The Nation 1887-08-11: Vol 45 Iss 1154
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
The Nation VOL. XLV.—NO. 1154. Schools. Alphabetized, first, by states; second, by Towns. CALIFORNIA, San Rafael! y ISS & L. #ORISON BOARDING / and Day School for Girls. &600 per year. Cireu lars on application Fall term Commences Sept. 5. CONNECTICUT, Lyme. LACK HALL SCHOOL.—A FAMILY and Preparatory School for boys. Thorough in- struction and careful training New and enlarged ac commodations. CHARLE® G BARTLETT, Prip-ipal CONNECTICUT, Lyme. ; — ‘i GRISWOLD SCHOOL REOPENS Oct. 3d. A delbghtful, beaithful home for young girls of all ages. Studies include ail branches. ONNE TICUi, Middletown. JILSON GRAMMAR SCHOOL —A / Freparatory School for Boys #500 per vear, For Circular address KR. H. Wivson, A.M. CoNnNECtICUT, New Haven. H ° PKINS GRAMMAR SCHOOL (founded in 1660). One of the oldest Classical Schools in U. S. ¥repares for colleges and Scientific School. Has prepared more boys for Yale than any other school. For catalogue addre EO. L. FOX, Rector. CONNECTICUT, New Haven, 33 Wall St. ] I-S BaRTLETT S (formerly Mi f Nott’s) Home and Day School for Young Ladies n application
will reopen Sept. 21. Circalars sent « ~ Connecticur, Pomfret. THE MISES VINTON’S SCHOOL FOR Girls willreopen Thursday » Se] t.290. Number timit ed to ten pupils. For es ular, address the Misses VINTON DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA, Wa hington, i212 and 12:4 14th St., and 1407 Massachusetts Ave. WE NORWOOD INSTITUTE, — A 4 Select Boarding and Day Schoo! for young ladies and little girls. . Mr. and Mrs. Wm. D. CABELL, Principals. TL. Nots, Chicago. 7, : (7 VION COLLEGE OF LAll FAL] term begins Sept. 21. For circulars address H BooTtn. In.inots, Lake Forest. | dam FOREST ACADFM ~ boys toenter any american Yollege English and Business Course for boys wh« to attend college. Next te pos opens Sept l4 Ad President W. C. ROBERTs or Principal G. &. CUTTING
MAINE, Augusta “2. CATHARINE 'S HALL. D an » Sehool for Girls. The Rt. Kev. H. A. Neeley, D.D President; the Rev. W.D Martin, AM, Principal. 20t year opens Sept. 14. Terms, 5 and $250. Strong cores of teachers. Special advantages in Art ‘and Music. Send for circular.
TARYLAND, Baltimy wre, 12 2 West Franklin St. DCE WORTH BOARD!NG AND DAY « School for Girls —Mrs. H. P LEFERVRE. Principal This School will reopen on THURSDAY. the 22d of SEI TEMBER. The course of instruction embraces all the studies ir cluded in a thorough English Education, and the French and German languages wre practically taught.
MARYLAND, Baltimore. U TNIVERSITY OF MARYLAND.—Lat School Eighteenth annual session, October 3, vai dress HENRY D. HARLAN. Sec'y MARYLAND, Cambridge. ( YUAMBRIDGE FEMALE SEMINARY. A healthy, refined home. Every branch of useful study conscientiously taught. Languages, Music, art Regular cuurse $200 per y« 4 For catalogue address J. F. Bat GHER, A M, Principal ~ MARYLAND, ‘atonsviltle. SH, FRENCH,
ay TIMOTHY SENGLI » and German school for voung lads reopens Sey tember 21, 1887 Address Misses M. C. & 8S. R. CaRTER. . ARYLAND, Ellicott City VJALPIN'S UNIVERSITY SCHOOL { Sixth Session opens 15th September. For Cata logues, address (« HAPMAN MAUPIN, M.A., Princ pal MASSACHUSETT: , Andover. BBOT ACADEM} YOUNG LA ‘ dies. The 59th 77 ~ hey ns on ya. ay, Sept. Stl For circulars apply to F. Draper For admission t Miss PHILENA Mt KeF¥N, Prin., Andover, Mass MASSACHUSETTS, Belmont, Waverly Station. | ISS L. A HILUS SELECT HOM 4 school. Fifteenth vear. Superior advantages t r those who wish to make up lost time Pupils also pre sared for colleges. Location delightful; grounds beauti ul, ample, and well laid out for summer and winter out door exercises, including horseback riding. Send for circular. THU! Massi RSDAY, AUGUST 11, 1887. PRICK ENTS joston. Massa
F HUSETTS
BY OS T% UN "ERSITY Law School pre d My . gt MM Dean, : ties I . tT Epwunp H. Bensett, LI
MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 23L W. Chester Park ‘ie VCH HOME” FOR YOUN ASSACHUSE ‘ lady students Lith ye ar. Frenen spoken exclu Vee sively and taug1t thoroughly Admits «ix Wenty frst ve « For circulars address Mak. THOMAS iss MASSACHU2ETTS, Boston, 69 Chester Square Massach r . ’ ( “AVAETT INS TiLUTE FOR YOUNG / d / ‘ { i 7 Ladies, Boston. Mass Family and Day School The “ tory boarding s s Thirty fourth \ ear begins Wed , Sept. 28, ISS For ca gir prter ‘ Ss talogue and ctreular apply to Rev. Gro, GANNETT, A.M For al thie MASSACHUSETTS, Boston ee ees Massa errs, S W . ‘ NS SOU Ta VO # TECHNOLOG Y. a } A "« Courses in Civil, Mechanical, Mining, and Flectrical ( ne } ’ ; : haratory S , : Kngineering, Chemistry, Architecture, et JAMES } Tv . MUNROE, dec’y. FRANCIS A. WALKER, tres : “wh : Ma . MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 259 Boyisto n Street \ t ‘ yr , y y , , ‘ . HAUNCY HALL SCHOOL | h Year Pees Preparation for the Wass tanaioute of Te hnol paratory ANS ‘ 4 is a specialty Reference is made to the institute Fac + r : + ’ ty he location is the most attractive in Boston. Howa . tary Massa HUSETTS, Boston, 25 Chestnut St Massa \ \ A / SS HELUISE BE. HERSEY WLI Z ’ \ open a new schoo! for giris in October spectal as ‘ .
|e ag fit for colle with best « tion, with %ne ternte «ourt ve @
at tention given to tbe English language and literatud® Sept 2 NS A fa 5 \ ’ Mass ACHUSETTS, Boston, No. 1 Huntington Ave d ‘Eng ts 1 “Home Sch ol for six gris willopen Sey ( ) tember 21, 1s: ‘rice, $1,0*4) per vVear. No extras Highest references given al i required \ aN 4 MASSA‘ HUsSETTs, Boston, Franklin Squar . d of Musi THI nd SEST FQUI \r ‘ > ‘ 8 ’ in the WORLD 100 2.186 Students las mick « year ets Thorough Instruction in Vocal and Instrur al Must Piano at rgan Funing Arts, ra , “A” t — French,German, and [talian Languages, Engi. *’S eee For Iliustsated Calendar, with ful’ informati a ‘ “sat ress E 1 YEE ¢ ' ‘ . MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, I Place * oa A , sa meer can ee recy A? Z : ; > . WEPARA TION y Lived with, & -_ tute Fechnolog nat } t+} a ' > 4 ‘ ) tute of hnology and ollege w ary ‘ 4 6 out Greek. Private School 1 Har r : 4 ~ 7 MASSACHUSED s, Bradford : 1k / E 7 A A » af 4 ] FY XR y } ‘ Nt A“AA rerers Home and day pupils s nd safe & er d 4% > year. Next term begins september 7, LSS For circu ‘ anes lars address I. N. ¢ LETON A.M tions Ser 4 rves ad es, 8 MASSACHUSET ES, Braintree . on & . FIT I rHAVE : ee - : 6GR A s rN fii ffi LA 1 id wi? 3 4 ~S VIN MANA ‘ P hevins Inesta ¢ wher 1&7 ¥ pour xi Wednesda September 14, 1 New Ham J BSewa South Bratntr Nass 1/ \S ’ ine t s “ey HUSEI Ts, Brook Ypres. 8 7 Wr busca . . y f 7 . er ike OF a a b 1A \ 7. mace f 1s ‘ hool for girls. Fail term begins Oct Enxla li ETTs, Cambridge = New J&RSFY awre 1TION HARWAR > [Ait . ] « \ private tui — ‘ at any a iret 4 ted for entr Fresh rs ions s ma r 2 f t Trance + at R r t . EF 4 Hi AM Ma hen ar S ar is Ss 4 y 2 ait ar. a °s JOHN W. DALZELL. A seston aint htabory 0 Y j MASSACHUSEITs, Lamoridge, Laren St New JERS M Pr > > map . mp Dp . ry FOR BOYS.—DR. ABBOT AD not more than four bovs into his famtly ce or educate privately. Separate tuitt of care in all respecta
.. , ° = — en Ste
ivu Lake | FUR YOUNG LA urse. Music and Art 1SN¢ £106 FUR Ser talogue atth on Wellewes EF. S. FRISREE, D.D , Pres't advantage = New Y iarden City, Long Island lessons at rrerss . r . ° lar please HE ¢ TH RAL SCHOOL OF S, menslinen’ School for boys. Fits f r Harvard
“4; Tee wh 4 Point tumbia, Yale, Trinity ete. Sixteen he accon — oma rer wre 7 a modations unsurpassed ; 17 miles from N.Y City .\ PREPARATORY) CHAS, STURTEVANT Moore, 4.B hool for boys. +t naration for , Harvard). Head Master
wy LAD ratories ck B. Knapp, 8. B.(M.LT
See also foliowing pages | al a OS
Page 2
Wation. [ Number 1154 1 i The N ation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science, and Art. FOUNDED 1865. CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. IEE WEE ss ohn dedscdnnesebensnessd0deeessdsencceseecasbed 103 SUMMARY OF THE WEEK'S NEWS..........00eceeeseeeeeee 106 EDITORIAL ARTICLES: Secretary Fairchild’s Circular see 208 Immigration Again , ‘ nek icewenpuien 108 The Race Issue in G eorgia.. (cb babdiehl ereunaee 109 SPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE; Sorel’s Montesquieu..... peuscales tear - ss 109 CORRESPONDENCE: The Art of House Furnishing bx ow 243 Sympathy with Crime ine aGne enh ae ssiuee Wandanowen 111 Divining-Rod Logic.......... lil OTE. cccccsscnsicssesccs orecenesse eveseccoceces enececees 111 REVIEWS: Colvin’s Keats.......... Rr ere ees. | The Confederate States Nav y eichawhennaweem . 115 Recent Psychical Research. . 116 RKeber's Medizeval Art. . 118 re Re ON III 5 cin c'gg'g bcs no boop ob oe seeps Sam . 119 Scotland as It Was: and as ItIs.. - 119 Philadelphia, 1681 18 ee P . 120 Annals of Augusta (¢ and SOR Virginia. . 121 Letters of Horatio Greenough to his Brother Hen. Ns cnvvsev ea cases eset esesien ; 22 Poetry and P hilosophy WENIOOURG. sccvacece avesessas 122 ccosccecccces 122 BOOKS OF THE WEER...cccccccccceccocococes TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three Dollars per year, in advance, postpaid to any part of the United States or Canada; to foreign coun- tries comprised in Postal Union, Four Dollars, The date when the subscription expires is on the Ad- dress-Label of each paper, the change uf which to a sub- sequent date becomes a receipt for remittance. No other receipt is sent unless requested, The paper is stopped at expiration of the subscription, unless previously renewed, Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter or by check, exyvress order, or postal order, payable to * Publisher of the NATION.” When a change of address is desired, both the old and new addresses should be given. Address THE NATION, Box 704, New York. Publication Office, 208 Broadway. TERMS OF ADVERTISING. yoo {No deviation. } | lines, On any page not specified, 15 cents per line,— each insertion; with choice of page, 20 cents ire A column (140 lines), $20 each insertion; with — choice of page, #27. ae A page (3 columns), $60 each insertion; with|— choice of position, $80. [- Twenty per cent. advance for top of column or) _ a other preferred position, when specified ; where|— positions are not spectfied, advertisements are|~ classified as far as poasible and arranged in or-|_ der of size, the largest at the top. |= 15 Twenty per cent, advance fer cuts, fancy or _ other letters not comprised in THE NATION|— fonts, and all other special typography (subject to ap- proval), Cuts are inserted only on inside pages of cover or fly-leaves, not on outside of cover, bered for binding. Marriage and Death Notices, 50 cents each, DISCOUNT on yearly accounts amounting to $250, 10 per cent.; $500, 15 per cent.; $750, 20 per cent.; $1,000, 25 percent, Credits are made De« Ona yearly acccunt amounting to 52 pages the discount is one- third. Advertisements must be acceptable in every respect, Copy received until Tuesday, 5 P M. THE NATION is sent free to those who advertise in it, as long as advertisement continues. The EDITION of THE NATION this week is 8,700 copies, The Subscription List is always open to inspec- tion, nor On pages num- ‘ember 31, * «* Copies of THE N VATION may be procured in Paris of J. G. Fotheringham, 8 Rue des Capu- cines; and in London of B. F. Stevens, 4 Trafal- gar Square; George Street, 30 Cornhill, E. C.; and H. F, G@illg & Co,, 449 Strand. School: 4 Continued from first page. NEW York, New Brighton, Staten Island. S T. AUSTIN'S SCHUOL, (lncorporated.) A Church schoolof the highest class for boys. Nine resident masters, from Brown, Lon- Cambridge, Durham, Edinburgh, and Dub- *v. ALFRED G. MORTIMER, B dD. Rector. Te rms #500. don, Oxford, lin. Apply to Re NEW York City, Room 72, Bible House. MERICAN KINDERGARTEN NOR- mal School Reopens, 25th year, Sept. 14. Special advantages and low terms at East Orange Home and in New York. Time and expense according to ability of pupil. Summer session every year. EMILY M. Cok, Prin. and Ed. of Amer. Kindergarten Mag. NEw York C1: Y, 103 East 61st St. A ADAME GIOVANNINI’?S YOUNG Ladies’ Select Family school of Music, Lan- guages, Literature, Elocution, and Painting, combined with all the appointments of a refined home. Highest testimonials. ferms mode rate. Send for c ireular. pat NEW YORK CITy, 32 and 34 Fast 57th St | JISS PEEBLES AND MISS THOMP.: son’s School will reopen Monday, October 3. _— September 1 address all communications care re) J KENNEDY Top & Co., Bankers, 63 Wiiliam Street, New v Yo ork. _ NEW “YorK C ITY, "Nos. 6 sand 8 Fast 3d St. Ves SYLVANUS REED'S BOARD ing and Pay School for Young Ladies. s.—The same able s’aff of Professors and Teachers 1s retained, with im portant additions. 24th year begins Oct. 4. NEW York Cry, 20 East 127th Street. dene: HARLEM COLLEGIATE SCHQGOL for Boys will open its fourth year Sept-mber 21, Number ore te 30 stu- Six boarding pupils admitted. JE ANRENAUD. dents, NEW York, Peekskil M JILITARY AC. IDE MY.—COL. CHAS. J. Wrigut, BS., Dr. JonN N. TILDEN, Principals. New York, Poughkeepsie. : Ir ‘ERVIEW ACADEMY. 52d Vear. Prepares thoroughly for College, the Government Ac * mies, and Business. Military Drill BISBEE & AMEN, Principals. ~ NEw York, Rochester 2 ORT HILL st “HOOL (FOR BOYS) removed from Canandaigua to Rochester, N. Y. For circulars address REV JAMES HATTRICK LEE, ¢ ‘anandaigua, N. Ye Roslyn. Long Island. : BE YVANI SCHOOL —A MILITARY academy of the highest grade, with primary, inter- mediate, and academic de ‘partments. One of the tinest sc hool properties tn the US, in proximity to country- ceatef the late William Cullen Bryant. Fall term opens Sept. 15. NEW YORK, C ORTELYOU & HINDs. - Pri rincipals. ~NEW Y ORK, Suspe nsion Bridge. ] yz VEAUX CULLEGE.—A Military Boarding Se a for Boys. WILFRED H. Munro, A.M., - President. ~NEW “YORK, svracuse. ies A RS. CHARLOTTE MAY WILKIN. son’s Home School for Girls.—#1,000 per year. No extras Only ten pupils. Beautiful and healthful situation on the hills above Syracuse. School year be- gins sept. 14, 1887 Kefers to Hon. Ahram S. Hewitt, George Wm. Curtis, Kev. Henry Ward Beecher, Thomas Wentworth Higginsou, Hen. Andrew D White, Louisa May Alcott, James B. Angell, LL.D., Hon. George V. N. Lothrop Seg York, “Uties Vk Fag Oe Be s SCHOOL FOR YOUNG caine, The next school year begins Wednesday, 21st, 1887. Appite: ations should be made early. NorTH C ‘AROLINA, Asheville SHEVILLE MIL: TARY ACADEMY, Fg S. © VENABLE‘ Principal.W. PINCKNEY MASON, Asso. Principal ard Comdt. For information and catalogue adaress P rine ipal or Asso Prine ipal ONTO, Cineninati, Walnut Hills. APs NOURSE WILL REOPEN HER English and French family and day school Sept. ‘i 1887. Pupiis may take special work or the full course of ‘study fitting for co lege e xaminations. / a Sept. ‘ PENNSYLVANIA, Bryn Mawr. IR VN MAWRCOLIEGE.—A COLLEGE for Womer, ten miles from Philadelphia. Offers rraduate and undergraduate courses in Sanskrit, Greek, Latin, Mathematics, English, French, Old French Italian, Spanish, German, including Gothic and Old High Ger- man, History, Policical Science, Physics, Chemistry, Bi- ology, ine luding Koti uny, and lectvres on p hilosophy. Gyninasium, with Dr, Sargent’s apparatus complete. Fellowships (value $400) in Greek, English, Mathematics, History, and Biology For Program, address as above. PENNSYLVANIA, Chester. WENNSVYLVAN/IA MILITARY ACA- demy.—2oth year opens Wed., Sept. 14. A military college with four graduate courses; CL1VIL ENGINEER- IVG, CHEMISTRY, ARCHITECTURE. and ARTS. Degrees conferred in each, respectively, C.E., Ph.B., B.Ar., and A.B. Preparatery Courses. Instruction in all Depart- ments by able Professors. Thorough work in Laborato- ries, Drafting-Room, and Field. Military System second only to that of West Point. CoL. THEODORE Hyatt, Pres, PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, 4112 Spruce St. ] A TSS GORKDON'S ENGLISH AND P French Boarding and Day School for Young La. dies. Superior musical advantag Pupils prepared far College. Miss = F. Gi anon, Principal Mrs. W. B. Hype, Associate Principal PENNSYLVANIA, Ogontz, : GONT7Z SCHOOL for YOUNG LADIES removed in 1883 from Chestnut 7. Philadelphia. to Ogontz, the svacious country seat of Jay Cooke, wili be gin its thirty eighth year Wednesday, Sept. 28th. For circulars apply to PRINCIPALS, Ogontz, Montgomery Coun ty, Pa. Principals. MIss FRANCES E_ BENNETT, Miss SYLVIA J. EASTMAN. Emeritus Principals, Miss M. L. BONNEY, Miss H. A. DILLAYE. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, Chestnut Hill. : }| RS. COMEGYs AND MISS BELL'S a Engiish, French, and German Boarding School for Young Ladies reopens Sept. 28. Students preparea for Coliege. Ample grounds afford advantages for outdoor exercise. Additional class and recreation-rooms built during the past year. PENNSY L v Phitade Iphia, Germantown. AND Vy gee N LANE SCHOOL Ww lls vy Preparatory (formerly Mme. Cle- ment’s) Poarding and Day School for young ladies. 3ist year opens — 21. Academical and College Preparato- ry Courses. For circulars address Miss ADA M. SMITH, Mrs. T. B. RICHARDs, Principals. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, 1350 Pine St. M LSS ANABLES BOARDING AND _ Day School for or Young L Ladies will reopen Sept. 22. PENNSYLVANIA, Swarthmore. WARTHMORE COLLEGE —Opens gth wn month, 13th. Thirty minutes from Broad St. Sta- tion, Philadelphia. Under the care of Friends, but all others admitted. Full college course for both sexes ; Clas- sical, Scientific, and Literary. Also a Manual Jraining and a Preparatory School. Healthful location, large grounds, new and extensive buildings and apparatus. For Catalogue and full particulrrs «ddress Epw ARD H. MaGILL, LL.D., PENNSYLVANIA, Williamsport. i ICKINSUON SEMINARY, — A LIVE school for both sexes. Abreast of the age in every Best facilities for thorough instruction in lan- guages, literature, science, mathematics, music, and art. Degrees conferred Elective courses provided Large grounds. Commodious buildings. Heated with steam. All modern appliances f r heaith and comfort. $183 per year for board, washing, heat, light, and furnished room. discounts to ministe rs, teachers, and to two from same family. Fall term begins August 30. Catalogue free. Address J. Gr AY, D.D., Pre sident. Pres’t. respect. RHODE Ista AND, Providence. ia PLE Ss SCHOOL FORK BOTA Sexes —Founded in 1784. A very agreeable home. Thorough instruction in Common English, in science un der specialists, in Vocal and Classical Instrumental Music, and in art. Most approved preparation for College. Address AUGU TINE Jones. LL B., Prin. VIRGINIA, Lexington. TIRGINIA MILITARY INSTITUTE. J The 4%th session of this well-known State Insti tution will open on the Sth September proximo. It pro- vides asystem of thorough military training, a distine tive Academic course of instruction, and fechnical in- struction in the several branches of Applied Science, which enables a graduate in the Academic School to attain to a professional degree as Bachelor of Science or Civil Engineer. These advantages are secured on terms not exceeding $36 per month, including clothing in addition to the ordi nary collegiate necessaries. For Catalogue apply to Gen. _PRANCIS H. SMITH, Superintendent. VIRGINIA, Salem. YOANOKE COLLEGE.--In the Virginia Mountains. Several Courses for degrees. Special attention to English. french ana German spoken. In- struction thorough and practical. Library, 16,000 vo- lumes. Best moral and religious influences. Good discip line, Expenses for nine months. €149, $176, or $204 (including tuition, board, &c.), Students from many States, Ind. Ter., and Mexico. Graduates in 28 States and Territories. THIR'Y FIFTH SEssIoNn begins Sept. 14 For catalogue (with view of grounds, buildings, and mountains) address Juutius D DRE HER, President. Virarsia, University of Virginia. 'd TNIVERSITY OF VIRGINIA. Founded / oat? Thos. Jefferson. 64th Session begins October Ist, a ty for catalogue to Secretary of the Faculty. U NIVERSITY OF VIRGINIA, A A. Te salina: ete. GOOD CHANCE FOR A DELICATE boy.—A gentleman (graduate of Harvard), who is educating his own boys on a farm, wouid like roy or two boys, between ten and —— years of age, to — ate with them. Address G. L.S , Box 1347, Portsmouth, N. H. HARVARD GRADUATE (86) rane sls like a position as tutur to one or two pupils, Address F. E. H. Box 664, Farmington, eB | HARVARD GRADU ATE, Ph. dD, experienced in teaching, d« at position as teach- er of history. Address P. O, Box 27, Cambriage, Mass. AA YOUNG EDUCATED SPANIARD, well versed in modern languages, would like an engagement in some Academy as professor of languages, or to accompany some scientific character to Mexico, Central or South America. address X, X., P.O. Box 1666, New Orleans, La, YOUNG LADY it ‘ISHES ss TO 1 4CH Pg Greek. Latin, and Anciept History in a school in or near Bos'on,. Received a certificate at the * Harvard Annex ’’;’o.).0r a Four Years’ Course of Liberal Study. Address, with particulars, 0. B., Cambridge, Mass. ( HARLES W. STONE, Tutor for Harvard, 68 Chestnut Street, Boston. A one iT WE TREN, tenes "we ath Pia
Page 3
vite is ascintbininenan ae
3 £ i 4
—-> — ~— Aug. 11, 1887] The Nation
LAVERACK COLLEGE. Wy cayirssioy HUDSON RIVER INSTITUTE, | | | CLAVERACK, NEW YORK REV. A. H. FLACK, A.M., President ‘ he .
Affords superio yy advantages for thorough and systematic education to young VSURPASS#D FOR HEALVHE! UNI iND BEAUTY OF I ATION Large and commodt ous builaings vecenely impro tted 48 RONG FACULI'Y OF EXPE » : i ) a ] IDDLE-AGED GENTLEMASA elassical education, also familiar with several modern languages (speaks three), desires tutorship | MIDDLE AGED, care of Nation TASSAR GRADUATE DESIKES | American Society for Psvehi — ‘onavsaiien for coming s . a sae High ;, s , \\ | | | | \ \I Ix { N iN | N bP x
J r 7 -
‘5 sa , . -,»)} est testimonials Address | ( al Resea reu. ** Va. SAR," 61 Fleet Street, Brooklyn, N. Y The R ' P e hesearch Work the Soctety ts af preset » between five ¢ mittees : 4 » 1 ee , , , ‘ ‘\ Summer hinge: ete, 11. The Commuter , : = engas n ascertainit « ether a viv mipress r . pe . HOME IN BERLIN ADAPTFD 70 | ee a, ae eee ruans of s BRENTANO'S, 5 Union Square the needs of three or four young men Wishing to sation ; : study in that city Address for parti ilars TEACHER, Ihe Cor try parit q ? NEW Y "4 care Nation. Reietemens given and requested. Houses wishes to t — ¢ ; is sources, of apparitions of absen . | ~ . . . Mi premonitions, whether thes r in «re NEW N - s School Agencies. Waking state, of disturbances in houses des 3 haunted,” and of any wnate phet ena ters by ; IARDEEN’S SCHOOL BULLETIN | | 3. The Committee on H_protisin ts eng the s : f Agency, Syracuse, N. ¥.,may be depended on to Ay OF the mesmeric or Rvp , © . . furnish suitable teachers, and to form no others a - ites! Se ig sige re, Jd ale prepara , : ‘ ks, Ww a syet aland phys x! ia pani s : IRIDGE TEACHERS’ AGENCY, 110 | _& The Committee on Mediumistic Phe B chiens Tremont St., Boston, Mass.—College, high and pri pools octal a * Setotecati : LE WESTERN vate school work, J. Raysom BRIDGE, Manager 5 cianeteia tainit port s : ry \E | DT | ln | ZO} ; Se = : ae Ble cheis eapadd “ mediates } ) Ye BOSTON TEACHERS AGENC} pe ape sanseng \ presence “ mit sate a a | \ IN \i \l CPN | (; \ (; | { | oe Supplies Teachers to Schools, Positions to Teach oceur , ¥ ; ; , AW rN VS 4s ers. Circular free, The Committee on Fry ta . s . E. O. Fisk, 7 Tremont Place, Boston = ing investigations in folk t wht or the study s : $ . pas = ae ae = meee gv in its psychological aspects ts “ sscert ? U JNION TEACHERS AGENCY, 6) OSS oe . FIRST MOR LOANS AN ‘ J Astor Place, New York City. W. D. KERR, Secre possess in common in virtue of their be X . . ‘ tery. Seu ter circulars. Sat ine Of pincee Sind. | GmMICGIAE Incas GrCUmmNERMIC GOLD DEB IE N TURES. ») ae! sons interested in anv br h of work of t . Ww ’ } \ sry r iwing Professional. Further fuformation cau be obtained ft WALL STREET. rough study of German, French, and other branches Summer resort for seabathing Fine surroundings s f : 5 F De snr RILLS OF EXCHANGE of Riigern, University of (treif-wald. For ctrceulars f -' 7.’ address PROF. J. M. CROW, Ph.D. G tnnell, lowa Lt ‘ , ¢ ‘ MMERCIAL axd TRAVELLERS’ CREDITS 1 yp bern BOOKS IN FOREIGN LAN : saree - iii Available in all parts of the Work. - guages. Miscellaneous Books 1n | ‘ F . F 7 . x r n Languages ‘ ‘ ' . : “ ( NOs ee ) ry ' Catalogues on application Foreign vertocdicals [ Russian, Sw st snish, Polish, Bungarian, He “wr DOLLS, ; for Description, |
CARL SCHOENHOF, |[mporter, 144 Tremont St., Boston. ' brew,etc. H. ROSENTHAL & 14 Cooper Union, N. Y¥. Bight dreas 30 cents). Box 185, Bethlehem, Pa
Page 4
1V The Nation. [ Number 1154 Solibmer Ge Weel: NEW BOOKS. Down the Road, or Remints- of a_ Gentleman Coachiian. CENUCES C. T. 8. Birch New edition, with colcred illustrations, Demy 8vo, cloth. Reynardson. $4.50. Sports and Anecdotes of Bygone Days, In England, Scotland, Ireland, Italy, and the By C, T. S. Birch Reynard With nu- Demy &vo, Sunny South. son, author of ‘Down the Road.’ merous illustratious in color. cloth, $4.50, The Memoirs of the Margra- vine of Baireuth. edited by H. R. H. In 8vo, cloth extra, $3.75, Translated and Princess Christian. The Margravine was the sister of Frederick the Great, and exerted great influence over his character. Her diary i. a wonderful narr tive of the petty intrigues and gossip of the German Court, The volume has as frontispiece an autotype copy of the portraic in Berlin. *,* Princess Christian, during her recent stay in Berlin, devoted much time and attention to the completion of the English edition of the memoirs of Wilhetmine, Mar- grvvine of Baireuth, sister of Freijerick the Great. The Privcess has ft r this edition written a special introduc- tion, explaining in a very interesting manner the main features of the gereral situation in kurope, and espe- cially in vermany at that time. In order to prepare her- self for this task the Princess made a diligeut study of the original manuscripts in the Berlin Koyal Library, the documents being placed at her disposal by the Crown Prince’s special reque-t In the course of h-r studies the Princess discovered an excellent portrait of the Margra vine by Pesne; and this, in the form of a beautifully exe cuted autotype, stands as the frontispiece of the book, A Flistory of Vagrauts and VAGRANCY, AND BEGGARS AND BEG- GING. By C. J. Ribton Turner. With nu- merous illustrations, demy 8vo, cloth, $8.40. * A monument of history and research which deserves, and will doubtless obtain, wide recognition. . he subject has been hanal- d with a fulness and complete ness that has never before been so much as attempted.” —ast. James’s Gazette. The Campaign of Sedan: The Downfall of the Second Empire, August- September, 1870. By George Hooper, author of ‘ Waterloo: the Downfall of the First Na- poleon: a History of the Campaign of 1815,’ With general map and 6 plans of battles. De ny &vo, cloth, $5.60, “ This is an admirable history. No one who reads these clear and sparkling pages could realize all the labor that has gone to the writing of them "—spec/ator. * His narrative is a mode! of orderliness and intelligibt- lity, and the style has, further, a vigorand a ‘go’ which make the volume as readable as itis useful) The military details are admirably handled, so that the sequence of events can be closely followed. . The volume, ina word, is excellent both as history and as literature, and wit be accepted as the best English authority on its sub- ject.”-—Globe | “The respectable and sometimes excellent transiations of Bohn's Library have done for Literature what railroads have done Jor inter- nal intercourse.”—R. W. Emerson. * I may say in regard to all manner of books, Bohn’s Publication Series is the usefullest thing 1 know.”—Thomas Carlvle. Bohn’s Libraries. CONTAINING STANDARD WORKS of EUROPEAN LITE- RATRE in the ENGLISH LANGUAGE, With Dictionaries and other Books of Reterence, Comprising in all Translations from the French, German, Italian, —— Scan‘linavian, Anglo-Saxon, Latin, and Greek. 687 Volumes, $1.40 or $2 each, with exceptions. RECENT ADDITIONS. Important Text-Books. 5 ae Psychology. By James MecCosh, D.D., LL.D , President of Princeton College. I. The Cognitive Pow- ers. II. The Motive Powers. 12mo, each $1 50, The first volume contains an analysis of the 2 vols., operations of the senses and of their relation to RANKE’S HISTORY OF THE LATIN AND | TEUrONIC NATIONS. Translated by P. A. Ashworth, Translator of Dr. Gneist’s ‘ His- tory of the English Constitution.’ HEINE'S TRAVEL-PICTURES: including the Tour in the Harz, Norderney, and Book of Ideas, together with the Romanne School. Translated by Francis Storr. With Appen- dices and Map. GOETHE’S CORRESPONDENCE WITH ZEL- | TER. Selected, Translated, and Edited by A. D Coleridge, M.A. THE STUDENT'S HANDBOOK ~ HISTO- | RICAL GEOLOGY. By Jukes- Browne, B.a., F.G.8., of the Geological Survey of England and Wales. With nu merous Diagrams and [Ilustrations, WERNER’S TEMPLARS IN CYPRUS. Trans- lated by E. A. M. Lewis. ‘Werner was a Freemason, and his religious notions were, at the date of his writing this poem, of a theosuphic order.”’— Preface. PAUSANIASS DESCRIPTION OF GREECE. Translated into English. with Notes and In- dex. by A. R, Shilleto, M.A. 2 vols, HOFFMANN’S TALES. The Serapion Breth- | ren. First Portion, containing Thirteen Tales. Translated from the German by Ma- jor A. Ewing. HAUFF’S TALES. The Caravan—The Sheik of Alexandria—The [nn in the Spessart. Translated by S. Mendel. GOLDSMITH’s WORKS. A New Edition, con- | taining pieces bitherto uncollected and a Life of the Author, with Notes from Various Sources. By J. W. M. Gibbs. 5 vols. FOSTER'S ESSAY ON THE IMPROVEMENT OF tIME_ Together with Notes of Sermons and other Pieces. CHRISTIAN [CONOGRAPHY ; or, The His- tory of Christian Art inthe Middle Ages. By the late A. N. Didron. Translated from the French by E. J. Millington, and com- yleted, with Additions and Appendices, by Stokes. tions. TALFOURD’S LETTERS OF CHARLES | LAMB. Witt Explanatory Notes. New Edition, Revised and Greatly Enlarged by W. Carew Hazlitt. 2 vols. HAZLITT’S SPIRIT OF THE AGE;; or, Con- temporary Portraits. New Edition. By W. C. Hazlitt. A SELECTION. ANTONINUS.— THE THOUGHTS OF M. AURELIUS, BAX’S MANUAL OF THE HISTORY OF PHILOSOPHY. BOSWELL’S LIFE OF JOHNSON (Centenary Edition, edited by Napier). 6 vols. CERV«NTES’ DON QUIXOTE, COLERIDGE’S WORKS. 6 vols. FalRHOLT’s COSTUME IN ENGLAND. (Dillon.) HUGO’S (VICTOR) POEMS. Traunsiated. MOLIERE’S DRAMATIC WORKS. 83 vols. PEPYS’ DIARY. 4 vols. RICHTER’S LEVANA. RICHTER’S FLOWER, FRUIT, AND THORN PIECES, SPINOZA’S CHIEF WORKS Translated. 2 vols, STAUNTON’S CHESS HANDBOUK, 2 vols. Translated. 2 vols, + The above books will be sent upon receipt of advertised price. stock wel be mailed, if desired, to those interested. Catalogues of our regular New Catalogue of Musical Literature ready. New Catalogue of Choice and Rare Books nearly ready. SCRIBNER & WELFORD, 743-745 BROADWAY, N.Y. 2 vols., with numerous ILllustra- | the intellectual processes, and devotes considera- ble space to a discussion of Sense-perception,from the physiological side, accompanie? by aporopri- ate cuts. The second volume continues the subject with a discussion of the power of the Conscience, Emotions, and Will. “This book is written ina clear and simple style; it breathes a sweet and winning spirit; and it is es bya noble purpose. In these respects it is a model of What a text-book should be.”—Prof. William De W, Hyde, Bowdoin College. +7, ss ) x. ._ Elements of Physiological ~Aps* 7 Psychology By George T. Ladd, D.D., Professor of Men- tal and Moral Ptilosophy in Yale University. With numerous Illustrations. 1 vol., Svo, $4 50. * His erudition and his broad-mindedness are on a par with each other; and his volume will probably, f rma ny years to come, be the standard work of reference on the subject..’,— Prof. William James in the Nation. Elements of Intellectual Philosophy. A Manual for Schools Noah Porter, D D., LL.D. This is an abridgement of the author’s* Human Intel lect,’ containing all the matter necessary for usein the class-room, and has been introduced as a text-book in Yale, Dartmouth, Bowd«ein, Oberlin, Bates, Hemilton, Vassar, and Smith Colleges; Wesleyan, Ohio, Lehigh, and Wooster Universities, and many other colleges, aca demies, normal and high sctools. Elements of Moral Science. Theoretical and Practical. By Noah Porter, D.D., LL.D 1 vol., 8vo, $3. Thts treatise is intended primarily for the use of col- lege and university students, and is prepared with refer- ence to the class room * Like all the writings of its distinguished author it is copious and clear, with ample scholarship and remarka- ble insight, and { am sure that all teachers of moral science will find ita valuable aid in their instructions.” —Julius H. Seelye, President Amherst College. By MARK HOPKINS, D.D., LL D., late Presi- dent Williams College. An Outline Study of Man; or, The Body and Mind in OneSystem. With Illustrative Diagrams. Revised Edition. 12mo, $1.75. This work ts on an entirely new plan It presents man in his unity, and his several faculties and their relations are so presented to the eye in illustrative diagrams as to be reauily apprehended, “For over ten years I have made it a text-book in the se- nior class »f this school. It is, | think, the greatest and most useful of the vooks of the greatest of our American educators, aud isdestinea to do a great work in forming not only the ideas, but the character of youth every- where."’—Gen. A. C. Armstrong, Principal of Hampton Institute. The Law of Love, and Love asa Law, or, Christian Etbies. Like the treatise on mental philosophy, this is adapted with unusual skill to educational uses. [t appears ina new edition, Which has beer in part rewritten in order to bring it into closer relation to his Qutline study of Man, of which work it is really a continuation. and Colleges. By Svo, $5. 12mo, $1.75, ** Correspondence and application for exami- nation copies of the above books are requested from ail teachers wishing to select a text-book in meotal or moral s¢ience, Charles Scribner's Sons, 743-745 Broadway, New York.
Page 5
: The Nation.
NEW YORK, THURSDAY, AUGUST 11, 1887 thy , | P: —_ alas The Week ne censttan a the @@K. ived bY { S . } +} rs ae - at while, tl t s ter Tut platform of the Virginia Democrats E t Pennes which he on the debt question is, asthe whole party's : , : é uy is r amend attitude has persistently been since the entire ; nie : me mber If the Pr State succumbed to the demoralizing intluence 1 . . E 4 | eXxas, ft I of Maheneism, disgracefully wrong. It is in : . i t t thie l ‘ teresting tosee the Chairman of the Democratic 3 : fi Fennessee; as it is, 1 State Committee, Mr. Barbour, appearing before \l * } = if IsSiss pr W the Convention, and declaring that while the he . : ext scene f n amend dishonest Riddleberzer settlement of 1883 must p F e ° cl rohtoition Convet be adhered to, he is in favor of having the ‘ on having resolved to seek f Federal Government assume a part of Vir ginia’s debt burden. The arguments which le advanced in favor of this proposition are neat , ; : + ae ae i We ( < ly or quite identical with those set forth by e . “ . a} } 1ys\ thre iW aa Mr. Blaine in his * History,’ and it is quite possible that it wes from this source that ‘ we ‘ tN S WW } } Mr. Barbour drew them. On = the ques : tion of repuaciation, tn fact, there is practically . . . ( "1 ‘ (1 no ditference in the attitude of the twe parties | sp ‘ ae 5 1] Stas in Virginia. Both are as hopelessly demora ay } } a } } — t { Cr Is lized as they can be, The plank in the pla ees Mascachusetts form which is devoted to the tariff question is simul that fine old) panacea for all soctal and sseaecniacallies t ? , , , , Committ t Bost ! dustrial ills which has so long done ° ° 1 } } tit ~t t ~ duty in literature of this kind. It Ne f , . ; dren, refused. in rt calls fora revenue requisite for the sup port of the Federal Government by a tari] . ) . } , ty 1 r ‘ \ upon imports, limited to the necessities of Gov 3 i . . ss of ( ernment economically administered, and so ad justed in its application as to prevent u i i burdens, encourage productive interests t lh ° ) ae ne whieh ar \ { home, the development of our material 1 ts =| N slut sources, and afford just compensation to labor
but not to foster monopolies No human = a is being can object toa tariff! of that sort It is — t = the very one that the whole world has beer , search of these many years. ' weeaaeee : es ‘ The amount of comfort and hope whi eS aS Republican hewspapers are vetti out ot! Lit system W - Mass Kentuc ky election is so great that in some —— ~ instances it amounts toan assumption that the Mr. G. W. ¢ s begN fate of next year’s Presidential contest bas beer Nati 1 Civil-S R settled in favor of the Republicans, It is | port wit] claimed by ene organ that a similar reduc- his With Ss tion of the Democratic majorities throug] SOO W S out the solid South would transfer Virginia W M S West Virginia, Tennessee, and North Carolina serves XI to the Republican column, giving the Rey s ean Presidential candidate the benetit of M Lies electoral votes, making, with Kentucky's, a S ) total of 54, though the organ in its SaVS M4 the total would be 64. This threateni in the solid South is alleged to 1 due to tl s spread of protection sentiment, combined w the disgust of hungry Democratic place-hunters eal And all the basis there is for this in OSsINg . editice ot hope is the fact that several thousands WwW } of the Democrats of Kentucky knowit sss W { : i that their ticket Was certain to be « s not take the trouble to go to the polls s It will be some days before the « . } s of the Th I \ sf \ I | i
W \W , VI \ 4) \ i ria ™ ‘ ; 4
Page 6
104 The Nation.
[ Number 1154
ordered to pack up and go to Portland, Me, Mr. Cole is a mar of unusual natural qualifica- tions for his work, who has devoted himself to | its duties with the greatest assiduity,and won the a clear vote respect and commendation, not only of the | business community, but also of the scientists of Boston and Cambridge, who have been closely associated with him. has rendered him capable of far better service than any new man could possibly render, and every consideration of the public interests dictates his retention in his present place as long as the Government can avail it- self of his uncommon talents. That such a man should be subject to arbitrary removal and degradation—for the Portland oftice is both less important and less lucrative—shows the injustice of the anomalous system which places a service so essentially civil in its nature un- der the control of the War Department. The business exchanges of Boston and lead- ing scientific men have interested them- selves to secure a revocation of the order for Sergt. Cole’s removal, and it is to be hoped that they may be successful. How- ever the case turns out, it ought to result in strengthening the demand for a change in the relations of the Signal-Service Bureau, which shall put an end to the possibility of such out- rages.
Senator Blair of New Hampshire is dili- gently engaged trying to ‘‘ work up” public sentiment in favor of his educational subsidy scheme, and he has been very anxious to se- cure the endorsement of his own Legislature. Resolutions commending the scheme and urging Congress to pass it were accordingly introduced by one of his friends, with the | expectation that they would be readily passed ; but the Committee on National Affairs, after careful consideration of the subject, has decid- ed, by a vote of seven to three, to recommend their indefinite postponement. This is a hope- ful sign of a change of public sentiment since the character of the ‘‘ Bill to Promote Mendi- cancy ” bas been exposed, and the wisest South- ern educators have announced that they oppose further agitation of the subject.
The Tribune has been asking the opinion of | Grand Army posts as to various pension questions, and among others as to whether they favor a service pension—that is, a pension to every soldier who served inthe Union Army, whether he was at the front for four years or never got beyond the recruiting camp; whether he is now a millicnaire or a tramp ; whether he is vigorous or broken down in health. The replies show that the Grand Army is fast be- coming unanimous in favoring this scheme, which was formally taken up by the State En- campment of Massachusetis three years ago. Among all the posts reporting we find but one which ‘“No” to the service-pen- sion question—Frank Post of Greeley, Kan.— and unfortunately this post forfeits the credit which it might otherwise claim by favoring the wild scheme for an equalization of boun- ties, and the still wilder scheme of paying veterans now the difference between the value of greenbacks and gold during their term of In most post is says service a quarter of a century ago. the replies state that» the cases His experience | unanimous in favor of service pensions, these being some ot the expressions used: ‘‘Unanimously yea”; ‘‘ Yes17,no1”; ‘‘ Yes, ‘““Yes, unanimously.” ‘* Not less than $8 a month ” is the lowest sum pro- posed by any post, while the feeling appears to be growing in favor of $12 a month, and a post in Traver, Cal., wants $12.50 a month, or $150 a year for the rest of his life to every man who was mustered in. The Tribune's investigations leave no room for doubt that the Grand Army is already a ma- chine for the procuring of pensions, and that it is fast becoming: a machine for demand- ing pensions for every soldier, on the threat that ‘‘ the soldier vote against any Congressman or President who opposes the scheme. The 7)¢bune las done a great public service in bringing out these facts. ” ’ shall be cast
The determined attitude of the United Labor party against Socialism is creditable, but it 1s difficult to see where the line is to be drawn. If all advocates of socialistic doctrines are to be excluded from membership, how are Henry George and Dr. McGlynn to Not only are their land theories pure So- cialism, but the utterances of both men have at times been as thoroughly socialistic as those of any of the avowed Socialists whom Mr. George is expelling with so great a show of virtue. remain? | come forward en masse and subscribe for the paper. This Labor declined to do. As weeks rolled on and the subscription list failed to swell, Mr. Swinton became more and more radical in his views on Labor. Some of his speeches were as socialistic and revolutionary | as those of the most extreme German Social-
Indeed, Mr. George’s nomination for | Mayor originated in one of the worst hot-beds | of Socialism which we have had _ here, the Central Labor Union, and it was from the same element that he drew his most active support in last year’s cam- paign. Nothing, for example, could be more purely socialistic than McGlynn’s well-known apology for killing the Czar, or his other declaration in favor of the assumption of all landed property by the State without adollar of compensation to its owners. For George and McGlynn to turn Socialists out of their party is, in fact, as absurd as was the recent professed determination of McGlynn to bring suit against the Archbishop ists, At Labor’s public meetings Mr. Swin- ton was received with uproarious applause, and there was hope that in time subscriptions to the paper would come in. But at this point Hienry George appeared. Labor at once turn- ed its back on Swinton and Sir/nton’s Paper, and followed Henry George and_ his paper, The proposal to abolish poverty appears to have been more enticing than the proposals to establish the Rights of Man.
The ‘‘ crank,” Mooney, who attempted to set fire to the steamer Queen last week, had | evidently been a close reader of the Tribune as well as the Irish World. He was an agent of some kind for the latter paper, and large bun- dles of it were found in his room, The lan- guage of his proclamation closely resembles that which both these Blaine organs are ac- customed to use in their utterances concerning the course of the Cleveland Administration on the fisheries question. Both have repeatedly denounced the President and Secretary Bayard as too weak to use the powers conferred by the Retaliation Act of the last Congress, and have time and again spoken of the State Department as being more English than American in its sympathies. Mooney declares in his proclama- tion that the conduct of the Canadian ofticials | towards American fishermen has been disgrace- under the conspiracy law, on the ground that | his excommunication amounted to a boycott. McGlynn apparently forgot for the moment that he belonged to a party which believes boy- cotting to be a sacred and inalienable right of every American citizen.
John Swinton has suspended the publication of the newspaper which he modestly named after himself, and the reason he gives is lack of support. He says he has sustained a heavy loss on every issue during the four years of its that he ‘‘has been wrecked by and in the labor I have sunk tens of thousands existence; this paper wherewith associations, | of dollars, all of it out of my own pock- ! of Labor This is a sad record for an apostle who started out with the avowed purpose of ‘‘ Preparing the Way for the Es- tablishment of the Natural Rights of Man: (1.) His Right to a Footing on the Earth ; 2.) His Right to Labor ; (8.) His Rights to the Fruits of His Work.” The task was a self imposed one, but was undertaken by Mr. et.” Swinton with great enthusiasm and un- bounded confidence. All that was neces- sary for its success was for Labor to . ful and malicious, and that ‘‘ there is no suita- ble means of redress which can be expected from any long-eared President associated with such a Cabinet, the majority of which are very extreme Anglomaniacs, and therefore more English than the English themselves.” This is exactly in the tone of the comments of the Blaine press. We do not for a moment sup- pose that the Blaine editors had any idea of ex- citing anybody to burn a ship loaded with peo- ple, when they reeled off their ridiculous par- | tisan tirades day after day; they were trying to gain votes by showing what a very different course would be followed if he were in the White House. But the danger of that kind of | writing always is that some weak brained crea- ture may take it in earnest, as Guiteau did, and as Mooney has done now.
The habits of the mackerel are not more remarkable than those of the gallant fisherman who pursue them. <A_ few years ago these wanderers of the deep abandoned the three- limit and took to the broad ocean, with sueh unanimity and _ persistence that the fishermen said that they wanted no- thing from Canada or Great Britain or any- mile body, and that they would be thankful if Congress would ‘annul the Washington Treaty so far as they were concerned, and re- mit them to their rights under the Treaty of 1818. In this they were accommodated. But now the mackerel have changed their minds and run in- shore” again, following them. three - mile naturally within the the fishermen The right to fish
alta Eat aN na
Page 7
ae PER ABS BKIED
Aug. 11, 1887
limit was conferred by the Washington Treaty, but was not included in that of ISIS. To be caught fishing in those waters is to forfeit one’s boats as well as one’s catch So wher a couple of seining parties belonging to thi schooners Frexch and Argo ft were plving their vocation within a mileand a half of Prince Edward [sland (according to the 72? x Tt port at the time of the occurrence), and when a Canadian cruiser went in pursuit of the seining parties, the schooners, although they were out side of the three-mile limit made for home as fast us possible. Having arrived at Gloucester, they have reported to Capt. Babson, President of the Fishery Association, that their seining parties were at least four miles from shore, and that an excellent: judge of distances has found other testimony which convinces him that the seizing of the seining parties of | the French and Argonaut was a new outrage for if they were really outside the three mile limit, the Caaadian cruiser) had no tight to molest them. Might it not be added that if they were outside the limit, the schooners to which they belonged had po right to abandon them totheenemy ” Why does not the President of the Fishery Association give us his opinion of the two captains who had so httle consider ation for their own rights and their own men that they surrendered both without even mak ing a protest against the seizure A great many inexplicable things happen in Wall Street, and one of the most Common is a general fear of impending chaos at a time when the conditions of business, and earnings, and crops, and the foreign exchanges, and the money supply are all encouraging, so that nobody can put his finger on any gen ral and wide reaching fact that threatens the prosperity of the country, It is easily un derstood that ‘‘depression” results from = tbe imagination of traders quite as often as from facts of an economical character; but when the street retires toa cave of gloom without any real cause it generally invents one, just as a hypochondriac sometimes imagines that a Wart on his nose is the beginning cf a cancer that is soon to — terminate his life. Wall Street, being in a melancholy mood without good reason, found its wart in
the Ives Stayner syndicate, and has been giv- ing so much attention to the excrescence that it has been unable to see any considerable part of the heavens or the earth for some weeks W benever any body asks why stocks go down, or why money is hoarded, or why new enterprises are not taken up, the answer is that everybody is waiting for the Ives Stayner syndicate to carry out their ‘* deal’ or collapse. It seems t be considered immaterial which of the tw alternatives happens, but until one of them does happen, everybody must clutch bis pocketbook and hold his breath, and Keep his eye on the Cincinnati, Hamilton and Dayton Railroad.
Now, what is the importance of the Cincinnati Hamilton and Dayton Railroad to the money market, or to the stock market, or to any market having its nerve centre in Wall Street What would be the consequence if this pr cious thing were carried off by witches ir bight time and nothing left of it but a right of
wal The common stock of the company Is ‘ +? between three and four millions; there may be sas much more « he preferred some We know that something less tl S? MM) OOD of thre latter s in the hands Mr. Robert Garrett, whieh be claims to | is Winnings in a game of forfeits played wit Ives & Stayner, and that tl latterhave brought a suit to recover it. There mav be some othe! small amounts of C.. H. and DD. preferres pledged for other ‘* deals but when if ts a reckoned up, it is such a wart, compared with the Ossa of general finance in Wall Street, that we can only wonder how it las come t so large a part of the field of view, and absor the attention of so many people Whose sense o j perspective is commonly good. Proba
explanation is, that) the human imagination is ilways most powerfully affected by the u secon and the unknown, An idea has got abroa hat the Ives & Stayner syndicate have borrowed a lot of monev on collaterals tha cannot — be real 1 oon but whether tb mount ) orrowed is few millions something near the v of he railros Sub. Treasury of the United States, is the ques tor Here is abundant room for play of the imagination. Here, probably, we tind the in ortance attached to the doings of «a pair } small tinanciers whotr nobody knew — six Get Boulanger took such offene it} thought it fitting t challenge the fort ticht i duel, has been Var uslv fr } rted cable It has now come to hand in tl Fren papers, and we subjoin the passage which so effectively pricked the inflation of the ex-Mir ister of Wat
‘If we are to belies at riotism is not only t ty but it is the exclusive p1 ips f certain sections, of the i not think like them, all t in the management of the ttl uutry the irresponsible rt tree apd reflecting action of the nstituted au thorities, and all who do not adore their idots and do not rush with them behind the chariot a1 café-concert St, Arnaud—all these are classe indiscriminately as the party of the foreig ; St. Arnaud was a promot ! of Napoleon IT [ brupt, upexpla 1 a apna prov xt s was mw) Weak vr s s v \ sco! t = \ M \ revit M VI ) ty ( . R , A > t - ‘ 's \ frankly . s SS ‘ \s } t t \ at I i “ eS r \ ( I ‘ i g R i a With ‘ Ss appreva | s et . Powers porte \ bulge , | iy r a . \ , ¢ ¢ ’ ? \ | ~ ¥ h re ‘ kas I }™ t i ( f ‘, - 1 st te ] { c et ‘ ! in a Siavs M ! not |} re + xy i i ? ~ ~ thr \t sal t i 5 i ac I ( “4 Ih in “ i P t A Is Cleat insat ¢ neh i 1 tnew venture Ristiteh equally mbitic nad estless, is ready t serve him in _ it, even against Russia. The Slav banner is be flung aloft, the Bulgarian Sobranye won hy the prospect of aid against Russia (ustria-Hungary’s friendly neutrality secured, ind Turkey lulled into the belief that her rain rights over Bulgaria and Eastern Ru melia will be respected. The scheme is fine it completely hollow,
we
Page 8
106 The Nation. [Number 1154 SUMMARY OF THE WEEK’S NEWS. [WEDNESDAY, August 3, to Tvespay, August 9, 1887, inclusive. | DOMESTIC, Secretary Farreurp of the Treasury on Au- vust 3 offered to anticipate the payment of in- terest on the 4.and 4!5 per cent. bonds up to January 1, 1888, with a rebate of 2 per cent., and invited proposals for the sale to the Gov- ernment of the 4's per cent. bonds falling due in L891, to be applied to the sinking fund. At the election of State oflicers in Kentucky on August1 the Democratic ticket, headed by Gen, 5. B. Buckner, was elected by a reduced majority, Which is computed to be somewhat less than 20,000 votes, At the election of members of the Utah Legislature on the same day a minority of nou Mormon = can- didates was elected. They made gains chiefly because of the disfranchisement by the Edmunds-Tucker act of the women. At the electionin Texas on August 4 on several amend ments to the State Constitution, chief of which was one prohibiting the manufacture and sale of liquors, the prohibitory amendment was de- feated by a majority of more than 75,000 votes. The resolutions adopted by the Virginia De- mocratic Convention August 4 pledge the ‘cordial support” of the party to President Cleveland's ‘* wise, conservative, fearless, and honest Administration,” demand the repeal of the infernal revenue system asa “‘relic of war,” favor atari! upon imports ‘‘limited to the necessities of the Government economically administered,” with incidental protection, ap- prove the refusal of the Legislature to ac cept the bondholders’ proposition regarding the debt, endorse the Riddleberger plan of settlement, ask for compensation from Con gress for territory ceded to the Federal Gov- ernment ant for loss of the territory” in- cluded in West Virginia, favor State pensions for Confederate veterans, and approve Federal nid to edueation, Senator Daniel in a speech opposed ervil service reform, The Glenn bill, making the education of white and negro children in the same school a penal offence, was passed by the Georgia House of Representatives August 2, by a vote of 124 yeasand 2 nays. The nays were cast by the colored members. A meeting of colored men in Boston, August 8, adopted violent reso lutions of indignation against the proposed law. Two leaders of a party of men who lynched a negro were brought to trial at Edgefield C. H., 8. C., but were acquitted August 5. These were the first men ever indicted in South Carolina for lynching, and no white man, it is reported, has ever been hanged in Edgetield County, though during the last thir- teen years more than 120 murders have been committed there, most of them by whites. Emile Riverre and Jobn Larrien, prominent Creoles of New Orleans, fought a duel August 7 with short swords about an article in the French paper, L’ Opinion, of which Riverre is editor, Larrien was shghtly wounded. S. B. Turner, a colored editor of Springfield, Ill., has caused the arrest, under the State Civil-Rights Act, of the proprietors of a restau- rant who refused to serve meals to him and two colored friends. J. P. Haynes of Galves- ton, Tex., a colored student of Dartmouth Col- lege, has been appointed Demonstrator of Anatomy at that institution. The Prohibitionists in Maryland nominated a full State ticket August 8, with S. Baldwin of Baltimore for Governor, A member of the State Board of Health of Indiana has reported to the Board that the jails in Lawrence and Perry Counties are untit for human habitation, that the poor-house of Law- rence County is in a horrible condition, and that the overseer takes the proceeds of the la bor of all the inmates that he ean hire to farm ers at SLT per week. Young children are forced to sleep witlrold inmates who are attict | ed with ) houses and jails were found to be in a similar loathsome diseases. Other poor- condition. Gov. Davis of Rhode Island has announced his intention to have the manage- ment of some of the State institutions at Cranston, about which complaint has been made, investigated. A former warden of the Cook County (IIl.) Insane Asylum, four former members of the Board of County Commissioners, and seven members of the present Board, known as the | Chicago ‘ boodlers,” on August 5 were found | guilty of conspiracy to defraud the county by false pretences. The verdict fixes the punish ment of four ata fine of $1,000 each, and of the , | others at two years’ imprisonment in the peni- tentiary. The Civil Service Reform League met at Newport August 2. Reports were made from forty associations. Mr. George Willtam Cur- tis, the President, in his address summing up the progress of the reform, said : ‘‘ But while we may believe, as I certainly believe, that the President is an upright magistrate, who, look- ing at the vast and complicated range of his | duties as the Chief Executive of a great nation, has been unable to accomplish in this depart- ment of his duty all that he would have gladly | done—while we may willingly acquit him of insincerity or indifference—we must yet be as just to ourselves as to him. It would be a great wrong to the cause of which the League is the authorized national representative if it | did not plainly and emphatically declare that it | does not regard the Administration, however worthy of respect and confidence for many reasons, as in apy strict sense of the words a civil-service-reform Administration.” In the resolutions, which have the same tone towards the President as Mr. Curtis’s speech, the League renews its recommendations that the civil-ser vice rules be extended, and declares that nomi- nations made by the President should be dis- cussed in open sessions of the Senate, and that all appointments and removals, with the rea- sons therefor, should be placed on public re- cord. Chief-Engineer George W. Melville, the Arctic explorer, has been promoted to be Chief of the Bureau of Steam Engineering in the Navy Department. Wilford Woodruff, who is President of the | Mormon Apostles, and has been in hiding for | two years to escape prosecution under the Ed- munds Act, has issued a proclamation assum- ing for the time the Presidency of the Mormon Church. A company of ‘‘boomers” near Arkansas City, Kan., have announced their intention to march and take possession of the country known as Oklahoma, in Indian Territory. United States troops are near by to prevent such a movement. A party of distinguished persons, including Senators Cameron, Vgst, and Farwell, the Governors of Alaska and Montana, President Gilman of the Johns Hopkins University, and Miss Edwards of the Mount Holyoke Semi- nary, having made an excursion to Alaska, ar- | rivedat Tacoma, W. T., ontheir return on Au- gust 8. Mrs. John Field of Philadelphia has present- ed a valuable collection of paintings, which was left by her husband, to Williams College. August 3 Thomas J, Mooney, an Irishman, set fire to the British steamship Qzeen, lying at a pier in the Hudson River. When captur- ed he had in his pocket a copy of a ‘‘ procla- mation ”’ containing a diatribe against the Eng- lish Government about the fisheries question, and announcing that all English ships in Ame- rican ports are ‘liable to seizure, attack, or destruction from the Ist day of August, 1887, until the Enghsh Government shall make am- ple and suitable apology to the United States.” Among his personal effects dangerous explo sives were found, There is an area of about 55.000 square miles in the Northwest extending from Madi son, Wis., on the north, to Bloomington, HL, ' on the south, and from Lake Michigan on the ~ast tothe Mississippi River on the west, where a destructive drought prevails. Crops are ruined and many cattle have perished. A tornado on August 4 destroyed seventy- nine houses in the town of Millbrook, Kap., causing a loss of $68,000. The people are in great distress, and a relief commuttee has been organized to solicit aid for the families whose homes were swept away. On August 7 the total number of cases of yellow fever that had been reported at Key West, Fla., was 221; deaths 45, cured 43, still sick 73. The supply of natural gas near Albert Lea, Minn., is judged to be so extensive that a com pany has been organized to transport and to use it, In a series of races off the Rhode Island and Massachusetts coasts by the New York Yacht Club, General Paine’s new yacht, the Volvn teer, bas proved itself the fastest of those that were entered, The date for the first of the trial races for the America’s cup has been fixed for September 18; if foggy, for Septem ber 14. Among the noteworthy persons who died during the week were Joseph H. Rainey, the colored ex-Congressman, at his residence in Georgetown, 8S. C., on August 2; Allen Fran cis, U.S. Consul at St. Thomas, Ont., August 4, of injuries received in a recent railway dis aster; the Rev. Eleazer Root of Jacksonville Fla., for many years a prominent citizen of Wisconsin, and the first) Superintendent ot Public Instruction in that State; Amos Reed, at one time acting Governor of Utah, August 7, at his home near Branchville, Md., aged sixty-four years; George Essex Montifex Drummond, Viscount Forth, on August 4, in St. Luke’s Hospital, in this city, where the British Consul lately sent him to be treated for consumption. The Viscount, who was left an orphan at an early age, was the grandson and heir of George Drum mond, fourteenth Earl of Perth, Earl of Mcl- fort, and bore the French titles of Due de Melfort, Comte de Lussan, and Baron de Valrose. He was born September 3, 1856. When fifteen years old he eloped with a woman of twenty-one, the maid of his ma- ternal grandmother, the Hon. Mrs. Capel. | They came to America and lived in great | poverty, doing manual labor in this city and | one of on Long Island. His widow and a son sur- vive him. On August 7 Alpheus Hardy, the most prominent and useful of the older merchants of Boston, died. [o- race Abbott, one of the best-known iron manufacturers and at one time proprietor of the largest iron works in the country, died August 8 at Baltimore, aged eighty one years. | Gen, A. W. Doniphan, a veteran of the Mexi can and of Indian wars, and one of the most prominent lawyers in Missouri, died at Rich mond, Mo., August 8. Henry Hastings, a well-known Boston mercbant who had con trolled a large fleet of merchant vessels, died August 9. FOREIGN. In the British naval mancuvres on August 4 the commander of the tleet who was instructed to attack England outwitted the commander of the defensive fleet, made a dash at Falmouth, anchored unresisted in the harbor lopg enough to have destroyed the whole town, landed an army corps, then steamed up the Channel, ran the Straits of Dover, and got into the Thames, where he had seven hours during which he could have seized Woolwich and destroyed all the Thames shipping and burned London. This suggestive success of the attacking com- mander has provoked serious comment on the possibility of invasion by many of the English journals, The bill to allow the construction of a tun nel under the English Channel, which was in troduced in the House of Commoos by Sir Edward Watkin, was rejected August 3 by a yote of 158 to 107 4 4 % 3
Page 9
Senn even i SG ES A aN CC es
Aug. 11, 1887
The Nation.
The Land Biil passed through the committee stage in the H[ouse of Commons August 3, and passed its third reading two days later In reply to the question in the House of Commons, August 8, why the Government re fused to submit a return showing the number of royal princes or persons allied to royalty by marriage Who hold posts in the public service and draw money from the public funds, and how many ollicers have been passed over by such appointments, Mr. Smith replied that in the Judgment of the Government such a return would be of an invidious character, and ought not to be granted. A private conference of Liberal Unionists was held August 4 in London to discuss means for checking the Gladstonian reaction. The speakers agreed in attributing their defeats partly to the enthusiasm and energy of the Home-Rulers in assisting the Gladstonian can didates, and partly to the want of united action on the part of Liberal Unionists and Copserva tives. The Unionist members of Parliament gave a dinner to Lord Hartington August 5, over which Mr. Bright, who made a bitter anti Gladstonian speech, presided. Lord Harting- ton intimated in his speech that he shouid join the Government during the recess of Parlia ment, The statement of the claim in the ease of Mr. Frank Hugh O'Donnell against the Lon don 7imes for £50,000 damages for libel in its articles on ‘* Parpellism and Crime.” indicates that the leading Parnellites will be called to testify during the prosecution of the case. A summons for perjury was issued on Au cust S against the London policeman who ar rested the young woman, Miss Cass, on the charge of beng an improper character. A sen sational trial is expected On the night of August 4, 4,000 employees of the English Midland Railway went on a strike. Freight tratlic was partially suspended for seve ral days. The tribunal at Charleroi, Belgium, has awarded a manufacturer of glass $175,000 damages “or the destruction of his works which were burned during the labor riots at Jumet. A loss estimated at nearly a half million pounds was caused by fire August 6 in White ley’s large drapery and general stores and ware houses in Westbourne Grove and Quer n Roud, Paddington, and several ¢ mployees and firemen lost their lives. At the village of Fotheringay, the scene of the execution of Mary Queen of Seots, man visitors witnessed a series of tableaux vivants by ladies of the neighborhood, on the occasion of the tercentenary of ber death, depicting the chiet scenes in her life The Crown Prince Frederick William of Gerinany underwent another operation in Lon don August 4 by Dr. Mackenzie for the growth in his throat, with good results. His general health is excellent, and his voice is improving The recurrence of the growth is the only alarm- ing feature. : Emperor William and Emperor Francis Jo seph met at Gastein August 6. They took a walk on Sunday, and later Emperor Francis Joseph paid a visit to Emperor William, At the end of half an hour they bade each other farewell, embracing at the top of the staircase Emperor William remained on the balcony ut til Emperor Francis Joseph disappeared from view, the crowd in the street in the meanwhile cheering. During the first half of 1887, 57,181 persor emigrated from Germany, as against 40,59 during the first half of 1886 ; 106 Government aided emigrants sailed from Queenstown for Montreal August 6. The one hundred and fiftieth anniversary of the founding of the University at GOtungen was celebrated August 7, The German feeling against France cot nues to find expression in newspaper coment and 1u irritating incidents Phe Deutsches J geblatt, in an article headed ‘* German- Batting in France,” says: ‘' If these persecutions con tinue, and the French Government adopt cot responding measures, We should simply regard France as 4 barbarous, uncivilized nation, and should break off diplomatic relations, « tinue railway and postal intercourse, and throw out a line of military outposts. Tf the French play at war against us in time of peace, let us do the same thing.” Thirty-eight Freveh rail road employees residing at Avricourt, Lor raine, near the frontier of France, were recent ly expelled from the country. It was reported August 7 that Baron Billing, late French Am bassador to Sweden, while visiting friends in Alsace, was expelled from the province. liscon
Nor do the relations between Germany and Russia become more conciltatory. The of Moscow and St. Petersburg make the « of M. Katkotf the oceasion of fresh outbursts of hatred towards Germany. The Areuz-Zeitung and other German ul nals attack the Danish Government for declat ing the necessity of tortifying Copenhaget against Germany, and warn Denmark that at alliance between France and Russia might lead to the conviction that the annexation of Der mark to Germany Was & maritime necessity rere t i i The late Alfred Krupp bequeathed $250,000 for the benefit of bis employees, and h Friedrich has added $125,900 to the amount for the people of Essen The Town ( of Essen has voted $15,000 fora statu fred Krupp. } 1 Prince Ferdinand, accompanies and the Bulgarian Foreign Minister ft na for Bulgaria August 9 ‘ \ ~ - \ 4 r\ wid \ I t { \ stu i _ \ Ad \ ‘I ( \ \ n i 4 - tain WW \ - \ “- ~ \ \ vl . “ ( ‘ ty ~ | M ti N i \\ i’ \ - i -~ i | IN? l s I ‘ \ ti \ - I \ Hi \ vl strv. W wie vy . i . i i * i solti Leg \ il ‘ G ‘ u Ilaw < So i wm ¢ niend tha \ Ye ARGU le the ( . His ut its Were derived i i Tine rigit to abrovuts of Was not one of these ‘Therefore, his iS abs itely lawless, and without exer except that of physical terror of death at th hands of the men who now constitute his advi sory. councl Added to these troubles is a 4 rave financial danger. Ex Premier Gibsou put a loan of $2,000,000 on the market, but the new Ministry will have nothing to do with 1¢@ bonds and there is danger of repudiatior Prime Minister Green asserts that the bonds ire worthless. The holders who are in dange of suffering loss ure English investors, Queen Kapiolani arrived July 26, +) ul
Page 10
~ 108 The Nation. { Number 1154 SECRETARY FAIRCHILD’S CIRCULAR. THE opinion of bankers and financiers in this city in reference to Secretary Fairchild’s circu- lar appears to be highly commendatory. The same opinion is reflected by the exchanges. A feeling of confidence has been exhibited in business circles which has been for a long time wanting, and which evidently nothing else could have supplied. It was in vain that crop prospects and railroad earnings and bank clearings were improving, and bankruptcies diminishing, so long as it appeared possible that the Treasury might absorb and lock up | the money of the country, and thus blight the fairest fruits of the most promising business season. Much of the existing apprehension was unfounded. The possible evils were exaggerated, But for all practical purposes they might have been real and well grounded. The man who believes that a thunderstorm is coming will stay indoors. It may not come, but he will act as though it were coming. So, too, the man of business, however clear- sighted and however little superstitious he may be, will steer clear of any, apprehended money stringency, arising from any cause or from no particular cause. He will do business from hand to mouth, and avoid a might expose him to disaster. importance to him whether the cas the Treasury is larger or sma was twelve months ago, in with the question what the balance be thirty, or sixty, or ninety days he If there is any doubt upon this point—if the operations of the Treasury are of a kind to draw money in large sums from business channels, and if the intentions of the Secretary regarding the surplus are veiled in mystery—he will cut all his undertakings and risks down to the minimum. He will hoard his own resources just in proportion as he im- agines that the Secretary is hoarding his. And the two hoardings together may cause a panic. To all men of the enterpnsing class the Secretary’s circular is especially welcome, since it signifies to them that the Treasury is not to be a sinister factor in the money market, nor any factor at all so far as Mr. Fairchild can The difticul- ties of the situation are very considerable, but The Secretary has no prevent. not insurmountable. power to diminish his own income, but he can add to his outgo temporarily, and suffi ciently to ward off present danger. anticipate his interest payments toan indefinite Ile can extent, and he can buy bonds in the open mar ket at his own discretion. It is doubtful whether any large number of bondholders, ex- cept, perhaps. the national banks, will care to have their interest paid in advance if they have to accept it with a rebate, but they can be required to take it if it is offered to them in full. It is no loss to the Government to pay it without rebate, since there is no other use for the public money than to pay public obliga tions. Still, the Secretary would not be justi- fied in paying the full interest in advance until he had tried the other way. We shall soon know whether the interest money is wanted in named. The na- advance on the conditions tional banks, being in the money-lending busi- ness, may perhaps take their portion with the | | rebate. If they do, it will be because they can make it earn them more than 2 per cent. per annum. When we turn io the Secretary’s alternative measure, the purchase of 414 per cent. bonds, we shall probably find that the offerings of bonds to the Government will be made at something above the current market rate. This, however, will be merely an_ every- day experience. When any large buyer comes into the market, whether for securities or for produce, he has to pay something above the current rate, and conversely every large seller has to accept something less than the cur- rent rate. Accordingly, if the Secretary should find signs of some _— speculation on his necessities, he need not hesitate on that account. There must be a reasonable limit to such speculation because the 4!5 per cents have less than four years to run. All the pre- mium that the present holders can ever realize they must get within that short space of time. Here again the Sec- retary would be justified in paying some- thing more than a private person would pay, because he has no other investment for his money. A private person might use his sur- plus in a hundred ways. The Treasury can use its surplus only in paying debts. The pur- chase and cancellation of $1,000 of 415 per cents the payment of about $180 in interest, ing that amount to the taxpayer. The pre- t quotation of 4135 per cents is about 110, y purchase at less than 118 is a saving to | theSGovernment. These bonds have so short a time to run that one would naturally look for a competition among sellers. IMMIGRATION AGAIN. Tue Democratic platform of Virginia is un- questionably the most degrading public de- liverance of the present year, but we would | not stake much on the prediction that the Re- publican platform of the same State will not be a more disreputable one. Among the doctrines labelled Democratic by the followers of Thomas Jefferson 1s this : ‘‘Weare unalterably opposed to the introduction of foreign pauper labor into this country, and we request the Congress of the United States to pass | | such laws as will prevent the immigration of such people who will become a burden upon the tax- | payers of this country, or come in competition with honest American laborers.” It is easy to see what this means, for although the words ‘‘pauper labor” and *‘honest American laborers” are cunningly in- troduced, in order to convey the impression that only the pauper classes and the dishonest classes of foreign countries should be exclud- ed, yet a careful reading shows that the inten- tion is to exclude every class. This looks much like the Know-Nothingism of thirty years ago, but it is really something worse, and we do not believe that public sentiment, even of the artisan class, composed as itis largely of foreign-born citizens, is pre- pared to go that length. We think that the utmost that any large number of Americans, whatever their nativity, desire, is some effective discrimivation between the good and the bad, the desirable and the undesirable, the thrifty and the unthrifty classes of immigrants ; and the question is, how to make the discrimina- tion, It is a well-known fact that more than one European nation would be glad to diminish the emigration from its shores, or detlect it into channels where it would redound mainly to the interest of the mother country. The act of emigration implies a_ dissolution of all old political ties, and generally the acceptance of a new — allegiance and new political relations. In the present political attitude of European countries to one another, this means a good deal. It means the loss each year of hundreds of thousands of able-bodie? men—men who have been nurtured at great expense to the State, and trained for military service, men who are producers, and of even greater value economically than as soldiers. Germany, Italy, Austria, and even Russia would be very willing to retain the services of these men, as there is every reason to believe that, should war come, each nation would require all its re- sources to meet its competitors. It would be strange, therefore, if in this situation the Government of the United States and those of Europe could not arrive at some understanding in which the wishes of each might at least in part be met. It would be impossible to prohibit migration, as the means of evading such a prohibition are too many, but we believe it is possible to devise some whole- some checks upon migration which would greatly improve the class of emigrants coming to this country. Furthermore, we believe that these checks could be more effectively ap plied in the countries whence the movement originates than in the customs ports of this country. The Boards of Emigration now act- ing under national legislation are confessedly carry out the full intent bungling le incompetent to | of their institution, and such gislation as the so-ealled labor reformers would apply, and of which the ‘‘ contract-labor law” isa fair example, is decidedly mischievous, and in fact only aggravates the evils of an un- restricted immigration by excluding the most workingmen—the skilled How, then, can these checks desirable class of labor of Europe. be applied ? It seems to us that the consular service of- fers the proper machinery for an attempt to improve the quality of emigrants from their respective districts. The consul is on the spot; he knows the general character of the popu- Jation of his district; he has, moreover, at hand sources of information that would enable him to decide a case in doubt. The most rea- sonable test would be one requiring the in- tending emigrant to obtain from the nearest American consul of certificate which will be issued only when the consul is rea- sonably sure that the applicant is capable a sort of self-support and intends to support himself and family. This, after all, is merely applying the general rules which are supposed to be enforced at the lead- ing centres of immigration in this country, and it is certainly easier to apply them to a small number of emigrants in their own coun- try than to bodies of tbree or tour thousand landed at our wharvesin oneday. The rules to be applied in the issue of certificates must of ne- | cessity be general, and their enforcement would | depend upon the energy and honesty of the con- | sul; but, great as will be the differences in in- a eh
Page 11
trot stata antenna. hy we
ot: 7 Aug. 11, 1887] terpretation that must arise, they will not en tail so much mischief as the loose action of the soards of Immigration in this country, neces sary as these Boards are, and eager as they are to perform faithfully the duties imposed upon them. We said that even the foreign governments might assist in this control of migration. In past years there have been indications of a wish on the part of some of the European govern ments to dispose of their vicious and imeapa- ble population by shipping them abroad. This wish, however opposed to the rules of comity and friendship recognized by international law, is, after all, a very natural one, and only the strong remonstrances of this Govern ment have prevented its being carried into effect ** Every society,” wrote Mr. Marcy in 1856, ** possesses the undoubted right to determine who shall compose its members, and it is exer cised by all nations both in peace and war”; and in 1872 Mr. Fish wrote positively that the Government of the United States ‘‘is not willing, and will not consent, to receive the pauper class of any community who may be sent, or may be assisted in their immigra tion, at the expense of Government or of muni cipal authorities.” On one occasion, Austria checked an undesirable emigration of Mormons at the request of this Government. Exactly how this participation of a foreign government in this plan for controlling emi gration is to be exercised we will leave for future discussion. It is doubtful whether it would be necessary often to call upon a government for action, as the classes over which it has complete control—the chroni paupers, the insane, and the -incapable—ar already excluded from landing at our ports by positive statute. But it would be well to have such an agency to fall back upon should a special contingency requiring it arise. In the meanwhile, we think that the consular certifi cate or passport would be a step towards a proper solution of this intricate question. As the machinery exists, and can be put to work without expense, there is a fair field for a trial. THE RACE ISSUE IN GEORGIA Tue lower branch of the Georgia Legislature has passed, with only two dissenting votes, what is known as the Glenn bill, The bill is enti tled ‘‘ A bill to regulate the’ manner of con ducting educational institutions in this State and provide penalties for the infraction of this act.” It provides that no school, col- lege, or other educational institution conducted for the education and _ training of colored peo ple shall matriculate or receive as a pupil any white person; ner shall any school, college, or other educational institution conducted for th education of white people receive or matriculat any colored person as a pupil. Any teacher or manager controlling an institution violati: this act shall, upon conviction, be punished t under a section of the code providing as th penalty for misdemeanors a fi Nhe not exceed ing $1,000, imprisonment not exceeding six months, or work in a chain-gang not exceed ing twelve months—any or all in the discreti of the court. If the institution has a chart not only the teachers, but the president, secre The Nation. } — iy 4x tarv, and trustees, who shall knowing mit this act to be violated, are subject to tn dictment and similar punishment. The act is aimed at the single institution i the State which has ever educated children of the two races together—the Atlanta University This institution was founded by the American Missionary Association, shortly after the war for the education of colored pupils, and is still chietly supported by Northern benevolence its only assistance from the State having been the allowance for some years past of half the $16,000 annual interest coming from its sbare of a national grant of publie lands to the States for educational purposes. The University has never had a White pupil from a Georgian family, and the only white pupils are a half-dozen children of } | he professors and of a clergyman associ t ted with the institution, who have been thus edu cated by their parents, partly from motives of convenience, as there is no other school in the vicinity, and partly from their desire to live uy to their principles of disregarding the race line. No charge has ever been made that the professors have acted as proselyters in the cause of mixed education, and no evidence has ever been presented that their course was meking mixed education so popular that native white parents were likely to imitate their ex ample. The act simply means that if a pre fessor in the Atlanta University te: own child in aclass with a negro chil be sentenced to a year in the chain Georgia, like every other Southe ind like many Northern States unt
years, has always maintained separ sel for the two races. The Constitution pro for ‘‘a thorough system of common. sch ‘ols which ‘‘shall be free to all cit f tl State; but separate schools s provid for the white and colored races In the exis ing condition of pubhe sentiment or question throughout the South, public edu tion could never have been establish attempt had been made by force to bring t! two races into the same schoel reom, and would be overthrown in @ moment if mixed schools were to be ordered now. The legality ind the expediency of separate school svstems are, therefore, not now in questior But is one thipg to provide that the races sl not mix in schools supported by | taxation, and quite another thing t cla that no school, however supported, shall te whites and blacks together without subjecting everybody responsible for this policy to the risk of a yearin the chain-gang. This is an outrage of the very worst sort. for wWhict defence that is ev Qh PIAUsI oie has bee i can be ™m ve I Is sin ply im outburst of mice prejudice in its most offensive form But much of the Northern comm | this performarce ts qu beside the p Many Republican papers talk as though this were a question of politics, and a matter for (¢ TTeSSIONAlL leis on, and a} pear o th . that. if there were a Republican Admini stra tior Washington, something would be done : A Connecticut organ, for examp is proposed to take the questicn of civil rights involved into Congress, and ippeal to the highest court in the land to have the law Set asic lf e editor had read the decision +
f e Supreme ( et ( tyig \ ssed bv ¢ ss constitut \ | Ve 1 “ " “ } “V tha i ( 7 " ty PF rig a Sta } oa 1 r clon t ‘ j pplies , If the teacher of aw i black puy \ suthe px ultv as thie wh a! rll rex iw ~ has sch Ss ‘ OVS « \ ‘ ‘ ‘ the 7 , , Y y if ‘ i \ lin sand p . . ! iChK Y . ‘ sul s is tl se OW The G ‘ Ne T ( that G I i . . ~ 4 I t . i t Stic \ ~ ‘ tory ( l ‘ \l ( mindn a Ww i au let t \ her \ . ( ‘ Tow . Ww t \ t ey - ‘ ig l . \ ‘ t Iipts “ . \ Miss ( \ eal: was slates ii Ss ; \ y | \] . t t ( vs ~ iss ‘ v t aol ells he tog I t} ; Miss ¢ Was arres i r I “i j \ A trie ined « t 1 ‘ ; \ = = I si,” ‘ ‘ i i M ‘ ! Ss hin “ t s \ \ yr WwW we il i | . shopkeepers W Se hem a morse od: the well was cd witl t 1 wate from other sources refused t sicians W 1 not wa ly he he ige Meeting- hou Was < aT | iwalns ( carriage In the |} ul convevances was denied them, and friends were forbidden under heavy fines to visit them cir house was assailed with rotten eggs and stones, and rally Vas Set on fire This happened in Connecticut only fifty vears age { white woman can teach colored pupils in Connecticut to-day, but not because ‘ weople have been com pt lled to allow her to do so by Congress or court. It is be cause they have come to see the Injustice ind inhumanity of their ancestors. If Georgia is to outgrow her present intolerant dispo sition, it must be in the same way. And if Northern Republican papers are impatient at the prospect that this will take a long time, they must remember that it was not until the ? year 1887 that the Northern State of Ohio
Page 12
110 The Wation. which had been controlled by the Republican party most of the time for thirty years, reached the point where her Legislature would abolish the last of the ‘‘ black laws.” SOREL’S MONTESQUIEU, PARIS, July 29, 1887. 1 GAVE an analysis of Boissier’s little volume on Mme. de S¢évigneé. I have now before me an- other volume of the same series, * Montesquieu.’ It is not an easy task to write anything original or new on the author of the ‘ Lettres Persanes’ and tha‘ Esprit des Lois.’ M. Albert Sorel, the author of this new volume inthe ‘ Grands Ecri- vains de la France,” has made himself known by a work on ‘Europe and the French Revolution,’ now in course of publication. His mind is more turned on diplomatic and histo rica] questions than on pure literature; be has occupied for some time a post in the French Foreign Office, 1s one of the officers of the French Senate and a professor in the Ecole Libre des Sciences Politiques. The family of Montesquieu adopted the Pro- testant reform in the sixteenth century, and re turned to the Catholic religion at the time of the abjuration of Henri lV. Charles Louis, the future author of the * Esprit des Lois,’ was born January 18, 1689, near Bordeaux, at the cba- teau de la Bréede. ** His father,” says M, Sorel, ‘*had the aristocratic austerity of the Vaubans and the Catinats; his mother was pious; they were both nobles who made themselves of the people, partly from a sentiment of the ¢ ' their rank, partly from a Christian feeli the moment when Charles Louis was b beggar came before the chateau; they key aud made him the godfatber of the child, im der that this godfather might remind him a his lifetime that the poor were his brothers.” This might be called an education @ la Rous- seau “before Rousseau. Tne pious and philan- thropic mother did not nurse her child, how- ever, but gave him to some peasavts, who kept him three years. Charles Louis lost his mother at the age of seven, and was sent to the Orato- riens, at Juilly, where he remained seven years, This education in an ecclesiastical school, away trom his family, did not develop his sensibility ; strangely enough, it prepared him for ineredu- lity. The education at Juilly was classical, and, it might be said, Roman; young Mon- tesquieu wrote at the age of twenty an essay to prove that the ancient philosophers did not de- serve damnation. After his law studies, he was made conseiller of the Parlement of Bordeaux, and married Mile. Jeanne de Lartigue, of Calvinistic origin. M. Sorel tells us that bis wife *t had more candor than beauty, more timidity than charm, more virtue than agrément.” He adds that Par/e- ment and family ** occupied little place in his life; he spoke of both with respect, behaved to- > but that was all. * His activity drew him towards the great in- tellectual curiosity ” (Renan introduced this use of the epithet great, la grande curiosité, la wards both with decency, grande culture). Montesquieu first gave his at- tention toscientific subjects: he studied anatomy. botany, physics—it was the fashion. President de Brosses was also devoted to science. Mon- tesquieu’s excursion in the scientific domain was shorter, but it gave him a method, a certain power of observing and classifying. The tirst object of bis philosophical observ a- tion was French society at the time of the Ke- gency of the Duke of Orleans. He described it in a light form in the ‘ Lettres Persanes’ (in 1721). Two Persians, one gay and critical, the other thoughtful, write letters to their triends in Persia and describe what they seein France. This idea of Persia was borrowed from the work of a celebrated traveller, Chardin. As a novel, the ‘Lettres Persanes’ are a mere pastiche; as a social study, they are stiil worth reading. In one year there were four editions of the ‘ Let- tres Persanes.’ Montesquieu, though he was blamed by many, became amember of the fashionable and lite- rary society of Paris, a friend of Maurepas, of the Chevalier d’Aydie, of the Comte de Caylus, He saw familiarly Mme. de Tencin, Mme. de Lambert, Mme. Du Deffand. He won the good graces of Mme. de Prie, who reigned at Chantilly with the Duc de Bourbon. He never lost his heart to any woman. ‘* The socie- ty of women,” he writes somewhere, ‘‘ spoils our manners and deforms our taste.” He was of a very timid disposition, and he affected not to feel any passion. ‘‘{ was,” he says, ‘‘in my youth happy enough to attach myself to women by whom I[ thought myself beloved ; as soon as I ceased to think so, I left them suddenly.” It is said, however, that he conceived an unhappy passion for Marie Anne de Bourbon, the sister of the Duc de Bourdon, who was called Mile. de Clermont. She had extraordinary beauty. The Due d’Aumale has in his collections a life-size portrait of Mile. de Clermont, by Nattier. She has in it the simple dress of a Naiad, being rep- resented as the deity of the spring of ‘‘ Sylvie,” one of the springs of the Park of Chantilly. Montesquieu composed, in order to please this charming goddess, a little pagan poem, called the ‘Temple de Gnide”—a fastidious poem in prose, artificial, quite unworthy of him, which would ,beentirely forgotten if there had not le edition of it, entirely engraved, with illustrations by Eisen. (This book has I Sary place among the livres @ figures of e eighteenth century.) I confess that I have read the “ Temple de Gnide ” without finding in it ‘the argument in prose of an elegy of André Chénier’s”; that I did not suspect that ‘* Chénier had muchaéad Montesquieu”; and that it never occurred to me that Montesquieu ‘‘ had been touched by the reflection of a ray of light com- ing trom Greece.” After publishing it, Mon- te:quieu presented himself to the French Acade- my. The King, who did not like the ‘ Lettres Per- sanes,’ refused consent to his nomination, under the pretext that he did not live at the capital. Montesquieu sold his office of président a mortier at Bordeaux, and fixed himself in Paris. He was reélected to the French Academy in 1729, and this time admitted. He began soon afterwards along journey in Europe: saw Germany, Austria, Hungary, Po- land, Italy, England; he took notes for the ‘ Esprit des Lois.”. But, while this great work was in preparation, he published the ‘ Considerations on the Causes of the Greatness and Decline of the tomans’ (in 1754), and the ‘Dialogue of Sylia and Eucrates’ (in 1755). The ‘ Considerations’ may be considered a model of what may be called philosophical history. The modern his- torical school somewhat despises this philosophy, believing in facts and documents, and draws no general conclusions: it is, so to speak, positivist— it does not believe in any final causes. Such works as Bossuet’s * Discours sur Vhistvire uni- verselle’ are no longer considered as having any historical value. Montesquieu did not bring to the study of Rome and of the Latin writers the profound knowledge which characterizes a Mommsen ; still, M. Sorel says ‘that, on the whole, the judgments of Montesquieu are just.” He well understood the Roman civilization and the causes of its downfall. Modern historians care little for science, and many of them have ” | (Number 1154 of a Montesquieu. His picture of the world at the time of the Roman conquest, his analysis of the Roman genius, of the causes of the greatness of Rome, cannot be forgotten. These * Considerations’ were an admirable pre- paration for the‘ Esprit des Lois.’ In this great work, Montesquieu undertook to analyze the va- rious forms of government which are found in the history of mankind, to show their advan- tage and defects, to point out their relations with the race, the geography, the religion. Machia- val had done something of this kind in his ‘Prince,’ but nobody before him had treated the problem of the government of men in all its gene- rality. This generality is found in the first sen- tence of the book, which is classical: ‘* The laws, in their most extensive signification, are the ne- cessary relations derived from the nature of things "—a definition so general that it can be applied to scientific as well as to social laws, The analysis of tbe various forms of government, into monarchiceal, oligarchic or aristocratic, and democratic, made by Montesquieu has become classical; the same may be said of his description of the English Government and its balance of powers, I will not dwell on these points, merely insisting a moment on t’e part which Mon- tesquieu left to religion in his study of human so- cieties. His mind was shut on the side of hea- ven; ie was notan idealist. He introduces here and there a phrase on religion, for fear of the censorship and of the Sorbonne; but it is clear that these phrases are purely conventional. He does not formally exclude religion from the va- rious elements which tend to constitute human society, but he gives it a subordinate place, after the army, after the political constitution, after the climate, after the geological nature of the soil, after trade, population, and police. He is tolerant, of course, but bis tolerance is mere indifference; the maximum of it is the Edict of Nantes. He dislikes religious propagan- dism, which he considers a cause of disturbance for the state, and which, in his opinion, ruins paternal authority in the family. His principles are thus summed up: ‘* When you are master of receiving into a state a new religion or of not receiving it, do not allow its establishment; when it is established, tolerate it.” He even goes so far as to show by what means a religion can be destroyed if its destruction is expedient for the state. He does not approve of violence and per- secution, but says: ‘‘Itis safer to attack a reli- gion by favor, by the commodities of life, by the bope of fortune, not by an advertisement, but by what makes it forgotten; not by what excites indignation, but by what cools and calms people —by what excites other passions while the pas- sions excited by religion remain silent. As a gene- ral rule, in matters of a change of religion, invi- tations are stronger than punishment.” With such views, it is not to be wondered at if Montesquieu preferred a state religion, tempered by the indif- ference of many and the unbelief of a select few, as much preferable to the struggle of contending religions. The ‘ Esprit des Lois’ was printed in Geneva in 1748, in two quarto volumes, It bore no name, but everybody knew who the author was. The influence cf this book can hardly be exaggerated. Voltaire was jealous of it; it inspired the men who tried in 1798 to establish a constitutional govern- mentin France; it is to be found in the diplo- matic documents written at various times by Talleyrand; it inspired the works of Mme. de Staél, the ‘Considerations on the French Revo- lution’; it inspired Tocqueville when he wrote his famous book on ‘Democracy in Ameri- ca.’ Sainte-Beuve has at various times criticised the ‘Esprit des Lois’; he has reproached Mon- good reasons for professing such indifference: it | tesquieu with placing humanity too high, with is not given to everybody to have the terse style “ treating it too much like an abstraction, with 2 ih NCA Tp BORED a ere SUR Iain oa ey ata! —— =
Page 13
4 fe ig Aug. 11, 188 S / not making sufticient allowance for the natural depravity of the species. To use the modern phraseology, he considers that Montesquieu is too much of an optimist and not enough of a pessi- mist. Sainte-Beuve was clearly of the same mind as Paul Louis Courier, who said: ‘* Of all the govern ments of men, the best is worth nothing.” In his tory, Sainte-Beuve reproaches Montesquieu with giving too little place to the caprices of chance and to the follies of men ; everything is too sim ple, and goes by rules in the * Esprit des Lois accidents are ignored, and history follows a sort of high road. The criticism is just; ‘* the law of nations ” is still empirical ; the economic laws are hardly yet understood ; constitutional laws are no better than ordinary laws, though they are more difficult to change. With all these restrictions, with all its imper- fections and shortcomings, the ‘ Esprit des Lois’ will nevertheless remain oue of those great monu ments of human thought with which every cul tured mind must become acquainted. After so many political revolutions, it cannot give us the secret of our future, but it can teach us, at any rate, prudence and wisdom, Correspondence. THE ART OF HOUSE FURNISHING. To THE EpiToR OF THE NATION: Sir. Will you allow me to call attention toa significant change in literature ¢ A few years ago all the heroines in novels were in the habit of retiring into their boudoirs, and presumably the rest of the house was in possession of the men Now it is the hero who retreats into his ** den,” and leaves the house actually in possession of the women, I presume we all agree that a woman who re quires a room to pout in, and a man who has to have a place to growl in, are equally uncomforta- ble members of both the family and the com- munity. The pouting woman is evidently a thing of the past, for boudoirs no longer exist. What can we do to abolish dens ¢ Dens will not disap pear either from novels or houses until men are allowed equal rights in the furnishing of our drawing-rooms or parlors. Most rooms are too much cumbered up with bows of ribbons on chairs, and scarfs tied on sofas, and tea-cups on little tables, for a man, if he is more than a carpet knight, to be comfortable in them long. I have a feminine love of ribbons, but Ll think they should adorn women and women’s apartments, and not take possession of the rooms that are intended for the use of both men and women. Give the womanly element to rooms by a table consecrated to flowers and sewing, but don’t make it womanish with too much of what is call ed fancy work. In one thing lam masculine—I detest tidies and scarfs of pongee, and all things that are so lightly attached to the furniture that they persisteutly adhere to one’s clothing. All rooms that are attractive look as if they were oc cupied, aud there should be nothing in them that seriously interferes with comfort. If a room is to be furnished, let it have in it first the things that are required for daily use, and afterwards add the things that society is supposed to demand. The successful furnishing of a room depends quite as much on taste as it does on the length of one’s purse, and of course it cannot be reduced to rule; but there are some faults that may be avoided if attention is called to them. People of moderate means should avoid spend ing too much for chairs and tables. The ey: rarely rests on the table, but it always looks at the things ou the table. Tables are almost al- ways too small for comfort or for beauty. Many ‘The NW atiom. a man’s happiness is wrecked if he bas no corner where he can pile up newspapers; and f some men to be three feet from an inkstand or a dictionary is as trying as to be twelve miles from a lemon. Therefore, have a large table, with writing materials and ampt room for books and papers, and banish the bric-A-brac to shelves above the danger of being swept off by the garments of the passers by. Avoid gilt in wall papers, and velvet and plush in carpets and furniture, if your rooms are small. These are only suited to large houses, and they vulgarizesmall ones. Don'tattempt painted floors with rugs, unless you have plenty of ser vants to keep them in order, and remember that even then they require a multiplicity of the essentials of life to take oif the bare look If possible, compare wall papers and carpets t see how they affect one another, and don’t take it for granted that if they are pretty in themselves they will be pretty together Give rooms that open from one anothet cidedly different tones of color, that the eve may be rested by the change, and not have to look out the detauls of the change. If economy has to be practised, begin by leaving off the borders carpets and the wide frieze from wall papers ; they absorb money that can be used to better advantage elsewhere If you want to beautify a room, use it con stantly, and the things that accumulate because they are wanted will give the room the character that it needs, which will be the reflection of your own.—Very sincerely M. N.S NEW BEDFORD, August 8 SYMPATHY WITH CRIME To THE Epitor oF THE NATION: Sir: There is an unpleasant feature whi characterizes the American daily press, and which is wholly peculiar to it, being found in t respectable papers of no European coumry: ! mean asort of underhand sympathy with cri You shall read a very virtuous leading editoria inavery high-toned paper, being greatly editi thereby. This is written by the editor-in-chief but, as you quickly discover, there is a wicked partner in the concern, and you shall presently tind some small paragraphs detailing criminal news, put into shape by some one whose sympa thies are evidently not with the victims. Ofte: the very slang of the criminal classes is adopt ina manner indicating a charming familiarity therewith This, perhaps, would not be so bad if it Were not for the direct implication, necessa ruy involved, that the reader is also familiar with it and relishes hearing of exploits of ** till tapping “ and *safe-cracking.” One of the | liest of these euphemisms is that which character izes scoundrelly bighwaymen as ** road agents It isa curious proof of the extent to which this sort of thing bas been carried. that even thos among us who have the most rdial contempt for this sneaking sympathy with crime, hav these expressions so constar lus by the daily papers that we unde stand their meaniog wheth Is it not time for all se which make no preten E purg f stuff? Or ’ might bh 1™ f ¥ n process of tit DIVINING-ROD LOGIC To THE Eprtor or THE NaTION: Str: Asa contribution on the above subject, I will state that several years agoanelderly witch- i! j | iting t ‘ Pipes leading ft r i pened tt f water i rod, a he su thev bead 1 ‘ ‘ The | s tix . th? | , amd ia " it the low s Now ts re« feet awa i t WW liv Ww vi i t “ not w Wer s 2 t \ ‘ in i y \ \ \ Notes LD. | \ t by M \ ‘ Ve =fs ty ! Ls ‘ wavs '() \ ee " S 1 Cant : \\ \ . hha . \ Trosthy i NI Mivihs a \I Kit ses S| ‘ \ l l is W ving M s y t \ an ¢ l \ x ( i s ~ \ \ N ( i : 3 N Las ghtv Years rreay a) notes VM i ‘ \ W M 1. \\ t M VW ‘ I > " i i? i ‘ ‘ ha t at i h susti VU bd H White's v \ N will ¢ : Amer s ( i ’ X i gut ¢ I 7 \ \ ts. al \ ag i Mg Mr.c. J. 1 I ‘ ive S 1lius i ihe amusing ‘ i rat by My Wa Besa ind tl t Jaine Rice are to ha hi rs of a librar lit } to the st \ me of w Ready-Mor Mor tiboy, will be prefixed an etched portrait of Mr Rice, and an account of the partnership by the surviving partne! By the middle of next month should appear the first number of the Curio, an illustrated month ly magazine of forty-eight pages quarto, devoted to Biography and Genealogy, Heraldry, Book plates, Rare Books and Prints, Old Furniture
Page 14
112 The Nation. and Plate, etc., etc. Tne editor is Mr. E. DeV. Vermont, and the publisher Mr. R. W. Wright, at 6 Astor Place, New York city. Fiction is to havea place, beginning with Edgar Fawcett. A triple number of the Art Review (New York: Geo. F. Kelly, 59 Carmine St.), to be is sued this month, embraces May, June, and July, and will contain fifteen full-page copper photo- gravures, The Albany Law Journal has published an in- dex-digest of vols. 21-34 inclusive. The Midsummer Puck is even more success- fulin its elaborate color-printing than was its elder, the Christmas Puck, and perhaps the letter-press is also improved. Certainly we re- call nething in the earlier publication as amus- ing and as delicate in its satire as * A Successful Failure,” ‘‘ written for Mr. Frank R. Stockton by H.C. Bunner.” Some of the social drawings are also most humorous. What is meant to be a piece of satirical esprit is put forth by Cassell & Co. with the title ‘The Republic of the Future, or Socialism a Reality,’ by Anna Bowman Dodd. It consists of seven letters from a Swedish nobleman, living in the twenty-first century, who recounts in them his travels among the inhabitants of New York, with the customs and the character of the people as they had been formed under a long-continued socialistic régime. The wonders of machinery play a large part; but most of the volume, which is no more than a brochure, is merely a carrying out intoexample of current notions that Socialism will result in dead levels, the equality of women with men in the State, the subjection of man, and the extinction of the nobler forms of love, and like propositions. These prophecies of the ruin to be wrought by “Socialism,” one may observe, are identical with those which for many years were made concerning ** Democracy.” The mechanism and the phrases show a later date, but essentially the book belongs to a past age. The latest issue in Mr. Wheatley’s ‘** Book- Lover’s Library ” (George J. Coombes) is a cu- rious collectanea about the herbs, fruits and flowers, and the ornamental trees of England, under the title ‘Gleanings in Old Garden Lite- rature,’ from the pen of W. Carew Hazlitt, whose ‘Old Cookery Books,’ in this same series, we have already had occasion to commend. For those who unite the tastes for gardening and for literature, this volume will be treasure-trove ; and, in fact, as a kind of history of the cultiva- tion of vegetables, the changes and ever-increas- ing variety of diet, with the views afforded of the tables of our forefathers, the volume serves to gather and compress a considerable amount of out-of-the-way information. On the orna- mental side, one gets notices of famous gardens and some landscape gardeners ; of the different fashions of the times, the arbors, the mazes, and the fruit-walls ; and, throughout, the literary quality is never suffered to give way to a scien- tific or encyclopedic or historical method mere- ly. The old books on gardening are catalogued, and some extracts are given ; perhaps Bacon is allowed more than his due share of literary quo- tations. At the end there are a dozen or fifteen pages containing ‘‘ A Short Account of Several Gardens near London, with Remarks on Some Particulars wherein they Excel or are Deficient, upon a View of Then in December, 16@$,” from an unpublished MS. by Gibson. We have found the volume one of the most entertaining of this very charming series. It should be added that its text hardly touches upon the present cen- tury, but is es-entially antiquarian in subject- matter, Mr. Thomas J. Morgan, Principal of the Rhode Island State Normal School, has collected in ‘Educational Mosaics’ (Boston; Silver, Rogers & Co.) passages from more or less famous writ- [ Number 1154 ers upon the choice of studies, theories of in- struction, and similar matters, together with a sprinkling of maxims and reflections kindred to the subject. There is no marked scheme or or- der in the arrangement of the extracts, which for the most part are from contemporary books, and represent the average ability and judgment of men who speak and write on the topic of edu- cation. The scales are kept even between the classics and the sciences, both of which are praised and discredited in turn; the elective sys- tem receives the same impartial treatment ; the kindergarten, the trade-school, ete., are included with their older associates. Altogether, a ca- tholic discretion has been exercised, and the vo- lume may be described as a handy one to quote from for persons with poor memories and insuffi- cient reading of their own. We have received the second volume of Trans- actions and Reports of the Nebraska State His- torical Society. Indian warfare and the contest over slavery are the subjects to which most space has been devoted; but many others, both of local and national importance, are treated. Several scarce county histories are reprinted, and there are the usual biographical notices. It is perhaps not too late to mention a tasteful volume entitled ‘ Historical Sketch of the South Church (Reformed) of New York City’ (A. D, F, Randolph & Co.), This church is the lineal descendant of that first set up by the Dutchin the Battery Fort in 1642. Its migrations in conse- quence of the growth of the city are illustrated by pictures of the several edifices from the be- ginning; and as these offer a curious study in architectural] development, so the portraits of the pastors are interesting as successive types of clerical aspect. The little book belongs to the general history of New York. The second annual issue of ‘ Poor’s Directory of Railway Officials’ (H. V. & H. W. Poor) shows a marked enlargement, the street-railroad system being now included; and the work is more than ever the best conspectus of the per- sonnel of the great interest in question, Froim the list on page 571 it appears that twenty-nine States and Territories are now provided with railroad commissioners. Foreign railways on this continent south of the United States are de- scribed on pages 317-335. Bridge builders, car and rail manufacturers, and contractors come within fhe scope of this Directory. We should hardly take so pessimistic a view of the race as ‘‘The world is chiefly filled up with sick folk,” which we find to be the starting-point of Dr. Hanchett’s ‘ Modern Domestic Medicine’ (C. T. Hurlburt), and seems to be the excuse for that volume, and for its smaller ‘Companion,’ which is devoted to subjects not suitable for treatment in a family book. In his effort to be useful the author sets forth much excellent ad- vice, but with it are some odd opinions, such as tnat woollea should never be worn next the skin until after the prime of life (p. 24), and that thousands have been killed directly or indirectly by overdosing with quinine (p. 241). The gene- ral tenets are those of the homceopathists. An anonymous medical book for popular read- ing is doubly suspicious, but, as an exception to the rule, a cheap although well-printed little work on * Accidents and Poisons, their Remedies and Antidotes,’ published by Rand, McNally & Co., Chicago, is excellent. Truly, when an emergency happens, there is little time to consult books, but those fond of this style of literature will find themselves forearmed if they study its warning when there is time. Nearly a third of the book is occupied with general hygiene, and all its teaching 1s sound, There is comparatively little new information given in the extracts from Emin Pasha’s Dia- ries published in the July Fortnightly Review, | but they are full of bright and picturesque de- scriptions of the country and people with whom he is placed, together with, at times, detailed accounts of important events. When first summoned to surrender by the Mahdi’s lieu- tenant after the capture of Lupton Bey, he called a public meeting of his officials and laid the matter before them. Unanimously they voted to surrender, but Emin, though ostensibly yielding to their wishes, succeeded in maintain- ing his position. He is very confident that, so far asthe upper Nile provinces are concerned, the Mahdi revolt was fomenied only by and in the interest of the slave-dealers. There are many touching allusions to his deserted condition; and yet, when about to start on ene of bis tours of inspection, he is as joyful *‘ asa schoolboy begin- ning his holidays.” The singular modesty of the man is shown in the ardent wish that he might meet Dr. Junker again. ‘‘ How thankfully,” he continues, ‘‘ would I have learnt from him out of the stores of his experience!” Very natural too is the passage in which he describes his first im- pulse on reaching a river, the Welle, whose waters flowed west, ‘‘ to plunge into its roaring waters and be borne by them to the west.” The diary closes with an entry dated January 12, 1885, his period of greatest despondency, and yet he does not give up hope: ‘* I have some belief in my good star.” The extracts are introduced by a short introduction by Miss Felkin, to whom they were sent, as letters. From samples that have already appeared we should expect much entertainment and_ solid scientific instruction from ‘ Ergebnisse naturwis- senschaftlicher Forschungen auf Ceylon in den Jabren 188486,’ by Drs. Paul and Fritz Sarasin (Wiesbaden: C. W. Kreidel; New York: Chris- tern.) The work will appear in four volumes, the first two being occupied with the zodlogy, the third with the anthropology, and the fourth with a general description of the island, con- cerning which the authors’ explorations were so extensive that they venture to believe they have something new to tell, These three divisions -an be subscribed for separately. There will be numerous plates. In place of a Society for Mutual Autopsy like that established by eminent men of science and of letters in Paris in 1876, Milan has an Institu- zione Loria, which undertakes an autopsy for any physician or private family that desires it. The complaint is made that, for the study of the brain, too much neglect has been shown in fur- nishing a life-history of the subjects examined by this institution. The Perseveranza for July 2 reprints the constitution of the Paris society above named. Calmann Lévy announces for immediate publi- cation a work by Prince Napoleon, of which the title is ‘ Napoleon et ses détracteurs.’ M. Noél Valois has reprinted in a pamphlet of forty-two pages a paper first published in the Annuaire- Bulletin of the Société de PHistoire de France, concerning the ‘ Privilége de Chalo- Saint-Mard.’ This total exemption from all im- posts enjoyed by the descendants of Eudes-le- Maire, called Chalo-Saint-Mard, went back, it was pretended, to 1191. M. Valois shows how the treasury and administration of the realm were the victims of a successful imposition in the mat- ter from the time of Philippe VI. to that of Louis XV. Forthose who enjoy the skilful disentangle- ment of obscure historical complications, the pam- phlet of M. Valois will be full of interest. M. Léopold Delisle has republished from the Gazette Archéologique an important notice upon the ‘ Exemplaires royaux et princiers du Miroir historial’ (Paris: A. Lévy). The vast compila- tion of universal history known under this name is the translation into Freuch of the famous ‘Speculum Historiale’ of Vincent de Beauvais, Ce a ee
Page 15
Aug. 11, 1887] made by Jean du Vignay at the command of Jeanne of Burgundy, the first wife of Philip of Valois, King of France. M. Delisle proves t the translation was made in 1552 and Pion & Nourrit have published * Les So phistes allemands et les Nibilistes russes.” by Th Funck-Brentano, professor at the Ecole Libr: This house had already issued, in a similar Svo volume by the sam author, ‘ Les Sophistes grecs et les Sophistes con des Sciences Politique Ss. temporains. They have just published an ISmo edition of ‘Le Marquis de Grignan, petit-fils de Mme. de Sévigné,’) by M. Frédéric Masson which appeared in the Svo form in 188] 1 Hachette likewise has published an 18m edition of Caro’s ‘ Problémes de morale sociale,’ which first appeared in 1876; and Perrin, in the same convenient form, * Henriette-Anne d’An gleterre, duchesse dOrléans: Sa vie et sa corres pondance avec son frére, Charles IL.’ by the Comte de Baillon. The first edition, Svo, appeared in 1885. The 1Smo editions of the same author's ‘ Henriette-Marie de France, reine d’ Angleterre,’ and of his ‘ Lettres in¢dites de Henriette-Marie de France,’ were published several years a In aid of the Academy at Ashfield, Mass., a fair is to be held on August 4, 25, at which will be sold the 1884 one-volume Macinillan edition of Tennyson, the 1881 volume of Selections from
Browning, the two-volume Matthew Arnold of ISS1, and the two-volume Riverside Aldine edi All these ex cept the last have been specially and hand-some tion of Lowell’s ‘ Biglow Papers.’ ly bound in morocco; each contains the auto graph of the respective poet ; and all except the Tennyson have, besides, a verse of the author’s in his own hand. It is proposed to open these vy lumes to competitive offers by mail, whi should be addressed to A. D. Flower, Ashtield ——We subjoin an extract from a letter of Di Caspar Rene Gregory, dated Leipzig, Ju “*T have been asked to prepare a course of tures upon ‘Religion in America. or *Churet History 19 the United States of America, and |
hope in the course of a year or two todos \ difficulty arises in the want of books. The library here, as well as the libraries in the other univers ties, have been and are more « pied with Con tinental questions, and their siender resources do vot permit them to keep up with tl Ger man books. They could not make extensiv: purchases in this American line. The questior has arisen whether, just as 1, asan Atmerican, wish to put America duly on record here, so other Americans will not wish to put their literature, the material for the history of their religious o1 ganizations, 1n a foreign iibrary where it will b appreciated, and where it will be at the servi every German professor who desires to approact these questions. The German university libraries send their books aboutat need, and Leipzig atfords a good centre for massing this American litera ture. Evenif I should not succeed in carrving out my plan, which of cour-e would culminat in a text-book for Awerican church | collection of vooks here would be ready another worker. I may add that I have ready given the lhbrary all of my wl books which I could spare. Personally, | should be indebted to any one who w give me a note of books for the earlier hteratt But where churches or men could send the books and the pamphlets pertaining t) their s} ’ societies, they would do a service. Everything historical, statistical, doctrinal, : would be wished for, from reports to single s
mons. Many such pamphlets are desti America because of the room they take uy oO course church newspapers in sets would be ] cular value.” We are requested to add that the documents specitied above may be sent to Dr. Gregory, at Leipzig, Liebigstrasse 9, iv,1; or Prof. Jos Henry Thayer of Cambridge, Mass., will g take charge of and forward avy books phlets intrusted to him for Dr. Gregory —The Midsummer Cent has for i's leader a decorative article, of which the illustrations are taken from the scenes of a Jersey cana Th tex s ist in tl half-fa ur, half-B milan st of wt s prominent art t ks set the example in the last holiday season, t Ss not stvle wl bears repetit wit SI ss. and is hard worth cultivating t i ew writer Tl s display sor clever i nag nt of tl spaces, but in tt effect scarcely equal Mr. F. Hopkinson Smith's al sketches, and they do not deceive us into think ing that we possess a true corner of Holla The Nat iON
Jer Joel Chandler Harris begins a thre part story, ** Azalia The principal ta paper is Geu. Joseph E. Johnston i ! Creorgia campa { I Ss ! i wl he makes some ral ret! . Jet? Davis, places the wl responsit y for his ow re val on the civ iuthorities, and isserts that if or tl ther Lieutenant-G rals his army instead Hood bad su eadend | ( mand Atlanta w 1 hav n held | the Army of Ten set rt i s rest for the illustration it giv f Davis i racter, and of divisions in the Souther The rest the body the number is tak with the Lu n t raphy a Mr Atk son's charts t Wages, protits tf Phe Lincoln biography i st rat int i vander! narratl at t : ! things, not pa ind ny s to be a history f the times, and 1 necting pers na —ely a \ t vents noted t t nteres vt i It is a success f half-u stood episo The tigur f I 1 s dwarfed by tl l i adopted, and ey nsuch a crit 1 t s life as was the Douglas debates, . ‘ mmanding 1 nent of nt s > Was ft spread { his I t s have t had iby t cart sult t witl sad ver t ing theret l “ ‘ t . y of t historian who knows “ y ré I ‘ is sf s a cal iss i t \ I s t r words wer i t nthe wl Nes a t S cv OL! ra sa : ? at Vv watts fortl g ’ tier Ww . ill it cal " 1 fi vork M Atk nf arrivy Wis i 1 . - . t yoma uest ast is i V s yy . Te ~ } \ > ] tal aptitudes as x! ‘ yt two sexes \ “ o “ ‘ “d thes Ter sa ie t -S i i t t t t \ t ar uy { I " : t : s knowledg \ ~ = “1V “ zard tot sira , perpet g¢ some of hese tT s:s we i serv rut t . 4 iuses WI I Ke W Ww at ti i 1 att led y t t s al 1uses ; [ t is certainly not t to sav that ¢t ~ s hav sually com- tei t ra iT igainst science f — — ‘- w~
sw \ ~ 4 il | ~ “ i isn Meos is x i! ‘ ( \ s i : \ 1 ( ( ~ ‘ . . ( i I ( Sha ’ s \ : " ‘ \\ I N ( } } ~ i i " i v kK \ Vox \ t ss ~ ‘ ‘ t on “ ty Wks yr t i ( i t 1\ the . eet i t {™ i Th ! Britons iv s 1 t «@ ! trv is sider ‘ slike ¢ ( t crandfa De Witt ¢ W ( gt (y al i l i i (‘adwaliader ¢ I nant-Grovernol f N 1) Y , n t te i at s r { bbett lik Arthur H { NM v amie very irteing ar \ i ~f Mr. Ste en + +3 ™ ] , "? , Writes of this yp ‘ i general Judgment in- «i tothat w bh he quotes from Lowell re carding him Phick as «hops are the acta rals wl i avs with that rank, however aid us professional visits in the Revolutionary War or in that [ Sl2-—Cochrane Cockburn the ed Washington), Codrington, Collier Collingwood. We may add Admiral Coffin, a Boston boy, who entered the navy on the eve of the Revolution. Sir Henry Clinton is also found in this volume, and so is Sir A. Cockburn, of the i/ahama Claims Commission, he July number of Les Lettres et les Arts Chas. Scribner’s Sons), like all the numbers of this rerue, has a special character of its own. This time the prevailing tone is that of remi niscence. M. Désiré Nisard of the French Acade my gives three extracts from bis mémoires um édits, under the general title ** A2gri Sommia.” In
” = * pe a |
Page 16
1i4. the second of these he compares the impression made upon Alfred de Vigny by Royer-Collard, in the visit he made to him as candidate for a va- cant chair in the Academy, when the old philoso- pher and statesman wounded the vanity of the younger writer so deeply by his celebrated reply: **A mon Age je ne lis plus, je relis,” with that which he received himself in a similar visit, when the old man did him the honor to talk of his own life and not of bis visitor’s writings. A delicate and charming portrait of M. Nisard, by E. Abot, and a reproduction of one of Royer-Collard, in the costume of the incroyables of bis earlier life, illustrate this portion of the article and add to its value. Comte Armand de Pontmartin, who has also reached the age when everything is tinged with recollections of the past, gives a little sketch which hovers between fiction and reality: ** La véritable auberge des Adrets.” Baron d’Estour- nelles de Constant recalls ‘* Un promenade autour de Tunis avant les embellissemeuts du Protecto- rat.” M. Maurice Tourneux, with his usual con- eiseness and clearness, and with that perfection in the selection and arrangement of materials with which he is gifted, has made of the long and serious article, ‘La Fédération du 14 Juillet 1790,” not only the most important, but also the most interesting, paper of the number. Among the numerous documents of the period of which M. Tourneux makes use, is a certain ‘‘ Avis aux confédérés,” by a most unexpected patriot and moralist, the famous, or ill-famed, Restif de la Bretonne. This pamphlet of the moment, of which the general good sense is as applicable to the present time as it was to the days of univer- sal peace and good-will a hundred yearsago when it appeared, M. Tourneux calls, with justice, one of the most curious pages of * fooeuvre informe et parfois prodigieuse” of its author, He also speaks of if as not mentioned by any of the re- cent biographers of Restif. There is a eharming little poem, by M. Armand Silvestre, ** Florai- son”; and M Pierre d’Igny, in his serial, takes his young countess to London in June. The brilliant article of the number, however, is * 1 Archipel,” by M, Gaston Bergeret, in which this charming writer relates, with the delicacy and grace of his always subdued sarcasm, the conquest, the pacification, and the organization of a colony in the Indian Ocean. All that relates to the Governor of the islands and to the com- missaire général who supplanted him, and espe cially to the delighttul savage tribes, the Nia- zous, is exquisitely indicated, with the lightest of touches. The only exaggeration is in the really eharming Miss Dolly simpson, the daughter of the English missionary; but she is caricatured with such delicacy, there 1s such an exquisite vagueness about the real meaning of her not too idiomatic French, that it all passes without oppo- sition, and the final situation is so supremely co mic that the reader turns the last page mm the most complete good understanding with the author, and gratitude to him fora half hour spent with such cheerful gayety. It is evident from the onslaught made on Prof. Friedrich Delitzsch, in the London Acade- myoft July 25,10 a review of the first fascicle of his ‘Assyrian Dictionary,’ that his recent veer- ing around on what Orientalists call the Sumero- Accadian question bas keenly nettled some of the orthodox students of the so-called pro-Cnaldean, or pro-Semitic, cuneiform literary remains. We can imagine what the feelings of Francois Lenor- mant, author of the ‘Etudes Accadiennes’ and ‘La Langue Primitive de la Chaldée,’ would be if he had lived to see the most brilliant and most diligent Assyriologist of Germany deserting the camp of the Sumero-Accadists, and reinforcing the hitherto almost solitary post of the French- man’s Parisian opponent, the “ anti-Accadist,” The Nation. Joseph Halévy. And we are anxious to see what the impetuous Fritz Hommel, who, in his * Die Semitischen Véiker und Sprachen,’ has poured out so much presumptuous learning and hair- splitting ingenuity on the ** vorsemitische Kul- tur” of Babylonia, will have to say on this unto- ward turn in the Leipzig professor’s Assyriologi cal evolution. The story of this turn, gradually foreshadowed in various recent contributions to Assyriclogy, and now almost completed, is told in a very interesting way by Prof. Lyon of Cam- bridge in an extensive notice of the ‘ Assyrian Dictionary,’ read before the American Oriental Society at its meeting in Boston in May last, and just published in its Journal, Some two years ago Delitzsch, after some guarded advances in the new direction, seized an opportunity ** to re- cognize openly,” as he wrote, ‘‘the high services of Halévy relating to the Sumero-Accadian question, above ali to the question as to the exist- ence of original’ Sumero-Accadian texts.” It seemed to him ** necessary to test anew, unbiassed in all details, this fundamentally important ‘ tra- dition’ which has been delivered to us younger As- syriologists.”. Numerous remarks of the Diction- ary show that, after doing a great deal of fresh testing, he is only one step removed from Halé- vy’s tenet that the civilization of Mesopotamia was from its beginning distinctively Semitic —not borrowed, with its cuneiform system of writing, from a primitive race, Turanian or other, which preceded the Chaldeans; and that what was held by the Sumero-Accadists to be pro-Semitic lite- rary remains, is only a hieratic way of writing Assyrian, It is needless to add that by the new accession Halévy’s view, though considerably strengthened, is tar from having become victo- rious, and tnat the old contest will only wax hot-
| Number 1154
ter. What is clearly shown is how shaky the | ground is still on which the lofty Assyriological constructions of our time are being reared, and how much Delitzsch himself will have to revise and correct of what be has already announced as discovered and proved. COLVIN’S KEATS. Keats. By Sidney Colvin. [English Men of Let- ters Series.] Harper & Bros, 1887. THE circumstances and general character of the life of Keats are already well known; the criti- cism of bis works and of bis temperament is abun- dant; little more remained for Mr. Colvin to do than to set down the result in a brief continuous narrative and to barmonize the features of the portrait. But each new writer brings something of his own, and in the case of one so tndividual- ized, so refined, and so self-confident as Mr. Col- vin, this personal element in the work is bound to be very prominent. It first shows itself ina contemptuous reference to Leigh Hunt, and this tone of half-mocking, half-patronizing deprecia- tion of that ‘writer of amiable memory and second-rate powers” is maintained throughout. it is much easier, no doubt, to tolerate Hunt's faults than to admit bis merits, and to a later day the literary fashion of his cloth offers marks for ridicule, as is usual with fasbions of all kinds once they are out of date; but be was the ‘man of taste” of bis time, just as Mr. Colvin is of ours; one cannot help perceiving the points of resem- blance 1n the literary type, though of course Mr. Colvin’s taste is far purer, bigher, and more ex- acting, in proportion as the culture of the time it is developed out of is richer and finer than that of the late Georgian age. This similarity, not between their characters and talents, but in their literary habit, points in certain ways the revolu- tions of ‘‘taste.” There is a-strain in Leigh Hunt, and in others besides Keats among his as- sociates, of weakness, almost of pulpiness, which
all the world is ready enough to condemn now. Thus, Mr. Colvin remarks of Hunt’s * Rimini” that it has some *‘ agreeable passages,” but ‘‘ for the rest the pleasant creature does but exagge- rate in this poem the chief foible of his prose, redoubling his vivacious airs where they are least in place, and handling the great passions of the theme with a tea-party manner and vocabu- lary that are intolerable.” <A little later he goes on: ‘In matters of poetic feeling and fancy Keats and Hunt bad not a little in common; both alike were given to ‘ luxuriating’ somewhat effu- sively and fondly over the ‘deliciousness’ of whatever they liked in art, books, or nature.” This is true, certainly, and hits off by emphasis the initial weakness of Keats, though it is some- what too subtle a stroke to condemn it in Hunt rather thap in the hero of the biography; and in the midst of the satiric and belittling sentences one remembers that ** luxuriating over delicious- ness” not unaptly describes the style of the ws- thetic school now reigning about Oxford, and that in certain art criticisms Mr. Colvin himself is not altogether guiltless of it. Mr. Lowell went out of his way to say a good word for Hunt not long ago. Apart from his patriotic services and his books, not yet altogether dead, he had the distinction of pleasing through a long life an ex- traordinary variety of men of genius, and of be- ing kindly regarded by them, from Shelley to Carlyle; and a biographer of Keats, whom he befriended, might fithy have spared the ridicule of him which is perhaps the most marked thing in this volume and the most inexcusable. To come to Keats, the poetical legend about him is now fairly dissipated. He was not the bard killed by tbe reviewer. He was an English boy of the middle class, with much physical pug- nacity and warm friendliness, and with courage and self-respect enough to make him ready to fignt his way and take his fate. He was tho- roughly ambitious, thoroughly sensitive, and he felt the weight of hostile criticism probably more than he confessed, and be seems to have sbrunk into himself from the coldness of public indiffer- ence to bis first works ; but he had no thought of dying from the “article.” Hereditary consump tion seized him and killed him. A second part of the legend about him is less easily destroyed, but it is now fairly on the way to extinction—name- ly, the characterization of him as a sensuous poet without ideas. He had strong senses, of course ; but he had also a growing mind, and was getting hold of the realities of thought and life with a strength and a width of vision in which alone is there any excuse for calling him, as Mr. Colvin does, ‘‘Shaksperian.” There is little justice in the adjective, and it belongs to him only poten- tially, if at all; but in the thoughts of his letters there is often a maturity as marvellous as their felicity of phrase, and in ‘SHyperion” and in some of the odes there 1s more than the promise of intellectual power, His sense of style and his feeling for the color of words, together with his physical sensibility, count for much; but hisclear and shining imagination, and that intellectual fire which is the centre of great poetry, were the prophecy of his immortality even then. No large portion of bis verse is of the first order, but that third of 1t which really constitutes his fame, and is in its realm unique and perfect, gives, on ana- lysis, imagination and thought as its constituent elements, equally with sensuousness of remark- able purity. Acquaintance and study only deep- en the impression—which Mr. Colvin states, though he does not argue for it with anything like the total strength of his case—that in Keats English literature lost a poet of the life of man rather than of the shows of things. The growth and tendency of bis mind and the bending of his con- scious aim towards that issue are clear ; whether the creative vision and the executive skill would
ke aston ents LAA RACES
Page 17
Aug. 11, 1887] have been his in the grand proportion necessary for a great poet in that sphere, is hardly more than matter of speculation. But as it is a gain to character to know that he was not ‘snuffed out” by Lockhart, it is a still greater gain to find in him not the puerile idol of a sentimental sen suality, but a manly, natural fellow, in whom truth as well as beauty was a passion, and wt was inspired poet enough te put man at the cen tre of all things. Mr. Colvin, as has been said, presents this view of him, though he might have supported it better than he does. In point of the character to be ascribed to Keats, no one would find this biogra phy lacking in essentials. He adopts, however too broadly the theory of Arnold that Keats in his love was “ passion’s slave.” One feels that Mr. Arnoid objected to that less becanse of the fact, than because in his love-letters Keats ex pressed himself in what that eminent respectabi lity considers an ‘‘underbred” way. The subject with all its iimiting and mitigating circum stances, need not detain us. In the criticism of Keats’s works Mr. Colvin is less fortunate. Of general and illuminating criticism there is none atall. What there is is of the minute kind, as, for example, the fault he finds in the ‘* Ode toa Nightingale”: ** By a breach of Jogie which is also, | think, a flaw in’ the poetry, be con teasts the transitoriness of buman life, meaning the hfe of the imdividual, with the permanence the song-bird’s life, meaning the life of a typ. This is just one of those plausible criticism which are inapplicable beeause the magic of th poem keeps it outside of the mind while the poem is being read; and thatis not really a fault in a poem which cannot be felt as a fault when it is being read. So, too, in the criticism with regard to the town that will be for ever *‘ emptied of its tolky which readers will remember is one of the most charming passages of the ** Ode on a Grecian Urn *—* In these lines there seems a dissonance inastipuch as they speak of the arrest of lite as though it were an infliction in the sphere of real ty, and not merely, like the instances of such arrest - given further back, a necessary condition in the sphere of art, having in that sphere its own com pensations”™ ; this is irrefragable, but it amounts to nothing. In other cases, as where he says “Neither is Milton a match for Keats in wor] like this: Throughout all the iste There was no covert, no retired cave Unhaunted by the murmurous noise of war Though searcely heara in mat rr or where he condemns the lips that * poesied with hers in dewy rhyme as ‘tan effusively false touch in the sugared tast not infrequent in his earliest verses’ r wher he cites the fine lines, ‘Only the dreamer venoms all his days Bearing more woe than all his sins desert as ‘‘acry of the spirit vanquished by the flesh in all such cases we can only put a note of ex clamation in the margin. The whole treat of the works is too piecemeal and over-refined the criticism lacks body, mass, comprehens and is always pottering about the superticies the poetry, the minor touches, the tipish, the cidents of its imagery and movement, to tl lect of its substance. On the whole, we are constrained to think that bad as Leigh Hunt’s poetry was at its worst, be was a better poetical critic than even Mr. Coly The iatter’s work in this branch of bis subject | no means takes the | ace of the studies of others one feels lacun® in it every where Phe nnets for example, are as inadequately represented the total criticism as the wonderfully in the biography itself. In the way criticism, one point is mack rainst Mr. G which is worth mention Th itter has Nation.
Page 18
116 Nation. ‘Lhe { Number 1154 tended cruises of the great commerce-destroy- ers. In other fields of professional duty must be mentioned the work done at Richmond by Brooke, the creator of the naval ordnance of the Confederacy, and in England by Bulloch, the agent through whose consummate tact and stead- fastness of purpose the Alabama, the Florida, the Shenandoah, and the Georgia were fitted out as Confederate cruisers. In writing a book upon this great and attrac- tive subject, Mr. Schar? has been fortunate in having an absolutely unoccupied field. Having been himself one of the pupils of the Naval Aca demy at Richmond, and having borne a credita- ble part in some of the famous exploits of bis service, he has exceptional advantages for his task of authorship. He has shown evident dili gence in accumulating materials, and his book includes a valuable collection of mémoires pour servir. A more careful revision would have saved him from many little inaccuracies in names and dates, and from occasional lapses in the use of his motker tongue, In many chapters his materiais have been loosely thrown together, with little regard to style or to structural arrange- ment. In these respects the book is seriously de- fective. The most extraordinary feature, however, of Mr. Scharf’s otherwise useful book is the undercur- rent of political animosity and bitterness which penetrates all his references to the causes of the war and the conduct and motives of the Union leaders. In holding that secession was a consti- tutional right, he only expresses the sincere con- viction of the majority of Southern men before the war; but he goes far beyoud this, and appears to think that no other view was possible to men of sincerity and average intelligence. Indeed, it is not quite clear that be regards the war as having done anything towards a settlement of the question. ‘‘ Whether the theory of a national or a compact government,” be says in his open- ing sentences, ‘‘ be the true theory of the Constitu- tion, pow and hereafter, it is not necessary to discuss,’ which would seem to indicate that the question is still open for discussion, The condi- tion of affairs at the beginning of the war is ex- plained by the statement that ‘tin 1861 events had presented to the States that most unexpected result—the soldiers and sailors, educated by the ‘ederal Government in its character as agent of the States, were called on by that agent to fight against its principal—by the servant to make war on the master, by the creature to destroy the creator.” Starting with this ‘‘ anomalous condition of the relations of the States tothe Federal Union,” as Mr. Scharf correctly designates it, the reader will not be surprised to learn that the war was a bloody work of repression, perfidiously under- taken by a tyrannical government, in the in- terests of a political party, and that the lead ers in the secession movement were the inno- cent victims of a trick perpetrated by Mr. Lin- coln's Cabinet. This opinion recurs again and again, and its manner of presentation is more remarkable for the author’s tone of unquestioned authority, and for a certain gran- deur of diction, than for cogency of reasoning. A fety passages will suffice to illustrate. Thus on D.. 20's ‘* The recital of these facts, as they existed at the South in 1861, establishes beyond controversy that no preparation for war had been made by any Southern State prior to secession ; that not one of the States desired war ; that there ought not to have been war, and that there would not have been war except to ‘save the Republican party from rupture.’ The facts of the times and the acts of men cannot be covered up from the search and exposure of the historian, who, when he comes to write the causes of the terrible war of 1861-65, must discover and expose those who, to secure themselyes in the possession of political place, deliberately played with the excited passions of the hour to involve the country in war, and dissoive the Union, so that its reconquest would perpetuate their party as- cendency, or that che loss of the Southern States would deprive their political opponents of the great bulk of their strength, and thus secure for themselves the possession of power in either the reconstructed Union or in the divided and dis- membered northern part.” Here is another passage: “Mr. Lincoln and his advisers bad outwitted and overreached all the precautions of peace taken at the South, and, by deftly and cunning- ly drawing the fire of the Charleston batteries, had inaugurated war. The latent spirit of devo- tion to the Union, which the echoes of the guns at Charleston aroused into such terrible force and proportion, stopped not to consider the trick by which the war had been begun. = It only saw the flag of the Union in the smoke of battle, and, whether right or wrong, rushed 1o its defence. But neither that expres- sion of loyalty to the Union, nor the extraordi- narv efforts in its defence, nor the triumphs of its army and navy, will be able to cover up and con- ceal from the reprehension of history the shame- ful subterfuge of provisioning Sumter as a start to war; but history will separate the glory of the people’s defence from the shame of the politician’s trick.” In regard to the Southern officers who resigned from the old navy, every candid student of his- tory is ready to acknowledge that, during the trying period that preceded their resignation, they discharged their duties with scrupulous fide- lity. It is, therefore, hardly necessary to give this lucid explanation of their conduct: ‘They did not presume to take upon them- selves the duty of dividing the navy among the States, notwithstanding it was the common property of all the States. In the excitement of the times, it would bave been pardonable con- duct to have brought their ships to the defence of the States; but their sense of honor, and a snilor’s duty to the government whose commis- sion he bore, required that he should divest bim- self of every selfish motive before he returned his commission to the Federal Government.” The author’s comments upon persons and events are what might be expected from the general statement of his views. The hotel-keeper who killed Ellsworth at Alexandria is a_ hero. ** Among all the acts of personal bravery during the war,” says Mr. Scharf, ‘‘not one exceeds in heroism that total indifference to personal safety which inspired the noble Jackson to brave in his single person a whole regiment of the enemy.” Farragut is an ‘ apostate,” who turns *‘at the prompting of self-interest against the people among whom he was born”; and his dif- ferences with the Navy Department in the last year of his life lead the author to moralize in this pathetic fashion: ‘It is the old story—they loved the treason, and they rewarded with honors and prize-money the exploits of the apostate son of the South, but they never took him wholly and sirgly to tbeir hearts.” If, as Mr. Scharf states, it was ** petty malice” that led the Secretary of the Navy in the heat of civil war to designate the Southern naval officers as deserters, what shall be said of an author who, twenty years after the war is over, has the presumption to say that the great Admiral was induced by the ** prompting of self interest ” to stand by the dag and the Union, and that his countrymen ‘never took him wholly and singly to their hearts”? It would be a waste of time to dwell upon the preposterous absurdities of this kind with which Mr. Scharf has seen fit to mar his history. He exhausts the language of petulance in his criti- cisms of Mr. Seward and Mr. Welles. The cli- max of childishness is reached in a delightfully funny passage on page 428, in which the Secre- tary of State is charged with having ‘*dirtied the pages of American diplomacy ” by an indeli- cate allusion : ‘The euphemism by which, when a bousehold is gladdened by the birth of a babe, the conva- lescence of the mother is described in technical and courtly phrase, ‘that the mother is getting on as well as could be expected,’ was introduced by Mr. Seward in a despatch to Mr. Adams, as, ‘The work of pacification in the region concerned is going on as successfully as could be expected. You hear of occasional guerilla raids, but these are the after-pangs of revolution in that quarter which has proved an abortion.’” Mr. Scharf is hardly fair in lashing Mr. Sew- ard so unmercifully for a metaphor which he does not hesitate to use himself, On p. 725 he speaks of ‘the prevailing ambition that the bosom of the James should bear ironclad ships over which the Confederate ensign should float,” and he adds: ‘* This pregnant desire gave birth to the Hich- mond.” Indelicacy isa very grave fault, but it is well with this, as with other offences, for some one who is witbout sin to do the stone-throwing. If Mr. Scharf, as he declares in his preface, is attempting to vindicate ‘‘ the political views of Confederate officers,” he has shot very wide of the mark; for it may be doubted whether there are many of hiscompanions in arms who would subscribe to his extravagances. Capt. Bulloch, whodid more than any other naval officer to sus- tain the Confederacy during its four years’ strug- gle, and who may fairly be considered a repre- sentative man of his class, says, in a work every page of which excites admiration by its dignity, its clear insight, its breadth of view, and its moderation: ‘*The South has accepted the result of the war; business and social relations are again inter- mingling the people of the two sections on terms of friendship and intimacy, and the great ma- jority on both sides can now recur to the events of the war, and discuss them as historical inci- dents, and not as subjects for strife and recrimi- nation.” In his address in New York oun the last 4th of July, Gov. Lee declared, with just pride, that ** Virginia was not sulking in a corner.” It is charitable to hope that sooner or later the his- torian of the Confederate Navy will emuiate Virginia’s noble example, and fall into line with Capt. Bulloch and his ‘* great majority.” RECENT PSYCHICAL RESEARCH. Preliminary Report of the Commission ap- pointed by the University of Pennsylvania to Investigate Modern Spiritualism, in accord- ance with the Request of the late Henry Sey- bert. Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott Co. 1887. 8vo, pp. 159. Proceedings of the [English] Society for Psyehi- cal Research. Part XI. May, 1887. London: Triibner & Co. THE first report of the Seybert Commission has been awaited with interest, but 1t is certainly somewhat disappointing. To be sure, the only disappointment that we here can testify to has little to do with the merely negative character of the results so far reached by the Committee. Incommon with most people who give themselves over to the modern spirit and like to trust its in- stincts, we, of course, have expected no positive results of any very serious importance, But then it has seemed to us that the Seybert Committee has a work to dothat must go far beyond mere spe- cial criticism of the so-called ‘‘ facts” of modern Spiritualism. Granted that one finds little but fraud and delusion in ost classes of these ‘ facts,” is it enough simply to report one’s fail- ure, with a considerable display of literary skill, and with a manifest readiness to assure the world that one is not easily to be fooled? We think that this is not enough for men who have under- taken the peculiar re:ponsibilities of the Seybert Commissioners. It up to tbe present time the Committee have found onl, deception and
Page 19
foolishness in those spiritualistic ‘* manifesta tions” that have come under their notice, it is more than ever their duty so to set forth their re searches as to aid in the work of educating the people at large to the point where they also shall be somewhat better able to distinguish imposture from reality. The real task before the Commit tee is, in fact, plainly much more to instruct the general public than to * expose” this or that ras cal. A Slade or a Mansfield may be very fair game to bag, and it is amusing enough to read how clever men like the writers of this Re port have dealt with such spiritual influences; but it is unfortunate that the Committee have laid so much stress on this part of their story. Seybert wanted them to ‘‘ investigate ” Spirit ualism, as one of the *‘systems which assume to represent the truth”; and they have certainly labored hard and well upon this task as far as they have gone. But Seybert surely planned this investigation principally as an authoritative and persuasive method of teaching the people He wanted the world to become Spiritualistic He had faith that if an unprejudiced body of learned men, appointed by auniversity, could be induced to give time to the subject, they would be come convinced of the truth of the faith that he himself followed. And his aim plainly was to have such an authoritative verdict used as a means of doing away with modern prejudices, and of gain ing for Spiritualism a hearing in the world’s best circles. Now, unfortunately, yet, of course, very naturally, the appointed judges find themselves so far unable to say one word that could satisfy Seybert’s hopes and wishes were he alive to hear from them. It is surely but fair that, with such a preliminary result on their hands, they should at least bear Seybert’s wish in mind enough to make their report a strong appeal, not to us who are sceptics and need no repentance and have al wavs made game of Spiritualism, but to the lost sheep themselves, and to the still more important sheep who are in danger of being lost. To make this appeal the Seybert Commission need not have done any mere preaching. That, indeed, was not their affair and will not be. But they surely might have avoided a tone that is amusing enough to us, but which must be distinctly and solely offensive to the very class whom they were most called upon to assist. Perhaps we are hypercritical, but to our minds the case stands thus: the belief of many people in spiritualistic phenomena of the illusory types that the Seybert Commission have so far met with, is plainly founded upon the very common popular confidence in any honest man’s power to judge for himself whatever he personally sees, and to report accurately whatever he has seen. This confidence is an ancient piece of folk-lore. To get rid of it altogether is impossi ble. We can only fight it wherever we meet it. The untrained human senses are in no wise accurate instruments for the study of unwonted facts; and the untrained human memory both is, and, for the practical purposes of living, ought to be, a largely unhistorical faculty. These are simple truths, but folk-lore has been from the first against them. Whata sensible man sees, is there ; what an honest man relates, must have happened : these two superstitions form the rock 1 on which Spiritualism builds. To do something towards mining away that ancient rock, is the business of any man who undertakes to deal wit! such beliefs. Now by implication, to be sure, the Seybert Committee set forth in their report cor siderations of genuine value for this pur] They mention the difficulties of observat in just this field, and they relate a number of stances of plausible tricks that would have de ceived most ordinary observers, but that did not deceive them. Yet they so relate these
‘The Nation. stences, and so mention these difficulties, that the moral will be lost on all who are in real danger of falling a prey to this particular delu sion. In short, this report offers to the ordinary ‘al most persuaded ” Spiritualist the treatment of
the north wind, not that of the sun. This almost wersuaded man says that he doe fess t understand it all so verv well s his dead wife and his baby at the ing s ance, In the dim light. The spirits even spoke to bim, and he did once find written inside the closed slate a message from his lost friend, which referred to a fact unknown, he is certain, to any one now living but himself. Furthermore, the trance-medium did once tell him this or that wonderful thing All this he is sure of, because he saw and heard it himself, and be has
simular tales from nmumberless other people at *fact-meetings ” and in private talks. However it all may be possible, then, the dead, he declares, do live again, and, after a fashion, do come back Such an * inquirer” now turns, let us suppose, te
this report, and he finds simply what he will call scoffing. Logically it may be justified, but practically it will be only mischievous to bi He says, “ f sawso and so; [remember plainly such and such startling things.” The Seybert Commission say, with much humor and great neatness of language, that they went to various places and never managed to see anything but tricks, and have remembered nothing but vanity Experience shows that this mode of treating an honest and deluded man onlv bardens him. He
loses confidence in your powers, because he Loses the sense of your sympathy. To his "| saw you respond with a smiling “1 saw nothing To his ** fact” vou have nothing to oppose but your private inability to tind any facts. His bag is fullof what, in his ignorance, he calls game You are tolerably sure that the * game’ is only ‘rows and sparrows ; but vou do nothing to it struct him adequately about that. You only as sure him that your own t J 4 ‘ you report that you suspect the woods of being
empty toc. This makes, t mind, a poor ¢ liminary report.” He only doubts your sports manship, and tenderly bigs his bag of crows homeward. In a passage of magniticent humor, Bunvat makes Christian and his fellow meet ot Athe ist,” trudging along with his back to the heave lv glow that marks the direction of the Celestia City. ‘* Where are you going savs Atheist t the Pilgrims. ‘* To the Celestial City,” is in su stance their response Atheist bursts int controllable laughter You fools t says ‘I have been hi ng for that pla these tw
ty vears, and have seen nothing of it vet. Plair ly it doesn’t exist.” We cite wholly from ar accurate memory, and ly hope tor i t reader of this famil ir s t and easy method of refuting t 5 Now, while the S bert Commission a . gmatic as was Atheist, and pr st . ss pen t I rn. th r met} i te ng th ta “ seem to tl s tualist i ia st as 1 mising ashis. Yet tl surely might hav " led leaving this Ssiol ai they show mor ul it lering their a t. Wes i } i\ si j on st ] t at al tt and theirs n of fraud gs pel { ist fiat themselves st b gidly suppressed ¢ s Re rt Tt te ‘ wn} : and tf reacdk ght ! I ft tos t } x ld } + #) , a , at ge ¢ hd | I ¢ : s langer partly | ruse he lacks nsidering st this topic, all sense of hu You ca . Ip! by making sport ' - ? ; ty ~] isl t tl it } ances t ke best. W rou can pe tod s to show in pla and drv speech, not s
fraud is ssibl r that he know sou ed senses i t : xt i +} 2 “W ti i “ its bo thus ? i ; ~ ‘ ¢ ' \ a kK ‘ } , \ 2 sare net t ir il t t im ¢ t ass bal s t . ‘ ‘ il sta bro i i ‘ actun LiScos . t } l sul ‘ _ wi t ‘ { t iriy ‘ Sad i ‘ { tl a ft ft ws ‘ if *¥ . ‘ oa , \ ‘ t . \ < S . i ’ = is i . oN i ti ‘ i . " i wr Ser i i \ is us ~f WwW * i wy . kK " has VW - ‘ ‘ “ 1 } nN \ ‘ ‘ . ~ M4 “ Sigrt i i ws Vets furt i ‘ irt ul the ks s to us be } } t 1 Vid © that ™ rs ‘tat { xperiments w Siad \ t iw is ta t s TeX y sig i te Sis sekiom n i ga statement. [he juite w the I pean trip w levoted to | } erton’s researc! { “ y imast irf x x sms searcely aft al very st \ tory is ld witl
— 2 } Society’s Psyc] h I gs vt ! Ss. avery te 1 sft lo what we Sey bert miss for not under Xpose a e-writing medium is one s} x th itrust worthiness f ary and untrained observer of slate inifestat : juit another and a portant thing. A slate-writer ex best, only one fraud the less in this he father of lies; the next fraud has equal chance of being believed. But an get a series of observers to attend ig exhibitions that are actually only tricks, and if you can promptly get n reports from these observers, there f ce of showing conclusively, by a com parison of the various reports with one another and with the actual facts, how worthless the best untrained witness is as to all the critical incidents f such an exhibition. Such a result is compara
——_
Page 20
118 The Nation. {Number 1154 tively general in its character. It may thus be possible to convince intelligent but untrained men that their observation and their memory are alike worthless in such a region. If they be- this, the next slate- writing melium who offers them his services will find their curiosity more languid, and their judg- ment of bis miracles less confident. In tbe pa- per on * The Possibilities of Mal-Observation and Memory, from a Practical Point of Mr. Richard Hodgson and Mr. 8S. J. Davey have set forth the outcome of just such an experimental investigation as this. Mr. Da- vey furnished the conjuring for the experiments, the greater part of reports that were come aware of perhaps Lap:e of View,” and Mr. Hodgson conducted the work of criticising the written out by the observers. Result: a most in teresting study of human fallibility. To be sure, the study is still very inexact, for obvious rea- If the investigation is to go mucs further, instantanecus photography, or some other me- chanically accurate metbod of registering cer- tain of the actual events, must be introduced to control the reports of the observers. But mean- while a fine piece of work has been done, and one sons, that gives new reason to hope for very good re- sults from Mr. Hodyson’s stay in this country as Secretary of the American Society for Psychical Research, The number of the Proceedings before us con other witness afresh to tains several interesting papers, two ot the rather dangerous ingenuity of Mr, F. endless and W. H. My- ers. Into the boundless and silent sea of recent hypnotic research this modern mariner’s ship bursts with an appalling speed. The white foam fies, and the furrow streams forth free. We do not assert, indeed, that the mariner himself has ever yet killed the albatross of truth. We ad- vise him, however, to be very careful of his cross- which bear bow, REBER’S MEDLEVAL ARI. History of Mediawval Art. By Dr. Franz von teber, Director of the Bavarian Royal and State Galleries of Paintings, Professor in the University and Polytechnic of Munich. Trans- lated by Joseph Thacher Clarke. Witb 422 illustrations and a glossary of technical terms. Harper & Bros, Dr. REBER’s ‘ History of Mediwval Art’ bas in its degree the same excelleaces as his volume on ‘Ancient Art,’ translated by the same writer and issued by the same publisber five years ago, and then reviewed in the Nation, The earlier volume had the advantage of covering a more arable Dr. Reber was more en- The divisions of the subject were more distinct, its branches less intricately interlaced, its material more manageable. In- deed, 1t would be hard to find a subject less pa- tient of historical treatment than medieval art. The only predecessor who bad adequately treated it, so far as we know, was Seh and Dr. has set himself the harder task of condensing into a single octavo field, and one in which tirely at home. a condensed aase; Reber volume the theme which in Schnaase’s ‘Geschichte der bildenden Kiinste’ occupies five. If, therefore, the present book has not so much the interesting deductions and sug- to be wondered at. It is only matter for congratulation that the work is well done, and the result directness, decision, and clear exegesis as last, nor so many gestions, it is not valuable. Dr. Reber’s plan differs somewhat from that of most of his prede- eessors In favor of more compactness and con- tipuity of arrangement, His distribution of bis subject seems to us just and well balanced, his opintons on general questions eminently reason able, and there is 4 commendable absence of partisanship. The intricate mingling of Latin and Byzantine influences in western Europe, the domination of the Latin; the successive preémi- pence and subordination of Saxony, the Rhine- lands, the southern and northern provinces of France; the Gotbic supremacy of central France; the late awakening of Italy—all these have their due place and value. The leading place is neces- sarily given to architecture, which was in the Middle Ages, even more than in preceding ages, the mother and queen of the arts, Guided by this clue, the reader finds the development made as clear as he could expect. The web is a very tangled one, and to present it with all the threads laid out in a plain pattern would be to misrepre- sent it. The discussion of the development and complication of Romanesque architecture in Germany is lucid and judicious, though some- what overloaded with detail. The rise and spread of pointed architecture is equally well de scribed. In all this a geographical arrangement inevitable. When it comes to painting and sculpture, political, physi- cal, and even ethnical boundaries seem to be much less significant, and the lines of develop- ment to be disturbed or effaced, rather than dis- played, by a geographical treatment. Here, we think, Dr. Reber might with advantage have pruned down his work still further. The leading lines in this part are much fewer and the facts multiply. sary for architecture gives the book the charac- ter of a handbook. The commentary must be either very minute or very sparing, and to give the facts without full commentary offers a dry and bony result. Here and there asalient point is slighted, which we should have liked to see dwelt upon with more emphasis, For instance, the transfer of archi- tectural control, at the end of the twelfth cen- tury, from the monastic orders to the laity, was one of the most important phenomena in the his- tory of medizval architecture. The influence of the Church, and especially the cloistered clergy, in conserving and developing the arts from the sixth century till the twelfth or thirteenth, is in- deed so important that no medieval history is adequate which does not insist upon it. Some- thing more might have been said with advan- tage, perhaps, about early Christian mosaics, about the use of vegetable forms in the orna- ment of the thirteenth century, and the change in plan due to the addition of lateral chapels to churches in the fourteenth century. If the ex- position of such points as these had taken the place of some cataloguing of artists and works of art here and there, the book would hardly have lost by it. In truth, its chief literary fault is the accumulation of detail which merely makes a fuller record, but adds no ideas, and rather cumbers the narrative with facts. The reader will still notice a little of the over- assurance in explaining things from the inside which was visible in the older volume. Dr. Re- ber never seems quite able to get away from the classic point of view. He is apt to accuse the Romanesque builders of not understanding the classic buildings about them, or of failing in their efforts to imitate them; and to forget that, while the Teutons were content to take hints from the work of their forerunners, they appear to have preferred their own ways of using them. We think be is tempted to press too far the theories which Semper and other acnte German writers have imprinted on the criticism of their country- men—theories of definite climatic forms, of archi- tectural details derived directly from the pro- cesses of other arts. of the discussion seems The distribution which seems neces- These theories are of sub stantial value, but of too facile application, The dogmatic use of them is repellent, and tends to divert the reader’s mind from the effort for artis- tic effect, which is always present, and is respon- sible for many things, we believe, for which now- adays it gets no credit. Every one who has busied himself with this sort of investigation knows how difficult is abso- lute accuracy of detail, and 1s disposed to be in- dulgent to minor errors. That there should be more or less of them ina book of this kind is to be expected, but we find slips that seem unneces- sary. We may warn the reader against some we notice. Thus, on p. 43, the author cites the Mosque of Omar at Bethlehem. There is no Mosque of Omar in Bethlehem, we believe, and Dr. Reber must mean the building popularly so called in Je- rusalem, but more properly known as the Dome of the Rock. Indescribing Mohammedan architec- ture, the name Mihrab is given to the covered parc of the mosque, wherein the worshippers assemble, and the prayer-niche is called the Kiblah. In reality, the Mihrab is the niche, and the Kiblah properly denotes the direction of Mecca, towards which the niche is but they are often confounded. On pp. 176 and 177 we find a plan and section of the “Mosque of Jumma at Bijapur.” Tbe un- skilled reader will probably interpret this by the analogy of the Mosque of Omar or of Amru. The usual form of the name is Jama Masjid (or Jumma Musjid}, which means Assembly Mosque or Chief Mosque. Most have mosques so named, and commonly spoken of in English as the Friday Mosques, because service is held there on Friday, the Moham medan Sabbath. The interior view given of the Mosque of Amru, by the way, not agree with the description on the next page, the arches being depicted as semicircular, but described as pointed horseshoes. There Is an analogous discrepancy between the plan and sec- tion of the Cathedral of Noyon, where the plan shows four-part vaulting, which is correct, and the section six-part vaulting. Dr. Reber takes pains to assign the first appearance of the horse- shoe arch to Sassanian architecture, forgetting that the Buddhist Chaitya halls and Vibaras, be- fore and about the Christian era as well as later, are full of it. The exchange of names between the spires of Chartres and the church at Ven- déme, p. 495, is a blunder in proof-reading; to speak of Cbartres as having piers alternating with round shafts may bea slip of the same kind. In several places the main or ceptral tower of a medieval castle is called the barbacan; but this is the keep. and the barbacan is an outwork. Ste. Nicaise for St. Nicaise is venial; and al fresco (in the open air) for a fresco (fresco painting) is more amusing than serious. The indiscriminate and inaccurate use of ‘‘cloister” tor monastery and convent comes evidently of translating too phonetically the German generic word Kloster. It saves some trouble, but makes difficulty where both the generic and specific are required, as where we have ‘‘ the Cloister [Areuzgang ?} 1m the Convent [K/oster 7] of Gerusalemme, Bologna,” which was really not a convent, but a monastery. We have not seen the book in German, and cannot speak of the translation from comparison, but itseems to be in general exceedingly well done. It is terse, clear, and vigorous; only once in a while does the terseness impede the clearness. Mr. Clarke, however, now and then shows an un- accountable reluctance to subject himself to the received terminology of architecture. He gives us ‘‘ Kernel’? (German Aern) for the bell of a capitol, ‘‘ vaulting-post ” for vaulting-sbaft, ** ar- rade” (Frencb) for a single arch, ‘*‘ surmount- ed” arches for stilted. ‘* Trapeze-shaped capi- tals’ smacks more of athletics than of ge- ometry, and ‘‘chapiter” for capital is per- haps as “surmounted” as the arch it sustains, We cannot believe in these liberties; itis difficult enough at the best to maintain order and clear ness 1n architectural language,{and if every new set ; Mahommedan cities does
Page 21
o> ne F Aug. 11, 1887] writer is at liberty to reform it according to bis own preferences, the confusion will be beyond hope. We have the same objection to the neo logism of Romanic for Romanesque. The last well established, and its meaning will not be clarified by a substitute. Mr. Ferguss have had us say Romance, but he did not prevail | Neither is it hkely that the English world wi consent to say Romanic The illustrations are abundant and ry w selected. many of them new to books of this pendious kind, and a pleasant exchange for the familiar ones. from other works, some very well ill. the well done, clear and concis They are, of course, repr 1nd some very The glossary at end is necessary and ,and not often t concise to be clear. A great improvemen previous volume is the bibliography. formal, and does not assume to be complet: the notes give authorities enough to show student how to continue his studies in ail parts the field. The authorities are the best, and r cent ones are not that in writing of Itahan Romanesque so tant Dartein’s ‘ Ar barde’ should have neglected, thot a book as chitecture L been overlooked But, att all deductions, we commend Dr. Reber’s book as the best account of its subject that the Eng! reader will find. Court Life in With Illustrations ISS7. Pp. vui, 298 TEWFIK PaAsHaA had Khedive about six months wnen the author of this Egypt, in January, 1880, as tutor to his chil For more than a year Mr. Butler lived in constant and familiar abundant opportunities for studying his ch: ter and observing the spirit which he brough his work as ruler. It markable picture (and one in most respects very different from the popular impression of Tewtik in England and in this country is drawn of a Turk who never smokes, is the 1 of one wife, has neither slaves bor harem, is simp! FEygupt. By Alfred J. Scribner & Welford. SvVvOoO been } ' DOOK lutercour-e with bim, is an interesting and re which husban in his tastes and pleasures, and, though a devout Mussuiman, isa member of a sect which believes chara in education and progress. How sucha ter could have been formed amid the corrupt in fluences of Ismail’s court, it is difficult to unde stand, and yet there can be no question that th new Khedive, though less brilliant and energeti than his father, Was an upright man, earnestly intent on reforms, and of bis wretched subjects. by numerous facts, but also by the reports of solicitous for the welfare } Thisis shown not Only some of the frequent conversations which Tewtik held with Mr. Butler on public affairs. We may cite the abolition of the Désab, that part ot celebration of the Prophet’s Birthday peculiar t Egypt, in which a sheikh, mounted on hi rides over the bodies of Mr. Butler witnessed this scene shortly after his arrival, and his description of the ** dre: revolting spectacle * is the most vivid we ber ever to have read. From his place in front of the Khedive’s tent, ‘* my feet tou of heads, [ could see with horrible clearness that happened.” The sheikh and the borse a stout cob snod with irot the rseback, hundreds of dervishes } Was a iarge mi: ‘““Many of the natives had told me tha horse did not tread on the but n stepped across them, planting bis feet berw This I soon saw was false: the bodies wer ed so close that the horse must trample uy On hecame_ I saw the dreadful vielding bodies as thigh or ribs, spine or sboulder tf crushing weight of the boofs, aud | saw writhing of the poor tortured forms a moment after he passed all bore the first shock in proof oftheir faith. Butafteran instant’s paus } 1 Dod Les, the dervishes lay st Slience, for this ts The Nation. all rose or tried to rise. Some were unhurt an imped pell-mell thers, as they tried t move, shrieked and velled und fell back fainting The wounded are sent away from Cau and t 1 ire buried secretly, and no one ever knows thet iber of either. lest it should be said that the Prophet's miracle was not accomplished \ rdingly the natives beheve that no one ever is hurt So deep an impression did this scene make upon the lishman that he lost no opportunity of upressing upon the Khedive (who, it should be sald, *‘ remained in his tent, preferring to see ht tle or nothing of the barbarities enacted ”) the du tv of putting an end to the practice. This he did : such tact and persistency that the required rder Was given, and the next vear the sheikh Was preceded by ‘'a strong body of police, ob \ meant to prevent any fanatics at the last rom throw themselves under the t trampled It was Mr. Butler’s good fortune to arrive in I ust in time to accompany Tewtik ona vup the Nile to the First Cataract, and i to Dan ta and Rosetta. This gave him a to see the country in gala dress, for every t ind village was decorated and at night br i vy Uluminated, while processions, ban juets, and receptions without number were given Kuedive \t one pla ‘e all t tr s were adorned on either side with con ti sarches of painted woodwork, and every arch was bu with flags and lanterns. Here wid there, perched im boxes over the roadway mid-air, groups of musicians or story-tellers recited san to the great amusement of the rowd below Whenever we reached the house of a notable or rich merchant, a band of mu sic struck up a salute, slaves salamed, and carpets ] i} . } we were spread for us to walk upon across the court the fact that tler was struck with “the men as a rule make a great deal of obe sau but are silent; they do not know how t¢t 1 i t} ‘ n the housetops raise their shr | ’ i tless the La figs), Which is used to express er joy or mourning Atay t the Delta tbe tents of the shelkfs ** were I g t t vere adorned inside w work nmow tl intry. the d signs sist g of flowers, fruits, a s mventional symbols ful taste at ry. One tent is sald to hav st £2.00 tler is enthusiastic over the beauty ar ( f Rosetta, with its gardens wd lonnaded str Ss lined with ancient palaces the windows of wt ire vered wit site mushrabia r lat work set ] riels; and within-d s abound splendidly carved ind painted ings of woodwork, and dadoes ind pave nts of ma mosal rt bief erest Mr. Butler's bex how r,is to be found it sa it of life in the i nad the persons tormed the Kobe i S rt H s s Wer tw bovs, Abbas SIX years 1, and Moha i Ali, barely t Tl w f . as fair s mas peans 1 zht ttv faces, and most \ yy : ad gol abilities \ s r is given Vins ! U) lay the V ig va ~ . a “el ft Worn Lom S t st be done bbas a ul t e up. and said i ae | t is a fellah W bv s il ‘ ‘Why ause he is w The pashas and rt tt sw g Turks or natives of tl $s M4 ant 1 f{ judiced ng the i ilways dreaming of ndepend g % Ce sstomes are told of them ssors which read like chapters ts. Some of these were reinftedd to tl rut! wftik ~ ‘ vers i witt r q i ‘ t 1 Fin ia Wt any ‘ ‘ i traved tl . ‘ . gave the tirst ‘ . ‘ m the ws I : ‘ i ‘ wl ht bad A puroose It wa it a red stor “ Mi i | s WAS girieight years 1 palace sers mB (UU ver it gra iow ra i ’ Phe stone has t ‘ the iskKead asf t | vi ar t ~ ti . . in tt Rg { - ‘“ } ~ S present wi ‘ stand Mr I was sf i t s wv? ment of Alex by the Englis s tures t pusilla \ f the Kiedy witt 1 i } -_ SAVIT * f yreat weakness . ‘ uti ives s ‘ { ent wi t i n of affairs ‘ q act with wi I ry é { Ww Ver ‘ 1 STs \ tt reign Powers, S | tt ma w t . . ft Kt \ i 1s t . } le | at to Fra “ N tioned the t k : . vtik greater liber Not : s ery, but he ‘has the great ri not merely becaus ‘ ‘ bu ils na int ¢ x i i and superstitious ideas of the w Asa st ‘ step towards reform this d t . himself started a sort of high s y Cair We cannot but reg t t has not shown, so far as it w sible for | to do so, what Lewtik ts i w hie r t the difficulties and dis Na ‘nts ! I tion have weakened ! Ss jas if WV | t Duk f Argvll. 2 vols. GP. I um’s Sons. 1SS7 THis book is a most striking lustration of the 10€ the saving tha i in must have an Is 1 a il rder t pinions of his own Phe y many times this sim } and the iltit a pinions, as well as tl | positiveness with which they are expressed, is in | due proportion. His wisdom in his own conceit justifies the hopelessness of Solomon. It is 88 un bounded as to constitute a most conclusive argu ment against the very position to establish wh he has written his book. His whims ar even in the very printing and publishing of the-e Nothing could L easier for so rich an author than to adorn a book sumptuous volumes. have upon this most romantic and picturesque of all themes with an abundance of the most superb
Page 22
120 The Nation. [Number 1154 illustrations. Instead of showing this moderate degree of consideration for the reader, he has chosen to distigure his work with some wretched woodcuts taken from drawings of hisown. These, as he states, pretend to no artistic merit, and were made chiefly for geological purposes. They are of little value even for such irrelevant uses, and are really introduced by the arbitrary will of the author, who takes pleasure, as he tells us, in reflecting that although all superticial objects, such as buildings, trees, etc., are of comparative- ly recent date, yet the outlines of the mountains and the contours of sea and land have remained unchanged for many centuries, The Duke of Argyll finds the existing defim- tions of political economy ‘‘confoundimg and confusing.” Of them he says: “Land, Labor, and Capital are the orthodox Three. . . . ‘Tbe deftimtion, therefore, alto- getber is scholastic and artificial in the bighest degree teucbing votving, suggesting nothing— because nope of its di-tuctions correspond with such great dividing lines as exist in Nature. One ot these lines ruus alonz the seeming gulf be tween Mind and Matter, aod another between our own share i bowb ot these. and the boundless volume of them which is external to ourselves, but with which, nevertheless, we have close re- lations These dividing lines are familar to us all inour thoughts, iv our actions, and ia our language. They seem to poimt toa better Uhree than Land, Labor, and Capital. Mind, Matter, and Opportunity would be tbe amended list. Mind is that which we know-—as we know no thing else Matter is that which is ours also in Muscle. and in all that 1t acts upon, or that reacts on it, Opportunity is a convenient term for every kind, degree, and variety of condition and of circumstance which belps to stimulate our de sires, to clear our alms, or to facilitate the attain- ment of them,” Accordingly, bis Grace having swept away the fictions of the economists, proceeds to elucidate the history of Scotland with the aid of a science of his own construction; and here at least the exclusive rights of ownership will be respected. The ttle of toe Duke to all rights of property in his Own private system of political economy is far more secure than his title to his lands. Nei- ther armed rebellion nor legalized robbery can ever molest him here, and even envy will avert her malignant glance from this possession, The fundamental principle of this system is tne abso- tute right of ownership in land. The whole his- tory of Scotland is one long testimony to the beneficent results of this right. In the case of the Island of Tyree, documents in the possession of the author “‘ prove in the greatest detail that every single step towards improvement which has been taken during the Jast hundred and fifty years has been taken by the Proprietor, and not by the people. Not only so, but every one of these steps, without exception, has been taken against the prevailing opiions and feel ings of the people at the time.” What is true of this island is true, according to the Duke, of the whole of Scotland. Her great landowners— for by ownership we are to understand the proprie- tary right of a great landlord, not of a peasant— have made her what she is, They lifted her out of the miseries of Celtic feudalism by granting charters, they established their beneficent rule by eptorcing covenants, they stimulated im provement by judicious leases, and enforced a rational agriculture in the teeth of the persistent opposition of an ignorant and brutish tenantry. Somewhat more than a hundred years ago, an other distinguished Scotchman, Adam Smith, observed, ‘The statesman who should attempt to direct private people in what manner they uught toemploy their capitals would not only load himself with a most unnecessary attention, but assume an authority which could safely be trusted, not only to no single person, but to no council or senate whatever, and which would no- where be so dangerous as in the hands of a man who had folly and presumption enough to fancy ‘ himself fit to exercise it.” In the opinion of the Duke of Argyll, not only is he himself fit to exer cise this authority, but also every one into whose hands it may happen to fall. He entirely omits the qualification of Aristotle, who justifies des- potism only when the ruler excels all other per- sons in the community in virtue. In fact, bis ar- gument, so far as it 1s an argument, would justi- fy the institution of slavery. We do not find it difficult to believe that the tenants in the Island of Tyree or elsewhere in the domains of the (ampbells should have opposed the measures of their landlords if they resembled the present Duke. We can easily understand how the most judicious scheme may have been presented in a manner so offensive as to compel a self respecting tenant to reject it on principle. So far as the argument of this book is directed against doctrinaires of the Marx and George type, we have no criticism to offer. If any one chooses to believe that the condition of the tillers of the soil was better under the hideous barba- rism of the tribe cr the clan, and that communal property resulted in anything more than univer- sal poverty, be will find the case against him stated with very telling force, Lt appears clearly enough from these pages that the tenant under the existing law is far better off than the clans- man could ever have been under the ‘com and livery,” the ‘‘ vopacbt,” the ‘* coshering.” and the “tallages ’ of thechief. But the author looks in the wrong quarter for hisenemy. Attacks either upon property in general or landed property in particular will be repulsed whenever proprietors really become alarmed about them. But land- lordism is a very different thing from ownership. The Duke of Argyll wholly fails to show that when the feudal chieftain ceased to fulfil the of- tice of a sovereign, owing to the development of the national sovereignty, be was justly entitled to retaia those attributes of sovereignty which immediately assumed the form of absolute pro- prietary rights m the soil. The land had beep given to him and his followers in the first place. It was bis to dispose of only among them and while he was their ruler; and when a greater ruler appeared, the rights of the chief ought to have been extinguished. The author also fails wholly to consider that the individual ownership of land by those who occupy it 1s a very different thing from the right of a single subject to dispose absolutely of a considerable portion of a king- dom. It would be unjust to deny that there is a great deal of interesting and valuable information scat tered throngh these pages. Neither the absurd pedantry of the author nor his intense bias can altogether avail to conceal his real knowledge or to discredit his genuine patriotism. But his view isso entirely one-sided that it is impossible to accept his account of the development of Scot- lish society as historical. He misrepresents not intentionally but because he cannot help it. Yet if we can make allowance for this, we may enjoy his graphic accounts of the wild deeds of tbe clans, and the quiet grace of his descriptions of the scenery of the Highlands. It is impossible not to regret that such powers of narration and such exceptional opportunities should be thrown away In a ridiculous attempt to maintain an ob solete theory. The vook might easily have been made a fascinating history; but as all its histori- cal references are introduced to support a certain proposition, we feel sure that there are other in- terpretations to be put upon them, and that nalf the case has been omitted. Considered as an his- torical argument, the book seems to us to bea monumental failure. We feel disposed to give judgment against the plaintiff on his own show- ing. His plea discloses an arrogance so offensive that it makes the very name of landed proprietor odious. A few more arguments of this kind would certainly put an ena tothe system of great estates in land. The Duke ot Argyll would do well to cease his appeals to the public, taking to beart the advice of an ancient philo-opher to the upregenerate sailors who, when a tempest arose, began to call upon the gods: ** Peace! Let them not know you are here.” Philadelphia, 1681-1887. A History of Munici- pal Development. By Edward P. Allinson and Boies Pevrcse of the Pbiladelphia Bar Balti- more: Publication Agency of the Johns Hop- kins University. 1887. THE title of this excellent book sufficiently indi- cates the purpose of its authors. Although their judicious treatment of the subnject required the pest legal furniture of their profession, as well as the thoughtful and digested learning of the his- torian, yet its great value will be to the student of social science, to whom the present extraordi- nary development of wealth and population 1s constantly presenting new problems of no easy solution. Notwithstanding the fabulous taies of ancient cities and their exaggerated populations, if is necessary to ac’ept and realize the fact that at no former time has the tendency of population towards great centres been so rewarkable ; and no branch of science has so lamentably failed to keep step with it, by applving knowledge to new social conditions, as that which aims especially in that direction, and which we rather indefi- nitely call social science. Tue reasons of this tendency are well understood by publicists, and are likely to continue and possibly to increase in force. They are closely connected with the pro- gress of mankind, and we would not modify them if we could ; but none the less are they tending to alter many or all the conditions of social, and therefore, in a free country, of political life. Inasiugle generation modern cities have grown from thousands to millions, and every succeeding census exhibits their constantly increasing per- centage of the aggregate population. As long a3 labor continues to be further divisible, and the forces of nature can be more and more harnessed to the work of man, so long will economy of pro- duction and distribution be promoted by these great municipal aggregations; and therefore. un- der the ceaseless spur of competition, the process must go on, and must be regarded as a perma- nent fact, calling for the most enlightened and effective application of al] that we know of both political and social knowledge. To study, col- lect, and preserve an important part of the know- ledge valuable for such purposes nas been the aim of our authors. Discarding the sentimental trash which too often swells the bulk of such local bis- tories, they have with excelent taste confined their work to tracing from innumerable, but dis- tinctly quoted, sources the actual political origin and history of a great municipality, pointing out with impartial fidelity the constant efforts, and almost as constant failures, to keep municipal ad- ministration fairly up to the civic wants, First we have a general and most entertaming sketch, tracing back some distinctive corporate peculiarities through our Englsh and Teutonic ancestors to the earliest usages of the Aryan race, and clearly distinguishing the three systems of local administration brought to the new world by the first colonists of the Eastern, Middle, and Southern colonies respectively, all of them equal- ly of pure English race. Passing brietly over the Delaware River settlements of 162U-1681, and approaching the subject proper, we next have the earliest proprietary charter of 1601, which was lost for nearly two centuries, and found by the authors, after most of their hook was written, amoug the private papers of an old city family (Biddle). The strictly medizeval character of taki NRSC eg
Page 23
Aug. 11, 1887 Pan) that instrument—which 1s far more antiquated than its dute—and its gradual modification and development towards modern views, are carefully and ably traced by methods which could scarce ly be improvei. We have a vivid picture of the steady growth and complexity of municipal wants, and the consequent ceaseless crop of cbar ters and law-making—all pushing the difficulties a little further ahead, but all equally futile to dispose of them—down to the latest charter tak ing effect April, ISS7, of which such great hopes are now entertained. Even this last charter has required, to get itself enacted, thirty years since its principal features were outlined in 1856 by the then Mayor, Mr. Vaux, in an able official message which has only now borne its fruit re the law, our modern municipal corpora tions are only artificial persons, as the rest of us are natural persons. Their duties should be sole- ly financial and administrative. They have no thing to do with the political or legal rights of persons or of things, and consequently there is no political significance in our authors’ conclusion, which we think must be shared by the intelligent portion of the public, that most of the failures of our local administrations are traceable to the universal tendency to usurpation of. executive functions by legislative bodies. In Philadelphia certainly—and probably in most American cities —the usual course bas been to start out with a reasonably strong and responsible executive, and then for the councils, by establishing a multi plicity of so-called ** departments,” with a stand- ing committee for each, and an obedient agent called ‘‘chief of department,” to grasp all pat- ronage, and meddie with every purchase and contract, till waste, failure, and ruin startle the public to demand more law and a new start, The new charter now has aimed to sweep aside this legislative usurpation by concentrating re spt nsibility in the executive, and vesting the ay pointments directly or indirectly in him, on the theory that power and responsibility are insepa rable, and as much as is refused of one must fail of the other. But this necessary concentration of power has been carefully checked by subject ing the appointments to systematic tests of sele tion by public competitive examination, thus seek lng to vest the patronage in an impartial system, instead of in an individual with personal frie: to reward, and perbaps enemies to punish. If we were willing to express a single dissatisfaction with this excellent work, it is that the authors have omitted to point out this important ch to autocratic power, since all friends of the char ter would admit that, without it, such power vested in one man would be offensive and dan gerous. It is of the more importance tbat this been tuliy dwelt upon, be- feature should bave cause if the public, through careiessness or want of appreciation of its Importance as a restrait upon the selfish use of executive power, should permit it to be evaded or frittered away, an in different individual migh> become an intolerable despot. Annals of Auqusta County, Virginia By Jos A. Waddeil, Member of the Virginia Hist eal Society. Richmond: Wm. Ellis Jones IS86, Pp, vil, 574. It was in September, 1716, that Gov. Spotsw scaled the Blue Ridge, forded the Shenandva and formal! took possessi for King G the First of England.” Chaplain Hugh Jones, his contemporary account of the expedition, in- timates that the Governor took witb him *‘a suf ficient Stock of Provision ™; and the honest dia rist, John Fontaine, who was one of the party shows us that the Jamestown muniste! misinformed, He says The Nation. 121 We had a good dinner, and after it we got! the men together and loaded all their arms, and we drank the King's health in champagne, and fired a voliey, the Princess’s health in Burgundy, and fired a volley, and ail the rest of the roval ‘ N family in claret, and fired a volley We drank the Governor's health and tired another volleys ay We had several sorts of liquors, viz, Virginia | red wine and white wine, Irish bh ! brandy, shrub, two sorts of rum, lew canary, cherry punch, cider, etc.” it « Those were droughty times, and if that sort of We may thing held for forty years, Thackeray did not \ exaggerate in describing the feats of the drinkers abused W at Castlewood. Tbis was the expedition of t * Kmgbts of the Golden Horseshoe’ Chaplain and tha I Y Jones will tell us why so called give it tot " ‘* For this expedition they were obliged to pr {trish fax w vide u great Quantity ot Horse Shoes; (Things fst seldom used in the lower Parts of the Country - where there are few Stones): Upon which Ac count the Governor, upon their Return, present years ed each of his Companions with a Golden Horse took t ‘ win \ Shoe, wita this Inscription: s§ ft cendere montes.” Peyton, in his ‘ History of Augusta County,’ has Rev. Alex v the astonishing reading it for tf, and t ! is more astonishing translation, ** Thus he swe to cross the mountains.” Finding that Augusta County now vers only , . MI about nine hundred square miles at bas beet limited to that since 1701), one will be tempted " to think that a gre int of sentitnent, to sa I nothing of good liquor, was indulped u ts f first discoverers. Buta glance at the may \ county as it existed, or Was supposed to exist, pag from 1758 to 1770, shows a vast empire, rut N i ‘« in the old lordly way clear to the Mississippi ar up to the Lakes, embracing all of Oh Ll Indiana, and Kentucky, with generous s s of WW Tennessee, New York, and Pennsylvania, just pres tying the bumpers and the volleys and tl order of kmghthood., ii Mr. Waddell bas done a piece of good work, = : \ He modestly disclaims anything beyond the t of annalist, but it 1s exactly in such explorat s) t f musty old records—tax-lists, pamsh | cs \ newspapers, and private journals—tuat tl est K \ ontributions to local history are made Bev \\V ton’s ‘ History, for example, is f " tious and discursiv mut is not nest 5 \ the present work for painstaking a i \ I irces, tor a ref iu n \ pressul f the tin We are g t \i \ Waddell was not deterred from NG : s 0 tr ict that Pevt > Vv i ha peared but tir Years ag “Y t tirst \ gusta County has had irge S [ neptinits populatior Relig = exiles f ! sting i north of Lreland, as 1 vof t vs - were, pushing emigrants from Penns-viva s ~ : ’ \\ Were others, their presence in the valley. t : : f haract ties, s al,} i l.above a : ¢ 12 Ss erm tt history of ft rst tw > t} gener ne Diss ers, the vet nag % to live peaceably und the Virg a Establis I : ‘ h partly tl gh tr ix I > Lug i ‘ lesiasti iws, | ) \ ans of eas > Ml ¢ T sclences 1D tak t tl t x i ‘ g i - } t ai { nd esis snetaiilcaiatel shane ¢ ‘ : - ‘ ‘ vas ~ illed Jes i t is i ul t s g I \ It is ! Au t S WOrKs sw t \ PM i nists ( i i} had Chaplain Jones g grievous fact 1 i Legislatur n tl bistry of ft tstablist t ~ s \ | 1 a pet n Z il ) ee Sus t SDY fe s wardiy | ! tmancipation ; that t H 5 ly =} s i s ! { pretty steady Whigs in na Was iCK Pr a l ss and pra t | Ss i have been ear! ly is \ 1tions t Sal illaws we f ved f I naintaining the Union na uld : oy ft grand if ri da ha per pLiy acqu ed in the Lbiirteenth Coger Was pres i f a breach the Ame nent. Mr. Waddell gives but few pag peace in driving bogs over the Blue Ridge on the to the revellion—those very suggestive, howevet Sabbath."’ More intelligible was the sentence of being made up almost entirely of extracts from ward Boyle to be put im the stocks fortwo his own diary—and fewer still to the era of re
Page 24
~ 122 The Nation. [ Number 1154 construction. He closes his annals with 1870. He might have made a better index than he did. On early ecclesiastical history he might have con- sulted Prof. Briggs’s ‘American Presvyterianism’ to advantage. Excepting these and a few other minor deficiencies, his work is excellent both in conception and performance. Letters of Horatio Greenough to his brother Henry Greenough, With biographical sketches and some contemporary correspondence. Edit- ed by Frances Boott Greenough. Boston: Ticknor & Co, 1887. THIS volume does net purport to give a complete biography of our first sculptor, but it serves for one; and, indeed, from these open and amiable letters and the modest narrative that connects | them, the reader obtains a view of Greenough’s life and an impression of his character that are | all sufficient. He was born into a talented fami- | ly, several of whom won distinction and led use- | ful lives, and he was educated at Harvard Col- lege. It was while there, and before he was | twenty years old, that he made the model for | Bunker Hill monument which, for form and pro- ‘ | portion, was adopted. Soon after graduatior he went to Italy, and there, he said, he ‘‘ began to feel nature’s value : [ adored her before, but as a Persian does the sun, with my face to the grovad.” He was compelled by illness to return after a short stay, and, on reaching his own country, went to Washington, where he had commissions for a while; but it was not long be- fore he was back 1n Italy, where, by the aid of Boston friends and the kindness of Fenimore Cooper, he remained at work until his reputation was established, and thereafter he made Italy bis home for the greater part of his life. He wasa warm patriot, however, in speech as well as in sentiment; he enjoyed his visits home, and he had the good fortune to die in his native land, December 18, 1852. He was only forty-seven years old, Such a lifeis naturally told with much com pleteness in the letters written home, These are, however, in the strictest sense home letters, and they bave the charm of familiarity, and occa- sionally sometbing of the tedium of personal affairs and the limitation of view within the family horizon natural to such epistles, The best of them are those written in youth, when the freshness, the unvertainty, and the ambition of the chase for fame had their hour. There is a frankness, a genuineness,a real boyishness about these earlier confidences and experiences that keep them stili vital; and with them must be included the package of return letters, written by his brother Alfred, which give us a passing glimpse of Boston at the beginning of the thirties, when John Hancock’s house, in which the family were living, still commanded ‘‘a view of the whole city, country, and harbor,” and when Greenough pére was ‘the only real-estate deal- er. Welearn from this same batch of letters that Mr. Ticknor bad the only copy of Shelley ‘*in the country ” (about Boston, let us hope) in 1831, and the editor adds that he was generous in lending this and other rare works by ‘ Elia, Goethe, Bulwer, and Disraeli.” Horatio’s later letters are occupied largely with his orders and with other detaus of business and family interests; very little is to be found in re- gard to art or books or famous persons. But con stantly one comes upon some little incident, some picture of nature, or pithy remark, or gets near to great events like the revolutions of °48, so that at the end there is a little wonder that such slight materials have turned out so well. The editor has handled his subject very deftly and pleasant- ly, and made it all interesting. It is painful to observe how Greenough was troubled and hurt Government in regard to the disposition and payment of his public works. His ideal statue of Washington has found few defenders, but his | protest against the pointof view from which it is now regarded, and his own intention that it should be seen in a closed chanel, are to be re- membered. Indepenaently of artistic merit, however, he was much vexed by the practical business involved in his engagements by the Gov- | | ernment, and he took 1t very much to heart, He | could bid the critics who suggested tossing his | great work ‘‘into the Potomac” a very satisfac- | tory defiance from the vantage ground of his ideal art; but no reply so solacing was to be found when the ‘lreasury withheld a draft. He behav- ed very well, nevertheless, and, after his death, matters were properly settled. There is an ac- count of Priessmtz, the founder of the water- cure, and of his establishment and manner of life at Graefenberg, and also a picturesque passage about the Malvern Hills and Wells. Greenough’s love of wild nature was strung, and bis eye for the salient points good; he seems to have been not unwilling to pen ‘‘a description ” in bis ear- lier years, and probably he was not greatly of- fended when the irrepressible Willis published a letter from ‘‘ a young artist in Italy, as it is so re- dolent of the land frem which it came, though not intended for the public eye.” But if was in other days than ours that the lover of nature, too long cramped in his ‘“bird’s-eye Florence,” breathing once more the New England sweet- briar of a May morning, could write it down— **God is great and Newport is His abode.” With this gem of a former age we take leave of the volume, which those will like to read who are interested in the people and nascent art feel- ing of old Boston, and who enjoy the words of a simple and unbookish man to his own folk. Poetry and Philosophy of Goethe. Chicago: 8. C. Griggs & Co. THIS volume contains the lectures and extempore discussions offered at the Milwaukee Literary School in August, 1886. This institution appears to be an imitation of the Concord School of Phi- losophy, or perhaps we should rather say an off- shoot; at any rate, no less than five of those who contributed to the Concord lectures upon Goethe in 1885 were present at the Milwaukee schvol, and are represented in the volume before us, which is thus, as we should expect, very redolent of the Concord aroma, From Mr. F. B. Sanborn by the difficulties of his negotiations with our | we have a repetition, with some additions, of his Concord lecture upon ‘‘Goethe’s Relations to English Literature,” and from Mr. Denton J. Snider a chapter of bis work on ‘‘ Faust,” noticed in the Nation of February 10, and also an ultra- Pindaric anniversary ode. One-third of the vo- lume emanates from Dr. W. T. Harris, who con- tributes two formal lectures and a numoer of lengthy extempore discussions. A lecture by Mr. James McAlister upon ‘‘ Gcethe as a Scien- tist” is given according to a condensed report in the Milwaukee Sentinel. As reported, the per- formance has little or no value. and seems to have been inserted only as a peg upon which to hang Dr. Harris’s attempted ‘tre-cue” of Goethe’s theory of color. The best essay in the collection is one by Mrs. Maria A, Shorey upon the ‘ Elec- tive Affinities,’ which is a thoughtful and sugges- tive study, couched mainly in the literary Eng- lish of the world’s people. Even this, however, exhales in patcbes the Concord aroma, as witness the followimg sentence: ‘Indeed, I think it will some time be admitted that he often grasped inteilectually, if be could not continuously hold, the underlying principle of all progress from the slime, up through the struggling, teemmg ranks of life to that half- poetic, half-propbhetic dream (which haunts us all) of a race of men and women whose souls, puritied by the discipline of the generations into harmony with celestial currents, know at iast neitver sorrow nor striving, but exist 1n peace, stirred only by the ebb and flow of the mighty ocean of divine desire and happy attainment.” The book is edited by Mrs Marion V. Dudley, Secretary of the School, who in a prefatory note commends her work to the public ip these words: ‘To emphasize the value of ideas; to stimulate profounder research; to cultivate in mortal youth, is 1ts earnest purpose.” On the title-page, for some occult reason to us inscrutable, stands the motto,**Das Ewig-Weibliche zieht uns hinan, BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Battles and Leaders of the Civil War. No.3. The Cen- tury Co, 50 cents Burbank, Kev. W. H, Photographic Printing Methods. seovill Manufacturing Co. ¥1. Dosioyevsky, F Prison Life in siberia. Harper & Broth- ers. 20 cents. Dumont, A. and Chaplain, J. Les Céramiques de la Grece propre: Vases Peints. Paris: Firmin, Didot & Cie. Fenn, G.M. The Bag of Diamonds. D. Appleton & Co. 25 cents, Finck, H. T. Romantic Love and Personal Beauty. Mac- mililan « Co. &2, Gaboriau, E. Marriage ata Venture. Geo. Munro, Grammaire Albanais. London: Triibner « Co. Greg, r. History of the United States. 2 vols. London: WH Allen & Co, Gréville, H. The Princess Roubine. Philadelphia: T. B. Peterson & Bros. 50 cents. Hoitzeudorff, F von Handbuch des Vilkerrechts. Vols. 2,4 Hamburg: J. F. Richter. Horton, 8S. Dana. The Silver Pound, and England’s Mone- tary Policy since the Restoration Macmillan & Co #4. Howorth, H. H. The Mammoth and tne Flood. London: Sampson Low, In an § vil Hour. and Other Stories Geo. Munro. Jack-on, 1 G. Dalmatia, The Quarnero, and Istria. 3 vols. Oxford: Clarendon Press; New York: Macmil- lan & Co, $10.50 James, Henry. Tales of Three Cities. 5thed. Boston: Ticknor x Oo Karr, H. W. S. Shores and Alps of Alaska. London: Sampson Low; Chicago; A.C. McClurg « Co. $3.50. Meade, L. T. The O’Donneils of Inchfawn. Harper & Brothers. 20 cents. Meyer, ©. F, The Chancellor’s Secret. New Bedford: Jas. M. Lawton, jr. Morfill, W. Kk. Simptified Grammar of the Serbian Lan guage London; Triibner & Co Nettleship, Prof. H. Passages for Translation into Latin Prose. London: Geo Bell x Sons. Paviovsky, Isaac. Souvenirs sur Tourguéneff. Paris: A. Lavine; Boston: Schoenhof. “Every child in America should have them.”—New England Journal of Education. “The ‘Young Folks’ Cyclopedia’ should be in every — library.”—From a Report of the Connecticut joard of Education. YOUNG FOLKS’ ( Common Things....$2.50 of - ae ogee CYCLOPEDIA ( Persons and Places.. 2.50 HENRY HOLT & Co., Publishers, New York, NFORMATION AGENCY, 109 EAST 9th St.. New York. Send doz. stamps for hints on finding books, buying and selling, market values, re- views, ete, JOHNS HOPKINS UNIVERSITY, BALTIMORE. Programmes of the instruction offered, for the | academic year beginning October 1, 187, to Gra- duate, Undergraduate, and Special Students will be sent on application. HILOSOPHY FOR THE PEOPLE. Quarterly. Pessimistic Essays on American Politi cal, Economic, and Individual life. 4 numbers $1.00; single copies 36 cents. Address HENRY W, CHEROUNY, 25 Vandewater St., N. Y. DURING HOT WEATHER EAT CURED MEATS. IT SAVES IN COOKING. HAMS! DAVIS’ DIAMOND BRAND, Sold by Grocers and Provision Dealers in United States and Canada. S. DAVIS, JR. & CO., 303 to 7137 Broadway,