The Nation 1891-12-24: Vol 53 Iss 1382

Page 1

The Nation eee eee Co ———— VOL, LII—NO 1382. THURSDAY, DECEMBER 24, 1891. > an Ya, % ICE 10 CENTS a . wn —_—— THE POPULAR SCIENCE D. APPLETON ® CO’S MONTHLY FOR JANUARY. New and Recent Books. THE NEW DRILL REGULATIONS FOR INFANTRY. As approved by the Secretary of War, and issued to the N.Y. National Guan! This volume contains the complete Resrulations, plates, and illustrations Recent Advances in the Pottery Industry. (lIllus- | trated.) By Epwin A. Barer. An account of | the rapid progress in American ceramic art made since the Centennial Exhibition, with figures of vases, table-ware, art-tiles, architectural pieces in terra cotta. etc. Theology and Political Economy. By Dr. Axprew | D. Wuite. How theology has hindered the opera- | tions of commerce and industry. Remarkable Bowlders. (lllustrated.) By Davin A, WELLs, Descriptions of massive stones that attest the power of glacial action. Tail-like Formations in Men, (Illustrated) Re markable evidence from the researches of German physiologists as to the kinship between man and the brutes. Our Population and its Distribution. By Carrou D. Wricut. The third of Mr. Wright's instructive lessons from the census. OTHER ARTICLES ON AN EXPERIMENT IN EDUCATION; COMMUNICATION WITH THE PLANETS; THE Musk Ox (illustrated); THe Poruta- TION OF THE EARTH; THE AVIATOR FLYiING-MACHINE (illustrated); SKETCH OF EL1As Loomis (with portrait). 50 cents anumber. $5.00 a year. D. APPLETON & CO., New York. identical with the copy issued se » the Army fr Headquarters, and incl addition paragraphs from Arn regulation mad to in thet I lations. It is boun t in blue leat tl in and favorably known, but with the impro convenient clasp Price, leather, 75 cents; stiff! paper cover, 30 cents EORGE MaceDONALIYS NEW STORY) THE PLIGHT OF THE SHADOW. By George MacDosaup, author of * Malcolm,” ‘Annals of a Quiet Neigh! hood," ete No SS. Town and Country Library itm cloth, $1.00 SECOND EDITION THE STORY OF COLETTE. From the French of } La Neuvaine de Colette." A new, lance pap With 36 th istration Svo. Cloth, $1.50 One of the Secale mnest of the books of fiction for the holiday seasor ** The tela ts well told. and itis hig | boameat ully illustrated with photogravares after French desigas.”— PAi adelphia Bulle “One of the gems of the s*ason. . “The work of a literary artiet of the firs’ rank, an{finevery sense worthy the ban“some setting in which ft Bas Been placed by ts — “rs, mak ng it oae of the most (eautful of holisay books,” suston Traveiier APPLETONS’ HAND-BOOK OF WINTER wennpetetwdri-al | For Tourists and Invalids. Giving comp it nation as to winter sinitaria and places of resort in the Unit od St ates the West Indies, The Bermudas, The Sandwich Islands, and Mexico. New Edition, December, ISO], revised to date. With Maps, lustrations, Table b upper cover, oO cents MY panggrerenarer JOURNAL, sys. 2. f Railroad Fares, etx Lime, By Lapy Durresr Extracts from letters home, writ while rd Dufferin was Governor General of Canada. With Portrait, “Map . and “‘Wusts ations from Sketches by Lond Dufferin. I2mo. Cloth, $2.00 ' - - _ Tliustrated Juventle Books. Little Smoke. A Story of the Sioux, By Witiiam O. Sropparp. $1.50 | Straight On. A Story of a Boy's School Life in France. } By the author of ‘Colette.’ $1.50 Midshipman Paulding. A True Story of the War of 1812. By Moury Ex.rot Staweut, author of ‘ Little Jarvis." $1.00 We All. A Story of Boys’ Adventures in Arkansas. By Octave THanet. $1.50 Syd Belton. The Boy who would not go to Sea. By Grorner Manvitte Fenn. $1.50 The Crystal Hunters. A Tale of Adventure in the Alps. By Grorer Manvitte Fenn. $1.50. G2 Send for the holiday edition of Appletons’ Monthly Bulletin, containing de- scriptions of a large number of new and recent books suitable for holiday gifts, with specimen U'us rations, efc. Mailed free on request. D. APPLETON & CO., 1, 3, and 5 Bond Street, New York

Page 2

—-* —-* The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science, and Art FOUNDED 1865. Entered at the New York City Post office as second-class mail-matter. } CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER THE WEEK.,..... peboscccoeasccecartecsesbesseees 479 EpITORIAL ARTICLES : Judgeships and Other Offices. ...........00.00. 482 A Repubtican Business Man..............eeee0- 482 A PUribnGal NOVG .ccccccccsscccecccccccescoss 483 European Tariff Changes.............+6- ecccce 454 SPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE ; The Financial Condition of Italy..... TeTTTT TT 484 The Victorian exhibition. ........cceeeeeeeeeee 485 CORRESPONDENCE : The Historical American Exhibition at Madrid. 487 Mathematical tudy on the ¢ ‘ontinent evcsecesce 487 Weak Forms of Been, and Pope’s Ximes........ 487 oi... 2. . 4, eer. 4x8 * A Genealogists NMS oo cc cusses 488 More Spoiling of the * Bbritannica’......... scsee £58 BSED, 500500 seos se eebnes skhsanscwessasbtencon bar 483 REVIEWS: New England Colonial Furniture.............. Gustave Doré Dobson’s Hogarth.. Miller on the Constitution The Hours of Raphael in Outline. : BOOKS OF THE WEEE oc cccccccccccces eee eeweeeeee TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION, Three Doilars per year in advance, postpaid fo any part of the United States or Canad; to foreign coun- tries comprised in the Postal Union, Four Dollars. The date when the subscription expires i. onthe Ad. dressLabel of each paper, the change of which toa subsequent date becomes a receipt for remittance. No other reccipt is sent unless requested The paper is stopped at expiration of the subscrip- tion, unless previously renewed. Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter or by check, express order, or pos‘al ord r, payable to ** Publisher of the Nation.” When a change of address is desired, both the old and new addresses should be given, Address 1HE NATION, Bow 794, Publication Ofice, 208 Broadway, New York. TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Fifteen cents p.r agate line, each insertion, 14 lines to the inch. Twenty per cent. advance for choice of page, top of co umn, or cuts, Cuts are inserted on inside pages only A column, $20 each insertion; with choice of page, @24. A page, 60 each insertion; front cover page, *8), Advertisem nts must be acceptable in every respect. Copy received until Tuesday, 5 P. M. DISCOUNT. IME— 4 insertions. 5 per cent, 8 Pr} : “ 0 13 624 2% =° 26 ” 15 ” 39 " 20 oie 52 te Q “ AmoUNT— Bae WR ATOR, 5c bcccckcnsccnunens 250 ae = bos) Ey ORES: 5 = 70 O° « 20 ‘ 1,000 * os . 2.000 ee = 2.500 id ra had THE NATION is sent free to those who advertise in it, as long as advertisement continues, The EDITION of THE NATION this week is 10,050 copies. The Subscription List is always open to the inspec tion of advertisers, *,* C opies of THE NaTIoN may be procured in Paris at Brentano’s, 17 Avenue de l’Opéra, and in London of B. F. Stevens, 4 Trafalgar Square, American mien a Agency, 15 King William Street, Strand, W. London agent for adve Sh R. J. Bush, 92 Fleet Street, E. € The Nation. Schools. DELAWARE, Wilmington, Franklin Street. i i WE MISSES HEBB'S ENGLISH, French, and German Boarding and Day School for young ladies and girls reopens September 22, 181. ‘LOUISIANA, New Orleans, 247 Pry tania Street. | RS. F D. BLAKE AND MRS. L. Zz Polk (hapman’s French and English merase and Day School for girls reopens Oct. 1, 1891, Stu- dents prepared for College. Ample grounds for out- door oxerene. MARYLAND, Annapolis. T. JOHN’S COLLEGE —103d Session J commences Sept. 16. Fight D partments. Bulid- ings heated by steam. Excellent Preparatory School attached. Terms moderate. Special rates and scho- larships for sons of thec ey. ‘or Catalogue address the President, THOMAS FELL, LL.D., Ph.D. MARYLAND, Paltimore, 1214 Eutaw Place. ] ISS RANDOLPH S SCHOOL LO- i cated inthe most beautiful part of the city, opens Sept. tr. with a very able corps of teac —_- Students yrepared for college. Principals—Miss S. N. Randolph, liss A. 1. arerene. MARYLAND, Paltimore, “122-124 West Franklin St. 7] HE EDGEWORTH SCHOOL FOR Girls, Mrs. H,. P. LEFEVRE, Principal. Circulars upon application. lee MAS#ACHUSETTS, Boston, 593 Boy Iston Street WAUNCY HALL SCHOOL (6gth Year) For Boys and Girls.—Prepara'ion for the Mass. In stitute of Techno oxv Isa specialty. Reference is made tothe Institute Faculty. The location of the school building, on Cepley Square. is especially attractive and is very near the Institute. Preparation also for College (with or i Greek) ones sie business, Special students reccived. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston. | 3 ee UNIVERSITY Law School EpMvunD H. BennetTr, LL.D. Address the Dean. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 112 Newbury Street. WE MISSES HUBBARD'S SCHOOL for Girls will reopen October 1, 1891 =A limited number of boarding scholars will be received. MASS8ACHUS. TTS, Cambridge, Larch Street. OME FOR BOYS DR ABBOT AD- mits not more than four boys Into hts family, to fit for college or educate privately. Separate tuition, with best of care in all respects. Charming cation. with fine tennis-court. F. E, Apgot, Ph.D Massacavusetts, Concord. Bp e ciel HOME SCHOOL.—TWEN- - ty-five boys prepared for colleve, scientific school or business. All the advantages of family life com- bined with best mental and physical training. Build- ines new and constructed according to latest models. Seventy- five acres of land. JAMEs S, GARLAND, Master, MASS ACHU sErrs, Plymouth and Duxbury. yrs KNAPP’S HOME SCHOOL FOR Boys, Plymouth.—12 boys; 25th year, H. B. LEARNED (Harv.), Head Master. Mrs. KNAPP P, Principal. JOWDER POINT SCHOOL, Duxbury. —22 boys. Laboratories. FREDERICK B. Knare, S.B, (M.I.T.), Principal. — MASSACHUBETTS, Quincy. {Pai MS ACADEMY, PREPARA- % tory and boarding school for boys. —School year began September 17. ror all information address iat ple - ; w ILLIAM Ev ERETT, Ph.D, M ASSACHUSETTS, Ww orcester, OHN W. DAILZELL’S PRIVATE School for boys, 66 West St.—Prepares for Col- lege or Scientific School Send for for C atalogue. NORTH (AROLINA, hieiite, 4 VENSCROFT SCHOOL.—PREPAR- atory Boarding and Day School for Poys. Head Mast er, Ronald Mc Donald, B. A. , Oxtord. PENNSYLVANIA, Bryn Mawr. RYN MAWR COLLEGE, 10 MILES from Philadelphia—A College for Women.—The Program, stating the graduate ani under-graduate courses of study for the academic year, will be sent on application. PENNSYLVANIA, North Wales. JORTH WAIES ACADEMY AND School of Bus’ness.—Twenty-second year Sept. 9. Board and tuition, #240. Graduates. either sex, enter Freshman best gt Smith or Wellesley Col le ce graduate assistants, . U. BRU INNER, P. 0. Box 41. P NYSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, Chestnut Hill. M?*: S. COMEGYS AND MISS BELL'S English, Fronch and oomen Boarding School ens Sept. 28, 189 for college. cae grounds for for young ladi s reo Students prepare outdoor exercise. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, 1350 Pine St. ] TSS ANABLE’S BOARDING AND Day chool for Young Ladies will reopen Sept.28. Germany, Berlin, 50 Kénigin Augusta Str, SUUNG LADIES’ SCHOOL.—THO- rough instruction fu. German, French, Music. Belles- Lettres, History, and the usual branches of education. Refers by permission to Hon. W. W. Phelps, U.S. Minister to wormsey. Mrs. Murat Hal- stead, ‘Brooklyn, N. Y., Mrs. Wm. D. Foulke, Rich mond, Ind. Fri. yi REINBRECHT. [Vol ‘Rigteaie. FRANCE, Paris, 69 Boulevard St. Michel. ARS VAN P&#LT’S AMERICAN Pension,—These apartments are spacious, face the Ss. of the Luxembourg. and being in a corner house, all the rooms are sunny. The proximity of the Sorbonne, where are given free lectures the Ecole des Beaux Arts, the Odeon Theatre, which is the Clas- sic National Theatre, and two of the best art schools, makes this locaiity especially desirable for stulents. = Van Pelt has secured the service: of a refined a thororgh French and music teacher) who will st her in making French the languace of the family and wili also accompany ladies to the lectures and as- sist them In taking notes. Those who do not wish to speak French will havea separate table, For references and circular address Mrs. E. L. HEAD, Germ: antown, 1 a. OLLEGE FOR WOMEN.—THE FIN- est winter resort in the South; the most beauti- ful grounds of any boarding-schovl in* the Union. Appointments of Boarding Departme t first-class in every respect. Advantages in Music, Art, and | ite- rary Departments unsurpassed. apply to the Pres dent. Rev. W. R. ATKINSON, D.D., Columbia, s. Cc. VIE BOSTON SCHOOL OF ORATOR Y. —The Leading School of Expression in America. First to teach the system of Delsarte. Send for cata logue to Moses TRUE | ROWS, M.A., Boston, Mass, \T » No 1382 Ve For catalogue, Teachers, ete. HARLES W STONE, Tutor for Har- vard, 68 Chestnut Street, Boston. School Agencies. WE SCHOOL AND COLLEGE BU- REAU, Elmhurst (Chicago), Ill., recommends Professors, Se ialista, and Teachers for all depart- mentsof instruction. Nocharge to colleges and schools, Best service guaranteed, Correspondence solicited. address C.J. ALBERT, Manager, Elmhurst, Ill. MERICAN AND FOREIGN TEACH- ers’ Agency supplies Professors, Teachers, Tu- tors, —— ete., to Colleges, Schoo/s, and Famt- lies. Apply to Mrs. MW. J, YOUNG- FULTON, 23 Union > quare, New York. — “T'HE FISK TEACHERS’ . 4GENCIES. 7 Tremont Place, Boston, Mass., 6 Clinton Place, N. Y., 106 Wabash Ave., Chicago, Ill, and 120% South Spring Street, Lo: Angeles, Cal.“ 100- -page Agency » Manual free. — EVERETT oO. FIsK & C Lo. 7 NEW A ME RICAN TFA ( ‘HERS’ AGENCY.—Teachers seeking positions snd those wishing a change at an increased salary. shou'd address C. B. RuGGLEsS & Co., (Palace Hotel Building), Room G, 237 wy ine St, Cc ineinnati, 0. MERIC ANAND FOREIGN Professors, tutors. governesses, teacher:, etc., supplied to Col. leges, schoo.s, and families. MIRIAM i ‘OY a . 159 5th Av. cor. 20th St, -¥ : CHERMER HORN S T E . ¢ ff E R s’ . ency. _ and best known in U.S Fetab shed 185 3 East Mtn St., N. ¥. GOLD MEDAL, PARIS, 1878 W. BAKER & C0.’S Breakfast Cocoa from which the excess of ot: has been removed, Is absolutely pure and tt ts soluble. No Chemicals are used in its preparation. It has more than three times the strength of Cocoa mixed with Starch, Arrowroot or Sugar, and is therefore far more eco- nomical, costing less than one centacup. Itis delicious, nour- ishing, strengthening, EASILy DIGESTED, and admirably adapted for invalids aa well as for persons in health. Sold by Grocers everywhere. _W. BAKER &C0., Dorchester, » Mass The Best ie published. Only One Dol- ar a year, with member- ship in Readers’ Union Li- brary Association, and 300- page Catalogue, saving 30 per cent. on “all books pur- chased. Sample copies ten cents. READERS’ Union Pvs. Co., Lansing, Mich.

Page 3

Dec. 24, 1891] The Nation. The Nation Is a weekly review of politics, literature, science, and art, conducted with the aid of the most competent writer able. The list of contributors who have been employed more or less frequently during the twenty-five years o nal’s publication, has included most of the leading names in literature, science, art, philosophy, and law in this c and many of corresponding eminence abroad. A bound volume of the .Vefron presents one of the most com accurate condensed records procurable of the world’s current history, with tmpartial comment on quest should occupy the attention of thoughtful men. Its Departments are: The Week. Brief comments on the most important current events, domestic and forei Editorial and Miscellaneous Articles, Careful and moderate discussion of prominent political and soca Special Correspondence. Yrom all quarters of the globe, by intelligent and trustworthy observers. Occasional Correspondence. Letters to the editor on every subject germane to the scope of Notes. Short paragraphs, chiefly on literary, scientific, musical, and dramatic topics. Reviews of Books. By able writers and scholars (mainly s pecialists) of both hemispheres Fine Arts. Competent criticism of art exhibitions and works of art, the drama, ete. Terms, $3 per annum, postpaid. Address THE Nation, 208 Broadway, New York 4A PARTIAL LIST OF WRITERS Henry P. Wright, ¥ Williston Waike Alex, Agassiz, Harvard U niversity. Frederic D. Allen, le College Herbert Ad nik ‘ rtford, Cona. Win, Ha we F. Bocher, = H. E. Bourne, Norwich, Conn, A. M.t RA Bowditeh, bi Robert P. Keep, ae eo “*hrist! Frankl Edward Channing Os i; David A. Wells, oe e Fabian Prank F. J. Child, H. H. Boyesen, ¢ ‘olumbia College. 8.1 { W. M. Davis, te W.H.C arpen ter ’ ye E. Emerton, = Dd, K. Do tge, by a Jo . e Kuno Francke, a R. J. H. Gotthell, “ ” ruay rn Samuel Garman, - -J. i Hysiop, = 2 ) CL Rose Geo. L. Goodale, se Brander Matthews, * = C. Weiling, Colum)bdar ersity, Was W. W. Goodwin, _ A.C. Merriam, ie - s nN . t \. Nautteal A An” Charles Cross, - John BR, Moore, " . mS ing S. Surreon General's ¢ A. B. Hart, - Henry F. Osborn, “* = Ss : U.S. Ge vogteoal Surves William James, ee Munroe Smith = = Henry Gannett, J.R. Jewett, - G. E. Woodberry, ‘* ts Ar 1 Hague Geo. M. Lane, bie Henry M. Baird. University of the City of New York H.W nehaw auof E «y Chas. R. Lanman, = H. P. Johnston, College of City of New York Elliott Coues, Smitheontan institur S. M. Macvane, = | : A, Allen, American Museum Natural History Widen H a Morris H. Morgan, = B, Bishop, New York fore «it Charies Eliot Norton, ‘ } We. H. Rish »p, aries avis, USN Geo. H. Palmer, + i J. W. Che dwick, w a ted Francis G. Peabody, “ | Edward PD. Ciark, - Russ soley Josiah Royee, bc T. M. Coan, ; Stock tou, C. 8S, Sargent, = W.A. Coltin, #6 jarrick Mallery, U.S.A N.S. Shaler, “ Moncure }. Conway, i A. A. Woarxihuill F, H. Storer, - Kenyon Cox, 7 Heary Adams, Washington C. F. de Sumichrast, * R. J, Cross, ‘ AS . et F. W. Taussig, = Courtenay DeKalb ie ray i J. B. Thayer, sa Theo. L. De Vinn e “ Now W.H. Tillinghast, se Edward Exgleston, : James A. Harrison, Washing ar C. H. Toy sd \ 2 M. Ferrias, “ J.M arnett warlottesvil va Justin Winsor, = Heury Ra Finck, " Addison Hogue, University of Mi«siss J.H. Wright x W. C. Ford, “ J. RS. Merreté, University of Las Lue gh arr, Peabody Museum of Archeology. James B. Fry. = .. Hosmer, Washineto rsity . Putnam, “ “a ™ Edwin L. Godkin, 303 Fisk P. Rrewer, Grinne wa Bae Fiske, Cambridge, Wendell P. Garrison, = } Geo. FL Howard, versity of N Arthur Gilman, is L. McK Garrison, om trank Parks, Linco N C. H. Grandgent, ” F. V. Greene, . J.D. Butler niverstty of Wiseonsetn W.. M. Griswold, = T. L. Greene, = R. B. Anders Madison, Wis a WwW, Higginson. bi D. Hag cue, be Hi Aa ‘ niversity of Michigan P. Longfellow, *“* : vel FS H: ips wd, a ieorge H . y H. wot ye, ve Emma N. lIreiand, : FW. Kelsey Wm. R. Thyer, A.S isaacs ” WH. Pettee Charles Francis Adams, : ees Boston, E. Lemcke, - Calvi as : . Gamaliel Bradford, = Thos, W. Ludlow, ma Alfr rson, Lake Forest. Tl, Charles A. Cutter, _ A. R. Macdonougn oe KR. . Bourne, Adelbert Collace Charles Eliot, = D. MacG. Means, 2 “a. FL Wrig wriin Co leg E. H. Greenleaf, - Luigi Monti, ‘ } DP. Cox. Cinciona W. E. Griffis, : Geo. 5. Morison, i A. broad le iy Henry W. Haynes, as Rolo Ozden, m2 L. & i James M. Hubbard, = G. Pollak, - \_* ardetic auta } ‘N Henry W. Holland, o J.P. Peters, ; E. S. Holds k Observatory a Edward J. Lowell, = Dean Sage, . Hale, cil , Ca i Percival Lowell, . Arthur G. Sedewick ; Ann . Logan, 3 trea Francis Parkman, Sy Frederick Sheldon : idwin Smith, Toron A. L. Ripley, ~ Charles B, Spahr, ; Janes lation Edw ard. Ro ‘binson, = Russell Sturyis, Wo oMo va . John C. Ropes, se Arnold Tanzer, sa by. Crawford Thorvald Solberg, ~y J. R. Towse, ‘ FPitaesiward Hall Lindsay Swift, “ William Hayes Ward, ‘ Aifrext C. La Wm. H. Whitmore, ha Horace White, . hiizateth KR Pennell, G. R. Carpeuter, Mass, Institute of Technology. c. K. Adams, Cornel! 1 ersity. Isa sidew ick Jules Laguiens, = ns T. F. Crane, we ‘ i Rus \ . Geo, F. Moore, Andover, Mass. O. F. Emerson, gz Albert \ ey ixfor William Everett, Quincy, Mass, ‘ tiage ; i Dver H. 4 Fay, Westborough, Maxs t . Ww. Buinham, ¢ lark University. Lose G. Kingsley, Leamington G. ‘tee Hall, M a. t n vit David P. Todd, Amherst College. Al 1 Web John T. St idar |, Smith College ames Darn eter, Par Franklin Carter, W iiliams College. Aruaruste O, M. Fernal Le Cocq treppe, Bliss Perry, = 5 Salomon *h agg Ww, Smal!, Colby University. H. vou Holst, University of Freiburg, Paden, wim. Foster, Providence. Tr hun leideiberg Woleett ‘ibbs, Newport. K.P. 1 *, Munich G. B Adams. Yale College w. Soot iz cet m t se Vs ‘ it ; D.C. Eaton, ” " Lat avette Oniles ard lorence Arthur T. Hadley, ™ 1 niversity of } x sti . Rome W. 1. Knapp, a ¢ iprin, Phila . 2). Safford Fiske, Ajassi« T. R. Lounsbury, ” He race Ho aaa Furness, Pailedelphia | N. D. Davis. Georgetown, Demerar Tracy Peck, = Henry C. Lea, ee ] Rodrigues, Rio de ‘aneiro D. Seymour, ” J. G. Rosemrarten “ | ©. Meriwether, Sendai, Japan. Ww. L Sumner, « Chas. S Peirce, Milford, Pa. | Garrett Droppers, Tokio. A. Van Name, . i J. H. Wigmore, THe Nation will be sent to new readers for examination, two months for 25 cents, —— — ] :

Page 4

1v ATLANTIC MONTHLY for January contains Don Orsino. The First Chapters of a Remark- able Serial Story by F. MARION CRAWFORD. James Russell Lowell. A paper of very great interest by HENRY JAMES. Boston. An Essay, never before printed, by RALPH WALDO EMERSON The Creed of the Old South. A strong and frank statement of the political views held in the South before and during the War, by Professor B. L, GILDER- SLEEVE. Why Socialism Appeals to Artists. ac An inter ‘esting paper by the fa- mous English artist, V VALTER CRANE. a Greatest Need of Col- lege Girls. A thoughtful and valuable essay, by ANNIE PAYSON CALL, The Missing Interpreter. A striking Short Story, by HER- BERT D. WARD. John Stuart Mill, and the London a and Westminster Review. Including several letters by Mr. MILL, edited by C. Marion D, Towers. Birds and “ Birds.” A delightful out-door paper, with songs inwoven, by EDITH M. THOMAS. The Political Situation. ‘An article likely to excite no little comment, $4.00 a year; 35 cents a number. HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO., Boston, yi East 17th Street, New York, ‘AN EXTRAORDINARY BOOK.”—Times, Phila. AMERICANS OF ROYAL DESCENT. “A collection of Genealogies of American families whose lineages are traced to the legitimate issue of kings.” New edition; 200 printed; 732 pages; 4,000 different surnames. ‘Its refer: ‘neces seem direct and are evidently trust- worthy.’ ’—Trivune, New York. * One of the most popular books in the Philadelphia and bop rey Libraries.” —Press, Phila. eof tho most curious of recent books in the Astor ‘Library * *"— Evening Telegram, New York. pas A unique book of American genealogy.” —Ledger, ue ta. It will soon become a bibliophilic rarity and trea- sure.””—The American, Book may be seen at Brentano’s, Union Square, N. Y. We have a fd. forsale. Price, $15, delivered, RTER & COATES, Philadelphia, Pa. The Nation. The Remington Standard Typewriter Wyckoff, Seamans & Penediet, 327 Broadway, New York, Is to-day, as it ever has been, the Leading Typewriter. Care- fully tested improvements are constantly added to this famous machine. SEND FOR AN ILLUSTRAED CATALOGUE AND PRICE LIST OF OUR ‘‘ PARAGON ”’ TYPEWRITER RIBBONS. Unmounted Photographs Of Ancient and Modern Works of Art, embracing reproduc- tions of famous original paint- ings, sculpture, architecture, etc. Price, cabinet size, $1.50 per dozen; larger sizes in pro- ortion. Lantern slides to or- der. Send 15 cents for 1887 Catalogue and 1890 Supple- ment of 12,000 subjects. Photographs mounted on a ple ate paper for the illustration of books on art and travel. Correspondence invited. SoULE PHOTOGRAPH Co., PUBLISHERS, 338 Washington Street, Boston, Mass. Please mention The Nation. KNA PIANOFORTES, UNEQUALLED IN TONE, TOUCH, WORKMANSHIP, AND DURABILITY, Taltimore. New York. 22 end 24 /. Baltimore St. 148 5th Ave., near 20th St Washington, 817 Market Space. STEINWAY The Standard Pianos of the World. The Largest Establishment in Existence Warerooms, Steinway Hall, New York. B ACK NUMBERS, VOLUMES, OR sets of leating aud scarce magazines, ete., for sale by H. WiLuiams, 1¥5 West loth St., N. YY, [Vol. 53, No. 1382 HATCHARDS. This is the favorite BOOKSTORE, and for 100 years the resort of the smartest people in London. It is visited and patronized by all who love books. London is the great market for books, and all the best as well as the cheapest editions can be had by writing to us. Special collections formed, and fuller information sup- plied than from any other house. Books both old and new, and relating to any subject, can readily +2 supplied at very moderate prices. Ageuis for Clubs, Libraries, and all private Collectors. W. 187. PiccapILLy, LONDON DO YOU WRITE? 100.000 PEOPLE ARE USING THE CALIGRAPH WRITING MACHINE, Thus saving Time and Energy. CAN YOU AFFORD wae THE PEN, WHEN CALIGRAPH CAN WRITE THREE TIMES AS FAST. MANUFACTURED BY THE AMERICAN WRITING MACHINE CO. HARTFORD, CONN. : 237 Rroadway, New-York. 14 West 4th st,, Cincinnati, O. 1003 Arch St., Philadelphia, English Factory, Coventry, England. A Brave Black Regiment. Col. Robert G. Shaw. Just Published. History oF THE FIirty- FOURTH REGIMENT OF MASSACHUSETTS VOLUNTEER INFANTRY, 1863-1865. By Luts F. EmiLio. With nine maps and eighty- three portraits. Cloth binding, $3.00 NET. The representative character of the Fifty-fourth, as one of the first colored regiments; its bravery and heavy losses in action and the heroic death of its first commander, Co'. : obert G. Shaw, while leading the charge on Fort W agner, give a special interest to this volume, You Branch Offices: PUBLISHED LY THE BOSTON BOOK CoO., 15 1-2 Beacon Street, Boston. FRE N Cc #! Actually Spoken and Mastered in Ten Weeks at your own home, by CERMA Dr. Rosenthal’s Meisterschaft System, (550th thousand.) All subscribers, $5.00 each for each eae become actual pupils of Dr. Ros- enthal who corrects all exercises, and corresponds with them ir regard to difficulties which may occur. Sample copy, Part I, 25 cents. Liberal terms to Teachers. MEISTERSCHAFT PUB. CO, *F — 196 SUMMER StRFET - BOSTON ubscription to forei foreign Book: S, pen Tauchnits Brithen Authors. Catalogues on > CARL SCHOENHOF, 144 Tremont St., Boston. plication. A TED ‘The Library of American Literature iss it ve pay you to find out by writing to C. L.WEBSTER & CO., 67 Fifth Ave., New York. i

Page 5

The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, DECEMBER 24, 1891, The Week. So many Republican newspapers are now edited by oftice-holders that anything like impartial Comment upon an act of the Administration is to be expected from few journals of the party. What the subsidiz ed organs think about the appointment of Elkins, but do not dare to say, finds ex pression in the remarks of two Republican newspapers, representing New England and the Northwest. Says the Manchester (N. H.) Mirror: ‘‘ Mr. Elkins isa smart chap, but neither his character nor his reputa tion is such as to entitle him to a seat among the able and upright gentlemen who constitute the Cabinet. We fear the Presi dent has made his first serious mistake.’ Says the St. Paul Pioneer Press: ** Mr. Elkins has shared with Dudley and Quay and others a position which may have been unmerited, but is none the less a dis- qualification, to some extent, for high and responsible office. It is for this reason that his selection at the present time will provoke surprise and disappointment. An appointment to so high a place should not be open to the criticism that will follow this. It can hardly be said that the nomi nation of Mr. Elkins is a fortunate one for the President or the party.” By the sudden death of Senator Plumb one of the most important personages in public life has been removed. Mr. Plumb had forged his way to the front asa Senate debater by sheer perseverance. When he first entered that body, he took a very humble rank among the members. By assiduous practice he became a_ for midable competitor of the ablest men there, and was really a power in the councils of the nation. His course in the last Congress, wherein he op posed the McKinley tariff in several very strong speeches, and finally voted against it. drew the attention of the country to him. This was a very bold step on his part, but the sequel proved that he had acted wisely. The State of Kansas was lost to the Republicans in the whirlwind that followed the passage of that measure, and Senator Ingalls lost his seat in conse quence. Mr. Plumb, while adhering to the Republican party, had guided his own steps in such a way as not to offend the po litical elements that were opposed to McKinleyism. There is good ground for the belief that Mr. Plumb at the hour of his death was stronger at home than he had ever been before, and this solely on account of his opposition to the Taritf Bill The unanimous reélection of Mr. Daniel to the United States Senate by the Legisla-

ture of Virginia is treated by the press of the Stateasa return to the practice of ante bellum days, whena faithful public servant was kept in oftice term after term. In the early days ‘‘ the Old Dominion ” formed an effective barrier against the ** rotation-in oftice " doctrine. In the Seventeenth Con gress, for example, eighteen of the twenty two Representatives from Virginia were old members, five of them being in their third terms, while tive others had served in from live to eleven Congresses. As late as th last Congress before the war, when the State was entited to twelve members, one had been elected three times, two four times, two six times, and one seven times A change was produced by the reconstruc tion era, and what the Lynchburg Vir ginian calls ‘‘the general dislocation and upheaval of social and political ideas | which followed the cataclysm of the wat Changes became frequent, and even the most worthy ofticials often had to tight hard for a continuance in public hfe. The pendulum is now swinging back, and Mr Daniel's unquestioned reélection is a sign of the times. The anti lottery section of the Demo cratic party in Louisiana have nominated a strong ticket, with an aggressive and ex perienced campaign leader at its head for Governor, and have also adopted a plat form denouncing the proposed Constitu tional amendment which continues the charter of the lottery and makes it a part of the Constitution. The ‘‘ united and in dividual support” of all the members of } the Convention is pledged to the principles of the platform. The Convention's action forces the lottery issue squarely upon tl other wing of the Democratic party whose Convention has not yet adopted a plat form, but has made its nominations It is noticeable that the members of this wing are declaring that their two leading candidates are anti-lotterv men | but it is certain that the nominee for Gov | ernor, Mr. McEnery, is a lottery man, and has acted in the past in the lottery’s int. rest. They are also circulating a report that a compact has been arranged between the anti-lottery wing and the National Re | publican Committee, the terms of which are, that, in return for Republican support of the anti-lottery ticket this vear, the anti-lottery Democrats will help carry Louisiana for the Republican Presidential candidates next vear. All these reports have the peculiar lottery flavor, and are obviously false. The only way by which the McEnery ticket can be removed from suspicion will be for the Convention to } adopt an anti-lotterv pledge similar to that which the other Convention has adopted The idea seems to be widely accepted that the President is compelled to issue a ! ’ pProciamiation on the first of January in Posiny chittes mh 4 stigray I asstsS tena cotfee, and hides when Unported from | countries that have not made reciprocity Let The truth is. 1 ssue such per } ' ' ’ ‘ }, ' Chihhkition or t jUst As Ne Plevises, s t ( lit f issuing at all isthe sta f his ow ? til Lhis w ” con DV & ittentive Nun " { thre aw. wl }

i tra ~ * t Wit art sand f =} th we ard ifter t t wv oof January ‘ Whenever a Is ‘ t t ‘ i ~t “ that ti CGrovernm ary ! Vv pre in ame Xpuort yr Ss irs inns Te tea, and hides AW oan 1 any { such art ~ Th iA trons upon the agricultura ther products oft the l el States “ ! ‘ ‘ { ? free titres t ~ ~ a! NNEON foe, tea, and ? . ! 1 States rasa cheer beet procally al ane reasonal ! shall " pew arn shall be his duty SUS] by proclamation totl t effeot the \ 4 thiis vet to tl fre «i + - h sts tea oe un hides 1 ai 1 < t ountrv, f . as he sha eo = etc It is easilv seen that the proclamation is to be issued onlv in case the President iv ai strife rf i If } «) 1 in 1a , State of ir yumi Ve ela, for ex il he owl hal wer her tariff our favor } ‘ l Teese’ cluties Trl oOtth sugar. coffee, and hid x from that Country B t} ~ it ik that the ’ reason assigned bw Ve a for 1 lower her tarit? ‘ hat she | net spare the revenue was a wood and valid reason, then if would not be imeun - , Iwe'l t« ~S immvs Preiama tien. because in such case the Venezuelan tarit? would not be reciprocally unequal and unreasonable It is not unequal ot Inreasonabie for anv country to Impose sufficient taxes to pav the cost of its own The case of the British West India Isl ands is somewhat peculiar These are all erown colonies, but all of them, neverthe less, are allowed to frame their own fiseal systems. The population is about 5 per cent. white and % per cent. black or mu latto. The whites and a small percentage of the mulattoes are the governing class, and they arrange the tax laws so as to throw the bulk of the cost of the local gov ernments on the working class, 7. e., the blacks and the imported East Indian coolies. This is accomplished by means of duties on imported food products. All or most of their food comes from the United States The duties on these articles are paid mostly by the poor and ignorant blacks, who know nothing about taxation, and could not understand the subject even if it were explained to them. When the governing

t ) i

Page 6

480 — classes of the islands say that these are revenue duties, and that they cannot be spared, they probably think so, but, as a matter of fact, they can be spared of the whites will consent to a land tax of suffi- cient amount to supplement the discarded It is only a question which class shall pay the cost of carrying on the local government. The British West In- dies are not the only countries where the rich throw the supporting the Government on the poor by means of du- ties on imports; but we refrain from men- tioning any other at present. duties on food. cost of The dedication in Philadelphia on Thurs- day of the Drexel Institute of Art, Science, and Industry was an event of far more than local interest and concern, The in- stitution is devoted to the work of prepar ing youth of both sexes for the activities of mature life through training in the practi cal and technical methods which they must follow in their chosen vocations, Thus the business department will provide training in stenography, typewriting, bookkeeping, business forms, accounts, correspondence, and the writing of English, with familiar lectures on the terms and operations of manufactures, finance, and law, and it will aim to prepare students for the higher employment clerks, bookkeepers, and secretaries. The department of mechanic arts will include a thorough course of manual will supplemented by carefully devised courses of instruc tion in drawing, mathematics, and other branches, with systematic train- ing in the workshops and laboratories, and an opportunity to acquire a prac tical knowledge of steam and electrical machinery and appliances in connection with the mechanical plants in the build- ing. The department of domestic economy will instruct girls and young women in everything pertaining to the organization and management of the household, its two vears’ course embracing cookery, milli nery, and dressmaking; the building, sani- commerce, forms of as training, which be science, tation, decoration, and management of the house; household economy, human physi- hygiene, business forms and ology and accounts, elementary economics, and phy- sical training. The edifice which Mr. Drexel has erected for the Institute, with its site and equipment, has cost half a million dollars, and he has given million more for its endowment in securities returning $50,000 a year. The benefaction is thus in every way most remarkable, and it is difficult to conceive a keener satisfaction than must be felt by the man who conceived the no- ble project and has carried it out during his lifetime. one The removal of the Premier of Quebec and his Cabinet for corruption will surprise no one who has followed the course of | The Nation.

affairs in Canada since the charges which have led to this result were first made. The sudden disappearance of leading persons involved as soon as an uncovering of the scandals was threatened, and a strong line of testimony against the accused, formed acase against them which later denials and a sudden energy in the way of libel suits did little to weaken. While it would be going too far to ascribe the large crop of public scandals over which Canada is now blushing to the use made of that country by fugitive officials from this side the border, the evil influence of the em- ployment of their country as a place of re- fuge by American thieves is conceded by Canadians. One of the finest residence blocks in Montreal was notoriously built out of the Broadway Railroad bribery fund, and is still known there as ‘ Boo- Block.” <A fugitive excise officer from this city took an active part in one of the railroad bribery schemes exposed in Canada last summer, and contributed his experience to the work. The leading Ca- nadian officers now in disgrace have had a career like that of our city public thieves —an entrance into office as men of small means, and a sudden development into men of wealth, with houses and diamonds to correspond. There is certain to be a good deal of race and religious feeling in- volved in the Quebee scandals, for the dis- graced officers will appeal to their French tongue and their Romanist belief to ob- scure the case against themselves. dlers’ The full text of M1 Goschen’s speech be fore the London Chamber of Commerce on the 2d enables us to form an opinion upon the whole matter with more distinctness than we could heretofore. His plan for an enlargement of the central gold reserve of the United Kingdom is briefly this: The Bank is to offer its £1 notes in exchange for gold; but in order to enable it to pay the expense of printing the notes, taking care of the gold, clerk hire, ete., it is allowed to issue £5 in notes against £4 of gold and £1 of Government securities (consols). It is assumed that the stock of gold in bank will be doubled by this operation, or raised from an average of £20,000,000 to £40, 000,000. It is conceded by Mr. Goschen that a certain proportion of the gold now in the pockets of the people would be ex ported and lost to the country (as gold) by That is, the gold repre sented by the one-fifth of new notes issued against Government securities, being libe- rated from actual use as currency, would be sent to the best market. But it would not be given away. It would be returned in the form of goods. Then Mr. Goschen says that he would rather have £40,000,000 ina central reservoir than £50,000,000 in the pockets of the people. He would rather have the smaller sum in a_ place the operation. where it can be got at, than the larger in a place where it cannot be got at. In this position he is unquestionably right.

[Vol. 53, No. 1382 Of what avail will this larger sum be in case of a panic? The Bank in that event is to have the power to issue notes beyond the present legal limit—7. e., in its own discretion, at a high rate of interest—the interest to inure to the benefit of the Gov- ernment minus a sum sufficient to pay the Bank for its risk. This plan does not con- template the suspension of specie pay- ments for a single moment. The Bank must assume the entire risk of the over- issue of notes, but the risk will be small if it has £40,000,000 gold in its vaults. Mr. Goschen speaks only of an internal panic —that is, a panic not accompanied by an export of gold. In the event of such a panic, an overissue of notes would be of no avail, since they would be presented for redemption as fast as issued. But the Bank would judge for itself whether the panic were external or internal or mixed, The plan is well conceived, and was well re- and would govern itself accordingly. ceived by those to whom it was addressed ; Mr. Lidderdale, the Governor of the Bank of England, moving the vote of thanks to Mr. Goschen at its conclusion. Our weekly contemporary Bradstreet’s has fallen into an error respecting Mr. Goschen’s remarks on the silver question in the above speech, which, it says, ‘‘only in dicated that, should another international conference be arranged for, the position of England in regard to the adoption of an international ratio of the value of silver might not be so inflexible as was the case in the past.” On the contrary, the speech declared in so many words that, whether there should be an- other conference or not, the position of England would not be changed one iota. So Mr. Ottomar Haupt, a bimetallist of some prominence in’ Paris, understands it, for he writes to the Financial Times ex- pressing disappointment at the inflexible attitude of England as indicated in the speech. Mr. Haupt adds to his complaint the important information that Austria- Hungary ‘‘has now finally decided to adopt the single gold © standard, for which purpose large purchases of the precious metal have been made.” Another piece of information contributed by Mr. Haupt may have some interest for the bi- metallists hereabout. He says that if an- other international conference should be held, bimetallism could only be adopted ‘on thé basis of about the actual value of silver; and neither the ratio of one to fif- teen and a half, as in the Latin States, nor that of one to sixteen, as adopted by Ame- rica, would stand a chance of forming the future basis of the establishment of uni- versal bimetallism. And precisely in this question of the choosing of the proper ratio are centred the greatest difficulties.” The death of the Duke of Devonshire will have more important political conse- quences than any Duke's death has had

Page 7

Dec. 24. 1891 | for many a day. It takes Lord Hartington out of the House of Commons, and Lord Hartington and Sir Henry James were the two men who gave the Liberal Unionists in the House any weight, and secured for them much public contidence. Lord Hart- ington, however, was the leader. Sir Henry dames was simply a highly re spectable and rather half-hearted mem ber of the rank and tile. It was Lord Hartington’s presence in the party, or set, which gave it an air of permanence. No one suspected him of personal ambition or disappointed hopes in breaking with Glad stone, as every one knew he was doomed to be a duke. taken by all the members of the set as a final guide, because every one looks on him as preéminently a ‘safe man,” which is the kind of man in public life the Eng lish admire. — His the House of Lords will, to all intents and pur- most removal to poses, take him out of politics, for he is | naturally indolent, and the House of Lords gives very little stimulus to exer tion. lead, and nobody any longer trusts Mr. Chamberlain. Sir Henry James has no desire to The latest curiosity of the English law as affecting the liability of writers and publishers is to be found in a decision of the Court of Queen’s Bench in London, rendered on December 8. Messrs. Chap man & Hall had lately published a volume entitled ‘African Stories,’ written by a certain Major Ellis. In one of the tales a character named James Peacock was introduced, who was de scribed as an ex-African merchant whose wealth had been acquired in an illegiti mate manner. Thereupon came forward | now be said: but Moreover, his advice was | ; on | here of late, are the farmers The Nation. | ness of Mr. Pinnock, cannot, of course we must say, without knowing anything about the merits of the particular case, that the public has to suf fer too many things at the hands of writers with a natural turn for the humorous, to make it regret very much this damper put upon an author who was trying to be mirthful against the grain the Bank the their The renewal of the charter of of France is close at hand, and cur reney “cranks” are preparing rious plans for turning the bank notes into vil something else than promises to pay gold demand. Foremost among these ais The fartuers in France have long been troubled by the | difficulty of borrowing money from the | banks, owing to their inability to give any easily convertible security Their land a veritable African merchant, Mr. James | Pinnock, who maintained that he was re ferred to by many infallible signs in the story, and asserted, furthermore, that his | fortune had been obtained in an entirely reputable way. action against the publishers, inasmuch as | the author was inconveniently absent in the West Indies, doubtless in quest of material for another volume. As soon as Messrs. Chapman & Hall learned that the book in question was giving of fence, they at once broke off its publica tion libraries. it not even al leged that the libel was intentional, vet Moreover, was He proceeded to take | may be good security in the long run, but it is very poor security for short loans, be cause it does not always tind purchasers in of somebody lend the farmer money on such case of default. Some means making security as he can offer has, therefore, long been a great desideratum in French politi tics, and he has at last. as might have been expected, turned to the Government for relief. Some of the farmers would doubtless like Petfer, like to have the Government it into the But others are more moderate What they ask for is that it should be made a condition of the renewal of the Bank charter that the Bank should make long loans on agricultural paper en “prepare” money, and “cover Treasury,” in their aims dorsed by the “Syndicats Agricoles,” which are societies of farmers not unlike our Farmers’ Alliances. The Bank, however refuses to lend on any paper which has not the characteristics of commerei: il paper that is, it must not run for more than thre months, and must be payable on a certain, and, in case of non-payment, must entail the bankruptey of the makers and endorsers. The farmers, however, are by no means satistied with this, and the rea } son is that the ‘‘basing”” idea has got a tirm foothold among them. We are all familiar here with this idea. It used to be and withdrew all copies issued to | preached vigorously in the old greenhack W t nile Lj Promissory days, even by such Phillips. That notes need not orators that convertible as ihe a is, be made wher | due, or convertible at all, provided they are libel it was, the jury said, and the plaintiff | was given damayes to the extent of £200 Expert testimony as to the nature of the of fending volume was given in court several authors—by Mr. George Meredith by among others, he having read the tales in manuscript. He described the work as ** an attempt by a writer of serious mind to be humorous.” Mr. Meredith himself not much taken with Major Ellis’s humor, he said, but thought it might tickle the public. What the result might have proved but for the unfortunate sensitive was that i t} th ‘based ” on something s as as something exists which the note ts posed to represent. Sumpson expan led this basing ” idea when he proposed that the Government should get experts to estimats how much gold there was in mountain «i and then ** base notes on the contents of the mountain as thus estimated The action of the Spanish Government of until June, 1892, has an important bearing upon all its without in extending commerce, eXisting treaties modification, +81 the reciprocity agreement with this coun try affecting our exports te Cuba and Porto Rico. Spain has held that she was bound to give to the nations with which she was in treaty relations the same ad vantages as those accorded the United States in the special reciprocity ar rangement Thus, only a few davs ago the Governor-General of Cuba received the following despatch from the Minister | for the Colonies In pursuance of a claim preferred by the Minister of | the l that merchandise and products co from Holland, at to the treaty Netherlands remind vour Excellency ming di reethy do embraced in the schedules annexed with the United States, « njov the same benefits as the American woods Under this ruling the United States have had me discrumina tion made in their favor as vet Such a discrimination would have existed after February 1. ISt2, the date at which all the Spanisl h their term pea treaties were to rea but now the Government gives notre that it will extend them for tive months longer, thus neutralizing the reciprocity conven tion for that added lemeth of tine And it should be rememberadl that bw next July a new Cuban taru® will be promi! gated. in which Spain will be able to ar range the rates so as to put her own ex ports beyond fear of our competition Brazils unique method of peaceful revo lution has its advantages. but us rapid ex t ton from one State f the country to nother gives it almest a comic au All that is necessarv, appr tly is fora group f the dissatistied to get towether and in dulge in threatening talk against the Gov ert when the latter Is expected at once to resiga This practice had become such a wellestablrshed rule of the game that t! wetin f the Governor of Per nambuco on Saturday in) calling ont the troops and actually firing upon the rioters, might almost be called unfair play He himself appears to have been filled with remorse at this breach of good faith on his part, as the imsurrectionary party neo doubt considered it, and hastened to file the desired resignation after what must be characterized, under the circumstances, as a y™ rien thy Unnecessary effuston of courage However and blood it is probable that the whole process has in- reality less the appearance of comic opera than it would seem to have at this distance; itis very likely only the local completion of the revolution at the capital which made an end of Fonseca Most of the Governors were his vassals, many of them having been directly appointed to their offices by him, and their forced re signations are doubtless to be looked upon as an expression of the popular desire to get rid of the last reminders of the Fonsece regime. Even so, the method is sufficient ly startling to a law abiding mind, and shows how many lessons in the art of re publican government Brazil learn. has yet to

Page 8

A82 JUDGESHIPS AND OTHER OFFICES. PRESIDENT HARRISON has once more earned the hearty commendation of the nation by the excellence of his judicial appointments. No President in recent times has been called upon to name so many judges in an equal period, and no President has main- tained a higher level in his selections. The last Congress required him to man a new court of appellate judges, and the nomina- tions for six of the places which he sent to the Senate on Wednesday week fully sus- tain the reputation which he had previous- ly established for the exercise of uncom. mon discrimination. The most striking feature of these nomi- nations is the fact that two of the six ap- pointees of a Republican President are prominent Democrats. Mr. William L. Putnam of Maine is by far the most con- spicuous and eminent member of the par- ty in that State, which has made him its nominee for Governor and would gladly have honored him with any office. His fitness for the bench may be estimated from the fact that he was offered a judgeship of the State Supreme Court a few years ago, and that the two Republican Senators from Maine earnestly recommended his ap- pointment as Chief Justice of the United States when that office fell vacant during Cleveland’s Administration. Mr. George M. Dallas of Pennsylvania is equally honor- ed by the people of his State, without dis- tinction of party. The Philadelphia Led- ger, which mixes independence with its Republicanism, says of him : ‘* No member of the bar of his age is better known throughout the State of Pennsylvania. He represents and fulfils the best traditions of the Philadelphia bar. That he has proved him- self a lawyer of the best type is the unanimous judgment of his contemporaries. He has dis- tinguished himself in the trial and argument of causes, and he has done his duty successfully and well in public matters, and especially as a member of the Constitutional Convention; but he has chiefly impressed the members of the bar asa man having a peculiar aptitude for the judicial office. The people of the Third Circuit may be congratulated upon having been given a judge learned, upright, and im- partial.’’ The Philadelphia Press, which takes its Re- publicanism ‘‘ straight,” is no less hearty. “The appointment of Mr. George M. Dal- las,” it says, ‘‘ ought to be, and we believe will be, highly gratifying to the people of Philadelphia regardless of party. His suc- cess and eminence at the bar, and his ap- pointment as Professor in the Law Depart- ment of the University of Pennsylvania, attest his capacity and learning as a law- yer.” The most important feature of these two selections, however, is not the fact that the Democrats chosen are excellent men, but that they are Democrats at all; that a Re- publican President gives one-third of these most responsible and distinguished offices to members of the other party. It was eminently the right thing to do. The Phil- adelphia Press tells the exact truth about Mr. Harrison’s performance when it says of it: _‘* The country will approve of his modera- tion and self-restraint in refusing to take all The Nation. the partisan advantage which the opportunity offered. That both parties are represented on the Federal bench makes strongly for the pub- lic safety and content. It promotes a healthy public opinion and belief in the essential non- partisanship and fairness of the Federal judi- ciary. The new Court of Appeals will stand stronger in the opinion of the = and be regarded more generally with favor and re- spect, because in appointing its Judges the President has broken through the border wall of party politics.’’ But the more heartily the President is praised for giving the Democrats so large a representation on this important bench, the more severe must be his condemnation for having applied the contrary system of the most rigorous partisanship to the great host of less important offices which he has disposed of during the past three years. If it ‘makes strongly for the public safety and content” to have both parties repre- sented on the Federal bench, so would it also to have both parties represented in minor departments of the Federal service. If such appointments ‘‘ promote a belief in the essential non-partisanship and fair- ness of the Federal judiciary,” and if ‘‘the new Court of Appeals will stand stronger in the opinion of the public, and be re- garded more generally with favor and respect,” because of them, so would the Postal Department throughout the coun- try be benefited if in appointments to it the President had also ‘‘broken through the border wall of politics.” In fact, the argument for giving a third or a half of the minor offices to the op- posite party is infinitely stronger than in the case of these high judgeships. Mr. Putnam and Mr. Dallas hold views dia- metrically opposed to those of Mr. Harri- son on all of the great issues which divide parties, and they are given offices which enable them to enforce those views, and to affect the attitude which the Federal Gov- ernment shall occupy regarding them; on the other hand, the overwhelming ma- jority of the minor Federal appointees can exert no influence whatever upon the at- titude of the Federal Government towards vital issues. Their duties are purely execu- tive, and for the most part mechanical. They stamp letters, sort mail matter, add up columns of figures, manage petty oftices— all of them duties with which partisanship properly has nothing in the world to do. The most eminent Democrat in Maine is given the most responsible office within the President’s gift at this session, and yet there is not a little post-office in the State where it would be thought proper to re- tain the most efficient incumbent if he were a Democrat. A year ago the term of Gen. Corse as Postmaster of the metropolis of New England expired. His administration had been so _ re- markable for efticiency and non-partisan- ship that the business community of Bos- ton hesought his reappointment, and even such bitter Republican partisans as Sena- tors Hoar and Dawes favored his retention. But Mr. Harrison refused to let him remain in_ this purely executive position, simply and _ solely on the ground that he, was a Demo- [Vol 53, No 1382 crat, and had not expressed himself in con- demnation of the course of his party throughout the nation. Even the cross- roads postmasters throughout the United States—40,000 of them—had to ‘‘go” if they were not Republicans, on the ground that it was essential to the successful ad- ministration of the Federal Government that every little office should be run by a man ‘‘in sympathy with the party in power.” And then the President who thus surrendered tens of thousands of minor of- fices to the spoilsmen, recognizes the funda- mental principle of civil-service reform by giving two out of six of the highest judge- ships in the land to men who have not one particle of sympathy with the party in power! The absurdity of the spoils system could not be portrayed more vividly than in this effective contrast. The nation will com- mend with the utmost heartiness Mr. Har- rison’s wise appointment of Democratic judges, by which it realizes more forcibly than ever before the folly of his refusal to keep in post-oftices and other Federal offices the thousands of efficient men whom he has removed simply for being Democrats. The President has thus, un- consciously no doubt, given a great impe- tus to the cause of civil-service reform. A REPUBLICAN BUSINESS MAN. THERE can be no question that Stephen B. Elkins, whom the President has nominated for Secretary of War, is one of the most representative Republicans of histime. We doubt if there could be found in the coun- try to-day a man who typifies more per- fectly than he does the principles and ten- dencies of the latter-day Republican party. He is, as one of the Republican Boys of this city lately described himself to be, a ‘‘ Republican from the crown of his head to-the soles of his feet.” For more than twenty years he has been devoting all his energies to the cultivation of Republican- ism as he understands it—that is, has been making his politics and his business work together for the.good of Stephen B. Elkins. The skill with which he has directed those energies is shown by the grand results. He is to-day a very rich man and a member of the Cabinet. The different steps by which he has reached these goals are so full of in- struction that we shall trace them in their order, as briefly and dispassionately as pos- sible. He began his political business career in New Mexico when, in 1867, he became a member of the Legislature of that Territory. Two years later President Andrew Johnson appointed him District Attorney of the Ter- ritory, and he held the office till 1878, when he was elected a delegate from New Mexico to Congress. He served two terms in this capacity, becoming during his ser- vice greatly interested in mining ventures, all of which had special Congressional grants, or Territorial court decisions, or some other political complication which enhanced their value to Mr. Elkins and

Page 9

Dec. 24. 1891] other stockholders. One of his most fa mous ventures at this time was the Max well land grant, a Mexican boundary claim with a bill behind it. Mr. Elkins worked | so zealously for this bill that it was passed, | and the grant was afterwards sold to a Dutch syndicate for several million dol lars. Prolonged litigation and ugly charges of irregular conduct followed the sale, but it was said that Mr. Elkins had severed his | connection with the business before the scandals appeared. In 1872 Mr. Elkins may be said to have entered upon his career as a national busi- ness Republican by becoming a member of | the National Republican Committee, a po sition which he has held continuously ever | since. He had about the same time be come the warm personal friend and ad mirer of James G. Blaine. When the Star route investigation began in LSS1, after Gartield’s inauguration, it was charged but not proved that Mr. Elkins, in his capa city as a Territorial Republican business man, had been connected more or less in timately with some of the objectionable contracts. Stephen W. Dorsey, another Republican business man, was shown to with them, and in a statement which he made | in 1884, Mr. Dorsey said : “S. B. Elkins, United Bank Building, New York, has probably a larger knowledge than any other person of all the Star-route matters and the moneys paid. George E. Spencer de- manded of the late J. W. Bosler and myself $12,000 to pay Mr. Elkins for the purpose of avoiding indictment and prosecution, and replied that I would not pay a penny, and never did.”’ In 1884 Mr. Elkins took a most active part both in the nomination of Mr. Blaine | for the Presidency and in the campaign for his election. After Mr. Cleveland en- tered upon the Presidency, and Mr. Bayard had become Secretary of State, there was found in the State Department a claim against Brazil for $50,000,000, made by one have been connected very closely Jewett for an alleged discovery of guano beds in Brazil. Mr. Evarts, as Secretary of State, twice rejected the claim. The accompanying correspondence showed that Jewett had retained Mr. Elkins as counsel, and that Mr. Blaine, while Gartield’s Sec retary of State, on August 8, 1881, had written to Mr. Osborne, the United States Minister in Brazil, reversing Mr. Evarts’s decisions and instructions in regard to the claims; and that Mr. Blaine had written also to Mr. Jewett saying that he had re opened the claim ‘‘at the request of Ste- phen B. Elkins, Esq., your attorney.” In | his letter to Mr. Osborne, Mr. Blaine said : “T am not sufficiently informed as to the | law of Brazil to know how far its formal | requirements as to the mere question of right and title would nullify this action by its Government, but I do know that in jus tice and in equity a responsibility has been incurred which cannot be escaped.” While the reopened claim was being thus pressed by Secretary Blaine and Mr. El kins, President Gartield was lingering be tween life and death. After his death, Mr. Blaine was succeeded in office by Mr. | | the claim during the latter’s term. Mr. Bayard had considered it carefully, he | | tion The Frelinghuysen. Nation. Nothing was done with When said of it: ‘‘Sucha claim, so stated, shocks the moral sense, and cannot be held to be It would be an act of international unfriend liness for the United States to lend them within the domain of reason or justice selves in any way or to any degree in urging, much less enforcing, such a de mand upon a country with whom we are or design to remain, on terms of amity. I, therefore, return the protest as enclosed | by you, and decline to transmit it to the United States Minister at Brazil, or to in | struct him to present it ofticially or other wise. While the Bering Sea negotiations with Great Britain progress a few it that Mr. Elkins, asa member of the North Ameri were in months ago, was discovered can Commercial Company, had great tinan cial interests at stake in preventing a set tlement, and it was only with the greatest difficulty and after long delay that his in It the time that the Presi dent's son and other Republican business men were interested with Mr. Elkins in this enterprise, and a Washington corre terests were compelled to ive way Was intimated at spondent hints that the President's son has been ‘‘let into” several other of the many good things which Mr. Elkins has control of, and that this the had some influence in securing the appoint ment kindness to son has We have touched upon only the chief incidents in the busy career of this eminent Republican business man, but enough has been given to show what his claims to the | position are, and to foreshadow with sutti cient clearness the kind of Secretary of War he will make A FURIBUNDAL NAV) THERE are times when it seems as if disin terested and faithful service of the country by no means the highest good, is to be found by men of honor, to whom money is only in the ranks of the army and navy That these two services are the best schools of real patriotism just now, we fear there ts But it has to be borne in mind both the and are voung men, and tighting men by profession, and naturally eager for a no question that the ofticers of army navy tive service, and, like military men all over the world, to take stand on their dignity, and exact satisfac For this every government which has an army or navy for real use, and not merely for show, finds itself obliged to keep a tight rein very ready offence, reason on any portion of either | which brings it in contact with foreign nations. The army seldom does bring it in contact with foreign nations, but the navy does so constantly, and therefore a stimulated navy—that is, a navy fed. either by its superiors at home or by the press at home, on highly seasoned food, and urged to assert itself and ‘‘stand no nonsense,” and make foreigners ‘‘ stand round "—is one of 485 the most dangerous possessions a na- tion can have, for it Keeps the coun try constantly on the verge of an ex pensive quarrel, either with a Power which has to be fought because it is so big, to be What naval officers, or with a Power which has fought because it is so little when let loose in times of excitement, can do in the was of reckless abuse of force, was Well illustrated in the Jamaica bles twenty trou years ago, when two young fellow s the a lieutenant and a midshipman in British a drumhead court-martial navy—constituted themselves and hanged a highly respectable colored han Ww hose sole offence was that he had been prominent in polities before the trouble began Wi which are just now passing through & crisis we think, makes these observations peculiarly appropriate. After a good muaany years Without a navy we have begun to get fone, amd have already the nucleus of a | formidable naval force with all the fmodern improvements. The public ts naturally much pleased and very proud and the naval oftticers have begun to ij recover from the humiliation so long in thieted on them by the old wooden ships This has put the navy anda considerable portion of the public in what may be called a fighting mood. There is abroad a human but not wholly respectable, desire to find somebody on whom our new armored ships and new guns may be tried with uit serious doubt as to the result and Chili just now seems to have been selected for the COrpPUS Chie The in structions issued by the Navy Department to the squadron at Valparaiso were in reditable, but with the influence of the Barrundia case and of the everv Wavy what new navy, they were not strictly obeved Our ofticers did show their bias in favor of with little o1 Admiral indiscreet in his Schle s Balmaceda, no attempt at concealment Brown was very movements; Commander was Very indiscreet in his corre and more than sending a large body of ashore at Valparaiso after being warned that the spondence indisereet in Saniors Chilian populace was very much excited It was, under the circumstances, a real “wha daur meddle wi’ The happen to the Chilians if they do not sub mit The manifesto threats that something terrible will to some sort of humiliation to which everybody knows we would not ask a first class Power to submit, continue, and, as usual, a portion of the press is active in keeping the excitement alive. Every move ment of our war ships, every launch of a | new one, and every repair in the navy-yard is treated as preparation to fight Chili. As usual, the press has done nothing to en- lighten or inform public opinion about the law or morality of the situation. It con- tines itself to stimulating the combative ness of the navy and the public. Secretary Tracy, as far as we know, is keeping his head cool now, or doing no- | thing to aggravate the crisis, but a strik- | ing illustration of the kind of pressure he has to resist appeared in the columns of an

Page 10

484 ee occasionally esteemed contemporary on Monday. Under the heading ‘‘ Quite Ready for Chili,” we find an interview with Secretary Tracy. Asked whether he had heard of a mob surrounding the American Legation in said he had not, and did not believe it. Asked whether he expected any trouble with Chili, he said he did not. Asked ‘‘what American line-of-battle ships are now within easy reach of Chili,” he said : “The little Yorktown is at Valparaiso, and the Boston will be there in a few days. The Baltimore is now on her way up to San Francisco.” This is all there was in the interview about Chili. It showed that the preparations for war with Chili are mainly being carried on in the news- papers, whose proper function really is, as preachers of morality, to try to keep war feeling down. This function would be dis- charged but for the extraordinary notion that the journalist’s highest duty is to create a large demand for his newspaper. No no- tice of this is taken, as far as we know, in recent works on political science, but it is a prominent factor in modern politics. Santiago, he EUROPEAN TARIFF CHANGES. THE commercial treaties recently negotiat- ed in such a way as to cover a large part of Europe, come as a striking fulfilment of a prediction made more than two years ago by an Italian economist. Writing in the Giornale degli Economisti of ‘‘ Tariff Policy during the Last Thirty Years,” he made out roughly a special character for each successive decade: the first, a period of gradually lowering duties, following the initiative of England; the second, the time of commercial treaties, in the negotia- tion of which France led off; and, third, the protectionist reaction of the last ten years, bringing back the features of the abandoned corn-laws, and reverting to the policy of internation al hostility and reprisals in trade. This reached its height in the commercial war between France and Italy, precipitated by the tariff laws enacted by the latter in 1887. It also led to the harmful French and German _ protectionist — legislation. Writing when this war of tariffs was at its hottest, the economist we refer to, Signor Stringher, maintained that the condition of things thus brought about would be found intolerable, and predicted a return to the system of commercial treaties securing freer international ex- changes. That the new treaties which have al- ready come stand for an abatement of the protectionist madness, is admitted on all hands. They may be complicated with political motives and questions of general international policy, but no considerations of foreign policy could make so many Eu- ropean statesmen seriously relax the pro- tective system, as they are doing, if they continued to think that system the secret of national prosperity. Even in France, where the protectionists appeared a few ’ The Nation. | months ago to be carrying everything be- fore them, a most decided halt has been called. The first drafts of the new French tariff were enough to delight the heart of McKinley himself,and his French analogue, M. Méline, expounded the protectionist theory of increasing wealth by taxation with a sincerity and earnestness equal to the American’s. No pernicious dis- tinctions were to be allowed between raw materials and manufactured articles, and the great exporters were told that they would get along just as well with taxed wool and silk and cotton. But the hammering which the bill has had to take on its way through Chamber and Senate, the unanswerable assaults upon it by men like M. Léon Say, from the eco- nomic point of view, and by the protesting manufacturers and workingmen, from the practical standpoint, have knocked a good deal of the mischief out of it. All the pro- posed duties on raw materials have, we believe, either been abandoned or made up for by drawbacks to be paid to export- ers, so that the Minister of Commerce, M. Jules Roche, could lately say in the Senate: ‘* But a few months ago many voices were lifted up for the establishment of duties on raw materials. We have succeeded in getting that idea to be abandoned, in the interests of our national industries. ’?’ More than that, the immense value to France of her foreign trade has been fresh ly emphasized in the course of these tariff debates. In denial of the ignorant asser- tions of M. Dauphin and others that France had been marching straight to ruin through buying from other nations more than she sold them, careful statistics have been com piled which show that there has been a great advance in the value of both real and personal property during those fatal years when foreign commerce was en- couraged. Even in the case of the much- pitied agricultural interests, M. Alfred Neymarck has shown that the value of farming lands increased from 61 to 91 mil- liards of francs between 1852 and 1882, while the value of domestic animals in the same time advanced more than 100 per cent. And as bearing on the future policy of France in the matter of international commerce, it has been too much forgotten that her new tariff system, in one of its features, leaves the door open for a great enlargement of foreign trade. We refer, of course, to the device of a maximum and minimum column, the latter of which, with its low duties, will be declared to be in force in the case of countries offering adequate concessions, on their part, to French exports. The hope and expectation of the Gov- ernment in this particular were made en- tirely clear in the speech of the Minister of Commerce referred to above, which was delivered on November 25. After declar- ing that it was ‘‘an essential condition of | the existence of France to seek a foreign market, to make advances to the new coun- tries just entering upon civilization,” he [ Vol. 53, No. 1382 proceeded to make the following signifi- ‘ant statements: ‘*The Government does not hesitate to de- clare that it will very soon introduce a bill to regulate this question; its object will be to grant the minimum tariff to the countries with which we actually have treaties. We have not wished to proceed with surprises or unexpected strokes, or to leave in uncertainty the nations to which the minimum has been conceded. Still less have we wished it to be supposed that the rules governing our international relations were to be suddenly modified. ”’ A word should be added respecting the influence of these European commercial alliances and proposals on South American trade. Already it has been announced by the Indépendance Belge that Brazil and the Argentine Republic have taken steps to se- cure admission into the German-Austrian- Italian Commercial Union, or at least to obtain some of its benefits, as also to negotiate treaties of reciprocity with England. Such a course inevita- ble on their part considering the sub- stantial advantages to be gained in that way, and considering also how strong are the commercial and financial ties which bind them to Europe. It may be doubted, however, if the Brussels paper is right in saying that such measures are advocated as a means of retaliation upon France for her high tariff. It is true that there has been some discontent On October 27 President sent a special message to the Brazilian Con gress, calling attention, among = other things, to the tax of 100 cent. levied on Brazilian coffee in France. He thought that very unfair in view of the fact that the Brazilian duties on goods of French production did not exceed 40 per cent., and asked for authority to in- crease But France could easily obviate that objection by offering her minimum tariff in return for a proper equi valent, or even by making a special treaty, as Minister Roche said the Government would be ready to do in particular cases. At any rate, it is clear that European na- tions have not watched our reciprocity ne- gotiations with folded arms, but have put was on this score. Fonseca per those rates. themselves in a way to equal if not surpass any advantages we may have secured there- by in South American trade. The signifi- cant remarks of the German Chancellor on Friday leave no doubt that he considers the new commercial treaties a powerful weapon against our ‘‘ Pan-American policy,” as he called it. THE FINANCIAL CONDITION OF ITALY. toME, November 30, 1891. Your Italian correspondent, ‘‘ J. W. M.,’’ whose profound knowledge of Italian matters and intense sympathy with Italy are so well known to me that I am generally disposed to doubt my own views when they differ from hers, has given in the Nation of October 1 an historical summary of the financial condition of the kingdom, from which I have derived not a little instruction, and with which, as history, I am not competent or disposed to find the least fault. But in the examination of the present position I see certain facts which she seems to

Page 11

Dec. 24, 1891] have overlooked, and certain consequences which she has not anticipated. In all that she says of the progress of Italy I fully agree; in her eulogiums of the post-office management, as organization, I think has not said enough, for the theory of the whole depart ment is the most perfect I have ever come across, and the only drawback to the prac tice is that the operations are unreasonably she slow, and the employees, overworked and un derpaid, are provokingly tedious in their at tendance on the public, and take ten minutes to perform an operation which in would require but one. England But in compensation you never lose a registered letter or object of value intrusted to the post. Ihave continu ally to complain of the loss of books coming by post from England, but never when posted in Italy. The officials are courteous and obliging to the last degree, and they give themselves far more useless trouble than they cause the people who make use of the post. The country is still very much behind in sanitation, travelling fa cilities, comfort and cleanliness in the inns and minor hotels, but it is necessary to have known it thirty years ago, as did ‘‘J. W. M.”? and myself, to unlerstand the real progress made in almost all respects. In certain details of the financial review, however, your correspondent leaves the state- ment incomplete rather than incorrect, and as it has been my business lately to investigate the subject at some length, I propose to fill out, rather than correct, her generalization. The riscontrato of which she speaks as a success, had hardly been put to the test when she wrote, and was not in any case the binding affair she had supposed. It was a weak and ineffi cient plan for meeting the weakest point in Italian finances, the condition of legal tender in the notes of banks which have only a local recognition. For instance, there are six banks which have the right of issuing circulating notes, the Banca Nazionale, Banca Romana, Banca di Napoli, Banca di Sicilia, Banca Tosca- | trate, a sort of clearing The Nation. brought to liquidation, it would be bankrupt. | The other banks have dipped more or less in the illegal loans, and the amount is variously | stated at from 200,000,000 lire to 500,000,000, to | alarge extent if not entirely in the same condi of forms of real estate which cannot be realized the therefore, not good in point of law or of im tion immobile capital, 7. ¢., in) various on. The comparison with Barings is, portance; nobody was obliged to accept the Baring securities, and the Barings had violated no law; they had been unfortunate, and, to avert the consequence of their misfortune, the Government advised their being assisted to liquidate on terms favorable but safe to all concerned. ° The Italian Government, having called on the banks to put themselves in a condition of legality, they replied by proposing the riscon house, but it was only volunteered on trial for a period at the disere tion of the banks. The experiment has been tried now for three months, and, as I foresaw and foretold, only strengthens the position of the banks. The legal all over the kingdom, pays out the notes Banca Nazionale, which is of the Banca Romana instead of its own, and avoids responsibility. At the telegraphic office in Palermo, the other day, the officials refused to accept notes of the Banca Romana, and at | Catania the branch of the Banca Nazionale re na, and Banca Toscana di Credito; all the notes | being legal tender in the province in which each not in the others, the Nazionale alone being universal. These are forbidden by law to lend money on real estate or long-date securities; series is issued, but recoznized banks they are allowed to issue notes to three times the amount of their capital, and must havea metallic reserve of the same amount, though, when the enormous over-issue of the building crisis came on a few years ago, they increased their legal circulation from 1,100,000,000 frances to 1,500,000,000, as ‘* J. W. M."’ says, and to legalize this excess, the present Ministry in- creased the proportion to four to one of capital, the cash reserve being still one to three. he relation of the State to these banks is not, as your correspondent assumes, in the least like that of the English Government to the Barings. The Italian Government makes the notes of these six banks legal money, and If these banks prove rotten, all the circulating medium in Italy is worth just one-third of its face, sup posing the metallic reserves are all the law re quires, which I should want to have verified before I would trust it. we have no other currency. 3uta note of the Banca Romana, legal tender in Rome, is refused at Naples or Venice, because it can be refused, and because it is known that the Banca Romana has loaned, contrary to the law, 40,000,000 of lire on real estate which is not in all probabili- ty worth more than a small fraction of the loan, being houses unfinished or unsalable. Its reserve should be 23,000,000, and its outstanding fused to change the notes of the Romana which they had paid out over their counter only ten \- ASS a calculation | made two vears ago, ts not less than twenty millions sterling, and more recent researches by one of the principal embassies sh below than ab here, much interested in trade statistics w n that my estimate is rather ve the reality Italy is prospering and improving in almost every respect, and when we consider that she is scarcely thirty vears out of foreign bondage, and that evervthing bas had to be done, it must be admitted that she deserves all the praise she is likely te get even from het friends of the temper of “J. WOM W.J.8 THE VICTORIAN ENHIBIUPTION Lonpon, December 4, INV! Wren a Victorian was announ w the Tudor, Stuart, and Guelph hots held during the last throw winters in the New Gallery, its success that is t financim but as a show of genuine interest-——-seemel doubtful. The result is even more depresung than one’s expectations The Victorian period in many Ways has been as great as Chose which preceded it, but with its greatness the roval family has had littl to do, and unfortunately royalty is given the most conspicuous place i these exhibitions. Besides, it was thought o cessary to limit the time uUlustrated to the first fifty years of Victoria’s reign, and the men and women represented, with the exception of the members of the Queen's family, to thos wi days before, and, even worse, they refused to , : , P P 3 eee are no longer living. But the chief reason { accept the notes of the Romana, paid out at as : - 7 , , é the failure of the collection now exhibited in the | one wicket, for a draft on a distant city, when : c “ s : : : bh ; | New Gallery to rival its predecessors ts the fa | offered at another wicket. The riscontrato is | } ’ : that, while its scope is professadiv historic, the an absolute mockery and delusion. ‘ : ; ‘ om }; large properti n pRcrures ft es one to Gon The weakness of the financial position in | Sder it from the point. The dk , ; . . | Italy is not in the official finance, because, as | oradation of art luring the Vieto “J. W.M."" says, if the taxes must be paid rian era scarcely needed this new overpower they will be paid, and can be. The burden of | ing proof “1 i is exaccers ‘ | , . as the present taxation is exaggerated and howl | Lowas has been the English art standand ; ed over by the classes who ought to pay and | guring the last fifty odd years, there have been don’t, much more than by those who pay their | creat artists at work in England. and art just proportion. I have heard proprietors ad- | movements of no little import have been mit that they do not pay the quarter of the | garted The Pre-Rapha val. what | taxes the law imposes; very few incomes or es- | ever one may think of its real value, was im- | tates pay in the legal rate, and most of them | mensely interesting, and produced at least one are assessed at the half of their real value, many at a much smaller fraction. The tax | payers howl on principle, as if they were pay ing the full rates, and the assessors let them alone. It is safe to say that not a single pro fessional income in Italy is stated at much, if any, more than the half of its actuality. The interest on the debt will be paid and the ex penses of Government met; the shadow in the prospect is the condition of the banks, and the consequent solidity or the reverse of the circu notes are 70,000,000. If, therefore, the bank were | lating medium—we know nothing about these It is this, and not the possibility of Italian in Md and lowers the Italian rentes. There is no debt in Europe safer than the Italian, in my opinion, solvency, which raises the premium on g but no one is sure that the currency is secured against acrash. That gold is at only 3 per cent premium, under such circumstances, is greatly in favor of the solvency of the country One element which all the statistics leave out and t of the account, vy the omission include a constant element of error, is the gold brought into the country by the visitors. The trade statistics show that the imports exceed the ex and until the last few ports by yet the months, thirteen million pounds sterling, premium on gold, has never risen above a fraction of one per cent., and the value of property, as shown by the returns of taxation, increases at the rate of a milliard a year. The solution is in the gold of the tourist and foreign resident, which, by painter of distinction. Of late vears reaction against the conventions of the Royal Academy has led to the formation of the Glasgow School in Scotland, the New English Art Club in Londen. But, though one can trace the growth of sentimental, infantile story-telling a! from Landseer to Burton Barker, of what has of no sign in the Victorian Exhibition, since only been done in the actual world art there is the work of the portrait-painter is shown, and only the portraits of people of note—social or political, clerical or scientific, literary or ar tistic far the more conspicuous are portraits of the royal By greater number and the family or records of royal events. In the case of Tudors and Stuarts, and even of Guelphs, this fact Stuarts and Guelphs, whether because they really cared (which is doubtful in the case of the latter), or whether they wanted royally the was no drawback, since Tudors and very best to be had in art, as in jewels or wine, succeeded in drawing to their courts some of the most accomplished painters of their day Holbeins, Vandykes, and and Gainsboroughs were the glory of the last three exhibitions. But the Queen, ever since the beginning of her reign, and all her chil- dren in their turn, have shown a preference for the most commonplace and least artistic work. At home they have always patronized the Hayters and Friths; abroad they have found Leynoldses ' nothing better than a Van Angeli.

Page 12

ASG The result is that the from Windsor and Osborne, from Buckingham Pa- lace and Marlborough House, might be a col- lection from the Bayswater ‘‘ Terraces’’ and Paddington ‘‘Gardens’’ of the city man: they are essentially middle-class, or, to use the A paint- er must indeed be strong not to be discounte- nanced by royalty, and to paint the royal sitter as he really is. Holbein could stand the test: modern naturalists could not ask for bolder naturalism than his Henry VIII. Velasquez could still better, and it is amusing to con- trast his Philip with the Philip of other paint- ers of his time, of Rubens, for example, in the portrait at Munich. But lesser men in the royal presence always have fallen below their usual comn onplace, and have produced not portraits in the least true to life, but a sort of ‘‘touched-up’’ photographs. When Prin cess Louise sat to Mr. Richmond, who is cer- tainly better than Van Angeli, Richmond failed to give her portrait even that decorative quality which, with him, sometimes makes up for lack of realism. Caton Woodville is a clever black-and-white man; Sir Linton is not quite so petty and puerile as Frith, and yet both, in painting royal ceremo- nies, have become as wooden and lifeless and dull as the dullest painter of the early Victo- rian period. There is not one royal portrait that can lift the royal collection above its middle-class level. pictures sent Socialist’s favorite slang, bourgeois. James D. hor can it be argued that this is the fault, not of the royal family, but of the condition of the art of portrait-painting in the last three- quarters of the nineteenth century. Have not Whistler and Sargent been painting in Eng- land? Are not the Holls and Wattses now in the New Gallery infinitely prefer- able to the inanities of Van Angeli? And abroad, has not Salon, for the last thirty years or longer, given a far wider choice of good portrait-painters than the whole Conti- nent offered to the Tudors ? But the truth is, the reigning family do not like realism in por- traiture, do not like good work. every one knows, the Prince of Wales allowed Bastien-Lepage to paint him, but when the French artist showed him how worthy a de- scendant in appearance, if in nothing else, he is of Henry VIII., he scorned the portrait, which, needless to say, does not hang on the walls of the New Gallery. The Queen may be remembered by after generations as a good mother—never as a patron of art. every Once, as Outside the royal family, matters are just a shade better, though the improvement is not general or great enough to redeem the show from dulness—that is, artistically speaking. Sir Thomas Lawrence painted portraits of many men—the Duke of Wellington and Sir Robert Peel, to mention no others—who were prominent during the first half of Victoria’s reign; and, mannered and over-inclined to the ‘* pretty business ’’ as he was, he painted with a distinction never found in the canvases of the Hayters and Winterhalters, the Beecheys and Grants, who mark the lowest depths to which art has sunk in England. Coming down to a later period, one finds portraits by contempo- rary artists, by Holl and Ouless, Millais and Watts, Herkomer and Collier, which have been too recently exhibited in Royal Acade- mies and other picture-shows to call for special criticism, and which certainly are a marked advance upon the earlier abortions, Here and there, on a screen or in a corner, one comes upon a smaller portrait of some little art value, as, for instance, a sketch of his wife by Rossetti, and his small drawing of himself. , The Nation. In the catalogue there is a Degas, a water- color of Pellegrini (the ‘‘Ape’’ of Vanity Fair), but as yet [have not been able to find it in the Gallery. When all is said, however, the fact remains that in the exhibition there is but one great masterpiece which will live for all time, and which will be honored by future generations as we to-day honor the Holbeins and Vandykes, the Reynoldses and Gainsboroughs. This is Whistler's Carlyle, sent by the Glasgow Corpo- ration, who, now that their haggling over its price is at an end, are proud enough of being its owners. The press view in the New Gallery was held the very day that news came of the French Government’s purchase for the Luxem- bourg of the same master’s portrait of his mother, together with the report that their of- fer of £160 was accepted by him just after he had refused one from a private individual for £1,500; and those who know Mr. Whistler can well believe it. It was instructive, just as one of his greatest pictures was thus allowed to go out of the country, to see how the English treat those that remain. The Carlyle is skied in a corner of a gallery where the centres of honor are reserved for Landseer and Millais! One might almost fancy a purpose in this eccen- tricity of hanging; had the directors wished to characterize an age in which bad work has been the rule and the great exceptions have been uniformly ignored, they could not have been more successful. From the historical standpoint the exhibition is but slightly more satisfactory. Much of the history of Victoria’s reign is contemporary his- tory, and the principal figures in it are still alive, and, therefore, because of the limits set by the directors, excluded from the exhibition. How small a part royalty has had in public af- fairs of genuine importance is revealed in the royal pictures. The genius of the Victorian period has been domestic, as the British matron will tell you with complacent pride,and the can- vases Which represent royal events, with but few exceptions, reveal this domesticity. They are pic- tures of royal weddings and royal baptisms, as if marrying and giving in marriage and the perpe- tuation of the Hanoverian race had been the sole end and object of the royal house; and how fully these ambitions have been gratified is also commemorated in that awful group of the Queen and the royal family painted during the jubilee year. Otherwise, their only possible interest is as a record of fashions during a long period in which women took pleasure in mak- ing themselves hideous. The introduction to the catalogue reminds the visitor that there have been two large and thirteen small wars during the period illus- trated. But of these there is slight trace in the show, whose general character is most pacific, save in the cases full of Gordon relies. It is also strange that, though Victoria is the first Empress of India, and though the Eastern colonies have been extended during her reign, there is little, if anything, to suggest the fact; and this is the more to be regretted since a chance dagger here and a bit of embroidery there remind one that the East could have sup- plied the art element so sadly missing. The line of statesmen, beginning with Wellington and Peel and Lord Palmerston, and ending with Disraeli and John Bright, tells only half the story of the Victorian period, since Mr. Gladstone is absent and the Irish Home-Rule party without representatives. To attempt to give the political history of Great Britain dur- ing Victoria’s reign, and to omit the Lrishman, is indeed a case of the play of *‘ Hamlet *’ with Hamlet left cut. As Mr. Parnell, by his late [Vol. 53, No. 1382 death, has fulfilled one of the conditions for admission, and as his public life supplies the others, one would think a portrait of him might have been secured. When it comes to literature, there is less fault to be found, though in this department, too, one is conscious of incompleteness. All the fami- liar portraits of Thackeray and Dickens are here, and all interesting enough in their way, especially that one of Thackeray as a baby with his father and mother, reproduced three or four years ago in Scribner’s, and one of Dick- ens as Captain Bobadil; but, strangely enough, none are of any special merit as paintings. Here, too, are Wilkie Collins and Bulwer,in characteristic pointed shoes and long waving locks, and an unexpectedly proper and prim little George Borrow in high stock. Ma- caulay and Grote, Carlyle and Matthew Ar- nold, remind one of what has been done in a more serious branch of literature. Jeffrey of the Edinburgh Review seems out of his time away from the men whose reputations he made or unmade for a day, and Christopher North, even if he did not die until 1854, belongs prac- tically to an earlier period. To find portraits of these men hanging in the same room with those of Browning and Rossetti is the best re- minder of the many years the Queen’s reign has lasted, while the presence of the two lat- ter but emphasizes the absence of Tennyson and Swinburne, without Victorian poets are as incomplete as Victorian statesmen without Gladstone and Parnell. whom One of the greatest surprises the exhibition has in store is a little sentimental, simper- ing George Eliot, painted by D’Albert Durade (whoever he may be), and start- lingly unlike the better-known chalk draw- ing in the series by the elder Richmond, so much overrated in their day. With a face as strongly marked as George Eliot, Richmond could hardly efface ail character, but even his Charlotte Bronté and Mrs. Gaskell have much of the conventional Book-of-Beauty type then fashionable. Many of his celebrated contem- poraries are included in the series, which, how- ever, now commands but little interest. It is useless to go through a list of all the portraits. Hardly any men and women of fame or notoriety have been forgotten; too many nobodys have been remembered. A few eall for more attention than others: for exam- ple, in the group of artists there are a small sketch of Charles Keene, his clay pipe in his mouth, a water-color of Fred Walker by him- self, and three portraits of Turner, the first with his old-fashioned tall hat pulled well down over his eyes, an amusing contrast to that other, his own work, in which he is as beautiful as Sir Thomas Lawrence could have made him, and to the vigorous little sketch, by Linnell, of a middie-aged and not very striking- looking Turner. It is interesting, also, to have the famous Tractarian movement and what might be called the Rugbyite departure in the public schools recalled by portraits of Cardinal Newman and Thomas Arnold; while those of Faraday and Herschel, Darwin and Carpen- ter, George Stephenson and Lyell, with the models of loco:aotives and ocean steamers and of the Forth Bridge, explain anew the real reason for the failure of the Victorian exhibi- tion. To have illustrated truly the Victorian age, the show should have been one of ma- chines and scientific instruments and appli- ances, not of pictures, By far the most delightful part of the exhi- bition is the least conspicuous—the collection of autograph letters and manuscripts in the balcony. Many of the letters have been print-

Page 13

Dec 24, 1891] ed and are as well known as the portraits, but this does not detract from one’s pleasure in sec ing the originals. They have been carefully cha It is quite as it should be that letters from Browning, who was so promi nent a figure in London society, should be ac ceptances or refusals of invitations; that one from Mrs. Gaskell should be a stamped ac knowledgment for payment of the copyright of ‘Right at Last’; that Thackeray's should be opened at one of his illustrated pages, Cal verley’s at his adimission of a ‘lurking fond ness for absurdity.’’ But it is still more im possible to go through this list without de generating into a catalogue, since almost every notoriety and famous man and woman of the Victorian era is here again represented arranged, most of them showing very racteristic passages. from Disraeli to Gordon, from Capt. Mayne Reid to Dickens, from Charlotte Bronté to Miss Mu lock. There are fewer manuscripts, but these are well chosen. Rossetti’s Disraeli’s ‘Endymion’ (and manuscript it is!), Macaulay’s big sprawling journal, Dickens’s ‘Christmas Carol,’ Mrs. Browning’s ‘ Aurora Leigh,’ and Browning's far neater * Isolando ’—these give at least an idea of the delightful material which directors have been able to secure. of Relics have been principal features of these historical exhi bitions, and in a great measure account for their popularity with the sentimental Bri- tish public. There are many good Britons who will prize Disraeli’s walking-stick and spectacles and the precocioys art efforts of the infant Victoria more than anything else the show can offer them, unless it be the odds and ends in the Gordon cases. Fortunately, how ever, a large proportion of the relics are of Thackeray and Dickens—not merely their chairs and writing-desks, but their MSS. and notes and sketches; and only endure, but enjoy. As for the stamps and medals, the decorations and coins, gladly leaves them to the specialist. Design for official purposes has been as artless as the painting of royalties during the Victorian age. N. N. ‘* Rose Mary,’’ what a bulky There are relics, course. these one can not one Correspondence. THE HISTORICAL AMERICAN TION AT MADRID. EXHIBI To THE EpitTor oF THE NATION: Sirk: One of the interesting and in structive celebrations proposed for the year 1892 is the Spanish celebration, the chief fea- ture of which will be an exhibition at Madrid, termed the Historical the special object of which most Exhibition, to iliustrate primitive American life and the history of the period of discovery and conquest. American Is In selecting the prehistoric and early historic eras for illus tration, the Spaniards will make their own ex hibition complete in itself, without in the least competing with the Chicago Exhibition The plan of the exhibition is, within its limits, a very broad one, comprising five general divi sions, viz.: Prehistoric America, the Historic Period, Indian Industrial Arts, Cartography, Nautical Instruments, ete., and the Fine Arts and kindred subjects. Under Lof the head of historic America, plans, models, reproductions, drawings, ete., are solicited of ancient caves and caverns, and anything that may help to show the use of these primitive places as human Similar models, drawings, or pho- dwellings. } | } } ; and i clude models of The Nation. tographs are desired of American menhirs, lolmens, and mounds, as well as lacustrine | dwellings. All sorts of implements and ob ure desired, such as jects relating to this period stone Weapons, articles of bone aud horn, pet tery, ornaments, utensils of .bome, wood, stone, other materials, with fossil or animal bones throwing light on the archmwology of this time. Examples of all the a life American « es and periods of the be mtinent are wanted primitive as they can traced on In the historic period the objects desired in ancient American buildings architectural remains, plans, models, and draw of sculpture, bas-reliefs, architectural paintings, ings restored ts Examples of Tone nn and other forms of painted decoration form an other class. Under industrial art is included clothing and adornment of the aborigines and uncivilized Indians, with implements of war, | offensive and defensive Jewels of gold, sil ver, bone and ivery, pottery, household uten sils, and articles used in transportation by wa ter and land, constitute another division of this branch, while written decuments in native tongues, pictures and photographs of Indians } and effigies showing native costumes, models Indian and dwellings, Indian cramia, forma third division. The department of cartography includes maps, plans, charts, and drawings, and all that concerns ancient cartography, with models of vessels anterior to the voyage of Columbus, as well as those he himself used A section devoted to nautical instruments, with the idea of the maps in use at the period of discovery, whik illustrating instruments, charts and objects in personal use by Columbus and pic tures of the same are also desired. The fine arts department includes ancient architectural monuments, sculpture, puntings, the dis LTRLUISTI and artistic work following American coins, literary and scientitic publica tions, manuscripts, charts, and plans of al kinds from the discovery to the middle of tl eighteenth century. Most liberal inducements are offered ft tending exhibitors from -\merica The ext bition will be held in the new Library and Na tional Museum building in the Park Mad: which will be used for the tirst time f this purpose, the exhibition serving as a sort auguration of the structure, which has been a number of years in buildin, fed on September 12, IN. and will clos December 31st of the same year, thus pt

the Chicago exhibitiou, whi t is designed a measure, to supplement ALL objects, if s curely and properly packed, will be forwantled eratis to Madrid, and returned to the exhibitor free of all expense, the exhiiition not only bear ing the cost of transpertation, but aiso, when

desired, attending to the arrangement and dis play of the objects without any charge. Thos who desire special cases of their own may } vide them, and special buildings may also tx erected in the Park if the design is approved by the General Conimitt AM ot ts f he exhibition will be a texl ty f nt Spain if they are withdrawn at lose of the exhibition, but tw sw be allowed ufter the end of t x n lx e articles need be returned \ nternations ¥, proportionate to tl I roft ex! ters from different « tries and the importan f their exhibits, w examine the articles displaved and award tl prizes. These will consist of a first prize of honor, a gold medal, a silver medal, a bronze medal, and honorable mention, each medal be ing accompanied with a diploma

ASG The exhibition covers, of re, the entin mitinent, Gut t nseure its oo seth citizens of the | sired Ther American « mplets SUCCES thre Ve umd assistance of nite? Ntates is etpecially de m why Americans should both be interested in this exhibition ard take part init The conditions are liberal, the prizes aniple, and the time is especially conve nient to intending exhibitors at the Chicag exhibition, as objects mav be exhibited both at Madrid and at Chicag N ty of the exhibition its least erit ra v Ann ry historv has alwavs been a favorite t study among huropean s irs, | tos saf tosav that if this ext tion is oa «i tasit s plar 1. it will Ye Pluropenatis first | peort VY thev ha ul ft \ tiv America fein tts prlert ‘ \ ree ‘ i t su ver ute iis Dke lesired at Madrid, a st s ely be hoped that tl gr t t Spx shi p™ pole t pearta t ‘ bian celebrat ‘ t ‘ ' +4 hearty supy " arn ‘ lent . IA i } PINENI To tas Epi ew NA N Sit l 5 t i ‘ ‘ow enut t \ ‘ ~ wit fore t ss ‘ \r : “ than t thre " ‘ versitv of Ber It w lL think, Is fortuna F - - e ¢ a” that a st t st ‘ i i ‘ ' " t Xtens . \ ~ ~ { »l and . - ~N “ ‘ ¢ @ wats i i i t of thy wit rv at

Page 14

488 tion (pp. 181, 287, 447), the various pronuncia- tions of the word ‘* been ’’ have been discussed without any scientific statement being given of the genesis and relation of the various forms. Prof. Wheeler (‘ History of Language,’ p. 413) has hinted at the correct explana- tion. The ME. pronunciation of the word was (using phonetic spelling) bén. This close é had by 1550 (cf. Palsgrave, 1530, in Sweet’s HES. 8818; and Lowisch, p. 52) approached very nearly to 7, and had generally reached that point by 1700 (cf. HES. §8818-820, 814, 816). We thus have two strong, or stressed, forms, an earlier bén and a later bin. For each of these a weak form arose in unstressed positions, namely bén for bén, and bin for bin. When thus phonetically two forms arise that do not find use in distinguishing meaning (as, early ME. on ‘one’—‘cin’‘an’)or function(as, offadv. —of prep.), generally one of the two in time supplants the other (for example, of late ME. On before yvowels—6 before consonants, only the former, now written one, has survived). While both forms are still in use, a poet occa- sionally allows himself to employ in rime the weak form for the strong—the most innocent poetic license. The weak form bén early yielded to the strong form bén, which then be- came bin; bén survived and got the upper hand only dialectically, especially in some parts of America. The weak form bin, that was in time formed from bin, has become general in America, while in Great Britain it would seem that the strong form bin has pretty commonly held its own. I am not at all cer- tain that the distinction of weak and strong forms is not still made by many English- men, who suppose they always say bin be- cause that is the sound they hear when they pronounce the word by itself, and so with stress. I am puzzled by ‘‘ X.’s”’ statement that ‘* Pope makes been rhyme with sin about half the time.’? I can find only been-sin 151-823 (Globe ed.); against been-seen 85-149, been- queen 142-704, bet ween—been 253-289, seen—been 395-117. This proves nothing for an 7 pronun- ciation by Pope; for he has such undoubtedly imperfect rhymes as seen-within 287-55, 473-8, mean, spleen-within 298-143, seem-him 451-4. Lowell’s statement, referred to by ‘‘F. H.,”’ is: ‘* Ben for been, of which our dear Whittier is so fond, has the authority of Sackville, ‘Gam- mer Gurton’ (the work of a bishop), Chap- man, Dryden, and many more, though bin seems to have been the common form.’’ This I can only understand on the supposition that when Lowell wrote it, the pronunciation bin, despite his visits to England, had not attracted his attention, and, when he met in literature such rhymes as seen-been, he supposed them to be imperfect, just as he knew them to be when he found them in the writings of his neigh- bors (for example, in Holmes’s ‘*‘ The Island Ruin’’). We may justly be indignant that the writer of a study of the Rimes of Alexander Pope, which has just appeared in the publications of the Modern Language Association, did not pre- pare herself for her task by a study of the Eng- lish of the last century. She would then never have done so absurd a thing as to base her classifications on the ‘‘authority’’ of a dic- tionary of living English. Though she states that ‘‘many of the words that have found their way into the list of false rimes may, in Pope’s time, have been true,’’ and that ‘‘ this obsolete usage has in general been indicated in the lists, ’’ she gives us more than a dozen pages of ‘‘ false rimes,’’ and does not indicate a dozen such The Nation. words. Poor Pope! He evidently could not rime any better than Chaucer could spell. GEORGE HEMPL. ANN ARBOR, Micu., December 12, 1891. ‘**GOD BLESS THE MARK!”’ To THE Epitor OF THE NATION: Sir: Mr. Browne’s letter in No. 1379, re- garding the exclamation, ‘‘God bless the mark !"’ alludes to only two meanings of the word mark, namely, what an archer aims at, and the cross as a signature. He probably does not accept either of these meanings for the phrase in question; but he neither rejects them, nor does he propose any other definition. The true import of mark, which it seems of primary importance to ascertain, is plain from the following passage, which I think Mr. Browne would have quoted if it had occurred tohim. It countenances his supposition that the exclamation was often accompanied by making the sign of the cross. It also shows Shakspere, like Scripture, to be his own best interpreter : **Never mole, hare-lip, nor scar, Or mark prodigious, such as are Despised in nativity Shall upon their children be.” (Mid, N. Dream, v. 2.) ‘* Prodigious ’’ has here no reference to size, but signifies portentous or of ill-omen. In ages of faith, many such marks were recog- nized. Gonzalo, ina storm at sea, had great comfort from a fellow who had no drowning mark upon him, but whose complexion was a perfect gallows. One gallows-mark was a black mole, coffin-shaped, under the right ear. King John saw ‘‘a fellow by the hand of nature marked to do a deed of shame.’’ So in ‘*Lear,’’ iii., 4, a squinting eye is as ill- boding as a hare-lip. Many an abnormal form in physique is chronicled in folk-lore as attest- ing moral obliquity. One specimen in a thou- sand of its wise saws we have in the doggerel: ** Trust not the man whose eyebrows meet, For .n his heart you LI find d. ceit.” Mark, then, in the phrase now in hand, originally meant some physical peculiarity be- lieved to be ominous as to one’s character or destiny. against such a mark—that is, it was asked to be poured out just where it was most needed. After the word mark came to be used in a wider sense, as it naturally did, embracing all signs of ill-omen, a blessing was begged to avert the evil which those signs boded. It is nothing strange to pray that a blessing may descend on the mark—the very place which needs it most. When Shallow needed Falstaff to speak for him, he cried: ‘‘ God bless thy lungs, good Knight.’’ So Edgar, when there was a tempest in Lear’s mind, exclaimed, ‘* Bless thy five wits,’’ and again, he says, when Gloster’s eyes had been gouged out, *‘ Bless thy sweet eyes, they bleed.’’ This linguistic usage thickens other proofs which do demonstrate thinly the significance of an obscure saying, and may fortify Mr. Browne’s notion that it was wont to be em- phasized by the sign of the cross. ‘*God save the sample!’’ is the reading of the phrase as spoken by the Nurse to Juliet in the quarto of 1597. This word sample half disposed Grant White to think that mark, as found in other places, may mean such a mark as was made by a little girl’s needle upon a sampler. But when so disposed he was strange- ly oblivious of his own statements that the copy for the sole edition showing the word ‘‘ sample ”’ was obtained by surreptitious and inadequate means—notes taken at the theatre during rep- The divine blessing was invoked [Vol. 53, No. 1382 resentation, ete., and that great corruption is manifest on its face. James D. BUTLER. Mapisoy, Wis., December 16, 1891, ‘“A GENEALOGIST’S GRIEVANCE.” To THE Epitor oF THE NATION: Sir: Asa record-searcher and one well ac- quainted with Mr. Waters, I beg to demur to that part of Mrs. Vernona Smith’s letter to you of the 6th ult. in which she imputes ungentle- manly behavior to him. Iam quite sure Mr. Waters is incapable of any such behavior, and my opinion will be en- dorsed by all those who have, like myself, been honored by his friendship. If he omitted to acknowledge his indebtedness to Mrs. Smith for any hint she gave him, it was, I am con- vinced, done inadvertently and without any discourteous intention. Mrs, Smith’s incidental declaration that she is not a ‘* professional worker,’’ has been read here with some astonishment. WILLIAM BRIGG (B.A. Cantab.). Sr. ALBANS, HERTS, ENGLAND, December 8, 1891, MORE SPOILING OF THE ‘ BRITANNICA.’ To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: What is to be said of the two latest enterprises to make spoil of the ‘ Britannica ’ —always the poor ‘ Britannica’ !—one of which assumes the title of the ‘ Americanized Ency- clopedia Britannica,’ whiie the other boasts that, except the American copyright articles, it is ‘‘ word for word identical with the expen- sive Edinburgh edition’? ? Writing to parties who are putting the former upon the market to learn if it was authorized by the Messrs. Black, I received the reply: ‘The publishers of the original work (which would have cost vou [observe the arguinent!] 3150) are not expected to countenance that which is a revision of, and an improvement upon, their own, and which we are enabled [how ?!] to offer you at such a low price.”’ And when I put the same inquiry to the other parties, what reply did I receive ? ‘Our edition is not authorized by the Blacks of Edinburgh, nor does it need to be. The twenty-five American articles contained in the Edinburgh edition were the only part of that edition subject to copyright in the United States. As we have had those twenty-five ar- ticles rewritten by equally eminent American writers and brought up to date, we are able to lawfully [!] publish the entire remainder of the work word for word.” The thought of any court of honor, or of any lawfulness not concerned with a question of fine or fmprisonment, seems never to efter into this discussion. And what is to be said when leading divines, superintendents of schools, presidents of col- leges, mayors, and bankers, lend their names in praise of either enterprise ? Can we never hope to escape that confusion of ideas which fails to see common dishonesty as such if only it favors education and the poor man ? Respectfully yours, H. D. C. Eastport, Me., December 17, i891. Notes. THE correspondence of the poet Cowper has been collected and arranged, with annota- tions, by Thomas Wright, of Cowper School, Olney, Bucks, England, and is nearly ready Dee ae Re Sa

Page 15

esr mare Ic te © Bee sos

Dec 24, 1891] for publication. Its magnitude may be in ferred from the fact that about four hundred of the letters were not included by Southey in his edition, which, for the rest, was necessarily imperfect in respect to those it did contain. Mr. Wright desires to reéxamine every origi- nal if possible, and asks for the loan of any in private hands. ‘The Platform; Its Rise and Progress,’ by Henry Jephson, private secretary to Mr. For ster and Sir G. Trevelyan, beginning with the days when an open meeting for discussion of public affairs was condemned as scarcely less than overt treason, traces the slow growth of political speech-making and analyzes the ele ments in its development. The work will be published by Macmillan & Co. early in Janu ary. They have also nearly ready the * Brown ing Cyclopedia,’ which has been in prepara tion by Dr. Edward author of ‘ Browning’s Message to His Time.’ Frederick Warne & Co. announce ‘ Electri city up to Date for Light, Power, and Trac tion,’ by John B. Verity, and the new volume of ‘ Barker’s Facts and Figures for the Year 1882,’ edited by Thomas Whittaker. Berdoe, The Nation. and approved by the Boston school authorities, and will very certainly be gladly availed of by school-teachers all over the country. Nine out of the thirteen authors were natives of Massa | chusetts, while Webster and Longfellow and D.C. Heath & Co., Boston, will soon issue | the first four books of Goethe’s ‘ Dichtung und Wahrheit,’ edited by Prof. C. A. Buchheim. An illustrated ‘ Handbook of New York City ’ is in preparation by Moses King, Boston. Benj. R. Tucker, Boston, will shortly pub lish ‘ The Duchess of Powysland,’ a new novel by Grant Allen. Mr. Tucker's Weekly Bulle tin of Newspaper and Periodical Literature, by the way, has just been doubled in size, and will hereafter catalogue 650 articles in each issue. The three-volume edition of Carlyle’s ‘French Revolution,’ just issued by Porter & Coates, Philadelphia, is handsomely bound, and caleu lated to make a good appearance on the shelves. The typography is clear and open, but shows some shortcomings on the part of the proof- reader. accented, even in the index, but on the tissue fly-leaf facing the Abbé’s portrait, it is misac cented (‘* Siéyes’’), just as Anacharsis Clootz’s name is spelt to his face ** Cloatz. The por traits constitute the chief excuse for this edi tion. There are upwards of fifty of them, with a few plates of famous scenes. have been taken in selecting them, and they have as a whole very little authenticity. One dozen photogravures from original canvases of The name Sieyés uniformly goes un No great pains repute would have been worth these five dozen Still, the sense is gratified by these interspersed plates, and we mean no more than that they enhance but slightly the value of the fair print. haphazard copies of old prints. Another holiday reprint, in five volumes, is Mrs. Mary Cowden Clarke's ‘Girlhood of Shakspere’s Heroines’ (A. C. Armstrong & Son). It is forty years since this series began to be published in English, yet the venerable author is still living, and furnishes a cheery preface to the present edition. There have been partial American reprints —in 1857, 1867, 1871—but the present is the fullest of all, and it alone is copyrighted. The books are handy in size, well printed, and bound in simple good taste in blue cloth, and have every- thing to recommend them as gifts and as In the last volume is given a bibliography of the works of Mrs. Clarke and her husband. ‘Masterpieces of American Literature ’ (Houghton, Mifflin & Co.) has nothing of the appearance of ‘‘a text-book for reading in the first class of the grammar-schools,’’ and pro- perly so, since it is capable of giving pleasure in possessions. private reading. Nevertheless, it was ordered | John Boyle O'Reilly were adopted citizens of the same State, leaving only Irving wholly out of touch with it. have a like local restriction, but have been de The selections in some measure termined partly with reference to rhetorical exercise. The volume contains the whole of ‘Evangeline,’ of Bound,’ of the ‘Vision of Sir Launfal,’ of Lincoln's Gettys burg speech (in connection with Lowell's es * Snow say, ete.). There is a biographical sketch and other apparatus for each author. not limited in its useful is the * Directory of the Beneficent Organizations of Another ‘‘ notion *’ ness to ‘* the Hub” Charitable and Boston, together with Legal Suggestions, ete., prepared by the Associated Charities.’ The third edition is before us (Boston: Damrell & Upham). charitable endeavor in a great city, which can This is a conspectus of organized not fail to profit those who turn to it for sug gestion and example EF. P. Dutton & Co. send us * Waymarks,’ a collection of sermons by Bishop Potter, select ed by him from his occasional discourses of the past twenty years, the last being the one de livered at the consecration of Bishop Phillips Brooks. ‘Duplicate Whist.’ by John T. Mitchell (Chicago: A. C. MeClurg & Co gives an intelligent account of the variant forms of that increasingly popular form of the game, and adds, in an appendix, the code of rules adopt ed by the First American Whist Congress, together with a summary of the ** Leads and Inferences of Modern Whist The composite character of Hadrian's wall, which bounded the Roman dominion in Eng land, has long been a crux exciting no ltt! controversy among antiquarians, The wall itself stands with a fosse to the north: imine diately south of it is a military road, and south of this again there are successively a rampart of earth, another fosse with a mound on its southern side, and then another rampart. Va rious theories have from time to time been framed to explain this complex structure, and now, in a little volume entitled * Per Lineam Valli,” Mr. George Neilson of Glasgow has pr posed a new solution. He holds that the southern rampart and fosse were a temporary work to guard the laborers engaged in quarry- ing and building the wall, while th rampart was a subsequent device to serve as a defence against any roving or rebellious bands of Britons and to guard the military road. Mr Neilson argues his case ably and clearly, show ing abundant familiarity not only with the de tails of the ground traversed, but with the R man writers on the military art. He writes brightly and pleasantly, moreover, and invests his somewhat technical subject with interest even to the uninstructed W. Ostwald’s * Solutions,’ translated by M M. Pattison Muir (Longmans), comprises a por tion of Ostwald’s well-known treatise on Gene ral Chemistry, and embraces the whole sub ject of solution in its various aspects. The translation has been made with the approval and even supervision of the author. The work, like the parent treatise, is in all respects admirable; in fact, it would be difficult to point out a more suggestive treatment of any subject in the whole domain of chemistry Chemists who do not read German will certain ly urge the translation of the entire work. The ‘Embryology of the Sea Bass (Serranus

ASO atrurius ly Hent vv.W Ison, Is @ in =al piece of work from volume ix. of the Bulletin of the United States Fish © GS pages of text and 10 plates, tir MWHINISSion It includes figures of which illustrate the development from seg mentation up to within a few hours of hate! ing. From bis drawings Mr. Wilson would appear to have been very fortunate in han (ne thing mav be noticwd Wilson in discrediting the homology instituted by Fost dling his material in pASSing Mr and adopted by Whitman and others, between

the lateral line organs of fishes amd the Seite Organe “* of certain anneld Phe cdiscreditest homology is an important one to advocates a theory of vertebrate d ut t worn The Mosquitos ot is ft Vv sty themaelves the Misskites, are an [Indian m pete nhabat the coast of ura sa amdof nert! eastern Hot vou ‘ x with neg? . ‘ ts, a“ only upon the rivers and creeks of t) t do they show a purer | wl Many trave rm have regarded the { tlre * as a jargon or mixed hk tn but TRLINN De Ret f Herrenhut, who made t ‘ trv impenetrable woods amd swamps, a pertia nent home, succeeded in acquictng t latictie of the natives in its fulmess, and itm testably to form ai tir tint fa \ \ “ Judge | Adam of KR s ha ‘ sit literature of this langua ard t rr { his linguist study is the ‘ t sued, * Lang Mosquit tira ‘ Vows bulaire, Textes Paris } Mais wd forming vo XIN {tl \ Library The texts are largely taken from the Bible stories of the Herrenhut misionaries and are accompanied by a } transla as are also the tw Ves “ M \vin has been al te os The vooa airy is ich and fills 1 \ ages, and ’ rammar contains ft urna . several awtive verbs, w i i v rsona suffixes, and s a larg I tevin forts M. Ernest Havet } <i three « ns of the Pensces Pasca s “iu ss is wellas an abn t t s f schools taken from the firs , ‘ M. Louis Havet has just | rht t wW assical edi tien of this a i rine t he ast plete edit amd 4 shed by Dela grave The text ! has taken directly from the edit f ISS With a - iniy ved read ngs r notes a Ernest Havet’s cor lensed, with sor f the less important enes Périer is taken, with some critical ) i and the Port 160 edi

“is now added from the To the slowly growing list of books about pauppet-shows, M. Lemercier de Neuville, the inventor of the Pupaczi, has now added an other, * Histoire Aneedotique des Marionnettes Modernes ’ (Paris: Calmann Lévy; New York F. W. Christern M. Jules Claretie, the di rector of the Comédie-Francaise, contributes a pleasantly written preface, the most interest ing anecdote in which is to the effect that when M. Claretiec was in Spain last autumn, he went to a puppet-show, a quignol, a Punch-and Judy—that is to say, an entertainment the performers of which were animated by the human thumb and finger, and not set in motion | by wires from above; and here he was able to recognize the play these manual laborers per formed as a modification of Moliére’s ‘‘ Mon- M. de Neuville gives sieur de Pourceaugnac.’’

Page 16

490 a list of the hundred and more plays he has written for his own Pupazzi in the past thirty years; and two pages of diagrams enable us to understand the modifications and improve- ments he has introduced one after another. M. D. Jouaust, to whom credit is due as the publisher of many fine and some charming editions of books both old and new, has just retired from business in Paris. His publica- tions have been, one may say, invariably in good taste, and it may be expected that, now they are going out of print, they will increase in value. The Figaro takes leave of him with the high compliment that he has known that ‘* to illustrate a book is not to make an album of it.’’ This is high praise; but if every pub- lisher strove for it, what would become of the Christmas books ? R. Kukula and K. Triibner publish through the Triibner house of Strassburg a ‘‘ Jahrbuch der Universitiiten der Welt,’’ under the title of Minerva, costing about a dollar. This year- book contains a list of the personnel of all the universities and university libraries of the whole world, and will doubtless be found con- venient and useful by many. No. ev. of the excellent ‘‘Manuali Hoepli ’’ (Milan) is Dr. Antonio Restori’s brief history of Provencal literature (‘ Letteratura proven- vale’). To the many who, without being spe- cialists, are interested in the history of Euro- pean literatures, this little book will be wel- come. Scarcely any literature is so elusive as that of Provence. Experts have written on it in German, French, and English, but Diez is labored, Bartsch curt, Fauriel antiquated, and Meyer’s well-known article in the ‘ Encyclo- peedia Britannica’ scarcely more than a list of names. Dr. Restori, without attempting to give the result of original investigation, pre- sents an orderly and accurate survey of the whole field, with an index and good biblio- graphical notes. The committee appointed by the Government of Barbados to report upon the Records of that old English colony have adopted a suggestion made by Mr. Hawtayne, C.M.G., of British Guiana, that the Record Office in London should be asked to undertake the sorting, calendaring, etc., of the old papers which have been put away higgledy-piggledy, into some twenty tin boxes, in hopeless confusion. The Colonial Secretary of the Island, Mr. Knollys, C.M.G.,who is chairman of the committee, has accordingly written to the Secretary of the Pub- lic Record Office, asking whether the skilled staff of that Department could be employed upon the proposed work. This cannot but be good news to the numerous persons in the United States and in Great Britain whose fa- milies have in past times been settled in Little England, as the islanders sometimes affection- ately call Barbados. Among the English officials whose connec- tion with the public service will probably ter- minate on the last day of this year, in conse- quence of the operation of the age clauses of the Order in Council, there are some whose names are familiar on this side of the Atlantic. Sir Edward Hertslet, the Librarian of the Foreign Office, whose volumes of Treaties are known the world over, will, after more than fifty years’ service, take repose at his home at Rich- mond, Surrey. It is also probable that Mr. Noel Sainsbury of the Public Record Office will sever his official connection. As the editor of those admirable Calendars of the Colonial Series of State Papers, Mr. Sainsbury has raised his own monument. Literary workers will miss him sadly, for he will take with him stores of information that have been gathered , | The Nation. through years of loving work upon his special subject. ‘* FF. M.”? writes to us from Hartford, apro- pos of a correspondent’s recent statement, in these columns, that Rossetti’s translation of Dante’s Francesca passage is not included in his collected poems, that it is included in at least two cheap ‘‘ pirated ’’ editions, ‘‘ one imprinted ‘Hurst & Co., New York,’ which I have owned for several years, and the other issued by the John W. Lovell Co., more recently. As both these are manifestly reprints of cost- lier foreign editions, the fragment must be in- cluded in at least one of those.’’ The sensitiveness of the Russian Government respecting the appearance of needing outside aid in its terrible famine crisis—its suspicious- ness, too, and unfriendliness to organized relief ona large scale—combined with the distrust which foreigners must naturally feel of Rus- sian officials into whose hands their contribu- tions must fall, suggest Count L. N. Tolstoi as the proper recipient of such contributions from the benevolent. He is already busy in the work, he knows the peasants and their ways, and has their love and confidence. There is probably no man in Russia with whom the Government is less likely to interfere. His wife has written to the newspapers to suggest this way, and says that every kopeck so re- ceived will be used directly to feed the poor in the kitchens which her husband is setting up. His address is: Khamovyniki 15, Moscow. A reader of the Nation obligingly points out an obvious error on p. 431 (col. ii., line 15 from bottom), where ‘‘ 1893’? stands:for ‘‘ 1794.’’ The sentence in which it occurs was a mere repetition of one above, but the proof-reader nodded. —Mr. Jonathan Scott Hartley, N.A.,S.A.A., who was for many years the instructor in anatomy of the Art Students’ League, has pre- pared from his lectures a small handbook for art-students, called ‘ Anatomy in Art,’ which may be had of the author, at No. 145 West Fifty-fifth Street. Such treatises on this sub- ject as have hitherto been published have very generally had two faults: they have been written by surgeons rather than artists, and have been burdened by a mass of detail which is practically useless to the artist and only con- fusing to the student; and they have been too costly for the proverbially slim purses of art-students. This book is written by a professional sculptor of standing, who has omitted much useless and cumbering informa- tion, and confined himself to the descrip- tion of those bones and muscles which affect the surface appearance and are, therefore, ne- cessary to be known, and it is published at a reasonable price. We do not think the ideal book on anatomy for art-students has yet been written. In that book not only the descrip- tions but the plates should be confined to the few great fundamental truths of the figure. The plates should be rather diagrams than de- tailed drawings. Such a book is to be desired, but, in the meantime, Mr. Hartley’s book is a step in the right direction, and we know of no- thing better at present existing. The plates are reproduced from Fau’s costly work, and are supplemented with drawings from Scha- dow’s work on ‘ Proportion,’ and with repro- ductions from photographs of the living model in action. Mr. Hartley has added a_ short treatise on ‘*The Art of Modelling,’’ which his great practical knowledge should make very useful to beginners. —The little tract by Mr. E. C. Clark, Regius Professor of Civil Law, entitled ‘Greek and [Vol. 53, No. 1382 Other Studies at Cambridge’ (Cambridge: Macmillan & Bowes), reminds us that Oxford and Cambridge are definitely confronted with the Greek problem, that is to say, the question whether students shall be admitted and take their degree without Greek, substituting some equivalent in the modern languages. The question was formally raised about a year ago by the teachers of the preparatory schools; and it was to come before the University of Cambridge in the month of October. A great hue and cry was started at once in the Times and the magazines. The Saturday Re- view may be taken to represent the irrecon- cilables who will not yield an inch to the Philistines. It is true the ‘‘ Philistines’ are, in this case, a large number of University graduates who, if they know anything, ought to know their classics; and this fact has been pointed out in a sober and moderate article in the October Contemporary Review, written by Mr. J. E. C. Welldon, Headmaster of Har- row. Mr. Welldon himself, if his initials do not mislead us, is a translator of Aristotle’s ‘Politics’; and if that is the case, he must bea peculiarly hardened Philistine, who has re- sisted abundant means of grace. Mr. Welldon unfolds the necessities which lay at the bottom of the teachers’ appeal—the multiplicity of subjects created by modern methods and dis- coveries, and the pressure which these bring to bear on both schools and universities; and again the significant fact that of all the boys attending the public schools in England, only one-half at present study Greek at all. The other half are turned away from the doors of the universities, though many desire to enter, but cannot spare the time for the ‘‘open sesame ’’ of Greek. To this class the Saturday Review answers, ‘‘ If you don’t like the terms of the universities, stay away; but don’t try to corrupt and debase their methods. ’’ —This stanch position, too, is the one Mr. Freeman takes in a reply to Mr. Welldon just published in the Contemporary Review. Mr. Freeman has made as good use of his Greek as any man alive; and his words are very weighty. He is, in fact, the Achilles of the conflict; and the boys of Harrow must feel that no merely mortal schoolmaster can stand before him. For Mr. Freeman insists ‘‘ not that Greek shall be thrown aside, but that it shall be better taught.’? With that frankness which is his peculiar gift, if not his grace, he even goes so far as to say that the headmasters in the public schools teach Greek very badly. He wants them to teach it ‘‘ scientifically, that is, rationally and easily.’’ His specific for this is to make the boys acquainted as early as pos- sible with Grimm’s law, and to show them from the very beginning of their study the relations and identities of kindred words in the Greek and in modern languages. He thinks that this method will brighten the path even of ‘‘ Passmen,’’ and will ease their painful career. Every one who has a word to say ad- mits that the ‘‘ Passmen’’ are in a very bad way; that their taste of the Pierian Spring is the merest bubble. It may be the ‘‘ symbol and badge of an educated man,’’ but it is far from being the ‘‘ roof and crown of a liberal education.’’ It is this fact, admitted by every one, which induces Prof. Clark to take a mid- dle position in the controversy. He, too, is an ‘*old classical man,’’ a lover of Greek, who would not part with his Greek for any modern language. He is disposed to smile at the holy zeal of those who would save the ‘‘ pass ”’ course as a bulwark of sound learning. He would prefer to make it a real bulwark if

Page 17

Dec 24, 1891] possible; and, in default of that, to substitute some genuine subject in modern languages. Like Prof. Goodwin, he believes heartily in the collegiate functions of the University. But he has more faith than Prof. Goodwin in the possibilities of the ‘‘ Cottagers ’’—that large University is to have a good time and plenty of athletics, under a certain amount of moral restraint.’’ He has even a good word to say for the outcome of their taste for sports. He has a humane faith that, if the University will only bestir itself, it will find the means of awakening and appealing to the dormant talents of these Bounderbys of the educational world. —Last comes an eloquent pamphlet of fifty- two pages, by Mr. J. K. Stephen, M.A. (Cam- bridge: Macmillan & Bowes), which defends compulsory Greek from all points of view, and which is chiefly valuable because Mr. Stephen offers himself as an example of a class of men who, if alternatives had been permitted in his day, would never have tasted Greek, and would therefore, by his own account, have lost a great boon and blessing. How thorough- going is his sense of this blessing may be seen from the following confession: ‘*T have said that I am not, and never was, never shall be, and never should have been a Greek scholar. But I began Greek before I was ten, and did not leave off studying it daily during term time until I was nearly twenty. I am afraid to reckon up the time which I must have devoted to reading Greek, and endeavor ing to master the rudiments of Greek gram- mar. I think it highly probable that I have forgotten more Greek than I remember. | cannot point to any practical or pecuniary ad- vantage derived by me directly from the study of Greek. But I can honestly say that I do not regret a single hour of those which I spent in the study of the language, nor is there any sort of knowledge which I would rather have im bibed than even that part of my boyish know ledge of Greek which I have forgotten.”’ It is evident that Mr. Stephen is under the spell and cannot be argued with. But his en thusiasm, which Mr. Charles Francis Adams would call fetishism, must be shared by a large number of University men who are not professional scholars. This is proved by the decisive vote which October The assemblage was the largest ever known in the Senate Hall of Cambridge, and the majori ty against considering an alternative for Greek was 525 to 185. This ‘‘latest Marathon”’ was a triumph beyond the dreams of the classical men. It declares emphatically that, for some time to come, those who covet the luxury of a degree from Cambridge (or Ox ford) must get some tincture of Greek, and must put up with the occasional niences of acquiring it. Mr. Freeman’s com- plaint of badly taught Greek is probably true of England, and is much more true of the larger part of the United States. But the minor Greek course in English universities is indefensibly weak, and would probably be strengthened by being forced to compete with any solid alternative in modern subjects. There is nothing to be said for a subject which is superficially acquired and thoroughly for- gotten. The movement was, therefore, not an assault on Greek culture; it was in the hands of the friends of the humanities. In our own country the corresponding movement was in the hands of the Goths and Vandals—the class who never knew the language and its histori cal position, or the class of whom it might be 29. was taken inconve said, éxdvyor wSar. —A correspondent writes to us from London: ‘*The exhibitions of the New English Art

The Nation. Club are always the best worth going to in London, and this year its members have de cided to give a winter as well as a summer show. The result, as one sees it now in the Dudley Gallery in Piccadilly, justifies their de cision. However, it must be acknowledged that the great value of the present collection : 7‘ bis | depends upon two large studie v Sargent class who think that ‘‘ the raison d’étre of the | “SP*™ pon two large studies by Sargent, who belongs to the Club, and three canvases which come from outside—by Degas and Monet, who have been accepted as masters by the group of men calling themselves London Im pressionists. Not another show in London just now can produce anything to rival these fine pictures. That which makes Mr Sargent’s contributions of special interest is the contrast they present one to the other, being striking jaadiaiees of the scope of his power, which his critics as a rule declare limit ed. He has been told again and again that he could not finish a picture if he wanted to, and now, by way of giving the lie to all these critics, he has sent to the Dud ley Gallery a study of the nude dangerous ly academic in its finish, but showing a knowledge of drawing and modelling sel dom surpassed. This finish, though his ad mirers do not care for too many examples of it, is appropriate enough in the painting of still life. But when it comes to an impression of movement, as in the ‘Javanese Dancer.’ then Mr. Sargent returns to the methods which he has long since made familiar, and his dancer has all the vitalitv and vigor, the actu ality and go, of his *‘Carmencita.” It is a very powerful impression and very tine in color, and, unfortunately for the other members of the Club, their work cannot well stand compa rison with it. It rare a Deg in London that his study of ballet-girls is : event in the London art world. That which gives it a special interest is that it was begun as a black-and-white drawing for the J//ustraf ed News, but the editor, heedful of the morals of his readers, would have none of it, and then Degas worked it over in oils and pastels, caring everything for the artistic effect produced, nothing for the means employed. Monet has been oftener seen and more successfully copied But the fact that these two canvases are lent by Mr. Sargent will explain at once that they are not among his least distinguished. If th other exhibitors cannot yet rival-the work of Sargent, Degas, and Monet, that thev take it asa model is at least a hopeful sign in a coun try which believes in the Royal Academy and accepts the colored supplement of the * Christ mas Annual’ for its standard of art Is sO to se A is

NEW ENGLAND COLONIAL FURNITURE The Colonial Furniture of New England: A Study of the Domestic Furniture in Use in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries By Irving Whitall Lyon, M.D... m the Connecticut Historical Soci illustrated Boston: Houghten, Co. Svo, pp. 285 ember of ty Fully Mifflin & ISO}. v and wiselv, en Dr. Lyon has, both mixtest! titled this ‘*study,** because, while it is a most important contribution to our knowledge of it not mates in his preface, first collecting old furniture, then the wish to know large and beautiful volume a the topics As he came the discussed, is exhaustive desire of more of the history and value of his specimens, lastly a willingness to assist others by placing He has has pursued his knowledge in a perma rm certainly done admirable w the best method, and will remain a pi the field, whoever else m treat more fully of some portions which he has oneer in ay come forward to passed over lightly To acquire any thorough acqus with the origin, age, of New England isa very difficult or merit of the older furniture t hing. In the first place, such furniture rarely bears up

on it any exact date; secondly, the material is largely the same as that loved in Europe; thirdly, the patterns are necessarily European ; and lastiv, for the past ten vears the fashion old furniture has been able demand for genuine largely met by_direct. importations from for- ed ‘The Gentleman’s and Cabinet-maker’s Di | author sh

491 eign countries. The result is, that the collee tor must still be mainly guided by the appear ance of the article, and especially by the place where it is found, in order to decide when and where it was manufacturad in colonial New England. Dr. Lyon has had the great ad vantage of being an early collector in the pro ductive region of Connecticut. He has consult ed and compared the acquisitions of a kindred collector in Massachusetts, and he is thus able to classifv specimens and to assign an approxi mate age to many of the more prominent styles He has also made a most careft nvestivation into the inventories on record in Boston and Hartford, and into the advertisements of deal ers in furniture during the eighteenth century

with results of which we shall speak later As to extraneous evidence as to the age of certain pieces of furniture, little can be f Family tradition is verv unreliable, or at best can hardly extend bevond a century with n h precision. Mention in wills and invent though of the highest value in showing the amount and kind of fur re in tse 1 et generation since the settlement of tl trv rarely serves to identify t x n = Dr. Lvon cites a chest dated in 1608, and has seen a few others of a ttt ul pert \ few desks and bureaus ma s scribed the one at which we w has a secret awe on the sid f which is written Wim. Patten his Desk Made by Wm. Danforth In the vear 7H. *’ Then, in anotl hand and k Josa. Patten His Desk. G 1 to him bvw his Father the Year IS) Rut chairs, tables and side- boards affornl few te tat s to the pen of the seribt ~ me v ast _ te ’ ‘ < ‘ ‘ that prime black .w ¢ amd ft siblw hick Vv. ar the onlv word Kelly } stinetive in New E Na ind r } st ik as Dr Ly states is naturally several shad larker than tl American, but ag : nt mav render this ! tain fest Aca t T st 1 word for expensis rnit has been, for more than a century suhoganv, which, being ‘ rn ev . \, t} sy ix N = 1 ‘ ‘ ¢ mechat I I.v nas lag at fav Ve + ™ | me " . } fa e¢ at black walnut was we bv " t-makers Bost Th that f TH) to LTA it was extensive us In Fngzl j Virginia wal t vas advertisad in 17 When. a few Vers ay ti i tal 1 ~ 1 bev the G ernor and Coun f Massachusetts was ce posited the Old State House, it was found that its frame was made of black walnut. Al though the tradit vas strong that this table was in use before the Revolution, the cabinet maker was in doubt because the frame was made of black walnut. He thought that this was a modern use of the wood, until research showed the fact, which Dr. Lyon emphasizes that, between 1740 and 1760, black walnut was the wood most in vogue As to mahogany, our ws that it was in use in London in T24, but it was for sale in Philadelphia in 1708 } and in use for furniture in Boston in 1782. Thirdly, as to patterns anddesigns: it seems to be past doubt that no distinctive style has ever originated in New England, at least dur The first emigrants furniture of ing the colonial period them During the period of our de brought with or less English make. more | pendence upon England she furnished the fash | ions and a certain amount of the articles, and our workmen naturally copied their English models. Dr. Lyon points out that the English | designer, Chippendale, whose name is so often taken in vain by the dealer of to-day, publish

Page 18

492 rector ’ in 1754, and that his plates were doubt- less used by our joiners. Yet his name does not occur in connection with any furniture here, and the attribution of this style to him is very, very modern. In 1787 Heppelwhite pub- lished in London designs for ‘ Secretaries and Bookcases’; in 1794 Sheraton published ‘ The Cabinet-maker and Upholsterer’s Drawing- Book.’ These guides are, therefore, compara- tively modern, leaving a century and a half preceding, during which American joiners were producing furniture. One thing is certain: our ancestors brought with them the tools and the knowledge for du- plicating any work which they had seen at home. They found here at their very doors an unlimited supply of all kinds of wood free to all. They developed the art of working in wood in all its main branches, and ‘‘ whittling ’’ be- came a Yankee specialty. The stone cottages of England were here superseded by houses of wood, and ship-building became one of the main industries of New England. We cannot doubt that cabinet - making took root here early, and the wonder is not that so much re- mains, but that so much has disappeared. Only two explanations are possible: one, that pine was largely used and supplied all tempo- rary wants; the other, that the ever-varying moods of fashion have caused the destruction of things no longer in vogue. We know that our principal houses, churches, and public buildings were designed from the best pub- lished authorities, and we may be sure that English fashions in furniture were rapidly transmitted hither. But much must have been left to the individual taste of the workman, and the variations, within certain limits, seem to have been endless. In fact, the one disap- pointment which the reader will have in Dr. Lyon’s book is, that his numerous and excel- lent illustrations will rarely give exactly the same form of desk, side-board, or chair which may be under examination. To return to the details of the volume: Dr. Lyon treats specifically of chests, cupboards, chests of drawers, desks, chairs, tables, and Receptacles are naturally divided into these classes, according to use, viz.: for hold- ing clothing, for table utensils and ornaments, The simplest piece bureau, clocks. and for books or writing. of furniture is the chest, an article of great antiquity, and many such boxes doubtless were brought over by the first colonists. Then chests were made with one or two drawers, e.g., ‘the chest with a drawer” mentioned in the inventory of the Rev. Nathaniel Rogers of Ipswich, in 1655, cited by Dr. Lyon as the earliest date known to him. The citations and illustrations of chests in this volume leave no- thing to be desired. To cupboards much attention is given, and our author has traced out the varieties with much patience and ingenuity. The examples figured are very interesting, and do full justice to what was the main pride of the halls of our richer citizens. Chests of drawers, bureaus, and dressing-tables are described in detail, and due note is made of the varieties. Chests of drawers with short legs were superseded by those with long legs, and these again become indistinguishable from tables with drawers. Desks in the same way begin with a mere chest with a sloping lid, a portable appliance to be placed on a table. Then legs were added, drawers appended, and the interior arranged with pigeonholes and drawers either obvious or secret. Then the bookcase was placed on top, and the secretary became a well-known piece of furniture. The department of chairs would require a The Nation. book to itself, if every variety should be re- corded. Dr. Lyon gives some beautiful speci- mens and notices many interesting facts. The earliest chairs seem to be of simple, massive forms. The legs are square, or simply orna- mented by round portions, the backs mode- rately high, the seats of leather, cloth, or rushes. High-backed and elaborately carved chairs of course occur more rarely, and bandy- legs seem to have been taken from Holland to England by William of Orange. The well- known claw-foot holding a ball is said to be primarily Chinese. Dr. Lyon finds ‘* 6 crow- foot chairs’’ in the inventory of Benjamin Ivory of Boston in 1737. His illustrations and citations rather point to the conclusion that from 1650 to 1750 the form of chairs was simple, whether in square frames or round, but that the so-called ‘* Chippendale ’’ style reached us by the middle of the last century, and thenceforward the open-backed, airy, and elegant forms which characterize this mode were adopted by our artisans. Cane chairs, we are surprised to notice, are mentioned in Boston in 1689, while the earliest mention in England is only 1679. Windsor chairs appear in New York in 1758 and in Philadelphia in 1736. In figure 74 we have a specimen of a rocking-chair, the only one shown. In view of the fact that rocking-chairs are now called ‘‘American chairs’’ abroad, we wish the author had given more facts in regard to the invention of this form, Certain- ly rocking-chairs exist which date from colo- nial times as to the main portion, but rockers could of course be added at any time. Little is said about sofas or settees, though figure 81 displays a charming ‘‘ double chair ’’ which deserves to be copied. Tables are discussed at full length, but beds not at all. We hardly understand the omis- sion of beds, since these were articles of large size and cost, constructed in many styles, and are now indispensable in fitting out a ‘*colo- nial’’ chamber. We hope that Dr. Lyon in- tends to write a special book on that subject, or a special chapter in his next edition. Finally, much information is given about clocks. The earliest were hung from the wall and were moved by a chain and weight, and possibly a few spring clocks were brought here. But about 1690 the tall pendulum clocks were produced, costing much more than the others, and these are found on our inventories. So many persons are specially interested in old clocks that this chapter of Dr. Lyon’s work will be widely appreciated. We have purposely refrained from making many extracts from this book, holding it to be unfair to the author to give ina brief state- ment facts which have cost him so much time and labor. It is a storehouse for the anti- quary, and, like Weeden’s ‘ Economic and So- cial History of New England,’ it shows what valuable information can be gleaned from the volumes of inventories in our older probate courts. Dr. Lyon’s success suggests that some central historical society might well undertake the collection of photographs of articles of furniture of established antiquity, to be for- tified by the evidence in each case. The glori- ous army of *‘ Kodak fiends ’’ might here be of great service, and a collection thus made would be of immense service in settling points which no one observer can fully reach. As it is, we do not doubt that the hearty welcome already given to Dr. Lyon’s book will renew the popular interest in the study of the domes- tic architecture of colonial times. [ Vol. 53, No. 1382 GUSTAVE DORE. Life of Gustave Doré. With 138 illustrations from original drawings by Doré. By the late Blanchard Jerrold. London: W. H. Allen & Co. Large 8vo, pp. viii, 415. It is now nine years since Gustave Doré died. He was an officer of the Legion of Honor, had attained considerable wealth, and was proba- bly more widely known than any other artist cf his day. His name was a household word in two continents. Yet he died a disappointed and embittered man, and is proclaimed by his friends as a neglected and misunderstood genius. He was known the world over as the most astonishingly prolific illustrator of books that has ever lived; he wished to be known in France as a great painter and a great sculptor, and because the artists and critics of France never seriously recognized his claims to this glory, he seems to have become a victim of the mania of persecution, and his naturally sunny nature was over-clouded with moroseness and suspicion. No man has been more extrava- gantly lauded or more extravagantly con- demned. Hailed by some as the emulator and equal of the great names of the Italian Renais- sance, and considered a great moral force—a ‘*preacher painter ’’—by others he has been denounced as ‘‘ designer in chief to the devil,”’ and described as a man wallowing in all foul- ness and horror, a sort of demon of frightful power. Both these extreme judgments are English. The late Blanchard Jerrold, an inti- mate friend and collaborator of the artist, takes, in the volume before us, the first view. Mr. Ruskin and Mr. Hamerton have taken the second. Doré’s own countrymen have never accepted either. Just where, between them, the truth lies, as we see it, we shall endeavor to show in this article. The main facts of Doré’s life may be dismiss- ed very briefly. He was born with a caul on the 6th of January, 1832, in the Rue Bleue at Strasbourg, near the Cathedral. About 1841 his father removed to Bourg, in the Department of Ain, where he was Chief Government Engineer of the Department. These two residences of the young artist are supposed to account for the mastery of Gothic architecture and of moun- tain scenery which his admirers find in his ma- ture work. He showed very early in life a pas- sion for drawing, and, as a small child, had always a pencil in his hand, which he begged to have ‘‘sharpened at both ends,’’ that he might work longer without interruption. His father intended him for an engineer, but he was determined from the first to be an artist. He was of a gay and jovial disposition, given to pranks and practical jokes, and of an athle- tic temperament. Théophile Gautier after- wards called him a ‘‘gamin de génie.’’ In 1847, when he was fifteen years old, being in Paris with his parents, he called upon Philip- pon, the publisher, and showed him some of his sketches. M. Philippon looked at them and sent a letter to Doré’s parents persuading them to allow the boy to remain in Paris, and promis- ing them to begin using his work at once and to pay for it. Thus, without any study of art whatever, be began his career, and in a few years had produced a prodigious quantity of work, and was a celebrated man before he yas twenty. No one knows how many draw- ings he made. He ‘lived like an Arab,’’ worked early and late, and with astonishing rapidity made thousands of drawings for the comic papers, besides early beginning the pub- lication of independent books. One estimate, which Mr. Jerrold thinks excessive, credits him with having published 40,000 draw-

Page 19

Dec. 24, 1891] ings before he forty! Mr. Jerrold himself reckons 266 drawings done in one year. His ‘Labors of Hercules ’ was brought out in 1848, he was sixteen, and before he was twenty-seven he had published was when his * Holy Russia,’ his ‘ Wandering Jew,’ his illustrations to Balzaec’s ‘ Contes Drola tiques,’ to Rabelais, and many other authors. His best work was done at an age when most artists are painfully acquiring the rudiments of their art. We all know the books that fol lowed. Meanwhile, he was determined to be known as a great painter, and, while flooding the market with his countless illustrations, was working at great canvases of Biblical subjects, which, though the French would not accept them, were hugely admired in the Doré Gallery in London. Later he tried sculpture also, and his last work was a monument to Alexandre Dumas, which he made at his own expense and presented to the city of Paris. He died in the beginning of the year 1883, worn out with ex- cessive production—a great name, but an un satisfied man. Mr. Jerrold has divided his book into parts, dealing first with Doré the illustrator, and then with Doré the painter and sculptor. It is an eminently natural arrangement, and, two in our effort to arrive at Doreé’s true position in art, we cannot do better than to follow it. Doré’s earliest work was frankly that of a caricaturist. and a certain extravagant imagination, and caricature was his inevitable field. however, as Mr. Jerrold himself remarks, ** a caricaturist who seldom raises a laugh.*’ Not hearty fun, still less delicate humor, was his. He had a quick eye, no training, He was, In the higher qualities of caricature his contem poraries Daumier and Gavarni were vastly his superiors. An exuberance of grotesque fancy and a recklessness of exaggeration were his His earlier work, up to and to many minds it iseven painful—but it is unmis takably caricature of a dashing, savage sort. To our mind it remains his best work and that by which he is most likely to live. At least it is the work that formed him and fixed his charac- teristics, and an understanding of it tial to any judgment of him. dominant notes, including the Rabelais, is not really funny is essen The qualities and the defects of his later work—that which is most praised and most blamed in his produc tion—are inherent in the work of this period, and are best explained by a reference to the latter. Take, for instance, what has been denounce ed as his love of horrors and of foulness, his de He is scored for this as if he were one of that modern French with Regnault, who have revelled in the realistic presentation light in blood and massacre. school, beginning, perhaps, of executions and battles, and have sought to effect by sheer sensationalism what they could not by gentler means. It is surprising that his critics have not seen that Doré’s battles are always, even to the end, the battles of a cari ecaturist. His decapitated trunks, cloven heads, smoking hearts, arms. still fighting though severed from their bodies, are simply a debauch of grim humor. There is never the slightest attempt to realize carnage—only to convey, by the caricaturist’s exaggeration, an idea of colossally impossible bloodthirstiness. One may not enjoy this kind of fun, but to take it seriously, as the emanation of a gloomy and diabolic genius, is absurd. The same test is equally destructive of much of the praise Doré has received. He is con stantly spoken of, even by severe critics of his painting, iNustrator who iden as a great The Nation. tified himself with the mind of one great writer after another. But Dore identified himself with no one: he was always Dore. Even in these early drawings he cannot keep to the spirit of the text, though the jects suited him much better than many he tried later. There is a great deal of broad gayety and *‘ Gallic wit "in the ‘Contes Dro latiques,’ but it not Doré, and he has converted its most human sub Was broad enough for characters into impossible grotesques Another thing for which Dore is praised is Mr. Jerrold repeats more than once Doré’s phrase, ** T have lots of his wonderful memory. collodien in my head,’ and recounts how he could scarcely be induced to make sketches from nature, but relied upon his memory. He also speaks of Doré’s system of dividing and subdividing a subject, and noting the details in their places, so that he could reproduce the whole afterwards. This question of work from memory is one of the most vital for an under standing of Doré, and one of general interest in all matters of art, and is worth attention Of course a man who made hundreds of draw ings every vear could not work much from na But what is the nature of artistic memory, and how We think the truth is, that the artist who habitually works from memory fills in his details, not from memory of ture, and came to rely upon his memory does it perform its task ? the object, but from memory of the way he has He toa series of formulae that he has gradually ac formerly drawn similar objects. reverts cumulated. This man must have a cloak > This is the way a cloak is done. A hand’ Nothing can be easier; the hand formula is ready. The stock in trade of the professional illustrator and caricaturist is made up of a thousand such for mule—methods of expression that convey the idea readily enough to the spectator, but have little relation to fact. So it is that Dore never learned, in the true sense, fo drat. He had of shorthand which enabled him to convey his superabun made for himself a sort artistic dant ideas quickly and certainly to his public, but his drawing is what is called mannered in the extreme. Itisnot representation of nature at all, but pure formula and chic. He to be a master of drapery, but he never drew a is said He is said to show great knowledge of Gothic architecture, but he never drew In his later years he studied anatomy with great per single fold correctly. well a single colimn or finial severance, and advocated the necessity of dis section, saying, ** Ul faut fourrer le main de dans"’ the manner was formed, and he never drew a (You must stick your hand in it); but leg with a bone in it. With this equipment he Quixote, Dante, the Bible he shows no sympathy illustrated Don Is it that with the grand sim strange plicity of Dante, or the subtle humor of Cer vantes, and that we can only be thankful that | he never completed his projected illustrations } cund beyond precedent, possessed a | strange drollery, to Shakspere’ Dore the illustrator was fe certain had a wonderful tlow of ideas, but was superticial, theatrical, and man nered, and as far from expressing real horror What say of Doré the painter and sculptor ? Mr. Jerrold Doré and Théophile Gautier in which the riles as from expressing real fun. shall we reports a discussion between of artist and man of letters are strangely m versed. ** Gautier and Doré.*" he says, ** dis | agreed fundamentally on the aims and methods of form Doré contended that art which said nothing, which c art Gautier loved) correctness, perfect the technique, in short, of art; whereas mveyed no idea, albeit perfect in form AOS and color, mise the highest quality and ratson détre of art What is plain from this is that Gautier was an artist and cared first of all for art, while Dor’ was never an art ist, properly speaking, at all, and never understood the artist's passion for perfection To Dore, what was neceswiry was to express himself anvhow—who cared if the stvle was defective, the drawing bad, the color cruck The idea was the thing. His admirers can defend him only on this ground, and they adopt of necessity the Philistine point of view. The art ists of Dore’s time and untry were very clear in their opinion The punters mays Mr. Jerrold, ** said he could not paint The sculptors admitted that he had teas im his groups, but he was not sculpturesque His friends protest against this judgment, and attribute it, ad nausea te malevolerns amd “Senvy What if his technique was les brilliant than that of Hals, they sav; what if his shadows are less transparent Chan those of Rembrandt (and they wal inke mo Menet COMPRUPISOnS He is teeming with noble thoughts,” and these will put his work na level with the masterpieces of the Ttaltan ues ters of the sixteenth century It is the Gon ception, the creation—-not the perfeet paunting of legs and arms aml heads, the harmonious grouping, the happy and deheoate coml ation of color-—bv which the becrver us held spe bound ALL these qualities, which his ad mnirers grudgingly admit that D had { are Classe} as rrye't lexterity amd an t considered worth a second thor This is the true literary gospel of art, but tt is one that no artast. ands ite Who has any true feeling for art. has ev rcoepted will ver accept Tt rhits is ePUots mav enha the va fa work of art ee re on aie P a tte but they have never preserved, and never will preserve, from eblivion bad painting r bad seul i stvle is t} artist if not Ww Inman; and of the two, beaut punting with n lea ata granting, for the sake of argument, that it exists). will ever be infinite Iv more valuable to the world than the lame expression of the blest thoughts What mav be the real value of Doreé’s thoughts is therefore a question with which we have no MCcern Whether they are trulv sublime, as his worshippers declare, or merely theatrically effective, as we believe, is really of no impor tance whatever The standard bv which he must lx idged is the standard of technical and bv this standard he is con achievement, demned, without stay of judgment on the plea of grandeur of conception \s painter and } seulptor, his lack of education and his great technical imperfections— his bad drawing, false light and shade, and crude color—relegate him Such reputation as he has is the result of the admira of art, but possessed of enough literary ability to trumpet for ever to a rank far below mediocrity. tion of those altogether ignorant abroad their praises of ‘* great conceptions,’’ and will as surely fade away to nothing as the reputation of such simple painters as Van der Meer painting as an art is loved and understood. or Chardin will continue to grow while DOBSON'S HOGARTH. William Hogarth Mead & Co of artists; By Austin Dobson. Dodd, Isl THE those of name Hogarth stands alone among he cannot be classed with any school, English or foreign, in method, style or subject; he created his own field, as he chose his own fashion of education. As he followed

Page 20

AOA. no one, so no one has followed him. Isolated, sharply defined, of exceptionally original vigor, it is not strange that both the man and his works have always formed an attractive sub- ject for critics. No less than 108 titles are given in the Bibliography which fills thirty-nine pages and forms Part IL. of the present work, covering a period of 160 years, from 1731 to the current year. They are of worksof all degrees of magnitude, from the single sheet of a news- paper (as that of the issue of the North Briton of September 25, 1762, which contained the memorable attack of John Wilkes upon Hogarth) to the monumental folio containing the engraved plates from his works, or the fourteen volumes in German by Leichtenberg. Able critics—Horace Walpole, Lamb, Hazlitt, Hartley Coleridge, and Leigh Hunt, to say nothing of Thackeray, Dickens, and Dr. Brown—have left their records of the impres- sions made upor them by the works of this artist. Such an array of literary comment is certainly a proof of the strength of the man; but there was yet ample room and more, a crying necessity, for a book which should ac- complish that which Mr. Dobson’s does, name- ly: the presentation in a concise form of both the story of the artist’s life and a complete his- tory of his work in connected sequence, while al- so giving competent criticism both of the works themselves and of the previous accumulated criticism. Such a task can only be performed after the lapse of sufficient time, and the pe- riod had certainly been reached for this sub- ject. The book is an amplification of that written by the author ten years ago for the ‘*Great Artists Series,’? but, with the excep- tion of the same admirable and interesting in- troductory chapter, has been entirely rewrit- ten. The complete bibliography, lists of prints and paintings, and the excellent index, are all virtually new, and occupy nearly one-half of the volume. Hogarth can never become hackneyed any more than can the great moral truths and phases of life which formed the almost exclu- sive subject of his pencil; and although the story of his life is meagre and contains no strik- ing episodes, the man himself will always be interesting, and will command respect from his strongly marked character and the valiant earnestness with which he championed his ideas and prejudices. The autographic ‘* Brief Sketch,’’ left by the artist and inherited from his widow by her cousin, Mary Lewis, from whom it was received by John Ireland, the en- thusiastic and sympathetic collector of Ho- garth’s works, in 1796, forms the basis of all that is known of the artist's life. He was born in London in 1697, and died there in 1764. He served an apprenticeship to a silver-plate en- graver, but deserted this trade for engraving on copper plate, working mainly from his own inspiration, although he attended later the school of Sir James Thornhill, where he might draw from the life when he chose other assist- ance than came from his own unaided powers It is interesting to note that upon the death of Sir James Thornhill in 1734, Hogarth, who had made a runaway match with his handsome daughter, inherited his academy in Covent Garden, and, associating with himself a number of artists, opened a ‘* Life School’? in ‘‘ Peter’s Court, against Tom’s Coffee House in 8. Martin’s Lane.’’ ‘*In this institution most of the artists of the reign of George II. and the early part of the reign of George IIT. were trained; and its usefulness only ceased with the establishment of the Roy- al Academy, to which ‘its anatomical figures, busts, statues, etc.,’ were transferred in 1768,’’ of observation. The Nation. In 1735 Hogarth was mainly instrumental in obtaining an act of Parliament against pirati- cal print publishers: the ‘‘act’’? is usually spoken of as Hogarth’s, and the engravings of ‘*The Rake’s Vrogress,’? which appeared in June, 1735, are probably the first which bear the words ‘* According to Act of Parliament, ’’ now so common upon engravings. In 1739 the Foundling Hospital, in which Hogarth took a warm interest, and for which he painted the portrait of Capt. Coram, the originator of the scheme, was established. This picture the art- ist considered bis best single portrait, and pos- terity agrees with him. The Hospital contains other paintings by Hogarth, and he was a ‘*Governor and Guardian’’ of the institution. Thus he initiated the practice of decorating the Foundling Hospital with paintings, and, other artists following in his footsteps, this place ultimately became possessed of a remark- able collection, ‘* which made a visit to the Foundling the :nost fashionable lounge of the reign of George LL., and, by a succession of cir- cumstances, indirectly, but not less surely, brought about the establishment of the Royal Academy.”’ In 1748 he made a journey to France, and was arrested while sketching the ‘‘ Calais Gate,’’ but was shortly released. In 1753 he published his ‘Analysis of Beauty ’—a book which brought him but little credit and much animadversion, and which, although it contains a good deal of sound sense and shrewd observation, is poorly constructed and incoherent in idea as well as form. Its origin as given by the artist is piquant. In the portrait of himself, now in the National Gallery, he had represented upon his palette a serpentine line, with the words under it, ‘‘ The Line of Beauty and Grace.” ‘* No Egyptian hieroglyphic,’? he says, ‘‘ever amused more than it did fora time’’; and, adds Mr. Dobson, ‘‘so numerous were the re- quests which he received for a solution of the enigma that, after applying to several of his friends to take up the pen in his behalf, he finally made shift to explain his symbol in print himself."’ In 1749 he bought a ** villakin ’’ at Chiswick, on the banks of the Thames, and there he spent more or less of his summer time. His home still stands, as does also his formerly majestic mulberry tree. And in the church- yard at Chiswick he is buried. This is the skeleton of what would be called his life; but his real existence must be read in the prolific work he left behind as the result of a long and constantly occupied career. Mr. Dobson gives a list of about two hundred prints engraved by Hogarth himself after his own works, and about as many more by other engravers after his designs—some of these pos- sibly also in part by him. Besides these about two hundred and sixty paintings are enume rated. The record of this voluminous work is all set down in the most orderly manner in the present book, and, without going into tedious detail, Mr. Dobson gives the main facts relat- ing to the creation and history of all the more important series as well as individual works, with such original criticism as is needful, and also very full citation in the text (but more especially in the admirable foot-notes, which abound) from earlier criticism. The treat- ment of the subject could scarcely be bet- ter, for here is gathered together and placed in systematic form all that it is necessary to know of the artist and his work. The student will find here either what he seeks, or trustworthy indication of where simple, | to seck it. A large number of full-page il- | lustrations adorn the book, among them | twelve photogravures most admirably exe- [ Vol. 53, No. 1382 cuted: one of these, the well-known portrait of the artist with his dog, in the National Gal- lery, forms the frontispicce. The book is a most attractive one with its heavy uncut leaves, faultless type and wide margins—all a fitting framework for the interesting story, charmingly told, which it contains. We cannot follow Mr. Dobson in his parti- culars, but we may be pardoued for quoting the following passages from his introduction, which present, in a forcible and condensed form, a vivid picture of the nature of Hogarth’s genius and the character of his work: ‘*He gives us,’’ says the author, ‘‘unro- manced and unidealized, ‘the form and pres- sure,’ the absolute details and accessories, the actual mise-en-scéne, of the time in which ho lived. But he has done much more than this. He has peopled his canvas with its dramatis person, with vivid portraits of the more strongly marked actors in that cynical and sensual, brave and boastful, corrupt and pa- triotic age. . . He was a moralist after the manner of eighteenth-century morality, not savage like Swift, not ironical like Field- ing, not tender-hearted at times like John- son and Goldsmith; but unrelenting, uncom- promising, uncompassionate. He drew vice and its consequences in a thoroughly literal and business-like way, neither sparing nor extenuating its details, wholly insensible to its seductions, incapable of flattering it even for a moment, preoccupied simply with catching its srecise contortion of pleasure or pain. In all is delineations . Wwe see Justice and Vengeance following hard upon the criminal. He knew, no doubt, as well as we, that not sel- dom (humanly speaking) the innocent are punished and the guilty go at large. What matter! that message should not be preached by him, at any rate. So he drew his ‘ Bogey’ bigger, if possible, and drove his graver deep- er in the copper. What antecedents, what progress of circumstance, what special conditions produced this unique and individual artist in an era of mediocrities? . . When all is said and done, the reader will probably find no more satisfactory reply to the question than this: that he was a great and exceptional genius, not to be entirely accounted for by any preconceived theory respecting his race, bis epoch, or his environment.’’ The satiric and comic elements are those which first attract in the prints of Hogarth, and superficially he is probably considered a humorist pure and simple; but so closely inter- woven are ‘‘ bliss and woe *’ in the ‘* thread of human life ’’ that, under all, we may see, per- haps, ‘‘the bitter smile beneath the painted grin he wore.’’ The little print called ‘* Finis, or The Bathos,’’ the last work he did, but a few months before his death, is a startling commentary on the facetious element in all his works. What could be more pathetic than this representation of chaos as the end of all effort? Both the ‘‘sublime’’ in art, which he had vidiculed without ceasing, and the naturalis- tic, which he had practised—virtue and vice —all things come alike to the same goal! One can searcely lay down this book without the strongest feelings of respect and admiration for this valiant preacher against vice and sham; for his clear and strong intellectual quality, and for the untiring energy with which he occupied the years of a long life. MILLER ON THE CONSTITUTION, Lectures on the Coustitution of the United States. By Samuel t'reeman Miller, LL.D., late an Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States. New York and Albany: Banks & Brothers. 1891. In receiving this legacy of a great judge, the people of the United States may congratulate themselves on their parsimony in the compen- sation of their higher officials. It is well known that Mr, Justice Miller, like his col-

Page 21

a Dec 24, 1891 | league in the Supreme Court, the late Chief- Justice Waite, died poor. At any time dur- ing his distinguished judicial career have gained a fortune by resigning his office and accepting employment from the numerous and eager litigants who would have hastened to retain him on his own terms. But, with a spirit of independence and of patriotic duty which characterized him through life, he pre ferred to continue in the discharge of his high functions at the sacrifice of his private inte Too much engrossed in his public duties, he could rests. and of too broad and generous a disposition to practise an economy not compatible with the dignity due to his station, he undertook, in order to increase his income, the task of de livering lectures to law students. Of the twelve lectures embraced in this volume, all but two were written for that purpose, and were read by him before a law school in the city of Washington in the winter of 1889 and the early spring of 1890. The career of Mr. Justice Miller was one of the most remarkable in judicial annals. He was not educated for the law, but for medi- cine; and it was at an age when most men have not only made a definitive choice of a profes- sion, but have also fairly got a start in the vo cation of life, that he studied law and came to the bar. But he had found the true sphere of his activity. At the time when he abandoned medicine for the law, he was a citizen of the State of Kentucky, and, with his positiveness of conviction and frankness of expression, he was inevitably drawn into the agitation, then daily becoming more acute, on the subject of slavery. Like most men of the time and place who possessed the means, he was an owner of slaves. With him, however, opposition to the extension of slavery soon grew intoa confirmed repugnance to slavery itself, and, taking his slaves with him, he went to lowa and set them free. With this change of residence and of political and social conditions, we may regard his career as actually begun. His progress at the bar was sure and rapid. While he could scarcely have been widely read and learned in the law, he possessed a strong common sense, ¢ force of character, and a firm grasp of prin ciples, which could not fail to secure for him an influence over the courts, as well as over his brethren at the bar. His elevation to the bench, after what must be considered as a comparatively brief period in the study and pursuit of his profession, took place when sectional feeling was intense and bitter, and when those who, in the political and legal controversies raised by the attempt at secession, had ranged themselves on the side of the Union, might have found a ready excuse, as many of them did, for exalting the restored national authority above previously accepted constitutional restrictions, and bearing down the opposition of those who contended for the right of local self-government. It can hardly be pretended that Mr. Justice Miller was lack- ing in a disposition to assert the supremacy of the national Government, or that he would have been compelled to yield to any man in the ardor or constancy of his desire for the establishment of that supremacy. his earlier opinions contain vehement and pas- sionate expressions of his feelings on that sub- ject. At the same time, he had the wisdom to look to the end. While he abhorred the attempt to destroy the Federal Government by force of arms, he was equally opposed to the tendency to revolutionize it through the forms of law. Like Lincoln, desired to restore ‘‘ the Some of he Union as it was,’ and, after remedying the de- fects that made the attempt at Lisuluon The Nation. sible, he wished to inaugurate again the reign of the Constitution. It was not long before he had occasion to and For the purpose of extirpating the causes of the war and safeguarding the future, the Thirteenth, Fourteenth, and Fifteenth adopted, to secure freedom and _ political en assert maintain these views. Amendments were franchisement to those who had formerly been The Su to deter these amendments oppressed, and equal rights to all. called ot Slaughter-house cases,*’ the of animals preme Court Was soon upon mine the scope and effect in the ** which grew out of an act passed by Legislature of for the regulating the of for food within the limits of the city of New Orleans, Louisiana purpose business slaughtering As this end was sought to be accomplished in the act by the granting of an exclusive right of killing animals within those limits to a cor | poration, the butchers of the city brought suit to enjoin the corporation from exercising the right, on the ground that the Legislature of | the State had, by the creation of a monopoly,

invaded their rights, and thus infringed the new amendments. When the case came up for decision, the court was found to be di vided. Four of the judges held that the act was violative of the amendments, and therefore invalid. Five of the judges, how ever, held otherwise, and among them was Mr. Justice Miller, who delivered the opinion of the court. The question on which the court was sharply divided was whether the amend ments should be construed broadly, so as to curtail the general powers of the States under the Constitution as affecting rights of person and property, or whether they should be con fined in their application by the consideration of the special purposes which they were de Mr. Justice Miller held that they should be so contined ; and, after ad signed to accomplish, verting to the fact that the real danger to the perpetuity of the Union disclosed by the civil war Was in the capacity of the States alone, or in combination, to organize resistance to the | general Government, he said: ‘* Unquestionably this has given great force |} to the argument, and added largely to the number of those who believe in the of astrong national Government. ever pervading this sentiment, and he may have contributed to the adoption of the amendments we have been considering, we do not see in those amendments any purpose & Necessity But, how wever it | destroy the main features of the system. Un der the pressure of all the excited feeling gro\ ing out of the war, r statesmen have still bx lieved that the existence of the States with powers for domestic and local government, in cluding the regulation eivil rights—the rights of person and property—was essential to the perfect working of our complex system of government, though they have thought proper to impose additional limitations on the covern

hn ou + \f ol

ments of the States, and to confer additional power on that of the United States. But whatever fluctuations may be seen in the his tory of public opinion on this subject during the period of our national existence, we think it will be found that this court, so far as its functions required, has always held with a steady and an even hand the balance between State and Federal power, and we that such may continue to be the history of its rela- tion to that subject so long as it shall have du ties to perform which demand of it a construc tion of the Constitution, or of any of parts.*’

rrnct BAADE ite is believe that Mr Miller regarded the delivery of this opi There is reason to Justice hion as one of the acts, if not, indeed, Most iniportant as probably it was, the most important act, of his judicial life. In his lecture delivered in June, ISST, before the alumni of the law de- | partment of the University of Michigan, on the subject he Supreme Court, he gives an | energetic,

of the Canes, interesting exposition decision in ** Slaughter-house and says

Aithouch this decision did not meet t approval of four out of nine of the judges some points on which it rested, vet ; sentiment, as found in tl Tress ard im t universal acquiescence which it nm ved cepted it with great unanimity \ while the question of the « t? : . amendmeats, and parti irly the } rte has often been before the Supe ( the United States, no attem t disregard this elementary decis Y of the three new Constitutional Amendmes upon the relations of the State Werntments the Federal Government has bb t arn it may be considered now as i that, w the exception of the specific provisions in t for the protection of the personal rights t citizens and people of the United States, and the necessary restrictions mn t , anes the States for that puryxx with tl " to the powers of the general Government enforce those provisions, no substa ulcha has been made The necessitw of: t ure powers « mcadead by the ¢ stitu ‘ , atiy to the Federal Government, and tl prnaal cessitv of the autonomy of t} States a it} power to regulate thei st tt “1 win as the reat features of ir com] < goverment. ”’ The lecture in which the passa just is found forms the « t = . tweis printed in the prosent v \ i : two not read before tf ‘ is VW ton, the ot ! by Mr. Just Mi t . ISS7, at Philad t : { the one hundmalth t \ ‘ tt rN and promulgation the ¢ This oration is so widely a * v k that it would be supert! her It is sufl : vy whoa! +f P } , ‘ . } ‘ } . in wn L Usa Was i ‘ ws AL expounder of the ¢ stitution, that he was chosen to pr t t ~ sion Bu t av be sa . arly ey es tha spu t { <j™ iw ow } was a controlli int! ‘ Mr. Jus Mil ler’s career ‘I but repeat.”’ he said 1 language of the Supreme Court of 1 L i States when I sav that in this t « is s nie No man is so high as b e tl \ No Wicer of the Gover t \ lis rn urd it with impunity To this in and native re gard f law, as a governing power, we are . 5 . indebted largely for the wonderful success and prosperity of 1x t . rity of our rights Let upon my fellow intrymen, and especially upon the tion of them, ¢t examine with Ti eiTh ly w ft? ’ - f govern f swial life, and if they do not rest i f veneration and respect for law as bond of social existence, let them be distrusted as al to human hap pPiness. The ten lectures ce i} re the law school in w asi rt rest veiy re ile to Th pl f Constru ‘3 Con stituth Execut Branch of the Gover ‘The Separate Powers of the Senate House of Representatives,’

**The Power of Taxation,’’ ‘‘ Naturalization and Citizenship,’’ ‘‘ The Judicial Power of the United States,”’ the ‘* Regulation of Commerce among the States,’’ ‘‘ The Right of Trial by Jury,’ the ‘‘ Impairment of the Obligation of Contracts,"’ and the ‘‘ Limitations upon the Powers of the States."’ It would be impossible within the compass of a review critical discussion of to attempt a these lectures, but it may be said that they present in clear and bold out- line the great fundamental principles governing The style is direct, and lucid, such as becomes one who our constitutional system speaks with authority. But we should do injustice to this publica- tion if failed to the of its we notice work

Page 22

AOG editor, Mr. J. C. Bancroft Davis, the accom- plished reporter of the Supreme Court. The spirit in which he has performed his task can- not better be described than by quoting from his preface the following passage: ‘‘I have endeavored to present this work to the pro- fession and the public in a manner worthy of the great judge who has passed away, so far as the limited time given me and my duties to the court would allow, It has been to me a labor of love to follow in the footsteps of whose great intellect, probity, manli- ness, and directness of purpose were recog- nized by the whole nation; whose amiable character was admired by all who knew him; and whose friendship I was permitted to en- joy for nearly a quarter of a century.’’ To each lecture Mr. Davis has added an explana- tory note, and, in order to make the work complete as at once a treatise and a text-book, he has also written a supplemental chapter containing references to minor provisions of the Constitution not discussed in the lectures. He has also embodied in an appendix a col- lated copy of the Constitution, with full re- ferences to the cases in which it has been con- strued or discussed, as well as collated copies of the Articles of Confederation and of Ran- dolph’s and Pinckney’s drafts for a constitu- tion. The presswork of the book is a credit to the publishers, and leaves nothing to be de- sired. We cannot doubt that this important work will receive, as it deserves, a warm and generous reception at the hands not only of statesmen and lawyers, but also of teachers and students of Constitutional history. one The Hours of Raphael in Outline. E. Williams. Boston: Little, Brown & Co. WHERE are, or where were, the famous ‘*Hours’’ of Raphael ? is a question which has very often been asked; and the answer has generally been, No one knows; or, They say they were somewhere in the Vatican, but no one knows where. Miss Mary E. Williams, for many years a resident in Rome, undertakes to answer this question in the beautiful volume just published by Little, Brown & Co. Cer- tainly all persons interested in the painting of the Renaissance, and more particularly in that of Raphael, would be devoutly thankful for any light thrown upon the origin of these well- known figures, and would welcome any con- vinecing arguments which should finally dissi- pate the mist of uncertainty which has always enveloped them. Probably few of the minor works of art of this class have received more attention from the general art-loving public than these ‘‘ Hours.’’ Their grace and sim- plicity attract at once. The numerous repro- ductions, gotten up in the most inexpensive form, are bought in large numbers by travellers, and not a few sojourners in Rome have carried away these simple mementoes, thereby laying the train for long researches in a vain attempt to discover the whereabouts and authorship of the originals. Students of a higher class have always known them from the folio volume of engravings, published in Paris in 1804-6, which contains prints of the twelve ‘‘ Hours’? finished by the burin by ten different engravers, but without text and with no clue to the original designer. This enshrouding mystery has added not a little to the fame and interest of the composi- tions. Has our author finally answered the question—or rather the questions, for there are two—Where were the ‘‘Hours’’? and, Who painted them? Her volume contains six- teen folio plates, comprising the twelve figures By Mary , The Nation. of the ‘‘ Hours,’’ two repetitions with varia- tions after Piranesi, and two plates of the ceil- ing which they are said to have originally adorned. The accompanying text is clear and remarkably interesting; it gives an account of all the known facts, as well as the author’s de- ductions therefrom. In the Royal Stamperia in Rome is a rare and highly prized engraving of the ceiling of the Sala del Camino, one of the suite of six rooms in the Vatican called the ‘‘Sale Bor- gia,’’ from Alexander VI., a Borgia, who oc- cupied them during his pontificate (1492-1503). This engraving was photographed for the first time for the reproduction which forms Plate 1 of the book now published. Neither the name of the engraver nor a date appears upon the engraving, but it was published by Monta- gnani, the well-known publisher of prints, who flourished in Rome about the middle of the eighteenth century, and it bears an inscription in Italian, translated by our author as follows: ‘*Ceiling of the Sala Borgia in the Vatican Palace, where are expressed the Planets, the Hours of the Day, and the Signs of the Zodiac by the immortal Raphael Sanzio of Urbino.’’ In this print the ‘‘ Hours’’ as we know them appear, six on each side of the central panel. This would seem to prove with sufficient cer- tainty the original position of the designs, and so to answer the first question, ‘‘ Where were the ‘ Hours’ ?”’ But to accept the attribution of them to Ra- phael upon the sole authority of this anony- mous print, executed two hundred and fifty years after his death, is quite another matter. Neither does the author undertake to do this ; she adduces other, ‘at least circumstantial evi- dence. In 1500 the ceiling of the Sala del Ca- mino was blown down and destroyed by a vio- lent storm, the Pope being overwhelmed by the débris. Julius II. succeeded Alexander VI., and in 1508 summoned Raphael to Rome to decorate the stanze of the Vatican. This occu- pied him nine years, and after the death of Bramante in 1514 he continued the latter’s work upon the loggie. Just at the angle of the arcades which form thisfeature of the palace, and directly under one of the stanze, is the Sala del Camino, the frescoes and ceiling of which had been destroyed by the storm of the. year 1500. Leo X., who followed Julius II., began at least the decoration of this room, as is shown by the insertion of his name in each of its corners. This Pope never employed an- other master than Raphael. From these facts alone it seems highly prob- able, if not quite certain, that the designs at least of the floating figures on the ceiling were by the great master. Moreover, in 1516, Leo X. had made Raphael superintendent of anti- quities and excavations at Rome. The Baths of Titus were discovered with their rich trea- sures, among which are especially mentioned ‘*the most beautiful mural paintings that had ever been seen.’’ Did some of these inspire the artist in his Vatican decoration? It is known that he employed many of his pupils, and notably Giulio Romano and Pierino del Vaga, to superintend the execution of his de- signs for numerous frescoes, and that Giovanni da Udine, who showed a special aptitude for this work, was made director of the grotesques and stucco ornament of the Sala del Camino. Pierino del Vaga was employed upon the ceil- ing, and continued to work upon it from the master’s designs till after his death in 1520. The form in which the designs have come down to us seems to indicate that they were not originally intended for the position which they eventually occupied, and the author sug- 3 No 1 ~ . 352 [Vol 5 gests that Raphael intended them for the thir- teen (sic) spaces opposite the windows in the loggia. This was uncompleted at the time of Raphael’s death, and its completion was post- poned till long afterwards. Miss Williams suggests that the pupils appropriated the ex- isting designs for the work more immediately in hand, to wit, the ceiling of the Sala del Camino. This, of course, is purely conjec- tural and of secondary importance. Apart from the proofs advanced, the author main- tains that the internal evidence of the figures plainly shows them to have been by the hand of the master whose ‘autograph is clearly visible to those who are thoroughly familiar with his work.’’ We cannot decide so confidently from the evidence of this volume, which consists of reproductions of tracings made by the author from outline prints en- graved, we know not exactly when, but certain- ly about 250 years after the artist’s death. These outlines, which are evidently most faithfully copied, are contained in a rare, if not unique, folio in the Romani Sarti library in Rome, and are by three engravers, two of them of un- known dates; the third, Ferdinando Mori, was born in 1775. As was said in the beginning, the medium through which the ‘‘Hours’’ have been known of late years is the volume published in Paris in 1804-6. The story goes that Canova caused these engravings to be made, but from what originals? An article in the London Notes and Queries (title, author, and date not given) states that in the seventeenth century ‘‘ ap- peared certain engravings in the style of Mare Antonio, the only artist who was allowed by Raphael to engrave his designs as soon as they were drawn and before he had begun to paint them, and in whose engravings some of the best works of Raphael (as his ‘‘ Lucretia’’) still sur- vive. These seventeenth-century engravings were universally called ‘‘ Raphael’s ‘ Hours.’ ”’ They thus (concludes Miss Williams) ‘‘ form the connecting link between Canova and Ra- phael.’’ These are all the known facts, and it seems to us that the conclusion may fairly be drawn, in view of the persistent tradition that Raphael was the artist, that the designs were by him. The book is a very beautiful one. Every portion—cover, text, and plates—has been pre- pared with the greatest care and with the hap- piest result. The reproductions are admira- ble, especially those of the whole ceiling, in which occurs an endless variety of the most minute Renaissance detail, rendered with strik- ing clearness and excellent tone. If any ad- verse criticism is to be made, it would be that some of the faces in the floating figures are a trifle heavy in touch; but this applies only toa part of them. We should have been glad, also, if the author had been able to give us some account of the present condition of the ceiling, and whether any vestiges of the figures remain. In point of fact, we believe that the whole ceiling has been whitewashed or stuc- coed over, and that nothing of the original decoration is visible. Altogether, this folio volume will form, not only a valuable addition to the literature of art for students, but a charming possession for all lovers of graceful and interesting designs. a BOOKS OF THE WEEK. A Directory of the Charitable and Beneficent Organiza- tions of Boston. 3d ed. Boston: Damrell & Upham. Aubert, Prof. E. Colioquial French Drill, Part U1. Henry Holt & Co. Babyhood. Vol. VI{. Babyhood Publishing Co. Barbe, Waitman. Ashes ani Innocence. Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott Co. $1.25, Bronson, T. k. Colloquial German. Henry Holt & Co. 65 cents.

Page 23

Dec 24 1891 ] mee wn, W.H. A Southern Edward Brandus & Co Burke, E. Federal Finances ; or, The Income of | the Untied States. Chicago: F. J. Schulte & Carlyle, T. The French Revolution. 3 vols. " delphia: Porter & Coates. Jacks and Jills. Heritage. 50 cents. New York: JO. Phila- New York: Raphael Clarke, Mary C. ines. New ed. Collar, W. C. Co. Cushing, Paul. Bros. 50 ce Dincklage, E. von. ner’s Sons, Deamee Sarah. rd & Co. vem Prof. A. J. 5 vols. A.C. ihe Gate to Cvsar. Boston: Cut with his Own Diamond. Harper * The Little Countess. the Robert Bon Voice. in Starlicht. Marcus Iat'n Prose Exercises based upon Livy, Book XXF. Boston: Ginn & Co. 40 cents. Ellis, A. B. Memotrof Rufus Ellis. Boston: William B. Clarke & Co. Emerson, P. H. East Coast Yarns. London: Samp- son Low, Marston & Co. — G.M. The Crystat Hunters. D. Appleton &Co. $1.50. Fox-Bourne, H. R. Sir Philip Sidney. (Heroes of the Nations.) G.P. Putnam’s Sons. 61.50, HENRY HOLT & CO., N. Y., | HAVE JUST PUBLISHED: Bright's Anglo-Saxon Reader. 12mo, pp. 384. Teachers’ price, $2.00; by mail, $2.11, Contains graded texts, from the easiest to the more difficult prose, with several suitable poems, all care- full edited and annotated. The vo%ms are supp'e mented by a chapteron verification The g'o’sar defines all the words in t e texts, furnishes much grammatical information, and gives etymological hin a. Whitney’s Introductory French Reader. 16mo, pp. 245. Teaches’ price, €5 cents; by mail, 71 cents. All the matter is easy enough to present no unneces- tary obstacle torapid reading, interesting enough to ho'd the attention. and varied enough to serve a+ an intr: dnetion to any reading that will beapt to follow. The selections are all froma thorsof repute. There are ample notes, including grammatical references, and a handy vocabu’ ary, Did It Ever Occur to You That GOLDTHWAITE’S GEOGRAPHICAL MAGAZINE is the only publication of its kind in the world ? A complete bird’s-eye view of the world each month, illustrated. We club with Century for ............... 4 50 We club with Harper’s for..........00ss. 4 00 We club with Scribner's for ...... ee eawte 3 50 We club with Cosmopolitan for.......... 3 00 We club with Forum for.............se0. 5 00 If you order this month. THE GOLDTHWAITES, 132 Nassau Street. N. B,—A sample copy of G. G, M, free toevery reade of } Ni ution. The Divinity School of T TRDOQITV HARVARD UNIVERSITY. For the year 1892-93, two resident (Williams) Fellowships of $500 each are offered to gradu- ates of Theological Schools who intend to de- vote themselves to the Christian Ministry. These Fellowships are designed to encourage advanced Theological work of a high order Applications, accompanied by testimonials and specimens of work, must be before May Ist, 1892. Cc. C. EVERETT, Dean HEIMBURG’S NOVELS. (WORTHINGTON'S INTERNATIONAL L IBRARY. A Maiden's Choice. Gertrude’s Marriage. Misjudged. Two Daughters of One Race. The Major’s Daughter. A -isters : ove Lucie’s Mistake. Christmas * tories. Magda'en's Fortunes. The Pastor's Daughter. In illuminated paper covers, 75 cents each. FOR FALE BY ALL BOOKSELLERS. WorTHINGTON Co., 747 B'way, N. ¥. DR ‘ADVA NCED CLAS SSES ONL y. r forall desirous of keeping up their French L'ECHO Li i TERAIRE, a school and home rrench Eu- ropean Magazine. Romance, poetry, plays, sketches, exercises, ete. Twice a month. Nearly 800 pages, post paid, at 61.25 per ‘oy Ror, Gcentsa mane numhk r. made to the Dean

337 South Broad St., Phila. ‘The Girlhood of Shakspere’s Hero. | Armatrong & Son, $5. | Ginn & |

The Nation. w. Page, H. Our Boys fim Ireland. Gueneey. J.@. A Beaut Milwaukee: The Author, #1.25. Greenwood, Grace. “tories of Many lands. New ed., sevases and enlarged. Unit d States Book Co. Hall, Prof. E, H., and Bergen, J.T. A Text Book of Worthington of Thebes, and Other Verses. Paoysios. Henry Holt @Co. &€1 25. Harrison, Esther W. Skye: The History of a Dog Philade —, The Au hor. Harrison, Jane F. ! oduct tory Studies in Greek Art

Macmiilan & Co. Henderson, Maj. G. F. t Aug. 6, 1870: The Pattle o° Spicheren, } A Study in Practical Tactics and War | Training. | Cw Gale & + olden Henderson, Maj.G. F. KR. The Campaign of Fredericks burah, Nov. hs . 1s62 A factical Study for | OMicers. S3ded. London: Gale & Polden. j Hu'me, F. E. The History. Prineiples and | ractice of Hera'dry London: Swan Sonnenschein & Co, New York: Macmilian. #1.25. Hume, Fergus, A Creature of Sampson Low, Marston & Co. panes, ° Kev. HL N. The Story of the Hilis, millan& Co. = @1.50. Jobnson, E. G. Sir Joshua Reynolds's Chicago C. McClurg & Co. ight. London Mac the Discourses. Makes Purest Bread. OVERNMENT Chemist Mott: “The Royal Bak- ing Powder i undoubtedly the purest and most reliable baking powder offered to the public.” ~ 1s y¥UROPEAN SUMMER AND WIS « ter Resort, University town of Innsbruck, ! rol, Austria; 1.400 feet above the sea, with dry, bracing climate. Hotel Tirol, open all the year, Carl Landsee lroprietor. Large. a'ry. sunny rooms, well furnished. Elevator. Superior cuisine table d"ho’e or A la carte Reduced rates in winter ¢ arri and sleighs at low rates. Charming excursions made fom the hotel at all seasons, Unusual advantages for securing teachers of the languaces, bistory. sc ence. art, muste, ete , at very moderate t& rma Eminent medica! care ard skilled nurses if desired. Best Engtish aod America encima sanseated emai lets sent on appl eation ARTISTIC PRESENTS of PERMANENT VALUE. Fine Pictures at Moderate Prices HIGH-CLASS | Etchings, Engravings, and Water pes FREDERICK EEPPEI 2) East 16th St, & oo ARIS, an between Union ras e and Pitta Ave. ‘FOREIGN PHOTOGRAPHS (DIREC? INPORTATION). rr? ? . C. H. DUNTON & CO., 1i6 BOYLSTON STREET, BOSTON, axwocwor a NEW CATALOGCE of over 10,000 subjects, co the important Views, Paintings. and Sculpture of the Old World, mounted and unmounted, Mai ed for 10c. in in stamps. Braas's arbou a Photegsapes. SACK NUMBERS OF and Reviews. both pnd y and recent. Nation in- oe. as also @ choice collection of books and pam A Catalogues free. A. 5. CLARK, °4 Park Row.

. City. MAGAZINES

AG Kapian, A.0. Baby's Biograpny Breatane

Kipitng, J.t. leastan’ Manininda Macmillan & Co, Lal Kolokotrones. The Kiepht and the Warrier. London T. Fisher Unwin; New York: Macmilian. 61.50 Lilite, Lucy ¢ For Honors sake “*hbitacelphia bor i ter & Coates |} Lowe, Martha P. Be-ale Gray, and Our Stepmother. | Boston: D. Lothrop Co 61.95, Macmilian, Nev. Hu A. The Gate eautifal and (ther Bibl: * Readings for the Young Macmillan & Co #1. Markheim. H. W. Molid e's Misanthrop. xford Clarendos Presa: New York: Macm ) cena Masterpieces of American Literature Hostom: Hough ton siimin & ca, | Matzke, J. & Vie or Hugo's Hernan! Heath's Modern Languige Serics Ro@ton D.C. Heath & Co. 70 cents Maycock, WP. A Firat Pook of Pleetricity asd Fac netism. London: Whittaker & co. New York | Macmillan. © centa. Milton's The Nativitw.’ Marcus rave Mitchell. J Dupl cate Whist. Chieagce A C M C.urg & Co Scents Norton, Prof. Cc. BE The IMvine ¢ nety of ant Alighieri 1 Purgatory Boston Hough tan, MiMin & Co. €1.25 | able

A Tonic HORSEFORD'S ACID PHOSPHATE A most excellent and tonic agree It invigorates the and appetizer nourishes and tired brain and body, imparts vitality, functions. renewed energy and and enlivens the Dr, Ernraim BateMaAn, Cedarville N. J., savs: * T have used it for several years, not only in my practice, but in my own in dividual case, and consider it under all circumstances one of the best nerve tonics that we possess For menta exhaustion or overwork it gives re newed strength and vigor to the entire system.” Descriptive pamphlet free. t I Rumford Chemical Works. 1 idence, RI | ‘ re the word ** Horsford’s is on the labe All others are spurious. Never sold in bulk THE CATALOGUE Ol HARV jupegs U gigi RSITY For 1801] is r sak W. Christern, 254 Fifth Ave... New York; tte nrell & Upham, 283 Washington St... Boston: Charles W. Sever, Cam | bridge. 490 pp. Price, 75 cts.; postpaid, 85 cts We buy and <el! bille of exchange on Letters oud ceales Cable |ransfers of money to f Europe, Austrailia, and the Wes«t Indies; oO al-o make Collections an! issue Com Cc lit mercial and Traveciers’ Crediis, availa TECIL. die in al parts of the wor d. Brown Brothers & Co., Bankers, NO, 50 WALL STREET, NEW YORK. prising | Anton Rubinstein’s | new book, entitled “A Conversation on Mu-ic,” translated for the author by Mrs. John P. Morgan, will be ready for publication very shortly. Cloth, Copyright isvl, by CHARLES F. TRETBAR. STEINWAY HALL, NEW YORK.

Page 24

4-98 5. WESTERMANN & CO., Foreign Booksellers and Importers, 812 BROADWAY, NEW YORK. A carefully selected stock of German Books, suita- ble for CHRISTMAS PRESENTS, is now displayed on our counters. IMPOR TA TION of Books from all parts of the or quantities, world, single copies A New THEOLOGY at greatly ‘reduced prices. ~ GUSTAV E, STECHERT, Importer of Booksand Periodicals No. 828 Broadway, New York, has the best facilities of getting and supplying FOREIGN PERIODICALS the quickest way and at lowest prices. Before orde ring your Peri xdicals for next year please send for prices to GUSTAV E. 28 Broadway, BRANCHES ; London: 30 Wellington Street, Strand, W. C. Leipzig: 10 Hospital Street. OLD LETTERS. The subscriber will pay cash for o'd letters or docu- ments written or sivned by Ciating uished 1 nell all kinds, American and foreign. fle parti riy de- sires letters of famous American‘,and especially those of the Colonial and Revolutionary periods, Also let- ters of Generals on both sides, tederal and « onfeve- rate, in the late civil war, lf you have any old letters write to me at once, WALTER R. BENJAMIN, 28 West 23d Street, New York City, S. B. LUYSTER, 9 NASSAU STREET, NEW YORK, AND LONDON, ENGLAND. NOW Books on READY. Catalogue of German STECHERT. New York.

Importer of Standard English Books, OLD AND NEW. Catalogues issued bi-monthly, tis to any address, en applic vation, W. H. LOWDERMILK & cO., 1424 and 1426 F Street, AE Be and sent gra- Washington, Publishers, Im; orters, and Dealers in Standard English and American BOOKS, LAW AND MISCELLANEOUS, And Choice and Rare Editions, U. 8S. Government Publications a specialty. Libearies purchased. PRINTS. EL IZABETHAN LITERA- TURE. BOOKS. Brentano’s will send to any address upon request a descriptive catalogue of rare and curious books, includ- ing a collection of prints, play-bills, and clippings re- lating to Vauxhall | ardens, works on Shakespeare and Elizabethan literature, etc., forming part of their re- cent purchases from some notable libraries, SRENTANO’S, 5 Union Square, New York. ROOK S FOR SALE.—THE KLAMATH Indians of Southwestern Oregon (langua) e,ethno- graphy). two large vols, 410, pp. 28, clot "810.00. he Karankawa Indians, Texas Coast Ce thnozraphy, oy nome 8100. A Migration Legend of the Creek Indians ‘history, ethno:raph linguistics), $2.00. Write to the author, ALBr ie 8: GAT*CHET, 1330 F Street, N. w., W ashington, D. «., and send for his catalogue of other books. F. W. CHRIGPERN. 254 Fifth Ave., between 28th and 20th Sts., New York. Importer of Forels n Kooks, Agent for the leading Paris Publishers, Tauchnitz’s 'ritish Authors, Teubner’s Greek and Latin Classies, Cati ilogues of stock mailed on demand. A large assortment always on hand, and new books received from Paris and ! eipzig as 800n aa nanan. J UNITARIAN PUBLICATIONS SENT FR Address

= 462, Comeord, Mass. JACK NUMBERS OF and Reviews, es req | and recent solicited, M. 4 GA ZINES Correspondence , Rorexw & Co., Boston, Mass.

The Nation. THE FORUM FOR JANUARY. THE LOUISIANA LOTTERY: Shall its Charter be Renewed ? Judge Frank McGloin, Of the Louisiana Court of Appeals. A History of the Company, Jno. C. Wickliffe, Of the Anti-Lottery League.

The Pope and the Future of the Papacy, Dr. F. H. Geffeken.

The Secret Ballot in Thirty-three States, Joseph B. Bishop.

Brazil: The Late Crisis and Its Causes, Courtenay DeKalb.

Why the Silver Law Should be Repealed? George S. Coe, President American Exchange National Bank.

The Treaty of Brussels and Our Duty, Judge Lambert Tree, Late Minister to Belgium.

Heresy Trials and the Briggs Case, The Rev. Dr. Philip Schaff, Union Theological Seminary, New York,

Theological Education and Its Needs, The Rev. Dr. C. A. Briggs.

Pensions Again: Time to Call a Halt, Gen. Henry W. Slocum.

The Health of the Survivors of the War, Dr. John S. Billings, United States Army.

Ts Crime Increasing in Massachusetts ? Warren F. Spalding, Seeretary Mass. Commissioners of Prisons. American Homes, Mrs. Schuyler Van Rensselaer. Christmas, and After; A Sermon for the Season, The Rt. Rev. Henry C. Potter, Bishop of New York. — 50 cents a copy. $5.00 a year. THE Forum, Union Square, New York. EQUITABLE MORTGAGE COMPANY Condensed Statement, June 30, 1891. C ‘apital rn er $4,000,000 00 RPL AMRD MUIMARD 00's Oo sain olka sot ore a yo 2, 048 Surplus and undivided profits....... "830, 396 67 OO RR RS an ne ert 14,074,813 56 This company solicits correspondence about all Jirst-class investment securities. Buys and negotiates Municipal, Railroad, Water, Industrial, and Irrigation Bonds. Issues its debentures and negotiates mortgage loans. CHARLES N. FOWLER, President. CHARLES BeNJ. WILKINSON, Vice-President. B. P. SHawHan, Sec’y and Treas. OFFICES, New York, 208 Broadway. Phila., 4th & Chestnut Sts. Lindon, England. Boston, 117 Devonshire St. Kansas City, Missouri. Berlin, Germany.

Direct F ast aan Route TO THE MEDITERRANEAN. First-class Passenger Steamer Service between NEW YORK and GENOA, ITALY, BY THE NORTH GERMAN LLOYD STEAMSHIP CO. ° TIME, LESS THAN ELEVEN DAYS, To meet the demand of the American public for some direct and expeditious means of reaching the pore < < the MEDIT .ANEAN during the FALL and WINTE months by steamers of the ea | a of s a coantert. excellence of service, an sine that marks xpress service of the NORDDECTSOHER LLOYD 8.8 Be S Load New York, Southamptca, Bre- have decided to despatch two of thelr wellknown’ xpress steamers from NEW YORK The fine, ay a FULDA and WERRA of 5,000 tons one 7,000 horse power have been designated for rvice, and will sail from NEW YOR for GIB- LDA, Jan. 2, Feb. 6, or Ld WERRA, on. 23, Feb. 2 apn * The time from NEW YORE to GENOA td these Ex- press Steamers is om than ELEVEN da: The traveller can reach ITALY and the shores of the Mediterranean by this route 4 the Fall and Win- ter months, without braving the Northern latitudes of the ATLANTIC, without crossing the C el, and without tedious railroad travel. From GENOA the traveller can proceed to CANNES, NICE, SAN REMO, MENTONE, MONTE CARLO, or other health resort on the RIVIERA and to all polnes in ITALY, in coum sparastvely one eet time by = Travellers bound for CHINA. PAN, and AUSTRALIA can make BM: at GENOA with the fine NORDDEUTSCHER LLOYD IMPERIAL MAIL STEAMERS that touch at that port on their way to the EAST, INDIA, CHINA, and AUSTRALIA Opportunity is offered the Wintersojourner in ITALY or in Southern France to return to RICA by the same route in the early Spring from GENOA. thus en- tirely wees * the rigorous climate of Northern lati- tudes. Apply to OELRICHS & CO., 2 Bowling Green. THE INTERNATIONAL MODERN LANGUAGE SERIES. Esckmann- Chatrian, Madame _ Thérése. E‘ited and annot:ted by George W. Rollins, Master in the Boston Vatin School. 70 cents. George Sand. La Famille de Germandre. Adapted and anno'‘ated by Augusta C. Kimball, Girle’ Hizh School, Bost: n. Edited by Professor Ferdinand Bécher, Harvard University: | , Montaigne. De I'Institution des Enfans. (Texte original de 1589.) 25 cents. Moliere. Le Misanthrope. (Texte original.) 25 cents, Racine. 25 cents, Fact by mail, postpaid, on receiptof the prices given ve.

Andromaque. (Texte de 1697.) GINN & COMPANY, Publishers _ BOSTON, NEW YORK, CHICAGO AND LONDON. CORSON’S Introduction to Browning. NEW EDITION With additional matter, portrait of Browning from recent photograph, and facsimile of letter to the au- thor. The book now contains thirty-four poems with not s and introductions, and four critical essays, Price, postpaid, $1.50 D. C. HEATH & CO., Publishers, _5 SOMERSET ST., BOSTON. ‘WHAT SALARY Does Speaker Crisp receive? For answer see Mowry’s ‘Elements of Civil Gov- ernment,’ p. 87. Mailed to any address on receipt of introductory price, 72 cents, SILVER, BURDETT & CO., 6 HANCOCK AVENUE, BOSTON, MASS. STUDY AND TRAVEL. Mrs. Benj. Fuller Smith announces that she will con- tinue to receive into her family in Dresden, Germany, pe a number of young ladies desiring to study

Mrs. Smith travels with her party during the sum- mer months and holidays. Information concerning expenses furnished upon application. bat Fag ne given and re- q . Address BENJ. FOLLER SMITH, Care Messrs. Thode & Co.. Bankers. Dreaden. Carbolate of Tar Inhalant. Catarrh, Deafness, Bronchitis, Consumption, Asth* ma, cured at home. ‘New Pp hlet and full particu- lars free. Address, naming this pe paper, DR. M. W. CASE, 809 North Broad Street, Philadelphia Pa.

Page 25