ‘Griselda’ unless the author gave it to him or helped him to it. His further comments on this transaction (vol. iii., pp. 454, 455) are not in his best style. The Cecilia Chaumpayne affair is too curtly dis missed, but not without a hint that the “little Lowys”™ for whom the ‘ Astrolabe’ was com posed may have been an illegitimate child. Prof. Lounsbury’s interesting discussion is not even referred to The evidence about Thomas Chaucer is well summed up, and we are glad to see that Mr. Skeat admits its cogeney. ‘There is a high probability,” he says, that Thomas was the poet’s son. We have never understood how scholars could refuse credit to Gascoigne’s express testimony, supported as it is by the heraldic argument. In marked contrast to most previous biogra- phers, Mr. Skeat refuses to dilate on the ro- mantie story of disappointed love and un- happy marriage which has been extracted from the poet’s writings by ingenious critics A well-digested list of the personal allusions in Chaucer happily replaces the long-familiar string of surmises and assumptions. In this reserve we detect the influence of the lively protest in Prof. Lounsbury’s recent ‘Studies.’ There is only one hypothesis of the usual sort that Mr. Skeat ‘feels justified in making.” The death of the poet's wife, he believes, was ‘*a serious loss to him in one respect at least. Most of his early works are reasonably free from coarseness; whereas such tales as thase of the Miller,” ete., ‘‘can hardly be defended.” If this conjecture is not a very important contri- bution to knowledge, it is at least harmless One other little departure from his reserve in this kind of biography must be noticed. Chau cer, Mr. Skeat tells us,‘‘ complains feelingly of the somewhat severe pressure of his official duties.” The delightful passage in the ‘ Hous of Fame’ here referred to contains not a word to which any such turn can fairly be given. The poet simply tells us that, when his work is done and his reckonings all made, he goes home to study, instead of taking rest and recreation There is no suggestion of complaint. This bit of overstrained interpretation is repeated in the introduction to the ‘Hous of Fame’ in vol. iii. In his utterances about the chronology of Chaucer's writings, we find Mr. Skeat holding fast to the prevalent opinion that by 15M1 “‘the Canterbury Tales had ceased to make much progress,” or, in other words, that the last nine years of the poet's life werea time of compa- rative barrenness. We could wish he had stated more fully the considerations which led him to subscribe to this opinion. At least he might have made clearer the significant fact that it rests mainly on a biographical conven tion as to the course of any poet's life and the rise and decadence of any poet's powers, It is time for somebody to overhaul the chronologi cal table of Chaucer's works from top to bottom Though the evidence is as scanty as possible, nations “ of philologists ire fast hardening into dogma, with the usual esnuit. Oner ntand peculiarly absurd fancy Mr. Skeat registers | self against. and that s Dr. Koeppel’s belief that the ‘Saint Cecile’ was written after the * Troilus 8309 Besides the Life, volume i. contains the * Ro maunt of the Rose’ and the Minor Poems, with introductions and notes. Mr. Skeat pronounces unequivocally for the first 1,705 werses of the ‘Romaunt’ as genuine, and rejects all the rest Unhappily we cannot be sure that this is bis present view. The introduction is dated, pa renthetically, 1S01—three vears before publica tion. In these three vears the ‘ Romaunt’ con troversy has not been quiet; and Mr. Skeat has been in the thick of the fight. His note on vy. S810, apparently written some time after his introduction, indicates that he was then giving way in his rejection of wy. OST1- Thus It is a great pity that the ordinary device 1 sorted to to keep introductions up te date pagination in Roman numerals—-was neglected in this volume This oversight is not repeated in vols. i. and ii., in which, therefore, we seem to bave a better chance of getting information of the same date as the im] Neither preface nor notes make any mention of Prof. Lounsbury's elaborate attempt ta prove Chaucer the author of “ f ti English *Romaunt.’ This is a ser s omission for which, however, Mr. Skeat has already suffered abundant penalty. Taken to task by an English reviewer, he a inted for his omission in a public letter which was brought to Prof. Lounsburvy’'s notice, and which really demanded a rejoinder In this reple Mi Skeat was pot only aceused of being illogical a rather common quid | ’ among scholars—but, along with all English speaking persons who reject Mr. Lounsburv’s theory Was consigned to the limb f—those wl either lack the literary sense or are suffer ing from “‘its partial paralysis If ina ty to believe in the Chaucerian authorsby { fragment B of the *‘ Romaunt’ were realiv enough to send one packing thither, this lin would indeed be, so far as Middle English scholars are concerned, ‘‘to few unknown for we know of nobody capable of weighing the linguistic evidence who accepts Mr. Louns- burv's extreme views rhe present edition includes all three fragments, but prints the second and third in smaller type. The text has been industriously revised throughout, and the commentary is new and useful The rest of volume i. is occupied by the Mi nor Poems, with a long introduction and very the editor was con- how to use his own vusiy published material Mr. Skeat's vion Press edition of the Minor Poems ling the ‘Hous of Fame’—came out in ISSS. and met with well deserved praise from every quarter. It was less elementary than his selections from the ‘Canterbury Tales” in the same series, and, in fact, needed but slight moditications to make it into an acceptable library edition. Accordingly, in the present volume, and in the part of volume iii. allotted to the ‘ Hous of Fame, we are presented with a revision of the ‘Minor Poems’ of 1888. This is right and proper. The trouble is that the revision has not been quite thorough Indeed, the attempt to use the ISSS volume as copy for the printer has resulted in two or three incon- sistencies for which bibliographers will not be grateful. Of ‘An Amorous Complaint’ Mr. Skeat remarks, in a sentence taken word for word from his former work, that ‘‘this piece, so far as he knows, has never before been printed Farther down on the same page he speaks of “ first printing the text in 1888,” and on the next page he tells what plan he adopted in reprinting the text in the present volume Here the confasion corrects itself, and is there fore merely disfiguring without being decep- ene lee : AA GRO RAO Oe Perego egy oD eee

Page 20

th a A AY Pa de ESD Sees 57 a walle eS Lae The Nation. 310 [Vol. 59, No. 1530 tive; but with regard to the ‘ Balade of Com- pleynt,’ a similar transference from the older work commits the editor to an uncancelled statement that the poem “ has not been printed before,” when, thanks to his own efforts, it has, in fact, been public property ever since 1888, Again, the discussion of Lydgate’s maddening ‘* Dant in English” was in place in section 3 of the introduction to the 1888 volume; in the present edition it should have been carried over to volume iii., in which the ‘ Hous of Fame’ is printed. These criticisms concern what may be called externals. We pass on to examine how far the interval between 1888 and 1894 has been utilized in those processes of minute correction and im- provement which are possible only when a prodromus exists. Here much has been done, but much has been passed over, sometimes de- liberately—the editor maintaining his old posi- tion—sometimes, we fear, hastily. In the com- ments that follow we shall not try to distin- guish between these categories, contenting our- selves with indicating some points in which we had hoped for improvement, or at least for modification, and in which we find no change, or not change enough. Ten Brink in effect retracted the doctrine ascribed to him in the note on ii, 38. Heritage can hardly be in the genitive (ii, 71), nor does the passage demand any twist so extraordinary. In ‘Book of the Duchesse,’ v. 23, no emendation is needed. In the note to the same poem, v. 37, the ‘long, early, and hopeless love theory” is treated with more fa- vor than the ‘‘ Life” had led us toexpect. We are surprised to find Mr. Skeat apparently still taking ‘‘that is doon” as meaning ‘‘ my pas- sion is over’’—a sense which the context re- futes. The note on v. 78 still presents us with an incredible subjunctive. The injudicious in- sertion of look in v. 206 is still insisted on, as well as the unnecessary change of for such to at whiche in the next line. In the note on v. 332 Warton’s remark that ‘‘there is reason to believe that Chaucer copied [certain] image- ries from the romance of Guigemar” is re tained, apparently with approval; yet nobody has ever pointed out in what this ‘‘ reason” consists. In the note to v. 368, Sarrazin’s edi- tion of ‘Octavian’ should have been mentioned. The distorted interpretation of ‘ Book of the Duchesse,’ vv. 1199-1201, is retained. It is due to a failure to recognize the interjectional with sorwe. The punctuation in the text is quite wrong. Mr. Skeat feels the inadequacy of his attempt atexplanation, suggesting, after all, an emendation, but none is necessary. In the note to ‘ Parlement of Foules,’ v. 364, the ex- planation of ‘‘farwel, feldefare” (repeated in the note to ‘ Troilus,’ iii, 861), is unlikely, though given with that confidence which Prof. Skeat has some right to feel, but which may often mislead his disciples. In v. 411 the remark about this is and this is incomplete in its re- ferences, and erroneous in its statement that neither this nor is has an ictus in the present line. The particularly unhappy explanation of v. 510 is retained. In v. 556 ‘his large golee” hardly means ‘ his tedious gabble”; both con- text and humor are against it. In ‘Former Age,’ forpampered is rather “spoilt by pam- pering” than ‘‘exceedingly pampered.” In the ‘ Envoy to Scogan,’ v. 15, it is really too bad to explain goddes as goddesse—i. e., Venus. In v. 7 of the same poem ‘ error” must mean abnormality, not ‘ignorance, false opinion.” We observe that Mr. Skeat is still sure that Lydgate meant the ‘ Hous of Fame’ by “ Dant in English.” For our part we cannot inter- pret Lydgate either in this’ phrase or in the context. Mr. Skeat’s explanation does not carry conviction. In connection with ‘Chau- cer’s Dreme’ (p. 44), Brandl’s allegorical inter- pretation is not mentioned, though it has met with some favor. The remark that ‘‘‘The Dreme of a Lover’ is the same poem, I sup- pose, as ‘The Temple of Glas’” should not have survived, in that form, in a volume dated 1894. The statement (p. 63) that the familiari- ty with the ‘Roman de la Rose’ shown by Chaucer in the ‘ Book of the Duchesse’ ‘‘ is such as to prove that he had already been employed in translating it,” should not stand without a caveat. We regret that Mr. Skeat maintains his opinion about the genuineness of the ‘‘en- voy” of ‘Flee from the Press.’ ‘‘ There is no reason at all for considering it spurious,” he says (p. 553). Two reasons are discernible: (1) it exists in but a single manuscript; (2) it is poor and spoils a beautiful poem. It is cu- rious, by the way, that no editor of Chaucer has yet noted that ‘Flee from the Press’ occurs in Tottel’s Miscellany, among the ‘‘son- nets and songs of incertain authors.” ‘TRILBY’ AND OTHER NOVELS. Lord Ormont and his Aminta. By George Meredith. Charles Scribner’s Sons. Trilby. By George Du Maurier. Harper & Bros. The Maneman. By Hall Caine. D. Apple- ton & Co, Highland Cousins. By William Black. Har- per & Bros. Vignettes of Manhattan. By Brander Mat- thews. Harper & Bros. THE story and the exposition are as easily separable in ‘Lord Ormont and his Aminta’ as in any of Mr. Meredith’s novels. Such a method has advantages; the many who take’ their fiction lightly can get, in an idle hour, an assured outline sharply accented with dra- matic situations, can smile, sigh, forget, and go about their business; the few who take- their fiction seriously have matter for solemn consideration and endless perplexity. Wrath- ful discontent may fill the souls of those who clamor for a fusion of parts into a symmetri- cal whole, who prefer a smooth highroad to a blazed trail; but let such eschew Mr. Meredith —they cannot walk together. He cannot help himself. His work is the product of two inde- pendent sets of faculties, or else of one human set and that useful adjunct which theosophists call an astral. An astral is like an oracle: plain speaking would ruin its reputation. It demands a special cult, and only the elect may interpret. In considering Mr. Meredith's dis- quisitions we cling to the hypothesis of an as- tral, for by frankly admitting incompetence to wrestle with superhuman powers our opi- nions may not be branded as quite below a decent standard of intelligence. The story of Lord Ormont and his Aminta is very pretty and interesting, pitched in a ro- mantic key as its name indicates, with a cen- tral situation and at least two characters, Lord Ormont and his sister, Lady Charlotte, unavailable for a chronicler of this moment of the collapse of caste, yet consistent with the ascribed period, and done with succinct- ness, clearness, and force. The drama is old, older than the lines, “ Crabbed age and youth Cannot live together ”; and the outcome is probably inevitable, if the sweet shepherd be high and the damsel ‘or dame inviting in ways as unmistakable as the tuneful lay. Things that are inevitable are not always right or just or admirable, and he is a wise man and a good artist who in fiction lets his doubtful case rest on the facts and feel- ing, attempting no argumentative justification. When Aminta and her high-minded young lover go off together, the venture appears na- tural, and plausible palliation is readily im- agined; but when we are counselled to observe an imperative urgency for such a proceeding other than human desire, and resting on a personal interpretation of divine law, then we reflect that Aminta had no case against Lord Ormont presentable even in a Sioux City di- vorce court, and we refuse to admit that black is white. Here we arrive at Mr. Meredith’s exposition, which, according to his privileged interpreters, is a thing for wonder and reverence. To ap- proach it in a plain, blunt way, we may say that it is not elucidatory; the thought which sufficient grim patience will finally extract is hidden in artificial form and eccentric phrase- ology; the pronouns avoid their nouns as care fully as the last part of a German compound verb shuns the first; floundering sentences laden with unusual words of Greek extraction alternate with interjections in crude vernacu- Jar. There is no fluency, no grace, no lucidity —nothing but an occasional outburst of epi- gram to redeem page after page from chaos ; and yet a small and precious group is positive in declaring that Mr. Meredith will pass into an English classic—for his style, of course, since it is style that lives. We have some English prose classics, and a hasty mental retrospect over two centuries suggests that a schoolgirl could parse every page, and that perception of the thought and of the lucidity and exactness of expression is simultaneous. The tests are slight, perbaps mean, but not wholly worthless for basing prophecy. English judges by es tablishing precedent frequently achieve fame; if Mr. Meredith is to live as a great master of Ynglish style, it will be (pace high-priests) for the same reason. P Picture the consternation among the savants of unborn ages falling upon a volume of Mr. Meredith’s novel and Mr. Du Maurier's ‘ Tril- . by’ simultaneously! If one be a specimen of later nineteenth-century English, what under heaven is, or was, the other? Grammarians will burn their books and there shall be norules laid down for the barbarous dead language without an interminable string of exceptions. As tough bits for construing, the authors, we believe, will prove about equally seductive, and those works now regarded as classics ap- pear in comparison as primers. Mr. Meredith’s English is as positively and indisputably his own as are his eyes and hair, and Mr. Du Mau- rier’s English (when it isn’t French) is that tongue, far from undefiled, which is babbled by the million, stamped with the flitting fashion of the hour, fluently and brilliantly up to date. For a thinly disguised personal me- moir, which we take this book to be as surely as if the author had frankly owned it, no lan- guage could be more vivid, no manner more attractive. The style, compared with -that of ‘Peter Ibbetson,’ falls short in delicacy, finish, and repose; but then that was a delibe- rately planned tragedy done with becoming gravity, whereas the really important and in- teresting matter in ‘Trilby’ makes no demand for serious and dignified expression. The love story on which the sketches of per- sons, scenes, and events are strung is effusively sentimental and unimpressive. Trilby’s de- voted love for Little Billee is a graceful as- sumption not made credible ; and indeed the

Page 21

Oct. 25, 1894]

The Nation. Sit

vivacious grisette, wherever she is asserted to differ from and soar above any Mimi or Nanon or Lisette of the Latin Quarter in fact or fic- tion, is herself a fiction, a fantasy, a dream. When an author makes good in action his as- sertions about a character, he has created something ; there is no smug-self-complacency in beholding his Work and exclaiming, Well done ! It would be bard for Mr. Du Maurier to make good his ecstatic chaunts to Trilby, and, perhaps, vaguely conscious of an impossi- bility, he has not concerned himself about the matter at all. His beautiful pictures of her, especially the portrait head, are quite con- vincing as to her physical loveliness, but there are certain beauties of character and conduct of which a charming face and figure unfortu- nately give no assurance. Many can yield to that charm to the extent of saying, ‘* Poor Trilby!” but few can heartily cry, ‘ Vir- tuous, hercic, sublime Trilby!” It is odd, and we think an evidence of the small pains bestowed on the realization of the charac- ter, that the author permits her, with her own hand, to repudiate his encouraging ad- jectives, and decline to be regarded as a Na- turkind, knowing not good from evil. In the fit of shame born of Little Billee’s horfor at finding her posing for the nude in an atelier, she writes a letter which, among other curious information, contains the names of the men with whom she has had temporary liaisons, and the comment : ‘I knew how wrong it was all along—there is no excuse for me—none.” Be it observed, too, that she writes this letter to a man (clean minded and honest, but still a map), and one cannot feel that that is a thing to be admired as a genuine first step towards the strait gate and the narrow way. It may be remarked here, parenthetically, that the dislike, amounting to horror, felt by Taffy, the Laird, and Little Billee, of Trilby’s posing for the ‘‘altogether,”’ doesn't jibe with the author’s authoritative declaration that to all artists (except those whom he thinks very lit- tle of) ‘‘nothing is so chaste as nudity.” If this be true, why was not Trilby’s exhibition of her body regarded as a practical lesson in the encouragement of high thought and fine feeling, salutary both for herself and the star- ing mob of heathen ” When Trilby, intimidated by her lover's re- spectable relatives, runs away from friends and lovers, there is a suspicion that she has gone in chase of a similar respectability; but her reappearance, singing like a thousand nightingales under the magic influence of Svengali, removes her from the commonplace, quite from the actual, clean into fairyland. Frankly acknowledged as a creature outside of human experience, she is well used as a splen- did centrai figure for thrilling dramatic scenes. Would that we had been spared her lingering death, with all the display of her ca- tholic taste in men implied by the perpetual fondling of her dear, clean, living Englishmen, and lamentation over her equally dear, dirty, dead Polish Jew. <A sigh, scarce a tear, may be given to Little Billee taking her demise so much to heart. Still, in moments of anguish, he could not hope to have for ever the support of Taffy’s strong arm and the solace of bis bed; so, having achieved fame and loved and lost, it was perhaps well that he should depart and be at peace. Though, in reviewing * Trilby,’ apology for particularizing defects in the presentation of the title character is superfluous, we offer one, for it limits the opportunity to dwell upon the pleasure given by all the rest. It may be ob jected that no group of people ever is or was

so adorable as most of the company in which we walk, but the first test is that Mr. Du Maurier makes makes Svengali appear the most loathsome of men, justifying by the wretch’s behavior an amazing torrent of vituperative description Long ago, how he must have hated a Sven- gali, and’ how he must have loved a Taffy and a Laird and all that gay, kind, happy company who call to mind our Thackeray and Miirger and Dumas and Béranger, yet make each a place in the heart distinctively his own. For we return to the impression that the author has narrated things which he him- self saw and of which he was a part, and when them appear so He also he was not, as he says he now is, a ‘‘ respect- able old Briton of the upper middle class,” but a genial and even frolicsome young Briton emancipated from class by his sympathies and genius. And by casting back over a long line of years, between memory and imagination, he has written chapters of real life glorified by the most tender and enchanting romance —told us of a dead past all radiant, and glow- ing now with the purple light of a vanished youth. Certain ancient axioms enshrine such highly concentrated, frozen truth that struggle to discredit them is vain and profitless. It is with reluctance that we number among these ‘**A woman’s face is her fortune,” because we are heartily in sympathy with every move ment which tends to indicate for women roads to fortune more immediately in their own con trol. Unless there be a conspiracy among the accredited delineators of contemporary life, the gentlemen novelists, to stifle either by ridicule or neglect movements dangerous to masculine supremacy, we are compelled to be lieve that the women of to-day, in divers mass- meetings assembled, are but frantically beat ing their heads against stone walls, and that the important issues of life are still decided for them by nature, as it was in the beginning That the small fry should indite innumerable histories turning on the look ina girl's eyes or the shape of her nose, is a trifle, signifying nothing; but from novelists, arrived, for va rious reasons, a t eminence and in many di rections abreast with the times, a recognition of the infiuence of a girl’s mind on her destiny may not unreasonably be expected. It is true that Mr. Meredith, Mr. Du Maurier. and Mr Caine in ‘The Manxman,’ do labor to ascribe to their heroines some g limmer of intelligence, some graces and virtues not immediately per ceptible to the naked eye perfunctory—eversthing turns on an accident of line and color. would have missed the em: t ut the effort is Perhaps Mr. Caine’s novel tional effects of dramatic contrast had he endowed Kate Cre geen with attractions less obvi a handsome animal; yet, with Philip Christian's intellectual refinement and fundamental good- us than those of ness of nature always in evidence, the feeling is that the temptation offered was not enough, and that his final expiation « 7 sin Was an ex- aggeration of the requirements of honor and morality Such would surely if Mr. Caine had undertaken to question of conduct;

roundings, ceptional. His insistent manded first stand well that be s! sight of G ances, the first bet: his wit : a id Christian's hy a

circumstan himself, strive He t to but a m with the reflection that he or typifying * be the judgment solve an abstract fication comes uli is not generalizing character, his sur- Ss are all ex- mental rectitude de of all, for peace, that he should and his spirituality , m~ acce ‘table in the : rof false appear- and when, after villi »- 7 Wuilliam’s trust,

he saw abysses of infamy gaping before him

he was not able to make an escape at the cost of Quilliam's despair. So he kept on doing abominable things, always a prey to the most poignant was nothing left but death or publi and open assumption of all the consequences of his own and Kate Cregeen’s sins. His choice of the nately the Isle of Man appears to remain as a self-aceusation, till, at last. there ¢ onfession,

latter course was heroic, and fortu proper scene for a display of dramatic passio which elsewhere would seem th sland in probably sensational The conception of Christian's character is

grand and tragic, and the permanent shadow of doom serves only to concentrate interest on the motive, not diminishing the natura ness of the movement or bampering the v ring talitv of the minor figures. The plan of the book is verv wide—as wide as the lift f its locality—drawn with consummate art and px fected by scrupulous care in detail. Ina work that implies so much deliberate arrangement the absence of artificiality and of strained in vention Is most noticeable If there be such an inexplicable force as inspiration capable of possessing a man and abiding with him unt the work which he has t le is dome. w al willing to believe that Mr. Ca \ l Manxman’ under its influence Mr. Black makes no sort of essions t the woman movement The Barbara Maclean whom he celebrates in * Highland Cousins * has marvellous Highland eves and wondrous erinkly hat: Most f her inst ts a wrong, most f her impulses are vulga nevertheless, she NSpres PMssion | the as cetic breast of a handsome, scholarly. and very dull voung man, whom, when pique by the frigidity of another voung man, sl reluctantly marries. Eventually s! lies jail, whither the law, insensible to the charm lufer it and hair. bas removed her for stealing om a draper's s hop We have no cet vy an illustration of the bereaved hus band standing with an appropriate air of de jection beside a tombstone, and bv his second marriage as subsequently chronicled A con siderable fraction of the average human life is needed for the writing of a book, even worthless one, and we cannot pretend to ar rive at Mr. Black's reasons for devoting that fracthk f inanity and ignorance. We prefer to think 8 largely to the doings of a monument } } that he really meant to write a book in glori fication of golf: but since the game. cheerful and invigorating though it is uld not be made to run through four hundred pages, he fell into wrote Wil Mr. Black has written up many games and musical vogue, but we recall no description in which despondency between ‘ holes,” and thout rhyme or reason. In his day L instruments at the moments of thei he is so spirited as in this of the once national now almost universal, game of golf Golf brings out character mostly of as meanness, spite, vainglory, and a marked ney in blasphemy. If Mr. Black had yermitted the village minister to play with the 2 proficie I col uncillor, what awful revelations might have been made! But we are thankful for bis game whoe’er the players, and deplore its unhappy juncture with a romance so meaningless, chill, and dreary. In ‘ Vignettes of Manhattan” Mr. Matthews renders twelve impressions of New York with the vf the skies, admira ble clearness and much grace. Froin } great cilV under summer and wurtel ‘ i na vivid picture may be draw its unrest and immense variety of 1m

a bad sort, such

a nace ne 4H ea enema Sime Ne ott

Paap gr rn OE ings 9 ne etivniinnninall

Page 22

CS <i ola oes PDEs. a Bohs Me Bee Bsc 29 cares SBS 65s TE SEE SS 312 terest, and of the horrible detachment of the individual from the life swarming about him. Some of the impressions include a complete episode, others give only a hint of an incident, as it were, a conjecture from a face seen ata window, a figure noted on a crossing. Occa- sionally there is a discordance between what, for lack of a better expression, may be called the human note and the sentiment of the scene. A suggestion more harmonious than that of relentless jealousy might have been elicited from the gayety and suavity of ‘‘A Private View.” The violent death of Clay Magruder jars on the stillness of ‘‘ A Midsummer Night,” and the only relief to shocked sensibilities lies in the reflection that upper corridors of burn- ing hotels do not fall in before smoke has pene- trated the rooms opening upon them. Slight defects in art do not, however, seriously im- pair the good effect of the whole, and may easily be forgotten before the distinguished excellence of sucha bit as ‘‘A Thanksgiving- Day Dinner.” There the agreement of scene, sentiment, and incident is absolute, while a dozen pages include two telling sketches of character and a whole tragic history, with the reason of it.

Life and Letters of Erasmus: Lectures de- livered at Oxford 1893-94, by J. A. Froude. Charles Scribner’s Sons. 1894. Just twenty-four years ago, Mr. Froude de- livered before a popular audience at Newcastle three lectures upon ‘‘The Times of Erasmus and Luther,” which were afterward printed in the first volume of his ‘Short Studies on Great Subjects.’ Now, as Regius Professor of Modern History, he comes back to the same topic, and reads to the students of Oxford twenty lectures upon the life and letters of the great scholar of the North. One would expect that the differ- ence in his audience would have made some difference in the method of his work: that in lectures addressed to the highest body af stu- dents in the land we should find something of the method, if not of the machinery, of scholar- ship. We should fancy that the man holding the highest position in the English academic world would wish to leave upon his student au- dience some impress different from that which he would hope to make upon the ‘ intelligent public.” Of such distinction, however, we find little trace. Mr. Froude’s style is here, as always, lively to the point of gayety. It bristles with pithy generalities which, upon occasion, take the place of matter more to the point. He has the literary sense which enables him to select the dramatic moments in his subject and to put them together in telling fashion. These lectures are interesting reading, and ought to have been attractive to Oxford students as an evening’s entertainment; but one cannot help wondering what must be the mental comments of the higher student body which finds its high- est university authorities dealing out such pabulum as this. We are not informed as to the actual attendance upon these lectures; it would be safe to assume that the casual visitor and the Oxford young person formed the bulk of the audience, for it has long been an open scandal of the English universities that their great, lights cannot get a hearing from the students. Professors have complained, doubt- less with good reason, that this neglect was be- cause their instruction was not aimed at the examination test, which seems likely to work woe upon English scholarship. Students have replied that the professors’ lectures were not worth their serious attention; and the students’

The Nation. contention, if we may judge from the present volume and from the specimens with which this country has been regaled, has very much to be said for it. In fact, the chief interest of these lectures is as an indication of the standard which the highest English academic authority sets for the instruction to be given by its chiefest orna- ments. Mr. Froude says that if you want to understand both a man and his time, you can- not do better than to study his letters; and so, from beginning to end, he makes not a refer- ence to anything but the letters of Erasmus. Unquestionably, to write of a man without using his letters would be the rankest folly, but to use nothing else is hardly wiser. To ac- cept Erasmus’s written estimate of himself is too much even for Mr. Froude, but he helps him- self out with ‘‘ probably” and ‘‘ perhaps,” in- stead of seeking in other sources for evidence which might serve to correct the impression of the letters. According to Mr. Froude, the keynote of Erasmus’s character is independence, and on the whole we are inclined to agree with him. If we apply this test to the supreme trial of the great scholar’s life, his attitude towards the Lutheran reform is more easily explained on this theory than on any other. He desired above all else to keep himself from entangle- ments. All his life he refused to identify him- self with any organization, even with any country. As he was a citizen of the world, equally at home—or rather equally not at home—in England, France, Switzerland, or Holland, so he would not commit himself to any party. His restless genius would not keep him contented in any one place, nor would it allow him torest happy in any one set of ideas. All parties wanted him, and it precisely suit- ed the independence as well as the vanity of the scholar to keep himself wanted by all par- ties. This thread is maintained by Mr. Froude with admirable clearness and consistency. His treatment of the letters tends towards this re- sult. Such portions of them have been select- ed as would bear on his main line of thought, and the translation bas been skilfully managed; it is seldom an actual translation, but rather a free version in highly idiomatic English. As regards Mr. Froude’s second proposition, that one best studies an age through the eyes of one independent man of letters, that is perhaps less true than he would have us believe. Certain- ly in Erasmus’s case the very complicated politics of his times gets little attention from him excepting as it bears upon his personal affairs. He was as little a politician as he was an organizer of reform. One would have fancied that an academic audience would have been glad to hear some- thing of the great mass of literature which has gathered about the name of Erasmus—the edi- tions, the commentaries, the biographies; but of all this not a word. Such an accompani- ment would ill suit with the tone of cheerful entertainment which runs through these pages. Entertaining they are ; and if, as we believe, the general impression of the character and position of a great man here given is the true one, we may, as general readers, be content.

Essays in Historical Chemistry. By T. E. Thorpe, Professor of Chemistry in the Royal College of Science, South Kensington. Mac- millan & Co. 1894. {nN this volume Prof. Thorpe has collected ten addresses and lectures which he has delivered at various times, and to audiences of very dif-

[Vol. 59, No. 1530 ferent type, during the past eighteen or twenty years, and three articles which have appeared in as many different periodicals. Making no pretension to be a history of chemistry, even during the period covered by its narratives, the book presents a series of biagraphical sketches which are ‘‘put together with the object of showing how the- labors of some of the greatest masters of chemical science have contributed to its development.” The essays are arranged in historical sequence, beginning with a lecture on Robert Boyle, continuing with sketches of Priestley, Scheele, Cavendish, Lavoisier, Faraday, Graham, Wéhler, Dumas, Kopp, and Mendeleeff, and concluding with an address on the ‘‘ Rise and Development of Synthetical Chemistry.” The great variety of occasion for which these essays were originally prepared has left its mark upon them; the discussion of details of chemical accomplishment which forms the principal part of the longer essays on Graham and Kopp being in striking contrast with the more popular treatment which renders most of the others so readable. The chemist will not quarrel with the essayist on this account, how- ever, but will rather be grateful to him for so full and adequate a summary of the labors of these eminent investigators. In reading these admirable and scholarly essays one is unavoid- ably impressed with their resemblance, in ease and clearness, to the felicitous biographical sketches which Hofmann gave us from time to time as memorials of the scientific worthies of the Continent. Prof. Thorpe bas in most in- stances well preserved the human interest in his treatment. The men appear not merely as chemists and investigators, but also as citi- zens of the world. The estimate of their work is, on.the whole, discriminating and just. In the ‘‘Honorable Robert Boyle, seventh son of the Great Earl of Cork,” born in 1626, the year of Bacon’s death, the ‘‘sceptical, in- quiring, reforming spirit” of the age found its expression in the domain of natural science. Under the title of the ‘Sceptical Chymist : or Chemico-Physical Doubts and Paradoxes touch- ing the Experiments, whereby vulgar Spagy- rists are wont to endeavour to evince their Salt, Sulphur, and Mercury to be the true Principles of Things,’ Boyle published anony- mously in 1661 a book which attracted imme- diate and eager attention not only in England, but on the Continent, where no less than ten Latin editions of it appeared. ‘‘In its revolt against mere authority, in its disdain of old- world notions, and in its ill-concealed contempt for the schoolmen, it so exactly caught and expressed the spirit of the time that it instant- ly arrested the attention of the learned world, and . . . of that infinitely larger public of thinking men who felt a growing impatience of the dogmas of the schools.” Boyle, with his disciples Hooke and Mayow, founded the first school of scientific chemistry, and was a mem- ber of the so-called ‘‘ Invisible College, an as- sembly of learned and curious gentlemen who applied themselves to the study of experimen- tal science,” out of which grew the Royal So- ciety of London, incorporated by Charles II. in 1663. ‘‘The growth of the new philosophy excited the jealousy and anger of those who affected to see in the ascendancy of the Bacon- ian method the subversion of everything that was orderly and of good repute. . . . Bish- ops anathematised; Hobbes . . . thundered, Butler lampooned.” But in spite of rough usage the Society continued to grow and pros- per, and science even became fashionable. Prof. Thorpe closes bis summary of the ‘Sceptical Chymist’ by saying: ‘‘I bave pur-

Page 23

Ae eee SRR Oct. 25, 1894]

posely quoted very largely from it, for I wished to show you, in Boyle’s own words, how won- derfully near much of the philosophy of the seventeenth century is to that which we are too apt to regard as the outcome of the nine- teenth. It is impossible to exaggerate the im- portance of Boyle’s labors. . . . The work exhibits in an eminent degree Boyle's character as an investigator,’ his strength and his weak- ness. ‘But tosay that Boyle is only inferior to Bacon and Newton is to assign him one of the first niches in the Walhalla of the heroes of science.” ‘‘ The ‘ Sceptical Chymist’ sealed the fate of the doctrine of the fria prima, and before the close of the century the Paracel- sians were as much out of date as a Phlogis tian would be to-day.” Priestley, theologian and chemist, the ‘ Fa- ther of Pneumatic Chemistry,” the keen and forcible controversialist, is a notable figure in the history of chemistry. Indefatigable and successful in his experimental work, he failed to see the important bearing of his chief dis- covery. “The discovery of oxygen was the death- blow to Phlogiston. Here was the thing which had been groped for for years and which many men had even stumbled over in the searching, but had never grasped.” ‘*The knowledge which Priestley . . . im- parted to the French chemists was used by them with crushing effect against his favorite theory. . . . Priestley, however, never sur- rendered. . . When age compelled him to leave his labor atory, he continued to serve the old cause in his study, and almost his last publication was his ‘Doctrine of Phlogiston Established.’ His own life, indeed, affords an exemplification of the truth of his own words, that ‘we may take a maxim so strongly for granted that the plainest evidence of sense will not entirely change, and often hardly mo- dify, our persuations; the more ingenious a man is, the more effectually he is entangled in his errors, his ingenuity only helping him to deceive himself by evading the force of truth.’ ” ‘That be was content to rest in the faith of Stahl’s great generalization . is the more re- markable when we recall the absolute sinc erity of the man, his extraordinary receptivity, and, as hesays of himself, his proneness * to em- brace what is generally called the heterodox side of almost every question.’ ” Of Scheele, Prof. Thorpe says: “An obscure apothecary, living. ..ina small town on the shore of a Scandinavian lake, hampered by poverty and harassed by debt, hypochondriacal, and, at times, the vic- tim of the most depressing melancholy, be yet succeeded, by the sheer force of his genius as an experimentalist, and under the influence of a passion which defied difficulty and triumphed over despair, in changing the entire aspect of a science. No man ever served chemistry 3 with more interested devotion than Scheele ‘Diese edel Wissenschaft,’ he wrote to his friend Gahn, ‘ist mein Auge.’ When every legitimate deduction has been made, Scheele’s work .. . stamps him as the greatest chemi- cal discoverer of his age.” ‘*Cavendish, a scion of a great house, was cold, retiring, reticent, passively selfish, a confirmed misogynist, a sora of noise and bustle. It was said of him that he probably uttered fewer words in the course of his four- score years than any man who ever lived so long—not even excepting the monks of La Trappe. . Mr. Cavendish rarely did violence to his love of solitude by asking any one to his house. If a friend chanced to dine with him, he was invariably treated to a leg of mutton, and nothing else. We are told that on one occasion, three or four guests being expected, he was asked what was to be got for dinner. He replied with the customary for- mula, ‘A leg of mutton.’ ‘ But,’ said the ser- vant, ‘that will not be enough for five.” ‘Then get two legs,’ was his answer.” These few extracts will serve to show some- thing of the quality of these essays, which many besides chemists will find very interest- ing and enjoyable reading. The Nation.

Chinese Characteristics, By Arthur H. Smith. Fleming H. Revell Co. Axpovt four years ago this book was published at Shanghai and was widely read throughout the English-speaking part of the world east of the Ganges. A few copies reached the United States, one of which we read; and, probably like all other present or former residents of the Far East, we were struck with the singular penetration, learning, and sympathy of the author. The book was generally accepted by students in the Far East as not only one of the ablest analyses and portrayals of the Chinese character, but on the whole one of the most truthful and judicial. In its first dress it was cheaply published, but now, in its second edi- tion, not only has it been revised and enriched with illustrations, but it exhibits a handsome, wide-margined page, with good print and binding, and a well-madeindex, thus becoming worthy of a high place of honor in the Chinese library. Twenty-two years’ residence among the peo- ple, with command of their language, has en- abled Mr. Smith to see the Chinese asthey are While pitilessly telling the truth, there is no- thing of the cynic about him. On the contra- ry, every page shows the author's kindness of heart and willingness to set forth the facts in both the light and the shade. Even in treat- ing as he does with philosophical power of the religions of China, he shows how great these conservative forces are in holding Chinese so ciety together and in keeping up a fair stan- dard of murals. He points out the entire free- dom of the Chinese classical works from any- thing which could debase the minds of the readers. There is not a single sentence in the whole of the sacred books and their annota- tions that may not be read aloud in any Chris tian family. He quotes with approval I: Legge’s remark that ‘‘on the last three of the four things which Confucius delighted to teach —letters, ethics, devotion of soul, and truth fulness—his utterances are in harmony both with the law and the Gospel.” Mr. Smith opens his discussions by treatit ot the Chinese ** face,” which term not only refers to the physiognomy, but is a compound noun of multitude with more meanings than the foreigner is able to describe or mpre hend. The Chinese have a strongly dramati instinct, and the theatre may be almost said t be the only national amusement. Upon very slight provocation any Chinese regards | self in the light of an actor inadrama. The

Chinese does not care much about losing his | life, but he does like to save his face—-that is, the appearance of things; an lit may be he will give his face in exchange for his soul. A Chinese district magistrate was allowed to be beheaded in his robes of office, because, though earing little for his head, he was thus able to save his face Chapters on the amazingly minut ’ and unintermitting industry of the Chinese follow. In the matter of politeness in daily intercourse the vast populations of the Chinese Empire are our superiors, as the most bigoted critic of the Chinese is forced te admit. Nevertheless, this excellence is not purchased without loss. The Chinese have an amazing disregard of time and of accuracy, and withal a positive talent for misunderstanding and for latter often exhibiting itself , “is which sbow an al-

indirection—the in various literary met

f pedantry. Indeed, the underlying causes of the present war between Japan and China have arisen as much out of peccadilloe

of pen, ink, and paper as from overt acts, diplo matic or military. The Chinaman is intellectu

ally turbid. There seems to be in bi ‘OUI para tively, an absence of nerves, and the author after giving many amusipg and striking illus trations of stic, asks Whiet is the best adapted vet struggles the twentieth century, the ‘nervous’ Eur pean, or the tireless, ali-pervading, and } RK matic Chinese?” The auth i sses tl contempt of the Chinamen f foreigners, al that absence of public spirit w t Is SO AS tonishing, and which may vet cause then loss of their nationality Yet int Is possible that the Chinese hav “ multiplication, degenerated The Book Odes, one of the most ancient of their classics contains this prayer uttered by the husband man: **May it rain first } . and afterwards extend t r opr nes Though almost totally indifferent ¢t fort and convenience, the Chinese are patient and persevering, and have a physical vitality which, in both the individual and the mass, is one of the wonders of the world. The people are content and cheerful, precminent in filial } piety, and markedly benev ion, but have little or no svmpathy with indi vidual suffering. Social typhoons ssionally arise, which keep society ft 1 utt stagna ion; but, though the social machinery ofte: creaks and sometimes under extreme pressur bends, it seldom actually breaks beneath tt strain; for. as the author says the Chinese body politic is provided with litt sacs of la bricating fluid, distilled, a drop at a exactly when and where thev a Thhost needed.” Most of the Chinese quarrels ar reviling matches, in which low language a high words are the chief features. W

tual responsibility and respeet for Law tlh : also mutual suspicion, and sincerity is usually nS} + by its absen i I ses s} hiv ri © and sugwestive kW a il tl ‘ t ‘ i ry ent needs r nanifold needs of China w x t a sing werativ ™ ‘ b * il ‘ \ . iv t \ } Bostem S flit I ed by Al Morse ; af it Pn ‘ NI ' nD A ‘ ce rca enten at at ;

Sn aE RO Em ee

Page 24

gs voi PTA ES SARE ie es re Tie SF Pro es RDA ean RSE” SARL OOM Ne aE a 314 The Nation. [Vol. 59, No. 153 Macaulay will prepare his picture of colonial days. That library now numbers less than a dozen of such diaries, but we may well hope that every publication of a family manuscript will encourage another. Witnesses to the Unseen, and Other Essays. By Wilfred Ward, author of ‘William George Ward and the Oxford Movement,’ * William George Ward and the Catholic Revival.’ Macmillan & Co, Mr. WARD makes a needless concession to the ‘indolent reviewers” in an introduction in which he explains the purpose of each one of the six essays in this collection. The interest and value of his books on bis father’s part in the ‘Oxford Movement” and the ‘ Catholic Re- vival” establish his right to our attention as often as he chooses to address us. He in- herits a good deal of his father’s dialectical ability. Students of the modern Roman Catholic mind in its most subtle manifesta- tions would do well to consider him. Promi- nent as was his father in that ‘insolent fac- tion,” as Newman called it, which was eager for the definition of papal infallibility, he has for the Cardinal the warmest admiration, and in two of these essays makes him the special subjectof treatment, and prominent in a third, while in another, ‘‘The Wish to Believe,” we have the expression of a mind which has nourished itself on Newman’s ‘Grammar of Assent.’ The principal object of that fasci- nating work was to show howcredibility might be converted into plausibility and plausibility into certainty in theological matters. Here we have a similar process—the endeavor to justify ‘the wish to believe” as a factor in the production of a rational belief. Unquestion- ably the wish to obtain some rational and bracing view of universal relations is legiti- mate; it is the inspiration of the most serious studies. But the wish to believe in any par- ticular theological nostrum is not a circum- stance favorable to the discovery of the truth concerning it. In the first essay, the ‘‘ Witnesses to the Unseen” are Kant and Newman and Tenny- son; for have we not Kant’s ‘Practical Rea- son” in spite of his “ Critical,” and Newman's conviction that ‘‘a thousand difficulties do not make one doubt,” and Tennyson’s ‘ Voice within the breast” triumphant over ‘‘the rea- son’s colder part” ? Now, Heine’s account of Kant’s conjuring of God and Immortality with the Categorical Imperative—‘‘old Lampe must have a God”—hints at a very general impression of the sentimental aspect of his doctrine of the Practical Reason. Mr. Ward thinks that Huxley, when he said he could compile a primer of infidelity from New- man’s writings, paid an unconscious tribute to their worth. But what Huxley had in mind was not the scepticism which Newman en- | deavored to refute, but that which is inherent | in the substance of his own thought and feel- ing. As for Tennyson’s emotional reactions from the visions of his pessimistic fancy, they will be of little service to those who are seek- ing some rational escape from rational diffi- culties. “The Clothes of Religion” pokes some admirable fun at Spencer’s “Infinite and Eternal Energy” and Harrison’s “Religion of Humanity”; but what would become of Mr Ward if Mr. Harrison should bring his caustic wif to bear on kis position? The paper “New Wine in Old Bottles” has a very special interest at the present time in view of the Pope's recent letter on the subject of Biblical Inter- pretation. Weare told how much better the Roman Catholics would have managed with a book like ‘ Lux Mundi’: ** A Catholic book on similar lines would be necessarily tentative, and would be liable to many hierarchical grades of revision and re- consideration. It might be condemned as dangerous or inopportune, yet much of it might be ultimately adopted astrue. It might be approved by an ecclesiastical superior (as in a recent case in France) and then censured by a more authoritative tribunal. And yet _such a double fact need not prevent much of the substance of the book from being fin: ally de- clared consistent with Catholic doctrine.” Certainly not--when it should become evi- dent that the Church was kicking against the pricks. Soon or late we shall probably have the whole body of modern science approved by the infallible Pope. But Peter's cock-crowing will not have hastened the rising of the sun, nor will it be necessary to apprise us that the sunisup. The Pope's recent letter simply gives Roman Catholic scholarship to under- stand that it is expected to bring the Bible and the dogma of the Church into perfect harmo- ny, and it knew that well enough already. In- fallibility is very much like Dr. Holmes’s ‘‘ Ka- tydid”— “It says an undisputed thing In such a solemn way. The essay on ‘Some Aspects of Newman’s Influence” has a personal and human touch that makes it the best one of the set. That re- viewing Dr. Edwin Abbott’s ‘Philomythus’ should have included his ‘Cardinal Newman’s Anglican Career’ in its attack. If this had meant a harder battle, the victory would have been better worth the fight. The general im- pression left by Mr. Ward's book is that he is in the same boat with the rest of us; that, for all the authority of Rome, her ultimate appeal is toright reason. We have advanced some- what when the Romanist says, ‘‘ Come and let us reason together.” It is not long since Car- dinal Manning told us that to seek rational confirmation of authoritative truth is to take the higbroad to infidelity. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Arnold, Sir E. The Light of Asia. T. Y. Crowell & Co. 75 cents. sane. Sir - Wandering Words. Longmans, Green, & Co. Atkinson, Rev. J.C. Memorials of Old Whitby. Mac- millan., $2.50. Banks, Rev. ee The Honeycombs of Life. Boston: Lee & Shepard. $2. Baring-Gould, 8. Kitty Alone. Dodd, Mead & Co. 1.25. Barnett, Samuel and Henrietta, Practicable Socialism. 2ded. Longmans, Green & Co. $1.56 Battershall, F. Mists: A Novel. Dodd, Mead & Co. $1.25. Bates, Fanny. B. Between the Lights: Thoughts for the Quiet Hour. A. D. F. Randolph & Co. $1.2! Bishop, Mrs. Isabella B. Among the Tibetans, Fleming H. Revell Co. $1. Bonar, J. Catalogue of the Library of Adam Smith. Maemiilan. $225. Bradford, A. H. The Sistine Madonna: A Christmas Meditation. Fords, Howard & Hulbert. 35 cents. Brown, Anna R. The Victory of Our Faith. T. Y. Cro- well & Co. Bruce, Rev. A. B. St. Paul’s Conception of Christiani- ty. Seribners. $2. Brush, Mary E.Q. Sarah Dakota. Hunt & Eaton. $1. Bulley, Miss A. A., and Whitley, Miss M. Women’s Work. London: Methuen & Co. Champernowne, H. The Boss: An Essay on the Art of Governing American Cities. George H. Richmond & Co. Champney, Elizabeth W. ww atc Winnie at Shinnecock. Dodd, Mead & Cc o. $1.5 Child, T. Wimples and ¢ vintug Pins: Studies in the ( ee ure and Ornaments of Women. Harpers, $2. Cla R. Golf: A Royal Ancient Game. Mac -millan. 3.6 Cc i ford, Mrs. W. RK. A Flash of Summer. Appleton crawford, F. M. La ve in Idleness: A Tale of Bar Har- bor. ." icmillan. Daudet, A. Tartarin on the Alps. T. Y. Croweil & Co. Davenport, Frances G. Classified List of Printed Origi- na! Materials for Englist h Manortal and Agrarian His ‘ 75 Ce nits. n Army in the War of Avans. : Geo. A. Spooner. ment for ‘Catarrh and essar, | Colds. “Home Series Publishing Co. Fenn, G. M. Firs Be i the Field ; .. Story of New South Wales. Dodd. M ad & Co. $1.5 Foss, 8S. W. Back Country Pos cae. Boston: Lee & e re The Kindergarten of the Church. Inorganic General Che- ston: Allyn & Bacon Gould, N. Harry Dale’s Jockey. Geo. Routledge & Sons. 50 cents. Guiney, Louise I. A a ~ ea any Gallery. Harpers. $1. Hamilton, Prof. D. J. Text-book of Pathology. Syste matic and Practice 4 2 vols. Macmillan. $10. Harland, ay The Roya! Road; or, Taking Him at His Word. . D. F. Randolph & Co. '$1.50. Hemp), P iy Chaucer’s Pronunciation and the Spelling of AS Ellesmere MS. Boston: D.C. Heath & Co. Herbert, A. Windfall and Waterdrift. Putnams. 75 cer Hesse, P. Atthe Ghost Hour. 4 vols, Dodd, Mead « $2. Minton, R. J. John Brown and his Men. Funk & Wag Hodder, FE. John MacGregor (** Rob Roy"), London Hodder Bros. Holley, Marietta. anomie among the Colored Folks. Dodd, Mead & Co. Holmes, Dr. O. W. The Last Leaf : A Poem. Boston Houghton, _— &C Hopkins, Prof. -J. Preparatory Physics. Longmans, Green & Co, 312 2% Irving, W. ‘ihe Ske tch Book of Geoffrey Crayon, Gent (Van Tassel Edition.) Putnams. $6. Jac eo J. Studies in Biblical Archeology. Macmillan. Johnson, C. The Farmer’s Boy. Appletons. $2.50. Keith, Alyn Y. Hilltop Summer. Boston: Lee & Shepard 1,25. Kelley, J. P. The Law of Service: A Study in Christian Altruism. Putnams. $1. Kiersted, W. Prevating Theories and Practices relat ing to Sewage Disposal. John Wiley & Sons. $1.25. Kingsley, H. Austin Filiott. Seribners, $1. Lano, Pie ao The Empress Eugénie. Dodd, Mead & Co. Lang, An now. The Yellow Fairy Book. Longmans, Green & Co, 2. Larned, J N. History for Ready Reference. Vol. es Greece to Nibelungen Lied. Springfield, Mass.: C. A. Nichols Co, Leighton, R. Olaf ba meg Seribners. $1.50. ee Rev. H. P. Life of Edward Bouverie Pusey. 1.111. Longmans, Green & Co. $4.50 Lithit's Living Age. Vol. 202. Boston: Littell & Co. Lubbock, Sir J. The Use of Life. Macmillan. “1.35. Mabie, H.W. My Study Fire. Dodd, Mead & Co. $1.50. Mack, Anna. Because I Love You: Poems of Love. 30oston : Lee & Shepard. $1.50. Masson, Fredéric. Napoleon, Lover and Husband. Merriam Co. $2. McCarthy, Justin. History of Our Own Times. 2 vols. New ed. Lovell, Coryell & Co. McLean, Alison. Quiet Stories from an Old Woman's Garden, F. Warne & Co. $1. Meissner, C._ Latin Phrase- Book. * Macmillan. $1.10. Merriman, Effie W. Mollie Miller. Boston: Lee & Shepard. $1.25. Miller, Emily H. Home Talks about the Word. Hunt & Eaton. ‘ Murray-Aaron, Dr. E. The Butterfly Hunters in the Caribbees, Scribners. $2. Old English Son s from Various Sources. Illustrated. Macmillan. a a House in Bloomsbury. Dodd, Mead « Co . Pailleron, E. Le Monde ou Von s’ennule. Boston: D.C. Heath & Co. 25 cents. — L. Where Honor Leads. Dodd, Mead & Co. Patterson, J. The Medea of Euripides translated into ee Verse. Louisville, Ky.: John P. Morton & Co. 00. Peckham, Mary C. Windfalls, and Other Poems. Butf- falo: Charles Wells Moulton. Raymond, Rev. B. P. Christianity and the Christ. Hunt & Eaton. 8&5 cents. Rhys, Ernest. A London Rose, and Other Rhymes. London : Mathews & Lane: New York: Dodd, Mead 7) Riley, J. W. Armazindy. Indianapolis: The Bowen- Merrill Co. Roberts, C, G. Dd. “The Raid from Beauséjour. Hunt & Eaton. $1. Robertson, J. L. History of ——- Literature for Secondary Schools. Harpers. $1.2 Sala, G. A. London up to Date. Mac millan, $1.25. Schmidt, &. Vorgeschichte Nordamerikas im Gebiet der Vereinigten Staaten. + ean F. Vieweg New York: B. Westermann & Cc Smith, Benjamin E, The Century c ‘yelopedia of Names The Century Co. $15. Stables, Dr. G. To Greenland and the Pole. Scribners. $1.50. Stevens, B. F. Facsimiles of Mant uscripts in E paogeer Archives relating to America, 17 73—1 783. Vol London ; BF. Stevens. Stratmeyer, Edward. Richard Dare’s Venture. The Merriam Co. Stretton, Hesba. Half Brothers. Cassell. 50 cents. Stretton, Hesba. The Highway of Sorrow. Dodd, Mead & Co. 25. —. G.S. Early Landmarks of Syracuse. Syracuse, N. Y.: Times Publishing Co. strate, ‘J. W. The Theory of Sound, 2d ed., revised. Vol. I. Macmillan. $4. Sunday Re - aed for the Young. E. & J. B. Young & Ae Mu. = ‘ause of Warm and Frigid Periods. Boston: G. H. The Second of the Rhymers’ Club. London Ms nghe ws & Lane; New York: Dodd, Mead & Co. 3 zy he we oman’s Book: Dealing Practically with the Mo- dern Conditions of Home-Life, Self Support, Educa tion, Opportunities, and Every-Day Problems. 2 vols. Seribners. Thomas, Miss Edith M. In Sunshine Land. Boston Houghton, Miflin & Co. $Lé Une Mere: Conte de Hans ¢ ‘hrs tian Andersen en 22 langues. St. Petersburg: S. M. Nicolaieff; London Th. Wohlieben. Verne, J. The Castle of the Carpathians. The Merriam > % Verne, J. The Special Correspondent. Lovell, Coryell Walpole, H. Memoirs of the Reign of King George the Third. 4 vols.- London: Laurence & Bullen; New York: Patnams, $138. arden, Gertrude. The Secret of a Letter. Interna tional Ne wsCo,. 50 cents. wx ods, Margaret L. The Vagabonds. Macmillar s a W ramat. Prof. W. Lectures on Human and Animal Ps chology. London: Sonnenschein; New York: Mac millan. $4. Yeats, W. B. » Land of Heart’s Desire: Poetry. Chicago: St « Kimball. Aes

Page 25

Oct. 25, 1894] The Nation. HENRY HOLT & CO.,N.Y. PUBLISH TO-DAY: HON. PETER STERLING, And What People Thought of Him. A Novel. By PAUL LEICESTER FoRD, editor of The Writings of Tho mas Jefferson, 12mo, $1.50. This story includes a purely fictitious romance, in which two women figure prominently, and a vivid pic ture of New York politics and labor troubles, in which the incidents and characters are founded on fact. A NEW EDITION OF HEYSE’S CHILDREN OF THE WORLD. A German standard that combines an intensely roman tic story with a vivid study of German life. 12mo, _ $i. 25. RARE ‘BOOKS FOR SALE BY THE HARVARD COOPERATIVE SOCIETY, CAMBRIDGE, MASS. 1. ATHENES AUX XVe, XVie, ET XVile SIE- CLES. Par le Crt. pe Laporpe. Paris, 1X4 2vols., 8vo. $40. Fine copy, newly bound in dark green crushed levant. 2. THE LIFE OF MR. RICH. HOOKER. Lon don, 1665. Small &vo. $9.00. A copy of the very rare first edition of Walton's Life of Hooker in the original sheep binding, but requires rebinding. 3. BIOGRAPHY OF THE SIGNERS TO THE DECLARATION OF INDEPENDENCE. By JOHN SanpeERSON. Phila., 1820. 9 vols Half olive moroeco. $63.00. A fine, freshly bound (in England) copy of this scarce book. Priced by Quaritch, £14. 4. THE WORKS OF ALEXANDER HAMILTON. Edited by Jonny C. Hamitton. New York, 1850, 7 vols., 8vo. Cloth. $37.50 Searce. A slight water stain in part of the first vol- ume. A copy priced last year on a New York catalogue at $50.00. 5. LIFE OF WASHINGTON. By WasHInaTon IRVING. New York, 1855-59. 5 vols . 4to. Large-paper copy of the first edition. Of this large — issue there were only 110 copies. This isin per ect condition, in the original cloth. $35.00. Yale Mixture. A GENTLEMAN’S SMOKE. You won’t know the luxury of Pipe-Smoking until you use Yale Mixture. A two-oz. trial package, postpaid, for 25 cents. MARBURG BROS., The American Tobacco Co , Successor, Baltimore, Md. High-Class Engravings and Etchings. Portraits of Literary and Historical Personages. Engravings and Etch- ings by the best masters. A large col- lection of prints relating to Napoleon. Correspondence invited. FREDERICK KeprpeL & Co., Paris, Chicago, and 20 East 16th ‘St. New York. THE LE NOX 3 IBR. \RY (AND READING ROO), Fifth Ave. and 70th St., is open every weekday from 10 A.M. to5 P.M. Exhibition of rare books; two galleries of paintings. Admission free; no tickets paindaseciensinsted ( TN-AMERICAN IMMIGRATION. — The latest statistics tabulated. By Re ena Michael Atchison. $1.25. CHARLES H. Kerk & Co. Pubs. Chi cago. PAPER BY THE POUND and envelopes. Greater quan tity, lower price than by quire. Samples, all crades, ee marked, on receipt of 10c. WM. R. JFNKINS. ne stationery, 851-53 Sixth Ave. (48th St.), N. Y. Problems Ie Far Ee JAPAN —-KOREA~— CHINA. By the Hon. GEORGE N. Curzon, M.P., author Persia,” ete. of ‘ Russia in Central Asia,” *' Svo, with 2 Maps and 50 Illustrations, which 21 are full-page, 461 pages, $6.00, “Very far above the average of books on Japan, Ko rea, or China is this work of the member of Parllament from Southport. Every page of it bespeaks the philoso phical scholar, thoughtful traveller, sympathetic man of the world, and broad-minded but thoroughly patrio tic Englishman .. He has written, not a book of travels, but a volume to be mentioned with the writings of De Torqueville or Bryce, Temple or Guicetardini It is doubtfal whether in any European language so clear a picture of peninsular and Lilliputian politics exists ei ‘Two chi ipters of fascinating interest conclude this suggestive book, which bristles with topics that tempt the reviewer to discussion, as they will the thoughtful reader to reflection.”— The Nation. LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., PUBLISHERS, 15 East r6th St reet, Ver Pall all Magazine PRICE, 25 CENTS. Edited by LORD FREDERIC HAMILTON, MP., and SIR DOUGLAS STRAIGHT. Amongst the Contents, which include contributions --Stories. Articles, and Poem:—from the best modern authors, the following may be specially mentioned THOMAS BAILEY ALDRICH, “AN UNDISCOVERED COUNTRY. GENERAL LORD ROBERTS, V.C., “ WELLINGTON WALTER BESANT, “"W age R. H. RIDER HAGGAR D, ‘AN H ASTE™ Sertal PAUL VERLAINE, “¢ ONQ LISTAD( R. E. F. BENSON, “ LOVE'S AP OSTATE MARY ANGELA DICKENS, “ ANOTHER FREAK LIONEL DECLE, “HOW I CROSSED AFRICA Besides a magnificent colored Frontispiece from ortet nal painting by B. M. Hewett, entitled “A Study in Colour.” The whole number is profusely {llustrated by well-known artists in black and white. There ar also several full-page Plates. Editorial and Publishing Offices—1ts harir ross Road, London, W. C : New York. The International | News Company; Toronto, The Toronto News pany; Montreal, The Montreal News Compar P.PUTNAM’'S SONS. Publishers, Importers, and Booksellers, NEW YORK: LONDON: 27 and 29 W. 23d St. 24 Bedford St., Strand. Give promptand careful attention to orders from libra ries or from individual buyers. for English and C nental Publications. Books can, w n desired, be sent to the customer by mai t fr the : Inf rmation and estin es furnis HUNT’S Reese SCHOOLS. int i enta. The purpose of -author of ¢l ~ vk » put int the han pupi t i teacher and t wat be fore the led as an introduc D. c. HEATH & "CO., Publishers, BOSTON, NEW YORK. CHICAGO S — te and = old by the RAG DOLLS Be Xl I a ne " Society Price, $3 Sent by mail, prepaid Apply t 107 t St t hlehem, Pa Nafion in numbers (57 vols No reasonable offer refused. Address Lovmsk DE Borre s Care of the Nation. GE OMETRY FOR GRAM- | A Tonic For Brain-lWorkers, the Weak Horsford’s Acid Phosphate Best Menta and Nervous Exhaustion: and is without exception the Remedy for releving ~ where the system has becom: debilitated by disease it acts as a general tonic and vitalizer, affording sustenance to both brain and body. Dr. E. Cornell Esten t Te @ . ‘ . Pa., savs L hav with ¢ reat pre N y ofr th ere bio Ss SVs iusiny C tv a \ Descriptive Pampt Rumford Beware of Substitutes and Imitations GARDEN AMD FOREST 1894—Seventh Year. Filled every week with ginal, entet taining. and exact inf it from tl best A ricat and | ropea iuthorities about trees, shrubs, flowers, and fruits the beautifving of | grounds, road sides, and parks preser\ f forests ind of natura scenery together with Vigorous edit treat it of topics wit} in its field, and illustrations of the highest ‘The best paper of its class in the language.” —N. Y. Sun. ‘* The arbiter in matters of rural taste."— Boston Transcript ‘A capital speci- men of pure literature."—N. Y. Journal of Commerce ‘Crisp and fresh text."—-N. Y. ‘Lilustrations of rare excellence.” fuffalo Courier. ** Edited with signal ability.” ‘A model of first- Philade Iphia Press. -Cineinnati Times-Star class journalism.” Beautifully illustrated. Published weekly. $4.00 a year. SPECIMEN COPY SENT ON APPLICATION. Garden and Forest, “New york.” en eet RE em

Page 26

The Nation. [Vol. 59 No. 1530 “THE BEST OF CHILDREN’S MAGAZINES,”"—AND NOW THE ONLY ONE. ST. NICHOLAS FOR YOUNG FOLKS. Beginning a New Volume. Now is the time to subscribe. Th e N ovem ber Ni um ber. ° best of children’s magazines” is now the only high-class monthly for TT" greatest year St. NicHo1as has ever had is just closing. ‘The young folks published in America. It is without a rival. Rudyard Kipling’s famous ‘‘ Jungle Stories,” written especially for St. NICHOLAS, were a great feature of 1894, and it will be pleasant news that Mr. Kipling will continue them ¥ in the coming volume, which begins with the beautiful November issue now ready everywhere. While their elders are reading Prof. Sloane’s Life of Napoleon in 7he Century, the boys and girls will be ee a story life of the same great hero, told by Elbridge S. Brooks, and superbly illustrated. ‘‘A Boy of the First Empire ’”’ is the title, and its hero renders a service to Napoleon, becomes one of his pages, and finally an aide. He is ¢ with him at the most critical times of his life—at the departure for Elba, and at Waterloo. The story glows with pageantry, and is a truthful account, verified by the latest information, of the life of ‘the man of destiny.” “A Boy of the First Empire’”’ begins in November. **The Quadrupeds of North America,” entertaining and up-to- date chapters on animals, will be contributed during the year by the well-known naturalist Prof. W. write a series to be called ** Hero-Tales from American History,” recounting farnous deeds of heroism which young people ought to know more about. The series on ** Historic Dwarfs” will be continued, and Prof. Brander Matthews will include in his entertaining papers on **The Great American Authors” accounts of the lives of Bryant, Emerson, Longfellow, Hawthorne, Whittier, Poe, and Lowell. Five Serial Stories are among the features: one called ** Chris and the Wonderful Lamp” recounts the marvelous adventures of a modern boy who became the accidental urchaser of Aladdin’slamp. A delightful story of college girls, ** The Three . T. Hornaday, and Theodore Roosevelt will shmen,” will appeal to every girl; and **Teddy and Carrots,” — Otis’s serial of newsboy life, will be read by every boy. A serial story ° Frances Courtenay ylor is to appear. *¢ West Point” will receive attention from Lieut. Putnam; and Life on a Man-of- War will be described by Ensign Ellicott, of the flag-ship “Chicago.” Stories of Famous Horses in history and er Bucephalus, r Napoleon’s and Sheridan’s horses, etc.—will be told. City e Depart- ments will be treated, and The Boys’ Brigade. More of Palmer Cox’s famous ** Brownies ” are promised. No home where there are children should be without the influence of ST. NICHOLAS. Begin to take it with November. This number is on every news-stand; price, 25 cents. A year’s subscription costs $3.00. All dealers, or the publishers, THE CENTURY CO., Union Sq., New York. A REFERENCE BOOK Gould Ou S for Editors, General Scientists, Libraries, Illustrated Newspaper Offices, re Biologists, Chemists, Dictionary Physicians, Dentists, oF Druggists, Lawyers. Medicine, Biology) pemi Quarto, over 1600 pages, AXD Half Morocco, . . Net, $10.00 Half Russia, Thumb Allied Sciences. ae. : a Net, $12.00 R& Samples of pages and illustrations free. P. BLAKISTON, SON & CO., 1012 WALNUT STREET, PHILADELPHIA. LANGUAGES MASTERED in 10 WEEKS Part I. (3 Lessons), either language, sent for 25c. MEISTERSCHAFT BUREAU, Boston, Mass. FRENCH, GERMAN, SPANISH, ITALIAN. We buy and sell bills of exchange on and make Cable Transfers of money to f Europe, Australia, and the West Indies: oO also make collections and issue Commer Letters } ial and Travellers’ Credits, available in Credit. all parts of the world. Brown Brothers & Co., Bankers, NO. 59 WALL STREET, NEW YORE. FOR SALE. The Theatre, Vols. 1-6, unbound................... $12 00 Scribner’s Monthly, Vols. 1-22, half morocco.... 28 00 The Caterer, Vols. 1-3, cloth...............-.00+00+ 3 00 The National Magazine, Vols. 1-8, half morocco.. 10 00 H. WILLIAMS, 195 West 10th St., N. Y. ADORESS ON IMPROVING THE MEMORY FOR TEN CENTS MEMORY LIBRARY 242 BROADWAY NEW YORE ALGIERS. American physician, M A., age 29, wintering in Al- giers, seeks engagement either as tutor or to take charge of patient. S French. References. Dr. WILLIAM peaks Bram, Hotel Continental, Algiers, Africa. OFFICE OF THE Atlantic Mutual INSURANCE COMPANY, New YorK, January 22d, 1894. The Trustees, in conformity with the Charter of the Company, submit the following State. ment of its affairs on the 31st of December, 159}. Premiums on Marine Risks from Ist January, 1893, to 31st December, 1893. $3,193,868 16 Premiums on Policies not marked off Ist ET» ROPE s sec cccccccnsnaseveriesesee 1,403,200 31 Total Marine Premiums..................++ $4,597,068 47 Premiums marked off from Ist January, 1893, to 31st December, 1893............ $3,490,552 70 Losses paid during the same period.............. $1,892,970 00 Returns of Pre- miums and Ex- penses.......... $711,138 89 The Company has the following assets, viz.: United States and City of New York Stock: City Banks and other Stocks .... $7,998,455 00 Loans secured by Stocks and otherwise.. 1,652,000 00 Real Estate and Claims due the Compa- ny, estimated at..............ccceeceeeees 1,086,828 74 Premium Notes and Bills Receivable..... 1,117,174 29 I ER os ceacapivensasrdscecccveseae 205,600 46 MED nskaanpaues dneiacaseveccannree $12,055,058 49 Six per cent. interest on the outstanding certificates of profit will be paid to the holders thereof or their legal representatives,on and after Tuesday, the sixth of February next. The outstanding certificates of the issue of 1889 will be redeemed and paid to the holders thereof, or their legal representatives, on and after Tuesday, the sixth of February next, from which date all interest thereon will cease. The certificates to be produced at the time of payment, and cancelled. A dividend of FORTY PER CENT. is declared on the net earned premiums of the Company for the year ending 31st December, 1893, for which certificates will be issued on and after Tuesday, the first of May next. By order of the Board, J. H. CHAPMAN, Secretary TRUSTEES: J. D. Jones, George Bliss, W.H.H. Moore, John L. Riker, Isaac Bell, A. A. Raven, C. A. Hand, Gustav Amsinck, Jos. H. Chapman, John D. Hewlett, Joseph Agostini, James Low, Chas. P. Burdett, Vernon H. Brown, William Sturgis, N.Denton Smith, C.de Thomsen, Jas. G. De Forest, C. H. Marshall, Leander N. Lovell, Wm. Degroot, Chas. D. Leverich, Everett Frazar, William H. Webb, Edw. Floyd-Jones, Wm. B. Boulton, Horace Gray, George H. Macy, Geo. W. Quintard, Anson W. Hard, Henry E. Hawley, Lawr’ce Turnure, Paul L, Thebaud. Wald. P. Brown, J. D. JONES, President, W. H. H. MOORE, Vice-President. A. A. RAVEN, 2d Vice-President. Cc Wm. E. Dodge, NA PIANOS UNEQUALLED IN TONE, TOUCH, WORKMANSHIP, AND DURABILITY. K Baltimore, New York, 22 and 24E. Baltimore St. 148 5th Ave., near 20th St. Washington, $17 Market Space. ‘ESTABLISHED 1858° H.-H. UPHAM :&:CO.: ‘MEMORIAL: TABLETS: ‘-IN- BRASS - AND - BRONZE: 5'4° South Fifth Ave: near Bleecker* St’ ‘NEW YORK"

Page 27

Oct. 25. 1894] ~ The Nation.

China and Japan Are hereditary foes and are seeking each other’s humiliation. Meszsene IF Zen wishes to humiliate nobody, but rather desires to promote good will, develop self-respect and increase the sum of hu- man happiness by furnishing reliable Life Insurance under three of the most popular policy contracts ever devised. Write for particulars concerning our new Incontestable Policy. $1,100,000 CASH SURPLUS COST 60 PER CT. USUAL RATES. Splendid Openings for Energetic Men to Act as Special, General and State Agents. GEO. A. LITCHFIELD, Pres., 53 State St.. Boston.

A little smoother A little more durable A little higher priced Tadella Alloyed=Zink Pens are worth trying and are cheapest in the end SAMPLES, 20 STYLES, 10 CENTS TADELLA PEN COMPANY 74 FIFTH AVENUE NEW YORK CITY So’d in 25 cent and $1. 25 boxes, postpaid UNMOUNTED PHOTOGRAPHS of Ancient and Modern Works of Art, reproduc- tions of famous paintings, sculpture.and sealant ure, with views from all parts of the world. Send 15 cents for catalogues of 14,000 subjects. List of World’s Fair Views and Art at the Fair now ready. Lantern slides made to order from any of our subjects. Photograph Mounting in Albums or on cards a specialty. Albums supplied. Soule Photograph Co.. 334 Wash'n St.. Boston Principal Agencies: New, York, E. P. Dutton & Co. 31 W. 23d St.; Chicago, M. O’Brien & Son, 208 Wabash Ave Philadelphia, J.E. MeClees & Co., 1417 Chestnut St

eoenol) Constable KaCo, ousekeepiny Goods. TABLE AND BED LINENS, Damask Towels and Towellings.

New and E egant Designs in LACE and LINEN and SILK EMB’D TABLE CLOTHS, CENTRE PIECES, and SCAREFS. H. S, Huck Towels, Linen Sheets and Pillow Cases. Extraordinary Geod Value. Blankets, Flannels, and Quilts. Sroadovay A 4 9th st. NEW YORK.

etait a A eo — | | . 3 Ne ane Tito aw a 4 rps ky cy ] | \ 1 S

Your latest work ts again a finance “ial success—s0 our publisher tells me. How do you mane use to keep in touch, efe , ete. Well, I keep my eyes open and subseribe to Romeike’s. Why’! I also am one of Rometke’s subscribers Of course. So ts rearly everyt«ty, but since he started his Press-Cutting bureau tn 1Ss1. 1] pot only cet criticisms of my works. but also facts and plots througt ae HENRY ROVIEIKE, 140 Rink Aone. Nee } Newspaper Clippir es mall the leading papers in pap PP the world, on any subje ARCHITECTURE. A copy of the scarce and beauttfal edition of - TTRU vits », vel moe tana Ay rk ~ saint old full “e rt 1 react and tail pieces; Come, 1521 GEOR iF t ats MP HR FY, 25 Exchange St.. Rochester

(merican Magazines, Newspapers, and Journals The Cosmopolitan @ $1.50 per vear. Best magazine issued in America. The Dirision Visifor, @ 50 cents per year. Best non-partisan and non sectarian tempe rance paper. Ask us to Quote om your wants. Mention Nation, AMERICAN PRINTING AND NEWS COMPANY 1111 ARCH ST... PHILADELPHIA. PA. B \ ‘L” numbers and sets of all magazines. For ( price, state wan s to Magazink EXCHANGE, Schoharie, N. Y.

Vil B. "WESTERMANN & CO., [LEMCKE & BUECHNER} BOOKSELLERS AND IMPORTERS, &1a Breadway, New } School and College Text Books, Dictionaries, and Grammars of Ancient and Modern Languages. FLCGEL’'S Great German and English Dictionary Svols. Special terms for introduction Thieme-Preusser, Koehler, and other German French, English, Italian Dictionaries Teubner and Tauchnits Greek and Latin Texts Mail-orders fo- Books, Foreyrn or Domesti ceive Lumediate attention LONDON. PARIS LEIPZIG NEW YORK GUSTAV E. STECHERT, Importer of Books and Periodicals, Ste BROADWAY, NEW YORK

Large stock of Foreign Books, new as well as rare and scarce, and sets of Perfodicals Subscriptions to Periaticals rece! ved Lowest rates, quick delivery Send for Catalogue BRANCH ES London the Street. Strand. W

Paris. 76 Rue de Rennes _lLeipe 10 Hospital Strasse ~ Al l AINE ae «ae We have just secured a smal! quan BR aive’s ‘ Twenty Years in ( ne roe Th Subscriptions to foreign Forcion Books viodicals. Tauchnitz Britsn rd authors. Catalogues on ap plication. Carl SCHOENHOF, 23 School St., boston. RARE | PRINTS—AUTOGRAPHS.

ues Issued Continually. BOOKS. | W.E. 5 4 22 E. 16th &t..New York.

be reper cote 1h some oe ee Np 80 a eR Ne ne ty wae

Page 28

per 7 EL BASS a ADS ox. LS =e ol” Sie STO ON Re Vill The Nation. [Vol. 59, No. 1530 Charles Scribner’s Sons’ NEW PUBLICATIONS. The Burial of the Guns. By THOMAS NELSON PAGE. 12mo, $1.25. Mr. Page’s new volume contains six stories, rich in the pictures of old Virginia life and character, for which he is justly celebrated. They are distinguished by humorous, pathetic, and dramatic touches, and are told with that simple, exquisite? art that stamps Mr. Page as the finest exponent of the old and new South in fiction. Musicians and [lusic Lovers, And Other Essays. By W.F. AptHorpP. 12mo, $1.50. Contents: Musicians and Music Lovers—Bach—Addi- tional Accompaniments to Bach's and Handel’s Scores —Meyerbeer—Offenbach —T-vo Modern Classicists in Music—J. 8S. Dwight—Some Thoughts on Musical Criti- cism—Music and Science. A Practical Guide to Whist. By the Latest Scientific Methods. By FisHer AMEs. Revised Edition from New Plates. 16mo, 75 cents. “The best we know—one cannot have a_ better guide.”—Boston Courier. The Sherman Letters. Correspondence between General and Senator Sher- man from 1837 to 1891, Edited by RacHEL SHER- MAN THORNDIKE. With Portraits. 8vo, $3.00. “Their historical value is incalculable.”—Chicago Tribune. Life and Letters of Erasmus. By JAMES ANTHONY FROUDE. 8vo, $2.50. ‘The volume is one of rare value and must become a historical standard.”—Boston Advertiser, Pomona’s Travels. A Series of Letters to the Mistress of Rudder Grange from her former Handmajiden. By FRANK R. STockTon. Fully fllustrated by A. B. Frost. 12mo, gilt top, $2.00. “One of the most delightful books Mr. Stockton has ever written. Mr. Frost’s illustrations are atl admir- able.”— N. Y. Times. Polly. A Christmas Recollection. By THomas NELSON PaGeE, Illustrated by A.Castaigne. Small folio, $1.50. Henry Kingsley’s Novels. Ravenshoe. 2 vols. 12mo, $2.00. Austin Elliot. 12mo, $1.00. The Recollections of Geoffrey Hamlyn. 2 vols, 12mo, $2.00. In press. “ Lovers of geet fiction will rejoice In the revival of the works of Henry Kingsley.’’—Boston Beacon. Wild Beasts. A Study of the Character and Habits of the Elephant, Lion, Panther, Leopard, Jaguar, Tiger, Puma, Wolf, and Grizzly Bear. By JouN HAMPDEN PorTeR. With 8 full page illustrations. Cr. 8vo, $2.00. William Shakspere. A Study of Elizabethan Literature. By BARRETT WEN- DELL. 12mo, $1.75, Costume of Colonial Times. By Mrs. ALICE MORSE EARLE. 12mo, $1.25. Czar and Sultan. Tae Adventures of a British Lad in the Russo-Turkish War of 1877-78. By ARCHIBALD Forses. Iilus- trated. 12mo, $2.00. The Butterfly Hunters in the Caribbees. By Dr. EUGENE MURRAY-AARON. With 8 full-page illus- trations. Square 12mo, $2.00. The Wagner Story Book. Firelight Tales of the Great Music Dramas. By WILLIAM HENRY Frost. Illustrated by S. R. Burleigh. 12mo, $1 50, a*s Sold by all booksellers, or sent, postpaid, by CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS 153-157 Fifth Avenue, New York, HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO.’S NEW BOOKS. ‘Tt fe - a Che Rubaiyat of Omar Khay- yam. Rendered’into Euglish Verse by EDWARD FITZGERALD. With a Biography of Omar — am, a Biographical Sketch of Mr. Fitz- gerald, and 56 superb Illustrations by ELrnu VEDDER. Popular Edition. Crown 8vo, $5. Che Story of a Bad Boy. By THOMAS BaILEy ALpriIcH. Holiday Edi- tion. With numerous Illustrations by A. B. Frost. Crown octavo, finely printed and bound in attractive style, forming an exceed- ingly attractive book. $2.00. Philip and His Wife. A strong story with a noble purpose, told with great power and grace, by Mrs. DELAND, au- thor of ‘‘ John Ward, Preacher,” ‘‘ Sidney,” ‘*Mr. Tommy Dove,” ete. 16mo, $1.25. ve . Timothy's Quest. A fine Holiday Edition of one of Mrs. Wia- GIN’S most popular stories. Printed from new plates, fully and artistically illustrated by OLIVER HERFORD, and attractively bound. Crown 8vo, #1,50. In the Dozy Hours, and Other Papers. Another book of fresh, original, and delight- ful Essays, by AGNES REPPLIER, author of ‘*Books and Men,” ‘‘ Points of View,” ‘ Es- says in Idleness.” Each, 16mo, $1.25. Lucy Larcom: Life, Letters, and Diary. A book of great interest about one of the noblest of American women, by Rev. DANIEL D. AppIson. With a Portrait. $16mo, $1.25. Master and Men: The Sermon on the Mountain, practiced on the Plain. A thoughtful book, contrasting current Chris- tianity with that of Christ, and illustrating the Beatitudes by the lives of Moses, Paul, George Fox, General Gordon, and George MacDonald. By Rev. W. B. WRIGHT, author of “Ancient Cities” and ‘‘The World to Come.” 16mo, $1.25. Three Boysonan Electrical Boat A thoroughly interesting and exciting story of the adventures of three boys, who saw and heard and took part in a multitude of inci- dents, and learned a great deal, practically, of the wonders of electricity. By JoHN TRow- BRIDGE, Professor in Harvard University. 16mo, $1.00. Sold by all Booksellers. Sent, postpaid, by HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO., Boston, 11 East 17th Street, New York. New Publications. The Life and Inventions of Thomas A. Edison. By W. K.L Dickson and Antonta Dickson. With numerous Drawings and Photographs. 4to, cloth, gilt top, boxed, $4.50. This volume has been prepared with Mr. Edison’s consent and approval, and furnishes a trustworthy account of the wonderful history and inventions of the famous ** Wizard of Menlo Park.” Scott’s Complete Poetical Works. With Introduction by Prof. CHarLes Extiot Nor- Ton. Carefully edited, with Explanatory Notes Printed from new plates on fine paper. With 34 Illustrations by eminent artists Photogravure Frontispieces. 2 vols , 12mo, cloth, gilt top, $3.00; white back, gilt top, $3.00; half calf, gilt top, $6.00. Twenty-five Years of Scientific Pro- gress. A series of Lectures by Wa. Nortu Rice, Professor of Geology in Wesleyan University. 16mo, 75 cents, Pelleas and Melisande. A Drama by Maurice MAETERLINCK, *‘ the Flemish Shakespeare.” Translated by Erving Winslow. 16mo, cloth, gilt top, $1.00. Famous Leaders Among Men. By Sarau K Botton. With Portraits of Napoleon, Wendell Phillips, Thomas Arnold, Charles Kings- ley. and others. 12n0, cloth, uniform with pre- vious volumes, $1 50. The Building of Character. By the Rev. J R Mrm.er,D D_ itmo, white back, gilt top, boxed $1.00; white and gold, gilt edges, $1.25; levant morocco, flexible, gilt edges, $2.50. T.Y. CROWELL & CO., New York and Boston. BRYN MAWR COLLEGE FOR WOTSIEN. Situated ten miles from Philadelphia. Offers under- graduate and graduate instruction. Awards annually two European Fellowships (value $500), five Graduate Scholarships (value $200), and nine Resident Graduate Fellowships (value $525) in Greek, Latin, English, Teu- tonics, Komance Languages, Mathematics, History, or Politics, Chemistry, and Biology. Full undergraduate and graduate Coursesin these departments and in Phi losophy and Physics. Graduate Courses in Semitic Lan guages, For Program or Graduate Pamphlet, address Bryn Mawr College, Pa. THE WORKS OF EMANUEL SWEDENBORG Contain the principles of a practical religion, the ap plication of which to the affairs of life would solve many of the difficult problems of the day. Send fora Catalogue. THE MASSACHUSETTS NEW-CHURCH UNION, 16 Arlington Street, Boston. GOLDEN SCEPTRE PERFECTION FOR THE PIPE. Send 40 cents for 4-0z. sample to SURBRUG, 159 Fulton St., N. Y. City. =IT FLOATS * IS NOT LOST IN THE TUB. THE PROCTER & GAMBLE CO. OIN'TI

Page 29