The Nation 1891-01-08: Vol 52 Iss 1332
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
‘The Nation
= VOL. LIL—NO.1332 THURSDAY, JANUARY 8, 1891. PRICE 10 CENTS
THE NEW PHILOSOPHICAL QUARTERLY THE MONIST. PUBLISHED BY THE OPEN COURT PUBLISHING COMPANY.
CONTENTS FOR JANUARY, 181. VOL. /., NO. 2. THE ARCHITECTURE OF THEORIES. CHARLES S. PEIRCE. ILLUSTRATIVE STUDIES IN CRIMINAL ANTHROPOLOGY. 1. “La Béte Humaine ” and Criminal Anthropology. 2. Psychiatry and a. Secretions of Criminals. b. Power of Smell. c. Taste. a logical Anomalies—Skeleton, Skull, Wrinkles. g¢. Tattooing. PROF. CESARE LOMBROSO. THE SQUARING OF THE CrircLe. An Historical Sketch of the Problem from the Earliest HERMANN SCHUBERT. THE CRITERION OF TRuTH. A Dissertation on the Method of Verification. EDITOR FivE SOULS WITH BUT A SINGLE THOUGHT. The Psychological Life of the Star-Fish. CARUS STERNE LITERARY CORRESPONDENCE. German Philosophy in the Nineteenth Century., PROF. FRIEDRICH JODI Recent French Publications. LUCIEN ARRKEAT., Book REVIEWS. SUMMARY OF THE CONTENTS OF THE LEADING PHILOSOPHICAL PERIODICALS OF AMERICA Single numbers, 50 cents; $2.00 a Year. Sold by all News (LONDON AGENTS: Messrs, WATTS & CO.,17 Jotnson’s Court, Fieet Street, B.C) THE LOST MANUSCRIPT. A Novel. By Gustav Freytac. Just published in two elegantly boun printed voiumes. 97édpp. Boxed. Price $4.00. Authorized transiation from the sixteenth German edition. Gustav Freytag writes as a motto for the American edition: ** A noble human life does not end on earth with death, It continues in the minds and the deeds of triends, as well as in the thoughts and the activity of the pation,”’ oy 7 yrreD . —_ _ OTHER PUBLICATIONS. THREE INTRODUCTORY LECTURES ON EPITOMES OF THREE SCIENCES e yy ° : I ‘ Old Testament His THE SCIENCE OF THOUGHT. By Pror. F. Max McELLEr, aaah ahh i ean Sakae Meee oe With a correspondence on ** Thought Without Words,"’ between F, Prof. H. OLDENRERG. ‘Experimental Psychology.’ By Prof Joseent Max Mueller and Francis Galton. the Duke of Argyll, George J, Ro- JasTROW. Cloth, 75 , manes and others. Bound in cloth, 75 cents, THREE LECTURES ON | WHEELBARROW. Articles and discussions on the Labor Ques THE SCIENCE OF LANGUAGE. By Pror. F. Max Mcvet. tion, With portraitof the author. 300 pp. Cloth, $1.00; paper, LER. The Oxford University Extension Lectures, with a Supple. 50 cents. ment, ** My Predecessors,*’ an essay on the genesis of * The Science of Thought,’ Bound in cloth, 75 cents. FUNDAMENTAL PROBLEMS. The Method of Philosophy THE PSYCHIC LIFE OF MICRO-ORGANISMS. A Study as a Systematic Arrangement of Kaowledge. By Dr. PAcLUARuS. in Experimenta! Psychology. By ALFRED Binet. Authorized | 267 pp. Cloth, $1.90. Translation,” 135 pages, Cloth, 75 cents; paper, 50 cents. boc : . : , ) ~*vL C ; “*hree ON DOUBLE CONSCIOUSNESS. Recent original studies in| — oo longest By hy <n : - —_ + Experimental Psychology. By ALFRED Binet. 96 pp. Paper, 50 actures delivered at the invitation of the Board of Trustees before gaa “i ssnsstattas ay Auceep Soe ail, Paper. the Society for Ethical Culture of Chicago in June, 1890, Cloth, 59 - cents. THE PSYCHOLOGY OF ATTENTION. By Tu. Risor. Authorized Translation, Cloth, 75 cents, | THE IDEA OF GOD. By Dr. Pavut Carus. 26 pp. 15 cents, THE OPEN COURT: A Weekly Magazine. Contains short essays on ethical, scientific, and philosophical topics, presents reviews of scientific discoveries and notes on general current topics. Single numbers, 5 cents; $2.00 a year. ront oents, THe Oren Court Pusuisuinc Company, 169-175 La Salle St., Cricaco.
Page 2
wad & pote The Nation. [ Vol. 52, No. 1332 The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science, and Art. FOUNDED 1865. Entered at the New York City Post-office as second-c'ass mail matter.) CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. BU Whee c conc es stccssccccecevicsvccvneveveses 21 EDITORIAL ARTICLES: ** Death of the Republican Party ”’............0. 24 Senator Sherman on Free Coinage. 24 A Lesson in Ballot Reform........... -. 2 Corrupting Testimonials........... 26 SPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE : The English Universities in Winter............. 26 Talleyrand in London and America............. 27 The Sidon Sarcophagi.—I..........cccccccsccees 28 CORRESPONDENCE : Se EE MN cs cin hells he aloes seaeie eee ek 29 een reece ee ca 30 The Party of Intellect and Culture.............. 3 BRS MNOS UB WINGR 6 6.5. 5.65-06.0'5:5 960.055 50000 31 ree rer aren 3 ee ee ee Pe Ee eT re 31 REVIEWS: Nicolay and Hay’s Lincoln.—II...............2. S4 Trees Of North AMECFIOR .. 0.66000 .0ccccccccece 36 Moulton’s Ancient Classical Drama............. 37 In the Footprints of Charles Lamb.............. 38 ee CE A TA ROU. ose csnoisuacdhdssesaceses 39 BOOKS OF THE WEEK .........++. Ce cccccvvece coon OO TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three Dollars per year, in advance, postpaid to any part of the United States or Canada; to foreign coun- tries comprised in the Postal Union, Four Dollars. The date when the subscription expires is on the Ad- dress-Label of each paper, the change of which to a sub- sequent date becomes a receipt for remittance. No other receipt is sent unless requested. The paper is stopped at expiration of the subscription, unless previously renewed. Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter or by check, express order, or postal order, payable to ** Publisher of the NaTIon.” When a change of address is desired, both the old and new addresses should be given. Address THE NATION, Box 794, New York. Publication Office, 208 Broadway. TERMS OF ADVERTISING, Fifteen cents per agate line, each insertion, 14 lines to the inch. Twenty per cent. advance for choice of page, top of column, or cuts. Cuts are inserted on inside pages only. A column, $20 each insertion; with choice of page, $24. A page, #60 each insertion; front cover page, $80. Advertisements must be acceptable in every respect. Copy received until Tuesday, 5 P. M. DISCOUNT, TIME— Se ee 5 per cent. 8 apketisedens sessueeevnesa eee 10 ei 13 MTCC TT rT 2% ° 26 Gpaobanieeaeessheentws ib nar 39 «—wtoeneuen acne cede 20 ne 62“ FochgaGan arses crete ae” Te AMOUNT— $100 within a year 250 500 $s on 750 ned = 1,000 nies i 2,000 a a 2) 500 os “ THE NATION is se nt free to those who adve rtise in it, as long as advertisement continues. The EDITION of THE NATION this week is 10,000 copies. The Subscription List is always open to the in- spection plies ertisers. *,* Copies of THE NaTION may be procured in Paris at Brentano’s, 17 Avenue de l’'Oyéra. and in London of B, F. Stevens, 4 Trafalgar Square, American Newspaper Agency, 15 King William Street, Strand, W. C. London agent for advertisements, R. J. Bush, 92 Fleet St., E. C. Schools. Alphabetized, first, by States; second, by Towns. CONNECTICUT, Hartford. OODSIDE SEMINAR Y.—Home and College-Preparatory for Girls. Miss Sara J. SmitH, Principal. DELAWARE, Wilmington, Franklin Street. ae MISSES HEBB’S ENGLISH, French, and German Boarding and Day School for young ladies and etris reopens September 22, 1890. LOUISIANA, New Orleans, 247 Prytania Street. A RS. F. D. BLAKE AND MRS. L. Polk Saw French and English Boarding and Day School fx dents prepared for college. door exercise. wr Girls reopens Oct. 1, 1890. Stu- mple grounds for out- MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 259 Boylston Street. WAUNCY-HALL SCHUOL (63a Year), For boys and girls.—Preparation for the Mass. In- stitute of Technology is a specialty. Reference is made to the Institute Faculty. The location of the school building, on Copley Square, is especially attractive and is very near the Institute. Preparation also for college (with or without Greek) and for business. Special students penive ed, MASSACHUSETTS, Boston. A ee OSTON UNIVERSITY Law School. Address the Dean. EpmMunD H. Brennett, LL.D. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 112 Newbury Street. HE MISSES HUBBARD’S SCHOOL for Girls will reopen October 1, 1890. A limited number of boarding scholars will be received. Massacuvserra, Cambridge. Wk CAMBRIDGE SCHOOL (FOR Girls). Application should be made to Mr. ARTHUR GILMAN, Director. MASSACHUSETTS, Cambridge, Larch Street. OME FOR BOYS.—DR. ABBOT AD. mits not more than four boys into his family, to fit for college or educate privately. Separate tuition, with best of care in all respects. Charming location, with fine tennis-court. F. E, ABBOT, Ph.D. MASSACHUSETTS, Concord. OME SCHOOL FOR BOYS.—SIX boys received into the family to prepare for Col- lege or business. Charming situation. Tennis-court and gymnasium. French spoken in the pts wry rate tuition and best care of health of pone. JAMES S. GARLAND, A darv., MASSACHUSETTS, Duxbury, Powder Point. WDER POINT SCHOOL — PRE- pares for scientific school, college, or business. Laboratories. The boys are members of ihe family. FREDERICK B. Knapp, S.B. (M.L.T.) MASSACHUSETTS, Plymouth. R. KNAPP’S HOME SCHOOL FOk Boys.—Twenty-fourth year begins Oct. 1, 1890. Mrs. Knapp, Prin.; H. B. LEARNED (Harv.), H’d one. MASSACHUSETTS, Quincy. DAMS ACADEMY, PREPARA- tory and boarding school for boys.—School year begins September 17. ‘or all information address WILLIAM EVERETT, Ph.D. MASSACHUSETTS, Worcester. OHN W. DALZELL’S PRIVATE School for Boys, 66 West St.—Prepares for Col- lege or Scientific School. Send for Catalogue. MICHIGAN, Orchard Lake. ICHIGAN MILITARY ACADEMY. —A College Preparatory School of the highest grade. Location thirty miles from Detroit, and unsur- passed for beauty and healthfulness. For catalogue, address Col. J. S. RoGrers, Supt. NEw JERSEY, Cranbury RIVATE HOME ‘AND SCHOOL FOR the Feeble in Mind. Address Rev. C. F. GARRISON. oo rom. Brooklyn, 140- 142 Columbia eig WE MISSES ELY’S SCHOOL FOR ris NEW York City, 6 and 8 East 53d St. ‘HE REED SCHOUL. Miss Julia G. McAllister, Principal (succeeding Mrs. Sylvanus Reed, who continues as visitor.) 27th year begins Oct. 1. NEw YORK, Kingston-on-Hudson. OLDEN HILL PREPARATORY School for Boys. #450 per annum. JouN M. Cross, A.M., Principal. New York, Syracuse. 5 RS. ALFRED WILKINSON’S School for Girls. Reopens September 17, 1890. Refers to Hon. Abram S. Hewitt, George Wm. Curtis, Hon. Wayne MecVeagh, ‘Rev. Edward Everett Hale, Thomas Wentworth igginson, Hon. Andrew D. White, NortTH Carona, Asheville. AVENSCROFT SCHOOL.—PREPAR- atory Boarding and Day School for Boys. Head Master, Ronald McDonald, B.A., Oxford. Schools. PENNSYLVANIA, Bryn Mawr. RYN MAWR COLLEGE 10 MILES from Philadeiphia—A College for Women.—The Program, stating the graduate and undergraduate courses of study for the academic year, will be sent on application. PENNSYLVANIA, Chester. ENNSYVYLVANIA MILITARY ACA- DEMY. 29th session. Winter term opens Jan. 7,91, A Military College. Civil Engineering, Chemistry, Architecture, Arts. A Preparatory Course of one year. Circulars of Col. C. E. Hyatt, President. PENNSYLVANIA, North Wales. ORTH WALES ACADEMY AND School of Business.—Twenty-first year September 10. Board and tuition, #240. Graduates, either sex, enter Freshman best « “allege s. Smith or Wellesley ¢ ‘ol: lege graduate assistants. S. U. BRUNNER, P.O. Box 41. PENNSYLVANIA, Philade Iphia, 1: 350 Pine St. ISS ANABLE’S BOARDING AND Day School for Young Ladies reopens Sept. 25. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, Chestnut Hill. RS. COMEG YS AND MISS BELL’S English, French, and German Boarding School for young ladies reopens Sept. 20, 1890. Students prepared for college. Ample grounds for outdoor exercise. ENGLAND, 40 mile 8 from London. ERKFECL SCHOOL—BOYS UNDER fourteen. Forany period. Happy holiday home if required. Lady speaks from personal experience. Son hh shiy plac ed in best U.S. Schoolon return. L. D., eare Clark & Carruth, Booksellers, 340 Washington St., Boston. FRANCE, NEUILLY, PRES Paris, 22 ‘Avenue de Neu illy R.A. RENACK RECEIVES IN HIS house and prepares with marked success @ limited number of students for the Sorbonne, the military and scientific schools. Special courses in mo- dern languages for Americans. Diplomatic references at Washington and Paris. TICA CONSERVATORY OF MUSIC, —A Training-School for Music-Teachers, Utica, N. Y. Louis LOMBARD, Director. Teachers, etc. R. F. de G., ENGLISH M.A., OXON., Fellow Coll. Organists (Organist St. Edward’s School, Oxford), desires an appointment as organist and choirmaster, Good organ and musical service re - quired. Highest musical references given. Address GODALMING, Surrey, England, ‘HOME FOR A MERICAN SCHOOL- Children in Germany, with a German family. One daughter speaks English. Satis fac tory references guaranteed. Address Frau Post- Sec’y HAUSMAN, Gottinge ‘n, Ge rmany. L OLMES HINKLEY, AM., 1 EVE- rett St., Cambridge, Mass., will prepare boys for the fall ex xaminations, and make tutor ng engagements for the winter. NSTR UCTION IN GE RMAN ‘LA AN. guage (Combination Method) and Literature. Spe cial rates for classes. H. Zick, Ph.D. (Heidelberg), 53 E ast 59th St. A LADY “WOULD LIKE TO PUR- chase an interest in a boarding and day-school for girls. _ Address A. H.S., care Nation. WYARIES W. STONE, Tutor fo Mar. vard, . 68 C the stnut Street, Boston. School A encies. MERICAN AND FOREIGN TEACH- ers’ Agency supplies Professors, Teachers Tutors, Governesses, etc., to Colleges, Schools, an Families. Apply to Mrs. M. J. YounG-FULton. 23 Union Square, New York. WE FISK TEACHERS’ AGEN CIES, 7 Tremont Place, Boston, Mass., 6 Clinton Place, N. Y., 106 Wabash Ave., Chicago, i.. *and 120g South Spring Street, Los Angeles, Cal. 100-page Agency anual free. EVERETT O. FiIsK & Co. MERICANAND FOREIGN Professors, tutors, governesses, teachers, etc., supplied to Col- leges, schools, and families. French, German, and Spa nish spoken. Miriam C OYRIERE, 150 oth Av. , cor. 20th St. CHERMERHORN’S TEACHER'S’ Agency. Oldest and best known in U.S. Estab ished 1 1855. 3 E ast iith St., N. Ye ~UROPEAN “WINTE R AND “SUM- mer Resort, University town of Innsbruck, Tirol, Austria; 1,900 feet above the sea, with dry, bracing climate. Hotel Tirol, open all the year, Carl Landsee, Proprietor. Large, airy, sunny rooms, well furnished. Elevator. Superior ¢ ulsine (table d’héte or a la carte). Reduced rates in winter. Carriages and sleighs at low rates. Charming excursions made from the hotel at all seasons. Unusual advantages for securing teachers of the languages, history, science, art, music, etc., at very moderate terms. Eminent medical care ‘and skilled nurses if desired. Best English and American references. Illustrated pamphlets sent on application.
Page 3
EET a?
¥ Ba rd bi y Hae ae ee %G #: 3 § ee
Jan. 8, 1891] The Nation.
cone
A STRIKING BOOK, THE SECRETE LOG-BOKE OF Christopher Columbus AS IT MUST HAVE BEEN NOTED AND WRITTEN BY HiMSELF IN THE YEARS 1,921,983. IMITATED AFTER THE CONDI- VION IT WOULD HAVE BEEN IN, WITH ACCUMULATION OF SEA-WEED AND SHELLS, AND STAINED AND WARPED BY LONG RESIDENCE IN THE SEA, IF FISHED UP ON THE UTH DAY OF AU- GUST, 1890. Brentano’s have arranged for the exclusive right to publish the above inthe United States, and bey to announce its early issue. Ordera may be sent to all the booksellers, or to the > publishers. Price $3.60. BRENTANO’SS, New YOrK.
5 UNION SQUARE, BERMUDA. The now far-famed BERMUDAS, with cable communication and equable winter temperature ot seventy degrees, beautiful scenery, and one hundred miles of good roads, headquarters of the British army ana navy of the Atiantic Squad- ron, is unrivatied in its attractiveness, reached by the magnificent iron steamers ORINOCO or TRINIDAD, in sixty hours from New York. The Tropical Islands, including St. Kitts, Martinique, Barbados, and Trinidad, also afford beautiful and interesting tours, all reached by steamships ot me Quebec Steamship Company from New York For descriptive pamphiets and dates of sailing apply to A. EMILIUS ee & CO,, Agents, 39 Broadway, New York, or THOMAS COOK & SONS, 261 Broadway, New York. KRUELL’S CONTEMPORARY PORTRAIT-GALLERY “The Nation. 1865-1890.
In commemoration of the 25th anniversary of this journal, Mr. Kruell has engraved on wood, in the highest style of the art, after a recent photograph by G, C, Cox, a portrait of the founder and present editor of the Nation, Edwin Lawrence Godin, The size of the block is 9x6 inches; the in on Japan paper, under the personal supervision of the artist, and is loosely mounted. Only one hundred proofs will be offered for sale, and each will be signed and numbered. Price, Ten Dollars, carriage prepaid Address GUSTAV KRUELL, East Orange, N. J. *.* Mr. Kruell offers at the same price, and in the Same style, proof portraits of CHARLES DARWIN (one in his prime, one in old age), Asa GRay, Wituiam Lioyp GARRISON, and WENDELL Puitups. The edition in pre ssion is
these cases is limited to 200 copies for all except Gray (10), - * Certainly te may look in vain among roraphi arts for anything con with thes igs.”
The Nation, January 23,
‘TO LIBRARIANS AND BOOK-BUYERS. G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS, BOOKSELLERS and IMPORTERS, 27 and 29 West 23d St., New York, 27 King William St., Strand, London, fill orders on favorable terms, by mail or ex- press, for al classes of current publications and out-of-print and rare books, American or foreign. Catalogues and estimates furnished on application, and careful attention given to inquiries by mail. In connection with their Branch House in London, Messrs, Putnam have exceptional facilities for purchasing at the lowest prices, for public and private libraries, supplies of British and Continental publica tions, KNABE PIANOFORTES UNEQUALLED IN TOUCH, WORKMANSHIP AND DURABILITY. WILLIAM KNABE & CO,, Raltimore. New York 22 and 24 E. Baltimore St 148 Sth Ave, near Oth St Washington, 817 Market Space IDLE Send for circulars to Wu. H. PARMENTER, General Agent of the one half the prefits. Wrsner INVESTMENT Co, 50 State Street, Boston, . = MONEY |)” L 0; ANS CB FoR CORPORATIONS ee INDIVIDUAL INV ESTORS MADE. SRAR- ng 6 i : We dealin MORTGAGE LOANS, COMMERC nF PAPERS, 3 NK STA KS, and M NICIPAL BONDS References coe al Rank f ansas City, First National Rank f New York, First National Bank of Chicago, Maveric k National Rank of Boston MERCANTILE LOAN AND TRUST CO., St., Kansas City, M JUS! PU BLISHE! Biological Lectures, delivered at y y TONE,
Invested to yleld & pree ent income of from 6 per cent te 8 per cent wil
ir
01-503 Delaware
sr story, W s H LNt* th, 2 pp. a strate! By ma ty id 81 ‘ in a work of rare ar special va ‘ s y ithe ne a isis ‘ - Tes Atl ate A teres s lents, tea estigators GINN & ” COMPANY, Publishers, Boston, New York, and Chicago JUST PUBLISHED. RUDIMENTARY ECONOMICS. By G. M. StgeLe. D D., LLD., Principal of Wesleyan Academy, Wi Mass, SHEWELL & SANBORN, ibraham, LEACH, New York, Boston, Chicago.
EQUITABLE MORTGAGE COMPANY. CG Tod are? | St reomenti "ae e rs ’ Capital subseribed ... ... $2 00,000 00 Paid in (cash) ‘ 1.000 G00 00 Surplus and und ivid Ler 4 pre fits. ‘ S08 716 SS Assets. - ohne 11 168,085 O4 The we!! known ane ’ - ° New Vert A TPES q ’ I ? ‘ ry 4 4 The Reproduc tion gues W) Repway a Clay ¥ te ‘ x ; very s r te: } “ —~ ~ ~ - , . Tr. COLLEGE NEWS a a I — ~ a IN THE EVENING POST.
Tae Evenina Post has for m: much space to news from the colleges, and to edi- torial discussions and important correspondence on educational subjects The system of «pectal letters from the colleges, published once a week in this paper during severa! years iast past, has iny years given met so cordial a reception among studenta and graduates as to justify its continuance and ex- tension. This feature will appear throughout the coming college year in each Friday's edition of Tur EVENING Post, and every means wili be used to make these columnoas a trustworthy source Of information on the current topics of educational work and student life. They will contain not only letters from correspondents who have acces to the best sources of informa- tion in the leading institutions, but aiso special articles on the intellectual, social, and ath.etio activities of the college world. Subscriptions will be received for Friday's edl- tion of THe Evenina Post at $1.50 per year. Reduced rate for clubs. Address THE EVENING POST, NEW YORK.
Page 4
iv The Nation. [Vol. 52, No. 1332 Charles Scribner’s Sons’ NEW BOOKS. History of the United States. By HENRY ADAMS. Complete set, 9 vols. in a box, 318,00, With the volumestreating of the second Admini: - tration of President Madison, Mr. Adams’ great- work, which has received the highest praise from botb reviewers and the public, iscompleted. No more important contribution to American his- — literature has been made inthis genera- on. Vols. I. and If. THe First ADMINISTRATION OF THOMAS JEFFERSON. 1801-1805, 12mo, $4.00. Vols. Ill. and IV. THe SECOND ADMINISTRA- TION OF THOMAS JEFFERSON. 1805-1809, 12mo, $4.00. Nols. V. and VI, First ADMINJSTRATION OF JAMES MADISON. 1809-1813. ~ 12mo, $4.00. Vols. VII., VIII, and IX. SECOND ADMINIS- TRATION OF JAMES MADISON, J813-1817. 12mo, $6.00, **‘A great mass of new materials has been put in requisition for the preparation of this treatise. The springs of many a movement which were be- fore obscure are here brought to sight. The nar- rative style of Mr. Adams is vigorousin its grasp of materials, dignified in its tone, and correct in point of literary form.’’—The Nation. Principles of Political Eco- nomy. By ARTHUR LATHAM PERRY, LL.D. Crown 8vo, $2.00. This work is devoted chiefly to the great prin- ciples of the science, history being used incident- ally to illustrate each topic. Itis entirely new ano distinct from the author’s two other works, * Political Economy.’ now in its twenty-first edi- tion, and * Introduction to Political Economy.’ Outlines of Physiological Psychology. By GrorGe T. Lapp, D.D. Illustrated. Crown 8vo, $2.00, This is not an abridgment or revision of the au- thor’s larger work, * Elements of Physiological Psychology,’ but, like that, it presents a survey of the entire subject, though with fewer details, that the beginner may acquire a clear knowledge of the outlines of the science, Ballads. By Rospert Louris STEVENSON. 16mo, $1.00. ** Like everything that Mr. Stevenson does, they are tullof picturesque movement and the warmth of life. One turns to reread ever and again with increasing fascination.’’— Boston Times. My Note-Book. Fragmentary Studies in Theology and Subjects Adjacent Thereto. By AUSTIN PHELPS, D.D., LL.D. With Portrait, 12mo, $1.50, ** There is intense individuality in every page. It will stimulate thought, and will be especially suggestive and precious to those who knew its author.’’—New York Observer. The Lion’s Cub, And Other Verse, By R. H. Stopparv. With Portrait. 16mo, $1.25. **There isa depth and charm in these verses that are peculiar to Mr. Stoddard’s genius, No one who cares for real poetry can afford to omit this volume.’’—Julian Hawthorne. How the Other Half Lives. Studies Among the Tenements of New York. By JacoB A. Ris. With forty Illustrations from Photographs by the author. 8vo, $2.50. ** This book has an extraordinary interest. It is, with ull its revelations, not sensational, simply offering in vigorous, bumane, and fascinating narrative the pluin truth.’’—Brooklyn Times, Life of John Ericsson. By Col. Winiu1aAm C. CHURCH. With 50 Illus- trations. 2 vols., 8vo, $6.00, ** This excellently and judiciously written life isin all respects a fit and worthy memoir of a remarkabie man.’’—N. Y. Tribune, *,* Sold by all booksellers, or sent, postpaid, by CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS, 743-745 Broadway, New York. ’ MESSRS. Seine . J. B. Lippincott Co.'s PUBLICATIONS. Chambers’s Encyclopedia, VOL. VI. Revised and Rewritten. New Type, New Lilustrations, New Subjects, New Maps. Edited and publi hed under the auspices of W. & R. Chambers, Edinburgh, and J. B. Lip- pincott Company, Philadelphia. Complete in 10 vols. Price ver vol,: Cloth, $3.00; cloth, uncut, $3.00; sheep, $4.00; half mo- rocco, $4.50. Specimen pages mailed on application. **This cyclopssdia is as reliable asit is cele- brated. It is reasonable in price, too, and it should be in every library.’’—Baltimore Ameri- can. **Itisa fact well known that the Chambers’'s Encyclopeedia is one of the best authorities in the world.’’— Washington (D. C.) National Tribune. **The new volume confirms the favorable opinion we formed of its predesessor. The ar- ticles gain not only 1n fullness and accuracy, but in freshness and interest.’’—-Literary World, London, **Not so large as one or two others, it has been more convenient; not so expensive, it has come within the reach of a larger number of persons of -moderate means. In breadth and accuracy it bas been the equal of the largest.’’— Pittsburgh Christian Advocate. RECENT WorKS OF EDWARD B. LaTCcu, Author of *A Review of the Holy Bible.’ Indications of the First Book of Moses, called Genesis. 12mo, cloth, $1.50, Indications of the Book of Job. 12mo, cloth, $1.50. **The ana'‘ysis in this volume is elaborate and minute, and there are marks of the most carelul investigation.’’— Lutheran Observer. THE LATEST FICTION. Patience. By ANNA B. WARNER, author of * Dollars and Cents,’ *My Brother’s Keeper,’ etc. 12mo, cloth, $1.25. **fhe M sses Warner are among the best friends a young girl can have as chaperon into the de- lightful kingdom of romance. The tales of the American writers supply a link between distinct- ively children’s stories and the novel direct. This is an excellent tale of lite in a little country town. The heroine is quite wortby of her prominent po- sition, and deserves praise as a character study. The sentiment of the story is very natural.’’— Phila. Public Ledger. A Successful Man. By JuLIEN GoRDON, author of ‘A Diplomat’s Diary.’ 12mo, cloth, $1.00. **This author is a story-teller in a day when story-tellers are getting scarce. She wields that magic art which makes the reader reluctant to lay down her book untilit is finished. Inmany re- spects she shews herself a well-equipped artist, especially in her rejection of unessentials and the skill with which she introduces a phrase, a figure, or scene which suggests much more than is actu- ally represented,*’—Phila. Inquirer, ‘A Successrur MAN’ and ‘A DIpPLOMAT’sS Drary.’ Two volumes, uniform binding, in a neat box, $2.00, The Other Man’s Wife. By JoHN STRANGE WINTER, author of * Bootle’s Baby,’ ete. The latest issue in Lippincott’s Series of Select Novels. 1i2mo, paper, 50 cents; cloth, 75 cents, ** The lightness and de! tnegs of touch displayed inthe portrayal of army characters is very re- markabie. The author is certainly gifted with rare powers of observation and a tascinating grace and facility of narration.’’—Chicago Times *,* For sale by all booksellers, or will be sent by the Publishers, free of expense, on receipt of the price, J. B. LIPPINCOTT CO., 715 and 717 Market St,, Philadelphia. BANGS & CO. 739 AND 741 BROADWAY, Announce the following sales: The Library of EDWARD BRANDON, ESQ., Comprising many valuable works of Standard English Literature, elegant illustrated works on Painting, Sculpture—choice copies of fine editions of the best recent works of History, Archeology, Philology, Phi- losophy, etc. The books generally in excellent condi- tion, and many of them in handsome bindings. The SALE to take place JANUARY 15 and 16. The Library, Consisting of English, French, and German Literature, and the well-known collection of Oil Paintingsand Engravings of the late L. Anthony Gescheidt, M. D. A Selection of Books from the Libraries of the late John and George Matthews, Comprising a large number of scarce works illustrated by Cruikshank, Gilray, Phiz, Rowlandson, and French and German Caricaturists. Also Dramatic Literature. A Portion of a Magnificent Library, Comprising many rare books on America, numerous works on Napoleon and the French Revolution, Irish History, Theatrical Memoirs and Biography, Travels, and Standard English works in General Literature, all in the finest possible condition, and, with few excep- tions, in handsome full calf bindings. The dates of the three sales to be announced later, and Catalogues will be mailed upen appli- cation and bids executed free of charge. “Not Alms, but Work !” Turkish Compassionate Fund, 304 Fifth Avenue, N. Y. Art Hand Embroideries FOR House-Decoration, Table- Linen, etc. Ball-Dresses, In the name of 2,000 Women in the East, for whom this Society provides employment, the ladies of Ame- rica are earnestly and respectfully solicited to read the following CAREFULLY. The ‘** Turkish Compassionate Fund ” isa benevolent society, established in Constantinople in the time of the Russo-Turkish War in 1878, to afford relief and give employment to the numerous Turkish and Bulgarian refugees who, burnt out of home and country, sought refuge in the capital of Turkey. The principal object of the ‘‘ Fund” is to provide work for the able-bodied (frequently over 2,000 In num- ber) and attend to the wants of the sick, the aged and infirm. The work of these women, always very delicate and perfect of execution, has lately been accepted in Paris, and while retaining its original character, has under- gone acomplete transformation in MATERIAL, COLOR, and DESIGN. Our present preductions differ absolute’ ly from all Eastern work yet placed in any market, and may fatrly claim a prominent rank among all Hand- made Embroideries in the world. We earnestly beg the ladies of America, foremost in all good works, to pay a FIRST visit of inspection for the sake of the large and practical charity which it is our object to promote. We trust to the exquisite beauty and REALLY UNIQUE character of our em- broideries for their further recommendation. Two remarkable bed-spreads on exhibition, same as made for the Princess Valerie of Austiia, Sole Agent in Paris and U.S. A.: CARICLEE ZACAROFF, 304 Fifth Ave., New York; 3 Rue Treilhard, Paris. President, Mrs. ARTHUR HANSON, Constantinople. YFTY PER CENT. SAVED ON English Magazines. LEONARD Scott Pus. Co., 29 Park Row, New York. La MER ROE... See
Page 5
S.. sBiaalleisiee Ste con os ake eae gy rae Ne Wea SCE The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, JANUARY 8, 1891. ~The Week. Tne war with Great Britain which was declared by one of our morning contempora- ries on Monday, and the news of which, when cabled to London, caused mucb consternation there, has come toa sudden end. The Bri- tish Foreign Office authorizes the state- ment that there is no such war, and now the President sends to Congress the latest correspondence with Great Bri- tain on the Bering Sea question, and all of itup to January 5, 1891. It consists of only two despatches, one from Lord Salis- bury, dated August 2, 1890, and a reply from Mr. Blaine, dated December 17. The text of Lord Salisbury’s communication oc- cupies fifteen printed pages. Mr. Blaines fills thirty-seven. If the strength were in proportion to length, Mr. Blaine’s paper would be two and one-half times more powerful than the one he replies to. Its repellent force will be found to be even greater than that by those who attempt to comprehend it at one sitting. But it has one great merit in that it formally aban- dous the mare-clausum doctrine as applied to Bering Sea, and substitutes for it some general considerations respecting the pre- servation of the fur seal from extermination which were laid down by Minister Phelps on the 12th of September, 1888. In other words, Mr. Blaine has got back to the place of beginning. He has boxed the compass, and is now ready to take up the subject where Mr. Bayard left off. He now says: ‘« The repeated assertions that the Govern- ment of the United States demands that Bering Sea be pronounced mare clausum are without foundation. The Government has never claimed it and never desired it. It expressly disavows it.” ‘‘ What has the long-winded controversy been about, then ?” the public may ask. Re- ference to Mr. Biaine’s letter of June 30, last year, supplies a sort of answer to this query. It would seem that he draws a dis- tinction between mare clausum and the al- leged right of exclusive jurisdiction over a space of one hundred miles from any coast or island belonging tous, this distance being fixed in the ukase of Alexander I. of Russia dated September 4, 1821. Mr. Blaine is well aware that international law knows no- thing of the Emperor Alexander's ukase or of any local regulations touching the high seas, and that it prescribes one marine league as the limit of territorial waters which are not strictly mare clausum. So he seeks an argumentum ad hominem against Lord Salisbury by citing a Brit- ish statute which forbade a vessel ‘‘ ho vering” within eight leagues of the island of St. Helena while Napoleon Bonaparte was confined as a prisoner there. What would have happened if any vessel not British had been caught ‘ hovering ” in that place would have been something like this it would have been brought in as a prize to a British admiralty court, and when the fact was established that it was on the high seas and was not a sbip subject to British juris diction, it would have been discharged, and the Government of the country to which it belonged would have had a perfectly valid claim for compensation. The upshot of the correspondence is, that we are not only not near a war with England, but rather further from it than before. Whether we are any nearer a settlement of the dispute is not so clear. The taking up of the Finance Bill by the Senate, in preference to going on with the Force Bill, does not indicate in any way the passage of the former measure. Still less does it look to the of Senator Stewart’s amendment for the free coin age of silver. Votes were cast for the motion to take up the merely because it passage Finance Bil) shelved the Force Bill, and on the other hand votes were cast against taking up the Finance Bill which would have been cast against the Force Bill if the question had been on the passage of the latter measure. The setting aside of the Force Bill bas split the Repub lican party in the Senate, if not in the coun try at large. Consequently, we may expect the twenty-nine Senators who have been voted down by the eight bolters and the twenty-six Democrats to be particularly alert and determined to defeat what they consider a treasonable coalition. The that there will be no financial legislation at all at this session. prospect is In addition to all other obstacles, the lateness of the period at which the measure is reached, and the necessity of passing the appropriation bills before the 4th of March in order to avoid an extra session with the terrible Democratic majority of the next Congress, will conspire to prevent any decisive action on the bill. There are, in fact, several Senators who habitually lash their sides and paw up the earth for silver, who will favor postponement whenever they can do so by indirection. Gen. Miles, who is probably as competent to speak on the Indian question as any man living, has a very instructive article on the subject in the last orth American Rerieie, which we commend to the perusal of every- body who is afflicted by the slaughter and terror which have been reach- ing us every morning from South Dakota dur- ing the last few days. A worse system than our Indian system for the civilization of savages—that is, their maintenance at the public expense as armed and mounted paupers—could hardly be devised, even if it were well administered. But it is not well administered. The agencies are made part of the spoils of office, and their distri- bution forms one of the steadily recurring scandals of each Administration. Not only reports of are they bestowed nearly every four years on new and inexperienced men, but they are apt to be bestowed on men who have failed inthe ordinary pursuits of civ have never turned their attention to any dustry but electioneering And yet the proper charge of a great Indian agency proba bly requires a rarer combination of talents and attainments than any of the non-pro fessional subordinate offices of the Gover ment. It calls not only for character good enough to bear removal from public observa tion, but for business capacity, for tact patience, self-contro!, and capacity for co mand and for teaching the igoorant and the dull. Thatsuch qualifications are hardly ever thought of in appointing Indian agents we need hardly say There is, in fact, a mass of literature devoted to the exposure abuses caused by the incapacity or dishonesty of Indian agents The story { every Indian trouble begins with some aceount of the sins, negligences, and ances of the agencies There is a ; ‘ mor given to the tragedy, ¢ by ¢ ary nts ‘onstantly emploved by | cians wi want the agencies as spoils, that it will not lo to intrust the care of the Indians to hard cold, unfeeling 1 f war like the army officers; that it is vy from ’ hee ier and workers that these unt tored men can get the ter le and watchful care whic their unhappy situa calls for Gen. Miles’s article shows that the notion that the danver of Indian outbreaks has been removed by the disappearance of the buffalo is a great mistake The place of the buffalo as sustenance for roving bands of rebellious warriors has been taken by the cattl f the settlers Warriors can now maintain them selves fully as wel over a vast range of country by raids on the white mans ld by the slaughter of rhe Indian is, too, eve ry year supplied with the latest and best fire arms, so that the more civilization closes in about him, the more dangerous he becomes. In fact, the time has come for a radical change in our Indian policy, not on grounds of humanity simply, but as a measure of pro- tection for the great civilized communities which are growing up around the Indians. The savages must either be civilized or extir pated. Tobe civilized they must be protect- ed, and they cannot be protected by the in- strumentalities we now employ for that pur- We had hoped that when a really re- ligious man like Gen. Harrison got into the Presidential chair, the moral aspect of the Indian question would make a deep impres- sion on him and profit by his spiritual cul- ture, ™ se. Of all the lobby forces ever congregated at Washington to promote indefensible measures and robbery of the public Treasury, those which have been precipitated upon Congress to promote steamship subsidies have been the most shameless and persistent and cor-
Page 6
a2 The Nation. (Vol. 52, No. 1332 rupting. The motive power of this lobby comes this time from Mr. H. K. Thurber’s Brazil Steamship Company, with some help, perhaps, from the Pacific Mail Company. Mr. Thurber is one of the patriots who dis- tinguished themselves by peddling forged quotations from English newspapers during the last Presidential campaign. The Pacific Mail Company would probably have been content to rest upon its laurels and leave Congress alone, if the allurement of a sub- sidy had not been dangled before its eyes by the pernicious activity of the Brazil interest. The Subsidy Bill comes up in the House as the first business after the holidays, It con- tains a flagrant untruth in its title, which re- cites that it is a bill to put the American merchant marine on an equality with that of other nations. Equality with what na- tions? If all the maritime countries of Eu- rope were paying subsidies and bounties to shipping of the same kind and amount as this bill calls for, it would still be for the friends of the measure to show two things: first, that itis right and expedient and just to their taxpayers under their seve- ral circumstances to do so; second, that our circumstances are the same as theirs. Neither of these things has been proved, nor has it been proved, except in the case of France, that such subsidies and bounties are paid. France does tax the farmer and the wagon- driver to pay the shipbuilder and the ship- owner, but with most discouraging results so far as the promotion of commerce goes. French ships are built and sailed for the bounty, rather than for the trade, and so it will be here if the bill has any effect at all beyond the putting of money into the trea- suries of the Brazil and Pacific Mail Com- panies. The English Post-office pays a fair compensation for actual transporta- tion of the mails, and to this there is no objection. Norway, which comes next asa maritime country, pays nothing. Germany pays nothing that can be called a subsidy. What is paid by Italy or Spain or other third-rate shipping Powers is of no consequence to us, since we are not seeking toemulatethem. They are not the coun- tries referred to in the title of the pending bill. This measure seeks to bind the Govern- ment to annual cash payments of unknown amounts for twenty consecutive years. The crowding of such a bill through a Con- gress discredited and beaten as the present one is, can only be regarded as the last desperate resort of men who have only a few days left to work the Trea- sury in, They know very well that the people have pronounced against them in tones of thunder. They know that the Con- gress elected two months ago would reject such a measure by a two-thirds vote, because the people themselves would reject itif they had the opportunity to pass upon it. Both parties in the West are at heart op- posed to it. The man who drives his canvas- covered ‘‘ prairieschooner” over the plains of the Dakotas without Government aid will not be easily reconciled to the doling of his money out to ship-owners of the Atlantic ’ seaboard under any kind of pretence. He ought not to be. The man who ploughs the land is as much entitled to bounties as the one who ploughs the sea. There is nothing surprising in the report which comes from Ohio, that there is much less talk than heretofore among Republicans in that State about making Mr. McKinley their candidate for Governor next fail. The impression is gaining ground, even in Ohio, that the task of educating the people toa proper conception of the beauties of the Mc- Kinley tariff is a very arduous one. Instead of liking the tariff better the more they see of it, experience appears to have quite the con- trary effect. At the present rate of progress, two years, Mr. McKinley’s own limit, will be entirely too short a period in which to convinceanything like a majority of the voters of the country that high prices are good for them and low prices ‘‘ nasty” and degrad- ing. As less than one year intervenes be- tween the present popular ignorance and the next Ohio election, Mr. McKinley himself would probably admit that he ought not to attempt to force the issue by running for Governor this year. By the time the Presi- dential year comes round, his limit will have expired so nearly that he may be willing to take a Presidential nomination. If he consents to allow the Republicans to nomi- nate him, we venture to predict that the Democrats will do nothing to interfere with the programme. The farmers of Minnesota have got their heads cleared of the protection humbug if the resolution of the Alliance may be taken as an expression of their aggregate opinion. They adopted the following resolution at their Convention at St. Paul on Thursday: ** We demand tkat the war tariff, which has too long survived the object of its creation shail be radically revised, giving very material reductions in the necessaries of life, and plac- ing raw material on the free list, to the end that we may compete with the world for a market, and that such luxuries as whiskey and tobacco shall in no measure be relieved from internal taxation till the high protective tariff has been wholly rid of its extortions; and we especially denounce the McKinley Bill as the crowning infamy of protection.” Where, we should like to know, were those working farmers Delano, Harpster, and Lawrence when this resolution, with its de- mand for free raw materials, such as wool and goat’s hair, was under consideration ? And where were Uncle Jerry Rusk, Secre- tary of the Department of Agriculture, and Statistician Dodge, the farmers’ guide, philosopher, and friend ? A new kind of Republican club is starting up in Massachusetts, which takes for its creed on the tariff question the following re- solution : ‘*(2.) We believe in a protective tariff that shall impose duties where they are needed, and only where needed, to equalize the labor cost of production and to develop American resources and American commerce, but not to relieve favored corporations or individuals from foreign competition,” This is not McKinleyism. It is the kind of Republicanism represented by the Chicago Tribune, the St. Paul Pioneer Ivress, the Omaha Bee, the Keokuk Gate City, etc., in the West. It has one representative journal in Boston, however, in the Zranscript, which says: ‘The McKinley prices for all household sup- plies, from dry goods to provisions, are the true educators of the people on the tariff ques- tion, and ex-Congressmen are not needed to instruct them. The lesson is a severe one, and its severity is daily increasing, but it is gettin in some most important work for the good o the country.’ Apropos of Mr. Henry C. Lea’s hopeful view, in the Atlantic Monthly, of the im- proving effect on the Republican party of its late reverses, on which we recently commented, it will be remembered that he said among other things that the Pennsyl- vania election had delivered the party ‘from the grotesque spectacle of the predominance in such a party of a man like Quay.” But has it? We find in the Ledger of January 3 the following account of the visit of ‘‘such aman” to Philadelphia on New Year’s Day: ‘** He was visited yesterday at the Continental Hotel by many political workers, including friends of Bromley Wharton, who have been active in their support of that gentleman for appointment as Magistrate, to fill the vacancy caused by the death of Magistrate Smith. ‘*The delegation included Surveyor of the Port John J. Ridgway, J. Edward Carpenter, Richard M. Cadwalader, Frederick M. Bissel, E. C. Knight, jr., Lewis H. Redner, G. Heide Norris, Dr. James F. Hayes, E. Waterman Dwight, John 8S. Forbes, George Q. Horwitz, Samuel T. Pemberton, Hobart Miller, and Frank E. Bond. ‘*They assured the Senator that the senti- ment which demanded the reélection of Coun- cilman Etting was equally strong in favor of Mr. Wharton, and that this sentiment should be recognized in the appointment. ‘* The delegation received an assurance from Senator Quay that he appreciated the position of affairs, and was anxious that the person ap- pointed should be of irreproachab!e character, so that. there might be no friction when the time came to select the appointee.” There is much richness in this, particularly in the character of the members of the dele- gation—all highly respectable and some be- longing to old Philadelphia families ; and in Quay’s anxiety that the appointee should be a man of ‘‘irreproachable character.” Quay is said to be a wag; if so, he must be having lots of fun just now. The Buffalo Courter and the Plattsburgh Republican are having a joint debate on the fitness of Mr. Smith Weed to represent the Democrats of New York in the United States Senate, especially in his character as a sup- porter of the present tariff of 75 cents per ton onironore. The Plattsburgh paper, which supports Mr. Weed's claims, made the erratic statement that ‘‘ far more labor in proportion to capital invested is required in the produc- tion of iron ore than in any other branch of iron manufacture.” This certainly has a suspicious ring. It sounds like all the un- principled rubbish which the McKinley Bill is composed of. But the Courter meets it with a quotation from the testimony of Abram 8. Hewitt before the Tariff Commis- sion of 1882, in these words: ‘In New Jersey, where I am a miner of magnetic ores on a large scale, and in Penn- sylvania, there is nota pound of ore—and I mine at least 100,000 tons—that is not put on the cars for less money than the freight from Africa and Spain to New York. This freight alone is more than it costs me to dig my ore and pay $1.50 a day.” ,
Page 7
fs] Sat ABS Dei bte sc ERC ERASE Jan. 8, 1891] The Nation. This means that if the labor of mining iron ore in Spain and Africa cost nothing at all, the freight charges would be ample protec- tion tothe American miner without any ta- riff duty whatever. Now, if Mr. Weed and the Plattsburgh Republican cannot contro- vert Mr. Hewitt on this point, the less they say about Labor, the better for themselves. The Tribune's Albany correspondent throws some light on the Senatorial contest. ‘The election of Smith M. Weed,” he says, ‘‘a protection Democrat, as Senator from New York State, it is said, was strongly pressed upon Gov. Hill by Senator Gorman as one means of allaying the alarm of manu- facturers at the prospective coming into power of the Democratic party, and also as showing these men that Gov. Hill is nota free-trader, like Grover Cleveland.” It may well be doubted whether so shrewd a politi- cian as Senator Gorman has shown his hand in the politics of New York on either side, but it is well known that his lean- ings have heretofore been towards the ‘* protection Democrats.” There are a few of these still extant, here and there, but Mr. Gorman will be the only one re- maining in the Senate after the retirement of Mr. Payne of Ohio. It is for the Demo- crats of New York to decide whether they want to perpetuate the variety by sending Mr. Weed to Washington to take Mr. Payne’s vacant place as a Senator out of har- mony with nine-tenths of his party. Any Democrat who is concerned to “allay the alarm of the manufacturers” had best join the Republicans at once and give in his ad- hesion to the McKinley Bill, According to the Albany correspondence of the 7imes, Tammany has sent two advance agents to the Governor demanding practical control of the incoming Legislature through its committee chairmen and clerks. Both Tammany and the Democratic machine in Brooklyn have, it is said, demand- ed more chairmanships, clerkships, and other minor positions than there are in the giftof the Assembly. There is nothing im- probable in these reports. The Tammany appetite, always large, has been stimulated beyond all bounds by the recent victory at the polls, and it long ago became evi- dent that this city alone would not be able to give it complete satisfaction, though extraordinary efforts have begun to be made to that end. Salaries are being in- creased in many instances, larger appropria- tions have been made for nearly or quite all of the municipal departments, every newly elected official has been compelled to distri- bute the subordinate offices within his gift as Tammany dictates, and it will be found, as time goes on, that the number of “places” will be steadily multiplied through- out all branches of the service. As for the demands on the Governor both from this city and from Brooklyn, it is natural that they should be made, for his follow- ing is composed exclusively of the kind of men who expect to be paid for their support at the public expense. In the current North American Reviete the ‘“‘Scholar in Politics” engages Statistics, that ‘‘modest handmaid of political science,” toteach the American people how to deal with the problem of immigration. He bas found in some official returns the following figures, in which the immigrants for the years 1873 to 1886 are classified: Professional........ “eee eee . . 31.8 3 OO eae ee , S7 Mu Miscellaneous, Samees 2 > us Occupations not stated........ 12S, 7 NS Without occupations Seeecese ‘ ISS Mr. Lodge is much terrified by the great num ber returned under the last head, and thus comments upon the untoward circumstance ‘* Throwing out those immigrants with occu pations not stated, it appears that, of all the vast immigration during those fourteen years, nearly one-half are persons avowedly without occupation or training, or, in other words, unskilled labor of the lowest kind, while professional and skilled labor amounts to nearly 11.49 per cent. of the whole ‘ Miscellaneous,’ which is neither skilled nor professional labor, amounts to 38 per cent.’ Further on, he finds indications that of late years this dangerous class of persons ‘‘ with out occupation” in proportion to the whole number of ar rivals, and concludes that we have here one of the reasons why America should close the wide doors heretofore opened for new comers from all parts of the and open a little postern only for the élite of mankind. Now, whatever grounds there may be for notifying Europe, as we have already notified Asia, that we want no more of her surplus millions, the 2 600, 000 persons ‘‘ without occupation” do not furnish any; for these persons sare sim- ply the wives and children of the adult men whom they accompany or follow. That only 48.1 percent. of the immigrants are thus classified, instead of 60 or 65, shows that much of the immigration—say on fourth of it—does not come in family groups, but is made up of young men and young women seeking to better only their own fortunes, has ‘‘slightly increased ” world, P The Engineering News publishes statistics of railway-building during the past year which show that 5,981 miles were sdded dur ing the twelve months—viz., 3,181 miles in the South and Southwest, and 2.800 miles elsewhere. The Northwestern section (Min nesota to Montana) had 991 miles, the Pacitic States, including Utah, 696, the Central States (Ohio to Wisconsin) 693. the Middle Atlantic States 328, and New England 92 miles. The year’s work brings the total mileage in the United States to 167,255, or more than sufficient to span the Northern world six times. Hitherto the business prosperity of the country bas been intimately associated with new railway construction. The building and equipping of new lines puts countless wheels in motion, and provides employment for capital and labor ina great variety of forms and places. The work is nowhere near completion. It will go on for many years, and even after the country is laced with as mapy lines as the traffic will sup- ye ~~ e port, the work of roads will call for very larie improving the existing as is the case in « New England at the present time But the heyday of railroad-building in our own - country is past. There is much unde veloped territory still in the much in the South, and there are spots all over the Union which will bear some fur ther elaboration But the reat distances been spanned, and the wide expanses have | of fertile soil and valuable timber have been pretty well covered, so that we must eventually, and at 1 verv distant day yond our own borders r the profitable ployment of surp'us capital which has tofore been absorbed in new ral Way the absence of secure reposttor os for savings has been a creat « of thrift. Memphis bas been one of th among Southern cities to realize their tance, and past two vears unti] there are now seven. The tures are tl work, in large measur f men and women e i of moderate means. To them, and to those who wish to build homes at a future time, essent a) ; The negro has suffered perhaps more than the white from the almost entire absence of savings institutions in the South. Thrift } h a race just enter ing upon freedom needed to learn. It is not too much to sav that the failure of the Freed- man’s Bank was the greatest misfortune the negroes have suffered since emancipa it was calculated to destroy the vir tue of thrift just as it was beginning to de- velop. Practically it put the race back in this respect fully twenty vears, for the bad effects have been felt down to the present R G. Dun & Ce.’s tables of mercantile failures in the United States for 1890 foot up 10,882, with liabilities of $189,856, 964, as against 10,679 with liabilities of $148, 784, 337 the previous year. The showing is by no means unfavorable when compared with the years 1878, 1875, 1876, 1877, 1878, and 1884, all of which showed a larger aggre gate of liabilities of failed firms. The failures of the year 1857 exceeded those of 1890 by €2,000,000, although the amount of capital invested then was probably not more thay one-third what it is at present,
Page 8
24. The Nation. [Vol. 52, No. 1332 ‘* DEATH OF THE REPUBLIVUAN PARTY.” By the votes of eight Republican Senators uniting with the Democrats, the Force Bill was on Monday set aside in the Senate. The shelving of the measure is universally re- garded as equivalent to its rejection, and even Senator Hoar admitted that it would be useless to press it further. This result is occasion for hearty rejoicing on the part of all patriotic citizens, North and South, and congratulations should be extended to the Republicans who brought it about—Messrs. Teller and Wolcott of Colo- rado, Washburn of Minnesota, Stewart and Jones of Nevada, McConnell and Shoup of Idaho, and Stanford of California. It is an ideal retribution upon Republican Bourbons of the Hoar school that the two new Sena- tors from Idaho, who had been admitted before the Territory was qualified to become a State, in order that they might help to im- pose radical legislation upon the country, should have cast their first votes on the other side. The significance of the result will appear more clearly as time passes. Senator Hoar, extraordinary as it may seem, perceived it instantly, and stated it clearly. ‘‘ Five minutes after the vote was taken which an- nounced the death of the Force Bill,” says the correspondent of the Sun, ‘ the Massa- chusetts Senator walked down the marble steps leading to the restaurant, and, in an- swer to the query of a friend, said in an em- phatic and solemn manner, ‘That means the death of the Republican party.’ ” In truth, the Force Bill scheme was the last rational attempt which is possible to maintain the theory that ‘‘the mission of the Republican party ”.is not yet fulfilled. That party was organized for a single pur- pose—to resist the aggressions of slavery. Its first national convention, in 1856, assem- bled in pursuance of a call addressed “to the people of the United States, without re- gard to past political differences or divi- sions, who are opposed to the repeal of the Missouri Compromise, to the policy of the present Administration, to the ex- tension of slavery into free territory, in favor of admitting Kansas as a free State, of restoring the action of the Federal Gov- ernment tothe principles of Washington and Jefferson.” The second national platform, adopted in 1860, began witha declaration that ‘‘the history of the nation during the last four years has fully established the pro- priety and necessity of the organization and perpetuation of the Republican party, and that the causes which called it into existence are permanent in their nature, and now, more than ever before, demand its peaceful and constitutional triumph.” From 1856 to 1888 the Republican party continued a political organization primarily devoted to issues growing out of slavery. For the first half of the period it really had a ‘‘mission.” Before the war it was neces- sary to restrict the progress of slavery. When, through the war, slavery had been abolished, it remained to pass the constitu- tional amendments which made the black man the equal of the white before the laws , of the land. That done, the work of the Re- publican party as it was organized in 1856 was completed. But its managers had found the slavery issue so profitable that they sought to perpetuate it. When the party came into power for the second time in 1889, it wes on a platform which proposed two important policies growing out of the slavery issue, both of which were contrary to all the traditions and precedents of our history during the century from Washing- ton to Harrison. One of these policies proposed that the Federal Government should assume control of the schools in the States, by making ap- propriations from the Treasury at Washing- ton for distribution among them, supervision necessarily following the appropriation. The other proposed that the Federal Govern- ment should assume control of the elections for Congressmen in the States, such control necessarily involving interference with the supervision by State authorities of the State elections held at thesame time. Both of these measures were advocated expressly in behalf of the negroes, and as essential se- quels to their emancipation. The Blair Bill was urged on the plea that the Southern States would not educate the blacks, and that consequently the Federal Government must interfere; the Lodge-Hoar scheme on the plea that the Southern States would not give the blacks fair elections, and that conse- quently the Federal Government must in- terfere. The first of these policies was rejected last March, by reason of the defection of a num- ber of Republican Senators. The other was rejected on Monday, by reason again of the defection of a number of Republican Sena- tors. In each case Republican Senators re- jected fundamental principles of the last Re- publican national platform, and declared their conviction that the Democratic party was right in opposing those principles. The eight recalcitrants of Monday voted against the principle which was set down as first and chief in the resolutions adopted at Chicago in 1888. Moreover, it is well known that the open opposition to the Force Bill in the Senate rep- resented only a small part of the actual desire for its defeat on the Republican side. What is still more important, the opposition in the Senate, both open and secret, does not equal the opposition among Republicans throughout the country as their views find expression in the party press. In other words, a large proportion of those who have called themselves Republicans are against a policy the enforcement of which the last na- tional platform declared to be the chief rea- son for the party’s existence. Under these circumstances Mr. Hoar is probably right if he said that Monday’s vote ‘‘ means the death of the Republican party.” Political organizations, like individual politicians, often do not recognize that they are dead forsome time after the event. The Whig party really expired in 1852, although the funeral ceremonies did not occur until a good while later. In like manner, the Re- publican party may survive forsome time as an opposition to the apparently eternal De- mocracy, but its fate as an organization based upon the slavery issue is sealed. There is no longer any *‘ propriety or necessity for its perpetuation.” The defeat of the Blair Bill last March meant that the black man must ‘take his chances” with the white man in the matter of schooling. The rejection of the Force Bill means that he must take his chances also in the matter of voting, like the ‘‘Canuck” in New England, the ‘‘ Dago” in New York city, the Pole in the manufacturing cities of Pennsylvania, or the Scandina- vian in the agricultural regions of the Nerthwest. ‘‘When a man has emerged from slavery,” said truly the Supreme Court of the United States in annulling for unconstitutionality the Civil-Rights Act, ‘and by the aid of beneficent legislation has shaken off the inseparable concomitants of that state, there must be some stage in the progress of his elevation when he takes the rank of a mere citizen, and ceases to be the special favorite of the laws, and when his rights as a citizen or a man are to be pro- tected in the ordinary modes by which other men’s rights are protected.” The rejection of the Force Bill means that this ‘‘ stage” has been reached, and conse- quently that ‘‘ the mission of the Republican party ” has been discharged. The future of political organizations cannot be forecast, but Senator Hoar is right in regarding Mon- day’s action in the Senate as ending a chapter in our history. SENATOR SHERMAN ON FREE COIN- AGE. WHEN the debate on free coinage of silver was started in the Senate by the setting aside of the Force Bill, the cause of sound money found a ready and well-equipped champion in Senator Sherman, who led off io a speech of unusual strength and earnestness. The text of this speech, as published in the Record, is much more effective than the newspaper reports indicated, and much less crippled by the commitments of the Senator to the Finance Bill of the last session or the one now pending. As to these half-measures, Mr. Sherman was par- ticular to say that he yielded his own judg- ment to the supposed necessity of a compro- mise, but he did not refrain from pointing out the erroneous principles of those mea- sures. Both measures, providing for in- creased purchases of silver by the Treasury, are bottomed on the thesis that Government ought to do something for that suffering me- tal, something to lift up its drooping head and advance its price in the market. The judi- cious and benevolent intentions of Congress, as expressed in the bill of last session, had (it was said) been frustrated by speculators. The Government had been buying four and a-hatf million ounces per month, but in spite of these well-meant efforts to revive silver and bring it to a parity with gold, there had been an accumulation of twelve million ounces from various parts of the world in the New York market, and the Com- mittee on Finance had been besought to take off that load, and so give silver another
Page 9
bee Sater es ate Jan. 8, 1891] The Nation. chance. Upon this point Mr. Sherman re- marks : ‘‘1] do not believe that was a wise idea; but still, in common with the President, the Secre- tary of the Treasury, and the general feeling on this side of the Senate, we thought it was better ‘> relieve the minds of our friends from this load, as they said, which bore down the market, and we proposed by the first section of the bill to buy that bullion at its market price and get it out of the way.” Something might be said here about Mr. Sherman’s own shortcomings. Apparently he puts some blame on the speculators for frus- trating the good intentions of the act of last year. ‘‘ If they had waited,” he said, ‘‘ and allowed the ordinary course of the business world to deal with the masses of silver that were brought out; if we had purchased re- gularly at the market price four and a half million ounces of silver a month, the ad- vance in the market value of that silver would have gone forward slowly and gradu- ally, and in a few years it might have reached the standard of gold. But that was not the policy. Speculations were en tered into,” ete. If we are to treat this concep. tion seriously, was it not incumbent on the statesmen who passed that bill to take specu- lation into the account as a factor to be reckoned with ? People will always be found ready to make money by buying property that they think is going up, or by selling what they think is going down. Teo legis- late as though such persons did not exist would be very foolish indeed. But it is not true that the speculators prevented any beneficent results from following the Silver Act of last year. They could no more makea permanent price for silver than the grain or cotton speculators can make a permanent price for those staples. Moreover, it was not for their interest that the price of silver should fall. On the contrary, it was greatly for their interest that it should rise—the higher the better for them. They set out, according to the programme published at the time, to carry the price up to 129. They got it up to 121, and at that point so much bullion came forward from one place and another that they could not carry it. All this by way of apology for a bad measure in order to avoid a worse one. But it appears that the worse one is not avoid- ed—not if the free-coinage phalanx, led by Stewart and Teller, can muster a majority of votes in favor of the amendment proposed by the former to the pending bill. That amendment is for free coinage of silver, or rather for free bullionage, which is worse, since coinage takes time, while bullion- age precipitates upon the country, in the form of legal-tender certificates, all the surplus silver in the world at once, or as fast as it can be collected together and presented at the mints. Against free bullionage or free coinage Mr. Sher- man brings all his powers as a debater, a financier, an economist. He shows that this means the demonetization of gold and the striking out, at one blow, of the larger half of the circulating medium, and the oncoming of a financial crisis more sweeping and dis- astrous than the world has ever seen. He shows, too, that instead of raising the price of silver bullion, the free-coinage bill would cause it to fall, since then it wou'd exchange for other commodities only at its actual value, whereas now its value is enhanced by the Government's purchasing arbitrarily the entire product of our own mines. It is a noteworthy fact that one of the effects of the recent pinch in the money market has been to close a large numberof silver mies in Colorado. The operation of cause and effect in this case is perfectly clear. The apprehension of the silver standard led to a hoarding of gold. Every gold dollar drawn causes the banks to curtail at least four dollars of their loans and discounts. The banks of Colorado could no longer make their customary advances to the smelters, who could no longer buy the ore from the miners. Hence all of the latter who wer not forehanded and able to do their own smelting or to pile up their ore were obliged to stop work. If this was done in the green tree, what shall be done in the dry ? If the small mines suffered by reason of a slight contraction of the and discounts of the banks, what will hap pen when one-half of the metallic money of the country, whichis the half upon which loans and discounts are based, is stricken out altogether ? Mr. Sherman has presented in stronger terms and with greater fulness the ideas em bodied in the letter of President Cleveland t Mr. Warner of Ohio in February, 1885. It is easy to say that the trouble which Mr. Cleve land predicted has not The truth is that it was only postponed and it is nat far if the present programme of the silver-men is to be carried out. We have had a foretaste of it in the past sixty days, and we shall another and a more bitter one justin propor tion as we approach, or as the public think we are approaching, the silver standard And this experience will be repeated just as often as that apprehension shall live in a semi-panic until all such fears are dissipated. Industry will ! ground down, factories and mines will b closed, bankruptcy will be chronic, and dis tress will be so great that even the misery of the McKinley Bill will be forgotten have OADS come {tO pass distant now, comes, We 4A LESSON IN BALLOT REFORM, THE grave controversy at Hartford over the Governorship is a most timely warning as to the unwisdem of all secret-ballot laws which do not provide a genuine official ballot. To the absence of any such provision in the existing Connecticut Ballot Act, passed in 1889, many of the present complications are due, and many more are certain to ensue | hereafter unless there is an essential change in the new voting law of the State. The ex periences with that statute are an instruct ive chapter in ballot-reform legislation, es pecially at the present time, when State legislatures are soon to meet and either mandy pass new ballot acts or revise those lready adopted. Near the close of the long session of the Connecticut Legislature of 1889, there was passed an excellent ballot bill, modelled on that of Massachusetts. There was at the OR ~*> time of its passage little doubt that Gov Bulkeley would approve the measure, as he had intimated that he would do so. But at the eleventh hour some of the “ practical politicians of the State got his ear They professed to have discovered ‘‘ complica tions” in the bill which would make. it ** clumsy” in its operation. So, acting part ly under their advice and partly under his own later and more partisan impulse, the | } Governor vetoed the measure, and bis . . r } Veto Was sustained by fluences br ght to bear on certain legislators But the +} or i? ?) ‘ Tot. PROF ¢ hi ciamor excliied Ov the Governors act, Ole } } ) % . ‘ public likeness to Hill which the Connect . } ‘ . cut papers began to } int out, and the grave ry yor tbyilie ) » bP cones Pal ” ’ . responsibility which the Republican party had assumed, scared its leaders. So, almost } } los } ’ at the last lewislative dav, the present crude aw was hatched rushed through both houses, substantially wit t ame t ana pre ptly Siy i Na “ive t ‘ j l | V t Was ed With Ve i iers A ‘ i doubtf phras to these we t now refer, The we wis As asthe immediate wa st AK hat tl Meh compeiied t State to stamp the ballot as ‘Or! 4 os zz aper for the ba ts. and Sper the Vv » be sed the law ive the | t g and the dis sok ) ’ : ribu of 1 OA . my nOCer aE sired, to the I irty MAHA . N ’ . 7 ’ Ww iit US Sex Ww se lyse | y vlots have work practice Alto ther ere | et he the C nectict iw. s was passed. tw i d » ‘ ee s cA ‘ i wr the State ; and ¢ genera stat ecrecth At ’ i of ore contests re have been endless “_owk | Ws es as ft r r anu gai form i | for pr the ballots, the use of pasters, } - 4 ’ } . | the 7 aces where the i s could be put, } ; , ; a hal f-a-doze otluer inatters A number | Boum } } . ’ } of cases, I reover, have aiready got into } +) n19te rn ) . ‘ ‘ied } the courts One was the case of the Citi put out at Hartford last spring, which the Supreme Court in October found illegal, and which so tarnished Gov. Bulkeley’s name. Besides, there has been For ° votes which now decision ; the on the Prohibition ballots left un- der the title of Judge of Connecticut Probate, which Judge Hall of the Superior Court has decided to be illegal, and which may yet throw out several thou- sand votes in the State; the rejection by the moderator of more than a hundred votes in Bridgeport said to have been marked; and other questions without number which either party can raise if it wants to. All but one of the cases stated enter into the Govern- orship contest now pending. As a direct | result, therefore, of the blunder of letting | the parties handle the ballots, the State is | . | plunged into a bitter and involved party conflict affecting the whole administration of the Commonwealth during the next two years, the outcome of which no man Can now see, Another old and familiar device which has been tried anew in Connecticut and has been found defective is the ‘‘envelope” plan. It was held by the promoters of the new
Page 10
26 | The Nation. [Vol. 52, No. 1332 law that the envelope assured secret voting, and to some extent it did protect the voter, as the election returns from the ‘‘bull- dozed ” factory towns showed. But, on the other hand, in almost every Connecticut town at the last election a number of votes were lost from failure to seal the envelopes, and the total number of votes thus nullified in the State must have been several hundred—enough, perhaps, to have changed the whole result of the election and to have averted the impending contest. Again, at each election some of these en- velopes have been missed. This means their possible misuse by political tricksters in working the ‘‘ Tasmanian dodge,” and send- ing around the bribed voter with a sealed en- velope to bring back one unsealed to prove his fulfilment of his evil compact. Unless the State Ballot Act is changed, or unless the Secretary of State varies, as he has not hither- to done, the form or color of the envelopes, those that are outstanding now may be used at future elections, not only for purchasing the voter, but also for certifying the delivery of his venal ballot. The sharp lesson which these Connecticut experiences teach us is, that for the State ballot pure and simple, without any clumsy ‘‘envelope ” attachment, there can be no ade- quate substitute. Any other plan necessarily leaves the party with its blunders and tricke- ries as an agent in the voting mechanism. Be- tween the old method of voting and the real official ballot there is no compromise. We must either adopt a plan in which the ballots are prepared and given out in the voting- room by officers sworn under penalties to the faithful and accur.te performance of duties, or else let the politician ‘‘run” the ballots, with the certainty that they will be botched by his knavery or ignorance. Toa real official ballot we can justly attribute the smoothness and accuracy with which the Massachusetts Secret-Ballot Act has done its work; and to a hybrid system we can with equal certainty charge the legal snarls and the befogged Governorship contest in which the sister State of Connecticut, just over the Massachusetts line, is now so deeply involved. CORRUPTING TESTIMONIALS. DuRING the examination of Mr. Porter, the Commissioner of Charities and Correction, the other day, before the Fassett Committee, the appointment of ‘‘ Fatty” Walsh to the Wardenship of the Tombs came up, and Mr. Porter mentioned the names of several prominent citizens who had signed testi- monials recommending him for the place. Mr. Ivins, who was examining the witness, thereupon added, as reported in the /vening fost, that ‘‘if he had been asked to sign the recommendation for his [Walsh’s] appoint- ment, he would have done so, as he thought he was a good enough man for the place and able to do the work.” As this seemed some- what startling, Mr. Ivins was asked for a con- firmation of it, and he corrected it as foilows: ‘The reporter who wrote that caught the spirit of what I had said, but not the letter, I did say that if I been asked at that time to sign the recommendation for his appointment, 1 should have done so. I considered Mr. Walsh at that time a good enough man for the 4 place. If anybody had asked me to recom- mend him for appointinent as warden of a penitentiary or State’s prison, I should have refused, because I never should bave consider- ed him fully capable of filling such a position.” Now, the difference between a State prison or penitentiary and the Tombs is that the two former are places of punishment, while the Tombs is a place of detention in which persons are confined while awaiting trial or the execution of the death penalty, or in de- fault of bail. The inmates of the Tombs, too, are a much smaller number than those of the penitentiaries, and therefore, on this account, that prison presents fewer difficul ties of administration. But Mr. Ivins’s no- tion that persons confined in the Tombs are not entitled tc as much consideration from the city government as persons confined in any other prison, is, coming from a reformer engaged in actual reform work—taken /la- grante delicto, so to speak—so curious and likely to prove so mischievous, and has already produced so much mischief, that it deserves some notice. There appears to be at the bottom of it some sort of vague impression that the charac- ter of jailershould in some degree depend on the character of his prisoners, and that if they are mostly riffraff, such as find their way to the Tombs for want of bail, anybody is good enough to take charge of them. There is nothing new in this idea. It governed the prison administration of nearly every pri- son in Europe before Howard’s time, and pro- duced the horrors in English and Conti- nental jails of which people now read with a shudder, and the disappearance of which is used in histories as illustrating so- cial and religious progress. It was succeed- ed by the idea, which is now supposed to govern the penal system of all Christian nations, that the officers who represent the State in its management of the helpless por- tion of its population, namely, its criminals, paupers, and lunatics, should be taken, to use the words of our illustrious Mayor, ‘‘from the highest order of citizenship the county affords” ; that is, that no man can be too wise, or too good, or too humane, or too experienced to take charge of a jail or an almshouse. He should represent to the unfortunate inmates the community at large in its best mvods, and show, both in his character and career, the qualities on which it teaches its children to set most value. That the services of such men cannot al- ways be procured for such work does not affect the rule. It is the duty of civilized governments to seek them by every means within their reach, and the duty of all good citizens, and especially reformers, to pro- claim the need of them in season and out of season. We have no more right to allow cruelty or injustice to be practised on the prisoners or paupers than on any other class of the poor or unfortunate. Our duty to them is not measured by their deserts, but by our obligations as civilized men administering a Christian government. Moreover, the prison- ersin the Tombs are not necessarily criminals, Every man in America is held to be innocent of crime until he is proved guilty, and most of the Tombs prisoners are persons who have not been proved guilty of anything. It proba- bly contains throughout the year many scores who areinnocent in fact as well asin law. But whether really guilty or simply friendless and unfortunate, we are none the less under asolemn obligation not to put them into the hands of men of bad character or ruffianly temper. Mr. Ivins’s qualification in his corrected statement, that he would bave signed “Fatty” Walsh’s recommendation at the time of his appointment, with the suggested inference that he would not sign it now, having seen ‘‘ Fatty” dismissed for miscon- duct in office, does not mend matters very much. All candidates, everywhere but in Bouffeland, for administrative offices which they have never filled before, rely mainly on their character and previous career to prove their fitness. If they have no marks for ex- perience, their standing in honesty, integrity, and efficiency must be at least 100, The theory that if the work desired be the care of bad men, the candidate need not bea good man, is about as rational as the famous assumption that a man ‘‘ who drives fat oxen must himself be fat.” There is no ra- tionality in it. It is a nursery theory. If ‘* Fatty” Walsh was fit to take charge of the chief prison of a great metropolis, it would prove the folly of inquiring into a man’s ante- cedents before giving him any responsible place whatever. Fatty’s career, in fact, ought, anywhere but in Bouffeland, to have proved his special unfitness for the care of the criminal class. A rumseller and gambler isin New York the very last person to receive a share in the administration of criminal jus- tice. Whatever would be censidered a dis- qualification for any respectable private place, ought to operate as a disqualification for this, The incident on which we are commenting is a good illustration of the way in which the growth of the criminal and semi-criminal class in this city is fostered by the moral and religious and well-to-do. We venture to as- sert that this reckless signing of testimonials in which so many respectable men indulge is a direct premium on crime and disorder. There are thousands of young ‘‘toughs” in this city beginning life very much as Fatty Walsh began his, and who, if they reach middle age, will have passed their lives as he has passed his. We invite the lawyers and merchants and judges who sign these testimonials to ask themselves what the effect on the juvenile criminals and rowdies of our streets must be of seeing careers of violence and disorder and lawlessness reward- ed with well paid wardenships of prisons and seats on the judicial bench. Every year the mire of our semi-criminal politics gets a lit- tle deeper, but we never unearth one of its scandals without coming on a lot of semi- religious promoters of it in the persons of cer- tificate-writers, —— THE ENGLISH UNIVERSITIES IN WIN- TER. Lonpon, December, 1890, CAMBRIDGE and Oxford lose much of their enchantment, in externals at least, to those who have seen them only in their summer at- tire, if they revisit them at the wintry season. There may be green turf in the courts of the ER aston ee BE ST REE ROA Se
Page 11
RI acaiig Bahn aca ene
Jan. 8, 1891]
The Nation
colleges, and here and there an ivy still of dark green; but the bare anatomy of the trees and the dull expanse of many leafless vines on their walls serve to emphasize the naked decay of a large part of the buildings, and one looks upon them as upon monarchs in tat- ters, and they are easily dethroned in the ima- gination. I never felt before so much—for this is my first sight of these university towns in the cheerless season—that hoar antiquity, or the quasi-antiquity which the English cli- mate so speedily produces, gains most of its loveliness from the verdure which shrouds it. It seems, too, as if there had been of late years a good deal of stripping of the ivy from the walls, to arrest the decay and disintegra- tion which, with all its beauty, it serves to produce. The grimy and ragged aspect of the worn-out stone facings of many of the college buildings—more, perhaps, in Oxford than in Cambridge—is far from pleasing ; nor is the sensation much helped by the painful contrasts where a spotted restoration has been made. But friendly sympathy, eliciting the most hospitable of courtesies, makes the visitor in this season, when so much depends on indoor intercourse, delay his departure from either of these academic circles. I came to them from Edinburgh, where the professors of the Uni- versity had been very kind, and even endeared to me; but the absence of the college halls is an unpleasing contrast, and the cosiness of a don’s chamber has nocounterpart in the Scotch University, or even in our own, One remem- bers a dinner or a lunch at a master’s lodge as a board of which one may have some concep- tion at the table of the president of an Ameri- can college; but a dinner at the high table of Trinity or King’s, or St. John’s at Cambridge, or at New College or Queen’s at Oxford, is something not within our American academic experience. The Latin grace at the beginning is said, by varying custom, sometimes by a scholar and sometimes by whatever senior officer may chance to be at the high table. At Trinity in Cambridge, it was read in alternat- ing sentences by the Vice-Chancellor—now the Master of that College—and by Aldis Wright, the Shaksperian, the Vice-Master. It is, perhaps, owing to the less diversified dinner of the undergraduates on the floor of the hall that their repast is sooner ended than that of the dons. They steal out of the hall, each one as he finishes, and the stranger on the dais, eager in talk with his neighbors, suddenly awakes to the apprehension that there is no one left in the hall but the occupants of the high table, Customs in the two towns and at the colleges in the same town vary much. The final grace is said at the high table. The sign for it in at least one hall in Cambridge is that the head- waiter places a large silver loving cup be- fore the presiding officer. On rising from the table the dons retire to a room which they call in Cambridge a‘‘ combination” room, and in Oxford a ‘‘common” room. It is usually a large and handsome room, hung with the por- traits of eminent graduates of the College, In retiring to this room, it seems to be the custom in Oxford to take the dinner napkin along with you; in Cambridge it is not. Here again I found different practices prevail in the balf- dozen halls in which I dined at the two univer- sities. At Trinity in Cambridge, for instance, you sit in this room at a long table and help to keep the decanter in motion, and have some biscuit and cheese with celery to nibble at. The usual practice, however, is to sit in a semi- circle before the fire with little round tables for the dessert and glasses, either in front of each chair or between each two. The propulsion of
sherry, claret, and port—these seem to be the orthodox wines of this after feast—gives a man something to do, in the gaps of conver- sation. With the fireplace forming the link which connects the ends of the horse-shoe curve of sitters, there is a difficulty in the course of tbe viney propulsion. Atsome colleges I found they got over it by reversing the direction: but at New College and Queen's in Oxford, they had devices of their own. At the one a little track ran along the hearth and sustained a lit- tle carriage, in which the restless and viney vessel sped across the hot side of the circle; and at Queen’s the track was placed upon the mantel-piece. After a half hour or more spent in this room, the dons separate for the smok- ing room, if they have one, or break up into little parties, and go to the rooms of one or more of their number, and continue the talk in a cloud of smoke. By this time the intercourse becomes more friendly, and the guest of the evening, who is likely to be of the same par ty, finds a succession of companionshbips in talk likely to keep him amid such hospitality till towards midnight. As he makes his somewhat angular march to his lodgings, forced into zig- zags by the perversity of the short cuts in the narrow streets, he is pretty sure to encounter the proctors, with their attending ** bull dogs,” on the watch for vagrant studenta I saw something of the literary activities of the two universities; but that which most in- terested me at Cambridge was the work which I found Aldis Wright doing for a new edition of his standard Shakspera The coming edi- tion will appear under his sole charge, and his own critical instincts will have fuller play than when be worked on the earlier edition in con- nection with a collaborator. There will be ac- cordingly some revision of judgments. The edition will be kept at iis old number of vol- umes, but each will be increased in bulk. I found he had three volumes nearly finished; and the publication will begin, I think, with the New Year for volume i, and with a reserve of completed volumes sufficient to insure a regular periodicity in publica- tion. The student of Shakspere will remem- ber that this long-established Shaksperian text now under revision was made with the great advantage to be derived from the use which the editors could easily make of Capel's wonderful collection in the library of Trinity, and with such reference as was occasionally necessary to the twin accumulation which stands in Malone's name in the Bodleian at Oxford. I have recently looked, for the second time in twenty years, at these marvellous accu- mulations for the Shaksperian student. It was easy to observe that the catalogue of the Bar- ton collection of Shaksperiana in the Boston Public Library—which collection it fell to my lot to arrange in 1S75-"T77—is a not unused key to the use of similar collections here. At Oxford I visited Dr. Murray and bis workshop, where the great historical Diction- ary of the English Language which bears his name is in the course of compilation. The University people speak of Dr. Murray's scrip- torium, and when | handed in my card at his house a little way out of town, the doormaid asked me to step round to the scriptorium. This is a building built ef corrugated iron, which stands in the rear of Dr. Murray's resi- dence, and it is the workshop in which he and bis staff are engaged. You are struck first on entering it by the array of the fore edges of the slips showing by citation the use of words during the successive periods of the language. These slips stand on shelves, edgewise, as high or higher than you can reach, on all the walls of the room, and the mass represents the results
Qe of the reading of a large number of scholars who have been employed to read for changes in the use of words through the historic periods of the English tongue reacers embraces scholars wherever the Eng- The number of such lish language is spoken—in Europe, America, or in Asia. On slanting shelves every where that the spaces of the room admitted, the leading dictionaries, whose collation is found necessary in passing on from word to word, are arranged, open at the points of pre- sent attention, so that the collator passes with the least impediment from one dictionary to another. It has been my fortune in years past to have been in the similar quarters of the staffs of the great dictionaries of Webster and Worcester, and more recently in that of the still larger York ; but the work or aims of no other has required quite the same extension of detail *Century Dictionary’ in New I have spoken in previous letters of two books which bave come in my way during my pre sent visit to England, which had been scored by Dr. Johnson when be was reading for his own dictionary. One | bad found in the pow session of Mr. Samuel Timmins of Arley, an other at the Chapter Library at Lochdeld, and a third Dr. Murray now showed
the books in his own working collection Il found Dr. Waldstein at Cambridge just closing up his University lectures preparatory to starting to take charge of the American School of Greek Archwology at Athens IustTin WiINSOR, TALLEYRAND IN LONDON AND AME RICA, PARIS, December » 1st) M. Pauratrn, the Director of the French Cus torns, employs his leisure in historical
Ha has turned kis attention to the diplon correspondence of Talléyrand, and put
lished already the inedited correspondence of Talley- rand with King Louis AVIIL during the Con- gress of Vienna. He intends to publish later Minister of Foreign Affairs of the French Di- rectory, his memoirs and reports addressed to Napoleon L, his instructions to ambassadors, his correspondence with his secretaries, etc. The volume just issued relates to Talleyrand’s mission to London in 1792, and contains also his letters to Lord Lansdowne, written from the United States after 174 Talleyrand arrived in London on January 1Z2, 1782, with the mission of forming a defen- sive alliance between France and England. On his deathbed, Mirabeau, who was the colleague of Talleyrand in the Diplomatic Committee of the Constituent Assembly, bad recommended this alliance to him. and publications cf Sytel and others have proved that Europe was never really united against the French Revolution, Prussia, Russia, Austria had views and interests of their own which could not wel! be reconciled. England did not really wish to make warso long as Antwerp and Amsterdam were not threatened. The first coalition had been broken after two years of vain and disconnected efforts. The death of Leopold and the excesses of the French Revolution had been the signal fora second coalition. Talleyrand suggested that a mission should be sent to Prussia, and <ffered to go himself to London in order to neutralize the efforts of the coalition. England was still neu- tral, and was in an expectant attitude. Talleyrand felt convinced that England would not join the coalition if France did not attack the Netherlands, Lord Grenville clear- ly explained to the French Ministers that the All the recent researches
Page 12
28 The Nation. [Vol. 52, No. 1332 Netherlands were the tie between England and Europe; at the Congress of Utrecht, England had stipulated that the Belgian provinces should never go out of the House of Austria— they were to remain a permanent barrier be- tween France and Holland. England remain- ed in reality neutral, and resisted all the offers of the Continental Powers till the French Gov- ernment adopted a policy of conquest and of propagandism, In vain did Talleyrand furnish arguments in favor of a policy of non-inter- vention ; the Revolutionary Government wished to create new republics, and was not long in threatening the Stadtholder of the Netherlands, Talleyrand, by his ability, had brought England to the acceptation of the French occupation of Belgium; it was the maximum which England would and could ac- cept. Holland was to be left outside of the in- fluence of France. But the policy of Talley- rand was not adopted, and, after the famous 10th of August, his mission came to an end. He remained in London no longer as an Am- bassador, but as a refugee. He asked first the Grand Duke of Tuseany for permission to re- tire to his States; his request was refused. In January, 1794, he received from the English Government an order to leave England in twenty-four hours. On the 3d of February, 1794, he Jeft for America, where he remained till 1796, His correspondence with Lord Lansdowne is published for the first time by M. Pallain, to whom it was generously lent by the present Lord Lansdowne. It begins with a letter written as far back as October 3, 1791, from Kensington Square. He replies to Lord Lans- downe, who had asked him to make him a visit at Bowood, that he is detained in London by the necessity of giving help to some French friends ‘* devoted to the cause of liberty, but turned out by pikes.” . . . ‘‘Atam~¢ment when everything is denaturalized and per- verted, the men w ho remain faithful to Liberty, notwithstanding the bloody mask which atro- cious scoundrels have put on her face, are very few in number. I cannot weary of ad- miring M. de Montmorency and M. de Beau. metz, who have come to me after having fora whole month been on the point of being mur- dered, and who still love liberty even for France and detest the foreign invasion.” Then comes a good picture of the debasement of France under the Terror: ‘* The clubs and the pikes kill all energy, and accustom the people to dissimulation; and if weallow it to contract this infamous habit, it will soon tind happi- ness only in a change of tyrants.” The second letter of the collection is written long afterwards, in Philadelphia (Feb. 1, 1795), and it has so much interest that I may be al lowed to give exceptional attention to it. Tal- leyrand was led to examine ‘‘what are the necessary relations that exist between the United States and England; wkat are the true dispositions of the two peoples towards each other.” In order to answer this question, he looks beyond the present moment and makes conjectures regarding a distant future. The passions ruling in 1795 will not be the passions ruling in the nineteenth century. He tells Lord Lansdowne very frankly that ‘ the ties which united America and England when America was the subject and England the sovereign, are inevitably destroyed; and all hope of resuscitating them, all effort in that direction, all expectations given or accepted on this subject, must be looked upon: as the dream of a delirious imagination or of a coarse and lying adulation. This 1 hold to be admitted.” It would seem at present (1795) as if there were in the United States a strong é inclination towards France and a great aver- sion for England. Talleyrand explains tbis state of things by the remembrance of the War of Iudependence; he admits that there are moments when the new Republic, though it is in essence pacific, would seem to be in- clined to let the balance of neutrality fall on the French side. He finds England at fault for exercising her neutrality, as far as Ameri- ca is concerned, in a manner which resembles open hostility. He adds, however, and here one must admire his foresight and his powers of observation, that ‘‘it requires more time and reflection than is at the service of an ordi- nary traveller to find out that, notwithstand- ing these circumstances, America is still all English (tout anglaise]; by which I mean that England has still every advantage over France for deriving from the United States all the benefit which a nation can derive from the existence of another nation.” (These words are underlined in the text.) How can a nation be useful to another na- tion? It must first desire it and then beca pable of it. Talleyrand boldly assumes that the natural inclination of America is ‘‘in fa- vor of England.” This proposition might seem paradoxical; but the war had come to an end, the pride of America was satisfied; the Ameri- cans are governed by their passions less than any other people; all their habits make them tributary to England with a force of necessity which no declaration could diminish. “The similarity of language establishes England’s right of ownership over all the in- clinations of the Americans in an irresistible manner. It fixes between the men of the two countries a common character which will always unite them and make them recognize each other. They will naturally think them- selves at home when they travel in each other’s country, and they will exchange with a revip- rocal pleasure their full thoughts and a dis- cussion of their interests, while an insurmount- able barrier is placed between peop'es of a different language who cannot pronounce a word without warning each other that they are not brothers, and to whom all transmission of thought is a painful task and no longera pleasure.” Taileyrand notes besides in the Federal Con- stitution a great resemblance to the leading traits of the English Constitution. He speaks of the habeas corpus, of trial by jury. In the discussion or application of the laws who is cited Whence are the analogies taken, and the examples? In the customs and rules of the British Parliament, in the common law, in the statutes and judgments of the English courts. * It is in vain that the words republic and monarchy seem to raise distinctions between the two Governments which cannot be con- founded. It is clear to any man who goes to the bottom of ideas that something savors of republic in the representative constitution of England and something of monarchy in the Executive power of America.” When Talley- rand wrote these lines, Gen. Washington was President, but their truth was independent of his great prestige and popularity. Talleyrand explains afterwards how the French Ambassador tried to interfere with the establishment of the Federal Constitution and to keep the States disunited. ‘‘ He wished to condemn them to a long and painful infancy before they could be emancipated without hav- ing the wisdom to conduct themselves or the strength to protect themselves. Such were the instructions of M. de Ternant, then the King’s Minister to the United States.” Talleyrand sees in the efforts of M. de Ternant and after- wards of Genét the germ of anti-Federalism. The Federalists became instinctively hostile to France, and their hostility became more and more marked. These men, ‘‘ though they had applauded the first efforts of France towards liberty, did not see with pleasure that she was taking a newroad in the art of constitutional- ism, and opposing the experience of England with bold essays which furnished momentary weapons to their adversaries. These interior motives have insensibly established between the so-called democrats and the so-called aristo- crats in the United States an issue on a point which ought to remain entirely foreign to the objects of the two parties, viz, the inclination towards the French or the inclination towards the English.” Talleyrand concludes his letter, which is in reality a long memoir, with commercial and economical considerations which have not lost their value, but which I have no room to trans- late. He ends by advising England to treat the United States with the greatest considera- tion, to send to Washington distinguished Ministers. ‘‘I conclude by saying that the Americans will remain independent, that they will be more useful to England than any other Power, and that this utility will be propor- tionately augmented as the English Govern- ment lays aside the haughty forms which it now employs in its relations with America.” There are three other letters addressed by Talleyrand to Lord Lansdowne, from New York, but they have no great importance. One of them relates to the Jay Treaty. ‘ All the debates on the Treaty have been kept secret; though the parties were very much ex- cited, nothing has transpired.” I recommend to all the readers of M. Pal- lain’s new volume a note in the Introduction (page 30), containing a letter written to Talley- rand by Madame de Staél in 1809; the original is in the British Museum. 1 have spoken in my letters to the Nation of the first relations of the famous daughter of Necker with Talleyrand, at the time when he was still called the Bishop of Autun. When Talleyrand returned from Ame- rica, it may be said that Madame de Staél made him Minister of Foreign Affairs, by in- troducing him to the important men of the Directory. In 1809 she was in exile, the object of the special persecution of Napoleon. Her letter to Talleyrand, written in the interest of her children, is a masterpiece of delicacy, of feeling, and of dignity. THE SIDON SARCOPHAGL—L Wincu_EstTER, Va., December 9, 1890. BEHIND Sidon and Tyre, at the foot of the mountains, there is an almost continuous line of rock-cut tombs. As in Palestine and the country east of the Jordan, so in Pheenicia also, the dead were buried in rock-cut tombs on steep hillsides and along deep watercourses, where the formation of the land allowed caves to be excavated with the least labor. Rich men, however, often built their tombs in their gardens, although this was liable to cause more labor, at least where the surface of the rcck was flat. In order to construct the caves in which they used to place the sarcophagi, they were then compelled to sink deep shafts in the solid rock, at the bottom of which they hollowed out their cave-tombs. Tombs of this description are often found in the grain fields and gardens behind the town of Sidon and be- tween that andthe mountains. It wasinsucha tomb to the southeast of Sidon, on the rock pla- teau just beyond the gardens, that the sarcopha- gus of King Eshmunua’zar, now in the Louvre, was found. This sarcophagus had been rifled of its contents, removed from the royal tomb, used again, and deposited in a tomb at that point ; so it seems. Here it was that Renan excavated, finding a number of tombs, so that Si ga Sone te a as SSRN Tala a eee Sneha
Page 13
oe ia i ages ‘aioe Rate! AE Men tee eR Ree Jan. 8, 1891] The Nation. on his map he deSignates this spot as the ne- cropolis of Sidon, This designation is entirely incorrect, for just as many tombs exist every- where else behind the town as at Renan’s so- called necropolis. The whole surface of the rock plateau above the gardens and below the hills is honeycombed with these tombs, occur- ring sometimes singly, sometimes in groups. Stone-cutters pursuing their occupation are continually discovering new tombs. They or- dinarily rifle them, seliing the lamps, bottles, etc., which they find to antiquity-dealers or chance travellers, It was stone-cutters who discovered the tomb containing the sarcopha- gus of Eshmuna’zar referred to above. Tie peculiar character of this sarcophagus led them to communicate the find to others, and it was obtained by the Duc de Luynes for the Louvre. Between three and four years ago a stone-cutter discovered a tomb containing sarcophagi on the edge of the plateau, close to the gardens, about as far to the north- east of the town as was Renan’s “‘ necropolis” to the southeast. The peculiar nature of the sarcophagi which he saw led the stone-cutter to inform the American missionaries at Sidon of his discovery, and through their agency, I be- lieve, the fact was communicated to Hamdy Bey, director of the Imperial Museum at Con- stantinople. This led to his excavations at Sidon in the spring of 1887, and the recovery of those remarkable sarcophagi which are just being thrown open to the public in the new Museum built to receive them in the Turki-h capital, In the winter of 1887-’88 it was reported by telegraph that one of these sarcopbagi was the sarcophagus of Alexander the Great. An en- terprising New York daily forthwith inter- viewed a number of savants here and abroad, and devoted much space to a discussion of the subject. After that the matter was allowed to drop, and very little has been heard of the sarcophagi since, except an occasional com- plaint that Hamdy Bey bad rot published bis results, nor allowed any une to see and study the sarcophagi themselves. In point of fact, he had no place to put them, and they remained in their boxes in the open air, while he was ar- ranging for the erection of a proper building-- for which the Sultan gave the money—and superintending its erection. The building is now about completed, the sarcophagi on exhi- bition, and Hamdy’s work on the same making its appearance, The latter is published in fascicules by Leroux of Paris, It is to be uniform with Renan’s ‘ Mission en Phénicie,’ and abundantly illustrated; for Hamdy Bey is a well-known artist and also an excellent photographer. I saw the sarcophagi in September and Oc- tober of this year. They were still in their cases, but I was allowed to examine them as long and as often as I wished to, I shali never forget my first visit. [ had just arriv.d in Constantinople, and had gone to call on Hamdy at the Museum. He proposed to show me the sarcopbagi, which were in the lower story of the unfinished new building. He com- menced with the sarcophagus of the ‘‘ Weep- ers,” opening one at a time, and finishing with the great sarcophagus which had been attri- buted in the telegrams sent to this country to Alexander the Great. I was amazed and utter- ly carried away; for although I had beard something of the beauty of the sculptures, I was not prepared to find such wonderful art treasures. I had never seen anything to com- pare with them, and each time I saw them afterwards, the more closely I examined them, the greater the impression. They take their QOD p’ace in the very front rank of the art treasures of the world, and it is worth a long pilgrimage to see and study them There are seventeen sarcopbagi in all, nine of which are adorned with polychrome sculp- ture. There were two tombs, one a Phasnician royal tomb practically unviolated,and the other a Greek tomb, all the sarcophagi in which had been broken intoand violated. The Phcenician tomb was at a higher level than the Greek. At the time the latter was constructed all knowledge of the existence of the former was lost. The builders sank their shaft and began to cut a chamber into the rock, when the bol- low sound warned them that they were pene- trating into an older tomb, Accordingly they sank their shaft still deeper, to the unusual depth of forty feet, when they were below the otber tomb, and could cut the requisite cham bers without breaking into others already ex- isting. Some notice of the discoveries in the Phoenician tomb, and more particularly of the inscribed sarcophagus of Tabnith, the father of the above-mentioned Esbmuna’ zar, Was published in the Revue Archéo logique in 1887, the writer erroneously, how- ever, speaking of the Greek tomb as being ata higher level than the Phanician. The writer of the article, M. Renan, also attributes the Phoenician tomb, and consequently the inscrip tion of Tabnith, to a date at least a century too late. Driver of Oxford does the same thing in his discussion of the early history of the He brew alphabet in the introduction to his ‘ Notes on the Hebrew Text of the Books of Samuel,’ assigning it to 300 B.c. Now there is one of the Greek sarcophagi already mentioned, found in the tomb first discovered, which can not be later than 300 B. C., and, as already stated, at the time when the tomb containing the sarcophagus was constructed, the exist- ence of the neighboring Phnician royal tomb seems to have passed out of remembrance. There are certain further details which Hamdy bey feels determine the date of Tabnith ap proximately, but which I am not at liberty to state. At least, his discovery furnishes con- clusive proof that the date of 300 B. c for Tabnith is too late by a bundred years or more, a result of some importance in Phwnician epi- graphy. The inscription on Tabnith's sarcophagus reads as follows : ‘“*{, Tabnith, priest of Ashtaroth, King of the Sidonians, son of Estmuna’sar, priest of Ashtaroth, King of the Sidonians, lie in this chest. Thou whosoever findest this chest do not open my tomb (4 nor violate it, for there is no image of silver, nor image of gold, neither any jewels hidden (. I only lie in this chest; do not open my tomb nor violate it, tor that is an abomination unto Asbtaroth; and if thou dost at all open my tomb and violate it, mayest thou have no seed among the living under the sun, nor resting-place among the mn shades! There is something pathetic in the testimony which this inscription affords to the insecurity even of royal tombs, The pains which had been taken to secure the sarcophagus in its chamber bear further testimony of the same character. It was buried ina hole in the rock floor of the chamber, which was filled up with smail stones and mortar, and on top of all was a great block of stone about ten feet long and five feet thiek. But the pathos of the attempt to preserve this tomb inviolate both by curses and by material means is somewhat marred by the fact that the very sarcophagus in which Tabnith’s mummy was found had been stolen from an Ezyp'ian tomb. There are uneffaced Egyptian inscriptions both without and wiihb- in, from which it appears that this great mummy-shaped stone chest was originally the a ~ a coffin of a ceriain Egyptian general named Panephtah. It seems probable tha’, afier the conquest of Egypt by the Persians, many an- cient tombs were violated, and that a traffic sprang up in second-hand Egyptian coffins, The sarcophagus of Eshmuna’sar in the Louvre is an Egyptian stone coffin of the same typeasthatof Tabnith, a result of the same traffic in funeral spoila As 1 have al- ready sta’ed, it was not found in its original condition, nor apparently in its original position. Hamdy Bey is inclined to suppose, with consi- derable probability, that the tomb of E«hma- nazar was in the same neighborhood as that of Tabnith, If so, then there is a possibility that the tomb of Tabnith may be a part of a sort of royal necropolis, and that unviolated graves of other kings of Sidon may be divcoverad hardly less interesting. Last summer stone-cutters ascertained that other tomb chambers exist close to those already found in the same grain and olive fleld. Hamdy Bey hopes to be able to excavate those next spring, and we must wish for bim at least some part of the remark- able success which attended his excavations in ISNT In the tomb of Tabnith, besides the chamber containing his own sarcophagus, were other chambers containing uninseribed stone sarco phagi, presumably the coffins of the women of his fam ly. Wi b none of these, so far as | am informed, was found anything of interest, but merely lamps and vases of ordinary forms. These also were transported to Constantinople to form part of the unique collection of sarco- phagi which fills the whole lower floor of the new Museum and overtlows into the court tn front. Joun PL Peters Correspondence. THE SIOUX “WAR” To Tue Eprror oF Tre Nation: Sir: To any one who knows all the facts, the present massacres of the Sioux are inex- pressibly sad and shocking. The Government makes treaties with the Indians promising them annually certain suppliea The supplies are mainly stolen by the agents, the Indians suffer in bedy from hunger, and suffer in mind at the thought that they are perfidiously treated. Their case is hopeless, and to any one who studies the matter, it is a very pretty ex- ample of like causes producing like results when we see them, in the same situation as the Jews under the Romans, losing all bope of earthly help and turning towards the thought of supernatural deliverance. They quickly adapted the Messiah idea to their own case; the ground was ready for the seed. It was my fortune to meet the Sioux as hos- tiles the first time I ever saw them, and our party, outnumbered five times, narrowly es- caped a fight that meant, as the mountaineers sail, that we should have been “ rubbed out.” Though I was then but a boy, it was plain to me that we were in the wrong as they charged us—making a new wagon road through their country without their consent by treaty or otherwise—though it took away none ofthe bitterness as we looked around at the hills with but five minutes more to live, as we be lieved. The following year I went to work at Fort Laramie in an old historical building of stone and adobe, as *‘ cub” or store-boy, selling goods to soldiers of the garrison, freighters, and emi- grants, and to the Sioux who were all around there. On quiet afternoons a party of Sioux would walk in and sit down wrapped in robes
Page 14
30 The Nation. [Vol. 52, No. 1332 or blankets and silently smoke and pass the pipe around. Sometimes the silence was broken by disoussions on various subjecta. The proprietor, my employer, had gone among the Sioux and Cheyennes at the age of sixteen, and raised an Indian family. But the squaw and most of the children were dead, and ‘* Yellow Hair” was a great rich man with a white squaw, and on his rare visits to the place his old friends felt honored to get to shake his hand and say ‘* How.” A frequent subject of conversation was how that the Great Father (President) sends goods for the Sioux, and the agents give them one- tenth and sell the other nine-tenths to the trad- ers, who trade them to the Sioux for peltries instead of giving them. I remember espe- cially one Indian, who came in with his boy and began telling me that he was just back from the wak-o-pominy. That meant a free distri- bution of annuities or presents. He told me he bad a squaw and three pappooses, and ‘* This is the share that my whole family got,” said he, as he contemptuously stuck his butcher-knife into a big plug of tobac o that looked as if it had been rained on. The In- dians said ‘‘ such a trader”—naming a French- man, formerly a trapper—‘‘got one wagon- load of the goods sent us by the Great Father”; such another ‘‘ got two loads,” and soon, ‘‘ and they traded some to us, and sent others up north to trade to other bands of our tribe.” Differentiation has done as much work among Indians as among whites, and there is not more difference between Crispi and a dago than between Spotted Tail, Little Thunder, Afraid-of-My-Horse (erronecusly called Man- Afraid-of-His-Horses), or Red Cloud, or any great Sicux chief, and the dregs of the Kaw tribe, forexample. ‘‘ Yellow Hair,” my white employer, said: ‘‘ I spent the winter of my six- teenth year in a Cheyenne village of two thou- sand souls, and every woman in it was vir- tuous. Any one could rely implicitly on the word of every man, and I should like to see the white village of which the same could be said.” But he added: ‘‘ That was before they had met the white men.” There was something so fascinating in the honest straightforwardness of the Sioux, who, en passant, call themselves ‘‘ Lah-kota,” that I would have imitated my employer and gone among them as one of them, for I do not see hew any impulse can be stronger than was then ‘‘ the love of vert and venison.” But it was plain to me that the wave of white men would sooner or later go over it all, and then I should be like the ‘‘squaw-men,” neither a white man nor an Indian. While female beauty was not general among them, it was true that Wahziminy, ‘‘ The-One-W bo-Smells- Like-Pine,” and Tinggaliska, ‘‘ The Antelope Fawn,” and others, were as handsome as women can be who are not white. All through the bloody year of 1865, when we were prompted to feel each morning whe- ther our scalps were in place, we could not fairly deny that the danger we were in came from the faults of our own race in their bad faith with Indians. The last lot of Sioux that I saw was Red Cloud and other chiefs and ‘*Strong Hearts,” in Cheyenne, en route to Washington. They were as straight as ar- rows, and as they stood in the streets surround- ed by crowds of the curious, they were like so many Sauls, a head and shoulders above any of the white men in town except the Sheriff (an old soldier of Stonewall Jackson’s) and two men who are now Senators from Wyoming. I asked one his name, and the words brought back re- collections like forgotten dreams ; but I could wah shnee?” (Don’t you know? also meaning, ‘*T don’t know.”) I could but feel a pang in thinking that such a race had extinction as its certain fate, and that their smooth, beautiful tongue, to them and their neighbors the inter- national and diplomatic language, as French is to the whites, must be lost to comparative philology. To me there is no dime-novel glamour about Indians to prompt this writing. Two genera- tions back of me in my family there were honorable gentlemen who were Indian agents, aname now almost synonymous with thief. I first saw the light in an Indian agency house, and near that my grandfather lies buried, and at one side of him is an Indian chief who asked that he might rest by the faithful friend of his tribe. 1 know by heart the Indians’ side of the story of the Black Hawk war, from my father, who was a lieutenant in Zachary Tay- lor’s regiment ; and he said it was a sickening sight to see the Lllinois militia shoot squaws who were trying toswim the Mississippi with pappooses on their backs. ‘‘ Nits make lice,” was Harney’s expression when he fell on Lit- tle Thunder’s band ; in more elegant English it means, Kill the children, or you will have to kill them when they are grown. The soldiers who do the butchering cannot be blamed. When Indians have been starved into desperation and determine and begin to kill all they can, there is nothing to do but to kill them. In somewhat intimate talks with Crook on the plains, I noted how cautiously that ‘*Gray Fox,” as the reds called him, avoided, as a soldier, expressing himself against the thieves of the Interior Department who drive the Indians to desperation. Is there no remedy? Some persons at Fort Laramie were green enough to think that the exposure of the robbery of the Indians would be followed by reformation in the methods of the Administration. They learned that the thieving agent was somebody’s brother-in-law, and that if public servants could plunder the white people of millions right under the eyes and nose of the Administration in a hundred ways, then, a fortiori, the Indian eel must learn to keep quiet in the skinning. All attempts at exposure and reformation only made powerful enemies for those who tried it. The best thing to do is to read the story of the Roman pro- consuls’ plundering, and congratulate ourselves that we did not invent the infamy. Though Big Foot was not one of my ac- quaintances, his track is familiar by repute. The frontiersmen have told me of seeing it after a disappearance of horses, and that it was as long as the stock of a gun. Studying languages as a pastime, I have learned some- thing of twenty, but not all of them furnish me an expression of my feelings as I think of him butchered in time to keep him from dying of pneumonia. And the pappooses !| No people are as kind to their incipient warriors as the Sioux, for they say, ‘‘ We are raising them to be killed and we must treat them well.” Let the man who unquestionably gave assurance that these butcheries might occur with im- punity, make a collection of Indian baby scalps as toys for his grandchild, and go to church and listen to the Scripture, ‘* Suffer little children,” etc. It was discovered that by turning the In- dians over to the churches, the ‘‘ Indian prob- lem ” would be solved. A certain long-haired bishop thought that if he could lay his hands on Red Cloud’s head, he would reduce him to peace when he was at war. A warden of the same church got to be agent under the régime of that religious denomination, and while his further than Fort Laramie, where he indus- triously played poker, and left his subordinates at the agency to do what is usual in the mat- ter of the Indian appropriations. And you, gentle reader of a great and scho- larly publication, kindly overlook the faults in this article by a writer whose education has been mainly gathered at odd times by himself. Turn your eyes to the plains of Nebraska and South Dakota, where the blizzard is sweeping in resistless fury over the frczen bodies of the red mothers pierced by the bullets from the Hotchkiss and Gatling guns that killed the babies on their backs at the same discharge. They are frozen now, and the wolves are gnaw- ing the breasts of the mothers and tearing off the legs and arms of the children who once sucked them. Not even their Messiah came to help them. Take up your ‘ Bleak House’ and your ‘Uncie Tom’s Cabin,’ and as you read them feel thankful that we area great and Christian pecple, and that the party in service is a party of High Moral Ideas. GEORGE WILSON, LEXINGTON, Mo., New Year's Day, 1891. THE PENSION ABUSE, To THE EpiTor oF THE NaTION: Sir: Is there any other safe treatment of our general financial interests than the entire repeal of all pension legislation enacted since (say) 1870? If not speedily done, it seems to me our en- tire fiscal system must be dangerously modified to procure the necessary revenue, entailing radical changes in commercial, social, and other respects, which on examination will be found inseparable from such change of system. The odious and fraudulent “ protective” de- ception is doomed, as it ought to be, and the danger now is that it may carry down with it even the good and time-honored system of raising revenue by a ‘tariff for revenue,” which in some form has prevailed throughout the national existence, It is improbable that any Congress, with the Western preponder- ance now fatuously given it for partisan rea- sons, will venture to restore the easiest-bear- ing, cheapest-collected, and most lucrative of al! taxes, viz., a moderate duty on sugar, coffee, and tea; and without those items no tariff, either for revenue or protection, can long afford the enormous amounts required. Already we see a graduated income tax called for by demagogues to meet the artificial and unnecessary deficiency. But such a tax, once incorporated into our regular system in time of peace, involves re- sults of far-reaching consequence which it is of the greatest importance should not be lost sight of till too late. It must cause not merely the concealment of capital, but its transfer in large masses to trustees and agents within foreign jurisdictions, and even the acquisition of foreign residence by citizens whose pre- sence, abilities, and capital are important to all classes here. It must also transfer a large part of the traffic in portable securities from American cities to London and other Europe- an bourses; and, worse than all for those who prefer or have to live here, it must tend, as intended, to impose the entire burden of the public expenditure on a small number, proba- bly not exceeding 10 per cent. of the popula- ticn, leaving the remaining 90 per cent, either indifferent to the rate of expenditure or di- rectly interested in its augmentation. None of these results and other kindred ones that wiil occur to thoughtful readers, can benefit any class of persons in this country; not exactly translate it, and he asked ‘ Lo-lo- ? agency was in northern Nebraska, he went no and yet a graduaied income-tax, once fastened Es Me ea ce
Page 15
’ te BS ERE RE Piatto ale ph Sutae ME. Peicrt ised veo aes The Nation. Si upon our regular system, would probably be harder to remove than any other fiscal blun- der, since the exempted 90 per cent. will soon learn to prefer a method which imposes nei- ther inconvenience nor visible burden upon them, and the borrowing States will see no ob- jection to Jaying the whole burden on the old- er States that bave labored longest and saved most, If there be any force in the views thus im- perfectly sketched, can there be any more pressing public necessity than timely agitation for the repeal of pension abuses which can alone supply a plausible excuse for a graduated or any other income-tax, with its train of haif- foreseen mischiefs behindit? Notwithstanding the growing hosts of pensioners, with the Washington lobbyists and their $37,000,000 of realized plunder at their back, there yet re- main to set against each at least twenty other voters as yet unsubsidized, and with sympa- thies considerably modified by the more re- cent legislative outrages. This condition would seem to offer a fair chance for success- ful agitation of the subject, if not too long deferred. a aa: Wes PHILADELPHIA, December 31, 1890, THE PARTY OF INTELLECT AND CUL- TURE. To THE EpitTor oF THE Nation : Srr: In your notice of Mr. Henry C. Lea’s article in the Atlantic Monthly on ‘* The Les- son of the Pennsylvania Election,” I am some- what surprised at your remark: ‘‘ We agree with Mr. Lea in thinking that the [Republican] party contains ‘the major portion of the intel- lect and culture of the land.’” If you had used the past tense, 1 could agree with you, for during the years when the Democratic party was vainly endeavoring to reconcile the irreconcilable, to adjust the party creed to wild and dangerous propositions and preju- dices which seemed likely to command votes with which to grasp power, not only the intel- lect and the culture, but the plain hard sense of the country was against it. But parties are made for men, not men for parties, Men are not born into parties as into a caste, or, if they are, they leave one for an- other if it appears to them that, through the agency of the other, the ends which they believe to be good for the community or selfishly good for themselves may be there by better subserved. Therefore the lesson of the November election (leaving out of count the result in Pennsy!vania) seems to be not so much that men are changing their views of economic principles, or of the proper functions of the general Government, as that they have discovered that they have vainly tried to get them expressed and embodied through one agency, and in vast numbers have gone over to the other. By way of illustration I add a story told me by a Massachusetts friend (and here condersed toits hurt), It is to the effect that the Ghost of Vice-President Wilson recently visited Senator Hoar and inquired as to the results of the November election in Massachusetts. The Senator gave him the names of those who had been elected as Governor and Congressmen, and told how those who had been defeated had cut down the “‘ normal” majority of their op- ponents in the way we know. The Ghost was delighted. ‘‘And now, Senator,” said the Ghost, ‘tell me who were the Democratic candidates.”— Yours, JOSEPH PaRRISH. PHILADELPHIA, January 2, 1891. MR. RAILTON'’S DRAWINGS. To THe Eprrorn oF Tae Nation : SIR: A very agreeable notice in last week’s Nation shows that my reference to Mr. Her- bert Railton, inan article in the last Scribner's, is liable to mislead by seeming to imply con- demnation of his work, which Iadmire. No- thing is better of its kind than his published sketches of picturesque buildings, and he has shown that nobody’s hand is surer when there is occasion for rendering architectural form. Allow me to explain that the criticism was of draughtsmen who, having fallen in love with bis picturesque touch, can think of nothing else when it comes to subjects that demand a different treatment. Pen drawing is an art in which the manipulation is so conspicuous and so enticing that it constantly draws the attention of the beholder, and of the artist, from the thing to be expressed to the means of expressing it. Here is the danger of follow- ing too enthusiastically a favorite example. W. P. P. LoNGFELLOW. Boston, January 5, 1801, THE MISPLACED H. To THE Epitor or THe Nation ¢ SIR: “Chommoda dicebat, si quando commoda vellet Dicere, et insidtas Arrius hinsidias,” Perhaps both Mr. Oliphant and “F. H.” would agree in sdmitting that this bit from Catullus illustrates the chronology and cho rology cf the * Habused Haitch.” Mr. Coote does not strengthen his argument by citing it in his ‘Romans in Britain.’ The suggestion that ’Arry lurks in Arrius can hardly be such an etymologema as causes Mr. Skeat to “' listen in silent shame.” ya 8 New BEDFORD, Mass., December 3), 180. To THE Epitor oF THe Nation: Str: In general, one gets little profit from any attempts to correct the blunders of the hopelessly ignorant. But the recent letter by ‘*F. H.” (Nation, December 25, 1880) entitled “H Displaced and Misplaced,” in which he touches upon Mr. Oliphant’s ‘ New English’ and upon the vulgar English wilfulness in foisting everything bad or ignoble in speech upon America, provokes one to an expression of scholarly spleen. The only thing in ‘“ F. H.'s” stricture that surprises me is its extreme modesty. That he, one of the chief readers for Murray's Dictionary, and saturated with English lexicology from the fourteenth ceutury down, should stoop to mention such paltry dates as 1801, 1796, 1793, disconcerts me, in fact. Or is ‘*F. H.” keeping back his trump cards! Had he written down boldly “S11” instead of **1811," even then he would have fallen short of the mark, for the AaitcA is as old as record- ed English speech. The oldest monument is the Epinal Glossary, of which Mr. Sweet, ‘ Oldest English Texts,’ p. 2, asserts, ‘* The MS. may have been written any time between 600 and 700.” Turning to this Glossary, word No. 50 p. SS, we find the Latin arellanus glossed aestl, The Corpus Glossary (later and differ- ing somewhat in dialect) has hael [for haes/), and—in another place—Aaesel/hnuftu. The word is our well-known “ hazel,” German Aasel. That the 4 is an organic part of the word is shown by Kluge, in his German Dictionary. Kluge assumes a pre-Germanic *Kaselo, cog nate with Latin corylus (r from s by rhota- cism) and old Irish coll for cosl, Turning now to Sweet's edilion of the * Pastoral,’ printed as long ago as 1871, we read, p. xxxi: “The frequent omission of initial A 1s a remarkable feature of the Pastoral MSS.: a@fdon [for hafdon, ‘they had") 27%; afde (for Acwfde, ‘Ll bad") 153 '*; és {for Ais} 43%", ete. The addition of an in- organic A is rarer: Ats for is 215"* ahebdbdad [for a-ebbad, ‘ ebbed away}, CAront cle, ed. Earle, p. 8%." All these examples are from genuine Wes compare sex documents of the ninth century. And see Cosijn, *‘ AltwestsAchsische Grammatik’ (erste Halfte, p. 181). From the tenth century | cite animo ste is {for Ais} mode, Kentish Gloss s, No. 54 (Zeitschrift fiir deutsches Altertum xx Later MSN show the AuifcA frequently Thus An.-S. Minora (Anglia xii! gu ¢ Aa ge-hearnian [read earnian) tcillath po Siu4® be ts [read Ais) geearnunge Si6'*, for Aus {read us) synfullan SIT See also the exam ples cited by Logemann in his edition of * The Rule of St. Benet’ (EH. E. To), pw lis. § For the fourteenth century we may note in Chaucer ost for Aost, ‘ House of Fame’ i ini. A ’ ‘Fortune, 4 In the un dance (for abundance), documents of this century, Aouwre (for cure heuery for every (Morsbach, ‘ Ursprung der Nevenglischen Schriftsprache,’ p 100) I bave gathered only a few examples, such as have lain in my path while bunting for worda No one, to my knowledge, has made especial study of the point, but lam confident that whoever does will be able to multiply ex- amples indefinitely, and make it clear ever to the wayfaring man, though a fool, that the English language from the seventh to the nine teenth century has always been lax in its haitches The examples from the Epinal, Pastoral, Chronicle, and Kentish glosses pre clude the possibility of assuming Norman in fluence J. M. Harr. CORNELL University, January St Notes. MeESskS. CHARLES SCRIBNER'S Sons and Scrib- ner & Welford announce that the branch of their business heretofore conducted under the name of Scribner & Welford will henceforth be carried on under the former name, which will thus include all departments of their busi- ness This change must bave been anticipated op the death of the late Charles Welford, whose name the book-lovers of this city may be trusted to cheri-h without the usual remind- er. The Messrs) Scribner have in press ‘A Practical Guide to Whist,’ by Fisner Ames ; ‘Talks with Athenian Youths,’ five selected dialogues from Plato, newly translated ; the annual edition for 18@1 of Janvier’s * Mexican Guide’; and the three concluding volumes of Henry Adams's ‘ History of the United States,’ embracing the second Administration of Madi- son. *Men and Women of the Time’ will be the expanded title of the new edition of ‘ Men of the Time,’ to be issued in the spring by Geo. Routledge & Sons. Macmillan & Co. will publish shortly ‘Stu- dies in Literature,’ by John Morley, and a new nine-volume edition of the * Cambridge Shak- spere,’ revised by W. Aldis Wright. The Cassel! Publishing Co. have nearly ready, in two volumes, T. Wemyss Reid’s ‘Life, Letters, and Friendships of Richard Monckton Milnes, First Lord Houghton.’ The United States Book Co, will be the American publishers of Dr. Japp’s edition of the posthumous works of De Quincey, and of Mr. Edmund Gosse’s authorized tranalation of Ibsen’s latest play, ‘‘ Hedda Gabler.”
Page 16
The Nation. [Vol. 52, No. 1332 Unwin Brothers, Little Bridge Street, Lud- gate Hill, London, E. C., invite subscriptions to an ordinary and a large-paper limited edi- tion of the ‘ Collected Sermons of Thomas Ful- ler, D.D.,’ begun by the late lamented John Eglington Bailey, author of the best Life of that worthy, and carried through by Mr. W. E. A. Axon. Each edition will be in two volumes. Many of the sermons are very rare. Among the publications of the English Folk- Lore Society for 1890 is an interesting and valuable ‘ Handbook of Folklore,’ edited by Mr. G. L. Gomme, Director of the Society. The object of this modest little volume is to give a definition of folklore and directions for its collection. The first: chapter attempts to explain what folklore is and to classify it in twenty-one classes, under four general heads: superstitious belief and practice (nine subdivi- sions) ; traditional customs (four subdivisions) ; traditional narratives (four subdivisions); and folk-sayings (three subdivisions). Each of the twenty-one chapters which follow contains a definition of the particular class of folklore treated therein, and a few typical examples ‘illustrating the way in which the folklorist compares and identifies the beliefs, customs, and traditions of modern ages.” Then fol- lows, in most of the chapters, a series of questions (there are 784 in all) for the direction of collectors, In chapter xv., ‘* Folk Tales, Hero Tales, Drolls,” Mr. Baring Gould’s convenient classification (adapted from J. G. von Hahn) of “story radicals” (seventy classes) is given, and it would be well for fu- ture collectors of popular tales to observe this arrangement as far as possible, in order to fa- cilitate reference. In conclusion, three chap- ters treat of the way to collect folklore, libra- ry work, and a sketch of the Folk-Lore So- ciety. In the second of these three chapters an account is given of the elaborate tabulation of folk-tales and customs undertaken by the Society, instalments of which are printed from time to time in the journal of the Society (now published under the name of Folk-Lore, a Quarterly Review of Myth, Tradition, Insti- tution, and Custom). Mr. Gomme's book is deserving of wide circulation, and will un- doubtedly do much to increase the interest already felt in the subject. We have received the second annual issue of the ‘Public Schools Year-Book’ published in London by Swan Sonnenschein & Co. It is edited by three public-school men of Eton, Harrow, and Winchester, and has every mark of system and thoroughness. Some American parents may find their account in the in- formation imparted about preparatory schools, examination papers, admission, studies, charges, scholarships, prizes, etc. The second part, about two-thirds as full as the first part, is wholly given up to athletics; and this may attract our college undergraduates, One of the appendices records and classifies the edu- cational books of the year. In the ‘ American Manual of Photography’ for 1891 (New York: Scovill & Adams Co.) the most noticeable feature is an interesting col- lection of twelve portraits of Daguerre. Seve- ral of these are from daguerreotypes, and in one case we have both a process print from the somewhat battered original, and Kruell’s wood- engraving from the same, properly reversed. The daguerreotype of 1548 has never before been reproduced, ard is one of the best of the series, The exigencies of Boston University, with its mixed classes, have forced Prof. Lindsay, in editing ‘ The Satires of Juvenal’ (American Book Company), to omit whole satires and mu- tilate others beyond ordinary precedent, Such ’ editions will make us doubt seriously if col- leges constructed on the theory of coeducation must not at last consent to strike certain classi- cal authors out of their course altogether, rather than use them in a form which can only lead to a distorted and incorrect notion of their contents. The editor’s notes, too, show great absence of proportion. Considerations of text occupy too much room for beginners, while advanced students—and only such ought to at- tempt the study of Juvenal—will be teased by the most elementary translations and com- ments. There is the fashionable profusion of pictures, including a reduction of Géréme’s ‘*Circus Maximus” ; but Prof. Lindsay’s scho- larship finds no real chance to show itself un- der so many hampering conditions. A good selection of Cicero’s letters edited for colleges is such a desideratum that our an- ticipations were strongly raised by Prof. Mon- tague’s ‘Selected Letters of Marcus Tullius Cicero’ (Philadelphia: Eldredge & Brother); but it isa very disappointing book. The let- ters are selected almost wholly for their histo- rical importance, and hence some extremely hard ones are given, and given early, while the editor, like too many editors of Cicero’s letters, neglects the profusion of short, simple, and easy letters to Tiro and Terentia, which throw no light indeed on Clodius or Cesar, but form an admirable introduction to epistolary Latin and Cicero’s domestic history. Tne book is loaded with extracts from all sorts of fami- liar manuals like Forsyth’s ‘ Life of Cicero,’ and some very antiquated ones, like Zumpt’s Grammar and Leverett’s Lexicon. Tedious ele- mentary information about subjunctives, to be found in every grammar, and known to every teacher, fills up space belonging properly to explanation of local and specific difficulties. Obsolete spellings like otii, coniicerentur, are retained; in one place the note assumes haud when there is none in the text; and elsewhere the impossible date A. D ti Kal: Mai; appears. M. Edouard Rouveyre, a Parisian publisher, who kas already deserved well of al) book- lovers for his sumptuous volumes on the fine- art of book-binding, has now begun the issue of a new ‘ Bibliothéque des Connaissances utiles aux Amis des Livres” with a volume on ‘Les Ex-libris et les Marques de possession du Livre,’ by M. Henri Bouchot (New York: F. W. Christern), which pleasantly supplements the information in Poulet-Malassis’s amus- ing monograph and in the more ponderous book of Mr. Leicester Warren. M,. Henri Bouchot points out that the book-plate had its origin in Germany, where the art of book-binding was never cherished, and that in the beginning the book-lovers who were clothing their precious vulumes in gilded mo- rocco bearing their arms, emblem, motto or name, scorned the mere paper-label of Teu- tonic origin. Nowadays, however, every true book-lover has his book-plate, and nowhere is the ingenuity of French taste more advan- tageously displayed than in the making of these dainty devices, Even in inartistic Eng- land, the fancy is spreading; and Mr. Licht- enstein and Mr. Laurence Hutton have al- ready written about American >»ok-plates. A winter trip to California is coming more and more into vogue with those who can spare the time and money, and the Sandwich Islands, too, are commending themselves as a pleasant and inexpensive excursion from San Francisco, The round trip can now be made for $125, the time required for reaching the islands being a week. This information, with a great deal more of value and interest to tra- vellers, is given in ‘The Tourist’s (Guide through the Hawaiian Islands,’ compiled by H. M. Whitney and published by the Hawaiian Gazette Company at Honolulu. It contains four maps of the different islands, and twenty illustrations of the finest scenery. In describ- ing the volcanoes, the editor has quoted freely from the writings of others, especially Miss Bird, whose book, though a little out of date, is still the most readable work on Hawaii. Of course, the information given in it as to routes and travel conveniences holds good no longer, and in this respect Mr. Whitney’s guide will prove a useful supplement. There are now two regular routes to the volcano of Kilauea, On one of these the tourist is surprised to come across a railway of twenty miles, on which a bye- excursion can be made; and almost as much, on reaching the Volcano House, at finding there a stove, a liberal supply of food, a parlor with easy-chairs, and even a small library. Several pages are devoted to the leper settlement at Molokai. We lately had occasion to notice the ‘ Cy- cloyzedia of the Manufactures and Products of the United States’ published by the Seeger & Guernsey Co. of this city. The firm have now made a Spanish edition of the work, in which the indice de tos arttculos alone fills nearly a hundred pages. The undertaking is one that makes for peace as the McKinley tariff makes for war. Mr. Cleveland is quoted in a testimonial as saying of this Cyclopedia that ‘‘ its contents ought to stir the pride of every American, and suggest to him that our industries are no longer infantile.” This ex- pression is much within bounds, With other college catalogues, those of Har- vard and Yale come to us, full of significance of the training to be got at either institution, and with interesting differences in the scheme of display. Together with them we receive the Treasurer’s report of the Harvard Law School Association, which has made a_ prodigious growth during the past year, the accessions exceeding the first year’s membership as well as the accessions of all the intervening years put together, The Law School’s own member- stip, it appears—very likely propter hoc—has kept pace with the increase in the Association, whose total membership is now 1,612; more than half being credited to Massachusetts (643) and New York (222). Mr. Henry F. Waters’s ‘‘ Genealogical Glean- ings in England,” in the January issue of the New England Historical and Genealogical Register, are divided between Harvard Col- lege and Washington. The Hollis family, so conspicuous for munificence among the early benefactors of the College, is here presented in the wills of several generations ; and there is a good body of testamentary and other evi- dence concerning Lawrence Washington the emigrant, which serves to fix the date of his coming over to Virginia. The Washington connection, also, of Sandyses and Spencers is developed at some length with satisfactory re- sults. Mr. John Ward Dean adds his interest- ing discovery concerning Roger Whilliams’s first love and rejected suit which has been al- ready made known to our readers, Thethirty- second paper of the Rev. George M. Bodge’s exhaustive researches relative to the ‘‘ Soldiers in King Philip’s War” begins a general review of the events of that war. He thus binds to- gether the several narratives in which the personnel and the fortunes of each company have been set forth. Those who are interested pro or con in the American origin of ‘Mother Goose Melodies ’ will find in the Boston Commonwealth of De- cember 27, 1890, a return to the subject on the part of Mr. W. H. Whitmore, clinching, if pos- sible, his negative argument already elaborated
Page 17
PR Sih os : Raila AES Fest He Soes pM mae ESSE AS SAD ee tel Jan. 8. 1891] The Nation. in his curious volume published by Joel Mun- sell’s Sonsin Albany. A letter from the most effective promoter of the American legend, the late William A. Wheeler, is the chief fea- ture of the article. The second paper on “ The Preludes of Har- per’s Ferry—John Brown, Guerrilla,” appears in the Andover Review for January. From a note-book of the Kansas period it reproduces memoranda of the effect produced on John Brown by the reading of Stocqueler’s Life of Wellington, particularly in what relates to the Peninsular campaign and the operations of the Spanish guerrillas. The rest of the paper is supplementary to Sanborn’s narrative in the Life of Brown. President Gilman of Johns Hopkins opens the new Educational Review, edited by Prof. Nicholas Murray Butler (New York: Henry Holt & Co,.), with a brief article on the Short ening of the College Curriculum,” mostly in the nature of a summary, but with the sugges- tion that the beginning of college life be brought back to an earlier age—sixteen for the average student. There are four other leading articles, by William T. Harris, Josiah Royce, Andrew S. Draper, and Charles De Garmo; Discussions, as on coeducation in Boston, the Bennett Law in Wisconsin, ete ; Editorials, and Reviews. The Review is attractively printed. Teachers of the classics and all students of educational systems and methods will be in terested in a new German magazine, which the recent widespread discussion of proposed re- forms in the curriculum cf the gymnasia has called into existence. The quarterly is enti- tled Das Humanistische Gymnasium, and is edited by Director Uhlig of the Heidelberg Gymnasium and published by Carl Winter in Heidelberg, at a yearly subscription of two marks, Dr. Uhlig is known among educa- tionists through bis syllabus of the courses of the study in the various German gymnasia and other pedagogical writings, andto Hellen- ists by his work in the Greek grammarians, in particular his edition of Dionysios Thrax. At the recent educational congress in Berlin he was one of the most prominent figures. The magazine represents in general the cause of gradual and cautious reform of existing in- stitutions as against the proposals of radical change and overthrow. It will contain full re- ports of current discussions and of educational conferences, as well as original papers by the leading educators of Germany. A remittance of sixty cents will cover subscription and postage. Petermann's Mitteilungen for December con- tains the closing part of Prof, Ratzel’s sum- mary of the scientific results of the Stanley expedition, and a paper on the rainfall of Europe, Western Asia, and Northern Africa, with four maps showing the amount at each of the four seasons of the year. An interest- ing indication of the variety and extent of the geographical literature of the past year is given in the index to the notices of books and papers on geographical subjects which have appeared in the scientific serials. number of notices is 2,475, of which 525 are of a general character, including histories of geography and biographies of travellers. Of the remainder, 753 are devoted to Europe alone; Africa having but 408, and America following a close third, with 391. Australia and Polynesia are fourth with 175, and Asia is fifth with only 118. This comparatively small number is probably to be explained, not by lack of interest, but by the difficulties and dangers still attending explorers in the remote regions of that continent. There were sixty The whole 33 notices of works and papers on the oceans, and forty-seven on the Polar regions, The second winter meeting of the Geological Society of America, recently beld in Washing- ton, Was an even greater success than the first meeting a year ago in New York. The at- tendance included representative men from all sections of the country, although the geolo gists of the National Survey naturally made a large part of the number present. The papers read were generally of excellent quality, aod promise a large and valuable volume of buile tins for the coming year. It is difficult to select a few titles from the large number for brief mention; but all who were present must certainly recall with especial interest and plea- sure the reports by Mr. Hayes on two peculiar- ly complex Appalachian overthrusts in Geor- gia, and by Mr. Russell on bis explorations last summer among the mountains and glaciers of Alaska. The summer meeting of the Nociety will be again in Washington, falling between the sessions of the American Association for the Advancement of Science and the Interna tional Geological Congress, Mr. A. F. Ernst writes to us from Water- town, Wis.. of a recent controversy in these columns: “* You allow the Missouri Lutherans to be attacked in the Nation in a manner so incorrect and unjust that I must believe ‘ An- dover’ to be a personal enemy of them. And your readers must believe that the Missourians are the Lutherans, That is all wrong. In ovr Central Committee, consisting of fifteen mem- bers, there were just two so-called Missourians ; and though they helped us as much as all the rest, they neither led nor originated the move- ment.” A serious typographical error made us say last week that the annual fee of membership in the American Dialect Society is ten dollars, whereas it is but one dollar. The Secretary's addresz, we will repeat, is Mr. E. S. Sheldon, No, 27 Hurlbut Street, Cambridge, Mass In the same unlucky paragraph, ‘biographies’ was printed for * bibliographies” —The Aflantic opans the vear with a light travel-paper, the first of a series, describing the journey of the author, Mr. Percival Low ell, to Noto, an outlying provinee of Japan The present sketch does not take him to his destination, but narrates the incidents of the way, and paints the scenery with that delight t } ne in the people and the country which is common charm of all who are now writing on thesubject. Mr. Lowell differs from the rest mainly by putting more of himself into the page and never being dull, though it must be said that his intellectual vivacity or nimble- mindedness sometimes becomes acrobatic. The remainder of the number is somewhat heavily packed with serious matter. Two articles upon education are of interest, but particular- ly the plea, by Cleveland Abbe, for courses in terrestrial physics in the universities Che state of our knowledge about the subject is set forth and the lines of immediate investigation are pointed out, with so much detail that the paper i i scientific periodicals Prof. Rovece’s account s really of the sort usually found in of Hege is also a novelt pic, out ¢ f the com mcn course of the general reader's opportun)- ties to enrich his knowledge; but it cannot be said that the expositor has succeeded in bring- ing Hegel within the reach of popular compre bension—he is as obstinately metaphysical and recondite as ever. There are two political articles, one on Boulangism, the other on the } a i€@SSo0n Of the recent election in Pennsvivania, by Mr. Henry C. Lea, on which we commented the means by which the State may exert some control over railway-strikes and other labor contests is contributed by Mr. Charles Worcester Clark, whose discussions of public questions we have before bad occasion to re commend to our readers The temperateness of the view taken is, in this a+ in the other instances, a striking characteristic. His dis cussion of the penalties to be imposed in case n is perhaps the most suggestive, as it certainly is the most dif- of the rejection ¢ f arbitrats ticult, part of the paper —The Century brings the long-awaited Tal- leyrand memoirs in the rather unsatisfactory shape of excerpts Minister Reid furnishes an introduction, which ts not a remarkable per formance, The memoirs themselves, in this in- stalment, deal with Tallevrand’s childhhow!, and part of his life through the time of his wisit to America. The principal persons especially mentioned are the Duke of Orleansaod Alexan ler Hamilton. The di-jointedness of the paper, however, with its parenthetical notices of what is omitted, is unfortunate and vexatious the reader; but whether the lack of vigor in the personal impression of Talleyrand ix due to this cause is uncertain It seems clear that the writer has passed over some of the salient points of his career with silence, The running comment on public policy and on his owns prin- ciples of action are tt most interesting portions, but the lack of portraiture and narrative is noticeable It appears likely however, that these memoirs will be an ad vantage to Talleyrand’s bistorical reputation, We must not pass over the shocking English of the translation, which is not only ungrammati- eal and slipshod, but full of French idioms and phrases often quite unintelligible What, for instance, does this mean?’ ‘She desired M. de Mercy to oppose the appointment of a French ; cardinal before the pr tion of the crowns Since then, m irndinal’s hat wa likely to have spent a few years in French for- tresses’ The second main subject in the num- occasion of two The Thi- betan journey goes on, with no great vivacily ber is California, which is the les and several pieces of ana in thie chapter, among the Mongols of the Azure Lake Oc ave Thanet contributes a very interesting picture of the Irish famine from the papers of an ‘Irish gentlewoman”™ ; ard not altogether out of barmony with this is the sketch of the estates and country houses of the planters of the Lower James, with some bisterically valuable cuts of architecture and nteriors \ fine portrait of Saint-Gaudens Cox is the artistic feature of the number, and with it goes a eulogistic sketch lhe war is represented by a j reminiscences of ‘* Mor- gan’s Rough Riders” by participants in the events narrated Mr. Gosse writes in the Forum of the probable future of poetry; and though the question has been much debated, he restates He dis- abuses the reader at once of the notion that some phases of it with cleverness, popular interest in verse is any sign of present A great genius may be unnoticed by his contempora- ries, and, on the other hand, many an inferior writer has been the laureate of the age. The reaily new condition in the present is obvious- ly the competition which our poets are forced to bear from the whole body of the dead. Un- til within the last half-century, the public read but the antiquarian excellence or future productivity. the writers of its time ; interest that has resulted in supplying us with editions of the poets of every English reign, last week. A very thoughtful examination of and countless volumes of selections, has made
Page 18
84
The Nation. [Vol. 52, No. 133
the struggle of new writers for recognition more difficult than in the case of the Eliza- bethans, the eighteenth-century poets, or even the Romanticists of this century. Mr. Gosse foretells a reaction and a coming intolerance of these older works; but, on his own theo ry that recognition does not affect the ap- pearance of original genius, this wider competition should have no effect, ex- cept by discouraging new poets, and dis- couragemert has frequently given the true poet only a sweeter and more piercing note. In forecasting the probable course of the verse of the next age, Mr. Gosse intimates that it will succeed more by matter than manner, that it will take the form of narrative in highly de- veloped rhyme and music, discarding blank verse; that it will revive the drama (a dream which others indulge, and which will come true if it is beld long enough); and that it will be ‘‘ very bare and direct, unembroidered, per- haps even arid in character,” and ‘‘ experi- mental rather than descriptive, human rather than animal.” He does not look for any re- version to didacticism, but nevertheless holds that there is much in the gathered stores of modern knowledge that issues in spiritual moods, and in hopes and fears for which only poetry can provide expression; and he antici- pates a special characteristic impressed by the democratic social movement. He is, after all, an interested rather than inspired prophet, and deals with the convenient may-be, not the shall*be of thorough conviction. Meanwhile the muse keeps her counsel, with <jaite the taciturnity of nature, according to her ancient wont, —The movement for ‘university exten- sion” marks the progress of the democratic ideal in education. An indication of the vigor of this movement in America comes to us in the Constitution and Circular of the ‘‘ Univer- sity and €chool Extension.” This association, a sort of Chautauqua of higher grade, designs ‘*to supplement and to strengthen the univer- sity and the school systems; to increase the culture and to promote the interests of teach- ers as members of a profession; and to advance and extend the knowledge of letters and of the arts and sciences,” The Executive Committee of the University Extension Faculty consists of Presidents Dwight, Patton, and Low; Dr. W. T. Harris, United States Commissioner of Education; Norman A. Calkins, and Seth T. Stewart. The President of the Board of Di- rectors is James W. Alexander, represent- ing Princeton College: and the Vice-Presi- dents are Chauncey M. Depew, represent- ing Yale; Charles S, Fairchild, Harvard; and W. Bayard Cutting, Columbia, The Society aims to be national in character. State and local societies are to be formed as auxiliaries, The constitution provides that “the Faculty of the University Extension shall consist of a president and professors ap- pointed by him from the universities and col- leges in the several States, on the nomination of their respective presidents, and, if deemed expedient, from among prominent specialists not professors of colleges. The four institu- tions [Harvard, Yale, Princeton, and Colum- bia]represented in the first organization of the University Extension shall be entitled to equal representation, and each State shall be entitled to at least one member in the Faculiy.” The means of instruction are ‘“‘ outlines for courses of study, class instruction, courses of lectures, correspondence, examinations, etc.” Sylla- buses haye already been prepared in Lan- guage, English Literature, History, and Sci- ence. Among the specialists who have pre- ¢
pared these outlines are Profs. Child, Mac- vane, Kittredge, and Shaler of Harvard; Ladd, Peck, and Seymour of Yale; Young of Prince- ton, and Theodore Dwight of Columbia. Other syllabuses are in process of publication. —What the English have done in this di rection has been told in the address recently given in Washington and Boston by Prof. R. G. Moulton of the University of Cambridge. Prof, Moulton, we believe, is one of the com mittee appointed by that university, in con- nection with Oxford, to have charge of this work, and, having given nearly all his time to it for fifteen years, not only as manager, but directly as lecturer, believes enthusiastically in its value, both as bringing learning within reach of the hundreds or thousands of adults already longing for it, and in spreading among a larger class a knowledge of possibilities in the way of education of which they had no idea; and, above all, for the reflex action upon the teaching body of the universities derived from their vicarious contact with the people through the university lecturers. Then, if we consider lectures as a means of education ra- ther than of amusement, the superiority of the English system as compared with our so-called lyceum lectures is obvious, Again, a most im- portant feature is that each course (of twelve lectures) is given to one subject—not Tennyson this week, Astronomy next, and Nihilism after that. As compared even with course lectures, such as those of the Lowell Institute, in this country, the English system has great advan- tages, first, in the application of the princi- ple that the lecturer’s business is not to give instruction (this being done by authorities named in the printed syllabus of the course), but to create or to stimulate the desire to learn; and, by means of the hour “class” held before the lecture, to exert personal influence and, incidentally, to get at the particular wants of the audience, —A valuable aid to the student of mo- dern German literature is Max Koch’s select edition of Karl Immermann’s * Werke’ in four volumes (Stuttgart: Spemann, 1890), issued as numbers 159 and 160 of Kiirschner’s ‘‘ Deutsche Nationalliteratur.” Immermann was unques- tionably a poet of superior, although essential- ly imitative, talent. His dramas, even when they represent scenes from contemporary life, are all patterned after some model—Shakspere, Calderon, Goethe, Schiller, or other typical author, whom he happened to be studying; as reading they are not especially animating, and have proved utterly ineffective on the stage. The same holds true, in a great measure, of his imaginative prose writings. The influence of ‘ Wilhelm Meister’ is traceable on every page of ‘Die Epigonen,’ which, in turn, had sufficient vitality and plastic force in it to in- spire and shape the earlier romances cf Gutz- kow, Freytag, and Spielhagen. The only pro- duction of Immermann’s that is an independent and really original creation is ‘ Miinclhausen,’ the best part of which, andindeed the only part that can be enjoyed and fully appreciated by the reader of to-day, is the charming episode of Westphalian peasant life, now published separately under the title of ‘ Der Oberhof.’ ‘ Miinchhausen’ proper is not only the persiflage of an impecunious and unprincipled Junker- thum or squirarchy, but also a satire on all the social, political, and literary tendencies of the time, in caricaturing which the author en- ters into details familiar only to a few of his contemporaries, and utterly forgotten by the present generation. Dr. Max Koch, in his an- notations to ‘ Miinchhausen,’ has taken great pains to follow out and explain the drift of these
obscure allusions, and has thus provided the work with acommentary which in fulness and accuracy leaves nothing to be desired. It is a monument of literary industry; whether the game was worth the candle or not is another question. It is certain, however, that no one who wishes nowadays to read ‘ Miinchbausen’ and understand it, can do so without Koch’s edition, NICOLAY AND HAY’S LINCOLN.—II. Abraham Lincoln; A History. By John G. Nicolay and John Hay. 10 vols, 8vo, New York: The Century Co. In military matters the cautious but steady progress of Mr. Lincoln towards asserting himself was interestingly marked. He evi- dently began with the idea that the art and mystery of military strategy was the result of lopg and laborious education. But contact with Scott dnd McDowell and McClellan and Meigs and Franklin soon taught him that its professors widely differed among themselves. He read authoritative treatises, and found that nothing over which so much noise bas been made is in fact so simple. Toknow where your enemy is, how strong he is, and to learn the theatre of operations as if you had lived in it and hunted over it from childhood—these are the elements out of which a courageous heart and cool head solves the rest of the problem by striking your forte against his faible. By the opening of 1862 he thoroughly understood this, and never forgot it. His criticisms of his ge- nerals in the Virginia campaigns go straight tothe mark. They pierce through all assump- tions of unuttered military wisdom.and mys- terious plan. His letter to McClellan giving details of a proposed movement from Antie- tam in October, 1862, showed that he was as familiar with the mountain gaps of Virginia as with the street-crossings around the White House. It simply demonstrated the success of the movement if it were pushed with vigor. Indeed, it was the fashion, before it wasknown that Lincoln was its author, to argue, in cer- tain circie:, that its excellence proved the sin- gular capacity of McClellan as a general and the singular incapacity of the Administration that removed him. We now know that Lin- coln resolved on the removal because the plan was not executed as it demonstrably might have been. In dealing with matters at a distance the President sometimes misjudged ; but no worse than Halleck and his other advisers. Few people could make a very good guess at the distance, say, from Calcutta to Hong Kong in a straight line. We are used to maps of foreign parts on a small scale, and we have no ready uvit of measurement when we think of the few inches on the map. The authorities at Washington in the fall of 1863 seemed to think Burnside could move from the Watauga River on the confines of East Tennessee and Virginia to Chattanooga, or that Sherman could march from Memphis to Rosecrans’s assistance, with about the same ease that a division could march from Washington to Bull Run or to the Rappahannock at furthest. Few were will- ing to make the effort to learn what breadth of country and what mountain chains and rivers lay within the scope of the little space they covered on the common map. Indeed, we may doubt if such an effort is ever tho- roughly made by anybody less painstaking than an officer of the German General Staff. It was not strange, then, that Mr. Lincoln should sometimes slip on the topography of distant regions. He was equal to any one about him in his comprehension of the military : ; 4 eet Sg ort een PREC Heap RS viet Si
Page 19
y 4 3 “ sad ARS Sas EF eee Oe Nica ae a ee TE Neal GIBBS Hokies ee a ee en nee Jan. 8, 1891] The Nation. problem and the proper methods, in general, for its solution. In reading the history of the time we cannot help wishing that Mr. Lincoln had sometimes put his military suggestions in the form of imperative orders. He so often and so plainly pointed out the right thing to do, that the command to do it was the only appropriate conclusion for the despatch. Halleck was less suggestive and more unwilling to assume re- sponsibility than the President. His maxim that a general in command of an army must not be ordered to move or to attack, was the cause of many a fiasco. When Longstreet was going to reinforce Bragg in September, 1863, and Meade was unwilling to attack Lee’s reduc- ed forces unless ordered to do so, not togive the order was to abdicate the position of general- in-chief of the army. Mr. Lincoln might well hesitate to command when he found Halleck so set against it, but he was sometimes forced to intervene peremptorily, and the fullest knowledge of the facts which we can now get justifies the wish that he had done so oftener. After the progress of the war had developed in Grant, Sherman, and Sheridan commanders whose energy needed no prompting, Mr. Lin- coln showed his modest self-poise by with- drawing from active effort to influence their action; but from first to last his grasp of the military situation was quite as clear and strong asthat of any of his professional ad- visers. In dealing with his generals in high com- mand, Mr. Lincoln was patient, sympathetic, and free (too free, if anything) from the as- sumption of power or control. He saw the weaknesses of men, and was tclerant of them because he doubted whether things would be bettered by change in commanders. No one ever acted more constantly upon the rule that it is ‘‘ better to bear the ills we have than fly to others that we know not of.” With this was curiously blended a deference to assumed pub- lic opinion, in the army or in the country, which sometimes looked like want of proper self-confidence. There was no need of re- moving McDowell after the first battle of Bull Run. Scott was stiil general-in-chief, and eve- rybody now knows, what the President then knew, that the tactical handling of the army on the field had been good and the disaster was not the fault of McDowell. A brief procla- mation saying so, and appealing to the peo- ple to be patient, would, as it now looks, have been met with an encouraging response. In a similar way, after the second defeat on that field, he knew and declared that Pope had done all that could be expected of him. It was understood that Halleck was to take the field with McClellan and Pope as his immediate sub- ordinates when the Army of the Potomae landed at Alexandria. A Presidential com- mand was needed to overcome Halleck’s in- ertia. Had it been given, the services of both the younger men might have been continued to the advantage of the country. But though Mr. Lincoln gave to Pope a strong written ap- proval of what he had done, a popular clamor was supposed to make a necessity for retiring him from active service. It looks again as if Mr. Lincoln had underestimated the influence he could exert upon pubiic opinion by taking the country into his confidence through a few earnest words, In dealing with those in high command, he had not only been personally kind and patient, he had ignored political preferences and party politics, In making subordinate military ap- pointments and promotions, he did not disguise the fact that political influences were power- ful. Ap example which his biographers have brought into renewed prominence by their ef- fort to prove him always ideaily right, is typi- cal, not only of his methods and his stand- point, but also, we are sorry to say, of the manner in which Messrs, Nicolay and Hay deal with facts when they stand in the way of their theory. The case is that of Gen. Sher- man’s celebrated protest against certain pro- motions made in his army, during the Atlanta campaign, without consulting him. The biographers say: (1L.) ‘“*regarded Washington with whimsical hor- rorasa sink of corruption and iniquity, and thought that no good could come out of it.” (2) ‘“* This prepessession sometimes had ludi- crous results,” ¢. g., (3.) Osterhaus was made a major-general, and Sherman wrote on July 25 an angry despatch to Washington saying, ‘* If the rear be the post of honor, then we had better all change front on Washington.” (4.) ‘This despatch was shown to the President, who, instead of resenting its tone of disrespect That Sherman and insubordination, wrote in his kindliest and calmest manner a letter to Gen. Sherman, in which he informed him that the promotion of Osterhaus had made upon written re commendations from less trustworthy sources than Gens. Grant and Sherman,” « ¢., at the close of the Vicksburg campaign of tle preceding year. (5.) That these recommenda- tions had ‘*somewhat faded” from Sherman's mind. (6) That Sherman “frankly acknow- ledged his error, and repeats in his Memoirs that he was ‘fairly caugbt.’” (7.) That ‘‘ the Government bore him no malice for this inci- dent. They continued to comply heartily with every request be made.” (S.) ‘‘ They even offered him, voluntarily, eight promotions to the grade of tributed on his recommendation among the most meritorious colonels of his command.” (9.) “It is curiously characteristic of the General that in his Memoirs he attributes this proof of signal favor to the Osterbaus letter.” We must examine a little_in detail this *‘cu- riously characteristic’ statement. (L.) Sherman had advised Halleck and Grant that the vicinity of Washington was a perilous place for a general because of the facility for intrigues by subordinates and by the political “influences” thera. The ex,erience of Me Clellan, Burnside, Hooker, and Meade had, each in turn, demonstrated it, and every writer of bistory, including the biographers, had noted it. The ‘* whimsical horror” must therefore be put in the category of rhetorical depreciation for the sake of making the rest of the case easier. (2.) The present case could only be * ludi- crous” to those who have no glimmering of the conditions of good military administra- tio». To others it bas been the reverse. 3.) There were two brigadiers promoted, not one. Sherman's Memoirs say they were ‘ Gen- erals Osterbaus and Alvan P. Hovey.” Sher- ruan’s reason, which be repeated in his despatch to the President of July 27, was that ‘* they bad gone to the rear—the one (Hovey) offended because | could not unite in the same division five infantry and five cavalry regiments, and the other (Osterbaus) for temporary sickness,” The “ offended” officer had, of course, either asked to be relieved or tendered his resigna- tion, and the papers were officially forwarded to Washington. The omission of the graver case by the biographers tends to belittle Sher- man’s position. 4) The despatch was addressed to Col. Har- die, Inspector-General, and Sterman bad no idea that the President would see it, or know more of it than that he regarded the promotions been no brigadier-general to be dis- ” . 35 as ‘‘an act of injustice to officers who stand be their posts in the day of danger.” (5) Sherman had not forgotten his former othera There recommendations of these or were recommendations for promotion dating from Vicksburg, not only, but from Stone's River, Chickamauga, Missionary Ridge, Knox ville, that were not acted upon. The time and circumstances of the selection made the cause of complaint. It was, or ought to have been, an understood condition of promotion, under old recommendations, that there should be continued meritorious conduct down to the time of confirming the new grade. Sherman's complaint was that the case was the oppocite of this. He knew, too (what the biograpbers are too familiar with the War Department re cords to bave overlooked), that at that very time captains and lieutenants were being sum marily dismissed the army for tendering their resignations when their commands were in the presence of the enemy. (6.) Sherman confessed no error in the mat Lincoln that the ter. He simp!y assured Mr despatch was not meant for his eye, and that be had loval confidence in the President, On the other band, be repeated, in more measured phrase, every assertion be bad made, and said to Mr. Lincoin himself; ** ldo think you will admit that their promotion was enough to occasion disappointment.” The words ‘fairly caught” in his Memoirs oniy ** fairly ” mean that his sense of humor recog nized Mr. Lincoln's good-natured and ‘“‘cha racteristic’’ use of the adroit argumentum ad hominem, (7) Mr and just to His answer to Sherman (which is not the History) obliged to make military promecetions under po- litical ‘‘ influences.” It was a formal apology for what be had done, and we honor his memory best by earnestly believing that he Lincoln was far too clear-sighted ‘bear malice” when the error was his own. he felt given in confessed that the teachableness that we admire so much His biogra- phers do not seem to appreciate the facts they narrate; for they themselves, in another place, laid the lesson to heart with in bim. have repeated the rather hackneyed but always successful jest about the boy throwing a stone at random in Washington city and hitting three brigadiers seeking promotion, when it was not a very good day in Washington for brigadiers, either. (A) When the eight promotions of colonels were put at the nomination of Sherman, he named them onthe recommendation of division, corps, and army commanders, for gallant and meritorious services in the campaign ; and in bis Memoirs heemphasizes the advantage to the army of making promotions in this way and not the other. it must not be forgotten, however, that the Administration did nof, witb these, offer him, ‘‘ voluntarily ” or other- wise, any promotions to the rank of major- general ; those had been already disposed of, as we have seen, 9) The connection between the correspond- ence and the authority to name elght colo- nels for promotion is this; The despatches were all telegraphic. Sherman’s protest to Col Hardie was dated July 25, 1863 ; Mr. Lin- coln’s answer is dated 26th ; Sherman’s reply is dated 27th ; and the authority to promote is dated 28th. We believe the biographers will stand alone in imputing it to vanity in Sher- man that he connected the action of the 28th with the correspondence of the 25th, 26th, and 27th. It would be very difficult, in so narrow a compass, to find so many examples of what history ought not to be, It might well serve
Page 20
36 The Nation. [Vol. 52, No. 1332 asa Seminar exercise for university students testing history, according to modern methods, in original sources, We are obliged, however, to repeat that it is typical. There is hardly a prominent name of the great war period that is not subjected to a similar process of belit- tling by innuendo, and of condemning by half- statement or by distorted statement of facts. Seward, Chase, Stanton, Bates, the Blairs, Wade, Winter Davis, Greeley, all foremost men in the Administration party, suffer in this way. Their moments of weakness are made the criterion of their characters, and the anec- dotes which put them in an unfavorable light are those by which we are asked to judge. This depreciation is systematic and persistent. Each is treated to perfunctory praise for pat- riotism and ability, and each in turn is pic- tured in the concrete as unworthy of the praise. It would often be as easy to expose the injustice of this as in the example of Sher- man. It will, of course, be gradually done. The epoch was too important, and the interest of the country in her foremost citizens is too great, to let any partial view stand for the his- tory of the time. The thing chiefly to be re- gretted is that Lincoln, who needs no such be- littling of others to stand as the central figure among his contemporaries, should have his memory thus linked to any wrong to them. This criticism applies only to what may be called Lincoln’s personal relations to other men. Frequently recurring as such passages are, they area small part of the book. The great current of events, both civiland military, is pictured with vividness and with success. The standpoint of a writer must always affect his view, but, in the general way of which we are now speaking, the estimate of events and of men, of campaigns and of generals, is fair and able. No one who has strong and well- defined opinions will find his views always in accord with the writers, but he will differ no oftener than he would with any other his- torians. In trying to picture Mr. Lincoln as he lived, the modern methcds of physical portraiture come happily in to give satisfaction to our realistic tendencies. The publishers have pro- vided a dozen excellent reproductions of pho- tographs, of paintings, and of statuary. The invention of Daguerre often gives us a hard- ened caricature of a man with no soul in it, Such photographs are worse than death-masks. But the hardest subject is sometimes caught in happy moments, and out of vast numbers of repellent pictures we may find some that help us to understand the person. Among these of Mr. Lincoln several help us to see the wisdom and the charity, the shrewdness and the friend- liness, the clear intellect and the latent will that inhabited his homely form. The frontis- piece to the first volume is a satisfactory pre- sentation of the man that was nominated in 1860. The life-mask taken at the same time is strong, with grave prophecy in its lines of the statesman grappling with his task. The picture taken from the photo- graph of the group in front of McClellan’s tent at Antietam shows him towering, like Saul, above other men, while it is thoroughly cha- racteristic in its pose and its slight stoop. The sitting picture of Lincoln and his son “ Tad,” with its not ungraceful repose and its uncon- scious dignity, appeals to everybody. The life-mask of 1865 is strong and pathetic, show- ing a great man who in four years has passed from iron vigor to waning age, but still fit to be the Nestor of his people. The illustrations have been judiciously re stricted to portraits of men who have some prominence in the narrative, very few of any ? other sort being retained. They make a gal- lery worthy of study as types of race and cha- racter, apart from their connection with the story. TREES OF NORTH AMERICA. The Silva of North America; a Description of the Trees which Grow naturally in North America, exclusive of Mexico. By Charles Sprague Sargent, Director of the Arnold Arboretum of Harvard University. Illus- trated with figures and analyses drawn from nature by Charles Edward Faxon, and en- graved by Philibert and Eugéne Picart. Volume I. Magnoliacese-lliciness. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co. 1890. Large quarto, pp. ix., 119, tt. 50. MicHavUx published his ‘ Histoire des Arbres Forestiers de l’Amérique Septentrionale’ in 1810-13. The work was in three quarto vol- umes, and contained one hundred and forty- five colored plates, while the number of species of trees described was one hundred and fifty- five. Some years later an English translation was published at Philadelphia; and three ad- ditional volumes by Thomas Nuttall contained one hundred and twenty-two plates, with de- scriptions of nearly as many trees, some of them from Florida and others from the Rocky Mountain region and the Pacific Coast. There was a still later edition also. These books, with Emerson’s ‘ Trees of Massachusetts,’ were for many years the chief available works for the student of American trees; for Lambert’s magnificent ‘ Description of the Genus Pinus’ is so rare and costly that few Americans have ever even seen it. Government reports have described some of the trees of the Pacific Coast, and the various Floras of different sections of the country have given brief accounts of the trees of their respective districts ; but there was no systematic account of the whole silva of the United States, no one work in which one could find figured and described the sequoias of California, the hickories of the East, and the palms of Florida. Prof. Sargent was charged with the task of making a report on the forests of North Ame- rica for the Tenth Census. To do this he visited all portions of the country, collecting specimens of all the trees he could find— leaves, flowers, fruit, wood, and bark—and making notes on their habit, distribution, uses, cultivation, abundance, and destruction. He also availed himself of the observations and collections made by many able assistants and correspondents. His report forms the ninth volume of the final report on the Tenth Census, He found not less than four hundred and twelve different kinds of woody plants which attain the dignity of trees. After enumerating them, with full references to their biblio- graphy, he gave tables of the specific gravity, and of the resistance to compression and trans- verse strains of the different kinds of wood, and concluded with a review of the economic aspects of the forests of the United States, Having finished this work for the nation, he has now undertaken to provide a complete botanical account of all the native trees of the United States and British America. Apart from his other qualifications for this work— and these all botanists know are of avery high order—his long experience as Director of the Arnold Arboretum and his work in preparing his census report have made him preéminently the proper person to write the long-needed new North American Silva. In the choice of an artist to illustrate his work, he has been very fortunate. Mr. Faxon’s drawings of ten years ago, were highly appreciated, and it is now evident that he has so far perfected himself as a botanical draughtsman that he may be fairly considered in this regard the peer of Sprague and Fitch. His work in the present volume compares favorably with that of Latour and Vivian in the ‘ Flora Jave.’ If a little stiffness is now and then perceptible in his drawings, it is more than counterbal- anced by the accuracy of the abundant details of structure which accompany all the plates, Under the direction of the celebrated Riocreux Mr. Faxon’s drawings have been engraved with sympathetic care and artistic nicety, and the result is worthy of the highest praise. The publishers’ circular puts the number of trees to be described in this work at 422, indi- cating an addition of ten species since the cen- sus report was printed. We are informed that Mr. Faxon has already finished the drawings for the entire work, 600 in all, having devoted the last eight years to the task. The engrav- ings for three volumes are already made, and it isthe purpose of the publishers to issue two volumes a year until the whole work, consist- ing of twelve volumes, is completed. When this is done, the silva of no other country will have been so amply described as ours. Perhaps the second place in this respect will belong to New Zealand, for the Colonial Government has recently published a sumptuous folio volume on the forest-flora of those islands, But the 142 plates of that work, though carefully drawn, are only lithographs, and cannot be compared to these excellent copper-plate engravings. Dr. T. Kirk, the writer of the New Zealand ‘Forest- flora,’ it may be saidin passing, has not con- fined himself to a botanical account of each species, but has devoted much space to the va- rious economic uses of each kind of tree. The first volume of the ‘ Silvaof North Ame- rica’ contains the descriptions and illustrations of thirty-four trees, beginning with the genus Magnolia, and following the usual sequence of natural orders through the holly family (Jli- cinew). Out of the twenty known species of magnoiia, six are found in the United States, two in Mexico, and the rest are natives of Asia, One of the finest of them all is the Himalayan Magnolia Campbellii, which is figured in Hooker and Cathcart’s ‘ Illustrations of Himalayan Plants.’ ‘This tree is often eighty feet high, and has a trunk four or five feet thick; the leaves are large, but deciduous, and the great flowers vary in color from white to deep rose-color or almost crimson; they open all over the branchlets in April, while the tree is yet leafless, Our own great magnolia is scarcely less in stature, and has thick and shining evergreen leaves and “‘ deliciously fra- grant creamy-white flowers seven or eight inches across when fully expanded,” so that it is a question which of the two species is the finest of the genus. The six North American species are given by Prof. Sargent as Magno- lia fetida, M. glauca, M. acuminata, M. ma- crophylla, M. tripetala, and M. Frasert. The first name is proposed instead of M. grandiflora, by which designation the most beautiful tree of the Southern States has been known since 1762, Botanists of conservative views in regard to nomenclature, and all per- sons of good taste who are not botanists, must regard it as singularly unfortunate that Prof. Sargent should feel it necessary to reject a name so fitting and so long recognized as grandiflora, and substitute for it the inappro- priate and unseemly appellation faetida, His reasons for the change were given in Garden and Forest, ii, p. 615. It seems that Lin- neeus at first supposed all our magnolias to be ferns in ‘the Ferns of North America,’ some of one species, and to that he gave the name of
Page 21
pies cee nitrates wie Ee tte 8 a GBB fhe Jan. 8, 1891] fhe Wation, M. Virginiana, describing the several forms as varieties, and this tree was called M. Vir- gintana, var. fetida, in‘ Species Plantarum,’ ed. i. (1753). Nine or ten years later, when the great Swedish botanist had learned more about American trees, he distinguished four kinds of magnolia as species, naming them M. grandi- flora, M. glauca, M. acuminata, and M. tripe- tala, dropping the name Virginiana alto- gether, and substituting for the first of his newly recognized species the name grandiflora, as being more suitable than fwfida, It is now claimed that having once uttered in print the word ftida, Linnewus could never recall it, even though it was proposed as the epithet of a supposed variety, and not as the name of a species! This is enforcing the mcdern law of priority with a vengeance, and gives it a retro- active effect which our national Constitution denies to civil and criminal law. Linneus seems to have confessed that in ignorance he had used an ill-chosen expression, for he re- placed it by an unobjectionable name. Is it not reasonable to accept his implied apology and adopt the amendment? Surely the great majority of well-advised naturalists will say yes, and this almost peerless tree shall still have an honorable name in botanical science. Even to meet the distinguisbed author of this book on his own ground, which is ‘* the method which imposes on a plant . . . the oldest specific name used by Linnzeus in the tirst edi- tion of his ‘Species Plantarum,’ or by any subsequent author,” it is pertinent to object that Linnzeus did not employ this offensive word as a specific name, and to ask why the Linnwan specific name Virginiana was not used for some one of the species which it at first included. The sweet bay (Magnolia glauca) extends its range further to tbe northeast than any other American species of the genus, for it has long been known in a certain swamp in Glou- cester, Mass.; and although the trees are fast being destroyed or removed into gardens, yet we learn from Prof. Robinson that there are still one or two less accessible swamps in Essex County where the tree grows in comparative security. Next to the magnolias comes the tulip-tree (Liriodendron Tulipifera), one of the three largest trees of the forests of the Atlantic States. As Magnolia is a genus common to Eastern North America and Eastern Asia, so Liriodendron occurs in China as well as in the United States, But in this case the identity is specific, for it is cur own tulip-tree that gives its shade to the Celestials. This genus, though now monotypic, was represented during the Cretaceous age by several species, both in America and in Europe. More than a dozen of the ancient tulip-trees are described by pa- leophytologists, and it seems strange that while none survive in Europe, a solitary species should exist to-day in such widely separated lands as China and our east- ern coast. Mr. Theodor Holm of Wash- ington has very recently printed in the ‘Proceedings of the National Museum’ scme ‘*Notes on the Leaves of Liriodendron,” in which he endeavors to ascertain what was the form of leaf of the archetypal tulip-tree. Con- fessing the difficulty of coming to any conelu- sion, heis “not unwilling to suppose” that it was oblong or acuminate, and not very unlike the magnolia pattern. He also discusses the varia tion in shape of the leaves of the existing species, and compares the definitions given by different authors, He considers the four-lobed leaf the normal form, but mentions and figures leaves with two, six, and even eight lobes or teeth. In the ‘Silva’ only the normal four-lobed leaves are described, and no mention is made of the variant forms which may be found growing together on any good-sized tulip-tree; and yet, curiously enough, the specimen from which Mr. Faxon’s fine drawing was made has leaves with an extra lobe or tooth on each side. The papaw of the Middle States (Asimina triloba) and the pond-apple of Florida (Anona glabra) are the representatives of the custard- apple family, a family much more numerous in tropical countries than in our own. The fruit of our papaw is said to be edible, and at times even sweet and luscious; that of the pond-apple is insipid, though slightly aromatic. Two more Floridian wanderers from the tropics follow next, the Jamaican Capparis, and the wild cinaamon (Canella alba), the bark of which is used in medicine. Next are the two arborescent species of Gordonia, a genus not far from Camellia in botanical characters, and somewhat resembling it in general appearance, The loblolly bay (Gor donia Lasianthus) is common enough in Southern swamps, but will scarcely live north of Philadelphia. The other species (Gordonia Altamaha, or G. pubescens, as it has been more commonly called) is one of the few American trees, perhaps the only one, which is now unknown in a wild state, for though it is sometimes found in cultivation, both in our country and in Europe, it seems to have entire ly disappeared from its native haunts on the Altamaha River in Georgia, and it is nowa century since it was seen growing without cul tivation. Plate xxiii. is a good representation of a branch of a small Californian tree, discovered by Frémont in 1846, and named Fremontia Californica by Dr. Torrey in 1850. It is the only North American tree belonging to the same family with the gigantic ceiba (Arioden dron) of the West Indies. Three species of linden or basswood follow next, The first (Tilia Americana) is a common shade-tree in our streets, and is valued for its timber, which is soft, fine-grained, and easily worked into panels, tables, etc., or hollowed into the com- mon wooderware of our kitchens, The other two species, though beautiful trees, are too rare to be of any commercial importance, One of the trees yielding the exceedingly hard and heavy wood commonly called lignum-vitx (Guiacum sanctum) comes into southern Flori- da, and so bas a piace inthis ‘Silva.’ The specific name is thought to have been given to it on account of its supposed wonderful and even miraculous healing virtues Three south- ern species of prickly-ash (Xanthorylum) have their places next; then comes the hop-tree (Ptelea trifoliata), whose bitter fruits have been used at times as a substitute for hops Then follow several more less-known tropical trees of our southern peninsula, and on plates xliii and xliv. is represented the true ma- hogany grew in southern Florida so abundantly as to be cut for exportation, but at tbe present time is found only sparingly on two of the Keya The volume closes with the five arborescent species of holly. Swietenia Mahagent), which once rhe first of them (J/ex opaca is much like the holly of Europe, but lacks the brilliant polish of the upper surface of the It is very rare in southern New Eng- land, is tolerably common along the coast of leaves, New Jersey, and is more abundant southward to Florida and in the lower half of the Missis- sippi Valley. Its spiny-bordered leaves and red berries are gathered for sale about Christ- mas-time, and its beautiful and almost ivory- white wood is much used in cabinet-work and interior decoration. The botanical names of the Dahoon holly and the Yaupon or Cassens have been more or less confused ever since the time of Linnwus, who supposed them to be varieties of one species. Professor Sargent has chosen names for them in accordance with the method announced in the preface, but a variance with the preferences of most of his predecessors. The next volume will contain the maples, the buckeyes, and prebably the locust trees of various kinds, and will be eagerly watched for by all tree-loving enthusiasta This iatter class would have been gratified if the illustra- tions could have been so planned as to give portraits of imdividual trees of the different kinds, as well as faithful engravings of the leaves and flowers, and the details of floral and carpological structure, Emerson bas a few such portraits, notably the Charter Oak and the Northampton Elm A goal series of American tree-portraits will undoultedly come at some future time Garden and is amassing one in the way of photographie process prints, MOULTON'’S ANCIENT CLASSICAL, DRAMA The Ancient Classical Drama A Study in Literary Evolution. By Richard G. Mos ton. Oxford: Clarendon Press; New York Macmilian ISA) MR. Movuton’s book isa study of very ar t material from a novel and interesting point of view. It is perhaps a little alarming to be told in his preface th drama we see ‘‘ deve bryo and on to maturity—unstable forms that continually originate literary changes, rever sions to type, and survival of forms long after ' their raison d'éfre bas passed away; wh le the Drama as a whole will present the double pro cess of growth in simplicity from the indefi- nite to the regular, and the passage from the simple to the complex.” This language, which has a familiar if not seductive sound, shows that the writer bas saddled a theory which he rides hard and occasionally rides to death Yet there is undoubted truth in the basis of his investigation; and the larger part of his work bas, moreover, a wider and more prac- tical aim which should commend it to any student of literature drama from a purely literary standpoint, and it is adiressed to readers in English as well as It differs, therefore, from the ordiaary histories of the classical literatures, such as Mii ler’-, Mahaffvy’s, or Cruttwell’s, in that it assumes no acquaintance whatever with It presents the ancient in the original. the original languages, and omits largely from consideration the personal or biographical ele- ment, The author has shown skill and resource in the difficult task of introducing his untravelled reader to the flavor of the mangosteen. He does this the more successfully because his own work shows everywhere a fresh and im- mediate acquaintance with the original sources, He dwells with great variety of illustration on the difference between the ancient and the modern dramatic form and conception, and il- lustrates this by many felicitous comparisons, The structure of the choral ode, for instance, is instructively contrasted with that of the Psalms. The Phallic Procession, or Comus, in which comedy originated, is paralleled by the curious customs of the Cornish flower-dance, or “ Furry,” which is stil] kept up at Helstone on the 8th of May. ‘The transition from satire to satiric acting is explained by a sword-dance, partly lyric, partly dramatic, sti 1 practised in Northumberland, in which the performers at
Page 22
88 one time recite a ballad, and again act its con- tents. The fundamental differences between ancient and modern tragedy are strikingly brought out by a very ingenious version of ** Macbeth ” arranged as an ancient tragedy. In this arrangement we have all the Greek conventionalities—a permanent scene, the courtyard of Dunsinane Castle, a prologue spoken by Hecate, and a chorus consisting of aged clansmen of Macbeth; the physician of Lady Macbeth speaks a rhesis of the Euripi- dean order, and a messenger, a spy who has been with the British army, describes their approach and the incident of Birnam Wood. On hearing his story, Macbeth bursts out in the traditional trochaic metre: **Ho, mine armour—ring the alarum—give the cla- morous trumpets breath; Bid them speak from every quarter, harbingers of blood and death ! Hang our banners from the ramparts, to our king- dom’s utmost bound Horsemen ride, and yet more horsemen, let them skirr the country round.” This speech is the last of Macbeth’s crimes. His death, the battle, and the explanation of Macduff’s birth must be reported, in accord- ance with the limitations of the Greek stage, by the aid of an English prisoner and messen- gers. It must have required something of the British hardihood which does not quail before the composition of Greek iambics, to attempt this clever bit of work ; but it answers its pur- pose excellently, and it incidentally reminds us how fortunate we are that Shakspere belongs to us, and not to the age of Pericles, The effect of the varying metres, both in tragedy and comedy, and the shades of feeling represented by their transitions, are analyzed and presented with great fulness and an accu- racy which is remarkable, considering that technicalities are avoided and English versions are used exclusively for illustration. The va- rieties of dramatic motives and of the choral udes are described with clearness and detail, and the remarks on the contrasts between these and the modern drama are generally so sound and acute as to tempt one to quotation. We should question the suggestion that the ** Hippolytus” is an illustration of ‘artistic retribution,” and that its moral is the ne quid nimis even in temperance. The very state- ment sounds like an absurdity. We doubt, again, whether the Greeks of Pericles’s time thought of Admetus as a ‘‘ holy personage,” representing the ‘‘cause of the religion of hospitable splendor,” for which sacred cult and personage Alcestis naturally cffered her life. The dying speech of Alcestis gives not the slightest suprort to such a notion. The hospitality’ of Admetus is a good reason for the friendship of Apollo and Heracles, and is dwelt upon according!y. Euripides simply took an old legend, embodying the primitive idea that the Fates must have their victim or a substitute, and made the most of unpromi-ing and difficult material. The origin of Greek tragedy and comedy, the steps and growth by which they changed their character and put on a modern aspect in the new Attic comedy, in Terence, in Plau- tus, and in Seneca, are pretty clearly made out as a matter of history, and must always be in- teresting even when dissected and dried and analyzed to fit the nomenciature of a theory. Mr. Moulton, as we have intimated, is very fond of Mr. Herbert Spencer's ideas and phrases, and notwithstanding all his cleverness —perbaps by dint of cleverness and a great turn for analysis—he has managed to make a rather dry herbarium of his classification of literary species and development. ‘‘ Choral in- stability and decomposition of dramatic unity, as lines of development,” ‘*‘ Counter tendency to imperfect unity,” are expressions which ’ The Nation. would be less forbidding if they were more ac- curate. While they wear the austere air of science, it must be remembered that they are based only ou analogy and are simply rather stiff ard ugly metaphors, For Mr. Moul- ton seems to forget occasionally that, on the whole, plays are madeand do not exactly grow, and thai a poet is something more even than a gardener. Atone time hespeaks of ‘tenden- cies” and ‘‘ cross-tendencies” and ‘‘ aggiutina- tion,” of ‘‘ underplot, embryonic in Sophocles, and complete in Euripides”; at another he uses ordinary language, and calls the prologue and the ‘‘ miraculcus close,” inventions of Euri- pides. Would it be any truer to regard the ‘** Alcestis,” for example, as a ‘‘sport” of the satyric drama which gave rise ultimately to me- lodrama, than to call it a first «experiment and invention of the poet? The fact is, that where we have history, we cannot neglect the personal and creative element; where history fails, the language of evolution answers well enough if we remember that it is based on analogy. The unhi.toric growth of literary forms corresponds reasonably well with the unconscious processes _of nature; the work of the conscious artist is apt to put the formulas of evolution to confu- sion. If Mr. Moulton is too much disposed to wire the flowers of literature into geometrical pat- terns, we may also complain a little of his pas- sion for catezories, This is a failing which perhaps leans to virtue’s side, His distinctions are generally clear and well-drawn, but they are sometimes overdrawn. Here, for ex- ample, are his varieties of comic wit: ‘the simple surprise, the reverse surprise, surprise perversion, surprise iterations, comic enume- rations, comic persistence”’; and these are the ingredients of Aristophaniclaughter! Yet, in spite of a certain rigidity of method anda fancy for hard names, there is, we believe, no book in English which exactly fills the place of this survey of the steps by which the An- cient Drama approached and merged into the Modern, none which presents the whole subject more distinctly and accurately, though not al- ways with the charm and sympathetic treat- ment that the subject deserves. Under the Cambridge University Extension scheme, Mr. Moulton’s lectures were delivered before adult audiences, representing all c'asses of society, in which not one person in ten would know a word of Greek or Latin. He finds that the ancient classics ‘‘rank second only to Shakespeare and Goethe as an attrac- tive subject for lectures.” At Newcastle-on- Tyne, his audiences reached a weekly average of over seven hundred, many of whom did re- gular exercises upon the subject of the lec- tures and were tested at the end of the course in a formal examination. A recent article in an excellent periodical (the Syracuse Acade- my) advocated the substitution of Anglo-Saxon and early English for the training derived from the Greek and Latin classics. Mr. Moul- ton’s wide experience goes strongly against any such substitution, ‘*The old English writers,” he says very truly, ‘‘ have bad less influence in moulding our literature than have Homer and Virgil and the Greek Dramatists. As a practica] teacher of literature, I find it almost impossible to give an intelligent grasp of form in Sbakespeare to those who are igno- rant of Classical Drama.” Another suggestion comes with much weight from an instructor of Mr. Moulton’s experi- ence, and may be nearly as much needed with us as it is in English schools and universi- ties. He complains that in practice, study of Latin and Greek is almost exclusively a study of language; that, with the student in the [Vol. 52, No. 1332 schools and the passmen of the universities, the element of language almost entirely swal- lows up theelement of literature. He reminds us once more that, after all, it is Greek and Roman literature and ideas we are studying, and that the mass of students get little or nothing if they carry away no clear conception of books and authors as a whole. Yet ‘‘ the ordinary student cannot cover the ground fast enough to compare work with work and author with author.” His study of the classics loses all perspective, ‘ tith- ing the mint and anise and cummin of oratio obliqua and the paradigms, but omit- ting the weightier matters of a poet’s concep- tions and literary force.” To meet this diffi- culty, various useful expedients, such as exten- sive sight-reading and private reading, are practised in our best colleges. Mr. Moulton boldly recommends that where a few books of the ‘ Odyssey,’ or a couple of plays, are read in the original, the whole ‘ Odyssey,’ or a group of plays, be prescribed for astudy in English, or some course of reading in ancient and English classics combined, of which his appendix contains examples. As to this ap- pendix, we might ask a place init for Wors- ley’s ‘ Odyssey,’ and we might query whether the ‘Epic of Hades’ is really an ‘ English classic,’, and whether the toil and sweat spent in reading it might not advantageously be transferred to the ‘ Paradise Lost’; and, lastly, we should warn studious readers against Rus- kin’s ‘ Queen of the Air,’ as a dazzling bubble, blown of so thin and doubtful material that it will mislead more than it can possibly instruct. In the Footprints of Charles Lamb. By Ben- jamin Ellis Martin, Illustrated by Herbert Railton and John Fulleylove. With a biblio- graphy by E. D. North, Charles Scribner’s Sons. 1890. A MORE readable book of the sort to which Dr. Martin’s belongs dows not often come in the way of the reviewer. It is agreeably written, pervaded by a fine literary feeling, and has the touch of personal devotion that often gives a charm to inferior matter. Lamb is an author who is loved by those who care for him at ail, and it is the nature of such literary af- fection to be curious about the small things of the hero’s life—where he lived, what he wore, how he conducted himself in his own house, and other such matters of little concern except to those who wish to enjoy the sense of inti- macy which only living acquaintance can give in its fulness. Lamb is an excellent subject for writing in this fashion. His personality was interesting, his life had both tragedy and humor in it, some qualities that all men ad- mire mixed with weaknesses which it is mercy to forgive; he was, also, the centre at his own rooms of a notable literary group on the one hand and of a strange collection of odd cha- racters on the other. The man who joked Coleridge and Wordsworth at his ease, and could, as he said, ‘‘ love a fool,” cannot fail to be winning; and yet the story needs tiat deli- cate touch of appreciation and understanding which Dr. Martin has successfully given, and given quite naturally, without patronage or preaching. He follows Lamb from lodging to lodging, and, aided by the illustrations of the different hou-es, has made this rambling jour- ney a kind of narrative; but the substance of the book lies in the successive portraits he draws of Lamb, in the anecdotes he recalls, the scenes from his life that be describes, and in general the filling in of the chapters with a kind of persona! reminisceuce at second hand. The papers originally eppeared in Scribner's, Poteet nent Stee so} Ne et on : ; BS | 4
Page 23
= 4 ic E, F 4 ; 4 ed i x F 5 i ‘ ' | 4 ee | '
3 a td ee ee
sale by Jan. 8, 1891 |
The Nation.
where our readers may remember them; but they gain very much by being read continu- ously, and they have been admirably printed and set forth to the eye and hand of the reader.
The Story of My House. By George H. Ell- wanger. D. Appleton & Co. 1891. Mr. ELLWANGER has been fortunate in giving his reveries and little essays a local habitation in the house which apparently he never built. He cultivates the literature of sentiment and of rare objects of taste; and the associations of a house, its plan and outlooks, its furni-h ing and decorations, and artistic pleasures, give an excuse as wel] as a probability to much tbat would otherwise seem merely the extrava gance of a collector in many fields. An esssay on the building of a house, with all its kaleido scopic possibilities in the way of reform, and its tantalizing successes before the fact, is always interesting; and the author is not nig- gardly in the good points he means to:ecure. It is but natural to follow these with a treatise on rugs, full of Orientalism and enthu-iasm; on the literary den and the otherwise; aller, welcome or on the cabinets of porcelain, the rare editions on the shelves, the br.efly indi cated details of the spoils of the cha:e in their proyer place ; on the greenhouse, with its curi
HENRY HOLT & CO. HAVE JUST READY: Taine’s “Modern Regime. By H. A. TAINE. 12mo, #2.50. Translated by John Durand. Vol. I The New York Times says: This volume *t opens with a remarkable study of Napoleon Bonaparte It is careful, thorough analysis of his character, and pre sents him more impartially and comprehensively than any previous writer has done So trenchant and er big ala review and survey of past and present as this olume constitutes has not seen the light for many a ian. Peru. Incidents of travel and exploration in the Incas. By E. GEORGE Sgurre, M.A tions. New Edition
Svo, cloth, €5.0« Johnston’s Shorter Ilistory of the United States. By ALEXANDER JOHNSTON, Professor in Princeton Uni With maps. cents; by mail, #1.06. versity. Pp. 340. Teachers’ price Adapted to younger pupils and shorter courses that the author’s previous * History of the United States.’ Before his lamented death he had written and tw revised the manuscript, and except for a few minor alterations that he would naturally have proofs, the book now appears in the shape in whicl hand left it. A New Volume of Champlin’s Young Folks Cyclopedi Games and Sports. SvoO, pp. SSL, #2.5 “No such collection hes ever appeared bef The Nation, ‘Should form a part of every juvenil Hartford Post. *A mine of joy.”—N. Y. Tribu
fore? ou Books, = riodicals. Tau z Briti Auth rs Cata rues on a , 144 Tremont St., Bostor plication. CARL ScHOENHOF v4 fOREIGN BOOKS SEN T BY MAIL, ostpaid, on receipt of adv ‘ A LEMOIGNE, Libraire ce Commissionair iL hue Donaparts iris IJARE AND S TANDARD SECOND. f hand Books 3o0ks purchased forcash. Cata logues issued. ». W. JOHNSON, 1336 B'’way, N. Y. City JACK NUMBERS, VOLI bce S, OR sets of le a and ‘arce magazi ete., for WILLIAMS, 105 West loth :Se., N Y
ous climate and wonderful botany and odors, about which the author writes with unusual charm and precision; on the dining-room and the dinner, on the one culinary feat that serves as example for perfection, and the salad which, though he mentions it not sadly, re quired the sacrifice of the fragrant blue violets on the table before its edibility was quite ‘di vine”; and on many other of those topies about which it is agreeable to read if the au thor is himself sufficiently interested in his task. The outer worid is kept in view by means of landscape and weather, and talk about the angier’s and the hunter's sport; and quotation, which is an indispensable element in this kind of literature, is frequent, and often affords some excellent bt of verse from out-of-the-way volumes, The book aims only tobe sgreeab's its literary flavor is pervasive, its sentiment kept well in hand, its interest in cur.os perhaps a trifle out of proportion; but it bas an indi viduality of its own, and is a pleasing addition to those winter books of the study which have ecme in the track of the summer books of cut doors and form a little class of their own BOOKS OF THE WEEK RBalza H. de The cl Ans. ¢ ‘ ’ ) Nally & ¢ Bellamy, Bla he W ind M Ww ‘ ™ irhic Boston: ¢ ner ts SVSPePpstil HORSEORD'S ACID PHOSPHATE In dyspe psia the stomach fails to assimilatethe food The Acid P hosphate assists the eaken ( stomach, making the process of digestion natural and easy Dr. R.S. McComr, Philadelphia, says “Used it in nervous dyspepsia, with success.” Dr. W.S. LEONARD, Hinsdale, N. H says: lhe best remedy for dyspepsia that has ever come under my notice.” Dr. T. H. ANDREWws, lefferson Med Coliege, Philade pia, Says: “A wonderful remedy, which gave me most gratifving results in the worst forms of dyspepsia Desi tive pampniet tree A ford ( 3] OW f , i Beware of Substitutes and Imitation
CAUTION: Be sure the word Horsf ™ is printed he label. A = = Ci mae Nev solid in bulk f exc? g iT = 7 : Bankers, y KX ‘ a r 1 r r {NS SECURED BY DEED 7% < Ma r es at and ¢ pr i Mid eorgia farming lands at 8% r store Inves s made. THos West, A t- Law Ma - Ref < «et Na . ink; I.¢ Pla x & Rankers. Ma . aries H ras vs amd. MeN & ‘4 . v.N I ‘ va I . M . ‘ 7 ‘ . s.} and rt ‘ ‘ l Sea » N ‘ \ ; “ t : MeNa x \ é ¥ x ew York ‘ { ‘ h } t ‘ f Al saka r r * y A * ' ‘ ‘ ‘ vr , t ~ Y s . \ ‘ ‘ ’ " N ‘ 4 uM . x Soh ¢ ‘ ‘ « ‘ \ Vv ‘ t \ k ‘ OF THE NEW ENGLAND SHORB i 5 as v . ts f v y . | \ P ; s ‘ Pox . . s ! u ‘ ands l e i to 3 a, < ‘ Ns t s } : yimating ¢ . - . . . ® the t x As 4 . s fer J. Murray Howe, » Schoo! ot... ,» Boston, Mass. 4 \| 0 = Oast OF iViaine. CAI - t T . ( e Ros As ites’ on Penols< Hay snearer Bos ithe Wes ak Har Mt. Desert, a offered for -ale arceis of fiv and te acres and up- wards These ands uprise over ten miles of almost continu « shore-frontage in one of the i most beautiful sections on the coast, tweive hours’ journey fr Boston, They fr tupon fine harbors, have beautiful rocky shores, beaches, woods, and mountain views, The rives along the shores and among the hills are very varied and beautiful. New
‘N Se ashore 7: nds IN THR MAINE COAST ANDOTHER PAR'S wharves have been built, and new connections “tablished, ffured an exceptional opper- tr at semhoats with daily tr and am a « y small sums fine and perfectly protected seashore estates, The ix will not be soid for specucat.on or in rota dd ROWDTITCH HENRY PAKKMAN, J. MURRAY HOWE, ) or 7 Schor] Street, Boston, Mase Trusts e4, MEMORIAL TABLETS Of all Deacriptions or LAM] Carmine St.,N.¥ i for Circulars
Page 24
40 ** Is it not good to turn to such help as this in beginning the new and untried year?”’ THE LIGHT OF THE WORLD, AND OTHER SERMONS. By Puiuures Brooks, D.D. 12mo, 21 Sermons, 382 pages. $1.75, **It is a striking testimony to the preéminence of Phillips Brooks as a preacher that the appears ance of a volume of his sermons has become an event in the religious world. . . . Of the present volume it may be said that they show no falling off from the high standard which the great preacher has set for himself in his preyi- ously published sermons. No one at all interested in the serious things of life, whether he be for- maily a Christian or not, can read these ser- mons without being tbe better for it. Their beauty of form, wealth of illustration, depth of thought, and passionate earnestness give them a place almost their own among the sermons pub- lished during the last year.’’—N. Y¥. Tribune.} **This isthe Fifth Series of Sermons by this great preacher, who in every successive publica- tion seems still rising to his prime.’’—Independ- ent. THE CAUSES OF THE SOUL. A Book of Sermons, By Dr. Wm. R. HUNTINGTON, Rector of Grace Church, New York. 12mo, 27 Sermons, 390 pages, $1.75. For sale at bookstores; or sent by mail, postpaid, on receipt of prices. E. P. DUTTON & CO., PUBLISHERS, jt West 23d St., New York. SILVER, BURDETT & CO., PUBLISHERS, 6 HANCOCK AVENUE, BOSTON. History, Prophecy, and Gospel. A series of Bxpociions of the International 8. S. Lessons for 1891. Edited by President ANDREWS of Brown Unt- versity. Ch oth, 500 pp. English 4to, elegantly printed, $1.75 An invaluable book for all Sunday-School Superin- tendents and Bible students. THE NATION, an independent weekly journal, was established in 1865. Its contributors in- clude the most prominent names in litera- ture, science, and art both in this coun- try and abroad. Itis emphatically found in the homes of people of culture and re- finement. No intelligent American de sirous of keeping abreast of the best political and literary thought of the day can afford to be without it. Sub scription price, $3.00 a year, postpaid. Address PUBLISHER OF THE NATION, 208 Broadway, New York City. W. - NASH, 80 NASSAU ST., NEW _«e York, dealer in Books relating to America, Local History, Genealogy, Indians, etc. Catalogues issued sent on application. The Nation. ~ Notable Books By JANE G. AUSTIN. A Nameless Nobleman. Standish of Standish. Dr. LeBaron and His Daughters. Three historical novels of the old Plymouth Colony, Each $1.25. Speaking of ‘Standisk of Standish,’ the NATION said: ‘The beautiful directness and purity of its style, the splendid picture-events in which great men form part and are not made small, the pathos with which that old colony life is invested, all unite to demand fromthe judging class of readers such praise as few novels of the year deserve ” HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO., BOSTON, ut East Seventeenth Street, New York, KNICKERBOCKER STATIONERY. WEDDING anp RECEPTION INVITATIONS, ADDRESS DIES, MONOGRAMS, CRESTS, ETC., correctly and artistically engraved. All orders are promptly executed. G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS, STATIONERS AND ENGRAVERS, 27 and 29 West 23d Street, New York. Grand Conservatory of Music OF THE CITY OF NEW YORK, (INCORPORATED) THE LEADING SCHOOL OF MUSIC, Has removed to 16 East 23d Street, (Madison Square.) Elocution, Dramatic Art, Foreign Languages, Drawing and Painting. Has been attended by over 10,000 students from all parts of the United States and C anada. Free advantages equal to 10 LESSONS PER WEEK. Weekly Entertainments, Lectures, and Concerts. Gold Medals and Prizes awarded annually to the most deserving students. Free scholarships now open for competition. For further particulars addres Dr. E. EBERHARD, 16 East 23d St., N. Y. School of Drawing and Painting, AND DEPARTMENT OF DECORATIVE DESIGN, MUSEUM OF FINE ARTS, BOSTON. eee and detailed information apply to the ager. SPECIAL FOOD FOR BRAIN AND NERVES. CROSBY'S VITALIZED PHOSPHITES. PREPARED ACCORDING TO THE FORMULA OF PROFESSOR PERCY. From the Vital principle of the Brain of the Ox and the Embryo of the Wheat and Oat. For mo:e than twenty years Physicians have used and recommended this Brain principle, asthe best restorer of vigor and impaired vitality. ‘Thousands ot the wor!d’s best Brain workers, college students, and those engaged in athletic sports, have maintained their bodily and mental activity by its use, It is not a ** Patent Medicine ”: the formula is on every label. It is a vital nutrient PhospHITE, nota Laboratory PhospHATE. Descriptive pamphlet, with testimonials, free. F. CROSBY CO., 56 W. 25th St., N. 4 Y. Druggists, or sent by matl, $1.00. [Vol. 52, No. 1332 B. WESTERM ANN & CO., Importers and Publishers, 812 BROADWAY, NEW YORK. Now Ready, Part I: seaman = ae 1-xxxii, 1-192, -—Bok, to be followed by the first part of the German- English volume, next month, of FLUGEL’S Larger German-English and English-German Dictionarv. AN ENTIRELY NEW EDITION. Will be published in J2 parts at $1.00 each, Special terms for advance orders and Public and College Libraries. Prospectus and —— Pages on Lahlesahendie CHEAPEST BOOKSTORE IN THE WORLD. 82,672 MAGNIFICENT HOLIDAY BOOKS AT OUR PRICE. 138,672 BIBLES, PRAYER-BOOKS, ETC., AT YOUR PRICE. 25,876 MAGNIFICENT JUVENILES AT ANY PRICE. HOLIDAY CATALOGUE FREE. LEGGAT BROTHERS, 81 CHAMBERS S8T., - NEW YORK, Three doors from Broadway, GUSTAV E. STECHERT, Importer of Books and Periodicals 828 Broadway, New York. Employs no agents in Europe, but has his OWN OFFICES at London: 30 Wellington Street, Strand, W. C.; Leipzig: Hospital Strasse, 10, and thus has facilities SUPERIOR to those of any otber firm. Books for Libraries, Professors, and Students aspecialty, Also rare and scarce books and sets of periodicals. S. B. LUYSTER, 98 Nassau SrrEET, New York, AND LONDON, ENGLAND, Importer of Standard English Books, OLD AND NEW. Catalogues issued bi-monthly, and sent gratis to any address, on application. F. W. CHRISTERN, 254 Fifth Ave., between 28th and 20th Sts., New York. Importer of Foreign Books, Agent for the leading Paris Publishers, Tauchnitz’s British Authors, Teubner’s Greek and Latin Classics. Catalogues of stock mailed on demand. A large assortment always on hand, and new books received from Paris and Leipzig as soon as issued. ELLIS & ELVEY, 29 NEW BOND STREET, LONDON, ENGLAND, Dealers in Choice Books and MSS. Catalogues issued periodically and forwarded ge larly to purchasers. Early illuminated MSS Century Books, with woodcuts—Horve on vdiline-iiean bindings—Rare Americana, etc., etc. E. F. BONAVENTURE, BooKs AND PRINTS, WEST 31ST ST., COR. B*oWAY, NEW YORK. _ Catalogues mailed on receipt of 10 cents. DUPRAT & CO., Importers of Fine Books, ted 5TH AVENUE. NEw YORK. MPORTANT REDUCTION IN PRICE of back numbers of the Nation prior to removal. Submit lists and proveit. Catalogue No. 31 just out, brimfull of gooc — A. 8S. CLARK, Bookseller, 34 Park Row, N. Y. City. = Sis ita PIP ARS aa pee Cae Hea EST