The Nation 1892-09-01: Vol 55 Iss 1418

Page 1

The Nation VOL. LV—NO. 1418. THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 1, 1892. PRICE 10 CENTS. THE SEPTEMBER NUMBE R NORTH AMERICAN REVIEW AN OPEN LETTER TO HER all WESTY THE QUEEN, By GAIL HAWaS, TON. Re ERRATIC NATIONAL TARIFF PLATFORMS OF Mem YEMOCRACY, “2 Sexatox Justix S. Moxa THE TARIFF PLANK AT CHICAGO, : : . Tur Hox. W. L. Wirsos INNOCENCE VERSUS IGNORANCE, , . Ametir Rives A FORECAST OF MR. GLADSTONE’S NEW ADMINISTRATION. ‘Justin McCaxrtuy, M. P. Mrs. Ametia E. Barn RicuaARD MANSFIFLD His Nephew, Cras. McLaren NOT IN SOCIETY, . A PLAIN TALK ON THE DR: AMA. REMINISCENCES OF JOHN BRIGHT, THE GARZA RAID AND ITS LESSONS, . M. Romero © Mezic an Minister of Finance ELECTIONEERING METHODS IN ENGLANW H. W. Lucy THE ILLUMINATING POWER OF ANECDOTE S. Artuuk Brent THE HOMESTEAD STRIKE. A CONGRESSIONAL VIEW, The Hon. Wm. C. Oates, Chairman Congressional Investigating Committee A CONSTITUTIONAL VIEW, . The Hon. Geo. Ticknor Curtis A KNIGHT OF LABOR’S VIEW. . Master Workman Powderly APROPOS OF CHOLERA, , Cyrus Epson, M.D. LYNCH LAW IN THE SOUTH, ; ; W. Casper Bruc WOMEN IN THE FIELD OF ART W ORK. ‘ , Mrs. Susan N. Carrer 50 cents a copy. $5.00 a year. Sold by all Newsdealers. THE NORTH AMERICAN REVIEW, 3 East 14th St., New York.

Page 2

The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, morence, and Art. FOUNDED 1865. [Entered at the New York City Post-office as second-class mail-matter.| CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. THE WEEK......... 155 SORE O RHR eee OOD ee eH eRe rEE eee EDITORIAL ARTICLES: The peeaing meficont Conmenntion. eeecocccces Peck’s Report 060 be0secsecees 158 Farmiog in Mai -- 159 Reform of "English Legal Procedure.. eee 160 SPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE: The Question of the Colonies.. 161 An Extra-Territorial panes: City. ae 162 Bardoux’s Lafayette.—11.......c.ecereeeseeeseees LO CORRESPONDENCE: Raphael's Hours and Galatea ...... nclebeseendunte 165 The Process of an Error..........ssecccecseses eves 165 WMOFTRB, ccc vocscccsecscees ovecvec recccccsssccecees cesses 1GO REVIEWS: Strachey's Hastings and a Benita Wee.» . 168 Freeman’s History of Sicily ee - 169 The Latest Year Books.. + ag The Autobiography of Isaac Wiiliams. 171 An lilustrated Dictionary to Xenophon’s ‘Ana- ° 179 vasis piano wen 2 The Robin. Hood of Vermont.. coooe 240 The Apodidz.. . 173 BOOKS OF THE WEEK. 20. 0c ccccccccescsccsscccssccesee LUD TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three dollars per year in advance, postpaid to any part of the United States or Canada; to foreign countries com- prised in the Postal Union, Four Dollars. The date when the subscription expires is on the Address- Label of each paper, the change of which to a subsequent date becomes a receipt for remittance. No other receipt is sent unless request ed. Rematiances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter or by check, express order, or postal order, payable to * Publisher of the NATION.” When a change of address is desired, both the old and new addresses should be given. Address THE NATION, Box 794, New York, Publication Office, 208 Broadway. TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Fifleen cents per a; agate line, each insertion, 14 lines to the inch, Twenty per cent. advance for chotce of page, top of column, or cuts, Cuts are not inserted on the first page. A column, $20 each insertion; with chotce of page, $24, A page, #60 each insertion; front cover page, $80. Advertisements must be acceptable in every respect, Copy received until Tuesday, 5 P. M. DISCOUNT, IME— 4 insertions. . 5 per cent. 8 “ 10 “ 13 ig - 124 * 26 “ 2s 15 “ 39 » o. 20 - 52 * . 25 * AmouUNT— $100 within & Year.........eceeseeeesseees JO per cent, 250 ee “ 500 oo “ “ 750 7 -“ o“ 1,000 “ . o 1,500 “ “ oo 2,000 + i “ THE NATION is sent free to those who advertise in tt, as tong as advertisement c rontinues. The EDITION OF THE NATION this week is 12,500 copies, The Subscription List is always open to the inspec- tion of advertisers. *,* * Copies of THE Natron may be rocured in Paris at Brentano’s, 17 Avenue de l’Opéra, and in oe of Re . a 4 bes - uare, American News r nc. in Willinra Suse, Brena WO. . London agent for advertisements, R. J. Bush, 92 Fleet Street, E. C. , ‘The Ne ation. [ Vol. 55, No. 1418 line! CONNECTICUT, Greenwich. oF Aes MY AND HOME FOR TEN me be s.—67th year :«f Academy, 13th of Home. Preparation for Coliege or Business. Absolutely heaithbfui location and genuine home, with refined surroundings. Gymnasium. References reqetred. J. H, Roo, Principal. OTORY s Hamden. P get TORY SCHOOL FOR BOYS.— #325 to $375, Homelike influences combined with tirm yon oo and tho: ough school system, Extensive grou Symesciem. boathouxe, etc. Send for clreular. Rev L. EVEREST,M.A.,Rector. CONNECTICUT, Litchtield Co., New Preston. hie SEMINARY. FOR BOYSAND Young Men. Baterences: President Dw ght, Yale Untvenibr Rev. T. L. Cuyler, D.D., of Brook- lyn. Forother references or intcrmation inquire of Rev. HENRY Upson, Principal. CONNECTICUT, Pomfret Centr “HE MISSES VIN7 0. ” S SCHOOL for Girls will reopen Tuursday, October 6. Number limited. ONNECTICUT, Wallingford. O SE MARY HALL. A COUNTRY SCHOOL FOR GIRLS. Miss RuvutTz-REEs, Principal. CONNECTICUT, Waterb ron MARGARET'S DIOCESAN School.—Advent term, siahieent year, omen Sept. 21, 1892. The Rev neis T. Russell, M Rector. Miss Mary R. Hilliard, Principal. DELAWARE, Wilmington, Franklin St. WE MISSES HEBBS ENGLISH, French, andGerman Boarding and Day School for young ladies and girls reopens Sept. 22, 1892. DIisTRICT OF COLUMBIA, Washington. WE UNIVERSITY SCHOOL FOR Boys.—Prepares for the colleges and spree ties. Full academic course. Number limited to 20. Mr. ston takes two boys into his house and gives them his personal attent yt anny begins Sept. 8 ROBERT L. PRESTON, ., Room 1, 1331 F 8t. District or CotumsBia, Washington. ORWOOD INSTITUTE. A School for Young Ladies and Little Girls, Eleventh session opens September 28. For catalogue address Principals, Mr. and Mrs. Wm. D. CABELL, LOUISIANA. New Orleans, 247 Prytania Street. RS. F. D. BLAKE AND MRS. L. Polk Chapman’s French and English Boarding and Day schovl for Girls reopens Oct. 1, 1892. Stu- dents prepared for college. Ample grounds for out- door exercise. MARYLAND, Baltimore, 706 St. Paul Street. OUNT VERNON INSTITUTE, Mrs, JULIA R. TUTWILER and Mrs. ANNE Ca- BELL Rust, Frecipels. removed from 16 Mt. Vernon Place to 70) St. Paul St., will reopen September 21, Poardiog pape) limited to twenty. Students pre- pared for Coll MARYLAND, B:ltimore, 1214 Eutaw Place. ISS RANDOLPH’S SCHOOL, LO- cated in the most beautiful part of the city, opens Sept. 21, with a very able corps of teachers. Students prepared for College. Principal, Mrs. A. L. Armstrong. MARYLAND, Baltimore, 120-124 West Franklin St WEEDGCEWORTH BOARDING AND Day Schoo! for Girls, Mrs. H, P. LEFEBVRE, Prin- cipal. 30th year. Reopens Thursday, sept. 22, 1892. MARYLAND, Baltimore, 915 and 917 N. Cha: les st OUTHERN HOME SCHOOL for Girls, ate Mrs. W. M. CARY, Miss Cary. Fifty-first year. Summer address, Ber Harbor, Me. MARYLAND, Catonsvil! NY 7.TIMO THY’ S ERE NCH, GERMAN, and English Boarding School for Young Ladies reopens Sepiember 22, 1892. Principals— Miss M. O. CARTER and Miss y R. CARTER. MARYLAND, Notre Dame P. O., near Baltimore, Md. OTRE DAME OF MARYLAND.— Collegiate Institute for Young inte and Preparatory School for Little Girls. MBLA. MARYLAND, Reisterstown (near Baltimore’. WE HANNAH MORE ACADEMY for Girls, founded in 1832—Western Maryland Railroad—long noted for healthfalness, careful train- ing, and thorough instruction. Rev. ARTHUR J. Rica, A.M., M.D. ASSACHUSETTS, Am AR GRO VE HOME SCHOOL FOR Girls reop ber 21, 1892. Miss Parume Ww. Wooren, A.B., Princ ipal. Massacuusetts, Amherst. RS. W. F. STEARNS'S HOME 44 School for Young Ladies reopens September © lieebiomal MASSACHUSETTS, Belm HE BE LMO NV T SCHOOL. —PRi- vate Boarding School for Boys. Boys prepared for Harvard on apy of the four common methods of admission, for sScientitic School, or for Business; laboratory courses; school limited to sixty; six in- structors, four with twelve years’ experience; two large buildings and new stone chapel (in course of erection); fine athletic track; two base ball fields; fifteen acres on the old Cushing-Payson Estate. Terms, ag J peryear. Addres F, HaRpina, A.M, (Harv. ), Head Master. 88ACHUZETTS, Billerica 11 TCHELL SBOYS’ SCHOOL, 18 miles m Boston, on the B. & L. R.R. A strictly select Famiy ‘School for Boys from 7 to 15inclusive. Fall term commences September 19. Send for circular to M. C. MITCHELL, A.M., Principal. ; MASSACBUSETTS, Boston, 593 Boylston Street. MTAUNCY HALL SCHOOL (6gth Year), For Boys and Girls.—Preparation for the Mass. Institute of Technology is a specialty. Reference is made to the Institute Faculty. The location of the school building, on Copley bg eet is especially at- tractive and is very near the Institute. eparation also for College (with or without Greek)andforbusiness, Special students received. MASSACHUSETTS, Poston, 23 West Cedar St. OME FOR GIRLS, Where they have refined, cultivated surround- ings, are carefully chaperoned while studying with rivate teachers or in any Drivate school. Number imited to six. Address Mrs. T. 8. WInsLow. Refer- ences: Rev. E. E. Hale, D. D.; Rev. 8. H. Dana, D.D. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 17 Blagden Street. ISS CLAGETT’S BOARDING AND Day School for Girls reopens Oct. 3. Pupi re- ared for eollege. References: the Rt. Rev. Peni lips rooks, Boston; Mrs. Louis Agassiz, Cambridge ; Gen. F.A. Walker, Pres. Inst. of Technology, Boston MASSACHUSETTS, Bosto TSS FRAN CES y “EME RSON, Successor to Miss Abby H. Johnson. HOME ond mS SCHOOL for GIRLS, Newbury Street. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 5 Otis Place. R. HALE’S SCHOOL PREPARES for Harvard Collegs and the Massachusette In- stitute of Technology. The tenth year will begin Monday, October 3. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 64 Commonwealth Ave, ISS C. JF. CHAMBERLA YNE Wil, open a Home and Day Schoo! for Girls, October 5, 1892, Prospectus sent upon application, MASSACHUSETTS, Boston OSTON UNI VERSITY Law School. Address the Dean. EDMUND H. BENNETT, LL.D. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 112 Newbury Street. WE MISSES HUBBARD S SCHOOL for Girls wll spepen Cct. 3,1~92. A limited num- ber of boarding scholars will be received. MASSACHUSETTA, aay); 8 Garden St HE BROWNE AND NICHOLS School tor Boys.—Tenth | year opens Soot. 28, Admission examinations June 2 , Sept. Four boys received for summer work at Land's End, Rockport, Mass. Send tor circular. MASSACHUSETTS. Cambridge, 13 Appian Way. R FOSHUA KENDALL'S DAY and Family Schoo! for Boys. Fits for College. Phy- sical laboratory. Circulars. Address (till Sept. 15), Islesford, Hancock Co., Massacuusetts, Cambridge, 17 Berkeley St. ISS INGOLS’S SCHOOL FOR GIRLS will reopen 8e; t. 29, 1892.—Application may be made at 12 Concord Avenue. MASSACHUSETTS, Cambridge, 20 Mason Street. WE CAMBRIDGE SCHOOL. (Private—for Girls.) MASSACHUSETTS, Concora. ONCORD HOME SCHOOL.—25 BOYS prepared for college, scientific school, or busi- ness, All the advantages of family life combined with best mental and pbysical trainiog. Buildings new and according to latest yoda. 75 acres of ground. JAMES 8S, GARLAND, Master. MASSACHUSETTS, Duxbury WDER POINT SCHOOL. — PRE pares for Mass. Inst. of Tech., Harvard, or Busi- ness, Laboratories. Individual teaching. The 22 boys’ are members of the f-mily. Elementary classes for young boys. . B. KNAPP. S.B. MASSACHUSETTS, Greenfield. . OSPECT HILL SCHOOL FOR GIRLS. —Twenty- nao pA Year. Prepares for College. Also Science, Art, and Music. James C, Parsons, Principal. MASSACHUSETTS, Leicester. EICESTER ACADE: UY. .—r0g9th Year. Fall term begins Sept. 6,1892. English and om ay ical Courses. Prepares for Business and the best Colleges and Technical Schoo al Both sexes. C. F. PALM B., Prin. Address A. H. CooLipaes, President Of Trustees,

Page 3

Seeterhihotiaea

Sept. 1, I $92]

_The Nation. lll

: ittioma? MASSACHUSETTS, Lexington. OME SCHOOL FOR EIGHT BOYS preparing for Harvard. Grorer L. STOWELL.

MASSACHUSETTS, Plymout R. KNAPP’S HOME “SCHOOL FOR Boys.—12 boys; 25th ye H. W. RoyaL, (Harv.) Head Tistes. n. Mrs, KNAPP,

MASSACHUSETTS, Quincy. DAMS ACADEMY. — BOARDING and Preparatory School for Boys. Second term now in progress. For all particulars address WILLIAM EVERETT, Ph.D.

MASSACHUSETTS, South Braintree. HE THAYER ACADEMY. First Term, Sixteenth Yeur, begins September 14. Address J. B. SEWALL.

MASSACHUSETTS, Springfield. R. AND MRS MOH. v McDUFFIE'S School for Girls. Formerly | Miss Howard’s. MASSACHUSETTS, Wellesley WE WELLE SLEY HOME SCHOOL for Boys prepares tor College and Scientific Schools. Address Re ev. EDwaARD A. BENNER.

MASSACHUSETTS, West Newton. 40th year. EST NEWTON ENGLISH AND serene School.—A family school for girls and . paration for all high educational institu- aa and for a Bee useful life. For catalogue, address ALLEN BROTHERS,

MASSACHUSETTS, Worcester. WE HOME SCHOOL, Miss Kimball’s School for Girls. Wide-awake, thorough, progressive. Send for illustrated circular.

MASSACHUSETTS, Worcester. WE HIGHLAND MILITARY ACA- DEMY. 387thyeir. Cas ical, Scientific, Busi- ness, Preparatory Depts. Gymnasium. Stric: dis- cipline. Homecare. J. A. SHAW, A.M, Head Master. MASSACHUSETTS, Worcester. , R& THROGFS SCHOOL FOR Young Lad es and Children.—Col ege Prepara- tory or Special Cuurses. Reopens Sept. 28, L8y2. MASSACHUSRTTS, Worcester, 66 West Street. OHN W. DALZELL'’S PRIVATE School for Boys.—Prepares for College or Scien- tifle | School. Send ft rv Catalogue. MICHIGAN, Orchard Lake : : ; : ICHIGAN MILIT. 1k} ACADEMY. —A thoroughly equipped College Preparatory School, abreast of the most progressive Eastern Academies "Catalogue & sent bapon application. —y NEw HAmpPsHIRE, Mount Vernon. CCOLLOM INSTITUTE.—A_ COZ- lege graduate, 20 years a teacher, living in a beautiful mountain viitage 50 miles from .vos.on will take into his family six i aod will personal- ly prepare them for col.eze. r busin as. JOBN B. WELCH, A.M., Prin. NEw JERSEY, Rrid: reton pei TH FERSE Y INSTITUTE. —27a year be -ins Sept. 14 Bothsexes. Prepares for any College, Tenehioe. or Business. French, Ger- man, Art, Music, Military Driil, Gymnasium. ee Tatas I wh H. K. 1 TRASK, Prin. — NEw JERSEY, Burlington. . d T. MARY’S HALL.—CHRISTMAS Term en Sept. 21, 1892. Miss CHARLOTTE TITCOMB, Principal. —

New Jersey, Cranberry RIVATE HOME A. VD SCHOOL FOR feeble in mind. Rev. . ©. F. . GARRISON, Principal. — NEw JERSEY, Deckertown, Sussex County. EELEY’S SELECT BOARDING oe for Boys, ages. Terms, $225; no ex- w. H. SEBLRY, / A M.. Prin. NEW JERSEY, Montclair, 777 Bloomfleld Ave. ny ONTCLAIR MILITARY ACADEMY —Thirteen miles from New an summit of Orange Mountains. Cadets prepared for scientific schools, college, or business. ery pesos, _P. Hughes, Inspector-General oO Cadets live in a. "Wy avoiding the ft of dor- mitory life. J.Q@. MacVicar, A.M., Print ipal.

NEw JERSEY, Morristown. M ISS DANA'S BOARDING AND DAY School for Girls reopens Sept. 21. College pre- — Resite t French and German teachers, horough tastrectson in English. with speciai ad- vantages in Art, Music, and Deisarte Gymnastics, ‘rerms. including board and tuition in English, Latin, and G Greek, $70v, NEw JERSEY, Mount Holly. a OUNT HOLLY ACADEMY (sa s.—Healthful, helpful. homelike. Cata- sage, | ex: Session.) Fall opens sept. 13. J. J. COALB, A. M. | (Princeton), Principal — New JERSEY, Princeton. WE PRINCETON PREPARATORY Ly opens Sept. 21. mn may be ad- President Patton of neeton College, or to J. B. Pors, Head Master. FOR

Educotional NEW JERSEY, Trenton. DD PUY SCHOOL FOR BOYS.—A school for boys backward in their stud es Terms $000, No extras. Only six boar: ng pupils EDWARD D. MONTANYE, Master. New YORK, Albany. 5 ; T.AGNES’ SCHOOL.—UNDER TH: direction of Bishop Doane. 22d year. Full course. of study from Kindergurten through Har-

vard course fur Women. 3 instructors For Cata- lage, address St. Agnes School. NEw Yorx, Buffalo, st. M t’s Place. argare 4 SCHOOL.—FALL Primary and advanced courses of study Harvard examinations for women. Ful y equip gymnasium, Sargent system For circulars address Miss Tuck, Principal. MARGARET'S ad hee Sept. 21. New YORE, Buffalo. UFFALO SEMINARY. The forty-second year. For circulars address Mrs. C. PF. HaRTT, 2s4 Delaware Ave. New Yor«k, Long Island, Garden City. S PAUL'S SCHOOL. — PREPARES - forthe best Colleges, Scientific Schools, and Business. Fifteen masiers. Thoroughly equ pped laboratories and gymnasium. Military dr i ander U. 8. Army Officer. CHARLES STURTEVANT MOORE, A.B, (Harv.). Head Master,

New York, Geneva. ELANCE Y SCHOOL FOR GIRLS.— For circulars address Miss M. 8. Smart, Prin. New York, Kingston-on-Hudson, G2z DEN HILL PREPARATORY —_ School for Boys. JoHN M. Cross, A.M., Principal. Ni EW Y ORK, Manlius. Sf JOHN'S MILITARY SCHOOL — Givi ‘able ad , Cla-sical, Commercial, Spe- ec al,and Prepi:atory Cour-eupt. New York City, 109 West 54th Street. f/ ORKINGMAN'S SCHOOL, U-R. it of the Society for Ethical Culture.—A limited number of pay paptis will be taken; tuition fee sau and $100. — ourse of Instruction: Ali te usual Ens lish branches, M»nuai Training, Freehand Drawin and Modelling, Science teaching, German, Voca Music, and Gymnasties in all classes. Full ecraded course, including Kindergarten. In the Normal Traini ¢ D partment for Kindergart ers, sta ieats will receive regular instraction in Psychology, His- tory of Education, Art, Vorel Music, and Science, in addition to the training in kiodergarten methods proper; the full course covers two years. Schoo! opens Sept. 12. Applications received now at the school. M. P. E. GROsZzMANN, Superintendent. New YorK City, 43 West 47th St. CADEMIC CLASSES FOR GIRIS.— Preparatory and Primary AE i Mri Indi- vidualism in education. Special attention to college preparation. Native teachers in Modern Languages. Gymnasium. Resident students, Mary B. Wurron, 4.B., and Lors A. Banes (ermesty of 525 Park Avenue). New Y O8K Crrr. 63 Fifth Avenue. , HE MISSES GRAHAM (SUCCES- sors to the Misses Green). Established in 1816. This school continues the careful training and tho- rough instruction in every department for which it has hitherto Lay so favorably known. 77th year begins October New York C ITY. 9 West Lith Street. HE BRYANT SCHOOL FOR S7TAM- MERERS.—ThirteensA year. For the correction andcure of -tammering and all nervous defects of speech. Pupils sent us by Drs. Hammond. Starr, Se- guin, Lusk, and other specialists. Circulars upon ap- Plication. New YorE Cry, Nos. 6, &, and 10 Rast 534 St HE REED SCHOOL.—BOARDING and Day Schoo! for Giris. Primary, Preparato- ry, Collegiate, and Special Courses. Miss Jouia G. MCALLISTER, neipal; Mrs. SYLvanvus ReEp, Visit- or. Twenty-ninth year begins October 4, 1892.

New Yore crry, 6 West 48th Street. lv TSS SPENCE S BOARDING AND Day School for Girls. Primary, Academic, and College Preparatory Courses. Special students — No more than eight pupils constitute any

NEw Youe ¢ Crry, 2 Est sath St. HE MISSES GRINNELLS DA School for G ria reopens October 4. Collegiite, Academic, Preparatory, aud Primary Deparimeats. Kindergarten, October lu. °)

Naw Yorn Crry, Riverside Drive, 85th and s6to S.reets. 7 WIE MISSES ELY’S SCHOOL FOR Girls.—( Formeriy of Columbia Heights, Brook- lyn.) New Yorx Crry, 8. E. cor. Wes’ End Av. and 71st St. V3 6 Vv NORMAN INSTITUTE (Founded fur Young Ladies and ebiidren. Princt- pai, vo a® NogmMa™

Educational. Naw Yorx Crry, 1941 Madison a ASSICAL St HOO! F GIALS “Pri ary an! Advinced werk. ° ertifleates ac- cepted by Wellesley and ot = Colleges. Delsarte Gymoas¥cs. Reopens Sept ? LILa Y Norta, Principal. New Yor« Crrrv, 423 Madison Avenve ¢ fi. MORSE = = F{007 FOR BOYS , Will reopen October 3 The Principal's address until September 16, will be Cotuit, Ma~s. New Yore owe) 69 Bast 52d St. A ISS CRO "KER'S SCHOOL FOR Girls cnet at3] W. 42d 8t., will reopen Oc- tober 5. Classea for small boys New York Crrr, 55 West 47 th St VSS GIBBONS s COL FOR RES, é Saran H. EMERSON, Principal, will reopen Sep- temberws. A few boarding pups taken New Yorx Crrv, 52 and #4 Bast STth St | ISS PEEBLES AND MISS THOMP SON'S Boaridi and Day School for Girls re opens ‘Thursday, Octo yer 6, LNPD New Lae Saratoga Springs. EMPLE GROVE LADIES’ SEMINA RY. rq i facilities for the Higher Sciences, Philosop Anguages, Music, Painting, watheric ~ ee ye Seth year begina Sept vl Ad- Cuas. FP. Down, Ph.D. Pres. New Yor«, Sing Sing Sed JOHN’ S SCHOO! A mae 4) —) SON. D.D., Rector, Warren S Adanis, A.M. Aa- sociate Principal. A prepar-tory school of high rade, Military aystem heroughiy equipped la » Patory, EY moasium with «wimming tank, and pia grounds. Special care of vounger boys. ibe 24t year will begin September 20. New York, Syracu<e, Sn zoane s Street. a Se hool for ‘Girls, under the directio a the Misses Goodyear and Mr. Walter A. Burlingeme, will reopen Sept. 14, 18v2. For information address Miss FANNY GooprTrReaRr. New York, Tartrytown-on- Hudson ft / \ 4 ‘ \ . Ss | ‘ : , A P / A ‘ for College or Bosines Summ . n Jone lv’. Reopens Sept i4, Sot . 1M

FURMAN N Ew Y ORK, Tarty town "on8 Day School for Gtris. will reap en ‘Sey pt 20. Miss M. W. Metre . Prine ipal, NEw Yorx, Tivoli-on- Hudson. t ie RINITY SCHOOL.—ZOCA T7704 Id surroundings unsurpassed Equipment com- sete Gymnasium, drill hall, bowling aliers«, etc. herough preparation for col ewe, scientific schools, or business. JAMES STARR CLARK, D.D., Rector. NorTR CAROLINA, Asheville, 7 HE MAITLAND SCHOO! POR Girls, 40 French Broad Avenue, reopens Mon- day, September 26 Mrs. BR. MarTLann, Principal. NORTH CAROLIN A. Asheville, IAVENSCROF y \ atory Roarding Master, RONALD Mc

PAR- Onto, Cincinnat | SS £GFP 1 4 reoren 8 peem have taken successful tion for ad oi LC -- ‘ Atew boarding pupils be sent on a egpgaancea. “Onto, Cincinnati, Law. ARTHOLOME W Classical Home and Day ; Ladies. Thorough Courses in Ancien languages, Science and Mathematics admits to College. G. K. BARTHOLOMEW, Ph. D. Onto, Cincinnati, WeiInut Hills. : | TSS NOURSE WILL REOPEN HER English and French Family and Day School September 28, 1892. Pupils take special work or the tall course f: Fr college examinations. z Ont0, Cincinnati. Miss ARMSTRONG 'S SCHOOL FOR f Giris. Liddesdale Place, Avondale. Family limited. Circulars sent on application. Onto, Cincinnati. fr DEX PARK SCHOOL FOR GIRLS.— « Twelfth year begins Sept. 26. Resident pupile limited toten. For circular address Mme. FREDIN. Oxnt0, Columbus, 151 East Broad St. TSS PHELPS’S ENGLISH AND Classical School for Young Ladies.—Special ad- van in Language, Literature, Music. Art, Ora- tory, Physical and Social Culture. "Fall term begins Sept, 29, }, 1892.

PENNSYLVANIA, Bryn — BALDWIN’ = "DA Y, BOARD- and as e Spepeeeions Senet for Girla foupenn pt. 28. ‘or circular ad as Miss FrorReNce BALDWIN.

Page 4

lV The Nation.

[Vol. 55, No. 1418

Educational, PRNNSYLVANIA, Bryn Mawr, 10 miles from Philada. RYN MAWR COLLEGE, A COLLEGE for Women, offers graduate and undergraduate courses in Sanskrit, Greek, ey Mathematics, Eng- lish, Anglo-Saxon. French, Old French, It Iian- Spa- nish German, including Poi and Old High Ger- man, Ce/tic, Hebrew, History, Political Science, Phy- sics, Chemistry. B ologv,and lectures on Philosophy. ymnas um, with Dr. 8 ent’s ap aratus compiete’ Fellowships (value $50!) in Greek, English, Latin, Mathematics, History, and Biology. For Program, dress as above.

wa Ae 4

PENNSYLVANIA, Chester. “ad dag f VANIA MILITARY ACA- EMY. 31st year begins September 14, 1892. °o A Miltary’ Oe ye Degrees in Civil Engineering, tecethie ceqnniees Preperotery Department. STA BLISH- ed in 1885. Chartered in 1887. A School for yaand Young Men. Will receive fifteen resident pupils. The Annual Register, with tull information, sent on application. Grores A. PERRY, A.M., Head Master. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, Germantown, 204, 204, 335 W, Chelten Ave. TSS MARY E. STEVENS’ BOARD- ing and Day Schoo .—24th year. “Approved” by Bryn Mawr College. The Bryn Mawr entrance examinations are held tn the school by an examiner from the college. Schoi certificate ai mits to Va-sar. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadeiphia. Chestnut Hill. Ae COMEGYS AND MISS BELL'S nglish, French, and German Boarding-School for Rn, ne ladies reopens Sept. 23. Students prepared for coliege. Ample srounds for outdoor exercise. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, 2037 De Lancey Place (former ly 2106 Spruce Street). TSS GIBSON’S FAMILY AND DAY School for Girls. Fali term begins Seotember i. 1892. Home pupils limited. Preparation for Col- ege. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, 2045 Walnut St. EST WALNUT STREET SEMI- NARY for Young Ladies. 26th Year. Is pro- vided for giving a superior education in Collegiate, Eclectic, and Preparatory Departments; also in Music and Art, Mrs. HENRIETTA Kurz PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelph a, 1350 Pine St. ISS ANABLE’S English, French, and German Boarding and Day School. 44th year. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, Germantown. ERMANTOWN ACADEMY, — ES- tablished 1760. Bight boerding pee Sakon. ERSHA PENNSYLVANIA, West Phils delphia. (2OkGE F. MARTIN’S SCHOOL FOR 7 Boys Established 1882. 6 boarding pupils taken. SouTs DaKkorT:, Sioux Falls. LL SAINTS’ SCHOOL.—A BOARD- ing and Day School for Young Ladies and Chil- dren, e school has special advantages; the terms are moderate; the building has every modern con- venience; Bishop Hare makes it his home. The h and dry air of South Dakota proves often very salutary to those who need such a tonic. Sioux Falls may be reached by five of the great railroads of the country. For particulars addre ALL Saints’ SCHOOL.

~~ VERMONT, Burling ERMONT EPISCOPAL INSTI- TUTE.—Home Schoo! for Boys. Prepares for college or business. Military drill; wholesome dis- cipline; most beautiful and healthful location in the country. Terms, $37 H. H. Ross, A.M., Principal. VIRGINIA, Bellevue

ELLEVUE HIGH SCHOOL.—T7HO- ag W. R. Apsor, Principal. as |youns me

OUTH OF FRANCE.—A FRENCH University Professor will accept two bovs in his family. Board, with lessons in French, $500 a year eac Boys sent to Lyceum if eee Cli- mate very mild "ind salubrious. Addres M. DE RUTHIE, noon France. "HARVARD GRADUATE AND German Ph.D, of exper ence wisbes to tutor forthe September examinations. Highly recom- mended. pon H. H. B., the Nation. ANUAL TRAINING TEACHER DE- sires position. Threeyears’ experience: wood work, iron work, drawing. Address Cus. A. HEATH, Brookline, Mass. VUNG LADY WHO HAS HAD several years’ experience in a library would like position. Address F. G., Nation office. WARLES W. STONE, Tutor ie Har- vard, 68 Chestnut St., Boston.

School Agencies. et) SCHOOL AND COLLEGE BU- AU, Elmhurst, (Chicago), Ill.. supplies col- legos, poet og academies, publie schools, etc, with the best teachers. Records of candiaates tho- roughly investigated and full information furnished to emplovers free of a Send for list of availa- ble candidates. Address ©. J. ALBERT, Tine Th.

HE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES, 7 Tremont Place. Boston, Mass., 70 Fifth Ave. - ¥.,106 Wabash Ave, Chicago, lil., and 371 Main Btrest Hartford, Conn. = -page Agen tT - r EVERETT ( AE NEI Ww A MERICA N TE ACHE RS Aaency.--Teachers seeking positions and those wishing a change at an ay, salary, shou'd ad, dress C. B. RuGGLEs & Co., (Palace Hotel Building} Room C, 237 Vine 8t., Cincinnati, O q: MERICAN AND FOREIGN Professors tutors governess, teachers, etc., supplied to Colleges, schools, and Jy ye MIRIAM COYRIEER, 50 Sth Ave., cor. 20th St., N. ¥ CHERMERHORN’S TEACHERS Agency. Oldest and best known in the U. 8. Hstablished 1855. 3 East 14th 8t., N. Y. NE. BUREAU OF EDUCATION Reasons why this Bureau has gained and deserves the confidence and patronage of so large a con- stituency of teachers and school officers ali over the nation. (1.) Because it is the oldest Teachers’ Agency in New England, having been established in 1875. (2.) Because its Manager for the last eleven years isa professional educator, and has become familiar with the condition and wants of every arade of schools and the necessary qualifications of teachers. (3.) Because the number of our candidates is large, and embrac’s many of the ablest teachers, male and female, in the profession. (4.) Because a'l applications for teachers receive prompt and careful attention. ‘}.) Because our pledge for fair dealing and de- votion to the interests of our patrons has been re- deemed. No charge to school officers. Forms and Circulars sent FREE. Register now !or the autumn vacan- cies; for winter and spring as well, as the de- mand is constant. Apply to HIRAM ORCUTT, Manager, 3 Somerset St., Boston. ANT AGENCY fate” fe Aorta of vacancies and THAT is aw... but it it if it tells you gy nog . is —_ to recom- snends yen, “that is mare. "Ou < 7s RECOMMENDS Cc. W. BARDEEN, 7 nna N. Y.

Educational. The Columbian University, WASHINGTON, D. C.

The OCoiumbian College opens.............--..Sept. 19 The Medical School of the University opens...Oct. 3 The Dental School of the University opens....Oct. 3 The Corcoran Scientific School opens........... Oct 5 The Law School of the University opens....... Oct. 5 THE LAW SCHOOL FACULTY. JAMES ©. WELLING, LL.D., President, And Professor of Pune oe and Private International

HE Hon. JOHN M. HARLAN, LL.D., (imental Justice of the Supreme Court ‘of the United States ) Professor of the Constitutional Jurisprudence of the Uni'ed States, of tue Law of Domestic Rela- tions. of Commercial Paper, and of Torts. THE Hon. WALTER 8, COX, LL.D. (Associate Justice of the Supreme Oourt of the Dis- tr ct of Columbia ) Professor of the Law of Realand Personal Property, of Contracts, and of Cr.mes and as THE Hon. WILLIAM A. MAURY. (Assis ant Attorn y-Generai of the United Bietes. ) frofessor of Equity Jurisprudence, of Common Law and Equity Piead ng, and of the Law of Evidence. THE Hon. DAVID J BREWER, LL.D (Associate Justice of the Sapreine ‘Court of the nited States.) Professor of ihe Law of Corporations, Pror. G. H. EMMO'1T, A.M., LL.B., (of the Johns Hopkins University,) Lecturer on the Civil Law. HENRY E. DAVIS, A.M., LL.M., (Sometime Assistant At oraey of the District of Columbia. Professor of Common Law Practice, and Lecturer on the History of Law Tus Hon. AUGUSCUs 8S. WOR! HINGTON LL.B. pa ometime Distr ct Attorney of the United States. § cturer on Lexal Bibliography and the Use of Au- thorities in Court. WILLIAM F. MATTINGLY, Esgq., (of the Washington Bar.) Lecturer on + ractical Commercial Law. THE non, Bed fener EDGAR SIMONDS, A.M.,LL.B., (United States C missioner of Patents.) Proiessor of the Law of Patents. THE Hon. ANDR2W C. BRADLEY, (Associate Justice of the Supreme Court ot the Dis- trict of Columbia.) Lecturer on Criminal Law, and on Criminal Plead- ing and Practice, WILLIAM G. JOHNSON, LL.M., (of the Washin.ton Bar.) Judge of Moot Court, and Professor of Legal Cate- chetics, Prof. Wm. G. Johnson. LL.M., will conduct quiz- zing classes, composed of #1l students in the Under- graduate Department, that by his catechetical analysis the teachings of both lectures and text- books may be impressed upon the memories of i\e pupils. This school opens Oct. 5. For catalogues, giving description of the Lecture Courses in the Undergraduate and Graduate De- partments, address JAMES ©. WRIESRG. LL.D., President. MUSEUM OF FINE ARTS, COPLEY SQUARE, BOSTON, MASS. SCHOOL OF DRAWING AND PAINTING. The Seventeenth Year will Open Oct. 3. Courses in drawing from the cast and from life in painting and in decorative design, with lectures on anatomy and perspective. Principal instructors: te Benson, E. Tarbell (Drawing and Painti: CG. Howard Walker, J. oe Smith (Decoration), pa: ward Emerson (Anatomy) and A. K. Cross (Perapec- tive). Pupils are allow: the free use of the eries the Museum. For circulars giving detailed inform- ation, address Miss ELIZABETH LOMBARD, Manager. WILSON COLLEGE FOR WOMEN. Fifty miles southwest of Harrisb Pa., in famous Cumberland Valley. Six trains daily. order climate, avoiding bleak north. $250 per year for board, room, etc., and all college studies except music and art. Large music college and art —, ae department this year, 154, independent of free classes. Full faculty. College course, B.A. and B.8. o es; mate college, B.M. Handsome park, yn te heat, eymnasiam, observatory, laboratories, Sto. No charge for distant pupils during Christmas and Eas- ter vacations. ev. J, EDGAR, Ph.D., Pres Chambersburg, 1856 MARYLAND 1892 AGRICULTURAL COLLEGE. OPENS Sige SEPT., Masog Situation Ser wi 4 health i? miles from Washineton, on the oO. R. R. Laeccenerel, © Scientific, Classical. Sot ness, ar Military Courses. Full Corps of Profes- sors. Terms, $140, gw gh Books beens tg Washing, Room ren Heat. Prepa ry De- partment in oes experienced t instructors. Fall particulars. Addre Maryland Agricultural College, College Pat Park. Md. HAMPDEN-SIDNEY COLLEGE. The 117th Session wilt open Sons. 15. For Oata- logues and other information iy to RICHARD MCILWAINE, hi, Hampden-Sidney, Vs.

ayo NE Sp yo I i ~ sy

Page 5

Tina P

—_—e A RNIN me ——— Se

Sept. 1, 1892] Educational. THE OHIO UNIVERSITY AT ATHENS now Offers ten t- graduate scholar- ships having a cash value of $100 each, exclusive of tuition. Th subjects are as follow«: Bnoglish Lite- rature, Mathematics, Latin, Psychology, His ory of Education, Chemistry, Biology, Physics. Philoso- pb = Italso embraces effi.ient Preparatory a Un dergraduate Departments. A thoroughly or- oised School of Ped FP. Gordy is ahesie © Pe

ey uncer the charge of Dr. process of developme ‘t. ARLES W. SUPER, President. OGONTZ SCHOOL FOR YOUNG LADIES. Established in 1850. Twenty minutes from Phila- delphie, two hours from New York. Opens Sep- r 28th. For circulars and reports apply OGONTZ SCHOOL P. O., PA.

Ft. Edward Collegiate Institute. | 35th year Sept. 19. $270. Superb modern buildings and appointments; steam heat; rooms for 100 young women and for 1: J gevcncoets and teachers; 6 gradu- ati courses and preparatory; intelligent care of health, morals,and ma iners; San ten thorough dept’s ‘of Art, Music, Elocution and, Languages. See illus, catalogue. Jos. E. Kina, D.D., Ft. Edward, N. Y, Worcester (Mass.) Polytechnic Institute Offers five courses of study, viz.: Civil, lectrical,and Mechanical Engineering, and Physical and Political Science. Unsurpassed (acili- ba for laboratory and shup work, For Catalogue, address cnet, or UNIVERSITY LAW SCHOOL. ty '3% aio ior graduate course) LL.M. Avstin Apsort, LL.D., Deanand Senior Professor. For Catalogue, showing tee Faculty, address Prof. I. F. Russge.i, University Building, Or 120 Broadway. New York City. UNIVERSITY OF MARYLAND, CULTY OF PHYSIC. The 86th enema session will begin Oct. 3, 1892, and will end in April, 1893. Ample c'inicaland laboratory re. Cireulars will be sent on application to I. E. ATKINSON,M.D., Dean, 605 Cathedral St., Balti- more.

In Chemistry,

The Thirty-rourth Year begins Oct.

THE CLAVERACK COLLEGE AND HUDSON RIVER INSTITUTE For Young Men and Women. will open its 39th year Sept. 19. For catalogues address Rev. A. H. FLac om, A... Pres't, Claverack, N Siglar’s Preparatory Sr ($600), Newburgh, N. Y. Opens September 14. Norooms kept for boys not arranged tor. HENRY |} Ww. . SIGLAR. WELLS COLLEGE 7oncxo%*: AURORA, N.Y. Three Full Courses of Study. Location beautiful and healthful. New Building with Modern Improve- ments. Session begins September 21, 1892. Send for Catalogue. E. 8. FRISBEE, D.D., President.

Pennsylvania College of Dental Surgery. The 37th Annual Session Oct. 3, 1892. Clinics ten months inthe year. Women admitted. For informa- tion address C. N. Pzircg, D.D.8., Dean, 1415 Walnut Street, Philadelphia, Pa.

THE BAKER&

The Nation. % Cl ance at the Difficulties of German Grammar. (1) Verjdhiedenartiges (Miscellaneous (2) Seitwerter Verbs) 3) Dieg gung der Seitworter COMPILED BY CHARLES FE. Ct Price, 50 cents. TING, Liberal Terms to Teachers For sale by Foreign Booksellers and } y the Publishers bia eo CROOM & COoMPANy, 2 St ate St reet, E 30ston, M iSSs, THIRD EDI ION Now READY University Publishing Co. EDUCA TION PUBL EK NEW YORK, BOSTON, NEW ORLEANS

Holmes’ Readers, Davis’ Readers, Venable’s Arithmetics, Sanford’s Arithmetics, - Maury’s Geographies, Gildersleeve’s Latin, ete G2" Please write for Catalocue and prices Dr. Sauveur’s New Editions. CAUSERITIES AVEC MF8 ELEVES, PETITES CAl SERIES, and LA P AROLE FRANCAISE. suj plemented with exercises and trans.ations La me Francaise hast a te ar vocabulart UST vtT PREMIERES LECONS DE GRAMM Ai FRAN CAISE, by Marie Sauveur and Sus ‘s Retail price, Yo cents A copy of any of Dr. Sauveur’s works w t sent to teachers only, on receipt of half the reta price and U0 cents for p ostace, by Send tor circulars om L. SAUVE 6c *y St., Roxbury, Mass RIVERVIEW sAGA25uy POUGHKEEPSIE, N.Y 57th year. Prepares thoroughly for Coliege. the Government. Academies, and Businesa M ganization. BOYS litary Or- BisBEes & AMEN, Principals. ‘FIT FOR COLLEGE OR BU SINESS, aT YF reehold Institute, N.J. Quil coe.

Vv FRENCH BOOKS And Books WILLIAM

the %¥ * . ’ oe * — ther Foreign Languages s BLISHED BY R. JENKINS \ . \ R NT \ \ IN ONG EE M N ¢ By e la \ ; . 13 I .t s W eX ‘ es by F. ¢ . Aas _ M ce l ul ‘ va : t ™ rit ENCH VI \ ~ De V 1 l peures. $1 LE FRANCAIS \ By Au £1.00 I CHAN PU CYG By res | N 16 Aber, CAMILLA ALIAN Ky } \ Ww x ’ ¥ notes ‘ ce “ BOUDERIE, Ry Maurice 1 pei eDiLs A piay i % IN PRE PARATIO N. To be ready Oct ris DES KINDES } rt Na “au @rey's Pre er Live es Eofante By Voo Wilbe e ta LA LIZARDIERE By Hen e Bor N ~mMoO, Pay . LES PROSATI TANCAIS XIN Ry Prof t a $1.25 ag ‘1 \* Ss CO; s Pr 74, Ww ral grat ai aketch a t nk lish by t astegnies e.-S FABLES CHOISIES I LA FONTAINE W ‘ preface a at ra y au hor haxslish es by J iofthe Brea FORTHCOMING FRENCH PUBLI CATIONS NANOS Sa wili for ‘ ‘ wil ta br WW “ r 1 Fre t umbia s New s s sued of *Quatrev t Viet Hug 1M au list y a R * mene KE Abou et Mon yd ti Ml s ~e r e \ my r e a 6to Ave., New York

Page 6

vi The Nation. [Vol. 55, No. 1418 Professors and Instructors who contemplate changing Text-Books are cordially invited to consider the following books published by Harper & Brothers. : ~ To facilitate and popularize the study of General Literature Ancient Literature. by furnishing nocunhins and pnts sila iota text-book on Cloth, $1 20. the subject was the aim of Prof. Joun D.QuackeENnzos in the preparation of his Illustrated History of Oriental and Classical Literature. An examina- tion of this work will show it to be all that could be desired as a manual of instruction. The following Anglo Saxon studies, by Dr. Francis A. Marcu of La- Anglo-Saxon. fayette College, are offered for the consideration of instructors in that subject: A Comparative Grammar of the Anglo-Saxon Lan- guage, in which its forms are illustrated by those of the Sanscrit, Greek, Latin, Gothic, Old Saxon, Old Friesic, Old Norse, and Old High German. Price $1 80.—An Anglo-Saxon Reader with Philological Notes: a Brief Grammar and a Vocabulary. Price $1 10—A Method of Philological Study of the English Language. Price 55 cents. The Sixth edition of Dr. Simon Newcoms’s Popular Astronomy. places Astronomy. that book in the front rank of class-books. The historic and philosophic sides of the subject have been treated with greater fulness than is usual in works of this character, while the purely technical side has been proportionately condensed. Price $1 30.—Recreations in Astronomy, with Directions for Practical Experiments in Telescopic Work, by Henry Wuite Warkey, is an original and interesting text-book. Price $1 25. j Of the books published in this branch of study the attention of professors Bible Study. and instructors is invited to Smith’s Old Testament and New Testa- ment History, published at $1 25 each,and Smith’s Smaller Scripture History, at 60 cents. The SMALLER Scripture History is perhaps more widely used than any other text-book on that subject. Thayer’s Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testa- ment, price $6 50; Westcott & Hort’s Greek-English Testament, price $3 50; and Westcott & Hort’s Greek New Testament, Student’s Edition, price $1 00, are all standard works, and are largely used by Bible students. En lish Words English Words, by Prof. Cuarves F. Jounson of Trinity College, 4 * Hartford, Conn.,is a book which aims at making Etymology sugges Cloth, &4 cents. tive and interesting, and at presenting the elements of the subject in such a form as to stimulate further investigation and lead to a more correct and literary use of words. The author has expressed himself in so happy and entertaining a manner that his book is as charming as a good story. : : Inthe series of ENGLisH Cuiassics, prepared by Dr. Wm. J] Rotre English Classics. and published with notes and illustrations, teachers will find aids to Cloth, 56 cents; Paper, gocents. — their work which are rarely equalled. ‘His rare abilities asa teacher,” says the Louzsuclle Courzer-Journal, ‘“‘enable him to prepare Classics like these in the best manner for school use.”’ ‘He has done his work ina manner that comes as near to perfec- tion as man can approach,” says the Boston Traveller. Browning’s Blot in the ’Scutcheon and Select Poems of Oliver Goldsmith, Select Poems of Thomas Gray, The Minor Poems of John Milton, The Lays of Ancient Rome, and Select Poems of William Wordsworth are contained in this series. No edition of Shakespeare so well answers the needs of the class room Shakespeare. as that prepared by Dr Ws J. Rotre of Cambridge, Mass. Dr. Roirr Cloth, 56 cents; Paper, go cents. is not only a conscientious but a brilliant worker, and has a wide reputa- tion asa Shakespearian scholar of great aoility. His edition is the only illustrated school edition published in this or any other country, and no teacher can fail to appreciate the rare discrimina- tion shown in the preparation of the author’s Notes and Introductions to Shakespeare’s Plays. The series is complete in forty volumes.

Page 7

Sept. J, 1892] The Nation. Vil . The Principles of Rhetoric and their Application, with an Appendix Pre Rhetoric. senting General Rules for Punctuation, by Prof. Apams SHERMAN HILt of Har- vard U niversity, is a text-book de ‘serving of the highest praise. The author treats the subject from the standpoint of a scholar and teacher, ‘and consequently made a representa- tive class-book. Price 80 cents Four other good books, namely, De Mulle’s Rhetoric, —emented Rhetoric, Boyd’s Rhetoric, and Whately’ s Rhetoric, are offered, each of which treats th subject in an original and characteristic manner. Under the editorial supervision of Dr. Henry Drister of Columbia College, the Greek. following texts have been issued: The Olympic and Pythian Odes of Pindar. With Critical and Explanatory Notes. By Dr. Gitperstreve —The Antigone of Sophocles. With Introduction, Notes, and Appendix. By Prof. Micron W. Humpureys of the University of Virginia.—Sicilian Expedition of Thucydides. With In- troduction and Notes. By Prof. W. A. Lamberton of Lehigh University.-.-Books VI. and VII. of Herodotus. With Introduction and Notes. By Dr. aA. C. Merriam of Columbia Col lege.— The Protagoras of Plato. With Introduction and Notes. By Dr. E.G. Situs The Iliad of Homer. With Introduction and Notes. By Dr. W.S. Tyter of Amherst Col- lege —The Phzacians of Homer. With Introduction and Notes. By Dr. A. C. Mexsian ot Columbia College—Stories from Herodotus and the Seventh Book of the History. With Notes. By Dr. Roperr P. Keep of Norwich Academy. , Under the editorial supervision of Dr. Henry Drisier of Columbia College, the fol- Latin. lowing texts have been issued: The Satires of Persius. Edited by Dr. Ginper- SLEEVE of the University of Virginia.—Three Plays of Plautus. With Notes. By Prof. C. S. Harrincron of Wesleyan University.—The Captives of Plautus. Edited by Dr. Joun Prouprir of Rutgers College. —The Andria and Heauton Timorumenos of Terence. With Notes. By Dr. ANpREW F. West of Princeton Colle ‘ge. Cato Major and Laelius of Cicero. With Introduction and Commentary, and the Offices of Cicero. Wich Introductory Essay and Commentary. By Prof. Austin Stickney, formerly of Trinity College —The Moral Essays of oe Edited with Notes. By Drs. Joun F. Hursrand Hexry C. Waitin , ‘he Student’s Series of Histories, containing twenty-five volumes, is widely History. bie favorably known among schools. Each volume is acknowledg to be the best summary in our language of the particular branch of Knowle ie ‘to which it belongs. Three volumes of the series are devoted to Ancient History, two to Church His- tory, one to Medizwval History, four to the History of England, one to France, one to Modern History, one to Germany, four to Greece, one to Persia, and tive to Rome. Full information of the entire series will be forwarded on request. For preparatory work the Smaller Histories are particularly suitable. I | i. The Outlines of International Law, with an Account of nternationa AW. its Origin and Sources and of its Historic al Development, by Price $2 0 Grorcrt B. Davis, U.S.A, Ass istant Professor at the WU. S. Military Ac: iseuie West P oint, is a work sufficiently elementary in character to be within the reach of students who me Ly desire to eg ain some knowle rer ve of the ye nera “al prince ip] es ol this Sl ubj ect. Mvtholo A Mythology of Greece and Rome, Pichincha spats Referen y SY: to its Use in Art, is a translation from the German of Prof.O. Seemann. The book, in a moderate compass, gives a clear and readable account of the le- gends of Pri am and makes an admirable class book for secondary schools. ce ? ' i Pri OO ¢ An excellent text-book on Psychology, by Dr. Joun Dewey of the Uni- Psychology. ve neha of Michig ran, is offered to protessors and instructors interested in this subject. Price $1 25. -An Introduction to Psychological Theory, and Metaphysics: a Study in first Principles, by Prof. Borpen P. Bowne of Boston University, bear the impress of a fine scholar and a true metaphysician. They will well repay an examination. 7, | The late Dr. James Orron’s work on Comparative Zoology is a manual of pede OBY: instruction parexce(lence. Its merits have been recognized, as its extensive use in ce $1 80 the class-room shows. The estadlished facts and principles of Zoology are clearly nel out, and it is believed that the arrangement of the work will especially commend itself to a teacher, A handsome illustrated Bulletin of Text-Books for Schools and Colleges will be forwarded on request. HARPER & BROTHERS, Pustisuers, New York.

Page 8

Vili The Nation. [Vol. 55, No. 1418 NEw AND FORTHCOMING BOOKS. Books of which the prices are given are ready, Goodwin’s Greek Grammar. Revision of 1892. By W. W. Goopwin, Professor of Greek in Harvard University, Price, by mail. postpaid. $1.65. No difficulty will be experienced in using the new edition of Goodwin's Grammar with texts that re’er to the former edition. A complete table of parallel references is given at the beginning of the new edition, First Four Books of Xenophon’s Anabasis. With an Illustrated Vocabulary. Edited by Professors W. W. Goopwin and Joan Wi LuiAMs Ware of Harvard University. 12mo. Half morocco. 355 pazes. Price, by mail, postpaid, $1.65; without Vocabulary, $1.10. The Beginner’s Greek Book. By JoHN WiLLIAMs WuitTe, Professor of Greek in Harvard University. [Ready by September 15.] Harvard Studies in Classical Philology. (Volume III., 1892.) 8vo. Boards. vi + 203 pages. Price, $1.30. An Avesta Grammar in Comparison with Sanskrit. By A. V. WILLIAMS JACKSON, Protessor in Columbia College, New York City. Parti. Phonology, Inflections, Word Formation, and an Intro tuction on the Avesta, or the Sacred Books of the Parsis. 8vo. pp. xlviii + 280. Price, by mail, postpaid, $2.25. Old Persian Grammar. With the Inscriptions of the Achzemenian Kings and a Vo- eabulary. By Heasert Cosnine ToLMAN, Ph.D. Assistant Pro‘essor of Sanskrit and Instructor in Latin of the University 0 Wisconsin. Long 24mo. Limp Cloth. 54-+55 pages. Price, by mail, postpaid, $1.00. — on the History of Classical Philology. By Dr. ALFRED GuDEMAN. [In press. Victor Hugo’s Quatrevingt-Treaize. Elited by James BorELLe, B. A. (Univ. Gall.), Senior French Master in Dulwich Colleze, England. Revised for American Schools. [Ready in Sep- tember. } La Chanson de Roland, (Extraits de la Chanson de Roland.) Redaction de Gaston Paris, Membre de Ilustitut. [Ready in September. ] La Cigale chez les Fourmis. Comédie en un Acte, par Legouvé et Labiche. With En ziish Notes by ALPHonse N. vAN DAELL, Professor of Moijern Languages in the Massachusetts In- stitute of Technology. [Ready in September or October. ] Soll und Haben. Von Gustav FreytTaG. Elited and Annotated by Iba W. BULT- MANN, Teacher of German in the Free Academy, Norwich, Conn. 12mo. Cioth. vi+ 218 pages. Price, by mail, post paid, 70 cents, Dietegen : Novelle von GOTTFRIED KELLER. With Introduction and Notes by Gustav Gruener, Tutor in German in Yale University. [Ready in September or October. Studies and Notes in Philology and Literature. Published under the direction ot the Modern Language Departments of Harvard University. VolumeI. Teacher's price, $1.00. Addison’s Criticisms on Paradise Lost. Edited by ALBERT S. Cook, Professor of the English Language and Literature in Yale Uriversity. [Ready in September. } The Art of Poetry: The poetical treatises of Horace, Vida, and Boileau, with the translations by Howes, Pitt. and Soames. Elitel by ALBert S. Cook, Professor of the English Lan- guage and Literiture in Yale University. [teady in September. ] Analytics of English Prose and Poetry. A Manual for the Objective Study of English Prose and Poetry. By L. A. SHzamas, Professor of English Literature in the University of Nebraska. [Ready in October. | A Primer of English Verse. By Hrram Corson, Professor of English Literature in Cornell University. 12mo. Cloth. iv+ 232 pages. Price, by mail, postpaid, $1.10. Cardinal Newman’s Essay on Poetry, with reference to Aristotle’s Poetics. Edited, with Introduction and Notes, by ALBert 8S. Cook, Professor of English in Yale University. 8vo. Limp cloth, with wide margins for notes. x-+ 36 pages. Price, by mail, postpaid, 35 cents, Ben Jonson’s Timber: or, Discoveries; Made upon Men and Matter, as they have Flowed out of his Daily Reading, or had their Reflux to his Peculiar Notiors of the Times. Edite., with introduction an! notes, by Feurx E. ScHELU:NG, Professor in the University of Pennsylvania. 1zmo. Cioth, xxxvili+ 166 pages. Price, by mail postpaid, 90 cenjs. The Beginner’s American History. By D. H. MontGomery. The subject is treated in thirty short biographies of the greatest Americans. 12mo, 234 pages, handsomely illustrated. Price, by mail, postpaid. 70 cents Recent Archeological Explorations in the Vailey of the Del--re River. By Cc. C. Asporr, M.D., Curator of the Museum of American Archeology. Price > stpaid, 80 cents. POLITICAL SCIENCE QUARTERLY. THE AMERICAN METEOROLOGICAL JOURNAL. SCHOOL AND COLLEGE. THE PHILOSOPHICAL REVIEW. JOURNAL OF MORPHOLOGY. THE YALE REVIEW. GINN & COM PANY, PuBLISHERS, ____ Boston, New York, Chicago. _ TIFFANY GLASS & DECORATING COMPANY *FURNISHERS:& GLASS‘WORKERS:DOMESTIC:& ECCLESIASTICAL: ‘DECORATIONS ‘ MEMORIALS: '333°'T0'341' FOURTH AVENUE'NEW'‘YORK’ N. B.——-WE WILL ESTEEM THE MENTION OF THIS PAPER A FAVOR. -ESTABLISHED 1858, ‘H.-H... UPHAM’&:CO.: | | | Cott, M E M 0 R IA L ‘TA B # E i S: Brown Brothers & Co,, Bankers, | IN: BRASS: AND: BRONZE: NO. 59 WALL STREET, NEW YORK. “54 South: Fifth Ave. near Bleecker’ St. H WILLIAMS, 195 W. 10TH ST., N. Y., dealer in Magazines and other peri- *NEW ° YORK: Oodicals, Sets, volumes, or single numbers, “ We buy and sell bills of exchange on | Letters and make C. ble Transfers of money to of Europe,Australia, andtie West Indies; also make coliections and issue Com- ? Leading Reference Books for the Office, Home, and School Library. THE NEW CHAMBERSS ENCYCLOPAEDIA. NEW TYPE. NEW SUBJECTS. NEW ILLUSTRATIONS. NEW MAPS. A DICTIONARY OF UNIVERSAL KNOWLEDGE. Complete in ten volumes. Price per volume: Cloth, $3.00; Sheep, $4.00; Half Morocco, $4.50. Woigs. Ll 5 PEE ho Vy ds, FEL, VERT, and IX, Ready. Vol. X. Ready in December. Specimen Pages mailed free to any address, This great work has been reédited, reset in clear, distinct type, and beautified with new illustrations and maps. The old articles have been rewritten so as to incorporate the latest information, and thou-ands of new ones intro- duced upon the subjects of Art, Science, Lite- rature, History, Biography, etc. The number of American articles has been greatly increas- ed, so that the present is more distinctly Ame- rican than former editions. The articles in every department are based upon the latest re- searches and investigations, and the census statistics are those of 1890-91. When completed it will be at least fifteen years later than any other Encyclopsedia extant. Worcester’s Dictionary Is the standard authority on all questions of Or- thography, Pronunciation, and Definition. and is so recognized by the colleges of the country, by the principal newspapers and periodicals, and by such leaders of American thought as Phillips Brooks, Edward Everett Hale, George Bancroft, Oliver Wendell Holmes, Irving, Marsh, Agassiz, Henry, etc. Leading book publishers recognize Worcester as the hi hest authority, and millions of school-books are issued every year with this great work as the standard. Sample pages and prices upon application. * aa b ] ° Lippincott’s Pronouncing Biographical Dictionary. Containing Complete and Concise Biographical Sketches of the Eminent Persons of all Ages and Countries. By J. THomas, M.D., LL.D. 1 vol., imperial 8vo, 2,550 pages. Sheep, $12; half morocco, $15; half Russia, $15. “Tt is a treasure-house of information; a text- book of necessity, embracing many subjects besides biography. Members of the C. L. 8. C. should in- clude it in the formation or building up of astan- dard library.’’—J. H. Vincent, Chancellor Chautau- qua University. For particulars, specimen pages, etc., address J. B. LIPPINCOTT CO,, 715 and 717 Market St., Philadelphia, y Biss: + a Sl cacumememennusesceneeme

Page 9

The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 1, 1892. The Week. THE correspondence between Secretary of State Foster and Mr. Herbert, the British Chargé d’Affaires, narrows itself to the single question whether the promise of the Canadian Government to abolish the discriminating rebates after the close of the present season ought to be taken as a suffi- cient concession on their part, and whether the President ought therefore to have withheld his proclamation regarding tolls on the Sault Ste. Marie Canal under the recent act of Congress. Mr. Fos- ter shows that no option was left to the President by the act referred to. If he was satisfied that the discrimination existed, he was to issue the proclamation. He had discretion as to the amount of the toll to be levied at the Sault Canal, but not as to the levying of some amount. It would have been mere affectation for the President to say that he was not satisfied of the fact of discrimination when that fact had been admitted by the other side, and was sought to be defended on various grounds. Being convinced of the fact, he had nothing to do but to determine the amount of the tolls to be imposed on Canadian vessels or property passing through the Sault Canal, and in this he was certainly moderate. It would have been better, in our view, if Congress had made the act prospective in its operation. If it had provided for the imposition of tolls at the Sault after the close of the present sea- son, probably all friction would have been avoided. As the matter is of small mo- ment any way, it would have been worth the taking cf some pains to avoid a diffi- culty. Premier Abbott inherited this em- barrassment from Premier Macdonald. That thrifty statesman found it necessary, in a certain political emergency, to con- ciliate the town of Kingston in order to get votes. He accomplished his end by making a discriminating rebate of canal tolls, the effect of which was to make Kingston a better transshipping point than Ogdensburg. The discrimina- tion was in violation of the spirit of the treaty of Washington, if not of its letter. That treaty secures ‘‘ to the citizens of the United States the use of the Welland, St. Lawrence, and other canals of the Do- minion on terms of equality with the inhabitants of the Dominion.” The refund of tolls to Canadians after the vessels have passed through is a violation of this provision, and the Canadian Gov- ernment has acknowledged that it is such by promising to discontinue it at the end of the present season. Still, as a matter of comity, we should have preferred that our own Congress had taken a little more time or left a little more room for Premier | Abbott to ‘‘ crawl out.” President Harrison made a short speech at Malone on Friday. The greater part of it related to the restoration of our ocean- carrying commerce, which he believed was an event not far distant, and aconsumma tion greatly to be desired. ‘‘I take great delight,” he said, ‘‘in the contemplation of the fact, which, I believe, is now assured, that before another year has rolled around one of the swiftest and best of all the great lines of steamships that go out of the port of New York will bear the Ameri- can flag at the fore.” The President's naive delight arises from the fact that Congress, in violation of the great princi ple of protection and of our wonderful navigation laws, has admitted two foreign-built steamships to American re gistry. Of course this might have been done before, in which case Mr. Harrison's heart might have been cheered years and years ago. In his remarks at Malone he had the grace to say that by the restora tion of our ocean-carrying trade we should merely recover a position that we former ly held. said, ‘‘of our once proud participation in the ocean carrying trade of the world. | think we should now resume it."’ The thing which has mainly prevented us from resum ing it heretofore has been the prevalence “We have been deprived,” he of an opinion that a cheap coat makes a cheap man, and that a cheap ship makes a cheap country. The gradual disappear ance of such crude notions will no doubt cause the United States ‘‘to step into the position of power and influence among the great commercial nations of the world’ which Mr. Harrison now so fondly pre dicts. There appears to be a commendable dis- position at the State Department to go slow and be sure of the facts in the case of the six Venezuelans forcibly taken from an American merchant-ship in Puerto Cabello. Venezuelan affairs are in such a chaotic condition at present that it is difficult to say who was the repre sentative of the legal authority over that harbor at the time; but it seems clear that the seizure was made by proper legal process under the de-facto authorities If this proves to be the fact, the parallel between this affair and the Bar rundia case will be close, and it will be in teresting to note whether our Government is again prepared to assert its jurisdiction in foreign waters The test question to put to Americans in such a dispute is the one asked by Prof. Woolsey in his recent article: ‘‘Suppose the Trent, with Mason and Slidell on board, had sailed into New York harbor, would the right of their seiz ure have been questioned by any power on earth *" It was only a few days ago that the Washington correspondent of the Phila delphia Ledger was severely rebuked by the Press of the same city for telling the truth about the condition of the Treasury He was reminded that it ill became a man who had been ‘‘ honored " by the Republi can party (meaning that he had been made Clerk of the Ways and Means Com mittee) to call attention to the fact that the Treasury was bankrupt, even if the fact were so. But he returned to the subject in Friday morning’s ledyer un dismayed, saving that his facts and figures may not be relished by parti sans, but it is due to the public that they should be fairly stated He reaftirms the bankruptey of the Treasury in the sense that ‘‘the appropriations made by Con gress for several vears have been in excess of receipts,” and that Secretary Foster has been forced by lack of funds to ‘defer ‘claims against the Government ” and ap propriations = for the construction of pubhe works This has been no secret, of course, in spite of Mr. Foster's per functory denials, but it is well to have the truth thus frankly set forth by a Re publican authority who thinks it his first duty to be honest. He quotes Senator Allison as saying that “after this year we are likely to have a deticiency, which must be met by an increase of taxes.” This seems a good place to recall a remark made by Senator Hale, when he was pro testing, in the name of Mr. Blaine, against the removal of the sugar duties: ‘I do not, for one, Mr. President, envy the fu- ture of any party that takes off taxes this year and is obliged to reimpose them next vear. rhe reason assigned by Mr. Sweeney, the leader of the switchmen at Buffalo, for declaring the strike ‘‘otf” was, that ‘‘ we can't fight 8,000 militia and twelve power ful railroad corporations This short sen tence comprises the whole philosophy of the strike and of most strikes in this coun- try. It implies that the strikers could carry their point if they were allowed to take possession of the property, burn cars, throw trains off the track, and kill or maim all persons seeking employment in But if the officers of the law do their duty, if they afford that protection to life and property which it is the main object and purpose of Government to supply- which is nine parts of the functions of civilized society--then Mr. Sweeney and the places they have abandoned. his troop of a few hundred men are com- pelled to acknowledge themselves beaten. When the outrages at Buffalo began, we were assured by Sweeney that they were

Page 10

156 The Nation. (Vol. 55, No. 1418 the work of roughs and tramps who are always ready for a disturbance in every large city, and that the switchmen were models of good deportment. They were ready even to mount guard over the prop- erty of the companies and prevent the disorderly elements from doing any damage. But now it appears that the strike is off simply because too many men had mounted guard over the property and too much coercion had been applied to the disorderly elements. The protection was altogether too complete and thorough. It must be said for Mr. Sweeney that he was not solely to blame for what took place at Buffalo. The strike was ordered by the switchmen as a body, and not by the Grand Master on his own responsibility. The failure of Hugh O’Donnell, leader of the Homestead strike, to draw a crowd to hear him in Cooper Institute last Thurs- day, isan encouraging indication. Only a handful of people attended, and O’Donnell got scarcely more than enough money to pay the rent of the hall. Various reasons are given for the slim attendance: the weather was very bad, and it was an- nounced in advance that in addition to an admission fee of twenty-five cents a col- lection would be taken up at the close. Both these reasons may have been suffi- cient to keep many people away, but they would not have operated in that manner a few years ago. The real cause of the meeting’s failure isundoubtedly the change of public sentiment which has taken place even among the workingmen themselves towards strikes and the leaders of them. The excellent conduct of the militia at Buffalo is deservedly calling forth praise from all quarters. Their duty has been far from a pleasant one, but. they have performed it without complaining and with really remarkable steadiness and self- control. The service was entirely novel to them, yet they have gone through it like veterans rather than like green troops. Taken in connection with the equally commendable behavior of the militia at Homestead, the experience at Buffalo affords ample assurance that in its citizen soldiery society has a safe and sure protection against outbreaks of an- archy in any form. The observations by Mr. T. V, Powderly upon the workingmen’s expectation of benefits from the protective tariff, will furnish food for a good deal of solemn Republican thought. Mr. Powderly says that ‘‘our Government has enacted pro- tective legislation in the interest of labor,” and that, having done this, it ‘‘quiescently allows the manufacturer to absorb the bulk of protection.” As authority . for this view he points to Republican Congres- sional speeches, saying that ‘‘in discus- sion on the tariff laws it was never ad- vanced as a reason why they should be , passed that capital would be protected—~ the argument always was that laborshould be protected.” He declares that the Homestead troubles would have been averted if, when the managers of the Carne- gie concern sought to absorb all the protec- tion, Government had interfered in behalf of the workingmen. ‘‘If we must have protection,” he adds, ‘‘let us see to it that it protects the man who works.” Is Mr. Powderly right or wrong in his claim that he finds authority for his position in the speeches of Republican Congressmen ? Everybody must admit that those speeches have for years been teaching the same doctrine which he insists upon now—name- ly, that the high tariff is designed pri- marily to keep American wages above the level of the pauper labor of Europe. In the current number of the North Ameri -can Review Senator Morrill preaches the same doctrine when, in reviving the old ‘‘free-trade scare,” he says: ‘‘Free trade builds up a few great important cities on the seashore, and creates million- aires in foreign trade. It depopulates the rural districts, and has nothing but lip-service to offer those who toil for their daily bread. Jt would give to the latter the dearer cost of living and the 77 per cent. less of wages which free trade in England offers to those who labor.” The same doctrine has in every Presidential campaign for years been displayed on countless Republican banners in the fa- miliar form: ‘‘ American Protection for American Homes—American Wages for American Labor.” Small wonder if Mr. Powderly and his associates, having ac- cepted it as truthful, now turn about and demand its enforcement by its inventors. The American Wooi and Cotton Re- porter has a sarcastic article entitled ‘‘The Political Arlington Mills.” These are the woollen mills presided over by Mr. Wil- liam Whitman. The Reporter finds it a matter for wonder that, if Mr. Whitman is able to make only 6 per cent. per an- num out of his tariff combination with the Ohio wool-growers, he should continue in that combination. Other woollen manufae turers, who are not in the combination, make 10 per cent. dividends. How does it happen that Mr. Whitman makes less ? The explanation is that Mr. Whitman’s ‘‘ par- ticipation in law-making has recently put more than 6 per cent. into the assets of those mills in such form as to be available as quick capital, if not practicable for im mediate withdrawal as dividends.” That there is something mysterious either in the company’s financial statements or in Mr. Whitman’s personal statements, the Reporter shows by publishing the finan- cial statements for two successive years, namely, 1891 and 1892. Mr, Whitman has explained that the profit and loss balance in the 1892 statement (viz., $932, - 809) was an accumulation of former years; but the profit and loss balance of 1891 (viz., $984,769) was actually larger than that of 1892. This would show a de- crease instead of an accumulation, but somehow the Arlington Mills stock rose in the market from 824g to 108, and Mr. Whitman himself has been in the market as a buyer of it, having increased his own holdings from 514 shares in 1889 to 1,164 shares in 1891. The Reporter points out the true sources of the Arlington’s pros- perity. It says: ‘* The facts. are that the Arlington Mills were financ ally weak in 1859, and have become financially strong in 1592 through the ability of Mr. Whitman to frame certain phrases of the McKinley Bill in the interest of his mills. Mr. Whitmen was abie to do this by swaliow- ing his previously announced convictions at the behest of Messrs. Lawrence and Delano, ard by allying himself with the Ohio clique. He has achieved a considerable measure of prosperity thereby, but he might have achiev- ed the same measure of prosperity by a tariff law which would have benefited the great mass of wool manutacturers as well as the Arling- ton Mills. ’’ It is evidently worth while to be President of the American Wool Manufacturers’ As- sociation if by that means you have the last hack at the bills which are nominally prepared by the Committee of Ways and Means. The importance which the Republican press attaches to Peck’s report shows its desperate poverty in argument. The fig- ures simply give the statements alleged to be made by 6,000 firms engaged in sixty- seven ‘‘ industries,” representing 1,121 ‘*trades,” as to the amount paid by them for wages in the year from September, 1889, to September, 1890, and in the fol- lowing year, and the value of their pro- ducts during those years. As to what has taken place during the year that ended yesterday, no information is given. Mr. Peck says that these industries ‘‘ give employment to 285,000 workingmen and women,” but his summary contains no figures upon this point, nor do we know to how many persons these industries gave employment during the former of the years taken for comparison. The figures show that $6,378,000 more was paid for wages in the second year than in the former, but as we do not know how many persons were employed in the former year, it is impossible to tell anything about ave- rage earnings. From what we know of the previous work of this ‘‘ statistician,” we in- cline to think that he has simply divided the increase reported in wages by the num- ber of employees in the second year taken. If he has not done this, bis figures ought to show that these ‘‘industries” are em- ploying scarcely any more men in the second year than in the former. Asto the increase in the value of products reported, it is impossible to judge of its significance, as we do not know the gross amount for either year or the quantity of goods to which this value is attriputed by their anonymous producers. Meanwhile we must say that destiny has already marked Mr. Peck out as the Superintendent of the next census, should the Republican party be then in power.

Page 11

(25 tne 4 Nl Sept. 1, 1892] There appears to be no doubt that the Republican managers in Maine, led by ‘‘Joe” Manley, have been guilty of a dis- reputable piece of trickery in the printing of the ballots which are to be used in the approaching election. The new ballot law of the State is to be tried for the first time. It provides for a party-group bal- lot, in accordance with modifications of the Australian adopted in several of the States. The names of all candidates are to be arranged in party groups upon a blanket ballot, and the voter can indicate his choice either by placing a mark oppo- site the party name at the top, or by plac- ing a mark against the name of each candidate for whom he wishes to vote. In all laws of this kind, except that of Maine, the blank spaces for the marks are placed before the names of the candi dates—that is to say, to the left of them. In the Maine law, the direction is that the blank spaces shall be placed at the right of the names, that is, after them. In printing the ballots according to this di- rection, the Secretary of State in Maine has arranged them as follows: REPUBLICAN, DEMOCRAT, As the natural place for marking or checking a name is before, not after it, the effect of this arrangement would be that careless Democratic voters would put their marks in the space following the names on the Republican ballot. and their votes would thus be registered and counted as Republican. No other similar law in the country has such an arrangement. Some of the laws have the marks placed after the names, but the blank spaces are so ar- ranged that a mistake is impossible. To understand how such a trick happened to be provided in the Maine law, it is neces- sary to recall the fact that the Republican Machine there, under Manley’s lead, fought the adoption of the reform law in the Legislature, and yielded their opposition only in obedience to the demands of over- whelming public sentiment. Not content with this, the Secretary of State has had the ballots printed on such flimsy paper that the voter's mark on it can be seen easily through it, even after the ballot has been folded, so that the secrecy of the ballot is impaired, if not completely de- stroyed. The Democrats have discovered the marking trick in good season and are making every effort to warn their voters of the dangers of it; but they are likely to lose many votes in consequence of it. There is a pretty loud demand in cer- tain newspapers that the President shall issue a proclamation prohibiting immigra tion while the cholera continues in Eu- The Nation. rope. Those who make such a demand seem not to be aware that the President has no more power to prohibit immigra tion than he has to prohibit importation or exportation. Moreover, how is he to dis tinguish between immigrants and Ameri can citizens returning to their own homes as steerage passengers? Are people to be ex cluded from their own homes merely be cause they are not able to travel in the cabin’ Nothing, we venture to say, will be gained by mixing the questions of immigration and of quarantine to gether. What is desired on all hands is to keep out cholera infected per sons, whether native or foreign-born, How to do this is a medical question purely, and is to be decided by the faculty, and not by whether citizens or immigrants. the President or any political authority. There is no occasion panic on this subject. for getting in a No person infected with the cholera germ can go five days without being sick in sucha way as to dis- close the true character of the disease. No ship can cross the ocean in five days. There fore, no quarantine officer can be deceiv ed, The outbreak has already had a dele terious effect on our export trade. One of the largest houses in the city in this line reports that it has not booked a new order in ten days. tosend his vessel to an infected port. No No shipowner wishes captain or crew desires to tempt fate in that way. Hamburg is one of the world’s great entrepots. It is the chief distributing point of northern Eu rope. Business is completely paralyzed there, and many of the merchants have fled from the city. great port, a most important one for our foreign trade. Antwerp is likewise of much importance to us. The reported presence of cholera in Antwerp is contra Havre is likewise a dicted, but as long as adoubt exists no ship will solicit a cargo for that port, except the regular liners. Thus, a temporary glut of the markets in certain lines may be looked for here, and a corresponding dulness of general trade due to the caution which accompanies every disturbance of the set tled course of things Fortunately, the period of frost is not far distant The success of Mr. John Morley at New castle is one upon which the Liberals may congratulate themselves for several rea Glad stone’s right-hand man and chosen instru ment in all home rule matters, so that his defeat would have been taken toargue Libe- ral lukewarmness on the Irish question. Of course he would have had a seat made for him elsewhere if defeated, but that would have been a mortifying expedient. His triumph, and by a larger majority than was hoped for, cannot fail to strengthen and solidify the new Cabinet. Its deter- mination to put Irish affairs first has now this new and cheering endorsement. More- over, his election is a fresh dashing of Conservative hopes, as their unexpected success in winning one seat at Newcastle sons. In the first place, he is Mr 157 in the general election made them conti dent of beating Morley on Thursday The memorandum concerning the coin age of silver addressed by Dr. Soetbeer to the International Monetary Conference is subjects d to rather destructive criticism by a correspondent of the London Feono mist. Dr. Soetbeer’s principal suggestion was that no gold coins or bank notes pay able in gold under the vaiue of twenty franes should be hereafter issued, and that those now outstanding should be with drawn. He puts the amount of small gold coins at about £82,000,000, the total amount of such coins and of small notes being esti mated by other authorities at £150, 000,000 Dr. Soetbeer’s critic points out that this is far below the quantity of full rated silver already circulating, or more properly, we should say, held by Governments as avail able for monetary use. The United States and France alone have from £220 000 000 to £250,000,000, and the total in all coun tries is probably not less than £600,000 OOO. If the silver using countries were to adopt the gold standard, using silver as Soetbeer, there would Dr. Soet beer says these countries might be able to suggested by Dr still be a vast surplus of silver get rid of a portion of this surplus in time, but he does not say who is to take it M. Paul Leroy Beaulieu has attacked vigorously the project for resuming work He believes that all the new money put into it will be lost on the Panama Canal as the former amounts were. That France has any peculiar interest in cutting the isthmus, whereby patriotic feeling ought to be enlisted in its faver, he denies. On he maintains that ‘' the cut ting of this isthmus will favor the United the contrary States at the expense of Europe as regards trade with the entire Pacific Coast and the- waters of China and Australia.” French prestige and amour propre are not con thinks, in the fact that a certain number of French citizens have cerned, he undertaken a great enterprise and have failed in it ‘No harm has resulted to the French name,” he says, ‘‘and this check is no reason for pursuing indefinite lv an enterprise singularly hazardous. It concerns only a matter of business purely financial, very risky, and which should be examined without getting excited.” M. Leroy Beaulieu evidently thinks that it is the weakness of the French character that it cannot look at Panama without getting excited, for he goes on to sketch a plan for getting the money if it must be done. In the tirst place, he dismisses the idea of a Government subsidy or guarantee The work must be carried on by private subscription if at all. as too idle to be considered. The smallest sum of new stock subscription that would serve as a basis for new loans would be $60,000,000 to $80,000,000 cash. Whether this amount can be raised as a speculation (as it might be invested in a lottery), he expresses no opinion.

Page 12

158 The Nation. [Vol. 55, No. 1418 THE READING RAILROAD COMBINA- TION. THE decision of Chancellor McGill of New Jersey, enjoining the operation of the Central Railroad by the Philadelphia and Reading, could hardly have been unex- pected by the managers of these compa- nies. The Chancellor examines the statute of 1885 prohibiting the leasing of domestic to foreign corporations without legislative sanction, which the companies failed to obtain, and declares it constitutional. It follows that the lease of the Central Rail- road, a New Jersey corporation, to the Port Reading Company, was not only without legal sanction, but in direct defi- ance of the legislative prohibition. As we understand the decision, if these com- panies had secured the passage of an en- abling act, the lease would have been va- lid; but Gov. Abbett’s veto disappointed their expectations, as well as those of the legislators who voted for the bill on the understanding that he would approve it. Such being the case, the consideration of the other features of the transaction does not seem to have been indispensable, but the Chancellor devotes much space to areview of the situation. He expresses the opinion that the Central Railroad has acted in a manner prejudicial to the in- terests of the public in order to make un- due gains for its stockholders, and holds that, in such a case, the Attorney-General of the State may properly institute a suit in equity to restrain a corporation. The prejudicial action consists in leasing its lines to a corporation interested in a busi- ness that should be competitive, the transportation of coal. It is true, the Chancellor says, that neither of the rail- roads concerned owns any coal lands or deals in coal. But they own the majority of stock in two great coal companies, so that their allegations as to ownership of coal lands are ‘‘ but disguise and evasion.” ‘To say that these conditions do not tend to a disastrous monopoly in coal,” Chan- cellor McGill declares, ‘‘ would be an insult to intelligence.” He adds : ‘*The commodity in which these companies deal is a necessary of life in this State. It is the principal fuel of its homes and factories. The slightest increase in its price is felt by a population of hundreds of thousands of per- sons, for their necessity cOmpels them to pay that increase. If once a complete monopoly be established by the destruction of competi- tion, whether that be through lease or co- operation, the promoters and sharers in it may have whatever price their cupidity suggests. The disaster which will follow cannot be mea- sured. It will permeate the entire community, furnaces, forges, factories, and homes, leav- ing in its trail murmurs of discontent with a government which tolerates it,and all the other evil effects of oppression.”’ It is obvious that in this portion of his opinion Chancellor McGill travels outside of the realm of law into that of economics. It is quite too hasty a conclusion that there may not be a saving of expense aris- ing from the combination of competing agencies, although, of course, the saving of expense need not be made a gift to the public, either in whole or in part. And it is absurd to say that the promoters of the combination, if they could establish a complete monopoly, may obtain ‘‘ whatever price their cupidity sug- gests.” On the contrary, every rise in the price of anthracite coal tends to reduce con- sumption, and the point is very soon reach- ed where the sale of the reduced quantity at the higher price brings in less profit than the sale of a greater quantity at a lower price. It is those who ignore this law that ‘‘in- sult intelligence.” The history of the cop: per syndicate isan admirable illustration of its working. Those speculators con- trolled the world’s production of copper, and they thought they had the world at their mercy. They put up the price to an extravagant figure, thinking they had made their fortunes, and they found themselves suddenly ruined. Some of those who used copper ceased to use it, some used other materials, some used old copper instead of new, all economized, and M. Secretan and his ring were hoist with their own petard. Anthracite coal is not a commodity that will endure arbitrary fluctuations in price any more than copper. It is exposed toa steady and formidable competition from bituminous coal, to a considerable com- petition from wood, to a great possible competition from oil and gas. It is also, we rejoice to believe, in immediate danger of competition from the coals of Nova Scotia, which will be admitted free as soon as the Republicans are turned out of office. Every rise in its price makes this competition more effective. Every rise limits domestic consumption. People of small incomes do not waste so much coal when it is dear as when it is cheap, and people of smali incomes are the great majority of consumers. Some of them will calculate that a wood fire will answer their purpose better than one of coal, some will decide to putin a gas- range or depend upon an oil-stove, and nearly all of them will pay only the same amount for coal that they paid before, be- cause they can pay no more. The ability and the disposition of consumers are a perpetual check to the greed of monopo- lists. After all, the controversy is a battle of abstractions. As Chancellor McGill ad- mits, and as President McLeod defiantly asserts, what was intended to be done bya lease may as well be done by an under- standing. The corporations are mere legal fictions. What is real is the body of men who own the coal and the railroads. These men have generally acted upon a tacit or secret understanding, and the fact that their understanding is now more per- fect and extensive than before will make little difference. President McLeod says that the traffic arrangements between the Reading and the Central will not be chang- ed, being mutually advantageous. The titles borne by certain officers will be changed, but not their functions. And, what is most important, the price of coal will not be changed, at least in consequence of thisdecree. As Mr. McLeod points out, the price for which that commodity sells is beyond the jurisdiction of a Court of Chancery, and he adds that it would be possible for the Reading Railroad to dis- pose of all its coal without entering the State of New Jersey. This is rather foolish talk, and Mr. McLeod’s course is perhaps not altogether a wise one. The price of coal was probably abnormally low last year, but it has been advanced at so rapid a rate as to produce irritation. PECK’S REPORT. A REPORT was given to the press on Monday from C. F. Peck, the ridiculous person who holds the position of Chief of the Bureau of Labor Statistics of New York. It is entitled the ‘“‘Effect of the Tariff on Labor and Wages,’ and it is hail- ed by the chief Republican organ as a great campaign document for that party. We do not think it will have the effect as- cribed to it, because it is impossible for any- body of Peck’s calibre to do any great amount of harm. It requires a man of considerable ability to handle statistics so that he will not contradict himself, or contradict higher authorities than him- self. Peck became the laughing-stock of statisticians when he made his first report five or six yearsago. Since that time he has scarcely been noticed, having fallen beneath contempt. His present publica- tion is noticeable only as a studied at- tempt to help the Republican party over a difficult piece of road. Even here its only significance arises from the sus- picion that it was put forth at this juncture at the instigation or with the connivance of Gov. Hill himself, who was in Albany onSaturday. The World’s Albany correspondent says: ‘‘ Yesterday Senator Hill and Chairman Murphy of the State Committee held a conference here, and last night the order was given to re- lease the report for Monday, August 29.” We profess to have no knowledge on this delicate subject. We merely say that the report itself will be harmless; but if it is an indication of what Gov. Hill and his crowd are about, then it behooves the Na- tional Democratic Committee to take the campaign in this State into their own hands exclusively, and without the least delay. The reason why Peck will not produce the harm to his own party which he evi- dently intended is that he has tremendous- ly overdone his job. He has contradicted Senator Aldrich, the chief Republican wage statistician, to such a degree that if we were to take both of them as true, we should be driven to the conclusion that the McKinley tariff was devised to benefit New York at the expense of all the rest of the country. Mr. Aldrich showed, or attempt- ed to show, that there had been an ave- rage increase of wages since the passage of the McKinley Bill of three fourths of one per cent. That was the extent of his claim, founded upon the investigations of the Senate Committee, which b°4 taken

Page 13

Sept. 1, 1892] a vast deal of sworn testimony, the witnesses all being subjected to cross- examination. Senator Carlisle, in his re- ply to Aldrich, showed that the only increase of wages had taken place in the non-protected industries, while there had been a decrease in the protected industries. What Peck meant to say the percentage of increase of wages in this State had been during the same period, cannot be made out of his jumbled statement. We print it, however, in parallel columns with AIl- drich’s: PECK’S REPORT. | ALDRICH’S SPEECH IN 8SE- “ Of the sixty-eight in- | NATE, JULY 26. dustries included, 75 per cent. of them show an in- creased average yearly earning in the year 18{)1, while the total average increase of yearly earn- ings of the 285,000 em- The investigation by the Senate Finance Com- mittee into wages from June, 1880, to Septem- ber, 1801, showed an average increase for the occupations included in ployees was $23.1] each. | the inquiry of three- The average increase of , fourths of one per cent.” yearly earnings of the Congyresston Re f employees in fifty-one | page 7,530, traies showing an in- | crease was $43.96 each | in 1891 as compared with 1890.” | To complete the record, we add what Senator Carlisle said in reply to Mr. Al- drich: ‘*The Senator from Rhode Island stated generally, as will be seen from his printed speech, that the Committee had found that, while there had been a decline in prices, there had been an increase of seventy-five hundredths of one per cent. in wages, whereas I assert now, with the tables before me, that the only instance in which any increase of wages occurred, tak- ing the whole together, was in these fifteen substantially unprotected industries; and I willshow presently that in the fifteen highly protected industries in which the rate of wages had increased before the McKinley Bill passed, there was a decrease after it passed,.”’ Peck’s jumble is evidently intended to have a resounding noise and to affect the imaginations of those who take the gene- ral purport of words without weighing them or examining their basis. It is worth recalling that Mr. Powderly, the head of the largest labor organization in the country, in a recently published arti- cle, differs radically from Peck as to the effect of the tariff on wages. Let us now glance at the sources of Peck’s information. He sends out a lot of blanks to the protected manufacturers, asking them certain questions about wages. Of course they all see the point and frame the answers to suit themselves. There is no cross-examination, indeed there is no examination in chief, but merely an exchange of letters by mail. The answers are not sworn to, and, even if they were, no prosecution for perjury could be had since the parties are not giving any evi dence which the law requires from them. Moreover, Peck himself tells us that the evidence is altogether of a private nature, that it has been given in confidence, and that he cannot submit it to the test of verification or rebuttal. Here is his col loquy with the Herald correspondent *** Are the original letters on file in your of tice ?’ I asked. ‘**They are, every one of them,’ was the reply, ‘ but they cannot be thrown open to the public. They are in many cases confiden- | The Nation. tial letters from business men who woul only agree to furnish me statistics on the assurance that the private facts concerning their busi ness should not be made public.’ ’ If Mr. Carroll D. Wright, or Prof. Rich mond Smith, or Gen. Francis Walker, or any other statistician of recognized cha racter and ability should publish a mass of statistics having a decided political cast, no other statistician would to accept them as conclusive without testing feel bound ! i their accuracy ; and if the means of testing it were denied, they would simply say that be they must judged wholly by our knowledge of the person collecting and preparing them. reasoning to Peck, the whole mass goes to If we apply this the garbage heap at once, along with his other reports, except that probably this one will goa little faster than the others on account of its political character. It was evidently put out at this time damage Mr. Cleveland and to prevent a Democratic victory in the nation. had not been the object, it would have been withheld until after the election to ; 159 *~ | which they lived free from encumbrance, and the number of those upon whose farn Whenever the answer showed that the farm or home is or houses there were mortgages was mortgaged, the Census Office has sought | to obtain by direct correspondence with the head of each family the value of the farm or house, the amount of encum | brance upon it, the interest paid on such } encumbrance, and the object for which the indebtedness was « ontracted Maine is the tirst complete State for which the results have been published, al though in response to an inguiry of Sena tor Petfer of Kansas the Census Office some months ago compiled the returns from some ten Kansas and an equal num ber of Ohio counties \ farm in the meaning of the census returns in i cludes, besides what = an commonly known ar farms, all considerable nurs eries, orchards, and market gardens cul If this | Any merely scientific aim that had been | evolved in the brain of Peck would have been as easily secured two months hence as now. But the political aim could only be accomplished now. It might be pointed out that if VPeck’'s statistics were to be taken as correct, in stead of Aldrich’s or Carlisle's, it still be incumbent on him or on somebody would to show the connection between the taritf and If this task cessfully achieved, the fact would remain wages. Were suc that an artificial increase of wages insome employments must be gained at the ex pense of other people in other employ ments. But it will be time enough to go into these branches of the inquiry when some evidence is advanced to sustain the statistics. FARMING IN MAINE, A RECENT census bulletin gives the results of the investigation into the ownership of the farms and homes of Maine and into the encumbrances upon them. This in quiry was entirely distinct from that into the recorded indebtedness of the country tivated for pecuniary protit, an the ing much labor as as of or didte bodied workman during the year. Cal bage and potato patches, family vegetable gardens, and ornamental lawns, not con stituting a portion of a farm for general } agricultural purposes, are excluded. No | tract of less than three acres was m ported jas a farm unless at least $500 worth of Each of the family schedules furnished | the enumerators contained the following questions: ‘*Is the home you live in hired, or is it owned by the head or by a member of the fami lv? If owned by head or member of family, is | nee? If ve farm the home free from mortgage encumbr the head of the family is a farmer, is U which he cultivates hired, it owned by him or by a member of his family? If owned by head or member of family. is the farm free from mortgage encumbrance? If the home or farm is owned by head or member of family, and mortgaged, give the post-office address of owner. or is From the answers to these questions, it is possible to determine how many fami lies cultivated farms and how many did not, the number of families who owned the farms they cultivated or the houses they o cupied, the number of those owning the farms they cultivated or the houses in | in Maine | States, as 33 per cent produce had been sold from it during the census year Out of the 150,355 families residing in Maine on June 1, IS), 62.122 are rn turned as cultivating farms as above de tined. It must be borne in mind that the families of hired farm laborers who do not own or rent farms are not included in the number of hose cultivating farms, while manv families some of whose resident members may have other thi th; } s- ¢ Oeca4r i an agricultural pursuits are included, so at the proport which these families on o the total number of families in the State is not necessarnly the same borne by wha mmonly termed the agricul t are cx i tural ciasses to The the total population. returns show that in Maine more than 92 per cent. of the families who cul- tivate farms own them, and nearly 72 per cent. own them free of encumbrance. If the selected counties in Kansas and Ohio, the returns for which have been published, fair the of respective States, the proportion of ten are samples of rest their ant farmers is less than one fourth as great it either of the of the Kansas and 37 per cent. of the Ohio farmers rent their farms. as is in other In the proportion of mortgaged farms Maine, while very much better off than Kansas, in which 43 per cent. of the | farmers have mortgages on their land, ‘is not quite so well off as Ohio, in which State the places of but 13 per cent. of the farm-cultivating families are mortgaged. In Maine the average value of the mort gaged farms occupied by their owners was, according to their owners’ estimate, only $1,449, while the mortgages upon ‘them It is that in all three States the ratio averaged $532, or about 37 per cent. noticeable

Page 14

160 The Nation. [Vol. 55, No. 1418 of encumbrance to gross value of encum- bered property is substantially the same, varying in the different States less than 2 per cent. The average mortgaged farm in Kansas or Ohio, however, was worth, ac- cording to its owner’s statement, more than twice as much asin Maine, the Ohio ave- rage being $3,848, and the Kansas $3,694. The mortgages were also proportionately larger, averaging $1,422 in the former State and $1,402 in the latter. The Maine farmner pays less for the money he bor- rows, the rate of interest on his mortgages averaging 6.26 per cent., including in the interest all bonuses and commissions he had to pay for the loan, while the average rate in Ohio is 6.85 per cent., and in Kan- sas as much as 8.12 per cent. More than 64 79 per cent. of the mort- gage debt of the Maine farmers was incur- red for the purchase of real estate and for that alone, and 75.12 percent. for the pur- chase and improvement of real estate. In Ohio the percentage of debt incurred for the objects named is 74.75, or almost precisely the same as in Maine. In Kan- sas, however, only 53.79 per cent. of the debt was incurred for the pur- chase and improvement of real estate uncombined with other objects. In all three States a much larger percentage of the farmers than of the other classes of the population own their homes. Thus in Maine only 48.02 per cent. of the families not occupying farms own their homes, as against 92 38 per cent. of those occupying farms; in Ohio the respective percentages are 30.36 and €2 90,and in Kansas 51 69 and 66.75. Home ownership is least common in the larger cities; thus, in Hamilton County, Ohio, which includes the city of Cincinnati, only 21.95 per cent. of the families live in their own houses, as against 50.24 per cent. in the other nine counties the returns for which have been compiled. In Maine, in the eight cities having 8,000 inhabitants each, 36.23 per cent. of the families own their homes, while in the rest of the State the percentage is 53.11. In Maine the mortgaged homes of families not cultivat- ing farms have a higher average value than the mortgaged farms, while the con- trary is true in Ohio and Kansas, In Maine and Ohio about the same proportion of homes and farms occupied by their own- ers are mortgaged, while in Kansas a much larger proportion of owned homes than of farms are free from encum- brance. REFORM OF ENGLISH LEGAL PRO- CEDURE, It is not without surprise that Americans read that the entire body of English judges have agreed upon a report which exposes numerous defects in the present system of administering justice, and re- commends a scheme for its improvement. We have so long been accustomed ‘to speak of British conservatism that it is hard to realize how much more rapid the rate of change has been in the mother ’ country in recent years, not only in po- litical institutions, but also in the substance and the practice of the law. In certain respects we were already so far in advance that we may still look back upon the pro- gress of English reform, but in others it cannot be denied that we have been distanced. The very fact that no body of American judges reports upon the methods of administering justice, or effects any material change in these methods, is an indication of itself that our system is defective. Judges are especially qualified by their experience to suggest improve- ments in legal procedure, and under an enlightened system of jurisprudence this would be one of their regular functions. The English judges seem to be able not only to suggest changes, but to a consider- able extent to initiate them without legis- lative assistance. Most of the reforms proposed by the “English judges are of purely technical in- terest, but there are a number of general importance, some é6f which deserve imita- tion in this country. Some twenty years since, the Judicature Acts were passed in England, under which changes were made similar in a _ general way to those effected more than forty years ago in the State of New York. The old distinctions between law and equity were to be abolished, the old forms of common. law pleading were to be done away with,and practice was to be so simplified as to enable every man to be his own lawyer. What the result has been in New York is well known and need not be dwelt upon. It is enough to say that the very evils that took place here in consequence of the adoption of our code have taken place in England in consequence of the Judicature Acts. The old forms of plead- ing had a quaint, not to say repulsive, as- pect, but they had resulted,after centuries of use, in making pleading a science. What it has become under a system which encourages the pleader, as Mr. O'’Conor said, ‘‘ to tell his story just as one old wo- man would to another,” every one knows who has had to answer a rambling, illogi- cal, and unintelligible complaint accord- ing to its folly. So far as simplifying pleading goes, the criticism of an English judge is applicable to both countries : “The reformers of the Judicature Acts found no difficulty in charming the public with the idea that it would be an excellent improve- ment to substitute a less rigid and less formal method, under which a simple man—so ran the thought—might tell his own unvarnished tale without any of the artifice and verbiage of the lawyer. Experience, unfortunately,soon showed that the artists who draw the narratives of litigants are not often simple; and it may be added that their tales are frequently not unvarnished. The ancient severity of the common-law pleading was replaced by lengthy statements on behalf of plaintiff and of de- fendant, from which the points could only be extracted by painful and (generally speaking) useless industry. Expense was doubled and simplicity was not promoted.”’ But whatever claim is made in favor of the modern system, or lack of system, of pleading, no one can deny that the intro- duction of the Code in New York was fol- lowed by a prodigious increase in the number of steps in a litigation. Under the old system the rules of practice were known to the bar and the bench, but when the Code came, both had to learn their business over again, and take up their time with inquiries as to whether the prac- tice prescribed in the Code was the same as before or different. However it be ex- plained, we have the fact to deal with that there has been an enormous multiplication + of interlocutory applications and appeals in this State, and that is precisely what has taken place in England since the Judica- ture Acts. By rendering the machinery of Chancery applicable to actions at law, these acts made available to litigants gene- rally such weapons as interrogatories and bills of discovery, to the great increase of trouble, delay, and expense. On the Chan- cery side there has been some improve ment, but the last state of the common- law litigant is worse than the first. These evils are dealt with in a drastic manner by the judges. It is proposed that within a fortnight of the beginning of an action a ‘‘summons for directions ” shall be taken out, under which the par- ties shall appear before a master, who will investigate the cause of action. He is to be empowered to settle the preliminaries of the trial, to direct as to its mode and place, to put a cause into a special list for immediate trial, to allow and disallow pleadings, to prescribe the kinds of evidence for particular points and the manner in which it shall be obtained and present ed, and in general to give such directions as to procedure as will prevent delay. It is believed that in this way the evil of incessant summonses, which correspond with our notices of motion, will be checked. The end is desirable enough, for at pre- sent the order of the master is taken on appeal to the judge, and from him appeal lies to the Divisional Court, thence to the Court of Appeal, and finally even to the House of Lords. The manner of dealing with this question of appeals we need not enter into further than to say that the time for interlocutory appeals is shortened to eight or fourteen instead of twenty- one days, and appeals from final judg- ments must be taken within two months instead of a year. This reform might well be imitated in this country. Other improvements proposed by the judges are: special calendars for commer- cial cases and special judges for work of this kind, changes in the method of ad- ministering estates, and other matters to which we cannot refer. Two subjects, however, are of so much importance as to deserve notice. At present, civil causes are tried at fifty-six circuit towns twice a year. But during the last four years there have been no causes for trial at one of these towns, only one case a year at a number, and at forty of them the number of cases is insignificant. By reducing the number of assize towns to eighteen, such an economy in the time of the judges will be effected as will enable harap seagasomtsaprns tse ecoue eo

Page 15

Sept. 1, 1892] at least eight judges to be always present in London. A more interesting reform, which is not without its lessons for us, is the proposed formation of a court of appeal in criminal cases. At present the Home Secretary prac- tically acts as such a court, but appeals are pressed upon him by all sorts of influences, and his position is an odious one. The pro- posed court is to be empowered to increase or to diminish punishment. Apparently the court is to be competent to quash con victions, but no new trial is to be granted. While the administration of the English criminal law differs so radically from our own as to make any analogy imperfect, there seems to be no reason why we should not follow suit in instituting a court of criminal appeal. We have never been able to understand why, with all the complaint of the excessive burdens thrown upon our Court of Appeals, there has never been any movement to relieve it of the review of criminal trials. It would be a perfectly simple and satisfac tory arrangement to constitute a court out of a certain number of Supreme Court jus- tices which should meet whenever there were appeals to be heard. In this way a very considerable relief would be atforded to the Court of Appeals, while the public would gain by the prompt application of justice in criminal cases. The present de lay between sentence and execution in murder cases does much to diminish the exemplary effect of the death penalty. THE QUESTION OF THE COLONIES. Paris, August 17, 1802. THE question of the colonies is the order of the day. ‘The eventsin Dahomey take up con- siderable space in the daily newspapers. Fe fore its adjournment three weeks ago, the Chamber discussed two interpellations in reference to the colonies, one of which resulted in the fall of the Minister of the Marine, M. Cavaignac. ‘This retirement, as, indeed, the discussion that took place upon the interpelia- tions, is in certain re-pects very significant. The work of the ‘lhird Republic, so far as ecncerns the colonies, has been im some points of view of considerable importance, Algeria and Cochin-China have been respectively en larged by the addition of Tunis antl Tonkin; and when, during these last few yeais, the various European Powers set about parcelling out to themseives the African Continent, France assured herself a considerable share, inasmuch as sbe placed Madagascar uncer her protectorate, and extended greatly the limits of the territories she had already acquired there, to wit, Senegal and Gaboon and sun dry factories on the coast of Guinea. The Government of the Republic found itself in many respects in a favorable position to ex- tend its possessions beyond the seas. The colonial enterprises of a country are always in a very large measure subordinate to its rela tions with other Powers. The desire of inter- vening in European questions naturally pre- vents the employment of large forces in far-off regions; and the necessity of conciliating the susceptibilities of allies who are also colonizing Powers may exercise a certain influence in preventing the annexation of one or another territory. Thus, for instance, the whole his- The Nation. tory of French colonization during the present century is subordinated to the state of its rela tions at any given date with its sister Power, England. ‘That country, jealous of any rival to its maritime and commercial supremacy, looks with unfavorable eye upen the different posts established beyond the seas by any other nation than itself. ‘ihe Government of the Restoration undertook to add new colonies to those that the treaties of 1814 had left to it. It directed important enterprises in Madagas- car and set itself the task of conquering Al geria. The Kevolution of 1830 came to put a sudden stop to its attempts. As a matter of fact, the Government of Louis Philippe, from the very beginning of that king's reign, saw itself obliged to rely for support on Great Britain. While on the one hand the Restora- tion, entering into fr.endly relations with Russia, bad been able to disregard English protests, on the other hand Louis Philippe was obliged to take account of them. Madagascar ceased compietely to occupy the Ministerial mind, and for many years the question could be reasonably asked, “Is Algeria going to be evacuated During the period of understanding witl England which lasted all through the reign of Louis Philippe and through a partof the reign of Napoleon LIL., the French Government was able to create a few colonial establishments. this was due to causes of a special nature. For example, when treaties had been signed, at the instigation of England, by which France undertook to help in the repression of the slave trade, and consequently to maintain crulsers on the coasts of Africa, it was necessary for the ships to have certain calling-stations as sured to them, and, to this end, to occupy a number of strategic positions. In this way the establishments at Gaboon were created, and the varicus factories on the Guinea Coast (1905 1845). Reasons of another order brought about the conquest of Cochin-China in Ise. After the disastrous war of 1870, France, rm nouncing for the time being ail interference Kuropean affairs, was on that account the more easily able to direct a part of ber activity towards her possessions beyond the seas. H work here was also the more facilitated inas much as circumstances peculiar to the time al lowed her to occupy fresh territory without thereby provoking any centlect with other V Continental Powers. Not that England was disposed to regard such atiempts with any more tavorabie eye; Lut besides that France had no longer any special reason to conciliate the susceptibilities of England—as was the case in the time of Louis Philippe and of Napoleon Iil.—she was no longer to struggie alone agaiust the ill-will of her neighbor. Germany tirst, and afterwards Ltaly, desired also t have colouies of their own; and England, hav- ing oppesed tu her not simply Fra: ce, but also a numer of Powers which in these matters were often united by cot ity of interest showed herself very much micre accommodat ing tOan in the past, rhe achievement of the work that the French Government had planned out was vet further helped by the excellent materials which it had at its disposal. Explorers such as M.de Braz- za, Capt. Binger, Lieut. Mizon—ihe last of whom returued to France only a short time ago—succeeded, In spite of e stoaii and olten- inadequate resources they pcs- umes utterly } sessed, in holding theirown s Aguinst the power- ful colonizing companies belonging to England and the Congo State. They succeeded, almost without escort and almust without striking a blow, in opening up roads of communication 161 and in establishing French influence cver large tracts of territory. So far as this kind of work is concerned, we have managed to do as well as any other nation. The success, however, is by no means so brillant wherever it has been necessary to or- sanize the possessions we have gained, or when an armed struggle has had to be under- taken against the natives. French administra tion, costivy and complicated in its working does not know how to adapt itself to circum stances, and would fain introduce its babits af routine into colonial government. In particu lar, the civil and the military element do not geton welltogether. Dusensions break out be tween the Minister for War and the the Marine. The partments Is a prime necessity to tin cooperation of these two de carry ling out of even the smallest operation, and yet each administration often keeps exclusive direction of the men under its orders. Each Minister, fearing more than aught else to compromise his responsibility, ives the minutest instructions to his subonmlinates, and as the result we see capliins in the navy obliged to refuse help to their brother officers in the army, even when this help is urgently demanded, It must, however, be recoguised that if such things happen—which all must re gret—the fau.t is not to be exclusively attr el to the executive power, Fora long time the Government bad to end, almost unceas lagly, against a very v t Lar y opposition. Monarchisis Radicals, ever seekipg oppertunities to overthrow the sus cessive cabinets, used to reproach the Govern nent Wilh Weakening PFrance bv scattering ber effective forees ali cver the globe: and when ever a diticuity arose, or a demand for money Was made, the necessity of evacuating the new colonies without delay was preached with hever-varyYing reirain. If this systematic and relentless opposition Was hever strong enoug to cause the Wovern ment to make & complet hange in its pelicy, it nevertheless contril 1 a great al & paralyze it and to prevent it from acting with the enercy 1 ght Harased wi ut ceas ng, ver K Wing what tl norrow might bring forth, and never definitely assured of the support of Parliament, the Government trial en t arry ta nial policy while seeming to be domg nothing. Instead of pre- hecessary means of paring with care the action, and of quietly pursuing the reabzation a largely conceived plan, it nearly always SK ught wo enterprise that it meditated, as also of the dissimulate the importance of the bstacles that it would have to overcome, The credits first asked for were always in- sufficient to assure an erergetic action,- and from the fact of these enterprises not being conceived as they ought, the resources actual- ly furnished, inadequate in themselves, were often squandered by reason of the bad man- agement referred to above. it would, however, seem that the respective positions of the Government and Parliament in reference to colonial matters have at least undergone a certain modification, and the re- cent Parliamentary incidents of which | spoke at the beginning indicate that the Chamber is now showing ou such questions a more just appreciation of events. A foraging company having falien into an ambusb in ‘lonkin, an interpellation was made in the Chamber, and the discussion that followed revealed the depu- ties in a new light—viz., as frankly realizing that such incidents are inevitable in a newly conquered country, for nobody spoke of evacuation. Still more, it would appear now

Page 16

16 [Vol. 55, No. 1418 that Parliament sees into colonial policy more clearly even than the Government itself, and, far from hampering its efforts, points out to it the course to pursue. In the campaign that is about to be opened against the King of Dahomey, the Minister of the Marine, M. Cavaignac, wished to maintain the deplorable traditions of the past and keep the command of the sea forces absolutely independent of that of the land forces. Kendered wise by experi- ence, the Chamber invited the Government to unite in one authority the command of all the expeditionary forces. The vote embodying this desire caused the resignation of the Minis- ter in question, but it is impossible not to recognize that this time it is the Chamber which was right. Another proposition, also voted in the last days of the session, is still moré significant. Bearing the signatures of MM. le Baron Heille, Lockroy, and Reinach—that is to say, of a Conservative, a Radical, and a Moderate Re- publican—it seemed to make plain that the Opposition is disarming on matters distinctive ly colonial, and that soon these questions, like those of national defence, will be placed above the quarrels of party. As for the tenor of the proposition, it simply invited the Government to push on with the formation of the colonial army. Yet such a vote as this is already a great progress. Indeed, to leave aside techni- cal considerations into which it would be too long to enter here, the formation of a colonial army, the principle of which was voted so long ago as last year—that is to say, the creation of regiments made up of special ele- ments and charged exclusively with the de- fence of the various colonies, instead of the troops sent at the present time from France— would isolate the colonies more from the me- tropolis, at least in certain respects, and would thus be a first step in the direction of a real colonial organization. Moreover, it would show that France has a firm intention of entering more and more upon a steady policy of coloni- zation, and this is why it is interesting to re- mark that it is now the Chamber itself that is urging the Government to form this army. 8. AN EXTRA-TERRITORIAL ITALIAN CITY. TRIESTE, August 1, 1892. WE left Venice as the splendid marine band, playing in the Piazza San Marco under the windows of the popular Rear-Admiral, Prince Thomas of Savoy, struck up a warlike march, Sheet lightning illuminated the Piazzetta, ex- tinguishing at intervals the electric lights there and on the deck of the Lloyd steamer Maximilian, on which we had taken tickets for the yonder shore of the Adriatic Sea. Venice may celebrate her silver wedding, for just five-and-twenty years ago she gave herself a glad, enthusiastic bride to one Italy, as yet uncrowned in Rome. A quarter of a century has passed, yet the memory of those days is still fresh. ‘lo the Venetians it seemed as though the Austrians would never take themselves off. “I vai? I vai?” (Are they going? are they going?) was the eager interrogation every morning until the glad day when the last white uniform vanished and the popula- tion, with one great sigh of relief, shouted, “T ze andai!” (They are gone). For the rest of Italy, though gladdened by the liberation of Venice, the outlook was gloomy. The catas- trophe of Custozza, the shame of Lissa, ‘sad- dened the hearts of all, The “useless Alps,” as Carlo Cattaneo called them, were and (alas) still are in the hands of the foreigner—France The Nation. encamped on the heights of Mont Cenis ; Austria, a stone’s throw from Verona, Bas- sano, and Udine. That the Tyrol will gravi- tate to the mother country sooner or later no one doubts, but it must be in virtue of some extraordinary pressure that Austria will cede ‘Trieste, her one great port on the Adriatic, the port till yesterday the most flourishing of all the ports on the Adriatic or Mediterranean shores. Reared and fostered by Austria at the ex- pense of Venice, which never for an hour or an instant concealed its hatred and contempt for Austrian rule, Trieste in 1848-’9 gave no sign of her relationship to the rest of Italy. On the contrary, when, the war between the Milanese, the Venetians, and their ally, Carlo Alberto, against the Austrians being at its height, the Sardinian fleet, commanded by Ad- miral Albini, with the Neapolitan and Vene- tian squadrons, entered the Adriatic, forced the Austrian fleet to take refuge at Pola, and on the 23d of May arrived in the Gulf of Tri- este, the soldiers of the garrison, the civic guard, and the militia took up position along the shore ready to repulse “the invaders” if they should attempt a landing. The cannon on the forts were ready, the treasure was car- ried into the castle. The consuls of the vari- ous nations protested that Trieste was a com- mercial city in which all nations were interest- ed; that any offence against ‘lrieste would be considered an offence against all nations rep- resented by the resident consuls. ‘lwo days passed, then the ships weighed anchor and left the Adriatic, the Admiral being recalled by a despatch from ‘lurin, as Germany had protest- ed against “the eventual occupation of Trieste.” The Emperor Ferdinand, when the catastrophe of Novara decided the fate of Lombardy, and when famine and cholera, more than the incessant bombardment, had compelled Venice to hoist the white flag, hand- ed over these rebellious provinces to the ten- der mercies of Radetzky; but “Trieste the loyal,” “'Trieste the faithful,” was rewarded with a lavish hand. In 1843 a special and se- parate constitution was granted to Trieste, which statuto the Triestines still look upon as their greatest treasure. “To the city of Trieste, city of the Empire, is guaranteed her abso- lute autonomy within the limits fixed by the Constitution of the Empire. The colors and the coat of arms of the city of Trieste are re- served intact.” To this city of the Empire “is guaranteed the right of sending two deputies to the first chamber of Parliament. The elee- tions of the representatives of the city of Tri- este in the second chamber will be regulated by the law of the Empire.” The number of the municipal councillors was increased from forty to fifty-six, the city detached from the Litorale and constituted into a separate pro- vince with the territory which extends from Rosanda in the valley of Zaule to the village of Santa Croce in Carsia. But all these new and important privileges were nothing in com- parison with the privilege of porto franco granted by Charles VI., by which the city was exempted from custom-house dues outside the walls; ships laden with merchandise could enter and quit the port, transfer their freight from one to the other, deposit their imports and exports in the warehouses on the Quay of San Carlo or in private stores, without paying cuty or tax. And this privilege was main- tained until 1888, when, some say to second the doctrines of the Austrian economists, others to punish the city for its late liberal manifestations, it was abolished, and grievous are the lamentations of the citizens. Not that it would be just to attribute to this material fact the deep and ever-widening in- crease of Italian feeling among the Triestines. The sentiment of their Italian origin, the prompt reply to the “ What is the city’s father- jand?” has always existed more or less; but until Rome was freed from the French and the temporal power of the Pope* abolished, the unity of Italy was not credited, and the an- nexation of ‘Trieste to the “kingdom of upper Italy” was never regarded as a desideratum. But since 1870 the feelings of the Triestines towards Italy and of the Italians towards Trieste have become more intense and of more daring manifestation. True, “unredeemed Italy” has been the watchword for factious demagogues who seek only to embarrass every government, and who have no intention to risk their necks in attempting the redemption; but here, as there, a strong and deepening conviction has spread that without Trieste and Trent, without the Alps and the Adriatic, Italy will never be strong or safe from invad- ers. This conviction it is which has brought many thorough haters of Austria to tolerate and even favor the Triple Alliance, believing that, in the case of any war with foreign Powers, Italy’s assistance or even her neutrality will lead to the peaceful cessicn of “one at a time” or even of both of the provinces. These speculations were rife among the many voyagers from Venice to Trieste, between which cities constant intercourse is maintained. On board there were a number of mandolisti, young Venetians of good families who have formed a club, and who, with their mando- lins, were going to give a gratuitous concert at the bathing station of Bagnolo. A heavy storm, accompanied by thunder and lightning, stopped their performances on deck, but below they made night weary with their scrapings and squeakings, which just now are all the fashion, so that it was a relief when dawn broke and we were able to distinguish in the distance the Gulf of Trieste on the eastern shore of the extreme Adriatic, with the moun- tains of Catinara and Opcina (the mountains of the Vena, as they are called), to the left, and the Julian Alps towering behind at some distance, while hamlets and villages strew the shore to the right and left of the city. ‘The horns of the Gulf extend, as though offering a welcome, from the station and St. Andrea. The city has an imposing aspect, and, with its villas nested among the verdant slopes and its rugged mounts, bare, stony and barren, re- minds you of Genoa; and of Genoa it has all the life and activity—the joyous sounds of hammer and anvil, the flags of all nations, and the business aspect at every turn, so wanting in faint and feckless Venice. ‘lhe Lloyd steam- ers lie at the Quay of San Carlo, so there is no need for boats or gondolas; the porters are decent and evidently in well-kept order; you deposit your few traps at the nearest hotel, and away in a tram for “anywhere it goes to.” ‘the first “anywhere” was Barcola, now a flourishing bathing station, bright, gay, and clean as a Dutchman’s house. Everywhere the cleanliness of the streets, the public build- ings, and especially of the charitable institu- tions, strikesone. At Barcola, an old Roman colony, the explorations for Roman remains have been carried on successfully. In the civic museum of antiquities an entire room is paved and walled with splendid and perfect mosaics. The remains of a vast thermal edi- fice with the plan intact have been discovered, and the municipality votes annually the neces- sary sums for the continuation of the works. ° The ‘Triestines, in familiar conversation, use

Page 17

i Sept. 1, 1892] the dialect, and the zezete of the soft Venetian tongue prevails; but the language written and taught in the schools is pure Ltalian, and the burning question is the maintenapce of the Italian language, for Which Austria has vain- ly attempted to substitute the German. But the commune builds its own school-houses and pays for the education of the poor; on its shoulders fall all the expenses for higher edu- cation, and the number of educational estab- lishmeuts is remarkable. Until the grant of the porto franco, the German language was unknown. When the Emperor Frederic III. wrcte for the first time to the city in German, a translator had to be found, and the Govern- ment opened an office, Translatador delle iet- tere tedesche. In 1524 the Council sent com- missaries to Ferdinand I. to implore that the judges who adjusted the questions between Carniola and ‘lrieste should use the Latin lan- guage, saying, “The mother tongue of the Triestines is Italian. No one born in Trieste understands the German language.” After the introduction of the free port, and especially towards the close of the last century, the num- ber of Germans, the employees and the mili- tary—German all—did their utmost to change the language, and Joseph II. decreed in 1786 that within three years the use of the Italian language in Government offices should be abolished. Next it was to be introduced into the schools, so that the people from their in- fancy should be familiarized with the German tongue. But all these efforts failed; the “old city” held its own. In the tribunals, in the Chamber of Commerce, in the municipality, Italian only is spoken. German, French, Eng- lish, and Greek are taught, but the attempt to substitute German has failed utterly, and in 1868 the Emperor decreed that “all the nations forming the Empire have equal rights, and that every single nation possesses the inviolable right to preserve and to cultivate its own na- tionality and its proper idiom.” This right, however, has to be paid for. The municipality alone spends 600,000 florins (about $300,000) for public instruction, half of this for the popular elementary schools, There are infant schools in every district, and these are really child-gardens, all the children re- ceiving a good meal a day. The gymnasia, lyceums, and superior schools are excellent. The female lyceum has eight classes and is thronged with students. The libraries, muse- ums, and other institutions are many and good, and the sum spent by the municipality does not represent the actualoutlay. The gym- nasia and realschulen are subsidized by the State; their chief purpose being to prepare students for the universities and technical bigh schools. It isa standing grievance that Tri- este has no university, while in Austria-Hun- gary there are eleven. Before the annexation of Venetian Lombardy to Italy, the Triestines frequented the universities of Padua and bo- logna; now, in order to obtain diplomas for the exercise of their respective professions, they are virtually compelled to attend one of the Austrian universities. Neither does Trieste possess a technical high school, of which there are seven in Austria for various branches of engineering and technical chemistry. Many schools in Trieste are endowed or subsidized by private contribution. The Jews and Slovenes maintain schools of theirown. ‘be latter is the troublesome element, detesting the It«lian supremacy, and the priests from their pulpits enjoin on the parents to abstain from sending their children to the schools. In Austria, though there is no poor-law entitling all to shelter, food, and clothing, the right to poor The Nation. relief is defined by an imperial statute; but the regulations for the apportionment of the cost are varied, and made by the separate pro- vinces. In Trieste the charitable institutions are many and wellregulated, ‘Lhe municipali ty spends now some 700,000, as the abolition of the free port bas thrown hundreds of families out of employment. The civic hospital is a magnificent building, containing ~,000 beds; the wards are bright and airy, and the wooden floors are white and clean as the deck of a man-of-war. A maternity ward has been opened lately, and the women are received without question and assisted on leaving to suckle and maintain their babes. There is no real foundling hospital, but waifs and strays are put out to nurse when found destitute. Infanticide, nevertheless, is a crime almost un- known; the “unfortunate” mothers in need being assisted at home. There is a general direction of public beneti- cence, and its arrangements are worthy of study and imitation. Starting with the “ poor fund,” augmented by private subscriptions and the grant by the Government of 5 per cent. on the wine duty, the General Institute for the Poor was set on foot, and in IS62 the Pia Casa for the poor was erected, capable of housing 800 individuals, Old men and women unable to work are received, fed and clothed; orphans and poor children are also admitted, instructed and taught a trade, and kept, the boys until sixteen, when they always find em ployment, and the girls until a situation is pro- vided. Here again the perfect cleanliness de lighted one, the peaceful harmony prevailing, the smile of welcome that greeted the kindly and devoted Inspector wherever he passed, so different from the cowed aspect of the inmates of charitable institutions in Naples, where the funds belonging to the poor are squandered by the “administrators” (governors employed for electioneering) and sundries. Some 5),000 tlo rins are distributed annually as out-door re lief, and now the soup-kitchen is, alas, crowded with men and women and children who a year or twoago were industrious members of the com munity. The kitchens of both hospitals and this poorhouse are splendid; the food exqui sitely cooked and abundant, especially for the aged and infirm. To these is given wine thre times a week; to the able-bodied who work, once a week. As the wine of the Istrian dis- trict is dear and scarce, while beer is cheap and abundant, 1 asked why the latter beverage was not substituted for the healthy inmates. “Beer is a tedescheria [Germanism],” said the administrator quite naturally. One branch of the house is set aside for the poor Jews with separate kitchen, and this is just, as the Israel ites contribute largely to the maintenance of public charities, and the Baron Elio Morpurg figures at the head of most public subscrip- tions. In a ward the beggars are kept apart until the managers can ascertain whether they are really indigent or ne’er-do-weels. In a separate building and with a quite dis- inct management is the reformatory or work- house fer boys found on the streets or declared by the parents to be incorrigible. Here the fare Is Spartan and the sleeping arrangements are certainly not luxurious. The lads are all drilled and bave a tine band; they receive an elementary education and are taught trades, and in both the houses the work of the youths is remunerative to the institution and to them- selves. So open and honest is, and 1 am as- sured ever has been, the administration that not a sou is squandered. Out of 500 waifs and strays taken in at six and kept till fifteen years 106 left the establishment last year. Of t! ’ thirty are skilled workmen earning ula ries; thirty-six mana to earn ir living ree hav been sent t t tia Ca ‘ eight are seemingly gone to the bad Every put ep t depends t? nicipality. The Magnitico Podesta ts the real - = - > > and venerated represent ’ communal electoral right is possessed DY every inhabitant over twenty vears of age who bas paid taxes for two years. Lhe Podesta ts alse head of the diet wh i representa the Grov ernment of the territory t t @ lar i by at least two-thirds of the members pres and these must 1 Lrieste t twenty-« t. The election must be confirmed by the Eanps ror, and the confirmation mimut teal to Lhe Council in public by u jusellor the Lieutenancy rhe present M »t sta, Dr. Ferdinand Pittari, elected by Ji out of counsellors present, and at . ontirmed in otlice, belongs to a well-kn la > teemed family of Liberals, and his son Richard is one of the literati of t! ity it Spoor hos * that accompanied the inaugural ceremony were noteworthy for the pervading leaven of Italian sentiment The “Magnifico,” on his elevation to t highest \ Ut yY, Was oo gratulated on being a “ [riestine by birth and at heart,” indepen and in returning thanks, after dweili on the lisastrous condit softii te at the present MomMenl-WAa Wol-dipected seltetow to Lie press men, Whom he exhorted “to keep in mind their high muss x their w sy i inti ence for the : i we ved ari este, to avoid party struggles and civic strife” he proused the cit IS present ¢ promote to tue ullel sit Land t euu- eation our peo im 4 ‘ An t iX foretat s, % n r-tongue sy 8 and mine which pledge was received with “rapturous app.aus Soon after his election, 4 rumor spread i A tour inspection, the Magnitico had addressed the populations in an alien tongue. He took the earliest opportu- nity to “ref the fabl saying, “In my tour if inspection throughout our territory, | spoke to ail and everywhere in Italian, nor could I have done otherwise or spoken ii an ‘unknown tongue.’ Although my principles in the ques- tion of nationality are deeply rooted in my heart, and their sincerity has been proved by my whole past, | gladly embrace this op- portunity to afiirm that the itegrity of my sentiments, of my love for our mother tongue and for our national culture, increases with increasing years, and that I hold it my highest duty to promote the advance of both.” Such public expressions of sentiments by pub- lic functionaries in Trieste itself are proofs be- yond all doubt of the Italianism of the citi- zens. During my too brief sojourn in the beautiful city, Dr. Attilio Hortis, the noted writer, most popular citizen, and the director of the civic library, was our courteous and in- telligent cicerone. Politics were naturaily es- chewed between us. Since the suppression of the Pro Patria society by the Government, the National League has taken its place, and its members are numerous and patriotic, Certain it is that if, whensoever and howsoever, Tri- este gravitate to Italy, the noble city and ter- ritory will bring a vast and valuable contribu- tion of civie virtue, of talent, industry, and self-government, in the Anglo-Saxon sense of the term, to the mother country, which will welcome it with open arms. J. W. M. of age, 80 per cent. may be called “ redeemed” ;

Page 18

= The Nation. [Vol. §5, No. 1418

BARDOUX’S LAFAYETTE,—II, Paris, August 16, 1892. On the 21st of October, 1778, Congress gave Gen. Lafayette leave to go to France and to fix for himself the date of his return. ‘The Alli- ance, the best ship in the navy, was chosen to convey him to Europe. Lafayette had a long journey to make on horseback, to go to Bos- ton, where he was to embark; he fell ill on the way, but he succeeded in reaching Boston, and put to sea on January 11, 1779. He ar- rived at Brest on the 20th of February. He had left France as a rebel; he returned to it triumpbantly. He had to undergo pro Jorma a week’s arrest for his desertion; he was allowed to spend the time at the Hétel de Noailles, All the ladies of the court wished to kiss him. Marie-Antoinette gave him a regi- ment. The French Government gave the com- mand of the corps which was sent to America to Rochambeau. Lafayette was only twenty- two years old; Rochambeau had served bril- liantly in the Seven Years’ War. Lafayette remained in the service of the United States and became a sort of negotiator between the French and the American forces, He embarked on the Hermione on February 11, 1780. ‘Two months before, Madame de Lafayette had pre- sented him with a son, who was named George after Washington, his godfather. A French squadron, with 5,000 men, reached Rhode Island on July 17, after seyenty days of navi- gation. The French fortified themselves, and Lafayette informed Rochambeau of the project which Washington had formed against New York, “The officers and soldiers of the Ameri- can Army,” wrote Lafayette to M. de Ver- gennes on July 23, “have nota shilling. The former receive only a ration, and get no clothes, nor have they, as the soldiers have, the hope of receiving clothes from France.” M. Bardoux gives us an interesting correspond- ence between Lafayette, who was ardent for immediate action, and Rochambeau, who stuck to Rhode Island, “It is always old Father Kochambeau who speaks to his dear son La- fayette, whom he loves and will always love and esteem to the end of his life.” When Gen. Phillips, by the order of Clinton, left New York to joiu the traitor Arnold, who had landed in Virginia with English troops, Lafayette was sent by Washington to Virginia with a force which numbered hardly 2,000 men, They had neither shoes nor shirts. The merchants of Baltimore lent Lafayette 2,000 guineas to buy cloth, The women whom he saw at a ball given in his honor undertook to make up the shirts. The young men of Bal- timore formed a squadron of light cavalry. Lafayette marched with great rapidity to- wards Richmond and arrived before Phillips. After the death of this officer, Lord Cornwal- lis came to make u junction with Arnold. Speaking of Lafayette, he wrote: “The boy " cannot escape me.” The boy escaped him, nevertheless, and was always on his flank or his rear. Writing to his wife, Lafayette says: “Tt was not reasonable to confide to me such a command; if I bad been unlucky, the public would have treated this partiality as blindness. . However, the campaign has taken a better turn than we could have hoped.” The end, in fact, was near, Cornwallis’s plan is now well known, ‘as well as Washington’s. A new French force was expected; Admiral de Grasse arrived with 3,200 men, and the memo- rable siege of Yorktown began. Cornwallis had to capitulate on the 19th of October, 1781. “The play is over,” wrote Lafayette on the 20th to the Comte de Maurepas, “and the fifth act is ended.”

Lafayette arrived in Paris unexpectedly on the 21st of January, 1782. M. de Ségur, the new Minister of War, announced to bim that the King had appointed him “Maréchal de Camp” of hisarmies. The return of Lafayette created a real enthusiasm. Verses were made for him on the stage; he figured in “ L’Amour Francais,” a play of Rochon de Chabannes. M. Bardoux forgets nothing. What do you think of this? “The eighteenth century always claimed its rights, and this model husband none the less inspired a very tender passion, which in time changed into faithful friend- ship, in the most charming person at court, and the handsomest, said her contempora- ries—Madame de Simiane.” Then comes a long eulogy of this lady; the climax is in these words: “To be beloved by Madame de Simiane seemed in the eyes of the old Duc de Laval to be as difficult a conquest as that of the principles of 1789,” Really we could not have expected to see the principles of ’89 in this affair. To be sure, M. Bardoux ends this little episode by saying the worldly successes of M. de Lafayette “were never of the same value to him as the pleasures of home.” Lafayette had become a representative man. “Surely it was much in the eyes of the nation to bave beaten the English, on land and sea, for the first time since Louis XIV., and to have thus avenged a century of humiliation. But there was another sentiment in the popu- lar tavor: public opinion felt instinctively that Lafayette had fought for a novle and just cause, the liberty of a people. It was the Revolution that came back from America, and the General represented at the same time the triumphs of the present and the hores of the future.” Lafayette’s letter to Washington (February 5, 1783) after the signing of the preliminaries of peace, is well known and has justly been admired; it is that in which for the first time he touches the question of sla- very. “Now that you are going to have peace, allow me to propose to you a plan which might become very useful to the negro portion of the human race. Let us join and buy a small estate where we can try to give liberty to the negroes.” Lafayette was always in quest of some great and noble purpose. He embarked in June, 1784, on his third journey to America, and was received triumphantly wherever he went. Washington met him at Richmond and took him to Mt. Vernon. He had a formal reception in the Congress; bis name was given to various towns; he became a citizen of the United States. His first act on his return to France was a campaign for the Protestants, who had no civil status at the end of the eighteenth century. Their marriages were not legitimate, their wills.had no legal force, their children were bastards. It is cer- tainly curious to see that at first Lafayette found no echo. “ Nobody,” he writes to Wash- ington, “is willing to give me a written line or to help me in any way.” In these years which preceded the French Revolution, Lafayette received many English- men and Americans. He had for his coureur an American Indian in his original costume, who catled him father. He received Marmon- tel, the Abbé Morellet, the writers and the philosophers. He lived with great simplicity. When the state of the finances determined the convocation of 144 Notables, he was chosen one, and he played an important part in the meetings of this pseudo-parliament, He ex- amined boldly all the reforms which could be made, and stood by the principle that retrench- ment was to precede the creation of new taxes. Calonne proposed to the King to shut

him up in the Bastille, but Louis XVI. was sincerely inclined to the policy of reform and of retrenchment. Lafayette was the first to pronounce ip the Assembly of the Notables the word “States-General.’® The effect was extra- ordinary. “What,” said the Comte d’ Artois, “you ask for the convocation of the States- General?” “Yes, Sir, and even something bet- ter.” The “something better” was a national and representative assembly. Lafayette obtained civil equality for the Protestants, and it is only just to say that his chief supporter was the Bishop of Langres. “He has,” said the latter, “spoken as a philoso- pher. 1 speak as a bishop, and I will say that I prefer the temple to the préche and ministers to prédicants.” Lafayette was elected deputy of the order of nobility for the sénéchaussée of Riom in the States-General at the very mo- ment when Washington had accepted the Presidency of the United States. His career in the difficult years of the Revolution is well known. He had illusions, but not too many. He knew that the Tarpeian rock was near the Capitol, On the very day when he arrived in Paris at the Hétel de Noailles, for the assem- bling of the States-General, he told this story to his family: He had made in 1785 a visit to the great Frederick at Potsdam, and in their conversation he had maintained that America would never have either noblemen or kings. “<Sir,’ said a moment afterwards the old King, fixing on me his penetrating eye, ‘I have known a young man who, after having visited countries where liberty and equality reigned, took it into his head to establish all that in his own country. Do you know what happened to hiw?’ ‘No, Sire.’ ‘Sir,’ con- tinued the King with a smile, ‘he was hanged.’” Lafayette would not have been hanged, he would certainly have been guillo- tined if he had not fled the army at the mo- ment when he had become the béte noire of the Jacobins. It will ever be a sad and painful thing to go over those agitated years which followed the convocation of the States-Genera], and which ended in the establishment of a bloody and or- ganized Terror. Events follow each other in quick succession, but their direction is always thesame. The Constitutional party, the party that thought of establishing in France a gov- ernment similar to that of England, has soon to give way to the Republican party; the deputies of France become the mere tools of the clubs of the capital; the clubs themselves devour each other—after the Girondins, the Jacobins. When we read this second half of the work of M. Bardoux, we are struck by the great hatred which Queen Marie-Antoinette felt for Lafayette. Ata time when there was a ques- tion of choosing between him and Pétion for Mayor of Paris, she preferred Pétion; she thought he could manage the popular party better than Lafayette. Lafayette was a gen- tleman, a nobleman, and the Queen resented what she considered as his defection more keenly than she did the folly of a Pétion. It is unbecoming and cruel to say a word against the unfortunate Marie-Antoinette; but the historian may deplore that she would never place confidence in a man like Lafayette, who was not a real enemy of monarchy, and’ who, at any rate, could always be trusted and was incapable of treason. Lafayette, as commanu- er of the National Guard of France, became the real gaoler of the King and Queen. Such are the terrible fatalities of history. His turn came soon afterwards; he, also, had his “ flight to Varennes,” but he was luckier than the

a

Page 19

nage

Sept. 1, 1892] The Nation.

King and the Queen: his life was spared, but he knew the bitterness of exile and the languor of captivity in an Austrian prison. Correspondence. RAPHAEL’S HOURS AND GALATEA. To THE EpiTror OF THE NATION: Sir: Your correspondent calls attention to the resemblance between the “‘Third Hour of the Day ” in Raphael’s “Hours” and the “ Galatea” in the Farnesina fresco. This re- semblance, which is so close as to make it im- possible to doubt that one figure was copied from the other, was long ago pointed out by Passavant in his book upon Raphael (‘Rafael von Urbino und sein Vater Giovanni Santi’). Oddly enough, in the original (the German) edition of his book Passavant, by a species of heterophemy, escribes the origin of these fig- ures of the Hours to the enthusiasm excited by the discoveries in Pompeii. 1 am writing away from my books, but I believe that in the French translation of the ‘Rafael ’ “the Baths of Titus” is substituted for “ Pompeii.” The action of the arms and bands is precise- ly the same in the “ Galatea” and in the “Third Hour,” but Galatea holds in both hands the reins with which she guides the dol- phins attached to her sea-shell chariot, while in the Hour a censer with burning incense is substituted for the dolphins, and the chains it swings by take the place of the reins. Another point to notice in the Galatea fresco is, that the Cupid lying on the dolphin in the fore- ground is as nearly like as possible to the in- fant Christ in the Bridgewater Madonna. Of these two figures also, it may be said, it is im- possible to doubt that one was copied from the other. Which of the two figures thus repeat- ed, the Galatea and the Cuftid, was the origi- nal? Were they first used in the Farnesina fresco, or were they employed in that picture after they had done service elsewhere—the one in the Vatican, the other in the Bridgewater Madonna? The figure of the “ Hour” is so well balanced in design and so logical in composi- tion that it looks made expressly for the place it fills. The “Galatea,” when compared with it, has rather the air, cf an adaptation. The Cupid, on the other hand, seems at home on his dolphin in the “Galatea,” while a sprawling lusty infant in the Madonna picture he has certainly an incongruous look. C.C. 1892, as FISHKILL-ON-HUDSON, August 22, THE PROCESS OF AN ERROR. To THE EDITOR OF THE Nation: Sir: I wish to make a few observations on a point which your review of Mr. Samyel Ramsey’s English Language and English Grammar, in No. 1410, leaves untouched. With regard to ‘‘ the expressions of which ‘the house was being built’ is atype,’’ Mr. Ramsey writes: ‘* According to Mr. Kington Oliphant, this form of expression came into common use about 1770, although he cites two examples more than’ 300 years older. How many ex- amples escaped notice we cannot say; but so much is clear, that the expression has been in the language more than 400 years.’’ P. 473. First we find Mr. Oliphant saying: ‘* The new-fangled tea is being made, or any such-like construction, was not in vogue until about 1770.’ ‘*OQwing to this confusion, a wholly new English idiom was produced about

1770." The Old and Middle English pp. 3887, 389, Mr. Oliphant is here indebted to me, though I am unmentioned, and not even alluded to In my English Adjectives in -able (1877), p. 28, foot-note, I quote ‘* there is a good opera now being acted,” and, ** Sir Guy Carlton was ta being exramined,’’ from letters of Mrs. James Harris (1769), pam her husband the fa mous philologist (1779), respectively. Desiring to be quite sure about these passages, I addressed a note to the late Earl of Ma!mes- bury, the editor of the work in which they oc cur, begging him to look at their originals The Earl thereupon wrote to me: ‘In reply to your note respecting the diction of the First Lord Malmesbury’s letters, I] beg to you that the manuscript was copied literally, and in no degree altered.’’ In The New English (1886), vol. 18S, foot-note, Mr. O.iphant of ** He seems unaware of the fact that the idiom was anything but new.’’ S7S) l ‘ . inform ii., p says me; Itsantiquity he professes » p. 273, .P to have shown in vol. i and vol. 5S. 1! The ‘‘ twoexamples more than 300 vears oh N > than 1770, which Mr. Ramsey refers to, I have proved, in this journal, vol. xliv., p. 447 (L887), to be forgeries of Mr. Oliphant, if in terpolation is forgery. This matter, I may add, has been examined by Mr. R. O. Williams, in Our Dictionaries, ete. (189), pp. 40, 41 and p. 138. Again, in this journal, vol. xiv., p. 318 (1887), I have pointed ont that Mr. Oliphant was misled, by unscrupulous editing, in his representation that ‘* [taly is berg held gerous’”’ fellfrom the in 1611. My discussion of Eng ish Imperfect in Modern English IST73), pp. 21 seems, by the by, dan pen of a letter- writer s Passive 359 an i Sos, to have escaped Mr. Ram sey’s researches. Anticipating, it , the emergence constructions jike those in question fs, ** still being robbed, vol. Pp Thomas Porter Earlier quotations of we re may a *? quoted in this journal, xiv., 156 (1S87), from The Villain, by 1663), than the the Harrises is , by upwards of a century, viv®n the followirg, above from which, if clear of corruption, is critically in point: ** Thence Creed and I, by water, up to Fox Hall, and over against it stopped, think: ng see some Cock-fighting: but . was just being done, and, therefore, back ain to Spring Garden.’’ Samuel Pepys (June L667 Diary, ete. (1875-79), vol. iv., p. 357, Myn appear <i by This sentence, taken from the Rev. Bright's edition of —— not among the excerpts previously. publishe Lord Braybrooke. The Prof. Skeat, kindness, informs me, relating to the sentence, rs does his never-failing reply to inquiry that believes Mr. Bright has been dead some years,* and adds ‘I do not know who now can read Pepys’ ci pher.’’ Rev. with in an he He also says, in the letter from which I am quoting: ‘I quite believe that is being can boast of no ‘early imstances.’ I know of none.’’ In Mr. Williams’s book which I have alrea- dy named, Miss A Austen’s ‘‘ for, as to Frank, it was more than being tacitly brought up as his uncle’s heir ’’ is cited as if it exemplified locu- tions like ts being built. But Miss ‘being brought up,’’ instead of forming part of an imperfect tense, is a passive gerund, forming part of a phrasal nominative after ** was, '’ the nominative before which is ** it,”? * Mr. Bright died in : 1883, - _Ep. NaTiox, Austen’s *- 16 it is not shooting, that I object to,’’ who would think of extracting ** is being shot,’ Furtber remarks on the style of construction about which Mr. Ramsey has repeated an ex ploded misstatement, I postpone to another o H

From ‘* but being shot, * as an imperfect ? casion. F MARLESPORD, EN@LANI Notes. », August 4, istry press th Henry Hout & volume of Ten Brink's Co. Rave in e@ second Karly Engiish Litera ture’; ‘German Literature in its Chief Epochs,’ by Prof. Kuno Francke « f tiarvard; a transla

tion of Prof. KR. Falkenberg’s ‘History of Mo dern Philosophy,’ from Nicholas of Cusa to the present time; ‘tiume,” by Prof. Aikens of Trinity, N.C. ; ‘Hegel,’ by Prof, Royce of Ha vard,; a‘ Dictionary of Botanical Terms,’ poy lar as well as scientific, by A. A.C rogier, and ‘Physics,’ by Prof. George F. Barker { the University of Pennsyly G. P. Putnam's Sons announce that they have Nin preparation an edition of the wri ms of Thomas Paine, edited by bis latest biographer, Mr. Moncure DD. Conway. It will make two or three volumes uniform with the Life, with divisions (1) political and sociological, and religious and literary; and the reprint will be from the original publications Mr. Can way will furnish notes. The undertaking is much to be commentied, The Shaks} ere Society of New York pro; a four-text edition of “Hamlet,” to be sold to 73) subscribers. In exact facsimile the texts of 1608, 104, 1623, will be paralleled with an eclectic modern text, and accompanied by a translation of the German version performed in Dresden in 10038. Lhe volume will be luxu riously got up. Macmillan & ¢ the King The ginally appeared in three oct by the with the if vel bv F. Marion ( rawford. bave in press ‘Children ‘a new pn of Charles Dik which ori- ‘ Letters kens, * avo volumes, are to be compressed same firm into one uniforni pepular edition of the novels Ginn & Co. pr n to Narrative rof. Morris H. Morgan of Harv The letters, ected in English version by Mr Fy rd, Christopber Columbus,’ volume, ir current ‘An Intro- Greek Composition,’ by mise in the fall ductic ard, etec., of been Paul Lei- ‘Writings of whieh will shortly be Webster & Co., who ‘Autobiographia; or, the Story of a Life,’ selections from the prose writings of Walt Whitman, by Arthur Stedman. the Century Company’s fall list inch ‘Old Italian Masters,’ veral other reprints from the Century, Mrs. Van ‘Eng Cathedrals,’ illustrated by Joseph Pennell—in two editions; ‘Plays in Provence,’ Columbus have colle cester in a volume called published by Charles L. anneunce also ides, besides Mr. Cole's se- viz., Rensselaer’s lish by the same artist in col- laboration with Mrs. Pennell; Dr. Weir Mitch- ell’s ‘Characteristics’; Dr. J. M. Buckley’s ‘Faith-Healing, Christian Science, and Kin- dred Phenomena,’ and a new edition of Frank Stockton’s works in tive volumes, sold only in sets. The Hakluyt Society in two volumes, Pietro della Valle’s eight ietters from India, edited by Mr. Edward Grey, late of the Bengal Civil Service. The same society will issue next year, also in two volumes, the voyages of Capt. Luke Foce and Capt. James to Hudson’s Bay, edited by Mr. Miller Christy. Mr. Clements Markham, the distinguished are about to issue,

President of the Society, has lately been stay-

Page 20

The Nation. [Vol. 55, No. 1418 ing at Genoa and studying the Columbian re- cords. He has promised to contribute a collec- tion of unpublished early voyages to America —fragments relating to Cabot, Cortereal, Ves- pucci, and Verrazzano. Mr. Delmar Morgan, the genial Honorary Secretary of the Hak- luyt, has in contemplation the publication of an edition of the letters of Peter Martyr d’Anghiera, the cbronicler of the great events of the reign of Ferdinand and Isabella. Mean- while, Dr. Robert Brown’s edition of Leo Africanus is nearly ready for the printer; and the same may be said of a book on early Eng- lish voyages to the Levant, with some account of the Levant Company, by Mr. Theodore Bent. Mr, Everard im Thurm, who is now in England on leave of absence from British Guiana, hopes to devote two months of work at Torquay this autumn to his edition of Schomburgk’s very admirable volume of Sir Walter Raleigh’s ‘Empire of Guiana.’ The latest step in the popularization of criti- cal views about the composite structure of the Pentateuch is taken in Prof. E. C. Bissell’s ‘Genesis Printed in Colors’ (Hartford: Bel- knap & Wartield). Each supposed documen- tary source or fragment has its own color of type, and the result is a typographically well- executed and graphic presentation of thescheme of textual analysis adopted by Kautzsch and Socin. Prof. Bissell himself does not go with the critics, and in a brief introduction makes an assault upon their methods and re- sults. This lends a curious impression to his book, as if it were a testimony to the robust- ness of his own faith: he reasserts the old opi- nion in the face of the demonstration that it is no longer tenable. ‘Poor’s Manual of the Railroads of the Unit- ed States’ (New York: H. V. & H. W. Poor) rounds out its twenty-fifth year with its pre- sent issue. In the quarter century the task of the editors has grown from dealing with 39,250 miles of road to dealing with nearly four times that number (170,601 on January 1, 1892). The tonnage in the same period has increased fifteen fold. When to these simple figures we add the capital invested and the number of persons dependent upon or immediately affect- ed by the railroad system, the folly of strikers who think the fiat of a ‘‘lodge’’ can with- stand the weight of such an interest, becomes apparent. The Messrs. Poor themselves suc- cumb to it, for in order to keep their volume within bounds they are constrained tu separate some matters for issue in a new form, viz., ‘Poor’s Directory of Railway Officials’ and ‘Poor’s Handbook of Investment Securities,’ which must share the authoritative character of the older publication. Two bibliographies are on our table, one a * List of Books relating to Aaron Burr,’ by Hamilton Bullock Tompkins (Brooklyn: His- torical Printing Club). This fills eighty-three pages and as many leaves, and indicates in what public libraries the books may be found. The other work is a ‘Homceopathic Bibliogra- phy of the United States (1825-1891),’ by Thomas Lindsley Bradford, M.D. (Philadel- phia: Boericke & Tafel), a work of large pro- portions—nearly 600 pages—and seemingly con- scientiously executed. It deals not only with books, and with books con as well as pro, but with societies, colleges, hospitals, dispensaries, pharmacies, and, synoptically, medical legis- lation in the several States, In reprints, we have ‘Three Feathers’ and ‘Madcap Violet,’ in the Harpers’ uniform se- ries of William Black’s novels; ‘The Old Curi- osity Shop,’ with ‘Master Humphrey’s Clock,’ and ‘Martin Chuzzlewit,’ in Charles Dickens the younger’s reproduction of first editions of his father’s worbs (Macmilian) ; and two final volumes in Roberts Bros.’ edition of Jane Aus- ten. The tirst call for no special remark, ‘ihe Dickens volumes have a particular interest for America, since the original scheme of ‘Master Humpbhrey’s Clock’ involved a journey to the United States in search of material for that ill-conceived periodical, and ‘ Martin Chuz- zlewit,’ if not a product of the journey, profited by it, and was laid to the charge of Dickens along with the ‘American Notes.’ The introductions give all necessary bibliographi- cal information, and the original illustrations are reproduced, The posthumous ‘Lady Susan’ and ‘The Watsons,’ together with Mr. Austen Leigu’s memoir of his aunt, fill one of the pretty volumes of the Messrs. Roberts, The other consists of a selection of letters of Jane Austen from Lord Brabourne’s compilation. Miss Woolsey, who is responsible for this, fur- nishes a preface. The set is now capitally rounded out. Two portraits of the author are given in these last volumes, and a view of her burial-place in Winchester Cathedral. The contrast between ‘Young Lucretia, and Other Stories,’ by Mary E, Wilkins (Harpers), and ‘The Pot of Gold,’ which was published contrary to her wish, is all in favor of the au- thor’s judgment. We willingly exchange the fantastic element of those earlier tales for these strong characters in plain setting. Miss Wilkins’s children are as real as her grown peo- ple, and as distinctly possessed of the New England conscience which gives point to nearly all the stories, Her condensed style will es- pecially suit young readers. Any student who is industrious enough to keep a manuscript volume of notes and criti- cisms on his reading, and a scrap-book in con- nection with it, will find opportunity for still further labor, not without compensation, in T. E. Shields’s ingenious ‘Index Omnium’ (Bos- ton: Joseph Knight Co.). This provides for a catalogue of the books annotated, and a diction- ary of leading words by which the thought or passage can be traced back to the author, or to the synopses and criticisms in the subsidiary volumes mentioned above. ‘the nearly three thousand lines of entry for books read would serve, if one chose, for cataloguing a very re- spectable private library. Two little volumes, the fruit of recent studies by Prof. A. Beljame, may be recom., mended to students of the French language, but also to those who would have a better knowledge of their own English tongue. One is a prose translation of Tennyson’s ‘Enoch Arden,’ facing the original text; the other is the same poem annotated and supplied with very happy comparisons of Tennyson with himself and with other poets and writers, and an elaborate examination of the versification of ‘Enoch Arden.’ Add a sketch of the life of Tennyson, and a bibliography which enu- merates translations into Latin, German, Spanish, Dutch, Hungarian, Italian, Nor- wegian, Czech, and French—for Prof. Beljame has had _ predecessors. His publisher is Hachette. From Hachette, too (Boston: Carl Schoen- hof), comes a school edition of Manzoni’s ‘I Promessi Sposi’ in pocket form, and therefore, of course, abridged; the sequel of the story after the flight of “the betrothed” being dis- carded. There are notes and a partial vocabu- lary. The eleventh annual report of the Dante Society at Cambridge, Mass., reveals an in- creasing membership and one very notable loss—the late Mr. Lowell. Prof. Carpenter concludes his valuable reproduction of docu- ments concerning Dante’s public life. Mr. William C. Lane, with his customary skill, records the additions to the Dante collection in the Harvard Library. A Harvard Annex prize essay of last year, by Lucy Allen Paton, concludes the pamphlet, and will be read with profit. ‘the subject is Dante’s personal character, and for the major part is ade- quately treated, with some painstaking induc- tions and references for which students will be grateful to the author. The old records of the ancient English Colony of Barbados are being now recopied at the public expense. Although the colony was planted as far back as 1627, fires and hurri- canes have wrought havoc among its archives, and historical students will be glad to learn that a fair number of papers date as far back as 1640. Americans who may be engaged upon his- torical researches should know that the branch of the Record Office, London, where the papers relating to America and the Plantations are dealt with, is now in charge of Mr. Hubert Hall, who is a most efficient successor to Mr. Noel Sainsbury. Prof. W. M. Davis has recently published an interesting article upon winter thunder- storms, in which, from comparison of observa- tions, he finds that while such storms are in- deed less common in winter than in summer, those which do occur during the cold season are chiefly at night and near the coast. He concludes that the convectional origin of sum- mer thunder-storms implies a like origin’ for such storms in winter, near or upon the ocean, even if they are chiefly nocturnal. He regards them provisionally as chiefly dependent upon a pronounced vertical temperature gradient, which may be determined partly by the cool- ing of the upper air by radiation about the lofty cloud stratum of cyclonic storms, and partly by the maintenance of relatively high temperatures in the lower air by the conserva- tive power of the o¢ean. At a recent meeting of the Royal Meteoro- logical Society, Mr. E.J. Lowe read a paper upon raindrops. By careful study, and after making more than three hundred sketches, he has developed some curious facts relating to the varieties in raindrops—subjects wherein the careless observer would have said no differ- ence could exist. An ingenious method of preserving their forms was described. By means of slates ruled in inch squares and made in book form, to be capable of instant closing, the splash of the drop was accurately obtained, and afterwards copied upon paper similarly ruled, It was found that some drops make a clean, circular spot, others show splashes about the edge, and some drops seem to be actually hollow, failing to wet the whole sur- face enclosed. The size varies from a mere point to a spot of at least two inches in diameter. Mr. lowe exhivited, also, diagrams of interest as showing the shapes of low-lying mist-drops, and of the forms taken by melting snowflakes. — The September Atlantic gives little occa- sion for comment. Apart from the serials, which occupy the space of the number to an unusual degree, room is found for a nature paper from the sympathetic pen of Olive Thorne Miller, under the clever but misleading title, “Cliff-Dwellers in the Cafion”; for a “Memory” paper, which contains a pre-natal reminiscence of the sort collected by psychical- research societies; and for a seasonable paper on the worn but important subject of how to teach literature in the schools, by Mr. Horace E.Scudder, It is not the first time that Mr. Scudder has urged the desirability of a more sntesntt “ap dea RbR ND Pherae A oa A ee eat

Page 21

é x Hn 3 a ? § 3 % . $ a I Ney Shi ERAN tA ae dn an’ Or etaeeR CW, aatecwittensanaean Sept. 1, 1892] —————————————— — - ~ rational method in the younger reading-classes, and, indeed, so much has been said in all quarters that nothing remains except to keep the subject alive and, if possible, troublesome, in the hope of wearing out the stolid conserva- tism of the “committeemen” by importunity, or of exciting the routine-drilled teacher to ex- periment by reiterated advice and encourage- ment. It may be suspected that one difficulty in the way is that such articles do not reach the power in control—that is, the schoul board; and teachers seem rather to rely on purely educational publications in which they have a voice, or, at least, find these topics treated from the pedagogic point of view. Mr.Scud- der treats the subject from the position of a man of letters who believes in the educating power of literature as one of its great func- tions; and the methods he suggests of prepar- ing the minds of school-children from the start, so that they shall come to the appreciation of the best books as naturally as they pass from arithmetic to geometry, are such as have been widely approved by thinking literary men, and should have entered upon the practical stage of reform before now. The poet Whittier pays a tribute to Dr. Holmes upon the occasion of his birthday, in lines which reflect the serenity and pleasantness of his own old age. —Harper’s continues the thumb-nail review of Parisian literary celebrities, or pseudo- celebrities, by Theodore Child, and at the head are placed the cultivators of “egoism” on the one hand and the followers of Vogiié on the other, as the present players on that stage of the coteries which has been contem- porary with literature in Paris; and the author winds up with sketches of the old lions, the dramatists, and the editors. The most spirited paper is Mr. Martin’s sporting contri- bution, describing fox-hunting in the Genesee Valley, where all the conditions for the sport exist in ideal perfection. Mr. Ralph writes of the State of Washington in his usual vein, and the back-country town-meeting is again de- scribed as “The Aryan Mark” by Miss Anna C. Brackett, while Mr. Howard Pyle pictures better than he describes the Sand-Hil/s. The most curious paper is Mr. Hutton’s series of illustrations of death-masks, ranging from Dante to “Ben Caunt,” with its thoroughly in- formed and lightly worded text. —The Century contains a full account of the exploration of the Grand Falls of Labrador last summer by Henry G. bryant, illustrated with several views which give us the first ocu- lar knowledge of this great natural feature of the North, which has so long lain just beyond our horizon, The expedition was made at the same time the Bowdoin College party set out with the same object, and a narrative of the ex- perience of the latter has been told, as Mr. Bryant remarks, in a scientific publication; but he was more fortunate in reaching results, and brought back measurements and photo- graphs. The height of the principal fall is 316 feet, and the breadth about 50 yards, being narrowed in the rapids from a breadth of 300 yards a mile upstream. The story of the journey is told in an interesting way, and the wonder is that in these days the journey should have been so long unperformed, though not altogether unattempted. Alaska affords ma- terial for another paper of travel, and Mr. Roosevelt touches the same ground of interest in his Elk-Hunt in Northwestern Wyoming. Mr.Stedman concludes his papers on poetry; the Life of Columbus and the World’s Fair series go on; and there is a large bunch of short stories. A welcome is given to Dvorak, The Nation. dore Robinson writes with enthusiasm, but not without restraint, of Monet; and Prof. Brander Matthews contributes a unique article upon ar tistic posters, mainly of Parisian origin, in which he contidently discerns the promise of a new, if humble, art. Scribner's brings forward the subject of the Tilden Library in this city, in regard to which Mr. John Bigelow makes several sugges tions, the most important being the proposition to place it in Bryant Park and to give ita special cruciform shape, in adopting which it is possible that librarians and architects might agree. The study is a suggestive one, and the proposals made will no doubt receive proper consideration. The article upon “The Educa tion of the Blind” gives information upon a subject which remains a mystery to most per sons, and elucidates the different systems of printing; incidentally, too, by mention of a few cases of striking success in educating the blind, the author encourages increased inte rest in what is certainly one of the most fruit ful of modern philanthropic efforts. The his tory of the buffalo, the prosperity of the Pueblo Indian, the Névsky Prospékt (in the Streets of the World), and ‘JIassical Painting, are the re maling series of Great French topics. —Prof. James Bryce’s interesting and sug gestive address on the “Migrations of the Races of Men Considered Historically,” de livered before the Royal Scottish Geographical Society at the inauguration of its London branch, is printed in the August number of After dwelling for a moment on the fact that geography is the meeting-point of the sciences, be defines the three different population under the terms Transference, lis persion, and Permeation. To the first of these belong the most of the prehistoric migrations and those which overthrew the Roman Em the Society ’s magazine. forms of the movements of pire. The second is the overtlowing of a race into new lands, as the British into Nort! America and Australia, or the Russians into Siberia. The third covers those instances in which “one race or nation so spreads over an other race or nation its language, its litera ture, its religion, its institutions, its customs, or some one or more of these sources of in fluence, as to impart its own character to the nation so influenced, and thus to substitute its | own for the original type.” The earliest known instance of this diffusion is that of the Minor and th® countries; a later, that of the Greeks over Asia adjacent Arabs over Syria, Egypt, and Nogthern Africa. Prof. Bryce suggests the possibility also of a similar result in India from English influence, with- out, however, any mixture of | bly with ia! little socia* intimacy,” U lood, “ possi between the European and native races. The main causes of these migrations are food, war, and labor; religion and love of freedom having operated rarely and with but comparat sults. usually those of words, they bave followed the “lines of equal mean temperature, and not so much, I think, of mean annual heat as of mean winter heat.” [he great movements of population Prof. bryce ively small re lhe lines followed by them have been least resistance, or, in other divides into five epochs or groups, the prehis- torie (including the Etruscan and Arvan, the earliest recorded); the Phconician, Israelite, and Greek; that termed by the Germans the Wandering of the Peoples ( Volkerwanderung) ; the Monammedan; and the modern, beginning with the discovery of America. The latter is 167 | whose portrait is the frontispiece; Mr. Theo divided again into four great eras, that of the Spaniards into tropical America, the negmes from Africa, the English and French tnto North America, and the emigration from Europe within tbe last seventy years. A brief reference only made to the analogy between these movements and those of animals and plants, as, for instance, the invasion of Europe in comparatively recent times by the brown itive of Asia gave reasons for the behef that the results of rat, a1 In closing, Prof. Bryce «litical organizations ind types of } n ure will be fewer and fewer, showing that since the eleventh century arisen in Europe, nor has races to America the migra 1 of iferen produced a new national type, The time is not ir stant, howeve whem the titable parts of the world will be tilled and the out- flow of the nations stopyx and then we miay enter upon a “new era, Whose phenomena will prove unlike any that have gone before “Franklin lortraits” is a notable feature of the July Bulletin of the Reston Pulliie Li brary, the list amounting to J numbers Phe two oil paintings of Franklin—a«a Duplessis and a supposed Greure nh the possessicn of the Library are very well copied by “process” to ! Nesides this valu able achievement in a field heretofore little ex plored, the editers of the Bulletin annex a catalogue of the “John A. Lewis Library,” now forming o1 f its most precious collee- tions in the domain of early Boston books and Purita ature ihe volumes repre senting the Mather family alone exceed two } ij undred, and in addition to the large propor- tion of sermons embraced in them there are hundreds by various ministers, in the very titles f which are reflected the annals of New Eng- land, the polity of the Bay Colony, the morals and the superstitions of the time Not a few of them 1 itudes since, doubtless de- served the rg title, “A manufactory ser- on,” inn nily applied to the Rev. Thomas Barnarid’s dise rse in 1758 before the Boston Society for Fr: iraging Industry and Em- oying the Poor. Others had serious occasion enough, like the common article of death, many worthies being commemorated at their taking if, as Benjamin Colman’s ‘ Ossa Josephi. t the | s Jose Considered in a ser- mon preached at the lecture in Boston after the funeral of the very honorable and excellent i720).? Comets always Joseph Dudley, Es ,as one did to Increase j- suggested a sermon Mather in 1682, viz., his ‘ Heaven's Alarm to the World. Or asermon wherein is shewed that heaven are the presages of great calamities at hand. Second ’ Much more, of course, were isend to the pulpit—* the f God and tokens of bis just displea- rding to the Rev. Thomas Prince in traced in 1749, after an acute “the natural and moral govern- ment and agency of God in causing droughts and rains.” After Cotton Mather’s ‘ Wonders of the Invisible World,’ it is meedless to cite the witchcraft sermons collected by Mr. Lewis. Mather furnished ‘the Answer of several ministers in and near Boston to that whether it is lawful for a man to marry his wives own sister,’ as well fearful sights and signs in kes a ge WoOTAKS sure,” ace 1727, who also experience, Incr@ise case of conscience, question, “whether it be lawful for a church-member among us to be frequently And he shot ‘An Arrow against as to the in taverns?” Profane and Promiscuous Dancing. Drawn out of the quiver of the Scriptures.’ Joseph Seccombe, on the other hand, held ‘ Business and Diversicn Inoffensive to God, and neces-

Page 22

168 The Nation. [Vol. 55, No. 1418 sary for the Comfort and Support of Human Society. A discourse uttered in part at Am- mauskeeg-Falls, in the fishing-season.” Apart from well-known New England rareties in this collection, we notice a ‘ Vade Mecum for Ame- rica: or a Companion for Traders and Tra- vellers’ (Boston, 1732); a Hebrew Grammar for Harvard students (Boston, 1735); and Tully’s “Cato Major” printed with explana- tory notes of his own by Franklin in Phila- delphia in 1744. —Some of our readers who have known Mr. F. C. Penrose, supervising architect of St. Paul’s in London, as Director of the British School of Archzeology at Athens, will be inte- rested to learn that the King of Greece has just conferred upon him the Golden Cross of ‘the Order of the Saviour, to which not a few Hellenists of distinction, Prof. W.W.Goodwin among them, already belong. Meanwhile, Miss Emily Penrose, his daughter, has illustrated Somerville College, Oxford, by achieving a dis- tinction never before won by any of her sex— a first-class in the Final School of Literw Hu- maniores. The remarkable knowledge of His- tory and Archzology which enabled her to win a distinction hitherto considered beyond a wo- man’s reach, was we)l exemplified in a lecture on “Ancient Methods of Voting” which she gave at a friend’s house in Oxford, just at the close of the recent heated electoral campaign. Miss Penrose has been presented to a Travel- ling Fellowship, and is now studying at Ber- lin, In the autumn she announces lectures on Greek and Roman history and archeology; some of them to be given (by permission of the Trustees) at the British Museum, Nor is this the only proof in store for us of the care- ful study of Greek that English women are now making. Following to some extent the example of Miss Harrison and Mrs. Verrall, Miss Eugénie Sellars is preparing a text, with translation and annotation, of those parts of the Elder Pliny’s Natural History which bear upon Art and Archeology. This work is al- ready so far advanced toward completion that its publication is arranged for. STRACHEY’S HASTINGS AND ROHILLA WAR. Hastings and the Rohilla War. By Sir Jobn Strachey, G.C.S.I. Oxford: Clarendon Press; New York: Macmillan. Macav.ay’s Essay on Warren Hastings has hitherto been accepted and admitted into the historical curriculum as not only a brilliant piece of narrative and rhetoric, but a faithful account of the events with which it deals and a genuine picture of the early period of British rule in India. As a study in history it ought now to be laid aside, however highly it may be admired as a specimen of narrative and rhetoric, With regard to the story of Nunco- mar, Sir James Stephen seems to have conclu- sively proved that the famous essay is a tissue of brilliant fable. He has shown that Hastings had nothing whatever to do with the trial of Nuncomar for forgery, which arose out of a lawsuit long anterior to the existence of any collision or relations of any kind between the two men, or with his execution; that the charges against Impey of judicial murder and other outrages are baseless; that Nuncomar had a perfectly tair trial, though under a very harsh law; and that the general picture of misrule and oppression, though by no means imaginary, is, like most of Macaulay’s pic- tures, monstrously overdrawn. THE Sir John Strachey has now performed a si- milar operation with regard to the “ Rohilla” charge. ‘hat charge was supposed to weigh most heavily of all on the memory of Hastings. It bad never been judicially investigated, Pitt having refused to impeach upon it, though he turned round and with his obedient train of followers voted for. impeachment on the charge of extortion practised on Cheyte Singh, which is now, we believe, held to have been ground- less, Cheyte Singh having been in reality re- quired to pay no more than was due by the terms on which he held his fief, or than a na- tive suzerain would have exacted. The charge continued, therefure, to pass current and ob- tain universal credence in Burke’s rhetorical or super-rhetorical version; and the author of the last Life of Burke, Mr. John Morley, ac- cepts it without hesitation and moralizes in the usual strain. It is now, apparently, dis- proved. ‘he belief. embecdied in Macaulay’s Essay is that the Rohillas were a nation of vir- tuous and prosperous husbandmen and me- chanics, “not negligent,” to use Macaulay’s expression, “of rhetoric and poetry”; that they were invaded without cause and ruthless- ly exterminated, while their smiling land was made a waste, by the Nabob Vizier of Oude; and that Hastings sold for a great sum the services of the British Army as auxiliaries in the invasion and extermination. The facts now, if we may trust Sir John Strachey, turn out to be that the Rohillas were not a nation at all, but a tribe of Afghan freebooters who had planted themselves in the midst of a con- quered Hindu yopulation and subsisted upon the labor of their subjects, not tilling the earth themselves nor pursuing any art or trade but war; that they had got, against the faitn of a treaty, into sinister relations with the Mahrattas, and were threatening to lay open Oude, and ultimately the British Dominion, to the devastating inroads of those terrible maraud- ers; that Hastings, in lending the Nabob the assistance of the British forces, was therefore pursuing a virtually defensive policy and vio- lating no rule of public morality—certainly no rule recognized in the political ethics of Hin- dustan; and that the payment for the troops was taken from the Nabob not as a bribe, or as the hire of mere mercenaries, but in fulfil- ment of a regular agreement that the cost should be so defrayed when. British troops were employed beyond the limits of their own terri- tory. Nota Robilla, it seems, can be proved to have been killed except in battle, and a por- tion only of them were ultimately banished from the cOuntry. Excesses were committed by the Nabob’s army, as excesses are commit- ted in all Hindu wars, but were deprecated and restrained instead of being cynically de- fended, as it has been alleged that they were, by Hastings. The native Hindu population, in- stead of being extirpated, bad reasen, when the war was over, to rejoice in their change of masters, and the land smiled more than ever. The only thing which lends color, it appears, to the black version of the affair given by Burke, and which his magnificent rhetoric has made familiar to all fancies, is the natural but compromising anxiety of Hastings to prove to his mercantile employers, the directors of the East India Company, that the transaction had been to their pecuniary advantage. A ridicu- lous feature of the fictitious indictment is the confusion into which the accusers fell of Hafiz Khan, an Afghan chief, who paid his tribute to the established custom of his clan by com- posing a lay of some kind, with Hafiz, the great Persian poet of the fourteenth century, whence Macaulay has distilled his general de- scripton of the people as “not negligent of poetry or rhetoric.” Sir John Strachey is disposed to exonerate Macaulay, whom he seems to regard with a somewhat Eastern veneration, on the ground that Macaulay only implicitly followed James Mill, the historian of India, without making any independent inquiry. To follow blindly a writer whose leaning is unmistakable, in a case where his bias was sure to be peculiarly strong and where justice to great characters was involved, is certainly Jess culpable than fabrication; but the amplification and exag- geration are Macaulay’s own. In the case of Impey, he cannot be acquitted of a still graver offence. Impey’s son put forth, after the pub- lication of Macaulay’s Essay, a defence of his father’s memory. The book was the work of a man devoid of literary and controversial skill, but it brought to light certain facts, at once incontrovertible and momentous, such as that Impey had been arraigned before the House of Commons and formally acquitted, and that, at the trial of Nuncomar, he sat not alone but with three colleagues on the bench whose impartiality was open to no suspicion. Macaulay must have seen the book, and he could have had no answer to its statements, but, trusting, with too much reason, to its unread- able character and to the popular qualities of his own Essay, he continued to circulate charg- es against Impey’s memory of the grossest kind, which he must thenceforth have known to be, in part at least, untrue. It is astonish- ing that he should not have been aware from his own knewledge of Parliamentary history that the charge of judicially murdering Nun- comar by the hand of Impey had been thrown out by Burke against Hastings in Westminster Hall, no dcubt under the inspiration of Fran- cis, and had been formally disclaimed by the House of Commons, which censured Burke for having made it, while Burke never attempted to vindicate bimself by substantiating the charge. We will venture to say that no one who has compared Macaulay’s Essay with the critiques of Sir James Stephen and Sir John Strachey, will ever again feel implicit faith in Macaulay as an historian. Burke fell a victim to the malignant infusions of Francis, the deadly personal enemy of Hast- ings, combined with his own generous but un- controlled sympatbies and his rich but delusive imagination. How far he was carried away appears from his having insisted that Francis, who had fought a duel with Hastings, should be one of the managers of the impeachment— an indecency upon which Pitt, of course, put his veto. His emotions completely overcame his sense of justice. ‘Lhe articles of impeach- ment drawn by him are pronounced by Sir James Stephen “as shuffling and disingenuous in substance as they are clumsy, awkward, and intricate in form.” “‘lhey are,” says Sir James Stephen, “extremely tricky, very full of insinuations, and covering by their profu- sion of irrelevant matter the total (and no doubt designed) absence of averments essential to the conclusion which they are meant to support.” The language of Burke’s speeches in Westminster Hall is incredibly rabid and in- decent, especially when it is considered that Hastings, who was present, bad at all events filled high imperial office and done great things. Mr. Law, Hastings’s counsel, did not very much exaggerate in saying that “the low- est blackguard in a bear-garden would have been ashamed of some of the expressions.” Sir J.Strachey quotes some examples: “For years he [Hastings] lay down upon that sty of disgrace, fattening in it, lying,

Page 23

ens. Sept. 1, 1892] feeding upon that offal of disgrace and excre- ment and everything that can be opprobious to the human mind.” “Such are the damned and damnable proceedings of a judge in hell, and such a judge was Warren Hastings.” “A wild beast when his belly is full may be pleased and lick your hand. You might have a serene day under such a beast, but can you under that man Hastings?” “A captain-gene- ral of iniquity, thief, tyrant, robber, cheat, sharper, swindler; we call him all these names, and are very sorry that the English language does not afford terms equal to the enormity of his offence.” “Sir Walter Raleigh was called a spider of hell, ‘This was foolish and indecent in Lord Coke. Had he beena manager on this trial he would have been guilty of a neglect of duty had he not called the prisoner a spicer of hell.” “What! compare this man, a bul- lock-driver [Hastings was alleged to have had something to do with a contract for bullocks}, with Tamerlane and those conquerors! When God punished Pharaoh and Egypt, he did not send armies but lice and locusts to lay the land waste.” The want of good sense and self-control dis played in these outbreaks, the list of which might be lengthened and which are not with out their counterpart in Burke's Parliamentary speeches, must be held in some measure to ac- count for what has been deemed his unjust ex clusion from the Cabinet, though aristocratic prejudice may also have been in part the cause. Thelanguage of Hastings, om the other hand, is uniformly dignitied, calm, and indica- tive of a self-possession such as we might ex- pect in the man whose courage, unquailing in «xtremity, enabled him, when he was beset by an infuriated populace at Benares and in the utmost peril of his life, to send out two de- spatches, one ordering the commander of the troops at the nearest station to hasten to his assistance, the other giving directions for the prosecution of an extensive scheme of policy in which he was engaged. It is not easy for con- querors to be moral, least of all when they are contending with Mabrattas and with powers of wrong and rapine such as dominated amidst the wreck of the Mogul Empire. but Hastings was no mere marauder or tyrant; he was a great ruler after bis kind, and his rule was felt to be at least comparatively beneficial, and a refuge from the plundering anarchy which reigned around, by those over whom he ruled. From personal corruption, whether in the Ro- hilla affair or any other, he is admitted to have been free. Some of the most sagacious and patriotic of Englishmen have doubted whether England did what was best for herself in assuming the political dominion of India, and whether she would not have done more wisely bad she been content with the possessiun of stations for her trade. We may all doubt whether conquest can really and permanently be made the in- strument of civilization, while we cannot help admitting that the British Empire in India is the greatest experiment of that kind. But no one will doubt that the story of the Empire is worth telling as a record of the energy, forti- tude, and administrative power of our race; and we cordially agree with Sir John Strachey in lamenting that it has not up to this present time been well told. Nothing but a history at once true and readable will displace frou popu- lar fancy the brilliant rhetoric of Macaulay. FREEMAN'S HISTORY OF SICILY. The History of Sicily from the Earliest Times. Vol. 11I. Tbe Athenian and Cartha- ginian Invasions. By Edward A. Freeman. Macmillan & Co. 18. Pp. xxxv, 730. Just as this volume issued from the press a few months ago, Prof. Freeman was suddenly stricken by smallpox in Spain, and died. We The Nation. may say, without disparagement, that Free man’s position as an historian was already es- tablished, and could not have been changed had he lived to produce many more volumes of the gigantic bistory on which he was engaged at the time of his death. At seventy, an au- thor’s methods are fixed, his message is known; we need expect from him no further surprise, but confirmation in various forms of bis life long opinions, and the reiteration of manner isms Which perhaps astonished when they were fresh, but grow tedious with age. In the vol ume before us, Freeman comes into direct competition with precisely the noblest speci men of historical writing which has ever been produced. ‘The account which Thucydides has left of the Sicilian Expedition remains, after two-and-twenty centuries, the model, whether of historical depth and accuracy or of histo rical narration. It is, indeed, the onlw record we have of that most momentous episode, and we believe it is trustworthy, not because we can or cannot corroborate it, but because we perceive that Thucydides was one of those rare men who, by a law of their being, tell the truth. If be ever misstated, if he was silent on points about which we should be g'ad of information, we may be sure tbat he did not intend to falsify or to suppress. The sixth and seventh books of his history, which chronicle the arrogant ambition and the appalling disas ter of the Athenians at Syracuse, being thus acknowledged not only masterpieces of histo rical composition, but also the sole adequat: source from which an account of those events can be drawn, it would seem almest supertlu ous for a modern bistorian to attempt to com pete with them. He cannot add much to the substance they contain, he cannot improve upon the manner in which they are presented what, then, ean he do For one thing, be can interpret them so that they shall be wholly intelligible to readers t day. Thueydides, writing as a contemporary. could not possibly foresee the ultimate sicniti cance of the actions he described; a modern can discern the bearing of those actions, not Athens and Spar a and Syracuse, but also upon the development of the world’s histery, only upon the immediate destiny of Again, many allusions which were easily understood by Thucydides’s fellows, now need explana- granted 10w needs to be set down. And, finally tion; much that they would take for har . there is a good deal of journeyman’s work to be done in reconciling textual contradictions and settling moot points in topography. To do these things is Freeman's especial task, and in doing them he is aided by the results of recent archeologists and by his own indefatigable search for microscopic facts that may shed light on the main theme. He has, moreover, the advantage of treating the subject from the Sicilian point of view. Other hi-torians have dealt with the Sicilian Expedition as an o7- shoot from the Peloponnesian War, or as a cri tical enisode in the career of Athens; be deals with it as an experience in the career of Sicily. And though we may deplore the ruin of Athens which it involved, nevertheless we can not help feeling that the result, so far as Syra- cuse Was concerned, was just, nor can we with- hold from the Syracusans who successfully re- sisted the aggression of the Athenians, admira- tion similar to that which we feel for any other people that fought for independence. To bring this side out clearly is one of the most important of Freeman's achievements. But we suspect that to scholars his work will commend itself chiefly by its minute dis- cussion of matters which are of peculiar inte- 169 He has succeeded in locating rest to schol irs. the position of the various Athenian encamp ments, of the lines of circumvaltlation andl counter lines, and of the route taken by Nicias on his retreat. He has examined, literally, every square rod of the site of Syracuve; he has drawn inferences from the wheel marks in this place and from the traces of masonry in that; he has speculated as to the probable changes in the coust-line ef the Great Harber and as tothe extent of the swamp of Lysime leia. For one who has made no personal in spection of these things on the spet, it is un becoming to presume to decide whether Free man’s conclusions are alWayvs correct; We may sav, however, that, having seen some of the yreat battlefielis of antiquitv and of modern times, and manv of the chief ruins of Greece anil Italy, we are 1 little sceptical as to the possibility of establishing, after twenty centu ries’ obliteration, the site of &’ Veariinhe 1 pal sacle Witheut for a moment belitths the real triumphs of archeology, we still find selves distrusting much of its rounwtant evidences terha { =f ina thank ingy that Freeman's plan is, in the main, eor rect, is the fact that by it we are able to fo low Thuevdides's count, which has bithert: seemed, in part, t 1 nfhieting statements as to the topography Nevertheless, though from the ind ar rologyY this be an nuportant ga t t of corpesps ia ut portance ft i ~ point of history tor history is efty neer i wit rcfyons and results, an mr be View if matters nparsa tively little whet! the double walls of the Athenians Irie nto the shorea rhong to the north or south of the spot whiel eemal assigns His propensity for investigations of this kind tain! pairs the terest of his work t t cen iy caus t ks imt often upon the flow of narrative, and, by cor stantiv diverting the attention to details, les sens t eft \ ss of those passages which t genera { the specialist would ilike agree in prenouncing the most men rable it is to be observed, too, that these di zressions often beget no facts, but only one or more conjectures; for, as we have remarked, f the Sicilian Expedition m contemporary and authentic Diodorus Siculus sources mes from ‘Lhuecvdides. wrote three centuries and a half later, and his account of the expedition is muddled, incom- plete, aud superficial—so much so, indeed, that we can hardly believe that he had Thucydides’s work to guide bim. Plutarch, in bis lives of Alcibiades and Nicias, is the only other autho- rity, and, though Piutarch made goed use of the material that reached him, st:ll he lived as long after the siege of Syracuse as we after the wars of the Roses. To piece out Thueydi des with such scraps as Diodorus and Plutarch afford, and with such allusions as are found in other classic writers is, therefore, a task of not great extent. The number of facts cannot be added to; additions can come only by inferences and conjectures. At this work Freeman has few equals, as a single illustra- tion will show. ‘Lhucydides mentions the towns of Centuripa, Hyccara, an] Inessa; in the text the definite article happens to be omit- ted before the first two. From this omission, which a casual reader might attribute to the inaccuracy of some early copyist, Freeman de- duces the following: “ ‘Thucydides did not ex- pect his readers to have heard of Centuripa, any more than of Hyccara in vi, 62, ~%. Most likely he had never heard of those towns him self till he heard of these particular facts

Page 24

170 The Nation. [Vol. 55, No. 1418 about them. He therefore gives them no ar- ticle. Inessa, which had played so great a part in Sicilian history, he knew even when writing his earlier books. Yo Inessa, there- Sore, he gave the article. Much of the life of a great original writer is lost when these delica- cies are neglected in modern reproduction” (p. 205, note 2). We have italicized the two sen- tences in which Freeman, who starts with a vague assumption, states a conclusion with ex- treme positiveness; but, we ask, by what rule of logic can a positive conclusion be derived from premises based on assumed probability? This is Freeman’s habitual method in clearing up difficulties; and while no one can deny that his theory is often very plausible, the point to observe is that he sometimes mistakes plausi- bility for fact. To give an example of his manner of ex- panding the brief statement of Thucydides into unnecessary prolixity, we will quote the follow- ing typical passage concerning the prcceed- ings of the Athenians at Rhegium. Thucydi- des says: “At length they reached Rhegium, the ex- treme point of Italy, where the fleet reunited. As they were not received within the walls, they encamped outside the city at the temple of Artemis; there they were provided by the inhabitants with a market, and, drawing up their ships cn shore, they took a rest. ‘lihey held a conference with the Khegians, and ressed them, being Chalcidians themselves, to aid their Chalcidian kinsmen the Leon- tines. But the Rhegians replied that they would be neutral, and would ouly act in accordance with the decisiou of all the Italian Greeks.” (Jowett’s Thucydides, p. 440.) Freeman’s paraphrase runs thus: “Tt was at Rhegium, the only ally of Athens, the far older enemy of Locri, a town which had fought on the Athenian side in ear- lier warfare, that the Athenian generals tad most fully looked for welcome and alliance. The Chalcidians of Rhegium at all events must be ready to avenge the wrongs of their Chalci- dian kinsfolk of mtini, their fellows in the first alliance made between Athens and any Siciliot or Italiot city. At Rhegium the three divisions came together; a mighty show they must have made in the narrow waters. Here they did meet with better treatment than at Tarentum or Locri; but still very far beneath their hopes. They were allowed to draw up their ships on shore, and, as the historian em- phatically adds, they rested. To Greek sailors the trireme, after ali, was not a home for a long journey, but a means of conveyance and an engine of battle. Owing to the unfriendliness of the other towns, they had had to live almost wholly at their oars ever since they started from Corcyra. The rest at Rhegium must have been indeed welcome; but rest and food only were to be had. The army was quar- tered, and a market was found for them, out- side the city, in the precinct of the Khegine Artemis. But none were received within the walls, save those who went in the character of envoys, among whom we may fancy Alcibia- des, rather than Nicias, taking the leading place. They addressed the Rhegine assembly, and called on them to join in helping their Leontine kinsfolk. The answer was that Khe- ium would not act alone for either side, but do whatever was agreed on by the other Italiots.” (Pp. 137-8.) Let the reader compare this passage, in which we have not followed Freeman’s whim- sical “reformed” spelling of proper names, with the extract from Thucydides, and decide for himself whether the trebling in length is accompanied by any material gain in vividness or precision, or by any addition of genuine facts. Such a comparison will serve, better than much criticism from us could serve, to explain both Freeman’s method and why it is that his volumes swell to so huge a bulk. At times bis work seems not so much a history as a series of theses such as candidates for the doctor’s degree prepare for the delectation of the faculty of a German university. We have given so much attention to what some persons may think minor details, because it is to minor details that Freeman gives most attention. He has his own view of the signifi- cance of the great struggle he is describing, but his passion for the minutiz of topography and archzology too frequently obscures this view. There are days and weeks concerning which we have not an authentic fact, but Freeman will not pass them over in silence; he must fill the void with conjectures as to what was doing; and the result is, that he detracts somewhat from the impressiveness of the really great crises in which he has been guided by the clear light of Thucydides’s nar- rative. He has done well to give Hermocrates due prominence, because Hermocrates, besides being conspicuous as a leader of the Syracu- sans, was the first to lay down that pro- gramme of “Sicily for the Sicilians” which reappears from age to age as the central po- litical ideal of the Sicilians, down to the ex- tinction of the Bourbon tyranny a generation ago. He also emphasizes, as he should, that remarkable speech of Athenagoras in which the principles of true democracy are stated with startling clearness. His portraits of Ni- cias, Alcibiades, and Demosthenes have no new touches, but he exceeds previous historians in attributing creat qualities to Lamachus, who may have been the consummate hero Freeman would have us believe, but whose claim to that distinction rests on insufficient evidence. In its way, there is nothing better in this volume than the description of the de- vices by which the elder Dionysius became the tyrant of Syracuse; we wonder that Freeman, who sometimes makes effective use of histori- cal parallels, did not suggest a comparison be- tween Dionysius and Louis Napoleon, between whom, in their rise to despotism, many resem- blances exist. Certainly, Freeman errs when he implies that the autocratic position of Dio- nysius at Syracuse in B.c. 405 has a counter- part in the position of Abraham Lincoln dur- ing our Civil War (p. 555). We Americans have reached the time when we see that Lin- coln was the central figure on the Northern side during the Rebellion, and when, speaking roughly, we say that he represents the cause of the Union, just as we say, speaking roughly, that Washington embodies the cause of the colonies during the Revolutionary War; but every American knows that Lincoln was not a dictator, that he was under the restraint of Congress just as Congress was hemmed in by public opinion, and that he could not possibly have made peace, or taken any other vital step, without the approval of both Congress and public opinion. And had he aimed at dic- tatorial power for himself, had his ambition been like that of a Cromwell or a Napoleon, he would have sought in vain for subservient accomplices. Dionysius, on the contrary, found a willing multitude ready to confer upon him autocratic privileges. To only one other of Freeman’s general cri- ticisms have we space to allude. He exagge- rates the rashness of the Athenians in sending tho first expedition against Syracuse. Judging their decision by its disastrous results, it is easy enough to brand it as foolhardy. Free- man goes farther. He can scarcely conceive how a people in its right senses could be lured into such an expedition. He quotes with ap- proval the words of Joseph Butler: “Why might not whole communities and public bo- dies be seized with fits of insanity as well as individuals? Nothing but this principle, that they are liable to insanity equally at least with private persons, can account for the major part of the transactions which we read in history” (p. 108). Freeman cites England’s reckless plunge into the Crimean War, and the French expedition to Egypt in 1798, as modern exam- ples of national mental aberration. It is of course possible that a person or a nation that adopts a policy which you would not adopt may be insane; certainly, it is flattering to your own sanity to hold this opinion; but, on the whole, it is wiser to endeavor to understand the motives which caused the adoption of that policy than to indulge in self-laudation, for two persons may be thoroughly rational though they cannot be stirred by the same motives. And in the case of the Athenians in B.C. 416 we shall discover reasons which, at the time, might have persuaded any people, the most rational, without rousing against it the suspicion of lunacy. The decision was not taken hastily; for months before the matter came to a popular vote, it had been agitated, and, having been once decided, it was brought up for reconsideration, an unusual proceeding, by the cautious Nicias. Grote has stated all this so clearly, and has given so cogently the various reasons which justified the Athenians in embracing this project, that we need only refer the reader to him. And now we must apply the last test to Freeman’s history—the test of style; for on this, in the end, the permanence of all histories depends, It isnot enough that an historian be erudite and painstaking, not enough that his facts be precise, in order that his work shall endure. Later discoveries may reveal new data, and the circle of erudition constantly widens. His work, therefore, must have form, symmetry, vividness, life, and charm; and to produce these he must have the poet’s imagi- nation. In these days, we take it for granted that the historian has the scholar’s equipment, but we have been taught to look suspiciously on any manifestation of the imagination; yet without its agency nothing enduring can be produced, because it is the organ which sifts the essential from the non-essential, which penetrates deepest, which discerns the farthest- reaching relations and laws, and which synthe- sizes and creates. Freeman possesses the syn- thetic faculty to a great degree, as he proves by stating tiat the chief purpose of his history is to show how Sicily has been the pivot on which the everlasting struggle between the Semitic and Aryan races has turned, and the battlefield of many nations. He has succeeded in these first volumes in keeping distinct the character of the diverse settlements in Sicily— not confounding Sicel with Elymian, nor Sican with Phoenician—and in tracing wherever pos- sible the influence of the parent cities cf Hel- las upon their colonies. This is quite as neces- sary in the history of Sicily as in a history of the American colonies; for Segesta and Seli- nus, to take only one example, had no more in common than had Virginia and Louisiana under the reign of George II. But while Free- man viderstands what is essential in the great currents of history, he does not succeed in Selecting what is essential to his narrative. He is not a good story-teller, because, as we have said, he too often interrupts his story by digressions or overloads it with details. His attitude is that of a disputant; he has himself debated so long over many of the points he treats of that he cannot state his conclusion without showing that he would like nothing better than to fight anybody who differs from him. A really great historian should bridle the disputatious tendency; he should state his opinions as emphatically as ke chooses, but not ee meres ahah NR Es i Te

Page 25

he area NEAT A BRR ah ct AY

Sept. 1, 1892]

fill his pages with answers to possible critics. It is time to defend himself after he has been attacked. Such is the method of Gibbon in his famous chapter on the early Christians, He gives the results, but not all the processes by which he reaches those results; and he knows that in the end no amount of arguing ean save him unless his conclusions are correct. So we think that Freeman’s chapter on the Sicilian Expedition is inferior as a narrative to the account given both by Curtius and by Grote. He bas not the consecutiveness of the former nor the symmetry and sweep of the latter; and they all fall short, of course, of ‘Yhucydides in those great passages in which the Greek historian has described the night at- tack on Epipola, or the naval battle in the harbor, or the tragic retreat and overwhelm- ing of the Athenians. resting portions of Freeman’s work are those in which he has not to compete with cither portions of his Some of the most inte- Thucydides or Grote- ninth chapter, in which he relates the second Car- thaginian invasion of Sicily and the destruc- tion of the great cities. Yet even here we find no specimen of historical narrative worthy to be placed beside Hume’s account of the last days of Mary Stuart, or Gibbon’s description of the capture of Constantinople, or Macau- lay’s picture of the siege of Londonderry, or Carlyle’s living story of the Feast of Pikes. These specimens, by men very different in methods and genius, all illustrate what great and permanent historical writing should be, and wherein it differs from the writing of his- torical disquisitions; and when we compare Freeman with these men, we are forced to the conclusion that he is not their peer. His work is an encyclopedia of historical facts, a store- house in which he has garnered all that is known and most that has been conjectured con- cerning his subject; but it has not the artis- tic symmetry and selection, nor the vividness, nor the narrative swing, of a great history. Scholars will prize these volumes, and long be grateful to their author for the patient fidelity he bestowed upon them; we doubt whether they will take rank as literature. In taking leave of this colossal fragment we eannot refrain from expressing regret that Freeman’s instinct for thoroughness led him to alter his original purpose, which was to write the history of Sicily during the period of the Norman invasion and the rule of the Hohen- staufens. For this task no other man of our time was so well-fitted as he. But in order t be thorough, he decided to begin at the begin- ning, and the consequence is that bis three volumes comprise more than 2,000 pages and bring us down only to the year 405 R.c. At that rate, he would have required a dozen more volumes to reach the Guiscards and Hauteville, and two or three volumes beyond those to reach Frederick If. In view of the fact that the history of ancient Sicily is com- paratively well known, while that of media- val Sicily is scarcely known at all by English readers, Freeman would have rendered a far greater service by presenting the latter than he has done by revainping the former. ) THE LATEST YEAR BOOKS. Year Books of the Reian of K 1 Kdward the Third. Year XV. Edited and trans lated by Luke Owen Pik Rolls Ser

Printed for Her Majesty s Ntationery OF & Spottisweod ISO] by Evr IN the last addition to the Year } s, the votume containing tl Easter, Trinity, and Michaelmas Terms of 1341 (15 Edw. 3), while the editor remarks in his |

The Nation. introduction upon several matters interesting to scholars, he mentions little of special legal importance. It is probable, however, that legal specialists will reap their own harvest even here. To them everything is grist; to know for certain that a given period contributes nothing to their purpose isa boon. The editor courteously acknowledges and puts into prac tice a these that the number of the cases should appear at suggestion made in columns, the head of each page; it is certainly a help to the reader. Better and more scholarly editing than Mr. Pike’s it would be hard to tind in any department of be proud that worthily treated. learning. their Lawyers may matters are now so In case 55 (Michaelmas) there isa dise W. ‘Thorpe acertain argument. “ Perbaps so,” ission over the statute De Donis. resses says Schar shulle, J., “for Hillary and | pleaded such a plea before Scrope inthe Eyre of Northany ton, because we had no other matter; and the plea was pending the whole Eyre, and then was adjourned to this Court and was pending before Herle [C.J., 1327-1337]; and he said that the strongest argument against us which he Hengham [J. and C.J., 1272 1309], who drew the statute, construed it in another way.” is found in Fitzherbert. The circumstance that Hengham drew the statute De Donis is interesting; it was mentioned by Hengham bimself in one of the Year Books of Edward I. At p. 84 the reporter notes that “where, by an obligation, one was bound in forty marks, the plaintiff was barred by an acquittance which purported that he received ten marks in full satisfaction of forty marks.” In a full record preserved by Mr. Pike, at p. 484, one knew was that This adds to what may note the persistence of legal phraseology A certain Richard recites that so and s: t scriptum suum perdonavit, relaxavit et omni quietumclamavit ipsi Ricardo or

tiones, querelas, et demandas, quas habuit, vel aliquo modo bhabere potuit, per viam com poti, debiti, aut alicujus alterius contractus, ab origine mundi usque diem confections preedicti seripti.” It is no longer the fashi to put such things in Latin, but is probably still good form in Wall Street At page 446 the reporter says: erwis tois ‘Note that John Leukenore and Elizabeth, his wife, did homage to William Thorpe this way: Both held their hands joined between the hands of W. Thorpe, and the hus! i I spoke in this form: ‘We do you homage and bear faith to you, for the lands whict of A., your cognisor, who bas grant our services in B and C., and th . &c., against all people he faith whict we owe to the King ! other lords.’ And both

en they did fealty; and bett ands on the book, and the hushe rds, and both kissed the book.” this is also rt, to w ‘

cases, as Well as those in the Book of Mr. Pike always has the gment of the writ,” l rr by his count be makes the donor t be his creat great-cran ifather jfresaer), ana by the writ he makes him to be cousin, where he ought to be called aha s says

| as in the writ and not consanquinews. Kelsbulle (Just When one passes above the great-grandfathe besae!l|, there is no other form but to call the ancestors cousins; for King John, the great creat-crandfather [fresae of the present King, is in Latin called cousin.” () rve tl evity of the Fren july t for linked names of ther te ance tors referred t Nor I f oY ooks i } t un i ay notices that the translation of it, in a page of 171 the French thirty-six lines, recularly overruns tive lines

rhe chief part of the elitor’s learned intr duction is devoted to an investigation of the word M het: “in England the payment of v het was . an unfailing indication of tenure in ville I ng of this term Bas been s ssxtl in con jou wit ertal a t Aims of rus as regards their f ule serfs. Mr. Pike regards t! juestion t yet ripe for an answe t ! 1 rthat Me t S th equiva is i, a c " fa persen of i rosex bev i ° $ his lori’s bul i riy story {Vv ize i writt a | Mr. “ t st te t i part siory tft » p™ A Lie ist i v 1 of | i thn ver in’ \ > be fw paste: Lishes ot eat i noevery fsi iv te ast y s > > a tiv or tite I is : Line v es iv wel t be a tw ? i v dishes « mea for the eV i I i r, « su 9 and nh ev a r ina « t ia I fish. v \ av t t SIX WAX Candles f the pensioner’s apartment here Were aiso t ca wed a basket of oats ¥, and tw loads hay vearly, for his two horses. He was to have vearly six loads straw for his apartment and twelve loads - 7 i i i lie Was also to i\ every Veal ne robe f suit of the I r’s « s for A 1d one robe of suit the Prior’s grooms for his greom, as We s twenty shillings for shoes and other essaries The Prior, it is true, denied the Ning’s right to exact these demands; but that act does not in v wavy affect the statement is to the requirements of an esquire and the ustration which it affords of the mode of life

ce fitting for an esquire comparing the An action of oeans of sustenance fitting for t! poor,

Cessarit was brought against the Abbot of } of certain services, among supporting five poor persons ) e. He had to tind for each i; of them one loaf of tl weight of tifty solidi | every day, with porridge and ale and a dish of

neat other food, according to the iny » of them, and half a dish to | the : of them was to have also a | cloth tunic suitable to h condition every ithe r veer ii tut / h Williams, B.D., Trinity College, Ox slited by | brother-in-law, the Prevost, late of Gloucester Longmans, Green & Co. Archdeacon | DEAN CHrourcH wrote, in his ‘Oxford Move { " nent * [sane Willams, if any man, repre ented im the movement the moderate and un itrusive way of religious teaching.” Yet no lracitarians was thrust into an

Page 26

172 The Nation. [Vol. 55, No. 1418 uglier prominence than was he by his Tract 80, “Reserve in Communicating Religious Knowledge.” As the controversy went on, this was interpreted as a plea for teaching Roman Catholic doctrines in the English Church, and Williams was punished by the loss of the Poetry Professorship in 1842. His ‘Autobiography’ is brief, but it is one of the most valuable contributions we have had to the history of the Tractarian Movement. Either his youth was without any promise of the seriousness of his maturity, or he delights to think so after the manner of the saints. The only passion which he names was for writ- ing Latin verses—an injury, he confesses, to his English style. His meeting with the Kebles gave his life a turn to serious things. The influence of Thomas Keble on him seems to have been greater than John’s. Under the latter’s roof he made the acquaintance of Hur- rell Froude, the Hotspur of the new depart- ure. In ‘what he writes of Froude there is the same disparity one always feels between the personal impression that he made and the arro- gance and silliness displayed in his ‘Remains.’ In 1822 Keble was writing the poems of the ‘Christian Year,’ which was published in 1827. Neither Froude nor Williams cared for them. Froude opposed their publication, saying, “People will take Keble for a Methodist "—a potent sign how low religious feeling must have sunk in Anglican circles. The most remarkable thing about Wiliiams’s book is the absence from it of all discussion or exposition of the Movement as an intellectual or spiritual thing. He has an algebraic term, “Church principles,” to which he continually recurs. What those principles were he never offers to explain. As in every account of the Tractarians, we are impatient till New- man comes upon the scene; and, once arrived, he has no brother near his throne. Before Williams knew Newman he was advised to seek him out as an evangelical person and also warned against him as a liberal. Written in 1851 and revised in 1859, this little book effect- ually disposes in advance of Francis Newman’s recent assault upon his brother as for many years a clandestine Romanist. It affords new evidence that Newman’s dislike and dread of Rome were very great, while his clinging to the Anglican Church was very strong. All painful things attracted his ascetic disposi- tion, and he might never have gone to Rome had his distaste for her been less. Williams’s strangest judgment of him is that he united the “German rationalism ” of Whately with the Churechism of Keb!e. Whately’s rationalism was soundly English and not German; Pu- sey’s beginnings had a German leaning that terrified many ; Newman seems to have had no acquaintance with the German Janguage or with German thought at first hand. ‘The state of religion in Oxford, or of ecclesiastical ob- servance, before the Tractarians made a differ- ence, was never better indicated than by Wil- liams’s statement that he was “often nearly the only one in church listening to the usual hack preacher, who was reading some old ser- mon, not necessarily in connection with the Saint’s day, earning his five guineas, in a manner unedifying and unprofitable to all but himself.” One of the preachers was flattered by his attendance, but objected to the trouble of hunting up sermons for the day. Williams’s admiration and affection for : Newman were very great, and the affection outlasted the ecclesiastical break between them, each writing to the other tenderly and each visiting the other; Newman’s last visit to Williams being a few days before the lat- ter’s death in 1865. But the admiration seems to have been always qualified by some dis- trust. Newman’s ascetic objections to the marriage of his friends troubled Williams, as did his suppression of bis own domestic affec- tions, and his tendency to daring speculations —a restlessness that nothing could abate. By far the most interesting part of Williams’s book is that discussing the relation of the Tractarians to Newman and the Church of Rome. He makes out fourteen writers of the Tracts. It has been often said that it was the reaction from Evangelicalism that made Trac- tarians. But Newman was the only one who had been reared in Evangelical circles; what is more remarkable is that he was the only Tractarian who went to Rome. This is Wil- liams’s most interesting fact. It means that those who met Newman on any sort of equality had a saving distrust of him. None of them were carried away by the fascination which he exerted on them. The converts to Rome who preceded Newman thither and who fol- lowed him were younger men like Oakeley, Manning, Ward, and Faber. Ward’s opposi- tion to Newman was at first very strong; his conversion to his opinions was very sudden, and his advocacy of them unsatisfied with any- thing short of perfect logical consistency. What will please Anglicans most in this book is Newman’s writing in 1863, that the English Church “upholds far more truth in England than any other form of religion would, and than the Catholic Roman Church could.” Some of the minor aspects of the book have an amusing turn. There are various incidents of the strange custom of preaching borrowed sermons: in America a fatal circumstance, in England taken-for granted. Newman was re- sponsible for the name of Williams’s Tract 80, on reserve in religious teaching; and the name was the worst part of it. Williams says, “I think perhaps Newman himself made use of it to further his own secret inclinations towards the Church of Rome.” Newman loses several of his divine attributes in the course of the narration, showing himself as one not without human weakness, vanity, ambition, touchi- ness, and pride. How the using of a little prayer-book held close to the eves came to be a Tractarian sign that was spoken against was in this way: Thomas Keble used a little prayer-book at the daily service in order not to wear out the large parish book too fast. John Keble and Newman fell into the same custom for the same reason. All the young neophytes had to copy Newman in this respect as in others, racing through the service, for ex- ample, and writing of “Saint Charles,” whom Cromwell beheaded, and “George the Good,” presumably the third of that name and not “the first gentleman of Europe.” Altogether there is more of disillusion in this little book than in any of its predecessors written with sympatby for the ‘'ractarian Movement. An Illustrated Dictionary to Xenovhon’s Ana- basis, with groups of words etymologically related. By John Williams White ani Mor- ris H. Morgan. Boston: Ginn & Co. 1892. Ir is refreshing to encounter a Greek school- book that is not translated or adapted from the German, and we are glad to learn that this ‘ Dictionary to Xenophon’s Anabasis’ ‘‘ has been made from the ‘ Anabasis’ itself, on the basis of an independent collection and exami- nation of all the places where each word oc- curs.’? Another point which the editors empha- size is their ‘‘ cesire,’’ in selecting English equi- valents for the Greek, ‘‘ to avoid that strange dialect which seems to have been devised by the Adversary for the express use of schools, and which has done much to make Greek (and Latin also) a dead language.’’ This strange dialect is, of course due, not to the Adversary, but to the traditional use of obsolete words which have held their own in the schools after they had disappeared from the practical vo- cabulary of every day; and while no sensible person will object to making the English fresh and lively and to a certain extent modern— while no one will raise a finger to save ‘*‘ be- hoove ’’—still, it is possible to go too far. If one man uses ‘‘salaam” for ‘‘ make obeisance,” the next man will use ‘‘ kow-tow,’’ and justify it, too—in fact, justify it more readily than Messrs. White and Morgan can justify their rendering of dearérns by ‘‘Czar.’’? As to that bugbear, the irregular verb, there is no use in quarrelling with the practice of making the vocabulary a key. But the trouble is to know when the help is to be with- held. If, unassisted by the grace of a dic- tionary, the beginner does not know that édaBov is to be referred to AauBavw, by what in- spiration is he to know that Aaéeiy is to be re- ferred to AavOdvw? If avéorny is put in, why is avéxpayov left out? By the way, the lexicogra- phers might have taken a hint from Auten- rieth, and have printed in different characters the forms that do and those that do not occur. A Thelan might be allowel to say pédwow: But who ever said BAdccw except a dictionary- maker or some late snapper-up of curiosities? This God-forsaken Theban for whom the editors apo'ogize says (vii., 1, 383), gor’ av uédwow; but éove, to a dainty Attic, is almost as bad as podwow, and yet our lexicographers, who have something to say about avrios, éfamivns, and ovv, have nothing to say about éore for éws, éwei for érecdy, as for Sore and for brws; and the student is allowed to consider au¢i as good as mepi, and ava &S common as xara. Perhaps, however, it is as well not to prejudice the youthful mind against Xenophon, who is in great disfavor with the purists just now, and we will not quarrel with Messrs. White and Morgan for not imitating Holden, who follows Sauppe’s system of noting the various kinds of wild honey that the Attic bee has stored in a hive which should have been consecrated to the nectar of Hymettus. Our lexicographers apo- logize for paying so much attention to ‘‘con- struction’’ in the several articles, but some- times the attention has not been close enough: mpiv is badly stated, and &« with accusative ‘through ’ is actually false. From the time of ‘he Messieurs de Port Roy- al and the ‘Jardin des Racines Grecques,’ teachers have been hoping marvels from the aid of etymology in enabling the students to master Greek, and some of the oldest genera- tion of Greek scholars may dimly remember acertain volume of ‘ Greek Primitives’ to be learned by heart. The results never come up to the expectation, and it would seem that Messrs. White and Morgan are too sanguine as to the practical service to be rendered by their groups of etymologies, among which there must be some individuals that will rouse the angry passions of. those who consider an ety- mology a sacred thing. At all events, in a school-book like this, the semasiology ought to be clear, and the phonetics ought not to re- quire an alembic. ‘‘ Borrow’’ ought not to be put down under amédpagis, nor ‘‘ hog’? under és, even if Skeat approves. And yet, after making all possible deductions, such as any one can make from any possible dictionary, it is but justice to say that the book is well cal-

Page 27

Deal tiie’ l Sept. 1, 1892] culated to give lifeand interest to the study of the ‘ Anabasis,’ and that the long articles on the antiquities, with their many illustrations, will jighten for learner and teacher alike their employment with a classic which shares the doom of Ceesar’s ‘Commentaries.’ The Robin Hood of Vermont. Hall, D. Appleton & Co. 1892. Pp. 207. Tus book cannot lack readers. The time is ripe for another work on Ethan Allen. Former biographies, as by Sparks and Hugh Moore, are three-score years old, and based on less accu- rate information than is now accessible. Al- len’s own narrative, published in 1779, always obscured by his imperfect education, more and more needs illustrating and supplementing. It ran through a dozen editions within three decades, and will never grow old while men have regard for the courage of a hero or the fortitude of a martyr. As long ago as 1866, a copy of the editio princeps was eagerly bought for $56. Allen has a larger hold on popular interest because of a sort of resem- blance to Abraham Lincoln on the humorous or (as some would say) the Jim Crow side. Both, too, used sportive sallies for a serious purpose. The racy remarks of both will live for ages in the mouths and memories of men. This Life of Allenis enriched to some extent from archives of which former biographers made no use, as, the Journal and expense- account of Capt. Mott and the letter of Wed- derburn, which we owe to the London research of Bb, F. Stevens. Hence, and in other ways, certain side-lights are thrown on the four car- dinal features of Allen’s career. These were his taking of Ticonderoga; his captivity; his struggle for independence of New York; and his diplomatic dallying with Canada. Recog- nition of his noble service at each of these crises moved Green Mountaineers to set up one statue over his grave, another in the Vermont State-house, and another in the Rotunda at Washington. The last-named is of really national celebrity because few American chil- dren grow up without learning his summons, in the name of Jehovah, to the head of the gar- rison at “Ty.” Mr. Hall’s style is terse, usu- ally clear, and he gives a more vivid picture of scenes in Allen’s career by grouping around them contemporary events. Familiar facts, under his pen, assume an unexpected freshness, and a reader becomes reluctant to lay down the volume till he reaches the last chapter. After all, it is greatly to be regretted that By Henry Mr. Hall died while in the midst of his labor | of love, for his work needed much more ela- boration and must be pronounced both super- ficial and ineccurate. Capt. Mott is shown to have been the Moltke of the expedition against Ticonderoga, but his name appears as Nott in four different places, and that in such a con- text as to suggest another man. ‘This mis- print or blunder could never have escaped Mr. Hall’s eye. In fact, however, this Nott must mislead many readers almost as much as | the omission of not in printing the seventh commandment did. In the Journal of Mott there is a misprint of “for” instead of “from,” The Nation. 1%3 have done, bow nearly that difficulty proved | that the Ostracoda are derived from the tri insurmountable, and how adroitly it was over come, though not till the last minutes of the eleventh bour. .But for the capture of Ticonderoga, it is not likely that the British would have been driven out of Boston. This Mr. Hall would have de- monstrated by further research. ‘The Colonial Records of Connecticut would have shown small arms and lead, sent from there to Wash- ington, “at his earnest request,” to have been among the spoils which Allen had taken. Mr. Hall would have set before his readers the army which blockaded Boston destitute of siege guns till tifty-nine pieces were secured from the same spoils. He would have quoted Washington's words to Knox, who was sent to Ticonderoga for these cannon: “‘The want is so great that no trouble or expense must be spared to obtain them witn the utmost de spatch.” He would have added that, in a week after they were in position, boston be- came untenable and that £300,000 were taken by an outlay of £520 Ls 8$3;d. In many other ways, had Mr. Hall sur vived, we should have been taught to appre ciate Allen’s exploits much better than is now in our power, have caught Bancroft and even John Fiske napping. But, in point of fact, the deticien cies in his own work cannot be numbered, spolis Vv alued at ’ In various details he would | bites, while the Cirripedia and Copepoda were Among minor ones we note a stumble on | the threshold. Allen’s birth-place is nowhere mentioned. This omission is the more note worthy because it is a point on which authori ties differ. was born in Roxbury; Dr. Dwight says Salts bury; Allen’s Biographical Dictionary Woodbury; and allfourare wrong. Kilbourne has found the record of Allen's birth as at Litchtield, on the town-records there. Errors as to Allen’s age were corrected by Mr. Hall. Washington, who met Allen but once, rm marked in him “ an original something which commands admiration.” We ail share that feeling, which deepens at every page we read of his own writings, and we honor Mr. Hall's endeavor to heighten and diifuse that feeling. The Apodide: A Morphological Study. By Henry Meyners Bernard, [Nature Series Macmillan & Co. 18v2, trated. Svo, pp. $16, illus- Hinman and Ailibone say Allen SAYS | THROUGHOUT this volume, determination to | establish particular opinions is so prominent that readers can hardly avoid questioning every statement. Evidence of what may be prejudice and partiality is met with every- where, and we Jay the work aside with the feeling that it must be done again before we | shall know what estimate to place on the author’s persona! equation, how to value his interpretations of facts, or whether his con- clusions are worthy of adoption. At the out- } } set it is stated that the purpose « f the book is | not likely to be suspected, but which renders | a whole paragraph totally obscure. “From our people” is supplanted by “for our people,” p. 64. Mr. Hall has a spirited page on Allen’s “alarum” which rallied his men, but not a word as to the boats, “the be-all and the end- all,” which, in Allen’s words, “ were procured with the utmost difficulty.” Had he put his last hand to the work, Mr. Hall would have made it manifest, as Goodhue and Chittenden 3) to prove the Apodidw a transition form, a connecting link, between the other Crustacea and the Annelida. The statement was hardly necessary, for the purpose is sufficiently mani- fest. The book contains a very interesting presentation of the author's views; it would be more satisfactory if it were more convinc- ing. It is decided that Apus is a modified an- nelid, and, therefore, a primitive crustacean ; that Limulus and Apus have developed from the same “bent crustacean-annelid”; that the Trilobite had the same origin, and are no- thing but specialized carnivorous annelids; that Limulus, Eurypterus, and Pterygotus are specialized forms of the early trilobites; and frem a larval, and the Phyllopoda and Maia costraca from an adult, form of Apedida. A deal of manipulation is required to bring the “bent annelids,” the Trilobite, the Euryp teridw, the Xiphosuridw and the Apodidaw and other recent Crustacea into such close relation ships, but Mr. bernard has accomplished it, to his own satisfaction at least BOOKS OF THE WEEK Alar 3 FS I ld of the Ra Cass Jo Cents Arnol Matthew N Ma AL $1.75 me Jane Lady Sus Bos Roterts Bre Bazan, Emilia P The Swan of Vilamorta. Cas« nh Beljami \ t Arle Podine ‘ l se ira t s ‘ Be ijbie, A Kunoch A texte a ais, av hotes ra ali aies « i . tarts Hachette Be ard, J. H Ka K n i Ma la Su Bigelow, | ¥ a s a t . Danute cL. W x ents Blunisehli, J. K the T ’ f e otate ed Oxformtl: Char Press; New York: Mac millan. $3 trewster, HP anc vy. GH England amd ts Rulers ( ‘ Ss. 4 Gries £& CN $1.50 Buxton, Mrs. Sy y Ss I $ Ul Hible Hus tory Mac ‘ > Clarke, Clara &S | Pox A a hiah Casse $i Dareumberg, G H 4 ses Causes, Movers de s'en Prose ba TH 4 Davis Mrs wa i = ~ anil s $i Es s by Sa { ws New York: A. l eA 4 Fi ay, Rev. G e Ppis e Fy as [hxposuter's | \ sir x oi Garia tis a SS mi Bos re Pubtis rat : ents Witter Rober i i> +.ains R ai fis La Gn I £ os New York: Ma a $. He eH l ira Sat hes I Ww Soot New \ k: A & Co » »nts Howking ~ ah A | a War Lock, Bow & Jagemann, | H.C. Gv } . Ge aL Sy utaAy L vy Hot &€ O ™) Ja s, UW. I Ha k University Ex s N H ‘ a: University Ext » c ¥ Johns ~A s Na aS yt KS.) Macmullan $1.75 K aru, Mrs and Wedded to Sport Na Low. KO Lear, W A ( ’ » te e lila English Re a 2 ‘ $t.e Leland, Cc. G Lea r Work I Whit iaker New Y Max Libat $1 Lewis, Mes. Harrie Beatrix Rohan Robert Bonner’s Sos $1 Macquok Katherine S Berris National Book 4 Marryat, Florence The Nobler Sex Hovendon Co $i Maytlower Tales. John A. Taylor & Co. 30 cents McVay, Miss S.C. A Modern Quixote: A Story of Southern Lit Chicag Morrii, Higyrins & Co, Merrill, E. A Electric Lighting: Specifications for the Use o Engineers and Architects. W JOHRSLOD Co Si.ov Michel, Excile Les Van de Velde lLes Artistes Céidbres Par lL Art; New York: Macmillan Miille Lucian. G ind Roman Versification. Jost Allyn & Bacon 7o cents Needeil, Mrs. J. H. The Story of Philip Methuen, oO 2o cents Oliphant, Mrs Ihnana the History of a Great Mistake. U.S. Book Co. $1.25. Payn, James. A Modern Dick Whittington. John A. Tayior & Co 50 cents. Reinach, Salomon Antiquités du Bosphore Cim mé Paris: Firmin- Didot & Cie oes Riadeil, Mrs. J. H. A Mad Tour. U.S gook Co, $1.25 Rolleston, T. W Selections from Plato. London: W. Scott: New York: A. Lovell & Co 50 cents. Salter, W. M. First Steps in Philosophy. Chicago: Charies H. Kerr & Co Sanborn, E. W. People at Pisgah. Appletons. Schoenhof, J. The Economy of High Wages. Put- nanis $!.50 Shields, T. E. Kuight Co Strecker, Karl. Der Sang der Ménchgut. sumi: HKremer’s Verlags- Buchhasdlung. Swank, J. M History of the Manufacture of Iron Index Omnium. Boston: Joseph Stral- in all Ages, etc. Newed. Philadelphia: Ameri- can Lron and Steel Association. $7.50. Tenger, Mariam. The Hungarian Girl. Robert Bonner’s Sons. $ The American Yacht List for 1892. ning. $10. Thomas Man-

Page 28

174 The Nation. [Vol. 55, No. 1418 The Monist. Vol.2. Chicago: lishing Oo. The Professor, and Other Poems. Paul, Trench, Trtibner & Co. The Story-Teller. No.1. Boston: W. B. Clarke & Co. i, Theuriet, André. A Young Man of the Period. Chicago: Laird & Lee. 50 cents. Open Court Pub- | Thomson, J. i The Study of Animal Life. Scrib- ners. 1.50. Underhill, John. ‘*The Athenian Oracle’’: a Se- lection. London: W. Scott; New York: A. Lovell & Co. 50 cents. Warden. Florence. Rall h Ryder of Brent. Na- tional Book Co. gap Cassell. 50 cents. London: Kegan War under Water. Whitney, H. M. ‘The Tourist’s Guide through the Hawaiian Islands. Honolulu: Hawatian Gazette Co. Williams, T. C. Principles of the Law of Real ~ ¢ erty. 17th ed. London: pm & Maxw Boston: Boston Book Co. Wilson, J.G. Memorial Histo: 7 of the mad of New York. Vol. Il. New York History Co. HENRY HOLT & COMPANY’S EDUGATIONAL ANNOUNGEMENTS Include—The long-expected Physics by Prof. Geo. F. Barker of the University of Pennsylvania (about Oct. 1), which will present Physics as distinctively the science of energy, and will have the benefit of all the numerous recent advances in physical science, anda large and almost en- It will consist of about 800 8vo pages and be included in the American Science Series—Advanced Course. tirely new set of illustrations. ‘* Representative English Literature,’’ Selec- tions with Historical Connections by Henry 8S. Pancoast of Philadelphia, the University Exten sion lecturer. (Large 12mo, about 500 pp., about Nov. 1.) A second volume of the late Bern- hard Ten Brink’s Early English Literature (12mo, about 800 pp., about Oct. 1), Short Histories of German and French Literature, entitled German Literature in its Chief Epochs, by Prof. Kuno Franke of Harvard (in English), and Histoire de la Littérature Francais, by Prof. Aleée Fortier of the Tulane University of Louisiana (in French). Materials for German Prose Composition, by Prof. Von Jagemann of Harvard (about Oct. 1). A Minimum French Gram- mar, designed as a help to quick reading and containing many selections, by Prof. E. 8. Contes de Daudet, edited by Prof. A. G. Cameron of Yale (about 250 12mo pp.), and other French and German Joynes of the South Carolina College (12mo, under 200 pp., about Dec. 1). texts with competent editors. A History of Modern Philosophy from Nicholas of Cusa to the present time, by Prof. Richard Falkenberg of Erlangen, translated under the author’s super- vision by Prof. A. C. Armstrong of Wesleyan, Ct. (8vo, about 550 pp., about Feb. 1,98). In Dr. Sneath’s Series of Modern Philosophers, 12mo, Hume, by Prof. Aikens of Trinity (8. C.)—and Hegel, by Prof. Royce of Harvard. Greek Lessons, by Prof. Thos. D. Goodell of Yale (16mo, about 870 pp., about Sept. 15), being an enlargement of his Greek in English that brings the pupil to reading Xenophon, and a companion Latin book, The Latin in English, by Prof. Harry Pratt Judson of the University of Chicago (16mo). READY THIS WEEK: Crozier’s Dictionary of Botanical Terms. By A. A. Cro- zIER, M.S., SECRETARY OF THE AMERICAN PomoLoa@icaL Socrety. 8vo, 202 pages. This work attempts to define in alphabetical order all terms, both technical and popular, that are applied to plants, and to indicate those obsolete or obsolescent, and of several synonyms the one mos approved, HENRY HOLT & COMPANY, 29 West 23d Street, N. Y. Crosby’s Vitalized Phosphites. The only Brain and Nerve Food from the phosphoid princi- ple of the ox érazm and embryo of wheat. Largely used, with best results, for preventing, as well as curing, nervous break- It isa down. It restores weakened mental and physical vigor. vital phosphzte, not a laboratory phosphate. For thirty years endorsed by leading physicians. Formula on the label. F. Cr OS by Co., 56 W. 25rx St., N. Y. Pamphlet with full information free. Druggists or by mail. $1.00. Government Baking Powder Tests. - NITED STATES and Canadian Government food investiga- tions show the Royal Baking Powder a cream of tartar pow der superior to all others in leavening strength. Statements by other manufacturers to the contrary have been de- clared by the official authorities falsifications of the official reports. should be APPLETONS’ ,, to vac LIBRARY of every book- buyer in the land. Graded Lists for School LISTS Libraries, and Topical Liste for teachers’, students’, and readers’ reference. SEND FOR THEM. D. APPLETON & CO., Publishers, JOHNS HOPKINS UNIVERSITY BALTIMORE. New York. Announcements for the next academic year are now ready and will be sent on application. HOMEOPATHIC eines? tree cate: logue. Oldest Pharmacy. Established in 1835. BOERICKE & TAFEL, 1011 Arch Street, Ph'ladelphia, P 1409 Chestnut St eet, Philadelphia, Pa. 14% Grand Street, New York. 7 West 4zd Street, New York. 36 East Maaison Sireet, Chicago. 627 Smithfield Street, Pittsburgh. 170 West 4th Street, Cincinnati. 228 North Howard Street, Baltimore. BIRDS! BIRDS! BIRDS! Every educator who teaches Natural History should subscribe for THE AUK, the only magazine in this country devoted exclusively to the scientific and popular life history of aves. L. C. FOSTER, Publisher, 35 Pine Street, New York City.

Page 29

The Nation. OLMSTEDS COLLEGE PHILOSOPHY. FOURTH REVISION. BY SHELDON. An Introduction to Natural Philosophy. Designed as a Text-Book in Physics for the Use of Students in College OLMSTED, LL.D., revised by E. S. SNELL, LL.D., and R. G. Kiwpauy, Ph.D. By Dentson Fourth Revised Fdition, by SAMUEL SHELDON, Ph.D. (Wirzburg), Professor of Physics and Electrical Engineering, Polytechnic Institute of Brooklyn. Svo, pp. xtit, 466 Price, for introduction, $2.50; by mail, $2.75. Copies for examination mailed to Professors upon receipt of Two Dollara I I It is now nine years since Olmsted's Natural Philosophy was last revised. In this time many changes have been made in the teehni- cal nomenclature of Physics, many improvements in the methods of presentation of complicated portions of the science have been pub- lished by experienced educators, and, above all, the whole subject of Electricity and Magnetism bas outgrown its former apparel For the present revision the whole book has been careful y gone over, the requisite changes made, and several chapters entirely rewritten Many new engravings from drawings made expressly for this edition have been inserted. The —— of those who have used this in Physics partment of a liberal education. From Prof. W. H. Hartshorn, Bates College. Lewiston, Me., May 31, 1892. I have been using Sheldon’s Revision during the past year, and am much pleased with it. From Prof. L. A. Johnson, Trinity University. Tehuacana, Tex., July 3, 1892. The Physics has been adopted as the text-book in the college course. It suits us better than anything else we have seen, From Prof. Geo. G. Hitchcock, Washington Ag’! College. Pullman, W., July 21, 1892. I am greatly pleased with it and glad that it maintains its high standard of excellence. I shall introduce it soon. From Prof. B. P. Gaillard, No. Ga. Ag’! College. Dahlonega, Ga., June 17, 1892. I adopted it and used it as a text-book in my Junior Class. Iam very much pleased with it. It suits my purpose better than any other book on that subject I am acquainted with. From Prof. M. J. Elrod, Illinois Wesleyan University. Bloomington, Ill., Jan. 13, 1892. I thank you for it, and think I shall be able to p!an my work so as to use it next year. From Prof. W. S. Ryiand, Bethel College. Russellville, Ky., May 28, 1892. I am using it as a text-book for my Senior Class. All things considered it is the best for my use I know of. From Prof. L. C. Haynes, Greenville and Tuseulum College. Tusculum, Tenn., June 10, 1892, We used Sheldon's Olmsted with our class last year, and with great satis- faction to both teacher and class. The work of revision has teen well done Electricity and Magnetism, the part rewritten by ,Prof. Sheldon, deserves special mention. From Prof. J. 8. Dawson, Georgetown College. West Washington, D. C., May 28, 1892 I bave examined the new edition and have proposed to the President and Directors of the College to use it. From Prof. J. H. Montgomery, Allegheny College. Meactville, Pa., April 11, 1892 I have received the copy which you sent me, and think I will introduce it next year into my classes. From Prof. J. T. Lovewell, Washburn College. Topeka, Kans., Feb, 20, 1892. Iam 80 well pleased with it that I shall probably introduce it into my next From Prof. J. P. Looney, Portland University. Portland, Ore., Feb. 13, 1892 I have examined it thoroughly. I feel safe in saying it is the best work on the subject I nave seen. I shall use it in the University. From Prof. W. W. Hamilton, Bethel College. McKenzie, Tenn., Jan. 16, 1892. I like it so that I expect to put it in our own course. From Prof. C. E. Barr, Albion College. Albion, Mich., Jan. 13, 1892 The book is now, to my mind, the most desirable in its general method of treatment of any before the public. From Prof. W. W. Hooper, U. S. Grant University. Chattanooga, Tenn., Jan. 9, 1892 The copy of Sheldon’s Revision was duly receivea and examined. I form- ed a class in it last fall and am well pleased with the work, From Prof, J. C. Adair, Tarkio College. Tarkio, Mo., Dee. 29, 1891. I think it an admirable work. If we can arrange so as to have an intro- ductory course I will use it in my higher class work From Prof. Peter Engel, St. John’s University. Collezevilie, Minn., Nov. 27, 1891 I have always considered Olmsted's Philosophy an exvelleut text-book for students sufficiently advanced in mathematics, and think this edition in seve- ral respects superior to the former ones. From Prof. Isaac S. Hopkins, Ga. School of Technology Atianta, Ga., Nov. 25, 1891 I think enough of Olmsted's Philosophy to use it with my classes. For clearness of statement, method of treatment, discretion of setection in the mass of material I know nothing equal to it as a college text-book. From Prof. A. W. Kelley, Battle Creek College Kattle Creek, Mich., Nov. 16, 1891 I have received the copy and am well pleased with it. We will orter the New Edition before we take up the work again. From Prof, Charles Fairman, Shurtleff College. Upper Alton, IIL, Oct. 30, 1891 I find the alterations very greatly increase the value of the work for edu- cational purposes. I shall probably use Sheldon’s Revision as a text-book next year. | From Prof. G. H. Colton, Hiram College evision since its publication in the autumn of 1891 is proof of its value as a text-book apted to the requirements of a college course. As now presented it is believed to contain all that is necessary for this de- From Prof. J. A. Bauman, Muhlenberg College Allentow Ta xt SO. ISD I at once introduced it and am using it now. Fo ¥ purposes the old edition was the best book I knew of, and as the Revision has brought it up te date its merits are very greatly increased From Prof. D. M. Martin. Hillsdale College. Hillsdale. Voc! wt. QD, INP Iam using Sheldon's Revision and like it mux Lknow no work that would take its place From Prof. B. s. Winchester, Whitman College Walla Walla, Was i’ 32, INV We are using Dr. Sheldon's Revision and are much pleased with From Prof. F. Sanford, Leland Stanford, Jr. University Mer Park, Ca it, CO. Sv! Iregard it as a very great improvement on the former editions The parts which have been rewritten by Dr. Sheldon are especially good l have recommended the book to my classes. From Prof. F. W. Martin, Fort Worth University Fort Worth, Tex . OQet. 30, 1801 lam pleased with Sheldon's Olmsted and expect { se it From Prof, J, T. Coleman, S. C. Military Academy Charleston, SC, Oct. 31, 1801 Olmsted's Collewe Pailos phy, edited by Sheld s in my opinion, a rep resentative college text. book It ts enough for the studens. te learn, and, when supplemeaoted by active practice in the Laboratory, will be an hieal course From Prof. W. J. Brown, U.S. Grant University Athens oO M, ISR] We have decided to use it in our college classes From Prof. J. B. For, Newberry Coll Newberry. S. C., Get. U7, ISO] I have been pleased with an examit ri he book, I will probabiy tr troduce it next year. From Prof. J. E. Lehman, Lebanon Valley College Annville, Pa., Oct. 3, 1801 I have a class in the subject and we are all enjoying the work From Prof. J. A. Moore, Southers University. Greensboro, Ala. Oct. 16,1881 am much pleased with it I will use ft after this vear with my classes in mechanics From Prof. W. FE. Henderson, Colleze of Emporia Emporia, Kans, Sept, 19, 1801 Iam very much pleased with it. I think wery strongly of introducing it in my classes here next year From Prof. S. W. Stratton, University of Ilinois Champtign, Tl.. Aug, 31, 1891 mirth Reviaior to our University luce the F I have decided to ir From Prof. M. L. Lipscomb, University of the State of Missouri Columbia, Mo., Nov. 23, 1891 I have been using Sheldon's Revision in my Freshman Class for tweive weeks, and am delighted with it j ! ook I have been in need of for a long time 1 heartly commend it as a work of high grade on general physics. It is just the | Re Hiram Ohio, Nov. 7, 1891 find that the Revision has been careful and thor The result is a most excellent college text-book, The clearness and conciseness of the origi nal work have not been sacrificed, while the matter added and the rewritten paragraphs have placed the work fully abreast of the times, From Prof. A. A. Bennett, lowa College, Ames, Iowa, Nov. 14, 1891. The Revision is a great improvement over the preceding edition, and brings it up to the present condition of the science. In my opinion it is the best college text-book, taking into account its limits, that is published. From Prof. G. W. Shaw, State Agricultural College, Corvallis, Oregon, Nov. 16, 1891. After a critical examination of the book I am satisfied of its superior ex cellence For the grade of work for which it is designed Ido not know of its i tor the class-room Frof. R. O. Graham, Lllinois Wesleyan University. Bloornington, Il., Oct. 26, 1891. Iam much pleased with the changes made. This work I always use in my college classes. and I decidedly prefer it to any other for advanced pupils. sein i n to date by the present revision, I believe it has no superior ng texts on poaysics, From From Pref. L. O. Cochran, Upper lowa University. Fayette, Iowa, Nov. 2, 1891, Iam quite well pleased with the new revision. Ina general presentation of the topics without too much elaboration, it is the best work in my Judgment that I have seen From Pro!. A. G. B. Wilson, Lenox College Hopkinton, Iowa, Oct. 31, 1891. Dr. Sheldon's Revision has added to the old edition all that was necessary to make it the most suitable book that I can find for class use. PUBLISHED BY CHARLES COLLINS, AND FOR SALE BY THE BAKER & TAYLOR € Z#¢ SIUM ALL VAS 0., 740 Broadway, New York. op OULD BE ADDRESSED.

Page 30

x The Nation. LONGMANS, GREEN & CO.’S SELECTED LIST. HISTORY, Epochs of American History. Edited by Albert Bushnell Hart, A.B., Ph.D., Assistan} Professor 0: History in Harvard College. Each volume with colored maps, bibliographies, mar- ginal notes and index. 12mo, cloth. I. The Colonies, 1492-1750. By Reu- ben Gold Thwaites, author of ‘*‘ Historic Waterways,’’ etc. 320 pages, $1.25. II. Formation of the Union, 1750- 1829. By Albert Bushnell Hart, A.B., Ph.D., the editor of the series. {In October. Ill. Division and Reunion, 1829- 1889. By Woodrow Wilson, Ph.D., LL.D., Professor of Jurisprudence in Princeton College, author of ‘* Congressional Govern- ment,’’ ** The State—Elements of Historical and Practical Politics,’’ ete. {In December, Epoch Maps Illustrating American His- TORY. By Albert Bushnell Hart, Ph.D. 14 colored naps, oblong quarto, limp cloth, net, 50 cents, Gardiner’s Student’s History of Eng- LAND. With 378 illustrations. Complete in one volume, with complete index, crown, S8vo, cloth, plain, $2.00. Or separately: Vol. I. Be. 55-a.p, 1509. With 173 il- lustrations and index, $1.20. Vol. If. 1509-1689. and index, $1.20. With 96 illustrations Vol. III. 1689-1885. With 109 illustrations and index, $1.20. Gardiner’s Atlas of English History. $1.59. A companion to the‘ Student's History o/ England.’ Airy’s Text-Book of English History FROM THE EARLIEST TIMES. With 16 maps anda fullindex. 12mo, 560 pages, $1.50. Lavisse’s General View of the Political HISTORY OF EUROPE. Translated, with the author's sanction, by Charles Gross, Ph, D., In- structorin History, Harvard University. With index, $1.25. Oman’s History of Greece from the EARLIEST TIMES TO THE DEATH OF ALEXANDER THE GREAT. Second and en- larged edition. With 12 maps ani plans, side notes and fullindex. 12 0, $1.50. Robinson’s First History of Rome. With illustrations and maps. itmo, 366 pages, 80 cents, GEOGRAPHY, Longmans’ New Atlas—Political and Physical. Half bound, $3.00. Longmans’ New School Atlas. With entirely new American maps, $1.50. Longmans’ School Geography. Second edition, revised. Large 12mo, 384 pages, with 70 illustrations, $1.25. Questions Based on Longmans’ Sehool Geography. Large 12mo, 40 cents. *,* A General Prospectus, covering the ‘‘ School Geography,’’ ** School Atlas,’’ and ‘* Questions,"’ which relate to one another and which are intended to form a basis for geography study in schools where more than elementary work is done, may be had of tie Publishers. ENGLISH, Longmans’ School Grammar. By David Salinon, With notes for teachers and index. New edition, revised. With Pre.ace by E. A. Allen, Professor of English in the University of Missouri. 12mo, 272 pages, 75 cents. ** Deserves to supersede all others with which we are acquainted.’’—Nation, N. Y. Longmans’ Junior School Grammar. By David Salmon. 12mo, 124 pages, 30 cents. The ‘ Junior Sthool Grammar’ is an adaptation of the first half of the author's ‘ School Grammar,’ with some of the explanations simplified, with many of the exercises amplified, and witha few of the difficulties omitted. Longmans’ Primary Grammar. By David Salmon. 12mo, 128 pages, 35 cents. Longmans’ School Composition. By David Salmon. Crown 8vo, 310 pages, 80 cents. Longmans’ Handbook of English LITERATURE. Complete edition in one volume, $1.35. - Five Parts, each part sold separately, 30 cents each, Part I.—From Tue Earuiest TIMES TO Cuavucer. Part Il.—From CHAUCER TO SHAKE- SPEARE. Part II[.—From Ben Jonson To LOCKE. Part IV.—From Swirr to Cowper. Part V.— From BurRKE TO THE PRESENT TIME. Lang’s Blue Poetry Book. For Schools. With lives of the authors of poems. 16mo, 60 cents. The Plays of Shakespeare. Falcon Edi- tion. With Introduction, Notes, and Glossary to Fach Play. Fep. 8vo. Each Play, 35 cents. *,* Messrs. Longmans’ Classified List of School and College Text-Books will be sent free to any appli cant. Contents: Algebra—Astronomy—Biology, Botany, etc.—Chemistry, Mineralogy, etc.—English Lan- guage and Literature—French—Geography, Physiography, etc.—Geometry, Trigonometry, etc.—Ger- man—Greek—History—Industrial Traininz, Drawing, etc. —Latin—-Mathematics—Mechanics, Engineer- ing, etc.—Mental ani Moral Philosophy-—-Object Lessons—Physics, Electricity, and Magnetism—Physio- logy, Hygiene, etc.—Supplementary Reading-Books—Text-Books of Science. LONGMANS, GREEN & CO., 15 East 16th St., New York. [Vol. 55, No. 1418 Successful Educational Works PUBLISHED BY A.C. Armstrong &Son, 51 EAST i0TH ST., NEW YORK. New Edition—from New Plates, TExT REVISED By A. L. MAYHEW, WADHAM COLLEGE, OXFORD. - , . . ‘ SUPLEE'S TRENCH on WORDS From the latest Eugiish Edition. With ano ex- haustive Auaiysis, Additonal wo.ds fur iliustra- tiou, and QuestivasSfur examination, By rrof. 5u- pice. lvol. neu$l. Furecaumanatiun, T5c , postpard. These questions were prepa.ed not on ¥ te call forta the tac.is stateu by ihe author, but also to tol- low up L.nes of thuushi suggested by him. Lu euch jecture alist ut words bas been auded, illustrating its various topics, and intended lo encourage urigi- nalr. search on the part oi the pupsl. Ze new ar- rangement of ine .ex , analysis, and questions cannot fail to be o great assis.ance. INTRODUCTION to the STUDY of Philosuphy. By J. W. Stuckenberg, D.D., Member of .he Ph losophical So i. ty o1 Berlin, Crown 5vo0, cioth, $2. (2 or examination, $1.39.) © Tits work mustcommand the respect ot ali schools of thought, Itisnet a phiwsopry nor a psychology, nor a book to detend a parvicwar sy.tem of metaprystes. 4108 simply what i purports to bé,an tulroduction to the sub- jec. In this respecc tt suppl es for teachers and students attke a much-fet want. The prociems aua relations of philosophy are clear yanalyzed and set out before the stu- dent, so that he mau gau some famidarity with ts ques- tions, withoui having to plod throuyh too many ortyinal sysiems or their hastory.”—N. 1. Nation, Unabridged Student's Hallam. FOR USE IN COLLEGES AND SCHOOLS, THE MIDDLE AGES. A View of the State of Eu- rope uuriog the Middie Ages. Revised and cor- rected editiun. Complete in 4 vols., cr. Svo, 2.00. CONSLITUTIONAL HISTORY OF ENGLAND, from the Accession of Heury VIILi. to the Death of George II. includiug Mr. Hallam’s sup;iemen- tal Volume of -evisioa up to .o#5.— ladispen- sable to students.)-Comp.etein 2 vol:., er. Svo, $2.50. INTRODUCIION TO THE LITERATURE OF EU- RUPE in the ldta, 6.h, a.d 17th Ceuturies, Re- vised and corre-ted edition. Compete i. % vols, $2.5.. MAY'S CONSTITUTIONAL HISTORY OF ENG- LAND, siuce the accession 0. George ILII., 176U0 to .871. By T. Ersxine May. 2 vois., cr. 3vo, price $2,vv. This is substantially a continuation of Hallam’s great work, tracing the progress and development cf the Bri- tish Constiiu on uuring ane tue century. Spectul p: wes offered for use as .ext-books, New and Cheaper Edit.on (Uniform with ‘ May’s History.’) DEMOCRACY IN EUROPE, A History. By Sir Thomas Erskine May, 2 vols., crown 3vo, cloth. /rice reduced tu $2.00. * Those of our readers who will recal. Mr. Erskine May’s Cunstitutional History of Englind since the Accession of George tae Third,’ need not be told that he has execute. this ‘His.vory of Democracy in Europe’ witu great skili, paiustaking accu:acy, and @: uuition, aud yet he is earnest and v gorous, and his book, once taken up, Will not be laid duwn . gain un il. he greater part of its contents is mastered.” —N. ¥. Evening « ost. STUDIES IN LITERATURE AND STYLE, By Prof. T. W. Hunt of Princeton College. 12mo, cioth, $1.25; jor exram.nation, To cents. t ostpard Itis the aim of these: studies to -tate and illus- trate the undamentual types of style, witn primary reference to the needs ot & giish literary student, The discus:ionis both pdilosoph ca: and practical, deveivuped in scholarly aud yet popular form. REPRESENTATIVE ENGLISH Prose and Prose Weiters. By T.W. Huat. 1l2mo, 54U pages; tull index. Net $1.20. Lramination copies sent postpaid jor 9O cts, Cpening witnacarefu. discussion of the leading historical periods of Engtish prose, it proceeus to the examinat.on of its various literary forms, and, as a tuird and final divisioao of the subject, presents acrit.cal study of representative Englisa authors as exponents of English | ro-esiyie. In subject-matter, asin method, it is thoughtfui and log cal, waile the English in which it is expressed is clear, vigorous, and tasteful, THE PRINCIPLES OF WRIT- ten Discourse. By 17. W. Hunt, Professor ot Rie- toric and English Language, Princeton College. 12mo, $l. sent, for examination, 75c., postpaid, This work gives a full and philosophic discussion of the subject with particular reterence 10 collegiate needs, A New Edition. with a Complete Analysis in Twenty Pages, of : THE STRUCTURE UF ENG- lish Prose. A Manual of Composition and Rheto- r.c. By Prof. J.G@ R. McElroy of the University of Pennsylvania. l2mo, $12U. (Exawisation copies 90 cis., postpaid.) “ Though theory is by no means lost sight of, the aim of the author ts emmently practical, t.us adapting his work for use im both Codege ans advanced cias es m high Schools and Academies.” ARMSTRONG & SON, NEW YORK. 2p iggp teen a as nina ke 3 RARE His DS IS a A FRA nena

Page 31

THE SEPTEMBER. BEG The Alarming Prof. J. J N number and ¢ The Lesson of Labor Trou May labor un The Nation

COLUMBIAN EDITION) (oF) THE UNITED ~~ STATES: A HISTORY. By JOHN CLARK RIDPATH, LL.D. AUTHOR OF ‘*History of the World.’ WITH OVER 800 PAGES anvd 300 ILLUSTRATIONS, Including Maps, Plans, Charts, toget _ with Por- traits of Presidents, Fl ags of all Nations, and Seals r ot “ene oft the States olors, covering vier 1492-1S91.

ULAR REE, , > . . ah ; One Volume, 8vo, Cloth, CC SPONDENCE SOLICI AGENT WANTED E YWHERE $ MM 5 LARG 3:75: CHARLES BROWN & CO., or THe Uniteo States History Co., __ Room 425. No. 53 State Street, BOSTON. FORUM. BRENTANO'S 1892. NEW TEXT-BOOKS. DURING VOL. XIV. The “Phonetic” Series Proportion of Venal Voters OF HAND-BOOKS TO THE STUDY OF LANGUAGES No. 1. Colloquial French for Tra- vellers and Students. ’ Handy sized lémo; tastefully boundi nis is the first volume of @ series tted? which has two aims—>ne to give a carefu! analysis, for students,of the seunas employe! in speaking IcCooKk.—A calculatio of their in analysis of causes. tlomestead: A Remedy for

bles. Hon. CHauncey F. Buack.—

ions not be ine rpo Methods and Morals of Campaign Commit- | v rious languares,as com ared wita English, wit tees: Publicity as a BERT WELSH. — public ity of ¢ * Plan for More Effective Management. | Ur Hon. M. D. Harter The Next Gre: Prof. R. H. T ‘A Tariff for Means. Davin A. WELLS it igh anal 8:8 of the Den Notable Religi The Enlarg —The increase of practical work; the decat doctrine. CARROLL, Special Churches. A Chinaman o: rpen litures an explanation of the differences in evsily under f stood terms; a {the ot Cure for Corruption. Her phrase-books fortraveller The secrecy of 1333, t of |No. 2. Colloquia! German for Travellers and Students. form with ‘Colloquia! French.’ 75 cents

ne eee? xhiy us No. 3. Colloquial- Travellers and Sendoats. Uniform at Problems of Mechanics. HURSTON, Revenue”: What it Really

with ‘ Colloquial French’ and ‘ Col iocratic position. ous Tendencies:

any language uf the we r d cat ed Church. Pror. Davin SwincG us Guides, Maps, Reference Books, Works on Histor

Science, aod Art in any language of the world We keep a ways on handa complete stock of t ratio > ; latest American text-books Religious Progress of the Negre. H. K Ce" Specta’ terms ees. prita Agent he Census ChOnis. and wmtversties, Lerectors +f suck msctiet = wt mma wf tterr adtan ave oe PEE MBT CF i) ° Estimates caretuiy made at iowest proces. ’ Paris Ora she Ww ry rf * 1 Our Treatment of China. , y under the jaw admettree is for YEN tnsti' tad YunG Kitna BRENTANO'S, i A Aduress: Provincial Pec mmerathe s of Western Life. 124 Fifth Avenue, New York; 1015 Pennsylvania ' author o The Stary of Ave., Washington. 204-206 Wabas Ave, Chi- E. W. Howe, au = = ora ago: 430 Strand, London; 17 Ave. de Opera try Town.’’—Society, P ics, and FR iON Paris in Western towns. , Studies in Immigration: Seandinavians in the Northwest PR iy KenDric C. Bascock of University of Mint € Pe . A oe sota. The Mine Laborers in Pennsylvania. Is u nexpecte e FREDERICK WARNE & CO’S Books for all Seasons. Not The Land of the Almi: ghty Dollar. By H Paxwre x W ‘ y lustrations by I M Terse at gra ’ . shrew *)

*Hea ul t sympa with satisfacti Hi ‘ we rhest sifa ‘ ers for 3 } Mr. G ‘ ein Ar ‘ emper } The Diary and L etters of Madame Evelyn's (John) Diary. Diary and , Esq,

The Diary of Samuel Pepys

Italian for ,

} } . v . 2} ’ t I } LN i .' S 4 w Many es THE CHANDOS CLASSICS tare i? se as i | Sup itary | i} lers. O } feratu ( Jasse | | in High s, Private Schools i Col | ieges is } Iss er, o7 lusa POrscabe ¢« i? t i list f ti s 7 | . P I | Popular Studies of the Nineteenth CENTCRY POETS By J. Marsnaut. MATHER In 12mo . $1.0 | Simple s Ww rth v, Coleridge, | Byron, |} . Te tending te create a wider interest In the poet and his w r Studies of the Nineteenth Century ill Mather pres * critical es nticing for 3, allied toa | i] stwle k a delight, | class of wort for whom it was originally written. but also toalllovers of good, forceful English."'—Curr nt Literature (July) Of all booksellers. or mailed free on veceipt of pric: by the Publisher : 3 Cooper Union, N. Y.

Page 32

The Nation. [Vol. 55, No. 1418 FHlorsford 's ACID PHOSPHATE, Recommended and prescribed by physicians of all schools FOR DYSPEPSIA, NERVOUSNESS EXHAUSTION, and all diseases arising from im- perfect digestion and derange- ments of the nervous system. It aids digestion, and is a brain and nerve food. Descriptive Pamphlet free. Rumford Chemical Works, Providence, R. I. Beware of Substitutes and Imitations. WE HAND YOU A FRESH SCALP) an one hair is gone, or {s falling out, or is thin and you have dandruff, or an itching or sore pg send $1.00 for a bottle of CAPILLIFORM. A well-known official of = Pennsylvania Railroad writes: “ For several years I had a distress'ng ecze- main scalp. Every time | scratched it the sores came off, always bringing more or less hair with them. I became bald in patches, and my hair no - strong. _* I tried all remedies in vain until C 1\P. LIFORM™M appeared. The very first coultoninen stopped all the itching, and in one week I was cured. My scalp is now perfectly pure and clean,and my h»ir has grown in in very nicely. I nowuse itregu- larly. and would not be without it.” AP M is an Infallible Hair Restorer ond Delightful Toilet Dress ng, Itis a — OLOMBIA Cl CHEMICAL Washington Ave., icohens, Pa, ABE PIANOFORTES, UNEQUALLED IN TONE, TOUCH, WORKMANSHIP, AND DURABILITY. J) 8) Baltim New York, 22 and 24 E. Salmore St. 1485th ave near 20th St. Washington, 8317 Market Space. THE GREAT Diabetes has bent cured by BUFFALO LITHIA WATER without other treatment.—Advt, Remington w SLIT Typewriter The policy of constant, careful, and progressive Improve- ment which has ever marked the history of the Remington will be unceasingly pursued in the future. Patents for Improvements are constantly issuing. It is now protected by 59 Patents, most of which run from 12 to 17 years. It is to-day not only Unsurpassed but Unapproached for Excellence of Design and Construction, Quality of Work, Sim- plicity, and Durability. SEND FOR DESCRIPTIVE PAMPHLET. Wyckoff, Seamans & Benedict, 327 aii New York Unlike the Dutch Process No Alkalies Other “Chemicals are used in the preparation of ” W. BAKER & C0.’S BreakfastCocoa which is absolutely pure and soluble. | Ithas morethan three times the strength of Cocoa mixed | m with Starch, Arrowroot or ~ Sugar, and is far more eco- nomical, costing less than one cent a cup. It is delicious, nourishing, and EASILY DIGESTED. rahe eit Sold by G-ocers everywhere. W. BAKER & CO., Dorchester, Mass, SOLID TRAINS BETWEEN New York & Chicago, Via Chautauqua Lake or Ni- agara Falls. An enchanting Panorama of mountains, f.- rests, an’ streams. Pullman Cars Between New York and Ro- chester, Buffalo, Niagara Falls, Toronto, Chautauqua Lake, Cleveland, Cincinnati, and Chicago. D. I. Roberts, Gen’! Pass.Agt. Nationa! Security Loan and Abstract Co. of Macon, Ga. CAPITAL.. -- $100,000 N. Y. correspondent and reference, Merchants’ Ex- change Nat’! Bank. Refers a'so to American Nat’l anae, First Nat’] Bank; Exchange Bank, Macon, Ga. Six per cent. first mo es (payable in gold) on choice city real estate, princi and inte- rest guaranteed. Seven and eight per cent. first mortgages ( ~ in ako oice city real es- ae = a a, eneral investments made. J.I3.C B. WEST, F.0O. SCHOFIELD, fs “levy and Att’y. Treas. O1L—LIME-—ELECTRIC LANTERNS, @ fy NE Mi ACG j STEREOPTICONS AND VIEWS. Large Catalogue Free. 2. B. Colt & Co. 16 Bookman St. New York o/ NET First Gold Mortgages. Paya- pie in gold. City and farm loans. Best of se- a Fy Frighest safe interest, Ad MA INVESTMENT Co., Tacoma, Wash, UROPEAN SUMMER AND WIN ter Resort, University town of Innsbruck, Tirol, Austria; 1,900 feet above the -ea, with ory bracing climate’ Hote’. Lge onan all the year. O:r' Landsee, Proprietor. rt nny ro ‘ms, well furnished. ovater. Superior culsine (tab ed’héteor a la carte). Re uced rates in winter. Carriages and sleighs at low rates. Charming excursions made fro'n the hotel at all seasons. Unusual advantages for securing teachers of the languages, history, science. art, mu- sic, etc., at very moder te terms. Eminent medical care and skilled nurses if desired. Best English and American references. Illustrated pamphlets sent on application. JUST PUBLISHED. Dr. William Bernhardt’s Hauptfakta aus der Geschichte der Deutschen Litteratur, With Notes, indenting Surther lines of Research, interleaved. Cloth, 75c CaRL SCHOENHOF, Publisher and Importer, Boston. EDITEUR ET LIBRAIRE FRANCAIS WILLIAM R. JENKINS 851-853 © AVENUE, NEW YORK Poh 4 de 48e rue. Ca talogue envoy franco sur dem lemanda. Back Numbers of “The Nation.” In response to frequent inquiries from subscribers: An incomplete set of THE NATION has little or no mar- ket value. Partial sets, bound and unbound, are al- ways obtainable ( usually ageking the carljest vol- umes), and do not command high rates. The bindin —-_ count for nothing, owing to great diversity styles. Volume I. has readily brought $10 and up- wae when complete, bound or unbound, but 1 bring very little in proportion if a single number is missing. Volumes II. and III. are also scarce, but not so ce priced as the first. ‘omplete sets, both bound and unbound, have sold m. $100, with tolerably quick bidders, and have an in- creasing value year by year. Single numbers not more than a year old can usually be supplied by the publishers at 10 cents each. For — more a2 a year old papeeeoss are > ferred to Mr. J. W. Christopher, 47 Dey St., Mr. 8. Clark, 34 Park Row, H. Williams, 195 West Tenth Street, New York; or A. H. Roffe & Go., Bos Boston, Mass. The publishers no longer undertake to buy by 4 sell numbers or volumes more than a year old, and can coy recommend sellers or purchasers 4 hegotiate a dealer or to advertise in THE NaTi (Publication was begun July 1, 1865, Vol. "L com ing the last half year. Two volumes per year since been issued, Vol. LV. comprising the last halt. year o

Page 33

Sept. 1, 1892] | The Nation.

The Historical Reference Book. Comprising a Chronological Table of Univer- sal History, a Chronological Dictionary of Universal History, a Biographical Dictionary. With Geographical Notes. For the use of Students, Teachers, and Readers. By Louis Hermprin. Third Edition, revised and brought down to 1892, Crown 8vo. Half leather, $3.00. ** Quite the most compact, convenient, accurate, and authoritative work of the kind in the lancuage. It ts a happy combination of history, biogra- phy, and phy, and should find a place in every f. y library, as well as at the elbow of every scholar and writer. . . The typography remains ideally good for such a manual.’’—New York Evening Post. **A most useful reference work, compiled with the extreme accuracy characteristic of its author."’ —Christian Union. A Chronological Table of Universal History. Extending from the Karliest Times to the Year 1892. For the Use of Students, Teachers, and Readers. By Louis HEILPRIN. 12mo, 200 pages. Cloth, $1.25. This is one of the three sections comprised in ‘The Historical Reference-Book,’ bound separately for conve ience of those who may not require the entire volume. Its ar- rangement is chronolo:ical, each paragraph iving, in briefest practicable form, an out- ine of the principal events of the year desig- nated in the margin.

Gee Send for the current number of Appletons’ Monthly Bulletin, containing announcements of im- portant new and forthcoming books. D. APPLETON & CoO,, 1, 8, anD 5 Bond STREET, New YorK. By T. E. SHIELDS. A REFERENCE BOOK designed for the use of STUDENTS AND PROFESSIONAL MEN, ona plan intended to save time and facilitate ac- cess to knowledge acquired by reading and study. GS No title can completely convey to the reader an idea of the value of this book. By asimple and ingenious method of indexing, the results of wide reading and study can be recorded and made avail- able for future use. Todd's ‘Index Rerum’ and other books have attempted this, but the outlay of time and labor has been so great that few persons have ever persevered in their use. By an insiznifi- cant outlay of labor the student can secure any item of knowledge he may wish to preserve. If properly used it will prove to be a key that will un lock the secrets of every library. One vol., quarto, about 400 pages, made from the best ledzer paper and bound in substantial half leather binding and cloth sides, net, $4.50. Speci- men pages and descriptive sheet sent on applica- tion. Will be sent by mail or express, paid, to any address on receipt of the price. JOSEPH KNIGHT COMPANY, PUBLISHERS, 196 Summer St., Boston, HATCHARDS. This is the favorite BOOKSTORE, and for 100 years the resort of the smartest people in London. It is visited and patronized by all who love books. London is the great market for books, and all the best as well as the cheapest editions can be had by writing to us. Special collections formed, and fuller information sup- plied than from any other house. Books both old and new, and relating to any subject, can readily be supplied at very moderate prices. Agents for Clubs, Libraries, and all private Collectors. 187 PiccapILLy, Lonpon W.

Richter’s Chemistries AUTHORIZED TRANSLATIONS. By Ep@ar F. Smits, F.C.S., M.A., Pu.D., Professor of Chemistry in the University of Penn- sylvania; formerly in the Laboratories of Witten berg College. Springfield, Ohio, and Mublendery Col lege; Member of the Chemical Societies of Berlin and Paris; of the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia; American Philosophical Society; So ciety Chemical Indus., England, etc., etc Inorganic Chemistry. A Text- BOOK FOR STUDENTS. Third Ameri- ean, from the Fifth German edition. 89 wood-cuts and colored hthographic plate of Spectra. 12mo. 428 pages. Cloth, $2.00. Examination copies, $1.50, postpaid. The Chemistry of the Carbon COMPOUNDS; of, ORGANIC CHEMIS TRY. Second American, from the Sixth German edition. Illustrated. l2mo. 1,040 pages. Cloth, #.50. Examination copies, $2.75, postpaid. Experiments Arranged for STUDENTS IN GENERAL CHEMISTRY By Epa@ar F. Smite, Professor of Chemis- try, University of Pennsylvania, Philadel phia, and Harry F. Ke.ier, Professor of Chemistry, Michigan Mining School, Houghton, Mich. 12mo. Cloth, net, 8.60. Second edition, enlarged, with 37 Illustrations. Chemical Analysis, Qualitative AND QUANTITATIVE. By G. C. CaLp- WELL, B.S., Pb. D., Professor of Chemistry in Cornell University. Author of Agricul- tural Chemical Analysis, Manual of Chemi- cal Practice, ete. Second edition revised and enlarged. $1.50 net. Copies sent for examination, $1.20 post- paid. P. BLAKISTON, SON & CO., PUBLISHERS, Philotelph

tot2 Walnut St., 4 MONTHLY CATALOGUE OF GOV- ERNMENT PUBLICATIONS. Edited by J. H. Hickcox. The publication of this valuable record was sus- pended from want of support. Weare happy to an- nounce that arrangements have been made to con- tinue its issuance. For particulars and sample copy address the publishers, W. H. LOWDERMILK & CO., Dealers in Government Publications, WASHINGTON, D.C. Rare Engravings and Etchings. FREDERICK KEPPEL & CO., 20 EAST 16TH ST... NEW YORK. A large collection of fine Colored Prints by Barto- lozzi and his pupils has just been received from Eu- rope: also anumber of rare old Mezzotints and . ther E vings. Correspondence invited; pictures sent for inspection free of charge. N

. B.—Illustrated Catalogue No. 9, descriptive of | Modern Etchings, ready this morth; free by mail ou receipt of ten cents in stamps. S. B. LUYSTER, 79 NASSAU STREET, NEW YORK, and LonpDon, ENGLAND. Importer of Standard English Books, OLD AND NEW. Catalogues issued bi-monthly, and sent gra tis to any address, on application ~ -reHeC SPECIAL OFFERS on lesding newspapers and magazines. Exc*ptional opportunity for teachers to sub-crife with «dvan- tage. Orders prompt y forwarded Price list free NATIONAL SUBSCRIPTION BUREAU, 4 Park =t., Bosion AUTOGRAPH LETTERS. SEND FOR PRICE LISTS. WALTER R. BENJAMIN, 28 WEST 23D STREET, NEW YORK CITY.

BACK NUMBERS AND SETS OF ALL MAGAZINES.

For price state wants to MAGAZINE EXCHANGE, Schoharie, N. Y.

Xiili EADING, 'RITING AND 'RITHMETIC are primary and easential. Refinement, (al- tare and Polish come later from Travel, Asso- ciation with the Educated, and Acquaintance with the best (houchts of gifted minds in the STEDMAN-HUTCHINSON “ LIBRARY OF AMERICAN LITER TURE” you can travel through every S'ate in the Union, associate co stantly with educated meno and women, and acquaint yourseif with the best thoughts of twelve hundred talented suthors, In this age, when a short-hand method of reading ia ne essary. and when breadth of information and A critical) ‘emeot. which can only be secgred by com: aring the writings of a creat many »uthors oa Various subjec a, ate so essential, “The Library of American Litera ure” is to every citisem aot @ luUxUPY,: Ut &@ neces-ity, It compresses a whole book-tore into a few volumes, and yet does aot Miu'ilate ur alter a single sentence ia any selection xiven. Toe var ety, value andarrangement of the mate rial are such as to ceuse the<e volumes to be used peraeee more than any other volumes taat could 9 pluacedin a library. I: is a purely Amerf an wok. containing the finest productions of Amertean authors from bl) 07 to isow In its elev-n el-gant Volumes are 6.0 pages, nearly 3.000 selections— prose aad poetry or st el ad wood portralts Ths work is highly endorsed by such men as A. R. Spofford, Librerten of Oongress; John Fi- ke, Librarian of Harvard U twersity; Joba G. Whittier, toe Qu ker poet, Noeh Porter es Pre<itent of Yale Unteersity, Moses Colt Tyler Pres dent of Cornell Un versity, «ad all the leadin educators wit out ecception. The complete wert coversthe entire Meld of Am-rican literature tna manner sat sfactory to every Amerean home Every member: f your family wiil enjoy ‘The Libre ry of Americ no Literature SOLD ONLY BY SUBSCRIPTION will find it profitable and pleas+nt te solicit aub seriptiona, For fullde ertption address T. M. WILLIAMS, Manager, CHAS. L. WEBSTER & CO., 67 Fifth Avenue, New York Cly B. WESTERMANN & CO., Booksellers and Importers, S12 Broadway (Seaditered), New York. Teachers Extensive stock of French, and English Books, Creer man, Books for the s udy of FOREIGN LANGUAGES, ancient and modern. a specialty. Stock of foreign text-books used in the leading Colleges: TEURNER and TAUCHNITZ editions of Greek and Latin Clas gies BRAUNE'S Gothic Grammar SOCIN'S Arabic Grammar. STRACK'S Hebrew Grammar BRUGMANN S Comparative Grammar KIEPFRT'S Wall Mans. SPRUNER’S Historical Atlas, STIELER'’S Modern Atlas FLCUGEL'S ana THIEME-PREUSSER’S German and Engtish lic tionaries TAUCHNITZ Collection of British Au ENGELMANN-ANDERSON thors Pictorial) Atlas to Homer Free of- Duty Importation for Libraries on liberal! terms LONDON NEW YORK LEIPZIG GUSTAV E. STECHERT, Importer ot Books and Periodicals slid BROADWAY, NEW YORK Large Stock of Poreiga Books, new as wella rar snd scarce, and sets of Periodicals rtation trom Envland filled in thre and France ia four to five Orders forimy Weeks, from Germany weeks Per als at lowest rates, quick delivery BRANCHES London: 30 Wellington Street, Strand, W.« Leipzig: 10 Hospital Strasse

RARE BOOKS. Picking-up Searce Books a specialty.

AUTOGRAPHS.

Send orders for Books not in Bookstores. PORTRAITS. Send stamps for Separate Lists. bargains in Choice Books, Autographs, and Portraits. ' AMERICAN PRESS CO., Bautiworg, Mp. F. W. CHRISTERN, 254 Fifth Ave., between 28th and 2 ‘th Sta., New York, Importer of Foreign Books, Agent for the le: ding Paris Publishers, Tauchnoitz’s British Authors, Teub- ner’s Greek aod Latin Classics. Catalogues of stock mailed on demand. A large assortment always on

We effer hand, and new books received from Parisand Leipzig: as 8000 as issued.

Page 34

X1V Or ance contracts. COMPANY $ BUILOING 256 BROADWAY. Pratt Portraits. Sketchei in a New England Suburb. By Anna Fuuuier. Second edition. 16mo, $1.60. ** Abounding in humor of a quaint and refresh- ing quality, crisp and palatable from its untorced originality, there are also hidden springs of pathos which contribute to the beauty of the autbor’s work. ’’—Rochester Herald, **It is just the book for an hour's leisure, but, more than that, it isa book to read over and over n, either through and through or with here a dip and there another, and one well worthy of a favorite place in the home library.’’—N. Y. Stan- dard. ‘That exquisite spirit of New England humor and pathos which has baffled the pen of many a fluent writer has been happily seized and imprison- ed in these delightful sketches. They are some- thing rare, of an almost unknown quality, in the presentation of the quaint old women, the midile- aged men, and the blithe young girls which make up its character. . . The leaves of this pretty book are in no danger of being left uncut, nor the pages left unthumbed.’’— Boston Transcript. *,* Notes on New Books, Vol. II., No. UL, sent on application. G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS, NEW YORK AND LONDON. “GERMANIA.” A Fortnightly Magazine for the Study of the German Language and Litera. ture. Subscription Price, $2.00. Sample copies free. P. O. Box 151. MANCHESTER, N. H. The Mail and les phany New York: ‘*Germania is an excellent journal and admirably adapted for the pu of enabling different grades of learners to ect themselves in the German language and its iterature.’’ LEND A HAND MONTHLY. PHILANTHROPIS. $2 a year EDWARD E. HALE, Editor. Send 20c. for single copy. ‘A New School Reader. The Man Without a Country. Sent postpaid, Boards, 25 cts.; paper cover, 20 cts. $F STILMAN SMITH & CO., 3 HAMILTON PLACE, . . BOSTON, MASS. THE PUL HOME Life Insurance Company W. J. MADDEN, Gen. AGr. 40 BROADWAY. New York. The Nation. ICIES OF THE New York are broad and liberal, both as to terms and conditions, and contain all the ad- vantages and options of modern Insur- GEORGE H. RIPLEY, President. ’ Unmounted Photographs Of Ancient and Modern Works of Art, embracing reproduc- tions of famous original paint- ings, sculpture, architecture, etc. Price, cabinet size, $1.50 per dozen; larger sizes in pro- portion. Lantern slides to or- der. Send 15 cents for 1887 Catalogue and 1890 Supple- ment of 12,000 subjects. Photographs mounted on plave paper for the illustration of books on art and travel. Correspondence invited. SouLE PHOTOGRAPH CoO., PUBLISHERS, 338 Washington St., Boston, Mass. Please mention the Nation. FOREIGN PHOTOGRAPHS. (Direct Importation.) Cc. H. DUNTON & CO., 136 BOYLSTON STREET, BOSTON, announce a NEW UATALOGUE Of over 10,000 subjects, comprising Imported Views, Paiutiags,and Sculpture of the Old world, mounted and unmouuted. Braun’s Carbon Photographs. Mailed for 10 cents in stamps. MATTHEWARNOLDIN THE ‘‘NINE- TEENTH CENTURY.” “The New York NATION—a newspaper which I read regularly and with profit, a newspaper which is the best, so far as my experience goes, of all American newspapers, and one of the best news- papers anywhere.” THE NATION, an independent weekly journal, was established in 1865. Its contributors include the most prominent names in literature, science, and art, both in this country and abroad. It is emphatically found in the homes of people of culture and refinement. No intelligent Ame- rican, desirous of keeping abreast of the best political and literary thought of the day, can afford to be without it. Subscription price, $3.00 a year, post- paid. Address PUBLISHER OF THE NATION, 208 Broadway, New York City. [Vol. 55, No. 1418 The Critic of Arguments. By MR. CHAS. 8. PEIRCE. On September Ist The Open Court will begin the publication ofaser.es of article. by Mr. CHARLES 8. +: EIRCE, to be entitied ‘lhe Critic of Argu- ments.” (lhe word critic here me.ns an art, like joqgic.) This series willbe devoteu toa critical and his:orica! discussion. f ‘he methois of reasoning. Mr. Charles 3 Peirce spne of the most disti. gu sh- ed schularsand n atnematicians of which America boasts. but especi.lly in the dep: rtmeut of Moverno Logic has his w rk contributed, perhaps more than that of any « ther living invest.gator, to the perma- nert:dva cement of science. The results of his thought are, however, f& rtne most part lockei up inth proceedings and reports of learned societies, and owfo the rst time, ip 7#e Open Court, are they to be presentedin aless rigidard techn cal form, and made acces:ibl to.:li who pl ce a value on rightthinki g. Every phil: sophical stndent shouid avail himself of the opporiunity to study this mas- terly series of logical papers. The Open Court : A Weekly Journal of Philosophy and Science. Yearly, $2.00; single copies, 5 cents. , The -Free Trade Struggle in England. By GENERAL M. M. TRUMBULL. Second edition, re- vised and enlarged. Cloth, 75 cents; paper, 25 cents. “It would be well worth while forany oe who has been misled by the common errors about the influences which brought Great Britain (o reverse her poiicy in i842, tore dup the economic history o: that period. Aitlthe facts ure given by t: e radical Miss Martineau .n her History of Fitty Years’ Peace; by the Tory Sir Stafford Nort cote, in his Twenty Years’ Financial Policy, exp ainiug the chanzes which Peel brought about; by the economist Jonn Nobie’s tiseal Lexzis.ation in Great Brit ii; or in Carlyle’s Past and Present. the best summary is to be found in the li tle book pu li hed n Cuwicago in 1884, by Gen M M. Trumbul), entitled tue Ame- rican Les-on of the Free-Trade Struggle in tug- land. In this book wil be found the whole reco'd of ‘he condition of England frum 1838 101-46. This history ought to be re d by every man who desir.s to make vp his mii d how *o act in this coun ry at the pre-ent time. Tie logic of ev-nts is the same. We are repeating history.’"—Mr. EDWARD ATKINSON in Pop. Sci. Mo.(Aug., 1890), THE OPEN COURT PUBLISHING Co, 17314, LA SALLE ST., CHICAGO, ILLS. A Useful Book for Teachers, Containing much more valuable matter than its title indicates. THE Compounding of English Words: When and Why Joining or Separation is Preferable. By F. HoRACE TEALL. 12mo. 223 Pages. Price, $1.25. W. J. RouFE, the edge ee scholar, writes: “It is almost faultless as a discus ion of the subject.” THE SCHOOL JOURNAL of May 2l says: “There ults reached by him will be of great iaterest and value to teachers.’ It ts the ONLY book in whieh its subject is fully treated, and it is absolute!y confi: ed to selection of the bes/ forms from actual aaee , based upon analogy. Highly commended by the pressin all sections of the country. Circular with testimonials sent on ap- plicatio: to the publisher. For sale by al: Booksellers, or sent postpaid on receipt of price by the publisher. JOHN IRELAND, nasa illness To Every One Interested in Wild Flowers and Ferns. Send for special circulars as to the most beauti- ful and standard books on our American species. Catalogue of Works issued on Natural History Subjects on application. BRADLEE WHIDDEN, 18 ARCH ST., BOSTON. JUST READY. German Lessons. Harris, Oberlin College. This cook is intended to give such know'edge of forms as will adequately prepa ethe student to read ordinary German. It is expected to /ead up to the advanced grammir on theonehanda 4d tothe study ot prose compositio: onthe other. As soon as pos- sible the pup'lis brovght face to face with the lan- guage itself. 178 pages. Cloth, 60 cents. Liberal terms forintr ducti n. D. C. HEATH &CO., Publishers, Boston, New York, and Chicago. By CHARLES peace ee ee

Page 35

ntti 26 ty Ihde NB: Be IR ube it | i

1892 | The Nation. SOME BOOKS. Works of Honore de Balzac Translated by KATHARINE PRESCOTT WORMELEY i12mo volumes. Uniform in size and style. Half Russia. $1.50 each. Already Published: PERE GORIOT. DUCHESSE DE LANGEAIS. RISE AND FALL OF CESAR BIROTTEAT ECGENIE GRANDET. COUSIN PONS. THE COUNTRY DOCTOR. THE TWO BROTHERS. FAME AND SORROW. THE LILY OF THE VALLEY. THE ALKAHEST. Cloth, library style, $1.50; Paper, $1.00. THE MAGIC SKIN. Th’s book is endorsed -y Hon. Adlai E. Steven MODESTE MIGNON. son, Hon. Calvin S. Brice, and Hon. John G. Carlisle COUSIN BETTE. Unquestionably the paramount issue of the cam Tre 7 paign is the tari? LOUIS LAMBERT. the political parties is n NEW r = “ PARIFE THE PARAMOUNT JSSUE. SPEECHES AND ‘WRITINGS ON THE QUES TIONS INVOLVED IN THE PRESIDEN- TIAL CONTEST OF 1892. BOOKS. | By Wititam M. Sprincer, Chairman of the Commi tee on Ways apd Means of the House of Repre sentatives, Fifty-second Congress W th Por traits of the author and others ore clearly marked than any Charles L. Webster & Co.'s: REFORM: Upon this issue the line dividing | A PARTIAL LIS! feducational Publicatoi HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CC. | The Riverside Literature | Series. | Sixty-three numilers alr vy published, oo ta . aster ‘ fr t “ v4 LONGPFtE w, BRYAN tt uES IRVIN Wh ’ 1 >} liaw ‘ N ere { a sth ra With ‘ 2 traits Biot icaland ii Sk es ond Note Aclay ted f rusein Primary, Gras ar, and His Schools | Masterpieces of Ame I iter: (ture.

nplete Prose vt Poet s ne fr e W ‘ IRVIN t YAN t sNK » H LMES, Hawrn RN? w ' T REA O'R I LOWER EMPRsoSN, W t ? ONGEE ow wit ata Aut " j Ise ‘ ‘ rs *. u ; te esa Rea t 5 act a Tex N At i a $ ’ Arithmetic Two Books, RASED a. METHOD NeTHUCTI ON ‘Sanen' 4 t t sons t ents: HONOW 4 See essons oO, GU ee \ Vors Bex Ss pwaj BUREAUCRACY. other. No statesman in the United States has given SERAPHITA. | the subject more earnest thought than Mr Springer, | « ‘ANE xr _ | who has been actively engaged in the study of this | SONS OF THE SOIL. question since 1868. The volume is a masteriv pre URSULA. sentation of the facts and arguments likely to prove AN HISTORICAL MYSTERY. most effective iu the Presidential campaiurn PIERRETTE. ‘‘Thetime should now be ripe for the introdue- Tl h of M k tion of English-speaking people to an author whose 1e S| ii OC } O On ( ‘Vs marvellous knowledge of human nature, subtile By R. L. ¢ ioe a eee analytic power, encyclopaedic learning, and brilliant 7 tH. Ls. GARNER. _ vo, with frontispie descriptive talent justify the daring comparison of his productive force with that of Shakespeare. ’’— Mr. @arner’s article sublist the leadit New York Tribune. owes aruces, Puouss : George Meredith's Works. ip ject, hove been widely read | and fav oral ¥ con Anew complete Uniform Edition of this great mented upon by scientific men both here and abroad The field he enters is absolutely a new one, and he novelist’s writings is now ready, Titles. has received such encouragement from sctentith and literary sources that he has determined to pur sue his researches in the heart of the Tropics, the native home of the great apes. THE ORDEAL OF RICHARD FEVEREL. EVAN HARRINGTON. MARRY RICHMOND. SANDRA BELLONI, VITTORIA. ONE OF OUR CONQUERORS. | RHODA FLEMING, BEAUCHAMP’S CAREER. In Beaver Cove and E1se- THE EGOIST. where. DIANA OF THE CROSSWAYS. By Marr Crim. Illustrated by EL W. Kea cloth, $1.00,

Ixy . - ens ’ Adventures of a Fair Rebel A RoMANCE OF THE Civin Wak By Ma CRIM With a Frontispiece in paper, 50 cents

by Dan Bea Svo, $i THE SHAVING OF SHAGPAT, AND FARINA THE TRAGIC COMEDIANS. | Cloth. $2.00 per volume. Popular American Edition, 12 volumes, 12mo. 12 volumes. 16mo. $1.50 per volume, ‘Mr. George Meredith is the greatest English ae living; he is probably the greatest novelist | of our time. He is a man of genius, a literary artist, and truly a great writer.’’—The Beacon. ‘ 7 my T Jane Austen's Novels fe From new type, with a frontispiece by Garrett for Life ol t I Alle W ine ish U at ly le each novel. This edition will be in eleven volumes, By Mrs. ALEXANDER al published as follows: bound), Svo, $1 = SENSE AND SENSIBILITY. Moonblight and Six Feet of Romance. By Daw Bran Iustrated by the aut Cc

2 volumes. ferful w i PRIDE AND PREJUDICE. 2 volumes. xh sympathy MANSFIELD PARK. 2 volumes. ace as : EMMA. 2 volumes. = Contete ei aan NORTHANGER ABBEY. 1 volume. . v ‘ PERSUASION. 1 volume. — LADY SUSAN. With a Memoir and Letters of Jane Austen. 1 volume. } LIBRARY EDITION. | F lower eT of the Vi Ine: ruby morocco, gilt top. $1.25 per ) volume. mantic Ballads and Ss spiri 1 Roma. EDITION DE LUXE. A special edition on laid paper, medium Svo, rus- Set cloth, untrimmed, limited to 250 copies, wil! be | By Wrorzaw SHat Cc’ A Fe issued simultaneously’at $2.00 per volume, onsub- | Ss Wife’ : wit! Mi ss Howard), “Lit and scription to the complete set. | f Jos With t tJ seph Severn, ete **A girl who wrote for girls, a woman who wrote for women, has become praised of all men.'’—

y Ro- 16mo. Half Letters sduction

THomas A. JANVIER, and a por of the

Transcript. al Tastefully bound with appropriate } x ‘Sict lot! $1.50 Send for descriptive circular and subscriptio : , blank (free). Sent epaid are pt of price

Roberts Brothers, Pubs., CHARLES L. WEBSTER & CO., BOSTON. NEW YORK CITY. lowe and His | plication, Mode rn Classics A SCHOOL IRRARY\ for > sé es I ‘ «4 . Peier of Ameri ican Litera ture. Bes oo HARDSON. Rev American Prose ne. il efelhe SY Whitt " mesiggh pace e son Arranged by H. BE. 8 her 4 hss he ric an rooms, . Civil Gover nment A Hist ory of tm nit ed States, John Pisk ~ cabanas & Stoddard's ram Imar. ly A NEW EDITH N, Latin

revisel | Henry r 2 Rol Ife S St inde nt ’ Series OF STANDAR i SLISH POEMS FOR s HOOLS AND. CO! aueés C< ous expla SCOT - ALY " ahi th Price $0 tee rs rexa 4 ents eat The Odyssey of ait omer Trans yth Pr By Prof. G.H Paine « mi ote e itic n. $2.00 — ne of Ancient, Media- al, and Modern History. Fy Carl Ploet: Transiated from tte German. witha Lditic ns, by W.H. Tillinghast. With ful! Index. $3.00 | Literary Landmarks. A tuide to Good Read ing for Young People, and T chers’ Assistant With Charts and Original | D. signs, and a listof the best books which cove: } * necessities of School Libraries. Teachers | ks. and Chidren’s Reading. By Mary E Surt. Teachers’ price, 64 cents, | atalogues and circulars, containing descriptions of the above books and of many others, sent on ap- HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO., 4 Park Mreet, Boston, 11 East 17th Street, New York, 28 Lakeside Building, Chicago. ’

Page 36

Xvi The Nation. | Vol. 55, No. 1418 Teachers’ Books; and JIext-Books. LATELY PUBLISHED BY CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS. THE STUDY OF ANIMAL LIFE. ByT. Arrtacr Tuomsoy, University of Edinburgh. 12mo, illustrated, $1.50 nef, THE REALM OF NATURE, By Hue R. MILL, Edinburgh. With Maps and Illustrations. 12mo, $1.50 net. ** A real advance towards an appreciation of Nature.’’—Prof. Wau. M. Davis, Harvard. THE FINE ARTS. By G. Batpwin Brown, Edinburgh. 12mo, $1.00 net. ** As a text-book for the study of the ** Fine Arcs,’ there is nothing in the literature of the subject that answers the require- ments as this little book.’’—Prof. J. H. Niemeyer, Yale Art School. LOGIC, THE ELEMENTS OF; THEORETICAL AND PRACTICAL, By James H. Hystop, Ph.D., Columbia College, New York. With Diagrams and Examples. Crown 8vo, $2.00. ** All that is of value in Jevons and much more besides.’’—Prof. H. K. GARDINER. THE LITERATURE OF FRANCE. By H. G. Keeng, Oxford. 12mo, $1.00 net. ‘* As an introductory text for schools and colleges or private readers, I have seen nothing so good.’’—Prof, E. 8. Joynes. THE ELEMENTS OF ETHICS. By J. H. Mcirueap, Oxford. 12mo, $1.00 net. ‘* Very clear, simple, and forcible.’’—Rev. Prof. G. S. FULLERTON. AMERICAN HISTORY SERIES. THE COLONIAL ERA. By Prof. G. P. Fisher, D.D., LL.D., of Yale University. 12mo, $1.25. ‘*A marvel of literary success. §0 much in so small compass, yet attractive and readable.’ —Prof. James Monroe, Oberlin College. Future volumes by Prof. SLOANE of Princeton, Gen. F. A. WALKER, and Prof. J. W. BuraGEss. THE GREAT EDUCATORS. ARISTOTLE, AND THE ANCIENT EDUCATIONAL IDEALS. By Tuomas Davinsoy, M.A., LL.D. 12mo, $1.00 net. **T know nothing in English that covers the field so well.’’—Pres. G. STANLEY HAtu. ‘* Work admirable. Topic one of the most profitable in the entire history of culture ’’—Hon. W. T. Harris. LOYOLA, AND THE EDUCATIONAL SYSTEM OF THE JESUITS. By Rev. Toomas Hvauss, S.J, 12mo, $1.00 net. ‘**This work places before the English-speaking public, for the first time in an English dress, the educational system of the famous Society.’’—Conpe’ B. PaLuen, in Educational Review. Future volumes: ALCUIN, by Prof. WEst, ABELARD, by Compayré; FROEBEL, by Bow ey, etc. A NEW IMPORTATION OF GOUIN’S THE ART OF TEACHING AND STUDYING LANGUAGES, which is receiving such exten- sive notice by the Press and by the Profession. 12mo, 430 pages, $2.25, NEW CLASSIFIED DESCRIPTIVE EDUCATIONAL CATALOGUE. Many important Additions have been made to this valuable Text-Book Catalogue, specially in the Departments of Science, Art, Phi- losophy, History, and Religion, besides a much enlarged list of Importations. Privileges of Examination, Introductory Prices, Ragular Rates to Instructors, to Libraries, ani to the Trade furnished on application. Full Descriptive Catalogue of these and many other distinguished text-books in all departments of education sent free. Miscellaneous Cata- jogue of American and Foreign Publications. Current books promptly supplied. Special facilities for procuring such as are rare or scarce. CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS, Publishers, Importers, and Booksellers, 743-745 Broadway, New York City

Page 37