The Nation 1890-02-06: Vol 50 Iss 1284

Page 1

Feb. 6, 1890] able. nal’s publication, has included most of the leading names in literature, scien and many of corresponding eminence abroad. accurate condensed records procurable of the world’s current history, should occupy the attention of thoughtful men. The Week. Terms, $3 per annum, postpaid. Alex. Agassiz, Hz arvard U niversity. Frederic D. Allen, F. Bocher, H. P. Bowditch, Edward Channing, F. J. Child, J. P. Cooke, Jr., W. M. Davis, E. Emerton, Samuel Garman, Geo. L. Goodale, W. W. Goodwin, Cc. H. Grandgent, J. B, Greenough, Charles Gross, H. A. Hagen, A. B. Hart, William James, J. R. Jewett, Geo. M. Lane, Chas. R. Lanman, S. M. Macvane, Charles H. Moore, Morris H. Morgan, Charles Eliot Norton, Geo. H. Palmer, Josiah Royce, C.S. Sargent, N.S. Shaler, F. H. Storer, F. We —- J.B. Th +f H. Tilinghast, . H. Toy, Se reno W ‘atson, J.D. Whitney, Justin Winsor. Lucien Carr, Peabody F. W. Putnam, *“ D. C. Eaton, Y Arthur T. Hadley, W.I. Knapp, T. R. Lounsbury, Tracy Peck, . D. Seymour, W. G. Sumner, J. K. Thacher, A. Van Name, Henry P. Wright, David P. Todd, Amherst College. Herbert B. Adams, Johns: Hopkins University. Wm, Hand Browne, A.M. Elitott, Christine L. Franklin, Fabian Franklin, B. L. Gildersleeve, D. C. Gilman, G. Stanley Hall, G. Brandt, Hamilton College. Henry F. Osborn, P rine eton ¢ ole ge. BR. Seott, Ko AC iams, Cornell U niversity. t. F. Crane, W. T. Hewett, Chas. H. Hull, B. I. Wheeler, H. S. White, B. G, W ilder, J. A. Allen, American —— Natural History. Aitved M. Mayer, Stevens Institute, Hoboken. H. Boyesen, Columbia College. w. H. Carpenter, A. C, Merriam, Munroe Smith, ee Museum of Archeology. ale College, oe THE Brief comments on the Edttortal and Miscellaneous « Spectal Correspondence. Occasional Correspondence. Notes. Short paragraphs, Reviews of Books. Fine Arts. By able writers |} David A The The list of contributors who have been employed more o Careful and moderate discussion From all quarters of the globe, by tntelligen Letters to the editor on every on literary, sciet and scholars (mainly s Competent criticism of art exhibitions and works of a1 Address THE PARTIAL LIST Wm. R. Ware, Columbia Colle Henry M. Baird, University of the City Ht. P. Johnston, College of Cit y of New York. H. Me Daniels, Hobart Col Franklin Carter, W illiams C olleg O. M. Fernald, Bilss Perry, F. A. March, Lafayette C sna Easton. J. M. Hart, University of Cincinnati. E. J. James, University * Pennsylvania a lo Heilprin, Phila E. G. Bourne, Adelbert ¢ ‘ollee. H. C Adams, University of Michigan. George Hempl, r. W. Kelsey, H. Pettee, ( vale in Thomas, D. Butler, University of w isconstn. Fisk i Brewer, Grinnell, a Or A. Harrison, _M. Garnett, Charlottesv ‘ile : kK. Hosmer, Washington Untv eraity, x rr lison Hogue, University of Mississi Welling, Columbian University, S. Nautical Almanac S. Surgeon General's Charles H. Davis, U.S.N Simon Newcomb, U Jonn S. Billings, U. J. Russell Soley, Garrick Mallery, U.§ A.A. Woodhull, S. F. Emmons, U. Henry Ganne tt, Arnold Hague, Elliott Coues, Smit hsonian Institt William H. Dall Theodore Gill, Alfred Emerson, _— Forest, Ul. E. S. Holden, Berkeley, C juiens, Boston Institute Jules Luy Charles Francis Adams, Jr., I Gamaliel Bradford, Charles A. Cutter, E. H. Greenleaf, W. E. Griffis, Isabel F. Hapgood, Henry W. Haynes, James M. Hubbard, Henry W. Holland, W. P. P. Longfell Ei tward J. Lowell, | Jas. Russell Lowell, Percival Lowell Francis Parkman, Edward Robinson, John Cc Ropes. Wm. H. Whitm ore, G. E. Woodberry, y T. W. Hisxinson, Arthur Gils A. L. Ripley, Willi am E H.W Wm. E. } W.J. Lit Robert f T. M. Coa W.A. Coffin Moncure 1). « war Kenyon Cox Theo. L. De V e Miwarni Faxles Nation ‘The Nation Is a weekly review of politics, literature, science, and art A bound volume of the Its Departments a most important current even WRITERS ‘ademy Natural Science es ston and Lee Universit v - Geo ‘logical Survey. John Fiske, Cambr

Page 2

lv The Nation. CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS NI:W BOOKS. Vols. III. and IV. Just Published HISTORY OF THE UNITEDSTATES By Henry Apams, Vols. [T. and Il. THe First ADMINISTRATION OF THOMAS JEFFERSON. $4.00. Vols. TH. and IV. TH SECOND ADMINISTRATION OF THOMAS JEFFERSON. $4.00, “A memorable addition to American historical Literature in a work which will take rank with Baneroft’s and above Hildreth’s, and which is likely to long remain without a rival in the field that the author has marked out for survey. His literary competence, his ripeness of culture, and fullness of in- formation, his breadth of sympathy and unswerving impartiality speak for themselves.”-—New York Sun. * There is evidence on every page of acute- | ness and independence ot thought, and the in- corporation of new material makes the book an important contribution to our knowledge of | fact. Inits fullness, accuracy, insight, and im- partiality, and in the admirable quuaiities of its style, it is plainly the work of a master.’’— Bos- ton Advertiser. AMONG ‘A great mass of new materials has been put in requisition for the preparation of this treatise. Le springs of many a movement which were before obscure are here brought to sight. The narrative style of Mr. Adams is vigorous in its grasp ot materials, dignified in its tone, and cor- | rect in point of literary form.’’—The Nation. CANNIBALS. An Account of Four Years’ Travels in Australia, and of Camp Life with the Aborigines of Queensland, By Cart LUMHOLTZ. With over 100 Illustrations. 8vo, $5.00, “Hits observations are tnteresting,and he has avery pleasant and modest style of narrative, so that the book ts as agreeable as tt ts instructive; tn short it is one of the most complete of its kind steadfast enterprise. in all respects, and a worthy record of We can infer from the stvle and fine temper of his narra- tive that he belongs to the higher class of sctentific explorers, who think far more of thetr work than thev ao of themselves The Religious Aspect. of Evolution. By JAMES McUosn, D.D., LL.D. 12mo0, $1.00, A broad, comprehensive, and masterly treat- ment of the subject, characterized by great clearness of logic and simplicity of style. The substance of the book was delivered as the Be- dell Lectures, 1887, but since then Dr. MeCosh has added much new matter. SAID IN —-The London Spectator. x ) 7 f T f ) ) The Poetry of Tennyson. By Henry VAN DyKk&, D.D. 12mo, $1.50. **Asastatement of the essence of Tennyson's poetical art, the book has no successful rival."’— Boston Beacon. ‘The entire volume is one which ought to be enjoyed by every lover of Engiish literature.’’— Philadelphia Bulletin. FUN. By Puivipe H. Wetou, With preface by ROBERT GORDON BUTLER. With many full-page illustra- tions by Rogers, Attwood, Bush, ** Chip,”’ Frost, Gibson, Herford, Kemble, Mitchell, Opper, Sheppard, Smedley, Snyder, Sterner, Taylor, Van Schaick,and Woolf. Square 8vo, $1.25. “ There ts not a pointless zest in the whole collection, and the pictures are abun- dant and ef capital quality. The work of the artists has been entirely a labor of love, for all the profit from the copyright goes te the fund for Mr, Welch's family. Whoever buys the book, therefore, not only secures a copious equivalent tn whole- some, clean, genutne ‘fun, but he also contributes something to the needs of the family of one of the gentlest, truest, and best-loved men in newspaper circles, whose death has been widely deplored.”—The Boston Journal. The American Railway. Its Construction, Development, Management, and Appliances. With 225 illustrations, Bound tn half leather, 8vo, $6.00, net, * The first satisfactory popular account of the American Railway. It is a striking ex- ample of thoroughness ard judgment, In the general design, in the selection of writers, in the illustrations, and in the arrangement of the matter the book is a model.’’—Christian Union. *.* For sale by all Booksellers, or sent, post- The Viking Ag ) “ino Aoe le Viking Age. The Early History, Manners, and Customs of the Ancestors of the Euglish-speaking Nations. By Pau. B. Du CHAILLU. With 1,400 illus- trations, 2vols.,8vo. $7.50, | ** Theauthor’s greatest work. Tothe student | of history the volumes will be invaluable, while | to the general reader the attractive style, to- |} gether with the profuse and admirable illustra- | tions, will make them a mine of instructive | pleasure.’"—N, ¥. Observer. paid, on receipt of price by the Publishers, CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS, 743-745 Broadway, New York. {Number 1284 Scribner & Welford’s NEW BOOKS. The Marriages of the Bour- bons. By CAPTAIN the Hon. D. BINGHAM, With II- lustrations. 2 vols., 8vo, $7.50. “Capt. Bingham is an anecdotal master in history and biography, and has made a special study of the dynastic annals ot France and of those memoirs which fill so large a space in French literature, and throw so vivid but so du- bious a light on the world of ante-chambers and boudoirs. To his tavorite task he brings the curiosity of a courtier and the skill of a journal- ist.’ —London Daily News. The First of the Bourbons, 1595-1610. By CATHERINE CHARLOTTE LADY JACKSON, au- thor of ‘Old Paris,’ *The Old Régime,’ *Court of Louis X1LV.,’ ‘Court of the Tuile- ries,’ etc. In 2 vols., crown 8vo, cloth extra, $9.00. In Tennyson Land: Being a Brief Account of the Home and Early Surroundings of the Poet Laureate, ana an Attempt to Identify the Scenes and Trace the Intluences of Lincolnshire in his Works. By J. CUMING WALTERS. With 12 Illustra- tions by F. G. Kirron, by drawings from photographsand sketches taken especially for theauthor, The pictures include representa- tions of Somersby Reetory, The Moated Grange, The Brook, The Mill, Louth Gram- mar School, ‘Tennyson’s Birthplace. Demy 8vo, white cloth, gilt, $1.75. Days With Industrials: Adventures and Experiences Among Curious In- dustries. By ALEXANDER H. JApp, LL.D., F.R.S.E., Author of * Industrial Curiosities,’ * Golden Lives,’ &c., &c. Crown 8vo, cloth, $32.25. CONTENTS: Quinine and its Romance—Curiosi - ties of Canary Culture— Rice—Pearls-—Amber— Common Salt—Burton Ale and Dublin Stout— Petroleum——E ectric Telegraphs—Railway Whis- the—Historical Bedsteads—Knives and Forks— Arsenic in Industry—Famous Diamonds— Arti- ficial Diamonds—Postage Stamps. = ay. : rth . ) 5 om Hayti; or, The Black Re by . public. By Sir SPENSER St. JiOHN., K.C.M.G., formerly Her Majesty’s Minister-Resident and Consul- General in Hayti, now Her Majesty’s Spectal Envoy to Mexico. New Edition. Revised, with a Map, large crown 8vo, $2.50. “One of the most astounding books ever pub- lishea, . . . It deserves to be read by every- body, even at the risk of being made sick with horror and of regretting that our race ever de- veloped from monkeys intosuch men and women as are depicted in the pages.’’— Illustrated London News. NEW VOLUMES OF THE IDEAL SERIES. e y V4 In Matthew Prior’s Selected Poems. With an Introduction and Notes by AUSTIN DoB- son. With Portrait from Michael Dahl. 12mo, cloth, gilt top, $2.00, A New Pilgrimage, and Other Poems. By WILFRID SCAWEN BuuNT, Author of ‘ Love Sonnets of Proteus,’ ete. 12mo, cloth, gilt top, $2.00, *,* The above books sent upon receipt of adver- tised price. Catalogues of our regular stock will be mailed, if desired, to those interested, SCRIBNER & WELFORD, 748-745 Broadway, New York.

Page 3

NEW YORE, THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 6, 1890. ‘The Week. THERE never was a more striking illustra- tion of Philip drunk and Philip sober than is afforded by contrasting Mr. Reed’s position now with his position ten years ago: PHILIP SOBER, PHILIP DRUNK. If it was my purpose The clerk announces the to reply to the gentleman | members voting in the who has just taken his | af_irmative as 161 and 2 seat, itseems tomethatit who voted in the nega would be a suitable and tive. The Chair there proper reply tosay to him | upon, having seen tne that the constitutional idea of a quorum is not the pre sence of a majority of the members of the House, but a majority of the members present and par ticipating in the business of the House, It is not the visible presence of mem bers, but their judzments and their votes, that the Constitution ealls for,— Thomas B, Reed, January members present, having heard their names called in their presence, directed the call to repeated, and, gentlemen not an swering when thus called, the Chair directed arecord of their names to be made, the fact of their presence, as bearing upon the which been whether be showing question has raised, namely, there is a quo- 580. rum of this House present todo business or not, ac cording to the Constitu tion of the United States | —Thomas B. Reed, Janu | ary 2%, Speaker Reed’s performances are quite as novel as the manner of robbing the Sixth National Bank, so that it is difficult to form an opinion as to the course the Democrats should follow. There nothing quite like them in parliamentary annals. has been There have been cases of great tyranny on the part of majorities, and there have been cases of occasional unfairness in rulings on points of order on the part of Speakers, and there has been a case where a Speaker was held down in his chair to prevent his abandoning his post before a motion was put; but there never before has been a case where a persist- ent refusal of the majority to adopt rules of procedure was followed by the assumption on the part of the Speaker of complete con- trol of the procedure without regard to rules, and by the daily display of contempt for the minority and disregard even of their cus- tomary parliamentary rights. Consequent- ly the Democrats have no precedents to guide them, and are placed in a position of some difficulty. To leave the House in a body, as has been proposed, would be a clear abandonment of their duty to their constituents. They are as much bound to stand their ground and oppose the pre- sent course of the Speaker and the ma- jority, day in and day out, as they are to participate in orderly legislation. But What kind of opposition? Well, every kind short of violence. They are bound to ob- struct by all peaceable means the transac tion of business until rules are adopted, and protest against the Speaker's conduct, persist ently and vociferously, whenever the occa- sion arises. In short, everything should be done to make outrages of this sort in parlia mentary government slow and difficult in their operation, and at the same time clear

and comprehensible to the We are, With hardly a doubt, witnessing the death 1 the ana t country throes of the Republican party, Democrats must make the scene as hideous and uncomfortable as the death of a har dened old sinner ought to be. The last Republican Speaker before Mr Reed was in December, 1881.) lh November, 1882, a new House of Represen tatives was elected. The 7riiune Alma for thus stated the this new House: Democrats, chosen ISS) membership of 19] ! Republi cans, 119; other partic s, 18. The incident that ind: Philadel lends point to these remarks by pendent Republican journal, the phia Ledger: ‘* Mr. Reed thinks he has won a great victory over the Democrats. Well let us wait and see. An appeal lies to higher court, whose decision may oust Mr Reed from the Speaker's chair at the end of the present Congress.” The Republicans finally rallied a quorum Monday, and ut Republican of their own members on lized it to tested the Virginia. been abundantly justified by the facts, the whi con West The procedure appears to hav seat a seat of a Democrat from } Democrat’s claim to an exceedingly nart plurality resting upon the G Vernors inter pretation of the letters ‘“‘twe"™ in a clerk's return as twelve instexd of two, which tl! evidence showed that they stood for It is so much dissatisfuc reported that there is on the Republican si } rnin } e against colng alon indefinitely under the ‘*one-man-power ™ sys tem which Mr. Reed has established, that t Committee on Rules will soon make their re port and allow the House to * determine t! rules of its proceedings,” as it ought to have done the first thing after it met last Decem ber. Mr. Carlisle has made an excet \ strong presentation of the Democratic po sition, in demanding the adoption of rules as the essential preliminar of any business in the Fifty first Congress as in every one of its tifty predecessors. Mr. Wilson of West Virginia made on the same day a powerful speech upon the anoma lous state of things in the House, and out very clearly one point which has not yet been much thought about—the bearing of ‘the one-man-power” system upon the question of the by In this new era [acting under general parliamenta ry law],” he said the lobbyist would be a power in iegislation. He [the lob byist] would pot be obliged to go around and give checks to individual members. What had members to do wit Jegislation? The Speaker passed the bills bother with members, but to ‘see’ the Speaker as a much more effective and cheap er way of lobbying.” The truth is, that here never | been seen under re presenta The Nation.

tive institutions a iN {s power as Thomas B. Reed w Le v if things went on through } te s ft { pst few days. It is a power whicl ught not t be wielded even by a George Was t Vr) an to Pr Mi Nev Was n Mor lav The T i rue tthe Sena Four vears ago it passed ‘ t upper | cl f ress by a vote three ne Pwo vears a tsecured but tet n rity, sothatachar f tive votes would have prevented its pass rhis t ’ ht ter f far short , maiority rr eount? y wi ) site at st witl ‘ t 1 d . t vi Py Tene atty or ins ‘ ‘, } +) N et? at } S +) heainge no i t Ww \ 1 is in dec! rit tie s i | Parity the & ‘ ¢ re ® the « XN Ody W ints It stl t 1 al artic the St. P Prose W cos ver the fact that re is every ‘ ty , ) that w ine ‘ ‘ $ s i ty i r nas let s s . TON b t ¥ in instance where CO} su J or ; | , ? eXperiel 1 ( i . ‘ s ‘ ‘ where t! } s empha wy ’ aw st V nN s ( SA l t s t \ SUA i }? ail ¢ ‘ ‘ ss ‘ ty ' . | “ t c ¢ hus ‘ t t - > s \ ‘ the | ‘ fc ) { ’ <s Was t take 1] ve Wor eV PENse tT the pec t l S tha thie pene e of ] waand 1. scan s T Ie expected ik 1 te t c } s ol work that ; | is i - ind adds that may mak pleasant tif anv of their ( Tess = it ss to have The pian proposed by the silverites in Congress—it has not vet been introduced, but there is no doubt that it will be offered as a substitute fom bi con t s the w cancellation of ry itstanding go) i certificates and silver cer- 1 ates as fast as the Government can get . hold of them, and the issue thereafter of coin certificates’ only. This is one of Senator Beck’s odd fancies. It has been : ; : " introduced by him several times. The object of it is to abolish the distinction

between gold and silver, so far as the law can accomplish this purpose, but, singularly enough, the distinction reappears in another part of the same bill, where it is provided that ‘‘coin certificates’ may be issued on silver bullion ‘‘when the market price of such silver bullion is not less than 99 cents for 41215 grains.” Of course, this means market price in gold, and thus the distinction between gold and silver which it is sought to repudiate and extinguish, comes in again, the bottle imp which the wicked ma 7) bine

Page 4

102 The Nation. | Number 1284 gician never could bury so deep or throw so far that it would not come back to him. But what would be the working of the measure if it should pass? Holders of gold certificates would draw the gold at their leisure—they need not be in any hurry about it—and when they wanted to make a fresh deposit of gold, they would put it ina bank instead of in the Treasury vaults. The banks will furnish ample facilities for receiving it and paying it outon checks. For their own purposes the banks will use clearing- house certificates instead of Treasury certifi- cates, and business will go on as before. The ‘*coin certificates” will all be silver certifi- cates. The bill proposes to make the coin certificates legal tender. This would be a measure not covered by any Supreme Court decision yet pronounced. What the Court has decided - is, that the Government may make its own debt legal tender. The certifi- cate is a warehouse receipt, not a debt. There is a plain distinction between it and the greenback. Perhaps the Court would hold that the warehouse receipt might be made legal tender also, but perhaps not. In one of the saddest leading articles that ever appeared in a newspaper, the 7imes of Tuesday came to the conclusion that the Werld’s Fair project is dead. So deeply was the editor affected by the disastrous ending of a campaign in which he had been so vociferous a leader, that in passing final judgment his usual calm judicial equipoise failed him. He says in his opeoing paragraph that the project has been ‘ killed by the poison of politics administered by the New York Senate at the command of Thomas C. Platt,” and then, in a most illogical manner, goes on to say that the legislation which the poison killed would of itself have killed the Fair if the poison had not been administered. The passage in which this complicated view of the situation is taken is so comprehensive a confession of the blundering policy of the entire campaign that we give it in full; ‘* But the opposition to this legislation on other grounds than those afforded by politics might have proved fatal to its purpose. The owners of property whose interests were affected, through the counsel who appeared at the Com- mittee hearings in Albany, avowed their inten- tion of contesting its validity in the courts and fighting the issues which they raised to the tri- bunal of last resort. Considering the facilities for cansing delays in such a litigation as was threatened, and the uncertainty of a prompt decision by the courts, it would hardly have been possible te proceed with the necessary ex- pedition under the proposed law. There could have been no assurance until the contest was decided that the proposed financial aid of the city could be relied on. it wouid not have been practicable to issue the bonds, for if the authorities were not prevented by injunction from taking action,bonds could not be sold when their validity was open to question. The com- bined opposition of Republican politicians and self-interested property-owners has doubtless killed the plan of legislation under which it was proposed to operate. Does this mean that the whole project is dead ? We are very much afraid that it means just that. It does unless a new departure can be taken upon other lines.” There is scarcely astatement in that confession which was not as apparent six months ago as it is to-day. The ‘‘ whole project is dead,” because the lines upon which it has been pushed since its inception in July last were foredoomed to failure. Senator Saxton has made an extraordinary confession in regard to his course on the $10,000,000 Fair Bill. The bill appeared in the Senate on Friday, January 24. Aneffort was made to rush it through both houses on that day, but was not successful. It was passed by the Assembly on the following Monday, On the next day a public hearing upon it was held by the Special Committee of the Senate. The bill was by that time lying in printed form upon the desks of all mem- bers, including Mr, Saxton’s, At Tuesday’s hearing, Mr. James C. Carter’s unanswerable argument against it was presented, and was also distributed in pamphlet form among the members. On Wednesday the bill came up for passage in the Senate. Mr. Saxton was present and had a copy of the bill, for he made an amendment changing its phrasco- logy ina comparatively unimportant particu- lar. He also heard the manly speech of Senator O'Connor against it. Yet he voted for its final passage. He now confesses that he examined the bill for the first time carefully on Saturday, and is frank to say of it: ‘‘A more outrageous one I never read,” and to confess : ‘‘ IT am ashamed that I did not join Senator O'Connor and vote against the bill.” It was evident at a glance that the drafters of the Fair Bill relied for escape from the Constitutional ‘‘ snag” in concealing the real nature of the measure. It will surprise many of our readers who have had no opportunity of seeing the bill, and who probably think that it is tilled with provisions for the holding of a World’s Fair here in 1892, that there is only one mention in it of any such scheme, and that an incidental mention. The title is, ‘““An Act to Provide for Exhibitions of Arts, Sciences, Manufactures, and Products of the Soil, Mine, and Sea in the City of New York.” There is not a word in it about Columbus or the discovery of America, or of a celebration of any kind in 1892, until we get to the twenty-eighth section, near the end, where it provides, en passant as it were, that the use or occupation of lands seized on under the act may be granted ‘‘ toany corporation that may be incorporated by an Act of Congress for an international exposition.” This is the sole allusion to the great ‘* World’s Fair.” The rest of the bill provides for the seizure of lands for the purposes of a permanent fair. ground at the upper end of the island, for all sorts of exhibitions, under the control of a permanent commission. The object of this concealment is, of course, plain. It is to ‘‘vet around the Constitution” by keeping out of sight the real nature of the bill, Mr. Carter, in his opinion, points this out, say- ing that the bill was ‘‘drawn with great skill and adroitness, and apparently with a view to obviate what were felt to be seri- ous difliculties.” The complaint is heard in Boston that Senator Dawes goes frequently to the White House to hold long consultations with the President concerning the distribution of the Federal oftices in Massachusetts, but that he is not bestirring himself at all to get a hearing from either the President or Congress for the demands which Re- publican manufacturers are making for free raw materials, What excuse he offers to the complaining manufacturers for his ap- parent indifference to their sufferings is not stated, but it may be similar to the one which his colleague, Senator Hoar, is credited with having made to one of the most persistent of them, who was assuring the Senator that unless he had free raw materials he could not continue his business. Mr. Hoar’s re- ply is said to have been a confidential assur- ance that relief would come soon by means of reciprocity with Canada—in other words, that while the Republican party in Congress is ostentatiously shooing free trade away from the front door, it is slyly preparing to let it in by the back door. A Washington correspondent of the New York Commercial Bulictin tells us that ‘‘ the Supreme Court has decided in favor of the legality of the act of March, 1839, by which the right to appeal to the courts was denied to importers.” Not at all. The majority of the court said that the law of 1839 left to an imperter an action of trover and of re- plevin, wherein the legality of a customs tax could be tested; but the McKinley bill cuts those away. The correspondent adds : **The Republican Senators who framed the Senate Tariff Bill say that they took the opi- nion of many eminent jurists upon these points, and are satisfied that leaving the deter- mination of facts to an executive board is within the Constitution. The right of trial by jury is so precious, however, to the American people tnat Congress may not care to take it away in these customs cases, even though con- vinced that they have the constitutional power.” Who were those ‘‘eminent jurists”? We wish we could see such an opinion in writing from even one of them. The part borne by the Supreme Court in settling the Government of the United States has been made the subject of many learned tomes, and is as far from being exhausted as the greater subject of the development of constitutional government in England, which embraces our own institutions as well. No subject is more worthy of study, since it includes the larger part of the ma chinery by which society is kept in its proper orbit. The celebration this week of the Supreme Court’s centennial will give a new impulse to this study, and supply a fresh stimulus to that undoubting faith in the permanence of our institutions which upheld us in the great struggle of a quarter of a century ago, and which now binds the utter- most parts of the republic together. As long as the Supreme Court retains the confidence of the people in its rectitude, its learning, its industry, and its courage, the country has a sheet anchor which even party rage—the mest dangerous menace to free government— cannot dislodge. Itis agreed upon all hands that the present court possesses this confi- dence as fully as any of its predecessors. The court over which Marshall presided, and which had more to do_ with hewing the Constitution into its present shape than all its successors, enjoyed a much smaller measure ot confidence, not because

Page 5

Feb. 6, 1890 Seen a it deserved less, but because the substruc- ture of the Government was not yet hard- ened. associates that they made a strong founda- tion for those who should come after them. It is the glory of the present court that they have built upon this foundation with telligence, firmness, and integrity commen in surate with the noble ground plan supplied to them. The operations by which the Sixth Na tional Bank, one of the soundest institutions in the city, was partially gutted and closed, have come upon the community like thunder out of aclear sky, and every one is asking whether every bank in the United States is exposed to a similar peril, and, if not, why not. Here was an institution having de posits of $2,000,000, a large surplus fund, and a reputation of the very first class, (its stock selling at 400 in the market), sud denly extinguished by the simple process of a transfer of a majority interest in its shares. The shares of all banks are salable, No body is required by law to refuse a satisfae tory offer for his property invested in such shares. Persons who have acquired a stand ing in the community by a long career of probity and prudence in business are under only moral obligations to preserve that a priceless possession. It is needless to say that the national-banking system lives only by virtue of the rigorous enforcement of the safeguards that have been thrown around it. These cover every kind of fraud that a bank officer can commit. The offence committed by Claassen looks like embezzlement, for which the law provides a penalty of not less than five years in the penitentiary. There are Other provisions of law which appear to have been violated as soon as Claassen got his hands on the assets of the bank. One such provision is, that not more than one- tenth of the substribed capital of a bank shall be loaned to any one person or firm. The capital of the Sixth National is $200,000. Yet Claassen made three loans of $60,000 each to himself, on very bad security. If the se- curity had been good, the law would still have been violated. It appears further that Claassen had never been legally elected President of the bank, his acts being, there- fore, entirely unauthorized, even if they had been proper in themselves. Here is a case, if there ever was one, for making an exam- ple of bank depredators, and we have no doubt that the enginery of the law will be | put in swift operation. The letters of Presidents Adams and Hughitt withdrawing their roads from the Inter-State Railway Association have an un- dertone of defence against the prevailing opinion of railroad men that the Union Pa cific and the Northwestern, by their con- tract, violated both the letter and spirit of the inter State agreement which both gen- It is the glory of Marshall and his | The Nation. alliances between members. What the ac tual effect will be upon the railroads of the Association must be a matter of conjecture The Northwestern has always been conserva tively managed, and is not a rate cutter The danger is in the effect of these combina tions and alliances upon the shorter lines The Chicago, Milwaukee and St. Paul has no line west of Omaha. Theories of the rect tude of the Union Pacific- Northwestern con tract will not restore to this road the proportion Itcannot be expected to rane d of trattic it is losing. bear this loss patiently for the general It will claim, rather, that the general good requires a surrender of a fair share of busi ness to itself. Now, when all roads are doing a good business, the break-up and re-forma tion of the Inter-State Association is a matter of speculation only; but when trattic falls off later on, the roads outside the much-discussed contract may think that rate-cutting is the them. It problem for all concerned, and the contract only salvation for is a ing roads, by insisting on their agreement at Whatever cost, and not even suspending the operation of it pending reorganization, have certainly not helped to clear the general situation. editorial Problem” A double-leaded article upon ‘*The Southern the Tope ka Daily Capitad of last Wednesday holds out In in its opening sentences the hope that this question has been taken in hand by a master The editor commends cent speech as a great one, but open to criti cism inthe fact that it failed to point outs Senator Ingalls’s re remedy, and thus increases the reader's con tidence that he has at last found the man who comprehends the necessities of the situ- ation. This when one reaches a sentence which with tl words *‘ The first step something practical: contidence grows begins ie ‘ here surely is tor “The first step towards legal and political justice to all men in the South is to recognize that the problem affects the constituuional rights of men all over the South regardless of color, and that the remedy can only come through the Republican party and national le gislaticn. The time has come for the Repubh can Senators and Representatives to say to the South this MUST stop, and to follow their ut terances with such legislation as will bring it about. Empty platform utterances do not meet the case. Double, treble, and quadruple the Federal! courts if necessary, with powers to protect citizens against the outrages, legal and political, that have made Southern States De mocratic monarchies for the past fifteen years.” But, after all, the reader is disappointe | It is easy enough to talk about such legisla : ay shi . Sto 8 | tion as will stop the trouble, but what kind | of legislation would that be Would it be : | = ae Gln ane ¢ such iegisiation as the Kuk ux Acta id the as . e 4 a : Civil-Rights Act The Repu udges | of he Sur y Yourt declared t} acts } of the Supreme Court deciared thase acts un- constitutional. Surely, the editor of tne Capital would not have Republican Senators in we ino in pMassine laws only to have Republican judges annul them on the cr and Representatives waste time und that they are not consti- he she tlemen exerted themselves to form, It | tutional. What uld do is to formulate is evident, also, under the conditions of | a bill which Mr. Justice Miller and the other withdrawal mentioned in the letters, that | Republican justices of the Supreme Court both roads expect the Association to | will not throw out because it interferes with be reorganized upon lines which will permit | «. the autonomy reserved to the States under 103 the Constitution,” to which, by the way, the last Republican National Convention reaf firmed the party's ‘‘ unswerving devotior An interesting lustration of tl tluence of the railroad in cultivati 4 distaste for farm life is furnished by a writer in the Con cord Moen: Coeds County is the northern most county of New Hampshire, lying al most entirely above the White Mountain range, and for the most part without direct communication with the out VMenitor writer describes his observations of deserted farms the southern part of the State, and emphasizes the absence of young men upen the farms, deeclar tha almost invariably the men who are Working the farms sre men of e age and past that age to old mei Bu Loos | inty he says, the situation is diferent Up ther vacant or deserted farms ar dl The voung men are with their fathers on the farms, and take their p with this world and its cares and through that pass into that world where the flelds are ver green; and when the home place is left many of them builda use OF A Sma frame one, and make them a new farm out of the wilderness. Perhaps if they were nearer the large cities and manufacturing centres hey would do as the voung ‘ 1 the cou ties further down in the Stat eave the farms, but the fact remains that they stay the farms and occupy their fathers’ places and that deserted or vacant farms are scarce in Cods County, while further wt a thre State wi] oT the farn s ire me irer N 1 aTket nd idVvahtages Mm many Wavs afte creater the boys eave U farms, & vacant farms are more rT iesS Pienty lt is thus one of the anomalies of the si i iat the build ing of a fa road nstes of perating ft ni prove the status { thre farmer tends to make him dissatis {i with his oc ipat on, sothat fewest deserted farms are found in that county of a State which has smalles Ta sul } Viecgres The awful cal Amity that has come upon Ser tary Tr cvs fam y Teves every one to ask what is to prevent a like calamity in any household in the land. Only a few can uild fire proof houses to live in. Hardly anybody ever does build such houses. © ( yntrary the fashion s to build with the greatest amount of woodwork, and oil, and varnish, so that when the tlames get hold of the structure they spread with the utmost rapidity. In this case it appears that the house servants, or some of them, were about their work while the fire was licking up the polished wainscotting of the parlor and stairway, all unmindful of what was going on, and that when they perceived the fire it was too late to save the lives of those who were -still sleeping. Slow-burning construction has been applied to factories without much ad dition to their cost. Ought not this calamity to teach the guild of architects how to apply slow-burning construction to private houses? If it does not have that effect, it will be a costly lesson that brings no return.

Page 6

[Number 1284 104 The Nation. “THE VERY BRINK OF A VOLCANO.” In the closing days of the Forty-third Con- gress, the radical wing of the Republican party, under the lead of Gen. Benjamin F. Butler, sought to push through the Force Bill, a measure designed to enable a Repub- lican administration of the Executive Depart- ment to secure the return of a Republican Congress by Federal interference with elec- tions in the South. The Republicans had a large majority in the House, but a number of their members—including such men as Eugene Hale of Maine, Henry L. Dawes of Massachusetts, William Walter Phelps of New Jersey, and Charles Foster of Ohio— did not sustain the Butler programme. The opponents of the Force Bill, following an un- broken line of precedents since the meeting of the First Congress, attempted to defeat its passage by refusing to vote when their names were called, although present in their seats, and thus preventing its friends from securing the votes of a quorum on their side when the roll was called. On the 24th of February, 1875, the Butler wing became convinced that they could not secure a majority of the whole House, al- though it was evident that a majority of the whole House were present in the chamber, and they resolved to try a new experiment in parliamentary methods. On one question the vote stood, yeas 142, nays none, not vot- ing 145—so that the roll showed the presence of less than a quorum, although everybody knew that there were many more than a quo- rum in the hall. ‘‘I call upon the Speaker,” thereupon said Gen. Butler, ‘‘to declare the presence of a quorum, if he believes there is a quorum in the hall.” James G. Blaine was then Speaker of the House, and he promptly replied : ‘‘ The Chair cannot declare a quo rum against a yea-and-nay vote,” pointing out that ‘‘ when the roll-call is resorted to, that is the last mode of certification, from which there is no appeal.” Gen. Butler tried toargue the matter with the Speaker, insist- ing that the latter knew, by the evidence of his own eyes, that there was a quorum pre- sent; but Mr. Blaine could not be shaken from his position. ‘The gentleman,” he answered, ‘‘sees the utter absurdity, if he will excuse the expression, of the Chair put- ting an opinion in against a record on the roll-call, He only knows there are 142 pre- sent,” Mr. Coburn of Indiana came to the sup- port of Gen. Butler, and urged that, when a member was present, but did not answer to his name, another member might point out the fact of his presence and ask that his name be recorded, and that a record might thus be made that the member in question was present and not voting. We quote verbatim what followed (Congressional Record, Forty- third Congress, second session, vol. iii., part 3, page 1734): ‘* The Speaker—The Chair never heard of that being done. He begs to remind the House, whereas that might and doubtless would be true, that there is a quorum in the hall, the very principle enunciated by the gentleman from Indiana has been the foundation proba- bly for the greatest legislative frauds ever committed. Where a quorum, in the judg- ment of the Chair, has been declared to be pre- sent in the House aghkinst the result of a roll- call, these proceedings in the different legisla- tures have brought scandal on their names. ‘*Mr. Coburn—It would be arecord made by the House. ‘““The Speaker— There can be no record like the call of the yeas and nays; and from that there is no appeal. The moment you clothe your Speaker with power to go behind your roll-call and assume that there is a quorum in the hall, why, gentlemen, you stand on the very brink of a volcano.” A similar question arose in the House of Representatives on January 29. That body now consists of 330 members, and 166 are required to constitute a quorum. The roll was called on a motion to take up an elec- tion case, and resulted in a total of 161 yeas and 2 nays—three short of a quorum. The point that no quorum had voted was imme- diately raised, but was overruled by the Speaker, who directed the Clerk to re- cord as present and refusing to vote the names of a number of Democrats whom he had observed to be in their seats. This action was promptly and justly denounced by Representative Breckinridge of Ken- tucky as ‘‘ revolutionary,” and various other speakers on the Democratic side showed clearly that it was without a shadow of pre- cedent in the hundred years during which there has Veen a Congress. The ruling ot Speaker Blaine just cited was quoted. There was also quoted a speech by Gen. Garfield, who, when it was proposed, ten years ago, to allow the presence or absence of a quo- rum to be determined by ‘‘ ocular demon- stration,” said : ‘‘ The Chairman of the Com- mittee of the Whole or the Speaker of the House is to see with his own eyes that there is a quorum present. Who is to control his seeing? How do we know but that he may see forty members more for his own purnoses than there are here in the House? And what protection have gentlemen if the Speaker says he sees a quorum if he cannot convert that seeing into a list of names on the call of the roll by the clerk? [think my friend from Vir- ginia will see that he lets in the one-man power in a far more dangerous way than ever has occurred before in any legislative as- sembly of which he and I haveany knowledge. Sir, the moment you get over the line, the mo- ment you cross the boundary of names, the moment you leap over the iron fence of the roll, that moment you are out in the vague, and all sorts of disorders may come in.” Worst of all for the Speaker, there was quoted his own speech on this very point only ten years ago, sustaining the very princi- ple which he now rejects, as having beeu recognized ‘‘ since the foundation of the Government,” and as one which must always be sustained in order to secure good govern- ment. To oppose a century’s unbroken array of precedents in the House of Representatives against him, Speaker Reed had only to pre- sent a ruling of ‘‘Dave” Hill when presid- ing over the New York Senate years ago, that he might order recorded the names of members present but not voting; and a simi- lar decision by a Speaker of the Tennessee House. Of course, neither of these prece- dents had the slightest parliamentary bearing upon the proceedings of Congress, which acts under the Constitution of the United States, and not under the Constitution of New York or Tennessee; while from the moral standpoint nothing could be imagined more ridiculous. than the idea of a Republican Speaker at Washington seeking support in a revolutionary position by quoting the autho- rity of the *‘ peanut politician” at Albany. THE STRUGGLE IN THE HOUSE. Ir is a mistake to suppose, if anybody does suppose, that the public look with indiffer- ence on the struggle now going on in the House of Representatives at Washington. Although everybody understands that it can- not last for ever, very few are unconcerned about it, and nearly everybody is trying to make out the merits and to divine the mo- tives on either side. That the House ought to have rules is acknowledged on every hand. The clause of the Constitution which says that ‘‘each house may determine the rules of its proceedings,” was inserted evidently not for the purpose of giving them authority to establish rules, but to negative the idea that both houses must have the same rules. Authority to establish rules is inher- ent in deliberative bodies because business cannot be carried on otherwise. All politi- cal and all religious conventions have rules which they adopt for their own guidance and government, Even the prize-ring, the race- course, and the cock-pit have rules, because nobody can know what he may do and what he is forbidden to do without them. The presiding officer of the deliberative body is the interpreter of its rules, subject to the superior judgment of the body itself, taken under an appeal from the decision of the chair; but rules are necessary to deter- mine how and when an appeal may be taken. In the absence of rules, the will of the pre- siding officer stands in the place of rules, and this means that it stands in the place of legislation. Ifthe Speaker can declare that a quorum is present when the roll-call shows the contrary, he can declare that a bill is passed when the roll-call shows the contrary. To what must we attribute the present tur- moil in the House of Representatives? First, of course, to the absence of rules. But why have there been no rules? We will presume, until a better explanation is offered, that the Speaker and his party wanted to decide cer- tain contested elections before adopting rules, so that they might be reasonably sure of having a quorum on hand at all times without the presence of any Democrats. There have been occasions in the past when the House was more evenly divided between parties than it is now, and when party spirit was at higher tension than it is now, but it never occurred to anybody be- fore to attempt to do business without rules. Probably nobody before Mr. Reed’s time ever thought such a thing possible. But if anybody did so think, he must have thought also that the remedy to be invoked against a turbulent and cbstructive minority was to put them in the wrong before the people, or let them put themselves there, and then take judgment against them at the next election. This is the American way, and the rational way, and the only practicable way to deal with a minority which behaves itself in a repre- = ae 20 ee a ae ee

Page 7

Feb. 6, 1890] hensible fashion. The minority must first be shown to be acting reprehensibly, and then the people may be trusted to take care of them. Speaker Reed and his supporters have taken the opposite course. They have not given the minority any chance to put them- selves in the wrong. We will suppose that the Democrats had it in their hearts to fili- buster against the reports of the Committee on Elections, using the customary rules for this purpose, and thatin order to prevent filibustering the rules have been kept back. It will not do for Mr. Reed and_ his backers to go before the people nine months hence and say that they feared there would be filibustering, and that filibustering is revo- lutionary. They must be able to show some act; and even if they could show it, it would be a fair argument to say that revo- lution is a disorder to be doctored by the people at the polls, and not by setting up an arbitrary power in the Speaker's chair un- known to any civilized country. But no such act can be shown to have taken place prior to the revolutionary acts of the Speaker himself. ‘The Speaker’s apprehensions can- not be accepted in lieu of the facts which might be relied upon to justify him. And what are the grounds for his appre- hensions? Two months have passed without any rules for the government of business in the House. During that time several bills have passed, one of which was extreme- ly distasteful to the minority. Nothing more distasteful is likely to come before them than the McKinley Administrative Bill, which abolishes trial jury in customs cases, Yet they showed factious opposition to it, they resorted to no obstructive tactics. They tried to amend it, and they voted against it as a whole, but they did not filibuster against it. There is no reason to suppose that they would filibus- ter against the reports of the Committee on Elections. Neither party has ever done so in the past. Everybody knows that filibus- tering does not take place upon personal grounds, because the people would not sus- tain a party on such grounds. It takes place on such measures as a Union Pacific funding bill, or a subsidy bill, or a national-bank bill, or a land grant, or a measure of some kind that ‘‘has money in it,” where a few members think that they can gain some éclat at home by making a tremendous battle against ‘‘ Wall Street.” Both parties have demagogues and strikers who are up to this kind of business. The filibustering in the last House was obviously not in the interest of the Democrats, because they were then the majority. They contributed their quota, but the Republicans contributed theirs also There is no reason to suppose that filibuster- ing in the present House would be on party lines, or that Mr. Reed fears that it wouid be Whatever his motives may be, he is doing enormous harm to free institutions by de- stroying the good understanding which en- ables free institutions to work. by no Parties car- ry on government by pulling and pushing | against each other within certain prescribed limits, Beyond these limits they cannot co without involving themselves in a common

| cord The Nation. ruin. They must not, for example, abolish the Supreme Court or impeach the Presi- dent merely because the incumbents are distasteful to them. They must not at- tempt to legislate without rules, since that procedure substitutes the will of one man for the will of Congress. All such Mr. Reed's acts have led to chaos already. They have produced a state of feeling which has not been known in acts lead to chaos. the halls of legislation since slavery disap- peared. The minority cannot be expected to succumb to the new and strange dispensation in the Speaker’s chair. They must fight against it at all hazards and to the last ex The only safe outcome is the adop tior of rules for the government of the House. tremity. This is a remedy which can be applied at any time. Then, if the Democrats adopt obstruc- tive tactics, the people will know how to teach them good manners. So, too, will they know how toinstruct Mr. Reed and his party if they persist in attempting to set up an un heard-of one-man power in the House of Representatives. The unfavorable comments of the un- muzzled portion of the Republican press have drawn from Mr. Reed a sort of apology for his conduct, which he has seen fit to send out through the Associated Press instead of delivering it from the floor of the House, and Such a proceeding on his part shows clearly that he is ‘ rattled,” and he well may be. What he has to say in defence of his as he has the right to do, as he ought to do. conduct is embraced in two paragraphs, all the rest being in the nature of invective against the supposed wicked intentions of the Democrats. He that Mr. Car lisle frequently put motions and declared them carried when less than a quorum of Says members voted—when, for instance, 80 mem® bers voted aye and 20 voted no. He might have added that motions are frequently car-

1O5 had received warning, and slipped out before

Charles came. ‘‘ Where are they?” demand ed the aDgTY King ‘The Speaker has eves to see and ears to hear only what the House, whose serv he is, shall decid replied Speaker Lenthall If M Reed had been in the chair, wou e have answered **T saw them slip out of that door just before you came in If not, why SMUGGLERS iN} UNDERVALUERS W ny is it that the Republican party commits itself to legislative projects which exclude taxpayers from the courts, banish juries, a deprive New York importing merchants of rights held in this country for a century and in England for mere than ve ce i Sy What are the essential Imitations of legis lative and exeeutive powers whi N publican leaders and the Harrison Ad . tration endeavor to obliterat The reckless imposition of customs taxes by Congress since 1861 bas work sult } similar to those produced in) England down | to IN41 It has elevated smuggling ant dervaluing into an industry and a \ Any history of English taxes a LAXA and any history of English erime will te what happened in that country during the era of protective taxes. Dut the cig ried and bills passed when nobody votes on | either side. By parity of reasoning, there fore, the House might transact when nobody but the Speaker was present, and this is Mr. Reed coming very passing of bills sanctioned business to complexion rapidly. The .is a method of . levwicl ; > nem. con i@Lisiation immemorial custom and When by by common sense. nobody Ou jects to a bill, everybody is understood to | s assent. When nobody raises the question of a quorum, everybody is understood to agree What everybody every- that a quorum is present. agrees to is the law parliamentary where The other point made by Mr. Reed is that the House is acting under a body of rules that le use in all their the American people r I assemblies e these rules? Is the ‘* When the rol/-cal! discloses the absence of a quorum, the Chair cannot go outside of the re- in deciding as to the presence of a quo- (Smith's * Manual,’ page 564 rum. nit * A precedent of some note in been drawn into the the present con- troversy which has not debate is the one set by the Speaker of the House of Commons when Charles I. present- ed himself in that body with a file of soldiers tive members. The members to arrest | held con j type, evasions of the } fy | ; everywhere in j :

teenth and the early vears of the nineteenth century, defrauding the customs ve became in England a national trait and pastime. <A great smuggler was acivic he Adam Smith wrote of asmugyvler and an un dervaluer as “a person who, t hn highly blamable for violating the laws of his country, is frequently incapable of vio lating those of natura stice, and we i have been in every respect an zen had not the laws of his made —_ hioch ) vir , + mean that a crime which nature never meant to be so.” Charlies Lamb said, ‘‘A smuggler is the only honest thief English courts up- 6 a z ; tracts to evade the customs laws of a foreig not illeral. But after Peel had well } h country as is great work of re ein } keErun ob

ducing taxes on imported goods, the crime of smuggling and undervaluing fell into insignificance, and is now 1 ined in England te tobacco The United States is going through a similar experience of attempting to stop, by severe penalties and punish ments, of which the McKinley bill is a customs revenue. - ‘ Phe dodging of present customs taxes is not our country considered im- noral. Thorold Rogers, in one of his lee- tures delivered at Oxford in 1887-8, said he bad four times crossed the Atlartic, and ‘always met people of American descent who n that they will pay the price of their passage tickets by the dif ference at which they will buy clothes at Poole’s in Savile Row, as com- pared with the price in Broadway.” No customs law can be enforced when women and clergymen see nothing immoral in its evasion. What they do, importing merchants are not likely to consider very reprehensible, They will look on tariff taxes as on the horse- cars when crossing Broad way—as things to be

Page 8

106 avoided and evaded. The paying of money to a custom-house inspector by an arriving traveller is a State’s prison offence, but who regards the law excepting slyly to disregard it? When our customs taxes on a woman’s gown costing in Paris $200 are $160, Mr. McKinley’s proposed Jaw to sim- plify the collection of that tax will be in vain when aimed at charming women—their husbands, brothers, friends, and admirers. Where is the protectionist who would hesi- tate, if a customs inspector were not insight, to bring for a friend a dutiable seal-skin jacket or coat across the Canadian border, and thus evade or defraud our revenue ? Would Mr. McKinley ? Does not the fact that the beneficial effects of protective taxes have not yet generally received moral recog- nition or cognizance prove a great deal ? Taxes, to be collectible, must be equitable, and not inflicted only for the benefit of a class. Secretary Windom’s screed against defrauders of the customs revenue reads like what was said in the days of medieval England, and by sovereigns of the houses of Tudor and Stuart, and in the early days of the house of Hanover, before Peel and Gladstone put decency and good sense into the system of British taxation. And now what is the answer to the second question asked at the beginning of this article? It can be seen in Blackstone, and in every accepted writer on the constitutional history of England since the days of Henry VII. We will quote from the early pages of Hal- lam, which describe the boundaries that determined the prerogative of the sovereign, the liberty of the people, and the rights of the taxpayer : “The essential checks upon the royal authori- ty were five in number: (1.) The King could levy no sort of new tax upon his people, except by the grant of bis Parliament. (2.) The pre- vious as-sent and authority of the same assem- bly were necessary for every new law, whether of a general or temporary nature, (3.) No man could be committed to prison but by a le- gal warrant specifying his offence, and, by an usage nearly tantamount to constitutional right, he must be speedily brought to trial by means of _ regular sessions of jail delivery. (4.) The fact of guilt or in- nocence on a criminal charge was de- termined in a public court, and in the coun- ty where the offence was alleged to have oc- curred, by a jury of twelve men, from whose unanimous verdict no appeal could be made. Civil rights, so far as they depended on ques- tions of fact, were subject to the same decision, 65.) The officers and servants of the crown, violating the personal liberty or other right of the subject, might be sued in an action for damages to be assessed by a jury, or, in some cases, were liable to criminal process; nor could they plead any warrant or command in their justification, not even the direct order of the King.” The first of these checks the Treasury has violated since Harrison came to power. The fourth and fifth Mr. McKinley, egged on by the Harrison Administration, proposes to overthrow in this country. PRESERVATION OF THE YOSEMITE VALLEY, AuTHOoUGH the esthetic sense is the highest product of civilization, and less developed in the average man than even the moral sense, it has on occasion proved a victorious antagonist of even. the utilitarian and busi- The Nation. {| Number 1284 ness instinct. Were it not for the senti- ment for the beautiful and sublime, Niagara Falls would have been utilized long ago for flour and saw-mills, and the geysers of the Yellowstone Park converted into Chinese laundries and steam factories. But perhaps in these cases a patriotic pride in having the biggest wonders in the world codédpe- rated with the «esthetic sense in securing the desirable result of Government protection. An opportunity will soon be afforded for a fresh exercise of these sentiments. It is be- ing gradually recognized that a mistake was made by Congress in 1864 when it reserved merely the Yosemite Valley and its immedi- ate surroundings as a public park, and placed it under the protection of the State of Cali- fornia. Perhaps it would have been better bad it remained national property, like the Yellowstone Park. But one thing is certain —the grant should have included a much larger territory. Those who have visited the Yosemite, and have had time to inspect not only the valley itself, with its precipitous surrounding peaks, but also the neighboring cafions, cliffs, and lakes, or who have read a description of them in Prof. Whitney’s ad- mirable manual (now unfortunately out of print), are aware that the Yosemite Valley is merely the grand climax of a series of cumu- lative natural wonders which make the heart of the Sierra Nevada Mountains the most romantic and sublime region in the world. It needs no argumentation that these neigh- boring wonders also should be reserved for all time as national property, for the benefit of the thousands who in future generations will spend their summers here in pursuit of health and pleasure. At a meeting of the Yosemite Commis- sioners last June, it was suggested that the National Government should enlarge the Yo- semite grant, making it include about fifty square miles instead of eight. Unless this is done, the lumber-men will ere long despoil these wonderful mountain-sides of their su- perb forests, as they have the shores of that gem of mountain lakes, Tahoe, for the pur- pose of supplying Carson City with fuel and Virginia City with planks for the mining shafts. It is expected that Senator Stanford will introduce a bill during the present ses- sion of Congress in accordance with the sug- gestion of the Yosemite Commissioners, and if this is done it should enlist the active sup- port of the entire press of the country, for it must be borne in mind that the disappear- ance of forests in the vicinity of the Yosemite would cause the snow to melt much sooner, and thus dry up very early in the season the many waterfalls which are the chief glory of the valley. The laudable action of the Yosemite Com- missioners in urging an additional grant cannot, however, disguise the fact that the past management of the valley has been open to serious reproaches, The sensational attacks on the management printed last winter in a San Francisco newspaper were too obviously prejudiced and exaggerated to do any good. But the January number of the Century contains an editorial article and letters by Mr. R. U. Johnson, G. G. Mac- kenzie, and Lucius P. Deming, which give a startling picture of errors of commission and omission in the treatment of the valley. What takes the matter entirely out of the field of controversy, and shows that the allegations are bare facts, is the cir- cumstance that Mr. Johnson is in pos- session of about a hundred photographs on which the sins committed in the valley are recorded indelibly. We have seen these photographs, and can testify from them and from personal observation last May that the strictures in the Century are not exaggerated or fanciful. Notwithstanding the Congres- sional enactment that ‘‘ the premises shall be held for public use, resort, and recreation,” a portion of the floor of the valley has been fenced in and the ground made to bear, in- stead of the beautiful flowers and grasses which naturally clothe it, hay for the horses of the transportation company, although it has been proved that the hay could have been more cheaply brought in on wagons, Horses and cattle have also been turned loose and allowed to trample down the wild azaleas and other flowers that constitute one of the special attractions of a trip to the Yosemite. Some of the finest trees have been needlessly destroyed, and Mr. Mackenzie writes that ‘‘ there are places in the valley where one is forced to wonder why the axes themselves did not turn and smite the men who were putting them to such base uses.” Mr. Johnson writes that ‘near the Yosemite Falls an unnecessary swath has been cut through the forest, to the sacrifice of some of the noblest oaks in the valley, the bolis of which lie where they were felled. The object of this is repre- sented to have been to open a vista from the bar-room of Barnard’s Hotel, to rival the natural view of the same fall from the Stone- man House.” Among the artificial attractions of the val- ley last spring were the carcass of a horse, and several huge piles of cans, one of them just behind the chapel, where all tourists pass on their way to Glacier Point. The State hotel was so badly constructed that it has been condemned as unsafe. One of its outhouses is a pigsty, which is sometimes so offensive that tourists are obliged to leave the piazza. The hotel is surrounded by a field of blackened stumps, and its location is as inconvenient as possible to all the chief sights, obviously to compel tourists to hire carriages or horses. The roads and bridges are laid on the principle of convenience, with- out reference to specially artistic view-points ; nor are there any foot-paths or benches. It is said, however, that the poetic Governor who is at the head of the Commission, has suggested the introduction of horse-cars for the convenience of those who are too poor to hire horses; and an active member of the Board has threatened to cut down all the trees under thirty years old, because ‘‘ under- wood” is dangerous in case of fire; in reply to which it may be stated that dead logs and heaps of dry busbes, which are much more liable to spread a fire than green underbrush, are lying about every- where. Some of the grossest nuisances in the valley will doubtless be remedied now that the venerable pioneer, Mr. Galen Clark,

Page 9

Feb. 6, 18go] has been appointed guardian; but after all he is only an executive officer subject to the orders of the Commissioners. These Com- missioners receive no salary, and meet only twice a year, and cannot be expected to give to the valley the attention it needs. It is therefore imperatively necessary that a sala ried landscape expert be appointed to super intend the valley, and a provision for his salary should be included in the proposed new grant. PARA, THE PORT OF THE AMAZON, ParA, Brazil, December 25, 1880. To the radical, positive-minded American, determined at any cost to have something definite, to know at least the altitude of his star of destiny, Brazilian politics must, it seems, continue inexplicable, guided by a spirit whose motions are to him incomprehensi- ble. At a distance of 3,000 miles, some dim ness was to be expected in our view of the situation. tive plans of reorganization which despatches failed to reveal. We could not but hope that great things were rapidly evolving out of the old imperial system. We looked forward to witnessing the stir of a new-born era. But, landed here in Parad, the signs of change and reconstruction are yet more indistinct, as a dim picture examined with a lens loses even the forin which appeared to the unaided eye. The recent history which Brazil has been making for herse/f is a series of unaccounta- ble acquiescences, We were ready to infer many ac An Emperor is deposed by a soldier in the name of the people. The Em- peror bows, gives his benediction, and departs. There is no grand rallying of the populace fol lowing this event, no enthusiastic ratification meetings—merely a quiet acquiescence, accom panied with some surprised rubbing of the The work the Republicans had contem- plated doing in some uncertain future was ac- complished for them, and they naturediy and accepted it. Next comes a de- cree from the Provisional Government declar- ing universai suffrage. This might be fraught with grave consequences if there were elections pending, but what matters it when there are no elections—none even called as yet? In al- most any other portion of the globe there would have been need for the Government to show good cause for so arbitrary a proceeding. Here it only occasions a shrug of the shoulders, and all bide the next rews from Rio. A Provincial Governor, appointed by Gen. Deodora da Fonseca, is the ensuing act. Dr. Justo Leite Chermont, at one time Brazilian Consul at New York, introduces martial law in Parad, as the incumbent of bonors from the President, seconded by a Vice-Governor, Dr. Paes de Cavalho, likewise of Presidential ap pointment. These are well-known, honorable, and trusted Paraenses, not eager for power; so martial law does not weigh heavily upon Para The Brazilians, drinking their café amid much animated political conversation, may seem on the eve of violent opposition; but political crises do not brew thus in Brazil. A smile passes around on the 14th of December when the eyes. smiled good- Provisional Government declares all foreigners |

resident within the country on that date to be | citizens of the new Republic. There is a secret joy over this, and the foreigners find no sym- pathy in their dilemma. It is a blow aimed at a class whom Brazilians—for a reason compre- hensible in the United States—cannot view with composure,

The Portuguese, coming in thou- sands, live and make money, and by and by re- The turn to their native land, having in no wise en- Nation. riched Brazil, and having never assumed any of the duties and responsibilities of citizens In the event of war this will at least render them subject to draft for the army. It remains to be seen whether the foreign governments may not have a word to say on this matter, if the case comes to an extremity. All that has been done has been by dictato- rial decree. Laws have been made, and suf- frage has been extended to thousands, from whom, whether advantageous or ruinous, it can never be wrested. Brazil is setting hard problems for herself to solve in the years to come. Meanwhile steps have been taken for a constitutional government, It that the Constitu tion will be, not only similar to that of the United States, but an exact copy of it. organizing is currently believed This ts a hasty conclusion of over-contident Republi eans, showing ignorance of our institutions, and of the buman which nurtured them They imagine that the same loom will weave soil the same fabric out of Brazilian tibre; in short, they fail to recognize the fact that, however faithfully they may endeavor to approach to our system, the conditions of life and the sccial Brazil give birth to peculiar national needs, with full cognizance of which their Government, be de traditions in to be stable, must signed. As a case in point, one rumor, recently circu- lated, has startled many people here, and eli cited some mutterings that savor of resistance The Provisional Government, in its alteration of the old rézime, has, it is said, taken under consideration the question of severing Chureb and State, northern Should this decree be issued, the Para and Amazonas in particular, might prove wanting in allegiance provinces, to the new Republic. These provinces have long recognized their great importance revenue-producing territory for the central CGiovernment, ment of the sugar practically ruined the trade of Ceara. Maranham, Ver- nambueco, and Bahia have tributary to them provinces of comparatively small extent, while as a Successive famines and derange

market have Para and Manaos are the depots for the pro- ducts of the richest valley in the world, whose Vast resources are accessible by pot less than 50,000 miles of inland waterway. Being fed thus by the great valley of the Amazon, « trolling the rubber market of the world, export- ing large quantities of cocoa furnish a hundred nuts, and spices, medicinal | perfumes, these cities, standi of the two provinces of the & position cacao), abe to articles of value, woods, lants, oils, and ng representative Amazon, occupy entitling them to = consideration

and respect. Their importance is enhanced by the Brazilian system of der ig support for the Government solely from export and import duties, and from fees of two princi- pal kinds, 1 } nere is no taxation or personal property, but when a piece of upon either real estate is sold, the purchaser is required to of 5 per cent. on

pay a fee to the Government

the selling price. All stores are obliged to ob tain a license, for which a fee is exacted, the amount varying with the kind of trade. The duties are extremely heavy; es upon cocoa portation of rubber perts, Parad and Manaos, cae that upon expurts

ubbe ard ex Amazon approxi- y, having a value of eing 25 per cent. ad valorem, that l4 per cent. he total rom the two amounts

mately tc tons a

in round numbers of 1,000, which alone would yield a revenue of $2,990,000. Of cocoa | 6,000 tons are shipped annually to France, worth in the aggregate about $1,000,000, yield- ing $140,000 revenue There are also exported

120,000 hect:

itres of > stan worth $500, (4% 4) tons vba n reis per pound, footing up $16.00 $15,000 worth of tonka beans, representing an expor tation of fifteen tons, together with t <, isin glass (from the fish Gumjuba), farina, ta, ‘ piassaba (invaluable for stiff brushes and brooms), and many more, sw g the sum so that, in the absence of exac’ statist it may still be safely estimated that the tax upon ex portations alone willexceed $4,000) (4% A still greater revenue is obtained from im portations, so that these two prov es st send not far from $ me) OM vearly to the public treasury at Rio de Jar This ft & population, exciusive {f savage | ins amounting to somewhat less tha e and s# half millions, is encugh to give these provi - a Vaiue to the nation such as ¢ tuse tl justly to feel entitied to consideration and spect, and toa voice in the Gov at rules them. Soit behoowes the new sto see well to it that disafTs ! * ir ise Gra» Para and Amazonas. It ts bn pet that their best interests wil “ prose d toy insistence upon the increased tax on rubble by which it is said the new Governn t is sought to subsidize a sing ANY, A tha a constitution will soon be in t Brazils into a united people for the moat . There are immense possi ‘satio for Brazil if legislation be only ected with in tellizence towards fa: tating (1 ve t f her gifts of nature. In Is t va the exports from Para was $1 424% sis small beside the outward ‘ *) but a comparis gross v ¢ alone ts “eptive The increase bas been in rubix \ In every other ise there as oo n arkeed decrease Cocoa in se davs brought 1 more than three cents per i Para, and Vet SA”) tons Were sent across the seas It is now worth over eig! Ss, al es ts Will not exceed 6,000 tons There were then shipped 44) tons of suga S tons of sarsapa r a. 12.000) bushels {fr 4° a es Ov feet of : av eo ese art cies appear Sof iading, save & paitry O00 hides. Rice is now t t from abroad toa country Which can produce a quality as fine as that of our Ca nas; « sh ito a prov abounding pastures; lumber forms the carg: from New York to a land possessing, in lavish profusion over thousands of square mules of unbroken forests, sixty-seven Varieties of the most valuable woods for structural pur in the world. Something radically wrong where such paradoxes exist. The answer the Nature's prodiga poses is far off as Kra- explanation of 1 efforts have t) files

1undone by restrictive tariffs, which have tied the hands that would have opened the re of the An to What Was raised was taxed; what was bought was sources

azon conimerce taxed; duty was levied upon the product of labor, and product; once more upon the payment for that so the world simply could not buy of the Brazilian, and the Brazilian had no- thing with which to purchase from the world. Thus the industries that were kindling into lif ife have been stifled; the cattle ranches have not prospered; cocoa plantations one by one have been abandoned to the encroaching fo- rests, and the chief occupation in the interior has become the gathering of rubber, a wild business, adapted to the Indian and partaking very little of that spirit of true husbandry which, by creating estates and wealth, gives dignity and strength, and builds up a class of | citizens fostering the arts and refinements of a | progressive and cultured age.

Page 10

108 Pard, instead of 80,000, migbt as easily fur- nish homes and employment for 800,000 people. Awaking from her dull, half-slumber, she might attain the prosperity which her position favors. The city is built within the angle be- tween the rivers Pard and Capim. Its cathe- dral towers above the red-tile roofs—a cathe- dral in name, but abandoned to the decay which speedily follows upon disuse. A fine architectural pile it is, however, and splendid buildings cluster around it and spread away to the south and east, with the domes and beltries of other churches rising above them, while the feathery tops of the palms wave over them all. Following the narrow streets, filled with men in cool garments of gleaming white, the north- ern eye is surprised at the sight of rows of buildings faced with glazed tile of delicate hues of blue and brown and pink. It gives an appearance of elegance, of sumptuousness even, which is heightened in the residence portion of the city, where these exquisite houses, product of the combined arts of potter and architect, peep from the luxuriance of tropical gardens, overhung by palms, and embellished by sur- rounding clusters of gorgeous bloom. The streets here are wide, and rows of splendid mangos (dense, heavy-foliaged trees) arch over- head, forming these mblance of a nave wherein a cathedral twilight reigns throughout the sun- niest day. There is a singular charm about Pard, Its soft, balmy airs, laden with per- fumes ; its daily cleansing showers, quaint streets, and lovely vistas—all impress a new- comer with delight. But ever present is the dread thought of fever, the great bane of this favored spot. When at last thereshall be done here what has been done in Calcutta, and a system of sanitary protection, sewerage, and quarantine, vigorous to the ultimate detail, be adopted, then will Parad be perhaps the most delightful city in the world, THE TUDOR EXHIBITION AT THE NEW GALLERY. Lonpon, January 13, 1890. Last year at the New Gallery a series of his- torical exhibitions was inaugurated by a show of Stuart pictures and relics, which was no- ticed at the time in your columns, and which proved one of the most popular ever held in London. This year the Tudor Exhibition which has succeeded it promises to be no less successful. This success is not to be wondered at, since both shows have appealed less to the artistic sense than to sentimental and _histori- cal interests, which Englishmen ean best un- derstand. That which insured the popularity of the Stuart experiment was not so much the no small number of really fine Vandykes and Lelys as the plentiful supply of bits of hair and skreds of raiment of the Stuart martyrs and rakes. For those who then visited the New Gallery principally to see these relics, the Tudor Exhibition provides a very similar assortment. The tooth of Katharine Parr, the tippet, stained with blood, which Anne Boleyn wore at her execution, the baby clothes Eliza- beth made for Mary when the latter thought she was about to become a mother—these, and many other treasures of a like nature, will satisfy the expectations of the general public. But, on the other hand, the bitherto unparal- leled collection of Holbein portraits and draw- ings would alone give artistie importance and distinction to any show, however trivial. It is but fair to add that, even without the por- traits, this Tudor gathering would not be alto- gether trivial, since it also includes a fine dis- play of arms and armor, of coins and medals, of MSS, and printed books. Still, the fact re- = he | N atio n. [ Number 1284 maius that the chief artistic interest of the show centres about the Holbeins. Of course, the exhibited portraits begin be- fore the Holbein period, with Henry VIL, the first Tudor sovereign. But the small group which marks his reign is interesting (on the whole) historically rather than artistically. The pictures in this group which have also an art value are by Jan de Mabuse and one by Lucas van Leyden. But several attributed to the former artist were most probably never painted by him, or else have been all but ruin- ed by ill-judged restoration; while it is difficult tounderstand why Van Leyden’s ‘‘ Card-Play- ers,” noteworthy as it is for its brilliant color, its attempt to deal with light, the expression and movement of its figures, should be includ- ed ina Tudor Exhibition. The finest Mabuse is a portrait of Henry VIL, lent by Earl Brownlow, in which the color is unusually good; this and several others of the King show the same refined, sad, intelligent face, with jong, thin nose and firmly-set mouth—such a contrast to the coarse, sensual, brutal head of Henry VIII. The others are notable almost entirely either for their subjects—as, for exam- ple, the pictures of Henry’s mother, Margaret Beaufort, his Queen, Elizabeth of York, his sister, Mary Tudor, in which the convention- ality of the early painters is but aggravated by the stiff female costume of the day (the dia- mond-shaped head-dress reducing all the faces, young and old, to one conventional type), and the portrait of Prince Arthur of Wales, wearing the badge of St. John the Baptist, by an unkn wn artist, the only one of the young prince ... existence—or else they are interesting as historical or artistic curiosities, as in the case of the ‘Marriage of Henry VII. and Elizabeth of York,” which belonged to the Strawberry Hill collection, and which Walpole explained to his own satisfaction, but not at all to that of modern critics, who declare it does not represent a marriage, and was not painted by Mabuse, as he asserted; or the pic- ture of ‘‘Henry VII. and his family,” with the royal sons and daughters (as on so many old fifteenth and sixteenth-century tombs) kneeling in two rows behind the King and Queen, while in the heavens above are St. George and the Dragon and allegory enough to suit those modern artists and art critics who would reduce all art toa system of symbolism; or the portrait of Sir Thomas Wyat in prison, with the cat whose love he won, according to the old story, bringing him a pigeon. But it is only with the next reign that the portraits begin to be valuable as works of art for all time. Whatever may have been the faults of Henry VIII, he must at least be given due credit for having had the sense to appoint as court painter Helbein, whom he discovered when the artist was in this country visiting his first English patron, Sir Thomas More. Asa consequence, while, later, Elizabeth’s reign was destined to be one of the most glorious literary periods England has ever seen, Henry's proved one of the most brilliant artistically. His name is so closely associated with things which have abso- lutely no relation to art, that one is apt to for- get him in his character of art patron. But it is thus he figures at the New Gallery, where the walls of the largest room-- save for the small space reserved for Henry VII.—are hung with portraits (the greater number of note anda few masterpieces) painted during bis reign. Of these, fully one-balf are attributed to Holbein. That all are his work, however, is more than doubtful; there is nothing in many to suggest his technique, and never was a painter made responsible for so many canvases by lesser artists as he was. Some were proba- bly done by his pupils and assistants, and were never even touched by the master. To others his name was attached in a later generation, when it became the practice to call almost all portraits of that date Holbeins. Unfortunate- ly not a few, about the genuineness of which there can be no question, have suffered from long centuries of neglect and from restorers of larger enthusiasm than knowledge. But there still remain many in a fair state of preserva- tion, and it must be remembered that Holbein’s finest portraits were painted in this country, where he remained for years devoting himself so entirely to this branch of his art that Eng- lishmen are apt to overlook the fact that he also could and did paint subject pictures, for which, indeed, he is best known on the Conti- nent, There are three in particular here which, if they alone had been exhibited, would still have given the show its artistic distinction. The third Duke of Norfolk—from the Windsor Gal- leries—in velvet and ermine, with the wands of office, is a triumph of delicate modelling, ex- quisite finish, rich color, and dignified compo- sition, and is usually considered the best of the several Holbein portraits of the same nobleman. The Christina, Duchess of Milan, the simple, graceful figure in rich black robes, against a dark background, the hands twisting a glove, the sweet pale face set in a close-fitting black hood, is the property of the Duke of Nor- folk, but has for some time been hanging in the National Gallery, and therefore, fortunately, is one of the best-known Holbeins in the country. It was to this masterpiece that Zucchero refer- red when he said he had seen nothing so good in Rome. The third is the beautiful study of Sir Thomas More—not quite spoiled by the retouching of the face—with its fine feeling of repose and dignity, and bits of brilliant color in the costume; the one from which copies have so many times been made. There are innumerable Henrys ascribed to the same master, several of well-sustained au- thenticity. Though it is plain that Henry, with Elizabeth, attached chief importance to a faithful and careful rendering of his gorgeous dress—of the slashed doublet, the feathered cap, the jewelled bands—it was impossible for Holbein to make of him a mere figure of con- vention, such as Elizabeth became in the hands of Zucchero. For all his silk and satin gor- geousness, for all his insignia of royal office, Henry is every inch a man, and a very common, hopelessly sensual man at that ; for the German showed him with the honest realism with which he rendered all his sub- jects, though for doing so, were he a modern, he probably would have been treated in the same fashion as Bastien- Lepage when he really painted the almost equally fat and coarse pre- sent Prince of Wales. It is curious to contrast with Holbein’s frankly vulgar Henry the portrait of the same sovereign by Paride Bordone — the somewhat famous ‘ Henry VIII. with scroll,” painted in 1535, the year ‘“*the King commanded all about the Court to poll their heads ; and, to give them ex- ample, he caused his own head to be polled, and from thenceforth his beard to be knotted and no more shaven,” in which fashion his beard and hair are here treat- ed. The Southern painter, more refined in conception if net in execution, evidently sought to subdue the repulsive grossness of kis royal sitter, and to trim down his superfluous flesh, with the result, however, that common- ness and fat are, if anything, more pronounced. This painting hangs ordivarily in that marvel- lous old hall of the Merchant Tailors in the

Page 11

Feb. 6, 1890] City. Of all the Henrys by Holbein, one of the most noteworthy is the large, vigorous cartoon made for the mural picture destroyed with the Palace at Whitehall in the fire of 1698, and owned by the Duke of Devonshire; it con- tains portraits of both Henry VU. and Henry VILL, the latter in his favorite position, legs stretched apart, his ‘‘ good calf” arms akimbo. Scarcely important the “Henry VIil. granting the Charter to the Barber-Surgeon’s Company,” in which the King stands surrounded by seventeen figures, almost every face in the group stamped with an individual character. Holbein did not live to complete this picture, but the composition, as weil as the greater part of the work, is his. It would be here impossible, and perhaps useless, to mention the other distinguished ex- amples by the same master, but I must at least refer to several which are simply catalogued “Of a Man,” but which, asa rule, are marked by strong character, as if Holbein even felt greater freedom when painting ordinary mor- tals; and also to the ‘‘ Henry VIII., Anne Boleyn, and Others,” known as *‘ The Dancing Picture,” in which, according to Sir Peter Lely, the male figures were painted by Holbein, the female by Janet (Francois Clouet). I believe that in the National Portrait Ex- hibition of 1866 there were as many genuine and so-called Holbein portraits as there are now at the New Gallery. But that which gives double interest to the present show is the fact that it includes the marvellous collection of Holbein drawings from Windsor Castle, ex- hibited to the public for the first time. There are eighty-two of these drawings, many be- ing the original studies for portraits bung on the near walls, so that an unequalled opportu- nity is now presented for the study of Hol- bein’s methods, rule with colored chalks or crayons on white paper, which in many has been first covered with a pale salmon-tinted wash. In some a man’s hair or beard, in others a woman’s head-dress or the decoration on her collar, is worked out or suggested with pen and ink, now in a few bold, vigorous lines, and again by much careful work, expressing all the modelling of the head or the growth of the beard, or the design of an intricate pattern. In the simplest, as in the most elaborate, will be found the same breadth of treatment, sim- plicity and delicacy of modelling, reserve and dignity of pose and composition which charac- terize Holbein’s finished portraits, many of which were painted from these studies and not from nature. It can only be regretted that a collection so valuable to the student should not, instead of being hidden away at Windsor, be given to the nation and placed on permanent exhibition at the National Gallery or the Brit- ish Museum. After Henry VIIL. the artistic interest of the show begins to grow gradually less. Among the very few portraits representing the short reign of Edward VL. there are two by Holbein, who painted that monarch when he was a chubby baby, but as the artist died when Ed- ward was in his sixth year, the others attri- buted to him, showing the King as a Loy of ten or eleven or older, can hardly be considered genuine. Queen Mary’s reign does not boast of a large number of portraits. Sir Antonio More had become court painter, and he is sponsible for most of the pictures of the Queen arrayed in a dress which, for stiffness, can vie with Elizabeth’s more elaborate costume, and with a face strongly marked with the Tu- dor energy, developing into fierce cruelty in the curious ‘‘ Hungad Petition,” by Lucas de Heere. A smal! Philip 1, with the Austrian showing, less is The drawings are made as a cases re-

The Nation. mouth very marked, and a certain richness of color, is ascribed to Titian; and there is a cu- rious Cranmer, by Lucas Cranach, with parch- ment-like face, contrasting with the sensual features so conspicuous in all other paintings of him. When we come to Elizabeth's reign, we find the portraits far exceeding in number those of Henry VILI.’s per iod, but Zucchero takes the place of Holbein, with the result that the pic Whether, however, this Queen would ever have tures are of far less importance. sub- mitted to the frankness and realism of a Hol- bein, is a very doubtful question. In all her existing portraits—and she was if anything, oftener than Henry—even in those which show her as achild, she appears as a painted, mere royal dummy on which to hang the most marvellous costumes, the most gorgeous stuffs and rarest jewels. Set in by great masses of reddish hatr and enormous ruffs and head dresses, the face is invariably colorless, ex In her at which one and lifeless. is the pressionless, therefore, it portraits, dress looks, and Zucchero’s painting of costume, of brocades and embroidery, is simply wonderful. No pre- Raphaelite ever approached, or even attempted, such careful and accurate working-out of detail as that which one finds in his rendering of her hideous short, wide skirts of gold and silver brocade, her jewelled stomachers, her barre! like sleeves, her high-standing lace ruffs. His portraits of her might serve as working draw ings for the embroiderer or the silk-weaver at his loom. Perhaps the only one in which there is the least suggestion of something human is by the same artist, painted on the background of acabinet, on the doors of which are, curi- ously enough, the busts of her four courtiers, Leicester and Essex, Lord Burleigh and Sir Walter Raleigh. While the greater number of the Elizabethan group are characterized by the same artificial ity, they naturally are not without a very de- cided historical value. No matter how badly they may be painted, one cannot look with en tire indifference at Essex, with his ‘* goodly person,” or Sir Walter Raleigh, bearded and bronzed, his son standing at his side, or Lord Burleigh, or Leicester, or Lord Bacon, or the many other great Elizabethan courtiers, states men, and heroes. ing are unquestionably the seven reputed por traits of Shakspere. Hanging together are the doubtful Felton or Fenton portrait, ing the head, with its vast brow and without the familiar short beard of the others; the bet o, in which the painter of a face and bearing ; the fine Charicote head, the badly drawn ** Burbage” portrait, But of all, the most interest- just sh w- ter-known Zuccher courtiers gives him ‘ourtier-like the earrings which most ular ideal of heads of Ben Jonson, with full red lips and ruddy cheeks of Fletcher.” with a mass of yellowish hair falling about in confusion above a But it must be Holbeins, even these seem insipid enough. t Mr graphs of many of the Y) fully realizes the pop the poet, There are a’so two » and two ** Poet fair face with short, fair beard admitted that, after the One can but hope that Cameron, who made such su; erb pho

Stuart pictures last year, will preserve a simi- , . + } > Teed of the most notable in the Tudor lar record le i collection. His photographic studies often have the richness and color of mezzotint, and he has never surpassed his Stuart series. myself but little space in which But the is, the portraits lead so enormously in in- I have left to speak of the many other exhibits. truth terest that they first claim and hold one’s at- tention, while the other articles exhibited sonnt mount into so many hundreds, those of impor- and the one with-

1O9 tance often being lost in a sea of commonplace ness, that it is impossible really to look at them all. However, I must say a word about L most picturesque whicl the arms and armor ly fli the main hall zabethan was the ul all t ive been he finest

most glorious age in « collections in the country b Ore fri Baron de C wn nh. that of the n, considered the most beauti Famous suits of ike Oss

ful example in England, are here; an r to the vd gilt which must attract every visit

lery is that formed by the

A-pie armor worn by the Earl of Pembroke at the battle of St. Quentin, and the blue-stee elaborately gilt, lossal suit f De Mont morency, Constable of France, and the russet and gilt suit of the Duc de Montpensier, | broke’s two prisot at t sume battle, tl armor having from at day this remaine in hisfamily. Coming, however, fresh from t! reading f Mark Twain's * Yankee of King Arthur,’ It must be confessed that this armor, exquisite as it is in desiga and work manship, suggests chieflw the dis rt a awkwardness of the wearers l » are als many curious and te eX" WS ATLA the large collection of swords, raplers, a daggers, and queer old whe ck guns at pistols. While the selection f MSS . t show very great dis at any le sa ofticial documents a of i res ‘ in the cases of Pt { Books are to be see valuable tirst editions Missals, a Layman's Prayer-Books But these, as well as the coins and plat lL must at ast n the Cellini shield presented by Henry VIIL, and lent by the Queen-——would require a letter to themselves. Of the 1 . I do not purpose to say any > <A few, as for example Queen Elizabeth's famous fiddle, With its wea { ir -, al not wi it artistic merit ; but as a rule they bear to t

Holbeins very much the same rel the jewelled bambinos in Italian « to the masterpieces over the altars But though much that is trifling finds a place in these historical exhibitions, taken al together they have one advantage which can not be overestimated: they give the average ance to learn many things his country which he study for be able to

For, thanks toa strong and influer mmittee made up of leading names, wl Sngland count for so much,

with the sold Dillon as Secretary, all the great old English houses and royal palaces have been drained of their treasures— treasures often unappreciated even by their owners, which have hitherto been uncatalogued and ab- solutely out of reach of the common man. And nowadays so many of just such treasures, hitherto banded down as heirlooms in the old English families, are being dispersed, owing to the indifference or impecuniosity of their pre- sent possessors, and bought up by men of genu ine taste like the Duc d’Aumale, for example, that one such loan exhibitions will be even possible, N. N wonders if in a few more generations TO BE REMEMBERED. ALGIERS, January 1, 1800. ALGIERS is becoming a favorite winter re- sort for the English Americans. Its charming views, its agreeable climate, its inte- and resting people, its opera, libraries, schcols of science and literature, churches, shops, fur- nished and unfurnished villas, present an un usual combination, in which the attractions of

Page 12

110 a French capital are added to those of a half- civilized Oriental town, The mail steamer comes daily from Marseilles, bringing advices from Paris that are only forty-eight hours old when they reach Algiers. This week a new sign of progress has been seen, The great English steamer Orizaba, of more than 6,000 tons burden, came within the mole for the first time, making here its second stop on the long voyage from Plymouth to Sidney. As we drew near the shore in this fine sbip, and were surrounded by the boats of the Al- gerines, dressed in Oriental garbs and chatter- ing in a strange mixture of tongues, as we saw them fight and quarrel for the persons and property of travellers, it was easy to believe that these Arabs were descended from the pi- rates who were the terrors of this coast three and fonr-score years ago, We were not very far from the scene of those great achievements of our brave countrymen, Decatur and Bain- bridge, which preceded and led up to the sub- sequent victory of Lord Exmouth, and began the triumph of civilization over barbarism which the French at length effectually com- pleted. But except to a reminiscent eye there is nothing in the harbor or in the streets of Algiers to remind the American of the famous exploits of his countrymen. One-half of Algiers remains Moorish, while the fcreign half is as truly French as Marseilles or Bay onne—French in language, Jaws, schools, cabs, boulevards, newspapers, cafés. Thinking over the wonderful transformation of the tyrannical government of the Deys into the republican ways of France, I went on Sun- day morning into the English Chapel, which stands just within the upper walls of the city, not far from a statue which commemorates the exploits of Marshal Bugeaud. One of the guide-books says that the chapel is built ‘in the Anglo-Saxon style,” and I expected to find a very simple early-English structure, It is rather Romanesque than Anglo-Saxon or Go- thic. pleasing in appearance both without and within, and it was beautifully decorated at the time of the Queen’s Jubilee with a dado of Al- gerian marbles. I had hardly taken a seat when my eye was arrested by a large white- marble tablet inscribed with these words: WILLIAM SHALER, M.A., Consul-General United States of America at Algiers from 1815 to 1829. During his residence here he displayed great ability under trying circumstances. His valua- ble work, ‘ Sketches of Algiers,’ was translated into French, and served materially to insure the success of the Expeditionary Force which captured Algiers, In it the first suggestion was made that, in the event of any future opera- tions against this city by a Christian Power, the landing should be made at Sidi-Ferruch in- stead of to the East. He subsequently became Consul at Havana, and died there 29 March, 1833, at. 55. Erected as a tribute of respect to his memory by R. L. P. 1878 I almost rubbed my eyes as [ read this simple eulogy, signed with the well-known initials of the British Consul, Sir Lambert Playfair; and, as I turned around, another tablet, of red mar- ble, placed face to face with a tablet which commemorates the Queen’s Jubilee, arrested my attention, This read as follows: _In memory of a distinguished citizen of the United States of America ,Commodore Stephen Decatur, who, in connection with Captain W. Bainbridge and W. Shaler, Esq., concluded a treaty with the Dey of Algiers, thus being the first to break through the intolerable bondage in which many Christian Nations were held by the Barbary States. This tablet is erected 20 June, 1887, by citi- zens of the United States grateful for the privi- lege of associating this commemoration of their oe eee countrymen with the Jubilee of that Illustrious Sovereign Lady, Queen Victoria, who has made the name of England dear to children and to children’s children throughout all lands, There were many other memorial tablets upon the walls, two of the most interesting bearing the names of the celebrated African ex- plorer, Bruce, and the noble British clergy- man, Rev. Devereux Spratt, who would not accept the ransom from Algerian slavery that was offered him because he preferred to stay and cheer by his presence his companions in bonds, But my mind kept recurring to the Consul, William Shaler, whose name is not on every- body’s lips, like the names of Decatur and Bain- bridge, but whose brave services in this dis- tant land have been so conspicuously honored by her Majesty’s representative. I knew the name of Shaler and the general story of his career in Algiers, but I was curious to know more; so, early on Monday morning, I found my way to the American Consulate to inquire into the records which are here preserved. Here I found a representative of the United States, Mr. Grellet, who fully appreciates the honorable services of his predecessor, and who placed in my hands, with commendable pride, two large volumes, bound in leather, contain- ing copies of corsular accounts and of consular despatches during the official career of Tobias Lear, and of his successor, William Shaler. If I understood him correctly, later archives were sent to Washington long ago, but these two volumes were astray. At least, they were hid- den in Marseilles, and it is only within a short time that they have been recovered and re- placed in the Consular Office in Algiers, In addition to these books there are many original letters and papers pertaining to the American Censulate upon the Barbary coast. Among them are several letters cf Charles Folsom, who was Chargé-d'affaires at Tunis in 1818-19, and others which bear the signature of Commo- dore D, Porter. Sir Lambert Playfair, the Bri- tish Consul, has made ample use of these manu- scripts in preparing the later chapters of his book on the ‘ Scourge of Christendom ’ (London, 1884). ‘* Not a single document,” he says, ‘‘ con- nected with Lord Exmouth’s victory exists in the British Consulate, but the admirable de- spatches of Mr. William Shaler fully supply the deficiency.” ‘‘At my urgent solicitation, Mr. Alexander Jourdan traced them out, and rescued them from the oblivion of a garret at Marseilles,” This remark applies to one of the volumes; the other was recovered subsequentiy by Mr. Grellet. I have taken a great deal of pleasure in por- ing over these original records. Here are the items of ‘** boodle” distributed among the cour- tiers of the Bashaw, in addition to the stipends paid in person to ‘his Highness ” (as the bar- barian was styled by all the Christians), in or- der to secure his good will, or rather to lessen his animosity. Here are the memoranda of the interviews which the Consul had with the Dey. Here are copies of his official reports to the United States Government, and of bis private letters to James Monroe, the Secretary of State. Here is a narrative of the circumstances under which the treaty of peace was negotiated at the end of June, 1816—the first effective limitation of the power of the Dey by a Chris- tian force; and here is the diary which Shaler kept during the English attack upon Algiers a few months later. As I have no access to printed books, I do not know what parts of these documents have already been published, and so I hesitate about making long extracts from them, particularly as my object is only to bring to mind the ser- [ Number 128 vices of a forgotten Consul, who ought to be held in grateful remembrauce by all Ameri- cans, but especially by those who visit this salu- brious resort. Shaler was here in a very critical period, when piracy and barbarity were giving way to modern ideas of law and order, and he bore himself with dignity, manliness, and good sense, contributing not a littie towards the ad- vent of Christian civilization. In the official commission authorizing three Americans to negotiate atreaty with the Dey of Algiers, the name of Shaler precedes that of Decatur and Bainbridge. The two naval commanders had prepared the way for negoti- ation by their captures on the open sea, and the presence of a strong squadron in the Medi- terranean was a great auxiliary to the work of diplomacy. Nevertheless, it required vigor, tact, and bravery to bring the Dey to terms. All these qualities were manifested by the Ameri- can Commissioners, who compelled the Bashaw, in the course of two days after their arrival in the port of Algiers, to sign the memorable treaty by which the Dey renounced his claim for tribute or payments of any kind; agreed to restore the property which had been taken in violation of the former treaty; promised to re- lease the American captives, and to place the United States upon the footing of the most fa- vored nations, After this treaty was negotiated, Shaler re- mained in the position of Consul-General for a period of fourteen years, a period of innumera- ble difficulties and annoyances. In this difficult position he was of the greatest service not only to his own countrymen, but to the Europeans who from time to time required his aid. Lord Exmouth, the British admiral, warmly ac- knowledged these services at the time they were rendered, and so did Mr. McDonnell, the British Consul; and recently they have been brought to mind by the inscription which has been already quoted, and by the writings of Sir Lambert Playfair. Shaler’s other claim for remembrance—his sa- gacity to perceive, and good sense to publish his perception, that Algiers could best be attacked by European forces, upon the west, at a point known as Sidi-Ferruch, and not, where other at- tempts had been made, in front or toward the east—is traceable toa book which was published in 1826, and soon afterwards translated into French. His suggestions were acted upon by the French in 1830, when they made their suc- cessful descent upon this coast. There is good authority for saying that they used the volume of Shaler as a handbook during their famous expedition. Indeed, the contemporaneous papers show that Shaler, without any pretence or bravado, was a brave man, full of resources, conscious of the dignity of an American representative, undismayed in the presence of a cruel and un- scrupulous despot, able and willing to protect and shelter the people of other countries, as well as his own compatriots. He was a capital publie officer, holding his station contrary to his own preferences, for an inadequate com- pensation, under the most trying circum- stances, simply that he might serve his Gov- ernment and be useful to his fellow-men. To his firmness, tact, and intrepidity is largely due the abolition of Christian slavery in Algiers, and to him, indirectly, perhaps, the subsequent successful conquests of the forces of France. I have never met Sir Lambert Playfair, and it is doubtful whether these lines will ever fall under his notice ; but if they should happen to do so, { wish they might convey to him the gratitude of a small party of Americans, spending New Year’s Day in Algiers, who have bee ter the re} in Ar be evi ed

Page 13

Feb. 6, 1890] been instructed by him in an interesting chap- ter of their country’s history, and who admire the generous candor with which the British representative in Algiers has commemorated in such enduring ways the services of an American consul who might otherwise have been forgotten by the English, the French, and even the American visitors to this reconstruct- ed capital. a Ge Correspondence. THE SEPARATE PARTY COLUMN. To THE Epitor OF THE NaTIoN: Str: It seems to us in Massachusetts that you do not understand the quarter part of the evils of the method of separate columns for parties under the Australian ballot system. You say: “The objection to it is that it is in the interest of strict party voting, thus acting asa check upon complete independence of action by the voter in marking his ballot.” The real evils of this method are more fundamental. It de- prives the system substantially of its secrecy. A voter who votes a straight party ticket has to be inthe marking compartment but a few seconds, while one who votes independently, even as to one candidate, has to stay in the compartment oneortwominutes. Now, the question usually is, not which party a man belongs to, but whether he is going to vote ‘straight,’ or to scratch (for example) Gov. Hill on the Democratic ticket or some particular candidate on the Re- publican ticket. This the party workers can ascertain under the party-column system al- most as well as under the old system of party ballots. In Connecticut the it was told whether a voter voted his party ticket or alter- ed it was on the same principle—by noting the length of time spent in the booth; and it work ed to acharm wherever there were any active party managers on the watch. Another disadvantage is, that it practically admits the use of party ballots, because, as there has to be on the official ballot a blank column in which any voter may paste names, it is only necessary to furnish to each voter a blanket paster with the names of the party candidates or any combination that may be got up by a trade, and this the voter is quickly to paste on to this blank space, and pass through the compartment. Indeed, it may be an advantage for a party to make no nomi- nation for the official ballot, so that all its members must use the blanket paster. That pasters can be readily used with great success was shown in two of the city elections in Mas- sachusetts last December. But with the Massa- chusetts official ballot a blanket paster cannot be used, as pasters can only be put in the sepa- rated blank spaces at the foot of each list. The above objections seem to us the most serious; but, in addition, will there be wrangles as to who shall be entitled, as between Tammany and County Democracy, for exam- ple, to the regular Democratic column? The board that has the summary decision of this question will have a vast power in its hands — Yours respectfully, R. H. Dana. way not Boston, January 31, 1890. PARTY NAMES. To THE EprTor oF THE NarTIon : Sir: The communication from "J. J. J.,” in No. 1282 of the Nation, was in general sufli- ciently answered by thatof ‘‘C. B. W.,” which just preceded; but permit me toadd one specific point in reply. The In Columbus, Ohio, from Nation. which “J.J. J writes, is located one of the leading colleges of that State, who Lhave known a number of young Republicans and left Democrats, but I have never beard of a single men went there change in the opposite direction. This change is not dus to any influence exerted by those ofticially connected with the institution, but to an intelligent study of practical economic ques tions, added to the general liberalizing tendency of higher education. A great many young men learn while at college that party namesare less important than party principles, and that while the party names remain the same, party prin- ciples change. Naturally, these young men gravitate to that party which offers them a living principle. 2. dod." Republicans among professors and college stu- dents would estimate of the proportion of not have been extravagant ten ? but itis true nolonger. In one of years ago, the State universities of the West, in a strong Republican State, one-fifth of the Faculty are former Republicans who will no longer act with that party on national questions. There isno doubt that the proportion is greater in the large Eastern colleges. ONE OF THE CONVERTED, JANUARY 27, 1890, HISTORY AS IT IS WRITTEN. To THE Epitor oF THE NaTIoN: Str: It may be of interest to your readers to see the following extracts in close connection: During the last thirty England is full of wealth, years of her protective sys- of multifarious supply for human want in every kind; produce, tem, and especially during the twenty vears from 1Sv6 yet inglanais to 1846, Great Britain tn iving of tnantition creased her material With fifteen milifons of wealth beyond all prece- workers, understood to he dent in the comm the stronwes€, the « Va history of the worla. Her. est, and the wiilingest r development of steam earth ever had, power gave to every Bri some baleful fiat has gone tish workman the arms of | forth saying, Touch tt Briareus, and the tnven- not, ye workers, . . ho tive power of her mecha- ma» of you be the niclans inereased the better for it s is amount, the variety, and chanted fruir.’’ the value of her fabrics these successful skilfu beyond all anticipatior workers some two n Every year of that period lions sit in w TK HOUSES, witnessed the addition of poor law prisons, have millions upon millions of ‘outdoor relief*’ tlung sterling tothe reserve capi ver the wall to them, the tal of the Kingdom. workhouse Bastille being At that moment Great Bri- | filled to burst thrifty Scotland itself tain had reason to feel supremely content.—James there are scenes of G, Blaine, in North Ameri woe, and destitution, and can Review for January, lesolation, such as, one 1390, pp, 30, 3, may hope, the sun never saw before in the most barbarous reg menever dwelt Th s Cariyle, in Faust and } sent hap ritem in Surely the champion of a system which is so loudly asserting its love for the laboring man, saying that n to feel supremely must have forgotten himself in “Great Britain had reas: content ata ime when, t ‘as every schoolboy knows,” the destitution among the working classes Was general and most deplorable TanRIFF-REFORMER THE TREASURY ACT OF 1789. To THE Eprror or TRE NaTION: Sir: The ori c: sv creat- consist of a nal Treasury Act of 1 ed ap accounting department to r Auditor, a Treasurer, and a Register. This was apparently in imitation of the ordinance of September 11, 1781, ‘‘ for the ecution of the business of the the public ac Comptrolle , an more effectual ex Treasury settlement of and unts,” which established similar office ‘ you or any of vour res this system of The system what State or colony, if any, checks was borrowed ! requires the stating of accounts by one officer, their re their fling and the recording of the certified balances | vision and certification by another, va third, and their payment by a fourth, presentation of the settlement certificate itself, iby department, reciting the but upon a distir the head of the which warrant n *t Warrant issue settiement, ust be countersigned by the Comptroller and reeorded by the Register. In the multitude of checks there is safety W asHivaTos, DPD. C., January 2 Tse) THE SWiSS CABINEI To tHe Eprror or Tar Nation Sra: If enough has net already been said on the subject of Cabinet Government, allow me to point to a country where the Federal Execu tive appears to occupy ground midway between gressional avs the parliamentary and the cor tems. The Federal Council of Switzerland is a com mittee of seven members elected by the Federal Legislature in joint t. however. to S@SSIOH, Te serve as long as the majority pleases, but for a letinite term of vears, namely, thre: Of these officers, one is designated, also by the Legisisa ime as President ture, to act for one vear atat of the Confederation. Executive power, how ever, is not vested in one man but in the Con mittee asa whole. Individual discretion is of course called for in the admuinistrat { the departments, but in law the Counetl is su posed to act as a unit In addition te the routine duties of ex secretaries, the Committee is charg proposal of legislation; if has no autocratic rights of initiative, even within its own party Any member of the Chambers may move the submitted to the must be adoption of a bill, but all are Council for an opinion, and returned certain time The Budget is especia witbina ly its work. It may propose any class of legis ation. In short, all bills, whatever their source, at some time pass through the hands of the Council and are stamped with its approval or disapproval. on does not thereby escape the scrutiny of members of the Cham- bers. The representatives of the people may eXamine projects as much as they please, but, at some time in their progre:s, laws are re viewed by those who are actually in the execu tive saddle and comprehend their bearings upon eXisting institutions Members of the Cabinet have the right to explain their motions in either house, and are liable at any time to interpellation upon matters of public policy. When, however, bills urged or approved by the Council are rejected by the Legislature, the ordinary parliamentary result does not take The Cabinet is elected for a given time, and, being place. No one feels obliged to resign. established, are avoided. In fact, such a thing is hardly Men who have proved capable ad- thus sudden and frequent crises known. ministrators are kept in office term after term. Of the Cabinet of 1589 one had been in service since 1863, another since 1866, and nearly all more than one term. It is needless to mention the good effect of this on the conduct of busi- ness, This long tenure has been partly due to the fact that the same party, or some shade of it, has been in power most of the time; but par- ties have not always upheld the projects of their own ministers and have yet given them reélection. They have kept them in office

Page 14

112 vty he Na tion. [Number 1284 because they knew the business, and it has happened that good executive qualities have brought men of different parties into the same cabinet. Whatever may be thought of such a result, the chief objection to party government— violent and rapid changes of ministries—would seem to be overcome by a compromise which secures both responsibility to the majority in the Legislature and a known tenure of office. J. M. V. JouNns Hopkins UNIVERSITY. CHAUCER EMENDATION, To THE EpIToR OF THE NATION: Sm: Your kind words about Dr. Skeat’s edition of Chaucer’s ‘ Legend of Good Women’ will be approved by all that are glad to see the great poet made more easy of approach. In respect, however, of v. 415, the difficulty in scansion of which both you and Dr, Skeat speak, is not, i think, real. For this verse is but one of a somewhat large class of verses in which Chaucer gives double length to the second accented syllable of his pentapody, by cutting off the unaccented part of his second trochee. Thus the line, if the stress syllables be italicized, is found to read, * Yet hath he mad | lew-ed folk de-ly-te,”’ a form that demands no emendation. Here, while the first stave is iambic, the second is trochaic, a variation that Chaucer much loves; and the second stave has his favorite allitera- tion on L, The same syncopation of the second foot is found in vy. 91, 195, 218, 251, 272, 286, 342, 5 and 40 of the Prologue, and doubtless in many others, both masculine and feminine. In Shakspere also this form is common, e. g.: ** Poor Cassio’s smiles | gestures and light behaviour,”’ — Othello, iv, i, 103. **On horror’s head | horrors accumulate.”’ —Id. iti., i, 370, THOMAS R, PRICE. COLUMBIA COLLEGE, January 30, 1810, Notes. THE third and fourth volumes of Henry Adams's ‘History of the United States,’ which relate to Jefferson’s second Administration, will shortly be issued by the Messrs. Scribner. They an- nounce also ‘ Emigration and Immigration,’ by Prof. R. M. Smith of Columbia College, and ‘Literature and Poetry,’ by the Rev. Dr. Philip Schaff. Macmillan & Co. have nearly ready ‘ Prob- lems of Greater Britain,’ by Sir Charles Dilke, in two volumes; * Leaves from My Life,’ remi- niscences by Montague Williams of the Eng- lish bar; and ‘ Notes on American Schools and Colleges,’ by Dr, J. G. Fitch. They will be the publishers, in time, of a life of the late Edward Thring, by Prof. George R. Parkin of Frederic- ton, New Brunswick—the third undertaking of the kind now in progress. Cassell & Co. publish directly ‘Star-Land,’ talks on astronomy with young people, by Sir Robert S. Bail. The Diary of Walter Scott is on the eve of being given to the world; and the Memoirs of Marshal MacMahon are said to be in type, but for printing in an edition limited to the author’s family. The seventh volume of the ‘ Henry Irving Shakespeare’ (Scribner & Welford) includes five plays, with the usual prefaces and notes. The illness of the late editor, Mr. Frank A. Mar- shall, lessened his share in the work, but he had the good fortune to supply his own hand Respectfully, by that of Mr. Joseph Knight in the prepara- tion of the stage-histories, one of the interesting features of the edition, while Dr. Richard Gar- nett, Mr. Arthur Symons, and other friends give assistance in the introduction and notes. The work is of the same general high average of discretion and scholarship hitherto shown. We observe tiat Dr. Garnett argues earnestly for the theory that ‘‘ The Tempest” was written for the court in the winter of 1612-13, specially for the occasion of Princess Elizabeth’s mar- riage, at which time it was certainly perform- ed. This would make it the last of Shakspere’s plays, and his true farewell. Mr. Knight, however, upholds the earlier date of 1610, Dr. Garnett’s comments on this play have more originality and literary interest than bave characterized the other introductions. The illustrations are of the same inferior character as those that have gone before. Mr. Marshall’s death, on December 28, 1889, before the com- pletion of his enterprise, is much to be de- plored. The ‘ Mirabilia Urbis Rome,’ the medizval guide-book to Rome, makes its first appearance in English in the translation of Francis Mor- gan Nichols, under the title ‘The Marvels of Rome, or a Picture of the Golden City’ (Lon- don; Ellis & Elvey). This most interesting to- pographical and archeological relic dates from the twelfth century, and was in vogue in revis- ed forms for three hundred years. It consists of a list of the principal antiquities then ex- tant, a collection of legends, and a tour of the city. It has been published several times un- der the editorship of antiquarians, of whose text the translator has made use. He gives the work in its first form, but, by an ingenious arrangement of brackets, includes also the later additions of its revised forms, so that one can tell by the eye the different parts of the text. He also furnishes at the end five cognate papers—the ‘Marvels of Roman Churches,’ compiled 1375, an extract from the ‘Itinerary’ of Benjamin of Tudela, extracts from a book of ‘ Processional Routes,’ two topo- graphical bulls, the list of relics in the Lateran, and a map dating from medizval times. Co- pious notes are printed at the foot of the page. The volume is small and admirably printed, and bears every mark of competent scholar- ship. It possesses interest as a memorial of the guide by which scholars and pilgrims saw Rome in the awakening centuries of the revival of antiquity, and also as a record of the city while many ruins now gone were standing. The tone of the work, too, is an excellent illus- tration of the mind of the time, and its legends, though now grown familiar, are most attract- ive in their original simple and credulous form. The town meeting still obtains in Plymouth, Mass. (which, by the way, ‘‘ was never incor- porated, nor ever by any act of colonial le- gislation created into a municipality”). On April 4 it voted to reprint in one volume the earliest records of the town down to the eigh- teenth century, at a cost not to exceed $1,000, and in the expectation uf a sale which would make the treasury whole. This volume has just appeared in good shape, under the editor- ship of a committee consisting of Messrs, Wm. T. Davis, Arthur Lord, Chas, G. Davis, W. W. Brewster, and Thos. B, Drew—names which mean competency and accuracy ; and is for sale by W. B. Clarke & Co, No. 340 Washington Street, Boston. It covers the period 1636 (for the town was long without a clerk) to 1705, and has been taken verbatim from the original records, but with comparison of official copies made at various times. The enterprise will go on if the town is reimbursed, as it is to be honed it will be without delay. By far the bulk of the entries relate to grants and bounds of lands, but miscellaneous topics are not wanting, as, cattle marks, the killing of wolves and blackbirds, the impeding of the run of herring and other fish, the restraint of loose swine, tax rates, fort-building, etc.,ete. Fines were imposed for slack attendance at town meeting. There are several lists of voters at such meetings. A few notes, historical, topo- graphical, and etymological, have been added, and there is an index of names and things. The first publication in book form regarding the great Pennsylvania disaster of last May is entitled ‘ fhrough the Johnstown Flood, by a Survivor,’ namely, the Rev. David J. Beale, D.D. (Philadelphia: Hubbard Bros.). The editor has done his part simply and in good taste, and with much descriptive power, and for a just idea of the catastrophe nothing more will be required. There is a morgue record of names, but the numerous photographic illustra- tions are as little painful as possible, and not at all sensational. The third volume of Prof. Masson’s new edition of ‘The Collected Writings of Thomas De Quincey’ (Macmillan) embraces the London reminiscences; recollections of Lamb, Walk- ing Stewart, Edward Irving, Talfourd, Allan Cunningham, etc.; the account of DeQuincey’s estrangement from Wordsworth; the Story of a Libel, with Thoughts on Duelling; the Con- fessions of an Opium-eater, etc. The frontis- piece consists of three miniatures of De Quincey’s father, mother, and uncle, Col. Penson—his resemblance to the last-named (as to the mother) being greater, one would say, than to his father. There has been prepared and printed for the members of the Pan-American Conference a report upon extradition, which contains not only much valuable information, arranged in convenient form, concerning the practice and rules of various countries, but a most interest- ing discussion of the subject in a general way by Mr. John B. Moore, the Third Assistant Sec- retary of State. No available source of in- formation has been neglected in Mr. Moore’s researches, of which the fruits are now made accessible to all. His report contains in its 214 pages every extradition treaty or conven- tion of the United States with foreign Powers, To these he has added an analysis of offences, from which one can learn at a glance what In any given country constitutes an ex- traditable crime under our treaties with it. More than one hundred pages are given to the practice of extradition in foreign countries — every country with which we have a treaty being mentioned except Spain and Sweden - Norway. The introduction con- tains some important remarks and sugges- tions upon the questions: Should citizens be surrendered? Should a person surren- dered for one offence be tried for another, before he has had an opportunity to re- turn to the jurisdiction from which he was taken? Which demand should be first com- plied with when several demands are presented by different governments for the surrender of the same individual ? To what extent may a government intervene in behalf of one of its citizens who is in a foreign country and is made the subject of a demand of extradition by a third State ? The delayed October number of the New Eng- land Historical and Genealogical Register ac- companies the January issue. The definitive tracing of the Washington pedigree by Mr. Henry F. Waters in the former number is al- ready known to ali our readers, but a large amount of supplementary matter on the same topic is published in the January instalment of ee we ta

Page 15

Feb. 6, 1890] the ‘“ Genealogical Gleanings in England.” Here, too, we find wills and other data con- cerning the families of Oxenbridge, Whitting- ham, Snooks, Pawlett, Alsop, Fairewether, Jobson, Northend, Isham, Tookie, We remark also some genealogical notes on the Lees of Virginia, with a table, by J. Henry etc. Lea. The Book-Buyer for February has a note- worthy portrait of Mr. F. Marion Crawford, the novelist, who is said never to have been pictured in public before. The face will not disappoint his admirers, Mr. Paul Leicester Ford, in a privately print- ed pamphlet, ‘Who was the Mother of Frank- lin’s Son ?’ goes over the ground of what be ealls this ‘* historical conundrum,” a small contribution to its solution, not as de- cisive, but only as suggestive. A pampbleteer of 1764, writing ‘ What is Sauce for a Goose is also Sauce for a Gander,’ contrives an epitaph for Franklin, which points out “his Hand Maid Barbara, A most Valuable Slave, The Foster Mother of his last Offspring,” ete. At the beginning of the year the Johns Hop- kins Hospital] opened for the benefit of gradu- ate physicians five advanced courses, viz.: in Pathology and Bacteriology, with special labo- ratory advantages; in Medicine, including bed- side and dispensary teaching, laboratory work, and lectures; in Surgery, in Gynecology, and in Hygiene. Among the physicians admitted to this advanced instruction are three women, two residents of Baltimore and one from Chi- cago, ‘““A. T. L.” writes to us from Boston: ‘* Your reference, in your issue of January 16, to the Schuylkill Fishing Company as ‘ the oldest English-speaking club in the world,’ reminds me that we have in Boston a_ society, the ‘Scots’ Charitable Society,’ founded January 16, 1657, and which had its 255th annual meet- ing last month. The records of the first meet- ing, in excellent condition, are in the Society’s and makes possession,” — Mr. Bishop’s account, in the February Neribner’s, of the two or three writers of con- temporary Spain whom he met in Madrid, is frankly a sketchy article, and yet it may be worth while to point out a few inaccuracies into which he has fallen. His naming * Dofia Perfecta’ as Galdés’s ‘first’? novel will be rather surprising to the Spanish critic who recently said that the novelist’s genius was at once perceived with the appearance of his first work, ‘La Fontana de Oro,’in 1868. In fact, ‘Dofia Perfecta’ stands pretty well down the list. ‘ Miau’ is said to be his latest, though at least three have followed it. ‘ Miau’ was the latest at the time that the little biographical sketch of Galdds was prepared for the series of ‘‘Celebridades Contempordneas,” and it was from that account of the novelist, by the way, that both his photograph and the facsimile of his manuscript were taken, without acknow- ledgment, for the Scribner's paper. The peril- ous nature of the attempt to keep tally of the productions of writers of such fecundity as Spanish novelists, is also shown in the reference to the *‘ latest book” of Emilia Pardo Bazan, said to be ‘Los Pazos de Ulloa’; it really is ‘Morrifia.’ Mr. Bishop’s surprise at hearing of *‘ one Spanish woman at least who writes,” would have been somewhat tempered if be had seen the ‘‘ Notes for a Biographical Dictionary of the Female Writers of Spain in the Nine teenth Century,” now publishing in Espana Moderna, and already including several scores of names, though only down to the M's. —In a recent number of the North Ameri Review, Canon Farrar gives the reasons “‘ why The Nation. he isan Episcopalian.” He admits that in or- der to be the best of Christians one has no need to be an Episcopalian at all, and that Episco pacy has no reason to arrogate the title of the Church in any exclusive sense. But among the superiorities which he claims for the Episcopal organization one is progressiveness, and as a conspicuous illustration of this excellence, he points to the Church of America. He adds: ‘As regards the Church of America, I am told that alone, or almost alone, of the religious communities on the Western continent, it is steadily, if but slowly, adding to its numbers, lengthening its cords and strengthening its stakes.” The growch of American Episcopacy has been rapid. According to Bishop Perry, its standard historian, its communicants, who in 1853 were 105,136, after thirty years, in ISS or 1886, had become 407,481—almost four: fold. But while rejoicing in this increment, how could the Canon be blind to the advance of other American sects ¢ Hisown London ‘ States- man’s Year-Book’ shows him in the same co lumn with 407,481) Episcopalians, 3,716,000 Methodists in ISS5 more than nine to one. Has the Methodist increase shown a less percentage than the Episcopal? By no means. Thé Methodist progress, on the whole, has been more than nine times faster than the Episco pal, for there were many Episcopal churches in the country before the first Methodist church was formed. Nor has recent growth among Methodists been unknown, as Canon Farrar fancies. On the other hand, it has been faster than that Episcopal expansion to which he points with pride. Bishop Simpson sets down the Methodists in 1865 as 029,259, which is! than one-fourth their census, as given above, in 1SS5. ess Regarding Baptists, Presbyterians, Lu therans, Disciples, and Conzregationalists, sta- tistics tell the same story. The six sects which outnumber what Cburch of England seem likely to do so still. now most of them call the — A Sabbatarian Frenchman is not so very rare as might be imagined, if we are to believe the Réforme Sociale That periodical, which is the bulletin of the Societ: and unions, prints the programme and statutes of y of December 14 d'Economie Sociale, of the social peace La Ligue populaire pour le repos du Di manche,” and says in its editorial introduction to these that ‘‘ the unions having for their pro gramme the Eternal Decalogue have always putin the first rank of their desideran restoration of the Third Commandment.” Cer- tain the habit of dwelling fondly on the phrase ‘the religionists have been in Everlast- ing Gospel,” but the ** Eternal Decalogue”™ is quite another sort of thing, as well as a quite That Sabbatarianism, properly this or new locution. so called, should establish itself during the next century in France, or any where else, we do not think likely. however, in this connection, that the Ligue is lt is proper to note, not Sabbatarian in itself, though there are some Sabbatarians among its promoters merely a or the Turks, infidels, and hereti league f Sunday rest; and ‘s are d cluded in it, as well as Jews and Christians Especially it bas for an object to obtain one free day in the week for workingmen, demonstrate th e necessity and point « f will attempt to benefits of the Sunday from the view of hygiene, of morals, of the family, and of the No one doubts, so far as we know, that sill be a useful and praiseworthy under- , and the names that are signed to the ) ue indicate clearly the programme of the Lig the support of it comes from no single sect, or ¢ f party, or church. Among them are those o Jules Simon and Léon Say, of two Protestant Za the | pastors, of an apostolic missionary (a Roman Catholic of cours f several managers of railways, of the architect of the city of Paris, and of other persons of distinction in various callings. —For a hundret and fifty vears, Whiston’s translation of Josephus has held its place ‘ from its own merits than from scholars have shrunk from the labor of con structing a revised text and giving a new ren dering. For the ‘ War,’ indeed, we bave Traill’s which is fairly good, but for the translation, * Antiquities’ there has been up to this tim only Whiston. Pending the formation of a better text, a new translation has just been brought out in England (London treorve [ & Sons; New York: Serbner & Welford Whiston’s rendering being revised by the Rey A. R. Shilleto, and topograp! ul not ulded by Sir C. W. Wilson, whose geographical work in Palestine is well known. Mr. St to ithe translator of Plutarch’s ‘ Morals’) seems ¢ have done his work well, correcting W hist s errors and awkwardnesses of ler. ancl dealing freely with his notes, son fw are ridiculous This first instalment gives us the ‘Life’ and the * Antiquities’ in three handy volumes; tw n v sow soon follow containing the ‘War’ and the ‘Tract against Apion.’ The translater , added a few critical notes, and might profit ably have given more, pointing out Josephus's omissions and errors, especially as these have been made clear by recent discoveries ! it might be noted (i, $2) that he falls ¢ tion Gideon's ephod, that the tit Pharaol nh, Ah) is not now supp sol ft t mn kK that the Assyrian King Ful iii, 1) is genera lv identified with Tiglathpileser: that was not Shalmaneser t Nar w k Samaria; that the Assyrian k \ ‘ phus desertbes as besieging Tyr , . thought bw George Nmit His vy of Senna cherib, p. OF to be Sennacher that thist arch survived the disast. n Palestine ta little while’ ! twenty vears. Suet notes would take uy tle s ~ and would he very useful to. the x ral rt i t transiation, as st ts sa grea v ment on W hist and wi i itself t all students of Josephus rh wentv-first volume f Laslie St phens i onary f National Riography Macn an) ends with G ster The four Wreorges, wl are described with a frankness that does not spare the feelings of their num«e is living posterity, collectively receive fuller treatment than any other personages, averag An actor, Gar rick, gets neariv tweive Owen Glend wer gets seven, Gibbon, who is favorably summed up by Mr. Stephen himself, cets six. Other prominent names in this volume are William Gifford of the Quarterly Review (by Mr Ste] het John Gay, Gillr iv, Mrs. Gaskell, and Mrs. Gilbert (Ann Taylor). We should also mention Sir John Gladstone (father of the Prime Minister)—‘t Gladstones” until he got permission by royal letters patent February 10, 1835, to drop the final s. The fa mous Mrs. Hannah Glasse is shown, as the dic- tionaries have already admonished us, not to have used in her ‘ Art of Cookery’ the instruc- “First catch y¢ Her “Take y when it is . 2. skinned tions, ur hare.” words were, uur hare cased” Thomas Geeran was one of the false centenarians whom the late W. J. Thoms took delight in exposing Among pioneers here commemorated are William Gascoigne (i612 1644), who invented the micrometer and its ap plication to the telescope; William Ged (1690

Page 16

114 1749), who invented stereotyping; Dr. William Gibbons (1649-1728), who made mahogany fashionable in England; Joseph Gillott (1799- 18733), who first employed machinery in the making of steel pens; Thomas Girtin (1775- 1802), *‘the true founder of the modern practice of ‘ painting’ as distinguished from ‘ tinting’ in water-colors,” ** laying in the object upon his paper with the local Color, and shadowing the same with the individual tint of its own shadow”; and Joseph Glass (1791-1867), who humanely suppressed chimney-boys by his un- patented machine for cleaning chimneys (Act of Parliament July 1, 1842). Garrick, too, was the fir-t stage-manager in England to light the stage by hidden lights. There is also sometimes a distinction in being last, and Elizabeth Gaunt, whom William Penn saw burnt alive at Tyburn on October 23, 1685, for treason (she had given money to speed an out- lawed conspirator in the Rye House plot), was the last woman executed in England for a po- litical offence. Three names are especially as- sociated with America, viz., Sir Humphrey Gilbert, who planted the first English colony in this hemisphere; Sir Thomas Gates, that Governor of Virginia whose account of his wrecking on the Bermudas helped Shakspere to his ‘Tempest’; and the much-married Lola Montez (Marie Gilbert), who died in this country, but at Astoria, not at Asteria (p. 383). And since we close with mention of a typo- graphical error, let us revert to vol. xx. in or- der to point out (in the article on Gen. Thomas Gage) the printing of *‘ John Harvey” for John Hancock, as excepted from Gage’s offer of par- don, and the assigning the collision of April 19, 1775, at Lexington to the return march of the regulars. — The death cf Mrs. Prudence Crandall Phil- leo at Elk Falls, Kansas, on January 238, re- moves an historic figure cast in the same mould with John Brown, and an earlier combatant than he with the Slave Power. She died al- most to a day on the fifty-seventh anniversary of a decisive interview in Boston with the editor of the Liverator, regarding ber purpose toconvert her flourishing school at Canterbury, Conn., for white girls into one for black, hav- ing *‘for some months past,” as she had pre- viously written Mr. Garrison, ‘‘ determined, if possible, during the remaining part of my life, to benefit the people of color.” When these words were penned, such a profession — the most Christian, certainly, that could be made —was unpopular, odious, even ‘ unconstitu- tional.” It was especially resented by an or- ganization pretending to aim at the same ob- ject, viz., the American Colonization Society, whose local agent became at once the leading persecutor of Miss Crandall and her school. The story of this persecution, through inbuman boycotting and a law expressly procured from the Legisiature, making it penal to bring colored children into the State to be edu- cated, is too well known to be repeated here. The law was repealed in the course of five years, and its victim was, when past eighty, pen- sioned by the State by way of atonement. She lived to see slavery abolished by the war, and Kansas, her chosen home, peopled by colored refugees from the Gulf States with no law, Federal or State, to hinder. The spirit of caste, however, which evoked the opposition to her benevolent plans, has but little abated at the North since 1833: the higher education of co- lored Americans, though now obtainable in the first institutions in the country, still leads only to an impasse in most employments; political advancement is grudged them, and social equality denied absolutely. Moreover, the old ,

The Nation. colonization mania, now more preposterous than ever, is revived as the solution of the ‘* negro problem” at the South, where strin- gent statutes make intermarriage a crime and put a premium on illicit intercourse, and where the endeavor of white educators ‘‘ to benefit the people of color” is rewarded with social ostra- cism. Wonderful as was, therefore, the revo- lution witnessed by Prudence Crandall in her long life, it must be confessed that the peopie of this country, whatever party name they as- sume or whatever section they inhabit, are still leagues behind her simple Christian princi- ple and practice. —The Rev. Dr. Richard Frederick Littledale, who died in London on January 11, was not only a learned controversialist, but an ex- tremely witty and clever and versatile con- tributor to English newspapers and reviews. He had hardly passed beyond the bounds of middle life, having been born in Dublinin 1833, and having graduated at Trinity College in 1854 with great distinction. He began to write early, and his work with the pen has been continuous for nearly five and thirty years. His chief works of an ecclesiastical sort are bis ‘Commentary on the Psalms,’ a continuation of the work of his friend, Dr. John Mason Neale; a‘ Commentary on the Song of Songs’; ‘The Petrine Claims’; and ‘ Plain Reasons against Joining the Church of Rome.’ Under the same head may be put his ‘ Offices of the Eastern Church’ and a multitude of liturgical and ritual pamphlets and essays. Dr. Little- dale belonged to the so-called ‘tadvanced ” or Ritualist School of Anglicans, and was a merci- less and perbaps not always too scrupulous con- troversialist on its side. He never could be more than an advocate in writing upon any religious question, and his wit and great learn- ing and ready memory made him a very un- comfortable antagonist to meet. Many even of those who most nearly agreed with him must regret that he did not employ his great abilities and acquirements more steadily in constructive and permanent work. Dr. Little- dale was a regular contributor to the Academy almost from its beginning, reviewing in it for the most part novels and light literature. His ability to work was astonishing. Besides what he did with the pen, he was all the time active- ly engaged in clerical work and in lecturing, though for the last twenty-five years of his life he was the victim of an obscure spinal disease that kept him in constant pain. THE AUSTRALIAN ABORIGINES. Among Cannibals: An Account of Four Years’ Travels in Australia, and of Camp Life with the Aborigines of Queensland. By Carl Lum- holtz. Translated by Rasmus B, Anderson. With portrait, maps, four chromo-litho- graphs, and woodcuts. Charles Scribner's Sons. 1889, Pp, xx, 305. S8vo. Ir would be difficult to find a more perfect pic- ture of savage life than this account of the North Queensland black. It is written with great simplicity and directness, and with a descriptive power which is shown especially in the individuality given to the natives. In most books of travel people of a low type have rare- ly more separateness than the different mem- bers of a herd of cattle, while the companions of Prof. Lumholtz, Willy, Jacky, and Yokkai, are as distinct personages as Robinson Cru- soe’s Friday. This fact alone furnishes strong evidence, not only of the carefulness of his observations, but also of the truth of his de- scriptions. His familiarity with native life Was not acquired easily. For more than a

[Number 1284

year he lived with the blacks, sharing their grass huts, eating their food, enduring their unspeakably repulsive habits, in constant peril of his life at their hands. One can scarcely imagine a more self-denying life, more full of privations, which were the harder to bear as all the comforts cf civilization were meanwhile close at hand. Such enthusiasm in the pursuit of knowledge the reader cannot but feel was wor- thy a higher reward even than the adding four new mammals to the fauna of Australia, and the raising of an enduring monument to a race which, but for the writer, would in a few de- cades have perished without leaving a trace of its existence. Prof. Lumholtz went tv Australia in 1880 to collect for the museums of the University of Christiania as well as to pursue studies of his own. After spending several months at a cat- tle station near Rockhampton, in Queensland, he went some eight hundred miles into the in- terior. The regions visited did not, however, prove favorable for his purposes, He found that the monotony of the inland scrubs, ‘* with their gray or brown masses of stiff, often shadeless trees,” was ‘rarely broken by the sight of a bird or any other living thing,” while the hardships from the fleas and the flies, the bad water, and the heat, were very great. The natives, he says, ‘* astonished me by their bodily structure; neither before nor since have [ seen them so tall, and upon the whole so well nourished, as in the tribe near Elderslie. Some of the women were even monstrously large ; their hair was generally straight. Their food consisted chiefly of fish, snakes, rats, and clams.” The native police in this region showed great skill in throwing the boomerang, and the au- thor suggests ‘“‘ that the idea was discovered in their games.” He says: ‘I have frequently seen them fold the leaf of a common palm into a square, give the two corners a little twist, one to each side, aud throw it into tke air, making it skim round and return. <A white man told me that his black boys, while round the camp fire, used frequently to amuse them- selves with the leaves of the Brigalow-acacia, which have a striking resemblance to the boomerang. They gave them a flick with the finger, causing the leaves to start off, but to re- turn in the same manner as the boomerang.” This weapon is of two kinds, the one plain, the other returning. The former only, which is far less curved than the other, is used in war or in hunting, as *‘it is impossible to aim accu- rately with the returning boomerang.” Being obliged to relinquish further researches in this region, Prof. Lumholtz took up his quar- ters at a deserted cattle station some forty miles from the mouth of the Herbert River in North- ern Queensland. It was apparently some two days’ journey from the nearest sugar planta- tion, so that, except for the white keeper of the station, who was not many degrees above his black neighbors in refinement, our traveller was entirely dependent upon the natives for companionship. The country was parcelled into districts called ‘‘lands,” each of which was inhabited by a tribe of blacks, who rarely went outside the limits of their own land. <Ac- cordingly, whenever Prof. Lumholtz wished to hunt in any district, it was absolutely neces- sary to obtain the help of some of the tribe to which it belonged. This added both to his diffi- culty and to his peril, as the further he went from the station, the wilder were the blacks. These were divided into the ‘ civilized” and the ** myall,” or savages, upon whom the for- mer looked with great contempt. To be civil- ized, however, it is only required that they should *‘ know that they will be killed if they

Pa h

Page 17

Feb. 6, 18go]

murder a white man, to be fond of wearing the garments and ornaments of white people, and to smoke tobacco”—certainly a not very ad vanced stage of civilization. Friendiy relations having been established with the tribe in whose land the station was, by judicious presents of tobacco, which takes the place of money with them, Prof. Lumboltz im- mediately began to collect. He found traces of what seemed to be two mammals un- known to science, and a keen search was at once instituted for them. It was his intense desire to obtain specimens of these creatures, called by the natives the ‘“‘yarri” and the ‘*boongary,” more than a purpose to study human nature in its most degraded and repul- sive form, that led him to endure the priva- tions and dangers of a fourteen months’ close companionship with the blacks. His fruit- less efforts to obtain either in the mountains near the station, led him further and further afield, until at length he found himself alone among tribes which have never before come in contact with a white man. Although they were treacherous and thoroughly untrust- worthy, the only precaution which he took was to regularly fire off at night his revolver (the baby of the gun,” the natives called it), giving the impression to his companions that he never slept. He secured at length one spe cimen of the yarri, which proved to be a rare, but not unknown, marsupial tiger-cat. As the blacks insisted that it was a small one, the au- thor is ‘‘convinced that there exists a large animal of this kind that has not yet been dis- covered.” This speciinen, however, was near- ly three feet long from the snout to the tip of the tail, apparently much larger than those previously described. Prof. Flower, for in- stance, speaks of it as the sizeof a common cat. With respect to the boongary, Prof. Lum- holtz was more fortunate, though bissearch was much more protracted. He bad hunted for it many days in vain when his companions sud- denly declared that it could only be got with a dog. This want it was not easy to supply, as the Herbert River blacks bave very dingoes. These as a rule are of pure blood, being rarely bred in captivity; they are found as puppies in the hollow trunks of trees and carefully reared, and not all receive the special training needed to hunt the boongary. When, with the aid of a dingo, a specimen of this ani- mal was finally procured, it turned out to be a tree-kangaroo of a species simiiar, though more variegated in color, to those inhabiting New Guinea. The skin of the first one captured was unfortunately devoured by one of the camp dingoes, but several others were taken, which Prof. Lumholtz succeeded in carrying safely to his headquarters. His main object being accomplished, ke returned to the coast and io civilization. The North Queensland black is regarded by our author as the lowest of the human race in point of culture. With this assertion we can hardly agree, although very likely none lower have been so carefully observed and fully de- In both Central and South Africa, and, if we are not mistaken, in New Guinea and some of the East Indian islands, to say nothing of Tierra del Fuego, there are tribes distinctly below the Australian savagesin intelligence and habits of life. The latter, for example, though living upon the grossest food, almost invariably cook it, never eating raw meat Fire is made in a few seconds by what Mr. Tylor happily calls the firedrill—that is, by twirling a stick rapidly between the hands on a soft piece of wood. with patterns shield, and thus constitute his coat soon few scribed. They ornament their shields ‘differ in each (which f arm Or arm

The Nation. and can draw pictures, though only of the crudest kind, yet ‘‘ still not without symmetry, the left side [of some human figures] was pre- cisely like the right.” expressionless ferent melodious,” though they have Their songs are not mere sounds, but are words set to dif tunes, a few of which are * tolerably a better ear for rhythm than for melody. ‘It is a remarkable fact that they themselves sometimes do not un derstand the words which they sing, the song having been learned from a tribe which speaks another dialect. Thus a good song will travel from tribe to tribe.” small, ‘their language is rich in words describ- While the vocabulary is ing phenomena that attract the attention,” there being various names, for example, for flame and coals. A rude form of sign language also exists among them. They send infort ** by the aid of tigures seratched on

ation to other tribes four The which & ‘message stick’ made of wood, about to seven inches long and one inch wide.” men plait baskets—the women never are ‘‘ wonderfully tine and stroug, and are often painted with red, vellow, or white ochre, and sometimes with stripes or dots of human blood the arm.” Now, all this implhes a condition many which maker takes from his own removes above that ot the lowest of the human race The Queensland blacks resemble the Bush but, singularly f the of men In many particulars, enough, have no knowledge bow and arrow, the principal weapon of this African tribe. when hunting in the serub, killing by flinging sticks of wood at it used in a wallaby hunt, their duels or tourna One of In fact, they rarely use any Weapons their prey Spears are and huge wooden swords and shields in ments, as they might be called these ‘* borbobys,” in which the members of d fferent

tribes engage, Was witnessed by Prof. Lu holtz, who describes it with great vivacity The raen fight in pairs, using a sword so heavy that the to let the weapon rest in front on the ground a few mo combatant is ‘* obliged ments before the duel begins, when he swings it back and past his head against bis opponent When one of them bas made bis blow, it opponent's turn, and thus they exchange bh is his wes

until one of them gets tired and gives up, or his shield is cloven, in which case he is regarded as unfit for the fight.” ‘*all disputes and legal conflicts were settled, not only between tribes, but also between indi-

viduals,” bloodshed is rare, though manv wo- men change husbands, the victor taking pos session at times of his opponent's wives. They know of but one crime (save the murder of a member of the same tribe), viz, theft, and the is the stealing of most common theft **Inchastity, which is called gqramma, & e., t steal, also falls under the head of theft.” As the women largely exceed the men in number, the more powerful or richest of a tribe have several wives, whom they generally treat kindly, and some even generous!y Thev are

fond of their trait of be towards tl ing } who are ill.” Prof. Lamholtz, ose however, regards them

In these combats, where | as Very treacherous, and incapable of the sentiment of cratitud There was but one among them all who showed the slightest signs of achment to him, not- withstanding his constant efforts to win them by liberal gifts of food and tobacco. At last he felt that there were few who would not have | 7 - } } r } ieh * killed him, if they had dared, for a stick of tobacce.

Their tribal lization is very loose, anv man leaving his ea ng another if } ‘ ses, and without any acknowledged chief or bead man. The most intlaential, ac

_— -) 11 cording to our author, is o

ften the one who is most skilful in procuring fa/gore, & ¢«, human flesh. Although he gives many instances of their cannibalism, vet it is to be noted that he himself apparently never witnessed an upon any direct traces of a human feast. 1 regard to the religious neeptions of the na tives on Herbert River, Prof. Lum tz savs “It is my opinion that they do not believe in any supreme good Being it y ad n and it was even difficult for them to cive anv definite a unt of this dev On tl ther hand must be admitted that the natives ar Very reluctant fo giv any ition in: gard to their reliious beliefs. Thev look upor them as secrets not to be divulged to persons not of their own race Their n bers are rapidly diminishing under the mbined i fluence of oj introluced by the ¢ exe and the almost universal prostitution and sequent barrenness of the w en, AS s As they come into contact w the w es We have left burt litth spa t s NN ft rs contributions to other depa ts of et He breu . with " " eve bur Tredd spe ns of birds, a larg bet ! reptiles ind batra % t s tishes, als Soe M4 S aha Ser at ‘ He discovered four new nt is a tre ha garoo, and three opass s Inan apr \ is given a short account the flora ar ‘ : the country The book fs ps isely and ex cellently illustrated, a: ntains ¢ 1 may ind an index DR. GRISANOWSAI Dr. EL G. FB. Grisanowski > Mitthe gen aus seinem Leben u Hse t 1 Briefen \ } . Melena Hanoy ‘er XX \ Seef Pp su Tuts is a sk ) ¢ , avery ® _ ing man, who, had he bad an e selfishness, less modesty an resery wou have had a world-wide reputatior It is writ ten by a warm friend, Mn Esperat 6 Schwartz, a lady of German parentage but English citizenshiy It consists also of letters written chiefly to herself during a friendshiy f forty years, Some mav perbaps sider ! has t th thor's r estimate f the subiect i ary e of friends 1d acquaintance in Germany, England, and America will bear testimony to their truth Ernst Grvzanovski (or Grisanowski, as the name is usually written) was born in Konigs berg, in 18/4 He was of Polish descent, al though his father and grandfather were also Konigsbergers, and of course Prussian subjects -entfered the University at K , be fore he igsberg, and Is45 was twenty-one, received the of Philosophy, ics and after an ex wrote ls re TiC ahs bl of he Uni mat Ody in He Hegelian } t losoy hy guaces wa a deep student the After leaving t versity be went to Berlin, where he was well received bv the Minister Von Caunitz; but it was two years before he obtained an appointment In 1847 he to the Legation in Rome, and there acted as Secretary to the 2 t< was mede attache Prussian mbassador Von Usedom, It was here that, in the following summer, he met with M. and Mme winter in Algeria, to take up their residence in de Schwartz, just returned froma Rome. Those were stirring times in Italy. petite for freedom naturally grew with its food, and reports of popular risings kept the usual influx of strangers ata low ebb Grisanowski The ap- and his friends were on intimate terms with Von Ke-tner, the Hanoverian Minister, and Geheim

Page 18

[ Number 1284 116 rath Alertz, physician to the Prussian Lega- tion. These gentlemen had easy access to Antonelli, and even to Pope Pius himself ; and to them at least it was no surprise when, after the assassination of Rossi, his Holiness left Rome on the night of November 24 in the suite of Count Spaur, the Bavarian Minister, wear- ing the livery of his servants, and fled to Gaeta. The legations all followed, and our Doctor was obliged to take up his residence in Mola di Gaeta, an exile from his beloved Rome. That his situation was not agreeable appears clearly enough from bis letters, which partake of the flavor of the lemon-juice with which, for secrecy, some of them were written. What happened in Rome after the Pope’s flight is generally known. Mazzini proclaimed the Republic, and Garibaldi prepared for the defence of the city against the French, Louis Napoleon having undertaken to reinstate Pius IX. He found it more of ‘‘a big job” than he had expected. After a few months in Gaeta Grisanowski left for Berlin with despatches. By this time he had become disgusted with diplomacy, its tortuous ways little harmonizing with his direct nature. In the following April he threw up his office, and writes triumphantly from Berlin: ‘* Jtaliam! Italiam! I am free.” He found his friends in Sorrento, who had ma- naged, with the help of Kestner and Alertz, to escape from Rome in the night. Kestner join- ed the party later, and a very agreeable sum- mer was passed in that earthly Paradise. It may be interesting to the lovers of Goethe to know that Kestner, then an old man, was the son of Werther’s Lotte, famous for cutting bread and butter. After a residence of two or three years, part- ly at Rome, partly at Genzano, supporting himself by teaching mathematics, Grisanow- ski decided to follow a taste which had always been strong with him, and began the study of medicine. He studied in Pisa, Mcntpellier, and Heidelberg; and at the last-named univer- sity took his degree of M.D., ‘“insigni cum laude,” in 1855. He practised his profession at different periods in Florence, Pisa, and Leg- horn. His residence at Florence was for him a very agreeable one. He found there a con- stellation of literary stars, e. g., Savage Lan- dor, the Brownings, Trollopes, Villaris, Mi- gnatys, Miss Cobbe, Donati, Karl Hillebrand, Louis Eblert, ete. This was a society that could well appreciate him. With Americans, too, he bad the pleasantest intercourse, and the Motleys, Storys, Crawfords, Nortons, Lowells will all bear witness to the learned Ductor’s various accomplishments. He removed to Pisa on the invitation of the English Consul, the official physician there having died sud- denly. In 1865 he married an English lady, Miss Wright of Exeter. If, as his biographer says, he sought happi- ness, late in life, in marriage, he certainly found it. Whether he chose wisely in his pro- fession, may be doubted. It was the science that attracted him so powerfully, but he was ill-fitted for the practice. In a shifting public, like the foreign population of an Italian town in winter, it is hard to establish a reputation. It is building a house on a quicksand. Other arts are necessary besides medical skill, Dr. Grisanowski was never so happy as when at his desk. It was during this period that he corre- sponded with the Nation, and also, from 1871 to 1877, wrote many articles for the North American Review. These may serve as a monument to his admirable English. Indeed, the editor at that time used to say that Dr. Grisanowski was his best contributor; and it was Mr. Adams's habit not to look at his MS., but wait until he saw the article in the proof- , The Nation. sheets! His subjects show a remarkable va- riety, e. g.: ‘‘The Rise of Popular Opinion in Prussia,” ‘‘ Regeneration of Italy,” ‘‘ Interna- tional Workingmen’s Associations,” ‘* Scho- penhauer’s Pessimistic Philosophy,” ‘* The Ro- man Church,” ‘‘ Comtism,” ‘‘ Wagner’s Theo- ries of Music.” The last title is a reminder that Grisanowski was nothing if not musi- cal. In the present Wagner mania, an extract from a letter, speaking of a visit he made to Bayreuth in 1882, may be of interest : ‘“Wagner’s ‘ Parsifal’ has made a deep and abiding impression on me. Who hears with the ear only will certainly get no satisfaction. Wagner, too, does not pretend to give ‘abso- lute music.’ But one gets, as compensation, something of a most peculiar kind, which can be compared to nothing before known. Eye and ear become one sense; and the double sense leads, not only to the emotions, but also to the intellect, on which the scenic representa- tion and the combination of mysticism and philosophy in the poem have the bighest claim.” ‘The first act seems to me perfect, in spite of its length. I bad not expected that the musical motifs would impress themselves so easily upon me. They are not melodies, and vet they can’t be forgotten. This kind of art is too original to have a future ; and Wagner must be received as a semel factum.” There are many who will say amen to this. After Pisa and another trial of Florence, a seaside residence was found better for Dr. Gri- sanowski’s health, and in 1877 he removed to Leghorn, where he occupied a beautiful villa outside the walls. Before this, President Eliot had offered him the professorship of German in Harvard College, which, however, he felt himself obliged to decline. Thinking little of his practice, he now gave himself up to his favorite studies. While in Florence he had become much interested in efforts made by the humane societies in England and Germany to check the practice of vivisection. It was his biographer, Mme. de Schwartz, who first sug- gested to him to take up the pen in behalf of suffering animals. The members of these so- cieties soon learned to appreciate its power when animated by his sympathetic nature, and the Sage of Leghorn, as he was called, found littlerest. The rule is held a good one by these bodies, ‘t not to urge a willing horse,” but they forgot that some consideration was also due to the nobler being. The Doctor’s willingness is proved by his works, a review of which, by Pastor Knodt, is appended to the memoir. In January, 1886, Dr. Grisanowski had a slight stroke of paralysis, which his medical attendants attributed to overwork. It was followed, a few months later, by one more vio- lent. It failed to kill, but he was left with the loss of speech and of the use of his right arm and leg. Fortunately, his wife had the aid and companionship of her two sisters, who hastened from England on receipt of a tele- gram announcing tbe first attack ; and, indeed, all their assistance was required in the compli- cations that followed, It was necessary to give up the villa they had occupied for eight years ; a new dwelling was to be found, the furniture to be moved, and the Doctor himself, though in so low a state that his physician would not take the responsibility of the change. The he- roic wife was equal to the emergency. After a long search, she found a suitable house near Lucca, distant some thirty miles ; she contract- ed for the moving of the furniture, and at the last moment asked her husband what he would do. ‘ Go,” he said—for he was able to articu- late single words. A mattress was spread in an open carriage, and he was laid upon it. The change of air revived him, and, in his new abode, he was able to survive for two years. It is situated in a beautiful country; and, though the house has not the charm of his former villa, there can be no doubt that he enjoyed it us much as one could enjoy any- thing in the state to which he was reduced. The following summer he was taken to the health establishment of Dr. Kriiche, near Mu- nich, but with little profit. During these last two years, who can describe the devotion of his wife, by day and night his constant attend- ant, frora whom alone he would receive help or food! At last his heart was affected to such a degree that breathing became more and more difficult, till, at the end, he lay for a week gasping for breath, occasionally uttering the word sterben in a tone that must still ring in the ears of all who heard it. The Italian doc- tor would willingly have shortened his suffering by morphine, but Grisanowski would not allow it. He died on the 31st of May, 1888, and lies buried in the English cemetery at the Baths of Lucca. Mme. de Schwartz bas done her work well.* It has evidently been with her a labor of love. Some may think she has exaggerated the pic- ture of her friend. Not so. ‘“‘The more,” she says, ‘‘the reader pene- trates into the intellectual wealth of his letters, the more difficult it will be to take leave of a man whose modest nature, shrinking like a sensitive plant from the world and its applause, concealed an affluence of ideas, an extent of wisdom, a clearness of perception and expres- sion, such as one seldom has found united. His real worth consists in this, that he knew how to combine all these intellectual endowments by the purity of his life, by his extreme self- abnegation, by his warm sympathy for others, into an harmonious whole which entitles him to a lofty place in the ranks of noble men.” Unfortunately, all these letters are written in German, and a translation of them would fail to represent the spirit of the originals. It would be well if the large circle of English- speaking friends with whom Dr. Grisanowski corresponded would mage a collection of their letters, and follow out the work so well begun by Mme. de Schwartz. As the poetical side of this many-sided man has been least dwelt upon, we would remind our readers of some Latin verses, addressed to W.S. Landor on his birthday, which appeared in a late Nation (No, 1271). As they may have escaped nctice, perhaps an English version of them will not be unacceptable : TO LANDOR ON HIS BIRTHDAY. Who taught thee to invoke a foreign Muse ? From whom didst learn to strike the Roman lyre? Did Sabine nurse perhaps give suck to thee, Or was it thine to drink from Castaly ? Alas! the ruined temples prostrate lie. No longer in celestial halls resound The echoes of the banquets of the gods. But there, where Homerand where Sappho quaffed, The gentle murmur of Castalian waves Is ever heard. Surely Melpomene, Weeping at sight of ruin such as this, Forbids the fountain e’er to cease its flow. Nor can the Goddess brook a vain delay. After whole ages to the Muse denied, Landor now claims acup from Hippocrene. O fortunate old man (if age can come After sich charms), whose happy lot has been To live in the enjoyment of these gifts! Whether thy songs move or to tears or mirth, Posterity will hail thee gratefully. Behold, Rome opens wide her gates! Return The sacred Deities in Ceesar’s train! Vanish the mitred rulers in the realm Of gloom and sadness! Landor, while thou Liv’st, All love of high Olympus cannot fade; Nor wilt thou ever, Landor, wholly die. RECENT NOVELS. By the Western Sea: a Summer Idyll. By James Baker, Longmans, Green & Co, 1889, The Spanish Poniard: Being the Story of the Remorse of Ambrose Drybridge. By Thomas R. Pinkerton. London: Swan, Sonnenschein & Co, 1890. * The reader will naturally not expect any of the stirring adventures which our lively authoress narrates in her * Recollections of Garibaldi,’ but he must not fail to read the Walfisch story on page 136, W

Page 19

Feb. 6, 1890] The Golden Days of *42: A Tale of the Califor- nia Diggings. By Kirk Munroe, Dodd, Mead & Co. With Gauge & Swallow, Attorneys. By Albion W. Tourgée. Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott Co. 1889. Lily Lass. By Justin Huntly M.P. D. Appleton & Co. Standish of Standish: A Story of the Pilgrims By Jane G. Austin. Houghton, Mifflin & Co, Gerald Ffrench’s Friends, sop. Longmans, Green & Co. The Bursting of a Boom. By Frederick R Sanford. J. B. Lippincott Co. McCarthy, TSv0, By George H. Jes A Summer in a Cafion: A California Story. By Kate Douglass Houghton, Mifflin & Co. Tentée, Par Th. Bentzon. Lévy; New York: F. W. ‘By THE WESTERN SEA’ is essentially a book Wiggin. Calmann 1S\4), Paris: Christern. for artists. Its plot, incidents, and characters cannot be appreciated except by that marked caste the chief business of whose life it is to look for beauty in nature or man, and immedi- ately think if said beauty can be represented in words, colors, clay, musical notes, or which- ever artistic medium comes most uaturally to the individual. discussions of to-day is touched, incidentally to the idyll—an idyll, by the way, which to- wards the end gets quite beyond the Theocritean or Tennysonian idyll, and dangerously near the romances of chivalry. But there is a large class not wholly composed of stupid Philistines, Almost every one of the art and yet not always looking out for beauty or To this class, no less than to artists, the central theme of the story will be touching if not very new ; the characters, principal and subordinate, real, considering how objects ‘* compose.” breathing men and women, and the knot of events generally well unwound. But it would be a relief to have half the descriptions of scenery bodily cut out ; to follow the hero and heroine, their friends without eternally having to stop and observe a ‘‘ bit” ; and enemies, and besides the mischievous boy, who happily is without the slightest feeling for art, to find some prominent character who dares to enter- tain an emotion, opinion, or passion which bas not been awakened through the eyes searching for beauty—in short, to have the minds, hearts, and souls sometimes put into a night express train so as to carry on the story without the possibility of seeing a subject. ‘ The Spanish Poniard’ meritorious, but not very profound or success- ful, attempt to portray the lives of a number of quiet people living in the town of Warwick in the days of Charles I. They hear very little of all the exciting events of the reign, and yet from time totime are swept into the whirlwind of violent preaching and other resistless forces is a very careful and which were waking up all the great centres of England to an implacable contest. In the in tervals of these general furies, the little knot of persons whose life the book tells are key excitement by the mystery, not very obscure, of a blind Spanish woman, and the Spanish poniard of the title, which is always turning upto make things lively and painful, as if it were the magic Only at in scholar and writer, a drowned sword of one of Ariosto’s champions, the very end are the characters swept into the full tide of civil war; and the siege of War 5S wick and battle of Edgebill are well described. 5

The book is not exactly bad, but the author has | laid out a scheme too heavy for him, and the result is tame. An honest story, somewhat in the old Mayne Reid style, is Kirk Munroe'’s ‘ Golden Days of The 40,’ telling in straightforward English the re Nation. gular difficulties, failures, and successes, wh every one knows by heart now, that attended the ‘‘ Forty-niners.” It reads much like a boy's book, and very much indeed like an old book, revived and vamped up in the hope of its px iss ing as new. The last paragraph, separated by stars from the rest of the book, and wholly unnecessary forthe story, begins, ‘* Forty years But this to have been There is net one word in the rest have passed.” written on. of the book that need have been written sin seelus 1850; not one allusion to the development the country, or to any event or man made prominent since that year, The volume has a gorgeous red, black, white, gold, and butt bind ing, and is illustrated in the highest form of the ‘*Scotch-mist” style—pictures that do not let 3 } you see exactly any man or thing, but merely gauge the different ‘* values” of fog. Judge to * Witi Gauge & Swallow,’ exalts the power of a law Tourgee, in his preface yer in a strain of eloquence that is really too lofty to be quoted, and reads like an address Western passes on to the commonplace that the lawyers before some very law school te are more likely to become acquainted with the extraordinary incidentsof buman life than any other profession, and continues with the portant remark that neither laymen nor law yers bave succeeded in incorporating such in cidents skilfully into a the ning from ignorance, and the lawver f1 Hence the popu tales where some miracle is made to take pla novel layman over-technicality. } Del by the complete overthrow of

court officers, and in the teeth of law. His idea is, that lawvers show their re powers by the skilful handling of what seem to be unmanageable facts; bringing, in fact, tl extraordinary and troublesome into the sphert of the ordinary and easy, and enabling not merely law, but ordinary human life, tot own peaceful course without baving constant low its to fight with stumps and rocks, He offers us then, aseries of tales (most 1 have appeared separately, but

ranged to form a continuous romance) ast by aclerk in an eminent law tirm which has successively to seize and tame these wild ar mals that infest our life. There is a good deal of sense in this pr but the plan is strangely carried out the case in every story comes into the hands Gauge & Swallow ; but sometimes their dea ing with it isa minimum ; sometimes the w arrangements of their office are upset to inves tigate a strange case, so that the supposed nat

rator tells us that the ordinary fa New York otlice was upset about once an some queer case, sometimes ti ur > their assistants are tur: int te : Again, the profound rule of law w sina to control the exciting case is slippe end of a story, and in short the whole book is a mass of wild, sensational magazine tales and simple, with just en

doubt) thrown in to be evidence, two centuries after the author's death, that a certain r nance-writer named Tourgée was probably an attorney's clerk, if not ead, an actual } tioner, The little story called * Lily Lass’ is w ten in direc » of all realistic theories, old and new has heroes and heroines of strange an be ¥ hiv crossed ve, inaccessible castles, secret passages, set tights and sudden brawls, with a very inte ing chorus in the person of an elderly Ori eur) ental scholar, who surveys nearly ali that goes 1 t on in this stormy season with tiality. us Imp » , a ~~) } . in} The tone of the whole is certain] i) lated, \ English is verv gool—not a Vays roved t American proof-reading in he s ¥ ins easily and entertalningiy t—ar he t sa larg n the alm \ tVvoWe ¥ pa tisa lhe Scene Ireland du ast pping shot of tt s { ists It is \ sthat Mr VeCarthy ‘ rw e this t kh w thie X} t i ‘ i SINg people s str gest t cs as ft e rig sand wr x of that « . t tw Ss are i ha vi if Wwe ef J Mit and NSruitl om ’ bew ps s it | el States ul r forty vears i have troubled miselve tor t iry Te { the events l rnd isas amd such sas tf y hay ire forn i stiv at se ior ft hand. But among those w Are « ‘ hav rea t a, % t t oe ‘ V Wes t ea ~ the upris ! i ws this ix an M M ( arty yal x i al v ‘ “ tf fa ~ “) t t t ‘ ‘ ‘ li w t ’ jue ‘ a. «f j will read ‘Lily Lass’ as ait » tribute ¢ Vrs st la i wl t t i s ” “ evitabiv be rt Ivan tha ia “ ‘ ta atory t sta Sta s M \ es i e ta sa I ti ‘i ‘ s { I iw irs Ww : ¥Y Was es s . t ~ i ‘ Wo P < I wt \ i . ‘ ‘ t ~ . “ t teers sa el ‘ sta ‘ . ery’ s A ‘ SIV } \ rij < . ‘ a i a fare We Sie w is WwW t i Vv. Carve t lrawn w | t Priscilla NM ‘ 31 . ‘ { il A lue . ar i sy. aii t w ~ “ ves e, Verv dainty treat é \ R . v in boast no fy al 4 b) Ss at bs sw ‘ < ¥ Six s s t } 1 iv sketches, al COV ( aid F fre Friends \ s t t el on fact, and \ i t i re transcripts from a ‘ mhiate ii aitera ' ns i sary tot wthe veil of te t t f the aracters.” Mr s 1 Irishman of gentle birth £ S ( tt bacifi Coast, re ae | years Leu ew this time it is his f any countrymen in a more s way he sketches describe a ew chara sti sy}. of the native

dified, of id all of entertain se, bw the new surroundings; a six are unusually successful and Rise and Fall of 4 il | ing ne, ** ihe ) 1 t is the most, indeed the only, vy humorous one: the others are all rather sad. The most sensational is ‘‘Queen of the Angels”; but perhaps the strongest is the last, he Redwood 17 in which the big uberman is described in a few bold and tell-

ing phrases, while bis devotion to bis little boy, and the child’s death, are powerfully por tiave i It has been said that opening situations are half the battle in writing a book, just as a be ina short arti- The situa- brilliant first sentence may a happy title for anything. | cle, or

Page 20

118 tion in which the hero and heroine of ‘ The Bursting of a Boom’ find themselves at the start is certainly sufficiently striking. The young man discovers that in his journey from Los Angeles to Ventura he has exchanged trunks with some young woman bearing the same initials as his own. The trunks having precisely the same locks and outward appear- ance, he does not become aware of the mistake until he has opened the trunk in the seclusion of hisown room, A tempest of emotions takes possession of his soul as he sees the pretty dresses and bonnets within, and the dainty lace and linen, while he imagines with horror the consternation of the lady—young, of course —when she gazes upon the coats and shirts and shaving-brushes promiscuously tumbled into his own box. Beyond this rather piquant open- ing the book has nothing noteworthy. Of course, he finds the girl; of course, he duly falls in love and marries her. The history of a Western land ‘* boom,” in which this young man gains some sad experience, is interspersed with more or less description of California scenery and manners, The language is far from elegant, often incorrect, while shall and will, should and would, are continually inter- changed in the bad fashion of to-day. ‘A Summer in a Cafion’ is a bright and taking little story, which does not have to be labelled ‘“‘for young people.” It is unmis- takably theirs. The fun is infectious, and many of the situations and speeches are irre- sistibly comical, The bane of American youth, however, is slang, and this otherwise healthful tale does not wholly escape it. Dr. and Mrs. Winship undertake the charge of a dozen or more persons during a camping ex- pedition on a large scale. For three months the happy party live in tents in Las Flores Cafion, under the spreading oaks and syca- mores, hung with mistletoe and gray Spanish moss, Which temper the perpetual sunshine of a California summer, Evidently the descrip- tions of the region were written con amore— even at the beginning occurs an almost eloquent passage expressive of the early-morning beauty of the day upon which the expedition sets forth. Some entertaining information about the old-style rodeo, and the early California days, is given picturesyuely ‘* round the camp- fire.” Mme. Thérése Blanc, who writes under the name of ‘* Th, Bentzon,” has long been a steady contributor to the Rerue des Deux Mondes. She might almost be called the foreign editor of it, if one considers the amount of work she has done in the way of translating and con- densing Americen novels and criticising the authors of them. She is herself the author of sundry novels and tales, one of which Mr. An- drew Lang found worthy to be included in a recent volume of translations. The book that we have in hand is made up of two stories, of which the longer gives its title to the volume. ‘La Tentée’ is Mrs, James Nevil, the Parisian widow of an Englishman, who makes speedy use of her freedom to leave the land of fogs and chill decorum and go back to the city of her heart. She finds her old school friend married to a literary man of the modern sort—Par- nassian, décadent, impressionist, Heaven knows what—whom his wife loves, but, as is usual in such stories, does not understand. After the usual fashion, also, Mrs. Nevil sets out at once to make her friend’s home happy by flirting violently with the superior husband. This connection, however, stops at about one millimetre this side its natural ending, and the heroine returns to England to marry Lord Mel- ton, and several castles, and countless acres, and a great deal of money in the Bank, The

The Nation. [Number 1284

book might quite as well have been called ‘*Tenté.” It is of no great value ; the English characters being wooden and dead, and the French ones not alive. ‘‘ Faélle,” the second and shorter story, has rather more merit. It is a tale of the disordered and precocious love of an Italian model of twelve years old for an Eng- lish walking-stick of a painter, and of her self- sought death. It is not a story to be praised without stint, but there are touches in it of feeling and observation. = —e —z Essays on Government. By <A. Lawrence Lowell. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co. 1889, THis little book has an importance that is in- versely as its size, It isa duodecimo of scarce 200 pages, but it contains more wisdom than is to be found in many elaborate and volumi- nous treatises, In fact, we do not know that any writer except Mr. Lowell has clearly dis- tinguished the vital and essential principle of our form of government, and certainly none has stated it so forcibly. It is probably the case that some of our political thinkers, as is indicated here in the essay on ‘‘ Cabinet Re- sponsibility,” were carried off their balance by Mr. Bagehot’s comparison of parliamentary with Presidential government. His persuasive power is such that it is always difficult not to be led by him; and when he maintained that parliamentary government was the more effi- cient it was impossible not to be convinced. Mr. Lowell does not possess the style of Bagehot, nor does he display that incomparable imagi- native power which enables such writers as Bagehot and Maine to divine the constitutions of early societies. This brilliant and captivat- ing gift, however, has its corresponding de- fects. It sometimes misleads the possessor; it sometimes dazzles the beholders; and neither of these remarkable men was an altogether safe guide. In the breadth of his view of the general nature of government, in the solidity of his reasoning, and in the soberness of his judgment, Mr. Lowell will take rank among the first. In the essay above referred to, he points out, in the first place, that whatever the respective merits of the two forms of govern- ment, it is impossible to combine them—that a responsible ministry involves the fusion of the legislative and executive functions: and in the second place, that efficiency is by no means the only thing to be thought of in government. This latter truth is more fully developed in the essay entitled ‘‘ Democracy and the Con- stitution.” It is almost hopeless to attempt to condense so concise an argument as is here presented, but we may briefly state its leading features. For the development of individual character and enterprise it is necessary that there should be freedom of activity, secure en- joyment of the fruits of labor, anda possibility of calculating the future from the past. These conditions can only be realized under a govern- ment of laws and not of men. They cannot be realized where absolute power is vested in any man or body of men, even if this body be the majority of the people. Hence the wisdom of **checks and balances,” hence the written Con- stitutions and Bills of Rights of America. The Constitution of the United States owes its dis- tinction to the ingenuity and success with which limitations upon arbitrary power were devised and applied. It was a deliberate at- tempt to restrain the power of the majority, and especially to prevent legislative tyranny. Although the Supreme Court has in recent years practically destroyed these safeguards by the Legal-Tender decisions, yet the fact that they endured for the greater part of a century

has developed a conservative spirit in our democracy that may for a long time repress the manifestations of arbitrary power. In illustration of Mr. Lowell’s development of this idea, we quote a passage from his 4de- scription of the process or art of framing a limited government. This art, he observes, consists not only in fostering the habit of self- control, but even more in making thatself-con- trol as little irksome as possible. He proceeds: ‘** Now, there are three devices which are capa- ble of promoting this result: (1) an arrange- ment such that no organized political body can feel that the laws depend solely upon its own will—can feel, in other words, that it has power to do whatever it pleases; (2) the creation of several independent political bodies, each of which is restrained by the presence of the others ; and (3) a process by which every pos- sessor of political power can be made amen- able to some final authority which will prevent him from overstepping the bounds prescribed for his action.” The first device means that in a democracy the mass of the people must not be an organiz- ed body, and that there must exist no single body of representatives which has absolute authority to express the popular will. The second device means that in the United States power is divided between the Federal and the State Governments, and in each of these is distributed among several representative bo- dies, deriving their authority from independ- ent sources. The third device is, in short, the regulative control exercised by our courts over our legislatures. This bald statement of Mr. Lowell’s argument deprives it of all ap- pearance of originality; but those who follow it out in detail will find, in place of the vague generalities which constitutionalists are prone to indulge in, a lucid, systematic, and singu- larly compact theory of the Constitution. It is all contained in the sixty pages of the chapter entitled *‘ Democracy and the Constitution.” The essay upon ‘‘ The Responsibility of Ame- rican Lawyers,” although intrinsically merito- rious, is, compared with the rest of the book, rather slight in substance. That upon the theory of the social compact is an historical summary which well deserves to be expanded into a separate treatise. The final chapter, upon ‘*The Limits of Sovereignty,” is a trenchant (altbough not in our opinion altogether un- answerable) criticism of Austin’s well-known theory. Of this, too, it may be said that its value would be increased if it were expanded intoa volume. It is a grave responsibility, in this age of diffuse writing and innumerable books, to suggest addition and multiplication to any author, but Mr. Lowell has displayed such unmistakable evidences of rare talent in the line of his choice, that a different rule applies in his case. Asit is, he has rendered a great and to hisown country a patriotic service in his exposition of the true character of the re- lation between the American Constitution and the American society. Those persons who find themselves disposed to yield to the allurements of modern socialism, although perhaps not in- tellectually so constituted as fully to appreci- ate this book, may yet understand from it how it is that clear-headed men look upon the hopes of the socialists as vain, and oppose all ten- dencies in that direction with unalterable sternness.

Marie Bashkirtseff ; The Journal of a Young Artist. 1860-1884. Translated by Mary J. Serrano. Cassell & Co. THIS much-talked-of diary of a young Russian artist of noble birtu, in which she has delibe- rately exposed her private life as directly and intimately as was in her power, in order to win a £ F

Page 21

Feb. 6, 1890]

” knew as ‘‘ fame” after death, is cer- tainly a remarkable book, and its present vogue is not wonderful ; it falls in with the appetite of the time for ‘‘ revelations,” and it what she ts is highly spiced with sensation. It is very sure, however, that these confessions exhibit to our eyes a Very different person from the Marie Bashkirtseff that its author supposed herself to be unveiling. Even toa greater degree than most autobiography, the volume tells more than was meant. It would have been scandal- ous in another to draw such a picture of this romantic and ungoverned young woman ; and it is ungallant at least to analyze and sum up her career and nature from the material she has furnished by admitting all men into Indeed, there is for- tunately no occasion to enter upon such a dis- the penetralia of her life. eussion, since her achievement in life was of no real importance, and curiosity regarding her concerns only her individuality, which in her own writ- They will do best, it must be said, to seek those who wish will seek for ing. in the original French, as the present transla- tion is not an excellent one, and falls far below the diarist’s own words in vigor, directness, and charm. It may not be amiss, however, to remark upon the extremely foreign character of her temperament, which happily has but slight analogy with anything in our own inteilectual life. She wasa ‘fair barbarian.” Though the words may sound harsh, they are accurately descriptive. She was personally attractive, and was besides endowed with a great deal of talent. She was also feverishly ambitious the not to nobly, but to live on the lips of men, ) in narrowest and lowest sense live She was not sparing of industry, and she made an im- perious will serve her purpose ; sbe devoted herself to the means of excellence, and accom- In fact, she died, or at least hastened death, by her wilful persistence plished something by her effort. in work, where alone she couid work, in Paris. She was a varied linguist, and read the masters, but one does not observe in her diary any thinking or any regard for ideas, except ina few pages upon her own subject, art. Of intellectual life, properly speaking, Yet, notwithstand- ing this interest in the things of civilization, remained itact ene does not see the traces she a ‘*barbariun.” Her co: with them was mainly external, In the first n her nature itself elements One realizes this in two ways place, there were i which are krown tous principally from the Middle A Her religion except by this gloss. ges, inte ligible not is She was superstitious, and the forms of her superstition were those of what to us is a long-past age. She inti- mates that the miracle of her cure at a Rus- sian shrine, which failed to be wrought, might have come about if she had firmly believed in the power of relics. As it was, she resents the fact that she got more co'd in the vaults. She gives in charity, avd hopes fervently that she will get something back for h I er money lild sa and is angry with God, like ac! : would call him unjust but for the fear of suf- fering worse things from him in consequence. She prays as to an idol, and with the material ism of a pagan peasant. The whole state of her mind upon religious matters, though e fused by knowledge of modern ideas, is a su vival from the thirteenth

century, and has more affinity with material than with spiritual religion ; in a true sense, it is that of the ‘bar arian.” Secondly, there is no moral me! her conception of how life is to be led—none oF that sense of responsibility, of that unselfish devotion to noble ends for their own sake, of that ideal of virtue in which the individual dis

° The Nation. appears by becoming one with the will of hea- ven, which belong to the modern and civilized mind and heart. This deficiency of the moral idea is the explanation of much in her book The traits which di vided this brilliant and eager Russian nature from the Paris of were fundamental ; the separation they effect which seems abnormal. which she seemed a part ed was a great gulf, unknown even to herself There is, however, a pervading quality, a femineity rather than womanliness, which lends attraction to her pages. To mention but one phase of it, her frequently expressed delight in the beauty of her person has a simplicity hardly to be rivalled in the books of women. Again, her confessions of her waywardness, of her treatment of her family and her opinions of them, and the repeated acknowledgment of her ‘second thoughts ” in her actions, of her ab sorption in *‘ the effect,” of her consciousness of the lurking question, ‘‘ What will the reader think of this ¢” nature ; belong to the same side of her and her frankly expressed jealousy of her rival, her bitter words and ignoble thoughts, read more like some character in a play than like the voice of a living woman to a public The of from the liveliness and directness of her style verisimititude such passages yains And here one should speak of her conversa tions with her lovers, of her confessions about for her band, all that part of the narrative, but we omit re the treatment of passion and of love by such a one love, of the candidates and flection upon these. She was romantic, and witbout any discrimination in speech, however innocent and modest in her simple garrulity, can be parried only by the reader's delicacy in silence. She was a brill

ant woman, evidently adapted to shine in society and te enchain ad miration, convinced of her power and not un willing to use it, often ina cold way. But she was not content with this natural supremacy, and sought for power of a different sort—the supremacy of genius through its works; st after gave her life it is true, but she gave it- obtaining personal distinction. One admires strained it with all ber force, and she ’ unnecessarily and imprudently, -with the hope of much in her ; but, after allowing for tl element in her temperament, there is no incon @ alien siderable part of her confessions ab one kee} s silent. Domingo Francisco de ton Mufion Chimalpahin Quauhtletn Sixieme et septiéme relations. Annales de

ilees e@

traduites sur le manuscrit original par R Siméon. Paris: Maisonneuve. ISS). Sv Or Mexican and Aztec history a goodly ni ber of volumes have come down to our age it much of it is contradictory, and what httle w think to be true is like iV to be re modified 1 many points by the recent put ation of Chi maipahin’s ‘ Relations.’ Nobody willdeny tt the history of the Mexicans, like that of al ther ancient nations, contains elements of ut certainty on a it of the imperfect art of writing, Of a def it chre gy for the early periods), and of the miraculous and legendary lementin historiography. From these defects Chimalpahin is more free than his predecessors ntemporaries He descended from the of the | hiefs of Amacameca- , and was bor ™. Notwithstand g his Indian origin, | idea eful study f all the branches of knowledge then taught n Mexico by the Spanist juerors, combin gz with these the history and topography of bis own country. The antiquarian Boturini succeeded in obtaining for his collection a part of bis manuscripts, and a portion of these final

ly came into Mr. Au is SSeS n ‘ a the most important part, ext from 1255 to 4s 8 tra at | " } ’ as { i ext the re edit t by stating disti \ ‘ strangled bim and f! they also strar i that of Tiat ( rth nh gx the i \ Culiacan is n es writers : t ‘ ‘ chitheca, my ‘ ‘ from an isian t t ‘ Aztlan, a pla moztoc. O Same Names in fat ‘ ‘ ditferent places writer savs n ‘ s island, if seems a st home of these ‘ N than upon t s s in districts t t Nahuatl were sy Concer! y e Mex Chimalpal a ove mark Hie s s s {ft at s tt tv. Ww \" spa s w ‘ WA . ney . : ‘al ! t en of . 2 s Scare = i Nar ‘ “ or Xo a The date t Mex va S Stated VA ’ an sM = ~ t int Y SS wi t? , < « < { t s, A hi 1 at we i i ‘ ere S s ¢ “ have t s t , f ness of t i t - thie \ { € pres w s } fu ts ; etalis i n t fies t he s vw Mex Ss used mit t! a “N ui wards t s { work tap] sf s assages ft s » Mex t Ss ai exter ve ar sot t wv! (} ! eight I wi i i bi . t ir 1 ¢ r has se i for t at tw x l é seventh r the al m ! mtu han all the rest fort | Mexican histor The appendix 1 t text trans ati sautl prope u persona and local, irring t tex it I rity f them the etym« y i hed Fanny Bur ey lhe I I Select Pas sages from her Diary and Other Writings. Edited by L. B. Seeley. With nine illustra tions after Reynolds, Gail igh, Copley, and West. Scribner & Welford THE vivacious pen of Mi Burney gives excel

Page 22

120 lent materia! for a volume of this sort, which paints her life among literary and royal per- sons with as much regard for her Surroundings as for her own individuality. The opening scenes, among her father’s musical parties and the solitude of his country retreat, are most pleasant; and as soon as ‘ Evelina’ appears, the figures of society add a new interest, and in particular the entrance of Johnson and Burke among her admirers is important, both of these great characters being admirably drawn. The life at court, on the other hand, is melan- choly reading, notwithstanding the near view it permits of royalty in its domestic life; one realizes the misery of the situation (and none | of it is spared in the telling) too keenly to take | interest in the senseless ceremonial routine: and the most vivid sketch of all—that of the King escaping from his keepers and walking and conversing with Miss Burney—is a painful exhibition of a weak andinfirm old man. The resignation of her office by Miss Burney comes | asa happy relief to all this, though there re- mained trials enough for her in her wedded life. Readers of the diary will understand | how brilliant the page is on which only Miss Burney’s most lively and direct passages oc- cur, and may well be tempted to renew ac- quaintance with her life by such admirable editing as Mr. Seeley has done. The portraits which interleave the pages are excellent repro ductions of excellent paintings, and add value; but the attractiveness of the text is due to the extraordinary reality of Miss Burney’s writ- ing, her observation of details that are most significant, and, not in asmall degree, to the simplicity and modesty of her own character. The book is a delightful résumé of one of the best memoirs of the century. Some Eminent Women of Our Times. By Mil- | licent Garrett Fawcett. Maemillan & Co, Pp, 231, Mrs. Fawcett has done a good thing for her sex—that is to say, a good thing for humanity in general—by recounting the stories of twen- ** Every child in America should have them.’’—New | England Journal of Education, **The * Young Folks’ Cyclopedia’ should be in every ae po library.””"—From a Report of the Connecticut oard of Education. YOUNG FOLKS ( Common f. hinges one 50. CYCLOP.EDL v | Persons and f ‘laces. $2.50 HENRY HOLT & CO., Publishers, New York. DAVIS’ DIAMOND HAMS And Breakfast Bacon. CINCINNATI. Read Circulars How to Cook Them. Letters gud ‘make cavie transfers of money to Of Aino make Cofteetions and iseue ‘Com: Cc lit mercial and Travelling credits, availa- redait. ple in all parts of the world. Brown Brothers & Co., Bankers. NO. 59 WALL STREET, NEW YORK. r. W. CHRISTER RN, 254 Fifth Ave., between 28th and 29th Sts., New York. pepeser of Foreign Books, Agent for the leading Paris Publishers, Tauehnitz’s British Authors, Teubner’s Greek and Latinc lassics, Catalogues of stock mailed on | demand. A large assortment always on hand, and new books received from Paris and Leipzig as soon as issued. y TANN’'S REFERENCE INDEXES.— P i References to and transcripts or translations of the literature of any subject furnished by PICKMAN MANN, Washington, D.C. z Correspondence fee, 60 cents, Explanatory cireulars ree, ( ATALOGUES ISSUED of Books in good | condition. Books purchased. E, W. JOHNSON, 1336 Broadway. The Nation. bo Number 1284 | ty-four women who have had a marked effect, | in one way or another, upon the time in which | they lived. The accounts are brief and straightforward and simple—they were writ- ten for the Mothers’ Companion, and addressed chiefly to working-women and to young peo- | ple—but the remarkable character of their con- tents is all the more striking on that account. In nearly every case, from Dorothy Pattison, who was obliged to leave home in face of her | father’s opposition and to work hard for three years as village schoolmistress, living without aservant and polishing her own grate, before becoming Sister Dora, to Mrs. Somerville, whose mother thought that alla woman needed to know was to write well and to keep accounts, these women who have accomplished important | work have done it in the face of active resist- ance, as well as chill repression, on the part of all their relatives and friends. The loss which | has accrued to the werld from the fact that many other women have failed to carry out worthy undertakings because they lacked the | supreme courage necessary to unsex them- selves in the eyes of all whom they loved, can- not easily be estimated. Sydney Smith, writing in 1810 upon the ex- | traordinary folly of closing to women all the ordinary means of literary education, remark- ed, as Mrs. Fawcett reminds us, that one con- sequence of their exclusion was that no woman | had contributed anything of lasting value to literature. Sydney Smith had a logical mind; the juxtaposition which the common man usu- ally gives to two such facts is this: Women have never accomplished anything in litera- ture, therefore they must be excluded from all means of literary education. As far as litera- | ture is concerned, the battle has now been fought and won: women have, in the first place, entered the field of literary production and taken full possession of it, and they have, in the non-natural order, afterwards gained entrance into the great strongholds of literary instruction. As regards theactive bettering of the world’s condition through agitation and other er means of easuaens they have | already made a brilliant record. Elizabeth Fry in prison-life, Elizabeth Gilbert in the condition of the blind, Florence Nightingale in nursing, the abolitionists, the advocates of a better life for women—these have had a marked effect upon the stream of events. But the great nur- sery of neroic and self-sacrificing action—a family life and a social life in which self-indul- | gent frivolity is the thing that is frowned down upon instead of a love of action—is a thing yet to be created. The world changes rapidly: Hannah More devoted the second half of her life to the ser- vice of the poor, but she allowed no writing | among her protégées, because writing was un- fitted to their station, Such a book as this of Mrs. Faweett’s, if it could be put into every | family in the country, would have a tremen- dous effect in making a life of activity and value seem to be an easy and a natural thing to all spirited young girls. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Beale, Rev. D. J. Through the Johnstown Flood, Philadelphia; Hubbard Bros, 32. | General Digest of the Decisions of the Principal Courts in the United States, for the year ending September, 1889. (Vol. IV. of the annual series.) Rochester : Lawyers’ Cooperative Pub, Co, 6. Handwiorterbuch der Staatswissenschaften, Parts 4, 5. Jena; Gustav Fischer. Lawson, J. D. Rights. Remedies and Practice, at Law, in Equity, and under the Codes. San Francisco: Bancrott-Whitney Co. #6. Nicoll. W. R. James Macdonell, Journalist. London: Hodder & Stoughton. Paul, a ne H. Grundriss de r Germanise hen Philologie, Vol. I., Part 3; Vol. Il., Parts 1.2. Strassburg: K. J. Triibner. Smith, Prof. W. R. Lectures on the Religion of the >emites. D. Appleton & Co. 4. Thackeray, S. W. The Land and the Community. D., Appleton & Co. . $i. The Scotch-Irish in America: Proceedings of the Con gress at Columbia, Tenn., May 5-11, 1889. Cincin nati: Robert Clarke & Co. $1.50. The Year’s Kright Chain, Quotations from the Writ- ings of Frances E. Willard. Chicago: Woman's Temperance Publication Association, 50 cents. Tilton, S. = The First Book in Color, Boston: S, w Fito Tourgée, / OW, With Gauge and Swallow, Attorneys. Phivadetphia: J.B. Lippineott Co. ; Tucker, Prof. T. G. The ‘Supplices’ of Aéschylus, Macmillan& Co. $2.60. Turtle, © W. Capt Francis Champernowne, and Other Historical Papers. Poston: Damrell& Up ham. $4. Twain, Mars. A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur’s Court. Chas. L. Webster & Co, Wood, Prof. A. Lessons in the Structure, Life and _ of Plants. Revised ed. A.S. Barnes & Co, 2. 4oTH | AN INUAL STAT EMENT AA TNA Insurance Company OF HARTFORD, CONN., Life JANUARY 1, 18)0. Premium receipts in 1889...... $3,739,410 82 Interest reeeipts in 1889......... Total receipts during the year... Disbursements to Policy-holders, and for expenses, taxes, ete... 5,520,966 84 1,781,556 02 | 4,605,230 50 | JUST PU BLISHKD. JOSHUA, A Story of Biblical Times. By GEORG EBERS. From the German by MARY J. SAFFORD. In ove vol. Paper, 40 cents; cloth, 73 cents, W.S. GOTTSBERGER &CO., PUBLISHERS, wt Murray Street, New York. School Agencies. HE BOSTON, NEW YORK, AND Chicago Teachers’ Agencies. Circular free. Evg- RETT O, Fisk & Co., 7 Tremont Place, Boston; 6 Clinton | Place, New York; 106 and 108 Wabash Ave., Chicago. Assets, January 1, 1890........ . 34,805,819 09 lYaunts Total TAmViUMER. cis eaeeasece 29,060,727 42 | : om : ser iene : 1 JANTED—-THE AID OF A LADY Surplus by Ct,, Mass,, and N.Y, ee o IL in making copies or extracts. Work may be BUTI INE oo oe x -diase aos ee cl cre wee 5,745,091 58 | done at any public library. Address, stating number Surpius by many States ..... 3 7,450,000 00 omive. per week which could be given, B. Y., Nation Policies in foree January 1, 1890, | 70,985, IMSURINE .. eee eee 110,669,718 94 | Att ications for the Asststant Profes- Policies issued in 1889, 9,873, in- ¢ whit v, GC ; ao 1. a BURNIE. oo :6.6csc ie bon oe 20,190,098 00 aL of Bees MORGAN GC. BULKELEY, President. J.C. WEBSTER, Vice-President. J. L. ENGLISH, Secretary. H. W. Sr. JOHN, Actuary. | GURDON W. RUSSELL, M.D., Cons’ g Physician. MUMFORD & BUSHNELL, Managers, 167 Broadway, New York. in the University of Texas will be received until Feb- ruary 24,1890. Salary $2,000; term 3 years. It is essen- tial that applicants have experience in teaching Geo- logy. Address | LESLIE WAGGENER, Chairman of the Faculty, University of Texas, Austin, Tex, | Yb NATION.— A BOUND SET, also an unbound set; various vols., both bound and unbound; 25. pd odd nunibers. Will buy. sell, or exchange, A.S. CLARK, 34 Park Row, \, Y. City. remit ary, Premit Janu Total | Premf 1NSV Losses perk Retur! Exp The C« Unite Stoc Loans Real F est Premi Cash | Amou Stix of pra legal! of Fe rhe be rer lexal of Fe wille of pa Ad net e endin be iss