The Nation 1891-12-03: Vol 53 Iss 1379

Page 1

RTP a ae 2c = ! rE ww

ws. Ee Site ee he Nation.

The Week. Tur latest ‘health bulletin” upon Mr. Blaire’s condition i3 sufficiently explicit, both in its contents and in the circum- stances of its publicat on, to command the thoughtful attention of President Harrison. According to the Philadelphia 2 esx, which publishes the bulletin, Mr. Blaine visit ed Philadelphia on Friday last for the express purpose of having bimself ex amined with a view to ascertaining his ability to withstand the strain of another Presidential campaign. ‘‘ A close friend of the Secretary,” says the /?} - ; t iy ; e ’ ,¢ for the Speakership, Having dispose a of “an nth, Mee is this matter, Mr. Carlisle adverts to another of even creatcr interest, 7. ¢., the _ <4 the Democrats in Congress on the silver ques y thie fete " - tion. Upon this point the Senator from Ker ids very sound views,

tucky he He says that the Demecratic party is united on the tariff question, but divided on the silver question, ‘Why shall we,” he asks , ‘on the eve ofa great national contest, when victory is al- most within cur grasp, abandon or ignore a vital issue, upon which we are united, and waste our strength in a fruitless controversy among ourselves over questions which can be better adjusted after it has been deter- mined what part of their earnings the peo- ple shall be permitted to keep?” The impor tance of this de'iverance by Mr. Carlisle can hardly be overestimatcd when we consider the commanding position he holds in the party,

5 f- shit 3+ . cama aA a before the public in about the same degree having been thrice Speaker of the House,

Page 2

on 4 i 4 "5% zh” “G aA I i bad whey oe a ae ee ° a) at + FEE I ae EERO OEE ee tt, pee pal rere Fao), ae oe a a Kept Rh Be ae ingot tee. Nahant: BS; Khe PE Sia 418 ‘The Nation. [Vol. 53, No. 1370 and representing a free-coinage State in the national Senate. It is not to be supposed that Mr. Carlisle wrote these words without due consultation end due understanding. We look upon bis letter as very nearly equivalent to a guarantee that no free-coin- age bill will pass Congress during the com- ing session. Senator Pugh of Alabama has written a very unwise and schismatic letter on the silver question in reply to Senator Carlisle. We call this letter schismatic for two rea- sons: first, because it tends to divide the Democratic party into two factions to be beaten in detail by their common enemy, the Republican party; (2) because it proposes to introduce a new plank in the platform of the Democratic party in advance of the meeting of the National Convention, The last convention, the one which met at St. Louis on the 7th of June, 1888, did not pass any resolution on the silver question, but it did endorse the financial policy of the Cleveland Administration as ‘‘wise and conservative.” It declared that that policy had ‘‘ not only averted disaster, but greatly promoted the prosperity of the people.” We all know what that policy was touching the si:ver question. It was diametrically op- posed to the policy which Senator Pugh ad- vocates, and which he now wants to thrust into the platform in advance of the meeting of the Convention. We have little fear that the party in Congress will go ahead of the Convention and run down a steep place into the sea, but if it doesso, its fate will be sealed as surely as was that of the Ohio Democrats when they put free coinage into their plat- form. If free coinage wou'd not win in Ohio this year, what is the chance of its winning in any Northern State next year? Senator Pugh cannot take leave of the subject in hand without a fling at ‘“‘ Wall Street.” This is the usual mark of the demagogue in financial matters. Wall Street happens to be the most convenient place for settling the balance of trade of the country—that of Alabama as well as that of California and of Maine. It may not always be so, but it is so now, and thus it comes about that money ac- cumulates there in the shape of bankers’ balances, Now the accumulation of money anywhere is a good target for demagogues, It is of no consequence who ownsit. It is of no consequence if all the people of the United States who own anything beyond the clothes on their backs have some share of this money or some interest in it. It is ‘Wall Street” just the same—a terrible monster and an object of loathing and hor- ror to Congressmen of a certain type. What Mr. Pugh’s type is we can judge from a sam- ple of his legislation on the statute-book. Some years ago there was a bill pending in the Sena‘e to extend the National Bank Act —the original act being about to expire by jimitation. This was a fine chance for some- body to do some harm to the system, and Mr. Pugh embraced it. He offered an amendmert providing that no bank should be a member of a clearing-house where si!- ver certificates were not received in settle- ment of balances. Silver certificates are not legal tender. The Government has nothing to do with clearing-houses any more than it has with any kind of labor-saving machine, A clearing-house is a contrivance for swap- ping checks. The banks meet in a common place for this purpose, instead of each one sending a messenger to all the others to col- lect what is due to it, at the risk of being robbed on the street. Mr. Pugh’s amend- ment, therefore, provided in effect that un- less national banks would accept something which was not legal tender in the payment of balances among themselves, they should be required to send messengers daily through the streets with piles of money at the risk of being robbed. Strange to say, this amendment was actually adopted by a wise Senate, and is now on the statute-book, It is worth!ess and nugatory, however, for all purpores, because it did not provide that the banks shou!d yay silver certificates to each other as well as receive them. There are not many ‘‘morais” to be drawn from the full official figures of the recent election in th’s State. Mr. Sheehan, the Di mocrat’c candidate for Lieutenant Govy- erncr, ran 6,882 vctes kehird Mr. Flower; and Mr. Vrooman, the Republican candi- date for the same office, ran 6,621 votes ahead of Mr, Fissett. The total vote cf a'l parties for Governor was 1,161,853, against 1,317,263 for Governor in 1888, and 1,026,- 239 for Governcr in 1885. Mr. Flow- ers total vote is over 81,000 greater than that cast for Hill in 1885, and Mr. Fas- sett’s is over 43,000 greater than that cast for Davenport in the same year. In com- parison with the vote for Governor in the Presidential year of 1888, Mr. Flower has over 67,000 Jess votes than [ill received, and Mr, Fassett has over 97,000 less than War- ner Miller received, though Miller received in that election over 19,000 less votes than Harrison. A curious revelation of this year’s returns is the total for the Probibition can- didate for Governor, namely, 30,353, against 30,231 in 1888, and 30,867 in 1885. The oflicial canvass of the Massachusetts election shows a total vote fcr Governor this month of 321,673. This isa poll with- out precedent in the record of State elec- tions, the only approach to it being the 312,357 votes in the year when Butler was beaten for rélection. In 1889 the total was but 263,047, and in 1890, when Congress- men also were elected, it rose no higter than 285 526. Last month’s contest brought out within 23 000 of the Presidential vote of 344,448 in 1888, and the result thus in every aspect records the most impressive verdict ever rendered by the voters of the State in such an election. The Republican State ticket below its head received votes rising from 150,697 on the Auditorship to 157,216 for the very popular candidate for Lieutenant Governor. The Democratic no- minee for the latter oftice had 145,865, which appears to represent the normal strength of his party, so that on the purely partisan issue the Republicans ought to have elected the Governor by over 11,000 plurality. Gov. Russell received 157,982, wh'ch was 12,000 more than the regular Democratic vote, and 6,467 more than his Republican op- fonent. Apparently about two thousand of the extra 12,000 came from the People’s par- ty, which polled only 1,772 for its candidate for Governor, but ran up its vote for Secre- tary of State to 3,729. Another thousand came from the Socialist Labor party, which cast 2,525 for Auditor, but only 1,429 for Governor. About fifteen hundred more seem to have voted for some of the minor candidates on the Prohibition ticket, but to have supported Russel! for Governor, The remainder of his lead, somewhere be- tween 8,000 and 9,000, represents Repub- licans who stood by their party on the rest of the ticket, but proved their independence by voting for the other party’s man for Gov- ernor, on the simple ground that he was bet- ter qualified to fill the office. When ihe Postmaster- General advertised for bids under the Mail-Subsidy Law, be laid out a roseate programme with his sixty-tw« routes, several of them transat'antic and others calling for the establishment of new lines to South America and different parts of the known and unknown world, At the time the bids were opened, on Qcto- ber 26, it was found that but eleven routes were bid upon. Of these, four call- ed for the opening of new lines, It now appears, however, that two of the four showed some ‘‘irregularities” in the bids, and had to be rejected, namely: the Boston- Liverpool route, upon which the ‘‘Columbia Safety Steamship Company ” was to put a fleet of first-class vessels earning $4 a mile from the Government, and the New Orleans Colon route, for which the Pacific Mail Company put in a bid. That modest or- ganization seems to have withdrawn tbis bid, apparently for fear that the new law might be brought into discredit if a clear majority of all the contracts should turn up in its hands, Asitis, it has four routes out of the nine upon which bids were accepted. Three of the others go to companies having established lines, upon which they will not need to put a single new ship or other improvement, and for operating which pre- cisely as they do now they are to get a bounty from the Government with no ser- vice rendered therefor. Some secoud-class ships are to begin running between New York and Buenos Ayres on December 1, 1894, provided nothing happens in the meantime to discourage the contractor. He has a route upon which an experi- enced steamship president has said that thé Augu:ta Victoria could not comply with the conditions of speed, yet he proposes to undertake the job with second-class steam- ers. The other new vessels to be built un- der the law are all fourth-class, We do not wonder that the great subsidy advocate, the Tribune, took two days to comment upon pike ai Shas em e SByt ROD ESM RMAC EAE LS. 1 De eS COE Ey NE

Page 3

pes lab eA Dec. 3, 1891} The Nation. 419 this result of its famous policy—nine routes, of which the Pacific Mail Steamship Com- pany, of odorous memory, gets four! A year or two ago, when McKinleyism was rather more aggressive than it is now, we were told that the increased tax on this or that article would amount to only three cents per head of the people of the United States. The people, however, decided, so far as they have been able yet to decide, that they would rather keep the three cents them- selves. And now the organ of the Manufac- turers’ Club in Philadelphia, playing a vari- ation on the tune, tells us that the sugar bounty will be only $9,000,000 this year, whereas the receipts from the tax on beer will be $28,000,000. In other words, the beer tax will pay the sugar bounty and leave $19,000,000 to the good. Again it says that the tobacco tax will yield $33,000,000, or enough to pay the sugar bounty three and a-half times. Contemplating the internal revenue as a gi‘t enterprise, it says that the sum 80 Collected will pay all the pen- sions and the sugar bounty, and leave a remainder of $15,000,000. This is a most dangerous suggestion, since it noti- fies all the people of the United States who are willing to take a bounty, where it may be obtained. Think of fifteen millions of unclaimed money! It is like the estates in the Bank of England that are awaiting heirs from the Smiths, Halls, and Joneses whose progenitors emigrated to America in the time of Charles I. The Boston Journal of Commerce has taken pains to get at the bottom facts re- garding the recent reduction of wages in the iron works of Jones & Laughlin of Pitis- burgh. Several contradictory stories have been in circulation regarding this mat- ter. Mr. Joms is the ex-Chairman of the Republican National Committee, hav- ing been the immediate predecessor of Quay in that position. Consequently, many Republican papers have been unwilling to believe that wages had been reduced by his firm. It was almost as bad as the bankruptcy of the Chairman of the American Protective Tariff League soon after the pas- sage of the McKinley Bill. The Boston newspaper says that, in consequence of the conflicting stories, it ‘‘ took occasion to as- certain the facts from an entirely reliable source, and outside of the firm.” The find- ing is as follows: “On Thursday, November 5, an order went into effect which affected the wages of several hundred men empioyed as laborers, but the change was not absolute as regards a reduc- tion in pay. In ail, about 1,200 men were in- cluded; all are now required to work ten hours per day, instead of nine as f« rmer- ly. Some had their wages reduced ircm $1.50 to $1.35 per dav, but not the entire 1,200 laborers. The virtual decrease made by the added workiag time affects, perhaps, 400 more. In those cases where no extra working time was added the pay was cut, and in seve- ral depsrtments both changes were made.” We advise that this paragraph be clipped out and collated with some Cozens, or scores, or hundreds of other like testimo- nials to the advantages reaped by labor from the McKinlev Bill. “G.W. 8.” writes to the 7ridune that some- body of the name of Curtice Bond has been casting aspersions on the fair fame of Mr. Blaine by a Dalziel telegram to the London press ‘‘G.W. 8S.” has had a conversation on this subject with ‘‘a person in authority ’ named X—he seldom has intercourse with persons of lower grade. The narrative, as he gives it, proceeds in this way: * You will not have forgotten one shameless attack on Mr. Blaine which was sent over here by Dalziei’s New York agency; one for wb ch Mr. Curtice Bond assumed the responsibility in his cbarecter of Mr. Blaine’s friend. On the mcrning when it was publi-hed in the Times 1 said to a person in authority, who must have read the despatch: ** Look here, X. Suppose I should cable to New York tbat Lord Salisbury bad a pariner in the sealing business in Hering Sea, and that he was preventing a settlementand sacrificing his country to h's partner, and for the sake of his own share in the plunder, what would you say ?’ ‘** What on earth do you tnean ?’ ‘“*] mean that that is exactly what Mr. Blaine is esccused of in the Dalziel despatch from New York in this morning’s Times.’ ** He reflected a moment, and answered: “* Well, itisasheme, I never looked at it in that light before.’ ** By which I understood bim tu mean that so long us the calumny affected Mr. Blaine only, it never struck him as a calumny; apply it to Lord Salist-ury, and the infamy of the charge, and of him who made it, became apparent at once.” Yes, but suppose he had cabled to New York that Lord Salisbury had written a letter to a person applying for a Government charter, or land grant, or favor of some sort, saying: ‘‘I will not be a deadhesd in this enterprise. Kind regards to Mrs. Fisher.” The effect of this kind of acabiegram would have been serious, because Lord Salisbury is not suspected of writing that kind of let- ters. With Mr. Blaine the cuse is different, and therefore cablegrams of this kind occa- sion no surprise, and few people take pains to ask whether they are true or not. Some doubt appears to exist as to the provisions of the Brazilian Constitution in regard to filling the Presidency in case of a vacancy such as has just occurred, even the Brazilian Minister in Washington not being able last week to enlighten a newspsper correspondent on the subject Article 41, section 1, of the Constitution of Brazil declares that the Vice-President, ‘“ elect- ed simultaneously with the President, shall serve in place of the latter in case of impediment, and succeed him in case of vacancy in the Presidency.” But article 42 adds: ‘‘In case of vacancy from any cause in the Presidency or Vice-Presi dency before the expiration of the first two years of the Presidential term, a new elec- tion shall be held.” As Fonseca’s term had not yet covered a single year, it is clear that Vice-President Peixoto can succeed him only temporarily. The regular date for Presidential elections is March 1, and it may be that a new choice will be made then. The Congress, st the time of its dissolu- tion, Was engaged upon legislation carrying out the provisions of the Constitution a relating to the Presidency, but had enacted no measure which would direct in the pre sentemergency. Much depends, therefore, upon the kind of man Peixoto turns out to be. Congress has been reconvened by him, and the whole question of the successicn may be settled this month in an orderly and lawful manner. Everything now promises a continuance of the republican form of government, though, for Brazil, it must be a form in adouble sense for a long time to come, Our esteemed contemporary, the Prasiian Republic, favored us with thirty-five copies of its issue of September 19, and a like number of its issue of September 26. We were somewhat at a loss to account for such a generous remembrance until we came upon the following editorial admission “We bave a contract with the Brazilian Government, in virtue of which we send to Europe 1,000 copies, 1,000 to the United States and Cana fa, apd 1,00) more we are distribut- ingia Brazil. The amounts ;aid? That is our business The objects sought? To spread the clear light of truth, ete.” After that there can be no question of the editor's entire sincerity and disinterestedness when he proceeds to sing the praises of ‘‘the best of Brazilian statesmen.’ He re fers to the man who had given him his con- tract, Baron Lucena, who has since accom panied Fonseca to retirement. We fear that the contract is now in danger of cancella tion, and that we shall have to get along, in the future, with a single copy of our un purchasable contemporary. The acute financial embarrassment of the Spanish Government is somewhat difficult to account for in view of the prosperous condition of Spain’s foreign trade as re- vealed in the returns for 1890, just pub- lished. The exports reached a value of $187,551.976, a cain of $10,180,000 over those of 1889, and the imports amount- ed to $189.427,585, an increase of $14,- 965 260. The preceding year, moreover, showed a considerable advance over the re sults attained in recent years, so that the last year ought to represent a high degree of prosperity; and, as the national revenues are largely derived from customs duties, the embarrassment of the Treasury seems sin- gular. If the public declarations of an ex- Minister are to be believed, the explana- tion is to be found in the extraordinary in- competence and dishonesty of the civil ser- vice. The Government ought to have a sufficient revenue from the existing laws of taxation, be asserts, but too much of the money collected from the taxpayers never enters the Treasury. We cannot enter into the arguments which the ex- Minister advances, except to say that the charge of incompetence is universally ad- mitted, and to such a degree that it comes to about the same thing as dishonesty. That is to say, the spoi's system, which has full swing in Spain, loads so many men upon the civil service whose only cleim is partisan ac- tivity, that the whole service is thoroughly demoralized. : 4

Page 4

Sate aia st alah antes ets wn re Ort a i “e i mish Sr pe ferme maagies age 4.20 The Nation. [Vol. 53, No. 1379 HOW RECIPROCITY WAS SET GOING. Tue evidence which we presented a fort- night ago to show that the reciprocity agree- ment with Brazil was dishonorably ob- tained by Mr. Biaine, has gone uncontra- dicted, That neither he nor Mr. Mendonca has denied the fact, although the latter at least, as we know, has been asked to deny it, isan added and strong proof that the charges recite the truth. Butit has been said that there is an antecedent absurdity in sup- posing that Mr. Blaine could have promised to shut out Cuban sugar from the free mar- ket accorded the Brazilian product, in view of the fact that the Aldrich amendment to the McKinley Bill made the offer of recipro- city to all countries, Thus Gen. J. W. Fos- ter was reported as saying: ‘‘ No person or government having a knowledge of the law of Congress under which the negotiations were carried on, could have been misled by any such alleged promise. The third section of the Tariff Act is an offer to all countries,” etc. The Boston Jour- nal has said that this statement of the case makes the charge against Mr. Blaine *‘ ridiculous.” It may be well, therefore, to review the history of the reciprocity clause and its working, in order to show that Mr. Blaine was in desperate need of getting some country to appear to accept that legis lation seriously, and so to have an example to hold up before the others, Going back to the fall of 1889, we find Mr. Blaine negotiating a genuine reciprocity treaty with Brazil. Commissioners from that country were in Washington, on the in- vitation of our Government, empowered to offer certain concessions, and were ready to accept Mr. Blaine’s offer of free sugar as a suflicient equiva'ent. No secrecy was affected about this, and, indeed, during the Senate de- bates on the reciprocity clause it was distinct- ly stated as an objection to making sugar free that it would upset the treaty which Mr. Blaine and the Brazilians were on the point of signing. Before that, as is well known, Mr. Blaine had cast all his influence against free sugar in the House; and his fierce denunciation of the McKinley Bill, with the famous hat-smashing episode in the presence of the Senate Committee on Finance, were the direct result of his disap- pointment at the loss of his sole available material for a treaty. Then came the reciprocity manceuvres iu the Senate. McKinley in the House had argued for free sugar solely on the ground of revenue reduciion; the Aldrich amend- ment coolly asserted that sugar was made free ‘‘ with a view to secure reciprocal trade.” This did not suit Mr. Blaine any better. His ideas were brought out unmistakably in his letter to Senator Frye, and more especially in the amend- ment and remarks of Senator Hale, offered as they were, without any concealment, in the name of the Secretary. What the latter wanted was the restoration of sugar to the dutiable list, with the proviso that the Presi- dent should be authorized, ‘ without any further legislation, to declare the ports of the United States free and open to all products of any nation of the American hemisphere, whenever and so long as such nation” should give free entry to certain exports of the United States. This was a fair and reasonable basis of reciprocity. We would call attention, how- ever, to the fact that Mr. Blaine intended to exclude Cuba as well as Canada from its operation. In his letter to the President, transmitted by the latter to the Senate, he took. pains to speak of the countries rep- resented in the Pan-American Congress, and the nations of the American hemisphere, as the sole ones with which he wished to secure reciprocity. The peculiar phraseology he employed, as also that of the Hale amend- ment, was commented upon in the Senate, and it was admitted that it was intended to shut out Cuba and Canada. Neither of those countries sent delegates to the Pan- American Congress, and neither of them is an independent nation. This is a point which those would do well to remember who now assert that it would have been preposterous for Mr. Blaine to hold out the idea to the Brazilians that he would favor their sugar and shut out the Cuban product. He certainly intended to do that in the beginning, however his conduct may have been shaped by circumstances subse- quently. But the Senate ‘rejected Mr. Blaine’s plan and accepted the Aldrich amendment. It did this in the face of Senator Evarts’s unan- swerable argument against its constitution- ality, and with the unconcealed idea that it would be taken as so much buncombe, and would never have any practical effect. Thus, Senator Hoar expressed the general sentiment on the Republican side when he said, after tacitly admitting that the Aldrich amendment was unconstitutional : “Tregard the amendment . . . rather as a declaration of purpose than as a defini- tion of legislative policies and enactments.” The House finally accepted the amendment, with Speaker Reed’s cynical remarks about it as the best indication of the spirit in which the action was taken. It was regard. ed as a harmless bit of sentiment, which might serve its purpose in the can- vass, and then would never be _ heard of any more. The Brazilian negotiators themselves had declared that if Congress made sugar free, they should have nothing more to ask of this country, and so there would be no basis foratreaty. That the President wou'd ever exercise the unconsti- tutional power voted him in the Aldrich amendment was universally regarded as out of the question, especially after the over- whelming Republican defeat in November, 1890. These, then, were the circumstances under which Mr. Blaine set about securing a reci- procity agreement with Brazil. The repre- sentatives of that country had said there was no Jonger room for a treaty; they had already received from this country the last favor they could ask. Yet it was not long before they were recommending a treaty to their home Government, and doing it, so four ex-members of that Government assert, because Mr. Blaine had assurcd them that he would secure free sugar for them and re- fuse it to Cuba. Without some such pro- mise, their action is wholly unintelligible, On Mr. Blaine’s part there was need of some such way of getting reciprocity started, if the whole thing was not to flash in the pan. With one country accepting it, he could persuade or bully others into doing so, and, in fact, as soon as tbe Brazilian agreement was made public, the joyful 7ribune hailed it as the means of exerting ‘‘powerful pressure” upon other countries, Thus, far from there being an antecedent ab- surdity in the Secretary’s promise to Brazil, we have shown that no other hypothesis so well explains the facts—this, be it remem- bered, apart from the positive evidence which we have advanced to show that there was such a promise, and which, as we said above, has gone uncontradicted. GOV. RUSSELL ON THE MASSACHU- SEITS ELECTION. THERE is no polit’cal leader who is surer of a hearing than the young man who was re- elected Governor of Massachusetts three weeks ago, after a most exciting canvass and on the largest vo‘e ever cast there in a State election. There is no subject, too, about which the public would rather have his views than the significance of this very elec- tion, upon which Gov. Russell contributes an article to the December number of the Forum. The Governor begins with a reference to the contest of 1890, when, for the first time since the war, the Democrats elected a ma- jority of the Congressmen and a Democratic Governor, after a campaign which was ‘‘chiefly directed against the McKinley Bill.” He recounts the desperate efforts made by the Republicans ever since his in- auguration last January ‘‘ to redeem Massa- chusetts,” telling how they made fheir or- ganization more thorough and efficient than ever before, formed a State club and local c’ubs, opened their campaign a fortnight before the Democrats, covertly ap- pealed to race and religious prejudice, put the Collector of Boston and other Federal officials upon the stump, held more cam- paign mee'ings than had ever been known even in a Presidential year, and, in short, made a ‘supreme effort” to win. They had always claimed that the result in 1890 was a spap judgment upon a small vote, aod that a full poll would restore the old Re- publican majority; but, although the total proved to be 36,000 larger than in 1890, the Democratic Governor was re@lected by & plurality but little diminished. The importance of this result, in Gov. Russell’s opinion, arises from the fact that the Republican leaders made their campaign chiefly upon national issues. ‘‘They de- clared from every stump that the electoral vote of Massachusetts would be in danger in 1892 if a Democratic Governor were re- elected in 1891.” The Democrats were glad to meet them on this line. National issues were aggressively raised in their platform; such Congressional leaders as Mills, McMil- lin, and Springer took the stump; the tariff issue was kept at the front, and the McKinley ST Mi 74 ips Sap is A a Ce ee et

Page 5

pent: STI RSE AE Dec. 3, 1891] The Nation. 421 Bill was made the subject of constant at- tack. ‘Democratic success was won in Massachusetts last year upon this issue, and victory was agaio achieved this year largely upon the same ground.” Gov. Russell shows how the Democrats put the Republicans upon the defensive on the silver question, by adopting a platform which placed the party definitely and ag- gressively in favor of a sound currency and in opposition to the dangerous law passed by the last Republican Congress. While not claiming that the silver question was impor tant enough to affect the result materially, Gov. Russell thinks that the attitude of the Democrats towards it helped the party to achieve its victory. But the main element was the growth of tariff-reform sentiment. The Democrats declared for the repeal of all provisions in the McKinley Bill which raise duties, and also for the repeal of all taxes upon food, fuel, fibres, ores, and crude or partly manufactured materials necessary in the processes of the State’s domestic in- dustries. Nearly the whole iron industry of Massachusetts, and a large section of the wool manufacturing industry, have been brought by the pressure of business interests to adopt this position in favor of free raw materials, and the Democrats thus appealed to a com- munity which was in a mood to hear their arguments with candor. Upon the signifi. cance of the election as affecting this issue, Gov. Russell quotes in his article from his speech delivered in Faneuil Hall on the day before the election, in confident anticipation of the result actually reached: ‘‘ It means, first, that Massachuset's adheres to her de- mand of last year for free raw materials, for the benefit of Ler industries and her people. It means that she demands that her sons— first, last, and always—shall stand for her rather than for Ohio or Pennsy)vania, and that she stands behind those sons who have stood true to her, It means that she is will- ing to take her chance in any fair compe- tition, but she demands that in that compe- tition her hands shall not be tied. She ob- jects to a policy that would destroy her na- tural advantages; she protests against law holding the knife that would cut the throat of any of her industries. True to her history and her traditions, true to the great agitations that she has led for humar rights, for free- dom and equality, she protests against un- equal and unjust taxation.” Gov. Russell’s remarks as to the prospects of the Massachusetts Democracy in the fu- ture will be read with lively interest. He points out that the recent growth of the party dates from the Presidential election of 1884, when ‘‘a large body of independent voters, including many of the most distin- guished and influential men in the State, left the Republican party.” Since then these voters have been gradually becoming more closely attached to the Democratic party, until he thinks that to-day nearly all of them are in its ranks. Cleveland’s Administration did much to strengthen his party in the State and to give it the support of the busi- ness community. The Governor concludes: “It cannot be claimed that Massachusetts can yet be counted as a Democratic State, whatever she may become in the immediate future; but the two last elections have shown that she is a State where the balance of power is held by a body of independent voters whose political action is guided by principle, and who are firm supporters of tariff reform. The Democratic party of Massachusetts cannot bold out to the national Democracy any strong prospect of securing the electoral vote of Massachusetts next year for any candidates, or for any policies, which cannot command this support; but these voters have now every inclination to continue to give their support to the Democratic cause, and a reasonable course on the part of the national Democracy will probably make Massachusetts a Democrat- ic Statein 1892. In order to attain this end, it is of paramount importance that the tariff question should be kept atthe frontin the next Congress, and that it should be made the one great issue of the Presidential campaign. If the Democratic party should commit itself —as fortunately there is now very little chance that it will—to the free coinage of silver, it must be frankly acknowledged that the Demo- cratic ticket would have little chance of suc- cess in New England in 1892, whatever might be its prospects elsewhere. We have shown in Massachusetts that we can hold what we bave won vron a vote 82,900 larger than tbat of last year [the officia! count makes it 56,000 larger] The Demceracy of this State is united and aggressive, and under favcrable condi- tions it believes that it can acain hold its own upon the yet larger vote which will be cast in the Presidential vear. It only asks of the na- tional Democracy a fair opportunity to make this contest.” This is the sort of talk which must have effect, for it comes, not from a ‘‘ doctri- naire” or ‘‘ theorist,” but from a politician who has just won one of the greatest victo- ries in recent politica! history. There is no more ‘‘ practical man” extant than one who can not only carry a State long controlled by the opposite party, when the ‘tidal wave” runs his way, but can do it over again a vear later, in face of unexampled opposition. What politicians always want to find out is how to carry elections. Gov. Russell has shown that he knows the way. THE SILVER SITUATION. Some little interest has been infused into the silver discussion by Mr. J. Edward Simmons’s suggestion in the columns of the Evening Test that the Secretary of the Tres sury be invested with power to sell silver bullion as well as to buy it, in order to re- plenish his gold resources. Secretary Fos- ter, in his speech at the Chamber of Com- merce dinner, had declared that he had the right, under existing law, to sell bonds bearing interest as high as 5 per cent., in or der to replenish bis stock of gold, if neces- sary. He had also affirmed that it was his duty to do so whenever that contingency should arrive. ‘‘ Why not sell some of the silver?” asks Mr. Simmons. The same question came into the mind of the late Secretary Windom, when he was wrestling with the silver problem soon after the Harrison Administration came into pow- er. Mr. Windom saw that something evil would grow out of that clause in the Re- publican platform which condemned the Cleveland Administration for its unfriendli ness to silver. So he began very early to ‘*start a back fire.” One of his plans was that the Government should buy silver and issue notes on it, and then sell the silver to redeem the notes on presentation, or at least to retain the option to sell it. But this did not please the silver-men, The silver- miners saw that if this plan were carried into effect, the Government would cease to be a buyer of any net amount of their pro duct. The Treasury would be like a ware- house which buys wheat at some times and sells it at other times, really exercising no influence on the market. The siiver-pro ducers would lose their special favors, and be relegated to the condition of the producers of other things. The sil- ver-men who are not miners, but who call themselves ‘‘the debtor class,” or claim to represent that class, opposed the selling of any silver because that would tend to pre- vent depreciation of the standard of va'ue What they wanted was a cheaper dollar—a seventy-cent dollar or something lower—and they knew it would be impossible to get this if the Secretary had the power to se!l silver for gold in order to redeem his Treasury notes. So Mr. Windom’s plan fell through. Nevertheless, there isa good deal of virtue in it, and we shall hope to hear more about it ty and by. The silver situation is one which can not last. The purchase of seven tons of bullion per day to be stored in dark places is too great a strain upou the Treasury, and is becoming too gro- teeque for the public sense of humor. See retary Foster has his eve fixed on Europe, and is looking anxiously for signs of relief from that quarter, in the shape of a new bi- metallic conference. Mr. Jesse Seligman has been cruising around with a quasi-diplo- matic mission to bring the Continental Powers into the movement. Somewhat ear- lier another gentleman visited England for the same purpese. A cab'e telegram the other day said that Mr. Seligman had had an interview with M. Ribot, the French Minister of Foreign Affairs, and that the latter had said that, while he sym pathized with Mr. Seligman’s views, France could not take the initiative in calling a new conference, and that Mr. Seligman had thereupon gone to Egypt to spend the win ter, In the convenient company of the Sphinx that amiable gentleman may learn quite as much about the future of bimetal lism as from all the cabinets of Europe. It isthe common opinion now that Con- gress will do nothing with silver this winter, This opinion is grounded upon the trium- phant success of the Democrats in New York and Massachusetts on anti silver plat- forms, and their humiliating defeat in Ohio on a free-coinage p'atform. If Congress does nothing, the purchase of seven tons of bullion per day will go on until the Treasu- ry breaks down under the strain and the Secretary begins to sell bonds to replenish his gold balance. It would be a mistake to suppose, however, that the silver extremists will remain quiet. They see the danger that awaits them when bond-selling becomes necessary. That would mean that the people of the United States were borrowing money in order to pay silver miners a higher price for their work than the market affords. There are few persons so squint-eyed that they cannot see this when the bond-selling be- gins. Naturaliy, in such a case many would join Mr. Simmons in asking, ‘‘ Why not sell the silver instead of selling bunds”? : i

Page 6

- i cH & a B : # ee a i a bel 3 = 8 ae a 3 a esccibs: sec ape q t ; | t ‘ ot Pe a

en 3 We Pe aR WR oF 4:22 The Nation.

[Vol. 53, No. 1379

This danger, this rock ahead, is clearly perceived by the silverites, and they will try to avoid it by a change in the present law, if they cannot do more. The first change they will ask will be an amendment to compel the coining of all the bullion bought by the Government, because bullion can be more easily sold than coin. The public would see good reasons for selling bullion when they would not see reasons for selling coin. To get the daily quota of seven tons of bullion into the form of standard dollars will be the first push of the silver crowd if they are not strong enough to pass a free-coinage bill. Very likely they will try also to repeal the clause which declares it to be the purpose of the Government to keep the different kinds of money at par with each other. If they do this, they will proclaim their own in tention tu depreciate the standard of value and to demonetize gold, It will be worth something to have this purpose set forth in black and white.

THE PROSPECT IN ENGLAND. Tse English Conservatives have followed the example of the Liberals in getting up a ** convention,” not for the purpose of nomi- nating candidates, as in this country, but simply to enable the chief men of the party to make speeches and compare views on the party prospects. In other words, the Con- servative Convention at Birmingham is an answer to the Liberal Convention at Newcastle, The Conservatives formally join issue with the Liberals, not only on Home Rule, but on the disestablishment of the Anglican Church both in Wales and in Eng- land, and, in spite of the past promises of the Ministry, the Convention voted against the bestowal of local government on Ireland. In the opinion of good observers, however, the Irish Local Government Bill foresha- dowed by Mr. Balfour will be introduced just the same in the next session, with the hope or expectation that some excuse for dropping it before the dissolution of Parlia- ment will be furnished by Liberal obstruc- tion. If this should come about, the Ministry would be able to go to the country at the gene- ral election with the cry that they had tried to give the Irish all the management of their own affairs that was good for them, but were prevented by the Liberal-Irish coali- tion. If on this the Conservatives came back to the House with a good majority, proba bly nothing more would be heard of the scheme. A great many good old-fashioned Tories dislike it, and if it were proved that the Ministry could win without it, it would be definitively laid aside. The Liberals are, however, fully prepared for this pro- gramme, and have determined, if Mr. Balfour introduces the bill, not to fur- nish any excuse for failure to pass it. The secret belief of the leading Tories,from Lord Salisbury down, is that arbitrary rule, to the extent provided by the Coercion Act, is good enough for the Irish, but they. are afraid to avow this doctrine to the new de- mocratic constituencies in England. What is most interesting in the rival plat- forms of the two parties is the way in which

they are trying to outbid each other for the votes of the laborers, especially the agricul- tural laborers. These until now have been an unknown quantity in electoral calcula- tions. The belief of the Tories when they extended the franchise— one of the pleasing humbugs invented by Beaconsfield—was that the Squire and the Parson, who are natural Conservatives, would be able to con- trol the Jabor vote in the country districts, so that the new democracy would be ‘‘a Tory Democracy,” and would stand for Church and King against the wicked Radi- cals and levellers of the towns. But this is now turning out to be a complete delusion. It is admitted on all hands that the agricul- tura! laborer is, as a voter, in full revolt against his old patrons and guides, It has taken him until now, for he is not quick-wit- ted, to find out that he can vote as he pleases, and there is much reason to believe that the party of his choice, for the present at least, will be the party to which the Squire, the Parson, and the Farmer do not belong. Like the negroes of the South after their enfran- chisement, he feels that his employers are not to be trusted politically, however kindly his relations with them personally may be. A correspondent of the London Zimes travel- ling through the country looking up election signs and *‘ straws” had been foreshadowing this for some weeks before the South Moul- ton election, at which the Conservatives had such a rude awakening, due mainly to the desertion en masse of the agricultural la- borers. Accordingly, the great Conservative cry now is that something must be done for “‘ La- bor.” One proposal is to apply the chief pro- visions of the latest Irish Land Act to Eng- land. so as to enable laborers to purchase small holdings with Government aid. An- other is to encourage the election of Labor candidates to the House of Commons, pro- vided they are Unionists. Mr. Chamberlain has a scheme of compulsory insurance for sickness and old age, like Bismarck’s, and he is trying to persuade the public, amid more or less laughter, that this is what he had in mind when he talked of the ‘‘ransom” which property-holders owed to the poor for having kept them out of their own so long. Of course, also, the Birmingham Convention resolved in favor of the establishment of ‘‘a labor department,” to be presided over by a Minister of the Crown to be term- ed a ‘‘ Labor Minister.” No political sop for Labor is now complete without some provi- sion for this functionary. What he is to do, or can do, for Labor, nobody ever explains, or indeed knows, but his existence gratifies the workingmen and seems to dignify manual toil in the eyes of the community, besides which, the place is pretty sure to be filled by a laborer. The only service a Labor Department can render or has render- ed the laborer anywhere is the collection of information about wages and strikes, as in the instance of our State Commission. More than this the Government cannct do for the laborer without either depriving him of a portion of his individual freedom by enact ing such measures as a compulsory eight- hour law, or giving him, or compelling some

one else to give him, money which he has not earned, The mischief which all such schemes do, lies in the support they give to that unfortunate superstition of the modern laborer, that the ‘‘ State” has somewhere a reservoir of wisdom and of cash which it can, if the rich and well-to-do will let it, draw on at any time for asudden and im- mense alleviation of the lot of the sons and daughters of toil. That this superstition will not disappear from the modern world without the trial of some very disastrous experiments, is greatly to be feared. Both of the English parties may now be said to have made their final appeal to the constituencies. Their programmes differ only with regard to the Welsh Church and Home Rule With regard to ail other topics they go to the country on their respective reputations for sincerity and real trust in popular capacity and good sense. What the Liberals anticipate from the general election, which will probably take place next spring, is a majority of about ninety, including the Irish. They do not believe they can with this carry a Home Rule Bill without having an- other dissolution forced on them by the House of Lords, but it will hardly do to dissolve again immediately. They will probably stay in office after a check on this question by the Lords, as they have often done before on other questions, but the delay will tell heavily on their leader, That is to say, the chances increase every day that Home Rule will be achieved, if ever, by other hands than Mr. Gladstone's.

THE CITY OF INITIATIVES. PaLerMo, November 13, 1891. ‘ HIRTY-ONE years ago we left Palermo, lite. rally a heap of ruins, with Garibaldi, for Milazzo. The indcmitable islanders who first, in the year of revolutions, 1848, bad thrown down the challenge to the Bourbons, ‘*‘ Reform or Revolution,” had been crushed, nct con- quered. For the next ten years they gave their cppressors no peace, No reforms or constitu- tions would content them now, for they bad realized the truth of Mazzini’s teaching, that no part of Italy could be free or independent until the whole should be united. When Lombardy was freed by the French and Sar- dinian armie:, and the rulers of Italy be- thought themselves only of northern Italy, Sicily determined to “strike the blow” on her own account, Crispi, with a halter round his neck, twice traversed the entire island, promising that if the people took the initiative, their Italian brothers would come to the rescue. They rose in arms and were partly subdued. The conspiracy of the Gancia was discovered, the conspirators exe- | cuted. Then the bands took to the mountains, aid Rosalino Pilo landed in a little fishing- boat, and sent the fiery cross throughout the country with the tidings, ‘‘ Garibaldi is on the way to rescue.” Then Garibaldi landed at Marsala, fought his way up by Calatafimi, dashing in with his red shirts, and Picciotti, crossing the Admiral’s Bridge to beard the lion in his den; and all the pecple rose to welcome him, improvising barricades, defying the troops in the fortresses and in all their posi- tions. Then followed the cruel, useless bom- bardment, then the surrender, and Paiermo in ruins acclaimed the dictator, and at his bid-

Page 7

Dec. 3, 1891] The Nation. 423 ding proclaimed Victor Emanuel Kirg of United ltaly, with Rome for capital. But Garibaldi had the Neapolitan continent yetto free, so that Sicily was leit to herself for a time; the flower of her youth of all classes joining him on the continent to free their Neapolitan brothers, from whom they bad received little kindness nor, it must be confessed, much gratitude for their services. The Piébiscite confirmed the will of the island- ers to form part of united Italy, but for many along year the moral unification was a desi- deratum. The Moderate party, who held the reins of government for sixteen years, under- stood nothing of the nature of the peo le. The Garibaldian leaders were ali ex: elled; the Si- cilians who had taken part in the revolution were looked on as revolutionists ,ure and sim- ple. The island was filled with soldiery, and the law of corscription, which the Bourbons bad never dared to apsly, was most harshly enforced. The Bourbon rulers had treated Sicily as a conquered people: no roads, no rail- roads, no schoo!s; the misery was frightful. The new rulers did nothing for the alleviation of misery or for the amelioration of the eco- nomical and social condition of the priest-rid- den populations, In 1862, when Garibaldiagain landed in Sicily, anc made Palermo his bead- quarters for the campaign to oust the French from Rome, the islanders answered to his call, and for this crime they were made to pay heavily in the following years. Martial law was prociaimed, citizens were shot without trial, the prisons were crowded, the law of suspects was applied without investigation, hundreds were deported to certain places, and in the chief towns civil and military authority was invested in the same person. In 1866, when the law for the sequestration of ecclesi- astical property was pasred, the religious or- ders and numbers of their adherents formed a conspiracy which very nearly succeeded; but the dread of destroying uni y brought out the best qualities of the people, who rallied round the authorities and saved the city from blood- shed. The Marquis di Rudini, now Prime Minister, was then syndic of the city of Palermo, and then, a young man of thirty, he made his mark, That was the time for the governors of Italy to bave studied the nature of the people and to have held out the olive branch. But it was an @ priori conviction with them that Sicily could be governed only with ‘*blood and iron.” So things went from bad to worse until, in 1875, the last Moderate Ministry brought in a bill for the grant by Parliament of fresh exceptional laws; Cantelli, the Home Minister, affirming that Sicily was ungovernable by any ordinary law. He informed the House that at that moment there were 152,000 persons subject to spe- cial surveillance by the police, besides the numbers in prison condemned or awaiting their trial, The fourteen articles of the law proposed were medellkd on the English coer- cion laws for Ireland, four of which were quoted as models. But the committee chosen to examine the law rejected it in toto. ‘*What Sicily wants,” was the conclusion, ‘' is a rigid application of the common law. The island bas ever been treated «es a conauered State. Of all the grants made for roads, railroads, schools, Sicily has not had even a partial share. The agents of police are the scum of the old police force of the dethroned princes. The well-disposed inhabitants have no security that if they help the authorities to discover real malefactors, they will not become victims and be left to fight their own battles.” The law was rejected, and in the following yeer the Ministry fell, Nicotera, the survivor of Pisacane’s expedition, ‘* the wounded of Sa- pri, the galiey-slave of Favignana,” was the first Home Minister of the Liberal party, De- pretis being Premier. Whatever other de- fects he may have had, as a firm administrator of law and justice he has never had a rival. W hile he set himself toextirpate the Camorra in Naples and the Mafia in Sicily, he infused such confidence in the law-abiding and order-loving citizens that they rallied at once to his side. He chose an energetic prefect, Malusardi, who broke entirely with the system of ignoring lawlessness in high places and punishing it only when discovered in the lower ranks of so- ciety. When he entered on his functions, the proprietors of villas and estates in the country round Palermo dared not visit them for fear of blackma! being levied, with the alterna- tive of being seized and kept in caves or grottoes until the sum demanded was pnid down. He succeeded in arresting the chiefs of most of the bands, discovered who were the manutengoli (the go-betweens), and whether they wereruch from willing consent or through fear, The former were first admoni-hed, then, if they continued in their evil practices, were arrested; the latter were protected and en- couraged. In a couple of years the city and the neighborhood were restored to a normal state. The city revived from that hour. Po- litical parties and administrative factions still rage in Palermo, as unfortunately elsewhere in Italy, but, be it said to the honor of the people, all the administrators of the city’s finances and affairs have had the welfare of the citizens at heart, and have not Wasted the substance of the commonwealth in corrupt speculations or in works of useless decoration. The result is that Palermo is transformed— cleansed, sanified, and at the same time beau- tified. I arrived bere some days since after a brief sojourn at Naples, about which city I prefer to write on my return, as at present it is ** un- der the ban”—tbat is, the municipal courcil was dissolved some time since, and a royal commissary appointed. Most of the public institutions are undergoing ‘inspection and inquiry,” so that in this abnormal condition of affairs it is hardly fair to speak in the terms of blame and deprecation which alone could be used. 1 will only say that all that Pasquale Villari wrote about the so-called works of sanitation is inadequate to express the horror with which the state of the wretched inhabitants inspired us) The money voted by the country for the poor of Naples bas been applied entirely to the construction of fresh streets and palatial residences for the well-todo classes, The Porto Pendino and other quarters have been partly destroyed to make room for the new streets and buildings, but not a single house that the peor people ex- pelled can pay for has been built in the quar- ters where they have their occupations; hence all the fondaci and the bassi—cellars, dens, and dog-kennels—of which so much was writ- ten at the time of the cholera, are now doubly crowded by the poor wretches expelled else- where, The filth, the stench, the misery, therefore, is doubled. All this bappens from the insane system adopted by the municipality of contracting with a society of mere sy; ecu- lators, who, of course, bave looked after their own interests and cannot be blamed for so doing. However, the term of the royal com- missary’s authority does not expire till vext month. The Government bas still some power over the Scciety, and even when the next mu- nicipality is elected, ‘“‘something may yet be dona” So we will wait and hope, and report progress or regress aller cur tour, Here in Palermo a quite other system is adopted. Here, as made sad ravages, especial.y in the poorer quarters of the city, and here it was decided that disembowelling (sven{rimentfo) and a tho- rough reform of sanitary necessary. But Palermo is so iittle visited and so little known to the rest of Italy that no national gift was proposed for bene fit. Simply the commune was authorized to con- tract a loan for thirty millions at 3 per cent, to be repaid in thirty years O¢ this not six millions have yet been expended, and yet the whole city strikes you as having been rebuilt. So entirely is this the ca-e that, after travers ing it from the sea to the innermost recess of the golden shell, then, taking it by quarters, litle can be Porta Felice, the quaftro cantont, the old Cassaro—now, of course, Victor and Via Macqueda, All the old labyrinths of alleys and by-ways have disappeared, broad streets traverse the entire city from north to south, from east to west; aud on el- Sicihan in Naples, the cholera arrangemenis was het recognized save the old Emanuel ther side palaces, houves of one, two, three (never more than four) stories are built or in process of building, or wide spaces are jeft for those who may choose to build in the future Matters here are managed in this wise: The vast plan for sanification was laid out in 1886, and approved after many changes by the mun cipal council and modifications by the Government bad been introduced. Then very gradually the municipality expropriated cer- tain of the worst quarters, but only when sure that all the inbabitants could find bouse- room at the same prices, without being de- ported from the theatre of their daily work. . This was not difficult to insure, as the munici- pality, availing itself of the law of 15885, which permits any unsanitary property to be taken and paid for at a certain gave orders for the demoiition houses within a given pericd, no attempt to find ‘societies "—-imply let on unlimited lease the ground-soil to private individuals, or (as in most caer) sold it, Here there have been no huge soctefd ediizte run- ning up jerry-built houses on borrowed capi- tal, and, failing, leaving them unfinished, Simply private individuals have built for themselves, or for letting, such houses as they bave thought fit; the municipality merely compelling them to keep in line and to build with decency. So sure do the purchasers feel of letting that they have ofien built splendid bourses and rows of houses touching the back waliso! the houses that are yet to be demolish- ed, so that they shal! be dry and habitable by the time the expropriation shal! becarried into effect. At the present moment house-rents have fallen in Palermo, as there is more than abundant house-rcom forall, This is good .or the public if bad for the builders. Whenever the municipality bas desired to atiract the poor to a certain spot, they have built and opened an elementary school, and this more even than a church attracts the very poorest classes. This is one of the most hopeful signs in Palermo. I have not yet visited any of the town schools, but have spent long afternoons at the different asilié rurali (infant schools) in the outskirts of Paiermo. [his is quite a new feaiure for the country. In the ‘‘ good old times” the street price, of the then made Arabs even of the city were left to run wild, half-naked, and uncared for; as for the chil- dren of the outskirts, I never saw such speci- mens of 'cute, quick, starved childhood as were gathered into the Garibaldi Institute by Al-

Page 8

) @ LEGER OSE Fitineatat ar > SRR Gerieet ae fale oe PORE ake, “ae ictRnanmes 4.24. The Nation. [Vol. 53, No. 1 379 berto Mario and made soldiers of in a trice, This Institution was destroyed by some Piedmontere hater of the ‘* Nice cabin boy.” Now into these asili they come in crowds at eight o’clock in the morning, and are kept there till four or five in the afternoon. The only obligation is that they shail have white pinafores, no matter how much mended if clean and not in holes. The nine asili are maintained by private charity, so that there are no fixed funds, and the ‘‘soup” which forms the essential feature of the Neapolitan infant-schools cannot be provided. Surpris- ing to relate, all the children are provided by their parents with sufficient bread and some sort of companatico, a tomato, an apple, a bit of cheese; and, now the oranges are ripening, the much-cherished fruit is ea- gerly devoured. At worst, they have the jichi @’ India (prickly pears) in abundance, and as all the children are of parents who belong to the fisherman or peasant or common work- ing class, they get a hot meal at home when the day’s work is done, of maccaroni and beans or some other vegetable; on Sundays, macca- roni and sugo, sauce made of tomatoes and onions, They look healthy and are of normal size for their respective ages; there is none of the servility, ‘‘ the kiss-your-band fashion,” of Naples. Some of these schools have three or four or even five elementary classes, into which the children pass from the asili ; and in the Educatorio Whitaker there are five hundred children and a normal school for the education of schoolmistresses, all Sicilian, with an addi- tion of a class for Froebel’s system. This was founded by the nephews of the famous Ingham of Marsala renown, and is now in a flourish- ing condition, only more funds are necessary, lt is wonderful, here as in Naples, what pri- vate charity does and can effect. There the industrial schools founded by Casanova are growing more perfect every year. There the hospital for poor children condemned to under- go surgical operations is a model unsurpassed in London, and the Ecce Homo, once a disor- derly brothel for oblates, now transformed into a home and industrial school for orphan- ed girls left homeless by the cholera, is already a thriving institution. But in Naples the pub- lic charities are in a deplorable state, Here we have yet to visit them. Meanwhile one is cheered and hopeful to see that in this most important part of the social programme the well-to-do pertion of the citizens are doing their part right well and earnestly. They are only awaiting the coming of Queen Margaret to inaugurate a magnificent hospital for poor children and an institute for the education of the blind. On the whole, Palermo is, by far, the cleanest, brightest, most thriving city that I have visited for a long time, The taxes are high, but the municipal budget balances itself, work is abundant and well-paid, and Palermo has effected all these reforms by her own un- aided perseverance. Garibaldi rightly named the city of his love “‘ the City of Initiatives.” November 14.—I thought I would not close this letter till I had seen the arrival of their Majesties, whose visits to the island are so few and far between (the last was in 1881). Never, to say the truth, have I seen such a we'come accorded to royalty in Italy or elsewhere, That the Sicilians, or at any rate the Palermi- tans, are all for a constitutional monarch I Was aware—no republican propaganda has ever taken root here; but the rapture of the greeting given passes expression. For the last month nothing else has been talked of save the coming of the sovereigns for the opening of the Exposition, Fabulous sums have been spent by the ladies in toilettes for the reception of her Majesty; the dressmakers and the modistes have been working night and day. But what is more touching by far is that the*poorest woman “‘ made Saturday ” on Friday in her honor, I had no idea how clean the poorest people are until my late ‘* slum- ming” here. On Saturdays they clean every- thing and scrub their one-roomed tiled or brick floor like an Anglo-Saxon housewife. ‘‘ Fare tl sabbato” (to make Saturday) is a Sicilian proverb for doing a thing thoroughly. So yesterday, to be free for the sight of the royal heads, all cleaned their houses a day earlier. At first a very official reception was arrang- ed, with all the troops turned out on the sea- wall. One of the daintiest ladies of an old aristocratic house said to me, ‘‘ Whata pity ! If Palermo is left in the hands of the people, there will be the most perfect order and a most hearty welcome, but the people turn restive at the sight of troops and police,” I happened to be at the Prefect’s when the Commander General of the troops stationed in Palermo came in and read a telegram from the King expressly ordaining that there should be no troops whatsoever. The General looked at the Prefect and the Prefect looked at the General, but a member of the aristocracy and a municipal assessor who were present said, ‘* Wise King Humbert! He seems to know our people!’ I must confess that I thought of the attempt made on Humbert by Passa- mante, and the torrents of blame that were poured on Cairoli’s head in 1878, but I wronged Palermo in the thought, Before dawn all the citizens were on foot, the landing place was bowered with greenery, all ugly corners bidden in flowers and leaves, The old Garibaldians claimed the first place, and, dressed in their red sbirts and caps, all with medals, they took their posts at seven a. Mm. I wandered in and out all down the Corso Vittorio Emanuele. Not a window but had its flag (all bear the white cross now), its magnificent old tapestry or modest drapery —here the names of the King, Queen, and Prince worked in flowers ; there some emblem of welcome, And every window and balcony was occupied, The people had taken posses- sion of every lamp, cornice, grating, and of the sea-wall, E‘ght, nine, ten struck, and every now and then the salutes fired filled the spectators with hope that the longed-for were coming ; but not a sign of impatience or weariness, not a shout nor a cry. One used to the noise and restlessness of Naples can hardly understand this grave, serious, yet intensely enthusiastic people, In order to see properly, we footed it, witha carriage in reserve, Though the America was sighted at half-past nine off Monte Pellegrino, two hours passed before the landing was really made, The sea and land blended in a crowd of heads, The municipal bark, with the meri- torious syndic, Senator Emanuele Paternd, and the Prince of Camporeaie, the President of the Exposition Committee, went cff, and as the America cast anchor a salvo of welcome poured out from the fort of Castellamare aud the ships of all nations anchored in the bay; then one deep, prolonged evviva, and the sove- reigns stepped on shore. Here the ladies of Palermo in fresh, rich morning toilets, with Signora Paternd Vassallo, wife of the syndic, presented the Queen with a splendid bouquet of flowers such as Palermo only can produce. The Prince of Naples offered his arm to the mayoress, and Humbert, bowing right and left, looking well and pleased, took the bouquet from the Queen and handed her into the car- riage. The Garibaldians, in their red shirts and medals, followed immediately as guard of honor—a fitting escort for the son of the King who from their Duce received two kingdoms as agift. Then the workingmen’s societies, with their respective flags and mottoes; then, pell- mel], ‘all the world”—all Palermo certainly, and hundreds of visitors from every part of Italy : Senators, Deputies, all the provincial authorities, etc. The order was simply perfect, and the evvivas, continued as they were, did not stun one as often elsewhere, The crowd separated either side the royal carriage so that the procession through the streets went at an ordinary pace. Taking a carriage, we reached the royal palace on whose balcony we last stood with Garibaldi, and there the crowd seemed to exceed that on the quay and in the streets, Here there was slight confusion, and four of the Garibaldians, in keeping the ranks, were thrown down and, I fear, hurt, At the foot of the staircase stood the clergy of the Palatine Chayel and Monsignore Di Marzo (I noted that the Ca- thedral is decked for the morrow’s service). As their Majesties appeared on the balcony, one shout reéchoed from the enormous piazza, “Viva i] Re! Vivala Regina! Viva il Principe di Napoli!” The King bas been moving about Palermo all day long, has visited the Exposi- tion and expressed himself delighted with his reception, as well he may be! Iattach little im- portance to royal! visits in general, but this one is significant, All the other cities of Italy are the resorts of the King and the Queex— Naples most of all; but Palermo, not to speak of the rest of the island, has been forgotten, ignored, neglected. Now continental Italy will cee that Palermo is one of the first, best, most orderly and progressive cities of the new kingdom, and it may be that the island will have justice done at last. I close before the inauguration of the exhibi- tion takes place,as those ceremonies are ail alike, Their Majesties wi.l not be able to see much, as most of the galleries are in confusion, but this was unavoidable, since, if the opening had been delayed, the opening of Parliament would have taken place first, and the Ministers could not have accompanied the King. Crispi is stillthe idol of the Palermitans, but they are prepared to give a hearty welcome to Di Rudini, their own citizen and Deputy, and to Nicotera, who spent three years in the dungeons of Favigna- na on their coasts, and who, again Minister of the Interior, must be well satisfied with the aspect of the city which he delivered from the horrors of coercion. J, W. M. MARBOT IN THE SAXON CAMPAIGN, Paris, November 13, 1891. NAPOLEON, when he left the army during the retreat from Russia, gave the command of it to Murat, ‘‘ who, in these circumstances, showed himself inferior to his task.” It must be confessed that the cold paralyzed almost every will; there was no discipline left; every morning thousands of dying soldiers were abandoned in the camps chosen for the night, Some colonels, Marbot among them, organized a sort of brigandage : they sent expeditions in- to the villages, which brought back cattle, salt meat, flour. Marbot gives curious examples of the effect of the intense cold which began in Decemb:r. A division, composed of 12,000 ‘conscripts, had left Wilna and joined the army. The transition from the well-warmed barracks to the field was fata) to it; the division was almost completely destroyed. ‘' The cold produced even nore terrible effects on 200 Nea- politan cavaliers of King Murat’s Guard. They came to meet us after having long sojourned in Wilna: they all died the first night they slept

Page 9

Dec 3. 1891] The Nation. on the snow.” The ieemene Italians, Spa- niards, Czechs deserted and took refuge in the villages. The retreat was, in one sense, easier than could have been expected, as the Rus- sians, accustomed to their warm izbas, suf- fered quite as much as, if not more than, the invaders; Kutuzoff contented himself with fol- lowing the French army at some distance with a feeble vanguard. The Cossacks alone rode round the army, but they were easily re- pulsed. On the 13th of December, Marbot saw again the Niemen at Kovno, the last Russian city. How different did the French look from what they were five months before! They were now in Prussia, and Prussia was still an ally; the inhabitants treated the French sol- diers kindly. Marbot slept in a bed, and the transition made him ill, Almost all the of- ficers became ill in the same way from the same cause. Marbot has a chapter on the causes of the disasters of the Russian campaign. He attri- butes them chiefly to our want of interpreters and complete ignorance of the Russian lan- guage, to the blind confidence of the Emperor in the fidelity of his allies; to the belief, which Napoleon entertained too long, that he should bring Alexander to terms, and dictate articles of peace in Moscow. He attaches little, if any, influence to the burning of Moscow; the de- struction of that city was not so complete that there did not remain churches, barracks, pa- laces, and houses enough for a whole army; there was also an immense amount of provi- sions. The losses of the grand army in the Russian campaign were enormous but have sometimes been exaggerated. Three hundred and twenty-five thousand nine hun- dred men had crossed the Niemen (155,400 Frenchmen and 170,500 allies). In February, 1813, 60,000 Frenchmen recrossed the Niemen ; 30,000 prisoners had remained in Russia, who only returned to France after the peace of 1814. The total loss of the Frenchmen was therefore 65,000 dead. Marbot preerved his regiment with so much care that out of 1,048 men who had entered Russia he lost only 855 and he could, in February, 1813, show at Dres- den 693 men who had all made the Russian campaign. This exceptional number was noticed by Napoleon, who paid great ccmpli- ments to the Colonel of the Twenty-third Chas- seurs, Napoleon had to make exceptional and even illegal levies to place his army again on a war footing; he madea great mistake in leaving about 70,000 men in the garrisons of the Ger- man cities, which he was unwilling to aban- don, but which he could not hope to keep if he was not victorious in the open field. Marbot joined his dé;6t at Mons, in Belgium, and re- constituted rapid y several squadrons, He joined his regiment again only after the bat- tles of Liitzen and of Bautzen. The French army had never been finer. The navy had given splendid men to Napoleon, and he had besides taken men from the gendarmerie, but, on the other hand, all the allied troops were on the point of abandoning the cause of France, “Napoleon,” says Marbot, ‘‘ ought to have treated with his adversaries, and, before all, ought to have conciliated his tather-in-law, the Emperor of Austria, by giving back to him Dalmatia, Istria, Tyrol, and a part of the other provinces which had been conquered in 1805 and 180%. Some concessions made to Prussia would have calmed the allies, who, it seems, offered to give back the French colonies and to guarantee him all the provinces as far ” Bn Rhine and the Alps, as well as upper but they expec him to relinquish ew Poland, Naples, and Westphalia.” The Allies bad an army three times as nvu- merous as the army of Napoleon: he had 820,000 men in nacaaniii they had as many as 800,000. He would not treat on these terms; he dismissed Metternich, whohad come to negotia’e with him, with much arrogance. An immense circle was forming, however, round the French army; the armistice was broken as soon as the circle was complete, two days before the date fixed by the Conven- tion. The Allies had cognizance of all the dispositions of Napoleon’s army, through the treason of Jomini, Marbot is severe on Jominvi, who was a Swiss, but whom Marshal Ney had protected, had made a French officer, and taken as an aide-de-camp, and who, through Ney’s influence, as well as by his own talent, bad rapidly become a general. Jomini went over to the Russians, taking with him all the notes relative to the opening campaign and the disposition of the French army. It was by his advice that Alexander, who took him as an aide-de-camp, opened hostilities two days before the day fixed for the rupture of the armistice. The Emperor inflicted a de feat on Blucher on three successive days, and forced him to retire behind the Katzbach, when, learning that the army of Schwartzen- berg, 200,000 strong, was entering Saxony, he marched rapidly on Dresden, which was occu- pied by Saint-Cyr, Marbot gives an account of the battles of the 26th and 27th of August, before Dresden. The Allies were obliged to retreat; on the second day they had lost as many as 20,000 men, killed or wounded, and 20,000 prisoners Schwartzenberg was retreating towards Tep- litg in Bohemia. Unfortunately, Vandamme, who pursued the retreating enemy, found him- self confronted at Kulm by overwhelming forces; he refused to surrender, and was him- self made prisoner. The battle of Kulm cost the French 2,000 mer, killed or wounded, and 8,000 prisoners; 10,000 men succeeded in escap- ing from Kulm. Saint-Cyr and Mortier, who were at Dresden, cought to have helped Vandamme; their inaction was the cause of his defeat. At the same moment, Oudinct suffered a defeat at Gross-Beeren, and Mac- donald on the Katzbach. Napoleon's victory at Dresden thus became useless) Marbot played his part, witb his usual bravery, on the Katzbach; he give: a very detailed and graphic acecunt of this bloody encounter. The army of Napoleon lost at the battle of the Katzbach 138,000 men killed or drowned, 20,000 prisoners, and 50 guns, It was a great disaster. Mac donald, who was the cause of i', assumed the whole responsibility for it before his assembled generals and colone!s he army retreat- ed on the Elbe. Marshal Ney was beaten at Jiiterbogk by Bernadotte For a fort- night the French army remained round Dresden; Marbot camped at Pilnite, and while he was there, he saw the first Tartars and Basbkirs, armed only with bows and ar- rows, Who hed come to join the Russian army. Napoleon one day visited Marbot's regiment. ‘I was getiing ready to shave in the open air, before a small glass nailed on a tree, when | feli somebody touch my shoulder. As l was in the midst of my regiment, I turned rapidiy, wondering who could presume on such familia- rity with the Colonel I saw the Emperor, who bad come in a postchaise with a single aile-de- camp.” Napoleon wanted to examine the posi- tion; he wished also to examine some Bashkir prisoners. On the 28th of September Napoleon passed in review Marbot's corps, and on this occasion be made him an officer of the Legion of Ho nor, a baron, and gave him a dotation. He praised Marbot's regiment, and said it was the only one which kept in good order at the 425 Katgbach, which took guns from the enemy, ard repuised the Prussians wherever it found them. The army slowly concentrated round Leipzig, and the Allies took the same direction. The Emperor arrived in that city on the Ith of October. Deaf to the advice of the King of Wirtemberg, who was the most faithfal of his allies, Napoleon resoived to give battle, and not to effect his retreat towards the Thiiring- er-Wald and Hesse, & mounfaisous country where defence was easy. The King of Wir temberg did not conceal frvm the Emperor the fact that the movement of the German people had become irresistible, and that he would soon be obliged himself to fall in with it The King of Bavaria sided with the Allies, and his army had marched already on the Rbine. When Napoleon beard of it, it was too jate; he had with bim 157,000 men, and he had to fight Schwartzenberg who had 30,000 men. The battles round Leipzig were terrible struggles. Marbot, before they took place, was camped near an ancie:.t Swedish earthen redoubt, on the Kelmberg. One night, be saw three men on horseback on the Kelmberg, and was near enough to hear their conversation ; one of them told the others that there were no Frenchmen in sight, and that ‘‘their Majes- ties’ might approach. Marbot, and those who were on the watch with him, soon saw about twenty people on the Kelmberg. Marbot was already hoping to make the Kinperor of Rus sia and the King of Prussia pri.oners, when one of his soldiers impradentiy fired a shot and killed a Prussian major in the midst of the group on the Kelmberg Imniediately their Majest:es and their sui:e disappeared at full gallop The battle began the next morn- ing; it lasted three daya On the isih, the Saxons turned against the in the midst of the baitia Bernadotte opened bis ranks to them and immediately turned their artillery against ux During those fatal days, Marbot received in the thigh an arrow which was four feet long; he had it extracted imme- diately and did not leave his reg ment, even for a moment, Napoleon was forced to retreat after the bat- tles of Leipzig. He had very little ammuni- tion left; he had lost 40,000 men, killed or wounded; the enemy had lost @,000, The bridge over the Ulster was blown up too soon, and the French army was cutin two, This was a terrible disaster—worse than the three days’ battle I cannot follow Marbot in all the details of the retreat of b.s regiment; he Was never more brave and active. I must refer the reader to Marbot’s own book, The end of this third volume of his Memoirs, which, alas, is the last, is sad. Na; oieon, when the campaign of 1813 was over, had lost all Ger- many, all Spain, the greater part of Italy; and the army of Wellington, which had crossed the Pyrenees, was camping on French territory. Marbot speaks rapiily of the inva- sion of France by the Allies; the subject was too painful for bim, for he was really at- tached to the Emperor, His book ends thus: “ The cause of Napoleon was now lost (aliud- ing to the proclamation of the Bourbons by the Senate), though his adherents were infinitely more numerous than those of Louis XVIIL, as the event proved in the following year.” French, | Correspondence, THE EARTHQUAI AKE IN To rae Epitor or THe Nation: Sim: Your readers have by this time receiy- ed full telegraphic news o the destruction and JAPAN,

Page 10

426 The Nation. [Vol. 53, No. 1379 ruin caused by the recent terrible earthquake in central Japan. At the present writing it seems that sore 80,000 houses are destroyed and about 8,000 people killed. The number of people left homeless reaches far above 300,000. Doubtless there have been funds started in the United States for the relief of thesufferers. My object in writing this brief note is to urge upon those disposed to give, the great need of sending as much relief as may be. The par- ticular feature of the calamity is not merely the loss of homes, but the destruction of means of livelihood. The most prosperous potteries in Japan bave been laid in ruins. Dikes and irrigation works must be rebuilt before agri- culture can be resumed with safety, The result is, that for months to come alarge portion of the people will be without any income from their occupations, even supposing they are able to borrow funds for rebuilding. Be- sides this, it must be understood that Japan is @ poor country as compared with America. There is not enough to spare, however charita- bly disposed her people may be, to give ade- quate relief to their fellow-countrymen. It is to be hoped that the people of the United States will come to the aid of Japan. A dol- lar will go a long way here; it will keep twenty-five people alive for one day; and every dollar sent here will tell, i dare say that the Mission Boards will all forward con- tributions of clothes (winter) and money. If one desires to send direct, the best address would be ‘O. Keil, Secretary Yokobama Chamber of Commere Yokohama, Japan.” Sincerely yours, J. BW, TOKIO, November 9, 1891. PATRICK EGAN, To THe Eprror oF THe Nation: Sir: Ido not doubt that Patrick Egan bas adopted a mistaken policy, and that his having been accredited to Chili has been a misfortune for that country, the United Siates, and his own reputation as a public man. But I must ask to be permitted to protest against your using such expressions regarding him as ** illiterate foreign adventurer,” his ‘‘ not even [having] a decent English education, nor any large business experience,” ete, I knew Mr. Egan for the twelve years previous to his leav- ing Ireland, and had a high opinion of him. He conducted an extensive business in Dublin, and was esteemed even by political opponents as an upright, straightforward man. ‘There was nothing about him to lead me to suppo:e he was less literate than the majority of us who have not received a university educa- tion. I have always maintained tbat he was right and justified in leaving Ireland. Hehbad had, as Treasurer of the Land League, the handling of large sums of money under circumstances which rendered it impossible for him to guard the directions in which some of it may have drifted. Considering the then temper of the Government, and the state of public feeling in Ergiand after the murder of the Secretaries, and the ease with which juries of men prepared to believe anything could be packed, his liberty was not worth a day’s purchase. The Times Commission after- wards proved that nothing really cculd have been urged against him. The vast majority of Irishmen feel that they owe him an eternal debt of gratitude for the probity and self-ab negation displayed in his manegement of the money affairs of the League. Nor can they forget that the unmasking of the Pigott for- geries was due almost entirely to his business regularity and foresight in preserving sundry of Pigott’s letters to him, Our trained diplomatic service may have its advantages; nevertheless, in foreign relations you appear to come cff as smoothly upon the whole as wedo, The spoils system on either side of the Atlantic is, of course, to be con- demned. Nor does it appear to me becoming that a great country like the United States should be represented by one who bas but lately become 4 citizen. From what I have read from time to time in your columns, I should, however, suppose that you have often been re; resented abroad by men far less qualitied as diplomatists tuan Mr. Egan. Very sincerely yours, ALFRED WEBB. DUBLIN, November 19, 1891. MR. WARNER'S “EVIDENCE {N FULL” COMPLETED. To THE Epitor oF THE Nation: fir: In your last week’s issue, Mr. J. B. Warner professes to give the ‘‘evidence in full” respecting Prof, Royce’s suppression of my reply to his (the latter’:) avowed ‘ attack.” The long letter he publi:hes as ‘* evidence” on this point is evidence of nothing but the law- yer’s attempt to put forward his own baseless assumptions in his client’s behalf as if they were assured facts, The adroit assumption in this case is, that the “ language” of my su; pressed reply was improper, and justified exclusion of the reply from the Journal of Xthics. This assumption I deny with vigor; and, what is more telling than any de- nial of mine, Dr. Adler and Dr. Royce, as editors of the Journal, denied it themselves, when at first they both accepted the reply for publication, had it put in type, and sent me proofs both of the reply and of Dr. Royce’s re- joinder toit, The subsequent rejection of my reply, under Mr. Warner’s advice, cannot un- do the effect of their previous sarction of it as perfectly fit for publication, But the ‘* evidence in full” on this point cannot be given without showing, by actual quotation, what really was the “ language” to which Mr, Warner so unreasonably object- ed. I have no right to ask you to devote much space te such quotation; but, relying on your well-known fairne:s, 1 must ask leave to cite, as a fair specimen of the ‘* language” cbjected to, the opening of the suppressed reply. The passages bere italicised were mark- ed by Dr. Royce himself as the grounds upon which he and his lawyer based their threat of prosecution and their suppression of the reply itself. It will be perfectly clear to any fair- minded man that they were aiming to force me either to concede that Dr. Royce’s original article was a legitimate criticism, or else to lose all opportunity of being heard in self- defence, That bis article was a libel, and not a fair criticism at all, has been proved in my pam- pbhlet beyond all possibility of a successful reply; and the reader, bearing this in mind, will judge for himself whether the “language” as such, or whether the effort to defend myself acainst the libel, was the real ground of Mr. Warner's threatening letter. The following passage from the suppressed reply is a fair sample of its ** language” throughout: ‘“*The mere fact that, in the International Journal of Ethics for last Octcber, there ap peared a hostile review of my book entitled ‘The Way Out of Agnosticism,’ by Dr. Josiah Royce, assistant professor of philosophy in Harvard College, would not induce me to break my uniform custom of silence in such cases, were it not that Dr. Royce oversteps the limits of legitimate literary criticism, throws out personal accusations of a slanderous na- ture, and resorts to empty and undignified official denunciation in order to flank indi- rectly a pb.losopbical position which he has bot ventured openly to assail. His mode of attack isa marked case of ‘ reversion’ to con- troversial methods which, common enough some centuries ago, are happily gowng out of use to-day. Dr. Royce presumes to accuse me, falsely and injuriously, of ‘frequently mak- ing, of laie, extravagant pretensions as to the originality and profundity of {my] still unpublished system of philoso- phy,’ and of ‘sinning aguinst the most obvious demands o: literary property rights’; and he even goes so far as (to issue a solemn * professional warning,’ formally addressed to ‘the liberal-minded public,’ against myself as a philosophicai thinker ani author, Such tac- tics as these are unknown among reputable literary men. They are justified by no higher ethical principle than that which dictated the old pettifogyer's advice to the young one: ‘If you have no case, abuse the counsel on the other side.’ ‘* This paper, therefore, is wri'ten as a reply, not toa critique, but to a libel. If I notice below what Dr. Koyce puts forward as * criti- cisms,’ it is not because they deserve to be noticed as such, but solely because they are made to serve as the ostensible warrant and support of his libellous ‘ professional warn- ing.’ And the only reason why I make my de- fence in these columns is that believing the ‘liberal minded public’ to be a just judge, I have greater confidence in the court of reason than I have in the courts of law. ‘*When civil-service reformers plead the ur- gent necessity of political reform, they are ir- relevantly charged by the adherents of the spoils system with being ‘hypocrites and pbari- sees.’ Precisely so, when I plead the urzent necessity of philosopbica! reform, I am irrele- vantly charged by Dr. Royce, in effect, with being a false pretender, a plagiarist, and an tmpostor. The charge is just as true in one cave as in the other. But, be the charge true or untrue, the attention of keen and candid minds is not to be diverted by this perfectly transparent device from the main point of reform, In both cases, inte- rests more important than any persoral repu- tation are at stake; and loyalty to interests more important than my own renntation re- quires me now to expose Dr. Royce’s endeavor to divert attention by irrelevant, useless, and utterly unprovoked vituperation from the main point of philosophical reform.” Will any fair man say that the ‘‘ language” here used is other than temyerate, dignified, and parliamentary? I protest against Mr. Warner’s attempt to misrepresent the charac- ter of my ‘* language,” as improper in any de- gree. A libelled citizen has a right to defend himself against the libel; and, when Dr. Royce blew his bugle-blast of defiance, ‘*‘ We must show no mercy, as we ask none,” he deprived himself of ail excuse, in the eyes of men who prize the good old English principle of fair play, for seeking refuge behind a menace of prosecution. And here I must express my sur- prise at Mr. Warner’s statement that ‘ Prof. Royce sought my advice in consequence of threats of a law-suit from Dr. Abbot.” Inever threatened Dr. Royce with a law-suit at all. Francis E, ABBOT, CAMBRIDGE, November 28, 1891. [We cannot print any more letters respect- ing this controversy.—Ep. NATION. ] * ROSSETTI’S FRANCESCA, To THE EprTor oF THE Nation: £1r: In an interesting review of Mr. Nor- ton’s translation of the ‘* Inferno” which appeared in the Nation for November 5, I find no mention of Dante Gabriel Rossetti’s version ‘of the celebrated Francesca di Rimini passage, though other and (as Ithink) inferior metrical versions are quoted in comrparison with the prose. Nor, indeed, am I sure that Rossetti’s bas ever had adequate publication; I myself only know it from its being quoted in a lecture on Dante by Mr. William Davies of Rome, a friend of Rossetti’s, It is not to be found, I am

Page 11

Dec. 3, 1891] The Nation. told, in Rossetti’s complete works, The pas sage begins: Quando risposi, com{ncat: na oe (When I made answer, I began: al ee oD But, not to trespass upon your s; ace, | will give only the lines quoted by your re viewer: “One day we read for pastime and sweet cheer Of Lancelot, how he found Love tyrannous: We were a’one and without fear. Our eyes were drawn toxether, reading th Full oft, and still our cheeks would pale ‘and glow; But one sole point it was that conquered us, For when we read :f that at lover, how He kissed the smile which he had longed to win— then he whom nought can cover from me now For ever, kissed my mouth, all Cy ye A Galahait was the book, and he that writ: Upon that day we read no more therein.” Retaining the original form both in metre and rbyme, it is at the same time, I think, far more poetical and far more literal than the versions of Cary and Byron, Only a great poet, equally at home in the two languages, withan almost magical gift of giving an Ita- lian grace and flavcr to unexceptionable Eng- lish, could accomplish such a tour de force. Even he, I suspect, could not have kept it up through the whole of the ‘Commedia.’ Still, one wishes he had tried. — Yours respectfully, M. D. “UNWELL.” To THE Eprror or THe Nation: Sir: In p. 337 you quote the Rev. Christo pher Wordsworth as commenting that unwell is ‘said to have been coined by Horace Wal- pole.” But my Modern English shows that, at least in its Scotch form, it was in existence long befcre Horace Walpole’s time, Sir Thomas Urquhart wrote, in 1653: “Whilst they were on this Discourse, and pleasant Tattle of drinking, Gargamelle began to be a little unweil in her lower Parts.”— Rabelais, Book L., Ch. vi., in Vol. L, p. 19 (t d. 1694). That unwell was formerly considered to be Hibernian appears from a letter of Lord Chesterfield’s dated in 1755; and, in 1781, as I have elsewhere pointed out, William Cowper called it ‘tthe Irish term.” However, Miss Elizabeth Carter used it in 1761 and 1764; and shortly afterwards, as could be evidenced, it became common enough. Coleridge has it in 1796, and Southey in 1797 and 1798, Yet, in the present century, it has teen stigmatized as a ‘‘Yankeeism.” The verb backen, which also you remark on, is a familiar word here in Suffolk. F. EL MARLESFORD, ENGLAND. “GOD SAVE THE MARK” To THE Epitor oF THE NatTIOon: Sir: This exclamation occurs twice in Shakspere, and the almost identical ‘* God bless the mark!” twice. The passages are: ‘The Jew, my master, who (God a the mark!) isa kind cf devil” (Mer. of V., ii. 2). “Of guns, and drums, and ‘wounds (God save the mark!) ” (1st Hen. IV., i. 3). ‘*And | (God bless the mark D his Moorship s ancient ’ (Othello, i. 1). ** saw the wound, I saw it with mine eyes —(God save the mark !}—bere on his manly breast” (Rom. and Jul, iii. 2). The commentators all (so far as my reading goes) agree that no satisfactory explanation has been given of this phrase. One conjec- tures that it may have been an exclamation used in archery, and another that it may have some reference to the mark or cross used in- stead of a signature; but they neither show that it was ever so employed, nor do they point out the relevancy of such meanings in the passages cited, 427 lf we put aside the use by Jago, where it seems merely an exclamation of contempt and disgust, we find that by the other speakers it seems to be used as a deprecatory formula accompanying the mention of something male ficent, as the devil, and wounds. In the passage last cited, the context, “here, on his manly breast,” shows that the Nurse touches her own breast to indicate the exact place of Tybalt’s wound; but, before tcuching it (or as she touches it) she :ays, ‘God save the mark!” Now we know that in superstitious times men believed that they lived in a ;erpetual beleaguerment of malignant powers or de mons, always on the watch to harm them in body or soul; and a careless act, word, or ges- ture might give a disastrous opening. Against such mishaps Christians were taught that the handiest prophylactic was the sign of the cross, which put all demons at once to flight. So I conceive that when the Nurse touches her breast she makes a cross upon it—*' God save the mark!” being equivalent to ‘* God protect from harm the place I now cross”; and this custom I surmise to have given origin to the pbrase. As the English gave up the habit of crossing themselves, the original signifl- cance was gradually forgotten, until the phrase was used much as writers and speakers of the present day occasionally use it, without any idea of what it means or what they mean by it. A curious passage in Petronius seems to sup- port this view, and indeed gave me the notion of this explanation. Trimalcbio is telling a story of witches yelling around a house in which a youth has just died. One of the family, a bold Cappadocian, draws his sword, rushes out of the house, ‘‘ et mulierem, fan. quam hoc loco (salvum sit quod tango), mediam trajecit.” Here Trimalchio evidently touches his own or his neighbor’s body to indicate the spot where the witch was pierced, and uses at the same time a y;rotective, or averruncine, formula to avert possible mischief. Wa. Hanp Browne. BALTIMORE, November 23, 1891. Notes. G. P. Putnam's Sons’ forthcoming publica- tions include a sumptuous edition of Irving's ‘Sketch Book’; * Napoleon,’ by W. O'Connor Morris, in the ‘‘Epechs of History Series”; the fourth volume of the Talleyrand Memoirs; * Teufel, the Terrier,’ by Charles Morley; and ‘Improbable Tales,’ by Clinton Rosa * Letters of Charles Dickens to Wilkie Col- lins,’ edited by Laurence Hutton; the ‘ Life of General Thomas J. Jackson (‘‘Stonewall”),’ by his wife, Mary Anna Jackson; ‘From the Easy Chair,’ selections by George William Curtis from his thirty years’ store of ; apers in Harper's Magazine; * Peter Ibbetson,’ by George du Maurier; and ‘Jasmin: Barber, oet, Philanthropist,’ by Samuel Smiles, are in the press of Harper & Bros Houghton, M:fflin & Co, will y;ublish imme- diately ‘Masterpieces of American Literature,’ selected from thirteen authors, D. C. Heath & Co, announce ‘Business Law,’ by Alorzo P. Weed. The new London edition of the late Dr. Car penter’s ‘Tbe Microsco; e and its Revelations.’ edited by Dr. Dallinger, wili bear in this coun- try the imprint of P. Blakiston, Son & Co., Philadelphia, Two books for young men, ‘Brave and True,’ by Thain Davidson, D.D., and * First Baitles and How to Meet Them,’ by Frederick A. Atkins, are to be issued by the Fieming H. Revell Co, Mrs. Fiora Haines Loughead bas begun the serial publication of her own novels through C. A. Murdock & Ca, San Francisco, ‘ The Man from Nowhere’ leading off this “ Gold Dust Series,” A History of the Holy Land, upon which Mrs. Oliphant bas been engaged, is to be pul lished by Macmillan, with illastrations from -ketches made by Hamilton Alic Saxon & Co, London, have secured the rights of translation of a taking French story for boya, ‘ The Adventures of a Prehistoric Boy.’ It is to be published in January, fully illustrated from designs by Félix Kdy The librarian of the Bodleian inivates the * Bodleian Facsimile Series " with a photolitho- graph of the unique and perect ‘Are Moriendi’ f 1491, either Caxton’s or W ynken de Worde’s production; and an bistorical tract printed tn Rome in 1572, the year of the Massacre of St. Bartholomew, describing the solemn procession in that city under the Pope's direction “per la felicissima noua destruttione della setta Vgo- notana.” These facsimiles will be marketed at a shilling each through B. Quaritch and the Clarendon Press Depository We learn from the Academy that the Shel- ley centenary will be marked by the offer of a monument of Shelley in marble and bronze, either to the nation or some public body, as the gift of Lady Shelley. The anniversary is also to be made the occasion of the pub teation of the Shelley Concordance by Mr. Ellin The Shelley Society, for its part, proposes to repeat the performance of “The Cenci,” but over this project there seems to hang some doubt. Mr. William Hamilton Gibson's engravings of the delicate things of the roadside and the flelds and streams have long charmed the eyes of those who appreciate either nature or the fine hand of art, and a few of them have been enough to make single vumbers of a magazine rememberabla He has now given a royal abundance of these treasures of the graver in a thick volume, ‘Sharp Eyes: A Kambier's Calendar of Fifty-two Weeks among In-ects, Birds, and Flowers’ (Harpers), which is il!us- trated with 275 cuts, many of them of marvel- lous truth of delicacy in rendering, and ali full of the spirit of animate nature. There is a generous text besides, descriptive of the habits, aspects, and curiosities of minute life, the natural bistory of the summer grass and air; and the story is told so as especially to interest the sharp eyes of young people. A better book to develop the young naturalist out of the schoolboy could hardly be put into the hands of youth; but the marginal piciure comment outweighs the text, and the eye is continually diverted from reading to look on the things themselves, The volume is luxuriously printed on heavy paper, and is an example of the best work of the press from which it proceeds, Another nature volume which is mainly in- teresting from its illustrations is Mr. W. H. Downes’s ‘ Arcadian Days: American Land- scapes in Nature and Art’ (Boston: Estes & Lauriat), The text is from the pen of an ob- server of landscape with the prepossessions of an artist, and flows along with great placidity and self-enjoyment, and not without tome charm for the like minded reader. The only distinctive trait it bas is, that it pleads for our vwn landscape as the proper subject of Ameri- can painting, and quite deserving of tuch re- gard; and with this end in view the autbor dwells on the p ciuresqueness and the various beauty of a higher sort which New England waye afford, from the farms to the seashore, The illastrations are by Mr. A. H. Bicknell, and though they lack character, as a rule, in anwey.,

Page 12

Se OPE aed 7 Katie adds

peep ben y arnt aint 4 Px i MAS *

428 The Nation. [Vol. 53, No. 1379

several of them there are excellent simple ef- fects, particularly of hillsides and roads. Asa whole, they are too sketchy and rudely done to support Mr. Downes’s suggestion as to the Americanization of our landscape art 80 forcibly as would have been desirable. Estes & Lauriat renew this year their well- known line of reprints of classic works, illus- trated with tinted photogravures or gelatine prints, In two volumes each they present Bulwer Lytton’s ‘ Rienzi’ and ‘ Last Days of Pompeii,’ in the faultless typography of the University Press, Cambridge, with fifty plates respectively, appropriate to the text. Those which are not ideal restorations in the case of Pompeii have been specially made from views taken on the spot, Someof the Roman views, too, are evidently of recent date, and so are creditable to the publishers’ enterprise, though one might have preferred glimpses of the state of the Forum, for instance, as nearly contem- porary with the age of Rienzi as possible. The covers of both books are elaborately de- signed with strong color contrasts in good taste, A companion undertaking, in one vol- ume of a larger size, is Scott’s ‘ Lady of the Lake,’ from the seme press, and adorned in its turn with twenty-five plates, all scenic, and many of them fine, It is needless to say more than that here are three extremely attractive and sensible gift-books, Mr. Harrison 8. Morris edits a collection of poems of the sea and the seashore under the title Where Meadows Meet the Sea: A Col- lection of Sea Songs and Pastoral Lays’ (Philadelphia: Lippincott), This is illustrated with twelve cuts by F. F. Englisb, which re- produce in a simple way characteristic sea- shore scenes, The anthology itself is excellent, including nearly 150 poems from the best writers of this century, both English and American. America, it is true, is re re-ented mainly by Walt Whitman, whose work in the ecmparison declares itself as not poetry, but nevertheless expresses with romantic feeling and occasional power characteristic traits of the ocean. The pieces of little merit are com- paratively few, and the body of the volume is of high excellence. Two pretty companion gift books in white and gold, ‘Roses of Romance’ and ‘Flowers of Fancy,’ are issued by Roberts Brothers of Bos- ton, with illustrations by Edmund H., Garrett. The first volume is from Keats, and includes ‘*La Belle Dame sans Merci,” “Isabelle,” ‘The Eve of St. Agnes,” and ‘‘Lamia”; the second is Shelley’s, made up of the ‘‘Cloud,” ‘‘Sky- lark,” ‘* West Wind,” and ‘The Sensitive Plant” and ‘Witch of Atlas,” Nothing could be better than such texts, but the illustrations in their turn reach an equal degree of inferi- ority, being superlatively tasteless in design and slevenly in execution. Such work as the cut figuring the Witch of Atlas as ** Arion on the dolphin’s back” ought to be impossible at this late day. Mr. Brander Matthews has done a service to students of the drama and of the history of the British theatre by collecting in a tasteful volume the ‘Dramatic Essays of Charles Lamb’ (Dodd, Mead & Co.), in which the scat- tered criticism and portraiture of that most conversable of essayists on the stage are ga- thered and set by themselves with excellent ef- fect. Mr. Matthews leads off with a pleasant essay of his own—a task of difficulty, since one must hit a peculiar tone of felicitous agree- ableness if his pen is to keep company with Lamb’s and not suffer; but he has written ad- mirably,and is at the same time light in touch, frankly critical, and sincerely appreciative He places Lamb, as a writer on the theatre, with Colley Cibber, and declares the two with-

out rivals, He shows the deficiencies of Lamb as a dramatic author in his own attempts, but speaks of the ‘‘ damned piece,” ‘‘ Mr. H.,” with more goodwill than it has hitherto met with, and takes an unctuous pleasure in recalling the fact that the farce was acted in Philadelphia by Mr. Wood’s company in 1812 ‘‘ with extraordi- nary success,” Here is another instance, he evi- dently means to say, of the superior apprecia- tion of an English author by our countrymen. The entire essay is interesting, and is charac- terized by that union of practical knowledge with the literary instinct which papers on the- atrical subjects are usually most lacking in; and the volume as a whole appeals as much to lovers of the stage as to students of litera- ture—perhaps more. Mr. Hogg’s ‘Uncollected Writings of De Quincy,’ previously noticed, is issued in a se- cond edition by Macmillan, Oriental reinforcement of Christmas enjoy- ment seems to be in order, even though com- ing from so distant a source as the Land of the Rising Sun, Sir Edwin Arnold’s book entitled ‘Japonica’ (Scribners) is timely in its appearance, for in both inward spirit and outward dress it belongs to holiday publications. Lured to Japan, as he tells us, not by guide-books or volumes of travel, but by a grammar, Sir Edwin found ‘‘a whole Japanese syntax constructed on the refined and gentle as well as eminently Christian principle of exalting another and depreciating one’s self.” When just about to leave the land whose language is governed by Chris- tianity in grammar, Sir Edwin received an invitation to furnish three articles for Scribner’s Magazine, These were duly writ- ten, and are now reprinted in a sumptuous volume with Mr. Robert Blum’s fine illustra- tions, Distilling the essence of the best Euro- pean and American writings concerning Japan, whether descriptive, critical, or philc- sophical, a ‘ding his own brilliant and kindly, rather than keen or profound, observations, and flavoring all with the honey gathered by his own study of the native poetry, he pre- sents us, as it were, with a pretty vase filled with sweet odors. His charming style and broad charity will surely swell the volume of travel towards the land whose praises are sung from the carmine head-line on the title- page to the colophon which, in an oval of Ja- panese script, is ‘‘ Sir Edwin Arnold’s Sea}.” Of Mr. Blum’s illustrations it may be said that their charm is that of intense realism combined with poetic selection and grouping. An artist’s eye has chosen the subjects, which are treated with power and, considering that no color is used, with remarkable effect. The dainty material and elegant mechani- cal execution make this book one of the most inviting of parlor-table books of the season, ‘ By Land and By Sea’ is the title of a hand- somely printed and illustrated book of travels by the late Harriet E, Francis of Troy, N. Y. Accompanying her husband, the Hon. John M. Francis, in his diplomatic mission at the courts of Greece, Portugal, and Austria-Hungary, this lady enjoyed excellent opportunities of travel and observation. Her keenness of in- sight is noticeable, and her story of incidents, with chats about history and legends heard or read by her, are in quality rather above that of the average of round-the-world tourists, There are ten *‘ chats” and as many printed extracts of letters descriptive of scenery or people, Occasionally we find a misprint, mis- spelling, or information of uncertain value, but in general the work is entertaining. The abundant full-page illustrations are creditable to the taste of the author who selected them,

as their execution is to the publishers (Nims & Knight, Troy). ‘ Swiss Pictures Drawn with Pen and Pen- cil’ bas appeared in a new edition (Fleming H, Revell Co.), with some new illustrations by Whymper, and a practical map in which the principal peaks as well as the mountain vil- lages are conspicuously marked for the con- venience of tourists, The pictures take up al- most as great a part of the 216 pages as the letter-press, which is by the late Rev. 8. Man- ning. The book was originally issued in 1866, and in the present edition an attempt has been made to bring it up to date by including places which have since become popular, and mention of some recent mountain railways— not the very latest, however. A useful feature is a table in the appendix, showing at a glance the height of the principal mountains and passes, Some of the pictures illustrate the disadvantage of introducing figures of city folks in landscapes: the mountains remain un- changed, as do the peasants, but the women no longer wear hoopskirts. One of the most attractive and popular of German holiday books is Cotta’s Musenal- manach, which was revived last year under the editorship of Dr. Otto Braun. There is a certain poetic fitness in the reappearance of this venerable annual after nearly a century’s sleep, as indicating a possible literary fulfil- ment of the Kyffiiiuser prophecy. The vol- ums for 1892 comes to us in a festive garb, the very pink of bibliopegic art, and the 300 pages of contents are as fresh and as free from fusti- ness as the dainty exterior. In fine, it is a Rip van Winkle of marvellously youthful mien and quite modern attire, and has awaked out of its long slumber, like the seven sleepers of Ephesus, with no traces of age in its features and no cemeterial scent in the folds of its gar- ments, Fiction is represented by Paul Heyse’s **Vroni,” the scene of whichis laid in the Ba- varian highlands. Heyse is unsurpassed in Germany as a writer of short stories, and this tragic tale is one of his best. The prose is followed by what Milton calls ‘‘ numerous verse,” of which ‘‘ Die Hexenmiible,” a narra- tive poem by Oito Roquette, ‘‘ Das Maienfest,” by Isolde Kurz, ** Die Unschu!digen Kind- lein,” by C. F. Meyer, and ‘‘Herzensfriibling, ’ by Ludwig Fulda, may be especially mention- ed. Six heliotypic reproductions of paintings by H6:<slin, Falkenberg, Max, Von Blaas, Hoff, and Roéssler greatly enhance the beauty of the work. In anticipation of more extended notice, two books of decided merit may be commend- ed to lovers of literature as well as to stu- dents. Mr. Mackail’s ‘Select Epigrams from the Greek Anthology’ (Longmans, Green & Co.) may fairly be called a work of art. It is by far the best anthology ever edited in Eng- lish, evincing the nicest taste and scholarship in introduction, translations, and notes, The typography is everything that a ** gentleman and scholar” could desire. Prof. Mahaffy’s ‘The Greek World under Roman Sway’ (Mac- millan) continues bis‘ Greek Life and Thought,’ noticed some years ago in these columns, and displays the same freshness of treatment, the same research in a somewhat neglected and out-of-the-way field, enlivened at intervals by discussions of life and morals which have a perennial interest, In ‘ English Social Movements,’ by Robert A. Woods (Scribners), one finds a good deal of information about English labor organiza- tions, new and old, the various Socialistic leagues and their aims and methods, the uni- versity settlements and reformatory schemes of the churches in London, and other similar subjecta, The account aims to be objective,

Page 13

Dec, 3, 1891] The Nation. 429 and is consistently so almost throughout; oc- casionally the writer’s sympathy with Socialis- tic doctrine comes to the surface. His evident open-mindedness lends significance for Ameri- can readers to what he says in his preface: “IT may express my increasing conviction of the substantial emptiness of the kind of criti- cism made upon the constitution of English society, which is intended to be an indirect felicitation of ourselves over our own social conditions. The American aristccracy is more powerful and more dangerous than the Eng- lish, And it can no longer be taken for grant- ed that workingmen are better off in the United States than in England. . .. We are beginning to see that the problem of lower New York is in some respects even more seri- ous than the problem of East London.” Mr. Archibald H. Grimké’s ‘ William Lloyd Garrison, the Abolitionist,’ just added to the ‘“*American Reformers Series” published by Fuok & Wagnalls, is the third attemptin Eng- lish to abstract in one volume the four vol- umes of the Life edited by Garrison’s children and published by the Century Co. A fourth attempt, by Mr. Goldwin Smitb, is, as we have already annourced, passing through the press, Mr, Grimké's possesses a peculiar in- terest in that the author has in his veins the blood of the race for whose redemption the Liberator was founded. A noticeable warmth of feeling and rhetorical exuberance proceeds from this cauce, and will not be harshly criticised, Mr. Grimké has a good construc- tive sense, and has made a book which hangs well together. His narrative is animated throughout. He is not a mere eulogist, and does not approve Garrison’s judgment or poli- cy at all points, but is fair in defining them. The most serious omission is in the matter of non-resistance and the Non-Resistance Society, the latter not being even mentioned. This is to lose the key to Garrison’s character at once as a man and as a reformer, and an indispens- able clue to the understanding of his relation to political abolitionism in the guise of the Liberty Party, Mr. Grimké shows here more than elsewhere a want of grasp of his abun- dant material. In *‘ Excursions among Words,” by Eugene Field in the Chicago News, much good advice is given to journalistic writers which we fear it is too much to hope they will follow. But the Erglish language is a very dangerous sub- ject to dogmatize upon. Mr. Field begins: ** There is no such word as ‘ wended’; the past of wend is ‘went.’ A man cannot be said to have wended his way. He either went his way or has went his way.” Perhaps this is some of Mr. Field’s bumor. More probably he had forgotten Scott’s— * Then slower wended back his way Where the poor maiden bleeding lay.” Music is the comprehensive title of a new magazine edited and published by Mr. W. 8. B, Mathews of Chicago. In size and external appearance it resembles the Forum. Mr. Ma- thews is well known to the musical world through his books ‘ How to Understand Music,’ his‘ Popalar History of Music,’ ete,; and the first issue of his magazine gives evidence that he takes his task very seriously. Music is in- tended to be ‘‘a convenient medium of inter- communication between the best minds of the musical profession in the United States and the world,” and the editor thinks that music has made sufficient progress in this country to call for an organ similar in scope to the literary magazines, in which there will be room and pecuniary compensation for articles that would be excluded by their dimensions from the daily papers and the weekly musical papers, which are chiefly devoted to criticism of current events and to trade mattera The November number of Music has a timely arti- cle on Paderewski, with a portrait, and arti- cles on the Dignity of Music, Music in the Columbian Fair, Music and the Individual, Some Pedagogic Needs in Music, book reviews, etc. Among the contributors to the December number will be Messrs. Upton, Liebling, Tom- lins, Fillmore, and Dwight. The November Proceedings of the Royal Geographical Society opens with an account of a journey in Persia, by C. E. Biddulph, the most interesting part of which relates to the great salt deposit known as the Darya-i-Namak. This is a tract of hollow ground more than fifty miles long by twenty broad, ** covered with anincrustation of solid salt several feet in thickness in most places, and in some parts, it might be said, of almost unknown depth.” There isapparently but a single path across it, and the passage must be made at night, as the dazzling reflection of the sun’s rays pre- vents persons from seeing where they are go- ing, and, once off the track, they are almost hopelessly lost. Mr. Biddulph crossed by moonlight, and found the surface like a frozen pond, except that ‘instead of being con- tinuous, it was broken up into countless poly- gonal blocks, whose dimensions varied from six inches across to two or three feet or more.” There was no vibration of the incrustation per- ceived, nor impression made upon it by the camels and horses; and an attempt to break off a block of salt witha hammer and an iron tent-peg was unsuccessful, the peg being bent nearly double. A few fragments were chipped off, which, after a day or two, becams soft and friable and changed color from purest white to a slaty blue. Just before the further side of the deposit was reached, the caravan got off the track, and the animals sank almost to the girths “‘in a substance that resembled «x- actly melting snow.” Among ths other arti- cles are some interesting ‘* Notes on the Sa- beans,” an obscure Persian sec’, who call themselves ‘followers of John [the Baptist)” The late John Marshall, one of the most dis- tinguished surgeons and comparative anato- mists of Eng'and, and Professor of Anatomy to the Royai Academy, left at his decease ast year a set of anatomical drawings of which he made use in his lec ures tothe Royal Academy. They remain the property of the family, as each professor is expected to furnish his own drawings. Asthe Professor was too mindful of the claims of humanity to leave behind him a fortune, his family would be glad to find a purchaser for the drawings. They are about eighty in number, and m‘ght well become the property of some institute Mrs Marshall's address is Bellevue House, Cheyne Walk, Chel- sea, London, —When M. Eugéne Melchoir de Vogiié two or three years ago delivered his address upon bis reception into the French Academy, we noted it as the first signal, shown from a bigh place, to mark the turn of a religious and lite- rary tide. Ever since 1848 the tide had been setting towards naturalism in literature, while in religion and morals it seemed to be flowing towards an abyss of mere negation. If M. de Vogiié was not the first to see ‘hat an ebb was coming, and in fact had begun, he was at least the first to cry aloud that this was so. His views were soon taken up by others: by M. Paul Desjardins in the Journal des Débats, in Figaro, in the Rerue Illustrée; by M. Eugéne Hollande in the Ermifage; by M. Edouard Rod in a striking series of articles in the Revue Bleue, since collected into a book under the title of ‘ Les Idées morales du temps pré sent’; and by many other writers of less weight. Most of these welcomed, or deplored, the coming of a neo-catholicism, a religion of faith and hope and love accompanied by a certain revival—or recrudescence— of ecclesiasticism. How this would come about none knew; that it would come, none seemed to doubt. A new writer, however, has just apreared upon the scene, M. Henry Bérenger, President of the Ass ciation des Etudianta Ina fine study, which a; peared in the Revue Bleue of October 10, entitled ‘* Les Idées modernes dans les livres de M. de Vogiié,” he takes up the whole question from a quite different point of view. It is a con- tribution to the discussion which deserves a careful reading, and which does not lend itself to any process of compression by which a fair notion of it could be given. He looks for no success in the exper’ment of putting the new wine into the old bottles over again, and ex- pects no revival of Catho!l cismin Franca M, Edouard Rod looks for such a revival, and +a, too, apparently, does M. Jules Simon, But M, Henry Pérenger may perhaps comfort himee!l?, if these excellent judges prove to be in the right, with the reflection that, after all, net even the Holy Roman Church isa finality to every religious mind, since many bave passed through it, as also through the Greek and An- glican communions, to the Catholic Church of mankind. —Prof, Rodolfo Lanciani bas repub ished from the Monumenti Anticits of the Academy dei Lincei, Kome, a monograph entitled * L'ltp- nerario di Einsiedeln e L’Ordine di Benedetto Canonico,’ His publication will be of especial interest to the students of the topogra; hy and antiquities of the E ernal City. The * Itine rary " discovered at Einsiedeln dates from the eighth century, but, in the opinion of Prof, Lanciani, it is merely a copy of the names of localities and monuments on a much earlier map, and may therefore be accepted as throw- ing light on Rome during the fourth century. It gives eleven tours or itineraries for pi)grims and strangers to followin their sight-seeing, setting down the places of interest on each side of the streets The ‘Ordo Benedicti’ furnishes similar notes—bufof a later period, it being a work of the twelfth century—for seven walks through the city. Prof. Lanciani has edited both these authorities with great care, collat- ing, wherever material for collating exists, ali references by early or medieval writers to the buildings mentioned. He gives in facsimile several pages cf the original manu- scripts, as well as plans and pictures of the more important sites. Most valuable, perbaps, is bis large plan of Rome, on which, by the use of black and red inks, he enables one to see at a glance the points visited by the traveller of Einsiedeln and by the Canon Benedict respectively. In this way, not only the changes in the nomenclature of particuler monuments, but also the disappearance of old buildings and the appearance of new ones, are readily illustrated. As we should expect, many of the old Roman names—tie thermm of the emperors, the Circus Maximus, the palaces of Nero and Trajan—are omitted from the later itinerary. The Canon records many more churches and shrines, and even in cases where the monuments of the pagan city still remained—as the baths of Caracallg and of Diocletian—he deemed them unworthy of mention to the pilgrim who went to Rome to be edified by its Christian monuments. The later authority passes over the Roman Forum with slight mention, but from the earlier we learn, for instance, that the cavallus Constan- tiné stood not far from the arch of Severus,

Page 14

Bae aie Hee ie Sp cep ‘ ESS Bh, Riltipraten Pan 68. Town Aaa WoeaeS ah Sle PU ie yang ecacy ey ote Sse aentoes ine 096 Aga Sie ~ y 4.30 The Nation. —We will not undertake to discuss the ar- cl w@ological details which Prof. Lanciani’s monograph brings forward, but we will point out that his work, although it is primarily addressed to antiquaries, necessarily throws side-lights on topics of wider interest concern- ing the post-imperial history of Rome. To take a single example, the itinerary of the twelfth century starts from the Churck of St. Anastasia—an indication, as Prof. Lanciani remarks, that the influence of the Byzantine tradition was felt long after the Western and Eastern Churches had drifted far apart. Again, these two lists of buildings—for guide- books in the modern sense they are not—fur- nish testimony on the much-mooted question as to when the spoliation and destruction of the edifices of imperial Rome began; they do not, of course, give particulars, but from the fact that we know that this or that building was still standing in the twelfth century, we know tbat it could not have been demolished by the Teutonic invaders, We can also guess, but with less certainty, as to the population of the city, when we know what parts of it were occupied and how thickly it was dotted with churches. Prof. Lanciani’s monograph is published with allthe luxury of type, paper, bread margins, and folio size in which foreign learned societies like to indulge. When will they learn, however, that a good index, like an honest heart, is better than all this outward finery ? —The Asiatic Society of Japan publishes a pamphlet of much interest to those engaged in the comparative study of institutions, entitled * Notes on Land Tenure and Local Institutions in Old Japan.’ The pampblet is based upon the researches of the late Dr. D, B. Simmons, an American physician whose long residence in Japan had familiarized him witb the cus- toms of the people, and whose cbaracter and abilities were such as to have secured him an exceptional place in their regard. His death unfortunately prevented him from going very far with these investigations, and his memo- randa were left in a chaotic state. Mr. John H. Wigmore has edited them, so far as it was practicable, adding mucky from his own knowledge and securing some contributions from Japanese scholars. The result is but a fragment, but it is fascinating in its sugges- tiveness. We catch glimpses of a society pos- sessing many resemblances to that of England in prehistoric or early historic times, not only in its feudal customs, but also in the relations of the people to the soil which they tilled. There are indications that, as in England, the serfs of early times represented the conquered peoples, whether aborigines or earlier immi- grants than their conquerors, and that the mass of the common people of to-day repre- sent the descendants of the early serfs. Many details are given as to local institutions, the divisions of the land, the size and tenure of holdings, the administration of justice, etc., as well as some curious specimens of feudal laws and customs, The essay opens up a tempting field of study. STEPHENS’S FRENCH REVOLUTION.—I. A History of the French Revolution. By H. Morse Stephens. Vol. II. London: Longmans, Green & Co. ; New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons. 1891, Five years have elapred since Mr. Morse Stephens published his first volume. Readers interested in historical research began to fear that some calamity had arrested the progress of the work. It is with keen satisfaction that we now find that this fear was groundless. The two volumes taken together bear out the opinion which we formed when we first be- came acquainted with Mr. Stephens’s writings, that his book when completed will be the lead- ing English authority on the annals of the Revolution. Few indeed are the critics who have any claim to criticise the detai!s of Mr. Stepbens’s narrative, for the men who in England or America possess anything like his knowledge of the period with which he deals form a very small and select class, This notice is not, we must in fairness add, written by one who claims to belong to this chosen body of histo- rical experts, But it is possible and desirable to form and exrress a judgment of Mr. Ste- phens’s book, not from the point of view of specialistr, but from the point of view of that large and more or less well-informed public for whcse benefit and instruction his ‘ French Re- volution’ is written. All that we attempt is, to consider fairly the characteristics of our authbor’s work and to “‘criticise” it in the true sense of that word—that is, to give an estimate of it which may avoid the impertinence and the irrelevancy at once of flattery and of cen- sure. There is a certain simplicity about Mr. Ste phens’s whole manner of work and mode of thinking which renders the task of criticism comparatively easy. A little reflection shows that his treatment of the French Revolution, especially in his last volume, is marked by one sterling merit which many readers will deem a defect, and by one fault which to many readers will undoubtedly seem a merit. Mr. Stephens’s great merit is his serious and la- borious honesty of purpose. Hence, a deter- mination on his part, which might be called excessive if in such a matter excess were pos- sible, to state facts in the plainest and simplest manner, and to avoid at any cost of tempo- rary popularity the vice of sensationalism, To a generation who have delighted in Carlyle’s highly colored pictures of revolutionary scenes, and in his rbetorical and occasionally bombas- tic moralizing on historical crises, or who have drawn their conceptions of the events which a century ago astounded Europe from the over- colored dramatization of Carlyle published by Dickens under the form of a novel, Mr. Ste- phens’s pages wi!l be grievously disappointing: but every lover of historical truth will feel grateful to him for his abstinence from every attempt either ‘‘ to point a moral or adorna tale.” He has remembered, what we have all of us too much forgotten, that an historian is neither a dramatist nor a moralist, but is pri- marily an investigator. It may be frank‘y admitted that Mr. Stephens has really no turn for the much overrated art cf word- painting, and it is just where the events he varrates are the most theatrical that his defi- ciencies as a narrator are most apparent, But, on the other hand, if he does not give his readers scenes, he gives them facts, and if he is least interesting where other writers most successfully excite the imagination or arouse the passions of students,he is able by the mere force of truth to give an interest to just those subjects which are of the highest importance for the understanding of a great crisis in Eu- ropean history,but which, because they do not lend themselves to dramatic representation, are most constantly overlooked. A few examples, taken from scores of in- stances to be found in Mr. Stephens’s pages, will give some slight idea of the way in which his honest and plain statement of fact adds to our knowledge. On no man has more misrep- resentation been lavished than on Marat. That at the erd of his life be was a sanguinary : maniac is to our mind yerfectly clear from Mr. Stephens’s own narrative, though this is not exactly the conclusion at which he himself arrives. It is, however, also ceriain that Marat was no “‘ horse leech,” but a man of very considerable literary, philosophical, and, above all, scientific acquirements. He he!d medical degrees from many universities; he was a good classical scholar, acquainted with most modern languages. Before the Revolution, he held a good medical appointment con- ‘ nected with the court; he possessed the j friendship of Franklin, and, before the out- ' break of the revolutionary movement, had , studied English society on the spot, and had, with a sagacity not found among many of his contemporaries, noted some at least of the de- fects of the English Constitution, Certainly, to understand this man ‘‘it is necessary to get rid of preconceived ideas. Suspicious and ir- ritable,excitable and rensitive to an extreme, i he attacked everybody, and attacked them with unaccustomed violence, But with all this he was in private life a higbly educated gentleman. The extent of his attainments appears from his numerous works, and it must be remembered that he could not for years have been a fashionable physician and held a court appointment without being perfectly polite and well bred.” About the perfect politeness and good breeding of Marat we may, with the highest respect for Mr. Stephens, entertain some doubt, Patients tolerate much from a physician who cures; eccentric brutality no less than urbane suavity has led more doctors than one to fortune. But it is clear enough that the popular picture of Marat is at best a caricature, He may, as we think he did, have turned into a morose and bloodthirsty agitator. But half the in- struction of revolutionary crises is lost if we do not recognize the fact that the victim of Charlotte Corday was at the beginning of his career no brutal ruffian. Take, again, our author’s account of the Sep- tember Massacres. He is not here at his best, The terribie tale needs to be told by a master of narrative. But even here we learn from him definite facts hardly a:certainable from the pages of most historians. We know precisely how long the massacres lasted and bow many were their victims, ‘‘ They began at midday on Sunday, September 2; they continued through- out September 38; the toal number of the victims bas been variously stated from 850 to 1,458 by serious historians, and probably may be fixed at about 1,i00. . . . Onthe morn- ing of September 4, Roland appeared . . . at the bar of the Assembly and remarked: ‘Yesterday was a day upon the events of which a veil should be drawn, I know that the peo- ple, terrible in its vengeance, has yet made use of a certain justice.’” These statements may seem bald, but they give us the gist of the whole matter. Pages of elcquence might give us far less information, and also make far less impression, So it is in everything of which Mr. Stephens treats, The King’s trial is not in bis pages a grand scene, but we learn from him, what we do not learn from our sen- sationalists, the way in which men really voted, and the strange inconsistency which marked their conduct at a terribly per- plexing crisis, We venture, however, to say, as we have already intimated, that it is in the dryer portions of his subject that Mr. Stephens’s high qualities as an histo- rian are best displayed. The history of the Republican army and navy, the nature of the Great Committee, the whole system of government by committees, wherein the Con-

Page 15

Dec. 3, 1891] The Nation. 431 vention was the unconscious imitator of the Long Parliament, the policy of alternate rash philanthropy and of unscrupulous tyranny which roused civil war in San Domingo, the composition of the Girondin party, the great part played by the so-called Men of the Plain, whore services to their country have been re- warded with oblivion—these and a score more of topics of which most Englishmen know nothing, and of which it behooves us all to know if we are to draw any useful instruction from history, are absolutely forced by our au- thor on the attention of bis readers. Nor does his merit end here. His love of facts is fatal to crude theories, It does much to modify re- ceived views; it dees still more to destroy our writer’s own theories. It is his highest praise that his honesty of statement enables us to correct what to many persons will seem the errors, in one respect, of his historical in- ferences. Mr. Stephens’s one fault isa crudeness of political judgment which leads him, we do not say to defend, but certainly to palliate, the Terrorists and their policy of terror. The novelty of the view taken by him of the Reign of Terror will recommend his history to all lovers of paradox, but it must in fairness be admitted that he is no paradox-monger. No one stands ata greater distance from writers such as Froude, Carlyle, or Victor Hugo. He has no special admiration for revolutionists, He is abwlutely free from the delusion—and this is one of his greatest merits—tibat the Jaco- bins were men of any exceptional ability. ‘It is necessary,” he writes, *‘to understand (hat these twelve men [the members of the Committee of Public Safety] were not exceptionally gifted, specially trained administrators. There were most probably bundreds of other men equally qualified to put an end to anarchy and to re- organize France, . . but circumstances thrust these twelve men to the front.” He does not, again, hold, if we understand him rightly, that the Terror was in the main the result of ;}anic. What he maintains is, that France was falling to ruin for want of a strong government, that the Committee of Public Safety, with its absolute and unlimited power, was the kind of government which the country for the moment needed; that the Com- mittee organized of set purpose a system of government through fear, that in the execu- tion of this scheme they put thousands of innocent men to death, not because these victims of judicial murder had committed crimes, nor because their executioners be- lieved them to be criminals, but because the rulers of France thought that fear of death was the best instrument for main- taining the discipline of the naticn. Mr. Stephens further, as we understand him, holds that the Terror was, from a political point of view, justified by success, and that it may at ieast be doubted whether any other method would have saved the unity and the independence of France, It is difficult to rep- resent briefly and fairly views from which a critic dissents, and which are to be gathered inferentially from expressions scattered up and down a long varrative. The following sentences, however, go a good way to justify our account of Mr. Stephens’s judgment of the Terror: ‘“‘Many evil deeds,” he writes, ‘“‘were done during the Reign of Terror, much blood was wantonly shed, yet for the organizers of the system excuses can be made. They honestly believed that the steady succession of execu- tions was necessary to msintain }eace and good order in France, and that, to save much bloodsh«d from anarchy and civil war, it Was necessary that some lives should be solemply taken with judicial forms, This may not be a valid excuse to strict moralists, but it is an intelligible attitude to adopt.” The attitude is undoubtedly “ intelligible”; so was the attitude of Catiline, of Tiberius, of Pilate, of Nero, of Charles IX, of Judge Jeffreys, and so has been, and always wi!! be, the attitude of every tyrant, bigot, fanatic, or scoundrel whose name history hands down to execration. It does not need a “strict mo- ralist” to condemn murder, or to denounce judicial murder as the very worst form in which the worst of criminals can take away the lives of his fellow-men. This, we are well assured, Mr, Stephens himself knows as well, and feels as keenly, as any of bisreaders. The point, and the only point worth discussing (for the question of morality is settled past discussion), is whether, on any view of expe- diency, the Terror admits of political justifica- tion, That the statesmansbip of the Terrorists was execrable no one really denies ; what we do deny is that it was statesmanship at all, and our great respect for Mr. Stephens’s honest work makes it a duty to deal with it honestly, and say that, in his criticism of the Jacobin leaders, his political judgment is, on the facts as he himself narrates them, utterly at fault. It is, as we have pointed out, his special merit to have tested the revolutionary no less than the anti-revolutionary tradition by the crite- rion of plain facts and, as far as circumstances admit, of precise numbers. Thus he bas given the English world for the first time the statie- tics of the Reign of Terror. Let us take the dates chosen by Mr. Stephens himself; let us assume that the true Terror lasted a little more, or a little less, than a year; that, in strictness, it existed from September, 1793, till the 27th of July, 1794 (th Thermidor, year IJ.), and, in any cas2, ought not to be dated back further than the beginning of April, 1798. Let us now consider what, according to our author’s own view, were the two leading features of this ‘‘crisis of the Re- volution ” which ‘‘is the period which distinguishes it from all other revolutions.” The country was deprived of any real Con- stitution. Twelve men—tbe Ccmmittee of Public Safety—were the absolute despots of France. They, and persons acting under their orders, bad for a!) practical purposes control of the property, the freedom, and the lives of every man and woman throughout France. They deliberately proposed, if Mr. Stephens's view be correct, to rule their c untrymen by asystem of abject fear. To make this bar baric method effective, ‘‘a certain number of executions per day, or per week,” were car- ried out in order ‘ to intimidate those who were not conten'ed with the existing state of affairs.”” What, then, was this certain number of executions, or, in plain truth, of judicial murders? They amounted to 17,540. Of these, 2,500 at least were perpe’rated in Paris alone, and let it be remarked that the num- ber of deaths went on increasing, week by week, like a rapidly spreading plague. From the 10.h of June to the 27th of July, 1893, 1,376 persons were executed in Paris, at the rate, on an average, of 196 victims per week. To all this must be added an untold number of im- prisonments and other acts of violenc>. Nor do we reach the tale of horror when we jlace before our imagination what may be called the specific atrocities of the Terror. As bad as open acts of oppression, or worse, are the menaces, the fears, the suspicions, the abject submission to intolerable wrong, which turned brave men into cowards, and freemen into slaves. The Reign cf Terror, we sball be told—and this is in fact what Mr. Stephens maintains— ! eaved France. But for this view be gives in reality no proof whatever. The authority of the Committee of Public Safety meant two different things It meant, in the first piace, that concentration of executive power which from the beginning of the Revolution bad been vainly demanded by every leader with any claim: to statesmanship, and no one need dis pute that the formation of a strong govern- ment was essential to the preservation of the country. It meant, in the second place, that the strength of the Government was used to carry out a plan of oppression and to en- force this system by organized terror, That this terror was expedient is a matter which neither is, nor can be, proved. The most elementary laws of buman nature, acd the condition of France in 17%, forbid the be. lief in the expediency of crusity and murder, Every civilized ruler knows that the force of punishment in driving men to action is, after all, very weak. Mr. Stephens rightly dwells on the fact that, during the height of the Reign of Terror, men were, as they always must be, mainly occupied with their daily and private sffaira But this is in reality concle- sive evidence of the smal! results produced by the infliction of the severest penal‘ ies Punishment, moreover, owes such effec! iveness as it possesses to its falling upon the guilty. It is absurd to suppoe (hat the execution of thousands whoare not gwil y of any offence will be a terror to evil doera But let any one who is not satisfled with in- ferences based upon the best established prin- ciples of penal legislation consider for a mo ment the state of Franca Were the French- men of 1798 caitiffs who needed to be driven into battle by the lashf Every one knows that this was not sa France abounded then, as sbe always has abounded, in men of high spirit and of rare military capacity. The Reign of Terror may well enough have been necessary to keep the Jacobins in power, but the authority of the Jacobins was not necessary to the salvation of France It was the soldiers of the Repubiic who saved the country, and there is no reason for supposing that France would bave been worse served by her sons had a fanatic like Robe«pierre, or a time-server like Barére, never had an oppor- tunity of exbibiting to the world all the hor- rors that ensue when narrow-minded enthu- siasm or unscrupulous sel. -seeking is combined with unlimited power. On Mr. Stephens’s own showing, the Reign of Terror co-t France over 17,000 citizens. To these we may fair'y, in our own judgment, add the 1,100 prisoners slaughtered in the massacres of September, and we sball not be far from the mark if we assume that between 19,000 and 20,000 citizens were the victims of Jacobinism. But the mere number of murders necessary to support the Terror gives no res] measure of the injury wrought to France by the excesses of rewolu- tionary policy, It is the Reign of Terror whicu has divided France into hostile camps; it is the Reign of Terror, and the traditions it has engendered, which has exposed the French to the constant danger of alternating revolu- tion and reaction; it is the Reign of Terror which, even now, makes it uncertain whether France will ever be the lasting home of ra- tional freedom. Our one quarrel with Mr. Stephens is that his political insight is not equal to his historical knowledge. In a succeeding article we hope to waive ali criticism and to show our readers on how many sides be har, by his diligence and his research, elucidated the his‘ory of the French Revolution. Meanwhile we wou'd sug- gest that, cddly enough, bis theory of a; ology

Page 16

a RE EN POR EN Ss Ee, pA Cas 4a age oe UNL, 482 The Nation. [Vol. 53, No. 1379 for the Terror is scarcely fair even to the Ter- rorists, Were their acts, after all, the result of policy? Panic, cowardice, and stupidity naturally beget cruelty. A poet may, it is pore sible, see further into this matter than an his- torian: “France had lit a light for all men, >reached a gospel all men’s good; Celtic Demos rose a demon Shricked and slaked the light in blood.” THE NEW GERMANY. Geschichte des deutschen LKinheitstraumes una seiner Erjillung. Ia den Grundlinien dargestelli von Dr, J. Jastrow. Gekrinte Preisschrift des Allg. Vereins fiir Deutsche Litteratur. Vierte Auflage. Berlin: Allg. Verein fiir Deutsche Litteratur. 1891. Imperial Germany : A Critical Study of Fact and Character, By Sidney Whitman, John W. Levell Co, 1891. The Young Emperor William II of Germany: A Study in Character Development on a Throne, By Harold Frederic. G. P. Put- nam’s Sons, 1891, Tue close of a period of doubt and strife in the development of a nation, the final or seemingly final settlement of a really vital question, always produces a new theory of the national history. Krom the point of view of the accomplished fact, the historian discovers that the whole movement of the national life has been towards precisely that crisis which has declared itself and that solution which has resulted from the crisis. 1688 created tha Whig theory of English, 1789 the Democratic theory of French history. The close of our civil war and the formulation of its results in the Thirteenth and Fourteenth Amendments have enabled both foreign and American writers to find the leading motive of the past century of our own history, That the estab- lishment of German unity should not have exerted a similar influence upon the historical literature of Germany would be inconceivable. The instinct of scientific synthesis is stronger amoung the Germans than any other people. ‘Too fragmentary,” said Heine, half a cen- tury ago, ‘is the world and life. I will be- take myself to the German professor. He knows how to put it all together, and makes of it an intelligible system.” In Heine’s time a philosophy of history which was very ropular in Germany showed that the evolution of the world was through the national to the cosmo- politan idea; and that precisely because the Germans had so little cf the “‘srecific na- tional” sentiment, Germany was marching in the van of human progress, But now that the Germans have obtained the national organization which their neighbors had achieved centuries before, cosmopolitanism has been relegated to a very distant future. The movement of the age is national, and Germany bas caught up with the proces- sion. The cosmopolitan sentiments of eigh- teenth-century Germans are now regarded as evidences of a morbid condition, and Goethe’s broad humanism, admirable in itself, is con- sidered a symptom of national disease, This view Von Treitschke has presented, with much invective against those of different opinion, in his occasional essays and in the introductory volume of his ‘German History in the Nine- teenth Century.’ This view Von Sybel sets forth, more calmly but not less decidedly, in the opening chapters of his ‘ Founding of the German Empire.’ To the defence of the same thesis Jastrow devotes his ‘ History of the German Dream of Unity and its Fulfilment. Jas'row presents a philosophical theory of German history from the time of Tacitus to the present day. He undertakes to show how and why the Germans failed to achieve na- tional unity under the old empire; how, never- theless, through all the period of their divi- sions, the conscicu:ness of national coherence was strengthening and the ‘‘dream of unity” taking shape; how then, between 1815 and 1850, the nation began to awake from the dream of a “ great Germany,” which should inciude all German-speaking men, and to ac- cept the idea of a ‘‘ narrower Germany,” with a federal basis and a Prussian apex. In con- cluding, he considers the nature of the present German Empire, and endeavors to show how beneficent have been the resuits of politi- cal unity in every part of the national life. His view of German history is more inte- resting than tbat of the purely political his- torians, because he goes beneath the politi- cal phenomena and searches for the hidden springs of the national development. German legends and poetry, religion and art, reveal the popular sentiments and aspirations; these and the practical needs of trade and industry make much of the political history with which a superficial opinion credits the politicians. In these special fields the author is by no means wholly dependent on the results reach- ed by others, He has long been known as an investigator in the domain of German Cultur- geschichte. Jastrow’s view of the ‘‘ mission ” of Prussia seems at first glance to coincide with Von Treitschke’s. The latter would not hesitate to accept the former’s succinct statement of the situation at the middle of the nineteenth cen- tury: “The rise of the Prussian State had a dou- ble significance as regarded the fulfilment of the German dream of unity. Itcould point to the accomplisbed fact that 18,000,000 Germans had found within i's frontiers that political unity which the other 18,000,000 were stiil seeking; and at the same time the stock of political power bere accumulated was large enough to enable P)us:ia to assume the long- desired leadership of the nation” (p. 153). But while Von Treitschke sees only the fact that in its two previous centuries of develop- ment the Prussian State bad destroyed every independent ‘political authority within its borders, "Jastrow points cut that the most important Iccal organs, the cities, lost their independence indeed, but received a generous measure of autonomy. They were simply relegated to their rroyer pluce in the govern- mental system of the modern state. And while Von Treitschke hopes and believes that the monarchic element in the new Empire— that is, the imperial power exercised by Prussia—will ultimately destroy the inde- pendence of the single States, Jastrow believes that Prussia has reconciled the State-rights idea with the requirements of national unity, as it had previously reconciled self-government in the cities with the unity of the State. To Von Treitschke, Germany is on the road to absolute unity, ‘‘ein werdender Einheitsstaat,” and federal government is merely a transitional form. To Jastrow the autonomy of the historic States within the Empire is only one degree less important than their union, and to him the federal form now existing isa presumably final form. It is in- teresting to see how completely each author’s interpretation of history is determined by his political ideals, Witbout attempting to de- cide which theory is the more plausible, it may be pointed cut that Jastrow’s view must be much the more acceptable of the two in Saxo- ny and South Germany; and it may be rugs gested to the Prussian historiographers that insistence upon Von Treitschke’s theory will hardly contribute to the smooth working of the present federal institutions, Jastrow, as we have said, presents a philo- sophical theory of German history, It should be added that he does not attempt to narrate that history; he assumes that the reader is familiar with it, Thatsuch a work should be included in the popular series published by the ** Union for German Literature,” and that it should have reached a fourth edition in six years, sufficiently disproves the recent asser- tion of the young Emperor, that his subjects are ignorant of German histcry. The book has deserved its success, not only by its intrin- sic merit, but by a warmth of tone and clear- ness of statement that are rare in German scientific writing. To the student the forty pages of notes at the end of the volume, with lists of the most important works upon Ger- man political, social, and economic history,are of special value. In the present edition these lists are brought fully up to date. Mr. Whitman’s ‘ Imperial Germany’ is dedi- cated to Prince Bismarck, and tie *‘ popular” second edition is prefaced by favorable ‘‘ opi- nions” from Prince Bismarck and Count Moltke, It is not surprising that these autho- rities were pleased with the work, for Mr, Whitman sincerely admires the Prussian mo- narchy, the German Army, and the ex-Chan- cellor, and devotes a very eulogistic chapter to each. He finds much to say, also, in favor of paternal government, though he is too good an Englishman not to feel its disadvantages, His study of German conditions has convinced him that a laissez-faire policy would ill sub- serve German interests; and he would obvi- ously like to see Government attempt in Eng- land some of the tasks which it performs in Germany, if it could be counted upon to per- formthemas well, Through all these chapters there runs a steady criticism of things English —so steady and sco incisive that one ends by wondering whether Mr. Whitman, like Tacitus, was not moved to write his ‘ Ger- many,’ in part at least, by the desire to make his own countrymen conscious of their evil estate. In the other portions of the book, which deal with the German people and their political, economic, and sccial characteristics, the author continues to criticise freely, but his strictures are directed in the main against the Germans. He is sympathetically conscious of their many adniirable qualities, but in matters political he finds them disposed to carp unduly and lacking in ; atriotism; in matters of trade be praises their diligence, but denies to them the originality and inventiveness which cha- racterize English and American manufactur- ers and merchants; and in matters social he conveys the impression that they are only three-quarters civilized. Like many of his countrymen, and all Americans, he finds the German wife too thoroughly ‘t domesticated.” He quotes Heiue’s saying, *‘ The German hus- band has no wife, but a servant,” and Bis- marck’s declaration that ‘‘our wives are the only ladies we are rude to,” as having ‘‘ more than a passing meaning.” Mr, Whitman’s book is anything but objec- tive: it is full of the personal impressions and feelings of the author. But these are by no means without value, for they are obviously the result of long scrutiny of German life by an unusually clear-eyed observer. No ordi- nary tourist or special correspondent could have written the chapters on **‘ The German Aristocracy " and ‘* The German Philistine.” In a book which attempts to cover so wide a field, it is of course easy te pick flaws. In the chapter upon ‘ The Intellectual Life,” the list personnes Be Per Pe

Page 17

Dec. 3, 1891] The Nation. 433 of notables is open to criticism both as regards the names included and those omitted, The description of German education is superficial and unsatisfactory. But these are minor blemishes. The style of Mr, Wkitman’s book is general- ly easy, if rather careless; but when he falls into metaphor the result is painful. On page 89 we read that “ the backbone of the Prussian nation is loath to pin its faith to foreign models of parliamentarism.” In the two following sentences the monarch appears as ‘‘a beacon- tower” and ‘‘a fountain of grace.” On page 141 we are told, ina single sentence, that Bis- marck’s oratorical “periods are nervously jagged and lack rotundity,” but that “ they fly straight as a dart and . . . pierce the enemy through and through, and thence pur- sue their winged course right across the coun- try, to be remembered as eledge-bammer blows of conviction,” etc. Mr. Harold Frederic’s study of William II. is, from the literary point of view, a well- constructed and uncommonly well- written book. As a contribution to history it is worth- less. The material is simple gossip—gossip of the clubs, the caié:, the legations—such as ‘our regular correspondent” furnishes once a week for a New York newspaner. Some of the statements are prebably true, or half true; some are almost certainly false; but it is im- possible to separate fact from fiction. Where the author goes back of current gossip to his tory, his statements are often inexact. He tells us, for example, that the formation of the Uitramontane or ‘‘ Centre” party was due to the ; ersecution of the Catholics by B smarck. The fact is, that when this par‘y first appeared in force in the Prussian and Imperial Diets, there had been nochange either in the Prus- sian laws regarding religious associations or in their application; and that the laws and their interpretation were confessedly more favora- ble to the freedom of the Roman Catholic Church than those of many Catholic States of Europe. Of ccurse Mr, Frederic, with his trained lite rary instincts, has appreciated the necessity of building a book on different lines from a weekly letter, There must be a central idea and a plot. The plot which he has selected is one familiar to every reader of fiction. There is a hot-headed but well-meaning young man as the hero, and there isastruggle between his good angel and his bad angel. Bismarck, whom the author cordially detests, makes an excellent Mephistopheles; and all that is un- pleasant in the young Emperor’s acts or utter- ances is ascribed to theex-Chancellor’s sinister influence. The good angel, however, is rather an unsatisfactory makeshift. Perhaps the au- thor, emberrassed by the fetters of fact, could find no better person to cast for this réle; but it must be confessed that the good angel is slightly ridiculous. He is an honest German pedagogue named Hintzpeter, of whom the general public knows only three things. Hintz- peter directed the studies of Prince William until the latter went tothe University. About the time that William succeeded to the throne, Hintzpeter published a psychological study of his ex-pupil which was received with general surprise, some annoyance, and a great deal of laughter. In 1889 Hintzpeter was sent by Wil- liam to the coal-fields of Westphalia and the Rhine Province to investigate the grievances of the miners, tens cf thousands of whom were striking. So much is generally known. What is not generally known is, that all that is noblest in William’s ideas and aims was im- planted in his youthful mind by Hintzpeter; that it is Hintzpeter who bas now won him over to the defence of the workingman and the cause of Christian Socialism; that it is Hintzpeter who, by sbeer force of nobility and goodness, forced the bad Bismarck out of office, as the angels in the second part of *‘ Faust” drive Mephistopheles away with rose leaves, All this it has been reserved for Mr. Frederic to reveal to the world, on the autho- rity of ‘‘ men who know the Kaiser well.” A Memoir of the Life and Public Service of Joseph E. Johnston, Edited by Bradley T. Johnson. Baltimore: R. H. Woodward & Co, 12mo, pp. viii, 362, Ir is hard to find a good reason for the exist- ence of this book, A good memoir of Gen. Joseph E. Johnston would be warmly we!- comed, He himself, in bis well known ‘ Nar- rative,’ gave to the world the most full and authentic history of his military career from his own standpoint. Whatever of authentic details of his youth or his private life could be added to this, would be useful and interesting as illustrating his individuality of character and opinion. His private and public corre spondence must contain much that ought not to be lost, because it would help to an under- standing of bim and the history of his time The volume in hand gives us little or no help in either direction. The military part is a not very reliable abridgment of the ‘ Narra- tive,’ untempered and uncorrected by any ap- parent study of the official records, now easily accessible toevery body who affects authorshi; on topics connected with the civil war. A gioss of historical facts from the standpoint of an ultra-partisan in 1865 is certainly an ana- chronism in 1891. The personality of Gen. Jobnston is left untouched except to apply to him, here and there, pbrases of overwrought laudation, A few incidents of a more inti- mate character are found io brief chapters of ‘* Reminiscences” by Gen. D. H. Maury and Col. Archer Anderson, It is impossible to be- lieve that Gen. Jobnston’s relatives aud friends can regard the work as in any sense an ade- quate memorial of him. Instead of any information as to Gen. John- ston’s opinions regarding the orig. u and the right of secession in 1861, we havea chapter giving the editor’s ideas; in which, after re peating the somewhat familiar fact that Washington was a rebel, be proves him also a secessionist by a novel account of the for- mation in 1789 of the Constitut.on of the United States. ‘*Eleven States,” he says, ‘‘ seceded from the Confederation which by its terms was to be perpetual, and formed a new union which was to be more perfect than the perpetual union which had only lasted ten yeara The prime mover in this secession, who presided over the secession convention at Philadelphia, ard who rigned the act of secession called the Constitu- tion, was George Washington, known to the world and in the hearts of his countrymen as the father of his country ”! His own notion of the great rebellion is this: “ By 1861 the power of government had been u-urped by one section, within the letter and in defiance of the spirit and intent of the law; and tbe minority, in the exercise of those rights by which Anglo-Saxon liberty had been protected and defended for a thousand years, withdrew from that Government, which was no longer their Government, and established a new Union, under an amended and improved Constitution, better suited to the pew con- ditions of society,and better adapted to secure liberty to their posterity.” The editor bas never heard that the gigantic struggle between the principles of free labor and slave labor had been going on for half a century, and has not even now learned that it cut any figure in the contest of 1861, for he does not mention it He is equally ignorant that the preéminent and capita! clause in the Montgomery Constitution, which he praises as “better adapted to secure liberty to their posterity,” was in these words: “* No bill of at- tainder, ex post-facto law, or law denying or impairing the right of property in negro slaves shall be passed.” These stand out upon the parchment with a lurid iUlumination which blinds alleves to the rest, so that the world (excepting the editor) reads them alone, he is ignorant that they are thera The living geveration of Southern statesmen have with one accord recognized the great truth of the century, that America has taken a long siride in true progress and civilization, so that no- thing could induce them pow to turn their faces in the direction they faced in INiL = It is a pity that any book can now be written about one of the Southern worthies without a clear recognition of thia Conscious of the fact that his material re lating to Gen. Johnston was insufficient to warrant its publication as a book, the editor has inserted a hundred pages of passionate attack upon Gen. Sherman for bis march to the sea and through South Caroliva, Johnston was not in military command during that peried, and the matter has no more re ation to Johnston's biography than to that of Lee or Stonewall Jackson. Here, again, one is forced to wonder at the Rip Van Winkle sleep the editor bas indulged in, Since INQ, no man in the nation Was more constantly in the popular eye than Sherman, no one was more trans- parent, no one was more free in speech or used fewer reticercea He went every where, Sourh as Well as North, Every man in the country (except the editor) knows that he was frank, impulsive, speaking the feeling of the moment with little care for apparent consistency, but acting in all important matters with high and fixed principles. His bluff words were accom panied by kind and sympathetic acts) Mean- ness, cowardice, cruelty, be abhorred. Peace being made, there was no Ove Whom Southern officers found more ready to do them friendly offices Johnston knew and felt this; he re- newed cordial relations with him; he was one of the chief mourners at his burial. Yet, of allthe men in the world, it is Sherman that the editor selects to pad bis book with an irre- levant attack the most uncharitable, the most false to characteristics fixed by universal pop- ular knowledge and solid reputation, the most absurdly inconsistent it was possible to make. Not only this, but if true it was most dispa- ragirg to Gen, Johnston that he should have renewed his friendship_with such a man and followed him mourning to his grave. The cli- max becomes ludicrous when the effcrt is made to picture the negotiation at Durbam Station, when Johnston surrendered, as evidence of bitter and unscrupulous hatred on Sherman's part towards the Scuth—a negotiation for which Sherman broke with Stanton and Hal- leck, and declared that no one should violate the faith pledged to those who surrendered ex- cept over his body! Sheridan is made the object of a briefer but not less angry at‘ack, but, comically enough, Grant is warmly eulozized in contrast to his great lieutenants in the very matters for which they are denounced, and for which, in Sheridan’s case, at least, he accepted the full responsibility of command, both in his official reports and in his personal memoirs, Asif to show that it is the praise and not the abuse which is to be taken in a Pickwickian sense, the appendix gives the evidence that Grant

Page 18

Ve APs SL ¥ eae ea NR a Sse ER Re A A IEE REN 5 434 The Nation. [Vol. 53, No. 1379 had interfered to release the editor from ar- rest for treason in 1866 We have, perbaps, noticed this book at too great lengtb, but it has seemed necessary to emphasize the fact that the time has passed when writings will be taken as historical which are mere appeals to passions supposed to be buried, and which, even in the circles to which they are addressed, will ‘“make the judi- cious grieve.” Ocean Steamships. Chas. Scribner’s Sons. 1891. Tu1s handsome volume, which is fully illus- trated, contains a series of articles printed from time to time in Scribner's Magazine, treating of the steamship, its development, construction, machinery, routes, and traf- fic. The plan is somewhat similar to that adopted by the same publishers for a work upon the American railway, and the articles bave been revised since their publication in the magazine and brought down to the present day and to the latest record-bresking of the transatlantic liner, With the exception of the last article of the book, the treatment of the ocean steamship is almost entirely confined to those engaged in transatlantic trade, and more particularly to steamers sailing to and from the port of New York. This limitation, however, is made only to a certain extent for local reasons, as the transatlantic routes from New York have, by their great importance, peculiar demands, and severe conditions, evolved the highest types of sea going steamers efloat. Vessels created by the demands of this trade, but superseded by other ships of a later type, can be found per- forming service in other oceans, and travellers to China, Japan, or New Zealand from some ports of England or the Pacific Coast may find themselves once more upon the decks of a one- time “favorite” Cunarder or White Star liner. The shortness of the yeriod covering the de- velopment of the steamship can be better re- alized when we read that the same engineer, Mr. John Robertson, who in 1812 placed the engines in the Come?, the pioneer steamer in British waters, also superintended their erec- tion in the South Kensington Museum in Lon- don as an antiquated object of curious histori- cal interest. A collection of models repre- senting the history of steam navigation in the United States would be an interesting feature for the Columbian Exposition at Chicago, and though a lack of symmetry might be suggest- ed in the absence of an American ocean grey- hound, still, models of the latest American cruisers and torpedo boats would show that the skill to create the greyhound was in ex- istence, and the non-existence of this type of commerce-creator could usefully serve to point a moral and adorn a tale. The marvellous economy which the inven- tive ingenuity of the present generation has created in the propulsion of the modern steam- ship can be somewhat appreciated when the statement is made that a half-sheet of note- paper will develop sufficient power, when burn- ed in connection with the triple-expansion en- gine, to carry a ton a mile in a transatlantic steamer. How an economy so great as this is to be still further increased and to go hand-in- band with increased speed, seemsa very difficult problem for solution. Little more improve- ment can be expected in the mode! of hull; the s lution lies more probably in improved ma- chioery and steam generators, in modes of pro- pulsion, and in the use of more efficient and compact fuel, The devel: pment of engines of the quadruple-expansion type may do some- thing, new systems of forced draught may prove more efficient and less destructive than those in use, and the use of petroleum (or rather the residuum of petroleum) may be made more practicable and safe; but it is doubt- ful if more than two propellers will add much to existing speed and outweigh the disadvan- tages presented. To those who expect much from the new cruisers designed to use three propellers, let us commend the words of the Engiueer-in-Chief of the U. 8. Navy, who says: ‘* Knowing that it was extremely im- probable that shafting of the great size neces- sary to transmit this enormous power to twin- screws could be obtained in this country, either in reasonable time or with any guarantee as to its strength, the Bureau decided to depart from the usual practice and to divide the power into three parts instead of two, each being de- veloped by a separate engine driving its own screw. . . . It is not supposed by the Bureau that three screws will prove a more efficient mode of propulsion than two; on the contrary, it believes that, except for the high- est power, they will prove slightly less efficient, but its reasons for adopting them have already been given.” The first article of the book before us is upon the development of thesteamship, by Command- er Chadwick, U.S. N. This leads us from the steamers Clermont and Comet, the latter forty feet long on the keel, to the City of Paris, the Teutonic, and the twin-screw Touraine of 11,- 675 tons displacement. This increase of size is not likely to end here, as already ship-builders are offering to build a vessel guaranteed to cross the Atlantic in five days, having a length of 630 feet, and with 33,000 indicated horse- power. The fastest passage given is that of the Teutonic in August last, in 5 days, 16 hours, and 31 minutes, at the average rate of 20.35 knots an hour. It may be of interest to state that the speed and capacity of the Teutonic, and also of her sister ship, the Majestic, are such that she can steam from Portsmouth, England, to Bombay, by the way of the Care of Good Hope, in twenty-two days without coaling onthe way. The distance is over ten thousand miles, and the significance of the fact lies in the future utility of vessels like these as Indian transports, in the event of the route by the way of the Suez Canal being closed in time of war. The article upon the building of the ocean greyhound, though by a non-profese sional, is clearly and well written, and eannot fail to be instructive. That of Lieut, Kelly, U. & N., upon the ship’s company is especially readable and spirited, written as it is with all the buoyancy and bonhomie so characteristic of its au- thor. With the least promising of subjects, he bas given us one of the best of the series, Mr, Rideing’s article upon the dan- gers and the safety on board of the Atlantic liner brings out in prominence, as it should, the element of danger involved in foggy or thick weather, and should serve to calm the impatience of the passenger who is suddenly shut out of port by a heavy fog or snow-storm. No tradition of the sea is better founded than that shown by the antagonistic feeling exist- ing towards those who profess to be good ‘fog pilots”; they are, indeed, a delusion and a snare. Much, very much, has been done to render steamship navigation safe; but nothing can eliminate the necessity for vigilance, or relieve the feelings of care and anxiety that at times press heavily upon the commander of an ocean steamer. The record of the year 1890, Lowever, speaks eloquently of the efli- ciency and good management of the trans- atlantic service. Nearly 2,000 trips were made from New York, about 200,000 cabin passengers were carried to and fro, and nearly 872,000 immigrants landed without accident. The inception of one of the great steamship lines of the world was due to an American— William Wheelwright—who was the father of the project which led to the establishment of the Pacific Steam Navigation Company, with its various routes and many steamers. Now that the unfriendly attitude of the Chilian people towards Americans of the North has become so prominent a topic of the day, it is of interest to note that of the three public statues erected to individuals in Valparaiso, one honors the memory of Wheelwright, to whom Chili owesso much for the promotion and introduction of steamship, railroad, and telegraphic communication, With all of the achievements of the ocean steamship so graphically depicted in these pages, and with allof the interest and pleasure aroused by a contemplation of the wonderful improvements created by buman ingenuity, comes an unavoidable regret that our own flag flies over so few ocean steamers, and over none that are peers of the modern transatlantic liners; and this in spite of the fact that our foreign commerce was never greater than now. Asbip, either of the navy or mercantile marine, is peculiarly a representative of the nationality to which it belongs, and with the national pride, that we all should have exists the desire to see the flag flying upon ships the equals of any afloat. Neither the skill nor the capital is now lacking to obtain or manage these, and it is to be hoped that the fiscal Jaws that prevent our steamship lines from equal- ling in efficiency and importance our great railways may speedily come to an end, Seas and Lands. By Sir Edwin Arnold, Longmans, Green & Co. Tuis reprint of the letters sent by Sir Edwin Arnold to the Daily Telegraph of London during a trip to Japan for rest and recreation, appears in the form of a handsome ornamental octavo volume. The book is an excellent specimen of mechanical work, and is well illustrated and indexed. The letters describe the people and country, especially in and around the Canadian, American, and Ja- panese capitals, Ten are devoted to America and thirty to Japan. The author’s style is bright, sparkling, and touched with the emo- tion of the moment, so that each letter, now transformed into a chapter, is exceedingly read- able. Sir Edwin seems to be at home in addressing an audience of Harvard students, a company of Japanese editors, a bevy of Buddh- ist priests, or in lecturing in a missionary university. He issure to say something that pleases each audience, though apparently not over-careful to make his various statements harmonize, One example of several, which we noticed in bis letters when first printed in the Tele- graph, and which we expected to find pruned out in the published volumes, is his allusion at Harvard to the Pilgrim ship Mayflower. **Do you know,” ssid he (p. 110), ‘* that the Mayflower which brought your ancestors thither (sic) went down in Indian waters cff Masulipatam?” This suggestive remark, in the form of a question—an echo of Sir George Birdwood’s—was given further publicity by the American, Mr. Henry Stevens, in his volume on ‘ The Dawn of British Trade to the East Indies,’ It is many months, however, since Sir George Birdwood, in his second edi- PR Rea tog cero iach Ay A ee

Page 19

Nera 2 AAR STARS AE IER TENSORS IT SS

Dec. 3. 1891] ‘The Nation.

tion of ‘ Old Records of the India Office,’ has shown, on the testimony of a contemporanecus entry, that the Mayflower which foundered « ff the coast of Coromandel! was a ship of between two hurdred and elghty and three hundred tons, The consort of the Speedwell from fouthampton to Land’s End was probably an old ship in 1620, sitca she nearly went to pieces on the At’antic, and had to be he'd to- gether with a good piece of Dutch bardware frcm Delft. To say nothing of a vessel built of ordinary English timber lasting until 1659, the famous Mayjlower was of but one hun- dred and eighty tons burden, or with less room on board than many an Erie canal beat. While among us, Sir Edwin visited our ‘* good grey poets,” Whittier and Whitman, and his narrative of experiences with these and with humbier folk is thoroughly enjoye- ble, albeit the description of the Camden inte- rior is said by the less other-worldly to be worthy of tbe author’s warm imagina- tion. In Canada, also, Sir Edwin came in contact with the singers, and graces his paces with their poetic gems, In Japan he lost bis heart, and his strain of praise is constaut and without a break. The women captivated him, and of the scores of illustrations, in the text or full-page, the majority pic’ ure women in every pose, of various estates, and in all kinds and quantities of array. Apparently Le saw few or nore of the stadows of life in Japan, and his rhapsody and j@an is one which Japanese husbands and fathers, to say nothing of the wives and daughters, weuld read with interest. Strange as it may seem, a gocd many of the native editors who listened to the flatteries of their brother of the pen, did not enjoy the sort of stroking which Sir Ed- win gave them. Certainly in Tokio, these flatteries compor'ted ill withthe intense serious- ness of the native editors, reformers, and lite- rary men. It is true that the author’s ‘ Light of Asia’ was, as he states, translated into Japanese, but the original and the translation bear the same relation to each other as a liv- ing man to a ghost, The real fact of the matter, and one which cannot be disguised, is, that the intellectual Japavese who bas come to himself, and enter- ed even partially into that estate of self-con- sciousness so characteristic of the Europear, is profuundiy dissati fied with the low estate of his ccuntry and people. He knowsthat all this fulsome talk of writers like Sir Edwin Arnold can atone but little for the intellaciual poverty of his language and litera'ure. Hav ing entered into the new world of ideas born in Europe, he feels teat compliments about his art, poetry, politeress, and the assurance that he and his daughter are the most charm- ing beings on earth, have a tcuch of irony. He does not even hesitate to question theif sin- cerity, or if be believe them to be genuine, as they often undouLtedly are, be regards them as condescension. His ambition is to see and think like an Occicental. To bim, compliments about what he deems trivialities are little relished, or at least less so than might su; er- ficially appear. It may be, indeed, that the genuine appreciativeness of a small minority of foreigners, and the large poy ular demand for their cheap art-procucts, will stimulate the Japanese to set greater stcre upon their undoubted gifts and good qualities, To the intellectual and more earnest Japanese, how- ever, the severe but kindly criticisms of Prof. Chamberlain, for example, are more we!come and help‘ul than lavish compliment. The author’s descriptions of nature, peoyle acd politics make fascinating reading. More than any other visitor to Japan kedwells upon

the art and poetry, the quaint cor ceits, lovely manners, and dainty decoration of the Ja- panese. He will delight thcusands of readers, and none the less because of the charm of hisstyle than because he gives but one sidc--the beautiful side—of a country and people whom to see is to like, if not to love. The final chs pters of the book convey information concerning Japan’s politics, army, Parliament, foreign relations, and need of treaty revision, which ought to be prized in England. On his homeward voyage past Sumatra Sir Edwin passed the Dutch blockading vessels. His version of the Acheen war and the present situation between Nether- lander and Malay is characte‘istic of a tho- rougk-going believer in the blessings of British rule in Asia,

The Ancestral Dictionary. Edited by John O.borne Austin, Prev dence: Published by the Auther. 1801, Tus is the third and the smal'est of the works with which Mr. Austin has illustrated the genealogy of his native State, but it is in close relation with his great ‘ Genealogical Diction- ary of Rbode Island’ and his waitin ‘ An- cestry of Thirty-three Rhode Islanders born in the Eighteenth Century.’ From fclio be now descends to octavo form, and talu'ates the pedizree for three generations of sixty. four persons, of whom tive-sixths are Rhode Is'andera, and the rest nearly all bave Rhode

Island affiliations, Twenty of them are s living, the editor among them; forty-tl died in the present century he first and fourth decades excepted), and bat one int last century. No reason is assigned for tt relection, and it is clear that this sort of work could be multiplied indefinitely, like the Messrs. Munsell’s series of ‘ American Ances- try.’ In fact, ore merit of this Dictionary is that it furnishes at the end a number of bilan! tables to be filed in ad /ibitum by the possess or. Some of the better known of Mr. Austin’s subjects are Gen. T L. Casey, Rowland R Hazard (1702-1874), Edward Harris, Sarat Helen (Power) Whitman, and Dr. Henry E Turrer. Aitogether, the 64 in their a:cent in volve most of the prominent families Rhode Is'and, as the 275 surnames of the inden show, Mis Betsey Williams (i700-183 repre-ente, not alone, the stock of Roger Willisms:, whose descendants for five generations were so fully set forth in the ‘ Thirty-three Rhode Islanders.” two at ‘east derive also from the mrch-mar- ried and prolific daughter of Lewis Latham that cheerful old centenaran (1555-16), fal- coner to Charles I, whise progeny was ex- hibited in the same work, An autber tic por trait of bim bas beea selected by Mr. Austin for a frontispiece, and bas a curious in‘ercst Nothing but praise can be bestowed on Mr. Austin’s part in this convenient form of family record. His arrangement is c’ear and taste.

ful, and his accuracy extreme as alwars,

Delagoa Bay, its Nativesani Natural Hist> ry. By Rose Monteiro. With ® original ilustration. Londen: G. Philip & Son. 1891, Pp. xti, 274 Seo, It would be difficult to fied a parallel instance to the life of which this book is a portrayal. For the rake, mainly, of collecting insecte,

the author, an Englist lady. spent five years in a cottege a little di-tance from Lourer¢ Marques, the Portuguese town at ‘hs bead cf Delegoa Bay, with none but Kafirs for her ccmranions, scmetimes abcla‘ely alone, and andnrine Cc enauring c h ieerfu ly very consid: rab! land privation. Her self-sscrifice in he interest

of science was, however, not witheut i: rewerd, for in summing up her work 5 says: “Many new insects in all clas have fallen to my share, too many to be e: meratei here. There is even a new pen: amoung the grassboppers. The earler cha; ters of her book contain bright and animat descriptions of ber bcuse and its surroundings, and the record of a day's cecupations. Thes consisted of at least seven hours of collectiny, the remainder of the day beirg devoted t» preparing the specimens, feeding ber caterpi lars and other captive animals, as well as pr viding for ber own scanty wants Accordty to her account, the attiactions of her hon: could not have been very great even to an e: thusiastic entomologist, for it was the abidir place of countless snakes, scorpians, cen pedes, lizards, cockr. aches, to say potbir

of moquitoer, spiders, fle, ants ef a inds, and swarms of fleas As her ex cursiens for insects were corfloal to ¢t immediate neighborhood of her t se, she sa comparatively little of the wild natives, that her references ¢ hese living near t coast cOntain little that is fre.h or warthy note. A possible exception should be made an interesting trad 1 related to ber by Katic ** bov,” as to the cause of » suberdis tion t ick thew se gre er re ¢ x, . it at f o the i | w t Ww ™ 4 f “ ; ro ww i ALA 3 way char r A ila ihere a yatew ¢ t e Po g > ana t 3 $ J trv, a ase : y rab'e. Fr pure lack «cf energy and « rprise e Por guese ALpear wh ng ef vally ev pth SON sofa x ally r te rv, which ts suffert x fy t 3 lack a suf rf at ihe book verry ra apy Car > with pe V £ ( iapt show ‘ } ction BOOKS OF THE WEEK b.¥. Psaiism s ted Lond Ls t Stock Ball, st bh alse il Age Modern Scter series Dd, — ton & *C Pa: cs. J. K i iywink Tales. New York H. Ra & rr. Mrs. A. } A Rose of a Hundred Leaves. 4 I i

I e Story Daxld, Meal &é 61.5 ~ = Ar _ The Poetand h.sSe.f. Poston: Roberts Bowden, E. M The Imitation of Bud : juotations from Buddhist Literature for each Dey tn the Yea: London Methuen & -8) Cherles Seribner’s Sons. 61.75. ‘@. Apatole. Thais. Chicago: ile CO, Smith ditshing: o. &) cents. e of Gettysburg. Boston: Lee

Dae hes: Annette, Chicago

Frith, Ren ry. The Biogra we a Locomotive Engtne a sel biishing Co

Page 20

Grimke, A, H. vie Sore, Geerioon, the Aboli- Hartley, J. Ss. Hawley, Helen A Hawley, Helen A. Friendly letters to Girls. A. D. Helmburs, W. Misjudged. Rand, McNally & Co. we — B. F, The Rice Mills of Port Mystery. Chi- Higginson, we Ws Co. $1.50, Hovey, Kichard. Tauncelot and Guinevere. United Johnson, Virginia W. The tionist. Funk & Wazn Griswold, W. M. Ad. — Fe “ft American, In- ternational, Komantic and British Novels. Cam- bridge, Mass.: W. M, Griswold. Harper’s Young People, 1591, Harper & Pros. | Anatomy in Art. New York: *tyles & | Lever, Charles. Charles O’Malley t'e Irish Di agoon. A. Friend!y Talks with Boys. A. D.F. Randolph & Co. 50 cunts, F. Randolph & Co. 50 cents 25 cents, : Charles H, Kerr Co. 50 ce ston: Lee& Shepard, #1.50. 1& Co. Holmes, O. W. Poetical Works. 3 vols, [Rivecsife Lytton, E. B. The Last Days of Pompeii. 2 vols. $4. Edition.| Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & States Book Co. Powells, W.D. An Imperst! ve Duty. Harper & Bros. Hughes, Rev. H. Frinciples of Natural and tuper- natural Morals. 2 vols. London: Kegan Paul, Trench, Triibner & Co. Huldekoyer, R. 8 Age «f the Domestic Animals. Philadeiphia : F. A. Davis. $1.75 Ibsen, H, Brand. londcn: Methuen & Co Lily of the Arno; or, | | ! Florence Past and Present. Eoston : Estes & Lau: riat. Johnson, Prof.C. F. English Words: An Elementary Study of Derivations. Harper & Bros. Kennan, George. Siberia and the Exile System. 2 | vols. The Century Co. #6. Kirkpatrick, Mrs. JT. J, The Modern Cook Bock. | —— ©O.: Mast, Crowell & Kirkpatrick, 60 | Kick Sines ©, Clobers; ‘Beaten: Houghton, MimMin | &Co. 81. 25. | Le Sage, A. R, The Bachelor of Salamanca. Worth- Little One’s Annual: Stories and Poems. Boston: Lombro 0, Prof. Cesare. The Man of Genius. London: 1.2 Loughead, Mrs. F. H. The Man from Nowhere. ts The New World and the New | Lounsbury. Prof. T. BR. Studies in Chaucer : His Life k. Bo: Hine, C, V. On the Indian River. Chicago: Charles | Lyttn, E. B. Rienzi, the Last of the Roman Tribunes. Horwitz, Miss C. N, Fairy Lure, Bootes : be Lotnsep Maclean, Clara D, Lighto’ Love, Worthington Co. Mather, Helen. One Summer in Hawail. Cassell Matthe ws, brander. ‘ihe Dramatic Essays of Charles Manrice, Rev. F.D. Lincoln's Ina. Sermons, Vol. ii. TM McLaren, E. T. Doctor John Brown and Pow: Sister 85 cents. ute ner. H. W. Our Amateur Circus. Harper & | wane: “Rev. W.W. | Molfére, J.B. Le Misanthrope. Boston: Ginn & Co, | Moody. Mrs, M. L. wu ger, Rev. Tt. T. Nas», Henry. Ba we 8 or, the Teland of Pearls. The Nation. [Vol. 53, No. 1379 brief sketch of the Dev elopment of the syanish 1 of Painting in Mexico. New York: The F Lamborn, R, H. Mexican Painting and Painters: a | Nevill, Palph. Od Cottage oy Domestic Arch tee- ture !n Southwest Surrey. d ed, —_. Eng.: Billing and fons ; New York. Dodd, Mead & ‘Co. Schoo Author, Ober, Fred. A. ‘The Knockabout Club ‘on the Spanish ington Co. vols, Koston : Little, Brown & Co. retes & Lauriat. $1.75, Walter Scott; New York: Charles Scribner's Sons. ‘*The Gold Dust Series.”} ‘tan Francisco: C, A Murdock & Co. 25 cents and Writings, 3 vols. Harper 2 vols, Boston : Estes & L auriat Boston ;: Estes & Lauriat Publishing Com pany Lamb. ‘Dodd, Mead & Co. $1 2 Macmillan & Co. ¢1.: Isabella. Sth ed, A. D. FP. fandolph & Co. Selected Fragments of Roman | Poetry. “Oxford: Clarendon ress; New York Macmillan. 25 cents. The Litt!e Millfonaire. Boston: Lothrop Co, $1.50. On the ee. New ed. Boston : Houghton, Mifflin & Co, Macmillan & Co, & Main. Boston: Estes & Lauriat. $1.50, O'Connor, T. P. The Life of Chartes Stewart Parne t Ward, Lock, Bowden & Co, 50cen A a Ivan. The Structure = the Bible. Grafton, Parke. T. H. } Peattie, Elia W. Peters, k. D., : Gospe! of Ch ist Prin My lersonal Experiences in Equatorial Africa. Charies Scribner's Sons. 6. *eacock, T.L. Melincourt. 2 vols. London : J. M. Dent & Co.; an S York: Macmilian. With Se se and Staff ; “A Tale of the Children’s Crusade. . F. Randolph & C oO. €1. jr. Modern yo: Methods of Cap- per Sme Itip 2d ed. New York: The Scientific Publishin Poole, J. g Co. Practical Telephone Handbook ard Guide to the Teleph pa Exchan e. London: Whit aker & Co.; New Y : Macmillan. 75 cents. Pope, F. L. Modern Practice of the sectals Telegrap!: ; Tith ed. D. Van Nostrand Co. Prentiss, Prof. G, L. The Agreement between ba a Seminary and the General Assembly. Randolph & Co, 50 cents. Pris. Bostcon: Roberts Bros. 50 cents. Pyle, Howard. A Modern Aladdin ; or, Lone Wonder ful Adventures of Oliver Munier. ‘Ha’ & Richarcs, Laura E,. Hildegarde's unde. Eoston : Estes & Lauriat. $1.25, | Robertson, J. L. Thomson's Seascns, ete. Oxford Clarendon Press; New York: Macmillan. Rose and Lavender. Boston: Roberts pe 61, kuftini, G. D. Doctecr Antonio. Chicago: A. C. ¥e- Clurg & Co. 75 cents. Fuskin, J. Poems. {Brantwood Fdition.] 2 vols Charles E. Merrill & Co. $3. Russe a Dora. Out of Eden. John W. Lovell Co. 5) cen Russell, W.C. The British Seas. Macmillan & Co Sumner, Prof. W. The Finaneler and the Financea of the Americ ch, Mais olution, 2 vols. Dodd, Mead &Co. €5. ‘“No better book can be found as a gift fora healthy GIRL or BOY.” — Loston Lost YOUNG FOLKS’ CYCLOP.7:DIA OF GAMES AND SPORTS By J. D. CHAM’ LIN, Jn., and AriHuR E. Bostwick, S37 pages, illustrated, #250, The Yatior peared befor N. ¥. Tribune: “‘A mine of joy. ., . A positive treasure,” ays: **Nosuch collection has ever ap Literary VW dmirable. . . . Destined to 1 wice sale. A treasure In every househo!d that belleves In games or spor ts of : bY sort. HENRY HOLT & CO., N. Y. _ of Maine. CAPE ROSIER, The lands of the *‘Cape Rosier Asscciates’’ on Penobscot Bay, 50 miles nearer Boston and the West than Bar Harbor, Mt. Desert, are offered for sa'e in pares 'sof five and ten acres and up- wards, These lands conmpri-e over ien miles of almost continuous shore-frontege in one of the bo'dest and 1raost beautiful sect.ons on the coast, twelve bours’ journey from Boston, They front upon fine harbors, have beauti ul rocky shores, beaches, woods, und mountain views, Thedrivesalong theshoresand among the bills are very varied and beautiful, New wharves have been built, and new connections with daily trains and steamboats establisked, In these !ands is offered an exceptional oppor- tunity to purchase for very small sums fine and perfectly protected seashore estates, The lands will not be sold for specuiation or in small lots. w ~_—— LI EN N eBay noe RAY HOWE, ‘RED BOW “y Gale Trustees R Schooi Street, Boston, Mass, we » - The Goldth waite Geographical Magi zne Pub- lishers, New Yorn, are offering special induce- ments to every one ordering through them, The Century, Harper's, Serib: er’s, or the Cosmopoll- tan for 1592, their Gecgraphical Magazine, tree. This is a most liberal offer indeed, and our read- ers who may desire: ny of these great Mag: zines, cannot do better than to order througn them. Sample copy of the G, G. M. Free to every reader of the Nation. THE GOLDTAWAITES, 132 Nussau St., N. Y oe ACK NUMBERS, “VOL UME. S. “OR a of leading and scarce magasines of. for B, WiLLiams, 196 West 10th St., N. ¥. | among college men, Dainty Foods Demand it. N EVERY Re- ri that calls tor baking ae r, he “Ro yal. oe) ase: -f Better results will be obtained because it 1s the purest. It will make the food | lig rhte r, sweeter, of finer flavor, more di- gestible and wholesome. It is always reliable and uniform in its work. i have found the Roval Bal Powder superior to all others. C. Gor]t Late Chef, Delmonico s. Professor Royce’s sémyont chemist wi Libel. A Public Appeal for Redress to the Corporation and Overseers of Harvard Universit bY Francis ELttincwoop Aszor, Ph,D. This pamphlet is exciting intense interest | especially Harvard gradu. | To be bad of your news. | ates, Price, 25 cents, | dealer, or GEORGE H. ELLIS, Publisher, { 141 FRANKLIN ST., Boston, A Tonic HORSFEORD'S ACID PHOSPHATE. A most excellent and agreea- ble tonic and appetizer. It nourishes and invigorates the tired brain and body, renewed energy and vitality, and enlivens the functions, imparts Dr, EpHRAIM BATEMAN, Cedarville N. J., says: “T have used it for several years, not only in my practice, but in my own in- dividual case, and consider it under al! circumstances one of the best nerve tonics that we possess. For mental exhaustion or overwork it gives re- _newed strength and vigor to the entire | system.” Descriptive moti free. , Providence, R. I. Beware of Substitutes and Imitatiens, CAUTION; Be sure the word ** Horsfcrd’s' isentnelabel, All others are spurious, Never ania oe hnoik 2 We buy and cell bills of exc hange oa Letters and make Cable Transfers of money to of Furope, Australia, and the West Indies; also make Collections and tssue Com c dit mercial and Travelers’ Credits, availa- reqait. bie in all parts of the world, Brown Brothers & Co., Bankers, NO. 0 WALL STRERT, NEW YORK. Mr. HL MISCHKE, 2 and 4 Barclay St. (Astor House), New York, bas now ready fcr the BOLIDAY SEASON / afine selection of of! paintings, water colors, photo gravures, etchings, and envravings. Also a full iMne | of books for ebild ren and adits, suitable for Christ mas and New Year’ 3 ap re se bts. ARTISTI RAMING A SPECIALTY, Pr MENDES IY Fs es a alates ORO IRE DRIES OE SE GBM ERE Ee ape APL aah Seis CR banc san namo