The Nation 1889-08-15: Vol 49 Iss 1259
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
New York, Claverack VAVERACK COLLEGE AND HUD.- son River Institute. Healthfully and beautifully ! ain the Hudson Valley Affords superior sivantages for thorou systematic education to young men and women. Careful attention given by a trong faculty of exper fessors and teachers itellectual, social, 1 ral, ar physical culture. \ Conservatory of Musie and Art of high grade Oth year opens Sept. Vth Send for strated catalogue, tk h. Ht. FLACK, A M., Prest NEw YorK, Garden City, Long Island, "THE CATHEDRAL S( HOOL 2? aN! Paul, 17 miles from N.Y.) Thorough preparation for college or seclentific school, Mite: iry discipline Location and building unsurpassed. Citas. STURTEVANT Moore, A.B. (Harv.), Head Master, NEW ore Mantius S 7. JOHN’ MILIT. {RY SCHOOL. . Eb Me Classics. Business, Rr. Rev. F. D. Ht NTINGTON, President. LT.-CoL, W. VERRECK, Superintendent. NEW York«K, Newburgh (on the Hudson VYIGLARS PREPARATORY SCHOOL, . $500, no extras.—There is at least one school in which a boy of elghtis happier, safer, and better off in every respectthan he ean be at home, no matter how go me) his home may be T have much to sav on the sub ect. Send for primer Koom for six boys next fall Hresky W. SiGiar, (Yale NeW YORK 125 Madison Avenue, near 1th St CY H. MORSE’S SCHOOL FOR BOYS. Will reopen The until Sept. 16, is Oct. I. Principal's address, Cotuit, Mass. NEW YorkK, Poughkeepsie, WVERVIEW {DEM Y.—s5ygth Year. \ Prepares thoroughly for College, the Govern meut Academies, and Business. Military dritl, sISBEE & AMEN, P saison NEW YorkK, Rochester. TNIVERSITY OF ROCHESTER.— David J. Hill, . I ve President. Two courses or study, the Classical, fentifne, Fall term begins rhursday, Sept. 12, 188). For catalogues address THE LIBRARIAN, NEW YorK, Roslyn, Long Island, SCHUOL EDU‘ surroundinys. E. HINDs, ATES A.M. Tt. BRY. ANT boysamid charming NEW YORK, S&ratoga, ‘4 RA TOGA IN SZ7TU TE FOR BOYS. » Prepares for leading colleges and business. Es tablished L856. idee PR ANKLIN B, YATES, A.B. NEw YORK, Syracuse. Ag S ALFRED WILEIN SON'S School for Girls Reopens September LS, ISS Refers to Hon. Abram 8S. ht witt, George Wm. Curtis Hon. Wayne MecVeagh, ‘vy. Edward tverett Haie Phomas Wentworth Higgir “ m, Hon. Andrew D.Whit New York, Tarrytown. OME INSTITUTE.—A BO and Day School for young Will reopen Sept. 16. Miss M. 1{1RDING and little METCALF, Prin. ) ; ladies Ww Kiris. NORTH CAROLINA, ~NGLISH AND FRENCH SCHOOL ~ for girls. Mrs. BuURGWYN MAITLAND, Principal Ihe best educational advantages, and the attractions of a beautiful home, in this great health resort. Young ladies may board with the re rine a the summer Address the Principal, Box ¢ Asheville, Onto, Cincinnad. 4 SDEN PAKK SCHOOL FOR GIRLS.— ~« Ninthyear. This schoo! is remarkable for its ugh patronage, home life, unsurpassed advantages for es, Music, ete., and for its beautiful walk from the Art School rculars address MME, FREDIN, dern languax ition, at a few minutes’ and Art Museum. Fore as above. 4 Sept. m oO Outo, Cincinnati, Walnut Hiils. ISS NOURSE WILL REOPEN HER English and French Family and Day School 5. Pupils take special work, or the full course for college examinations, Circulars are ready. OHIO, Cincinnati, 166 4 Seventh Street ] cSS LEP ON SCHOOL FOR P Girls will reopen Buckntthesd 26. > ave been prepared with marked success for co the Har vard examinations apils' / rw A few resident p -received, Onto, Gambier. ARCOURT PLACE Prepares thoroughly f¢ men, or gives a complete SEMINAR Y.— the leading colleges course Onto, Gamble "EN YON MILI TARY ACADEN Y.— A Prepares thoroughly for C ollez e 2 or business. hart ANIA, Bryn Mawr Bree AWE COLLEGE A COLLEGE ynen, ten miles from Philade fYers lergraduate courses in Sar iskrit, Greek ics, English, Anglo-Saxon, Fre d Spanish, German, including Goth ia, History, Political set : y 8 xv, and Ph uP | afus comy hi ish I ry AC Aas AvUOVE vidress PENNSYE VANIA Chester ro 'NSYLVANIA MILITARY ACA- demy. Twenty-eighth session opens September { Military Co . Civil Engineering, Chemisiry hitecture, Arts “Th roughly organized Preparatory irses, Circulars of CoL, CHas, E, Hyatt, Pres. The I] vy ¢ mA STL TAN A, Ox Montgomery (¢ OGONTZ s OL FOR ¥¢ dies, removed in 18 3 from Chestnut deiphia, to (gontz, the spacious « Cooke, will begin its fortieth vear Wednesd 25th. For circulars apply to PRINCIPALS, ¢ t Principals: Miss Frances KE, Kennett Fastman; Principal Emerita: Miss H. A PENNSYLVANIA, Philadel j i GYS aA neh, ane tre 1 | ye s sept IsSv if ( ee \ Pp PENNSYLVANIA, Phil iphia, si ARTIN SCHOOL A the school year LXS¥-1s90, Boys only of the highest character can be received. §600 a year. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadeiph _s M SS ANABLE'S BO. ANI iw School for Young Ladie Sept. 2 eM leacte a, 1454 Pine st 1 to MOTSELLE BONAME'S nel 1d Fnexlish boa n snd Day S« joy Sinan bade s. Will reope pteniber N ber of resident pupils limi It i struction and home care PENNSYLVANIA Niladely and Yo4 W. Chelten | ISS MARY E. STE 4 ing and Day School begir 1889. “‘Approved"’ by Bryn M i thorized *’ to prepare students for n » ¢ nations. Pupils pass these examin atlor Sin thiss PENNSYLVANIA, Swarthmore i ete > ARTHMORE COLLEGE OPENS ~ th onth, loth, 30 minutes from Rroad St. Sta t a Under the are of Friends, but a Full college course for both sexe Classical, SejentifiCc, and Literary. Also a Manua Training and a Preparatory School (2 classes Hear ful location, large grounds, new an lextensive bulld ig ratus. For Catalogue and full particu lars, address EDWARD H, Ma LL, LL.D... Pres't RIN GOA a, Willi amsport. [ICKINSON SEMINARY. A) THO roughly ~ ipped classical and scientifi tor both sexes itteen te hers lreowrees n | Elective studies when de sired Rare facilities in M sic and Art. Buildings spacious Steam, wate ve tilation, fre-escapes, $183 per year for board, w ing, heat, light, and room Tuition according to situ dies Discounts to preachers, teachers, and two fr tl same family, Fell term opens Sept. 2. Catalosue fre E. J. Gray, D1 Presider PENNESSEF, Nashvill TANDERBIL FUR There are vacancies for five boarding UNIVE Over Professors nd Studer Seven distinct ’ ents Academie, Law, Medical, , Pharmaceutical, For catalogue address Wits VIRGINIA, Lexington. CHOOL, WA S?77 7¢ woes he Law = for sessi ( onths 12. Apply for catalog ar expenses. For catalogue address General FRANCIS H. SM S I . PRES } 8, 27 Bouleva Meee VEATMAN OM ti for voung lad is July 2S8t how ve > } NECILLY st 8, [2 Avenue VfB A REN ACK RECEDES 4 t aD re} s wit! ark mi r} 4] *s mls My al dern languages for Ar ans ' t St “OuUntry seat } ay, Sept Jation. iy ida~ i ¢ list a. instr nee hus ~All Civ ex t a * ler ‘ ‘ A nm Vears ex 1a Neu wh ‘ eee in m 7 i 4 ¢ ‘ [Tf School Tr LALO ¢ ‘ t \ 1 > kK RS Deg ' te ‘ and s 8 a ar \ at y M ‘ ‘N Vi S si vert ’ ~~ Ci Ad at ess SI A ~ = ] ‘ ‘ Ke any toreig \ te \ N ¢ ’ { tei\ 5 x ‘ NS ‘ ve x ) T { ai ty I I Te Ste ¢ Nr. oY es, SFT. 2¢ te 1 less ti l - te r 1S I The Nat vertisement « Orders may esponsi } : r directiy t 4} ( vard, 48 Chestnut i ~ ’ \ cf JEL. 9 } L124 ll ‘ W s States 4 \ e ¢ Ss i t i ~ t i K ba | i x «(6h ( s ) i} Se } } nes, S$wq.C et \1 Veal . i rhe eT wer ~ st { { \ I I \ i $39 be torwarded t Ou | ¢ . aUvVCitlis ~ ¢ \ co » ] \ \ 208 Broadwa v. ¥ mde ae pad
Page 2
lv The Nation. SCRIBNER'S EDUCATIO! [Number 1259 VAL BOOKS Suttable for Use in High-Class Schools, Colleges, and Ladtes’ Schools. An Elementary History of Art. By N. D’Anvers. With a Preface by Prof. Roger Smith. An entirely new and enlarged edition. Architecture and Sculpture, Painting. With 360 Illustrations, Large crown 8vo, cloth, gilt top, $3.75. For students who desire thus to train their own minds, for those who wish to oe are themselves for Continental travel, and, above all, for pupils in schools of a | igh class, no handbook of Art History could be more suitable than this volume. Biographies of the Great Musicians. Specially prepared for Schools, Amateurs, and Students of Music. volume strongly bound in decorated cloth. Per volume, $1.00. HAYDN, SCHUBERT, BACH, WAGNER, HAND#L, SCHUMANN, WEBER, ROSSINI, MOZART, PURCELL, MENDELSSOHN. ENGLISH CHURCH COMPOSERS, Atlases. All the latest and best English Atlases for School Use, ete., always on hand, including the following; JOHNSTON'S HISTORICAL ATLAS. —— POLITICAL ATLAS. UNRIVALLED MODERN ATLAS. ~ UNRIVALLED MODERN ATLAS, - UNRIVALLED CLASSICAL ATLAS. - UNRIVALLED CLASSICAL ATLAS. BLACK’S GENERAL ALAS. Folio, $22.50. The Moon: Considered_ as a Planet, a World, and a Satellite. By James Nasmyth and James Carpenter. A new and cheaper edition. With 26 Iilustrations of Lunar Objects, Phenomena, and Scenery, pro- duced from drawings made with the aid of powerful Telescopes, and numerous Woodcuts. Medium 8vo, cloth, $7.50. Lotze’s Microcosmus: An Essay Concern- ing Man and His Relation to the World. Translated from the German by E. Hamilton and E, E. C. Jones, Edition. Thick 8yo, 1488 pages, cioth, $6.00, Vocabulary of Philosophy. Psychological, Ethical, Metaphysical; with Quotations and References. By William Fleming, D.D.; Professor of Moral Philosophy, University of Glasgow. Fourth Edition, revised and largely reconstructed by Henry Calderwood, LL.D., Professor cf Moral Philosophy, University of Edinburgh. 8vo, cloth, $3.00 net. Bell's (C. T. and A. M) Standard Elocu- tionist. Principles and Exercises. Followed by a copious Selection of Extracts in Prose and Poetry. Classified and adapted for Reading and Recitation. New edition, reyised. With Plates. 12mo, half roan, $1.50. Handbook of the English Tongue. For the use of Students and others. By Joseph Angus. 12mo, cloth, $2.00, Stormonth’s (James) Dictionary. An Etymological and Pronouncing Dictionary of the English Language. Including a very copious selection of Scientific Terms, For use in schools and colleges, and as a book o7 general reference. nunciation carefully revised by the Rev. P. H. Phelp. Seventh edi- tion; with additions. 12mo, $3.00, Each 16mo, $1.00. 16mo, $1.00. Folio, bds., $1.40. Folio, cl., $2.00. Folio, bds., $1.40, Folio, cl., $2.00. Second SCRIBNER & WELFORD also supply the entire series ef BoHN's LIBRA- Res, including the Classical, Collegiate, Scientific, ete., ete., containing the Best Editions of Standard Works for Educational and other purposes. Com- plete detailed lists of these and our other publications supplied on application, SCRIBNER & WELFORD, 743-745 BROADWAY, NEW YORK. The pro- | | The History of the Roman Republic. Abridged from the History by Prof. Mommsen. By C. Bryans and F. G | R. Hendy. One volume, 12mo, $1.75, | The merits of Professor Mommsen’s History are well known. The need of an | abridgment of this great work—a book that shoulda present the salient points of the | original in a form suitable for use in schools and colleges—is well met in this cor densation by two competent English scholars. **T have examined it with care and find the work skilfully done, It will be a very welcome book, I am sure, to teachers and students. Ishall be glad to use it with my classes and believe it wiil be widely adopted as a text-book in our schools and colleges.’’—Prof William A. Packard, Princeton College. Important Works by Prof. G. P. Fisher, DD., LL.D. History of the Chris- Manual of Christian tian Church. Evidences. 8vo, with numerous maps. $3.50. 12mo, 75 cents. **T have to tellyou of the pride and de ‘* By all odds, the best treatise on the light with which I have examined your | evidencesof Christianity that we know,’ rich and most instructive volume. As | —The Evraminer. an American, let me thank you for pro- “It touches every leading point of ducing a work so honorable to the coun- | Christian evidence, and meets every in try.’’—Hon,. George Bancroft. | portant objection.’’—The Churchman. First and Fundamental Truths. Being a Treatise on Metaphssics, LL.D. 12mo, $2.00. Dr. MeCosh regards this work as the copestone of what he has been able to do in philosophy. It is destined to rank as the most important of all his works. ** The things noticeable in this book are its fulness of form, its simplicity of diction, its frequent and happy use of illustration, and its steady flow of clear and ample thought.’’—N. Y. Evangelist. By ex-President James MeCosh, D.D., Important Works on Mental and Moral Sctence. An Qutline Study of|The Law of Love, and Man. Love as a Law. bg! nae ia AND MIND IN ONE SYSTEM. With illustrative STIAN ET 'S > Mar diagrams. By Mark Hopkins, D.D., Or, CREST AN BESS. By Mark LL.D., late President Williams Hopkins, D.D., LL.D., late Presi- —— Revised edition. 12mo, dent Williams College, 12mo, Di.so. $1.75. This is designed to follow the author's ‘Outline Study of Man,’ As its title in- | dicates, it is entirely an exposition of | the cardinal precept of Christian philoso do a great work informing not only the | pby in harmony with nature and on the ideas but the character of youth every- | basis of reason. Like the treatise on where.’’—Gen,. 4.C. Armstrong, Principal | mental philosophy, it is adapted with of Hampton Institute, | unusual skill to educational uses. **For over ten years I have madeita text-book in the senior class of this school. It is, I think, the greatest and most use fulof the books of the greatest of our American educators, and is destined to Elements of Physiological Psychology. By George T. Ladd, D.D., Professor of Mental and Moral Philosophy in Yale University. With numerous Illustrations. One vol., 8vo, $4.50° ‘*In giving us something vastly more exact and complete on the physiological sidethan those sorry writings of the!Spencers, the Carpenters, the Maudsleys, anid the Luyses, Pror. Ladd earns the warm gratitude of all English readers. His eru dition, in short, and his broad-mindeduess are on a par with each other; and his volume will probably, for many years to come, be the standard work of reference on the subject.’’— Prof. William James, in The Nation. Elements of Moral Science, Elements of Intellec-| tual Science. | A Manual for Schools and Colleges. By Noah Porter, D.D., LL.D. 8vo,; THEORETICAL AND PRACTI- b come = en | CAL By Noah Porter, D.D., is is an abridgment 0 e author’s | cocoa ‘Human Intellect,’ containing all the | LL.D. 8vo, $3.00. matter necessary for use in the class- room, and has been introduced asatext-| Julius H. Seelye, President Amherst book in Yale, Dartmouth, Bowdoin, | College: ‘* Like all the writings of its dis tinguished author,it is copious and clear, with ample scholarship and remarkable insight, and I am sure that all teachers of moral science will find it a valuable ' aid in their instructions.’’ Oberiin, Bates, Hamilton, Vassar, and Smith Colleges; Wesieyan, Ohio, Lehigh, | and Wooster Universities, and mauy other colleges, academies, pormal and high schools. *,* The above books will be supplied to teachers at SPECIAL NET RATES. Terms given on application. ‘CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS, PUBLISHERS, 743-745 BROADWAY, NEW YORK.
Page 3
The Nation.
NEW YORK, THURSDAY, AUGUST 15, 1889 demnation of Trusts and mbines” which | in Florid S323 per cent North Carolina oa the Philadelphia Press urged upon the Con- | 41.9 per cent. in Mississippi, 42.54 q r -entio?r “thine can be found in it which * ogyrart $37) reer mt ’ , 8 A he \\ eek vention. Nothing cat found in which | Georgia 48.5 | el A Hin e ' » implies any dissatisfaction with any monope cent. in Louisiana L482 per : ; : ; ly whatsoever. On the there is | South Car \ l y &§ [ne meeting held at Harrisburg last week tes +e) ) we ar eas " esd : é ° A resolution Walch hea; A) commenaus the In Wale Siavery eXls i ‘ t pet was nominally the Republican State Con- Sele oni frleciiie i P wn by Con ‘ ¢ eas eet Sint RR ‘ ” ise ha Trienaly LOCA , Soown vo om centay ol tleraey 1,iss \ . (OSs or Da evliwani< it actuall a ck sei . : . vention of Pennsylvania, but actually a d missioner Tanner to his brother soldiers enincke wi Delaware. Marvie \ monstration for Matthew S. Quay. After |...) : ees \ \ . eg os 2 Biss “Qehotres ; : sii sac : Lis ; . endorsing the Chicago platform of last year, |) gona, , fTritad tatoa + ity +) f | | the Convention set about its business Dy ; | passing two resolutions on the trem ndous are os | : , !
subject of Quay. The first of these dwells | abs RS upon the ‘‘ Pennsylvania leadership” of last Pe é — year as the cause of the party’s victory in , Four alle ts se ine | S | the campaign. Not satisfied with this, | — or ; a seer Pi 6 another resolution follows immediately, Am bares mde imeniviags giving particulars. ‘‘ The Republicans of e _ ss ‘ Pennsylvania,” the platform continues, | , — | . ‘claim especial recognition, for the reason | sing _ i oacreeni | < that, in the hour of its extremity, they fur : ; 2 ; Rtas ~~ , nished to the national Republican organi- | P ae 3 ky ; me ah _— e ct zation a Chairman who, during all the anx ma = seeShpeae cau ror Re ase ones = ~ ious days of the recent national campaign, | =_— ; mae os phates : _ a renat % S | in codperation with the honored representa- ngs reve ays : es ayia ehi at w . tives of other States, so controlled the soagiieshioninaireds a : iv a = ere - Pied ee fort forces at hand as to compel victory. The ee ee ¥ i Cilla “ ' G 3 s thanks of the Republicans of this Com ses — a ee eee " monwealth are due and hereby tendered to “tie eateniinnan - vhatarianthe. — — | gai : “— . ‘ the Hon. Matthew 8. Quay for the honorable a ee: Se Oe ee eee ee aig i A mee aud masterful way in which he conducted ee wcthis Pi - , that campaign.” This, we think, is without : ‘ , precedent in our political history, asan exam | ? a pets ‘ _ ‘ ple of arrogance in tone and_ blatherskite | siesta rete | 1 in composition, Mr. Quay not being the no- | MWC® Cf Pieeses : s minee of the Convention for any ottice, and | pn year the Sensaylvama Hep M the refore not proper! the 1 ‘ t of t) tor tA sion { t t : culogy customarily bestowed upon candi. | ' lates The placing of t se two resolut s | j : 2 ihead of tl e Wwhk endorses tl] Ad- | ns stration of President Harris y terrinty : tly not the result of lent. It} * } ] i esig g + ~ Q is t yreater mat tw \ ¢ ) s Ou writ = ’ ‘ Fexas doorkeey ! sh : trrad i ~, That such a convention s ] t t Rey : : Adniinistration because it ‘‘seeks so to ad- | usual spi W ) just the burdens of taxation that those per- | to take little interes t nvass, S . sons and interests able to bear most shall vas t ) I bear most, and so that those able to bear | paign that a fortnight acothe party man rs least shall bear least,” was to be expected Set ito] par st th fepul ms Pres t js lled by the M The theory and practice of representative | might snatch a victory: but the r sult shows ’ government require and suppose that taxes | that there is litt Pros] shall be laid by the legislative branch, and | revolution in Kentucky, the latest returns | \ ( f the patronage that the executive shall not ‘‘ adjust the bur Ind iting that the er rat I rity for | ¢ (x t \ } turned ert
dens of taxation’ at all. The present execu Treasurer will rise t td | Gen. M leclares that ‘‘ the Preside tive has had no opportunity as yet to : | has | vise Congress how such burdens should b The Philadelphia Jess makes a serious | Re] il t idjusted. The Convention has, therefore blunder when it savs explanatior | ticket it minated, and that given its approval to a policy to | this v has t iT g \ \ v the the Constitution or to any form of lj est x Tates t | be ] l ieir noses, to Te government in the world. Nor s | its f State t W r the bosses may direct td move made by mistake. It was a com | The last cen showed the proportion of | ‘‘ We believe we speak for 50,000 true, tried mendation of the policy of increasing taxes | persons ten years of age and upwards unable | Republicans when we say they will not sur; by Treasury decision, and substituti | to read in Kentucky as but 22.2 per cent., | re nder their rights and their convictions at method of advancing private and while it was 24.1 per cent. in Texas, 27.7 | the command of any cabal or combine that terests in place of acts of Congress. We] per cent. in Tennessee, 28.8 per cent. in Ar- | would seek to prostitute the Republican or
look in vain in the platform for the con- ! Kansas, 34 per cent. in Virginia, 88 per cent. ' ganization to such base uses. They wil!
Page 4
122 draw the line between the Repudlican party and the Wahone suction, and when the two contlict, they will support the former all the time, and place their seal of condemnation on the latter.” It is amazing that Northern Republicans should not see as clearly as a Southern Repub- lican like Mr. Yost how fatally the party is discredited when a Republican Administra- tion tries to make such aman as Mahone boss of agreat State. Mahone is a worse man than Butler, but Massachusetts Republicans who considered their State disgraced by the elevation of Butler to its Governorship con- done, if they do not commend, the attempt to saddle Mahone upon Virginia through the prostitution of the civil service of the United States in that commonwealth. There is not a Northern Republican State which would stand such rule as Warmoth gave Louisiana and Clayton gave Arkansas, in the recon struction era, and yet Northern Republicans do not protest when a Republican Adminis- tration turns over the patronage of those States to these discredited politicians. They even profess to wonder that Southern Demo- crats of character and property do not turn Republicans while the Mahones and the War- moths and the Claytons personify Republi- canism in the South. The attention of farmers is directed to the unavailing effort of Secretary Rusk of the Department of Agriculture to secure from the Treasury Department the admission free of duty of potash salts ‘‘expressly used for manure,” as provided in the tariff of 1883. The Secretary’s letter on this subject con- tains a late decision by Judge Lacombe that such salts are entitled to free admis- sion ; but the Treasury refuses to accede to the decision unti] it shall have been passed upon by the Supreme Court. Mean- while, somebody who is making potash salts in this country will be licensed to plunder the American tobacco-grower, and eventual- ly the importers of the salts will recover the amount unlawfully taken from them. The judgment awarded by Judge Lacombe in the case before him was $2,225.84. Interest on this sum is now running at 6 per cent. The pressure upon the Treasury to levy a customs tax on railway cars engaged in transportation and = entering the United States from a foreign country, has all along seemed to us as only a part of the protection- ist ‘fad ” which culminated in the election of Mr. Harrison. Of course, it is always open to Congress, by an appropriate law, to tax such cars on eachentry. Secretary Man- ning suggested to the Ilouse Foreign Affairs Committee, in reply to inquiry respecting retaliation for Canadian treatment of our fishermen, that if Congress wishe? to be of- fensive against Canada, it could levy sucha customs tax, but he did not intimate that the Treasury could levy the tax under existing legislation. That was the outcome of a sub- sequent condition of affairs in the Treasury, when, under Assistant-Secretary Maynard and Special-Agent Tichenor, there seemed to be no limit to the levy and increase of taxes The Nation. by Treasury order, That these cars are brought into the United States no one can deny, nor that the tariff law of 1888 covers railway cars. Secretary Windom concedes that when he warns the Detroit Collector that the ‘‘ free importation of foreign-built railway cars” is not to be permitted. If for- eign-built or foreign owned railway cars, bringing merchandise into the country, are to be taxed, then why not foreign-built or foreign-owned vessels arriving at the port of New York? And, indeed, on the basis of the Vanderbilt-portrait decision, why not every vessel or car or horse and wagon, no matter where built or by whom owned ? Secretary Windom steers clear of the main question by saying that his predecessors have held that the cars are not taxable, because engaged in the international transportation of articles in bond, and Congress has au- thorized such bonding contrivances for the articles. He treats the cars as vehicles, or movable coverings for the bonded articles, and as the articles are bonded, so are the cars. Hle says nothing of mere passenger cars not bonded, but which are stopped on the frontier in order to levy and collect taxes on taxable articles therein. Free interna- tional traftic in such articles, free trade there- in, is not permitted; and why are the cars un- taxed? He abstains from discussing the ques- tion de novo, and yet, only a few days before, his Department had decided that, if an American-built and owned steamer on the lakes received repairsin Canadian waters not required by stress of weather, the repairs were dutiable when the steamer entered an American port. Really, what a queer thing our protective tariff is. The flurry in Atlanta last week over the appointment by the Postmaster of a negro to a place in the office where he would come into constant association with a young white woman, threatened on Monday to develop into a storm which might involve the two races in open warfare. The ill-feeling had been aggravated by the shooting of a negrc offender by a white policeman, and the ex- citement grew almost uncontrollable when it was announced that the negroes proposed to burn in effigy the white woman who re- signed her place in the oflice rather than associate with the negro, in return for the burning in efligy by the whites of the Post- master who appointed the negro. Cool- headed leaders amony the whites, notably Gov. Gordon, succeeded in averting a col- lision, although the ugly feeling which has been aroused will not easily subside. The whole performance appears ridiculous to outsiders. Negroes have been employed in other positions in the Atlanta Post-office without anybody's making objection, and in the present case it would seem to bea purely personal matter for the woman af- fected to settle herself. She settled it by re- siznation ; but another white woman was readily found who was glad to accept the position —a lady who, the Constitution says, is the widow of a school principal, and ‘‘is well known throughout the city.” So far as the Postmaster is concerned, he ap- [Number 1259 pears simply to have discharged a duty, under the Civil-Service Law, as to which he had no discretion. The Committee on World’s-Fair finance ap pointed by the Mayor is entirely competent to deal with the question before it if the members take hold of thesubject in the same spirit that they would undertake the financing of a new railroad or any great industrial en- terprise. They cannot have failed to observe the very general comment of the press in other cities, that there is no public spirit in New York. The idea iscommonly entertained that either Chicago or St. Louis can raise more money for any purpose when local pride is aroused than New York can. Sar- castic inquiries are every where made concern- ing the state of the Grant Monument Fund and the Centennial Arch Fund, and it is assumed that because a million dollars have not been contributed to the one and a hundred thou- sand dollars to the other, New York has no public spirit and no local pride. The fact is forgotten, perhaps, that the Washington National Monument, a commemorative enter- prise in which the whole nation was equally interested, lingered thirty years, although a very industrious committee had it in charge, and was finally finished by an appropriation from the public treasury, and would not have been finished in any other way to this day, if ever. The Grant Monument Com- mittee laid out too large a programme for voluntary effort. New York gives very large sums of money every year to charitable purposes. Her contributions to the sufferers by the Johnstown tlood and the Chicago fire were in proportion to her resources. Nobody has ever found fault with her for the small- ness of her donations to the afflicted, either within or without her own precincts. But she has not been very liberal in the way of monuments, nor has any other city, nor have the American people in general distinguished themselves in this way. Even the monu- ments to Lincoln and Douglas, at Springfield and Chicago, were built by public appropria- tions of the State, and the fine bronze statue of Lincoln at Chicago was the gift of a single citizen. The new schism in the Single-Tax party is not made exactly intelligible inthe last num- ber of Henry George’s paper. The Rev. Pentecost, in the Zirentieth Century (schis- matic), asked Mr. George, immediately on his return from Europe, nine questions seriatim. He wanted to know, first, whether Mr. George ‘considers that the object of the Standard, and of all those who are working for eman- cipation, should be the enforcement of « great religious truth, or a mere readjustment of taxation, and nothing more.” Also, whether he agrees with one of his fellow-editors in thinking ‘‘ that the emancipation movement should be lifted ‘ out of the howling-dervish stage of emotional insanity, into the reign of common sense and practical action ?’ ’—the ‘‘howling-dervish stage of emotional in- sanity” being a sarcastic phrase intended to be descriptive of Mr. Pentecost and his supporters. Also, whether he ‘‘ approves of the editorial declarations of the Standard that
Page 5
Aug. 15, 1889] ‘the right of private property in land is not the presem practical question in connection with the single tax.”” Also, several other pointed interrogatories, all implying that Mr. George is sheering away from his text and abandon- ing his flock to the wolves. If so, the Rev. Pentecost ready to } their shepherd, and has prepared himself for that function by procuring lists of a number of Mr. George's Single-Tax clubs and sending stands vecome specimen copies of his own paper to them. This method of preserving the tlock has, how ever, been stopped orders, issued Mr. George as soon as he arrived, not to allow Mr. Pentecost the lists, by by to have access to Two different organizations of Socialists, the Possibilists and the Marxists, have just held in Paris. attempts were made to fuse the two bodies, but without success. It is a little hard to make out what great difference exists be the two. great enough to keep them long apart. separate congresses Some tween Certainly none appears Both avree in their main end and aim, which is the appropriation by society at large of the capi tal now existing in private hands. Both de collectivism,” communism word sire a their -~or as is—and their only difference seems to be as to the agent who shall have charge of the public goods and be in the The Marxists would prefer a collectivism organized by the State, while the Possibilists look rather to munici possession of power. pal collectivism. Doubtless, if at any time, in consequence of a revolution, let us say, or of some other social upheaval, either party saw a chance of success, the other party would at once join it and march under its banners into the Promised Land. Everybody who has—as so many have found pleasure and profit in Prof. Mahaffy’s literary and historical work, will be pained and disappointed by his treating the Ameri- can public, almost as soon as he landed, to a sharp lecture on the impropriety of diifering from him on one ofthe most burning, no torious, and much thrashed questions of British politics. It appears that those who do not with him about Irish Home Rule have had ‘‘ their minds poisoned from Ireland by agents of the non-Unionists ” ; that they cannot understand it * are deep scholars,” agree hae they unless and that they are igno rant of the doctrines and history of the Catholic Church, of which he was pleased to give them a brief sketch. Considering that nearly half the English people, includ of their nd some wna scholars, and a majority of the Scotch, dissent ing ublest statesmen from the Professor on this topic, itis difhi cult to know what name to rebuke of his to Americans. call it at present hope he will not repeat. He will ly welcomed here l give to this We shall only an indiscretion which we } s be cordial ergy and a as a Ci scholar, but nobody looked or expected his politi party politic i in, opinions to have the smallest value Phat he is rather ubfi discuss questior i voyernmen! publ his disquisit
The Nation. relations of Utah and the Southern tothe Union showed clearly, and we hope his States Chautauquan friends will turn his attention into some more suitable field. The Canadians are plunged into a flerce religious controversy, Which may have im portant political results, by the restoration to | the Jesuits by the Quebec Legislature of the property which was confiscated when they It AC were expelled from the country in 1782. is estimated at $300,000 now, and when the poration of the Order in Canada, it is no The fund, of absolute d Incor companied, as it is or is to be, by small gain for the Church, isposition of will be at the | the Pope. The tremendous uproar among the Protestants of course, transaction has created a the other provinces of the Dominion, and they are furious with the Governor General for allowing the act to go into force without vetoing it or ‘* disallowing” it, as the phrase is, Which he is empowered to do under the Canadian Constitution. On what ground he could have vetoed it, it is, however, hard to see. The property in question lies within the Province of Quebec. It is confessedly at the disposal of the provincial Legislature, and the only good objection to its restoration is a moral and the Jesuits are a ought be not a legal one bad namely, that organization, which not to encouraged. It is very difficult in our day to put this argu ment into legal shape. The Jesuits’ plea that the contiscation of their was simple robbery accomplished with the is, property strong hand, and that its restoration is resti tution and not simple donation. A goo many Canadians think such a thing could not be done in the United States; but i could. Nothing prevents the estat
of the Catholic Churchin New York, with rich endowments from the State Treasury, but the determination of the majority of of the State not to permit sort. he people anything o The trouble in Quebec i jority is Catholic, pious, thinks the Jesuits estimable and ill and how this difticulty is to be got day it is hard tosee. It will, however, make a good many Americans think twice before letting (duebec into the a -_ mack A sale by auction was made
July 17 which in its way is as noteworthy as the sale of Millet’s picture. The property disposed of was ‘* one entire and undivided share in the Adventurer’s Moiety of the es tates and interests of the New River Th Adventurer” was Hugh Mrddelton, the projec r of n New R ver and t s is the tirst share « lat property which has beet sold since the work was completed in the vear 1613 The va of a share at that dat was £100, There were seventy-two shares n all; half were taken by the King and half went to Sir Hugh, who was knighted by Tames | Te i The King’s shares 1 by Charles I. to th elton r = on e 9 crow if OM) px \ l ie t I i f) SUATCS WA ist Vea ye Sew fe iv the no
minal ¢: ipit of the «a pany is Ss wh v Parliamentary returns, is only about three ind ahalf mill 3 Phe company possesses the exclusive right of supplving water to all the northern suburbs of lon, to ¢t whole of the city of London and pa H Westminster, to several wealthy parishes in the West End, and to parts of Middlesexa Hertfordshire Valual states also be ce t the chief f whicl the Mvyddelton square property sists tv a s the very heart of I Lor The New Riv iqueduct was an object of public interest
and curiosity long after it was « plete Evelyn notes in his ary a Visit to it tt vear 1686. The share that was sold t ’ , dav brought £122,8 7 ‘ } I i€@ 4 ca 4 Nels | iv } ad i ‘ ‘ inttne at ’ a r tr ACleeyer a i 1 CC iin iss \ ‘ i . . ve lers in } Yr mm f wi m the ’ ° has, under the iz t £ ¢ . 8 s and the rowth of wealtl rather spread of wealt! reased enot sly ng the past ten years hev ss the European ¢ iinet z iss Spires bu n heavy battalions, s« . personally « ed Wor LOO) by « f 4 ‘ aptuins, t ener still helpless fx \ borhood ~ thev K ‘ w! to see they know 1 wWhia Thev are t only foreigners w W ate Italy luring the summer 1 : happy fore, t ’ ‘ cTt i ty Ww evervwher \s i ‘ i T t search the \ S est know ledge t ( \ { torelyg aves or law i eTs OT ¢ st s } { st vy. of 4 rar mi y ‘ tor - ‘ < graphy fa i i } inv ‘ t} ‘ re wl ‘ iT he \ COS ~ ‘ } ‘ SarvV ey At i r ena TAN anv ’ . } n ' , mMor;©e than & CUA t ir md Ss ( bd ’ V exper of cas Yr } cS v ? ‘ fre @} b ius every 3 k SSUI . » Ss tain amour f knowledge thie ibove ¢ ? 4 ae +) - eids ihe two th Ss, as ag i it -} } yw, ¢? , , ¢ » y which press them st are e specta f women working the fields and the 7 } ‘ } , absence of igrace-checkKs, Wha peagues andi «bewilders them most Is the I of their trunks at the railroad stations, a1 he : : ied s service of n courses at the tables : Thote It i t surprising that under these +) ) — } circumstances e elders at least soon vet tired and sick, and that ve to t¢ | Y sit dow and talk al Jim Smith and »;! | + } , , ' Bi 4 s at [ t There is a pathe i storv, which we believe to be ithentic. of a cert creme a a0 1 Maine who ‘* doing Europe ‘ pany with his wifeand daugh terc a f ag y at t! » oreat ad ters a Tew vears age, met at the great door f St. Peters at Rome a friend who happened ) } to have about He's Ban W? and which came to the General, weary with the Eternal the iim a COpy of Bouts which he offered him, manna in wilderness City, as Ife seized it, sat down on the steps to peruse it, and let his women-folk”” inspect St. prot ibly the h Bow ighest compli thre Al brave indeed aby erican je has ever received
Page 6
1:24. THE BLACK-DIAMOND SEIZURE. Tue cable despatch received by the Montreal Gazette stating that ‘‘ the imperial authorities have decided that British rights in Behring from outrage,” is probably authentic. We so consider it be- Sea must be protected cause it represents the sort of decision we should come to ina parallel case. Reluctant as Great Britain is, and must be, to have any difficulty with us, there are limits beyond which she cannot be pushed. The seizure of one’s vessels on the high seas is very provok ing to national pride, One such seizure may be regarded as accidental and unauthorized, but if followed by another and another and another, a state of public feeling may be ex cited which no Government can cope with. The Behring Sea controversy is in that criti cal state where both Governments are at the mercy of chance. A very little spilling of blood, perhaps only accidental, might bring on a deadly conflict. It is important, there fore, to know where we stand, and what our reasous are for being in danger of embroil- ment with our next of kin. In the first place, let us dismiss the idea that England will allow (any more than we would) any commercial gain to outweigh the national honor. We have been told over and over again in the past two weeks that she is just as much interested in protecting the seal-fishery as we are; that if we catch the seals, the skins all go to London to be tanned, and sold, and distributed to the world; that consequently she would lose as much as we should by the extermination of the race at the hands of the ‘* pirates.” What does all thisimply? That any great nation is going to allow others to decide that her subjects are pirates when they are prose cuting on the high seas under her tlag a trade which she recognizes as lawful, mere ly because a tannery is making money ? The conception is too absurd. That England did assent to our suggestion for international policing of Behring Sea, with the express purpose of preserving the seals from destruction, is evidence of her good will, but by no means signifies her assent to our assumption of exclusive police jurisdiction in those waters. On the contra- ry, it presupposes that we, having put forward the idea of joint action, will stay our hand until it is carried into effect, no delay having been interposed by her meanwhile. Why were these peaceful and proper nego- tiations broken off 2? The diplomatic cor respondence does not show, but, perhaps, when the later volume, now in the Govern- ment Printing Office, comes out, we may know more. In the absence of better in formation, it is a fair inference that the poli- tical deadlock of the last two years frusirated this intended treaty, as it did the Fishery Treaty, the Extradition Treaty, the Chinese Treaty, and everything else that might have reflected credit upon Mr. Cleveland’s Ad- ministration, The Senate was determined to reject anything that would have that. po litical effect. Its Committee on Foreign Re- lations resolved, for example, that the fishery question was not a fit subject for any treaty or gny negotiation, and the Senate refused to The Nation. amend the treaty that was negotiated in any way whatsoever, or to say in what way it might be made satisfactory. We allude to these things not in the way of reproach. That is all burnt powder. What we now infer is, that the impossibility of doing anything in the foreign department by reason of the political deadlock was the reason Why a very promising beginning for the settlement of the Behring Sea question came to no conclusion at all, either satisfac- tory or otherwise. Itis not a strained infer- ence, also, that the present Administration has been so engrossed in the task of peddling out the offices that it could not find time to take up the threads of the suspended nego tiation, but was compelled to give a general order respecting Behring Sea, and then trust to luck. that inspires high officers of the Government, now that trouble is impending, to apply the term ‘* pirates ” to people wheare fishing for seals, although if they were taking whales or walruses in the same waters, they would be very respectable persons, It should be borne in mind that Russia has larger interests in those waters than England has, and that her codperation is more need- fu). The seal in his wanderings does not ob- serve the line drawn north and south from Behring Strait, midway between Alton and Copper Islands, nor the line drawn east and west along the Aleutian Islands. He is now on one side and now on the other of both lines. Russia, like ourselves, has seal-breed ing islands, from which she derives a reve nue. She is interested like ourselves in preserving the race from extermination. To suppose that the seal can be preserved by Probably it is a sense of laches ’ catching ‘‘ pirates”? on one side of an imagi- nary line and leaving them free on the other side is ridiculous. Now, Russia was an active party to the negotiation for international protection of the seal. She wanted to have the line of immunity, or non-fishing, drawn considerably south of the Aleutian group, and Mr. Bayard acquiesced in this. But here, as we know, the negotiation ended. It is due to Russia as well as to Great Britain, that it should be resumed oa the original lines, and that meanwhile no chance should be left open for the embroilment of the two nations in war or serious estrangement. THE NEW YORK PAVEMENTS. Pror. J. S. Newberry, of the Columbia College School of Mines, has been making a careful examination of the different kinds of street pavement in use in some of the principal European cities, and has thrown the result of his observations into a paper in the School of Mines Quarterly on ‘‘ The Street Pavements of New York.” These pavements are, notoriously, so bad that they have to a large extent driven out of use every mode of transportation for persons except the railways. The number even of the rich who keep carriages for pleasure either diminishes steadily, or does not increase in proportion to population, so great is the wear and tear of horses and vehicles caused by the condition of the roadway. For in- valids—and especially for women invalids— [Number 1259 carriage exercise except in the Park has become an impossibility; and to use the Park with comfort or safety they have, con- sequently, to live very near it. Bad pave- ments, too, mean insuflicient sweeping and general indifference to appearances. The use of the streets to keep wagons in, and to pile up ashes and garbage in, would not be tole rated very long in a well-paved city. From all this, too, the poor are the worst sufferers. Curiously enough, considering how demo- cratic the government is, the rich secure all the good paving and good sweeping there is. It is the quarters of the poor which are most nevlected. It is, of course, only with the material con ditions of good city pavement that Prof. New berry, as a scientific man, occupies himself. He says that ‘tin New York a greater variety of excellent materials for street pave ments can be obtained, and at acheaper rate, than any city in the world,” notably the blue- stone, which is found in inexhaustible quan- tities at various points along the Hudson, and granite, which can be found cheap and good in the Highlands about West Point. This latter has been used in the pavement of Fifth Avenue, which he calls ‘‘ reaily good,” but says it would have been better if ‘* the blocks had been thinner and the roadbed had been more carefully prepared.” In fact, this failure to prepare the substratum properly for the pavement is one great cause, perhaps the greatest, of the bad condition of our streets. In his account of the as- phalt pavement in London and elsewhere, he touches on another cause, perhaps as power- ful as any—the reluctance of Americans to make any provision for the maintenance and repair of streets and roads after they have been once put in order: ‘* The result of the experience of the last ten years has clearly shown that the pavement made with the Trinidad asphalt is equal to any in the world, and superior to any other kind of pavement in use. Its excellences—cleanliness, silence, and salubrity—are so apparent that no argument is now needed to enforce them. ‘To these may be added, and placed first in the list, economy ; for it costs as little and lasts as long as any other good pavement, and is much less trying to horses, vehicles, and hu- man nerves. it is rapidly growing in favor, and it is not too much to say that itis the pave- ment of the future, and is destined in most lo- calities to supersede all other kinds. * Ina recent visit to Washington I found some of the streets in a bad condition. Even on Fourteenth Street, in front of the Treasury Building, the asphalt pavement is full of holes, and the condition of this great thoroughfare has led to an opinion which I found quite pre- valent, that asphalt was only adapted to streets where the traflic was not great and the vehicles were light. This isa mistake, however. There is no street in America or elsewhere in the world that bas as much trafficas Cheapside, London, and among the vehicles which pass through it are omnibuses, loaded with passen- gers inside and on top, carts of all descriptions, and, heaviest of all, the trucks of the great brewers with their enormous borses and tons of ale and porter. And yet Cheapside is paved with asphalt and is as smooth as a house-floor. The secret of its perfection is the thorough manner in which the pave- ment is laid and the incessant care given toit. In nothing is the axiom truer tban in the asphalt pavements, ‘that a stitch in time saves nine.’ The material has little hardness, and if, from irregular settling of the roadbed or loval violence, a break occurs, the passing wheels rapidly shear off the sides of the hole, and it soon assumes formidable dimensions. In London this is prevented by constant wateh- Julness ; persons are employed to traverse the street with a light repairing outfit, and wher- Aug. everad and soe ished ments a years a than a “Ow is at ou r (tcl irene would ] Hecessa pr mpt ‘(me improv New ¥ which 1 iy ne or for or fro trates seems ments, quently yviven ¢ paver smooth in a far beyond nection matter probab tory sy ways $ pipes, € out tea opened structi prove 1 lation, er stree iuch ¢ surmot than ce Prof. ! are rea ments lin, in in use. The ment i berry « come \ neer: And y parisol don, 01 If, for were streets cause litfere us nc work creat fact th not sel luties, creat ut th spendi Phe pr the ocke n tu ce G elicier iblie ilwavs ist W
Page 7
Aug. 15, 1889] ever a defect is ebserved, this is patched at once, and so effectually that the spot cannot be distin- ished. The contractors who lay the pave- ments agree to keep them in order for fifteen years at a price which does not average more than a few cents a square yard. * Our people seem to think that no parement is a good one unless when once laid it will for rtake care of itself; but there is no such cement. Even our rough stone roadways would pay excellent interest on the expenditure necessary for constant inspection and repairs promptly made when needed. ‘One great difficulty stands in the way of the improvement of the pavements in the city of New York, and that is the frequency with which they are torn up for the purpose of lay- i new lines of gas, water, or steam bipes, or for the repair of such pipes when broken or frozen. The depth to which frost pene trates the ground in our severe winters secms to make it necessary that our pave ments, as at present laid, should be fre jaentiy torn up, and until more care is viven tothe removal and replacement of the pavementit is impossible that we should have smooth roadways. This evil could bave been in a large degree obviated by sinking the pipes beyond the reach of the frost, but, from the con- nections already made, this would now be a matter of extreme difticulty, and it is even probable that we can never have a satisfac- tory system of paving until commodious sub- ways shall be constructed to receive all the pipes, and where they may be accessible with- out tearing up the streets. In tue new streets opened in our rapidly growing cities the con- struction of such subways is possible, and would prove not only a great convenience to the popu- lation, but a substantial economy. In the old er streets the cost and inconvenience would be much greater, but the difficulty is not here in- surmountable, and the benefits would far more than compensate for the cost.” Prof. Newberry’s conclusions about asphalt are reached after an examination of the pave ments of London, Paris, Brussels, and Ber lin, in all of which stone and wood are also in use and have been thoroughly tried. The greatest of all obstacles to good pave mentin New York, however, Prof. New berry does not mention, because it does not come within the province of the civil engi neer; We mean what is called ‘* politics.” nd yet, without the mention of this, all com parisons Of our pavements with those of Lon- don, or Paris, or Berlin, must be misleading. If, for instance, a German or Frenchman were to come to the conclusion that our streets were in their present condition be- cause Wwe were ignorant of the merits of lilferent kinds of paving, or had among experts competent work in the best manner, he would make a sreat mistake. Our difficulty lies in the fact that the men who govern the city are it selected for their fitness for their special luties, and do not give their minds, when a creat publie work is undertaken, to anything ut the advantage to be got out of the -pending of the money for their own party. (he public mind, too, has been so debauched the spoils system that people are not ocked when they see an expert like New- n turned out to make way for a politician ce Gilroy. The spoils system is fatal to ‘iciency or honesty inthe execution of all iblic improvements, because it is concerned \ways in the filling of places, and not in the ist with the quality of the result. is no to do such THE MAYBRICK CASE. lie report from Bar Harbor that ‘* neither resident Harrison nor Mr. Blaine will con ent to talk for publication on the subject of Mrs, Maybrick’s fate” is probably true; but The the remark which the Nation. that, Maybrick lost her American na reporter adds, ‘*as Mrs tionality and became an Englishwoman when she married her late husband, it is difficult to see in what manner the United States Government could interfere in her behalf is another and somewhat amusing illustra tion of the way in which, as the country ‘ grows, the knowledge of law, which used to be so common, seems to decline. The belief that President Harrison possessed and would exercise some of many Republican editors sort of dictatorial powers towards the South f of the Rey vention of Pennsylvania that the ern States, the belit mublican Con is charged with the duty of ** adjusting burden of taxation with reference to the needs of the taxpayer, and that ‘* the honest collection and honest disbursement of the proceeds of public taxation” are a discretion ary work which the Administration is en titled to praise even for ‘‘ proposing,” and the confessed ignorance of the editor of so promine nt, a paper as the Indianapolis Journal that there exists any tribunal for the interpretation of the Federal Constitu the conspicuous feature in the American system of government—all tion—the Supreme Court being most these things are striking signs of the decay, even among politicians, of f their Thirty years ago mistakes of a knowledge of the machinery ¢ own yovernment, this sort, when they appeared in the Suturd Revi as they often did—used to merriment here, but the number of thos who would fallen olf Somewhat similar ignorance seems widely d see the fun of them has sadly prevalent among another el: duty of the Government t iss wards . arraigned for criminal offences, before for eign tribunals, in civilized countries. There is lurking in many that our Government possesses the power of revising, and if need f annulling, the be, of judgments of such tribunals in the case of American citizens, and this notion, it must be admitted, got some counte minds & vague notion unusual, and that confess is not extorted by ny species of torture r persecut This is doubly true with regard to offences conil tted i | ind \“ st eT 4 t ire ware Xe \ } ri “? ‘ ! ’ «} = ‘ ‘ ‘> ‘ It: —— = it = ‘ M s Mavi ‘ cease had not st her tionality or woman against the legal consequences of the commission of a crime on fore! Sell, There s no ippeai fror t dict of a Britis iry rf lecis f i Britis! idge, either to President H son or Secretary Blaine rto Quav or W maker, any 2 e than fr v ‘ American jurv and the decisi f Ame can judge to Lord Salisbury, Mr. Matthews Chamberlain or Ra ph Churel if Judge Stephen has cor tlead errors ¢ in his rulings on the evidence or in his cha to the jury, they will be examined in u tish Court of Appeal. If the verdict of iry has been p! ¥ given sins v denct either it w be set as or t soner Will be par {i bvt I ~ tary The po; I proaur in Liv . (it 1! tedly iT \ et ( \ J ? ‘ Ste } ‘ ‘ misinyg Way w! } res s ments. Almost vy other i thre lish bench might doubtless hav t S strongly against the pris is “ it creat sco } ex ‘ s ul non for an Ex sh } race against a prisoner \ I . t twist evid et . Il has ne I e tI r th CHSC i Lor ( amp hy l Int! case of P r. wl it is part it the current Ss { t \ the Julge was determined to ha f ! itset. so sure was | f his l as appears tk be now maintai it f the spectators in the troo! ‘ the | populace of Liver ght toweig! wit the trovVerTn? wt thar tiie f thre Lor ina the verdict f the vy. ti inference would appear to be ivoidal i that ises of this k ght to be tried i Athenian fashion, by a public meeting, a the verdict taket by i Vote « the Australia | systen At this st e the presum} lof Mrs Maybrick’s guilt appears to be | overwhelmingly strong. Her argument tha she would not have been found guilty if she | had not had a lover, sounds ve ry like a plea | that the desire for the victim’s money, us in Palmers case ght not to be admitted as corroborative proof. The first and main | bestior all criminal casesis the (Ue stion } of 1 ve No sane person is supposed t } commit a deliberate murder for fun THE ANNUAL WAR ALARM. Tit annual discussion of the probabilities of extraordinary conduct of in the case of O'Donnell, w} Was convicted ar executed for the murder of Carey the i: former. There was vo doubt of his | guilt or of the fairness of his trial, br it seemed to many asif the sentence ought not to have been carried t wit an examination and approval of the pr ceedings by our Secretary of Stat T same question was raised in the Lamson cas but with less success. Lord Salisbury gav acertain sanction to such agitations by ask ing the Governor of Missouri to postpone the execution of Maxwell until some sort of fresh appeal could be sent to him from Eng land. It ought to be known even in primary schools that when an American commits murder or robbery in any foreign country of Christendom, the power of interference pos sessed by our Government is limited to see ing that he is brought to a speedy trial, that he is allowed communication with his counsel and friends, that the trial is fair) conducted according to the procedure of 1} country, that the punishment is not cruel or a general Eurepean war” has just taken |} place in England—the only country in which h adiscussion can take place with any The for such a war is probable, and which furnish suc frankness reasons thinking that
Page 8
126 the journalists with a good many topics, are about the same from year to year. There is in the first place Turkey, which is always in danger of breaking up; there is Greece, which is always eager to enlarge her borders by seizing Macedonia; there is Bulgaria, which wants Rumelia, and Servia which wantsa piece of Bulgaria; there is Russia, which wants to absorb or control both Ru- mania, Servia, and Bulgaria, and kick Aus tria out of the Panslavic region. Then there is Italy, which wants to take away the Canton of Ticino from Switzer- Jand, anda bit of Dalmatia from Austria. There is France, which wants to get at Germany, and to get the English out of Egypt, and have more colonies than she can afford to settle. There is Germany, which is determined that France shall not catch her unprepared,and also to have as many colonies as Great Britain has. Though last, not least, all the first-class Powers except England —viz,, France, Germany, Austria, Russia, and Italy —have standing armies so large as to constitute an almost overwhelming burden on industry and to increase greatly the tide of emigration. It is easy to see What an enormous number of topics such a situation affords, and what an excellent showing any one may make out of them for the view that we are on the eve of one of the most terrible contlicts the world has seen since the fall of the Roman Empire. Nevertheless it contains, we repeat, certain guarantees of peace, for the present at least, of extraordinary strength. One of them is the size of the modern armies. There is a popular view that the size of these armies tempts governments to go to war. We hold, on the contrary, that every government which possesses them shrinks from putting them in the field, partly owing to fear of the effect on the national industry and finance, and partly to the very natural doubt whether it has generals fit to handle them. A bad general at the head of a small army is a comparatively harmless person; a bad general at the head of a million of men may prove a monster of mischief. The great armies of the Napoleonic period were created by generals who had slowly learned to use them in active service. The armies now in existence, Moltke having retired, would be led by men who may possibly be geniuses, but may also be veritable dunderheads. Every government feels this and puts off the hour of trial accordingly. Moreover, the absurdity of the notion that permanent peace can be secured by one great fight is becom- ing Clearer to the European mind, On the contrary, every great fight sows the seeds of future quarrels, because the victor is sure to seize something with a ‘‘mailed hand” which the vanquished determines to wrest from him as soon as he isable. Therefore people say, with much wisdom, that terrible as is the bur- den of a great army in time of peace, war would make it twice as terrible, The Franco-German war was due to the ignorance of the French, both about their own military resources and those of their adversary. That ignorance exists no longer. Each side kuows what the other can do, Moreover, the material conditions of a cam The Nation paign between these two adversaries have greatly changed since 1870. The French army has been completely reorganized and much increased, but Metz has become absolutely impregnable. No hostile force can now” get within nineteen miles of the old Vauban fortress which the Germans invested. On the other hand, all the ground round Paris which the Germans occupicd in 1870, has been tho roughly fortitied. In fact, itis estimated that the French have spent on the new defences of the city the enormous sum of $675,- 000,000. The outer circle is now seventy- five miles long, and on the north and south side is an entrenched camp capable of holding 150,000 men. When the works now in progress are completed, the circle will be ninety miles long. The difference this will make in the next war is obvious. If we add to the uncertainties thus created the absolute ignorance in which the world now lives as to the results of a great naval war, with the new iron-clads and torpedoes, we have abundant reason for believing that there are more signs of war in the newspa- pers than in the war offices. THE SWISS ITALIANS., THe internal politics of Switzerland have an interest for Americans, even when io trinsically unimportant, in that they afford an opportunity of observing the working of political machinery in most respects like ours, on matters similar to those which have figured in our politics, or may do so_here- after. Indeed, the recent agitation in the canton of Ticino, and the Federal interfer- ence therein, recall vividly the Reconstruc- tion period in the Southern States, though the usurpation of power by the central Government, with us checked by the Su- preme Court, appears in Switzerland to have ridden triumphantly over the rights of the States. The disregard by the Swiss executive of the letter, if not the spirit, of the Constitution was as complete as that which occurred during the ‘‘conflict period” of 1864-5 in Prussia; but as the majority in both houses of the Swiss Parliament is of the same party as the executive, it naturally did not wish to take any action, like the bill of indemnity passed by the Prussian houses after 1866, which would imply recog nition of a violation of the organic law. The canton of Ticino, whose affairs have led to this amendment of the Constitution by legislative decision, is the only one in which Italian is the prevailing language, and, though long connected with the German cantons in a territorial relation, is the youngest of the cantons to enjoy the rights of statehood. It was abominably misgoverned during the last century—so much so, according to the account of the abuses common while Bonstetten was Governor, as related in his entertaining letters, that relatively, if not positively, the exactions of a proconsul were far exceeded. Partly from this cause, and partly from the neces- sary poverty of the people, it is one of the most backward districts of Europe, not only in political and religious enlightenment, but in the respect of material progress. Most [Number 1259 of the “Italian” barbers and organ-grinders in foreign countries, not to mention great numbers of agricultural laborers who appear annually in the adjoining parts of France and Germany, attest at once the poverty of the population and their fondness for their ng tive land, since all of them who are able ty save anything return sooner or later. Though the canton boasts of a ‘‘ unity of faith’ second only to that of Tyrol, there has long been a strong opposition to th clerical party, the lawyers being as activ: and devoted on the ‘‘ Radical” side as tly priests and wealthy class are on theirs. And though itis long since there has been a chang: of administration, yet the parties are so evenly balanced that every election is the occasion of violent agitation, and the colonization of a few hundred voters would at any time change the result—a fact of importance in view of the character of the emigration from the district. It has long been alleged by the Radicals that their opponents ‘‘ colonized” in a quiet way, in spite of a law, passed with the assent of both parties, declaring non-resi- dents not entitled to the suffrage. For tli election which was held the 8d of last March the Radicals determined to do on a large scale what their opponents were said to have done on a small one. In February the news papers announced that one of the Radical leaders was in Paris arranging for the return of a large number of natives whose domicile was in France, and 900 are said to have ap peared in answer to the summons. They were prepared to assert their claims by arms, and the authorities were equally prepared t resist them. It was at this point that the Federal Government began to act. Now, the Swiss Constitution, though amended in the direction of centralization in 1874, still retains provisions, apparently copied from that of the United States, guaranteeing the rights of the cantons, and asserting that all rights not in terms given to the Federal power are reserved to them. The Sixteenth Article also provides that ‘‘ when internal disturbances exist, or when danger from another canton is threatened, the Gov- ernment of a canton shall immediately in form the Federal Council [7. e., the Execu- tive], in order that the latter, so far as its powers extend, may take proper measures, or summon the Parliament. . . . If the cantonal Government is unable to call for help, the Federal Government jay act on its own initiative, and if the security of th country at large is in danger, it sii2/ do so.” But in the Ticino affair, as is shown by Dr. Vogt, himself a Liberal, in his moderate- ly worded pamphlet on the ‘ Tessiner Frage, and as has been urged vehementiy by the Conservative press, order was not disturbed— there merely was danger that it might be; tlc cantonal Government did not ask for aid, but, confident in its ability to put down any ris ing, protested against Federal interferenc: and there was no pretence that either of the other contingencies had arisen. Inu fact, not only was no blood spilt, but, in spite of the attempted colonization and the moral sup port given by the Federal authorities, not on!y through the occupation of the canton troops, but also through a written protest to the \ Aug. cantona iw, the The wh fore, lie al prece the wri wards ¢ the sup manage us that Federa the ele that the one, ar executi have Ci TH I MU dordy, first p ties in the cou its fore as com portan ed wit the Co survey Years’ Years’ Frencl not m shown ISTO, born « de Ch ty of « gitime in the foreig sembl the ne Paris: creat on Sy choos by tk whick articl regul, from dordy a mis’ “A fte befor herse and « macy Hung favor of ac uneas trian is eas its Ww M. rope, now liane safeg his e consi and | are n Fran
Page 9
ug. do \ Pe 15, 1889] cantonal Government against the non-resident iw, the Opposition was again unsuccessful. lhe whole importance of the incident, there- fore, lies in the establishment of a constitution al precedent, in that the executive disregarded the written law, and the Legislature after- wards did not condone, but approved, its ac But had the Ticino Liberals studied our history, they might, confident as they were of the support of the Protestant cantons, have managed better. sar Lon It appears plain enough to is that their proper course was to secure Federal interference after, instead of before, the election. They had then only to claim that their opponents’ majority was an illegal and to set up their own Legislature and executive in a hall, after which they could have called for troops at their leisure. one, THE FRENCH FOREIGN POLICY, PARIS, July 25, 1889, I musT return to the book of Count Chan- dordy, ‘ France in 1889,’ I have analyzed its first part, which treats of the state of par- ties in France and of the interior condition of the country. The second part is an analysis of its foreign policy, which derives much interest as coming from a man who has occupied im- portant diplomatic posts, and who is acquaint ed with all the eminent diplomats of the Continent. The author begins by a rapid survey of the wars of the last centuries—Thirty Years’ War, the Peace of Westphalia, the Seven Years’ War, the Partition of the French Revolution. The wars of Napoleon are not narrated, but their results are rapidly shown. oar SiO, most Poland, Let us come immediately to the year When the Empire fell, the Government born on the 4th of September ought, says M. de Chaudordy, to have felt at once the necessi- ty of creating for itself an authority and a le gitimacy which were necessary to it, not only in the eyes of the country, but in the eyes of foreign Powers. Elections for a National As- sembly ought to have been held at once. But the new Government was only preoccupied with Paris; it was not really preoccupied with the great Powers. It had no mght to count much on Spain, which had become more free to choose a sovereign, nor on Italy, which profited by the war and took Rome, nor on Russia, which rebuilt Sebastopol and wiped out some articles of the Treaty of Paris; but could not a regular French Government expect some help from England and from Austria! M. de Chau- dordy believes that England and Austria made a mistake in not interfering in favor of France: ‘After having waited for some French success before pronoancing in our favor, Austria threw herself into the arms of victorious Prussia, and consecrated, in a fit of diplomatic inti- macy, the new German Empire. The Austro- Hungarian Empire alienated prematurely in favor of Prussia the greater part of its liberty of action. Hungary being always in a state of uneasiness on account of Russia, and the Aus- trian province having German aspirations, it is easy to understand that Berlin now dictates its will to Vienna and to Pesth.” M. de Chaudordy analyzes the state of Eu- rope, and shows that there is little foundation now for an alliance of the Latin races—an al- liance which has often been considered as a safeguard for Europe and for peace. It is, in his eyes, a mere dream; on the contrary, he considers that the old alliance between Prussia and Russia is come to an end, and that there are many reasons foran understanding between The Nation. ginning of the century, Prussia and Russia had always walked hand in hand; they gave reality to what was called the ** Holy an alliance which embodied profound analogies of ich represented a common defence of the old régime, Alliance ” ambition, of principles, of government; wh a common opposition to the more liberal Occi dental ideas. Under the Emperor Nicholas, the was on the side of Russia; prestige since his death it has been on the side of Prussia. But we have seen in our time anew phenomenon, a revival of the old-Russian party. What is an old-Rus sian? Is he essentially an enemy of Germany de velopment by the systematic exclusion of all imported men or ideas; an adept of Slavism as represented by the Moscow Gazette and by the school of Katxotf. in counteracting this Russian self-development, Not so much as a partisan of a Kussian self France has no interest since, not being a neighbor of Russia, she can not expect to play directly a part in ber inter nal affairs. Germany is Russia's neighbor, and there has been a constant importation of Ger mans into the Russian Empire. The whole mo dern literature of Russia shows how deep is the enmity between the old-Russian elements and the imported German element. Poland has long stood between France and Russia, but ‘‘ we are now,” says M. de Chau dordy, ‘‘unable to help the Poles, and our inter vention has, in fact, always aggravated theit situation. We ean, therefore, only advise them to come nearer the nation with which they have such a narrow community of origin.’ There seems, therefore, to be no hindrance now to intimate relations between France and Rus sia. ‘* All those who, in France, can exert an influence, great or small, on our ought to work for it; all parties, all foreign poliey opintor s, ought to concur in this, t& Witis our salvation abroad. The two great Slavic and French races are admirably fitted to understand each other, and the two nations will tind immense advantages in it.” Peter the Great, wt ! came to Paris, Napoleon at Tilsit, Napoleon II] en he in 1856, at the time of the Treaty of Pari had this alliance in view, The task of Russia in the future is in yr and, in order to accomplish it, she needs all having no interests in contradiction with her own. The United States have sometimes seemed to be such an ally, but the United States follow a policy of non-intervention, and d not meddle with the affairs of Europe sia has Slavie provinces and covets the ¢ provinces which are a part of Russia; n over, the Baltic, Denmark, the passages of the Sound can always bec a bone of cor n As for Austria, she is the natural enem tussia, and we now see the Balkan Pe torn by factions which are n Ww in but the Austrian faction and the Ru tion. The rivalry between England and Ru sia has been proverbial; M. de Chaudordy re vrets it, as better relations betw these tw countries could only be very advantageous t France. It might, perhaps, he thinks, be pos sible to reconcile them. Pt I n Eng land on the subject of Constantin and the Dardanelles is not what if was at time of Lord Palmersten. Since the opening of the Suez Canal, the Eastern objectiv f England has been transferred from ¢ stant to | Egypt. The ntent | vading India, sometimes speak of it. Their ambition bas an amy areer Asia, and they content themselves with ad vancing slowly, between Pers 1 Afghani- stan, towards the Persian Gulf. At the tim when Prin Alexander of a France and Russia. Since the wars of the be ! Bulgaria became very popular in and, and when it was th ight by s that a effort R ° be made in his favor against 1 ia, the Kritis Parhament showed very iriv that had 1 intention of picking a quarrel with Russia, and many articles appeared in the English press tending to prove that Egypt had become the only point in the East w England had ang vital interests to The survey ke rf 1} ait Isvd by M le Chaud iv is i t i Gover! nt of M. TI s had, s s foreig j \ } ‘ , \ ' - t self «iit t blangerous SVste i ‘ the head of th sta Is \ is no way {f repea he an ert tt CrOVe ment of Marshal MacMahon wa ondu { after tl 1 trait il met . M Chaudordy condemns in strong t s nial policy which was adopted by o) ors of Marshal MacMall " Avs, W 1 a country created 8 Ope ia ‘ field for her trade, as th: iv Was » buy exclusively the prod s of the metr . in our Citne Virtu f reatie 7 \“ i various Powers, these Powers can ade with our ¢ nies n the sa »f sas sel Ves ‘We do not s N Lal { if why wes! 1 s . ju \ w“ is i t x i Ww hall reap the eo wa embroiled us w ( 1 a Power w r later will hav " thy At Ww i ed tot ex hast \ ‘ i i ‘ wal t w tn ‘ ’ pr ect t is t . f “ tou ( i } ‘ i ‘ i - 3 rs and asatnits, Aa t seo4re { thie , \ Ferry (always ca Por . small press . rt ‘ was rin Vo oma H i \tr t war of 1S] ‘ ‘ Nail s Spear t f t i { t s sa ance of Prussia, Austria-} ra ’ LUssia is now replaced by a St ‘ ‘ IRSIA, Austria Ht wary itmiy t Ssia ‘s “nh j discontented rs Treaty of Be | and maintains an isolated and s 1 attitude | The misundersta x w Prussia and |} Russia has t eevers av past | two Vears more a e, and ves in a state I" tu the esent t ALANCE | has be a dange stead of being a pro fect i | A cument ideal to M Cha rdv's took has attracted much att 1. Itisa de spatch from M Saint-Valher, November 14, SvY, giving ana it of a versa i be tween t French Ambassador and 1 e bis- arckK, On his ret f Vienna, after tl nelusion of t alliance with Austria. It is easy to recog t language of the German Cha aiwavs old, f ible. sometimes very | nesque. The Prince did not conceal fr M je Saint-\ r that the policy of Russia with regard to Germany was modified, and it t i endship had given place to ealousy and distrust: and he explained how he Was going t ike of Austria an obstacle to the amt 1 of Russia. He always felt the I ssity of keeping Austria as a bulwark, he her after Sadowa, he would not muti- ate her rhe familiarity of the conversation, the eloquence of the speaker, the richness of his images, the depth of his views, make this locu it the most interesting part of M. de Chaudordy’s volume. There may have been official deniais of the authenticity of the docu- ment; but whoever will read will see that, with ime i ; . | the exception, perhaps, of a few words, it must M. de be genuine, Saint-Vailier is now dead,
Page 10
128
but I believe that he read this despatch to va- rious people of his acquaintance, on account of the clear view which it gave, in Prince Bis- marck’s own words, of the new state of things in Germany, and of the character of the alli- ance of the two empires—an alliance directed against all possible enemies of the German na- tionality. THE FINE ARTS AT THE PARIS EX- POSITION, I.—FRENCH SCULPTURE. Panis, July 28, 1889. In order to comprehend the extent of the exhibition of the fine arts at the Paris Exposi- tion of 1880, some statistics must be given. This exhibition constitutes the first of the nine great groups of the Exposition proper, and is itself divided into five classes: first, oil paint- ings; second, paintings of different kinds, and drawings; third, sculpture and medallions; fourth, architectural drawings and models; fifth, engravings and lithographs, The works of art exhibited by France, and by each foreign country, are classified under these five heads in the official catalogue, and, so far as possible, the classification is marked in the placing of the works in the galleries. As a matter of course, both because this is first of all a French exhibition, and because there is far greater production of the best work in the fine arts in Paris than in any other art centre, the French department is the most com- plete and the most extensive. There are 1,418 oil paintings alone; of other paintings and drawings 214, of sculptures 561, and of en- gravings 445—a total of 2,777 works. These are exhibited in more than thirty large gal- leries, without counting the hall called the Galerie Rapp, where on the ground floor a great part of the sculpture is exhibited, or the wide corridors outside the walis of the Palais des Beaux-Arts, along both sides of which sculpture is placed. Other groups of sculpture, again, are placed in the open air—on the prome- nades, and in the nooks of the gardens. To this total is to be added the magnificent ‘* Retrospective Exhibition,” comprising from 600 to 700 works executed by French artists from 1789 to 1889, the catalogue of which is not yet ready, and the special exhibitions of the Society of French Painters in Water Color and of the Pastel Society. These organizations have each a building of their own, and exhibit- ing, the ‘** Aquarellistes” 468 works and the ** Pastellistes” 153, bring up the total of the French part of the exhibition tosomething over 4,000 works. The exhibits of other countries are placed in similar galleries in the northern half of the vast Palais des Beaux-Arts, the southern half being occupied by France; and, though in the main remarkably complete and varied, and coming from more than twenty-five different nations, they just about equal in their totality the number exhibited by the French. For some reason or other which I was unable to learn, the Belgian pictures and statuary were not included in the catalogue, but a note re- ferred to the special catalogue of the Belgian exhibit, which I did not find it possible to pro- cure, I should say, however, that the number of works from Belgium must be about the same as that sent from the United States. We have 572 works in all classes, and are closely followed by Great Britain with 552. Then aor Owl, come Italy with Holland (Pays-Bas) with 288, Denmark 248, Sweden 228, Russia 205, Switzerland 168, Spain 179, Austria-Hungary 159, Norway 143, Germany (not a fully repre- sentative collection) 101; and Greece, Finland, The N ation *
Rumania, Servia, the South and Central Ame rican States, and the International Section, including artists from various countries not represented in the Exhibition, follow these with smaller numbers. In an exhibition of such enormous extent it is scarcely possible to see everything; but the galleries are admirably arranged, there is room enough and to spare in many of them, lighting and installation are excellent. Perhaps it is only a question of time and of physical en- durance to accomplish it. It is, however, easy to determine where to begin. We must study the French exhibition to see what progress, if any, has been made since 1878. We can then compare this with the Retrospective Exhibition; and, the position of the French as the leaders in the modern schools of art being determined, we shall find interest and instruction in com- paring with their work that which is being produced in other countries, We shall thus be best able to find the reasons of certain well de- fined ‘‘ movements” which are manifesting themselves in different places, and to judge of their value and influence on the art of the future. Nothing shows better the strength and the activity of the French in the arts at the present day than the work of their sculptors. Though sculpture is fostered by the State, and a con- siderable number of commissions are annually given by the national Government and the mu- nicipalities, it {s by no means patronized by indi- viduals as painting is. The official patronage, moreover, is mostly given to the sculptors of reputation, and we are almost at a loss to un- derstand how the younger and still struggling artists go on producing, year after year, the important works we find them constantly ex- hibiting. The expenses are great, even for the production of a single work, and after it is done and exhibited the artist usually has it left on his hands, or is only able to dispose of it at a price that barely covers his outlay, exclusive of living expenses, and gives him no remuneration for his time. The only explanation possible is, that devotion to his art keeps him up to his work until lasting recognition is assured, and in the meanwhile he must keep himself alive by whatever gaqgne-pain comes in his way. The production of pot-boilers, which many young painters find a means for tiding over the days of adversity, and the making of which so many unfortunately adopt as a permanent profession, may not be so readily carried on by the sculp- tor as by the painter. The ignorant or urcul- tivated buyer who relieves the dealer of his cheap and superficially painted pictures never cares for sculpture in any form, for it is not gaudy and showy enough for his taste. Even when it is bad, it is unattractive to him. The Italian sculptors of to-day, it is true, find a market for their pretentious figures, in which the imitation of stuffs in marble and the trompe- Vail of a gauzy veil enveloping weakly senti- mental heads of women are elements in an en- semble of mere prettiness ; but this manner of belittling a noble art finds no favor in France, and the sculptor who should practise it would scarcely find a reputable place to show off such work. In the face of popular indifference, however, and a necessarily limited Government patron- age, the sculptors of France show no falling off in productiveness or excellence. The men of achieved reputation are represented in this ex- hibition by many of the best works that have come from their hands in the past decade The administration has also inciuded in the competition for prizes such works as have been placed in the museums or in public places, and
cannot therefore be brought to the Champ
{Number 1256 de Mars. These works are entered in the cata logue, and the place is given where they are to be seen ; but they are not numbered, and do not, of course, form a part of the 561 pieces of sculpture mentioned above. Guillaume, Dela- planche, Mercié, Aimé Millet, Saint-Marceaux, Moreau, Lemaire, Frémiet, Allar, and Barrias are well-known names among those whose ex- hibition at the Champ de Mars is oniy a par tial showing of their ten years’ work. Chapu is well seen in a group of nine works, including a fine figure in marble, ‘‘ La Peinture,” ani Paul Dubois exhibits three busts, one of them of Paul Baudry, whose death since the last ex- hibition entitles his name to be emblazoned in the dome of the Cour @honneur, where the principal works of the Retrospective Exhitn tion are placed. Of younger men I find none that seem more promising than Antonin Carlés, who conies, like Mercié, from the South, and whose work began to attract attention in the salons in the commencement of the eighties. There is no more beautiful figure in the exhibition than the one by him called ‘‘ La Jeunesse,” a grace- fuland chaste young form, modelled with ad- mirable firmness and yet with the most delicate and nervous touch. ‘‘ Abel,” a marble figure of a young man dead, is again a work of much strength, but of reserved strength, and with no indication of that rugged brutality which Rodin and his followers have made the fashion in many quarters. Adrien Guaudez, the author of ‘‘Le Molsonneur,” that bent figure of the harvester with which he made such a brilliant début at the Salon of 1879, is another man of mark whose success is assured, and from whom much may’ be expected, to judge from his beau- tiful figure, ‘‘ Echo,” in the present exhibition, and his fine statue in plaster of Parmentier, To be noted also are Laoust, with excellent clothed figures of “ Lully,” violin in hand, and an effective rendering of an oft-treated sub ject, ‘* Pierrot”; Lombard, with a delightful womanly “* Diana”; Suchetet, with a charming recumbent female figure, ‘‘ Byblis”; and Etche- to, Enderlin, Berteaux, Boutellier, Albert-Le- feuvre, and Lefévre. Auguste Rodin, of whom so much has been said and written in the past two years, since the production of his famous group of the six ‘Bourgeois de Calais,” may be better judged at the special exhibition of his work at the gallery in the Rue de Séze, where there are some thirty of his works, than here, where there are but five. <A fragment of the group of the ‘* Bourgeois "—a single one of the figures—three busts, and a group, which compose his exhibi- tion, show his to be an unusual talent, and his work is strikingly vigorous and robust. One of the busts, a portrait of the sculptor Dalou, is notable for its fine, nervous construction and individuality of character. Another, that of M. Antonin Proust, the Commissioner of Fine Arts of the Exhibition, is equally fine in the quality of character seized and fixed, but the artist was less happy in his sitter than in the case of Dalou. The single figure of the ** Kour- geois” is exceedingly impressive, even when thus seen detached, after one has seen the group of six. However opinions as to the talent of Rodin may differ, it is quite certain that he is the most prominent figure in the ‘ new school ’--those who seek to throw away entire ly academic traditions—and, despite eccentri- cities, is a man of commanding power. Delaplanche, whose charming figure “ Mu- sic” is well known in America, and who was selected to do the figure of France distributing crowns to the nations come together at the Champ de Mars (a task in which he has ac. quitted himself well, it should be said in pass-
Page 11
iS c+ Aug. 15, 1889] ing, for the great winged figure, poised on one foot, with drapery flowing in graceful lines, looks imposing at the top of the huge central dome of the Exhibition buildings: and in the small model exhibited in the galleries it is seen to beif not an original, at least, an artistic and dignified coneeption)—Delaplanche has done nothing better than a figure in marble which was first exhibited at the Salon of last year. and yet voluptuous, slender of limb and fine- ealled ©: La Danse.” Sinewy and lithe, ly jointed, the head poised gracefully on the lovely neck, it is an exquisite expression of the dance. Dalou’s most remarkable work is a large bas-relief, representing the States-Gene ral at the sitting of June 25, 1780, a striking and dramatic composition of numerous figures. St.-Marceaux is seen at his best in a supple fe male figure, ‘* La Danse Arabe,” of less charm than the work of Delaplanche just mentioned, but of infinite elegance, and the woman of a handsome type. dozen works, is strongest in his powerful and terrible group of a gorilla carrying off a wo- man, for which he received the medal of honor in sculpture at the Salon of 1SS7. These are some of the most notable men and their works in this part of the French collec- tion, There are many others of which I should like to speak, interesting both on account of the merits of the work or the fame of the artists; but enough has been said to show that there is no falling off in the excellence of French sculpture, nor any diminution of ac- tivity in producing on the part of the artists. The great art of sculpture has reached its high- est development in modern times in France, and it may safely be asserted that it is better now than ever before. There is no Rude and no Houdon among the men of to-day, perhaps, Frémiet, among nearly a as we their contemporaries view them near by; but it is quite possible that among those named posterity will find a greater than either of these. For the American who hopes for a great future for our own art, there is nothing to wish for more ardently than that a knowledge of the work being done by the French sculp- tors to-day may be widely spread among us. Such a knowledge would add to the dignity, the honesty, and the beauty of our art. WILLIAM A. COFFIN. Correspondence. WASHINGTON AND PROTECTION, To THE Epitor oF THE NATION: Sir: When, in his spirited biography of Washington, recently contributed to the Ame ican Statesmen Series, Henry Cabot Lodge discusses the origin of the American protective system, he seems to present an excellent exam ple of reversion to type. All through the first volume and the early pages of the second we evidently are reading the conclusions of an his torian; but we turn a leaf, and, to our bewil derment, not to say disgust, we are confronted with the words of the campaign orator and According to Mr. Lodge, Washington was a protectionist Congressional special pleader. because his views of the national welfare were broad and far-seeing. After one or two pre liminary remarks ip this vein, our historian continues with the following candid state ments: ‘** Washington was brought up and had lived all his life under a system which came as near as possible to the ideal of the modern free trader. The —— ot Virginia were devoted almost entirely to a single interest, tobacco growing, that being the occupation in which The Nation. , | No legisla } vanced them money. Cheap labor, a single staple with wide fluctuations of value, a credit | system, entire dependence on foreigners, and | absolute free trade, according to the Manches- | ter theories, should bave produced an earthly | paradise” (vol ii, p. 114). | j | The intelligent mind stands app: d before such stuffasthis. Isit humor Is it satire Buteven satire must contain an element of sense, In the last lines quoted, Congressman Lodge has been ingenuous enough to associate the chief features of the colonial system with modern free trade as equally ruinous from an Fortunately he does economic point of view. not stop there. Virginia, in common with the rest of the Union, soon got the advantage of her sister States to the north passed her with giant strides in the race for wealth and popula tion. Hedid not live to see her become, asa result of her colonial system, a mere breeder of slaves for the plantations of the Gulf States.” Can it be possible that protective taxes did not make of Virginia ‘‘an earthly paradise,” de spite slave labor, a speculative business, and an uneconomical credit system / Verhaps after all Washington did not live * all his life under a system which came as near as possible to the ideal of the modern free-trader.” Perhaps not we should like to say undoubtedly not, but Mr Lodge is so sure; and whoever caught a pr tectionist Congressman ina misre} or an exaggeration { There ts a little moral to all this, viz, let us have our history and our party speeches sepa rately.— Yours respectfully, ELDRI Boston, July 10, 18S80. ENGLISH WOMAN-BURNING. To THE Eprror oF THE NATION: Str: Your correspondents who have recent ly discussed the question of witch-burning have not made it clear whether there is an authen- tic case of Woman-burning for any offen the penal records of England. While, as was pointed out by your correspondent in the issue of August 1, there were at least tw slackstone’s day that were still punist burning alive in cases where they were there is much doubt women, mitted by whether this extreme penalty was ever inflict ed. Blackstone deciares that there are ‘* very few instances (and those ac rby ligence) of any person's bei: ‘ door burned till previously deprived of sensation by strangling.” That these persons thus ‘ac dentally * burned alive were women is render ed highly improbable because of the existence of the same refined delicacy of feeling that forbade our forefathers publicly to expose and mangle the bodies of women culprits. This view is strengthened by the express laration f Chitty, in his * Crimi: who till lately were I 1al Law, th “women urned alive for high and led at the , stake before the commencement of the burn petit treason, were always stran ing.” It is, of course, possible that witchcraft, which was ranked with heresy have met ' with less mercy than treason or the killing of a husband. That under the English law wo- all the ‘‘ legislative artifices" which our early statesmen could invent. What was the result Mr. Lodge shall tell us in his own perspicuous language. The condition of things was, he says, ‘bad enough in his [Washington's] time, but he did not live to see Virginia, with her wasted and exhausted lands, stand still, while they could most profitably engage | nen might be conden 1 to be burt \ tive artifices had been employed to enable | for witeheraft aimits of little doubt IV. 1 *or wer 4 sftries wr by, them to diversify their industries or to estat 60. 47). but is there an authent nstat lish manufactures. They bought in the cheap est market every luxury and most of the ne- | Where this se Was literally en cessities of life British merchants supplied } t WW ti all their wants, carried their tobacco, and ad- | yoyye, « ttre. a SN SHAKESPEARE’S “MARRIAGE BOND To THe Eprrok or THe Nation Sir I have been asked by letter to explain the nature of Shak eare’s ‘“ mart ‘What was it ‘ and why was it \ It was a bend for good | Avior, so to speak William Shakespeare wasa minor, bet heal t a woman eight vears older than himself ( the 2Sthof November, 1582, the Bishop of Wor cester granted him a Hcense te marry wit! proclamation ( ti bans, instead f which last would have delaved the tuarria, Nn month. In return, the Bishop received Shak speare’s bond of indemnity for 44 Asa minor could not be surety for 1 xt and as the friends of ad res son to desire the marriage to be speedily brought about, dohn Richardson of Shottery, witness to Richard Hathaway's w {t vious year, and Fulke Sandells, executor of that will, alsoof S} tery, becar Shakespect sureties to that amount. John Shakespeare bad been bondsman for Richard Hathaway sixteen vears before, so there had bee tercourse between tl fariiies The bend, ete., may be found in the sev edition of Halliwell] ss "4 s t if seems to e there is as iis va ‘ dor in admitting and expla x its true natur CA} ne Lika y Ta Notes. Mr. PA x ‘ as is No > Clark Street, ! kiv nN. ¥ w have ready ey te mS \ ¢ in graphy a: Ge c- List of t >Trn s, (at logues, Refe nm sts, and sts of Author ties of A t anf AS d Su s a quart voiume pl ted 1 Wile inate pages, a i con taining ry les, arranged bv sut t under i divisions and 150 subdivis sw i ASS fi f conte 1 s lex At t tir rd will bring out his 1 1 graphy A List of Rooks | writt by ating to Re amin Franklin,’ an edition « xa! Comes unife in size witl | B ws octavo edition of Frank s Works N fewer than “) titles and references are SS ceaiiiliadi plea list of works wl iv or in part | written by Franklin numbering @), and bis pseudonyms a nting ¢t I re will t } hr log i classical, and genera ices, tion of the braries where the works nsulted rv Holt & Co. will issue next month a ok of Psychology: Senses and Intel leet. by James Mark Baldwin, Professor of Philosophy in Lake Forest University ‘Problems in American Society, by the Rev. Joseph Henry Crocker, will be published in a e H,. Ellis, Boston Frederick Warne A Co. announce few weeks by Geor that the fortheoming volume of ‘“* The Cavendish Li br iry sad Critic” being selections from his writings, with will be ‘ William Hazlitt, Essayist and a memoir, biographical and critical, by Alex ander Ireland Mr. Richard Le Gallienne, the author of a little volume of bookish poems, is preparing ‘ George Meredith, Novelist and Poet: A Series of Essays,’ which will be published in London
Page 12
1830 by Mr. Elkin Mathews, with a bibliography by Mr. John Lane, ‘With Friend and Book,’ and ‘ In the Study and the Fields,’ are the titles of two booklets by J. Rogers Rees, author of the ‘ Pleasures of a Bookworm,’ which will be published in very limited editions by Mr, Frank Murray, of Derby and Nottingham. The sixth volume of the ‘ Her Irving Shakspere’ (Scribner & Welford) adds ‘‘ Othel- lo,” ‘Antony and Cleopatra,” ‘ Coriolanus,” and ‘*‘ Lear” to the edition, with the usual in- troductions and notes. Mr. Marshall’s illness has occasioned some changes, in consequence of which Mr. Joseph Knight furnishes the stage histories of the plays, except ‘‘ Othello”; the Rev. H. C. Beeching is responsible for **Coriolanus,” and Mr. Arthur Symons and Mr. Verity act as substitutes in two other plays. Mr. Cscar Fay Adams is also a collabo- rator. The new volume maintains the same general character as its predecessors, and the near completion of this useful and cheap edi- tion is to be hailed with much satisfaction. M. J. J. Weiss is one of the French authors whose great repute among the best French critics it is not always easy to understand. In the case of M. Weiss the reason is perhaps that his chief labors have been as a journalist, and only those on the spot can fully appreciate the merits of journalism. He has published very few books, but the latest of them, ‘Le ThéAtre et les Moeurs’ (Paris: Calmann Lévy; New York: F. W. Christern), 1s brilliant enough to justify the affectionate eulogies of MM. Sarcey and Lemaitre. Perhaps the most interesting passage is the autobiographic pre- face, in which M. Weiss describes his wander- ings through France as a boy with his father’s regiment, in which he had been enrolled as an enfant de troupe—just as Victor Hugo had done in his youth, It is pleasant to see that a writer as learned and as acute as M. Weiss has a good word to say for Scribe, whom the younger literary critics treat with undeserved intolerance. The beautiful ‘ Almanach des Spectacles ' ap- pears for the fifteenth time, and the equally dainty ‘R¢pertoire de la Comédie-Frangaise’ for the fifth, each with a portrait of Mlle. Mul- ler, one etched by M. Lalauze and the other by M. Abot (Paris: Jouaust; New York: F. W. Christern), The more or less edifying controversy over ‘Christianity and Agnosticism,’ begun by Dr. Henry Wace at the Manchester Church Con- gress last year, and prolonged in the Nineteenth Century and Fortnightly Review by Prof, Hux- ley, the Bishop of Peterborough, Mr. Mallock, and Mrs. Humphry Ward, has been gathered into a volume of 329 duodecimo pages by D. Appleton & Co, Mr. Wm. C. Collar’s reputation among clas- sical teachers would insure attention to his ‘Practical Latin Composition,’ just published by Ginn & Co, It may be briefly described as a method of connecting immediately the read- ing of the Latin text with exercises upon it, using the text as the source at once of vocabu- lary and construction. Its very unlikeness to the disgusting and impotent older method of a generation ago (and later) is a certificate of merit. Old New York is the title of a monthly journal relating to the history and antiquities of this city, edited and published by W. W. Pasko at 19 Park Place. The first number is dated August. It is typographically tasteful, and illustrations are promised hereafter, The hither term of ‘‘ old” New York is defined as “a period within the recollection of middle- aged persons.” The table of contents reads as The Nation. follows: Notes on the History of Printing in New York; An Englishman’s View [the Rev. Isaac Fidler, 1831]; Index to Engravings in Valentine’s Manual [a serviceable performance by an unpractised hand]; Extracts from Early Newspapers; The Introduction of Methodism; Death of Dr. Alexander Anderson [extracts from the journals of ‘‘ the father of American wood-engraving ”]; The Claims of Nicholas Jones; Editor’s Notes. The stream seems like- ly to run full for an indefinite time. In the London Academy for July 20 there is a note from Mr. G. C. M. Smith, which gives a list of parallel passages in Fitzgerald’s version of the ‘Rubdiydt’ of Omar Khayydm and the new prose translation by Mr. McCarthy. Fitz- gerald dealt with his author as the potter deals with his clay, and one might imagine Omar’s ‘“‘half-obliterated tongue” protesting at his treatment of him. Nevertheless, Fitzgerald left a better Omar Khayydm than he found. The Academy also publishes a list of all pen- sions granted during the last year, ending June 20, and charged upon the Civil List, arnong which, as possessing a certain literary interest, we note the following : Mrs. W. G. Palgrave, £50; Mrs. R. A. Proctor, £100 ; the widow of Prof. F. Guthrie, £50 ; Miss Emily Faithfull, £50 ; and two or three other grants of £50 each to the widows or daughters of men eminent in some branch of learning or science. All these are not only in recognition of service done, but also on account of the recipient’s in- adequate means of support. Ascompared with somé other items in the Civil List, the ones that we have quoted seem very meagre and scanty. The seventeenth number of the ‘Complete Index to Littell’s Living Age’ (Philadelphia, No. 1185 Pine Street: Edward Roth) finishes the Geographical topics and begins on History, which is advanced into France. The divisions which now succeed the long one of Biography promise to be rapidly disposed of. We make a somewhat tardy mention of the completion of the thirteenth volume of ‘Meyer’s Konversations-Lexikon’ (Leipzig: Bibliogra- phisches Institut), and of the eighth volume of the compact ‘ Allgemeine Weltgeschichte’ is- sued by Grote in Berlin (New York : Wester- mann). The Cyclopedia is brought down to Rubinstein, and has its customary variety of excellent maps and plates in black-and-white and in color. In the ‘ Universal History’ is concluded the story of the Middle Ages, by Julius von Pflugk-Harttung, the parts i:mme- diately before us dealing with the Lombard, Frankish, and Anglo-Saxon kingdoms, the Byzantine emperors, the Papacy and Islam. Here again the illustrations continue to be of a high order, and conspicuous among them are fine facsimiles of medizval manuscripts. Sun and Shade for July (New York: The Pho- togravure Co.) has a well-chosen group of plates after paintings and from nature—a smoothed out but otherwise characteristic portrait of Barnum, the Eiffel Tower, and the Sphinx, be- ing most noticeable. In this last view, an American base-ball team using every coign of vantage onthe front of the Sphinx serves at least to give a scale to the monument. We have received from the University of Pennsylvania a sumptuous ‘ Handbook of In- formation’ concerning the School of Biology attached to that institution. The equipment and courses are fully set forth, and the exterior and interior of the school buildings illustrated by heliotype (alias Levytype) plates which speak for themselves. The school was organized five years ago, and has a library of its own of 2,000 volumes. We have on our table ‘ The Navajo Chant: A Navajo Ceremony,’ by Dr, Washington [Number 1259 Matthews, U. 8S. A.—a voluminous reprint from the fifth annual report of the Bureau of Ethnology, illustrated in colors and otherwise; and a ‘ Further Contribution to the Study of Consumption among the Indians,’ by the same excellent and entertaining writer. Dr. Mat- thews is confirmed in his view that the Indians most in contact with civilization perish most largely from consumption, for causes some of which are certainly preventable. A very interesting subject is attacked in Prof. A. S. Packard’s memoir on the *‘ Cave Fauna of North America,’ with remarks on the anatomy of the brain and origin of the blind species, and with numerous plates, print- ed in vol. iv of the Memoirs of the National Academy of Sciences. A map of the Mam- moth Cave is given. —Neany twenty years of the life of Wash- ington are comprised in the second volume of his Writings edited by Mr. Worthington C. Ford. It opens amid the preparations for the capture of Fort Duquesne, in 1758, and ends with the Commander-in-Chief’s address to the New York Provincial Congress on his way to Boston, June 26, 1775. In this interval he mar- ries the widow Custis, and furnishes their home with liberal orders from London, where his clothes are also ‘t‘ made by one Charles Law- rence, in old Fish Street,” and much of his wife’s attire is procured. There, too, he sends for a new stylish chariot, on which he makes bold to paint the Washington arms. He did not appear to be ashamed of this dependence on a foreign country, not being yet a full- fledged American protectionist and Harrison Republican; but he joined heartily, in 1760, in urging non-importation as a check to British oppression of the colonies. ‘*T have always thought,” he wrote to George Mason, ‘‘ that by virtue of thesame power. . which assumes the right of taxation, they may attempt to restrain our manutactories, espe- cially those of a public nature, the same equity prevailing in the one case as the other; it being no greater hardship to forbid my manufactur- ing than it is to order me to buy goods of them loaded with duties, for the express purpose of raising a revenue” (p. 260). A Life of Mason, by the way, Mr. Ford an- nounces on p. 263 as in preparation by a de- scendant, Miss Kate Mason Rowland of Balti- more. —There are many glimpses of Washington the planter in letters and diaries. On April, 1760, the plantation ‘* Doctor Laurie came here, I may add, drunk.” The negroes that year had the smallpox. On July 2, 1766, Washington sold to the West Indies the boy Tom, wh9 was rogue and runaway combined, and whom the captain was enjoined to handcuff till the ves- sel got to sea. Tom's equivalent was to be a hogshead of molasses and another of rum, a barrel of limes, a pot of tamarinds, and two of sweetmeats. In 1770, Washington ‘* went over to Col. Thomas Moore’s sale, and purchased two negroes, to wit, Frank and James.” In 1775, he sent some of his imported indented servants to the Ohio with his land-agent, whom he sup- plied with minute descriptions of each one in case they should run away and it should be ne- cessary to ‘‘ advertize a good reward ” for them. On April 23, he had to advertise $40 reward for a Bristol joiner and a Scotch brickmaker, who thus gave him the slip ‘ton the 19th in- stant at night,” ‘in a small yawl.” On another side Washington appears as guardian of the un- studious Jack Custis, and as the benefactor of William Ramsay’s son, whom he offered to educate at Princeton. —We have received from Macmillan & Co, a small 12mo of 272 pages, being a translation of
Page 13
and Protagoras. It is by J. Wright, M.A., Trinity College, Cambridge. There is no pre- face or prefatory note of any kind. The title- page claims that it is a ‘* new and literal trans- lation chiefly from the text of Bekker.” Each dialogue is preceded by a rather full and very well executed summary of its contents, Other- wise, there is no note or comment whatever. If Mr. Wright and most of the other authors of literal translations were asked to define exactly what they mean by the word “ literal,” they would, we think, find it somewhat diffi cult to answer. Mr. Wright’s translation is characterized by a remarkable, not to say sur- prising, fidelity to the Greek text. At the same time the English is so idiomatic, so easy and flowing, that a person who did not was a translation might often read half pages without suspecting thefact. This is par- ticularly the case where the interlocutor speaks in the manner of disquisition rather than dia- logue, as for example, in the famous discourse on love which Socrates ‘‘ preaches” in the *Phedrus.’ Where the dialogue assumes a really conversational form, with a mure equal distribution of the amount of talk between the interlocutors, Mr. Wright seems a little “literal” and, it appears to us, a little happy. However, even in this case, we think the translation one of unusual merit. In mechanical make-up the book is a gem, know it a-dozen “ce less less its —In 1881 Prof. G. A. Wentworth of Phillips- Exeter Academy published his ‘ Elements of Algebra,’ a work very extensively used since that time in our academies and high schools, The next year he published his much larger ‘Complete Algebra,’ not, as the title might im- ply, an entirely different work from the ‘ Ele- ments,’ and really to be called a *‘ Completed Algebra.’ The new ‘College Algebra’ (Bos- ton: Ginn & Co.) is constructed on a dif- ferent plan. Although it begins at the be- ginning in its development of the science, yet it practically assumes, on the part of the student, a previous acquaintance with al- gebra as far as quadratic equations, What the work contains up to this point is de- signed rather for the purpose of rendering it complete in itself, and to enable the student, by a brief review, to refresh his recollection of his former studies, than to be used by those who have never studied the subject at all. This course is very proper in a work on algebra de- signed especially for college use, because no student can enter college at all without having previously studied algebra to that extent. From quadratic equations on the treatment is very full, We have no space for detailed criticism, and can only mention one or two peculiarities of the work as distinguishing it from the author’s previous treatises and from other works. The number of examples and problems for solution, although quite sufficient, is not so superabundant as in most of his text-books, There is throughout the work an evident attempt at novelty, an endeavor to say old things in a new way, which we do not think is in all cases an improvement. Among matters not usually treated in algebra we may mention a chapter on the ‘Graphical Representation of Func- tions,” a subject which the student usually first meets with in Analytic Geometry, and a chap- ter on Determinants. The latter, which is very good, is, however, not by Prof. Wentworth himself, but by Prof. Sawin of Harvard Uni- versity. On the whole, the book is a very good one, but we do not think it will greatly add to the reputation which Prof, Wentworth has al- ready acquired. —Those who wish to obtain some knowledge
The Nation. of Old High German at a minimum expendi ture of time and money will find their reckon ing in Wright's ‘ Primer of Old High German (Oxford ; Clarendon Press; New York: Mac millan). In this little volume of 170 pages the full and clear outline of the phonology and grammatical forms of the lan- and in *and a glossary.
editor gives a guage, some extracts in verse, from Tatian to the ‘ Muspilli, The grammar is based, of course, upon Braune, and is therefore trustworthy. We notice that at page 56 the pronoun iz (modern neuter es) is ’ it.” » there of modern German define es in es gicbt as prose detined as Would a grammarian ‘there’! The distinction (p. 85) between twesan and werdan in forming the passive is not put very scientifically. Vowel length is marked throughout, an excellent feature in a book of the sort. We have to find fault with the glos sary. It is altogether too meagre for the needs of a beginner, and is notaccurate. Thus aya leizi is put down as feminine. How will this enable the pupil to read in managemo ayaleize in the first line of Otfried, where the adjective be Braune’s glossary gives a feminine in -7, shows piainly that the noun cannot femi- nine } in -i. The editor would have follow gi- compounds and a neuter done better to enter all pounded form. Braune’s example and the His present arrangement is under uncom exasperating. And in general the vocabulary should be at least twice as large, with fuller definitions and copious references to both text and grammar, An editor can searcely help the beginner too much in this direction. We hope to welcome the primer ina second edition, with the glossary recast as we have indicated. gi whom we know —M. Abbé only the name, has just published at Amiens a Fourriére, of little book called ‘ Les Emprunts d’Homére au Livre de Judith,’ acquaintance with which have made only in a brief notice, with extracts, we in the Rerue Critique. Some of the Abbé’s opinions are amusing enough. Of Homer he says: ‘*‘The authors comprised under this name were of Jewish origin.” ‘ There were Jews inthe Troad, especially in the country about Mount Ida, the inhabitants of which were called Idwans, a name almost identical with that of Judwans, or Jews.” ‘* When Homer says that an object bears two names, one in the language of the gods, the other in that of Hebrew, by the compares the E men, he means by the first tongue other, Greek. If one with the Hebrew, bet ween them.” Hebrew at from lic dialect , striking resemblances are found One « f the ? mblance ** Looked the religious point of view, the work of Homer if these is the rese vau to the .Eolic digan
is a battering-ram Biblical monothe- against ism, against the religion of the Hebrews.” The author reserves all his rights of translatiot and reproduction. ‘* Nothing is fair or good 1 Foner mmerson
alone,” as says, ard Mr. Ignatius Donnelly may never know what argument his creed to the Abbe'’s book has lent. he national museum of E qui t Bulak contains a very in ng col- lection of plants which have been found in the catacombs and sepulchral monuments of the Dr. Schweinfurth the was f this ancient flora, which, according to e Scientifique, contains no example of a plant that does not grow to-day in the Nile valley. Nor does the most minute examination show the least difference between the vegeta tion which flourished fifty centuries ago and that of the present time. In « ) t color of the flowers can be clearly distin- guished, as, for instance, the purple larkspur, the red poppy, the reddish-brown saffron, and cases the the
the blue lotus “The leaves of tl Wate! melon contain grains of ! peerte visible in the microseope All t “ found in great numbers in the burial place f the fifteenth dynasty, Sooo , al tomb of the same time sor ars of ba In later monuments were discovered miustar flax, cucumbers, lentils, pine-cones, juniper Ties, dates, holl vho« ks, brvsanti olives, onions, rapes. Around and upon the breasts of the I f ‘ RB. Cc. were garlands of celer “ay ‘ lotus-flowers. In regard to ¢t \ i ‘ mens of crain discovers t may | that no attempt to make row succeeded, the plants having bee ‘ great heat at the time of the emba ! and burial, which, while it preserved stroyed their germinating power \ tres in which muminy wheat is said ¢ ive t raised are due simply to the fraudulent mux of modern with the ancient grains The tenth number of the G while it contains perhaps thing w anny ne need feel that | SIfLVeLY ‘ fore eating or sleeping, is st \ . ing, or at least will be thought so byt ‘ ‘ ries of the cult which it: represents r archives at Weimar hav to 5 l up the usual batch of hitherto unpublist ters, the best of those given this vear some letters written by Goet! ‘ “ LSOs-) to their son Au t,w Mad sate tered the University hes sives $ a pleasant glimpse of ¢ poet S CATMICITY of paterfamilias, promising mot y selling temperance, and making s stions upon the art of living wisely in one’s y In view of his own early disgust w a life, such a passage as this is suggestiy I also approve V taking few I study, everything depends upon one’s iste g. step by st tha w } 3 to acquire As soon as ¢t s fered grows ver s 1 be s stolid or sgusted i s sil P ed to re t the w S t } er outburst of J 8 s y his torv the a wif v ~“ s i i n the f . \ \f tt ¥ y < ; ‘ i «al * e tra t tl . s t spirit 1s s TOV ‘ “ i “ bv this “7s 1 tha sa ry ist ai th i learn how t " n huma earthiv fas what ha st, a what has remained as a living for s as str tive as if is delig a! t young in whose f 3 t ist iv i the Past in s la i prepares for fe ( the letters { t re t ba i\ th it affect it i, on the writte Ss t nes in es it lern Ame! rexample, after bidding is ease With respect to 1 ney, assuring him that his father will not be close if he y spends his allowance properly, and pr sing to send an occasional remittance on her own a unt, she adds: *‘ But I hs oniv won 75 guiden at the lottery; with these I shall ance, and this time I shall surely ntributed the most valuable Classiker und Romantiker,” It is really an inquiry into the origin of that far-famed antithesis. It is well known that there was an excellent under- standing at first between Goethe and the Romanticists. The members of the “ school” — Of the essays « entitled ‘ by Jacob Minor. is one
Page 14
182 The Nation. admired him and sang his praises, and it was not until after 1805 that any breach became apparent. Minor attempts to trace the influ- ence of the Romanticists upon Goethe’s work, maintaining among other things that the First Part of ‘‘ Faust” was strongly affected by the new movement, and really took on the form of a “romantic” drama in Tieck’s manner. Finally, we observe that the Jahrbuch’s eighty pages of bibliography testify abundantly to the world’s—more especially Germany’s—un- wearied activity in the production of Goethe literature. RECENT EDUCATIONAL LITERATURE. The First Three Years of Childhood. By Bernard Perez. Edited and translated by Alice M. Christie. With an introduction by James Sully, M.A. Syracuse: C. W. Bar- deen. Lectures on Pedagogy, Theoretical and Prac- tical. By Gabriel Compayré. ‘Translated, with an introduction, notes, and an appen- dix by W. H. Payne, A.M. Boston: D. C. Heath & Co. Occasional Addresses on Educational Sub- jects, By S. 8S. Laurie, A.M., LL.D., Pro- fessor of the Institutes and History of Edu- cation in the University of Edinburgh. Cam- bridge, Eng.: University Press; New York: Macmillan. Notes on the Early Training of Children. By Mrs. Frank Malleson. Third edition. Boston : D, C. Heath & Co, Sonnenschein’s Cyclopedia of Education. A Handbook of Reference on all Subjects counected with Education (its History, Theory, and Practice). Edited by Alfred Ewen Fletcher. Syracuse: C. W. Bardeen. Two classes of books mark the progress of education: first, original contributions to pedagogy and the kindred sciences, such as psychology and ethics; second, books that. recast old pedagogical truth and attempt to bring the maxims of common sense into the working consciousness of teachers. The work by M. Perez that heads our Hst may fairly claim a place in the former of these classes, The book is already too well known to require extended comment ; but the appearance of an authorized American edition of the English translation is a sign of the interest of our teachers in the scfentific study of babyhsod. The author has not, like Darwin, written a biographical sketch of a single infant ; but he has observed and compared the activities of many children, tracing the development of perception, the sentiments, will, memory, ima- gination, and the other mental activities in the early years of childhood. No one observer can see all there is in child nature, but M. Perez has seen a great deal that is of psycholo- gical interest ; and, ‘‘not blushing to descend to petty details,” he has recorded his observa- tions with scientific thoroughness. Moreover, he has studied his material carefully, and pre- sented the results of his study in the lucid French style that lends itself to intelligible translation. The translator, too, deserves praise for reproducing in English the clearness and simplicity of the original. It is a pedagog- ical commonplace that the art of education is a practical application of the science of psycho- logy, and psychogenesis is now one of the most important chapters in psychology. Thoughtful teachers, then, do well to study works like this and Prof. Preyer’s ‘ Die Seele des Kindes,’ for they form the best text-books ia infant psychology. ‘ Lectures on Pedagogy’ is another good translation of the work of a well-known French writer. These lectures, originally de- livered by M. Compayré at the normal schools of Fontenay-aux-Roses and Saint-Cloud, give a good résumé of the theory and practice of The book is enriched by judicious eminent writers. It is well The part devoted to practical pedagogy is especially The author is no advocate of that pe- dantry of method that would have every lesson taught by scholastic formule; nor does he deem it necessary to stuff the memory of teachers with the ‘ pedagogic nonsense” of those writers who divide instruction into many education. selections from written, scholarly, and interesting. sound. forms, as the achromatic form, the erotomatie, catechetic, analytic, synthetic, paralogic, and the like; and then subdivide into a score of Modern education is said to ap proach nature. ‘ Alas!” he exclaims, ‘‘ we are far from nature with these distillers of peda- gogic quintessence, who split hairs, who dis- tinguish and analyze the siraplest things, and invent several barbarous terms to designate identical operations.” One criticism may be made upon this book. While the author bases the science of education upon psychology, his sections upon Will, At- tention, Memory, Habit, and the like lack the emphasis and suggestivenes that modern phy- siological and experimental psychology has im- parted to these subjects. The author, however, has handled the facts of introspective psy- chology unusually well, and presented their pedagogical aspects in a suggestive manner. Prof. Payne’s translation of Compayré’s ‘ His- toire de la Pédagogie’ is the best history of pedagogy in English; and he has again ren- dered valuable service to education by this translation of the ‘Cours de Pédagogie, théo- rique et pratique.’ The book just noticed and Prof. Laurie's ‘Occasional Addresses’ are none the less valua- ble for belonging to the second class of books mentioned above. Most pedagogical truths are commonplace; but platitudes usually con- tain the genuine ore of wisdom. They are like old worn coin, not valuable because old and worn, but old and worn because valuable. One who can recoin them, stamp them with his own individuality, and make thetr original value recognized at the world’s counters, does a service well-nigh equal to that of one who makes an original contribution to science. This is, in great part, the work of Prof. Laurie in these addresses, Much of the book consists of what if said in a different way would be commonplace. But the author has caught an inspiration from his philosophical studies, and nothing to him is common. Few writers put so much life Into the discussion of such subjects as ‘The Organization of the Curriculum of Secondary Schools,” ‘‘ Free Schooling,” '' Ex- aminations,” and the like. The essay upon ** The Respective Functions in Education of Primary, Secondary, and Uni- versity Schools” is one of the best. According to Professor Laurie, the idea that should domi- nate instruction in all these gradesis nutrition. Butin the secondary schools there must also be the special aim of discipline. The youth are in the turbulent period of adolescence. ‘' The chief lesson to be taught now is the lesson of law and duty, and of personal effort.” The aim of the university likewise is nutrition— “the nutrition of ideas.” The discipline, how- ever, should be self-discipline, which is possible only through the utmost freedom. The follow- ing passage will indicate the author’s radical position: processes. ‘* The essence of university life is freedom for the student and freedom for the professor. [Number 1259 It is simply because the university has become a certifying and graduating body that even the calling of class-rolls is justifiable. Even as a graduating body | doubt, after all, if it is justi- fled in calling them. The professor offers to show the student the way to knowledge, and to teach him how to use the instruments of know- ledge, whether they be books or microscopes; and there his function ends. If any parent is unwilling to send bis son to the free life of a university, let bim keep him at home and call in a trained nurse or a paternal tutor.” In Prof. Laurie's opinion, the curricula of universities should be entirely elective. have no place in the higher academic halls. They should remain in the secondary schools until they receive the moral and intellectual discipline that fits them for the ideal atmos- phere of the university. Mrs. Malleson’s ‘ Notes’ are the straight- forward utterances of common sense in regard to the training of children. The critical reader may pronounce them commonplace, but there are plenty of mothers who will find the advice in this little book helpful. Such books are al- ways useful if they are read by those for whom they are written. The last book on our list isa valuable addi- tion to educational literature. Among the con- tributors are such prominent educators as Principal Donaldson, Oscar Browning, Sir Philip Magnus, Arthur Sidgwick, and James Suly. A wide range of subjects is treated, including the various branches of study, school virtues, methods of teaching, main points in the history of education, together with bio- graphical sketches of prominent educators and explanation of pedagogical technicalities, ‘‘ It has been the aim of the contributors,” says the editor, ‘‘to give a telescopic rather than a microscopic view of the educational facts and questions discussed, and to bring their purely pedagogical features into clear outline.” Sub- jects of special importance, however—such as Schools of Antiquity, The Reformation, Uni- versities, Technical Education, School Law, and the more common branches of study—are treated at considerable length. These longer articles are very valuabie, and the blographical and miscellaneous sketches are convenient. The emphasis is placed upon education in England; but, on the whole, the subjects have been judi- ciously chosen and ably discussed. Some omissions, however, are to be regretted. For example, no mention is made of the Church Fathers. St. Jerome at least should be noticed on account of his letters on the educa- tion of girls. And among scholastic teachers, while Alcuin, Abelard, and Roger Bacon are noticed, there are no sketches of Capella, whose ‘Satyricon’ was the great text-book for a thousand years, nor of Peter Lombard and his famous ‘ Sentences,’ nor of Thomas Aquinas, whose philosophy has dominated the higher Catholic education for the last 600 years Among women eminent in education, Jacque- line Pascal and Madame de Maintenon are noticed; but Madame Necker and Madame Guizot are slighted. The view of American education presented is astigmatic rather than ‘‘ telescopic.” No ade- quate account of our public schools is given, and little attention is devoted to higher educa- tlon in this country. There is some account of Harvard and the University of Virginia. The post-graduate work at Johns Hopkins, Yale, and other prominent universities is barely men- tioned; but we learn that the Illinois Wesleyan University has established non-resident and post-graduate courses of study. Isabella Gra- ham, Ezra Cornell, Peter Cooper, and James Garfield (sic) are the subjects of separate bio- graphical sketches; but Benjamin Franklin, Alex. Dallas Bache, and Thomas Jefferson are Bous
Page 15
Aug. 15, 1889] not mentioned. American literature in the bibliography has not been entirely accurate. ‘tH. R. Adams” stands for H. B. Adams (p. 559), and Charles Francis Adams would hardly recognize # B K polemic on the Greek question by its new title, ** A College Fetch” (p. 552). When the editor turned his telescope towards the past, the images of Rome and Judea must have fallen on his mental blind-spot ; for, while the long article devoted to ‘* Schools of Anti- quity” gives an interesting account of educa- tion in Assyria, Babylonia, China, Egypt, India, and Persia, there is no mention, except incidentally, of Greek, Roman, and Hebrew schools. This omission is in part supplied by separate articles devoted to Athenian and Lace- dwmonian education, But one looks in vain for sketches of such men as Pythagoras, whose fa- mous school at Crotona certainly mention, and Quintilian, whose ‘ Institutes’ presents in detail the Roman ideal of an ora- tor’s education from the cradle to the forum, and Plutarch, the first, so far as is known, to write a special treatise ‘‘On the Training of Children.” In short, the account of Greek edu- cation is incomplete, and both the practical education of the Romans and the domestic and religious education of the Israelites are entirely neglected, The book, for the most part, is written in plain English, but the author of the article on “ Pedantry ” (p. 258) begins with slovenly rhe- toric, as follows: ‘* Pedantry is an awkward ostentation of needless learning, or an obsti- nate addiction to the forms of some private life, and not regarding general things enough,” The typography is generally good; but the book is cheaply bound, and the insertion of ad vertisements between the pages of the text is unpardonable. Teachers will be grateful, how- ever, for so good a cyclopwdia of pedagogical information in any form, and the value of the book is enhanced by an excellent bibliography of thirty-four octavo pages. - Even the proof-reading of his deserves MADAME DE STAEL—I Madame de Staél; her Friends and her Influence in Politicsand Literature. By Lady Blenner- hasset. 3 vols. Svo. London: Chapman & Hall; Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott Co. 1889. SAINTE- BEUVE, wuo had a weakness for Madame de Staél, says that ‘tthe best good fortune for an immortal memory is to have, long after death, two or three of those revivals and magnificent awakenings which astonish new generations, and convince them that a great man lies dead there, still powerful in his shade and silence.” Such revivals are brought about by the posthumous publication, after the lapse of many years, of autobiographic me- moirs ; of correspondence, published as it was written, unchanged, simply in order of dates, which can show the writer as he really was— not dressed up for the public ; and more rarely by a well-written biography, especially if it be based on unknown or little known materials. Mme. de Staél has had none of this good for- tune. Unluckily for her, and for us, too, her son died childless; her only daughter married a Duce de Broglie, and one of her granddaughters a Comte d’Haussonville; and the proprieties of | these noble families might suffer by allowing | the public to see Mme. de Staél too closely. Not even the correspondence with Mme. Réca- mier has been printed, though it was read by Sainte-Beuve. Much has been written about her, but seventy-two years have elapsed since her death, and there has been no adequate bi- ography of her, The book before us is an ef- | j The fort to though Nation. this The of supply want anthoress, the Irish German by birth (born Countess von Leyder wife an Baronet, is a and the book was originally written in Ger- man, Thetransiation acknowledges some omis- sions which are generally unimportant, and it and that the three To those who are but superfi isa pity there are not still more, book has not been reduced in size fror volumes to one. cially acquainted with those times, the history of the French Revolution, the account of Neck 1238 of the Bishop d’Autun upon the s t church property, she Savs It is ex cellent, it is admirable, in short, there are tw pages in it which are worthy of M. Necker Afterwards she savs that wisdom isa very rare ¢ quality, and she knows of no one who possesses it ina superiative degree except her father It was this edmiration which led ber into some | of her political errors Mile. Necker’s marriage was beset with great | difticulties. B er’s tinancial and political schemes, and the m Mma, de Staé! met or knew, will be instructive and interest- biographies of every one who ing; but there are probably few who are really interested in Mme. de Staél, memoirs and correspondence enough to have who have not read previously made acquaintance with all these Full as it is, the book does not take in everything even of what is printed; people. and al though the authoress has consulted unpublish- ed letters of her heroine in the library of Up sala and in private hands, she has evidently not had access to the family archives at Cop pet. Some points in Mme. de Staél’s life are even thus left misty, and such is the wealth of extrinsic detail that it is only by picking and choosing and putting together detached bits of the book that we arrive at any idea of Mme de Staél herself. Born in 1766, when her father was still only a Swiss banker in Paris, Anne Louise Germaine Necker was brought up among the of the day salon. Her education iterary celebrities who frequented her mother's was directed by her mother, who was herself almost a learn ed woman, but strict and severe, and a great in vinced that everything could be learned, and that study the chief Had ber daughter not possessed originality and a mind of quick intelligence whic believer method and rule. She was eon was thing in education, her own, as Well as a remarkably } h replaced perseverance and application, she would have broken down under the system. As it was, her health gave way, and the great Tronchin prescribed a coun- try life, continuous exercise, and with the complete cessation of all mental ex fresh air, ertion. Mme. Necker could not accustom herself to this, and lost her interest in her | daughter when she found she could no longer | make her as she wished. Years after, when some one was praising Mme. de Staéi’s ex- traordinary gifts, Mme. Necker characteris- tically replied: ‘‘ They are absolutely nothing to what I intended them to be.” Her surroundings made her as a child pre cocious, priggish, and pedantic, ar developed her love for conversation earliest vears she wrote, first, then *h, ** Mont- morency,” written when she was about in the fashion verses, essays, and plays—one of whi character thirteen, is said to have been cl id she loved to read it aloud neur Morris says, ver, long afterwards; but, as Gouver ** She writes much better tl she reads.”’ Before she tift she had notated ‘ L'Esprit des Lois, had Was een tten a trea tise on the Edict of Nantes, when the Abbé 1 fi r by proposing to incorpo- at n of his ‘* Histoire des nd tthe same time she review ed her father’s ‘Compte Rendu,’ pretending that it was done anonymously, although he recogn i the style. All her life Mme and of bein fe Stacl had need of loving oved, At first she spent this feeling . Whom she always admired and 730, says: “I hat in my life 1 never saw such exube- vanity as that of Mme. upon the bject of her father. Speaking of the opinion writing In 1 Morris, de Staél th she and her parents prefers a French alliance ; but, although the sons of great noble houses did not scruple to marry the daughters of financiers, Necker was a Protes ant, and it was not till 1788, on the ev { the Revolution, that the ban of the law was 1 +) moved from Protestants, their vil rights 1 stored, and their children legitimived, forint eve of the law thev were all bastards Wi she was seventeen, she might have marricd William Pitt, then twenty-four years old whom she had met at court at Fontainebleau The proposal was made by Pitt after his return to England, and was warmly supported by t! Neckers, But their daughter refused, as s could not tear herself away for life from Pa: which to her was equivalent to France Her mother, who was then dying, scareely f aN ( her. It was only after his rejection, if at a that Pitt said he *“‘ was already wedded ¢ ‘ country The successful wooer was ’ Eric Magnus von Stacl- Holstein, Secretary ¢ the Swedish Embassy, who was already a fa vorite in French society Supported by the Comtesse de Bouttlers, he bad for five vears sought the lady's hand; but Necker's litions in Consideration of his positic and his large fortune, were very hard They were “iL) A life appointment of Staél to the kre h Emioassy ) a pension of 2.000 franes, should unforeseen events deprive bim of his post: ) the title of Count——espectally te t Viate any confusion between Baroness de Sta and another lady of the same name who bore a loubtful reputation; (4) a sol 1 promise on Staél’s part only to take his wife to Sweden for a short time, and then only with their consent investiture of the Order of the Polar Star tor the nhassador, ©) an explicit declara tion from Marie Antoinette tn favor of this narriage.” Such conditions show Necker’s immense con- ceit with himself and his belief in his great im- rtance. King Gustavus, however, did not inclined to accept them, and it was only n the personal request of Marie Antoinette, and after the island of St. Bartholomew had been ceded by Sweden to France, that he agreed it} of Count and to everything except the title the life appointment. He named Staél Ambas sador for six years, and promised him an addi tional term of six years) Two other suitors had meanwhile appeared—Count Axel Fersen, who had made the proposal only to please his and readily gave way to his friend; ince George Augustus of Mecklenburg, a brother of t he reigning Duke, who deseribed himself as a posthumous son with many debts, but used as an argument that Mlle. Necker wi jus become related by marriage to the King of England. Finally the marriage con tract was witnessed by the King and Queen of France, and the marriage itself was celebrated in the chapel of the Swedish Embassy at Paris in January, 17%, about three months before the bride had attained her twentieth year. In Paris, Baron de Staél was overshadowed by his brilliant wife; but his recently published letters and despatches prove that he was by no means the nonentity which her friends account- ed him, but he was unable to express his feelings in that gushing manner which seemed so neces- sary to her nature. She continued to live un- He was sincerely fond of his wife,
Page 16
1384 eee der the same roof with him, though, while her parents were in Paris, the most of her evenings were spent with them, and her real salon was at their house. After some time she became indifferent to her husband, In the well-known chapter in ‘De lAllemagne,’ on love in marriage, she hints that he had dis- played too little sentiment—or sentimentality, perhaps—in married life; and in ‘ Corinne,’ hints that he could not retain her esteem because he possessed so little intellectual distinction. Bollmann heard her say one day: ‘With a man who is only clever I assert my- self, and I do the same with a man who is only learned; but a man who is both makes me feel that [am only a woman.” De Staél felt keen- ly this desertion, and, only three years after his marriage, when to a great extent given up to mysticism, he wrote to a friend: ‘*] have —“ many bitter hours since your departure. If I knew how to bear my cross, my fate would be more endurable; but the old Adam prevails. 1 have deserved my present sufferings. I am punished in my in- nermost feelings, but I still dare to think that, notwithstanding all my faults, my heart has remained steadfast. Pray for my wife. May she never suffer from the torment I endure.” entirely she also The marital relation, however, continued, and it was not until 1798, when Mme. de Staél, by her meddling in French politics, and by the disfavor in which she was held by the Directory, threatened to wreck the Ambassa- dor’s career for a third time, that a formal separation—de facto, if not de jure—took place, Staél was at that time considerably in debt, partly through the great expenses neces- sitated by his position, partly through large amounts spent to carry out the orders of his sovereign, and partly from his wife's extrava- gance, which had needed even the Queen’s warning. Some small debts were paid by Necker, who otherwise refused to have any- thing further to do with his son-in-law. Napo- leon, we know, had his own reasons for dislik- ing Mme. de Staél, and yet it is difficult not to agree with him in a letter written to his brother Joseph from Aosta, March 19, 1800: ‘*M. de Staél is in the greatest misery, and his wife gives dinners and balls. If you must continue to visit this woman, would it not be as well to persuade her to bestow a thousand or two thousand francs a month on her husband ? What is to happen next if decent people allow not morals only to be trampled under foot, but duties more sacred than those that bind chil- dren to their parents? Supposing Mme, de Staél were to be judged as if she were a man, and as one who had inherited Necker’s fortune, enjoying all the advantages of a distinguished position, and yet leaving his wife in a state of misery , while he was living in luxury—I ask if such a man would be received in society ?” In 1802, finding that her husband’s health had entirely broken down, and wiiling at last to show him the kindness which she was so ready to bestow on others, she wrote to him in Sweden that she would condone the past and would return to him. They started together for Paris, but he died suddenly when only fif- teen miles from Coppet. It is to be supposed that the poor Baron had tacitly condoned the faults of his wife. She was always a believer in friendship, especial- ly with the male sex. Wherever she was, her house was full of men—either as protégés in the paths of literature, politics, and virtue, as recipients of her bounty, as friends, as ad- mirers, or as something more, Her first great passion was for Narbonne, who was credited with being ason of LouisXV, Their intimacy had lasted during their residence at Paris; she had saved his life in the Reign of Terror, and she had subsequently given him hospitality in England, Their relations had then ceased, and ‘* what had been a mere episode in his life was ‘The Nation. closed with the same indifference with which he had begun it.” She kept up an outward friendship, though she suffered long from the wound he had inflicted on her heart, and had many a bitter pang at his death in 1815. Next followed Benjamin Constant, who, after her husband’s death, offered to marry her. This offer she refused unless she could retain her own name, as she was unwilling to confuse Eu- rope (désorienter l’ Europe) by changing it. There were probably many other reasons, for their relations were not altogether happy ones, and Constant was always trying in vain to break loose from the chain which bound him to this masterful woman. He revenged himself long afterwards with his little masterpiece,‘ Adolphe.’ In this he had so changed all outward circum- stances as to make himself think that she would not be recognized. But all near friends who had been spectators of their intimacy—espe- cially the simple-minded Sismondi—knew at once who was meant by Ellénore. On reading the book, one has the utmost contempt for the weak and despicable character of Adolphe, in which Constant has faithfully painted him- self ; but one realizes that the position of a lover of Mme. de Staé] must have been an In- ferno. Nevertheless, even after the Restora- tion, Mme. de Staél lent Constant 80,000 francs, so that he could purchase property in Paris in order to qualify himself for election as a Deputy, on condition that half of it should be repaid on her daughter’s marriage. When this took place, she was obliged to remind him more than once ; and he wrote in his private journal, which has just been published: ‘‘ Furious let- ter from Mme. de Staél. I am lying in wait for her, and shall crush her. I have all that is necessary for it.” The threat, however, was not carried out. When in Italy in 1805, Mme. de Staél, as is is evident from her letters, fell desperately in love with the poet Monti, but as she tried in vain to induce him to join her band at Coppet, and submit himself to her influence for his literary improvement, there was apparently nothing which could be called a liaison. In 1810, after she had gone through a period of mysticism, from the religious part of which she never recovered, when she was about forty- five and had said and believed, ‘‘ The door of my heart is shut,” she gave sympathetic and tender care to a young patrician of Geneva, Jean de Rocea, who had served with distinction in the French army in Spain, had been shot through and through by guerrillas, and whose life had been preserved almost by a miracle through the care of a pitying Andalusian girl. Rocca was so much impressed by the mistress of Coppet that he said to a friend that he ‘* would know so well how to love her that in the end she would marry him.” ‘* When he was told that she was old enough to be his mother, he replied that he was glad to have another rea- son for loving her. What seemed improbable took place. The woman who had _ never been beautiful, and who had never awakened any lasting affection in her youth, became the object of a passionate attachment ennobled by constancy, at a period when she had re- nounced all hopes in that direction.” Still, with her ideas of her social rank, and with the thought that the eyes of Europe were fixed upon her, she refused to change her name or drop the title of Baroness, and hated to have it known that she had had the weakness to marry & man so many years younger than herself. The marriage, therefore, was kept secret, al- though in Sweden, for the sake of her children, it was revealed in confidence to the King. Elsewhere, and even in England, rather than {Number 1259 people suppose that she was travelling with her lover and her illegitimate daughter. It was only after her death—shortly followed by that of Rocca—that the marriage was made public. WINSOR’S ABORIGINAL AMERICA. Aboriginal America, [Narrative and Critical History of America, edited by Justin Win- sor, Vol. 1I.] Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co. 1889. In presence of a book like this, the seventh issue in the important series to which it be- longs, the critic finds it difficult to remain faithful to his duties as a ‘‘ critic.” There is so much to laud and so little to animadvert up- on that he feels himself exposed to the re- proach of partiality. Of course, no man is ever completely satisfied by the work of any other man, and the first thing one does, in examining the doings of somebody else, is to try and find out wherein that somebody ‘**seems” to display less knowledge, less expe- rience, less depth, than he—the critic—might have displayed under similar circumstances and in face of the same exigencies. But it must be said of the work which Mr. Winsor has undertaken, that he has left less room for fault-finding of this narrow kind than any one who ever trod the difficult path of ancient American history. : It is natural that the bibliographical intro- duction should be furnished by the editor him- self, since nobody was better fitted than he to give an idea of the Americana extant in libra- ries. It is pleasant to read the praise which he accords to Mr. H. H. Bancroft as a collector of sources, Whatever may be one’s opinion in regard to the use which Mr. Bancroft has made of these sources—whether his own conclusions suit us or not—the mere fact that he has ga- thered and stored them should entitle him to our lasting gratitude. Nobody has ever paid a higher tribute to Mr. Bancroft on this score than Mr. Winsor, and nobody was better fitted to doit. It is somewhat regrettable, however, that the list of libraries rich in Americana does not extend beyond the United States. The libraries in Mexico, for instance, like the Bibli- oteca Nacional and the private libraries of Don Joaquin Garcia Icazbalceta, José Maria Agre- da, and of the Cura of Amecameca, Fortino Hi- polito Vera, contain rare treasures. The paper on ‘‘The Early Descriptions of America,” also by Mr. Winsor, is an admirable piece of work. Beautifully and appropriately illustrated, and supplied with bibliographic notes of the highest importance, it is without parallel as yet for fulness and careful criticism of sources, The reader is made acquainted, in amanner as scientific as it is vivid, with the development of literature pertaining to the New World in the earliest times. It is the best existing guide to preparatory studies in American history—studies which, to our great regret be it said, have been until now largely neglected, After these two introductions follows the chapter on ‘‘ The Geog raphical Knowledge of the Ancients considered in relation to the Dis- covery of America.” Mr. W. H. Tillinghast, to whom this chapter has been committed, ex- hausts the subject as far as is now possible. Splendid copies of almost forgotten maps ac- company the article, and the Atlantis tale, the legends of Saint Brandan and Saint McLeod or Malo, as well as the question of the myth- ical island Antillia, with its seven cities, are very thoroughly ventilated. It strikes us, how- ever, that, in regard to this kind of myths and hypotheses, the author might profitably be called Mme. de Rocca, she preferred to let have consulted the second edition of Garcia’s
Page 17
Aug. 15, 1889 od - a
“Origen de los Indios,” so largely amplified and transformed by its editor, Andres Gonza- lez Barcia. Not only would he have found therein references to numberless speculations concerning the origin of the Indians which are to-day lost sight of, but he would have met with notices of manuscript sources extant at the time. He, perhaps, also passes too lightly over the ‘“montagna bruna” Dante. It should not be forgotten that this allusion may stand in the same light as the remarkable pas- of sage, ** All’ altro polo, e vidi quatro stelle "’; and that, while the latter appears prophetic in regard to the subsequent discovery of the Southern Cross, the former may be equally so with respect to a geographical fact. In all these legends and myths there is probably a di- minutive grain of truth, and whenever they show an exceptional persistence, it Is a sign that cannot. absolutely them. Among the elder descriptions of the earth we miss the one given in 825 A. b., by the Irish monk Dicuil, under the title, ‘ De Mensura Or- bis Terre.’ This little book (printed with an elaborate commentary by Letronne in 1514 not a “‘ first-hand ” source ; still, it is valuable, and the more so because it contains the posi tive statement that Irish monks had gone to Iceland prior to the year ‘UU. par. i, 6) In ‘** Preeolumbian Explorations,” Mr. Win sor gives a résumé, accompanied by the usual abundance of notes and bibliography. He, too, is silent on the subject of Dicuil, and does not menti-n among the sources the valuable book of Christoph Friedrich Muenter, ‘ Kirch- engeschichte von Daenemark we diseard is (See cap. Vil ’ und Norwe- gen.’ That author gives among other things, on p. 576 of vol. i, the text of the bull of Pope Gregory [V., wherein the words, ‘* Gron- landan—JIslandon,” It to insist upon the general excellency of Mr. Winsor’s monograph, by the side of which such slight omissions are truly insignificant. The cartography of Greenland is a masterpiece. Chapter iii, on ‘* Mexico and Central Ame- rica,” is a very careful review by the editor of what has been written and suggested as to the past of the Mexican and Central American tribes. He is wisely non-committal in regard to the differences of opinion concerning the stage of culture of these tribes at the time of the conquest and previously. It is not so much an historical as a purely ethnological question. The two “ schools ” that have arisen since Mor- gan’s first radical but necessary efforts are distinguished from each other especially by the methods of research. The ‘‘men of Morgan,” as H. H. Bancroft calls them, claim that ethno- logical study will enable us to re(stablish the original condition of the Indian anywhere, and some even go so far as to assert that ethnologi- cal research will prove a very useful check on the statements of Spanish chroniclers, whose testimony they do not reject, but regard as reliable in many cases, provided a just and -areful scrutiny precedes their use. In this consists the fundamental divergence of the two groups. The others ete., occur, is needless separate documentary study from ethnology altogether, and even fre- quently fail to apply the most simple rules of o The Nation. livia, and there is no section of the western like those initiated by Morgan, Powell, and Cushing, upon existing tribes, are more needed, and would, at the Our knowledge world where studies same time, be more profitable. of ancient Peru and the adjoining regions is as yet wholly based upon books and ruins, with but casually made upon the natives. Ellis’s ** The } the slightest sprinkling of observations Red Indian of Contact with the French surprise nobody who has read his book on ‘ The Red Man and the White Man in North America.’ improvement upon the latter in the short essay embodied in Mr. Winsor’s volume. But of practical acquaintance with Indian nature Dr. George E. North America and English” will in Still, there is some lack is here also the great drawback In chapter vi, ‘*‘ The Prehistoric Archaology of North America,” Prof. Henry W. Haynes has undertakei a very intricate, delicate, and difficult task, but the manner in which he has fulfilled it is certainly worthy of the book in which it appears. To give anything like a de- tailed sketch of his valuable paper would go beyond the limits of a review. Very cautious and guarded, Prof. Haynes has handled this subject with as much tact as learning, keeping of to every one for what aloof from any hazardous speculation his own, giving due credit he throwing the responsibility where it properly has said or done, and thus in each case belongs. His monograph is a fit transition from pre- ceding ones to the interesting essay by Mr. Winsor on ** The Progress of Opinion Respect ing the Origin and Antiquity of Man in Ame rica.” In this the editor proceeds, in his calm, dispassionate, and objective manner, to exhibit the course taken by publie and learned opinion regarding the origin of the Indians of America, It is in keeping with his previous monographs. But we fear he has done injustice to old Father Garcia when he says: ‘“* He goes over the sup the Phoenicians, the i tity of Peru with Solomon's Ophir, and len posed navigations of the chances of African, Roman, and Jewish migra- and to favora coming of Tartars and Chinese.” to chapter xxv, book 4, of the it becomes plain that Garcia favors, in fact, hardly any theory in particular, but admits that there is a likelihood in each and absolute In this respect the old Dk minican has set an example that might have tions, only to reject them all
By referring second edition, certainty in none, protited a great many of his successors, amon
whom he has had not a few detractors. Lastly, there is again sketch of archological and a condensed i Reli of Religions « a bibliography, a museums and maga- aper on the ‘‘ Myths I ie Aborigines.” All spirit zines, an three of nest criticism which are by Mr. Winsor, and br the research, and h learning, characterize his and most of t! » other papers, In short, sincere gratitude isdue to Mr, Win- sor for this valuable and in many respects model publication, which to the scientist is in- dispensable, to the intelligent general reader We regard to the illustra- nent and a
an orn: priceless guide, will word, in
criticism to the study of sources. But history can no longer be divorced from ethnology, especially in America, where the types of pri- mitive mankind are still found, and may be in- vestigated with comparative ease.
The monograph on ‘* The Inca Civilization of Peru,” by Mr. Clements R. Markham, suffers t some extent from want of ethnological data Hardly any part of the American continent is ists as Peru and Bo so neglected by ethnolog
they are all *‘to the point,” and useful animents of the text. The reproduc } ti of title pages are excellent, and the | copies of ancient maps also. Like the preced j it ‘8, this one has a special index, anda lex is promised in connection with | th and final volume | 1 Text f Ast } for Col | <a Neteont Soh s Ky Charles A \ g. Ph.D. LL.D. Boston : Ginn & Co
tions of Prof. Young for the iH ‘) ne ‘ is ‘ piaait | original investigator in many branches of l ‘ fy, . task Of writing a general astronomy
science, his success as a popular wi and lecturer, and his wide experience as a tea - have all, in particular the latter ributedl to his special fitness. Histor ! tive, rather than philosophic peculatis the book displays excellent Judgment, and "
thoroughly competent exposition of U to-day plex astronomy of In the arrangement of his material, 1 Young has not been less careful tha widely varied choice of it. Everywhere t is evidence of a study of relati ta and the whole is full, fair-minded, and cious. Nota chapter but is wt 1 wit au enthusiasm begotten of complete and accurat knowledge. To quotea few | son tl tensity of solar attract ‘If it were attempted to replace by | sof steel the invisible gravitation which | is t earth to the sun, we should find the surpris result that ic would be necessary to covet whole surface of the earth with wires as large as telegraph wires, and only about halfar apart from each other, in ord lic connection that could stand the strain i ligament of wires would t be stretched a st the breaking point.
to yet And in the following page, three bodies, he says
* Its difficulty hea sumply in the tnadeq v of our present mathematical met is. a * altogether probable that some future this difficulty will Ix ver vers possibly by the invention of “ s and numerical tables wt sha bear s such relation to our present tables wn rithms, sines, etc., as these do to t it plication table of Pythagoras The book will not, however, & stak for mere entertainment for that s f ar reader who must not be bothered to t ‘ while be reads. s literary stvile is well known and ated. a this text-book is easily his best work. His ca perhaps over-judicial, way of stating things may often make if seem to the uninformed that astronomers know very little, any way about the celestial spaces; but slight error on this side is better than on the other. If th rough instruction is attempted, the entire work will be found too exhaustive for the average elementary collegiate course and for some teachers the necessary omission of much w prove a delicate task. But the treatise cellent in every particular, and will be an in spiration to both teacher and taught No mass of material alike two writers would fit together such a there such thing as an absolute arrangement, but in fact, no is, the general order adopted by Prof. Young seems in every way well advised. First, the practical side of the science is insisted upon. The logi and must help much in precision of thought definitions are ally developed, speech. The treatment of precession is better
than we remember to have seen elsewhere, and the precession in declination, usually over looked in works of this sort, is here given pro- per prominence. Prof. Young appears at his best in the chap- where ters on the physics of the sun he is most at home. The treatment is clear and suc- einct cially dealt with, and the observations and The socalled reversing layer is judi theories of others are generously set forth, though contrary to his own. The chapter on eclipses, solar and lunar, is full and clear, though compendious. In the chapter on cen tral forces, mathematical formule are freely used, and the expression of the semi-axis majot interms of the velocity from infinity is very
momers possess the marked qualifica
neat, The exposition of the lupar perturbs
Page 18
136 tions is excellent, and the phenomena and ex- pianation of the tides are well and sufficiently elaborated. The planets’ apparent motions in loops alwaysinterest the student, and it would seem wise to have made a little more of them. Planetary perturbations are briefly dwelt upon, but very clearly; and an entire chapter is re- served for the determination of the distance of the sun, wherein the various methods are care- fully classified, and the precision of each is prominently brought out. This is, in fact, one of the best chapters in the book. Comets and meteors are difficult subjects to handle, and Prof. Young’s success with them is the more worthy of note. In taking up the stars in the three concluding chapters, the author remarks the entrance upon a vaster subject, and, he might have added, a vastly more satisfying one, The treatment is peculiarly felicitous. In dealing with the popular notion of central suns, the solar system is contrasted with the stellar in these terms : “The solar system is an absolute monarchy with the sun supreme. The great stellar system appears to be a republic, without any such central, unique, and dominant authority.” Of the triple and multiple stars known to consti- tute physical systems, he writes: ‘‘ As, for in- stance in the multiple star @ Orionis, we have a number of stars not organized in pairs, but at more or less equal distances from each other, we are confronted by the problem of n bodies in its most general and unmanageable form. Nature challenges the mathematicians.” Prof. Young concludes the cosmogony as follows: ‘*To use the technical language now usually employed, energy is unceasingly dissipated by the processes which maintain the present life of the universe; and this dissipation of energy can have but one ultimate result—that of abso- lute stagnation when a uniform temperature has everywhere been attained. If we carry our imagination backward, we reach at last a * beginning of things’ which has no intelligible antecedent; if forward, an end of things in stagnation. That by some process or other this end of things will result in ‘new heavens and a new earth,’ we can hardly doubt: but science has as yet no word of explanation.” For astronomical text-books, there is much that is novel both textual and illustrative. Sumner’s method in navigation is lucidly set forth (p. 87); the additional matter about the achromatic objective is welcome (p. 25-6), and a few lines relative to the tests of lenses by the simple method of spectral images would here have been a further assistance; it is an excellent thing to express the masses of the planets in terms of the earth’s instead of the sun’s mass: star spectra are simply and effectively present- ed; and among other novel and helpful illustra- tions are the equatorial coudé (55), Pickering’s meridian photometer (475), and the photogra- phie telescope of the brothers Henry at Paris (44). Also the new methods o7 observing the eclipses of Jupiter’s satellites, photographic and photometric, are not forgotten. The student is now and then referred to the sort of observations he may advantageously attempt, even without instruments—variable stars for example; and occasionally there are directions for the use of the telescope in practi- cal observation. It seems a mistake not to have made more of this, as the pupil may enter more fully into the spirit of the science by ac- tually making observations of his own, crude though they be, than by cramming the infor- mation with which the book is so amply sup- plied as to be in parts encyclopadic. Sundry fallacies receive a merited exposure. A frequent popular blunder relates to the lunar cusps, where it is only necessary to notice that ‘*the horns are always turned away from the sun; so that the precise position in which they The Nation. stand at any time is always predictable, and has nothing whatsoever todo with the weather. Art- ists are sometimes careless in the manner in which they introduce the moon into landscapes. One occasionally sees the moon near the horizon with the horns turned downwards, a piece of drawing fit to go with Hogarth’s barrel which shows both its heads at once” (p. 158). There is little that could have been omitted, the amount of repetition is trifling, and even the professional astronomer will rarely consult the book in vain. Some notice of the method of least squares might well have been included, as also of the almucantar. In dealing with di- rect and retrograde motions of the bodies of the solar system, there is no need of the distinction between inferior and superior planets made in all text-books ; the phenomena are simplest ex- plained as a case of parallax, and a single rule then suffices for all the planets—that when fur- thest from the earth they advance, and when nearest regrade. All matters are well brought down to the date of issue. Here and there an insignificant error isa blemish. There was no lunar eclipse in 1886, and 1884 is apparently intended; on page 439, the name of Thomsen is incorrectly printed. Occasionally the types are at fault in grammar, and a dozea or more cross-refer- ences are wrong, Which a subsequent edition way well correct. On page 519, in dealing with the abandoned rings in the nebular hy- pothesis, they are said to be “thrown off,” although three pages earlier the author has wisely cautioned the student against the use of this expression. On page 325, too, the engra- ver has bluudered in cutting the phases of Venus in the precise way explicitly pointed out before as incorrect. The typography is attractive. The arrange- ment of the pages, the variety of type, and the illustrations, well-chosen and engraved, make up an inviting book. In a few instances the engraver has been unfortunate in cutting pla- netary details too baldly, and a comet or a nebu- la is occasionally a failure. The proof-reading has been pretty thoroughly done, and the pub- lishers have afforded a strong, serviceable binding, with ornament eschewed. Great care has been exercised in the preparation and ar- rangement of a most ample index, which makes the whole easy of access for reference; but slovenly alphabetization detracts appreciably from otherwise perfect workmanship. Prof. Young’s success in attempting a ciear, accurate, and justly proportioned presentation of the principles, facts, and methods of his science merits the widest recognition. Deductive Logic. Longmans, Green & Co. By St. George Stock, M. A, Fy », bob, One of the author’s friends who looked over this book in manuscript advised him not to publish it because it was too like all other Logies ; another advised him to cut out a con- siderable amount of new matter. We cannot help being of the opinion that both of these friends were persons of a great deal of wisdom. In spite of the fact that the latter advice was followed, a good part of the new matter which is retained is, as we shall presently show, erroneous, and the old matter is, to say the least, not better set forth than in several other text-books which we could name. This is not saying that it is not, at many points, fresh and admirably expressed and fully mastered by good sense. It would be impossible fora man who has been studying and teaching logic at Oxford for seventeen years to write a thoroughly bad book on the subject, It is merely saying that the teacher {Number 1259 who should decide to adopt this book in his class-room instead of Kain, for instance, would be doing his pupils an injury. The trouble which the student usually has with his book on Logic is that it seems to him too much like a mixture of dry bones and sawdust. The best exposition of the subject is one which forces him, at every step, to see that there is an inti- mate connection between its formal rules and the trains of thought which actually go on in his own mind, Mill is still the only book for “ the gentieman and the scholar” to read ; but, for the young person who must be put quickly through the drill established by the school- men, and who must at the same time see that it has a close bearing upon the present perplex- ities of the scientific man and the practical thinker, hardly anything is so good as Bain. Bain, it is true, is open to plenty of objections of another kind; and there is no subject in which there is more urgent need of a new book which shall embody the recent improvements in the science, and which shall at the same time exhibit a kindly consideration for the weaknesses of immature minds, Mr. Stock, as far as appears from his book, is wholly unacquainted with Symbolic Logic. That is a subject which throws so much light on logical theory that a brief treatment of it ought to be introduced into every text-book; but even if that is not done, no one who writes a book should be content to be ignorant of it. The conventions which Symbolic Logic finds absolutely essential are a source of very great simplicity and consistency in ordinary Logic. Mr. Stock does not mention Venn among the writers who have helped him, and he can hard- ly have read his persuasive plea for the thorough-going introduction of De Morgan’s idea of a limited universe, and of the conven- tion that particular propositions must imply the existence of terms, and universal must not. With this convention, it is true that we must “accept the awkward corollary” of the col- lapse of the time-honored jingle about opposi- tion; but worse things than that have been lived through. If it bas been shown that black swans are not found in Africa, and that they are not found anywhere else, what follows in real life is that there are no black swans; but what the old-fashioned logician wishes us to believe is that one or other of the two state- ments must be false. It is evident that the former is the more reasonable conclusion. Mr. Stock calls the statement ‘ If a is b, cis d” a complex proposition. It should be called a compound proposition, that is, a proposition about propositions, or, better still, a sequence. The term complex proposition is needed for such as have subjects or predicates that are to be broken up in the course of the reasoning, as when we infer from the statement, ‘‘ Citizen- students are always revolutionists,” the other statement, ‘* All students are revoiutionists, or else they are not citizens.” The three things which logic considers would then be the con- cept, the judgment and the sequence, the last being defined to be the statement that one proposition follows from another or from several others, either logically (that is, as in- ference), or materially (that is, as matter of fact).* Mr. Stock’s introduction, on the whole, is good, though a more psychological account of the concept might have been given; and good, also, is his treatment of extension and inten- sion. But be has a curious idea of what con- stitutes induction. The concluding from ‘‘ All the metals which we have examined are fusi- * The distinction between the logical and the material sequence is very much the same as that between the verbal and the real proposition,
Page 19
Aug. 15, 1889] ble” to ** All metals are fusible,” he gives as an example of what induction is nof, and then he argues that it is a mistake to talk of inductive reasoning as though it were a species distinct from deductive. The above kind of reasoning he stigmatizes as a ‘‘ vague instinct,” but be forgets that before the days of Aristotle the strictest syllogistic reasoning was vague in stinct in everybody's mind, that it is so now in the minds of all but a very few, and that it is so even in their minds in all but a very few hours of their existence. Another ‘curiosity of literature”? Mr. Stock furnishes he argues, under fallacies, that it is wrong to ask your opponent to grant the point under dispute, when because it is Violating ‘the first of the general rules of syllogism, inasmuch as a conclusion is derived from a single premise, to wit, itself.” But the most original part of the book is the treatment of immediate inference as applied to compound propositions, and this, unfortunate In the first place, the treatment is totally inadequate on account of the fact that it apples only to singular propositions. The denial of ‘* No kings are tyrants ” is *‘ Some kings are tyrants,” not ‘** All kings are tyrants.” ‘If all men are gentle, all women are brave” is the same thing as ‘“‘ If any women are not brave, some men are not gentle,” but it fs far from being the ‘* If no women are brave, no men But even for singular proposi- tions, in which “ The sun shines” and ‘* The sun ly, is almost wholly erroneous. same thing as are gentle.’ does not shine,” for instance, contradict each other, Mr. Stock is still chock-full of error. His mistakes are due to two causes—to his ignorance of the fact that particular proposi- tions necessarily imply the existence, real or logical, of their terms, and to his ignorance of the fact, admirably set forth by the late Prof. O. H. Mitchell, in the ‘Studies in Logic,’ that propositions in two dimensions are necessarily six and not four in number. The reason for this latter fact is, that ‘‘ All rivers are some- times dry * may mean either that there are times when every river is dry, or that every river is dry at one time or ancther; and that reasoning cannot proceed with safety until it is known which of these two things is meant. We shall not take time to set forth the ef- fects of these two fundamental errors, It is suflicient to point out that no one but a hardened logician would suppose the state- ment, *‘ Either operators must be careful, or telegrams will not be correct,’ to be the same thing as “ Either telegrams are correct, or operators are sometimes not care- ful”; nor would he suppose that in order to deny the statement, ‘ Either men fight, or Either men fight, or tyrants do sometimes not reign.” sometimes tyrants reign,” we say ‘ It zives one a distinct feeling of dizziness, if not of nausea, to be told that these two statements are the denials of each other, To refute him who says, ** Either corruption ceased, or the country went to the dogs,” it would be necessary to ustablish both that corruption did not cease and that the country did not go to the doga It happens that statements in either or and in tf are ab- breviated forms for untrersal sequences, and thatit is imposs#ble to express with those words the particular sequences which are necessary for denying them. All thisis as plain as day- light to any one who has been trained in Sym bolic Logic, as well as to any one who has not studied Logic at all. If this author showed greater strength than he does in plain questions of Logic, more inte rest would attach to the fact, which appears from an advertisement in the end of the book, that he attributes “ importance to spiritualism, and gives a degree of credit to its pheno- The Nation. mena.” There is an admirable liection of examples Days Out of Doors. By Charles C. Abbott LD. Appleton W CO. ISSO OVO, OW) Pp. IN considering books such as those of Tho reau, Joln Burroughs, and other literary field naturalists, the critic mindful of the rights of readers and the aspirations of authors will be led to inquire what is their purpose or func tion, and to judge any particular book by its efficiency measured in terms of this ideal stan dard, It would seem impossible it standard to omit the element of accuracy « statement in regard to the facts of nature ko us this must take its place as the essential framework, the gudispensable foundation « the literary edifice The most charming style, the most enthusiastic description of wood and vale, and all that « ‘in, When based on misconception of that Nature the author would ) l teach us ecome little better In proportion the effort be thie el tself untram to appreciate, | than meretricious frippery. error enters in, so far must Fic 9 a melled, may give a seac iis deem Nd ast to the kingdom of f Arden, heed ed a failure, ‘tion may he Bohemia, and lions to the wood « less of the smiles of critics. But when an au thor says, ‘* Come with me and see the hidden treasures of the pasture, the woodland, or the brook,” and we follow, let him beware if he leads us astray. The hope that through his agency We may attune ourrelves more truly to the music of insect wings and the clear voices of the birds; that may rhtly read, rig wrongly, into the microcosmic tragedy we comedy of the lives which animate the bro and hedges, something of the pathos or joy which gives interest to our own, and feel n keenly nature uu . }, } ad r relationship to the great these desires may not be idly with. The ignorance of laymen may preserv: them from the disheartening recognition of tinselamong the author’s gold; but with thos who know the wilds and thei wilful or careless misreading o Nature will always present itself crime, Abbott's books we id his f} and recognize the merits of h In previous reviews of Dr. have endeavored to applat enthusiasin is sty le, whil precating a carelessness of statement, and a gross inaceura tendency to occasional g spoil much of his work for thorough natural ists. In the present work the pleasant diction and the hearty enthusiasm are the same, and ited ble contempt by the author, seems to have had previous criticism, though tre the effect of rendering him some careful. Dr. Abbott seenis t 4 t existence of a greater amount of intellige and individuality among animals, even ef low ly types, than they are usually giv reslit for. In this contention we are in sympathy with him; but he does not seem to realize th danger of loose inter] ti the action of auimals to the establishment of his hypothesis The nurse who attributes to a suckling infant reasoning and logic which belong to an adult, commits a similar error, without very serious ‘ consequences. But when the attitude of man towards the inferior creation kind in general depends largely on an accurate understanding of their respective positions, the avoidance of a non-sequitur has rtance. When the author boldly set pported opinion t the facts gat a host of observ- t lass careful, earnest, and devoted than urage, but He is « ardly cau be said to exbibit disoretion. c himself, he may exempli nay te t t his t wik refusa t i { ‘ i r 7) ‘ r \ i The Hist { it ¢ wfien \ Hand l K wend uy M Gustave )D Irav's Histoire son le lat isation Edit ed by Rev. J. \ v M.A Witt : trat s Db. A ton & ¢ ss Svo Tp p Pur ter story [ \ ation t i wo quite d Y if senses Wea t fn i ir withit f1 G t, wl 1 snhates by tapl wap inal f the great current fi ? “ t? ‘ ‘ ila to tra heu influence wp t i ‘ und uy the t sia nad fl ranity t ‘ ngs of cause and effect his is wheat ¢ wna anid | k f x have ‘ v tl term, f w (iu t But if mav be tak as by the author of ¢ t k tx © us, ast t puivalent of the Get in iA ¢ s " which 1 re descriptive than analvt Vinge } le oft feof society rather tha ira terizing it as a wt This is no t . ful a work as t her, indeed st prel rv tort: there im bet ur analy sis, of any value, which does not rost ups exhaustive study of deta Rut we s prefer to reserve U te 1for tt i ‘ higher w ~—the mer v Ww rust ni irt 5 Phe present work, indeed, consists s ' of ‘ t t if 7 AS TD f 7 s Y bet he a plete history ven } t vents and tary campaigns are given at sor th It consists of three books —The Nations of t Fast, Greek Civ : : 7 1 An World. 1 ul urte ipters ull, the scope of whict n bb ‘ by the titles of the four chapter the Greek 1 v The eck | gion, Greek | tics, Greek | terature and Art, The Diffus of Greek Ce nius. It willt t this treatise covers a wid ground i ist rest upon the basis of very va ‘ nd extensive scholarshiy I genera the s« ‘lars! pois sound an i accurate, but it cann always be trusted. For example, the CeDS Se Sis Ned igre “' the Ire sident of the ite iis represe! ted as pre ginthatl v——the duty of theconsuls. On the f wing page the Assembly of the Tribes, 1 to be that but the le sided over bv the tribunes, is sa took part” ) »} cers of the plebetans, could presi lebeian assembly le peopre usivelv } n is Gracchus “‘had . there than in t Gal given up his tribuneshi; lack of **‘ caution ” abeut it from the Presidency it Hannibal, having ex 1@ Gauls and others, disappointed ”; but the people of Lower Italy that disappointed him. ve that Otfried Muller's theory of the antag of the with Sparta and Athens as their yet staal ntial aid-—it was naament undament al nism Dorian and nian races, is not now held in so distinct respective ty pes, a for The elegant and luxurious Corinth was a Dorian city; the peculiarities of Sparta were rather Spartan m as is presented on page 150. than Dorian. We note as misprints Jupiter Olympus (for Olympius, p. 114), and Dracati (for Diacriot, p. 164). Most astonishing and inexcusable of all, we have, on page 1S], a hexastyle temple in a plain presented for the Parthenon! There is DO Index.
Page 20
1838 The Nation [ Number 1259 The Scientific Papers of the late Thomas An- drews, M.D., F.R.S., Viee- President and Pro- fessor of Chemistry in Queen’s College, Bel- fast. With a Memoir by P. G. Tait, Sec. R.S.E., and A. Crum Brown, M.D., F.R.S., Professors in the University of Edinburgh, Macmillan & Co, 1889, THe handsome volume before us contains a complete record of the life-work of a man who labored long and effectively in the border-land between physics and chemistry, but who is perhaps less known in this country than many who have done less valuable service. Profs, Tait and Brown have given us an interesting though somewhat colorless memoir of Dr, An- drews, who seems to have been a man of very sterling worth. Thomas Andrews was born at Belfast on the 19th of December, 1813. He belonged to the Scotch-Irish race which has produced so many distinguished men, and appears to have been a clever and precocious boy, with an inborn taste and faculty for scientific pursuits. At the age of seventeen he went as a student to Paris, where he worked in the laboratory of Dumas, Returning to Ireland, he spent four years in Trinity College, Dublin. He then studied me- dicine at Edinburgh, graduating in 1835, and settled in Belfast as a physician, but during the next ten years gave instruction in chemis- try, and, though in successful practice, found time for valuable investigations, chiefly on the heat of chemical combination. He soon made the acquaintance of other chemists, notably of Graham and Faraday, with both of whom he became on terms of intimate and lasting friend- ship. In 1845 Andrews gave up his private practice, and became Vice-President of what is now Queen’s College, Belfast. Here his real- ly active scientific life began, and here he worked unceasingly till, in 1885, op the 26th of November, the final summons came. The place of Thomas Andrews among scien- tific men, if not aniong the highest, is still very high. Thongh his papers were numerous and varied as regards subject, he will be re- membered by three prominent investigations. Of these the first is on the heat evolved during chemical action, and it embraces three series of very important papers. Others had worked in the same field of study, but the work of An- drews so far surpassed what had been done be- fore him that we can hardly hesitate to call him the founder of the new science of thermo- chemistry, at least from the experimental side. Subsequent investigations have shown that Andrews’s work was excellent in quality. Good, says a French proverb, is the father of better, and the work of Andrews will in due time be superseded; but we doubt if that time has yet arrived, though far more elaborate and extensive investigations have since ap- peared, About the year 1856 Andrews began the se- cond great work of his life, the investigation of ozone, the beautiful discovery of Schénbein, The subject was at the time almost in its in- fancy. It was not known whether ozone con- tained only oxygen, or whether it was a higher oxide of hydrogen, or again whether there was not more than one kind of ozone. An- drews proved that ozone, from whatever source derived, is one and the same substance, having identical properties and the same constitution, and is nota compound body, but oxygen in an altered or allotropic condition, The investiga- tion was continued in conjunction with Prof. Tait, and led directly to the true theory of the constitution of the new form of oxygen. But the crowning work of Andrews’s life was that on the continuity of the liquid and [gas eous states of matter—a work which, if he had done nothing else, would alone have given him a permanent reputation. Cagniard de la Tour in 1822 observed that ether, alcohol, and water, when heated in sealed tubes, were reduced to vapor in a space between two and four times the original volume of the liquid. Faraday, in the following year, liquefied chlorine and some other gases by pressure alone. It was reserved for Andrews, by a careful study of what was then called carbonic-acid gas, to clear up the whole subject of the passage of a liquid into a vapor. For the beautiful and simple methods of investigation and for the purely scientific details of the results, we, of course, refer our readers to the original me- moirs. It will be sufficient to state that these results rendered it possible to liquefy oxygen, hydrogen, and nitrogen gases, and that, with- out the direct experimental application of Andrews’s work, the liquefaction would have been impossible. Profs, Tait and Crum Brown have done the work of editing most carefully, and have erect- ed a noble monument to the memory of a man of remarkableendowments, who has written his name permanently upon the history of physi- cal science. The Problem of the Northmen: a Letter to Judge Daly, the President of the American Geographical Society. By Eben Norton Horsford. 4to. Tus letter appears to have been published be- cause Prof. Horsford was ‘‘ stung” (as he terms it) by the charge of ‘ perversions” made by Mr. Justin Winsor, in the ‘ Narrative and Critical History of America,’ in a disparaging estimate of the value of Horsford’s ‘ Discovery of America by the Northmen.’ Hence his endea- vor to place his critic in a ridiculous light. To accomplish this he institutes a comparison be- tween the fruits of his own researches, enume- rated under nineteen heads, and the results de- rived from Mr. Winsor’s methods, of which he givesa single illustration, accompanied with his reasons for supposing the result to be erroneous. The Professor’s methods are epigrammatically described by himself in the words ‘ Prediction and Fulfilment.” The most striking instances upon his list are the discovery of Fort Norum- bega (No, 15) and the identification of the re- mains of Norse houses, huts, fish-pits, ete. (No. 19). Both of these sites are on the Charles River, the former being in Waltham, and the latter just below Mt. Auburn, in Cambridge. Mr. Winsor’s conjecture that the ditch at Waltham might possibly mark the site of an early attempt to found the town of Boston, is first contrasted with results like those we have selected above, then characterized as a guess, then demolished in an argument abundantly fortified with italics, The Massachusetts Historical Society comes in for a share of the Professor’s satire. A committee of that society ventured to dissent from some of his conclusions. He alludes to a ‘*tone of conscious infallibility ’ and ‘‘an un- dertone of recognized authority ” in their re- port, and buries them under the weight of the question, ‘‘ Is Massachusetts a preserve /” This is not the place to discuss the questions suggested by the weighty claims made by Prof. Horsford, nor can we at this time attempt to measure the relative values of the methods of research pursued by himself and Mr. Winsor. Mr. Winsor’s history is fitly described by Prof. Horsford as a monumental work, and he him- self can rest assured that his name will become famous if but a small part of the nineteen re- sults which he enumerates shall be accepted by students of American history (or, as he, per- haps, would prefer to put it, American geog- raphy). Before leaving the subject, however, we wish to call attention to some points to which the Professor has briefly alluded, but which he may perhaps treat more fully in the forthcoming papers which he promises, And, first, is he not in error in seeking to identify Verrazano’s C. St. Margarita through the abundance of the daisies in a neighboring field ? Bigelow thinks this weed was introduced here from Europe. Reliance upon Thevet and an analysis of the alleged Indian word Norumbega lie at the foundation of the discovery of Fort Norumbega. Yet we are told that Thevet was in error in supposing that the fort was the work of the French; and the argument (for- merly advanced by J. R. Forster, see ‘ Nar. and Crit. Hist. of America,’ vol. i., page 98, note 15), that Norvegia and Norumbega are different forms of the same word, is held to contain the solution of the problem of the Northmen. The photographs of the Norse canals with which the letter is illustrated, do not give a clear idea of their character; but such a sys- tem as is described seems to militate against Horsford’s fort almost as much as against Win- sor’s conjecture of the intended site for Boston. The minute identification of the site of Leif’s house, of Thorfinn’s house, of the huts and of the fish pits, on a spot continuously occupied since the day when Saltonstall landed near there, can readily be proved by archeologists. If Prof. Horsford’s contidence is as great as it seems to be, he can afford to wait for the tri- umph which will follow this proof. The more severe the language of his critics, the greater will be their discomfiture. Meantime, those who do not blindly accept his conclusions will prefer to wait for this proof. BOOKS OF THE WEEK, Anderson, Dr. W.G Light Gymnastics. Effingham Maynard & Co, Autobiography of Froebel. Syracuse: W. Bardeen. —— n, Prof. H. H. The Light of es Oseatunnaee, . Appleton & Co. 75 cent Pr bell, W. W. Lake Lyrics, and Other Poems. St. John, N. B.: J. & A. MeMillan. Christianity and Agnosticism: A Controv ersy. Papers by Huxley, Mallock, Mrs. Humphry Ward,ete. D. Appleton ’& ¢ oO. $1. Clifford, E. Father Damien. Macmillan & Co. 75 cents, Collar, Ww, iC. Ginn & Co. Corelli, Marte. J. Ivers & Co. 50 cents. Ellwanger, G. H, The Garden’s Story: and Trii uis ai an Amateur Gardener, D, Co. 2 Fisher, Rev. °. Macmillan & C Garnett, Prof. J. “i. noth; Anglo-Saxon Poems, “ne. R. Elementary Algebra. tyr ‘a Latin Composition, Boston: Krdath: The Story of a Dead Self. M. or, Pleasures Appleton & 2d ed Elene, Judith; Athelstan; Byr- Boston: Ginn & Co, #1. Longmans, Green inane of the Earth’s Crust, &C Gre sssberg, J. G. Poems. Chicago: Occident Publish- ing Co, 25 cents. Himmel, E. von. The Discovered Country. Boston: Ernst von Himmel Publishing Co. Kempis, T. The Imitation of Christ. A. D. F. Ran- do ph & Co. $3.50. Kent’s Commentaries, Vol. I, 14thed. Philadelphia: Blackstone Publishing Co. Lange, Helene. Frauenbildung. Berlin: L. Oehmigke. Lieb, H. The Foes of the French Revolution; Centrali- zationand Anarchy. Belford, Clarke & (0. Macdonald, Rev. D. Oceania: Linguistic and Anthro- pologic al. London: Sampson Low. Mahaffy, Prof. J. P., and Bernard. J. H, cal P hilosophy for English Readers. Il. The Prolegomena translated, Appendices. Mac millan & Co. McKenna, 8, Ryllis Darke: A Novel. lishing Co. 50 cents. Moses, Prof. B. The Federal Government of Switzer- land. Oakland, Cal.: Pacifie Press Publishing Co. Newell, Jane A, A Readerin Botany. Partl. From Seed to Leaf. Boston: Ginn & Co. 70 cents. Norris, W. E. MissShafto. Henry Holt &Co. #1. Nourse, H. S. The Military Annals of Lancaster, Mass., 1740-1865. Laacaster Palmer, J. A., jr. One Voyage and its Consequences, Boston: D. Lothrop Co. $1.25. Rice, Prof. W.N. Science-Teac nine in the Boston: D. Cc. Heath& Co. 1l5cents Réné de Pont Jest. Artist and Model. Chicago: McNally & Co. Rockwood, Caroline W. A Masque of Honor: toga Romance. Funk & Wagnalls. Rosenfeld, Mrs. Sidney. ’Twixt Heaven and Earth. United Service Pub, Co. 25 cents. - T. The Winning of the West. Putnam’s Sons. $5. me, A. His Private Character. G, W. Dillingham & Co. 60 cents. Shepard, J. Essays and Pen-Pictures. Shepard, J. Pensées et Essals, Paris mentatre, Kant’s Critt- New ed. Vol. with Notes and 0, “Minerva Pub Schools. Rand, a Sara- 2 vols. G Paris. Librairie Docu
Page 21
Aug. 15, 1889] HENRY WILL HAVE EDUCATION NAL WORKS. The Nation. HOLT READY SOON THE FOLLOI Vv & CO. 7X JOHNSTON’S (A., late Professor in Princeton) BRIEF HISTORY THE UNIT {7 MEISSNER S AUS MEINER WELT. Edited, with eo calnice: ped Carla Wenckebach | Professor \V s ( OTIS'’S (C. P., late Professor in Mass, Inst. of Technoloey)\ ELEMENTARY GERMAN x | In wl rpora Author’s Second Part: The whole arranged aud edited by Horatio Stevens White (Professor in Corne! : PECK’S (H. 7., Professor in Columbia College) SUE TONIUS'S LIVES OF TH: SARS. With I 1 ¢ ar WALKER'S(F. A., Pres. Mass. Inst. of Technology) FIRST LESSONS IN POLITICAL Vo. BALDWIN'S(j. M., Professor in Lake Forest Univ.) HANDBOOK OF PSYCHOLOG) Senses and I: —— LATELY PUBLISHED: HOWELL’S (W.H.) DISSECTION OF TH1 As a basis for the Study of Phys y. 8y } I s e, 3 \ mail, $1 By , OT7S’S (C. P.) MIDDLE HIGH GERMAN. Being an Outline of Middle High G in G S Nibe Lied, with notes and a vocabulary. Svo, paper, 156 pp Teachers’ price #1 by ma $ PACKARD’ S (A. S.) ENTOMOLOGY FOR BEGINNERS. For the use of Yeung | 3, | Growe Farmers Ga 1zmo, 367 pp. Teachers’ price $1.40; by mail, $1.53. REMSEN’S (IRA) INORGANIC CHEMISTRY. S8vo, 827 pp American Science 8 \ ced ¢ Feache S as by mail, $3.08. SMITH’S(C. J.) SYNONYMS DISCRIMINATED, New Edition, with the author’s st ‘ s s ‘ Teachers’ price $1.80; WHITNEY'S (W. D. ) RS mo, 47 by mail, $1.04. COMPE NDIOUS = PP. evercises, E P. Pan's New Sons, YORK AND LONDON, PUBLISH THIS WEEK: MODERN CHESS By W. $1.50, IN- Large THE STRUCTOR. Part I. 254 pages, Steinitz. octavo, CONTENTS : tation—Laws of the Game—Technical Terms— stesso price $1.30; Description of the Game—The No- | Chess as a Training of Mind~—The Modern School | and its Tendency— Relative Value of Pieces and Principles of Play—Analysis of the Following | | contains the highest character o Openings, with Illustrative Games: The Ruy Lopez, Double Ruy Lopez, Three and Four Knights’ Game, The Scotch Gambit, The Two Knights’ Defence, Petrotf’s Defence, Philidor’s | Defence. The Appendix contains the games of the contest between Messrs. Steinitz and Tschi- svorin, played at Havana in January and Feb- ruary, 1889, with annotations by the author. This volume, by as the highest authority on the subject of chess analysis, is the first original work in its depart- ment that has appeared in this country. GREAT WORDS FROM GREAT AMERICANS. of Independence, of the United States, with notes, Washington’s Cir- the Constitution cular-Letter of Congratulation and Advice of the Thirteen States, and Seeond to the Governors Washington's First Inaugural Addresses and his Farewell Address, and Lin- coln’s First and Second Inaugural Addresses With an Index to the Constitution and an Appendix. Wit and his Gettysburg Address. i portraits of Washington and Lincoln, Popu- lar edition, 16mo, cloth, 75 cents. SEVEN THOUSAND WORDS OFTEN MISPRONOUNCED. A guide to correct pronunciation. By W. H. P. Phyte, author of ‘ How Should I Pronounce?’ * The School Pronouncer,’ ete. l6mo, cloth, $1.25 In the Sertes of KNICKERBOCKER NUGGETS, No, 21. Tales by HEINRICH ZSCHOKKE, Translated by Parke Godwin and W, P Prentice. 16mo, cloth extra, $1.00, *.* Lists of Announcements for the ! seca sent on application TERMAN GR ¢ i by mail, $1.44. Key A LITERARY MARVEL—$2.50 ———— i TEURUUUEEE We are publishing a reprintof the ENCYCLOPEDIA BRITANNIC h we third the price of the latest English edition, whi volume, The same number orf volumes (24) completes our set, as does the or! ner or Stoddard editions. No such book has ever been authors and specialists. The Encyclopedia Britannica is a library in itseif, in Physics, History, Politics, Trade, Art, Geography, | on every subject. | a writer who is recognized | Comprising the Declaration | fe specially desire to obtain as subscribers all those w ho ever enter mutupon the market of such sire and knowledge and literature in the o It is the greatest work of its kin and stands re and Philosophy; , being lese th for map, * ’ per ve page, map t ae an one reproduce j age for ume f ginal, and at half the price of the Serib qual tv of binding for so k Written by the rt tin the Ene) ady on the she to furnish the waprice. It teminent living age er every questios ation wanted d ever nats ae ivest jatest inform logy ined an idea of « whing the Enc ve | dia Britannica, but hesitated on account of the high pr Veare now ready to deliver the set « Agents wanted. THE HENRY G ALLEN COMPANY, 1 ishers 126 Washington St., Chicago 78v and 741 Broadway, New York We. have unexcelled facilities for ss } ~ l- 3 ~ Y + 1° “4 . the manufacture, introduction, JOlins Hopkins University, and sale of Books of all kinds. . . . atl _ BALTIMORE. UTHORS and Publishers having 7 books they want made are request- Announcements for the next academic vear ed to correspond with us. are now ready and will be sent on applica- THE KEYSTONE PUBLISHING Co., tion , vph) ¢ Dh tlaslateaht ee : a . mee . ° 1oth and Filbert Sts., Philadelphia. S. Davis, Jros Cincinnatz ANDOVER PUBLICATIONS. Valuable Theological Works. Ar ver, Mass CHRISTE W RN, + Fifth Ave erween TSt fut s., New York te t reigt &s. Ax t for © (eading } shers, T . \ ~ € reek and Larin Bstics, cues af s K maile lemand \ larg ssor ‘ ays on band, an books : S' FT ( 4 »A ‘ \ \ nN guages, Mis t Ks ara 3 aoy f 4 k ™“ OEN i : ‘OM Pi Vu - a0 s nz Age; N 7 DoW rea and a i? xa t va pes E. Rota, 1153 Pi St. F when one Pack NUMBERS. VOLS. AND SETS ) of the Nation bought, sold. and exchan nged A. S. CLARE, Ht Park Row, New York City. Diamond Hams m whom obtain circulars w to Cook the Diamond Ham Are prepared to sud! sites Bis hop Gorham & Van Klee ck EDW RISHOP, — AUSTIN G. GORHAM. DENI ER, HENRY VAN KLEECK.' COLO. INVESTMENTS AND LOANS. Morey loane), interest collected, investments made and taken care of for Eastern investors in Colorado References: Robert M. Morse, Jr., and Edward ©. Perkins. Rosta James M. Mclean, Pres. Man. Life ns. Co Amos Cotting, New York, and the banks of v I etter We buy and sell Bills of Exchange on and make cable transfers of money to rope, Australia, and the West Indie nake Collections and issue Com ercial and Travelling credits, availa bl e in all parts of the world. Credit. Brothers & Co., Bankers. ‘9 WALL STREET, NEW YORK. Brown NO.
Page 22
vi The Nation.
[ Number 1259
STAND ARD SCHOOL BOOKS SELECTED FROM THE CLARE}
.-DON PRESS SERIES OF THE UNIVERSITY OF OXFORD. Agents for the United States, Macmittan & Co., New York.
ENGLIS ADDISON.—SELECTIONS H CLASSICS. FROM PAPERS IN THE “SPECTA- | TOR.’’ With Notes. By T, Arnold, M.A., F.R.U.I. $1.10. BURKE.—THOUGH'S ON THE PRESENT DISCONTENTS: the | Two Speeches on America, With Introductionand Notes, By E. J. Payne, | M.A. Second Edition, $1.10, BY RON. —CHILDE HAROLD. With By Tozer, M.A. 90 cents | wae Saree and complete an edition of an English poem has rarely appeared.” | —Athenaum, j CLARENDON.—HISTORY OF THE REBE “ os Alt IN. Book VI. With | By T. Arnold, M.A., R.U.1. $1.10 | The editor has Introduction and Notes, Introduction and Notes. *A book which is admirably ‘adapted to the ye Schools. po his work thoroughly.’’—Schvolmaster. GOLDSMITH.—THE TRAVELLER. Ry G. Birkbeck Hill, D.C.L. Stiff ex GRAY.—SELECTED POEMS. covers, 40 cents. JOHNSON.—LIVES OF nes, M.A., London, id With Notes and Introduction. vers, 25 cents. | Edited by Edmund Gosse, M.A. Stiff | DRYDEN AND POPE.—Edited by A. Mil- Stiff covers, 60 cents. MILTON.—POEMS, Edited by R. C. Browne, M.A. Edition. $1.75. Separately—Vol. L, @1; Vol. IL., MILTON.—PARADISE LOST. Boox I. Beeching, B.A. 40 cents, Two vols. Fifth 75 cents Edited by the Rev. H. C, POPE.—ESSAY ON MAN. With Introduction and Notes. By Mark Pattison, B.D. Sixth edition. 40 cents. CHAUCER. 1.—THE PROLOGUE TO THE CANTERBURY TALES; THE KNIGHTES TALE, etc. Edited by R. Morris, LL.D. 60 cents. SPENSER.—THE FAIERY QUEENE. Booksland2. Edited by G. W. Kitchin, D.D. Each 60 cents. SCOTT’S LAY OF THE LAST MINSTREL. With Preface and notes. By W. Minto, M.A. Paper covers, 50 cents. ‘*The work is a model tn its class.’’—Notes and Queries, SHAKESPEARE.—SELECT PLAYS, Edited by W. G. Clark, M.A and W. Aldis Wright, M.A. MERCHANT OF VENICE, 30 cents. MACBETH, RICHARD THE SECON), 35 cents. HAMLET, Edited by W. Aldis Wright, M.A. 35 cents, 40 cents, THE TEMPEST $5 conte. CORIOLANUS, 40 cents, AS YOU LIKE IT. 35 cent RICHARD THE THIRD. 40 cents. A MIDSUMMER NIGHT Ss pik EAM. 35 cents. HENRY THE FIFTH, 40 cents, aah FTH NIGHT, 40 cents. KING JOHN, 40 cents, JULIUS C-ESAR. 40 cents. KING LEAR, 35 cents. “No teacher should consider himself fully ec Plays without this edition.’’—Jrish Teachers’ Journa ‘We have often expressed an opinion that this edition ts simply without a None even comes second to it.’’— Westminster Review. ppen for the study of these rival, | A SECOND LATIN EXERCISE BOOK. By J. B. Allen, M.A.
GERMAN CLASSICS. Edited by C, A. BUCHHEIM, Phil. Doc., Professor in King’s College, London. BECKER'S FRIEDRICH DER GROSSE, Tables and a Map. cents. ‘The editor has done his part excepttonally well. . . The best of the Se ve s to which it belongs,’’— Educational Times. GOETHE.—EGMONT. Witha Life of Goethe, « GOETHE,—IPHIGENIA AUF TAURIS, 75 cents. HEINE.—HARZREISE, With a life of Heine. 60 cents. HEINE.—PROSA. With English Notes, $1.10, LESSING.—NATHAN DER WEISE. $1.10. NIEBUAR'S GRIECHISCHE HERSEN-GESCHICHTEN, by EmmaS. Buchheim, 50 cents, SCHILLER’S Ww ILHELM TELL. Sixth Edition. 0 cents. “As complete and satisfactory in every way as could be desired.’’—Athenceum. SCHILLER’S WILHELM TELL. School Edition, With Briefer Notes and Map. 50 cents. SCHILLER’S HISTORISCHE SKIZZEN. and Belagerung von Antwerpen, amap. 60 cents, * This volume is one of the best adapted of the Series for German Students.”’ Saturday Review. LESSING’S MINNA VON BARNHELM. A Comedy. Fourth ‘* Dr, Buchheim has certainly done his work thoroughly and well.” FRENCH CLASSICS Edited by GUSTAVE MASSON, B.A., late French Master at Harrow School. MOL = RE’S LES FEMMES SAVANTES. With Notes, Glossary, &c. 50 cents. REGNARD’S LE JOUER, and BRUEY’S AND PALAPRAT’S LE GRONDEUR. 60 cents, VOLTAIRE’S MEROPE. Edited by G. Saintsbury, M.A. 50 cents. 70 75 cents, ate, Edited Egmonts Laben und Tod, Third edition, revised and enlarged, with edi- —Academy.
LATIN RUDIMENTA LATINA. AN AND GREEK. By J. B. Allen, M.A. 50 cents. ELEMENTARY LATIN GRAMMAR. By J. B. Allen, M.A Fifty-seventh Thousand. 60 cents. A FIRST LATIN EXERCISE BOOK. By J. B. Allen, M.A. Fourth Edition. 60 cents, cents, si Evidently the work of a scholar and a practised teacher.’’—Saturday Revi: A LATIN PROSE PRIMER. By J. Y. Sargent, M.A. 60 cents. A GREEK PRIMER FOR THE USE OF BEGINNERS. By the Right Rev. C. Worasworth, D.C.L. Seventh Edition. 40 cents. AR.—THE GALLIC WAR. With Notes and Maps. By C. E Moberly, M.A. 1.10, CLESAR.—THE CIVIL WAR (FOR SCHOOLS). Maps. By C.E. Moberly, M.A. 90 cents. “ Stands high amongst the best classics we have met.’’—Saturday Revie. CICERO.—SELECTED LETTERS. Notes by the late C. E, Prichard, M.A., and C. E. Bernard, M.A. 75 cente. HORACE.—THE ODES, CARMEN SECULARE and EPODES With a Commentary. By E. C. Wickham, M,A. New Ex lition, Revised, #1.4 ‘* Probably the best school Horace in existence.’’—Saturday Review, D. IUNII IUVENALIS SATCRAE XIII. Thirteen Satires of Juve- CES 3 With Notes and nal. With Introduction and Notes by C. H. Pearson,M.A., and H. A. Stron M.A., LL.D. Crown 8vo, él. 50, “ This truly admirable edition.’’-—Atheneum. LIVY.—BOOKS V. TO VII. Notes by A. R. Cluer, B.A. Revised by P. E, Matheson, M.A, $1.25. LIVY.—BOOKS XXL-XXIIL T. Tatham, M.A. $1.25. ** A thoroughly good school book.’’—Saturday Review. PLINY.—SELECTED LETTERS. Notes bythe late C, E, Prichard, M.A., andC. E. Bernard, M.A. 75 cents, TERENCE.—ANDRIA. Notes and Introductions by C, E. Freeman, M.A., and A, Sloman, M.A. 75 cents, With Introduction and Notes by M. TIBULLUS AND rae ERTIUS. With Introduction and Notes by G. G. Ramsay, M. J $1.50, VIRGIL, —_ENELD. “BOOK I. With Introduction and Notes by C S. Jerram, M.A. 60 cents. ** We have seldom seen a better -edited school-book,’’—Freeman’s Journal. VIRGIL.—-ENEID. BOOK IX. With Introduction and Notes by A. E. Haigh, M.A. 60 cents. ** The notes seem to be quite scholarly.’’'—Guardian, VIRGIL. Ww ith Notes, etc. By T. L. Papillon, M.A. 2 vols., crown *—Journal of Education, and Notes by Arthur Sidgwick, Sve “ The sg working edition of Virgil.’ <ESCHYLUS. With Introduction M.A, AGAMEMNON, 75 cents; CHUZPHOROI, 75 cents; EUMENIDES, cents. ARISTOPHANES, With ere ‘tion and Notes by W. W. Merry, DD. CLOUDS, 50 cents; ACHARNIANS, 75 cents; FROGS, 75 cents KNIGHTS, 75 cents. EURIPIDES. With Notes, ete., by C.S. Jerram, M.A, ALCESTIS, ¢ cents; HELENA, 75cents; HOR-ELAID, 75 cents; IPHIGENIA, 75 cents DEMOSTHENES.—THE FIRST PHILIPPIC AND OL YN THIACS I.-I1I. eae tes by Evelyn Abbott, M.A., LL.D., and | E. Matheson, M . 75cent **4 model of What a school boo ;k should be, The notes are clear and to t point,’’—Academy. HERODOTUS. Book IX. With Notes by Evelyn Abbott, M.A. LL.D. 75 cents, ‘An admirable specimen of scholarly editing.’’—Seotsman. HOMER.—ODYSSEY. Books L.-XII. With Notes, Introduction, and Synopsis of Homeric Forms, by W, W. Merry, D.D., Editor of ‘ Aristophanes in —o e Plays,’ ‘Selections from Herodotus,’ &c, Fortieth Thousand $ “Mr. Merry’ s editions have revolutionized the study of Homer throughout the country.’’—Oxford Magazine. PLATO.—THE APOLOGY. With Notes and Introduction, for the use of Schools, by St. George Stock, M.A. 50 cents. ‘* 4 better edition could not be placed inthe hands of the student,’’—Schoo! master, PLATO. —MENO. With Introduction and Notes by St. George Stock, f.A. 50 cents. « Tne introduction, the anatysis of the argument, and the notes, which clea away all difficulties, are all that could be destred.’’—Schoolmaster, SOPHOCLES. For the use of Schools. By L. C ampbell, * A,, Evelyn Abbott, M.A. New and Revised Edition, Two Vols., $2.76 ‘The ideal form of aschool classic. . . . This edition ought to be’ possesse:! by all young students of Sophocles, as there is no chance of a wortby rival taking the field for several years.’’— Atheneum. ‘*An excellent school edition,’’--Saturday Review. THE PLAYS SEPARATELY, EACH CEDIPUS TYRRANUS, and 50 CENTS: E: PHILOCTETES, _(EDIPUS COLONEUS. ANTIGONE AJAX, 2LECTRA, TRACHINLE, XENOPHON.—EASY SELECTIONS (for Junior Classes). With Vo- eabulary, Notes, &c., by J.S, Phillpotts, B.C.L., and C.S, Jerram, M.A. * cents. XENOPHON.—SELECTIONS (for Schools), With Notes and Maps By J. 8. Phillpotts, B.C.L. 90 cents.
*,* Macmillan & Co.'s new General Catalogue, embracing also the miscellaneous publications of the Oxford Clarendon Preaa, for which they are th: appointed American agents, is now ready, and will be sent free by mail on application. MacMILLAN & Co., 112 Fourth Avenue, New York.
Page 23
The N Tation. and Students Aug. 15, 1889] Works for THE STORY OF THE NATIONS. 12mo, cloth Illustrated. Per volume, $1.50. No. XTIT. THE STORY OF MEXICO. T eachers HISTORY. By Susan Hale. No. XXIV. THE STORY OF PHOENICIA. By Prof. George Rawlinson No. XXV. THE STORY OF THE HANSE TOWNS. By Helen Zimmern. No. XXVI. THE STORY OF RUSSIA. By W. R. Morfill. PREVIOUS ISSUEs. II—ROME, by Gilman. Ill —THE JEWS, by Hosmer. IV zin. Gould. ViI—Norway. by Bovesen, VII—SPAIN, by E. E. HUNGARY, by Vambery. ix ARTHAGE, by Churen, X--SARKACENS, by Gilman. Xi—THE SPAIN, by Lane- Poole. X{I—THE NORMANS, by Jewett. XLif—PERSLIA, by Benjamin. XIV—ANCIENT EGYPT, by Rawlinson. XV—ALEXANDER’S EMPIRE, by Mahaffy. XVl—ASSYRLA, by Ragozin, XVII- IRELAND, by Lawless. XVII[—GOTHS, by Bradley. XIX—TURKEY, by Lane Poole. “XX—MEDEA, by Ra gozin,g XXI—MEDLAVAL FRANCE, by Masson. XXNIT—HOLLAND, by Rogers, Fuil descriptive lists sent on application, FRENCH CLASSICS FOR STUDENTS. Edited by T. Il. TABLEAUX DE LA REVOLUTION FRANCAISE. $1.50 ll, LE ROMANTISME FRANCAISE. $1.50. ll, LA SOCIETE FRANCAISE AU DIX-SEPTIEME French Society in the XVII[th Century in its Relations to the bibliography, and notes. 16mo, cloth, $1.50. WORKS ON PRONUNCIATION SHOULD I PRONOUNCE ? or, Third edition, 16mo, cloth, 21.25. I—GREECE, by Harrison. CHALDEA, by A as V—GERMANY, by Baring { and S. Hale. VI MOORS IN F. Crane. Account of with int: SJECLE. An Literature of the Period, oduction, By W. H. P. Phyfe. I. ‘HOW Art of Correct Pro- nunciation, THE SCHOOL PRONOUNCER. i6mo, cloth, #125. Ill, SEVEN THOUSAND WORDS OFTEN Handbook of Difficulties in English Pronunciation. names and words and phrases from foreign languages. AMERICAN LITERATURE AMERICAN LITERATURE By Charles F. rature in Dartmouth College. Octavo, eloth, two vols, $6.00, Part I, The Development of American Thought. Part Il, (Completing the work) American Poetry and Fiction, HEBREW SCRIPTURES. Arranged and edited as an introduction to the study Bible, by the Rev, Edward T. Bartlett, D.D., Dean of the phia, and the Rev, John P, Peters, Ph.b., Professor of P, ©, Divinity School in Philadelphia. Part I. Hebrew Story from the Creation to the Exile. 12n Part Il. Hebrew — Tales, Poetry, and Prophecy. pectus.) $1,50. From the Rev. Geo. Ww illiamson Smith, D.D.. Pres. Trinity College \ work of great worthy of the scholarly men who have prepared it, and calculated to render much student, as well as to the ordinary reader of the Bible.’ KNICKERBOCKER A Selection of some of the World's Classics, uniquely The Principles of the Tl. Sused on Webster's Unabridged Dictionary. M/ISPRONOL Including an cloth, $1.25. "NCED. larze A complete unusually number of proper loémo, 1607-1885 Richardson, Professor of Lite of the Protestant Episcopal Divinity School in Philadel the Old- Testament Languages and Literature in the , red edges, pp. 546, $1.50, red edges, pp. 564. See separate pros 12mo, and permanent value, assistance to the advanced NUGGETS and tas tef il uy printed by the Knickerbocker Press, and otfered a3 specimens, as Well of artistic typography as of the best literature i2mo, cloth extra, gilt tops, XV. THOUGHTS OF THE EMPEROR MARCUS AURELIUS ANTONINUS, Trans by Geo. Long eee! oo XVI. AZSSOP’S FABLES. Rendered chietly from original sourees. By Kev. Thomas James, WA. th 100 illustrations by John as 21.25. AVI ANCIENT SPANISH B ALL ADs. Historical and Ron ranth franslated, with notes. by J. G. Lockhart. Profusely illustrated 1.50 XVIII. THE W ANI » WISDOM nversation Sia) itings and ¢ —Comme OF SYONEY SMITH. A Se lection of the Most Memorable Passases in his W: TALES BY HEINRICH ZSCHOKKE, $1.00, ** Little gems of book: (race Ctn aking.’ NX. AMERICAN WAR BALLADS, Ballads and Lyries which were produced during ited, with notes, by Geo. Cary Eggleston, With original illustr (Full list sent on application.) 1oteworthy of and the Civil War Ed A Selection of the more the Revolution, the War of 1812, tlons. NCE. A Comprehensive rred by John WORKS OF REFERE? THE POCKET ATLAS OF THE WORLD. of 54 Maps, illustrating Political and rhysi Beautifully printed in 32mo, cloth extra, $1; full leather, 3! : THE POCKET GAZETTEER OF THE WORLD. A Dictionary of General phy. Edited by J. G. Bartholomew, F.R.G.S with nine lithographic maps, uni form with the Pocket Atlasof the World. Cloth, extra, $1 fuli leather, #1 THE PRACTICAL POCKET DICT/ONARY, in Four By Ignatius Em. Wessely, 4 Vols., S2mo, $4.5 ELEMENTARY. THE NURSERY LESSON BOOK. A Guide for Me thers in Teachi By Philip G. Hubert, Jr. Fifty easy lessons, each lesson co ining simple and} reading, writing, arithmetic, drawing, and singing. 75 cts, STUDIES IN PRIMARY EDUCATION. By Mary Putnam Jacobi, M.D. Contents. —The Flower or the Leaf—Experiments in Primary Education—The Place for the St guages in a Curriculum of Education. and Pot Bart hol lar Series ‘al Geography Preps mew, F.R.G.S. Geogra Large 32mo, 65) pages, German, and Italian, ng Young Chil rogressive instruction tn iren $1.00. idy of Lan ‘ ination and introd n. Ea tional and fad lists sent napplication, SONS, *,* Special terms to teachers for era: G. P. PUTNAM'S | 27 and 29 West treet, New York. . 23a 5 INN & ( Bulletin of New Books AL GUST ISSY uo. ENGLISH ANI] MODERN LANGUAGES HANDBOOK OF RHETORICAL ANALYSIS John T. Genung of Amherst | xe. $ dies in stvle and invention esixcned pany the author's Practical } t R with notes. questions, and references INTRODUCTION TO THR sT ry Fr TH OF RORERT BROWNIN be W \ Professor of English iu University Elo GARNETT'’s ELENE, a translation t An AX os Bienes udit? Ath ‘ t ‘ trumanburh, and Hyrhtwosh, tl N Maldon. Ky Prof. James M. Garnett of versity of Virginia. ) cents INTRODUCTION TO MINI OS MANUAL OF FN Prose Literature, reprinted esp ally rc qua students 1S cents PAGES CHOISIES DES MEMOLRES Uc \ Simon, edited and annotated Fre A.N. van Daell of the Mass. Ins logy i pages t4 cel ! consists of three selections from 4 laine. THE BEGINNER'S BOOK IN) GERMAN ‘ with humorous pictures v> thor of * The Bewinner’s Book tn Fspecially designed for tren t plan as‘ Phe Beginner's Book in THE BEGINNER'S BOOK IN PRENCH ‘ Reading Lessons iy Sophie | With a vocabulary. CYNEWULF'S ELENF, eciited in ¥ \ Saxon Poetry bw Prof. Cha sw ‘ University of Tennesse ANCIENT LANGUAGES PRACTICAL LATIN MPOSTTION, By W author of the * Reginuer’s Latin k THE BRUTUS OF CICERO ellogxg of the University and Notes, $1.2 Texta . Pay This is the second volume tn thre ¢ gv S « Latin authors, A LATIN-ENGLISH Pict N Hatch €1 A SCHOOL ILIAD, Greek in Yale ¢ leather $i 25 With full intradiuction, ample t e and Sev illustrated vocabulary The six-bouk edition wil $1.60), HOMERIC Vi rts CABULARY y ir Db. S 7S cents, A vowabulary to Une illustrations THE PROTAG eTies of f the Robbin ‘ th, $1 paper, BS « ~onts, IPHIGENIA AM PIDES, edited i thors by Prof. Isaac Flage Texta Zi.4 paper, $1.1 Tent, pop v0 THE IRREGULAR VERRS ATTIC ‘ ‘ Prof. Addison Hog f the University of Missis- Mp F150 MATH? ALGERRAIC ANALYSIS siashan. $1.50 it , ‘ rst SiN [ke sKS € the ‘ w a Qty. THE NGQ@ THE TA the College ANALYTIC jae Harvard College. # The first edition of this work has idet enlarged, ar Somers lin many particulars ARITHM+TICAL RE EWS. by J Patterson of Lawrenceville School, N.J.. 1 the tials of arithmetic c NATURAL SCI UTLINES OF LESSONS EN BOTANY. Part I: } mVenienti Seed to Leaf. By Jane H. Newell, Lilustrated &) cents . 4 READER IN BOTANY. Part l.: From Seed to Le Ry Jane H. Newell, lLllustrated. 6) cents s l.ctions and adaptations from weil known auth HISTORY. THE LEADING FACTS OF FRENCH HISTORY Db. H. Montgomery, author of The Lealing Fact in English History,’ ete. #1.12. With fuil black and colored maps, tables, et A BRIEF HISTORY OF GREEK PHILOSOPITLY. itv 7 c. Burt, weer Fellow in the Johns Hopkins University. $1.1 MYERS’ GENERAL “HISTORY, by Pres. P. ¥._N. yers, author of the Mediawval and Modern Hi- tory Ancient History,ete, A text book for hich schools, academies, and seminaries. With full colored maps and illustrations. $1.50 Keay August 25. *,* Coptes will be sent to teachers post paid on receipt of the introduction prices given abhore Fuller infor mation respecting any of these publications will be given on application. GINN & COMPANY, Publishers.
Page 24
THE. The Nation. ise nail 1259 O LEADING SCHOOL BOOKS . B. LIPPINCO rr COMPANY Worcester’s School Diction- aries. TIE STANDARD IN SPELLING, PRO- nunciation, and Definition. These Dictionaries contain more Words than any Others of Similar Grade, end are the Latest mg Dictionaries pub- lished, he New Academic, Comprehensive, and New Schoolare New Books, The Revision has re- sulted in the Insertion of all the more Common New Words. Reset from New Type, and contain- ing New Illustrations. New Plates have been employed, WORCESTER'S PRIMARY DICTION- ary. Profusely Illustrated. 384 pp., 16mo, half roan, 48 cents, WORCESTER'S NEW SCHOOL Pe -alog Pp.. tionary. With Numerous Illustrations, COMPREHEN.- half roan, 80 cents, sive Dictionary. pene Illustrated. 688 pp., WORCESTER’'S NEW 12mo, half roan, $1.40 WORCESTER’S NE W ACADEMIC Dictionary. 688 pp., L2mo, half roan, $1.50. Sanford’s Series of Analyti- cal Arithmetics. Mental and Written Arithmetic successfully combiued in each book of the series. By Shelton P. San- ford, A.M., Prof. of Mathematics In Mercer Unit- versity, ‘Georgia. hos RY, INTERMEDIATE, HIGHER ANALYTICAL, ‘OMMON SCHOOL, es HOLLAND TRUST CO., NO. 7 WALL ST., NEW YORK, $500,000. - - - SURPLUS, $660,213 CORRESPONDENTS : DE TWENTSCHE BANKVEREENIGING, AMSTERDAM, HOLLAN For sale by all booksellers. LIPPINCOTT COMPANY 715 and 717 Market Street, Philadelphia. CAPITAL, B. W, BLYDENSTEIN & CO,, LONDON, ENGLAND. Allows interest on deposits and interest on balances of active accounts of merchants and others. Transacts a general banking business. Lends money on promissory note with New York or Brooklyn appraised real estate first mortgage, with ti- tle guarantee policy as collateral security. Acts as Executor, Trustee, and Guardian under wills for the fixed statutory charges; also, as registrar, trus- tee, transfer and financial agent for States, cities, railroads, towns, and other corporations, and for real- estate mortg es with coupon bonds in New York, Brooklyn, and elsewhere. Collects rents, coupons, and dividends, Negotiates State, city, railway, and corporate loans. TRUSTEES. John D. Vermeule, cone Van Voorhis, . W. Van Voorhis, Gen W. Van Siclen, James Roosevelt, Augustus Van Wyck, Vanderhorst Kuyt, Henry W. O. Edye, Jotham Garret A. Van Allen, Warner Van Norden, Hooper C, Van Voorst, James B. Van Woert, G. Van Nostrand, John R. Planten, Henry W. Bookstaver, Robert B. Roosevelt, Ww Hitiam Remsen, W. D. Van Vieck .H ROBERT B. ROOSEVELT JOHN D. GEO. W. President, VERMEULE, Vice-President. VAN SICLEN, Secretary. KNABE PIANOFORTES. UNEQUALLED IN TOUCH, WORKMANSHIP, AND DURABILITY. WILLIAM KNABE & CO,. Baltimore, New York, 22 and 24 E. Baltimore St., 148 5th Ave., near 20th St., Washington, $17 Market Space, TONE, f ELEMENTARY LESSONS IN HEAT (Just saoage). By S. E. Tillman, Professor of Che- mistry, U. Military pone my at West Point. 8vo, iliustratea. cloth, $1.8 Lippincott’s Popular Series of Readers. The series consists of five books, substantially bound in cloth, and handsomely illustrated, with a supple- mentary’ volume rey SIXTH READER) for advanced pupils. FIRST aoe 20 cents. SECO READ- ER, 33 cents. D READER, 44 cents. NLOURTH READ ER, 60 cents. FIFTH READER, 90 cents. SIXTH READER (for advanced classes), #1 .00. LIPPINCOTT’S POPULAR SPELLING Book. Prepared to accompany their well-known POPULAR SERIES OF READERS, 1lzmo, 160 pages, bound in boards, 20 cents. THE BEGINNER'S READING BOOK. By Eben H. Davis, A. M., Superintendent of Schools, Chelsea, Mass. Illustrated, 12mo, cloth, 30 cents. Teacher’s Edition, 42 cents. —_—— Cutter’s Physiological Series. BEGINNER'S ANATOMY, PH YSIOLO- gy, and Hygiene. Sy John C, Cutter, B.Sc., M.D. 12mo, 140 pp., 47 illustrations, 30 cents, Sample copies sent, on recetpt of price, PH Y- A.M., 200 INTERMEDIATE ANATOMY, siology, and Hygiene. By Calvin Cutter, .D. A Revision of the First Book. 12mo, pp., 70 Suamcntionn, 50 cents, COMPREHENSIVE ANATOMY, PHY- siology, and Hygiene. By John C. Cutter, B.Sc., M.D. 140 illustrations, 12mo, cloth, $1.00. PRIMER OF SCIENTIFIC KNOW- ledge. By Paul Bert, author of * Bert’s First Steps in Scientific Know ledge. ’ Translated and Adapt ed for American Schools. Illustrated, 12mo, cloth, 36 cents. FIRST STEPS IN SCIENTIFIC Knowledge. By Paul Bert. Adapted and Agrempes for American Schools by W. H. Greene, M.D. W 570 Iliustrations, Complete in one 16mo vol. pp. 6v0cents. SHARPLESS & 313 5 PHILIPS’S ASTRONO- my. Prepared by Prof. Isaac Sharpless, Se.D., of Haverford College, and teorge M. Philips, A.M., Principal of State Normal School, West Che ster, Pa. Clear Explanations. Freshnes; of Matter: Profusely iJlustrated, 12mo, cloth, $1.00. CHAUVENET’S GEOMETRY. A Trea- rece Elementary Geometry. Crown 8vo, cloth, 1.60, ABRIDGED EDITION. By W. E. Byerly. Ph.D., Hany of Mathematics, Harvard College. 1,20, Pro- 8vo, by the publishers, THE EQUITABLE Life Assurance Society assues a new policy which, like a bank draft, 7s a simple PROMISE TO PAY. USIC-ART-ELOCUTION and General Cu : ty ese open to progressive students. wi veneiee valuable information Free, ble Positions All interested iz i | | anaaned Boston, — O M E OPA THIC DESCRIPTIVE Catalogue Cocke, medicines, etc.) mailed free. Address BOERICKE & TAFEL, 1011 Arch St., Philadelphia, Pa., or 145 Grand St., New ‘York. Oldest H hic Pharmacy, established in 1835, by addressi: ng E. NE. CATALOGUE of Books in good con- dition now onnny. Books purchased. W. JOHNSON, 1336 Broadway. ORCESTER’S DICTIONARY ‘‘ The highest authority known as to the use of the English language.” With or without Denison’s Patent Index. The Standard of the Leading Publishers, Magazines, and News- papers. The Dictionary of the Scholar for Spelling, Pronunciation, and Accuracy In Definition. Send for large Circular to the Publishers, J. B. LIPPINCOTT COMPANY; PHILADELPHIA. ONEITA PRONOUNCED BY CONNOISSEURS THE BEST AND MOST AGREEABLE TABLE WATER IN THE MARKET. PURE, CLEAR, SPARKLING, AND DELICIOUS. ONEITA ee Pace UTICA, J.M. BEL L & CC co. )., 3] 31 Broadway, New York. 7 WEODORE MUNDORF F, cian, Care of the sight. "Srazilian pebbles, eye- glasses, opera-glasses, field-glasses, etc. 1167 Broadway, New York, under Coleman House, OPTT-