The Nation 1888-01-05: Vol 46 Iss 1175
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
‘The Nation THURSDAY, ISS S VOL. XLVI.—NO. 1175 JANUARY 5, CHE Life and Letters SE . E Charles Darwin. INCLUDING j 'TOBIO- AN AUTOBI( SPRAGUI GRAPHICAL CHAPTER. | pik. 121 VOLAPUK. CHLEYER'S the World: rs heeds red Edited by his son, FRANCIS DARWIN. | RERCKHOFE'’S Abric WITH PORTRAITS AND VIEWS OF DOWN HOUSE, DARWIN'S RESIDENCI In two vols., 12mo, cloth. Price Darwin's Complete Works. Origin of Species by Means of Natu- i nof Favored | IWANOWITITS( \ ral Selection, or the Preservat Races in the Strugyle tor Lit ss? OO Descent of Man, and Selection in Re- lation to Sex With illustrat . ] cloth, 33.00 BF KERCKHOFF’S Journal of Researches into the ; 144 Natu- ral History sited | ind Greolagy of Countries \ vare of HOM.S.) Beagle Round i Lime, cloth, a» , _ Dic tronn Emotional E ap rceene of Man and the Lower Anis mo, hs . Westermann & C WAY, NEW \ LK I KE MC i BOOKS. | The Variations of Animals under Domestic: Professot and Plants ition With a t \ Asa Gray vols cloth. so 00 SoS BROA CHI ICE Insectivorous Plants. t2mo, clo a OW) Movements and Habits of Climbing Plants With illustrations | 4 3 heey The Various Contrivance Orchids are Ferti I lustrations immo, « th, Sl The Eft ivn > ' ‘ ‘ Za il i Cy fects of Cross and Ik cloth, <2 00 Different Forms of Flower of the sat Species Wit Limo, cl ith, S1 The Power of Movement With illustrat ns l 1O, The Formation of Veget through the I vations on their -Ino, ¢ Complet Letters tles, $30 APPLETON Put 5 Bond Street, New York. © set, & CO.,) WILLIAM R. JENKINS, ; 3, & INSU RANG AtHantic N Vasher Tad ‘ «)\ ANY, rTAMONT. KA TIMORE,MD re Most beautiful sur re and families best ventilat!
Page 2
The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science, and Art. FOUNDED 1865. {Entered at the New York City Post-office as second class mail matter. } CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. Cy SO) Pe ee ere re eee rer rey 1 EDITORIAL ARTICLES : Reform of the House by Constitutional Amend ment ; ee The Blair Bill Once More 5 Pictures and Picture-Buyers 6 The Chace Copyright Bill 7 Protection to Liquor- Dealing re 8 Mutations of the Book Trade in Germany 8 SPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE ; The Yellowstone Park as a Forest Reservation +f Chamber and President in France....... ee CORRESPONDENCE : The President’s Message acs Sane ees eee waaieee eg 11 How is the Tariff to be Modified ? 1 ; 1 In This Connexion ”’ ‘ « (ae Robert South and the Encyclopedia Britannica 1 LEVIEWS: Renan’s History of Israel 16 Crawford's Story of Sumter er . 17 Howells’s Modern [tallan Poets , ; .. ae Vinter 7 1!) Philosophy of Theism : 1) The Standard Cantatas gentacuwie 20 Half-Hours with American History 20 BOOKS OF TE WO oie ons obese esses sti vocworeess 20 TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three Dollars per year, in advance, postpaid to any part of the United States or Canada; to foreign coun tries comprised in Postal Union, Four Dollars. The date when the subscription expires is on the Ad dress-Label of each paper, the change of which to a sub sequent date becomes a receipt for remittance. No other receipt is sent unless requested. The paper is stopped at expiration of the subscription, unless previously renewed, Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made
by registered letter or by check, express order, or postal | order, payable to ** Publisher of the NaTIos,”’ When a change of address is desired, both the old and new addresses should be given. Address THE NATION, Bow 794, New York. Publication Office, Broadway. TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Agate ee lines. [No deviation. ] On any page not specified, 75 cents per line each insertion; with choice of page cents, ee A column (140 lines), #20 each insertion; with — 3 choice of page, #27. af A page (3 columns), #60 each insertion; with — choice of position, #80, ¥ Twenty per cent. advance for top of columnor __ 10 other preferred position, when specified; where positions are not specified, advertisements are classified as far as possible and arranged in or- — der of size, the largest at the top. . 15 Twenty per cent. advance for cuts, fancy or __ ther letters not comprised in THE NATION — fonts, and all other special typography (subject to ap proval), Cuts are inserted only on inside pages of cover or fly-leaves, not on outside of cover, nor on pages num bered for binding. Marriage and Death Noti: Ss, cents each. DISCOUNT on yearly accounts amounting to $ , 10 per cent; # » 15 per cent.; $7 per cent.; $7 ,% 2 per cent. Credits are made December On a yearly account amounting to pages the discount is one-third. Advertisements must be accevtable in every respect. Copy received until Tuesday, 5 P. M. THE NATION is sent free to those who advertise in it, as long as advertisement continues. The EDITION of THE copies. tion. NATION this week is 8,70 The Subscription List is always open to inspec- «* Copies of THE NATION may be procured in Paris of Brentano Bros., 15 Boulevard St. Mar tin; and in London of B. F. Stevens, 4 Trafal- gar Square ; George Street, 30 Cornhill, E. C.: and H. F. Gillig & #0. , 449 Strand. Seale of | The Nation. Schools. Alphabetized, first, by States; second, by Towns. CONNECTICUT, Lyme, ILACK HALL SCHOOL,—A FAMILY and Preparatory School for boys. Thorough ir struction and careful training. New and enlarged a: commodations. CHARLES G. BARTLETT, Principal. CONNECTICUT, Middletown. JILSON GRAMMAR SCHOOL. — A 4 Preparatory School for Boys. $500 per year. For Circular address E. H. Winson, A.M. CONNECTICUT, New Haven. 7° PKINS GRAMMAR SCHOOL (founded in 1660). One of the oldest Classical Schools in the U.S. repares for colleges and scientific schools. Has prepared more boys for Yale than any otherschools. For catalogue address GEo, L. Fox, Rector. CONNECTICUT, Pomfret. THE MISSES VINTON S SCHOOL for girls. Second term will begin Feby. 1. Cir- culars sent on application, MARYLAND, Baltimore, 1214 Eutaw Place. V, ISS RANDOLPH §. SCHOOL, Sarak tL N. Randolph, Principal. An able and experienc- ed corps of teachers offers unusual advantages to the pu- = of this school, Students are prepared for col ege. MARYLAND, Baltimore. TNIVERSITY OF MARYLAND .— Law School. Eighteenth annual session, Octo- ber 3, 1887. Address HENRY D. HARLAN, Sec’y. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston. JOSTON UNIVERSITY Law _ School. ) Address the Dean, EpmunD H. Bennett, LL.D. MASSACHUSETTS, BosTON, NSTIZTOLE OF TECHNOLOGY. Courses in Civil, Mechanical, Mining, and Electrical Engineering, Chemistry, Architecture, ete. JAMES P MUNROE, Seec’y. FRANCIS A. WALKER, Pres. MASSACHUSETTs, Boston, 25) Boylston Street. ‘Fo NCY-HALL SCHOOL (60th Year). y Preparation for the Mass. Institute of Technolo ry is a specialty. Reference is made to the Institute Faculty. The location is the most attractive in Boston. Preparation for Harvard, with or without Greek. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 152 Huntington Ave. V it DECOMBES’ FRENCH L and English Home School for six girls now open. Price, $1,000 per year. No extras. Highest references given and required. MASSACHUSETTs, Cambridge, Larch Street. FLOME FOR BOYS.—DR. ABBOT AD- mits not more than four boys into his family, to fit for college or educate privately. Separate tuition, with best of care in all respects. Charming loeation, with fine tennis-court. F. E. ABBoT, Ph. D., Proprie- tor. (No vacancy at present.) MASSACHUSETTS, Northboro LLEN HOME SCHOOL FOR TEN Winter term opens January 4 E. A. H. ALLEN. F boys MASSACHUSETTS, Plymouth. | R. KNAPP’S HOME SCHOOL FOR d Boys (twenty-first year).—Begins September 22, 1887. MASSACHUSETTS, Quincy. ADAMS ACADEM Y.— PREPARA- Ps tory boarding school for boys. School reopens January 9, 1888. For all information apply to WILLIAM EVERETT, Ph.D. f= M ASSACHUSETTS, S. Williamstown, Berkshire Co. ( REYLOCK INSTITUTE.—A PRE- paratory School for Boys. 46thyear. Catalogues on application. GEORGE F, MILLs, Principal. NEW JERSEY, Short Hills. : IAQUET INSTITUTE. THOROUGH English, French, German, and Classical Boarding and Day School for Young Ladies and Little Girls. Lo- eation unsurpassed for beauty and healthfulness, Win ter term will begin February 2, 1888, For Circulars ap- ply to Miss HARRIET STUART BAQUET. NEW YORK, Suspension Bridge. iF VEAUX COLLEGE.—A Military Boarding School for Boys. WILFRED H. Munro, A.M., President. NEW YORK, Syracuse. | Mh RS. C. M. WILKINSON'S HOME d School for Girls. Number limited to ten. $1,000 r vei No extras. School year begins September 14, 1887. Refers to Hon. Abram S. Hewitt, George Wm. Curtis, Hon. Wayne MacVeagh, Rev. Edward Everett Hale, Thomas Wentworth Higginson, Louisa M. Alcott, Hon. Andrew D. White. NEW York, Utica. a | RS. PIA TT S SCHOOL FOR YOUNG d Ladies.—The next school year begins Thursday, Sept. 20th, 1888. Applications should be made early. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, 1350 Pine St. TSS ANABLE’S BOARDING AND Fs Day School for Young Ladies will reopen Sept. 22. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, Chestnut Hill. | ff RS. COMEGYS AND MISS BELL'S 4¥£_ English, French, and German Boarding School for Young Ladies reopens Sept. 28. Students prepared for College. Ample grounds afford adv antages for outdoor exercise, Additional class) 1 recreation-rooms built during the past year,
[Number 1175 JAMAICA, Potsdam School, Sta. Cruz Mts. THE REV. W. D. PEARMAN, M.A. (Cambridge), prepares forjBusiness and Universi ties. In the Cambridge University Local Examis., 1854, a Potsdam boy stood 2d in Greek and 10th in Latin, of all England. For terms apply as above. ry. Teachers, etc. A HARVARD SPECIAL, Experienced, desires a position as resident or travelling tutor. Address P. O. Box A, Cambridge. A PH.D. OF THE JOHNS HOPKINS f University, wishing to teach Greek and Latin exclusively, desires a change in position, Address E. M., care of the Nation, New York (<=. W. STONE, Tutor for Har- vard, 68 Chestnut Street, Boston. F inert TE TUITION BY HOUR OR month for College or Law. FE. Heaton, B. A., Ox ford, Barrister at Law. E. Kershaw, B. A., Cambridge. 305 Fifth Avenue ANTED.—A HARVARD GRADU- s ate to assist a schoolboy In New York city in preparing for the Harvard entrance examinations. Ad dress G., care of Nation, School Agencies. YARDEEN’S SCHOOL BULLETIN Agency, Syracuse, N. Y., may be depended on to furnish suitable teachers and to inform no others. ~@ASTERN EDUCATIONAL BU- « _reau, 50 Bromfield St., Boston, supplies teachers for all grades. Circulars free. W. A. Mowry, Pres. WALTER H. Mowry, Mer. THE BOSTON TEACHERS’ AGENCY Supplies Teachers to Schools, Positions to Teach ers. Circular free. E. O. Fisk, 7 Tremont Place, Boston. ( NION TEACHERS’ AGENCY, 16 Astor Place, New York City. W. D. KERR, Sec retary. Send for circulars, and list of places filled. Wants. ANTED.— WILL GIVE $1 EACH for Financial Chronicle, vol. 1, No. 1, Hlunt’s Merchants’ Magazine, Feb., L868, Nov. , 1870 ; A.S. CLarK, 34 Park Row, New York City
Professional. SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT AND leader writer on a LEADING LONDON DAILY PAPER is open to an engagement for a weekly letter to an American paper. Adress ** F. M.,” care of Me srs. Street & Co., 30 Cornhill, London, England. HARLES ELIOT, LANDSCAPE Architect, 9 Park St., Boston.
THE ENGINEERING & BUILDING RECORD ESTABLISHED, 1877, ConoucTeo By HENRY C. MEYER. OEVOTED TO ENGINEERING AND ARCHITECTURE. OF SPECIAL INTEREST TO
ENGINEERS, ARCHITECTS, Builders, CONTRACTORS, MECHANICS, AND MuniciPAL OFFICERS. THE TREATMENT OF MUNICIPAL PROBLEMS A PAOMINENT FEATURE. “*It has been of incalculable value to the general public, whose interest it has always served.”’— Cincin- nati Commeriatl. ** Tt may be regarded as the representative paper de- voted to Architecture and Engincering.’’— Boston Herald. **It stands asa fine example of clean and able jour- nalism.”’—Aailroad Gazette. ** A paper whose excellence and independence merit continued prosperity.’”’"—Aalroad and Engineering Journal. ** Congratulate it upon the enviable position it has attained.””—A merican Machinist. Published Saturdays at 82-84 Fulton Street, New York. $4 per year. roc. per copy. N. B.—An attractive feature is its lseries of critically selected Architectural Illustrations, artistically rendered and handsomely reproduced. Te Y ~ ~~ £4 LANGUAGES. The Meisterschaft System, by Dr. Richard S. Rosenthal, is the only successful method ever devised for one to learn to speak without a teacher, and in a few weeks, FRENCH, GERMAN, SPANISH, OR ITALIAN. Endorsed by leading linguists. Terms $5.00 for books of either language. Sample copy. Part I, 25 cents. Liberal terms to Teachers. MEISTERSCHAFT PUBLISHING Co., BOSTON, MASS. A MARVELLOUS BOOK. ml al .T OW ~ TALES BEFORE SUPPER. From Théophile Gautier and Prosper Mérimée. Told in English by Myndart Verelst. And delayed witha yroem by Edgar Saltus. Cloth, $1.00; paper, 50 cts. “The ‘ Tales Before Supper’ belong to an order of odd and entertaining stories which can never be too plenti ful for the delectation of readers who like ingenious plots, fine workmanship, and fiction that does not tax one’s thinking power.”’—Mr. Geo. Parsons Lathrop. Published by BRENTANO, 5 Union Square; 101 State Street, Chicago. For sale by all booksellers.
——
|
Page 3
Srp cee sem Re Oe Jan. 5, 1888] Jarvis-Conklin MORTGAGE TRUST CO KANSAS CITY, MISSOURI. Capital Paid up........ inneee eae we we wee ae $1,000,000 Surplus... tenes ib eveaes cawewunene 100,000 teserve Liability - J 1,000,000 Offers its 6 PER ¢ ‘ENT Debenture Bonds of $500, $1,000, and $5,000, runring ten vears, to TRI —— GUAR DIANS, and INDIVIDUAL INVESTOR S. Secured by first mortgages on real estate worth three tit nes the paying of the loan, and held k~ the MERC ANTILE “RUST COMPANY OF NEW YORK, Trustee Secured aah the entire paid-up capital « if $1,000,000 It also offers GUARANTEED SIX PER CENT. first mortgages on Kansas City business property and im proved farms in KANSAS and MISSOT Ri Call at office or write for full particulars to JARVIS-CONKLIN MORTGAGE TRUST CO.,,
New York City, 239 Broadway, Sent f t stam) Providence, R. I., 27 Custom House St. F Philadelphia, Pa., 144 South 4th St. \ London, England, 95 Gresham St 1? Sere . - WILLIAM EVARTS BENJAMIN rt. . = ” Ye =. x The Middlesex Banking Co., 744 Broedwar. New ¥ MIDDLETOWN, CONN. os Capital Stock, Paid up......... ; $300 000 . - ~ +yN PER CENT. FIRST MORTGAGE OCKET ATLAS SBENTURE. BONI THE WOR ) DEBENTURE BONDS. OF THE WORLD ? nterest payable at Fourth National Bank, New . seus ‘ P . ka ’ York Also Guaranteed First Mortgages. Organized C ontaining Qg2 new and ACCUrAL 1875. Under same supervision as the Savings Banks | Regularly examined by the State Bank Commissioners maps ‘ea % si ae iyi E Vi Oo RY oF 7 W. BAKER & C0., Dorchester, Mass. = owe | iny book earned in ray Re ‘commended by MARK Twaln, Ri HAR Scientist, Hons. W. W. Astor An ENT AMIN i>) MINOR, &« Class f Lim) Imbia Law S . . lasses of 200 eax at Yak 4m) at University of » Phila.; 400 at Wellesley College, and three larg een at Chautaugu University, &« Prospex s s fr m PROF. LOISETTE, 287 Fitt \ N ) 2 = IT Re ION R R PIANOFORTES aTIK RUSIN UNEQUALLED IN hese TONE, TOUCH, WORKMANSHIP, - AND DURABILITY. “Mos WILLIAM KNABE & CO, ; WAN Baltimore, New York, 22 and 24 E. Baltimore St., 112 Fifth Ave., Washington, 817 Market Space. y YAN ELEVENTH TAUCHNITZ and JOUAUST SEASON /:' 2M i a ~~ ag scopes, A s ‘ . 3,000 MILES, 96 D AYS an ‘ of FOREIGN TRAVEL, includiug the princt — |) ae seco : : TRIES, CAPITALS, SIGHTS and SCENES Ail travel Tad #1 y . and boveis Eres class. All expenses included. PARTY + . : SELECT, Fullest enjoyment and protit, with greatest 7 Suages. Mis K “ econ ates time and Abs lute freedom frot Latogues . care. Good management 1 intelligent yma » Books
Page 4
1V Scribner & Weltford’s NEW BOOKS. The Last of the Valors: And the Accession of Henry of Navarre, 1559-1589. By Catherine Charlotte, Lady Jack- son. Large crown 8vo. Cloth, $9.00, In two volumes. With por- traits onsteel, The portraits tothe above work comprise Henry Iif., Henry LV., Henry de Lorraine, Charles IX. , Anne, Duc de Montmorency, Sully, Le Chancelier de VHOpital, Gabrielle d’Estrées, and Catherine de Médicis. Lady Jackson’s previous works on French history are * Old Paris,’ ‘Court of France in the Sixteenth Century,’ ‘The Old Régime,’ *French Court and Society,’ and * The Court of the Tuileries.’ The Court and Reign of francis the first, King of France. By JULIA PARDOER, author of ‘Louis the Four- teenth and Court of France in the Seven- teenth Century.’ With numerous portraits and illustrations on steel. A new edition. Three volumes, demy 8yo, cloth, $15.00. The illustrations to the above work comprise : Francis the First (two portraits by Titian)—Queen Eleanor—The Emperor Charles the Fifth (two portraits by Titian)—Duke of Bourbon and Con- stable of France (by Titian)—The Chevalier Bay- ard—Henry the Eighth (by Holbein)—Henry the Kighth Embarking for France—Ignatius Loyola (by Wierix)—Marguerite de Valois, Catherine de Médicis (two Portraits)—The Duchesse d’Etampes —Diana of Poictiers—The Duke of Alva (by Schu- bert)—Annas Montmorency, Constable of France—and Julia Pardoe. The cover of the book is from a design by Diana of Poictiers. de Pen and Pencil tn Asia Minoy. Or, NOTES FROM THE LEVANT. LIAM COCHRAN, Member of Arts, London By WIL- the Society of formerly of the Asiatic Society, Illustrated and and Shanghai. with Kighty-nine Engravings, made chietly from Water-Color Sketches by the Author. Demy Svo, cloth extra, $6.75. Recorits of Shelley, Pyron, and the Author. By Epwarp Joun TRELAWNY. New Edition, with two Portraits. I2mo, vellum cloth, 1.75, # The Nation. ** The respectable and sometimes excellent tran:- lations of Bohn’s Library have done for Literature what railroads have done for internal intercourse.” —RK. W. Emerson. ‘*T may say in regard to all manner of books, Bohn's Publication Series is the usefullest thing I know.’’—Thomas Carlyle. Bohn’s Libraries. CONTAINING STANDARD WORKS of EUROPEAN LITE- RATURE in the ENGLISH LANGUAGE, With Dictionaries and other Books of Reference, Comprising in all Translations from the French, German, Italian, Spanish, Scandinavian, Anglo-Saxon, Latin and Greek. 687 Volumes, $1.40 or $2 each, with exceptions, RECENT ADDITIONS. RANKE’S HISTORY OF THE LATIN AND TEUTONIC NATIONS. Translated by P. A. Ashworth, Translator of Dr. Gneist’s ‘History of the English Constitution.’ HEINE’S TRAVEL-PICTURES: including the Tour in the Harz, Norderney, and Book of Ideas, together with the Romantic School. Translated by Francis Storr. With Appen- dices and Map. GOETHE'S CORRESPONDENCE WITH ZEL- TER. Selected, Translated, and Edited by A. D. Coleridge, M. A. THE STUDENT'S HANDBOOK OF HISTO- RICAL GEOLOGY. By A. J. Jukes- Brown, B. A., F. G.S., of the Geological Survey of England and Wales. With nu- merous Diagrams and Illustrations. WERNER’S TEMPLARS IN CYPRUS. Translated by E. A. M. Lewis. ** Werner was a Freemason, and his religious notions were, at the date of his writing this poem, of a theoso phie order.’’—Preface. PAUSANITAS’S DESCRIPTION OF GREECE. Translated into English, with Notes and In- dex, by A. R. Shilleto, M. A. 2 vols. HOFFMANN’S TALES. The Serapion Breth- ren. First Portion, containing Thirteen Tales. Translated trom the German by Major A. Ewing. HAUFF’S TALES. The Caravan—The Sheik of Alexandria—The Inn in the Spessart. Translated by S. Mendel. GOLDSMITH’S WORKS. A New Edition, containing pieces hitherto uncollected and a Life of the Author, with Notes from Vari- ous Sources. By J. W. M. Gibbs. 5 vols. FOSTER’S ESSAY ON THE IMPROVEMENT OF TIME. Together with notes of Sermons and other Pieces. CHRISTIAN ICONOGRAPHY; or, The His- tory of Christian Art in the Middle Ages. By the late A. N. Didron. Translated from the French by E. J. Millington, and com- jeted, with Additions and Appendices, by M. Stokes. 2 vols., with numerous Illustra- tions. TALFOURD'S LETTERS OF CHARLES LAMB. With Explanatory Notes. New Edition, Revised and Greatly Enlarged by W. Carew Hazlitt. 2 vols. HAZLITT’S SPIRIT OF THE AGE; or, Con- temporary Portraits. New Edition. By W. C. Hazlitt. A SELECTION. ANTONINUS.—THE THOUGHTS OF M. AURELIUS. | BAX’S MANUAL OF THE HISTORY OF PHILOSOPHY. | | BOSWELL’S LIFE OF JOHNSON (Centenary Edition, | | edited by Napier). 6 vols. | CERVANTES’ DON QUIXOTE. | COLERIDGE’S WORKS. 6 vols. | FAIRHOLT’S COSTUME IN ENGLAND (Dillon.) 2 vols. | HUGO’S(VICTOR) POEMS. Translated. | MOLIERE’S DRAMATIC WORKS. | 3 vols. | PEPYS’S DIARY. 4 vols, |} RICHTER’S LEVANA, | RICHTER’S FLOWER, FRUIT, AND THORN PIECES. SPINOZA’S CHIEF WORKS. Translated. + TAUNTON’S CHESS HANDBOOK, 2vols. Translated. 2 vols. | of price, by *,* The above books sent upon receipt of advertised price. Catalogues of our regular stock will be mailed, if desired, to those interested. New Catalogue of Choice and Rare Books ready. CH AR] ES SCRIBNER & WELFORD, 43-745 BROADWAY, N. Y. [ Number 1175 . \ Is stevel- *. Robert Lou sons Ess In reviewing Mr. Stevenson's two recently put lished volumes of essays, the New York Tribune says : “Tf there are among our readers any lovers Be of good books to whom Mr. Stevenson is still a stranger, we advise them to make his acquaint- these collections of es- says. The papers full of the rare indivi dual charm which gives a distinction to the lightest products of his art and fancy. He isa notable writer of good English, who combines in a manner altogether his own the flexibility, freedom, quickness, and suggestiveness of con ance through either of are temporary fashions with a grace, dignity, and high-breeding that belong rather to the past.” Virginibus Pue- risque. Puerisque—Crabbed ) U CONTENTS. —Virginibus Age and Youth Or- dered South—Aes Triplex—E] The English Admirals—Some Portraits by Raeburn An Apology for Idlers Dorado Child’s Play—Walking Tours—Paris Pipes A Plea for Gas Lamps. 1 vol., 12mo, $1.00. Memories and Por- traits. ae ge Home A CONTENTS: Some College Memories—Old College An Old Seotch Gardener—Pastora] Memories of Islet— Talkers—The of Dogs—A Penny Plain and Two Pence Color Mayazine —The Manse Stevenson—Talk and an Thomas t Character ed—A Gossip on a Novel of Dumas’s—A Gossip on Romanece—A Humble Remonstrance. 1 vol., 12mo, 31.00 Familiar Studies and Hugo's Burns—W alt Books. Some Men CONTENTS: Victor Robert Romances Aspects of Whitman Henry D. Yoshida Poet, and Housebreaker Thoreau: His Character and Opi nions — Torajiro Francois Villon, a g 4 # i - Charles of and Wo Student, Orleans—Samuel Pepys—John Knox men, 1 vol., 12mo, $1.25. For sale by all booksellers, or sent, postpaid, on receipt SCRIBNER’S SONS 743-745 Broadway, New York.
Page 5
7 © er NEW YORK, THURSDAY, JAN The Week. THe minority report of Mr the Pacitic Railway Commission sec the wildest official production that has eve appeared in print since the Pacific was opened for business. Mr commends that all plans for recovering Government’s money be made subordinate to the “punishment of the ¢rimi ‘s that the first step to be taken sl forfeiture of the charters of How this forfeiture should be is not made very clear. If done by act of Congress, the Central Pcific’s charter was State of California might constitu stacle. If it is to be done by which the United States is to t tiff, it might be objected that under th of the original act the debt to the Government is not due until some ten years hence, that under the Thurman Act nothin except certain payments to the sinking which have been duly made in accordance with the terms of that act would be set up in bar of such when the Government established a mx payment by the Thurman Act, and receives payments under the same,it was estopped from forfeiture proceedings as to any acts or thing occurring before that time, sé terms of the act are complie whole scope of Mr. Pattison’s r the impress of crankiness that two members of the Commi the main object of thetr appointment in vie) and sought diligently for means t Government's money paid, 7 right-minded attorney of in handling a debtor's estate The main points of the report mission are that the companies s a formal mortgage to the Go place of the present statutory mort shall include in it their branch their property; that thereupon tl be extended to fifty Vears at « rest, payable semi-annu: ] fund of one-half of one per cent ten vears, at the end of which : } ing fund shall be established wl off the whole debt at) maturity added a proviso that the roads shall er the Attorney-General of States to bring any suit he may half of the companies to secure moneys due to the companies vate individual or corporation perfectly rational througho be adopted by Congress at an ¢ The Stock Exchange seems t amiss the action of the \ not increasing their dividends to their earnings, the quotati The a creditor we ation. lecis Ws ins i \ \ Ww Willi s s tC I Vallve i Ss Was . S \ NV h iV up & Preserve There at It which repres “ I beeaus ive to write tl I nt i i l » ' . > veut » a ? poprcar \ i - — \ al t Which mav 1 i al 4 ‘ . 1 borrow i Sis. f tr e col nine | FOW , PY \ 1Lé¢ l ict si ente , ? YY n \ ef them } | + T. tha Costs i ] Phe exper : C¢ Pitks five ve s ¥ i if! s ‘ ? { we ty ! iv ists \ a > 1) N I \ s f Ww it iN : S Ss s | - ws ey . " \ is , I SCT Mi : f , S Vi ¢ | 4 ai é ASS I { eag ue
Page 6
; ; : . | authors in trying to secure international | The ab- | . . P A | sence of this coéperation has been until now great difficulties in the way copyright legislation this winter. one of the of success; publishers, as ‘‘ practical men” and extensive employers of labor, having with than books. As long, too, as more weight Congressmen writers of there was enough comity between publish- ers to secure respect for any arrangement which any one of them might make with foreign authors, they were not very zealous in favor of acopyright treaty. The pirate has destroyed all that, however, and con- vinced them that there is no security except in legislation. This will go far to narrow the opposition down to simple enjoyment of theft—or, in other words, of benetit of kind at Nothing is more comic or more novel, and yet more characteristic of our age, than the argument which one frequently hears in opposition to international copyright, that although it is wrong to clothe or feed your- self, it is quite right, and even praiseworthy, to develop yourself mentally, with the pro- ceeds of another man’s labor. some another man’s expense. Whatever may be done about the case of Dakota, it is to be hoped that nothing will come of the scheme reported to be under con- sideration at Washington for admitting seve- ral Territories as States at the same time. New Mexico and Montana, which = are suid to be included in this scheme, are not fit to become States, and will not be for some time to come. New Mexico is still largely a foreign community, and has no just claim to exercise an equal influence in the Senate with great States like New York | and Pennsylvania. Montana still retains many of the elements of a frontier region, and it is not yet certain that it will not prove well to change the boundaries between Montana and adjoining Territories. Washington Territory has been so long set-
tled by a homogeneous population that it has | a just claim to admission as soon as the ques- tion of rectifying its eastern boundary line is | settled; but Montana and New Mexico ought The evils | of the Territorial condition are grossly exag- to serve a long apprenticeship yet. gerated by the politicians who hope to get the State offices, and they are really but small, Even if they were much greater, they | should not offset the evils to the nation of making States too soon—evils which have been forcibly Ulustrated in the case of Nevada. One experience of that sort is quite enough | for all time. We did not know how largely the national | prosperity is due to the tariff on potatoes until we read Monday's 7rijune. We then learned from jan interview with a dealer in the article that if the duty of 15 cents per bushel were repealed or materially lowered, we should not be able to compete with European potatoes in our own markets. our fiercest competitor at Washington Mar- Scotland, it appears, is ket, but England, Holland, Belgium, Ger- | many, and Denmark are pressing the Long | great Island farmer with energy. ‘“‘If,” | Oe ’ ' | cannot differ with him | recommendations are in the says this New York dealer, ‘‘they send as much as they do while there is still a fif- teen-cent tariff on potatoes, what would be the limit of this supply if that much profit is added to each bushel? It would, I think, soon be found unprofitable to raise potatoes in America.” It might be added—and the re- flection will occur to every logical mind—that if we cannot raise potatoes without a tariff, we shall soon be unable to raise wheat or cotton without it, and that we are rapidly approach- ing the condition of not being able to earn a living off the most bountiful lard in the world without a system of taxation that locks up $100,000,000 a year of our money. The poul- try dealers are already complaining of the com- petition of foreign-laid eggs. The ice-cutters a few years ago wanted a duty on foreign ice, and thought that they were ill used because they didn’t get it. The fishermen have up- set the Treaty of Washington and got us_in- to a deal of trouble for the sake of a duty on salt fish. And now the sorghum-boilers in Kansas are protesting against any med- dling with the duty on sugar because they say that make sugar as cheap- ly as it can be made in Louisiana. A hod-earrier in this city lifted up his voice the other day against any disturbance of the tariff, fearing apparently that brick buildings erected by pauper labor might rush in here from Europe. <As to coal, how often have we been told that al- though we have about thirty times as much of this mineral as Great Britain and Canada combined, we should be compelled to leave it in the earth and depend upon for eign supplies if the duty were removed. In- deed, we can imagine a condition in which they can we should all be thrown helpless on our backs, | and be compelled to receive our food, cloth- ing, and fuel from foreigners, giving them nothing in return. How long they would continue to supply us on those terms, heaven only knows. Goy. Hill has certainly done himself credit | by his message sent to the Legislature on Tuesday. It is a plain, sensible, straightfor- ward document, without any bunkum or The Nation.
[ Number 1175 to affirm a conviction if, in its opin- ion, there was sufficient evidence to war- rant it besides testimony improperly admit- ted—a much-needed reform, which would save the court from much popular distrust. He argues at much length, and with force, in favor of the restriction of the confirming power of the Senate to the cases in which it is called for by the Constitution ; but reserves his heaviest artillery for the refusal of the Legislature to provide for the State enumera- tion and apportionment. On the liquor question he is as dumb as an oyster, and has hardly a word to say for ‘ labor ”—except that the Board of Arbitration is in ‘ fairly successful operation,” which will be news to most people. Some of his topics need more comment than is possible in a mere sum- mary; but, on the whole, he has acquitted himself much more like Gov. David B. Hill than the ‘‘ Dave Hill” of last year, who has hitherto afforded so much sport to the Republicans by allowing himself to be put ‘‘in a hole.” Gov. Hill’s removal of Messrs. Jay and Richmond from the State Ciyil-Service Com- mission has been looked for every day since he asked for their resignations last July, without giving any reason. They refused to resign on the very good ground that such places as theirs ought not to be vacated without some explanation to the public of the cause of the change. The usefulness of these gentlemen, however, was greatly di- minished by the Governor's unconcealed hos- tility to the law which they were trying to enforce, and the influence of his example in | instigating nearly all the State officials to demagogy in it, or anything on which one | respectfully. His main very good. He advocates spring municipal elec- tions and a revision of the charter of this city ; the provision of a special counsel to the Legislature, to revise bills before they become | ", ‘ N . : | sioners in advance. No matter wh: ye | laws—an excellent suggestion, which he has . 1 matter what we | already made; a revision of the tax laws of the State, with the view of making personal property ‘‘ pay its just share’—a chimerical idea, against which the experience of the civil- ized world is everywhere running. Personal property in our day is too readily concealed to be a proper object of taxation atall. He violate or ignore it in a greater or less degree. Mr. Jay and Mr. Richmond had the prime qualification of thorough de- votion to their duty, and gave their time and attention unstintingly for what was to men in their position practically no compensation. What the Governor's motives in removing them are, can of course only be guessed at. His new appointments do not shed much light on the matter. From Mr. Man- ning and Mr. Treadwell it is perhaps fair to expect an honest attempt to execute the law. As regards the new President of the Board, Gen. Sickles, we shall have to get used to him in the character of a re- former before being able to pass any judgment on his merits. It will not do, however, to condemn the new Commis- | may think of the motives or manner of their | appointment, we are bound to give thema fair trial, and hope for the best from them. Possibly the fact that they are the Governor’s own selection may help to secure from him more cordial coéperation than he was willing | to give their predecessors. as . | recommends the abolition of the State Board | of Charities and of the State Board of Health, and the transfer of their powers respec- | tively to a single officer—a step in the right | | + . . . | same time he makes this sweeping promise: | direction—and of the Board of Regents as ¢ purely ornamental body; the useless and calling of the Constitutional Convention ; the permission to the Court of Appeals
Col. Fellows has begun his term of office as District Attorney in a somewhat unusual manner by giving a public feast. At the ‘For the next three years I shall endeavor to make the city of New York an unhealthy and unpleasant place for the
re Ceara
~ : tania ei Nite tats
Fe
Page 7
Jan. 5, 1888] The Nation. % criminally disposed.” This lays out as large | be reached. Mr. Chamberlain is opposed to | poor Mr. G a field of work as any man would wish to | commercial union between Canada and t it thr h tl Hl e- ww enter upon. The Mayor, who naturally feels | United States. beeause it would lead shortly t tin) some responsibility for the Colonel's ‘‘simple | political union, and he does not want to} rh Sie ty \ ' S Christian life” in the District Attorney's of n political union by roundabout means vever. 1 . ‘ fice, hastens to remind him on his entrance | But he does not. s Y. and proba! reducti aan upon its duties that there are 15,000 '
cases awaiting trial in the’ pigeonhole of the office, and says ‘*T know that you bedience to the mutual “wish s of the tw \ are sensible of the deplorable consequences | countries unintluenced by trade relations. | justify P which result from the failure to dispose of | As an Enelish diplomat. he could not favor criminal charges and to assure a prompt trial | any step looking to the loss of Canad 1) be and speedy punishment in case of conviction.” | though the loss itself he might a ee i Now the District Attorney can in no way | when it comes without his actis make New York more ‘unhealthy and un pleasant for the criminally disposed” than Spe ae ae ‘ yom Phe London correspondent of the 7) by bringing these bail cases to trial They : t \ > ‘ : : . ~ | oucht to be a little mor seful ahout the |" are nearly all for violations of the excise laws, ; ss least arias deanggadien spies facts in forwarding ‘‘ free-trade” ste s s and the greater part of them are against men
who have ‘ pulls” in politics. For years bid Hess — sere i deans eet F sini \ the criminal machinery of the city has | {3 UNS S& ey sear Sane ee on Ir been paralyzed by ‘‘ pulls” of this kind, and : sep oi aa - sstiok “ Apnaie, aa B: the reason is that the violators of the laws are | —~ we — mah a dash rspilctataiccadl FeO Ke also political workers, whose liquor-saloons | ‘ een sia je ee eee eee ; and gambling-dens are centres of political | 0°" SSS nal nana “7 ——— activity. The Colonel has a great opportu , - — sei rae gisis he phe nity before him by striking down this most | “TPS einige caued Co pernicious conspiracy against the laws. treme yet spoken of—he would Know that | e the right of lev ry customs duties Was 1 . served to the British Parliament it A despatch from St. Paul, Minn., makes | Irish Parliament would have no power wl this announcement: “The State Railroad | ever to make a tariff. But what can we ex | | Commissioners to-day issued orders that after | pect from a correspondent of the 7 January 1 each upper berth in any sleeping | When the editor says I car run or operated upon any railroad in this | the election of Cley 1 would State shall remain closed whenever the berth | American industry beneath the same shall be occupied by a pas senger, until such upper berth shall be needed ‘Tinnmcinte Caen wie : = for actual occupancy.” If this brief order | ,; ate erietag a ‘ could be put in force all over the country, one |, we ae oe * ne aay ate of the meanest advantages taken of the travel oad ‘ a Ry ao t a pine \ ling public by the sleeping-car companies : a it Pie =o are y 3 ny fe would no longer have to be submitted to. In | ,; He? Cites a “ “ne explanation of this order it may be stated seipionedh-Seatihic thies: weeds ins , : P that the aim of the sleeping-car companies | \ Se “‘CQlads ° : : (after charging, in addition to the regular Act. TI ‘a : 5 railroad rate, as much for a sleeping accom a ei ciaat reat é modation as is charged for a room and board |... led - ie ecciale in our best hotels) is to make every passenger |}. paiy been ise Deiediatictian sign ceiriiliain’ eX pay as much as can be extorted from him van to fall still fu ae Paces Each ‘“‘ section” of a sleeping-car contains 4), ; rh : ; ; two “berths.” If a passenger hires a lower | , net Baye he ; ¥ ie ; ; mn \\ ‘ 7 , berth and the one above him isnot taken, the | |,’ Tor = area - aden ara Si porters are compelled by the company, | ...., " ; : under a severe penalty, to let down the upper |, seals = : berth when the lower one is made u} ( 4 i : ae o ; ‘ pane ae Pesci a ss iad cont : settlement of the fishery disput Whether rents was bad igh ; it would t lently expect a return of the good tir 4 the settlement comes through arbitrat l ss f : Ad I Gonzale (which was recommended as a last resort by ever, that t Liberal-Unionists would not Whenit is remembered that all this the New York Chamber of Commer r support this position, and that if it were ad- companied by the same wide gap between } otherwise, the country will be thankful, and hered to,there would have to be a dissolution | governmental receipts and exper ires Which accordingly has reason to be thankful wher f Parliament. Soa bill was introduced pro- has been charactet f tl t « r so cool a participant as Mr. Cha rla ling that ¢ wccursed thing should be it looks as if the old financial po f “‘aftei tells us that, in his opi MS t will \ . It elute were tf tin f s creat
Page 8
<A REFORM OF THE HOUSE BY CONSTI- TUTIONAL AMENDMENT. To the end that the Constitutional Amend- ment for the reformation of the House of Representatives, which we lately presented, may be more clearly apprehended, we reduce toa few plain, concise points what it will ac complish and what it will not do : (1.) It now takes thirteen months to pass from a Congressional election to the time when the members elected assemble. The proposed amendment will enable the people to change one-half of the members of the House tn one month, and the other half in the same time that they can now do it. With this fact so plainly in view, we are at a loss to under- stand the hallucination which says that the amendment will remove the House further from the people. (2.) If animportant change of public opi- nion should come over the country, say in two months after an election, it will be about three years, under the existing system, before the people can replace the recently elected House of Representatives. Under the proposed sys- tem they could replace one-half of them in Constituted as the American Congressman is, we know that a decided ex pression of public opinion at these annual elections will be just as potent on the men who are not then elected as on the men who are; in fact, with an election before him ‘‘next year,” a Congressman will be much eleven months. more sensitive to public opinion than if he had just gained his seat. We can, indeed, conceive of no possible method for bringing the House of Representatives nearer to the people and making it more sensitive to the public will than that proposed. (3.) Under the present system all the mem- bers of the House hold their seats through half of their operative official life (7. e., through the most important session of Con- gress) after their successors have been elected, and when nearly two years must expire be- fore another election can be held. Under the proposed system no member will oceupy his seat afte r his successor has been elected, and the monstrous absurdity and abuse of the present system will disappear. (4.) Under the present system, no matter what the public exigency, no matter what the condition of the legislative business, a law more unalterable than that of the Medes and Persians compels the dissolution of Congress in each alternate year at a fixed day and hour. The inevitable and gross abuses of the system are too well known to need repeating. Under the proposed system that arbitrary dissolu- tion will disappear, the termination of the one session will be as manageable as the ter- mination of the other, and Congress will have no excuse for doing its work hastily or adjourn- ing before its work is done. (5.) The present system, bringing dissolu- tion as frequently as it does, involves the most astounding waste of everything that should be economized in the legislative sys tem. Not only does Congress expire, but everything which it has labored upon, if not actually completed, expires with it. As we now go to press, the House of Representa tives is still unorganized, and the single indi
| ic sentiment felt it to be a | commemoration of the one The Nation. vidual who forms the committees and who may, if he pleases, dictate the policy of the House, has not yet completed his selection. Under the proposed system, the Louse will be organized from the hour when the Speaker is elected; a working body equipped for work, and ready for work, and able on the second or third day of the session to take up the work of the nation precisely where the pre- ceding Congress left off. Let us now turn to the things which the proposed amendment will not do: (1.) It will not retain the present vicious system of the short session. (2.) It will not keep members in office after their successors have been elected. (8.) It will not retain the arbitrary destruc- tion of the legislative organization in each alternate year. (4.) It will not bring together a large, un organized mass of new members within a month, or two months, of their election (as proposed by the Crain amendment), with the heat of the election still upon them, and all the dangers of disorganization before them. (5.) While it will make public sentiment felt annually, and almost instantly in Con- gress, it will not go to the dangerous extreme of enabling some temporary public excite- ment to overpower the national legislature. With these facts plainly in view, we ask every thoughtful person to remember that while everything in our country has grown greater —its territory, its population, its intelligence —the product of our national legislation has not improved, and, indeed, has so deterio- rated that the werk of the last Congress is not comparable with the work of the first ; ponder the following and then to ques- tion: What would be thought of a great railroad corporation that in each alter- nate year, on the 4th of March, at the hour of noon, stopped all of its trains wherever they might chance to be, in the midst of a prairie or crossing a bridge; blew the water out of the boilers, put out the fires, invited the passengers to get out and walk, unloaded the freight, burned the tick- ets, blanks, and forms, cancelled their contracts, recalled their advertisements, and then took a long breath and began again? And what would be thought of a company that kept on doing this for no better rea- son than that they feared, if they did not, the brakemen might be a continuing body, and some day run away with the trains? A plan to change the administrative me- thods of government will frequently at- tract no attention whatever, sometimes will arouse Warm opposition, occasionally will re- ceive decided approval. Amendment from the 4th of March to the 30th of April was of the last class. Its merits were in- stantly perceived; the bar and the bench re- cognized the practical advantages which would accrue to legislative work; patriot- graceful hundredth anniversary of Washington's inauguration: the press advocated it, and the militia sent in petitions asking for its adoption. But the Constitutional Amendment to reform the House of Representatives which we have
[ Number 1175 propounded, has been remarkable in being received in none of these ways. Probably no other ever caused at the same moment and in the same persons so much commendation and so much doubt. Thus, in a very fair and intelligent article, wishing the question to be discussed and settled, the Washington Post says: “Tt will require much argument to convince us that this plan is desirable. It is true that the Senate, being not only a continuing body but indirectly responsible to the people, is so slow of political change that the will of the peo- ple, expressed every two years in the election of {epresentatives, is often nullitied by the Senate. But this does not seem to be any reason why the House should be less expressive than it is of prevailing political opinion.” And the Buffalo Covrier, in a more extended and equally fair article, might be cited to the same purport, A constitutional scholar who possesses the rare advantage of having lived for many years at the national capital, in familiar and confidential intercourse with the most dis- tinguished statesmen of both parties, without having been in public oftice himself, and whose name we regretfully withhold at his request, writes : “* T entirely concur with so much of the rea- soning of your article as relates to the necessity of modifying the despotic power of the Speaker, and of bringing the meeting of a new Congress into closer contact with each new election for its members. As to the expediency of making the House a permanent body like to the Senate, in this respect I confess that I have some demur. Will not such a reformation tend still more to consolidate the power of the legislative branch of the Government—already stronger than the other branches? Will it not make change in Federal policies and Federal laws still more difficult of attainment’ The great vice in the present polity is its ultra-conservatism—the fact that institutional means for effecting po- litical changes do not keep pace with social and economic evolution, Will not the proposed re- formation make our polity still more conserva- tive?” On the other hand, we have seen a private letter from Mr. Robert C. Winthrop, who not only is a veteran statesman, but was for ten years a member of the House of Representa- tives and repeatedly Speaker of the Massachu- setts House, in which he says: “Thad read the article in the Nation with great interest, and have now read it again and with renewed satisfaction. Ishould gladly see the first amendment (relating to the inaugura- tion) pass separately and on its own merits. But the second (relating to the House of Repre- sentatives) seems to me a great improvement on our present system. I heartily hope you may succeed in getting both adopted.” In presenting the proposed change to our readers, we depicted, illustratively, the House as it is and the Senate as it is in this matter | of organization. The reference to the Senate, | . . . | though merely an illustration which every- The Constitutional | to change inauguration day | | precisely like the Senate. | body knew something about, has led some correspondents and critics to suppose that we advocated changing the House into a body No writer has, in- deed, gone so far as to say that we desired secret sessions, or meant to reduce the num ber to seventy-six members; but the misap prehension has stopped short only at those points. We referred to the fact that the President pro tempore of the Senate is changed with every change of party; but the amendment under consideration will extend neither to the Speakership, nor to any matter of detail. Indeed, the term of the presiding officer of the House is not now regulated by
AERA ERB IOP 855 FEE Gwe awe on cota Mitaneriins,
ji i b 4
Page 9
ee
Jan. 5, 1888] the Constitution. ‘‘ The House of Representa tives shall choose their Speaker,” is all that is written concerning the tenure of the office; and, ‘‘A Speaker may be removed at the will of the House,” says Jefferson’s Manual. In other words, the Speaker of to-day holds his office, just asthe President pro tempore of the Senate holds his, ‘‘ at the will of the House.” The end to be kept in view, however, is not the term of the Speaker's office, but his power over and control of the committees. Some thoughtless talk has been indulged in; such as, that in the selection of the Senate committees there is doubtless a friction which the public do not hear and a manipu Whether there be a friction or not, we neither know nor lation which they do not see. care—it is a friction which will hurt nobody outside of the Senate Chamber; but concern ing the committees of the Senate three things are undeniable: (1) that there is no barter and trade, between the presiding officer and persons who wish to con trol committees; (2) that there is a ona tural selection of the fittest, whereby the committees are well made for the work they have to do, and the ablest men of th controlling party are at the head; (8 that they are always organized and ready for work, and have their work well in hand With a continuity of organization in the House, the actual experience of the Senate warrants a belief that the system of natural Under the present disjointed system of biennial dis selection will naturally be adopted organization and reorganization, the despotic and dangerous power of the Speaker seems inevitable. It has been said of the Senate that it is further removed from the people than the House. If that means that the Senate is less observant of the public will than the House, it is an error which every year of legislation contradicts. We cannot at the moment re call a single important non-political measure, such as the Presidential Succession Act, the Electoral Count Bill, the National Library measure, in which the Senate has not been years in advance of the House. It must bx remembered that the Senate is part of the legislative power, part of the treaty-mak ing power, part of the appointing power The element of secret the ‘‘courtesy of the Senate,” this paper has steadfastly sessions, and Which opposed and condemned, spring out of the latter pow ers; but the legislative work of the S nate, considering what slovenly statutory work comes from the House, and the shame ful mannerin which appropriation bills have been held back, is, as a general rule, well Indeed, if there be one legislative body in the world which has been character
done. ized during the last ten or fifteen years by dignity, decorum, freedom, and yet « mendable temperaieness of debate, and keeping its own share of the legislativ work always in advance of the other house —in short, a body which the intelligent citi zens of a civilized country may look uy with reasonable satisfaction—it is the Senate of the United States. That ‘‘continuity of organi render dangerous a legislative
The Nation. Whose members will go out of office every year is certainly an extraordinary fallacy The Long Parliament was a usurpation, be cause for twelve years and more the peopl of England could hold no election of mem bers Organization is nothing more than machinery in working ordet Dislocating the engine will not lessen the power of engineer No nation is ever going to be en slaved by legislators whose term of office is so short-lived as that of our Represen tives in Congress. If usurpation comes, it will be the work of the bad and the unprincipled who can find no instrumentality better fitted for their purpose than an unscru pulous Speaker and an unorganized Hous } +} between one Congress and anoth — ik happens now to be an interval of some months but it is only a few years since Congress was sitting almost continuously. Phe Thirty ninth Congress expired on the 4th of March L867, and ‘‘ the first session of the Fortieth Congress Was begun, and held in the city of Washington on the 4th day of March, a. p 1867. The interval of disorganization, the revlection of the Speake r, Clerk, and other ofticers, the fresh deal and dicker of commit tees, did not lessen the power of the dominant party in that House, nor hinder the mad im peachment of the President during the en suing winter In conclusion, we desire to impress upot our readers the simple fact that the constitu tional continuity of the House of Representa tives means simply continuity of orgar tion; that organization mean TEP i ition s simply machinery for doing its proper work ; that a new Congress does not mean ph LOSOPhICR ly or prac tically the same set of pont ims 1 appearing under a new name, but a new s members, newly elected, bringing w them a new exposition of the public w that the proposed amendment will secure tw different but desirable results broken business organization of the Hous 2) the annual and in Liste | ira of new members w evel vy mav be THE BLAIR L ON M He ques wh r I GOV ment ougl » appr el = se national Treasur i . schools in the States, for . ofthe S h, received roug scuss WW propos was t i \ ) ] ( gress l < ’ ged rs v S W beings ‘ ‘ . \ ib] { ? viv q v SS ppror B 9 . 7 TASS) S Ng x ‘ u eaducat i 4 l t = “ Wel s wet and 8 r . t ~ cwes l res ar verd gvainst t] S s pass | gress Was g lv Ww T he ipleteness s rev pu sentiment was shown 1 the ost striking way possible by the action of 1 New Hampshire Legislature last summer. Mr. Blair appealed to the law- ypaker a wn SS ‘ MAKCTS OF LIS WW ra « ‘ hearty endorsement s ‘ 1 the ¢ ¢) = Fiftieth ¢ gress I es A t to f wh were Repu ns by av nit totw } ( I t } teal eX pode t t aly . ¥ - ) , f Mr Blair's frie is Ww req red to sav diiy frojsryny tl } ’ ‘ I i rh tine . ‘ } \ Tine Le Sia i } | VA } . ' . ar \ i t» to 127 As t New Hamy Sens sists ’ } } ¢ lj Le ale i i s \ Tests } . hy } : ‘ S ra SW 1 WwW Alns i ! \ Vears ’ \ th { new ot ~ \ \ veloped the 1 t l " measure is based ‘ 7 } 1} } racy l STLEN V < s SM Ww sh We 1] i Ne } Tu States nea r ¢ +} rs Ww nhs T 1 nil W l . WAVs presented Dy \ . s s1\ ev t a } \ sf that INN YK ¢ South ire Fes an SOV \ . we Who co Ww MU : “ } s rf tt} \\ \ , over tw \ \ ~ \ \ \ . } } \ I ~ \ ‘ cv w X s SSO) Was . ‘. F Ww i nd s& Te i - i ~ s ~ ~AS | { s ‘ ~ ~~ \\ W l i}? i wl . s \ I = \ = 1 Is w | < so that WwW . WwW \ y \ \ s WAYS In SIS S < ~ en iv s ¢ . s ~ s eN rth W \ ed out that P iris s with thinly set t 1 ¢ l st S ‘ M ine Ne Ww ly] a } » . y — } } Hampshiz and Verm md have shown that illiteraev has been avoided in these New rNgiahd States by a s avstem no better a ee ee } — +} ; ’ ha iat Which manv Southern States already ave, and which the others will soon have at present rate f progress It was a great surprise to Northern people when we nstrated that a number of South States Keep their children in school ivs in the year than New Hampshire es hers, but the truth is at last accepted by New Hampshire, and the Concord WV which is generally known as the f Mr. Blair's colleagus readers that ‘‘New Senator Hampshire has less schooling than Delaware, Maryland, Virginia, West Virginia, or Mis souri to which it should have added Texas and Kentucky, while Florida and two or three others are within a few days of the New In like manner the Monitor might have shown that a larger per- centage of the children of school age are en- Hampshire average.
Page 10
G rolled in the public schools of some Southern States than in New Hampshire, while even South Carolina, which has the largest propor- tion of negroes, falls only a trifle behind New Hampshire in this respect. The latest reports of the Superintendents of-Education in the Southern States teem with proofs that outside help is not needed, a few of which must be cited. The average length of the school year in Virginia is al ready nearly six months, and the Superin- tendent recommends as perfectly practicable a further extension through the increase of local assessments. In West Virginia the average length is nearly five months, and the Superintendent urges an increase, remarking that ‘‘ the additional tax for two months would scarcely be felt.” In Tennessee the Superintendent reported that ‘‘ our public- school system is growing in favor with the Legislature justified his statement by doubling the school tax within a month after the Blair bill lapsed by the expiration of the Forty-ninth Congress, while the counties in their turn are doubling the local fund raised for education. In Alabama the Superinten- dent recites the growth of the system within four years from 4,624 schools with 177,428 pupils and a school fund of $392,904, to 5,595 schools with 252,967 pupils and a school fund of $523,358; he says that ‘‘our educational facilities must be increased to keep abreast with the material prosperity of the State,” and adds that ‘‘ all know there has been a gratify- ing increase in the resources of the State during the past few years which requires an increase in the annual appropriation for schools.” In Arkansas the Superintendent reports that ‘“we are making rapid progress in our edu- cational interests, and in a few more years Arkansas will stand side by side with the most favored of her sister States in the edu- cational advantages she offers to her chil- dren’—a statement which is certainly war- ranted by the increase between 1883 and 1886 from 2,462 teachers, 112,238 pupils, and $479,471 expenditure, to 3,691 teachers, 175,- 935 pupils, and $866,892 expenditure. In Georgia the Superintendent reported an in- crease within four years of pupils from 244,- 197 to 309,594, and of expenditure from $498, - 5383 to $723,161, while he showed once more that a small increase in the tax, which could be laid ‘‘ without unduly burdening the peo- ple,” would enable the State to keep the schools in operation for six months of the year. In Florida the Superintendent reports that the amount expended upon schools has risen within four years from $133,260 to $400,000, while the school year falls only a few days short of New Hampshire and Maine. In Texas the Superintendent reports a steady people,” and the more than and rapid advance in the cause of popular education, and insists that ‘‘ the school term throughout the State should not be less than seven months.” Space will not permit a full presentation for each State of the wonderful progress which has been made in developing the school system of the South within the past few years, The Blair bill was introduced in December, 1881, upon the ground that the South was so ‘impoverished by the war” The Nation. that it could not raise any more money for schools than it was then raising, and that Federal aid ought to be granted for eight years. Six of the eight years have pass- ed ; the amount raised for schools has been largely increased in every State, and doubled or trebled in some, while the man who should now talk about the South being ‘‘impove- rished by the war” would provoke the deri- sion of every self-respecting Southerner. The rigorous test of time has been applied to the plausible pleas which were origi- nally made for the passage of this bill, and their fallacy has been clearly exposed. The South has shown herself able to overcome the difficulties of the situation, and her success is another tribute to Ameri- can self-reliance. The most satisfactory fea- ture of the matter is the fact that the opposi- tion which has defeated the ‘‘ Bill to Promote Mendicancy ” was largely the opposition of self-respecting Southern men, like Senator Butler of South Carolina, who put the case against it most forcibly four years ago, when he said : _ “ We ought to pause and reflect. for fear that in throwing this large amount of money into the States you will check the effort in those States to develop their own common-school sys- tem in their own way. Why, Mr. President, there is no success in life comparable to the suc- cess which attends individual effort, none so en- during, none so satisfactory. I would, there- fore, be very cautious before I would appropri- ate money and put it with the States, the effect of which, I am afraid, would be, among others, to induce a very great many men who are now earnestly struggling to build up their own local institutions, to put their hands in their pockets and say: ‘ The general Government is going to educate everybody—what is the use of any man paying taxes for education? ” PICTURES AND PICTURE-BUYERS. A CORRESPONDENT in the West writes, on behalf of some local economists who are just now occupied with the tariff discus- sion, to ask us whether we set paint- ings down among the things known as *‘Juxuries,” and therefore a fair +. ject for Custom-house taxation. The que- ‘ion will most probably come up this winter in con- nection with the 30 per cent. duty which we now levy on the works of foreign artists, and which we believe nobody any long- er defends on the ground that it is legitimate protection for native industry against foreign competition. Thirty years ago there were American artists who dreamed of the possibility of making by the aid of the tariff a sort of art vacuum in this country which native talent would fill with a purely and distinctively American school, owing nothing whatever to European pre- cept, spirit, or example. But this dream has for the most part passed away, and Ameri- can artists have resigned themselves to tak- ing part in the general struggle for distinc- tion and a market without any adventitious aid. If any are now disposed to rely on the tariff at all, itis rather for protection against the dealers in this country than against profes- | sional rivals abroad. They say, and witha good deal of force, that in no country is the dealer so powerful an influence in the picture market as in this, because in none are there so many buyers with long purses who do not | | | | | [ Number 1175 venture to rely on their own judgment in making their purchases. When the time comes in their career, therefore, at which they think it is incumbent on them to fill their houses with works of art, they put themselves unhesitatingly into the hands of an importer, and he generally covers their walls with the products of foreign studios, and, if he allows them to buy American pictures at all, recom- mends them only for bedrooms and the less frequented parts of the house. Against this discrimination the human nature in American art naturally revolts, and if the tariff would do anything towards repressing it, we imagine a good many advocates for the duty on foreign pic- tures would be found among American painters. But as a matter of fact the duty on foreign pictures, although it may in some degree prevent importations being as large as they would be in its absence, has not perceptibly diminished them. The ebb and flow of the American demand for European pictures seems to be more affected by the condition of the stock market than by any other influence known to us. In truth, the ordinary American picture-buyer is rather stimulated than deterred by dear- ness. The addition of 30 per cent. to the price is in nine cases out of ten more likely to increase than to cool his ardor. In his own ignorance of the conditions which fix the value of a picture in money, he is apt to defer to the judgment of those who profess to know something about them, and to conclude that their asking a very high price isasort of confession of the importance of what they have to sell. He does not know, what is literally true, that the picture mar- ket now closely resembles the stock mar- ket—that it has its bulls and_ bears and corners, just as Wall Street has, and that dealers not infrequently ‘‘ sell short” works which they know are held in considerable quantity by a rival, in order to break him down, or ‘‘make corners” in works which they know he is seeking, and unload freely on “lambs” from the West works in which their own expectations have been disap- pointed. So that, on the whole, the effect of the tariff on the sale of foreign pictures, though doubtless considerable, can hardly be said to be perceptible. It keeps foreign pictures out to some extent, but we do not know to what extent. The only aid in approximating to an estimate of it is to be found in the large num- ber of counterfeits of distinguished European artists which are to be found all over the coun- try. A French connoisseur came here a few years ago to catalogue, if possible, the more valuable works of French art to be found in this country in private collections and public galleries. He had not gone very far, how- ever, before he came on forgeries, enough to astonish him, of the more readily imi- table works of such painters as Corot and Rousseau. In fact, we have ourselves been assured by a leading American painter that there is in one of the su- burbs of New York a Corot factory, from which you can obtain works of this master of any size or inany quantity you please—either by the dozen or the single copy. That the
Page 11
oy ES
# * 34 ee PMN RISE AA
Jan. 5, 1888] tariff fosters frauds of this sort is very cer- tain. The smuggler and counterfeiter al ways follow close behind the custom-house inspector. The objectior™ to the picture duty which American artists, we imagine, feel most keenly, is the discredit it inflicts on us in the eyes of foreign nations, which contain a large proportion of the public whose opinions they value. We are the first civilized country which has ever sought to make difficult the importation of works of art. All the leading governments of Christen dom spend money in buying pictures for public galleries, and encourage by every means in their power the introduction of them from abroad by private individuals, both for their own greater glory and for th cultivation of the popular taste in an im- portant field of human expression. We enjoy the amazing distinction of being the only people to put pictures on a level with cotton goods, and pig iron, and raw wool. Every American who occupies himself either with literature or art or sci ence, or with the cultivation of the ideal in any field of human observation, is, of course, compelled to hang his head for shame when he is asked to explain this to a foreigner. But the reason why he hangs his head for shame in talking to the foreigner is also the reason why he is_ puzzled and embarrassed when he is called on to explain to the ordinary Congressman why taxes on works of art are all wrong. He cannot make the Congressman understand the part which art plays in the higher development of the race any more than he can make the for eigner understand the Congressman’s indiffer ence to it. If a mansees no educational value in art, one can hardly reveal it to him by any sort of exposition. It is, like color-blindness or the absenceof ear for music, a difficulty which can only be overcome by faith. That is to say, people who see nothing in pictures, whether old or new, must trust that immense body of the best men and women of all ages who have treated art as ‘‘ the flower of hu- manity.” The accumulation of. first-rate pictures in America, in spite of all difficulties, is very rapid. They are, it is true, luxuries, in the sense that only rich men can buy them. But they are luxuries which rich men canaot con sume, which delight the eye and cultivate th taste and imagination of millions who could not afford to buy them, and ina vast num ber of cases they find their way in the lor " run into public galleries and become to al intents and purposes the property of the people. We can hardly check this tenden \ by any import duty, however heavy. The money the present duty brings in is a mer bagatelle, so that in levying it we accom plish little beyond making our legislation seem barbarous. THE CHACE COPYRIGHT BILL. SENATOR CHACE of Rhode Island has again presented to the Senate his International Copyright Bill, with no change in the text except that the date in the enacting clause is set forward one year to July 1, 1888. We
The Nation. ri have before summarized the provisions of this pretence t ‘im tl bill, and now desire only to revert to the claus is necessary to secure At f Which prohibits the importation of any At number thr how foreign edition of a book reprinted” true reason for tl S01 jus in the United States Although tl Instead two measures proposed to secure copy ne, simply right to British authors which, for the m legislation, we discover Mr v A ment, are attracting the largest share of pul eas Words, quoted above tha lic attention, both originate in Philadelphia, | of this article ts 1 they are diametrically opposed in one respect. | pury While Mr. Smith's proposed bill is designed Mr. Chace states to give the utmost latitude to competing ed sent tariff tions, upon the plea that in this way | what is rey ily referred MM the lowest price will be secured to th himself as the h reade r, the effect of the pr hibition of t Ss, Would importation clause in Mr. Chace’s bill is | tion” to the At absolutely to remove competition. Should | in the produ . \ this latter bill, as it is now worded, become | the it \} law, American readers may find themselves | nal editions obliged to choose either to go without the 1 dutv” of ! f | book, or to pay for the American reprint) price, would pt : of Tennyson’s next poem double or treble | rimental to the 1 s of t An the price of the original English edition. | can repul rs. | This is no fancy illustration. Whenever an to enact alaw wl . \ English author of established popularity | reprinte: shall announce a new work, American ) much per cent t | “ publishers will hasten to compete for the | enal privilege of issuing it in America, and 1 bidder offering the highest price to th i rding to Mr. ¢ author will, of course, secure the right to re the an publish. Having thus obtained the entire | tion.secure to himself a Ar American market for his edition, with the ab- | this is very evice \ v sign and solute prohibition of importation enacted in | purport of 1 \ “ <M the bill barring out any and every compet Lea says \ ing foreign edition, the acute publisher will mMpor Ise I \ rests very naturally hasten to recoup himself for) the 1 shox Americ his outlay by demanding from Ameri readers the highest obtainable price forth highest possil } 1 1 nterd t “ work thus secured. Ss concer : , with Mr This is so plainly the practical result of | C hat they W the legislation proposed that it is with cot t Ss Dy siderable curiosity one turns projectors and defenders of this bill have t . sav in defence of this stipulation. The argu i .
ments made are threefold l That it is ‘an invariable rule in all countries wher Dyna ition of 1871-72 copyright exists 2) that it is necessary tl : sand sof PI lelphia held enforce the requirement of the Americar .1 { Januat f it vear, at manufacture of each book copyrighted; and wl Mr. Henrv ¢ v Baird presided Q ei s
sed law, as that which he now | Philadelphia IT) ; +} ¢ hy ATIST MY t rr) occupies. It is, therefore, but a transparent | grievance
Page 12
8
PROTECTION TO LIQUOR-DEALING. Tre Excise Board presents both a majority and minority report to Mayor Hewitt, in making suggestions, in compliance with his request, for changesinthelaw. The majority, Messrs. Andrews and Von Glahn, are opposed to high license and in favor of licensing houses instead of persons, and of issuing licenses to “keep open all night to liquor-dealers in cer- tain portions of the city, in the restaurants, ho- tels, and drinking places about the markets, at the ferries, railway stations, about the print- ing-offices, and at certain points on the They would also li- ” main thoroughfares. cense certain places to keep open on Sun- day during specified hours, for the ac- commodation of that large portion of the community who take beer or wine as part of their daily diet. On the num- ber of drinking places they would place no restriction whatever, and as they would only charge a ‘‘ moderate fee ” for the privilege of carrying on the business in any particular house, and as they admit that ‘‘ the rental value of places licensed is greater for that than for any other business as a rule,” they must contemplate an indefinite expan- sion and cultivation of the business by all property-holders desirous of securing an un- usually high rent for their premises. Mr. Woodman, the minority, on the other hand, would restrict the number of licenses granted tp one to 500 of population, which would cut down the number of drinking places now existing in New York frem 8,000 to 3,000, and would make the license fee very high, and add imprisonment to the fine for violations of the law, and would in all cases compel the landlord of the premises on which liquor-dealing was carried on to go on the applicant’s bond, if he were not him- self the applicant. Both reports are worth careful reading as the expression of the two great divisions of public sentiment about the liquor business. Mr. Woodman represents those who think that **the Excise Law was not made, and should not be administered, in the interest of the liquor- seller. It was made not to promote, but to restrict the traffic ; not to protect the seller in his. business, but to protect the public against the inevitable evil results of that trade. So inevitable and so evil are these re- sults that the tendency of public opinion and of excise legislation in all civilized countries for many years past has been towards severer curtailment and control of the liquor traftic. In several States of our Union it has culminat- ed, through popular vote, in absolute prohibi- tion. “Every new step, therefore, should be towards further restriction and repression, The saloon, as it has developed in this city, is a gigan- tic evil in the vastness of its proportions and in the character it too often bears. It is sapping the strength and endangering the safety of the commonwealth. I believe it to be in the high- est degree unwise to do anything to enlarge its scope or strengthen its grip upon the commu- nity.” Messrs. Andrews and Von Glahn are not equally explicit in stating what their attitude towards the liquor traflic is, but it comes out clearly enough — incident- ally through their recommendations. They evidently consider it a source of com- fort and convenience to a large body of the population, liable to abuse certainly, and therefore to be regulated, but in no way to be discouraged or frowned upon. ‘Obstacles are The Nation. not to be opposed to the business. The conduct of it is to be made safe and convenient; the license is to be transmissible to heirs and executors; the applicant is not to be required to reside in the county in which he sells liquor; licenses are to be issued for short terms for special occasions; connection with theatres and places of amusement is to be permitted; there are to be no prohibited hours or days for all drinking places. In fact, the only condition worth men- tion which they would attach to permission to carry on a liquor store, is the condition which is attached to permission to carry on a bakery or dairy lunch-room in all civilized communities—that is, abstinence from disor- der and indecency. For, most assuredly, if it appeared that bakeries or dairy lunch-rooms were the favorite resort of bad characters of both sexes, and noted for the num- ber of fights and murders which occurred in them, and for the number of persons who issued forth from them to commit assaults in the streets, or go home to ‘ pound ” their wives and smash their own furniture, bakers and milk-dealers would be carefully licensed and looked after by the police. Now, whatever be the merit of this as- sumption of Messrs. Andrews and Von Glahn, it is certainly not the one which now commands general acceptance, or on which the bulk of this community — will any longer allow liquor legislation to be based. Whatever change is made in the law in this State must be, and we believe will be, made in the direction indicated by Mr. Wood- man. In other words, public opinion de- mands, all over the country, with in- creasing force, that since liquor - deal- ing cannot be abolished, it must be discredited ; that entrance to it must be made difficult ; that the number of those en- gaged in it must be restricted ; that liquor- dealers must, by hook or by crook, be ousted from their present intluence in our politics ; that all regulation of the traffic must openly recognize and provide for the fact that it is by far the most fruitful source of crime and disease and poverty known to the modern world. There is not a civilized country to-day which is not deal- ing with this problem on these lines. All thoughtful men are everywhere seeking to make liquor-dealing an uncomfortable and disreputable calling. This tendency may be temporaily bafiled here and there, but its triumph is certain in the near persons conducting an orderly place in a or about “‘honest, thrifty, moderate way,’ law-abiding” drinkers, will arrest its progress. MUTATIONS OF THE BOOK TRADE IN GERMANY. THE decadence of the book trade, outside of our largest cities, has been much discussed by those immediately interested, but it is to be feared that the reading public fails to perceive that the disappearance of the country book-shop implies a corresponding narrowing of the area of literary culture. In this connection it is in-
[ Number 1175
future, and no flummery about ‘‘ reputable |
which afflict the American. These are three in number : first, the dying out of the habit of buying books as part of the furniture, as it were, of the homes of all families of even mode- rate wealth and cultivation. This is chiefly owing to the enormously increased taste for bric-a-brac, engravings, artistic furnishings, and the like, the gratification of which ab- sorbs the margin of income formerly spent in providing well-bound sets of the Waverley No- vels, Littell’s Living Age, the Atlantic Month- ly, and the newest volumes of Huxley and Lowell. Want of space forbids our discussing this point in detail, and we therefore refer those interested to Mr. Henry Holt’s New Haven ad- dress of last year. Another evil is the revolu- tion in values—that is, in the instinctive con- sciousness of what one ought to pay for a book, caused by the existence of the twenty-cent libra- ries. The literary democracy which these have established has destroyed the aristocracy of good editions and authors’ monopoly, which, apparently, had nothing to support it except custom and tradition. These two causes would probably have been sufficient to limit the bookseller’s stock to “libraries” anda few gift-books for the holi- days, and this limitation is fatal to his pros- perity, because the margin of profit on the ‘ li- braries” and on school-books is very small, while the gift-book season is short, and the danger of being left with damaged or passé stock is great. But that which, in the opinion of the trade, is the greatest evil, and the one from which, in a different form, the Germans also suffer, is the underselling, by which a few deal- ers are able to profit at the expense, and event- ual ruin, of the majority. This is the ‘ bazaar ” nuisance, the system under which publishers sell quantities of their most salable books, at the same or greater discount, to the miscellane- ous shops modelled on the Bonne Marché or the ‘Universal Provider,” one, at least, of which is now to be found in every considerable town, and which use books, along with denti- frices and soaps, as decoys to entice buyers of their other wares. Nor is the influence of these shops confined to their immediate neighbor- hood, for some of them do a large business by post. The same thing, it appears, is going on in Germany, and is ruining that particular fea- ture of the German book-trade which, accord- ing to our Jahrbitcher friend, is the envy of foreigners, and which has undoubtedly, as he says, largely helped to make Germany the country in which learning is geographically most widely distributed. By means of it, the scholar who lives in the remotest country town enjoys the same advantages, as regards current literature, as the dweller in the largest city. He has only to give his local bookseller the name of any book which he possibly may find valuable, and by return of post it is on his table. He may keep it several months, and | after making any useful extract, return it with-
out compensation for the loan, Two-thirds of the books he receives are thus, at the end of a year, returned to the publisher, and the book- seller makes his living out of the profit on the third book, which is bought. The rural scholar is thus never obliged to buy a pig in a poke— he has ample opportunity to learn, by examina- | tion, whether a work is indispensable, and to teresting to learn (from an article in the Preus- | | sische Jahrbiicher for November) that the same | result is threatened in Germany, though the | ‘ a o . German trade suffers from only one of the evils have the use of the larger number which, though not of permanent value to him, are of great temporary use. Another advantage of the system is that it implies the presence in every little town of a bookseller who is obliged to anticipate, to a large extent, the wants of his | circle of customers, and hence to be a man of considerable intelligence, if not a scholar, him- a <a Es # v
snboater tne on AE BER EES
Page 13
i
Jan. 5, 1888]
self, and whose shop, in a small way, is a ‘literary centre But some clever Berlin dealers a few years » since conceived the idea of offering publishers to take at one time a large quantity of each book on which they were sure of a large sale, the publishers, in consideration of the large number sold, to give a discount of 40 or 50 in stead of the usual 25 or 33 per cent., at which rate they were able to sell the book at about the same price which it cost the small bookseller By this arrangement publishers and dealers alike profited, but the old-fashioned retailer, of course, came to grief. Two years ago the pub lishers discovered that this was a short-sighted rh the large deal ers in the end were smaller than they had been
policy—that their sales thro under the old plan, and 600 of them agreed to have no dealings with firms which dealt on this principle. On September 25, 1587, this boycott was strengthened by a resolution of the Book dealers’ Union hereafter to regard every dealer who gave a discount of more than 5 per cent. as coming under the ban. But though the local bookseller in Germany, thanks to these sharp measures, will die a more lingering death than his American brother, his doom seems to be just as certain, The resolution of the Union, which we mentioned, has been unfavorably commented upon by the press, and the Jahrbiicher article is largely areply to these criticisms. The writer maintains that the prices of serious works are low enough, but admits that those asked for school-books and belles-lettres are too high. In defending these positions, the (anonyinous writer givessome interesting statistics, which, as the Jahrbiicher is issued by a highly respect ed firm of printers and publishers, are, we su] pose, trustworthy. Incidentally the exports and imports of Germany are compared with those of France, the result of which, in view of
their political relations, is In 1885) France imported books, en ete.,, to the value of $6,400,000, and exported $9,000,000 worth. But taking the trade wit}! Germany by itself, the proportion was reversed, the importation being $3,600,000, the exporta tion only $765,000, The total German trade for IS86 Was—iinports $6,000,000, exports $15,550, OOD, We get, too, some light on the pecuniary pr fits of authorship in Germany, though the writer apologizes to his brethren for telling tales out of school, It seems, then, that the cost of puttin on the market a strictly scholarly work, of which the number that may be sold will not ex ceed 500, and assuming the author to be neither unknown nor famous, is: Composition and presswork for an Svo volume of 820 pages, 5 copies, Shick paper S41.25, author's ¢ mn pensa tion, $125, incidental expenses 853.75; total 337 Moreover, the author of a work of more popu lar character, which may be expected to s 1,000 copies, or of a novel which sells copies, gets no more for his labor; but tl piler of a school-book which is likely to s 5,000 copies, gets the fabulous sum of § The insignificance of the sums paid the authors of works of scholarship and fiction mig accounted for on the ground that so many works of these classes are published with a view to benefit the author’s reputation rather thar his pocket; but compilers of school-books not usually work for * glory THE YELLOWSTONE PARK AS A FOR EST RESERVATION, WASHINGTON, J
OF the varied beauties of the Yellowst Park much has been said in praise. The
Tne splendor of the Grand Cation, the grandeur of Nation. the Lake and of those scientific curiosities, the geysers and hot springs, bave been describ over and over again until every one is more or miliar with the natural marvels of this less fe
wonderland. Now that the once famous pink and white terraces on the shores of Rotomahana in New Zealand have ceased to exist, the simi lar deposits in the Yellowstone Park stand rivalled, Notwithstanding all that has been
Written, based upon sentimental considerations in favor of a maintenance of the Park byt yeneral Government, the most foreible argu ment for its preservation Is an economl we fal outWeighing all others in importa It is vhich has received but slight attention outside | of a narrow circle of the friends of t ba who realize the true value of the region The object of first importance in maintain. | ing the Park is the preservation of its forests Forest preservation is rightfully attracting in- | creased attention in all parts of t intry, | ind it is now very generally admitted that a | rigid enforcement of the proper restrict tl utting of timber is demanded for the | lie welfare, Owing tothe many tlictin t rests in the more settled communities, adidit al protection by leygislati s by no means a simple problem. Nowhere is this better show? than in the struggle in New York State to pr | serve the timber of the Adirondacks avainst the encroachment of lumbermen The Park is a natural reservoir admirably adapted by its topographical structure f storage of water. No region of equal area the heart of the Rocky Mountains presents s many favorable conditions for receiving, st j ing, and distributing a liberal water su; | For the preservation of this water the dense | forest Which covers this region is of inca ble value. The central portion of the Park t broad, elevated volcanic plateau ‘ ae | ibove sea vith a t ribout S000) feet t is f pressed basins and s Lby rges and narrow valleys. Surround t} S t} ist. 1 th. and 1 + TOES | peaks and m tain ridges rising f nn 1.000 feet above the general level ed ta land \cross this f t itheast tot northwest, w 11 S , ean 6 eCaeeer E ng the waters of the Atla . the Pa Ss il large bodies ta \ Ws re) ~ Vis Lak I 1 sucl iract st : both sides the is s ve t i Lak ‘ e | E = . » e &§ ‘ Y " R ew } aT thar = \ ~ gli t \ “WwW i s ark ! i s ¢ . . anal ars = i rest is os t is A w groves of aspen 4 Orillia yt autumn a t g t ant that from an economic P y may be discarded, |
i 7 K \s s black ‘ ~ } vit ~ ( . ‘ ‘ aes | t ‘ - . > 5 t ‘ i i i s “ 1 ‘ i s ana ra i \ ‘ \ otf ‘ i ‘ ~ LN \ \\ ‘ \ x x y 2 . ‘ ‘ \ * x . i ) e and t tikes; tl for i i \ ‘ jyua miles, and t i ro i i juare mille
orl i neasures three squaee les. These reser Voirs pour their waters into the Snake, which also finds its source near the southeast coruer of the Park.
Page 14
10 In the autumn of 1886, with a view of obtain- ing some data upon the amount of discharge, the largest bodies of water were accurately measured. Not only was the time selected the dryest period of the year, but all lakes and streams stood at a lower level than at any time during the previous five years. Yel- lowstone Lake stood twenty inches below the high-water mark of early summer. The mea- surements may be said, therefore, to have been taken at the minimum discharge. Measured just below the outlet of the lake, the discharge of the Yellowstone River was found to be 1,525 cubic feet per second, or, in other words, 54,- 000,000 imperial gallons per hour. The outflows from Shoshone, Lewis, and Heart Lakes com- bined yielded 104 cubic feet per second. The Lamar, Firehole, Gibbon, and Madison Rivers were gauged, and careful estimates made of the Gallatin and Falls Rivers, based upon the size and flow of the streams and the area of the country drained. According to estimates of Dr. William Hallock of the United States Geological Survey, who kindly undertook the gauging of the streams, it was found that the minimum discharge was equal to one cubic foot per second per square mile over an area some- what more than 4,000 square miles, and that the amount of water running into the Park and leaving it through the five main drainage chan- nels would make a river five feet deep and one hundred and ninety feet wide, with a current of three miles per hour. While this may not indicate a large supply as compared with cer- tain highly favored areas, yet it is for the arid region of the West an exceptional and excessive amount. s In an arid and sparsely timbered country and one of unequally distributed rainfall, forests and moisture maintain reciprocal relations. Experience has shown in Europe, and unfor- tunately already in America, the injurious ef- fect of disafforesting a country near the head- waters of large rivers. One instance will suf- fice to illustrate this protecting influence of the forest. The report of the recent Forestry Com- mission of the State of New York says, speak- ing of the sources of the Hudson River, ‘‘ that the summer flow of the Adirondack rivers has decreased within the memory of men now liv- ing from 30 to 50 per cent. Many of the small streams which a quarter of a century ago were abundantly supplied with water during the entire summer are now dry during many months.” Remove the forests from the sources of the Yellowstone and Snake, and the region would become a barren waste, The snows, under the scorching rays of the sun, would rapidly disap pear, and early spring freshets and floods, car- rying devastation before them, would strip the rocks bare of the meagre soil with which they are now covered. Under the influence of the forests the soil and vegetation are protected, which in turn act as a sponge, regulating the flow and slowly supplying the springs and streams. The climatic benefits derived from this forest-protected region can scarcely be overestimated. From the cool, wet surface of this broad storehouse of water, the dry winds coming from the West absorb immense quanti- ties of moisture, which is again precipitated over the agricultural and grazing lands to the eastward. Not only should the present reserva- tion be carefully guarded, but the area of the Park should be enlarged to the east and south, so as to take in a dense forest region useless for agricultural purposes and destitute of mining resources. It embraces a rough and mountain- ous country abounding in streams, the real sources and feeders of Snake River, Yellow- stone River and Lake.
The Nation. The proposed increase extends the boundaries twenty-five miles to the eastward and nine miles to the southward of the present ill-defined limits, which were established at a time when the region had been but little explored. By this enlargement, not only the entire western slope of the Absaroka Range, with its moun- tain torrents flowing into the Park, but the tim- ber-lands near the heads of streams which run eastward (the waters of which drain into the Big Horn, an affluent to the Yellowstone), will fall within the protected area. To the south- ward, on the opposite side of the Continental divide, the country, although less rugged, is equally well supplied with streams, springs, and Jakes, whose waters uniting make a broad deep river of the Snake before it fairly leaves the mountains for the plain below. A proposition looking to the enlargement of the National Park has already been brought before the present Congress by Senator Vest of No obstacles exist to-day against for ever setting apart this additional terri- tory adjacent to the Park. If left alone, it will soon be invaded by the lumberman, char- coal-burner, and railway-tie cutter, the advance guard of a rapidly increasing population. The preservation of the Park is a necessity to the nation, but to no part of it more than to the Territories of Dakota, Montana, and Wyoming. ARNOLD HAGUE. Missouri. CHAMBER AND PRESIDENT IN FRANCE. Paris, December 13, 1887. THE third French Republic has already had four Presidents. The first three retired volun- tarily before the end of their terms. M. Thiers resigned his power, in a moment of anger, in the hope that the Constituent Assembly would recall him immediately. Marshal MacMahon was protected by the constitutional laws en- acted soon after his accession to office; he was irresponsible, and could play the part of a con- stitutional king. But when he dissolved the Chamber, with the consent of the Senate, in accordance with these new constitutional laws, the general elections were hostile to his Cabinet. He remained, however, a little longer in power, with M. Dufaure as Prime Minister; he might have remained to the end of his term if he had been willing to play exactly the part which is played in constitutional monarchies by the sovereigns, since the Constitution under which we live places the Presidential power above all parties. The Marshal could not persuade himself to obey in everything the dictation of his Ministers; he revolted when he was asked to ex- clude from active service in the army some of his old friends and comrades. stronger in him than the President; he resigned, and M. Grévy was elected in his place. The new Constitution was this time put fairly on its trial. M. Grévy affected to take no part what- ever in the politics of the day; he uttered no opinions, he seemed to have no opinion; he merely watched the Chamber of Deputies, and gave the power of forming a Cabinet to whoever could dispose momentarily of the ma- jority of the Chambers. The struggle for pow- er became very fierce, and the Cabinets were very short-lived. Every man was tried in his turn; the President seemed to live in a higher His retired life, his solitude, helped to surround him with a certain halo. He was thought to be a safe, prudent, shrewd man, who could use men at his will, who remained caim amid the conflict of passions, and he was espe- cially credited for his adherence to a policy of peace, though he allowed the expeditions of Tunis and of Tonquin to take place. At the end of his first term, he expressed a desire to be The soldier was sphere.
[Number 1175 reélected, and this desire was immediately obeyed by the Chambers, though he was becom- ing old, and there were already some men anx- ious to obtain his inheritance. When M. Grévy was reélected, nobody could have the slightest doubt that he would quietly end his second term, if he lived long enough. But fate had decided otherwise. I will not enter here into a painful analysis of the inci- dents which determined him to resign and to abandon an office which he might have kept five years longer. I will only examine the question from a constitutional point of view. The term ‘ Presidential crisis” has been often pronounced in France in the past two months, and nobody seems to have felt its impropriety very much. People have used it as naturally as they do the term ministerial crisis. <A change of Ministers seems as natural an inci- dent as a change of weather; a change of Presi- dents ought to be quite another thing. Accord- ing to the Constitution, or rather to our constitutional laws (for we have, properly speaking, no Constitution), the President can only be removed from his office in case he com- mits acts which go under the name of high trea- son. There is nothing in the constitutional laws which gives the Chamber of Deputies the means to remove the President from the Presi- dential chair; but what have we seen in the case of M. Grévy? We have seen what can only be called a ministerial strike. M. Grévy offered the Premiership to one after another of the public men who are in the Chamber of De- puties, after this Chamber had upset the Rou- vier Cabinet ; one after another, these public men refused to undertake the formation of a new Cabinet. The Chamber of Deputies open- ly, distinctly, refused to give Ministers to the President. There remained the Senate. Unable to govern with the Chamber, M. Grévy could go to the Senate, and as the constitutional laws do not give him personally the right of dissolution, he could ask the Senate to come to his help and grant him the permission to dissolve a Chamber of Deputies which refused him the means of governing. An appeal to the people, in such a case, seemed the proper remedy, and the only remedy. M. Grévy did not send a message to the Senate, and he made a mistake in not doing so, as, in such a crisis, everything must be made public. He contented himself with conversing with the President of the Senate and with some of his friends, The Senate, which is haunted with the memory of the 16th of May (when a dissolution was granted to Marshal MacMahon), which is also afraid of the Chamber of Deputies, and anxious to prolong its own existence, which at times is threatened by the Radical party, did not in this case defend its own prerogative and the pre- rogative of the President. There was hardly any struggle, any discussion. M. Grévy was made to understand at once that the Senate was not disposed to allow him the right to order general elections. It thus happened that though the Constitution makes him irresponsi- ble, and gives him the right to form at his will responsible Cabinets, the President found him- self placed in the impossibility of accomplish- ing the duties of his office. He was like an animal placed under the pneumatic pump, who dies for want of air. Irresponsible in theory, he became responsible in practice, and not even responsible for his own faults—for faults which he had not himself committed. Those who still care for constitutional law must see that a dangerous example has been given, Let us leave aside the person of M. Grévy, and let us talk only of the Presidential power. The Chamber of Deputies has learned
peo ty eee
ES RRR
Page 15
Jan. 5, 1888] by what method and by what means it can dis- pose of a President almost as easily as it does of a Cabinet. have nothing to do but to form a passive coali tion ; they can oppose their non possumus to the President almost the day after his election The Chamber of Deputies has learned, also, that the Presidential power does not find in the Senate a sufficient support. The present drift of our institutions is therefore markedly to wards the convention system—the direct absolute government of one chamber. The Presidential power, so essential to the stability of the republican government, could only regain its importance if it was confided to The leaders of the various groups and one of those remarkable men who are a power in themselves, and who have an innate faculty M. Thiers may be He was capable of for the government of men. cited as one of those men. using any constitution so as to obtain the maxi mum of power. But the men of his type are rare. M. Carnot, who has been chosen by the Congress of Versailles as the successor of M. Grévy, was chosen for his negative rather than for his positive qualities. It two fractions of the Republican party, which was because the go under the name of Opportunists and Radi cals, could not unite on the name of M. Ferry or of M. de Freycinet that they chose a third candidate. M. Carnot elected unanimous vote of the Republicans of the two Chambers, but this unanimity itself shows that his personality was not very well marked, and that both parties expected to find in him an obedient instrument. The division, which had ceased for a day, or, to speak more correctly, for an hour, became apparent as soon as M. Carnot attempted to form a Ministry. all the Republicans, he attempted to satisfy them all, and to form a Cabinet of what is call ed Republican concentration—a singularly ill chosen word, since, when you mix wine and was by As he had been elected by water, you cannot be said to concentrate the wine or the water. M. Carnot tried, in his turn, every man in the Chamber, and spent ten days at the Elysées conferring with the parlia- mentary leaders and chiefs of groups. He took notes, and studied the situation with the exact ness and method of a pupil of the Polytechnic School and of an engineer. Last night he final ly succeeded in getting a Cabinet. The attempt made upon the life of M. Ferry in the lobbies of the Chamber of Deputies probably helped to hasten the solution. It was high time that the crisis should come to an end. The Radical press had inflamed the public mind, and the wretch ed man who fired at Ferry was incited to his crime by the bitter denunciations and ravings of the revolutionary party. We have now a Ministry, as we have a Presi- dent, and the fever may subside. The budget has to be voted; the new year is coming with its customary ‘‘ gréve des confiseurs.” But the late events have left behind them a bitter and an ominous lesson. M. Carnot is known to be an upright, honest man; he is, no doubt, animated by the best intentions. lican dynasty, if the word may be used, and his He belongs to a repul very name is strength to the Republic. But he finds the Presidential power weakened, de prived of its prerogative, humbled, and almost impotent; he finds the Republican party split into two sections which are becoming more and more irreconcilable, as one of those sections is becoming allied to the communistic and archical elements of the population of the great cities. The walls of Paris have been « with red placards signed with the names of the surviving leaders of the Commune of 1871. M Rochefort, during the Presidential crisis, was a power in Paris. The Municipal Council an vered T Nati he
ceived deputations from all the anarchical s I soon find s thes nd sent ley it is t \ snilles: it Was \ “i } hes all ready to proclaim the Commune if M. | y had been elected by Congress. It is e to If t polit uns of speak of nceentration in ft ict { su s { this hat 1 lemon itions,. No government would be yx s ‘ t sib] if a handful f agitators, ! ved va s i arty lrunken mob ild dictate its will to tl . - . lative power and appoint the executiy we I t The present Chamber is doomed. It can. set t ther give suflicient strength to the Exe ‘ f ‘ power, nor can it reduce the revolutionary 1 vort nority of the country to its natural insigt \ st \ cance It has diminished the Presider \ Babtiy pow it has increased the danger of C munism. Sooner or later it will have to be dis HOW Is \ M solved, and the Senate
to its dissolution, l E | } Na ‘N a) La \ 1 ‘ mentary art 1 \\ Correspondence. free-trade ef Nevert NS \ se ceadibeis : ma THE PRESIDENTS MESSAGE gis v1 ‘ To THE EpitorR OF THE NATION : presented \ Sirk: The President’s message is already taking a ul view done the country a great service, even tl lw tok vw M its recommendations should be succes VO} Carlis ‘ \ posed fora time. It calls into acti t large i i f ‘ class of cultivated men who had 1 ! is Is \ gusted with politics, and who were tl ate 1 \ t t with paralvsis of all patriotic feeling l S LOU OOO O00) otk t Now condition of tl gs constitutes a danger not s how w i \ \ ‘ grave than the financial and commercial ite Lis dition” which it is sought to reliey \ few of hy ¢ these men, to be sure, have expressed the s ike off a x content with the low standards of the exis ‘ political parties, and, though few, tl ! \ Y x ready exerted a powerful influe But v ‘ who naturally belonged with t M SS I wumps” or Independents ” took 1 ‘ ( ‘ s “S sw ' part, and did not even care to vot t ‘ Y ’ . Presidential election Ss I ta rhe late message has cleared the air. at Ist of the surprises of the next President \ x paign is to be the number of cultiv i 2.) What S who will resume their functions as s s sos S rouse a large body of } st and w s SIN citizens to exercise their rights to st T . patriotic feeling wit s S k t st more worth w t S rt ¥ in and to strive to ] te it sisas s this . L speak ‘ t : cond ton nd 1 i Pres . s i t ‘ Lincoln M sW SEY \ sepa a S \ ton AWREN N e 4 AS " m) pM t rthe for i manuta ire in tions to ¢ s tr { the \me in ( rent Never } s t siM aces have plain me of t courses to farast W - rs sa Say t . shut up, or reduce cost ibor) by $5.00 Pres t beer t k was scarcely per ton, or 35 per cent Can you think of any drv va t x <s vs the wav’ If not. do you think American cal ite W feat Ar a hanics, artisans, and laboring men, and the t sof persona s the nat fp fa rs who find manufacturing centres their nur i Ss, DY t s of irties W mor highest priced markets, will permit any party r SS Davy t art to take to stand which advocates such action ? the place s by na ial con I ask these questions, not to argue for a sys ventions to be ft case, our country i tem that has many inconsistencies but to get
will be forced
OTl.
Page 16
12 light on the practical phases of a question af- fecting every American citizen. H,. CINCINNATI, O, [ We have never advocated taking $100,000, - desirable, we could find ways to do it with- out producing all of the evils apprehended by “11.” The Bureau of Statistics classifies our imports, for purposes of conyenience and simplicity, in six schedules, with the amounts of duty collected, thus: Class A—Food and live animals..... $67,998,330 Class B—Articlesto be manufactured = 19,567,903 Class C—Manufactures to be further ‘ manufactured pik ene se aeminn® 20,393,494 Revenue from these classes....... $107,959,727 The other schedules are ‘‘ manufactured articles ready for consumption” and ‘ arti- cles of voluntary use, luxuries, ete.,” which need not be here considered. The ‘‘ manufac tured articles to be further manufactured ” consist of tin plates, wire rods, paints, dyes, and chemicals, lumber, leather, furs, mate for hats, and woollen and Pie iron is in the list of crude arti rials worsted yarns, cles to be manufactured, and is an incon siderable item so far as the revenue collected from it goes. An effectual measure for the reduction of the surplus would be the repeal or reduction of taxes on the following articles : $30,000,000 30,000,000 30,000,000 Domestic tobacco, ..... Sugar (reduce one-half). . . Other food and raw muterials. . $90,000,000 The surplus is a tremendous fact. It was $55,000,000 on the Ist of December. It is now $66,000,000. Any person who objects to any particular mode of reducing it is bound to show a better one.—Ep. Nation. | “IN THIS CONNEXION.” To THE EprTorR OF THE NATION: Sirk: One of your correspondents, some months ago, ventured to characterize the words of my heading as at once “a New England phrase” and ‘a very illogical pro- vincialism.” My compendious reply to him, in No. 1127, was: ‘‘ It is neither ; and I could make good my contention.” I now do so. By normal development, connexion, original- ly abstract, has come to be also concrete, for ‘*person or thing in connexion or connected”; and it is, further, used collectively, as in ‘the Whig connexion,” ‘the Methodist conne.rion.” But the fact is overlooked, by lexicographers, that it has been synonymized with confect; ex- cept that, in this acceptation, it is seldom, how ever unobjectionably, found immediately pre- ceded by the definite article. goes to show,” or the like, I do net remember * The connexion to have met with more than once. Etymologically considered, though not with the sanction of ordinary usage, like the Latin contextus, context signifies, according to Dr. Johnson’s first definition of it, series of a discourse” “the general ; a definition which the latest editor of Dr. Johnson’s Dictionary, Dr. Latham, has omitted. As all but invariably employed, the term imports, with reference to a discourse or composition, viewed as a com- plex, one of its items, clauses, or topics, re- garded relatively to something to which it is either adjacent or allied. Connexion, precisely so taken, is exemplified in the subjoined quotations, &c. : “ This word, in certain connexions, denotes,” | The Nation. &e.: ‘The word, in all its connec- tions throughout the Hebrew scriptures,” &c. Rey. Martin Madan, Thelypthora (1780), vol. i., pp. 48, 62. | | | ‘‘Martin took the sentence out of its connec- | tion.” ‘‘Here, then, we have not only the same ar- gument stated, but nevion.” William Hazlitt (1807), Political Ks- says (1819), p. 415. words. in different connerions, they may seem (but only seem) to acquire and ex- press different meanings.” James Gilchrist, The Labyrinth Demolished (1815), p. 22. “In such a conne.rion, the indefinite article answers a useful purpose.” Jd., The Etymologic Interpreter (1824), p. 138. ; *“Sulpicius also happens to mention, In an- other connexion,” &e, Cardinal Newman (1833, &e.), The Church of the Fathers (2nd ed. of 1842), p. 412. And again (1542) in the Cardi- nal’s Essay on Ecclesiastical Miracles (1848), p. 82, and in other works of his. “Those who pick the word out of its con- nerion,” &e. Rev. Dr. S. R. Maitland, Re- marks, &e. (1836), p. 31. ‘Its influence on the planting and manufac- turing interests is a subject to be considered in another connexion.” Miss Harriet Martineau, Society in: America (1837), vol. i, p. 103° (ed, 1839). Also in vol. ii., pp. 117, 252, 306, ‘This is almost the only connexion in which the word ‘woman’ is used.” J/d., tbid., vol. iii., p. 83. **T certainly had not read it [sci/., a certain yassage] in its original connerion.” Rev. Dr. V. H. Mill (1846), Five Sermons on the Nature of Christianity (1548), p. 130. “Tn another connexion.” Rev. Mark Patti- son, Oxford Essays (1855), p. 277. “Tn such a connexion.” Mr. Walter Bage- hot (1859), Literary Studies (1879), vol. i, p. 213. ‘“In a different connerion.” Dr. W. G, Ward, Nature and Grace (1860), pp. 349, 416. ‘In different connerions.” Rev. Benjamin Jowett, Essays and Reviews (1860), p. 371. “Ina different connerion,” ‘in another con- nerion,” Prof. John Conington (died 1869), Miscellaneous Writings (1872), vol. i., pp. 266, 458. “Tn a somewhat different connection.” Mr. tichard Congreve (1870), Essays, &c. (1874), p. BOA. “In such a connection.” Mr. John Morley, Richard Porson, Letters to Mr. Arch- | : | deae Travis (700), p. 310. 000 off the customs revenue; but if that were | deacon Travis (1790), p. 3 stated in the same con- | [Number 1175 ‘““We shall treat of them in the same [7. e., one and the same] connection.” Spirit of the Age (1825), p. 159%. Connexion is here much the same as contexte, agreeably to the first part of one of the defini- tions of it in the Dictionary of the French Academy: ‘Un texte queleonque, considéré par rapport & rensemble didées qu'il présente, | ou au sens que certains passages empruntent de ‘* By placing any of the arithmetic signs or | Critical Miscellanies, vol. i. (AST), p. 318. “In | the present connection.” Id., Voltaire (1871), p. 295 (ed. 1872). “Tn such a connection.” Mr, Leslie Stephen, Hours ina Library, First Series (1874), p. $21. “In any other connection.” English Thought, &c. (1876), vol. ii., p. 408, * In several connerions, in different connevions.”. Mr. Matthew Arnold, God and | the Bible (A875), p. 207 (ed. 1SS4). “In the same connerion.” Prof. Sidney Col- vin, Landor (1881), p 21. Passing by unnoticed a great many similar proofs of my position which are at hand, I give four quotations exemplifying the not unusual substitution of connexion for context in a trala- titious sense : ‘Many ideas may be excellent as parts of a great whole, which, when violently torn from their connection,” &e. William Godwin, An Enquiry concerning Political Justice (1793), p. 220, ‘A subject in all its import, meaning, con- nections, relations, aspects, and bearings.” James Gilchrist, Reason the True Arbiter of Lanauage (1814), p. 7. Id., History of ‘** Meantime, the clergy were pretending to | find express sanctions of slavery in the bible, | and putting words to this purpose into the mouths of public men who do not profess to remember the existence of the Bible in any | other connexion.” Miss Martineau (ut supra), vol. iil., p. 231. ** How should a story prove the existence of | unidiomatical. God, which, if told in any other connection, | would only prove its narrator to be the victim or the author of a lie?” Hours in a Library, Second Series (1876), p. 142. On at least one occasion, William Hazlitt pretty clearly extends the meaning of connex- ion, so as to make the word equivalent to dis- course. It is where, having premised the names of Byron and Scott, he goes on to say : Mr. Leslie Stephen, | ce qui les précéde ou de ce qui les suit.” The word context, in all likelihood, seemed too formal and technical to those who pro- posed, in place of it, connexion used restric- tively. The latter has, but little affected, on the whole, the prevalence of the former ; and we find, in the pages of a living author, even ‘in this context,” in preference to the phrase which has been objected to. Mr. Richard Congreve has (1873) : however, ‘** But, if I wished to indicate the general de- fect under which we labour, a general ground for our not producing a greater effect than we do, I should avail myself of the words of one of our number—not used in this context, but suit- ing my present purpose,—and say,” &e. Essays, &c. (1874), p. 450. As respects the particular combination “in this connexion,” possibly it had not yet appear- ed in 1800; and, at present, Iam unable to show that its age is more than half a century. That all along during that time, however, it has had the support of very good authority is evidenced by the ensuing quotations and refer- ences; ‘** Such, at least, is the theory; and one fact, in this connexion, is,” &c. Miss Martineau (ut supra), vol. i., Also in vol. ii., p. 28, and vol. iii., p. 75. “In this connevion we are led to quote,” &e, Cardinal Newman (1841), Essays Critical and Historical (1871), vol. ii., p. 272. “Tn this connexion, therefore, it is full of in- terest to trace back,” &c. Bp. Samuel Wilber- force, A History of the Protestant Episcopal Church in America (1844), p. 13 (ed. 1846). Prof. F. W. Newman, History of the Hebrew Monarchy (1547), p. 854: Miscellanies (1860), p. 302. Rev. G. S. Faber, The Many Mansions, &e. (1851), p. 457 (ed. 1862). Rev. Dr. S. R. Maitland, Fight Essays on Various Subjects (1852), p. 150. Saturday Review (1861), vol. xi., p. 662. Literary Churchman (1861), vol. vii., p. 447. Mr. John Morley, Critical Miscelianies, vol. i. (IST1), p. 822. Ld., On Compromise (1874), p. 116. Mr. Leslie Stephen, Hours in a Library. First Series (IS74), p. 192: Third Series (1874), p. 198, tev. J. D. Aylward, in Essays on Religion and Literature, edited by Cardinal Manning, Third Series (1874), p. 86. Dr. C. EK. Appleton (1876), Life and Literary Relics of him (1881), p. 175, ; Mr. J. A. Symonds, Shelley (1878), p. 85. “George Eliot,” Jmpressions of Theophrastus Such (1809), pp. 271, J48, The expression is there used figuratively. Dr. W. G. Ward (1882), Essays on the Philo- sophy of Theism (1854), vol. ii., pp. 122, 182. — we The want of sufficient specification in some of my old notes prevents me from referring here to the Rev. Dr. Whewell and many other au- thors of acknowledged repute. Even it ‘in this connexion” stood, as it has been supposed to do, for the elliptical **in con- nexion with this,” still it could not be arraign- ed either as ‘‘ very illogical,” or as violently Nearly on all fours with it, thus understood, is ‘tin his company,” with which may be compared ‘on this account,” ‘*on this score,” ‘tin his stead,” and similar ex- pressions in abundance. Madame D’Arblay’s ** jn its comparison,” for ‘in comparison with or of it,” is certainly very peculiar. See her Diary and Letters, vol. vi. (1846), p. 199, “Tn this connexion,” ‘tin a.other connexion,” ‘*in such a connexion,” &c., are, obviously, ho- mogeneous. The second occurs, in the range of paperless staat cs SS 8"
Page 17
Jan. 5, 1888] my reading, as early as the first. Cardinal Newman has been cited for both of them; and, in the absence of proof, it is not lightly to be assumed that such a master of English idiom would countenance so illegitimate an ellipsis as ‘in another connexion,” for ‘‘in connexion with another matter,” or the like Finally, if the use of connexion for context frequent as it is, had not been cverlooked, probably the expressions here discussed would have incurred no censure. As regards ** in this connexion,” the late Mr. Edward S. Gould was well advised in declining the advice given him to condemn it. That it is “not often employed by the best writers in England” is one of the numerous statements hazarded by the editors of Dr. Webster's Dictionary which require mo dification, while their prim&-facie explanation of it, ‘Sin connection with this subject,” calls to be revised.— Your obedient servant, F. H MARLESFORD, ENGLAND, December 13, L887, . ROBERT SOUTH AND THE ENCYCLO PLEDIA BRITANNICA To THE EpITtoR OF THE NATION: Sir: In the last volume of the * Eneyclopa dia Britannica’ (volume xxii), in the article ‘* Robert South.” it is said: ‘‘In 1710, he (South) showed himself a keen opponent of Sacheverell.” Now, in the memoir of D1 South which is prefixed to the edition of his works published by Bohn of London, in 1850, it is said (page vii): ‘* His zeal for the welfare of his beloved Church lost none of its ardour, and we are not surprised to find that, among the last acts of his public life, was his interesting himself on behalf of the notorious Dr. Sache verell.” Again, Dr. Lake, ham, says in his essay on South (Kempe’s ‘Clas the present Dean of Dur sic Preachers of the Englisi Church.’ p. (4 ‘“(He] was a warm supporter of Sacheverel e somewhat Confidence in this statement may impaired by the fact that Dr. Lake adds that this occurred “tin 1670.7 whereas Sacheverell was not born till 1674. The internal evidence, however, would be all in favor of Dr. Lake and the Memoir and against the * Encyclopedia sritannica.’ Sacheverell was an ardent Tory, who preached two sermons in 1700, declaring the Church in danger from the course of the Whig Ministry. February, 1710, and was all his life proclaiming the divine right For this he was prosecuted in South, too, was astrong Tory, of Church and State and non-resistance to royal ordinance. It is inthe highest degree improbable that he should be a ** keen opponent” of a man whose position he so thoroughly sympathized with as that of Dr. Sacheverell. I have not at hand the means for consulting authorities mort widely and determining whether the ‘ Encyclo pedia Britannica’ has made a mistake here, as would seem to be the case. Can any of you readers settle the question It is also stated in the same article that South was, before the Restoration, ‘a strong supporter of Presbyterianism.” I can tind no evidence of this, except the fact that in 1655 the year in which he took his B. A. degree at Oxford, he published a Latin panegyri Cromwell. When we remember that La verses in England, even in our own day, ar not the most natural medium for the express of the author's opinions, and that the subjects for such verses are often set by the college au thorities, stronger proof of South's ardent support of Presbyterianism will be needed tl of that he w these verses. As negative pi is not attracted to) Presbyterianisn poted the tacts that t sat edt hli sen vit ¢ 7 I ¢ his public capacity of 7 ve | 4 x that he drew upon } se the severe repri life The illustrat mand of Dr. John Owe ( ‘ s Viee printed, and tl Chances r of tl for tinu wort s ha ing to Worship a t t! uw ~ s i after it had bee t that } was | 1 sa it admitted to holy or ‘ a ved | t bishop, wl s, if | ‘ t i I An A ine of Presbyvt a nm } i it i I ! Db have s 1 ition ft t st ' t st thorities. or, if more ‘ 1 Kr some hier yr tbs i tha ' t takes mad i nt itt . l Professors of G : Work I ‘ quity mm the Inder t is erin true, It Is) pos I t iN ! had l 1a =I ‘ i = i ‘ enough t swer f nt ilways fittest hamy tf the estal t.w i pell Ma n ile is | t l the ease. to answ - . . - P Shakspe \ of a ing moa Gi Presby te i t I ( S a very brief tin ( ! ! ( mvict the I | Brita e* 4 } again ! \ t ( t SKINTOWS ‘ f \r = . t Notes. , . t - ‘ ‘i i CHAS. SCRIBNER'S Sons ! sa Unit 3 tl ‘Men a Ter by R . ’ Le S Sfevensor ¥ | t \\ e Indies, by J A. Fre it iS i 1 New ] \ SI Spain,” by the Re He M. | , ‘ edition, thoroughly re st 7 2 ¢ x's ‘United States N Kr t sla tion of Prof. Franz D sch’'s his ‘Commentary Gi Anson I). | ( i \ x mim tely * TI sby . f Har ! i = ( y State in \ i; tow 1 ( ‘ Hist \ t Pres \ , from 17 t aN i s Ia \ \ P} 1) ‘ on the Lif { mil \ \ \ s Hodder, aut | I S . ‘ bury The Dante Si t . ( s lance of tl I) if “ Prof. | A. F $ i 1 ~ L ti md ‘ “V i . . ‘ now ready f pr " tain b ht s Ss the g s i “ S racy in tl y r . \ \ ad irs, by sul . . will be ar ~ s tr l yr A ‘ . s valual it Subs \ . sent t Mr VW Ss \ Bost srs \ \ x ( T + Py WL Kr \ ss g ta M . 4 i f (y cr \ s t wis a this . Vas Ring Py Kr I N painting 1d he : t I I h searches W \ Uo e i N sr I neatiy = = . ran ¢ “ s EN e S i rsified t t \ g Ve managing edi Ag s s ~ associates, Messrs ‘ Tt? ‘ ‘ ir ai a Notes already take tne Nation. sa n treat ilts ‘ S - { ~~ f \ \ N ‘ ~ ‘ ’ N ‘ \ ~ } xs ‘ al \ } iw i that nai Ve il + ¢ Cis suita ' " i It w Ve 1 A? 1 Pr f ht. ts What se i i lead in * Luacle t lw La " ‘ . \ \ rs pel
Page 18
—s 1+ taining to the scientific teaching of modern languages and literatures. This comes of hav- ing a high purpose and the courage of one’s convictions. We have only one remark to offer upon the general direction of the Notes: it is, that English philology has not the prominence that one might look for in an English journal. This bias towards the foreign is doubtless one of which the editors are not at all conscious. It is at bottom the result of occult psychological forces. Educated as so many of us have been in foreign schools, we are apt to overlook the truism that the foreign is there the native. If we are to rival the Germans, for instance, not merely in form but in spirit, we shall give the lion’s share to our own modern language, as they give it to theirs, Carl's essay on the life and works of Thomas Lodge, Anglia x, 235-258, is a good summing up and restatement of what was already known, but it scarcely adds to our knowledge. — Like so many other disquisitions in the Anglia, it suffers from an overflow of “ Quellen”; the three pages of authorities might profitably have been condensed into one. And one mono- graph on Lodge, the most important of late years, is strangely conspicuous by its absence— we mean Gosse’s paper, in his ‘Seventeenth Century Studies’ (London, 1883), From it Carl might have learned of Lodge’s being entered at Merchant School, March, 1571; also that the non-mention of Lodge in his father’s will by no means implied disinheritance for bad conduct. Car] does not seem to be aware of Lodge’s later proclivities to Roman Catholicism, touched upon by Gosse. Read in this light, the passage, cited p. 261, condemning the use of Scripture for the drama, is anything but “irony”; it is rather the language of a convert. The latest issue of the Englische Studien, xi, 1, contains an instructive article of twenty- five pages by Krummacher on the language and style of Carlyle’s ‘ Frederick IL.’ We are all familiar by this time with Carlylese, its strong and its weak points. But such a sys- tematic treatment of it by a well-trained for- eigner will give us a clearer perception of its oddities. The words are arranged in alpha- betical order. Not the least valuable portion of the paper is that which treats of compounds and derivatives. The author has erred occa- sionally in treating as Carlylese what is com- mon literary property—thus, ‘‘ abeyance,” page 80. ** Doggery,” page 83, can scarcely be a rendering of Canaille ; ** thimblerig-filouterie, page 82, is too obvious in meaning to call fora ” (4). ‘* Inarticulate,” page 85, is interpreted ” ‘beliebter Ausdruck fiir wortkarg, verschlos- sen, unberedt, auch fiir unverstaéndlich”; not one of these quite hits the mark. An interesting recent) Russian publication is ‘Old St. Petersburg,’ by M. I. Pylayeff, with numerous illustrations taken from old prints. The city is old enough and has under- gone enough changes to render such a book ap- propriate, though it cannot compete with many other European capitals in the beauty of its ancient structures, whatever may be said about the buildings of the present day. General Alexander von Kaulbars, before he | became so conspicuous in Bulgarian affairs, was chiefly known as explorer of the Oxus, or Amu Darya, River and its basin. He has recently issued a new book on the subject, entitled ‘ The Most Ancient Beds of the Amu-Darya.’ Thanks to the labors and investigations of specialists one of the most prominent questions of late has been as to the former course of that Central- Asian stream, and it is a question of some in- terest independently of its purely scientific as- pects. Recent researches have revealed traces of the former channel of the river through the The Nation. present oasis of Khiva, below Pitnyak, and further out on the steppe towards the Sari- Kamyshk basin, and also of an ancient channel through which the overflow of this basin reach- ed the Caspian Sea. General Kaulbars’s latest volume is devoted to the subject of these an- cient channels ; and he notes the traces which are met with above Pitnyak, along the banks of the river’s present channel, and in the stretch lying between Khiva and the northern exten- sions of the Paropamisus, nearly to the Caspian Sea. His volume is published by the Geo- graphical Society at St. Petersburg, is accom- panied by charts showing the altitude of vari- ous points above the level of the Caspian Sea along the line of Tcharjui-Merv, etc., by a detailed chart of the country between the Caspian Sea and the Sea of Aral, of the dis- tricts adjoining the Amu-Darya, and by other charts. The December Proceedings of the Royal Geo- graphical Society contains a brief sketch of Mr. A. D. Carey’s remarkable journey in 1885 from Ladakh through Central Asia and from Lob Nor across the Altyn Tagh into northern Tibet. The solitariness of part of the region through , Which he passed can be realized from the fact that for eighty days he did not see a human being save the members of his own party. When they at length reached an inhabited place, his followers in an ecstasy of delight knelt and kissed the first human foot-prints which they saw. There were some fertile tracts, but this part of Turkestan is generally very sterile, and the people are wretchedlys poor. They were very friendly, however, and apparently well governed. Crime was rigidly repressed, and life and property as safe as in India. At one point Mr. Carey reports falling in with an incredible number of antelopes, and at another he saw tigers hunting on the ice. Petermani’s Mitteilungen for November con- tains the conclusion of Dr. V. Jhering’s report on the German colony in the Brazilian province of Rio Grande do Sul, together with a sketch of Capt. J. S. King’s explorations in Somali- land. Dr. Schinz throws very serious doubts on the genuineness of Mr. Farini’s ‘ Through the Kalahari Desert,’ hinting very plainly that it is nothing but a ‘‘Jules Verne’sche ” romance. A supplementary number contains an elaborate monograph on the island of Corfu by J. Partsch, accompanied by three admirable maps. The third part of ‘ Bibliographie générale et raisonnée du droit belge,? by Edmond Picard and Ferdinand Larcier (Brussels: F. Larcier), has been published during the year and com- pletes the alphabet of authors. The three parts, of which the first was published in 1882 and the second in 1885, make one volume of S67 octavo pages. A second volume is to con- tain the periodicals, series, and all the anony- mous works, notwithstanding that when the authorship of an anonymous book has been dis- covered, the title appears under the author's name in this first volume. The publisher also promises a subject index. The period covered begins with the year 1814, and the number of titles recorded is 6,786. This number includes, however, the contributions to 186 periodicals and society publications which are indexed. When these are deducted, there remain about 4,200 titles of books and pamphlets upon law subjects issued from the press of Belgium in Latin, nearly every book is in the French language, the only exceptions being seventy- one titles in Dutch, three in German, and a single one, ‘The Laws of Belgium which Affect British Subjects,’ in English. The titles are given with reasonable fulness, including the [ Number 1175 place of publication, name of publisher, and date, while the size of each book and the num- ber of pages it contains are stated, and, when it was published for sale, the price is added. Only the last edition of a work is catalogued, but ina note the dates of the earlier editions are mentioned, and the notes also contain brief references to review notices, while, in the case of deceased authors, biographical references are appended. The new Berlin school for the study of Orien- tal languages has 115 students, 40 of whom are preparing for the diplomatic and colonial service. There are about as many who expect to be teachers and naturalists or explorers, the remainder being merchants’ clerks. The Ara- bic and Chinese classes are most numerously at- tended, the Japanese and Turkish coming next. —In the January Atlantic, fiction comes well to the front, with two new serials, and the pro- spectus for the year promises yet a third from the pen of Henry James. The leading place is given to a novel fresh in topic and treatment, the scene being laid in Japan, The opening chapters introduce us to a missionary circle and exhibit the limitations of mind and culture in some of its members, with an unsparing frankness. One overhears in the comments of the principal character, who tells the story in his own person, the author’s disapproval of some traits which it is not surprising to find in earnest and narrow persons from among whom the ranks of missionaries are necessarily recruit- ed, and there is something of harshness in the words used, however just they may be in particu- larcases. But the Japanese heroine is drawn with a tender touch, and has the pathetic quality apt to be found in aliens who interest the Western mind; and the episode of her early life, which is the main incident of these chapters, is a de- lightful child-story. The progress of this tale from a new hand will be looked for with a hu- manitarian’s as well as a novel-reader’s interest. The other serial is from Miss Murfree, whose engraved portrait accompanies the number; it is in her well-worked style. The remain- der of the contents is variously made up of tra- vel to the two Golden Horns of Constantinople and California; of some letters of Franklin to Strahan which illustrate the sort of books our great-grandfathers read; and of ashort contribu- tion by Mr. Edward J. Lowell to the endless discussion of what should constitute a liberal education for an American boy, from the point of view of the smaller college. Mr. James Russell Lowell contributes a brief poem in lyrical form, which exhibits both the grace of his muse and the mastery of his hand, and is another foretaste of the promised volume for which the public still waits, —The illustrated article in Scrilner’s is one upon medieval armor. It is very complete, and is accompanied by a text which is not too technical, though somewhat difficult to follow as a history of armor. The Great Pyramid, a subject whose interest seems to be as eternal as the stone, is admirably pictured from many points of view, and the story of its exploration in modern times is well told, Fiction is repre- sented by a new long novel by Mr. F. J. Stim- son, ‘‘ First Harvests”—presumably the first results of American civilization in society. | The scene is in New York, the characters are something like seventy years. Aside from a | large number of inaugural dissertations in | fashionable, the tone is cynical to a fault; the work has received high finish, and there are some beautiful descriptions of the sights of an oil refinery, in which there was opportunity for the author's poetic feeling. Mr. Brownell con- tinues to exalt the French genius for intelli- gence, but his essays suffer from comparison with Mr, Hamerton’s late papers, My. Lang
Page 19
Jan. 5, 1888] has a charming motive fora poem in **‘ American Antiquities,” of which he makes the most he is able to do; and Mr. Aldrich contributes a pathe- tie single-thought “White Edith.” A very interesting article to those whose taste leads them to Oriental art is from the hand of Mr. William Elliot Griffis, on ‘‘ Japanese Art, Art ists, and Artisans,” poem, with illustrations after draw ings by a Japanese artist. Municipal finance and Balzac are topics to add variety, and the Mr. Robert Le number is rounded off by Stevenson, who confides to the reader how his waking moments have been served by his dreams, which have given suggestions or scenes for some of his stories, lies -The interest of the January Harper's largely in its illustrations. Two of the butions treat directly of art subjects, and yet in such a way as to leave the pictures in the first place. The of the Magi,” which leads the number, shows the changes of contri * Adoration rendering and spirit which different times have brought about in the case of one of the con stant themes of the painter’s imagination, from the walls of the Catacombs to the Church of the Incarnation in this city; and the article upon ‘* French Sculpture” makes the modern masters of France known by a number of examples of their characteristic The text of both papers is inferior. Archdeacon Farrar’s sketch works. of the share of America in Westminster Abbey is also mainly attractive from _ its cuts ; but the attention of those who are England be interested in placing memorials in to testify to American filial directed to the Archdeacon’s§ desire to “erect a worthy window” to John Milton's memory inthe Church of St. Margaret’s, and his declaration that if any of Milton’s American admirers should be willing to assist in this de sign, he would ‘‘on public grounds most hearti The piety, may ly welcome their munificence.” twenty portraits of Italian Deputies, principally minis ters, are also of interest to the eye, and the text is what it should be, brief and to the point Mr. Watterson writes of the tariff from the re the ness and point specially desirable now. close The city of Savannah is graphically laid before th: former's standpoint, but hardly with reader in an article that glows with the optim ism and pride of the new South, and is mate rially instructive as well. Mr. Black begins a new novel, and Mr. Curtis again passes to his readers the compliments of the season. —The ‘ Social History of England,’ by Louise Creighton (London: Rivingtons, 1887), is the second contribution toa series called ‘* High ways of History,” edited by Louise Creighton, the first volume of which, ‘ The Government of ‘ATE 1 says the pre England, by the same author, in ISS4. ‘* The aim of this series,” apy spectus, “is to give consecutive treatment to certain important subjects in English History The treatment of the subjects in this series is adapted for the use of students who have already mastered the general outline of English History, but wish for more connected information with regard to some special point Each part is complete in itself, and treats of its own subject without reference, except where necessary, to the general course of events.’ In the ‘Social History of England,’ the author has, on the whole, done her work admirably development, Saxo Every important phase of social from the f the medieval towns, gilds, monasteries, mark system « ns, tl feudalism villeinage, etc., down to the reforms of the nineteenth century, is briefly comprehensively discussed. In a like this, based omissions and errors of on many authorities, s detail are inevital Uls The Nation. On p. 10 the important points of tween English and Continental feudalism should have been briefly characterized. Tl distinction between e yurt baron ¢
tomary, on p is not fully enough stated The old gild-halls of England did not bear the name Hans h is asserted on | ex perhaps in the two cases of Beverley and Y k Th f ul t Was not ! reiv the 1 t the bur sses to collect t rotval dues | i. ing to a town (p. 25), but the mmutation of those dues by the annual wnt of a tinxned sum of money There is no good auth tv for the statement, on p. 25, that ‘‘a branch of t famous Hanseatic League had bee stab] { in London certainly since 67." F irq) np read 1 f feutont nh |] AL liar Lt But we are not 1 to emphasize these and some tcomings that ha ttract our attention. The work is a compilation real merit, whi may be safely ¢ mended not merely to voung students, but also to ler per sons seeking to supplement or to refresh t knowledge of the Culfurgeschichte of England Sievers’s Anglo-Saxon grammar, whether in the original German or in Cook's translation is doubtless somewhat bulky and complicated for the beginner Admittir this, we cannot withhold from the * Outline Anglo-Saxon Baskervill and Harrison Grammar,’ by LS Barnes & Co.) the merit of undertaking to meet a practical want. The pamphlet is an ff print,” with some corre: is, of the Appendix
to the Dictionary, published two vears a But we suspect that the editors are not f abreast with the times. Why, for instance, do they adhere to Koch’s antiquated class it of strong verbs, instead of following tl scientitic clas ition of Braune, Sievers, and Noreen? Ortreat tGd, fot, bGc as ed stems Or speak of nik? as indeclinabl \s the adverbial genitive fes, mentioned by them, we tind a geniti idverbia rv venitis hte, a dat lat pl if rt sta | ! } ' t i the verb forms (a-/ ire based Boswort Toller and Groschopp, and tt rthograpt ted by Sweet's * Read s t ving It would have been incom it sat t follow Sievers’s se 1 it } \ what is meant | lar verb-forms I \ ers of S rs know that the i i s early English, and that t early and late ms. | they know of regula { mus as s Ma st if lar. ‘I litors ha et “i t uchout s spellings as Jican (pr Is this lar in dist n ft i W ossex i And of the six forms , s eg i Ti i - would be difficult t s > : er j } ’ sat t p ‘ s nter i Tha sent s suff g } i “i i 4 ~ = ‘ i ara \ t ~ x t ‘ k ] ~ Plants \r s in Trans (sia t t Res « W t t whose work Is tat s Greek ind Lat WI Ss. a is x i t l what i it 4 t ir ta piants i als, 1 s x Saal ¢ interestine aspects the su S as W Ss ta But now 308 Otto Keller, assuring us “ that there } , } is pe Nal) world a s ius t trea i iN ‘ SIs \ . Sprite ¢ ¢ cates and ev \ Jd gogr . Ler t exit ! s i ‘ ¢ t t I oa | Muse ul Ri —™ s ‘ uiv i ¢} 1 text self t itso Ass SN Ar stud ‘ 1 Ra an iA s 1 I s ‘ ist s ai “ \ ~ ‘ S wil i} at bel ‘ A iv, al i becins wit ‘ =, e Le t, Ww +) } by T} yerhy th sHOUgH ta
» Lmperial Publi » PR u n wi t lew ed pert ly agreed a his, that hon the ar ais antiguity¥ is it }* t s \ tira With is ul MS A t } t t i ww k vy i nr i i l is s n ss Spe pea s text t . s 5 wea vied a tx | } al = i _ ‘ ? q ir te t 7 , } " i \ N = ai ‘ \ k . Vises i P i ‘ iN * i { ‘ ‘ as a \le Va w . “ N ‘ P \ ‘ x \ iw \ . \ ‘ ~ i and = 1 . ali« ~ \ 4 n ~ VAS ed < s t s Ns in i ORS thie s ] ‘ “ 1 iter a te armed pore i ~ } i ~ A h 1 4 ~e s for Hi s ppear (ner t and has other modest An im t t i { I } i i ecluc ‘ ike the aut rities, and . ance be thoroughly tha i Amel! i The first free rb f tl ! nory of the vas opened | lay before yester day vesterday it was thronged. It the modest outfit of four thousand juired from various sources, and is to establish a great many more the hope that workingmen may abandon the dram-shops Library is accessi-
Page 20
16 ble to everybody, it is by no means free in the American sense of that term ; it is more like the Astor Library, and the officials shake their heads in amazement and doubt when I reply to their queries as to whether we have any like it in America, No books are permitted for use at home. Only personal friendship with a librarian will give ‘ public libraries’ one that privilege in the librarian’s name. It seems that the public here abused the privileges accorded to them even in the matter of a full printed catalogue, of which it was found im- possible to keep a perfect copy on hand, so that now only a partial catalogue is generally available, and not a single book can be had without a signed application. also, an application made in the morning is only filled after three Pp. M. These precautions are probably the outcome of unpleasant experience ; but the effect upon the In many cases, or the next day. officials of such an establishment of my descrip- tion of the unprotected reference books and the free public imagined than de methods in American better general libraries can be scribed,” RENAN’S HISTORY OF ISRAEL. Histoire du Par Ernest Re- nan, member de l'Institut, professeur au Col- lége de France. Vol. I. Paris: Calmann Lévy; New York: B. Westermann & Co. 1887. ‘euple AIsraél, In order to complete the ‘ History of the Origins of Christianity,’ which he initiated a quarter of a century ago with his ‘ Vie de Jésus,’ and continued in ‘Les Apdtres,’ ‘Saint-Paul, ‘L’Antechrist,) ‘Les Evangiles, ‘ L’Eglise Chrétienne,’ and ‘ Mare-Auréle,’ M. Renan goes back to the early history of the nation to which the founders of the Christian religion belonged, tracing the origins to their remote springs, ‘the great prophets who introduced morality into religion about 850 Christ.” But then, “ prophetism itself has its root in the antique ideal of patriarchal life, an ideal created partly by faney, but which had been a reality in a remote part of the Israelitish tribe.” Consequently Renan must begin the be ginnings with the history of Hebrew patri- archal times. But is there such a_ history? Have any records of it been preserved? Are the Biblical Abraham, Jacob, Joseph, historical personalities? years before Jesus M. Renan has not the least hesi- tation in answering these questions with a bold negative. Abraham is a transformed recollee- tion of a mythical Babylonian King—the good Orham, or ** father Orham,” Ab-Orham. and Joseph are abridged names of nomad clans, Jacob-El and Joseph-El, devoted to the worship of El, like Ishma-El and other Arab Elites. The stories told about Jacob them in Genesis are childish tales, full of miraculous traits, which readers of our time cannot but find absurd in the highest degree. Yet such is the vast learn- ing, Biblical and Semitic in general, at the dis- posal of our writer, and such the magic pow- er of his poetic fancy and descriptive diction, that he can venture to reconstruct Israel's earli- est history, partly out of general observations on Arab nomad life and primitive institutions, and partly out of threads woven by the into their historical Hebrews scanty ancient myths and tales, As we remarked on a much earlier occasion (see Nation, No, 215), ** M. Renan, without any qualification, rejects as incredible everything supernatural; but the shadows that accompany the delineations of supernatural things he saves, and — quite as artfully as artistically them into works neW ilnages. Hus new images are often excellent imitations of the sacred ones he | The Nation. tears ; but while orthodoxy must spurn them as devoid of all sacred substance, mere un- impassioned criticism, too, can see in them little more than shadows.” Thus he created his Jesus and his Apostles, and painted their Galilee and the cradle-time of Christianity, and thus he re- constructs and paints, with admirable skill, [Israel in his infancy and childhood. We use this personal (and Scriptural) form of expression, for under the poetic pencil of our author the nation becomes a hero, and its history a bio- graphical epic. He follows Israel in his wan derings—as a child—from Arabia, along the western banks of the Euphrates, to Padan- Aram, to Canaan, into Egypt. For this period of his hero’s life he has nothing but fond sym- pathy. Israel walks, or might have walked, in perfect simplicity and innocence; his God, then, was the homeless nomad’s El, or Elohim, a benevolent, impartially just, unnational, ani The pictures of this life, of this faith, are impressive and beguiling from appa- rent naturalness of delineation and coloring. And everything is chastely done, almost to the versal god. exclusion of ornamentation, which saves the | idyllically sublime from becoming ridiculous. Nor is the necessary support from varied stores of antiquarian and Oriental lore wanting to the tableau. The reader must not hastily form the conclu- sion that M. Renan’s epopee of Israel will be as unmixed in features as that of Jesus or St. Paul. Far from it. His Israel will become a nation in Egypt, and ‘alas! ning of the world no amiable nation has yet since the begin- been seen.’ veh (Jehovah), a special national god, a god- protector of Israel. The national idea will de- Elohim will be exchanged for Yah- | | examine his mand a god caring only for his nation, to the | detriment, the abasement, the woe, of all its op- The theology of Israel, in Shiloh and Shechem, Jerusalem and Samaria, ponents and rivals, will be as black (the author does not spare the color) as it was pure and amiable under the starry skies and in the healthy air of the desert. The Jehovah of the time of the judges and early kings is not just and kind like El, ‘‘ the Elyon or the Shaddai of ‘*shockingly partial” to Israel, ‘ frightfully hard” to other nations. ‘I tue, il ment, il trompe, il vole pour le plus grand bien d’Israél.” Fortunately for the world, the development of | Hebrew theology does not end there. ‘It will be the work of the prophets "—of the ninth cen- | tury B. C., and of their successors—‘‘ to recreate the patriarchs.” He is | 1 the Elohism of old by dint of reflection,” to | perfect it, to bring their people back to it, to | make it the perennial stream from which all nations will finally draw waters of bliss. ‘‘Elo- him is the universal God, the God of mankind. In reality, it is to Elohim, not to Yahveh, that the world has been converted. The world has become theistic—that is, Elohistic, not Yahvis- | | or Midianitish merchants, or tic. It has forgotten how Yahveh’s name was | pronounced; every one, to eternity, will furnish | Neither Chris- tianity nor Islam knows Yahveh.” fact, the keynote of the volume. These are surely radical notions for an histo- it with vowels as he fancies. This is, in | rian of the chosen people, a student of the ori- | gins of Christianity, who began his work, and continues it, with a kind of religious ardor. But radical and bold as all this is, the history, as such, must be pronounced far from destruc- tively critical compared with recent German works on the same subject. Wellhausen, in his well-known sketch of the history of Israel (pub- lished in the ‘ Britannica’) wastes not a para- | graph on the patriarchal period—to which our | | author devotes 150 pages—evidently deeming all the traditions coucerning it valueless as a substratum for history completely Stade, [Number 1175 in his extensive work (see Nation, Nos.1152 and 1133), barely alludes to them in a few lines, dis- tinctly declaring: Gewissheit ist bei dem bruchstiickartigen die- ser Ueberlieferungen und ihrer durchgiingigen Versetzung mythologischen Elementen nicht zu gewinnen.” He not only ignores all that is told about the migrations from Ur of the Chaldees to Haran through Canaan, but also the sojourn of the Israelites in Egypt, and their march under the lead of Moses to Sinai, and thence to Gilead. M. Renan has chapters on ‘‘ The Beni-Israel in Egypt,” on ‘Egypt's Influence on Israel,” on ‘* Israel’s Exo- dus,” on ‘Israel in the Desert of Pharan,” on “ Sinai,” and on ** The March toward Canaan,” devoting much learning, some original criti- cism, and animated diction to particulars which the more consistent German critics reject as ‘“Irgend eine historische mit completely fictitious. M. Renan’s inconsistency in rejecting the bulk of the all that has real historical importance—as legendary and rather idle tradition, and picking out some few slender threads, presumed to be of older texture, to weave them into a fanciful work of historical reconstruction, is flagrant. He knows no Joseph (barring the clan Joseph-El), no Pentateuchal narratives clearly historical Moses—‘* quoique son exis- tence soit trés probable’—no Aaron, no Levites, and doubts the existence of a Joshua; and yet he enters upon speculations on the route taken by the Israelites at the exodus from Egypt, imagines a substitute for the crossing of the Red Sea, speaks of Marah, Elim, Rephidim, Meribah, ete., and introduces Sinai in the high- When we find is said to have become a est strains of descriptive rhetoric. fascinating narratives, we them hollow. Israel people in Egypt—‘‘ Israél n'est plus une tribu, Cest déj& une nation”—but a little brackish water, sweetened by the infusion of ‘‘ certains branchages,” keeps up this people at Marah, and seventy palm trees and some tamarisks give it shade at Elim. Of course. M. Renan re- duces the millions of the fugitive Israelites to a comparatively very small number, and their forty years’ wandering in the desert to a very rapid march through it—though with a sense- less deviation *‘ toward the awful wilderness ” of Sinai; but in order to explain away an un- avoidable residue of the miraculous, he must still resort to remarks like the following: ‘‘ The fugitives might have taken along grain and pro- visions from Egypt. things which they had appropriated to them- selves, if the narratives be credible, they could have procured something from the Ishmaelitish a herd for themselves. Possibly the [Sinaitic] Peninsula was not so denuded three thousand years ago as it isat present.” ‘‘ Might,” ‘if,’ and ‘‘possi- bly” are poor substitutes for the wand of Moses, a surfeit of quails, and plenty of manna from heaven. The fact is, M. Renan is a much more radical unbeliever now than he was when he wrote his ‘Vie de Jésus,’ and he is still as Bible-loving, imaginative, and artistically ambitious as he was then. Israel without the least admixture of the su- pernatural, he cannot resign himself to present- ing it incomplete, with gaps, and devoid of its exceptional embellishments. A disciple of the prophets and Bossuet, a critical follower of Kuenen and Wellhausen, and always poetical, he turns what he cannot accept as a sacred ac- count and is unwilling to reject as an historical romance, into a romantic history. He begins with dissecting legend, and ends with rehabili tating it, forgetting his own maxim, ‘Il y adu danger A chercher trop d'histoire dans de vieux 3y means of the precious form Purposing to write a history of i 4 3 a
Page 21
Jan. 5, 1888] se distinguent pas des hommes.” footprints of the infant Israel—and to him limit remarks here—a whole image cf him is drawn, réves oft les spectres ne From the scanty we must our with the magic help of Semitic philology, Ara Egyptian lore, and philosophy and poetry. The remarks, learned or other the author's bian archeology, Babylonian and inter spersed partly drawn works and dissertations from numerous previous The critical de tails may be too numerous for the general pub are generally sugges tive and seductively plausible lic, but they enhance the value of the book for students. Some of the generalizations, whether sound or forcibly in more than one way, characteristic of the specious and glittering, are most presented. The following extract is, work: “Far from advancing the reli ment of Israel, Egypt only strewed obstacles and perils upon the road which Ge had to wander over. Egypt contributed the ‘golden calf, that eternal stumbling-block of the multitude: the brazen serpent, which the puritans detested; the lying oraeles (Urim and Tummim)]; the Levite [‘ark-tender’], who be came Israel's leprosy ; perhaps also circumci sion, the people’s greatest mistake, which for a time threatened to defeat its destiny. Except ing the ark, Egypt introduced into Israel only perturbing elements, which had to be eliminat ed, sometimes not without a crisis. If was not thus with the notions borrowed from Chaldea These were all fruitful, and, excepting perhaps the unpronounceable name [of the Divinity] have remained strong supports of religion, Be lieving mankind still lives on them, it owes t those old fables a prehistoric antiquity in which it delights, and a cosmogony of which it is proud. Israel's genius did not spring from Chaldea; but Chaldea furnished it the first ten pages of the book which has made its unparal leled success, ‘*Egypt, on the contrary, supplied it with few fruitful germs. And how many exquisite things it killed! The beautiful Jacobelite life is gone. Those noble types of [patriarchal] aris tocrats, proud, honorable, and religiously seri ous, have passed away. Authority rests no longer in the hands of the tribal chief The multitude has now a voice, and this voice will not at all bein favor of religious puritanism The Elohim-worship will appear dull On every occasion the people will longingly regret the vulgarities of Egypt, and, in order to satisfy it, it will be necessary to erect for it Apis figures with gilded horns.” ious develop
sg people
soon CRAWFORD'S STORY OF SUMTER Civil War: The By Samuel Wylie Crawford, A.M., M.D., Web The Genesis of the f Sumter, 1860-61, Brevet Major-General U.S. A., LL.D. Charles L. ster & Co, Story of SVO, pp. XXIV, 455. THE story of Sumter is doubtless an important chapter in the genesis of the civil war, but it is by no means the whole of it; and Gen. Craw ford’s method of telling the story, full of makes it Inte resting matter as it is, only more clearly evident how impossible it is to narrate the * full of the United States during the period imme diately preceding the war genesis” without writing the history Indeed, the cannot be understood exct pt by regarding it as Wal the culmination of antagonist forces operating from the establishment of the Federal Constitu tion ; and must, therefore, be considered as one of the closing chapters of a constitutional his tory conceived upon the philosophic plan whiel Von Holst has followed. But even when we try to limit the field of the ‘genesis * to the half year immediately follow
ing Mr. Lincoln’s election, as Gen. Cr 1 has done, we find that the progress of sentiment in every State of the Union, fr Maine to Texas, the action of political parties within those States, their legislation, the atti tude of the press, the views of leading : und many other things, help make up the The Nation. events which swept the nation onward t ts creat crisis, If we confine ir view to the ae tion of Congress and of the seceding States, the attitude and influence of the border slave States, nat Wash essential elements in and the conduct of the Administrati ington, we shall lack some he critical analvsis of the causes leading to th outbreak of the war, though we should still have (ren. (
narrower [ilhes SO Necessarl much as he has done v falls short an adequate grasp and presentation of the sul ject which is the principal title of his book. The secondary title—* The Story of Sumter “—much better indicates the scope of it, though we an readily understand that a broader title suggest ed itself by the accumulation of material that bore upon the general policy of the nationa Government and that of South Carolina l venesis ” of the book would seem to be this Inthe autumn of 1800 Gen. Cr: army, and the gwar harleston harbor in the assistant surgeon duty lical officer in Moultrie in ¢ as mer him to volunteer for military duty was not employed as surgeon, and he took active personal part in the transfer of the litt garrison to Fort ind in th 1 !
Maj he Confederate Anderson until it Army und North he of the latter fort by Was surrenderes Beauregard. On his return to the military duty sought pointed Brigadier-General of Volunteers \s brigade and division With honor in the close of the war His part in the histor 1 fence of Sumter led him to colleet materials all the events connected with it
including } printed books and pamphlets would furt but what could be proc spondence or conversation with prominent racters on both sides, and He had intimate intercourse with J papers
Black, who had been a: er of Buchanan's Cabinet, and valuable original documents w procured from him, as we is fr Judge H nother memibe tt sa Ca t. and private | ipers of Gov I kK s Sout i lina, of Mr. Seward {WG Anderson i ort t ‘S The story of Sumter has grow t a these se es, and is centrally t 1 ry hus tory of the forts i l il t Charles i bor, the efforts at reli yt i t luction by the Confederates, w t ; il hist ry *-¢ é ‘ tx =f Se \ ‘ with the fate t forts and the garris In iting the ite e has ‘ ‘ iuthor has a ica y—t i y.™ think—the express . wn judg I zt t : ae t ch t ' = ae : ™t = at = ‘ ¢ P s s , r s , cy s y S s t ~~ ' 7 = ¢ t . | sing kK if t ‘ s S i s t ta t = >> s by = = t \ ad A> péaSs ‘ F * ’ ‘ ~ ~ ? ~ t s ft ced wav " s Fes t s y States ~ ~~ \ ) ~ Vas war, but tha Army of the Potomae till the s\ ¢ { ul t \ W t ‘ ti that that Wi lel Ww eve Sa S sary i s) “ iNIs ~ t w sy Ww ‘
Page 22
18 this principle is settled, and his work will be the more respected even by those who fought against it, if he logically and clearly sticks to it in his analysis of events. There seem to have been five distinct periods of the controversy between November, 1860, and April, 1861, and as many varying attitudes of the national Administration. First, the period when avowed secessionists like Cobb and Thompson were potent influences in Bu- chanan’s Cabinet, and when the executive con- duct seemed to admit the full claim of South Carolina. Second, the period when the Presi- dent theoretically denied the right of secession, but denied also the power of the Government to oppose it. Third, the period when the Ad- ministration, under the influence of Black, Holt, Stanton, and Dix, asserted the right to hold and defend the forts and other public prop- led to flagrant war. Fourth, the opening period of Lincoln’s Administration, when Mr. Seward’s view pre- erty in the South, even if it vailed, that while the right to oppose secession by force was unquestionable, it was politic to bear even with the surrender of Sumter, if by so doing the border slave States might be kept in the Union and the seceding ones possibly induced Fifth, the period immediately before the surrender of the fort, when it was determined to take all the conse- quences of decisive efforts to send supplies and to reconsider their action. reinforcements to the garrison. The warlike acts of South Carolina were First was the placing of State troops in charge of the United States arsenal, nominally to protect it and the public property in it; but that this was a seizure was evident from the fact that the of- ficer in command of the forts was not allowed to take ordnance stores from the arsenal, even in the smallest quantity. Second was the seizure of Castle Pinckney by force, escalading the quite as numerous in their succession, barred gate and making prisoners of the officer Third was the Fourth was the seiz- Fifth was the erection of batteries on Cummings Point and Sullivan’s Island, and preparing all the forts for the attack on Sumter. Sixth, the firing on the Star of the West when she tried to carry in supplies and men to Sumter. Seventh, the bombardment of Sumter itself. It seems quite clear that Major Anderson regarded all these acts as hostilities, but thought himself restrained by his orders from replying to them with his cannon, unless he should ac- tually be attacked. His mental struggle seems to have been greatest when he saw the Star of the West fired upon and driven from the har- bor. His military impulse was to fire upon those who were firing upon the national flag, but dread of the responsibility for the first shedding of blood restrained him. The letters and papers quoted by Gen, Crawford seem to prove that at that time Anderson believed the dissolution of the Union was an accomplished fact, and was only anxious that events Which seemed inevitable might run their course Without actual conflict. His personal sympathies were with the South in the political contest, yet he was determined to do his duty as a soldier with scrupulous fidelity. and one or two men in charge. seizure of Fort Moultrie. ure of Fort Johnson. Hence arose a conflict in his own breast such as few men have’ undergone, and it is not strange that he solved his doubts in favor of avoiding bloodshed till he was actually attacked, and would have been glad to have been starved out instead of being reduced by the bombard- nent, It is curious, however, to see how far even the officers of the United States had gone in yield- ing to the assertions of the secessionists that a The Nation. shot from the Government forts would be the beginning of war, while all the military prepa- rations for the reduction of Su.uiter, and even the firing upon a Government ship, were to count as peaceful. As late as the 11th of April, the day before the bombardment opened, Com- mander Rowan of the Pawnee, off the harbor, refused to sail in for the bar, for the reason that it would be ‘‘ to begin civil war”; but when on the 12th he saw the flashes of the guns, he was eager to join the fray which the Confederate batteries had begun. It is the consideration of the confused state of mind in which were so many of the responsi- ble actors in the great drama, both civilians and military men, that makes us feel it to be the duty of the historian to clear up the muddle, and help his readers by an analysis of the events which shall leave as little doubt as possible re- garding the legal and military responsibilities of either side. The new matter which Gen. Crawford has collected is most of it very valu- able, and a little bolder application of the prin- ciples we have suggested would make the book wholly satisfactory as a presentation of the dramatic beginning of the great conflict. HOWELLS’S MODERN ITALIAN POETS. Modern Italian Poets : Essays and Versions by W. D. Howells. With portraits. Harper & Bros, 1887, Mr. HOWELLS’s agreeable book is taken ata little less than its worth by the critics, because they regard it asa study of rather trivial lite- rature, like those primary and secondary son- netteers of Bettinelli who are embalmed in Sydney Smith’s satire. But the book is really a chapter in the history of liberty, and the author was plainly led into this series of studies by the same generous impulse that led him—mistaken- ly, it may be—to petition for the life of the Chicago anarchists. The finest saying of Thomas Paine was his refusal to accept the motto Ubi libertas, ubi patria, on the ground that a brave man’s motto should rather be ‘*Where liberty is not, there is my country.” When these younger Italian poets wrote, liber- ty did not exist in Italy; their aim was to se- cure it, or at least some measure of it; and Mr. Howells’s first object is to give an intelligent comprehension of the work they did. We, however, find it necessary to defend his pur- pose not only against his critics, but against himself; for when he comes to writing his intro- duction he evidently distrusts his readers a lit- tle, and reverts, like so many heroes in his own novels, to an attitude of understatement and al- most of persiflage. When he complains that, after all, political satire is not best relished in free countries, he forgets that it is but a little more than a quarter of a century since the last of the ‘ Biglow Papers’ was written in our own; and he means, let us hope, a little more than he says, in adding, ‘‘I am not sure that literature is not as nobly employed in exciting men to he- roism and martyrdom for a great cause as in the purveyance of mere intellectual delights” (p. 10). If he had not really felt sure of this, he would never have given us these three hun- dred and seventy pages of minor Italian poets. Besides a little preliminary account of the ‘* Arcadian Shepherds,” Mr. Howells offers us sketches, longer or shorter, of eighteen authors, all of these being modern in the sense of dating back no further than the French Revolution. In this selection he again underrates the knowledge or the sympathy of his audience by assuming that even the best known of his poets is ‘‘ scarcely more than a name to most English readers” (p. 51). Of course the ma- jority of such readers do not read Italian, and [ Number 1175 if that is what is meant, no Italian poet is more than a name to these. Ina stricter sense also, itis true that ‘‘I Quattro Poeti,” though still issued in a joint volume, have long since prac- tically shrunk into two poets, Dante and Pe- trarch surviving Ariosto and Tasso. But poets may be more than names, even if we do not read their verses, and the picturesque and stormy life of Alfieri was so well recorded in his own autobiography, and was, moreover, so intermingled with the English and French ad- ventures of his time, that he is really a more distinct figure than Ariosto to most English- speaking readers. Mr. Howells has skilfully retold Alfieri’s story—the essay being that pre- fixed to his edition of the autobiography, as re- printed in 1877; but he has relied mainly on materials already familiar. Again, in the case of Manzoni, the novel of ‘I Promessi Sposi’ is still one of the common Italian text-books; Leo- pardi’s poems have just been translated, fully though somewhat prosaically, by Frederick Townsend, with a preface by O. B. Frothing- ham, in which Leopardi is rated quite as high- ly as by Mr. Howells; Silvio Pellico is still re- membered for his imprisonment and his naive uarrative; and Ugo Foscolo is almost counted as a naturalized Englishman in literature, a fact to which Mr. Howells searcely alludes. He tells us that Foscolo went to London and ‘*rained a livelihood by teaching the Italian language and lecturing on its literature” (p. 123); but he does not tell us that he was a favorite contributor to the London reviews, through the perfection of his English style: and that his essays on Dante and Petrarch, written in English, dedicated to Lady Dacre, and pub- lished in 1825, belong almost as essentially to English literature as do the sonnets of Ros- setti. Even these comparatively unforgotten poets, however, will doubtless take a new lease of tife through the friendly intervention of Mr. How- ells, and his treatment of the remainder will certainly shield them, for a time at least, from oblivion throughout the English-speaking world. But in considering the mode in which this is done, it is impossible not to perceive that Mr. Howells loses by the want of that possession in which Mr. J. A. Symonds, for instance, is so strong—a classical background for his modern study. In what Mr. Symonds writes we al- ways see modern Italy in its proper perspective as relieved and illustrated by the older Italy behind; for Mr. Howells it is simply a modern country without historic past. This makes an almost insuperable drawback to a satisfactory treatment of Alfieri, who, although avoiding the Greek and Roman classics in his youth, be- came more and more infused with their spirit as time went on. When, for instance, Mr. Howells analyzes the differences between Al- fieri and Shakspere, he treats them simply as a personal matter, and wholly ignores the sim- pler solution that the one was a classicist and the other was not. Alfieri’s handling of Orestes and of Fate, which was in reality a mere survi- val of the Greek habit of mind, is viewed by Mr. Howells (p. 95) as an individual whim, of which the whole key is lost. But if the modern period is to be treated as something absolutely disconnected from the earlier age, no one could do it more felicitously than Mr. Howells. He sometimes pats and plays with it a little too much, and turns upon you with the sort of familiarity which he dis- likes in Thackeray, as,‘*Is not this most charm- ingly done ?” (p. 44,—or even in a way that verges on the slangy and journalistic, as, ‘I do not begin to think this ‘s all true” (p. 69). Sometimes, also, he employs a foreign idiom, as when he says in a footnote, ‘‘ Question of ws a
Page 23
Jan. 5, 1888] Macchiavelli” (p. 119), meaning that the pas sage refers to that name. He has this sure merit, that he makes his book attractive; and his ventures into the field of translation have a peculiar charm. We have here the complaint to make, however, that he does not follow the usual course of Italian translators in giving the first words of the poem translated, for conve nience of identification; and it is vexatious to have to look through the two hundred and fifty sonnets of our quarto Alfieri of 1800, merely to ascertain that those rendered are the 107th (Quel tetro bronzo) and the 167th (Sublime specchio). When found, the poem proves itself musically and faithfully translated, with such Howells-like felicities of phrase as ‘* A proper nose” for Giusto naso ; but it smacks of indo lence when so skilful a master of words can hit upon no better rhymes than ‘ mild” and ** em broiled ” (p. 101); and still more when we find him utterly disregarding that limited sequence of rhymes on which the Italian poets so pride themselves. The translator is right in giving us the alternate rhymes which Alfieri, unlike Petrarch, admitted; but whereas in each of these two sonnets the original has but four dis- tinct terminations for the fourteen lines, the translator allows himself seven, and winds up, worst of all, by the Shaksperian closing couplet, which is alien to Italian verse. Mr. Howells has thus indulged himself in a far easier task than the occasion required, and one far lighter than other modern translators of son nets exact of themselves. Weregret tosay that the same self-indulgence or negligence fur ther shows itself in many lines so careless as to be almost doggerel, such as, from Fusinato (p. 365): * And now be shivered upon the stone here Till thou be free again, O lyre Ll bear.”’ This is the more to be regretted because he is capable, under sufficient effort, of very grace ful and sweet translation, as in the cradle song called “Nanna” (p, 361), though even this is disfigured by such careless rhymes as ‘love me” with ‘ love thee,” ‘‘come” with ‘* doom,” and *‘ abroad” with ‘* God.” We have been thus frankly critical with Mr. Howells because he is justly called upon, as one of our acknowledged masters, to do his work thoroughly and keep to a high standard. His book, as a whole, is a most agreeable one; the publisher’s part is well done; the portraits, though unattractive, are probably not more so than the Italian originals; the binding is pe liarly appropriate, and there is no serious de fect except the want of an index, Winter. From the Journal of Henry D. Th reau. Edited by H. G. O. Blake. Boston Houghton, Mifflin & Co. 15ss. THOREAU himself questions whether any life is rich enough to be journalized; but his editor's method, of making the whole life cover only a single natural year by selection and rearrang ment, probably never occurred to him as a so lution of the difficulties of triviality and mono- tony that make the days tedious. In the case of a growing mind such a method would hardly be applicable. Thoreau did not change muc! either in himself or in his surroundings, and perhaps the type of his character is better dé fined by this composite-photography device of laying day upon day in the record. In this last instalment, which ends the series, he preserves his three-fold interest as an observer of natur a man with a theory of plain living, and a writer whose mind was visited by sti thoughts. In all of these aspects he is st noticeable figure in our literaturs The season of winter is one which he was es
The Nation. pecially fitted to report. He could not keep in that religion ex doors, and by the help of skates and snow-shoes | that it did not ex he travelled far. The New England winter fort rounds too, Is a season of marvellous sky-color and verv resp. snow reflection, and for color Thoreau had a | sew that t sensitive and appreciative eye. Some of scenes he gives to us are of great beauty merely i ble m for their graduated tones and hues. Of bird ‘os and plant and animal life there is little, but | Prof. Bow: the lack is abundantly made up for by these | ess iwit broad prospects, which were his principal plea sure until the sound of running water undet the snow and ice made his pulses warm wit! the thought of the coming spring. But, rich | he may atta t as the record is, it is not one which the reviewet and ov ‘ can report. vertnot Vtot Of Thoreau’s theory of life enough has been | ist vuthor’s Written in the time when it was a novel thu been w not in itself, but in the practical illustration he letiance wl gave toit. In these entries one sees how yvenu tift tion of ft inely he held it, and both what it did and what ive treat t w it failed to do for him The principal value of | f it was that it left him time to meditate, not s assurat \ much to think as to be a passive instrument “ ] that mood when thoughts occur to the 1 Many of these are treasured in the journa me | t t t \ wonders whether it was not to him what the | note-book was to Emerson, a receptacle te which he had recourse in writing his books f Their literary form is clear and hard, and of ten they have the indetinable quality of fe ties. It is singular to observe once more t { wide interval between the poetry of his prose and the prose of his poetry. He had the tou tha of the poet now and then, but in his verse his | Cal: muse was disenchanted, the fairies’ gift chan ing at once into sticks and stones in = his s hands. He had some of the methods and the | ld w Waiting spirit of the poet; but the messag l came without music. He writes: * To pleas st our friends and relatives we turn our silver into cart-loads, while we neglect to work our | G
mines of gold, known only to ourselves, fat in the Sierras where we pulled up a bush in ou ft mountain walk and saw the glittering t sur his is a t imag It isa] . t uncy When he speaks of the ice that ervst s \ al tl . the ground as ‘*t f t I the eart! ts beard s ts infrequent lr} ire striking sente S s \ friend i hist« i 5 Ke S t Ss i i I 1 t xt {I ‘ u i ibout tl \y ittra Stl \ HH is ‘ ft nothing sald, but has a 1a Ww . t lips of it Su Xamples 1 1 us ag Thoreau’s t terary facultv, the pow t perfect speec! Sos is We begin t st the st. begins is an apotheg f his own lif On id kee; t : but it is suff nt to be r na + tw | < . such a literary gift is p1 Las isshow so | rnals, together with st i ‘ . sis \ wn thoughts, s ~ if Fr | t . n natural beauty a su t st t | sa 1 : } [ reatior i reau t . sad | i | ist rit sf + + 4 1 4 ¢ \\V =} vas + + + i =) . } } S ‘ ' just I i i} i erest fo | Presumably this is s = | } ks. and putting ¢ © s | < } e sur t t . . = WwW it i g f New 2 | t x lan | ar } i s s P . ? Harper & SS 1 : < t } S Ste < . . ' i ‘ ‘ - t tha a $ xiste G and in , . P 9 a , of a sa f is as before. Whenit wast ght ' ism and athei
Page 24
20 which is as positive and as dogmatic a creed as either of the others. And there is the fourth, of letting the question entirely alone. But what are you going to do with this ominous silence? You cannot argue with it, for it is irrational to pick a quarrel with a man who is peaceable and says nothing. It remains, then, as a system which adapts itself to known facts, and has neither belief, knowable. logic is not the Nemesis of Faith. nor disbelief even, about an un- Hence there is one case in which The Standard Cantatas: Their Stories, their Music, and their Composers. By George P. Upton. Chicago: A, C. McClurg. Pp. 367. ISR, Mr. Upton has added another ful musical handbooks. It is arranged on the same plan as his ‘Standard Operas’ and ‘ Stan- dard Oratorios,’ the first named of which is al- ready in its fourth thousand. In the historic introduction he calls attention to the different senses in which the word cantata is used. He himself uses it in the widest sense, and includes to his very use- in it such works as Berlioz’s ‘‘ Faust” and ‘‘ Ro- meo and Juliet.” In the case of the classical composers, Who were very prolific in this kind of composition, only a selection could, of course, be made, and of Bach’s 480 cantatas, for instance, only the four which are most fre- quently performed are analyzed. Besides de- scribing the plot of the texts, Mr. Upton always calls attention to the best musical numbers, avoiding technical terms as much as possible. A large number of cantatas by American com- posers are included in the list. We hope that Mr. Upton will not rest on his laurels, but will prepare another handbook that would prove very useful. Every observer of concert-hall audiences must have noted that many pay much closer attention to a piece if they know something regarding its origin and the pictorial idea that may have been in the Nor is this curiosity at all to be condemned; for the composer’s mind when he conceived it. mind’s eye being given some scene to fix upon, we are enabled the more easily to forget the artificial surroundings in a concert hall. More- over, people like to talk about the pieces they have heard, and it is much easier to talk about the biography of a composition than about the music itself. Now, if Mr. Upton would select a few hundred of the symphonies, overtures, ete., ete., that are most frequently played, and ex- plain their meaning, pictorial or biographic, ** Every child in America should have them.” England Journal of Education. ** The * Young Folks’ Cyclopedia’ should be in every — library.”"—From a Report of the Connecticut soard of Education. —New YOUNG FOLKS’ ( Common Things...$2.50. of CYCLOPEDIA Persons and Places. $2.50 HENRY HOLT & CO., Publishers, New York. i841. S. DAVIS, JR.’S 1841. Diamond Hams. CINCINNATI. ACKER, MERRALL & CONDIT and PARK & TILFORD, New York. Germany. PROF. A. FLEISCHMANN, Eldena, Pommern. Tho rough study of German, French, and other branches. Summer resort for seabathing. Fine surroundings. Isle of Riigen, University of Greifswald. For circulars address PROF. J. M. CROW, Ph.D., Grinnell, Iowa. JARGAINS IN BOOKS, AUTO- graphs, ete. Cat: mosee s free, LORRAINE BooK 6» 41 W, 31st St., New York | Hall, S.c — The Nation. ! with some eesthetic remarks on form and feel- | | ing, he would do a service to all concert-goers. And concert-givers would find it an advantage to get the author's permission to reprint on their programmes such of his notices as might be desirable. Half-Hours with American History. By Charles Morris, author of ‘ Half-Hours with the Best American Authors.’ Vol. I. Colo- nial America. Vol. Il. Independent America. Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott Co. 1887. Mr. Morris aims to present the story of the nation by selections from the works of leading historians upon the most important topics. These selections are chronologically arranged, divided into periods, and connected by brief outlines of intermediate events supplied by the author. History does not so readily lend itself to this mode of treatment as do other branches of literature, and we miss especially the con- tinuity and unity so important to the complete presentation of a subject, and which cannot be supplied by connecting notes. On the other hand, there is value in the emphasis given by the method to events of particular importance, and in the variety of treatment. Taken in connection with some standard history, the work will also do good service by interesting its readers in the authors represented in the se- lections. The difficult task of culling has been executed with much skill by Mr. Morris. One is glad to find that while liberal, but not ex- cessive, use is made of such writers as Bancroft and Parkman, local historians have not been neglected. While we must wish that more fre- quent use had been made of contemporary writers, yet the selections, on the whole, seem judiciously chosen for the purpose in view. The notes, which are simply condensed statements of fact, are in general correct: but the author is not entirely free from errors, as in the slip which makes him say that Alexander Hamilton was one of the defenders of popular rights at | the time of the negro plot in New York. The reference is to Andrew Hamilton. BOOKS OF THE WEEK Gérard de Nerval. Syivie. Recollections of Valots. George Routledge & Sons. % Goodwin, Mrs. H. B. Our P. arty of Four: Travel. Boston: Cupples & Hurd. &t. Guiney, Louise Imogen: The W hite Sail. Ticknor & Co. Hale, E. a The Life of George W aj. gton Studied Anew. . P. Putnam’s Sons. 1.7 The Book of British Balli ads. Illustrated. G, P. Putnam’sSons. $1.50. A Story of Boston: G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS, Importers of OLD AND RARE SECOND-HAND ENGLISH BOOKS. Often very destrable sets of Standard English good second-hand condition, at bargain prices. Correspondence solicited, Send for New Catalogue (No. tssued. Authors may be obtained in 5) Just New York, 27 & 29 W. 23d St. London, 27 King William St., Strand. [ Number 1175 Harrisse, H. lino et ses Memorie. F, W. Christern. Harrisse, H. Le Quatriéme Centenaire de la Découverte du Nouveau Monde. Genoa: Donath; New York: F. W. Christera. Henry Ward Beecher: mouth Church. Huebsch, 8. Volapiik: A Guide for Learning the Unt- versal Language. New York. Hutton, R. H. Essays on Some of th » Modern Guides of a 2 Thought in Matters of iaith. Macmillan & oO Heron-Alle “4 E. The Suicide of Sylvester Gray. Bel- ford, Clarke & Co. Hornaday, W. T. Free Rum on the Congo, and What it is Doing There. Chicago: Woman’s Temperance Pub lication Association. Howells, W. D. April Hopes. Harper & Brothers. Jastrow, M. A Dictionary of the Targumim, the Tal- mud Babli and Yerushalmi, and the Midrashic Litera- ture. PartIIl. G,. P. Putnam’s Sons. ¥2 Jubilee and Plantation Songs, Sung by Hampton Stu- dents, Jubilee Singers, and others. Boston; Oliver Ditson & Co, = ge May. oe, f. An Inquiry into Socialism. Green & Co. $1.50 Larcom, Luc 2 2 The Cross and the Grail. Chicago: Woman’s Te mperance Publication Association. Lawless, Hon. Emily. The Story of Ireland. G. P. Putnam’s Sons. $1.50. Life’s Problems, Here and Hereafter: An Autobiogra yhy. Boston: C u »yples & Hurd. 81.25. Lillie, Lucy C. he Colonel’s Money. Brothers. Lockyer, Prof. J. N. The Outlines of the Earth. Mac millan & Co. 60 cents. Madan, F. Rough List of Manuscript Materials Relat- ing to the History of Oxford. Arranged with an In dex. Oxford: ‘Clarendon Press; New York: Mac millan Co, Mahaffy, J. P. of Alex che to the Roman Conquest. Co. $3.50. mepeey. 3. P. The P rinciples of the Art of Conversa tion. P. Putnam’s Sons, 75 cents. Mahaly Saw ver; or, Putting Yourse If in her Place. Boston: C upple s& Hurd. 31.2 Martin, Frances. Elizabeth Gilbe rt and her Work for the Blind. Macmillan & Co. $1.75. May, C Moly: A Book of Poems. G. P. Putnar’s Sons. $1.25. McNamara, Mrs. Miles. Belford, Clarke & Co. Molesworth, Mrs. Little Miss Peggy: Only a Nursery Story. Illustrated. Macmillan & Co. $1.2 Morgan, Mary. Poems. Montreal: J. Theodore Robin son. Muir—Carnegie. Practical Chemistry: A Course of Laboratory Work. Macmillan & Co. 80 cents. Murray, Prof. J. Elocution for Advanced Pupils. G. P. Putnam's none. ne Neubauer, A. Medizval Jewish Chronicles. [Anec reap ol on oda } Oxford: Clarendon Press; New York: Macmillan, Nicholas, G. A. The Biddy Club: and How its Members Grappled with the Troublesome Servant Question. Chicago: A.C. MeClurg & Co. $1.24 Noel, Lady Augusta. Hithersea Mere. Co. E. O’Donnell, Jessie F. Sons. $1.25. Ohorn, L. M. The Angel of the Village. ples & Hurd. 31.2 Palgrave, W. G._ [ Many Lands. Pattison - Slater. & Co. 3 Personal Re me ‘mbrances of Sir Frederick Pollock. In 2vols. Macmillan & Co. $5. Plummer, C. Elizabethan Oxford. Clarendon Press. Pomeroy, J. N. A Treatise on the Law of Riparian Rights, as ie is Formulated and Applied in the Pacitte States. Paul: West Publishing Co, Purdy, T. i. Peed of the Susquehanna, and Other Poems. Illustrated. Philadelphia; J. B. Lippin ecott Co. $1. Randolph, H. F. _ Fifty Years of English Song. Selec tions from the Poets of the Reign of Victoria. In 4 vols. A.D. F. Randolph & Co. * Wood, H. Natural Law in the Business World. Boston: Lee & Shepard. 30 cents. Wood, J.J. A Child of Genius: A Sketch. C. T. Dil lingham. 30 cents. Christophe Colomb et Savone. Verzel Genoa: A, Donath; New York: A Memorial. Brooklyn: Ply- Dreams to Sell. Longmans, Green & Longmans, Harper & Greek Life and Thought from the Age Macmillan & Prince Coastwind’s Victory. Macmillan & Heart Lyrics. G. P. Putnam’s Boston: Cup F ysses; or, Scenes and Studies in Maemillan & Co. $3.50. Elementary Chemistry. Macmillan DAVID G. FRANCIS, 17 ASTOR PLACE, NEW YORK. DEALER IN VALUABLE OLD ann NEW BOOTLS. Priced Catalogues issued from time to time, sent gratis to any address. NOW READY, And mailed to any address, CATALOGUE NO. £8 Of odds and ends from Various Libraries for sale by HENRY MILLER, 30OKSELLER AND IMPORTER, 79 Nassau Street, New York, between John and Ful ton Streets. ITERARY AGENCY.—/. P. McAuley, 214 E. 50th St., will search libraries, offer MS. to publishers, and do ‘other like work for out-of-town saemens and writers. 7 W. 14SH, ry N ASS: 4U hy GARE 1 en ae e has just issued a new catalogue of books, among which will be found works on America, Local History, ete. Senton - EN 'D go CEN TS ~ ST. 4MP S. English or German, *‘ Daily "Vords”’ fer the Moravian Church. FOR 1888 of THE Book ANTIQUARY, Easton, Pa,