The Nation 1888-10-04: Vol 47 Iss 1214
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
‘The Nation VOL. XLVIL—NO. 1214. rPHURSDAY, SER 4, 18 PRI o CENTS D.Appleton& Co, a BEERS G.-P. Putnam's Sons l HAVE JUST PUBLISHED: = NZ, -\ ; ° ° AR NV I: T ) a " 7 , = . Cc he Advance-Guard 01 y ee. eae 4 Western Civilization By JAMEs R, vest “Edmund Kirke’ author of ‘The Rear-Guard of the Rev tion, ‘John Sevier as a Commonwealth Builder,’ ete. With Map, and Portrait of | James Robertson. 12mo. Cloth, $1.50, This work is a narrative of an episode which is | serve perhaps the most unique and remarkable in | duty American history—that of thesettlement of Mid die Tennessee. Itis in a measure a continua tion of the thrilling story told by the author in | his two preceding volumes, * The Rear-Guard of | ° the Revolution’ and * John Sevier as a Common- wealth-Builder.’ The three volumes together cover, says the author in his preface, * ( lected period of American history, and th close facts well worthy the attention of h ans—namely, that these Western men turn tide of the American Revolution, an - quently saved the newly-formed Union fron i dis- —— and thereby n nade possible our present rreat republic.’ U1. | A History of Charles the | Great (Charlemagne). By J. I. Mompert, D.D., author of * Hand- Book of the English Versions,’ * Great Lives,’ etc. Svo, cloth. 600 pages. Price, | so $5.00, This work, which consists | now presented for the first time in almost wholiy on the conten rea wu Annals wud Chronictes, Biographies, Laws, Poems, Luscriptions, et« UT. Researches on Diamavnet- ism and Magne-Crys- tallic Action, Including the Question of Diamagnetic Po- larity. By Prof. JoHn TyNpDALL. With | re Ten Plates. 12mo, cloth. Price, $1.50, | Westminster and other) By Count Lye wee. Authored LAR 6 NU Ee etd ie I ERI ) “ ; 4 \ ‘ ‘ Lint RY, the HIBBER sermons. = wii CENEN, STRAUSS.” 7BL By RICHARD CHENEVIX TREN Archbishop. 12mo, cloth. Price, This posthumous volume by Archbis Tols Trench contains sermons preached in West rrr n aT ree => UT \ As S \( ONS. ster Abbey and sermons preached in [relat <<a eee Oe os j ; ITO! 27 AND 29 . 23D . New YORK A Text-Book of Human) 220.3." " MANN & CO. alten . WESTERMA & LVSLOLOS), Ant New York, By Austin Fiint, M.D., LL.D ey ‘ : } 1 Booksellers and Importers. edition (the fourth) entirely rewritter : i Tertdool oreign and . er) With 316 Figures and two Plates. \ . ‘ : , 7 Progra poms ean ‘ cloth, price, $6.00; sheep, $7.00. wc , HIEME-PREUSSER, German-Engl. Dic For sale by all booksellers; or any HS the publish rs bu mai ( mparative Grammar. $5 price. 1, 3, & 5 Bond Street, New York. | : ~ Co., 747 B’way, N.Y. | Catalogueson application . postpaid, on?
Page 2
The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science, and Art.
FOUNDED 1865, Entered at the New York City Post-ofice as second -ciass mail matter.) CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER THE WEEER......sccccccsvccseoe eerecececercesesess SOO EDITORIAL ARTICLES :
The Ordnance Blunder... ......sccsccsessccsee & 52 How Common Things Become Sacred... 262 The Cost of the Present Tarilf................... 2 t The Balance of Trade **The Wages Racket”’ The Great Awakening.. SPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE : Imperial Federation........ In the Footsteps of Dante....
CORRESPONDENCE : The True Inwardness of the Vermont Election... 268 A Psychical C oinc idence g * Preventative The Indices to He ulkett and L. MAND ccc vente is MOTHS. ccccccocsccccecsccscscccoscues vecccccccccce at
REVIEWS : Recent Novels............ aaa German History, by a Frenchman... Grant and the P gag for the Mass. Institute of Technolo- fy isaspecialty. Reference is made to the Institute aculty. Of the twelve candidates presented by Chaun- ey Hall at the June examinations only one had any condition in mathematics. The location of the school building, on Copley Square, is especially attractive, and is very near the Institute. Preparation for Harvard, with or without Greek. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston,36 Commonwealth Ave, f OME FOR YOUNG LADY STU- dents,—-Miss Putnam, having relinquished her school in Marlborough Street, will receive into her family a limited number of young ladies who may wish to avall themselves of the superior educational facilities which Boston affords. She will make a de- lightful home for thein, giving them the same privi- leges and social advantages as though they were her pupils. Her beautiful house in Commonwealth Ave- nue presents unusual attractions. Address MISS PUTNAM, hr HUSETTS, Boston, 233 Marlborough St. _ M E. H. SEARS’S SCHOOL FOR i Girls will reopen October 1.—Advanced courses of Instruction a special feature. Circulars sent on app" ‘ication. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 2 25 Chestnut ‘St.
j ISS HELOISE E. HERSEY'S ei school for girls; the fall term will open Octo- ber 3. Circulars sent on application to the pr neipal. MASSACHU SETTS, Boston, 152 Huntington A Ave, _ ME. E. DECOMBES’ FRENCH L and English Home Schoo! for six girls reopens September 17,1888. Highest re ferences. Massacnv SETTS, Boston, 112 Newbury Street, “WIE MISSES HUBBARD'S SCHOOL for Girls will reopen October 1, 1888. A limited number of boarding scholars will be received. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 5 Otis Place. MR HALE’S SCHOOL FOR BOYS prepares for the Institute of Technology and for Harv vard Coilege. Address ALBERT Hal E. MASSACHUSETTS, ( Yambridge. Larch Street. f OME FOR BOYS.—DR. ABBOT AD- mits not more than four boys into his family, to fit for collece or educate privately. Separate tuition, with best of care in all respects. C —s location, with fine tennis-court. F. E. ABRor, Ph. Z Massacuusetrs, New Bedford Lr NDS’ ACADEMY, — COLLEGE Preparatory “=e Special Courses. Tuomas H. ECKFELDT, Principal. — MASSACHUSETTS, P lymouth, Mi KNAPP’S HOME SCHOOL FOR [ oe (twenty-second year).— Begins October MASSACHUSETTS, Quincy. DAMS ACADEMY.—PREPARA- wi tory boarding school for boys. School reopens —ee 12, 1888 For all information apply to Wi.uian EVERETT, Pn.D,
MASS8ACRUSETTS, 8S. Williamstown, Berkshire Co, “REVYLOCK JIJNSTITUTE.—A PRE- T paratory School for eye. 46th year. Catalogues Gr ORGK F. MILLS, Principal. on application. NEw HAMPSHIRE, Portsmouth. , EF OME SCHOOL FOR BOYS.—SPE- elally_ healthful situation. Preparation for Harvard and Institute of Technology. G. L. STOWELL, A.B. (Harv.). NEW JERSEY, Morristown. : ISS E. ELIZABETH DANA RE- opens the Seminary for Young Ladies September 19. Thorough instruction in English, French, and Ger- man; Music and Art. Grounds ample for recreation. Climate of Morristown unsurpassed. Terms: Board- ing pupils, $500. Circulars on application. - NEw YorK City, 348 Madison Ave. for GIRLS 1| Mise UDON’S SCHOOL Reopens Oct. 1. Five pupils received into family. New York Ciry, 423 Madison Ave,, near 49th St. 6 a. De — > SCHOOL FOR BOYS e reopens Sept. 2 Principal now ‘at home. New York, Dobbs Ferry. i AY SCHOLARS FOR M/SS ters’ School. A pleasant home and care for a few young ladies and little girls w to attend Miss Masters’ school as day scho ars at once, or call on, Mrs, F, A, WALKER, care Re Niven, D.D MA S- — 10 desire Address v.25. . New York, Garden City, Long Island. ATHEDRAL SCHOOL OF ST. PAUL. Boarding School for Boys. Accommodations un- surpassed, thorough preparation for Harvard, Colum- bia, Yale, ‘Trinity, ete. 16 teachers employed. Mili- tary system under a United States Army officer. Address. CHARLES STURTEV ANT Moore, A.B. (Harv ard). New York, Suspension Bridge. L E VEAUX COLLEGE.—A Military Boarding School for Boys, WILFRED i. “Mv NRO, A, M.. . President.
NEw YORK, Syracuse. A fe. C. M. WILKINSON'S HOME School for Girls. Number limited to ten. $1,000 er year. Noextras. School year begins September 19, . Refers to Hon. Abram 8. Hewitt, Geo e Wm. Curtis, Hon. Wayne McVeagh, Rev. Edward Everett Hale, Thomas Wentworth Higginson, Louisa M, Alcott, Hon. _ Andrew D. Wh NEW York, Utica. ys RS. PIATT S SCHOOL FOR YOUNG Ladies.—The next school year begins Thursday, Sept. 20 20th, 1888. Applications should be made early. Oun10, Cincinnati, No. 166 W. Seventh St. WE SCHOOL FOR GIRLS ESTAB- lished by Miss Storer and Miss Lupton In 1881, and conducted by Miss Lupton for the past two years, will open for its eighth year Sept. 26. Preparation for college is made a specialty. The official circular from Harvard College shows that this school is the only pri- vate school in the West whose pupils have passed with out condition their examinations for women identical with the examinations for admission to Harvard Col- le; ege. = few resident pupils are received. , PENNSYLVANIA, Bryn Mawr, near Philade iphia. f RYN MAWR COLLEGE. —A | COL. J lege for Women. The Program stating the gradu- ateand undergraduate Courses of study will be sent on applica ation. PENNSYI. VANIA, Chester. ENNSYLVANIA MILITARY ACA- demy. 27th year opens September 19. A MILI- TARY COLLEGE with four graduate courses: CIVIL ENGINEERING, CHEMISTRY, ARCHITECTURE, and ARTS. Degrees conferred in each, respectively C. E. B.S., B.AR., and A.B. A thoroughly organized Prey a- tory’ Department. For Circular, with fuil infor mation, address Col. Cuas. E, Hyatt, Pres’t.
PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, Chestnut Hill. RS. COMEGYS AND MISS BELL'S English, French, and German Boarding School for Eat adies reopens Sept. 28, 1 Students prepared for College. ia grounds for outdoor ¢ exercise. PENNSYLVANIA, ., Philadelphia, 14: m P ine St. ADEMOISELLE BONAME'S French Home School for six young ladies, reopens 26. Thorough course in English and French. PENNSYLVANIA, Philade!phia, 1350 Pine St. TSS ANABLE’S BOARDING AND Davy Schoo! for Young Ladies will reopen Sept. 26. Sept. VV = VirGINiaA, Norfolk, opposite Old Point Comfort. F ing YOUR DAUGHTER DELICATE ? Build her up by sending her to schooi in this de- lightful, healthful winter climate. Full collegiate courses, music, art; equipment, $60,000, Attractive home school, Personal care. Address _NORFOLK COLLEGE. GERMANY, Wiesbaden. ~DUCATION IN GERMANY, WIES- _4 baden College. Thorough German and French. Preparation for University. Boys can be met at New York. Refers to Prof. M. L. D’Ooge, Ann Arbor, Mich., Mr. L. Cushing of Yale College, Mr. A. Loeb, '204 La Salle St., Chicago. Forcirculars apply to BRENTANO’ 8, 5 Union Square, New York; 101 State St., Chicago : 1015 Pennsylvania Ave., Ww ashington, D. c. JAMAICA, Potsdam School, Sta. C ruz Mts. _ WE REV. W. D. PEARMAN, M.A. (Cambridge), prepares for Business and U —— rsi- ties. In the Cambrilke University Local Exams., a Potsdam boy stood 2d in Greek and 10th in ton — all England. For terms apply as above,
Page 3
*andeducation with her own h, Music, and Drawin LADY IN ENGLAND OFFERS A Spenth h, the daughters of n. Terms, tt days, £200 perannum. Very highest re fe re nm es given and required, Address Mrs. MARILLIER, Messrs. Holt Lawrie & Co., 17 Whitehall Place, London, England | WILLIAMS GRADUATE D# = AES e preparatory or college tutoring in New Y« y Exp4rience in private tutoring—-one vear in pr e} ar ‘ tory school, and one as instructor in Willlams ¢ we Reters to Pres’t Carter and Williams Professors. Ad cae. W. D. M., care of Nation VIARLES W. STONE, Tutor for Har vard, 68 Chestnut Street, Boston. HY%: MES HINKLEY, A.M., PRI- vate Tutor, 1 Ware St., Cambridge, Mass. ANTED.—BY A GRADUATE Ol! Smith College, a position as teacher in a private school or as governess in a private family Has had experience and can give the best of references Ad dress Smith College, care of the Nation. School Aseiicies. YARDEEN’S SCHOOL BULLETI: v | Agency, Syracuse, N. Y., may be depended on to furnish suitable teachers and to inform no others. Y es BOSTON TEACHERS’ AGENCY
supplies Teachers to Schools, positions to Teachers. Circular free E. O. Fisk & Co., 7 Tremont Place, Boston Wants. i IRRESPONDENCE JIS DESIRED with an American student who is to be in some German city by December next and ¢ ul lL assist a youth bag completing his fling al preparatic or Harvard Colle Address ** P,’’ Hox 533 y Hoaton. Viass THe HARVARD UNIVERSITY EX- AMINAT! ONS FOR WOMEN will be held n New York on June 27, 28, and 20, 1889. Two seh« larships of $300 and $200 each are offe red in connection with tt examin tions For informs ation apply to the Secretary, No. #2 East 33d St. COLUMBIA COLLEGE SCHOOL OF
POLITIC AL SCIENCE. The prime aim of tl ve 1 sche hoot is the development of all branches of the political sciences. It offers eight courses in political and constitutional history, nine in policical ecouomy, five in constitutional and admi nistrative law, four in diplomacy and international law, three in Roman law and comparative jurispru dence, two in political philosophy, and one in bibliio graphy—in all, forty-four hours per week through the academic year. The fullcourse of study covers three years. For admission as candidate for a degree, the ay plicant must have satisfactorily completed the rezular course of study in this college, or in some other main taining an equivalent curriculum, tothe end of the ju nior year. Special students aimitted to any . without examination upon payment of proporti fee. For circular of information apply to Rewyistrar, 49th St. and Madison Ave., N. Y. city. For information apply to HENRY DRISLER, LL.D., Acting President. F. A. P. BARNARD, LL.D., D.C.I President of Columbia College. THE DUTIES PROPOSED BY The Mills Bill, COMPARED WITH PRESENT DUTIES. A complete Table of Comparisons will be found in the New York WEreKLY Post of August 30. The same issue contains a re production in facsimile of the cele brated ** Fat’? circular appealing for Republican can paign funds, in which the admission is made tha manufacturers get ** practically the sole benefit’ of the tariff laws. A third edition has been printed to meet the n tinued demand Price 3 cents per copy, or & hundred, postpaid. Address tHE WEEKLY POST, New York BOOKS! BOOKS!! BOOKS!!! MURRAY'S REGENT HOUSE BOOKSHOP
Is the place for rare and valuable Be low prices. Catalogues issued freq gratis to any applicant, Address t : VOTTINGHAM, ENGLAND, Orders may be sent through Messrs. G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS or Mr. B. F. STEVENS of New York and London, r.W.CHARISTE , Fifth Avenue, between 23th and 2¢th Sta., New York. orter of Foretga Books, Age nt for the leading Paris Pu ylishers, Tauchnitz’s B h Authors, Teubner’s Greek and Latin ( lagsics. Catalogues of stock mailed on demand. A large assortment always ou hand, and new booka received from Paris and Lelipvig aa anon as leaned OLUST PUBLISHED.—THE NATU- ral Method No, @, Vol. IT Will be sent on ar plication to stude nts % and teachers of dress STPRYS Sch: LANG Kast 44th street, New y ae x . , > yk’ D p h Pees BOOA SS. —- AMSSIAN f 3 Hungarian, Swedish, Danish, Hebrew, French, (rer
~
man, etc. H. ROSENTHAL CO., 14 Cooper Uni
every respect.
( comple te New Shorthand. PHONOGRAPHY THE NEW Text-Book of the witt ( NN \ R. Bis s em. 7 k mber (aud SS t S . Ass'n. & I 3 5¥- « 1 part of the vinnie 1 H yul Y ONE sound of bef Lin ' s Con 8 Ww ' : vling Exercises Ww 1 Mv for M I s yt graved,—fully illustrating all pr ples e. t pod ge leather, TW ARS { ‘ulars vad OPINIONS of XI SHORTHAN WRITE! sent Address ( Bist N. } STOCK EXCHANG N.Y DAVID G. FRANCIS, Astor Pacer, New YORK, DEALER IN VALUABLE OLD ann NEW BOOK Priced Catalogues ™ . trom time to time, sent gratis STME \I's SARE INVES i rplus, $35 18 e Principal and interest both full capital and surplus of $1,105,016. In of business we have seek Bence 4,6 0% TO 12% ; at 5
t ty or <8 3 dolar. Real Fstate First Mortya 1mi i] niure Bonds and Savings Certvficates always on hand for sale -In savings departments, in amounts of &® and uf ward; in the mortgage department, & and upwa Full information regarding our various securities fur nished by J. B. WATKINS LAND MORT- GAGE CO., LAWRENCE, KANSAS, OF New York M’n'a’r. HENRY DICKINSON, 319 Broadway IROWN, BRO Lb THERS & CO 69 Wall STREET. BILLS OF EXCHANGE OOMMERCIAL asp TRAVELLERS’ CRRI Avaliable tn all parts of the World eR SAKER R's 187 Breaktist (i ast nn Warranted absolutely pure Cocoa, from which the exceas of Ot] haa beer poved. It haa ¢irce times the strength of Cocoa mized with Star Arrowroot « and is therefore far more eco cal, costing ies than one cent @ cup. It ts delicious, nou — strengthening, easily digested, and admir — os weil aa for persons tn health. Seld by Grocers everywhere. W. BAKER & CO., Dorchester, Mass. 4 a
ly adapted for tn.
RNIN ABSOLUTELY SATISFACTORY REMINCTON Standard Typewriter. SPEED CONTESTS. Verfital “ [Hanke
New ¥ N } i $ " . “ k a SS . | ‘ e $ . . ~ + a S < SS g t Ss ‘ . . . Fx nie 3 S S New K e k . ‘ s * KS a ‘ ex 474.4 ss ‘ . Ne AS kK 8 ‘ A t : Sit - 7 ’ : « ’ , ¢ e wa < " after slay © Seve -_ . — on f 1882 w e of ™ ftar < 4 afte mlay s a x “ st ¢t? w . ? 1 at t e ¢ . ~ i< 4 are? on the pany for the year xs f “ t tifcates w s I i first of May next rof Board L\PMAN. Secretary tt George Bliss , ’ A. Hand Anson W. Ha 4A Hew N Smit 3 . \ H. We ac I WwW < wis P. Burdett Edw. Floyd Jones wley Thomas Maitland Jos x H. Marshall, Ira Bursley K Tas. G. De} <t, James A. Hewlett % a Lever Geo. H. Macy, x Dear. John L. Riker Lawrence Turnure " Vm. } tye HN I IONES,. President W.H. H. MOORE, Vice-President
4. A. RAVEN, 24 Vice President PiTALISTS ) M i! and Timber Lande Cop per, a Mine t P pr ptlive Circulars of these rich properties I ington St.. Baltimore {5 vols., for sale by A. Ss. CLARK t Park Kow, New York city.
———
Page 4
1vV Scribner & Weltford’s | NEW BOOKS. Twelve Good Men. B.D., Lives of By John W. Burgon, Dean of Chichester. 2 vols, Svo, cloth, $6.00, CONTENTS. I.—The Learned Divine. Martin JOSEPH Routh. {I.—The Kestorer of the Old Paths. JAMES ROSE. IlI.—The Saintly Liver. CHARLES MARRIOTT. —The Great Provost. EnwarRD HAWKINS. V.—The Remodeller of the Episcopate. Sam- VEL WILBERFORCE. VI.—The Humble Christian. LYNCH CoTTON. VIlI.—The Faithful Steward. WELL. VIli.—The Pious Librarian. vius CoxF. 1X.—The Christian Philosopher. LONGUEVILLE MANSEL. X.—The Single-Minded Bishop. JACOBSON. XI.—The Earnest PAGE EDEN. XII.—The Good Layman. HIGGrns. RICHARD GRES- HENRY OctTa- HENRY Parish Priest. CHARLES CHARLES LONGUET The Life and Adventures of Edmund Kean, Tra- gedian. By J. Fitzgerald Molloy, of Peg of ‘ Life and Woffington,’ Author Adventures ‘Court Life Below Stairs,’ etc., etc. 2 vols., crown 8vo, cloth, $5.00. ‘*A really good biography of the gifted actor, whose life wasso fullof dramatic contrasts, and c me sorry an ending: a full, fa'r, carefully studied record, embellished, too,with sketches of the great little man’s contemporaries eminently readable and sympathetic.’’ World, to so The Originator of the Weather Bu- TCQAN, Life of Matthew Fontaine Maury, Nav} Navy. United States and Confederate States Author of ‘Physical Geography of the Sea, and Its Meteorology.’ Compiled by daughter, Diana Fontaine Maury Corbin. Svo, cloth, 33.75, Portrait. *,* The above books sent upon receipt of advertised price. full lists of all Bohn’s Libraries, will be SCRIBNER & WELFORD, LICHARD WILuraM | HvuGH | The Nation. * The respec table and sometimes excellent transiations my Bohn’s Library have done for Literature what rail roads have done for internal intercourse.’’— . Emer son. “I may sayin regard to allmanner of books, Bohn’s Publication Series is the usefullest thing I know.’’—Tho- mas Carlyle. ‘‘An important a of cheap literature, for which every living worker in this country who draws strength from the past has reason to be ”? Professor Henry Morley “The publishers are making constant additions, of an eminently acceptable character, to ‘Bohn’s Libraries.’ ”’ Atheneum, Bohn’s Libraries. CONTAINING STANDARD WORKS of EUROPEAN LITE- RATURE inthe ENGLISH LANGUAGE. With Dictionaries and other Books of Reference. Comprising in all translations from the French, Ger- man, Italian, Spanish, Scandinavian, Anglo- Saxon, Latin and Greek, 700 Volumes, $1.40 or $2 each, with exceptions. RECENT ADDITIONS. TOR HUGO’S DRAMATIC WORKS.! HER- NANI—RUY BLAS—THE KING’S DIVERSION. Translated by Mrs. Newton Crosland and F. L. Slous. $1.40. VIC | THE LETTERS AND WORKS OF LADY MARY | FAIRHOLT’ s ~ cosTU ME his | WORTLEY MONTAGU. son, Lord Wharncliffe ; tions derived from original MSS., and a Memoir by W. Moy Thomas. New Edition, Revised, in Two Vols., with Portraits. $4. **A most convenient reprint of Mr. Moy Thomas’s ad- mirable edition.’’—Athenwum. Edited by her great-grand- with additions and correc- Illustrative Notes, AN EGYPTIAN PRINCESS. An Historical Novel. By Georg Ebers. Translated by Emma S Buchheim, $1.40. ** The translator’s rendering is easy and elegant.’’— Morning Post. ADAM SMITH’S THE WEALTH OF NATIONS. An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of. Re- printed from the Sixth Edition. With an Introduc- tion by Ernest Belfort Bax. Two vols., $4. SENECA (L. ANN.EUS) ON BENEFITS. Ad- dressed to Abutius Liberalis. Translated by Au- brey Stewart, M.A. $1.40. ‘* This is a faithful rendering of the ‘ De Beneficiis’ in plain but Academic English.’’—St, James’s Gazette. RANKE’S HISTORY OF THE LATIN AND TEUTONIC NATIONS. Translated by P. A, Ash- worth. $1.40. HEINE’S TRAVEL-PICTURES. Translated by Francis Storr. $1.40. ‘* Mr. Storr’s brilliant version .”’—Academy, GOETHE'S CORRESPONDENCE WITH ZEL- TER. Selected, Translated, and Edited by A. D. Coleridge, M.A. $1.40. THE STUDENT’S HANDBOOK OF HISTORI- CAL GEOLOGY. By A, J. Jukes-Browne, B.A., F.G.S. $2.40. PAUSANIAS’S DESCRIPTION Translated by A. R. Shilleto, M.A. 2vols. #4. HOFFMANN’S TALES. The Serapion Brethren First Portion, Translated by Lieut.-Col. A. Ewing. $1.40. HAUFF'S TALES. The Caravan—The Sheik of Alexandria—The Innin the Spessart. Translated by S. Mendel. $1.40. GOLDSMITH’S WORKS. J.W.M. Gibbs. 5 vols. $7. OF GREECE. A New Edition. By A SELECTION. AWroREnUn, THE THOUGHTS OF L ADDISON’S WORKS. vols. $8. BAX’S MANUAL OF THE HISTORY OF PHILOSOPHY. $2. BOSWELL’S LIFE OF JOHNSON >" geeeared Edition, edited by Na ier). “=. $8. COLEKIDGE’S WORKS. M. AURELIUS. 6 vols. $8.4 “4 IN EN GLAND (Dillon). 2 vo LESSING’S L. AOKOON. Translated, LESSING’S DRAMATIC WORKS, 2 vols. Translated. MILTON’S PROSE WORKS. _ 5 vols. MOL —— S DRAMATIC WORKS, 2 vols. PEP ve S" DIARY. 4 vols, $8. PLUTARCH’S LIVES. 4 vols. (Stewart & Long’s trans.) $5.60, SPINOZA’S CHIEF WORKS. Translated. 2 vols. $4. $2. Translated. | STAUNTON’S CHESS HANDBOOK, mailed, if desired, Catalogues of our regular stock, also to those interested, BROADWAY, N. Y. 743-745 {Number 1214 “A WONDERFUL BOOK.” CITIZENS’ ATLAS OF AMERICAN POLIT CS. 1789-888, With a series of over 150 Colored Maps and Charts. By Fletcher W. Hewes, author of * Scribner's Statistical Atlas of the United States.’ Folio, $2.00. *“‘It is aseries of 150 or more colored charts, giving a survey of American political history as wonderful for its completeness as for its simplicity and convenience for common use. Without the labor of study or re search, every point of national progress for 100 years is presented to the eye and atonce understood. By the adoption of graphic methods of illustration, the great tariff problem of to-day finds in this work its simplest explanation and material for a ready understanding.”’ The Washington Post. Large HISTORY OF THE POLITIC TIES. **Theentire history of the political parties from 1776 1s88 is portrayed, and a more interesting study of the same matter has never been presented.’’ Brooklyn Times. POLITICAL AND NATIONAL PRO- GRESS. “It offers endless study to the curious, at the same time that it presents compactly and strikingly the salient features of our politic: il and national progress.’’—The Nation, RESUME OF AMERICAN POLITICS. **No work we can now recallis more complete as a resumé of American politics.’’— Wheeling Regis ter. FOR THE TARIFF STUDENT. ** The most comprehensive charts come to the assist apee of the student of the problem of. tariff, revenue, and wages, and he has at his command and before nim material which would fill vol umes if reduced to writing.’’—Pittsburgh Post. ECONOMIC STATISTICS. ** Tariff and w ages, wages ‘and cost of living, imports and exporis, the progress of the various econo mic industries, increase and decrease of revenue and percentage of duty, distribution of manufac- tures, strength of foreign population, the arca comparatively of the prevailing vote of the country in the whole vote—a thousand things which cannot be enumerate d here are to be found packed away in tinis ‘nutshell.’ and solu cidly that one readily learns the method of use. It is a wonderfully ingenious and compact piece of work that every man who ever reads at all should have and use.’’—Chicago Times. FOR EVERY VOTER. ‘AL PAR- ~ But the barest outline of the immense mass of use- ful knowledge, political and economical, impart ed in the most striking and convincing manner in the pages of this handsome Atlas can be given. If every voter in the United States should buy and diligently study it, the result of the Novem- ber election—whatever it may be—would not be due to the efforts of stump speakers and party pupers, but to the sincere convictions of the peo ple, founded upon reasons truly worthy of re spect.’’—-N. Y. Journal of Commerce. *,* For sale by all booksellers, or sent post- paid, upon receipt of price, by CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS, 743-745 Broadway, New York.
Page 5
NEW YORK, THURSDAY, TOR riy | he Mi m Saturday evening Tribune, one actually , BLAINE s speech at t P as publisl delivered by him and
the other papers. In substance, he long speech was the same as rit was show that high tariffs aused national tariffs have always brought on
rises and disaster. The har get ove was the followin iis History, describing the ¢ he low taritfl of 1846 Fhe Whig viet of 1848 wa y decisive to warrant any att there t n desire, to Change the t Taylor had been elected
scribing to a platform or ] to a specifi measure, and he fore In a position to resist appeals of the ordinary partisa moreover, the tariff of IM6 w abundant revenue, tlre ( ounteu was ina fl in time his Administration s Money be une Vel y abu i t i « S40, large enterprises e unde lation was prevalent, and for a na 4) : peta ne pure 852 th Democrats ha usputed ontrol of the Gover had gradually | ye a free - tz The principles embodied in 1 ta seemed for the time to be so entirely und approved that resistance to only ¢ one the neon] but mi My amone the f pie, OU il tion economists, and even amon furerstoa large xctent acquiescence that in 1556 a ( was not suggested or even hinted the
Week. so venere commercial crisis, he stated tha which came eleven years late1 was staved off by a numbe lental circumstances, such as in war, the discovery of g fornia, and the Crimean wat
these had exhausted their | uunteracting influences, t f the low tariff of 1846 b nt selves, and the tardy crisis of 18 itself. But why did not Mr. B hese things in that iptel now tells us were as Ww x then. Why did he suppress Supposing that Mr. Blaine had finishing his history and befor: What would situation of the this speech world and of pos spect of knowledge of the true ca crisis of 1857 Absolute dearth groping in darkness ant
rance; and all becaus then reveal what he knew f auses
The } I was y one } ( “1 \] v Was about three times as long as thi
Nation.
P We would ea I? . l’r. Storrs S bay . \ | ‘ i i as : s if the old se th 3. the | \ +} ‘ rent na tie ns¢ n WwW \ i. N z , P s the 1 sinew of \ Wet 1856 and 1866. wl ive el E slasm Which carried t rh \ i . ; i +) ~ created fk lose g i Su ‘ which inv rascals i f } ri ' F ¢ ¢ : shelte ie f R man o t Mr. James G. B ‘ is 4 (, l 11u ‘ t ‘ S 1Xes f I > say nothin ft own i \ i i Paterse empioyer ill in 4 } \y i i r IALLY . vo il ‘ = 3 : ; ¥ ther ’
Page 6
Brothers are certainly in fortunate position to plunder the American Consumers of linen ods, as they can transport labor from one place to the other as it may suit their own interest There ought to be somebody to look after them \s to the savings of the operatives in the two countries, however, we find a remarkable contradiction between the statement given above and the testimony f one member of the firm, Mr. Thomas Bar bour, before the Tariff Commission in 1882, viz. (vol. i, page 290) We hare eat many workers info this country, but we tind that, as a rule, they spend more money in America for rents and for food, thev dress far better, and become more extravagant in this country, and do not import da fay up any itore wages than they do in Treland.” So it appears that the Darbours are importers of contract labor, and that they tell different stories at different times about the savings of their employees. This Mr. Barbour wanted to have the duties on the kind of linen he produces in Ireland re- duced, and the duties on the kind he makes here raised from 85 per cent, to 50 per cent, aud valorem, The Tariff Commission listened to him with imperturbable gravity, but de- clined to follow his suggestions in either di- | rection, that American newspaper, the fron Era, which the Republican Committees and the Repub- lican press substituted in place of the English fron Eva as the authority for the following campaign lie, namely: We have been making search for ‘*The Cobden Club is trying to raise a large sum of money to be spent in furthering the free-trade propaganda in the United States. Lord Brassey has given £1,000, and others less, and the hat is going round.” No such paper as the /ron Era could be found in New York, Philadelphia, or Pitts- burgh. None of the large firms in the iron trade in New York knew of it. An inquiry addressed to the office of the Jron Age led to the disclosure that there was a weekly paper of this name published at Dover, N. J., but that it was not a trade journal. Pursuing the subject to Dover, N. J., we now learn ihat the Jron Fra of that place, when it pub- lished the Cobden Club item, credited it to the Knalish Tron Fra, and said that it, (the | | | Dover fron Fra) had found it, not in the } Baglsh Iron Era, Wut in another Ameri- | an paper credited to the aforesaid Eng- lish paper This is the paragraph of which the Philadelphia Press, the other day, when explaining the wrong credit, said that nobody disputed the accuracy of the item: the only wrong thing about it was that the | American and not the English paper of that ame was responsible for it. Now it ap pears that neither for it. The thing ! ow fever, of them was responsible was ‘Sin the it Was caught, like yel We have been favored with a copy of Mr. circular ‘‘ To the [t will hurber retracted i Wave-Earners of the United States.”’ Mr. T i. portion of the original circular and pro- KX. Thurber’s amesde be remembered that ised not to send out any } . MCSC: The Nation. * When the London Jinies thinks the best use they can make of Irishmen is to help them | emigrate to this country, and join the Demo cratic party, and thus help break down our protective tariff, that makes me think that our tariff is a great benetit to this country, and of course [ range myself on the side of a protect- ive tariff.” ion and apology for statement, Mr. Thur n the London 7iémes’s In making his retract sending out this false ber said that he had see quotation in a speech in Congress, that he had taken it to be genuine, and that he had considered it ‘‘ public property.” So far so What does he do next? He amends sends out a fresh good, the circular, and edition with these words: ‘When a London paper thinks the best use they can make of Irishinen is to help them to | emigrate to this country and join the Demo cratic party, and thus help break down our protective tariff, that makes me think that our tariff is a great benefit to (his country, and of | course, I range myself on the side of a protec- tive tariff.” This, we submit, is a worse offence than the | ” paper, Not the has acknowledged so “A London forsooth ! London paper ? Times ; Mr. Thurber much. He cannot pretend that he has found the new saying in a speech in Congress, or ¢ around, or that it is public property. On thecontrary, this is Mr. Thurber’s private first What one, voin property. Ife alone has any ownership in if. To Mr. Thurber, the [lome Market Club, the Hartford Courant, and all the other wor- London | shippers of British opinion, we present an- | other genuine quotation. It is from the well-known technical journal ALagineering, of the date of September 21. That contains an article on ‘‘Japan as a Market for British Manufactures,” us with the following brief reference: “From American competition in Japan we have not much to fear, always supposing our manufacturers do fail their wares and supply them of good quality. not paper | which disposes of | to advertise | | again, also very America, it is well known, owing to her | protective tariff, cannot compete with us in | iron and steel manufactures out of her own | country, and she is further handicapped in | | Japan, as regards all heavy goods, by higher | freights, since such goods coming from the Eastern manufacturing States require to go via the Suez Canal, owing to the heavy charges for railway carriage across the .Ame- rican continent.” ¢ th id signs of e go tle times is the the field of Col. Wentworth Higginson to run against Gen. N. P. Banks for Congress in the Fifth Massachusetts Dis trict. Banks has been United States Marshal for a good many years, and was allowed by sent Ad: aa 3efore his removal he expressed the One of uppearance in the pri ninistration to serve out his term. highest opinion of President Cl eveland; since his removal he has been denouncing the Administration in unmeasured terms, and is now the Republican candidate for Congress. What his real politics are we pre- But Republican war-horses, sume nobody knows, not even himself. he is one of the old who has to be provided for, no matter how more of them, | useless he may be, and sending him to Con cress is the eastest thine te do. Col. Higginson’: | Number 1214 that contain ne- think = y represents those who Legislature should the national body but competent legislators, and should not be used as an asylum for decayed poli IIe may not be elected, | stundard of it ticians, but in run ning he helps to raise the politi cal hose who capacity, and to organize mean that it shall be kept high The Sun says, speaking of the Democratic opposition to Hill: ‘*In the whoie historv of American politics there bas never before been a plot so remark able. In its inception and execution it is sim- ply a violent attack on the Democracy.” Come, now, was not your own “ plot” in i884 just as ‘‘ remarkable ” Did you not begin the canvass that year by declarine that ‘* Should the Convention determine to nomi- nate one of them (Cleveland or Flower}, we say emphatically that the candidate will stand a fair chance of carrying the State of New York, and that the best efforts of the Sua will be devoted to securing his entire success ‘ Sooner than join in making James G. Blaine President of the United States, we would quit work, burn up our pen, and leave to other and, perhaps, rasher heads the noble controversies of politics and the defence of popular self-gov- ernment”? after repudiate the Demo cratic candidate and begin to abuse him savagely, for reasons satisfactory to yourself, and to run a candidate of your own, con cerning whose strength in this city you made Did you not soon the very remarkable error of 129,659 in a total of 136,656? Was not the end of it all,as far as you were concerned, the loss of half your circulation, and the substitution therefor of mortgages to the amount of $235,000 or thereabouts, and the rise into power and wealth of your detested rival ‘‘ Judas,” and the immense amusement of the public over your sorry plight? Is not your ingratitude to us, who saved you last spring from committing the same follies remarkable, considering that by collaring you in time, when you were marching straight to destruction, and were prophesying publicly against Cleveland in the most fatuous manner, we prevented you from engaging in another open bolt ? It is true you are now trying to knife the ticket, and are privately predicting the defeat of the Democratic candidate; but this, bad as itis, will not hurt you as much as coming out publicly against him would do. It is your interest only, you will ob- serve, that we consider in this matter. Your support of Hill through good and evil re- port is, we confess, not remarkable at all; for when has there appeared in politics a rascal who did not call forth all the tender- ness of your nature, and for whom you were not ready to move Acheron ? Boston has become greatly stirred up over the question of Roman Catholic influence in the conduct of the publ provoking cause being the exclusion by the School Committee of a text-book which members of the Catholic Church considered objectionable because of a reference to that church, and which was admitted to be so by the Rev. Dr. Duryea, one of the most promi- nent Protestant clergymen of the city. The ic schools, the
Page 7
(~ _— ey —— Oct. 4, 1888] The Nation.
result is, for the first time since women were | entouragt which mav or may not 1 ls sel s given the right to vote in school elections in | an insinuation that the ex] ress is Massachusetts, a general disposition on the | bottom of the whole matter ' i part of women to avail themselves of the | B right of suffrage. The movement appears to It is now said that Prof. Geffcken, who | 1 1 Inst Ma : have begun with Protestant women, and the | has been arrested and is to be tried for pub yet tak first development of significance is the reve- | lishing the Emperor Frederick's diary, wi yu s lation that the Committee of One Hundred of | plead the Emperor Frederick's permission, | mat which proves conclusively that there have | but if he has it not, the danger is that he will | DP weve! it few been a large number of cases of perjury | be tried for defaming Frederick’s memory, | stantia statement that among the Catholic women, many of whom | in alleging that any such permission was ever | 1 \ f the crisis I x are charged with having appeared before the | siven. Bismarck’s resources in dealing with | fa tly Wi assessors, and taken oath to signatures which | e cudless were written by other persons. Not less eror to } ‘ i \ noteworthy is the statement in a Boston ( iris : I l
despatch that ‘‘ the two factions show much | Bismarck himself might be tried for reveal- | 1 revel re a * : more spite and bitterness than do the men ing state secrets, in saying that the Rmperer | i ; |} William for fe hin . ( | . ‘ | Pr nee si tlie l ~ | \ Towards the latter part of September, Mr. Ses - ‘ ; | revealed lie shi ¢ B. P. Hutchinson, a member of the Chicage he F ; a a 2 . was V to thie rench, seen to lia i } . \ Board of Trade, made a calculation that he | ; ; , , : : ; bilitv, but itis verv ba ! yone w | eould buy all the wheat in the Chicago e}) ae ‘ : ° . W ted prosecute Db rch ators, and hold it a few days. He ] ad t} atuvlats +} ret Bismuat Sieave t l ’ then made another calculation that) no ; ; k 4 uncerta ty it Li } s i ! i large amount of wheat could be brought yee ; “4.8 . : ch i I I I s t ’ to Chicago from the elevators of Mil- | ~ oieagi ‘ ‘ of this uncertainty on Ger 1 1x 11 waukee, Poledo, St. Louis ind = other 7 a : . P 1 ‘ . io ivht if be, rathiel i ! iting par iS i i . i storage points, and be Inspected and | z : . é ; ,; | highly civiliz a people as the Gern pando \ ) hoisted into store, and weighed and certi- ficated, before the close of business on Satur- . J day, September 30. Having made these cal- culations, he began to bet with his feilow- |, speaioulavie i | il } , ‘ | ions, likes, I slikes ld w . members that they could neither get wheat | } S “ : , ,, | much in peace and war, seems now an | : . to Chicago from other points, nor get hold | ; : | ; ' of any of the wheat that was actually in Chi- - : cago, during tl ie remainder of the month } — 1 | of September Naturally, he won all his | The granting of charters to thr Sov bets. Great efforts were made to run | reign Companies” by the British Crow: a express trains loaded with wheat from St. | in the last two months carries one back Louis and other points to Chicago within | the old days of the Elizal \ the time mentioned in the bets, but they | 1 polies, and revives S were generally failures. ‘This is the true ex- | ries of the East India Company, w planation of the corner in September wheat | up an empil fille W SS s at Chicago. fame. A charter has bet nany which is to 1 the vallev of the N
_ = oy : | in Africa nother to rule N Bort a , ; ; Phe Rundschan, which d the ex- | : age S70 : t ] \ } ‘ : ; i} and to another which is to take possessiot : me ; tracts from the diary of the Emperor Frede- | ‘ ; i ila : ‘ i i tn ( ~ \ rick, has got itself into a bad tix, for Bis- | oy Bea pS ofr 3 Par rates at a figrut t was a . : : : . | Africa, carved out of the territories t the : marck is after it with all the terrors at his f : nig . é | Sultan of Zanzibar They i fs ess command, Asan enemy, too, he does no . . . + 7 AUT, CCCSS \ \ > = x ‘ thing by halves. Everybody who has stood , . . ‘ } . } 7 I ist i ‘ ( ‘ in his way, except the late Emperor, he has a then LIS] ( s managed to ruin utterly. He is not con , °, ah Sar . . . then annex ' tent with driving a man from office: h } 3 . Gerinan Federal a
Page 8
THE ORDNANCE BLUNDER, Tue circular from Gen. Benet, Ordnance, which has just come to light, mak 4 is i] to divide the | ana ing arrangements arsenals between should think, Covernment armories the two parties, would, we furnish Secretary Endicott with a striking illustration of the danger of letting military | men issue circulars on political matters, with outsecing them. We have no doubt whatever that Gen. Benet thought, as explains, that when he issued he himself now this order he was doing something for civil-service reform, But the reason of this was, doubtless, that, like the great majority of military men, as well as politicians, he did not know what was meant by the phrase civil ser- vice reform, or what the legislation on that subject had been. There is nothing very surprising about thi Any one who had not had actual experience of it, woul be amazed by the ignorance of most men in political life about the demands of civil-ser and about the provisions mide to satisfy them by the Civil-Service Law An found in the fact } sles was appointed to the vice reformers and the regulations framed thereunder. illustration of this may be that when Gen. Sicl Civil-Service Commission in this State last year, he made known in an interview that he for thought examinations State law related entirely to literary subjects, places under the and one of the first things he was going to do was to make them ‘ practical.” The plan of dividing the offices equally between the parties is about as much civil service reform as a great many menin public life can ones have laid hold of the idea of pass exa grasp, Some of the more gifted minations to see if the man whom they want for it; but 1 truly compre- to putin the place is really fit very few indeed ré ally ane hend, and conceive asa contemporaneous pos sibility, the awarding of places in the public service by open competition without regard to politics. They hear talk about this from professors and literary men, as they hear talk about Kant’s categorical imperative, but that to carry it D. I888, is some- any honest effort is being made out in the United States, A. thing they are as yet mentally incapable of believing. We have little doubt that Gen. Be net belongs to this class, and that he really thoucht that stride inadvance when he prepared to divide the different the arsenals gradually between Democrats and he was making an immense force in. the grades in Republicans; and we believe it all the more of of his rule to “women and Nobody but a even if rather because the application children.” conscientious, well-meaning, stupid, body would have thought of select- ing women and children for employment in arsenals according to their political opi- Gen. Benet, we have no doubt, is a but he is a dreadful man nions. first-rate artillerist, for circulars The ; comfort to the Republicans, and it is un far extract the Jron government circular is apparently giving great valuable from the Era, But in both doubtedly for them a more than a forged Times of thing or rood London tlie friends Chief of the offices in the The Nation. parties, and in all parts of the country, will note with unmixed pleasure the fuss they are making over it. When a party which for twenty-five years rigidly confined all the of fices of the Government to its own members, professes to be shocked by a clumsy attempt of its opponents to divide the offices equally between both parties in one department of the Government, it shows that, in spite of all ob stacles, the good time, in which political strife will rage wholly over better things than small places, is rapidly approaching. Every reproach hurled at the Presi dent for his shortcomings in the use of patronage, every ‘‘ scandal” made by bad appointments or wrongful dismissals, or foolish circulars or orders,shows that the seed has not fallen on stony ground, and tbat a return to the old stateof things is impossible. Let those who are disposs d to be disheartened for General by the smaliness of progress recollect moment that a if issued in 1868 or circular like 1872 one Benet’s, , would ac tually have been considered a ridiculous con cession to the Opposition, and that the See- retary of War would have been called on to reprimand him, not for proposing to divide the arsenals between the two parties, but for letting a single Democrat, man, woman, or child, inside the gates. At that time Gen. Benet would have been called a traitor to his party : he is now de- nounced as an Inhuman monster and crite. We do not know which he would find it harder to bear; but those who accuse him hypo of ‘‘making war on women and children ” confess by implication that the times have changed for the better, and that the battle of reform is really won. COMMON THINGS BECOME SACRED, HOW Any student who wants to understand how institutions such as monarchy or aristocracy acquired in earlier times a sacred character, and became hedged witha sort of divinity, so that it was considered impious to examine their origin, or question their claims on hu- has only to read careful- party were man reverence, ly the history of and of the tariff. brought for the first time face to with the curious fact that a very large body of Americans were possessed by the idea that the Republican party was entitled by moral right to remain in possession of the Republican In 1884 we face the Government for an unlimited period. We remember hearing one man of promi- nence lay it down that President Arthur to the Adminis- to a successor unless that it safe Clergymen were hand = ovet Democratic ought not tration was entirely satisfied was he and expedient to do so, hunted out of their parishes, workingmen lest their their custom, gagements cancelled, on this same assump- tion that the Republican party had, with out refercnce to the quality of its mana- character, which made against it the sign of moral obli- quity. Attempts to show that a party was but a means to an end, that it was sure in storekeepers their en- employment, and and lecturers had sacrosanct gers, a voting + [Number 121 the long run to outlive its usefulness, that human societies had to change their insti- their changed, and that contrivances, such govern- questioning and tutions as needs all human ments, needed periodical as overhauling, were resented as sophistries di- rected against American peace and order. The Democrats were painted as political de- vils, who would revel in the ruin of the pub lic credit, the plunder of the Treasury, and the destruction of the national industries, One has only to read the defences of the tariff now frequently put fo.th to see how successful it also has been in twenty five years in becoming sacred. 1860 to 1865 it was treated as a purely human con- From trivance for raising a very large revenue, After that it began rapidly to take on the sac- rosanct character—that is, to become some- thing like the flag, ‘* by angel hands to valor vivep,” or like one’s aged mother—which it irreverent, to discuss, \t did it only laid himself open to the charge was unpatriotic, v7. e., or even investigate. first a man who of impropriety or profanity, that is, of something objectionable because it shocked the rest of the company. Professors at college who taught free trade began to be looked on with suspicion, as Uni- tarians used to be in the beginning of the Fathers whose talked trade began to feeling that the boys were keeping bad company sons free century. have an uneasy and getting into evil ways. The Cobden Club, which prominent politicians like Gen, Garfield joined without hesitation 1865 and 1870, economi- cal society named in honor ot a great phi between as an lanthropist, between 1870 and 1880 took on the air of a society of evil disposed per- sons, raising immense sums of money for disreputable purpeses, such as the ruin manufacturing families, the colleges, and of American corruption of young men at the hiring of adventurers to propagate false- The pro- cess of sanctification was so rapid, in fact, hoods in peaceful communities. that by 1880 men shrank from the charge of belonging to the Cobden Club as they would shrink from the charge of frequenting a faro-bank or dealing in lottery policies, The reaction against such superstition, which, like the reaction against the witch- craft delusion, is sure to in all ci- vilized communities, has set since 1884 undoubtedly. That year saw it at its height. The removal of the dread of the Democratic party—which pursued so many come in people’s lives—stripped the sacerdotal robes off the Republican managers, and prepar- ed the way for the purely secular treat- ment of the tariff as a device for raising money. People have begun to examine it, just as they examine their own in- come and expenditure, in a thoroughly ra- tionalistic way. numerous proofs of the religious reverence But one still comes across with which it is regarded in some cir- cles, especially by those who profit by it. We have before us the refusal of a country editor to print even as an adver- tisement any criticisms of it in his pa- per. The worthy man shrinks from such things as he would shrink from the
Page 9
Oct. 4, 1888] The Nation. publication of an immoral tale or one of str} rt “Bob” Ingersoll’s controversial lectures 2 ¥ He does not know the mischief he may | ?°0" : do by breaking down the pepular reve Bread He asks himself, What C become of the rence for the tariff. would Church and what a of the home if the tariff were lowered All of these industries Where would the domestic affections be impered , less by pr under a 42.78 per cent. duty What is the | are somewhat advanced, but only “of state of religion and morality in countries | as the public is ec} W eres where wool is free? Is it not true that in | advances which these . Ss mak free-trade countries profane swearing is dis- | others and to t Government wl gracefully prevalent and chastity little more | buy their raw materials and machinery thananame’? The Turks have lit a This burden must not be cour i tw tariff, and what is the result Look into the If thissurvey becontinued throuch t harems, and see the degradation of their | tire st of inufactures, it comes women. He thinks too much attention is | rent that only about two tifths given to the relation of the tariff | sh l issed ont ! to wages and profits, too little to its | rather than am ‘ the pavers, of relation to the fundamental human virtues. | tive taxes The agg ' buet He « a man understand the state of mind of | tl that corrupting in easy el irse | binations, ar n spite of the use of imnot who thinks there s nothing hood of 82 essentially with foreign dealers, or that you can have | ed machinery and the ex steel rails cheap and yet love your neighbor | which Government-aided 1 | s! or your country. The good man tit prices of the | ‘ over this by and by, but we must be pa t | much more than half as h the with him. is the tariff duties make pos It w THE COST OF THE PRESENT T.A1 F} A) CORRESPONDENT, referring to th st But here an : of protection to the taxpayers of the | ed Phi nsumers of se protected United States, wants to know what tle ire often the manufacturers themselves, 1 present tariff costs, both in the amount of | finished pl ict of or factory is revenue collected and in the enhanced pric miuteria inothet l of protected goods produced at home tries pay er ® A rhe question 1s not an easy one to answer. | changed raw 1 rials The amount of revenue collected from du nearly two-thirds of these is ties on imports it is, of course, easy to ascer protection Whether paid 1 t ty tain. For the last fiseal year it Was it | ment o I ! S . $228, 000,000, As to the other sum—the extra burden upon the cons amount paid to the producers of protected | though in a broad way it is goods—there have been gross exaggerations prosperity of the country I t = on both sides, and any estimate must be | 000,000 previously ind y > largely a matter of conjecture. Some per- | 000 must therefore be s sons have gone so far as to assume tf lo the result thus f all manufacturers are protected, and that th idded because of the tariffs prices of the protected articles are i ris ] tax the full extent of the duties. It is worth sugar industrv of Louis while to notice, therefore, that the two ] { &6 OOO,COU ay I na s ing manufacturing industries of the country | protect ** st are absolutely unprotected. The census of | struction of our forests at rage O 1880 placed the product of the flouring and | farmers to use as shee] stures land W grist mills at $505,000,000, and that of the | is worth sixty dollars slaughtering and meat-packing (not includ- | raising—thes« ing retail butchering) estavlishments atin the increas cost f 4 pr $303,000,000. The iron and steel lus- | of the w en and lu : .e WN try ranked third, with $296,000 O00 a total product of | to be In the two former industries | mor J stof 1 7, tice sret the protective system does cause a slig! l vance in prices, since it makes deare he | Gov plant used, and often prevents small est $ | S lishments from purchasing needed ma however, is valent to! total S chinery. Yet the advance in price thus) mu pal taxat caused is inconsiderable; and in making estimates, these exporting industries, whose ther ye tax t s development is hampered by protection, ! 1 clusses long rather among the taxpayers than among I cons the tax. gatherers. bly If we descend to the minor industries, and | tration of this is to be found in the tariff take in alphabetical order all thos ng pper ore, w over 1,000 establishments, we find 1 lustry, having its t Bost lowing list tin vir it of s { mix " \ \ I . Ww many \ ‘ \ ' . i : i y WW '\ ‘ _ . ’ \ \ \\ \ ~ v _ ~ ce SA i \ < i 3 i : : < X yr ‘ 1 ; { ¥ \ ta , Then the f ~ t Te — Tr a 8 shv ofl WOIS ¢ rred 1 | 4? Vaile v6 r si ‘ something - utters of the re i democrat! s}) ul, acquired a f which it still w = , great many people } shar rcoumstance that ha is from the nightmare of s the silver craze that started up be in to repent of ’ na ‘TY hack t ind come back to
‘ \ \ ( irs ‘ i ‘ \ eX were , - f ¢ y Seas) 1 { \“ weal a ‘ avency i scuttled green ned with ce P emTmniy i-stained ( ienta red The back gave ct Gold oreign and ears to the he Iped to gold drains the its dastard We all about
Page 10
264 remember how Wall Street, and the gold bugs, and the bondholders, and the na- tional banks have been berated and _ scoff- ed at as a privileged class, as an oli- garchy, as bloodsuckers, vampires, etc., ete. This kind of talk is. still issu- ing from the mouth of Senator Stewart of Nevada, and occasionally, but not so much as formerly, from that of Senator Beck of Kentucky. The accusation has been perpetually brought against the gold bugs that they were intentionally doing some injury to silver. Striking down silver and disinheriting silver have been the crimes laid to their charge from year to year, with the intention, of course, of unduly exalting gold and conferring upon that metal the birthright belonging to its twin brother or sister. Naturally, sympathies are aroused for the ill-used metal, the disinherited mem- ber of the family. 30th of these circumstances have been ad- ventitious and both misleading, but they have laid the ghost of the balance of trade pretty effectually. Nobody fears gold ex- portation now; and since nobody fears it, no- body talks about it. We presume that this is the reason why Mr. Baker has dropped gold out of the list of avail- able spooks, and has substituted in place of it ‘‘our stored-up wealth.” ‘* What is a balance of trade?” asks Mr. Baker. ‘‘ It is the difference between what a nation sells and what she buys. If she sells more than she buys, the balance is in her favor, and it adds to her stored-up wealth. If she buys more than she sells, the balance is against her and has to be paid for out of her stored-up wealth.” No = defini tion of stored-up wealth is given by Mr. Baker. There are very few forms of wealth that will bear storing up for any considera- ble time. Grain, cotton, provisions, and the bulk of the commodities which are accepted in exchange for other commodities very soon deteriorate on storage. The stored-up wealth of the country consists almost wholly of the instruments of reproduction and transporta- tion, including buildings and other improve- ments on land. Of course, gold is included in the list of stored-up wealth, but we judge that Mr. Baker did not have this in his mind when he used the phrase. What he meant to say, apparently, was that if a nation buys more than it sells, the balance has to be paid out of her instruments of reproduction and trans- portation—not out of the products thereof, but by handing over the instruments them- selves to foreigners. Looking at the subject in this light, we are amazed at the financial crisis impending over the British Empire. Usually the balance-of-trade philosopher in this country shuns the trade statistics of Great Britain because they show an enormous balance of trade against that country every year, and this fact does not tally with the common be- lief that England is a creditor nation towards the world in general, while the balance-of-trade theory requires us to believe that, since her imports exceed her exports, she ought to bea debtor nation. But Mr. Baker does not dodge the English statistics at all. On the . The Nation. illustration available to sustain his position. IIe shows in tabular form that British imports have exceeded British exports regularly every year from 1854 to the pre- sent time, and that the balance of trade against England now reaches the enormous sum of $11,892,633,118. This, he says, ‘* teaches a highly significant lesson.” What does it teach?) Why, that England owes to other countries a sum equal perhaps to her entire stored-up wealth in the form of ma- chinery, buildings, railroads, and canals, for Mr. Baker says that the trade statistics fall far short of showing the real balance of trade against her, since $250,000,000 per year of her exports are those of foreign and colonial produce, which should be added to the balance against her. So here we have a few billions more or less of British indebt- edness to other countries to be added to the large total already mentioned. That Mr. Baker is not thinking about a ‘‘drain of gold” is evident from the fact that Great Britain’s debt, according to his estimate, is more than double the entire amount of gold in the world, as estimated by good judges, including that used for purposes of orna- ment. Weighed down with such a load of debt, Mr. Baker does not wonder that Great Bri tain would like to get this country into the same predicament as herself. ‘‘ What,’’ he asks, ‘‘ could be more natural than that Ene- land should desire to unload a part of her crushing adverse balance of trade upon the shoulders of the United States? And this,” he continues, ‘‘ is precisely what the scheme of the Chairman of our American Ways and Means Committee would accomplish.”” What will become of Great Britain when the other nations call on her for payment, or what will become of them if she fails to pay promptly, Mr. Baker does not tell us. Considering that the other nations have no collateral se- curity, we should say that their position was rather the worse of the two. Is it not proba- ble that England maintains her navy in order to resist the collection of this debt? Our explanation of the balance of trade is, that a nation is enriched by the goods that she receives rather than by what she parts with. This theory harmonizes with the prevailing conception, that Great Britain is a creditor instead of a debtor nation. It also enables us to cherish the opinion that the eleven or twelve billions of dollars of ad- verse balance of trade that have been piled against her in the trade returns of the past thirty-five years, represent a gain to her rather than a loss. “THE WAGES RACKET.” Weare in receipt of a large number of inqui- ries on thesubject of wages, most of which it is What is the present rate of wages in Belgium ” What was the rate of wages in Germany under the free-trade policy 2? What was the rate of wages in the United States before the war? What is the comparative rate of wages in this country and in Aus- tralia? We desire to do evervthing in impossible to answer, as for example: contrary, he welcomes them asthe aptest | our power to satisfy seekers after truth [Number 1214 We look upon the inquiries themselves as very hopeful signs of the awakening of the people to the momentous problem that will, for some years to come, constitute the chief issue in our national politics. But in order to give any satisfactory answer to any ques- tion, we must first know what is the basis of the inquiry and what the answer signifies, “The rate of wages.” What wages? Wages are of every kind and degree, from those of the street scavenger to those of the skilled weaver who can produce the Lord’s Prayer on a silk handkerchief; from the stone-breaker on the public highway to the electrical engineer; from the boy who carries sheaves in the wheat field to the gold-beater who produces leaves of metal the 367,000th of an inch in thickness. Evidently ‘ the rate of wages’ is as impalpable as the Milky Way. But, it may be replicd, we mean the ave rage rate of wages. There is no average rate of wages. Professor Richmond Smith, without any party bias,and with only a scien- tific intent, has proved, in a series of articles in the Political Science Quarterly, that the current tables, compiled and published by the grandmothers of statistics in this coun- try as average rates of wages, are quite delusive. What is the average rate of wages of three boys, four girls, twenty-five women and seventy-five men, one foreman and two assistant foremen, all working at different trades ? The usual way to determine the ave- rage rate is to add up the total weekly wages of all and divide the sum by the number of persons. But what does this tell us? Mere. ly that if the whole sum were thus divided, each person would get a wage quite different from what he does get. reached this useless result, we need to know But when we have how many hours the wage-earners work, and how steady their employmentis, and whether the unsteadiness of employment is due to their own choice or to the slackness of trade. In order to reach any useful result, we need to know especially what is the efficiency of labor, that is, what any given unit of labor produces. In India, for example, grass is cut with a pocket-knife by men squatting on their haunches, and carrying a jute bag on their shoulders in which they put the hay crop by handfuls. In America, it is cut by a hay harvester drawn by horses, the driver sitting on a comfortable seat. In Italy, ploughing is done by relays of men and women using wooden mattocks. In England, it is done by gang-ploughs run by steam or electricity. An American work- man turns out 33 per cent. more shoes with a given machine than an English workman using the same machine. Whiat can the rate of wages do for us in such cases towards the solution of any economical problem? Yet such cases are as multifarious as tants of the earth. Again, the rate of wages is different in different parts of the same country. This variation happens in the same trades. The variation will sometimes run as high as 100 per cent. Mr. John Jarrett testified before a committee of Congress, in 1883, that the wages in Western rolling mills was from 50 the inhabi per cent, to 200 per cent. higher than in the
Page 11
The Nation.
Bethlehem [Tron Wo of Pe ! l if in almost every mind cay We will quote his exact words clear and unprejudiced reasoning N . . } r mnt . a ar ‘¥ ‘Now I want to at t W S Chus, f CXaAMpte resp ' paid in that concern were in some insta 3M some time since of 4 pr £ £950 by the R ; per cent. less than those paid in the W mn ee aia ae : 1} ¢ } forn oO thy} eit r ¢ hest essay mills. [will ge further: I will sav, for in rm Ciuo of this city t us *. stance, that in 1SS2 there was at least over dou the injurious influences of the existing taritl t ble the amount paid in Western mills for rol in } ' , ; +} } : } on the local Industries of any distric $ ~ ing hands that was paid in that mill, perhaps nearly three times as niuch ” i Mr. Jarrett is a well - known hich - tariff : : spouter. Mr. Blaine is another, and he told so us, in his famous cotton-goods report, that a the wages of cotfon-spinnersin Massachusetts f were higher than in the other New England eo States and their hours of work shorter. ? Now, we ask again, what can the ‘ rate of wages” tell us, even if we couid resolve that Milky Way and bring it into our arith metical tables’ Nothing at all Fake the m comparative rates of wages that are now | bait) ¢ flooding the country from Washington undet ' e +9 ’ \ ° r Ni the frank of ‘‘ Bill” Chandler Here isa " specimen Enelan vu. 8 Cotton-mill bands ‘ 4 SLT. Both figures are wrong, as Mr. Blaine | , } . ; é : iV, COM mMon-sens prop Ss and ( proved tous In the report already referred r tions, not lacking in wi ind ha yr W i to But suppose they were richt Would é . ‘ ri antes oo . i strong old-schoo P T Lril¢ i\ s they tell us how much cloth $4.60 in wages ; : “f : - - | titled ‘ Tariff Chestnuts, or, Prepared | yroduces in England at vy much in the ; ; ; ” 1 ns for an Over-fed but still Hungry Public,’ by United States Would the nit AS HOTS ch cue Melee. und Reekia 31 ae lav paid to the ] Tndinn. oy = eas ies bar da maid to the East Indi : itte ' ily I i t i - in i l Boston As a speci! f its ‘ convince us that the American horse-mower , ‘ I nis 2 a if i ti ve uote the f } wing fr S eX . getting $1.50, could never compete with | o¢ « What constitutes Prot Aino. 1. | Pahl raStl ua Ss , ’ him in the hay market? A few years agoan ’ _f . can Industries American citizen went to Brazil to restore a ruined sugar plantation, The first thing he * Protection to American industries is not ze — , ; x paid by reigners, ey y A ‘ t did was to double the rations of the hands. | cans. [f vou thin vw ’ ‘ They had been half starved, and were in a} try that you are t t ‘ condition of bodily weakness and menta Bee pitt ie he Ns mutiny. The result of doubling the pay was 1 1 will open a vy Ame? } rr ry ’ eel t ) to more than double the crop The planta } Ra I. \ i i SA ‘ sof Ss ( y rn tion was restored and became profitable to its t m s450 a vear and allow then favs owner. You <a} fohowing isan ar t u una nun rs {t ea } There are signs th le Wage ket be taxed has nearly run its course, and t! W ng 0 ; ¢ men are beginning to see its hollowness and | ! oa ce we gE : ; tuke this inconsequential character. We d tw . 7 “ae + , : I gt : ther it will hold out thirty days re! In the new industry tw : il t | ved t j ves work. Sixty sand rs f \ THE GREAT AWA VING neration t y severe mental s Iw , THE greatest drawback to t ff reform in native Americans, ar a i . years gone by has been the inability to int pl “ spf ce “1 rest the masses in the subject r law of I wil ntinue. and I w : : . . 1: ‘Ss } . } e the vy ras of ¢ inertia, or indisposition to change, isas great | Teduce the wag } and significant in the mental or intellectual rv. Poland. or Italy t sac dial ve , world as it is in the material. Something has | There shall be 1 shut vn,’ no strikes, and | unw tar | — + . 1 : i ve : iwree got to take place in both cases, or the tet ; ; : : A , 84 nasiu Ss} i dency of things will be to remain as they at agree to find politicians w w nt t and in the case of the tariff i litv, this | © pebina , ss something did not occur in suf? nt force will refer to this ‘mvs : ; until the bold and clear appeal which President ns absoiuteiy upon t ~ s a Cleveland made to the Amer | N | Haven't + ' - < December last, comm led tue [ s ‘ ty for - t ) office, universal attentior Simultar isly gle “2 : _— . ; ice, ul I I i ok ernie ace ‘ Dent ‘ . popular interest was excited, Every Lay has industries Is a pronit tot ¥ and st ‘ Slace seen 1t Widen and deepen, and now 7 one of its most striking features is the num Passibly sor n read } mav? ber of elaborate investigations which indivi vard this illustratior f Mr. Brickett duals in different portions of the country are | though a happy or aS 1 ss some making in respect to the claims of the pr what extravagant; but, if so, they would be | - tectionists for a longer continuance of high | mistaken. for within a few davs one Charles duties, and the almost uniformly iverse | Duffy, in a letter to the Chit Inter-O , au ave land judgment which such
es to the snub ! the title of t ar - a = — " 7 | are nas put the case much more forcibiv and | audie
is Mr. B . | $
~— ~ ‘ s s | ‘ . x ely ‘ ‘ ~ < mY ~ w“ } N a : i . ‘ i that vear \ s ‘ a ie ‘ - 4 il Ss 3 i é are r the new = on t : - tr ‘ ils i a i i Ys with lle t t if on this t 1 vithin a « t irtes vears ag I scussed the] t! tlied Imperial Fede it ti inion (the reat debating x 1), the question was looked upon Not only was this true of under rd, but of many men in public i then talked upon the subject there was one found who had it yi at ill All this has been ‘, ast few years. J. R. Seeley, Wn Cambridge Professor of His ted a brilliant series of univer ect, and these, publish he *‘ Expansion of Eng have found an immense and sympathetic throughout the English-speaking
Page 12
266 world. Goldwin Smith, the no less brilliant, but somewhat pessimistic, Oxford Professor of as his home, employed in History, who has chosen Canada finds his pen pretty constantly trying to throw cold water upon which threatens to blaze up into a national en- thusiasm, but which is opposed to certain pet political dogmas of his own invention. For some time the reproach most commonly made by Mr. Smith and others against the ad- vocates of a more complete national unity was, that they were mere theorists, that practical public men held the idea at arm’slength This reproach no longer exists. Probably one of the most practical, shrewd, and business-like men that the House of Commons has known for some years was the late W. E Forster. To the problem of Imperial Federation he devoted much of his later thought, and he had publicly announced that his chiet object in life was to do all he could to forward the idea. Lord Rosebery, whose past career and present pres- tige clearly mark him out as a possible Pre- mier of England, a man of tried caution and approved judgment, has deliberately accepted for himself the leadership of the movement since Mr. Forster’s death; and though he leads the way too slowly to satisfy some, yet he loses no opportunity of pressing the idea upon his countrymen as one of the first importance both for those at home and those abroad. As Presi- dent of the Federation League, he lately, by a special circular, directed the attention of the bishops present at the Lambeth Conference from every part of the British world to the na- tional importance of the subject, particularly in its bearing upon the great missionary enter- prises of British Christians. With a like ad- dress he endeavored to enlist the sympathy of the members of the Pan-Presbyterian Council in session at London. In both cases the appeal met, I believe, with satisfactory Lord Rosebery points out that the object of the League is to secure ‘‘ the closest possible union of the interests ruled by the: British Crown, consistent with that national free development which is the birthright of British subjects all over the world—-the closest union in sympathy, in external action, and in defence.” He goes on to say that, ‘‘so far as the human intellect can discern, there is nothing in the affairs of this world which is so likely to realize that ‘peace and good-will towards men’ which it is the object of the Church to establish, as the voluntary entrance of the people of this great Empire into a federation for the defence of common interests, the maintenance of common rights, and the fulfilment of those responsibili- ties which have ever been held by the British race to be attached to the possession of power.” a movement res} onse, In expressions such as these, I believe that Lord Rosebery is only reflecting sentiments which are fast becoming a fixed idea in the British mind, or, at least, in the mind of that section of the British people which thinks. The idea is not monopolized by any party or any set of politicians, and its warmest advocates are drawn in about equal numbers from Libe- rals and Conservatives alike. Many thinkers believe that no finality can ever be looked for on such a question as Irish Home Rule until it is dealt with on a broad national basis, when all the English-speaking parts of the Empire shall be placed on a similar footing, and when a definite line of separation shall be fixed between matters of local and matters of imperial in- terest. Two utterances upon this aspect of the question have attracted a good deal of atten- tion within the past few weeks. In Canada Archbishop O’Brien of Halifax, speaking at a meeting of the Imperial Federation League, took the ground that the objects of the League The Nation. did not clash with the aspirations of the Home tule party, but that Home Rule would have its best opportunity in a wisely federated Empire. ‘“We hope to see,” he said, ‘Seach colony and state of this Empire brought together and knitted into one grand whole, in which indi- viduality will not be swallowed up in union, but unity secured and perfected by the guaran- teed autonomy of each unit.” The late corre- spondence between Mr. Rhodes and Mr. Par- nell touched upon the same point, Mr. Rhodes, an influential British subject from South Africa, pointed out to Mr. Parnell that he and many others, while sympathizing with the idea of Home Rule, could not, as ardent supporters of Imperial Federation, also support a measure which, like Mr. Gladstone’s Home Rule Bill, did away with Irish representation at West- This provision, he claimed, looked to disintegration rather than federation. Mr. Parnell at once replied that he bad regarded the clause referred to asa great defect in Mr. Gladstone's bill, and affirmed that Home Rule, as heunderstood it, was not at variance with the aims of the Federation League. A sub- scription of ten thousand pounds to the Irish fund by Mr. Rhodes was the outcome of this declaration of Mr. Parnell. These facts may serve as illustrations of the dritt of the national thought. That Government has begun to feel the strength of the movement is shown by the significant circumstance that last year, at the suggestion of the Federation League, Lord Salisbury was induced to summon a con- ference of officially appointed delegates from all the great colonies to consult and advise upon questions of common interest. Ten or fifteen years ago such a step would have been looked minster. upon by an English statesman as absurd: now it seems but a natural recognition of the widen- ing of the national horizon. Thefact that such a conference could, without special difficuity, be called in London, was itself a striking proof that space is not now a sericus hindrance to effective national unity. Population goes on increasing in Britain with surprising rapidity. The addition each year is estimated at about 400,000. The accumulating which this implies gives a strong impulse to political thought. Only a few weeks ago an influential deputation waited upon the Premier, and urged the advisability of giving direct financial support to a large scheme of State-aided emigration to the colo- nies, supporting their views by the argument that such astep would serve the double pur- pose of relieving pressure at home and strength- ening the Empire in its outlying parts. While public aid is thus invoked, private philan- thropy is working on parallel lines, and va- rious religious and benevolent bodies are en- gaged in the work of selecting good emigrants, and assisting them to find better homes in Canada, Australia, or South Africa. The con- ditions under which colonization of this kind is carried on, tends to strengthen greatly the sense of national unity. The points to which I have referred are only a few of the many indications that are visible here in England of the rapidly gathering strength of the Federation movement It would never have gone so far, however, unless there had been a responsive or, indeed, a pre- liminary movement in the colonies. I think that the most critical or hostile observer would be forced to admit that at present, throughout the Empire, the tendency is decisively towards closer union of the various parts, rather than disintegration. It is probably the largest question now coming up within the domain of peaceful political development. GEORGE R. PaRKIN. social pressure [Number 1214 IN THE FOOTSTEPS OF DANTE. RAVENNA, July 31, 188s, HERE, in face of Dante’s tomb, it is per- haps allowable to regret that Ampére’s charm- ing ‘ Voyage Dantesque’ is after all so imper- fect, and that no one has had the courage to supply what is lacking in that, and still less to write another book on the same theme from a somewhat different point of view. Italy is better known to outsiders than it was when Ampére wrote; but there are many places where Dante stayed which are seldom visited by the traveller, and about the aspect of which at the time when Dante lived the reader of the ‘Commedia’ knows next to nothing. Yet Dante seldom mentioned a place, and never spoke of one in the way of description or com- parison, unless he had himself seen it and it had left a strong impression on his mind, Among the multitude of commentators few have ilustrated the great poem, either as re- gards persons or places, by a careful study of local history. Blanc, in his well-known dic- tionary, and even Don Giacomo Poletto, in his more ambitious ‘ Dizionario Dantesco,’ of which the seventh and concluding volume has recent- ly been published, often give no further infor- ’ mation about a person or a place than is found in Dante’s own words, turned by them into prose. Many of the allusions of the poet can- not be properly appreciated until the family history of each of the men praised or abused by Dante is thoroughly understood, and the re lations of these men to each other and to Dante have been carefully studied. Owing to the migrations of families, the Guelphs and Ghibel- lines of the different Italian cities seem con- nected with one another in such unexpected ways that it requires a considerable knowledge of old chronicles and of more modern compila- tions to disentangle the knot. A study of this kind has been undertaken by Isidoro del Lungo of Florence, who has long occupied himself with that epoch, in a book just published called ‘Dante ne’ tempi di Dante.’ But, in order to be thorough, the author has been obliged to restrict himself to very few subjects, and treats only of the new people in Florence in Dante’s times— William of Durfort and Campaldino; a family of Pisan Guelphs in Dante’s time; the relations of Dante to the house of Este; and his dispute with Forese Donati. A month’s stay on the slopes of the Apen- nines, on the edge of the Romagna, interested me in several of the old castles and towns men- tioned by Dante; and drives through the country, and occasional visits to the libraries of Forli, Faenza and Ravenna, convinced me that much might still be done to elucidate the poet’s invective against the Romagna, in the fourteenth canto of the ‘ Purgatorio,’ as well as to throw light on other passages. According to Balbo, Dante probably went from Arezzo to Forli in the autumn of 1302. He must either have gone up the valley of the Arno and then crossed the mountains with great difficulty, or he must have gone back to- wards Florence as far as Pontassieve and taken the well-known road through the pass which is now traversed by the diligence. The road to Faenza, almost parallel to this, is not known to have existed until a century later. At all events, he stopped, apparently for more than a day, in the monastery of San Benedetto, situ- ated on a high hill, a little below the high pass where several small valleys come together, and the streams which flow through them combine and form what is now called the River Mon- tone, and was apparently then known as the Acquacheta, What is now the largest and
Page 13
Oct. 4, 1888] The Nation.
evidently the main stream is now called the | now except a small chur the Montone above this junction, even to its sou hill: the villa which i i i San At San Benedetto it receives from the right | in Alpibus, partly grouped about the Badia the Troncalossa; then a few steps further on | and partly in the valley below. TI ef
the left, the Acquacheta; and half a mile fur- | street leading up to th ur is pamed Via ther down on the right, the Caprile. Increased | Dant by other brooks, it is a stream of considerable As w lescend tl va th id size at Castrocaro, especla ly In the spru or Mnetimes ciose to the Water, at others % autumn, and in summer immediately after | Sharp turns at the edge of precipices bundreds rain. Just before reaching Forli it is joined f feet above, we see on the other side twee! ! 4 by the Ronco, a stream of nearly equal size, | Port ind Rocea San Cascia t flowing down the parallel valley on the right lt old castie of Ca 4 home of that which, in distinction from the Acquacheta.was house e so powerful, at Forli, of w ? known inthe Middle Ages as the Acquaviva | member is praised by Dante the * Purgat r Formerly the river again divided, and embraced | while 1 remainder are istigated because Forli between its two arms, both of which fall | they were of opposite parties to Dante and his into the sea, and often caused great danger by | { nds, and one of t Fuleiert i Ca the severity and frequency of its freshets Phe | isin power at I ret This castle was be name Montone—the ram—is variously explain- | s doin the autumn « : y ( i ed: by some, on account of the two horns or | Novello, then Podest& in Faenza for I branches of the river; by others, from tl | savage frequency with which it butted against | in order to wrest this post f t xiles the walls of Forli. The ancients knew on f and free t nei ing peasants a su { ( the two arms running into the sea—and _ possi tt t toel roads i l bly even both—as the Vitis, Vitius, or Utens. | C@stle RB and Gu Ps . , pee : ; | lords of t ind with t , S The rage of the river has since been appeased, 1 and SOO de rs: the Senate of B Na omha. But we now fav te su . , 3 t f Forli, w ent the agreed that, in all probability, the aspect t ibitant ! . ‘ ; } | ; eri e ¢ place, from the cutting down of trees and t ful v s \ t s was t ‘ " a! the ¢ wearing away of rocks and earth, is very differ home of Guid ea t oe | it s ent now from what it was in Dante’s tim [iy ed t invect ava t ona it i . vals, t Lam t ind a walked up the ravine far enough, however, t whose identity seems lost t , t . t lin these latter we see that the hillsides were ploughed at short | Gu s. Intl is rtinore st it ! ed ms by } and me of distances with the tracks where, in spring ast f I nta, whos i prote i Dante | t st it ves in Faenza, where rainy weather, torrents ran, lea
down to reach the stream below; and I ild | tral hon f poor Francesca da re ik { ‘ s very obnoxious. By 1281 not help wondering whether the word thousands | remains not f it now if ss | Tibaldell ait zh he had always been a (mille) could not refer to these torrents rather | mound, ¢ aft t ast was stroved its , y = than to the expected inhabitants of either tow: stones were taken to | a litt hax s | the conquerors, and especially with the Lam or abbey. Both are in a very picturesque situ- | nas { . 1 ndo Guer St tti) wit erta ‘ had recently insulted him by ation: the ruins of the abbey—for there is little ! the su f abort 1 senting some of | killing his favorite little pig, that bh vore ven
Page 14
geance, He began to feign himself insane, to lament immoderately for his lost pig, and to do all sorts of nensense. He professed to divert his affections to a lean, half-starved old mare, nothing but skin and bone, which at last he carefully shaved, and, with plentiful use of sticks and stones, used to chase through the town. The rabble followed with shouts, and when the up- roar caused the Lambertazzi to be on the alert. they found nothing but crazy Tibaldello and his old mare. Then he began to raise commotions at night, with criesof ‘* Toarms! toarms!” until he had entirely succeeded in lulling the vigil- ance of the usurpers, and was given full immu- nity for his absurd acts. Then, with a confi- dant, he one morning issued from the town, dressed as a sportsman, with a falcon on his wrist and a brace of setters, amid the laughter of hiscompatriots. Once outside, they changed their clothes for friars’ gowns, and rode straight for Bologna, where, in secret council, they revealed their plot, and offered to deliver up Faenza. After some little negotiation the plan was arranged,and at duwn of St. Bartholo- mew’s Day the gates were opened to the Bo- lognese, and the ruling faction was awaked by loud cries of ‘* Long live the Church! Death to the Lambertazzi and the Forlivesi!” After a sharp fight, in which many were killed, the Lambertazzi and their supporters had to flee, and forsome years Faenza was restored to the dominion of the Church, Tibaldello and all his family emigrated to Bologna, where they received all the privileges of the native nobility, and there was established the festival of La Porchetta, or the little pig, which was for cen- turies celebrated on St. Bartholomew’s Day. Pope Martin IV., encouraged by this, wished to get possession of the other towns of the Ro- magna, and sent out a considerable army, in which were many Neapolitans and French, un- der the command of a French general Giovanni (also called Guido) d’Appia. Ina battle on Sep- tember 16, which brought Forli to great straits, the papal troops were victorious, but, among others, Tibaldello was killed. In the fourteenth canto of the ‘ Purgatorio,’ Dante says: **O Ugolin de’ Fantoli, secure Thy name is, since no longer is awaited One who, degenerating, can obscure it.’’ And the commentators pretty unanimously tell us that Ugolino was a worthy and honorable gentleman of Faenza ** who died without heirs, and thus his name was saved,” taking the words in their literal sense. Apparently, how- ever, the poet speaks sarcastically. Ugolino di Albertino Fantolino di Zerfognano, Count of Brisighella, lived at the Castle of Calamello in the valley of the Lamone in the mountains above Faenza, and was a noted Guelph. He died in 1278, but not without heirs; and his son, Ottaviano, two years afterwards, married the daughter of the Tibaldello just spoken of. So that Dante probably means that Ugolino’s name had sunk so low that no degenerate de- scendant could obscure it more. Nearly every line of this fourteenth canto contains a scrap of municipal history sadly needing elucidation and explanation. My stay in Castrocaro interested me in the lines: **Baznacaval does wellin not begetting, snil ill does Castrocaro, and Conio worse, In taking trouble to beget such counts,”’ especially as the commentators have offered no reasonable explanation of them. Bagna- cavallo is now a small town on the railway be- tween Bologna and Ravenna, about fifteen miles from the latter city, and is perhaps bet- ter known to us as the place where Byron’s daughter Allegra died in a conventual school. In the latter half of the eleventh century we The Nation. find Bagnacavallo governed by independent counts of the Malvicino or Malaboceca family of Ravenna, who, in spite of some disasters, maintained themselves for over a hundred years. Count Ruggiero, who succeeded in 1250, had even a strong party in Ravenna itself, opposed to the Traversari family, of whom also Dante makes mention. Bagnacavallo was not large enough to satisfy the ambition of the princes of that time, and when Malvicino IIT. succeeded in 1281, he was living and intriguing at Forli. In 1296 he was elected Podesta of Cesena, in spite of the fact that he had been ex- communicated and outlawed by the Pope. Nevertheless, he was not an adherent of the Ghibellines, and two years afterwards he ravaged and sacked the territory of Cunio. He was, of course, included in the general peace of Romagna towns in 1300, the jubilee year, but was still an object of dislike to Dante’s friends when the poet first visited that region. He died about 1305, leaving an only daughter, Catherine, though a certain Ludovico, the very last of the family, appears on the scene fifty years later. In 1308 Bagnacavallo was cap- tured by the Counts of Cunio, one of whom, Count Bernardino, was elected Podest& and maintained himself for twenty years, when he was exiled, and the town was annexed to the papal dominions, of which it formed a part un- til the present century. Cunio, which Dante calls Conio, and the site of which seems utterly unknown to the com- mentators, was at one time a strong castle situated on the level country on the left bank of the Senio, between the town of Cotignola and the parish church of Felisio. It had in- deed been destroyed before Dante wrote—for the last time, and then thoroughly, in 1296, by the Ghibellines, and especially the people of Faenza, lest it should be sold to Ravenna, But the Counts still existed—a large family of them too, who had sway over a large and fertile territory—and, when they could not rebuild Cunio, took refuge in one of their other castles, Barbiano, whence, on account of family dis- putes, some withdrew to Lugo and Imola, and ultimately founded several families. At that time, being independent and warlike, they caused considerable trouble to the Ghibellines, and we caneasily understand Dante’s wish that they should have no posterity. It was better, for the fame of the family at least, that this prayer was not granted, for Alberico was a very distinguished condottiere at the end of the fourteenth and the beginning of the fifteenth century. He defended Romagna against the Duke of Anjou; as Captain-General ot the papal troops he was victorious at Naples, and triumphed at Rome; in 1402 he took Bo- logna from the Visconti, and was then made Grand Constable of Naples under King Ladis- las; the next year he took Bologna again for the Pope, and only two vears afterwards was excommunicated because he had gone back to the Neavolitan service without permission, and had been accused of irregularly seizing papal castles, It seems almost needless to say that the better we understand the motives of the poet and the allusions which he makes, the better we appre- ciate the poem. Even these hasty and brief studies—mere amusements of a summer journey --convince ine that it would probably be possi- ble, although it would be a difficult and long task, to explain every historical allusion in the ‘Commedia’; at all events, there is room and } need for a careful dictionary of every place and person mentioned by Dante. E. S. [Number 1214 Correspondence. THE TRUE INWARDNESS OF THE VER- MONT ELECTION. To THE EpIToR oF THE NATION: Sir: Some weeks since, a Vermont corre- spondent of the Nation—presumably a Congre- gationalist clergyman recently settled in the State—complained somewhat bitterly of the Democratic management of the post office busi- ness in that State, with reference to the duty of the Independents in the approaching national election. This complaint, in connection with the recent State election, and some uses made of it by partisan Republican journals and platform speakers, suggests this note from one who has some knowledge of the State ‘‘ from Pownal to Derby Line.” It is lamentably true that the postal service in Vermont has suffered very material depre- ciation during the present Administration, and noone who knows the nature, capacity, and pur- pose of the Vermont Democratic ring will be at all surprised, or greatly disposed to criticise President Cleveland. The Vermont Democra- cy is the most unique organization in the his- tory of modern political development. It is not a party. in the sense of an organization with political ideas or policy of administration to enforce and illustrate for the public weal, measures to carry, and reforms to be adopted. The Vermont Democracy is not a party; it knows nothing about ideas, principles, and mea- sures: it is a clique, a ring, small and select, of party bosses, with several thousand voters who go to the polls and register the will of the leaders. There are Democrats good and true in the State by the thousand, but they are not organized so as to resist effectively the unscru- pulous ring. These Democrats are as intelli- gent and patriotic and public-spirited as any men in the State, and they constitute the ma- jority of the 17,531 votes given by the State in 1884 for Cleveland; but they are practically outside the ring, and have no effective influ ence on the conduct of the party or the ‘* base uses’ to which it is put by its masters. In fact, the Democratic party does not exist in Vermont for State purposes, though it goes through the form of nominating State officers biennially, and voting for them, so as to pre- serve the party from disintegration, For years before the war the venerable Paul Dil- lingham used to stand as the party candidate for gubernatorial honors; and after theelection was over and his overwhelming defeat was ‘* officially assured,” John G, Saxe, then of the Burlington Sentinel, would indite him a poem of political condolence over his misfortune, Later ‘‘ Governor ” (as everybody calls him) W. H. H. Bingham of Stowe, did the honors for his party; a few years ago they persuaded the Hon. E. J. Phelps, who, in addition to his other achievements, wrote the best poem on ‘* Essex Junction” extant in the English or any other language, torun for governor. Recently, they have picked up such men as they cculd get. This year’s candidate no one but a_politi- cian would think of as governor, while Mr. Dillingham, the son of Paul, one of the great war governors of the State, is confessedly the brightest, most capable and promising young man in Vermont to-day. The Vermont Democracy exists and is ruled by two bosses, well known to every Vermonter at home and abroad, for the sole and supreme purpose of the national patronage in the State during a Democratic administration. This is its sole and only reason for living. It seeks no State victory; in fact, [donot believe they would
Page 15
sineiniatineeeinendiieineinetemanauntnemeadammsmameen
Oct. L505 +? iow what to do with the State on their hands if by some accident they should carry an ele tion. It is th tration they want. } ¢ waiting, the day of I » spoils of the national Adminis After twenty-five vears of these bosses came, and, as there is but one custom office in the State, and one boss wanted that—and but one Government buildin erected, and the other wanted was only Hence, old, experienced, and valuable route-agents were dismissed by Col, Vilas, at the behest of these party first-class out, and, in not a few instances, wholly in the superintendency of that—there u the postal service for the henchmen. leaders, turned postmasters ‘om- their places, petent men put int And so it has gone all over the State, and this kind of busi } ness was just as congenial to Col. Vilas as to the Vermont leaders. The same is true to a large extent throughout New England, and henee Col. Vilas’s adminis tration of the Post-Oftice l failed to actua Department not only make friends for the President, but lly alienated some of his best sup- has porters. The postal service comes home to the great masses of the people in New England, and the one thing clergymen, teachers, and tolerate with any of for the sex or political aftilia business men there will not bad them care not patience is mail service. Thousands ete., but they
tion of postmasters, route ¢ good and that is where insist on Col tration in New service; Vilas was the evil genius of the Adminis England, and his work his party in Vermont; and in the recent election the people associated this vitiated mail service with these well-known party bosses, and
took this opportunity to ‘Shit’ them. But for these things Vermont would have shown mark ed Democratic gains Hence, tepublican gains are not attributable to Ed munds’s ** loyalty” this year, nor yet to fres! party enthusiasm, nor to any free-tra albeit high tariff on wool is political orthodox State, though more Vermonters ¢ in dairying than in wool-growing, and even this isin the hands of the small but wea thy and influential Merino sheep ring. The ap parent Republican gains grow out of this revolt obnoxious bosses and a de felt
against lie service, which is in nearly every in the State As an original Mugwump, an unyieldir dependent, and a friendand supporte1 dent Cleveland, I write this to show the Vermont election inwardness of keenly regretted that this degradation of the Vermont by local postal service in
politicians, as above described, : net should be used by
ofticers, } } political opponents as a proof of his declining strength. The same is true too largely in « portions of New England, and this mail service is the only feature of public life which would inder Blaine not have been worse CHICAGO, September 25, 1888.
4 PSYCHICAL COINCII To THE Epitor o¥ THE NATION
Sr: For the benefit of investigators int the subject of coincidence, I send you the f lowing statement, premising that t parties man and wife) to educated people, past given to superstition, an t as they actually occurred, without any paring down or dovetailing The two persons were asleep in the same room about 7:00 A. M., servants being up and moving about in the house, and m: which could easily be ? r 1eard in the bedroom
at that place young ma with evident silent asevere rebuke to the young in, apolo as he did so, to the bystanders for his he A moment afterwards, the wife Wakened and begun detailing the following dream, bet having heard anything of her husba sdrean She had been at home, engaged in s . Keeping matter wi 1 occupied tora her full attention, when her husband oy» the door and called to her. b e is gaged for the moment, she neither tur: round nor answered him, whereupon he s ed her sharply, when she awoke before wa able to make the full explanation she had begu to give while she was asleep At the instant of waking, tl wil { her dream, and the husband detailed he what he had dreamed a few mon s be e lhe question seems to be wt r bot ur ties heard, while asleep, sounds wt produ parallel, though not exactly s al t sions upon their minds, or t in dres talked in his sleep so as to be ird byt in her sleep, and only partially unders i These two weople have f " miber , noticed that exactly tl same t ght quently occurs to them at the sar when they are together alone, and b i their mind re impressed b t ‘ stance which, while they set brat lo not f lv va . . S that ! xpression of t Neither n n Ww i aw : KHnOW! the el to ALK I Ww islee] ON} DREAY s “ N War AN SSS PREVENTATIN I Tt I ITOR THe Nat N Su Dr. Worcester ting | ; entati 1 s that t Ww 2 rectly used for f ' Was . Similarly, in 1e of i “ dictionary known as ‘** Webster's is called **a gross I it t ns ot ti same work ft it s rectly used instead of nr 4 Latham, as ¢ r f : s vives if ‘ A Gregorv's F \ no fault with it. § . P s Ww = f t . Ww ? I With res t \ nother v Mr Wt f his W ; ses Words that t Words T + + ++ T + + + t } s a tt i it i a low gra tellig : Mr vard S. Goul $ R } lisa} ves of, tells his 1 ers that are already s al us gig r and they are gradually work As estimated by Dr. William Mathews, in ! HW s ‘ Ai i fat ranks witl base inages, bar sms which st i excommunicated by * bell, book, a andle.’ Many ritics besides thos ju ted above have
if t 4 Uslness nity fe He a ldressec m he was in the habi *Ked intention f&«
Upon this the first of mee s } )
La questi ht @igot ing at ftFensive Speake! adminis
nat ' il 1 ; I I
w* - -_ ( ~ ~ -_ ty “ ‘ i¢ ina e . \ I “ ~ ft’ x ‘ 1 . i SUpPPoOSsINng Aa it ha X = “ . \\ R Hod ‘ : i . ‘ t \ i ‘ ‘
bal i in v { ais ‘ \ i va ‘ ‘ efere ‘ " } uN i : tt i ' \ . i ‘ \na st - ‘ ‘ \ ‘ . = ‘ \ s + \ i A re . , P < , ~ is the best “ st ach Lhe s N \ . ‘ Sv Sé wid i 4 \ ‘ , il \\ . aft 1 Hi . M4). we ' t ex ‘ ig nst tl ¢ ,° is stakes | s en . , iA iz i ul Vj ™ \ ¢ ¢ ‘ P i is L preve ' i set n my = Sout ( a Vol 1 tae \ fof ‘ oft ‘ } I] hh Vol. XXXV Ne 6 | ye 7 t if i nf this " i,w aid us | t " par f mAaV serv asa} niati t | Ne f f the Letters, et si ? he ‘ tative which George Tuber mends, in nitory rhymes, 1s Doctor, vol. iv (18387 The preventatires of superstition Wil- im Taylor of Norwich, in the Monthly Re- i vol. xxii. (1813), p ** They have several kinds [of fish] which are ffectual remedies for sins. I do not know whether they have any that are preventative ; nor does that seem a consideration in their si}
Page 16
fe 270 religion.” W.S. Landor, Wor/'s (ed. 1846), vol. li, p. 226. ** Do you know the late Dr. Baillie’s prerenta- five of the flatulency which tea produces ?” Cardinal Newman, Loss and Gain (1848), p. 163. And the Cardinal has preventative in his Kssay on the Development of Christian Doe- trine (1845), pp. 101, 423. ‘* His intolerance of perfunctory remissness led him to adopt a complicated disciplinatory system, remedial and preventative.” Isaac Taylor, Wesley and Methodism (1851), p. 280. The word in question is also found in Bp. Heber’s Sermons; in the Life of William Wil- berforce, by his sons, Archdeacon R, I. Wil- berforce and Bp. 8. Wilberforce; and in the Asiatic Researches. My references to these works I cannot, however, at present verify. By possibility, without consideration that it intercalates preventive worse than needlessly, preventative was modelled on some long adjec- tive of similar termination. At any rate, once conspicuously before the world, it was adopted through heedless sequacity; and reiteration of it has gradually operated to the effect, that, rated by the standard of good usage, it has at- tained to considerable respectability. Pensa- tive, for pensive, exemplifying an equally idle outlay of letters or demand of breath, was hazarded, in 1582, by Nicholas Lichefield, and was used as late as 1654 by Edmund Gayton. Viewed ety mologically, it is better capable of defence, as is also Sir Thomas More’s asserta- tion, than distributative, instead of distribu- tive, the property of the Rev. John Carpenter, writing in 1607. But such cumbrous devices, even where a classical ancestry, real or analogi- eal, can be challenged for them, have, as was to be expected, found scant favor in a language whose tendency is shown in, for instance, its refusal to naturalize idvlolatry; in its prefer- ence, from the first, for coercion rather than, as in French, coercition ; and in the imminent disappearance from it of dilatation before the handier dilation, Your obedient servant, F. H. MARLESFORD, ENGLAND, August 23, 1888. THE INDICES TO HALKETT AND LAING, To THE Epiror oF THE Nation : Sir: May I, as editor of Haikett and Laing’s ‘ Dictionary of the Anonymous and Pseudony- mous Literature of Great Britain,’ ask you to give publicity to the fact that 1 am not the compiler of the indices which form the conclud- ing portion of the fourth volume of that work recently issued? As I have already stated, in the London Athen@um of August 18, the pre- face which bears my name, as written by me for the press, coutained the following sentence: ‘*T have to add that my labors closed in 1885 with letter Z ; the indices, etc., being the work of another hand.’ These words were omitted, without my know- ledge or consent. As the Dictionary is, I be- ieve, well known in America, I shall esteem ita great favor if you will allow me to dis- claim all responsibility with regard to the indices.—Your obedient servant, CATHERINE LAING. EDINBURGH, September 18, 1888, Notes. \MONG the forthcoming books, one likely to lave more political than literary interest. is ‘ The Private Correspondence of Daniel O'Con- neil, the Liberator,’ which Mr. W. J. Fitzpat- rick has edited, adding a memoit and abundant notes, It will be published by Longmans, The Nation. Green & Co. The same firm announce a ‘ Life of Lord Stratford de Redcliffe,’ by Stanley Lane-Poole, which, seeing that this English diplomat was British Minister to Washington in 1820-1823, possesses an American interest. Macmillan & Co. further announce ‘ Natural Inheritance,’ by Vrancis Galton; ‘ Popular Lectures and Addresses on Various Subjects in Physical Science,’ by Sir Wiliiam Thomson; ‘Scientific Papers,’ by the late Prof. Andrews; a translation of Amédée Guillemin’s popular treatise on ‘ Electricity and Magnetism’; ‘A Practical Text-book of Pathology,’ by D. J. Hamilton; a seventh series of ‘Cameos from English History,’ by Charlotte M. Yonge, em- bracing the Rebellion and the Restoration, 1642- 1678; an ‘ Alphabet of Economie Science,’ by Philip H. Wicksteed; a translation of Plato’s ‘Phaedo, Lysis, and Protagoras,’ by Josiah Wright, in the Golden Treasury Series; ‘ The Classical Element in the New Testament,’ by the Rev. C. H. Poole; ‘Some Contributions to the Religious Thought of Our Time,’ ser- mons and addresses by the Rev. James M. Wilson; and ‘ University Sermons, New and Old,’ by the Rev. Charles J. Vaughan. Mac- millan & Co. have determined to enlarge their English Illustrated Magazine to seventy pages, without increase of price, the added space being especially desirable for the department of fiction. Chas. Secribner’s Sons have in preparation the ‘Diary and Letters of Gouverneur Morris,’ in two volumes ; * Cyclopedia of Music and Musi- cians,’ by John D. Champhn, jr., and Wm. F, Apthorp, in three volumes; * History of French Painting, from its Earliest to its Latest Prac- tice,’ by Mrs. Clara H. Stranahan; and ‘ First Harvests,’ by F. J. Stimson. Thomas Whittaker has in press ‘ Musgrove Ranch,’ a tale of Southern California, by J. M. Browne; ‘Our New Mistress,’ by Charlotte M. Yonge; and in the Camelot Series, ‘ [rish Fairy Tales and Folk Lore,’ selected and edited by W. B. Yeats; in the ‘‘Canterbury Poets,” ‘Chaucer,’ edited by F. Noel Paton; in the ‘* Great Writers,” ‘Crabbe,’ by T. E. Kebbel— English issues by Walter Scott, London. In the last catalogue of Hachette & Cie. we tind an announcement of the first French edi- tion of Prof. Guyot’s ‘Géographie Physique Comparée,’ now first published in the original , French, with a preface by M. Vivien de Saint- Martin. Wilhelm Hertz, Berlin, will publish this fall the second volume of the Memoirs of the Duke of Coburg, which promises to be fully as enter- taining and instructive as the first volume, al- ready noticed in these columns, We doubt if any volume of the ‘ Battles and Leaders of the Civil War’ will be found to sur- pass in interest the third, just issued by the Cen- tury Co. It deals in the first place with Bragg’s invasion of Kentucky in 1862, a campaign of | which General Buell, who narrates the Federal | part in it, says that it extended over a wider | territory, and involved greater hazard to the | Union cause, than any other. Incidentally, | General Buell reveals his idea of generalship | when vindicating his course on this occasion, | both his own and his adversary’s prudence hav- | ing drawn popular censure from their respec- tive ‘‘ countries.” He has also a pregnant para- graph on the rule of Confederate inferiority in numbers and superiority in effective fighting, which is philosophically explained much, we | fancy, as posterity will explain it. Burnside at Fredericksburg, Chancellorsville, Gettys- | burg, Vicksburg, Port Hudson, Chickamauga, and Chattanooga, are the other grand topics of | the volume, discussed by both sides. The | leading chapter on Chattanooga is one of | Number 1214 General Grant’s, and is criticised by General * Baldy” Smith. This interesting and weighty writer shows how, contrary to a certain dic- tum, the Chattanooga engagement was fought exactly as it was nof planned. His brief demonstration of this would make a good foot- note to Tolstoi’s thesis, that such deviations from the plan are the rule in war. The vol- ume before us is, we need hardly say, like its predecessors, a marvel of typographical beau- ty and wealth of valuable illustrations. If any one is disposed to vote politics ‘‘slow” this year, it is Mr. Edward McPherson, who delayed bringing out bis invaluable ‘ Hand book of Politics for i888’ till it was clear that he would lose the campaign market it he held back longer for the Presidential letters of ac- ceptance, The volume accordingly appears without them (Washington: James J. Chap- man), but contains everything else of impor- tance. The editor notices the two prime achievements of the past two years—ihe pas sage of the Electoral Count Act (pending since 1872) and the Inter-State Commerce Act (pend- ing since 1884). Among the statistical tables is a comparison of rates in the Mills Bill and in the Tariff Act of 18585. Sections 15 and 19 exhibit the Constitutional amendments pro- posed or carried in the several States and in the United States respectively. No fewer than forty-two amendments to the Federal Consti tution are recorded as proposed in Congress from December 16, 1586, to January 25, ISS. Mr. Blair and Mr. Crain had the honor of presenting four each. Roberts Bros. have issued, ina style similar to their edition of the ‘ Imaginary Conversa- tions,’ Landor’s * Pentameron,’ linking with it the ‘‘ Citation and Examination of William Shakspeare,” various minor pieces of prose, and the critical papers upon Petrarch, Catulius, and Theocritus, all in one volume. It is a very convenient collection, and we may congratu late ourselves that this really great writer is so easily accessible to the American public. An author whose works are more distinctly litera- ture, has not| been kuown in the present cen- tury. Ginn & Co., Boston, have issued a new and revised edition of ‘ A Text-Book of Geometry,’ by Prof. G. A. Wentworth of Phillips Exeter Academy. Although the whole book has been rewritten and considerably increased in size, it is essentially the same as when it first appeared in 18i%. The alterations consist principally in the simplification of some of the demonstra tions, and the increase in size is mostly due to the greater number of exercises. The great popularity of the book is sufficient evidence that the characteristics which distinguish it from others of its class meet with the approval ot teachers generally, and we see no reason to dissent from the verdict. That concurrence, however, does not imply a complete agreement with the current methods of treating and teaching geometry—a subject which we have no room to discuss. An ‘Academic Algebra’ and a ‘College Algebra,’ by Prof. Bowser of Rutgers College, published by D. Van Nostrand, are both excel- lent works. The only essential difference be- tween them is that the latter is the more exten- sive, treating many subjects omitted in the former. But the ‘College Algebra’ does not assume any previous acquaintance with the science, and is equally adapted to the beginner and the undergraduate. The ‘ Academic Alge- bra’ contains all that is necessary for entrance to any of our colleges. While speaking of text-books, we may men- tion, as aids in -the teaching of English worth examining, the Milton,’ from Johnson’s ‘ Lives A
Page 17
Oct. 4, 1888] of the Poets,’ and Goldsmith's ‘ Tra r.’ both edited with abundant notes (Clarend Press, and Macmiilan), Anedition of ** Richard II1 prepared by Prof. C. H. Tawney of Calcutta for the students of Indian universities (Maecnuil lan), surpasses ordinary Western needs in the matter of notes, but may be all the more use ful in some quarters among us Moore’s ‘Irish Melodies and Songs, with Kenny Meadows'’s illustrations (reduced), has taken its place in the pretty Nuggets Series of the Messrs. Putnam. The ornamental borders of the pages have the green tint of Erin We can do no more at this time than rey the welcome appearance of Prof. Edward Al len Fay’s ‘ Concordance of the Divina Comme dia’ (Boston: Little, Brown & Co It makes a handsome volume of SI‘! pages, and would alone be worth the formation of the Dante So ciety of Cambridge, Mass., under whose aus pices it sees the light. Dr. F. Ratzel’s ethnographical volumes, in the series called ‘ Allgemeine Naturkunde’ (New York : Westermann), are concluded with the 117th instalment of the entire work. The final issues (108-117) deal with the African popula tions of the equator belt stretching from Bornu to Abyssinia; the Asiatic from Persia to China and India; the European from the Caucasus westward; and the semi-civilized people of out western American coast. As usual, there are numerous excellent colored plates of costume implements, weapons, vessels, ete., and still more wood-cuts of a trustworthy kind. There now remains to complete this great enterprise only one volume in the botanical division, which has been delaved by the editor's illness, but is expected to be ready in a few mouths, _ The most significant article in of American History for October is ** The Story of a Prince,” by Lee C. Harby. ‘ A Ro mantic Chapter in Texas History” is its sul title, and is fully borne out by this account of the founding of a German colony in Texas be fore it was wrested from Mexico. The narra tive is not controlled by documentary evidence as it should and might yet be (for gun), but it was worth writing. Numerous por- traits and other illustrations accompany the paper. The September number of Les Lettres et les Arts (Paris: Boussod, Valadon et Cie.; New York: Chas. Scribner's Sons) contains six arti cles, of which the two most attractive are the first part of ‘* Les Canons anciens et modernes,” by General Thoumas, with its reproductions « curious old wood-engravings, and the second part of ** L’Opéra sous lancien re Adolphe Jullien, which is also illustrated by Among them is a little miniature of Sophie Ar- nould anda portrait of the irresistible tenor reproductions of old pictures and engravings. Jéliotte as Apollo, in full court dress and wig, holding a singular lyre. But the most expres sive of these illustrations is from an old en graving of the time of Lows XIV., signed by the engraver, Trouvain, and representing the ambassadors of Morocco at the Opéra during a ‘Carnaval de Venise representation of the **Orchardson et son q@uvre,” by Frederick Wedmore, is especially interesting on account of the five illustrations from the artist's work which accompany it. If our memory serves us, the extrava with which Le Livre for September opens is the first incursion of fiction into this journa And more is apparently to come, for ** L’Héri tage Sigismond: Luttes homériques d'un vra bibliofol,” by MM. Octave Uzanne and Adolphe Robida, is preceded by the general title, **Con- tes pour les Bibliophiles.” It cannot be said that this department was needed to enliven tl Nation. element has certa ? lira ~ 6 i y | . . it j it : ‘1 place ‘ r illv bet wes , ‘ na ** that yina st tl alities , ™ s attractive ‘ iiss ft i ‘ . y ¢ W . th of er ‘ t Mont Bla i : pression t t pe'rsiste! ‘ is t rreparal ta ary, t tus always of ~ and reflect I im i tha dy . ted passayes press Litky i ~} i iie is tra i t set ‘ ™ ’ J re ‘ _ 4 Ne pranets i \ ‘ — = s t ‘ ‘ airy t i {fa i “ is ‘ t t al a Crosse does } ‘ i ‘ uler W vw } ! tt * \ \W i wi) S81 vey } } vas I ! i Yas ney : SAvS ‘ \r ~ s sO V sa soa - any I Ss i apes sa “ ‘ t NAVs t ul i ‘ t 41is ‘ > NG ‘ Mr > tw . Nuis tha x ta t ‘ t - it sw i » 3 ‘ i . i : ” ethe ext P i « h was ~ ses shi t the : f G . ssor of ( Litera ¢ . : ' ures Lausa \ i resent As - ¢ 3 ‘ iM. Rod , iL woe 4iis . i xt t , = s pre } . i t | ad t ul } t ‘ . t smaii ‘ s ent their au tl tot anks of the Fr h Academ It st sa wever, tha n spit f M vod 's sk i ea. the ad at f adimira th t Na to the autl t Poemes antiques, t Potmes barbares ind the I s trac ies sen S alwavs ft I yiven test will everyone be able to sa “u sent critic that the aga vent of the sist t reader is attenuated M. Paul Stapfer ¢ s the third and neluding part of s* Rabelais, sa vie et son ceuvre,’ a very straightforward, unpretentious account of the fe of Ra iis,and a ¢ exposition of the nature of his work. A very similar article, though upon a writer entirely unknown to most western readers, is the one entitled ‘‘ Jean K ir et la poésie panslaviste au xixe siécle, f which M Louis Leger, the first among h Slavic scholars, gives the second and last part. Like all that appears in this periodi cal, even from scholars and specialists like M i Leger, it is as simply and plainly written as it
Page 18
is new and interesting, for the articles of the Bibliotheque Universelie never belong to what is very expressively called in Paris the litera- ture of Two excellent articles, “ L) Histoire réligieuse de la Révolution fran- mandarins, caise,” by M. Edmond de Pressensé, and ‘ Le Pessimisme philosophique et l'Optimisme chré- tien,” by M. Léo Quesnel, are very characteris- tic of the Revue, which, without being religious in its tone, is addressed to a community in which Protestant Christianity is respected. Among the lighter articles is one by M. G. van Muyden, ‘‘ Les grandes Régates anglo-améri- The Parisian, German, English, Swiss, are, as usual, very readable, caines.” various chroniques, —The tenth volume of ‘ Meyer’s Konversa- tions-Lexikon’ (New York : B. Westermann & Co.) has been completed, and the eleventh far ndvanced, ending with the article on Minting. The profusion of engraved and colored plates, among which latter we remark one of insect mimicry, and of maps, is well maintained. The articles on the colonial strivings of Germany; on Corinth and its canal, to be finished in 1891; Krakatoa, ete., show the editing to be abreast of the times. So do the biographies of Prince Krapotkin and of Robert Koch, with his comma bacillus; but the notice of Dr. Mo- on rell Mackenzie makes no mention of bis attend- ance upon the Emperor Frederick, and the sub- sequent unpleasantness. run- ning (Laufen) is illustrated by Muybridge’s plate of In general, American achievements are apt to be slighted, The article on the galloping horse, as for example in the sketch of the development of the pianoforte. The Knights of Labor are postponed to a later stage of the alphabet. Since cyclopedias are the great disseminators of error, it is worth while to point out two the stands typographical article Gen. McClellan : for slips in on for. Brinton, and Kossuth is judged; and in reply to a subscriber the editors Brenton Grange Orange. severely say in their correspondence sheet that the day of Kossuth’s birth was, and may still be, un known to himself. Through the same channel they affirm against Vapereau that ex-President Grévy was born in 1807, not in 1815; and they add that his baptismal name was Judith Fran- cois, which he took the liberty of exchanging for Jules. —The Convention of the American Library Association, just held in the Catskills, was, as The weather as at convention, accommodat- violent storm on the coast, no walk or drive among the beau- ties of wind or rain. there many papers at these meetings, Jeaving no time for discussion. This year there were only two papers, sent by members who could usual, a success. was, every other most ing. Though there was a the Catskills was hindered by We have always said that were too not come. Topics were suggested by the President, or introduced by short talks from some one who desired information, and were then discussed in a very informal manner, Some very unexpected facts came out, and in one case the discovery led to the most important action taken. It was found that a list of por- traits other than those separately published, that is, of portraits contained in collections, in biographies, in art periodicals, and the like places where they might be overlooked, had made considerable progress in a certain large library, and that others had done more or less work in the same direction. It was agreed that such isolated work, leading necessarily to considerable duplication, was unwise, and that such a list ought to be prepared in codperation, The result was eminently satisfactory. | The Nation. as was Poole’s ‘ Index to Periodical Literature,’ and with a view to publication when finished, A committee was appointed to report at the next convention (to be held at St. Louis next spring) what works of this sort are going on. The preparation of such a general list of por- traits was suggested some years ago by Mr. R. R. Bowker of the Publishers’ Weekly to the English Index Society, and the Index was put upon their list; but that Society has frittered away its energy on the production of little in- dexes of extremely limited value, and nothing has ever been done, so far as we know, to or- ganize that codperation without which a scheme of this magnitude could not be carried out. It is to be hoped that the coming report will not confine itself to enumerating all the biblio- graphical work that can be discovered to be going on in this country, though that of itself would be of great value, but will outline a method by which the iconographical index can take its place as the third of those useful labor- savers of which Poole’s ‘Index’ is the first, and Fletcher’s ‘Essay Index’ is to be the second, —One session was devoted to architecture. The plans of the new rooms destined for the State Library in the Sta e House at Albany, prepared by a librarian, were approved; the plans of the Howard Library just finishing at New Orleans, one of Richardson’s latest draw- ings, were riddled with objections. All of Richardson’s designs for libraries are, from the library point of view, failures. We do not know whether that famous architect ever gave any thought to the object for which his build- ings of this sort were intended: there is little indication that he did in any of them. He ap- pears to have been satisfied if he drew a beauti- ful design, and to have left it to some draughts- man to fit in the books and the service. When shall we find an artist who will plan for use first and beauty next; who will see where his book-shelves and his reading-halls and his work- rooms ought to go for the highest efficiency, and then will mould his library building around them? Looking at such plans as this of the Howard Library (where, for instance, an attendant must go 320 feet to get a book within 10 feet of the delivery desk), and scores of others like it, not excepting even the magni- ficent structure just begun for the Boston Pub- lic Library, one may say, as did the President of the ‘*The architect the natural enemy of the librarian.” Association, is —The late report of the Astronomer Royal, Mr. Christie, to the Board of Visitors of the Greenwich Observatory, exhibits a gratifying state of activity in that institution. The struc- ture itself has been undergoing extensive re- pair, and is now modernized quite as much as is desirable, the chief addition being a new dome made by Sir Howard Grubb. paratively recent introduction of spectroscopic and photographie branches of the work neces- sitated temporary arrangements which are re- placed in the completed building, whole of the astronomical establishment is now brought together. As in Paris, the neighbor- ing traflic has rendered the astronomers solicit- ous as to the foundations of their instruments, and the subject of approaching railways thus engages their serious attention. Railway in- terference with observatory piers varies much with the character of the geological formation, but the nature and amount of the disturbance near Greenwich were settled once for all by not- ing the effect of passing trains upon a reflect- ing mercurial surface which the astronomer has frequent occasion to make use of: the tre- The com- and the mors were found to produce exceedingly de- [Number 1214 leterious results while trains were passing at a distance of some six hundred yards; and up to distances of one mile, the effects were dis- tinctly marked. As a consequence of this work, the recommendation of the Astronomer Royal to the Admiralty led to the abandon- ment of the construction of a new railway across Blackheath. —As everywhere else, very bad weather dur- ing nearly half of the year is found to have disastrously affected the number of observa- tions; but the calculations of results are ina most forward state. No progress has been made for a year in the construction of the great refracting telescope, of 28-inch aperture, as the glass-inakers have not as yet succeeded in producing the crown-glass disk for the ob- jective. The measurement of the motions of stars from or towards the earth by means of the spectroscope is continued with very inte- resting results; while, in the photographic de- partment, it is noteworthy that, by combining Greenwich solar pictures with those from In- dia and Mauritius, records are at hand for 361 days out of 565. During 1887 the spotted area has rarely amounted to 1-2,000th of the sun’s visible hemisphere, and the average is less than one-sixth that recorded in 1885, near the time of maximum Preparations are making for a redetermination of the difference of longitude between Greenwich and Paris. A photographic refracting telescope is needed to spots. enable the Observatory to bear its share in the international work of mapping anew all the stars of the sky; some thirteen observatories, in both hemispheres, have already ordered their instruments of like dimension for codperation in this great undertaking. This need has just been met by a Treasury-grant. A year Astronomer Royal referred to the increased demands upon the Observatory by the scien- tific and the general public, and he now calls attention to the fact that in 1835 there were six assistants, having no computers to superin- ago, the tend, no extraneous work worth mentioning, no magnetic and meteorological observations, nc altazimuth observations, nor any spectro- scopie and photographic work. At present there are but eight assistants, excluding the chief assistant, having fifteen computers to superintend; and of the assistants’ staff, five are absorbed by the newly developed branches of work, leaving thus practically only three assistants to do the astronomical work which in 1835 required five, and in addition to per- form varied extraneous duties imposed by the Mr. Christie therefore very properly pleads for adequate provision for the primary objects of the Observatory, in default of which the voluntary work—the supply of hourly time-signals, for example—may have to be dropped. public interest. RECENT NOVELS. The Reverberator. millan & Co. A Virginia Inheritance. ton. D. Appleton & Co. From Lands of Exile. lated from the French by Clara Bell. Gottsberger. The Black Arrow. By Robert Louis Steven- son. Charles Scribner’s Sons, By F. J. Stimson Charles Scribner’s Sons, By Henry James. Mac- By Edmund Pendle- By Pierre Loti. Trans- WS. The Residuary Legatee. (J. S. of Dale). The King of Folly Island, and Other People. By Sarah Orne Jewett. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co,
Page 19
Oct. 4, 1888] The — . , . Nation. A Little Maid of Acadie. By Marion Reeves D. Appleton & Co, this limitation, and she was moved thereto not | f Then it was really Miss Dosson who created | , ; : h by a doubt « tr. ] sg theses as Roger Berkeley's Probation. By H ; ! i ] f Mr. Flack’s grea eS a » ' ; ° byt Wledye gathered f il 1 sia bell. Boston: Roberts Bros e - ath , that the grandest matches were mad " A Hard-Won Victory. By Grace Denio Lite! by American girls ** r there,” which know field. G. P. Putnam's Sons ledge had fired her with vaulting ambition for | ¢ Virginia of Virginia. By Amélie Rives. Hat nes : . 17} rrant thaw thoncht 7 tnrals . per & Bros. ee ee AGRO, 1 DAVE as Seq j ‘ : that it was a splendid thing to have a column | Hillingdon Hall, or The Cockney s J ar es , . _ i . : . In the J erte f ali about Prancie and [ R. S. Surtees. London: John (¢ Vimmo , ~ y ‘ a portrait, with the skeletons in the closets of her | ' New York: Scribner & Welford : Fran \merican fiane’s family, expose Ir has long been taken for granted that the « ld type to a gaping world. It was disti: ments of Mr. James’s novels shall be few and | tion! It was fa They were obliged to see | simple, the characters and phases of life tyy that the three demoiselles Probert. by mar- | cal. Nobody expects anything to happen, or | riage ennobled, took a different view of anticipates emotional excitement Perhay Miss Dosson wa mad" with Flack ' his strongest book, ‘The Princess Casamas he had apparently broke (Ft! ral | sima,’ missed general appl it ! u but ; t ' ‘ ives. th | strange incidents and deep fet I lpr y tl j berts s | conceived opinions, and exhibit an t the end « time they ve would. | cumseribed than public wisdom pe t rs vel wt author. If that wisdom was disturbed es had b nfided to he Gv with bk 7 slightly by the exceptiona | ter nt } ‘ self ot t | berator’ will reéstablish it ti ’ ! t thre art tl list manuscript of the plot conid be pa itly ince than to perceive a fulfilment of her pre | ina nutshell, or a summary there raved { vhen she had l t ya 1 to Gas- |} by an ingenious person on a dim l sub ton Probert—that “she knew she w i ject, too, is that which the maki hist something ] now } As f the author’s fame, viz., the hoy lift ’ the sassin. Flack. what Wd he ha in social point of view betwee ) tain cla ‘ te t rantediluvian frumps. wl of Americans and another class, not so certa 1 row because their door vd been f but not American. The differencs wi lit r sl es desecrated. for the t he argument rests will doubtless apy I the Reve for’s circulation, and it dividuals of that certain American class, if by | for t} , ite nt mankind any chance they read Mr. James, t f \ Mr. Fla 1 monster. a re monstrous and ridiculous pretext for a stor. foot thet hated os : : pronounce this judgment, not | s ’ fort iSSU t now ‘count themselves in that class, but 1 il tra i ii } sincerit S they know that the author is a fir \ itt | va , fellow, whose soul is dead t t ! l S t own, his 1 land, and wl " \ t} 5 Tar g about for a chance to have i flin t 11 t} t Versv, 1 t 1 rea rn que n is simply whether 9 . . } . your private affairs set fort 1 st t ant ¢ \ journal ”’—set forth, either with tlatte: uld t have ted among t paragement, always mendaciously—or whether The Proberts are sl} ced and furic } 4 you don’t. On one side of the quest sta mal sts rag haract stic fas , e the Dossons of America, newly arrived in Paris e, brought to the family bar, is bew ‘ and Mr. Flack, George M. Flack, res] t | It dvesn't ir t t lenv inr nt of the Reverberator; on the ot ral irraved t tv wit ] nor to feign s\ pathy the Proberts, originally of South Ca it doe t ir tothe Proberts t in the second generation of denat ition sty To t Galli nd. that was un Mr. The Dossons are new-rich, yet not on that a ss avowal of shame. One word of exaggera count offensively aggressive; on th: ntrar tion here w i convert a serious scer toale of the lowest degree of humility consistent farce, but that word is not written. Fra with self-respect and free-born Americanisn whose fascinat for Gaston Pre rtisa mat- The treatment of the Dossons is most admira ter of fine lines and lor. is endeared to tl ble. They have so little marked individuality Anglo-Saxon reader by this splendid exhibi that they are almost characteriless, vet t iu- | tion, not of irage, but of natural-born inca thor manages to characteriz them I y pacity for lving It akes her worth Pr rt's Da “ One cannot decide which is the more wond reluctant sacrifice, and worth, t t i ful, his power of divinati f t se, g ul ] “ “ R effortless « x pre ssion. r fortunes are narrated . No people were ever more hel; sly what I terest ‘A Virginia Inhe a? nature made them than the Dossons; t for tres int nflicting claims of the N ag no people could be for themselves a fuller ex f ttert Manor andt Sout rt planation and more cordially a pta rpol ! pos t Asin‘ 1] R rhe rv. They deserve all the syVimpat t f l i yInsenuoUs aS Never to have thought of being I y and argument pretentious can get They t ta i : 8! art nd al I $ by virtue of s office, was 7 t ani , Georze M. Flack, comma i Xists ‘ N ear aud time of princes and t t S ‘ ‘ spar ‘ greatest of his guild. His expla t t ‘. whetles ie aie ot ; was ‘‘only a correspondent ” se1 a I t errati hampion of the Virginia exalt him; for how much greater ar riree | Chesters, ‘the right of eminent domain, f 1 i y to roam abroad than an editor d } to stay association. is at least equal t edita t ul ‘h 3 at home i sit ‘ i atasti { tM ue S prea vhi 1 we ‘ 5 ‘ \ i il unp i ‘ reve — vw i wma 1 /are ari al tl
Page 20
¢pry ww 6 4 from Malabar and Africa, entitled, ‘ From Lands of Exile.’ The author, an officer in the French navy, has the quick, all-embracing eye- sight of a tried sailor, the ready apprehension of a Parisian, and the dreamy, sensuous tem- perament of a poet. He sees all there is to see, and so there are plenty of facts which are un- deniably very important aids to realization of unknown and exceedingly odd and Far more than that, he feels in one way or another all that he sees, and it is his full and rich expression of a most sensitive impressionability that vivifies his fact and plunges his readers into the atmosphere of his He takes us first in a ship’s boat across a bay of Anam and up a river that leads to the town of Touran. On the way we notice some a“ things strange. scene. roof bristling with hideous and diabolical emblems, horns, claws, and in the midst the huge lotus flower :” then, a sentinel, ‘ squatting in his little lair by a huge tom-tom, looking like a nasty old woman with a gown on and her hair in a knot.” we are entertained in a bamboo hut, drink tea out of tiny blue cups amidst the waving of fans and umbrellas, in a litter of bronzes and lacquer queer things—a temple with ‘‘ concave Presently we come to Touran, where and paper rubbish which would be the despair of a Western collector. From the mandarin’s, on to the market, where hosts of ‘ senile, child- ish creatures” are trotting about in fluttering, gaudy rags and absurd hats. Their chatter is maddening, their filth and squalor are disgust- ing, and the air is laden with their smell, that heavy, musky smell with which the Chinese curio shops at home have already acquainted Passing from the streets to the pagodas, art appear so eccentric, unaccountable, and anomalous as when re- garded piecemeal, isolated in the incongruous West. It seems natural that such travesties on humanity should express themselves in writh- us. Chinese does not ing, nightmare monsters, and in pudgy little demons with bulging eyes and malign grin. Our impressions of China are-not pleasurable but they are intense, and they do most forcibly suggest to us thoughts of the *‘ wide gulf which parts us from the men and things of this land; the different darkness in which we had our birth; the disturbing dissimilarity of our pri- meval origin.” On the whole, we do not regret China, and at Singapore are irritated that it is not vet quite behind us. Here the Chinese min- gle with every nationality and predominate. It is all ‘“‘ yellow, bustling, greedy, simian, ob- > Once at Mahé, on the Malabar coast, a kingdom of calm and beauty is ours. scene, ’ ‘*At about five in the afternoon,” says the author, ‘‘ I disembarked there on a sandy shore, at the mouth of a little river which makes a cutting, a winding bay throngh the dense wood. i had come from afar, from farthest Asia, and had almost forgotten the charm and splendor of Hindostan. At such a time it is enchantment to see it again, unique as it is and matchless. The sun was already low, and shed a glory of color on the river up which [ had come; the palms, where it touched them were gold—wonderful gold—and the air seemed full of gold dust. On theslope of each bank, at the foot of the palms, which form vast green hangings, sat groups of Indians watching my boat pulling in. They took grand attitudes, like gods, wrapped in white, red, or orange- colored draperies; and they and their trees and their land and their sky were all bathed in the radiance of an apotheosis.” From India to Obock there is no stop, and here, beneath a fierce sun, on the shimmering, sandy edge of the only continent that still pre- serves any mystery, for us the journey ends, The sketches of ‘‘ The Death of Admiral Cour bet "and ‘An Old Salt,” included in the vo- lume, are profoundly pathetic. The spirit of melancholy that lurks in aM the pages domi- The Nation. nates these; yet it is a gentle and tearful melancholy, not that loathed thing, ‘* Of Cerberus and blackest midnight born.”’ Boys with an appetite for tales of violent ad- venture—that is, all healthy boys—will doubt- less get considerable comfort out of ‘The Black Arrow.’ The scene is in England during the Wars of the Roses, and the personal exploits of the hero, Dick Shelton, have the national strug- gle for background. Dick fights, and loves, and also runs away, in manly fashion. He is the eternal boy, with nothing medizval about him, except his doublet and hose. There isa certain monotony of hacking and killing in his career which, in the mature mind, begets a list- lessness as to its catastrophe. Few are the men and women who retain that youthful joy in deeds of physical daring which the author ap- pears to carry with him from the shooting of the first Black Arrow to the last. The narra- tionis all alive. Dick is always up and doing, always too busy for dull thinking, or for mak- ing critical observations on the radiance of the sun by day or the shine of the stars by night. His physical bravery is no greater than bis mo- ralcourage, which he proves gallantly when his royal namesake, Richard of Gloucester, qualifies a favor granted, with—‘t By the glory of Heaven, there your favor dies.” ‘‘ Mine be the loss,” says Dick, and turns his back upon the glittering future so recently opening before him. In his treatment of Gloucester the au- thor takes no heed of the report of ancient men of the fifteenth century, who had seen the Duke and who affirmed that he was of ‘‘ bodily shape comely enough, only of low stature.” His Richard is entirely the Shaksperean, the popu- lar Richard, and is memorably drawn in the scene outside the church of Holywood, when, behind the files of his army winding along the road, ‘“‘girt by steel-clad knights, the bold, black-hearted, and ambitious hunchback moved on towards his brief kingdom and his lasting infamy.” The little comedy of ‘The Residuary Lega- tee’ is very well managed, and, by way of com- pensation for the flatness of John Austin’s post- humous joke, bas the happy, true comedy end- ing. The tale is based on an extravagance, yet there is no good reason why the hero should not have been endowed with a slight measure of common sense, not to say something like brains. He is represented as an actual, an every-day young man, and a Bostonian be- sides. He is fastidious about what he drinks, and wears garments, or a garment, which the author is pleased to describe as ‘* Poole-built trousers.” He has an obsequious valet named Schmidt, whose name would never disclose the fact that he is ‘‘a sinuous Oriental.” Yet, with all these advantages, the abused donkey has a splendid intelligence compared with that of Mr. Austin May, and, beside him, a monkey is a figure of virility. ‘The King of Folly Island’ includes half a- dozen sketches of New England life, all so like previous sketches by Miss Jewett that we might as well be reading the last volume, or the volume before that. The fishermen, the coun- trymen, the old maids by hill and shore, are familiar friends, and there is no obvious reason tor presenting them under new names, except to keep before us the author’s skill in the de- lineation of them. The last sketch (there is not a story in the volume), ‘‘ Mére Pochette,” is of French Canadian life, somewhere between the settlements, the Eastern States, and the St. Lawrence country. The location is indefinite, but it serves. The sketch does not indicate any more definite acquaintance with the people than with the topography. Mére Pochette, {Number 1214 the several curés, and the rest are conventional peasants, not Canadiens, The sweeping cha- racterization of the habitants as ‘* hardening into stolid farmers,” growing ‘stupid and heavy,” “drinking gin and bad beer,” is an unjustifiably severe criticism of the French in the Province of Quebec. It betrays almost as superficial a knowledge of their actual condi- tion as the reference to ‘‘ merry, vine-growing ancestors” does of their history. It is not re- corded that their ancestors were gloomy, but it is set down with exactness that the vine-grow- ing provinces furnished but few colonists for New France. There were forests and snows and savages to be encountered in the new land—not a prospect seductive to vine-growers, merry or sad. The best that can be said for Miss Jewett’s tentative excursion into foreign territory is that she has not the blighting tendency to mis- represent for romantic effect, and that thus far the Canadians are fortunate in her hands. Miss Reeves is possessed by this tendency, and the Acadians in ‘ A Little Maid of Acadie ’ are the sufferers. Such a family as ber De Landremonts nev er took root in Acadie. Fine folk roamed in Acadian wilds in their day, but few of them founded families there, and none have continued fine for two centuries anda half, as her De Landremonts presumably bave done. The Acadians to be found near the scene of her story, Madawaska, about the head-waters of the River St. John, are de- scendants of those who fled towards Canada, escaping in the untrodden wilderness the depor- tation of 1755, the year still known to the people as that of the grand dérangement, The seig- neurial system never prevailed in their settle ments, and though they are as a rule well-to-do, wealth, power, fashion, are practically un- known words to them. Great allowance should be made for a novelist’s assumption, but the allowance is the more easily made when the assumption is not too evident. Nevertheless, Miss Reeves’s misrepresentations are harmless, and, for an essentially artificial romance, the incongruity between fact and fiction matters not at all. “Harmless” is the word that describes most comprehensively Berkeley’s Proba- tion’ and ‘A Hard-Won Victory.’ The authors of these stories are alike animated by a desire to enforce the necessity of self-sacrifice in order that the whole world may be benefited. In the first instance, a young man is the self-ca:ti- gator, in the second, a young woman. Mrs. Campbell’s Roger uses the scourge with more reason than Miss Litchfield’s Jean, for he per- forms a family duty, whereas Jean only per- mits herself the luxury of unnecessarily assum- ing an extremely disagreeable position. The conduct of these admirable young persons in trial is all that could be desired, and there is enough interest in their experiences to hold the attention and stir the sympatby of amiable and patient novel readers, ‘Virginia of Virginia’ is the old tale of a lowly maid who loved without requital above her station, suffering through that love excru- ciating torment, and for the loved one’s sake a most dreadful death. The loved one, as usual, has no qualities that excuse a mad passion, He is a particularly stolid and insensible English- man, whose chief attraction for Virginia seems to have been that he took so many baths, that his ‘‘ole blue shirt’’ smelled ‘‘ good, kinder briery and soapy.” The incidents of this story, expanded into a thick book by kindly aid of type and margin, are cheaply sensational, Vir- ginia’s character is hysterical and an offence against taste and common sense, while the de- scriptive language is superlatively extravagant. A modification of the coarse and fleshly quali- ‘Roger
Page 21
ther to Dragons.
It is scarcely probable that the | lu e of ] ti sagacity than is i t M exists to-day who could read th ‘Hal icecredited to M.S n " t f don Hall, or inte ist s in to the servant. He as- | us rest in this reprint of tt forty- | serts (FE ror William, transl, v Tin vas ex four years ago is of the it te tha tl neept f tl ! it > > rary curiosities. It is iv that pos nilitary ntest with Austria | ngs to the | t ! terity is the infallible judge of literary great King, and its execut t arck, Moltk N : ness, but if any one should desire personal yt und Von Roor This stat ent is in ac | t ul sy test the truth of that truism, let him mpare ance neither with the facts w t! lata | t t * Pickwick’ and ‘ Hillingdon Hall, Wel 1 | elsewhere furnished by M. Si 1 hin I | \ sa t Jorrocks. If that doubting person should also | di t test against Austria was le | it wish to satisfy himself that the ¢ ral read by Bismar it rankfor ‘ I k | A I ‘ ableness of our second rate nevels is sor ’ William I\ was Kk and t} m pensation for our paucity of first-rate, let him | contest was dist t f udowed in Bis select * Hillingdon Hall’ first among a bundle | marck’s Frankfort despateche I e \ : of the second-rates of the first half of « en liam assumed the Reg \ SOS) with f1 | ny s tury. It appears from the illustrations of t! eelings towards Austria, and a b t ‘ novel that humor, expressed by | rt’ | Prussian and Austrian wns must m not of the highest excellence, ret: t power } wise against dem y sma : t ‘ to amuse longer than that of inferior ! titude at Fra ! N art. The Flathers and Jorro tl Marg t tw t nl i \ t of Bray and the Duch of Dor \ re t cordingly tra erred to S ters I ‘ N us caricature of an insufferably dua nd; but | orde » substantiate } that | \ it is just as easy to laugh at Wildra ! 1 William had alrea l it \ ‘ ‘ of ‘The Guests Departing from D ton ( tria), M. Simon treats this trans isa ‘ty \ tle ’ and ** The Surprise,” as it was t they motior indicating t} ‘ W were d wh, isi ) k’s mor trativ + , + \ tria Bb Bismarck | t ‘ — — ; . i ' ira st ind pict le ises, ad | “ GERMAN HISTORY, BY A FRENCHMAN . ¢ t he was sit om + St As \ « L’Empéreur Guillaume et s Par | Petersburg irly | atat Frar t ‘ . Edouard Simon. S&vo. Paris: Ollendorff id been t hot t t ( LSS6, From St. Petersburg } { v t \ The Emperor Williagin and his Reign I m policy of Prussia du t Ita bi } the French of Edouard Simon. 2 vols vO So) with sha ul outs —s London: Remington & Co.; New York: Serib- | He saw Austria's difficult Prussia’s ner & Welford. 1886. nity; and when Prussia s . | Histoire du Prince de Bismarel Far | 1 ere ees = 5 ard Simon. vo. Paris: Ollend Si prs sam : ‘ W t nis the kK 1 s | s LEmpéreur Frédéric Par Kdou 1 Simon 4 > iers} " su ? As at | l2mo. Paris: Hinrichsen, 188% — .. but as — . I i iS a wn] | Tne biography of the Emperor Frederi fu roval pre ve He led su man to | nishes a natural pendant to M. Simon’s prey S lefend the reorganization vag | Ss books, and affords a welcome occas briefly t the opposition the Diet the int notice the same author’s ‘Emperer William The war of 1866 was Bismarck’s w t Ki iwos - " \ and ‘ Prince Bismarck,’ which together isti was drawn into the strug y st sw } iy tute an excellent history of the making of the This M. Simon « ressiy re t Ss (trans : ‘ new Germany. M. Simon possesses me of | vol. i, p. 177); but he ex} s the relu tails t the best qualities of an historian: patien n! the King to carrv out his own 1 ¥ " ris . x. S search, accuracy in presentation, and fairness | a rding to M. Sim i Sev . t of judgment. The latter quality could not be t re—by tl wsumpt sud S s ‘ put to a severer test 1 these biographies ples S144 for the writer, hims ‘anchman, ibes | But while M. Sin st far shit ‘ the men who worste ‘e In diplom and | ing for the King t act s ft in war, deposed her from the first e ! 4 if the years ISH4-66, it is t that W sats ‘ Continental Powers, and despoiled her t im Was no puppet in t inds of Bismarck . f of her best provinces—and all this in his own Che Prussi =G ists r r 1 schk s - sa : day. We scare xpect a Frenchman t n his recent el it t tot r t t t urt write dispassionately about Pitt or Mett perors } ests t t s Wellington or Bliicher; but M. 8S has | itter rightly that K W Y drawn three of the most typical figures t la sing lant v war of 1N70, not merely without bitt ss, but ra itters s t t st in | ! without a sign of prejudice. An Am i a uld fi re t t: V Roont . t lin ‘T W well find, in Bismarck’s diplomacy ul i t M t i arck i . t practice and a touch of brutality: M.S t xe ¢ . ’ f tl t of Ger may think the same, but he av ls savir t } ssia ac terman 7 Bismarck is obviously, to him, ar s 1 veg t t . t ! the d rij the thetic personage: but he describes t i was t Sas Y it t 1utl s iry in and truly, as the faithful servant of his King | sent 1 ssent . ‘ AS ts hi Such phrases as ‘* pe and country; the man who saw a 1 t t acts of ist dese the outset, the real character of the Ge er war of 1886 it was st at t t I S by the intr nof Old question and the means of solving ind w I . t us r ( . " strong ultramontane bias pursued the solution with inflexil i fG s xtend to t vi i transi | | et tion and the biczhest Irag Mair St t avaria For the Emperor Willia t thor : \\ < : stadt) we ! the three books, we find evidently a warmer feeling—a y t : ve 1 thev se. f ‘ ugh, that ‘ Prince Bismarck’ and rence and almost affection. In M. S S| aseparat : eracy t before this treat Em} William’ contain more historical pages the Emperor William ay irs as vas sig Bisn k i negotiated secret | material, “ ‘Emperor Frederick’ is almost honest and kindly natur id a sti a4 1 + wit these South-German i, vl iphical, The old Emperor and his
Page 22
76 ©) ~~ Chancellor made history; their lives are in- separable portions of a great era. phy of Bismarck is necessarily a descrip ion of A biogra- European politics since 1859; and in his ‘Em- peror William’ M. Simon has set himself to de- scribe the career of the King, not the develop- In this extraordinary life the development of the man was in fact ended, and the ordinary limit of useful activity almost passed, before the career of the King began. Prince William was sixty-one years old when the illness of his brother made him Regent, sixty-three when he became King, and nearly seventy-four when he was proclaimed German ment of the man In the natural course of events the internal development of the new empire during the next seventeen years would have devolved upon But the pro- longed life and vigor of the father, and the strict Prussian tradition, held the Crown Prince Emperor at Versailles. his son. remote from the affairs of state. Once only, in the summer of 1578, when the Emperor was prostrated by wounds inflicted by a Socialist assassin, the Crown Prince was summoned to act as Regent; and the firmness and tact with which he discharged the duties of the office gave earnest of a reign. But in the autumn of the same year Emperor William wise resumed the exercise of the royal power, and As inspector of the South-German armies, he held the Crown Prince returned to private life. an honorable and important, but not onerous, position. He relieved the aged Emperor of mucb of the drudgery of royalty, receiving and making visits of ceremony; and on several occasions he was charged with important diplo- matic missions. But he was best known and most often seen as the patron of letters and art, presiding over reunions and congresses, opening expositions, and distributing medals. When, at last, the Emperor William passed away, full of years and honors, Frederick ascended the throne a dying man. in which he participated are associated in first instance with other names, and his biography The great events is necessarily a record of personal experiences and a study of character. M. Simon therefore tells us much of Frederick’s youth, of his mar- riage, of his domestic life and his foreign The book is more anecdotical than the ‘William’ or the ‘ Bismarck’; but the anec- dotes are well chosen, and serve toillustrate the travels. frank and genial character, the ready tact and kindly humor of the Prince whom all Germany called “ our Fritz.” M. Simon’s book was pub- lished immediately after the Emperor Frede- rick’s return from San Remo to Berlin. It lacks the last sad chapter: we do not see the Emperor dying by inches; and we are spared the spectacle of the strife and intrigue of political parties, court cliques, and differing doctors about the imperiai death-bed. M, Simon’s ‘Emperor William’ has translated into English. If the ‘ Bismarck’ or the ‘ Frederick’ is to be translated, it is to be hoped that the task will be assigned to other hands, The standard of English translation is not high, but work so bad as this is fortu- nately rare. When an English translator is been unaware that there is such an English word as ** customs,’ ’ and speaks sometimes of a Zoll- verein and sometimes of a union of when he the distinction ‘* States” ‘** Estates”; when phrases as ‘‘ declaring war to Austria,” “found- ing himself” on a treaty (meaning basing his action thereon), ‘ governments ” (meaning allied or confederate), and ‘‘ compli- cated in a political trial” (meaning involved); when he speaks of the republic as “prevalent ” in douanes ; ignores between and ‘ he uses such coalesced France, as if it were analogous to smallpox,
The Nation. vinces, and coins such an adjective as ‘‘ con- querous "—tho reader wonders how long and where this foreigner studied English before attempting to write it. The book is also de faced by numerous misprints, often destructive of the sense, e. y.: Federal for feudal (i., 101); Saxony for Prussia (i., 212); minority for ma- jority (i., 280); Prussian for (ii., 44); protest for pretext (ii., 47); agreement for argu- 153); imports for imposts (ii, 250). 2ussian ment (ii., Paper and type are good. GRANT AND THE POTOMAC ARMY. The Personal Memoirs and Military History of U. S. Grant, versus the Record of the Army of the Potomac. By Carswell Me- Clellan, Brevet Lt.-Colonel U. S. Vols., on staff of Gen. A. A. Humphreys, 1862-1504 ffoughton, MitHin & Co. Tuk relations of General Grant to the Army of the Potomac are, and will no doubt long con tinue to be, a moot question in history. Had only his ‘ Personal Memoirs’ been written, the Boston : 1°2m0, controversy would have been softened, though it still would have existed. The modesty of tone and the simple directness of the ‘ Me- moirs’ go far to impress the reader with the sincerity of the writer’s convictions and the honesty of his expression of them, But it inipossible to forget that Badeau’s ‘ Military History’ was avowedly Grant’s own story, and that he had declared himself substantially re- and of opinion, except its personal praise of himself. 1S sponsible for its statements of fact 3adeau’s systematic depreciation of the promi- nent officers of the Potomac army, in order to heighten Grant’s greatness, has therefore (and quite naturally) been taken as the true dis closure of Grant’s personal attitude towards them; and the more considerate tone of the ‘Personal Memoirs’ has been interpreted his habitual modesty of as meaning only that personai expression avoided the sweeping judg ments of his military secretary, which he had endorsed, if he had not dictated them. at least, may be said to be the opinion of a con- siderable party among the officers of that army, and this is the sentiment which is repre- sented in Colonel McClellan’s book. The controversy generally takes even a wider The military soundness of Such, range than this. Grant’s plan of campaign and of his methods is drawn in question, and it is often assumed that it is necessary to argue that he is a greatly overrated man, if the subordinate officers are to be relieved from the damaging effect of His un- The two subjects of contro- versy do not necessarily go together. Grant may have been quite as great a soldier as his most devoted admirers claim, and may yet have been prejudiced and partial in his treat- ment of particular men, or even in his judg- ment of the Army of the Potomac as a_ body. His colossal reputation is an historical fact, and it would seem to be in the last degree im- politic to make the vindication of Warren or the proper estimate of Meade or of Hancock re- quire the conclusion that Grant was not the fit man tocommand the army. <A time will come when the critical estimate of the man and his faults may be made as coldly and judicially as we make that of Marlborough, but it will hard- ly be in this generation. Public gratitude and political prejudices combine to put both friends favorable opinion. and foes in a frame of mind which is anything | but judicial. There is not the same obstacle to fair public judgment when the question is carefully nar- rowed to one of mistake in particular facts or of unjust judgment of a particular man. Even talks of *‘ an equivalent equal to” certain pro- ! in such a debate, however, he is a blind dispu-
[Number 1214 tant who does not see that the reputation of General Grant will outweigh almost any indi- vidual opinion, and put any one who disputes his judgment at an enormous disadvantage. He will be extremely unwise if he lugs in any subject of discussion but the one in hand, or uses any method but the most serious and thorough appeal to clearly stated and well de- fined evidence, After Badeau's ‘ Military History lished, but before Grant wrote his ‘ Personal Memoirs,’ Gen. A. A. Humphreys wrote his ‘Virginia Campaign of 1864 and 1865.’ Few men were so well fitted for the task by experi- He an eminent army engineer, who had also an established re- ’ was pub- ence or by education. was putation as a brave and able commander of troops in the tield. He had been chief-of-staff to General Meade during the greater part of the campaign of which he wrote, and had an intimate personal knowledge of the facts he was dealing with, so far as one man could know what took place in so great an army. His character was of the highest, and his tem- perament of the calmest. He differed from Badeau’s version of the campaign in a number of particulars, portance than others, but, taken together, they Some of them were of more im- would lead to another conclusion than Badeau’s on some of the controverted points to which al- lusion has been made General Warren’s performance of duty and the justice of retiring him from the command of the Fifth Corps at Five Forks. General Humphreys’s method was that of a He did to say when he could not accept Badeau’s state- notably to that touching self-respecting historian. not hesitate ments as accurate, and to give the grounds of difference, either from personal memory from his examination of official documents. He carefully avoided criticism of General Grant, and sought to make his narrative of events so explicit and clear that intelligent readers could draw their own conclusions, In short, his book comes within which wise discussion of or the lines have been above noted, as points in which the author knew the reputa- tion of Grant was in fact behind the statements of Badeau which he criticised. It was there- fore a very positive and weighty contribution towards the settlement of the history of an eventtul period. General Humphreys would have been the last man to claim that the per- sonal authority of his own narrative would override that of General Grant in a matier concerning which both had personal know- ledge, or in which their opinions clashed. He might, however, rightly feel that his deliberate and temperately expressed conclusions would challenge the impartial investigation of stu- dents, and suspend judgment, even in face of an opinion or statement of Grant himself. Colonel McClellan’s book purports. to com- pare the statements of both Grant and Ba- deau with ‘‘The Record of the Army of the Potomac”; but at the outset of his task he de- clares his purpose ‘‘to use, with very little other reference, the work of General Hum- phreys, as embodying substantially the estab- lished record, as far as it shall be necessary to examine it.” Indeed, throughout the book, when the ‘*‘ Record” is referred to, it will be found that a textual quotation from Hum-
phreys 1s made, whether the usual marks of quotation are inserted or not. What in is fact given, is therefore a series of quotations from Grant and Badeau, compared with others from Humphreys, connected by a running com- ment, in which the proof of error in the first two books is supposed to be complete when their disagreement with the last is exhibited. Justice to Colonel McClellan requires_us to
Page 23
‘Lhe N ci I ION.
; te that he defends his metl { vbich s to 1 cf is ( i Vill Acree ith Al vno are t i i rors DY Vin prey sly y pressed an opinion ou the su t } t ivs of General tiw \} hrey i is , , of: + on authorities might W, ll be limited to ofticial pendent com! lint t t ‘ , i 1, but y 3 documents which those ab 4 sult for the purpose of verifying or correcting = Meck s within t ru P ’ , his memory. infant ic that ae se Apart from all such considerations W
Colonel McClellan's
cism is whollv untenable, and s ‘ rly vest ‘Gg ‘ that it was foredoomed that his ! ‘ Grant and Badeau with what ‘ S y at e ‘alls the ‘‘ Record ” could ba
Page 24
278 time, has left such a perfect memorial of itselt as the French spoken in English courts of jus- tice, and written in various instruments of the same period. There are other ancient lan- guages which we know as they were written in history, poetry, or philosophy, and which have left such indications of ordinary speech as are to be found in the drama, or in artificial dis- plays of oratory. But the colloquial phrases and idioms used by men of cultivation in their ordinary avocations more than five hundred years ago, have been handed down in the Year Books, which are, in this respect, absolutely unique.” This very important and interesting under- taking would seem to be included in the plans of the Selden Society. There ought to be a co- operation between this society and Mr. Pike in accomplishing this purpose, but we observe no in the announcements of either to the plans of the other. this volume Mr. Pike has followed the same excellent method as before. Four manu- scripts have been collated, and occasionally more than one report is printed. A comparison of these reports with the original records is con- reference t in stantly bringing out important matter supple- menting, correcting, or illustrating the reports. ‘‘In this way a double task is being accom- plished, as the Year Books are made toserve as a guide for the selection of all that is most im- portant in the rolls, in relation not only to legal but also to social history. The reported cases are almost invariably found to be the most important for all purposes, even though the report be meagre and not easily in- telligible.” The editor of these fers to all the cases in the Book of Assizes and in Fitzherbert which are also found in the pre- sent series. Mr, Pike continues the good custom of point- ing out inthe introduction such cases as seem to him worthy of particular remark, and adds much valuable original matter of his own. Thus the subject of redressing errors in the Court of Exchequer, before the establishing of the Court of Exchequer Chamber, is illustrated by the printing of an important record of the year 1337, volumes re- which shows the successful claim of the Barons of the Exchequer tc correct their own errors at home, by calling into the Ex- chequer ‘‘ other the King’s lieges, among whom were included the Justices of the two Benches.” In discussing the case No. 45 in Trinity Term, the editor refers to the four men neighboring townships, who are summoned in to inform the Court of King’s Bench more fully as to the facts relating to the obligation to repair a certain bridge—as having a func- tion nearly akin to that of modern witnesses, This seems hardly so, for their information ap- pears to have been given to the court during the process of pleading; an issue was subse- quently reached and a jury of trial summoned. These seem to be our old friends who figured, e. g., in the previous century at the Gloucester iter of 1221 (Maitland, ‘Pleas of the Crown,’ xlii-xliv), and their function in this case seems from four | more like that of the secta than of modern wit- | nesses, But the subject is dark. A highiy Novel Disseizin (No, 11 Easter Term) in which the jury gave a special verdict, and were ques- tioned by the judges as to how they knew cer- tain things which were matters of record. They stated how they knew it, not saying that they had ever seen the record, but, according to one report, that they knew it by hearsay, and, according to the record itself, that ‘‘ they had no certain knowledge that there was such a plea or judgment, and they would not absolute- ly say that there was any; but by the summon- ing and resummoning of? Walter and Mar- gery and by the view of the land and because interesting case is an assize of The Nation. it was generally said in the country, . they understood that there was such a plea and judgment.” The court refused to give judg- ment on this verdict till they saw the record, and when it was brought in they declared that, although there was such a record, yet it reiated to a different piece of land from wkat the jury assumed; and so they disregarded this part of the verdict. It is noticeable, however, that in point of this jury right and the court was wrong: the land really substantial justice were was the same. trate the great benefit that these volumes are conferring upon legal scholars by that compari- son and publication of different reports and of the original record to which we have already referred. In another case the editor notes that a deed executed on Sunday appears to have been re- cognized as good, and he rightly remarks that Coke’s quotation of ante-Norman laws to show that Sunday had always been dies non juridi- The first ‘‘Sunday law” since the Conquest appears to have been the stat. 27 Henry VI., c. 5 (1448-49). ‘“‘ After the Reformation, statutes relating to the observ- cus is misleading. aan : | This case will be found to illus- ance of Sunday or the Lord’s Day increased | and multiplied, but there seems every reason to believe that, from the reign of Richard [. to the reignof Henry VL., the distinction between Sunday and other days was but little recog- nized even by the Church, and, of course, not more by laymen than by the clergy.” About a quarter of a century later than the Sunday law of Henry VI. we find it stated as the law of the period, in an argument by Serjeant Pi- got, in 1472 (Year Book, 12 Edw., IV., 8, 22), that ‘““a market cannot be held every day in the week, for on the Lord’s Day no market cau be held as matter of common right, since it is against the law of God. If a return day falls on Sunday, ne court will be held until the fol- lowing day. . . a contract that on the Lord’s Day he became bound to do so and so, it is void, for the con- tract is unlawful. And moreover there is a statute 27 Henry VI. e. 5, that merchandise shall not be shown on the Lord’s Day,” ete. This was in part denied by counsel on the other side, and there was 109 decision, for the matter in issue in the case. But as regards the practice of holding court on Sunday it may probably be taken as correct. Mr. Pike has interesting comments upon a was not practice, which some of the cases disclose, of lending money to another touse in merchandise for the proiit of the lender: ‘‘ The liability was limited and could not possibly extend beyond the amount originally risked. our forefathers enjoyed all the advantages of the ‘ Companies Acts, 1862,’” The only criticism of this excellent volume that occurs to us relates to a mere mechanical It would help the reader such cases as are carried In this respect ete, device of reference. if the numbers of through several pages were placed at the top of each page. The Capitals of Spanish America. By Wil- liam Eleroy Curtis, late Commissioner from the United States to the Governments of Central and South America. — Lilustrated, Harper & Bros, 1888. THE South American Commission of 1884 was, diplomatically, so complete a failure as to be laughable. But the mission on which Stevens went in 1839 was politically barren, while its literary results were highly important. There, we are sorry to say, the parallel does not | hold. Mr. Curtis has got together much in- information. Several of his chap- teresting And if a man counts on } 214 { Number 1 ters, judged as fugitive magazine articles (and in that form many of them first saw the light), make a favorable impression. Fora half-hour’s skipping reading, the book, with the help of the numerous illustrations, would be fitted to almost all tastes. But beyond that it does not seem to us to go. Its name is not happily chosen. Of course, an author should be given great liberty in the selection of his own title ordinarily, but he ought not to choose a misleading one. This is far trom being a handbook to the capitals of Spanish America. Of Mexico, for example, fifty fuller and more accurate descriptions have been published. In general, but the vaguest impressions are left by Mr. Curtis’s handling of the subject proper of his book. Bogota and Quito he did not see, yet his ac- counts of those cities are only a little more in- definite and devoid of local color than in most of the other cases. The title of the book, in fact, seems to have been a despairing recognition of the impossibility of giving a unifying name to the miscellaneous collection of statistics and history, anecdote and narrative, odds and ends about climate, customs, architecture, govern- ment, trade, and politics, drawn from the au- thor’s note-books and reading. It is but fair to the reader to advise him that if he expects to get either a good description of the cities, or a satisfactory account of the history of the countries and the habits of the peoples, he will be disappointed. If we were to speak of the minor inaccura- cies we have noted in the book, there would be noend. A few of the graver faults should be mentioned. Mr. Curtis appears to have car- ried the habits of a Washington newspaper correspondent into his writing of history. Mis- understandings of authorities, frightful mis- translations—above all, a readiness to take an idle tale as demonstrated fact and to print all sorts of rumors as veritable occurrences—are A good instance of the competence of the author as an historian, and, at the same time, asample of his ideas about Spanish, is found in the account he gives of the origin of the name Nicaragua: ‘‘ Here he found on the borders of the lake a vast population of In- dians under a cacique named Nicaro, and called the country in his reports Nicaro’s Agua, or waters; hence the name” (p. 154). Mr. Curtis makes unwarrantable charges against public inen, in the true style of an anonymous and ir- responsible newspaper Such, despatch. at least, in the absence of a shred of procf, we frequent. must account his grave accusations of Presi- dent Cardenas (p. 106). The fact that he states wrongly the date and many of the incidents of the revolution in Costa Rica, of 1870, affords a fair presumption that his whole account of the motives leading up to that occurrence has no historical basis. Not once in the whole book, we believe, is an authority cited. It may also be to Mr. Curtis’s newspaper work that some of his errors in taste and faults of style are traceable. Among the former are to be noted the truly Jenkins-like descriptions of the persons and possessions of certain promi- nent Hispano-Americans, who must, we should think, take great offence at the liberty with which their names are used, if they should see this book; among the latter, the too frequent witticisms, which are usually ckeap, often sala- cious, and occasionally indecent. In point of paper, print, and binding, the book is very attractive. The illustrations, too, are abundant, and most of them successful. They suggest, however, a word as to the proper limits to be observed in the use of old plates. The publishers have drawn pretty freely on their stores, In particwar they have laid
Page 25
~
under contribution the t h Andes and the Amazon,’ Hoiton’s ‘ New Gra Mr. Eaton's other ] i i nada,’
o's I Mexico and her Lost Provinces.’ This is legit upon God It rey mate enough (except that the cuts from the old | Prof. Alexander All
N ation. Eaton's nine chapters is Moreove t produces the thought in | rians ers, who \I en’s *{ itinnity of Chris x , ‘+ plates are too often rior in execu were | tian Thought, which Mr. John Fiske found | wit unt l t it not that sometimes acquainta s of other | reason to approv in his Idea f God t t days are made to masquerade under new | to the effect that the theology of Eastern the Chat names. Thus, the picture on page 316, called | Christendom was much less anthropomorpt s itt the S st f ‘* A Passenger T1 is taken fr Holtor and mu more a smic theis than t pa and 3 f where it is called “ Riding on the Sil/on,” and | theology of the West. This proposition, whi Fa is meant exactly to illustrate the Peruvian side- | is fundamental to Prof, Allen's } k, is retur? sf Sa ‘
saddie in use
nor is exple
ton’s appropriate ‘* A t on Travels” | so contemptuously becomes Curtis's vague ‘t Across the Conti- | sympathies with tl nent” (p. 457 Bishop was pretty thoroughly lv, if the tree can b pillaged to set out Griftin’s ‘ Mexico of To-day Christianity of the but had then to undergo no such surprising and Christianity of the painful transformations as are now wrought " ng in philoso with some of his pic ig wm of | ft moral ¢ nest Bishop is a picture of * fa at Puebla.” | attain A very d In Curtis (p. 9) this ed bodily to | ipter is that ‘t
the City of Mexico \ still more worthy rival | was made under t i i of the Loretto miracle is the ecarrving { some ind fr rand m eon St of Bishop’s buildings from Orizaba to Guat
ma 1 ened. Certain Litu ithe Fut e known by its frurts, t a : : East was better than t v West If the West was the 8 Y hy? t ad se ethir f t i ‘ w the East did not | t : bef stat ial this ¢ .
mala, and of an entire street from the City of fourt} nd s, when August . ft Mexico to the capital of Honduras. We refer | lived and wrote, There is no eviden to the pictures to be found on pages “ and I: existence before the end of the fourth cent i of Curtis and 195 and 49 of B p ind none of its accepta vt Chur ! t t wre the eichtl \ Mr. Eaton’s nd chapter | Ss ( ! . The Heart of the Creeds: Historical Religion | strong than a j Pt inti-Calvinism tha . . : ‘ in the Light of Modern Thought. By Ar-| norvades his book. In view of certain phrases , t thur Wentworth Eaton. G. P. Putnam’s f the New Testament stles. he is mu ¢ ” Sons. 1588. severe upon Augustine and Calvin, as if they ‘ : t Mr. Eaton’s volume is a sign of the times, and | had got their doctrine of human depravity en there are many like unto it That it is not | tirely from their own inner consciousness. It is ue, is clearly shown by the succession of interesting here, as elsewhere, to tind Emers anthologies which precede the s il ipters juoted as a g 1 authority—sometimes t . aS They greatly enhance the value of the book; | very phrases that were anathema to his Unita \ { Org they indicate the sources of the writer's inspira- | rian brethren in his Divinity School address of \ . ‘ tion, and, while th include many es | tv vearsago. What is not irint " Phys " ‘
and passazes from Unitarian writers, so ma | ter upon Christ is others are from contemporary writers in at thir nt 1 of tl least nominal fellowship with evang il 1 homage so 1 1 churches, that Mr. Eaton is clearly seen to } | t 1 ratio!
one of many—the exponent of theological ten- | has ] ied with Mr. Eat mav be inferred dencies which are very deep and wide, and | frot stat t it st’s atanement was : ax which derive their volume and momentum his ‘*r it ft cht freed ‘ ‘ part from tributary streams as fal ’ | tl lient sou ind tha S itv is . Schleiermac! and Matthew Arnold I | ss ¢ by ever however defect K R t problem is how to keep up “* the fori of sound ive his philos ; ‘ ving reas al tey eft | doctrine” and observance when all they on | and g Iness seeks erat vt contained has vanished into thin air, Sebleier- | his own soul from s ‘ ‘ x t : macher, a master of the Hegelian metaphysic, \ chapter on the Creeds gs out t N had great success in doing this. It was really | sharply than the prt ne ers t eas . doubtful whetber any the points of the d | going way in wh t trad ymas are 5 : ‘ vork. the trine were believed by him, but his last act ! entert ed by Mr. Eaton's : s ans ‘ f S ' was to cail for cup and platter to ad ster | The Thirty nine Art : not a trina tw t acterist " the Eucharist, and he had neve tticultv | standard, we ar i Mr. Fat loes not see s Kant itation is c in using theological terms vhy s ker « i not : no particie of their traditi aim i } tosubsen her sa “ f S x t S i indi ¢ Dr. John Caird’s ‘Philosophy of Relig . t e | < t R ‘ < . the it and Dr. Elisha Mulford’s *‘ Reput f God’ | ] -as an his : i : ——y" : st of the crit are the books—-one in Great Britain and ft trin sta . \ 4 s lians ’ he ted against his other bere—that represent tl H n N t ‘ = N ‘ he « P y by] and the scho« Christianity in its most engaging s s f < \ great i featu of Eaton places them first upon t st of s | and. as M ‘ . ‘ al} 7 it possil t enetrate } that have done much to shay rat to. t ns tt s tt s x tatt exp f eater tim shape—his thought. If he had named the than the , sts. Mr. Eat sg rally , than the tinted have tod te we should have known that he had bee very gra 1s tarians ntlv | toit result 4s t went ¢ them. Matthew Arnold's scher for res e t ‘ r S I to r vate } vatem t the Chureh of England int LS ts it ng al sects losopl Lland where the promotion of goodnes retai R nt : ‘ f Pla ha heen tent » lor to articles aud liturgy, while und tthe A c : vast ig it this kind en in miracle and immortality ar : t ’ t t ling of its | t stakes th ™ m } e Kant God, however intellectually remote tf t f but t anv t this and isually deter ed | An ASSO] Hegelian school, had much i n vit F s thus W SAY T < n that will not eXxA { [t , moral tendency But his was vhost Virg g ‘ sel that Kant wa ant of yption and clear-voiced insists t Marv if] i is Pilate, was cruci pl 1‘ projected ystem from his former thing
Page 26
Q2RSO Nothing He lectured on the physical introspective philosophy. could be more unfounded. sciences for forty years before beginning his philosophy, and was a rival of La Place for the honors of the nebular hypothesis. This fact ought to disarm criticism based upon the pre- Kant was perfectly aware of the offence to ‘** common sense ” which his position offered, and hence this effort to point out the connection between metaphysics sumptions of physics, and physics. Besides, he is entitled to the bene- fit of a second and equally significant fact, which ought to have much ad hominem force with the physicist. but an extension of Locke’s and Descartes’s view regarding the ‘secondary qualities” of matter—light, sound, ete. They idealized these, and Kant had only to put the question, Why Kant’s theory of space was not the ‘‘ primary qualities” also, space and time? The physicist everywhere accepts the Lockian and Cartesian doctrine, while Kant’s view has the merit of completeness and consis- tency, whatever may be said of its correctness. To scholars the evidence that Kant construct- ed his idealism with a view to recognizing the most extravagant claims of physical science will be very strong inthe contents of this work, for it is largely occupied with questions for which the physicist will look in vain in the ‘ Critique,’ and which indicate the very prob- lems to be solved by all subjective systems of philosophy. It more than else- where, that the scholar will discover the aftini- is here, too, tics between Kant and Leibnitz ; and this fact is interesting because the compatibility of Leib- nitz’s philosophy with the physical sciences has never been questioned. Although Kant says nothing about *‘ monads,” *‘ preéstablished har- mony,” and other Leibnitzian conceptions of the kind, the influence of Leibnitz is unmistak- ably present in the discussions of force and mat- ter. The commentary helps very much to make this apparent. Highways and Horses. By Athol Maudslay. Chapman & Hall; Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott Co, London: THE title of this book is likely to raise expecta- tions that will be disappointed by its contents, There is hardly anything in the whole five hun- dred pages concerning the breeding, selection, or care of horses, and very little about the con- struction of highways. What there is under the latter head relates principally to the old Roman roads, a subject upon which more satis- factory information can be obtained elsewhere, In fact, the author seems to have had no clear purpose in writing, and to have jotted down whatever occurred to him without regard to continuity. He does not hesitate to quote page after page of Dickens, upon the ground that everybody enjoys reading whatever Dickens wrote; he makes long extracts from the adven- tures of Dick Turpin; he inserts ‘‘ The One- Hoss Shay” entire ; and in general he fills up the gaps between his own observations with miscellaneous clippings from the newspapers. The proper title for this book, or for so much of it as should remain after a severe pruning, would be ‘ Coaches and Coaching.’ Upon these subjects the author has really something to say, and, in spite of his lack of system, he often says it pleasantly. Some of his stories of by- gone days upon the road are worth preserving, but they are generally too long for quotation. There is nothing better, however, in this line than the remark, made some forty years ago by Will Bowers, the Oxford coachman, to Sir Henry Peyton, a famous whip and member of the Four-in-Hand Club, upon the superiority of coaching to railroading: “‘ Why, you see, Sir The Henry, if an accident happens to a coach, why, Nation. there you are; but if an accident happens toa train, where are you?” The time made by coaches immediately be- fore the introduction of railways was very good, averaging eight and a half milesan hour. The Exeter day-coach made 165 miles in seventeen hours, and the Manchester day-coach ran 186 miles during the day. A coach called the ‘Beaufort Hunt” maintained the extraordi- nary speed of eleven miles an hour between London and Bath, except where it encoun- tered steep hills. The ‘* Quicksilver” went down to Brighton on the opening day of Parliament, with a copy of the King’s speech, in three hours and forty minutes—fifteen miles an hour. The regular time of this coach was four hours and a half. With the revival of coach- ing in recent years, this line has been reéstab- lished by an amateur, but the time is now six hours, with a half-hour’s rest. As to the details of coach-building and fur- nishing, Mr. Maudslay supplies a good deal of intormation that may be of interest to amateurs in this country. The proper kinds of timber for the various parts of the coach, their season- ing and painting and varnishing, the axles and wheels and tires and springs, are all described, and directions are furnished for the guidance of purchasers in obtaining what is most ap- proved in the shape of harness, lamps, coach- horns, etc. But, except to those who are specially interested in coaching, the book is not likely to be of much service, and it can hardly be recommended to the general reader. once The Story of Ohio. By Boston : D. Lothrop Co. Alexander Black. 1888, Tuts is the second volume published in the ‘*Story of the States” series. the first having been the ‘Story of New York.’ The book, like Hinsdale’s ‘ Old Northwest,’ lately reviewed in these pages, is a centennial monument to the settlement of Marietta by the passengers of the second Mayflower, in April, 1888, and covers to a great extent the sarne ground as President Hinsdale’s book. The thirty-six very pretty illustrations, and the omission of everything that is dry or unpleasant, betoken a semi-juve- nile work, and it can hardly be criticised from any other standpoint. The of the > comprises 300 pages in large print, followed by ten pages of a chronological epi- tome, an abstract of the Ordinance of 1787 and of the present Constitution of Ohio. Then fol- lows a short list of books bearing on the subject, and a copious index. How difficult it isfor the ‘* story” writer to arouse an interest in the doings of an established American common- wealth may be judged from our author's com- pressing into 146 pages the history of Ohio from its admission down to our own day, while giving up 154 pages to the origines. body “story ” Among these may be found Washington’s first cam- paign to the forks of the Ohio; the expedition which wound up in “ Braddock’s defeat ”; the defeat of St. Clair, and the victory of Mad An- thony Wayne—all of which, though of great importance to the settlement of Ohio, took its But the expedi- tion of George Rogers Clark, by which the re- volting Americans took the Northwest, is wholly ignored. The establish- ment of the Moravian missions among the De- laware Indians at Gnadenhiitten, by Heckewel- der and Zeisberger, is not related in the narra- place beyond borders. possession of tive; we only read how the settlement was de stroyed and the ‘‘ praying Indians” were mas- sacred in the ‘‘last winter of the Revolution” by a party under Col, Williamson. Gov. Ar- { Number 1214 meddlesome, overbearing blunderer, who made the powers of the Executive, and above all the veto power, for ever odious to the people of Ohio. much the more admiration, not only by reason of her beauty and grace, but also of her courage, her horsemanship, and her skill with the rifle. One of the illustrations shows her sitting on horseback, while young Brant, son of the mighty Mohawk chief, passes by and throws sheep’s-eye glances at her. The old story, that by refusing to marry him she brought an In- dian war on the first settlers of Ohio, is given for what it is worth. The story of Ohio, when it entered upon Statehood and since, is told with a strong bias against slavery and slaveholders. Due praise is bestowed on Ephraim Cutler (son of Dr. Manasseh Cutler, the founder), who, in the Convention of 1802, by his word and vote, turned the scale towards the total exclusion of But his daughter Louise comes in for so slaveholding. A long chapter is devoted to the ‘‘ Underground Railroad” and its worthy President, Levi Coffin. Mr. Black gets the origin of Mormonism within his jurisdiction, which Joseph Smith with his little band of * Latter Day Saints” made at Kirkland, in Lake Coun ty, Ohio, but also, and mainly, through the cir- not only by reason of the short stop cumstance that a young poet, Solomon Spauld- ing, living at Conneaut, in the Western Reserve, wroie an unpublishec poem, under the title, ‘The Manuscript Found,” which the ** prophet” and turned Book of Mormon. shrewe came across into his Blennerhassett’s Paradise, and the serpent Burr who entered and ruined it, also find their way into our story, though the island on which the refined [Irishman lived was a part of Virginia. notwithstanding their powerful influence in shaping public sentiment in Cincinnati and The Germans of Ohio, other large cities of the State, are disposed of The struggle between temperance and free liquor, which has for nearly forty years held the foremost place among local questions, is not alluded to at all. The faction fights, growing out of the entry of the Standard Oil Company into State politics,are passed over in silence. But the great men whom Ohio has furnished to the nation are mentioned with much pride Grant, the Shermans, Sheridan, Hayes, Gar- field, Chase, Waite, and Wade, and the late George R. Locke (Petroleum V. Nasby). in a few lines of foot-note on page 2S. Peninsular Catifornia: Some Account of the Climate, Soil, Productions, and Present Con- dition chiefly of the Northern Half of Lower California. By Charles Nordhoff. & Bros. 1888. In this unpretentious narrative of a hundred pages, Mr. Nordhoff relates the steps he took to satisfy himself of the wisdom of making an Harper investment in Jand lying along Todos Santos Bay, and gives the results of his inquiries and personal observation as to the situation and prospects of the Mexican Territory. He opens with a brief historical summary, which will do till Bancroft’s promised volume on Lower Cali- fornia appears, when, of course, it will be but a cockle-shell to a royal seventy-four; basa chapter on the query which ninety-nine read- ers out of a hundred would at once put—why t}e peninsula was reputed a desert ; and then proceeds to display his evidence of the Terri- tory’s wealth and development, particularly under the operations of the Internationai Com- pany holding vast grants from the Mexican Government, and to make a clear and satisfac- tory statement of the legal rights and privi- thur St. Clair is to our author not a hero, buta leges of settlers and purchasers under the Com-
Page 27
Oct. 4, 1888] ‘rhe Nation.
pany’s titles. The author frankly writes as an Firth, C,H. Johnson's Lives of the Poets: Milton ‘ ‘ +s Rooks and 3 « 7 tats : lacm 4 nts Min x $ advocate, but, so far as our knowledge goes, Fowl s of the 3 strate v ’ A Seas . on t with scrupulous fairness. His prophecies are | 4; ° e Adva { Weste tter: not too glowing, and may very easily all be ful ) \ x $1 r ate - . Hartner, Fva Pythia’s Pupils A Story for ¥ Bins filled, we should think But no one ought to tirls. George | ge Sons. $1. Sha : : , Hi rovdsmiit he Tra vl M n& imitate the author’s example without imitating ‘ > cents ‘ A : ss | ' } e s ¥ ‘ his caution. Noschemes of colonization have 7, dat & ¢ y : ‘ : s . LN 2 been more disastrous than some tried in Lower Huge. ¥. ON s Ninety j . [Translated by Mrs l i Bos n l . California. Some of Mr. Nordhoff's Mexican Rrown & ¢ I ‘ vell& : +) Hugo, V The M Ww , Ry P s . : authorities are belated. Following a publica king \ I ws Y. Crow \ tion of 1874, he puts the population at 23,000, or | Ty h. He the | Tt sibsaeniuelie . , | nas \ aker under. It was offlci: ald declared last year t erram,€.S. The Second Ok Nenopl Ana ? ? 2 ’ : ‘ Macn ar AX ( i wuts be 34,668. Senor P: ‘0 is mistakenly called |) Kirkland the MeVey An Episode ‘ : ‘ th NR ie fae Houghton, Mifflin & Co, 1e Secre ary ol apni Lreasury (p. i nerfs w. HOW eat rt ¢y s hk ‘ ra iby Boukgt 3 t Hou wim & Co 6 \ BOOKS OF THE WEEK Charles ¢ t a i : $ Allen, The Devil's Ch ’ ni MePhe un. EF. Handb r sf 458 W Atkinson. | Phe Elements of klectri iting l ingt " ( tm Nostrand. Middlet \ S N . 1 Capt ’ upliy ‘ ‘ s t Xx \ v. J rly ‘ ter un & ‘ \ , * i \I x ? qs " ( I MT, , oO. $1.50 Sons. § : ‘ \ rhe ‘ h ailw \ bo v x $ a Wa X f \" I « Farrineto Margaret Vere ry i t t his Knigit fthe I ind Tat I r I N ! Ss ¢ 3 ‘ Putnam sons J n& ) ‘ ris \ Fay, Prof. EF. A. Concordat ft I I Mask dia Boston: Litt Brov S hia orn ‘ > PROT E IN| ] DY » . ca a ) i ) ) - ) —s ) — u¢ Fi it VW. | YT ie 2 1 \ il} ) ‘ | i ~ ( ) 4 recent Valuable Book: x sr ES I IRODS. The ism which teaches that waste makes wealt By BLISH} \ Frof. Wm. G. Sumne léme, cloth, $ Post paid 3 rue ‘ 7 ; ia i 1-2 . Henry Hour & Co., 29 W. 23d St., N. Y \\ \ | ERMAN X AME Ie _ ss Cambridge, Mass, ler PARIS ILLUSTRE, | soecinstony’siger ‘aie seve vans rae Pay |
K 1 ’ t x . = French edition published weekly, by Goupil & . 4 x Co.'s successors Every Issue CONTAINS Specimens ] : x us 4 liv at of the best work of the most famous tists t Professor Charles ar asa x kof Europe, beautifully illustrated in color readi in Economie Histor t ar an rea een adopted f is pos “ his paper has no equal a ted r ino A sve tit 2 3 riodicals cither in Europe ¢ i i e in political see ‘ . Anew edition of this weekly, with ENGLISH It rudmirably adapted for t nd im view TEXT, will appear eariy in Octole I ‘ t? t Ya published in America simultiane sly with) the t is worth more than is cl i fo \ French edition in Paris hole Agents éav the o be is com " oe a ant cs — rince Vance The International News Co., | counts: sina"to ‘make focsiie a new branch NEW YORK AND LONDON. Hab'fa
AMERICAN AND FOREIGN ral <T \ . STA S : s . W. Tauss Assista fess ’ — ; . School and Coll ege Text: books Feonomy in Harvard y, auth Phe Book of Christmas. AND SCHOOL STATIONERY SUPPLIES earift Bi é' Sta i CONSTANTLY IN STOCK — ; Foreign Text- books scatakuins doe thane ak Gieiaies ek Gendeae te ; ; ‘ IMPORTED AT SHORTEST NOTICE AND LOWEST . of tariff legislation. the argument oa the tariff. RATES. the discussion of its effects . f i 5 Union Square, N. ¥ TM d {INT ENGLISH STATUTES : . of . LO1 State St licag aitt gen ° - Brentano's, ) sare Are Wen ek ee eirconere FRENCH, GERMAN. shiarcibe ealant Up citer sindintnet ip hab, ys be for Cat mas a rE SP: RMAN 7 ANISH, ITALIAN, | Seitalscti® iene ema co EE
You can, by ten weeks’ n r S¢ ? ‘ langu: ages sufficiently for siness ” o . . b . versatio by Dr. Ricw. 8S. Ro t rate : ss ' ft . MEISTERSCHAFT SYSTEM," T r books of ss < eas a ol each language, with privile ge of 3 ] “ ? . ions, and correction of ex py rt ™ . as , : cents. Liberal terms s so. 8 t . MEISTERSCHAFT PUBI ISHIN¢ + BOSTON, MASS, s $ in a Ss M ! lasses scopes, ¥ . ic Cane for D ss. Ear Cornets. et . , ‘ : c Pi i ERTS BI rHERS, Bost , Optician, 41 Cnion Sjuare, New York }. iicceilie nde Pras “ he Cc logues by enclosing stamp Established 18 as : tos ; ; - ‘ Ss t S « wes Miser ane 4 Books Fore Language r f . - at cuer application Forets Perlodicals Boston
it St
Page 28
2. B82 Ma cmillan & ‘9° S NEW BOOKS. New Volume of the Dictionary of Na- tional Biography. rice in cloth, 33.75; in half morocco, Tol. XVI. (Drant—Edridge) of the Dictionary of National Biog- raphy. Edited by Leslie Stephen. This day, $6.50 * One of the best edited. as it is one of the most use- ful and important enterprises known to our day and weneration. . . Obe cannot exaggerate the help thus afforded to the student of eve ry branch of human activity, and particularly of English literature. . . We have also pointed out the interest which Americ: ins have in this Dictionary. especially in the case of the founders of the several colonies, but also all along the line down to the present time. These and many others touch our history in many me- morable ways. . All these articles can be read with the greatest proms. and should be accessible in every library in the land, to say nothing of every gentleman’s library, whither this D.ctionary should find its way, even if merely in recognition of so lauda ble and costly an enterprise.’’-—Nation. Collected Edition of Robert Browning. NEW VOLUME. The Complete Works of Ro- bert Browning. Vol. VI. ‘‘ Dramatic Lyrics” Globe 8vo, $1.50. of 16 volumes. and * Luria.” This edition will consist Published monthly. ] - y . , “ A Popular Handbook to the National Gallery, Including, by special permission, Notes collected from the Works of Mr, Ruskin, compiled by Edward T. Cook, with Preface by John Ruskin, LL.D., D.C.L. 12mo, cloth, $4.00: half morocco, $4.50, Also, an edition on large paper, limited to 250 copies. 2 vols., Svo. ** Here we have at last a guide to the Gallery, which is at once adequate and Coumendabie - The hook Is full of historical aad biozraphical information, andone of its greatest chars is the lavish quotation from the works of Mr. Ruskin, which their author has specially and amlab.y permitted.”’—- London Globe, New Volume of The trated Magazine. The English Hlustrated Magazine—1888. A handsome volume, consisting of containing Extra cloth, English Ilus- With 500 Pictures, 852 closely nearly 500 $2.50, printed pages, and illustrations, THe ENGLISH with * A new volume of ILLUS- TRATED MAGAZINE the October number. Price, 15 cents, annual subscription, $1.75. begins Clarendon Press New Books. JOHNSON’S LIFE OF MILTON. ed, with Notes, etc., by C. H. Firth, M.A., College, Oxford. 16mo, paper, 40 cents. BUCHHEIM’S MODERN GERMAN READER. PartI. A graduated collection of ex- tracts in Prose and Poetry from modern German writers. Edited by C, A. Buchheim, Ph.D., with English No'es, a grammatical appendix, and acom- plete vocabulary. Fourth edition. 16mo, 60 cents. ELEMENTARY POLITICAL ECO- NOMY. By Edwin Cannan, M.A., Ballio! College, Oxford. 16mo, 25 cents. ** Mr. Cannan displays a complete mastery of the es- sentialelements of his subject. . . One of the most sugwestive bi 0ks that have appe: ired on the sub ject for some time,’’— Fall Hall Gazette. MACMILLAN & CO., New York, 112 Fourth ’. Edit- Balliol Avenue ° ~ ~ The Nation. Longmans, Green & Co. HAVE JUST READY: The Life of the Right Hon- ouvable Stratford Can- ning, Viscount Stratford de Redcliffe, K.G.,G C.B., LL.D., etc. From his Memoirs and private and official With $12.00. papers, By Stanley Lane-Poole. 3 Portraits. 2 volumes. Svo, cloth, » ~ The Record of a Human Soul. By Horace G. Hutchinson. 15mo, cloth, $1.00, Our Kin Across the Sea. Firth. 12mo, cloth, $2.00. ‘ Mr. Firth has read much, and has thought - observed more, and what be says deserves and will receive respectful attention. . . . In the work before us he describes a tour through the United States; and hackneyed and thread- bare as the subject has become, Mr. Firth brings to 1t a new mind, and he has studied his American cousins from an original point of view.”—Extract from Preface. By J. C. Froude. With a preface by J. A. WorkKs BY CARDINAL NEWMAN. Apologia Pro Vita Sua: Being a History of his Reli gious Opinions, By Joha Henry, Cardinal Newman. Crown S8vo, $2.00. The Idea of a University De ~. dand Ilustruted, 7th edition. Crown Svo, 32.5¢ Historical Sketches. Volume t. — Volume Il. Crown S8vo, $2.00. Volume III. Crown 8vo, $2.50, Discussions and Aryun ents oa Various Subjec's. Svo0, F2.0 An Essay on the Crown 8vo, $2.00 Certain Difficulties felt by Anglicans in Catholic ing Considered, Volumel. Crown 8vo, $2.50. Volume Il. Crown 8vo, $2.00. The Via Media of the Anglican Church. Tlus srate din Lectures, etc. 2 vols., crown 8vo, each, $2.00. Essays, Critical and Historical, 2 20g 8vo, $4.00. Essays on Biblical and on Crown 8vo, $2.00, An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of Assent, $2.50. Crown dSvo, £2.00, Crown Development of Christian Doctrine. Teach- Ecclesiastical Miracles, Crown 8vo, The Arians of the Fifth edition. Crown 8vo, 82.00 Select Treatises of St. Athanasivs in Controversy with the Arians, 2 vols., crown Svo, $5.00, Verses on Various Occasions, Crown 8vyo, $2.00, The Dream of Gerontius. 23d edition. 16mo, 20 cents; cloth, 35 cents. x1rochial and Plain Sermons. New edition. fold separately. Eacn, cloth, $1.75. Fifteen Sermons Preached before the University of Ow- Jord, between A.D. 1826 and 1813. New edition. « row n 8vo, cloth, $1.75. Fourth Century. sewed, 8 vols, Sermons Bearing upon Subj ects bf the Day. New eii- tion. Crown 8vo, cloth, Selection, Adapted to the Seasons of the Ecclesiastical Year, from the * Parochial and Piain Sermons,’ Crown svo, cloth, $1.75. Lectures on the Doctrine of Justification. tion. Crown &Svo, $1.75. Fourth ei Messrs. Le Green & Co, will be happy to send their DPLOACHIES, Catalogue of General and Educa- tional Books post free to any address furnished for the purpose. LONGMANS, GREEN & CO., 15 East Sixteenth St,, New York, @e {| Number 1214 APPROVED TEXT-BOOKS FOR PRIVATE SCHOOLS. Messrs, IVISON, BLAKEMAN vite attention to the subjoined list of Text- Books, selected from their Catalog & CO. in- 1e of Publi- cations, as specially adapted for private schools. Teachers dissatisfied with any books now usd in their classes are invited to correspond with the publishers regarding the following: SWINTON’S READERS. -- In Five Numbers, supplemented by a Siath or Classic English Reader. Fresh and attractive in methods of teaching, character of the selections, iilustra- tions, paper, and binding. SWINTON'S ADVANCED RWADERS, — In Four Books. Fitted to supplement the author’s or any other school reading books. THE GEOGRAPHICAL READER.— Being a revised edition of Guyot’s Introduction to Geo- graphy. Adapted to all grades. DR. LOCKWOOD’S READINGS IN NATU- RAL HISTORY.—Part 1, Mammats. Part 11. stories of Animals and Birds, beautifully told by **an old naturalist.’ WHITE’S INDUSTRIAL DRAWING — Re- vised. —The latest and best course. SWINTON'S GEOGRAPHIES.—- Course—the Introductory and the School. METCALF’S SPELLING Birds — Delightful Two-Book Grammar AND LANGUAGE 300K —Modern methods, by an experienced teacher. SPENCERIAN COPY - BOOKS. Small and Large. Adapted to every grade. FISH'S ARITHMETICS.—A complete course in two books. ROBINSON'S HIGHER MATHEMATICS, TENNEY’S NATURAL HISTORY OF ANI- MALS.—Profusely Iliustrated. DANA'S GEOLOGICAL STORY BRIEFLY TOLD. — Simple and attractive in methods, and charming in style. GRAY’S SCHOOL AND FIELD BOT ANY—Revised. — Issued just death of the distinguished wuthor. PHYSICAL GHOGRAVDPHY. The BOOK OF before the GUYOT'S } } righest American authority. COOLEY’S CHEMISTRY FOR BEGINNERS. Recently issued and fally representing the present state of the s« ience, TEXT-BOOK OF PHYSICS, and teachable book. TOWNSEND'S SHORTER COURSE IN CIVIL GOVERNMENT Treating Natioual, Stute, County, and Municipal Principles of Govern ment. SWINTON'S OUTLINES OF THE WORLD'S HISTORY.—7J he most widely used book of its class. FISHER’S HISTORY. tant in English. COMPTON’S FIRST COOLEY’S NEW An interesting OUTLINES OF UNIVERSAL The best work of its class ex- ‘—N. ¥. Tribune. LESSONS IN WoOopD- WORKING.—Gives such specific and exact directions as willenable any teacher to begin the work of manual training. NEARLY READY. Harper’s Inductive Latin Method. Harper’s Inductive Greek Method. By WILLIAM R. HARPER, Ph.D., of Yale Uni- versity. Gastineau’s Conversation Method with the French. DESCRIPTIVE LIST of the above special descriptive free on application. *,* BRIEF and other publications, or circulars of any book, sent *,* Specimen Copies tor examination furnished on favorable terms. IVISON, BLAKEMAN & CO., 758 and 755 Broadway, New York. 149 Wabash Avenue, Chicago.