The Nation 1887-05-26: Vol 44 Iss 1143
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
VOL. XLIV.—NO. 1143. THURSDAY, MAY 26, 1887.
MACMILLAN & CO’S NEW BOOKS. THE IRISH QUESTION. THE HISTORY OF THE LEGISLATIVE UNION OF GREAT Britain and [reland. By T. Dunbar Ingram, LL.D. 8vo, &3. ‘Nobody cau read this book without coming to the conclusion that many of the popular theories respecting the passing of the Union are absolutely without foundation.”—Scotsman. AUSTRALIAN DEFENCES AND NEW GUINEA : Compiled from the Papers of the late Major-Gen. Sir Peter Scratchley, R.E. By C. Kinlock Cooke, B.A., LL.D, With an Introductory Memoir. 8vo, $4. THE FIRST NINE YEARS OF THE BANK OF ENGLAND. An ge into the Weekly Record of the Price of Bank Stock from August, 1694, to September, 1703. By James E. Thorold Rogers, M.A. 8vo, Oxford Univ. Press, $2. ‘* An extremely valuable contribution to our financial history.”— Money. ‘* A book of supreme importance, discharged with rare skill and success. . . . Every banker and financier should make of 1t a constant companion.”—Butlionist. THE PRINCIPLES OF MORALS. Part 2. Being the Body of the Work. By T. Fowler, D.D., Professor of Moral Philosophy in the University of Oxtord. S8vo, Oxford Univ. Press, $2.75. BUMBLEBEE BOGO'S BUDGET. By a Retired Judge. With Illustra- tions, 12mo, $2. KING JAMES THE FIRST. An Historical Tragedy. By David Graham, Author of ‘ Robert the Bruce.’ 12mo, $2. LESSONS IN ELEMENTARY PRACTICAL PHYSIC: los” Prof. Bal- four Stewar+, M.A., and W. V. Haldane Gee, B.Sc. Vol. 2. Electric, “Se ~netism. 12mo, $2.25. ‘sr DYNAMICS FOR BEGINNERS. By the Rev. J. B. Lock, M.A. . 206, $1. ELEMENTS OF DYNAMIC, An Introduction to the Study of Motion and — a -_ and Fluid Bodies. By W. K. Clifford, F.R.S, Part 1. Kiaematic. Book 4. 12mo, $1. 75, AN ELEMENTARY TREATISE ON THE MATHEMATICAL THE- ory of Perfectly Elastic Solids. With a Short Account of Viscous Fluids. By William John Ibbelson, M.A. 8vo, 86. A New Edition, Enlarged, of ‘ Macmillan’s First Latin Course.’ MACMILLAN’S LATIN COURSE, FIRST YEAR. By A. M. Cook, M A., Assistant Master in St. Paul’s School. New Edition, Revised and Enlarged. 12mo, 9% cents. In this second edition exercises have been added in the Indicative Mood of the Passive Voice, an English-Latin dictionary has been provided (in addition to the vocabularies), and the Latin-English dictionary bas been enlarged so as to include all words used in the exercises. Should any teachers be so fortunate as to find the exercises more abundant than they require, the remedy is simple —they can omit at will. They will agree with the author that in this point excess i» vetter than defect. The Literary World says: ‘‘ Tois work, which is a praiseworthy attempt to make the difficulties of Latin easier at the beginning, deserves a little more notice than the many unsystematic books of exercises which seem to be the delight of publisbers and the despair of schoolmasters. It proceeds on a definite plan, and that plan, we venture to think, is the most satisfactory if not the only satis- factory one.” CAMEOS FROM ENGLISH HISTORY. Sixth series. Forty years of Stewart Rule—1603-1643. By the author of ‘ The Heir of Redclyffe.’ 12mo, £1.25. A New History of England for Schools. HISTORY OF ENGLAND FOR BEGINNERS. By Arabella B. Buckley, author of ‘The Fairy-Land of Science,’ etc. With additions by Dr. Robert H. Tubberton. With maps. Globe 8vo, $1.00. /mmediately. In this book Miss Buckley, whose skill in exposition has been abundantly testified in the field of natural science, has tried to set before young readers a connected history of the mse and development of England. ‘‘ While giving as far as ible,” says the author in her preface, ‘* the chief facts re- quired by students, I have been especially anxious to present a vivid picture of the life, the difficul- ties, ana the achievements of our ancestors; showing how our laws, our constitution, our trade, and our colonies have arisen.” 7 MACMILLAN & CO., NEW YORK, 112 Fourth Avenue.
he Nation 4 y PRICE 10 CENTS. Microbiblion. 1. QUINTI HORATIL FLACCL Parisiis (Di dot), 1828. Full morocco, China paper a i an ok c44000500endes $15.00 2. LE RIME DEL PETRARCA, Londra (Pick ering), 1822. Fall mor, 3'<x1', in.. $5.00 38. FALCONER (W.). The Shipwreck; and HAYLEY (W.). The Triumpbs of Temper London. 1825, Full mor. 5x24 in.. $9 00 4. PH-EDRI FABUL.®. Aurelie. 1773. Full mor, 3',x2', in OEP TMDnpagTer Pant gal “tenes DUPRAT & CO., } 5 ast s7eh Stree Booksellers, \ New Yer’. Library-Givers —anybody having occasion to make collections of books—can sift the book world at home and abroad for its best, make money go its furthest, and be re- lieved of all detail, through the under- signed (of the late firm, Lockwood, Brooks & Co., Boston), 25 years in the trade, with every advantage. 1. S. LOCKWOOD, 82 Equitable Building, Boston, ; J arvis-Conklin MORTGAGE TRUST CO., KANSAS CITY, MISSOURI. Capital Paid-up einssunsnasentestesesoenes . . 81,000,000 Offers its 6 PER CENT. Debenture Bonds of 8500, $1,000, and $5,000, running ten years, to TRUSTEES, GUAR DIANS, and INDIVIDUAL INVESTORS. Secured by first mortgages on real estate worth three times the amount of the loan, and heid by the MERCANTILE TRUST COMPA NY OF NEW YORK, Trustee. Secured also by the entire paid up capital of $1,000,000, It ake offers GUARANTEED SIX PER CENT. first mortgages on Kansas City business owe and tm proved farms in KANSAS and MISSOURI. Call at office or write for full particulars to ROLAND R. CONKLIN, Secretary. Equitable Building, New York. Messrs. Moraax & BRENNAN, Providence, RL. or JOHN M. SHRIGLEY, 411 Walnut St., Philadelphia, Pa. DIAMONDHAMS. S. DAVIS, JR’S., Cincinnati. FORTY-SIXTH YEAR. The Centennial Commission in 1876 reported an award to these Hams: “ First, the excellent flavor of the meat,” “Second, its good keeping quality, demonstrated by the perfect freshness of hams cured in 1873.” Sold by Provision Dealers and Leading Grocers in Prin- cipal Cities, who have circulars “ How to Cook the ‘ Dia mond Hams.’”’
Boe sr: IN aan AUTOGRAPHS, RARE PRINTS, ETC. Catalogues Free. mane &cCu., 4. W. saat 08. FY. ‘, SPECIALTY ; Better than the Best’
; ee ee een ees Pe
Page 2
The Wation. [Number 1143 The Nation. 4 WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED To Politics, Literature, Science, and Art. FOUNDED 1865. CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. A Fis ctitcncincadcascenssensnes Coccccccceccccoccocs 437 SUMMARY OF THE WEEK’s NEws... EDITORIAL ARTICLES: Parties and the Supreme Court Fisheries yo The French Cri SPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE: The Marriage of Louis XV CORRESPONDENCE: Western Mortg The Beverly Inc Tent Another View of Alfred Stevens i IE SII, vctcceccccscesbossss Deccceses “ Ils Being Built,” etc................ The Senatorial Situation in West Virginia. Something New on Metempsychosis REVIEWS: A French Constitutionalist on the English Constitu- tion . 45 Recent Novels.. Charles Reade The Evangelical! Revival in the Eighteenth C entury 455 —— Chinese Ghosts. 5 ew Books OF THE WEEK.......... FINE ARTS: The American Art Association TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three Dollars per year, in advance, postpaid to any part of the United States or Canada; to foreign coun- tries comprised in Postal Union, Four Dollars, The date when the subscription expires is on the Ad- dress-Label of each paper, the change of which to a sub- sequent date becomes a receipt for remittance. No other receipt is sent unless requested. The paper is stopped at expiration of the subscription, unless previously renewed. Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter or by check, express order, or postal order, payable to “ Publisher of the Nation.” When a change of address is desired, both the old and new addresses should be given. Address THE NATION, Box 794, New York. Publication Office, 210 Broadway. TERMS OF ADVERTISING. [No deviation. } On any page not specified, 15 cents per line|— each insertion; with choice of page, 20 cents, A column (140 lines), $20 each insertion; with chotce of page, $27. A page (3 columns), $60 each insertion; with % choice of position, $80, ae Twenty per cent. advance for top of column or|_ other preferred position, when specified ; where| positions are not specified, advertisements are ~ classified as far as possible and arranged in or- der of size, the largest at the top. Twenty per cent. advance for cuts, fancy or|— other letters not comprised in THE NATION|— fonts, and all other special typography (subject to ap- proval), Cuts are inserted only on inside pages of cover or fly-leaves, not on outside of cover, nor on pages num- bered for binding. Marriage and Death Notices, 50 cents each, DISCOUNT on yearly accounts amounting to $250, 10 per cent.; $500, 15 per cent.; $750, 20 per cent.; $1,000, 25 per cent. Credits are made December 31. Ona yearly account amounting to 52 pages the discount is one- third, Advertisements must be acceptable in every respect. Copy received until Tuesday, 5 P. M. THE NATION is sent free to those who advertise in it, as long as advertisement continues. The EDITION of THE NATION this week is 8,700 coptes, The Subscription List is always open to inspec- tion, *, * Copies ‘of THE NATION may be procured in Pari is of J. G. Fotheringham, 8 Rue des Capu- — and in London of B. F. Stevens, 4 Trafal- gar Square; George Street, 30 Cornhill, E. C.; and H. F. Gillig & Co., 449 Strand. Schools. Alphabetized, first, by States; second, by Towns. CONNECTICUT, ea. BrAck HALL SCHOOL. —A FAMILY ‘New and .--~ ac- CHaARLEs G. BARTLETT, Principal. CONNECTICUT, Middletown. TLSON GRAMMAR SCHOOL —A For r Ctreular address Rehoo! for BoT"a. Wieon, AM.” CONNECTICUT, Plainvi APLESIDE HO: WE SCHOOL FOR young ladies. Pupite powpenee pi college. Na- tive German and French teachers. Graduate of Bremen, a teacher of music. Academic and collegiate course. . Box 20, Plainville, Conn. District OF CoLomBIA, Washington, 1212 and 1214 14th St., and 1407 Massachusetts Ave. WE NORWOOD INSTITUTE. —A ect Boarding and Day School for young ladies Sel and little on. R. and Mrs. Wm. D. CaBELL, Principals. MARYLAND, Baltim NIVERSITY OF MARYLAND.—Law School, Eighteenth annual session, October 3, Address Henry D. HARLAN, Sec’y. MASSACHUSETTS, Belmont, Waverly Station. TSS L. A. HILL’S SELECT HOME school. Fifteenth year. Supetes advantages for those who wish to make up lost time. Pupils also pre- ed for colleges. Location delightful; grounds beauti- ul, ample, and well laid out for summer a winter out- door exercises, inc luding horseback ridin Send for circul ar. MASSACHUSETTS, Bos’ OSTON UNI VERSITY Law School. Address the Dean, EDMUND H. Bennett, LL.D. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston. NSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY. Courses in Civil, Mechanical, Mining, and Electrical eneneeting. Che Architecture, etc. James P. Munrox, Sec’y. FRANCI8 A. WALKER, Pres. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 18 Boylston EPARATION FOR T. HE fh INSTT- tute of Pochncinay oe and for Harvard College with- out Greek. Private ALBERT HALE. 259 Boylston Street. WA UNC Y. TALL “SCHOOL ( 59th Year). —Preparation for me Maas. Institute of Technol is aspecialty. Reference is made to the Institute Facul- ty. The location is the most attractive in Boston. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 25 Chestnut St. ISS HELOISE E, HERSEY WILL open a new school for girls in October. Special attention giv on to the English language and literature. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, No. 152 Huntington Ave. ME. E. DECOMBES’ FRENCH AND English Home yt for six giris will open Sep- tember 21, 1887. Price, $1,000 -. year. No extras. Highest references given and required. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 76 Marlborough St. REPARATORY SCHOOL FOR GIRLS. —Miss S. Alice Brown and Miss Amelia L. Owen will open, October 3, at 76 Marlborough Street, a School for Giris, twelve years old and over. The special design of Se & School is to prepare girls for College or Scientific rhools. A thorough school woining and advanced instruction in special branches will be given to pupils not contem- [ty a college course. Individual needs will be care- ully considered. A limited number of students, not members of the School, will be received for Laboratory practice. _ For further particulars, address Miss ROWN, : mt Bao MASSACHUSETTS, Brookline, Cypress S: ISS LEWIS’S BOARDING AND day school for girls. Fall term ~_— Oct. 3. MASSACHUSETTS, Cambridge, Larc OME FOR BOYS.—DR. ABBOT AD- mits not more than four boys SS his Ay fit for college or educate ——a a An with st of care in all respects. (nen yy loca- tion, with fine tennis-court. F. E. ABBOT, Ph.D., Pro- prietor. MASSACHUSETTS, Cambridge, 13 Appian Way. Rk. JOSHUA KENDALL'S DAY AND Family School for — ¢ .—Fits for col —SUMMER VACATION, Mr. Kendall will take charge of four boys (with or without instruction) during the months of July and August, at bis farm on Sutton’s Island, opposite Northeast Harbor, Mt. Desert, Me. Circulars. MASSACHUSETTS, Duxbury, Powder Point. CIENTIFIC PREPARATORY School. A home school for boys. Preparation for Harvard and Mass. Inst. Technol Laboratories. FREDERICK B. Knapp, 8. 8. (M. I. T.). MASSACHUSETTS, Plymou R. KNAPP’S WOME SCHOOL FOR Boys (twenty-first year).—Begins September 22, 1887. MASSACHUSETTS, Q DAMS aM CADEM Y, — PREPARA- tory and beanding school for boys. Third term be- gun April 13, 188 For all information address WituiaM EVERETT, Ph.D. MASSACHUSETTS, S. Williamstown, Berkshire Co. REYLOCK INSTITUTE.—A ‘PRE- paratory School for ron’ ie . Catalogues on apnitcation. EF. wits, Principal. MicuieaNn, Orchard Lak TCHIGAN MILITARY ACADEMY. A Select Boarding Sport for Boys. 30 miles from Detroit, and w wavarpomses tee beauty 2 ond healthful- ness, e courses of study are so active ‘pusiness and AT ed a thorough - para for College. S ttention paid to erastinal drill in Eng- lish work. Gradua’ ates receiving our diploma are admitted to the University of Mich., Cornell University, and the Mass. we of Techno without examination. Lieut. F. S. StroNG, U.S. A,, my Instructor. Ast. U.3.N tructor in Manual "Col. RoGers, Supt. Eng’r F. W. BARTLETT, Tra . For Chairs ides aes New HAMPSHIRE, P 3S A.C. MORGAN’ "s SCHOOL FOR me ladies reopens Sept. 28th ye “ A better, healthier, and of Blace for’ a 1 could scarcely be foun England. leasant- in New New JERSEY, Lawrence AWRENCE VILLE ‘SCHOOL. —JOHN C. Green Foundation. It is Retoante that applica- tions should be made from 3 to 6 months in advance of date of entrance. For Catalogue containing Courses of Study and Calendar, —¥ EV. JAMES — MACKENZIE, Ph.D. Yo UNG LA- Music and Art. New York, Aurora, C ELLS COLLE CE. OR dies.—Full oqteniote course. Session begins September 14, 1886. Send for catalogue. E. S. FRISBEE, D.D., Pres’t. New York City. 323 Lexington Avenue. ME. AND MLLE. CASTEGNIER'’S French and Drawing Classes will reopen on Octo ber 10, at their residence. Classes for children and ad- vanced pupils. Special classes for conversation Con- ferences on French literature. Six boarding pupils will be received. New York, New Hartford, near Utica. RS. COLLIER’ S SCHOOLAND HOME for girls from six to sixteen. Open the entire year. New York, Roslyn, Long Island. UMMER ‘SCHOOL FOR BOYS AND young men. For catalogue apply to Gro. B. Cor- TELYOU, Principal. The Bryant ae New York, Suspension Bri VEAUX COLLEGE. —A Military Boarding Gepost for Bo ve. WILFRED H. Muwro, A.M., President. New YORE, Syracuse. RS. CHARLOT TE MAY WILKIN- son’s Home School for Girls.—$1,000 per year. No extras. hang Fn ten pupils. Beautiful and healthful situation on the above Syracuse. School year be- * Refers to Hon. Abram S. Hewitt, ~ J Rev. Henry Ward Beecher, Thomas Wentworth * Higginson, Hon. Andrew_D. White, Louisa Lathe James B. Angell, LL.D., Hon. George V. N. RS. PIATT’S SCHOOL FOR YOUNG Ladies.—The next school year begins Wednesday, Sept. 2ist, 1887. Applications should be made early. PENNSYLVANIA, Bryn Mawr. RYN MAWR COLLE | GE.—A COLLEGE for Women, ten miles from Philadelphia, Offers aduate and unde uate courses in Sanskrit, Greek, tin, Mathemati nglish, French, Old French, ‘Ttalian, Spanish, German. cluding Gothic and Old High Ger- man, Histo Political Science, Physics Sn ml Bi- ology, inclu tng Botany, and lectures on Phil losophy. Gymnasium, with Dr. Sargent’s a) ratus pom Fellowships value | $450) in Greek, English, Mathematics, History, For " ~- as above. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, 4112 Spruce St. “ yNGLISH AND FRENCH BOA RDING and Day School for Young Ladies.—Resident French fea! (natural method of instruction). Special musical vantages, Miss E. F. Gorpon, Principal. Mrs. W. B. HypDE, Associate Principal. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, Chestnut Hill. RS. COMEGYS AND MISS BELL’S En a "gene and German Boarding School for Young —— a for College. ——_ grounds afford advantages for outdoor exercise. Additional class and recreation-rooms built during the past summer. PENNSYLVANIA, Phitade Iphia, Germantow: ALNUT LANE SCHOOL “AND Wellesley Preparatory (formerly Mme. Cle- ment’s) Roarding and Day School for young ladies. 31st year opens Sept. =. Academical and College Preparato- ry Courses. For circulars address Miss ADA M. SMITH, Mrs. T. B. a... Principals. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, 1350 Pine St. ISS ANABLE’S BOARDING AND Day School for Young Ladies will reopen Sept. 22. Teachers, etc. GENTLEMAN, NATIVE GERMAN, four years a student at Berlin, A.M. of Harvard, experien teacher and traveller, desires an engage- ment as tutor, companion, or in any suitable capacity. References from eminent men in Europe and America. Address J. T., 46 Holyoke St., Cambridge, Mass. 1 GENTLEMAN WILL RECEIVE one or two boys into his home for the summer, for tutoring or yest) Be Classics, mathematics, and mo- dern | uages (4). sidence retired and healthful, one hour sade quarter from New York. Highest references for character and capacity. = reasona ble. “oO Be * Nation. GRADUA TE OF HARVARD AND f a German university cum laude, and a4 success- ful teacher of five years’ ex d ment in classics. classics in the East. perienee, engage- erences to the ray | "professors of “ Classics,” Nation o'
Page 3
May 26, 1887]
The Nation. lil
Teachers, etc. A GRADUATE OF VA. MIL. INSTT- Py tute and A.M. of Indiana State University, desires a position in some reputable college or university, as pro- fessor or instructor of German, French, and Spanish. —~ 3% years at Berlin, Paris,and Madrid. 5 years’ rience. References given. a3 , P. O. Box 280, Gohtam d, Hanover County, Virginia. N EPISCOPAL CLERGYMAN WILL receive a limited number of boys, whose parents may wish to travel, into his home for the summer. Also college men received who wish special , eeenas for the summer months. Address W. L. R., P. O. Box 75, Lexing- ton, Mass. SPECIALIST IN CLASSICS (HAR- vard Ph.D.), who has taught several years. desires a professorshio in a ogkege or high school. Address C, Box 144, Tallahassee, UNIVERSITY OF VIRGINIA GRA- , duate, with experience in teaching, would tutor one or mcre boys during the summer. Box 246, Univ. of Va. ( HARLES W. STONE, Tutor for Harvard, 68 Chestnut Street, Boston. ke ROPE —A lady who has graduated from 4 auniversity. has travelled extensively in Europe, and 1s now teaching in a well-known college, is willing to accompany one or more young ladies abroad for a year of travel or study. Highest reference es given. Address *32.” care of the Nation. School Agencies. ARDEEN’S SCHOOL BULLETIN Agency, Syracase, N. Y.,may be depended on to furnish suitable teachers, and fo » inform no others. ‘DRIDGE TEACHERS’ AGENCY, 110 Tremont St., Boston, Mass.—College, high and pri- vate school work. . RANSOM BRIDGE, ‘Manager. — b ROCKWAY TEACHERS AGENC y, Times Building, Chicago, will supply superinten- dents, grade teachers, specialists with positions in Cen- tral, Western, and Southe ern States for ensuing year, CHERMERHORN’S TEACHERS’ Agency. Oldest and 5 fudd mo- rocco, gilt edges, $45. Sold only by Subscription. ‘ FY NHIS new edition of Les Miseradles is the first to present to English readers the greatest work of the greatest modern French writer in a form betitting its grandeur and beauty. No pains have been spared to make it as perfect as possible. The book contains near ly FOUR HUNDRED ILLUSTRATIONS from the designs of some of the most eminent French artists. De Neuville, the celebrated painter of military subjects; Scott, whose views of interiors are always admirable; E. Morin, ip furnishes some charming vignettes; Brion, . Bayard, Valnay, and others—all selected for oe special knowledge of the subjects assigned to them, and thoroughly acquainted with the places and personages described, thoroughly French in feeling and spirit, and in full sym pathy with the author. Last, but not least among the illustrators, is Vietor Hugo himself. Send for ilustrated circular. Please mention this paper. McDONNELL BROS., Publishers, 185 Dearborn St., Chicago. 2‘; > m“ € > cular free, BE. O, Fisk, 7 Tremont Place, Boston,
;
Page 4
1V The Nation. {Number 1143 Scribner & Welford’s NEW BOOKS. Cucumber Chronicles. A Book to be Taken in Slices. By J. Asnsy-Sterry, author of ‘The Lazy Minstrel,’ ‘Tiny Travels,’ &c., &c. fcap *vo, cloth extra, gilt top, with Four Collotype Il- lustrations. $2.00. OUTLINE OF CONTENTS: In Search of a Giant— Tubbieton's—A Lazy Morning—The Superior Animal—Change for Sixpence—An Ancient Hostelry—-A Lounge on the Lawn—¥tor Babies Only—The Wooden Midshipman—My Village— Christmas Traveliers— Bachelors—Amid Autumn Leaves—Miss Betsy Trotwood’s—An Early Walk —A Few Cigarettes—Windows—The Haunted Pre- cinct—A Firelight Sonata. *,* A volume of light and charming essays for summer reading. The Perfect Way; Or, THE FINDING OF CHRIST. By ANSA Bonus KInGsForp (M. D. of the Facul- ty of Paris), and EDWARD MAITLAND (B. A. Can- tab). Revisedand Enlarged Edition, being the first with the authors’ names, Square 8vo, cloth, uncut tinted paper, $3.75. “Itis a book that will be largely read by stu- dents of esoteric philosophy, theosophists, and investigators of recondite branches of thought and philosophy.”— Boston Transcript. Court Life in Egypt. By A. J. BuTLeR, author of ‘The Ancient Coptic Churches of Egypt.’ Demy 8vo, with Illustra- tions, cloth, $4.50. New Books in Limited Quan- tities. LETTERS FROM A MOURNING CITY. Naples during the cholera scourge in the au- tumn of 1884. By AXEL MUNTHE, Trans- lated by MAUDE VALERIE WHITE. With a Frontispiece, crown 8vo, cloth, $2.40. A NEW and POPULAR EDITION of LORD BEACONSFIELD’S LETTERS, 1830-1852. Including *“* Home Letters” and “ Correspondence with his Sister,”’ with Addi- tional Letters and Notes. With Portrait, crown Sve, cloth, $1.00. THREE YEARS OF A WANDERER'’S LIFE. By J. F. Keane, author of ‘Six Months im Meccah,’ 2 vols. 8vo, cloth, $8.40. THE LIFE AND ADVENTURES OF PEG WOFFINGTON, with pictures of the period in which she lived. By J. FItZGERALD MOLLOY, autbor of * Court Life Below Stairs,’ ete., ete. Third Edition. In one volume, cloth, $2.40. IN RUSSIAN AND FRENCH PRISONS. By Prince KrRopotkKin. 12mo, cloth, $3.00. “To many readers the malin interest of this book will lie in the facts it communicates, and these are of the most seasational kind. But tothe more thoughtful ic wilt suggest very serious problems, both political and social. It well aeserves to be read and deeply pondered.”’--Scotsman. THE REVOLUTION I1N TANNER'S LANE. By the Author of ‘ Mark Rutherford’s Autobiography’ and ‘Mark Rutherford’s Deliverance.’ Crown 8yo, boards, $3.00. Atheneum.—“ The writer has the good fortune, which he well deserves, to be remembered by ap- prectative readers from one to another or his rare works.” “The respectable and sometimes excellent translations of Bohn’s Library have done for Literature what ratiroads have done for inter- nal intercourse."—R. W. Emerson. ““T may say in regard to all manner of books, Bohn’s Publication Series is the usefullest thing I know.”—Thomas Carlyle. Bohn’s Libraries. CONTAINING STANDARD WORKS of EUROPEAN LITE- RATURE in the ENGLISH LANGUAGE, With Dictionaries and other Books of Reference, Comprising in all Translations from the French, rerman, Italian, Spanish, Scandinavian, Anglo-Saxon, Latin, and Greek. 687 Volumes, $1.40 or $2 each, with exceptions, RECENT .ADDITIONS, RANKE'’S HISTORY OF THE LATIN AND TEUTONIC NATIONS. Translated by P. A. Ashworth, Translator of Dr. Gneist’s ‘ His- tory of the English Constitution.’ HEINE'S TRAVEL-PICTURES : including the Tour in the Harz, Norderney, and Book of Ideas, together with the Romantic School. Translated by Francis Storr. With Appen- dices and Map. GOETHE’S CORRESPONDENCE WITH ZEL- TER. Selected, Translated, and Edited by A. D Coleridge, M.A. THE STUDENT'S HANDBOOK OF HISTO- RICAL GEOLOGY. By A. J. Jukes- Browne, B.A., F.G.S8., of the Geological Survey of England and Wales. With nu- merous Diagrams and I\lustrations. WERNER’S TEMPLARS IN CYPRUS. Trans- lated by E. A. M. Lewis. “ Werner was a Freemason, and his religious notions were, at the date of his writing this m, of a theosophic order.”’—Preface. ” ods ’ PAUSANIAS'S DESCRIPTION OF GREECE. Translated into English, with Notes and In- dex, by A. R. Shilleto, M.A. 2 vols. HOFFMANN’S TALES. The Serapion Breth- ren. First Portion, containing Thirteen Tales, Translated from the German by Ma- jor A. Ewing. HAUFF’S TALES. The Caravan—The Sheik of Alexandria—The Inn in the Spessart. Translated by 8S. Mendel. GOLDSMITH’S WORKS. A New Edition, con- taining pieces hitherto uncollected and a Life of the Author, with Notes from Various Sources. By J. W. M. Gibbs. 5 vols, FOSTER'S ESSAY ON THE IMPROVEMENT OF TIME. Together with Notes of Sermons and other Pieces. CHRISTIAN ICONOGRAPHY ; or, The His- tory of Christian Art inthe Middle Ages. By the late A. N. Didron. Translated from the French by E. J. Millington, and com- os. with Additions and Appendices, by . Stokes. 2 vols., with numerous Illustra- tions TALFOURD’S LETTERS OF CHARLES LAMB. With Explanatory Notes. New Edition, Revised and Greatly Enlarged by W. Carew Hazlitt. 2 vols. HAZLITT’S SPIRIT OF THE AGE;; or, Con- eagueey Portraits. New Edition. By W. C. Hazlitt. A SELECTION. ANTONINUS.—THE THOUGHTS OF M. AURELIUS. BAX’S MANUAL OF THE HISTORY OF PHILOSOPHY. BOSWELL’S LIFE OF JOHNSON (Centenary Edition edited by Napier). 6 vols. CERVANTES’ DON QUIXOTE, 2 vols. Translated. COLERIDGE’S WORKS. 6 vols. FAIRHOLT’S COSTUME IN ENGLAND. (Dillon.) 2 vols, HUGO’S (VICTOR) POEMS. Translated. MOLIERE’S DRAMATIC WORKS. 8 vols. PEPYS’ DIARY. 4 vols. RICHTER’S LEVANA, RICHTER’S FLOWER, FRUIT, AND THORN PIECES, SPINOZA’S CHIEF WORKS. Translated. 2 vols. STAUNTON’S CHESS HANDBOOK, *,* The above books will be sent upon receipt of advertised price. New Catalogue of Choice, Rare, and Second Hand Books ready. ready. SCRIBNER & WELFORD, Special Net Catalogue of Books greatly reduced in price 743-745 BROADWAY, N.Y. NOW READY. Scribner's Magazine FOR JUNE CONTAINS :. BONAPARTE. Frontispiece. From a painting by Appiani. SOME ILLUSTRATIONS OF NAPOLEON AND HIS TIMES. By John C. Ropes. With illustrations from the au- thor’s collection. COLLECTION OF UNPUB.- LISHED LETTERS OF THACKERAY. —ItI. Illustrated by portraits and reproduc- tions of drawings by Thackeray, (To be con- tinued in further numbers.) MISS PRINGLE'’S NEIGHBORS. A powerful story by Mrs. Robert Louis Ste venson. AN UNCOMMERCIAL REP UB- LIC. By W.T. Brigbam. With many il- lustrations. MISS PECK’S PROMOTION. Story. By Sarah Orne Jewett. Illustrated by E. W. Kemble. THE ETHICS OF DEMOCRACY. By F. J. Stimson. SETH’S BROTHERS WIFE.— Chapters XXI.-XXIII. By Harold Frede- ric. TWO RUSSIANS. Story. By Nora Perry. THE MAGIC FLIGHT IN FOLK- LORE. By H. E. Warner. POEMS. By H. C. Bunner, John Boyle O’Reilly, Henrietta Christian Wright, Ellen Burroughs, Mrs. James T. Fields, Gra- ham R, Tomson, Elizabeth Akers. ITH this number is completed the first volume of Scribner’s Maga- zine. The publishers have prepared a unique and handsome form of binding in English buckram cloth especially im- ported for Scribner's Magazine. Price of binding, 75 cents. FOR SALE BY ALL DEALERS. 25 Centsa Copy. $3.00 a Year. Charles Scribner's Sons, 743-745, Broadway, New York,
Page 5
The Nation.
NEW YORK, THURSDAY, MAY 26, 1887. The Week. Tue Democratic party is under obligations to the Administration of President Cleveland for removing another of the arguments tbat have done such effectual service against it during the last twenty years. Thousands of voters have been influenced in different sampaigns to continue voting an anti-Demo- cratic ticket because of the fear that, if the Democrats once got into power af- ter their long banishment from the table at which the official loaves and fishes are served, they would prove the accusation that their party was only an ‘‘ organized appetite,” and begin an era of extravagance that would be perilous to the country. There could be no more effectual answer to tbis than such an order as was issued by the President on Satur- day, making a reorganization of internal-reve- nue districts which wipes out of existence with one stroke of the pen twenty-two entire districts, with their official corps, saving to the taxpayers at least $100,000 a year. An act like this leaves the Opposition no chance to quibble over its motive. It is honest economy at the cost of a great many offices which, a few years ago, would have contributed largely to the managers of political campaigns and to the campaign treasuries. This order is so sweeping in its effect that it deprives six States—Nevada, Rhode Island, Delaware, Mis- sissippi, Maine, Vermont—and one Territory, Utah, of their internal-revenue collectors en- tirely, merging these offices with those of other States. Moreover,as the despatches show, every one of the officers whose place is thus cut from under him isa Democrat. When the campaign of 1888 comes to be fought before the people, this order, as an illustration of President Cleve- land’s sincerity as a civil-service reformer, will knock to pieces a thousand Republican argu- ments directed against his fidelity to his pledges, and founded on cases of individual removals of Republicans from official positions. Yet there are persons who think Cleveland will not be renominated !
Mr. Geo. Wm. Curtis acquired some celeb- rity at the hands of an interviewer a few weeks ago by means of the paradox put into his mouth that Mr. Cleveland would inevitably be renominated by the Democrats, and that Mr. Blaine would inevitably be renominated by the Republicans, and that neither of them would be elected. In his speech at the Commonwealth Club on Monday Mr. Curtis alluded to this dro) saying, as an introduction to a very clear defi- nition of the attitude of the Independents toward the two political parties which divide the country. Their anain purpose is to pro- mote the cause of civil-service reform, believing that in this way only can the true expression of the popular will, untrammelled by the pecuni- ary interests and the corrupting interference of office-holders and their immediate adherents, be obtained in the recurring popular elections.
An election should be the means of recording the preference and desires of the people as be tween opposing policies, and not the means of getting a living out of the Government. The Independents would carry this distinct aim into the campaign of 1888. They were well aware that neither the Republican party nor the Democratic party had any such aim at the pre- sent time. They were moved by the desire to get as many votes as possible from all the unattached groups—the Independents, the Prohibitionists, the Labor party, and the Irish party. It was proper for the Independents to take every ad- vantage of this desire to promote the cause which they had espoused. If this were called ‘* sitting on the fence,” he could say that the position was not an uncomfortable one to those who had no personal ambitions to grati ty. But he warned the ingenuous youth who were coming upon the stage of action filled with the desire to promote the public welfare, that they must tirst cast out personal ambition, and with it the fear of being ostra- cized by a political party. If there lingers in any man’s breast the desire for political prefer- ment, he is not capable of giving his full strength and his best service to the cause of reform,
We observe from an interview published in the Commercial Advertiser that Henry George has repudiated all connection with James G. Blaine, and all intention of supporting him for the Presidency, or, we judge, any other oftice. We cannot help thinking that this is a mis take on Mr. George's part. He would find Mr. Blaine an invaluable assistant in bis efforts to abolish Poverty. There is, in fact, no more determined enemy of Poverty on this continent. All his life long he has waged un- relenting war on it, and bas, as far as his own poverty is concerned, abolished it whenever it raised its head, with any weapon within his reach. In fact, Poverty knows so well the kind of man he is taat it keeps out of his way carefully. We must add, too, that we think Mr. Blaine’s help would be very im- portant in bringing about that just distribution of property which, Mr. George says, the Creator originally intended, but was never able to carry out, owing to the opposition «f the capitalists. With George, McGlynn, and Blaine and the Anti-Poverty Association at his back, we cannot help thinking the Almighty would at last be able to arrange human society on what George says was His original plan, which, however, until now He has never been able to carry out.
The Anti Poverty Society seems to us in danger of wasting its strength through want of a definite legislative programme. We would suggest, therefore, that instead of passing the time in denunciation of capitalists, they should work for an amendment to the State Con- stitution abolishing poverty in the State of New York, simply as an experiment. This amendment would doubtless be approved by the present and next Legislature, and would be ready for submission to the people in 1889, ,attractions of this
when it would be sure of unanimous adoption We would suggest the following as a suitable form Art. 17. Neither poverty nor = involuntary shortness of money, except as a punishment for crime, whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the State of New York after the first day of January, 1800. Doubtless other States, after witnessing the working of the new system in this one, would be willing to follow the example of New York, and in this way poverty would tx gradually banished from the country without causing any serious social or political disturb ance, such as might ensue if the whole Union abolished it at once.
Mr. Benjamin Butterworth of Ohio, as good a tariff Wharton Association man as Senator Sherman or Mr Barker, delivered an Hall in address at this city on Thursday evening in favor of reciprocity with Cana da by wholesale, as distinguished from the retail reciprocity of 1834 Mr. Hitt of Illinois, the Republican leader in foreign affairs in the House, has been the same lines as Mr. Butterworth in the columns of the Philadelphia Amerrecan, Writing on and both have a strong ally in Prof. Goldwin Smith We have to express our high approval of Mr. Butterworth’s address, He tells us that ‘protection to the industries of the United States against Canada means no more and no less than taking the money out of the pocket of one citizen and putting it into the pocket of another, the latter belonging to the protected and favored = class.” This is an ower true statement, and = it seems to derive new point and force coming from the protectionist side of the house, even though qualified by the explanation that a protective tariff may be justified when the can ditions of production in two countries are un- equal. Weare not inclined to taunt Mr, But terworth with the borrowing of an old free trade maxim. We think that free trade with Canada would be a good thing for both countries, and that it would lead to freer trade with other countries.
Au examination of the immigration returns points to a remarkable conclusion contrary to the generally accepted opinion concerning the country for agricultural populations. At no time in our history have opportunities for acquiring land abounded as in the last twenty years, during which the pre- emption and homestead laws have been in full force, and of themselves constituted a factor of great moment, while the opening of the West has been conducted with unwonted ener- gy. Yet not for fifty years has the percentags of immigrating farmers been so small as in the ten years 1873-83, as the following comparison will show: Percentage of farmers. 1820-30 . . 8.5 PEMD cveccvcancceaccvcetatvenseved peesege seene 13 << a. eseeeneire poate aon ane edine 14.5 DPD sec ebbeceded, Cosdeededens epadnedanddered 14 1s6i-os . 119 1873 83. PR OS TS 8.3 The decreased immigration of farmers might be accepted without criticism were there not
Page 6
438 The Nation. . [Number 1143 also a change in the character of immigrating farmers, and a change for the worse. The proportion of farmers coming to the United States from countries where the lowest grades of farming are the rule is_ be- coming larger each year, while that coming from countries which possess agri- cultural skill and intelligence is becoming less, or remains unchanged, In 1873 14.7 per cent. of the immigrating farmers came from the United Kingdom ; in 1886 the percentage was about the same (14.4), though it had fallen to 8.8 per cent. in 1882, a fall due chiefly to a decrease in the movement of farmers from Ireland. Denmark and France furnished nearly the same _per- centage in 1886 as in 1873. On the other hand, the share of Austria-Hungary rose from 1.2 per cent. in 1878 to 3 per cent. in 1886 ; of Italy, from less than 1 per cent. in 1873 to 7.3 per cent. in 1886 ; of Russia, from .5 per cent. in 1873 to 2.5 per cent. in 1886; and of Swe- den from 2.3 per cent. in 1873 to 7 per cent. in 1886. These are all very heavy increases, and clearly point to an abnormal develop- ment of this class of immigration in the most unwholesome lines. The percevtage of farm- ers coming from Germany fell from 48.6 in 1873 to 27.9 in 1886, and from Norway from 10.5 in the former year to 2.9 in the latter. There are several interesting points in the testimony of Mr. Jay Gould before the Pacific Railroad Commission. They all centre upon the consolidation of the Union Pacific with the Kansas Pacific, the Denver Pacific, and va- rious other ‘‘cats and dogs” that were going cheap about that time. Before the consolidation was effected, Gould controlled the Union Pacific by the ownership of a ma- jority of its stock. He suggested the forma- tion of the ‘‘ Kansas Pacific pool,” by which all the securities of this company except the first-mortgage bonds should be grouped to- gether for the purpose of making a consolida- tion with the Union Pacific on the basis of the relative values of the two properties, each class of securities in the pool being reckoned at its own value in the order of precedence. Kansas Pacific stock was taken as an ‘‘ index number” at 121¢ cents to the dollar. The bulk of this stock was held by St. Louis people, and they were quite willing to put it in at that figure, since it was rather more than the selling price in the market. After they had put it in, Gould offered them cash for their stock at that figure, which they gladly ac- cepted, since their highest anticipations were to get Union Pacific stock in place of it at the same ratio of 124g. Having got the Kansas Pacific stock, he controlled the pool as com- pletely as he controlled the Union Pacific Company. Accordingly, he withdrew the stock from the pool, and worked things so. that Union Pacific stock was ex- changed for it at par, resigning his position as a director of the Union Pacific while the transaction was taking place. Of course, such a swindle on the other stockholders of the Union Pacific could not be consummated without the concurrence of the Board of Di- rectors, and it remains to be seen how this was brought about, whether by giving them a share of the spoils, or by alarming them with the prospect of paralleling them by an extension of the Missouri Pacific, or by both. When asked how it hap- pened that he (Gould) was paid for his pool stock in new stock at par instead of other se- curities according to the original pool pro- gramme, he said that ‘‘ perhapsit was more convenient to the company.” This was a fine touch, artistic and sardonic, but not more so than another incident in which Gould pictures ‘*Ames and others” as saddling on him the Central Branch Railway at a high price by inviting him to go over the road, and then hold- ing back the freight trains fora week in order to give the appearance of a large business to his inexperienced eyes when he arrived. Mr. Gould is so much in the habit of judging of the value of a railway by mere surface indications, ignoring earnings and expenses, that ‘‘ Ames and others” would naturally resort to some simple device of this kind to take him in. A rather remarkable exhibit has been made in the annual report of the Illinois Central Railroad, showing cost of locomotive service for each year of the past thirty years. The cost per mile run has fallen from 26.52 centsin 1857 to 13.93 cents in 1886. This reduction has been effected wholly by inventions and improvements in machinery. But the figures show that the progress of invention has been even more remarkable than these figures im- ply, because the wages of engineers and fire- men have risen in the same period from 4.51 cents to 5.52 cents per mile run. In 1857 the engineers and firemen received as wages 17 per cent. of the entire cost of locomotive ser- vice. In 1886 they received 39 per cent. of the total cost. The table is as follows : I. C. R. R. CO. Performance of locomotives, Relation of wages to total cost per mile run: fire- tire- men per mile run, gineers and gineers and Total cost per mile | Cost of wages of en- oe S | men per mile run x © | Total cost per mile ey ° co SUSVOHOUOr Sr Or Oe SON St OVO Orie OO ofthe Or OOC®@-~) SSSRSSERSLISSFII s 05058 SRSz Currency. orc ot et ID mi OO TIAS TAS DANS Smo wb om inte bit Currency. ener NN NS > SHOT EN os OS AARP AMNG SS 9 > wo | In 1857 the engineers and firemen received 17 201-1000 per cent, of total cost. In 1865 the engineers and firemen 15 091-1000 per cent. of total cost. In 1867 the engineers and firemen 20 865-1000 per cent. of total cost. In 1886 the engineers and firemen 39 627-1000 per cent. of total cost. received received received Gov. Ames of Massachusetts has heeded the warning of the Boston Journal that ‘‘a change of 4,732 votes would give the State to the Democrats,” and that ‘‘ tHE Bri [for the division of Beverly] OUGHT NOT TO BECOME A LAW ” (to use the Journal's typography), since his veto undoubtedly defeats the measure. The Governor bases his action upon the ground that ‘very large sums of money, altogether dis- proportionate to the honest necessities of the case, have been raised and expended in the promotion and passage of the bill,” as ‘‘some $20,000 have been spent to indirectly influence the action of the Legislature.” He points out that ‘‘the abuse has been investigated, ex- posed, and rebuked in scathing terms by the committees of both houses,” one cf the reports closing with these words: ‘‘ Legislation cannot be pure unless free and untrammelled by in- sidious influences. These influences, how- ever, wherever, or by whomsoever ex- ercised, should be and must be em- pbatically and sternly condemned.” He thus disposes of the plea that the anti-division- ists have also spent money: ‘‘ Two wrongs do not make aright. It is a just as well as an equitable maxim that those on whom is the burden of making out a case shall come with clean hands, and not seek to excuse the lack of them on the ground that an opponent’s are soiled.” He quotes the Senate Committee’s report that the methods pursued ‘‘ deserve the strongest condemnation and the most effective remedy,” and concludes that ‘‘the strongest condemnation and the most effective remedy I can apply is a veto.” We have received letters from advocates of the division, one of which is elsewhere pub- lished, protesting against the view taken of the incident in these columns last week, urging that the division scheme was not, as it has been represented by Boston papers, a tax-dodging move, and dis- puting other minor points in our article, but laying most stress upon the plea that the old Beverly people had also used money. Waiv- ing discussion of these particulars, it still re- mains true that it would have been most scan- dalous if a measure pushed by such methods bad become a law, and Gov. Ames deserves praise for interposing his veto. Whether Texas votes prohibition into the Constitution next August or not—and the anti- party appears to be really alarmed lest the amendment may carry—the State is going to have a law which will largely prohibit the sale of liquor after the 4th of July. On that day an act goes into operation which forbids the use of a screen or any other device to obstruct the view into a saloon, and prohibits pool tables or any other tables used for games of chance in such places. Sales are forbidden to minors, stu- dents, and habitual drunkards, and to any per- son whose wife, mother, daughter, or sister gives notice to the dealer through the sheriff or other peace officer not to sell to such person. A bond of $5,000 that he will strictly comply with the law must be furnished by every deal- er. This is about as severe a law as could be framed and stop short of prohibition. The dedication of a monument to the un- known Confederate dead at Hopkinsville, Ky., last week, illustrated Low wide is the differ- ence between the South of slavery and the South of freedom. The spirit of the occasion was that which Senator Sherman expressed in his Nashville speech, when he said that ‘‘ the courage, bravery, and fortitude of both sides
Page 7
May 26, 1887] The Nation. 439 are now the pride and _ heritage of us all.” Mr. John C. Latham, jr., a Ken- tuckian, who was a Confederate soldier during the war and is now a banker in this city, con- tributed the money for the monument, and he originally hoped to make it a joint monument to unknown Federals and Confederates, though this purpose was defeated by the removal of the remains of the dead Federals to the Nation- al Cemetery at Fort Donelson. Letters of sym- pathy were read from various prominent Federal officers, and many old soldiers of both armies were present. The orativn was delivered by Mr. W. C. P. Breckinridge, who, like his famous uncle, was a Confederate soldier, and is now a leading member of the Kentucky delegation. It was noteworthy for its frank confession of the differences between the old and the new, and of the advantage of the new. ‘‘ This new generation now coming into power, this post-bellum generation who will soon be dominant,” he said, ‘has been trained North and South under auspices, influences, surroundings wholly unlike those by which we were trained. In the North the youth are not trained to overthrow slavery; in the South the youth are not trained to defend slavery. In the admission of new States, in the settlement of new Territories, there is no ‘balance of power’ to be maintained or overcome. No longer must the surplus of Southern enterprise be invested in new lands to be tilled by owned labor; and this surplus will seek, is seeking, new enterprises ; and diversified industries are supplanting the old-fashioned way of raising a single pro- duct. This will cause new rivalries, new com- binations, new adjustments, which will in time cause new political alliances.” The Christian Union for this week makes public a new phase of the trouble of the A. B. C. F. M. with its missionaries. Two appli- cants from Andover, Messrs. W. H. Noyes and D. T. Torrey, sons of missionaries, and very highly recommended, were set aside by the Prudential Committee of the American Board. These rejected, or ‘‘ deferred,” appli- cants ‘‘deemed it advisable to submit to the Committee a more ample statement than previously had been given of their motives in seeking appointment, the spirit in which they desire to labor, and their doctrinal beliefs,” with the hope ‘‘ that a full explanation of the manner in which they held opinions which had excited opposition to their appointment, and especially that a careful indication of the pro- portion and emphasis which they attached to these opinions, would open the way to a happy and peaceful adjustment of the issue which had been raised.” Accordingly, they prepared an eiaborate statement of their purposes and desires as _ missionaries, and of their religious belief, wherein they say: ‘‘ We believe, therefore, that the heathen without Christ are lost ; we believe also that, unless found by Him, or if rejecting Him when offered to them, they are lost for ever.” But they do not say that they believe that the hea- then cannot be ‘‘ found” by Christ after the end of earthly life—they say the ‘‘ now” of repent- ance is ‘‘the time of hearing the Gospel mes- sage” (whenever that may be). It is reported that the Foreign Secretary of the Board warmly advocated the acceptance by the’ Com mittee of this proffered basis, and was st, ported by members of the Committee. But the Home Secretary practically ignored the new overture, adhered to and emphasized the old issue, and was followed by a majority of the Committee. The Home Secretary wrote that ‘‘while recognizing the ability of the re- vised and carefully prepared statement,” yet, in view of non-withdrawal of previous statements in relation to ‘‘ the belief in a continued pro- bation ” for ‘‘ those who die without the know- ledge of Christ,” regarded as ‘‘ in harmony with Scripture” and ‘‘ a necessary corollary” of a belief in ‘‘the universality of the atone- ment ”; and ‘‘the hypothesis of a future pro- bation for those who have not the Gospel,” held as ‘‘not without support in Scripture”; the Com- mittee has ‘‘no option but to decline to appoint the candidate so long as he holds these views.” The incident will probably have its use in bringing matters toa crisis. As the Christian Union says: ‘‘ The question presses for deci- sion whether the churches who sustain the Board are willing that men of the character, ability, Christian spirit, and evangelical faith evinced in this correspondence shall be exclud ed from its employ.” It appears that the mob which attacked O’Brien in the streets of Toronto on Wednes- day week as a “loyalist” demonstration was composed of ‘‘some of our best people,” in that resembling the mob which fifty years ago dragged Garrison through the streets of Boston with a rope round his body. We are sure Mr. Goldwin Smith was not among them, but we greatly fear some of his disciples were. We have no great sympathy with O’Brien’s mission, and do not think that a man who ¢arries a domestic row into a foreign community can fairly complain if he finds himself surrounded by rioters. But on the other hand, the way in which the English majority has fallen back on brute force in dealing with the Irish question, the way in which so many lead- ing Englishmen frankly avow that they do not care how the bulk of the Irish people feel or think on any subject—that they are to live in the English way or go to jail or be shot—seems to justify the Irish party in resorting to any sort of agitation or protest within their reach. Lord Lansdowne would have more of the sympathy of intelligent men if his friends at home were not legislating to enable him to clap into prison with hard labor any- body on his estate who combines with his fel- low-tenants to bring about a reduction of rents by any meaps, however peaceable in them- selves, The labor troubles which have broken out again in Belgium are the natural and inevitable consequence of the competition with which Belgian industry has to contend in every market. Some of the late coal strikes were directed against companies which have not paid a dividend for eight or ten years. But behind the labor prob- lem there is grave political discontent with the smallness of the voting population, or of the ‘‘ legal country,” as it is called. The property qualification for the exercise of the franchise is so high that not over 2 per cent. of the population can vote. The Liberal Associa- tions have taken this up as the great question of the day, and are preparing for a Con gress in which an effort will be made to bring about some sort of agreement with regard to it between the Moderates and the Radicals. The latter demand universal suffrage, which the former oppose on the ’ ground that the ignorance of the masses is still so great as to make it dangerous, and suggest as the first step towards an extension of the suffrage the introduction of an educational qualification, in addition to, or rather in lieu of, the property qualification, where this is wanting. A Berlin despatch in the Politische Zeitung of Vienna, touching Gen. Boulanger’s retention as War Minister, says that Germany desires rather than fears his retention, as she thinks ‘his experiments with the army will prevent France from regaining the strong official posi tion she formerly held, while his vanity, which leads him to publish all he has done or intends to do, will afford security against military enter prises.” His vanity is an unkoown quantity and nobody can teil what it may lead to; but the cost of his experiments with the army is only too well known, and there is not the smallest doubt that they are fastening a mill stone round the French neck. In other words, the preparations for war are costing so much’ that the country will not be able to afford a war. The collision of the Celtfe and the Britannic last Thursday shows how litde value is to be attached to the blowing of fog whistles if the commanders of the ships give no more atten tion to the signals than the straining of eyes and ears to make out the direction from which the warning comes. The only importance of the whistle is to convey the information that there | is danger close at hand. The whistle does not locate the danger, it only announces its ex- istence. What is required in such a case is not half speed nor quarter speed, but the slow- est motion that the ship is capable of until the faintness of the sound proclaims that the danger is past. The motion should be so slight that the accidental mecting of the two at any angle whatever would not break a hole in either. It is seldom that a fog is so dense that the approach of one steamer towards another cannot be made out within a distance sufficient to stop both if they are going under low steerage way. A few years ago the City of Rome and the Belgenland came within a few feet of each other in a fog off Sandy Hook. Being in shoal water as well as in a fog, the Belgenland was moving with ex- tra caution, having just sufficient speed to stop within sight of any solid object in front of her. The City of Rome was not moving at all, being fast aground. Both were blowing their whistles. The former came bow on towards the midship section of the latter, but was able to control herself within a yard or two of the City of Rome's bull, If both had been out at sea in deep water and following the practice of ocean steamers as illustrated by the coming together of the Celtic and the Britannic, the Rome would probably have gone to the bottom as the Oregon went last year, i Bf i 2 i ; t
Page 8
440 The Nation. [ Number 1143 SUMMARY OF THE WEEK’S NEWS. (WEDNESDAY, May 18, to Tugspay, May 24, 1887, inciusive. } “ DOMESTIC. Tuer President issued an order on May 21 changing a number of the internal-revenue districts so that the fcl!owing districts will be abolished and the collectors thereof retired from the service: The District of Nevada, of Rhode Island, Second and the Fourth of Illinois, Eleventh of Indiana, Fourth of Iowa, of Delaware, Tenth of Massachusetts, of Mis- sissippi, Fourth of Missouri, of Maine, of Ver- mont, Third of New Jersey, Fifteenth of New York, Sixth of North Carolina, Sixth of Ohio, Nineteenth and Twenty-second of Pennsylva- nia, First of Texas, Fourth of Virginia, Third and Sixth of Wisconsin, in all 22 districts. The saving to the Government in salaries and expenses will not be less than $100,000 a year. A Grand Army post at Wilmington, Del., sent a resolution of thanks to President Cleve- land for vetoing the Dependent Pension Bill. In his reply he wrote : ‘‘ Those of our citizens not holding office, and thus entirely free from the solemn obligation of protecting the interests of the people, often fail to realize that their public servants are toa large extent debarred in official action from the indulgence of those charitable impulses which in private life is not only harmless but commendable.” The citi- zens of St. Louis have invited the President to visit that city late in September, while the Grand Army of the Republic will be in camp there, and he has accepted the invitation. The President has appointed Major J. L. Rathbone of California to be Consul-General of the United States at Paris. He is a native of Albany, N. Y., was educated at West Point, and served for several years on the staff of Maj-Gen. Schofield. Secretary Fairchild on May 20 issued a call for all the outstanding 3 per cent. bonds, amounting to about $17,000,000. The call will mature July 1. The circulars offering to redeem uncalled bonds of the 3 per cent. loan on presentation have been revoked, and no more bonds will be redeemed betore maturity. Lieut. Charles T. Hutchins of the navy, who is now stationed at the Naval Academy, is the winner of the prize given this year for the best essay on ‘‘ The Naval Brigade, its Or- —* quipment, and Tactics.” Ensigns lewes and Copps, who were sent to Glasgow last year to take the advanced course in con- struction and marine architecture, have finished the first term and won prizes. Secretary Whit- ney thinks the way is now clear, with such men, to make the construction corps of our navy se- cond to none. The Inter-State Commerce Commission has caused a letter to be published which sets forth that the Commissioners do not consider that they have the power permanently to suspend the operation of the long-and-short-haul sec- tion of the law, which they believe to be its vital point; that the letter and the spirit of the law are just as binding upon the Commission- ers as they are upon the public; and that the Commission, in the exercise of the limited dis- cretion given it to suspend the operation of this section in certain cases, will be governed by the letter of the law, and will order no suspensions except for special reasons and after an examina- tion as to the facts in each case. On May 23 the receiver of the Texas and Pacific Railway Company filed a petition in the United States Circuit Court at New Orleans to secure an in- terpretation of this clause of the law. The pe- tition sets forth that the receiver is an officer of the court, that duty requires him to keep the court informed of facts affecting the interest and revenues of the road, and that the execu- tion of this clause has been hurtful. The Supreme Court of the United States on May 23 handed down two decisions which up- hold the validity of the patent on driven wells. This brings to an end a legal fight of fourteen years, and will result in causing the holders of the patent to receive millions of dollars for roy- alties and infringements. These wells are used to supply several cities with water, among -_— are Brooklyn, N. Y., and Newark, After seven months the Federal Grand Jury has returned thirteen indictments against rominent politicians and election officers at ndianapolis, for forging or mutilating the election returns last fall—eleven Democrats and two Republicans. On May 19, Samuel Pasco (Dem.) was elect- ed United States Senator from Florida. Mr. Pasco, an Englishman by birth, was gradu- ated from Harvard College in 1858, but he bas spent most of his life in Florida. He is Speaker of the House of the present Legislature. The special session of the Legislature of Virginia adjourned May 23, with the State debt as far from a settlement as when it was convened for the special purpose of settling it. The political campaign will begin early in the summer, and the debt will again be a control- ling and vexed issue. The Legislature of Connecticut adjourned on oy 19. The failure to pass the High-License and Grade-Crossing Bills is cause of disap- pointment to a large proportion of the citizens of the State. The Governor of Massachusetts has signed the Employers’ Liability Bill, which will go into effect on September 1. An employee who is injured by the negligence of a fellow-employee exercising on Rpmenye authority as part of his duty, may recover of the employer or cor- poration just as if the injured person had not been in the service of such employer or corpo- ration, damages not greater than $5,000. The Saturday-Half-Holiday Law in this State went into effect last Saturday. The offices of the municipal government in this city and in most of the other cities of the State were closed at noon. Most of the commercial exchanges shortened the day's work, and the banks closed as early in the afternooa as they could. The tendency was for wholesale commercial houses to shut up, and a very few retail merchants took a half holiday. The factories and the workers inthe country did not, on the first day of the law’s operation, show that they were aware of it. At Morristown,-N. J., C. B. Reynolds, who was tried for blasphemy under an old statute and defended by Col. R. G. Ingersoll, was con- victed on May 20, and fined $25 and costs. On account of the ill-feeling provoked by Mr. G. W. Cable’s criticisms of the Southern race ag ys his engagement to deliver a lec- ture in the Columbia (S. C.) Opera-house this week, for the benefit of the public-school library fund, has been cancelled. A scientific expedition from Princeton Col- lege will go to Russia to observe the total eclipse of the sun on August 19, made up of Profs. Young, Libbey, and McNeill. The will sail on June 25, and on the way back will attend the meeting of the British Association for the Advancement of Science at Manches- ter. Mr. Charles Green of Trenton, an alum- nus of Princeton, will furnish most of the funds for the expedition. Archbishop Corrigan of this city has received a letter from the Pope, dated May 4, in which the Pope approves the “‘ firmness, joined with signal charity,” of his course in regard to “‘ the contumacious disobedience of a priest” (Dr. McGlynn), and ‘‘the false doctrines concern- ing the right of property disseminated ~ 4 him among the people in newspapers and public as- semblies.” The strike and lockout of workmen of the bu trades at Chicago are not yet formally ended, but not only are the employees beaten, but the employers have perfected an organira- tion with a determination to exclude from ¢m- ployment all who will not pledge themselves not to force other men to quit work. At a meeting of one organization of employees on Sunday a resolution was adopted asking men out of employment not to go to Chicago. At Haverhill, Mass., 3,500 operatives in the shoe shops were locked out forty-eight hours. They returned to work May 19, when an agreement was made by committees representing both sides. At Everson, Pa., a mob of 300 strik- ing miners on May 20 attacked a few men who were at work at the coke ovens, and beat them severely. The mob did injury also to property. Nearly the whole town of Lake Linden, in the Keweenaw Peninsula, Mich., where the Calumet and Hecla’s stamp mills are situated, has been burned, causing a loss of perhaps $2,000,000. The forest fires which have been burning in nearly every county in the State have destroyed much other property, and en- dangered many towns. Two persons, a man and his wife, have died of yellow fever at Key West, Fla., and a sister of the dead woman was stricken with it May 23. The disease has been traced to bedding which was brought from Havana. The Board of Health at Key West and the Marine Hospi- tal service are expected to deal successfully with the disease. Although these cases have caused great local alarm, there is little reason to fear that the fever will spread. The transatlantic steamship Britannic of the White Star Line, which sailed from this port May 18, on the afternoon of the next day, in a dense fog 350 miles out at sea, came into collision with the Celtic of the same line. Several steerage passengers on the Britannic were killed and a number badly hurt. The White Star vessels were accompanied to this port by the Marengo and the British Queen, which fell in with them on the next day, and kept near so as to render assistance if need- ed. Both steamships were considerably da- maged. A monument to Schuyler Colfax set up by the Odd Fellows was unveiled at Indianapolis May 18. Among the noteworthy persons who have died since the last number of the Nation was issued are ex-Gov. William Smith of Virginia, in his ninetieth year, who had twice been Gov- ernor and had filled many other public posi- tions ; Charles E. Stuart, once United States Senator from Michigan, who was one of Ste- phen A. Douglas’s ablest supporters ; Timothy Coop, a rich Englishman, who had identified himself with educational advancement in Kan- sas, and endowed the University at Wicbita, which he named Garfield University because of his admiration of the ex-President; William H. Macy, President of the Seamen’s Bank for Savings in this city; Albert Palmer, formerly Mayor of Boston. FOREIGN. Since the resignation of the Goblet Cabinet President Grévy has summoned MM. Clé- menceau, Ferry, Devés, Freycinet, Raynal, Rouvier, and other prominent party leaders, and had interviews with them in relation to the formation of a new Cabinet. M. Frey- cinet declined to undertake the task after consulting his friends, and Rouvier undertook it and gave itup. The centre of interest and of disturbance is Gen. Boulanger, in favor of whose retention in the War Office a consider- able demonstration has been made. An elec- tion was held on Sunday for a Deputy for the Seine. M. Mesurier, who is a Socialist, re- ceived 198,297 votes, and Gen. Boulanger 33,- 038. Gen. Boulanger’s candidacy was illegal, and his friends voted for him simply to show his popularity. The French State Council has rejected the appeals of the Orleans Princes for a reversal of the decree expelling them from the army, but the appeal of Prince Murat for restoration has been admitted, AYO OX RUNDE ate
Page 9
PRIOR AR a6e
May 26, 1887]
The Nation.
The total amount realized from the sale of the French crown jewels is 6,864,000 francs. More than one-third of this was paid by Tiffa- ny & Co. of New York, who were the largest purchasers. Dr Edme Félix Alfred Vulpiav, Dean of the Faculty of the French Academy of Medi- cine, died May 18, aged sixty-one; on May 21 Francisque Xavier Michel, the French arche- ologist and translator, died in his seventy-ninth year; and on May 238 died Sir Horace Jones, the English architect who designed Caversham Hall, the Royal Surrey Music Hall, the oak roof of the Guildhall, London, and the principal modern London markets. The work of Germanizing Alsace-Lorraine continues. An official census has been pub- lished showing that during the five years since 1880, 37,000 Germans have displaced 49,25 natives. It is estimated that if the native emigration continues in the same ratio, the provinces will be completely German within a quarter of a century. Crown Prince Frederick William of Ger- many on May 23 underwent a serious opera- tion for cancer in the throat. Prince Bismarck is said to desire the appo‘nt- ment of a Papal Nuncio at Berlin so that Dr. Windthorst may be deposed from the dictator- ship of the Centre party. It is reported that Prince Luitpold, the Re- gent of Bavaria, will receive Emperor Francis Joseph’s sanction to assume the Bavarian throne, and that Emperor William’s consent has already been obtained. In the Reichstag May 21 the Supplemen- tary Budget and Loan Bill passed the third reading. The Westphalian Manufacturing Company has closed its works in Russia, because of the heavy duties imposed by the new tariff on the material used. The Tzesarevitch was on May 18 installed with great ceremony at Novo-Tcherkask as Hetman of the Don Cossacks. The reception of the Russian royal family is reported to have been enthusiastic. There were processions and exchanges of presents and compliments. Al- though the whole route of more than 1,000 miles from St. Petersburg was guarded with soldiers, an effort was made to kill the Czar. Five more persons were executed at St. Pe- tersburg on May 20 for complicity in one of the recent efforts to kill the Czar. During their trial the details of a well-laid plan were made known. It has been reported that an- other effort was made to kill him before he re- turned from the Don Cossack country. The Porte has asked the consent of the Powers to the issue of a loan of £5,000,000, to be guaranteed by the Egypt and Cyprus tri- butes, Theconvention between England and Turkey provides that the British shall evacuate Egypt three years hence. If, after that time, internal troubles arise in Egypt, British and Turkish troops shall reoccupy the country jointly or separately, as the two Governments may agree. No other Power shall be allowed to intervene in Egyptian affairs. A representative of Lord Salisbury’s Govern- ment has begun negotiations with the Vatican, in a semi-official capacity, for the resumption of official relations between the Vatican and England. The House of Commons in committee on May 18 began the consideration of the second clause of the Irish Coercion Bill. This clause proposes to extend summary jurisdiction to conspiracy, boycotting, resistance to eviction, and the offences designated in the Whiteboy acts. An amendment limiting the operation of the clause to the offences committed after the passage of the act was rejected on the first evening. After the rejection of many other amendments and the limiting of the debate by frequent application of the closure rule, the
second clause of the bill was adopted May % by a vote of 235 to 103. Among the noteworthy political incidents of the week in England were a discussion in the Commons of the causes of emigration from Ireland, when Mr. Macdonald (Parnellite) asked: ‘‘Isn’t the increase of emigration partly due to the introduction by the Govern- ment of the Crimes Bill and the desire of the Irish people to escape its tyranny?” and the Speaker called for order; an amendment of fered by Mr. Chance (Nationalist), altering the title of the Crimes Bill to ‘* A bill for the sup- pression of free speech and trial by jury’; an appeal by Sir George O. Trevelyan, in a speech at Manchester to the Unionists, to refuse to sup- port a Government which struck at its Liberal rivals through the reputation of the Parnellites; and the votes of 143 members of the Eighty Club in approval of home rule and against coercion, against the votes of 55 in favor of co ercion and against home rule. Father Keller, the Irish priest who was im- prisoned in Dublin several months ago for re fusing to tell what he knew about the plan of campaign and the part he took in furthering it, was released on Saturday. When he arrived at Youghal he was met by a great crowd, which cheered and blessed him. By an election in the St. Austell division of Cornwall, May 19, to fill a vacant Parlia mentary seat, Mr. MacArthur, the Gladstoni an candidate, was elected by a majority of 211. Four hundred members of the House of Commons attended a jubilee service at St. Mar garet’s Church, Westminster, on Sunday. At the head of the procession were the Speaker, Mr. Gladstone, Mr. W. H. Smith, Lord Hart- ington, and Mr. Goschen, who were given the seats of honor. The service was conducted by the Archbishop of Canterbury, the Archbishop of York, the Dean of Westminster, and Arch- deacon Farrar, the hymns being composed especially for the occasion. The Bishop of Ripon preached the sermon. The London 7imes continues to publish ar- ticles on ‘* Parnellism and Crime,” which re- late to the work of Irishmen in America. The article of May 20 was about the League Con- ventions in Chicago and Philadelphia, and the Clan-na-Gael Society’s share therein. A committee of English iron manufacturers have asked Sir Henry Holland, Colonial Secre- tary, to urge the Government to protest against the proposed increase of Canadian import duties on metals. After September 30 all protective customs duties will be abolished in New South Wales, and the new duties will all be specific, and they will be levied on twenty-three classes of articles. There is an increase in the excise on tobacco, and an imposition of an excise duty of 4d. per gallon on all kinds of aie and beer and porter manufactured in the colony. The committee appointed some time ago by the House of Commons to inquire into the charges of misconduct against the London Corporation has reported that there has been much reckless expenditure, but that there is not sufficient evidence to establish the charge of corruption. Thirteen thousand workmen have struck in Belgium. The strikers in the district of Bori- nage have intimidated the employees of facto- ries where there was no strike and stopped their work. The houses of a number of work- men who would not strike have been blown up with dynamite. In consequence of nightly Socialist demonstrations in Brussels, proces- sions and gatherings in the public streets have been prohibited, and a number of persons have been arrested. The first anniversary of the birth of Alfonso XIII., King of Spain, was celebrated at Mad- rid May 17, with elaborate ceremonies. The Queen Regent remitted one-half the sentence of every soldier imprisoned for participation in —————_—_= == <= A rather violent shock of earthquake was felt at Monte Carlo on the morning of May 20 When Mr. William O'Brien, carrving on his agitation in Canada against Lord Lansdowne for eviciing tenants from his Irish estates, spoke at Toronto he was mobbed. While he was walking on the street with several companions, a mob formed around him g.oaning and hiss ing, and shouting ‘‘ Away, traitor!” ‘Down with the dynuamiter!” and ‘* God save the Queen!” ‘The policemen were overpowered, and the mob pursued him, throwing stones and eggs. Mr. O Brien made his escape, with a few bruises, by entering a bicycle shop, and returned to the hotel by another street. When he went to Kingston, be began a speech in the evening Without the least hostile demonstra tion. Butamob gathered on the outside of the building, and responded with groans to every cheer from the inside. When he came out of the hall the mob shouted, ‘* There he is!” ‘Kill him!” and threw. stones and bricks. Mr, O'Brien escaped, with wounds into the residence of an Irish citizen, The mob broke the windows of the hotel where they supposed he had found shelter, and they wrecked the office of the Canadtan Freeman, an Irish paper. The mob was made up of men who were aroused to a murderous piteh,and Mi O’Brien no doubt saved his hte by eluding them. He went to Niagara Falis and spent Sunday, and he was so badly bruised that a physician advised him not to travel or to exert himself fora time. But on Monday he went to Hamilton, where he had an engagement to speak. While he was returning at myght from the hall where he spoke, several shots were tired from a disorderly crowd, one of which wounded the driver of the cab next the one Mr, O'Brien occupied. At Toronto and Kingston two of the correspondents of New York news papers who were with Mr. O'Brien were hurt. The conduct of the mobs has been condemned by the Canadian papers of all parties. The Toronto Board of Trade on May 19 en- gaged in an animated debate on reciprocity with the United States. The dominant senti ment is expressed in the following clauses of the resolution adopted: ‘‘ That this Board be lieves that a commercial treaty creditable and advantageous alike to both parties can be framed in such a spirit of fairness as will afford the best ruarantee for its perpetuity”; but ‘‘ that it disapproves of any proposal to discriminate against Great Britain, whose protection we en- joy.” On the same evening Mr. Butterworth of Ohio, the author of a measure introduced in the last Congress looking towards the removal of customs duties by each country on goods imported from the other, addressed the Cana- dian Club of this city on that proposition. Talking on the same subject in this city on May 23, Sir Charles Tupper, Canadian Minister of Finance, said: ** It would be 1mpossible for the United States to consent to a customs union or free trade between Canada and the United States, as that would really mean free trade be- tween the United States and England. A com- plete customs union is simply impracticable. It would be quite impossible for Canada to adopt a tariff so hostile to the mother country.” The Mayor of Nanaimo, B. C., has sent an appeal to the Mayors of several of the larger cities in the United States for money to relieve the suffering caused by the recent mining dis- aster. Thirty-nine widows and more than 100 children are destitute. Mr. Manning, United States Minister to Mexico, has presented to President Diaz the request of the American Government for the remission of the death sentence of the three Mexican officers condemned by court-martial to be shot for their violation of American ter- ritory and judicial jurisdiction at Nogales. A Chinese railway, from Taku to Tien tsin, was opened May 20, The first railway in China was a short line from Woosung to Shanghai, forty miles, half of which was finished and opened for traffic in 1876. It was purchased
the revolt of last September, by the Chinese Government ard closed in 1877,
Se oe ts nee oe pam uaree e
Page 10
442 The Nation. | Number 1143
PARTIES AND THE SUPREME COURT. A REPUBLICAN organ in Chicago, comment- ing upon the vacancy in the Supreme Court and the suggestion that a Southern man will be appointed to fill it, says: ‘‘The South looks to the ultimate reconstruction of the Supreme Court as the means of unsettling all the re- sults, and destroying all the fruits, of the loyal victory in the war. With five rebel jurists on the bench of that court this could easily be ac- complished. It is no wonder that they de- mand the first vacancy. If itis filled as they desire, it will require but three more such ap- pointments, including Jusiice Field, to give them a majority of the bench.” The organ is of the opinion that ‘‘ the honest people and the loyal people of the country will hold their breath, metaphorically speaking, until Presi- dent Cleveland shall make an appointment to fill this vacancy,” and it declares that “‘if a rebel successor to Judge Woods should be ap- pointed, it would be a cause for both dismay and shame.” We have already pointed out that the time for talking about the danger of appointing a ‘‘rebel” on the Federal bench has passed, since there has sat for several years upon such a bench,as United States District Judge in Ten- nessee by the appointment of a Republican President, David M. Key, who ‘entered the Confederate Army in 1861, and served through the entire war as Lieutenant-Colonel of the Forty-third Tennessee Infantry,” and who in 1868 supported Seymour and Blair upon a platform declaring that ‘‘ we regard the recon- struction acts, so called, of Congress as a usurpation, and unconstitutional, revolution- ary, and void.” The criticism of the Chicago paper, how- ever, goes beyond this question of appointing a man who fought for four years, like Mr. Key, to overthrow the Government. It involves the theory that there is a sharp line of division be- tween Republican jurists and ‘‘ rebel jurists” — meaning by the latter term Southern Demo crats appointed to the bench—and that a bench containing a majority of Southern men would interpret the Constitutional amendments and the reconstruction legislation in such a way as to ‘‘ unsettle all the results, and destroy all the fruits, of the loyal victory in the war.” It ought to be sufficient answer to this anti- quated sort of rant that, outside of a few hope- less Bourbons, nobody in t!< South has any desire to unsettle all the results of the war. Except by such Bourbons, it is frankly con- fessed by everybody that it is most fortunate for the South that the war resulted as it did. But the Chicago paper doubtless means that a Supreme Court with several Southern mem- bers would reverse the attitude of that tribunal toward the legislation of Congress regarding the South, and especially regarding the negroes, and toward the relation of the States to the Federal Government. Only the most cursory acquaintance with the recent tendency of the Supreme Court while all of its nine members but one were Republicans (and he, too, a Re- publican when Lincoln appointed him) is re- quired te show that this old theory of the Re- publican party has already been largely over- thrown. One of the reconstruction acts which Judge
Key, like other ‘‘ rebels,” regarded as ‘‘ uncon- stitutional, revolutionary, and void,” was the act ‘‘to enforce the right of citizens of the United States to vote in the several States of the Union and for other purposes,” popularly knewn as ‘‘the Kuklux Act.” Four years ago the Republican Supreme Court, without a dis- senting voice, pronounced this act unconstitu- tional. Another law, which was regarded as the cap-sheaf of reconstruction legislation, was the Civil-Rights Act passed in 1875. In 1883 the Republican Supreme Court, with but a single dissenting voice, decided that the vital sections of this act were ‘‘ unconstitutional and void.” The theory upon which that famous act was based, the Court held, ‘‘ would make Congress take the place of the State Legislatures and su- persede them,” and it characterized as ‘‘ ab- surd” the pretence that, under the Constitu- tion, such a theory could be maintained. The relation of the States to the Federal Government is a question upon which it might be expected that partisan lines would be drawn upon the Supreme bench, and especially in the interpretation of a provision like the Eleventh Amendment to the Constitution, which declares that ‘‘ the judicial power of the United States shall not be construed to extend to any suit in law or equity commenced or prose- cuted against one of the United States by citizens of another State, or by citizens or subjects of any foreign State.” But when the question of the right of the holders of Virginia coupons receivable for taxes to pay them in as such, and compel the State to re- ceive them, was brought before the Supreme Court, the eight Republican judges divided evenly on the point whether the eleventh amendment protected the State from being sued; and, oddly enough, Judge Field, the Democratic member, who thus held the cast- ing vote, threw it against the States-rights doc- trine. It is thus evident that there is no “‘ rebel ” or Democratic interpretation of the Constitu- tion, in contradistinction to a ‘‘ loyal” or Repub- lican interpretation. The decision of the Su- preme Court on such a fundamental issue as that involved in the Civil-Rights Act would not have been different if every judge had been a Democrat, like Judge Field, or a ‘‘ rebel,” like Judge Key. Moreover, when one considers questions of constitutional interpretation liable to arise in the future, it becomes still more manifest that there is no dividing line between parties. Take the broad issue of paternalism in government, which underlies the question of Federal aid to education in the States, for example. The stoutest opponent of this scheme on constitutional grounds has been Senator Morgan of Alabama, a ‘“‘rebel.” But no- body more vigorously sustains the South- ern Democrat in this stand than Senator Hawley, the Union soldier and __possi- ble Republican candidate for President in 1888, who holds that propositions like the Blair bill are ‘‘ fatal to the very fundamental theory of the Government,” and declares that ‘the tendency towards a consolidation of the entire powers of government is one of the strongest to-day, and one of those most danger- ous to the republican experiment, as our fathers understood it.” There can be no doubt that, if any measure based upon this paternal
| theory of government were to become a law, and to be submitted to a Supreme Court of which Morgan and Hawley were members, the “loyal ” man and the “‘ rebel” would unite in declaring it unconstitutional. And while there are many Northern Republicans who do not agree with Senator Hawley, just as there are many Southern Democrats who do not agree with Senator Morgan, there are so many who agree with him in the hearty praise which he has bestowed upon Mr. Cleveland for resist- ing the tendency to paternalism by the Texas Seed Bill veto, that his party standing and his availability as a Presidential candidate are not injured by his agreement upon this vital point with ‘‘a copperhead President” and a ‘*rebel” Senator. It is fortunate for the country that neither in _ the legislative,nor in the judicial department of the Government, nor among the voters them- selves, is there any longer a dividing line between ‘“‘rebels” and ‘‘loyal” men. In the Louisiana slaughter-house cases, which involved the question of the scope of the Thirteenth and Fourteenth Amendments, Justice Miller, in concluding the unanimous decision of the court against the broad interpretation which had been asked, iu 1871, used this striking language: ‘In theearly history of the organization of the Government, its statesmen seem to have divided on the line which should separate the wers of the nations] Government from those of the State Governments; and though this line has never been very well defined in public opinion, such a division has continued from that day to this. ‘* The adoption of the first eleven amendments to the Constitution so soon after the original instru- ment was accepted shows a prevailing sense of ones at that time from the Federal power. And it cannot be denied that such a jealousy con- tinued to exist with many patriotic men until the breaking out of the late civil war. It was then discovered that the true danger to the perpetuity of the Union was in the capacity of the State or- ganizations to combine and concentrate all the powers of the State, and of contiguous States, for a determined resistance to the general Govern- ment, * Unquestionably this has given great force to the argument, and added largely to the number of those who believe in the necessity of a strong national Government. ** But, however pervading this sentiment, and however it may have contributed to the adop- tion of the amendments we have been consider- ing, we do not see in those ametdments any purpose to destroy the main features of the general system. Under the pressure of all the excited feeling growing out of the war, our statesmen have still believed that the existence of the States with powers for domestic and lo- cal government, including the regulation of civil rights—the rights of person and of property—was essential to the perfect working of our complex form of government, though they bave thought roper to impose additional limitations on the tates, and to confer additional power on that of the nation. * But whatever fluctuations may be seen in the history of public opinion on this subject during the period of our national existence, we think it will be found that this court, so far as its func- tions required, has always held with a steady and an even hand the balance between State and Federal comer and we trust that such may con- tinue to be the history of its relation to that sub- ject so long as it shall have duties to per- form which demand of it a construction of the Constitution or any of its parts.” The course of the court since this decision was rendered fifteen years ago has justified the confidence which Judge Miller expressed, and the same hope for the future may now be enter- tained, whether Mr, Cleveland follows the ex- ample of Mr. Hayes in appointing a ‘‘ rebel,” like Mr. Key, ora ‘‘ loyal” man who bolds to the Hawley creed.
Page 11
May 26, 1887] The Nation. FISHERIES FALLACIES. Ir was stated not long since in the London Times that the Earl of Rosebery declared, when resigning office, that the most serious question he left behind him was the dispute between the United States and Great Britain respecting the fisheries. Lord Iddlesleigh is reported to have made, shortly before his death, a similar declaration as to the gravity of the controver- sy. Both these statesmen betrayed, by these expressions of opinion, an intelligent appre- hension of the character of the dispute, and of the consequences not unlikely to result from its cormtinuance. A prolonged cor.troversy between nations, while always fraught with danger, is peculiarly liable to end in hostilities when waged, as the fisheries dispute actually is, be- tween contiguous countries and in a spirit of exasperation on both sides. The history of the oyster fisheries in the Chesapeake Bay is a strong domestic illustration of the dif- ficulty of maintaining good relations between the hardy champions of rival fishing in- terests, even when they belong to friendly communities under one central government, with no questions of tariff or of rival nurseries for seamen to excite cupidity or inflame na tional pride and resentment. Three modes of settling the fisheries dispute have been suggested. One is that recently made by Lord Salisbury, as at least a tem- porary expedient, of an exchange of free fish- ing in Canadian waters—with the same privi- leges and regulations for American as for British fishing vessels—for a free market for Canadian fish in the United States. Another mode is that proposed by Mr. Bayard, of a permanent set- tlement on the lines of the Treaty of 1818, by a definition of the limits of the exclusive and common fishing grounds under that conven- tion, a joint system of police by the two Government:, and the admission of Ameri- can fishing vessels into Canadian ports for the purchase of bait and other supplies, ete. A third mode of settlement which has been proposed, is to abrogate the Treaty of 1818 and fall back on the Treaty of 1783. It is to the last mode that we wish to direct attention, for, while it is not a new idea, it has lately been accepted in certain quarters with not a little favor, and has received at the hands of Mr. John Jay, late Minister to Vienna, a very thorough and de- liberate exposition, published in the form of a letter to Mr, Evarts. An examination of Mr. Jay’s pamphlet will lead to the disclosure of fundamental fallacies in his position, and throw not a little light on the general aspects of the dispute. Under the Treaty of Peace of 1783, between the United States and Great Britain the fisher- men of the United States had, as is generally known, the right to take, dry, and cure fish in the territorial waters and on the coasts of British North America. The enjoyment of this right was suspended by the war of 1812; and when, after the close of that conflict, the American fishermen sought to resume their rights under the Treaty of 1783, the British Government objected, on the ground that the war had put an end to the treaty. This was denied by the United States, which contended that the Treaty of 1783, be- ing a treaty of separation and settlement, for the division of common property, and not a grant of rights and privileges by the mother country to the United States, was permanent in its character and not affected by war. The Treaty of Ghent, concluded December 23, 1814, for the purpose of ending the war of 1812, contains no mention of the fisheries, It is known, however, that they formed a fre- quent topic of discussion betweea the nego- tiators of that convention, and that the British Commissioners unequivocally declar- ed that they would not thereafter ‘‘ grant” the liberty of fishing, and drying and cur- ing fish, within exclusive British jurisdiction without an equivalent. (Memoirs of J. Q. Adams, vol. iii., p. 119 e¢ seg., December 22, 1814.) The American Commissioners main- tained the position that the rights of the Ame- rican fishermen were not affected by the war, and thus the issue was made, The disagree- ment was complete. The controversy thus begun continued until the conclusion of the Treaty of 1818. The in- tervening period was one of great irritation, and the two countries were continually on the verge of a hostile outbreak. Mr. Adams gives in vol. iii. (p. 265 e¢ seq.) of his Diary an account of an interview with Lord Batburst, in London, in September, 1815, in which his Lordship declared that American ves- sels could not be permitted to fish in British territorial waters; to which Mr. Adams replied, maintaining the American position, and promising soon to address his Lordship a note on the subject. In volume iv. of the Diary we find an account of a con- versation between Mr. Adams and the British Minister at Washington, on the 18th of March, 1818, in which the latter stated that Ad- miral Milne, commanding the Jamaica station, had issued orders, like those of the preceding year, to seize all American vessels which might be found fishing within the British jurisdiction. Mr. Adams replied at length, and closed by saying that the United States would probably have to fight for the matter in the end. The Minister replied that Great Britain had gone as far in the direction of ac- commodation as she could go, The orders issued by the British Admiralty from 1815 to 1818 to seize American vessels found fishing in British waters were not con- tinuously enforced, but were at various times, and for various periods, generally with a view to negotiations, suspended. But the Diary of Mr. Adams, as well as other contemporaneous records, shows that many seizures were actual- ly made, Such was the condition of things when, on the 20th of October, Messrs. Gallatinand Rush concluded the Treaty of 1818. By that con- vention the United States ‘‘ renounced for ever any liberty heretofore enjoyed by the inhabi- tants thereof” to fish within three marine miles of any of the ‘‘ coasts, bays, creeks, or harbors” of his Britannic Majesty’s do- minions in America not included within certain limits, in which the right of fishing was expressly reserved to American fishermen by the treaty. This in terms con- stituted a permanent settlement of the boun- daries between the common and exclusive fisb- ing grounds. We are now prepared to consider the pro position, as advocated by Mr. Jay, to settle the present dispute by abrogating the convention of 1818, and resting on that of 17838. In support of the right of the United States to abrogate the Treaty of 1818, he cites the annulment by Congress in 1798 of the treaties of 1778 with France, for the reason, among others, that those treaties had been rm peatedly violated by the French Government, He also cites the opinions of several publicists to show that the violation of a treaty by one contracting party releases the other, This proposition no one will controvert. But when he comes to apply this doctrine, Mr. Jay is notso fortunate. After saying that the violation of the Treaty of ISIS by the Canadians has given us a right to abrogate it, he declares ‘‘ that its abrogation would restore to force article 3 of the Treaty of Peace in 1783, the operation of which was suspended by the Treaty of IS18, but which would revive in its original force were the Treaty of 1818 abrogated ; precisely as the latter treaty, after being suspended by the adoption of the Reciprocity Treaty of 1854, was revived by its termination in 1866, and, after being again suspended by the Treaty of 1871, was again re stored by its termination in 1885," The fundamental fallacy of this deduction is the singularly erroneous assumption that the Treaties of 1854 and 1871 ‘suspended ” the Treaty of 1818. The Treaty of 1818 has, in fact, remained in force from the moment of its ratification to the present time. Both the Treaty of 1854 and that of 1871 provided, in terms, that ‘tin addition to the liberty secured to the United States fishermen” by the convention of 1818, they should enjoy for a certain time a common right of fish- ing with her Britannic Majesty’s subjects on certain other coasts than those to which such right was confined by that convention. In a word the Treaties of 1854 and 1871 tempo- rarily restored what the Treaty of 1818 had renounced. They did not supplant nor sus pend a single right enjoyed under it. The Treaty of 1818 was made as a permanent set- tlement of the whole subject; and if its abro- gation, instead of restoring to American fisher- men the enjoyment of the rights and liberties defined in the Treaty of 1783, merely remitted us to the disputes of 1815-1818, the practical side of the suggestion +dvocated by Mr. Jay could not be regarded as of more value than its argumentative basis, Another prevalent fallacy is the criticism of the negotiators of the Treaty of 1818 for having yielded without cause the rights of the United States in the fisheries. However sound may have been the American position as to the per- manency of the fishing articles of the Treaty of 1783, we have seen, from the review of the situation between 1815 and 1818, how little the argument availed the American fisher- men in practice. Nevertheless, Mr. Blaine declares, in his ‘Twenty Years of Congress ’ (p. 617, vol. ii.), and his view has been widely spread, that the Treaty of 1818 wes “‘ altogether the most inexplicable in our diplomatic histo- ry.” He says that ‘ neither in the minute and important Diary of Mr. Adams, nor in the pri- vate letters,as published, of Mr. Gallatin and Mr, Rush, is there the slightest indication of a =}. fates
Page 12
PEL The Nation. [Number 1143 any reason for recommending, or any necessi- ty for conceding, the treaty.” And, to com- plete the case against the negotiators, he final- ly states (p. 619, vol. ii.) that ‘‘ of this extra- ordinary renunciation Mr. Rush wrote many years after: ‘We[Mr. Gallatin and himself] inserted the clause of renunciation; the British plenipotentiuries did not desire it,’” We have already seen what the Diary of Mr. Adams has to say on the subject, and that in March, 1818, he expressed to the British Minis- ter the opinion that the matter would probably have to be settled by war. Such was doubtless the apprehension of Messrs. Gallatin and Rush; and ‘he latter, in an appendix to his ‘ Resi- dence at the Court of London,’ giving an ac- count of the negotiations, expressly so declares. ‘Neither side,” says Mr. Rush, “ yielded its convictions to the reasoning of the other. This being exhausted, there was no resource left with nations disposed to peace but a com- promise. Great Britain grew willing to give up something. The United States con- sented to take less than the whole.” The compromise having been agreed upon, the question of phraseology arose. The American plenipotentiaries inserted and insisted upon the word renounce, not, as Mr. Blaine would lead us to suppose, for the purpose of giving up something the British plenipotentiaries did not wish them to yield, but for the following rea- sons, stated by Mr. Rush in the appendix above quoted: ‘‘(1) Toexclude the implication of the fisheries secured to us: being a new grant; (2) to place the rights secured and renounced on the same footing of permanence; (3) that it might expressly appear that our renunciation was limited to three miles from the coasts.” It thus appears that the renunciation was a final reassertion by the American plenipotentiaries of the permanency of the fishing articles of the Treaty of 1783. Compelled, as they believed, to yield something for the sake of peace, they renounced what they gave up, so asto preclude the supposition that in making the compro- mise they had abandoned the principle. THE FRENCH CRISIS. Te way in which what was called the ‘‘ Pagny incident,” or, in plainer English, the dispute over the arrest of Schnaebelé, the French Com- missary, between France and Germany, has ended, has had a reassuring effect in France touching Prince Bismarck’'s state of mind, and Prince Bismarck’s state of mind is to-day, for Frenchmen, most important thing in the world. V aebelé was arrested, after being en rerman soil, under a charge of high treason against the German Govern- ment, it was feared, and not without reason, that it was simply a device to tempt the French Government or press into some extravagance of behavior which would justify the men of war at Berlin in taking offence and putting in motion once more that ‘‘ flail of destiny,” as it was called in 1870—the German Army. The conduct of all parties on this occasion showed how great is on all sides the dislike of war. The French press and politicians were extraordinarily patient and moderate, and though the German press was less so, Bismarck was never calmer or more judicial-minded. After due consideration, he wrote a dry and almost technical despatch to the French Am- bassador, saying that Schnaebelé would have been justifiably arrested if he had come on Ger- man soil of his own accord ; but that it was clearly proved that he had crossed the line on the invitation of his German colleague, Gautsch, toarrange some administrative business, and that this invitation ought to have operated as a safe- conduct. This said plainly enough that if there was to be another quarrel with France, it would not begin about a trifle. But this does not entirely clear the sky. It is felt all over Europe that, although Bismarck will not fight France about a trifle, neverthe- less tliere are limits to his patience, which are well settled in his own mind, but which he has only revealed very vaguely andindefinitely. He has intimated that he assumes the existence of a determination on the part of France to attack Germany some time or other, as one of the fixed facts of the political situation. His policy, therefore, is to be regulated by the modes and degrees in which the French give expression to thisdetermination. So people watch France eagerly in order to form an opinion as to what he will do. They are now ask- ing what effect the importance attached by popular sentiment to Boulanger’s remaining in the Ministry will have on him, and how he will take Boulanger’s plan of ‘‘mobilizing a corps d’armée,” asa test of the efficiency of the new organization, at a cost of 3,600,000 francs, Boulanger has done wonders in preparing the French for war, and he bas done it in such away as in some degree to restore the old French military pride and self-confidence. But he has done it at enormous cost in money. The French budget is now a subject with which no French Ministry has found itself capable of dealing. Deficit follows deficit year after year with unfaltering regularity, and each deficit is met by temporary loans which have ended in creating a floating debt, the amount of which the Government shrinks from revealing in its entirety. The shrewdest financial heads in France, in fact, such men as Léon Say and Leroy Beaulieu, believe that a Treasury collapse of some kind is not far away. In this terrible problem Boulanger is undoubtedly the worst element, and by Bou- langer we do not mean simply the man, but the popular sentiment which he represents—the determination to put a large part of the national resources, both mental, moral, and material,into preparations for war. He weighs on the budget with tremendous force, and in fact makes it unmanageable. It is the budget which has driven the Goblet Ministry from office, and no one is willing to succeed him, and take it up, as long as Boulan- ger is securely ensconced in it. Al! the cool heads in the Chambers, known under the general name of ‘‘ Opportunists,” orrational politicians, as we should call them, see this clearly, but there is not one of them, proba- bly, who is willing to assume the task of form- ing a Cabinet with Boulanger a necessary mem- ber of it; and yet that Boulanger should be a necessary member of every Cabinet is appa- rently what popular sentiment demands. This is now the situation, but it can hardly be called immediately alarming. To provoke a German irruption, in the present condition of the army and the finances, would be a cala- mity so awful that every man in France over forty probably shudders at the thought of it, and the country is still governed by men over forty. For a similar reason it seems very unlikely that Bismarck will take of- fence at the carrying out of the plan of mo- bilizing a corps d’armée. Not only would it cost over a million dollars in hard cash, besides causing an immense derangement of industry, but probably nobody knows better than Bis- marck that it would reveal defects in the French organization which it wouid take years to cure. On the matter of military preparation no people is so liable to fall into immense delusions as the French, They have never yet, except under the first Empire, begun a great war in a state of complete readiness, and never began one with- out supposing that their readiness was complete. It has been well said that they are a warlike and not a military nation. The very ardor which carries them readily to the battle-field makes them shrink from the indomitable pains- taking in details which, on the part of the Ger- mans, enabled Moltke, as the story goes, when the news of the declaration of war was brought to him on the night of the 15th of July, 1870 and found him fast asleep, to turn over and go to sleep again after telling the messenger that the proper portfolio ‘‘was in the second drawer on the left,” Even if the story be not true, it is emblematic of the infinite labor with which the Germans prepare to fight. HOME RULE AND ENGLISH JOURNAL- ISM. One of the interesting but in many ways de- plorable results of the bitter political contest now raging in England, is the disappearance of what may be called the independent press, the two foremost representatives of which were the Spectator and the Economist. There has prob- ably been no foreign or remote observer of British politics who has not, during the past forty years, been placed under deep obliga- tions to both of these journals for the extent to which they furnished him with cool and impartial judgments of men and things, even at, or perhaps we should rather say, especially at, times of great party excitement. We doubt, indeed, whether any financial jour- nal has ever played the part which all financial journals ought to play in poli- tics—that of a perfectly disinterested looker- on—so faithfully as the Hconomist in Mr. Bagehot’s day. Political criticism reached in its columns, when he was its editor and principal writer, a point of excellence to which perhaps no other periodical has ever attained. He saw with remarkable clearness that not only must a financial journal bring judicial-mindedness to the discussion of purely financial questions, but to the discussion of all questions. No- body ever long relies, in pecuniary matters, on an adviser who takes passionate views of financial enterprises, or allows his forecast as to the results to be colored by his likes or dis- likes of persons engaged in them. Not only is this true, but it is also true that nobody relies long in pecuniary matters on an adviser whose judgment in any of the affairs of life is greatly clouded by his prejudices, or whose temperament drives him into hasty or ill con-
Page 13
May 26, 1887] The Nation. A445 sidered action. In other words, to be listened to respectfully by people who have money to invest, or who are making plans for the re- mote future, a man must be habitually cool, and cultivate what we may call the scientific way of looking at human activities of all kinds, In Mr. Bagehot’s day the Economist played this part in an eminent degree. He brought to the analysis of the political phenomena of the day precisely the same sort of acumen which he brought to the analysis of the last bank report or a new funding bill. Reading his articles was very like having a private and confidential talk with a shrewd and experienced manof the world, who had special means of information, but was perfectly indifferent to the bearings of the phenomena which he explained for your benefit. In fact, he brought to modern pol tics the same spirit of disinterested inquiry and minute observation which he brought to the examination of the history of national growth in his remarkable book on ‘ Physics and Politics.” He knew that his influence in the commercial world was dependent on his constantly cultivating in all things a spirit of philosophical detachment ; that it would not do for him to rail about Disraeli, or grow en- thusiastic over John Bright, if he wished to be listened to with respect about the bank rate or the trustworthiness of a foreign loan. The London Spectator never could boast the judicial temper of the Economist, but it placed its readers under somewhat similar obligations by its steady application of moral standards to politics, and its constant habit of examining both political men and mea- sures from the moral point of view. Its love of analysis, the manifestations of which in some fields—that of theology, for instance— were excessive, always found instructive and interesiing expression in its treatment of poli- ticians and pending questions of legislation. One might not agree with it; one might often grow wearied of its sublety or over-re- finement, and often accuse it of fancifulness, and of too much prophetic spirit, and too great eagerness for signs and wonders; but its columns were always edifying to any one who was watching English politics simply as an observer, for the simple reason that he might always feel sure that the editor did not hold a party brief, and was not bound to ex- tenuate or defend anything for party reasons, or to consider the effects of his utterances on party fortunes, and that he was treating every public man on his merits without regard to his political antecedents or surroundings. We are sorry to say that the home-rule dis- cussion has changed all this. There are no more violent party papers in England to-day than the Economist and Spectator. We do not mean by this simply that they argue against home rule, and are deeply impressed by its incon- veniences or dangers. We mean that they at- tack it in precisely the same spirit and with the same weapons as the 7imes or the Standard, and are as worthless to a disinterested observer desirous of seeing the situation exactly as it is. For instance, there is nothing so tiresome and often disgusting, as all American news- paper readers know, as the way party journals have of dividing the voting population into two groups, one composed of ignorant and reckless people, blinded by their passions and hostile to, or careless about, property or order ; the other composed of sober, thought- ful, industrious, patriotic, and God-fearing people, whose supremacy in national affairs is necessary, not only to peace and secu- rity, but to the very preservation of the social fabric. The division of the leading politicians is of somewhat the same sort. On one side are a band composed of reckless de- magogues, without conscience or honor, seek- ing the ruin of their country for purely personal profit, through falsehood and perversion, and utterly indifferent to the consequences of their policy as long as it keeps them in power or enables them to win it; on the other, a band composed of calm, wise, moderate men, speaking and acting in politics with a single eye to the national prosperity and glory, es- chewing all sophistry or misrepresentation,and constantly uttering pregnant truths, without caring for the effect on their own personal or political fortunes. In England there has hitherto been less of this sort of classification than here, ow- ing to the transfers of power from one party to another, which take place more frequently under the Parliamentary system than under ours. Every Englishman who has reached the age of forty has seen probably two or three of these transfers, so that it is impossible for the party press or orators to work him into that state of fear and suspicion about his political opponents in which Republicans, for instance, lived with regard to the Democrats during the twenty years before 1884. Nobody has hither- to been able to persuade the Liberals that if Salisbury came into power he would probably betray the Government to its enemies, and plunder the Treasury; or persuade the Tories that Gladstone would surely propose an equal division of goods and knock down the price of all securities 50 per cent. But just new the Economist and Spectator even, to say nothing of the rest of the Conservative press, talk in this to us very familiar strain. The Economist has got so hot in its fury against the Irish that it actually commends military courts-martial as the best tnbunals for the punishment of crime—military officers, it says, making excellent jurors—and objectiona- ble only on account of the prejudice against them among philanthropists and Americans. Chamberlain, who was its déte noire two years ago, when he was denouncing inequality of taxation, is now its model statesman. But the Spectator far outdoes the Economist, as might have been expected, in the fervor with which it surrenders its soul to Liberal Union- ism. It is impossible to read without a smile its accounts of the way in which not only com- mon sense and common honesty, but mentai capacity, has deserted that immense body of the British people who follow Mr. Gladstone. Not only are the Irish representatives all thoroughly dishonest and unscrupulous, and elected by 4,000,000 of rogues and assassins—this was to have been expected—but the Gladstonian leaders have become igno- rant, absurd, sophistical, and stupid. Glad- stone, John Morley, Harcourt, Bryce, Rosebery, Childers, Russell, and Trevelyan now never open their mouths without falling into obvi- ous blunders or misrepresentations or fallacies Eloquence and knowledge have both desertec them. They have lost either the desire or capacity to present any question in a right light. Notonly are they wrong occasionally, in the old human way, but they are always wrong, in the diabolical way, On the other hand, Salisbury, Chamberlain, Hartington, Selborne, James, Holland, Goscben, nay, even Smith, Balfour, and Churchill, never speak without hitting the nail on the head. Their reasoning is always perfect ; their illustrations apt; their forecasts timely and correct. In fact, the state of mind just now of the quon dam independent journalist in England is enough to give a pessimist an illustration in which he would delight, of the tlimsiness of the human mind and the weakness of the human character. THE MARRIAGE OF LOUIS XV. Paris, May 7, 1887. THe marriage of Louis XV. and a Polish Princess, Marie Leczinska, is one of the most romantic incidents of French history in the eigh teenth century. M. Paul de Raynal, a French magistrate, has lately studied the circumstances which brought about this extraordinary union between the sovereign of the most powerful coon try of Europe and a poor and exiled Princess, | knew, in my youth, a gentleman who was old enough to remember Louis XV. He spoke al most with emotion of the fascination which was exercised by this sovereign in bis youth. Louis XV. was like a prince of fairy land. He was as handsome as the day, to use a familiar expres- sion of our ancestors ; his manners were charm- ing ; he had been brought vp with the greatest care. He had been promised, since his earliest infancy, to the daughter of the Duke of Anjou. the Infanta of Spain. Why was the Infanta suddenly dismissed, and why did the young King marry the daughter of a Polish nobleman, who had been kept on the throne of Poland tor a few years by the protection of Charles XII. of Swe- den, and who afterwards had become an exile and a pensioner of the French Government / When Louis XIV. died, the Duke of Orleans was proclaimed Regent of the kingdom, and as- sumed an almost absolute power. He asked in 1721 the hand of the Infanta, Anna Maria Victo- ria, who was then three years old, for the young King of France. Philip V. gave his consent at once. The Regent obtained at the same time the hand of the Prince of the Asturias for his own daughter, Mile. de Montpensier. Louis XV. was then eleven years old, and entirely under the influence of his preceptor, Fleury, Bishop of.. Fréjus. When the matter was brought before the Council of the Regency, tells us that the eyes of the King we that he, said ‘‘ Yes” in a low voice when asked to give his consent to the marriage, which was in consequence declared. Saint-Simon was sent as Ambassador to Spain, and he gives in his memoirs full details of his. mission. He paints with his usual vigor Philip V., who had become so different from the hand- some Duke of Anjou ; the Queen, who was his second wife, who had exiled the Princesse des Ursins, and completely enslaved the King and condemned him to a solitary and monotonous life. The Infanta was exchanged at the frontier ; for Mile. de Montpensier ; one of them was in, tended to wear the crown of France, the other the crown of Spain. The exchange took place on January 9, 1722, on the Bidassoa River. Soon afterwards the marriage of Mile. de Montpensier was solemnized in Madrid. The Infanta, a mere . ; b a #4 e ee o— a H q ' | | +] . : ‘
Page 14
446 The Nation. [Number 1143 child, was brought to Paris, and, on her arrival, Louis XV. gave her a doll worth 18,000 livres, ‘Tout le monde,” says Barbier in his Journal, ‘trouve le mariage original.” The King lived at the Tuileries ; the Infanta was lodged at the Louvre. When Louis XV. attained his majori- ty, he was left almost immediately without a guide, though he was only entering his fourteenth year. Cardinal Dubois died suddenly, and the Duke of Orleans was struck by apoplexy on the 2d of September, 1723, at the age of forty-nine years. The Duke of Bourbon, the first Prince of the House of Condé, took the office of Prime Minis- ter, as Fleury, who was the real master of the mind of Louis XV., did not yet dare to take it for himself. Monsieur le Duc, as he was called, was only thirty-one years old. He had lost an eye, and his contemporaries called him the sinis- tre or the borgne. He lived at Chantilly in great style. He had iost his wife, and was entirely un- der the sway of the celebrated Marquise de Prie. Mme. de Prie was the daughter of a wealthy con- tractor for the army ; she was handsome, witty, ambitious, and affected an infidelity which was then the fashion with some members of the aris- tocracy. She was the declared mistress of the Duke of Bourbon. The Ambassador appointed to Spain by the Duke of Bourbon was the Comte de Tessé, who was Marshal of France. Tessé had served with great distinction in the French armies, and had already filled many diplomatic missions. He ac- cepted his new post notwithstanding his old age, and he was on his way to Spain when the news arrived of the sudden abdication of King Philip. The Prince of the Asturias was proclaimed King under the name of Louis L, and it was known that all his friends were enemies of the French alliance and partisans of the alliance with Aus- tria. Louis did not like his French wife, who, says M. de Tessé, in one of his despatches, ‘‘ had learned many things at the Palais Royal which she had not forgotten in his palace.” The union of Louis XV. and the Infanta had been solemnly promised, but the Duke of Bourbon was very ad- verse to it. The Infanta was only six years old, and she could not become the wife of the King before the age of ten. The prolonged celibacy of Louis XV. was a danger for the succession and a danger for the King himself. Louis XV. took no pleasure in the Infanta; on the contrary, he could but feel for her a sort of aversion. If Louis XV. died without ason, the crown would pass to the Duke of Orleans, the son of the Regent, a vir- tuous prince who hardly concealed his contempt for M. le Duc and for Mme. de Prie, Mme. de Prie kept ber lover in a state of con- stant inquietude, and prepared him by degrees for a rupture with Spain and for the dismissal of the Infanta. It did not hinder her frum asking for a grandesse for her husband and for her children; this request recurs often in the corre- spondence of Marshal de Tessé under the name of Vaffaire des charbons. The Marshal does not seem to have been very anxious to procure this favor for Mme. de Prie, The King of Spain fell ill suddenly, and, at the age of seventeen years, died after a very short attack. Thecrown passed to the head of the second son of Philip V., the In- fant Don Ferdinand, who was only eleven years old. The Duke of Bourbon was very much alarmed at the consequences of this change. It was clear that the young King would be com- pletely in the hands of the grandees of Spain, that the kingdom would fall into complete anar- chy. He wrote to Philip V., who was the only true friend of France in the peninsula, and begged him to come out of his retreat and assume the power bimself. Philip consented, with some reluctance; and M. le Duc, confiding in his senti- ments, in his love of quietness and peace, in his affection for his nephew, Louis XV., thought that he could now, without any danger of war, send the Infanta back to Spain and find another wife for the King of France. Mme, de Prie knew that she would never obtain the grandesse from the pious and scrupulous old King of Spain; it was thought by her as well as by her lover that the time for action had come. Secret councils were held at the Duke of Bour- bon’s a few weeks after the death of the young King of Spain. They were composed of M. de Fréjus, of Marshals Villars and Uxelles, of the Comte de la Marck, the Comte de Morville, and M. Pecquet. The Duke of Bourbon explained the reasons for a prompt marriage of Louis XV. with another Princess than the Infanta, and the reasons that would prevent Philip V. from de- claring war on France. M. de Morville issaid to have exclaimed: ‘‘ Certainly, the Infanta must be dismissed, and par le coche, so that it may be done sooner.” The question at once arose, What Princess would be chosen in place of the Infanta? Seventeen names were pronounced in a special report made by Morville, among the others, ‘* Ma- rie, daughter of King Stanislas Leczinski of Po- land, aged twenty-one.” There were objections to all the names: some were promised, some were ill, some were of another religion. The Duke of Bourbon, however, gave his preference to Prin- cess Anna, the eldest daughter of the Prince of Wales, and asked the French Ambassador to in- quire of the Ministers of George I. if they would give her tothe King of France, on condition that she should become a Catholic. Time pressed; at the age of seven, the Infanta was to be solemnly affianced to the King of France. The Spanish Minister in Paris had no suspicion of any change in the intentions of the French court. Marshal Tessé was suddenly re- called and replaced by the Abbé de Livry,chargé @affaires in Portugal. Louis XV. was made to write a letter to the Pope announcing that he could not marry the Infauta, and begging him to soothe the irritation of Philip V. Livry had to deliver at the same time a letter to the King of Spain announcing the change. Philip V., who had been previously made aware of its contents, refused to receive it; he showed calmness and dignity, but his wife, Elizabeth, was furious, as were all the Spaniards. The Abbé de Livry was ordered to leave the Spanish territory, and Mlle. de Beaujolais, who had been promised to Don Carlos, was sent back to France. Mme, de Prie did not much approve of a mar- riage with an English or a Russian princess; she wished for some modest, poor, plain princess, whom gratitude would always tie to her. She found all she desired in the Polish Princess, who had neither wealth, nor pride, nor fortune. She espoused her cause with much warmth, and what she desired was soon after the wish of the Duke of Bourbon. She was helped by the English Government. The proposal which had been made by the Comte de Broglie for the young English Princess had been thought very flattering; the Count had shown the King a picture of Louis XV., who was at that time most beautiful. The religion, however, had been thought an insur- mountable difficulty, and a negative answer was finally returned. The disappointment of the Duke of Bourbon was great. He thought for a moment of on his sisters, Mile. de Vermandois, who had brought up in the Convent of Fontevrault an wished to become a nun. President Hénault and some other writers of the time say that Mme. de Prie went to Fontevrault under an assumed name, and saw Mile. de Vermandois, She spoke to her of her brother and mentioned Mme. de Prie. At the mention of this name, Mlle. de Vermandois interrupted her with vehemence, and manifest- ed the greatest contempt for the person who had enslaved her brother. Mme. de Prie changed the conversation; her mind was made up—it was not for her to put the crown of France on the head of Mile, de Vermandois. From that moment the Polish Princess became the most eligible candidate. The humility of her position was an advantage, as it tended to soothe the irritation of Philip and of the Spaniards; the Infanta was not sacrificed to a great princess or to a powerful country. The marriage ceased to be a political affair. The offer was made, but not before Louis XV. had seen a portrait of the young Marie, She was not handsome, but she was agreeable and had a very pleasing counte- nance. Marie Leczinska was six years older than the King, but every objection was put aside. It is easy to judge of the emotion of the poor ex- iled King of Poland when he was informed of the project of the King of France; after having re- ceived the letter of Louis XV. at Wissembourg in Alsace, he entered the room where his daughter was sitting with her mother: “My daughter,” said he, ‘let us kneel and thank God.” ‘My father, are you recalled to the throne of Poland?” ‘‘ No, my daughter,God is more merciful—you are Queen of France.” The marriage was for a long time a happy one. The Queen hed a very amiable disposition, When she made her presents to her ladies she said mo- destly: ‘‘ This is the first time in my life I have been able to make presents.” She did not, how- ever, accept the tyrannical friendship of Mme. de Prie. Fleury, the Bishop of Fréjus, found in her an ally, and she became an unconscious in- strument in the disgrace of the Duke of Bourbon. The victory of Fleury became complete. The Duke was dismissed from the Council, and Mme. de Prie was exiled to one of her estates. She fell into a state of despair, and the memoirs of the Marquis d’Argenson tell us that she lost her beauty, and that in 1727 she poisoned herself. By a strange concatenation of circumstances, which completes the romance of the life of Marie Leczinska, this Princess, who was so poor that her father, when the offer of the King of France was made to him, tad just pawned her jewelry, had, in fact, brought to France a magnificent dower: her marriage had for one of its conse- quences the reunion of Lorraine to the kingdom. Correspondence. WESTERN MORTGAGES. To THE Eprror oF THE NaTION: Sr: Allow me a reply to *L.” Western de- velopment has always been the profitable oppor- tunity of Eastern capital. The older always lend to the younger States. Europe did it fifty years ago; now we do it from our own profits in West- ern growth and trade. Western mortgages are no experiment. System and experience have simplified the matter in bcth convenience and safety for the investor. The incident of loss by foreclosure has actually been eliminated. While foreciosure itself has been reduced to a fraction of 1 per cent., the profit of foreclosure is absolute- ly assured. A Western corporation of tried, pru- dent, and wealthy men, who themselves super- vise the loans, and examin> titles and values, and select their mortgages, can and does actually produce the choicest 6 per cent. security which the experience of insurance companies, savings banks, and private investors has been able to find during the past fifteen years. Of this there is ample evidence in the reports. We cite one— the Bank Commissioners of New Hampshire, 1886, page 419. There was no foreclosurein West- ern loans; all foreclosure was in Eastern mort- gages.— Yours, H. W. Hau.
Page 15
May 26, 1887] The Nation. 447 THE BEVERLY INCIDENT. To THE EpIToR oF THE NaTION: Sir: That the “‘ Beverly Incident” should be of sufficient importance to deserve an editorial certainly makes it worth while to correct, from the record, certain unintentional misstatements of fact which have found place in your article: (1.) The move for separation is not an out- growth of the summer population. In the Bos- ton Globe of May 19 you will find the testimony of old inhabitants of the Farms who have been familiar with the plan for separation for more than twenty-five years. 2.) It is not a tax-dodging move. The Farms are to take one-half of the town debt. The inte- rest on this, the payment to the common sinking fund, and the Farms’ share of other common fixed charges, make a rate of 8.95 on a thousand, upon the valuation of the Farms for 1888, or 14.89 on a thousand, upon the valuation for 1885. Adding the lowest possible tax for the expenses of the Farms themselves, the rate could not be less than $13 on the valuation of 1886, or $21 on the valuation of 1885. The beavy valuation of 1886 (said to be by way of punishment for the at- tempt to separate) was one of the chief grounds of complaint made by the Farms at the hearing this year. There is no hope of a tax rate below $15 at the Farms for many years tocome. The rate in Boston last year was $12.70. (3.) It is not true that the question was tried last year ‘‘on its merits” and this year not on its merits. Precisely the contrary is true. Last year there was so little :nterest taken that it was impossible to induce the Legislature to got Be- verly and see for themselves. This year nearly all the members of both houses, in bodies of thirty or less, went to old Beverly and to the Farms, and examined the ground and the people in the presence of representatives of both sides, (4.) There was no material difference in the amount of money raised and spent by the Farms people last year and this. This year it was $18,- 000, last year it was $14,500. (5.) In both years money was raised and lob- bies were employed by both parties alike, and both parties used precisely the same methods. This is stated in as many words in the findings of the committee in their report. (6.) Substantially the same counsel acted for the parties on both sides in both years. While agreeing with you in your comment on the use of lobbyists, it must be borne in mind that the chief fault lies with the legislators them- selves. If each member would kick a lobbyist instead of listening to him, the lobby would melt away in a week.—Very truly, OBSERVER. ANOTHER VIEW OF ALFRED STEVENS. To THE Epitror oF THE NaTION: Str: Your critic (Nation, No. 1142) handles M. Alfred Stevens’s ‘Impressions on Painting’ without gloves. I have not read the book and do not care to defend it—certainly the extracts your critic gives are not profound; but when he speaks of Stevens the painter with such con- tempt as ‘‘a painter of millinery and stuffs and fashion-plates,” and as ‘‘a painter for the nou- veaux riches,” I feel impelled to protest. I think I speak for the whole body of painters —certainly for all the painters I know—in say- ing that we find M. Stevens a painter for paint- ers as well as for the nouveaux riches. I know many painters of the highest aims and of high achievement, ani I know none of them that would deny to M. Stevens an exceedingly high rank in his profession, or that has not the heartiest admiration for his work. Would this be so if the work were as ‘‘ vicious,” as ‘‘ shallow,” and as “‘ meretricious” as your critic thinks it ? When painters of the most varied aims and methods agree in admiration of a brother paint- er’s work, is it not safe to assume that there is something admirable in it ? M. Stevens is a born painter, of marvellous gifts. He has doubtless done much work which is unworthy of him, but it is not by that that he must be judged. His best work is marked by exquisite harmony of color, by an astonishing power of rendition, and by a mondaine grace and charm in his female figures not at all de pendent on the ‘“ millinery” which they wear. M, Stevens chooses to paint well-dressed ladies presumably because he likes well-dressed ladies better than peasant women, and because the “stuffs” they wear give him the material for his delightfu! color-schemes; but ladies are human beings, and a man may paint them without making ‘fashion plates.” 1 think even Titian had a fancy for painting ladies now and then, and dressed in the height of the fashion, too, KENYON COX. NEW YORK, May 19. THE CRANSTON ARMS. To THE EpIToR oF THE NATION : Sir: My attention has been. called to a review of ‘America Heraldica’ in the Nation of May 5. I quite agree with the writer of the article in his estimate of the valne of coats-of-arms in this country, but as the assertion of a right to their use involves a question of honesty, will you kindly permit me to give, in as few words as possible, the authority for the use of the Crans- ton arms, even though there ** ce wrong some- where ” in the Cranston pedigree { Tne authority, both for the pedigree and arws, is a certificate given to Samuel Cranston, Governor of Rhode Island, under date of June 29, 1724, by Sir Alex, Areskine, Lyon King of Arms, Edinburgh. A second application was made to the Lyon office in 1881 with special re- ference to an error in the pedigree. The re- ply, signed Geo. Burnett, Lyon, states that ‘‘as regards the arms in question, it [the certificate of Sir A. Areskine] is absolutely authoritatire, and not to be gainsaid by the dicta of Peerage or other works”; and he goes on to say: *‘* There was a period in the first half of last century when the pedigrees, as detailed in the armorial certificates granted from the Lyon office, were not so carefully got up, or so absolutely free from error, as at other times.” A little investigation has led me to conclude that the error in question was caused by a mistake of similar names im two branches of the same family.—Respectfully, G. E. C. {In regard to the Cranston case, the only in formation open to the public was the epitaph printed in the Heraldic Journal, page 59. It seems that at Newport, R. I., is a stone, in scribed as follows, over the grave of Gov. Samuel Cranston, who died in 1727: ‘He was son of Gov. John C., grandson of Rev. James C., chaplain to King Charles I., who was son of John C. of Pool, who was son of James, son of William, Lord Cranston.” This is the most favorable view to take of the in- Heipticn as to generations. William, first ‘Lord Cranston, died in 1627. By this pedigree, Gov. John C., who was born in 1626, was great-great-grandson of this lord, and yet born in his life-time. If not impossi- ble, it was at least almost incredible. Now, Mr. G. E. Cranston gives us the authority of the present Lyon King at Arms, as endorsing the arms, though the pedigree is wrong some- where. Our complaint against Mr. Vermont's plan was, that he puts this coat among well authenticated examples without giving any authority, and very possibly without deing acquainted with the private letter cited by "'G. E. C.” Until that letter is printed, no critic can be blamed for pointing out the very un satisfactory state of the matter as it stands in the Lleraldie Journal.—Ep. Narion. | Y ‘IS BEING BUILT,” ETC ; To THE Eprror or THE Nation: Sir: On this form of expression a reviewer re marks, in your issue for March 17: * Dr, Hall gives ita respectable age: he has found it as early as 1769. A look for it in (Mr. T. L. Kington) Oliphant shows examples in 1447-48." If the re viewer had turned to Mr, Oliphant’s alleged au thority, he would have seen something noticea’ bly different there. Naming Shillingfon}'s ‘ Letters,’ Mr. Oliphant writes, in i, 273: “In p, @ there is a startling change of idiom, which did not become common until 300 years later; being is prefixed to a past participle; wyn ts being y put to sale; this idiom is repeated in p. 100.” Now, in Shillingford, pp. ¥1, G2, there occurs: “Wyn by his officers ofte tymes deing ther y put to sale,” ete. And at p, 100; “And so thei, being seised of the saide nywe tenements, made oute,” etc. The interpolation by which Mr. Oliphant alters the first quotation to what he wishes it to be is not “startling “ toany one who has scruti nized the peculiarities of bis doings as a philolo gist. That here and elsewhere I am not unduly severe will probably be acknowledged by those who read to the end of this letter. ; Referring to my quotations for ‘is a being acted,” ete., Mr, Oliphant says of me, in ii, INS: ** He seems unaware of the fact that the idiom was anything but new; see my book, i, 273; ii, 8.” It is obvious to ask why he did not cite some- thing of the second passage from Shillingford, as he cited something of the first. Did his evil courage fail him, after scheming so as to foist in “as” once! Be this how it may, it is bad enough that, even on a single occasion, he has distinctly sophisticated an old text, apparently in order to * make a point against me, Again, he delivers himself very uncritically as regards the idiom under consideration: ‘ Being is prefixed to a past participle.” This 1s his defini- tion of it; and it thus seems to be indifferent to him whether being built, for example, is preced- ed or is not preceded by is, was, or the like. Of phrases like those which, as given above, are met with in Shillingford, | do not claim to know the antiquity; but it has not been proved that they had not been long established before develop- ments corresponding to Mr. Oliphant’s spurious ‘*wyn is being y put to sale” became ‘at all cur- rent, The expression ‘“‘ was being seducyd” is, per- haps, found in a translation, published in 1844, which is said to have been executed late in the reign of Henry VIII. If at any time I have an opportunity of consulting the manuscript of that translation, I shall return to the expression. A letter written in the first quarter of the seven- teenth century coatains the locution, ‘Italy is being held dangerous,” if we may believe Mr. Oliphant, who, building on his adulteration al- ready spoken of, styles it ‘‘an idiom of the fif- teenth century.” Of what there really is in that letter I have, at present, no reasonable assu- rance, Among the quotations connected with the con- struction before us which Dr, Murray gives in mevinge vad it ene wtp 9 | oa tapes ase sate. gt TS tiatscremten
Page 16
448 The Nation. [Number 1143 his Dictionary—all of which I had given pre- viously—the first, as I have lately ascertained, should be dated 1572, not 1596; the second edition of the translation of Lavater, used by me, having nothing in it from which one would infer that it was not the first edition. Further, since Dr. Murray treats only the quotations beginning with that of 1795 as un- exceptionally exemplifying that construction, it is interesting to be able to adduce a similar one, which I have very recently chanced on, earlier by three years. William Roberts, in No. 26 of the Looker-on, published November 3, 1792, has the words, ‘“‘ while the Looker-on was being read.” Let me now touch briefly on the manner in which Mr. Oliphant has noticed the examina- tion of his ‘Sources of Standard English,’ con- tributed by me to the North American Review for October, 1874. In the preface to his ‘Old and Middle English’ he says that he “ cannot understand why an author need whimper under the rod of reviewers.” Whimpering is unmanly enough, doubtless ; but hg has done much worse than whimper. Others may decide whether I am wrong inimputing to him, with respect to me, fictitious representations and breaches of vera- city in the passages, taken from his work last mentioned, which I shall now produce and anno- tate. Very significantly, neither am I named by him, nor is any of my writings indicated, in con- nection with those passages. Clue there is there- fore none, of his furnishing, for testing the fideli- ty with which he exhibits the matters that he animadverts on. As in every case here brought forward he has strayed into the region of down- right fable, his rule regarding me is determined by the solitary instance where, exceptionally, be has satisfied himself with gratuitous carping only ; for there he discloses my personality. This is at page 52. I once spoke of “helpless slaves of what a metaphysician might call the sequacious diathe- sis” (see my ‘English Adjectives in -able,’ etc., p. 173). Just before thus expressing myself, I had come upon two pompous old acquaintances, **sequacious” and ‘‘diathesis,” in the pages of the Saturday Review, Mr. Oliphant’s ardent pa- negyrist ; and these I jocularly fancied brought together, introducing them, as is seen, much as one would imtroduce a quotation. It was my imaginary metaphysician that married the for- midable couple. ; Adverting to my palpable jest, Mr. Oliphant informs us in his preface: “I have let off no fireworks like ‘ Asyndetic Codrdination’ or ‘ Se- quacious Diathesis.’” But he could not rest there. On page 84 he classes me among “ professors of fine writing”; and he likewise describes me as “one of them, who writes about sequacious dia- thesis.” He knows full well that his gibe would have lacked all color of justification, and would never have been ventured, if he had been in- genuous enough to transcribe my context. For when and where did I ever profess to uphold ‘* fine writing,” or to do anything for which I should be ranked with ‘‘ professors” of it? The English which I advocate for general use is pre- cisely such as the common sense and the needs of our age account expedient, and not the piebald, jejune, vague, nerveless, and affected jargon which he champions ; and of this he is perfectly sensible. The remark of miue, *‘ lesser enjoys his sanc- tion,” certainly affords no evidence of passion ; and yet, crookedly avoiding citation of the re- mark, he does not shrink from saying, at page 268, ‘‘One critic was very angry with me for using this classic Old English form.” The in- eptitude of this falsehood does not require to be ~ dwelt on. Once more he writes, at p. 220: *‘ One critic is much disgusted at my using overlord ; in this I simply follow my betters. He would probably prefer superior dominator, or hyper-despot. He stands up for sociology as a neat compound; so he would, of all things, I suppose, prefer hyper- dominator.” Let us now look at the facts. Constructing a sentence ‘‘ made up entirely of his own pet archa- isms,” as 1 accurately characterized it, I em- bodied in it the word *‘ overlord”; and there an end. To assert that I was ‘‘ much disgusted” at his using it is pure invention. As to “ sociology,” I merely asked, ‘‘ who would prefer a circumlo- cution” to it? Shortly before I had observed that, ‘‘as to real verbal hybrids,” such as ‘‘ mine- ralogy,” ‘‘terminology,” ‘‘murderous,” and ‘‘ righteous,” *‘ we readily learn to tolerate them, if handy”; this observation following a com- ment on Mr. Oliphant, who had discovered, in “the wondrous word penology,” a mixture of “ Latin with Greek.” Ei There is no ground, then, for taxing me with holding *‘ sociology ” to be **a neat compound.” I applied no epithet to it, laudatory or otherwise. Moreover,where Mr. Oliphant says that 1 ‘‘would, probably, prefer” one thing, and, as he supposes, ‘** would, of all things, prefer” another, since he supposes nothing of the kind, he consciously de- viates from the truth, and that from sinister mo- tives, indubitably. -A wholesale and unscrupu- lous pseudologist, forsooth, is my Oxford-bred critic, if I may use a compound which, besides being strictly descriptive of him, one cannot deny to be sufficiently ‘‘ neat.” For what I say touching ‘“ penology,” “‘ socio- logy,” “lesser,” etc., see the North American Re- view, as above, pages 317, 318, 325. In spite of my corrections, by the by, we read, in Mr. Oli- phant’s last work, ‘ New English,’ ii, 217: ‘‘Ina letter on prison discipline, printed in the Times of September 5, 1872, we find the wondrous word penology; the writer compounds Latin with Greek, and knows not how to spell the Latin he has compounded.” Accordingly, idle as it is to gainsay the position, Mr. Oliphant is still uncon- vinced that, as of horology, so of penology, both the elements are Greek; and, in all consistency, he ought to deem it unuscholarly to put penal in- stead of peenal. Here I drop my frontless defamer for the pre- sent. That I have vindicated myself against him in the Nation has its explanation in the fact that, in the country where I am writing, no journal, I believe, would permit the malpractices of an Englishman to be exposed in its columns by an American. Such, as Jong experience has instruct- ed me, is British comity.— Your obedient servant, FITZEDWARD HALL. MARLESFORD, ENGLAND, May 14, 1887. THE SENATORIAL SITUATION IN WEST VIRGINIA. To THE EprtTor OF THE NATION: Sir: The two braaches of the West Virginia Legislature having met in joint assembly, and having cast a majority of their votes for Charles James Faulkner, it now remains for the United States Senate to determine whether he, or the Governor's appointee, Daniel B. Lucas, will be seated. Theconstruction which is placed by that body upon the clause of the United States Constitution which declares in mandatory terms that ‘‘the Executive may make temporary ap- pointments until the next meeting of the Legis- lature, which sball then fill such vacancies” (art. i, sec. 3), must decide the point at issue. This would be conclusive in favor of Mr. Faulk- ner’s claim, were it not fcr that provision of the Constitution of West Virginia which provides as follows: ‘‘The Governor may, on extraordi- nary occasions, convene at his own instance the Legislature ; but when so convened it shall enter upon no business except that stated in the pro- clamation by which it was called together ” (art. vii., sec. 7), from consideration of which it appears that in no just and proper sense of the term has the Legislature yet convened. Beyond the expressly and specifically enumerated pur- poses for which the Governor called together in extraordinary session the component members of the Legislature of West Virginia, of which the lection of a Senator was not one, there has been no ‘‘ next meeting ” of the Legislature ; and the result of their balloting for Senator is as abso- lutely null and void of force and effect as it was violative of their oaths to support the United States Constitution, and defiant of the organic law of their own State. Suppose, on the day following the expiration by constitutional limi- tation of the last regular session, the members of that about-to-become historic body had met in joint assembly and chosen a Senator, without awaiting the call of the Gevernor, merely dis- pensing with that purely formal ceremony ; does any one claim that their action would have been valid, or entitled to the respect of the Senate ? Yet, would any greater violence have been done the State Constitution than it suffered in the attempted election of Judge Faulkner? On the other hand, as far as the transaction of any other business than that stated in Gov. Wilson’s pro- clamation is concerned, would it not have been as truly and as validly constituted a meeting of the Legislature within the meaning of the United States Constitution? Wherein consists the dif- ference so far forth as relates to the election of a Senator? In other words, if the last-mentioned instrument, as ‘‘the supreme law of the land,” can and does so override the Constitution in that particular which shears the Legislature of all power except within the express terms of the grant of the Executive, can any reason be given why it should not wholly dispense with the ne- cessity for the Governor’s proclamation, and vali- date any action of the assembled members which resulted in the expression of a choice of a Senator, though such meeting were wholly fortuitous ? These facts, considered in the light of that broad principle of law and common sense which de- clares that two instruments, or two statutes, or two clauses of the same instrument, shall be so construed as to give effect, if possible, to both, offer an easy solution of the question by which the sanctity of the United States Constitution may be preserved inviolate, not having its revered provisions distorted and stretched to cover cases it was never intended to embrace, and the Con- stitution of West Virginia escape desecration by her own sons. D. L. B. WasHINGTON, D. C., May 18, 1887. SOMETHING NEW ON METEMPSYCHOSIS. To THE Eprror OF THE NaTION : Srr: In the New York Independent for April 23 Mr. Henry F. Reddall discourses concerning ‘“*Unnatural Natural History,” and exposes seve- ral popular and, we trust, also, unpopular falla- cies. Speaking of the impression which some have, that pelicans feed their young from flesh of the mother’s breast, Mr. Reddall says: ‘* The fact that the pelican is provided witha large bag under her neck, into which she thrusts her finny prey, and, digging therein with her gory beak, feeds her young and dabbies her plu- mage with bloody fragments of fish, has given rise to the mistake concerning her habits.” With such a caption as ‘‘ Unnatural Natural History,” it is impossible to criticise this item; but inasmuch as the ordinary pelican has the “large bag” upon the under mandible of her beak, and not upon her neck, might it not be that, in some eccult manner, Mr. Reddall’s peli-
Page 17
May 26, 1887] can has received the soul of that amiable old gen- tleman in ‘Oliver Twist’ who was continually offering to eat his head, but was ever diverted by some passing thought from accomplishing his purpose? Itseems reasonable. Conway M. MILLAR. MINNESOTA UNIVERSITY, MINNEAPOLIS. Notes. We regret to learn that the three-volume ‘ Life of Darwin’ by his son Francis will not be brought out this summer, but next autumn—doubtless a more favorable time forits proper consideration by a public now absorbed in the contest over Irish home rule. Ticknor & Co. publish immediately ‘ The Sun- ny Side of Shadow; Reveries of a Convalescent,’ by Mrs. S. G. W. Benjamin; ‘ Letters of Horatio Greenough to his Brother, Henry Greenough’; and ‘The Nigritians’ and ‘ Tne Melanesians’ in Mr. A. Feathermann’s laborious series called ‘‘ The Social History of the Races of Mankind.” We learn from the last number of the Harvard University Bulletin that the Corporation have authorized the publication, through Charles Scribner’s Sons, of a memorial edition of the late Prof. E. A. Sophocles’s ‘Greek Lexicon of the Roman and Byzantine Periods,’ under the oversight of Prof. Joseph Henry Thayer. In this number of the Bulletin, by the way, is bound up a list of works on North American Fungi, pub- lished before 1887, by W. G. Farlow and Wm. Trelease. Works on Schizomycetes are inten- tionally omitted. Lee & Shepard announce ‘Life Notes; or, Fifty Years of Outlvok,’ by the Rev. William Hague, a prominent member of the Baptist de- nomination; and ‘The Obelisk and its Voices,’ by Gen. Henry B. Carrington, a poem inspired by the Washington Monument. Judge Wilbur F. Bryant’s ‘The Blood of Abel,’ which the author will publish at Lincoln, Nebraska, appears to be an apotheosis of Louis Riel, and a campaign document directed against President Cleveland, ‘‘ whose judgment,” the Judge says, ‘‘none of us would accept as to the value of forty acres of wild prairie land.” This opens up a new vista of tests of Presidential can- didates. Subscriptions are solicited for ‘ New Papers on Canadian History, Art, Science, Literature, and Commerce,’ gathered from those read before the Canadian Club of this city. The volume will be edited by G. M. Fairchild, jr., and illustrated by Thompson Willing, R. C. A. Profs. Goldwin Smith and Chas. G. D. Roberts, Principal Grant, and George Stewart, jr., are among the con- tributors. Mr. J.S. Ross, Canadian Club, No. 12 East Twenty-ninth Street, has the book in charge, Maisonneuve (“ Librairie Orientale et Améri- caine”) has in press volume vy. of the ‘“‘ Mé- moires et documents pour servir 4 histoire des origines francaises des pays d’outre-mer,” edited by M. P. Margry. The fifth volume of this col- lection has recently appeared. It has for a special title : ‘ Premiére formation d’une chafne de postes entre le fleuve Saint-Laurent et le golfe du Mexique, 1685-1724.’ The publication of a valuable work for the study of French history and literature is an- nounced, It is an ‘Album paléographique,’ a collection of important documents relating to the history and literature of France, reproduced in heliogravure from the originals in the national libraries and archives, with explanatory notices by the Société de Ecole des Chartes: and an in- troduction of twelve pages by M. L. Delisle. It isa large folio,containing fifty plates of facsi- The Nation. miles. Three hundred and fifty copies have been printed at 150 francs each. A great deal of enterprise has been shown by the West Publishing Company in completing what it calls the ‘‘ Nationa] Reporter System,” by which the legal profession is furnished weekly with ‘‘all the current decisions of the Federal Courts and the courts of last resort of all the States and Territories”; and also monthly with a Di- gest of all these cases. There are nine series of these Heporters, viz., two of the National Courts, the ‘‘ Supreme Court ” and the ‘* Federal,” and seven of the State and Territorial Courts, the Atlantic, Pacific, Northeastern, Northwestern, Southwestern, Southeastern, and Southern. The type is good. The chief drawback to these re- ports is the absence of a statement of the facts, or the slight statement of them. But, taken just as they are, the quick furnishing of them at a price under $50 a year for the whole of them, including the Digest, is an immense advantage to the lawyer. Indeed, by rendering easily ac- cessible to judges and others these current de- cisions of all our American courts, it is probable that this enterprise will have a considerable influ- ence in developing and unifying our law. We have received a prospectus of the Modern Muse, *‘a quarterly review of poetry,” to be launched at Buffalo in January next by C. W. Moulton & Co. Poetasters need not take heart ; the scheme offers no place for * original verse.” It involves the reprint of standard poems by living and dead poets, and selections from the current poetry of magazines on both sides of the water. Biography and critical and explanatory annotation will go hand in hand with biblio- graphy and liberal indexing. ‘‘ With number two will be published a bibliographical list of all the verse, English and American, issued in book form during 1887.” Scrupulous editing is pro- mised. Another novelty in periodicals is the weekly Public Service Review, already in its third or fourth number (New York, Broadway and Thir- ty-third Street). Its range takes in the military and naval service, and the civil service of munici- pality, State, and nation. The’ backing of this enterprise is chiefly from the army, and one fea- ture of the Heriew isa monthly showing of the stations of the land and naval forces of the United States. The Illustrated News Company, of this city, is printing, ‘“‘from duplicate pistes, by special ar- rangements with the proprictors,” the Jlws- trated London News and other foreign pictori- als. Notes and Queries for May 7 speaks of ‘George Eliot (née Mary Ann Cross).”’ Some vigorous and intelligent art criticism is contributed to the May Portfolio (Macmillan) by Mr. F. G. Stephens, whose theme is William Mulready—a first paper. He strikes impartially in a sentence that will displease the English as much as the American public, when he classifies the existing ‘‘ schools of artistic motives,” nam- ing the third “the sentimental school, as ex- hibited in the works of Ary Schefer [sic], certain Germans, and numerous Englishmen, who have affected the twaddle and whine of Longfellow and such-like falsities.” But there is much to respect in his judgments, and on Mulready he is an authority. A clever etching after this artist's homely ** Choosing the Wedding Gown ™ forms a frontispiece to the present number of the maga- xine. David Wilkie is the principal subject of Mr. Walter Armstrong's third illustrated paper on Scottish painters. The Studio for May mingles with its independ- ent criticism of the late exhibition at the National Academy of Design, and of George Fuller's work as a painter, six full-page photographic illustra- tions representing as many pictures of the Wolfe AAD collection, naw the property of the Metrop litan Museum. It announces for the July number a portrait of Mrs. Cleveland, etched by Paul Rajon, of which, as usual, proofs on Japanese paper will also be made, to the number of 500, for such as desire to procure them, and proofs on large paper. The Fall Mail Gazette “ Extra” No, 34 is an illustrated catalogue of ** The Pictures of 1887” to be seen in London, as, at the Royal Academy, the Grosvenor Gallery, the two Water-Color Ex hibitions, that of the British Artists, etc. Ina certain number of cases the preliminary sketches are also reproduced, and now and again informa- tion is given as to engravings to be made after the paintings here sketched. Mr. Christern sends us the illustrated catalogue of the Salon of 1887, in which we *emark the in creased number of memorandum sketches, owing to the greatly diminished scale admitted. There is the usual range of subjects—the thousand and one excuses for the nude ; war scenes, but these equally distributed in time and not promotive of revanche ; portraits in the greatest abundance, but few striking—one, Boulanger on horseback, besides a portrait bust ia which the most is done for his common physiognomy ; literary topics, like Musset’s ‘Namouna’ at one extreme, and Renan’s ' Abbesse de Jouarre’ at the other ; and such repulsive delineations as a clinic at the Sal pétriére, or cholera morbus. We notice the work of one American painter, ‘* St. Genevieve," by C. S. Pearce, and there may be others. The English rendering of the titles exhibits its cus tomary infelicities. Two snake - charmers, * Charmeuses,” become * Bewitching Women,” while ** Une Charmeuse” is “A Charmeress.” The types are respousible for ‘* The Soul Deperl- ing to Heavens.” The article of greatest popular interest in the last number of Petermann’s Mittet/wigen is on the Yakuts, by Prof. Ed. Petri, who controverts the assertions made by Vambeéry and others that this most northern representative of the Turco- man race is dying out, though he describes their condition as extremely wretched and a disgrace to the Russian Government, which bas done little or nothing for them. He also vigorously defends them from the accusation of a lack of poetic feel ing, and gives an interesting analysis of one of their popular tales, ‘*The Bride-Quest [Bravf- fahrt) of Jurung-Uolans.” It contains many re- ligious and mythological allusions, Other arti- cles are by J. Menges, on the caravan route be- tween Suakin and Kassala; and by Dr. Th. Pose witz, on the island of Blitong. The May Proceedings of the Royal Geographi- cal Society opens with a paper on the ‘‘Alpine Regions of Alaska,” by Lieut. Seton-Karr, who dwells especially upon the admirable field for re- search into glacial action which Alaska presents. This is followed by an account of the explora- tions of Dr. Junker in the country to the west of the upper Nile, by Mr. J. T. Wills, who indicates to some extent the character of the country and the people through which the Emin Pasha Relief Expedition may pass. The Scottish Geographical Magazine for May contains an article on the ‘‘ Landslopes Separat- ing Continents,” with especial reference to the West African coast, by Mr. J. Y. Buchanan. Among other peculiarities of the ocean bed, he describes an immense submarine cafion extending from the mouth of the Congo some thirty-five miles into the ocean. Here it is six miles wide and 3,000 feet in depth below the surrounding ocean bed. Its origin he attributes, not to ero- sion, but to the upbuilding of its sides by the river silt. Mr. Carmichael contributes another article on the ‘‘ Place-Names of {ona.” The extracts from the journal of Benjamin Constant, which have been the most attractive : i
Page 18
4.50 The Nation. (Number 1143 ——= feature of the Revue Internationale during the first three months of the present year, are now brought to a close, but a new series, also from the family papers of his relatives is offered to us in its pages. In the number for April 10 are the first eighteen of the ‘‘ Letters of Benjamin Con- stant to his Family,” which a note of the editors of the Revue informs us are published through the kindness of Mme, de Loys de Chandieu, and of her son, the Marquis de Chandieu, a de- scendaut of one of Benjamin Constant’s maternal aunts. The recipient of the greater part of the letters was another of the Chandieu sisters, the Countess of Nassau, to whom Constant wrote faithfully and untiringly until her death in 1814, All but three of the letters in the present num- ber are addressed to her, most of them during the early months cf the year 1794, the last two being written immediately after his arrival in Paris in May of that year. The first of the series is one to his aunt, Mme. de Loys, when he was between twelve and thirteen years old. It is one of the astonishingly precocious productions of the young Constant, who never appears older or more worldly than in his very youthful letters. The Nouvelle Revue announces a new series of papers by the anonymous and composite person- age who signs, with the name of Comte Paul Vasili, the gossiping and at times indiscreet reve- lations concérning society in the various Euro- pean capitals which have appeared in the pages of the Revue during the past two years, under the titles ‘‘La Société de Londres—de Ber- lin —de Saint Pétersbourg,” etc. The new series, to be called ‘‘ La Société de Paris,” will make several volumes when completed. The first of these is to be ‘Le Grand Monde.’ While ‘ La Société de Rome’ was appearing, M. Henri des Houx was seriously suspected of at least furnish- ing materials for the ubiquitous Comte Paul Vasili, as other literary and political persons had been before suspected of doing for the preceding works of the series. The present opinion, how- ever, seems to be that variou; persons supply the material, which some one, probably Mme. Adam (Juliette Lamber), works over into a systematic account. The late O. H. Marshall’s ‘ Historical Writings relating to the Early History of the West’ (Alba- ny, N. Y.: Joel Munsell’s Sons) is a volume possessing great merit in its way. Marshall was a careful, industrious, and conscientious investi- gator; and though all his work was of a local and special nature, it 1s of very considerable value. His papers on the expedition of Denonville against the Senecas, and that of Champlain against the Onondagas, are favorable examples, as is also his account of the expedition of Céloron de Bienvilie down the Ohio. He generally com- bines a personal examination of localities with a close study of original documents, partly from originals in the Archives of Paris, which he visited a few years ago. He had a good know- ledge of French and a well-grounded distrust of translations. Had we any title to be counted among the ‘many friends” of Mrs. Amos R. Little, we fear we should not have joined in their urgent solicita- tion that she should describe her tour of the globe in 1883-4 in a quarto volume of 476 pages (‘ The World as We Saw It.’ Boston: Cupples & Co.). However, let us be thankful for the handsome manner in which the volume is got up, and for the ulustrations — some kind of phototype — which areexcellent and unhackneyed. Persistent readers of books of travel will have little to learn from this lady’s journals. Her route to the East was by way of New Zealand, Tasmania, Sydney, and Port Darwin. The great earthquake has, since Mrs, Little was in New Zealand, made havoc of the Hot Lake re- gion and of the terraces that she visited. It is reported, however, that a new White Terrace has been discovered not far from those destroyed. It is not yet very large, nor has it the glittering fretwork and lovely coral-lipped basins that cha- racterized the old terraces, but, as it is in process of formation, these will probably in time make their appearance. A philological curiosity has been published in Russia for the use of Russians—a pocket glossary in 100 languages. Of these 70 are spoken in the Russian Empire itself, 10 in Central Asia, 10 in various Slavic States, and 10 in other Kuropean countries, —The Atlantic for June contains two articles of special interest to students of the relation of political theories to history. Mr. A. L. Lowell traces the rise and transformations of the ‘‘Theo- ry of the Social Compact” as the source of civil government. He finds it first in old ecclesiasti- cal Hvuoker, and follows it through Hobbes, Locke, Rousseau, the Constitution of Massachu- setts, and Kant, with brief abstracts of their doc- trines and a strong grasp on the course of his- tory. He shows that a different disposition of mind in the thinker and the particular set of po- litical circumstances in his horizon made the- theory a ready servant of absolutism, democra- cy, revolution, or transcendental ethics, as the case might be; and one ends the article witha very strong sense of how much easier it is for } men of the best brain to decide rightly on the practical problem of their time than to give a reason for so doing that shall be of general appli- cation. Ina day when knowledge is running so much into detail as now, such an article as this, with its broad views held simple and whole by means of strict definitions, and touching solidiy whatever it touches at all, is a very notable pa- per. The second instance of the relation of po- litical theory to history is given in Mr. John Fiske’s discussion of the debate on the Executive Power in the Federal Convention. It is a com- monplace that the mode of election of our Presi- dent is not at all that contemplated by the Con- stitution. On the general question Mr. Fiske em- phasizes the fact that Sherman made a suggestion which, if followed out, would have framed the Presidency on the modern ministerial idea instead of on the ancient monarchical idea; and he as- cribes the error, as he thinks it, to the absence of definite political facts to govern and direct the argument, and to lack of an understanding of the ministerial development of the English Con- stitution, which had been obscured by the acci- dent of George II[.’s personal rule. He declares plainly against our system and in favor of the English. The executive might have been made, he says, ‘‘ what it ought to be, the arm of the legislature, instead of a separate and codrdinate power.” He seems to hold the same view as to the judiciary, likewise; he accepts the popular will expressed by a parliament immediately re- sponsible as the whole of authority. This has no more weight than a private view; but the histo- ry of the theory of the fathers about the execu- tive, and the way events dealt with their schemes and arguments, make an instructive lesson in politics. —In Harper's Bazar for May 7, “*T. W. H.” cites certain figures in support of his position that American literature is not only progressing, but is increasing in a ratio rivalling that of the material progress of the country. The Atheneum, in its issue of the same date, comments on the Bazar statement as follows: ‘‘The number of books copyrighted in the United States last year was 11,124 as against 2,076 in 1880, So says ‘T. W. H.,’ an accurate writer; but we should like to know whether the number for 1886 (more than twice that of English copyrights in the same year) is exclusive of works produced on this side of the Atlantic.” The Athenceum’s question is partly answered by the statement that every issue of the ‘‘ Seaside” (and, we believe, other “libraries”) claims copyright; but, aside from this, the assertions of “T. W. H.” cannot be maintained. In the first place, the number of books copyrighted in 1880 was not 2,076, but 7,108; hence “the suddenness of expansion” which he mentions does not exist. Then, as re- gards his comparison of the two countries in re- spect to the number of copyrights, we should like to know where he got his English figures. So far as we know,the statistics of the British Copy- right Office are not published, and we suspect that ‘‘T. W. H.” used not these, but the figures uf the compiler of the English Catalogue. But the figures of the Catalogue are not only exclu- sively of books, but of published books; those of our Copyright Office are of titles entered, which entry is often not followed by publication. Moreover, of the entries classified as ‘‘ books,” probably one-half are ‘‘ books” only in a legal sense, being telegrams in newspapers, pamphlets descriptive of every variety of article in trade, from silverware to quack medicines, blank-books and forms in immense numbers, as well as ‘‘dime” and ‘‘half-dime” literature. We cannot claim accuracy on this point, but it is our belief that none of these would figure in the statistics, if ac- cessible, of the British Copyright Office; they cer- tainly do not figure in the English Catalogue. —The article in the April number of the Eng- lish Historical Review to which most readers will turn first is Mr. Gladstone’s review of Gre- ville’s latest Journals, covering the years from 1852 to 1860. A survey of this period by Mr. Gladstone is a valuable contribution at first hand to our knowledge of history. The principal sub- ject covered by this article is the Crimean War, with regard to which it expresses the judgment that it ‘‘ will hold in history no dishonorable place.” The reconstitution of Italy and the com- mercial treaty with France are also treated at considerable length. The opening article of the number is by Mr. Thomas Hodgkin, upon Visi- gothic Spain—a subject which he is especially qualified to treat. In the condition of Spain dur- ing this period, he says in conclusion, ‘‘ we see not only the historical preparation for feudalism, but also its historical justification.” Our coun- tryman, Mr. Henry C. Lea, has an article ona subject peculiarly his own—‘‘ Confiscation for Heresy in the Middle Ages.” There is some- times a disposition, in writers of excessive libe- rality, to apologize for persecution on the ground of the sincerity and single-mindedness of the per- secutors, Mr. Lea shcws, however, by a cool analysis of events, that ‘‘of course it would be unjust to say that greed and thirst for plunder were the ‘impelling motives of the Inquisition’; but we are perfectly safe in asserting that, but for the gains to be made out of fines and confis- cations, its work would have been much less tho- rough, and that it would have sunk into com- parative insignificance as soon as the first frantic zeal of bigotry had exhausted itself.” The fourth article is by Mr. O'Connor Morris, upon Turenne. The Notes and Documents are of unusual interest, containing a very long examination of the Semi- ramis legend by Prof. Robertson Smith, and an- other, by D. G. Hogarth, upon the ‘‘ Deification of Alexander the Great.” —Mr. A. H. Bullen has added to his edition of the old dramatists the works of John Marston, in three volumes (Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co.). In mechanical execution this edition is all that 2 standard work should be—convenient in size, beautifully printed, built to last, and at the same time inexpensive; but the editor does not show that improvement upcn acquaintance which might be expected from a growing student. Mr
Page 19
May 26, 1887] The Nation. 451 Bullen seems to be in haste. He has already ed- ited many books, but he has not yet elaborated any thoroughly scholarly plan worthy of one am- bitious to be a successor of Dyce. Misprints are common, and they are by no means all listed in the ‘ errata,” which unfailingly accompany his books. Other errors, rather to be classed as oversights than misprints, are frequently to be found, as, for instance, such persistent ascription of the speeches to a wrong character as occurs in ‘The Fawn,” i, 2, 70-81. The best of editors can- not avoid slight mistakes occasionally, but a large number of these indicate carelessness. The lack of system in the notes is a worse defect; sometimes they are unnecessarily full and some- times they are altogether to seek. Cross-refer- ences, without further explanation, are excusa- ble when made to the work itself, but to other books they should be made sparingly, in explain- ing words at least. The general impression one gets from Mr. Bullen’s notes is that if anything occurred to him about the passage he put it in, and if nothing came to mind he said nothing; one perceives quite plainly limitations to his read- ing and to his memory. An unpleasant trait, as it seems to us, is the familiar and colloquial tone and extraneous matter that sometimes intrude upon the text, as when, in connection with an emendation in ‘‘ The Insatiate Countess,” he has to mention Mycerinus, and adds, “I saw his bones this afternoon at Bloomsbury!” Such re- marks in books of this sort are impertinences, It may beexcused to Dr. Furnivall that he lately in- corporated bis son's bicycle record asa part of the dedication of a Shakspere Quarto-Facsimile, but it is to be hoped that such personalities wi!l not become an example to young editors. It must be added, too, that Mr. Bullen’s notes are certainly exposed to the charge brought against Gibbon, of making learning a cover for gross- ness. A considerable acquaintance with Mr. Bullen’s work has convinced us that his editing can be amended in carefulness, system, and taste; but his services are very considerable; he is con- scientious in investigation, and his texts, in spite of blunders, are excellent. His faults are princi- pally annoyances. —In the present case we have an edition of Marston which brings within easy reach all the works with which, as playwrigbt or satirist, his name was memorably connected ; and of them ‘Eastward Ho,” in which Jonson and Chapman codperated, 1s one of the great comedies of Lon- don manners. ‘‘The Malcontent” is the play he himself lives by, and the farcical scenes of ‘*The Dutch Courtesan” are good citizen-drama. For Marston’s other work, excepting as a part of the history of our stage, we have but shght re- gard; it is not great, and one can say no more for it than that it is Elizabethan—it had a kind of greatness thrust upon it. It is usuaJly foul and often brutal, and makes one feel the gross- ness of the audience. It plays, as is easily seen, better than it reads, and to us its most interest- ing trait is its contemporary echo of Shakspere, which is frequent, and is especially instructive as to the latter’s popularity and literary influence, Marston seems to have been an embittered man, better than bis fate, and he was a clever drama tist, having the stage and the audience in his eye, and ever alert for a good hard blow at an enemy, particularly Jonson ; but the poetry was left out of him, and his intellectual parts were too ex- clusively satirical in their operation. The en- thusiasm of an editor, especially of one who works in the dreary rhodomontade, crudity, and filth of the early drama, leads Mr. Bullen to overpraise ; but when he attempts the critic, he is far less successful than when he keeps to his editorial task. Lamb's name has shielded a vast amount of nonsense about these minor drama- tists, and Swinburne is making himself responsi- ble for a good deal more ; between the two, Mr. Bullen has fallen into bad judgment and an un- reined style. It would not be the worst thing that could happen should Time grant nine-tenths of Marston's prayer, and give that proportion of his works to oblivion. —Perhaps, after all, the disgraceful scenes which recently led to the withdrawal of ‘* Lohen- grin” at Paris after more than 200,000 francs had been subscribed for the first ten performances, will do more to insure a great future for Wag- ner’s music in France than an uninterrupted se- ries of performances would have done for the present. They have thoroughly disgusted all educated Parisians, and ranged them practically on the side of the Wagnerites against the Chau- vinists. In 1861, after the failure of ‘ Taun- hiuser,” Berlioz wrote to his son that ‘‘ Wagner, on going out, was treated on the staircase hke a scamp, an insolent fellow, anidiot. . . . The press is unanimous for his extermination.” “This whole ‘Tannhauser’ affair,” writes M. Jullien, ‘‘from whatever point of view we re- gard it, is anything but honorable for us,” and he mentions that only four of the critics—Baude- laire, Weber, D°Ortigne, and Franck-Marie— showed any sense of justice on that occasion. But in the ‘‘ Lohengrin” affair all the respectable newspapers were on the side of Lamoureux, and resented the gutter censorship of the gamins in art matters. Several things have contributed to this change of attitude: Wagner's death, a spread- ing knowledge that he was not such a swallower of Frenchmen as he had been supposed to be, and a rapidly growing taste for his music, thanks partly to the compositions of his French imita- tors, and partly to familiarity with bis own works acquired at the concerts of Lamoureux, Colonne, and Pasdeloup. As a writer in the Temps remarks: ‘‘ The fact that the ashes of Ros- sini left Paris at the moment when Wagner made his entrance, was an accident, but this accident is the symbol of an interesting truth: Italian mu- sic has ceased to give us pleasure, German music is triumphant. And it would be wrong to think that this victory is only apparent; that it is the work of a few fanatics and music-maniacs, or a caprice of the wealthy classes, consenting to be bored for the sake of fashion and in order to get the reputation of being intelligent music-lovers. The Sunday concerts are besieged by a motley crowd of which the petites gens form the majori- ty, students, shop-clerks, office-clerks; all these come with worshipful fidelity to hear with con- centrated attention this mystic music, which at first frightened them a little, and into which they now plunge with ecstasy.” M. Jullien, in an appendix to his Wagner biography, gives an account of what has been done at these Sunday concerts for Wagner's music. The latest success is the Flower Girl Scene from “ Parsifal,” which had to be repeated. Other specifically German composers are also coming to the foreground in Paris. The Société Nationale recently gave Bach's Christmas Oratorio, and (mirabile dictu) one number, a chorale, was ‘‘encored.” At the Opéra as well as at the Comique, Weber's “* Obe- ron” is in preparation; and the list might be easily enlarged. —Concerning ‘‘ Lohengrin,” a few more details may be added from the foreign papers. It seems that some commotion was excited in Germany by the report that Kapellmeister Levy of Mu- nich, who bad been invited by Lamoureux to at- tend the dress rehearsal in Paris, had remarked that the performance was “a humiliation to Ger- many.” Lamoureux consequently wrote a pub- lic letter in which he explained that Levy simply intended to compliment him on having given Wagner's score complete, whereas at most Ger- man opera-houses extensive cuts are made. The correspondent of the Berlin Boersen-Courier states that Lamoureux's orchestra of ninety was admirable, consisting, as it did, of some of the best men of the two Paris opera-houses, with the addition of talented pupils from the Con servatoire. He adds that ‘the mise-en-seene was greatly admired in Paris. We Germans are accustomed to something better.” The principal singers—Devrids, Van Dyck, Blauwaert, and Du vivier—are all well spoken of ; but it was re gretted that, after more than twenty rebearsals, the réle of the King was taken away from a com petent German and given to an incompetent French singer, for fear of arousing ** patriotic” suggestions. For the same reason, Nuitter re moved from the text all allusions to Germany Difficulties of copyright made it necessary to re tain Nuitter’s translation instead of Victor Wild er’s, in which the words are more carefully adapt ed to the accents of the music. Wilder also trans lated ** Die Walkiire” for Krussels, where it bas just met with such extraordinary success. There is every reason to believe that the Parisians, when they read that the authorities at Rome have just renewed their contract with the manager of the opera on condition of bis giving ** Die Meister singer at an early date ; wher they read of the great success of German opera in New York, and that twenty-three performances of “Die Wal kiire” were given at Brussels this season-—-will imperatively demand some more of this music which Alphonse Daudet finds ‘‘au-dessus de tout.” A FRENCH CONSTITUTIONALIST ON THE ENGLISH CONSTITUTION, Le Développement de la Constitution et de la So- ciété Politique en Angleterre, Par E. Boutmy, Membre de l'Institut, Directeur de l'Ecole Li- bre des Sciences Politiques. Paris: E. Plon, Nourrit et Cie. 1887. A REVIEWER of Boutmy’s essay on the develop- ment of the English Constitution bas before bim a task which, if pleasant, is also difficult. He must describe, if possible, the qualities of thought and expression which mark out our author as a writer of undoubted originality, not to say of ge- nius, He must, in the next place, give the intel- ligent readers of the Nation some idea of the kind of results attained by a thinker who brings a fresh mind, stored with wide learning, to a topic which, though so often worked, is still so unex- hausted as is the Constitution of England. Boutmy’s genius is best described by the state ment that he is the most brilliant representative of that school of French legists and bistoriaus who combine the erudition of Germany with the tucidity of France. Tocall our author the repre- sentative of a school is in no way to detract from his individuality. His writings bear that inde- scribable impress of personal character which givesto every page of a book, such, for example, as De Tocqueville's ‘Ancien Régime,’ a charm that nothing else can replace. It is, in fact, because he is so distinctly not a mere collector of informa- tion, but a living author, that Boutmy repre- sents so completely the best traits of a band of scholars from whom France and Europe must hope much. It is hardly possible to conceive that such a writer stands alone. The whole tone of his writings sufficiently proves that he is stirred by feelings and inspired by aims common toaclass. We shall hardly be mistaken in the conjecture that Boutmy, together with Glasson and others, belongs to a school who have deter- mined to restore to their country that reputation for thorough, thoughtful workmanship which has been, to say the least, obscured by the ac- knuwledged preéminence of French authorship in $ 4 ‘
Page 20
4A52 The Nation. {Number 1143 lucidity of style and in epigrammatic form of ex- pression. The truth appears to be, and it is a truth well worth attention, that in one department, at least, of thought—in the province, that is to say, of le- gal and historical study—Frenchmen are prepar- ing once again toastonish and instruct the world by exhibiting that capacity for putting forth fresh life after crushing calamities which is the most marked trait of French bistory. However this may be, the one thing which is absolutely certain is that Boutmy has, by combining erudi- tion, lucidity of expression, and insight, given a new impulse to the comparative study of consti- tutions, His earlier book, ‘ Etudes de Droit Con- stitutionnel,’ contained, in three or four hun- dred pages, a greater number of important obser- vations on the contrast between Continental and English or American constitutionalism than any work with which we are acquainted. From the nature of things, a great deal of it consisted of matters which could not have any novelty for Englishmen or Americans. But for all this, these Studies in Constitutional Law brought out, iv a very striking light, contrasts between what may be called the French and the English idea of a constitution, which might easily escape the no- tice of persons who, if well acquainted with Eng- land or America, had never studied the constitu- tions of the European Continent. What is true of the ‘ Etudes de Droit Constitu- tionnel’ applies with even greater force to Bout- my’s new book, ‘ Le Développement de la Consti- tution et de la Société Politique en Angleterre.’ Here again we have displayed thorough know- ledge of his subject. Hallam, Stubbs, Freeman, Gneist, Pollock are all as ‘familiar to Boutmy as they are, or should be, to every educated Eng- lishman, He has done much more than analyze the works of these writers: he has appropriated and assimilated all their best ideas. He has seized as firmly, for instance, as Gneist, the truth that the growth of the Constitution cannot be separated from the growth of the political society uf which the Constitution (in the limited sense of that word) is merely apart. He never forgets for a moment the connection, which Stubbs and Freeman impress in every page upon their read- ers, between the immense power originally pos- sessed by the English Crown and the subsequent growth of English freedom. He has followed out the characteristics of the English land law as sketched by Prof. Pollock, and now, it may be assumed, understands the mysteries of English manors and English settlements as thoroughly as does his teacher. Boutmy has, in short, achieved what hardly any other writer on the Constitution bas rarely accomplished, the combination, name- ly, of the legal with the historical aspect of con- stitutional history. Nor has he stopped at this point. He has attempted, at least, to comprehend within his view the economical no less than the political and social sides of English life. If in some degree he is perhaps less to be trusted on economical than on legal or political questions, the reason is that his authorities are not quite so trustworthy as are the authorities on whom he can rely when dealing with history or law which is strictly constitutional. It may, perhaps, be doubted whether Mr. Toynbee’s speculations, how- ever ingenious, were not inevitably too immature te support the inferences drawn from them by Boutmy; and Arthur Arnold’s political princi- ples may, a critic cannot but feel, have made him not quite an unbiassed witness on the condition of English land or of English laborers. The credit, however, to Mr. Boutmy of having studied writers who might naturally seem to lie out of his path, far outweighs any discredit which the most unfair criticism could attach to him for having occasionally relied upon guides whom an Englishman might feel to be possibly rash or prejudiced. It would, moreover, be the greatest mistake to suppose that our French author brings nothing to his subject but what he has gained from the books he has studied. He contributes a lucidity of style certainly not gained either from Gneist or Stubbs; he has a vivid percep- tion, which could hardly be attained by any one but a Frenchman, of the instructive contrasts between the course of English and of French civilization; he exhibits in its highest form that French capacity for generalization which, if it leads an ignorant man into absurd blunders, is, when combined with knowledge, nothing less than a keen eye for the essential features of great subjects. We bave all learned from Gneist and Stubbs that the overwhelming power of the early Nor- man kings checked the disruptive tendencies of feudalism, endowed England with an adminis- trative system far in advance of its age, estab- lished the rule of equal law, and, by compelling the nobles to become the leaders of the people, laid the foundation on which were ultimately built up the liberties of England. On this topic Boutmy must of necessity follow his predeces- sors. But it is characteristic of his genius that he has one or two new and valuable remarks to make on a subject which, it might well have been fancied, was worn down to triteness. He, for example, emphasizes the effect produced by England being an island : ‘‘ The sentiment of na- tional unity [solidarité séparée] springs up and acquires force far more rapidly in an island than in a coptinental country.” The consciousness of a separate national existence hence grew up in England centuries before it was known to France, or, indeed, we may say, before there was a France in which it could be known. Even at the time of the Reformation, there was serious danger lest the monarchy should be dismembered by the wars of religion. ‘‘The French nation needed still to be created [était a faire] in the seven- teenth century. She was no longer a federation; she was not yet a separate people.” France, in short, when she met the perils of the great re- ligious revolution, had still to encounter difficul- ties which in England had been overcome in the time of John and earlier. Nor did the smallness of the country tell in favor of national progress only by intensifying national feeling: it in- creased the power of the Crown, which, in the Middle Age, meant the authority of the law. Feudal monarchies were weak because the au- thority of the Crown extended nominally over territories too vast to be really subject to its power. In England the kiagdom was small, manageable—if one may use the expression, ‘*handy.” The county, the largest administra- tive division, equalled on an average not more than half a modern French department, and was a small district indeed compared to a French province. It was, too, as-Boutmy points out, a happy circumstance for English freedom that Scotland was not added by Edward to his king- dom. Such an addition would, it is likely enough, have led to the creation of vassals powerful enough to balance the authority of the Crown. No doubt other writers have noticed the effect on the progress of English civilization produced by the insular character and the smallness of England ; but no one with whom we are ac- quainted has placed the matter in so clear a light as this French critic, who understands Eng- land because at every moment he compares Eng- lish institutions with the institutions of France. The most original, if not always the soundest, part ef our author’s work is his statement and explanation of the paradox presented by English progress during the eighteenth century. The paradox is this. The period, as contrasted with the ages which preceded it, was one of apparent repose, not to say immobility. The religious contests of the sixteenth and seventeenth centu- ries,had ended; tke political revolution which had led to the death of one king and to the exile of another, was closed. The tyranny of Charles and the ecclesiastical despotism of Laud were as dead as the Protectorate of Cromwell or the Westminster Assembly. Between 1689 and 1829 there occurred hardly any great constitutional change. Historians have naturally agreed to de- scribe the eighteenth century, politically at least, and as compared specially with the seven- teenth century, as a tame period of peace and conservatism. Yet if the matter be looked at from another point of view, to which Boutmy specially directs attention, the political turmoil of the seventeenth century was productive of far less real change than the political stagnation of the eighteenth. The Puritans attempted large changes in Church and State, and the Whigs of the Revolution finally put an end to ail danger of royal despotism. But neither the Common- wealth nor the Whig leaders ot 1689 attempted to effect social changes. The men of the eighteenth century, on the other hand, carried out, uncon- sciously, for the most part, a gigantic system of political or social revolution or reaction. They founded or extended the rule of the gentry—that is to say, of the titled and untitled landowners— throughout the country. The Parliament, under an elaborate system of party government, came to be mainly controlled by large parties led either directly or indirectly by the greatest land- lords in the country. Politics became more and more a matter of family, and the contest between George the Third and the Whigs, though it broke down the predominant influence of the great Revolution families, and to a certain ex- tent increased the influence of the rich mercan- tile classes, did not substantially affect the real established system of government. The yeomen, who had been a real power at the time of the great rebellion, dwindled away. Those of them who succeeded in the struggle for existence join- ed the class of large landowners; those who fail- ed solid their land, increased the population of the towns, or emigrated to the colonies, Strict settlements had all the effect of entails, and the land fell more and more into the permanent pos- session of large landowners. The country labor- ers, meanwhile, became niore and more depend- ent on the Poor Law, and the Poor Law was ad- ministered, like everything else throughout the country, by the magistrates, who systematically favored the extension of outdoor relief, and whose legal powers were constantly increased, while the checks on the exercise of these powers, which, in the time of the Tudors, had been a reality, were, by almost imperceptible changes in the law, made little better than a sham. The eighteenth century, in short, was in England marked by the gradual transformation of the Government into something like an “‘ oligarchy » —if the word oligarchy can be applied to a class so numerous as that of the gentry. The causes, moreover, of this change are not hard to trace. The diminution of the regal power prevented the growth of any ‘‘ administration,” in the foreign sense of that. word, which could supervise or check the exercise of the powers lodged in magistrates or in small corporations. The smaller towns were absorbed in the country; the large cities which now ill the north of Eng- land, were only coming into existence, and had no share in the political representation of the country. The yeomanry were turning, under the stress of economical causes, into farmers; the great merchants connected themselves by mar- riage with the landed nobility, and, from the time of Pitt, at any rate, found easy access to the peerage. The manufacturers were uot yet a power. The city artisans and the country labor- ers enjoyed personal freedom and parish relief,
Page 21
May 26, 1887] The Nation. 4538 but as a body took no part in politics. The coun- try, moreover, flourished, and the mechanical in- ventions which, by raising up a great manufac- turing population, were destined to cause the po- litical fall of the gentry, were for the time bene- ficial to their power because they tended to in- crease the wealth of the landowners. A more masterly sketch of constitutional and social changes of which many eminent writers on the English Constitution do not appreciate the importance, can hardly be found than the picture given of it in the third part of Boutmy’s treatise. Two criticisms on his views are allowable. He is apt, like most Frenchmen, to attribute, in lan- guage at least, rather more to conscious design on the part of statesmen or classes, and rather less to the unconscious pursuit by all human be- ings of their obvious interests, than facts war- rant. Not a single statesman, Whig or Tory, contemplated, we suspect, the transformation of the Euglish Constitution from a more or less popular to a more or less oligarchical system of government. Scarcely justice, again, is done by our author to the real justification for the autho- rity assumed or exercised by the gentry. They were in the main the rulers of the country be- cause they were, on the whole, the class best fitted to govern it. Tried by the only fair stan- dard, that is, by a comparison witb the system of government existing during the eighteenth cen- tury in other countries, the English oligarchy are entitled to the verdict that they ruled the country with skill. England prospered, personal freedom was secured, and the body of magistrates, in whom, as Boutmy points out, were vested real- ly vast powers, were, though sometimes incapa- ble, neither oppressive nor corrupt. It may, in- deed, be doubted whether any men wiclding power under very slight legal restraints have ever been more free from the vice of personal corruption than those justices of the peace whom novelists and satirists have agreed to deride. When Chatham and his son wished to reform the representation, their idea of improvement was to increase the weight of county representatives. Such a reform would, as events proved, not have met the necessities of the case. But we may as- sume that towards the end of the eighteenth cen- tury the county freeholders were the soundest and least corrupt part of the nation. If, however, Boutmy has done a little less than absolute justice to the way in which the gentry exercised their authority, he has rendered an im- mense service to students of constitutional his- tory by forcing on their attention an aspect of English institutions which we constantly over- look. A French constitutionalist naturally fails to see some things easily perceived by English- men; but Englishmen, on the other hand, may learn from a Frenchman like Boutmy many im- portant and disregarded facts about the develop. ment of the English Constitution. RECENT NOVELS. The Feud of Oakfield Creek. A Novel of Cali- fornia Life. By Josiah Royce. Boston: Hough- ton, Mifflin & Co. A Child of the Century. By John T. Wheel- wright. Charles Scribner's Sons, Two Gentlemen of Boston. Co. Two Gentlemen of Gotham. By C. and C. Cas- sell & Co. The Whole Truth. By J. H. Chadwick. Cassell & Co. In One Town. By Edmund Downey. D. Ap- pleton & Co. The Strike in the B—— Mill: A Study, nor & Co. [Round Robin Series.] Boston: Ticknor & Tick- Lil Lorimer. By Theo Gift. D. Appleton & Co. Victims. By Theo. Gift. Henry Holt & Co. {Leisure Hour Series. } A Zealot in Tulle. By Mra. Wildrick. D. Ap- pleton & Co. The Lovely Wang: A Bit of China. By Hon. Lewis Wingfield. [Leisure Hour Series.] Hen ry Holt & Co. Baldine. By Karl Erdmann Edler, Translated from the German by the Earl of Lytton. Her- per & Bros. THE opportunities which a reader of current fic- tion may have of giving an hour or two of bis time to the work of other than unskilled and fre- quently presumptuous writers, are, relatively speaking, only too rare. The immense quantity of trash that is thrown into the form of novels, and in some way provided with publisher and audience, is so noticeable that to even speak of it seems commonplace. It is not at all wonderful that we should have this vast stream of fiction, which can in no way be classed as literature, con- stantly flooding the book-stalls; yet, like some other plainly visible and unremarkable aspects of the time, it is regrettable, and must be, to some who look to fiction to become a great teacher, discouraging. To these latter, and to all who care for good work, ‘ The Feud of Oakfield Creek’ will appeal strongly. Prof. Royce has made bis novel one of California life, concerning which he can speak from the chair; and while the scenes and the mechanism of the story are so perfectly flavored with the soil that one feels distinctly enough the impossibility of detaching the lives of Escott and Eldon, of Margaret and Harold. from their environment, yet one at the same time realizes, even more distinctly, that the pas- sions and natures of these people are true to bu manity. What is better still, they are true toa phase of humanity which is neither degraded nor trivial, but which, though of necessity marked with error, 1s nevertheless essentially noble and high. We know of no instance in fiction where alove between man and woman, which could not exist and be given expression to within the bounds of honor, has been depicted with the quiet strength and delicacy, and with the entire ab- sence of anything vicious or demoralizing, that characterizes the bistory of Margaret and Ha- rold. Without sentimentality, one pities the pair, and looks on them leading their separate, sorrowful lives as creatures of an inevitable fate —too strong to be rolled in the mire, and only strengthened and chastened by their past. The story is not altogether sombre, however, though one migh: reasonably ask that a little more cheer- fulness bad been scattered here and there through- out a tale essentially sad. Alf Escott is the only really cheerful figure, and what one sees of him at first hand is very telling 1m its lightening ef- fects; but the book is so largely a narrative in the past tense, and the incidents in Escott's hfe are so persistently unfortunate, that one thinks more on his broken existence and wasted taleuts than on the bravery, modesty, and evenne s—al- most recklessness—of temper with which he bears ill-luck. But, for all that, there isa very strong personality about the man, a genuine integrity and independence that makes one have a kindly feeling toward him, even as a mere acquaintance. It is because so great a part of the book is written in a narrative furm, also, that there is only now and then occasion for anything more than the plain, straightforward, vigorous style that counts for so much in the admirableness cf the whole work ; but when there is occasion for a dramatic scene, it is always drawn with power and truth and (notwithstanding the appearance sometimes of gracefulness sacrificed for strength) secundum artem. In fact, the novel is sterling throughout. It is good in plot and workman- ship, and in the portrayal and conception of * character ; it is natural and lifelike, and it is interesting. It is all this not now and then merely, but continually, and with an even, level temper which looks as if the writer had kept carefully within the limits of what was posi. > tively attainable. One gets ap idea, that is to say, that the next novel one may have the good fortune to receive from the same hand will be even better than this one. ‘A Child of the Century’ is another novel which is better than the average ; but it is not so good as it ought to be, nor would it be fair tar compare it too closely with ‘The Feud of Oak field Creek.’ The tone is much less earnest, for one thing, and the impression of trivial nothing ness which the admirers of an older school of novel-writers complain so much of nowadmys, is rather strongly given. And it may be said gene- rally that when a writer's endeavors to be bril- liant, or witty, or epigrammatic nothingness charming in itself to make airy become notice- able, success at the same time becomes impossi ble. Mr. Wheelwright introduces his hero at the age of thirty-five: yet, if the election to Congress were omitted, one would never take him to be other than the ordinary hero of from anywhere between twenty-two and twenty-eight, who is only a hero by courtesy because of his place in the cast. A child of the century may, in the re stricted sense of a detinition, be one who is wholly commonplace, who is tolerably honest, who talks intelligently of Dante for years and then resolves in vain to read his poem, and who, above all, takes a steamer for Europe as ordi nary mortals take a horse car; be may be one, to quote Clough’s lire from Mr. Wheelwright s title-page, among the { * Peeble and restless youths, born to Inglorious days.”’ But because the class thus defined is so situated as to give a certain color to much of what might be called society literature, one is not therefore to conclude that true heroism has died out of the world, nor that plain living and high thinking are altogether gone out of fashion. The scenes of the novel, like the conversations, are some- what fragmentary, and skip about from country to country and city to city with true modern capriciousness, and some of them—such as the strike in the Valley Lron Works or Cyrus Penni- man’s breach of trust—are unnecessary and dis- tracting. There is one very unfortunate quota- tion of Miss O'Hara's from Swinburne which is out of character and taste. Two anonymous novels,‘Two Gentlemen of Boston’ and *Two Gentlemen of Gotham,’ are i somewhat alike as well in the artificiality and } pretentiousness with which they are written as iu their names. The former, one can venture to guess, is by a woman, and, for impossible situa- tions, overdrawn characters, magical friend- ships, and the whole machinery of opportune deaths and sudden illness, can be recommended to them that like the mildly sensational. There is such a confusion of persons and places, and the **two gentlemen ™ have so little which identifies them with any special locality, that Boston might be any one of half-a-dozen different cities by merely changing the name of a street here and there. ‘Two Gentlemen of Gotham’ seems to have been written in partnership, and partly for the purpose of showing how apt the writers could be at making quotations. Percy Aylmer is some- thing of a prig, though he was evidently drawu for an admirable Crichton. Some of his disser- tations do not sound particularly fresh or origi- nal, and even thecultured Mr. Vere—whose por- trait might with justice be objected to as person- al and smacking too much of journalistic pen- pictures—does not despise an illustration or a sto- ry because it happens to bean old friend. Simple- sts: rare aati of FD a bap SCRE
Page 22
454 The Nation. [Number 1143 hearted Dick Twyffert, too, must bave uncon- sciously remembered Goethe’s Autobiography and Lili’s ruse of ‘‘ brushing,” when he shattered the Sévres vase in his predicament. Altogether, the book is more a reminiscence of other books than a product of thought and observation. ‘The Whole Truth’ is a study of an exceptional phase of character, which, developed under mor- bid conditions and portrayed by means of inci- dents and combinations highly improbable and melodramatic, serves no good purpose either in life or in art. One is never more strongly im- pressed with the fact that it takes more than a Pod plot or a single well-drawn character to make a novel of any worth than when reading stories hke ‘The Whole Truth,’ in which the writer, seemingly confident that the mere strangeness of his conception will suffice to arouse all the sympathies and emotions that are necessary to his end, neglects the simpler but better and more difficult methods of his art. Mr. Downey, on the other hand, is to be blamed for making too much of unimportant things. Not that he gives them too much weight in the evolution of his tale, but rather that he gives them too much space when they have nothing at all to do with the story. The result can only be fragmentary and disappointing. The subject of strikes is just now so general that one is not surprised to meet with it in fiction. While the writer of ‘The Strike in the B— Mill’ has not signally succeeded either in produc- ing a worthy novel or in shedding any new light on the question of labor and capital, he has ne- vertheless shown a fairness of temper and a kind- liness of spirit that will insure the success of his book’s purpose. This, as modestly expressed in the preface, is merely to emphasize in the minds of his readers the evils and dangers attendant upon certain manifestations of the present day in this country. Theo, Gift still shows the rapid and skilful hand which makes novel-writing almost a matter of mere manual labor, and turns out three vo- lumes of properly balanced love and hate, myste- ry, jealousy, and surprise as neatly as a moulder makes acast. Neither ‘Lil Lorimer’ nor ‘ Vic- tims’ can be praised as showing anything higher than a great facility for stringing episodes and using adjectives, together with a knack of charac- ter paiuting and a knowledge of the value of con- trasts. The former is by far the better of the two, aud is here and there delightfully fresh and breezy, especially in the South American scenes; but the unnecessary tragedy and depressing sad- ness of the latter cannot, even by the buoyancy of the style and the hurried action of the story, be sufficiently relieved. There is an excellent tone of earnestness about Mrs. Wildrick’s book, a sincerity and conscien- tious effort to honestly do the best possible, which is all the more gratifying to meet with because it issorare. The novel, one might say, is a novel for its own sake; and while it does not turn out a sermon, still there is nothing in it but what is elevating. The influence of romance is perhaps always a refining one, and there is a good deal of the romance of a past century woven in with a very pretty tale of the present one. Books on China are already so numerous that tourists in the Middle Kingdom find it well, on their return home, to cast their notes in the form of sermons, essays, or novels. Considering the mass of weighty documents in the library on China, this course is rather to be commended than condemned, It need not necessarily spoil a story, though there is danger of overloading the warp and woof of plot and dialogue with too heavy embroidery of unnecessary particulars. The novel before us is as full of brilliant color, almost to gaudiness, as a butterfly’s wings. The author’s note-book during a sojourn in Foh-kien province became, with jottings of native scenery and customs, and Chinese and foreigner’s gossip, as fullasa larval grub. Then, hieing to the se- clusion of Nikko, Japan, the chrysalis state was entered, and now we have the gorgeous novel. The story illustrates Chinese marriage customs, wherein it is easily possible for old knaves to out- wit their relatives-in-law by substituting the ugly for the pretty; and, under stress of temporary need, the wrong sex for the right one—tricks which are common 1n Chinese Asia, and as old as Laban and Jacob. The Lovely Wang, a charm- ing maiden and a noble character, thus falls un- wittingly in love with a male scapegrace of a Hung, who has been introduced in place of his lovely sister into the sick-room of her (Wang's) brother. By a counter-deception practised by Wang’s father, the lad and maiden, already in love with each other, are married. Hung junior then flies to Peking, and, in straits of poverty, sells himself asa slave. Meanwhile, the sick boy Wang dies, and the ‘“‘ Lovely Wang,” his sister, finds out that she is actually wedded to her sup- posed sister-in-law, who is a man. She goes to Peking. finds and redeems him, and all ends hap- pily. The novel is aclever production, full of pictures of Chinese scenery, but rather too full of the port-gossip of foreigners’ hongs and tiffins, with plenty of fun, facetious description of do- mestic life, and accounts of the fox superstition and of slaves and their redeemers. In short, it is a lively story for a summer’s day, and an easy way of enjoying a peep into Chinese domestic life. ‘**One can be profound without a great number of details, and subtle without a great many words,” says Canon Joseph Roux, in his ‘ Nou- velles Pensées.’ A more exact description of the style of the writer whom the Earl of Lytton has introduced to the English-reading public, by his translation of Karl Erdmann Edler’s three sto- ries—‘ Baldine,’ ‘ Notre Dame des Flots,’ and ‘A Journey to the Grossglockner Mountain’—it would be difficult to find. Nothing is lacking to render the charm of these simple yet profound stories supreme. Plot, dialogue, description, are all that could be asked, and they are couched in exquisite prose. Without being in the least sketchy, they leave much for the reader to fill in from his own heart and sympathies, and the delicate art of the writer is as convincingly dis- played in this respect as in that portion of his tales which he has expressed in words. The reader instantly comprehends what is required of him, and it is only when he reaches the end of the volume that he realizes how much has lain between the lines, and what a triumph the author has scored in guiding him so deftly and imperceptibly to supply it out of the fulness of his own nature, instead of himself giving utter- ance toit. An outline of the plots of these three life tragedies would convey but a feeble idea of their dramatic, poetic, and romantic worth, which the reader must obtain for himself at first hand. Their artistic value is well set forth in a preface by the translator, who will, it is to be hoped, afford the world a further opportunity of studying so refreshing a writer. That the translation is an entirely adequate one, is a mat- ter of course. If there is any criticism to be made upon it, it is that some of the author’s sen- tences are amplified or rounded out, though not at alltotheirinjury. It is possible that the dif- ferent editions may vary to this extent, and this theory is the best to adopt, in view of the perfec- tion of workmanship, A Handbook to Dante. By Giovanni A. Scar- tazzini. Translated from the Italian, with notes and additions, by Thomas Davidson. Boston : Ginn & Co, 1887. 16mo, pp. viii., 315. THE object of this volume i:, in the words of the translator, ‘‘to furnish intending students of Dante’s works with the necessary preparatory information, historical, bibliographical, bio- grapbical, and literary.” Scartazzini’s edition of the ‘Divine Comedy’ is so good as to afford assurance that any work of this sort from his hand will be of value. But the Handbook is fit- ted rather to be a companion to the student than an introduction to the study of Dante. The in- formation contained in it is so multifarious as to be likely, in some part at least, to be confusing to a student at the outset, and to become of interest and service to him only when he has made some advance in knowledge of the wide field of study. To every such student the book, in either language, may be confidently re- commended. The translation is moderately well done, but it bears marks of haste and of occasional unscho- larly carelessness. For instance, on page 7 we read, ‘It having occurred to Leonardo Bruni d’ Arezzo that Boccaccio had written of the life and character of Dante as if he had been writing about Filocopo, Filostrato, or Fiametta, made [sic] up his mind for his own pleasure to write anew the life of Dante.” The sentence, correctly translated, should read, ‘‘ As it seemed to Leonardo Bruni d’Arezzo that Boccaccio had written of the life and character of Dante as if he had been writing his ‘ Filocopo,’ his ‘ Filos- trato,’ or his ‘Fiametta’ (that is, as if he had been writing a romance, for these are the names of three well-known romances of Boccaccio], he undertook,” ete. Again, on page 30; Mr. David- son gives us the following unintelligible sentence: ‘*He [Dante] succeeded by assiduous study in attaining such a knowledge of the divine essence, and of the other separate intelligences, as cannot be comprehended here below by human powers,” Properly translated this sentence should read : ‘* By assiduous study he came to know respecting tue divine intelligence and the other separate in- telligences whatever may be comprehended of them here below by human wit.” Mr. David- son’s cannot is to be accounted for by his mis- taking ne, ‘of them,” for the negative par- ticle née. Translating, on page 43, words of Leonardo Bruni, Mr. Davidson writes: ‘‘The cavalry of Arezzo conquered and overcame the company of Florentine cavalry in such a tempest that the latter, being (almost) surrounded and taken cap- tive, were,” etc. Here are two errors. Bruni’s words are, ‘‘ con tanta tempesta vinsero e soper- chiarono la schiera de’ cavalieri Fiorentini, che sbarrati e rotii,” ete.—which mean, not “in such a tempest,” but “‘ with such fury of onset conquered and overcame the band of Florentine horse that the latter were” not “‘ (almost) sur- rounded and taken captive,” but ‘ put in confu- sion and routed.” In the original passage from Bruni, the word rotti is misprinted in Scar- tazzini’s ‘ Manuale’ as folti, and the misprint ac- counts for one of Mr. Davidson’s errors. Mis- prints have been a snare to him. On page 83 he states, that ‘in the sentence of condemnation pronounced on the 27th of January, 1302, it is said that Dante and his companions — were cited and summoned, according to law, by means of the Commune of Florence, to appear within a certain time.” How they could be cited and summoned by means of the Commune does not seem evident. The words in the Ma- nuale are per mezzo di, correctly translated ‘‘ by means of,” but the mezzo is a misprint for messo, as Mr. Davidson might have learned by looking at the original text of the condemnation, where he would have found per numptium (‘ by a messenger”) of the Commune. There are many other errors similar to these, which detract from the confidence to be placed in the book, and which would be less surprising
Page 23
May 26, 1887] The Nation. 455 in the work of a translator of less literary pre- tension than Mr. Davidson. A more serious fault is to be found in the notes he has added to Scartazzini’s text. Some of them, indeed, are excellent, supplying omis- sions or correcting errors in the original; but most of the longer ones are controversial, and have a tone of assurance, and even of arrogance, such as happily is less frequent in the writing of scholars to-day than it was some generations ago. In this Mr. Davidson follows the unfor- tunate example of Scartazzini himself, who, in the earlier part of his comment on the ‘ Divine Comedy,’ exhibits an astonishing command over the resources of the Italian vocabulary of terms of literary abuse. But it would have been better had his translator taken note of Scartazzini’s open repentance in the preface to the ‘ Para- diso,” where the first rule that he lays down for a supposed editor of a future edition of his com- ment is— Si cancelli assolutamente ogni parola, ogni sillaba, di polemica che si troverd nei tre volumi. Had he but regarded these words, Mr. Davidson might have spared us such phrases as, ‘* All this is a piece of special pleading without any foundation whatever ”; ‘‘ absolutely ground- less assertion”; ‘‘ this conclusion is utterly il- logical, unfair,and at variance with facts,” and others of the same sort. In some instances Mr. Davidson has good ground for regarding Scar- tazzini’s views as incorrect, and his arguments as feeble, but in others his own position is decid- edly more questionable than the one which he attacks. An instance of this is his long and pre- sumptuous note (pp. 132, 133) on the translation of three verses from one of Dante’s eclogues, in which, asit appears to us, he is manifestly in the wrong, though in so saying we ally ourselves with many scholars who, according to Mr. Da- vidson, have committed ‘‘a gross blunder,” and hold to what he esteems “a curious and amus- ing misunderstanding and mistranslation,” than which he hardly knows any more so. The proof-reading of the volume has been very careless, and errors abound in the pages—for ex- ample, page 8, ‘ Valutello” for Vellutello ; ‘‘ Li- ber . . . nune primum editus” for“ .. . nune primum editum;” page 9, ‘‘ Moreno” for **Moreni ”; page 11, “‘ compilate” for ‘‘ compi- lata”; page 14, ‘‘ Biografi de lui” for ‘ Bio- grafi di lui”; ‘‘ A work of marvellous erudition, but less essential,” for ‘‘ A work of marvellous erudition not less essential.” Subsequent pages show a multitude of similar errors. In spite of its defects, however, the book is one that many students will find useful. Charles Reade, D.C.L., Dramatist, Novelist, Journalist. A memoir compiled chiefly from his literary remains. By Charles L. Reade and the Rev. Compton Reade. Harper & Bros. 1887, Tuts is a somewhat remarkable memoir. It is made up of extracts from the private papers of Charles Reade, in the shape of letters, diaries, and unpublished squibs, and also of a connecting narrative of great fluency and spirit. Responsi- bility for the former part rests upon Charles L. Reade, the literary executor of the novelist, and that for the latter upon the Rev. Compton Reade, a nephew—a division of labor so carefully. in- sisted upon by the two partmers in the book that each seems to be disclaiming any share in the other’s work instead of standing for his own. The greater interest lies in the narrative portion. It is salacious, and smacks much more of its au- thor than of its subject; but as he is apparently every inch a Reade, one learns something of the distinguished novelist’s character vicariously by the idiosyncrasies of his nephéw, evidently a chip of the same original block. In fact, one un- derstands very readily the petulance, quarrel- someness, and violence of Charles Reade by ob- serving in how similar a way his relative ex- presses himself. There are two things which the nephew cannot think of without getting into a rage: one is Mr. Slatter, a schoolmaster of the stupid flogging kind, from whom several of the Reades suffered, and to whom the writer adminis- ters a literary birching of such long-continued ferocity that the reader half wishes that he would ‘let up” on the brute; the other is the society of the Fellows of Magdalen College, toward whom he entertains a most scoffing spirit. If the ob- jurgations of Slatter and the gibes at Magdalen were left out, the memoir would lose a large share of its vigor, which is mainly of the fight- ing variety. The Rev. Compton Reade is nota man much given to respect, however, and there would still be plenty left to give him a character for speaking his mind with frankness and fulness in regard to all matters of offence to him. Charles Reade’s mother, to whom he is said to have been tenderly attached, bad her peculiarities, and these come out with Sufficient clearness; but it was hardly necessary for her grandson to add, after having freely exhibited her less amiable traits, that she was ‘“‘a domestic tyrant.” One cannot think that Charles Reade would have ap- proved such an expression about his mother in his own memoir. This is perhaps the worst slip; but to point out instances of bad taste in the Rev. Compton Reade’s narrative would be as su- pertiuous as to stop to remark upon his English, which, as any one may observe, tomahawks syn- tax and diction with a reckless dexterity very amusing to witness, We dwell so long upon the Rev. Compton Reade because his personality is really the one that affects the reader; he effaces his uncle ex- cept where the extracts from the latter's diaries and letters force him to give place. This is, of course, wholly unintentional, and, indeed, only the unconsciousness of the self-assertion would excuse it. But when one comes to the end and asks what more he knows about Reade than he knew before, the ineffectiveness of such a method of biography is very plain. Reade came of a county family of old stock, and the opening chapters about the Squire and bis home and the childhood surroundings of the novelist are the best part of tke book. It was a fine, sturdy, evangelical, fox-hunting, India-emigrating fami- ly, Charles Keade being the eleventh and last scion, and all its members were of excellent Bri- tish stuff and took their stations in the world as they ought. It fell to tke lot of this youngest son to be a Fellow of Magdalen, which provided bim with an income for something over fifty years—a small income for a gentleman, it is true, but cheap, since he did nothing for it worth men- tioning. He was also a make-believe lawyer, an expert in the repair of old violins, and a candi- date for theatrical honors; and at last, rather late in life, he made a success as a playwright and became famous as a novelist. The letters which he wrote home when he was travelling abroad are without character, and the other ma- terial from bis papers is of little value. Of his nature one learns very little not already well known, and few new illustrations of it are to be found in these pages. Mrs. Seymour, his house- keeper, is a mere figure, and no light is thrown upon the bond which united the two, though the Platonic character of the attachment is strongly insisted on. On the whole, the memoir is chiefly remark- able, next to the Rev. Compton Reade’s pugna- cious sprightliness, for its plentiful lack of fresh information respecting its subject. Reade’s pe- culiar temperament, his methods of work, and his controversies are an old story. As an Eng- lishman he was the type cf the man who pro verbially writes to the Times; as a writer, he was a novelist only because be could not be a dra- matist, and in his books he tried to come as near to writing a play as the form of the novel per mitted. He lives by a few strong stories, now, and will live by ‘ The Cloister and the Hearth,’ it is to be hoped, a long time; but bis anomalous position in literature is well Ulustrated by the a! most infinitesimal place occupied in his biogra phy by other literary persons. It is unfortunate that his life was not told by some one less hike himself, and in a simpler and calmer style. As to the main matter, whether Reade led a life worth any fuller record than that given to it by his works, one inclines to the conclusion tbat there was not much to tell. The Evangelical Revival in the Eighteenth Cen tury. By John Henry Overton, Canon Lincoln and Rector of Epworth, Anson D Randolph & Co, Tue third volume of the “ Epochs of Church History * series has a more interesting subject than either of its predecessors, but it is not a more interesting book than Canon Perry's * Re formation in England,’ or the Rev. Mr. Tucker's ‘English Church in Other Lands.’ The author has done little more than give a dry compendiun: of events, which only needed a spark of genuine sympathy, it would seem, to set them all aflame Perbaps be was discouraged by the fact that Southey, and Lecky, and other effective writers, had been before him and said all the good things Brevity in historical writing is not alwavs the soul of wit. It is much oftener its body of death from which it fain would be delivered. But that the Evangelical Revival can be treated briefly and at the same time effectively is proved by Mr. Lecky'’s ninth chapter in his ‘England in the Fighteenth Century.’ His treatment is considera- bly briefer than Canon Overton's, but while it omits nothing of importance that is here express- ed, and contains much of importance that is here omitted, it is full of interest and fascination. The whole is sometimes greater than the sum of all its parts, ani while Canon Overton's ac.» count of various separate parts of the Revival is faithful and significant, we miss a proper and in- spiring sense of its unity and integrity. His in- troduction is extremely brief. It is for the most part concerned with the causes of the religious apathy at the beginning of the Georgian era. o'r 1. i The cause most insisted on is the influence of. Sir Robert Walpole. This influence, he avers, ‘*contributed more than all the other causes com- bined * to that condition from which Methodism was a violent reaction. But it was an apathy which was relieved by the great names of Berkeley and Butler, and William Law, whose ‘ Serious” Call’ was the fountainhead of the Revival, though Law himself had little admiration for the deepening and expanding stream. The arrangement of Canon Overton’s material is good so far as it goes, but the material is insufficient. A movement passionately ethi- cal and pietistic is regarded almost wholly from an ecclesiastical point of view. The chap- ter upon Wesley is discriminating, and, for an ardent Churchman, even sympathetic, but the emphasis is almost wholly on Wesley's relation to the Establishment. We are interested in see- ing how little of the practical working of the Revival was deliberately planned ; how much of it was determined by the various exigencies of the time, in spite of Wesley’s predilections, In the chapter upon Whitefield, Charleg Wesley, and other ‘‘ helpers,” the balance is very evenly held between Whitefield and Wesley. The achieve- ment is an easy one for Canon Overton because he is himself ‘‘a moderate Calvinist’; less Cal- vinistic than Whitefield, more so than Wesley. 2 2 4 ; a rs €] ie 4 §
Page 24
456 The Nation. {Number 1143 When we read that Charles Wesley wrote more than 6,000 hymns, we wonder that more of them were not good by merest chance among so many. In the account of Fletcher of Madeley there is no mention of his controversial work, the most im- portant on the Arminian side the time produced. A chapter on “* Methodism and Evangelicalism ” distinguishes the Revival in the Church as op- posed to Methodist forms of activity, from the Revival freely using novel means of pro- pagation; and Canon Overton's inclination is evidently to include as much as_ possible under the head of ‘‘ Evangelicalism.” Loy- alty to the Church is his cardinal virtue. Wes- ley’s appointmert of Coke and Asbury as bishops for America is his single reinous fault. Newton's slave-trading is reserved for the climax of his unconverted wickedness; but of the rela- tion of Whitefield’s predilection for *‘a planta- tion of fat niggers” to his converted sanctity nothing is said. The literature of the Revival has a chapter to itself, the longest in the book. It was decidedly inferior to the religious literature immediately beyond its scope—Butler’s, Berke- ley’s, and Law’s. It is to be hoped that the chap- ter on the results of the Revival is imperfect— that there were other results of the Revival more important than any named, except the abolition of slavery in the West Indies. Wesley’s opinion of slavery, and not Whitefield’s, was generally held by the reformers. Thomas Clarkson’s part is needlessly depreciated to enhance the value of Wilberforce’s, the credit of which is claimed for the Evangelicals. The nature of the opposition to the Revival, its doctrines, and its relation to other religious movement are treated briefly in the closing chapters. Some Chinese Ghosts. By Lafcadio Hearn. Bos- ton: Roberts Brothers. WHILE the ghosts of Japan and Corea seem to be wet and bedraggled creatures, born of wells and water and swamp, the Chinese ghosts manufac- tured by Mr. Hearn are wrought outof fire. The author, possibly, has been in the Middle King- dom and made himself familiar with the proper environment of the spirits that dwell in bronze and pottery. He has read well the writings of Si- anologists, and saturated his mind with images de- dightful to the fancy of the sons of Han. His style is exquisitely polished, his vocabulary is the cream of language, and his six stories are told with literary art. ‘‘ The Soul of the Great Bell,” ‘“*The Story of Ming-Y,” ‘‘ The Legend of Tchi- niu,” ‘“‘ The Return of Yen-Tchin, King,” “‘ The Tradition of the Tea-Plant,” ‘‘The Tale of the Porcelain God,” with appendices in the form of notes and glossary, complete his modest table of conteats. The booklet has less than 200 pages, and to each chapter, besides the title-page, is ap- pended a line of Chinese characters. At least the mystic marks are intended to stand for Chi- nese mottoes, Buddhist banner legends, sentences from the classics, the name of China, etc. They show, in their tell-tale craziness of copying, crook- edness of writing, and roughness of engraving, their Occidental manufacture. This, when laun- drymen are numerous in every American city, is unfair to the shades of Confucius as well as to the ghosts. If it be little glory in the West to be killed in battle and have your name misspelled in the despatches, surely the spirits evoked by the literary resurrectionist should be right- ly written. Not only does Mr. Hearn mix his proper names as given in German and French spellings, but he even calls up a ghost known only in Japan to frolic and masquerade in China. Nor should even the Chinese be held to account, in addition to all their other sins, for the lasci- vious coloring given to a very simple legend. “The Tradition of the Tea-Plant,” seems to be the most artificially and clumsily constructed of the six stories. ‘‘ The Soul of the Great Bell” is that of the virgin daughter of a bronze caster who could not win success in his mould except by the cremation in the crucible of a beautiful maiden. Ming-Y isa lad who helds wassail and gains priceless literary relics from a famous cour- tesan whose spirit hovers over the ruins of a pa- lace razed centuries ago. Tchi-niu is a paragon of filial reverence ; and the Porcelain God is the deified man who baked himself into his own clay biscuit, and is now worshipped by potters and furnace-tenders in China. Altogether, the impression madé upon a West- ern reader of Mr. Hearn’s semi-Chinese produc- tions is not pleasant, though it might have been made so. Still, those who keep and enjoy the art products of Cathay welcome whatever legends will unlock the mysteries of the Chinese wonder world. Just as with the fairy and mystic lore of Japan, after the bloody, revengeful, and li- centious elements are eliminated, there remain enchanting meadows of perfume and fragrance, so in Chinese literature ahd folk-lore there are yet untrodden gardens of sweet fancies. So long as the art of Asia is studied, there will be need of popular interpretation for Occidentals. Ghosts flourish most when there is a demand for them, and the multiplying museums and private col- lections of the bric-&-brac of Sinim call for occa- sional works like this modest book of Mr. Hearn, which, while in taste and emphasis of objection- able elements not wholly worthy of him, is a promise of better things to come. New York: The Planting and Growth of the Empire State. By Ellis H. Roberts. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co, 1887. To conde.se within the limits of 700 small pages the story for 280 years of a growing State, de- scribing material conditions, unfolding the se- quence of events, portraying inherited and per- sonal character in the men who guided them, and whom in turn they controlled—to impress this picture with continuity and dispose it in due perspective, is no easy task. It is not surpris- ing, then, that the author of these volumes offers his readers abundance rather than coherence cf material, and that his examples overwhelm the philosophy his history should teach. The annals of no other of our thirteen primary commonwealths offer the diversity that causes this difficulty. New York alone among them was planted by one people and conquered by another, changing nationality with name. It was the only colony that welcomed all faiths and blended all races. She alone bore the stress of war with the most potent and civilized cf Eu- ropean States on the one side, and the most com- pact and cruel of savage confederacies on the other. She carried on trade, conflict, and di- plomacy with alien neighbors as no other colony was forced todo. After independence, the second war disturbed commerce, harassed the frontiers, and strained relations with the Federal Govern- ment more severely for her than for other States which stood less resolute and less faithful. And as to her political history, whether as colony or as State, her mixed population, with its early control by great families and its later concen- tration into great cities, singularly complicates the study. In either of two methods the growth of such a commonwealth might be treated. One is to ana- lyze the national elemerts composing it, and the material conditions under which these developed, tracing their interaction on philosophic princi- ples, supported by copious illustration ; the other is to set down in consecutive narrative the more important po-nts in its progress, with color of incident, but without research into causes and their workings, The author seems to have adopt- ed neither method frankly, halting between the two. He does sometimes state a principle and accumulate relative facts, but refuses the labor of demonstrating their living connection. This occurs oftenest where the causes are mors simple and obvious, in colonial times. Inthe story of later days, since the century began, the attempt is less often made, and for its neglect may be pleaded the obscurity and complexity of the ele- ments for study. Yet ina history brought down to last year, one naturally asks for some account of the rise and reasons of the Labor party, or some note of the portentous growth of Romish pretensions. As instances, taken at random from the most diverse classes of subjects, of the want of propor- tion in the author’s historical treatment, the topic of land and rent is discussed in eight pages, while a single page recalls the Liberty party, mentioning only one of its leaders, and omitting those who inspired its ideas. A page is devoted to the battle of Plattsburgh, while an incidental mention and a dismissal with less than two lines are all that is given to that on Lake Erie. An extended account of the French invaders’ enter- prises, religious and warlike, among the [roquois , throws into the shade the far more important re- lations of the tribes with Dutch and English colonists. In general, however, that part of these volumes recounting colonial history is written with more care and clearness than the sequel, opening with this century. The portraits of royal governors are done with some touch of individual quality, far more lifelike than the style of the detached sketches of later statesmen, reminding one of re- porters’ little biographies, pigeonholed for obi- tuary issue. Hardly an attempt is made to show the development in the State of legal doctrines on such important topics as the rights of women and the relations between the spheres of national and of State governments. And though some de- tails are touched upon illustrating the evils of legislation in early times, we must regretfully dissent from the conclusion that ‘‘the standard of morality and honor for legislators is higher than it was in the earlier days.” The index is carelessly pitched together, omit- ting, for example, any mention of the Erie Canal or of Myron Holley, one of its chief promoters, as he was also one of the New York creators of the Liberty party, though all these subjects form part of the volume. In brief, the work may be summed up as a rather perfunctory and far from thorough record of dates and facts, useful so far as it goes, but falling much below the dignity of a monograph on the history of the State of New York. The Game of Logic. Mac- millan. 8vo, pp. 96. By Lewis Carroll. It need not strike any one with wonder that the author of ‘ Alice in Wonderland’ should write a book about logic. Even if he were not known as a mathematician, it might safely be predicted that a man who could make such beautiful non- sense as that book contains would have a very good head for sense. The principle that it takes a thief to catch a thief does not hold here: one must have a very pretty taste for logic if he wishes to compose pleasing specimens of un- logic. This little book describes a device for working syllogisms by means of compartments marked out on a piece of card-board, and counters, red and gray, which indicate respectively that the compartments are occupied or empty. The counters are put into their proper places in ac- cordance with the demands of the premises, and
Page 25
May 26, 1887] The Nation. A577 then whatever results are irrespective of the mid- dle term are read off as the conclusion. This plainly does not constitute a game, but merely a mechanical plan for working out a series of puz- zles. As a logical machise for three terms, it is very workable, and possibly amusing. If there are some children or some grown people who may be led by the pleasing device of colored counters to exercise themselves in drawing or in testing conclusions, it will doubtless do some good. The same thing is more readily accom- plished, however, by algebraical than by geo- metrical means. But mechanical logical methods do not show to good advantage in anything so simple as syllo- gism. Their proper field is in more complicated combinations of premises. It may well be doubt- ed whether they do not injure rather than add to the automatic feeling of the inevitableness of a conclusion, which is what one has to trust to in real life. One does not strengthen the legs by using crutches, although they form an admirable means of getting over the ground when legs are found to be inadeguate. If a person is unable to say at once what conclusion, if any, follows from any simple pair of premises, he may feel sure that his logical machinery is in need of oiling. What plan is best for putting it into good condition itis not an easy matter to decide. Probably the ideally perfect method would be for the person who sees at once, to drag out of thesub-conscious regions of his mind the actual process by which he sees, and to set it forth in the plain light of day, and then to discipline the patient with count- less instances until the process has become auto- matic to him also. To expound to him the rules of syllogism is a very different thing; it is a mat- ter of accident whether they follow the actual course of thought or not in any given instance, At the same time, he ought to have perfect com- mand of some guod and simple method, and to be able to apply it with ease as a means of last re- sort in cases of difficulty. That such cases are not far to seek, it would be very easy to show. Euclid himself does not seem to have been aware that the contrapositive of a proposition is always true. And his latest followers, with the single exception of Mr. Halsted, so far as we have noticed, have thought it necessary, for instance, to prove that two parallels to a line cannot go through a point, or, in other words, are parallel to each other, although it is a mere restatement of the axiom that through a point only one paral- lel to a line can be drawn. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. =~ i J. Cucumber Chronicles. Scribner & elfo: Barine, A. Portraits de Femmes—Mme, Carlyle, George Eliot, etc. Paris: Hachette, Beecher, H. W. Speeches on the American Rebellion, bag ot in Great Britain in 1863. Frank E. Lovell & so. wy J.B. “Roundabout to Moscow. D. Appleton & Co. 50, Bumblebee Bogo’s Budget. By a Retired Judge. Mac- millan & Co. $2. Butler, A. J. Court Life in Egypt. Illustrated. Serib- ner & Welford. Cameos tresa English History: Forty Years of Stewart Rule. 1603—1643. By the Author of ‘ The Heir of Ked- _clyffe.’ Sixth Series. Macmillan & Co. $1.25, Champsaur, Félicien. Le Défilé. Paris: Victor-Havard ; Boston: Schoenhof. Cook, A.M. Macmillan’s Latin Course. First Year. Mac- millan & Co. 90 cents. Cooke, C. K. Australian Defences and New Guinea. Com piece from the Papers of the late Major-General Sir Sa Scratchley. With a Memoir. Macmillan & Co. Douglas, W. Duelling Days in the Army. Scribner & Fowler, Prof. T._ The Principlesof Morals. PartTI. Be. ing the Body of the Work. Macmillan & Co. $2.75. Frémy, E. L’Académie des derniers Valois d ‘apres les documents nouveaux et inédits. Paris; E. Leroux: Boston: Schoenhof. Garrett. Rev. A.C. The Eternal Socetiice. and Other Dis- courses. James Pott & Co. $1.25 Gitmore, J. R. John Sev a asa - -- eS Builder. @ D Aopietcs & Ce. #1. —— jraham, D. ing James t Tst: An Historical Traged PR oy co. A. 4 ireenous tters of Horatio Greenough to his plrother Henry. Be net S Co. rowt Church Institutions. rarnomnes tr TD a Hee if thi rye . of the ~? Unioa of Great Britain and Ireland. Macmillan $s. . Kehrbach, K. Monumenta Germania Pedagogica. Bund lL Braunschweigische Schulordnungen 1. Bund IL Ratio Studiorum = Institutiones scholastic Roctstetts : A. Hofmann & Co.; New York: F 0. Lecky, W. E.H. History of England in the 18th Century. Vows. 5 and 6. D. Appleton & Co. $2.25 each. k, J. B. Dynesaies for Beginners. Macmillan & Co. #2. Mauthner, | Von Keller zu Zola: Kritische AufsdAtze. Berlin: J. J. Reine; New York: Westermann. m. if J Mrs. Marr ing and Giving in Marriage: A Novel. Harper's Franklin Square Library. 15 cents. O’Connor, Evangeline M. An Index to the Works of Shakspere. D. Appleton & Co. $2. Page, T.N. In Ole Virginia: or Marse C han, and Other Stories. Charles Scribner’s Sons. $1. Pessard, H. Mes petits posters. 1850-1870, Paris; Cal mann Lévy; ton: Schoenhof. ton, Margaret J. Colonial Ballads, Sonnets, and Other Verse. Boston: Houghton, MiMlin & Co. $1.25 Read, Jane M. Between the Centuries, and Other Poems. Boston: Henry A. Young & Co. Renan, E. Studies in Religious History. Scribner & Welford. Rosmini Serbati, A. The Ruling Principle of Method Ap- plied to Edncation. Boston: D.C. Heath & Co. 81.50, Row, Cc. A. Future Retribution, Viewed in the Light of Reason and Revelation, Thomas Whittaker. $2.50. Schurz, ©. Life of Henry Clay [American Srateomen Series}. 2 vols. Boston: Houghton, MiMflin & Co, $y 50. Sewnet—See. Lessons in Elementary Practical Physics Yol. IL. er and Magnetism. Macmillan & Co. Thlorry. B. La coméaié- Francaise pendant les deux siéges, 1870-1871. Journal ‘de l’'Administrateur-gé- néral, Paris: Tresse & Stock: Boston: Schoenhof, Whinfield, E. H. Masnavi I Ma’navi: The Spiritual Couplets of Maulana Jalabu.’D-Din Muhammad | Rumi. London: Triibnuer & Co. Fine Arts. THE AMERICAN ART ASSOCIATION, At the Third Prize Fund Exhibition, under the mapvagement of the American Art Association, there is a collection of some 230 pictures. As has been the case in the two previous exhibi- tions, many of the important canvases have been contributed by American artists abroad. This year, however, Messrs. Harrison, Simmons, Mos- ler, Walter Gay, Bridgman, and Donoho, who have been prominent contributors in the past, are unrepresented, and Messrs. Boggs and Ulrich are exemplified by comparatively unimportant pictures. The good average which has charac- terized the exhibitions is well sustained this year, for there are some new names of note among the contributors from the foreign colony, and the artists at home seem to have made even more than the usual effort to be well represented. In figure-painting the bonors are carried off by Mr. Robert F. Blum, whose picture, ‘‘ Venetian Lace Makers,” No. 24, is much the best work he has ever exhibited. A dozen of th? proverbially picturesque Venetian girls of the people are seen in this picture seated in groups around their cushion-stands in a large room, the doors and windows of which are shaded from the outside glare by green blinds. The gay, almost gaudy, colors of the girls’ dresses are happily contrasted, and the picture is excellently painted throughout. In fact, it is marked by unusual knowledge and completeness in treatment, and is in every re- spect a strong picture. There are some delight- ful bits in it, such as the figure of the girl bend- ing over her work near the door in the middle of the composition, and the one in the red dress in the foreground, in which admirable delicacy of color and breadth of painting are sbown. The effect of diffused light in the room is well render- ed, and the girls, chatting and laughing over their work, look natural and real. “A Difficult Duet,” No, 128, by F. D. Millet, is a picture which shows to perfection this artist's recognized cleverness in painting subjects of the latter part of the eighteenth century. The young woman at the piano, the man in striped change- able silk coat and periwig playing the violin, the quaint old piano, the music stand, the round mirror on the wall. are all execated with the pre- ciseness and prim charm of a Dutch master. The picture is simple in composition and quiet and agreeable in color. One of the best genre pictures in the exhibition is * Forging the Blade,” No. 62, by F. 8. Dellen- baugh. The subject is nothing more than a blacksmith standing by a forge with a long blade ou which he is at work in his hands, but it is so well painted, the effect of light coming through a narrow window and falling on the figure and the dusty brick walls of the forge is so truthfully given, detail is so carefully painted, while com- pleteness of ensemble is preserved, that this little picture is admirable. *The Deathof Minnehaha,” No, 69, by W. L. Dodge, which is said to be the werk of a young painter of one-and-twenty, is certainly a picture of much promise. The canvas is large, and con- tains three life size figures. The dead body of Minnehaha is laid on a bier in the middle of the picture, and two warriors are seen mourning, the one on his knees on the ground at the head of the bier, the other seated, bolding bis head in his hands, at the foot. The painting is in general broad and skilful, and the picture possesses many excellent technical qualities, It is in no way remarkable for color, and it is seriously deficient in drawing in parts, notably in the fig- ures of the two mourning braves; but the nude torso of the dead girl is good, the picture holds together well, and is well managed as to general treatment. It is the most ambitious work in the exhibition, and as the contribution of a young _ artist, who has but recently come into notice among the American artists abroad, it is entitled to consideration as well as for its intrinsic merits, “A Souvenir of Picardy,” No. 167, by F, ¢ Penfold, a life-size study of a tisher-girl carrying a heavy seine net on ber shoulder, with a back ground of beach ard ocean—a strong, vigorously painted figure ; ‘‘ The Toilers of the Sea,” No. 105, by George Hitchcock, a party of fishermen and women coming across the sands at low tide, paintedin a strong effect of hght with great truth of observation and justoess of values; ** The Tired Moss Gatherer,” No. 127, by J. Gari Melchers, a peasant girl lying with her basket at her side on the dunes at early evening, a pic- ture painted in a quiet key of color, and noticeable for its fine quality of at- mosphere; ‘‘ Arrival of the Fishing Boats,” No. 156, by W. E. Norton, a scene ona stone pier at Dieppe, representing a crowd of market peo- ple and idlers congregated at the water side, where a mass of boats are being moored, whose tall masts and broad sails rise in picturesque lines against the gray French sky—an effec- tively composed and frankly painted picture; ** Charity,” No. 84, by C. L. Fox, life-size figures of a strolling player girl lying on a rush mat in a hut, with a wrinkled old crone bending over her, in which there is some good painting, but which is insufficient in drawing; ‘ Lavoir in the Gatinais,’ No, 32, by Amanda Brewster, a large canvas with a num- ber of figures of washerwomen at the edge of an enclosed basin of water, composed in a haphazard sort of way, but of considerable ex- cellence as a study; and ‘‘ Consolation, Church of St. Fiac, Brittany,” No, 182, by H. M. Rosenberg, a nook in an old country church, with five old peasant women sitting in a row on a bench awaiting the coming of the priest—a picture which is sober and dignified in intention, but which would be more successful were it less bizarre in composition—are other works by figure painters sent to the exhibition from Europe which merit commendation. To these ehould be added Mr. Childe Hassam’s three ex- cellent pictures of Paris scenes—‘‘ Les Grands and “A Paris,” No. 101, “Woman Milking,” No. 225, by Horatio Walker, which shows the interior of a stable with a strong light coming in through the open doorway and a woman milking a cow—a vigor- ous and healthy piece of realistic painting ; ‘* The Year was Young,” No. 176, by Mary C. Richard- Boulevards,” No. 102; ‘ Over the Seine,” No. 103, > é ER ee |
Page 26
458 The Nation. [Number 1143 son, an excellent life-size study of a young woman with a child in her arms, painted in an out-door effect with a background of green foliage, remark- able for its subtle modelling and simplicity; ‘‘ In Blossom Time,” No. 60, by Herbert F. Denman, | | of these only one, ‘* Portrait,” No, 52, by Ken- | neth R. Cranford, a half-length figure of a gen- | tleman, bas much merit to recommend it. In | landscapes there is a fine showing. two young girls in pseudo- Greek costume, painted in a delicate color scheme of pale tints, and noticeable for refined decorative quality. “The Wedding Gown,” No. 152, by Rhoda Holmes Nichols, a strongly painted study of a young woman sewing on a white satin robe ; “Searching for the Will,” No. 12, by W. V. | is the daring title given by Mr. Thomas Allen to Birney, a clever genre, in which an old woman is seen bending over a table piled with quantities of musty books and papers; ‘Giving an Estimate,” No. 135, by Leon Moran, a nicely painted conceit of a sign-painter (in the time of Louis XVL) and his patron discussing the cost of a gorgeously carved and gilded sign- board; ‘‘Inspiration,” No. 20, by Edwin H. Blashfield, a large canvas with a female figure of Music, seated in a sort of niche, and an angel or muse hovering above her—a decorative picture possessing many substantial merits; and ‘‘ Sap- pho,” No. 126, by G. W. Maynard, a picture of the poetess seated on a high bench in a marble hall with clouds of incense floating about, pos- sessing great beauty of tone and refined in senti- ment—these may be picked out of the large num ber of other figure pictures for special mention. “ Still Life,” No, 229, by J. Alden Weir, a study of blue and white jars, a brass lanthorn, a copper basin or two, and a bunch of lilacs, the whole placed on an old table, with a piece of the wall of a studio as a background, is ex- ceedingly handsome in color, In the same field are to be seen two still-life pictures by Emil Carl- ‘sen, ** Decorative Panel in Yellows,” No. 41, a rather ineffective and forced arrangement of yellow roses and yellow stuffs ; and ‘‘ Azaleas,” No, 42, a great bunch of pink flowers in a stone jar which are certainly peonies, and ' whose title of Azaleas in the catalogue must be owing to a | mistake—a color study of considerable beauty, strongly and freshly painted. The present exhibition is very weak in portrait work. There are only five or six altogether, and * Over all the hill-tops is rest, Even thro’ the trees thou feelest Scarcely a breath,” his picture, No. 3,.in the catalogue. Itis a large landscape, simple'and noble in composition. A hill sloping down from right to left, with a group of massive trees half-way down the descent, a purple-tinted evening sky, and the newly risen moon riding in the sky just above the crest of the hill, is the motive, and it is broadly and amply painted. This picture belongs among the best American landscapes of recent years. It is an excellent example of the best kind of realis- tic treatment of nature combined with a fine poetic feeling. Two pictures, “An October Day,” No. 218, and “ Night,” No. 214, exemplify the charming talent of Mr. Tryon. ‘ Night” is a picture of the moon nearly at its full, rising just above the horizon, with a low-roofed: barn and a hay-stack in the foreground of the compo- sition. The artist has succeeded admirably in rendering his effect, a very difficult one, too, and in getting rid of the presence of paint in his pic- ture. The moon seems actually to light the picture, in every part of which there is a vibrating sense of atmosphere in both light and shadow. This picture by Mr. Tryon is of a high order of merit, and would hold its own in the most distinguished company. “* Broad Acres,” No. 86, a large canvas signed by Edward Gay, is thoroughly American in subject. A waving field of ripe grain fills the foreground, | and in the middle distance are seen a row of tele- graph poles indicating a roadway through the fields, and a stage-coach toiling wearily along un- der the hot sun; clusters of country houses are scattered along the rising ground in the distance, and a luminous noon-day sky stretches high up over all. There isa great deal of nature in this picture, and it is conscientiously and frankly painted. ‘“ By the Woodside,” No. 153, by Burr H. Nicholls, isan autumn scene, of woods and fields and a distant river, in which there is some excellent drawing of trees. ‘‘ Snow and Sunshine,” No. 164, is one of Mr. Walter Palmer’s effective and truthful studies of winter sunlight. ‘ Late Afternoon,” No. 59, a large landscape by Charles H. Davis, reveals a flat plain and low horizon with a broad expanse of pale-tinted sky and a mountain of pink clouds. It is delicate and pretty to the point of weakness, and is artificial and false in effect. ‘‘ Moonrise,” No. 166, by Richard Pauli, reminding one strongly of the methods of Daubigny, yet possessing good qualities of its own; “The Tide River,” No. 241, by Charles H. Woodbury. a large landscape representing marsh lands with stacks of dried grasses and a stream of tide water wind- ing through them, luminous and fairly good in effect, but altogether too brutal in texture; ‘‘ The Close of an Autumn Day,” No. 45, by B. W. Clinedinst, a nicely-painted picture of a garden, evincing accurate observation; and “ A Garden by the Danube,” No. 82, by R. B. Fitz, a study of a potato-field, in which there is excellent quality of atmosphere—are some other notable landscapes. Mr. Murphy is well exemplified in ‘‘ September Noon,” No. 144, and ‘* Morning Greys,” No. 146; Mr. Dewey in “‘ October,” No, 64; Mr. Van Bos- kerck in ‘‘ Near the Sea, South Plymouth,” No. 221; and Mr. Minor in ‘‘ September Afternoon,” No. 131, and ‘‘ Solitude,” No. 183. Mr. Rehn ex- hibits a strongly-painted marine, ‘‘ The Surging Sea,” No. 173. ia’ should be in every “The ‘Young Folks’ Cyclo . Report of the Connecticut uvenile Hbrary.”—From a card of Education. YOUNG FOLKS’ f Comenens Things. . ...$2.50 Oo CYCLOPADIA © | Persons and Places... 2.50 *,* Sent, postpaid, on receipt of price. HENRY HOLT & Co., Publishers, New York, _ TY am YT . ~ # BRENTANO’S, 5 Union Square, NEW YORK, Have constantly in stock GUIDE BOOKS to all parts of the world, ali the NEW NOVELS and MISCELLANEOUS BOOES on the day of issue. Orders by mail promptly attended to. For any desired information about books published or that are to be published, old and rare books, English, French, German, Spanish. or Italian books, write to us and it will receive our immediate attentivn. F. W. CHRISTERN, 254 Fifth Avenue, between 28th and 29th Sts., New York. - rter of Foreign Books, Agent for the leading Paris lishers, Tauchnitz’s British Authors, Teubner’s Greek andi Latin Classics. Catalugue of stock mailed on demand. ived trom assortment always on hand,and new books re- Solve Par's and: Leipzig as soon as issued. > CO., Bre! W ‘NV, BROTHERS 59 WALL STREET. BILLS OF EXCHANGE. COMMERCIAL and TRAVELLERS’ CREDITS Available in all parts of the World. FOR times abroad! As escort, companion, &c., ey L ee, PY A an E UROPE / ceed Nation, New York City. Eevee Fitted wth a peoher Glasses. Field, Marine, and 1 — Telescopes, Micro- 4 ‘Deafness, Ear Acoustic Cane Cornets, etc. oof WALDsTEIN, Optician, 41 Union Square, New York. Catalogues b by enclosing stamp. stablia Or a tour round the world! ed 1840, ‘4 TALOG NO” 23, BEING “ODDS and ends ” from » ae literary . Shop” of A. 8. k, 34 Park Row, N. Y., now ready. Five | Roberts Brothers NEW BOOKS. A Week Away from Time. 16mo. Tasteful cover. Price, $1.25. ‘A Week Away from Time’ is the record of delightful days which some happy summer idlers passed on “ the very tip of the end of the heel of Cape Cod,” where time is of no account. It is a kind of modern Decameron, with stories related by the various members, while still an- other recites their daily adventures. summer book, and will be found in all tourists’ travelling bags. A NEW “NO NAME” NOVEL. Cracker Joe. 16mo. Brown cloth. Price, $1.00. JOHN EVERETT BRADY. rt SOUND.CHANGES IN MODERN GREEK: (German text) Die Lautverinderungen der neu- riechischen Volkssprache und Dialekte. vo, 75 cents. A practical treatise on the sound-changes in Modern Greek as developed from the Ancient | Greek. The Modern Greek pronunciation is also | discussed. Of value to students of Greek Philo- logy. and especially to auy interested in the study | of the Modern Greek language. It is a charming | | Thy épacmiavny mpodopav | épevvg tas Scadéxtovs THs veoeAAnvixiis. “Td Tedxos ToUTO méyeorov mapéxer Td évdiddepov Sia mavra“EAAnva, idiws Suws ba mavta”EAAnva giAdAoyor ” —Néa’Ednpmepis (Athens). ““Arodecxvie: chadepav kal peTa TOAARS EuBpideias ‘H &a- | tpBy airy peyiorny agiav éye ba mavtra “EAAnva «al | péycora dua rods PrdoAdyous.”—Axpémods (Athens). ‘Cracker Joe’ is a story of Florida life, written by the | author of some of the most popular novels of the day, who now seeks the anonymousness of the “‘ No Name Se- ries.” It makes the eleventh volume in the third “‘ No Name Series.” The Shaving of Shagpat. A Novel. By George Meredith, author of ‘Richard Feve- rel,’ ‘ Evan Harrington,’ ‘ Harry Richmond,’ ‘ Sandra Beltoni,’ ‘Rhoda Fieming,’ ‘ Vittoria,’ ‘ Diana of the Crossways,’ ‘ The Egoist,’ and * Beauchamp’s Career,’ in our new and handsome uniform 12mo edition, bound in English cloth, uncut. Price, $2. The Alkahest. By Honore de Balzac. Uniform with ‘ Pére Goriot,’ ‘ The Duchesse de Langeats,’ ‘César Birotteau,’ ‘ Eugénie Grandet,’ ‘Cousin Pons,’ ‘ The Country Doctor,’ and “The Two Brothers.’ 12mo, half morocco, French style. Price, $1.50. Sold by all pooksellers. Mailed, postpaid, by the pub- lisners, ROBERTS BROTHERS, Boston. AG DOLLS.— Vide Nation, Feb. Nos. $3 (night dress 30 cents). Box 185, Bethlehem, Pa. Ii, | By the same author. ‘Is another example of the good work which the younger American scholars are doing.”— London Academy. ‘*Ts the fruit of great labor.”—Basil L, Gilder- sleeve. STUDIES IN QUINTUS CURTIUS RUFUS, (English Text.) Just ready. 8vo, $1.00 B. Westermann & Co., 838 BROADWAY, NEW YORK. ASH & PIERCE, 80 NASSAU ST., N. Y., Booksellers. Local History, Genealogy, rst American Editions, Old and Scarce Books in all ae- to La Catalogues sent on application. CHOOL BOOKS IN FOREIGN LAN- guages. Miscellaneous Books in Foret; ery 0a applivation. Fore’ Peri ARL SCHOENHOF, importer. 144 Tremont St.. Boston. OREIGN BOOK S.—Frerch, German, Russian, Swedish, Pe Polish, Hi etc., ROSENTHAL ac 14 Cooper Union, N, Y,
Page 27
foe