The Nation 1894-01-11: Vol 58 Iss 1489

Page 1

: The N: VOL. LVIHI—No. 1489, _ THURSDAY, JANUARY 11, 18094 PRO MU Bern rs SOME NEW “SUCCESSFUL BOOKS. “ey 5 | CUSTOMS AND FASHIONS IN OLD NEW ENGLAND. Thousand | By Mrs. Avice Morse Earir. 12mo, St. 25 * A picture of colonial life which has been faithfully draw1 The work kt hardly hav

_— Herald | 7 | THE SABBATH IN PURITAN NEW ENGLAND. Thousand | ” Mrs. ALIcE Morse EARLE. 12mo, $1. 25 | ‘A graphic picture of the life of the Puritans.’ Bo | THE ONE I KNEW THE BEST OF AL od Thousand By Mrs. Frances HopcGson BuRNE?T 1 Fully ilusts lL by ROB. Bu 12 S: * It has the eng: ging ¢ ‘andor and tran 8 ire f all sincere autbiography, vet it is revea \ <u x ‘ and absence of self-consciousness we forget th at the child heroine is Mes h nets , Wrs Kats} eae - 4 MEH LADY. Thousand A Story of the War. By THomMas Netson Paci Iilustrate yt. @ Small folio, $1.50. — ‘Its contrasted humor, force, and pathos put it foremost among any © Sout \ } ever read.’ —Independent. 5 MARSE CHAN. Thousand A Tale of Old Virginia. By Thomas Neéison Pact Illustrated by W. TLS Small folio, $1.50. ‘A story of Virginia before and during the war truthful, bene Atic, pathet Mr. Page enjoys the rey x written the most exquisite story of the war which has vet appe i i vu 6 THE OPINIONS OF A ita at neee Thousand By mass sivlny-vaguitay With numerous [1h tions by C. Ss. R rt a ae ley. 12mo, Sr.

| * A wonderfully bright book The best thing M ur s writt 16 |THE REFLECTIONS OF A _ MARRIE » TIAN. Thousand By Ropert GRANT. 12mo, $1.00 “It sparkles with Mr. Grant's pleasant wit 8 DAVID BALFOUR. Thousand Being Memoirs of His Adventures at Hon \! By Ronere | .

SON, T2mo, St. 50° ** Nothing better in the field of hist as been prvxduced s S | 40 | STORIES FROM SCRIBNER. Thousand | Stories of Italy. Stories of New York. Stories of the South. | | Stories of the Army. Stories of the Railway. Stories of the Sea. | Each vol ume illustrated, r6mo, paper, so cents; th, 75 its; half calf, $1.5 the | 7 set, 6 volumes in a box, paper, $3.00; th, $4.50; half calf, $9.00 30 VERSE AND TALES BY EUGENE FIELD. Thousand A Little Book of meee 1 Verse \ Little Book of Profitable Tales L Second Bi of Verse Each 16mo, gilt top, $1.25. A Over 100 | FAMOUS wo OMEN OF THE FRENCH COU RT. Thousand Translated from the French of Imbert age saint Women of the Valois and Versailles Courts, 4 vols vine “Ant nette, 3 vols ‘E mpress Josephine, 3 vols. Em | : : ' press Marie Louise, 4 vols 1) ess of Angouleme, 2 vols. Duchess of Berry, 3 vols Each r2mo, with Portraits. $1.25

CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS, 743 and 745 Broadway, New York.

Page 2

The Nation.

[Vol. 58, No. 1489

The } A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Nation. Politics, Literature, Science, and Art. FOUNDED 1865. [ Entered at the New York City Post-office as second-class mail matter.)

CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER.

EK. ckancbnnnessessencbecthcicoscaayeesaveses css 21 EDITORIAL ARTICLES : ee ee 24 The Graver Evils of the Income Tax............-.. 24 The Report Against Mr. Hornblower.............. 25 MOWMORDEE BOC is once ssccevevsccsercossccecevces 26 SPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE : Italy and the Triple Alliance................s.eee0 26 TO REE MG MEOUEIRS occ cksccedcncenseceecsscose 27 CORRESPONDENCE : Am O16-World LeGROD........ccccccsceee 00 vocccccsee 28 The Admission of Utab.............cceeeeeeeeee soi ee Our Forefathers on Football —< oe Two Rare Editions of Gags, .......ccescceees co Jupiter's Satellites in 1764........-.... .....e-0e- 29 To Spell For, ‘To Intimate a Wish For,’ ‘ To etait e 1 ORME 65 5555 sncocsacsasscacnesraceveses 30 EE Sab knck remdnsieshbsnkebvey sia dsscarbbevsensapewne 380 Book REVIEWS: Adams’s Massachusetts and its Historians......... 83 PT CIN, oc cntcsectersecsvoese asene 34 A New English Dictionary..... 35 The Letters of Lady Burghersh. 36 BO EE LW GET ce sccccesceveccseseses ones ae I Sr I rv nncccnccscesnesiccnepwisicesssses 87

TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION, Three Doliars per year in advance, postpaid, to any tren of the United States or Canada; to foreign coun- ries comprised in the Postal Union, Four Dollars. The date when the subscription expires is on the Ad- dress: Label of each Paper, the change of which to a sub- sequent date becomes a receipt for remittance. No other recei; t is sent unless requested Remittances at the risk b the subscriber, unless made by registered letter or by o express order, or postal order, payable to “Publ hor f THE NATION.’ Whena change of addres % is desired, both the old and new cemveente should be given. Add THE NATION. Box 794, New York. Publication Office, 208 Broadway.

TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Fifteen cents per agate line, each insertion, 14 lines to the inch. Twenty per cent,advance for choice of age, top of column, or cuts. Cuts are not inserted on the first page. A column, $20 each insertion; with cho of page, $24. 4 pow, $60 each insertion; front cover page, $80. sertisements must be acceptable in every respect. Copy received until noma 5 P.M. Discounts on application The EDITION of the NATION this week is 9,350 copies. The Subscription List is always open to the in- spection of advertisers. MUSEUM OF FINE ARTS, Copley Square, Boston, Mass. SCHOOL OF DRAWING AND PAINTING. Eighteenth year now open. Instruction in drawing from the cast and from life, in painting, modelling, and decorative design, and also in artistic omy and wg Principal instruc tors: F. . Benson, C. Tarbell, and Philip Hale (Drawing iP Painting), C. How Walker and Mrs. William Stone (Decorative Design), B. L. Pratt ——— Img), G. H. Monks, M.D. (Anatomy), and A, K. Cross (Perspective). Pupils are allowed the free use of the ga'leries of the Museum. For circulars giving detailed a emaion, address Miss ELIZABETH LOMBARD, Manager. SI. JOHN'S MILITARY SCHOOL, MANLIUS, N. Y. Next term begins January 11, 1894. Rt. Rev. F. D. Huntington, Pres.; Wm. Verbeck, Supt.; Ist. Lieut. Ww. P. Burnham, U. 8. A., Commandant.

LAKEWOOD HEIGHTS SCHOOL — LAKEWOOD, NEW JERSEY. AMONG THE PINES. A thorough and attractive School for Boys. JAMES W. MOREY. RIVERVIEW ,, acapemy: 58TH YEAR. Prepares thoroughly for College, the Gov- ernment Academies -_ Business. Military organiza- tion. pals.

BOSES & AMEN, Prine

F-:ducatonal. CALIFORNIA, Los Angeles, West 23d Street. _| | haat 'GH SCHOOL for GIRLS, it Mrs. Gro. A. CASWELL, Principal.

Connecticut, New Haven, 56 Hillhouse Avenue. CHOOL FOR YOUNG LADIES.— WEST END INSTITUTE. Mrs. Cady and Miss Cady, Principals. Prescribed and Elective Courses of Study, or College Preparatory Course. Circulars. Early ap- plication necessary.

CONNECTICUT, Waterbury T. MARGARET'S DIOCESAN School.—Nine‘eenth year opens Sept. 20, 1893. The Rev. Francis T. Russell, M.A., Rector. Miss Mary R. Hillard, Principal.

DELAWARE, . Wilmington, Franklin Street. HE MISSES HEBB’S ENGLISH, French, and German Boarding and Day School for young ladies and girls reopens Sept. 22, 1893. Mary LAND, Baltimore. 122 and 124 Ww. Franklin St. 4 OGE WORTH BOARDINGAND DAY School for Girls. Mrs. H. P. LEFEBVRE, Principal. 8ist year begins September 21, 1893.

MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 593 Boylston Street. (= UNCY HALL SCHOOL (65th Sear). For Boys and Girls.—Preparation for the Mass. In- stitute of Technolegy is aspecialty. Reference is made tothe Institute Faculty. The location of the school building on Copley Square, is especially attractive, and is very near the Institute. Preparation also for College (with or without Greek) and A Sor business, Special students received. Massacuvu SETTS, Boston, 9 Appleton Street. OSTON NORMAL SCHOOL OF G nastics.—Fifth year opens September 26, 1893. AMY Morris HOMANS, _Diree tor. ’M-

‘annua HUSETTs, Boston. fposro: N UNIVERSITY Law School. Address the Dean. EDMUND H. BENNETT, LL.D. MASSACHUSETTS, Cambridge. HE CAMBRIDGE SCHOOL for Young Ladies. Mr. ARTHUR GILMAN is the Director.

MASSACHUSETTS, Concord. he ORD HOME SCHOOL,.—25 BOYS prepared for college, scientific school, or business. All the advantages of family life combined with best mental and physical training. oe, ad and ac- cording to latest models. 75 acres of grou JAMES S. GARLAND, Prinetpal. “Massac HUSETTS, Duxbur OWDER POINT. ” 5¢ HOOL-—PRE- ares for Mass. Inst. of Tech., Harvard, or Busi ness. Individual teaching. Laboratories. 50 boys. Ele- mentary classes for young boys. Home and outdoor life F. B. KNAPP, andl MAssAct HUSETTS, Greenfield. ROSPECT HILL SCHOOL FOR GIRLS ~Twenty fourth Year, Prepares for College. Also Science, Art, and Music. JAMES C, PArsons, P rincipal. ~ ‘MASSACHUSEI JSETTS, Plymouth V R. KNAPP’S HOME SCHOOL FOR R Boys—12 boys; 27th year. H. W. Roya (Harv.), Head eet Mrs. Knapp, Principal.

MASSACHUSETTS, Quincy. DAMS ACADEMY.—PREPARES Boys for the leading Colleges. Second term begins January 8, 1894. Address W.R. TYLER, Master.

MASSACHUSETTS, Worcester, 66 West St. COHN W. DALZELLS PRIVATE School for Boys.—Prepares for College or Scien- tific School. Send for Cueieges. New Y ORK, Kingston on Hudson. “OLDEN HILL PREPARATORY T School for Boys. Joun M. Cross, A.M., Principal. New York city, 9 University Place. EACHERS’ COLLEGE, AFFILIAT- ED with Columbia Collge, offers to both men and women university a Lag’ Pedagogy, leading to the degrees of A.B., A.M., and P WALTER i Cae RVEY, President.

NEW York City, 183 Lenox Ave., near 119th St. HE MISSES MERINGT ON.— French and English School. Resident pupils.

NEW YORK, North Granville. Soar: Sp loffer, free tuit'n, no (oN $50,- 000 b’ld’ £, g board, sends st’ mp, name Nat. 88th yr. NEW York, Utica. MVM RS. PIATT S SCHOOL FOR GIRLS. —The next school year begins Thursday, Sept. 21, 189: J _ Applications should be made early. NORTH CaRoLinA, Asheville. DAVENSCROFT SCHOOL—PREPAR- atory Boarding and Day School for Boys. Head Master, RONALD McDoNALD, B.A., Oxf rd.

Educational. PENNSYLV ee * Slaaaaaematatiae 202, 204, 335 West Chelten A Ss Seale cts MM: S MARY "E. STEVENS’ BOARD- and Day School.—24th year. “ Approved” by Bryn Mawr College. The Bryn Mawr entrance exa- minations are held in the school by an examiner from the College. School certificate admits to Vassar. ny ARS. COMEGY’S AND MISS BELL'S English, French, and German Boarding-School for young ladies reopens October 2. Students pre pared for College. Ample grounds for outdoor exer- cise. ny TSS ANABLE’S BOARDING AND Day School for Young Ladies. Estab. in 1848. Opens Sept. 28.

PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, Chestnut Hill.

PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, 13850 Pine St.

FRANCE, Paris, 112 Avenue Victor Hugo. YRENCH PRIVATE SCHOOL for Girls, Number limited. Miss HESS and MLurE. FOURNAISE. THE SAUVEUR SUMMER COLLEGE OF LANGUAGES. NINETEENTH SESSION. The next session of The Sauveur College of Languages and Amherst Summer School will be held at Amherst, Mass. For a and ea" address SAU Copley St.. yp Plain, Boston, Mass., Or, Prof. W. L. MONTAIGNE, Amherst. Mass. —

Teachers, etc. } TANTED IMMEDIATELY—BY A lady in Baltimore, an expert stenographer and typewriter (woman). Applications may be addressed to D.G., care of the Nation. N INSTRUCTOR IN PHYSICS IN one of the foremost Western Universities (A.B. Harvard, Ph.D. Germany) desires a change. Also tutor- ship. Willing to travel. Address Dr. X. B., care Nation. FEW PUPILS WILL BE RECEIV- ed in a New York Suburban Boarding School for — January 9 until June 6 for $200 each. Ad- ress

PRINCIPAL, . Nation office. —

LADY OF EXPERIENCE, QUALI- fled to teach Academic or Primary branches and Nations wishes engagement. Address “ACADEMIC,” care vation N EXPERIEN CE D ART TE AC ‘HER R —lady—wishes engagement for teaching Art and Art History. Address ” ART,’ care of the Natton. ARISI. 4N HOME FOR YOUNG LA- dies.—Madame ALYs BARRAULT GIROUX, Bureau des Champs Elysées 49, Paris. HAREES W. STONE, Tutor a Har- —_vard, 68 C hestnut Street, Boston.

School Agencies. MERICAN AND FOREIGN TEACH- ers’ Agency supplies Professors, Teachers, Tutors, Governesses, etc., to Colleges, Schools, and Families. Apply to Mrs. M. J. YOUNG-FULTON. 23 Union Square, New York. _ FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES, 4 Ashburton Street, poste. a Main Street, Hart- 10

—_ 70 Fifth Avenue,N.Y., Wabash Ave., Chicago, a South Spring Street, Los Angeles. Agency a0 ree. E VERETT 0. _ FISK & Co.

HE NEW AMERICAN TEA CHERS’ AGENCY.—Teachers —— positions and those wishing a change at an increased salary should address . B. RuGGLEs & Co. (Palace Hotel Building), Room C, 237 Vine Street, Cincinnati, O. 4 MERICANAND FOREIGN Professors, tutors, governesses, teachers, etc, supplied to colleges, schools, and ree MIRIAM COYRIERE, 150 oth Ave., cor, 20th St., -Y. VATION. AL BL 'TREAU OF EDUCA- i V_ TION, Miss Crostuwait, Prop., cor. Church and High Sts., Nashville, Tennessee. The Leading School and Teachers’ Agency of the South and Southw est

HE ALBERT TEACHERS’ AGENCY, 211 Wabash Ave., Chicago, has now vacancies for Fall at and winter t terms. . J. ALBERT, ] Manager. —

CHE RMERHOR. Vv’, s Ug Oe Se bg “nS Agency. Oldest and best known in the U. Established 1855. 3 East 14th Bt »N Ye HE BRIDGE TEACHERS’ AGEN- cies, 110 Tremont St., Boston, and 211 Wabash Ave., Chicago. Agency Manual free toany address. is valuable in proportion to its An Agency influence. If i merely hears of vacancies ‘and Th sf? is something, but if tells you about them is asked to recom- TTA * » _ - 2s mend a teacher and sane pf vendo nds mends you, that ismore. Ours : * W. BARDEEN, Syracuse, NY

Page 3

Jan. 11, 1894] The Nation. PUBLICATIONS FOR 1893 OF G. P. Putnam’s Sons, New York and London. HISTORY AND BIOGRAPHY. The Story of the Nations. Large i2mo, | fully illustrated, cloth, each $1.50; half leather gilt top, $1.75. 35. The Story of the Tuscan Republics. By Be La DurFy. 36. The Story of Poland. By W. R. MorFity 37. The Story of Parthia. By Geo Raw.inson. Heroes of the Nations. Large 1i2mo, fully tMustrated, cloth, each $1.50; half leather, $1.75. 8. Napoleon, Warrior and Ruler, and the Military Supremacy of Revolutionary France. By W O'CONNOR MORRIS. 9. Henry of Navarre and the Huguenots in France’ By P. F. WiLLert The Leaders in Science. Each, fully il- lustrated, cloth, $1.50. 2. The Life of Louis Agassiz. By Cuar.es F HOLDER. The Writings and Correspondence of A Conflict of Evidence. By Ro Orto LENGUI, author of “An Artist in Criame,” etc Lebo paper, 50 cents; cloth, $1.00 The Home; or, Life in Sweden. By FREDRIKA BREMER. Two volumes, Ifmo, $2.50 : Reprinted from the original edition insued in Isde | by G. P. Putnam, with the authorization of the author The Coral Ship: A Story of the Florida Reef. By Kirk Monn author of “Cab and Ca poase (No. TV. in sg Rail ‘and Water" Sertes) Illustrated. 12mo, $1.25 Diccon the Bold. A Story of the Days of Columbus, By JoHsn R. CORYELL, author of “ Diego Pinzon.” 12mo, illustrated, $1.25 FOLK LORE, ETC | The Light Princess, and Other Fairy THOMAS JEFFERSON. Edited by Pav. LEICESTER | Forp. Uniform with the sects of the Writings of | > om “ - = | Forty Tales from the Arabian Nights. “ Hamilton,” “ Franklin,” Washington.” To bee i leted in 10 vols., Svo, half leather. The set, 850 Limited edition, 750 copies, printed from type. teiees volumes ready. Tales. Ky GEORGE MacDoNaLp Humphrey, Svo, $1.75 The Little Mermaid, and Other Fairy Tales. By HANS ANDERSEN. Illustrated by J. R. We guelin. 4to, $3.00. Illustrated by Maud Pictured by Joun D. Barter. Svo, $2.00. | Chinese Night’s Entertainments. by Old Court Life in France. By FRANCES | ELu0T. Two volumes, illustrated Svo, $4.00. Woman in France during the Eigh- TEENTH CENTURY. By JvuLia KavaNaGu. Two volumes, illustrated, Svo, $4.00. Venice: An Historical Sketch of the REPUBLIC. By Horatio F. Brown. With maps and Plan. Limited edition. Svo, $4.50. The Empire of the Tsars and the Rus- SIANS. By ANATOLE LEROY-BEAULIEU. Translated by Z. A. Ragozin. To be complete in three volumes. Part I. (complete in itself), The Country and Its Inha- bitants. Svo, with maps, $3.00. The Church in the Roman Empire, A.D. 64-170. With Chapters of Later Christian His tory in Asia Minor. By W. H. Ramsay, M.A. Svo, with maps, $3.00. Three Generations of English Women. Memoirs of Susannah Taylor, Sarah Austin, and Lady Duff Gordon. By Janet Ross. With Portraits. New, Revised, and Enlarged Edition. Svo, $2.00. Lorenzo de’ Medici. An Historical Por trait. By E. CARPENTER. 16mo, cloth, $1.00. The Jews of Angevin England. By Jo SEPH Jacoss. (No. VI. inthe series “ English History from Contemporary Writers.”’) 16mo, $1.25. MENTAL SCIENCE AND THEOLOGY, The Gospel and its Earliest Interpre- TATIONS. A Study of the Teaching of Jesus and its Doctrinal Transformations tn the New Testament. By ORELLO Cong, D.D., author of ‘ Gospel Criticism,” ete. Svo, 81.75. The Bible: Its Origin and Growth and ITS PLACE AMONG THE SACRED BOOKS OF FHE WORLD. Together with a list of books for study and reference. With critical comments. By JaBkEZ THOMAS | SUNDERLAND. 12mo, $1.50 An Historical Interpretation of Philo- | | The Works of William Shakespeare. SOPHY. By Jouy Bascom, author of “ Natural The ology.”” 12mo, cloth, $2.00. The Meaning and the [lethod of Life. A Search for Religion in Biology. By GrorGE M. | I 75 | GOULD, A.M., M.D. Svo, $1.75 The flonism of Man; or, The Unity of THE DIVINE AND HUMAN, By Davip A. GoRTOS M.D. Svo, $2.00. The Philosophy of Individuality ; or, THE ONE AND CHE MANY. Ry ANTOINETLE BROWN BLACKWELL. Svo, with diagrams, $3.00 FICTION, A Literary Courtship. By Anna Fuel LER, author of “ Pratt Portraits.” ldmo. Illustrated $1.00. Marked ‘‘Personal.’’ By ANNA KATHA RINE GREEN (Mrs. Charles Rohifs), author of “ The Leavenworth Case,’ etc. 16mo, paper, 50 cents; cloth, $1.00. Harvard Stories. Sketches of the Un dergraduate. By W. K. Post. Third edition. 12mo, 1.25. Holiday Numiéber of ** Notes on New Books, ADELE M. Fievpe. Lilustrated by Chinese Artists vo, $1.75 Voodoo Tales as Told Among the Ne groes of the Southwest. By MARY ALIcla OWEN With an Introduction by Charles Godfrey Leland mag by Julfette A. Owen and Louls Wain Svo, $1. Parchies from Nature. By Mrs. ALrrep Gatry. Two volumes. (First and Sec md Sertes Illustrated by Paul de Longpre Bach $1.75 English Fairy Tales. Second Series Compiled by Jose ppb Jacobs and illustrated by J. D Batten. @vo, $1.75. TRAVET. The Wilderness Hunter, with an Ac count of the Big Game of the United @tates, and Its Chase with Horse, Hound, and Kitle. By hur DORE {OOSEVELT. With {llustrations by Rem “Yanan . Frost Sandham, Faton, and others. Svo, $3.50 Studies of Travel. By E. A. FREEMAN Author of “ The History of Stelly.” I.—Italy. I] —Greece. Each complete in one volume, with frontispiece. 16mo, 75 cts EDUCATIONAL. Outlines of Roman History. By Henny F. PELHAM, Professor of Ancient History in the Un versity of Oxford. 12mo. With maps. 61.7 Manual of Linguistics. A Concise Ac count of General and English Phonology, with Sup plementary Chapters on Kindred Topics. By Jons CLARK, M.A. Sv¥o, $2.00 Orthometry. A Treatise on the Art of Versification and the Technicalities of Poetry, with a New and Complete Rhyming | R. } BREWER, B.A. 12mo, 82.00 Vertebrate Embry ology. - By A. MILNES MARSHA M.D, Pr fe ssor wlogy in «wens } lege, England. Fully tllustra sted svo, § GENERAL LITERATUR? driel Edition. Each P! size, large t trated with and bo t Phis edition will! of which bave thus pest, A Midsu Ve Tu wi the Se is Pa He ir an : lers wi any v Authors and Their Public in Ancient TIME S. A sketct tions, and of the relations witht pal c terary prextucers, from the earliest times t e int ton of nt ir Ry Gro. Haves Prtyam, author of “The Question of Copyright,” ets 1.2 A History wr E English Dre ess, from the Saxon Pertod ¢ ~ ay By HEORGIANNA Hi 2 vols... Sv with 14 stee i plates, $7.50 ‘ ‘ Z ‘ , FY, sof Vations Seri mion applicati The Pottery and Porcelain of the United STATES. Au Histortcal Review of © Cerat Art in America, froin the Faritest Times & Day. Ry Fowrs A. Harner, A.M. H rary ator f the Department of Amertean Pottery ar t lain in the Pennsylvania Mu i ‘ ths. “ over 200 illustrations, $5. Comparative Administrative Law. \» Analvsis of the Adiministrative System, Na sla Lawal f the United States. England rra Germany Ry F ti DNOW, Professs cA trative Law itn Columbta ¢ “ ‘ Literary Gems. mo, with front Plece, morocco, git Cops Fa ? . Fifth Series 1. ideas of Tru t sh House of Life. Ry Rossettl 3 . ‘ By De Quincey 4. The kre N?_ A s v Reals 5 he Stu ipyof Poetry. By Arnot ‘ Conguer. By Gokismitt Knickerbocker Nu gxgets New Volumes WHIST NUGGETS, Papers at W sf amt Whis Players. Compiled by Wa ais. @ The Hiads of Homer. Translated fr the Greek ey Gs ara W . from Flaxman’s deskeen. ant f eck Vases vols., $3.72 Studies by a Recluse. In Cloister Town, and Country Re A sti. KBs An Agnostic’s Apology. By | STEPHEN, author of H rs t a i ary WY 0 The Shrubs of Northeaste: rn America. Ry Cras S, Newna aut Tees ‘\ eastern America, ef sv ustraieat 6 Princetes Sketches. The Storv of Nas aau Hall is 1 Wea act A r tion by mF An tra w P West Nustrated “Y g20 Pictures from Greek Life and Stor y. By Rev ALFRED J. Crreen ’ ireck Children,” et L2mo, tustrated. § Songs of the Orchard By Noxwan R Gate, author of A ine Romance t ivm StL A Country Muse Second Series, cloth The Making of a New spaper. Exp ‘ f Cert ain Representative Ame : i sates Os lated by Themselves and Eidlited by Me ville *ntllips i¥meo, Fi. The Genesis of Art Form. An Fssay in 4 parative Aesthetics. By Gro. S. Raywes an hor of “ Poetry es a Representative Art strated Svo, S225 Ruminations: The Ideal American Lady, and Other Essays. By ALRERT MaTHEWs wl Sieg volk aut a 4 Bund of Papers et 12m i: ONOMIC SCIEN An Introduction to English Economic HISTORY AND THEORY. Ry W ASHLEY, M.A Part ll. Bringing the work down to the end of the Middle Ages. 12mo, $3 American Railroads as bavestenents. Ry S.F. Van Oss. With seven maps, printe lors, showing competitive lines of K allwag in diffe rent parts of the United States. Alx« SOO pages Sen dave The Silver Situation in the United STATES Rv Prof. F. W. Tavssie, author of “ The Tarif History of the United States Questhe ons of the Day ” Series," No. 74 Third editton SVo, 75 cts A Brief History of Panics, and Their Periodical Occurrence in the United States. By Cie MENT J Lak. FEnglished by bDeQourcy W Thon With Explanatory Tables Series, No. 74 Svo, $1.00 The Socia! Contract; or, The Principles of Political Rights Ry JEAN JACQUES Rovusse@at Transiated by Rose M. Harrington, with Introduction and Notes by Edward IL. Walter Svo, $1.50. Prisoners and Paupers. A Study of the Abnormal Increase of Criminals and the Public Burden of Pauperism itn the United States; with a Consideration of the Causes and che Kemedies. By Henry M. Bores, M.A., Svo, with tllustrations, $1.50 Questions of the Day for Young People, Prospectuses of the Story

Page 4

[Vol. 58, No. 1489 MACMILLAN Enamoured. >, & Co.'s And Books Announced for Immediate Publication. THE LOVER’S LEXICON. A Handbook for Novelists, Playwrights, Philosophers and Minor Poets; but especially for the By FREDERICK GREENWOOD. ‘* It is unique in its treatment, delightful in its diction, quiet in its humor, and altogether satisfactory..—New York Herald, New Books Crown 8vo, $1.50. Fourth Edition Fust Ready, The United States: AN OUTLINE OF POLITICAL HISTORY, 1492-1871. By Gotpwin Smita, D.C.L., author of ‘* Canada and the Canadian Question,” ete. With Map. 12mo, cloth. Price, $2.00. “It isa marvel of condensation and lucidity. In no other book is the same field covered so succinctly and well.”"—New York Sun. Third Edition Fust Ready. The Life and Art of Edwin Booth. By WitLiAM WINTER, author of ‘‘Shakespeare’s England,” ‘*Shadows of the Stage,” ete. With 12 full-page portraits in character, reproduced by E. Bier- stadt, and other Illustrations. Crown 8vo, cloth, gilt top. Price, $2 25. ** Destined to take high rank in the long catalogue of important biographies.” —Boston Journal, Anatomy and Physiology for Nurses. By Diana C. Kimeer, Assistant Superintendent of Training School for Nurses, Blackwell's Island, and Lovise Darcue. With numerous Illustrations. vo. Just Ready. Mental Development in the Child and the Race. By J. Mark Baupwin, Ph.D., Stuart Professor of Experimental Psychology in the College of New Jersey, author of ** Handbook of Psychology.*’ Crown 8vo = Just Ready. Chronological Outlines of American Literature. By Secpgen L. Wartrcoms, A M. Witha Preface by BranpeR MatTTHeEws, Pro- . fessor of Literature in Columbia College. Uniform with ‘* Chronological Outlines of English Literature.” 12mo. Just Ready. Second Edition Fust Ready. Seventy Years of Irish Life. Being the recollections of W. R. LE FANU. One vol., crown &vo, cloth, gilt top, $1.75. “This delightful book. . . . It is long since we have seen a book so full of entertaining matter as the ‘Seventy Years of Irish Life,’ by W. R. Le Fanu This volume is stuffed as full of anecdotes asa Christmas pudding is with plums.” The Sun. Fust Published. Vol. I11, New Edition. The Diary of Samuel Pepys. With Lord BRAYBROOKE’s Notes. Edited, with additions, by Henry B Wueart- LEY. F.S.A. 12mo, cloth, Vol. IfT., $1.50. Vols. I. and IL. also ready. Price, $1.50 each. *,* Also an edition on large paper, limited to 100 copies, sold only in sets, $5.00 per volume, THE DAWN OF ASTRONOMY: A STUDY OF THE ASTRONOMY AND TEMPLE WORSHIP OF THE ANCIENT EGYPTIANS. With numerous Illustrations and full-page Plates. By J. Norman LOcKyYERr, F.R.S., author of ‘‘The Meteoritic Hypothesis,” ‘‘The Chemistry of the Sun,” ete. Royal 8vo. Just Ready. THE EVANSTON COLLOQUIUM Lectures on Mathematics. Delivered before Members of the Congress of Mathematics he d in connection with the World’s Fair in Chicago, at Northwestern University, Evanston, lll., by Fetrx Kueiw. Reported by Professor Zwier of the University of Michigan. 8vo. Just Ready. Town Life in the Fifteenth Century. By Mrs. JoHn RicHARD GREEN, author of ‘“ Henry the Second * (Twelve Eng ish Statesmen Series.) Two vols ,8vo. Just Ready. A Commentary on the Writings of Henrik Ibsen. By H. H. Boyvesen, Professor of Germanic Languages aud Literature at Colum- bia College, author of ** Goethe and Schiller,’ ** Essays on German Litera ture,” ete. Crown 8vo. $2.00. The Raiders. By 8S. R. Crockett, author of * The Stickit Minister, and Some Common Men.” 12mo. Just Ready. The Physical Review. A Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics. Conducted by Epwarp L. NicHo.ts and Ersest Merritt. Published bi-monthly for Cornell Uni versity. Single copies, 50 cents; annual subscription. $3.00 Being Some Passages in the Life of the Faa Lord, and Earl of Little Egypt. | NEW NOVELS. THE KING OF SCHNORRERS. Grotesques and Fantasies. By I. ZANGWILL, author of ‘‘ Children of the Ghetto,” etc. With Illustrations. 12mo. Just Ready. Catherine Furze. By Mark RUTHERFORD. Edited by his friend, REUBEN ScHapcorrT. 12mo, $1.00, Periodicals. THE PSYCHOLOGICAL REVIEW. A new Bi-Monthly Publication under the Editorship of Professors BALDwrn (Princeton University) and CatTrE Lt (Columbia College). First number to be issued in January. Single copies, 75 cents; annual subscription, $4.00. The Portfolio. An Artistic Periodical. Edited by P. G Hamerton. Single copies, 75 cents; annual subscription, $7 50 *,* With the January number the Portfolio assumes a new and improved form, calculated to render it more attractive MACMILLAN & CO., 66 Fifth Avenue, New York. ene error

Page 5

The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, JANUARY 11, 1894. —— —— —— elite The Week. THE tariff debate has begun at last. Mr. Wilson’s opening speech is of a very high order. He begins by showing what has become of the vast surplus left in the Treasury by the first Cleveland Ad ministration. The cash balance in the Treasury at that time was $185,000,000. This was the amount that Secretary Win dom acknowledged to have received from Secretary Fairchild. Where is it now ? What has become of an annual surplus of §105,000,000? Why is the Gov- ernment confronting a deficit of $28,000,- 000, or $50,000,000, or some other unknown amount, notwithstanding the fact that the sinking-fund appropriation, amount- ing to nearly $50,000,000, has been drop ped from the public accounts ? Mr Wil son does not indulge in any railing accu sations on thissubject, but points out the undeniable fact that the present strained condition of the Treasury is not due to the party or the policy that he represents. He shows, too, that the arrangement of the national finances under the Repub- lican régime of the past four years has been such as not only to deplete the Treasury but to increase the taxes on the mass of the people, and to create boun- ties and privileges to particular classes. . Looking at these particular interests, and especially at those of wool, coal, and iron ore, Mr. Wilson makes an un answerable argument in favor of put ting all of these articles on the free list and of reducing correspondingly the duties on the articles into which they enter. The great merit of Mr. Wil- son’s speech is the fearlessness with which he attacks these intrenched shams. He shows how they have grown bolder and more impudent with the lapse of time, until everybody who is protected at all thinks that he ought to have a prohibitory duty, so that the consumer shall not buy anything ex cept at his shop. It is upon this beautiful theory that a duty on coal is still demanded. Nobody considers coal-mining an infant industry. No body pretends that coal can be mined more cheaply in Nova Scotia than in this country. Yet we are asked for aduty on coal that will enable railroads to car ry it from the western slope of the Al- leghanies to the eastern boundary of Maine, and this in the name of protec tion. This is only one of the monstrosi ties of the present system which Mr Wilson has struck in the face. The value of his speech consists more in its spirit than in its detailed analysis. It assures us that the bill which he has presented is to be passed without unne cessary delay, and in spite of the new non-voting tactics adopted by the Re- publicans. There is some danger of the latter making themselves — ridiculous If they persistently etface themselves from the list of yeasand nays, the public may forget that there is any such party in the House The letter of Mr. Andrew Carnegie on tariff reform which the Tribune pub lished on Monday, is something lke the report of the Tariff Commission of 1882-1888. That report was in part the work of H. W. Oliver, jr, Mr. Carnegie’s fellow-laborer and capital ist in the iron and steel trade, and almost as distinguished as he. Mr. Car negie now stands where Mr. Oliver stood ten years ago. Both maintain that it Is not a mere blind, unreasoning outery that leads to the political movement for lower duties, but that there is a sound conservative sentiment at the bottom of it which ought to be respected They agree also in thinking that Ameri can industry, even from the protection ist standpoint, has more to gain than to lose by acquiescing In a moderate mea sure like the Wilson bill or the Taritf Commission bill of 1883 than in an unceasing battle and the uncertainty which attends it. Upon this point Mr Carnegie is very strong. The Democrats, he says, if allowed to pass their bill, would not attack their own tariff. Somme years of peace would be secured, and that would be worth far more than a temporary victory to be followed by a new agitation. Of course the is greatly disturbed by this view, becaus: it wants a tariff for polities only It has already been announced that the Carnegie iron and steel works have taken the place formerly held by the Britishers as bugaboos to the American manu facturers. In other words, the Carne gies have so far outstripped all their do mestic competitors In the con } leteness and perfection of their machinery that the latter need protection against Carne gie rather than against John Bull. This is especially true in Pittsburgh, where we are told that the condition of the poor and of the unemployed is ren- dered worse every day by the continued operation of the Carnegie rolling-mills The reason is that he does work at such low rates that other mills cannot make any money. This may be true, but the tariff supplies no remedy for such a con dition. It is a condition which has its parallel in many other places and trades Contining our present view of it to the iron and steel trade, there is no room for i doubt that this country can hold its ow: with Great Britain or any other natior on terms of equality as regards the pri cipal products, and that the tariff n longer has any protective element in it except as to a few specialties Nobods who has to compete with Carnegie need fear competition with anybody in En: land The latest Hawatian news leaves annexationists with their thirst for} still unslaked. Minister Whillis’s ou “Good day, gentlemen it the clos his conference with the provisional gov ernment, was an indescribably bass betrayal of those who had their gory headlines and their articles of a peact ment all ready In his statement regretted the delay which had ed the action of the United St but truthfully satd that it had bee: avoidable If the decision wil communicated to the provisional gov ernment on December ty uld have beer made on March (9, or even on Apt Ivor May 10, there is no doubt that it would have been speedily acquiesced in At that time the attitude of all parties in Hawatt was that of awaiting the tind ing of the President of the United States as arbitrator But the laps« ei en cessary for the President's fu and pa tient investigation left opportunity for the provisional government to strengthen itself sothat it is not surprising that it should now decline to relinquish power On what grounds it bases this refusal will not be known, apparently until President Dole’s answer reaches Washington Meanwhile, Minister Thurs ton, who left this country with the ex pressed determination to set up an in dependent Hawaiian republic, now an nounces that nothing of the kind will be attempted. The present ‘ semi-Ame rican government will be continued. That is a good phrase. The \meri can” part of the government consists in owning the land and being on the official pay rolls, and the ‘* semi’ part consists in denying the right of suffrage, in taxing the majority without allowing them representation, and in setting up an oligarchy by the aid of a standing army and calling it a republican form of government We take pleasure in noting the Out look’s denial that it holds to ‘‘one code of ethics for individuals and another for nations.”’ It now tells us that ‘the analogy between the nation and the in dividual is perfect,’ in the sense that ‘if the nation has done a wrong, it ought to be ready to rectify that wrong But it goes on to say that the analogy is unsound both in logic and in morals in the Hawaiian business, ‘ because

Page 6

12% The Nation. [Vol. 58, No. 1489 the nation gave Mr. Cleveland no au- thority to determine whether the wrong had been perpetrated, or to set it right.’’ What this means, unless it be that the Hawaiian revolution of Ja- nuary, 1893, was not an issue in the Presidential election of November, 1892, we confess we cannot see. There is no question that the nation gave Mr. Cleveland the Presidency, and with it the constitutional right and duty to initiate or withdraw treaties, appoint and receive ministers, and in general direct our foreign and diplomatic polli- cy. The Outlook does not specify, and cannot, a single particular in which the President has gone beyond the powers given him by the Constitution, yet it talks as glibly as the partisan press of his ‘usurpation of power.’’ That ap- pears to us to be unsound both in logic and in morals. The Rev. C. M. Hyde of Honolulu, ‘‘ the only resident missionary of the A. B. C. F. M.,’’ whose treatment of Father Da- mien brought down on him the scathing comments of Robert Louis Stevenson, says, in his letter to Mr. Blount, that his instructions are, ‘‘to induce in the Hawai- ians more of the sentiments of personal independence and self-reliance, and to de- velop that strength of character which shall enable them to withstand the un- favorable influences which have hitherto depressed them, and still exist, from their contact with so large a foreign popula- tion.’’ He has beensalaried for this work ever since 1877 by the A. B.C. F. M. It is a work which, we need hardly say, would require infinite tact, deep sym- pathy with the people,thorough compre- hension of their character on its best side, and a style of living which would be an assurance of disinterestedness. All these qualifications are apparently wanting in Mr. Hyde’s case. He livesin a large and comfortable house, which, as Mr. Stevenson says, is ‘‘ a cause of mocking in the streets of Honolulu.” This house, too, he admits, was sup- plied by the capitalistic class of foreigners, or the ‘‘ missionary element,” which the native Hawaiians regard as their enemies and ae. That there must be some foundation for this prejudice, we judge from the fact that while Americans and Europeans own 1,052,492 acres of the land of the country, the natives own only 257,457, and the 861,800 acres left to the Government is mostly of poor quality. The monthly pay-roll of the provisional government, too, before they began to weed out, showed that exactly the same sum was paid to American officials as to twice that number of native Hawaiian offi- cials. Such facts as these may be ac- counted for on grounds not discredit- able to the foreigners—although the ex- perience of mankind is against this view—but they naturally keep alive a deep distrust, in the native mind, of the ‘‘missionary element.’’ Under these circumstances what are we to think of the policy of sending, at the ex- pense of American Congregationalists, “to induce in the Hawaiians more of the sentiments of personal independ- ence and self-reliance,’ etc., a man who lives among and makes common cause with those whom they regard as their enemies, and—this is the worst of it—who abuses publicly the people he is sent to evangelize, denounces their manners and morals, and belittles their intellectual capacity? It may. be well to have this done, but think of its being done by asalari d missionary. That he has succeeded in retaining his place so long under such conditions shows how much the machinery of the American Board needs overhauling. The Board settled, or rather agreed to leave un- settled, the question of the future of the heathen in the next world. We think it would be well now to examine the men- tal attitude of the living heathen to- wards its agents. The Rev. W. L. Sheldon sent out 500 letters to employers of labor in St. Louis, asking them the following questions. *“(1.) What has been the average number of your employees in ordinary times at this season of the year ? ‘*(2.) How many have you in your employ now ? “(3.) How much of a reduction in wages has been made in your line of business ¢ ‘*(4.) What percentage of your employees do you think have been accustomed to save something from their wages for a future emergency ¢ **(5.) Do you think conditions are growing better or worse ?”’ To these letters he received 254 answers, from every kind of trade and business. To the first two questions the answer was 47,049, and the decrease in this number owing to the financial crisis or anything else was 6,938. Five establishments only reported themselves as having ‘ shut down.”’ Inthe great majority there had been no reduction in wages. About 11,- 000 to 12,000 out of 40,000 are supposed to save something out of their wages. This is the kind of work which ought to have been done here long ago by some- body. We dare not say that the condi- tion of St. Louis is a fair specimen of that of other cities, but if it be, it will be rgadily seen that the situation is not as bad as it has seemed. Judge Dean of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania rendered an interesting de- cision last week on the question of boy- cotting. There was a memorable strike of the building trades of Pittsburgh in 1891, which brought building operations there to a practical standstill for two months over the question of nine hours’ wages for eight hours’ work. Most of the local dealers in building materials ee ee entered into an agreement not to sell materials to contractors who gave employment to strikers. One contractor thus deprived of supplies brought suit to test the question whether such an agree ment constituted an illegal boycott. In the lower court he secured a verdict of $1,500. This the Supreme Court re- verses. Judge Dean points out that, while the strike of the laborers referred to, and their efforts to prevent men from working, would have been an indictable offence under the common law in Penn sylvania, acts passed by the Legislature in 1869, ’72,’76, and ’91 gave the men a right to strike, and to prevent others from working except by the use of force. The court reasons thus: “The moment the Legislature relieved one class, and by far the larger number of citizens of the commonwealth, from the common-law prohibitions against combinations to raise the price of labor and by a combination the price was raised, down went the foundation on which common-law conspiracy was based as to that particular subject.” Furthermore, the deduction is made that ‘* however unchanged may be the law as to combinations of employers to inter- fere with wages where such combina- tions take the initiative, they certain- ly do not depress a market when they combine to resist a combination to arti ficially advance price.’’ The meaning of all this in simple words is, that it is a poorrule that will not work both ways, and that when labor organizations ap- peal to the law-makers for some special provision in their interest, they must not complain if the courts extend the same protection to employers. The lagest action of the striking Dan- bury hatters, who recently expressed their mortal dread of being forced into slavery if they went back to work, is to pass resolutions against any of their weaker members who may be induced to desert theirranks. Their threat ‘‘not to speak to nor associate with any such persons ’’? might be endured with Chris- tian resignation, one would think, but they go further and declare: “That, while living within and not break- ing any of the laws of the State or of the United States, we will endeavor by all proper means to make the lives of such persons in this town so unpleasant that they will seek their abode elsewhere, in a place filled with their own kind.” This seems indiscreet in those who are appealing to the public to prevent them from falling into slavery. They never, no, never, will be slaves, but they have no objection whatever to being slave-driv ers and cracking their whips over those whose one offence is that they want to support themselves by honest and free labor. In discussing last week the ballot laws which have been enacted in thirty-six States of the Union, we said that in nine teen of them the Massachusetts method of arranging the names of candidates in

Page 7

Jan. 11, 1894] alphabetical order in groups under each oftice had been followed. As the laws were originally passed this was the case, but within the past year or more in tive of these laws the alphabetical order has been abandoned, and the party-col- umn order adopted in its place. The States making this change are Vermont, Wisconsin, Washington, North Dakota, and South Dakota. The list of States should stand, therefore, as concerns the blanket ballot, as follows: With alpha betical order, 14; with party column, 19 Of the three remaining States with bal lot laws, New York, New Jersey, and Connecticut, all of which have separate party ballots, the two former are likely to change to the blanket ballot this vear —whether to alphabetical order or party column remains to be seen, Municipal elections were held in the province of Ontario last week, and at the same time a plebiscite was taken on the question of prohibition. The vote was not on the adoption of any form of law, but for the purpose of determining whether the people desire the Legislature to enact a prohibitory statute. The result was an overwhelm ing majority in favor of prohibition, estimated as high as 100,000 in the whole province. Not only country vil lages but cities voted in the affirma tive, the majority in Toronto being more than 2,000. In these elections, for the first time in the history of the province, women possessing cer- tain property qualifications had the privilege of voting on the liquor ques tion, but only a small minority of those thus qualified—1,136 out of about 5,000 in Toronto—went to the polls. The ma jority for prohibition throughout the province was so great that the Legisla ture can hardly fail to enact it Despatches from New Zealand give the details of the first parliamentary elections within the British empire held on a mixed (male and female) franchise The New Zealand women, as a new addition to the electorate, have, as a body, confirmed the political opinions of the men by whom they had hitherto been represented, and to this extent their vote may be called conservative While the data at hand make it impossi- ble to discérn minor intluences due to the fresh body of voters, there is no trace whatever of the reactionary et fects which, it is commonly assumed, women willimport into politics. The New Zealand Government which has just re ceived endorsement is the most radical that the colony has had for many years the ministry were returned with fifty four members in a House of seventy-f of whom four are Maoris, or native met bers; thirty-three of the old members failed of reélection, and i The tion of the lists suggests that the new Nation. electors have taken their duties seri ously, and exercised judgment in the Among the issues of the election were secular edu selection of candidates cation and local option, bu even on the liquor question the women have | shown much less partisanship than was | expected, as but twenty four of the fifty-four Government members ire known to be in favor of a direct veto on licenses by a majority vote of the local electors. It is worth mention also that but one prominent member of the Opposition failed to retain his seat To quote the London 7imes: ‘The result decisively scatters any fears of a sex vote, and testities to the discrimination and wholesome division of opinion of the new electorate.” The wrath of the anarchists in Euroy. is being made to work for international amity and peace in unexpected ways When the President of the French Chamber was able to read despatches of sympathy, on the occasion of the bomb throwing, from the Speakerof the Hous of Commons and from Government of cials in Italy and Austria and Switzer land, while Emperor William’s unofticial expression of horror at the crime Was in the newspapers, the general applause wit nessed toa spirit of concord between the nations quite unwonted. Already ther: is talk of an international movement or agreement for the suppression of dyna miters, though it is doubtful if this will come to anything more than a better un derstanding in regard to the speedy ex tradition of persons charged with anarch istic crimes against life and property The important thing is, the growing con sclousness that the whole social order upon which modern civilization rests Is involved, and that this rises in impor tance far above any international feuds or jealousies. The anarchists themselves cannot complain of this result, as one of their tenets is the folly of war They have, in fact, brought upon themselves much obloquy, as men without a country,’ because they have argued that the reconstitution of society after their ideas Was more important than anythi: that passed by the name of patriotism and because their ‘ atechisms st™ cially prepared for distribution in the barracks, have adv ated the retusal to | obev orders calling upon the soldiers of | one country to attack those of another Although Mr. Gladstone’s age makes him now one of the wonders of the cen tury, there is no question that it is the main cause of the slow progress of legis- lation in England It is generally a knowledged that if he were dead or dis ibled, the Liberal party would undergo it least a temporary eclipse. and proba bly a permanent division. The Radicals Labor party would split off from the . *)> ~*? Whigs ar th nt ul Tones would have execut t it least one Par nt It is very it 1 nat whether { I wiasel ] ‘ care eatlv al it ho ‘ { i cannot dispense with ¢t tw ir votes ind thew are « raw ‘ } 1 ier into | eving t bnecessarv Ra iT ‘ I } ‘ thev wou continu { t Mr (rindstone swt wa s t not easily answ l ( t se i tt { rive? | and prot i VexXa t \ ( i t lmportance to his party " hey therefore, ev s ay al obstruction ¢f hewst t ‘ They kept t} Par miost to the ist t t home rule | ' { t { wished longe: t t now obstructing t | . undoubtediv with t x ta t ins ul tN iV 1 Vs premier il t uk \ l s Teaiv . ‘ though I s ~ sf ‘ ria t if x { ( \ tives at atu \ ‘ t t t pass rT power Rives Is how a att ‘ tix oT as er to tl a * \ st stoft 1 try thre tt i 1 th councets | i \ all t t] rar e int v i Their persistent opy tien to the s, therefore ‘ Teality at thi home rule b wl av be rodu in the spring this is put out of tl wav. Orif the ] e rule | snot ir tr iced in the spring. there iv ea issolution in tl irlv su er, and the Grand Old Mar wv go to the country with such feathers in his « ap) as the « } vers ila ty 1 ist efeated v the Lords, and the paris] incils bill Should he, with these two bills and the home-rule bill before the country, win another election, the passage of the home-rule bill would be almost a cet tainty because thie chief argument against it—that the country had not con sidered it—would be no longer avail able It is not to be wondered at, then, that the Conservatives should be ‘ play ing against an old man’s life,” as Mr. Gladstone has more than once said they were Hlis own knowledge of this fact makes more astonishing than ever his strength of nerve To sit night after night opposite to a large body of men who are watching eagerly for the slight- est symptom of weakness or infirmity, and to whom his death would be the most welcome news they could receive, nist be an ordeal from which youth and perfect health might well shrink. To face it successfully at eighty-four, with the cares of an empire resting on his shoul ders, is probably the most wonderful dis play of vitality recorded in history Cedi $ be

Page 8

ETSI peecegrrerser eeer rs 2 4. The Nation. [Vol. 58, No. 1489 THE NATIONAL FINANCES. THE comparative statement of receipts and expenditures of the United States during the month of December and also during the half year is as follows: RECEIPTS. 1SH2. 1803. December, .... . $33,066,963 f 22,812,027 Halt Year... «00+ 14,251,040 151,7:5,444 EXPENDITURES. December ................. $33,407,900 gg 2 Sa Sern 100, 102,830 $30,058,269 18,379,773 This shows a shortage in revenue, as compared with last year, of nearly $11,- 000,000 for the month, and of more than $42,000,000 for the half year, while ex- penditures have varied less than $1,000,- 000 in the half year. The public-debt statement, issued si- multaneous!ly, shows a net cash balance of $90,875,555, all of which, except $9,483,955, is the remains of the green- back redemption fund, which was accu- mulated by a special sale of bonds in 1877-8 for a particular purpose. In other words, the Government is now meeting its daily expenses in part with money borrowed at 4 per cent. interest. No so- phistry can disguise this fact, nor can anybody pretend or imagine that new taxes can be put in working order in time to relieve the Treasury or to stop this shrinkage of the gold reserve. On the contrary, there is every reason to be- lieve that the deficit of revenue for the full year will reach $76,000,000, and that the gold reserve will be reduced to $35,- 000,000 on the 80th day of June, unless remedial measures are taken meanwhile. Fortunately there is no outflow of gold at the present time, and, therefore, little danger of alarm in the public mind. If there should be such an outward move- ment, it would be necessary for Congress to act at once to replenish the Treasury by some form of borrowing, and, indeed, that resort, in our opinion, cannot be long delayed. The facts were presented to Congress by Secretary Carlisle on the 19th of De- cember. There was not time to do any- thing before the holiday recess, yet the interval might have been well employed by the committee on ways and means in coming to some decision on the points pre- sented inthesecretary’s report. Instead of this a majority of the Democratic mem- bers have voted in favor of an income tax of 2 per cent. on individual incomes above $4,000, and also for a tax on the income of corporations and an increase of the tax on cigarettes, the estimated re- ceipts of all of which are about $42,000,- 000. Shall this internal tax bill be attach- ed to the tariff bill, or be left to make its own way on its own merits—to stand or fall by itself? Upon this point we have the very decided opinion that if it is patched upon the tariff bill, it will pull that measure down and defeat both. Internal-revenue bills and tariff bills have in almost every instance been pass- ed separately, yet there are precedents for tying them together. The tariff bill of 1883 was one of the latter kind, but it be- came so, not by the choice of the two houses, but through a_ parliamentary tangle. If the committee should attempt to carry an income tax on the back of a tariff bill now, itis probable that a num- ber of Democrats would deem them- selves absolved from any party obligation to support a measure thus weighted, and would vote against the whole, in obedience to the demands of their con- stituents. This would disintegrate the party even if it did not defeat the bill, whereas if it should defeat the bill altogether, it would kill the party. The people would say that the De- mocrats had been preaching tariff re- form for twenty years, and had _ suc- ceeded in making it the distinctive if not the sole issue in politics, and had finally carried the country on that issue, but were not able, even with the House, Senate, and Executive in their hands, to carry their ideas into effect. What else could follow but the trampling of such a party under foot ? Since the Government really has no money of its own at present, but is living on the greenback redemption fund, the first step to be taken would seem to be some provision for raising a loan in an honorable way. Upon this point our es- teemed contemporary the Cincinnati Southwest thinks that there would be danger in the plan of giving the secre- tary of the treasury power to issue ex- chequer bills, or interest-bearing Trea- sury notes, at any time, to meet short- ages of revenue. It says: “During Mr. Cleveland’s first administra- tion it was a surplus of a hundred millions, and now it is a deficit of similar magnitude that we have to cope with. For almost a gene- ration our Congresses have never cared a straw whether our revenues balanced our expendi- tures. With the aimost irresistible energy which every Congressman develops in the di- rection of extravagant appropriations for his ‘deestrict,’ we fear that it would be bad policy to make running into debt so easy.” We think that all experience since the close of the war shows that the danger lies in the existence of a surplus, not in the power to borrow money. It was the great surplus left by Mr. Cleveland’s first administration that incited the pension-agents and contractors for pub- lic buildings and internal improvements and everybody else to ‘‘go for it.’’ They did go for it and they made short work with it. Theyemptied the treasury in short order. Now, does anybody sup- pose that this looting would have taken place if there had been nothing to loot? Would the Billion-Dollar Congress have dared to pass those bills if it had been necessary to borrow the money to pay the appropriations ? Assuredly not. There is nothing that the American people are so much averse to as borrow- ing, and there is nothing that they give so little heed to as spending a surplus. THE GRAVER EVILS OF THE INCOME TAX. THE discussion of the proposal to levy an income tax on all incomes above $4,000 has mostly proceeded on the lines of ex- pediency, fiscal and partisan. Looked at solely from that point of view, the pro- posed tax cannot be defended, as it is perfectly certain to prove inquisitorial in operation and wasteful and diminish- ing in collection, while nothing can be clearer than that it would be fatal to any party making itself responsible for it. But there are other aspects of the matter which are far more important to those who watch our social and politi- cal development with anxiety, and which, to them, are decisive of the case. That it would be apiece of unblush- ing class legislation even its advocates do not deny. Indeed, that very fact is what commends the tax to them. They want to get at a class of men who, they say, do not contribute to the Government in proportion to their means, and to put the screws on them. They assert that the tax would be highly *‘ popular,” and thereby, as Congressman Cockran has truly said, confess that it is unjust. It could be popular only because it ap- peared to the masses to relieve them and to make a comparatively few citizens sweat. That is class legislation of the most vicious sort. Beside it the bounty and protective laws which we already have, and which the present Congress was elected to abolish, are innocence and equity personified. The Democratic party floated into power on the wave of indignation which the favoritism of Republican legislation had aroused, and if it now proceeds to give us laws of which the little finger is thicker than the loins of tariff and bounties, it will find, unlike the poet, that there are many who fear the wag ging of an gss’s ears, and will have neither part nor lot with it. The ever-increasing demands of the protected classes would be nothing com- pared to the accelerating evils of such socialistic legislation. To set off by themselves a class of citizens who may be considered fair game for demagogues, would be an experiment of which the issue could only be disastrous. If the people having anincome above $4,000 can be spoliated to the extent of 2 per cent., why not 5 or 10 or 50? What check would there be on national extravagance when the wealth of the entire country could be drawn upon without limit ? And, conversely, if the Democratic party has suffered and our politics been cor- rupted by the large money contributions of the protected manufacturers to cam- paign funds, what an orgy of vote-buy- ing and legislature-purchasing would be sure to result when all the large property- owners of the country were driven to lavish political outlay in order to protect themselves from spoliation ! What could ballot-reform or corrupt-practices acts sake anit 22 2 Ra hh Seasons

Page 9

Sh a eis Shaya Regina sre Jan. 11, 1894] do to prevent the demoralizing irrup- tion of the moneyed classes into politics, who would always be ready to spend one-quarter of their all in order to save half of it % It is said the rich largely escape tax ation under customs laws and internal- revenue statutes. This is by no means so Clear as is often assumed, though it may be admitted that, under the in genious arrangements of McKinley, the poorer classes are disproportionately taxed. But federal taxation is not the only kind, is not the most important kind, of taxation in this country. State and municipal taxation surpasses it in amount many times over. Who pays this tax, and escapes it % Everybody knows that it is the large estates and the middle classes which this burden falls, and that the poor are almost entirely freed from it. Here is another powerful argu ment against the income tax, that it tends to exalt the national government over the local government, to extend the mis chievous idea that the federal govern ment and federal politics are the only things for the citizen to concern himself about, and that all legislation must more and more be confided to a great central power which insensibly shades off into the all-wise and benevolent State of the socialists. Finally, it is said that, even if all this is true, the aggregation of wealth in private hands is so great adanger that it must be attacked at all hazards and by any means. This is a thoroughly Popu list position, theoretically, and, practi cally, it completely overlooks the means by which wealth and its blessings are, in the long run, invariably diffused through the community. If a rich man is a niggard, the chances are ten to one that his sons will be spendthrifts, and a hundred to one that his grandsons will be, if the family lasts so long as the third generation. The devil, or Providence, as one chooses to consider it, has a fateful way of breaking up great properties in this country, so that, looking merely at the typical miserly rich man whom the Populist is aching to get his taxing hands upon, it is certain that, all in good time, ‘ distribution will undo ex cess and each man have enough.”’ On the other hand, the philanthropic rich and the effect on them of laws aimed at their property are altogether left out of the Populist account. Yet it is certain that they give up every year of their wealth for the public good, if not for wasteful legislation and for socialistic schemes of state industries, who upon mostly sums of money far vaster than any system of taxation could possibly extort forthem. Take Mr. Rockefeller, for in stance. He is a man for whom, person ally, we have no particular admiration But he is precisely the kind of man growing rich out of public franchises, whom the Populists have in mind as fit The subjects for spoliation Nation. Yet to Chicago University alone he has given, since its foundation, upwards of $3,500,000, while his other charities during the same time must bring the total up to $5,000,000 Could any such sums have been wrung from him by any conceivable system of taxation? On the other hand, if he and men like him were singled out for spe cial and onerous taxes, would not the certain effect be to dry up the streams of It ought to their public benefactions % be clearly understood that if the wealthy classes are to be set off by themselves as subjects of burde nsong and increasing taxation, the result will be sure to be, partly through diminishing their ability and more by diminishing their good will, to cut off the support of hospitals and libraries and museums and colleges and churches, for which now such large and constant demands are made upon their generosity THE REPORT IGAINST MR. BLOWER HORN IT is unfortunate for Mr. Hornblower and for the country that his rejection by the Senate committee should have po litical importance, but such importance it has him have never been serious. To say that he is young for the place is to disregard many precedents and to err grossly about human maturity. A man who at forty-two is not fit for any place calling for judgment, knowledge, and discre tion is sure never to be fit at all. The cases are, indeed, rare in which any merit after that age. It is lite meridian of life. He may advancement based on to a man rally the subsequently have a larger practice. but he cannot deserve it more. We should be indeed fortunate if we could get al l our federal judges at that age. so that we should have a fair prospect of thirty } | years of service from them on the bench The objections to him touching the | nature and amount of his practice, hav: been equally trivial. They have been urged in the main by two obscure law yers whose enmity he has excited in the course of his’ practice, and who have gone to heavy expense in printing and travelling in order to vilify him. The opinion of the bar of this citv and State has been unmistakably on his side. We believe that a vote of Mr. Hornblower’s own profession would place him among the digniss Moreover, he will lose with all «the Supreme bench by either Mr. Cleveland nothing by comparison appointments to the hitherto made or Mr. Harrison, and this we say while ing that Mr. Harrison's appoint ments were exceptionally good What. then, h combination of causes. It cannot be is led to his rejection? A forgotten that he was one of two lawyers whose presence on the commit The professional objections to} comes | tee of the Bar Association which inves ticated the election frauds of ist Vea Maynard specially asked for lt was therefore, a deep mortification to May nard and his partisans, famaliariy known as * the Hill crows when these two lawyers joined in tl inti Mavi report It isa cAaradinai ! ant tthe rupt politics in which Hill and revel, that not onlwvsl ana ne ! be deserted, but that ar t T s vlad never be forgive: Thev were. t refore bound by the omstitution f tt ring not only to 1 inant M for the Court of Appe ter any of his judges on w the could lay hands. Th revenge are few, for. we \ ber of the committee ts or is likely to be any political office It wa . Mr. Hornblowers ev lected for a polca ve wl within the range = ‘ lee The rt .’ { s t Which assumes that the who gets Into that vow the public good in) passit : rhea tions made from his own Stat tle powerfully ace t mation ar et ting if But there wer t . just as powertlu w t wo Ish to t al t ‘ N of pul spirit Senate } sides rt rres t AVS are gone out of it | W t t are all engaged i: sta t kind ot } irtisa pe t kv Sonat Lioanr who is supp t s eu the great tr s t ty yt i vou pte s 1 \ ir I with stirring up strife n the Der crate } irty than In provi Tha ood judges for the Supreme bench In other words. the tari?, being regarded by so wmv men as Aa quest 1 rf property produces a bitterness and unscrupulous ness in everybody wl has an in terest in it, which destrovs all real regard for anv function of the gov ernment which does not propose to till his pockets There is nothing sa ered for a high-tarifi in When brought to bay Ewill beat Wells if I have to mortgage the: lil sald a Connecticut manufacturer, and doubtless many a Senator would help put «a May Supreme Court if he nard in the were sure it would embarrass the President or increase the number It isa notorious fact them of his enemies that a large number of to-day occupy themselves in trying to find out what he wants in order to prevent his getting it. He has not grown in the alfec tions of politic al men since his election On the contrary the hatred which led them to scout the idea of his nomination and caused them to witness his election with dismay,has been greatly aggravated by his reappearance in the presidential chair

Page 10

26 The Nation. [Vol. 58, No. 1489 We should like to stop here, but it is due to the history of our time to say that the President has done little or nothing either to disarm hostility or to increase the number of his friends. He is not ‘*magnetic,’’ and if we said he had win ning manners, we should depart widely from the truth. Ever since he came in- to oftice, he has almost studiously ig- nored his chief supporters of 1884, 1888, and 1892. He has not sought their coun- sel, and he has apparently tried to forget that they ever served him. His allusions to the civil-service reformers in his message to Congress and in his letter to Mr. Van Alen were very unfortunate coming from a gentleman who owed them so much. The notion, too, which at times has seemed to possess him, that he could in any way consis- tent with his character and principles conciliate his enemies in this State, showed a surprising simplicity in a gen- tleman who had lived among them so long. Either he or they would have to undergo a complete change of heart in order to live together in amity or to work in concert. A very small experience of them, together with a very small modicum of worldly wisdom, would seem to have prescribed to him, when he took office, the propriety of fostering the devotion of those who com- pelled his nomination and secured his election. They were what is best in the Democratic party as well as in this com- munity, and the only men who can give the Democratic party any future after Mr. Cleveland’s career is closed. The no- tion that Hill and Murphy and their kind can ever commend that party to national favor or acceptance is surely a great hallucination. It must live, if it is to live, by the presence in it of such men as Mr. Cleveland and his anti-snap- pers, who alone saved it from total wreck at the last election. Everybody else in it was totally discredited with the coun- try at large. NEWSPAPER SOCIETY. AN evening journal in this city received the following by special messenger a few days ago: ‘*Srr: In publishing names of attendants at the Charity will you kindly mention Mr. and Mrs. ! If you mention costumes, Mrs. - in pink and Nile novelty satin ‘décolle- té,’ old lace, diamond ornaments. We were late and missed the newspaper men. If there is any charge, kindly let me know by bearer, and greatly oblige. ‘‘ Signed by Mr. ———. ” What is interesting about this is the belief it reveals that some portion of the public carefully peruses the lists of people at charity and other public balls, notes who was there, and makes a men- tal image of the costumes. But this again is based on a still profounder faith, that by getting into the newspapers you get into ‘‘society.”’ If the public only knew the extent to which the givers of teas, receptions, and little gatherings of all sorts coéperate with the reporters in getting an account of these festivities into the ‘‘ society column ’’ of the morn- ing papers, it would read that col- umn with renewed zest. ‘‘ Society’’ in New York really means nothing except a collection, more or less large, of people who invite other people to their houses, either to dinners or to dances or to parties of some kind. It connotes nothing as to manners, or education, or birth. As soon as &@ man or woman begins to do this, he or she is on the way to society. By per- sistently issuing invitations to entertain- ments for two or three years people at last begin to accept them, and the aspirant is ‘* in society,’? and becomes a “‘ society man,’ or ‘‘ society woman,”’ or ‘‘ society girl,’’ asthe case may be. But itstands to reason that no such rapid progress would be possible without the aid of the press. Being a candidate for society would be a very tedious business if nobody knew it but the people who get your invitations. So the reporters are called in, and through them it is given to the world that on a certain afternoon Mrs. A gave a tea, which was attended by Mrs. B, Mrs. C, and Mrs, D, and Miss G, and 80 on. Now the effect of this on the outside world is very curious. The great body of the readers believe that there was at Mrs. A’s a very brilliant gathering, and that she and her company are, so to speak, ‘ init” up to their eyes. If it were not so, Why should it be in the newspapers? And once Mrs. A’s social doings get into the newspapers, they really never get out of them as long as money lasts. Teas, receptions, and dinners succeed each other in rapid succession, and at the close of the sea- son the ‘‘ newspaper man”’ follows Mrs. A to Bar Harbor and Newport, still keeping up the popular excitement about her doings, until her triumph is assured. Publicity, in other words, carries the day. To the outside world the ‘‘society column’’ is paradise, where the men and women live in silks and satins and drink champagne all day long, and are eagerly watched by man- kind. In reality it is a region of very hard work and some anxiety. Mrs. A has to get as much space as Mrs. B, and ‘‘ newspaper men’”’ are notoriously slippery customers and have to be ca- joled and ‘‘ placated.’’ Then it is very hard to make them get the costume right without giving it to them yourself in writing, and once you do this you are in the creature’s power for ever, and he can trample on you as he pleases. No account of the troubles of news- paper society, however, would be ade- quate which said nothing of the snares set for it by enterprising press specula- tors. Of course this passion for publicity is well known to the great army cf pub- lishers of one sort or other who try to make a living out of the weaknesses of their fellow-men. These gentry are natu- rally constantly occupied with the inven- tion of modes of extracting ‘* honest dol- lars’? out of people’s anxiety to be thought members of the world of fash ion. Their activity has been greatly in- creased since a foolish and ridiculous man set down the number of New York- ers who could be said to belong to ‘‘ so- ciety’’ at 400, but without giving any list of names. This exact definition of the number was all the speculators wanted, and they at once set to work printing lists of their own, and of course they could not be expected to put any- body on the list for nothing, and they were sure of a saleof four hundred copies of the work to those who knew they were in it, four hundred more to those who hoped to be in it, and at least four hundred to those who wanted to see who were in it. Other speculators, of course, got up lists of their own, and the “Four Hundred’’ be- came a newspaper synonym for aris- tocracy. The aristocracy of New York then underwent more mutations in a month than that of France or Venice in a thousand years. The way estimable citizens, male and female, were kicked in and out of the Four Hundred by ri- val newspaper men was a sight which ought to have moved the sternest to tears. There is even now a speculation under way, carried on by a body of unknown persons, doubtless live journalists, call- ing themselves the ‘‘ Historical Com- pany,” which we think will tickle ‘“ society people’’ terribly. The compa- ny sends you a circular, acknowledging that you are a conspicuous member of “the Four Hundred.’’ You are touched by this. You feel that these fellows evi- dently know who’s who, and you read on. You find that the biographies of the Four Hundred are going to be published, and for this purpose you are asked for particulars about your birth, parent- age, education, and situation in life, and about your ancestors for three de- grees, fuller than any French juge din- struction would require in a murder case. If you do not answer, this list of the Four Hundred will probably appear with- out you, and there you are. If you do answer, you probably will have to lie freely in order to make your antecedents respectable. If you do not lie, and your antecedents are not respectable, how will you ever show your face at the teas ? The rascals who have got up these dilem- mas of course care nothing about your feelings. They simply want to make a little money, and they will probably make it. ITALY AND THE TRIPLE ALLIANCE. Rome, December 26, 1893. It suits France to assume that the Triple Alliance is the cause of the Italian financial embarrassment, and it pleases the republicans and radicals of Italy to repeat it, but in point of fact the Alliance, by means of the military confederation, enables Italy to provide for her ins caine aa

Page 11

Jan. 11, 1894] security from attack by land with a much di- minished army. The Italian army at this mo ment is only about 160,000 men under arms, hardly enough for all the garrison duties and the public security, and this number includes the carabinieri, who are more policemen than soldiers. It is perfectly well known, and | have the highest official assurance of the fact, | that the treaty of the Triple Alliance imposes no conditions asto the force to be kept under arms by either of the allies; but as the enemy against whom all the members of it had to provide was chiefly France, and in the alterna tive Russia, and the only desire of the central powers was peace and a successful defence if war came, the confederation of the central | powers enabled each to diminish its force, and I know that the strength of the army is really | much less than it would be considered prudent to leave it if Italy were isolated. It is now less than that of the English army. The great gain of the two northern powers by the al- liance was the security of Austria against an attack on the south in case she should be en gaged with Russia, and an aggressive part in a possible campaign has never been expected of Italy. The total cost of her army this year is less than $50,000,000, and when we consider that the army is the great school of the nation, the most efficient means of reducing it to unity and homogeneity, that the total budget of the king- dom is a milliard and a half of lire, more or less, of which the army takes about the sixth. it cannot be said that the military expenses are the ruin of Italy. The fact is, and the recent outbreaks in Sicily show it, that the army is not large enough to secure order and legality in the kingdom. The present Government of Italy is gathering the fruits of ages of mis- government as well as of extravagance during the past thirty years. State property to the amount of three milliards of lire, or six hundred millions of dollars, has been wasted in various ways, but mainly with the purpose of avoiding the necessity of taxing the nation to carry on the business of the state; and now, when the patrimony is exhausted and taxation is neces- sary, it is found that the Government demands sacrifices. Three milliards and a half have been expended in the construction or purchase of railways, of which not a single network pays its expenses and the interest on its cost- partly owing to their construction having been conducted on electoral principles, to couciliate the voters of the provinces served, and partly owing to their bad and wasteful management, so that the railways alone make a deficit in the national accounts of about one hundred millions a year, exclusive of the interest on the bonds for their construction. The army of impiegati, the public servants in the vast and complicated machinery of the state, is in most departments double what is required, and diminution is rendered impossible by the num- ber of votes they would influence. Their num- ber is probably much more in excess of the actual needs of the country than that of the army, even if the ranks were full. The present distress of the country is due to the commercial crisis, due in its turn to the immense inflation of all kinds of business, and especially building, and real-estate operations connected therewith, beginning about ten years ago, and connected more or less with the absurd megalomania consequent on the ac- quisition of Rome as the capital of the nation and the idea of the third Imperial Rome of spring, by the way, of Quintino Sella. the pride of Italian finance, not of Crispi, who only came in for the promises and debts which The Nation. Sella & Co. had made As long as loans were | protected by treaties in her neut ty, is now easy and the income sufficed to pay the int blizged to strengthen | army to a rest, all went on smoothly, and it was onl Violat her fron when the commercial crisis dimiuished incom col 1 lee ‘ ere that the public began to realize that spending | Switzerland is busy fortify } meant, sooner or later, paying But extrava and putting her armoryin order, what gant expenditure in all directions had become | has Italy, then, to keep out of thet so the rule of the state and the commune that Then we have Massowah, whicl ’ it was impossible to arrest it at once. Rome | other fifty millions and returns no | tn and Naples became bankrupt, and the Royal | yond the chance of now and then show Government had to take up their obligations as it had done those of Florence ten years be fore. Rome alone had sunk 700 millions of lire in works either useless or totally unre munerative, and the state has had to under take the completion of all the public works Under various laws, from IS7 to ISS), there were appropriated for public works at the | | | | | ' charge of the state 1,610 millions of lire, and | for 19 railways voted in the first of those years | the expense exceeded the appropriation by 200 | millions. All these have had to be paid for in the subsequent years. As if it were not enough to have overloaded the finances of the state with debts for poste rity to pay, the ministries from 1880 to 1885 abolished taxes which at a moderate estimate would now produce 150 millions a year, among them being the grist tax, which would alone now give an income of over LOO millions a year, and the abolition of which has not affected the price of bread in the least ot really benetited the lower classes, but which cannot be reimposed. The salt tax, which > could be depended on for about 25 millions, was another of the abolished taxes which can- | not be restored. This is the way in which | the prosperous days of the Italian existence were provided, to be paid for by a mortgaged future, become an almost bankrupt present But this was not enough. The earlier govern ments, which earned cheap glory by the con (legal tender, we called it though they had contracted a debt of 600 mil lions to abolish it; and what was infinitely corso forzose | traction of debts for the present, also left it th | | | worse, they left the finances of the state and } ¢ the issue of the currency the monopoly joint-stock banks, arranged in such a way that | the banks would get all the profits, if any, and the country all the losses. These banks are now practically bankrupt. They lent th: capital during the great crisis of four or five years ago on real estate and other securities | which they were legally forbidden to lend on, and they have now a circulation of about 1,(h* millions out, and cannot realize on the secur) ties they hold to redeem it if presented, and the presentation is prevented only by the legal tender provision of the law. The natural re sult is that the premium on gold is cripple enterprise and add enormou the losses and embarrassments already almost paralyzed by the bursting of the great speculation bubble What share, then, has the military expendi ture of less than two hundred and fifty mil- lions a year, and the naval of about one hun Would the withdrawal of Italy from the Triple Alli D acvens ablo } | dred, in the present state of things ince eba ert dismiss an armv when what she has is not enough to keep order in the state Could a nation which is one of the most activ the European nations on the sea, be wi ita navy Would not exclusion from any alliar nd isolation in Europe, with the risk of a war on the north and an- ther say nothing about the accidents which all civilized nations have to risk, cot npel ber to have a larger rather than | | | a smaller army and navy? Even Belgium, as just now at Agordat, how well the Italan military organization works and what yalla fellows their officers are, and this we all knew long ago. But this toe bas nothing to do with the Triple Alliance. Nor has any e of u chief causes of financial embarras nt wl now afflicts Italy, except the single fact that she does not sell so much of her wines to | ‘ as she used tf And that t ex andl protectionist measures now adopted agains Italy would have been adopted any ca the protectionists is made more than probat by their application to Switverland, wi not in the Alliance The break of wa Europe, even if Italy were not directly iny ed in it, would cost ber far tha ‘ sent system of cooperation in a league the ject and up-to-date effect of which has i Is to keep the peac t * it iw \ through French spectacles that the Triple Al liance is seen as the prime cause of anv fina cial or political trout to Ttals Zz French want war, and mean war, and Italy in is an er obsta to this inter talk peace, t sa x-atl the war of IS7U said to me last sum 1 We want it after we have t back Alsace a l raine \nd that is what if really means "\ Ss MAN THE SPANIARDS AT MELILLA ALG S. Lh tribe J lsu No one out of the pet dur the past few months of hasti between Spait ted anv idea of the pr tiling excitement i int of this event The Spanisl ews papers have devoted pages of every issue the * campaign in the Ru? country pages of headlines and of glorification of Spain and het soldiers. The calling out of the first army r serves has fl half-uni rmed levies, movement of troops has drawn ani wds to the railway stations. Every railroad and every harbor in southern Spain has been strained to transport soldiers and supplies to the scene of action and a cabinet crisis almost occurred because the war minister could barely be dissuaded from resigning his portfolio and placing him self at the head of the glorious expedition All this has furnished plenty of excuse for a display of blatant patriotism and national vanity which. to an American, has in some of its aspects a familiar Blaine or Jingo air Nevertheless, this ‘‘campaign”™ has been a great boon to the gossips of the cafés and a stimulus to promotion in the army, and as it has brought Spain into prominence among the European powers holding African possessions, of course little consideration is paid to the fact that the expense thus far has exceeded fifteen millions, and has greatly added to the existing financial troubles of the Government Melilla itself, as seen at sunrise from the roadstead, presents a wonderfully picturesque appearance, being situated upon and around a high rock jutting out into the Mediterranean. The old-fashioned fortifications, with here and

Page 12

28 there a threatening cannon, the crowded little Spanish houses, with an occasional new bar- rack; the tents of the soldiers, and the outly- ing forts on the hills beyond; the heavily laden transports and the grim men-of-war floating on the blue water—all this makes an enchanting spectacle. Indeed, it is not until the crimson rays have faded away into white, and the many clear-voiced bugles have ceased their musical calls to reveillé and to breakfast that one real- izes that the curtain has not risen on a new opera, and that the interest of the place lies not in its picturesqueness, but in the pur- poses and actions of the armed men it con- tains. Viewed in broad daylight, Melilla is a sur- prisingly small place, with next to no attrac- tive houses. Its streets are very narrow and very steep, and it is evident ata glance that the town has not the slightest value except as affording Spain a foothold in Africa and the advantages of an open roadstead for her ships. On the 14th of December, the day of my visit to Melilla, hostilities were still suspended pending the negotiations for peace, so that in- spection of the camps was everywhere per- mitted and there were not even sentries at the landing-place to question a visitor’s purpose. The faces of two or three Jewish traders, who Jooked sadly through the barred windows of the small cell which forms the guard-house, proved, however, that the commander-in-chief, Marshal Martinez Campos, is in earnest in his efforts to check any traffic in guns or ammuni- tion with the enemy. In that portion of the town which lies at the foot of the rock there was a pitiful attempt at a market; stores were few and far between, but there were a number of booths of the usual camp-followers, most of them for the sale of liquors. In an Anglo- Saxon camp of corresponding size, this sale would be suppressed; but a drunken Spanish soldier is a rare sight anywhere. The only building in the least worthy of the name of a hotel was a shockingly dirty place, but so ex- tensive was its business that the privilege of occupying a chair cost five pesetas (about one dollar) a night! So few women and children were to be seen that it was evident that num- bers of the inhabitants had withdrawn during the hostilities. One met with quite a number of friendly Moors, and ai the landing-place a most interesting crowd of soldiers, sailors, boat- men, Moors, negroes, gendarmes, and civilian laborers could be studied. From a military standpoint, there is much to find fault with in Melilla. Perhaps the most striking thing in the whole town is the lack of the simplest sanitary arrangements and precautions. With the exception of the tiny square in front of the chief military of- fice building, the streets are very foul. Even in the camps outside the walls there are no evidences of systematic policing, and useful materials are thrown about in an inexcusably careless way, while nowhere is there that neatness ever to be expected of good soldiers. The fortifications are antiquated, and, with the exception of four Krupp pieces, the heavy guns are still more so, dating back to 1850, and in the case of the mortars to 1780, suggesting at once in their appearance the old trophies at West Point. The marshal himself says that the outlying forts are badly located and not well built. They have to be reprovisioned once every eight days, and that at a serious cost of life if warfare be going on. From the electric search-light tower the walls of the new fort were visible, which have since collapsed, owing to the rains. It was the construction of this fort, together with the extension of the The Nation. neutral zone, which brought about the whole trouble. At present there are some 30,000 troops in Melilla, and these are commanded by 26 line generals. Throughout, the number of officers in proportion to the soldiers is very large. The regiments are generally small, but have been more or less recruited. One artillery regiment at home had but 300 men to some 35 to 40 offi- cers, I was informed; but this may have been an exceptional case, and doubtless those at the front are considerably larger. At Melilla the light artillery guns were parked in the open air without breech coverings, whereas mules and horses looked well taken care of. The sol- diers themselves wore the fatigue working suits, originally of some coarse linen, but they were so campaign-worn it was hard to tell what they had been. The men were in the best of spirits, and, as far as could be judged, made light of their hardships and enjoyed their rations of wine and the puchero doled out to them. This latter dish, a sort of soup of peas and other vegetables, forms a large part of the diet of the Spanish soldiers, as well as of the peasants, but it seemed a scanty fare. The English soldiers at Gibraltar spoke of it with an amusing mixture of horror and disgust, combined with a good deal of pity for their Spanish brothers-in-arms, but the latter seemed to relish it, and I saw nothing of the dissatis- faction which, according to French despatches, is universal. A large detachment of men car- rying heavy burdens of flour joked and larked as though it was very good fun, and they went, in fact, almost too far with their noise. The soldiers appeared to have a great deal of liberty about town, and in consequence there was considerable wrecking of traders’ booths, for which, as an example, one poor fellow was sentenced to be shot. As a whole, the Spanish soldiers are under-sized and under-aged, nor have they a very strong physique. The officers are neat and very soldierly looking. In the afternoon of the 14th there was a di- vision drill along the beach, across the river, and upon the hills, which are the spurs of a r mountain 3,000 feet high, by no means a blot on the landscape. The men marched quickly, executed the skirmish-drill movements well, and, from a distance, appeared to be carefully and ably handled, which was a distinct sur- prise after what I had seen in Spain. As though to add realism to the picture, blank-cartridge firing was indulged in, and as the manceuvres were executed near the neutral line, small bo- dies of Moors appeared to watch the spectacle, which was put an end to by a heavy rain. The town of Melilla itself is not well situated, and the opinion has more than once been expressed that it is defensible only against.the Moors. It certainly seems as though some modern cannon on the neighboring mountain would speedily render it untenable. At anchor in the roadstead lay the fleet which recently created such havoc among the Moors by firing upon them suddenly at night by aid of the powerful search-lights. There were six ships in all, ranging from an old ves- sel with tall spars very much resembling Far- ragut’s Hartford to more modern ships. The flagship Alfonso XII, added to the martial picture of the afternoon by practice-firing from a bow gun. There were no foreign men-of-war in harbor. On the 18th a gale drove ashore a Spanish vessel which the Moors promptly attacked. The nearest forts replied, but the affair soon ended and the Moors have humbly apologized. In fact, as the expensive fort has fallen to pieces and the Sultan has promised to disarm the belligerent tribes, we [Vol. 58, No. 1489 shall soon see Spain once more pacific, and doubtless well satisfied at having added an- other glorious triumph to the many feats of Spanish arms. 0. G.V. Correspondence. AN OLD-WORLD LESSON. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION : Srr: It is not only German professors of philology who were in some way moved by their experience at the World’s Fair to sympa- thize with women in their desire to get access to German universities. Prof. Klein was so well convinced of the fitness of an American woman to become an attendant upon his lec- tures (what he discourages most aspiring Ame- rican men-students of mathematics from un- dertaking) that he brought his powerful influ- ence to bear upon the Prussian Cultusminister upon her account, and has thus caused the doors of the ancient University of Géttingen to open enough to let exceptional women in. It is to be hoped that, when the next world’s fair is held, at Berlin, the Harvard College authorities may be sent thither, and may there discover that, even under Old World customs, it is possible for women to listen to great pro- fessors in the same room with men with a very high degree of safety to them both. X. THE ADMISSION OF UTAH. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir : You say that ‘‘ because we have several States which ought to be Territories is no reason for making another mistake of the same sort.” Most true indeed is this ; but, conversely, is that a reason for refusing statehood to a Ter- ritory that in an eminent degree possesses all the qualifications heretofore deemed essential in a new State, and especially those of prime importance—population and wealth? The popu- lation of Utah in 1890 was 207,905, while the aggregate population of Idaho, Nevada, and Wyoming was 190,851, a difference in Utah’s favor of 17,054. The assessed valuation of property in Utah for 1893 (a year of extreme business depression, when values of all kinds were greatly depressed) was $115,114,842; total Territorial debt, $700,000; value of public pro- perty, $1,175,459. 76. As to Congressman Harter’s objection — “that we do not want any more States until we can civilize Kansas”—that is most unfair to Utah, for it may be that Kansas never can be civilized; and let it be remembered that Kansas, ‘‘bleeding Kansas,” got its form of civilization from the New England Emigrant Aid Society, and not from the West. You commend Senator Proctor’s bill for an- nexing Utah to Nevada, and say it is an ‘ideal solution of a problem which otherwise must apparently always remain on our hands.” That problem is Nevada’s, not Utah’s. It may be answered, it probably will be answered, that Congress and Nevada will decide the ques- tion, and that the people of Utah will have to abide that decision. But would not the impo- sition of the Constitution of Nevada on the people of this Territory, willy-nilly, be an out- rage on them and a gross violation of the best traditions regarding the admission of new States ? And the further question arises, may it not be unconstitutional? It is safe to say that to-day Utah’s population is six times greater than Nevada’s, and to annex us to her against our aspirations and will would surely Ae esa re Sat as rece ee i

Page 13

Jan. 11, 1894]

be to make the tail wag the dog, and a bob-tail at that. Iam sure the Nation is wrong when it intimates that opposition to the proposed an- nexation would come from office-seekers main- ly. It would come from the entire people, ir- respective of politics. In Utah we have had a long struggle for the vindication and supremacy of the nation’s laws, and to-day they command the respect aud obedience of all. The past is past, and all are looking forward to a happy, prosperous, and honorable future as a State of the Union. We in Utah are pleased to think that we have, in the language of Prof. Bryce, a share of that ‘reserve of force and patriotism more than sufticient to sweep away all the evils which are now tolerated, and to make the politics of the country worthy of its material grandeur and of the private virtues of its inhabitants.” If Utah is not fitted for statehood let her re main a Territory, but we do ask not to be an- nexed to the pocket borough of Nevada. Yours very respectfully, ALFALES YOUNG SALT LAKE City, January 2, 184. {We cannot let our correspondent’s historical inaccuracy pass uncorrected So far from Kansas civilization being a product of New England, the original settlers:from that district and New York together were outnumbered by those from Indiana alone, to say nothing of Illinois and Iowa (whence Kansas de- rived its some-time appellation of the State of the three I’s). The problem of civilizing Kansas is still a Western, not an Eastern one.—ED. NATION. ]

OUR FOREFATHERS ON FOOTBALL. To THE EpItor OF THE NATION: Sir: Apropos of your crusade against foot- ball and of what is said for this college pas- time (is not a college, sir, a place where they play football—or is this the description of a university 7, I send you some old comments on the sport, from which your readers may draw their own conclusions. In Sir Thomas Elyot’s ‘Boke named the Governour’ (1531), after de- scribing various games profitable for exercise, he says: ‘* Verily as for two the laste be to be utterly abjected of al noblemen, in like wise foote balle wherin is no-thinge but beastly furie and ex- treme violence; wherof procedeth hurte, and cmt rancour and malice do remaine with them that be wounded; wherfore it is to be put in perpetuall silence” (L., p. 295). In Croft’s edition of the ‘Governour,’ from which the above is taken, occur some interest- ing notes on the same subject. For example, King James I., in commending athletic exer- cises to his son, says, in the ‘ Basilikon Doron’ : ‘*T debarre all rough and violent exercise, as the foot ball, meeter for laming than making able the users thereof.” Carew, in his ‘ Survey of Cornwall’ (1602), de- scribes ‘‘ Hurling,” which seems to be the mo- dern football, as ‘‘a play verily both rude and rough.” He adds: ‘*The ball in this play may be compared to an infernal spirit, for whosoever catcheth it, fareth straightways like a madman, strugglin and fighting with those who go about to hol him. . . . I cannot well resolve whether I should more commend this game for the man- hood and exercise, or condemn it for the bois terousness and harm which it begetteth: for as on the one side it makes their bodies strong, hard, nimble, and puts a courage into their ~IS

The Nation. 29

hearts to meet an enemy in the face, so on the | schreibungen.” The unwarrantable omission of other part it is accompanied with many dan- | Gass’s name from the title page has caused the gers, some of which do ever fall on the play- | 4} , , ’ , . . ’ troul and lor lelay in identifving tl ers’ share; for proof whereof, when the Hurl . a 5 ing is ended, vou shall see them retiring hom ation t is tt ast deg uprobable as from a pitched battle, with bloody pates that any German version of the genuine Lewis bones broken and out of joint, and su bh | and Clark a ared in 1814 « as t) bruises as serve to shorten their davs; vet all ve in good play, and never attorney nor coroner | S't) Was i isQeu : ary Sit troubled for the matter.” N. M see Na No. 143% There ts no quests New York. that the Crerman edit lid his work in goad fait! this is a Gass com; t gh tl sh pearan ff Jetferson’s NI andi Clark's &rWoO RARE EDITIONS OF GASS letters wives the book tl ur of one of tl a} " . ore ; eTrv pha, imi tl PN “ i t SSS y yraphy To THE Epitor oF THE Nation cit ; ra ethnology, and natural history became in pass Sir: (1.) The catch-title of a certain German ine through French inte an is best le ¢ publication relating to the travelsof Lewis and | ¢p. eerritied imacin Clark has haunted bibliography fot >) E lately handled in t ary M years. I first noticed it in ISTH, but have been apolis a Gass whi Was ow until very recently unable to identify the book | ghouch Sabin cites it anhv 7 to which it refers. As given by Kayser, it 3 entitled as fi _ reads: ** (Lewis und Clarke Tavebu he. Fart Lewis and Clarke’s | Jou ’ ' ’ i KY deckungsreise durch Nord. Amerika in d. Jah Mountains | In the years 1NO4.-I8ai.- ve ren 1SO4-6, Aus d. Engl. v. Weyland. Mit. 1 | pated by! Patrick Gass. | one of t ” - Karte.” It is described as gr. Svo, Weimar, | phe Expedition Now Ba = \ 1815, and as forming Band IL. of the ** Neue | pjoeai.c Bae Cee are sate" } tthe is tf Wihes a\ } bolas Bibliothek der wichtigsten Beschreibungen.” | pus Clattin. & ¢ Si ete. Lremarked in my edition of Lewis and | | Oye vol. sm. Svo cs a but S lea Clark that this might be a Gass; and such ap | ty 4 siena . LS af acivin pears to be the fact, for T have just received, | with many ¢ st . through the attentions of Mr. Francis P. Har for paginat biraee eye . ntist per of New York. a German Gass which ena : is tit pp. iv.-y ire prefa ated Mar bles me to lay the ghost in question. Follow 3. 1S : ae ing is the full title: os ere f i on Bey Ser Tagebuch einer Entdeckunys - Reis J b us pp. 1 ix} ~ durch | Nord - America, | von | der I so 6 Gass. It is a fa des Missuri an bis zum Einfluss der t al ll: vinal of 1807. witl in den stillen Ocean, | gemacht | in den Jahren | out any extraneous text, though the illustra 1804, 1805 und 1806, | auf | Befehl der Regie-"| gions are all interpolat — . rung der Vereinigten Staaten, | von den be no doubt, the sa . = 1 Ells got uy den Capitaens Lewis und Clarke Ueber fom the anus a Lewis and Clark which he setzt | von | Ph. Ch. Weyland Mit einer | published at Davton in 184 Ir nize the Charte. Weimar, | im Verlage des H. S. | two portraits as being the sameT but have not privil. Landes-Industrie-Comptoirs. | [S14 hed an onoortunity of mparing the rest. 1 . c } 26) it} , rye , . One vol. Svo, pp. i-x, 1-362, with one may am clad to fi t an ) st book—whether Title, verso blank, pp. i, ii; Jefferson's messag: s wanted to make amends for his misdeed to Congress, pp. lli-v; translator's preface, py f 1S or Wanted to preseribe good medicine vi-viii; contents, pp. ix-x; bastard title, vers f eorders lent to the “ Oregon fever ‘ ». ; , 145 leat = blank, pp. 1, 2; main text, pp. 3-345: two | SS ELLiorr Coves ters of Clark, pp. 346-362; map at end, , : t Sy STAN IN x - r sua inches high by 7°, wide This is a genuine Gass, with which | have compared it carefully. The transl s I R'S SATELLITES IN 1644 very free one, and undoubtedly was made ae A ‘ “ T y ry t rT NATION the French version of Lallemant vo. Paris : 1810}, though Weyland may easily have also Stn: Lhave brought to the notice of three had an edition in English before him. But | Sstrot ers an interesting letter of John that he followed Lallemant appears from the | Wint the second of that name), written facts (1) that the Jefferson message is prefixed | in 1664 to Sir Robert Moray, in which Win- and Clark’s two letters are suftixed, as in Lal! throp declares that, * having ked upon Ju mant; (2) the twenty-five ch: h | piter with a telescope,” August 6, 1663 (old headed with the dates of the J the stvi t saw fv satellites very distinctly respectively cover, as in Lall the | about that planet.” He reports the observa- } ! French translator's notes are re tion with natural distrust, lest it should be ‘‘a

man; and (4) the m s letters and | mistaken novelty.” <As the letter (which is legended ‘*Carte pour Servir au Voyage des | printed in the Proceedings of the Massachu- Cap" Lewis et Clarke, A 'Ocean Pa I | setts Historical Society for June, IST8, p. 220)

cannot see that the German editor has added | had never been noticed by the three astrono- ew © Vorbericht | mers above mentioned, | make the following

Wevland | extract from it for the entertainment of other r Pat k Gass. ~ tifie antiquaries among your readers. If and explains th: f histary any one knows what has become of Winthrop’s the expedition had not vet appeared any | astronomical ‘‘tube,” perhaps he will inform

rate had not reached Europe. the Journal of you Yours respectfully, D. C. GILMAN, Gass would answer a purpose for the time be- Jonnxs Hopkins UNIVERSITY . 7 Baltimore, Mp., December 22, 1803 ing, et Ihave no doubt whatever that this book is , . my: . : , ; : ; iat - , JoHN WINTHROP TO StR Ropert Moray. the one Kayser cites. Tl lifference in date 1N13 instead of 1814) pr ans ' HARTFORD, Jan: 27: 166A, than that the next 1 <daeechiieen = In mv former I gave your honor an account a s ‘ uit ‘ » Yt aaa : ise ut’. ‘ = saat f the fav IT had of vour letter by the Hon. le S 3 . : { Colovell Richard Nicolis. I then omitted to f the ** Neu Bit Thex er wichtigsten b acquall t vour honor what now I will be bold to

Page 14

30 The Nation. [Vol. 58, No. 1489 add: that havinge looked upon Jupiter with a Telescope, upon the 6th of August last, [saw 5 ) Satellites very distinctly about that Planet: [ observed it with the best curiosity I could, taking very distinct notice of the number of them, by severall aspects with some convenient tyme of intermission; & though I was not with out some consideration whether that fifth might not be some fixt star with which Jupiter might at that tyme be in neare conjunction, yet that consideration made me the more carefully to take notice whether I could discerne any such difference of one of them from the other foure, that might by the more twinckling light of it or any other appearance give ground to be- lieve that it might be a fixed starr, but I could discerne nothing of that nature: and I consider that the tube with which I looked upon them, though so good as to shew very clearely the Satellytes, yet was but of 3 foote and halfe with a concave ey-glasse; and I question whether by a farre better tube a fixt star can be discerned so near the body of that planet when in the ever bright activity of its light, for, if so, why are there not often if not alwayes seene with the best tubes the like or more. Is not Jupiter often in neere conjunction with them, especiallv in via lactea? Ihave beenin much doubt whether I should mention this, which would possibly be taken from a single af- firmation but a mistaken novelty: but I thought I would rather beare such sensure than omit the notice of it to such worthy friends as might from the hint of it take occasion to cause more frequent observations to be made upon that planet, & at least this will at length be cleared, whether the light of Jupiter doth not takeaway the appearance of fixed starrs so neere in con- junction with it, as that they should appear within the periphery of that single intuitus by a tube which taketh in the body of Jupiter and that at the same unmoved aspect: and I am bold the rather to mention this as an inquiry whe- ther any such number of Satellites or moons hath beene seene by your honor or Mr. Rooke or any mathematitians or other gentlemen that have good tubes and often have the curi- osity to view the planet, for possibly it may be new to me which hath beene more usually knowne by others, though the notion of such a thinge is not new to my selfe, for I remember I mett with the like narration many years since in a little booke intituled Philosophia Naturalis per Joh. Phociliden, though then I thought that was but a mistake of some fixed starrs.” TO SPELL FOR, ‘TO INTIMATE A WISH FOR,’ ‘TO SCHEME TO OBTAIN.’ To THE EprTror oF THB NATION: Srr: This expression, which I lately ventur- ed in a letter, is one which has been very little investigated. So far as I have discovered, the only lexicographer that notices it is Mr. F, kK. Robinson, in whose Glossary of Words used in the Neighbourhood of Whitby it is defined, ‘to try to obtain by address.’ This, substantially, is the sense which it bears in the following quotations: ‘* Was it not, to every intent and purpose but the technical form of words, a promise? Was it natural, in such a case, for the one party to superadd, or possible for the other to require, a formal promise; or, consistently with the smallest particle of gratitude or delicacy, to spell for such a thing in the most distant man- ner, or to conceive that it would superadd any- thing to his security?” Jeremy Bentham (1790), Works (1888-43), vol. x., p 230. ‘* Before I had given him anything, he be- gan to spell for something.” Cardinal New- man (1840), Letters (1891), vol. i., p. 429. ‘*It will be observed, too, in the foregoing letters, that he ‘spelled’ for the curacy and suggested the idea to me.” Jd. (1860), ibid., vol. ii., p. 105, Besides that everybody hereabouts employs to spell for after the manner of Bentham and Cardinal Newman, I have long and often heard the phrase, alike from gentle and sim- ple, in many parts of England. Is it known in the United States’ As being terse, and at the same time free from all tang of vulgarity, why does it not deserve a higher rank than that of colloquialism ? The guesses concerning its origin which have occurred to me, since they will readily occur to others, may go unmen tioned, That the spel/ for here considered is in any seen in the Irishisms ‘*to spoil for a fight,” ‘‘to spoil for an argument,” ete., phrases familiar to Ameri- cans, seems far from likely. BS i. way connected with spoil for, MARLESFORD, ENGLAND, December 10, 1893, Notes. A WORK in twelve volumes, each distinct, is contemplated (and partly executed) by Mr. Charles 8S. Peirce, member of the National Academy of Sciences. Its full title reads: ‘The Principles of Philosophy; or, Logic, Physics, and Psychics, considered as a Unity, in the light of the Nineteenth Century.’ The first volume, which is ready for the press, will be ‘A Review of the Leading Ideas of the Nineteenth Century.’ Mr. Peirce also issues a prospectus of a limited edition, now in course of printing, in two colors on hand-made paper, at the De Vinne Press, of ‘The Epistle of Pierre Pelerin de Maricourt to Sygur de Fou- caucourt, Soldier, On the Lodestone.’ The original treatise dates from 1269, and ‘‘ occu- pies a unique position in the history of the hu- man mind, being without exception the earliest work of experimental science that has come down to us.” The transcript of Peter Pere- grinus’s text has been made afresh from a con- temporary MS. in the Paris Library, and is reproduced in black-letter together with a translation and notes. Subscriptions for either work should be addressed to Mr. Peirce at Milford, Pa. Joel Munsell’s Sons, Albany, announce ‘The Pioneers of New France in New England,’ or the French incitement of the Indians against the English settlements, with documentary French evidence and illustrations. The author, Mr. James Phinney Baxter, is president of the Maine Historical Society. Mr. A. D. Weld-French of Boston purposes issuing in an edition of 300 copies his ‘ Notes on the Surnames of Francus, Franceis, French, ete., in Scotland,’ with an account of the Frenches of Thorndykes and a discussion of the family connection with the Stuart kings. D. Appleton & Co. will publish shortly ‘ Ger- many and the Germans,’ by William Harbutt Dawson, a writer on German socialism; and ‘The Greater Glory,’ a new novel by Maarten Maartens. Prof. Boyesen’s commentary on [bsen’s plays is nearly ready to be brought out by Macmil- lan & Co. From the Scribners we may expect R. E. Prothero’s ‘Life and Correspondence of Dean Stanley,’ in two volumes, ‘Psychology, De- scriptive and Explanatory,’ by Prof. George T. Ladd of Yale, ‘The Philosophy of Reality,’ by Dr. James McCosh, ‘Essays about Men, Women, and Books,’ by Augustine Birrell, and a ‘Chess Pocket-Manual,’ by C. H. D. Gossip. Thomas Whittaker issues this week ‘The Ascent of Faith; or, Grounds of Certainty in Science and Religion, by Alexander J. Herri- son, and ‘The Son of Man among the Sons of Men,’ by the Bishop of Ripon. Roberts Bros. will soon bring out ‘The Aim of Life: Plain Talks to Young Men and Wo- men,’ by the Rev. Philip Stafford Moxom; ‘Allegretto,’ a volume of poems by Gertrude Hall; and Balzac’s ‘Memoirs of Two Young Married Women,’ translated by Miss Worme- ley. Lee & Shepard have in press ‘The Politi cal Economy of Natural Henry Wood. The third volume of Mr. Wheatley’s defini tive edition of Pepys’s Diary (London: George Bell & Sons; New York: Macmillan) ends with the year 1663, and has for its two illustra- tions a photogravure after Sir Peter Lely’s portrait of the diarist in the hall of Magdalene College, Cambridge, and a likeness of Sir Samuel Moreland, from a drawing in the Pe- pys collection. We notice length the first volume in the collective edition of Huxley's works. Two other volumes of his essays are now at hand, ‘ Darwiniana’ and ‘Science and Education’ (Appletons). The former contains the brief obituary of Darwin contributed to Nature, and the much longer one from the Pro- ceedings of the Royal Society. The latter volume embalms the little skit ‘‘ Emancipation —Black and White,” published on the heels of our Federal triumph in the civil war, which, beginning with some patronizing and slightly contemptuous remarks about the freedmen racially considered, playfully tosses aside the woman suffragists in order to make a serious and just plea for the higher education of women—‘‘ Emancipate the girls.” In making designs for Macmillan’s edition of Irving’s ‘Rip Van, Winkle’ and ‘The Legend of Sleepy Hollow,’ in one volume, Mr. George H. Boughton must have felt the pleasure of re- patriation. His preface recalls his delight, in his cis-Atlantie days, in sketching and roam- ing along the shores of the Hudson, and his pencil must here have worked con amore. We do not find these pictures proof of a special aptitude for book-illustration, or superior to their predecessors. Some are out of scale with the size of the book, and the most successful are vignettes; invention and imagination are sparingly to be detected. Outwardly the book is very pretty. ‘Hazell’s Annual for 1894° (London: Hazell, Watson & Viney; New York: Scribners), though an alphabetical lexicon of current bio graphy and history—‘‘a cyclopzedie record of men and topics of the day”—has much en- larged its classificatory ‘‘ key to the contents,” and furnishes at least one brand-new innova- tion of plain, uncolored maps of out-of-the- way countsies, scenes of international conten- tion. Some of the fresh topics are the African transcontinental telegraph now building from Cape Town northward, the cholera epidemic of last year, the Liberator frauds, the Bering Sea question, and the World’s Fair. We wish the editor might distinguish his work above all others by giving lists of the members of the French, German, and Italian Parliaments in addition tothat of the British. The value of this excellent compendium must not be judged by errors like these in the article on Grover Cleveland, all carried over from last year: ‘*born af New Jersey,” ‘Judge Foulger ” (for Folger), ‘** Agnes Folsom” (for Frances). ‘The Year’s Art for 1894’ (London: J. 8. Virtue & Co.) attains its fifteenth annual issue. The name of Marcus B. Huish is re- placed by that of his former associate, A. C. R. Carter, as editor, but the scheme is un- changed and could hardly have been improv- ed upon. Law,’ by elsewhere at There are the usual photographic memoranda of pictures exhibited, but, in lieu of the portraits of artists hitherto inserted in classes, we have a good number of faces of editors or art directors of periodicals devoted wholly to art, or eninent for their illustra- tions, as, for example, Mr. Hamerton of the Portfolio and Mr. Gilder of the Cenfury. In pac A ae Aa nen eats

Page 15

Die ite 6 ot ila Sol

Jan. 11, 1894] the rear comes the indisp. nsable directory of | artists. The illustrated magazines bid us review them in their bound volumes-—for the half vear (Century), fora year (Seribner’s). They have the World’s Fair in common, together with papers on Florida, on art in Japan, ete. Two books have emerged from the Century. Janvier’s ‘Embassy to Provence’ and Salvini's Autobiography, and from Mrs. Burnett’s ‘The One I Knew the Best of All’ and Robert Grant's ‘Opinions of a Philoso- pher.’ In point of illustrations, Scribner's is the innovator with its colored plates; and all signs point to the multiplication of these hereafter in all the magazines. The California Midwinter International Exposition connects with the foregoing, in a way, vol. xxii, of the Overland Monthly, but it also marks the predominant Pacific-Coast character of this magazine, in which we find examples of famous paintings owned on the coast, an account of the long- est jetty in the world—viz., at the mouth of the Columbia River—with papers on campiug- out in Mendocino, the Thlinkets of Alaska, the California fish patrol, the Chinese regis- two Seribner’s tering under the Geary act (with a profane photograph of General Grant actually seated at the same table with the heathen Li Hung Chang), a penological reform movement in California, ete. Without exception, perhaps, the cuts are process work, but they are aids to understanding. The illustrations of the Green Bag (Boston Book Co.) are wholly personal, and now that the series of this legal periodical has reached a fifth volume, the professional portrait gallery is probably the most extensive and valuable (at least for the American bench and bar) in existence. The character of this periodical, both in the serious and the lighter vein, has been well maintained, and such verse as Mr. Stafford’s *‘ A Contrast,” on p. 523, does not often find its way into our literary maga- zines. Babyhood is a magazine whose name ex- plains its interests. Its medical editor, Dr. Leroy M. Yale, has extracted from the files several hundred letters and these the Contemporary Publishing Company of Philadelphia have printed in book form as *‘ Nursery Problems.’ lems are such as constantly confront young his replies, and convenient The prot parents, and their solution by Dr. Yale shows competent knowledge and excellent judgment An admirable illustration of what is euphe mistically termed British conservatism is the persistence with which the identity of typhus and typhoid fevers was held by their physi- Louis and Gerhard, in the thirties, had satisfied all students in France and America cians. that they were distinct diseases, and physicians at large in both countries accepted this asa ‘The done abroad, D1 Nation. Jenner's unanswerable which is a masterptece Of sctentifi

servation and analysis, is What gave light to his compe triots; and although the medical prof: long since moved past the epoch it his countrymen, it deserves study as a type o argument built entirely upon fact For his countrymen he broke up continued fever int four varieties, of which those two are th: principal and Diphtheria, 149 to IS7¥,) Macmillan & ¢ have reproduced, in a well-indexed octavo that In ‘Lectures and Essays on Fevers

should become a classic, this and other papers on the same general topics, all marked by the same lucidity. ‘The Vital Equation of the Colored Ra and its Future in the United States, by Dr. 1 R. Corson of Savannah, a reprint from = the ‘Wilder Quarter-Century Book,’ is an essay whose conclusion is that the future of that race will be inability to maintain itself asa race, and that the world has reached a poin where everything must give way to the Cau casian. This has been derived from conten plating the high infantile death-rate, the im paired vitality of the mixed strains, and the the Southern negro, esp. low seale of life of cially in the larger towns. Vitality doubtless is influenced by race distinction, but the tigures and the enough to

area are neither detinite nor large furnish positive deductions. The lesson that seems to us nearest the surface in this paper is the necessity for strong, kindly persistent action in lifting the blacks by struction, by sanitary injunction, and by ganized charity. This last should stimulat not pauperize We have received the completing section the fifth Kluge’s edition of Etvmologisches Worterbuch der Deutschen Sprache’ (Stras burg: Triibner). The book hs . pages, 15 of which are taken valuat

chronological groupings of the German wor stock, made by Dr. F. Mentz. The new art cles contain mostly foreign and dialect words such as grassteren, Grippe, Gi .G s?, under G. Additions have been made inthe chronology and in the geographical distribution of words Such a dicti made by one man alone, nary is a growth, so Prof. Kluge enjoys and acknowledges the continued help of persons known and unknown to him who give valual hints and make actual contributions. We st surprised that under Geist the new « peats the statement that Encl. aghast means ’ F *- This w at , z of Geis ghost, anyway. U1 zetteln, English to fed. mear to scat

might have been mentioned.

matter of fact and acted accordingly. In the British Islands as well as elsewhere they had always been grouped as continued fever, and the suggested differentiation was a novelty not to be countenanced. In 1544 a leading medica! quarterly, discussing this very question, beld ‘*there is but one kind of idiopathic fever,” ar it was not until ‘D0 that the (now Sir) William Jenner demonstrated by the Ish young Dr closest scrutiny of the conditions before ar after death that they were as distinct as meas scarlet merly confused types. les and fever, apother brace of for His argument was too convincing to be ignored, and British subjects (in both the legal and the an > atomical sense) furnished the material, Britis! inasmuch as medicine, about twenty years after its bors, fell into line with them in this respect Notwithstanding the work had already been neizh

S. ‘hay-tedder is} xa s overlooked under F f Ciiter th gives only Anuglo-Saxot ognates wl later English w i be more wel ia } f ire tt. mal | > | t respect } D'Ancona’s * Manual a | t " } ana’ has itlY apr t ging vork | down to th nd t ght is pleasant to not the ¢ tra phy and seve} . * , i and audat * Cv v Db ’ Lith ' kK is mich in rive V SRarpiy det es wh inte st a times. Dr. Statfettis ‘ ‘ ul wt but T quite i M " fox and 1 united, | ‘ what dispropeo mately fox \ & pope, as U host [ lay is three times a tent VY note ( earth, as lo tlie i f both | gna a and trusted i ( pears itt t . probable | I ft ! tor { I pats t s his friend D Cos his ow? s WwW most b mt w ‘ wWors Stall WwW ik ‘ il ‘ ~ r | WW K \ Wa ‘ t i i ‘ s S ~ + s Ww 4 ‘ sul t t ‘ 4 ‘ { = it 4 i Y t i al \ Naviga \ Was perhaps as orig a sa ke a es : n ' ‘ ’ s ‘ S \ lk: wv ts : i strat i M May sa t ° Vl VW tt iis = i ( Ss experiments an-fl t coat \ $180 4 st writ We saves, | ~ “4 i erably safe s M Waters’s alogical Glea yiand tl nuar ‘ .% \ His t i ew) t I . i Wi Sewa a, % bia . \ ia sil 1) one Ss vs * Harv i Gradu tes and of Wil n. son Marv Dver, tl (Juakeress Ww Was | vt { her relig i Bost ( mil ' i hes ec wal b 1 great mat fa ‘ i illustrate : Mr. Waters’s skilful g sof testament W } ted not es 1 communication fr a respond respecting La Nalle’s sta t 1 of Starved Rock on the Illinois River \ slight article on this romantic spot and neigl borhood by the Rev. Frank J. ¢ Catholic WV hiefly on account of the views LL.D

Y Reilly, in the orld for January, deserves mention which accom Washington:

Page 16

32 The Nation. [Vol. 58, No. 1489 W. H. Lowdermilk & Co.), has for its object to popularize the investigations of scholars by giving a brief account of the progress of the language from its earliest forms to the present day; but the author overlooks the fact that a certain amount of knowledge at first hand, es- pecially of the older periods, is necessary for this purpose. When we find in the table of contents ‘Ancren Riwle’ translated ‘‘ Ancient Rule,” and this repeated in the text, it arouses our suspicions, which are more than confirmed by the perusal of the first few chapters. The author has not the most remote conception of the structure of the Old English (Anglo-Saxon) language, speaking of it as ‘‘a compound of all the idioms spoken by the warlike invaders,” and remarking: -‘‘ There were four declensions for nouns, adjectives, and adverbs [sic], and even the article was declined with the strang- est vagaries of inflection”—with much more of the same sort. King Alfred is placed 150 years after Caedmon, Egbert is given to him for a father, and the year of his birth is stated as that in which the Danes ‘‘ drove him into con- cealment.” The author has dipped into Sir Frederic Madden’s edition of Layamon’s ‘ Brut,’ but without understanding its language, and there are numerous mistakes in the quotations from it. Errors of the press abound, and in fact there are more errors of all sorts to the square inch than in any work we have ever read, The brief account of the ‘ Beowulf’ (pp. 16, 17) is a caricature, and Geoffrey (not Geof- froy) of Monmouth’s Chronicle is spoken of more than onceas a ‘‘ poem.” The ‘Ormulum’ is sandwiched between the ‘‘ Genesis and Exo- dus” and ‘the Ayenbite of Inwit [Inwyt], which means Again-bite of Conscience, or Re- morse,” although the work is professedly his- torical. Orm is said to use ‘‘two consonants in the beginning and end of a word, and some writers have supposed they were placed at the end of a word to denote a short syllable or a long one, but it is not very clear which” (}). His work ‘‘is very singularly composed in a Northern dialect,” and ‘of all his contempo- raries he is the least regarded as an authority upon the state of the tongue at the time he wrote.” After asummary of pronominal forms in the ‘ Ayenbite’ (p. 90): ‘‘ It will be observed from this summary,” the author remarks, ‘that the adverbs are declined like nouns, and that the numbers and genders of pronouns in the oblique cases cannot be determined by their form, but must be traced back to their substantives.” A short course in Old and Mid- dle English would have prevented all this, —The ‘Choephori of A®schylus,’ by Dr. A. W. Verrall (Macmillan), is a continuation of that series, the earlier volumes of which by the same editor, the ‘Seven against Thebes’ and the ‘Agamemnon,’ have already been no- ticed in these columns. In completeness of apparatus and in literary ability this edition is almost a counterpart of Prof. Jebb’s ‘ Sopho- cles,’ while in scholarship and in sobriety of judgment it suggests contrasts as well as com- parisons with that great work. Dr. Verrall takes his own view of every question, and writes with an ingenuity and élan which are interest- ing even where they do not carry conviction. The chief novelty of the present volume is Dr. Verrall’s explanation of the recognition scene, wherein Electra, visiting her father’s tomb for the purpose of offering oblations, discovers there Orestes’s dedicatory lock of hair, and re- cognizes the owner by some magic process of inference which was ridiculed by the rising generation of Athenian critics, apparently, and which has been something of a stumbling- ' block to classical scholars ever since. A maid- en who was separated from her brother in early childhood divines his presence, after many years, on the evidence of a lock of hair and the conformation of footprints which bear some resemblance to her own. Euripides makes much of this apparent absurdity, and ridicules it expressly in a passage of his ‘‘ Electra,” which has been berated by the anti- Juripideans from Schlegel down. Euripides hints that it is a slip of old age; yet this same old age begat the ‘‘ Agamemnon.” The lovers of Aschylus have regarded it as a trivial or pardonable lapse; to our mind it seems that the emotion of the situation—and a good actor —would carry it off successfully before an au- dience which was not hypercritical. —Dr. Verrall will not listen to this. He main- tains ingeniously, at great length, that the re- cognition is based on a fact known to Aschylus, viz., that Pelopsand his immediate descendants, being from Asia Minor, had some racial pecu- liarity in the shape of the foot and the skull, something marked in the color and texture of the hair, which distinguished them from the Achaian race among whom they had settled. This is felicitous if true, but for its truth Dr. Verrall produces no sort of warrant. This pecu- liarity, he next assumes, was a well-known tra- dition to the audience before whom the play was acted. Lastly, he assumes that this tradition, perfectly familiar to the theatre-goers in A. C. 458, had vanished temporarily forty years later —vanished so completely that Euripides, a pro- fessional playwright, and tolerably conversant with the stock-in-trade of his craft, had no no- tion of its existence. Thisis a large assump- tion with reference to a poet who gives us those quaint survivals of naive tradition that are embedded in the ‘‘Bacchae” and the ‘‘Iphi- geneia among the Taurians”; but the assump- tion becomes comic when we reflect that, at the representation of the ‘‘ Choephori,” Eu- ripides was, in all probability, himself an alert and interested spectator, a young man of about twenty-two, and was therefore, ex- hypothesi, one of the audience on whose per- fect familiarity with the peculiarities of the Pelopid family Aschylus had implicitly relied. In short, Dr. Verrall’s flight of imagination reminds one of the bird of paradise: it is fasci- natingly brilliant to look at, but it does not condescend to touch the vulgar ground of facts, and it does not appear to have a leg to stand on. —The current number of the Bulletin de Correspondance Hellénique is occupied chiefly with the raw material of archzology—a col- lection of Phrygian inscriptions, partly antici- pated by Mr. Ramsay, which are settling by degrees moot points in the geography of Asia Minor; and a descriptive list of hitherto in- edited vases in the museum of the Louvre, which M. E. Pottier contributes towards a complete catalogue. The paper of most gene- ral interest is M. Kambanis’s research as to the construction and period of the great works which drained Lake Copais in Beotia. The system consisted of two parts, a network of canals and embankments connected with the natural outlets, or rock-tunnels, called ‘* Katavothre ” ; secondly, a supplement- ary subterranean tunnel, descending Mount Kephalari, and following its water-courses, connecting and discharging a series of sixteen shafts or wells, sunk at such intervals as to se- cure drainage of the mountain streams. The depth of the shafts varies from 18 to 63 me- tres; the length of the artificial tunnel is not less than 2,400 metres. The former system makes use of the natural outlets, is carried out with more boldness than science, and displays in the stone-work of supporting walls a primi- tive style which resembles that of Mycenz and of the island of Gha close by. Hence M. Kam- banis refers this workmanship, grandiose yet naive, to the Minyans, with whom Greek tra- dition associated it. But the tunnel with its shafts, so precisely arranged and so accurately executed, is the calculated conception of a man of science and the work of experienced hands. It may be compared with a subterra- nean aqueduct about a mile long, pierced by Eupalinus through a mountain in Samos about the sixth century B. C.—a piece of work not less astonishing than the pyramids of Egypt: here, again, however, we find less science and accuracy than in the work at Ke- phaliri. For these reasons, M. Kambanis as- signs this latter undertaking to Crates, an en- gineer contemporary with Aristotle and Alex- ander the Great, who in fact is mentioned by Strabo as a ‘‘mining-engineer,” a native of Chalcis, engaged by the Boeotians to clean out and repair the channels which had become choked and exposed the neighborhood to in- undation. M. Kambanis expresses the highest admiration for the science, the workmanlike skill, energy, and perseverance which could pierce a tunnel so extensive through the hard rock of this region, with the primitive means which the ancients had at their disposal. —Criticism of missionaries and missionary methods on foreign soil is not usually received with gratitude or frequently acted upon, how- ever rational, when the strictures are from “men of the world.” In the Japm Evan- gelist, the first number of which is just issued at Yokohama, we find some uncommonly good sense, and severe but needed criticism, by a veteran American missionary. The facts he states are eloquent in showing that of the six hundred missionaries, male and female, now in Japan, a good many of the older ones— ‘‘perhaps a majority of cases’”—have made ‘‘a mistake that has narrowed the missionary’s field of usefulness, and has marred his life- work.” This mistake has been in not thorough- ly learning the Japanese language, or in acquiring a vocabulary fitted for conversation and public discourse on religious subjects only. In a country where universal politeness is the national characteristic and the slow growth of a millennium, but few, comparatively, of the missionaries are able to talk in private or make a public address on subjects most vital and timely to the Japanese. Unfortunately, this neglect of mastery of the language extends to pen and ink also, for even when Japanese is written it is transliterated into Roman charac- ters. The causes of this radically wrong pro- cedure lay in the visionary hopes, held out by no less a personage than the late Arinori Mori, that the vernacular would be either almost An- glicised or wholly abolished, and also in the eagerness of the natives to learn English. So far from its being a sin to spend time in study of Japanese, so immensely enriched in vocabulary during the past quarter of a cen- tury as to be almost a new language, Dr. De Forest recommends the newer missionaries— one-half of the total having come to Japan during the last five years—to spend three years in the exclusive study of this profoundly interesting tongue, using both script and speech, ‘A nation of 40,000,000, with a_his- tory and traditions that inspire deepest re- verence for the past, cannot be made to break from its language.” Dr. De Forest claims that a Pilate age oanceecn ri Seana os ben ai ME ERIE BESTE

Page 17

Peay antgeoaneee eset ao PRS Jan. 11, 1894] only those able to master the vernacular should be sent out as missionaries. He de- plores the fact that there are too many in the field ‘‘who, though they stay here a century, will not be able to use the language with accu racy or grace” The Romaji Zasshi (Roman- Letter Magazine), though once enjoying a cir- culation of over 6,000 copies, ‘* has died a lingering death.” The Japan Evangelist also contains a translation of a powerful article on “The Good and Evil Effects of Buddhism on {Japanese} History,” from the Kokumin no Tomo (The Nation’s Friend), the Liberal daily newspaper of Tokio. MASSACHUSETTS HISTORIANS. ADAMS'S AND ITS Historians and Its His- tory: An Object-Lesson, By Charles Francis Adams. Boston: Houghton, Mithin & Co. 1893. Pp. iv, 110. THOUGH easily read through at a sitting, this little brochure of Mr. Adams's is likely to cause more discussion than many a volume of more bulky dimensions. In the form of lec- the substance of which Massachusetts, Its tures, was delivered before the students of Harvard University in April, 1893, Mr. Adams has elaborated views of the history of Massachusetts in regard to religious liberty, and of the treatment of that theme by Massachusetts historians, already indicated in his ‘ Three Episodes,’ published in 1892, and in the spirit of Mr. Brooks Adams's ‘Emancipation of Massachusetts.’ It is need less to say that Mr. Adams has put his thoughts in a form that is telling and brilliant, and that holds the interest of the reader as it must have held the attention of the Harvard undergraduates. To the author's thinking g, the value of the history of Massachusetts, as of any other land, is in its relation to the great human drama, “The Emancipation of Man from Superstiticn and Caste.” In regard to the latter of the two phases of this world-wide struggle, Mr. Adams declares : ‘** The record of no community seems to me to be more creditable, more consistent, nor, indeed, more important,” than that of But her record as a whole, and Massachusetts. Toleration, until a comparatively recent period, has been scarcely even creditable.” That this story has been defended in its es- sential features by a great school of writers whom Mr. Adams designates as the ‘‘ filio-pie tistic,” and of whom Palfrey may serve as a type, is due, in the author's estimate, to a pro vincial neglect of the principle that, ‘tin the study of history, there should be but one law for all. Patriotism, piety, and filial duty have nothing to do with it; they are, indeed, mere spares and sources of delusion.” ‘as respects Religious In reality, Mr. Adams holds, Massachusetts, in the person of her ministers and magistrates, ** missed a great destiny ” and Sir Harry Vane, and the Antinomians ; and gave herself up to an intolerance as un worthy as that of Philip II. or Louis XIV., and even more indefensible, since the Puritans, unlike the sovereigns of Spain and France, sinned against better knowledge, refusing ** to by rejecting Roger Williams, see a light which they had seen clearly enough in England.” This wilful and inexcusable intolerance, be coming the fixed policy of the commonwealth by the time of the Antinomian synod of 1°37, led to a * theologico-glacial * period, lasting till 1761, during which, under the chilling in- fluence of enforced uniformity, mental activi- - Nation. ty dwindled, and which has left as its typical products fhe works of Cotton Mather and Jonathan literary boulders deposited by the receding ice.” Edwards—** huge The religious the ture, apparently, which impresses Mr only fea Adams is his overwrought picturings of future suffer of his en system of Edwards —of which ing—isthe characteristic ‘* outcome vironment.” Thesystem of reasoning on which the up. *‘ by putting a final stop to any intelle I \ theology of this glacial period was built tual movement, created a universal paraly sis—this system had to be slowly outgrown These ‘ Calvinistic, orthodox seventeenth eighteenth tuted nothing more nor less than an tenets of the and centuries const! outrage on human nature productive in all probability On the con trary, they ied to * phases of acute mania,” of 1691-12 and of no beneficial results whatever which the witcheraft delusion of the “‘Great Awakening” of 1734-44 were the natural manifestation In all this period, Mr. Adams holds, the re deeming feature was ‘‘that political activity which in Massachusetts had from the very be ginning flowed as a stream of living water be neath the thick ice-crust of theology the dominance of this characteristic that gave distinction to the next period, 1761-17 which Mr. Adams conceives Benjamin Fran! lin and Samuel and John Adams to have been **more than any other typical of the environ It was Si, of ment.” suppression of And this ep ch passed over, after the into the florescent,” period, extending Shavs's rebellion, ‘scientific. or from 1788 to 1865. To this latter age alone Massachusetts letters belong, for ‘From Cotton Mather to Nathaniel Haw thorne is along stride, but in Massachusetts lit rature there is po intermediate The Magnalia was published in 170, 7 stepping-stone Told Tales in 1837, that vear of profuse germ pation: and, between the two, so different and vet both distinct and unmistakable products of the Massachusetts mind, the one a boulder and the other a flower—between them there is nothing.” Adams quali to Franklin's autobio This sweeping statement Mr With a reference fies graphy as a ‘possible exception,” and are cognition, in a note, that * Thanatopsis ip peared in IS Now there ibt that Mr principle that history should be written wit! can be no dor out ‘‘filio-pietistic”™” bias is correct, and bas been often sinned rians. It is true, also, that effort has | made by the school which Mr. Adams V ways justly criticises to gloss over and defend that which is not always defensib! Mr in saving elsewhe of religious tolerance the Puritan exiles to New England showed that thev w not in advance of their times That they w pot Was again an element of their strength: for they were essentially practical men, and not idealists Nevertheless it seems clear that i criticism, Mr. Ad shas gone to an extren almost as excessive as that which he opposes The repressive px v of New England was one partly of political defence, partly of rel gious persecution, at least in its earlier mani festations. Massa setts hist ans have usu ally made e phase the ott f this two-fold motive exclusively prominent. They ave eithe ke Palfrey, largely ignored the 5} us ment t ntolerance based on purely religious ns ations, and excused almost everything on the plea of political neces sitv, or, like Mr. Adams. they have fixed at tention onlv on the element of ceution, and have practk ally « the repressive Williams the sv alled bert Ch any system, and, as such, were religious +. but in part, position of the Spain of senters from the national fait! t Was e363 religious perse ] unted as nothing the exigencies of the political situation But sinst Roger is, and Ro ld with ~ had a twofold iim. In part they were designed to prevent interference with the established religious s worthy f Mr Adams's widetination they were the produ . alse of Louis XIN where no real ground for, tical fear existed in the presences 1 few “ the posits n of Holland, where a i] Wat » tolerati minians shows how even H ttiders ld po maintain its erpment in the should disturbances at hoa r Appes ‘arliament provoke English ° And, in so far iwits Aa ms Wet Trane nh} seventeenth century that of New England dimpl ritative character of a divine was entirely the work of tl mind Reason, establish New Mrs laimed another n. or former councils, or is, was from the first the only because Hutchinson and the Quakers « gious matters that Now which Jed in ioxious to the Puritan was this principle one evitably, if slowly, to an intelligent religious freedom; it made the New England pulpit in tellectual and argumentative, and it taught n to think—for there religious truth claimed fy held to be same pre sCOSSES by every Puritan congregati Was no insight inte the ministry which was not attaina ble through pre the unclerical man As Mr isely the Adams has els« where pointed out (‘Three Episodes,’ p. 574), the Antinomian movement had nothing bette: to offer. One may venture further and hold that if this movement, from the repression of which Myr age, had triumphed, it would, by substituting Adams dates the Massachusetts ice mysticism for reason, have substituted a worse principle for a better Mr. Adams fails also to make due allowances

Page 18

34 The Nation. [Vol. 58, No. 1489 for the practical teachings of the New England ministry and for the value of their work asa moral force. One feature of that instruction, certainly open to severe criticism, has attracted his notice; but picturings of future woe, how- ever prevalent, formed only a fragment of New England religious teaching. An examination of the sermons of Edwards, for example, shows that the large majority were on themes recog- nized by religious teachers of all ages as of the highest practical importance. The excesses of the ‘Great Awakening” were, what one finds no hint of in Mr. Adams's pages, local and ex- ceptional; the more fanatic aspects of the movement were combated by the faculties of Harvard and Yale and by leading ministers of Massachusetts ard Connecticut. The preach- ing of the Rev. James Davenport, which he quotes, was no more typical of the pulpit of the colony of Connecticut, whose General Court sent him home, than that of William Miller of the New England of 1843. Mr. Adams has designated the last of bis periods as ‘‘florescent.” The epithet is apt, for it describes its relationship to the epoch which he far less happily characterizes as ‘“‘ gla- cial.” Flowers do not come from boulders. Florescence implies a period of unflowering growth, which is none the less true life. Nor is a comparison of the literary unproductivity of a country of scanty resources and cramped material life, like the New England of the se- venteenth and eighteenth centuries, with the productivity of the mother country in the same period, quite adequate. Rather it should be judged by the standards of other English colonies, and, when tested thus, it had a gene- ral diffusion of intellectual vigor which they have not equalled, and its fruitage, when it came at last, was richer than any they have borne. It is not entirely, as Mr. Adams would have it, an illustration of ‘‘ the post ergo prop- ter fallacy” to hold that, where training has been followed by such results, the training can- not have been wholly an evil. Massachusetts persecution was bad enough; but it was largely the working of the intoler- ance of a thinking community, engaged in an enterprise characterized by intensity of belief and threatened by considerable perils from without. It was not marked, in general, by personal vindictiveness. It was free from popular blood-thirstiness. It never took the deep hold on the people that it did in Spain or France. Detrimental it undoubtedly was; but that it, or the period of intense conviction of which it was one of the characteristics, did the full amount of harm that Mr. Adams holds it did, seems far from proved. HUXLEY’S ESSAYS. Method and Results; Essays. By Thomas H. Huxley. D. Appleton & Co. 1893. HUXLEY’s collected essays are to appear in nine volumes, of which this is the first. It is well-printed and agreeable to read. An intro- ductory autobiography will serve to remind readers what Huxley’s real profession is. He has, to use his own language, ‘‘subordinated” his ‘ambition for scientific fame” to the ‘ popu- larisation of science” (in his separate treatises) and (in his essays) to an ‘‘endless series of battles and skirmishes ” with ecclesiasticism and other powers. Intellectual nettles are these essays, suggestive and stimulating to the point of painfulness. Though Huxley is not a physiologist, bis branch of science lies near to pbysiology, and physiology borders «louse upon metaphysics; and a remarkably well-read man in philosophy (for an outsider) Huxley is. This goes to feed and strengthen his originality, and gives it breadth. At the same time, it greatly heightens the literary interest and animation of his essays. Not that he does not sometimes show that his reading has been hasty, and that the tedious operation of rumination, which is so necessary in philo- sophical thought, has been a little abridged. Thus, he adheres to the sect of English nomi- nalism—the school of Ockham, Hobbes, Locke, Hartley, Berkeley, Hume, Bentham, and the Mills—without perceiving how antagonistic they are, upon the whole, to the spirit of science. One of the prime doctrines of these men, for instance, a doctrine inherited from the pre-scientific ages, is that ail generalization is a mere matter of convenience. The scien- tific man, on the other hand, without theoriz- ing about generals, implicitly holds that laws are really operative in nature, and that the classification he is so painfully trying to find out is expressive of real facts. In short, the two classes of thinkers take the con and the pro of the question concerning universals. As the printer’s devil would have it, Huxley’s opinion is expressed on the bottom of a right- hand page and the top of the following left- hand one. We read (p. 117): ‘ Classification is merely a convenient [turn over] facts”; which sounds like a patch-work of two sentences. He follows the Mills in speaking of Hobbes with an ex- travagance of laudation which is amazing, as coming from a scientific man. What! will you call that man a great reasoner who could write treatises to uphold a circle-squaring fallacy, and whom John Waliis, hardly a mathematician of the first class, could so ut- terly demolish as he did? What! will you speak of him as an exponent of the spirit of science who is known in physics only by bis peculiarly virulent opposition to Boyle's method and its results, and whom Boyle, a weakish sort of disputant, laid out so hand- somely ? Huxley praises Hobbes’s ‘‘ vigorous English”; but Hobbes’s style, both of writing and of thinking, as well as the chief substance of his doctrines, is borrowed, or closely imi- tated, from William of Ockham. Now Ock- ham was a brilliant thinker, and some people fancy there was something modern-like about his thought. Nota bit of it; another mind so completely steeped in scholasticism of the most intensely wordy kind can hardly be instanced. Hobbes was an original thinker, even if not a very great one, but his method of thinking is scholastic, wooden, what Huxley calls ‘a priori,” and anti-scientific im the extreme. Two extraordinary ideas have come to the modern consciousness from Hobbes. One is the association of ideas, which he undoubtedly stole from Aristotle; and the other 1s the theory of Motives, which, though it has im- posed upon the world, is, in the view of many modern psychologists, a mere logical jugglery, a circle-squarer’s style of thought. Two of the most impressive essays in this volume, making a fifth of its bulk, are devoted to the praise of Descartes as the great scientific philosopher of his age. In fact, when Huxley entitles this volume ‘ Method and Results,’ he means thereby to declare that the * Discours de la méthode’ is the true exposition of the me- thod of science. More profitable reading than these two essays of Huxley on Descartes the literature of our time has not afforded. Never- theless, it is impossible that the judgment of history upon Descartes should be reversed. That judgment is that while his geometry was simply the making of modern mathematics, al’ expression of his other ideas proved utterly unprofitable and unscientific. Prof. Huxley may persuade us to dock the last epithet, but, about the other, his- tory cannot be wrong. ‘‘ There are some men,” says Huxley, ‘‘ who are counted great because they represent the a of their own age, and murror it as it is. Such an one was Voltaire, of whom it was epigrammatically said, ‘he expressed every- body’s thoughts better than anybody.’ But there are other men who attain greatness be- cause they embody the potentiality of their own day, and magically reflect the future. They express the thoughts which will be every- body’s two or three centuries after them. Such an one was Descartes.” What a thing that to say of a man! And Huxley fairly makes it out. How can it be that, for all that, Cartesianism was scientifi- cally barren, except in geometry, while there so richly fertile? It was a pretty complete theory of logic, nature, and the soul—the three categories under which Hegel has well summed up philosophy. But systematic completeness, as Hegel’s own system well shows, is about the idlest decoration that can be attached to a philosophy. The great desideratum for a phi- losophy, its indispensable condition, was first stated by a thinker whom Huxley treats with uncalled-for hauteur—Auguste Comte; that is to say, a philosophy, to be fruitful, must be ‘* positive ’—it must lead to unmistakable con- sequences comparable in great detail with ob- servation. If it does that, and if those conse- quences are verified to any considerable ex- tent, it will aid the advance of knowledge. It is that which has made evolution, in the defi- nite form given to it by Darwin, a great agent of discovery. But was not this character possessed by the theories of Descartes? Per- haps: but if they were ‘‘ positive” theories, they were not theories which there was any prospect of being able to put to the test to any considerable extent, then and there, in the state of mathematics and of observational means which were at command. Hence, though Huxley can show us now that the Cartesian ideas had a scientific character, yet, for practi- cal purposes, they had not that character for the men of that time. But this was not their only defect. It has been repeatedly pointed out by students of the history of mechanics that De- seartes’s theories really grievously offended the very rule of philosophizing upon which he had himself so muchinsisted. They were not clear and distinct. Worse than that—for that, in itself, would not have been fatal—they were not capable of being made clear and distinct. Like the works of many other philosophers, at first glance they seemed beautifully sharp-out- lined, but, when closely studied, they were found to be a composite of nebulz which no scrutiny could resolve. They wanted that fundamental perspicuity to which so few writers except mathematicians attain, which consists in this, that, unintelligible as they may seem at first reading, yet when they are closely studied they are seen to be based upon the dis- tinctions which were pertinent to the problem. In his long and deeply interesting discussion of Descartes’s theory that animals are automa- tons, Huxley manifests the great disadvantage under which a comparative anatomist must labor who is not an engineer, or who has not a practical acquaintance with anabytical me- chanics. He thinks he makes out very clearly that animals (man included) act like machines. But he uses neither the language nor eoncep- tions of dynamics. Far from convincing a student of mechanics, be leaves him profound- ly convinced of the disparity between machines and animals. He talks about ‘* causes,” but the student of dynamics has nothing to do with

Page 19

ae IASON LERNER ye

Jan. 11, 1894] ‘causes. That a machine could possibly act asa frog deprived of his front brain is ce scribed as acting is what Huxley does not make at all clear toa man whose business bas lain with machines and with mechanical systems Another fifth of the volume is taken up with a review of the Progress of Science in the first fifty years of the reign of Victoria, IS37-LSS87 Among its many suggestions, we have only

space to notice the following ‘The doctrine of evolution, so far as the present physical cosmos is concerned, postu lates the fixity of the rules of operation of the causes of motion in the material universe beac But it is possible to raise the question whether this universe . . may not itself be a product of evolution from a universe of such matter, in which the manifestations of energy were not definite—in which, for ex ample, our laws of motion held good for some units and not for others, or for the same units at one time and not at another—and which would therefore be a real epicurean chance world’ For myself, | must confess that I tind the air of this region of speculation too rari fied for my constitution, and | am disposed to take refuge in ignoramus et ignorabimus.” It is always unphilosophical to say ignorahi wus, and the shores of science are strewn with the wrecks of such predictions. It is particu larly rash to base such a prediction on the . . > circumstance that the author of it would be perplexed to see how the problem is to be made amenable to exact reasoning. One-third of the volume is taken up with re cent essays concerning the general theory of polities. They are very far below the level of Huxley’s work of twenty years ago, and, in comparison, seem almost mediocre, although they contain a good deal of interesting infor mation concerning the history of some of the theories. The pretence that one can see no meaning in the statement that all men are born free and equal, would hardly have been patient ly tolerated by our Revolutionary forefathers Huxley reviles Rousseau as a mere sentimen- talist. Of course, Rousseau was a sentimental ist by conviction, and it is quite true that, since he wrote, the world has received terrible proof of the evil of exaggerated sentimental ism. Still, civilization rests, and must rest, mainly upon sentiment. Prof. Huxley seems to pass a sweeping condemnation upon the ap plication of what he calls “a prior? reasoning ~ to questions of justice. By “a priori reason- ing” he means deduction from general princi ples, such as Rousseau practised; but Huxley's general condemnation of this mode of argu mentation makes it incumbent upon bim to explain how be would have a court of justice reason. He even goes so far as to sneer at the principle of toleration. Where would Huxley, or any other evolutionist who lived in the sixties, have been without that principle’ The principle of toleration is intimately connected with the fundamental principle of science, for it can have no rational basis except the a knowledgment that nothing is absolutely cet tain. In those branches of physics where knowledge is the most perfect, in metrology, geodesy, and astronomy, no self-respecting man would consent to put forward an assel tion without coupling with it his estimate its probable error. What scientitic men meat by “science ™ is not knowledge, but sfigoa tion. Now the scientifi nan will not shut off any question whatever as too sacred or too we known for further investigation. and t he must tolerate every opinion. But t in regard to questions of politics and the scientific man must admit that can the true alternatis ot bx rtai ed, but also that no formula can be frat whose possible consequences shall] be st: al

The Nation. for that reason it is most desirable that, ak

te tte ~ ? A a ‘ side of the formula which is less erroneous, f six V nies pposite formula which is more ert f ele : st al should constantly have its rdvocates, so th theref is Inay not be forgotten when the moment « at which it is to be preferred to the other il f . this point of view, what Huxley calls ** the Thus, to choose an ex doetrine of modern liberalism, that the tolera the section before us tion of error is a good thing in itself.” appears | squie unknown t has to be not, after all, out of harmony with the with a rare Old Lrish w | ideas of science, } historical noection has | tra In the last essay Huxley discusses, in an ever- | etyn ev of i sun ta lnteresting manner, the pposing claims of tos hough t “ Individualism, or /aissez-fatre, and Socialism, | back than L770; that or, as | hooses to call it | ere at ned | voned late Gd br ‘ reaches the easy ! sion that neith in ty ivf Mand sens sk ‘ udmittedas an absolute pr pl rt ath. | i er lam he leaves t] matt Without s not surely ¢ i WN ing the oby s remark that ev itionis S } and the word ts t . plies a third political max perhaps super rja t ities, W to either of tl thers. For. th ! rent W tt " s ims admit that man was developed from an ape, | lish, Known from t six! Whether suddenly or by insensible degrees, we | t es back t ire led to surmise that the rudiments of gov- | alone wit! tt ernment antedated humanity At anv rat support it, and w ‘ vyovernment must be considered as one of those | Ss f adaptive characters of the ¢ s/ wl erb t sult from development This is true not ovals ~ P , government generally, but of each special fort LV ; ESOS ANY s rowth and strengt red Ww vst s . that there is no all ation f suff . i : ft . mankind except wit) g i Dies e \ t tion, and the res Ne t “ s x zw ! is whe the garn f i ve | “W t s s t | s hands hav ts ug features y th S ul strit Lot? 1 . 7 solat = tot ~ st eigion W we | eve st : ib quota sw t i Xa their posit fa \ ¢ a3) shite 1 ' tat that ~ Vas esson of inte tua ecrity as been tf iw w have Sl an, I7IS, and S penal cenit ad etest este’ ; \Villiam Hamilt . intieipat Ma ae t irety sy sw t te h : \ ~ stances yina . \ es Aut M r etree n the first svilable ih \ ~ i ; * oD ‘ b aiready iti sixteenth centur Con x \ xt ( st i svilable began to be asso wit Press: New York: 3 : s caece nd perhaps by t | M ays ( s s " S nteenth and eighteent! entur “ ‘ . s 32 vas this t t. wh th ‘ e - ~ ‘ . : z the ti ind tl p! ! i it m4 e with t i il fi tl | N t i i tl! Woalke : fata 2 | ‘ t ; t ve ead fe " the v raf thle in \ ~ t ‘ teenth-centul thelas, coutelase t . eXxtens t through the intermediate perversion KR. N. QV. N.Y. Z and thre " fit nr and frlas urtelacs fa - > sa | © ye jaritie which it tennis I] that st not ‘ be rr red for | form eurtal ar, with its variants, wi rd Sw ss ewhat xeess of ( The re- ! tinct from cuflass that at acquired |

Page 20

The Nation. [Vol. 58, No. 1489 36 permanent standing, the identification of the final part with ar being favored by the use of the weapon in delivering slashing blows”; (3) court-lodge for curtilage (i. e., cortil, courtil, little court or garth, plus the Romanic suffix -age, which piain folks, however, took for a compound of court with lodge, ledge, etc ). The literate are responsible for the ‘‘ merely graphic 6” in crumb (crum), which began to be added in the sixteenth century,” and “probably appeared first in the derivative crumble (where it has also invaded the pronun- ciation), after words of French origin like humble; there was also the apparent analogy of Old English words like dumb, where b was retained in the spelling, though no longer pronounced: cf. thimb.” Culprit, which is “‘ known (as a word) only from 1678,” is an ab- breviation by the legal profession. An abun- dance of evidence is cited by Dr. Murray in confirmation of the legal tradition ‘‘ that when the prisoner had pleaded ‘Not guilty,’ the Clerk of the Crown replied with, ‘ Culpable: prest d’averrer nostre bille, i. e., ‘Guilty; {and Iam] ready to aver our indictment’; that this reply was noted on the rollin the form cul, prist, etc.; and that, at a later time, after the disuse of law French, this formula was mistaken for an appellation addressed to the accused” instead of a negation of his plea, etc. Among the educated, again, cult, ‘ worship,’ was used in the seventeenth century, perhaps direct from the Latin, then went out of fashion, and is rarely met with till the middle of the nine- teenth, ‘‘ when often spelt culte as in French.” Indebtedness to the French has been masked, on the other hand, in the locution curry favor (1510), which is the older curry favel (1400), from ‘Old French estriller fauvel, . . . to curry the.chestnut horse, hence, to employ de- ceit or hypocrisy, to gloze.” Deliberate inven- tions are exemplified in cyclone, ‘‘a name in- troduced in 1848 by H. Piddington, as a general name for all storms or atmospheric disturb- ances in which the wind has a circular or whirling course.” Carlyle alone has found culottic a handy synonym for respectable, and its noun culoftism for respectability; nor do the French appear to have been tempted to ap- propriate them. Herman Melville is first cited as having given literary currency to the form curio, for curiosity (1851). The historical function of the Dictionary is well displayed under curfew, beginning with the definition : “(1.) a. A regulation in force in medieval Europe by which, at a fixed hour in the eve- ning, indicated by the ringing of a bell, fires were to be covered over or extinguished; also, the hour of evening when this signal was given, and the bell rung for the purpose. b. Hence, the practice of ringing a bell at a fixed hour in the evening, usually eight or nine o’clock, continued after the original purpose was obso- lete, and often used as a signal in connection with various municipal or communal regula- tions ; the practice of ringing the evening bell still survives in many towns.” Here we will introduce the illustration bor- rowed from Lyell’s ‘Second Visit to the United States’ (1850): ‘‘ Every evening at nine o'clock, a great bell, or curfew, tolls in the market- place of Montgomery, after which no colored man is permitted to be abroad without a pass.” Then Dr. Murray takes up the parable : ‘““The primary purpose of the curfew ap- pears to have been the prevention of conflagra- tions arising from domestic fires left unex- tinguished at night. The earliest English quo- tations make no reference to the original sense of the word; the curfew being already in the thirteenth century merely a name for the ring- ing of the evening bell, and the time so mark- arr The statement that the curfew was introduced into England by William the Con- queror as a measure of political repression has been current since the sixteenth century, but rests on no early historical evidence. See Free- man’s ‘Norman Conquest’ (1875), iii., 185, as to what ‘seems to be the origin of the famous and misrepresented curfew.’ ” We conclude our already too extended re- marks by observing that the true, and only, English use of cui bono? is, as appears from the earliest to the latest quotations, ‘‘ what good 2” “‘to what end?” “the ultimate pur- pose?” The classic sense ‘“‘ who profits 7” in other words, is not good English, and it is im- pertinent to hold us to it. The Letters of Lady Burghersh, afterwards Countess of Westmoreland, from Germany and Frante during the Campaign of 1813-14. Edited by her daughter, Lady Rose Weigall. London: John Murray. 1893. PRISCILLA, the daughter of William Wellesley Pole, afterwards Lord Maryborough, grand- daughter of the musical Earl of Mornington, and niece of the great Duke of Wellington, married, in 1811, Lord Burghersh, eldest son of the Earl of Westmoreland. Lady Burghersh was then only eighteen. Lord Burghersh had been aide-de-camp to the Duke of Wellington in the Peninsula, and two years after his mar- riage he was appointed military attaché at the headquarters of the allied sovereigns in Germany, and was ordered to Berlin. But all French and Dutch ports were closed to English vessels, and Hamburg had again been seized by Bonaparte, so that the journey had to be made from Yarmouth to the south of Sweden, and thence across the Baltic to Stralsund, on the coast of Prussia. Lady Burghersh had hitherto been so delicate that her family urged her not to attempt such a journey, but as she had no children to leave behind, she de- termined to accompany her husband. After being driven back to Yarmouth and delayed there by contrary winds for nearly a fort- night, Lord and Lady Burghersh landed in Sweden after an eleven days’ passage, across the North Sea. From the landing-place they had to walk most of the way to Gothen- burg, with nothing to eat but Swedish cakes, baked only twice in the year and as hard as stone, and nothing to drink but a little rum and water. From Gothenburg they drove in their own carriage to Ystad, the port in the south of Sweden at which they were to embark for Prussia. This drive of 250 English miles occupied four days from eight in the morning till midnight; horses could be hired, but the rope harness had to be bought. Lady Burghersh had everything to arrange, for her husband was much occupied, and her French maid (afterwards most efficient) had not recovered from the voyage, and would only say, ‘‘J’ai tant souffert que ma mémoire ne me sert plus.” Beds had to be carried, for the inns provided only an empty room of a few feet square in which to eat and sleep. Lady Burghersh writes: ‘‘ We do very well. I have never seen a carpet or curtain, basin or jug, but we send the servants into the yard to snatch up the pans the chickens feed out of, or the pails from the stable, and make use of them.” The passage of seventy miles from Ystad to Stralsund took three days, and the latter part had to be made in a galliot, ‘‘a small thing with one mast and no cabin,” so that Lady Burghersh and her maid sat ina boat on deck. Just as the galliot entered the harbor at Stral- sund, an English brig, laden with nine thousand barrels of ball cartridges, blew up. ‘‘ The balls and splinters of the ship came rattling down like a thick shower of hail. Every man fell flat on his face except B, who threw himself over me.” On looking up, the whole sky was covered with black smoke, and not a single vestige of the ship was left; the effect on the sea was exactly as if it boiled. Lady Burg- hersh was so wholly intent on the magnificence of the sight that, as she says, she neither jumped nor trembled, but said to her terrified maid, ‘* Mais regardez donc; comme c'est beau.” No- body was hurt on board the galliot, but houses were wrecked two miles off. The journey south from Stralsund to Berlin occupied nearly a week, although Lord and Lady Burghersh were in their carriage nineteen hours out of the twenty-four. They reached Berlin just after the great battle of Leipzig: prisoners were arriving in large numbers, in- cluding several French marshals, and nearly forty thousand wounded were in the city. The ladies of Berlin had sold their jewels, and hal sent their horses to the army; and at the daily receptions of Princess Radziwill everybody was busied in scraping lint. Before long, Lord Burghersh had to follow the allied forces to Frankfort, and his young wife, after enduring three weeks of suspense as to his fate, deter- mined to make her own way thither. Accom- panied by her maid, and attended by an Eng- lish officer, who was an old friend of her hus- band’s, Lady Burghersh undertook this journey of nine days, travelling in the depths of a Ger- man winter from two hours before daylight till ten o’clock at night. She writes: ‘““We have come all along the line of the French retreat, and, as it is not a month since they passed, the roads are covered with dead horsesand the remainsof dead men. . . . Every bridge blown up, every village burnt or pulled down, fields completely devastated, orchards all turned up. None of the country people will bury the French or their horses, so there they remain lying all over the fields and roads, with millions of crows feeding: the river Saale full of dead bodies.” One night Lady Burghersh had to pass in a wretched cottage crowded with soldiers; she lay on the carriage cushions spread on the floor of a windowless, fireless room, and in that bitter November night her only rug was a great coat. Yet, she says, ‘I slept well, and set off merrily next morning.” Frankfort, where Lady Burghersh at last rejoined her husband, was full of sovereigns and ambassa- dors, the only women besides herself being two Russian grand-duchesses, sisters of the Emperor, and the Princess of Thurn and Taxis, sister of the late Queen Louise of Pru:- sia. The squabbling and indecision among all the different powers was incredible, and Lady Burghersh often longed for her firm and de cided uncle Wellington to be the one head to whom all should look up; The Emperor Alexander, in speaking to her of the recent campaign in Russia, regretted that he had not had such a commander as Wellington. As it was, he added, ‘‘c’est que le bon Dieux nous a servi de capitaine, et que l’exemple des An- glais nous a donné du courage.” A month later Lady Burghersh writes: ‘‘ We are just as far from any decision. The Emperor Francis and all his people are bent on one plan; the Emperor Alexander is directly against it; and the King of Prussia disapproves of both. They are all equally positive and obstinate.” At length the Austrians prevailed, and a move was made to Lérrach, a village close to Basle. Lord and Lady Burghersh had here only one small room, and the aide-de-camp slept on straw in the kitchen, but Lady Burghersh made English tea every evening, and all the ait on cae «

Page 21

BESSA 31d ee

acommnessietth

Sabha ney e St papas ng

ae Jan. 11, 1894]

generals and their respective staffs met in her room to discuss the position and to receive re- ports. The bombardment of Huningue near Basle was going on, and Prince Schwarzenberg, the Austrian general, had a hut built from which Lady Burghersh could watch the pro- gress of the siege by day. At night she saw from her bed the shells bursting, but, after a short time, the noise ceased to disturb her sleep. Household troubles did, however, an- noy her. The German landlady threatened to drive Lady Burghersh’s chasseur out of the house, and the English footman declared with tears that he should lose his senses because his country was insulted. Early in 1814 Lady Burghersh followed her husband to the headquarters of the allied forces at Langres in France; her first stage was thirty-one hours, during which time she never left her carriage. At that period the allies were everywhere received with open arms, and Lady Burghersh, while rejoicing as a wife in the probable termination of the war, adds: ‘‘ As a soldier I must think it a pity to have had the power and not to have crushed that wretch [Bonaparte].” She accompanied or followed the allied forces from place to place, mourning over the misery and destitution around her. The troops had been insulted at Langres, and from that time no efforts of the commanders could either maintain discipline or prevent pillage throughout the greater part of the armies; the Cossacks knew no law, and robbed friends and foes alike; the streets of the towns were crowded with women and children begging for food, and Lady Burghersh ac- knowledges herself to be sick of war and all itshorrors. A congress, consisting of six mem- bers, was opened at Chatillon, but they did little but give great dinners to each other, and the uncertainty and indecision continued. Lady Burghersh wrote from Chatillon: ‘‘ 1don’t know what they mean to do, but I know that Bona- parte is employing all his energy, all his ac- tivity, and all his power, and that we are dilatory, uncertain, and (enfre nous) fright- ened.” Lord Burghersh was again separated from his wife, and for a fortnight they had no news of each other. At last, quite at the end of March, Schwartzenberg gained a decisive vic- tory over Bonaparte, and a few days later the allies entered Paris. Lady Burghersh missed this magnificent sight, as she had had to retire to Dijon, in order to avoid Bonaparte and his Lord Aberdeen, Lord Castlereagh, and Prince Metternich, entreated her to wait before attempting the journey to Paris, but without consulting them further she set out with only her maid and footman. She was once arrested on the way, but was de- tained only for a few hours, and, after a jour- ney of three days @nd nights, she joined Lord Burghersh in Paris. Lord Aberdeen and Lord Castlereagh never forgave her for having reached Paris before them. On the conclusion of the war, Lord Burg- hersh entered the diplomatic service, and was British minister at Florence for sixteen years, at Berlin for nine years, and at Vienna for six years. Lady Burghersh had twelve children, and although she thoroughly enjoyed the culti vated and brilliant society with which she and Lord Burghersh were everywhere surrounded, her heart was always in her home. vived her husband for twenty years, and died arly in 1879, at the age of eighty-six troops. Her advisers, She sur-

‘The Nation. The Paris Law Courts Sketches of Men and Manners. Translated from the French by Gerald P. Moriarty Charles Scribner's Sons. 1St, THE illustrations with which this work is adorned will be a sutfticient of legal not intended for him. sutiicient, the fact presented is based upon a French original, * Le Palais de Justice de Paris,” which was pro duced by members of the ** Association de la institutions that it is Were this warning not grave student that the translation here Presse Judiciare,” would stamp the charactet of the work unmistakably. taken by the journalist engaged in gathering The point of view at the courts such items as the public are sup posed to delight in, is altogether different from that of the jurist or legal antiquary. But it must be conceded that the art of graphic writ ing is not one in which the authors of works upon comparative jurisprudence have excelled, and that the idea we get of the English courts from Dickens's stories, although somewhat dis torted, is more vivid than that obtainable from other sources. Dickens's pictures, however, were generally caricatures and were always *xaggerated, while the aim of the French re porters in this enterprise is a serious one, and is carried out with as much sobriety as the na ture of this class of writers admits of. We have accordingly an unquestionably accurate description of whatever is to be seen by the eyes and heard by the ears at the Palais de Paris—so much so that a careful reader would feel quite at home were he to visit these halls, and would be able to under stand the general movement of business with Justice in sufficient clearness. Further than this we can not go, for we know little more of the nature of the law that is administered in France after reading this book than we did before; and, al though we are constantly reminded of the dif are not able to form any consistent idea of them. In faet, as the authors probably no acquaintance with other systems of practice, and had no in tention of writing for readers outside of their own country, we could hardly expect to get ferences in the procedure, we have more than a superticial view of the subject Yet if we bear in mind that our jurispru dence is distinguished from that of France by two fundamental peculiarities—the use of the jury in civil actions, and the limitation of the functions of the judge in criminal proce: to the application and exposition of the law itis easy to see that we are upon familiar ground. We listen to the same c the delays of the law, of excessive costs, of numberless fees, of absurd technicalities, of

judicial arrogance, of the litiga tion for the poor, et f the different courts, it ts true, e me thodical French mind has es vision of judicial labor much farther than we have: but, human nature being pretty much the same everywhere, the character of the griev- ances that are brought before the courts is not very different. Nor is the aspect of Frenel litigants and lawyers and criminals anything peculiar, as we may learn from betl » text and the illustrations. Of these, by the way, We may speak strongly are as a rule

spirited and suggestive, « itly taken from life iwh with a touch of caricature, yet true and goal character-drawing. Per-

text, which is as clear as a as sprightly as a column of forcibly suggest the fami wn court-houses that we ap

it say that they were cleverer warning to the

Alth nal cases in magh trial by jury takes place in crimi France, it has its peculiarities Phe number of jurwmen is very small, thirty six bemg expected to try all the cases of a term, and the number of challenges is limite! to twelve to each party. Hence the constitu tion of the jury, which of course is frequently of the véimost consequence, becomes a matte: upon which the highest talents are by the advocates The exercise! antecedents of thes three dozen men are carefully studied by coun sel, both for the prosecution and the defence their political opinions, the religious views iigtt their wives, their family connections are all minutely investigated. In a case tried a few years ago in Corsica the selection of tl ury was so carefully attended to that when ¢ number was at last complete, the 4 général leaned toward the nsel for the fendant and said, with a smuilk Your mat acquitted by ten votes to tw So he is answered the other when | oked ower tl list, and so it proved to be when the v Was given Neither evidence nor eloaque: had affected the foreordained result. But we fear that stories as bad as this rhed bee t English juries \ pret the whole we mav sav that those wl want a good guidebook to ¢ baris tx 4 intelligible a int { t Anne! wi business is there transacted, and some Fret moralizing of at . me ving arn ter, Ww tind their requin satis \ met by this t n } KS rHE W K Abbots ! T ters a . a 4 aria eas sors Walte ~ < A.& C, Black ; New York: Ma . $ Adama, Prof ; Rh Civ ’ { La Mie Ages Seribners 2 Anti Higher Criticis r. Test ‘ allidality f the Ribl Hunt & Fa s Osa wd

o att Sohrab and Rustum Maynard Merrill & Cx Lv cents ATK ims Philly The Ff Transforma f Power le fou Crosby wkwowd & S Now rk » Van Nostrand « Rayne, Tt is Seott’s mi of t sles xfor Clarer Press: New York Ma ‘ Benson, F Six Common 1 es n Osgood M va x Bercy, t h Reader for Advanced Classes. W R. Jenkins Fe Brvy« James. Legal Studies in the niversity Ma n a ents Bu Rev. S ¢ rhe {William A. Bucking t ar vert necticut. Springfield A [ams arter, A. I i Year's Ar sad ol I Ss Virt & « ast Exerton Ene k Plates, Anctent and amdor ( xe Bell & Sons; New York an. $3 ry ev, Shel T Greek Ma a G. W. Dil cha erbu \ fetor A i Horse: Art and Arch logy e Acropolis. Philadelphia: John Wana An Fssay on Judiciai Power and Un Legisiation. Philadeiphia: Kay & Bre du. College Preparatory French Gram enkins ‘ Robert The Negro as Hels: A Story M Sentinel Print, 50 cents N. Meteorology : The Elements of Weather

ethuen & (%« of. N, F Elements of Synthetic trv. Macmillan. $1.4 Prof. Robert. History tory Scribners. ‘ Freshfield, D. W.. and Wharton, Capt. W. J.L to Travellers, Scientific and General. 7th ed Royal Geographical Society Gamgee, Prof. Arthur. A Text Book of the Physiolog! cal Chemistry of the Animal Body. Vol. li. The Phy sinlogical Chemistry of Digestion. Macmillan. §4.50. Garland, Hamlin. Prairie Songs. Illustrated. Stone & Kimball. $1.25 Grannis, Anna J Skipped Stitches N.H.: Darling & Co Greenwood, Frederick. The Lover's Lexicon. Mac millan. $1.50 Grosart, A. BR A Bower of Delights from the Works of Nicholas Breton Elizabethan Library.) Chicago A.C. McClure & Co. $1.25 Gunnison, Almon Wayside and Fireside Rambies Boston: Universalist Publishing House Harrington, W. BK. Our Dick. San Francisco: ©. A. Murdock & Co. 50 cents Harrison, J. P. Archwologia Oxoniensis Architecture before the Conquest. Oxford don Press; New York Macmillan Hazell’s Annual for Isv4. London: Hazell, Watson & Viney; New York: Seribners. $1.50 Hektoen, Dr. Ludvig, The Technique of Post-Mortem Examinations. Chicago: W.T. Keener Co. $1.75. Helier, Prof. Otto. Meyer's Gustav Adoif's Page. Hos ton: D. C Heath & Co. 30 centa. Herbert, George. The Temple: Sacred Poems and Pri vate Ejaculations. lustrated. Macmillan. $2 Solid tieo- of the Philosophy of His Hints London Verses heene, English Claren

Page 22

38

Hinsdale, Prof. B.A. Fow to Study and Teach Histcry, with Particular Refere ne : to the uly and T of the United States, Appletons. $1.5( Holyoake, G..J. The History of the Rochdale Pioneers. Sded, revised and enlarged. London: Sonnenschein; New York: Scribners. $1. Irving, W. Rip van Winkle, and the Legend of herig 4 Hollow. Illustrated. Macmillan. $2. Jenks, Edward. Walpole: A Study in Politics. Lon- don: Methuen & Co. Jerrold, Walter. Bon Mots of Charles Lamb and Dou- las Jerrold. London: J.M. Dent & Co.; New York: acmillan. 75 cents. Jobnes, Winifred. Miss Gwynne, Bachelor. G. W. Dillingham. 50 cents. Lang, Andrew. Prince Ricardo of Pantoufila. London; Simpkin, Marshall & Co.; New York: Longmans, Green & Co. f Laveleye, Emile de. Essais et Etudes. Premiere Série. 1861—1875. Paris: Félix Alcan. Lethaby, W. R. Leadwork, Old and Ornamental and for the most part English. Macmillan. $1.25. Lee, Vernon. Althea: A Second Book of Dialogues on aa ~~ and Duties. London: Osgood, Mclivaine a ‘Miss Lily A. Apprentices to Destiny. Merrill & Baker. $1. wees, Se Thomas. Le Morte Darthur. Macmillan. Marcotte, C harles. Governments and Politicians, An cient and Modern. Chicago: The Autbor. Martin, T.C. The Inventions, Researches and Writ- ings of Nikola Tesla. The Electrical Engineer. Matheson, Rev. A.S. The Church and Social P: roblems. ray a Oliphant, Anderson & Ferrier; New York : . D. F. Randolph & Co. watt, J.A.H. A New English Dictionary on His- torical Principles. Part VIII. Sect. I. Crouchmas— | Czech, Caress : Clarendon Press ; New York: Mac- | millan. $1.00. The Nation. fVol. 58, No. 1489

O'Grady, Standish. The Story of Ireland. London : Methuen & Co. Perkins, C. C., aud Dwight, J.S. History of the Handel and Haydn Society of Boston. Vol. I. Boston: Alfred Mudge & Son. Phelps, W.L. ‘the Beginnings of the English Romantic Movement. Boston: Ginn & Co. $1.1 a Claude. Sir Joshua Reynolds. Scribners. Piati, 5 J. Little New-World Idyls, and Other Poems. Longmans, Green & Co. $1.25. Polk, Dr. W.M. Leonidas Polk, Shop and General. 2 vols. Longmans, Green & C Rand, Katharine E. The C hildnood of an Affinity. Bos- ton: Arena Publishing Co. 50 cen Robinson, Edward. Catalogue of Greek, Etruscan and Roman Vases in the Boston Museum of Fine Arts. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co. Ross, Albert. Young Miss Giddy. G. W. Dillingham. 50 cents. Rossetti, Christina. Goblin Market. Macmillan. $1.50. Rossetti, Christina. Sing-Song: A Nursery Rhyme- Book. Macmillan. $1.50. Salt, H.S. Richard Jefferies: A Study. London: Son- nenschein; New York : Macmillan. 90 cents. Samantha at the World’s eet. By Josiah Allen’s Wife. Funk & Wagnalls. §$2.5¢ Sanderson, Edgar. History of England and the British Empire. F. Warne & Co. $3. Seavy, Manson. Practical Business rome re by Double Fntry. Boston: D. C. Heath & Co 55 Seidensticker, Oswald. The First Century of German Printing in| America, 1728—1830. Philadelphia : Schaefer & Koradi.

1. | Schwatka, Lieut. F. In the Land of Cave and Cliff Dweilers. Cassell. $1.25. . | Scherer, Georg. Gedichte. Berlin: Deutsche Verlags- Anstalt. Schénbach, Anton G. Uber Lesen und Bildung. Graz: Leuchner & Lubensky. Schopenhauer, Arthur. .-% Selected and Trans lated by T. B. Saunders. Burt. $1. Schulze-Gaevernitz, G. von. gy RS A Study of the Trade Union Movement in England, , Lon on: Sonnenschein: New York : Scribne $1. Seott, Sir W. Kenilworth. International a 2 vols. oy oy Estes, Lauriat & Co.; New York: Bryan, Tay or & C Scott, Sir W. Peveril of the Peak. petaree: A. &C. Black ; New York: Macmillan. $1. = b. Cc. The ae House, Sell Gace Poems. Otta- : J. Durie & Son Scott, Sir W. The abbot. American Book Co. 60 ts cents. Sidney, Maggnee’. The Child’s Day Book. Boston: D. Lothrop Co. 50 cents Salis, Mrs de. New Things to Eat, and How to Cook Them. G. W. Dillingham. Sizeranne, Maurice de la. a. Blind as Seen through Blind Eyes. Putnams. $1.25. Smith, Goldwin. Fssays on Questions of the Day. Mac- millan. $2.25. Smith, mon aret V. The Governors of Virginia. Wash- ington: . H. Lowdermilk & Co Smith, her J.B. English Orders: Whence Obtained. London: Skeffington & Son. Some Minor Arts as Practised in England. Illustrated. Macmillan. $7.50. = Green Bag. Vol. V. 1893. Boston: Boston Book The: Secret ngroaey of the 8 og res. Boston: Ameri can Printing and Engraving C $1. Usséle, L. A Travers le Japon. Paris : J. Rothschild. Waliszewski, R. The Romance of an Empress, Cathe- rine [f. of Russia. Appletons. $2. Ward, Wilfrid. Witnesses to the Unseen, and Other Essays. Macmillan. $3. Wieser, Prof. F. von. Natural Value. Macmillan. $3. Yeats, W. B. The Poems of William Blake. London : Lawrence & Bullen; New York: Scribners. $1.75.

AMERICAN SCIENCE SERIES. BARKER’s Puysics. Advanced course. REMSEN’S CHEMISTRY. 3 courses. PACKARD’s ZOOLOGY. 8 courses. MaRrrTINn’s HuMAN Bopy. 8 courses. WALKER’S POLITICAL Economy. 8 courses. Newcomes & HOLDEN’s ASTRONOMY. 2 courses. BEssEY’s BOTANY. 2 courses, JAMES’s PSYCHOLOGY. 2 courses. SEDGWICK & WILSON’s BIOLoGy. HENRY HOLT & CO., N. Y. JUST PUBLISHED: Studies and Notes in Philology and Literature, VOLUME II. Edited by a Committee of the Modern Language Depart- ments in Harvard Univ oy. 8vo, paper, 220 pages. Price by mail, postpaid, $1.50. This volume contains articles by J. M. Manly, Kuno Francke, W. we Carruth, Max Mnkler, E. S. Sheldon, A. R. Marsh, W. H. Schofield, and R. L. Weeks. GINN & CO., Publishers, BOSTON, NEW YORK. CHICAGO, LONDON. Heath's Wodern Language Certs JUST ISSUED. The most famous work in German historical fiction. EKKEHARD (Scheffel). Abridged and Edited with Notes by Prof. Carla Wenckebach oF Wellesley. Cloth, 241 pages, 85 cts. D. C. HEATH & CO., Publishers, BOSTON, NEW YORK, CHICAGO, LONDON. CORTINA TEXT BOOKS. ntended for Self-Study or for use in Schools. SPANISH IN 20 LESSONS. Introduction from H. H. Don CARLOS DE BorBON. 11th Edition. Cloth, $1.50. INGLES EN VEINTE LECCIONES. Prologue’ by Don EMILIO CASTELAR. 4th Edition. Cloth, $2.00. AMPARO. A charming novel in Sp. and —. reading book oe yatveseees, colleges, ete. 75c. EL IND O, In Sp. and Eng. 50c DESPU Es DE LAL UVIA. Alinotated in English. 35c. VERBOS ESPANOLES MODELOS PARA CARTAS. "40e. ‘Cortina School of Languages,” 111 W. 34TH ST., N. Y. Liberal discounts to Dealers. Professors a and C Colleges.

UNIVERSITY TOWN OF INNSBRUCK, TYROL, AUSTRIA. 1,900 feet above the sea, with dry, bracing climate. HOTEL TIROL. Open all the year. CARL LANDSEE, Proprietor. Large, airy, sunny rooms; modern conveniences; superior cui- sine. Reduced rates in winter. Eminent medical care if desired. Unusual educational advantages on mode- rate terms. Excursions a speciality. Best references. Illustrated pamphlets sent on application. DESIDERATA IN BOOKS, ENGRAVINGS, AU- TOGRAPHS, MSS, etc., searched for. Corre- spondence invited. Rare arid Unique Dickens and Thackeray Books, Autographs, etc., for sale. Apply to FRANK T. SABIN. 118 Shaftes- bury Avenue, London, W. a OOKS WANTED, mo Lew v, Merston& Co., L’d, St. Dunstan’s House, Fetter ote London, haves “fal facilities for supplying out-of- print and scarce English, American, and Foreign Books wanted by Booksellers, Libraries, and Collectors.

HATCHARDS. This is the favorite BOOKSTORE, and for 100 years the resort of the smartest people in London. It is visited and patronized by all who love books. London is the great market for books, and all the best as well as the cheapest editions can be had by writing to us. Special collections formed, and fuller information sup- plied than from any other house. Books both old and new, and relating to any subject, can readily be supplied at very moderate prices Agents for Clubs, Libraries, and all private Collectors. 187 Piccapitty, Lonvon, W. Vale S2%ites. Mixture For the Pipe. A Delightful Blend of St. James Par- ish, Louisiana, Perique, Genuine Im- ported Turkish, Extra Bright Plug Cut, Extra Bright Long Cut, and Marburg Bros. Celebrated Brand ‘‘ Pickings.’’ Marburg Bros., Baltimore, Md. LOMBARD, Equitable, Jarvis-Conklin, and Other Mortgages BOUGHT FOR CASH. CHAS. E. GIBSON, . . . 45 Milk St., Boston.

- etters We buy and sell bills of exchange on ‘i and make Cable Transfers of money to of Europe, Australia, and the West Indies; also make collections and issue Com- Credit mercial and Travellers’ Credits, availa- < . ble in all parts of the world. Brown Brothers & Co., Bankers, NO. 589 WALL STREET, NEW YORK. A specialty of American book- S plates is made by THE ART MATEUR. All owners of ex- inate ae areinv a to po es with the editor, MC sathsinanail E MARKS, 23 Union Square, New York. PAPER BY THE POUND and envelopes. Greater quan- tity, lower price than by er. Samples, all grades, rices marked, on receipt of 10 Wik JENKINS, ne stationery, 851-53 Sixth Ave. “(apth St) yN. Y.

Brain Workers. Horsford’s Acid Phosphate is recommended by physicians of all schools, for restoring brain force or nervous energy, in all cases where the nervous system has been reduced below the nor- mal standard by overwork, as found in lawyers, teachers, stu- dents, and brain-workers gene- rally. Descriptive Pamphlet free on application to Rumford Chemical Works, Providence, R. I. Beware of Substitutes and Imitations.

For sale by all Druggists. ®

: : : re MAYER & MULLER. Booksellers, 51 Markgrafenst., Berlin (Germany). Direct supply, at best terms, of GERMAN NEW AND SECOND-HAND BOOKS, PAMPHLETS. and PERIODI- CALS in any department of Learning and Literature. a and most inexpensive opportunity for Libra- ries, Professors, and Students. Best references, AUTOGRAPH LETTERS. PRICE LISTS SENT FREE. WALTER ROMEYN BENJAMIN, 287 Fourth Ave., NEW YORK CITY. KOEHLER, NEUMANN & CO., Rozetgn Hookset- ers, 149A Tremont Street Boston. Mass. Subscriptions to Periodicals. Regular importations from Leipzig, Paris, London, etc.

Page 23

Jan 11, 1894] The Nation.

uF you have hitherto been unable to get. “5 COSMOPOLITAN €> \Worlds Fair p/ \u ml PT suca:welume vataabte tor ete of your Newsdealer, you can find it there now, as the SECOND EDITION has brought the total up to 400,000 cortEs—/0r 926 7707 07 syn ornen sacar By Bourget, Besant, Howells, Mark Twain, Hopkinson Smith. ete. Oy 477 Meses-Stan WITH NEARLY 200 ILLUSTRATIONS. BEGIN YOUR SUBSCRIPTION NOW ($1.50 a Year). | 5 HATEVER other publications you take, you will need THE COSMOPOLITAN for 1894. The most famous writers of the CENTS world and the cleverest artists contribute to its pages. _THE COS MOPOLITAN PUBLISHING CO., oth Ave. and [th St. New York.

Some of the Recent Publications of WILLIAM R. —s 851 AND 853 SIXTH AVENUE, NEW YORK MANUEL DE LITTERATURE FRANCAISE. By A. DE ; EXTRAITS CHOISIS DES(EUVRE SI F vs ANCOIS COP ROUGEMONT, A.M. Half leather, $1.25 | PEE. Notes by G. CasTEGNIER. Cloth, 00 cents COLLEGE PREPARATORY FRENCH GRAMMAR. By LE FRANCAIS PRATIQUE. By Patt Bercy, BLL, Ll CHARLES N. Du CRoQueT. Half leather, $1.25. | Cloth, 81.00. PAUL BERCY’S FRENCH READER. For advanced | VE CHANT DU CYGNE. By GEoRGE ONNET. N classes, Contes et Nouvelles Modernes Choisis et an. | CONTES CHOISIS. Paper, 25 cents notes. By PavuL Bercy, B.L., LD. Cloth, $1.00. | NANON. Ry GEORGE SAND Notes by B.D. Woopwar LES PROSATEURS FRANCAIS DU XIXeSIECLE. By | _FD-D. Paper, GO vents. Cloth, SScents. C. FonTAINE, B.L., L.D. Half leather, — FORTEZZA. By E, DE is. Notes by T. FE. Compa oan ee aie | No.6. NOVELLE ITALIA NE: Paper, 35 cents AMILLA. By E. DE Amicis. Notes by E. COMBA. | EL PAJARO VE R DE Ry J. VaLER«. Notes by Paper, 35 cents. No.4. NOVELLE IT ALIANE. | Rosas. No. 1. TENTOS SELECTOS. Paper, 33 cents | CONTES DE beth ‘dited by GrorGe M. Hanrer LA LIZARDIERE. By VTE HENRI DE BORNIER. No, 20. ROMANS CHOISIS. Paper, 60 cents | Ph.D., of Princeton University, and L. BE. Livixuw FABLES CHOISIES DE LA FONTAINE. With Notes by | 4-B. Cloth, $1.00. B. Beck. Boards, 40 cents. | DES KINDES ERSTES BUCH. Illus. Boards, 4 Introduction prices at the rate of 20 per cent. discount from above prices. Copies for eraminat ’ sent upon application. SARGENT’S GREEK LINES And Other Architectural | Essays. By Henry VAN Brunt. With Illustrations Crown Svo, $1.50. ‘A book of more than ordinary interest to | allwho regard beauty of form as an expres sion of the ideal.”—Poston Beacon. HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO., Boston. wi East 17th Street, New York. ‘ESTABLISHED 1858" ‘H.. H.. UPHAM’&‘CO.:

BALI BEARING ROTARY BOOKC WSES »above are two of many styles. We ve ry id for home or office use. Special style fo r tt

~ r y VT | CENTt RY Dictionary and Eney Mopedias. Illustrated MEMORIAI PAB |: rs catalogues free. Address SARGE FG. CO., either 4 aa a 4 ve 4has } S14 Br New York, or factory, Muskegon, Mict

rmadway, Quote the Nation.

‘IN - BRASS: AND - BRONZE: "54° South Fifth: Ave:near’ Bleecker St. ‘NEW * YORK To Librarians, Book-Lovers and Bookse Our NEW CATALOGUE of RARE and CHOICE BOOKS, comprising works on architecture, biography. belles lettres, the drama, first editions, Shakespeariana, rare

= > = .°] 7) French Books, works of art, ete., etc., will be sent, post- | UNEQUALLED IN paid, upon request. | $37 Attention is called to this valuable collection | ‘ON- ( iT jf NA MEANS BRENTANO’'S, | a “7 z , 31 U nik on Suue are. New York. Pa American Magazines, Newspapers, and Journals | = one i “MA r ew rk Our price-list has been exhausted. The new one will | 22 and 24 EF. Baltimore St 148 Sth Ave. near 20th St not be ready until January 1. Send us your list for | Washir 1894 and we will quote you prices. New list will bx sent when ready. Our prices are the cheapest. Men tlon Nation. | n judice AMERICAN PRINTING AND NEWS COMPANY. | 9) 128" we B ts. LEAKS \N 1) + Laon N \ ~ Ss “ . ‘N AL MANA ‘ 4 1s « WwW \K ALMANACK _ " R . \ ‘ SN " iW < \ ( ~ N \ PA ~ NEW VORA GUSTAV E. STECHERT, Importer of Books and Periodicals, s RROADWAY, NEW YORK Large stock of Foreten Books was we as rare and scar and sets of Perto als Subs . { sfor lsv4 w rece et Lowest rates k delivery se f alow ‘ I \ WwW ¢ -~ ~~ Poe New spaper ms Clippings, Dickens Magazine Thacke eray ; Articles, Portraits, Lincoln Books. We buy ar ell Ana of every description about these Patines: Als irgains in Scarce Books, Portraita, and Auto aphs AMERICAN PRESS COL, Baltimore, Md. F. W. CHRISTERN, DYRSEN & PFEIFFER, Suc’rs), 234 Fifth Ave., between 28th and 20th Sts., New York, looks: Agents for the leading itz’s British Authors, Teubner’s Catalogues of stock mailed A large assortment alwavs on hand, and ceived from Paris and Leipzig as soon as P# {77 inzi is friends, enemies, and acquaintances to his new Bookstore, cor. 12th St and Ath Ave. (late Cammeyer'’s), N. Y., and don’t forget r pocket books HT] WILLIAMS, 195 WEST 10TH ST., N.Y.. dealer in Magazines and other periodicals Sets, volumes, or single numbers

B \CkK numbers and sets of all magazines For ». Ls @, state wants to MAGAZINE EXCHANGE, Schobarte ‘ TED TO PURCHAST VUM bers, Sele on sete ofthe Nation. Address with ‘iets A. S. CLarRK, 34 Park Row, N. Y. City

Page 24

The Nation. [Vol. 58, No. 1489 A cream of tartar baking powder. Highest of all in leavening strength —Latest United States Gov- ernment Food Report. “ Roya Bakina Powper Co , 106 Wall St., N. Y. FILL YOUR PIPE with Golden Sceptre IF You love GOOD TOBACCO. Send ten cents to SURBRUG, 159 Ful- ton Street, for a big sample. $1.30 per pound, 40c. 4 oz., prepaid. Only and highest award at World’s Fair. UNMOUNTED PHOTOGRAPHS of Ancient and Modern Works of Art, reproduc- tions of famous paintings, sculpture,and architecture, with views from all parts of the world. Send 15 cents for catalogues of 14,000 subjects. List of World’s Fair Views and Art at the Fair now ready. Lantern slides made to order from any of our subjects. Photograph Mounting in Albums or on cards a specialty. Albums supplied. Soule Photograph Co., 334 Wash'n St., Boston. Pool Agencies : New York, E. P. Dutton & Co., 31 W. 23d St.; Chicago, M. O’Brien & Son, 208 Wabash Ave.; Philadelphia, J. E. McClees & Co., 1417 Chestnut St. KEGAN PAUL, TRENCH, TRUBNER & CO.,, LIMITED, Publishers, Importers, and Booksellers, Paternoster House, Charing Cross Road, LONDON, Import American Books, Export European Books, Buy Editions, Arrange simultaneous publication for copyright pur- poses in Great Britain and the United States. ABOUT A CATALOGUE 4 } 4 si 4 4 TU 4e Our business is buying and selling Old Books, ranging in size from a single book to large and famous libraries. Throughout the year we are offered job-lots and re- mainders of new and fast-selling books, but buy only those we can sell far below the publisher’s price. We have = issued a Clearance Catalogue of such Books, including an illustrated history and description of our store. hen sending for it mention Nation. No return stamp required. Leary s Old Book Store, No. g South gth Street, (First Store below Market St.) odicals, Tauchnitz British au- Foretgn Books. T 5 thors. Catalogues on appli cation. CARL SCHOENHOF, 23 School St , Boston. PHILADELPHIA. Subscriptions to foreign peri. G. P. Putnam's Sons, NEW YORK AND LONDON, HAVE NOW READY: THE RELIGION OF A LITERARY MAN. By RICHARD LE GALLIENNE. 12mo, $1.00. CureF Contents: The Relative Spirit—What is Sin —What is Pain—Free Will—The Hereafter—Essen- tial Christianity— Dogma and Symbolism—The Reli- gious Senses, etc. ** Probably the sunniest book on religion ever pub- lished *—Mr. Zanawitt in the Star, London. ‘*The book is certainly a remarkable one, and we urge our readers not to trust to any second-hand account, but to make themselves acquainted with its contents by the ancient method of perusal.*’—Lon- don Speaker. THE STORY OF JAPAN. By Davip Murray. (Being No. 39 of the Sto- ry of the Nations Series). With Maps and Illustrations. 12mo, cloth, $1.50; half lea- ther, gilt tops, $1.75. WAH-KEE-NAH, AND HER PEO- PLE. The Curious Customs, Traditions, and Legends of the North American Indians. By JAMES C. STRONG, late Brevet Brigadier General Reserve Corps, U. S. A. With frontis- piece. Price. $1.25. ARIEL SHAKESPEARE. Third Group. Comprising seven of the Tragedies, viz. : HAMLET, MACBETH, OTHELLO, KING LEAR, ROMEO AND JULIET, JULIUS C42- SAR, and ANTONY AND CLEOPATRA. Each play in a separate volume, pocket size, large type, complete and accurate text, illustrated with the celebrated designs of Frank Howard, and bound in flexible mo- rocco. Sold separately, per volume 75 cts. This edition will include all of the Plays, twenty- one of which have thus far been published. Subscriptions are invited for the entire set (thirty- eight), to be delivered as published, and orders will be received for any volume or volumes. ‘‘Among the innumerable editions of Shakespeare, this is one of the most convenient and pleasing.*’-- Boston Literary World. AUTHORS AND THEIR PUBLIC IN ANCIENT TIMES. A sketch of literary conditions, and of the re- lations with the public of literary produc- ers from the earliest time to the invention of printing in 1450. By Gro. HAVEN Put- NAM, author of ‘‘The Question of Copy- right,” etc. 12mo, $1.50. CureF Contents: The Beginnings of Literature—- Chaldea—Egypt—China—Japan—India—Persia —Ju- dea — Greece — Alexandria — Book Terminology in Classic Times—Rome--The Byzantine Empire, ete. ‘A special field of study, which Mr. Putnam has cove in a particularly interesting way. .. . His little volume is the more attractive because it is un- pretentious and freely acknowledges its obligations 4 French and German students.’’— Philadelphia ames. ‘An important contribution to the discussion of the property in literary productions .. . The book, so far as it goes, is admirable.—New York Examiner. THE SPIRIT OF THE AGE; OR, CONTEMPORARY PORTRAITS. By WILLIAM Hazuitr. Edited by Reginald Brimley Johnson. (Being a new volume in the Knickerbocker Nuggets Series ) $1. *,* Illustrated Holiday Catalogue, Notes on New Books, a quarterly bulletin, prospectuses of the Story and Herves of the Nations Series, and Catalogue of Books for Young People, sent on application. “He is WELL PAID that is ‘well SATISFIED.”’ —Merchant of Venice. The Verdict OF ALL WHO Is that it SATISFIES EVERY DEMAND of the careful housekeeper for frying and shortening purposes. It is far cheaper than butter, more economical than lard because it goes twice as far, and is sure to produce good results without waste. Therefore IT PAYS WELL TO USE ©tiolene GET THE GENUINE. Sold by all grocers in three and five pound pails. Made only - ThE N. K. FAIRBANK COMPANY Chicago, New York, Boston, Montreal, San Francisco, Philadelphia, St. Louis. IvoRY« » SOAP IVORY °IT FLOATSs we FORK TABLE LINEN. THES PROCTER & GAMBLE CO., CIN'T!

Page 25