The Nation 1894-07-26: Vol 59 Iss 1517
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
‘he Nation VOL. LIX—NO. 151 7. THE Popular Science Monthly FOR AUGUST. The Chaos in [loral Train- | ing. By Prof. JoHN Dewey. Points out the confusing character | of much of the training as to right and wrong given by parents to their | The facts are drawn from | children. the recollections of a class of students in Ethics. A Proposition for an Artifi- cial Isthmus. By Ernest A. Le SuEvr. A scheme for an immense dam be- tween Scotland and Ireland, which shall enable the tidal power in the North Channel to be utilized. This power would be transmitted electric- ally to the British industrial centres. e . Rain-Making. By Prof. FERNANDO SANFORD, Gives the natural laws upon which tain well-known ‘* rain-makers,”’ The Story of a Great Work. (Illustrated). By J. Jones Bett. the tunnel under the St. Clair River. OTHER ARTICLES: MILK FoR Bases (illustrated); Na- | TURE AS DRAMA AND ENGINERY: THE NOCTURNAL MIGRATION OF Birds; MopERN VIEWS AND PRop- LEMS OF Puysics: FoRM AND LIFE: ACCURACY IN OBSERVATION: THE PHOTOGRAPHY OF COLORS: SKETCH OF WittiaAM Marrieu WILLIAMS (with Portrait). CORRESPONDENCE: Eptror’s LITERARY NOTICES: CELLANY; NOTEs. ABLE: POPULAR Mis- JO cents a number; $5.00 a D. APPLETON & NEW YORK. Memoirs f ¢ : , | unfitted for lying. » fall of ri ‘pends, and shows | & | the f ull of rain de pends, : nd show ~ | tremely interesting, and it is as important as up the imposture in the claims of cer- | ae y THURSDAY, JULY 26, 1894. Illustrating the History of Napoleon I., From 180? to 1815. By Baron CLAUDE-FRAN COIS DE MENEVAL, Private Secretary to Napoleon. RON Edited by his Grandson, Ba NAPOLEON JOSEPH DE MENEVAL., With portraits and Autograph Letters. | In three volumes, volume. SVo. Volumes |. and IL. now ready. ‘** These memoirs, by the private secretary of Napoleon, are a valuable and important contribution to the history of the Napoleonic veriod, and necessarily they throw new and interesting light on the personality and real sentiments of the Emperor. If Napoleon any- where took off the mask, it was in the seclu sion of his private cabinet. The memoirs have been republished almost as they were written, by Baron de Méneval’s grandson, with the ad dition of some supplementary documents.” London Times. ‘The Baron de Méneval knew Napoleon as few knew him. Ha was his confidential secre tary and intimate friend. Students and historians who wish to forma trustworthy estimate of Napoleon cannot afford to neglect this testimony by one of bis most intimate associates.” London Daily News. “The work will take rank with the most im portant of memoirs relating to the period. [ts great value arises largely from its author's transparent veracity. Méneval was one of those men who could not consciously tell any- thing but the truth. He was constitutionally The book is ex- it is interesting.”—\ Times. Climbing in the Himalayas. | By WILLIAM Martin Conway, M.A.FLRLG.S., An Account of the construction of | Vice-President of the Alpine Club; former- Cloth, 22.00 per | Th?,. sr ts PRICE ro ¢ Twp, ENTS - D. Appleton & Co.'s ne ~Books. | The Claims of Christianity. By WILLtamM SaMvew Liiuvy, Honorary Fellow of Peterhouse, Cambridge; author of © The Great Enigma,” et: Svu. Cloth, 6 The author takes what might be termed the | publicist’s point of view, and deals with Chris | tianity as a factin the world’s history. He dis cusses the claims of Buddhism and Islam, and / after a masterly analysis of the development Christianity and the Church, he maintains the | necessity of organized spiritual power to vindi ' cate the rights of it age, when the tendency is to strengthen the state against the individual Mr. La torical analysis and inc , } vital questions of the day { and suggestive volum« onscience, especially in es } islVe Appletons’ Guide-Books. REVISED ANNUALLY Appletons’ General Guide to the United States. With nun illustrations I2mo Fl tuck, $2.50 Part 1... New ENGLAND AND Mippie STATES Part ll RN STATES; cloth, $1 erous maps and xible mor with separately, AND } CANADA: cloth, $1.25 SoutTu ERN AND WEST? | Appletons’ Canadian (Ciuide-Book. Prof. Maps cloth, 21 3 Ry With flexible RoORERTS ’ 2mMa, CHARLES G. DD and = = lilustrations Appletons’ Guide-Book to Alaska. ly Miss E. R. Scrpwore. With Maps and Illustrations. 12mo, cloth, $1.25 Hand-Book of American With Maps, I Railroad Fares, et flexible | Appletons’ Summer Resorts. lustrations, Table of I2mo, paper, ! cents ly Professor of Art in University College, | Liverpool. With 300 Illustrations, by A. D. McCormick, and a Map. 310.00. Svo. Cloth ‘It would be hard to say too much in praise of this superb work. As a record of mountain- | eering itis almost, if not quite, unique. Among records of Himalayan exploration it certainly stands alone. . he farther Himalayas have never been so faithfully words, so poetically —presented as in the mas | terly delicate sketches with which Mr. McCor- mick has adorned this book.”—/ News, ondon Daily The Purple Light of Love, HENRY ‘A Precious By GoELET McVickaR, author Trio.” et 12mo 75 cents A story of New York and Newport social life, most adroitly and cleverly told. For sale by all th. | in other | of | Cloth, | Appletons’ Dictionary of New York. I§mo, paper, 30 cents; cloth, 60 cents RECENT ISSUES IN Appletons’ Town and Country Library. Each 12mo, paper, 50 cents; cloth, $1.00 DR. JANET OF HARLEY STREET. By Arane LA KENEALY Molly and her Man-o' War,” et« author of OUTLAW AND LAWMAKER ‘Christina Chard,”* By Mrs. CaMpee.i Prakp, author of * Decem ber Roses,’ ete A DAUGHTER OF MUSiIc. thor of By G Concerning Oliver Knox, | THE TRESPASSER. By Gitsert Parker, author of “The Translation of a Savage,” ete COLMORE, au ‘ete booherilers, or will be sent by mail on receipt of price by the publishers, D. APPLETON & CO., 72 Fifth Avenue, New York.
Page 2
ii The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science, and Art. FOUNDED 1865. | Entered at the New York City Post-Office as second-class mail-matter.}
CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. TUB WERE. cc ccccccoccvcccocccccevscccsvecessesscccs cose OG EDITORIAL ARTICLES : A Washingtonian Precedent.....................005 58 Plaything Labor Commissions..................0005 58 The New Theories of Wages.................0.eeeeee 59 Clubs Within the Churches...............-0eeseeeee 59 SPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE : Franktin’s ‘Explanatory Remarks.”—I........... 60 CORRESPONDENCE : The Great Northern Strike. ...............ceeeeeeees 61 Pullman and Its Inhabitants. .................0000 61 Labor Anarchists of the Last Century............. 62 IE. 3. 3. Gnd cane Weatpahaneeceenssont seesens 62 The Public Library in New Hampshire............ 62 AME cvcvtenrvensevaseareresscicrees 62 Popular Election of Senators.... ...........seeeeee 62 rere 62 PE GE EEE a nesccdecvescccscgecenes séeudente 63 Bion hcts bncenct0tssvesn cstseuneaccess Sasvccsecessnce OS Book REVIEWS: Marcella, and Other Novel.............s.ceececeees 66 A Columbian EN dds assure bboetbepnandoss sess 68 EE OI, occ ccceccossccanccesncoeccecsese 69 pe Errore Sesdulcsakeves 69 0k con uns anos 6 pebaseheeeotane 70 EEE FEED: MEMEEONS,. nccce coveccccovcvocctsccceves 70 Books OF THE WEEK..........+ eeecccccccsvesovceccoss 70
TERMS. OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three Dollars per year in advance, postpaid, to any partof the United States or Canada; to foreign coun- tries comprised in the Postal Union, Four Dollars. The date when the subscription expires is on the Ad- dress-Label of each paper, the change of which to a sub- sequent date becomes a receipt for remittance. No other receipt is sent unless requested. Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter or by check, express order, or postal order, payable to “Publisher of the Nation.” When a change of address is desired, both the old and new addresses should be given. Address THE NATION, Box 794, New York. Publication Office, 208 Broadway.
TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Fifteen cents per agate line, each insertion, 14 lines to the inch. Twenty per cent. advance for choice of page, top of column, or cuts. Cuts are not inserted on the first page. A column, $20 each insertion; with choice of page, $24. A page, $60 each insertion; front cover page, $80. Advertisements must be acceptable in every respect. Copy received until Tuesday, 5 P.M.
DISCOUNTS, “t insertions. LichasyixeaNunaneseiccbienethiss m per cent zt 8 “ we wile ae 39 * 52 ™ 750 ae 1,000“ 1,500 * 2,000 “
The NATION is sent free to those who advertise in it, as long as advertisement continues The EDITION of the NATION this week is 9,200 copies. The Subscription List is always open to the in- spection of advertisers.
*,* Copies of THE NATION may be procured in Paris at Brentano’s, 17 Avenue de l’Opéra, and in + pee oa Ba F. a 4 Mery i uare, American News r Agenc ing Williara 8 Street, Strand, Sard sitet London agent for Adver tisements, R J. Bush, 92 Fleet Street, E. C.
The Nation. E:ducationatl. ALABAMA, Marion. © hin 4 INSTITUTE FOR GIRLS AND YOUNG LADIES. The 57th session will open the 27th of September. Apply for the Catalogue. im 8. W. Avi ERETT, President. — CALIFORNIA, Los Angeles, West 23d Street. az BOROUGH SCHOOL for GIRLS. _ Mrs. Gko. A. CASWELL, Principal.
ConneeTic ut, Bridgeport. “OLDEN HILL SEMINAR Y.—A Beard- 7 ing and Day School for ‘Girls. Delightful location. Superior advantages. Number of boarders limited. College preparation. Miss Emmy Neson, Principal; Miss ANNIE S. Gipson, Associate Principal.
__ CONNECTICUT, Cheshire. Fa PISCOPAL ACADEMY OF CON- ~« NECTICUT prepares boys for Coliege, Scientific School. and Business. The one hundred and first year opens Sept. 19. Address Rev. Janae STODDARD, M.A., Principal.
CONNECTICUT, Coscob in Greenwich. RS. BEECHER’ S FAMILY SCHOOL, now in its eleventh year, is intended primarily for young motherless girls. Unusual care jis given to the promotion of health, to composition writing, and to music and singing. Circulars sent, and pupils received at any time.
CONNECTICUT, New Haven, 56 Hillhouse Avenue. EST END INSTITUT. *oe0
Girls. Pre- pares for any college. Circulars. Early applica tion necessary. Mrs. S. L. Capy and Miss C. E Capy¥. Principals. CONNECTICUT. Norwalk A TSS BAIRD’S INSTITUTE FOR Girla.—23d year. Primary, Intermediate. and Col- lege-Preparatory Course?. Musi ce, Art, and the Lan- guages. Care’ul attention to morals and manners. New buildings, steam heat, gymnasium. Circulars
ConnecTicuT, Pomfret Centre. HE MISSES VINTON’S SCHOOL for Girls will reopen Thursday, October 4. Num- ber limited. CONNECTICUT, Simsbury. M*t= AN SEMINAR Y FOR GIRLS.— College Preparatory. anne < Opuee, French, German, Art, Music. Rev B. MCLEAN.
ConNNECTICUT, Washington. HE RIDGE, HO. VE SCHOOL FOR six boys. Prepares especially for Harvard and Yale. New plant. agg beautiful location. Wo. G. BRINSMADE (Harvard, ’81).
CONNECTICUT, Waterbury T. MARGARE 7” S DIOCESAN «J Boardingand Day School for Girls reonens Sept. 19, 1894. The Rev. Francis T. Russell, M.A., Rector. Miss Mary R. Hillard, Principal. : : koro DIstTRict OF COLUMBIA, Washington. HE COLUMBIAN UNIVERSIT Y.— For copies of new Catalogue, containing a descrip- tion of Lecture Courses in the College, the Medical School. the Dental School, the Law School, the Corco- ran Scientific School, and the newly-erected School of Graduate Studies, address RoBerT H. MARTIN, Secretary.
District OF COLUMBIA, Washington. ATIONAL PARK SEMINARY FOR rs Young Women.—Suburbs of Washington, D. C. Collegiate and Seminary Courses. Beautiful grounds. $75,000 buildings. A cultured home. $300 to $400. Send for Illustrated Catalogue to Washington, D.C. a 1g It is a liberal education to live in Washington.” 5 DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA, Washington. {7 NSTON INSTITU ae foe GIRLS. 2926 and 2928 P Street, Mr. and Mrs. eank R. MASON.
ILLINOIS, CuicaGco, 708 Chamber on Smmeanee. YIICAGO COLLEGE OF LA Law Department Lake Forest ae and three year course. For information, address E. _E. BakRETT. LL. B., Secretary. Two ILLINOI, Upper Alto ] ESTERN MILIT. ARV ACADEMY. —Sixteenth year. An old and thorough prepara- tory school, with graduates in Yale,Princeton, Cornell, and other Colleges. Cadets prepared for college or for Dustness. Circular sent on 18 BRows, Si Col. Wi LIS BROWN, Superintendent. — KENTUCKY, Shelbyville. CIENCE HILL, An English and Classical School for Girls. Oldest in the South. First-class in allits appointments. Pre- pares for Wellesley. W. . POYNTER. MARYLAND, Baltimore, 122 and 124 W. Franklin ‘Ste. fr 2Ge WORTH BOARDING AND DAY _ School for Young Ladies wili reopen Wednesday, September 26.
32d year. Mrs. H. P. LEFEBVRE, Principal, — MARYLAND, Baltimore, 915and 917N. Charles St. OUTHERN HOME SCHOOL for Girls. Mrs. W. M. Cary, Miss Cary. “Fitty- third year. Summer address, Bar Harbor, Me.
MARYLAND, Catonsville. we 7. TIMOTH Y’S ENGLISH, FRENCH nd German School =~ Young Ladies reopens Sep- tember 20,1894. Principals: Miss M.C. CARTER, Miss S. R. CARTER.
[Vol. 59, No. 1517 E:ducational. ~ MARYLAND, Hagerstown. WEE MAR COLLEGE and Art Conservatory.—A choice school for girls. Finest climate in the world, beautiful grounds, elegant buildings on a hill. large and experienced faculty, all home comforts, rare advantages, reasonable rates. Send for Catalogue and Journal to C. L. KEEDY, President. AND MUSIC
MASSACHUSETTS, Amherst. Xv RS. W. F. STEARNS'S HOME School for Young Ladies reopens Sept. 20, 1894. MASSACHUSETTS, Andover. BBOT ACADEMY for Young Ladies begins its 6@th year September 13, offering en- larged opportunities. Three Seminary Courses of Stu- dies and a College fitting Course. Address Miss Lav ra 8S. W ATSON, P rincipal. “MASBACHU SETTs, Auburndale (10 miles from Boston). jp Aséet SEMINARY FOR YOUNG WOMEN Suggests to parents seeking a good school, considera- tion of the following points in its methods: Ist. Its special care of the health of growing girls. Resident Nurse, supervising work, diet, and exercise; abundant food in good variety and well cooked; ony and long sleep; a fine gymnasium, furnished by Dr. Sar- gent of Harvard: bowling-alley and swimming-bath; no regular or foreknown examinations, etc. 2d. Its broadly planned course of are Boston proximity both necessitates and helps to fur- nish the best of teachers, including many specialists; with one hundred and twenty pupils, a faculty of thirty. Four years’ course; in some things equal to college work; in others planned rather for home and womanly life. Two studies required, and two to be chosen from a list of eight or tenelectives One preparatory year. Spe cial students ees if eighteen years old or over, or a as oy of High Se Is. 3d. Its homelike air and character. Training in self-government; limited number (many declined every fall for lack of room); personal over- sight in habits, manners, care of person, room, ete.; comforts not s inted. 4th. Its handiwork and other unusual departments. Pioneer school in scientific teaching of Cooking, Mil- linery, Dress- te Aten Business Law for Women, Home Sanitation, Swimm ng Regular expense for school year, $500. For illustrated catalogue address (mentioning the Nation), Cc. C. Braapon, Principal.
MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 593 Boylston Street. YAUNCY HALL SCHOOL (65th Year). For Boys and Girls.—Preparation for the Mass. In- stitute of Technology is aspecialty. Reference is made to the Institute Faculty. The location of the school building on Copley Square is especially attractive, and is very near the Institute. Preparation also for College (with or without Greek) and for! business. Spec vial stude nts received. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston Removal to 86 Beacon St. R. HALE’ S SCHOOL The 12th year will open Sept. 26, at No. 86 Bea- con Street. Preparation for Harvard and the Institute of Tech- ae. Full Classical Course. Also Modern Language and Scientific Course. Preparatory Department for boys of nine or ten years of age. Gymnasium, with bath- rooms and shower-baths. Address till August 1, ALBERT HALE, 5 Otis Place, Boston. MASSACHU SETTS, , Boston, 66 Marlborough Street. 'LASSICAL SCHOOL FOR GIRLS.— Boarding and Day School. College orc paration; certificate admits to Smith, Vassar, and Wellesley. S. ALICE Browy, A.B., AMELIA L. OWEN, A.RB., Principals. References: Pres. L. Clark Seelye, Gen. Francis A. Walker, Mrs Louis Agassiz, Mrs. Alice Freeman Palmer.
MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, Franklin Sk fee W ENGLAND CONSERVATORY oe MUSIC. The Leading Conservatory of America, Founded by Dr. Eben Tourjée. CARL FAELTEN, Directer, Send for Prospectus giving full information. FRANK Ww. HALE, General Manager.
MASSACHUSETTs, Boston, 252 Marlborough St. MM SS CLAGETT’S HOME AND DAY School for Girls reopens October 3. College Pre- paratory, Regular, and Elective Courses. Specialists in each, Tenth year. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 18 Newbury Street. TSS FRANCES V. EMERSON, Successor to Miss Abby H. Johnson, HOME AND DAY SCHOOL FOR GIRLS. ee 20th year opens Oct. 3, 1894. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 110 Boylston Street. OSTON COLLEGE OF ORATORY. The Delsarte Ideal Training School. Send for Catalogue and see our advantages over all other schools.
MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 9 Appleton Street. OSTON NORMAL SCHOOL OF GYM- nastics.—Sixth year will begin September 25, 1894. Amy Morris Homans,
Ese Director. — MASSACHUSETTS, Boston. s°* TON UNIVERSITY Law School. Address the Dean. Epmunp | H. ‘NETT, LL.D. MassacHUSET?Is, Bradford 4RLETON SCHOOL FOR YOUNG Men and Boys.—English, Classical, and Scientific. Eleventh year. ine new gymvasium, schoolrooms, bowling-alley, tennis-courts, ete. Home for 13 stu- dents. $550 per year. Ph D. Reo a. 19, 1804. I. N CaRLETON,
Page 3
es EN Sa July 26, 1894] Educational. MASSACHUSETTS, Cambridge, 7 Garden Street. HE BROWNE & NICHOLS SCHOOL for Boys. 12th year begins Sept. 27, 1894, in new spec ial building. Best ventilating obtainable. Fight years’ continuous course under the same teachers. iome for a limited number. Catalogue. MASSACHUSETTS, Cambridge, 13 Appian Way. V R. JOSHUA KENDALL'S DA Y and Family School for Boys. Fits for College. Phy sical Laboratory. _Cireulars. MASSACHUSETTS, Cambridge. HE CAMBRIDGE SCHOOL for Young Ladies. Mr. ARTHUR GILMAN ts the Director. MASSACHUSETTS, Concord. “NONCORD HUME SCHOOL.—25 BOYS prepared for college, scientific school, or business. All the advantages of family life combined with best mental and physical training. Buildings new and ac cording to latest models. 75 acres of ground. JAMES S. GARLAND. Principal. MASSACHUSETTS, Duxbury. DOWDER POINT SCHOOL. Prepares for Massachusetts Institute of Technolo y, Harvard, or Business. Elementary classes for young yoys. Laboratories. Individual teaching. Exceptional advantages for home and outdoor life. Fifty boys. FP. RB. Knapp, S,B. Massac HUSETTS, ‘Greenfield. ROSPECT HILL SCHOOL FOR GIRLS “AN IDEAL SCHOOL”’—So says a Boston parent. Reference, Rev. E. E. Hale, D.D. JAMES ©. P ARSONS, Prine ipal.— MASSACHUSETTS, .L owell. Yo ROGERS HALL SCHOOL FOR GIRLS. Euiza P. UNDERHILL, M.:! P en ipal. “‘Massac HUSETTs, Plymouth. \, R.KNAPP?S HOME SCHOOL FOR Boys—12 boys; 27th year. H. W. Koyat (Harv.), Head Master. ; Mrs. Knapp, Principal. MASSACHUSETTs, Springfield. 7 R. AND MRS. JOHN McDUFFIE'S a School for Girls. Formerly Miss Howard's. MASSACHUSETTS, Vineyard Haven. ; AYSIDE SUMMER SCHOOL FOR Boys. A healthful Summer home for Boys by the Sea. Out- door life; careful supervision; private tutoring. « References, by permission: Rev. Dr. Coit, St. Paul’s School, Concord, N. Hamilton W. Mabie, Esq., Clinton Hall, peek L.. N.Y, The Rev. WM. CLEVELAND Hicks, M.A., He admaster. Massa ACHUSETTs, Wellesley. ] JELLESLEY HOME SCHOOL FOR ‘ Boys.—Prepares boys for college. Rev. Epw. A. BENNER MASSACHUSETTs, Wellesley. fT OME SCHOOL FOR GIRLS. Thorough preparation for ¢ ‘ollege. Address Miss A. M. GoopNow. MASSACHUSETTS, West ‘Newton. , W* ST NEWTUN ENGLISH AND Classical School. Allen Brothers. The forty second year of this family school for boys and girls begins Wednesday, Sept. #, ISv4. Prepares for College, Scientific School, Busines:, and a useful life. Attention to character-building. Send for catalogue, or call Tuesdays at _ALLEN BROTHERS. MASSACE HUSETTS, Worceste V ORCESTER POL y ‘TECHNIC IN- STITUTE.—Courses in Civil. Mechanical, and Electrical Engineering, Chemistry, and General Science. New and finely equipped laboratories and workshops. Address i. T. '. FULLER, P h.D., P reside nt of Fae ult ye MASSACHUSETTS, Worcester. HE HIGHLAND MILITARY ACA- demy.—Begins 39th year Sept. 12. Classical, Sci entific, Business, Preparatory Departments. Gymna sium. Athletics encouraged. Careful training. Home influences. JOSEPH ALDEN SHAW, A.M., Headmaster. MASSACHUSETTS. Worcester, 66 West St. OHA Ww. OAMLZELLS FRIVATE x School for Boys.—Prepares for College or Scienti tic School. Send for Catalogue. MICHIGAN, Houghton. | TICHIGAN MINING SCHOOL.—A ie State Schvol of Engineering and allied subjects. Has Summer Courses in Surveying, Shop Practice, As saying, Ore-Dressing, and Field Geology. Instruction thoroughly practical. Large equipment. Tuition free. For Catalogue, write to : M. E. Wapsworts, A.M., Ph.D., Director MICHIGAN, Orchard Lake, ] ICHIGAN MILITAR ¥ {CADEM Y. 5: —-The * West Point of the West.” Beautiful loc tion and healthful climate. Noschool in the count offers better advantages for thorough preparation f college. Address Colonel RoGERs, Superintendent. "MINNESOTA, aneep re “TANLEY HALL, A BOARDING AND Day School for Girls. ‘14 instructors ¥ resident, 130 students. Full courses in Music, Art, Langu ages Two years beyond College P reparatory Courses. | ifers scholarship (value $400) to Bryn Mawr College. For catalogue, address Miss OLIVE ADELE Evers, Principal. The Nation. kduc nile: New HaMPsuHiRe, Portsmouth. JOARDING AND DAY SCHOOL FOR Girls. Formerly Miss Morgan's. College-prepara tory and Academic Courses. For circular, address GEORGIANA S, Woopsury, A.B., Principal. NEW JERSEY, Bridgeton, Seven Gables } RS. WESTCUTT’S BOARD! p School for Girls. Certificate admits to ae « ‘oh lege. Special students received Native French and German teachers. In the piney region. Physical cul ture. Climate mild and dry. Illustrated circular on application. NEW JERSEY, Englewood. VOLLEGIATE SCHOOL FOR GIRLS.— Collegiate and spec ial courses of stud.y Cc SROLINE M. GE KRISH, Princ cly al. New JERSEY, M rristown, ] ISS DANA'S SCHUGL FOR GIRLS 4 reopens Sept. 1. Resident, native French and German teachers. Special advantages in Music and Art. Certificate admits to Smith, Wellesley, and Baltimore College for Women Terms for boarding pupils, $700 per year. NEw JERSEY, Nutley. ( “SLOVERSIDE—A Home School for Girls. Under patronage of Bishop Starkey. Opens Sept. 2u, 1sv4. The Misses PimMLow. New JERSEY, Princeton. HE PRINCETON PREPARATORY School opens Sept. 19. Inquiries may be addressed to President Patton of Princeton College, or to - B. FINE, Head master. — MASSACHUSETTS, South Hadley. Y iw NI HOLYONE COLLEGE offers three Collegiate Courses. Music and Art. Libra- ry, Laboratories, Cabinets, and Observatory. The fifty eighth year opens Sept. 18, 1804. Board and tuition, $25v. Mrs. E. S. Meab, President. NEw Or aCE SC i, "ENT PLACE SCHOOL FOR GIRLS, ‘% Elev i over four hundred feet; beautiful house and grounds; all departments; thorough prepara tion for college; high standards and best methods of teaching. Opens September 28 Miss AMELIA S, Watts, Principal New York, Brooklyn, 160 Joralemon Street, ] ISS KATHERINE L. MALTBY'S Home and School. Highest Academic, Art, and Musical advantages, Circular on application New York, Buffs Fy, 254 Delaw are Avenue. , FFALO SEMINAR rhe forty fourth year. For circulars, address Mrs. C .F. HARTT, Principal. — NEW YORK, Newb urgh. 7 HE MISSES MACATE’ S SCHOOL FOR GIRLS, Twenty ninth year. Certificate admits to Vassar and We Uesley. NEW YorK City, 207 Broadw ay M* TROPOL/S LAW SCHOOL Incorporated June, ISV1l. ARNER C. THOMAS, LL. » Dean. Case system of instruction. Degree of CB after course of three years. Morning division, y to 12; evening division, S to 10. For catatogues, ap ply to Prof. CLARENCE D. ASHLEY NEW YorK CI 43 West 47th St ] tss WHI 7 ¢ Ka A.B ~ and Miss BAN » ue English Classical School Native teachers in Modern Languages. Kesident — Certificate ad mits to Smith, Vassar, and Wellesiey. Spectal care in home and school given to little girs. Gvmnesium, NEW YorK ( ITY S57 Fifth Avenue. ‘School of Expressi un. To sup ral edu ation, make acquired Knowledge prac teal, and afford training for the home and for soctety. wu. ALBERTI. New York Crry 32, and 34 East Sith Street. {VD MISS ALS PEELS: SON'S Boarding nd Day School for thursday, October 4, lsvud New YorK Crry, 55 West 47th Street. ) Ms GIBBONS’ SCHUOL FOR GIRS Mrs Sara H. EmeERsos, Princi A few board ing pupils t aken. Re pens October 3 New York, R reeside Detve, | sStb ond Sé6th Sta. THE MISSES ELY'S SCHVOL FOR GIRLS New YorRK Crrty, 183 war ow ad 4 French and English Schaw. Resident pupils. New York, P TOM S I. MARA ~~ ‘an be receive x. 40th vear LD. President NEw Yi rk, Staten island, | New Brigh ton yi HAWAINS'S 1RINITY SCHOOL f r Bows Pre} } ares for college by individual sys tem. Students coacte uriog summer for fall exami lel em ao Educational. New York, Tarrytown lo hp INSTITE ‘ t SOARDIN and Day School for Girls, wil open Sept, 10 Mi , «a MLW Mere alr, Pring New York, Utica, ] RS. PIATT’S SCHOOL FOR GIALS + The next school year begins Thuratay, Sept is¥4. Applications should be made early New York, West New Brighton, Staten Island OT AUSTIN'S MILITARY BOA tng School, Reference Rev. H.C. Potte Bishop of N.Y Terma, $ Rev. G. E. QuaiLe, #4. (Trinity College, Dall Headmaster NORTH Ake LINA, Asheville IAVENSCROFT SCHOOL \’ ik atory ncenio and Day Schoo! for Bows. Head Master, RovaLcp McbDonaup, BLA xford (son of Georg Mac Donaid). Onto, Cincinnati, 14, 17. ls Morris Street eae SCHOOL FOR GIRLS « English and French Day and Fa y Net ior ope us September 27 Onto, Cincinnatt AMS ARMSTRONG'S SCH y Girls, Liddeadale Place, Avonda Family linatt ed. Cireulars sent on application Onto, New Athens ~RANALIN COLLEGC: vines % Sept. 3. Board, tuition, furni ks Sl.S0 to BS OO a wk : total et, $185 a Yr. § courses Do saloons; cheapest, safest, boxt, atahwguc free Ww.aAaA. Wu aX Pres PENNSYLVANIA, Bryn Mawr, t0 miles from t a IA YN VAR ¢ Ld ee lege for Women. The Program stating © etal ate and undergraduate courses of «tf ¥ for the acacte mic year, will be sent on application PENNSYLVANIA, Bryn Mawr MS SBALDWIN’'S may. BOARDING, and COLLEGE PREVPARAT RY SCHOOL FOR GIRLS re pens Sept. Ya ISDE A iress Mise FLORENCE BRatowtn PENNSYLVANIA. Bustleton. near Philade . . ry Ss: LOCALES SC&é * A HIGH CLASS PREPARA RY Ilustrated Catalogue CHARLES H. St lS ror A refined t both «exes Pure mountain air. D+ iCampus. Perfect sa ation Thorough instr ton Charges miuxterat« Send for reular. FMT MIs, A.M... Principal Puxnsy! pV ANIA Germantown, 202, 204, 335 West 4 ten Ave As MARY EL STEVENS BOAR ing and Day Schanl.—v6th vear Approved by bryn Mawr College t Mawrentrance exa ns are held in the school by an examiner from the College. School certificate admits to Vassar PENNSY?VasNta, Hollidaysburg OLLIDA VSBUARG SEMINAR 5 Thorough instruction. Home comforts. Loca tion healthful. Address Mra. R.S. Hitchcock Pr pep vaNtaA, KRingsto WY” ING Si WIN ay. Coeducational. One of the largest and best equipped Seminartes in the U S. Average experience of teachers, tep years Literary and Scientific Courses, Preparation, Business, Music, Art, and Elocu tion. For Catalogue, address Rev. L. L. Srraeve, D_D., President College wr v rr, DONS 4110 and 4112 Spruce St. Day School for Young I men Liberal Education, with Preparation for College. French, Art, and Music rs. Jutia R, TUTWILER, Associate Principal. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, Chestnut Hill yes OMEGYS DM1iSS BELL'S English. French, and German Boarding-School for young ladies reopens October 1. Students prepared for College Ample grounds for outdoor exercise. PENNSY , VANIA, Philadelphia, 1350 Pine St. Af= ANABLE S BOARDING AND Day School for Young Ladies. Estab. ia 1844. Opens Sept 26 P a LVANIA, Philadelphia, 3606 Powelton Ave Mis BARDWELLS HOME AND Day School will reopen Sept. 25, 1804. Limited numbe rof boarding pupils. *ENNSYLVANIA, Willlamsport Di AINSON SEMINARY, — BOTH Sexes. Regular and Elective Courses. Degrees conferred. Fits for College. Musi, Art, Modern Lan guages specialties. Steam heat, electric light, home comforts. Write for catalogue. E. J. Gray, D.D., President. nations, Vith year begit a 2s { Educational continued on page vi.) en ae
Page 4
iv The Nation. [Vol. 59, No. 1517 MACMILLAN & COMPANY’S NEW BOOKS. *¢ A Remarkable Book.’’ JUST READY. FOURTH AND CHEAPER EDITION, WITH NEW PREFACE, SOCIAL EVOLUTION. By BENJAMIN Kipp. 8vo, cloth, $1.75. ‘* A book notable alike for originality and breadth, philosophical reasoning and literary attractiveness. **—Chautauquan. “The volume , conducted through the strong, dignified, and courteous discussion. From a scientific point o logical sociology.’’—Independent. . owes much of its success to its noble tone, its clear and delightful “ye. and to the very great pleasure the reader experiences as he is view it is the most important contribution recently made to bio- SECOND AND CHEAPER EDITION. BY THE LATE DR. C. H. PEARSON. NATIONAL LIFE AND CHARACTER: A Forecast. By CHARLES H. Prarson, Hon. LL.D. St. Andrews, late Fellow of Oriel College, Oxford, and sometime Minister of Education, Victoria. Second Edition. Crown 8vo, $2.00. . “A very remarkable and striking book. Mr. Pearson's speculations on the future of national life and character are certainly a notable sign of the times.” Times. ‘ Forecast.’ "—Saturday Review. ‘*A book with which many will disagree, but which will set a very large number of able persons thinking.” — Academy. ** We at once confess that we have here the mature reflections of a man of superior learning and wide information. . ing, and stimulating to a high degree."°—Andover Review. ‘It is some considerable time since we have read a book on politics with anything like the interest which has accompanied our reading of Mr. Pearson’s . . The book is thoroughly interest- ““. . . One of the most suggestive and stimulating books that have for a long time appeared.”.—New World. ‘¢ The Temple’’ Shakespeare. New Volumes. MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING. LOVE’S LABOUR'S LOST. With Prefaces, Glossaries, etc. By IsrazL GoLLancz, M.A. Imperial 16mo. Printed on Van Gelder hand-made paper, in black and red. Cloth extra, flexible covers, gilt top. Price, each, 45 cents; paste grain roan, limp, gilt top. Price, each, 65 cents. *,* By permission, the text used is that of the ‘Globe Edition, but care- fully amended from that of the latest ‘‘ Cambridge * Edition. ** An exceedingly dainty and enticing edition. ’’—Congregationaliat. Now Ready. Vol. il. THE HOUSE OF FAME. THE LEGEND OF GOOD WOMEN. TREATISE ON THE ASTROLABE. The Oxford Chaucer. Complete Works of Grorrrey CHaucrer. Edited from numerous manuscripts by the Rev. WaLTEr W. Skat, Litt.D., LL.D , M.A., Fellow of Christ’s Col- lege, Cambridge. In six volumes, with Portrait and Facsimiles. &vo, buckram, $4.00 each, net. Already Published. Vol. I. ROMAUNT OF THE ROSE [Minor Poems. Vol. Il. BOETHIUS. TROILUS AND CRISEYDE. The remaining volumes will be published at short intervals during the pre- sent year, “The volumes take rank distinctly among textual critical edicions of our = English classics, like the ‘Cambridge Shakespeare *’’—Literary World Boston). JUST PUBLISHED. A HISTORY OF GERMANY IN THE MIDDLE AGES. By Ernest F. HenpErson, A.M. (Harvard), Ph.D. (Berlin), editor of ‘‘ Select Historical Documents of the Middle Ages” (Bohn). 8vo, cloth, $2.60 net. “Tt must be accounted a happy chance that a volume which unlocks so vast a store of the treasures of research gathered b ory should have been presented in the first plece to the general reader inthis country. T the fleld of German medieval h digested, and is presented in a singularly lucid and attractive way.’’—Scotsman, | Just Published. The Unemployed. By — DraGe, Secretary to the Labour Commission. Crown 8vo. Price, 1.50 i the multitude of workers in 1e material is thoroughly well Primitive Civilizations; Or, Outlines of the History of Ownership in Archaic Communities. By E. J. Smcox, author of ‘ Natural Laws,” etc. 2 vols, 8vo, $10.00. NEW BOOK BY JOHN RUSKIN. LETTERS TO A COLLEGE FRIEND, DURING THE YEARS 1840-1845. Including an Essay on ‘‘ Death before Adam Fell.” By JoHN Ruskin, D.C.L., LL.D. 12mo, cloth, gilt top, $1.50. ALREADY PUBLISHED, VERONA, AND OTHER LECTURES. Delivered principally at the Royal and London [nstitutions between 1870 and 1883. By Joun Ruskin, D.C.L., LL.D. Illustrated with Frontis- piece in colour and 11 Photogravure Plates from drawings by the author. 8vo, cloth, $2.50 net. Vol. 1, New Translation, The Novels of Ivan Turgenev. Translated from the Russian by Constance GARNETT. In seven volumes. 1fmo, cloth extra, gilt top, $1 25 each. Now Ready. Vol 1., RUDIN. Further volumes in preparation. ‘*Mrs. Garnett‘s version of ‘ Rudin’ reads, indeed, with all the charm and ease of an original work, and all true lovers of good literature will feel grateful to her for having so ably accomplished a difficult task *— Publishers’ Circular. Fust Published, Hints on Driving. By Captain C Morvey Knieur, R.A. Illustrated by G. H. A. Waits. Royal Artillery. 12mo, cloth, $1.25 net.. Fust Published. Children’s Singing Games. With the Tunes to which they are Sung. Collected and edited by ALice B Gomme. Picturedin black and white by Winifred Smith. Oblong &vo, or- namental, $1.50, *,* Also two Editions de Luxe, limited; one printed on Kelmscott paper, bound in linen, $9.00 net. The other, printed on Japanese vellum, bound in vel- lum, $11 00 net. ; Aspects of Modern Study. Being University Extension Addresses by Lord PLayrarr, Canon Browne, Mr. Goscaen, Mr. Joun Morvey, Sir JAMES PaGet, Professor Max MU Lier, the Duke of ARGYLL, the Bishop of DuaHam, and Professor JesB. 12mo, cloth, $1.90. FULY NUMBER NOW READY, BOOK REVIEWS. A Monthly Journal devoted to New and Current Publications. Price, 5 cents per number. Yearly subscription, 50 cents. *,* The leading article this month is the second of the series of papers by Mr. F. MARION CRAWFORD, entitled ‘‘ Modern Views of Mysticism.” MACMILLAN & CO,, 66 Fifth Avenue, New York.
Page 5
iP i PERLE 5 NEW YORK, THURSDAY, JULY 26, 1894. The Week. THE letter of President Cleveland to Chairman Wilson was both timely and just. Mr. Cleveland had a perfect right to senditto Mr. Wilson. Mr. Wilson had an equal right to read it in the House or to send it to the clerk’s desk to be read if the House was willing. The Senators, each and all, have the equal right to vote for or against the President's views. This is a comprehensive statement of the case, and it cannot be considered as alarming in any point of view. Nor can it be said that ‘‘ undue pressure’’ has been brought to bear on Senators by the President. Our history does not show the existence of danger to liberty in that quarter. As a matter of fact, the sayings of a President are of little avail with Senators or Representatives unless those sayings find a response among the constituencies. Probably Mr. Cleve- land’s desire and intention were to awaken such a response, and he has suc- ceeded in doing so. Senator Gorman has ‘‘freed his mind,”’ and it is to be hoped that he feels better for it. Certainly he has done no harm to the cause of tariff reform by his pas- sionate outburst of Monday against Mr. Cleveland. The Maryland Senator deceives himself greatly if he supposes that the people are going to pay much attention to a controversy as to the President’s attitude toward the forced comproniises in the tariff bill while the matter was pending in the upper branch of Congress. The country has studied the career of Grover Cleveland for a dozen years with the utmost care, and long since made up its mind in regard to him. The one charge which it is most ridicu- lous to bring against the President is that of disingenuousness, duplicity, and de- ceit. It isa mere waste of words for Gorman to try to convince the public that Cleveland deliberately misled Sena- tors as to his attitude. He might as well set out to demonstrate that he him- self is astatesman whose sole aim has always been the public interest. There is no higher authority on con- stitutional law in the United States than Judge Cooley of Michigan, and President Cleveland may well feel proud to receive an expression of* the ‘‘unqualified satisfaction’’ which he feels with every step taken by the executive in vindication of the national authority during the recent crisis. Judge Cooley is of the opinion that ‘a great and valuable lesson in constitu- tional construction has been settled for The Nation. all time. There can be no dissent from this view. The President's course has been formally endorsed by each branch of Congress almost unanimously, and it has been sustained bv an overwhelming majority of the people in every part of the country. It was practically a new issue in the administration of the na- tional government, and the executive was called upon for a decision as to the proper construction of the Constitution. It is fortunate for the future of the United States not only that Mr. Cleve- land’s decision was right, but that it has been promptly and universally accepted as right. As Judge Cooley says, a great issue has been ‘‘ settled for all time.”’ An extraordinary lot of jargon comes from the mouth of Gov. Hogg of Texas, indicating that Senator Gordon, as the leader of the Loyal Confederate Legion, ought to have an eye onhim. Accord- ing to the World's report of a militia re view at Austin last week, the Governor was in very low spirits as to the future of the nation. President Cleveland's action in sending troops to Chicago without the sanction of Gov. Altgeld had gone far, he thought, towards the dis- memberment of the Union. We were on the eve of a revolution if such things should go on. ‘ In that event,’ he said, ‘“*l want to see Texas fall on her feet, and live under her old Constitution of 1856 asa republic.” There are several obstacles to this dénouement. One is, that General Gordon, with his army of Confederate veterans larger than Lee ever commanded, would march to Tex as and bring the Lone Star back to the place where she belongs and perhaps hang Governor Hogg on a sour-apple tree Another is, that the Texans themselves don’t want to ‘‘fallon their feet and live under the old Constitution of 1836." They want to stand on their feet and live in the American Union, whether President Cleveland sends troops to Chi cago or whether he sends them to Austin —and he would as soon send them to the latter city as to the former All the Hoggs in Texas are not Gov- ernors. One of them is a professor, and he introduced resolutions at the recent State Teachers’ Association calling for a systematic course of instruction in the schools ‘‘ which shall embrace not only a broader patriotism, but a more extend- ed moral instruction, especially in regard to the rights and duties of citizenship, the right of property, the security and sacredness of human life.”’ He rightly maintained that the ideas on these sub- jects which got into the heads of the prove of the open defiance of the rights and security of property, their education on the subject cannot begin too early His resolutions were not adopted, but were commended to the attention of the National Educational Association. Su perintendent Hogg of Fort Worth seems to be right on the trail of Gov Hogy of Austin The latest batch of riotous boycotters to be indicted at Chicago were released on bail, and their bail- bonds were sign ed by city officials This is but one more proof of the sympathy of the city authorities with the violent strikers. It is no wonder that the power of the mob was so desperate in a city so governed The anarchist vote is still thought to be worth angling for in Chicago We shall see men running for city oftices at the next election on a platform of the city for strikers, no troops, and death to employers who will not arbitrate. There is no likeluhood of suceess on such a platform, any more than there was in the attempt to beat Judge Gary for having tried and condemned the Hay market anarchists The sentiment of the city is no doubt overwhelmingly on the side of law and order But the strikers and the agitators make so much more noise than the respectable folks that vour stupid politician runs after the rioters, and then is surprised when the people read the riot act to him as well as to them ** President © Debs has issued his pro clamation to the people of the United States urging them not to ride in Pull mancars. The object of this is two fold: first, to carry out the boycott that Debs attempted to enforce but could not; second, to express the sympathy of the American people for rioters and incendiaries, law-breakers, and train wreckers. It is safe to predict that so long as Debs’s desperadoes are at- tacking trains and turning switches and loosening rails, those people who must travel will ride in Pullman cars, be- cause they are 50 per cent. stronger and safer than ordinary cars. Apart from this consideration, it is quite certain that all but the merest fraction of those who can afford to ride in Pullman cars will do so to show their abhorrence of mobs, if for no other reason. The out burst of approval of President Cleve land’s action in sending troops to Chi- cago to suppress Debs and raise his blockade, is a sure sign that the only boycott which meets public sympathy is that which the railroads are applying to the villains who are throwing stones 25,000,000 school-children of this coun- try would come out when they became | ee . P i citizens, and that if they are to disap- | through car windows, and sawing bridge timbers, and displacing rails and switches, ae a ental settee seg eC ow rm ts ns na es my Maem © “ Sap re 4 apt neg Hey ee en
Page 6
6 One thing about the Pullman situa- tion that seems to stick in the crops of a great many people is the fact that the company did not lower rents when it was forced to lower wages. Mr. Pull- man’s statement of facts in regard to the car-building business—a statement fully confirmed by his competitors—has stilled fault-finding on the score of re- duced wages. The men earned less, but the company earned nothing. That is admitted; but people say, ‘‘ Yes, but the company is not only acar-builder, it is a landlord as well, and should have lower- ed rents when it did wages.’”’ Now, what are the facts? About two-thirds of the Pullman employees do not live in the company’s houses at all. They have homes in Roseland and other adjoining places. Rents there are as high as in Pullman, accommodations and conve- niences considered. So if the company had lowered the rent of the one-third of the employees on the premises, it would have been bound, in justice, to make an equivalent present to the other two- thirds. Then what would the neighbor- ing landlords have said at such a cut- ting under the ruling rentals? They would have had a grievance, and in ac- cordance with strict ‘ethical concepts” would have had a just claim on the Pullman Company for a sum equal to their diminished receipts. In short, there would have been no end to the absurdities and injustices which would have result- ed from any such attempt to make up to the men in rent what they were los- ing in wages. There would have been just as much reason in asking the local butcher or grocer or clothier to knock off one-quarter of his prices on account of a reduction in wages. When we add the factthat no workman was compelled to stay in Pullman, and that the com- pany was actually $70,000 behindhand in rents due from employees, we see how little there is in the whole contention.
The statement of the law relating to strikes, made on Wednesday week at Indianapolis by Judge Baker of the United States Court, deserves general attention. The case before him was that of a striker accused of contempt of court in violating an injunction, and Judge Baker laid it down flatly that it was contempt of court for any body of men to engage in a com- bination ‘‘to strike and to interfere with anybody else who goes to work, and to denounce them as scabs.’’ ks, and hurl innocent men to death. That 1s what it means. They talk about being peacea- ble. Every one that has any sense at all knows that a strike would not amount to any- thing unless they follow it out by violence. They know that if they would do what they have a right to do, decently and orderly, go about their business and leave the employees alone, a strike would not amount to anything. They know it wou'd absolutely fail.”
These remarks of Judge Baker were apparently obiter dicta, and the question raised is of such far-reaching impor- tance that it will unquestionably be carried to the Supreme Court of the United States for final decision. But it is greatly to be desired that the precise point involved should be kept free from all confusing elements, and that the attention of the public should be fixed upon it. The question is not of the right to strike; that, if not con- ceded, is at least not in issue. It is not of the right to combine to strike, al- though that question will require tho- rough consideration. The true question is, how far a striker may go in prevent- ing his former employer from hiring an- other man to take his place, and how far a combination of strikers may pro- ceed in the same direction. From an- other point of view, and altogether the higher one, the question is whether or no a man desiring to work shall be pro- tected by the law against the threats and the violence of men who desire that he should not work. We hear much long- ing expressed for ‘‘ industrial peace.’’ It is upon the answer to this question given by the Supreme Court of the United States that industrial peace depends.
Judge Baker’s decision in the case of the Lake Erie and‘Western Railroad Com- pany vs. Bailey is the most comprehen- sive and exact statement of the rights of workingmen and the paramount rights of society that the labor troubles have given rise to. It stands in respect of judicial opinions on the same plane with Senator Davis’s speech in public discussion. It is replete with sympathy for the poor man, but firm in its main- tenance of the right of the state to exist. Society cannot exist unless the right of every man to labor and to enjoy the fruit of his labor is protect- ed and upheld. ‘If society were over- thrown,” says Judge Baker, ‘‘and men turned back into conditions of an- archy, as they were in large measure during the dark ages, when power and force made right, the condition of the laboring man would not be bet- tered. If such were the condition of so- ciety, the man or the men with great intellectual power and great wealth would become the masters of the iaboring classes,as in the dark ages, and the la- borer would be little better than a slave, ”
An assault upon life or property commit- ted by members of a labor organization, he affirms, is just as much a violation of law, both human and divine, as one committed by a single individual against a traveller on the highway. ‘‘If they compel submission, it is robbery, because whoever compels me, by force or terrorism, to give up one dime of my money, or one dime’s worth of my prop erty, is equally guilty, whether it be the man who meets me on the street corner in the night time, or an organized band of strikers who take possession of my property and deprive me of its use.”’
But that is not the worst of it, says the judge. These combinations teach disregard and contempt of ail law: “They make people think that human rights are of novalue. They teach the fantastic and monstrous doctrine that a man who is hired to labor, and is paia for bis work, has some sort of equitable right in the property of his employer, together with a right of perpetual employment. It has been said on the floor of the United States Senate that the laborer has a sort of equitable lien on the rroperty of the man for whom he works, whose money bought the property, together with the mght of perpetual employment. It may do for men that are reckless of the wel- fare of human society—-who care nothing for its peace and good order-—-to imperil life, property, and liberty, and the perpetuity of our institutions by teaching such doctrines; but the judge who tolerates it ought to be stripped of his gown and be driven from the sacred temple of justice.”’ Truer words were never spoken from the bench.
Congress has been humoring ‘‘ Labor’ by passing what seemed to be a harm- less sort of act, but there is already trouble about the new law. It provides that the first Monday in September, ‘‘being the day celebrated as labor’s holiday,”’ shall hereafter te a legal pub- lic holiday ‘‘in the same manner as Christmas, the first day of January, the 22d of February, and the 30thday of May are now made by law public holidays.”’ In the first place, there is no act of Con- gress under which the days just men- tioned are public holidays; they are made such by Statelaws. In the second place, the new law does not make it clear whether Congress intended it to apply to the District of Columbia alone or to the whole country. In the third place, the first Monday of September is not universally ‘‘the day celebrated as labor’s holiday.’’ The second State in the Union observes the first Saturday of Sep- tember; and if the act just passed is of national application, Pennsylvania will have two labor holidays in the same week. The bill appears to have slipped through Congress without much notice, as a harmless sop to ‘‘ Labor,” but it will be necessary to pass another law to clear up the uncertainty and confusion caused by its hasty enactment.
The conduct of the Senate in insisting upon increasing the appropriation for the Department of Agriculture against ee $ a
Page 7
a Be ake aa ct kako eee July 26, 1894] the recommendation of Secretary Mor- ton, is as unprincipled as it isindefensible. Secretary Morton has distinguished him- self by effecting very great economies in the administration of his department, in accordance with the principles and professions of the Democratic party, and he has the mortification of seeing his labors nullified by a mongrel majority of Populists, Republicans, and recreant Democrats, who propose to compel him to devote amillion dollars to the extir- pation of asingle weed. The attitude of the Populist Senators is especially note- worthy as showing the insincerity of their professions of anxiety to relieve the burdens of the common. people. The House of Representatives may with the greatest propriety make a vigorous tight upon this item. The passage by the House of the reso lution for a constitutional amendment providing that Senators shall be elected by the people was generally expected, but itis universally admitted that the matter will be shelved in the other branch. There will be little pro test against such action by the Senate, for public sentiment has not yet become pronounced in favor of the change. The chief argument urged for the amendment is the claim that legis latures are subject to corruption and often to bad influences, and Congress man Everett of Massachusetts made a forcible reply to this when he said: ** Who choose the legislatures, Mr. Speak- er? Where do those legislatures come from ‘ They come from the people; they come from the very ones to whom you wish to intrust the election of Senators. I believe in the people; but | believe that if there is corruption in the legislatures, it must be because there are weak spots somewhere in the yeople that lead to this corruption. If there is corruption showing itself in the elections of the legisla- tures which chocse the Senators, that cor ruption will show itseif sooner or later in the popular vote.” When one sees a Peffer in the Senate, it is natural to think that the blame must lie in the method of choice; but when we find that the popular vote gave the same state a Lewelling for Governor, we perceive that there is no assurance of obtaining statesmen by any device. Poor Secretary Gresham has done it again. After having so many times incurred the honest scorn of the news- paper Jingoes, he has now tried to please them by ‘‘ reversing himself ’’ and taking the nations by the ears in the he roic Blaine fashion, but only to find him self scorned and flouted worse than ever. To be sure, the basis for the scorn seems rather crumbly on investigation. He had grossly insulted Japan, it was clear, but the Japanese minister denies it, and says that he and his Government are well pleased with the course of the Adminis- tration in the Corean affair. This may be Oriental duplicity, however. It has that air. Other terrible features of the | stery look more kindly on examination The Nation. When the whole correspondence is pub- lished, the able editors may be the ones to have to reverse themselves. But that will not help Mr. Gresham. Reversed or going ahead, they are always able to make out that he is a blunder er and an ignoramus and a no account American. He should have known bet ter than to meddle with Corea. We read that a Japanese empress named Jingo attempted the conquest of Corea in the sixteenth century. Naturally her American descendants are touchy on that subject There is much interesting reading for the friends of liberty in Hawai in the record of the proceedings of the Consti tutional Convention for the day when it was decided to appoint a President for six years. A few timid souls objected Delegate Emmeluth thought the con vention had no right to appoint a Presi dent. Minister Damon said that to ap point a President in a convention called for another purpose * looked too much like a sharp move.”’ Delegate Kahau lelio observed that it seemed as though ‘‘in Honolulu the people could not trust their representatives.”” Counse! lor Smith favored going through the form of a popular election, on the ground that it would ‘look better abroad.”’ But all these gbsurd views had no weight beside the argument set forth by Councillor Brown. Said he ‘**We have got things now in our own hands. Shall we loosen our hold in the slightest degree? We never know in this country what politics will bring forth. l advise holding on to what we are sure of, and taking no chances of losing it.”’ He was strongly supported by Delegate Robertson, who pointed out what an ‘‘enormous temptation’’ it would be to the royalists to try to carry the election, if one were weakly conceded. He, to», thought it ‘* better to take no chances."” Delegate Vivas said that, with action like that, a tight would come sooner or later, as ‘‘stable government was not a possibility as long as such oligarchical proceedings were tolerated.’’ But twenty-seven out of the thirty six delegates decided to take no chances, regardless of how it would look abroad. President Dole himself, much to his credit, protested against the ac tion, and affirmed that the convention could not constitutionally appoint a President.’’ But he accepted the oftice, nevertheless, and thus presents the cu rious spectacle of a President who con fesses that he has no constitutional war rant to his title These deep mysteries of Hawaiian representative institutions we have in vain asked their ofticial champions in this country to expound. They remain silent, but we get the needed light from a man on the spot. One of the truest and ' most forward patriots now in Hawaii, -—- -~. ‘ *) Mr. W. N. Armstrong, gives the true constitutional view of the situation in an article printed in the HHeawatian Ga vette of June Li. He shows how “the necessities of the case demand an un commonly strong central government with very large powers in the hands of a few,’ and then adds, with a noble disr gard of how it will look abroad “This proposal is not *demecratic,’ but is based on the necessities of the cas if we were here alone, very ittle government would be quite sufficient, because the true Anglo Saxon does not require much gover? ment; each man rules himself it uptist be distinctly understoed that, besides ruling themselves, the whites must create a f : government through which they can rule na tives, Chinese, Javanes: amd Portugues mn order to prevent being ‘snowed under That is, we need two distinet forms of government made up into one form, one for ourselves and one for aliens, who outnumber us That which may be quite suffictent for us, would probably be utterly insufficient for them tf we wish to keep control.” A recent articie by M. Paul Leroy Reaulieu in the Journal des IMbats is de voted to the “ homestead."’ This word is now often heard in political discussions in France, and it seems that in their rather desperate struggles to do some thing to quiet social discontent, the French politicians have grasped st it as suggesting an American tnstitution which they might utilize M. Leroy Beaulieu considers the matter with his usual ability, and points out that, taking the word in the sense in which itis used in the statutes granting Government lands to actual settlers, the institution would be in France an impossibility. He then examines the‘ homestead exemp tion’ acts of the several States and shows how completely they have failed to ac complish their purpose. They have had no effect whatever in fixing families to the soil, in making population permanent, in causing the transmission of property from father to son. Nor has the true pur pose of this legislation—the protection of the wife and infant children—-been at tained. The power to encumber and to alienate being retained, the exemption act becomes utteriy ineffective. It is said that in Seneca County, in the State of New York, there were forty declarations of ‘‘ homestead exemption’? within the two years following the passage of theact, about 1[850; since which time there has not been a single one. As M. Leroy BKéau lieu says, it is idle to discuss the policy of trving an experiment in France which has so completely failed in this country; besides which, there are conditions in French institutions which would make the scheme incon- gruous. We must confess that it is rather surprising that the plan of ren dering small homesteads actually in- alienable has not received more atten tion in this country. It would be to a certain extent a return to medieval conditions; but then, trade-unions are medieval institutions, and they have been enthusiastically advocated by some modern reformers par seit yaar meet eeagheine® matareammenay ~ venta gthareriaes ed Lye we agutimpucac sitet to 2 ke i a cane d OH thn
Page 8
58
The Nation. [Vol. 59, No. 1517
A WASHINGTONIAN PRECEDENT. In the debate on Monday, Senator Gor- man appealed to the authority of George Washington to shield the Senate against what he called executive dictation. George Washington’s example is better authority than Senator Gorman’s inter- pretation of his words. What Washing- ton did is of more consequence than what Gorman said. We therefore pro- pose to examine the record of Washing- ton’s first term of office, and of the first Senate of the United States, in order to see how far Mr. Gorman is justified in his appeal to history. It will be useful, as a preliminary step, to ascertain what the Constitution says about the duties of the President towards public measures, Article 2, sec- tion 3, says: “He shall, from time to time, give to the Congress information of the state of the Union, and recommend to their consideration such measures as he shall judge necessary and expedient.”’ This does not restrict the President to an annual message. He can send mes- sages every day of the session if he likes. He is not restricted to general principles. He can go into details to any extent. He is not limited in any way whatever either as to time or as to form or man- ner of communication. He can make his communications either in writing or in person. It is customary now for the President to communicate his views in writing in all cases, but that was clearly not the original con- ception or intention. Washington him- self presided over the convention that framed the Constitution His name is the first one appended to it. He was the first President elected under it. The Senate which sat during his first Presidential term contained eleven members of the Constitutional Conven- tion. What they did not know about the spirit and meaning of that instru- ment we shall not be likely to learn from Arthur P. Gorman at the present time. : The outrage committed by President Cleveland within a few days past con- sists in writing a letter to the Hon. W. L. Wilson, a member of the House of Representatives, which that gentleman obfained leave to make public. The letter dealt with certain details of the tariff bill and gave the President's views concerning the same. Is there anything harmful in that? The Con- stitution says that he shall recom mend such measures as he shall judge necessary and expedient. In this par- ticular case he recommended them to the chairman of the House committee on ways and means—a very fit person to receive a communication of this sort. He might have sent the same letter, without the change of a syllable, to either branch of Congress or to both. If he had gone to the Senate in person and taken the Vice-President’s chair
and told the Senators all that he told Mr. Wilson, and then had waited to see them vote, he would have done no more than Washington did in the month of August, 1789, without exciting un- favorable comment among members who had sat with him in the Constitu- tional Convention. But if Mr. Cleve- land had done this, Mr. Gorman and Mr. Vest and several other great constitu- tional lawyers would have been petrified with amazement and indignation. The narrative of Washington’s action in the case referred to is found in the diary of Senator Maclay of Pennsyl- vania, who kept a record of the proceed- ings of the first session, when that body sat with closed doors. Congress was then sitting in New York. On the 22d of August, 1789, President Washington, having a communication to make to the Senate concerning the Cherokee Indians, went to the Senate Chamber in company with Gen. Knox, secretary of war; the Vice-President, John Adams, vacated his chair and President Washington took it. He told the Senate what he had come for, and said that he had brought Gen. Knox along because he knew all about the business. The Indians had complained of harsh treatment by the people of North Carolina. The papers in Gen. Knox’s hands would explain the situation more fully. Then the President handed a treaty of seven articles to the Vice-President and asked him to read it. He didso. There was so much noise in the street from passing carriages that the Senators could not hear it. So the Vice-President went back to the beginning and read the first article again and immediately put it to a vote. Hereupon Mr. Maclay sug- gested that, as the subject was of some importance, he would like to have the accompanying papers in Gen. Knox’s hands read also. Here, says Mr. Maclay: “I cast an eye at the President of the United States. I saw that he wore an aspect of stern displeasure.” The first article of the treaty was postponed, then the second, and then the third. Finally, a motion was made and carried that the whole subject be postponed till the following Monday. Then, says Mr. Maclay: **As I sat down, the President of the United States started up in a violent fret. ‘ ‘This defeats every purpose of my coming here,’ were the first words that he said.” The whole story will be found in pages 122-125 of Mr. Maclay’s book, and we commend it to the serious attention of Mr. Gorman and the other great consti- tutional lawyers who are impressed with the teachings of Washington, and are alarmed for the independence of the Senate. PLAYTHING LABOR COMMISSIONS. THE strike now being over but for the sporadic bandits who keep on wrecking trains, it appears that the President
will soon appoint the promised commis- sion to investigate it, or ‘‘sit on the corpse.”” A common impression is that this commission is going to arbitrate something or other, or at least to offer to do so. This is because the law under which it is to act is known as the arbitration law of October 1, 1888. But the appointment of the commission is provided for in sections 6 to 11 of that statute, which were meant to cover a case like the present, where both parties to a “ difference”’ will not agree to sub- mit to arbitration. In such event a com- mission may be named by the President, ‘either upon his own motion or upon the application of one of the parties,” to ‘* examine the causes of the controversy, the conditions accompanying and the best means of adjusting it.’? The ap- pointees have no power to decide or ar- bitrate anything, but shall report to the President and to Congress, and there- upon their ‘‘ services [at $10 a day] shall cease.” From all this it is clear that all we shall get out of the inquiry will be a huge Government report which nobody will read, which will settle nothing and satisfy nobody. <A striking example of the futility of such Government commis- sions is afforded by the recent bringing to a close of the labors of the English Royal Commission on Labor. Appointed by Lord Salisbury in 1891, it has taken testimony from all sorts and condi- tions of men and has sought contribu- tions from the ends of the earth, with the result of having filled sixty-five blue- books, spent $250,000, and accomplished absolutely nothing. Some of the vol- umes and reports contain instructive facts and views, but they were all acces- sible beforehand. Many of them are loaded down with fantastic opinions and wild theories of cranks and revolution- aries, who were delighted at the chance to get into print at Government expense, but who are no more edifying there than when mouthing at street-corners or in socialist mass-meetings. By sound eco- nomists and by agitators alike, the com- mission is condemned as a gigantic failure. Yet there is nothing more popular just now than commissions to investi- gate labor or silver. A Dutch commis- sion on labor has been sitting since 1890, and has just published its twentieth volume. It would seem as if the design were to crush out all rational interest in the investigation. Men will say: ‘‘ If we've got to read those thousands of pages before knowing the merits of the labor question, let us die in happy igno- rance.’’ A mere epitomized index to the English commission’s publications fills more than 200 pages. What a warning that is to mortals to leave hope behind if they enter there! Yet the demand for commissions survives even such horrible examples. As far as the European gov- ernments are concerned, the principle
sae Zo i os SPOR ee
Page 9
Beet oy AERO $ be RS Ries: Ea eR SF HOS eR,
gh
July 26, 1894]
on which they agree to name a commis- sion on labor or silver has been well de- scribed by the German economist Bam- berger. He said that Caprivi’s latest silver commission was very much like the advice of a physician to a hopeless invalid to go to the south of France: it interested the patient for a while, though it did him no good whatever, and relieved the physician. Lord Salis- bury was hard beset by the Radicals in 1891. They wanted laws on wages and strikes and arbitration and heaven knows what. ‘ No,” said his lordship gravely, ‘*T can’t commit the Government to such measures just now, but I'll give you a labor commission.’? Thereupon there was great rejoicing in labor circles, Something was going to be done at last. Even the Tories saw that things could not go on as they were much longer. Well, the Labor Commission has come and gone, and things do go on as they did, and will continue to do so in spite of the sixty-five blue-books. Mean while, the patient has had something to occupy his mind for three years, and the physician has had a pleasant vaca tion. For the complaining workingmen, on the other hand, a labor commission is a good deal like a plaything. It gives their leaders a splendid chance to air their views and get a respectful hearing from grave investigators, and be bound up and buried at Government expense. They will have nothing new to say to the Chicago commission. They will state their grievances and their ideas of what ought to be done, and then the Pullman people and the railway mana- gers will give their side of the case and say what cannot be done, and then all will be printed and turned over to Con- gress, and nobody the wiser or the better. If the workingmen are pleased with that sort of thing, they are welcome to it. All we can say is, they are easily pleased. Erasmus Darwin’s little boy used to get so tired half-way round the park that he could not possibly walk another step, and then his father would give him his cane to ride home, and he would gallop off in delight. If thestrikers can be sent back to work equally happy with their com- mission, it is certainly wise to give it to them. But that it will ever prove any thing more than an expensive plaything there is no reasonable prospect.
THE NEW THEORIES OF WAGES. THE boycott and the sympathetic strike were not the only institutions that were badly damaged during the recent dis- turbances at Chicago. Anarchy in general received a blow more than sufficient to make up for the en- couragement recently given it by Gov, Altgeld’s pardons, and socialistic views and tendencies were severely nipped by public opinion. The position taken by the “* ethical school "’ of political econo-
mists in regard to wages has hada great deal more to do than is commonly sup posed with arousing discontent among wage-workers, and it is interesting to see how untenable this position becomes when examined in the light of recent events. The gist of what used to be known as the ‘‘ wages-fund theory’ was that wages were paid out of previously accu- mulated capital It was further laid down that, at any particular time, the amount of capital intended to be applied to the payment of wages was a fixed quantity. It followed from this that whatever tended to increase’ the amount of capital applicable in this manner was a good thing for those who -arned their living by selling their labor. Provided their numbers did not increase in the same proportion as capital, their wages necessarily would increase. It was also a corollary that whatever in- duced people to devote a larger part of their wealth to productive enterprises, was advantageous to the working-class es. The expectation of profit, there fore, was the mother of wages. When the “ ethical school’”’ took hold of political economy, the first thing they attacked was the wages-fund theory, and they succeeded, according to their statements, in ‘‘ exploding’’ it. It was too mathematical in character for sentimental purposes. They said that all the theory amounted to was the identical proposition that with a certain dividend and a certain divisor you will get a certain quotient. In stead of this dry and heartless way of looking at things, they proposed to es tablish an ‘* industrial partnership’’ be- tween the workman and the master, in which the profits were to be divided ina more equitable manner than of old. The scientific basis assumed for this partner- ship was found in the doctrine that the workman’s wages came out of the pro- duct of his industry. Thus, if a man was hired to build a boat, a certain portion of the boat, as fast as it was construct- ed, became ethically his, as the embodi ment of his labor. In other words, workmen were rightfully entitled to a share in the profits of their labor; and when this doctrine became diffused among them—which it naturally did with great rapidity—they at once felt that they were suffering great injustice because this share was not larger The weak spot in the new theory was always the possibility of there being no profits, and we have never been able to discover that the ethical professors were willing to explain how this difficulty could be overcome. But the strike of the Pullman workmen throws the whole mat- ter into the clearest light. The Pullman Company asserted positively that it was making no profits at all, even after it had reduced wages, and that therefore it would not raise wages. But the work men said that that made no difference;
that if the company could not pay wages out of its future profits, it must pay them out of its past profits. These profits had either been fixed in the busi ness or had been distributed to stock holders as dividends; but that did not affect the demands of the workmen Wages, they had been told, came out of profits, and they no doubt thought it immaterial whether these were present, past, or future In this, itmust be admitted, the work men exceeded their instructions; but this only makes it clearer how imprac ticable the theory of those instructions was, Just so soon as any strain comes, men naturally tly back to what ts not only the common-sense view, bat also the actual and necessary fact, that wages are paid out of accumulated capital, No doubt wages are paid because the capi talist expects to make a profit by paying them; but they must be paid in advance of the profit—-before it is certain that any profit will be made, or, if any, how much; and they remain paid although the whole capital is lost They are sure; profit is contingent. It is because of this that profits require to seem large in order to tempt capitalists to make invest ments, They know that they may have to expend large sums in wages before they get any return, and that perhaps they may never get any return. Into such a partnership as this workmen can not enter, although it may be for the in terest of the capitalist to share the pro fits with them, when he makes any The “ ethical”’ theory thus crumbles away when it is put to the test of expe rience. It would require that the em ployees of the Pullman Company should now work for nothing, for that would be about their share of the present profits of the concern. On the other hand, if the sounder theory of wages is adopted, everything is made to depend upon the accumulation of wealth and the expec tation of profit, for the expectation of profit leads to the competition of em ployers for the services of laborers, and the possession of wealth makes this com- petition effective. The present condition of business is sufticient to make the folly of threatening investors and denouncing capitalists apparent. No better plan for keeping wages low can be devised than to assure the owners of wealth that, if they invest it, the control of it shall be taken out of their hands, and the propor- tion of it which they shall pay in wages be determined by other people. CLUBS WITHIN THE CHURCHES. No development of church life within the past ten years has been more strik- ing than the rise and prominence of what may be called clubs within the churches. The Christian Endeavorers, with their gigantic annual meetings and membership wide as the world, are just now the most conspicuous organiza-
i pot
A, I gener,
wt tHE SPAMS i
22 on gies eRe He wy A
ie del
nent
<a SOR te ee ee
Page 10
GO The Nation. [Vol. 59, No. 1517 - = tion of the kind, but there are many others. A iittle hand-book lately print- ed by the Congregationalist gives a long list of church associations for men and boys, running all the way from the Young Men’s Christian Asso- ciation, founded fifty years ago, to the ‘* Knighthood of King Arthur,’’ organ- ized only last year. The public is be- ginning to hear a good deal of the ‘* Boys’ Brigade,”’ a church organization about four years old in this country, but already numbering 10,000 members. Then there are the well-known Episcopal ‘* Brotherhood of St. Andrew,” ‘‘ Boys’ Clubs,’”’ and ‘‘ Men’s Clubs,’’ the ‘‘ Men’s Sunday Evening Clubs,’ and various others. Of course, the obvious intent and main avowed purpose of these clubs is religious. They are organized as auxili- ary to regular church work. ‘‘ The Men’s Sunday Evening Club,” for ex- ample, was got up to help clergymen solve the distressing problem of the Sunday evening service. By having a club take charge of the service, and de- vise special programmes, and give par- ticular attention to music, and induce the pastor to agree to preach short ser- mons, gratifying results have followed in certain churches, for a time at least. Others are more frankly social. Thus, the object of one ‘‘men’s club”’ is said to be a monthly meeting ‘‘ of the nature of smoke talks without the smoke.’’ But this is an extreme case, it must be admitted, and most of the clubs in the list exist avowedly for the purpose of doing some kind of religious work in connection with the church in which they are established. Yet there appears to be little doubt that their success and increasing mem- bers are due to causes not directly and explicitly religious. Novelty is the main charm in many of them,and no doubt some will disappear, as their predeces- sors did, after this attraction has worn away. To goto church or prayer-meet- ing simply may seem a stupid affair to many a young person who may be quite fascinated, for the time at any rate, by wearing a badge and belonging to a so- ciety with a mysterious set of initials. Doubtless many a boy is lured into church or Sunday-school by the uniform and military drill and summer encamp- ments of the ‘‘ Boys’ Brigade,’ whom it would have been hard to catch by any of the staid old forms of public worship. But itis the social element which un- doubtedly gives these organizations with- in the churches their great hold. They are peculiarly strong in country church- es, and it is in country places that the social influence of the church is most felt and appreciated, and, we sincerely be- lieve, needed. Nothing is more depress- ing about the decay of churches in New England hill towns than the correspond- ing decay of the social intercourse which once went hand in hand with the life of the churches. If the new church clubs can do what the old theology cannot any longer, and develop the social side of life in the very place where it most of all needs cultivating, it is no wonder that they are popular or are encouraged. The deeper relations of such organi- zations, whether to the church or to society in general, invite a more thorough discussion than we can give here. Some persons see in them a peri- lous spread of the mania for organiza- tion, which, in the industrial sphere, has wrought so much evil, substituting the tyranny of the majority or of a few skilled leaders for the independent judg- ment of the individual. Clearer, perhaps, is the insidious danger to the Church herself—the historical Church, we mean a fountain of authority and channel of divine grace. There is no telling what these organizations which she is now warming in her bosom will do to her when they get their growth. After the ‘‘ smoke talk without the smoke”’ may come the preaching service without the sermon. Indeed, the tendency at present decidedly is to let the smoke in and crowd thesermon out. The ‘‘ Men’s Sunday Evening Club” already insists upon a ‘‘ short sermon.’’ From that the step is not a long one to such an attrac- tion as we revently saw advertised in the notice of anevening service ina country town, ‘‘Sermon omitted.’’ That step taken, could the morning sermon long escape assault? Seriously, the teaching, authoritative function of the Church seems menaced by these clubs which are usurping so much of her time and strength; just as, on the other hand, her very welcome of their aid.is a sign that she feels her grasp upon the affec- tion and the conscience of men to be loosening. Meanwhile, there is no de- nying the extent of their power over the young people of the modern church. In the main they are doubtless liberalizing in their effect, and do much for the so- cial life of those whom they most attract. FRANKLIN'S “EXPLANATORY RE- MARKS.”—I. BROOKLYN, July 21, 1894. WHEN preparing my “ Bibliography of Franklin ” some years ago, I spent much time trying to unravel a sentence in a letter of Joseph Galloway's to William Franklin, dated March 30, 1764, in which he stated: ‘* I enclose a Copy of your worthy Father’s Remarks on our Assembly Resolves. No answer has yet been attempted by the Proprietary Faction, who seem much depressed.” A careful search failed to find these ‘ Re- marks,” or anything that could be construed to be such, in any edition of Franklin’s writ- ings. Still, I could not but draw the inference from the quotation that it had been printed, for, though written sheets were often handed about from hand to hand in the colonial days as a way of disseminating political arguments, yet, had such been the means of circulation for this paper, it would hardly have been possible for the opposite party to see it, without which an answer on their part was not conceiva- ble. I therefore made a careful examination of the columns of the two Pennsylvania papers published at that time for the whole period in which the publication could possibly have been made, but without fiadiog it. From this I inferred that it was printed either as a pamphlet or broadside; but as correspondence and search in various directions failed to fur- nish the slightest clue to it, I did not feel justi- fied in making a hypothetical title for inclusion in my list, and merely made a mental note of it as one of several Franklin introuvables to be watched for. This led to my later discovery, in the Eng- lish Rolls Office, of another allusion to the piece, in a letter from Gov. Penn to the Pro- prietors, which further convinced me that it had been printed at the time, but otherwise brought me no nearer to its discovery. Re- cently, however, I have been fortunate enough to purchase the piece. It is a folio broadside, of two pages, headed: “EXPLANATORY REMARKS ON THE ASSEMBLY’S RESOLVES, Published in the Pennsylvania Gazette, No. 1840.” Before noticing it, an outline of the political controversy which produced it may be of in- terest. The real matter at issue was of long and serious standing, having been practically the main political question for many years in Pennsylvania: but the supply bill passed by the Pennsylvania Assembly in the spring of 1764 was the immediate cause which precipi- tated new action on the part of the Assembly party in Pennsylvania. In June, 1763, Sir Jeffrey Amberst informed the Governor of the colony of the danger of the Indian out- break later known as Pontiac's conspiracy, and asked an immediate calling of the Assem- bly to vote the troops and supplies necessary to quell it. Among other acts voted in pursu- ance of this was one granting ‘this Majesty the sum of fifty-thousand pounds,” to which the Governor refused his assent, being bound by instructions from the Proprietors (Votes, v, 325-6). The Assembly at once appointed a committee ‘‘to draw up and bring in certain resolves upon the present Circumstances of this Province.” A new supply bill was also framed, to which the Governor again refused his assent, aud to which the Assembly resolved unanimously to adhere; and a message was drawn and sent to the Governor explaining the reasons for their action (Votes, v, 329-30). This in turn produced a message from the Governor and a counter-message from the Assembly, leaving each side determined to maintain its position. The committee on reso- lutions therefore promptly introduced (March 24, 1764) a series of resolves, which were at once published in the local press. The resolutions so adopted were in effect an indictment of the proprietary government. But evidently Franklin did not feel that the mere vote, however unanimous, of the Assem- bly. asserting a series of facts was sufficient to cause conviction of the truth of the resolutions by the public. He accordingly prepared this series of ‘Explanatory Remarks,” his prefa- tory paragraph stating: ‘*Resolves of Assembly being short Resolu- tions, formed after Debate and full Considera- tion of any particular Matter, they are gene- rally very concise, and seldom contain the Rea- sons at large upon which they are founded; and although they are always so full and ex- pressive as to be clearly understood by those who have attended to the Subject, yet, to ena- ble others rightly to comprehend their Mean ing an explanatory Account of the Facts seems = & es : & 5 OT Rc: ions Se i ptt Sn REN eg Fo ia a erence ac Sa eg ae
Page 11
Pegi (A pe ROE tail emery ay: pecinirromnniaees SFR
July 26, 1894]
necessary. It is with this View the following Remarks are submitted to the Consideration of the Publick.” The remarks that follow, taken in connec tion with the original resolutions, constitute the most satisfactory party platform or state- ment of grievances I have yet found on the whole proprietary dispute in Pennsylvania. The paper is too long to print entire, but a few excerpts are worth making. The first resolve practically states the view of the popular or Assembly party as to their relation to the Proprietors. RESOLUTION. FRANKLIN'S REMARKS, That it is the Opinion As this Resolve is the of this House, that the first in Order, so itis the Proprietaries of this Pro- | most’ important, and is vince, after having dele- intended to point out the gated their Powers of | deepest Wound which has Government, can be just- | been made, by an undue ly or legally considered | Attachment to Proprie- in no other Light than as_ tary Interest, in the orig private Owners of Pro- | inal Constitution of this perty, without the least | Government. By — the Share or constitutional | Royal Grant, * free, full Power of Legislation and absolute Power, is whatever. given to the Proprietary ‘lieutenants and = Gov | ernors,’ to ordain, make, and enact Laws, for the Raising of Money, &c., according to their Discretion, with the Advice, Consent and Approbation of the Freeman of the Country, or of their Delegates and Deputies.’ The Powers of Legislature being thus fully granted by the Crown, to the Governor for the Time being, and the Peoples Representatives, “tis evident the Proprietaries can have no Constitutional Share in Legislation, or Right to give Instructions to their Governor, whereby his * Discretion’? must be to tally destroyed. And therefore all such Instruc tions are a manifest Violation of the Royal Fa vour to the good People of this Province, and a most dangerous Invasion on the Rights of the Sub- ject. They not only destroy the Exercise of Judgment in the Governor, but render the Repre sentative Body of the People mere Cyphers in the Constitution And vain is it for the People to send their Delegates to the seat of Representa tion, as all they can do when met, is to give up their Freedom and Exercise of Judgment, betray those very Rights they were sent to preserve, and servilely submit to Proprietary Will and Pleasure. Much better will it be for the Inhabi tants of Pennsylvania to invest the Proprietaries with absolute Power at once, permit them to or- dain and enact Laws at Three Thousand Miles Distance, and only transmit them here for Publi- cation and Execution. For whose interest they will in that Case be calculated, and of what Spirit they will partake, modern Measures have fully demonstrated. The second and third resolutions relate to the misuse of the proprietary power of bind- ing governors from assenting to laws passed by the Assembly: RESOLUTIONS. FRANKLIN'S REMARKS. That the Obstructions The first Attempt to and Delays the Measures | enforce this mischiev of the Crown have so re-| ous Claim, happened peatedly met with in about Fifty Years past, this Province during the when William Penn, in late War, were solely Governor Evans's Com owing to Proprietary In- mission inserted a Clause structions, respectingthe reserving “to himself private Interest of the | and his Heirs their final Proprietaries. Assent to the Laws” That all the Misehiefs | which should be passed; to the Province,which the and thus assumed the Governor mentions in Royal Power, which by his late Messages, as oc- | the original Charter was easioned by those Ob- | reserved to the Crown. structions, are there- How evidently does this fore chargeable wholly demonstrate, that Men to the Proprietaries, | of the fairest Characters | are not to be trusted when under the Influence of private interest. A virtuous Opposition, how
The Nation. ever, both in the Proprietary Council, and As sembly, repelled this Invasion of their Rights and the reservation was declared illegal and void And from this lime Proprietary Instructions ne ver appeared, till the Beginning of the late War 4 Time when the Frontiers were bleeding in every Quarter, and the unhappy Inhabitants re duced to every Kind of Misery and Distress that the deepest Want, and the most relentless Bar barities of a savage Enemy could devise and in flict. This it seems was thought the most conve nient Time to enforce these Claims, and reduce the People to a Subjection to them And cer tainly a Time like this was necessary to their Success. For, upon their being laid before the Assembly, they plainly appeared to be formed solely with a View to increase the immense Wealth of the Proprietaries, and to oblige the People to bear their Burthens; and were found equally regardless of the Orders of the Crown, as of the Good and Safety of the distressed Inhabitants Influenced by these illegal Instructions, what unjust Claims have the Governors of this Pro vince made in Favour of their Principals! They first insisted that the Proprietaries should not be taxed at all, although their Property was to re ceive equal Protection from it; then that their Quitrents should not be rated: next that their lo eated and uncultivated lands should be exempt ed; and lastly that the Bills of Credit, issued as well for the Protection of their Property as that of the Inhabitants, should not be a Tender in the Payment of their Rents, contrary to all Justice and good Conscience. The Assembly, consistent with that Duty they indispensably owed to their Constituents, could pot agree to these unjust Demands. This created Disputes; those Disputes created Delays, which greatly obstructed His Ma jesty’s Measures; and whether the Proprietary Pretensions, or the Assembly's Opposition, wer most just and well founded, is submitted to the Candid and Impartial Resolutions four to eight are in elaboration of the preceding, describing how the Governor had been placed under penal bonds by the Proprietors (in order that, like Governor Den ny, be should not dare to depart from their instructions), and to the partial system of tax- ation which discriminated between lands beld by the Proprietors and those owned by the colonists. Patt LEICESTER Forp Correspondence. THE GREAT NORTHERN STRIKE. To THE Eprror oF THE NATION Sir: In an editorial in your number for July 12 you unjustly charge the committee of St Paul and Minneapolis business men who were called upon to assist in the settlement of the strike on the Great Northern Road with giv- ing a decision in favor of the strikers upon a matter which was not submitted to arbitration as youclaim. The agreement to settle by ar- bitration was made between the president of the road and the strikers May 1, and provided that the men were to be taken back without prejudice on account of the strike except cer- tain ones. Had this been in writing. no ques tion would have arisen. As it was, however, verbal, the committee was called upon two weeks later to give its understanding and re. collection as to the exact exceptions made The following are the exact words of the re- port of the committee upon this subject : It was agreed between Mr. Hilland Mr. Debs that all the employees of the company might return to their proper employment without prejudice for having taken part in the strike, except those men who had maliciously injured or destroyed the company’s property, or were in the hands of the law. As no other excep- tions were made, this committee is of the opin- ion that the men who abandoned their trains
between stations, as claimed, however re; hensible such conduct may have been, have a right to be restored to the e nployment of tlie company under the terms of the agreement The committee's interpretation of the meanin of the term ‘those in the hands of the law was, and now is, that the men in the hand the law, if found guilty, should mot be emp! ed by the company in the future, but, pendin the determination of their cases, they s! not be excluded from employment by the pany because of the charges brought against them.” The editorial in the 7’ er Press of Mav {4 a copy of which IT enclose herewith, states case correctly, and you must see that vy ticle puts the committee in a fals t \ one of that committee and a reader of s per, I trust you will correct vour stat made in the article referred t Yours truly, CHuAKLES PL N St. Pact, Miss ils i i {Our implied censure of the committee really rested against the original agt ment on the basis described by our respondent, in terms differing little ft our own.—-Ep Nation PULLMAN AND TTS INHABITANTS To THE Eprror or Tue Narion Sir: While livi at South Ct P “ is only a few miles | ut whof ] an I had observed in uversation w - - had worked at that model tow ‘ " ia sought work in) th Lilin Steel W ks South Chicag a feelin f discontent w and hestilitvy towards Pal i amd s & a regulations The denunciat < were general rather than specitic. and the tone was rathes fairly large number of workn 1 met gay me the impression that on the whole it was f a man’s advantage t ve in f Pullman houses. It was pot necessary, but 1 policy to rent from Pullman, ana ithe whole they failed to appreciate his benevolence in furnish ing them a good, clean | k house with unlimit ed pure water, gas, and sewerage The ral complaint seemed to be that they were too much under Mr. Pullman's thumb: there was no reom for individuality or independenc There was a gentle but never ceasing Pull man pressure about them The workman owned nothing except the clothes on his back and the furniture in his rented house. The house, the land, the grassplot in front of each house, the stores, the school, the ehurch, the very streets were Pullman's. As nearby as | could make out, the cause of discontent was lack of individual freedom, and opportunity to acquire something one’s own. The very commendable desire of nearly all skilled work men to have and control a bit of land and some sort of a habitation thereon for one’s very own—a castle of rest, where he is su- preme boss in his own household—this was im possible under the conditions of life in Pull man’s model town Coupled with the fact of the suppression of the individuality of the workman, or rather lack of opportunity to get on like his brother: workmen in other places not ‘model,’ was a feeling of perhaps awe and envy in the ave rage workman's mind at the stupendous and seemingly unlimited resources of the Pullman Company, or, as they thought, Mr. Pullman himself. The contemplation of the immense Pullman building on Michigan Avenue, and Mr. Pullman’s magnificent private residence, together with the fact that a few years ago he
aa a 9 in goon UN agp ta eg Oucvatin gh nereortinte ee See — evan ilicntipk cio
Page 12
62 The Nation. [Vol. 59, No. 1517 was merely a plain, humble workman like them- selves—a carpenter and house-mover—these im- pressions, constantly reinforced by the sight of the sumptuously furnished Pullman cars they manufactured for him, showed a plane of living far beyond any possibility of their attaining. Trivial as it may seem, the fact that their mas- ter bore a European title helped widen the gulf between employer and employee. The promptness with which the whole town, previ- ously Republican, voted the Democratic ticket when Mr. Pullman expressed a desire that they should vote the Republican ticket, was no sur- prise to observers who knew the employees personally. Had these same men been engaged in manu- facturing pig-iron, for instance, instead of an article which constantly reminded them of a higher and to them impossible condition of life;-had they been living in a frame dwelling of their own in a back street, on a lot 25 feet by 100, paying their own taxes for water, side- walks, and pavement, instead of living per- force in a rented building in a community where they had nothing to do with the local government, I doubt very much if the meddle- some Debs could have made them under such conditions his unfortunate dupes. After years of intimate association with the American workingwan, I am convinced that one of the strongest sentiments in bis breast is the love of home. When, at the close of a day’s toil, he can put on his coat and hat, leave the shop behind him, go home, ‘ wash up,” and eat supper, smoke his pipe and read the paper or watch the children play, or play with them while his wife is ‘‘doing up the dishes”; when he feels he owns everything about him in fee simple, that he is the boss and master in his own house—that man is happy. When his wife in the back kitchen hums “Home, Sweet Home,” it is full of kindly meaning to him. Mr. Pullman in his scheme for a model community for American workmen overlooked this peculiar American characteristic. Hence, in my humble opinion, these tears. E, L. C. MorsE. Irnaca, N, Y., July 28, 1804, LABOR ANARCHISTS OF THE LAST CENTURY. To THE EpiToR oF THE NaTION: Sir: It may be of interest to see that the methods of strikers have not changed in a hun- dred years. In a letter to John Ross, under date London, May 14, 1768, Franklin says : ‘*Even this capital, the residence of the King, is now a daily scene of lawless riot and confusion. Mobs patrolling the streets at noonday, some knocking all down that will not roar for Wilkes and liberty, courts of justice afraid to give judgment against him; coal- heavers and porters pulling down the houses of coal-merchants that refuse to give them more wages; sawyers destroying sawmills ; sailors unrigging all the outward-bound ships, and suffering none to sail till merchants agree to raise their pay ; watermen destroying pri- vate boats and threatening bridges ; soldiers firing among the mobs and killing men, women, and children, which seems only to have pro- duced a universal sullenness, that looks like a great black cloud coming on, ready to burst in a general tempest.” And to Joseph Galloway, under the same date : “While I am writing, a great mob of coal porters fills the street, carrying a wretch of their business upon poles, to be ducked and otherwise punished at their pleasure for work- ing at the old wages. All respect to law and government seems to be lost among the com- mon people, who are, moreover, continually , inflamed by seditious scribblers, to trample on authority and everything that used to keep them in order.” Further on in the same letter: ‘Several of the soldiers are imprisoned. If they are not hanged, it is feared there will be more and-greater mobs; and, if they are, that no soldier will assist in suppressing any mob hereafter. The on either way is gloomy. Itis said the English soldiers cannot con- fided in to act against these mobs, being sus- pected as rather inclined to favor and _ them.” A. B. JULY 15, 1894. A CORRECTION, To THE Eprror oF THE NATION: Stir: Your article on ‘‘ Gov. Altgeld and the President,” in the Nation of July 12, speaks of the authority under which the President acted in sending federal troops into Ilinois, as de- rived from sections 5298 and 5299 of the Re vised Statutes, and assigns dates to the sec- tions. Section 5299 was enacted April 20, 1871, as you state; but section 5298 was enact- ed July 29, 1861, not 1891. The mistake is the more confusing as Gov. Altgeld, in his first communication to the President, refers to the ‘* federal statute ” under which the President was acting as ‘‘in reality a war measure,” which, in a sense, section 5298 undoubtedly is. This in the interest of accuracy, not of Alt- geldism.—Truly yours, RUSSELL WHITMAN. Cuicaao, July 16, 1894. THE PUBLIC LIBRARY IN NEW HAMP- SHIRE. To THE EpiTorR or THE NATION: Sir: Will you permit me to call attention to an error in your notice (July 12, p. 28) of my ‘Public Libraries in America’? You make it appear that I state that New Hampshire has passed a law requiring towns to establish and maintain public libraries. I only said that such a law had been presented to the Legisla- ture of the State and ably advocated by its au- thor, a member of the State Library Commis- sion. That such a law can actually be passed in any State for some years to come is very doubtful. W. I. FLETCHER. AMHERST, Mass., July 19, 1894. HAWATIAN SALARIES. To THE EpITOR OF THE NATION : Sir: Your editorial in the Nation of May 24, entitled ‘‘Playing the Missionary for All He is Worth,” is full of remarkable mistakes. A prominent one is in your comments upon your statement that the Government has voted its members increased salaries. The appropria- tion bill for ‘‘ salaries and pay-rolls,” you say, ‘* was made valid for two years so as to guard against unpleasant contingencies.” This ought to have indicated to you that the pay provided for was to cover the whole period of two years. You suppose the salary voted was for one year, and with this fundamental error on your mind you are led to make false and unjust criticisms. You say the ‘Hawaiian chief justice receives $1,500 a year more than Chief Justice Fuller.” The truth is that the statute fixed my salary at $6,000 a year, and the Legislature, having only biennial sessions, voted me $12,000 salary for the two years. Chief Justice Fuller’s an- nual salary is $10,500, and he thus receives just #4,500 more a year than I do. You also say: ‘‘Each of the cabinet draws $1,000 a year more than the members of our cabinet.” The fact is that the salary of a cabi- net minister here is $9,000 for two years. Di- viding this by two, the annual salary is $4,500, which you are pleased to say is $1,000 more than that of a secretary of a department of the United States Government! The former salary of a minister here was $9,600 for two years, or $4,800 per annum. The present mi- nistry thus voted themselves a reduction of $300 a year. Will you please make these corrections and oblige your subscriber, A. F. Jupp, Chief Justice Supreme Court of the Hawaiian Islands. HONOLULU, June 15, 1894. [We must, of course, accept the Ha- waiian Chief Justice’s interpretation of an appropriation act which, on its face, naturally bore the meaning we gave it. In asserting that the present ministry voted themselves a reduction of $300 a year, however, Chief Justice Judd is scarcely ingenuous. Whatever the sala- ries may have been at some indefinite period, the record of the proceedings of the councils shows that increased sala- ries were voted the ministers by the ministers, and that despite a rule cited against their right to doit. We should have been glad if the Chief Justice had specified any other of the ‘‘ remarkable mistakes’’ of which the offending ar- ticle was ‘‘ full.’-—Epb. NATION. ] POPULAR ELECTION OF SENATORS. To THE EprroR OF THE NATION: Sir: The proposition to give directly to the people the election of United States Senators, which has been embodied in Senate and House bills for amending the Constitution, and has been discussed in the pages of the Nation, sug- gests the idea of giving to each State three Senators instead of two, with the provision that in each State one Senator should be chosen by popular vote every two years at the same election at which Representatives in Con- gress are chosen. This plan would preserve the equality of the States required by our federal system, and, the term of a Senator re- maining six years, would improve upon the present division of the Senate into thirds, in that each class or third would contain a mem- ber from every State in the Union, and the biennial renewal would bring a third of the entire membership fresh from the people of all the States. An enlarged membership of the Senate will be recognized as an advantage, in view of the immense volume of business press- ing upon its committees. J. W. H. WASHINGTON, July 20, 1894. THE PARTHENON FRIEZE. To THE EpIToR OF THE NATION: Sr: I have just rediscovered among my files of journals the letter of Dr. Waldstein on the above subject, and beg to be allowed to say a wordon it. As long ago as my first resi- dence in Athens, twenty-five years ago, I was victimized by one of the so-called antique ter- racottas, admirably made and _ ingeniously broken to prove its genuineness better. I then discovered that the manufacture of these ‘* plaques” was a business at Athens, and that any desired number of them could be got by ee eis in sil ae alan Ris ef ‘
Page 13
cosas OMS PS ON i atitortmarcticsee ce a July 26, 1894] The Nation. exercising a little caution. [ am not surprised that Dr. Furtwaengler should have been de- ceived, for his work on the ‘ Master-Works of Greek Sculpture’ shows that, however much he may know of archeology, he knows very little indeed of art; but I am surprised that Dr. Waldstein should persist in maintaining the possible originality of these terracottas, for the genuineness of which there is not the least evidence. The very variations which he takes for evidence of it is proof only of the cle- verness of the Athenian counterfeiters, who are extremely able sculptors, in some cases at least, and quite capable, once the manner is furnished, of giving you excellent imitations of any epoch. The simple fact that, in the offi- cial excavations of the débris of the Acropolis, no fragment of these hypothetical sketches of the Parthenaic artists was found, ought to sa- tisfy one that their existence was a myth. If they were the originals, where would one ex- pect to find remains of them if not on the spot where the originals were used for the repro- duction in marble? And where were they found? No one can tell us—in excavations here and there, where they could not have had any relation to the Parthenon. Dr. Waldstein’s appeal to the authority of the late Alessandro Castellani is unfortunate, as that fortunate dealer himself admitted to me that he knew very little about archeology, and did not pretend to judge of the genuine- ness of an antique (?), but limited himself to the quality of the art. The extraordinary counterfeit of a Roman horn which he sold to the Emperor Napoleon III., and which was given to the museum at S. Germain, showed that his expertise could be supported only at the expense of his honesty, which is, I am sorry to say, the case with a good many deal- ers in antiquities. At all events, his testi- mony in favor of the “plaques” is worth no- thing, for he could not even tell a false from a genuine “figurine,” and did not pretend that he could. The counterfeiting of all classes of antique objects is now carried to such perfection that we can in most cases be certain of the genuine- ness of one only by knowing where and by whom it was dug up; but for the Parthenon plaques there never was a reason, except utter inexperience in such articles, for accepting them as antique. M. Reinach’s judgment in these matters is one in ten thousand; and if there were a judgment more trustworthy than his, I should say it could only be that of the maker of the counterfeits himself. Yours truly, W. J. STILLMAN, Rome, July 7, 1894. . “BACK AND FORTH.” To THE EpItor or THE NATION: Sir: For the last ten years I have been in constant association with Cornish miners iocated on Lake Superior. The expression ‘‘foorth and back” is a common one as used by these men, and, as far as I remember, con- veys the idea of ‘‘ wrong end to” or ** hindside forth.” I have heard a woman say, referring to her husband’s head-gear, ‘‘’Ee ‘ave ‘is ‘at on foorth and back.” I recall a Cornish pitman discussing the failure of a duplex steam-pump to run, saying, ‘“‘I gnawed they pump wudna run, fur ‘ee ‘ad they rockers in foorth and back.”—Yours truly, J. PARKE CHANNING. NARRAGANSETY Pier, R.L, July 19, 1894. Notes. JOHN WILkY & Sons announce ‘ The Memphis Bridge,’ by George S. Morison ; * A Text-Book on Roads and Pavements,’ by Fred P. Spal- ding of Cornell University; ‘Sewage Disposal,’ by Wynkoop Kiersted; ‘The Principles of Modern Dairy Practice,’ from a bacteriological point of view, by Gosta Grotenfelt ; and ‘A Record of the Transportation Exhibits Build- ing of the World’s Columbian Exposition of 1893,’ by James Dredge. Ginn & Co. have nearly ready ‘ Medieval Europe 800 to 1300 a. p.,’ by Prof. Ephraim Emerton of Harvard, in continuation of his ‘Introduction to the Study of the Middle Ages.’ J. Selwin Tait & Sons will shortly publish ‘Before the Gringo Came,’ stories of early Califorvia days by Gertrude Atherton; ‘A Seventh Child,’ by John Strange Winter; and ‘The Untempered Wind,’ by Miss Joanna N Wood, a Canadian writer. Prof. A. C. Fraser's two-volume edition of ‘An Essay concerning Human Understand- ing,’ from the Clarendon Press (Macmillan), contains not only Locke’s great Essay, but a very valuable introduction of 134 pages of bio- graphical and critical matter, embodying, perhaps, the best thoughts of Prof. Fraser himself, who has also added copious foot-notes, to the extent, as we estimate, of a third of the two volumes. The best of all the new matter is, we incline to think, the account of the various interpretations which have been given, not only of the Essay itself, but of its different topics, books, and chapters. The critical sections bring out with great clear- ness over against Locke the views of real ex- istences—self, God, and outward things—which characterize Prof. Fraser's school. It need hardly be said that this edition constitutes henceforth an indispensable instrument for every teacher of Locke, and might be used along with Fowler's little digest, reviewed in these columns in 1880, The Rede lecture delivered at Cambridge, England, on June 13, by J. W. Clark, Regis trar of the University, has been printed in a thin volume (‘ Libraries in the Medieval and Renaissance Periods’; New York: Macmillan The subject naturally lent itself to illustration, and the lecture was in fact delivered with the aid of lantern slides, drawn from books, manu- scripts, and photographs of libraries still in existence. Only seven of these are reproduced in the printed volume, whose value would have been greatly enhanced if the remainder had likewise been admitted. Still, the principal types of lecterns and shelving, and the disposi- tion of chained books either on their sides or on end with their fore edges showing, are well depicted, Mr. Clark proves that the fittings of collegiate libraries were imitated from the monastic, and in general makes evident the closeness of tradition in these matters from classic times, with such changes as the inven- tion of printing necessitated. The number of plans in *‘ Academy Architec- ture,’ the annual review for 1844 (New York: Scribners), is relatively small, as usual, but the elevations and interior views possess quite the average interest. They are drawn in the main from the exhibitions of the Royal Academy, London, the Royal Scottish Academy, Edin- burgh, and the Glasgow Institute of the Fine Arts, and are supplemented by some foreign examples, in which the United States is repre- sented. Drawings and photographs from the 63 finished building or monument or detail are mingled. Curious is the design for a new co metery at Chiavari, Italy. There are several views of the interior of the Court Museum at Vienna, and some queer Russian structures, in cluding an iron memorial church. The editor himself supplies a view of bis fine girls’ school building at Zurich. Prof. Dr. J. Scheiner’s ‘ Die Spectralanalyse der Gestirne,” brought out in the original Ger- man edition four vears ago, has been translat ed, revised, and enlarged, with the cooperation of the author, by Prof. Edwin B. Frost of Dart mouth College. Ginn & Co. have just pub lished this excellent treatise on astronomical spectroscopy in appropriate and available form for the purposes of both teacher and investi gator. The seventh volume of the ‘Journal des Gon court’ comes from the press of Charpentier It covers the vears ISS) SS, and, aside from the querulous and fretful complaints of M. Ra mond de Goncourt, treats chiefly of Daudet’s ill health and his need of chloral passages about other authors, here and there, There are and numerous references to Porel, who man aged the Odeon and brought out “ Henriette Maréchal”™ and ** Germinie Lacerteux”: an ill tempered attack on Sarcey, which, appearing neo credit to the author; and two sneers at the late President after the lapse of years, does Carnot, one on the oecasion of his election to the Presidency, and the other, at the very end of the book, on account of the interdiction of *Germinie.” Yet the book, though largely frivolous and thin in matter, is interesting, for it exhibits plainly the temperament of the writer, and gives incidentally a clear insight into some of the causes of the particular kind of decadent and noxious literature which has afflicted France of late and still afflicts it, though sigus of healthy reaction are fortu nately not wanting In M. Gaston Deschamps’s ‘La Vie et les Livres’ (Paris: Colin & Cie.) such signs are After the pages of Goncourt, the pages of Deschamps are invigo- strong and encouraging rating. There is a clean feeling about them which is not their least valuable feature. M Deschamps is the literary critic of the Temps, and he has a very captivating style, as all readers of the articles ‘“‘La Vie littéraire’ know. His idea of criticism is to think of the reader as well as the writer, to examine and set forth, as plainly as possible, the causes at work in the world which have brought forth the particular book he is to review—in short, **to combine the observation of events with the analysis of the work,” and to make the history of books contribute to the knowledge of com temporary society. The application of his ideas is a series of charming articles, in most of which not a single book or writer, but a group of writers and books, is discussed intelli- gently, wittily, but not superficially, and with much catholicity of feeling. Particularly inte- resting are ‘‘ La Conversion de M. Paul Bour- get,” ‘Sur la mort de Guy de Maupassant,” ‘Littérature et politique,” and ‘ Officiers et soldats.” Gustave Merlet’s ‘Etudes litt¢raires sur les classiques francais’ has long been known to and appreciated by students of French litera- ture. A new edition, by M. Eugéne Lintilhac, has been published by Hachette. The text has been recast, Merlet’s notes in successive edi- tions being incorporated into it, and all neces- sary corrections and additions made which the progress of literary criticism called for. Be- sides smaller additions of his own, M. Lintilhac has contributed studies on Villehardouin, Frois-
Page 14
64 a tte ee sart, Commynes, the letter-writers of the seven- teenth and eighteenth centuries; Voltaire, cri- tic, philosopher, and polygraph; and Buffon. An excellent table of works of reference great- ly enhances the usefulness of the two volumes. M. Maurice Albert’s latest book is on ‘ Les Médecins grecs & Rome’ (Paris: Hachette). In it he shows how the Greek physicians fairly took and kept possession of Rome. The book is entertaining even to laymen, who will learn something more of Archagathus, Asclepiades, and Galen than their mere names, and at the same time something about Roman life. We have before us the first number of the New Science Review, a quarterly ‘* miscellany of modern thought and discovery,” published in Philadelpbia, and addressing itself to the public at large (Transatlantic Publishing Co.). The articles are decidedly short for a quarter- ly, and the longest are not the best, teste Mrs. Bloomfield Moore on the propeller of Keely’s air-ship (‘A Newton of the Mind”!), and Ju- lian Hawthorne on ‘Scientific Creation,” alias Keely and his motor. Mr. M. D. Con- way writes about ‘‘ Thomas Paine and the Re- public of the World.” There are also articles on the ice age, on the problem of the pole, on diamonds and gold: and Prof. Angelo Heilprin edits a department of ‘* Current Scientific Dis- cussion.” The Architectural Review, Boston, begins its third volume under its present title with the May number. It has an established re- pute among professional journals of its class, and has doubtless not reached the end of its development. In the number just named Mr. Thomas A. Fox continues his interesting notes of a tour in Greece, with a chapter on Argolis, accompanied by charming views of temple, tombs, gateway, and landscape at Ar- gos, Nemea, Mykenw, Tiryns, and Nauplia. Especially to be remarked are the Treasury of Atreus, the Lion Gate, the Gallery at Tiryns, the platform of the Herwon at Argos, the head of Hera, and the Plain of Argos from Mykene. Baron E. von Toll gives an interesting ac- count of bis adventurous journey last year across northern Siberia, in Petermann’s Mit- teilungen for June. His principal object was to examine the remains of a mammoth recent- ly discovered, and tomake astronomical obser- vations, for which purpose he was accompa- nied by a Russian naval lieutenant. When the place where the mammoth had been found was reached, the snow was too deep to permit of a thorough search, and accordingly, with four men and three dog-sledges, they crossed the ice—a two-days’ journey—to the New Si- berian Islands. On the southernmost they made a cache of provisions, and a second in lat. 75° 37’, for Dr. Nansen in case he should be obliged to abandon the Fram and retreat to Siberia. The spring opened nearly three weeks earlier on the islands than in 1886, when the Baron had previously visited them—a fact which he interprets favorably to Dr. Nansen’s plans. At that time the first bird was seen on May 28; but, in 1893, gulls appeared on May 10, and on the next day geese, and, from the north, ducks. A little later the robber-gulls came, and fed upon the lemming, who were migrating in great numbers. ‘These sole winter inhabitants of the islands were ex- changing their quarters; some were going from the mainland to the islands, others were leav- ing the islands for the mainland.” The return journey was very diflicult, on account of the melting snow and ice, but was accomplished safely, and the coast was reached May 27. After an ineffectual search for a perfect speci- The Nation. [Vol. 59, No. 1517 men of a mammoth—only a skull from which the tusks were gone, some bones and hide, being found—the explorers crossed the tundras by a mostly hitherto untravelled route, partly on reindeer and partly in sledges, to the settle- ments on the Yenisei. An interesting account of the great Siberian Railway, by our consul-general at St. Peters- burg, Mr. J. M. Crawford, is published in Con- sular Reports for July. Since May 12, 1891, when the Tzesarevitch laid the first stone in Viadivostok on the Pacific, preliminary sur- veys have been made over the entire route, and the work of construction is now going on in three of the seven sections into which the whole line is divided. Trains are running for 160 miles eastward from the western terminus, Tcheliabinsk, and from the Pacific terminus westward 120 miles. There appear to be no serious engineering difficulties—only one tun- nel, less than two miles long, is mentioned— while the highest point reached, at the divide between the Arctic and Pacific Oceans, is only 3,665 feet above the sea-level. The total length of the road will be 7,115 miles, and the estimated cost is about $175,000,000. In addition to this sum, $7,000,000 have been appropriated for cer- tain auxiliary measures in connection with the railway, as the construction of a branch to the Ural mines, improving the Siberian rivers, and developing steam navigation on them and in the Kara Sea, assisting colonization, encourag- ing iron works, and equipping geological expe- ditions, especially for studying the Amur re- gion, etc. A map and a longitudinal profile of the road-belt accompany the report. The hopes that the recent trade convention between China as the suzerain power in Tibet and the Indian Government would soon lead to free intercourse between the two countries have been rudely disappointed. Two English missionaries who recently crossed the Indo- Tibetan frontier in violation of the conditions of the convention were arrested by the Tibe- tans, and would have been murdered but for the intervention of the Chinese guard, who conveyed them back to India. The result has been that all the advantages expected to be gained from the treaty are endangered. Trad- ing has apparently almost ceased, and the Ti- betans are reported to be building a wall along the frontier, where the missionaries crossed, to prevent any further intrusions. This would seem to disprove the assertion of some tra- vellers—notably of Miss A. R. Taylor, to whose adventurous journey in this country we have called attention—that the Tibetans are anxious to break down the barriers between their coun- try and India, but have been prevented hither- to by the Chinese in the interests of their trade monopoly. These sturdy mountaineers, how- ever, apparently fear that, with the coming of the Europeans, their independence will be lost. So strong a feeling has been aroused by this incident that the Lieutenant-Governor of Ben- gal has been compelled to recommend to the Chinese Government to stop a missionary party about to enter Tibet from China. Naturally this has excited much bitterness against the Government, but the responsible organs of British opinion in India realize that ‘even missionaries cannot be permitted to extend their excellent work at the sacrifice of the Bri- tish character for international good faith.” The Bulletin of the American Geographical Society for June 30 makes a timely appearance with reference to the distracted condition of Nicaragua. Mr. Courtenay de Kalb contri- butes a not inconsiderable Bibliography of the Mosquito Coast, filling upwards of six pages. By far the larger number of titles have been verified by Mr. De Kalb by personal examina- tion of the works which bear them, and he had the advantage of having visited the Coast and studied the political conditions of that anoma- lous little territory. —The sixteenth annual session of the Asso- ciation Littéraire et Artistique Internationale will be held at Antwerp, August 18 to 25. It will be the third reunion in Belgium, a pre- vious meeting having been held in Antwerp in 1885, and one in Brussels in 1884. It is not to be expected that this year’s conference will be as epoch-making in the history of literary- property protection as was the noteworthy Brussels copyright congress of 1858, but the subjects for consideration are sufficiently im- portant and varied. The programme is a long one, and, what with the interruptions caused by social attentions, and the special tempta- tion to irregularity of attendance incident to the presence in Antwerp of the International Exposition, it is doubtful if the whole of it can be discussed. A number of topics are carried over from last year, such as publication con- tracts; property in titles, portraits, photo- graphs, and translations; the question of regis- tration and deposit of copies, and, in connec- tion with this last, the interesting project of the establishment at Berne of a universal bureau for the recording of copyrights. New subjects for discussion are collaboration, arbi- tration in literary-property disputes; property in personal names ; property-rights in stereo- type plates; the rights of authors in relation to gratuitous representations, and some clauses of the International-Copyright Treaty. Re- ports are also expected on the status of copy- right in North and South America, Great Britain, Denmark, Norway, Austria, and Rus- sia. The project of holding next year’s session in the United States having fallen through, efforts are being made to secure the naming of some German city for that honor. —One of the most serious results of the in- creasing army expenditures in Prussia has been the curtailment of the public-school fund. Prussia, proud as she is of her school system, has always been rather indifferent to the lot of the schoolmaster. The school census of 1891 showed that the teachers in the elementary schools were not only sadly underpaid, but greatly overworked. There was then an ac- tual deficiency of 12,652 teachers—that is to say, in 25,304 classes the teachers had to do double work, and many of these classes number- ed 120 to 150 children each. Since then matters have not improved, and the Minister of Public Instruction not long ago declared before the Diet that the country was threatened with ‘a collapse of its public-school system.” The causes, according to a well-informed writer in the Berlin Gegenwart, himself a ‘‘ Schulmann,” are to be found not only in lack of funds, due to the demands of militarism, but also in the influence of the church and the aristocracy over the public schools. In spite of the law of 1872, according to which the supervision of schools rests entirely with the State, the coun- try-school inspectors are almost everywhere clergymen. The entire pedagogical outfit of these inspectors is in the majority of cases acquired in a six weeks’ course at the semi- nary. The district inspectors (Kreisschul-In- spectoren) are likewise generally theologians. The teacher, dependent on the good will of his clerical superior, often performs menial ser- vices. Only since last February have the country teachers been released by ministerial ordinance from the performance of such duties
Page 15
July 26, 1894] as the sweeping of church floors, the tolling of bells, the lighting of fires, etc. The influence wielded by the landed proprietors, who have still so largely the right to appoint teach- ers Within their domains, reduces the ap pointees to a condition not far removed from vassalage. In 1891, 12,160 teachers’ positions were within the gift of the nobility; Count von Donnersmarck appointing 12%, Prince Pless 123, the Duke of Ratibor 87, and the Duke of Ujest 65. Efforts to improve the pecuniary status of the teachers sometimes meet with an almost brutal rebutf. Thus, a Pommeranian commission, discussing the subject during the ministry of Von Zedlitz, declared that a salary of 600 marks ($150) was more than sufficient for teachers in that province, and that, indeed, it ought not to be more than 586 marks. A grave aspect of the situation is the impossibi- lity of endowing properly the higher technical and industrial schools (Fortbildungs-Schulen), They are likewise hampered by lack of funds, and do not compare in efficiency with the schools for workingmen (Arbeiter-Bildungs- schulen), which have been established under socialist auspices. There was a certain justice inthe remark of Herr Liebknecht last Janu- ary, that, ‘‘whatever knowledge of politics and economies our laborers have acquired, they owe to the Social Democrats.” —Among the members of the Board of Visi tors to the Royal Observatory at Greenwich the present year are Lord Kelvin, President of the Royal Society; Lord Rayleigh, the Earl of Rosse, Profs. Sir George Stokes and Sir Robert Ball, Dr. William Huggins, Prof. Dar win of Cambridge, and Capt. Wharton, Hy- drographer of the Navy. Theannual visitation took place June 2, and the Astronomer Royal, Mr. Christie, reported upon the conditions and workings of this immense establishment in the fullest detail. Owing in large measure to the tine weather prevailing through a great part of the year, the fundamental instruments se cured an exceptionally bountiful harvest of observations, and these are kept well advanced towards the final publication—vastly better, in fact, than at other observatories under Gov- ernment auspices. Satisfactory progress is re ported upon the new universal transit circle, or altazimuth, constructing by Messrs. Trough- ton and Simms. Sir Henry Thompson bas generously offered the sum of $25,000 to pro- vide a large photographic telescope and the necessary subsidiary accessories, and this valu able gift will serve as an important comple- ment to the 28-inch visual telescope just com- pleted. No delay in the permanent installa- tion of this fine instrument seems likely; the Admiralty promptly accepted the offer, the aperture of the photographie lenses was fixed at twenty-six inches, and the order was given to Sir Howard Grubb, the eminent Dublin optician, who has contracted to com plete it before the end of 1895. The as- trographic survey is progressing fairly, near- ly a thousand plates having been made during the year. Also the moon.and several double stars and planets have been photo- graphically recorded. The sun’s activity in spottedness has been fully maintained through- out 1893, and the Greenwich photographs, when supplemented by those from India and Mauritius, afford a permanent record of the solar surface on 359 days of the year, whose characteristic has been rather the great num- ber of groups visible at the same time than the extent of any one of them. Here also the for ward state of the computations precedent to the permanent availability of this important The Nation. work is worthy of note. For the summary of meteorological details, the Astronomer Roval’s report must be referred to, but itis interesting to observe that the number of hours of bright sunshine recorded automatically during 1808 Was 1.454, the greatest since the commence ment of the registration in 1877, and 171 above the average of the preceding sixteen years Occasional longitude campaigns are under taken; Montreal, Paris, and Liverpool having been determined from Greenwich. It is evident from the report of the Mission- ary Conference, recently held in London, that the scientific stags in the history of missions has been reached. The papers read and the discussions upon them all emphasized the truth that, for the successful propagation of Chris- tianity in heathen lands, its doctrines and pre cepts must be presented and enforced with care ful relation to the habits, laws, and religious beliefs of the people. This important principle was very clearly shown in the interesting dis- cussion on polygamy. The majority of the early missionaries (not all of them) inexorably required that a man on accepting Christianity should put away all but one of bis wives, and in making this demand they were upheld by the general approval of the Christian world But it was shown, and by none more forcibly than by Mr. R.N. Cust, the well-known lodian official and writer, that to do this was to in flict a grievous and lniquiteus Wrong Upon rn nocent women lawfully married to their hus bands. A religion making such a demand upon its converts could expect but little success among the Hindus at least, with whom the marriage tie is indissoluble. Mr. Cust’s con- clusion (aud that, apparently, of all who took part in the discussion) was that ‘‘a man can not be permitted” to become a member of a Christian church ‘tat the expense of his in- nocent Wives.” While there was little or nodi versity of opinion as to the propriety of bap tizing a Woman although she was one of several Wives, only two or three laymen advocated the baptizing of men who are polygamists. But in India, according to the last ceusus, this is a case which would but rarely occur, the vast majority of both Hindus and Mohammedans being monogamists —In this same conference the Rev. Horace Waller brought a heavy indictment against the English Government ip respect to slavery in the island of Pemba, in the protectorate of Zanzibar. According to the report, in ISSS, of a naval officer on one of the cruisers on the east coast of Africa, 5,000 slaves a year wer at that time smuggled into the island to work upon the Arab spice plantations. This is an enormous Waste of life, considering its size A square miles) and its estimated population from 10,000 to 50,000), and makes probable the report that “the longest-lived of the slaves succumb in eleven years, and that on the ave rage they die in about seven These facts would seem to demand some action on the part of the Government, at least to protect the slaves. But, according to Mr. Waller, ‘no mine in Siberia tilled with criminals transport ed for life is more safely sealed up against prv- ing investigation than Pemba. There is bei ther consul, vice-consul, nor missionary there Those who inquire cannot find in Blue-books nor in any public office that a consul ever lived a month on the island or made a report upon the number (even approximately) of the plantatious or the slaves upon them The question of the revival of the Olympie games bas lately been considered and discussed = >; ) by the International Athletic Congress, whi bas just closed its sesstor Pari \ comn tee Was appointed, under the presidency of Mr Bikelas, whe, on June 1% read a long memoir from the Panhellenic Society of Athens con cerning the rules and conditions under whict the ancient games were celebrated, and those under which it would be fitting that the : vived Oly pics should take plaee After hea: ing this, the committee voted unanimously for the reéstablishment of the games Pree cussion then followed, and if was agreed that the new Olympics shall be four vears ; that the first contests shall take place in the year ISAO tn some capital city t be determined upon hereafter; and that the second shall be in Paris during the Expositio of a. D. 1800, It is expected that none but amateur athletes will take part in the games with the single exception of tl fencing matches, It was precisely this thorny ques tion of amateurism and professionalism, ove which floods of ink have been shed, which was likely to give the tumMission mast troubl The problem existed of ul tiin Gut unaslern civilization has greatly plicated it, Ther will be much curiosity to see what detinition of “professional anil amateut the cum niission will set forth. Lt seems to be starting out in a Wise and sensi Way It has already decided that betting is a disquali at that contestants are ¢ thay 1 shin any yate-mones ii st sreatties ie ludes gymnastics, shooting ithletic «sports and values, rowing, Vachtiog, sw writ, t ‘ and fencing If the death of the Countess \ worde Ga parin had happened twenty vears age, it would perhaps have seemed a greater and more inune diate loss to literature than it does now Since the death of her 1 band in IS71 sl has been living for the most part in retir ment, and if she bad not lite given oOVel writing, her later books have been much less in view Besides, many of the causes which in their dark bour Gasparins nobly advo cated have gained th lay; others are no longer of pressing interest. But Sainte-Beuve theught a study of Mme. de Gasparin a work net unwerthy of his time and pains, and even bow one may properly stop to note the close fa literary life that has been more than half acenturvy long. Valérie Boissier was born in Geneva in ISi3. the sister of the well known Swiss botanist. She began her literary work by writing some stories of no great value un der a pseudonyu her powers, and her ‘ Voyage dune ignorante dans le midi de la France et en Italie,” which appeared in IN‘), showed unmistakable quali l ties In N37 she marred Count Agenor de Gasparin and removed to Paris, where her husband sat in the Chamber of Deputies from 1842 to IS48. Here her ‘ Mariage au point de vue chrétien’ appeared in 1842. It received a gold medal from the Academy, and its success gave her an assured position as a writer. Then followed the long series of volumes of travel, of religion, of politics and sociology, and of romantic fiction which have madeher a vame, There is no need to recount their titles: some are already forgotten, some, perhaps, will live through this generation at least. The ‘Horizons Prochains,’ the ‘Tris tesses Humaines,’ and the * Horizons Célestes ’ have some pages of a real eloquence in them and breathe a spirit of sympathy and tender pity which is most delicate and persuasive. Sainte-Beuve was able to say much more of her than this He found in her work ‘‘ une Sait caeeteenatealealliadat DOP a
Page 16
66 The Nation. [Vol. 59, No. 1517 vigueur incomparable,” a style ‘‘viril et em- porté,” a talent full of ‘‘s?ve et la vitalité ”— qualities which are less obvious to us to-day. Mme. de Gasparin died at a country-house near Geneva on the 18th of June. MARCELLA, AND OTHER NOVELS. Marcella, By Mrs. Humphry Ward. Mac- millan & Co. A Bundle of Life. By John Oliver Hobbes. J. Selwin Tait & Sons. The Rich Miss Riddell. By Dorothea Gerard. D. Appleton & Co. His Vanished Star. By Charles Egbert Crad- dock. Houghton, Mifflin & Co. The Raiders. By 8S. R. Crockett. Macmillan _& Co. Cheap Jack Zita. By 8S. Baring-Gould. J. Selwin Tait & Co. Claudia Hyde. By Francis Courtenay Baylor. Houghton, Mifflin & Co. Life’s Little Ironies. By Thomas Hardy. Har- per & Brothers. The King of Schnorrers. By I. Zangwill. Macmillan & Co. The Flower of Forgiveness. By Mrs. Steel. Macmillan & Co, A Protégé of Jack Hamlin’s. By Bret Harte. Houghton, Mifflin & Co. In Exile, and Other Stories. By Mary Hal- lock Foote. Houghton, Mifflin & Co. Salem Kittredge, and Other Stories. By Bliss Perry. Charles Scribner’s Sons, THE idea of human equality that animated the terrific drama played by the world in the de- clining years of the eighteenth century, in- spires in its dying successor a drama of equal pretension to the earth for its stage and the na- tions thereof for actors. That furious, histori- cal passion which imperilled the existence of nations and changed their destinies, was natu- rally productive of a noble literature. In our own actual drama the force of that desperation which must move on to overwhelming tragedy is not yet felt, and in the literature to which it has given an impulse, the strain that will not die is not yet heard. It would seem that the idea has lost some of its intellectual and spirit- ual splendor, and that its most urgent appeal leaves the imagination cold, thus assuring us of a catastrophe far short of universal smash, and also depriving us of any certainty of as- sisting at the blossoming of a new group of im- mortals. A cry for equality of dinners, rest, and play has not enough soul or sonority for an epic, or enough yearning pathos for impe- rishable lyrics. It quite lacks the imperative note that deluges spheres in blood. But by volume and persistence and the occasional spur of a bomb it can command earnest and agitat- ed attention, and can supply the realistic novel- ist with facts whereon to build a fictitious case which may be exciting, widely significant, and entirely consistent with a conscientious abhor- rence of romanticism. Already the fictitious cases are as the stars in heaven for number, and also for degree of luminosity. Among the hosts of little twin- klers an occasional steady light shines out, but Mrs. Ward's ‘ Marcella’ is the only approach to a first magnitude. This was of course ex- pected as soon as it was rumored that Mrs. Ward had tackled the social question. It is curious to note the eagerness with which a novel by Mrs. Ward has come to be expected, especially when it is perfectly known that she will speak to the thoughts of men, never to their senses or caprices. People believe that she will, in some impressive way, formulate ideas which to-day interest the multitude and which yesterday were the exclusive property of the philosopher, the poet, or other rare freak of nature held in suspicion of lunacy by the vulgar. Her third novel is a flattering tribute to the justice of such expectation and the wisdom of this popular belief. Everybody is now familiar with the plot, the fictitious element of ‘ Marcella,’ and there is superfluity in saying more than that it is cleverly fashioned for illustration of the idea, and well sustained. The points less frequent- ly noticed are the comprehensive treatment of the idea and the justice of perception of the value of our modern, actual drama. Almost every conceivable ‘‘ view” has a representa- tive well fitted by nature and circumstance for his réle, and the whole case rests at fizzle, compromise; foreshadowing infinite talk, ad- justment, and readjustment, some violence, but no world-desolating tragedy. We do not mean to imply that the characters are merely well-considered, galvanized ‘“ views.” Their enthusiasm for absolute or approximate equali- ty of material good impels them to experi- mental action, in the course of which one gets a notion of their individuality separated from a temporarily absorbing cause. With the ex- ception of the scholarly and instructive Hal- lin, each makes an impression of completeness; and in his case the failure appears to be in the author’s inadequate grasp of the intellectual height where she wished to place him. Mar- cella, the personage of the novel, is very tho- roughly grasped and very vividly set forth. In her impetuous career she falls foul of most of the thrilling situations which our drama can provide, the occasional accidental trage- dy, and the enduring ugliness of poverty with its attendant evils. The end of Marcella, so far as Mrs. Ward takes her, is carefully pre- pared from the beginning—too carefully to stimulate a very great liking or any sort of confidence. Her vanity, self-complacence, and love of power are even more obvious than her intelligence, her hatred of injustice, and her compassion for physical suffering. When she abandons her admirable lover because he will not yield about the petition for reprieve of the condemned poacher, considerable resent- ment for the personal snub is mixed with her turbulent sympathy and acute impersonal dis- tress. When she carries coals for sick Jew- esses and rushes into tenement-house frays, her spirit of adventure is having its fling, but it is not possible to feel that her vocation is for self-abnegation in obscure slums—that she is going to stick. On the other hand, her return to love and luxury does not argue shal- lowness or insincerity, but is a very natural reaction for a damsel so eager for experience and so ardent in the business of living. The humor of her reasoned descent from tragedy to commonplace is patent and delightful to a cynic, but Marcella didn’t see it—Marcellas never do. Mrs. Ward’s obliviousness to hu- mor gives the last touch of excellence to the drawing of such a character, yet is a fatal ob- stacle to greatness as a delineator of life. In the whole book there is not the ghost of a smile—a grave fault, but one that would be much more oppressive if it could as justly be found with our actual drama as with its coun- terfeit presentment. This deficiency in the sense for comedy, the sense that relieves the tension of well-ordered life and makes existence lovely even for con- scious sinners, is not the defect of the author of a little book entitled ‘A Bundle of Life.’ Indeed, the lady who assumes the name John Oliver Hobbes has so many of the qualities that Mrs. Ward lacks, and so few that she pos- sesses, that one wishes the two could be made one, and all doubts about the coming of the great novelist set atrest. Mrs. Ward gives us people largely fashioned by the spirit of the time and, in turn, fashioning it—people whose thoughts have been widened and passions modified by the process of the suns; Mrs. Craigie gives us the primitive human entity, the thing that was born when Adam and Eve realized that cheru- bims and a whirling sword of flame were keeping the closed gates of Paradise. Mrs. Ward has power of sustained thought, judg- ment, balance, sympathy, observation, and in- formation. Mrs. Craigie has wit, humor more biting than gentle, passion, and intuition. Mrs. Ward’s method is punctiliously careful, her style decorous, the style of conscience and in- formed intelligence. Mrs. Craigie has no de- liberate method, but produces out of discon- nection which is all but incoherence a vivid impression of unity. Her style is too nipping, at once too polished and too reckless, to be good, and is more the utterance of capricious impulse and direct instinct than of conscience and intelligence. What she writes from page to page may be out of the line of expectation, and generally is, yet, for the moment, is sur- prisingly satisfactory. She seizes only the critical moment of fortune and character, and at once makes the reader a sharer of its intensity. In her people nature is heavily handicapped by the external artificiality im- posed by rank and wealth; yet, with a light and scornful gesture, she casts off the weight, and shows you how impotent are the restrain- ing trappings when once the human being is in a race for life. Tothose who believe that man is but one thing permanently, and that is, unregenerate; who know and acknowledge, though it may be with tears of shame, that his abiding interest from century to century is in himself, in his own opportunity and no other, it must seem that Mrs. Craigie strikes at essential truth and dips up a bit of the heart on the tip of her light, sharp lance. The fragility, indeed frivolity, of her weapon may mislead the unreflecting as to her aim, and the apparently casual waving of her trophy may obscure its value. Besides, the fragment of truth is so unflattering to our cultured self-esteem that we may without too gross hypocrisy declare its exhibitor to be no better than a worldling and a cynic. To our mind the fragment is genuine, and would fit the heart of the humble altruist as neatly as that of the blatant egoist, of the pauper as well as the prince. It is the spark of life and the justification of existence in ‘A Bundle of Life,’ and in all the author’s preceding work; it is the excuse for much seeming bitterness and malice, Without it Mrs. Craigie would be only a manufacturer of phrases and epigrams, providing a smile for the wicked, held in horror of the righteous, and speedily forgotten by all. At the end of ‘A Bundle of Life,’ Sidney Wiche says to Teresa Warcop: “I do not know whether I love’you or not; I only know that I hate my life without you.” A few hours before, Wiche has been making pic- turesque love to another woman, yet we know that he speaks the truth to Teresa, and though, in her only great scene, she has fairly screamed with jealousy, we feel that she is a good and strong woman and needful for the completion of Wiche’s suc- cessful career. Such is the art of Mrs. Craigie, Between Teresa Warcop and ‘The Rich Miss rec Di
Page 17
July 26, 1894] Riddell’ there is pronounced resemblance of fact. Each is immensely rich, unmistakably plain, and faithful in love from childhood for ever. The similarity extends to the culmi- nating scene in theif respective stories. Miss Riddell’s lover has made up his mind that her vastly superior wealth must always be an ob- stacle to their union, and the pressure of immi- nent death is requisite to wring from him a declaration of devotion. To his great chagrin death passes him by, and Miss Riddell holds him relentlessly to the bond of his supposed last words. After a lengthy discussion, she is about to abandon him when he exclaims, among other things: ‘Stay here, Georgie. I can’t do without you.” The difference in im- pression made by the two stories is as wide as the resemblance in circumstance is close. Teresa is created in a few pages ; Miss Riddell requires a whole book of description, yet re- mains after all a vague, improbable image. Why Burton should want her (her wealth be- ing no object), and, moreover, what he was going to do with her when he got her, are problems of which the author discreetly avoids attempted solution. Miss Gerard could hard- ly have intended to write an instructive book, yet if her novel be read immediately after ‘A Bundle of Life,’ few are so dull as to be thereafter incapable of perceiving that the facts selected for a foundation have little to do with the worth or beauty of the fictitious superstructure. Early in Miss Murfree’s literary career it be- came evident to her warm yet discriminating admirers that she was born to sketch episodes and character, not to write elaborate novels, and it was hoped by those who prize a small and perfect gift that she would return to the field where her first laurels were won. But, probably in response to a demand for maga- zine serials, she has persisted in the composi- tion of long tales which are really a succession of short tales spoiled by a frail connecting thread which is constantly being lost among voluminous reports of the weather and the morning, noon, and night aspects of the Ten- nessee Mountains. ‘His Vanished Star’ in- cludes several striking incidents and lively characters, but is a rather deplorable novel. It has no drift, no unity, no steady guiding light. At first, imagination rests on the gratuitously disagreeable architect, Kennis- ton. Much as it may be regretted, one feels called on to give first attention to him and his affairs. Presently he and his interests fall back, and a familiar yet ever-welcome figure, with long boots, jingling spurs, and a slouch hat, this time yclept Jack Espey, steps to the front, at once capturing attention by the an- nouncement that the sheriff is after him for murder done in Tanglefoot Cove. After a short and brilliant run, Espey is relegated to a minor part; a new star appears in the Tennes- see heavens; the mind reverts to the title of the book, and proceeds slowly to adjust itself to recognition of Jasper Larrabee, the dis- coverer of the star, as the real and only hero. The effort is not successful, for having got through half the book with little aid from Jas- per, and none from the “ gracious, supernal, stellular presence” (his star), we cannot feel that they were intended from the beginning, and resent the prominence hereafter allotted them. The failure to foresee from the begin- ning, and with that foresight to feel, propor- tion, value, interdependence of character and incident, is irredeemable failure as a novelist. In Miss Murfree’s case, failure is happily mi- tigated by spirited incidents and by the sur- prising uaturalness and drollery of her moun- The Nation. taineers. Though she has represented or ima gined (we decline positively to commit our- selves) so many, those who appear in ‘ His Va- nished Star’ are perfectly fresh, vigorous, and spontaneous, The only suggestion of weakness or concession to convention here is in the sub- stitution of remarkably beautiful maidens for the gaunt, hollow-eyed, weary women of the early stories. It may argue a thankless dispo sition, but, as we could cheerfully part with all Miss Murfree’s novels if that were necessa- ry to keep even one of her stories, so we would willingly sacrifice her lovely Julias and Adeli- cias for one of those pinched and heart-starved women whom she pictured, as they stood, for ever holding out pleading, empty hands to the indifferent passing years. Mr. Crockett, the Scotch author of the vol- ume of excellent sketches entitled ‘The Stickit Minister,’ makes his first appearance as a novelist in ‘The Raiders.’ His qualities and defects are very like Miss Murfree’s. He can give a swift, vivid impression of a detached in cident, and fill with the breath of life charac ters studied by the shores and among the hills of his native Galloway, but he cannot, or, at least in the ‘ Raiders,’ does not, link the inci- dents deftly, or develop the characters with any appearance of inevitableness. For a story of romantic adventure his period and scene are admirably chosen, and there are so many blood- curdling perils and critical moments, such a tangle of smugglers and gypsies and wild High landers, such a flourish of dirks and cracking of pistols, that the imperfect coherence is only a fault of art through which the momentary in- terest suffers no diminution. Besides, only Sir Walter Scott (a large exception) has given the Scotch cattle lifters, xyYpsies, and kindred red. handed men their proper prominence in fiction; so Mr. Crockett has the luck to offer nov elty of a peculiarly stimulating kind. In both matter and style he swings to and fro between old-fashioned romanticism and modern real- ism, and these variations may be taken to mean that he has deliberately fashioned his novels on Sir Walter's. With due recognition of possible admiration for a master so pro- found as to incite to conscicus imitation, we are inclined to give Mr. Crockett exclusive credit for his well-adjusted variety of manner; all the praise for versatile talent wide enough to include subtle humor and genuine pathos, broad comedy and dignified tragedy; and all the honor for the original creative ability displayed in the figure of Johnne Faa, Lord and Earle of Little Egypt. By placing the adventures of ‘Cheap Jack Zita’ in the Fens of Cambridgeshire, Mr. Bar- ing-Gould gets the advantage of a locality as attractive to the imagination and less familiar in fiction than are the Scotch Highlands. For picturesqueness, too, the nomadic Cheap Jack serves about as well as any other sort of a va grant; and when he, or in this instance she, is announced on the title-page, one plunges in with the comforting assurance that, whatever the story may be, it is not likely to be dull This story opens uncommonly well, catching the fancy by the Cheap Jack's audacity in ply- ing his trade at the very doors of the minster of St. Etheldreda. Zita’s first appearance, as she takes her father’s place to harangue and cozen her despised general public from the front of her van, is a great success, and her spirit, shrewdness, and ready wit are sustained vivaciously through all her subsequent trials. The scene in court where she ignores the dig nity of the bench and upsets its gravity is ir- resistibly comic, and that in the Red Wing Mill, where she seriously attempts to ‘‘ make a 67 deal” for her lover with a supposed rival, is hardly less so. Though she does herself no in justice by declaring that she is Cheap Jack to the end of her fingers, by involving her in tra gedy the author shows her private integrity distinctly separated from her public unvera city and humbug, and endows her with a soul capable in emergency of scorning considera tion of deals and profits. He has also rendered the Cheap Jack's point of view so sincerely and convincingly that one could hardly be sure it is not his own, unless he should answer in the negative the question with which Zita floored the presiding magistrate: “You never was a Cheap Jack, was you, your worship By writing ‘Claudia Hyde,’ Miss Kaylor has also written herself down reactionary. The home of the lady whose name breathes classi dignity and patrician estate was certainly T's radise, though geographically known as Vir ginia. When Gerald Mildimay, the English aristocrat (unjustly deprived of his confidently anticipated lordship, and reduced as alternative to tentative agriculture in America), enters the portals of Elysium, we fear the serpent, but no, he is a British ange! directed by destiny to the very atmosphere fitted for the expansion of his wings. The intention which pervades, we cannot say animates, this novel, is so estima ble that to dwell upon intrinsic improbabi lity, upon unlikeness to human nature monly seen, known, and experienced, seems like barefaced iniquity Yet it is our sor rowful duty to point out that absolutely har- monious combinations of impregnable virtue, lofty and cultivated intellect, and serenely dig nifled manners, are so rare as to put the gua ranteed possessor bevond the accepted limit of possible mortal perfection, and to make him or her a mark for the scot? of the cynic and the mirth of the consciously imperfect. In the zeal of her effort to decry the emancipated woman, “the woman with fads, isms, cranks,” the ‘‘woman who, like Samson, is pulling down the house, but by weakness, frivolity, and vice.” the author has overwrought her figure of domestic virtue, has almost carica tured tranquil and refined family life, and bas fairly wallowed in platitude Clearly, however, Miss Baylor is not ham- pered by any fancied necessity for drawing from life, and she is terribly addicted to fine writing. A very superficial observation of young Irish or English gentlemen would have saved her from perpetrating the wild absurd ity embalmed in Flanders and Mildmay. Offi- cers in her Majesty's service have neither the illiterate vocabulary nor the brogue of bog trotters, and idle, athletic English noblemen do not habitually garnish their conversation with French phrases or erudite classic meta- phor, such as ‘‘the Scylla of the county alms- house and Charybdis of the county jail.” It must, in honesty, be noted that Mildmay fell into the classics after being domiciled with the Hydes, and that his case may have been one of mild infection from the old gentleman whose amusement it was to make scholarly criticism of Euripides, and the young lady who fed babes on spontaneous quotation from Horace. But the evidence of the whole is that Miss Bay lor believes in the naturalness of ber Mildmay, and that she is entirely with Claudia in per ceiving about him “the mille fleurs bouquet of the accomplished European gentleman, the repose of the Vere de Vere caste, the cachet of St. James.” One cannot but regret the dulness of wit which condemned such a being to re main penniless when be might have made his everlasting fortune through the medium of a dime museum. zea eunueiensens Cats
Page 18
The Nation. [Vol. 59, No. 1517 In the writing of short stories the British author has long been industrious, has occa- sionally risen above mediocrity, and once or twice has come near perfection. In the volume entitled ‘Life's Little Ironies,’ Mr. Hardy’s great literary power almost triumphs over national ineptitude. For conciseness, directness, form, much is to be desired, but throughout his grasp of the subject and ex- position of the idea are masterly. It is always taken for granted that bis subjects and ideas shall be worth the pains of comprehension and development. Any one who may be beguiled by the title into anticipation of an hour’s agreeable distraction will be much disappointed. These so-called ‘ Little Ironies ’ are, in truth, grinding tragedies, vulgar tragedies, always going on, wearing out hearts and souls, unmitigated by opportunity given for heroic pose or a transient enjoy- ment of enviable publicity. Irony there un doubtedly is, but it is savage, the irony of misfortune entailed by one’s own act, inex- tricably woven with the fulfilment of the heart's desire. In addition to this irony of destiny, there is Mr. Hardy's personal irony, ~ which does not precisely move to heart-easing mirth, and by whose unsparing use he joins to the office of narrator that of commentator and judge. ‘‘As ye sow so shall ye reap,” summarizes his judgment, which is amplified by the comment, If you happen to sow like a fool, why should I sentimentalize over your folly or permit any one else the luxury of un- diluted compassion ? In the elimination of sentimentality from fiction, he goes further than any English novelist, and in this volume he presses that desirable reform to such an ex- treme that we wonder what sorrow or infirmi- ty we might heartily pity without feeling either contemptible or ridiculous. Mr. Zangwill vexes not his soul to unfold the mystery of pain and the futility of passion. The stories in the volume entitled ‘The King of Schnorrers’ are undisguisedly superficial, and meant for entertainment only. The title- story is very clever, The impudence of the Jewish beggar is so ingenious and imperturba- ble that it clothes bim with a dignity supposed to be the birthright of kings. The rest of the volume may be labelled * warious,” comprising tales of love, fantasy, and humorous adven- ture. They are trifling, jocular, flippant, and spasmodically clever. They assume to impart casually the liberal knowledge of a man of the world, but the real display is of the knowing- ness of an incorrigible gamin. Asa delineator of Jewish character and customs, Mr. Zang- will is an author to be cherished, but when he goes prancing among the end-of-the-century London gentiles, he is an author whose exist- ence is not necessary for the perpetuation of the tradition of polite letters. Mrs. Steel’s volume of stories entitled ‘The Flower of Forgiveness’ displays more lavish- ly than did her recent novel her intimate know- ledge of life in the Empire of India and her feeling for the natives. She seems to see with their eyes and speak with their voice. Several, if not all, of these stories have appeared in English magazines, and are probably earlier compositions than the novel. In the art of tale-telling she is rather uncertain, being fond of a doubtful ending, and not able to insinuate delicately a satisfactory probability. But of stories to tell she has a fine lot, and a large va- riety of character and situation. She presents in easy succession plodding peasants, turbulent tribesmen, religious fanatics, wandering min- strels, artisans, beggars, criminals, all decreed to be what they are from the beginning of time, and almost all content to remain what they are to the end. Western discontent and unrest make but slight impression on their im- perturbable, devout acquiescence in the fiat of the ages. Even their profound deference to the ubiquitous ‘‘ Presence,” the worshipful representative of the Empress, is tinged with contemptuous irony, as who would say, ‘‘We crawl before you because we must, but you, thing of a day, shall pass away and we, the up- changeable, remain for ever.” All this feeling is given by the author through the lips of her people and the movement of her tales. Whether it is just or not, it is so strong as to seem to be truth itself, and what more than that can the wise demand of a story teller? Occasionally she diverges into direct information, into criti- cism of the powers, and sarcastic reference to the reformers who find Europe and America too contracted for their zeal. Her information strikes the ignorant as correct, andthe powers can probably bear her criticism without flinch- ing. As for her sarcasm, there is not the slightest danger of its depriving the Indian Empire of the services of one young man or woman whose enthusiasm in a dragon huntcan be satisfied by nothing short of a go at the hoariest antiquity. The miners and irrigators of the Pacific Slope have bad a long run in fiction, and show no signs of becoming defunct. Bret Harte’s ‘Protégé of Jack Hamlin’s’ and Mrs. Foote’s ‘In Exile’ resound with the click of the pick and swish of reluctant water between alien banks. Mr. Harte’s volume again testifies to that diminution of creative vigor which has so often of late years chilled the soul of his ad- mirers. His persistent resuscitation of Jack Hamlin is painful. He died in his complete- ness. Perhaps we could have better spared a better man, but why should bis poor ghost dis- turb a memory ever green? ‘An Ingénue of the Sierras” gleams here and there with the old-time brilliancy, and, thankful for that, one can afford to forget the shabbiness of its com- panions. Mrs. Foote’s little love stories are agreeable, as love stories with the genuine ring always have been and will be, yet the only notable tale is not of love, but of wreck and the horror of slavery. It is called ‘‘The Alca- zar,” and is told by an ancient mariner looking down at the hulk of a weed-clothed slave-sbip. It was published many years ago, we think, in the Century Magazine, and is instinct witha strength and elevation of imagination which Mrs. Foote has never since quite reached. By its presence a touch of distinction is added to the pleasantness of the volume. The title-story of Mr. Perry’s volume, ‘Salem Kittredge,’ takes precedence in quality as well as position. Though not told in dialect or adorned with startling phrases, it has the un- impeachable American birtb-mark and is a distinctly original addition to our fiction. Wandering in foreign lands, Mr. Perry lapses into conventions, and it would probably he well if he should take to himself the moral of his presumably allegorical tale, *‘ An Incorri- gible Poet,” and stay at home. The wisdora, in his case, of fidelity to thé well known, is evi- dent towards the close of the volume in the tale ‘*Number Three.” Here is a situation possible only in America, and beautifully fit to capture the national smile. A COLUMBIAN CARTULARY. Christopher Columbus; his own Book of Privi- leges, 1502. A photographic facsimile of the manuscript. Transliteration avd transla- tio; by George F, Barwick; introduction by Henry Harrisse. The whole edited by B. F. Stevens. London, 1893. Folio. New York: Dodd, Mead & Co. In 1502, just as Columbus was starting on his last voyage, depressed with the prospect of a denial of all his supposed rights, he deter- mined to put the record of the royal and of- ficial documents in his favor beyond the chance of destruction. He caused four copies to be made, varying somewhat in number of documents, and in the perfectness of some, and these were attested by a notary. One of these collections, on paper, less perfect than the three others, which were on parchment, he sent off to his factor to be preserved in the New World. This one has disappeared. A second was sent to the Convent of Las Cuevas, where the discoverer’s body was later first laid. Our last positive knowledge of this second copy is that in one of the law-suits brought by Columbus's heirs for the recovery of his rights, in 1588, it was produced in court, as we learn from the ‘Memorial del Pleyto,’ where it is described as a bound volume. There is a probable later trace of this Cuevas manuscript. In 1818 Mr. Edward Everett bought in Flo- rence a manuscript book, to which he was at- tracted by the reference to Columbus in the title, but its cramped chirography and bewil- dering contractions prevented at that time a careful examination of it. Tn 1823 the Govern- ment of Genoa had directed Father Spotorno to print and annotate that one of the four copies preserved in that city, which was published as the ‘Codice diplomatico Colombo-Ameri- cano.’ When this book reached Mr. Everett, it reminded bim of his purchase, and, in com- paring the Florentine manuscript with the printed text, he found it substantially the same. The ‘Codice’ proved, however, to have afew documents at the end not contained in the Florentine copy. About this time, in De- cember, 1824, he delivered his Plymouth ora- tion, and, when printing this address early in 1825 at Boston, he added, apropos of a refer- ence to Columbus in the text, a note, in which he described the manuscript in his possession and set forth the story of his obtaining it. This recital was not reprinted in any of the subse- quent editions of that oration, but it is cited at length by Mr. Harrisse in his present introduc- tion, wherein that writer adds: ‘‘Mr. Everett never again referred tothe subject, and [his] is the only description ever made of that valua- ble manuscript, which has since disappeared altogether.” This is not quite true. Mr. Everett had said that Spotorno’s book had been shown to him by a friend, and it is probable that this friend was the late Caleb Cushing, who, a few months later, in the North American Review (October, 1825), took occasion to use Spotorno’s text for rehearsing the story of Columbus’s life. At the conclusion of this article he gave a second brief description of the Florentine manuscript in these words: “This curious and valuable manuscript, which we have slightly examined and compar- ed with Spotorno’s book, is of parchment, written with great elegance, and bears every mark of being from two to three hundred years of age. It begins with Pope Alexander's bull of partition, and then follow the documents which we have designated above as the first set in the Codice diplomatico. Another bull of Alexander copied on paper is also placed with- in the covers. Mr. Everett’s manuscript, so far as it goes, is a much more perfect one than the Oderigo [Genoa] manuscript, as several passages which Spotorno was unable to deci- pher in the latter are very plain and legible in the former, which indeed is in most complete preservation. We hope Mr. Everett will favor —— (i Raitt SIRS eT Lie eta r ae et as ae a & a ;
Page 19
Grin, ways TON ae Stay a eR, slang - z July 26, 1894] The Nation. the public with a more particular account of his manuscript and note the variations between this and the printed copy.” Dr. William Everett, at the time the present writer inquired of him about it a few years ago, was not aware that his father had ever had or described such a manuscript, and could give no explanation of its disappearance. It is, of course, not impossible that it may here- after come to light. The third and fourth copies made for Co- lumbus—the Spotorno codex being one —were transmitted to a friend of the Admiral, Nicold Oderigo, for preservation in Genoa. That one of the two already mentioned has what is sup- posed to be the original binding, but apparent ly the other was enclosed unbound in a leather bag. This bag is now at Genoa, and is pictured in the present book. The introduction says of it that ‘it is the only object once belonging to Columbus which has come down to us.” We might discard the Madrid armor and the pen- and-ink sketch sometimes associated with the great seaman, but had supposed the books pre- served at Seville, with Columbus's annotations in them, were satisfactory ‘‘objects” of this kind. These two Oderigo cartularies were in 1670 given by his heirs to the republic of Genoa. Some time after 1700 one of them disappeared, but was recognized in 1816 in a sale in Genoa of Count Cambiaso’s library, when it was bought by the King of Sardinia and given to Genoa, This was the one used by Spotorno. It was again printed at Havana in 1867, and the Royal Columbian Commission, acting under a warrant from King Humbert, are to include it in their great Raccolta, now in course of publi- eation. Meanwhile the city of Genoa has caus ed a few photographic copies of it to be made. This present Genoa codex is somewhat less per- fect than the other now to be mentioned, and is described as being in a different hand— ‘‘more neatly and legibly written, with beauti- ful Arabesque ornaments by pen and brush, and many of the initial letters are artistically illuminated.” The other Oderigo copy was seen in Genoa as late as 1805, and was a part of the plunder taken by Napoleon the First to Paris, and not returned when other portions of such plunder were sent back by the allies. It was supposed to have been lost till about fourteen years ago. In 1880 the archives of the Foreign Office in Paris were thrown open to investigators, and Mr. Harrisse was one of the first to avail him- self of the new privileges. Among other docu- ments laid before him was a volume marked with the initials of the French Republic, in a binding of green morocco, which had appa- rently been put upon the manuscript at some time intervening between 1848 and 1852. Har- risse could discoVer no signs of an earlier bind- ing; and when he found it to be a collection of the privileges, patents, and concessions grant ed to Columbus, he knew he had discovered the lost copy of the two sent to Oderigo, preserv ing in attested form the documents which in their original shape are now in good part owned by the Duke of Veragua. The finder first made known his success in his Life of Co- lumbus, published in 1884, which was big enough to satisfy even Mr. Harrisse’s luckless derision of ‘‘ ponderosity.” During the Columbian year this treasure was publicly exhibited in the Bibliothéque Na- tionale in Paris, subsequent to which Mr. Ste vens was allowed to take the negatives s> effectively used in the present production. The volume before us matches in size the Ste- vens Facsimiles, aud the reproductory leaves are separated by others containing, in an adroit way, both the extended transliteration and an English version exactly corresponding, page for page. There are also added at the end similar reproductions and elucidations of three well-known letters of Columbus, ex- plaining his interest in this act of attestation The book is curiously bound, in a way to suggest the period, ‘‘in half pig skin, with plank board sides and (brass, anchor-shaped] clasps.” Big-Game Shooting. By Clive Phillipps-Wol- ley. With contributions by Sir Samuel W Baker, W. C. Oswell, F. J. Jackson, War burton Pike, F. C. Selous, Lieut.-Col. R. Heber Perey, Arnold Pike, Major Algernon C. Heber Perey, W. A. Baillie-Grohman, Sir Henry Vottinger, Bart., Earl of Kilmorey, Abel Chapman, Walter J. Buck, and St George Littledale London Longmans, Green & Co.;: Boston: Little, Brown & Co 2 vols. Illustrated. [The Badminton Libra rit IN all books on sport not purely in the domain of fiction, there is apt to be a sameness which becomes monotonous, but in the present work this fault is reduced to a minimum. The two rather formidable-looking volumes contain articles on big-game shooting all over the world, and in each instance the chapter is written by a man of known experience. The initial chapter *‘ On Big-Game Shooting Gene rally,” by the editor, is excellent as an intro duction to what follows—neither made tedious by an excess of detail nor abortive by too much generalization. There are five other articles by the same author, * Big Game of North America,” ‘* The Caucasus,” ** Mountain Game of the Caucasus,” ‘* Camps, Transport, ete.,” and ‘Hints on Taxidermy, ete.” Of the American chapter we cannot speak in praise. Everybody who knows anything about American big game is aware that the best and in fact at present only remaining good hunt ing-grounds are to be found in western Wyo ming, Idaho, Montana, and eastern Washing ton, as wellas ina few remote spots in Utah and New Mexico. Mr. Wolley was actually quite unacquainted with any of them when he wrote for this book his * Big Game of North America,” and the only acquaintance he had with any portion of the western United States was represented by a three weeks’ hunt in a populated district of Colorado! Mr. Wolley appears to have made his home in Victoria, the capital of British Columbia, a country which, it is generally conceded, is by no means a paradise for the big-game hunter ; for though there is plenty of big game there, the exceed ingly dense forests which Mr. Wolley, in a mo ment of forgetfulness, confesses ‘* fairly swa'- low a man up,” make it difficult to find and more difficult to kill. Mr. Wolley’s special fad appears to be to pose as a ‘hard’ man who roams the forest in the guise of an Indian, with the silent footfall of the aboriginal hunt- er. In his list of camp requirements he re commends his tender-feet readers to take two spare deerskins with them to patch their moc casins ! British Columbia will see few readers of the Badminton volumes who will want a single patch. One day's trial on rocky ground, we have always found, is in ninety-nine cases out of a hundred enough for men not accustom- ed to this footgear, prominently as it appears in their accounts of their sport. And besides, does Mr. Wolley really think that the sports- man-Visitor to British Columbia will have fo use up two whole deerskins for patches before GY he can expect to killa deer and thus obtain a supply of patching? Mr. Wolley bas quite un consciously come nearer the truth than he knew, for, to judge by what the writer has seen of these hunting-grounds in two extended shooting expeditions, one can view more game in one day in Wyoming and Idaho than in six months in British Columbia By far the most readable articles, from a purely literary point of view, in the book are those on South African shooting by W. Cotton Oswell. Their charm consists in the fact that they are the true recital of personal adventure, that thev treat of early days on *' The Dark Continent,” and tell of thrilling exploits in the most modest and straightforwanl way This writer was with Livingstone in Africa and a personal friend of his. He hunted fo years in what must have been th rigina ‘Happy Hunting Grounds,” and killed ever, kind of game found there, without t help of Improved Weapons and modern comforts The contrast is very marked between his methods and those of the author who follows him with several articles on modern sport Fast Africa, F. J. Jackson. His idea of thea eyuipment necessary for a hunt trip to those parts ts so elaborate as to preclude the possibility of any bat those “with money t burn” ever following bis course, and the luxuries he mentions appear to the uninitiated rather foreign to the idea of the hardw hunter In speaking of “Camp gear,” he saws, Com fort in camp should be one of ations,” and he must have hadit atent wit! floor-cloth, and bath-room attachment: iron bedstead, with cork mattress and a leat! ) pillow stuffed wit! N and three nen case for the same: a good bath andl this s} i be an ordinary oval one with lid ‘an awk ward load fer a porter, and one he dislikes very much, but it is well worth taking Mosquito curtain with c¢ also mentions that. “before having the mogs quite curtains removed in the morning, it is a good thing to take a cup of coffee or cocoa before getting out of bed.” Rather luxurieus sport this’ And when one stops to consider that all these things must be “ packed” on the backs of men, he realizes the great outlay suc! a trip must involve. Imagine that beth-tub going through the woods! Mr. Jackson scorns arubber one. Still, if a man can afford these things, he should undoubtedly have them on a trip which is sure to be a hard and dangerous one. fter disposing of African and American shooting, the second volume takes us almost to the North Pole after walrus and polar bear, then through all the mountainous districts of Eu- rope and Asia, a very considerable space being occupied by articles on shooting in India by Lieut.-Col. Reginald Heber Perey; and finally closes with three eminently practical chapters on camping, rifles and ammunition, and taxi dermy. With the exception noted, the book is most complete, with room for pure adventure, zoology, and, above all, practical instruction in hunting the various kinds of big game. One would, however, hardly sit down and read it through for the pleasure of reading Ancient Skips. By Cecil Torr. Cambridge, Eng.: University Press; New York: Mac millan. 184, Dovupst is at once aroused as one turns over the illustrations in Mr. Torr’s new book and fails to find among them Graser's time-honored reste ration of the exceedingly uncomfortable ‘‘ be tween-decks” of a Greek trireme. Doubt be OT a eine
Page 20
TO
The Nation.
[Vol. 59, No. 1517
comes suspicion as one reads (page 45), “‘ There are no materials for rigidly determining the relative positions of the lines of rowers in these three-banked ships or in the larger war- ships.” The words of the preface, ‘‘ Evidence from all sources falls short of what is needed for a complete description of the ships,” makes of suspicion a certainty, and Mr. Torr stands disclosed as an original worker and not a mere compiler of treatises, dissertations, and ‘ pro- grammes.” He has in preparationa ‘ History of Ancient Shipping,’ by which title he means a history of commerce in the Mediterranean from 1000 B. c. to 1000 a. p. The present small volume is a prelusio to the whole, and deals merely with the nature of the ships them- selves. In presenting his subject, Mr. Torr has fol- lowed the model of Hermann’s ‘ Lehrbuch.’ The main facts are given in coarse print, cov- ering generally not more than half a page, or even less; the arguments and the authorities are subjoined in copious footnotes, and these notes are to the student the most valuable part of the whole. The book is not divided into chapters, but the principal subjects, indicated by the running titles, are Ships with Oars, Arrangement in Banks, Dimensions, Tonnage, Materials, Structure of the Hull, Anchors, Ca- bles, Steering-gear, Rigging, Flags, Sounding- lead, Log, etc. Then follows an appendix in which are briefly described thirty different types of ships or boats aside from the regular men-of-war. There are full indexes of sub- jects and authorities, and the book ends with forty-seven illustrations, fully described, and all taken from ancient works, no restorations being admitted. In a work like this, which may be called encyclopedic in its own little field, errors will declare themselves only after frequent consultation, verification, and use. But few of these are, we think, to be feared, for there is practically nothing here in the way of theory, and, consequently, we have for the first time a dispassionate statement of what the author has found in the original sources, and no more. He is, of course, acquainted with the modern literature of his subject from De Baif in 1536 down; but this acquaintance has taught him distrust, and in his preface he gives several amusing instances of the ab- surdities which abound in our manuals be- cause the compilers have trusted their prede- cessors instead of going to the sources for themselves. He himself depends first upon inscriptions, chiefly the inventories of the Athenian dock-yards; second, on the literary evidence, though this, unfortunately, consists for the most part of mere passing allusions; third, upon the material sources, such as the ruins of the docks in Athens and the works of art. In using the latter he has carefully avoid- ed, so far as he could, the danger of taking them at second-hand, and most of the illustra- tions which he gives are from photographs or from casts. The statements of scholiasts and ancient lexicographers he has the courage to reject altogether. The whole book, there- fore, rests upon the soundest foundation, and the author deserves hearty thanks for his clear and accurate presentation of what is real- ly known on a subject that has hitherto been obscured by clouds of words.
Overheard in Arcady. By Robert Bridges. Charles Scribner's Sons. It would be hard to find a more attractive- looking volume than ‘Overheard in Arcady,’ by the well-known * Droch” of Life. Paper-
maker, printer, illustrator, and binder have combined to achieve what might be truthfully advertised as ‘‘ an elegant souvenir for a lady.” The author’s part in the performance is not so serious as to annoy the lady by a discovery that she is a victim of the trick of the gilded pill, nor so brilliant as to make him an object of invidious distinction to his fellow-workmen. The device of criticising authors through the medium of dialogue conducted by their own creations, passes for cleverness when worked through weekly instalments of a publication avowedly frivolous, but, between covers, the ingenuity of the device palls and its unfairness assumes proportions. This unfairness is com- prehensive, affecting both critic and criticised. Among the voices in Arcady, it is easy to dis- tinguish the authoritative one, that of Mr. Bridges, and since the opinions it utters are generally in cordial agreement with our own, we believe them to be unimpeachable. By ex- pressing his opinions in a manner imitative of people created by Mr. Howells, Mr. Kipling, or Mr. Stevenson, the author not only loses the force which a man’s own style gives to his ideas, but also, largely, the credit of the ideas. The unfairness to the authors is clear. Cari- cature and even burlesque of serious work are held to be legitimate, chiefly because they are provocative of laughter, but Mr. Bridges has not played the buffoon; he has, with considera- ble travail, just caught and caged far-off rever- berations of other men’s thunder.
In Maiden Meditation. By E. V. A. Chi- eago: A. C. McClurg & Co. BLUE sashes, white muslin frocks, and gra- duating-day ata young ladies’ seminary would seem the natural and harmonious accompani- ments to compositions written in the strain of these five essays. Not, however, because their writer has not taken pains to explain that she has ‘‘wandered among many ages and climes of literature,” and not because she has failed to give the world at large her profound atten- tion. Some of her deepest reflections occur to her while her ‘‘ ball dress is thrown over the chair.” In the main they might have filled the soul of Miss Pinkerton with pride if her favorite, Amelia Sedley, had written them. Becky Sharp, it is quite certain, never would have written them. The reader is adroitly put upon his mettle to distinguish between other people’s thoughts and the author’s own by be- ing told beforehand that quotation marks are always omitted, on the flattering supposition that he has ‘‘wandered as widely” as the authoress herself. He is also reminded that no one can be expected to be wholly original, not even ‘‘Homer, singing the myths and tradi- tions of olden Greece, nor yet inspired Shak- spere, embodying into classic and enduring form the legends of all lands and ages.” “KE. V. A.’s” own method of increasing her acquaintance with literature deserves atten- tion: ‘* Often, when sewing or dressing, I have before me a book with marked passages, or a newspaper clipping, that I am conning again and again, or I am repeating some verse or sentiment that has struck my fancy. I believe that the most delightful and satisfactory edu- cation is gained in this way, little by little, until it is wrought in the memory, is a part of one’s being, and seems but the echo of one’s own thought.” The reader who elects to follow these medi- tations at first hand can be promised enter- tainment on several grounds. Like egotism in a hew acquaintance, they will be found agree- able while one is taking their measure. A
slight thread of personal history runs through them, of course stringing a romance. More- over, ingenuousness, and freshness, and youth- ful exuberance, even when it overflows in au- thorship, have always their own attraction. And, finally, a volume like this grows less and less likely to be duplicated. Its sentiments are those of a departing generation, if not a departing type of womankind. Manifold influ- ences are at work to evaporate them. No one can regret their passing, but they command something of the tenderness of feeling that a parting always momentarily brings with it- self. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. A Superfluous yu, Cassell. 50 cents. Bennett, Prof. W. H. The Books of Chronicles. {The Expositor’ 8 Bible.) Armstrong. $1.50. Berens, E. M. Hand Book of My thology. Maynard, Merrill & Co. Agi aor 3 <a Charles de. Vieille Histoire. Paris: Colin Binet, Alfred. On Double Consciousness. Chicago: Open Court Publishing Co. 25 cents. Clédat, Prof. Léon. Grammaire Raisonnée de la Langue a Paris : H. Le Soudier; New York : West- Cobb, “Thomas. bt wo Doengnensance of Mr. Derwent : A Mystery. F. T. Neely ts. Conway, Moncure D. Centenary History of the South Place Society. London: Williams & Norgate; New ork: Putnams. §2. Davidson, W.L. Theism as Grounded in Human Na oe Longmans, Green & Co. $5. mps, Gaston. La Vie et les Livres. Paris: Ar- — Colin & Cie. Doubl E. 8. Just Plain Folks. Boston: Arena Publish ng Co. Frazer, Persifor. AJ Manual of the Study of Documents. Philadelphia: J. B. ae gg Co. Fundenberg, Elizabe First Lessons in Reading. American Book Co. 25 cents. Gibbes, Emily O. Essays. C. T. Dillingham & Co. Goethe, J. W. ere of Werther. Mascot Pub- lishing Co. 50 cents. Bogesay es Arséne. La Pécheresse. Paris: Calmann New York: Charles Eitel. Index: Catalogue of the — ae A -" a Surgeon-Gene- ral’s Office, U. S. Army. Vol . Universidad— Vzoroff. Washington : Genmusens Printing Office. Kenealy, Miss Arabella. Dr. Janet of Harley Street. Appletons. Lang, Andrew. Cock in and Common Sense. Long- mans, Green & Co. $2.2 Littell’s Living Age. a 1894. Boston: Lit- tell & Co. aaitland, J. A. F. Masters of German Music. Scribners. Manley, R.M. The Queen of Ecuador. H. W. Hage- mann Publishing Co. 50 cents. Marryat, Florence. Parson Jones. Cassell. 50 cents. McKenzie, F. A. Soberby Act of Parliament. London: Swan Sonnenschein. Nichols, Prof. E. L. A Laboratory Manual of Physics and Applied Seog my 4 Vol. I. Macmillan. $3. Oman, Prot. J.C. The Stories of the Ramayana and the Mahabharata. {Great Indian Epics.} London: George Bell & Sons; New York: Macmillan. $1.50. Pestalozzi, J. H. How Gertrude Teaches her <— oo gga Sonnenschein ; Syracuse, N. Y.: C. W. Bar- dee Ramebotham, F.S. Scenes from the = of Aischy- lus. Longmans, Green & Co. 50 cen Ransom, J. U. Longman’s Gann * Composition. Longmans, Green & Co. 90 cents. Spyers, T.G. The Labor Question: An Epitome of the Evidence and the Report of the Royal Commission on Labor. London : Sonnenschein: New York: Scrib- ners. $1. Stevenson, R. L., and aon L. The Ebb-Tide. Cambridge : Stone & Kimball. Stone, Roy. New Roads and Road Laws in the United States. D. Ma Nostrand Co. $1.50. ah n° .von. Countess Janina. G. W. Dilling- The Le Letters Of Amerigo Vespucci, and Other Documents — of his Career. London: The Hakluyt So- The e Shorter P Poems of Robert Bridges. London: George Bell & The Women’s Conquest of New York. Harpers. 25 cents. Human Physiology. Longmans, by nny Pog se reen oo) m Trumbull, Rev. A. C. Studies in Oriental Social Life. Philadeiphia : J.D. Wattles & Co. $2.50. Tuckwell, Gertrude M. The State and its Children. London’: Methuen & Co. Turgeneff, I. Rudin: A ty translated by Constance Garnett. Macmillan. $1.2 Walton, Alice. The Cult of aabientes. [Cornell Studies in Classieal Philology.) Boston: Ginn & Co. $1.25. Wardrop, Marjory. Georgian Folk Tales. London: David Nutt. Waring, G. E. Modern Methods of Sewage Disposal. dD. Van , Co. $2. : Walker, Prof. Williston. A History of the Congrega- tional Churches in the United States. Christian Literature Co. $3. Wenley, R. M. Aspects of Pessimism. Edinburgh : William Blackw & Sons. Williamson, Benjamin. Introduction to the Mathe- matical Theory of the Stress and Strain of Elastic Solids. Longmans, Green & Co. $1.50. ; Williams College: A Record of the Centennial Com memoration. Cambridge : John Wilson & Son. Willis, O. R. A Practical Flora. American Book Co. woli1 T. Geografia y Geologia del Ecuador. Leipzig : A. Brockhaus ; New York : Westermann 4 woot ke £ Modern Magdalene. Boston; Lee & rd 1 Wontnater, Dr. A. Small Hospitals. John Wiley & So .25. Wright, $ F. An Outline of the Principles of Modern Theosophy. Boston; New England Theosophical Corporation,
click WRI SDM sac one
eee
Page 21
tad Mate Ace “ ay, four in buckram.”- ~Henry IV.—IT. 4. * This series of linen covered volumes that have con tine many other delightful sketches and tales. Y. Times 16mo, Buckram, with frontispiece, 75c. each. QUAKER IDYLS. Just Out. The Prisoner of ZENDA. 4th Ed. A SUBURBAN PASTORAL. 2d Ed. JOHN INGERFIELD. 2d Ed. HENRY HOLT & CO.,N. Y. AUGUST ATLANTIC Contains, among other attractions, Love and Art. A charming short story by ELLEN OLNEY KIRK. Philip and his Wife. Mrs. DELAND. Letters of Sidney Lanter. 17. W.R. THAYER. August Birds in Cape Breton. FRANK BOLLES. NAIII-XXYV. Cardinal Lavigerte’s Work in North Africa. WILLIAM SHARP. Some Evils of our Consular Service. ALBERT H. WASHBURN. Voices from Afar. EpItH M. THOMAS. The College Graduate and Public Life. THEODORE ROOSEVELT. $4.00 a year; 35 cents a number. HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO., Boston. 11 East 17th Street, New York. Lessons in Elementary Mechanics. Introductory to the Study of Physical Sci- ence. With Numerous Exercises. By Sir PHILIP MaGNus. New Edition, rewritten and enlarged. (Thirtieth Thousand.) 12mo, 387 pages. $1.20. ‘The special feature of this book is the admirable manner in which energy is discussed and its ope- ration illustrated. ... An excellent high school course, "’—Science. LONGMANS, GREEN, & C0., 15 East 16th Street, New York READY SOON. THE LITERARY STUDY OF THE BIB By Ricwarp G. Mouton of the University of Chicago. This book deals with the Rible as literature, without reference to theological or distinctively religious mat ters on the one hand, or on the other band to the histo- rical analysis which has come to be known as the “ higher criticism.” D.C. HEATH & CO., Boston, New York, Chicago. | By BEATRICE HaRRADEN. The NOW READY: The Hudson Library. Published bi-monthly. Registered as second- class matter. 16mo, papor, each 530 cents. Subscription per year, $3.00. Volume J. Love and Shawlstraps. By ANNETTE LuctLe Nose, author of “ Un- cle Jack’s Execators,” etc. (Ready.) Volume /Z, Miss Hurd. An Enigma. By ANNA KATHARINE GREEN. (In prepara- tion.) Nation. ALSO READY. Uncle Jack’s Executors. By ANNETTE L. Nosie. The Ninth Edition. 16mo, paper, 50 cents; cloth, $1.00, “Comes from a writer of unusual talent Remarkable for its sketches of character, its natu ralness, its frequent flashes of intellectual bright ness, and its genuine humor. .. . One of the best novels of the season, and deserving of a permanent lace among works of genuine American fiction.” e Churchman, Red Cap and Blue Jacket. By GEORGE Dunn. A Tale of the Time of the French Revolution. American Copyright Edition. 16mo, cloth, 21.00. ‘Not many novels of recent times contain more outa characters, which are as real and original as if they had been created by Scott The great merit of the book is its humor, which is rich and good and real, avd not artificial. It is never more effec tive than in the Luxembourg, under the shadow of the guillotine, with the tumbril making its horrid rounds. We make noattempt to tell the story. The author must be left to do that, In his own way, whic) is all his own.’’—The Scotsman “The characters are vividly delineated, and there are many dramatic incidents on sea and land; a fight between an English anda French man-of-war, a ship wreck, the closing scenes of the French Revolution, and two romances."*—The Literary News. In Varying Moods. Copyright Ameri- can Edition. 16mo, paper, 50 cents, cloth, $1.00. ‘The author's touch is most dainty and graceful, and her description of the various people who figure in these bits of life are so vivid as to make them for ever a part of the mental furniture of the reader w pe has once known them. **— Boston Tomes *The author of this volume isa literary artist of rare facility, who chooses words with a fine sense of their value, and puts them together with exqui site harmony."’—N. ¥. Times G.P.Putnam’sSons NEW YORK AND LONDON. 3 K NAB PIANOS UNBQUALLED IN TOUCH, WORAMANSHI/P, AND DURASBILIT Baltimore, New York, 22 and 24 E. Baltimore St 148 5th Ave., near 20th St Washington, 517 Market Space. KINDERGARTEN SUPPLIES t rath St., N.Y. TONE, rkores, 7 Las YALE MIXTURE. The choicest tobacco made, and pre- -eminently a gentleman's Marburg Bros., The American Tobacco Co., Successor, Baltimore, Md. ; smoke a im ONLI For Bratn-Workers, the Weak ° , y +9 , ana Debiltiate qT. Horsford’s Acid Phosphate is without exception the Best Remedy for re Mental and Nervous Exhaustion: and ‘lieving where the system has become debilitated by disease it acts as a general tonic and vitalizer, affording sustenance to both brain and body. Dr. E. Cornell Esten, |) Pa., savs: ** L have met with the est and most satistactoryv results dyspepsia and general derangement of the cerebral and nervous systems causing debility and exhaust Descriptive Pamphiet free Rumford ¢ Beware of Substitutes and Imitations August, 1804. Now Ready. Price, 28 cents Pall [all Tagazine SUMMER N 220 pages, profusely tliustvated, and 3 Phot vate é ‘ Edited i — FREDERIC HATILTON, "P., d SIR DOUGLAS STRAIGHT. This spec a number surpasses all previous ones for varied literary interest an beauty of tlustration, and is unapproached by any other magagine of the same price and class Though very considerably enlarged the price remains the same CONTENTS Stories by-—-Frayk R. Stock Tos (serial story continued Hewry HeRMan (new serial story BILL Nye,” Wu LiaM WaLporr Astor, LADY GWENDOLEN CretL, Bra TRICK Kipurse, Howarp Pease, and Percy REEVE Articies by—DvUKE OF MaRLrorovoen, FIELD Warnenat Viscount WoLskLry, ARcaIRaLD Forres, Dr. Kari Bunn, Lorp RosaLy GoweR, E. T. Lyyxe, and 1. Zana wilt. Poems by—Taomas RatLey ALDRICH, RUDYARD KIPLtxe, the late Hon. Ropen Nogi, Norway Gace, and Curis TIAN BURKE Resides the three fine photugravure plates and nume rous full-page illustrations. the whole number is copt ously illustrated throughout by leading artiste In black and white. ena Offices, 18 Charing Croas Road, London, . C. Publitshing Offices—London, 18 Charing Cross eee. Ww. c.; New York The International News Company; Toronto, The Toronto News Company; Mon treal, The Montreal News Company JOHNS HOPKINS UNIVERSITY, BALTIMORE, MD, Announcements of the Graduate, Col legiate, and Medical Courses for the next academic year are now ready and will be sent on application. THE LENOX LIBRARY (AND READING ROOT), Fifth Ave. and 70th St., is open every weekday from 10 aM. toOP. M.. Exhibition of rare books; two galleries of paintings, Admission free; no tickets required.
Page 22
bane Stein ee alll The Nation. [Vol. 59, No. esa vy Velgcabiaidsed [Continued from page tii.} RHODE ray Providence, 26 Cabot Street. Mi: S MARY C. WHEELER'S PRE- ratory,Collegiate, and Art School reopens Octo- ber 2, Sod. Yertificate admits to Brown University, Smith and Wellesiey Colleges. College Professors n Collegiate Department. Art Schoo! prepares for Paris studios. Limited number of boarding pupils. RHODE ISLAND, Providence. Vy RIENDS' SCHOOL FOR BOTH SEX- es.—Founded in 1784. Excellent Home. Students from 18 States, All denominations. Thorough work in English, Science, Classics, Music, and Art. Address AUGUSTINE JONES, , LL. B. TENNESSEE, Franklin. JALL AND MOONEY’S SCHOOL for Boys.—Fits boys for the leading Universities. Discipline rigid, instruction thorough, expenses rea- sonable. In writing for Catalogue, mention Nation. TENNESSEE, Nashville 7ANDERBILT UNIVERSITY. Next session opens September 19. Full graduate as well as undergraduate courses. Ten Fellowships for college graduates. Seven Departments. Send for catalogue. WILs WILLIAMS, Secretary. VERMONT, Burlington. 7TERMOUNT EPISCOPAL IN STT- “TU TE.—Under supervision of Rt. Rev. A.C. A. Hall, D.D. Boys’ Boarding School. Military Drill. Certifi- cate admits to College. pues course. Forty-five boys. | Catalogue. H. BH. Ross, A.M., Principal. VireintA, 3 miles west of Alexandria. 4 I ak ISCOPAL HIGH SCHOOL OF VIR- _« GINIA.—For Boys. L.M BLackForD, M.A., Prin- cipal, Coraiogues sent. 22 Next annual session opens Sept. § 26, 1894 Vv TROINIA, Lexington. Peon MILITARYVINSTITUTE. 56th Year. Scate Military, Scientific, and Tecbni- cal School. Thorough courses in general and applied Chemistry and in Engineering. Confers degree of gradu- ate in Academic Course, alsu degrees of Bachelor of Sci- ence and Civil Engineer in Technical Courses. All ex- penses, including clothing and incidentals, provided at rate of $36.50 per month, as an average for the four years, exclusive of outfit. New cadets report Sept. 1. 2 BS Gen, Sc oTT ‘SHIpp, Superintendent. VIRGINIA, Norfolk. ORFOLK ACADEMY FOR BOYS.— Prepares for Un. of Va., J. H. Un., U.S. Mil. and Naval Academies, Schools of Science. _ROBERT Ww. TUNSTAL Ly B. A., Principal. — Vinainta, Suffolk UFFOLK MILITARY ACADEMY, 1875-1894. Equipped with Scientific Apparatus, Fuginowses Instruments, and handsome Cadet Rifles. from 6 States. Splendid winter climate. For Illustrated Catalogue, address JOSEPH KING, A.M., Prin. ENGLAND, Parkstone, near Bournemouth. y NGLAN D. BOURNE SCHOUL FOR « GIRLS. Designed for the American girl abroad, offering her the care and interests of a home life combined with the advantages of foreign travel during vacations. Patronesses : Mrs. Grover Cleveland, the Countess of Malmesbury, Lady Glynn, Miss M. Carey Thomas, Dean of Bryn Mawr College ; Miss Gladstone, Vice-Principal Newnham College, and others. For further information address Miss H. F. SEAL, = — s College Preparatory School, Bryn Mawr, Pa. “dy ee GNES’ SCHOOL FOR GIRLS, & Albany, N. Y¥.—Under the direction of Bishop Doane. Copoice of four courses of study for graduation. Special studies may be taken, or a tull collegiate course. For Cc ‘atalogue, address Miss E. W. Boyp, Prin. he 7 thorough Instruction given at Duncan's Davenport Business College, Davenport, Iowa, is verifiea by more than 100 Banks using their students. HE SEMINARY, Mt. Carroll, Ill., with Conservatory of Music and School of Art, now in 42d year since incorporated. Send for Sree Oread, — RIVERVIEW ,.,,ASABESY, aa N. Yo 59TH YEAR. Prepares gsoney for College, the Government Academies and Business. U.S. Army offi- cer detailed at Riverv oe by Secretary of War. ISBEE & AMEN, Principals. Z JOHN'S MILITARY SCHOOL, ANLIUS, N. Y. Next term Re Sept. 19, 1894. Apply to wri. VERBECK, President. S COLLEGE Sze Three ‘Pull tas of Study. Location beautiful and healthful. New Building with Modern Improvements. Session begins September 19, 1894, Send for Catalogue. Ber ULARS of Best Schools, with Advice. - free to parents. Teachers supplied for Colleges and Schools without charge. KERR & HU wasoue UNION SCHOOL BUREAU, 2 W. 14th St.. N.Y. COLLEGIATE INSTITUTE. Ft. Edward, N Y. For Young Women. 37th year Sept. 25. Six courses and P ‘rep. Music, Art, Elocu., Phys. 8.Cul. $270. Jos. E. KING, D.D. Bingham School for Boys, ASHEV ILLE, N. & tstablished in 1793. 1793 Major R. Binenam, Superintendent, . 1894 E:ducational. Educational. THE SIGLAR SCHOOL, Newburgh-on-Hudson, N. Y. $600 a year—no extras. Thirty Boys. I hate to tell parents that they don’t know how to manage their boys, so that every year shall count in their growth of body and mind, of manners and morals and grip on the world. I have a boy myself—I’m afraid I do better by other boys than I have done by him. I suppose it is true that a parent can't. You say you haven't the the knack. I haven't the knack with my own boy. I have sent a lot of boys to Yale, and they have done me great honor. I hope I haven't spoiled my own. I have had success with other boys—when I fail I al- ways think it’s the parent’s fault— there is rarely a failure due to the boy himself, unless he begins too old, and that’s the parent's fault. The age to begin at is 8; if too late for that, at g; if too late for that too, 10; if 10 is past, he has lost two years; if he is 11 and still go- ing wrong, what sort of a man do you think you have made him? Tell me about your boy. HENRY W. SIGLAR. Museum of Fine Ar Copley Square, Boston, Mass. SCHOOL OF DRAWING AND PAINTING. Nineteenth year will open October 1, 1894. Instruction in drawing from the cast and from life, in painting, foawenn gy - decorative design, and also in artistic anatom ae tase TT Priacipal instruc- tors: F. W. D eon, (Drawing and Pair ting), Mrs. William Stone (Decora- tive Design), B. L Pratt (Modelling), G. i Monks, M.D. (Anatomy), and A. K. Cross (Perspective). we are allowed the free use of the galleries of oe, useum., For circulars one detailed information, iss ELIZABETH LOMBARD. Manager. HACKETTSTOWN INSTITUTE, HACKETTSTOWN, NEW JERSEY. College preparatory for gentlemen. Ladies’ College. Best building of its class. Music, Art, Elocution, Lal ratory. Twogympasiums. Location unsurpassed. "Terms moderate. Catalogue free. Rev. GEO. H. WHITNEY, D.D., Pres. University of Virginia, CHARLOTTESVILLE, VA. ee Session begins 15th Sept. Full equipment and corps of instructors in Academical, Engineering, Law, and Medical Departments. Excellent climate. New Gymna‘ium, with baths free to all students, For cata- logues, address WM. M. THORNTON, LL.D., Chairman. ROCKFORD COLLEGE FOR WOMEN, Fall Term opens September 19, 1894. Classical and Science Courses. Excellent Preparato- ry School, weeny organized departments of Music and Art. ell-equipped Laboratories. Fine Gymna siums. Resident ee, —— Hall enables students to reduce ex ‘or catalogue address Lock Box 10. SARAH F. PL ANDERSON, Princip in OGONTZ SCHOOL For Young Ladies. Established in 1850. Twenty minutes from Philadel- hia, two hours from New York. Opens a 26. or circulars and reports appr te to Princi GLENDALE FEMALE, FEMA L E ForTY-First YEAR. BEAUTIFUL AND HEALTHFUL LOCA- TION. Fifteen miles north of Cincinnati. Full course of study, PREPARATORY AND COLLEGIATE. Best facili- ties‘ in Music, ~~ etc., with home care and supervi- sion. Rev. L. D. POTTER, D.D., Glendale, Ohio. THE THAYER ACADEMY, BRAINTREE, MASS. First term, eighteenth — begins WEDNESDAY, Sept. 12. It is expected that the new Chemical and Physical Laboratories and the Gymnasiums-one for rls and one for boys—will then be opened. Address he Headmaster, South Braintree, Mass. UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS. The chair of Physics and also the chair of Biology in the University of Texas, at Austin, Tex., are vacant. Applications to fill said chairs, with testimonials and’ references, should be os to F. W. BALL, Chair- man, Fort Worth, Tex Salary of Physics, $3.0 000; of Biology, $2,000. HOWARD SEMINARY, West Bridgewater, Mass. An excellent home school for girls, limited to 50. For full pastiowiess and iilustrated circular, address HORACE M,. WILLARD, Sc.D., Principal. WASHINGTON AND LEE UNIVERSITY, Lexington, Virginia. Academic, Law, Engineering. Opens Sept. 13. For catalogue, address G. W. C. LEE, President. “NORWOOD INSTITUTE. A School for Girls. Full Academic Course. Complete School of Modern Languages. Best advantages in Music, Art, and Elocution. Special preparation for any S- Opens Sept. 27. Address Mr. and Mrs. W. D. CABELL, 1407 Massachusetts Ave., Washington, D. C. CHELTENHAM MILITARY ACADEMY. OGONTZ (NEAR PHILADELPHIA), PA. Unexcelled as a College Preparatory School. Now represented by its —- in Yale, Harvard, Princeton. Cornell, Lehigh, fayette, Trinity, Univ. of Pa., and West Point. 24th year begins Sept. 19. JOHN C. RICE, Ph.D., Prine _ PENNSYI Mores ter - COLLEGE CHESTER, PA. 33d Am begins September 19. Civil Eneineering (C. E.), Chemistry (B.S.), Arts (A.B.). EPARATORY COURSES in English and Classics. Refers to Mr. GEo. B, STERLING, 7 East 17th St., City. Catalogues of Col. C. E. HYAPT, Pres. . , 1; ’ - > AURORA, Cayuga Lake Military Academy, “58984 om gg —A well- disciplined school. Experienced teachers. Location near Cornell University. Term be- gins Sept. 19, nae For illustrated circular, address ol. C. J. WRIGHT, B.S., A.M., Prin ipals or yer K. MCALPINE, A.M., wig LAKE ERIE, SEMINARY, Practically — with the care and culture of home, Miss MARY EVANS, Principal. time—I say you haven't ist aL oe ee CSI IEE Pe ro Cee. oat
Page 23
7
ee Lee er se
.
Jay 26, 1894] Teachers, pn [JZANTED—A GRADUATE OF College of good standing to do some special work and lecturing in connection with Civil Govern mentand Political Sclence. Special fitress in the way of preparation, ond marked ability to interest an au dience essential. Add ress SCHERMERHORN’S TRACHFRS’ AGENCY, 8 East 14th St... N. ¥ A ZANTED—BY A VIRGINIA LADY, position as Companion, or Goverpess to small children. Musie a specialty. Can give the best of references. Address Miss CLARK, Scottsburgh, Halifax Co. V Va.
vou NG ¥% ADY WHO COMPLE TE. S a: her course of study in Paris this summer, wishes an engagement for the fall and winter in New York city as visiting governess in afamily. FEngtish, Latin, Frenc h, and the Piano. W. H.C, care the Nation. UW TANTED — LIBRARIAN, — MU: ST be entirely competent to manage the business and direct the cataloguing of a large library. Address, with references, UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS, ( ‘hampaign, Il. “CIENCE TEACHER.- A HARVARD ~J A.M. desires a position in good High School or Aca demy. Three years’ experience. Excellent references. H. L., 70 Agricultural St , Worce-ter, Mass. J RTH GERMAN LADY (diplomee de £ Berlin) seeks engagement for the fall in college or high standard school. Good American references, Address Friiulein H, FrErNow, Sage College, Ithaca, N. Y. AN EXPERIENCED TEACHER, ee with highest American and foreign references, wishes a position as Greek instructor in a college. Salary $1,500. Address ‘* GREECE,” care of the Nation. Z TEACHER, A PH.B., DESIRES A 27 postition in school or college. Mathematics, Sci ence, or Latin. Central States preferred. Address Miss G.,¢ are Nation. CH ATR OF GREEK OR PHILOSOPHY by a specialist. Experience. “Courses in Philoso- phy” sent on request. INSTRUCTOR, Box 41, Wyncote, Pa. (=~ W. STONE, Tutor for Har- vard, 68 Chestnut Street, Boston. School Agencies. MERICAN AND FOREIGN TEACH- 21 ers’ Agency supplies Professors. Teachers, Tutors, Governesses, etc., to Colleges, Schools, and Families. Apply to Mrs. M. J. YounG-FuLTon, 23 Union Square, New York. _ HE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES, 4 Asbburton Place, Beston; 70 Fifth Ave., N. Ys 106 Wabash Ave.. Chicago; 32 Church Street. Tors nto; 803 Twelfth Street, Washington, D. C.; 12046 South Spring Street, Los Angeles. Agency Manual free. EVERETT ©. Fisk & Co. HE NE Ww AMERIC AN TEACHERS’ AGENCcY.- Te achers seeking positions and those wishing a change at an increased salary should address © B. RvuaGLes & Co. (Palace Hotel Building), Room C, 237 Vine Street, Cincinnati, O. HE ALBERT TEACHERS’ AGENCY has filled over 1,300 positions,.more than half with in the last two years. High-class vacancies now for Sep tember. New handbook sent free. C.J. ALBERT, Ma nager, 211 Wabash Ave., Chicago, Il. MERICAN AND FOREIGN Profes- sors, tutors, governesses, teachers, etc., supplied to colleges, schools, and families. MrrtaM COYRIERE, 150 5th Ave., cor. 20th St., N. Y. “CHERMERHORN’'’S TEACHERS’ » Agency. Oldest and best known in a4 U.S. _Established 1855. 3 East 14th St., N. Y. HE BRIDGE 7 EACHERS’ AGEN- cies, 110 Tremont St., Boston. and 211 Wabash Ave., Chicago. Agency Manual free to any address. MERICAN AND FOREIGN TEACH- a ers’ Bureau. Miss Grace Powers Tuomas, M’g’r 3 Park St., Boston, Mass.
: , is valuable in proportion to its 4 1m. dge HCY inttuence. If it merely hears of vacancies tl tells Th q is something, but if you about them (¢ it is asked to recom mend a teacher and recom- PD ,. ‘ - mends you, that is more. Ours Recommends C. W. BARDEEN, Syracuse, N. Y Tours. Tyrolean Tours. INNSBRUCK, TYROL, AUSTRIA. 1,900 feet above the sea, with dry, bracing climate CENTRE FOR COACHING TRIPS and Excursions of all kinds. HOTEL TIROL. Open all the year. CARL LANDSER, Propriet Large, airy, sunny rooms; modern conveniences caonel recul sine. Reduced ratesin winter. Eminent metic al « ‘are if desired. Unusual educational advantages on rate terms. EXCURSIONS A SPECIALTY. Best refer ences. Mlustrated pamphlets sent on application
N ation.
WOMAN SUFFRAGE Is claiming the attention of the country as never before. ‘Will it be a good thing for woman and for the public at large?” is the ques- r asec cece Ss SouiaTIO a leading exponent of Natural Pre- mium Life Insurance, is certainly a blessing to both. Cost 60 per cent. usual rates. The NEW POLICY of the Massachusetts Benefit Life Association has nosuperior, It gives Cash Dividends, Cash Surrender Values, Paid-Up Insurance, aud other desirable options, Splendid Openings for Energetic Men to Act as Special, General and State Agents REO. A. LITCHFIELD, Pres., 53 State St., Boston, MRS. PEARY MY ARCTIC JOURNAL. “Mrs. Peary’s descriptions of scenery are admirable London Spectator, Price, $2.00. CONTEMPORARY PUB. CO., 5 Beekman St... N. Y. A Curtwus Book. Les Moeurs Secretes du XVIlle Siecle. Colligees par Octave UZANNE. 4to, sewed, uncut, tllus trated. Paris, ISSS. $5.00, GEORGE P. H 7MPAREY 5 Exchange ay Rochewters Y American iain Newspapers, and Journals The Cosmopolitan @ $1.50 per vear. Best magazine issued in America. The Dirision Visitor SO) cents per year. Best non partisan and nop sectarian tempe rance paper. Ask us to quote on your wants. Mention Nation. AMERICAN PRINTING AND NEWS COMPANY 1111 ARCH ST.. PHILADELPHIA. PA Flistory of Dartmouth College AND THE TOWN OF HANOVER, N.H. by Frepe RICK CHASE. Vol I. To the outbreak of the college controversy. Large Sv« cloth $3.50, net; postace 24cents. Sent on Feceipi of price by ‘RD, Hanover, N. H KOEHLER, NEUMANN & CO., Foreign ookse ers, 149A Tremont Street Boston, Mass. Subscriptions to Periodicals. Regular importations from Leipaig Paris, London, ete. Tauchnitz British Authors, etc. RARE | PRINTS—AUTOGRAPHS. BOOKS. ,. Cotetegees Issued Continually. BENJAMIN. 22 EL 16th St. New York Subec Tiptions to foretgn pert Fi ye ton Book A’S, odicals, Tauchnits British au thors. Catalogues on appli cation. CaRL SCHOENHOF. 23 Schoo! St.. Boston Boks AZ COST t harchoidses No > liability. Catalogue free. Social Science our spe clalty. CHARLES H. KERR & Co., Publishers, 175 Monroe Street, ( “hicago. PAP ER BY THE PO C ND: an ton velopes. Greater quan tity, lower price than by quire. Samples, all grades, — marked, on receipt of Ide. WM. R. JENKINS, ne stationery, 851-53 Sixth Ave. (48th St.) N.Y ACK NUMBERS, VOLS.. AND SETS of the Nation bought, sold, and exchanged—a com _— set of the Nation now ready—by A. 8S. CLaRK, 34 ark Row, N.Y. Catalogue No. SS ready
Tie = b—'* Mary Barton, Manzoni s ‘ Be- * o « * trothed Lovers.” Burney's ‘Evelina,’ Beck ford’s‘ Vathek, Murray's s* Prairie Bird.’ Mailed prompt ly Pratt, 6th Ave... cor. 12th St.. N. Y. H: WILLIAMS, 195 WEST 10TH ST., N.Y., dealer in Magazines and other pertodicals Seta, volt ames, or sifigle numbers
Vil B. WESTERMANN & CO., [LEMCKE & BUECHNER BookKsSELLERS AND [Mportt School and College Text 8 K Grammars of Ancient and M ‘Th Language FLCGEL'S Great German ar Pog lis ’ ‘ S vols. Special terurs fou Thieme-Preusser, Koehler " French, English, Italian Diet os Teubner and Tauchnita Greek a La Tex Mai-orders f Rooks. I
ceive imim GUSTAV E. STE CHERT, Importer of Books and Periodicals. I SLO BROADWAY, NEW ¥ K Large stock of | x ks " ‘ as scar and sets of Br Subscriptions to} Lowest rates, quick Send for Cata
x . Lond W s Ww Paris Hun } Leiprig Hospital S THE UNITED STATES, « ‘ Lavy-Is7Tl Rye G VIN Sur New \ ‘ Macmillan & 1 ‘ . pages. Pu ~ . 2 r < postage, | . We have secure! a few pies of this ar anid famous Dowk, and t “ we nS only They willl not < ) ©. Eneeiic Old Q b Store, N os s t First 4 “™ ~ a F. W. CHRISTERN, (DYRSEN & PFEIFFER, Suc'rs), 854 Fifth Ave. between ¥sth and 2vth Sta. New York
Importers of Foreicn | k Agents for the leading Paris Publishers, Tauchnite’s tish Authors, Teubner’s Greek and Latin Classics t gues of stock iled ondemand. A large assortm aiwars on hand, and new books received from Par prig as scx AR issued. Lf vou nny NCH BOOKS, of any z ~~ S , Books, N i to WILLIAM. R. JENKINS, Pi Importer, 8§% and 853 SIXTH AVENUE havent Steen). NEW — Catalogue on application For Ace ” Ay MEYER. BROS. & CO., 13 WEST 24TH ST., NFAR BROADWAY, LARGEST SELECTION OF FRENCH BOOKS. Importers and Publishers of French Books. Sele agents for A. Lemerre, Parts Catalogues mailed on ce mand. New boots received from Paris 3 times a week. Bindings, Kare Boos, Etchings, Prints, Photos, ete. Special importations to order To Litrarians, Book-Lovers, and Booksellers. Our NEW CATALOGUE of RARE and CHOICE BOOKS, comprising works on architecture, biography. beiles lettres, the drama, first editions, Shakespeariana, rare French Books, works of art, etc., etc., will be sent, post paid. upon request tS Attention is called to this valuable collection BRENTANO’'S, $1 Union Square, New York. { AL 1) B ( ( KS We make a specialty of hunting up old books and magazines. W« buy large and amaill libraries for cash. If you want any thing in the book line write to us. Monthly Hat of of4, rare, and curious books free. THE PHILADELPHIA BOOK CLEARING-NOUSE, 144 N 7th St., Philadetphia, Pa. B: AC K numbers and sete of all magazines For on state wants to MAGaZIng EXCHANGE, Schoharie, N
Page 24
The Nation. [Vol. 59, No. 1517 A Lire Hicuen iw Price, BUT—! We invite Housekeepers to insist upon being supplied with the “FERRIS” BRAND Sold by the Better Grocers. —«a#!_ Back Numbers of “ The Nation.” In response to frequent inquirles from subscribers: An incomplete set of Tak NATION has little or no mar- ket value. Partial sets, bound and unbound, are al- ways obtainable (usually lacking the earliest volumes), and do not command high rates. The bindings gene- rally count for nothing, owing to great diversity of styles. Volume I. has readily brought $10 and upward when complete, bound or unbound, but will bring ve’ little in . if asingle number is missing. Vol- umes IT. and III. are also scarce, but not so high-priced as the first. Complete sets, both bound and unbound, have sold for $100, with tolerably quick bidders, and have an increas- ing value year by year. Single numbers not more than a year old can usually be supplied by the publishers at 10 cents each. For numbers more than a year old purchasers are referred to Mr. J. W. Christopher, 47 Dey St., Mr. A. 8S. Clark, 84 Park Row, or H. Williams, 195 West Tenth Street, New York. The publishers no longer undertake to buy or sell numbers or volumes more than a year old, and can only recommend sellers or purchasers to negotiate with a dealer or to advertise in THE NATION. (Publication was begun July 1, 1865, Vol. I. compris- ing the last half year. Two volumes per year have since been — Vol. LVLII. comprising the first half-year of 1894. MAYER & MULLER, Booksellers, 51 Markgrafenst., Berlin (Germany). Direct supply. at best terms, of GERMAN NEW AND SECOND-HAND BOOKS, PAMPHLETS, and PERIODI- CALS in any department of Learning and Literature. Cheapest and most inexpensive opportunity for Libra ries, Professors, and Students. Best references. FOR SALE. New England Magazine, N.S., Vols. 1-8, unbound. 00 Illustrated American, Vols. 1-15 6 00 The Theatre (N. Y.), Vols. 1-6, unbound. Gentleman’s Magazine, 140 vols H. WILLIAMS, 195 West 10th St., N. Y. Novels, Handbooks, Music, and Plays. CATALOGUE FREE. You will find something of great in- BOOKS sas POPULAR BOOK COoO., Cricago. GOLDEN OFFICE OF THE Atlantic Mutual INSURANCE COMPANY, NEw York, January 22d, 1894. The Trustees, in conformity with the Charter of the Company, submit the following State- ment of its affairs on the 31st of December, 189}. Premiums on Marine Risks from lst January, 1893, to 31st December, 1893. $3,193,868 16 Premiums on Policies not marked off 1st January, 1893 Total Marine Premiums 1,403,200 31 $4,597,068 47 Premiums marked off. from 1st January, 1893, to 31st December, 1893 $3,490,552 70 Losses paid during the $1,892,970 00 Returns of Pre- miums and Ex- $711,138 89 The Company has the following assets, viz.: United States and City of New York Stock: City Banks and other Stocks .... $7,903,455 00 Loans secured by Stocks and otherwise.. 1,652,000 00 Real Estate and Claims due the Compa- ny, estimated at Premium Notes and Bills Receivable 1,117,174 29 CRG BOs oso 58s ices ssp easece vintacenin 205,600 46 RIE. 200056 008er000 wsveee pourncceceon’ $12,055,058 49 1,086,828 74 Six per cent. interest »n the outstanding certificates of profit will be paid to the holders thereof or their legal representatives,on and after Tuesday, the sixth of February next. The outstanding certificates of the issue of 1889 will be redeemed and paid to the holders thereof, or their legal representatives, on and after Tuesday, the sixth of February next, from which date all interest thereon will cease. The certificates to be produced at the time of payment, and cancelled. A dividend of FORTY PER CENT. is declared on the net earned premiums of the Company for the year ending 31st December, 1893, for which certificates will be issued on and after Tuesday, the first of May next. By order of the Board, J. H. CHAPMAN, Secretary. TRUSTEES: George Bliss, W.H.H. Moore, John L. Riker, A. A. Raven, C. A. Hand, Jos. H. Chapman, John D. Hewlett, James Low, Chas. P. Burdett, William Sturgis, N. Denton Smith, Jas.G. De Forest, C.H. Marshall, Leander N. Lovell, Wm. Degroot, Chas. D. Leverich, Everett Frazar, William H. Webb, Edw. Floyd-Jones, Wm. B. Boulton, Horace Gray, George H. Macy, Geo. W. Quintard, Henry E. Hawley, Lawr’ce Turnure, Paul L, Thebaud. Wm. E. Dodge, Wald. P. Brown, J. D. JONES, President, W. H. H. MOORE, Vice-President. A. A. RAVEN, 2d Vice-President. J. D. Jones, Anson W. Hard, Isaac Bell, Gustav Amsinck, Joseph Agostini, Vernon H. Brown, C. de Thomsen, “ESTABLISHED 1858" H.: H. UPHAM -& -CO.: “MEMORIAL: TABLETS: ‘IN- BRASS - AND - BRONZE: 54° South Fifth: Ave: near’ Bleecker St’ ‘NEW YORK: SCEPTRE. PERFECTION FOR THE PIPE. Send 40 cents for 4-0z. sample to SURBRUG, 159 Fulton St., N. Y. City. CASS REALTY CORPORATION. Incorporated under the laws of the State of New York. Capital invested only in productive real estate in the city of New York. This Corporation is organized for the purpose of providing a safe and profitable method of investing money for persons of limited means, and it is be- lieved that no safer or better way can be found than in the purchase and holding of well located and pro- ductive real estate in the city of New York. The Capital Stock is divided into Common and Pre- ferred shares of the par value of one hundred dol- lars each. The Preferred shares are entitled to dividends at the rate of five per centum per annum, payable quarterly, and to a preference for principal. The investor has the advantage of knowing that the property of the Corporation is always in sight and can be readily located and inspected, that its value is permanent and easily ascertained, that the income is certain. . For people who seek safety and permanence, to- gether with a moderate return, this investment recommends itself. Common and Preferred shares are now offered at the par value of ONE HUNDRED DOLLARS each, in large or small amounts. Payments may be made in installments. Application must be made to Cass Realty Corporation No. 503 Fifth Avenue, NEW YORK CITY, NEW YORK. tte We buy and sell bills of exchange on Letters and make Cable Transfers of money to of Europe, Australia, and the West Indies: ; also make collections and issue Commer- Credit. cial and Travellers’ Credits, available in all parts of the world. , ’ bed Brown Brothers & Co., Bankers, NO. 50 WALL STREET, NEW YORK. 99257 «PURE FOK THE BAPY. THE PROCTER & GAMBLE CO., CIN'TI.