The Nation 1894-01-04: Vol 58 Iss 1488
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
/ f The Nation VOL. LVUI—NO. 1488. tn, i sin THE JANUARY NUMBER 7 THURSDAY, JANUARY 4, 1894. OF THE NorTH AMERICAN REVIEW INCOME TAX ON CORPORATIONS. By the Hon. WILLIAM L. WILSON, Chairman of the Ways and Means Committee. REPUBLICANISM IN BRAZIL, . ; . Tue Brazttian Mints AFTER-THOUGHTS OF A STORY-TELLER, Grorce W. Ca ARE THE SILVER STATES RUINED? ; ; Pur Governor or C THE ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH AND THE SCHOOL FUND, Pure Bisuor « VUBAN) DINNERS AND DINERS, : : , Lapy JEUNI HOW TO PREVENT A MONEY FAMINE, . Tit ComMprro.LeER OF THE CURRENCY THE HAWAIIAN QUESTION, é ; . Freperic R. Coupe THE SUNDAY-SCHOOL AND MODERN BIBLICAL CRITICISM, Pure Rev. C. A. Brices, 1.1). IS THE VALUE OF OUR FAST CRUISERS OVERESTIMATED? , Rear-Apwirat Auuren, UL S.N, WAGNER’S INFLUENCE ON PRESENT-DAY COMPOSERS, : ANTON S¥EIDi THE GLORIFICATION OF THE JEW, ; Pror. Apram S. Isaacs, eer i ia tala a sia | { Dr. }. Wits Wun IN TERCOLLEGIATE ] OO] BALL, . e . . ) Dr. Horatio "9a Woop _ TARIFF AND BUSINESS. By EX-SPEAKER REED. RECENT ROMANCINGS ON HEAVEN AND HELL, . . Gerrrupe B. Ror PROF. TYNDALL AS A MATERIALIST, Pror. J. G. Hippen STREET BEGGING AS A FINE ART, : K. K. Benrwick 50 cents a copy. $5.00 a year. Sold by all Newsdealers. THE NORTH AMERICAN REVIEW, 3 East 14th St., New York.
Page 2
The Nation.
[Vol. 58, No. 1488
The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science, and Art. FOUNDED 1865. [Entered at the New York City Post-office as second-class mail matter.)
CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. TE PRE si ncikn icc tndey che cicnkeccucesscssvassthvtssnes 1 EDITORIAL ARTICLES : Rallot Laws and Election Frauds..............+.+++ 4 The Naval Alarm in England ...............-.es-s0¢ 4 The Evolution of a Dynamiter................e500 5 The Popularization of Evil...............ccceeeeeeee 6 SPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE : The Parliamentary Year in England........ ...... 7 Vaillant, Socialism and Militarism................. 8 HaHemiUs POMUBCOM. ......00cccccccccccscccecccocces 9 CORRESPONDENCE : EU a neccobseccocscccce€essevarcecesesdenens 10 i a. ss svbate dec eebaersuncsctenne¥ 10 RIED, covasvccons bebasondencepesoneresos 10 The Understatement of “‘ Guess ”’............0.-0006 11 I ons ck een ccnvcvvesnescccwsescccesccvesvacarsscenees 11 Be 10K REVIEWS : IES on vcoccececccvencvescoccsesesunvovesecésese 13
i sccrccinnonneveneessacks cohventt 15 William Jay and the Constitutional Movement for the Abolition of Slavery ...................05+ 16 RO SE occas cinccercoccesccsacescpeseces 17 PE Chin anevenskneshinsenesesecencesseseene 18 The Diary of Col. Peter Hawker .................5+ 18 oeney Es Sa chwtteeseveccccoscetcccceenvesvens 19 An Unknown Heroin 19 Utility of Quaternions in SEDs cia saspussebesees 19 Fs ve icicctncnccastvcccccvccssscess 19
TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three Dollars per year in advance, postpaid, to any part of the United States or Canada; to foreign coun- tries comprised in the Postal Union, Four Dollars. The date when the subscription expires is on the Ad- dress-Label of each Paper, the change of which to a sub- sequent date becomes a receipt for remittance. No other receiyt is sent unless requested Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter or by check, express order, or postal order, payable to “ Publisher of THE NaTIoNn.” When a change of address is desired, both the old and new addresses should be given. Address THE NATION, Box 794, New York. Publication Office, 208 Broadway.
TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Fifteen cents per agate line, cach insertion, 14 lines to the inch. Twenty per cent. advance for choice of page, top of Cuts are not inserted on the first page. A column, $20 each insertion; with choice of page, $24. A page, $60 each insertion; front cover page, $80. Advertisements must be acceptable in every respect. Copy received until Tuesday, 5 P. M. column, or cuts. DISCOUNTS. TIME— De IIIIOORG, oo ccc cccccccccaccncccsccencess 8 i. Sehpeeheneeebepeese’, Sebeanwee 13 F Waar omitaatiaas 202, 204, 335 West ny ingand Day School.—24th year. by Bryn Mawr College. The Bryn Mawr entrance exa minations are held in the school by an examiner from the College. School certificate admits to Vassar.
PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, Chestnut Hill. MES. COMEGY’S AND MISS BEIL’S English, French, and German Boarding-School for young ladies reopens October 2. pared for College. Students pre- Ample grounds for outdoor exer
cise. P#NNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, 1350 Pine St. nv TSS ANABLE’S BOARDING AND ‘I Day School for Young Ladies. Estab. in 1848. Opens Sept. 28. MUSEUM OF FINE ARTS SCHOOL OF DRAWING AND PAINTING. Second term begins Jan. Ist, 1894. Instruction in drawing from the cast and from life, in painting, modelling, and decorative design, and also in artistic anetomy and ———, Principal instruc tors: Benson, arbell, and Philip Hale elie ad Painting x), C. Howard Walker and Mrs. William Stone (Decorative Design), B L. Pratt (Model- ling). G. H. Monks, M.D. (Anatomy), and A, K. Cross (Perspective). Pupils are allowed the free use of the ga'leries of the Museum. Forc'rculars giving detailed —— address Miss ELIZABETH LOMBARD, JOHN'S MILITARY SCHOOL, SI: MANLIUS,N. Y. Next term begins January 11, 1894, Rt. Rev. F. D. Huntington, Pres.; Wm. Verbeck, Supt.; Ist. Lieut. W. P. Sareiom, U. Ss. A. Commandant. LAKEWOOD HEIGHTS SCHOOL LAKEWOOD, NEW JERSEY. AMONG THE PINES. A thorough and attractive School for Boys. J AMES W. MOREY. RIVERVIEW, ACADEMY, POUGHKEEPSIE, N. Y.
58TH YEAR. Prepares thoroughly for College, the Gov- ernment Academies and Business. Military organiza- tion. B ISBEE & AMEN, Principals. Teachers, etc. We: NTED— AFTER CHRISTMAS Holidays, in the Bryn Mawr School in Baltimore, a college graduate (woman) to teacb mathematics two and a half hours daily. Applications may be addressed. PRESIDENT BOARD OF MANAGERS, Bryn Mawr School, Baltimore. DARENTS OR GUARDIANS WI/SH- ing to place children in a comfortable, happy home in England, where a thorough education is offered, may apply for terms and particulars to Mrs. AITCHISON, Lan- crigg, Grasmere, W vestmoreland, E gran. [ ANTED IMMEDIATELY—BY A lady in Baltimore, an expert stenographer and typewriter (woman). Applications may be addressed to D.G., care of the Nation. A’ Harvard, Ph.D. Germany) desires a change. ship. Willing to travel. Address Dr. X. B.,
N INSTRUCTOR IN FAHY SICS IN one of the foremost Western Universities (A.B. Also tutor- care Nation.
FEW PUPILS WILL BE RECEIV- ed in a New York Suburban Boarding School for Girlsfrom January 9 until June 6 for $200 each. Ad- dress PRINCIPAL, Nation office. 4 LADY OF EXPERIENCE, QUALI- ed fied to teach Academic or Primary branches and Pravin: wishes engagement. Address “ACADEMIC,” care afton AN EXPERIENCED ART TEACHER —lady—wishes engagement for teaching Art and Art esta scavess “ ART,” care of ated Natton.
ARISIAN HOME FOR YOUNG LA- dies.—Madame ALYs BARRAULT Giroux, Bureau des Champs Elysées 49, Paris.
(ares W,. STONE, Tutor for Har- vard, 6S Chestnut Street, Boston
Page 3
Jan. 4, 1894] SC rary y) GCNCIES. MERICAN AND FOREIGN TEACH/- ers’ Agency supplies Professors, Teachers, Tutors, Governesses, etc., to Colleges, Schools, and Families Apply to . Mrs. M. J. YOUNG-FULTON. 23 Union Square, New York. HE FISK TEACHERS AGENCIES, 4 Ashburton Street, Boston, 371 Main Stre et Hart ford, 70 Fifth Avenue,N.Y., 106 Wabash Ave , Chicago, and 120% South Spring Street, Los Angeles. Agency Manual free. EVERETT ©. Fisk & Co. HE NEW AMERICAN TEACHERS AGENCY.—Teachers seeking positions and those wishing a change at an increased salary should address » B. Rua@.es & Co. (Palace Hotel Building), Room ©, 237 Vine Street, Cincinnati, 0.
MERICANAND FOREIGN Profi oe tutors, fad fami teachers, ete, supplied to colleges, schools, and — s. MIRIAM COYRIERE, 50 Sth Ave., cor. 2ZUth St., N.Y.
SSUKS, JATIONAL BUREAU OF EDUCA- LY TION, Miss CROSTHWAIT, Prop., cor. Church and — h Sts, Nashville, Tennessee. The Leading School Teac he rs’ age ney of the South and Southwest HE . ALBERT TE. ACHERS "AGE NC Y; 211 Wabash Ave., Chic ago, a now vacancies for Fall and winter terms. ALBERT, Manager. re TEACHERS \CHE R ME RHOR. Vv" Ss
Agency. Oldest and best kagres in the U.S Established 1855. 3 East 14th St., N. Y. HE BRIDGE TEACHERS’ 4 GCE N- cites, 110 Tremont St, Boston, and 211 Wabash Ave., Chicago. Agency Manual free to any address. MABE UNEQUALLED IN TOUCH, WORKMANS/HTP, AND DURABILITY. Baltimore, New York, 22 and 24E. Baltimore St. — 143 5th Ave., near 20th St Washington, 817 Bauhet Spac @. THE STUDENT'S FROEBEL. - Adapted from FROEBEL’S DIE ERZIEHUNG DER MENSCHHEIT By WittiaM H.
TONE, HERFORD. The purpose of this little book is to give a brief, yet full account of Froebel’s Theory of Education. Cloth, 128 pages, 75 cents. D. C. HEATH & CO., BOSTON, NEW YORK, Publishers, CHICAGO, CORTINA TEXT BOOKS. Intended for Self-Study or for use in Schools. oer IN 20 LESSONS. Introduction from H. H. Jon CARLOS DE BorBON. lith Edition. Cloth, $1.50. INGLES EN VEINTE LECCIONES. Prologue’ by Don EMILIO CASTELAR. 4th Edition. Cloth, $2.00. AMPARO. Acharming novel in Sp. and Eng., reading book for universities, colleges, ete. 75e. EL INDIANO. In re op Eng. 50¢ DESPUES DELA LLUVIA. Annotated in English. 35c. VERBOS ESPANOLES. 40c. MODELOS PARA CARTAS. 40c. ‘Cortina School of Languages,”’ 111 W. S4TH ST., N. Y. L seerel discounts to Dealers. Professors and Colleges. UNIVERSITY TOWN OF INNSBRUCK, TYROL, AUSTRIA. 1,900 feet above the sea, with dry, bracing climate HOTEL TIROL. Open all the year. CARL LANDSEE, Proprietor airy, sunny rooms; modern conveniences; sine. Reduced rates in winter. if desired, Unusual educational advantages on mode rate terms. Excursions a speciality. Best references Illustrated pamphlets sent on application. GERMAMA press as *‘the best effort vet made to assist the student of German, and to interest him tn his pursuit.” Its BE GINNER’S CORNER furnishes every year a complete and interesting course in German Grammar. §Y a year: sin gle copies, 20 cents. P.O. Box 151, Manchester, N. H. Large superior cui Eminent medical care
A monthly magazine for the study of the German Language and Literature, is bigh'y recommended by college professors and the
The Nation. WALTER BAKER & CO. COCOA and CHOCOLATE Highest Awards edals and Diplomas) World's Columbian Exposition. On the following articles, namely: BREAKFAST (COCOA, PREMIUM No. 1 CHOCOLATE, ,GERMAN SWEET CHOCOLATE, ANILLA CHOCOLATE, , COCOA BUTTER, For ** purity of material,” “excellent flavor,” and “unt- form even composition.” SOLD BY CROCERS EVERYWHERE. WALTER BAKER & CO., DORCHESTER, MASS. UNMOUNTED PHOTOGRAPHS Modern
of Ancient and Works of Art, reproduc tions of famous paintings, sculpture.and spuiiectare, with views from all parts of the world. Send 15 cents for catalogues of 14,000 subjects. List of W orld’s Fair Views and Art at the Fair now ready Lantern slides made to order from any of our subjects. Photograph Mounting in Albums or on cards a specialty. Albums supplied Soule Photograph Co., 334 Wash'a St., Boston Principal Agencies : New York, E. P. Dutton & Co., W. 23d st.; ¢ a ago, M.O'Brile n& Son 20S Wabash Ave Philadelphia, J. E. MeClees & Co., 1417 Chestnut St.
$1
Fust Ready. The Only Treat THE LAW OF STRIKES, LOCKOUTS, LABOR ORGANIZATIONS, ETC. By THOMAS S, CoGgLey, a member of the Bar of the Dis trict of Columbia, and author of Cogley’s Digest. Everybody wi!' at once recognize the value of this book, because, notwithstanding the great importance of the subject, no attempt has heretofore beep made to treat the matter exhaustively, and only fragmentary refer ences to it are to be found in other works. This book » ives all the case and statute law on the subjects of which it treats, and contains in full, or sufficiently so to answer all practical purposes, cases out of print and bevond the reach of all save those who have access to the larg est libraries. It contains references to all Engtish and American cases and statutes down to date COGLEY ON STRIKES AND LOCKOUTS ts an attrac tive octavo volume of best Jaw book stvle in its make up. Price $4.0u net by express, prepaid, on recetpt of amount with order W. H. LOW DERMILK & CO l aw Book Publishers and Dealers 1424-1426 F St., k-Lovers. a f RARE andi ¢ ture, t edit ns. art, ete., ek Washington, D. ¢ n u To Litrarians, B Our NEW C comprising: Works lettres, the drama, first French Books, works of paid, upon request. cz” Attention is called to this “2 4 R ! liar J DUUASCIIETS. BROOKS, belles ATAT OMG on F ar rites
riptions to f{ BookSELLERS LAON DON LELPZLG ARIS Subscriptions ior Period *, Poreig for 1884 now received Now ready ALMANACH DE GOTHA, Ima, § WHITTAKER’S ALMANACK, ISA . Mail lers for Books, Foretg ceive immediate attent A Catalogue of : Nets \ if Pa? f * ‘ ‘ ‘ i- New Classical Catalogue LAI NDMON PARIS LEIPZIG N , \ GUSTAV E. STECHERT, Importer of Books and Periodicals, 810 BROADWAY, NEW YORA Large stock of Foreign Books, new aa wel! as ra and searve, and sets of Pertodicals Subscriptions to Pertodicals for lsv4 wer ! Lowest rates, quick delivery Send for Catalogue nu A’ ‘ London: 30 Wellington St Stra Ww i Paris: 76 Rue de Rennes Leipzig: 10 Hospital Strasse kW. CHRISTERN (DYRSEN & PFEIFFER, 254 Fifth Ave, t Suc'rs), @sth and Sta. Ne
wel Ween w \ % Importers of ‘ 2 Paris Publisher . ‘ Greek and Lati Stok ‘ ondemand. A lars hat a new Pooks recetve from lb’aris ar 5 < as a issued We have just secured a st quantity Blaine’s ‘Twenty Years in ( aaa a The work is Diete In two roval oactayv volumes of alkou 0 Dares each, printed from new electrotype plates on supe ring book paper, bound in fine English mus mart edges. Published by Henry Bi Publishing N wich, Conn rigtnal price, $7 Our price for the two vol es, $3 x Leary’s Old Bookstore, Vo. o Sout Vey First Store below Market St i apt ‘ OLIDA) LARGEST Rooks LPTOWN IMartes BOOKSTORE stmas je WILLIAM R. JENKINS, x velties Sixt tationery = s FRENCH & s PEN EVENINGS merican Magazines, Newspapers, and Journals Our pricelist has been exhausted he new one wili not be ready until January 1. Send us 5 list for S¥4 and we wi yuote vou prices. New list will be sent when ready. Our prices are the cheapest. Men tien Nafion AMBRICAN PRINTING AND NEWS COMPANY. 1111 ARCH ST., PHILADELPHIA, PA » RARE BOOKS c “ e t R I : BARGAINS. . A Send stamps for Lists { ; I Picking up Scarce Books @ specialty A T Address P s AMERICAN PRESS CO., H Raltimore, Md S AUTOGRAPH LETTERS. PRICE LISTS SENT FREI WALTER ROMEYN BENJAMIN, ee 287 Fourth Ave., NEW YORK CITY. KOEFHI I R, NE M ANN & O.., lers and import ers, 140A Tremont Street, Boston, Mass. Subscriptions to Periodicals. Regular importations from Leipzig, Paria, London, etc Foreign Booksel
Page 4
lv The Nation. [Vol. 58, No. 1488 Ginn & Co.s Recent Publications. ENGLISH. A Practical English Composition. By Professor Newcomer of Leland Stanford Junior University. 90 cents. Outlines of Rhetoric. By Professor Genung of Amherst College. - $1.10. Practical Elements of Elocution. By Professors Fulton and Trueblood. $1.50. Classic Myths in English Literature. By Professor Gayley of the University of California. $1.65. Analytics of Literature. By Professor Sherman of the University of Nebraska. $1.40. The Beginnings of the English Romantic Movement. By Wm. Lyon Phelps of Yale University. $1.10. Leigh Hunt’s «« What is Poetry?’’ Edited by Professor Cook of Yale Univ. 60 cts. MODERN LANGUAGES An Introduction to the French Language. By Professor van Daell of the Mass. Institute of Technology. $1.10. French Prose: Popular Science. Edited by Professor Luquiensof Yale Univ. 70 cts. Michelet’s La Prise de la Bastille. Edited by Professor Luquiens. 25 cents. Auerbach’s Brigitta. Edited by Professor Gore of Columbian University. 55 cents. Die Erhebung Europas gegen Napoleon I. Edited by A. B. Nichols of Harvard University. 66 cents. Collar’s Shorter Eysenbach. By W.C. Collar of Roxbury Latin School, and Clara S Curtis. $1.10. LATIN, 4Eneid, Book VII. (School Classics Series.) Edited by W. C. Collar. 50 cents. 4Eneid, Book VIII. (School Classics Series.) Edited by John Tetlow, Headmaster of Girls’ High and Latin Schools, Boston 50 cents. Livy, Books XXI. and XXII. (College Series.) Edited by Professor Greenough of Harvard University and Professor Peck of Yale University. $1.35. Catullus. (College Series.) Edited by Professor Merrill, Wesleyan Univ., Ct. $1.50. Harvard Studies in Classical Philology, No. IV. Edited by a Committee of the Classical Instructors in Harvard University. 31.50. GREEK. Beginner’s Greek Composition. By W. C. Collar and M. Grant Daniell. 95 cents. Greek-English Word-List. By Professor Baird of Northwestern University. 35 cts. Cornell Studies in Classical Philology, No. IV.: The Development of the Earlier Athenian Constitution. By Dr. Botsford. $1.50. MATHEMATICS. Fourier’s Series, and Spherical, Cylindrical, and Ellipsoidal Harmonics. By Pro- fessor Byerly of Harvard University. +3 15. Field-Book for Civil Engineers. By Professor Carhart of Western University of Pennsylvania $2.50. Elements of Solid Geometry. By Professor Baker of the Univ. of Rochester. 90 cts. Mensuration. By Professor Hall of Lafayette College. 55 cents. MISCELLANEOUS. Student’s Laboratory Manual of Physical Measurements. By W. C. Sabine of Harvard University. $1.35. Psychic Factors. By Lester F. Ward. $2.00. The Mark in Europe and America. By President Bryan of Washington State Agri- cultural College. $1.10. ; Droysen’s Principles of History. Translated by President Andrews of Brown Uni- versity. $1.10. Any of the above books sent, by mait, postpaid, on receipt of prices given above. We have an announcement in the Nation every week, either in this place, or immediately after ‘* Schools.’ GINN & CO., Publishers. Boston, New York, Chicago, London. FILL YOUR PIPE with Golden Sceptre IF You love GOOD TOBACCO. Send ten cents to SURBRUG, 159 Ful- ton Street, for a big sample. $1.30 per pound, 40c. 4 oz., prepaid. Stbsofutely Pure A cream of tartar baking powder. Highest of all j our ’ = in leavening strength —Latest United States Gov Only and highest award at World’s Fair. ernment Food Report. Roya Bakina Powper Co , 106 Wall St., N. Y. For Children ? is worthy every parent’s study; not only what they can eat, but what gives the most nourishment. No children are better, and most are worse, for eating lard-cook- / Wied food If, how- ever, their yfood is prepared with the health- ful new vegetable & COTTOLENE instead of lard, they can eat free- ly of the best food without danger to the digestive organs. You can easily verify this by a fair trial of Cottolene. 8 y Sane ore Made only by The N.K.Fairbank |=; Company, Chicago, Boston, New York, St. Philadelphia, San Francisco. Q9%% * PURE FOK THE BABY. THE PROCTER & GAMBLE CO., CIN'TI.
Page 5
TEC The NEW YORK, THURSDAY, JANUARY 4, 1894. | that the increase was necessary and The Week. THE steady decline of the cash balance in the Treasury will force Congress to pass some kind of a bill immediately on reassembling. The balance is now less than $90,000,000, and this includes the greenback redemption fund, which has long been below the statutory require ment. There is now no export move ment of gold, and no apprehension that the country will be forced to the silver basis. Hence the Treasury balance may fall considerably below the present figure without producing distrust. Yet it is not wise to incur the risk of fresh trouble. Nor is it wise to postpone Gov ernment obligations which must be paid The secretary, in his annual report, re commended an alternative for replenish ing the Treasury for the time being— namely, the issue of obligations not ex ceeding $50,000 ,000in the aggregate, bear ing interest not exceeding 3 per cent., to be paid to such creditors as will accept them, the remainder to be sold at not less than par (these obligations to be payable at the pleasure of the Government one year after date) ; or, investing the secre tary with authority to issue five-year bonds in the ordinary form, and in de nominations of $25 and upwards, bear- ing not more than 3 per cent. interest —the latter to be a continuing authority to protect the Government’s gold re- serve. These bonds would take the place of those authorized by the old laws for maintaining the greenback redemp- tion fund, but would be available also for meeting casual deficits of revenue. In fact, under present conditions what ever accomplishes one of these ends ac complishes the other also. All the money in the United States being the equivalent of gold, any money which comes into the Treasury answers the purpose of making good the greenback redemption fund and of meeting the public expenses. We think that both the plans suggested by the secretary ought to be adopted That is to say, the secretary ought to have discretionary authority at all times to issue exchequer bills to meet tem porary deficiencies in the revenue, and this authority ought not to be limited to $50,000,000. It ought to be equal to at least one-half of the appropriations of the Government for any fiscal year. There is no danger whatever that such authority would be abused. No administration likes to have its interest-bearing obligations increased, because such increase puts a club in the hands of the oppo site party, and unless it can be shown unavoidable, the consequences are sure to be disastrous in the ensuing elec tions. But there is something still more disastrous, and that is inability to meet current expenses. The Government's debts are no greater by reason of the issue of exchequer bills They have merely taken a different form. In stead of owing contractors, pension ers, clerks, and manufacturers, who have groups dependent on themselves, and who cannot afford to wait for their money, it owes people who desire that form of investment. satisfied. This is not saying that a Government obligation should be cre So ev ery body Is ated because some people would like to find a safe investment for their idle money. That would be a form of so cialisin quite as reprehensible as any other. The rules which should govern in this case are the same as those which apply to a private corporation, Mr. David A. Wells has in the January Forum an article on ‘** The Teaching of Our Recent Economic Experiences, which supplies answers to a great many queries as to why the repeal of the silver purchase law has not been followed at once by better times He estimates the total loss, expressed in terms of money, which this country sustained because ot its trifling with its standard of value, at one thousand millions of dollars,or mors than one-third of the amount of the national debt at the close of the war, and says of it that the burden of these losses ‘‘ fell most grievously and disproportionately upon that portion of the population of the United States which was least able to bear it, name ly, those who depend upon each day's earnings to meet each day's needs I goes on to show that the causes of thes: disastrous experiences were mainly arti ficial, and wholly unnecessary, being due to ignorance as to the origin, na ture, and function of money and as to all other economie subjects—an ignor ance which prevailed ‘‘ not only among the masses, but among many whoare fill ing g important stations as legislators, editors, and educational directors and teachers. ”’ No one will ot je t te the Senate com mittee summoning before it as many men as it pleases, to tell what they saw, or failed to see, in Honolulu last Janu ary; but no grown man will expect to see the case against Stevens made any the less black thereby That case does not rest upon what any man or men saw or said, but upen the documentary evi- dence furnished by Stevens himself and } ‘ President Dole, and upon the calendar ‘A Nation. and the watch There that evidence stands, and no lawverlor full witt: vilian who studies it can doubt its con clusiveness,or admit the possibilitw of its being overthrown by any verbal testi mony or explanations whatever Alle) protests of patriotic motives and benevo lent intentions that can be made do not touch the evidence We cor end te Stevens and his pious allies in overthrow ing the Hawaiian Government th: legal view of Mr. Justice Maule, wl asked a man on trial for stealiny watchif he had anv witnesses to ‘ ‘No one but my Maker, who knows that I am innocent,” was the reply Y justice settled back for a moment, at then said Gentlemen of the jury, t] prisoner has summoned one witness, does not appear, on the other hat ‘ have heard the evidence of two wit: es Who saw him steal the wat The House of Repre sentatives passed on December 14 a bill of uch gener interest, which has attracted verw lit tle attention tn the newspapers It was reported by the joint co ssion of ( gress to Inquire into tt status of pws ry , ny the eXe fry 1 , , immd it went thi h wit ; ve sition. Its popular featur rakes a re luction in the } of pos (ney orders, to place the 1 pa t t spect vith the 1 nev roler 5 | \ the express companies do itva shes the postal not I irguinent pre ted in favor of the latter change was thatthe postal note furnishes no security to the sender, for if one ts lost 1 iplicate can be obtained. Under the new law a change of fees is enacted, which permits the issue of money orders for sums not exceeding we ‘oO for three cents As monev-orders ire subject to endorsement, if one is re Ceived at an office that is not authorized to issue or cash them, it can be endorsed to some one who will cash i On larger orders the rates of issue are materially reduced. The measure went through the House so rapidly that its natural oppo nents did not have time to get their forces in line, but it is intimated that the ex press companies will be on hand when the bill comes up in the Senate These companies were in active opposition to the change in the postal laws years ago that instituted the parcels post, but the mea sure was 80 popular that Congress dared not defeat it. The same will probably be the case with this bill) Further than this, it is understood that the ex- press companies find their money-order business so profitable that they may not care to make it a subject of public de- bate in Congress, as already some bank ing institutions are said to be thinking seriously of entering into competition for it
Page 6
2 Abundant evidence is furnished ina large number of letters from bankers in all parts of the South, published by the Manufacturers’ Record, that the farmers of that section are now in a better condi- tion than ever before. The low price of* cotton for the last few years has had the good effect of forcing them to raise their own food-stuffs because they could not buy them, and this disposition was strengthened by the decision of bankers and factors not to advance money so readily as before. In this way there is beginning to be a change from the old and improvident -credit system, with its reckless buying, to a cash system which requires the closest economy. This change has reduced the volume of gene- ral business, but the business which is done rests on a solider foundation than ever before, and the bankers without ex- ception report that the farmers are less in debt now than for years. Money which formerly went North and West for pro- visions and grain has been retained at home, and there is every reason to be- lieve that the South is less in debt to those sections for supplies than ever be- fore since the end of the war. Gov. Waite of Colorado seems to be the most hopeless case among the cranks who have been landed in high office by the political upheavals of the last few years. Some weeks ago he intimated that he was going tocall an extra session of the Colorado Legislature in order to secure a restoration of the State’s former prosperity. The proposition has met with nothing but opposition and protest, for public sentiment is overwhelmingly against it, and earnest appeals have been made to the Governor not to carry out his purpose. But nothing affects so con- ceited a fool as Waite, and he has issued his proclamation, specifying a large number of absurd plans which he wants the law-makers to carry out. There is no money in the Treasury to pay the ex- penses of the extra session, and although the members must obey the call of an executive who has the legal right to convene them, he cannot prevent their prompt adjournment. Colorado—that is, all of the State ex- cept the Populist Governor—has so fully recovered from its fit of blues that the commonwealth is in better spirits this winter than ever before. The Rocky Mountain News, which only a few months ago prophesied absolute ruin in case the silver-repeal bill were passed, now de- clares that Denver is the most pros- perous city and Colorado the most prosperous State between the Atlan- tic and the Pacific. Ex-Gov. Grant says that ‘‘Colorado is the first State to show signs of business revival,’’ and that it will offer in the future, as in the past, ‘the most inviting opportunities for labor and capital of any State in the The Nation. Union.”’ Ata recent gathering of busi- ness men from all over the State in Den- ver, the speakers admitted, to quote the words of one of them, that ‘‘this terrible importance of our silver is overdrawn,” while another boasted, ‘‘ We have more coal per capita than Pennsylvania, we have greater agricultural resources per capita than the States of the Mississippi valley, we lead all others in the produc- tion not only of silver but of gold.” There has been a wonderful develop- ment of gold-mining during the last few months, and the new gold camp of Cripple Creek is producing marvellous supplies. Altogether it is hard to be- lieve that this is the same State over whose impending destruction Senator Teller was shedding tears in the Senate only a few weeks ago. The most notable passage in Gov. Flower’s message is that in which he puts himself squarely upon record against the present Hill ballot law and in favor of the adoption of a genuine ballot-reform law. He says that repeated experience has shown that changes in the direction of sim- plicity are desirable, that the ‘‘ pre- sent system leads to confusion, mistakes, and annoyance,’ and recommends the ‘* adoption of a so-called blanket ballot, with the names upon it so arranged and printed that the elector can easily vote for the candidates of his choice.’”’ The Governor also favors a uniform elec- tion-inspector law, and recommends the amendment of the present corrupt-prac- tices act in such a way as to include cam- paign committees and political agents in the requirement of sworn publica- tion after election of all money received and disbursed. All these suggestions are excellent, and we are glad to learn that the Legislature will be given an op- portunity to embody all of them in law. One of the most disgraceful incidents in Tammany rule has been the attempted appointment of a certain Pentecost as assistant district attorney by Mr. Fellows, although this might have been expected from the election of Mr. Fellows himself. Pentecost is a half-cracked preacher and labor agitator, who gave up preaching for the law just one year ago, and joined Tammany Hall. He has been a Baptist minister, a Congregational minister, a Georgite lecturer, and a socialistic edi- tor. He has, in his incendiary labor speeches, declared ‘‘there is enough money in this country to give every man $5,000 a year,” and that, if he does not get it, he hoped there would be ‘‘a revo- lution, even though there should be a bloody one.’ In the Twentieth Century, which he edited, he came out strongly against capital punishment. That he has any knowledge of the law, or any mental capacity for acquiring it, or any fixed views on any subject, or any fidelity or loyalty to any social organization, there is no reason for supposing. As a public prosecutor he would, of course, have been ridiculous, but he was not selected to prosecute criminals. He was to draw a salary in order to please the radical and revolutionary labor element. There are encouraging features in so notori ously unfit an appointment. It is al- most a maxim, in a case of outrage- ously bad government, such as this city rests under from Tammany, that it must reach its worst point before public opinion will so assert itself as to make reform possible. On merely debatable questions of government the masses will not stop to reason and to think. But the nomination of a Maynard, the elec- tion proceedings of a McKane, and the elevation of a Pentecost to the prosecut- ing oftice need scarcely any argument to prove their character, and they thus arouse public opinion to a realization of the course down which their affairs are drifting. In the face of this opinion Pentecost has declined the appointment. The striking Danbury hatters have sent us a little pamphlet entitled, ‘“Slav- ery Revived in the United States’’—that is, by the employing Danbury hatters. We were a good deal startled by this, knowing that slavery was prohibited by the Thirteenth Amendment of the Unit- ed States Constitution, and knowing also, that, under the Connecticut Constitu- tion, no man could be deprived of his liberty except by a judicial sentence. We asked ourselves, in amazement, whether the Danbury employing hatters could be so crazy as to suppose that they could impose forced labor and the punish- ment of stripes on a body so respectable and numerous as the working hatters, particularly as the condition of slavery was, according to the pamphlet, to de- scend to their children. We, therefore, turned to the ‘‘exhibits’’ in the pamphlet with rising indignation, and found that the ‘‘slavery”’ lay in four forms of agree- ment which the ‘‘masters’’ asked the slaves to sign. In No. 1 the slave applies for work, and aftirms that he does not belong to any association which will pre- vent his carrying out any agreement into which he has freely entered, and that in case of disagreement with the master about prices, the matter shall be re- ferred to a committee of masters chosen by the slaves. In No. 2 the masters agree to pay wages punctually to the slaves, and have due regard for their ‘‘ rights and convenience,’ and _ for their ‘‘ health and comfort,” to renew and readjust the wages paid twice a year, and oftenerif requested, and to let any slave who wishes to run away to another master have an honorable dis- charge if he has been six months in pos session of his last owner. The slave, on the other hand, agrees to work faithful ly, to obey plantation rules, to make all ”
Page 7
: 3 . i : Jan. 4, 1894] complaints first to the overseer and then to the which will prevent his fulfilling lawful contracts, and to pay two weeks’ wages as liquidated damages in case of viola tion of the contract. The other agree- ments relate to giving instruction in the business to young slaves, and to the ne cessity of giving two weeks’ notice of intention to run away. All we can say about this is, that what strikes us in the agreements is their extraordinary justice, fairness, and considerateness. The tribunal for deciding disputes ought to contain some slaves, but with this exception the terms are, we think, the best ever offered by masters to a ser- vile race. As any slave is at liberty un der the contract to run away on giving two weeks’ notice, the system isintinite ly milder than any other form of slavery ancient or modern. Even the Apostle Paul did not countenance the flight of slaves, for he returned Onesimus to his master. master, to join no association There are signs that the Presbyterian heresy troubles are going to run parallel to those of the Congregational church of a few years ago, which, it will be re membered, first raged for a time among the churches in this country, and then broke out on the missionary field. A Presbyterian missionary in Siam, the Rev. E. B. McGilvary, has lately resigned on the ground that he cannot accept the doctrines of the inerrancy of Scripture or the Mosaic authorship of the Penta teuch. The General Assembly declared at Portland that any Presbyterian minis ter who did not accept those doctrines ought at once to leave the denomina tion. A few liberal ministers in this country took up the challenge and re signed, but many more fell back on the doubt whether the Assembly had a constitutional right to make any such demand, and refused to resign. Mr. McGilvary casts in his lot with those who resign. He seems to have been pe- culiarly well fitted for his work, having been born in Siam of a missionary father, and having pronounced scholarly tastes. He was educated at Princeton, and his defection must raise horrid doubts about the soundness of the teaching in that institution. The Board of Missions were reluctant to accept his resignation, and speak in the highest terms of his cha racter and abilities. But, of course, it would never do to let a man keep on trying to induce people to stop sacrific ing to white elephants who had any to leration for Deutero-Isaiah or the Jeho vist. The Tribune published on Sunday a | striking letter from ‘‘ a prominent Ame rican ’’ resident in Rio de Janeiro, in which the present troubles in were intelligently discussed, and, in par ticular, the only concern of the United Brazil | The Nation. States in the squabble tersely set forth He protests against the pyrotechnic patriotism in which American editors are continually indulging " whenever there is a rumor that the monarchy is to be restored in Brazil,-or anything done there agreeable to anybody in Eu rope. He denies, in the name both of Americans resident in South America and of South Americans that the United good in setting up as themselves, States can do any the policen in ot the continent,” or ** the stepfather of every petty republic this side of the At lantic.”’ With much force he points out that such an interfering protectorate has never been desired by any of the coun tries in question, but that,on the con trary, they have always resented it both | in theory and in attempted application When Blaine was performing his antics with Chili in 1ssl, and in 1892, the result was to arouse feelings Harrison his of strong hostility to the United States throughout all South America,and there was much talk of the need of a Latin American union te resist the overbear ing assumptions of the United States Nothing else could be + xpected to to.low any meddling of ours in Brazilian af fairs at present, and our sole duty, as well as interest, is to keep scrupulously out of that quarrel altogether Despatches from Brazil represent stock-jobbers and other speculators as very that the should ‘‘ enforce the Monroe doctrine anxious United States and say that the news of the departure of the New York for Rio is received with ‘ great satisfaction,” presumably on the ground that the aforesaid doctrine will be enforced by the big ship light on the m This throws needed ddern concept of the Monroe doctrine What it means | historically, and how it fits into the general body of international would be vain to inquire of those who drag it out as a sort of fetish on « casion of disturbances like those wit which Brazil is now torn; and it is only by some such specitic application of it as the one quoted that we see what the doctrine means, and why t is apne to, nowadays. Evidently, a rding t this, the first end and air trine Is to prevent Americans engag I speculation in South American intries from losing money. When their ventures go wrong and tl ey see their nitrate beds and rubber concessions slipping away from them, the first thing to do is t summon the ghost of James Monroe help them out. Then mission to local laws somewhat irksome and would like to have some way of set ourts at defiance, Monroe do trine, properly interpreted. We to see that the Washington ting the writs of local: there is nothing like the ure clad authorities are she Wing ne dis encourage this view of the duty of the United States. under the Monroe or any other theory of international bullvin and have instructed the admiral 1 The acquittal on Saturday of all th Frenchmen on trial for the murder at Aigues Mortes last Au gust s s deplorable a inca t of justice as was the fatlure of t! New Orleans grand jurv even & flict for the massact Italia that tv in Is Pre a " 5 said to have excla edo ow ur of it Juris re k t tries W hat ! t nt i { t that it is idle to expect rv t v tf one of! ore { thre w ‘ try nen for irdering for wl t nurder has grown out of race hatred As soon expect to hay men nvict f murder who kil foreigners warfare It must be said, howe that the French machinery { istres did not break down so disgracefully as ours in New ©) ul The Fr } aSSassiIns Were at least brought ¢ tria though thev wer not Victed But the New Orleans grand jurv would 1 even indict Thev handed ina long m I rt t Ww ke ear thre le " who were slaughtered tn cold blee ecl t} thev were not puustitic n presenting indi ents is hos the Ss re Was vw in t! first st i ven th st iw ! if ns This « \ Th gv between the two case ext s also to the payment of ince nity t ney is it might be wlled. President Harrison's adminis tration disclaimed all legal or inter tional responsibility for the assassina tion of the Italians in New Orleans, but egee t Italian (,overnment to aceept) 125.000 franes for distribution al ng the amuilies of the victims, las a means of etfacing all memory of the unhappy tragedy The French vy, before learn ing of the verdict on the \igues Mortes Government had already intimated its readiness to SsSassins iv an indemnity to the Italian Gov- ernment, and something like 400,000 frances had been agreed upon But the payment was to be on the basis f reciprocity, the Italian Government, in its turn, being expected to indemnify Frenchmen had destroyed by mobs in Genoa and Rome It is whose property been now reported, however, that the Italians are so enraged by the acquittal of the Aigues: Mortes criminals that they . position whatever to | will refuse to pay any indemnity. In that case they will simply lose the poor satisfaction of getting blood-money for The in fact, appears to their murdered fellow-countrymen jingle of the guinea, be the only cure left for the hurts of in ternational honor.
Page 8
Tee Rretesr aa A [Vol. 58, No. 1488 BALLOT LAWS AND ELECTION FRAUDS. It is astriking commentary on the evil influence of David Bennett Hill upon the political history of this State that the new Legislature will be asked to enact a genuine ballot-reform law. The agita- tion for ballot reform in this country was started in this city five years ago, and the first comprehensive measure (for more than municipal application) embodying the fundamental principles of the Australian system which was drawn in the United States was present- ed to the New York Legislature in the winter of 1888. It passed the Legislature and was vetoed by Gov. Hill. It was again presented in 1889, again passed, and again vetoed by Gov. Hill. In the meantime the agitation had reached Massachu- setts, and in 1889 a law which was mo- delled closely upon the measure origi- nally drawn in New York, was put up- on the statute-books of that State, and Massachusetts thus obtained the honor of being the first American State to adopt the reform. Other States followed rapidly in her wake, and five years after the movement had been started no less than thirty-six States had enacted laws embodying the new system in various forms. The larger number of these fol- lowed* the Massachusetts plan, which provides a single or blanket ballot, with the names of all candidates printed upon it, arranged in groups in alphabeti- cal order under each office. Other States adopted a blanket ballot with the names of candidates arranged in party columns, with the party name at the top, and still others added to the names an emblem or symbol. Three States, New York, New Jersey, and Connecticut, all acting un- der the influence of Gov. Hill, adopted a compromise or makeshift system, which provides separate party ballots, and which has never had the approval of bal- lot-reformers. We show in the sub- joined table the distribution of these laws among the States: Whole number of laws... ................ bbe keesleniee 36 Se IN Do ncccb cscs bpcccsccwces etee.sccncks 38 Blanket ballots, alphabetical order................... ly These are: Alabama, Nebraska, South Dakota, Arkansas, Nevada, Tennessee, California, New Hampshire, Vermont, Massachusetts, North Dakota, Washington, Minnesota, Oregon, Wisconsin, Mississippt. Rhode Isiand, Wyoming. Montana, Blanket ballots with party group and name........ These are: Illinois, Maine, Pennsylvania, Iowa, Missouri, West Virginia. Kansas, Blanket balots with party group, name, and em- IR Stbss Wihak nk chs idepecieeesbevinvncs cischabesnsbaees | These are: Colorado, Kentucky, Michigan, Delaware, Maryland, Ohio. Indiana, With separate ballots....m............00008 eee pans ee These are: Connecticut, New Jersey, New York. With “ paster” ballot, New York alone. The poorest, most inconvenient, and most easily ‘‘worked”’ for fraudulent purposes is the New York law, which Gov. Hill invented and allowed to go upon the statute-books in 1590. The Connecticut and New Jersey laws have many of the evil features of Mr. Hill’s contrivance, but they do not have the worst of them, which is the ‘‘paster.’’ To get rid of: this and of the other bad features of the law is at present the object of the City Club’s special committee, which, in consultation with representatives of various political and other organizations, is now preparing a new ballot act embodying the essen- tial principles of the Massachusetts law. Thus, five years after the beginning of the agitation which has been taken up and carried to success in three-quarters of the Union, New York is still engaged in trying to get for itself a genuiue_ ballot- reform law. There is, we are glad to say, excellent assurance that success will crown this winter’s efforts. The need of a better law than Gov. Hill was willing we should have was very clearly shown in the last election. The Tammany workers, not satisfied with the cheating facilities which the use of the ‘‘paster’ affords them, have been studying, ever since the law was passed, to discover methods by which to ‘‘beat’’ it. They tried a number of these methods at the recent election, and with such boldness that nearly one hundred of these gentry are now under indict- ment for violation of the law. What their fate will be, with Col. Fellows as their official prosecutor, remains to be seen. The methods which they operated were more audacious than ingenious, They made the provision which allows a phy- sically disabled voter to take a friend into the booth with him to prepare his ballot, an excuse for accompanying into the booth voters whom they had bribed, having them first swear that they were either blind or prevented by palsy or lameness from preparing their ballots. Several of the blind men who had been aided in this way, incautiously picked up. matches and pins from the floor after coming out of the compartments. In several instances Tammany workers, in defiance of law, placed themselves behind the booths or compartments, cut holes in the backs of them, and thus communicated with the voters on the inside, preparing their ballots for them. One Republican inspector whose atten- tion was called to these proceedings, de- clared that he was not able to see them, and it was discovered subsequently that he had a glass eye, and was studiously keeping that fixed upon the Tammany operators. In other districts no pretence was made of following the regulations, and tramps and repeaters voted freely without regard to the re- gistry list or anything else. So far was this carried that in a district in which there are not more than 7,000 voters, no less than 13,000 votes were cast. When it came to counting, the two Tammany inspectors, assisted in many districts by the Republican inspectors, showed such zeal that in several locali- ties in ‘‘Paddy’”’ Divver’s bailiwick not a single Republican vote was counted. In one district there were seventy-five or more ballots upon which the name of an independent candidate for the Assem- bly had been pasted. The inspectors were preparing to reject all these because the pasters were not placed exactly over the name of the regular candidate. Whena vatcher called attention to the fact that the law expressly provided that such ex- actness was not necessary, the Tam- many Chairman said, pointing to his two associate inspectors in turn: ‘‘ You vote to reject, you vote to reject, and I vote to reject—we don’t count ’em—see?’’ These, and in fact nearly all the worst frauds of the late election,were in direct and open defiance of the law, though the use of the ‘“‘ paster’’ and the somewhat lax condition of the law generally may have contributed somewhat to make the violations more difficult to de- tect and punish. It is going to be difficult, however, to draft a law which will prevent an enterprising Tammany man from getting behind a booth and boring a hole in it, unless the bocths be constructed of sheet-iron, and unless it be distinctly specified that in- spectors with one glass eye or policemen with two, or with no eyes at all, shall not be eligible for duty on election day. The best law that human in- telligence can devise will be powerless to prevent fraud if its administration is in the hands of a lot of thieves and other rascals—which was the case in many quarters of this city in November last. A step towards preventing this will be taken when the old law giving the Republicans two inspectors to every Tammany two shall have been restored. With a blanket ballot, with all ‘‘ past- ers’’ forbidden, and with an equal po- litical division of inspectors, we shall certainly be much better off than we are at present; and these, as we understand it, are to be the leading provisions of the law which is now in preparation. THE NAVAL ALARM IN ENGLAND. THE alarm in England over the condi- tion of the navy is adding seriously to the troubles of the Gladstone ministry. The revenue is declining, but an expen- diture of about $50,000,000 on the navy is imperatively called for, in order to maintain its superiority to the combined forces of France and Russia. The panic is anold one. Every generation has to pass through it. It occurred under Louis Philippe, when the Prince de Joinville wrote a pamphlet showing how England might be ousted from her supremacy at sea. It occurred under Louis Napoleon when he began to build ironclads, and it has come up now again, under the re public. The controversy is very much obscured by the lack of exact information about
Page 9
Jan 4, 1894] the navies of both France and Russia, the Tories probably exaggerating their size and strength, and the Liberals in like manner underestimating them. There is much the same trouble about the British navy. Opinions widely vary about its strength and efficiency, but the nume- rous accidents which have of late over- taken it, and the poor behavior of some of the large iron-clads in bad weather, necessarily have diffused a great deal of anxiety through the community. but if the navy were ever so eflicient, it is diffi- cult to see how British commerce is to be protected in the narrow seas, where torpedo boats can dash out from a hun dred ports and creeks in the dark nights and play havoc with it. This commerce is to-day enormous. It is hardly too much to say that Great Britain is in possession of the carrying-trade of the world. The ocean freight business of all other coun- tries put together is comparatively tri- fling, and this is another illustration of the way in which Great Britain profits by other people’s folly. She has no navi gation laws, and -nearly every other country has, so she takes the business away from them. Of course, as the discussion has pro gressed, each side has caught at every foreign authority that came in sight. Our Capt. Mahan’s ‘ Influence of the Sea Power’ has in particular done yeoman on the Conservative It is in all respects a remarkable book, and shows, in flowing English, how from the earliest days supremacy on the sea has carried with it supremacy on land. service side. and eloquent But a good deal of its reasoning on this head has been weakened or vitiated by the inven tion of railways, which has consider ably diminished the importance of wa- ter transportation. If Napoleon had to fight Wellington again in Spain, the possession of the sea would do vastly less for the latter. But there isno ques- tion whatever that, for the British Em- pire, the control of the sea is a question of life and death. Along with Capt. Mahan, whose autho rity none will dispute, Lord George Hamilton, a civil lord of the admi ralty in the late Government, cited | our ex-Secretary Tracy as an autho rity concerning the number of Great Britain ought to have in order to hold her own against the navies of | the world. We are quite sure Mr. Tracy never uttered any such opinion with the expectation that it would be quoted in Parliament as the opinion of an expert Even a lifetime in the navy of a great power evidently is hardly a sufticient qualification for forming a judgment on this subject, for the British naval thorities differ about it considerably; and Secretary Tracy can hardly have thought that four years in the Navy De partment at Washington, taken from the practice of the law, in middle life, fitted him to ‘‘ give them points’ au on The Nation. the with which Englishmen have had to deal. If this were true, the training of men for most serious naval problem the sea from youth up would be a great farce, and we should, when war broke out, readily gather up a lot of admirals from the dry-goods stores and law of fices, and, above all, from the newspaper ottices, of any great city This citation of Mr. Tracy was evi dently made in great ignorance of the way in which our navy is governed. Ours in the world, we be All the Continental navies are governed by ad- is the only navy lieve, Which has no naval head mirals—that is, the minister of marine, the officer answering to our secretary of The government of the British navy is pecu liar, its being the commissioners admiralty the navy, is invariably an admiral commanders lords of the Of these there are six, but only two are Then, too, it has to be borne in mind that, ow civilians, the other four admirals ing to the permanence in public life of English statesmen, the civil lords are generally men who have given a good deal of attention to the navy during long This condition has been in a measure fulfilled in the case of our Mr. Herbert, for he was, before his years in Parliament accession to his present position, chair of the But a rule our secretaries navy are committee of the lawyers who, before being called to pre- man naval as side over our military marine, hardly knew the bow from the stern of a ship nor, as a rule, has there been the slight est that with any reference to their marine ex pretence they were selected perience. As long as we made no pretence of having a navy this was perhaps a matter of small importance, but now that we are preparing to become a naval powerit has a good deal of importance. We un doubtedly owe to it most of the recent It is an old and sound rule of all the military the world that mistakes in matters of discipline services of ‘**no man Is , that manage obey’’—that must to the army or navy by having himself served is every man learn subordinates in ships under orders. Accordingly, in all armies and all navies each man has to begin at fit to command who has not learned to | the beginning, and take a long course in | obedience, before he is allowed com mand of the lives or reputations of the soldiers or sailors. In this way, and in this way only, can he find out how much an: he can fairly exact under him. Herein 7 in the places of lies the value of sail- - ors ministers of or lords of the admiralty. l the fe VW lies | lv of suddenly seizing a lawyer ommand of the fleet least idea how to treat and putting him in« He has not the officers and men; and the way in which Commanders Whitehead, Reiter, Higgin- son, and Admiral Stanton have been keel ‘ hauled shows the need of some reorgani i what kind of service | ‘' from those who serve | marine |} Herein, too, | 7 > zation of the Navy Department if we are to keep on increasing our navy THE EVOLUTION OV} 1 PYNAMTI THE police inquiries into the antecedents of Auguste Vaillant, the aspiring youth who set about ushering in the Golden Fret h Instruction al Age by trying to blow the Chamber, full of warning, as they show up are verv neativ the process by which bomb throwers are grown. Vaillant had taken a full cours in socialism, and was, in fact, as fie himself declares, only meting, us a consistent graduate in that discipline should when he thlung his bomb Aftera life of considerable irregularity, in which we see him deserting his wife nad tak ing another man’s as his mistress, |} Was first heard of as a public character in the guise of a founder of a Cere!] Philosophique,”’ at Chotsy The kind of philosophy advocated in this ‘ may be inferred from the fact that it Was soon merged in the Revolutionary Soctalistic Union of the eighteenth arrondissement, Paris, in which we known revolutionaries Like Mo Guesd: gave “courses” im “* social economy and ‘‘ special philosophy In other wavs did Vaillant ally h self with the socialistic propaganda He had for a time a connection with the Crid j He was also a dabbler in local politics. For some time he was at the head of a vement t present a bust of Marat to the « ity which was somehow expected to give a great lift to But tinally the bust ized by Vaillant’s landlord for the socialist party WAS Se un and so that movement came He kept up his poh ty, however, and paid rent, to grief tical activi SeVeETAL Sax ialistic pro clamations put forth by him as secretary of his ‘‘ group” have been unearthed One ot t hem, dated ISS6. called upon his fellow-citizens to join their ballots nh electing a certain candidate, ‘ while - > waiting for the time to come to join our rifles to fight against a reactionary so- clety Another one, put forth in 1887 defined the purpose of his ‘‘ union’’ to ‘* pursue, no matter by what means, the socialization of the means of production | This is only the common socialistic jar gon, still used and defended even by the French Vaillant unsparingly socialists who now condemn Vaillant is to be traced for some time in various socialistic organizations—the Parisian Agglomeration,’ the ‘‘Fede ration of Free Thought,” the ‘Equals of Montmartre,” dozen A part of his zeal in attending their meet ings may have been due to the fact that he used to work off a good deal of rice cotfee on fellow-socialists; but this resource soon failed he then time in South America, Paris about a year ago, he tried hard to get a nomination as deputy last August. and a others. and at a commission his him, and spent some teturning to
Page 10
G [Vol. 58, No. 1488 Had he been successful, he might have been comfortably sitting with the other socialistic deputies in the Chamber on December 9, and left it to some other advanced reformer to throw the bomb from the gallery. Such a career is worth detailing, be- cause it so characteristically reveals the evolution of an anarchist out of a social- ist, and of a dynamiter out of an anarch- ist. In his own weak and vain head, Vail- lant illustrates the precise and necessary operation of the socialistic philosophy up- on thousands of, other weak and vain heads. Is it anything strange that they should take to throwing bombs in order to hasten the destruction of a social or- der which, they are assured by their teachers, is one vast system of legalized robbery? A writer in the Débats says most truthfully on this point: “One can easily, link by link, reconstruct the chain which joins the anarchist who throws a bomb in the Palais-Bourbon with the writer whose anti-social theories and incitements and provocations are spread abroad every day in the socialistic newspapers, or with the orator who makes their gatherings reécho. They are sowing in brutal natures the seeds of every kind of violence and fury, and are giving weak minds the most dangerous sophisms to feed upon. They are planting germs of hatred, they are corrupting the reason and destroying the conscience; and yet, when they have been listened to attentively, when the destructive practices which they have incited have done their work, they disavow their own doing and protest that their hands are clean.” The truth of this is witnessed to in the very condemnations visited upon Vail- lant’s head by his former socialistic col- leagues. They call him ‘rash’ and ‘‘premature,’’ and say that the ‘ really responsible criminal’’ is ‘‘ the villany of existing society.’’ If this is so, what folly for them to denounce a man for adopting means of his own which to his mind seem more rapid and effect- ive than theirs for putting an end to that villany! They both aim at the destruction of the present social order. Not one stone of it is to be left upon another. Why, then, quarrel about a mere detail of the destructive process? At any rate, as long as their so- cialistic doctrines are all the while turn- ing out such graduates as Vaillant, it is not possible to disclaim all re- sponsibility for him. He himself as- serts that he is the most consistent of socialists, and, as a mere matter of logic, it would be hard to show that he is not. It is easy to say that he is a crack- brained creature who has no grasp of the true socialistic principle ; but the world is full of just such fellows as he is, and our benevolent professors and writers who preach up the ‘ na- tionalization of the means of produc- tion ’’ may be sure that they have plenty such in their audiences, ready, like V ail- lant, to put their doctrines to the prac- tical test with dynamite. M. Epovarp Rop has been remarking on the predominance in current French cari The Nation. cature of repellent types. He shows how the progress of the art has been away from the clumsy fun of André Gill, all the rage fifteen years ago, through the more delicately conceived raillery of Grévin and Robida, down to the pitiless sarcasm and delight in human brutality which mark the style of Forain, who to- day sets the fashion. ‘‘ And you must observe,’ says M. Rod, ‘‘ that Forain’s success is not an isolated fact; it harmonizes with tendencies to which the Théatre-Libre has given striking emphasis, and which are also conspicu- ous in some of the recent reviews. It is always the same thing: an over-acute observation which searches after evil, which finds it and rejoices to find it, and displays it with ironic satisfaction. People wallow in all sorts of baseness and laugh at it; they appear to be well pleased to wallow in it and to laugh at it, and they seem to say, ‘ What a fine thing it is that men are horrible, and what should we have to amuse ourselves with if they were not!’ ”’ Putting artistic questions aside, M. Rod asks what must be the effect of all this on the public. What about the plain people who have no resemblance to the moral monsters pictured for their entertainment, who live quiet lives and enjoy simple pleasures? Do they laugh at these cruel caricatures, and go to plays which turn on abnormal vices sim- ply to be in style? He almost hopes that they do, but he has to admit it to be more likely that ‘‘ these terrible engravings, with their terrible explana- tions, awaken in them, almost before they know it, dormant instincts long held in check by civilization, but to which it suddenly becomes proper to give full rein—a legacy of ancient savagery, a survival of primitive fero- city.”’ If that is the case, says M. Rod, we can see whither we are marching, and we must learn betimes to hate the human beast most of all when it is talented. We may still congratulate ourselves that the talented human beast has made but meagre conquests in this country. Perhaps we ought to hang our heads in shame as benighted Philistines in con- fessing it, but anyhow it seems to be a fact that the predominant literary and dramatic and artistic taste of Americans does not yet take kindly to those subjects which, as Haraphaof Gath said of Samson, ‘‘ need much washing to be touched.”’ But how if we have a human beast without talent? If it is still true that our writers and artists find their best inspiration and reward in themes that are wholesome, have we no other agencies for the popularization of evil, comparable to those of which M. Rod de- plores the bad effects in France? It is trite enough to say that the sensa- tional press is such an agency, but it is fair to ask if there is not a clear analogy between its harmful influence and that of the worst forms of French naturalism. Leaving entirely out of account for the present the responsibilities of newspaper proprietors and newspaper purchasers, let the simple question be put, What is bound to be the effect on its readers of the con- stant exploitation of crime and vice and scandal which plays so great a part ih the daily press? The question may be thus isolated and asked merely as a psychological and sociological one. Say nothing about the taste and pleasure of the reader or the ethics and profits of the editor, and inquire only what effect the daily presentation of the human beast, without any glamour of literary art about him, is going to have upon the people in whose faces he is thrust every day. To begin with the lowest class of read- ers, it has long been well understood by criminologists and alienists that the epidemic character which crime often seems to have in modern times is largely due to the broadcasting of all crime by the press. Leta peculiarly brutal or novel method of murder or suicide be invented insome part of the country, and itis sure to be duplicated as soon as the news- paper suggestion of it can be brought to bear on the unstable brains only waiting for some such push. Something of the same sort is clearly traceable in the plague of dynamite explosions now sweeping over Europe. The bomb in the theatre at Barcelona seems to suggest the bomb in the Chamber at Paris, and that a dozen others, until now the French police are every day arresting half-luna- tic criminals perfectly crazy to throw a bomb at somebody. So, too, the passion for sending infernal-machines to promi- nent men seems often to go in waves of infection of which the newspapers make themselves the vehicle. We may be sure that the psychologi- cal law which we see here so plainly operative, works also in the obscurer cases. ‘‘The fig-tree looking on the fig- tree becometh fruitful,’ says an Ara- bian proverb. Daily contemplation of the vices and meannesses and domes- tic unhappinesses of mankind is a dangerous test for any man to subject himself to. If he is pure-minded and high-minded, he is in danger of losing, by familiarity, that quick sense of dis- , gust and repulsion which is his safeguard at first. If he has any diseased parts in his mental and moral make-up, they are sure to be inflamed. A man _ brood- ing over his own wrongs or misfortunes, fancied or real, will be given a perilous tilt towards executing the villany he sees spread before him. Into slow-witted natures hints of baseness and trickery will be dropped which they never could of themselves have originated. Inno- cence and reticence will become more and more impossible to find, and a banal - sophistication on all subjects will be- come universal. Such results are cer- tain to attend the popularization of evil,
Page 11
a
Jan. 4, 1894 and to mark the progress of the human beast, with or without talent THE PARLIAMENTARY YEAR LAND. IN ENG LONDON, December 19, 1803, ALTHOUGH the Government majority, after the general election, fell slightly short of what sanguine Liberals had anticipated, seldom did a session open with higher hopes than that which met here on the 3ist of January. The Q@ueen’s speech foreshadowed the following great measures: home rule, registration re- form, shortening duration of Parliament, one man vote, employers’ liability, parish councils, local veto, church suspensory bills preparatory to disestablishment for Scotland and Wales. All these have been abandoned for this session, except home rule, employers’ liability, and parish councils. Besides the passage of the estimates, for which Parliament is primarily called, home rule practically occu- pied the entire session from February till Sep tember inclusive. After the bill had thrown out by the Lords, we met again on the 2d of November. The parish-councils bill came up for second reading and was passed without division on the 7th. The employers’- liability bill came up from the grand commit- tee and was passed on the 16th. It was subse- quently, in the opinion of three-fourths of the Liberal party, destroyed, at least in one of its most vital provisions, by the Lords. The com- mittee stage of the parish-councils bill was taken on the 17th of November, since when it has practically occupied Parliament. We are to have only three days’ vacation at Christ- mas. Possibly this bill may not be carriéd through even in January. Only nineteen of seventy-one clauses have yet What treatment the Lords will inflict on it re- mains to be seen. Such a state of affairs is without precedent. A deliberate and deep-laid plan is being car- ried out to block business, play into the hands of the Lords, discredit the Government, and precipitate a general election. Nor is the Op position altogether responsible for the block- ing. As Mr. Balfour pointed out the other day, the notice paper, when the bill was enter- ed upon in committee, included no fewer than three hundred amendments by Government supporters. The interest of the Government is clearly not to dissolve until it has done effec- tive work, and, if possible, strengthened its hold on the electorate by the passage of the registration and one-man-one-vote bills. To outsiders it may appear that the Conservatives, in thus opposing and delaying Liberal reform, and the Lords in aiding and abetting them, are undermining their own position. But English are a peculiar people. So long as they get what they want, they do not care under one been been passed. the what name or at whose hands it reaches them This, perhaps, bas helped to make their pri gress steady. They know that both parties must in the end cater for them. classes have staved off as long as possible mea sures imperilling their position and impugning their interests; but they have at the same time maintained their prestige by conceding when it was inevitable, and they often manage t get the credit of passing such reforms as can no longer be withheld. joy the advantage of The upper The Conservatives et immense having the
dead pull of vested interests always on their | side. We will suppose the Conservatives are in power. Certain reforms come to be desired which they are loath to concede. Upon a
The thousand Nation. platforms enough enthusiasm is aroused to overcome these The Liberals are ceeded. The those recently attacked thirsting for rever vested interests returned, the reforms cor Interests reassert their powe) All the Liberals have now to offer is good government. The Conservatives can bid as high in this regard. The Liberals are turned out until a fresh crop of necessities arises Ireland, meanwhile, unless when making be: affects the dailv lives likely to be left out of account; and so party succeeds party And it is to be noted that when Conservatives see fit self a nuisance, so little of Englishmen as to be to take reforms in do so with the consent of the interests compromised, which thatat is better to be disturbed by their friends than their opponents As yet hand, they realize of real unt of tl action there is no sig
against the Lords on acc regarding home rule or employers’ liability The middle classes gravitate more and mor: towards conservatism; the overwhelming pre ponderance of Irish Protestant opinion against home rule is being exploited with persistent against Mr The churct and liquor interests areupin arms. The L are generally found willing to pass any mea ability Gladstone res sure, however radical, proposed by a Conserva tive The cuse for delaying reform by whomsoever pr posed, If years, it appears as though only a government Liberals have no ex affairs go on as they have of lat Conuserva tive government is to be permitted to carry through extensive reforms. It must soon be come apparent that there is some cause for the present deadlock beyond the presence of eighty Irish National members in the House (who, ex cept at question time, have scarcely opened desire of the Li rule bill. It must were not an Iris! their lips for months), or the beral party to pass a home be evident that even if there Home-Ruler in Parliament, the present et! to transact the affairs, great and small, thirty-five millions of people at home a1 manage a widely extended empire abroad is breaking down under its own weight. Navy the absurdity of the attempt would be 1 , apparent if Ireland were not agitatir home rule, for then her four millions and half of inhabitants would not out their vearly requirements of minor matters being po what they were at the attended to. Compari: litical needs in tbe two islands now w time of the Union, the difticulty of legislating intelligently for bet! one assemblv has been greativ increas: There is an established church in Englar there is none in Ireland. Equality of instit tions existed in Pitt's time. Since then have
developed different land laws, a different educational svstem, a different } © sv¥stet different marriage laws. Difference of insti tutions induces other differences. The tenden cv has been more and more towards diversity All this is te w on the parliamentary machine. B . more embarrassing, per s, has bee v reasing complica tion of w, and its application, 4 manner forn ¥y unknown. tot every-day concerns ife There is bardly a line of this paris! neils bill tha as not to be nsidered it relation to other cislation passed in late vears, Law formeriv. however rude in its nstruction, how rough-and-ready in aj lieat iv a sin pen network over the land. It is now more and more closely woven, and the introduction of new threads, the passing new laws, is increasingly difficult There is, in truth, almost as much difference between law in its complexity now and the law
ai tests ™ <s wou sent tary lies have not vet ¢ i rv. Iris) Ireland ible of maintenance as that int supremacy in ld be of realization filling Mr Even he cannot please them
f SiXtV¥ Vearsa ist ~ ‘ twi wt x ‘ sw ‘ " ~ t ‘ i in ‘ thast \\ tw . ~ at law is it wae i \ 1 “i wid ia . t il host I waibily wi t ( V thre i tory = 1 Vv ix ! ! t aus he ‘ the: mt tt " “ nar iv suring -ft } 1 \ i fepends i | at a Un ibteally stuate Ta irelat ‘ bal ew! is i { = haps una il 1iSAast! s Y ts sire for mie! Teetiy \ ti I vn iaws and titut 2 t ed in tt hearts t l ‘ ter i nd vot t ts pers nal s t ~ l sert of way t t intentior abe do not ca that it s with thet " i terests r ! ya i wit n . “ ‘ ‘ tiv i le v \ . hav le t CAS s ullw Ww ‘ tr i ft. bv i iN served themsely - ! be rt sta ssucha the pres t 1} \ ; a Protest “ i { \ illwou ! insert selves Mi < ‘ ‘ — ‘ ss : hav on pt ~ t w“ i“ { \ by es ‘ ers — " < sy Se Ve! t \ ’ TA i . caus t sented by SK ! ib ? . x! is n a se Ww ACeS s vy t . t SS OX]x \ ss what it ned k t r ed ‘ wh <s ore w . ‘ ike lA ge ses, ft ‘ ~ ire< This kes e ts i tx t evicted and tenants ¢ +} try the set net . \ iLitsa } constant gra t I tiest a sti gest, a Irish Castle government is such a nicelv com pacted hine that nen like Mr. Morley and Mr. Brvce in their administrative action have Deen able to mal ittie Impression upon t. The masses of the Irish people see littl hang Neither the promises nor the antici at s f ti rer i t have been realized This tends upon the one hand to } itlca ido ana pen tl other to strengtl the hands the I irnellites, who fav i hillside nd reconcilable policy Nevertheless, the real irreconcilables in Ireland w vet be found to be the Protestant and Con servative party The Nationalists have within th ast twenty-five years advanced much Los than thev to a reasonable settlement They have definitely abandoned the separation | Conservatives and their English abandoned the idea of Pro a theory as im of separation Mr. Bryce is at pre- Morley’s place as chief secre I find the
Page 12
pepe Ne ER BER ES ee oe on fete pica > Rae 8 [Vol. 58, No. 1488 Seen ———————————— —_———————————— following in the Pall Mall Gazette of yester- day: “If the object of the prime minister in selecting Mr. Bryce as the mouthpiece of the Irish government was to insult and irritate Ulstermen, he has clearly achieved an admira- ble success.” If they are not satisfied with the government of men like Mr. Bryce, with whose government would they be satisfied ? It is, in truth, for the English people to consider whether they prefer the friendship of the masses of the Irish people, who can be recon- ciled, or that of the Irish minority, who could be kept in good humor only upon terms impos- sible of maintenance in a democratic commu- nity. Two articles regarding Ireland, signed “ X,” but evidently by different authors, which ap- peared in the Fortnightly Review for last month and this, have attracted considerable attention, The first attributes, to a mistaken extent, much of the economic depression in the country to railway and bank mismanage- ment. It dwells upon the general drawbacks, such as I have above indicated, and, while largely attributing them to the want of home rule, questions whether it is not now too late for the application of that or indeed any other re- medy. The second article is devoted princi- pally to an over-colored diatribe against the ‘* Rhetoricians,” the line of Irish patriots from Swift downwards, and against all but a small number of those who now speak in the name of Irish nationalism. It especially emphasizes present differences, not only such as existed be- fore the ‘‘ Parnell split”? between Nationalists and Orangemen, and which have since widen- ed between Nationalist and Independent, but those which from one cause or another exist among Nationalists themselves. It would be easy to explain how all these differences have arisen, as differences arise in every country and almost every party. The length of the contest, the heart-sickening of hope deferred, the sufferings endured, the demoralization of the present idle life in Parliament, are almost enough in themselves to cause bickerings. In whatever direction we turn our gaze, the outlook is clouded and uncertain. At no period, perhaps, were there a larger number of people at home and abroad more sincerely anxious to serve Ireland, more fully prepared to spend and be spent for her regeneration. Yet everything appears for the time at cross purposes. If Irishmen at home and abroad avail themselves of present discouragements and differences as excuses for slackening in the struggle for home rule, the results will be disastrous. If, seeing beyond these complica- tions, they support a reasonable policy, the present deadlock will prove to be only a phase in a long course of conjunctures all pointing towards one inevitable solution. D. B. VAILLANT, SOCIALISM AND MILITA- RISM. Paris, December 22, 1893. WHEN the new French Chamber met, it was difficult to know exactly what its character would be. One thing was certain: the mo- narchical group, Royalists and Bonapartists together, which numbered as much as 150 in the last Chamber, had been reduced to about fifty. But the republican majority was com- posed of very heterogeneous elements: it em- braced the Opportunists, the more or less con- servative Republicans, the more or less ad- vanced Radicals, and with them a large num- ber of socialists. In the first discussions which took place in the Chamber, there was a The Nation. split in this republican majority. M. Dupuy resigned almost immediately after the meeting of the Chamber, and was replaced by M. Casi- mir-Perier, the grandson of the Perier who was a minister of Louis Philippe. M. Casimir- Perier asked for a vote of confidence, and ob- tained it only by the help of the Right; he be- came the protégé of the monarchists. He saw 200 republicans on his side, and 200 republi- cans (I speak in round numbers) against him. The reason of this division was obvious: M. Dupuy, and after him M. Casimir-Perier, had declared themselves in favor of a homogeneous cabinet and against the policy which has taken the name of concentration, by which word was meant the coalition of all the republican groups, whatever their ideas and doctrines might be on the most important subjects, and the representation of all these groups in the cabinet. The policy of concentration had great defects: it rendered all serious legislative work next to impossible; but it had also great merits in the eyes of our politicians. Thirty or forty deputies had nothing to do but to form a ‘‘group,” which consisted merely in naming a president and a board, in meeting and dining together, in having a paper, generally without subscribers but kept up by the aid of the class of financiers who became so conspicuous in the Panama trial. ‘‘Je marche, done je suis,” said the group, and the group helped to make and unmake cabinets, and its leader, unknown yesterday, had a good chance of obtaining a seat in case of a readjustment or a reorganiza- tion of an administration. ‘*Concentration ” was invented by M. Thiers after the 16th of May, when he made up his elec- toral lists from the 363 deputies, without an ex- ception, who were hostile to Marshal MacMa- hon. It continued so long as there was any danger of a restoration; it survived Gambetta, Ferry; it served against Boulanger; but when the republican form of government and the Constitution had ceased to be in question, it be- came very obnoxious to the country. There were no real parties in the Chamber founded on principles; the groups formed and reformed perpetually; all questions became personal questions. A sort of crusade began against this policy after the last elections. Casimir- Perier was notoriously among those who favor- ed a new policy. His début was not fortunate; all ambitions were visibly ready to conspire against a man who would give no hope to any group, and who spoke of forming a homoge- neous administration. His cabinet seemed lost as soon as it was formed; it was saved by the most unforeseen event. The bomb thrown by Vaillant in the Chamber had the effect which no reasoning, no eloquence could have had. The Chamber had hitherto been trying to un- derstand itself; now it found itself, it became conscious. A majority, an overwhelming ma- jority, has been found in favor of the new Ad- ministration; the groups have disappeared, at least for the present; the Chamber has obeyed the elementary law of self-preservation, ‘‘ Pri- mum vivere, deinde politicari.” The Government has asked the Chamber to furnish it with certain indispensable arms against the anarchists, and hasintroduced four bills, which have been voted with extraordina- ry haste, after hardly any discussion. All as- sociations formed for the committal of crimes against life and property are to be unlawful; all understanding with the members of such associations will be equally punishable by law, as well as all public apology by means of news- papers or of public meetings. A large supple- mentary credit for the increase of the police has been placed at the disposal of the Govern- ment. Public opinion has fully endorsed all these measures; it feels that a real war has be- gun against all social institutions. All the rea- sonings in the world, all the teachings of po- litical economy, are of no avail with people who have invented the new system of propa- gandism—what they call propagandism par le fait, by facts; that is to say, by crimes. Socialism is no longer what it was in the days of 1848; it has completely transformed it- self. Ideas are like the rays of light which take the color of the transparent medium; socialistic ideas, which in the higher classes assume sometimes a religious, sometimes a philosophical, character, become deformed when they penetrate the lowest classes of the population. We have seen in our time, espe- cially in the past twenty years, an extraordi- nary development of socialism. We have in France what is called Christian socialism, preached by men like M. de Mun; we have the Tolstoian school, which began with admira- tion of ‘War and Peace’ and the other beauti- ful novels of the great Russian writer, and which ended in the sort of primitive Christian- ity which is now preached by Tolstoi, and which is the negation of personal property and of personal rights. We have read a Papal encyclical under the title of ‘*De condi- tione opificum.” Emperors and kings have spoken of the duties of society toward the workingman, Our politicians have made pro- mises of all sorts to the wage-earning classes; irreligion has worked side by side with reli- gion: those who denied to the poor a future life promised him the kingdoms of the earth. Under all these influences, is it much to be wondered at if the workingman has conceived hopes which cannot well be satisfied? Disap- pointment has thrown a bridge between social- ism and anarchism. In the famous monologue of Cinna, Augustus speaks of these men : “ chargés de dettes et de crimes, Que pressent de mes lois les ordres légitimes, Et qui, désespérant de les plus éviter, Si tout n’est renverse, ne sauraient subsister.” Maxime Du Camp has well described this class of men, which is always found in great capitals. They were the men who made the Commune after the war of 1870; they now have taken anarchy for their cry, and they place themselves at the head of the advanced socialists. The danger of socialism has probably been increased by the militarism which is the order of the day in Europe. In countries where military service has become an obligation, and where every man is called to his regiment first for two er three years, and afterwards from time to time for various periods till he is forty- five years of age, it is not surprising that the individual expects much from the State; the State claims from him services which it must repay. The ‘droit de travail” which was preached by Louis Blane at the Luxembourg in 1848, seemed a paradox at the time; it seems now almost an axiom to the workingman. Militarism has another effect: it depletes all European nations, and in this way creates in- creasing poverty, and poverty is the perpetual theme of all socialists. Italy might have lived happy and contented if she had kept out of the combinations (what the Germans call the constellations) of the great powers. She enter- ed the Triple Alliance, and condemned herself to expenses which are too large for her finan- cial capacity; she begins now to pay the price of her ambition, and is passing through a most dangerous crisis. The great men who achieved Italian unity are gone; her parliamentary per- sonnel is very mediocre. Crispi has again been called to power, as he is considered the
Page 13
“¥ a Bot Mae PEERS ee ae a dae eer
Jan. 4, 1894]
The Nation.
only strong man of the Parliament; he is very clever and very versatile, but one hardly sees how he can detach Italy from the bonds of the Triple Alliance; he can only ask the Italian people to pay new taxes, and taxation has al- ready become almost intolerable in Italy. The finances of France are not in danger, but they preoccupy all who think of the future Certainly the resources of France are immense, but they are not inexhaustible. France has one great advantage: her debt is held almost en tirely at home; she is not under the necessity of buying gold in order to pay her foreign creditors. In this respect she has a great supe riority over Italy, as an immense part of the Italian debt is in French or German hands France has another advantage: she is a pro ducer of wine, andsells much of it in various countries; she exports, besides, many manu factured articles; as a rule she is almost, with regard to foreign nations, in the position, not of a debtor, but of a creditor. She therefore bears no losses from exchange. This said, we must add that her debt is increasing in an alarming way. M. Boulanger, a Senator, who some time ago made a report on our finances, showed that the funded debt of France alone was equal to the united funded debts of Ger many, Austria-Hungary, and Russia. Eng land, alarmed at the prospect of a combination of the Russian and the French fleets in the Mediterranean, is going to vote again large sums for the increase of Ler already powerful navy. The navies of Italy, of Germany, of France have absorbed enormous sums of late years. Surely, if the old maxim, ‘Si vis pa- cem, para bellum,” is true, peace was never better assured; but it is difficult to imagine how the perpetuation of armaments will secure for ever the continuation of peace, and on the other hand to imagine anything more absurd than the perpetuation of armaments which are to remain useless. HABEMUS PONTIFICEM. IraLy, December 16, 1893. CRISPI is again at thehelm! Zanardelli was unsuccessful in forming a cabinet, owing tothe diversity of opinion on the financial question Saracco and Sonnino, members of the Centre, declined to join him, and the King naturally felt that it would be impossible to accept a ministry without a minister of finance. Then occurred another incident. Zanardelli had chosen for minister of foreign affairs Oreste Baratieri, a native of Trent, who had form- ed part of the expedition of the Thousand (1860), is now a general in the Italian army and governor of Eritrea. Baratieri accepted, but, on the eve of the completion of the minis- try, suddenly declined. This was a singular proceeding, as the King had manifested his ap- proval of Zanardelli’s choice. It is said that the Austrian ambassador protested—this again is denied—and there will be an interpellation in the House on the subject. This was the last drop in the cup. Zanardelli informed the King that he must decline further attempts to form a ministry. The King summoned Farini, president of the Senate, who, refusing to at tempt to form a ministry himself, advised the King to summon Crispi, and so he did on thi day of his arrival from Naples. Even Crispi has found immense obstacles, owing entirely to the financial difficulties, as he was resolved to allow no question of party or of persons to influence him in his choice of men whose characters and abilities might in sure a strong minitury. He had interviews
save tl Phen summoned Nicotera, and all old quarrels were him in 1801, but they came to litth Rudini gave promise of support. made up. Nicotera, who is one of the most generous and patriotic of men, promised his support to his old friend and fellow-conspirator without making any claim for the admission of his friends to the ministry. Crispi had als«
long interviews with Signor Col lian republican socialist, who first called th attention of the House to the banking scandals and who has now written a really wonderful book entitled * The Banks and the Government He was the most formidable opponent of Crispi during his late cabinet, but, being first of alla patriot, then a Sicilian, accepted the interview and expounded his views on the best measures to secure the pacification of Sicily Sara and Sonnino accepted, the former the depart ment of public works, the latter that of the treasury. It was hoped that Perazzi, Sella’s alter ego, would accept the department of finance, but he did not see his way clear, so Sonnino has that also in the interim. Great difficulty was experienced in finding a minister of foreign affairs, but at last Baron Alberto Blane accepted the offi t Tice, and seems to be yer rally acceptable, even to France. Similardif} culties occurred in securing a fitting maniste of war, and it is in the war budget that all tl difficulties The King deprecates any reduction in the budgets of the army and navy riginate whereas all the real authorities on tinanee maintain that, without this reduction, no real equilibrium between expenditure and incom can be attained. Gen. Ricotti, in a letter t the Opinione, aftirms that eighty millions must be found immediately, and that before burden ing the country with fresh taxes, forty mil lions of economy must be effected in the va rious budgets, commencing with twenty lions in the War and Navy Department \n it is the opinion of this veteran general and ex minister that the war budget might be red from 246 to 232 millions by modifying the or ganization of thearmy. ‘If.” he writes, persist in maintaluing twelve army rps only are economies impossible, but other tifte millions must be found; and an army w army corps thoroughly efficient w stronger than anarmy with twelve army corps which cannot be rendered efticient wit! aforesaid addition to the budget.” Gen. RB aftirms that he felt the irage t the reduction and to effeet the economy fourteen millions, but that Crispi, ring his proposals, did not invite him to minister of war. This letter is mucl mment ed on by the partisans of partial disarmat t whereas the champions of an “Italy pow by land and on sea” approve Crispi f ing as a eague a niste ‘ ourage” to reduce the a be f \ rps The actual minister war. { Stanislao M cenhi, is @ member the Chamber of I ties, and is credited with tl tent f ef fecting ¢ LOM t var t vet wit t ducing the rps Prof. Guido Ba s ha wit ght by the universitv s ents as - ¢ eation. Cris sts Cardu \ went to Rome gave s opinions on t difticult quest s to be resolved He w not in ANY case a t fice unless allowed t rev itionize tire sVstelm t put | str Ml as if eXists v. beg ne w ° tt Oy a t eXisting ul ‘ sit ~ i ~ is i bs ‘ i \ ‘ . ‘ 4 seh . , ‘ ° : e} ( i . : t . ‘ i = Ia t t KR ‘ tia ‘ xt \ } * , ~ ‘ i is } Ves ‘ < WAS s i ‘ a} the i . . - — oe \ t t toa certain ‘ \ t } si? | = ‘ hank rh «i ill —~ NI : - ‘ nat ’ ew ris « eff te ¢ S < ‘ tful that . ‘ : . tet sts LILA t sha ld : vhos wits i xht t sa irakes i t pur- ~sS N gE, U t gained by t a amd sa chance ( s av sufl nt influence to prevent at least the tin f +) House being Vasted lisctussing itters which, at this pe- i i i } perky sifted only i irt sti | refer to the matter s ly to show how involved is the situation mi what irage and skill are needed to ex t it v fr the rocks and shoals and quicksands which inexpert helmsmen hav i wed tl frail bark to drift And when all these difficulties are enumerat ed. the greatest and most urgent remains that is. the pacification of Sicily. Since I wrote last, two fresh rebellions have broken out in the province of Palermo. At Partinico the people protested against the intolerable taxa tion—the | ll tax the tax on beasts of bur ien; the tax on flour. Their remonstrances were unheeded, nay, scoffed at. Then they sur- i the municipality, burned the tax rolls, itt ad ot} er misdemeanors. Fortu nately, the president and other members of isu ceeded in pre t much calumniated fase ing | ionstrating with the enraged populace, reminding them that, inthe municipal council, at least three members were
Page 14
10 The Nation. [Vol. 58, No. 1488 chosen by themselves to protect their interests; and with equal good fortune the troops did not intervene. But at Giardinelli, a little com- mune close to Palermo, a far more serious riot occurred, The people clamored for the aboli- tion of certain taxes; the syndic refused to en- tertain the proposal. The people went in pro- cession, a woman carrying the portrait of King Humbert at its head. Disorders were commit- ted, as at Partinico—tax-rolls and other docu- ments burned. But one carbineer was in the place; he summoned the military, and, how or why no one seems able to explain, without warning, without the three trumpet-blasts which would amount to reading the riot act, shots were fired and eight victims fell—first of all the woman carrying the King’s portrait— while other seven were seriously wounded. The troops retreated to a tower outside the village, not one of them being injured. The lieutenant who was in command affirms that he gave the order not to fire. The post- mortem examination of the bodies proves that different bullets were used. Many of the spec- tators affirm that the first shots were fired from the private house of the syndic. Of course there is an ‘‘inquiry,” but inquiries have been made after all the disorders, and, as Colajanni stated yesterday, ‘‘in eleven months, twenty- five Sicilian citizens have been killed and more than a hundred wounded, while not a single Government agent has been punished.” This is an ugly record for the Giolitti ministry, and Senator Cordova’s letter may pass for its epi- taph: ‘*TIn October I wrote from my unhappy land to the competent authorities, praying that the white cross of Savoy might not se steeped in blood. [received thanks and promises; but what are words worth when not followed up by deeds, when affairs are allowed to take their course down the slope of Mussulman fatality that has no rival in history? Misery, neglect. suffering —these are the three garlands which encircle the brow of the victors of Palermo and of Mi- Jazzo, abandoned to the tender mercies of a communal and provincial oligarchy whose im- pudent peculations are safeguarded by the pro- tectorat- of the clients in high places with the complicity of the prefects ” Yesterday it was Senator Villari, to-day Senator Cordova, who stigmatizes the conduct of the governments and of their agents. Now all the hopes of the Sicilians are centred in ‘*Don Ciccio,” as they familiarly call Crispi. Sidney Sonnino, who is at the Treasury and pro tem. holds the portfolio of finance, was the first exponent of the wants and woes of Sicily in 1876; and quite recently, as private deputy, presented a bill for the adjustment of contracts between proprietors and farmers. But the bill savors too much of the Irish land-bills without touching the absentee proprietors. These must be reached if agriculture and agri- culturists are to be saved from utter ruin. Crispi knows that two and two make four and not five. To save the country, he must restore the people to the land, and the land to the peo- ple; he must deal with a high hand in all ques- tions relating to the land. He must ordain an inspection of the municipal admiuistrations, especially in the matter of dazio consumo. Think of a city like Palermo, where more than half the population are either without any re- gular calling, or who live from hand to mouth, never eating a breakfast till they have earned it, and who yet pay nine millions in taxes on food. Think of the fact that, while articles of luxury have yielded less by half a million than in former years because the administration is, to draw it mild, defective—because smug- ’ gling is rife—fleur has yielded 35,000 lire above the average; flour being taxed at the rate of 8 per cent. besides the Government custom-house tax. Think that, while the sanitary works are suspended for want of funds, 75 000 lire were voted for the theatrical company which comes to divert the wealthy classes, and these alone, as no workingman can afford a ticket for the theatres there. And now comes the municipal crisis at Palermo, precisely on account of the budget—another complication while half the communes in the island are under royal com- missaries. Of course there are not wanting numbers who assert that the resolution of the late crisis by the King was unconstitutional. This is un- true, but it was unusual. The King did ‘choose his own minister,” and stands by his choice ; and if Crispi should assume certain powers which will bring down on him the epi- thets of ‘dictator,’ of ‘‘ Bismarck in minia- ture,” the King must uphold him still, granting him power if needed to dissolve the House and appeal to the country in word and in deed; otherwise Mazzini’s prophecy may be fulfilled, and Crispi may become the last minister of monarchy in Italy. J. W. M. Correspondence. SUUM CUIQUE. To THE EpIToR OF THE NATION : Sir: In your last issue Senator Proctor’s bill for the annexation of Utah to Nevada is men- tioned with praise. The same plan was embo- died in a bill introduced by Mr. Oates of Ala- bama in the House of Representatives very early in the extra session. In your remarks on the vote for extra mile- age, it is not fair to give the discredit of it en- tirely to the Democrats. It was opposed by several prominent members on that side of the House, notably Mr. Sayers of Texas, the pre- sent, and Mr. Holman of Indiana, the former, Chairman of the Committee on Appropria- tions. No opposition appeared from the Re- publican side, that party preferring to let the Democrats fight it out among themselves. What is least creditable, the opponents of the measure were refused the right to go on record by a call of the yeas and nays. Among those who voted against additional mileage in the House were Mr. Wilson of West Virginia aud Mr. Powers of Vermont, among the most distinguished of their respective sides. The vote in the Senate stood 41 to 12, the opposi- tion showing very prominent Democrats such as Mr. Mills as well as Republicans. Yours respectfully, WILLIAM EVERETT. Quincy, Mass., December 31, 1893, ANTI-ROMANIST FOLLY. To THE EpIToR OF THE NATION: Sir: Letters in Nos. 1480 and 1482 of the Nation from Mr. Alexander Milne of Colum- bus, Ohio, suggest the idea that readers who are interested in the growth of the American Protective Association may wish to know the part that organization has been playing in re- cent elections in Chicago. Before the November election for judges of the courts of Cook County, the Association is- sued a circular giving in parallel columns the names of the candidates of the two leading parties, with asterisks, calling attention to certain nominees termed ** Romanists ”* in the foot-note. ‘These circulars seem to have been widely distributed in a quiet manner by the members and friends of the society. A care- ful study of the tabulated vote, however, re- veals the fact that only a few hundred citizens were influenced by this appeal to prejudice, and that no judicial candidate owes his defeat to it—this in spite of the fact that the contest yas close, one Democrat and eight Republicans being elected. The Republican who was de- feated was not opposed by the A. P. A., and the Democrats who were so opposed did not run behind their colleagues to any material extent. The one Republican who was marked for defeat was successful with the rest of bis ticket, with the exception noted. The special election of December 19 for a mayor to succeed the late Carter H. Harrison gave the Association an opportunity to present a clear issue to its sympathizers. It apparently embraced the occasion, for circulars were dis- tributed not only from hand to hand as hereto- fore, but even in some churches on the Sunday before the election. The following is a copy of the card : CANDIDATES TO BE VOTED FOR DEC. 19, 1893. : GEO. B. SwiFt, Protestant. JOHN P. HOPKINS, Romanist. No one could be found who would admit hav- ing authorized this electioneering device, the campaign committees being particularly eager to disavow such action; but with many the A. P. A. received credit for the publication, and that was doubtless the source from which it emanated. The response of the people in electing Mr. Hopkins, a young man of great promise, reassures those who hope for the speedy extinction of the religious issue in American politics. The rancorous nature of the A. P. A.’s oppo- sition is well illustrated by the resolutions cur- rently reported in the Western press to have been adopted by a Denver (Colorado) society upon the occasion of a recreant member ap- pointing a Catholic to office. The resolutions conclude as follows : ‘*Resolved, That a likeness of said traitor, with a copy of these resolutions duly certified, be sent to each and every supreme council, supreme lodge, supreme camp, and grand com- mandery within the jurisdiction of the United States, as well as to each local council within the jurisdiction of the State, with the request that the same be read and that the name of ‘Marion D. Van Horne, traitor and perjurer,’ be proclaimed three times at each of four con- secutive regular meetings of such councils. ‘* Resolved, further, That a photograph or likeness of said traitor be prepared bearing across the breast of said likeness a Roman cross painted thereon, surmounted by the word ‘ Traitor,’ said likeness to be draped in black and hung in our council chamber; be it “Resolved, further, That all communication, socially or otherwise, with said traitor and perjurer by any member of this order do now for ever cease; that in his joys or in his sor- rows, in his hopes or in his disappointments, awake or asleep, in health or in sickness, at his fireside or with his fellow-men, we ask Provi- dence to grant one faint ray of conscience to quicken his Plutonian soui so that he may see himself as others see him; be it ‘*Resolved, further, That when his carcass reposes in the arms of Mother Earth, in what- soever land, au unknown committee, duly ap- pointed, shall perform its last rite in the name of this council by marking the place so all may know: ‘Here lies a traitor. ”—Chicago Re- cord, October 21, 1893. bL. FF, Ss. CHICAGO, December 22, 1893. THINGS CHINESE. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: In your notice of ‘Things Chinese’ on page 475 of your issue of December 21 you na- turally take exception to the use of this plan ewes nea sigarinctiet eae Heneo % di ie: v mentite Pag LS
Page 15
lee a — 4 i $i 4 ;
Jan. 4 1894] The Nation.
Prof Japa of book without Chamberlain, the In justice to the author of the former acknowledgment te author of * Things nese.’ work it should be stated that this apparent discourtesy is probably the fault of the Ame rican publisher; for in the writer's edition, issued by Sampson Low, Marston & Co., the following occurs in the preface: “On the appearance of ‘Things Japanese’ it was suggested to the author that he should prepare a book on similar lines w ith regard to Chinese subjects, and the present volume is the result. His thanks are due to B. H. Cham berlain, Esquire, for the courtesy and kindness which accorded a ready assent to the request that the classification and plan of arrangement used in ‘Things Japanese’ might be copied in ‘Things Chinese’ as far as was compatible with the subject-matter of the latter.” Yours, Cc. A.B BosTon, December 25, 1893. THE UNDERSTATEMENT OF ‘* GUESS.” To THE EpiTor OF THE NATION : Sir: The remarks of ‘ F. H.,” in your last issue, on the Yankee use of the word * to “imply a positive certainty,” have renewed a long-standing wonder that no writer, so far as I know, not even Lowell, has mentioned a possible, and, to my mind, the most natural. explanation of that use. One of the simplest rhetorical devices, and one particularly con genial to sententious and satirical peoples like the ancient Romans and the modern Yankees, is that of understatement. Thus, when a Yankee is asked a question the an swer to which appears to him absurdly obvi- ous, he naturally replies by a sarcastic affecta tion of ignorance. If, loaded down with bun dles and looking utterly dragged out, I am greeted with a cheerful inquiry ‘‘ whether | feel tired,” I answer not with the courteous and reflective ‘‘I think I do,” but with the ironical ‘‘I rather think I do,” or, being a Yankee, ‘* I guess I do.” The case is exactly paralle] with the common use of the conditional mood, in such phrases as ‘‘T should think so!” when what is really implied is a most emphatic indicative. Why should one of these uses be branded as more of a solecism than the other EW: H. guess” ironical DECEMBER 29, 15893. Notes. MAcMILLAN & Co. announce as nearly ready Mrs. J. R. Green’s ‘ Town Life in the 15th Cen- tury,’ and as in preparation ‘The Dawn of Astronomy,’ by J. Norman Lockyer, with nu- merous illustrations. Ginn & Co. will Lessons in Civil Government,’ by Jesse Macy, a work for young children. Henry S. Morais, No. 46 North Fiftl Street, Philadelphia, is about to issue to scribers ‘The Jews of Philadelphia: Thei: History from the Earliest Settlements to the Present Time.’ The Schulte Publishing Co., publish ,in an illustrated imperial octavo \ ume the papers read before the recent Inter national Congress of Anthropology. ‘Heinrich Heine’s Life Told in His Own Words’ is the title which Mr. Arthur has given to his translation, just published by Henry Holt & Co., of Gustav Karpeles’s wel known ‘ Heine’s Autobiographie. As Hei did not himself select the this book is composed, the change issue next month * First ay} sul Chicago, will Dexter material of which
seelus very appropriate indeed To those fa miliar with Heine's writings the book offs little that is new, as it Msists almost ex sively of passaves taken from his collected works, arranged in chronological ordet I those, however, who wish to have put before them in a compact and authentic estimate of himself, nothing could be more us ful than this volume. The translation, at least of the prose part, is of rder of excel lence. As the be hard to recognize a hich « ] } for poetical passages, it would * Die frommen klugen Gaze in ‘The vazelles, in their innocent inning or “Die Kleine, die Feine, die Reine Fin in “My pet, my darling, my dainty, my ow But one ought not to be too harsh with an who dares to translate Heine t might easily be beheved that an educate and travelled Spaniard would have something worth our while to make a note of in book as * Yankees: Viajes por la América del Norte’; but, alas! its author to say such a Costumbres
José little int Sanchez Somoano, brought so lectual baggage, and owns a pair of eves so far little one from achromatic, that his book ts almost For thing he prodigious talent, and that is a laborious mis barren of interest. has a understanding of what he has seen or read One of brilliant achievements of that the origin of philanthropist, his most the Common: * A sort is following account of Boston great named Common, had the happy idea of pre senting the children of Boston with a leafy grove of great trees” p ISG A translation of Arrian’s (Anabasis Alexander’ and * Indica,’ by Edward James Chinnock, M.A., LL.D. (London: Geor He & Sons: New York: Macmillan), has just beer issued in the revised series of Boh It is a serviceable work, executed with car and following the original with sutticient close ness and accuracy. The notes, geographica and historical, furnish the intelligent reader with a guide to the itinerary of Al to the chief maps add to the usefulness of a volume whi sourees of his while not conceived on the seale and of Mr praiseworthy in its Dakvns's ° the work would be greatly increased by a tailed index of n
The eighth book of Thuevdides, bv H. ¢ Goodhart, professor in Edinburgh University Macmillan), is a piece of minute and ca scholarship, especially dwelling on points grammatical construct and inter resuming the labors of pr ling ~ adding some independent studies of the mat script autl tv and the hist " stions connected . with this art t st Among these is an able scuss { t 1 tio I vdides's atiy I ton of ear ' . keke tle’s “At an ( stitut Karl Gje t Danish t . Seve W i . tics a a f a very suggest work ¢ ¢ ¢ XI t ‘ t l iraresa as ~ xt si\ “Ww ‘ iv t s ‘ Nans ’ Sy . | " \\ “ S \ralua seninitin i “ is We is a ‘ i i ’ ? t ‘ irks ~ ‘ ~s ‘ is a \ M W \st { Fives a { i t ia ~ at . x rent ~ i x \ i t hen \ y \ al \ heard \ \ t heavy \ . t l V peosses rime tise . | - ss ane i vil wes 1 ) wl is ted and s of? l \ ‘ lect a rich Werftul man, Out some por peasant feb “ l exp appears to be nearly strand Wa pack ils and porters, i Mr. Chai s npa n, Lieut. von Hoh aving Ix severely wounded by a rhi s. has bee l i to return to the ast i pof tt ber isof the Anglo i tugmuese b ndary n Kast Africa, con s byt I sh sect f the boundary ssion From t accompanving gee ’ al tes appears that a large part of y thr h which the boundary line ses Is tically ninhabited The S i tphical Magazine for De mils tains al interesting address by Lord } rts on India, past and present. The st striking part is that relating to the Mu tiny, of which | ives some personal reminis es, t gh h sheds no new light on its iuses. I si he strongly defends the pre sent Afghan policy, arguing that, under the present umstances, Lord Lawrence, the reat advocate of masterly inactivity,” Would approve done on the ne resting series of what has been and is being An inte show the rthwestern frontier of historical maps
Page 16
growth of the empire from 1760 to 1893. An- other map shows the advance of Russia since 1857. In the geographical notes a strange er- ror for a scientific journal is made in the state- ment that ‘in March last two French scien- tists, MM. Hermite and Besancon, ascended from Vaugirard” to a height of 52,480 feet, where the minimum temperature was —60° F., and remained several hours. The balloon, in fact, contained nothing but some automatical- ly registering instruments. The article of most general interest in the current number of the Annales de Géographie is M. Maistre’s account of his expedition from the Congo to the Niger. He confirms the state- ment of other travellers as to the spread of Mohammedanism in this part of the Sudan and of its elevating effect upon the people. In describing a partial ascent of Ararat, M. Chantre calls attention to the remarkably rapid absorption of the water from the melt- ing snow, and suggests the existence of a vast subterranean reservoir. Only three springs are to be found upon the mountain, and the neighboring plain is uninhabitable in summer from want of water. There are also articles upon the lakes of Jura and on Brittany, to- gether with geographical notes and correspond- ence. A valuable map, with an accompa- nying explanatory text, shows the distribution of animals throughout the world, and a useful map of Africa gives its present political divi- sions. It is interesting to note that the French claim the northwestern shore of Lake Tchad. The recent smallpox epidemic in Norway has attracted increased attention to this dis- ease throughout the North. Of the many discussions of the subject, one of the most inte- resting is a series of papers ina Danish medi- cal journal on the influence of light on the skin, with special reference to its use in the treatment of skin diseases. As long ago as 1300 the English court physician, Gaddes- den (the Gatesden of Chaucer’s Prologue), reported the results of his experience in surrounding the smallpox patient’s bed with red curtains, adding that by following this method he cured the king’s son without leav- ing any marks. For many hundred years this treatment was followed throughout Europe, and as late as the seventeenth century it re- ceived additional confirmation from the great Danish physician and scientist, Thomas Bar- tholin. Later itwas contemptuously put aside by the medical men of a more enlightened age as a foolish error of the past. Its modern re- vival comes from Bergen, Norway, one of whose hospital physicians makes report not dissimilar in its main results to cold Gaddes- den’s of 600 years ago. Among the recent evidences of the progress of Western ideas in the East is the formation of the Bengal Academy. Its chief object is to develop Bengali as a prose literary language by the compilation of an authoritative dic- tionary, which shall define, consolidate, and purify the written dialect. It also aims to se- cure the ‘‘scientific criticism of Bengali style and grammatical structure, the discussicn of Bengali works, and a collection of biographies of Bengali authors.” The first great impulse to vernacular composition in this language was given by the movement for widow remar- riage in 1854. Previous to this time its litera- ture consisted of a few poems and ballads; now, one of its enthusiastic admirers asserts that, ‘“‘apart from ephemeral and worthless productions,” Bengali literature contains about 700 works. ‘‘ Of these, 450 are dramas or works of fiction, 20 are histories, and 50 are philosophi- cal or scientific treatises.” The rules of the a . The Nation. Academy, says a writer in the London Times, ‘‘are conceived in a practical and modest spirit.” And he adds: ‘There is something that must appeal to scholars and men of letters of all nations in this quiet and carefully planned effort to give form and consistency to one of the new literary languages of the world.” Sir William Dawson of McGill College, Mon- treal, has lately published an essay on the Canadian Ice Age, which, as the author ad- mits, may be classed with Howorth’s ‘ Glacial Nightmare.’ It is an ardent presentation of obsolescent views, in which land ice-sheets are restricted far below the extension now gene- rally allowed them, and in which floating ice is held accountable for a great part of the gla- cial deposits in northeastern America, Those who are sceptical about glacial theories will take much comfort in this book, in which the learned author objects to what he calls ‘‘ the rough-and-ready method employed by so many of his juniors.” On the other hand, those who have slowly approached a general understand- ing of the conditions of glaciation by a close examination of the drift deposits of Canada and the northern United States, and who recognize great glacial extension across the in- ternational boundary, as well as a certain amount of marine and lacustrine iceberg ac tion, will here find little to disturb their views. Prof. J. W. Spencer, State Geologist of Georgia, has recently issued a report on the palzeozoic rocks of that State under the head- ing of the ‘Geology of the Ten Counties of Northwestern Georgia’ (Atlanta, 1893). Little work of finished quality has hitherto been done in Georgia; the present volume is much more detailed in its discussion of the structure and resources of the northwestern part of the State than any heretofore issued. It opens with a general geological description of the region, which is followed by local county reports. Then come an account of the economic re- sources, chiefly iron and coal, and a chapter on roads, with the relation of their construction to the supply of stone or brick-making clay. The latter should attract general interest in a re- gion where the roads are so much in need of improvement. With the sections for Hanover, Stuttgart, and Munich the fine publication, Dr. C. Vogel’s Map of the German Empire, is brought to a close (Gotha: Perthes; New York: Wester- mann). The fourteen parts can now be bound up together, and most subscribers will not fail to possess themselves of the index of names, which is issued separately for three marks. The work is a very valuable addition to patri- otic and scholarly resources. The Christmas number of Light and Shade is wholly given up to a commemoration of the Columbian Exposition in photogravures of va- ried tints, from many unusual points of view. The Photographic Times for December 22 contains the only sort of general view of Phila- delphia possible from the nature of its site, viz., froma balloon, It is very effective. —The contents of the Atlantic for January are varied, though by no means of absorbing interest. Mrs. Deland begins a new novel, and Charles Egbert Craddock continues the mo- notoncous course of ‘ His Vanished Star”: there are biographical sketches of Admiral Howe and the late Gen. Armstrong, and ten letters which Coleridge wrote to Southey in his usual vein, just after his own return from Germany. Most worthy of discussion, how- ever, is a single point in Prof. Shaler’s some- what too elaborate article on the transmission of learning through universities, with regard [Vol. 58, No. 1488 to the character of the instruction which should be given in scientific and technical schools, Just what that should be is one of the most im- portant, though least debated, problems which modern educators have, by theory and by ex- periment, yet to solve. The extremely rapid growth of such schools during the few years they have been in existence shows the as- tonishingly large class of young men from which they draw. The greater part of Scrib- ner’s is a rethreshing of old straw. Mr. Craw- ford concludes his excellently illustrated ac- count of Constantinople, Mr. Hamerton writes briefly on Edouard Manet, and Mr. R. C. Winthrop on Webster’s reply to Hayne and the way in which Webster was accustomed to prepare his speeches for delivery and for publication. It is comforting to find at last in a popular article on the Israelites in Egypt the statement that the ‘‘monuments and papyriof Egypt, so far as at present explored, are absolutely silent about the history of the Israelites while in Egypt and about the man- ner in which they left it.” —The collocation of articles in the current number of the Century is happy in the ex- treme. We have Mr. Cole’s engravings of Franz Hals, in continuation of his series on the Dutch masters; some masterly generaliza- tions on the function of the poet, from one of Lowell’s lectures; Mr. Brander Matthews’s ap- preciative but reserved criticism of the work of Andrew Lang; and, to take mere articles of information, a scholarly statement of the light which Assyrian literature and archeology throw on the Bible, and an interesting ac- count of the discovery of chloroform by Sir James Simpson in 1847. In the essay last men- tioned it is worth noticing that poetry was the handmaid of science, for Dr. Simpson was continually spurred on to new and sometimes reckless experiments by remembering Shak- spere’s ‘‘ not poppy nor mandragora, nor all the drowsy syrups of the world” and _ similar Elizabethan references to narcotic drugs. A curious error, by the way, is that of the sonnet on Guittone d’Arezzo, whom the author calls the ‘‘ Columbus of the sonnet,” and represents as gay of song and life—an opivion which no one could form who had ever waded through the platitudinous wastes of this pedantic and garrulous versifier. —The place of honor in Harper's is rightly given to the opening chapters of Du Maurier’s new novel “ Trilby,” which depicts so faithfully and charmingly the studio life of long ago in Paris that it is hard to tell whether the text or the illustrations are more delightful. In addi- tion there are the usual articles of travel. Mr. R. H. Davis concludes his series of descriptions of English life with a somewhat ill-humored criticism of English hospitality, and Mr. Weeks continues the interesting account of his Eastern travels, which would, however, be less confus- ing if they were provided with a map. Besides ‘ Trilby,” the most noteworthy article in the number is Dr. Griffis’s statement of the extra- ordinary influence which the Dutch in the Old World exerted over the future colonists of New England, and the Dutch in America over their northern and eastern neighbors. In the spirit of the late Douglas Campbell, not only much of New England's commercial prosperity, not only that fertile inventiveness which is sup- posed to be a Yankee’s birthright, but much of what little physical or mental ‘‘ sweetness and light’ the poor New Englanders had, is ascribed to the practical, genial, and sensible influence of the Dutch.
Page 17
NR dre atch patisisenclcaceh Goma geae t ' f
Jan. 4, 1894]
—The American Psychological Association held its second meeting on December 27 and 28 at Columbia College. Papers were read on the first day by Prof. Fullerton of Philadel phia, on the ** Psychological Standpoint ”: by Prof. Royce of Harvard, on ‘* The Case of John Bunyan” (an attempt to throw into the cate- gories of modern alienism the mental pertur bations of the period of insistent impulse and incipient illusion of Bunyan's early life); by Mr. H. C. Warren of Princeton, on ** Experi ments on Visual Memory” (showing by in teresting curves the relative reliability of the memory of a large number of male and female students for simple square figures after inter vals of ten, twenty, and forty minutes); by Prof. Murray of Montreal, on the question of the occurrence of dreams; and by Prof. Butler of College, on M1 Fiske’s doctrine of the ‘* Meaning of Infancy Prof. Cattell, Prof. and Dr Scripture gave accounts of the work done dur tastes in Columbia Miinsterberg, ing the past year in the laboratories at Colum bia, Harvard, and Yale respectively. the most interesting item from a practical and Perhaps educational point of view was the description by Prof. Miinsterberg of a new device for pro ducing stereoscopic visual effects from plane figures without any of the usual aids from mir rors or prisms. The effect is secured by throw ing pictures prepared for each eye separately into the eyes in succession separately. By means of a simple rotating apparatus the or dinary zodtropic effects may be added to the stereoscopic effect. This opens up the possi bility of showing by lantern slides animals, machines, etc., not only in lateral motion, but at the same time in relief, and also in motion to and from the plane of vision. This, with other of the Harvard results, of the paper of Prof. Royce on Bunyan, are to be noted in the Psychological Review for January. On the second day papers were read by Dr. Hyslop of Columbia, Mr. Mead of Michigan, Mr. H. R. Marshall of New York city, Dr. Scripture, Prof. Miller of Bryn Mawr, Prof. Pace of the Catholic Uni versity at Washington. Among those who contributed to the Dewey of Michigan, James of Harvard, Strong of Chicago, and Starr of the New York Col The next as Well as part and discussions were Profs. lege of Physicians and Surgeons. session is tobe held during the Christmas r« cess 184-95 at Princeton, with Prof President and Prof. Cattell as Secretary. James as —On the 5th of December the Congregation of the University of Oxford, by a majority of forty, passed a resolution in favor of estab lishing an honor school of English languag and literature. deal of controversy in recent years as well as The subject has excited a good enthusiastic support ; some elections to the Council (which alone can initiate legislation have turned upon it, and the vote of the other day marks a change in public nority has become a substantial majority oOplpioen a nil t 11 broad principle now affirmed is the acceptat I I Modern History, Law, Oriental Languages have previously of English—as cepted—as a proper and adequate means university education and training supporters of the movement have not yet a complished their end. The statute en the resolution has yet to be drafted, :
divergence of opinion is likely to appear as to } the relative proportions of phil logy the proposed sch
rature to be required in It is felt, on the one hand, that a good ar of philology is essential to give needful weight and to save it from being what
The Nation. has been described (in terms suggested by phrase familiar at Harvard) as a ‘soft tion,” dents attractive On the other, it is urged that phi gists are apt to give undue mainiv to the weaker stu subject, to the practical exclusion of all the greatest books and writers in English since the fifteenth century It is to be hoped that a satisfactory compromise may be arrived at, s that what is assuredly a strange omiss mar no longer distigure the list Oxford studies The lively interest still felt in the Sudar is shown by the fact that *Ten Years’ Captivi ty in the Mahdi’s Camp’ (Scribners) has react ed its ‘tenth, abridged, popular edit vear from its first pr i This \ partly to the yvreat int st of the pers il narrative, but mor specially tot that it has a unique historical va in bee t only account which we have, or possibly can ever hope to have, bv a Eure pear vewit ness of the Mahdi'’s rebellion from the begir ning. Father Ohrwalder, a member of t Austrian mission to Kordofan, reached hi
station, about four hundred miles te the soutl west of Khartum, in 1881, just at the out ik of hostilities \ vear later he was carried captive to the Mahdi’s camp, and was present at the siege and fall of El Obeid. After a fiy vears’ slavery in or near this place, he was sent to Omdurman, the Dervish capital ty of some one hundred and fifty thousand in habitants, lving across the Nile from Khart and built largely from its ruins. Here he was allowed some liberty, and earned his own hv me, a ne t e by soap] } vith Lupton Bey ti . tha t ribbon-weavet | 1 f an A ine tw Sur } Italia . } mission, with a sl sca t i seven davs’ rire nh « ls first hLeyptia peas tis . tant In addition to the stor f his own luring these eventful vears, Father Ohrw Rives a ndensed his t Ma ment nterspersed w traits of principa iders \t 5 s vw the Mal I tes 1 v b an, of dark- br lex f vy kept sk he t s ~ Wert Te ta t His ry bs t nt Suda — < the Mos e i s w i have Ww N tra i x : . t ( has » “ t Ma i NV pat } . s also added niar i i i e @astern Suda
res i have revelation of his
t t ‘ at a sof this terest re ! x {te very be EMEBRAN VW s Mi tne l tut e the } I Ss « } it } ! W ay f piat 4! TeX . s Ss s stad +} ( i sles | \ We XN 4 sre ust . t iv as N s +! ‘ ‘ \ v ‘ \ ™“ a" ¢ that ~ \ “As te } ~, a ‘ } x. a iter i \I™ x1 st t . t searcl . t < hifes if ‘ . 1 xs i _ Ww ’ i his ‘ \ } - bd i ‘ ‘ ee 0 l ‘ - a 1 s < ‘Nv . i? ~ “ ~ t t \ ‘ t ‘ , -) Ss, & ity wen s of ‘ ~ t ~ j iw ~ ts ~ v i k is at ‘ ~. as st ‘ s rN f s . sterv. MM cs one of i . R it and his sv al. and, w \ ve | | trans <s ad bw We have not vt i t wi the T = w i i ind ‘ “ i test if is in t . r t ulti ! Mr . t s dis 1 useful We adt . st wha ites he thought t sul ss ss vs t the treer Ss; those w ! s added are really . are most welcom Hardly too an be said praise of the illustrations ire the bellogravures after paintings st admirable woodcuts is te t that supe r authenticity of pho vy wil s made modern criticism ithe reproduct ns of the etehings ariy everything except that w ndertul \ t etched line which nothing can \ special feature of this publica s the number and prominence of the re ns of drawings and sketches, those ate records of the artist's moods, and s, struck off at white heat, which often mind and heart re ftimished productions We sugyest that in preparing these this been as wellto translate the prices, publication in country it
Page 18
14. The Nation. [Vol. 58, No. 1488 which are given in florins, francs, and pounds, but never in dollars, and to lament the absence of a fuller index. There are catalogues of paintings, drawings, and etchings, a_biblio- graphy, and anindex of proper names, and, of course, a table of contents and a list of illus- trations, and the strict chronological order of the text makes reference fairly easy; but all this is not always sufficient. References from the text to the illustration are rare, and from the illustration to the text non-existent, and many of the illustrations are widely separated from the passage in the text that refers to them. As an instance take the ‘“ Rembrandt leaning on a stone sill.” The plate is at page 211 of the second volume. The date of the etching is 1639,which would naturally bring the text referring to it somewhere in the latter part of vol. i. When the illustration was reached, we tried to turn back to the passage in the text for verification, but have not yet been able to find it. A Life of Rembrandt reads much like a Life of Shakspere. Really next to nothing is known about it, and the elaborate investiga- tions undertaken of late years have served more to destroy legends formerly believed than to add much of authentic information. ‘* Possibly” and ‘perhaps’ are the ever-re- curring words, and we are more often told that he may, might, could, would, or should have done or felt this or that than that he really did so. The possibilities, too, have a strange knack of becoming probabilities, andthe probabilities certainties in a few pages, and so lend themselves as bases of deduction for new possibilities, which go through the same trans- formations. Most of M. Michel’s guessing is plausible and seems to have some foundation in the only real record of Rembrandt's life, his work, which is generally dated. The sys- tem is burlesqued in Mr. Bolton’s little book on Saskia, which is an utterly superfluous work. Of Saskia nothing is known at all ex- cept her birth and parentage, the date of her marriage, the dates of the birth of her chil- dren and of her own death, and such an idea of her personal appearance as can be gathered from various portraits more or less plausibly assumed to be hers, and very different from each other in expression and even in feature. How then write a Life of her ? The task is easy. Bring in the Prince of Orange and Sir Philip Sidney, Alexandre Dumas and ‘La Tulipe Noire,” lions, monkeys, and Dr. Tulp; assume that if Rembrandt scratches an etching of a woman in bed, Saskia is failing fast, and then introduce a most robust personage as a por- trait of her a year later, make her a good in- fluence in his life, and tell how, after her death, ‘his hand etched pictures unworthy” of him, in the face of the fact that the worst of the ‘* free” subjects are of the year 1(40—and the thing is done. We shall give one instance in the author’s own words, but with our ital- ics, and have done. On page 2, ‘‘ Rombertus van Ulenburgh, the father of Saskia, in the early autumn of the year 1578 was a student in some foreign university, perhaps at Paris or in England.” On page 3, “he must have en- joyed his walk to the Thames to see the barge of Leicester pass, or to look upon the gray beard and knitted eyebrows of Burleigh, the great minister.” M. Michel is not so bad as this, but even M. Michel works his guesses rather hard. He ob- jects, justly, to the ‘‘ mania for identification” which has given various historic names to Rembrandt's portraits and etchings, but he seems to us not free from the malady himself. Rembrandt's father is His identification of plausible, but he makes Saskias and Hendrick- jes of female figures, nude or costumed, that have slight resemblances to each other, and, once having decided that Rembrandt worked much from members of his household, will have brothers and sisters and servants at every turn. Perhaps the strangest of all is his identification of the so-called Sobiesky with Rembrandt himself, in spite of a discrepancy of ten or fifteen years between the apparent age of the model and the date of the picture. The master played strange tricks with his own features, but we find it hard to believe in this one, especially as the head seems one of the most living and real of his works. The eye and nose are not unlike Rembrandt's at a later date, but the lower part of the face is entirely different in form from that of any of his por- traits. Eliminating the conjectural in Rembrandt’s life, what is left that is important can be briefly enough told. Rembrandt Harmensz, who sometimes called himself Van Ryn, was born in Leyden of a respectable lower- middle-class family on the 15th day of July, 1606-7 or 8—for the date even is uncertain, and there seems about as much documen- tary evidence for one of these years as for the others. ‘‘ No record of Rembrandt's early youth has come down to us,” we are expressly told by M. Michel, but the may-have-beens bravely fill the gap. He was enrolled in the university, but how much he studied there we can only guess. At ‘‘about” the age of fifteen he began the study of art with a bad painter, Jacob van Swanenburch, and ‘ probably” stayed with him three years. In 1624 he went to ‘Amsterdam to study with a painter of greater reputation, the Italianizer Pieter Last- man, but remained in his studio less than six months, when he returned to Leyden, deter- mined ‘‘to study and practise painting alone, in his own fashion.” This was in 1624, and his earliest known works, the ‘‘ St. Paul in Prison” in the Schénborn collection and ‘‘The Money Changer” in the Berlin Gallery, are dated 1627, so that three years are unaccounted for. After this time he soon began to be celebrated, so much so that Gerard Dou became his pupil in 1628 and remained with him until 1631. That Dou was his pupil seems strange until one finds that Rembrandt’s work at this time was much more like Dou’s than like his own later produc- tions. In 1631, when he went to settle definite- ly in Amsterdam, he was already a well-known painter, and was shortly the fashionable por- trait-painter of the day. The next year, when he was not more than twenty-six years old, he painted the ‘*‘ Anatomy Lesson,” which set the ‘ap-sheaf on his glory and made him the most famous of Dutch artists. At this time he met Saskia van Uylenborch, a young woman of a much wealthier and better family than his own, and was welcomed as an aspirant by her relatives, and married her in 1634. In 1639 he bought the house in the Bree- straat that was never paid for, and filled it with the collections that figured in his invento- ry eighteen years later. He was fond of his wife and his work, always busy, the master of many pupils, earning much money, and spend- ing it lavishly on his wife and on his collec- tions. He bought paintings, engravings, and bric-A-brac at extravagant prices, and seems to have been regularly fleeced. by dealers and money-lenders. Titus, the only child of his marriage that lived to maturity, was born in 1641, and Saskia died in June of the next year. In that year also he painted ‘‘The Night Watch,” that puzzling picture which genera tions of critics have fought over, and which Capt. Cocq and his company, for whom it was painted, understood as little as the rest of the world. This was the beginning of the end. Rembrandt was becoming too original to be popular; and as time went on, and his work grew better and better, the public neglected him more and more. He shut himself up in his work, made his servant, Hendrickje Stof- fels, his mistress, and let his finances take care of themselves. The crash came, and in 1657 he was declared a bankrupt, and sold up. From that time his life becomes more and more sor- did and miserable. He had no money of his own, and could have none, and Hendrickje and Titus, in partnership, took charge of all his affairs, and made him an allowance. In 1661 he painted his grand picture of ‘‘ The Syndics,” perhaps the greatest of his masterpieces, but it does not seem to have been admired. It is likely that his eyes were beginning to fail, for his etchings cease altogether from this year, and from 1662 to 1664 there is no work at all from his hand. Hendrickje must have died about'this time, though there is no record of it. Titus married and died, both in 1668, and in 1669 the old man himself followed him, an obscure pauper. He left a daughter by Hen- drickje, who did not live long. In the next generation his posterity seems to have become extinct. But if the known facts of his life may be thus briefly catalogued, it is very different with his work. In this also is he like Shakspere, that commentary and discussion on his art are endless, and that judgments on it have been passed which differ as the North from the South. One extreme is marked by the opinion of a painter of the next generation, Gerard de Lairesse, a contemporary and rival of Van der Werf, which Michel quotes as follows: *‘ In his efforts to attain a mellow manner, Rem- brandt merely achieved an effect of rotten- ness. The vulgar and prosaic aspects of a subject were the only ones he was capable of noting, and, with his red and yellow tones, he set the fatal example of shadows so hot they seem aglow, and colors which seem to lie like liquid mud upon the canvas.” The other ex- treme is marked by the latter-day thick-and- thin admirers of the master, of whom M. Michel is to some extent one, who maintain that he was not only a great poet in light and shade, but a great colorist and a great draughtsman as well, and who lay all the blame of the ugliness of some of his figures upon the models. M. Michel is explicit and reiterative upon this point, and considers poor Saskia and Hendrickje responsible for the bandy legs, sprawling hands, and stumpy bodies of various Susannahs, Bathshebas, and Danaes. He expatiates on the difficulty of se- curing models in virtuous Holland, and ex- plains that Rembrandt had to take what he could get. We must confess that this seems to us wilfully blind and shallow. Many of Rem- brandt’s portraits are as ill-proportioned as his nude studies, while the works of Terburgh and Metzu, his contemporaries, and of Ver Meer of Delft, but little younger, are there to show that there was grace and beauty and refine- ment in Dutch life at the time. When Rem- brandt does show a sense of beauty, his wor- shippers cry aloud and call upon us te admire it; why should they not admit that more often he does not show it? Fromentin’s remark, that Rembrandt saw nothing in life ‘‘ but phy- sical ugliness and moral beauty,” still remains, as does so much else that he has written, the truest word of criticism upon that strange genius. In what else we have to say we pre- tend to do no more than to follow Fromentin’s
Page 19
Jan. 4, 1894]
illuminating critique, condensing it to suit the space at our disposal. According to our teacher, then, Rembrandt was two men in one. On the thoroughly trained Dutch painter of the time, the realist par exce llence, the perfect techni cian, the observer, [homme extérieur. Of this Rembrandt no better example could be cited than that known to all of us, ** The Gilder. Here is no poetry, no idealism, no style, but a one hand was the piece of work so thorough, so wonderful, so truly seen and rendered, that it rightly ranks among the masterpieces of the world. This is the Rembrandt who was the idol of the Dutch public, the man whom the compatriots of Ter- burgh adored. The other Rembrandt was an idealist, a dreamer of strange dreams, a wor- shipper of light. The ‘‘ Supper at Emmaus” in the Louvre, recently recalled to 1 Cole’s engraving inthe Century, and of which Michel The is by gives a fine photogravure, is his work mysterious charm and power of such work as this is indescribable and incommunicable. For once a result seems to have been produced in art without any visible or analyzable means Something supernatural seems before one, and one feels himself in the presence of a being who has really died andrisenagain. Yet in techni cal matters the picture is every way inferior to the portrait of ‘‘The Gilder.” It is not parti cularly well drawn, and it is entirely without color. In its physical appearance the canvas is mean and insignificant—and its handling is timid and almost fumbling. With something to say that had never been said, how should he say it with assurance and in the current lan guage of art ? As long as these two Rembrandts were sepa rate, one was sure to please. But the dreamer insisted on having a hand in works where the observer only was needed, and the result was such an enigmatic picture as ‘*The Night Watch.” It is a splendid failure, and Capt Cocq can hardly be blamed for preferring the accomplished mediocrity of Van der Helst Again the two Rembrandts take up their dif ferent tasks, but the public confidence is shak- en, and public favor is deflected upon m« liable artists who can be trusted not to dream Shut off from public favor and public commissions, the dreamer is strengthen ed and the technician weakened. Strange periments are made, violences are resorted to, re re mal-apropos. ex methods become more and more startling and original. Late in life, once or twice only, the master-painter and the great imaginer coin cide, and pictures like ‘‘ The Syndies ” duced—pictures in which imagination and ob servation work together for the production of the perfect masterpiece; but it is too late, and the technique, perfect as it is, is no longer the Ni one comprehends and no one cares, and the are pro- smooth accomplishment of earlier days great painter drops into his neglected grave A colorist, save once or twice, Rembrandt never was. Neither was he, properly speak ing, a draughtsman. He was never sure of to line of ¥. proportion, and had next no sense Even in his etchings he works, normally, wit! light and shade, and his outline, when he uses it, is never classic or intrinsically beautiful, but only picturesque and suggestive, givin r the sense of light and shade even when these are entirely absent. Of chiaroscuro he is the s preme master. It is almost his only method of expression, and with it he expresses s strange things as were never, befor s expressed in art, and makes us dimly s of the greatest and most profound 7 minds in the world’s history. Like all s minds, he had no artistic posterity, and work
The Nation.
ed almost pure harm to those who were influ. | points of view are suggested lv and enced by him Like Michelangelo, he was the n the seco n ruin of his followers. The language of thes Bes st st w 1) ~A solitary minds is fitted only for the expression | sess as \ wid ‘ Maltke's of their own thoughts, and becomes empty | studi \ , verbiage in the mouths of imitators ey ? “ “ ‘ . In S [Naps t = t ( ‘ Emmy t il it ‘ ‘ » MOLTKE AS A WRITER marck’s advice te A i t Essays, Speeches, and Memoirs of Field-Ma geal acs shal ¢ nt Flelmuth Volthe The essavs i ‘ “ s =v } L* =" y ’ ; , \ translated by Charles Flint MeClumpha, | ! : : . . Ph.D.; the speeches by Major C. Barter, | ya Pp, aka , D.A.A.G.: and the memoirs by Marv Herms t i striking fact that w : 2 vols. Svo, 308, 239 pp. Harper & Bros ar OF thes pow ' . “om trian Pp P ¢ ‘ ders, and pul pinion led astray } speeches and by the press allthese, gen pa i Ss wiiil ary eal tha ‘ I the « it n of wal mien
Page 20
[Vol. 58, No. 1488 16 would lose their moral energy and unlearn the virtue of sacrificing their lives for an idea” was not altogether without foundation (Vol. i., p. 277). This fear seems to have taken stronger hold upon him in his later years, and perbaps his last thought was expressed in the answer which he is said to have made to the address of a Peace Society: ‘‘Gentlemen, universal peace is a dream, and not even a beautiful dream.” All the earlier essays are characterized by a directness of diction and a transparent simpli- city of style which correspond to the inner- most nature of the man himself. Figures are rarely used, but in a paper on the Eastern Question we find a very striking one: ‘ The division of Turkey will be like the division of a diamond ring ; the question is, who is to pos- sess the most precious of solitaires, Constanti- nople” (Vol. i., p. 278). But in the essays Moltke had aot yet achieved that terseness for which he afterwards became famous, and which is so marked in his parliamentary speeches. Some of these consist of a simple sentence of two or three lines. The two long- est might each have been delivered in twenty minutes. Their relative length is explained by the fact that he was speaking on important bills, that he was arguing against a probable adverse majority, and that he had many inde- pendent points to make. But, in spite of the brevity of these speeches, Moltke’s meaning is always unmistakable, aud his arguments are so fully developed that we feel, in reading, that the addition of more words would only weaken them. Scarcely less remarkable is the infrequency of his speeches. Moltke sat for twenty-four years in the Reichstag and for nineteen years in the upper house of the Prussian Diet. He spoke but forty-one times in the former body and but three times in the latter. He never spoke simply because of his interest in the sub- ject under debate; he certainly never spoke to win applause. He spoke only when it seemed necessary. Among his papers were found two different drafts of a speech which was prepared for the Customs Parliament in 1868. It was— or would have been—an admirable speech. It was never delivered; apparently because he was convinced that the motion which he in- tended to oppose would be defeated (as, in fact, it was) without any speech from him. If it be added that none of his speeches shows the slightest tinge of personal or party feeling; that he always assumed (without saying it, of course) that his hearers were open-minded and fair; that his effort was solely to make them see things which they had seemingly overlooked or to remove from their minds misconceptions due to error—we cannot wonder that his rare speeches were received by a house almost breathlessly silent, and that he was judged to be the most effective orator (in the literal sense of the word) in the German Parliament. The speeches, with introduction and notes, occupy the first half of the second volume. The second half is chiefly made up of reminiscences of Moltke, furnished by relatives, friends, and colleagues. These are of very unequal value: they range from collections of nearly pointless anecdotes to really important contributions to a memoir of Moltke and to the history of his time. To the latter class belongs the following episode, narrated by Count Bethusy-Huc: “Tn the spring of 1867 we sat in the Consti tuent Reichstag; the Luxemburg affair had come up again, and Bennigsen’s motion was on the order of the day for the next day but one. . Gen. von Moltke, in a conversation with me in [one of] the ante-rooms .. . spoke as follows: ‘After a war such as we The Nation. have just-had, no one can really feel adesire to have another, and no one can be farther from cherishing such a desire than Iam. And yet I cannot but wish that the occasion given for a war with France were taken advantage of. Unhappily I regard this war as absolutely un- avoidable within the next five years, and within this period the now indisputable supe- riority of our organization and weapons will be equalled by France. . . . The sooner, therefore, we come to blows the better. The present occasion is good. It has a national character, and ought therefore to be taken advantage of.’” After a consultation with his political friends, Bethusy-Hue reported Moltke’s words to Bismarck. ‘‘Count Bismarck recognized the justice of Moltke’s remarks, both from the political and military point of view, but declared that he could never bear the responsibility of bringing the misery of a war upon his country unless [it was] necessary (as in the case of the Austri- an war), in defence of its vital interests and its honor. The personal conviction of a ruler or statesman, however well founded, that war would eventually break out, could not justify its promotion. Unforeseen events might alter the situation and avert what seemed inevita- ble. ‘* When I told the General this, next day, he answered: ‘ Bismarck’s standpoint is unassaila- ble, but it will cost us many human lives one day.” (Vol. ii., pp. 204, 205.) The translators of these volumes have done their work faithfully, but with different de- grees of success. The rendering of the speeches is excellent; that of the reminiscences (‘‘me- moirs” gives a false impression) is good; but the English of the essays is often deplorable. William Jay and the Constitutional Move- ment for the Abolition of Slavery. By Bayard Tuckerman. With a preface by John Jay. Dodd, Mead & Co. 1893. A stupy of Judge Jay in a single phase of his career was well worth making. Something more than this, though less than a full life, is to be found in Mr. Tuckerman’s narrative and Mr. John Jay’s summary; but in the main we have to do with the relations of the subject of this memoir to the abolition societies and the political anti-slavery parties. Great stress is laid upon his insistence on the incompetency of Congress under the Constitution to abolish slavery in the States, and no doubt his con- cern on this point led to the explicit acknow- ledgment embodied in the constitution of the American Anti-Slavery Society at Philadel- phia in 1833. In the practice and aims, how- ever, of those who formed that Society, there was nothing to make them hesitate to adopt Judge Jay’s view. They had confined their political efforts, as he had done, to the aboli- tion of slavery in the District of Columbia and other United States territory, and to prevent- ing the further extension of slavery. A year before, Garrison had denounced the Constitu- tion for the immunity it gave to slavery in the States, and afterwards held himself and in- duced his followers to hold themselves dis- franchised because unable to take oath to sup- port such a constitution. Still, Judge Jay un- doubtedly did good service by helping to make the lawfulness of the society’s methods plain and unmistakable; and when it was attempted, in 1838, by a new adherent, Alvan Stewart, to revoke the article in question, he saved the day, to Garrison’s satisfaction among others. Judge Jay had scruples about the expediency of a national anti-slavery society, but, once founded, he lent it the great weight of his name and high character, and became the president of the auxiliary New York State Society. He manifested the conservatism of his profession by discountenancing appeals to the courts, as against the pro-slavery violations of the mail in New York, Charleston and at the South generally; and by deprecating the practice of passing ‘‘resolutions’’ which the shifting as- pects and incidents of the agitation forced upon the various abolition bodies. One such casual resolution, which did no more than recommend testing the constitutionality of slavery by peti- tion to Congress or in the Supreme Court, he curiously considered equivalent to asking Con- gress ‘‘ to commit perjury” and to interfere with slavery in the States. So strong a feeling that the Constitution opened no way for gene- ral emancipation tended to keep Judge Jay at one with the Garrisonian wing of the abolition- ists, who resisted the proposal ‘‘to change,” in Jay’s language, ‘the anti-slavery enterprise from a religious into a political one.” ‘I doubt,” he said in July, 1840, ‘‘the practica- bility of forming sucha party; and I moreover question whether sucha party would be con- sistent with our obligation as citizens.” He objected to the singleness of its aim, in neglect of questions of ‘‘trade, the finances, internal improvements, foreign affairs, or the military power of the nation”; and he advanced many other valid considerations against it. On the other hand, his conservatism was shocked by the free expression of opinion on subjects not directly associated with the anti- slavery cause by its chief promoter, and espe- cially by the stand taken for the equal share of women in the labors and direction of the cause. Hence he joined the seceders in 1840, and be- came one of the managers of the really person- al organization of Mr. Lewis Tappan calling it- self the American and Foreign Anti-Slavery Society. To this he fondly looked “as a refuge for such abolitionists as had been expelled from the [American A. 8.] Society by the faithlessness of those who had converted it into an instrument for spreading other than anti- slavery doctrines.” The new society, by its con- stitution, stood pledged ‘‘carefully to abstain from all the machinery of party political ar- rangements in effecting [its] objects,” but the very next year this pledge was almost unani- mously stricken out in favor of ‘‘the maxim now promulgated in certain quarters, that the friends of immediate emancipation should labor to secure for themselves all the loaves and fishes in the gift of the republic—the power and emoluments of every office.” Meantime, Alvan Stewart had, more than al- most any other man, drawn the ‘‘new organi- zation” abolitionists into the Liberty party, and Judge Jay found himself voting for Bir- ney in 1844. The second refuge proved no safer than the first, for, in 1845, he wrote to Henry B. Stanton complaining ‘‘of the strenu- ous efforts now making to change its charac- ter, and to convert it from an anti-slavery party into one for matters and things in gene- ral,” beginning with Stewart's old heresy ‘that the Federal Government has the constitutional power to abolish slavery in the States,” and ending with the later heresy ‘‘that women should exercise the right of suffrage and be eligible to office.’ In 1846 Jay wrote: “I shall leave the Liberty party whenever it makes abolition a pack-horse to carry favorite measures unconnected with sla- very, whether those measures are of Whig or Democratic origin.” The party was, how- ever, already moribund if not dead, and Jay’s standing for Senator in its name in 1845 ap- pears to have been his last identification with any party, though he did not abate his con- sistent anti-slavery endeavor. Weshould have been glad of some light on his attitude towards
Page 21
ee ee Jan. 4, 1894] the doctrine imposed upon Free-Soilers and Re- publicans by the logic of the disunion aboli- tionists, viz., that the Constitution was an anti-slavery instrument; but in lieu of that we have his very courteous letter (in marked con trast to that of prominent Republican politi- cians) to T. W. Higginson and his fellow-dis unionists of 1857. After pronouncing the Union a curse to the people of the slave and the free States alike, as well as to the unhappy bondmen whose chains it riveted, he said : ‘“While I believe you are doomed to disap- pointment, I nevertheless rejoice in every ex- posure of the demoralizing influence of the Union. When the people of the North cease to idolize the Union, they will cease to offer on its altar their rights and their duties. ; When all this happens the North will continue its Union with the South, and you yourselves will have no wish to see that Union severed” Judge Jay retained, throughout, his connec- tion with the Episcopal Church, whose unfaith- fulness to the slave’s cause he knew and persist- ently combated—in some minor issues with suc- cess. Noabolition utterances on the awful short- comings of the ecclesiastical bodies of the land exceeded some here cited from his pen, which may be summed up in two: ‘The church of the living God”—he means the self-styled church—“ is the great buttress of slavery and caste in the United States” (the bulwark, in Birney’s phraseology); ‘‘ Our pro-slavery cler- gy, our negro-hating clergy, our slave-catching clergy are the most successful apostles of infi- delity in the country.” It was in accordance with Jay’s sweet temper that while he could not imitate those (the so-called ‘‘ come-outers”) who refused to sit under such a clergy, and while he deplored the spiritual dangers of their course, he never indulged in abuse of them. This blameless and most estimable man de- served the larger work contemplated by his son, whose ill-health vetoed the undertaking. What we get from Mr. Tuckerman lacks the accuracy and the grasp which we should exact of a veteran of the anti-slavery days. So far as Jay is allowed to speak in his own words, the book is a substantial addition to the sources of anti-slavery history; how much more so might it have been made if the store of MS. material implied on pp. 158-159 as available had been printed even without link or comment. A Colony of Mercy ; or, Social Christianity at Work. By Julie Sutter. Dodd, Mead & Co. 1898. MANY persons, we fear, will be repelled from this book by the almost hysterical key in which it is pitched. A large part of it is taken up with ecstatic exclamations and pious rhapso- dies, and, after the subject has been properly completed, a wild screed is added upon the agrarian question in Great Britain. But if we omit this digression upon a topic with which the writer 1s wholly incompetent to deal, and skip some of the sincere but inept religious ef- fusions, we shall find matter which is well de serving of attention. In fact, as the beautiful story of the results attained by wise and de- voted benevolence is revealed, we are moved to look upon the writer's lack of restraint with forgiving eyes; and although we could wish the facts presented in more systematic man- ner, we are glad to have them upon any terms. The ‘Colony of Mercy,” or Bethel, is in the immediate vicinity of Bielefeld in Westphalia, lying at the foot of the Sparrenburg, a strong hold of the counts of Lippe in former years From the hill upon which the castle is ptaced, views are obtained over the ranges of the Teu- The Nation. toburger forest and the Weser mountains, the intervening country being the principality of Lippe-Detmold. Here in 1867 an institution for epileptics was founded by private benevo lence, which has not only greatly increased but has gradually developed at its side a house for the training of deaconesses, from which 600 nurses have been sent out, a similar house for the training of deacons or brothers, a labor colony, and a workman’s-home association. A farm-house was first acquired and four epilep tic sufferers were provided with a home; but the work grew at once, and, under Pastor Bodelschwingh, who was called in 1872, it has assumed its present dimensions. There are now more than one hundred houses in which the epileptic sufferers are grouped in families, and the different enterprises now occupy one hundred and fifty houses in all necessary to say that useful work, physical or mental, is provided for all who are able to do it, and the trades of the carpenter, the mason, the tailor, the printer, the bookbinder, the basket-maker, the baker, ete., prosecuted, An immense labor has been under It is hardly are actively taken in reclaiming a barren waste in the neighborhood—a sandy surface underlaid at the depth of three or four feet with an imper vious stratum which requires to be broken up before vegetation can flourish. To a re markable extent this colony of epileptics has been self-supporting, but there has never been any lack of revenue from charitable offerings. Its success has led to the establishment of many similar institutions in Germany, and its me thods deserve the study of all to whom the condition of a peculiarly helpless class appeals It is impossible to do justice, in our space, to the spiritual influences that have made this colony what it is. Even more than the insane the epileptic are repulsive and helpless. Their seizures are so distressing that merey to them selves as well as to others requires them to live apart, and the hope of recovery is in most cases so smal] as to make it seem almost cruel to endeavor to protract lives of increasing suf fering. Without love and sympathy no one can undertake the care of such sufferers, and love andsympathy are not to be had for wages As we understand Miss Sutter, all service in this cause is without pay. Teachers, managers, nurses, patients, all live together as a great family, all receiving food, clothing, shelter, and provision for true wants, but none recely ing pecuniary compensation, and none giving it except those who are able. incessant manifestations of disease and the In spite of the constant deaths, if we may trust this account, an atmosphere of cheerfulness, even of happi hess, prevails, music is constantly heard, and an unquestioning faith in the merey of God causes death to be regarded less as the natural end of their suffering lives than as the begin- ning of a more blessed state. Altogether Miss Sutter’s picture is affecting in the extreme, and few can read of such cheerful self sacrifice | as has been displaved here, and its beneficent results, without being strengthened in all kind- ly feeling. We can barely hint at the extraordinary variety of col ral enterprises that have grown out of this home for epileptics. Among them are a retreat for the mildly insane and others for the incurable, a hospital for con- sumptive infants. a home for idiots, a refuge for fallen women, an orphan asylum, a re formatory for drunkards and others literally too numerous to mention. But the ** Labor Colony ~ and its complements, the relief-sta- tion and the wayfarer’s home, deserve special mention on account of the distress now pre vailing among the poor of our oWn country Somewhat more than a dozen years ago (ik many was suffering from a collapse of bus ness, and the country swarmed with tramps They were always fed and clad by Pastor von Bodelschwingh, but the results of this imdis criminate charity were so pernicious that he determined to take radical measures for treat ing the evil. He obtained a grant of funds from the province and founded an industria colony, devoted principally to the reclama tion of the barren waste already referred Thenceforth applicants for relief received it as Wages, not as alms. The policy was not t give a breakfast for an hour's work, but t novate the tramp externally, and, so far as possible, internally, by making him work 1 til he had earned what he had received t} * colonist,” im fact, is made to si a ‘ te work for his board, although after a ten cents a dav is allowed him as a gratuity But this is the limit, except for piece work and even these modest savings are paid ove such a way asnot to be squandersd The a is not to provide permanent to prevent men out of work from being dris by despair to begary and crime, and ¢t them in the wav of getting remunerative ployment. In spite of the fact that th lon is not self supporting, the saving from diminution of vagrancv more than outweighs the apparent loss, Labor-colonies upon this model now number some twenty-five in Get many, and their effectiveness is greatly creased by the fact that they are direct chiefly by private persons; and it ts als creased by cooperation. In this wav the a: tecedents of nearly every appheant for relief are investigated, and provision is made that his future movements shall be recorded. This is partly done through the relief-stations, of which we condense Miss Sutter's account Along the great high roads, she writes north, south, east, and west—there are Netu /-Verpflegungs-Stationen, at a distance from one another of half a day's march. The man in search of work, having obtained a kind of passport which is regularly risr, ’ perhaps from a labor-colony, and reaches his station at mid-day. There he gets a dinner, works all the afternoon. generally at wood cutting, has his supper and a bed. and in the morning—unless it is Sundav—after getting breakfast resumes his travels. His destina tion being fixed, he may not deviate from the course prescribed in his ticket without forfeit ing his claim to entertainment. These sta tions are employment-agencies, and if a man reaches the end of his course without finding work, he may be committed as a vagrant, or, if deserving. receive another certificate and re sume his search. These relief-stations are maintained by law, and although it is scarcely ten vears since the first was established, they number 2,000, and shelter on the average about 8.000 tramps every night. A grade above them are the Herbergen zur Heimath, or wayfarers’ homes, where, for a trifling sum, any decent artisan is accommodated while wandering in search of employment. There are some 400 of these sustained by private benevolence, with accommodations for 13,000 guests, and they are said to be always full We state these details not because this book contains the most accurate account of the Ger man system of poor relief, but because many will read a book of this kind who will not look at official publications, and there is enough here to suggest solutions for our own prob lems. It may be laid down as an axiom that our people are too kind-hearted to refuse to
Page 22
SITE A 18 feed tramps and give to beggars, unless it is demonstrable that proper relief for urgent wants is regularly provided. Their theories may be economically sound, but when they fear that a fellow-creature may starve or freeze to death if turned away, they are un- willing to take any chances. They would rather that ninety-nine guilty tramps should be fed than that one innocent one should go hungry. But the relief of tramps by private persons is not only an expensive but a danger- ous exercise of charity. It directly increases vagrancy, and it results in an increase of crimes, frequently of the most revolting cha- racter. The losses suffered through incendiary fires have been so severe that many farmers do not dare to refuse a beggar for fear of having their buildings burned. The injury to railroad property through these vagabonds is enor- mous. Scareely an accident occurs’ to a freight-train which does not kill some tramps who were ‘stealing a ride,” and their other stealings are in the aggregate very large. Better regulation of this evil is a crying want of our country, and the German system seems to cover the ground. It is as impossible as it would be unjust to prevent men out of work from going forth to search for it; but it is neither unjust nor impossible to require those who need help to be identified and to submit to regulation. When this is done, and the money now spent in maintaining vagabonds is systematically applied, we can enforce prohi- bitions of begging. The evil will then be re- duced to manageable dimensions. An Old Master, and Other Political Essays. By Woodrow Wilson, Professor of Jurispru- dence in Princeton University. Charles Scribner’s Sons. 1893. Pror. WoopROW WILSON gives us, in a small volume, five essays, four of which have al- ready appeared in the pages of the Atlantic and New Princeton Review. The first of these lends its name to the volume, ‘An Old Master,’ and the Old Master is Adam Smith. This es- say is a most appreciative and agreeable study of a great, brave, modest man, whose simpli- city and unassuming reticence in his daily in- tercourse with his fellow-men seem strangely at variance with his boldness—his almost audacity—of conception and design whenever he took his pen in his hand. At this day, when Adam Smith is little more than a name, though still a respected and renowned name, this sketch is most acceptable. On other subjects, ‘‘ The Study of Politics,” ‘* Political Sovereignty,” ‘‘ Character of De- mocracy in the United States,” ‘‘ Government under the Constitution,” Prof. Wilson writes with a facile pen—a too facile pen, many peo- ple may think, for there are subjects that de- mand a cautious pen which will record only guarded utterances. Prof. Wilson talks with his pen: it runs in a clear, fluent, unhesitating manner, and it throws off unguarded expres- sions as if they came in the warmth of ani- mated conversation. It is an easy thing for him to write that ‘the English have transform- ed their Crown into a Ministry,” and ‘ have kept a strong executive without abating either the power or the independence of the repre- sentative chamber,” while we, ‘‘ being under the spell of the Constitution, have been un- able to see the facts which written documents can neither establish nor change”; or that “the old, blunt, antagonistic veto is no longer needed * in England, yet ‘‘ is needed here, however, to preserve the Presidency from the insignificance of merely administrative func- The Nation. tions”; that the veto is ‘‘ neither revisory nor ” corrective”; that it ‘‘ is merely obstructive,” ‘‘a simple blunt negation.” But such seed, planted in the minds of many who will accept his conclusions as superior to their own know- ledge, may bear very undesirable fruit. Prof. Wilson knows, though many of his readers do not know, that the veto of the Crown has been obsolete for more than two centuries, and that there is no power that can revise or disapprove an actof Parliament. Yet he says: ‘“*In England the veto of the Crown has not passed out of use, as is commonly said. It has simply changed its form. It does not exist as an imperative, obstructive ‘No’ uttered by the sovereign. It has passed over into the pri- vilege of the ministers to throw their party weight, reinferced by their power to dissolve Parliament, against measures of which they disapprove. It isa much-tempered instrument, pore that reason all the more flexible and useful.” Now, ‘‘the privilege of the ministers to throw their party weight ’—whatever that may mean —‘‘reinforced by their power to dissolve Par- liament, against measures of which they disap- prove,” has not one element of the veto power. That the Opposition can frame a political mea- sure and carry it through Parliament against the will of the existing Government is an im- possibility. There never was a case where a ministry dissolved Parliament to prevent the passage of a bill of which they disapproved. The veto power is a supervision of legislative action lodged in some one who is outside of the law-making or (if it be preferred) the bill-mak- ing machinery of government; and a disap- proval by the President is not ‘‘a simple, blunt negation,” ‘‘ merely obstructive,” for the very plain reasons that the President is required to set forth his objections for the consideration of Congress, and if those objections are not deemed well taken, Congress can immediately pass the bill over the veto, the only restriction being that there must be a decisive majority in favor of the measure. A prime minister, on the contrary, is neither a President nor a King, but a person who is an integral part of the legislative machinery, and who has undertaken to carry on the government agreeably to the will of Parliament. When he fails to do so, the bargain is at an end, and out he goes. Such were the agreed terms of his employment. Oc- casionally he may say to Parliament, ‘‘ You employed me to carry through this and that measure, or to manage the government on such and such lines of policy, and I have done so and am willing to continue to do so—it is not I, but you who have broken the compact; I appeal to the country ”; and then, as the repre- sentative of the sovereign, he dissolves Parlia- ment and orders a general election. This “flexible and useful” veto power of an English ministry, which appears so superior to our own in the eyes of persons who are not ‘Sunder the spell of the Constitution,” then amounts to this: If the legislative power is not of the premier’s way of thinking, he can influence and bully and intimidate members by threatening them with the pains and penal- ties of a new election; if, notwithstanding his threats, a sufficient number stand firmly by their convictions and refuse to pass one of his measures of which they disapprove, he can smash the existing government, legislative and executive, and plunge the country into the turmoil of one of our Presidential elections. That any intelligent person, American or Eng- lish, can characterize such a quasi revolution, constitutional though it be, which may be pre- cipitated on a country at any moment and by [Vol 58, No. 1488 the will of one man, as ‘‘flexible and useful,” and that he can regard it as superior to the quiet and orderly proceeding of the American veto, would be inconceivable if it were not in print. Such comments on constitutional systems will not affect the judgment of any man who has given the matter thoughtful attention, but they form most unfortunate seed to be sown in the minds of young American citizens. The Diary of Col. Peter Hawker. With an introduction by Sir Ralph Payne-Gallwey, Bart. In two volumes with illustrations. Longmans, Green & Co. Cot. PETER HAWKER was one of the most noted sportsmen and brilliant shots of his time. Moreover, he possessed the faculty of im- parting a rare interest to all that he wrote, not only concerning the sports of the field, but in relation to his personal experiences in a wider sphere of action. Unlike most Englishmen of his epoch, he did not indulge in fox-hunting. He confined himself exclusively to the pursuit of upland game and of wild-fowl. Col. Haw- ker was a soldier who had served under Wel- lington. A wound in the thigh incapacitating him for active service, he devoted most of his leisure to fishing and shooting. He was a man of large wealth and the owner of a beautiful and extensive property. Thus equipped, and endowed with an inventive and ingenious mind, a tireless patience and perseverance, and a gluttony for slaughter, he attained to that apogee of some Englishmen’s ambition of being the foremost gunner of his time. In his forays against the wild life of the fields and waters, he proceeded upon military principles. He made careful maps of the ter- ritory over which he proposed to shoot. To his retainers, of whom he employed many, and to his brother gunners, he assigned positions care- fully indicated upon his charts. All prepared, with markers in the tallest trees and his beat- ers in advance and on his flanks, he swept the country in his front. A dead shot and a re- morseless one, nothing escaped him. On one occasion he determined tu ravage the land of a certain Parson Bond. This theologian, having got wind of the proposed attack, carefully planted his territory with traps for the dis- comfiture of man and dog. The Colonel, however, was not to be caught napping. He made a personal reconnoissance, and, having ascertained the sites of all of the machines, marked them upon a map of the property which he had already constructed. A facsimile of this chart is reproduced in the first volume of his diary. Thus fortified, with his beaters, markers, and dogs he descended upon the par- son and cleared the Jand of its game. Colonel Hawker’s account of his subsequent contro- versy with this gentleman, who from a conve- nient perch had witnessed the triumphant march of the gunners, is most amusing. Those portions of Col. Hawker’s diary which relate to the sports of the field are by no means the most interesting. They are somewhat pro- lix and monotonous, and too much space is given to technical details and statistical notes. Where he is the more entertaining is in his ac- count of travels at home and abroad. He hasa keen sense of humor and a blunt, vigorous style of narrative which imparts a most delightful piquancy to all that he relates. His relations of a visit to Scotland and one to France imme- diately following the fall of Napoleon have, within their limitations, rarely been excelled. On his way to Scotland he halted at Gretna Green, where he had an interview with Joe Parsley, the blacksmith (so called) who united lle si Pe § ie sad wie satcalle Tie tiie. bn since thie B See
Page 23
ee ees } si steal at ALY 0 et eae AES oD Sass, ° ie Bieide tts, RoPan stews: Jan. 4, 1894] The Nation. eloping couples. This practitioner on occasions received fees of from $200 to $500 for tying the knot. He was, however, an intolerable drunk- ard, and had no sooner received his pay than he hastened to the grog-shop, where he remain- ed until every penny was expended, Joe Pars- ley was not a blacksmith, as is commonly sup- posed, but a tobacconist. On his visit to France, Col. Hawker was ac- companied by Mrs. Hawker. Upon landing at Cherbourg they were met by the hospitable in- habitants with a volley of paving-stones; al- though they managed to escape the fury of the mob, the captain of the boat was seriously in- jured. This experience at Cherbourg was du- plicated at many other points in France. The journey was a continual battle with sullen foes and wrangles with hotel-keepers, postil- lions, and officers of The Colonel's narrative is a most vivid picture of the demo- ralized condition of the French at the time. The egotism of Col. Hawker is on occasion very much in evidence; but this is lost sight of by the reader in the admiration which his ab- solute contempt for danger under any condi- tions inspires. His savage greed for killing game is lamentable, but this was before the uaysS Woen ally >eot ot wes made against the wanton slaughter of the wild life of the woods and waters. Apart from this, Col. Hawker was a man of much refinement. He was amu sician of no little ability, and published a book of ‘Instruction for the Best Position on the Piano-forte.’ He also author of ‘The Journal of a Regimental Officer during the Recent Campaign in Portugal and Spain’ (1810). Moreover, he the inventor of several devices of value. His great popularity was owing to his ‘Book of Instructions to Young Sportsmen.’ It passed through twelve editions, and was for fifty years the recognized manual on guns and shooting, especially in that relating to wild-fowl. justice. was was Sunny Manitoba. By Alfred O. Legge. Lon- don: T. Fisher Unwin. 1893. Mr. LEGGE states that his justification for writing this book is his desire to remove some of the prevailing misconceptions and convey accurate information about a muchcalumniated province of the British Empire. His endeavor to reéstablish Manitoba in the affections of English emigrants is based on the following fa- vorable considerations. He believes—-and there is good authority for this belief—that the yield of wheat increases as the northern limit is ap- proached within which it can be grown at all; ud he claims that Manitoba wheat excels in quality as well as in yield per acre. He praises the system of experimental farms conducted by the Government, which have been eminent- ly successful in testing the merits and adapta- bility of different seeds and fertilizers, and have thereby greatly assisted the farmers. He quotes various cases which have come under his observation showing the remarkable results of a few years’ farming by emigrants starting with little or no capital. And, finally, he says all that it is possible to say in favor of the cli- mate. Having exhausted his brief on this side of the case, he then proceeds to give some idea of the other side. He admits that the tempera ture runs to very high figures in the summer | and very low ones in the winter, with a mean temperature for the year of about 82°, which seems to harmonize but coldly with the title of his book. He further confesses to a very de ficient water supply, which renders a large part of southwestern Manitoba unfit for settle ment, and is more or less felt in other sections His remedy for this is an extensive system of forestry, to be carried on both by the Govern ment and by individuals, with a view to in creasing the rainfall best, results cannot be expected for many years His general conclusion is, that those who see their way to a tolerable livelihood in England had better not emigrate to Manitoba ‘** because of the sacrifices involved.” a plan from which, at rather a lame and impotent conclusion, and will our “much border. hardly be received with enthusiasm by calumniated” friends across the In the present condition of agricul- tural and other pursuits open to young men in England, it is probably more difficult: than before to make a tolerable and it may be safely assumed that Englishmen will continue Atlantic, they settle permanently in’ whether they follow a common Canadian cus- ever livelihood, to cross the whether tom—very annoying to Mr. Legge’s patriotic feelings—and drift over the border into the Dakotas. This is | Manitoba, or | ' Mr. Legge has something to say about mis- sionaries, and he finds that they meet with the same difficulties among the Canadian Indians as in other parts of the world. The Indian argument against Christianity has a familiar sort of sound: “If your Bible is true, why are the white men worse than the they who have taught us our worst vices.” Indians’ It is The book has a number of excellent illus lib It is fairly well written, although trations and a map of the province on a ral scale. Mr. Legge is fond of unusual words and pecu liar spelling. A startling instance of the latter ‘* whose ambition ser is the man es above the log shanty “i An Unknown Heroine: An Historical Episode of the War Between the States. By L. FE Chittenden. Richmond, Croscup & Co IN comparison with the numerous imyx biographies, weightier rtant and still documents that grown out of the war, Mr. Chittenden’s latest volume has a modest but yet significant part to play. recollections, personal historical have As it deals almost entirely with pri vate history, it is happily removed from the field of party controversy, and as it is the ad miring and appreciative testimony of a former Union soldier to the bravery and humanity of a Southern woman, it displays a spirit of dispas sionate generosity which carries the reader's feelings along with it Clearer circumstantial evidence, indeed, to the inherent soundness of the ‘‘human heart by whatever political creed it happens to have which we live.” under been nourished, it would not be easy to find be tween the covers of a book. Into the details of Mrs. Metre’s sturdy her rescue from death of a wounded near Harper's Ferry, it is Van ism in her and abandon ed Union officer, needless to go: the accor of the Vermont officer's steadfast gratitude. and of his assist ance to Mrs. Van Metre in finding her Confede- rate husband in a Northern prison, may also be left to the reader's curiosity. The letter to Mrs. Van Metre from Gen. Hitchcock, inform- ing her of Secretary Stanton’s « for her life of an enemy, rder of release husband, in return for the preserved ffers, as here quoted, one of and then to be to prove for the nonce justice is not a fiction of the imagi nation, but a homely dweller among the stern realities of life The ; those pleasant incidents met with now which seem that poetic The value of a book of this kind is quite inde pendent of questions of literary form or finis! 19) Its use is to give permanence and notoriety to an episode similar to many that must survive inthe memories of persons still living on the borderlan } with the legre 1 of f which North is unfs and South, the know tunately passing lives of those who witnessed them r such a record does appear, it: is sirable that it should be disseminate! larters Where sectional feeling is still . or wherever there are individuals t with unreconstructed opinions upon the subject of the war. Carefully read, it may in a quiet and unobtrusive wav, do much ¢ wards making felt the oneness of our nationa life, and can hardly fail in helping to neutradire the efforts of the sham patriotism which seeks to make political capital lragging f ‘ issues of a dead and bu fe tility f ee ate i Ss 4 Bs x s iy \ MeAulay, Lecturer in Matl ttics a Physics in tl University f Ta ara iea Macmillan & ¢ Tsust WHEN a man has acquired a nsideral ectual for andatta ~ 1 people hanging upon his lips everyv propstit mh he av ay pon, beinu human, he stratucht talk about thimgs conocer is not qualified to form ar t nion. In that wav, Maxwell, in his * Fleet citv and Magnetism’ ($1) said I an Vineed that the intr ct f tl leas, as listing she fr 1» at sand et huovte { Quatert . ¢ at se t s i all parts of subject wh sasn as to sav that he w 1 adopt ® addition-; ess tu tipie a bra, w t its m tay at } ess > ar t is ama g what anu fluence this dictum das had in preventing men rom studving quater ns. Yet in truth Max well was not ¢ wh versed in the sul t to know what tl s f quater s are Evervt v who has eve xhibited anv mas ial. Mr. MeAulay and especiallv of the hich value f this calcu f physical problems. We is thesis to be sound: but we are sorry k will do little truth to bring rt of self-will, dis There is a s spirit, an arbitrary the quality best Its in ions in notation are confusing and quite nissibl Worse still, plaved in it that is far from he purpose of persuasior the reasoning is in many places decidedly obscure, and often quite intricate Tait, the some needless] y Prof hat We can but agree with first of sections of the book are veritable do it.” Moreover, Mr MecAulay does not seem to be as familiar with living quaternionists, models of ‘Show not to the works of Hamilton as it behooves an apos tle of quaternions to be Yet, not useless, and as it has probably not stood in with all these serious faults, the work is the way of the publication of any other, we are glad to get it. Though it will not convert the scoffer, it here and there offers suggestions which disciples of Hamilton will receive with satisfaction BOOKS OF THE WEEK. A Standard Dictionary of the English Language. Vol I Funk & Wagnalis (« 12 Atwood, G. Complete Graded Arithmetk Part J j Part Il. st Boston : D.C. Heath & Co 45 cents
Page 24
20 The Nation. [Vol. 58, No. 1488 Raden-Powell, B. H. Land Revenue and its Adminis- tration in British India. Oxford : Clarendon Press ; New York: Macmillan. Broughton, L. Estoppel by Matter of Record in Civil Suits in India. Oxford: Clarendon Press: New York: Macmillan. ee c. F. Canned Foods. Retail Grocers’ Publish- ing Cheney, J. V. Ninette: A Redwoods Idyl. San Fran- ciseo~ William Doxey Dixon, W. M. English Poetry from Blake to Browning. London : Methuen Franqueville, Le Cte. sg “Le Systeme Judiciaire dela Grande Bretagne. 2 vols. Paris: J. Rothschild. Gray, W.C. Camp Fire Musings : Life and Good Times in the Woods. Randolph. Hooker, J. D., and Jackson, B. D. Index Kewensis. Part —~ Oxford: Clarendon Press; New York: Mac- milla Huxley, “prof. T. H. l oe Appletons. Number Work in Nature Study. Jackman, W.S Chicago: The Author. Minerva: Jahrbuch der Strassburg: Triibner: Kukula, R., and Tribner, K. Gelehrten Welt. 1893— 1804. New York: Westermann. AMERICAN SCIENCE SERIES. BARKER’s PHysics. Advanced course, REMSEN’S CHEMISTRY. 3 courses. PACKARD’S ZOOLOGY. 3 courses. MarTIn’s HuMAN Bopy. 3 courses. WALKER’s PoLiTIcAL Economy. 3 courses. Newcoms & HOLDEN’s ASTRONOMY. 2 courses. BEssEY’s BOTANY. 2 courses, JAMES’s PSYCHOLOGY. 2 courses. SEDGWICK & WILSON’s BIOLOGY. HENRY HOLT & CO., N. Y. Pall Mall Magazine January Number Now Ready. Science and Education : Essays. Part Edited by Lord Frederic Hamilton, [1.P., and Sir Douglas Straight. Will contain, amongst many other contributions from famous authors, the following: Second Part of George Meredith’s new story, “Lord Ormont and his Aminta”’’; ‘“‘ The Decline and Fall of Napoleon,” by General Lord Wolse- ley; ‘‘ Pomona’s Travels’ (first three letters), by ‘Frank R. Stockton; ‘‘ Marshal McMahon,” by Archibald Forbes; ‘‘ A Narrow Escape,” by E. Lester — ete. Colored Fronti and penny illustrated seat ah by the b aa artists ‘ When we come to speak of the PALL MALL MaGa- joo it must be in superlative adjectives, the num- so very excellent from s art to finish.”—Gen- tlewoman. yn aitorial Offices, 18 Charing Cross Road, London, .C._ Publishing Offices—London, vets Routledge & Manchester, n’s Row; New aay: + Toronto, The he Montreal News com Ltd., arqoewes. Ludgate Hil E George Routledge ns, Ltd., 16 Jackso York, The poe Ad News Com Toronto News C ‘ompany; Montreal, Company. . ° ° “= 0 . » . T » Economic History Since 1763. Selections illustrating Economic History since the Seven Years’ War. Compiled by Benjamin Rand, Ph.D. Second Edition, revised and enlarged 8v0, pp. 567, $3.00. Dr. Rand enables any student of the wonderful indus- trial changes of the last 127 years to derive from the very best authorities a thorou, ughly trustworthy outline of the economic and financial development.—The Lite- rary World. JOHN WILSON & SON, UNIVERSITY PRESS CAMBRIDGE, MASS. Extract from Letter of Prof. John Tyndall. “T consider the portrait I have marked as the best that bas ever been made of me, and hope you will pre- serve the negatives for future orders.” Imperial Panel Photos. on heavy bevel mounts, 14x17. Price, $8 00 each. Also Cabinet Photos. For sale by THE F. GUTEKUNST CO., 712 Arch St., Philada. YALE? duce or that money can buy. Lowell, J.R. A Apes ~¥ Critics, Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co. 30 ¢ The Sp salah Pioneers. A.C. An Elementary Text-book of Hebrew Hebrew Union College; New Masson, Fréderic. Napoléon et les Femmes. 9th ed. Paris: Ollendorff : New York : Christern. Moehler, J. A. Symbolism; or, Exposition of the Doc- trinal Diffe prence - between Catholics and Protestants. Seribners. Moscomder, r. C. * Heart-Beats. Boston: G. H. Ellis. 1.50. Neville, Ella H., Martin, Sarah G., and Deborah B. His- wetie Green Bay Green Bay, Wis.: The Authors. Cc. C, Snelley. London : Son- Lummis, C. F. Chicago : McClurg & Co. Margolis. M. L. Accidence. Cincinnati: York: G. E. Stechert non ‘Augustus. How to Wire Buildings. Ostrogorski, M. The Rights of Women. nenschein: New York: Scribners. ° A. 8. Barnes & Co. Paul, Kenneth. The New Minister. Voyages of Elizabethan Seamen. First $1. Payne, E, J. ries. 2d ed. Oxford: Clarendon Press; New York: Macmillan. Platt, C. A. NOTEWORTHY BOOKS OF POETRY. Mercedes. By THomMAS BAILEY ALDRICH, author of ‘* The Sisters’ Tragedy,” ete. 16mo, $1.00. Mr. Aldrich’s two-act tragedy, produced with signal success last spring in New York. Poems. By THomas WILLIAM PARSONS. top, $1.25. A book of rare poetic value, which is sure to be more prized the better it is known. Translation of Dante. A wonderfully poetic translation of nearly all of the Divine Comedy, by T. W. Parsons. With an Introduction by Proluane CHARLES ELioT NorTOoN, and a Biographical Sketch by LovuIsE IMOGEN GUINEY. 12mo, gilt top, $1.50. A. Roadside Harp. A new volume of strong, suggestive, remark- able Poems, ns LOUISE IMOGEN GUINEY, au- thor of ‘“‘ The White Sail,” etc. Attractively bound. 16mo, gilt top, $1.00. Fair Shadow Land. A new volume of Poems by EpitH M. THo- Mas, one of the most thoughtful and lyrical . living American poets. 16mo, gilt top, 1.25. Greek Poets in English Verse. Edited by Wm. H. APPLETON, Professor in Swarthmore College. 12mo, $ “To those who do not know the Greek tongue, yet wish to learn something of Greek poetic thought, its depth, richness, and transparent lucidity, we cannot do better than recommend this admirable compilation.”—The Church- man, New York. Horatian Echoes. ro JOHN O. SARGENT. With a Biographical Sketch of Mr. er ge and an Introduction by Dr. HOLMES mo, $ ‘*Mr. Sargent has raised a Seta to his own memory as well as that of his beloved poet.”—R. H. Stoddard. Sold by all Booksellers. HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO., Boston. ir East apeh Str eet, N ew York. $1.40. Italian Gardens. Harpers. $5. 12mo, gilt Sent, postpaid, by PAPER BY THE POUND and env ES Greater quan- tity, lower price than by quire. Samples, all ee rices marked, on receipt of 10c. WM. R. JE ne stationery, 851-53 Sixth Ave. (48th St) N. Y. MIXTURE The choicest Smoking To- bacco experience can pro- MARbuRG Bros. Rand, Rev. S.T. Legends of the Micmacs. Longmans, Green & Co. San Rearden, T. H. Seamtteco : William ey. Ricks, George. Object Lessons and How to Give Them. First and Second Series. Boston: D.C. Heath & Co. Each 90 cents. Rouge, sd Vte. ougenss % Seoerenhie Ancienne de la say pte Paris: Rothsehil d. Stoner’ s Ma azine, Tags. 2 vols. Scribners Seeley, C. 8. The Lost C: anyon of the Toltecs. A.C, ~~ lurg & Co. oe: s .R. — evennet after Sixty Years. Bos- : Roberts Bros Sieaned, Elizabeth, Rumour. 2 vols. Chicago: A.C. 1893. McClu The Over iy Monthly. July—Dec., cisco: Overland Monthly Publishing C oO. Thoreau, H. D. Spring. Excursions. Boston : re &Co. Each Tozer, Rev. Selections from Strabo. Clarendon Press; New York : Macmillan Teeeactines of the Royal Historical Society. Series. ys VII. Longmans, Green & Co. Wheatley B. Pepys’s Diary. Vol. UI. London: George Bell & Sons: 3 ew York: Macmillan. $1.50 Petrarch, and Other Essays. Doxe ‘Chie ago: San Fran re $1. ar ; New Brain Workers. Hor is recommended by physicians of all schools, for restoring brain force or nervous energy, in all cases where the nervous system has been reduced below the nor- mal standard by overwork, as found in lawyers, teachers, stu- dents, and brairsverkers cene- rally. Descriptive Pamphlet 1 Rumford Chemical Works, Providence, R. J. Beware of Substitutes and Imitations. For sale by all Druggists. ‘ESTABLISHED 1858" ‘H.. H.. UPHAM '&: MEMORIAL TABLEIS -IN- BRASS AND - BRONZE: "54° South: Fifth: Ave:near’ Bleecker * St. ‘NEW * YORK: We buy and sell bills of exchange on and make Cable Transfers of money to Europe, Australia, and the West Indies; also make collections and issue Com- Credit mercial and Travellers’ Credits, availa- 4 ble in all parts of the world. Brown Brothers & Co., Bankers, NO. 59 WALL STREET, NEW YORK. LARGE COLLECTION OF PORTRAITS of | THE- ATRICAL, LITERARY, and DIPLOMATIC CE- LEBRITIES. 74 AMERICANA, and ENGRAV- INGS PRINTED IN COLORS. etc. Apply with list of desiderata to FRANK T. SABIN, 118 Shaftes- bury Avenue, London, W. . PS pages WANTED.”— Low, Marston & St. Dunsian’s House, Fetter Lane, London, have spectal facilities for supplying out-of-print and scarce English, American, and Foreign Books wanted by Booksellers, Libraries, and Collectors. Letters of