The Nation 1887-03-17: Vol 44 Iss 1133

Page 1

‘he Nation AMERICAN LITERATURE, 1607- 1885. By Charles F. Richardson, Professor of English Literature in Dartmouth College. Part 1 (complete in itself).*The Develop- ment of American Thought. Second edition. Octavo, cloth extra, $3.00. “TY find it admirably adapted to the uses of a class who will take with me, next semester, a course of lectures on the same subject. Prof. Richardson has the gratitude of all teachers of American Literature.”—Louise Manning Hodgkins, Professor of English Literature in Wellesley College, “It is proving to me an instructive and suggestive vol- ume of reference. The author’s method of treatment has advantages which I have tested in the work of my de- partment.”—S. A. Longwell, Teacher of English and Saxon Literature in Smith College, Northampton, Mass. “One of the few books on literature in which the his- torical and logical methods are happily combined "— Prof. T. W. Hunt, Princeton, N. J. *He has shown a discriminating insight and literary judgment in the treatment of our American literary work.”’—New Princeton Review. “The most thoughtful and suggestive work on Amert- can literature that has been published.”— Boston Globe, “Nothing approaching it in completeness and broad grasp of the subject has heretofore been produced by any writer.”--New York World. “It is not a mere compilation of facts, but enters into philosophical and critical discussion, and becomes a trustworthy guide to those who would learn what Ame- rican literature is and what it has achieved. It is itself a most desirable contribution to it.”— The Churchman. “ Prof. Richardson’s style is always animated, always clear, always forcible, and often brilliant. He has the art of making dull things bright, and there is hardly an uninteresting page in his whole volume.”—New York Tribune. “No class should go out of the American academy or high school that has not had access to this latest, most independent, most enjoyable consideration of the deve- lopment of American thought.'’—New England Journal of Education. ‘Shows wide and careful study of the theme, a coc! judgment, and a steady hand in formulating the results of that judgment. . . . Accurate in information, cor- rect in taste,and eminently simple and interesting in style.”—Chicago Times. “An honest, searching, and dispassionate criticism of American literature, and as such deserves the careful at tention of those whose interest is in our national im- provement.”—Baltimore American. G. P. Putnam’s Sons, 27 and 29 W. 23d St., New York. THURSDAY, MARCH 17, 1887. IMPORTANT NEW BOOKS JUST PUBLISHED BY / ) mm A.C. Armstrong & Son. MODERN METHODS OF ILLUSTRATING BOOKS. By H. T. Wood, Secretary to the Society of Arts, London. 12mo, cloth, uncut edges, $1.25. London Literary World says: “This volume is very welcome. The author has evidently thoroughly mastered the subject, for he has produced a book which is a model of clearness and conciseness, minus technicalities.” REPRESENTATIVE ENGLISH PROSE AND PROSE WRITERS. By T. W. Hunt, Pro- fessor of English Language in the Colleze of New Jersey. 12mo, $1.50. Opening with a careful discussion of the leading his torical periods of English prose, it proceeds to the « amination of its various literary forms, and, as a third and final division of the subject, presents a critical study of representative English authors as exponents of Eng lish prose style. In subject matter as in method it is thoughtful and logical, while the English in which if is expressed is clear, vigorous, and tasteful. HISTORY OF THE OLD ENGLISH LETTER FOUNDRIES. With Notes—Bibliographical and Historical—on the Rise and Progress of English Typography. By Talbot Barnes Reed. Crown quarto. Printed in old style type, on antique paper, with quaint head and tail pieces, and with numerous illustrations and facsimiles of type, $10. (Furnished to subscribers before publication at $8.40.) (Only 75 copies furnished for America. The subject is one which throws a considerable and curi ous light on the history of English Typography. The book will be found to embody a full Ribliography of works, not only relating to, but illustrative of, the Type founder's Art, and to contain numerous anecdotes of Founders, Printers, and Authors, together with interest ing particulars concerning some of the most famous pro ductions of the English press. Rev. Dr. Wm. M. Taylor's New Work, THE PARABLES OF OUR SAVIOUR, Ex- pounded and Illustrated. Uniform with the same author's * Limitation of Life,’ ‘Con- trary Winds,’ and other sermons. Crown, octavo, 454 pages. $1.75 each. Rev. Dr. A. B. Bruce's New Work, THE MIRACULOUS ELEMENT IN THE GOSPELS. Uniform with the same author's ‘Parabolic Teaching of Christ.’ Svo, cloth, each, $2.50. New Princeton Review FOR MARCH. * The quality of the New Princeton Review has that fine and rare depth and earnestness which is often wanting in American reviews. As the magazine wins its way {t es tablishes a firm foundation of regard In the thoughtful public. Literature ts enriched by its scholarly articles and a thoughtful consideration of social questions en couraged.”— Boston Journal. “ The New Princeton Review has scored nearly all the successes of the higher order of periodical literature that have been made in this country since its publication be ayear or more ago. The March number is packed solid with articles on different subjects, and there is no thing from cover to cover which one could afford two have omitted.”— Boston Heraid. “ There has been nothing in the history of American periodical titerature more striking and hopeful than the certainty of touch and distiactness in standard shown from the outset by the editors of the New Princeton Re view in selecting the ground to be occupied and in carry ing oat the plan thus formed with marked judgment and unerring taste."—N. F. Christian Union. TERMS: 8a year tn advance, postage free. Single numbers S) cents, We make the special offer of 1886 and 1887—fwe years in one subscription—/for 85 A. C. ARMSTRONG & SON, 7145Broadway, N. Y. PRICE 10 CENTS. DUE NORTH. By Maturin M. Ballou, author of ‘Due South,’ ‘Edge-tools of Speech,’ * Genius in Surshine and Shadow,’ ete. $1.50, Mr. Ballou’s previous travel-books have had an immense popular success, which will doubtless be repeated in this picturesque and vivid record of his recent travels and observations in Russia and Scandinavia. Beginning with two brilliant chapters on Copenhagen, it contains attractive accounts of the Swedish and Norwegian capitals, Stockho!m and Chnstiania; chapters devoted to Bergen and Trondhjem; the Lo offodens and Maelstrém; the North Cape and Midnight Sun Lapland and Finland; St. Petersburg and Mo» cow; the Neva and Volga; Nijni Novgoral, Warsaw and Russian Poland. ri , ay. ‘ry . . ¢ . PWO GENTLEMEN OF ) ie bl ’ BOSTON, A Novel. $1.50 * The story is one of those unpretentious, quiet, realistic, and yet vivid narratives, which are per haps the very most popular among the great bulk of story-readers, like‘ The Lamplighter,’ * Rut ledge,’ and many others which have sold wond-r fully, and still sell.” | Ft. noe Thee TRIKE IN THE »* - MILL. No. 1, Second Se, “a, wnd-Robin novels. #1; paper c. W/O cents. This exciting story ak Y ‘th a question of vast importance—the idea” . workmen combin ing against their employers. DISCOURSES ON ARCHI- PECTURE. By E.-E. Viollet-le-Duc. 2 vols., 8vo. Richly and copiously illustratea. A new edition of this noble classic of architecture and @sthe- tics, $15. For sale by all booksellers. Sent, postpaid, upon re ceipt of price. Catalogues of our books mailed free TICKNOR & COMPANY, Boston. For One-third of a Century PARK & TILFORD and ACKER, MERRALL & CONDIT HAVE SOLD THE DIAMOND HAMS CURED BY S. DAVIS, JR. & CO., Cincinnati, ANY Boox noticed or advertised in the Nation wii! he supplied on receipt of price by LAUGHTON, MACDONALD & CO., Booksellers and Importers, 131 Tremont St., Boston, Mass. “

Page 2

ae ae The Nation. [ Number 1133 The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science, and Art. FOUNDED 1865. CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. We FOR a kc cdndcncicccdcnscssnnstacscescnqaccessepecesees 217 SUMMARY OF THE WEEK’S NEWS.,...........00ceeeeeeeees 220 EDITORIAL ARTICLES : The State of Pennsylvania vs. the Anthracite Coal ii ncicntn chan dodennhen+h4eesessectanpectceces 222 Mone v and Political Machines...... a -- 222 MN ” iastediidedates 223 A Study in “ Politics ” Henry Ward Beecher. . SPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE: British Politics and Soctety...............sscscecsecees 226 The Re port of Lord Cowper’ 3 Commission.......... 227 CORRESPONDENCE : I sn cc ntndgccsndacsesanerecssosssene 2°98 Se Ry sc non.ckatascacecesccvccesesese 229 Results of Sanitary Inspection in Chicago... ... . 230 The ———— Postmastership.............. esse 200 Transformation of Surnames... ..............seeeeeees 230 BI, 6 icns60000805s06sensenteccccedesneses cecccccece ccccce 900 REVIEWS: Gardiner’s Great Civil War. ................-ceeeeeeeee 233 OTe 235 llections of a Private Soldier in the Army of SR iikdbenbinewahaathbesarediadesnsebencna 236 The New English The Practical Horse BooKS OF THE WEEK............... Cecccccececccccecccoce TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three Dollars per year, in advance, postpaid to any part of the United States or Canada; to foreign coun- tries comprised in Postal Union, Four Dollars. The date when the subscription expires is on the Ad- dress-Label of each paper, the change of which to a sub- sequent date becomes a receipt for remittance. No other receipt is sent unless requested. The paper is stopped at expiration of the subscription, unless previously renewed, When a change of address is desired, both the old and new addresses should be given. Address THE NATION, Box 794, New York. Publication Office, 210 Broadway. TERMS OF ADVERTISING. voy (No deviation.) lines. On any page not specified, 15 cents per line|— each insertion; with choice of page, 20 cents. | _ A column (140 lines), $20 each insertion ; with|— chotce of page, $27. ery A page (3 columns), $60 each insertion; with|— choice of position, $80, — Twenty per cent, advance for top of column or|_ 10 other preferred position, when specified ; where|— positions are not specified, advertisements are|— classified as far as possible and arranged in or-|_ der of size, the largest at the top. —15 Twenty per cent,advance for cuts, fancy or|_ other letters not comprised in THE NATION\— fonts,and all other special typography (subject to ap- proval), Cuts are inserted only on inside pages of cover or fly-leaves, not on outside of cover, nor on pages num- bered for binding. Marriage and Death Notices, 50 cents each, The EDITION of THE NATION this week is 8,700 coptes. The Subscription List is always open to inspec- tion. f OM@GOPATHY.—THE BELIEF that homceopathy is simply infinitesimal doses isanerror. Similia similibus curantur (Like cures like) says nothing about the dose, and the small dose is the result of experience, proving that it acts quicker and safer than the large one, provided it be selected on the line of nature’s law of similars. But such medicine to be efficacious must be prepared with the utmost care and accuracy, and for this reason buyers should go to old and well-known pharmacies only. Ours was the first estab- lished after the introduction of Homcopathy into this country in 1825, and remains the only one whose prepa rations have n awarded vo . fair pos for urity and excellence. RICKE & AFEL. Homeopathic Pharmaceutiss, New York: 145 Grand St. and 7 W. 42d St. Philadelphia : 1011 Arch St. and lose ¥ alnut St. Baltimore; 212 W. Fayette St. Washington : 938 F. S o>» I. W. Pittsburgh : 51 6th Ave. Chicago : 234 Wabash Ave. CHOOL BOOKS IN FOREIGN LAN- guages. Miscellaneous Books tn Foret Catalogues on applivation. Foreign Periodicals. CARL SCHOENHOF, Importer, 144 Tremont St., Boston. , Schools. Alphabetized, first, by States; second, by Towns. CONNECTICUT, Lyme. LACK HALL SCHOOL.—A FAMILY and Preparatory School for boys. Thorough in- struction and care! training New and enlarged ac- commodations. CHARLES G. BARTLETT, Principal. CONNECTICUT, Middie TLSON GRAMMAR SCHOOL —A Preparatory School for Boys. %500 per year. For Circular address E. H. WiLson, A.M. — DIsTRIcT OF COLUMBIA, Washington, 1212 and 1214 14th St., and 1407 Massachusetts Ave. o WE NORWOOD INSTI TU Th. Select Boarding and Day School for young ladies and little om. Mr. and Mrs. Wa. D. CABELL, Principals. MARYLAND, Baltimor Os VERSITY OF MAR YLAND,—Law School. Eighteenth annual session, October 3, _ HENRY D. HARLAN, Sec’y. MASSACHUSETTS, Bost« OSTON UNIV "ERSITY Law School, Address the Dean, EpMuND H. Bennett, LL.D. ETTS, Bos' NSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY. Courses in Civil, Mechanical, Mining, and Electrical Engineering, Chemis euiery, Architecture, etc. JAMES P. Muwnrok, Sec’y. Francis A. WALKER, Pres. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 18 Boylston Place. EPARATION FOR THE INSTI- tute of Technology and for Harvard College with- out Greek. Private School. ALBERT HALE. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, 1350 Pine St. ISS ANABLE’S BOARDING AND Day School for sone. ea will reopen Sept. 22. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, Chestnut Hill. RS. COMEGYS 4ND MISS BELL’S bens pw My French, and German Boarding School for Young Students prepared for College. Ample grounds afford advantages for outdoor exercise. rr tional class and recreation-rooms built during the past summer. ALY, Flore’ LASSICAL "SCHOOL FOR GIRLS, FLO- rence, I ~~ Two Boston ladies, having years of ex en in Florence, Italy, th Taylor, a uate of Souene College, will bet in pom of the English De eee assisted by a corps of ative French, German. . Italian Lo ge The best masters will be ‘procured for vocal music, the piano, mandolin, and other instruments. Instruction given in nting from life, copying from eries, also in model ng. Students pre tor Smith or any Coll which receives women. Mothers allowed to their daughters. A ny A will io America in September to conduct —— to Italy. For further particulars, ad- —= Miss IsaBELLA G. TaYLor, P. O. Box 5083, Boston, ass. References, Rev. E. E. Hale, D.D., Pres. L. Clarke Seelye, Northampton, Mass. Teachers. HARVARD GRADUATE (85), PRI- vate tutor for the past two you desires engage. ment after July 1. Address A. B., Box 488, Waltham, HARVARD SENIOR DESIRES TO take ch: of one or twe lads preparing for col- lege, on a tri road for the sun.mer, or for one year. Has travelled in Europe and is an experienced tutor. Good_ references pan. Address Senior F., care carrier 404, Cambridge, MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 259 Boylston Street. WAUNCY-HALL SCHOOL (59th Year). Preparation for the Mass. Institute o: Pochnology as ecialty. Reference is made to the Institute F: he location is the most attractive in Boston. MASSACHUSETTS, Cambridge, Larch St. OME FOR BOYS.—DR. ABBOT AD- ts not more than four boys into his e. tultion, fit for p~ + or educate — Separate tuition, with best of care in all respects. Charming loca- —. fine tennis-court. F. E. Assor, Ph.D., Pro- prietor. MASSACHUSETTS, Duxbury, Powder Point. CIENTIFIC PREPARATORY School. A home school for boys. ia gy for Harvard and Mass. Inst. Technology. Labor: na FREDERICK B. Knapp, 8S. B (M. 8. T.). MASSACHUSETTS, Qu DAMS Ted DEM Y. — PREPARA- and beneding school for boys. School year an is September, 1886. ‘or all information address WILLIAM EVERETT, Ph.D. MASSACHUSETTS, S. Williamstown, Berkshire Co. REYLOCK INSTITUTE.—A PRE- tory School for aoe. 45th year. Catalogues on application. | GEORGE F. MILLs, Principal. MASSACHUSETTS, West Bridgewate OWARD COLLEGIA TE INSTI- tute. Full prepa yt , with shorter fw nee a AGILL, Ph.D., Graduate of Swarthmore College, Boston’ Gaiety, and Newnham College, Cambridge. England. New JERSEY, Lawrenceville. AWRENCEVILLE SCHOOL. —JOHN C. Green Foundation. It is desirable that applica- tions should be made from 3 to 6 months in advance of date of entrance. For Catalogue containing Courses of Study and Calendar, address Rev. JAMES C. MACKENZIE, Ph.D. HAR FARD STUDENT WHO WAS kept from college by illness at the beginning of the year Doula like a position as tutor or teacher. Has had four years’ experience in private tutoring. mot make a protracted e' ment if necessary. Addres . J. HOLLAND, Springfeld. Mass. PROFESSOR OF FRENCH HAVING had several years’ ex wwaemee of teaching in France and the United States, holding the ae testimonials from M. Outrey, ex- Minister o France de Pressensé, Senator ; Hon. Vorman Colman, (att LI of the Ag- riculture, ete.; besides being a graduate of the Sor- bonne (Paris), is open to an engagement. A preference would be given to college work, though experience ren- ders him fitted for private tuition. Address Prof. V. D. Berghen, Librairie 8, Rue Capucines, Paris, France. CC icran W. STONE, Tutor for Harvard, 68 Chestnut Street, Boston.’ OHN W. DALZELL, PRIVATE TU- tor, 15 Appian Way, Cambridge, Mass., will take one boy into the family. COLLE el ICHARD ERDMANN, uate,who has been studying classical lan and sciences in the Universities in -~¥ Tueb a Berlin, Goettingen, desires an engagem References given. 226 East 10th ‘ot New York. School Agencies. ARDEEN’S SCHOOL BULLETIN furnish a esitatle Ear > and } Fy. a pos ry ‘hat RIDGE TEACHERS’ AGENCY, 110 Tremont St., Boston, Mass.—College, h and pri- vate school work. J. Ransom BRIDGE, Manager. ROCKWAY TEACHERS AGENCY, Times Building, Chi will supply superinten- dents, e teachers, specia! ists with positions in Cen- tral, Western, and Southern States for ensuing year. NEw JERSEY, Princeton. REFARATORY SCHOOL, SPECIAL reference, President James McCosh. Pre tho- roughty and quickly for Princeton and all colleges and Scientific Schools. One vacancy for third term. Address J. REMSEN BisHop, Head Master. w YorK, New Hartford, near Utica. V RS COLLIER’S SCHOOL for YOUNG [ girls from six to sixteen. Open the entire year. NEW York, Suspension Bridge. IF VEAUX COL LEGE. —A Military Bo arding School for + WILFRED H. Munro, A. M., President. NEw York, S A RS. CHARLOT. TE MAY reg nl son’s Home School for Girls.—$1,000 No extras. oo“. ten pupils. Beautiful and ealthfui ——-: “> the hills £ oe Syracuse. School year be- gins Se 4, 1887. Refers to Hon. Abram S. Hewitt, George XM Curtis, Rev. Henry Ward Beecher, Thomas Wentworth Higginson, Hon. Andrew D. White, ious i 4 Alcott, James B. Angell, LL.D., Hon. George V 9throp. NEw York, t Uti A RS. PIA TT" ‘S SCHOOL FOR YOUNG Ladies.—The next school year begins Wednesday, Sept. 21st, 1887. Applications should be made early. PENNSYLVANIA, Bryn Maw: RYNMAWR COLLEGE. —A COLLEGE for Women, ten miles from + 4 Offers io. and undergraduate courses in Sanskrit, Greek, atin, Mathematics, English, French, Old a Preach. Ttaltan, Spanish, German including Gothic and Old High Ge man, History, Political Se lence, Physics, Chemistry, Bi. ology, including Botany, and lectures on Philosophy. Gymnasium, with Dr. Sargent’s oeialish complete. Fellowships value #450)in Greek, lish, Mathematics, History, and Biology. For Program, address as above. CHOOL AGENCY.—Oldest oud test known in the United States. Estab’d 185 J. W. SCHERMERHORN & Co., 7 East ath St., New York. HE BOSTON TEACHERS’ AGENCY Supplies Teachers to Schools, Positions to Teach- ers. Circ E. O. Fisk, 13 Tremont Place, Boston. J] JNION TEACHERS AGENCY, 16 Astor Place, New York City. D. KERR, Secre tary. Send for circulars, and list of Bt. filled. Wants. ANTED—BY A YOUNG LADY, A ition as com fon to a maiden lady or widow; prefers the country, and does not object to travelling. Aadress Care the Nation. The Divinity School of Har- vard University. For the year 1887-88 two resident Fellowships of $500 each are offered to Graduates of Theolo- gical Schools who intend to devote themselves to the Christian neers © These fellowships are intended to encourage advanced theological work of a high order. Applications for a ** Williams Fellowship,” accompanied by testimonials and specimens of work, must be made to the Dean be- fore June 1, 1887. Cc. C. EVERETYI, Dean.

Page 3

March 17, 1887] The Nation. NEW ENGLAND MUTUAL Life Insurance Company, BOSTON, - - - - MASSACHUSETTS. STATEMENT OF BUSINESS FOR 1886. DOB. 60 65 05:66.60 6045040056440 $17,966,845 66 RECEIPTS. For Premiums. ........0..00.- $2,211,776 47 For interest, rents, and profit and loss, less taxes.......... 902,579 89 3,114,356 36 DyPMtpindipst $21,081,2 yr 02 DISBURSEMENTS. Death claims. ...............+5 $1,035,243 00 Matured and discounted en- GOWMGMEGB. 2.0.0.0 ccccsccees 257,315 00 Cc i = and surrendered a a paddetdensespenencoase 228,736 pistribution of surplus....... 450 23 9 17 Total paid to policy-holders. ‘$1, 97 2, 57: 73 60 Amount paid for commis- sions to agents, salaries, medical fees, advertising, printing, stationery, andall ether incidental ex»nenses at the home office and at GUT ncngce 6o0csgecccees 383,054 55 Amount paid for premium on investments purchased during the year, and ac , crued interest thereon...... 94, 492 | 62 2,454,120 77 B18, 62 7,081 95 LIABILITIES. Reserve at Massachusetts standard 4 per cent........ 215,679,993 48 Ralance distributions unpaid 99,407 389 Death and endowment claims approved............ _VWi2,474 € 00 15,951,875 37 "$2 2,675,205 88 Every policy has indorsed thereon the cash surrender and paid-up insurance values to which the insured is en titled by the Massachusetts Statute ——-LIFE KATE EN DOWMENT | a are issued at the old life rate pre JAL CASH distributions are paid upon ALL polic ies. Pamphlets, rates, and values for any age sent on appli- cation to the C Poy ’s office, or to KENNY & RATCLIFFE, Gen. Agents, = Broadway, New York, N.Y. NJ. F. STEVENS, President. JO3. M. GIBBENS, Secre oe JARVIS-CONKLIN MORTGAGE TRUST COMPANY. Capital Paid Up, $ This company offers its Debenture Bonds of $500, $1,000, and $5,000 each, drawing six per cent. interest, and run ning ten years to Trustees, Guardians, and Individual Investors. Secured by FIRST MORTGAGES ON REAL ESTATE, worth three times the amount of the loan, and held by the MERCANTILE TRUST ae gd OF NEW YORK, E Second by the entire - -up capital of one million dollars. It also offers guaranteed 6 per cent. first mortgages on Kansas City business property, and improved farms in KANSAS and MISSOURI. Call at office or write for full particulars to ROLAND R. CONKLIN, Secretarv. Equits able Building, New York. NVEST THROUGH THE a SOUND AND RELLABLE Tv ~ me) see s Western Farm Mortgage Co. F. M. PERKINS, ewer raw L. H. PERKINs, President. LAWRENCE, KAN. Secretary. PAID UP CAPITAL, $250,000.00, The choicest 1st Mortgage Farm Loans, also the Com- pany’s Ten Years Debentures based upon its paid up Capital and Assets of over $650,000. No Losses. Eleven Years Experience with absolute sutisfaction to over 1,500 Investors. Send for circulars, forms, and full informa- tion; Branch Offices in N. Y : - Y. City and Albany; Office, 137 Broadway. C. HINe & SON, Agents. 1OUX CITY, |0Wn. Parties who neglected to invest in Kansas City and Minneapolis real estate at the propertime and missed it, have now another opportu. nity in Sioux City. Those who did invest in Kansas City and Minneapolis and consequently enriched themselves, are invited to inspect the COMING CITY OF THE WEST. Send for circulars. Address JOHN PEIRCE, Sec’ 'y, Sioux City, lewa. St, 000,000 OO. Germany. PROF. A. FLEISCHMANN, Eldena, Fommern. Tho- rough study of German, French, and other branches. Summer resort for seabath: Fine surroundings. Isle of Riigern, University of Greifswald. For cireu address PROF. J. M. CROW, Ph.D. Grinnell, lowa. (CATALOG NO, 23, BEING “ODD. and ends” from the“ Literary Junk Shop” of A. Clark, 34 Park Row, N, Y., now ready. Ss 8. Rare and Modern Books. THE FIRSTENGLISHCATALOGUE. A cata logue of the most vendible Books in England, ete. The like work never yet performed by any. London, 1058, 12mo, old calf, $12 MORLEY (H.). Of English Literature in the reign of Victoria, with a glance at the past, Frontispiece, album of 175 facsimile auto graphs, and inserted. ltmo, half Levant mor., zg gilt top, uncut (étui), NERVAL (Gerard de). Sylvie. Paris (Conquet), 1886, 16mo0, with portrait of the autbor on Japan paper inserted. (The handsomest book of the year.) #12. GREVILLE MEMOIRS. First Series. 1874. 5 vols. Svo, cloth, uncut, edition. $50. GIBBON. Decline and Fall of the ilt back, Do. 00), London, Original Roman Em pire. Notes by Milman and Guizot. Lon don, 1862. 8 vols,, 8vo, half mor., gilt top. uncut. (W. Matthews) $30. LOCKER (F.). London Lyrics. New York: Printed for the Book-fellow’s Club, 1SS3. l6mo, boards, uncut, edition limited to 104 copies. $4. LACROILX (Paul). in the Middle Ages. 4to, cloth, uncut $40. SWINBURNE (A, 1865, half mor. $6. CHERBULIEZ (V.). Sam’l Brohl & Co. 12mo, half red mor., gilt back, with portrait (and all the Standard French Novels and Classics in similar binding), per vol., $1.60, FORBES (A.). The War between France and Germany. Tauchnitz Edition. 2 half mor. (and 2,500 other volumes of the Tauch- nitz Collection in similar binding), per vo lume, $1. DUPRAT & C0., 5 East 17th Street, New York. *,* Catalogues of Rare Books, Tau ad Jouaust ation. Libraries, on app Literary, Scientific, and Poli- tical Information. QUESTIONS UPON Arts, minanners, Customs,etc., London, v.d. 5 vols., (numerous illustrations), Chastelard. Moxon, uncut, Ist edition, C.). , gilt top, vols., Anitz ar ALL SUBJECTS ANSWERFD A Bureau of General Information ag the of the Nation. JOSEPH B. MARVIN, Manager, Assisted by Experts in all Branches. Office in the Coreoran Building, opposite the Treasury, P. O, Lock-Box 370 Washington, D. ¢ Capital *,.* Send f ( th te rer "LANG t \GES The Meisterschaft System, by Dr. Richard S. Rosenthal, is the only successful method ever dev learn to speak without a teacher, and in ¢ es, et FRENCH, GERMAN, SPANISH, OR iAN Endorsed by leading linguists. Terms 85.1 for books of either language. Sample copy. Part 1, 25 cents. Lib ral terms to Teachers. MEISTERSCHAFT PUBLISHING Co., Boston, Mass, CHRISTERN, F . Y West Twenty-third Street, New York, Importer of Foreign Books, Agent for the leading Paris Publishers, Tauchnita's British Authors, Teubner’s Greek and Latin Classics. Catalogue of stock mailed on demand. A large assortment alw ays on hand. and new books re ce ‘ived from Paris and Leipzig as soon as issued. GERMAN SIMPLIFIED. An eminently practical new method for learning the German language. Edition for self instruction, in 12 numbers (with keys), at 1 scho without kevs\, bound in cloth, #1.2 sellers. Sent, postpaid, on receipt « Knoflach, 40 Nassau St., New * York. YES Fitted with W ' Prospect tus tree proper Glasses. Fieid, Marine, an i oe Giasses, Telescopes, Micro scopes, Acoustic Cane for Deafness, Par Cornets, etc H. WaLpsTery, Optician, 41 Union uare, New York. Catalogues by eociosing stamp. tablished 1840, PIERCE, So NASSAU ST., d ~~ Rooksellers Lowal History, Genealogy, First American Editions; Old and Scarce Books in all de partments. Catalogues sent on application WAG DOLLS. Nation, F. Nos. L $5 (night dress &) cents) Box 185, Rethlehe mm, Pa. TASH & = & 8G 26 portraits of eminent authors | | HALE HOURS BEST AMERICAN AUTHORS. THE Selected and arranged by Cfarits Morris Four Crown Octavo Volumes. Cloth, gilt top $6.00; half moroceo, &10.00; three-quarters calf, $15.00, Also, of an Edition de luxe a limited number Ame poetry Phe best examples trom every rican author of note in history, art, and philosophy are grouped here, so that the reader &an lake up any one of the four volumes, and, turning at random, find something particularly meritorious to entertain him. EXTRACTS FROM THE PRESS. *A more complete collection of gems from the best authors cannot be imagined than is contained in these four volumes. The se- lections are well chosen, and it is just the book to be popular, because it gives an idea of the best style of our many popular authors.’ America works of the Baltimore ‘Among the most successful publications of be times are works of compilations, and of the works of this character none was ever better fitted to meet the public demand than ‘ Half Hours with the Best American Authors.’ It is a book over which American book-lover’ must rejoice. Gems have been gathered from every department of literature, and have been edited with a taste and refinement fitting their own high character.”- every — Meadville Chautauquan. ‘Here the brightest story-tellers, the cleverest descriptive writers, and the most musical poets all find a place. It is needless to point out that the cream of many books 1s here and that the volumes are a mine of entertainment to one fond of good literatare.”—San Francisco Chronicle, *,* For sale by all Booksellers, or will be sent, tranapor tation paid, on receipt of price, by the publishers, J.B.LIPPINCOTT CO. 715 and 717 Market St., Philadelphia,

Page 4

lV The Nation. [ Number 1133 Scribner & Welford’s NEW BOOKS. A Look Round Literature. By ROBERT BUCHANAN, 12mo, cloth, $2.25. “He ourvens the literary field from Aschylus to ‘Tenayson. r. Buchanan’s pronouncements are, as might be expected, an agreeable mélange of praise and blame. His attitude is that of antago- nism to what he deems the ‘authorized’ criticism of the day. It is gratifying to meet with the criti- cal work of a man at once so enthusiastic and so independent. It would, indeed, have been a pity had Mr. Buchanan not given a permanent form to ome so thoughtful and so stimulating.”— London Flobe, The Book Faucier; Or, The Romance of Book Collecting. By PERCY FITZGERALD. New Edition. Elzevir 8vo, vellum cloth, gilt top, uncut, $2.00. CoONTENTS.—Ot Book Collectors and Book Deal- ers; of the Mazarin Biole; Concerning the Incuna- bles or Cradle Books; of the Elzevirs, Plantins, | and old Printers; of Caxtons and of the English Printers; of the Library; of Binding and its Curi- osities; of Curiosities of Printing; of Illustrated Books and “Luxurious Editions,” etc., etc. *“ Amusing and agreeable toread. There is hard- ly a branch of the sport of book-hunting that he does not touch on; he is always diverting.”’—Sa- turday Review. -:ngland’s Case Against Home Rule. By A. V. Dicey, B.C.L., of the Inner Temple, Fel- low of All Souls, and Vinerian Professor of English Law at Oxford. Second edition. Crown 8vo, cloth, $3.00. * Prof. Dicey’s exhaustive *Case Against Home Rule’ for Ireland makes its appearance ovportune- ly. Hetreats his subject judiciaily and from an absolutely dispassionate standpoint.”’— Times. “ This isa book which will richly repay the most careful study.”—Scotsman. “It is in our judgment absolutely conclusive.”— Saturday Review. The Ministry of Fine Art to the Happiness of Life. Essays on various arts, By T. GAMBIER PARRY. CONTENTS.—The Purpose and Practice of Fine Art. Ministry of Fine Art to Common Life. Ministry of Fine Art to Spiritual Life. Art in Archeology. Ministry of Color to Sculpture ana Architecture. A Sketch of the History of Mosaic, (i.) Ancient, (li) Christian. The Art andthe Art- ists of Glass Painting. Ancient and Medieval. Aaornment of Sacred Buildings. Builders and Buildings of the Abvey of St. Peter, now the Ca- thedral at Gloucester. Appendix: The Method of Spirit Fresco Painting. 8vo, cloth, $5.60, > > Handbook to Robert Brown- e 9 - ing’s Works. By Mrs. SUTHERLAND ORR. Second Edition, re- vised, f. cap, 8vo, cloth, $2.25. “This book bears evidence throughout of that courage, patience, know.edge, and research, and that lightness and firmness of hand which are es- sential in dealing with the work of a master whose art ranges so high,so wide, and s9 deep.”"—Acade- my. Music and Manners: Personal Reminiscences and Sketches of Charac- ter. By W. BEATTY-KINGSTON. 2 vols., demy 8vo, cloth, $12. “The respectable and sometimes excellent translations of Bohn’s Library have done for Literature what railroads have done for inter- nal intercourse.”—R. W. Emerson. “IT may say in regard to all manner of books, Bohn’s Publication Series is the usefullest thing I know.”—Thomas Carlyle. Bohn’s Libraries. CONTAINING STANDARD WORKS of EUROPEAN LITE- RATURE in the ENGLISH LANGUAGE, With Dictionaries and other Books of Reference, Comprising in all Translations from the French, German, Italian, Spanisb, Scandinavian, Anglo-Saxon, Latin, and Greek. 687 Volumes, $1.40 or $2 each, with exceptions. RECENT ADDITIONS. RANKE’S HISTORY OF THE LATIN AND TEUTONIC NATIONS. Translated by P. A. Ashworth, Translator of Dr. Gneist’s ‘ His- tory of the English Constitution.’ | HEINE’S TRAVEL-PICTURES : including the Tovr in the Harz, Norderney, and Book of Ideas, together with the Romantic School. Translated by Francis Storr. With Appen- dices and Map. GOETHE'S CORRESPONDENCE WITH ZEL- TER. Selected, Translated, and Edited by A. D. Coleridge, M.A. THE STUDENT’S HANDBOOK OF HISTO- RICAL GEOLOGY. By A. Jukes- Browne, B.A., F.G.8S., of the Geological Survey of England and Wales. With nu- merous Diagrams and I[llustrations. WERNER’S TEMPLARS IN CYPRUS. Trans- lated by E. A. M. Lewis. “Werner was a Freemason, and his religious notions were, at the date of his writing this poem, of a theosophic order.”’— Preface. PAUSANIAS'S DESCRIPTION OF GREECE. Translated into English. with Notes and In- dex, by A. R. Shilleto, M.A. 2 vols. HOFFMANN’S TALES. The Serapion Breth- ren, First Portion, containing Thirteen Tales. Translated from the German by Ma- jor A. Ewing. HAUFF’S TALES. The Caravan—The Sheik of Alexandria—The Inn in the Spessart. Translated by S. Mendel. GOLDSMITH’S WORKS. A New Edition, con- taining pieces hitherto uncollected and a Life of the Author, with Notes from Various Sources. By J. W. M. Gibbs. 5 vols. FOSTER’S ESSAY ON THE IMPROVEMENT OF TIME. Together with Notes of Sermons and other Pieces. CHRISTIAN ICONOGRAPHY ; or, The His- tory of Christian Art inthe Middle Ages. By the late A. N. Didron. Translated from the French by E. J. Millington, and com- . with Additions and Appendices, by . Stokes. 2 vols., with numerous Illustra- tions. TALFOURD’S LETTERS OF CHARLES LAMB. With Explanatory Notes. New Edition, Revised and Greatly Enlarged by W. Carew Hazlitt. 2 vols. HAZLITT’S SPIRIT OF THE AGE;; or, Con- temporary Portraits. New Edition. By W. C. Hazlitt. A SELECTION. ANTONINUS.-— THE THOUGHTS OF M. AURELIUS. BAX’S MANUAL OF THE HISTORY OF PHILOSOPHY. BOSWELL’S LIFE OF JOHNSON (Centenary Edition, edited by Napier). 6 vols. CERVANTES’ DON QUIXOTE., COLERIDGE’S WORKS. 6 vols. FAIRHOLT’S COSTUME IN ENGLAND. (Dillon.) 2 vols. HUGO’S (VICTOR) POEMS. Translated. MOLIERE’S DRAMATIC WORKS. 8 vols. PEPYS’ DIARY. 4 vols. RICHTER’S LEVANA., RICHTER’S FLOWER, FRUIT, AND THORN PIECES. SPINOZA’S CHIEF WORKS. Translated. 2 vols. STAUNTON’S CHESS HANDBOOK. 2 vols. Translated. ¥,* The above books wili be sent upon receipt of advertised price. stock will be mailed, if desired, to those interested. Catalogues of our regular New Catalogue of Musical Literuture ready. New Catalogue of Choice and Rare Books nearly ready. SCRIBNER & WELFORD, 743-745 BROADWAY, N. Y. ——=S|} Charles Scribner's Sons WILL PUBLISH SATURDAY: Agriculture in Some of its Re- LATIONS WITH CHEMISTRY. By F. lH. Storer, S.B., A. M., Professor of Agricultura) Chemistry in Harvard University. 12mo, $5.00. This work, the fruit of many years’ public instruction in Harvard University, is in no way a technical treatise, nor designed for students of chemistry. From a literary point of view, it ranks with the standard treatise of Mr. Marsh, ‘The Earth as Modified by Human Action,’ rather than with the professional and learned treatises on Agri cultural Chemistry. It is Agriculture rather than Che. mistry that forms the*subject of the book, and it ts the general and universal phases of the subject:that are treated rather than any particular operations of the agriculturist. The different topics discussed are very numerous, and refer cniefly tothe relations of soil, air, and water to the plant and to each other; tillage, ma- nures and fertilizers, rotation of crops, irrigation, the growth of crops, are fully treated, and there are chapters on the staple crops. The style is clear and straightfor ward, and the discussion throughout is open to the com prebension of any intelligent reader. 2 vols, A Child of the Century. By John T. Wheelwright. 1 vol., 12mo, cloth, $1.00; paper (yellow covers), 50 cents. This novel is one of the most thoroughly enjoyable that have been published for many a year. It is in every way a story of to-day, of American life and character; not that portentous and ever impending event, “* The Great Ame rican Novel,” but atypical story of political and social life, free from cynicism or morbid realism, and brim- ming over with good-natured fun which is never vulgar or merely farcical. It is a full fledged novel, too, with a well-developed plot ending happily and satisfactorily. A NEW VOLUME IN THE EPOCHS OF MODERN HISTORY. The Early Tudors. Henry VIL; Henry VIII. By the Rev. C. £. Moberly, M.A., late a Master in Rugby School. With 1 vol., 16mo, $1.60. In a clear and concise style the author has given a re markably interesting account of this most important period of modern history. The political and social con- dition of Europe at the beginning of the sixteenth cen- tury, the civil wars and internal development of Eng land during the reign of Henry VII., the more European policy of his successor, with the alliances and rivalries of Henry VIII., Francis L, and Charles V., the revival of classical learning, and the early Reformation, are all vividly portrayed. This volume fills the interval between ‘The Houses of Lancaster and York’ and‘The Age of Elizabeth,’ of thé same series. EPOCHS OF MODERN HISTORY. “ The volumes contain the ripe results of the studies of men who are authorities in their respective fields.”—The Nation. Beginning of the Middle Ages.—Normans in Europe.— Crusades. — Early Plantagenets.-— Ed- ward III.—Houses of Laneaster and York.—-Ear- ly Tudors.—Age of Elizabeth.—Protestant Revo- lution.—Thirty Years’ War.—Puritan Revolu- tion.—Fall of the Stuarts.—Age of Anne.—Early Hanoverians.—Frederick the Great.—French Re- volution.—Epoch of Reform. Seventeen volumes, 16mo, Price per vol., $1.00. The set, Roxburgh style, gilt top, $17.00. Four Maps. ** These books for sale by all booksellers, or sent, postpaid, on receipt of price, by Charles Scribner's Sons, 743-745 Broadway, New York.

Page 5

The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, MARCH 17, 1887. The Week. Ir is‘a long while siuce there has been a more conspicuous application of the spoils doctrine in our politics than in the substitution by Gov. Lounsbury of a paper-barrel manufacturer for Prof. Arthur T. Hadley as Commis- sioner of the Bureau of Labor Statis- tics in Connecticut. During his two years’ service Mr. Hadley has won a place as an investigator and statistician beside such men as Carroll D. Wright and Francis A. Walker; he has disarmed the not unnatural prejudice of the labor organizations against a college professor; he has rendered not only the State but also the country great service by re- ports which have taken a high rank in the lite- rature of industrial study. Experience had qualified him to render the public far greater service in the future; and every censideration which would lead a man like Gov. Lounsbury to retain in his private employ a man of demonstrated capacity and fidelity, dictated Mr. Hadley’s retention in the service of the State. The Republican party had really by implication committed itself to his reappointment when, in the convention which nominated Mr. Lounsbury, it adopted this resolution : ‘‘ We demand an honest and thorough enforecment of the Civil Service Law, and as far as practicable we favor the extension of its principles to municipal and State administrations,” the most fundamental of these principles being the retention of faith- ful officials. Gov. Lounsbury’s attempt to explain his ex- traordinary course only shows how sadly the acceptance of the spoils system may warp the judgment of a man. In the conduct of his private business Mr. Lounsbury probably has no fixed terms of employment, engaging his trusted subordinates upon the usual system, which really amounts to retention during good behavior. If there were, how- ever, regular times for deciding the question whether a man should be reéngaged for an- other definite period, he would expect the man to rest his claims to such reéngagement solely upon his record. This is precisely the course which Prof. Hadley pursued in his relations with his employer, the State of Con- necticut. After remarking that some _ per- sons, chiefly protectionist manufacturers, had objected to Prof. Hadley on the ground that he was a free-trader, the Governor says, as though he were adducing a perfectly conclu- sive reason for his course: ‘‘I have not been asked to reappoint Mr. Hadley by a single indi- vidual. I have not received a single letter re- questing his reappointment. Mr. Hadley him- self never mentioned the matter to me. In view of all these facts, I decided that I should not be justified in making a reappointment.” In other words, Prof. Hadley, likea self-respect- ing gentleman, chose to rest his claim to reappointment solely upon his record. He employed no lobbyists to urge his reeppoint- ment. He urged no friends to write letters to the Governor in his behalf. (We should not be surprised to learn that he might even have asked his friends to refrain from writing, be cause he did not wish the element of personal solicitation to enter into the matter.) The newspaper press of the State, as the event has shown, and as he doubtless knew, was almost unanimous in desiring his reappointment, and yet he did not procure, as so easily he might have done, the intervention in his behalf of a single Republican editor. And because he pursued this course, because he preferred his own self respect as a gentleman to the adoption of the truckling politician’s methods, the Gov ernor decided that he “ should not be justified in making a reappointment ”! Mr. Edmunds has been interviewed on the subject of the next Presidency, and his remarks will be read with interest in the latitude of Augusta, Me. To the question whether Mr. Cleveland would hold the Republican votes he got before if he should run again (as Mr. Ed- munds expects him to do), the Vermont Sena tor replied: ‘‘As between two evils they would vote for him.” But he does not expect that it will again be a choice ‘* between two evils” in 1888. Having confidence in the wis dom of the Republican party, he thinks it is | sure to nominate a good man” the next time Mr. Wharton stanchest supporters in Pennsylvania, says in last week's discussing the Presi dency in 1888: ‘‘We say frankly, and we know that we are speaking for many Re publicans when we say, that it would be a most desperate experiment, in view of the consequences of failure, to renominate Mr. Blaine. He has had his candidacy. He was loyally supported by every element that will have the right or the opportunity to consider the second proposal of his name. That he failed is not their fault, but his mis fortune. He cannot justly ask to enter with him again on so perilous a venture.” He intimates, also, that Mr. Blaine, hike Mr. Clay in 1844, reached the height of his strength in 1884, and he asks, “*Ts it possible to increase or even maintain the enthusiasm of his admirers of two years ago? Is it possible to bring him any new elements of support? Is there any quarter in which he is more popular now than in 1884? Is the confidence which he inspires in other public men and party leaders greater?” All these questions he answers in the negative. Of Mr. Barker's suggestion of Sherman and Harrison as substitutes for Blaine, we will now say no thing, except this, that if Mr. Blaine’s sup- porters mean to withdraw him from the field next year, they must do it thoroughly, and without reservation or subterfuge —that is, they must not only relieve the party of Blaine, but of Blaineism. They must not put up somebody who has a secret agreement with Blaine to work under his orders or influence, or to put him into the State Department, so as to enable him to begin over A Nie rica i them Barker, one of Mr. Blaine’s | again the old pyrotechnics of ISS]. For ¢ must not be forgotten that Blaine’s perform Secretary of State disgusted and alarmed pearly ances as as many Republicans as his financial trickery and falsehood, Senator Sherman says that ‘‘the House of Representatives should have taken the initial step looking to some measure to reduce taxa tion,” and he derates the Democratic party for incapacity because nothing was done, Two } t take the taitial step in this direction by considering a tariff? Dill conspicuous attempts to * were made during the Forty-ninth Congress in the first session on the 17th of June, [S86 and in the second on the ISth of December On these occasions the two parties divided as follows For Consideration, Aguinst . Lod Dromis, uy dh . June t Reps 1D Revs + 145 Demea Tht ‘ ‘mt . . December GB Reps 1 Reps It thus appears that on the question of taking the initial step 80 per cent. of the Democrats voted yea the first time, and 86 per cent. the second time; while only 3 per eent, of th: Republicans stood on the right side in Ju and but 4 per cent. in December. It) will puzzle a shrewder politician than Mr. Sher man to convinee the public, in the face of Demoerati party which should be held responsible for such a showing, that it is the the failure reduce taxation Speaker Carlisle’s address to the Boston if the Bay State Cluh on Saturday, like Senator Hawley’s address to the Michigan Republicans at Detroit on Wash ington’s Birthday, was a vigorous plea for State rights, Democrats at the dinner Explicitly disclaiming any belief in secession or nullification, he enforced the necessity of maintaining States’ rights in the proper sense against the present’ tendency toward centralization and a darigerous ag: grandizement of the Federal Government. He urged that the Democratic party should reas- sert its ancient doctrines as to the nature and extent of Federal power, “ It believes,” he said, ‘‘that the Government was created for the people, and that its functions should be confined to the limits prescribed by them.” This is the same idea which Mr, Cleveland so forcibly expressed in his Texas Seed Bil! veto, that ‘‘ though the people sup- port the Government, the Government should not support the people.” Indeed, Mr, Car- lisle’s speech *hroughout was really a response to the position against paternalism which the President assumed in bis Seed Bill and Pauper Pension Bill vetoes, Its chief value is as show- ing that the wisest leaders of the Democratic party recognize that Mr. Cleveland’s stand on this vital issue is as popular as it is sound. The Tennessee Legislature responds quickly and heartily to the President’s plea fora re vival of the old-time ‘‘ sturdiness of eur na- tional character.”” Within a week after Con- gress had adjourned, and the scheme of Fede- ral aid to Southern education had thus lapsed,

Page 6

218 The Nation. | Number 1133 the lower branch of the Legislature, by a vote of more than five to one, passed a_ bill, in which the Senate will doubtless concur, in- creasing the amount of the permanent fund available for school purposes from 2,000,000 to $5,000,000, and so much more than doubling the annual contribution of the State to public education. Tennessee has been growing rapidly in material wealth of late years, and this action of the Legislature shows not only that the State is able to maintain a good school system, but, what is sti!l] more im- portant, that she is ready to do it without try- ing any longer to unload the burden upon the shoulders of the Federal Government. It isan object-lesson in self-reliance and _ self-help which will not be lost upon other Southern States that have beeu backward in this matter. The Memphis Appeal does not exaggerate in the slightest degree when it declares that ** Tennessee has not done anything in the last twenty-five years that redounds so much to her credit as the passage of this bill.” The refusal of the Missouri Legislature to make any appropriation for the expenses of the militia is beyond question due to the pressure of the labor vote, which was annoyed by the interference of the militia to protect life and property when the Knights were engaged in ‘‘war” with the railroad companies and the community in generai last year. Of course the labor voters there as elsewhere are a small minority, but they frighten demagogues in the Legislature there as here, by the fact that they are organized and work together at the polls; and they will continue to frighten them until decent people band together in like manner for the punishment at the polls of the demagogues, like Gov. Hill, who pander to them. This is, bowever, an obvious view. We mention the subject mainly for the purpose of calling attention to the way in which such occurrences as this abolition of the militia in Missouri steadily encourage the growth among us of mercenary troops like Pinkerton’s Men. Of course own- ers of property in Missouri, whether corporations or private individuals, are not going to leave themselves dependent on the city police and the sheriff for protection against ‘‘ Labor.” When threatened, they will promptly callin Pinkerton and garrison their premises in medieval fashion. Pinkertons, too, will begin to multiply as the demand for private armed force increases, and the disci- pline and organization of their troops will be improved, Itis not impossible that before the end of the century, if Americans do not wake up in the interval, we may see yards and factories protected by bastions armed with light artillery, and pitched battles fought between Scabs and Labor like the fights of the Ghi- bellinesand Guelphs. The attempt to organize the whole body of those who labor with their bands into a so- ciety hostile to all the rest of the community, and, indeed, to the Government and the laws, has been shown very clearly by the events of the past year to be a failure. Even Henry George begins to see this, and has the courage to say so. The notion that a large strike is more formidable than a small one has been thoérough- ly exploded. But the fact still remains that not only the Knights «f Labor, but nearly all the trade-unions, are managed on the theory that employers are necessarily the enemies of the laboring man,and that capitalists—meaning people who have saved money and hold it as a fund for the employment of labor—are ene- mies of society and to be treated as such; that is, discouraged, denounced, and legislated against. This is not all, however, nor the worst. They are all, or nearly all, maraged as military or- ganizations; that is, ruled despotically by a few officers, whose word of command over- rides the individual judgment of the members, not only about the general policy or utterances of the organization, but about each man’s personal interests and those:of his family: A very large proportion, the larger part, in fact, of the workingmen of this country, see all this as plainly as anybody and do not belong to the unions. But their position outside the unions is, as Mr. Hewitt has said,a ‘‘ pitiable ” one. Being unorganized, they have to stand alone, not only as against their employers, but as against the unions, which persecute them remorselessly, hunting them from town to town and shop to shop, as if they were wild animals, with a pitilessness and cruelty such as neither king nor capitalist would in our day venture to display towards any human being. We are glad to say that a movement for the organization of the non-union men has at last been begun. The non-union printers have started an organization, which is intended to give those who do not care to surrender their individual judgment in the control of their lives, all the benefits in the way of assist- ance and protection which the unions now give their members, without rob- bing them of their freedom, and without placing them in an attitude of hostility to the rest of the community. It leaves itis members, in short, part and parcel of the American business community—dependent, as editors, lawyers, and merchants are, for suc- cess and respect, in their callings, on integrity, and capacity, and independence, but shielded, as;far as mutual help and codperation can go, against all misfortunes not brought about by misconduct. It leaves every man to rely on honesty, diligence, and fair dealing for his standing in his calling, and discards such ques- tionable practices of the old unions as striking without cause or without discussion, or wait- ing until the employer is in some pinch or necessity, and then stopping his business in such manner as to do him the greatest possible amount of damage, as if he were a criminal or outlaw. It proposes, in short, to place the workingman on a footing of business equality with the capitalist, with com- mon aims and aspirations, and it recognizes the undoubted fact that no employer who is fit to carry on a business of any kind, is ever likely to resist the reasonable and fairly pre- sented demands of a body of workmen whose intelligence, and reliableness, and capacity make them valuable to him. The new organi- zation is called the Printers’ Protective Frater- nity. Cardinal Gibbons, if correctly reported, has been partaking freely of the labor beverage, and appears to be as much under its influence as Gov. Hill. His report to the Propaganda on the view to be taken of the organization by the Church, which was published a fortnight ago, was, as far as literary form goes, a far better document than Gov. Hill could produce, but the reasoning was in all respects worthy of the Governor when his head is stuck deepest in the sand, and shows that ‘‘ politics ” sus- tained a terrible loss when the Cardinal entered the Church. He has since been re- ported as having announced himself ‘‘ the enemy of plutocracy and of soulless corporations and men,” as indeed we all are. But he adds, also, that the Catholic Church is ‘‘in this in- stance” (the case of the Knights) ‘‘ going to take the side of the weaker against the stronger,” which is also a blessed announcement, but, in the Cardinal’s mouth, needs explanation. We hope that it means—but should like to be as- sured that it does—that the Cardinal himself is in this country going to take the side of the ‘* scabs ” against the Knights of Labor, which is, towards those Jaborers who do not belong to it,the most ‘‘soulless corporation ” in existence. The Cardinal, as a good Catholic, must surely intend, when he gets back, to assert the right of the individual poor man to regulate his own life in his own way, and especially his right to belong or not to belong to societies or organizations, and to sell his labor on his own terms to cus- tomers of his own choosing. By ‘‘the weaker” he must surely mean that vast body of laborers —the majority—who, because they donot wish to join the Knights or other associations, are, as Mr. Hewitt has well said, ‘‘ called opprobrious names, hunted from shop to shop, denied em- ployment on the fearful penalty of stopping all work, however pressing or important.” This is not all, however, Mr. Hewitt might have added that they have often to follow their callings under the protection of an armed guard, are often afraid to return to their homes at night lest they should be murdered or maimed on the way; are often fired at with pistols, struck down with slung-shots, beaten with bludgeons, and denied food at the stores, simply for exercising the simplest of an American citizen’s rights. The men who carry on this atrocious persecution, or encourage it, or wink at it, or say it cannot be helped, are the Knights of Labor, and notably such emi- nent Christians as Powderly, Turner, Quinn, and others, and that eminent philanthropist and philosopher, Henry George. We take it for granted the Cardinal has not heard of all this, and that when he does he will let loose some of his ecclesiastical thunder on those oppressors of the poor, the soulless ruffians who have been humbugging him into supporting at Rome the claims of one of the most anti-social and des- potic organizations ever set up, to be petted and fostered by the Vicar of Jesus Christ. We can vouch for the correctness of the fol. lowing statement of the real features of the Sully-Garrett deal. Sully agreed to buy and Garrett agreed to sell 80,000 shares of Balti- more and Ohio stock at 200—that is, for the total sum of $16,000,000, payable as follows: $1,000,000 on Thursday last, 10th inst., $5,000,000 additional in forty-five days thereafter, $10,000,000 more in one

Page 7

March 17, 1887] The Nation. 219 year from the date of the contract. The con- tract further gave Sully the right to make the whole of the stock the basis of an issue of $10,000,000 collateral-trust debentures. In this very feature lay the impracticability of the scheme, for the creation of such a trust would leave the first six millions to be paid entirely ‘‘in the air.” Mr. Garrett dil not bind himself to put any of the stock in escrow, thus leaving the question an open one whether he would have been able to deliver the whole amount conditionally sold. For a long time negotiations have been carried on between Mr. Garrett and other parties than the Sully combi- nation for the purchase of his interest in the Baltimore and Ohio stock. We have reason to think that these negotiations are far more likely to result in the accomplishment of their object than the collapsed other ‘‘ deal.” The decision handed down by the Supreme Court a few days ago, whereby the ‘‘ drum- mers’ tax” levied on salesmen from other States by the ‘‘Taxing District of Shelby County, Tenn.” (in other words, the city of Memphis), was declared to be unconstitutional, will deprive several States of considerable reve- nue, In an argument made last year before the House Committee of Commerce, counsel for the Traders’ and Travellers’ Union pointed out that fourteen States and Territories and the District of Columbia levy this tax in some form. Among them are Delaware, Maryland, Vir- ginia, North Carolina, Alabama, Louisiana, Texas, and Colorado. The Richmond State says that the revenues of Virginia will be di- minished by not less than $50,000; the revenues of North Carolina will fall off quite as much, and the loss will not be smaller, perhaps, in any of these States which had built a protective barrier against the ‘‘ commercial missionary.” Some of them levy a tax on salesmen whether they solicit orders for houses within or without the State; but since the Supreme Court has de- clared the tax on those who live outside the State unconstitutional, because it is an interference with the freedom of inter-State commerce over which Congress has exclusive control, the pre- sent taxes on ‘‘home drummers” are sure to be repealed by the next Legislatures of all these States. This decision makes unnecessary the bill introduced in Congress by Mr. Darwin R. James, which prohibits the levying of any such tax by any State on salesmen from other States. The decision will have—at least it ought to have—a good effect on commercial morals that will do more than make up for the loss of revenue, These taxes were so generally evad- ed that in many communities it had become : point of honor among travelling salesmen not to pay them. At this evasion their custom- ers winked, and not infrequently both drummer and customer profited privately by it. A premium was put on com- mercial dishonesty, The Traders’ Union pub- lished the statement last year that 7,000 drummers visited Washington in 1885, and that instead of the $1,400,000 which the Dis- trict of Columbia would have received if its $200 license fee had been paid by every one, it received only $10,000. ‘‘ It may be perti nent,” they remarked, ‘‘to inquire what be- came of the $1,390,000 not accounted for ?” There is no reason to believe that the treasury of any State or Territory received a much larger proportion than this of the revenue that its law contemplated, and it is certain that this kind of ‘‘ protection ” did not protect anybody or encourage respect for the laws in general. Financially and morally it was very like pro- tection on a larger scale. If any of the women of this State feel down hearted over the defeat of the Municipal Woman-Suffrage Bill at Albany, they may find some consolation in a report just made by the Secretary of State of Massachusetts on the practical operation of the law of that State allowing women to vote at elections for school committees. This law has been in operation long enough to test the question how eager women are for the ballot, and the statis tics are as follows: In 1881, 3,349 women qualified themselves to vote by registering, but of these only 1,571 went to the polls. In 1882, 2,951 women registered and 1,346 voted. The registration in 1883 was 38,138, and the vote 1,469; in 1884 the registration was 3,778, and the vote 1,896; in 1885 the registration was &,260, and the vote 3,227; and in 1886 the regis- tration was 4,219, and the vote 1,911. Thus in the six years the average number registered was 3,782, and the average vote was 1,903. Plac- ing the average male vote of Massachusetts at 300,000, the total female vote should be 337,500, as the female population of the State exceeds the male by about 66,000. Therefore, we find that the eagerness of the female part of the population of Massachusetts for the ballot is measured by the fact that one woman in every 176 votes when she is allowed to. There is one point, however, brought out in these statistics which deserves consideration. While only woman in 176 votes when she can, one in every 80 takes advantage of the opportunity to regis ter. Perhaps, now, the female suffragists have made the mistake of demanding the bal lot, when what the political female heart is longing for is to put her name on the registry list. one The Salisbury Ministry seem to be flounder- ing from one difficulty into another ia their dealings with the Irish juestion, and each one seems greater than the last. They have secured the promise of 70 votes from the Unionists in support of a measure of coercion, which is to consist simply of an enlargement of the summary powers of the local magistrates. Of Hartington they are tolerably sure to the end, as he looks at the whole Irish problem, land question and all, from the pointof view of the heir to a great dukedom. The hold they have on Chamberlain and on the rank and file of the Unionists is of a different kind. These men calculate that if, by supporting the Tories pretty steadily, they can keep them in power during the present Par- liament—say five years—they will before the next general election have got rid of Glad- stone by death or infirmity. They feel very confident taat no other Liberal will be able to keep home rule before the voters as a burning question, and they will thus be able bye.and bye to step back into the Liberal ranks them- selves without fear or reproach, This policy may work very well if nothing occurs to excite public opinion against the Ministry to a point which would frighten the main body of Unionists and lead to desertions But things are daily occurring which make this contingency seem very probable As was expected, Bismarck’s victory in th late electoral contest has had a tranquillizing effect upon European international politics He has proved to France that he has all Get many, practically undivided, behind him, and that he will be prepared for every emergency During the Parliamentary debates which pre ceded the election be had repeatedly as sured France, and all Europe, not going to be the attacking party ‘* under any circumstances,” after the triumph is in evident harmony with that as surance. that he was and his conduct The reasonableness of the determina tion was, in fact, so patent, considering the general military and political situation, that only blind hatred could doubt its sincerity The ery which some weeks ago went through France and Russia, and other countries, that the ing to be invaded, is now almost completely hushed, and France is so delighted with the triumphant manifestation of French patriotism by the electoral constituencies of Alsace Lor was retchoed = in republic was go raine, that she quietly enjoys the cheering pros pect of immunity from aggression, and waits for Russia to begin the attack on Germany, This temporizing France keeps the sword of Russia in the disposition of scabband, while to render Russian aggression a still more hazardous task, a Franco Russian alliance an attempt of mast questionable utility, the German Chancellor has and the consummation of tightened the bonds of the formerly indefinite alliance created by himself between Germany, Austria-Hungary, and Italy. A formal triple alliance,mutually guarantecing the present pos- sessions of the contracting Powers, is now posi- tively asserted to have been concluded at the beginning of this month for three years. And it also appears trom various indications that Rumania, hitherto wavering opposite tendencies—the her security from the overwhelming pres- sure of the Russian neighbor, and the equally strong desire to wrest from Austria- Hungary, with the help of Russia, extensive districts mainly inhabited by Rumans—has finally decided on casting her lot with the Cen- tral European coalition, The Kingof Servia is more than an ally, he is almost a vassal, of the Hapsburg Emperor, who secures his throne against the pretenders of the House of Kara- george, now related by marriage to the Prince of Montenegro, the only faithful friend of the Czar in the Balkan Peninsula. The Sultan himself was nearly won over by skilful diplomacy to the Russian side in the great imbroglio, but he, too, has apparently been driven trom it by the fear of having to contend both with Bismarck’s coalition and the power of Great Britain. Russia thus remains isolated, with only France as a prospective ally. But she has a popula- tion of a hundred millions, a tremendous eh gine in autocracy, an undying fanaticism, and an unbounded faith in her Siavic destiny ; and passion goads her on, between two desire to insure

Page 8

220 The Nation. [Number 1133 SUMMARY OF THE WEEK’S NEWS. WEDNESDAY, March 9, to TcEspay, inclusive. | March 15, 1887, DOMESTIC Tue bill providing support for the militia of the State of Missouri was defeated in the Legislature on March 9, and the companies theretofore organized have disbanded, or will disband. The failure of the bill is reported to be the result of the opposition of the labor organizations. The lower house of the Tennessee Legisla- ture has passed a bill to increase the permanent school fund of the State from $2,000,000 to $5,000 000, which, at six per cent. interest, will yield nearly $300,000, or $180,000 more than the present fund yields. The Legislature of California has passed a ** Pure-Wine Bill,” which prohibits the manu- facture of impure wine, and requires every wine-maker and bottler in the State to affix his name to all his bottles and casks. A label for every bottle or cask must be procured from the State Comptroller. But the law is not a reve- nue measure, for the State charges for the labels a price that covers only the expense of print- ing and distributing them. More than 1,000 women at Leavenworth, Kan., have registered and will cast their votes, as allowed by the recently enacted law which grants municipal suffrage to women. In the New York Assembly on March 15 the High-License Bill, which fixes the tax for selling spirituous liquors at $1,000, was order- ed to a third reading by a vote of 65 to 51. All the yeas were Republicans. This insures the passage of the measure. The Congressional Apportionment Commit- tee of the lower house of the Pennsylvania Legislature has agreed on such a redistricting of the city of Philadelphia as, it is thought, will prevent the election of any Democratic Congressman from that city. ‘lhis action is significant because it may ‘‘shut out” Mr. Randall, The Florida State Colored Fair was opened at Jacksonville on March 15. The total value of the exhibits is not less than $400,000, and among them are drawings, maps, and other handiwork of the colored pupils of Florida schools. There isa big display of preserved fruits and cereals, and of fancy work, silk wraps, dresses, and the like. Texas cattlemen have decided to build a large refrigerator canning and packing estab- lishment at Houston, which will make Houston the most important cattle market in the South. Arrangements have already been made for the transportation of the beef to England. The loss of cattle in Montana Territory this winter is thought already to be not less than 30 per cent., and many more will die be- fore the snow entirely disappears. For two months the stock in many places has been al- most without food and exposed to intense cold. The thermometer has been as low as 57 degrees below zero in Northern Montana. For the first ten days in February the average was 20 below. This extreme temperature, and the lack of grass, and hard-crusted snow two feet deep, have caused the death of even the hardiest animals. Sheep-raisers are suffering to almost the same extent as the cattlemen. The consequent financial depression extending to many branches of trade will be felt for the whole year. Stock-raising on the ‘‘ rustling ” plan, that is, by trusting to favorable weather on the ranches, it is reported, will not be ex- tensively tried another season. The winter ranch, it is thought, will give way to the stock- farm. Great destitution has been caused among the Cheyenne Indians in Montana because the snow has cut them off from the Government’s sup- plies, Many plantations below Vicksburg have been inundated by the overflow of the Mississippi River. A company has been formed with $5,000,000 capital, it is reported, which will build cotton- seed oil mills in most of the Southern centres of trade. The strike of the railroad employees at Pitts- burgh and west of that city has caused a seri- ous blockade of freight at Youngstown, O., but the strike has been discountenanced by the leaders of the labor organizations, and no fur- ther trouble is anticipated. Five hundred la- borers on a railroad near Marquette, Mich., who struck for higher wages, were prevented by officers of the law from doing violence to new employees, and the work which was sus- pended for a few days has been resumed. Great excitement was caused in railroad circles on March 9 and for several days follow- ing by the rumor that the control of the Balti- more and Ohio Railroad Company had passed into the hands of a syndicate which would thereby become controllers of one of the most extensive railway systems in the world, ex- tending from New York almost to the utter- most parts of the South and far into the West, and including the Central Railroad of New Jersey, the Philadelphia and Reading system, the Richmond Terminal and Richmond and Danville lines, the East Tennessee, Virginia and Georgia lines, the Central Railroad of Georgia, and the Baltimore and Ohio, making not less than 16,000 miles of track. This great consolidation has not been made, but there is yet expectation that some modification of it will be consummated. On April 13 the ceatenary of the reorganiza- tion of Columbia College will be celebrated. On March 9 the Board of Trustees of Cor- nell University elected a Law Faculty, con- sisting of Judge Douglas Boardman of the Supreme Court of New York, who will be Dean of the school; Prof. H. B. Hutchins of the Law School of the University of Michigan, Professor of the Law of Real and Personal Property and of Equity, and Charles A. Col- lin of Elmira, N. Y. In addition to these resi- dent members of the Faculty, Judge Francis M. Finch of the Court of Appeals, Daniel H. Chamberlain of New York, William F. Coggs well of Buffalo, and Theodore Bacon of Rochester, were elected non-resident lecturers. Prof. Herbert Tuttle was elected Professor of English Constitutional Law and International Law, to lecture both in the Law School and in the School of History and Political Science. At a subsequent meeting the Executive Com- mittee of the Board of Trustees appointed Francis M. Burdick of Hamilton College Asso- ciate Professor of Law. A statue of Gen. Garfield will be unveiled in the circle at the junction of Maryland Ave- nue and First Street, Washington, on April 12. The warden and engineer of the Cook Coun- ty ([ll.) Hospital (in Chicago), the warden of the insane asylum, and a bookkeeper of a firm of contractors who have done work for the county, have been indicted by a Special Grand Jury for conspiracy to defraud the county. The American yachts the Dauntless and the Coronet set sail from Sandy Hook on March 12, for a transatlantic race to Queenstown for a wager of $10,000 a side. On the morning of March 14 a suburban train from Dedham, Mass., bound for Boston, on the Dedham branch of the Boston and Pro- vidence Railroad, fell through an iron girder bridge between Roslindale and Forest Hills, a station about six miles from Boston. The train comprised nine passenger coaches, six of which were thrown in the gap below, causing an ap- palling loss of life and limb. As many as 30 persons were killed and 100 injured. All the passengers were persons who lived in the sub- urbs of Boston or in the city itself. Many thousands of people viewed the re- mains of Henry Ward Beecher in Plymouth Church, Brooklyn, on March 11. (The funeral was preached by the Rev. Charles H. Hall, and funeral services were held in several other churches, and the business houses in Brooklyn were closed during the greater part of the day. Mr. Beecher was buried in Greenwood Ceme- tery on March 12. James B. Eads, the engineer of the bridge across the Mississippi River at St. Louis, and of the Mississippi River levees, and the de- signer of a ship-railway across the Central American isthmus, died at Nassau on March 8. Eben F. Pillsbury died at Melrose, Mass, on March 12. He was until within a few years a resident of Augusta, Me., and was a promi- nent lawyer and Democratic politician in that State. He was appointed Collector of Internal Revenue for the Eastern District of Massachu- setts by President Cleveland, but the Senate refused to confirm him. FOREIGN. On March 18, the anniversary of the assassi- nation of Alexander II., an attempt was re- ported to have been made to take the life of the Czar. Persons with explosives in their posses- sion were arrested in St. Petersburg on the route he was to have taken to attend a service held in commemoration of his father. The strongest confirmation of the seriousness of the plot is that the Czar again retired to his secluded residence at Gatchina, which he occupied during the first months of his reign. A report has been published at Vienna that a_ well or- ganized plot has been discovered to over- throw the Government of Russia, and to estab- lish a limited constitutional government. This, however, lacks confirmation. The Imperial Court of St. Petersburg attended a funeral ser- vice before the tomb of Alexander II. in the Cathedral of St. Peterand St. Paul. Services were held in all the churches and at the shrine over the spot where he was killed. In the eve- ning the city was illuminated in honor of the accession of Alexander III. The Czar on bis forty-second birthday (March 10) received cor- dial telegrams from the King of Italy, the Bm- peror of Austria, and the Prince of Montene- gro. The Emperor and Empress of Germany gave a gala dinner in his honor, at which Gen. von Moltke, Count Herbert Bismarck, all the members of the Russian Embassy, and many other distinguished persons were present. Definite information was published on March 15 at London and Vienna that while the Czar was returning from the requiem services a bomb attached to a cord was thrown under his carriage. The intention was to tighten the string, which was connected with the mecha- nism, and thus explode the bomb ; but, before it could be executed, the student who threw it and a suspected accomplice were seized. It was found that they lived together in a lodging- house in a suburb of the city. The police vi- sited this house and discovered there a quanti- ty of explosives and a number of revolutionary pamphlets. More than 200 persons have been arrested. The bomb was shaped like a book, so that it could be carried in the hand without exciting suspicion. The persons arrested in connection with the constitutional plot indignantly deny that they are in any way connected with the effort to take the Czar’s life. Their motto, they say, is ‘“‘The people; with the Czar or against the Czar.” They have published a lithographic periodical composed mainly of extracts trom the works of notable writers on constitutional law and political economy. The statutes of the Society obliged all the members to join, at the signal of their chief, in doing their utmost to subvert the existing Government and estab- lish a constitutional government. It is report- ed that the conspiracy of Russian land-owners and tradesmen to overthrow the Czar’s Gov- ernment was very extensive, and included a number of military officers, and that it was chiefly on this ground that the Czar was averse to undertaking war.

Page 9

March 17, 1887] The Nation. 1 ~ ~ The plot against the life of the Czar has had a tendency to revive talk of war. The Berlin Post on March 16 said: ‘‘ With terror and regret we say that Europe must prepare to see Russia adopt a policy of despair, taking shape either in fatalistic resignation or frantic ad- ventures. The latter is the more probable. It will require a superhuman effort on the part of the Czar to oppose the tempest of voices calling for war as a remedy for Russia’s woes.” Two more of the leaders in the recent insur- rection in Bulgaria have been sentenced to death, and 125 other participants in the revolt have been sentenced to prison. Conflicting reports have come of thwarted plots of insur- gents, but there has been no other outbreak. The Regents have decided to summon the Great Sobranye and submit to it reports of the recent trouble, and to ask either that a supreme power for the government of the country be formed or that the present régime be confirmed. It has been reported that the German police have discovered a great Anarchist conspiracy extending throughout Germany, Switzerland, Russia, and America. But no definite facts about it have been made known aad no action taken, except to disband certain suspicious so- cieties in Alsace-Lorraine. During the discussion of the budget in the Provincial Committee of Alsace Lorraine, a Deputy, speaking for the Government, said, on March 15, that the spirit which the late elec tions had shown, induced the Government to resort to measures to protect the province from illegal agitation. The Government was con- vinced that the time had arrived when it was necessary to adopt measures more severe than it had wished to adopt to weld the province in closer cohesion with the rest of Germany. Great preparations are making for the cele- bration of the ninetieth birthday of the Empe- ror of Germany on March 22. The King and Queen of Saxony, the Crown Prince of Wiir- temberg, the Princes of the Houses of Baden and Hohenzollern, Prince Louis of Bavaria, and the Dukes of Saxe-Coburg and Saxe-Mei- ningen are going to Berlin to take part in the festivities. It is reported that eighty members of royal families will be present on that occa- sion. The Prince of Wales is expected on the 20th and will remain a week. The Crown Prince of Denmark and the Crown Prince of Sweden and Norway are also expected. Prince von Hohenlohe, Governor of Alsace-Lorraine, has ordered a grand celebration of the day, the festivities to include military reviews and other pageants. The Czar will send the Grand Duke Vladimir and the Grand Duke Michael, with a large suite, to Berlin; and Nizami Pasha will represent the Sultan of Turkey. Paragraph 1 of the Septennate Army Bill, which passed its final reading by a vote of 227 to 31 (84 members not voting) in the Reichs- tag on March 11, fixes the peace effective force of the German Empire from April 1, 1887, to March 31, 1894, at 468,400 men, ex- clusive of one-year volunteers. Paragraph 2 fixes the infantry at 534 battalions, the cavalry at 465 squadrons, the field artillery at 364 bat- teries, the foot artillery at 31 battalions, the pioneers at 19 battalions, and the trainmen at 18 battalions. The passage of the Septennate Bill in the German Reichstag and the quiet that followed the insurrection in Bulgaria gave a peaceful tone to European news for a week. But it is now reported that 10,000 men are engaged night and day in fortifying Cracow. ,, Austria has made great though late preparations for war, and Germany is prepared to start a cam- paign on a day’s notice. The army contracts are signed, the officers have sealed marching orders, and the expectation of war is yet general in both Austria and Germazy. The fourth son of Prince William, son of the Crown Prince of Germany, was baptized at Potsdam on March 12. The Emperor was pre- sent and held the infant at the font during the baptism, M. de Lesseps has made a visit to Berlin, which it has been suspected and denied was of political significance. On March 9he was the guest of Emperor William at supper, and both the Emperor and the Empress bestowed upon him marked attentions. His effort to se- cure the neutrality of the Suez Canal is report- ed to have been amicably but evasively re ceived by Prince Bismarck Russian admirers of the French Gen. Bou- langer have presented to him a valuable sword. By an accidental explosion of mélinite, a new explosive, in the French Arsenal at Belfort on March 10, six men were killed and eleven injured. An important incident of political discussion in Great Britain was a speech by Mr. Joseph Chamberlain on March 9, in whieh, speaking for the Liberal-Unionists, he declared that groundless hopes had been raised among the Gladstonian Liberals, who were mistaken in throwing up their hats before they were out of the woods, and that the difficulties in the way of a union of all factions of the Liberal party were greater than ever. The Liberal-Unionists, he said, would never surrender an inch of their demand that the Imperial Parliament should retain its supremacy with members from every section of the United Kingdom within its walls. The central authority at Dublin must be sub- ordinate to Parliament and not codrdinate. They would never consent to surrender the lrish Protestant counties to the control of a Dublin Parliament against the will of the citi zens of those counties. He congratulated the Liberal-Unionists on the fact that they remain- ed in fighting trim. Mr. Gladstone on March 10 gave notice to the Liberal party that he himself would lead the Opposition to the Coercion Bill in Parliament. Mr. Gladstone, replying to the request of a number of his adherents for information as to the coacessions offered to the Unionists, has said that the Liberals may rely upon his firm adherence to the principles and bases of his home-rule policy. The Radical Unionists at- tribute the failure of the conterence negotia- tions to Mr. Gladstone’s decision to abide by Mr. Parnell’s demands. Since the breaking off of negotiations with the Gladstonian Libe rals, the demands of the Unionists have grown. As formulated they comprise the following es sentials : That Ireland be represented in the Imperial Parliament ; that Ulster be separated from the jurisdiction of the Dublin Parlament; that the Insh Parliament be subordinate to and not codrdinate with the imperial body ; that the subordinate powers of the Irish Parliament be strictly defined and limited; that the main tenance of law aud order remain under the con trol of the imperial authority; that Mr. Glad stone’s financial proposals be abandoned; that his proposition that the Irish Parliament be composed of two orders be abandoned, and that British credit be not pledged for the bene fitof Irish landlords. The Parnellites and Glad- stonians scout these demands as unworthy of consideration. A sensation was caused in British politics by the publication of Gen. Sir Redvers Buller’s evi- dence before the Lrish Land Commission. [he drift of his testimony was that it would be a serious matter, with their grievances unre- dressed, to attempt to suppress by force the tenants’ right openly to associate for the pro- tection of their interests. This testimony was so reported as to take much of its force away, and it was said that the important part of it was suppressed. That any part of it was suppressed was promptly denied, but that this testimony was embarrassing to the Government has not been denied. On nearly every one of the thousand pages of the blue book is evidence favorable to a suspension of evictions and to Gen. Buller’s plan of legal machinery between tenant and landlord. The testimony for coer- cion occupies about one twentieth of the space, the remaining being for legislation. The Prince of Wales presided on March 11 at the annual meeting of the Royal Thames Yacht Club. The money forthe 1,000-guinea jubilee prize has already been subscribed, and the 14th of June has been fixed as the date for starting the race. The course laid out is from the Nore northward up the east coast. of England,’ around Scotland and Ireland to Dover The cataract in Sir Michael Hicks-Beach’s eye is becoming more dense, but his health its better A foreman and a draughtsman at the British navy-yard at Chatham have been discharged for revealing secret naval designs to Russian agents, At the Papal Consistory on March 14 the Pope announced that Monsignor di Rende, Papal Nuncio at Paris; Rampolla del Tindaro, Nuncio at Madrid; Vannutelli, Nuncio at Vienna; Masela, ex Nuncie at Lisbon ; and Bishop Gordani of Ferrara, had been created Cardinals. He also announced the appoint ment of eight Italian, two Spanish, one Portu guese, and three East Indian Bishops The Pope has asked Cardinal Manning for his opinion on capital and labor, and will await a reply before writing his encyeheal, Cardinal Gibbons, who is now in Rome, bas been report ed as saying that there would be no conflict In. the United States between the Catholie Church and the Knights of Labor, An earthquake shock was felt on March 11 throughout the region of the late disturbance At Mentone it was the most violent since that of February 25. The walls of many houses were again cracked, and mirrors and glassware were broken. Visitors hurried away, and resi dents camped out in the open air, At Monte Carlo the shock caused a panic in the gambling rooms, The vibration was felt) sharply in Marseilles, where for a time there was a pani The hotels and the Bourse were emptied in 4 very few seconds The walls of many build ings were cracked, Mr. Walker Fearn, United States Consul General to Greece, on March 14 opened the new building erected by the American Society* at Athens for the study of classical archwology. Mr. Fearn and the principal of the Society thanked the Government for the gift of the Site. The Stanley expedition for the relief of Emin Bey arrived at Cape Town an March 10, and proceeded to the Congo River The men composing the expedition were reported to be in fine condition. News has been received at Zanzibar from Emin Bay. In November he went to Uganda, but permission was refused him to go through the country. Advices from Uganda, dated January 24, say that Dr. Junker’s caravan reached Emin Bey safely, and that he was well. The members of the House of Commons of the Canadian Parliament recently elected are divided as follows: Ministerialists 112, Oppo sition 95, with 8 meribers from disputed dis tricts not reckoned. The Canadian Government has forwarded a propositien to the Colonial Office in London concerning the fisheries dispute with the United States, wherein it is suggested that Great Bri- tain should at once propose to the United States the settlement of all questions without reserve by the appointment of a commission te consist as follows: One delegate to be named by the Governor and Council of Canada, one from Newfoundland, by and with the consent of Great Britain: two from the United States, and one from some independent European Power. With such a Commission, it is said, all questions could be satisfactorily adjusted. It is understood that Germany is the Power which Canada would prefer as referee. The Canadian protective fleet in the fishing waters this year will Se larger than that of last vear, and ‘‘the Yankee smack that succeeds in trespassing within the three-mile limit without molestation,” Sir John McDonald is quoted as saying, ‘* will have to be command ed by an uncommonly eunning old sea dog.”

Page 10

22: ~~ wo The Nation. { Number 1133 THE STATE OF PENNSYLVANIA VS. THE ANTHRACITE COAL COMPANIES. TowaArD the end of last summer the Governor of Pennsylvania let it be known that he had discovered a corrupt agreement between the companies engaged in carrying anthracite coal, and that he had determined to exert the whole power of the State to break it up. As every one who read the newspapers knew that the ‘‘coal pool” had been in existence for nearly two years, and as there seemed to be no reason for supposing that there was any more corruption in it than in other pools, the public listened to this announcement with chilling indifference. It was suggested that the Governor’s action was caused by the ap- proach of the fall election, and the feeling that something ought to be done to rescue his Ad- ministration from impending oblivion. He had been elected as a reform Governor, but he had instituted no reforms, and his course from the beginning had been a disappointing one. Such suggestions as these called forth vigor- ous protestations of good faith from Gov. Pattison ; but the report of the proceedings in the suit that he caused to be instituted against the coal companies precludes belief in these protestations. A more humiliating failure on the part of a plaintiff is inconceivable. To be sure, the suit was begun too near election time to advance very far before a change of ad- ministration occurred, but the witnesses called by the State heaped up such a mass of evidence against it that no subsequent proceedings could make much difference with the result. That must be a weak case for the plaintiff in which he relies upon the defendant for his evidence ; but, with one exception, all the witnesses call- ed by the Attorney-General were officers or agents of the defendant companies, That exception was in the case of an officer of the State Bureau of In- dustrial Statistics, and bis testimony was more damaging to the case of the State than was that of the defendants themselves, The State had charged that the companies had re- stricted production during the year 1885. The Attorney-General succeeded in establishing out of the mouth of his own witness that this charge was false, and that, in fact, the produc- tion of that year had increased by 6,000,000 tons. The palpable absurdity of these figures would have discredited the defendants’ case had they introduced them; when brought out by the plaintiff they turned the whole proceed- ing into a farce. That the way of the demagogue is hard was curiously illustrated by another circumstance that appeared upon this investigation. The miners are now generally paid upon a “‘ sliding scale ’—their wages rising with the price of coal—and their pay constitutes from five-sixths to six-sevenths of the cost of production. If, then, the companies had succeeded in raising the price of coal, they would have conferred a benefit upon “labor.” In some communities it might be urged that the interests of the great mass of laborers who consume coal were of more consequence than those of the small num- ber who produce it. But this argument has always been regarded as fallacious in Pennsyl- vania, and is, moreover, hostile to the ‘‘ labor ” policy. Gov. Pattison, therefore, found himself in the awkward position of denouncing the em- ployers of about 100,000 laborers, most of them voters, and Democratic voters at that, for adopt- ing a policy that would raise their wages and lessen their hours of work. For these reasons the attack upon the coal companies must be pronounced a failure; but the testimony taken in the suit is in some re- spects of real value. It illustrates several im- portant economic laws. The production of anthracite coal is substantially a monopoly. This is not so much due to an agreement among producers as to an agreement among the car- riers, who are much fewer in number than the producers, and upon whom the pro- ducers are dependent. Monopolies have an odious name; but it is often the case that their interests are the same as_ those of the public. It may be questioned whether the great coal companies have in the past been governed by this principle, but the circum- stances of the present time have compelled them to act in accordance with it. They have been ground between the upper .mill- stone of the competition of the producers of bituminous coal and the nether millstone of the unions of miners, with the result that they have to treat all parties fairly. In fact, it seems to be their stockholders, and not the public, who have now most cause to com- plain. Thus it appears that in the case of the Le- high Coal and Navigation Company the price of coal was lower in 1886—under the alleged corrupt combination—than in any year since the war, and lower than the average of any previous year except 1879. This price, more- over, was very little above the cost of produc- tion, nearer to it, in fact, than in 1879, on ac- count of the advance in wages. The profit made by this company, whose coals are ex- ceptionally valuable, was in 1886 only 15 cents a ton, without allowing for royalties, interest, or depreciation of improvements. As the surface seams of coal are ex- hausted, it becomes necessary to use ex- pensive hoisting machinery, and the cost of keeping the collieries free from water steadily increases. As the coal is taken out more tho- roughly, more timber is used, and the price of timber has itself advanced. Greater care also has to be taken in preparing coal for market, for people have grown fastidious. The fluctuations in price that regularly take place during the year, and the variations in the amounts produced from month to month, are not so arbitrary as the public suppose. They are caused by a very simple physical fact—the bulky character of the commodity compared with its value. The expense of storing coal is so great where land is valuable that large con- sumers prefer not to buy it until they need it. Furthermore, the expense per ton of rehan- dling it when it is stored by the companies is more than the average profit. The cheapest place for storing coal is the mine. The economical management of the business, therefore, re- quires that when the coal is once moved, it should be kept steadily in motion until it reaches the consumer. Hence it becomes necessary not only to reduce production when the demand is slack, but to lower the price at the same time. Were this not done, the cost of production would be greater and the average price higher, while the miners would be idle for months at a time, Were the production to be the same in every month, the companies would at one time be overloaded with their own products, for they have not storage room for more than a million tons, while at another they could not supply the demand. Formerly, when there was no ** pool,” the fluctuations of price were much more violent, the periods when the miners were idle were much longer, and the expense of doing the business was much greater. Upon the whole, it seems that the ‘‘ coal pool” has been the result of an economic necessity, and produces an economic gain. The com- panies were charged with entering into a con- spiracy to restrict the production of coal, to raise its price, and to lower the wages of miners, The evidence so far brought for- ward in support of these charges shows that, whatever the purpose of the ‘‘ conspiracy ” may have been, it has been attended with an increase of production, a reduction of profit to the producers, a reduction of price to the con- sumers, and an increase of wages to the miners. There is no reason to suppose that this state of affairs will be bettered by the interference of the State. MONEY AND POLITICAL MACHINES. Mr. Wiuu1aM M. Ivrys has published in the Evening Post two more papers, in which he follows up the growth of the evils so forcibly pointed out in his paper before the Common- wealth Club, and indicates the remedy for them. His new revelations, while not so startling as those in the first paper, are scarcely less interesting. Mr. Ivins shows that we owe the demoralizing practice of heavy assessments to the fertile politi- cal genius of John Kelly. Nothing affords stronger evidence of the merits of the in- vention, from a political point of view, than the broad general results which it ac- complished within the short period of a dozeu years. The grand total of ‘‘ assessments ” was run up from a few thousand dollars in 1872 to nearly a quarter of a million in 1884, Three political Machines were built up, con- trolling on election day an aggregate force of 45,000 men, equal to one-fifth of the entire voting population, all of whom were un- der pay and who had a pecuniary interest in the outcome of the election. The total amount of money distributed among these 45,000 on election day was over $700,000. They had at stake in the election at least $1,000,000 more in salaries, which their leaders hoped to get from the city for themselves and as many of their followers as could be quartered upon the city’s payrolls. Looking: at John Kelly’s mission in politics, in its proper light, that of obtaining the largest possible amount of spoils, no man can view these results and deny that he was a great leader. He re- duced politics to such a perfect system that, when his power was at its height, he made the government of this city literally a matter of bargain and sale. He quarrelled with Governor Cleveland because the latter would not take this view of public office, and he quarrelled with every Mayor who made like objection. He had Tammany Hall organized into as subservient an army of mer

Page 11

March 17, 1887] The Nation. cenaries as ever existed, and we had an ex- ample of what he was able to do with them when, in 1884, he threw almost their solid vote against the Presidential candidate of his party, whom he had repeatedly pledged himself to support. He literally sold his whole Machine vote to the Blaine managers in return for Republican votes for his candidate for Mayor, and nobody can examine the figures of the returns and not be convinced that the bargain was kept by both sides. The fail- ure to deliver quite enough to insure success in the election undoubtedly had much to do with hastening Kelly’s death. He had made a final and remarkable demonstration of the perfection of his system, but he had failed in a stake for life or death, That bargain of 1884 was only an instance on a large scale of what goes on in every mu- nicipal election, and what must, from the na- ture of the case, go on in every election so long as the present machinery is continued. Mr. Ivins shows with great clearness why this must be so The State has neglected to supply the needed machinery of elections beyond the mere recording, receiving, and counting of the vote. Gradually there have been built up to supply this de- ficiency three political organizations, com- posed of men who have taken up this as the most profitable business lying open to them. They have gone into it from no mo- tives of public duty or patriotism, but simply to get a living ‘The more extravagant and corrupt politics can be made, the better living will they get. They cannot be blamed for this. They have taken up a business which nobody else would touch. They are able to take it up solely because the respectable people have been too indifferent to do it for them- selves, and too careless of the public good to provide for its doing by the State. The won- der is not that the Machines are so corrupt and unscrupulous, but that they do any good at all. They do put fit men into office occasionally, though if they were always to combine in favor of bad men, they could win in spite of all obstacles, There are encouraging signs that the people of this city are waking up to the disgrace of allowing such a state of affairs to continue. We put a tax upon nominations for oftice which excludes all but rich men from getting into high positions, and we put a premium upon political dishonesty and trickery by throwing all the machinery of elections and all the money for its operation into the hands of the worst elements of our population. We do not mean to say by this that there are no honest men in the Machines. There are many there, but the majority fn all Machines is composed of men who have gone into politics because they had no other business, and were unfit for any other. We can never hope to reform this by starting a Machine composed entirely of honest men,sim- ply because the honest men will not do the work, It is useless to talk more about reform- ing the Machines by infusing into them a larger proportion of what is known as the “better element.” That has been tried over and over again, but has always failed and failed ludicrous- ly. Then, too, even if we could reform the Machines, what right have we to put a tax upon candidates which is so heavy that it excludes poor men and even men of moderate means from public office? The State pays for the registra- tion and reception of the ballot, and on pre- cisely the same principle it should pay for its printing and distribution. Instead of this being, as some persons curiously claim, con- trary to the spirit of our institutions, it is in perfect accord with it, for it is the only way by which we can be supplied with a free and untrammelled exercise of the right of suffrage. Mr. Ivins shows, in the ingenious parallel at the close of his second paper, how completely the evils which we are suffering under Ma- chine control can be eliminated by the adop- tion of the remedy which is embodied in the English law. In his third and conclud- ing paper he sets forth elaborately and clearly the provisions of this law, whose working in the elections of 1886 can now be studied in a very exhaustive report which has recent- ly been laid before Parliament, This re- port gives for the first time a detailed statement both of the expenses of the candi- dates under the heads into which the law di- vides their outlay, and of the charges made to the candidates by the returning officers The most significant fact disclosed is, that the grand total of expenditures by candi- dates is only a little more than one-half of the grand total allowed by the law. Omit- ting the universities, there were in the election 794 candidates in 460 English con stituencies. The maximum scale allowed under the Corrupt Practices Act for all these constituencies was £667,400. The actual outlay on items allowed by the law was only £364,811. In Wales the maximum was £43,675, and the actual outlay was only £18,838. About one-fourth of the elections in England and Wales were uncontested, and the expense of most of these was very small. But had they all been contested at the average cost of the other three-fourths, the maximum would still not have been reached by more than £200,000. Commenting upon these figures, the London Daily News says: ‘* The first thing which they prove is the complete success of Sir Henry James's act. The chief feature of that act was that it laid down a maximum expenditure, to exceed which would be a corrupt practice, voiding the seat. The experts said that the maximum was placed too low—the experi- ence of the last election demonstrates that, as usual, the experts were wrong, and that on the contrary the maximum is too high. It would be possible to reduce by at least one- fourth the sums allowed by law without io any way starving the elections. There are very few cases in which the maximum was reached.” This is a remarkable showing. Within the short space of four years, and after two elec- tions, it has been demonstrated by actual figures that the extravagant and corrupt use of money in elections can be completely abolished by the simple process of forbidding it by law. As extravagant expenditure constantly bred greater extravagance, so on the other hand does honest expenditure breed economy, for if one candidate does not bribe and corrupt, his rival has no need to, Neither do we find in the English comments on the results achiev ed any intimation that there is a falling off in the popular interest in the elections. The voters go to the polls with as much eagerness as they did when they were paid for their votes, “ PULLS." No effect of the spoils system is so striking as the way it distorts people's notions about the relations of the Government to the people, A most curious illustration of this is the appar ent novelty of Mr.Cleveland’s saying tha’ “pub lic office is a public trust." When one thinks over it a little, this seems so obvious a truth as to wear somewhat the air of a platitude. Nevertheless, when first produced it startled people a good deal, and for some months took rank as a discovery in political science, Indeed, it is still repeated in the papers frequently as a valuable addition to the literature of trusts. The reason of this was, that although the doctrine of trust in government had never died out in moral philosophy, or in school and college text-books, it had assumed in American the character of what theologians call a‘ pious opinion "-—that is, an opinion which may or may not be true, and which it does onws soul good to entertain, which body is bound to regulate his conduct. It Was open to any good American to on an office simply as a great responsibility imposed on him solely for th countrymen, but he ws- politics but by k ok benefit of his at the same time any one who took this view held by ticians to be a man as unfit for as one who felt himself bound to give his coat to anybody who bad taken his cloak, would be for the dry-goods business. Two-thirds of the work of civil-service reformers has, in fact, consisted in contending with the notion that offices are not private property, and that a man who acknowledges that the public has any in terest in them is not an amiable visionary. Fifty years of the spoils system have had a somewhat similar effect on the political mind about the exercise of the appointing The common-sense and ordinary business view of the appointing power is, that any- body who is invested with it is bound to keep in office all persons whom he be- lieves, on due ‘inquiry, to be discharging the duties of their respective places effi- ciently, and is bound to search diligently for persons qualified, in his own judgment, to fill vacancies, Nine out of ten Mayors and Governors, however, have wholly lost this early human notion of political duty, When they find themselves charged with the duty of filling vacancies, they are very apt to look on themselves simply as the custodians of lost articles, bound to deliver them to all who can identify them, or as officers charged with the distribution of prize money or of an indemnity fund. That is to say, instead of going to work to find proper persons to fill the places, they sit down and wait for “pulls.” ‘‘ Pulls” are among the most curious and interesting products of the spoils system, A ‘“‘pull” is an oc- cult force by which a public officer is com- pelled to do something which his judgment condemns, and for which he himself sees no was poli oftice power,

Page 12

224 The Nation. [Number 1133 good reason—such, for instance, as putting in an important place somebody of whom he knows nothing, or whom he knows to be a great rascal. It is only in politics that ‘‘a pull ” is ever plead- ed as an excuse for doing a shameful or absurd thing. A respectable man who excused him- self for the neglect or violation of any private duty by saying that he did it in obedience to ‘‘a pull,” would be considered insane or a humbug. but if he says that ‘‘a pull” has made him in some manner betray the public interest, we are all disposed to go about saying, ‘‘ You know, poor fellow, he could not help himself. He hated to do it, but so-and-so had a ‘pull’ on him, and he could not stand up against it.” The performance of Gov. Lounsvury, de- scribed in another column, in refusing to re appoint Prof. Hadiey, is an almost comic ex- ample of the way in whicha “pull” works. The Governor found an excellent oflicer in charge of the Labor Bureau of that State. The chief business of the Commissioner is the collection and arrangement of statistics touch- ing the condition of laborers. Prof. Hadley had remarkable training for the work, was, in fact, a man such as any government is lucky in securing for such work, and, moreover, had during one term given ample proof of bis fit- ness for it. One would expect that, under these circumstances, the Governor of a highly civilized State would at once satisfy himself that it was his duty to reappoint him. But Gov. Lounsbury did nothing of the kind. He knew the vacancy was coming, but he made no preparation to fill it. He simply sat down and waited for ‘‘pulls.” They soon began to be felt. There were ‘‘ pulls” from manufacturers, and ‘‘ pulls” from labor organi- zations, and ‘‘pulls” from ‘‘callers,” against Hadley. He supposed of course there would be pulls for Hadley also, and that Hadley himself must have been running about the State starting ‘*pulls” in his own interest. But to his sur- prise he felt no Hadley “ pulls” at all—none came from any quarter, Even Hadley said nothing in his own favor. Accordingly, says the Governor, with delightful simplicity, ‘‘in view of all these facts I decided that I should not be justified in making a reappointment.” About the manner in which Hadley had done his work, or about the nature of the work to be done, not one word does he say. His explana- tion is all about ‘‘ pulls.” It is evidently in- conceivable to him that anybody should ex- pect him to reappoint a man who had no ‘‘pulls.” All he says for Hadley’s suc- cessor, Mr. Hotchkiss, is that he knows “‘ the men who have endorsed him would not en- dorse him unless he were worthy of endorse- ment”; or, in other words, that his ‘‘ pulls” are strong. A STUDY IN “ POLITICS.” A CommirTEE of the Legislature of Indiana was lately appointed to investigate the condi- tion of one of the State prisons known as the ‘** State Prison South.” It has made its report, which ought to be in the hands of everybody who still believes that public offices should be used for the reward of party service, and that any sort of politician is good enough to take charge of criminals and paupers. ? The Committee found, to begin with, that the books of the prison were falsified and entries omitted, under the direct orders of the Warden; but they nevertheless dis- covered, without much difficulty, a defi- cit of $20,000. What became of the mo- ney they were unable to say, because the Warden refused to show his check-book. The Warden himself, A. J. Howard, is a most in- teresting person. Of course he is a good Dem- ocrat. The State being Democratic, the State prison had, of course, to be managed by Demo- crats, on the Jeffersonian plan. It does not clear- ly appear through what influences he got his place in the first instance, but the Committee found reason to believe that he used money on the directors, both when he was first elected, and when he was retlected two years ago. The main argument in his favor which could be produced was the very familiar one, that ‘*Jack Howard was honest and big-hearted,” and always stood by his friends, and ‘‘ never was known to break his word.” When he was retlected two years ago, the directors not only forebore to overhaul Jack’s accounts, but re- ported the prison as being in beautiful order, and did not require him to renew his bond. So he went to work to steal and misappropriate with renewed vigor. Jack Howard, like our late friend John Kel- ly, has a newspaper, called the Jeffersonville Evening Times, in which doubtless he de- nounces, or used to denounce, Cleveland and **snivel-service reform,” and urge upon the President the duty of ‘‘ turning the rascals out.” Kelly used to make the _liquor- dealers subscribe to his paper, in order to procure licenses. But Jack Howard was & more enterprising man than even Kelly, for he made the convicts subscribe to his pa- per, charging them on his books $4.50 per an- num out of the money they earned. Those who were ‘‘ hard up” were allowed to subscribe by the month, and the librarian, a convict named Martin, acted as canvasser for the journal among his brother criminals. Jack used also to borrow money from the eon- victs—that is, appropriate their earnings, and money sent them by their friends and on ac- count of pensions. Sometimes, when a con- vict’s term expired and he had to be paid what was due, Jack would be terribly embarrassed, and used to have to borrow from his subordi- nate officers and other ‘‘ big-hearted” friends. He had other resources, too. He used to appro- priate to his own use flour belonging to the prison, and ‘‘ garden truck and vegetables” raised by convict labor on ground belonging to the State, and used to convert raw material belonging to the State also. Jack never ad- vertised for bids for his jail supplies. He bought them from his friends, one of whom, a Louisville butcher, supplied ‘‘quarters and shanks” to the jail, ‘‘the choice portions going to other parties”—of course, on prison account. Besides this, Jack used to supply pork from a pork house owned by himself and his brother. He used also to inflict cruel and unusual punishments. Two men died from punishment while under his charge. The body of one was cut up and burnt in the furnace. The body of the other was disposed of without a preper inquest. The account given by the Committee of the filth of the prison is too disgusting to be laid before any community which is not responsible for Jack or his doings. With regard to the Prison Directors who appointed him, and who regularly reported that he was behaving in an exemplary manner, the Committee find them guilty of ‘‘gross if not wilful neg- lect of duty,” and recommend that ‘* their immediate resignation be requested.” They also declare that, as usual, Jack Howard had a ring who worked with him inside the pri- son. It consisted of the Deputy-Warden, the Steward, and the Clerk, each of whom had his own special share of the spoil. The oddest figure in the affair, who would also bea droll figure, too, if anything or anybody could be droll in such a sink of iniquity, is the chaplain, a certain L. F. Cain. The Commit- tee call him ‘* the Chaplain,” but in his exami- nation the wretched wag called himself ‘‘ the Moral Instructor.” He ‘‘ worked” his official position, as politicians would say, or, as the Committee say, ‘‘ prostituted it,” by ‘‘ securing the confidence of the convicts and obtaining money from them for the alleged purpose of se- curing pardons forthem.” While he was in the prison he apparently got tired of giving ‘‘ moral instruction,” and determined to study medicine. Being intrusted officially with the purchase of books for the library out of a fund formed by an admission fee paid by visitors to the prison, he bought medical books exclusively ,and charg- ed them to the prison at nearly double the cost price. He was a man of very large views, in fact, and fit for something better than a retail business; for, according to one witness, ‘*At one time he called the lifetime men tegether, and told them if they would donate him so much money—some considerable amount, I do not re- member just now—that he would go before the Legislature and he would procure the passage of a bill making fifteen years a lifetime sentence; and they gave him the money, and he went to Indianapolis, and when he came back he laughed and said, if they didn’t get their bill through he would get his bill through to raise his salary from $800 to $1,400.” We may add, in conclusion, that the maxi- mum number of times in which Jack Howard was, by the evidence, seen drunk in the jail was fifty. McFadden, the hospital steward, used to get more drunk than the Warden, but apparently not so often, and the guards did a fair retail whiskey business with the convicts. We cordially commend the report to the perusal of such of our readers as are interested either in the spoils system or in prison discip- line. But we would caution those who may feel disposed to reproach the decent people of Indiana for allowing such horrors to exist so long in a State institution, not to roll their eyes over them too much. For they must not for- get that a Warden has been appointed to the principal prison in this city whose character and career offer far fewer guarantees of efficiency and integrity than Jack Howard’s did when he got his place. We are displaying to-day to all the young criminals in the city the spectacle of an old and life- long member of the criminel class, known as ‘‘Fatty” Walsh, at the head of a great penal establishment. We are denouncing the liquor-dealers as the foes of decency, and order, and morality, and moving heaven and earth to get a bill passed reducing their number and restraining what we consider their infernal

Page 13

March 17, 1887] The Nation. o> & Kk? Kae) activity, and yet we have submitted without a murmur to the appointment of an old liquor- dealer and gambler to take charge of the mur- derers and thieves and rioters whom his trade has created or fostered. HENRY WARD BEECHER. Tue death of Mr. Beecher leaves in the United States no man of such unique and striking per- sonality as his, no man of such rich and strange experience, no man whose part in the anti-slavery conflict was comparable with his own. His face , and form and motion were as individual as his mind. For those who knew him well they seem- ed its inevitable expression. * His eloquent blood Spoke in his cheeks, and so distinctly wrought hat you might almost say his body thought.” His humor twinkled in his eye. One had but to see his mouth to know his nature's tenderness; and equally his enjoyment of all things purely sensuous—all lovely colors, all beauteous forms, and all delightful sounds. The physical volume of the man was necessary to his intellectual ener- gy and to his stormy eloquence. His impassioned outbursts would have been ridiculous in a man of slighter mould. His appearance during the last years of his life, if it did not gain in fine- ness, acquired greater impressiveness from his ruddy face and flowing silver hair. A stranger could not meet him on the street without know- ing him to be no ordinary man; without wonder- ing if he were not quite extraordinary. He was one of many children in the house of his parents. So far as we can trace his qualities to his immediate progenitors, his mother seems te have done much more for him than his father. His love of nature and of all beautiful objects and his glowing piety were distinctly her impres- sion, Of beauty as a means of grace Lyman Beecher had a very poor opinion. ‘“{t 13 all moonshine,” he said, *‘ with no doctrine, nor edi- fication, nor sanctity in it, and 1 despise it.” But the mother died when he was three or four years old, and her immediate successor was of such strict and ghastly manners in religion, and the father spared the rod so little, that the won- der is that religion and morality were not equal- ly distasteful to the boy’s maturer mind. Mrs. Stowe has written that as a child not a single toy was ever given to him, nér any little féte. And yet, because he was a boy and had good health and knew where sweetflag grew, and where the sassafras and chestnuts and the hicko- ries were to be found, be was not by any means unhappy. Doubtless it was by torce of contrast with the grim and loveless circumstances of his youth that beauty had for his manhood a keener zest, and love a more insatiable charm. Father Taylor objected to Channing that he had not bad a liberal education. His meaning was that the latter had only been to college—that he had none of his own rough-and-tumble sort of life. Doubtless the Boston Latin School and Am- herst College did much for Mr. Beecher, though in neither was he devoted to the curriculum; but what made his education hberal was a habit early formed of eager observation—a passion for good books, not mainly theological—the homely hfe of rising Western towns—the necessity for making his strength self-serviceable in many ways—the political and theological circumstances of his early manhood. ‘A course of mobs,” said Emer- son, ‘made Phillips the best stump-speaker in America.” Mr. Beecher's experience of one mob in Cincinnati—that which destroyed the press of James G. Birney—was a distinguished factor in his anti-slavery education; but for his lessons in the art of public speech his main reliance was on the rudeness of his congregations at Lawrence- himself apprehensible to them by speaking in the vernacular and with the aid of abundant illustrations. There was a time when the at- tractions of the ministry for him were less than those of journalism, at which he made some trial in 1856 as temporary editor of the Cincinna ti Journal. The Birney outrage happened dur ing his brief incumbency, and his first anti-sla- very work was done in the way of vigorous de- nunciation of that miserable affair. That he had already attained to some strength of fibre, to some capacity for individual thought and pur- pose, is witnessed by his conduct here and by bis rejection of the theological system which his fa- ther, with * logic afire,” was at that time doing noisy battle for against the ** Scotch-Irish-Presby- terian-Calynistic fatalism” rampant the region roundabout. The time spent at Lawrenceburg and Indiana polis, ten years in all, may be regarded as a time of preparation for the succeeding forty years of Brooklyn lifeand work That was the ante-room in whicb be tuned his instrument before he came upon the stage. It is true that his * Lectures to Young Men’ date from this early period, and they still have a steady circulation. They were important, too, as bringing him the recognition which resulted in his call to Brooklyn. But they were essentially ‘prentice work. On his arrival in Brooklyn he had already done something in the line of book-making, lecturing, and journal- ism—the three avocations that were to engross him more and more, but without taking any- thing from his preacbing, the work which he rightly apprehended as his regular vocation, and to which he made all other things subordinate His earliest connection with journalism was, as has been said, in Cincinnati, when, theologically, he was— in “ Wandering between two worlds, one dead, The otner waiting to be born.” His next was with the Western Farmer and Gar- dener, the first non-political paper published in Indiana, The love of flowers and of all green things growing was native to his mind; but in connection with his editorial work in Indiana he entered on those horticultural and floricultural studies which became a passion in his later years, furnishing him with myriads of apt and striking illustrations for his talks and sermons, and mak ing a seedsman’s catalogue more fascinating and religious for him than a theological treatise. Of much more importance was his editorial connec- tion with the Jndependent, and later with the Christian Union. The former was the principal vehicle of his anti-slavery opinions. His edito- rials were dashed off at the last moment, but the immediate haste was justified by ample prepara- tion, not only from complete acquaintance with the current topics of the time, but also from a thorough knowledge, broadly but not finely accurate, of our political and constitutional history. The Christian Union was his most characteristic journalistic enterprise. His ob ject was to make a journal like his church, in which persons of every sect might come together in a genial fellowship. With excellent codpera- tion, bis success was great and admirable in ac- complishing bis object, together with a circula- tion reaching at one time to 150.000. It would be hard to overrate the diminution or oblitera- tion of sectarian boundaries involved in such an enterprise as this. The Plymouth Pulpit was another of his rezu- lar serial publications. From week to week it contained tis sermons and his prayers. It went on for several years, and was an immense ex- tension of his pulpit influence. His books, with two or three exceptions, were also reproductive in their character; they were made up of ex- tracts from his sermons and selections from burg and Indianapolis, the necessity of making excerpts of a friend, succeeded by a similar vo lume which he much preferred, probably did more than any other agency to win for bim the sympathy and admiration of the young people in America—the many mal schools and female seminaries, and humbler thousands who, in nor colleges and theological schools, were preparing to do the teaching and the preaching of a gene ration, His novel *‘ Norwood’ showed bim in no new light and to shape its thought and feeling There was nothing in it which was not in bis sermons ina better form. His‘ Life of Christ is without any critical value, and its discontinu ance is not a matter for It was a bril liant paraphrase of the New Testament parra tion, in which Mr. Beecher spoke ten times from his emotion to once That he did not sooner resolve to write his autobi grapliy, regret. from his reason and carry out his purpose, is a great pity, Mr. Beecher's voluntary lecturing, as that part of his lecturing might be called which was not necessitated by the pressure of political events, was simply the more secular, social, political, of wsthetic side of his Brooklyn preaching seeking a wider audience. It gave fuller humor than his Sunday pulpit, and to his skill in repartee when there was any “ talking On this he actually throve. What would have disconcerted Sumner, what would have left Phil lips simply imperturbable, was exactly what he needed to twing bim fairly to himself, scope to his back.’ He never did so well as when there was some violent and noisy opposition, No orater of the anti-slavery contlict had his control of adverse elements, or bis power to rouse a sympathetic audience to ts highest pitch of generous enthusiasm and heroic purpose. When, at the Broadway Tabernacle ia 1860, he seized the chains John Brown bad worn, and, making them a symbo! of all slavery, dashed them to the floor and spurned them with bis feet, those who were witnesses to that * lime emotion ” were lifted to a seventh heaven of impassioned ardor far humanity Less emotional, but more intellectual, and, as a revelation of his personal force, alone in his ex perience, was the series of addresses made in Great Britain in the fall of 1863 In the reports of the speeches the questions asked, the cheers, the jubilee of sub gibes, the laughter, occapy almost as much spacs as Mr. Beecher’s If sometimes the re sult seemed doubtful, bis pluck and humor and good-nature triumphed in the end. At Liverpool it took him an bour and a half to get control of the meeting; then, for an equal length of time, he had bis way with it. The series of addresses, tive in all, was a masterly vindication of the po sition and the purpose of the North. In each he treated a new aspect of the matter, making good Dr. Holmes’s comment: “ Mr. Beecher delivered a single speech in Great Britain. Its ex- ordium Was uttered on the 9th of October in Man- chester, and its peroration on the 20th of the same month in Exeter Hall” This “single speech” made Mr. Beecher for a time our most honored citizen, If in England it did less than bas reckoned to change the course of public sentiment, it did much, anc it gave the sympathizers with the North their first good opportunity to show their strength and to enjoy a splendid vindication. For the speech was not more bright and humorous and auda- cious than it was just and strong and wise. Mr. Beecher was not at any time an abolition- i-t mn the technical sense of that term. His anti- slavery position was that of the Republicans, as such: freedom national; slavery sectional But while legal interference with slavery stopped for him at the State boundary, for moral interfe- rence he accepted no such limitation. The vote rolled up for Frément and for Lincoln bad no in- dividual aid superior to his. His brother Thomas words, sometimes been his articles. His ‘ Life- Thoughts, the sermon- once said of him that he had no more backbone

Page 14

226 The Nation. [Number 1133 than aneel. But it wasa faulty analysis which charged him with lack of courage. In 1850, amid and in defiance of the pro-slavery violence stimu- lated by the compromises of that year, he opened his church to Wendell Phillips, overruling the trustees. In 1866 he took sides with President John- son. Of the President’s character and motives he had no rightfulapprehension. His position was an expression of his abiding faith (in which he had great companions) that a policy of the largest clemency was the best policy of reconstruction. But the act which marked his utmost courage was his support of Cleveland in 1884. Often im- pulsive, he was here exceedingly deliberate. In 1876 he was resolved as clearly as in 1884 that if Blaine were nominated he would bolt the ticket. Tooppose an impersonal crowd of hundreds or of millions does not require the courage necessary to oppose a dozen friends. For Mr. Beecher, lik- ing to be liked and loving to be loved, fond of success and popularity, it must have been a fear- ful thing to array a score or two of his best friends against himself, and at the age of seventy- one to endanger, if not shatter, the congregation which was his joy and crown, Nevertheless, he did this thing, and waited the event. It was less damaging than his partisan Republican parish- ioners expected and desired. It was, however, as a preacher, not as a writer, journalist, or orator, that Mr. Beecher was most proudly conscious of himself, and it is as a preacher that he must principally be considered in any general estimate of his influence and fame. He was the most remarkable preacher of his time, the most popular, the most influential. He preached to nearly or quite 5,000 once a week, and the art of printing multiplied this number many times, Ne preacher ever spoke more free- ly and frankly about his methods as a preacher than he did in his ‘Yale Lectures’ and else- where. His ideals were simply the reflection of his individual ways and means. He did not blunder into his success. He studied other preachers, but he studied still more carefully himself. He was very careful of his general health and of his immediate physical condition. On Sundays he was ascetic. On Saturdays he loafed on principle. On Sunday morning the chosen subject was magnetic to the multitude of data, read or observed, with which his mind was stored, and it pounced on its own wherever it found it. The sermon had little organic unity. Its parts were always better than the whole. These were what the people carried away—the telling passages, the striking sentences. He the- orized that sermons should have dull and dreary passages to rest the audience, and as he theorized he preached. The illustrations and the bursts of eloquence made the main impression. His illus- trations were innumerable. He was always on the watch for them in his walks about town and his rambles in the country, and later they came trooping to his call. To be appreciated, it was necessary that he should be heard ; for he was a good actor, and, lacking his impersonation, the iJlustrations and the humor lack more than half their value. His whole body was at the service of his art. Sometimes there was no heart in his vehemence, but at other times it was so central that his whole frame trembled and shook witb his emotion, and the very building seemed to rock beneath him as with an earthquake’s throes. ‘* All men like poetry,” said Emerson, and Beecher was essentially a poet. Few of all our major poets have said so many poetical things, so many beautifully tender and pathetic things. Then, too, he was well-nigh our greatest humor- ist, sometimes as broad as Dickens, sometimes as delicate as Charles Lamb, sometimes as gentile as Thackeray, or as satirical—and he could suit the actien to the word. Here were two great at- tractions, but the greatest was his humanity and his sympathy with all things human. £ He wea man, and nothing human was foreign to him. His delight was with the sons of men. He hada great and overwhelming sense of the Divine Love, and he never tired of celebrating its incar- nation in the life and character of Jesus Christ. He was very far from being orthodox, judged by any of the traditional or formulated creeds. His theological preaching varied with his moods, but it was habitually less sound than his deliberate doctrinal expressions. But even these at various points—election, human depravity, atonement, future punishment—were much at variance with the Westminster Confession, the God of which he denounced as “barbaric, heinous, hideous.” The “salvation” of his preaching was Christian manhood: a clean body, a sound miad, a clear conscience, a good heart~not escape from any possible doom beyond the grave. Already his influence upon theology and reli- gion in America has been very great. * All can raise the flowers now, For all have got the seed.” But forty years ago the rigidness of dogma and the exclusiveness of sect were much more intole- rable than they are now, and Mr. Beecher has done more than any one else to scatter and tend the seed from which a harvest of untheological religion has sprung up. What he has done he will go on doing—not by his printed words to any great degree, but through the mediation of hun- dreds of preachers and thousands of the laity who have been touched and quickened by his spirit. In all the nooks and corners of America, as well as in its populous cities, there are men and women who owe to him their escape from a religica of terror, and are grateful to him fora gospel full of hope and cheer. Few men of his time had so much admiration as was granted him; few had such honor and success; and few were tried as he was in the fur- nace of adversity. If it is true that never after this did he have the weight, the influence, the au- thority in political and religious matters which he had before, it is equally true that the after- thought of many grew less and less adverse to him as the years went by. To many who hated him for political or theological reasons, ‘‘the great scan- dal” was a pretext for despising him for whith they were not ungrateful. But many others (and a much greater number) have not and never had a doubt of his complete and perfect inno- cence of any serious fault; and all who have any adequate appreciation of his great career must feel that, whatever fault was his, it was inherent in a nature strong and sweet and sane, and that it cannot be permitted to outweigh his general de- votion to all high and noble ends. ‘They say, best men are moulded out of faults”; and, if he was not moulded out of his, he was, in spite of them, a man most kind and lovable, of splendid gifts, of generous purpose, and of lasting service to mankind. BRITISH POLITICS AND SOCIETY. LonpDoON, March 5. Tue present Government is a Ministry of sur- prises, The resignation of Lord Randolph Churchill, the displacement and death of Lord Iddesleigh, and the entrance of Mr. Goschen into the Cabinet have been followed by the retirement of Sir Michael Hicks-Beach from the Chief Secretaryship for Ireland, and the appointment of Mr. Arthur Balfour in his place. The news is but a few hours old, and is stiil in the stage of discussion and speculative contradiction. There are journals and news agencies which prefer to be startlingly wrong rather than to be unobtrusively right, and they are trading in the public uncer- tainty and curiosity, But the news is true. Sir Michael Hicks-Beach suffers frem an affection of the eyes, necessitating, it is said, an immediate operation. Inalmost any other office than that which he has held it would be possible for him to take a few weeks’ leave of absence. But the Irish Secretary cannot “‘ interpose a little ease” even for a few hours. Sir Michael Hicks- Beach is respected by every one. He is a good type of the English country gentleman in office—a man of business and a man of breed- ing. Officially hated by the Irish Nationalists, Phe is not personally disliked by them, as Mr. Forster always was and as Sir George Trevelyan came to be. In society and by those who have served with him and under him he is in the highest degree popular. The rumors which are already afloat that his ill health is poli- tical as well as natural, and that he differs from the policy on which the Government has decided, would best be answered by his remain- ing in the Cabinet in some unlaborious depart- ment, changing, perhaps, his seat in the Commons for a peerage. But before the present Ministry was formed Sir Michael used to talk not only of declining office, but of giving up public life alto- gether, and he may beforea long time has elapsed act on that intention. Hissuccessor, Mr. Arthur Balfour, who gives up the Secretaryship (not the Secretaryship of State) for Scotland for the Irish Secretaryship, is one of the ablest men in the Government and in the House of Commons. But it may be doubted whether he is by temperament fitted to deal with the Irish members. He is critical, fastidious, and, though personally amiable, not free from a cer- tain intellectual sensitiveness which verges oc- casionally on irritability. The nephew of Lord Salisbury, there is a good deal of the Cecil dis- dainfulness about him. A less razor-edged in- strument than his intelligence would probably do better the rough work of hewing Parliamentary blocks, It would seem, after all, that something might possibly come of the Round Table Conference. Hitherto it has been regarded with a mixture of curiosity and scepticism, in which the scepticism has decidediy predominated, as if the five gen- tlemen seated at it were engaged in a sort of political table-turning, waiting until that piece of furniture tilts up, not without suspicion of a confederate leg, and proceeds to rap out a re- sponse. Perhaps, after all, in a sense different from Wordsworth’s, there msy be “‘a spirit in the wood.” A letter of Sir George Trevelyan’s to the Unionists of Aberdeen, and a speech deliver- ed by him at a House dinner in the Devon- shire Club, unreported and obviously distorted and discolored in detail by second-hand versions, but no doubt accurately represented in its gene- ral bearings, shows a hopeful and even confident temper. Though Mr. John Morley has de- clared that the principles, the policy, and the plan of Mr. Gladstone must be respected, there can be little doubt that the plan must go if the principle and the policy are to have legisla- tive effect given to them. The scheme for governing Ireland, in imperial matters, by a Parliament elected exclusively by the constitu- encies of Great Britain, is absolutely incompati- ble with elementary constitutional doctrines. It would reproduce in substance the state of things from which Grattan’s Parliameat was a success- ful revolt, and would not differ much from the ‘ Grenville, Townshend, and North policy which led to the American Revolutionary war. The fact that, for the exigencies of the moment, the Irish members were consenting parties to the arrangement, could not make it last- ing. No nation could consent to be perma- nently excluded from deliberation on those great matters of foreign and domestic policy the power

Page 15

March 17, 1887] The Nation. of dealing with which distinguishes a nation from &@ province or a dependency. The problem of union or separation would present itself in the question, Shall Ireland have this sovereign power in association with England and Scotland, through its:representatives in an Imperial Par- liament or as a separate nation, accidentally ruled by the same monarch as England, just as Eng- land and Hanover were until, on the death of William IV., their differing laws of suc- cession separated the two countries? The problem which is before the Round Table in the first instance, and v‘ ich, if they solve it to their satisfaction, will cume before Mr. Glad- stone and Mr. Parnell in the second instance, is to make home rule compatible with and subject to the Parliamentary Union. The condition of business in the House of Commons, not now only but during many Parliaments, shows the need of an arrangement by which purely insular con- cerns, British and Irish, shall be referred to pure- ly British and Irish assemblies, whether called legislative bodies, or national councils, or parlia- ments, while the common affairs of the United Kingdom, and these alone, shall be dealt with in a united Parliament, in which Great Britain and Ireland shall be equally represented. In tbe imperfectness of political nomenclature, the word Federal is that by which an arrange- ment of this kind can be least misleadingly de- scribed, though text writers, guiding themselves by precedents and definitions, may prove that federation, asin the United States, in Switzerland, in Germany,and in Austria-Hungary ,is impossible in the United Kingdom. Very likely, but in the art of politics, as in the art of poetry, definitions must follow practice, instead of tying down practice to themselves. In the meantime, it must be observed that the Round Table Con- ference is conducted entirely by members of Mr. Gladstone’s late Cabinet. Lord Herschell, Sir William Harcourt, and Mr. John Morley re- mained in it to the last. Mr. Chamberlain and Sir George Trevelyan seceded from it, ob- jecting to the plan and not to the principle and the policy. Lord Hartington and the larger and more important section of Liberal Unionists who declined to admit the principle or entertain the policy, and who therefore refused to join Mr. Gladstone’s Ministry, hold aloof from the con- ference. Lord Hartington and his followers still give their support to the Government, in which they are represented by Mr. Goschen ; and the concessions which would satisfy Mr. Chamber- lain and Sir George Trevelyan might leave the Hartingtonian Unionists unreconciled. The social gatherings which accompany the Parliamentary session have commenced. Mrs. Peel’s receptions follow the Speaker's Parliament- ary dinners, which are ruled by an order as rigid as that which governs the debate, and one which is much better observed. These dinners are given on Wednesday, the only Parhamentary day on which an afternoon sitting is held. At the first dinner the Speaker entertains such of her Ma- jesty’s Ministers as have seats in the House of Com- mons; on the second, the members of the preceding Government. On the third, Privy Councillors and other members of former administrations who have not been included in the recent politi- calarrangements of either party, are the Speaker's guests, and no doubt much candid conversation is heard with respect to men and measures. Then the rank and file of Parliament foliow by batches until the whole is exhausted. Many members have been in the habit of refusing the Speaker's invitations. Old Cobbett did so more than half a century ago on the ground, stated by him in his letter of apology to the Speaker who then was, that he was not accustomed to the society of gentlemen. Mr. Cobden and Mr. Bright used to do so--the former until the day of his death, the latter until he took office—from an insurmountable reluctance to put on court dress, For Mr. Bright, when he became a Minister, a new ubiform was invented of black velvet, to spare him the necessity of investing him self in the blue Windsor uniform with its epaulettes and sword. Very well he looks in his court suit, When M. Blowitz intruded himself into the prison of a celebrated French political offender, uninvited and for interviewing purposes, the victim described himselt as struck by the approach of something which resembled une boule surmontée par une orifice. Mr. Bright, in his velvet attire, looks like a stately pin-cushion, surmounted by a singularly handsome and venerable countenance, and endowed with locomotive properties. The number of persons who entertain Mr. Cobden’s objection to court dress is considerable in the present House of Commons, and for them the Speaker has arranged a supplementary banquet, not exclusively Parliamentary, for which eve- ning dress suffices. There are still grumblers, for among working-class members the modern dress-coat and white tie are viewed as bourgeois symbols, The deference shown to the Speaker is probably unique in the attitude of popular representatives to their President. He is ad- dressed in conversation as ‘Sir,’ a title other- wise given only to the King, when there is one, and to royal princes. There have, indeed, been two exceptions to this monopoly. The late Sir Robert Peel told Lord Stanhope, the historian, that Mr. when Grattan became a mem- ber of the British House of Commons, those Irish members of the Umited Parlia ment who had sat at Dublin with him, always addressed him as ‘Sir. Lord Castlereagh was among those who did so. A similar sign of de ference is studiously observed by many of his younger colleagues and other members of his party to Mr. Gladstone. The unceremonious habits of English society, in which the use of the words ** Sir,” or ‘*My Lord,” or ** Your Grace” are becoming obsolete, and are scarcely heard ex- cept from tradesmen, servants, and dependents, is rather an insular peculiarity, involving departure from the stately formality of a previ- ous generation, as well as from existing European and, I presume, American usage. Mrs, Peel's receptions are naturally of wider scope than the Speaker's dinners, not only as regards numbers, but as regards quality, and include all that is most notable in political society. In the suite of stately rooms of ‘the Speaker's house,” from the walls of which the present Speaker's predecessors gaze down upon the assembled groups, no more dignified and urbane host, and no more graceful hostess, could discharge the duties which fall to Mr. and Mrs. Peel. The other principal places of political receptions are, for the Conser- vatives, Lady Salisbury's in Arlington Street, and Mrs W. H. Smith's in Grosvenor Place; for the Liberals, Lady Granville’s in Carlton House Terrace, Lady Spencer's at Spencer House, near St. James's Palace, and Lady Rosebery's in Lans- downe House, which has been let to the late Foreign Secretary during the absence of the pre- sent Governor-General of Canada. More places of reception are, for the Conservatives, Lady Stanhope’s in Grosvenor Placeand Lady Hayter’s, the wifeof Sir Arthur Hayter. a subordinate member of Mr. Gladstone's last Government, once an assistant whip of the party, and the son of a more celebrated § whip. The palmy days of great houses and great hostesses are, however, over—the days when youthful Macaulays were introduced by brilliant Lady Hollands in historic palaces to ambassadors and earls. In their place is to be seen a staring crowd, looking about them, like a party of eye ye ~ ~~ é personally conducted tourists deserted by their conductor, obviously ill at ease as to their behavior, and uncertain as to what is expected from them. The periodically renewed rumors of the conver sion of the 7imes into a penny paper are again afloat. No doubt the intention will be denied until it is executed, and probably with truth, for when the purpose is definitely framed it will be promptly put into effect. The public will be in nocent of the knowledge until it applauds or con demns the deed. Meantime the newspaper offices are perplexed with fears of a change which, if it takes place, must have momentous consequences It will be fatal either to some of them or to the Times itself. Whetber the 7imes ata penny would remain the the question must be either the Times or nothing. Under Mr, Buckle’s editorship it has certainly recovered something of its old authority, and the decline in its circulation has been stopped and has even been turned the other way. Notwithstanding, there have been signs of weakness in Printing- house Square, It bas condescended to recognise the manin the streets, and at the railway stations, and on the knite-board of the omnibus, by the issue of bills of contents after the manner Times is amd it of its penny rivals, These bills are wantily supplied, it is true, and they are hidden shamefacedly in obscure corners, Sdll they are there, if you look for them, The Times is apparently dabbling its foot timidly in the water until it can make up its mind for a plunge. The hesitation is excusable The step it is supposed to be meditating means either suicide or a magic renewal of youth and strength. of its circulation bas of late ) ears been its strong hold ; and that has made it the medium through which public men of all parties express them- selves when they have had anything to say by the press. Its law and Parliamentary reports make it essential to lawyers and politicians, To * write to the 7imes,” and to * see a thing in the Times * are not mere survivals of speech : they express a belief in its unique character, an it retain the features which have given it this pre- eminence for a penny ¢ L. L The quality and not the quantity THE REPORT OF LORD COWPER’S COM MISSION, [ Dcursuin, February 28, 1887. Tre Roval Commission on the Irish Land Laws, presided over by Lord Cowper, has pre- sented its report to Parhament. The only repre- sentative of the tenants on the Commission (a Conservative farmer from the County Armagh) dissents from the general report, and prornises to present his own within a short time. The pub- lished report may therefore be looked upon as representing the landlords’ view of the question ; and, as such, it completely justifies the Plan of Campaign and the proposals made to Parliament last autumn by the National party. The fall in prices during the last two, as com- pared with the preceding four, years is stated to be 18', per cent. This, in conjunction with un- favorable seasons, has so impaired the farmers’ ability to pay rent that an immediate revision of judicial rents is recommended. The Commission proposes the following changes in the law as re- gards rents: (1) The revision of rents every five years, instead of fifteen; the revision to be effect- ed according to the general average of prices which have ruled during the five years preced- ing the revision, as compared with the average of prices for the five years before them. (2) The admission of leaseholders to the land courts to have fairrents fixed. (5) The admission of town- park occupiers, exclusive of those who hold less than five acres, of pasture farms up to £100 value,

Page 16

DQ 28 The Nation. [Number 1133 As to the first suggestion, nothing is said on the most important point of how the percentage of fall or rise in prices is to be applied to the in- crease or diminution of rent. The admission of the classes of tenants referred to in the second and third suggestions has been claimed by the Irish members as a matter of justice on every opportunity since the iatroduction of the Land Bill in 1881, and was refused peremptorily by both Liberal and Tory Governments. The pro- posal to regulate rents according to the average of prices for periods of five years would be 1m- practicable. The principle is undesirable, and no clear suggestion is made as to how it is to be applied. The amount of produce of any farm depends on the capital employed as well as on the skill of the farmer and the seasons. The cost of labor is quite as important an element in determining the net profit as the prices rea- lized. So is the amount of capital employed and the rate of interest to be allowed upon it. Cereal produce, meat of all kinds, and butter are im- ported from all parts of the world into Ireland, as well as exported fromit. Prices are not, there- fore, dependent on local conditions alone ; the good prices in any quinquennial period would not be a guide to the rent that could be paid in a succeeding period of lean years. Where a pay- ment is small in proportion to the value of the annual produce, as in the case of tithes, the money value may be made dependent on prices without mu*h inconvenience; but where rent presses on the means of subsistence, as in many districts in [reland, it cannot be so regulated. Instead of facilitating the collection of rent, such a method would encourage its being withheld, and would give rise to perpetual disputes and claims for the introduction of other elements into the calculation. Rents in Ireland are now in theory perpetual in duration, though uncertain as to their amount. In France and Switzerland the creation and im- position of perpetual rents are forbidden by the Constitution or by fundamental laws ; they are looked on as inconsistent with the true conditions of liberty and democracy. Rents in Ireland should be made redeemable, instead of trying to perpetuate them. The existence of a small rent-receiving class, retaining, attached to their rents, undefined powers of interference with the conditions of tenure, is not consistent with the economical and social health of an agricultural community. As remedies for the evils of congested districts, which are defined as being those where the soil is poor and the population too dense to live upon its produce, the Commissioners recommend (1) technical education for children, (2) emigration, (3) migration of families to other parts of Ireland, (4) colonization. As to the details, how and at whose expense these things are to be done, no- thing is said. It may be remarked incidentally that it is a mistake to suppose that the Irish Na- tionalists are opposed to emigration. What they have protested against is the schemes offered and enforced by the Imperial Parliament, which pro- vided little more than the bare passage of the emigrants and often of very unfit classes, who, flung in shiploads on tbe shores of strange coun- tries, with no further provision, were likely to be as badly off as if they had stayed at home. Irishmen have also claimed that a Government’s first du'y is to make the conditions of life at home—so far as laws can do so—such as to ena- ble the population to live and thrive, instead of seeking to get rid of them by any and every means, which has been the English policy in Ire land from time immemorial. When the popula- tion of [reland was under three millions, it was said to be overpopulated; the same is said now when the population has decreased by morg than three millions in thirty years, and when four or tive million pounds are paid away annually to absentee land-owners. The other recommendations of the Royal Com- mission deal with the policy of enabling the ten- ants to purchase up the landlords’ interests by State loans. They do not advise compulsor . ex- propriation, or any change in the terms on which loatis are made, but make a multitude of small proposals, with the object of enabling landlords to get rid of legal and technical difficulties and obstacles in the way of selling their estates. They omit, however, to make suggestions as to estab lishing any system of cheap and speedy transfer for the proprietary interests to be conferred on the tenant. This is an all-important matter; the law and practice of land transfer and with respect to the devolution of real estate in the United Kingdom are such that no system of small pro- prietorships of land could endure or be successful under it. Within the last thirteen years I have known it to take nine years from the institution of the proceedings to get the sale of an estate completed, The average time taken to sell an es- tate in the Land Judges’ Court is officially stated to be two years. The costs of selling or buying real estate are enormous, and increase in inverse proportion to the size of the estate. The prepa- ration of the deeds of transfer is only a small por- tion of the cost incurred in a sale; but I have known the purchaser of a small parcel of land to pay for his transfer deed five times as much as he paid for the land. It is a crime for any Gov- ernment to confer the ownership of land upon peasants without at the same time making pro- vision for its certain, cheap, and speedy transfer and devolution in future. In most of the British colonies land is transferred on the record-of-title system with certainty and cheapness. In many colonies professional assistance is unnecessary. In Switzerland land can be bought and sold by the yard at a trifling and known cost. It is the same in nearly all other civilized European coun- tries; the only heavy expense being the duty charged by the State on transfers. The omission of any mention of this matter from the report of Lord Cowper's Commission evidences its incompetence and the incomplete ness of its inquiry. The Nationalist party gave no evidence; the witnesses were almost alto- gether landlords, agents, and officials. Nething was, however, expected to come of the Commis- sion’s inquiry; the enlargement of the rent pro- visions of the Land Law to include the classes excepted at present will probably be the only useful result, for such a change introduced by the Conservatives would meet opposition from no other party. The neglect, however, of es- tabli hing a system of cheap and easy transfer may possibly prove fatal to the plan of lending public money on the security of the tenants’ hold- ings. When it takes years to sell a parcel of land, and when the cost of doing so is uncertain, but always great, it is evident that small parcels of land are a bad security from the fact of their not being marketable. Land reformers have often pointed out that the reluctance of banks (the na- tural traders in loans) to lend upoa land is one of the greatest condemnations of the English land-transfer system. When the owner of a small lot of land subject to a mortgage to the State gets into difficulties, he cannot dispose of his interest until he may have become hopelessly involved, and incurred a bill of law costs which may leave him without anything from the reali- zation of his estate. He cannot, moreover, sell to the best advantage when he meets a buyer with an appetite, for nothing can be done without lawyers’ aid, and nothing can be done off-hand. Many small freeholds have from such causes been eaten up by costs attendant upon family arrange- ments and partitions. The opportunity offered by a sale through a Government Commission is the most favorable for arranging for the future free transfer of land sosold. The title is cleared; the land is identi- fied and defined by a map. If the record-of-title system were adopted for all such land, it would be a marketable and good security. The posses- sion of a small parcel of land would not then be, as Lord Brougham thirty years ago said it was, and as it still remains, ‘‘a ruinous extravagance for a man of small means.” The general meaning of the report of the Cow- per Commission, then, is in the sense of making amendments in the existing laws, of grafting new statutes on to the aiready complex laws re- lating to the relations of landlord and tenant and the purchase of land. It recommends no new departure, not even simplification and con- solidation of the existing laws, If its proposals are embodied in legislation, they cannot be ex- pected to contribute much towards a settlement ona permanent basis of this troublesome and vital question. A LAND VALUER. Correspondence. THE ELECTIVE SYSTEM. To THE EpriToR oF THE NATION: Sir: On page 163 of the current volume of the Nation, ‘* A. H.,” in commenting on the state- ment that Harvard has been the leader in the ‘elective system,” claims the leadership for the University of Virginia, and quotes a paragraph by Prof. Noah K. Davisin support of theclaim. Dur- ing the last few years this claim has again and again been made, but, in the opinion of some, upon a misunderstanding of the term “ elective,” which is applied to the system of the University of Vir- ginia, but is there used in an entirely different sense from the more commonly accepted mean- ing. That it may be understood in what way the system of the University of Virginia is elective, the following js a brief sketch of the ‘elective system ” and the University of Virginia ‘‘elective system.” The main facts are these. At Harvard, in 1823 and 1824, sixty-four years ago, the Faculty (Reports of the President of Harvard College for 1885-84 and 1884-85) *‘ began to elaborate a sys- tem of instruction and discipline for students in the liberal arts which has come to be known as the elective system, because it permits each stu- dent, under limitations and guidance which are partly artificial but chiefly natural, to choose his subjects of study.” Previous to the time men- tioned, a uniform “curriculum” prevailed in most, if not in all, colleges in the United States, to which the student was required to conform. It extended over four years, and prescribed not only the kind of studies, but the order in which they were to be taken. Further, all persons ad- mitted were presumably candidates for a degree (no provision being made for persons not candi- dates for a degree), and only in connection with such persons is the term ‘elective system ” ap- plied generally at present. In 1825 laws were adopted at Harvard which provided for the admission *‘ of persons who are not candidates for a degree” and ‘“ for the con- sideration, to a limited extent, of the desires of ‘ students in the arrangement of their studies.” Beginning with some ‘‘electives” at this time (1825), it was not until 1841 that the electives be- came numerous, when they were allowed in all years except the Freshman year. In 1846 the electives were restricted to Junior and Senior years, where they remained for twenty years. In 1867, electives were allowed in Sophomore year again, and were gradually extended to Freshman year, so that at present there are only a few re- quired studies in Freshman year,

Page 17

March 17, 1887] In order that a person may be admitted into Harvard College and become a student under the elective system, he must pass an entrance ex- amination, and that the student thus admitted may be recommended for a degree, it is required (Barvard Cat. 1885-86. The requirements given below have been changed, Cat. 1886-87, but are quoted because they are in part yet in force, and show the numerical standard required), that the applicant has obtained as a minimum ‘“ two- fifths of the maximum mark in each of the pre scribed studies of the college course and of the prescribed number of elective studies, and has, moreover, attained one-half of the total maxi- mum mark for each year of the whole course from the time of his admission.” Besides the provision for regular students, at Harvard in 1825, it was announced that ‘‘ The University is open to persons who are not candi- dates for a degree, and who desire to study in particular departments only.” This was the re sult of a committee report, which said™ that pro- vision should be made for the admission and in- structioa of students in the University who may not wish a degree, but to pursue some particular studies to qualify them for scientitic and me- chanical employments and the active business of life; such students to have a right to choose their own studies, and, upon passing the regular pre- scribed course with the approbation of the Gov- ernment, to be entitled to a certificate stating their character and qualitications.” The pro- vision for these students was repealed in 1847, and none were admitted again until 1876. At present these persons are called *‘ special” stu- dents, who are admitted to the courses of study in Harvard College (Cat. 1885-86) on satisfying ‘the Faculty of their fitness to pursue the par- ticular courses they elect, although they have not passed the usual examination for admission to College,” and ‘‘a certificate of proficiency” is given, if desired, to any special student who has ‘attained not less than seventy-five per cent. of the maximum marks” in his chosen subjects. The special student may receive a certificate on Commencement Day and honors. At the University of Virginia, which com- menced its first term on the 5th of March, 1825 (‘A Sketch of the University of Virginia,’ 1885), the scheme of instruction is based upon a system of *‘ schools,” each under the exclusive control of its instructors, in each of which ‘a separate de- gree is conferred denominating the recipient a ‘graduate’ in that school.” ‘The University may .. . be fairly regarded as a collection of schools, each devoted to a special subject.” In 1826 the Faculty proposed ‘‘ To drop all the old unmeaning titles, and adopt in their stead the single term of ‘GRADUATE,’ except in the Medical School, where it will be necessary to re- tain the title of M.D. The degree of Graduate shall be conferred on those only who have ac- quired an accurate and extensive knowledge of the subject of one or more of the classes (ina school), or in-any single language. . . . The exact title shall be GRADUATE U. V.” This would not do, for in 1828 the Board of Visitors invited the Faculty to consider ‘‘ whether it may not be proper to adopt the ancient denominations of Bachelor, Master, and Doctor, or some of them.” In 1832 a degree with the title ‘* MASTER OF ARTS OF THE UNIVERSITY OF VIRGINIA ” was conferred upon ‘‘those persons who had graduated in the Schools of Ancient Languages, Mathematics, Na- tural Philosophy, Chemistry, Moral Philosophy, and in at least twoof the languages taught in the School of Modern Languages "—at present French and German are prescribed (Cat. 1885-86). In 1848 the degree of ‘‘ Bachelor of Arts of the University of Virginia ” was established. The system at the University of Virginia (Cat. 1885-86) “ allows students to elect for themselves - The Nation. the departments to which they are led by their individual tastes and proposed pursuits in life. This fraedom of election commends itself par- ticularly to those who desire to make special at- tainments in some one department of knowledge.” ** No student is subjected to entrance examina tions, except Virginians seeking tree tuition.” “A certificate of DISTINCTION is conferred ow one who bas attained three fourths of the value of the questions at any General Examination.’ ‘A certificate of PROFICIENCY is conferred on one who hes passed examination on —— special subjects "—of which there are nipeteen. ‘A Diploma of GRADUATION is conferred on one who bas passed examination on general courses "—of which there are twenty-two. A comparison of the requirements and awards for special study at Harvard and elective study at the University of Virgimia shows very close agree ment. At Harvard, ‘* elective studies” are not mentioned in connection with special students, At the University of Virginia election is not men- tioned in connection with degrees. The election at Harvard is for a degree. The election at the University of Virginia is for special study with- out reference, necessarily, to a degree. At the University of Virginia the requirements for degrees were prescribed, and were rigidly ad bered to,except in the School of Modern Languages in the M. A. and two options in the B, A. degree, un- til 1880-81, when some moditications were made in the requirements, which have resulted at the present time in giving ‘‘ options” in severa] de- grees; but during these changes the highest de gree of the University, *‘ Master of Arts,” has had its requirements inexorably fixed. The re- quirements for degrees are adbered to at the Uni- versity of Virginia in a way that is without pa- rallel in any college curriculum. In all prescrib- ed courses the minimum of 75 per cent. bas to be attained. No substitutions whatever are allowed, No excess in one study can make up for the least deficiency in another; tradition saying, for ex- ample, that in one case a student excellent in classics lost his degree of M.A. because he made only 74.5 per cent. instead of 75 per cent. in one of his scientific subjects. Any question as to the meaning of a degree ef the University of Virgi- nia has never been asked there, except, perhaps, during the past four or five years. Election at the University of Virginia, as far as degrees are concerned, simply means that the student may take the prescribed studies in what order he pleases and in what time he pleases or can. ** The student obtains them (the Honors) whenever be cas undergo the rigid examinations to which can- didates are subjected.” It at Harvard it were said that passing in a cer- tain numer of special courses would entitle toa degree, then there would be sometbing like an ap- proach to the elective system of the University of Virginia. If there be leadership in either direc- tion, it rather seems as if 1t belonged to Harvard, for, since 1880 81, the University of Virginia has made its degree of Bachelor of Arts much more flexible than ever before, and has conferred upon it some little of the indefiniteness of which so much complaint is made. With regard to the religious exercises at the University of Virginia, they are voluntary in quite adiffereat way from the courses of instruc- tion. They are in no way connected with the University officially, and are not part of the scheme of education. No provision is made by the government of the University for religious exercises. The Chaplain is supported by the vo- luntary contributions of faculty and students. He has no official standing in the University. He is the private chaplain of certain persons who happen to be at the University. The success of the elective religious system 1s just the same kind of success as religion meets with in the sIOIC) world outside of the University fully, LEXINGTON Va, Yours respect W. G. Brown, March 0, 1587. THE TARIFF AND SOCIALISM. , To THE Eptror oF THe NATION ; Sin: The article by Mr, E. L. Godkin fn the March number of the New /rinceton Review, on the political and social aspects of the tariff, pre sents a view of the tariff question that ts tk« much neglected. The the pecuniary results of the present system in the Umited States, although important, may fairly be regarded as of much less importance than the controversy over question of the effect of the pohey of protection on our political and social iustitutions It may be said that the fundamental princtple of American, as well as of Engush constitution al law, is the protection of the rights of the in dividual—or, more correctly stated, the tion of the individual in the legal enjoyment and assertion It is for this chiefly, that laws have been made and adminis tered. If we turn to the records of the proceed ings of the courts, as found in the ports of cases, both inthe United States and in England, we find that the great effort of those who have beeu charged with the administration of the protec of his rights, PUrpor published re law in both countries has been to develop and ap ply, sometimes under the most adverse conditions those great principles of personal liberty which are regarded as peculiarly the birthright of the Anglo-Saxon race. Even in which the State intervenes to avenge a public wrong, the tendency has been to iIncrerse the safeguards of the accused, even at the expense of certainty and swiftness in the execution of jus tice. In view of these legal traditions, and of the op position which has been manifested, especially during the first half of the present century, by the people of the United States, to the idea of “paternal government ” forms, it scarcely seems credible that they deliberately and intelligently entered upon their present pro tective policy, which exhibits one of the extremest forms of sociahsm. That they did not do so is sufficiently proved by an examination of our tariff laws, which discloses on every page the in- fluence of private interests; and so far has this influence been carried that not infrequently we find it violatang the very principle in whose name it is exerted. But, whatever may have been the forces that brought the protective system up to its present condition, the system is here, and it is important to understand what it means. Its ostensible basis is protection to ‘American labor,” or, to state the case more definitely, to those laboreis who are employed in certain industries. No advocate of the system would admit that itis intended principally to benefit the manufacturer, the capi- talist. Its justification is derived from its sup- posed benefit to the laborer. Now, taking this principle as the proper basis of legislation, we are led logically and unavoida bly to the regulation by the State not only of the price of products, but also of the rate of wages, It is believed that no legislature bas as yet at- tempted to fix the rate of wages which shall be paid by private employers to a certain class of laborers, but if A, a consumer of a certain arti- cle, may be required to pay to B, the manufacturer, a certain price for the bene- fit of C, the manual laborer, why may not B reasonably and legally be required to pay a cer- tain proportion of that price to C¢ In other words, why may not B legally be required to pay to C that portion of the price which the lawmaker intended that C should have ? It is evident that this would place society on a criminal cases, in In Various

Page 18

230 socialistic basis. But such legislation, instead of introducing a new principle, would simply give a definite and substantial form to the theory of protection to the laborer, which supports the pre- sent tariff system. J. B, M. MARCH 8. —_ RESULTS OF SANITARY INSPECTION IN CHICAGO, To THE EpitoR OF THE NATION: Str: Some time ago a committee of British ex- perts, on a visit of inspection to this country, pro- nounced the sanitary work of the Chicago Board of Health superior to that of any other city in this country. Chicago seems to maintain that su- premacy, and to vie with any cityin Europe io its successful coping with filth, disease, and tene- ment-house abuses. By the courtesy of the able Health Commissioner, Dr. Oscar C. De Wolf, to whom this work is largely due, I am enabled to give the following results, which have just been tabulated: | |Number per | thousand | Total mor-| of popu Years. | Population. tality. tion. cad weaned | §40,000 13,874 | 25.69 Pcscsaieseses 560,693 13,234 | 23.60 SSSRNSGRESE: 580,000 11,555 | 1992 Mines coseecesces 630,000 12,471 | 19.80 ar 664,634 12,474 } 18.76 FRETS 704,000 13,690 | 19.43 With an increase of 164,000 in the population the actual number of deaths has diminished. If the mortality had increased 50 per cent. in the last five years, as has the population, the deaths in 1886 would have been 4,337 greater than they were, The lives of over 4,000 were thus saved. The best indication of the health of a city is the fewness of deaths from zymotic diseases, such as fevers, which are held to be in large measure the result of poor sanitary conditions. Judged by this test, the results in our leading Western city are equally striking with those just given: a ° 3 Zn L Ss. 8g =a $s 853 s 6/2 3 “¢ 82 /s%|~ 8 Zz nas Cit o,2 ect Pas z° nem coeEv =n he} ooo Se ss 4 5 aa8, 4 Ss, Loe re _~ S 3 oe? “= @ ° £8 se So S z a § 22 13° . = 3 Ses 2 $4 Years. z Aw a Zz Pec cksccccccccsesde 4,213 7.80 7,371 13.65 Peenctenccccscnsacts 4,509 8.05 6,645 11.90 BE ctesvcsacccsscas 3,053 5.25 5,875 1013 BEBE. wcccccccccsccces 3,506 5.26 6,666 10.58 BEER. cocescccces. cece 3,210 4.8% 6,187 9 32 BERG. cvccrecccccesecs 3.437 | 4.88 6,763 | 9.61 fe Ss ; » i Fs 8 .fi8s $2 5 a s 3 $ a= 3 So2 | 2 £38 5s _ tee =&. ~s em-8 | Sess sua $3 | @=38 S$s S52 | ¢%e- g-g | Sha | S583 Age 2° 18 os Years - Zz | gs hee. i iicissacesscacicsneies 4,374 | 8.10 30.37 Be cccccesceses 4,059 7.25 34.07 i icdhiaavdduniesess 3,850 6.64 26.42 BB reccccccescocccccoscees 4,179 6.63 28.11 BEB accce cecccccceses 4,000 6 02 25.73 Ris cldasiacechensbidnrs 4,081 | 65.80 25.09 As is well known, not a house can be erected in Chicago until the plans have been approved by the Health Commissioner, who can order changes; nor can the house be occupied or the plumbing concealed until a second imspection, Old houses The Nation. [Number 1133 must be remedied of unhealthful conditions, or vacated on order of the Commissioner, who ex- amines every house and tenement in the city every year or two without waiting for com- plaints. Instead of young medical students who know almost nothing of sanitation or plumbing, practical plumbers, and competent, if not highly educated, assistants, are employed as inspectors under the direction of expert sanitary engineers. The results are shown above; for, although Chi- cago is too young to have the rookeries and con- sequent mortality of some older cities, there is no way of accounting for the remarkable decrease in the death rate unless it be ascribed to the work of the Board of Health. Not only have the lives of over four thousand a year been saved, but the homes, and consequently the health, of tens of thousands of others have been improved, doctors’ bills saved, and decent modes of living made pos- sible. Similar results will follow similar work elsewhere. EDWARD W. BEMIS. SPRINGFIELD, Mass. THE PHILADELPHIA POSTMASTERSHIP. To THE EpIToR OF THE NATION: Sir : In your review of the two years’ adminis- tration of Mr. Cleveland, you charge that the President did not fairly carry out his promises in some cases as to removals from office, and cite the removals in Philadelphia. 1 wish to put upon record the facts as to the removal of Mr. Huidekoper, the Postmaster. On the 6th of June, 1885, in company with some ten members of the Philadelphia Independents, I called upon the President to urge the retention of Mr. Huidekoper, Mr. Valentine, the District At- torney, and Mr. Eyster, the Assistant Treasurer, and these alone. We were all strangers to the President, and were introduced and had a very satisfactory interview. Within a few weeks one member of the delegation, without informing the others of his proposed action, wrote to the Presi- dent, reminding him of the interview, and say- ing that he desired to withdraw all support of Mr. Huid koper, and, in fact, made serious charges affecting him in his official capacity. No intamation of this action reached the other mem- bers of the committee until after the removal in November following. In entire ignorance of it, none other of the committee took any further steps on behalf of Mr. Huidekoper, and no refu- tation was made of the charges, which, in justice to him, I must add, were entirely groundless. Tie circumstances were very unfortunate for Mr. Huidekoper, for they doubtless caused his removal, the President naturally taking the ut- terances of one member for those of the whole committee. Mr. Eyster served out his full term. Mr. Valentine is still the District Attorney. Respectfully, etc., Jos. LAPSLEY WILSON. PHILADELPHIA, March 12, 1887. TRANSFORMATION OF SURNAMES. To THE Eprror or THE NaTION: Str: In your interesting column of letters some time ago were several anecdotes connected with changes of names. Allow me to present the following as a companion : Many years ago, on a farm in Vermont, there was a Frenchman at work whose surname was Papillon. His fellow-laborers found the name difficult to pronounce, so the owner of the farm suggested his being called by the Englisb equiva- lent, Butterfly. That was adopted, but soon grew too long, and degenerated into ‘‘ Fly.” He never knew any other. His descendants would find it difficult to trace their ancestry if they de- sired, under such circumstances, From the aristo- cratic Papillon to ‘‘ Fly ” is indeed a great de- scent,—Very truly yours, Ceci. HaMPDEN Howarb. Tue Astor Lisrary, New York, March 11, 1887, Notes. G. P. Putnam’s Sons publish immediately ‘ The Inter-State Commerce Act,’ with an analysis and a legal dissertation on the legality of the act, by John R. Dos Passos, of the New York bar. They have also in press ‘The American Electoral System; its Character and its History,’ by Chas. A. O'Neil, of the New York bar. Probably no provisions of the Inter-State Com- merce Act will involve more dispute than the phrases ‘‘ like service” and ‘‘ substantially simi- lar circumstances and conditions”; but similar terms, andgp some instances identically the same terms, have been used in the railway acts of Great Britain for more than thirty years, and the English courts have been called upon fre- quently, and in diverse circumstances, to con- strue them. Robert Clarke & Co., Cincinnati, have in preparation, to be issued in a few weeks, an annotated edition of the Inter-State Com- merce Law, collecting all these authorities, Harper & Bros. are about to publish ‘ Waste- land Wanderings,’ by Dr. Chas. C. Abbott, the well-known New Jersey naturalist ; a ‘Manual of International Law,’ by Lieut. Geo. B. Davis, U. 8. A.; translations of three stories, ‘ Baldine,’ etc., from the German of Karl Erdmann Edler ; a translation of Paul Céliére’s ‘Startling Ex- ploits of Dr. Quiés’; and Blackmore’s ‘ Spring- haven.’ T. Y. Crowell & Co. have nearly ready ‘ The Death of Ivan Ilyitch, and Other Stories,’ by Count L. N. Tolstoi; ‘Cuoré,’ by Edmondo De Amicis; ‘Sigrid,’ from the Danish of J. T. Tho- roddsson ; and ‘The Picture of Paul,’ by the Rev. H. R. Haweis, Funk & Wagnalls announce a new edition of Dr. Lyman Abbott’s ‘Henry Ward Beecher, his Life and Characteristics,’ with many portraits. ‘ Juanita: a Romance of Real Life in Cuba,’ yet not all fiction, written (as we infer, about 1830) by the late Mrs. Horace Mann, is to be pub- lisned by D. Lothrop & Co., Boston. Under the title, ‘Celebrities of the Century,’ Cassell & Co. will soon publish a biographical dictionary of the century,‘‘ containing condensed accounts of the lives of every man and woman who have won distinction during the years from 1800 to 1887, no matter what quarter of the globe they may be natives of.” This work, in one large volume, is edited by Lloyd C. Sanders, of Christ Church, Oxford. They will also shortly begin publication ot Prof. Henry Morley’s ‘ His- tory of English Literature,’ in twenty volumes, The whole narrative will be continuous, but the volumes will be grouped in sections, which may be read as distinct histories of periods, and each volume will be separately indexed. ‘ English as She is Taught,’ announced by Cas- sell & Co., is a public-school] teacher’s scrap-book of actual mistakes recorded in her experience with her pupils. The first two volumes of the six-volume edition of Browning, undertaken by Houghton, Mifflin & Co., will appear in April. They will shortly add Marston to their series of ‘“‘ English Dramatists.” An édition de luxe, limited to 100 copies, of ‘ Half-Hours with American Authors,’ is pro- mised by J. B. Lippincott Co. Mr. C. H. Howard, of the Astor Library, is about to issue, through F. Housh & Co., his lecture on the ‘ Life and Public Services of the late Gen. J. W. Phelps,’ read in December before the New England Historic-Genealogical Society in Bos-

Page 19

March 17, 1887] The Nation. 231. ton. He is also preparing ‘ Amherst in Prose and Verse,’ a companion to his ‘ Brattleboro.’ Craig & Barlow, Chicago, have in press ‘ Ro- manism: The Danger Ahead,’ by A. J. Grover, a lawyer of that city. D. C. Heath and Co., Boston, will issue at once, in their series of ‘‘ Monographs on Education,” a paper by Prof. J. F. Genung of Amherst College, on “The Study of Rhetoric in the College Course.” ‘Letters from the Far East’ is the title of a forthcoming book, by Col. De Lancey Floyd- Jones, U.S. A., now on the press of the Public Service Publishing Co., of New York. It will contain a number of full-page illustrations from photographs collected en route. Mr, James Payn is gathering into a volume, to be called ‘Holiday Tasks’ (London: Chatto & Windus; New York: Scribner & Welford), cer- tain of his pleasant little papers ina lighter vein, akin in style to his ‘Some Private Views’ ani ‘Some Literary Recollections.’ Mr. R. H. Tilley, Newport, R. I., is preparing for publication his ‘Genealogical Queries’ for 1887, and desires all who intend to insert queries therein to send them as soon as possible. His purpose is to have it ready and distributed by June 1, sending a copy to each public library, State library, historical society, and every per- son known to be interested in genealogy in the United States and Canada. One hundred and three copies will also be sent to England. The Rev. Dr. John Croumbie Brown, Had- dington, Scotland, author or compiler of several works on modern forestry, offers to present copies to the extent of his ability to public libraries in this country, on receiving a certificate from the State government along with the application. We are informed bya circular from the Fa- culty of Letters of Lyons (France) that they pro- pose to issue a photolithographic reproduction of the celebrated manuscript known under the name of Bible vaudoise., This manuscript is one of the treasures of the library of the Palais des Arts at Lyons. It contains the greater part of the New ‘Vestament, and has, at the end, a Vaudvis or Cathar ritual of the highest interest for the his- tory of the attempts at religious reform in the Middle Ages. The manuscript coutains five hundred pages, of which fifty were published in 1878 by Foerster. It is said to be very difficult reading on account of the great number of abbre- viations, and the repreduction will consequently be as interesting to paleographers as it will be useful to students of Romance philology. ‘The French Principia,’ Part iii (Harper & Bros.), presents itself in a very attractive form for a school-book, and a careful examination of the contents only confirms the good impression made by the material execution of the volume. This Third Part is an ‘Introduction to French Prose Composition,’ by the Head Master of the French School, Christ’s Hospital, the Rev. P. H. E. Brette, author and annotator of other valuable text-books. It is upon the plan of Smith’s well- known ‘ Principia Latina.’ The grammatical in- formation is so full and so clearly given that a pupil who had only an elementary knowledge of the accidence of the language might use the book satisfactorily, to acquire all that is absolutely necessary in order to write French correctly. The plan pursued in the exercises is not new. There are numerous passages of English prose to be translated into French, with many carefully made notes and references to the grammatical portion of the book. The only objection that suggests itself is that the extracts seem very se- rious, very little space being given to the callo- quial part of the language; but doing that per- haps would have made the ‘ French Principia * differ too widely from the books upon which it has been modelled, Besides its other advan- tages, the work is providei with an excellent index, a very full set of questions on French Composition, and a sufficient English-French vocabulary. The praise we have heretofore yiven to M. de Rougemont’s ‘ La France,’ as a truly useful text- book in schools, can only be repeated with em- phasis in view of the new edition, to which the Writers’ Publishing Co. have addei a map of France, while improving the quality of the bind ing, ete. In the series of monographs published in Paris by J. Rouam, under the title ‘‘ Les Artistes Cé- lébres” M. Champfleury’s ‘La Tour’ takes a high place by its literary quality. It is a very graceful, informal presentation of episodes in the hfeof this famous painter in pastel, rather than a consecutive biography, and is really a study of men, women, and manners in the eighteenth century. Thus we are shown La Tour's relations, as a portraitist and otherwise, with Rousseau, Diderot, Voltaire, Mme. de Pompadour, Mile. Camargo, Mile. Fel, etc. Many portraits of this group are reproduced here, and sufficiently well where acrayon effect is concerned. The copies of engravings after La Tour are inadequate except as memoranda. Incidentally, M. Champfleury, citing a letter from Rousseau to La Tour, re- marks the careless employment of avai! (avais) eight times in four lines. M. Camille Saint-Saéxs, the distinguished com poser, has just published a most interesting little pamphlet on a subject which would seem quite out of his line to any one not aware of his active interest in all the arts. This is a ‘ Note sur les décors de théfitre dans lantiquité romaine’ (Paris: L. Baschet; New York: F. W. Chris- tern). Considering the elaborate architecture of the Roman Theatre, of which that at Orange may be taken as the best known example, be shows the incongruity of the ornate and abun- dantly sculptured decoration of the proscenium for the effect of the acted drama; and he sug gests that the light and attenuate columns which appear so frequently in the Pompeian frescoes, are a decorative reminiscence of the slight wooden scaffoldings which he supposes to bave been erected inside the stone proscenium when ever a performance was give. on the stage. He supports this suggestion by a reproduction of certain frescoes, and by an apt quotation from Vitruvius. Within the past year M. Octave Uzanne, edi tor of Le Livre, has published two books of inte- rest to all book-lovers—* Nos Amis les hvres* and ‘La Reliure moderne’; and now a third is an- nounced, ‘Bouquineurs et Bouquinistes: Du Ponot-Royal au Pont-Marie—Physiologie des Quais Parisiens.' This is a monograph on the open-air book trade along the parapets of the Seine, the favorite fishing-ground of the book-hunter, as Mr. Lang has shown him to us in his graceful ballade. The book will have an etched frontispiece. and about a hundred sketches by M. Emile Mas scattered through the text. The edition will be limited (Paris: (juan- tin; New York: F. W. Christern). A new series of * Shakspere Reprints ~ (Lon- don: Whittaker & Co.), consisting of parallel texts of the First Quarto and First Folio, with variations of the later Quartos and Folios at the foot of the page, edited by Wilhelm Vietor, Ph.D., Professor in the University of Marburg, is begun with “ King Lear.” The editor repro- duces the Pied Bull Quarto from the copy known as the British Museum Perfect, but he was obliged to depend upon a friend's transcript and subsequent verification of the proof until the fac- simile of it by Pretorius was published. For the Folio likewise he relied on the facsimile, and for the readings of other texts on Furness or the Cambridge editors, The difficulty of work under such a system is the greater in this case, because only two of the six copies of this quart collated by the Cambridge editors are alike, being made up of corrected and uncorrected sheets in various combinations. A brief comparison of the prevent reprint with the quarto facsimiles and the colation in Mr. Daniel's preface shows that the editor's work is not scrupulously exact, slight errors in spelling (II], iv, IM, note Q | and in punctuation (V, iii, 41, note Q 2 variations from the typography (V, i, 19 noticeable; but these are immaterial, so far as we have observed, to the study of the text. The volume is small and handy, and the series will be very serviceable in bringing together the facts and being of the texts for convenient study We have already characterized the handsome edition of the **‘ Waverley Novels,” manufactured by the Messrs. Black in Edinburgh, with American imprint of J. B. Lippineett Co, Two more volumes, ‘The Bride of Lammermoor’ and *The Heart of Midlothian, have come to band From the same American house we have another volume tn the pocket Thackeray edition of Smuth, Eider & Co., the * Irish Sketch Book.’ A magnifying glass should be thrown in with the new edition * Nuttall’s Standard (Frederick Warne & Co thing has been sacrificed to condensation, It is illustrated. ‘The Romance of Invention ley (Cassell & Co.), is a treasury the with their refreshing typography Imo) of Dictionary * Every by James Burn of curious facts and anecdotes relating to nearly every depart tokt in an entertaining way, the monotony inseparable from sucha subject being often avoided by thi skilful grouping of topics by some remote con nection instead of the natural of aim ages, and treating of inventive cooks, hair dress ers, and toy-makers as well as the Arkwrights and Stephensons, Accounts are also given of the alchemists and the pursuers after the phantoms of perpetual motion and the eternal lamp. and ment of mechanical iadustry These are one of similarity The range is very wide, embracing all there are chapters showing ingenuity in concoct ing poisons and devising tortures and punish ments. In the chapter on ‘ Castles in the Air” we do not find a reference to the great instance in which a balloon was of practical importance, The space given to Nasmyth's love story would have been used to better purpose with an account of his steam bammer, remarkable among inven- tions from the fact that, instead of being the~re sult of long and costly experiments, it sprang, Minerva-like, full-grown and perfect from the inventor's brain. It muy be well to note, in case a second edition is reached, that the first success ful newspaper in this country was the Boston News Letter, published in 1704. The book is made useful for reference by an excellent index Not devoid of brightness, and not without some merit in respect of efforts to inculcate do mestic virtue, is a story called ‘ Forced Acquaint- ances, written for young girls by Edith Robin son (Ticknor & Co.). It is, nevertheless, a poor production, ill-balanced and tedious; too much is said of disagreeable details. too little of grave wrong-doing, while the dialogue and character drawing are unsatisfactory. Mr. Elliot Stock’s promised ‘ Book Prices Current : a Monthly Record of the Prices at which Books have been Sold at Auction,” is be fore us in the January number. It is a comely duodecimo pamphlet of sixty-four pages, am is sold only to subscribers, at £1 5s. 6d. per annum. Each title is numbered, the last here recorded being No. 1,040, while in every case the auction eer’s catalogue number is given in brackets. Un der each sale the arrangement is alphabetical, by authors if possible, and hence it is easy for col- in enabling Gambetta to escape from Paris

Page 20

The Nation. [Number 1133 lector or dealer to find the entry that interests him. If Bewick, here is the first edition of the ‘ Quadrupeds’ selling at £3 13s., and the second for £25s.; if Cruikshank, here is his ‘Comic Almanac,’ fetching £2 8s , or his ‘ Phrenological Tilustrations,’ in the original wrappers, £2 12s. ; if Dickens, here is the first edition of ‘Oliver Twist,’ original cloth, £6 17s. 6d.; if Ruskin. here is the first edition of the ‘ Stones of Venice,’ £16 5s.; if Shelley, here is the first English edi- tion of ‘The Cenci,’ £1 4s., etc, ete. Still, an index embracing all these titles under one alpha- bet would greatly enhance the convenience of using this catalogue; nor would it cost much. The second number of the Audubon Magazine (New York: Forest and Stream Publishing Co.) has for a frontispiece a process reproduction of Audubon’s plate, ‘‘ The Great Auk.” The January issue of the American Naturalist shows a marked improvement in its typographi- cal appearance, beginning with its cover. The cause is to be found in the new imprint, the maga- zine betng now published by J. B. Lippiucott Co, In Science for March 11, Prof. Mendenhall, im- proving a hint of De Morgan’s, constructs curves showing the relative use of long and short words by Dickens (* Oliver Twist’ and ‘ Christmas Carol’), Thackeray (‘ Vanity Fair ’), Mill (‘ Poli- tical Economy’ and ‘ Essay on Liberty’), Ed- ward Atkinson in sundry writings, and Cesar (‘ Commentaries’). These curves are shown to be individual enough to warrant the prosecution of the inquiry: and we commend this not unfas- civating labor to any intelligent person with sufficient leisure for it. It has its practical uses, as Prof. Mendenhall shows, and may-in time be applied to the determination of Shaksperian au- thorship. One hundred thousand words are deemed a proper basis for the characteristic curve of any given writer. Incidentally it is shown that the mean word Jength of Atkinson is 4.298 letters, of Dickens, 4 342, Thackeray, 4.481, of Mill, 4.775. Conformably to an order of the Prussian Ministry, the inaugural lectures of instructors, the discourses delivered and the books written in celebration of festal occasions, the dissertations of the graduating doctors, and various other pub- lications made by the German universities or un- der their auspices, are henceforth to be recorded in an annual list. The first Jahres-Verzeichniss of this kind has just appeared (Berlin: A. Asher & Co.). Tt covers the year from August 15, 1885, to August 14, 1886, makes an octavo of nigh 250 pages, and costs five marks. An edition on thin paper, printed on only one side, and intended for the use of all who make card-catalognes, may be had for the same price. But the knights of the scissors and paste-pot are not the only ones who will rejoice to see the importance of this new de- parture recognized by so high authority. Princeton is to have its Annex as well as Har- vard, and we rejoice to record the fact. The in- stitution will be called ‘‘ Evelyn College”; will give ‘substantially the same course of study that is pursued at Princeton College, including the lectures of the professors, with examinations upon them ”; ‘*‘ will have no sectarian character,” nor “ will anything of the nature of co-education be represented in it.” The building is all ready, comfortably and even luxuriously fitted up, and the first term will open on September 28, 1887. A preparatory department is provided. Elective studies, except in the case of Greek, are confined to the Junior and Senior years. Application for information should be made to the Rev. J. H. Mclivaine, D.D., President. The Harvard Summer School of Geology will open its sixth session at Cambridge on July 6, at the Museum of Comparative Zodlogy, under the direction of Profs. Shaler and Davis. A fortnight , spent there in introductory work and short daily excursions will be followed during the next four weeks by excursions to the Connecticut Valley, the Hoosac Valley and vicinity, and the foot-hills of the Catskills. ‘‘ Advanced knowledge of ge- ology will rot be required, but only teachers, graduates of colleges, or persons of maturity and some training, can be admitted ”—and men only. Applications should be made to Mr. T. W. Harris, Divinity Hall, Cambridge, Mass., not later than June 1. The expenses, including tuition, are cal- culated not to exceed $120. Pach Brothers, 841 Broadway, send us a large photographic group showing the staff officers of the Thirteenth New York Regiment, with Mr. Beecher in chaplain’s costume—cross on hat, and sword in hand—for the chief figure. ‘Tastes will differ as to the costume and the character in which his admirers will prefer to remember the great preacher who has just leftus. Ifthe choice were left to Count Leo Tolstoi, we may be sure he would care little for the unique ‘ portrait in uniform ” now before us, good (and appropriate- ly grim) as it is. —Prof. C. C. Everett’s article upon “ The Poems of Emerson,” in the current Andover Re- view, is not written from the literary point of view, and is the more interesting on that ac- count. Whether he agrees with Arnold’s dictum that the ‘ Essays’ are ‘‘ the most important work done in prose” in this present century, is not plain, but, after quoting it, he adds that, in his opinion, the ‘‘ Poems” are ‘‘the most complete and worthy expression” of Emerson's genius. He is himself most at home in philosophy and ethics, and he certainly does not overrate Emer- son’s work in these departments; his analysis of it leaves a meagre residuum, and he concludes that ‘‘ obviously this, so far as it can be called a philosophy, is the philosophy of a poet,” and, secondly, that ‘‘ as his philosophy is the phi- losophy of a poet, so his ethics is the ethics of a poes.” It would appear that Prof. Everett thinks that “ a poet’s ” philosophy and ethics have some privileges not shared by the ordinary scholar ; but one can only admire the polemical art which utilizes so serious a reservation for a greater praise. Coming to the poems, the writer finds the usual qualities in them, but he states some of them in a way to provoke challenge. ‘‘ The notion that the poems of Emerson lack passion is as wide of the mark as the complaint that they are abstract,” is a remark that at first seems sub- versive of our old ideas, in both its assertions. Here the temper and the training of the critic count very strongly. He frankly acknowledges that he speaks of Emerson’s obscurity ratber “from hearsay than from very much personal experience” ; but to pass the point of ‘‘ abstract- ness,” and come to that of ‘ passion,” it is clear that Prof Everett has a very different meaning in mind from the usual sense of the word, when we read that in many of Emerson’s poems “there is another, if not a higher, passion than the person- al” Emerson, he immediately adds, had a pas- sion for Beauty and for the Ideal ; but is this anything more than saying that ke was suscep- tible of intellectual exaltation? Lt is not this quality that is denied to him when he is said to lack passion. Here, as in the question of obscu- rity, Prof. Everett seems to us to be executing a not very successful flank movement. Another startling remark is that in which he speaks of Emerson’s poetry as ‘‘ the voice of a spirit all the more confident in its optimism because it had been bold enough to gaze down into the darkest chasms of life.” Was Emerson’s knowledge of evil so profound ? Thus one finds matter for con- troversy ; but the paper is one which will be read with great interest, and is of higher critical value than any late contribution to the reviews, —M. Francisque Sarcey, in a short series of articles in the République Francaise, has again brought up the much debated question of the im- portance of the French patois. He very justly remarks that a number of French words now fallen into desuetude, but still preserved in the lo- cal dialects, should be restored to the literary lan- guage. Such are aveindre, quérir, and the short and expressive form c’étant, which has been re- placed by puisqw’il en est ainsi. But M. Sarcey does not stop there. He could wish the patois to be less rigorously excluded from the primary schools—that teachers in the south of France, for instance, should be allowed to use Provencal in the class-room. Thereupon his friend, M. J.-J. Weiss, writes to him from his retirement at Fon- tainebleau, that he has raised rather ‘a political than a pedagogical question.” Later, a writer in the Temps raises the cry against the *‘ Félibres” and all those who are aiming to establish a second national language in France. He sees, in the writing of Provencal poetry like that of Mistral or Aubanel, only *‘un divertissement de manda- rin,” which will always remain inaccessible to the people at large. But in the claims made by those who wish to rehabilitate the dialects of their native province he sees a serious, a dangerous tendency, which, if it could ever reach the point aimed at, would endanger the political unity of France. It may be noted that a first step has al- ready been taken. Telegrams can now be sent officially in Provencal and Breton as well as in French. — Professor Gneist contributes to the Febru- ary ani March numbers of the Deutsche Revue a sort of epilogue to his Constitutional History, in the shape of an article on the change wrought in the English Constitution by the legislation of the last fifty years, and by the attempts to wreck it in bebalf of Irish autonomy. Prof. Gneist’s opinions deserve respect, not only because he is probably the most thorough student of this sub- ject of the century, but because, for a German and a professor, he is a remarkably “‘ practical” politician, having served without interruption in the Prussian Parliament since 1859, and in the German since 1871. English institutions, he says, are in a state of solution, and cannot regain the cohesiveness in which lay their strength until the Irish element is gotten rid of. But even if the conservative classes (using the word ina social rather than a political sense) understand this, they may well hesitate to apply the remedy, for its adoption involves, by force of example, a complete reconstruction of the society of Great Britain. The Irish land bills, past and future, cannot, he says, be fitly compared with the Stein and Hardenberg legislation in behalf of the Prus- sian peasants, because these had for several gene- rations been paying the taxes and performing the military service in exchange for which the land was held by the dispossessed holders. The estates in question, that is to say, were held of the Gov- ernment by a feudal tenure ; and as the feudal obligations, translated into modern civic duties, fell on the shoulders of the peasants, they had almost a legal claim to a share in the land. But in [reland, according to Prof. Gneist, the pea- sants have no such claim ; so that the property of the landlords is in part to be confiscated solely from expediency, on political and economical grounds. As there can be no limits to legisla- tion dictated solely by expediency, the social- istic greed thus awakened will surely, he thinks, extend to the countries across the Channel. The difference between English institutions and the Continental arrangements more or less modelled on them lay in the fact that the former—Church and Parliament, local and na- tional administrations—were inextricably inter- twined, while the latter were created ‘each to

Page 21

March 17, 1887] stand on its own bottom. But while, in a society so constituted, each member is a support to the others so long as itself is in a healthy state, it isa corresponding source of weakness when this con- dition is changed. The machinery of the Consti- tution, which formerly worked so smoothly, has gradually been getting out of gear ever since the first Reform Bill, owing to the enormous in- crease in wealth and numbers of the industrial middle class, for whose assimilation the old sys tem did not provide. But it is possible, Prof. Gneist thinks, when a perpetually foreign ele- ment like the Irish is removed, to maintain the parliamentary form along with complete social reconstruction, although the aristocratic class is likely to become irreconcilable, as in France. As to Ireland, there is not much home rule in the scheme of autonomy which the Professor thinks the only practicable one ‘‘ in view of the want of self-control of the Irish, as shown in the United States.” He proposes a legislature in which the majority shall be nominated by the Crown; the local administration, modelled on the French, to consist of prefects assisted by elective councils, service in which may, in time, give the people the political understanding and experience essen- tial to the successful working of the principle of self-government, —‘Aus dem deutschen Universititsleben des sechzehnten Jahrhunderts’ is the title of one of the most recent numbers of the ‘* Frankfurter zeitgemiisse Brochiiren” (Neue Folge, Band vii, Heft 12. Frankfurt am Main: Foesser, pp. 31). The author is the celebrated Ultramontane his- torian, Johannes Janssen, whose ‘ Geschichte des deutschen Volkes seit dem Ausgang des Mictelal- ters’ has elicited so much discussion in Germany, The monograph consists of interesting extracts from a wide range of authorities, showing thet immediately after the Reformation the German universities degenerated, and that in the second half of the sixteenth century they were the seats of sloth, drunkenness, murder, and many other abominations. ‘‘ The ecclesiastical revolution of the sixteenth century,” says the author in his preamble, ‘‘ which loosened all the old bonds of discipline and order, also exerted a very para- lvzing and pernicious influence upon the intellec- tual life and the institutions of learning.” Lu- ther himself asserted that ‘‘the universities de- serve to be crushed to powder; nothing more hellish and devilish has appeared on earth since the beginning of the world” (p. 2). Melanchthon wrote in 1521 that ‘‘ nothing had ever been in- vented more baneful and godless than the uni- versities; not the Popes, but the devil himself was their founder” (p. 2). In 1614 the students of Wittenberg were ordered to discontinue the practice of drinking beer in the *‘ Auditorum”™ during the lectures (p. 10). A student of Basel stated in 1587 that either the professors were re- miss enough to lecture very seldom, or they taught without method, mixing up heaven and earth (p. 12). ‘‘The name learned,” says Prof. Hofmann in 1578, ‘‘is almost detested by high and low” (p. 13). ‘‘The conduct of the students was so unseemly,” writes another authority in 1557, ‘‘that the glistening tears often fell from Melanchthon’s eyes during his lectures. and be frequently said that the unbounded license of the young men was a sign that the end of the world was near at hand” (p. 19). Some of the state- ments which Jaussen cites in support of his posi- tion are, in all probability, exaggerated; for ex- ample, the assertivn on page 26 that in the year 1540, within six months, four hundred persons drank themselves to death at Wittenberg. Doubt- less, too, other elements besides the Reformation helped to bring about the decadence of the Ger- man universities. But the author’s general ac- count of the shocking condition of the latter dur- ” The Nation. ing the sixteenth century may be accepted as correct, — Mr. Welldon’s translation of Aristotle's ‘ Rhe- toric’ (Macmillan) is careful and reasonably smooth and idiomatic, but the translator's admi- ration of the original has led bim into strange state- ments. We will not question what he savs about the neglect of rhetoric as an educational instru ment in England; only we would guard against the inference that Aristotle's work has been undu- ly neglected, except so far as every editor, every translator, thinks that his bright particular au- thor is a slighted wall-flower. But it is going too far tosay,as Mr. Welldon does, that the art of rhetoric was the creation of Aristotle, and that “‘whatever has been best in it from this time to the present is due to him.” Aristotle cannot be called the creator of rhetoric, and, instead of be- ing a brilliant success as a teacher of the art, he was a conspicuous failure in comparison with Isocrates, who, in other respects, is not to be named in the same breath with him ; and, pro- found and valuable as is the basis on whica he has reared the structure of his‘ Rhetoric, bis trea tise had little practical worth in the eyes of his successors, who were far from being his equals in intellectual grasp, but who had the great merit of not being above their business. Mr. Welldon thinks that the fiell of rhetoric was amplified in a direction which Aristotle had de- liberately left alone. This, again, is claiming far too much. The later rhetoricians cannot be ignored by the student of literature except at his peril, as has been amply shown by Volkmann and by Blass. In fact, modern wsthetic criticism has much to learn from these despised rhetoricians, who give us system where the modern critic gives only hints. The third book of the * Rheto ric’ seems to be accepted by Mr. Welldon unre- servedly as Aristotelian, but he does not note that. if it is by Aristotle, it is a singular tribute to Aristotle’s rival, Isocrates, to whom the phi- losopher is obliged to resort for illustrations of some of his points. In his rendering of this book, by the way, Mr. Welldon has not been invari- ably felicitous. So the famous cipouery he trans- lates, after Mure, ‘jointed,’ an absurdity from which he might have been warned off by Mr. Cope. who suggests ‘disjointed,’ which is cer- tainly much nearer the mark. The refusta versio has the droll word consuspensa, and the other La- tin versions try tracta, fusa, and what not. Mast scholars prefer to keep the non-committal Greek, but surely the meaning is plain enough. The Aekis_ eipouevyn is the ‘strung style,’ the ‘all-in-a row style,’ the * chaplet,’ the ‘ rosary’ style ; the words being held together by the conjunction as the beads are held together by the knot of the string. In this rosary style the conjunctions are represented by the larger beads, and such a dis- course could go on for ever, whereas the periodic style carries the end in itself. — The thirty-six-inch lenses for the great tele- scope of the Lick Observatory, whose coustruc tion has been some five years cMayed through the impossibility of obtaining the necessary glass, were completed at the workshops of the Clarks in Cambridgeport last autumn, and have been successfully transported across the Continent and finally deposited in the vaults of the Lick Ob- servatory on Mount Hamilton. The matter of transportation was one of the greatest moment to the trustees, as any mishap to the lenses would defeat their expectation of completing the ob- servatory and its equipment during the present year in such shape that it could be finally banded over to the Regents of the State Univer-ity of California. Mr. Fraser, the superintendent of construction of the observatory, made a special journey to the East for the express purpose of carrying out the lenses, and the manner in which 233 they were prepsred for this journey is well cde scribed in a late number of the Sidereal Messen They were wrapped separately in fifteen or Next came a thick laver of cotton and then a laver of paper. The glasses were then put into boxes of wood, lined with felt. the lenses, and the boxes were made the shape of ger. twenty thicknesses of soft cotton cloth No nails were used pear These boxes were enclosed in tw: others of each pearly cubical in form and packed tightly with curled hair, Each box was enclosed in another steel box, the inner the glasses. steel, steel sides of which were covered with spiral springs Both steel boxes were made aur-tight and water proof, and the outer chests packed with asbestos to render them fire-proof, pended by pivots in strong wooden frames, with Each was then sus contrivances for turning each chest one juarter way round every day during the journey to California, This was to prevent any molecular dis arrangement in the glasses and to avotd the danger of p larization, it being feared that the jarring of the train would disturb the present arrangement of the molecules, unless the position of the glass should be changed and all lines of disturbance thus broken up. The trustees have placed the separate contracts for the other por tions of this great telescope with manufacturers who have so far met with special success in the particular class of work involved, all the me chanical parts of the telescope (or mounting, asit is technically called) being made at Cleve land, by Messrs, Warner & Swasey, the micro meter or measuring apparatus by Fauth & Cot pany of Washington, and the which, like the telescope, is to be the most power ful in existence—by Mr ed a long and able apprenticeship uoder Prof Langlet at Allegheny trustees finally decided not to adopt the new pat apectrusc 4™ Brashear, who bas serv For obvious reasons, the tern of spherical dome which bas very generally the great telescope on Mount Haaoniton, but placed the contract fora dome of the ordinary pattern and nearly eighty feet in diameter with the Union Iron Works at San Francisco. Of the $700,000 of the original bequest made by Mr. Lick eleven vears ago, his trustees have already expended all bat $190,000, and they now contemplate assem bling together all the separate parts of the great telescope (which itself with accessories has cost nearly &200,000) at some time during the coming summer or autumn, when ther control of the in stitution will cease. been described as that which would cover GARDINER'S GREAT CIVIL WAR. History of the Great Ciril War, 1642-1049. By Samuel R. Gardiner, M.A., LL.D. Fellow of All Souls, ete.. ete. Vol. i, 1642-1644. don: Longmans, Green & Co. 1886, Lon- ‘Tue Civil War, the outbreak of which was an nounced by the floating of Charles’s standard on the hill at Nottingham, was rendered mevitable by the inadequacy of the intellectual methods of the day to effect a reconciliahon between oppos- ing moral and social forces, which derived their strength from the past development of the na- thon. The personal characters of the leaders might do much to shorten or prolong the time of . open warfare, but no permanent restoration of harmony would be possible till some compromise which would give security alike to the disciples of Hooker and to the disciples of Calvin, had been not only thought out by the few, but gene- rally accepted by the many.” This is the opening paragraph of Mr. Garidi- ner’s new volume. The words of it deserve care- ful attention. They strike the keynote to all that follows; they sum up the great merits and ind1- cate the possible deficiencies of the mode in which Mr. Gardiner looks at history. He is essentially a student of ideas. The true subject of all bis writings is not events, and the visible transactions which make up the matter of

Page 22

234 The Nation. [Number 1133 historical composition, but rather the spirit, the notions, the beliefs, the opinions, or (to speak generally) the ideas, which, as they ultimately govern human action, give its form to the pro- gress of mankind. The special belief which, throughout every volume of his invaluable work, Mr. Gardiner keeps before his eyes, is the belief, developed so slowly and opposed by so many ob- stacles, in religious toleration—or, rather, in that respect for the human conscience, and for the truths discovered by the light of conscience and of intellect, which forms the real basis of enlight- ened toleration. So truly is Mr. Gardiner con- cerned with the progress of opinion that it were, from one point of view, no untrue description of his history to say that it was an account of the steps by which the doctrine of toleration was first worked out by thinkers, and then acquiesced in by the judgment of the nation. But though Mr. Gardiner’s interest may be truly said to lie in what, borrowing a term from theology, we may call the growth of political dogma, he is distinguished from writers who trace the evolution of particular beliefs, by his in- tense interest in actual men and women, and by the tenacity with which he clings to the convic- tion that (if the acti_ns of mankind are in a sense governed by their ideas) dogmas and opinions, in so far as they are influential at ali, can only ex- ist in the minds and hearts of living human be- ings, who themselves are swayed by all the feel- ings, base or noble, which we see governing the society in which we live. It is this balance be tween the abstract and the concrete view of his- tory which gives to Mr. Gardiner’s writings their peculiar power, and also their very peculiar charm. He knows that ‘‘ the inadequacy of the intellectual methods of the day” was ina very true sense the cause of the civil war. But he also knows, and never lets his readers forget, that the ideas, good and bad, of the seventeenth century produced very different results on dif- ferent characters. Charles and Cromwell, Falk- land and Pym, Bunyan and Chillingworth, were no doubt each and all influenced by the concep- tions of their time. But the results of this in- fluence were in each case very different; and for any profound understanding of the age in which these men moved you must, as Mr. Gardiner never forgets, pay at least as much attention to the personal peculiarities of the actors who play- ed their parts in it, as to the general ideas which gave the direction to each man’s individual ac- tion. Thus, to take one example among a score, when Mr. Gardiner wishes to make us under- stand the various fcrces which led men of very different types to rally round the Crown, he does not present us with a number of abstract reflec- tions as to the different reasons which might be adduced in favor of the Royal cause, but takes two or three men, such as Rupert, Lindsey, Falkland, and Waller, and tells us, as far as our knowledge, or rather our ignorance, al- lows, what were the motives which in fact de- termined the course adopted by each of these eminent persons. To know the reasons of their action is to understand why thousands of other less well-known Englishmen found themselves— sometimes to their great surprise—arrayed in arms for the King and against the Parliament. This mode of treating a great historical crisis has two great advantages : it gives the historian him- self a kind of intellectual impartiality ard calm- ness which is the rarest, if not the very greatest, of the gifts required by any one who is to unen- tangle the confused threads of great historical transactions ; it impresses, again, on the reader, with a force which cannot be attained by any mere general statements, that the contest be- tween the King and the Pariiament—and the same thing is in @ measure true, it may,be sup- , posed, of every great struggle—was a battle in which good men and wise men, as well as wicked men and fools, were pretty equally divided on each side. The simple truth is, that the crisis was one of great difficulty. Looking back on the great civil war from the distance of more than two centuries, it is, we conceive, possible to say that on the whole the supporters of the Parlia- ment were in the right. They acted with more wisdom than their opponents, mainly because they had perceived one fact which was hidden from the eyes of the wisest Royalists. This was the untrustworthiness of Charles. Time has pro- duced many worse men than Charles I.: he was morally a far better man than his father or his sons ; but history has produced no man less trust- worthy. The sagacity of James L., the selfish common sense of Charles II., the dull obstinacy of James II1., gave adherents some characteristic on which they could rely. On Charies I. no man ever placed reliance without. suffering for his folly. But though this vital fact was, when once perceived, decisive in favor of supporting the cause of the Parliament, no one can wonder that many good and sagacious men did not see the fatal flaws in Charles’s character. Still less can one wonder that men who associated in their minds the supremacy of the law, the reign of order, and the very existence of national free- dom, with the authority of the Crown, should have trembled at plunging into a civil war which, if the King triumphed, was likely to pro- duce royal despotism, and if the Parliament tri- umphed, either anarchy or the supremacy of a military tyrant. Never was there a case where men of sense might more reasonably differ, and never was there a case where men of goodness might each think, with more show of reason, that their side was the side of virtue. If Mr. Gardiner had rendered no further ser- vice to our knowledge of the past than to make us not only know but see why it was that the best men of England were at the time of the great civil war ranged on different sides against each other, he would deserve the thanks of all students. But our author has, from the way in which he looks at history, and the infinite industry with which he has worked out his own conception of impartial narration, done far more than merely make us understand in a general way the state of feeling in England from 1642 to 1644. He has, as we are informed by persons competent to judge, provided for the first time a detailed and intelligible account of the military events which make those years famous in the annals of war- fare. He has described with the utmost accura- cy the fluctuations of feeling which marked the early years of the civil contest—the intense yearning for peace, which unfortunately itself tended to prolong the war, the anticipation that the war would be of short duration, and that the Parliament might count on a speedy triumph; the disappointment which engued when this anti- cipation was found to be groundless. The great- est, however, of the benefits which Mr. Gardiner has conferred upon every lover of truth is the new light which he has thrown upon the growth of the complicated body of beliefs designated by the name ‘liberty of conscience.” He shows that the doctrine now so universally recognized, that a man for his beliefs, as contrasted with his acts, is responsible to his conscience and to God alone, was a truth which, at the beginning of the seventeenth century, not one man in 10,000 could even dimly perceive; that it gained acceptance rather from the force of practical considerations than through the strength of argument, though the theory of the relation of the citizen towards the state and towards God, which ultimately solved the most pressing problems of tho age, was occasionally worked out, with more or less completeness,{by solitary thinkers Jong before it commanded the allegiance of practical statesmen. Fuller, Chillingworth, Roger Williams each par- tially seized the clue which was to guide men out of the mazes in which they were involved by the traditional notion that the magistrate was bound to inculcate theolegical truth by use of physical power. That this was so is probably in a vague manner known to most of those likely to read Mr. Gardiner’s pages. What he will make clear to many for the first time, is, first, the singular fact that the author of an anonymous tract—an author whose name cannot even now be plausi- bly conjectured—anticipated in 1644 the doctrines of Locke and carried them out with more consis- tency than the author of the celebrated ‘‘ Letters on Toleration”; and, further, that statesmen who would in words have condemned the doc- trine of toleration as a heresy, came (in England, at least), as the seventeenth century advanced, to perceive that civil lhberty, social order, and the progressive development of society demanded that kings and magistrates should tolerate many beliefs which they did not share. The historical importance of tracing out the spread, during the seventeenth century, of opin- ions and practices favoring liberty of conscience can hardly be overrated. It bridges over, or in reality abolishes, the chasm which teachers of a certain school wish to open between the men of the seventeenth and the men of the eighteenth century. The great civil war was, according to a view openly proclaimed by Carlyle and tacitly adopted by many other writers, a contest of he- roes. The Revolution of 1689 was, according to the same authorities, little better than a transac- tion carried out by politicians whose statesman- ship lacked every noble and heroic quality. Any one, however, who realizes that toleration was the need of the age, sees at once that the Revo- lution of 1689 in reality solved the problem whi¢h had baffled the statesmen and soldiers of the great civil war; and that the essential work of the eighteenth century was to give practical ef- fect to ileas which had only been dimly grasped by the best and greatest men of the seventeenth century. The inadequacy of the intellectual me- thods of the day gave occasion to the civil war. The improved intellectual methods of the next age produced in England a period of reconcilha- tion, peace, and progress, That this is one of the lessons that Mr. Gardiner’s ‘ History of the Civil War’ will impress upon the world is, in our judgment, past a doubt. It is taught all the more impressively because Mr. Gardiner comes forward bona-fide as an investigator and not as a preacher. Never, it may be added, was teach- ing more needed. The civilized world of Europe is again becoming involved in practical difficul- ties which have their ultimate source in the con- fusion and uncertainty of prevailing opinions. Wise men who study the annals of the past, will feel inclined to watch and see whether improved intellectual methods, or the recognition of some new or forgotten truth, may not close the con- tests of the nineteenth century, just as the doc- trine of religious toleration terminated in Eng- land the feuds which culminated in the great civil war. Mr. Gardiner is so eminent among historical in- quirers that his most fervent admirers, among whom we are glad to number ourselves, need not hesitate to acknowledge that he has, like all men of superior powers, some of the defects al- most involved in his great qualities. The sen- tences with which this article begins suggest what these defects are. He is, like all persons who delight in dwelling on the influence of ideas, a little too prone to underrate—at least, soit may seem to acareful student—the immense influence of personal character. We believe it to be abso- lutely and entirely true that no complete recon: ciliation betweenJopposing moral and social

Page 23

March 17, 1887] forces could, during the first half of the seven- teenth century, have been effected by the power or sagacity of kings or of statesmen. Nothing but the increase of knowledge, and the conse quent growth of new beliefs, could by any possi- bility have put an end to the political and theo- logical animosities which found their ultimate expression in the contest of rival armies. But it seems by no means clear that the presence on the throne of a monarch different in character from Charles might not have prevented the outbreak of a civil war. Speculations, indeed, on what ‘might have been” are necessarily in one sense futile, but they are sometimes useful as enabling us to measure, hypothetically at least, how far a slight change of circumstances might have af- fected a given course of events. The assertion that Charles’s character, and especially his un- trustworthiness and his stupidity, had a great deal to do with turning latent discord into open civil war, admits of something very like proof. James I. was not a man of heroic mould. He was morally—and, it is probable, physically—a coward ; but he was a man of natural sagacity, and his prudence, contemptible as were often the forms in which it exhibited itself, did enable him to keep on the throne, and in some degree to in- crease the royal power, without bringing the nation even to the verge of civil war. If Charles had been gifted with his father’s shrewdness, there is no reason to suppose that he might not have ended his life as peaceably as did James. It is, again, perfectly clear that the sentiment of loyalty to the Crown was, during the whole of Charles’s reign, a source of power which would have enabled any king of average ability not only to resist assailants, but probably to strength- en his own position. Wedo not for a moment suppose that Mr. Gardiner would dispute this ; but if we concede that a monarch of no very ex- traordinary talent could have averted or post- poned civil war, we in effect grant that the pecu- liarities of Charles’s nature had at least as much to do with changing a Parliamentary conflict into an armed rebellion as had the inadequacy of the intellectual methods of the day. ANCIENT ISRAEL.—II. Geschichte des Volkes Israel. Von Dr. Bernhard Stade, Professor an der Universitit Giessen. Mit Illustrationen und Karten, Vol. [. Berlin 1887. New York: Westermann. [* Oncken’s Weltgeschichte in Einzeldarstellungen.’| THE legends of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, our author emphatically asserts, embody no histori- cal facts. They were local legends, separately clusterinz around sanctuaries of the ancient Ca- naanitish inhabitants of Palestine: the sanctuary of Hebron, the sacred well of Beer-sheba, and the sacred stone of Bethel. These spots were sa- cred before the arrival of the Israelites in the land. With the changes of the religious notions of the dwellers around, the character of the le- gends varied; they were modified and remodi- fied, The Israelites—this appears almost certain —did not dwell under patriarchs in Palestine west of the Jordan, before their settlement in the lands east of that river. That they migrated in to Egypt is equally improbable. Joseph is a Pa- lestinian heros eponymus, the legendary repre- sentative of a tribe; his transformation into a ruler of Egypt is a work of late fiction. Even the poetical fancy which made the Israelites enter the Nile land as a family and leave it as a nation, left allthe intervening time an absolute blank: the monuments know nothing whatever of the whole affair. Searching, as some Egvptologists still do, for the Pharoah of the oppression or the traces of the exodus, is a childish amusement: no- thing is to be discovered in Egypt in reference to The Nation. Israelitish history. The Israelites possessed no distinct and positive historical recollections reaching back beyond the time of the settlement in western Palestive. All that was earlier recol lection centred dimly in the two names Moses and Sinai. Moses had taught them at Sinai to wor ship Jehovah. This worship bad made them a people distinguishable from other members of the Hebrew race, such as the Moabites, Am- monites, and Edomites. The Hebrew race was kindred to the Arabs on the one side and to the Aramezans on the other. Closely akin to Israel were the Canaanites west of the Jordan and the Lebanon, including the Pheenivians. The Israelites were descended nei- ther from a Shem nor from an Eber. They were called Hebrews (‘ibrim) by their western Canaan- itish neigbbors, as dwellers beyond (‘éber) the Jor- dan—not the Euphrates, as former explanations had it. They called themselves sons of Shem when they had become masters of the iand west of the Jordan, as the nobles of the land (shém meaning name, glory, or distinction). They ap- pear to have been originally a clan established east of the Jordan, on both sides of the Jabbok. Their heros eponymus was Israel, the legend of whom was subsequently blended, west of the Jordan, with the legend of Jacob, the seat of which was Bethel. The name of the clan wasex- tended to others confederated with it, in the same way in which the appellations Latins, Alemanni, and Teutons have gained their widely comprehen sive significations. The Hebrew clans which in later times constituted the nation of Israel, came into the Transjordanic region mainly from the Sinaitic peninsula; some immigration may possi- bly have taken place from regions bordering on the Euphrates, whence the legend of Abraham derives the wholerace. As nomadsof the penin- sula they lived in peaceful relations with the prob- ably Arabic tribe of the Kenites, and from them —who were perhaps allies of the Midianites they seem to have received through Moses the religion of Jehovah. It was not the religion of their ancestors, but entirely new to them A slow migration carried them into Gilead and the adjoining districts, the Judaic clan alone proba bly wandering northward, with the Kenites and the Arabic Calebites, into the region west of the Dead Sea. When these migrations took place, and how long they lasted, it is impossible to tell. In Gilead the nomads, hemmed in between the Jordan and the desert, by the kindred Moabites and Ammonites on the south, and by Aramaic tribes on the north, gradually turned tillers of the sol, built cities—Mahanaim, Succoth, Ja besh, Penuel, etc.—and grew too populous for their territory. The stories of the conquest and distribution of the country by Moses, of the Am- orite Sihon, of Balak, and Balaam are fictions As the Midianites and Amalekites did in later times, the Israelites, in their nomadic state, must have made frequent plundering incursions into Western Palestine, the many fords of the upper Jordan offering easy opportuoities for crossing Peaceable transmigrations came afterward, the Israelites wedging themselves in between Ca- naanitish settlements, steadily gaining ground, and gradually absorbing the neighboring popula- tion. The whole bistory, in its more authentic features, clearly shows that there was no sudden conquest or invasion, no extermination of the na tives, no deadly feud between them and the Is raelites. The Hebrews, or Transjordanians. lived mostly in peace with the kindred Canaan- ites during the time which is generally, though erroneously, designated as the period of the judges—that is, before the union of all the tribes was effected under the monarchy. The figure of the great conqueror, Joshua, as we have seen, is the production of a late age. That no general conquest took place, and consequently no division of the conquered country, is shown by the ear lier relation in the first chapter of Judges, ac cording to which the separate tribes attempted separate conquests. That chapter, now falsely attached, as a coutinuation, to the book of Joshua dy the words ‘“‘ After the death of evidently an extract from an extensive narrative running parallel with that book and refuting it which may have begun with ‘ After the death of Moses * or Joshua,” is ‘After the crossing of the Jordan.’ The warlike exploits spoken of in the earlier rela- tion are. however, also far from being contem poraneous or authentic history. No such exploits, no such simultaneous movements, ever took place. The Canaanites generally held their cities plains, and valleys, and here and there also a plateau or mountain; the Israelites mostly occu pied first the intervening forest lands, which they cleared. Their peaceful advance did not exclude exceptional conquests with the sword sudden inroads from beyond the Jordan prises and sacks. But these rarely effected per immanent results. A part of the tribe of Dan suc ceeded in capturing an isolated town, Laish, in the extreme north, and establishing themselves sur there; Levi and Simeon treacherously surprised ° the Bene-Hamor of Shechem, but were driver away and scattered the Canaanites, and Israel, instead of helping, execrated their treach ery. Israel was the first Transjordanic Hebrew clan which gained possessions west of the river. Clan after clan followed. Living among the Canaan ites, they partly blended with them riages prevailed. The sacred places of Canaan became sanctuaries of Israel, In all other mat ters of culture the Israelites learned from cities of Capaan; in the worship of Jehovah they remained faithful to their own traditions and customs. Inferior in the arts of industry, they were superior to their neighbors in religious con ceptions and ethical spirit. This superiority de cided the product of international blending in The Israclitish element began to predominate. Moral leadership led to material rule. The rural first: the towns much later, partly by Israelitish intrusion and peaceful commingling, and partly by treaty by Intermar favor of Israel districts were won and conquest, Severe contests for possession and sharpened religious antagonism finally created permanent animosities, and the Israelite looked down upon the Canaanite as vile and fit only to be a serf to the Sons of Shem. And yet many an Israelitish gens had more Canaanitish blood in it than Shemitas. The absorption of much of the native element so strengthened some of the clans, especially those which obtained much clearable land, that they grew into separate tribes. A regular division of the people into twelve tribes The country was never Israelites however, never existed distributed, nor did the the whole of it The warlike tribe of Gad was powerful in the land east of the Jordan, and, west of the river, in the earliest times, the central tribe of Joseph. The latter, after extending its possessions in a southerly direction, was divided into Benjamin, Manasseh, and Ephraim. The tribe of Judah, in the south, arose muh later, forming itself out of Israelitish, Edomitish, Canaanitish, and Arabic elements. Enveloped by it were the remnants of Simeon, which, after the discomfiture at She- chem, never rose tothe dignity of atribe. The dispersion of Levi was more complete still, but its boasting of Moses as its member united its families into a kind of a priestly caste, to whom the managing of the sanctuaries was generally intrusted, The priesthood was not derived origi- nally from Aaron, who is unknown to the earlier traditions, but from Moses, whose descendants we find figuring as priests at the northern sanc- tuary of the Danites, Reuben never had any po- ever possess the! “

Page 24

236 The Nation. [Number 1133 litical significance, almost disappearing between Gad and the powerful state of Moab, its constant enemy. Issachar, Zebulun, Naphtali, and Asher, in the north, formed a group of tribes living in small clans, closely surrounded by the Canaan- itish natives, whom they were unable to assimi- late or to conquer. At one time only (during the struggle with Sisera) Zebulun and Naphtali ap- pear conspicuous in I[sraelitish history; Issachar and Asher never acted a noticeable part in it. That portion of Dan which remained between Judah and the Philistines was almost as power- less as Reuben between Gad and Moab. The ex- termination of the tribe of Benjamin is unhis- torical. The chronology of the pre-monarchical times is a systematic creation of late redactors, and entirely valueless. The first attempt at founding a royalty more comprehensive than clan chiefship was made by the houss of Jerub- baal in Manasseh. It proved a failure, though based on Gideon’s deserts as deliverer from Mi- dian. The greater merits of Saul as deliverer from a more general and more lasting oppression led to the establishment of the Benjamit: throne, and to the union of the tribes, Samuel—who, like Eli, was a priest, and not a judge—promoted, instead of opposing, this transition from tribal anarchy to monarchical unity. With it real Is- raelitish history begins. We have made no attempt to acquaint our readers with any of the critical processes which have led to the construction of the foregoing scheme of the earliest history of Israel. Those familiar to a degree with Biblical inquiry in its recent stages, even if as yet ignorant of the ad- vances made on the basis of the Graf and Kue- nen theory, which has completely changed the relative value of the main Old-Testament narra- tives, will neither be surprised by the results stated nor ask for explanations, which must needs transcend the bounds of a review in a journal like this, Readers who know only their Bible and apologetic commentaries, and perhaps an apologetic Bible dictionary, will, we have no doubt, be amazed at statements so often flagrant- ly at variance with the best-remembered texts of the Scriptures, and not a little inclined to attri- bute some of the assertions to defective know- ledge, wrong judgment, or evil propensity on the part of the critical innovators, Such suspicions we are unable to disarm here by evidences to the contrary, but we owe our general] public the as- surance that the work itself completely refutes them. Never has the minute examination and dissection of historical tradition been carried out with more painstaking earnestness, sounder know- ledge, and greater freedom from religious or anti- religious prepossessions, than in the histories of Wellhausen and Stade. In the work of the latter author, which iu its analysis of the traditional accounts is firmly grounded on the writings of the former, the destructive analytical labor is so convincingly justified by intrinsic evidence from the respective texts—the Hebrew as well as the Greek of the Septuagint—that only he who shuts his eyes to all evidence conflicting with cherished notions can gainsay it. Of course, we are far from saying that no point of detail can be con- tested. The constructive labor of the author, in which more originality is evinced, is naturally based in part on conjecture, and his conjectural facts are, we confe:s, often propounded with too much positiveness. It is, perhaps, owing to the frequency of instances in which hypothesis must do duty for knowledge—a frequency demanding a reiteration of acknowledged doubt too tedious to carry out—that much appears presented with an assurance not warranted by the saved rem- nant of dissected tradition. The plausibility of the facts or conditions constructively elicited here from a mass of conflicting testimony is gene- rally very strong, though a most pldusible guess but too often proves a mistaken guess when veri- fication is possible. Recollections of a Private Soldier in the Army of the Potomac. By Frank Wilkeson. G. P. Putnam’s Sons. 1887. THE author of this book thinks that the generals have had too much to say in regard to the histo- ry of the war, and that it is high time the pri- vates nad their turn. His contribution will cer- tainly be welcomed, for it is a vivid picture— perhaps a little too bloody and harrowing, but none the less realistic—of the life of the private soldier, upon whom fell, as in all wars they must fall, the greater portion of the hardships, suffer- ing, fatigue, hunger, cold, and death, which are inseparable from war, and which, in the accounts of strategic movements arid brilliant charges, are apt to be overlooked. As a contribution to history, books like this are only valuable in so far as they recall the intense savagery, the re- lapse into cold-blooded barbarism, which is the accompaniment of war, and again as they de- scribe the morale of the rank and file of a par- ticular army at a stated time. Further than this, of course, the recollections and opinions of a private soldier, with his necessarily circum- scribed vision, have no historical value. But in the two respects above stated this book is valua- ble. The writer enlisted in the .winter of 1863-64, and went to the front in company with six hun- dred bounty-jumpers—escaped criminals all, or nearly all. His active service lasted just six weeks, from the crossing of the Rapidan to the first assault of Petersburg; but they were the bloodiest six weeks of the whole war, and a blood- curdling tale does he tell of them. Deaths of tke most horrible character, sickening wounds de- scribed at length, rifling of dead bodies, stealing rations from comrades in the fierce struggle for existence, cowardice of the bounty-jumpers and ‘coffee boilers,” cruelty from officers to men, heartlessness, dissatisfaction, discontent, insubor- dination—all make a picture which can hardly be characterized as other than revolting. Yet it would be rash to deny its accuracy in any par- ticular. Itis only half, or less than half, of tke story of the Army of the Potomac during those terrible six weeks, but it is a half which it is well not to forget. As to the morale of the army, what the author has to say is of great interest. When the first fight in the Wilderness was over, and the troops were withdrawn from their lines, the men said to each other, ‘‘ When we get to the Chancellors- ville House, if we turn to the left, we are whipped ; if we turn to the right, it will indicate the purpose of Grant to fight.” When they reached that point, they turned to the right. ‘Instantly all of us heard a sigh of relief. Our spirits rose. We marchedfree. The men began to sing. The enlisted men understood the flank- ing movement. That night we were happy.” Yet six weeks later—six weeks in which every day had seen an engagement and every week a battle—the same men said, ‘* No, we are not go- ing tocharge. We are going to run toward the Confederate earthworks, and then we are going torun back. We have had enough of assaulting earthworks. We are hungry and tired, ani we want to rest and eat.” And the author brings a charge which we have never before seen in print, viz., it was not so much the men who shrank at that time, as the officers: for while the losses among the enlisted men during the two periods, May 4-May 31, and June 1-October 28, were ap- proximately equal, yet the losses among general officers during the first period were four times as numerous as during the latter. Of the criticisms and opinions of the enlisted men on the course of the campaign, and of the system of ‘‘ news-gatherers” who passed from camp to camp at night carrying the news of the day, much interesting information is given, and the following extract is worth quoting without abridgment : “The enlisted men spent much time in com- paring Grant with McClellan. The latter had many warm friends among the soldiers. Heonly, of all the men who bad commanded the Army of the Potomac, was personally liked and admired by his troops. Soldiers’ eyes would brighten when they talked of him. Their hard, lean, browned faces would soften and light up with affection when they spoke of him—and still it was affection only ; they did not, as a rule, con- cede to him military talent. And the general opinion among them was—given Grant in com- mand of the army in 1862, and the rebellion would have been crushed that year. Asked how McClellan would have done with the army of 1864 under his command, they shrugged their shoulders and said dryly, ‘ Well, he would have ended the war in the Wilderness—by establishing the Confederacy.’ ” The Private is not content with telling his per- sonal reminiscences and drawing a striking pic- ture of the savage scenes through which he passed; in addition, he has his theory of the pro- per conduct of the war. It 1s only briefly stated, and is confined to the Preface, being neither proved nor disproved by anything in the text. His theory is, that the disasters of the war were due to two causes, (1) the calling for volunteers instead of enforcing the draft at the outset; (2) the placing of West Point graduates in command of troops. As to the first, it need only be said that a draft in 1861 was politically impossible; incidentally it may be noted that it would have put worse men in the ranks than the system of volunteers. Asto the second, the Government acted largely on his theory in 1861 when it ap- pointed Butler, Banks, Frémont, and Sigel among its first major-generals and assigned them to im- portant commands, It was only disaster that caused the Government to look among trained soldiers for its generals, and from them pro- duced Grant, Sherman, Sheridan, Thomas, Han- cock, and the other great commanders—gradu- ates of West Point with but very few exceptions —who finally put down the rebellion. The New English. By T. L. Kington Oliphant of Balliol College. Macmillan & Co. 1886. Mr. OLIpHANT’s ‘New English’ is a record of the rise of new words in English literature. He takes the date of the first well-formed specimen of the new English to be 1303. He begins with Friar Michael of Kildare, his printed pieces dat- ing shortly after 1300, and enumerates the new words and phrases which occur in them, point- ing out that such and such are from the French, this and that from the Scandinavian, and many from the Anglo-Saxon. Then he takes up an- other book and deals with it in the same way, making good speed through scores of little-known authors to Chaucer, to Shakspere, and at last to Morris and the last revised Bible of our own day. A verbal index is added, containing something like 20,000 words and many more thaw 20,000 references. ‘New English’ will serve as a com- pendious historical dictionary till the great work of the Philological Society shall be available. One who reads Dr. F. Hall’s handling of Bishop Coxe’s English philology in the Nution of March 3 might be interested in the expression “‘is being built.” Dr. Hall gives it a respectable age: he has found it as early as 1769. A look for it in Oliphant shows examples in 1447-48, ‘“ You was” comes up in 1699, in Bentley, king of scholars ; great, too, in idiomatic English. It was current afterwards for & hundred years. The South English abuse of A is an interesting puzzle in its cause and age. Oliphant finds it first in Miss Hawkins’s novel, ‘The Countess and

Page 25

March 17, 1887] The Nation.

Gertrude,’ published in 1811 ; a rustic talks of a ‘‘ot loaf,” and a lady’s maid of a “ himpeeral” (imperial). These examples favor the view that the dropping of A is the old natural weakening; the adding, an affectation in high life below stairs. Persons often wonder when and where our queer spellings started into use. A look at could in Oliphant refers to the records (1440-1450) of Coldingham Priory, vo]. i. ‘* There is a start- ling change in p. 160,” he says; ‘‘the old cude (potuit) is written culde, from a false analogy with shulde and wulde.” In Bishop Hall (1598) the old Teutonic rime is first ‘* confused with the Greek rhythm, and becomes rhyme, p. 10; this absurd spelling ought never to be used in our time.” Besides single words and forms, much care has been taken to note phrases, especially proverbs, and other expressions which embody the habits of thought or record the customs of each age, and everything which throws light on the pronunciation either of English or foreign words, Thus much about the book considered as a sort of dictionary. Its distinctive feature and emi- nent merit is the exhibition of numbers of words and phrases together as they are found together in books. This presents us with the mate rials for the study of the language of any book, of any author, or of any age. About 250 writers are examined before Shakspere’s time, and 100 more to our day. Tnese writers have been selected on the ground of their importance in the history of the lan- guage; many of them are of small importance or none at all, as literature. Comic and colloquial authors are best for this purpose. Little notice is taken of Spenser and Milton, much notice of Udall and Still. But the most elaborate study is made of Shakspere and Chaucer. Shakspere’s plays are taken up one by one, and each has as much space as a whole book usually gets. The whole is stuffed full of curious facts, and suggests still more curious questions. In ‘* Love’s Labour Lost,” to begin with, the French caporal fig- ures as a corporal; the law term escheat be- comes cheat, the people’s notion of a lawyer's function; epithet appears for epitheton ; anew kind of time-piece, the watch, takes the place of the dial; the adjective spruce (from Prussia) tes- tifies to the smart dress from Prussia which pleased the Londoners; andso on. Some eighty words and phrases are mentioned in this play, a great part being phrases or loose compounds. The order in which the plays are treated does not agree with that in which it is generally supposed that they were written—perhaps Mr. Oliphant has strong opinions in favor of the order he has adopted. But his discussions donot depend upon the order as much as one might suppose, for most of his examples occur but once in all of Shak- spere. At least, suspecting this, we turned up the words in ‘‘ Romeo and Juliet,” and found it to be so there. So that, in addition to the other matters, we have material for examining Shak- spere’s hapax ‘egomena. Mr. Oliphant is an Oxford man, and well up in the latest scientific knowledge of English as it appears in the works of Prof. Skeat and Dr. Murray. This particular kind of work is all his own. In 1873 he published ‘Standard English,’ a sketch of the sources of English, traced in the same method which he uses here, but through fewer books. That must have cost him several years of labor. He has now spent a dozen more years in enlarging it. In 1878 ‘Old and Middle English’ appeared, and now we have the comple- tion in ‘ New English.’ Such a work must be in- complete, from the nature of the case. One man cannot read everything. Dr. Murray's readers have gone over thousands of volumes to Mr. Oli- phant’s hundreds, But, such as itis, all students of English will be glad to get it and must have

it; for none of them will venture to decide ques- tions of English etymology or historical gram- mar without consulting him. Mr. Oliphant has a lively liking for pure Eng- lish, and plenty of sharp thrusts for modern de basers of it. The Johnsonese of the press hurts him worst. He is most courteous to American scholars, and bountiful in praise of them; but he cannot see how they can write Aonor, ete., in stead of the old honour. It pares down history, robs us of all our Norman glories. The old word ‘**should abide with us in the shape it has always hitherto worn.” This looks as if Mr. Oliphant had not noticed that of all the old words of this sort, honor most frequently appears in the old books with -or. Picking a place in Shakspere by the concordance where the word occurs fre quently, ‘‘ Coriolanus,” ii, and turning to the First Folio, we find honor fifteen times, and no he Another trial, ‘* Measure for Measure,” ii, 1, gives honor nine times and honour eight, most of them being the address Your Honour, with one honorable. Looking to the analogy of the language, as our verb honor and the noun honor have the accent on the same syllable, they are naturally spelled alike, and like French hon orer’, rather than honneur. nour,

The Practical Horse Keeper. By George Flem ing, LL.D., F.R.C.V.S. Cassetl & Co, Mr. FLEMING says in his preface: ‘** This little work is intendel as a guide to those who have to do with horses, either as owners, purchasers, breeders, trainers, managers, or attendants, and whose experience has not been so extensive as those on whose knowledge it is based.” As such and for Great Britain it is a desirable manual Its value for this country is largely diminished by reason of the different uses to which horses are put here, necessitating, for general purposes, especially those outside of hauling heavy loads, animals of quite other types than any in com- mon use in England. For instance, ‘*the hunt er” and “the hack,” probably the best-known aud commonest types of English horses, would not be recognized by these names in this coun- try except in the localities where English manners, customs, and nomenclature are most affected, and really do not exist as aclass. The ‘* tradesman’s horse,” a variety treated of by Mr. Fleming, would also bea hard animal to find here, perhaps because there are either so few or so many *‘ tradesmen.” Again, the horse which in this country takes the place of the English hack, and we may almost say, hunter also, is the light driving horse for road or general utility pur- poses; and he, from his different conditions of use and treatment, is broken, bitted, harnessed, driven, and cared for in a manner radically different from any taught in Mr. Fleming’s or any other English book, and intinitely better for the end desired. Consequently, the parts of Mr. Fleming's work devoted to the hack, the hunter, ‘ pur-chas- ing at fairs,” breaking, training, and feed ing, while undoubtedly excellent for the British Isles, are of but limited utility elsewhere, and much inferior for home application to several American treatises on the same subject. The latter portion of Mr. Fleming's book, however, bas no such limitations of usefulness. It treats concisely and admirably of the common intirm- ities of horseflesh, and gives plain and sensible instructions for their relief. The chapter on “Nursing” 1s especially to be commended, and Mr. Fleming says, what can be proved by every humane man who has had horses in his charge, that “‘ when a horse is sick, or ill from injury, recovery is much accelerated by careful and sympathetic nursing. However indifferent a horse may be to caressing or kind | attention during health, 8385 when ill he certainly | appreciates them,” ete as seen from The Fallof Maximilian’s Empire, a United States Gunboat. By Seaton Schin« Ss. N New York: G. 1 Pp. 150 LIEUT. SCHROEDER has written very pleasantly der, Lieutenant, U Putnam's Sons, ISS7 ; and intelligently, and withal modestly, of the do

ings of the United States steamer J7acony in Vera Cruz harbor during the spring and summer of Iso7. His narrative is but lightly and inciden tally connected with the important movements going on in the interior, and he makes no preten of being able to see as far as Querctaro from the Tt should be said, however, that neai’ the « events in thase closing struggles show a good ai sea-board ly all tis allusions to and causes of Uurse quaintance with the facts, The Orizaba confer ence, leading to Maximilian’s fatal decision to rm turn, is rather unsatisfactorily sketched, and the amount of revenue promised the Emper We are not pleased wit! Mexteo's that siderably exaggerated the author's spelling of the name of true, we believe Santa Ana was the original great hero-traitor. It is form, but it has been entirely superseded by the common orthographs in the writings of Mexicans themselves, and to return to it now seems almost affectation, The tombstone in the Gaudalupe * pantheon “has the the ordinary Mexican names had to two n’s. If ation from English spelling of any var be at tempted, we think a change might hav: juster treating d of Vera Iss] INS. been made in the case of Uloa, Ulua cidedly preferable. The “ Bird's-eye View Cruz ” (p. 8) is correct for 1807, but not for the walls of the city having been demolished long since, BOOKS OF THE WEEK Adams, Sarah Flower Arise, My SS 1 Ariane Bost u leew & Shepard #1 Burty, P. Bernard lalissy l’aris Rouam Carroll, I The Game of Lawt Macmillan d& Co. § Champfleury. La Tour. Parts: J .Rouan Cournault, « Jean Lamour. Part< Rovuam Creighton, Prof, M A History of the Papacy during the Period of the Keformattop Vols, itt aad tv The italian Princes. 1464-1518. Boston: Houghton, MiMliin & Co. $75 De Rougemont, A. La France. Notes d'un Américain New ed The Writer's t shing Ue Du Boiggobey, FL Cectle’s Fortune. Chicag Rand. M Naliv & «« cents Du Rotazobey, } The wiective’s Eve Chicag Rand McNally & ¢ 25 cents Du BRoreawober, } The Steel Necklace Chicago: Rand MeNali¥ & « QS cents M A Treatise on Surveving. Theory and Gillespie, Prof. W amd Practice Revised and enlargea by Cady Staley

PRD. D. Appleton & + Gladness of t aster Hpom the Poets Baston: Le Shepan a Uruyer, Fra Rartolomme della Porta et Martotto Alvertinelli, Paris; J. Rouam Hall Stevens. A 7ext Book of Fuchd'’s Elements for the f Schools. Parti Books i. and ti. Maemillan & Co

Historia Numorum Macmillan & Co. #1 w Hints on Writing and Speech Maki: ; Lee & Shepard cents Canning Englist namans, Green & Co A Manualof Greek Wu Worthies Serics (roorne Landon: I Jerome, Lrene kb The Message the Biuebird Told to Me to Tell to Others. Boston: Lee & Shepard. $1 Kingsley, « See the Land her Easter heeping. Boston Lee & Shepard. #1 Lemaitre, Les Contemporains e série, Paris: H, ne et Oudin Lax Millet. F. Alfred Lebrun’s Catalogue of his Etchings, Heliographs, Lithographs, and Woodcuts Frederick Keppel & ¢ Von ff vist. Dr. H. The Constitutional Law of the United States of America. Authorized edition. Translated by Alfred Risbop Mason. Chicago: Callaghan & Co Weld, Martha Coles, iUlustrated Tableaux for Amateurs 1, fi. Harold Roorbach Werner, EF. A. Civil List and ¢ the Colony and State of New Parsons & C Whately netitutional History of York albany: Weed, Archoishop. English Synonyms Discriminated New ed. Boston: Lee & Shepard cents, Whedon, Rev. D. D. Essays, Keviews, and Discourses With a Biographical Sketch, Phillips & Hunt. 2 vols Wilkins, W. J. Modern Hinduism; betng an Account of the Religion and Life of the Hindus in Northern Indla. Scribner, Welford & Co Wilson, E. Quiet Observations on World. Ulustrated. Cassell & Co. #2, Winsor. J. Narrative and Critical History of America. Vol. tv. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co. Winter, J. S. Mignon’s Secret, and Wanted—a Wife Harper's Handy Series. 25 cents. Winter, J. S Regimental Legends. Harper's Handy Series. 25 cents Woodhouse. KR. I. Co, 40 cents. Yonge, Charlotte M. The Victorian Half Century. A Jubilee Book, Macmillan & Co. 35 cents, the Ways of the What is the Church? D. Appleton &

Page 26

238 Nation. The [Number 1133 Foes Holt & Co. HAVE READY : VOL. IL. OF MODERN 1814 to 1848, 8vo EUROPE. By C. A. Fyffe. , $2.50, The Nation said of the first volume: ‘ As bril- liant a sketch as we have seen for many a year.” The Boston Advertiser said: “ The first volume is a masterly achievement.” The Churchman said: *‘ Bids fair to be recog- nized as the best history of Modern Europe.” The London Saturday Review said: ‘‘ Vigor- ous, thoughtful, and well-written.” HENRY HOLT & CO., NEW YORK, THE Popular Science FOR APRIL. FYFFE’S Monthly Ready March 19. CONTENTS : BRAIN. FORCING IN CHILDHOOD. mond, M.D. THE HISTORY OF A DELUSION. By Wm. A. Ham. By M. G. Valbert. ASTRONOMY WITH AN OPERA-GLASS.—THE STARS OF SPRING. By Garrett P. Serviss. (Mustrated ) SOCIAL AND PHYSIOLOGICAL INEQUALITY. By H. D. Chapin, M D. IN. 7 . TION AND DISINFECTION. By Robson Roose, D. ON MELODY IN SPEECH. By F. Weber. SCIENTIFIC AND PSEUDO-SCIENTIFIC By Prof. T. H. Huxley. BIRD MIGRATION. By Barton W. Evermann. A REMARKABLE EXPLOSION. By Prof. L. R. F. Grif- fin. THE SCIENTIFIC AGE. ON THE TRUE AIM OF PHYSIOLOGY. Preyer. REALISM. By Dr. Werner Siemens. By Prof. W. TURPENTINE FARMING. W. Robarts. ROSTIC SUPERSTITION, SKETCH OF LEO LESQUEREUX. (With Portrait.) CORRESPONDENCE. EDITOR'S TABLE: Science and Statesmansbip.—The Growth of Industrialism. LITERARY NOTICES-—POPOULAR NOTES. By L, By L. R. McCabe. MISCELLANY. Price 50 cents Single Number; $5 per Annum. I). APPLETON & CO., Publishers, New York. A new volume by the Rev. Dr. C. C. S. ROBINSON. ry a )y ‘ THE PHARAOHS ‘THE BONDAGE AND THE EXODUS Treated in the ligat of tne recent remarkable discoveries at Balak in a series of lectures. The topics include: The Modern Land of Egypt, The Great Discovery in 1881, Mummies as Evidences ot C bristianity, The Father of ‘ Pharaoh's Daughter,” God’s Purpose with Menepbtah, Go- shen and the Obelisk of On, Wonders in the Field of Zoan, Pharaoh’s Heart Hardened. etc., ete. Price, in cloth, $1.00; in manilla, gilt, 50 cents, THE ( CENTU RY Co., New York. BRENTANO BROTHERS. 5 Union Square, New York. Just issued : - PUBLISHERS, BOOKSELLERS, STATIONERS, NEWS- DEALERS, MUSIC DEALERS AND IMPORTERS, English, French, German, Spanish, and Italian Books, including not only the latest novelties, but a complete stock of Classics always on hand, Send for catalogues. Full line of foreign magazines and papers. Ary book fur- nished, no matter where published. NDEXES,DIFFICULT “RESEARCHES and books hard to find. E A. Mac, 603 B’way, N. Y. , Roberts Brothers NEW BOOKS. The Egotst. A Novel. By Georce MEREDITH, author of ‘ Richard Feverel,’ ‘ Evan Harrington,’ ‘ Harry Richmond,’ ‘San dra Belloni,’ ‘ Rhoda Fleming,’ ‘ Vittoria,’ and ‘ Diana of the Crossways,’ being the eighth in our new uniform 12mo edition, bound in English cloth, uncut. Price, $2. Mr. Meredith’s novels are an intellectual tonic. They are great, and. indeed, we may say they are the - novels of any ives author which deserve to be called great. They will take the same high and permanent rank that is assigned to the works of George Eliot and George Sand.— Boston Traveller. Cathedral Days. A Tour through Southern England. By ANNA BOWMAN Dopp. With 23 Illustrations from Sketches and Photo- graphs by E. Eldon Deane. 12mo. Cloth, $2. This is the record of a trip in Bn as little frequented by tourists, told with so much fascination of style that the reader seeins to share the deli — jourses with the travellers. Oneof our foremost critics says of Mrs. id: “She is, of allthe women [ know, the most thoroughly educated and ace om pli: hed—one of our ablest writers on literature, art, music, ete. I have looked over her de- seriptive record of a tour among the Southern Cathe- dral towns of England, and find it very charming.” Some Chinese Ghosts. By LaFcaDIo HEARN. CONTENTs.—The Soul of the Great Bell; The Story of Ming-y; The Legend of Tchi-Nu; The Return of Yen- Tchin-King; The Tradition of the Tea Plant; The Tale of the Porcelain-God. 16mo. Cloth, $1.00. *‘ Some Chinese Ghosts,’ by Lafcadio Hearn, is a collec- tion of half a dozen legends culled from the realm of Cathayan story, The style has such grace and finish that it is charming. and the imagination is fresh and wholly original. This little gem is sure to have a permanent setting in American literature. Sonnets in Shadow. By ARLO Bates, author of ‘ Berries of the Brier.’ 16mo, Cloth, $1.00. poetical volume, ‘Berries of the Brier,’ though not long since published, is entirely out of print. ‘Sonnets in Shadow,’ being an in memoriam, strikes a tender chord, but it is the plaint of a soul which has thoughts worth the telling. Mr. Bates’s first all booksellers. Mailed, postpaid by the pub- OBERTS BROTHERS, Boston. Sold b. lishers, French Books For Sale. uentin-Bauchard, #8 Semmes bDi- 1. Amiel, H. F. Frag 8. ments d’une jour- nalintime. 2 vols., ° bliophiles (xvie, eDess, naneteseate $2 50 xviie et xviile sié 2. Jacob, Bibliophile, cles). 2 vols., 8v0.$15 CO Mélanges biblio- 9. Martel. Petit re graphiques. 12mo 2 50 cueil des pro- 3. Dr. P. Regnard. ver’ franyais, Les maladies épi Pee 1 00 démiques de I’es- LO Toussenel. Les prit. Sorcellerie, | juifs rois de l’épo- magnetisme, mor- que. histoire de la phinisme, délire éodalité finan- des grandeurs, ciére. 2 vols., ouvrage illustre ere 200 de 100 gravures. 11. Lettres de Ninon OOM 3 60 de Lenclos, précé- 4. Desbarrolles. Les dée de mémoires mystéres dela sursa vie. 12mo. 1 00 main révelés; art 12, Genin. —— de connaitre la | comparé de la vie, le caractére, | langue de Meliére la destinée d’aprés et des écrivains Vinspection des du xvile siécle. mains. 12mo..... 1 50 Svo, halfmor...... 4 50 5. Desbarrolies. Les 13. Genin. Récréa- mystéres de l’éert- ' tions pnilolo- ture; art de juger giques, recueil de les hommes sur | notes pour servir leurs autographes | a Vhistoire des avec nombpreuse | mots de la langue fac-simile. 12mo. 1 20 | francaise. 2 vols. 6. Lacombe (Paul).Bi | in 1, half mor. 4 00 bliographie pari- 14. Godefroy. Lext- sienne. ee. } que comparé de phieanalytique et } Corneille et de la raisonnée des | langue au xviie ouvrages relatifs siécle. 2 vols., aux mceurs de 8vo, half mor..... 4 00 Paris, de 1600 a 15. Delachenal. His- 1880. SvoO....... 6 00 toire des avocats i a | a Aurevil- au Parlement de ly. es ceuvres Paris au moyen et les hommes. Age de 1300 a 1600, Sensations d’art. BOO accccccescosqece 2 40 Svo, 3 25 John Delay. 23 Union Sq., N. Y. OOK ¢ ‘HA T shows at a glance every article . appearing in the current magazines of the world, subject ; also gives Baigent of all new books. Samples, conte, #1. OO per yi ENTA NO. BROS., 5 Union Square, New York. Macmillan & Co.'s NEW BOOKS. By THOMAS HUGHES. JAMES FRASER, SECOND BISHOP OF MANCHESTER. A Memoir (1818-1885). By Thomas Hughes,Q.C. With a,Portrait. 8vo, $4.50. By CHARLES KINGSLEY. FROM DEATH TOLIFE. Frag- ments of Teaching to a Village Congrega- tion. With Letters on the Life after Death. By Charles Kingsley, Rector of Eversley. Edited by his Wife. 16mo, 75 cents. GODLINESSANDMANLINESS. A Miscellany of Brief Papers touching the Relation of Religion to Life. By John W. Diggle, M.A., late Lecturer of Merton Col- lege, Oxford. 12mo, $1.75. A NEW BOOK BY MR. LEWIS CARROLL. THE GAME OF LOGIC. By Lewis Carroll, author of ‘ Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland,’ &c , &c. 12mo, $1. Clarendon Press Series: New Volumes. ANINTRODUCTION to GREEK Sculpture. By L. E. Upcott, M.A. 12mo, $1.10. CICERO. CATO MAIOR DE SE- NECTUTE. Edited, with Notes, by Leonard Huxley, B.A. With Introduction and Notes. 16mo, £0 cents. SELECTIONS FROM TIBUL- LUS AND PROPERTIUS. With Introduc- tion and Notes by G. G. Ramsay, M.A., Pro- fessor of Latin in the University of Glasgow. 16mo, $1.50. *‘One of the most remarkable school-books which we have seen for some time.”—Journal of Education. JUVENAL. TIRES. Edited, Notes, by C. H. Pearson, M.A., Strong, M.A., LL.D. 12mo, $1.50. Classical Series: New Volumes. OVIDII METAMORPHOSEON XIIL, XIV. Edited, with Introduction, Analyses, and Notes, by Charles Simmons, M.A. 16mo, $1.10. —_——— TACITUS. HISTORIES. Books land 2. With Introduction and Notes. By A. D. Godley, M.A. 16mo, $1.10. CESAR. DE BELLO GALLICO, COMMENT 5. Edited, with Notes and Vo- cabulary, for the use of schools, by C. Col- beck, M.A. Elementary Classics. 18mo, 40 cents. TEXT-BOOK OF EUCLID’S ELE- MENTS. Including alternative proofs, to gether with additional theorems and exer- cises, classified and arranged. By H. 8. Hall, M.A., and F. H. Stevens, M.A. Part 1, con- taining books 1 and 2. 12mo, 50 cents. MACMILLAN & CO., New York,‘112 Fourth Avenue. THIRTEEN SA- with Introduction and and H, A,

Page 27