The Nation 1893-08-24: Vol 57 Iss 1469

Page 1

ArT SE NRE RENEE RS AU ON Bien

‘The N VOL. LVII—NO. 1469. Harper’s Magazine FOR SEPTEMBER.

The Letters of James Russell Lowell. By CHARLES ELto’r NoRTON, Down Love Lane. By Tuomas A. JANviER. With 11 Illustrations by W. A ROGERS. A General Election in England. By RicHaRD HarRDING Davis. — [lustrated. The Diplomacy and Law of the Isthmian Canals. By SIDNEY WEBSTER. ‘* When Phyllis Laughs.”’ A Poem. By Joun Hay. Illustrated by W. T. SMepLeEy. Edward Emerson Barnard. By S. W. BurnHAM. With 5 Illustrations. An Albert Durer Town. By EvizABetH R. PENNELL. Illustrated by Josepu PrEN- NELL. Gabriel, and the Lost [lillions of Perote. A Story. By Maurice KinGstey. Illustrated by F. REMINGTON, Texas. By ex-Senator SAMUEL BELL MAxey. With 8 Portraits and [llustrations. The General’s Sword. A Story. By Ropert C. V. Meyers. _ Illustrated. The Handsome Humes. A Novel. By Witiiam Brack. Part IV. [ilustrated A Gentleman of the Royal Guard. By WittiamM McLennan. Ilustrated by REINHARI Riders of Egypt. By Colonel T. A. DopGce, U.S. A. With 7 Illustrations Horace Chase. A Novel. By ConsTANCE FENIMORE WooLSoN. Part IX September. A Poem. By ARCHIBALD LAMPMAN Editorial Departments

Subscription Price, $4.00 a Year. Postage free to all subscribers in the United States, Canada i Meri Bookeellers and Postmasters usually receive Subscriptions. Swdseriptions sent direct to the publishers should be accompanied by Post-ofice Money Orde Draft. When no time is specyjied, Subsecripti nunber THURSDAY, AUGUST 24,

Published by HARPER & BROTHERS, New York.

tion. ~< Son, log PRICE 10 C&NTS Harper & brothers’ LATEST BOOKS. The Prince of India. Or, Why Constantinople Fell. By Lew. Watiace, A thor of ** Ben-Hur,” ‘*t The Bovhood of Christ,” et Iwo volumes. 16mo, Cloth, Ornamental, $2 5< Ha Leather, $4 00; Three-Quarter Leather, $5 oo; || Quarter Calf, $6 oo; Three-Quarter Crushed Levant S88 oo (Ready to-morrow. ) The Refugees. \ Tale of Two Continents By A. Conan Dover, At thor of ** Micah Clarke,” et lilustrated by PHULsTRUP. Post 8vo, Cloth, Ornamental, &1 7s The Rebel Queen. \ Novel. By Waiter Besant, Author f ** All Sorts and Conditions of Men,” et lilustrated. r2moe.C Ornamental, $1 50 The Private Life. Three Stories: Zhe Private Lire, Les Visits By Henry James rome, Cloth, Ornam S1 oo A Child's History of France. By JoHN BoNNER Illustrated Post Svo, Cloth, O: mental, $2 oo. The Complaining Millions of Men. A Novel By Epwarp Futter Post 8vo, Cloth. O namental, $1 25. The Distaff Series: Il oman Tt th Alre ; , Edu: rr? di I | ted \ AN? ( BRACKE1 16mo, Cloth, Ornamental, $1 oo The Literatur f Philanthropy Edited by FRANcES A Goopalt 16mo, Cloth, Ornamental, $1 oo aréy 2 ‘ Edited by ALict Morse EArt ind Emiry EttswortH Fi RD 16mo, Cioth, Orna mental, $1 co. (OQTHER VOLUMES IN PREss.) Harper's Black and White Series: The Work ef Washington Irving. An Address By CHARLES DupLEY WARNER Edwin Booth By LAURENCE HuTTON The Decision of the Court \ Comedy By BRANDER 32mo, Cloth, Ornamental, 50 cents each is ¢ for sale by all booksellers, or will be sent by mail, post my part of the United States, Canada, or Mexico, on receipt of “s CaTacLoeve will be sent to any addreas on receipt of Tern ARPER 4 ] 4 efiotmins

“si Pa

Page 2

11 The Nation. [Vol. 57, No. 1469

The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science, and Art. FOUNDED 1865. [Entered at the New York City Post-office as second-class mail-matter.}

CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER BS Fens vvnexnecocveccevivesscossescevonesshenves 127 EDITORIAL ARTICLES : EEE. cc ncrenkeadscsabdovcsaecencdgssesesas The Real American Ruler. Dasiness OF GRO WSS... ccccsccccccssccccccvccevecees

SPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE:

The Columbian Exposition.—IV... , .. 182 The Pope and the American Se hoc .. 183 PENNE, BG NO TIDE... cocsccvccscccccnccesccscecses 134 CORRESPONDENCE: A Substitute for the Sherman Act.................. 1385 Purchasing Power of the Rupee.................... 135 The Religious Parliament at Chicago.............. 135 Mr. Alcott and His Blographers..................... 136 IIL <n neni cot nnnvececessvacerescessenes 136 Early Use of the Title “‘ University ”............... 136 RIG ac sanackenn esecsecaetesvesese0ae 137 EE cn nda tenbskenthiurersdncondscasevvccesasednnenies 137 REVIEWS : PEOMNOOODENE ID TEBTOVG 4 0.0000 50000cerccvvccscsscees 139 W. G. Ward and the Catholic Revival.............. 140 EE Sl EG bo cckbandtonsctdeuspeseessenese 141 NS MINED, ov ccccccnccesccce etencsecere 142 ED, CINE nc nccdsncensevccgnsesonspscoeeess 142 An Elementary Treatise on Pure Geometry.—An Elementary Treatise on Modern Pure Geometry. —Geometry in the Grammar School ............. 148 De EE NOE eco nscccsdcerecenevissencees 143 EE Ge I svn creeccaccescncecscisnasisccacss 144

TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION, Three Dollars per year in advance, postpaid, to any part of the United States or Canada; to foreign coun- tries comprised in the Postal Union, Four Dollars. The date when the subscription eapires is on the Ad- dress-Label of each paper, the change of which to a sub- sequent date becomes a receipt for remittance. No other receipt is sent unless requested. Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter or by check, express order, or postal order, payable to “Publisher of Tuk NaTIon.” When a change of address is desired, both the old and new addresses should be given. Address THE NATION, Box No. 794, New York. Publication Office, 208 Broadway.

TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Fifteen cents per agate line, each insertion, 14 lines to the inch. Twenty per cent. advance for choice of page, top of column, or cuts. Cuts are not inserted on the first rage. A column, $20 each insertion; with choice of page, $24. A page, $60 each insertion; front-cover pagé, $80. Advertisements must be acceptable in every respect. Copy received until Tuesday, 5

DISCOUNTS. TImME— 4 insertions. 6% 8 13 “ 26 “ 89 “ 52 “ MOU 500 750 = 1,000 ml 1,500 pe 2,000 ?

The NATION is sent free to those who advertise in it, as long as advertisement continues. The EDITION of the NATION this week is 12,500 copies. The Subscription List is always open to the inspection of advertisers. BUY A NEST-EGG. _ Why not be a holder of real estate at Washington, D. C., which will rapidly increase every year? Iam the owner of tracts of land fronting an electric line pass- ing Cleveland’s former residence, Oak View, connecting with Pennsylvania Ave. cars, which I offer from $400 to*$1,000 per acre, on easy terms in lots of from 1 to 50

acres. Refer to all Washington Banks and Trust Com- panies, JOHN E. BEALL,

1321 F St., Washington, D.C. Educational. CALIForstA, Belmon ELMONT SCHOOL, DELIGHTFUL- ly and advantageously located, 25 miles south of San Francisco, prepares for Harvard, Yale, the Mass. Inst. of Technology, and other Colleges and’ Scientific Schools. T. Rei, A.M. (Harvard), Headmaster.

CALIFORNIA, Los Angeles, West 23d Street. Jf Atesonorce SCHOOL for GIRLS. Mrs. Gro. A. CASWELL, Principal.

COLORADO, Denver. ENVER EPISCOPAL SCHOOLS.— Wolfe Hall for Girls; Jarvis Hall egg’ for Boys. Teachers raduates of best Eastern co leges. Attention is called to the curative qualities of this at- mosphere for delicate constitutions. Catalogues on ap- plication to Principal

CONNECTICUT, Clinton. OSEPH H. SPERRY, ASSISTANT Principal of Morgan School, receives for school year three boys into his home. High class school. Plea- sant home. : ersonal care.

CONNECTICUT, Greenwich. CADEMY AND HOME FOR 10 BOYS. 68th year of Academy, 14th of Home. Prepara- tion for College or business. Absolutely healthful location and genuine home, with refined surroundings. Gymnasium. References required. J. H. Root, Principal.

CONNECTICUT, Hamden. ECTORY SCHOOL FOR BOYS.— $325 to $375. Homelike influences combined with firm discipline and thorough school system. Extensive rounds, gymnasium, boathouse, ete. Send for circu- ar. Rev. H. L. EverRgEst, M.A., Rector.

’ CONNECTICUT, New Haven, 56 Hillhouse Avenue. CHOOL FOR YOUNG LADIES — WEST END INSTITUTE. Mrs. Cady and Miss Cady, ae. Prescribed and Elective Courses of Study, or College Preparatory Course. Circulars. Early ap plication necessary.

CONNECTICUT, Norwalk lv ISS BAIRD'S INSTITUTE FOR Girls.—22d year. Primary, Intermediate, and Col lege Preparatory courses. Mu sic, Art, and ‘the Lan “$7 ages. Careful attention to morals and manners. ew buildings, steam heat, gymnasium.

CONNECTICUT, Pomfret Centre. HE MISSES VINTON’S SCHOOL for Girls will reopen Thursday, October 5. Num- ber limited. CONNECTICUT, Stamford. BE: TTS ACADEMY. 55TH YEAR.— CLASSICAL AND ACADEMIC COURSES. SPE- CIAL FEATURES: Making the individual the basis of work; home influences; learning ‘“‘how to study” of first importance; cultivation of habits of observation and research; a development of p' phystaue. WM. J. Betts, M.A. (Yale), Principal. momma Wallingford. f° MARY HALL, L A COUNTRY SCHOOL FOR GIR iss RUUTZ- on ‘Principal.

row are Waterbu MARGARE T'S DIOCESAN iS Rn —Nineteenth year opens Sept. 20, 1893. The Rev. Francis T. Russell, M.A., Rector. Miss Mary R. Hillard, Princi pa al.

DELAWARE, Wilmington, Franklin Street. HE MISSES HEBB'S ENGLISH, French, and German Boarding and Day School for young ladies and girls reopens Sept. 22, 1892.

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA, Washing HE COLUMBIAN UNIVE Serr y.~ For copies of new Catalogue, containing a descrip- tion of Lecture Courses in the College, the Medical School, the Dental School, the Law School, the Corco- ran Scientific School, and the newly verected School of Graduate Studies, address JAMES C. WELLING, Pres’t.

ILLINOIS, Chicago, 3715 Langley Avenue. HE CHICAGO PREPARATORY School fits for the best colleges. Day and Boarding Pupils. Primary and Kindergarten Departments. Rev. JOHN H. Parr, Principal.

ILLINOIS, Up ay Alton. ESTERN MILITARY ACADEMY. 15th year. An old and thorough preparatory school, with graduates in Yale, Cornell, Princeton, and other colleges. Cadets pre pone for college or for busi- ness. Circular sent on application.

INDIANA, Lima, La Grange County. OWE GRAMMAR SCHOOL.—AN Episcopal Boarding School for Boys. Prepares for highest University Courses, or for business. ‘ully oenees for Intellectual and Moral training, and for : — development. Numbers limited. Send for Re- gister.

KENTUCKY, Farmdak, near Frankfort. ENE OCK YY MILITARY INSTI- TUTE.—Located in probably the healthiest coun- try in the world. 48th session begins Sept. 11, 1893, and closes June 13, 1894. Address Col. D. F. Boyp, Supt.

KENTUCKY, Shelbyville. ye ALLL, nN An English and Classical School for Girls. Oldest in the South. First-class in all its appointments. Pre- pares for W ellesley. W. T. POYNTER.

Educational. MARYLAND, Baltimore. WE SARAH RANDOLPH SCHOOL FOR GIRLS. Founded a Miss S. N. Randolph of Virginia, 214 EUTAW PLACE, pind Druid Hill Park. Mrs. A. L. ARMSTRONG, Principal.

MARYLAND, Baltimore, 706 Saint Paul St. : OUNT VERNON INSTITUTE, English, French, and German School for Girls, Mrs. JuLia R. TUTWILeER, P rincipal, will reopen § September 27. Boarding pupils limited to twenty. Students prepared for college. MARYLAND, Baltimore, 122 and 124 Ww. ‘Franklin St. pOGk WORTH BOARDING AND DAY School for Girls, Mrs. H. P. LEFEBVRE, Principal. 81st year begins September 21, 1893. MARYLAND, Baltimore, 915 and 917 7 7N. c harles St. OUTHERN HOME SCHOOL for Girls, Mrs. W. M. Cary, Miss Cary. Fifty-second year. Summer address, Bar: Harbor, Me. MARYLAND, C ‘atonsv ille. : ; T. TIMOTHY'S English, French, and German School reopens Sept. 20, 1893. Principals: Miss M. Cc. Canta, Miss S. R. CARTER. Maryt. AND, Embla P. O., near Baltimore. OTRE DAME OF MARYLAND.— Collegiate Institute for Young Ladies and Prepara- School for Little Girls, conducted by the School Sisters of Notre Dame.

aoe HUSETTS, Amherst (Suburbs), MES RK. GC. WILLIAMS’S SELECT Family School for Girls. Opens Sept. 20, 1893. Free access to Amherst College collections in natural seiences and the fine arts; also to the libraries and class- room lectures. MASSACHUSETTS, rs, Andover. » BBOT ACADEMY FOR YOUNG LA- dies, begins its 65th year September 14th, offer- ing enlarged opportunities. Three Seminary Courses of studies and a College fitting Course. Address Miss Laura S. Watson, Principal.

MASSACHUSETTS, Billerica. TTCHELL’S BOYS’ SCHOOL.—18 miles from Boston, B. & L. R. R. Strictly select Family School. $500 per year. Admits ages from 7 to 15, inclusive. Special care and training to young boys. Fits for college, serra: 3 and business. Send for circular to - Mite! HELL, LL, Principal. —

MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 593 Boylston Street. YIAUNCY HALL SCHOOL (65th Year), For Boys and Girls.—Preparation for a Mass. In- stitute of Technology is aspecialty. Reference is made to the Institute Faculty. The location of the school building, on Copley Square, is especially attractive, and is very near the Institute. Preparation also for College (with or without Greek) and for business. Special students s received. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 5 Otis Place. R. HALE’S SCHOOL FOR BOYS, Fits for Harvard and for the Institute of Tech- nology; preparation for Harvard both on the usual classical plan and on the plan which gives prominence to modern languages and gy science. The latter plan forms a fine preparation for the Institute. Tenth year will begin Sept. 27. Circulars. ALBERT HALE.

MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 252 Marlboro’ St. A TSS CLAGETT’S HOME AND DAY School for Girls reopens October 3. Specialists in each department. References: Rev. Dr. Donald, Trinity Church; President Walker, Institute Tec hno- logy.

MASSACHUSETTS. Boston, 9: 31 Marlborough St. V, ISS WEEKS AND MISS LOUGEE'S LV Home and Day School for Girls opens Oct. 3, 1893. Junior, Senior, and College Preparatory courses. Ad- dress Miss S. C. LouGEgr, 188 Walnut Ave., Roxbury.

MASSACHUSETTS, Bostor J ISS FRANCES V. “EME RSON, Successor to Miss Abby H. Johnson HOME and DAY SCHOOL FOR GIRLS, 18 Newbury St. 19th year opens Oct. 4, 1893.

MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 9 Appleton Street. OSTON NORMAL SCHOOL OF GYM- nastics.—Fifth year opens = tember 26, 1893. Amy Morris Homans, Director.

MASSACHUSETTS. Boston, 25 Chestnut Street. ISS HELOISE E. HERSEY’S School for Girls opens Oct. 6. Two vacancies for house pupils. Nostudent received without a personal interview. Circulars on application.

MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 112 Newbury Street. HE MISSES HUBBARD’S SCHOOL for Girls will reopen Oct. 3, 1893. A limited num- ber of boarding scholars will be received.

MASSACHUSETTS, Bostc da STON UNIVE R A a A Law School. Address the Dea EDMUND i. BENNETT, LL.D. MASSACHUSETTS, Braintree. HE THAYER ACADEMY. First term, seventeenth year, begins Wednesday, Sept. 13, 1893. Address J. B. SEWALL, South Braintree, Mass.

ga nied

be. — co

Page 3

Aug. 24, 1893] |

Educational. MASSACHUSETTS, Cambridge, 13 Appian Way. J R. JOSHUA KENDALL'S DAY at F

amily School for Boys. Fits for College. Phy sical Laboratory. Circulars. Address until Sept. 15, Islesford, Hancock Co., Maine. MASSACHUSETTS, Cambridge. "T'HE CAMBRIDGE SCHOOL( fer Youn Ladies). Advantages of Boston. Quiet of Cam bridge. Comforts of home. Small classes. Mr. ARTHUR GILMAN ts Director. MASSACHUSETTS, Concord. XONCORD HOME SCHOOL.—25 BOYS _ prepared for college, scientific school, or business. All the advantages of family life combined with best mental and physical training. Buildings new and ¢ cording to latest models. 75 acres of ground. JAMES S. GARLAND, Principal. MASSACHUSETTS, Duxbury. QVOWDER POINT SCHOOL,.—PRE- pares for Mass. Inst. of Tech., Harvard, or Busi ness. Individual teaching. Labor: atories. The 50 boys are members of the family. Elementary classes for young boys. F. B, Knapp, S.B. MASSACHUSETTS, Greenfield. : ROSPECT HILL SCHOOL FOR GIRLS, —Twenty-fourth Year. Prepares for College. Also Science, Art, and Music. JAMES C. Parsons, Principal. M TP aRD Ph Lexington. HH: ARVARD PREPARATORY SCHOOL for boys requiring especial personal direction in their courses. Limited to eight. For particulars and references, address GEORGE L, STOWELL. / instruction. Best of references.

MASSACHUSETTS, Newburyport. : OME SCHOOL FOR CHILDREN. Children received at any time for home care : Home for delicate or motherless ¢ Address Miss Aba E, Ti

IWLE,. MASSACHUSETTS, Plymouth. : R. KNAPP S HOME SCHOOL FOR l Boys.—12 boys; 27th vear. H. W. Roya. (Harv), Head Master. rs. KNAPP, Principal. ‘| s, September 21,

MASSACHUSETTS, Quincy. DAMS ACADEMY. Boys for the leading Colleges. 1893. Address w. R. — PREPARES School year begins TYLER, Master. Ma ASSACHUSETTS, . Springfield. / R. AND MRS. JOHN Ms ‘hool for Girls. Formerly Miss Howard’s. MASSACHUSETTS, Taunton. IRISTOL ACADEMY,.— FOR BOTH sexes. Founded In 1792. A Harvard feeder for jan. Year -rincipal. , ee nee — University . F. PALMER, generations. begins Sept 5 M ‘ST HUSETTS, West Newton. ly/*> NEWTON ENGLISH AND ‘Clas: bs School —Family and Day School. Both sexes. 41st ye ar. College, Scientific, and Business pre

paration. Send for Catalogue. At home Tuesdays. ALLEN BROTHERS. M ASSACHUSETTS, Worcester HE HIGHLAND MILITARY ACA- DEMY begins 38th year Sept. 13. Classical, Scien tific, Business, Preparatory Departments. Gymnasium Athletics encouraged. Careful Training. Home influ ences. JOSEPH ALDEN SHAW, A.M., Headmaster

MASSACHUSETTS, Worcester. HE HOME SCHOOL. Miss KIMBALL’S SCHOOL FOR GIRLS Wide awake, thorough, progressive. College Prepara- tory and Spec i ul Courses. Send for illustrated circular. MASSACHUSETTS, Worcester, 66 West Street. OHN W. DALZELL’S PRIVATE x School for Boys.—Prepares for College or Sci entific School. Send for Catalogue. ) ICHIGAN MINING SCHOOL.—A | State School of Mining Engineering and allied subjects. Has Summer Schools in Surveying, Shop Prac tice, Assaying and Ore Dressing, and Field Geology. La boratories, Shops, and Stamp Mill well equipped. Tui tion free. For catalog ue write the Director. MIcHIGan, Houghton. J MICHIGAN, Orchard I ICHIGAN M11 iy ARY —A College Preparatory School ACADEMY. of the highest grade. Location thirty miles from Detroit, and unsur passed for beauty and healthfulness. For Catalogue, address Col. J. S. RoGERs, Superinte ndent ; MINNESOTA, Minneapolts. TANLEY HALL, A nr Day School for Girls. 117 students. Full courses in Two years beyond College Pre ac holarship (value $400) to ft BOARDING AND 14 instructors—¥9 resident, Music, Art, Languages aratory Courses. Offers tryn Mawr Col For ADELE EVERs, Principal. ' lege. catalogue, address Miss OLIve NEW HAMPSHIRE, Mont Ve rnon. UF gute nel INSTITUTE—A FAMI.- ly Boarding School for ten Seas in a beautiful mountain Village 50 miles from Boston. Thorough pre paration for College and Business. Best personal care and individual instruction. Backward boys rapidly ad vane ved. Joun B. WELCH, A.M., Principal. NEW we F, Portsmouth. 4 ISS A. MORGAN’S SCHOOL FOR Se ptember 27, 1893

Y oung Lat "Me and Misses. 20th year.

McDUFFIE’S

The Nation. Lieducational.

New JERSEY Asb iry P ark. “CHOOL OF THE GOOD SHEPHERI * A HOME SCHOO! FOR GIRLS Children deprived of a mother’s care, and those wt from previous fil he alth have fallen behind others of their age, will receive loving sn and special in struction. $250 per vear liiress SISTERS OF THE GOoD SHEPHERD, 410 West 19a ee New York NEW JERSEY, Burlington BB! 4 best universities "RLINGTON COLLEGE. fitting school for the home and abroad. Buildings just refitted with every modern conventence. Campus of 12 acres, splendidly shaded, on the banks of the Delaware. $400 a vear both at Rev. J. M. WiLtiaMs, Pb.D., Reetor NEW JERSEY, Freehold [i REEHOLD INSTITU TE.—soth Year Boys’ Boarding School. Primary, College, Prepara tory, and Business Courses A. A. CHAMBERS, A.M Prin ae PRIP Hammo non ‘and ae lly deaf chil ares n HH althe il \ wation ft the pines of Southern New Jersey. Number of pupils limited. Correct English, aural development, s and lip-reading the prime objects. Constant f association. For circular of information and ences, address WALTER BROWNING PRI New JERSEY {AE WOO . Lakewood. ) HEIGHTS SCHOO!

a Among the Pines A thorough and attractive SCHOOL FOR ROYS James W. Morey NEW JERSEY, Montclair, 1: smilce from New York UY jee TCLAIR MILITARY ACADEM} 4 Summit of Orange Mountains.—Gra luates ul mitted to leading colleges without examinations. Lars: gymnasium, with special instructor Cadets live tn cottages. J. G@. MacVicar, A.M., Principal NEW JERSEY, Morristown Mis DANA'S SCHOOL FOR GIKIS pens Sept. 20. College preparati ilent h ative French and German teachers. Spectal adva tages in music and art. Terms for boarding pupils 87 00 per year Circulars sent on application NE “A Jr rR SEY, Mount Holly MeUx DP aotry acapemy—it School foe Boge af allages. Prepares for College Scientific School, or business. Catalogues Rev. Jas. J. CoaLe, A.M. (Princeton), Prit NEW JERSEY, Princeton. THE PRINCETON PREPARATOR S School opens Sept. 19. Inquiries may be addressed to President Patton of Princeton College, or t J. B. Fink, Head-master New York, Brooklyn, 402 Herkimer sS ** CYSTERS’ HOME SCHOO! » For little girls will reopen © % ’ culars, apply at SisTeRs’ House. Tert - year NEW YORK, Brooklyn, 180 Joraler Stree ‘aan and. Se hox r Highest Acader Ar i Musical Advantages. Circular on appli i ~ iy? » Geneva, Hi amilt n Be ik: yy cy »¢ QO ( TR ‘ Fourteenth year opens Sep 20. comy ete organ! zation, including Primary and Ac adem i Thorough preparation for le Pee i olleges f

Miss M.S. Smart, Principa New York, Havana ‘ 3 . — , OK ACADEMY Fi OTH SENES Classical, Scientific and Liter ‘ rses. Mus and Art. \ New York, Irving M SS BENNET girls may have all t! f t training an d best ed icati th sid teachers aims at tl 1g grades Preparatior le ege New Y¥« RK CITY 43 West 47 Street CADEMIC CLASSES FOR GIRLS.— if Primary om Pemennen ASSES arding an ght Bees u Individual Instruc tion. College Preparati MARY B. WHITON, A.B., and LOIS A. BANGS References he Rev. Joseph T. Duryea, D_D The Rev. William R. Hunt ton, D rk ¥ The Rev. L. Clarke Seely

fiducatronal New \ K vr. 4 Mat vA ; woe € , Au t “ m for a x aiid tu Ma » New \ y i ‘ ‘ 1 f r 5 Thursday, October Isvu New ¥ in ¥. ISS Le x Ave " } N \ h and - sh ™ } = . New ¥ K, Sara ‘ : ary. —Suyj r fa sfort z . . v. La ues, M . we t ur ‘ Acted * ‘ New \ Sing id a“ } ww 4 “ " w > New ¥ ‘ , 1 x ‘ ‘ AD} ‘ N i 4 A ’ \ \ \ t ry 4 | at * t t NA M VA A i ‘ \ S ! A urs 8 ; ‘ | ‘ ’ " s \Na 4’ 4 ‘ \ \ A ¢ Pe NAS VaNta ‘ \ Sey s . y ‘ *ENNSYE VAN \ \ N¥S SrA . . I] = 4 7 ‘ . , Six . ally r : a ik assical,s 1 ses. Musicand Ar arce M and Musi ar this year ¢ t " b 1s en ‘ + ‘ Ss. 4 x: Mus ex RB.) : ~ , P , « gs. stea « 4 ‘ aboratories t N ard ¢ pugils > rist wa " “A s 4 VS) x “ ay , ‘ ‘ , s s vil } 4 str os Arts 4 Als PRE ISES s : BSahos it rs } 1e 4 ‘ re Wa as. BF. Hya I PE NWS ara. Fa \ 7 F = rbhoth sexes. Pur i! ampus. Perfect sanita Phe S 1 1. « wl F.M.1 wis, A.M.. Principal ‘ anita. l aster County, Lititz ' EMINAR YS A Moravian N for Isand Young Women ar c Se} 1 are a supervision Lil rse and rational methods of Instruct Rev. C. B. SHULTZ Principal PENNSYLVANIA, Germantown, 202, 204, 335 West ‘ elten Ave » ISS MARY STEVENS’ BOARD.-

llege

: 24th year. “ Approved” Mawr College Bryn Mawr entrance xa : held in ol b¥ an examiner from

School certifi o admits to Vassar.

Page 4

The Nation. [Vol. ‘57 No. 1409

— —————————

‘etniabiiaial PENNSYLVANIA, PhiJadelphia. 7 M TSS GORDON’S BO. ARDING AND Day School for Young Ladies, 4110 and 4112 S ruce Street. Most delightfu location in Philadel »hia. 18th year ogee s September 20, 1893, French, Music, wy Cc ene eparatory. Cc ircular o on n application. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, 2045 Walnut St. 1 EST WALNUT STREET SEMI- nary for Young Ladies—27th year. Is provided for giving asuperior education in Collegiate, Eclectic, and Preparatory Departments; also in Music and Art. Mrs. HENRIETTA KUTZ.

PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, Chestnut Hill. RS. COMEGYS AND MISS BELL'S l English, French, and German Boarding-School for young ladies reopens October 2. Students pre- pared for College. Ample grounds for outdoor exer- cise.

PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, 1350 Pine St. fo’ it ANABLE’'S BOARDING AND Day School for Young Ladies. Estab. in 1848. Opens Sept. 28. SoutH Caro.ina, Columbia, Cie GE FOR WOMEN. A fine winter resort for girls and young ladies, where protection from inclement winters an unsurpassed advantages in education are secured. The grounds, four acres, the handsomest of any school in the South, make a winter garden attractive for out- door exercise. Same te as 8 ville, Aiken, or California. — and Art specialties. French and German spo- *ulldings heated by hot-water heaters. Appointments od sqeterz arrangements first-class. W. R. ATKINSON, D.D., President.

TENNESSEE, Franklin ALL AND MOONEY’S SCHOOL for Boys.—Fits boys for the leading Universities. Discipline rigid, instruction thorough, expenses rea- sonable. In writing for Catalogue, mention Nation.

TENNESSEE, Nashville. , : ; 'ARD SEMINARY for Young Ladies. —Opens Sept. 7. Withouta rival in its delight- ful location, buildings, and equipment. Finest Art De- partment in the South. Conservatory of Music. Best advantages in Literature, Langgegre. and Elocution. BLANTON, Pres’t.

VERMONT, Burlington. Vz RMONT EPISCOPAL INSTI- TUTE.—Boys’ Boarding School. Military Drill, Our certificate admits to most co leges. Also business course. Accommodates forty-five boys. Catalogues H. H. Ross, A. _. ‘Principal.

VERMONT, Saxton’s River, near Bellows Falls. FEW GIRLS RECEIVED AT OUR house. French (the language of the family), Ger- £3. Italian, Latin, and Music taught. Rev. Prof, and Mrs. Roux.

<= T. AGNES’ SCHOOL FOR GIRLS, Aiens, N. Y.—Under the direction of Bishop Doane. Choice of four courses of study for graduation. Special studies may be taken, or the Harvard Course for Wo- men. For atalogue address Miss E. W. Boyd, Principal. HE BOSTON SCHOOL OF ORATOR Y. —The Leading School of Expression in America. Send for Catalogue. Moses TRUE snows, M.A., Har- court Hall, St. Botolph Street, Boston, Mass.

FRANCE, Paris. C. INSTITUTE.—FIRST-CLASS 2 merding and Day School for American young ladies. Also post-graduate courses in Music, Art, Mo- dern Languages, etc., for those who have already finished school or college. Pupils escorted from New York to Peris and back by Principal and lady chaperone. Terms moderate. Send for circular explaining new and interesting specialties. Address Rev. H. C. MAYER, No. 371 Marlborough St., Boston, Mass.

GERMANY, Echz NSTITUTE Z 7 'CIUS. — BOARDING School for Boys. Prepares for German gymnasium and Universities. Beautiful location. Best of refer- ences.

Educational. MUSEUM OF FINE ARTS Copley Square, Boston, Mass. SCHOOL QF DRAWING AND PAINTING. The eighteenth year will open October 2, 1593. Instruction in drawing from the cast and from life, in painting, modelling, and decorative design, and also in artistic anatomy ane pompeceye. Principal instruc- tors: F. W. Benson C. Tarbell and Philip Hale ad and Painting), C. Howard Walker and Mrs. illiam Stone (Decorative Design), B. L. Pratt (Model- ling), G. H. Monks, M.D. (Anatomy), and A. K. Cross (Perspective). Pupils are allowed the free use of the alleries of the Museum. For circulars giving detailed nformation, address Miss ELIZABETH LOMBARD, Manager.

COLLEGE OF PHYSICIANS AND CHICAGO, /LL. Winter term begins September 18, 1893. Course of study covers four years; for Bachelors of Arts and Sci ences, three years. Preliminary examination required in English, Physics, Mathematics, and Latin. Fees, $100 ayear. Laboratory equipment for students une- qualled. For announcement and further information, address Dr. BAYARD HOLMES, Secretary, Venetian Building, Cc hic ago, ml. SURGEONS, NEW ENGLAND CONSERVATORY Founded b CaRL FAELTEN, Dr.Eben Tour}ée. OF MUSIC. Director. The Leading Conservatory of America. In addition to its unequalled musical advantages, exceptional er, are also provided for the study of Elocution, the Fine Arts, and Modern Lan- guages. The admirably bg eg Home affords a safe and whi.” residence for lady students. Calendar Free. FRANK W. HALE, General Manager, Franklin Square, Boston, Mass. OGONTZ SCHOOL For Young Ladies. Established in 1850. Twenty minutes from Philadel- oe. two hours from New York. Opens September 27. or circulars and reports apply to Principals, OGONTZ sc HOOL P. ©. PA. THE: CLAVERACK COLLEGE ND HUDSON RIVER INSTITUTE FOR Bors AND GIRLS, will open its 40th year Sept. + For Catalogues, address Rev. A. H. FLACK, A.M., Prest., Claverack, N. Y. THE YOUNG LADIES’ SEMINARY, FREEHOLD, N. J. Admits to Smith, Wellesley, and Vassar on certificate. Graduates from the Seminary Course. Preparatory Class, Art and Music. Home care. Miss EUNICE D. SEWALL, Prin. ROCKFORD COLLEGE FOR WOMEN. 45th year begins Sept. 13, 1893. College course and excellent Pp aw school, Specially organized de- partment of Music and Art. Four well-equipped labo- ratories. » growing ~ mig Fine gymnasium. Resident physician. Memorial Hall enables students to much reduce expenses. For Catalogue, address SARAH F. ANDERSON, Principal, Rockford, Ill., Lock Box 10. WASHINGTON AND LEE UNIVERSITY, Lexington, Va. Academic, Law, Engineering. Opens Sept. 14. For Catalogue, address W. C. LEE, President. CHELTENHAM MILITARY ACADEMY OGONTZ (NEAR PHILADELPHIA), PA. Represented by its eo mt in Harvard, Yale, Princeton, Cornell, Am- erst, University of Pa., Lafayette, and West Point. (Lehigh University and Trinity College added for "93-9 23d year. JOHN CALVIN Rice, Principal WILLIAMSPORT DICKINSON SEMINARY. WILLIAMSPORT, Pa. Both sexes. Regularand elective courses. Degrees —. Fits for college. Music, Art, Modern guages jialties. Steam heat, electric light, home comforts. $2: 5.40 per year. C atalogue free. Year opens Sept. 4. E. J. Gray, D.D., President.

Educational. The Columbian University WASHINGTON, D.C. The School of Graduate Studies Has Lecture Courses leading to the degrees of A M. and Ph.D. in English, Greek, Latin, French, and German, in Mathematics, Mathematical Physics, Solar Physics, Theoretical Astronomy, Astro-Physics, General Chem istry, Minera! C hemistry, Agricultural Chemistry, Bio C hemistry, Geology, Meteorology, Zoélogy, Compara tive Anatomy, Anthropology, Speculative Philosophy, and the Philosophy of History, Also Lecture Courses leading to the degrees of Civil Engineer and Electrical Engineer. For Catalogues, giving description of the several courses, address the 7 wistrar. JAMES C. Ww EL L ING, President. UNIVERSITY OF VIRGIN CHARLOTTESVILLE, VA. Session begins 15th Sept. Full equipment and corps of instructors in Academical, Engineering, Law, and Medical Departments. Excellent Climate. New Gymnasium, with baths free to all students, For catalogues address WM. M. THORNTON, LI..D., Chairman. UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO. Applications, with testimonials, will be re- ceived by the undersigned for the position of Professor of Logic and Metaphysics in the Uni- versity of Toronto, until the twentieth day of August next. Initial salary $2,500, with an annual increase of $100 until the maximum of $3,200 is reached. Gro. W. Ross, Minister of Education. EDUCATION DEPARTMMNT (ONTARIO), TORONTO, 12th July, 1893. College of Gymnastics. Extension and Enlargement of former Normal Course of the ALLEN GYTSINASIUM. Thorough Course in Gymnastics, theoretical and prac tical, including eo 5 Swimming, Bicycling, Voice Culture, Anatomy, and hysiol logy. For Prospec tus, —— Mary E, ALLEN 42 to 56 St. Botolph Street, Seton. UNIVERSITY Thirty-fifth year be gins October = 1893. Confers LL.B.; also LAW SCHOOL for frataste course) AUSTIN ABBOTT, Dean and a ol Professor. Address, for Catalogue, PROF. RUSSELL, _At University Building, or 120 Broadway, N. Y. City. WELLS COLLEG FOR WOMEN, AURORA, N.Y. Three Full Courses of study. Location beautiful and healthful. New Building with Modern Improvements. Session begins Sept. 20, 1893. Send tie E. S. FRISBEE, D.D., President. Kenyon Military Academy, GAMBIER, OHIO. Much the oldest, largest, and best equipped bgarding-school for boys ‘in Ohio. The vil lage noted for healthfulness and beauty, is on a hill-top 00 feet above sea-level. Illustrated ‘catalogues sent.

Excellent Boarding School Near Philadelphia, will receive daughters of profes sional men at half-price. Address, for Catalogue “ PRINCIPAL,” P. O. Box 1592, Philadelphia, Pa. CLASSICAL AND HOME INSTITUTE, POUGHKEEPSIE, N. Y. Young ladies may pursue the graduating course, prepare for college, or select their own studies. A pleasant home with good care. SaRAH V. H. BUTLER, Principal.

THE BAKER& TAYLOR CO., 740 Broadway, N.Y. can completely fill at the lowest rates all orders for School and Miscellaneous Books wherever published, and promptly forward same in a single shipment. specialty. SCHOOL and COLLEGE TEXT-BOOKS Of all Publishers at WHOLESALE PRICES. Educational Materials a specialty. 59 Fifth Ave., N. Y. WM. BEV. HARISON.

Supplying schools with books a Catalogues of and Estimates for School and Library Books ¢ on application. ” $chool Supplies, Maps, GLOBES, Blanks, Pads, BOOK COVERS, Biackboards, etc.

rh _eOuerro —s: roy —™ =, o nate.

Page 5

Aug. 24, 1893] E:ducatonal. St. John’s Military School, MANLIUS, N.Y. Rt. Rev. F. D. HUNTINGTON, Prest.. WM. VERBEX ist Lieut. W. P. BURNHAM, 6th Infantry, U.S. A., mandant. Apply to Superintendent for circular RIVERVIEW ,,, AcaBEMY: POUGHKEEPSIE, N.Y. 58TH YEAR. Prepares thoroughly for College, the Gov ernment Academies and Business. Military organiza tion. BISBEE & AMEN, ba rine ipals. VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY, NASHVILLE, TENN. Next session opens Sept. 20. Full raduate as well as undergraduate courses. Ten Fe! owships for College Graduates. Seven Departments Fully equipped laboratories and museums. WILs WILL IAMS, Secretary. ton The Misses Ely’ s School for G RIVERSIDE DRIVE, 85TH AND 86TH STREETS, NEW YORK. Girls, LAKE ERIE SEMINARY FOR YOUNG WOMEN, PAINESVILLE, OHIO. Early application necessary for September, 18v3. BUFFALO SEMINARY. THE FORTY-THIRD YEAR. For circulars, address Mrs. C. F. HARTT, 284 Delaware Avenue, ASHLEY HALL Music, Art, Languages. lege. Mi BUFFALO, N. Y. Home School for 20 young ladies. Ten liles from Boston. Thorough oe paration for col iss WHITTEMORE, Principal, Montvale, Mass. Cayuga Lake Military Academy, Advantages: A well-disciplined school, experienced teachers. Location near Cornell University. Term be gins Sept. 14, 1893. For illustrated circular, address Col. C. J. WRIGHT, A.M.,? principals or ALFRED K. Mc ALPINE, AM. oo HACKETTSTOWN, AURORA, N. Y. _ x Hackettstown Institute, NEW JERSEY. College Preparatory for Gentlemen. Ladies’ Collese Music, Art, Elocution. Best buildings of itsclass. Steam heat; electric lights. Location healthful, grand. Illus. ( ‘atalogue free. Re v. GEo. H. Ww HITNEY, D. D., Pres PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, 1924 Chestnut Street. MISS BOYER’S English, French, and Music School FOR BOARDING AND DAY PUPILS. COLLEGIATE INSTITUTE, Ft. Edward, N. Y, For Young Women. 36th year Sept. 26. Six courses and Prep. Music, Art, Floc., Phys. Cul. $270. Jos. E. Kine, D.D. Teachers, etc. oe SORSHIP OF PSYCHOLO- Ys ethics, ete.. is desired by a competent spe cialist. A wife, an ace omplished voice-culturist, would also teach. Address PROFESSOR, 1522 Q St. N. W WwW ashington, dD. Cc. J a position as teacherin aschool. She is qualified teach German, French, and Italian. teference, Prof. C. E. Norton. Address, eare of Prof. Norton Ashfield, Mass. 4 N EXPERIENCED TEACHER, all graduate of an Eastern college and of a German University, desires a college position. Specialties English and German. Address Phb.D., care Nation. N INSTRUCTOR IN PHYSICS IN ISS AN. v. 4 PE TERSE. Vv DE TRE S 4 one of the foremost Western Universities (A.B. Harv ard, Ph.D. Germany) desires a change. Also tut } ship. W illing to travel. Address Dr. X. B., care Nation, | ’ YALE GRADUATE (1890) WISHES 4 a position the coming year as tear her of Classics, German, or Engieh in pre ents school. Address LOBBINS, Ruskey, Dutchess Co., N ARLES W. STONE, Tutor for Har- | vard, 68 Chestnut St., Boston. School Agencies. HE ALBERT TEACHERS’ AGENC} always receives many calls for teachers during the months of August and September by telegraph as as by correspondence. These vacancies must be quickly. Teachers with good te paration or good cords are now in demand. Fg: ress J. ALBERT, Manager, 211 Ww ‘abash Avenue, ( “hi NV: ATION AL BU REA U TION, Miss CrosTuwait, Prop., ¢ High Sts., Nashville, Tennessee. and Teachers’ Agency of the OF i K,Supt., | The Nation. Agencies. * ICAN AND FOREIGN TEACH a ers’ Agency supplies Professors, Teachers, Tutors Governesses, ete., to Colleges, Schools, and Families Apt ly to Mrs. M. J. YounG- Fc. ron, 23 Union Squat e New Ye rk 7 fit SK TEACHERS At VC/ES, 4 As} rton Street, Boston {71 Main Street, Hart ford, 70 Fifth Aven N. Y., 106 Wabash Ave. Chicag and he South Spring Street, Los Angeles. Agency Manual free. EVERET?Y ©. Fisk & Co. NEW AMERICAN TEACHERS | GeNcY.—Teachers seeking positions and those wishing a change at an increased salary, should address | C.B. RvGa_es & Co, (Palace Hotel Building), Room C, } 237 Vine Street, Cincinnati, O | Ate ER | {ND FOREIGN Professors, tut rs, vernesses, teachers, rg supplied t Solle ges, schox K. ind families. MIRIAM COYRIERE 150 Sth Ave., cor. 20th St., N.Y VERHORN’S TEACHERS y. Oldest and best Known inthe U.S 11855 3 Fast 14th St. N.Y : 37-4, 18 Valuable in proportion to its 4 Ly l fC} influence If it i hears of vacancies am is something, but if it tells you about them that *; asked to recom mend a teacher and recom » 5 pmenansn penta mends you, that is more, Ours A CCOMMENAS Cc. W. BARDEEN, Syracuse, N. Y | . . P b . | 7 ~ ’ } en) ’ ~ (y ( ‘University Publishing Co, EDUCATIONAL PUBLISHERS, NEW YORK. BOSTON NEW ORLEANS ] , ) ] - Holmes’ Readers, Davis’ Arithmetics, Arithmetics, Maury’s Geographies, Reade rs, Venable’s Santord’s Gildersleev es Latin, ere, >” Please write for Catalogue and prices 10TH EDITION, OF SURVEYING, PROF. J. B. JOHNSON Svo, cloth, $4.00 | ‘} Asample coy Ex ation with a view | troduction wili be s posta any Ins it pt of $2.67 JOHN WILES New York. | LEIF ERIKSON. \ new work s Lvesti ; gat nh made by t 4 n the locati f I INELAND,” and apa pe n ‘the “GRAVES ORTHMAN,” by hi % With m =e un stratt ns; beautifully printed fr the University Press umbrids Paper, $1 t bound, $2 S y DAMRE 1 L & UPH. AM, BOSTON. > y 2 Dictation fr Englis ssics, wit ath al J ~ i = ( Ms 4 eto Sp A vra vornis \ t by ¢ ~ schools a ss ces. By m 24 cts H. PE NN 4 AN, Philadeiphia, Pa. JAMES 4322 Sansom Street, GARTEN SUPPL f ED {- ’ ’ “pNr ITN eae oc . cor. Church and INDER A AES Tne Leading School » Ka ¢ \ } South and Southwest i y Sass 1G weg Ue 8 The Theory and Practice & SONS, Make a Specialty of Supplying Public, Private, and School Libraries. Correspondence with book purchasers solicited. Any book published in United States sent postpaid on receipt of price Liberal discount to parties ordering quan tities. Send trial order Lists of books for Libraries priced gratis | The Legal Code of Alfred the Great. | Fdlited. with ? t4 by Milton H. Turk. P? Profeasor in ge. Svo, boants. wilt. 147 pages Price Pst pa $1 This, the first ( w «le plete, w t 1 of special . stud 8 of Anglo-Sax GINN & CO., Publishers BOSTON, NEW YORK CHICAG LONTHON V enth and Khia Pniareed Vdition Cyl TET? & ag Se | Jiti' AN ELEMENTARY TREATISE ON “ANALITIC GEOMETRY EMBRACING BY PROF, EDWARD A. BOWSt R. / L.. I, Professor of Mathematics and Engineering gers College, New Br swick, N In this revised edition some he strat . are shortenes si i ew Us Propositions are et are it ar carefully the solution buted thr One volume 2 loth, illustrated, § Special tertus f eNATine D. VAN NOSTRAND) ¢ Craries ‘i [ittingham «& Co., WHOLESALE BOOKSELLERS, 766 Broadway, New York, ‘ k yY ¢\ fuer z | , q é \ fLA«* x iF wLA 7.¥4 ‘¢ £4 « ter Resort, University Town of Innsbruck, Tirol i act Lwh? feet above th Austria e sea, with drv r Zz n Tirol, open all year. Carl Landsce, } arge, airy, sunny xoms, well furnished Fleva Supert uisine (table d’haite ora la carte Redu in winter Carriages and sleighs at low rates. Charming excursions made from the hotel at all seasons Unusual advantages for se uring teachers of the languages, history, sete art, m sic, ete., at very muxderate terms Eminent med care and skilled nu rses if desired. Rest English and American references application. Sx at pb we . Nlustrated pamphlets sent on li orks AND THE es RE F THE NEW HURCH . Send t for a complete Price List MASSAl n SI | [IS NEW-CHURCH ~—UMON, 16 A n gton Street, Boston KENTUCKY MULITARY INSTITUTE. jated six miles from Frankfort, Ky q Large central building with three rows of barracks, all rick and two stories high, with 123 acres of land. A military school of fifty vears’ standing. No better lo ation in the untry Can be had cheap. Apply to PaAYETTE Hewitt, Frankfort, Ky GRECIAL CATALOGUES, » Hoveaton rnin & Co.'s Books of . Art, Biogra phy. Essays, Fiction, History, Poetry Politics, Religion, Setence, and Travel, will be sent to any address upon application. 4 Park Street, Boston thin,

Page 6

vi The Nation. [Vol. 57, No. 1469 Macmillan & Co.s Announcements — OF — NEW BOOKS BY AMERICAN AUTHORS TO BE PUBLISHED DURING THE AUTUMN OF 1893. CHARLES DEXTER ALLEN, Hon. Corresponding Secretary for the United States of the Ex Libris Society. American Book Plates. With fifty illustrations. Small 8vo. By By KATHARINE LEE BATES, Professor of E»glish Literature at Wellesley College. An Outline of the Development of the Early English Drama. By Professor FLORIAN CAJORI of Colorado College, Colorado Springs. A History of Mathematics. By Professor JOHN R. COPIMONS of the University of Indiana. The Distribution of Wealth. By F. MARION CRAWFORD. Marion Darche. A new novel, written on the same basis of plot and character as his play of that name, soon to be put upon the stage by Mr. Augustin Daly. By Professor KARL P. DAHLSTROM of Lehigh University, Bethlehem, Pa. A translation of Weisbach’s [lechanics of Hoisting Machinery, As revised by Professor HERMANN. By Professor N. F. DUPUIS, M. A., F.R.S.C., Professor of Pure Mathematics in the University of Queen’s College, Kingston, Canada. Synthetic Solid Geometry. By President DAVID J. HILL of the University of Rochester. Genetic Philosophy. By Professor DUGALD C. JACKSON of the University of Wisconsin. Notes on Electromagnets and the Con- struction of Dynamos. By Professor HENRY B. ORR of Tulane University, New Or- leans, La. A Theory of Development and Heredity. By Professor GOLDWIN SMITH, aushor of ‘‘Cinadi and the Canadian Question.” The United States—A Political History, 1492-1871. 12mo, cloth, $2.00. To be published Sept. 12. By the SaMeE AUTHOR. Bay Leaves. A collection of Translations from the Latin Poets. By D. W. TAYLOR of the U.S. Navy Yard at Mare Island, California. The Resistance of Ships and Screw Propulsion. By Professor J. Ae TUFTS of the University of Chicago. A TRANSLATION OF Windelband’s History of Philosophy. By WILLIAM WINTER. The Life and Art of Edwin Booth. This work has long been in preparation, with Mr, B >oth’s espe- cial sanction, and wiil be very fully illusirated. By the SAME AUTHOR. A NEW EDITION, ILLUSTRATED, OF Shakespeare’s England, With numerous full-page and vignette [\lustrations, and a new photogravure Portrait of Mr. Winter, after the original drawing by Arthur Jule Goodman. By Professor ALEXANDER ZIWET of the University of Michigan. An Elementary Treatise on Theoretical Mechanics. Part 1. KINEMATICS. Part Il. STATICS. Book Reviews, a Monthly Fournal devoted to New and Current Publications, MACMILLAN & CO.,, Price, 5 cents. Yearly Subscription, 50 cents. Publishers, New York.

Page 7

The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, AUGUST 24, 18938. _ The | Week. THE most important feature of the com- mittee appointments in the House is, of course, the constitution of the Ways and Means Committee, which must frame the new tariff bill. Speaker Crisp has made the wisest possible selection for the chair- manship of this Committee in Representa- tive Wilson of West Virginia, who is a thorough student of the subject, a vigor- ous and able debater, and a man of the highest reputation with both parties. The restoration to this Committee of Breckin- ridge of Arkansas and Bynum of In- diana, who were formerly members of it, strengthens it, and it seems to be ad- mirably framed for its work. The retire- ment of Holman from the chairmanship of the Appropriations Committee is a great gain to the cause of good government, his ridiculous ideas of ‘‘economy” having brought much discredit upon the theory of frugal administration, while his suc- cessor, Sayres of Texas, is, by the con- fession of his political opponents, a man of broad views, without any tendency to extravagance. Having disregarded precedent as to these two commit- tees by refusing to reappoint their former chairmen, it is a great pity that Speaker Crisp did not do the same thing by deposing Mr. Bland from the head of the Coinage Committee. It is some consola- tion that Bland has among his Democratic colleagues such sound-money men as Tracey of New York, Rayner of Maryland, and Harter of Ohio, but a man of Harter’s type ought to have been the chairman. Fortunately, the importance of this committee will be greatly diminished after the passage of the pending bill re- pealing the Purchase Act. it Senator Vest’s coining ratio of 20 to 1 has received a fatal blow from Secretary Carlisle, who has prepared a statement showing that it would cost $89,741,900 to give effect to it in merely recoining the standard silver dollars, and that it would cost $23,124,421 to recoin the subsidiary silver so as to make it bear the same pro portion to the new silver dollar that it now bears tothe existing one. These two items of cost foot up $112,866,321, which it would be necessary for Congress to appro- priate. Without this recoinage, Mr. Vest’s bill could not be carried into effect. We could not have two silver dollars of differ- ent weights under the principles of free coinage. We might have any number of such under the present system of limited | coinage and gold redemption of silver. The metal in the present silver dollar is worth only 56 or 57 cents. That of the Vest dollar would be worth 72 or 73 cents. We might have as many varieties there are long as the coinage is only on Government account. But if the mints be opened to unlimited coinage for private individuals, all silver dollars must be alike. as Senators as Hence the gravity and seriousness of Secretary Carlisle's letter. It would require years, moreover, for the mints to do the work, and mean- while free coinage would be in abeyance. Meanwhile should benefits of the gold of free silver coinage, have neither the standard, nor those if there are any. Of all the devices called out by the pre- sent crisis, this to 1” scheme is the most impracticable, and, when closely ex amined, the most ludicrous. If it had the advantage of conforming to the market ratio, that would be something in favor, as it would afford an international agreement, not even that advantage. we *D() its some basis for has but it Secretary Carlisle’s service in the cause of sound money has been recognized on all hands as particularly effective. What he has practically done is to assume the right of a Cabinet officer to a seat and a voice on the floor of Congress. Yet in what a roundabout and handicapped man ner he has had to do it, by writing letters to the Chairman of the Committee Finance and giving out statements to th press. on These have been particularly tell ing, it is true, and his volleyed figures have gone like grape and canister through the ranks of the silver men; but deadly wrought, and how much more surely he could have caught and influenced public sentiment, if he could have been really, as he made himself constructively, on the floor of the Senate, the truth home in the give-and-take of debate. As it is, Scnator Vest will probably take a few days to bind up his wounds, and will how much more execution he could haves driving then make some sort of reply, which will have to go unanswered until Mr. Carlisle can go through the process of getting an other letter published. Face to face with an opponent, and with equal right to free speech, he could not only smite the enemy through the midriff, but could twist the spear in the wound until there was an en of the business. By an instructive coin cidence, on the same day that Secretary Carlisle was doing his long-range shooting in this country, the Chancellor of the Ex chequer in England was at close quarters in the House of Commons with his oppo nents on the Government's silver policy, and was putting them hors de combat on silence and nullity, on all pending ques tions of sense to have it in its best form. Perhaps if we oftener had members of the Cabinet legislation, it is only common of Mr. Carlisle's effective debating powera, we should become ashamed of compelling them to dodge about committee rooms and write letters in get before Congress and the country. order to their views Senator Vest says in his speech on the silver question ‘It is a favorite expression now to talk the ‘silver lunacy.” Mr. President, lam w ing to follow that great lunatic, Thomas Jeffer son, on this question This shows how necessary it is for a Sena tor to know the history of the subject he is talking about. There are few events in our monetary history better Known than the fact that Thomas Jetferson, when President of the United States, in the vear 1805, gave a peremptory order to the Mint to stop and that this corni g sil er do Irs. order remained in force until 836, although res d e reason why is thus stated by Mr work entitled Jeiferson had long ceased to tx nt and had long been dead rt he gave this order Upton, in his ‘Money in » ? — Politics ‘He } desired that 1 should circulate as well as silver, and yd he peremptorily ordered the M . continue the coinage of the silver dollar Whatever the motive, he certainly gave the order, and that is the reason why there is a blank in the coinage statistics n ISG to of the silver dollar fror The bill reported by Senator Voorhees from the Finance Committee is sufficient for all purposes, and if passed will stop the panic and bring out of its hiding places frightened ere is a great deal of mis- the meney now locked up by depositors. Ti chief done which cannot be undone, but the bill when passed—and we have little doubt of its passage—will restore confidence, which is the great desideratum and sin« qua non. The clause which declares it to i be the policy of the United States to con- tinue to use both gold and silver as stan- dard money, and to coin both gold and silver into money of equal intrinsic and exchangeable value, etc., of no conse- It is what called, on another oc- casion, ‘‘a stump speech in the belly of the bill vote for the measure by reason of the stump speech w ho would not otherwise do is quence one way or the other. Thomas H. Benton If anybody can be brought to | so, then, in Heaven’s name, let him have the spot. He was doing directly and by | warrant of custom and law what the | American Secretary was doing indi- rectly and by a tacit and awkward over- riding of custom if not of law. to have the system at all, and are not to condemn our Cabinet officers to absolute If we are it. The declaratory clause is a nearly verbatim copy of the Chicago platform. If it will help the bill along to put in the Minneapolis platform also, let that be done. The two are so nearly alike that no incon gruity would result,

Page 8

128 The Nation. [Vol. 57, No. 1469 The statement of tke condition of the banks of New York city published on Satur- day, which was awaited with so much in- terest, proved in several respects encou- raging. The gain of $4,500,000 of reserve is satisfactory,as showing that the condition of the banks is stronger, and as demon- strating that their solvency is above sus- picion. Taken by themselves, the shrink- ages in the amounts of the loans and of the deposits are not cheering, but taken together some elements of hope may be extracted from them. The loans have decreased over $5,000,000, but the deposits have decreased less than $2,000,000. This may be considered to indicate that we are reaching that stage in our financial crisis when deposits increase faster than loans— the period when stagnation succeeds panic. At first the banks cannot contract their loans as their deposits contract, and a long process of pinching has to be gone through with until something like an equilibrium between deposits and loans is brought about. Then follows a period when de- positors are more disposed to put their money in the banks than the banks are to lend it—a period of general business de- pression but of gradual recuperation. When loans begin at last to expand, we may be tolerably sure that prosperity is returning. The fact that the India Council in Lon- don has sold bills on Calcutta at the rate of is. 344d. per rupee, thus confessing its inability to maintain the rate of exchange at 1s. 4d., has been construed by some un- informed people as tantamount to a fail- ure of demonetization in India. Even the London Standard has fallen into this error. The truth is, that this contingency was carefully considered by the financial au- thorities of India before they decreed the demonetization of silver. Their original programme did not contemplate the fix- ing of a rate of exchange between the rupee and the sovereign. Their plan was simply to stop coining silver, and then to leave the rate of exchange to find its own level. The idea of fixing a rate of ex- change at 1s. 4d. came from’ the Her- schell Commission. It was seen by com- petent financiers to be a blunder the mo- ment it was announced. It is now proved to be such. But the Indian Government, in accepting the suggestion, was careful not to pledge itself to maintain the rate of exchange at any particular figure. Its members foresaw that it might be impos- sible, under all circumstances, to make good sucha pledge. So they limited their undertaking by the following words: ‘* Arrangements will be made to issue rupees from the mints in exchange for gold and sove- reigns at the rate of sixteen pence per rupee until further notice.” Therefore the only argument to be drawn from the sale of India Council bills at fif- teen and a quarter pence per rupee is that the Herschell Commission made a mistake. That Her Majesty’s Opposition should make the most of this is to be expected Fortunately for the Gladstonians, Mr. Balfour, the leader of the Opposition in the Commons, committed a greater mis- take the other day by making a speech in favor of bimetallism. This equa]! will soon blow over. It will then be seen that the demonetization of silver by India is an accomplished fact, and that the maintaining of a rate of ex- change has no necessary bearing on the main question. All persons who expect the Government of India to take the back track will be disappointed. Our problem will continue to be exactly what it has been from the beginning. (Qur silverites will get no help from the Asiatics. They will get no help from any quarter. Their fa- vorite metal will fall to the level required by its cost of production. And so it would do even if we had free coinage. Free coinage in India did not prevent silver from declining in value there. Free coin- age in Mexico does not prevent its declin- ing in value there. The only thing it would accomplish here would be to cheat creditors and wage-earners, including all bank depositors, savings depositors, and pensioners, and persons who have fixed in- comes. After ‘his had been accomplished we should havé two kinds of money—gold and silver—the latter being at 40 or 50 per cent. discount. The Times seems to be the only London paper taking a calm and ac- curate measure of the fact that the arbi- trary par of exchange cannot be maintain- ed. It warns speculators not to risk money on any theory that the India mints are to be reopened to silver. The absurd attempt to make apprehen- sion of tariff changes responsible for our business troubles was all along so devoid of support from any commercial body that when the Tacoma Chamber of Com- merce was reported to have come to its support, many despairing Republican edi- tors thanked God and took courage. It now turns out that the resolutions be- wailing the ‘‘threatened overturning of the protective policy” were so laughed at and repudiated in Tacoma itself that the Chamber had to recall them. They were originally adopted on August 1. On August 5 they were reconsidered, and everything about the tariff left out, to the satisfaction of all concerned except one lonesome member, who could see no- thing but tariff on every bush. This leaves the record clear again, and we can still challenge the high-tariff organs to produce the testimony of a single respect- able commercial or financial organization to sustain their view. Secretary Carlisle has notified the North American Commercial Company, the les- sees of the Pribyloff Islands, that the re- duction in their rental made in 1890, 1891, and 1892 was without warrant of law, and tbat they are liable for the full amount. This involves a question of law which the courts will undoubtedly be call- ed to pass upon; but as far as the equities of the case go, there will be a general agreement that the company ought to pay for the trouble and expense it has put upon the Government to maintain its monopoly. The whole controversy arose out of the wrath of the monopolizing company at the invasion of its pre- serves by the impudent Canadians; and whatever advantages have been won by the Paris arbitration will inure to its bene- fit solely. No American citizen can do any pelagic sealing in the close season, or venture within the 60-mile zone, any more than a British citizen. The whole result is to confirm and establish a mono- poly of the sealing industry in the hands of this San Francisco company. That. is what it has been after from the beginning, and all the tears shed over the suffering seals, and the talk about the “crime against nature” in killimg the gravid females, and the pictures of the absolute despair and misery of the human race when deprived of sealskin cloaks, had their origin in the fears of an endan- gered monopoly. The company has kept the country in hot water for seven years, has drawn us to the verge of war, and saddled the taxpayers with heavy expense ; and if now it can legally be made to foot a part of the bill, there will be no objection from man or seal. There seems to be some misapprehension in regard to the question of damages un- der the findings of the Arbitration Tribu- nal, The only precise award of damages which the arbitrators could make, in ac- cordance with the treaty, was for the abstention of British subjects from seal- ing during the pendency of the arbitra- tion, or for the limiting of the catch by the American Government, in case its claim of exclusive jurisdiction were sustained. This award the arbitrators must now have made to Great Britain, ‘*for the use of her subjects,” though the amount fixed upon has not been an- nounced. The treaty only stipulated that the amount ‘‘shall be such as, under all the circumstances, is just and equitable, and shall be promptly paid.” On _ the question of the liability of our Govern- ment on account of the seized Cana- dian sealers, the arbitrators were em- powered to make a finding only on ‘any questions of fact involved in such claims”; ‘‘ the question of the liability of either Government upon the facts found to be the subject of further negotiation.” In other words, the Canadians will have to go to work in the usual way to prove their claims, either before our Govern- ment direct or before a mixed claims com- mission agreed upon for the purpose by England and the United States. The action of the Republican State Con- vention in Iowa last week assures the re-

Page 9

Aug. 24, 1893] The Nation. peal of the Prohibitory Law by the Legis- lature which is to be chosen in November. It is now about a dozen years since the Republicans in that State took up prohibi- tion as an issue,and they have had enough of it. In the last two gubernatorial con tests it lost them the Governorship, and in 1891 one branch of the Legislature as well. It was certain that furtheradherence to it would lose them the State offices again this year, and probably also the Legisla- ture, which is to choose a United States Senator. So, although in the last contest for Governor they stood by the law and had *‘no apologies to offer for the Repub lican record” on this question, the late Convention declared that ‘‘ prohibition is no test of Republicanism,” relegated the subject to the Legislature, «ndorsed the principle of local option, and nominated an anti prohibitionist for Governor. In any event, therefore, the election must re- sult in the choice of a Legislature which will repeal the existing law, as the Demo- cratic members will all be on that side. It is not so certain, however, that the Re- publicans will control the body. It was only by a narrow margin in a total vote of more than 1,200 that prohibition was rejected in the Convention, and a great many Republicans still believe so devout- ly in prohibition that they will vote for candidates committed to its support rather than for what they consider ‘‘faithless” members of their own party. The figures contained in the fourth an- nual report of the Statistician of the Inter-State Commerce Commission show that no other region in the world of any- thing like an equal extent is so well sup- plied with railroads as is that portion of the United States which extends along the Atlantic Coast from the northern boundary of Massachusetts to the southern bound- ary of Maryland, and stretches westward to the Mississippi Of course there are small and densely peopled countries like Belgium, with a land surface about one- fourth that of the State of New York, which have more miles of line in propor- tion to their total area, as there are thinly peopled commonwealths like the Austra- lian colonies which exceed it in the ratio of railway mileage to inhabitants. But in extent of territory it is with the great nations of Europe, Russia except ed, that this region of the United States can be most fairly compared, covering, as it does, more than twice as much surface as either the United Kingdom or Italy, a fourth more than either France or Germany, and but a few thousand square miles less than Austria-Hungary with Bosnia and Herzegovina thrown in. If the comparison be thus made, it will be found that in proportion as well to area as to population, the eleven American States in the region mentioned lead the world in railway mileage. For every one hundred square miles of their land surface they have 17.97 miles of railway, while the United Kingdom has but 16 42, Germany 12.44, France 11.06, Italy 7.10, and Austria- Hungary 6.30. Relative to population, of course, the superiority is even greater, there being 17.09 miles of line for every 10,000 inhabitants, while in the United Kingdom there are but 5. 17 miles, in France 5.91, in Germany 5.35, in Austria-Hungary 3 91, and in Italy 2.62 miles. The net impression derived from the Pa- pal Ablegate’s visit to this city is, that he came here for the express purpose of fore ing Archbishop Corrigan to what amounts to a public recantation and profession of obedience in the future. This impression is distinctly contirmed by the authorized interview with Archbishop Satolli’s pri- vate secretary, which as good as said that the object of the visit was to find out whether the Archbishop of New York was ‘*sincere” or not in his loyalty to the Pope. We do not wonder that the friends of the Archbishop are indignant at the terms of this interview, and denounce it as in accurate, but we observe that the private secretary and the Ablegate are at no pains to correct it. The fresh outbreak of splut tering in the Sun by anonymous cham pions of Archbishop Corrigan shows in what quarter the bolt has struck. We may expect this clanking of chains to go onfor some time, but the fact remains that the Pope's representative, with the Pope’s full sinction, has ridden over the reactionary extremists of the Catholic Church in this country, and is now ex hibiting the chief of them tied to his chariot. The result of the French elections was a foregone conclusion, and it may be con sidered that the Republic is now establish- ed in France as the political capacity of the French peo ple affords. The royalist faction appears tohave been nearly extinguished and the question as to the form of government deti nitively answered. Henceforth the problem to be solved is not whether there shall be a republic, but what kind of a republic there shall be. Upon this subject the ap- upon as substantial a basis proach of the general election naturally called forth many brochures, in which the political history of rm cent years was criti cised from various pointsof view. We have not observed among these any serious at tempts at laudation of the Chamber just dis solved, the most ventured in this direction being rather shamefaced apology, while | the torrent of invective poured forth upon the members of the expiring body has been terrific. As to the earlier record of the Republic, however, the case is some what different That record has been ex amined with especial ability and severity by M. Francis de Pressense in an essay en- | titled ‘La France, les partis et tions,’ which has been received with gene- ral admiration, has forth some vigorous replies The best the moderate Republican journals, les elee- drawn | of the ' but which | Danish vote in Schleswig 2a9 ~ * 1 Temps, has exerted all its abilities to dimi nish the force of M. de Pressense’s attack, and, it must be admitted, with some de gree of success. Among the two thousand candidates who asked the suffrages of th electorate on Sunday, but a very small number have gained distinction in any way except in politics, in the French harrower sense of the term. This has been made a subject of remark in many quarters, but nowhere more forcibly than by M. Sak mon Reinach in an article in the Aepu blique Francaise. He shows how publi life has a diminishing attraction for the in tellectual élite of France. The few brilliant exceptions which may be pointed out only serve to make more conspicuous the low level of the great mass of ottice holders and candidates for office. Most of entirely unknown outside of a limited local them are circle, and an exceedingly small number have ever gained a name in acience or literature or art or education. M concludes that Reinach ‘we are travelling towards a state of things such the United States caste of politicians, side by side with the as eXists in the formation of a narrow increasing withdrawal from public life of men who think and make others think.” Precisely this result was pre dicted by Burke a hundred vears ago when he spoke of the ‘ multitudes of the inferior sort” which would be drawn in- to public life as “ the objects of ambition are multiplied and become democratic The democratic fact, has brought with it a deterioration of per sonnel in the world. It has brought it well asin France movement, ta official class all over the in England as so much so as to point the remark lately made by John Morley in answer to an objection urged against the character of the men found in the proposed Irish Parliament, likely to be that if legislation were to wait until a thoroughly nice Legislature could be got together, the wheels of government would be blocked in on earth. every democratic country A minor feature of the recent German elections the increase in the While as hither to but one Danish member was returned, his majority has been was considerably greater, | and the minority votes of the other Danish | candidates were without exception in creased. In spite of the determined efforts | of thirty years, the Germans are no further advanced in their plan of Germanizing | this conquered Danish territory than when | they began. | homes, Danish papers are still read, and Danish is still spoken in the Denmark is still regarded as the people's real fatherland. Nor are the Danes at home more reconciled to the of ‘Southern Jutland.” In every possible way they seek to support the cause of their former countrymen and to express their warm sympathy for them loss

Page 10

[Vol. 57, No. 1469 GOLD AND CREDIT, It is very obvious that most of those who may be called ‘‘practical bimetallists ’— the owners of silver mines and the politi- cians controlled by them—are really in favor of monometallism. They demand the free coinage of silver, and they are unable to clothe the assertion that the gold standard could still be maintained with a rag of argument. But it is undeniable that a considerable number of honest peo- ple are convinced of the theoretical ad- vantages of bimetallism. Like Mr. Ar- thur Balfour, they sincerely dread the adop tion of gold monometallism. It seems to them to involve the diminution of the ‘‘reservoir” of precious metals, and to threaten a serious, and, to debtors, an oppressive decline in prices. So far as we have observed, however, these theo- retical bimetallists do not pay sufficient attention to the fact that 1t is a ‘‘condi- tion and not a theory that confronts us.” They fix their minds upon a real or sup- posed fall of general prices that has taken place during the last twenty years, and upon an imagined or anticipated fall that is to take place in the future, and ignore the frightful depreciation of the present moment. That depreciation we attribute to the apprehension not of gold monome- tallism, but of silver monometallism. How- ever this may be, it shows that there are causes in operation which the bimetallic theorists do not take into account. These causes arise out of the credit sys tem of doing business, a system which has been carried in this country toan extreme never before witness2d. Until recently it might almost be said that money in the strict sense had gone out of use in the United States. A man would carry on an extensive business for months without touching a gold coin. A silver dollar he would reject, and the only semblance of metallic money that he used was the token coinage, which after all passed upon its credit more than upon its intrinsic worth. There was some gold held by the banks in their reserves and a good deal was held in the reserve of the Goverament. The only object of holding it was to as- sure the holders of paper money that they could get gold for it if they wanted to do so. If the holders of this paper were entirely satisfied that the Government had the ability and the will to redeem it in gold, we do not hesitate to say that the banks might keep their reserves in legal-tender notes instead of gold, and the Government might get along safe- ly with a reserve of a hundred mil- lions of gold. It might be formulated as a law that the amount of gold required for the transac'ion of the business of this country varies inversely with the credit of the Government. If that credit is above suspicion, the amount of gold need- ed is infinitesimal; but if the credit of the Government is shaken, it ceases to be available as money to the same extent, and more gold is required. To simplify the matter, we may throw The Nation. out at once the factor of positive ability to pay. No one doubts that the United States is abundantly able to pay all its ob- ligations without difficulty. But since the silver legislation has prevailed, it is unde- niable that doubts have arisen as to the honesty of the purpose of our Government. The political platforms have in many cases not been reassuring. A great many Repre- sentatives and Senators have loudly pro- claimed that existing debts ought to be made payable in silver, and have voted for free coinage in order to make their intention effective. Rightly or wrong- ly, those who Lad lent gold dollars or their equivalent regarded this intention as dishonest. They perhaps had no clear views about monetary theories, but as be- tween gold and the paper promises of a govirnment of suspected honesty they had a practical preference for gold. Hence the contraction of credit; hence the strenuous demand for currency to take the place of the credit that had disappeared; and hence the reappearance of gold as money. What now would be the effect of a clear, emphatic, and sincere declaration by a substantial majority of Congress that every creditor of the United States shou'd be paid in gold, and that no more silver would be bought or coined? According to the bimetallic theorists, this ought to pro- duce a fall in prices. They think that there would be a greatly increased de- mand for gold, a struggle among nations for it; that its value would be so en- hanced that prices would fall, and the ‘‘debtor class”’ would be ground be- tween the upper and the nether millstone. The facts show that nothing of the kind would take place. There would be a rise and not a fall of prices. There would be a lessened and not an increased demand for gold. There would be no struggle of nations over the matter, for, in the first place, the struggle is not between nations but between individuals, and in the second place gold would be rather at a discount than at its present premium. The ‘‘debtor class’ would find that its credit was im- proving, business men would be able to get their notes discounted, timid people would release their hoards, and, in short, by restoring credit to its function as money, the requirement for actual money would come to an end. To sum up, our existing currency is com- posed of gold and credit. If there is less credit, there must needs be more gold. If there is more credit, there need not be so much gold. If the bimetallists are logical, they will recognize the fact that credit is a much more important factor in curren- cy than silver, and that their endeavors to force silver upon a reluctant business community depress prices instead of rais- ing them. If we are to have bimetallism, we shall have to give up a large part of our credit. It may be wrong and deplor- able, but it is the fact, and sensible bimetallists ought not to ignore it. We think the correctly reasoned convictions of the ‘financial classes” are against them, but, granting that itis only their un- reasonable prejudice, the practical ques- tion remains the same. Shall we regard these prejudices and continue to do busi- ness on a little gold and a great deal of credit, or shall we defy them, and try to do business on a great deal of silver and what gold and credit the financial classes are disposed to contribute? This is the question that the American people is now asking its representatives in Congress. THE REAL AMERICAN RULER. “IN no country in the world,” says Mr. Bryce in his ‘American Commonwealth,’ ‘‘is public opinion so powerful as in the United States. Towering over Presidents and State Governors, over Con- gress and State Legislatures, over conven- tions and the vast machinery of party, pub- lic opinion stands out, in the United States, as the great source of power, the master of servants who tremble before it. In America opinion is not made, but grows; : does not originate in a particular class, but grows up in the nation at large.” We commend these utterances, by the most penetrating and friendly student who has ever analyzed American institutions and character, to all persons who have doubts about the action of the Senate on the pro- posed repeal of the Silver-Purchase Law. We commend them also to the interested advocates of silver who are seeking to create the impression that there is at pre- sent a majority against repeal in the Senate. To any one who has followed closely the history of this country, there are visible in the situation at Washington the very con- ditions which have usually preceded a great triumph of public opinion and a disastrous defeat for selfish, personal, and private interests. It has happened almost invariably that we emerge from our most momentous crises by a very narrow margin of safety. It is well known that when President Grant vetoed the Inflation Bill of 1874, he was at first inclined to approve it, and had prepared a message to that effect, but that he tore it up and wrote a second one which rescued the country from the abyss of illimitable paper money. Public opinion saved us in that crisis, as it saved us again from the free-silver-coinage peril in 1890. When the Free-Coinage Bill passed the Senate in that year, there was a general expecta- tion that it would pass the House as well, but it was turned back because of popular protest against it. That protest was a very feeble voice compared with the one which is heard now, for the people have been going through a course of compulsory education on the silver question during the past few months which has taught them more about it than they would have learned in a lifetime under ordinary con- ditions. Again and again partisan zeal in Con- gress has brought the country to the verge

Page 11

Aug. 24, 1893] of pernicious and dangerous legislation, like the successive force bills and the Blair Educational Bill, only to be turned back at the last moment by the influence of aroused public opinion upon a few of the more conscientious and high-minded mem- bers. In the Legislature of New York a few years ago a bill was passed, with arro gant defiance of public cpinion, authoriz ing the disfigurement and spoliation of | Central Park. Its advocates had more votes than they needed, and they scoffed atthe idea of yielding to ‘‘ popular clamor.” But, within a few days, these same advo cates, grinding their teeth in rage, bowed before public opinion and repealed their | own measure. they were merely frightened into submis- sion to the only power of which they stand in awe. The of President Cleveland is crowded with instances of this power of They were not converted; career public opinion to overcome all obstacles, and they are so familiar to everybody that it is not necessary to recall them. How often has it seemed tothe political prophets that his public career had been brought to an end because the politicians and statesmen of his party were arrayed in almost solid mass against him. He triumphed over them in every instance because he had public opinion behind him, and they found themselves, when that opinion asserted itself, as powerless as the most insignifi cant citizens in the land. They could not defeat him in their political conven- tions, and they were unable to prevent his triumph at the polls. We are confident that the present con- test will result, like all others of the kind, in the triumph of public opinion. The in- fluences which are at work in the Senate to prevent it are the same as have worked against Mr. Cleveland in previous conflicts. How familiar it sounds, for example, to read in the Washington despatches that ‘*in the opinion of many it rests with Sena- tor Gorman to determine the action of the Senate on the question of the repeal of the Silver Purchase Act.” We heard good deal of talk of that kind at the open ing of the National D-mocratic Conven- tion last year, but the event that Mr. Gorman had very little power in the premises. It sounds equally familiar to read in the same despatches that Sena- tor Hill would be glad to aid Mr. Gorman in defeating repeal in the Senate, hoping thereby to show the President that he can- not carry out any policy without the aid of that wing of his party which Hill, Gor man, and Brice represent. But this wing has endeavored to make precisely the same a showe rd demonstration many times before, and, for various reasons, has. not succeeded. What would be the position of the Demo- cratic party in New York and every other Northern State were these anti-Cleveland Democratic Senators to defeat bill? Every man of them knows that it would be a question only of the size of the Republican majorities after that might like to see President Cleveland's the repeal They year’s statistics. The policy fail, but they are Nation: anxious to commit political suicide in order to cause failure. The trouble is that Cleveland's policy is the people's policy, and the two 10t its f cannot be separated. Cleveland would not be injured by the failure of the Senate to pass the repeal bill, but the Democratic party would be blown so far out of exist ence by that failure that it would have no voice in directing the government of this | country for another quarter of a century, and would deserve to have none. This is why, after all the bluster and bribery that the silver advocates can bring to bear the with the House in voting for repeal. on the situation, Senate will unite BUSINESS AT THE WEST. THE passing of the Northern Pacitic Rail road Company into the hands of a re de cline in railway earnings and in general ceiver calls attention to the marked business in the States west of the Missouri River. The so-called transcontinental lines report a larger falling-off in traffic than is shown by companies east of Chicago. The losses reported by the Union Pacitie for June will be exceeded, it is said, in the July statement. traftic the roads shown Temporarily at least, the States named falling in has on all a away from last Merchants in that tion are alive to this fact, for in Sei several instances we are informed that pools in In these pools the shopkeepers of a town or small goods have been agreed upon. city agree not to order goods from the East till the total stock of the town is exhaust | ed. In this way a trader who is out of nails | amount or calicoes will apply to a neighboring storekeeper for those articles with which to supply his customers. The agreement resembles the clearing-house system under which the banks with a surplus reserve assist their weaker brethren for the time. The effect of such agreements is of course for the moment to reduce still further the of brings the end in sight, after which, railway shipments; yet it under improved conditions, a more than normal movement of merchandise will set in The movement regarding the also peculiar situation of the affects the cTops territory in question, Even allowing for the unusual surplus of wheat carried over, we shall be short perhaps 150,000, bushels as compared with last vear; vet the cash price of grain does not reflect th statistical position. Farmers who hav formed themselves will try to arrange their sales so as not to sacrifice their whea In ordinary times no planning would b needed, for speculators would borrow fr the banks, and, by bidding against eac other, would raise the price of cash wheat at harvest toa 1 ~-e n eqguivaient of the ticipated scarcity of ear of the silver stan machinery of ex nh itor overcoming issue of certified +> 13] for in some way, though at heavy sacri tice, the crops must be moved Yet it is well to remark regarding the bank check plan that only the capitalists who have money in bank will be able to avail themselves of it, whereas formerly other brokers, greatly outnumbering the capi talists, could, by borrowing from the banks, aid the farmer in getting the hig est cash price for his grain. In short, wit! the most favorable makeshifts for movu the crops, the producers all over the cour try, by supporting, or not opposing, tl Sherman Act, have given themselves over to the ‘‘ bloated capitalist,” and hav f those prived themselves of the assistance who may believe in higher prices for breadstutls, but who cannot obtain the | credit assistance which in other years was theirs for the asking } This state of things will no doubt pre ys from eld to Miuneapolis or Chicago—tl Western Av is and will vent an early movement of the ere the fi very shipments upon which the This del ie roads usually count be a factor in the shrinkage in earnings which the trans Chicago lines are now showing or may hereafter report Well informed persons declare that farmers are financially able to hold their wheat After two vears of fine crops at good prices the Western producer is ina much better condition than his neighber the manufacturer. It is said that the money in lowa savings banks is largely that of farmers; and the general farming situa tion is the same in other States The grain-producer may be expected, there fore, to ship his product much n slow ly than in previous years, with a corre sponding effect upon railways of a smaller trattic now and a better ein cra I tie future It is not a caus wonder that the younger States should feel the business depression ‘acutely Their growth has been phenomenal, but their citizens have forgotten that their prosperity was de pendent upon credit. Faith in t pro titableness of their mines and fields wis he ground of the Eastern or foreign in vestment of capital, without which such ievelopment would have been impossible The prosperity of the Wcst was owing en tirely to the expansion of our system of credit tinanciering. Nodoubt Eastern goods were sold there on too long time, and in general the credit svstem may have been carried too far, but nevertheless the confi- lence of both lender and borrower was found to be generally justified. As a single nstance the railway first mentioned, the Northern Pacitic, may be taken. For the year ending June 30, 1857, its gross earn- ings were upwards of $12,000,000. For the vear ISY1 those earnings exceeded £25, 000, - MW). four of their allowed a doubling of receipts within Regardless of the the Western system of credits to be attacked vears basis prosperity, States the whole until generai distrust ensued. It is a rule in commercial affairs that new enterprises are the first to be affected in a panic;

Page 12

132 The Nation. [Vol. 57, No. 146 so we need not be surprised that general business there felt the effects first and heaviest. The situation at the West points a clear moral: that for their own interests and to hasten a return to their former abounding prosperity, the newer States should take prompt steps to restore public confidence in the standard of value. THE COLUMBIAN EXPOSITION—IV. THE ENSEMBLE. Curcago, July, 1893. AN article in the Revue Bleue last winter contained an account of the buildings of the Chicago Fair as they then appeared. The writer was strongly impressed by the general effect of what is now called the Court of Honor and the design of the buildings surrounding it. His ad- miration, indeed, amounted to an enthusiasm. There was a trace of proper French surprise that a combination so artistic should have been made at that distance from Paris, but he re- membered that much was still to be done. The architects had succeeded in grouping their masses harmoniously, and the buildings were in themselves imposing. He was sure, how- ever, that much of the fine effect then obtained would be lost when each edifice should be dis- figured by the coarse and tasteless decoration sure to be lavished upon it. One smiled at the flavor of cockneyism that is rarely absent from the Parisian judgment, but, just the same, one shared the critic’s distrust as to those ‘‘ finish- ing touches.” Favorable testimony came from all sidesand from competent witnesses, and yet our incredulity was never entirely dissipated. We owned to ourselves that an equal weight of testimony would have secured unclouded belief had the Fair been in Paris, but, as it was in Chicago, an attitude of reserve was no more than natural. Our first view from within the grounds was when, from the terminal station of the Illinois Central Railway at the Fair, we passed through the Administration Building to the terrace from which is seen the whole Court of Honor. We remarked by the way that the Administra- tion Building was much more imposing in real- ity than in the pictures of it we had seen. The colonnade under the dome especially was more stately and had more relief than they had led us to expect. Nor had we looked for anything so majestic in size. As to the interior decora- tions, seen in crossing under the dome, they were on a higher level both as to conception and execution than the Parisian critic had fore- seen. But what would he have said on coming out into the Court of Honor, now that an abun- dant scheme of decoration supplements the dig- nity of the masses in general? What could he have said, except that he might have trusted those capable of conceiving such a whole to look well after its component parts? As far as we know, there exist no two opinions as to this stupendous spectacle. In detail, as in mass and grouping, it compels admiration from every one, and the scale upon which it is car- ried out puts it in the very front rank of simi- lar displays. As a complete departure from the conventional exhibition architecture—the endless variations made upon the original Crys- tal Palace and that of the Champs-Elys¢es—it is not quite unprecedented. At Amsterdam a few years ago the great feature of the Inter- national Fair was the show of products from Java, and the architect of the main building thought fit to give a facade made up from Ja- vanese motives. The result was a great suc- cess, though, as far as we know, it did not at- tract the attention it deserved. It was tho- roughly exotic. Amidst the sober quaintness of Amsterdam, its snowy mass was like a pal- ace in a dream, and yet it was quite appropri- ate to the exhibition it prefaced. It was more original than the setting at Chicago; we had almost said it was more appropriate, but we remembered that if Javanese architecture fits a Javanese show, so does Roman architecture, and its successor of the Renaissance, fit a dis- play of the products and industries of the civilized world. In respect of the choice of an architectural setting for the Fair, it is a great good fortune that the Gothic style, proposed and favored by one, at least, of the architects concerned, was not fixed upon eventually. This we say not less as admirers of medieval art than as friends of what is meet and suitable. It might be said that Chicago is not even the second to break away from the conventional world’s-fair style, since some of the buildings of the last great show in Paris were architec- tural feats of a high order. In originality of conception, in bold ‘‘ modernity,” Chicago can show nothing to compete with the combination of the Eiffel Tower and the dome of the Ma- chinery Hall, unless it be an originality to turn back so completely to types consecrated by age. However that may be, Amsterdam could boast of but one palace, unsupported by any group in harmony with it; and, whatever be the relative value of the works of the French and the American artists, in themselves consi- dered, nobody can deny that Chicago has, in the ensemble of the Court of Honor, accom- plished something unique and splendid, prob- ably beyond all feats of decorative architec- ture of our time. There are two points of view from which we especially loved to gaze at this fine scenic dis- play. From the terrace in front of the Ad- ministration Building the eye looks straight down the long basin of water between the Agricultural Hall and that of Manufactures and Liberal Arts to the peristyle with the gild- ed statue of the Republic in front and the blue of the lake seen between the columns. The sheet of water is vast, the main lines of the surrounding buildings are simple, the general effect is indescribably majestic, though, at the same time, made gay by the gondolas and launches that enliven the basin, and the per- haps too manifold flapping of flags on the roof edges. It is from here that the Manufactures Building is seen to advantage. It is the huge roof, with its really noble lines, which gives it character and goes far to redeem the common- place, railway-station look it has when one sees it from near at hand _ It is splendid in mass, but poor in detail, apart from the decorative paintings, some of which are beautiful, but which do not count in any general view of the hall. The second point is on the north-side bridge looking across the basin toward the south canal, where the end of the Machinery Building con- fronts that of Agriculture, and the two are connected, in the background, by a colonnade of exceedingly elegant design. This view is much smaller than the first, and, instead of the breadth and simplicity of that, we have a charming richness, picturesqueness, and grace. The two main buildings are perhaps the most successful compositions of their class at the Fair. The ‘‘ Palace of Mechanic Arts” is a de lightfully rococo combination of belfries and domes with colonnades and porticoes, grouped by a master hand. The Agricultural Hall, which, in the form of its dome and various other features, invites comparison with the Art Building, is in some respects better than that, and inferior to it only in disposition and subordination of masses. It is especially superior in force, variety, and originality of design. This group is enriched by a bridge, by rostral columns, an obelisk and statues, forming alto- gether a composition as unrestrainedly splendid as the dream of a theatrical decorator—one of the things that seem ‘‘too good to be true.” It isso bright and exuberant that it strikes one as foreign to the practical American genius, and, we fancy, elicits less general admiration than many less clever but more sober combina- tions. And yet its festal character is in no- wise exaggerated; there are salient points enough to give animation, gayety even, to the scene, but not enough to be confusing. And just here we would touch upon what, to us, isa defect in the great beauty of this court. Let any one look at the charming Mac- Monnies fountain from one side, and at a little distance, and he will see what we mean. Ina line with one part or another of the fountain —itself rich in figures—are two Corinthian columns with an eagle atop of each, two ros- tral columns, four stags, all white and all seen against a white background. The effect is bewildering. The multiplicity of forms, all in the same color, makes it difficult to see any one of them in proper relief, and all to- gether make an_ inextricable confusion. Neither of the peoples whose architecture has suggested all the features of this court would have made such a mistake. Gold and bronze and color would have been employed, not in quantities sufficient to take away the general whiteness of tone, but so that each member of the group would have stood out in needed relief. The delicate tint on the walls of the Agricultural Building adds much to the value of the colonnade in front of it; and, though we frequently heard regret expressed that Mr. French’s statue of the Republic had not been left in its original whiteness, the ob- jectors failed to consider that, at the proper distance for seeing it, the statue would then have been scarcely discernible. Again, itseems ungrateful to quarrel with the abundance of a feast, but six rostral columns exactly alike, and each bearing at the top the same Neptune, give a machine-like character to the decorations, all the more noticeable as the standard of excellence in them is so high. So there are at least six of those stags and four buffaloes; and the fine farm horses and oxen which embellish the landings on the great basin, are repeated on those of the south canal, ete., etc. Of course the temporary nature of the entire spectacle is the excuse for these inartistic econo- mies in profusion. It is, however, due to the administration to add that our surprise is less that such repetitions should have been indulg- ed in than that they should be so few as to be easily lost sight of in the variety, the richness, and, above all, the high level of the work in general. Were the often-expressed wish to be realized, and these buildings made permanent in marble, it would not be necessary to add all the decorative surroundings at once, but then it would be imperative that each one should be unique. This wish, that. the beauty of the Court of Honor might be perpetuated, is the natural expression of the admiration it excites. It is also the protest of the imagination against the ugliness of our cities, their general sacrifice of the aspirations of the educated minority to the supposed wants of the majority; and it is de- light in a generous offering to our inner desire for a lovelier setting to our lives. The Chicago people are naturally proud of the splendid work 4 ; ie 3 q £

Page 13

| ' | Aug. 24, 1893] they have called into existence, and the com parison they invite with the last Exhibition in Paris is excusable. In one way this compari- son may be:made more wholesome than plea sant, and that is in thinking, as is inevitable, of the surroundings of each. The Paris Exhibi- tion was a jewel in an equally wonderful set- ting. It was not out of place in, but was worthy of, what is still the most beautiful city in the world. There was no transition from one to the other—one was only the complement of the other. At Chicago you go out of the Fair grounds into a hideous suburb, whence a train whirls you away to a grimy, workaday city. Whatever harmony there may be be- tween Chicago and its superb creation is an in- ner and moral We willingly believe, however, that this harmony is real, and is an earnest of what the Chicago of the future is to be. Quitting the Court of what is peculiar to the Chicago Exhibition—its glory, its clou—for a fair like another; a very big one, it is true, but still a fair such as we have seen only too often. The waterways are here also, and serve to enliven the general commonplace. The north end of the lagoon, surrounded with its ‘‘samples” of architecture, is a picturesque enough higgledy-piggledy. It is a pity, however, that the south end of the Wooded Island could not have been a formal arrangement of landscape gardening, in har- mony with the architectural group about it, consisting of the Manufactures, Electricity, Mining, and Transportation Buildings. No doubt the accomplished artist who laid out the island saw clearly enough how much this part one, Honor, one leaves of the basin would have gained by such treat- | That he did not act upon his knowledge | is a sufficient proof that the difficulties in the | ment. way were not to be overcome. The Transportation Building is a revelation as to what the Fair has escaped by adopt- ing Renaissance architecture and prevailing | whiteness. Close at hand the building is an entertaining salad of styles. The so-called ‘“*Golden Doorway” successful enough fusion of Romanesque, Arabic, and East In- dian motives. The arcades of the sides are Roman in plan with columns of original form. Is a In the spandrils are very modern Byzantine | | | | | angels, reminding one of Sarah Bernhardt as | Theodora—altogether, a pleasant building to | pass the time with; but seen at a distance, all | these details fail of effect, and the epithet ~*shabby ” applied to it by the London Times seems justified. We are now in the region of conventional exhibition architecture, where there is much that is good with some that is bad. the Transportation Building, or nearly so, is the horticultural display. is naturally in the variety of greenhouse which has become the exhibition style. But it has been treated well in the spirit of much modern French work. The dome, from any point of view, is pleasing, and the whole merits more praise than it has got thus far, unlike the Art Building, which has got rather more than it merits. Not that this last is not deserving of praise, and of high praise, but scarcely of such as we have heard givenit. At least. in its present state, its classicality is suggestive of the cold Munich sort; and parts, as, for in stance, the attic and pediment over the main entrance, are distinctly poor. Its dome, t of beautiful form, would be improved by mor: vigor in its details. The pediments about it look thin, the decoration about the drum to delicate for a place so far from the eye of the 4 observer. The sister dome on the Agricultur Next to | The housing of this The Building is more fortunate in these respects By the Nation. way, the circle of turkevcecks that does duty for the conventional Greek honey suckle as a crest to the drum, is at once origi \ similarly happy inspiration made the architect of the Fisheries nal, appropriate, and pleasing Building use fishes and aquatic plants and animals for the ornamented mould ings, the capitals and shafts of his columns many of which are full of spirit and grace By a mistake of the workmen, who copied the ornamentation on the columns only so far as it was shown in the drawings furnished then, the lower part of the shafts is quite plain. We cannot help thinking the blunder a happy one, as by it a certain expression of freshness, of a first impulse, that creased marks the work is in- Among the State buildings there are two | those which attempted nothing but a pleasing dis play of the most rustic sorts that are especially interesting forms of construction and decoration—these at least show something of the products of the States and the ideas of their people—and those which reproduce, by copy or suggestion, some historical monument The others are merely more or less successful architectural compositions without any pecu liar appropriateness. Of the foreign buildings, the German is the most important. It is a very characteristic example of the style which the Germans call their Renaissance, very effective in its way and picturesque—but as for their Renaissance, ** Bless thee, Bottom! bless thee! thou art translated!” Had they called it Wiedergeburt, it would have been all right Such as it was, however, it had a beauty and a character of its own; which is more than can j be said for their structure in the Liberal Arts | Building—as commonplace a copy of Italian motives as could well be produced. It natu rally provokes comparison with the French pavilion near it, a florid composition, such as the occasion and place warrant, and vigorous, well adapted to its purpose, and thoroughly artistic In one respect the impression of beauty gene- rally received from the Fair inspires uneasi ness. It is not unreasonable to fear lest the Court of- Honor mark the beginning of an out- break of white over the land, which will make the vagaries of Queen Anne and the colonial style appear the good sense and good taste. Ror ture less than that of the Georgi classicality height of lan architec era lends itself to performances in pine boards and white paint. But we may hope that the Fair will bear good fruit as i well as bad. and its final lesson will be oue of reserve and re American builders that simplicity and nament remarkable rather for quality than for finement If good proportion, quantity, are worth more as factors of perma nent suce t turesqut wgias iels, dormers, ete., ete., that they now delight the Fair will have accomplished a work of last ing value S. K THE Po! \ND THE SCHOOLS Rome. July 27. 188 Ir is not s sing that t —" f+ Vatican in: at to ft > ols Ar i should y e Those W are not ate t rst decrees of R rst . To the ast degrees 1 Ss initiated except thos =" . ver to take exceptior jn elek te ¢ } I ‘ clarati ftruth as 1 ewiatt Vatica except tl ils, t s res ts t et and in spite of what is currently believed the Vatican has no official orga Informa tien is furnished t held never to 4 the views certain papers which are iblish anvthing contrary t of the Vatican, but which are nev admitted to be official further than direct munications are concerned. The matters which there is no declaration of dogma Papal decision (which is not reckoned as dog ma, but as no longer subject to dispute , ar like the laws of nature, subject to different terpretation, but, like those laws, more or less authorit© vely interpreted; and as Nature has | her law-readers, so the matters thus left outsid of the decisions of the Church are read wit authority which approaches the Papal, mor less On all the questions thus left in limbo, t Rev. Father Brandi, famous Jesuit cont: Sialist, is recognized as the bighest authority and he is always put forward t attacks on the doctrine of the Church, and has the fullest access to the documents and persons giving light on the respective subjects. He is th authoritative interpreter, to whom all outsid the circle of the Bishops, highest illumination, such as rehbishops, Monsignere of the vart ous degrees below Cardinal, give respectful ad hesion. He was put forward to reply to the articles in the Contempora Re ~, and has now published, in the Cirifa Cea of the order in the United States, headed his dictum on the school question \ New Pontifi cal Contirmation of the Parochial Schools in America.” It is followed by the text of Pope's letter to Cardinal Gibbons ‘on the | troversy about the public and parochial schools of the United States.” which the Rev. Fath j says ‘‘has been received with grateful mind , and applause by all who were and are, here Rome] or elsewhere, strenuous defenders of a1 education strictiv Cathol f t Catho vouth in Catholic schools. Nor wuld it b otherwise, it being known to all that suct an educ mm depends great part the tru and genuine well-t t only of individuals but also of the family, the State. and tl Chureh I will endeavor to give as clear an idea of the arti which the Rev. Father has pub lished as the original permits, and where there is a passage in the original which seems subject to any question, I will render it literal Iv. and in the rest will give such a résumé as will not ‘‘ betray” the author. For him I have respect one can have for a man who ly and with his whole soul sustains the mast uncompromising adherence to the rigid doctrine of the Church as it is defined by the Papal bulls and rescripts, defiant of all the temporizing and « mpromising weaknesses which maintain the nominal boundaries of the Catholic Roman Church at the cost of its dis- Father ho patience with the Catholics who question Brandi bas pune and compactness he recognizes nothing but the most implicit a ptance of the authority of the Church, and w none of the modern liberalization of it iheretore be says (ur readers are not ignorant how the bitter struggle for the existence of the Catholi school, and the principles on which it is founded, has been in the United States, especially dut last two vVears, sustained not only against the attacks of the societies which there not less than in Europe, ani mated by a Satani fury, do everything to pervert the education of the youth, but also and chiefly against certain laicizing Catholics, wi under the pretence of patriotism the secret reach

Page 14

134 The Nation. [Vol. 57, No. 1469 ing a friendly hand to the enemies of the Church, seem to desire to subordinate in the school the religious good to the civil good, and fully approve, against the decrees of the Popes and the prescriptions of the Plenary Council of Baltimore, such a method of educating the youth as should be divided from the Catho- lie faith and from the authority of the Church.” That there exists in the United States such a party among the Catholics he considers a grave and painful fact, and he stigmatizes the Western Watchman as a sacrilegious assailant of the true doctrines of the Church, associat- ing with it the Colorado Catholic of Denver, the Catholic Union and Times of Buffalo, the Northwestern Chronicle of St. Paul, the Free- man’s Journal of New York, and the Catholic Times of Philadelphia. To put a stop to the propaganda of the pernicious principles of these pseudo-Catholics, the Father undertakes to comment on the letter of the Pope to which re- ference has been made; and the readers of the Nation may take my assurance, as of one in the most friendly and (as far as is possible to a non-Catholic) confidential relations with some of the most liberal and clear-headed prelates in residence here, that what Father Brandi says is what the Vatican means, and what must be accepted by all who desire to re- main in the grace of the Church. The letter, he shows, must be accepted as the sole and in- discussable rule by which all Catholics must be guided on the question involved, being, not the teaching, either theoretical or practical, of a prelate or private teacher, but the decision of the head of the Church, intended to put an end to the dissensions and disputes which have existed on the subject of the schools. These are the authoritative words of the Pontiff: ‘For the rest, in order that there may re- main in the future no reason for doubt or clash of opinions in a matter of so great gravity, as We have already declared in our letter ad- dressed on the 23d of May of the past year to the venerable brethren, the Archbishop and Bishops of the Ecclesiastical Province of New York, so again, as far as is necessary, We de- clare that the decrees established according to the rules given by the Holy See through the Councils of Baltimore, in regard to the paro- chial schools, as well as all that the Roman Pontiffs, either directly or through the Sacred Congregations, have prescribed on the same subject, are to be constantly observed.” Follows a résumé of the history of the Coun- cils of Baltimore, and quotations from their decrees, insisting on the retention in the hands of the clergy of the education of the Catholic youth. ‘‘We exhort the Bishops,” says the first Council, ‘‘ and, in view of the grave evils which habitually proceed from a not well- instructed youth, we conjure them by God's bowels of mercy, to endeavor to found in their respective dioceses schools annexed to each church.” This was confirmed by the second Council, which further urged that not only the religious, but the literary, education of the Catholic youth should be conducted by the clergy. The third Council, affirming what had been said by the prior ones, adds that ‘‘ each parochial church should have, in the space of two years from the promulgation of the pre- sent decree, its own school where it does not already exist, and keep it up perpetually, un- less for serious reasons the Bishop considers that a delay may be accorded.” And further, it adds that a priest who neglects to obey this rule deserves to be sent away from his parish. To these decrees of the Councils, Brandi addsa digest of the allocutions and letters of Pius IX. and Leo XIII. confirming this rigid view of the question, concluding with an extract from the Encyclical Sapienticee christiane, and one from the letter of the past year to the Arch- bishop and Bishops of New York. ‘Here the Holy Father declares that his de- cision, like that of the whole episcopacy, ‘ de- nies the possibility of approving the neutral schools—t. e., those without religion—and as- serts the necessity of confessional schools in which the youth shall be instructed in religion by those whom the Bishops shall have judged fit for that office.’ After this last solemn de- claration of the Holy Father in favor of the parochial schools and the decrees of the Coun- cils of Baltimore, illustrated by the documents to which he refers and which we have de- sired to quote at length, we believe that, ac- cording to the expressed desire of the Pontiff himself, all controversy on this subject ought to cease. In another of our works published apropos of the decree of the Holy Congregation of the Propaganda, we concluded with the words of St. Augustine, ‘Jam de hac causa duo Consilia missa sunt ad Sedem Apostoli- cam: inde etiam rescripta venerunt. Causa finita est.’ We now add the remainder of the sentence, which we then omitted: ‘Utinam aliquando finiatur error.’ ” Father Brandi is right, and those who live in Rome and are daily witnesses of the struggle going on between the Church and its opponents are perfectly aware that there is no compro- mise possible and no ‘‘liberalizing” of the Roman Catholic Church, in the way that so many non-Catholics and lukewarm Catholics are desirous of seeing it liberalized. The very foundation of the organization is the principle of authority of the Holy See, and Father Bran- di sees, as the Pope sees, that any weakening of this authority is simply the beginning of a schism. Private judgment no longer exists on any matter on which the Church has spoken, and it must be remembered that it is not merely the opinion of the person who holds the papacy in hand, but the deliberations of the highest authorities of the Church, as expressed in its conclaves and councils, of which he is the mouthpiece. We who maintain as the vital element of human progress the absolute liberty of human intelligence and the inherent wisdom of doubt, consider as a theological fiction the authority of the papacy and the dogmas of the Church, under whatever form; but, if the Church is to stund, it must stand by authority, and every member who doubts and claims liberty of judgment isan illogical Catholic and an enemy to the Church, and it is far better for it that he should be excised from it than that he should air his liberalism in it; that the Church should be diminished in numbers rather than weakened by want of cohesion and homo- geneity. This is the feeling of the great body of the churchmen who live near the head of the Church, and it is the logical conclusion of Ro- man Catholic doctrine. X. NAPOLEON, AND NO END. PaRIs, August 3, 1893. WHat may be called the Napoleonic revival continues, and I can offer as a proof the great success obtained by two works of M. Henry Houssaye, ‘1814’ and ‘1815.’ M. Henry Hous- saye is the son of Arséne Houssaye, well known in the literary circles of Paris, who was for a few years Administrator of the French Thea- tre at the end of the Second Empire. M. Henry Houssaye devoted himself in his youth to the study of Greek; he speaks modern Greek; he wrote a ‘ History of Alcibiades and of the Athenian Republic from the Death of Pericies to the Period of the Thirty Tyrants,’ and several other works on the Hellenic world. Finding, probably, that Hellenism has re- tained but few adepts in our day, he turned himself to modern times; he wrote a short ac- count of the campaign of France in 1870, and afterwards betook himself to the study of the downfail of Napoleon. He worked in the mo- dern fashion, trying to forget all that had been written on the subject, and searching for ori- ginal documents in the rich archives of our Foreign Office and the unexplored archives of our War Department. He says in a note tohis last volume that 200,000 letters and reports came under his eyes. According to the modern historical fashion, he never advances a fact without mentioning in a small-print note the document or documents relative to this fact. The method has been justly criticised, not in itself, for the historian cannot consult too many documents, but in its excesses, when the historian merely counts the documents without criticising and weighing them. An innumera- ble mass of small strokes do not make a pic- ture; the historian need not take us into the re- cesses of his library and the recesses of his own mind. The great public is satisfied if it is in- terested, and the interest suffers somewhat by perpetual annotations and references. It must be confessed, however, that M. Henry Houssaye has used his documents artfully, and has thrown as much as he could into notes which the general public may read or not; and he has not overburdened himself in his narrative. In fact, I confess having read his ‘1815’ as ra- pidly as I could have read the most thrilling novel. Yet is it not fiction, this extraordinary and miraculous ‘vol de laigle” of Napoleon from the island of Elba to the Tuileries’ There is nothing in the history of the world more ro- mantic, nothing which has so much the charac- ter of an epopee. The return from Elba as- sumed the character of a legend almost imme- diately after having marked its date in history. It is eminently dramatic. It has painted itself in the popular imagination in a succession of tableaus such as remain for ever engraved on the mind. First we have the departure from Elba, the small flotilla carrying ‘‘Cesar and his for- tune”; Napoleon on the deck of the Inconstanf, watching the English and French cruisers, with his battalion of Elba, composed chiefly of old grenadiers. ‘Towards four o’clock, the Jnconstant had rounded Cape Corse, when a war-ship was sig- nalled, coming right on her. The Emperor gave the order to clear for action. ‘ Let her approach,’ said he, ‘and if she attacks us, we will board her.’ After a few moments Tail- lade [the captain] recognized the brig Zéphyr, which he had often met in this part of the Mediterranean, and which was commanded by one of his old comrades, Capt. Andrieux. The Emperor, who wished to avoid a fight, ordered the grenadiers to take off their high bear-skins and to lie on the deck. The two brigs passed each other. Accustomed to see in these waters the flag of Elba, Capt. Andrieux showed no hostile disposition. By the Empe- ror’s order Taillade took the speaking-trumpet and hailed the commander of the Zéphyr. ‘Where are you going ’’ asked Taillade, re- peating the words of Napoleon. ‘To Leghorn: and you’’ ‘To Genoa. Have you any com- missions?’ ‘No. And how is the great man ?’ ‘Very well.’ And the two ships left each other.” Second tableau: Theships of the little flotilla had met in the deserted Golfe-Jouan. Napo- leon had taken his column, composed of about a thousand men, directly to the mountains, thus avoiding the royalist region of Provence, and striking for Dauphiny. The details of his march are most interesting, but let us come at once to the critical point, to his first meeting with troops sent against him. This took place in a narrow passage, on the road to Grenoble, at Laffrey. Commander Delessart had been sent to dispute the passage of Laffrey witha bat-

Page 15

Aug. 24, 1893]

talion of the line and a company of engineers. He had with him Capt. Randon, an aide-de- camp of Gen. Marchand, who commanded at Grenoble. ‘‘The Commander recognized Napo- | leon by his gray redingote and saw him dis- mount. The Emperor seemed very much agi- tated. He walked on the road, then stopped and looked at the battalion with his glass.” There was a moment of uncertainty, of anxiety: | would the soldiers sent against Napoleon fire on him, his soldiers of the Old Guard, his Polish lancers ? The captain of artillery, Raoul, aide- de-camp of Napoleon, first rode alone towards the front of the battalion, and said: ‘‘ The Em- peror is going to march on you. If you fire, he will be the first struck. You will answer for it before France.” Mute and motionless like statues, the soldiers seemed insensible. The Polish lancers rode on, and Delessart, seeing his men hesitating, ordered the retreat; he was almost immediately ashamed of retreating, and, the lancers having had the order not to charge and returned towards Napoleon, Deles- sart stopped and turned the head of his bat- | talion again towards Napoleon. ‘*Then the Emperor ordered Col. Mallet to have all his men keep their guns under their left arm. Mallet having objected that it would | be dangerous to come thus disarmed before a troop whose disposition seemed uncertain, the Emperor said: *Mallet, do as I say.’ And, alone, before his old chasseurs, bearing their guns low, he marched towards the Fifth of the line. ‘Tbere he is. Fire! screamed Capt. Ran- don, beside himself.” The unfortunate soldiers were livid, their legs shook, their guns trembled in their hands. When he was within pistol-shot, Napoleon stopped. ‘¢*Soldiers of the Fifth,’ said he with a strong and calm voice, ‘know me again.’ Then, advancing two or three steps more and opening his redingote, ‘If there is among you a man who wants to kill his Emperor, he can do it. Loffer myself to him.’ The trial was too great for soldiers. lEmpereur!’ so long repressed, burst forth. The ranks were broken; the white cockades covered the road. selves towards their Emperor, surrounded him, knelt before him, and touched, like idolaters, his boots, his sword, his redingote.” Third tableau: Napoleon has gone on, he has The Nation. lowed by a thousand horsemen of all arms and of all grades, riding in disorder, brandishing their swortis and vociferating ‘ Vive TEmpe reur |" The door of the carriage is opened, Napoleon seized, torn from it, carmed from arm to arm to the vestibule, where other arms drag him to the steps of the staircase. All these men are attacked by a furious deli- rium. . ‘In God's name,’ screams Cau- laincourt to La Valette, ‘put yourself in | front of him! La Valette braces himself | against the avalanche and walks backwards, preceding the Emperor, saying all the time, ‘Is it you, you, you’ Napoleon seems to hear nothing, to see nothing. He allows himself to | be carried on, with a fixed smile on his lips. as | if ina state of somnambulism.” M. Houssaye does not content himself with | these pictures; he has an object prove that the return from Elba was nota mere military triumph: that Napoleon was not only the idol of the army, that he was as much the idol of the people. But, on his own showing, there were distinctions to be made both in the various provinces of France and among the various classes of the people. Na poleon, after landing at Golfe-Jouan, never dared to cross the royalist parts of Provence, where he had been so ill-received and almost ill-treated when he his journey from Fontainebleau to the Island of Elba: he tra versed the Revolutionary province of Dauphi- ny, and afterwards that part of the eastern provinces of France which was most chau vinistic. It is true that all resistance in the Gironde, in Brittany, in the southern part of made France which was hostile to his enterprise. came toan end when he again in the Tuileries: the Due d Angouléme, the Duch- Was once | ess, the leaders of the Vendean party, could | make only spasmodic efforts against Napoleon Nevertheless, the middle classes were where alarmed at the consequences of the re turn of Napoleon. Though Napoleon, urged by his friends to recommence 1743, everyv- and to be | come the true successor of the men of the Ter A long cry of ‘Vive | The soldiers threw them- | | populatre—that is to say, the mob. entered Grenoble, he has entered Lyons: as he | said on landing, the eagle has fled from spire to spire to Paris. The soldiers join him wher- ever he goes; the peasants follow his ever-in- creasing army and look with amazement on him. Marshal Ney, who had forced him al- most brutally to abdicate at Fontainebleau. the year before, who had left Louis XVIIL., saying that he would bring back Napoleon in an iron cage, has gone over again to the cap- tain with whom he had fought so many bat- Let us see the end of the triumphal march. Napoleon is approaching Paris: Louis XVIII. has fled. All who composed the Im perial Court have gone, one by one, to the Tuileries—councillors of state, chamberlains, masters of ceremonies, all in their uniforms, generals, ladies in court dress, with all their diamonds, as on a great gala day. They meet each other, like ghosts, in the Salon des Mar: - chaux. pets the fleurs-de-lis have been put over the imperial bees. The ladies go on their knees with scissors, and the bees are seen Time goes on; they are all waiting: approaches; the Emperor does not come: per haps a fanatical royalist has tired at him tles. Somebody perceives that on the car again the night towards nine o'clock, a distant of horses and cries all along It comes nearer, it becomes for A post-carriage enters rapidly, fol- * At last, noise is heard the quays. midable. ror, said, *‘I will not be the king of the canaille,” he felt himself that he had with him only the army and what M. Houssaye calls the He called Carnot into his Cabinet, he appealed to the in- bought the Diens na- during the Revolution; but he counted really on the ar my, on his own genius, on the fortune of war The second volume of * 1815.’ which has not vet terests of those who had tionaur—the estates confiscated appeared, will show us the end of the terrible drama. Correspondence. A SUBSTITUTE FOR THE SHERMAN At To THE EpitorR oF THE NATION Str: The people of this country have f some time been supplying Senator Jones “and ten thousand gentlemen more” with fowl, clothing, shelter, and a few luxuries, in returt for mining and smelting silver, transporting it to Washington, and coining ntin and guarding it. The peop! yw show some signs of a disposition to quit this business by repea ing the Sherman Act: and t iplovees, naturally indignant, insist on a substitut Nothing will answer the purpose but the f lowing: ** Be it enacted, That all the silver now in the Treasury be carried hack tot West reconverted int re, and deposited again i the mines!” The malcontents w i be e1 ploved : the va f silver w lee hanced t ireadful iia t t sing that pr s cold as mot ‘ ea nd Repul he intends to | t

eans and Democrats would be fr resume their discussion of the academical question What function of the duty n eth s the price of another Incidentaliv. ¢ +} . praved desire of the millic ns who want to own silver tea-sets would be thwarted Dow t know, on the authority of an eminent writer on international law, that a cheap tea-caddy makes a cheap man As for the silver tit cates, they might, | presume, remain used on the silver, of which ‘there would a8 much in the country as ever there was \ New Beprorp, Mass PURCHASING POWER OF THE RUPE} | To THe Epirtror or THe Nation Sir: The London Economies! of J “ss as quoted by Mr. Wells in * Recent Econom | Changes,” has something to the same point as vour editorial ** Another Silver Humbug Ex ploded” “The argument has been that, owing tot! fall in silver, the gold which the seller In dian wheat here gets for his produce is worth | 25 per cent. more rupees than before, and that fas the rupee commands in India the san } amount of wheat it formerly did, the all in silver is practically equivalent to a bounty } 2O per cent. upon shipments hither But if the purchasing power of the rupee, instead of maining unchanged, has fallen YW t t..a the official record of prices w 1 = t show, then obviously the angu al } theories that have be based t fall t the ground 1 have been told by one who |! i products that the price of indig es decline of silver, and it tsa , t that the United States people los < silver-standard countries If sily ~- and the silver price of indigo rises why the cold price should g¢ t tell me where this arguiment is best where best refuted Yours tr ART? Mt ROCKVILLE NN., August 17, 18 If you mean the ‘‘common argument that the United States peo} lose il lions to silver-standard countries we have rever seen any argument on that subject, but merely the private opinion of certain persons that such losses take place. We do not know where or by whom the announcement of this opinion has been ‘* best made.’ The best refuta tion of it that we are acquainted with that of Sir David M. Barbour, the l the eui Sir although a finan adviser of Indian Government David, bimetal list, advised the d-monetization of silver of reas strong by India on account the loss°s that India sustained by of His paper on this subject was n the silver standard. laid before Parliament and published re- cently in conjunction with the other do cuments relating to the action of India on silver. —Ep. NATION THE RELIGIOUS PARLIAMENT AT CHI CAGU To THE Eprtor oF THE NATION Str: The most important and far-reaching benefits to mankind from the Columbian Ex- position are not those which are most palpable to the ordinary visitor, but those which are result from the series of 1¢ Art Institute ongresses in conjunction witb

Page 16

136 The Nation. [Vol. 57, No. 1469 the Exposition. It is only the comparatively small number of the most intellectual class of visitors who appreciate their value while in actual progress, but they are destined to exert a Widespread influence when laid open to the world by publication, and they cannot fail to develop further thought and stimulate fur- ther investigation. We have already had abundant evidence of this in the papers and discussions of leading minds of the world which have been secured by the wise fore- thought of the projectors of this feature of the Exhibition. The reports of them in the daily papers have sufficed only to show how rich a treat is in store for those who may here- after be able to study them with thoughtful care; and doubtless there are many in every community who will derive more enjoyment from their perusal than was afforded by the gorgeous material display in the various buildings and on the grounds. But of all the assemblies to be convened dur- ing the Fair, none can equal in interest, or in the opportunity it will afford for social progress, as a stepping-stone towards univer- sal brotherhood, the Religious Parliament which is to be held at the Art Institute from September 11 to September 27. Its conception was a Sublime one, and the manner in which the call has been responded to from every quarter of the globe affords sufficient evidence that the times are ripe for the effort. The grand underlying spirit which prompted it may be expressed in the words: ‘* Have we not all one Father ? Hath not one God created us *’ And in this spirit the leaders of spiritual thought of every nation and sect on earth have been asked to come toget her, and explain the doc- trines which they hold to be most favorable to such spiritual development as will be acceptable to the common Father. No such assembly has ever been seen on earth as will then be gathered in Chicago. Leading representatives of every existing faith will be present in person or contri- bute papers, animated by the wish to ascertain wherein they agree. rather than to magnify differences; recognizing the weakness of hu- man nature, and trying to help each other by drawing nearer together and seeking for good wherever it is to be found, in accordance with the words of Whittier: “So to the calmly gathered thought The innermost of truth is taught, The mystery, dimly understood, That love of God is love of good; That to be sacred is only this— Salvation from our selfishness.” It is a significant and very suggestive fact that the two most decided and uncompro- mising opponents of the Religious Parlia- ment are the Archbishop of Canterbury and the Sultan of Turkey! Neither of these magnates will admit a discussion which involves the necessity of recognizing any faith but their own, or that spiritual pro- gress is possible on any but the conventional lines prescribed by the churches of which they are the heads. Comment is needless, and per- haps it is a just cause for congratulation that such a conspicuous example has been furnished to illustrate the effect of bigotry in defeating its own object. Fortunately, neither of them can control the leading minds of their follow- ers, and noble representatives of both beliefs will take part in the discussions. How. 6.0. MINNEAPOLIS, August 7, 1893. MR To THE Eprtor or Tue NatIOoN: ALCOTT AND HIS BIOGRAPHERS. Sir: Are you quite sure that, as you say, ‘it #s a serious reproach tothe candor and accu- racy of the Memoir (Mr. Alcott’s] that the name of Joseph Cook does not appear in the index”? What is there in that particular name which accuses Dr. Harris or myself as inaccurate or uncandid if we omitted it, either in the index or the Memoir? Might we not, by possibility, have forgotten it, or have failed to see that it had any more claim to be inserted than a hundred other names in the Boston Di- rectory? But you then proceed to tell your readers that, without this name and some events that you say are connected therewith, Mr. San- born’s description of Mr. Alcott’s Western journey in 1880-1881 ‘‘conveys a wholly false impression.” And this, it further appears, is because Mr. Alcott’s success in that jour- ney (as you say) ‘‘was largely explained by the fact that he now had the evangelical endorsement behind him, given with all the more ardor because the Trinitarians claimed him. As the friend of Emerson, he had re- turned from a tour of Western lecturing with a single dollar in his pocket; as the friend and supposed convert of Joseph Cook, then at the height of his popularity, he brought back a thousand dollars.” Now, you either mean to assert that such an explanation was in fact given (though neither myself nor Dr. Harris may have heard of it), or else that the fact, as you state it, was true, whether mentioned by anybody or not. In either case, we have here a question of fact. May I then ask you to give me the evidence on which you base either of these assertions ? Although I was intimate with Mr. Alcott at the time of this journey, and long afterwards —far more intimate, I am sure, with him and his circle than you can have been—and although I should have had no objection whatever to stating your alleged faet, had it been within my knowledge, I must say that I hear of it now for the first time, and do not believe it. Per- haps you can convince me; but mere assertion will not, for I have reason to know that the fact itself was very far from your explanation. Both Mr. Alcott and several of his hearers and reporters on that journey (he was reported in print many times, and I have seen these re- ports) informed me that the apparent cause of his success (apart from his own eloquence, such as it was) was the universal desire to see the father of the ‘ Little Women,’ and to hear something concerning the circle to which the Alcott family belonged. It was never even suggested, at that time, that his brief and slight acquaintance with Mr. Cook had any- thing to do with a matter which was quite suf- ficiently explained by what I have mentioned. Nor do I suppose that either of Mr. Alcott’s biographers thought of Mr. Cook as so con- nected with the substantial facts of the re- markable career they had to describe that he came into their minds at all, except as an il- lustration of that generous courtesy which it would be too much to expect from all critics— but not, I hope, from those of the Nation. F. B. SANBORN. ConcorD, Mass., August 11, 1893. [The evidence on which our opinion was based, upon the point at issue, was that of personal observation as to the de- meanor and expressed opinions of Mr. Alcott «t some of the repeated séances he'd for him at the rooms of Joseph Cock in Boston during at least one winter; and the corresponding change of tone among the evangelica! clergy of that region. Mr. Alcott himself was wont to exult over the increased readiness of clergymen, during his later Western trips, to receive him into their pulpits and houses; and it is idle to deny that this must have made a great difference in the expenses and profits of his lecture-tours. It is to be no- ticed that the explanation now given of his increased success—the popularity of his daughter's writings—is one which, however probable, is not mentioned in the biography. To call his acquaintance with Mr. Cook ‘‘ brief and slight” simply shows that his main b‘ographer did not fol- low him up so eagerly, during that impor- tant digression of his later years, as at other more satisfactory periods; and it was precisely this omission that we re gretted. The vagaries and inconsistenc‘es of a prominent man are by no means the least instructive parts of his career. Dr. Harris sets, in our opinion, a good exam- ple to Mr. Sanborn when he admits, dur- ing the last twenty years of Mr. Alcott’s life, ‘‘a growing compromis? with things as they are”; and thi3 certainly took, at Mr. Cook’s rooms, a form very painful and disappointing to the few of Mr. Alcott’s earlier friends who were present. —Ep. NATION. | MADISON’S JOURNAL. To THE EpiTor oF THE NATION: Sir: In your note on Madison’s Journal of the Constitutional Convention in No. 1467 of the Nation, you do not distinguish between ‘The Madison Papers’ and Madison’s ‘ Journal of the Constitutional Convention.’ The latter is only part of the former, the Journal occupy- ing 939 pages in the original edition, instead of 1,624, as you state. The index is not ‘cut to suit the editor’s caprice,” but adapted to this edition, as is clearly stated on the title-page. If the writer of your review will take the pains to make comparison, he will find that every reference in the original edition to matter in the Journal is retained. The book is exactly what it claims to be, a reprint of the Journal of the Constitutional Convention, invaluable to every student of American history, and not accessible in any other single-volume edition. Yours respectfully, Cnicaao, August 19, 1893. E. H. Scort. [We must apologize for our too hasty comparison, though we cannot think that the sparation above descr.bed should be dignified by the name of ‘‘editing.”"—Ep. NATION. | EARLY USE OF THE TITLE “UNIVER Sry.” To THE EpItTOR OF THE NATION: Sm: Your correspondent, J. G. R., in the is- sue of August 17. asks for an ‘‘ American in- stance of an earlier use of the title ‘ Univer- sity’ than that of 1779 in Pennsylvania.” Harvard was first legally styled ‘‘ University ” in the clauses relating to the College in the Constitution of 1780—those clauses having been reported by a committee of the Conven- tion in October, 1779. President Edward Everett, in a paper submitted with his Report

Page 17

Aug. 24, 1893] The Nation.

for the academic year 1847-1848, after remark- ing on this fact, goes on to sayt ‘But the name, with the supposed exclusive wrerogative of a university, that of conferring 1onorary degrees, had been claimed for the College at a much earlier period. President Increase Mather, in his public address at com mencement, in 1692, after his return from England, with other remarks pertinent to the point, says: ‘The General Court of Massachu- setts, the Governor, Council, and people of New England have named and established Harvard College as a University (academia), with authority to confer degrees, in the man- ner of the English Universities.’ In the title- page to the ‘ Magnalia,’ published in 1702, the fourth book is said to be ‘An Account of the University of Cambridge in New England. ” Various early diplomas are also cited by President Everett to sustain his point that the College had been frequently regarded and spoken of as a university during the colonial period. Increase and Cotton Mather were both learned men, and ought to have had a concep- tion of a university too large to be filled by the struggling college at Cambridge which they knew. Perhaps the growth of that Col- lege into a real university should enable us to entertain hopes concerning the various ‘ uni- versities * throughout some parts of the coun- try to-day, whose diminutive faculties not only lay claim to the title, but vigorously exercise ‘*the supposed exclusive prerogative” of in- stitutions which bear it—the prerogative of conferring honorary degrees. Very respectfully, Wuitutam G. Brown, GORE HALL, CAMBRIDGE, August 19, 1893.

A HARVARD PARALLEL. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Srr: In your review of Edward Everett Hale’s ‘A New England Boyhood,’ you quote from the book the following sentences descrip- tive of a Harvard Class Day in 1830-1838: ‘*Then, on the afternoon of Class Day, 3 all the College assembled, and every other male loafer who chose to come where there was a free treat. Pails of punch, made from every spirit known to Cambridge innkeepers, were there for everybody to drink. It was a horrid orgy from end to end. . a Change in the above the words ‘* Class Day” to Commencement Day, and you have a barely exaggerated description of the day which marks the beginning and end of the present Harvard college year. Immediately after the exercises in Sanders Theatre, there is a general adjournment to the class reunions, at each one of which there is a strong rum punch, a claret punch, with little or no provision for men de sirous of less stimulating refreshments or for men of temperance principles. The graduating class, being the guest of every other, is quick to become disorderly, and the younger gradu- ates, as well as many older, are sure to over- step all bounds. A ’61 man—a regular attendant —assures me that last Commencement was the worst he has ever seen; an ‘88 man is equally positive that he can find at his class reunion only the men eager for a ‘‘free treat,” the better element going to the clubs to seek friends. Nor are some of these clubs one whit better (last year a man was thrown from the first-story window of one of them by a drunken crew). The whole is to-day a‘ horrid orgy.” inexcusable in 1838, stiil less so in 1803, and calls for immediate action on the part of th: proper authorities and the better class of graduates. Viewed in any moral light, it isa gross wrong, a constant temptation, a source of corruption, and a disgrace to an enlightened

University. And what a fearful example to take their entrance examinations Very truly yours, INKS A.B., NEW YoRK, Au vust IS. 1S0Q2 Notes. Mead & Co Pu ritan Love Letters, of John Winthrop and his wife the Rev Joseph Twichell; a translation of Maxime de la Roche terie’s ‘Life of Marie Antoinette’ ldylls,, by Jane Barlow; ‘The Girl at College,” a comparative account of in stitutions. Henry Holt & Co. have in preparation ‘The History of Mankind,’ in four volumes, by John S. Hittell, and nearly ready the ‘ History of Modern the Richard Falckenberg, and a * Minimum French Prof. Edward S Dopp, announce * Some Old Margaret, edited by ‘ Irish and American Philosophy,’ from German of Grammar and Reader,’ by Joynes Ginn & Co. will publish next month * A Field 3ook for Civil Engineers,’ by Prof. Daniel Cat hart. ‘Jamaica at Chicago’ is one of the nume rous Official publications intended to reinforce the exhibits of foreign States. It tentious narrative, partly descriptive, is an unpre partly historical, and a little repetitious, illustrated with a variety of landscape views which one regrets to find disconnected from the text. The the Hon. C. J. Ward, Hono rary Commissioner for Jamaica, manifests a humane feeling towards the black population, whose character and progressiveness he vindi He his and tranquillity writer, Lieut.-Col eates against their traducers saves general picture of prosperity since complete emancipation in 1838 by a mere allusion to the which the name of Gov ciated. * disturbances of IS64." with Eyre is indelibly asso There is a special chapter on Colum bus in Jamaica and a large map of the island The Boston Fruit Co., we read on page 4, has by its business enterprise ** saved the two most easterly parishes . from reverting, su gar being extinct, to the condition of primeval forest.” Under what is plainly a pseudonym, Zept *Fabrique de Pion Paris: Savine), attacks vigorou Raganasse, the writer of lessly the educational system of France, espe cially that portion of it \ the Ecole Normale. Th: ire defects all educational systems, whether | Eng lish, or American, or even German, 1 ? nies. That the French system is as utterly bad as Zéphyrin would have us believe, is } t credit, especially in view of the many brillant normaliens at present occupying distinguished positions in art, letters, science, and politics M. Hippolyte Parigot has given us, in his ‘Le Theatre d'Hier’ Paris: Lec?ne, Qudin & Cie.), a series of instructive studies on the dra matists of the nineteenth century. He had al ready proved his ability to | such a sub- ject in the V iluat i Vsis \ugiers life and work w vrot r tt thon f ( Lass} s | la s In t re? sent volume he reviews the work done bw A gier, Dumas fils, Pa Lat Meilha and Halevwy, Sar a Ag ral idea of his sions be f i from a perusa f tl trudu to t book wh h int ? tien. by t} wavy " re . s given to Serilx whose behalf M. Parigot also takes up t iwvels This 1 val of Scribe is be Dg ark every day,

| | and it is plain that the strong reaction whicl set undergraduates and the boys on hand to | swept him into the limbo of tempt has nearly spent itself. The main interest of M Parigot’s book, however, lies in the verv careful study of each master’s work ment, moderate, usually, in to passed upon each author, as well as on tl whole drama of the present time M. Leopold Mabilleau’s ‘Victor valuable addition to the works written about the poet. It contains very littl bi uphy just what is needed to make one grasp ints gently the analysis that follows That analy sisis of the genius of Hugo, of his gifts of + sion, Imagination, and expression It is ast mirably not to In timate the great French poet at his real wort! conducted, profoundly interesting, a missed by any one who desires to es Not the least pleasant feature of the work ts t! absence of fulsome laudation on the one hand and of mean vilification on the other. The writer

manifests an impartial spirit, and gives aniple evidence of having simply sought to ascertain and tell the truth hoA e Lat litert t Paul G sty Paris Charnent - } The distribut f parts in the great scheme the Cl ix Fa is authoritatiy vy set fortl Mr. Burnham's address before the World's Congress of Architects that city The ad iress mav be read thie i erican irchitect f August 12 1 a nt of his irneys in French Indo- China by the H GN. Curzon, M.P., in the eographica urnal for August, is very ly view of the events of the past few weeks. In describing the geographical charac teristics of this region, the writer refers to the rapid growth of the river deltas which consti tute the bulk of the French possessions. Hanoi, ¢ the capital of Tonkin, now sixty miles from the sea, was upon it in the seventh century, and Hongyen. a maritime trading port only two hundred years ago, is now thirty-five miles in the interior In these deltas, traffic is car ried on wholly by river boats. The main route through the peninsula to Saigon is by the Man which one may travel by pony, darin’s Road I palanquin, orchair. In Aunam isa very ancient

Page 18

The Nation. { Vol. 57, No. 1469 system of Government postal stations or tranis, an Annamite word, to which a body of carriers is attached. Aslight reference is made to the disputed sovereignty of the Mekong valley, Mr. Curzon asserting that the ‘‘ French in- fluence can hardly, except in a few places, be said to extend beyond the main crest of the range” which runs close to the sea through Annam. Capt. J. W. Pringle contributes an account of the Government railway survey to Victoria Nyanza, with a map. Incidentally he mentions the depressed condition of the once-dreaded Masai, occasioned by the cattle plague, which has destroyed their herds and re- duced them to a starving condition, and sug- gests that the time may have come to make practical use of their “discipline and soldier- like qualities.” In an article on the ancient trade route across Ethiopia, Mr. J. T. Bent de- scribes some interesting ruins in Abyssinia. He found the inhabitants of the ‘‘ Regio Trog- lodytica” of classic times still making the mountain caves.their granaries and refuges for themselves and their cattle when threatened by marauders. A sunshine map of the British Isles, in the Scottish Geographical Magazine for August, is especially interesting as being the first at- tempt of the kind. It is constructed from ob- servations taken at various stations during the past ten years, and exhibits the mean an- nual sunshine by graded colors. Apparently the south coast of England is the most favored part of the United Kingdom in this respect; Falmouth, near Land’s End, having 1,700 out of 4,400 hours of ‘‘ possible sunshine.” Jersey exceeds this by about 100 hours, and is the only station ‘‘ recording in any month, on the mean of the ten years, an average of even one- half of its possible duration of sunshine.” The least amount, 1,200 hours, is to be found in the mountain regions and the northwest coast of Ireland. Perhaps the most striking feature in the distribution of sunshine, writes Mr. H. N. Dickson in the article accompanying the map, is that ‘‘the greatest percentage of sun- shine is attained in districts where the annual range of temperature is least.” There is also in the magazine an interesting account of Col. Yate’s mission for the demarcation of a part of the Russo-Afghan frontier. He reports a very decided increase of prosperity in parts of the Amir’s dominions, particularly in the country about Herat, which is ‘‘ marvellously improved since 1886, much more populated and flourishing.” Prof. A. H. Sayce argues in the Asiatic Quarterly Review for July against the com- monly accepted view that the Mt. Sinai of the Old Testament times was situated in the so- called Sinaitic peninsula. The origin of this belief, he holds, can be traced to the Christian anchorites of the second century. The Red Sea of the book of Exodus he identifies with the Gulf of Akaba, and is inclined to look for Sinai ‘‘on the borders of Midian and Edom, among the ranges of Mount Seir, and in the neighborhood of the ancient sanctuary of Ka- desh-barnea, whose site at ’Ain Qadis has been rediscovered in our own day.” We are requested to say that an index to Thayer’s ‘Cases on Evidence’ has been print- ed, which will be sent free to all purchasers of the first edition of the book on application to the publisher, Charles W. Sever, Cambridge, Mass., through the dealer of whom the book was originally obtained. —The fourth and last volume of Prof. John- ston’s ‘‘ Correspondence and Public Papers of John Jay” (Putnam’s) ence more suggests the inquiry why the compilation was begun. It cannot be said that the editor has been just to either Jay or his subscribers, for he has added nothing to what was known of Jay, and he has not sought to give his readers so much as an outline of the events in Jay’s life that called out his state papers. It is remarkable, too, how many points in Jay’s career were subjects of violent controversy, that could be made ex ceedingly interesting. This volume begins with his mission to England, where he negotiated the famous treaty always associated with his name, and closes with extracts from his will. As ne- gotiator of a treaty which gave rise to a con- troversy that enlisted the ablest writers, that brought forward constitutional questions of grave import, that embarrassed the Admipis- tration and strained its relations to the Legis- lature, and that led to results which have clouded the diplomatic relations between Eng- land and America to this day, Jay was surely a subject fit for a historian, much more fora specialist. Why has not the editor given us even a glimpse of this treaty and its relations to the times ? Why has he omitted Jay’s letters to Monroe, Monroe’s caustic and officious com- ments; Jay’s letters to Hamilton, and Ran- dolph’s and Jay’s correspondence? We are compelled to repeat that this edition of Jay is more remarkable for what it does not contain than for what it reprints. While it proves the respectability of the man, the confidence he in- spired in others, and his even balance of thought, these qualities were already known. What was wanted was some light on certain points in his career of political and historical interest—his labors as a member of the Conti- nental Congress; his attitude in the negotiations of 1783; his weakness with Gardoqui, and his surrender of all points in the Treaty of 1794. In passing we must note the omission of Mrs, Jay’s letters as printed in Boogher, which are worth more than dozens of letters from non- entities, on formally uninteresting topics, that have found a place in Prof. Johnston’s work. The proof-reading, again, is carelessly done. Why John Hartley (p. 153), when the letter must refer to David Hartley’s ‘ Argument on the French Revolution’? Wenote Tankenville for Tankerville (p. 174), and a probable error in date of the Committee letter (p. 286). The gentleman referred to in the letter of Wash- ington (p. 197) was William Pickman. Hamil- ton drafted the instructions to Jay (p. 10). Of special interest are Peter Jay’s account of a po- litical meeting (p. 238), and Schuyler’s opinion of Jefferson (p. 273). —To the already numerous writings on bi- metallism by the famous German publicist and parliamentarian, Ludwig Bamberger, must now be added an interesting monograph entitled ‘ The Catchwords of the Silverites’ (‘ Die Stich- worte der Silberleute’; Berlin: Rosenbaum & Hart). Herr Bamberger looks at the problem, it is true, chiefly from the German standpoint, but his exposition of the sophistry of the bime- tallists is none the less valuable to foreigners. In Germany the chief advocates of free silver consist of the large Prussian landowners, who persist in ascribing the agrarian depression to the “accursed gold standard.” Herr Bam- berger shows that monometallism cannot af- fect one industry to tbe exclusion of others, since the problem is one of general prices, and he then disproves in detail the alleged injury to German agriculture through Russian and Indian competition as a result of the monetary situation. Incidentally he shows up the essen- tial selfishness and hypocrisy of the German silver agitators. With the other catchwords —the insufficiency of the gold supply, the fall in prices, and the sufferings of the debtor class—Herr Bamberger makes equally short work, In a striking passage in the discus- sion of the last point he shows how erro- neous it is to suppose that the debtor is necessarily or even generally the poor man. A final part of the work is devoted to the project of international bimetallism. Here again Herr Bamberger shows how politically impossible and economically unwise such an arrangement would be. The Brussels Confer- ence is handled without gloves; and our author couples his frequent not over-complimentary allusions to our own silver situation with the prediction: ‘‘ Before the six mouths [after May 1, the time set for the reconvening of the Con- ference] are up, affairs in America will, no doubt, have taken such a shape that the Ameri- cans themselves will have to set seriously to work to solve the difficulty into which their own light-headed legislation has plunged them.” Only too sadly has his prediction been fulfilled ! An appendix contains a translation of a recent essay on ‘Silver and Gold’ by the French expert, M. A. de Foville, in which a mass of statistics are collected to prove that it would be suicidal for France to reintroduce free coinage of silver. In fact, in France, as in Germany, there is not the least likelihood of any triumph for “silver.” —The subject of glacial physics in its rela- tions both to the phenomena of the Great Ice Age and to those of glaciers generally is at- tracting unusual attention among geologists at the present time, and bids fair to become with that class of investigators a bone of conten- tion only less violent than was the Darwi- nian theory of descent among biologists some thirty years ago. It cannot be said that the two subjects are in any way of equal significance, but they agree in so far as they both represent topics which have been more generally discussed and universally treated than any other in their respective sciences. English and American geological literature is especially fertile in ‘glacial ” contributions, and it has even been remarked by some of the opponents of the United States Geological Survey that its name might ap- propriately be changed to the United States Glacial Survey. It is somewhat surprising, in view of the attention thus paid to the subject by English-speaking geologists, that no com- prehensive work covering the field of glaciolo- gy should yet have appeared in the English language, and it is probably equally true of American geologists as it is (as has been re- cently asserted by a past-president of the Lon- don Geological Society) of English geologists, that a large number of them are not even ac- quainted with the one critical and authorita- tive work that has been published—Heim’s ‘Gletscherkunde.’ Like the most important general work on geology that has appeared in the last quarter of a century, Suess’s ‘ Antlitz der Erde,’ this one still awaits a translator and a publisher. —We called attention in a recent issue of the Nation to a paper by Prof. Bonney in the Geographical Journal for June, 1893, entitled, “Do Glaciers Excavate ’”’ in which it is con- tended, in opposition to the views held by the extreme glacialists, such as Ramsay, Tyndall, and Newberry, and even to those held by the average geologist, that the excavating power of the land ice-sheets, whether large or small, is all but nil. They erode, abrade, and polish, and to that limited extent modify the relief of

Page 19

Aug. od

the land-surface; but they are incapable of re- moving large obstacles placed or left in their paths, and are entirely powerless as scooping engines. This view is enunciated after a per sonal study of the principal glacial valleys of the Alps, and it is strongly corroborated by the researches of Douglas Freshfield in the Cauca sus and of Mr. W. M. Conway in the high Himalaya. If the data brought forward by these investigators be fully sustained, they vir tually deal a death blow to the theory which attributes to glacial scour the excavation of large rock (lake) basins and the fashioning of rock-bound fjords—a theory, indeed, which has always appeared unreasonable to a large body of geologists. Sir Henry Howorth, the well- known writer on the mammoth and the flood, boldly announces in a recent publication that the Great Ice Age, however it may have been represented in the region further to the South, was entirely unknown in the far North—the Arctic regions generally- where the climate has been steadily growing colder. His work, ‘The Glacial Nightmare and the Flood: a Se- cond Appeal to Common Sense from the Extra- vagance of Some Recent Geology,’ will cer tainly attract the attention of geologists, and seems likely to prove a firebrand in the coun sels of the glacialists. —A decidedly new departure in missionary reports is made in a readable pamphlet com- piled by the Rev. J. H. De Forest of Sendai, Japan. One hundred and fourteen pages are devoted to the literary, self-supporting, inde- pendent, and coOperative work, and six pages only, of names and notes, to Board’s Mission.” It is rather startling to find a missionary urging that the natives be left to do the main work of preaching, tbat the foreigner drop the money-reins and financial whip, and ‘‘pass over in bulk the money granted through joint consultation about the needs of the field.” Yet this is what Mr. De and most, or at least the best, of the American Board's missionaries are ready to do. ‘The American Forest He argues that they who insist that ‘so long as we furnish the money we shall control the work,” lose in moral influence and more than they gain. As matter of fact, the step away from the traditional method was taken ten years ago, when, on the formation of the Doshisha University, the money raised in the United States was passed over to the pow er Japanese in bulk. tinued. A committee of three in consultation represents the American Board, without re serving the right of voting. The pampblet is entitled ‘ Brief Survey of Christian Work in Japan, 1892, with special reference to the Kumi-ai Churches.’ These fifty-two Kumi-ai (associated) churches are absolutely independ- ent of all foreign control. duct the services wholly and a foreigner’s preaching is the rare exception. During the year ending March 31, 1893, more conversions and baptisms were reported in these native in- dependent churches than in all the other Pro- testant churcbes or organizations, though over thirty foreign societies now have representa- tives in Japan. The list of periodicals and books written by natives and widely circulat- ed, in addition to numerous translations, shows, by the seriousness of the themes and the abili- ty of the writers, how profoundly Christianity is leavening the nation, even while the tics of extension show curtailment over those of previous vears. The notes on Shinto, Buddh- ism, and Confucianism, philosophy, ete., This practice is still con- The natives con- statis are very valuable and set in attractive literary form, Some of the statistics summarized are:

Roman Catholics, 44.812, in 244 congregations; Greek Catholics, 20,2385, in 21 Protestants, 35,534, in 365 local churches tisms for ISY2 numbered 5.344; a52 the three folds. Whether division or union be more illustrated by % congregations ; Bap >and 3,731, in Protestants, let the figures decide The 31 Protestant organizations are reduced to 12 alliances for work Five of these alliances comprise 33,300 Christians, 1.644 to the remaining seven bodies, which represent leaving only be apportioned among twenty-fournames. During this present sum mer. over four hundred students met in a sum mer school on the modified Chautauqua plan Two of the leading men, J. T. Yokoi the Yokoi who was assassinated in ISS for ad and Ebi na, are on their way to attend the Con Religions at Chicago son of vocating toleration of Christianity gress of HOUSEKEEPING IN EUROPE 1 House-Hunter in’ Euro} By Williar Henry Bishop. New York: Harper & Bros 1SO8. Pp R70 Mr. BisHopr has given us a very agreeable book and one which will commend itself as useful to the large class interested in knowing the condi of the sort of houses that may be had, their rent and the cost of livinginthem. A family of two, Mr. Bishop and his wife, ** wanted to gratify to the full the American ‘taste for antiquity and roman tions housekeeping abroad tic tradition,” as well ag.to ** test personally the cheapness of foreign ving, of which we hear so much.” There were, at the outset, no chil dren to bring up, no purposes of special study no social aims to complicate the problem. They simply wanted to enjoy a couple of vears in Europe, just as hundreds, perhaps thousands of young households in America are always thinking of doing, and they continued their experiment for five Vears, instead of two, a tually living in France and Italy, and explor ing tentatively Spain, Algiers, and England They do not seem to have felt dra) either Switzerland or Germany, but in the countries named they examined the

ties of many places. In Fran for instance they kept house in Paris, in Villefranche, and in Nice, but they looked at habitations in D nan, Versailles, Eeouen, Blois, Orleans, Pa Nevers, Avignon, and a dozen other towns charming in as many different ways, but a at the time, for some reason or othe Appea ing desirable. There was, as We see, a certal width and, at the same time, a certau st tion of choice \ flavor of antiquity t rusticity Was what they wants th eizh borhood, and a bit of garden for tl wn: as to the sort of house they were not reas bly exacting, but the price of it must be rate, and it should be unfurnishe How many there are who w ke t the same thing, and who w be grat t Mr. Bishop for saving them so much trout a Wished-for future! Others w i have bee glad had so capable an ex} a s searches yet further. Why did he not got Senlis, for example, or Grenobl Monty lier, and why did he resist th nat te stop off at Chartres’ We wish, too, he had set at naught the foolist wl k him from going to Palen e search would have been worth s x to th gel house- hunter, even had the upsbot been that Mr. Bishop found nothing in S v suited t his wants. The ignorance and prejudice of some of his friends had well-nigh kept him away from the Riviera, where, at last, he hit

upon what he was king for. We f s that Sicily contai: as ir pearadis ‘ before engawing " t f tw have been glad he ex] . ; abexplorer as Weall ! t iptivated by a svinpe a! ‘ towns, and wea ive drea » bility of spending so. yoars them, away from t un it that elsewhere wei ~ “ \ . hope, had Mr. Bishop only st such place there was aw t t ‘ hous f \s to have in ise t - a retuge DY ! Ww Xt . ‘ these lines has i om t the bax as how ¢ ‘ ‘ warn, ind passed wi vers near to tl { s sea \ Amandiers was t vo any ’ house t TAIN t att M Bis! Is I i el his «1 Was x att is Opport s! t . iny {ti i if VANES poss i \ KF pros uN ‘ mia ite st s ‘ It throws on ornt of nl} st 1 inent Mos juaint \ i Wraith ? \ the } \ a> 1 m \ ‘ s s \ “ ‘ ‘ iv > st . t \ s e a a & Ly ” : } bn Ss ax i vea ~ bxcey . i ax av a . Ss: a il sVsic NA t ts a ta “ i he Ses ked at va i e bet weer ) wi sa 3 : em being h large tha “AS The amounts paid we i *) francs in Paris ss than he Verona, a mh at Ville incl The \ Lexy} t Was jyuit isa factory ne ’ ttle } se} ed hot in summer ! W er, and was far from the cen t1 tthe town: those, however, who know the yard } t stands a the view which mmands, will not wonder at the ch: Add to this that Verona was the place wher witl excellent market, prices Were an excep n to what our author calls the * usual price for provisions There seems to be some law by which beef is about a shilling a pound, and eggs from a shilling toa shilling and a halfa down everywhere At Verona however,

Page 20

140 The Nation. | Vol. 57, No. 1469 “eggs were but fifteen sous (cents) a dozen, milk was four sous a litre, and the best filet of beef three francs a kilo—two and one-fifth pounds—as against five francs in France.” It might have been added that such a difference is that of Italy everywhere as against France, and that it is even more marked in the case of vegetables and fruits. The teeming abundance of Italy in these products makes them of an almost phenomenal cheapness. Other things to be noted by the house-hunter are : (1) That houses are more plentiful, more commodious, and often no dearer in places where theré is active demand for them, such as Pau or Nice, than in unfrequented cities where competition does not regulate the price. This rule applies to France. In Italy, Florence seemed dearer in respect of rents than Nice, and Rome expensive like Paris. (2) That it is easier to find furnished than unfurnished houses, at least in the less visited towns; and (3) that a cheap rent is apt to be in a quarter where other people live cheaply and are unde- sirable neighbors. These last two observations are, however, often contradicted by individual experience; in semi-rural places the cheapest rent is often found combined with the best situation—that, by the way, is our remark and not Mr. Bishop’s. In the course of his explorations, the author had his eyes open to many things besides the conditions of housekeeping, and he has thrown in plenty of pleasant pages upon society in Paris, upon Algeria, and various towns in Spain, ‘upon Spanish literary men, and, in general, upon the ouside aspects of all sorts of places. We have noted many good sayings; and the judgments expressed are, as a rule, those of a man who knows the world and is superior to small prejudices. For instance, ‘‘There is a word to be said as to the rigid severity with which religious dissent was repressed in Spain, which—now that it all can’t be helped—may reconcile the amateurs of art to it. The churches were not racked to pieces by religious wars, as in all the rest of Europe, and have kept their treasures mainly unimpaired.” On the other hand, there are those who will think that he need not have taken the Félibres as seriously as they take themselves, and, on the principle of giving ‘‘the devil his due,” we should say that he has not stated as strongly as he might have done the case for Monte Carlo. It is not pleasant to seem to defend so pestilent an institution, but since people can stake there only what they actually happen to have in their pockets, and cannot engage their other belong- ings—as they could at a club—cases where the tables bring more than a temporary incon- venience to players are extremely rare. For this and for other reasons, we believe that most of the stories of suicides are apocry- phal. The book is so agreeably written, and Mr. Bishop so well knows what he is talking about, that it would be an impertinence to praise bis general correctness in details. He will pardon us, then, if we call attention to a very few slips of the pen, as, for instance, where (p. 353) he spells Emanuele with two m’s, or where (p. 37) he writes ‘arts d’agreement”; similarly (p. 343), he speaks of St. Zeno and St. Anastasia as being examples of ‘ Byzantine-Gothic,” what- ever that may be, and (p. 102) puts Verdi in- stead of Gounod as author of the music of ‘* Mireille” and original of a bust in the house of Mistral. Again, the island of Corsica (p. 279), though it may be only in mirage. is fre- quently seen, not only at Nice, but for a great distance along the Riviera. To see it distinct- ly at evening portends rain. After all this, it is pleasant to call attention to the fact that the book is furnished with a good index. “Taking the pros and cons generally, for living abroad, S——, who was no strong enthu- siast for the scheme at first, was apt to argue as follows: Vastly cheaper rent; provisions and servants’ wages not any dearer (probably, on the whole, less), a brighter, freer life in an agreeable climate (this not till after we had found the agreeable climate), and improving picturesque surroundings. “** Put in.’ she adds, ‘that if rich people, with everything to make life enjoyable at home, like so much to come over, it ought to be all the more attractive to those in moderate circumstances.—No, don’t put that in. It might bring over some with wholly different views from ours, who would get into all sorts of diffi- culties; they wouldn't want to give up the friends, local interests and duties to which tf are attached; they might not like it at all, **So I don’t put that in. Please consider it not put in.” W. G. WARD AND THE CATHOLIC RE- VIVAL. William George Ward and the Catholic Re- vival. By Wilfrid Ward, author of ‘ William George Ward and the Oxford Movement.’ Macmillan & Co. 1893. AN interest so fascinating attaches to the Ox- ford Movement, and Mr. Wilfrid Ward’s book about his father as related to that movement was such a valuable contribution to the litera- ture of the subject, that the reader coming to this second part, in which the scene is wholly changed, will hardly g@xpect to find himself so well pleased and entertained as in the former part. But he will be agreeably disappointed. If the scene is changed, some of the leading actors are the same, and the gain in novelty more than makes up for the loss of some fami- liar things. Moreover, here, as in the former book, the personality of William George Ward is always dominant. He continues to be pecu- liar and eccentric, and the exhibition of his in- tellectual powers is much more impressive as he attains ‘‘the years that bring the philoso- phic mind.” To the intelligent Protestant the book should be a lesson of modesty and for- bearance, for here, as in the case of Newman, we have one of the brightest intellects of the time entirely devoted to the Roman Catholic Church, and, to a degree beyond Newman, to the infallibility of the Pope. When, in the same book, we have such men as Mill and Mar- tineau and Huxley allowing the commanding force of Ward's mind and the rigor of his logi- cal procedure, and yet differing from him im- measurably in their conclusions, it is evident that the race is not always to the intellectually swift nor the battle to the logically strong. Ward was born in 1812; he joined Newman’s party in 1838, and straightway set about acce- lerating Newman’s tardy pace towards Rome, instigating him to the publication of ‘Tract 90,’ and supporting it with two tracts of his own, and finally, in 1844, publishing his ‘ Ideal of a Christian Churcb,’ in which he maintained that an Anglican could hold all the Roman doc- trines in good faith, and for which he was de prived of his Oxford degrees in February, 1845, the Rev. A. P. Stanley furnishing the eloquent conclusion of his speech in Convoca- tion. He made his submission to the Roman Church in the following September, a month earlier than Newman, whom his zeal continu- ally outran. At this point Mr. Wilfrid Ward again takes up the parable. His book is writ- ten in an admirable spirit. He is an ardent Romanist, but he treats all sorts of heretics and schismatics with a consideration from which many Protestant theologians and bio- graphers might learn something to the advan- tage of their own criticism and polemics. In- deed, though Ward and Newman both insisted that the Church still had the right to perse- cute, aud refrained from persecution only on grounds of expediency, it is impossible to read such a book as this without feeling that an immense change has come over the religious mind of Christendom; that an immense gain has been made for toleration when men of such widely different tendencies and opi- nions can cherish for each other such sym- pathy and admiration as are here displayed. These seem the real things, and the formal ec- clesiastical opinions very unreal in compari- son. Ward did not share the sanguine expecta tions of those converts who looked for an Angli- can stampede into the Roman Church. That amusing medizvalist, Pugin, who was shocked at finding Ward’s windows at Oxford without mullions, built him a house near St. Edmund’s Roman Catholic College, which presumably had mullions in abundance. Ward was one of those Tractarians who disappointed Newman by marrying; but though he multiplied chil- dren after the manner of the poorer clergy, his life was almost conventual. His relation to his children was one sign among many of his lack of sweet humanity. He generally heard, he said, when they were born; after that he avoided them until they were old enough to be his intellectual companions. In general his sense of blood-relationship was a sense of dif- ference and repulsion. He got along with relatives best by arranging not to be on speak- ing terms with them. Once, having so ar- ranged with his brother Henry, they met at the theatre, and, forgetting the arrangement, had a happy time together, but the next morn- ing they exchanged apologies and resumed their uncordial basis. The death of an uncle in 1849 changed Ward's condition from one of poverty to that of a large landed propyietor. What Tennyson called his ‘‘ grotesque truthfulness” found here an interesting illustration. When his uncle was sick, Ward was troubled in con- science because he was impatient for his uncle’s death. He consulted a priest about his feelings, and was told that it was quite enough that he should feel a certain regret at his uncle’s death, though he might be pleased to inherit his prop- erty. Ward protested: ‘I feel no regret whatever at the prospect.” ‘‘ Well,” said the priest, ‘‘you must have a certain wish, quite apart from other consequences, that he might be spared.” ‘Not the slightest,” was the re- joinder; ‘‘I never cared for him.” ‘* Your poor uncle has been suffering,” urged the priest; ‘‘ your spirits fall a little when you hear that he is worse.” ‘‘On the contrary, they rise,” said Ward; but he allowed that he would not do anything to hasten his uncle’s death. He was equally honest when he went to get his life insured. Asked if his general health was good, he answered, ‘ It is deplora- bly bad.” Asked if he slept well, he said, ‘I have never had a good night in my life.” By this candor he secured at thirty-eight the average terms of a man between sixty and seventy, and he reached the latter year. Mr. Wilfrid Ward divides his father’s Ro- man Catholic career into three parts—the first that of his professorship at St. Edmund's, from 1851 to 1859, during which years he was excogitating the doctrine of his ‘Nature and Grace’; the second part, from 1860 to 1870, that of his defence (as editor of the Dublin Review) of papal infallibility against Dillinger and others; the third, 1870-1882, that of his po- lemics against the experience philosophy of MARRS Ruins

Page 21

Pea iain iit sein Aug. 24, 1893] The Nation. Mill and Bain. The first of these three pe riods was the happiest of his life. But he was not cordially received at St. Edmund's, to the disadvantage of being a convert adding that of being a married layman. It seemed a paradox that he should be a teacher of young priests. Yet no clerical ideal of the priestly function was more exigent than his. Assured that there was nothing for him to do, he soon made him- self felt and needed. He found the Old Catho- lies of England in a state of ‘‘ miserable intel- lectual degradation,” not even able to express themselves correctly in the English language. Vaughan, the successor of Manning, was at first suspicious of him, but became one of his strong admirers before long. Living in a world of abstractions, Ward’s knowtedge of the mate- rial and practical side of life was next to no- thing. There is a capital instance in his first meeting with Vaughan. Vaughan, it seems, knew a beech tree when he saw it. ‘*‘ Wonder- ful man !” exclaimed Ward. ‘‘ You know all the minutic of botany.” A correspondence with Mill was one of the most interesting inci- dents of the St. Edmund’s period. It took its rise in Ward's review of Mill’s ‘ Political Eco- nomy.’ Each had a warm appreciation of the other’s intellectual power and sincerity. Their mutual relations became much more important in the third period of Ward's intellectual activ- ity, when he put forth all his strength against Mill’s doctrine of the experiential basis of all intellectual and moral ideas. It was Mill’s own feeling that his doctrine had never met with keener opposition. Some falling away from Mill was evident, and the break would doubtless have been much worse if Spencer had not brought up his reserves of inherited tendency. It is good to find Mill and Ward heartily as- sociated against Gov. Eyre, and to find Ward applauding Mill’s famous declaration, in his ‘Examination of Sir William Hamilton,’ that he would ‘“ call no being good who was not what he meant when he applied that epithet to his fellow-creatures; and that, if such a be- ing could send him to hell for not so calling him, then to hell he would go.” Already in the St. Edmund’s period Ward's eagerness for the exercise of papal authority was greatly in excess of Newman’s. Ward would have had a papal bull with his 7imes for breakfast every morning, and he hailed the decree of Immaculate Conception five years in advance with glee, while Newman was indiffer- ent and quizzical. In the interval between his resignation at St. Edmund's and his assump- tion of the Dublin Review, Ward's relations with several of his old Oxford friends, Catho- lics and Anglicans, were resumed. The pages given to Faber are some of the most interest- ing in the book. Ward did not like Faber’s preaching, and he dearly loved the theatre. Faber’s London chapel was turned into a thea- tre, and Ward, going there toa play, records two thoughts that came to him between the acts: ‘‘The first was, Last time I was in this building I heard Faber preach. The second was, How much more I am enjoying myself to- night than the last time I was here.” Faber’s mind was so much sicklied over with the pale cast of his ecclesiastical notions that it is most refreshing to find him meeting Ward’s ques- tion, ‘‘Shall I go into retreat 7” with, ‘‘ A re- treat! It would send you to hell. Go tothe play as often as you can, but don’t dream of a retreat.” There is other evidence that the Ox- ford set carried themselves somewhat more naturally and humanly after their submission to Rome than when they were on the way to her embrace. So much is said of the elephan- tine bulk and weight of Ward that we crave to know how much he are not informed, but infer something prodi actually weighed We gious from the fact that, riding for his health, he arranged to have six horses an hour, using up one every ten minutes. But this was part ly because he sat his horse as if he were him- self a bag of sand. The second period of Ward's career was less happy than the first because he was the intel lectual leader of that ‘‘insolent faction,” as Newman called it, which was clamorous for a formal declaration of the Pope's infallibility, and thus he was brought into painful confiict with Newman, for whom he had a very real Mr. Wilfrid Ward's account of the controversy is meant to be ex tremely fair, and is so with the possible excey tion of the treatment of Dollinger—an exce} tion to be expected from the radical difference of Dollinger’s position from that of Ward, with which the son is in perfect sympathy. He is very careful to distinguish Newman's po sition from that of Dollinger and the extreme French Liberals, and Ward's from that of the extreme French Ultramontanes, who practical ly identified the Pope with the Holy Ghost Their view was not incorporated in the Vatican reverence and affection. Definition, nor was Ward's so completely as he could wish, and thus he had an opportunity to subject his personal opinion to the dietum of the Church, and did so with a better grace than his habitual dogmatism would lead us to ex pect. The matter as finally settled is not so plain that a wayfaring man, though a fool, may not err therein ‘**While the decree condemned the Gallican view that the consent of the Church is neces sary to the validity of a definition, the Fathers enforced the share of the Church as represent ed by bishops, synods, and scientific theolo gians in its framing, and, by consequence, the practical necessity of their aid in its inter yretation, and in determining what was infal ibly and irreformably decreed and what was not.” The net result will probably be an infallibi lity which confines itself pretty closely to mere truism and platitude, or,as in the last pronounces ment of the Pope upon American affairs, is so ambiguous as to leave both parties disputing the possession of the field. Ward was nothing if not logical, and his interest in the matter proceeded more from his passionate eagerness for a logical conclusion than from any other source, The general reader will find n ) part of this hay tel } biography more interesting than the on the Metaphysical Society, much has been written, but nothing more in structive than these pages, which are al! the better for being rich in quoted passages fr Hutton, Huxley, Martineau, and others. who have given some account of the m able symposium of modern times about whi st remark most valued members Ward was one of the by none valued more than by those opy him most heartily. Huxley was one of thes —at the most opposite extreme, Ward than any one else in his skill in logical fence and his quickness to detect the of an opponent's argument It was Greek meeting Greek when he and Ward crossed swords. One of their encounters at the outset was characteristi Some one suggested that there should be no element of moral reproba tion in the discussions. Whereupon ** While acquiescing in this condition as a gen eral rule, 1 think it cannot be expected that Christian thinkers shall give no sign of the horror with which they would view the spread of such extreme opinions as those advocated by Mr. Huxley Then Huxley: “As Dr. 141 rhess sav that Ward has spoken, I must in f it will be verv difficult for me to conceal my feeling as to the intellectual degradation which would come of the general acceptance Ward holds cloud-bursts cleared the atmosphere, and it of such views as Ih These was generally perceived that this sort of thing would never do. With his customary frank ness, Ward told Huxley in private that he con sidered him guilty of absolutely unpardonabl - My dear Dr. Ward, ley, “if you don't mind, I answered Hux lon't Huxley error complains that the point of the anecdote has been found in his retort, and not in the evidence it affords of Ward's character at philosophical and theological Don Quixote, if it were not that our assowiations with the name of the Knight of La Mancha are mainly derived from his adventures, and not from the noble directness and simplicity of mind whi led to those misfortunes In the closing chapter there is much entet taining matter concerning Ward's personal traits, habits of reading, and so on son was his neighbor and friend, and, after his death, ing one of his most wrote a sonnet on him lines Most Ward In trees, flowers, Ward could not distinguish one tree or flower from ntain clumsy generous of all Ultramontanes, his love and knowledge of and birds he was at Ward's antipodes is because another, and hated bi noise; the nightingales especially keepir awake The lesson that came home in his last illness—**to make more all r the inevitable differences between one mind and another is the great moral lesson of bis life. His own mind wasa singularly interest ing One In its passionate hankering for aut! tative guidance on the one hand, ar ts eager ness for free speculation on tl ther T have had all the creat questions wl I s cussed with such unsparing logic and such violent rhetoric suddenly settled by a papal edict, would have been for him a dreadful blow. Yet it is difficult to understand why their authoritative solution is not as desirable as that of any question on which the Popes have, so far, infallibly ed Rooks in Manus: f \ Short Introduction to their Study and Use. With a chapter on Records. By Falconer Madan. M.A. Lov jon: Kegan Paul; New York: Scribners THIS newest volume in the series of ‘ Books About Books” has been fortunately intrusted to Mr craphy in the University of Oxford. He has Madan, Lecturer in Mediaval Palzwo succeeded in meeting the primary needs of the amateur and the student, while at the same time furnishing a lucid survey of the whole field for the general reader, in a style not more scholarly than simple and entertaining. A Singular amount of information, brought down to date, is packed away in less than 200 pages In the chapter on mate rials for writing and the form of books, Mr. Madan tells of the recent discovery of a face and back, rus; of the disuse of this material in Egypt Europe after the of the microscopic proof f open characters raright and wrong side, to papy after the tenth and in eleventh century: within a few years that the yellowish paper found especially in Greek MSS. till the fifteenth century was of linen rag like the rest, and not cotton, as the books have heretofore taught. He traces the etymology of paper, parchment, and vellum, assigns the first manufacture of pa- per outside of China to the approximate date 7) aA. D., and notes that water-marks are a

Page 22

142 purely Western invention, by the aid of which we may determine the forms of books as folio, quarto, etc. The next section is on the history of writing and (in cursory fashion) of the alpha- bet, with its summing up: ‘We see, then, that readers of the present day (outside of Germany, which, ‘‘ both in writ- ing and painting, has always stood apart, and lags behind the other nations of western Eu- rope in its development”] owe their eyesight and their comfort to (1) the revival of pure forms of an old Roman kind by Charles the Great; (2) the seemingly accidental fact that the later Ca- rolingian writing of the twelfth century was imitated by the Italian scribes of the fifteenth; (3) the happy natural selection by which print- ers chose thie revived kind of letter. Had any one of these links failed, our type would have failed to attain its undoubted excellence.” In the section on scribes and their work, Mr. Madan finds the evidence in favor of wholesale dictation very scanty, and concludes that indi- vidual copying was almost the universal prac- tice. He then deals with illuminations and the extraordinary achievements and influence of the Irish school. As landmarks we may cite the statements that a scene within a letter is not met with before the eleventh century, and a consistent true perspective not before the fif- teenth. Further: ‘‘ A theory has recently been started (but as its author has not fully worked it out, a refer- ence only is here permissible) that the Eng- lish, Irish, and French writers and illuminators of this medizval period used different stan- dards of measurement, so that their work can be tested mechanically by observing to what scale the sizes of written page or painting be- long, and that the English scribes used Roman standards, the Irish Greek, and the French their own.” The blunders of scribes are next taken up, with an examination of the sources of error in transcription and the psychological rules of correction. Here we read that, “instead of the corruptions and variations increasing in number in proportion to the distance of MSS. from the author’s time,” they actually dimi- nish as scribes grow more intelligent, or through the “‘ mixture” of MSS., which re- sults in eliminating the personal equation. The MSS. of Virgil and the Four Gospels are particularly examined, and the number of the former extant (some two to three hundred), sufficiently striking in itself, becomes doubly so when it appears that that of the Gospels alone surpasses it—of course very greatly surpasses it. The succeeding chapter is on famous libra- ries, beginning with the British Museum, which claims to have ‘the largest collection of the literature of every foreign country which ex- ists outside that country.” Here we must not overlook a passage which throws a flood of light on the recent discussion in these columns concerning books arranged with their backs to the wall : ‘““In general, the volumes were disposed much as now—that is to say, upright, and in large cases affixed to a wall, often with doors. The larger volumes at least were in many cases chained, so that they could only be used within about six feet of their proper place; and since the chain was always riveted on the fore-edge of one of the sides of a book, the back of the volume had to be thrust first into the shelf, leaving the front edge of the leaves exposed to view. Many old volumes bear a mark in ink on this front edge, and when this is the case, we may be sure that it was once chained in a library; and usually a little further investiga- tion will disclose the mark of a rivet on one of the sides.” We need not specify the famous manuscripts described after the famous libraries, nor the literary forgeries enumerated. These chapters are typically comprehensive and among the most readable in the book. Necessarily dryer ee eee [Vol. 57, No. 1469 and more special are those on the treatment and the cataloguing of MSS. and on public and private records. An appendix gives a list of public libraries containing more than 4,000 MSS. (and it is to be remarked that these ac- quisitions are by no meansstationary: ‘‘ Libra- ries which possessed 3,500 MSS. in 1882 may be estimated to contain 4,000 now”), together with a list of printed catalogues of MSS. in Euro- pean languages in the greater English libra- ries. The eight full-page plates have been very carefully chosen and are very minutely ana- lyzed in a table. One misses, in the chapter on writing, any facsimiles in the text, where they ought to be rather copious in order to make an intricate subject intelligible; but Mr. Madan has purposely yielded the floor, in this particu- lar, to Mr. Edward Maunde Thompson of the British Museum, who has just issued his ‘ Hand- book of Greek and Latin Palzography.’ Current Americanisms. By T. Baron Russell. London: Saxon & Co. 1893. OF expressions peculiar to the United States, some which once obtained have become obso- lete; of others the vogue is circumscribed, lo- cally; and, again, of others, the occurrence is frequent in everyday conversation, but is com- paratively infrequent in print. Respecting all such, how can we look for exact information except to one of ourselves? To any one else, obviously, the treatment of Americanisms in a manner at all trustworthy is little short of impossible. And even an American, unless at least conversancy with English literature of the two last centuries and also proficiency in the English dialects are predicable of him, is not equipped, otherwise than partially, to dis- course on the subject anything like satisfacto- rily. That no American who has hitherto es- sayed to handle it in detail has given token that he possessed in due measure the qualifica- tions just noted could, if it were necessary, be demonstrated copiously. Among scores of words and phrases, unquestionably neither indigenous nor inany way distinguishing us, in using which we are bid to believe that, on some ground or other, we Americanize, Mr. Bartlett, for instance, includes attitudinize, counter- jumper, coverlid, educational, excursionist, immigrant, immigration, an independent for- tune, once and again, over and above, prayer- ful, right hard, socialistic, summarize, sun- down, vegetarianism, wastage, together with aggravate, ‘ vex,’ a bright lad, elect to go, hard up, ‘short of funds,’ immediately, ‘ as soon as,’ let things slide, pull up, ‘stop,’ not to be sneezed at, staging, ‘scaffolding,’ stop at an inn, ‘stay,’ etc., and upset price. To exhibit one sample more of Mr. Bartlett’s headlong criticism, there is his significantly illustrative assertion that ‘‘ No Englishman would say ‘the boat has gone,’ ‘has come.’” Nor, to pass to Professor Schele de Vere, are his errors less numerous or less flagrant than those of Mr. Bartlett, from whom not a few of them seem to be credulously adopted. Whole hosts of his comments are typified in his remark that at once “is used in the Uni- ted States, North and South, instead of the English immediately”; and in his considering back for ago as American. Of Old England, linguistically, he knows, indeed, save at second hand, but little more than he knows, as to its people, of New England, where, he tells us, ‘* perfect social equality has prevailed from the oldest times.” Mr. Farmer’s pretentious and misleading compilation we reported on soon after its ap- pearance. In the main, it commands but slight confidence ; and of the work now under notice, though its scheme is by no means equal- ly comprehensive, we are compelled to speak in terms still more unfavorable. Personally, as is manifest, a stranger to the United States, its author announces discoveries about matters of language here whicb would certainly chance to nobody but one circumstanced like himself. For example, he has found out that ‘‘ ‘male- sheep,’ ‘ male-hogs,’ ‘ gentlemen-turkeys,’ and ‘ gentlemen-game-chickens’ belong to the natu- ral history of refined Boston only.” With something of the speech of Great Britain still to acquire, he characterizes as ‘‘ negroisms,” or “negro, originally,” the verbs conflagrate and consociate, with robustious and ruination, though the second of these words dates from the sixteenth century, and the first and fourth from the seventeenth century, and though ro- bustious was sanctioned by the Chronicler Hall, Shakespeare, Drayton, the water-poet Taylor, Milton, Thomas Fuller, Dryden, and Swift. Being, also, still to master sundry items among the initial mysteries of etymolo- logical science, he stigmatizes approbate, con- sternate, and infract, betterment and obtusity, not one of which, as he should know, had its birth in America, as ‘‘false derivatives” ; the verbs in the list being, in his view, from appro- bation, etc., by what is now called back-for- mation. Hypothecate was long ago employed by Blackstone, Sir William Jones, Burke, and H. T. Colebrooke ; and yet he produces it as an Americanism, and marks it as ‘‘ German.” His article on authoress runs: ‘ Pickering re- gards this word (and any patriotic Briton must wish to agree with him) as an Americanism. Perhaps manageress, tailoress, and similar abominations are so, likewise—a consolation devoutly to be wished”: as if Mr. Pickering, who wrote in 1816, were an authority for ‘ cur- rent Americanisms” ; as if manageress and tailoress, with which rank mayoress, prioress, and tutoress, could be rationally objected to ; and, especially, as if authoress, or its equiva- lent, had not been perfectly classical for up- wards of three hundred years. Recourse to dictionaries of recent date does not appear to have occurred to Mr. T. Baron Russell as a source of assistance. To no person, however, of a moderate amount of reading, and of ser- viceable memory, would such recourse be re- quired, in order to preclude the gross ignor- ance which is betrayed in seeing Americanisms in abolitionist, addressee, to advise with, to affection, alienage, allottee, the alone God, to ambition, appetizer, to argufy, available, and so on through the alphabet. Todwell further on a bock that teems with trumpery is needless. Besides its shortcom- ings glanced at above, it fails, for the most part, to discriminate between worn-out ex- pressions and such as are now in use, as also between those which are common to us gene- rally and those which are sectional, while it largely mistakes, as belonging to our popular speech, others which were simply creations for the nonce and have never obtained a foothold. Since we have, at last, a Dialect Society, there is reason to hope that we may look for a thoroughand scholarly investigation of Ameri- canisms, and, in course, for a dictionary of them deserving of reliance. Princeton Sketches : The Story of Nassau Hall. By George R. Wallace, Class of "91. G. P. Putnam’s Sons. 1893. 8vo, illustrated. Pp. 200, Nassau HALL once meant Princeton. The

Page 23

Aug. 24, 1893] one building was the material college. Under its roof the students lodged, studied, took their meals, worshipped, recited, and declaimed. It sheltered their literary societies as well. It still may be taken as the type of the institution. Solid, persistent, well founded, it is the centre about which a whole brood of halls cluster. Its old cupola has-become almost a spire, lead- ing further aloft with more grace if not with greater breadth; and as its long brick ‘‘en tries” (typifying, perhaps, the hard but straightforward way to a degree) have been cut up by partitions into corridors that begin at a spiral stairway and run against a dead wall, so the old courses of arts and letters, ap- proved of gods and revered by men, have been chopped up into electives that begin and end not dissimilarly. A new Princeton has grown about the old, but the old nucleus is the core and the heart. It is not too much to say that the beautiful ‘ampus and the rugged background in some respects reflect themselves in the character of her graduates. Her older men have boasted that Princeton was a national college; her ju- nior sons in somewhat different phrase repeat the claim. We believe it is true that the _Princetonian is proud of his college, and that he often justifies the college in being proud of him. They hold, we think with truth, that it is a democratic institution, where in all col lege matters men stand on their own merits; and it is certainly a delightful feature that the class exclusiveness which marks another lati- tude is, barring a little discipline of Freshmen, not to be found there. So far as this particular book is concerned, it is not unkindness to say that its most in- structive feature is the illustrations. The vil- lage of palaces set forth is still inadequate to shelter the thousand This is the brick-and-mortar side of the extraordinary development of the last twenty-five years, the fruition of seed sown in President Maclean's later days. The text, so far as it goes, is fair ly accurate, but the author in his next edition may care to change some statements. The literary societies after the conflagration of scholars. 1802 found their new rooms in the Library, now the offices, built in 1803, not in Nassau Hall again. There is no good reason to sup- pose that the cannon which is so essential a feature in the outdoor ceremonies of the Col lege, played any part in the battle of Prince- ton. It was a could not have been used by either army in that engagement. It is much more prob- able that at unimportant broken carriage determined its detention for example, when the French marched north to return home. The dwelling in which Mer- cer died, in rear of the critical field of battle, should continue to be known as the Clarke house, in memory of those kindly and patriotic Friends who graced it through several gene rations, notwithstanding that its ownership is now changed. The enemy in that battle were not Hessians, but a brigade of British regulars under Mawhood. June, 1544, marks the date of the new Commencement; the resolution to make the change may have been in 1843. The writer, brought up in the atmosphere of modern sports, looks upon the play ‘with balls and sticks ” objected to by the Faculty in 1787 as ‘‘ the first appearance of base-ball at That was a sheer guess, and a bad > was thus aimed at, and it was siege piece, and as such some period a Princeton.” one. ‘* Shinny’ not suppressed until sixty years afterwards, when the authorities planted the ‘back cam with trees, beautifying the quadrangle There is internal pus” and preventing the game. evidence The Nation. that author is an American Whig, who inadvertently betrays one of his Hall secrets. These are little matters, but the our babes and sucklings in local history should have their milk pure Whether calling itself such will make Prince ton a university, may be doubted. It called itself a boating college, and “the university boat-house” is among the illustrations. There should be an aftirmative born of two negatives, but this may be the exception to that venera- ble rule. To discuss seriously the influence of enormous Classes, of costly dormitories, of mul tiplied electives, of the weakness that strains after ‘*’varsity” effects, would be placing too heavy a stress upon this slender span that would bridge the space between the graduate of to-day and the polished Jonathan Belcher An Elementary Treatise on Pure Geometry, By John Welles ley Russell, M.A. Oxford: Clarendon Press; New York: Macmillan, 1893. An Elementary Treatise on Modern Pure Ge By R. Lachlan, M.A. with numerous examples. ometry. Macmillan. 1893. Geometry tn the Grammar School; An Essay Together with illustrative class exercises, and an outline of the work for the last three years of the Grammar School. By Paul H Hanus, Assistant Professor of the History and Art of Teaching, Harvard University. Boston: D. C. Heath & Co. 1893, THE two text-books cited above, one from Ox ford, the other from Cambridge, are on a sub- ject lately introduced into the university exa- mination The Oxford book shows somewhat more mathe matical and geometrical ability, and contains upwards of 1,500 examples, mostly of real in- papers. Neither is of great merit terest. The elementary explanations of the Cambridge book are somewhat superior, and it deals with some interesting topics altogether omitted from the other treatise. It doubt the more convenient text-book the is, for less, | tion without being gifted with teacher, though the less profitable for the | earnest student. The great the arrangement of both books is well shown by comparing them together in this respect The theorems are pitchforked together upon no principle, and as for the examples, it is really curious to remark under what diverse heads one and the same proposition may be treated. The leading propositions of each book are mere illustrative examples for its rival The reason why analytical methods are more easily handled than the synthetical geometry is chiefly that the former arrange the whole subject in a perfectly detinite and unmistakable manner. No wonder a pupil is puzzled to aj ply a theory consisting of some thirty frag ments not connected by any intrinsic bonds As long as this state of things exists, notwith standing the infinitely greater elegance of the pure geometry, its great practical use will x to serve as a guide in the reformation of analy- sis. The older treatises upon modern geometry did not exhibit this loose the reason that they dealt chiefly with projective culation, for arti properties, and introduced what little metrics they gave as corollaries to the projective theo- This could no k it suggests the proper way of arranging the subject. No text-book of either synthetical or analytical geometry omits that grand propo- Cayley, that projective fact about a rems nger be thought of, yet sition of every metrical fact is a certain fixed quadric, mn of this quadric by the plane; nevertheless, writers of or in plane geometry about the secti arbitrariness of | } minent characteristics 14:3 text-books put them together as if they did not really this. If it eternal fitness requires that true, surely an the diagrams and conics believe te pro jes tive geometry of rectilinear should precede all metrical matter, and that the Euclidean geometry should be taught as a particular case of the non-Euclidean Prof. Hanus’s want of acquaintance with geometry, beyond what everybody knows, is very apparent. He applies general principles of pedagogy to give a few maxims too Vague to be of much positive value, and upon that basis proceeds to pronounce ex cathedra upon haps the most difficult problem of intellectual education—the question of what, when, and how to teach in the first instruction in geome The illustrative exer trv ises eXer vs methods in teaching applicable to many sul jects and widely used in our schools. The course laid out could not well be much worse than it is, and is calculated to impart to t scholar ideas of geometry as confused as those of Prof. Hanus himself William Kitchen Purke FLRIS scret Lite Hunterian Professor of Anatomy and Phy siology in the Roval College of Surgeons of England: A Biographical Sketch by his Son T. Jeffery Parker Macmillan & Co. Ise) Svo, pp. 145 RESEARCHES on the foraminifera and on the vertebrate skeleton of scholars familiar A multitude of future their gratitude and respect. His splendid se ries of monographs have prepared aw ne for the opportunity given by his s f know ing the man more intimately, of learning how it was he placed himself among the great men of science. The story is that of a dissatisfied farmer boy who became a drugyist’s rk. a village physician, and ultimately a Fellow of the Royal Society It is ar that ght be cited in support of Dalton's sions t “that no man can achieve a very hich reputa verv high abili and ‘“‘that few who tl high abilities can fail in achieving WOSNONS ese very ties” eminence yet, from what we learn of his farmer ances trv, it is not an instance to support the theory of hereditary ability in general. Religious fervor, lasting from his fifteenth vear till the end, and scientific enthusiasm, were most pro- f a truly amiable man. him in! his ill-health, his hours of de; Our sympathy goes out t is struggles, ression or exalta tion, he our esteem and such particulars as how unsystematic »w talkative, detract nothing from Some vd. ¢ ti of a dog going was or h one, we are Was re minded by the Professor's style home, firm in his purpose and sure to get there, now on this side of the road, now on the other, now scratching at a rat-hole, and now dashing across the field for a friendly or hostile sniff at There is also a lively anecdote of another dog a visitor who, at mention of a skull, was car- | ried off to the study, and, unable to get in a dozen words, was overwhelmed by explana- th evening, then accompanied to the door for a ten or fifteen-minute conclusion, and finally al- lowed to depart, while the Professor sank into ns, illustrations, and sketches for the entire a chair, ejaculating, ‘‘ That’sa most intelligent young man, but I thought he'd never go; ['m lead tired.” The author has done his work well, without overestimate of the great importance of his father’s works. A letter from William Bowman contains this summary of Prof. Parker's temperament: ‘He was a bright, Sir

Page 24

vats si adbn sider Rare by teat are ae Sate EH 14.4 The Nation. [Vol. 57, No. 1469 happy, loving man, full of reverence, intensely | Cahun, Léon. La Tueuse. 1241. [Romans Historiques.] erie ‘ sf ees Paris: Armand Colin & Cie. feeling the pure pleasure of the contemplation Campbell, W.W. The Dread Voyage: Poems. Toronto: and investigation of Nature, who greatly ad- Chase, F. H. The Old Syriac Element in the Text of Co owledge bec: ex Bezae. acmillan. §2.50. vanced kn ow le Ig bec ause apparently he could Comma Deana, Woas tttiee. Aanlotes. not help doing it, the joy was so pervading. First Three Republican National Conventions. Minne- apolis: C. W. Johnson. $2. —— | Gardener, Helen H. Facts and Fictions of Life. Chi- Gautier ot gd te Impérial. (Ro! His , , > WEEK. autier, Ju > ragon_ Impérial. mans - BOGER OF TEE WHEE. toriques.}] Paris: Armand Colin & Cie. Angell, G.T. Autobiographical Sketches and Personal | Grey, Maxwell. An Innocent Impostor. Appletons. $1. Recollections. American Humane Society. Horton, E. A. Noble Lives and Noble Deeds. Boston: Besant, Waiter. The Rebel Queen. Harpers. $1.50. Unitarian Sunday School Society. Bonner, John. A Child’s History of France. Harpers. | Howe, Maud. Honor. St. Paul: Price-McGill Co. $2. Jacolliot, J. L. The Froler Case. Robert Bonner’s Sons. Boyle, Virginia F. The Other Side: An Historic Poem. 1. Memphis, Tenn.: A. R. Taylor. $1. James, Henry. The Private Life, and Other Stories. Bradley, F. H. Appearance and Reality. London: H rs. $1. Sonnenschein ; New York: Macmillan. $2.75. Johnson’s Gardener’s Dictionary. Part If. London : Bunner, H.C. “ Made in France”: French Tales retold George Bell & Sons; New York: Macmillan. 40 cents. with a United States Twist. Keppler & Schwarzmann. | Johnston, W.J. An Elementary Treatise on Analytical Burke, J.M. “Buffalo Bill’: from Prairie to Palace. Geometry. Oxford: Clarendon Press: New York: Rand, McNally & Co. 50 cents. Macmillan. Leroy-Beaulieu, Anatole. Israél chez les Nations. ¥th edition. Paris: Calmann Lévy. Leverson, M. R. Thoughts on Institutions of the Higher Education. 8. & D. A. Huebsch. Mach, Prof. Ernst. The Science of Mechanics. Chicago : Open Court Publishing Co. $2.50. Maycock, W.P. Electric Lighting and Power Distribu tion. Part III. London: Wh ttaker; New York: Macmillan. 75 cents. er Y Prof. E. T. Catullus. Boston: Ginn & Co. Roberts, J. W. Looking Within. A. S. Barnes & Co. $1. Rothwell, R. P. Universal Bimetallism. Scientific Publishing Co. 75 cents: Sanborn, Kate. A Truthful Woman in Southern Cali- fornia. Appletons. 75 cents. Savage, R. H. The Passing Show. F. T. Neely. 50 cents. The Open Secret. Boston: Arena Publishing Co. 75 cents. The Principles of withing Sor Apprentices and Students. London : Whittaker; New York: Macmillan. $1.50. Thorpe, Prof. T. E. A Dictionary of Applied Chemistry. Vol. III. Longmans, Green & Co. i we Prof. L.G. The Theory of Determinants. Mac- millan. HENRY HOLT & CO., New York, Have Published During the Past School Year: Barker’s Physics (Advanced Course, American Science Series). By GrorGE F. BARKER, Professor in the University of Pennsylvania. x+902 pp., 8vo. Teachers’ price $3.50; post- age 28 cents additional. A comprehensive4text book for bigher college classes, rigorous in method, and thoroughly modern in its treatment of the subject as distinctively the science of energy. The London Chemical News pronounces it “the best truly modern manual of physics in our language.” ’ ee . Baldwin’s Elements of Psychology. By James Mark BALpwin, Professor in Princeton College. xvi+372 pp.12mo. Teachers’ price $1.50; postage 11 cents additional. Presents the essentials of the science, in@uding the latest results of experimental psychology, in a single compact volume, While based on the aut*>r’s larger “ Handbook of Psychology,” whole sections have some. times been rewritten and even whole chapters recast. The exposition has been simplified throughout and more illustrative facts and explanations added. Falckenberg’s History of Modern Philosophy. ‘Translated by A. C. ARMSTRONG, Jr., Professor of Philosophy in Wesleyan University. xvi+655 pp. 8vo. Teachers’ price $3.50; postage 25 cents additional. A comprehensive view of the history of modern philosophy from Nicolas of Cusa tothe present time. Full and appreciative in its treatment of British and of general nineteenth century philosophy. Beresford-Webb’s German Historical Reader. Edited with an introduc- tion, connecting passages, and notes, by CHARLES R. BERESFORD-WEBB. 240 pp. 12mo. Teachers’ price 90 cents; postage 5 cents additional. Selections from German historians, mostly of a popular order, which, taken together, present a fair outline of the history of German and continental affairs down to the present century. Fischer’s Practical Lessons in German. By A. ALBIN FiscHER. Fourth edition. viii+156 pp. Teachers’ price 75 cents; postage 7 cents additional. This book, new to the list of its present publishers, has been found to be a successful modification of the natural method, insuring great thoroughness. Jagemann’s Materials for German Prose Composition. With notes and vocabulary. By H. C. G. von JAGEMANN, Assistant Professor of German in Harvard University. vi+288 pp, 12mo. Teachers’ price 90 cents; postage 8 cents additional. Easy connected prose, chiefly narrative and historical. The notes consist chiefly of references to the author’s “Elements of German Syntax,’”’ which is intended to accompany this book. The vocabulary is especially complete, and discriminates between synonyms. Riehl’s Burg Neideck. With introduction and notes by ARTHUR H. PALMER, Professor of the German Langu and Literature in Yale University. x+66 pp. 12mo, boards. Teachers’ price 30 cents; postage 3 cents additional. One of Riehl’s brightest and most pleasing historical genre-pictures, using the period of the Seven Years’ War as a background. Daudet’s Contes de Daudet. With introduction and notes by A. Guyor CAMERON, Assistant Professor of French in the Sheffield Scientific School, Yale University. xx-+299 pp. 16mo. Teachers’ price 80 cents; postage 7 cents additional. Eighteen tales, aw pe Os elle Nivernaise, representing the different types under which Daudet’s short stories may be grouped jalectal and other difficulties are carefully explained in the notes. The intro- duction is unusually full and adequate. Daudet’s La Belle Nivernaise. With Notes by A. GuyoT CAMERON. 79 pp. 12mo, boards. Teachers’ price 25 cents: postage 3 cents additional. Taken bodily from the foregoing volume, with the same notes and references. Joynes’s Minimum French Grammar and Reader, By Epwarp S. JoyNes, Professor in South Carolina College. vi+269 pp. Teacher’s price, 75 cents; postage 6 cents additional. Combines in a single brief volume the essentials of grammar, with ample exercises, and graded selections for easy reading, with notes and vocabularies. The object is to reduce preliminary grammatical study to the minimum consistent with due method and completeness. Goodell’s Greek Lessons. Part I. The Greek in English. Part II. The Greek of Xenophon. By THomas D. GooDELL, Professor in Yale University. x+376 pp. 16mo. Teachers’ price $1.25; postage 8 cents additional. This volume, an enlargement of the author’s “ Greek in English ” (which is still published separately), forms a continuous course preparatory to the Anabasis. As far as possible, the exercises of Part II.consist of con- nected speech, and are based on the Anabasis. s , s 242.3% yr: . McLaughlin’s Literary Criticism for Students. With an Introduction and Notes by EpwarpD T. MCLAUGHLIN, late Professor in Yale University. xx+236 pp. 12mo. Teachers’ price $1.00; tage 10 cents additional. Selections from the leading writers of English criticism with double reference to the study of good prose models and the discussion of general traits of style and important facts in literary history. Prof. Brander Matthews of Columbia College says: “It is very well done, and it was well worth doing. It seems to me just the kind of book to recommend to advanced students, just the kind of book which will help to open their minds.” ’ * * * saracay — igs Pancoast’s Representative English Literature. By Henry S. PANcoasr. xiii+-514 pp. Large 12mo. Teachers’ price $1.60; postage 15 cents additional. Described by Samuel Thurber of the ton Girls’ High School,as ‘‘an excellent primer of English literary his- tory, combined with an excellent selection of literary specimens ” [complete texts]. The Nation says: ‘‘ The style is more than respectable, the text accurate, the method excellent.” f. Carpenter of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, calls it ‘‘an excellent text-book both in method and in subject-matter. Although it is specially adapted for use in secondary schools, I shall use it next year with the Sophomore class.” ten Brink’s History of English Literature. Vol. II. Part I. Wyclif, Chaucer, Earliest Drama, Renaissance. Translated by W. CLARKE ROBINSON, Ph.D. 339 pp. Large 12mo. Teachers’ price $1.60; postage 13 cents additional. Uniform with Vol. I. of the same work, published at the same price. The lamented author left materials for a third volume which will finish the wank. Clark’s Art of Reading Aloud. By J. Scorr Ciark, Professor in the Northwestern University. 159 pp. 16mo. Teachers’ price 60 cents; postage 5 cents additional. The essentials of elocution illustrated by direct application in the reading of Dickens’s ** Christmas Carol.” Scudder’s Brief Guide to the Commoner Butterflies. By Samuer. H. ScuDpDER. xi+206 pp. 12mo. Teachers’ price $1.00; postage 9 cents additional. Contains all the apparatus necessary for the identification of the commoner butterflies of the Northern States, and a short introduction to the study of butterflies in general. Complete catalogue free on application, Lndtieestion Horsford’s Acid Phosphate Is the most effective and agree- able remedy in existence for preventing indigestion and re- lieving those diseases arising from a disordered stomach. Dr. W. W. Gardner, Springfield, Mass., says: ‘‘I value it as an excel- lent preventative of indigestion, and a pleasant acidulated drink when pro- perly diluted with water and sweet- ened.” Descriptive Pamphlet free on application to Rumford Chemical Works, Providence, R. J. Beware of Substitutes and Imitations. For sale by all Druggists. A GRAND COMBINATION. YALE MIXTURE FOR THE PIPE. A Delightful Blend of St. James Par- ish, Louisiana, Perique, Genuine Im- ported Turkish, Extra Bright Plug Cut, Extra Bright Long Cut, and Marburg Bros.’ Celebrated Brand ‘“ Pickings.”’ Marburg Bros. FRENCH 28 eit French desiring good literature will take plea- sure in reading our RO- MANS CHOISIS SERIES, 60 cents vol., and CONTES CHOISIS SERIES, 25 cents vol. Each a masterpiece and by a well-known author. List sent on application. WILLIAM R. JENKINS, 851 and 853 Sixth Avenue (48th Street), New York.

Page 25

Aug. 24, 1893] The Nation. Vil EIGHT GREAT DICTIONARIES FOR SCHOOLS AND PRIVATE LEARNERS. Liddell and Scott's Greek Lexicon. Revised and Enlarged. A Greek-English Lexicon. Compiled by HENRY GEORGE Ltbbrir, DD ROBERT ScoTT, D.D. With Co-operation of HENRY DRISLER, Jay Professor of Greek in ¢ College, New York. pp. xiv., 1776. Seventh Edition, Revised and Augmented throughout it Sheep, $10 00. Liddell and Scott's Intermediate Greek Lexicon. An Intermediate Greek-English Lexicon, founded upon the Seventh Edition of Liddell and s« Greek-English Lexicon. pp. iv., g10. Small gto, Cloth, $3 50; Linen, $3 75; Sheep, $4 ‘* T have seen so much evil from the use of the little abridged lexicon by college students, and bave had so much difficulty in persuading all to use the large lexicon, that I shall be glad to exert my influence in favor of the * Intermediate Greek Lexicon’ for ordinary stu dents.”—T. D. SEYMOUR, Professor of Greek, Yale College. Liddell and Scott's Greek Lexicon. Abridged. A Lexicon Abridged from Liddell & Scott’s Greek-English Lexicon. The /cvemtret’ kefttion, caretully Revised throughout. With an Appendix of Proper and Geographical Names, prepared by the R JAMES M. WHITON, Ph.D. pp. 832. Small 4to, half leather, $1 25 Harpers Latin Dictionary. Founded on the translation of ‘* Freund’s Latin-German Lexicon.” Edited by E. A. ANoRE Ws, LL.D Revised, Enlarged, and in great part Rewritten, by CHARLTON T. Lewis, Ph.D... and CH .S LL.D. pp. xiv., 2020. Royal 8vo, Sheep, $6 50; Full Russia, $10 ei . ee Lewis's Latin Dictionary. A Latin Dictionary for Schools. By CHARLTON T. Lewis, Pho lol. Lary vo, $5 50; Sheep, $6 oo. ‘*This dictionary is not an abridgment, but an entirely new and independent work, designed to explain every word or phrase inthe Latin literature commonly read in schools, viz., the complete works of Cwsar, Terence, Cicero, Livy, Nepos, \ irgil, Horace, Ovid, Juvenal, Phadrus h I : I and Curtius, the Catiline and Jugurtha of Sallust, the Germania and Agricola of Tacitus, and a few words found in some extracts of Florus Sutropius, and Justinus. The original meaning of every word is first given, and then the modifications Which it underwent in usac A Eutroy and Justinu T} ginal g of ; i first ; i th th ficat I Preface. see, il ; — Lewis's Elementary Latin Dictionary. An Elementary Latin Dictionary. By CHARLTON T. LEWIs, Ph.D. pp. a§2. Small 4t ther, $2 00. ‘‘T have put it to the test of constant use over the range of authors now read by my classes, Cicero, Horace, Tacitus, Plautus, Terenes and Juvenal, and have found it ample. The definitions are clear, and the interpretation of passages often very happy J. HOWARD 81 *H Professor of Latin, Midland College. Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon. Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament; being Grimm's Wilks lated, Revised, and Enlarged by JOSEPH HENRY THAYER, D.D.. Bussey Professor of New Testament Criticism and Interpretation in the Divinity School of Harvard University. pp. 746. 4to, ¢ mi - a . ~ $5 00; Half Roan, $6 00; Sheep, $6 50 ‘+ Altogether the volume is one of great value, and the eminent scholars who have beet neerned in its production should have the thanks of all who love the study of the New Testament in the Greek tongue.’— Preshyfertan, PAdad ’ 7 ; ~ ° “ . / . . ~ = ~ - + »\r ~ Yonge’s English-Greek Lexicon. o S An English-Greek Lexicon. By C. D. YONGr. With Many New Articles, an Appendix of Proper Names, and Pillon’s Greek Synonymes. To which is prefixed an Essay on the Order of Words in Attic- Greek Prose, by CHARLES SHORT, LL.D. Edited by HENRY DRISLER, LL.D. pp. 8c4. Royal 8vo, Sheep, $4 50. ‘This work is nota mere collection of Greek words which may be equivalents of certain English words, thrown carelessly together without system, but a carefully arranged lexicon, in which a scholar can see the nafure of the word he is employing, whether it is poetic or spe cially Homeric, SP ge veep. or peculiar to comedy. or colloquial. The work is certainly a great accession to our apparatus of classical instruction."—W. W. Goopwtn, Ph.D., Eliot Profess f Greek Literature in Harrard eu I 77 have hoobe may he bh e af . cA “ (fp f y ; 4 ie) The 200VE GOVURS MMaAV Cé& Aad Tks ‘ ‘ ; MOIS AL? cei Pra i weréa ni y Mia lo fei cnt HARPER & BROTHERS. Publishers, Franklin Square, New York.

Page 26

tha tiie, cai Sal tale: Re EO Matte ha POE vill The Nation. Some Leading High School and College Books. Grammar, 80 cents. Metklejohn's En li sh Metklejohn’s English . ents. 4 : £ ° English Literature, 80 cents. Hawthorne & Lemmon's Amert- can Literature, $1.12. Strang’s Exercises in English, 45 cents. Williams's Composition and Rhetoric, go cents. Corson’s Introduction to Shakespeare, retail price, $1 50. Corson’s Introduction to Browning, retail price, $1.50. Sci ence Shaler's Geology, $1.00. Shepard's Chemistry, $1.12. She- * para’s Briefer Course (with chapter on Organic “Chemistry), 80 cents. Remsen’s Organic Chemistry, $1.20. Chute’s Practical Physics, $1.12. Colton’s Practical Zoology, Botany (in press). 80 cents. Spaulding’s Introduction to M th ti Cc The New Arithmetic, 75 cents. Bowser’s Aca- a ema S. demic Algebra, $1.12. Bowser’s College Algebra, $1.50. Bowser’s* Plane Geometry, 75 cents. Bowser’s Plane and Solid Geometry, $1.25. Bowser’s Elements of Trigonometry, 90 cents. Bow- ser’s Treatise on Trigonometry, $1.50. (Send for full Descriptive Catalogue of texts in all departments of Education. ) D.C. HEATH & CO., Publishers, BOSTON, NEW YORK, CHICAGO. MAYNARD, MERRILL & CO., Successors to Effingham Maynard & Co. and Charles E.. Merrill & Co., Nos. 43, 45, and 47 East 10th St., New York, Publish approved text-books in Reading, Writing, Spelling, Arithmetic, Language Work, Grammar, English Literature, Rhetoric, Physiology, Modern Languages, Maynard’s English Classic Series (catalogue free), etc., etc. They are the authorized American publishers of Mr. Ruskin, and publish the Brantwood Edition of Ruskin’s Works, with Introductions by Prof. Charles Eliot Norton. Catalogue free on application to MAYNARD, [IERRILL & CO., 43, 45, and 47 East 10th St., New York. BURR’S LIBRARY INDEX. FOR INDEXING ony ‘TS, TO AID THE STUDENT, SCHOLAR, CLERGYMAN, wren, PHYSICIAN, DITOR, AUTHOR, TEACHER, AND ALL LOVERS OF BOO All Words and PR are indexed by the first TWO letters, with nearly 400 er aes of the Alphabet, printed in Thumbholes cut in the edges of the leaves. Opened instantly at any combination by the use of one hand! Write for Descriptive Circular and price, THE BURR INDEX COMPANY, An index to information for immediate or future use, Sole Manufacturers, HARTFoRD, Conn. KEGAN PAUL, TRENCH, TRUBNER & CO.,, LIMITED, Publishers, Importers, and Booksellers, Paternoster House, Charing Cross Road, LONDON, Import American Books, Export European Books, Buy Editions, Arrange simultaneous publication for copyright pur- poses in Great Britain and the United States. To Librarians, Book-Lovers, and Booksellers, Our NEW CATALOGUE of RARE and CHOICE BOOKS, comprising works on architecture, biography, belles- lettres, the drama, first editions, Shakespearians, rare French Books, works of art, etc., etc., will be sent, post- paid, upon request. gP Attention is called to this valuable collection. BRENTANO’S, 31 Union Square, New y York. — > : Ww e buy and sell bills of exchange _ L etters and make Cable Transfers of mon Man of Europe, Australia, and the West Indies; * . also make collections and issue Commer- Credit, cial and Travellers’ Credits, available in all parts of the world. Brown Brothers & Co., Bankers, NO. 59 WALL STREET, [NEW YORK. A HOME IN AMERICA’S UPLANDS, A gentleman desirous of securing the advantages of the rarified atmosphere of Colorado, with its 300 clear days in the year, can find a home (in the mountains, elevation 6,500 feet) with a refined family, where the privacy and comforts of a genteel home may be had. For full particulars, address W.E, Y., Buffalo Creek, Colorado. The Columbus Memorial, Containing the First Letter of Columbus descriptive of his Voyage to the New World, and a Narrative of the Four Voyages of Amerigo Vespucci. Reproduced in facsimile from the excessively rare originals. With Translations, Introductions, and Notes. “A most interesting and valuable memortal.”— Boston Jou rnal of Education. Should have a place on every shelf devoted to His- tory.”—Phila. Evening Bulletin. Small 4to, cloth, illustrated. Price, $1.00; paper, 50c. THE JORDAN PUBLISHING CO.. Publishers, ___ 4302 Filbert St., Philadelphia, Pa, FRANK T. SABIN’S CATALOGUE _ Of FINE and RARE BOOKS, ENGRAVINGS, AU- TOGRAPHS, etc., (52 pp.), is NOW READY, and will be sent on application. 118, _118, SH AF TESBU RY . AVENU E, L¢ INDON, W. 75C ne ane. — Percy's ‘ Reliques, U ‘alton’ s s i ‘Complete Angler,’ ‘Dr. Syntax,’ ‘ Ingoldsby Li egends,’ Johnson’ s ‘Lives of the Poets,’ Butler’s ‘ Hu- dibras,’ Hallam’s ‘ History of England,’ Ockley’s ‘Sar acens.’ Try them. Mailed promptly. PRATT, 155 6th Ave., N. Y. . Subscription to foreign peri- Fore ron Books. — MauchnitzBritish au- ors. Catalogues on appli- cation, Cant. SCHOENHOF, 144 Tremont St.. Boston. ae Wy4 NTED TO PURCHASE.—NUM- bers, Vols. eats sets of the Nation. Address with lists, LARK, 34 Park Row, N. Y. City. aH . WILLIAMS: 195 W. 10TH ST., , dealer in Magazines and other periodicals. Sets, volumes, or single numbers. B: ACK numbers and sets of all magazines, For orice, a state wants to MAGAZINE EXCHANGE, Schoha- ie, N.Y. Recent Text- Books Elements of Physics. By Henry S. Caruart, University of Michi- gan, and Horatio N. CauTE, Ann Arbor High School. 12mo, cloth, 388 pages. Price, $1.20. The basis of the whole book is the introductory statement that physics is the science of matter and energy, and that nothing can be learned of the phy- sical world save by observation and experience, or by mathematical deductions from data so obtained. The authors do not believe that immature students can profitably be set to rediscover the laws of Na- ture at the beginning of their study of physics, but that they must first have a clearly defined idea of what they are doing, an outfit of principles and data to guide them, and a good degree of skill in con- ducting an investigation An Academic Algebra By Professor J. M. Taytor, LL.D., Colgate University. 16mo, cloth, 338 pages. Price, $1.00. This work presents the subject of Elementary Al gebrain a clear, scientific and attractive form The order of presentation has been determined mainly by three considerations. First, to introduce as early as possible the equa tion, of which Algebra is the science Second, toshow how each subject bears directly on the end in view, namely, the solution and use of equations. hird, to eliminate as far as possible any unneces- sary difficulties of the science The book is adapted to beginners of any age, and covers sufficient ground for admission to any Ame ri- can college or university. ALLYN & BACON, Publishers, Bo ston, lass. An Indispensable Companion to the New U. S. Pharmacopwia. A [anual of Weights and [leasures. By OscaR OLpDBERG, Pharm, D., Member of Revision Committee, New Edition, U.S. Pharmacopoeia. Third Edition Revised, 12mo., cloth, $1.50 net, postpaid. FROM THE MEDICAL RECORD. “Tt is astandard work on the subject treated, a fair index of which appears in its title. The adoption of the Metric System of weights and measures in the Phar macopoeia, to the exclusion of all others, re nde rsa thorough knowledge of that system imperative.’ FROM THE MEDICAL NEWS. “To those already familiar with the useful little book, it is unnecessary to speak well of it, and to those who are not fortunate enough to possess it, we would earnestly recommend its purchase, particularly if they are engaged in pursuits which bring them in contact with the metric system or with accurate measure ments. The very large number of books intended to yrovide for similar wants may, perhaps, be useful, but Prot. Oldberg has surpassed them, as much that is usually uninteresting is presented in so clear a manner that one cannot fail to understand what he reads ona single reading, while the tables are models of com pleteness.” THE W. T. KEENER CO., Medical, Dental, and Pharmaceutical Booksellers, g6 Washington St., Chicago. *,* Cur Bulletins with announcement of Recent and Forthcoming Medical and Scientific Books sent gratis to any address upon eon. JOHNS HOPKINS UNIVERSITY. The Medical Department of the Johns Hop- kins University will open October 2, 1893. Cir- culars and further information can be obtained on application to the Registrar of the Univer- sity, Baltimore, Maryland. LIBRARIAN. Assistant Librarian (male) in large library, having a wide knowledge of literature, and six years’ “ne rience in library work, desires position as Head Librarian. Terms moderate. Address Lisp ARIAN, care Nation,

Page 27

Aug. 24, 1893]

George Routledge & Sons, LIMITED, London, Manchester, and New York, Are publishing a Uniform Edition of The One Hundred Books, Recommended by SIR JOHN LUBBOCK, in Red Cloth, Uncut Edges, or in Blue Cloth with the edges cut.

In the Universal Library EDITED BY PROFESSOR HENRY MORLEY, and now complete in 63 vols., substantially bound in cloth, price 40 cents each, will be found many volumes well suited for School and College Text Books, among which are: Richard Brinsley Sheridan’s Plays, Ben Johnson’s Plays and Poems, George Peele’s Plays and Poems, Oliver Goldsmith’s Plays and Poems, De Foe’s Journal of the Plague, Ideal Commonwealths, containing More's Bacon’s New Atlantis, ete., ete., Goethe’s Faust and Marlow’s Faustus, Locke on Civil Government, Hobbes’s Leviathan, Racon’s Essays, Lamb’s Essays of Elia, De Quincy’s Confesstons of an Opium Eater, Edmund Burke’s Speeches on Conciliation, Machiavelli’s The Prince, and other pieces, The Acharnians, Knights and Birds of Aristophanes, The Plays of 4schylus, The Plays of Sophocles, Alcestis and the Plays ofE uripides, The Bacchanals, and other Plays of Euripides, Hecuba, and other Plays of Euripides, Dryden’s ®neid of Virgil, Chapman’s Homer's Iliad, Utopia, Complete lists of the above Libraries will be furnish ed on application. THE TRAGEDIES OF by the late The Very 12mo, cloth, $1.50. THE TRAGEDIES OF by the late The Verv 12mo, cloth, $1.50. SOPHOCLES Rev. E. H. PLUMPTRE, Translated D.D. ARSCHYLOS. Rev. E. H. PLUMPTRE, Translated D.D.

or For paid, on receipt of price, GEORGE ROUTLEDGE & SONS, Limited, 9 Lafayette Place, New York. 1 “7 oven | re The Evolution of Mechanics. Just THE SCIENCE OF MECHANICS. A Criti- cal and Historical Exposition of Its Princi- ples. By Dr. Ernst Macu, Professor of Physics in the University of Prague, Aus- tria. Translated from the second German Edition by Thomas J. McCormack. 1 vol., half mor., gilt top, 538 pages, 250 illustra- tions and cuts, $2.50. The aim of this work is to exhibit the evolution of mechanical science, and to present its principles from the point of view of the theory of knowledge, freeing it from all metaphysicism. In the original it has attracted, by the simplicity, clearness,and profundity of its views, the attention of thinkers in all parts of the world. The Religion of Science Just Out. sale by all booksellers, will be mailed, postage by the publishers. Out. THE RELIGION OF SCIENCE. (Religion of Science Library, No. 1.) By Dr. Pau Carus. Extra souvenir edition. 112 pp., paper, 50 cents. he Primer of Philosophy 2) 2) The Primer of Philosophy. In Press. THE —— OF PHILOSOPHY. By Dr. yp., Cloth, $1.00. OF WEISMANNISM. (Ready in September. PAUL Carus. 220 EX: AMIN ATION By G. J. ROMANEs. THE OPEN COURT PUBLISHING CO. Dear 4, AN 770 Monon Butlding, 320 orn St., CHICAGO, ILL.

‘The Nation. RECE

The Empire of the Tsars and the Russians. By ANATOLE LEROY-BEAULIEV. Translat ed with annotations from the third French edition by Z. A. Ragozin. Part L (complete in itself), ‘The Country and Its Inhabitants.” Svo, with maps printed in colors, $3 00, ‘This work contains some of the best informed, most strikingly discussion, as well as soundest er aa and her people that we paps Time 8s. written, most wisely itical have symnipaathe judgments of seen.’ Ne ‘Beaulieu’s work will be found of a sur pass ne interest, combining the triple excellences of con plete preparation, unbiased judgment, and th piquancy of Gallic expression.” Chicago Tribune The Wilderness Hunter. With an Account of the Big Game of the United States, and its Chase with Hors», Hound, and Rifle. By THEopore Roose VELT, author “Hunting Trips of a Ranchmin,” “History of the Naval War of of 1812,” ete. With Illustrations by Remington, Frost, Sandham, Eaton, B ‘ard, and others. &8vo, $38.5) ‘A book which breathes the spirit of the wilder hess and presents a vivid picture of a phase of Ame rican life which is rapidly passing away, with clear, incisive force."—New York Literary News ‘For one who intends to go a-hunting in the this book is invaluable. formation. * But it has better qualities It is good reading for anybody, and people who never hunt and never will are sure to derive pleasure from its account of that part of the United States, relatively small, which is still a wilderness.”"—New York Times West One may rely upon its in The Trees of Northeastern America. By CHas S. NewHaLti With ductory Note Nath. L_ Britton With illustrations made from tracings of the leaves of the various trees. $2.50. * We believe this is the some volume of its kind, an Intro by ~ vo, most complet and on aceou

pleteness and the readiness with wh it warts information that everybody needs and few possess it is invaluable. No lover of ¢ liry Scenery a rambles should be without this volume, f ‘

observations which have been amus ‘and refres ing will become entertaining and highly inst Binghamton Republican The Leaf-Collector’s Hand-book and Herbarium. By CHas. S. NEWHALL. An aid in the preservation and in the classitication of specimen leaves of the trees of North- eastern America, Illustrated. $2.50. ‘The idea of the book is So good to recommend itself ata ¢ cares to know our trees or to m a collection of their leaves “— N. } New portfolio edition

The Shrubs of Northeastern America. By CHARLES S. NEWHALI ihe author of **

Trees of Northeastern America,” ‘* The Leaf Collector's Handbook,” ete. Fully illustrated. Svo, pone 50 * This volume is beat eautifu paper, and has a ist of 1e ! s calcula toexplain thetext. It has ¢ f precious formation, such as is seldom gathered wit covers of su a vol . R FY *# * yr ee oy Pe tN é ‘ 5

ix T IMPORTANT PUBLICATIONS. Outlines of Roman History. By Henry F. Pevnam, Professor of A cient History in the University of Ox ford. Large 12mo. with Maps, $1.7 I shall take zg < hands of my iscs tncient Hist ( For advwar is ~ R know of for the study of f sl a tional History of | th 3 ! ‘ tirably succeed 1 | . wrade students i Histo N i ef \dmirably s sa students I hav s classes and sha h aan { Michs A Literary Courtship. Under the Auspices of Pike's Peak ANNA Futcer author of L's hou traits iS rated, $1.0 Ana P. ‘ * The brig ! fun a ‘ many a dav It is a " with pleasa ulthat f ‘ \\ The Silver Situation in the United States. By Prof. F. W. T, au Taritf! Histor, the Qu ms oO Lda ~ XN Svo, ¢ h, 7 WwW. s , Spects as ex t ly ~ essary is t a is s 1 insur Ata ‘ itt } ~ \ . ee i 4 “ bel i ‘ The Making of a Newspaper. Experiences ‘ n ‘ sentativ American Jour is relat vt sel and vM ! l2mo, cloth, $1.50 » ~ “ “ s . z \ The Meaning and the Method of Life. A Search for Religion in) Biolo l Gero. M Gorip, MA MD 12n S175 A x < i i a Ww levers \ a . . f s ‘ would r ‘ i ~ a ‘ ‘ = ; e , \ j } . « t. « I “ *x - athe t t i Ie 4 tia { if \ as . \ i An Nu Ii G. P. PUTNASIV’S SONS, LONDON: New York: 27& 29 West 23d St. 24 Bedford St., Strand.

Page 28

A cream of tartar baking powder. Highest of all in leavening strength.—Latest United States Gov- ernment Food Report. Roya. Bakina Powper Co., 106 Wall St., N. Y. Tf you area PIPE Smoker, we want you to try Surbrug’s Golden Sceptre All the talk in the world will not convince as uickly as a trial that it is almost perfection. Ye will send on receipt of 10c. a sample to any address. 159 Fulton Street, New York City. Prices GOLDEN SCEPTRE: 1 Ib., $1.30; 14 Ib., 40c. postage paid. Send for pamphlet, giving list o dealers who handle our tobaccos. SARGENT’S BALL BEARING ROTARY BOOKCASES. The above are two of many styles. We cover every demand for home or office use. Special styles for the Century Dictionary and Encyclopedias. Illustrated catalogues free. Address SARGENT MFG. CO., either 814 Broadway, New York, or factory, Muskegon, Mich. Quote the Nation. Nast UNEQUALLED IN TOUCH, WORKMANSHIP, AND DURABILITY. Baltimore, New York, 22 and 24 E. Baltimore St. 148 5th Ave., near 20th St. Washington, 817 Market Space. CHURCH LIGHT CHURCH Frink’s Patent Reflectors for Gas, Oil, or Electric. give the most powe softest, cheapest, and best ight known for Churches, Stores, Banks, The- atres, De S New and el- TONE, Eatablished 1857. Den’t 1. P. BEANS, 1 Pearl BtorNe Xe The Nation. [Vol. 57, No. 1469 B. WESTERIIANN & CO., BOOKSELLERS AND IMPCRTERS, 812 Broadway, New York. Book-buyers can save themselves much trouble and save money by sending all orders for both Forergn and American Books to our firm, prepared to furnish all Books, wherever published, promptly and at lowest rates. School and College Text-Books, Dictionaries, Grammars in all Languages, Greek and Latin Classics, Atlases, Wall-Maps. Catalogues on application. LONDON. PARIS. LEIPZIG, NEW YORK. GUSTAV E. STECHERT, Importer of Books and Periodicals, 810 BROADWAY, NEW YORK. Large stock of Foreign Books, new as well as rare and scarce, and sets of Periodicals. Subscriptions to Periodicals for 1893 now received. Lowest_rates, quick delivery. Send for Catalogue. BRANCHES : London: 30 Wellington Street, Strand, W. C. Paris: 76 Rue de Rennes. Leipzig: 10 Hospital Strasse. Books Bought. If you want a book, no matter when or where pub- lished, call at ourstore. We have, without exception, the largest collection of Old Books in America, all ar- ranged in Departments. Any person having the time to spare is perfectly welcome to call and examine our stock of two to three hundred thousand volumes, with- out feeling under the slightest obligations to purchase. Leary s Old Book Store, No. g South gth Street, (First Store below Market St.) PHILADELPHIA. Ss. B. LUYSTER, 79 NASSAU STREET, NEW YORK, AND LONDON, ENGLAND, Importer of Standard English Books, OLD AND NEW. Catalogues issued bi-monthly, and sent gra- tis to any address, on application. F. W. CHRISTERN, (DYRSEN & PFEIFFER, Suc’rs), 254 Fifth Ave., between 28th and 29th Sts., New York, Importers of Foreign Books, Agents for the leading Paris Publishers, Tauchnitz’s British Authors, Teubner’s Greek and Latin Classics. Catalogues of stock mailed on demand. A large assortment always on hand, and ad _— received from Paris and Leipzig as soon as ssued. American Magazines, Newspapers, and Journals We take subscriptions to all American Magazines, Newspapers, and Educational Journals. We collect any back number of any monthly magazine and supply them either in sets or unbound. We will quote you low- est prices on your request. ATMERICAN PRINTING AND NEWS COMPANY. BOX 974, PHILADELPHIA, PA. ee IT WILL BE TO THE ADVANTAGE Of book-buyers to send for our Catalogue of new and second-hand books at reduced pe. W. B. CLARKE & CO., 340 Washington St., Boston, Mass. NATURAL HISTORY.—Gameland, the gentle sportsman’s illustrated magazine of sheoting and fish- ing, reveals virgin woods and waters, and treats ex haustively of birds, fishes, and all animals. Yearly, $1; three trial numbers, 25c. GAMELAND, 1267 Broad- way, New York Find fault with the cook if the pastry does not exactly suit you. Nor with your wife either—perhaps she is not to BLAME It may be the lard she is using for shortening. Lard is indigestible you know. But if you would always have YOUR Cakes, pies, rolls, and bread palatable and perfectly di- gestible, order the new short- ening,“‘COTTOLENE,”’ for your WIFE SOLD BY ALL GROCERS. Reuse ALi SusstituTEs. Made only by N. K. FAIRBANK & CO., Chicago, St.Louis, Montreal, New York, Boston, Philadelphia, n Francisco, etc. Send three centsin stampe to N. K, Fairbank & Co., Chicago, for hand- some Cottolene Cook Book, contain- ing six hundred recipes, prepared by nine eminent authorities on cooking. BEFORE THE PUBLIC, MODERATE PRICES, TERMS REASONABLE EVERY INSTRUMENT FULLY WARRANTED. CATALOGUES FREE. EMERSON PIANO CoO., 174 TREMONT ST., 62 FIFTH AVE., BOSTON, MASS. NEW YORK: ‘H.. H.. UPHAM'&‘CO.: MEMORIAL TABLETS: IN: BRASS: AND - BRONZE: ‘54° South: Fifth: Ave:near’ Bleecker’ St: ‘NEW: YORK’ WATER CLOSETS There are 172 “Nautilus” closets in the “Savoy” Hotel, New York. The finest hotel in the world uses the finest water-closets in the 4 WILLIAM 8. COOPER RASS WORKS, PHILADELPHIA,

Page 29