The Nation 1886-10-14: Vol 43 Iss 1111
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
VOL. XLIIL—NO. L111. I). Appleton & Co. WILL PUBLISH OCTOBER 16TH: I The Silence of Dean Mait- land. A Novel. By MAXWELL GREy. 12mo, paper. Price, 50 cents. Published from advance sheets. ‘The Silence of Dean Maitland’ is by anew English author, who gives promise in this striking story of a bril- liant future. [t is a novelof a high intellectual order, strong in plot and character. II. VOLUMES OF WORTHIES.” Ben Jonson. By JOHN ADDINGTON SYMONDS. Richard Steele. By Austin Dosson. ‘English Worthies,” edited by Andrew Lang, consists of short lives of Englishmen of influence and distinction, past and as nm eatery. naval, literary, scientific, le- gal, ecclesiastical, social, etc. The previous volumes of the series are: CHARLES DARWIN, by Grant ALLEN; MARLBOROUGH, by GEORGE SaAInNtTs- BURY ; SHAFTESBURY (the First Earl), by H. D. TrartL; ADMIRAL BLAKE, by Davip Hannay ; RALEIGH, by EpmMunp GOSSE. Small r2mo, cloth. TWO NEW ‘“ ENGLISH Price, 75 cents each. Ill. ) s New and Old Sermons New and Old. By Archbishop RICHARD CHENEVIX TRENCH, D.D. 12mo, cloth. Price, $1.50. The late Archbishop Trench’s ‘ Notes on the Parables and the Miracles of Our Lord’ have been widely read, and the admirers of those se and instructive essays e will welcome the selections of the Archbishop’s Sermons coptained in the present volume. IV 7 e “N The Warwick Shakspere. A new and exquisite edition of the complete Works of Shakspere, in 12 volumes, l6mo, bound in cloth or in half leather, and put up in a tasteful cloth box. Price, in either style, $9.00 for the set. This edition of Shakspere is from the same type as the * Parchment Shakspere,” but printed on thinner paper, making handier aad more flexible volumes, at a lower price, but retaining the peculiar elegance of that edition. V. The Philosophy of Educa- tion. From the German of Professor JOHANN KARL FRIEDRICH ROSENKRANZ, of the University of Kénigsberg. International Educational Series. Edited by W. T. Harris, LL.D. 12mo, cloth. Price, $1.50. *,* For sale by all Booksellers ; or any volume sent by the publishers, by mail, postpaid, on receipt of the price, 1, 3, & 5 Bond Street, New York. THURSDAY, OCTOBER 14, 1886. E.& J. BL YOUNG & COUS NEW PUBLICATIONS. A New Story by Mrs. Fiwing. ¢ - « . Marys Meadow, . And Letters from a Little Garden. By Juliana Horatia Ewing. Illustrated by Gordon Lrowne. Engraved and printed by Edmund Evans. Small éto, tluminat ed board covers, 30 cents net; by mall, 38 cents. ‘Mary's Meadow ’ was the last serial story written by Mrs. Ewing. The origin of the story was from the fact of the author's residence at Taunton, where she had a set tled home with a garden, and was able to revert to the practical cultivation of flowers, which had been one of the favorite pursults of her girlhood. By the Author of Wood's ‘ Man and His Handiwork. Showing the History of the Hyman Race from the Wea pons and Utensils used by Man at Different Pertods By the Rev. J. G. Wood. With about 500 (lustrations &vo, cloth, $3.15 net; by mail, $3.25. Natural History.’ “ This book is inno sense a treatise on technology, but is a brief sketch of human handiwork. It deals with man, towhom was given the divine command to sulxtue the earth, and shows some of the means whereby he is steadily carrying out his high mission.""— From Pye face A Reproduction in Cheaper Form of . . — . The Likenesses of Christ. Being an Inquiry into the Verisimilitude of the Received Likenesses of our Blessed Lord. By the late Thomas Heaphy. Edited by Wylie Bayliss. 4to, cloth, black and gold side, red edges, #1 50 net; by mail, #1 6° With 12large colored plates, heightened with gold in the facsimile of the ancient paintings, from which th recognized portraits of Christ are derived, imcludi four on cloth, of remote antiquity, one enamel, seven after mosaics in the churches of Rome, with numerous wood engravings in metal . Catacombs anc Second and Cheaper Fdition NAO VT )) . : The Gospel and Philosophy. Lectures delivered in Trinity Chapel, New York, by Mor gan Dix, S.T.D.,D.C.L. 16mo, paper covers, &) cents net. E. & J. B. YOUNG & CO., Cooper Union, Fourth Avenue, New York a : ~" ¥ \| d v ¢ x Timelv Manuals. I. MANUAL OF TAE DISEASES OF THE NOSF AND Throat. By J. M. W. Kitchen, M.D. 16mo, f!lustrat ed, cloth, $1. Il. CATARRH, SORE-THROAT, AND HOARSENESS. By Dr. J. W. M. Kitchen. 1lémo, fllustrated, cloth, $1. III. CONSUMPTION: ITS NATURE, CAUSES, PRE vention, and Cure. By J. M. W. Kitchen, M_D., 12mo, cloth, $1.25. G. P. Putnam's Sons, 27 and 29 West 25d St., New York. = ~~ 2 ae German Simplified. An eminently practical new method for learning the German Edition for self instruction, in 12 numbers (with Keys), at 10 cents each; school edition (without kers\ bound fn cloth, $1.25. For sale by all book sellers. Sent, tpaid, on receipt of price, by Prof. A. Knoflach, 140 Nassau St., New York. Prospectus free. - *)- PRICE 10 CENTS Works of Reference. Compact, Concise, and Comprehensive 1. THE POCKET ATLAS OF THE WORLD. A Comprebensive and Po pular Series of Maps, illustrating Political and Physical Geography, prepared by Joh: Bartholomew, F.R.G.S. Beautifully printed in 82mo, cloth extra, $1; full leather,’ $1.50 “Is a littl wonder It is well done ws Exceedingly convenient to all."-—Con. yregationalist ‘Isa most inviting little tome beget ble and intelligible.” — New Advertiser York Commermal “One of the published.” fi. Tae HAND-BOOX DIC- TIONARY A Practical and Conversa tional Dictionary of the English, French and German Languages in parallel colurans George F. Chambers, FLR.A pp. xi, TA. | $2.00 “Simple in construction and comprehensive in character.”"—Adinburgh Scotsman ** It is literally a hand-book."—N, Y, most convenient little hooks ever Ry ISmeo, roan Critic, * Toa tourist through France or Germany it is indispensable. It is the best work of the kind that has come into our hands.”—/ndianapelis Journal lll. THE GLOBE PRONOUNC ING GAZETTEER OF THE WORLD, DE SCRIPTIVE AND STATISTICAL. Being Ca. Geographical Dictionary for Popular Use ‘oth extra, with 32 maps, £2.50. ~r, hke a dictionary, is never quite in these four hundred and sixty ‘ion to the thirty-two maps, in double colun. 4 >, Upareil type, an amount of information is , 7 red that is marvellous, We pat the volume a aong our own choice books of reference. "— Churchman. comple. “a. two pages, 7 lV. A POCKET CLASSICAL D/C- TIONARY, for ready reference. By Frede- rick G. Ireland. 16mo, cloth, 50 cents. ‘Tt is a perfect gem.”—F. B. Gault, Supt. City Schools, lowa City, lowa. ** [t is acomely, concise, and correct little book, which it is a pleasure to commend.” —C. F. P. Ban- croft, Prin, Phillips Academy, Andover, Mass. G. P. Putnam's Sons, 27 and 29 W. 23d St., New York, A CATALOGUE of choice RARE and MODERN BOOKS, at very attractive prices, including the TAUCHNITZ LIBRARY and all the Standard FRENCH NOVELS and CLASSICS in half morocco binding, now ready. Addrniss DUPRAT & CO., 5 East 17th Street, New York,
Page 2
The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science, and Art. FOUNDED 1865. CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. BD FrRaccnpcccscesovecesccecsceccsceseces songnewennhin’ 299 SUMMARY OF THE WEEK'S NEWS...........00sceeccescees 302 EDITORIAL ARTICLES: The Record as to the Offices ..............¢ceeececnens 804 The Recent Theological Controversies . oe Coéperation and Character .... ........ ee CORRESPONDENCE: Republicans and Free Trade in Michigan... ........ 305 Michigan's Saloons and Foreign Population......... 306 The Madison Post-office eo Disgedscedenes 0 0 Results of Bad Teaching............... Why We Notice the Labor Agitation . 307 The Andover Controversy ........ . B07 French Humor.. .... . 807 The Transformation of Surnames ........ oon ae Fa onc bsccccccceseesces cosceccscscccsecccccoccccescese 307 REVIEWS: Admiral Porter’s Naval History .............00...005- = English Explorations in North America ............ Russian Authors for French Readers ................ 312 I sci chcen nnueedddvedesttecdceascavedcocets ne La Religion A Rome sous les Sévéres ...............+. 314 History of the Reformation in England,.... Addresses and Speeches on Various Occasion Assyrische Lesestiicke........... . . 315 - 315 A Romanized Japanese Reader . 316 Living Paris and France ........ . 316 Virginia Carolorum....... . 316 ET i ncen podnccnssenecscsgecsesss . 317 Gazetteer of Grafton County, N. H....... .........65 817 TD Py Fei ncntccnsdesecsenenseconssccssccecsess 317 TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION Three Dollars per year, in advance, postpaid to any part of the United States or Canada; to foreign coun tries comprised in Postal Union, Four Dollars. The date when the subscription expires is on the Ad- dress-Label of each paper, the change of which to a sub- sequent date becomes a receipt for remittance. No other receipt is sent unless requested. The paper is stopped at expiration of the subscription, unless previously renewed, Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter or by check, express order, or postal order, payable to “ Publisher of the NaTIon.” When a change of address is desired, both the old and new addresses should be given. Address THE NATION, Box 794, New York. Publication Office, 210 Broadway. TERMS OF ADVERTISING gos [No deviation. } | lines. On any page not specified, 15 cents per line — each insertion; with choice of page, 20 cents. ri A column (140 lines), $20 each insertion; with — choice of page, $27. at A page (3 columns), $60 each insertion; with|— choice of position, $80. |— Twenty per cent. advance for top of column or _ 10 other preferred position, when specified ; where|— positions are not specified, advertisements are|— classified as far as possible and arranged in or-|__ der of size, the largest at the top. Twenty per cent.advance for cuts, fancy or|— other letters not comprised in THE NATION — fonts, and all other special typography (subject to ap- proval). Cuts are inserted only on inside pages of cover or fly-leaves, not on outside of cover, nor on pages num- bered for binding. Marriage and Death Notices, 50 cents each, DISCOUNT on yearly accounts amounting to $250, 10 per cent.; $500, 15 per cent.; $750, 20 per cent.; $1,000, 25 per cent, Credits are made December 31. Ona ye arly account amounting to 52 pages the discount is one- third. Advertisements must be acceptable in every respect. Copy recetved until Tuesday, 5 P. M. 15 THE NATION is sent free to those who advertise in it, as long as advertisement continues. The EDITION of THE NATION this week is 8,700 copies. The Subscription List is always open to inspec- tion. *,* Copies of THE NaTION may ‘be procured in in Paris of J. G. Fotheringham, 8 Rue des Capu- cines; and in London of B. F. Stevens, 4 Trafal- gar Square; George Street, 30 Cornhill, E. C.; and H. F. Gillig & Co., 449 Strand. ? _The Nation. [Number 1111 Schools. Alphabetized, first, by States; second, by Towns. CONNECTICUT, Hartford TEELE’S SCHOOL FOR YOUNG LA- dies, No. 25 Wethersfield Avenue, Hartford, Conn.— Location and sanitary conditions uns 1; —- able peoel of resident teachers; pils graduated or Preer for Smith, Vassar, or ehlesley ; German French spoken in the family ; Art Department com- prehensive and thoroug Fall term begins September 22, 1886. GEORGE W. STEELE. CONNECTIC LA Ce HALL L SCHOOL. —A FAMILY straction and ST a —S.. roy = co tions. CHARLES G. BARTLETT, Principal. CONNECTICUT, Middletown. OME SCHOOL FOR YOUNG LA- dies. Pupils prepared for College. Classical, Ger- a, - Departments. #285 a year. Address P.O. CONNECTICUT, Middleto TLSON GRAMMAR SCHOOL GIVES a oe pacagention for Coilege. The Princt- pal has served a term of three years as tutor in Yale Col- ege. Send for ciroular. E. H. WILson. DISTRICT OF Coamiante, Washington, 1212 and 1214 Fourteenth Street, N. C. we NORWOOD INSTITUTE.—A se- t Boarding and Day School for Young Ladies and Lite Girls. Mr. and Mrs. Wa. D. CaBELL, Principals. MARYLAND, Baltimore RS. WALLER R. BULLOCE, £3. Ca- thedral St. Boarding School for girls. Reopens Sept. 22. French, German, and Latin included in the oneee. MARYLAND, Baltimore. NIVERSITY OF MAR YLAND.—Law School. Seventeenth annual session, October 4, HENRY D. HARLAN, Sec’y. MARYLAND, Catonsville. 7. TIMOTH Y’S ENGLISH, FRENCH, and German Boarding and Dey School pf = Ladies reopens September 21. Principals, we CARTER and Miss S. R. CARTER. MASSACHUSETTS, Belm OME SCHOOL, SX MILES FROM Boston ; delightful | noted for pure air and pure water ; cou itry delights and city advantages. Ex- cellent o portunities for those who wish to make up lost time, or to make a specialty of Literature and Modern Languages. Send for cl circular to Lucy A. HILL, Prin. MASSACHUSETTS, OSTON UNIVERSITY Law School. Address the Dean, EDMUND H. Bennett, LL.D. CHUSETTS, Bos NST TI 1U0Zias "OF TECHNOLOGY. Courses in Civil, Mechanical, Mining, and Electrical ngineering, Chemistry, Architecture, etc. JamEs P. MUNROE, Sec’y. FRANCIS A. WALKER, Pres. A MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 259 Boylston Street. YIAUNCY-HALL SCHOOL (s9th Year). —Pre tion for the Mass. Institute of Technolo; is aspecialty. Reference is made to the — Facul- ty. The location is the aa attractive in Bosto MASSACHUSETTS, ny RS. QUI vCY 4. "SHA W PROPOSES to establish a Normal prreinies Class wy oung women who wish to become Kindergartners. ‘ollege Course or Normal School Course, or what shall be con- sidered an equivalent, will be en yey as nday, October for admission. The Class will beg n on Mon October 18, 1886, at the School, No. 6 — orough Street, and will be in session till June, 1887. Laura Fisher, who has had such classes in St, Louis, aan who has been Super- visor of Public School Kindergartens there, will have charge of the work. T sons in Frébel’s Philosophy of Education, Instruction in the Gifts, Occupations, Songs, and Plays of the Kindergar- ten, and other speciallessons. Tuition $150 for the course. Application can made to LAURA vues. 873 President Street, Brooklyn, N. Y., and to Miss L. B. PIn- GREE, 302 Marlborough Street, Boston, Mass. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 18 Boylston Place. EPARATION FOR THE INSTI- tute of Technology. ALBERT HALE. MASSACHUSETTS, Cambridge, 13 Appian Way. Rk. JOSHUA "KENDALL’S DA Y AND _ Family School for Boys. Fits for college. Circu- lars. ~ MASSACHUSETTS, Cambridge, Larc OME FOR BOYS.—DR. ABBOT AD- mits not more than four boys into his family, tely. Separate ws ong with best of care in all respects. Charmi loca- ton, with fine tennis-court. FE. E. ABBOT, Ph.D., Pro- prietor. MASSACHUSETTS, Plymo R. KNAPP’S WOME SCHOOL FOR Boys. The ee = (twentieth school year) be- gins Se September 22d, 1 ae DAMS I CIDEMY. — PREPARA- torv and boarding school for boys. School year began 15th September, 1886. For all information address WirLuiaM EVERETT, Ph.D. MASSACHUSETTS, S. Williamstown, Berkshire Co. “REYLOCK IN. STITUTE.—A PRE- ZT paratory School for Dove. 45th year. Catalogues on application. GEORGE F. Mints , Principal. New YorK, Canandaigua. frOkr HILL SCHOOL (FOR BOYS), Individual instruction. Home training. Prepara- tion for College, Scientific School, or Business. . No —— v. JaMEs HaTrrick LEE, Head Master, NEW Tone Crry, 215 W. 57th St. AN NORMAN INSTITUTE.— Founded 1857, Mme. Van Norman, Principal.—Re- ns September 30, with boys ayy ~~ and new stu- alo under Prof. F. Rondel. v. Dr. Burchard, Moral and Mental Sciences. New York Cry, 32 E. 45th St. ‘ JFJOODBRIDGE SCHOOL.—DISTINCT Scientific and Classical courses. Junior Depart- a Introductory to all colleges. Reopens September Ew York, Poughkee IVER VIEW MCADEM Y. —Prepares for College and the Government Academies, for Busi- ness and Social relations. Thorough Military Instruction. Eortnatets Cadet Ri- fles. BISBEE & AMEN, Principals. NEw York, Suspension Bridge E VEAUX COLLE GE. —A Military Boarding aon o Ry . Munro, A.M., President, New York, S RS. C. M. WILKINSON’ S HOME School for Girls.--$1,000 r yote, No extras. Only ten pupils. Refers to Miss Fouisa M. Alcott, Hon, John Lowell, Geo. wm Curtis, Esq New York RS. PIA TTS S SCHOOL FOR YOUNG Ladies.—The next school year begins Wednesday Sept. 21st, 1887. Applications should be made early. Onto, Cincinnati, Walnut Hills. ISS NOURSE WILL REOPEN HER English and French Family and Day School Sept. 28, ere are special classes for those entering for a limited time and a full course fitting for college ex- aminations. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelp! 4. SIONAL “SCHOOL ‘OF ELOCUTION Philadelphia. Aims to make natural dlegant, — Proreiote Readers and Speakers. Large and experienced staff of teachers. Diplomas and degrees. Fourteenth year begins Sept. 27th. nd for catalogue, PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, 1350 Pine St. _ TSS ANABLE’S BOARDING AND Day School for Young Ladies will reopen Sept. 22. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, Norwood Avenue, Chestnut Hill. : RS. WALTER D. COMEG YS and Miss Bell’s English and French Beosdins and Day School for Young Ladies will reopen Sept. 21. Teachers. Oe ARLES W. STONE, Tutor for Harvard, 68 Chestnut Street, Boston. INGING, PIANO, HARP INSTRUC- tion by experienced ney teacher. Highest refer- ences. CANTABILE, Nation office. YW’: ANTED.— PROFESSORSHIP OF German and French. Correspondence solicited. H, Nation, New York City. School Agenctes. ROCKWAY TEACHERS’ AGENCY, Times Baiting, Cc —- “yl will supply superinten- dents, ie teachers, oy ts with positions “4 Cen- . tern, and Sou States for ensuing year CHOOL AGENCY.— OLDEST AND best known in U.S. Established 1855. J. W. SCHERMERHORN & Co., 7 Bast 14th St., N. Y. WE BOSTON TEACHERS’ AGENCY age Se Teachers to Schools, Positions to Teach- ers. Circu E. O. Fisk, 13 Tremont Place, Boston. CHOOL HOME FOR YOUNG LADIES. —Miss Putnam having relinquished her school, will receive into her family six young ladies who may wish to avail themselves of the superior educational advantages which Boston affords; and will act as their chaperone, and care for them in every respect as though they were her pupils. Her beautiful new house in oe Avenue presents unusual attractions. Addres Miss PutNaM, No. 36 Commonwealth Ave., Boston, Mass. Di! any family, whether large or small, but es- pecially where the number of children is large, a record of th e constitutional peculiarities of each one, and the whole course of its iy A development in sickness and in health, is cert instructive and may prove invaluable. Sucha pooges is Professor J. B. Fonssagrives’s *‘ Mother’s consisting of a se of tables scientifically fo or brief and convenient entries. A separate volume for boys and for girls. Price ae. 75 coats per volume, or $1 25 for two volumes. Publisher of the Nation. ‘CHOOL BOOKS IN FOREIGN LAN- guages. Miscellaneous Books in te Me Languages. Gatalégues on applivation. Fore’ Peri als. CARL SCHOENHOF, Importer, 144 Tremont St., Boston. RITICAL AND SOCIAL ESSA YS.— Spigity the place ofthe fat cro voluanes of he paper son very — Sloth. 1smo 2mo, price $1.60. Sent post ~ - HENRY HOLT & CO., New York.
Page 3
' ' iy f \
Oct. 14) —
THE Onis GLASS COMPANY 333 & 335 FourTH AVENUE New YorK STAINED AND Mosaic GLASS LOUIS C. TIFFANY Pama MITCHELL Pres’t and Art Director Vice-Pres’t and Manager JOHN DUFAIS JOHN CHENEY PLATT Secretary Treasurer
A NET SIX = INCOME FROM DEBENTURES OF THE FIDELITY LOAN AND TRUST COMPANY OF STORM LAKE, IOWA. CASH CAPITAL, $100,000. These are regular coupon bonds, $500 and $1,000 eacn and are issued in series of $50,000. Each series has an independent mortgage security representing over $130,- 000 of improved property. A superior investment for Trust and similar funds, where safety is the first consideration. Address WILLIAM G. CLAPP, Treasurer, 7 Nassau St., New York.
GOLD MEDAL, a. 1878, BAKER’S , Breakfast Cocoa. Warranted absolutely pure Cocoa, from which the excess of Oil has been removed. It has three times the strength of Cocoa mixed with Starch, Arrowroot or Sugar, and is therefore far more economi- cal, costing less than one cent a cup. It is delicious, nourishing, strengthening, easily digested, and admirably adapted for invalids as well as for persons in health. Sold by Grocers everywhere. W. BAKER & CO., Dorchester, Mass. Rhododendrons. Being the representatives in America for John Watter- er & Sons, the famous English Rhododendron growers, we can offer these splendid flowering Evergreens in any quantity and at the lowest prices consistent with the well-known high quality of this firm's productions. Prices, $3 to $12 per dozen; $15 to $75 per hundred, freight from England added. Standards and specimens #2 to $15 each. Small orders filled from stock in our nursery. Orders of $25 and upwards may be selected from Messrs. Watterer’s catalogue, the largest and best collection in the world, and will be shipped in our care direct from England. Orders taken now for spring de- livery. Safe arrival and satisfaction guaranteed. Full particulars and our superb illustrated catalogue of roses, hardy plants, and bulbs sent free. B, A. ELLIOTT CO., Pittsburg, Pa. Unmounted Photographs OF ANCIENT AND MODERN WORKS OF ART, pen enn panes of famous original ntings, eee ee Price, cabinet mise’ a1 50 per = ag th 10-cent a for catalogue and supplement of over 7,000 subjects. SOULE PHOTOGRAPH CO., Publishers, 338 Washington Street, Boston, Maas. Please mention the Nation.
YES Fitted with ae Glasses. a, _— , and Telescc e, ani Son yy, + ye Ste chalaiee aha. 41 Union New Ye York. Catalogues by enclosing stamp. 1840.
The Nation. IG. P. Pitnens's Sons.
READY THIS WEEK : 1. THE OLD ORDER CHANGES By W. H. Mallock, author of * 1s Life Worth Living? ‘The New Republic,’ ete. Imo, cloth, $1.00, paper, 50 cents. (In the Trans- atlantic Series, No. 21.) Tl, THE ROMANCES OF CH1I- valry. The Legends and Traditions of * Sir Isumbras,” ‘Sir Degori,” “Sir Bevis of Hampton,” **The Squyr of Lowe Degre,” ‘* Valentine and Orson,” **Guy of Warwick,” etc., ete. By John Ashton, author of * The Dawn of the Nineteenth Century,’ ete , etc. With fifty illustrations in facsimile. Limited letter-press edition. Octavo, gilt tops, $5.00.
IIT. CHIVALRIC a 1Y¥S AND Youthful Deeds. By E. 8. Brooks, author of ‘Historic Boys,’ ete. Svo, fully illustrated, uniform with ‘ Historic Boys,’ $2.00. Contents. —Cinderella’s Ancestor—The Favored of Baal—The Gage of a Princess—The Tell-Tale Foot—The Boys of Blackfriars—The Cloister of the Seven Gates—The Field of the Cloth of Gold, ete. 27 and 29 West 23d St., New York. Houghton, Mifflin & Co.'s NEW BOOKS. [Ready Saturday, 16th.) Holy Tides. By Mrs. A. D. T. Whitney, author of ‘ Bonnyborough,’ ‘ The Gay worthys.” ete. Square 16mo, beautifully printed and bound, 75 cents. A tasteful book of thoughtful poetry, celebrating the none letter” davs of the Cbhure Advent, Christmas, ‘pipha.y, Lent, Whitsunday, Trinity, and Easter days which commemorate events notable in the religious ex pastenas of mankind. Ten Dollars Enough. By Catherine Owen. 1émo, $1.00, A household book of remarkable value. The writer tells a pleasant story, and weaves into it recives and excellent directions for cooking and housekeeping. The story ap eared serially in Good Housekeeping, and has received he ungualified commendation of many who have tested the recipes and followed the suggestions. gassiz’s Life and Works. New uniform edition in six volumes, including : LIFE AND LETTERS. By Mrs Agassiz. 2 vols, 12mo, GEOLOGIC AL SKETCHES. Two Series. i2mo, €1.50 METHODS OF STUDY IN NATURAL HISTORY. 12ma, #15 AJOU RNEY IN BRAZIL. INustrated. 12mo0, $2.50 The Set, 6 vols., 12me, $10. Weta ro » . Essays and Poems. By Jones Very. New and complete edition. With a fine yhototype portrait, an Introduction by C. 4. Bartol, ».D., and a Memoir by James Freeman Clarke, D.D. Crown Svo, $2.00.
*,* For sale by all Booksellers. Sent by mad, post- patd, on receapt of price by the Publishers, HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO, BOSTON. 11 E. 17th St., New York. B. Westermann & : Co., S38 BROADWAY, NEW YORK. FOREIGN and AMERICAN TEXTBOOKS for COl- LEGES and SCHOOLS. New French and German books received weekly. Importation of single books or quanti ties from England and ali othes European countries. The pam none of second-hand book dealers supplied and ders a filled promptly at lowest rates. Foreign rate best German and English Dictionary, H(EME- PREC USER, by mail $4.50.
NM ASH & SS MK ng 0 NASSAU ST., Local His Fart americin tions Ok ad Scare begees bacie a enealogy. Catalogues sent py 2
ae —_— wwe BH TICKNOR. T. RB. TICKNOR. ©. F GODFREY a) icknor & Co.'s Books Sent postpand. by the publishers ry ; + i ( I: I 4 ( r sale by Roodseedlers HNIUS IN) SUNSHINE AND
Shadow. By MM. Rallow. I’m #1 A book of piquant anecdotes and incidents about the worki's heroes, sages and notables. [ntensely interesting, and fullof permanent value to all. The Garette catts tt fascinating to every reader of refined and etucated taste The Truredier calls it a rare and delightful book 7s Le . 2 2s. DGE-TOOLS OF SPEECH By MM. Rallou. &vo, etl » € Au enoyotopentta of quotations, the brightest savings of the wise ad famous. Invaluable for debating socteties, writers and public speakers, A treasure for small Ubrartes The Boston Traveller calls tt The chiticest expres sions of the great thinkers of all ages, fr ‘ fuctus to Ruskin, These pungent apothegms are classified by toptes, Le will be indispensabt® to all weiter and speakers, and should be tn every Ubrary ETERKIN, PAPERS. Lucre Ua P. Hale's Inimitable and amusing stories of Aga
memnon, Solomon John and the Lady from iM hthadel phia have just been brought out in a handsome new quarto edition, oa fine calendered paper, and crowd ed with quaint pictures §1 0 .-yS . . HRISTIAN SYMBOLS AND Stories of the Saints, bv Clara Erskine Clement and Katharine FE. Conway, ts a larce and rtchiv Ulustrated handbook *Pullof tnustruction and wtadom AVS a Benedictine abbot Not only attractive aud tnte resting in itself, but ntaining particularly valual information,” says an Usurtine abbess A titerars biographical, and chronological treasure,” «ays a nun of the Visitation NEW PUBLICATIONS. TARAS BULRA_ Ry Nigora Vt 1. With portrait ofthe author. T: anslated by Lea bel F. Hapmood. btm $1.00 ei S ‘ REAT MASTERS OF RUSSIAN LITFRATI RB? By Erxxest Dervy. Sketches of the Life and Works of Ge mol, Turgenief, Tolstei With portraits, Translated by Nathan Haskell Dole. (2mo, $1.25 Tr. JOHN'S EVE, AND OTRER STORIES. From “Eve nings at the Farm,” and “ St. Petersburg Stortes ly Niko tal V. Gogo igmo, $1.2 RIMF AND PUNISHMENT. By Fropor M. Dost YEVSKY. 12mo, $1.50 “ The readers of Turcénief and of Tolstol must now add Dastoyevsky to their list if ther wish to understand the - asons for Ue supremacy of the Kusstans tn modern fic mW. D. Howells, in Harper's Monthly J for Septem Ser. STORIES FROW LIF? Ry Saran K. Borton, author of “ Poor Boys Who Became Famous,” ‘Girls Who Be came Famous,’ etc. i2mo, $1.25 THE LABOR MOVEMENT 1N AMERICA Ry Prof. S Ricuarp ff. Evy. imo, $1.25 Although Prof. Ely has been a frequent contributor to Harper's Monthly and other perk mite ‘als upon similar topics, he has not heret< fore written any complete treatise on the great social question such as he now offers to the public, as the re sult of long and careful study of a subject upon which he is acknowledged to be an authority: aud his book will doubtless become a standard work of reference to those who discuss this question in the future ILENT TIMES. A book to help in reading the RPible into life. By the Rev. J. R. MILLER, D.D. i2mo, $1.25. MEDITATIONS OF A PARISH PRIEST. Thoughts by Ga T JosEern Roux. 12mo, eit top. #1.25. Translated from the French by Label F. Hapgood. IRLS WHO BECAME FAMOUS. By Saran K. Botton. Lives of Harriet Reecher Stowe, George Eliot, Helen Hunt Jackson, Harriet Hosmer, Rosa Bonheur, Florence Nightingale, Maria Mitchell, and other eminent women ( ‘ompanion book to ‘ Poor toys who became Famous 12mo, with portraits, $1.50 HF RIVERSIDE MUSEUM. By Jak, the author of * Birchwood,’ and‘ Fitch Club.’ 12mo, #1.25. a CHRISTMAS COUNTRY, AND OTHER FAIRY 4LES. Translated from the Danish and German by samt J. SaFForD. With new and original fllustra- tions, by Charles Copeland, 12mo, $1.59. BOYS’ BOOK OF FAMOUS RULERS, By Lypia Hoyt I} FaRMER. Lives of Agamemnon, Julius Cesar. Cha riemagne, wrodersey, the Great, Kichard Coeur de Lion, Robert Bruce, Napoleon, and other heroes of his toric fame. Fully ‘illustrated with portraite and nu- merous engravings. 12mo, $1.50, N PERILS OFT. By W.H. Davexrport AbDams. A book of daring adventures and heroic decds by soldiers, sailors, travellers, and men of renown, in various parts of the world, 12mo, fully illustrated, ‘gi. 50, THOMAS Y. CROWELL & €0., 13 Astor Place, New York.
Page 4
lv MACMILLAN & CO.’ NEW AND RECENT BOOKS. The Modern Historian. Lectures on the Study OF Medieval and Modern History AND KINDRED SUBJECTS. By WILLIAM STUBBS, D.D., BISHOP OF CHESTER. So. $2.60. Just Published. Prof. Stubbs is one of the best examples of the new school of investigators who are putting a fresh face upon English and all other European history, indefatigable in research, richly equipped in knowledge of authorities and sources of discov- ery, and filled with the scientific spirit which pur- sues truth for its own sake and not for its testi- mony to preconceived theories and opinions. This is the spirit which distinguishes the true scientific treatment of history. Prof. Stubbs is full of it; and while he is decided in his expressions of opi- nion, there are few authors to whom we can refer with more confidence foran exact and full state- ment of facts.—New York Tribune. New Book by Canon Westcott. CHRISTUS CONSUMMATOR: Some Aspects of the Work and Person of Christ in Relation to Modern Thought. By Brooke Foss Westcott, D.D., D.C.L., Canon of Westminster. 12mo, $1.50.
THE NEW NOVEL. MACMILLAN’3 DOLLAR NOVELS.—NEW VOLUME. NEARA,. ATALE OF ANCIENT Rome. By John W. Graham. 12mo. $1.
WORKS ON ANTHROPOLOGY. STUDIES IN ANCIENT HIS- tory. Comprising a Reprint of ‘ Primitive Marriage, an Inquiry into the Origin of the Form of Capture in Marriage Ceremonies.’ By the late John Ferguson McLennan. A New Edition. vo, $4. By the same author, recently publisied. THE PATRIARCHAL THEORY. eo na and Completed by Donald McLennan. vo, KINSHIP AND MARRIAGE /N Early Arabia. By W sunertnes Smith, M.A ,LL.D. 12mo, $2.5( “ It is enough to say that no student of early history ean afford to be without ‘Kinship in Early Arabia.’ Nature. MACMILLAN’S SHORTER LA- tin Course. Being an Abridgment of ‘ Mac- millan’s Latin Course, First Year.’ By A. M. Cook, M.A. 16mo, 40 cents.
Macmillan’s Foreign School Classics.—New Volumes. FAUST. By Goethe. With an In- troduction and Notes. By Jane Lee, Lectur- er on German Literature, Newnham College. Part 1. Followed by an Appendix on Part 2. 18mo, $1.10. BRITANNICUS. Tragedie par Ra- cine, With Introduction and Notes. By Eugéne Pellissier, M.A., B.Sc. 18mo, 50 cents. FRENCH READINGS FROM Roman Histo Selected from various Au- thors, and ited, with Notes, by C. Col- beck, M.A. 18mo, $1.10, MACMILLAN & CO., New York, 112 Fourth Avenue. ,
The Nation. [Number ane Robert Clarke & Co. CINCINNA T7/, HAVE JUST PUBLISHED: The Mosaic Tabernacle. The Wonderful Tent. An Account of the Erection, Signification, and Spiritual Lessons of the Mo- saic Tabernacle, erected in the Wilderness of Sinai. By Rev. D. A. Randall, D.D., with a Bio- graphical Sketch of the Author and Portrait. PDA os dena cates cesnssasanneinabiadesrinacuinnions #2 00 Spinoza. Spinoza and his Environment. A Critical Essay, with a Translation of the Ethics. By the Jate Prof. Henry Smith, D.D., LL.D., of Lane Semina- Cp. WHS FGRIEEE, BUBic cecccccccces cccsccsces $3 00 Neff Family. Niif-Neff Family. A Chronicle, together with a lit- tle Romance regarding Rudolf and Jacob Nif of Frankford, Pennsylvania, and their Descend- ants, including an account, with Genealogical Tables,ot the Neffs of Switzerland and America, Coats of Arms, etc. By Elizabeth Clifford Neff. eas hank sina cdbccesessanestontessnaneces #4 00 Marshall Family. The Marshall Family; or, a Chronological Chart of the Descendants of John Marshall and Elizabeth Markham. Sketches of Individuals and notices of Families connected with them. By William PM ndedvecccssncee > dsssponsecdaonsnne #2 50
R. C Co. publish the following va uable books: 4LZOG’3 Universal Church History, 3 vols., 8vo. ..$15 00 leer | a E in the Public Schools: The Cincinnati ee Ldb6 6006 60060606060046000000600068006006000006000 00 _.. R’S Prophecies of Ups and Downs in Prices. 1 00 BOU ay A S Expedition against the Ohio Indians pahnd 0bhedusedesesdeseseseedscdsencqosnseosoos 3 00 BU ar 3 The Far East: Letters from Egypt. Pales- PIN tcckctdetnadadbcakcdcemnteeieideadtnwsnaece 1 50 CLARK’S Campaign in the Illinois, 1778-9... ah abelede 2 00 Cc coe s Synopsis of Chess Opening, edited by J. W. — PPPS TTT ee TTT PPT TT TT TTT Tt Te 2 ¢ CURRIE’S Principles and Practice of Common- BOOST TORGIO 06 ccccsccccs cesccocce svccccces 1 00 DR. DRaKE’S Pioneer Life in Kentucky............ 2 00 GALLAGHER’S Miami Woods, and Other Poems... 2 00 HASSAUREKR’S Secret of the Andes: A Romance... 1 50 HASSAU REK’S Four Years among Spanish Ameri- GOB. cccccccoccccccccccsccosccccscevesscescesceescese 1 50 HENSHALL’S Camping and Cruising in Fiorida.... 1 50 HENSHALL’S Book of the Black Bass............... 3 00 HOUGH'’S Elements of Forestry............ ......05- 2 00 HOVEY’S Celebrated American Caverns............ 2 Ov HUBBARD’S Merry Songs and Games for Kinder- SE BA ME nccnddscccrbaccasscréonadeseoe 2 50 LONGLEY’S Eclectic Manual of Phonography...... 75 LONGLEY’S Phonographic Dictionary.............. 250 LONGLEY’S Every Reporter’s Own Short-Hand Dic- Ss 65nd cscndnekehbecdesssdidanscneein chesaseacse 2 50 aes ~~“ S Pioneer Biography of Early Settlers. i ntuctaksetakeiciaeeins <eciebhtepeseeshes evades 6 50 MISS McLAUGHLIN’S China Painting.............. 75 MISS McLAUGHLIN'’S Pottery Decoration.......... 1 00 MISS McLAUGHLIN’S Suggestions to China Paint- Pdntknke SU6beehsthenerses Miles teubbbbeenseescens 1 00 MacLEAN’S Manual of the Antiquity of Man....... 1 00 MacLEAN’S The Mound-Builders.................... 1 50 MacLEAN’S Mastodon, Mammoth and Man......... 66 MANSFIELD’S Personal Memories—1803-1843, 200 METTENHEIMER’S Safet mg keeping, an ‘Ex- pose of Book-keepers’ Frauds................se0e 1 00 MORGAN'S The Shakspearean Myth................. 2 00 MURDOCH’S The Stage—Recollections of Fifty onecdGnabebin tedeked eakwuneusasiseesnscnsnces 200 MAE’S Life of Rev. Charles Nerinckx..... ... ...... 2 50 OHIO VALLEY Historical Miscellanies.............. 2 OSBORN, Ancient Egypt, in the Light of Modern PE cndnsdcbonesncenanticetnsseceacdccsecese 1 25 QUICK, Essays on Educational Reformers.......... 1 00 ROBERT, Charcoal Drawing Without a Master..... 1 00 THE ST. CLAIR PAPERS, edited by Wm. Henry SL, SE dudandicnenscasabaecendsenastedacsees 6 00 SMITH’S Captivity with the Indians—1755-59....... 2 50 Ty CR SED hn. 0 cdenccenscocenseseseeces 1 00 VAN HORNE’S History of the Army of the Cumber- ey. We Pe SE cnnccncendcccedceseececenss 6 00 a “eee Moravian Missionary—Diary 1781-98 6 00 Any of the above sent by mail, prepaid, on receipt of the price. ROBT. CLARKE & CO., Publishers, Cincinnati,
"Selon C. Nimmo’ S New Books. NEW VOLUMES OF THE ELIZABETHAN DRAMATISTS SERIES. Three Vols., post vo, cloth, price 7s. 6d per vol. net ; also large Fine-Paper copies. me- dium 8vo, cloth, each numbered. THE WORKS OF JOHN MARS- TON. Edited by A. H. BULLEN, B.A. Three Vols., post 8vo, cloth, price 7s. 6d. per vol. net ; also large Fine-Paper copies, me- _ dium 8vo, cloth, each numberea. WORKS OF CHRISTO- PHER MARLOWE. Edited by A. H. BULLEN, B.A. Eight Vols., post 8vo, 7s. 6d. per vol. net ; also large Fine-Paper copies, medium 8vo, cloth, each numbered. THE WORKS OF THOMAS MIDDLETON. Edited by A. H. BULLEN, B.A. The next issue of this series will be THE WORKS OF THOMAS DEKKER. in four volumes. The remaining dramatists of this Period will follow in due order. THE ELIZABETHAN DRAMATISTS. Note.—This is the first instalment towards a collective edition of the Dramatists who lived about the time of a ae type will be distributed after each One of the chief features of this New Edition of the Elizabethan Dramatists,"besides the handsome and em | size of the volumes, will be the fact that each work will be ares edited and new notes given throughout. —This series may be obtained either from Messrs. one zhton Mifflin & Co., Boston and New York, or from the nglish publishers. In Two Volumes, Demy 8vo, ‘wed parchment, gilt top, 30s. net Robin Hood Poems, Songs, and Ballads. A Collection of all the Ancient Poems, Songs,and Ballads now extant relative to that celebrat- ed English Outlaw. To which are eo Historical Anecdotes of his Life. , &. Ritson. Illustrated with Eighty \V Food na gravings by Bewick,printed on China Paper. Also Ten Etchings from Original! Paintings by A. H. Tourrier ani E. Buckman,
A New and Beautiful Edition of the Imitation of Christ. In demy 8vo, with fifteen etchings, bound in ful/ white parchment, gilt top, price 21s. net. The Imitation of Christ. Four Books. Translated from the Latin by Rev. W. Benham, B.D., Rector of St. Edmund, King and Martyr, Lombard Street, London.
A new volume of Elizabethan Lyrics. Small post 8vo, cloth, qilt top, hand-made paper, price 10s, 6d. net, each numbered. Lyrics from the Song Books of the Elizabethan Age. Edited by A. H. Bullen, B.A. Note.—This volume is printed at the Chiswick Press, and the edition limited to 5€0 copies. Type distributed.
Fine medium 8vo, paper, with Seven Illustra- tions on Japanese paper. Half parchment gut top, price 15s, net. Carols and Poems From the Fifteenth Century to the Present Time. Edited by A. H. Bullen, B.A. Note.—A complete List of J. C. NIMMO’S New Books for the autumn of 1886 may be had on application.
London: JOHN C. NIMMO, 14 King William Street, Strand, W.C.
Pee Set Sk haa a ae eel
Page 5
RETTIG Pere me ARR tigi The Nation. = NEW YORK, THURSDAY, OCTOBER 14, 1886. The Week. Tue expedient of calling in 3 per cent. bonds in large amounts has had little effect upon the supply of active money; and the offer of the Treasury to cash uncalled bonds on presenta- tion, though before the public for more than a month, has only elicited some two and a half millions. It is the most signal in a long series of proofs that the redemption of bonds by the Treasury, whatever else it may accomplish, does not act as an efficient relief to a money market which is habitually depleted by the Treasury's operations. So far as the money market is cramped by the collection of surplus revenue, the calling in of bonds offers, though with uncomfortable delays, an adequate re- turn. But the position is complicated by the presumed requirement of law to lock up all the lawful money received from national banks on account of bank notes retired. This lock-up has now reached the sum of nearly $70,- 000,000—a sum which withdraws the whole capital of the banks of this city, $59,312,700, and one-fourth of their surplus of $42,759,000. The Evening Post prints a memorandum on this subject, submitted in October, 1882, to Secre- tary Folger. The principles involved are un- changed; the money locked up is some seven- teen millions greater. The document is now published in order to bring its suggestions be- fore the business community. A correspondent asks why may not the na- tional-bank circulation be continued indefi- nitely, by the banks leaving in the Treasury the money received by them when their bonds are redeemed, except, of course, the 10 per cent. margin which the law requires when bonds are deposited. The answer is that that is exactly what is done, to a very large ex- tent. The October statement of the Comptrol- ler of the Currency shows that the sum of $68,529,417 lies in the Treasury to redeem an equal amount of national-bank notes. The one sum offsets the other. The national- bank circulation is not necessarily curtailed by the redemption of the bonds, but its elasticity is curtailed, or rather suppressed altogether, since the banks have ceased to exercise any control over it, and the Government has no function to discharge in the premises except to redeem it when the notes are presented for that purpose. As the law requires the money deposited by any bank for the redemption of its notes to be placed to the credit of the bank on the Treasurer's books, it is plain that the Department has no control over the deposit except for that specific purpose. To vest the Treasurer with any dis- cretion as to its use would be to authorize him to go into the banking business himself, for he could make no other use of it than to lend it to somebody, or possibly to redeem more bonds, which would be simply repeating the process. The important fact is, that the circulation of national-bank potes is not necessarily lessened by the redemption of bonds, but the aggregate circulation of banknotes and greenbacks is lessened, and that of silver certificates is aug- mented. The London Economist has lately had some interesting tables illustrative of the effect of the fall in the value of silver on trade. The bimetallists maintain that it has been very great, but have never been able to produce in support of their assertions facts not explainable on any other hypothesis. It so happens that while British imports from silver-using countries de- clined considerably after 1876, and were very high in 1882-3, they have been nearly steady during the other years which have since elapsed. Onthe other hand, British exports to silver-using countries have risen almost steadily since 1876 We reproduce the totals in millions TRADE WITH SILVER USING COUNTRIES Year. Imports. Ex ports. ili din hii rete £03,071 2OLST Serre re cre 64.051 OO.075 Ae ee ; T2917 116,058 A eer TAM) 65.400 RRR ree - 65 0389 os S59 Seer er errr er H5.7TRL 4.107 PER ce 63,088 51,421 ML Piskbaenchecee enue T1244 W471 The anti-ten hour strike in the pork-packing houses at Chicago has probably been precipi tated by the great decline in pork products There is just so much foundation for th charge that the packing-houses connived at ot were not averse to the strike. had ceased to be profitable, and it was detri mental to the interests of the trade to pile up more stock upon a glutted market. This is a situation Which not seldom comes to pass in other trades. be carried on so as to yield a profit by working ten hours a day, but cannot be carried on with eight hours’ labor, it is for the interest of all that the ten-hour rule should be adopted. If the facts are, as the men claim, that the int rests of the employers are served by a stop page, that is a first-rate argument for their a cepting the ten-hour rule, at least until the pork market improves. The business If the business can still The price of wheat in the Chicago market on Monday fell below seventy cents per bushel This is said to be the lowest quotation that has been seen in a quarter of a century. Can any one doubt that the American farmer has at last secured the ‘‘home market that he has been so manfully striving for these twenty-five vears under the blessings of a pro tective tariff’ He has been told from time to time that there was nothing like a tariff to make a market for his wheat and his corn and his pork ; that it was simply ridiculous to send his stuff 3,000 miles and pay freight on it when he could have a market at his own doors by keeping out foreign goods. He believed all this because it was so plausible and so easy to understand. He was told to ‘grin and bear it” until the manufacturers had time to get started, and then he would see good prices for everything he had to sell. He bas borne it since 1861, but without grinning = to any great extent, and he is still. He has been virtually hiring people to eat his products, and the more he bas hired the less he has got for what he had to sell, There is nothing very strange about this ex cept that the should have lasted so long bearing it delusion in the bucolic mind John M. Corse as Boston is an The appointment of Gen Postmaster of excellent one Gen. Corse was one of the finest officers who served in the Union army during the war and his exploits were such as in any Eun pean country would have been rewarded with all sorts of enduring testimonials. He has been a lifelong Democrat, and pathy party Uwavs in sym with the Naturally PPOLTESSI Ve element in his since his resi therefore dence in Massachusetts he bas opposed But lerism, and he has been «a hearty supporter of President Cleveland He is a sincere be civil service liever in reform, and may be trusted to enforce the law in the largest: post office of New England withas much fidelity to both its spirit and its letter as Collector Saltonstall has displaved in conductit the chief custom house in that division of the country Gen, Corse is a man of executive ability, and well qualified for the pasition Which he assumes. His appointment is thus in sharp contrast with that of his Republican pre- decessor, who Was given the place upon eles mosynary grounds, rather than because of any fitness for its responsibilities The President has now filled four of the chief Federal oftices in New England previously appointed Leverett Saltonstall Col lector of the Boston Custom bouse, George M Stearns United States Distriet Attorney for Massachusetts, and John E. Fit lector of Internal Revenue forthe Eastern Mas having yrerald Col sachusetts District, which is the most important in the Eastern States. No candid Republican will question the high quality of each of these appointments, and it is simple truth to say that together they represent a higher average of ability and character than has been seen in these four offices for years. An Administrn- tion is properly judged by the character of its appointments to the most responsible offices in its gift; and judged by this test, no fair-minded man will deny that the cause of good government in New England has gained rather than lost by the committal of the appointing power to a Democratic President. Nor can any shrewd politician fail to see that the party is stronger in New England by reason of such appointments than it would have been if these important offices had been turned over to Democratic spoilsmen. Democratic Mr. Andrew’s letter accepting the Demo- cratic nomination for the Massachusetts Gov- ernorship is a brief but admirable document, A better statement of the existing political situa- tion could not easily be made than this: ‘Two years ago the Republican party, which for a quarter of a century has controlled the national Government, was deprived of ite power by the deliberate action of the people,
Page 6
800 The Nation. [Number 1111 because it sought only its own preservation and stood for nothing but a political machine. Since then that party has shown an absolute un- willingness or incapacity to profit by the lesson of defeat, while the Democratic party has given the country an honest, able. and fearless Ad- ministration, satisfactory to the people, and has shown a progressive spirit ready to deal with the issues of the day. The intelligence of the nation, irrespective of political parties, heartily approves the earnest efforts of President Cleveland to divorce the civil service from politics ; to reduce the tariff to the requirements of times of peace ; to lessen the burden of taxation, and to prevent the coinage of a debased currency.” The nomination of Mr. Andrew appears to rain strength as the heads of the two tickets are contrasted, and he is receiving the hearty support of the Independent voters, never so numerous in Massachusetts as now. On the other hand, the Republican candidate arouses no enthusiasm in his own party, and the main reliance for his election is the hope that he may attract to his support the worst elements of the opposition. , The nomination of Mr. Abram 8. Hewitt by Tammany was probably the greatest surprise to which that institution has ever treated the public. He was one of the last men in the city we should have expected its managers to talk of, much less to nominate for high office. Thatit is a good nomination we hardly need to say. Mr. Hewitt is just the kind of man New York should always have for Mayor. His one defect is the condition of his health, but if elected he would, by a rigid enforce- ment of the Civil-Service Law and a rigid abstinence from ‘‘deals” or ‘‘dickers,” lessen the demands of the office on his strength and energy by at least one-half. He is an eminent business man, one of the largest and most successful employers of labor we have, an authority on most of the economical questions of the day, and has a_charac- ter on which, although he _ has_ been for long years in politics, nobody has ever been able to inflict the smallest damage. Whether he will accept we do not know, but if he does, we should think the best thing the County Democracy can do, if Mayor Grace will not run again, is to adopt thenomination. Mr. Hewitt is to all intents and purposes a County Democrat rather than a Tammany man. In fact, his production by Tammany for a municipal office would seem to indicate some serious internal change in the moral constitution of that body. The action of the County Democracy and of:-the Republi- cans will now be awaited with interest, The latter are still talking of Mr. Acton, but we believe he would not accept, possibly through dread of the ‘‘knife.” The ‘‘ boys” will probably hit on some one whose goodness will be less offensive. Henry George's submissiveness in taking away the plates of his book from the printing- office in which a strike was pending, in obe- dience to the demands of a trade union, is a fine illustration of the kind of Mayor he would be if elected, The strike was by boys, none of whom were old enough to be voters. When it first began, Mr. George was asked to in- tercede in behalf of the boys, but, nothing coming from that, a union ordered him to take the plates of his book away from the establish- ment on pain of their immediate displeasure, which was, of course, a threat not to vote for him for Mayor. Mr. George submitted at once, swallowing his frequently uttered protests against dictation. When he was asked a few days ago about the threat of one of his campaign leaders to ‘‘spot” every union man who ‘‘scabbed” on election day, he said that the ‘‘labor organizations were not so low as that,” and that the ‘spirit of the labor movement was the reverse of coercive.” Now he submits tamely to ‘‘ coer- cion ” upon himself, and does all he can to as- sist a boycott which is brought in aid of a strike. He would be a fine ‘‘ reformer” to have in the Mayor’s chair if the demands of every union were to be yielded to as meekly as this one was. Mr. George apparently has great faith in the ‘free lunch” contingent of the labor party. He said in a speech on Monday night: ‘*T want you to show these political managers that the workingmen have a mght to be heard right here in New York. Why, as you are now placed, you have no rights but to work, and toil, and pay what you earn for the privilege of liv- ing. Why have you no rights? Because you have not asserted them. These horse cars that run along your streetsshould be as free as air— just as free as the elevator that carries you up into the upper stories of tall buildings. It 1s your privilege to have cars to run you out to the unoccupied land that lies all about you and is held by the millionaires for a rise.” If the workingmen are entitled to free horse- cars, and free house lots, why not to free cabs and free meals and free theatre tickets? Why limit their ‘‘ rights” at all? They will need to have everything free if Mr. George’s theories about their not having to toil and work and pay for their living are to be put into practice. The Governor's action in pardoning the Theiss boycotters strikes us as humane and wise. All of his reasons must command the respect of fair-minded men. There is no doubt that the boycotters were ignorant of the fact that they were violating the law. They did not know that there was anything in the Penal Code which applied to boycotting, and their ignorance is not surprising, for at the time of their offence the same ignorance pre- vailed in the editorial rooms of nearly the entire press of the country. It required re- peated quotations from the Penal Code and re- peated exhortations to the press of the country to explore its treasures, to disseminate the valua- ble information that boycotting was a crime, and that persons practising it were liable to fine and imprisonment. The sentence of the Theiss boycotters was a valuable lesson not only to them and other laboring men, but to the newspaper press of the country as well. Having received their lesson, and _hav- ing promised that, if pardoned, they would refrain from boycotting in the future and obey the laws of the land, the Theiss boycotters have served a most useful purpose. They bad the strong excuse of ignorance, since they were the first to be tried under the law. Future of- fenders will not have this excuse, and the Gov- ernor’s act cannot, therefore, be made a pre- cedent, The meeting of the American Board at Des Moines has taken action on the question of the conduct of the Prudential Committee in re- jecting, or even virtually recalling, missionaries who do not hold the Committee’s views of the ultimate fate of the heathen, But the action as reported is only the familiar verdict of ‘‘ Not guilty, but don’t do it again.” Itis a settlement which settles nothing. From the nature of things this must be the case. The differ- ence between the two parties is fundamental, and the cleavage extends from the bottom to the top, leaving no possible point of meeting. One side holds that the heathen must be for ever lost if the Gospel be not preached to them in this world; the other believes that opportunities of salvation may be afforded after death. There is no possi- bility of ‘“‘hasmonizing” these views, and as there exists no authority in the Congregational order to declare which belief is true or binding, the divergence must continue. It is a striking sign of the times that whereas Mills and his companions had only an ardent, unquestioning desire to send the Gospel to the heathen, the American Board of to-day, outcome of the prayers and labors of those pioneers of mis- sions, is inquiring what the Gospel is. One serious trouble in the matter is, that many of the leading ministers of the denomination in this country hold and preach the probation the- ory, and the question therefore arises very na- turally why, if this doctrine is so poisonous for the heathen, it can be administered in such large doses to Americans without mischief. Mr. Newman Smyth of New Haven and Dr. Ward of the Independent would probably be consi- dered excellent missionaries to the heathen, and yet they teach the probation heresy in this country. The case of the poor heathen is, un- der the circumstances, a very hard one. When they are converted, and hear for the first time about eternal damnation, they are natu- rally very solicitous about the fate of their dead relatives, and would like to get some sort of assurance, knowing what kind of people they were, that they were getting another chance to behave decently in the next world. But the Board is unwilling to have the mis- sionaries say a single word of cheer to them on this subject, so that the poor fellows receive with Christianity the awful revelation that the better Christians they are, the more certain it is to them that they will never see any of their de- ceased kinsmen again. . The Andover professors who believe in the ‘*second probation ” theory are to be brought to trial on a charge of fraud—that is, that they are drawing their salaries under a pledge to teach certain doctrines which they do not teach. The culprits are five in number, and their offence isknown as ‘‘the Andover Hypothesis.” The Board of Visitors of the College has summoned them to appear and answer October 25, but the professors have denied the jurisdiction of the Board, and there the matter rests until the 25th. That the charge is very serious may be inferred from the fact that the complain- ants look on the hypothesis as destructive of the doctrine of the atonement, of eternal punishment, and of the inspiration of the Scriptures. If this be true, of course, the controversy over the missionaries is a very subordinate incident in the affair. The trial, if it takes place before an ecclesiastical court, must be very long, but the case will, in all likelihood, find its way eventually into a court of law, as theological controversies are apt to do when the question of salary is involved. OTE TIT NS LONER
Page 7
ee LU Oct. 14, 1886] v he Nation. The Register of the Treasury adds a note to the list of ‘‘ balances due toand from the United States,” which has lately been published, calling attention to the necessity of looking into each of the several statements in order to determine the indebtedness of a particular officer. That is, after finding a balance set down against one, further search may show him a creditor on an- other account, The Register maintains that this state of affairs ‘‘ demonstrates the necessity of a system of unification, where a total indebted- ness can be found at one glance.” It seems strange that the Negister, who is the official bookkeeper of the Treasury, clothed with im- portant powers, and supplied with a large corps of clerks, cannot introduce this demon- strably necessary change in the method of keeping the Government accounts. But the truth is, as may be inferred from the plaintive note in question, he is powerless. He is, as his title indicates, a mere ‘‘ register” of the balances which are certified to him by the Comptrollers, and each of these works in igno- rance of the operations of the others. The First Comptroller, for example, may to-mor- row certify a balance to be due to a marshal or to a consul of the United States, and order its payment, too, though the Commissioner of Customs may bave a large outstanding dif- ference against the same individual as a former Collector, or though the Second Comp- troller may have been urging him for years to close his accounts as late paymaster in the navy. Under the present system this frequently occurs, and when it does not occur it is due to some accident or to the superero- gatory diligence of a clerk. What is needed to bring about the unification of the accounts, as well as other important reforms, is a radical change in the present system of accounting. We have long since outgrown the present sys- tem, which was adapted to our wants when we had but one Auditor and one Comptroller. We now have six Auditors and three Comp- trollers (calling the Commissioner of Customs a comptroller), who act independently of each other, and often at cross purposes, who establish rules of evidence and methods of procedure which are constantly clashing, and who allow credits to an officer without confereuce with each other concerning his accounts rendered in another official capacity. It is obvious that a consolida ion of the three Comptrollers, or the bringing of them into more intimate relations than at present exist, would be a palpable im- provement of our civil service. The correspondence between Mr. Phelps and Mr. Allen Thorndike Rice about the non-presentation of tte latter to the Prince of Wales has been printed, and is very droll, all the droller because it was Mr. Rice who pub- lished it. Mr. Phelps’s letter would have been cruel if written to a person with keener percep- tions than Mr. Rice, but he rallied after it promptly, and took bis revenge by intimat- ing that he (Rice) did not consider Mr. Phelps fit for his place. What made the letter cruel was Mr. Phelps’s production in full of the undoubted fact that the pre- sentation of any American at court is a purely discretionary civility on the part of the Minister, and always has been so: and Mr. Rice’s claim- jog it as a right, and denouncing its refusal as “‘censorship of the press,” was therefore al- most as funny as his claiming a dinner at the Legation would have been. The Minister is supreme judge of the expediency of presenting anybody. He would not present a personal ene- my, nor would he present the editor of the Police Gazette, and nobody would be silly enough to ask him for his reasons. It would have been a gross impropriety to present to the Prince of Wales the author or editor of a blackguard lampoon on his superior officer and personal friend, the Secretary of State; and the Prince of Wales, we are sure, would be the first man in England to recognize the fitness of his refusal One of the drollest things in Mr. Rice's letter, however, is his calling ‘‘ Arthur Richmond,” the blackguard whom he admitted to his Review, **The Press,” and denouncing any- body who did not like ‘ Richmond's” ruffianism, as a ‘‘censor.” Calling him **The Press” reminds one of the practice of call ing strikers ‘‘ Labor” when they are throwing brickbats at non-unionists, If Mr. Rice were to let a man occupy one of his front windows to abuse the passers by, or distribute libel lous handbills on his sidewalk, he would, we suppose, consider any one who gave him a good kicking an enemy of ‘* Liberty.” A queer controversy has started up respect ing the ‘‘ loyalty” of a school-book published by the house of A. S. Barnes & Co., entitled a ‘Brief History of the United States,’ by the late Prof. J. Dorman Steele of Elmira, N. Y. The question was raised a few weeks ago in the Grand Army Post at Saratoga whether this work was suitable to be putin the hands of youth as a text-book,Nand it was decided in a qualified way in the negative. tion is now agitating the Board of Education of Newark. The facts have been brought out that the book has been in use fourteen years without a word of disapproval un til now on the score of loyalty; that it was prepared by a Union soldier who was desperately wounded at the battle of Fair Oaks while leading his men (Company K, Eighty-firsts New York Volunteers) in ac tion; that it received the approval of the official organ of the Grand Army of the Republic (the National Tridune), and that the principal charge brought against it— that of underrating the numbers of Lee's army at the final surrender at Appomattox, and thus belitthng the achievements of Gen. Grant—is untrue, since the author in a foot-note gave the official returns of both sides. Such a contro versy has more of the marks of a fight among book agents for the command of the market than of a competitive examination for loyalty, The ques The biennial report upon the schools of Vermont by Superintendent Dartt, presented to the Legislature upon its meeting last week, shows that the educational system of the State is retrograaing rather than improv- ing. In 1880 the number of children en- rolled in school at some time during the year was 73,952, while in 1886 it has sunk to 71,667. As the last census showed 99,463 per- sons of school age, it follows that only 72 per cent. of the children now enter a public school, against more than 74 per cent. six years ago. The present proportion falls below that in four Sp ae nmerions —— _ 301 of the Southern States—Delaware, West Vir- ginia, Florida, and Texas—79 per cent. of all the children being enrolled in the last named commonwealth, while Missouri is within 4 per cent. of Vermont's record, and even South Carolina falls but 9 per cent. behind Senator Pike of New Hampshire, who died on Friday, had suffered so much fron? ill health since he was elected three years ago that he had not been able to show his quality, which was much above the ruling level in’ New Hamp shire Senators of late years crank, like his associate Blair, nor a mere wire puller, like Rollins, whom he succeeded, but a He was neither a man of good ability and unusual independence fora State where partisans are as a rule so hide bound. Itisto be regretted that he did not enjoy the opportunity of doing something to relieve New Hampshire Republicanism from the reputation of charlatanism in statesmanship or the Machine reprewnting only in politics. The Legislature which is to be elected) next month will have the choice of his) successor, but as that txxly will not, in the regular course of things, meet until next: June, the Governor will appoint a man Who will fill the seat during the next ses sion of Congress. The Democrats are given an unex cted chance to gain a seat in the up per branch of Congress by Mr. Pike's death, but they have only carried the Legislature twice (in IST71 and in 1874) during the thirty years since the Republican party was formed, and it is not very likely they will have such a piece of good luck this year We say it with deep pain, but we cannot avoid it, that in our opinion the Suva demon strated on Monday that Lieutenant Schwatka did not River,” or any other river in Alaska, and that the discover ‘‘the Jones river to which he has given the name of “Jones” has been known to the Russian and other explorers for a century or there- abouts. Unless the Sun's reproduction of the map from Telmenkoff’s Atlas is a base forgery, it is fatal to the contention of the 7¥mes that Schwatka had any right to give a name to any river in that region, This resuit is made all the more melancholy by the simultaneous: ap- pearance in the 7imes of a sarcastic poem, con- taining passages of great power and beauty, di- rected against the editor of the Sun. But for the Tebienkoff’s Atlas it would have been diffi- cult for the editor of the Swn to stand up against this poem, The Atlas has saved him in the providential way in which a copy of the New Testament ina young man’s waistcoat pock- et occasionally stops a bullet in battle. We need hardly say that we do not think any blame in the matter attaches to Mr. Jones beyond over-confidence in Schwatka, who is, we should say, a sanguine, fussy sort of person, whose ‘* discoveries " should be received with great caution. To Mr. Jones the mortifica- tion of having his name forcibly detach- ed from the river will doubtless be great, but giving one’s name to rivers or mountains, in the teeth of opposition, is a delicate business on which a prudent man will not venture, It is a distinction in which the civilized world has to acquiesce, in order to give it any perma- nence or value, er Page Saree
Page 8
302 The Nation. [Number 1111 BSUMMARY OF THE WEEK’S NEWS. ([Wepwespay, October 6, to Tugspay, October 12, 1886 inclusive. DOMESTIC. A FeEpeERAL office-holder has decided to re- sign on account of the President’s order about non interference in politics. Philip Kumler, United States District-Attorney and Republi- can candidate for the Common Pleas Judge- ship in Cincinnati, will send his resignation to the President. The President is reported to be very indignant at the way in which his order has been violated, and it is believed that he will make conspicuous examples of several offenders. The United States District Attorney who has been warned by the Administration that he must resign if he desires to run for Congress,is understood to be A. J. Delaney of Wisconsin, who defeated Gen. Bragg for renomination in his Congressional district. Mr. Delaney has recently said that he did not under stand that the order prevented any man from seeking another office, and he believed he could hold his present oftice until he became a repre- sentative of the Second District in Congress. Charges of interference in active politics are brought against Collector Troup of New Haven, and Collector Bishop of Cincinnati. Gen. John M. Corse has been appointed Postmaster at Boston. He has a brilliant record as a soldier. The Civil-Service Commission in all proba- bility will amend the civil-service rules so that employees may be transferred from the various departments throughout the country to places at the national capital. The object is to strengthen the service in the departments there. The American schooner Marion Grimes was released on Tuesday afternoon at Port Shel- burne, N. 8.. Consul Phelan having deposited $400 for the fine. The British Minister at Washington, acting on instructions from his Government, has ap- plied to the Department of State for all in- formation obtainable in regard to the recent seizures of the British Columbian schooners Onward, Thornton, and Carolina by the U. 8. revenue steamer Corwin, for alleged violation ot the laws regulating the hunting of seals in Alaskan waters, The New York Times on Sunday said : ‘“We take pleasure in laying before the public copies of several letters bearing upon the re- ported misconduct of Mr. Sedgwick, the Special Agent of the State Department, in the City of Mexico. The testimony of these letters is strong in vindication of Mr. Sedgwick and in support of his own published denial. We are confident that they will be accepted by his friends and the public as a sufficient answer to the accusations brought against him.” From the annual report of Gen. Miles as commander of the Department of Arizona, in New Mexico, it appears that the surrender of Geronimo was unconditional. Gen. Miles in his report argues at some length the question of punishment, and calls attention to the fact that heretofore in such cases removal has been deemed sutficient. He suggests that the Apa- ches be treated as other Indians have been under similar circumstances. He highly compliments Capt. Lawton, Lieut. Gatewood, and the offi- cers and soldiers generally for their meritorious services during the campaign. Judge Brown of the United States Court at Detroit, Mich., on Monday handed down his decision in the case of the United States against John Craig, on the action brought to recover a penalty of $1,000 provided for in the ‘‘ Assist- ed Immigration Act” of February 26, 1886. Judge Brown sustains the constitutionality of the law. Gen. Gordon was on Wednesday elected Governor of Georgia without a contest. Two amendments to the Constitution were almost unanimously adopted. The first was to extend the power of the Legislature, which now may furnish limbs to maimed ex-Confederates, so that in its discretion the relief may take any other form. The effect of this amendment will be to give Georgia an extended pension list, The second amendment is to permit local legis- lation to originate in the Senate as well as in the House, instead of in the House exclusively, as formerly. The majority of the Legislature is undoubtedly for the policy of prohibition. The Colorado Democrats on Wednesday nominated Alva Adams for Governor. The platform favors the free and unlimited coinage of silver on the same terms as gold, and criti- cises the Republican party, claiming that they have while in power created and maintained gigantic monopolies, resulting in serious con- flicts between capital and laber, which now agitate all sections of the country. It alsocom- mends President Cleveland ‘‘ for his impartial execution of the Civil-Service Law,” and con- gratulates the Democratic party on its return to power,and upon the “ honesty and integrity which, by reason of such return, has cha- racterized the administration of public affairs during the past two years.” In his letter accepting the Republican nomi- nation for Governor of New Jersey, B. F. Howey says: ‘I have carefully examined the platform adopted by the Convention, and am in hearty accord with its declarations. In ac- knowledging the distinguished honor conferred upon me by the Convention, I beg to say that 1am a Jerseyman by birth, as were my ances- tors; that my interests are coupled with the prosperity of the State, and that my affection for the commonwealth is such that, should I be called upon to act as her Chief Magistrate, it will be my constant care to guide her inte- rests and protect her honor.” At the Tammany Hall Convention on Mon- day night Mr. Abram S. Hewitt was nomi- nated for Mayor of New York by acclamation. The motion was made by P. Henry Dugro, who had previously declined in committee to accept the nomination himself. The nomina- tion wasa complete surprise to the uninitiated. It is probable that the County Democracy will approve the nomination. Mr. Hewitt has not yet signified his intention to accept. Richard H. Dana recently wrote to John F. Andrew, Democratic candidate for Governor of Massachusetts: ‘‘I hope 1 am not asking too much when I beg you will let me and the public generally know if there is any truth in the rumors of your contributing large sums to the Democratic campaign fund? I have heard denials also.” Mr, Andrew rephed: ‘I am happy to reply that I have long thought that the extent to which money is used in po- litical campaigns is very injurious, and that candidates for office should not be called upon to supply funds. The leaders of the Demo- cratic party were informed of my views upon this subject before the Convention tendered me its nomination, and they recognized their en- tire propriety. They knew that money would not be furnished by me, directly or indirectly, for campaign purposes, and they perfectly un- derstood that this is my fixed determination.” Mr. Dana has announced that he will support Mr. Andrew for Governor, and the whole Mugwump organization of 1884 will proba bly work in his favor. 70v. Hill on Saturday commuted the sen- tences of the Theiss boycotters to’ 100 days’ imprisonment in State prison, which made their terms expire on Tuesday. The Governor has written an elaborate opinion giving his rea- sons for this decision, among which are the fol- lowing: That the prisoners were not aware that they were violating any law of the State in what they did; that the prisoners are honest workingmen who do not belong to the criminal class, and this was their first offence; that they are now penitent, and have promised in writing to hereafter cease boycotting and obey the laws of the State; that the District At- torney of New York favors the commutation of the sentence; that the prisoners, or nearly all of them, have families dependent upon them for support, and are all poor men worthy of Exe- cutive clemency. Notices were on Thursday morning posted in all the stock-yards’ packing-houses in Chicago to the effect that on and after Monday the hours of work would be ten instead of eight, as is now the rule. The notices were signed by nineteen firms, comprising all the packers of consequence in Chicago. Another great strike of pork-packers was accordingly begun on Fri- day. About 16,000 men are involved. Order has been well preserved. The Convention of Knights of Labor at Richmond, Va., has not yet succeeded in transacting any important business, Mr. Powderly has written a letter on the color-line, which aims to conciliate both North and South, and in effect recommends a proper respect for local prejudices. Judge Gary, in the Criminal Court of Chi- cago on Thursday, overruled the motion for a new trial in the cases of the eight Anarchists charged with the Haymarket massacre, and confirmed the verdict of the jury that Spies, Parsons, Fielden, Schwab, Engel, Fischer, and Lingg should be hanged, and that Neebe should suffer imprisonment for fifteen years in the State Penitentiary. On Saturday they were sentenced to be hanged on December 3. Ove of the indicted ex-Aldermen of 1884, H. L. Sayles, has fled to Canada. His brother and bondsman, after transferring his property, has also left the city. Ten of the ex-Aldermen were rearrested on Tuesday afternoon on a bench warrant, and required to give more bail. In the Protestant Episcopal Convention at Chicago on Thursday, Dr. Huntington’s motion to appoint a joint committee to consider the whole subject of liturgical revision, and report not later than the tenth day of the session, was adopted. The following is the committee : Bishops Williams, Bedell, Doane, and Lyman, the Rev. Drs. Huntington of New York, Egar of Central New York, Gold of Chicago, Hart of Connecticut, and Hale of Iowa, Messrs. Sheffey of Virginia, Nash of New York, Dr. Shattuck of Massachusetts, Packard of Mary- land, and Gilbert of Long Island. At the conclusion of the long debate of the American Board of Congregational Foreign Missions on Thursday relating to the new de- arture, the following was resolved : ‘‘ That the ~~ recognizes and approves the principle up- on which the Prudential Committee has con- tinued to act in regard to appointments for mis- sionary service, in strictly conforming to the well-understood and permanent basis of doc- trinal faith upon which the missions of the Board have been steadily conducted, and to which, in the exercise of its sacred trust, the Committee had no option but to conform. The Board is constrained to look with yreat apprehension upon certain tendencies of the doctrine of a probation after death which have been recently broached and diligently propagated, that seemed divisive and perversive and dan- “— to the churches at home and abroad. n view of these tendencies they do heartily approve of the action of the Prudential Com- mittee in carefully guarding the Board from any committal to the approval of that doctrine, and advise a continuance of that caution in time tocome. The Board recommends to the Prudential Committee to consider, in difficult cases turning upon doctrinal views of candi- dates for missionary service, the expediency of calling a council of the churches, to be consti- tuted in some manner which may be deter- mined by the good judgment of the Committee, to pass upon the theological soundness of the candidate; and the Committee is instructed to report upon this matter to the Board at the next annual meeting.” The resolution was adopted by a two-thirds vica-voce vote. All the members of the Prudential Committee were re- elected on Friday except Dr. Thwing and PT
Page 9
itso abeuaatl Oct. 14, 1886] The Nation. 3083 Prof. E. C. Smyth of Andover. The former could not act again because of his removal to the West, and the latter was dropped. Charges of heresy have been preferred against five Andover professors, and brought before the Board of Visitors. They are ac- cused of preaching the doctrine of second pro- bation. Senator Austin F, Pike of New Hampshire died suddenly on Friday at the age of sixty- seven. His term would have expired in 1889. Ex-Senator David Levy Yulee of Florida died in this city on Sunday after a six days’ illness. Mr. Yulee caught a severe cold on a Fall River steamer and died of pneumonia. He was born at St. Thomas, W. I., in 1811. His name was David Levy. His father took him to Virginia in his boyhood. He removed to Florida in 1824, studied law, and became a planter. He was elected to the Twenty-seventh and Twenty-eighth Congresses, and changed his name to David Levy Yulee. From De- cember 1, 1845, to March 3, 1851, and again from 1855 to 1860, he was United States Sena- tor from Florida. He went with his State in the secession war, and was confined in Fort Pulaski in 1865 as a prisoner of State. Rear-Admiral Edward T. Nichols, United States Navy, died in Pomfret, Conn., on Tues- day, at the age of sixty-three years. Admiral Nichols was one of the most efficient Union naval officers during the recent war. He was born in Georgia in 1823. In 1836 he entered the navy, and in 1850 was made a lieutenant. During the first two years of the civil war he commanded the Winona of the West Gulf Blockading Squadron. When Farragut’s fleet went up the Mississip oi he accompanied it, and it fell to his lot to receive the surrender of the two strong rebel forts, Jackson and St. Philip, on which the Confederates depended for the safety of New Orleans. He was also in the river engagement against Vicksburg, and as- sisted in penning up and destroying the rebel ram Arkansas. In 1866 he commanded the Mendota of the North Atlantic Squadron, and was on duty in New York for two years. His promotions were to a captaincy in 1866, to the rank of Commodore in 1872, and to that of Rear-Admiral in 1878. FOREIGN. The Bulgarian Government has notified the foreign consuls at Sofia that Gen. Kaulbars, through the Russian consul at Rustchuk, or- dered the military commander there to release the political conspirators in his custody, threat- ening to hold him responsible if he disobeyed, promising him as a reward for compliance pro- motion to the rank of Commander General ‘‘when the Russians arrive,” and informing him that the penalty of refusal would be reduc- tion to the ranks. The Commander informed the troops under his command that he had receiv- ed and declined the command, and the soldiers applauded his conduct. Gen. Kaulbars has telegraphed to the Czar that he must now be either recalled or furnish- ed with troops. The failure of his mission is enerally admitted. It is reported that the Russian Government is preparing a note to the Powers, which will be the forerunner of deci- sive measures in Bulgaria. A plot has been discovered to create revolts throughout the two Bulgarias by means of armed bands engaged by the Russian Consulates at Sofia, Philippo- polis, and Rustchuk. Several of the ring- leaders have been arrested. In the Bulgarian city elections for members of the Great Sobranye to elect a successor to Prince Alexander, all the Government candi- dates have been successful. M Karaveloff, pro-Russian, received but 50 votes out of the 1,500 castin his district. During the elections on Sunday, Macedonians inspired by the Rus- sian Consulate endeavored to create a disturb- ance. The returns of the Bulgarian elections so far show that 400 Ministerialists and 21 Pro-Rus- sians or Zankovists have been chosen, Al! the members of the Ministry have been elected by immense majorities. It is said that Prince Alexander 1s prepared to accept the Bulgarian throne if retlected. A despatch from St Petersburg says that the Czar, while discussing recently the Bulgarian crisis, said: “If the Bulgarian question can be settled peaceably, well and good, but I will not go to war for the sake of the disorderly Bulgarians.” The news papers of St. Petersburg are unanimously of opinion that decisive action by Russia in regard to Bulgaria is imperative. Rumors were current on Thursday to the ef fect that a conspiracy had been discovered to kidnap King Milan of Servia, and to force him to abdicate, with the alternative of death. They have not been confirmed. M. Karaveloff has resigned as Regent in Bulgaria. Gen. Kaul bars has been treated with marked coolness during his tour through Bulgaria, Premier Von Taaffe, in the Lower House of the Austrian Parliament on Friday, replying to interpellations, said that any supposition that the relations between Austriaand Germany had been shaken were completely groundless. ‘‘The relations rest now, as hitherto,” added the Premier, ‘‘ on the basis which the Ministry have repeatedly defined before the Delegation, There is no occasion to apprehend any loosen ing or disturbance of the close and trustful re lations existing on both sides.” It is currently rumored at Constantinople that France, Russia, and Turkey are on the eve of coming to an understanding, and that Turkey will send an ultimatum to England demanding the immediate evacuation of Egypt There is a vivid growth of the war feeling in France. The Boulanger party have begun the issue of two new journals—La Rerunche and Le Soldat Labourenr—io advocate an of fensive policy in vindication of the old military prestige of France. Gen. Boulanger, however, disowns any connection with the papers. M Lavedon, the military critic, writes to the Figaro that Gen. Boulanger has prepared a well-conceived plan, in conjunction with a staff officer of high rank, for a Continental campaign. The Militaire says that Gen. Bou langer desires war, not for the purpose of re covering Alsace, not to gratify personal ambi tion, but asa step leading to the solution of se cial questions. The strictest taboo of every thing German is being observed. Premier de Freycinet has informed his col leagues in the French Cabinet that the disputes between the Malagasys and the French in Madagascar are almost settled. Louise Michel has been pardoned and will soon be released. It is reported that Sefor Zorilla left France voluntarily in order to prevent embarrassment to the French Government. It now appears that the Spanish Cabinet really resolved to confirm the sentence of death against the revolutionists, but an under-secre tary misunderstood Premier Sagasta, and an nounced to the waiting crowd that the sentence had been commuted, and it was quickly spread over the country. The whole Cainet resolved to resign. The Queen thereupon called on Sefior Sagasta to form a new Cabinet. The Queen has signed a decree freeing the re mainder of the slaves in Cuba from their terms of servitude. A new Spanish Cabinet has been formed as follows: Minister of the Council, Sefiior Sagas- ta; Minister of Foreign Affairs, Sefior Moret ; Minister of Justice, Sefiior Martinez ; Minister of Finance, Sefior Puigcerver; Minister of the Interior, Sefor Leon Castillo; Minister of Pub lic Works, Seftor Rodrigo ; Minister of War, Gen. Castillo ; Minister of Marine, Admiral Arias; Minister of the Colonies; Sefior Bala- guer. It is rather more conservative than the receding. The first act of the Ministry will to raise the siege. It will endeavor to check the disaffection in the army, and will pursue a policy compatible with the gradual execution of the Liberal programme, A London newspaper reports the details of a startling Anarchist plot to destroy Vienna and to assassinate Emperor Francis Joseph ‘he conspirators, whose plans were frustrated by the authorities, had intended to carry out the plot on October 4.) A large number of for eigners and Austrians were arrested, The ring leader escaped to Germany The Vienna police have furnished the press with an account of the plot. Although many deiails are obviously suppressed, it ts shown to have surpassed in extent and diabolicwl ingenuity any dynamite plot) hitherto con cocted, Seventeen of the conspigitors have been arrested. An examination of the prisor ers shows that the plot was hatched in and directed from America and London, and was to be carried out by Viennese Anarchists who recently returned from America The plan was cleverly discovered The conspirators were divided into several groups, one of which was detailed to set fire to the city, another to take charge of the dynamite operations, and another to forge the neces SSary official docu ments and to coin money forexpenses. Parties were detailed to set fire to Penzing, Untermeid ling, Hetzendorf, Meidling, and Favoriten The police got wind of the plot and: watched until it was almost mature, Thev receive universal praise for their zeal and circum spection., The Russian Government will introduce a tobacco monopoly throughout the empire in 1887, The London Davy Newe announced on Sa turday morning, ina two column article, that the Government intend to bring in a bill estab lishing home rule in Ireland upon the basis of four national councils, representing the pro vinces. It added that Lont Hartington and Mr. Chamberlain had been consulted aboui this. Both were prepared to support it. The Marquis of Hartington has authorized a denial of the statement that he has promised to sup port the bill. The London Dady News said on Monday morning: ‘It is the intention of the Govern ment, after promising a home-rule bill, to take up the procedure measure as the first business of the session, The Government have so inti- mated to Lord Harf€&igton and Mr. Chamber lain, but nothing definite has been arranged. Although the Government hope to carry the home rule measure by a majority of 100, they prefer to secure the right of closure first. It is likely that the Parnellites will object to the Government's programme, and insist that Irish affairs be the first business.” The Conservative newspapers avoid direct mention of the Daily Newze's statement that the Government will introduce a bill giving four provincial councils to Ireland. The Standard refers to ‘ big gooseberry revelations of im- portant Cabinet secrets before the Ministers themselves have arrived at any decision.” The bill is generally discredited. The Director of Catholic Missions in Paris has been informed that 700 Christians have been massacred in Tanhoa, Tonquin; also that thirty villages in that district have been burned, and 9,000 inhabitants are starving. Advices from Apia, Samoa, state that the English, German, and American Commission- ers have begun their conference respecting the rights and claims of their respective Govern- ments in the Samoan Is!ands. ‘The conference is said to be proceeding smoothly. The column of British and Indian troops sent from Minhla, Burmah, to relieve a sur- rounded garrison, has succeeded in performing the mission. It took the column six days to make a march of thirty miles through one jungle. In this the troops found several cruci- tied British messengers. Every officer and nearly every man in the rescued garrison was prostrated with fever when the relieving ex- pedition reached them. The long overdue steamer Anchoria arrived at St, John’s, New Foundland, on Monday; all on board well. She had broken her shaft. — Ps nae - OO age ms
Page 10
304 The Nation. [Number 1111 THE RECORD AS TO THE OFFICES. Tue Civil Service Record has rendered the pub- lic a great service, in securing and publishing a large collection of statistics as to the changes which have been made in the various executive departments since the new Administration came in, a year ago last spring, The lack of such data hitherto has prevented anything like a comprebensive exposition of the facts, and it has consequently been impossible to show with any approach to exactness the real state of the case. The Record’s tables enable us to get at the truth, and the showing is full of interest The first thing which strikes one is the evi- dence that the Civil-Service Law has been strictly enforced. This is furnished by the ta- ble of removals in the ‘‘classified service,” which is the term adopted to designate that part of the service subject to the law of 1888. There are about 5,650 such places in the departments at Washington, and, un- der the old spoils system of a ‘‘clean sweep” upon a change of national administration, this army of clerks appointed under Repub- lican rule would have been discharged in short order. In point of fact, between March 4, 1885, and June 16, 1886 (since which latter date very few changes have been made), the whole number of removals aggregated but 368, or only one in every fifteen persons, and thirteen of these were on account of reduction of force. In some departments the reasons for discharges are furnished in every case, and it is evident that they were made solely for the good of the service. Thus in the War Department sixty-one persons were removed during this period, and Secretary Endicott gives these as the causes: Reduction of appropriations, 10; services no longer required, 15; to accept appointments in other departments, 2; inattention to duty, 2; intemperance, 7 ; absence without leave, 6 ; in- efficiency, 10 ; misconduct,8; political, 1. Ten persons in the classified service in the Post-office Department were removed, and the cause in each case is recorded, as, ‘‘ drinking to excess,” ‘‘ ab- sent from duty without permission,” etc. It thus clearly appears that the Civil-Service Law inter- poses no obstacle to removals for the good of the service, while the impossibility of filling vacancies except upon proved merit, as estab- lished by competitive examinations, removes the motive for discharging efficient employees to make room for personal or political favor- ites. The moderation of the Administration in the use of the removing power is also shown by the record as to changes in the unclas- sified service, to which the law does not apply. The detailed statistics as to these are given in the case of the Interior Department, and they show that out of about 1,080 such employees only 223, or one-fifth, were removed. The 105 resignations doubt- less include a large number of persons who would have been removed had they not vo- luntarily taken themselves out of the way; but even lumping all the removals and resignations together as forced, they amount to only 30 per cent. of the whole mumber who might have been summarily got rid of with- out any violation of law. Even in the Department of Justice, among the Territorial judges, the United States attorneys, marshals, etc., only two-thirds of the whole number have been changed, and our readers have doubtless noticed that one of the Federal at- torneys whose resignation has just been de- manded, because he has been nominated for another office by his party, is an Ohio Republi- can. The showing as to the diplomatic service is peculiarly creditable and encouraging, since this branch of the Government has long been the refuge of broken-down party hacks. The changes made in this service since Mr. Bayard became Secretary of State, counting every- thing, from an envoy extraordinary and minister plenipotentiary down to an interpre- ter, aggregate only 144 out of 327 such offi- cers in the service of the United States, or only 44 per cent. The Administration at Washington has changed from one party to another for the first time in a quarter of a century, and a list compiled in the second year of that Administration shows that, in- stead of the old-fashioned ‘‘clean sweep” abroad, much less than half of the representatives of this Government in foreign lands have been changed. To understand what this really means, one should contrast this record with that made four years before, when there was not a change of parties, but only of representatives of the same party in the executive departments. When Mr. Garfield became President and made Mr. Blaine Secretary of State, he found the diplomatic service filled with men appoint- ed by Republicans, yet during the four months between March 4, 1881, and the day of the Guiteau tragedy, no less than fifty-five changes were made in a total number of offices then but little exceeding 300. In other words, changes were made in 18 per cent. of the diplomatic offices within four months by Mr. Blaine as a Republican Secretary of State, against only 44 per cent. in more than a year by Mr. Bayard as a Demo- cratic Secretary, although the change of par- ties presented the strongest temptations and ex- cuses for wholesale changes in the latter case. Such figures as these are full of encourage- ment to the friends of civil-service reform. They show that the system of treating public offices as public trusts is steadily making bead- way; indeed, that it has already become too thoroughly entrenched ever to be overthrown by the spoilsmen. THE RECENT THEOLOGICAL CONTRO- VERSIES. WE are not concerned to note the merely eccle- siastical relations and results of what is known as the Andover movement. Still less do we feel called upon to discuss the theological bear- ings of the points at issue, being content, for our part, to leave to the factions engaged in the dispute, and to the religious press, a mo- nopoly of sweeping assertions on one side and the other in regard to a matter concerning which man has no means of proving any- thing. But there are certain larger relations of these recent church controversies to which we would call attention. Almost for the first time since the civil war, we are given a reminder, in the events alluded to, that the divisive forces of Protestantism are not spent. There is a schism, practically, in the Congregational Church. It may never take organic form. The troublesome faction may not be cut off ; it may not go out volunta- rily. Yet there has been made evident such a sharp and radical difference on a point re- garded as of the essence of the faith, as would have led, infallibly, in other days, to the crea- tion of a new sect ; as would lead now, in a de- nomination possessing any central authority, to trials for heresy, and excision. Here we see, then, a recrudescence of the schismatic tendencies of Protestantism. These were in a state of high activity in the United States during the closing years of the last century and the first half of this, and were remarkably fertile in the pro- duction of new sects formed on a basis of theo- logical differences. The more recent rendings of the American churches were the work of slavery. Now, it would appear, after a long period during which the disruptive forces have been in abeyance, there is danger of cleavage along theological lines again. This is all the more significant in the face of the immensely widened tolerance of divergent views which has come to prevail in the churches. A difference must be great indeed to lead to a schism in a church whose policy, more and more, has been to keep up the spirit of religion by admitting all opinions into the sanc- tuary. No complaint is oftener in the mouths of the older clergy than that denominational names have lost their meaning. Pascal was astonished to find that two degrees of lati- tude were enough to reverse the principles of jurisprudence. A much shorter dis- tance is all that need be travelled in the United States to find the same denomina- tion standing for different things. Thus the conservative element in the meeting of the American Board counted it no small advantage that the sessions this year were held at Des Moines, the Congregationalism of the West being of a far different temper from that in the neighborhood of Boston. It is highly note- worthy, we repeat, if a party in the church has come to hold views too radical for even such an elastic mantle of toleration to cover. It is a sign that the course of Protestant de- velopment is still to be marked by disruption, as well as by slow and peaceable change. The complacency with which some of the other sects have been regarding this movement within the Congregational body is not without its amusing aspects. The Unitarians, for ex- ample, have been maintaining all these years that they have followed the only sure course towards denominational stable equilibrium, and that change and advance must necessarily go on in other denominations until a resting- place similar to their own is reached. Accord- ingly they have seen a clear confirmation of this opinion in the agitations of Congregation- alism for the past ten years. But they are just now rudely disturbed by the need of attending to a threatened schism in their own church. The Western Unitarian Association has decided that the way to secure an equilibrium really stable is to broaden the basis of denominational fellowship; and the old leaders of the church, who had supposed that all was settled, are lifting up their voices against dangerous tendencies, quite in the ortho- dox fashion. At the other extreme may be
Page 11
os Mal Oct. 14, 1886] seen the Presbyterians, proudly pointing to their rigid ecclesiastical system and _ their definite and obligatory creed as effective bulwarks against all innovation They sad- ly shake their heads when they talk of the ‘‘New Departure” in the Congrega- tional Church, and begin planting missions of theirown in New England so as to be sady for anything that may happen. Yet some of them are half-conscious that they may be making the same mistake which Principal Tulloch showed was made, in supposing that the Scottish churches had remained quiescent in religious thought because they maintained the old Calvinistic creedsintact. It must cause a sense of hollowness in Presbyterian self satis- faction to remember that some of the most out- spoken leaders of the Andover movement were, until recently, Presbyterians, honored and un- questioned leaders. Then there must be some ground for dis- quiet in the attitude of the hyper-orthodox Presbyterian Church of the South. That body makes no concealment of its conviction that the Northern Presbyterians are not safely orthodox. This conviction is now, probably, the greatest obstacle in the way of a union be- tween the two churches. In fact, it would seem that one effect of these recent theologi- cal disturbances will be indefinitely to ad- journ the question of a general union of the Protestant sects—a union h rald ed by many as an event of the near future. All attempts towards such a consolidation, thus far, have been rather sentimental than practical. Aside from an extremely limited co- operation on some missionary fields, little has been accomplished beyond the exchange of yague inter-denominational compliments and greetings. It has not been possible to form a basis of doctrinal agreement. It seems certain that these recent revelations of theological differences so marked within the bounds of a single denomination will make a‘general Pro- testant union still more out of the question. We should be sorry to be thought to see in these movements within religious circles no- thing of significance for the larger interests of truth and hberty. These varied theological opinions and disturbances seem to be necessary stages in the slow education of mankind. Count Tolstoi speaks of the curious way in which an individual often reproduces in his personal development the historical progress of the thought of the race, as in the embryo the different steps in the evolution of its an- cestry are displayed. In a similar way it would seem to be sometimes the fate of a de- nomination to represent in epitome the whole history of religious thought. Certainly we cannot hesitate to pronounce fragmentary and divisive Protestantism vastly better than the dead solidarity of religion in Spain and Turkey. It is as much better as liberty is better than slavery, intelligence than superstition, progress than stagnation. COOPERATION AND CHARACTER. Tue British diplomatic agents have made a re- port on codperation in various countries, and it has been issued in a small volume, of which we find a summary in the London Daily News. Nothing can be more interesting than ; The Nation. experiments in codperation, because it is the only one of the proposed solutions of the ‘‘labor problem ” which has even a flavor of rationality about it. We include profit-sharing under the same term, for it is a form of codperation, and depends for its success on an appeal to the same mo tives. Among European countries, France occupies by far the foremost place in the field of codperation in production. Codpera tionin consumption, which has been so suc cessful in England, the French, for some unex plained reason, have never taken to. But they have set up cieties for more codperative so production, and carried them on more successfully, than any other country. Before the Franco-German = war they were numerous, and some of them very successful. A society of working piano makers, for instance, starting with simply their own little savings, were worth $8,000 in two or three years. The war and the Commune ruined most of them, and there has been no revival of the move ment, Those who are disposed to try indus trial experiments have for the most part joined the Socialists and Anarchists, and are clamoring for the conversion of the whole State into a codperative association. In fact, the success of the codperative associations in France destroyed or greatly damaged codperation as a solution of the ‘‘labor problem,’ in the eyes of the discontented working class in France. This is an extraordinary and at first sight puzzling fact, but the explanation of it is easy, and we commend it to the aitention of all who are pottering over the labor problem in this country. The explanation is this: All the experi ments made brought out, more clearly than is possible under the part played = by industrial success. wage system, the character ‘in producing **The fate of these insti tutions,” the Daily Neirs says, ‘‘ was in exact conformity with the law of all human en deavor. Where the associated workmen were prudent, honest, self-deny ing, they were prospered ; where they were not, they failed.” The result was, that in spreading they tended to create a sort of natural aristocracy in the working class, and to mark off the prudent, honest, labo:ious, and self-denying from the shiftless, dishones?, lazy, and extravagant. The associations had to get rid of their less capable and trustworthy mem- bers as a condition of success, and associa tions which were not made up in the main of picked men soon went to the wall. This ruined them in the eyes of the inferior workmen and in the eyes of the labor aitators. These last in France are now the worst enemies of codperation. They discou laborious, and rage all attempts at it, and preach in more and more savage tones the great gospel of ‘* Collec tivity,” which proposes to have the ‘‘ State’ tak« possession of all property, and hire each per son to do his particular kind of labor, This is a very instructive phenomenon, which we advise our professorial and clerical Socialists to study carefully. Trades unions, including the Knights of Labor as at present conducted in the United States, all have in view the concealment of those differences of character and capacity which the codperative associations bring to light. The object of the former is to arrange the work of production in every feld in such a way that it shall not be possibl perceive which of any dozen men working gether is the ablest. or most skilful, or most dustrious; and that the lazy, or shirking, or i capable man shall escape the penalties with which he is, remorselessly pursued under our present civilizatio In other words, thev want to eliminate from industry the influence of character on success. They seek to over throw in the moral world the law of the sur vival of the . fittest survive, both the fit and unfit; that virtue s! They insist that all shall not have even the reward of achievement, and that the qualities which most distinguish moat from the brutes shall not profit any individual man materially, The savage war on non un men to force them to enter the unions tsearred on in furtherance of the same ides Phe are hindrances to the dead level system. OF course the unions might be conductad with out this system. They might give free play to individual superiority; but to do so with out exciting heartburnings and jealousies would call for greater skill in management than has yet been displayed Correspondence. REPUBLICANS AND FREE TRADE IN MICHIGAN To THE Eprror oF THe Nation Sir: You seem to think that the nomination of Mr. Robinson, “a pronounced snti-protectior ist,” as you call him, by the Ropublicans of the Detroit district is an indication of a change of opinion on their part reganding the tard. Ver mit me to call this an error, and fo tell vou why Robinson was nominated and who he is Your articie in the same number of vour paper regarding Henry George's candidacy for Mayor of your city makes me think that the informa tion might interest vou, as their cases are to some extent analogous, and perhaps your readers would like to hear a little about practical politics in Michigan been an enthusiastic leader of the Greenback party of this district, but has not refused outside help to get an office. At present he is a justice of the peace, the election to which office he ob Mr. Robinson has for many years tained on a Greenback-Labor nomination, sup ported by a bargain under which his party sup ported the rest of the Republican candidates in return for their endorsement of Robinson. Mr. Robinson has been one of the leaders of labor or ganizations that have exercised a reign of terror in this city during the last year, crippled business, and compelled workingmen to suffer want when they had a fine chance of earning gocd wages. He bas never advised deeds of violence directly, but bas made speeches at socialistic meetings de nouncing capitalists, banks, etc., which must of necessity have had a pernicious effect on his un educated hearers. Some of those speeches he would now like to have forgotten, and in a dis- creditable manner he now denounces the then re ports of the same as false. In short, Mr. Robin son might be called a demagogue, for he has the character and ambition to be one, but lacks the ability even for that réle. His election would in some respects have the same results as that. of Mr. Henry George, which you consider so very grave. Some time ago the labor organizations of this city nominated him for Congress on a free-trade, greenback, silver, anti-monopoly, etc., platform.
Page 12
The Nation. [Number 1111 A = = = === —=— Subsequently the Democrats nominated a very able though somewhat dissolute man on a free- trade platform, and then the Republicans, know- ing what little chance they had in this Demo- cratic district against those two candidates, be- gan to look around for a candidate of their own. Disregarding Robinson's political character and history, his principles, or those of his party, so antagonistic to their own, they nominated or rather endorsed him as the only man who, owing to his labor associations, had a chance of being elected, adopting, however, a high-tariff plank in their platform; and Robinson, carried away by ambition, accepted their endorsement, and now stands before us as a candidate on two*plat- forms as much opposed to each other as possible. Success is what the Republicans want, cost what it may; success is the consideration for which Robinson casts aside, or rather embraces, all principles. It is touching to hear how Re- publicans try to reconcile their tariff views with their wishes for the welfare of the laboring men who suppose that their candidate stands ona free-trade platform. They of course point out the difference in favor of American laborers between them and their brethren in Europe, and ascribe it to the results of a providential Republican tariff legislation. This must be puzzling to many. The laboring man who votes for Robinson has, however, his choice between a free-trade and high-tariff candidate combined in one individual, and is sure to see his condition bettered in any event. This, again, must be most gratifying to the laboring man. The Republican party managers, however, un- derstand their business and know their man. They perceive how even now the flattery of a Republican nomination, the friendly smile of their prominent men, has intoxicated Robinson, how he is now already polishing up his old Re- publicanism; and they correctly assume that, if by any chance he should be- elected, he will be one of theirs, and his further political career will be under their control, for be is ambitious and weak, and they are powerful and influential, The Republican party in Michigan is a lumber, copper, and iron party, and will see to it that no free-traders are elected with its assistance. Asa matter of fact, there is little chance of Robin- son’s election, but his endorsement is a shrewd scheme to catch the labor vote with a Republi- can hook to be used on future occasions, Yours respectfully, W. E. H. Derroit, Micn., October 5, 1886. MICHIGAN'S SALOONS AND FOREIGN POPULATION. To THE EpiTor oF Tue NatTIon: Sir: As bearing upon the labor problem and the liquor traffic, the following statistics drawn from vol, i, Census of Michigan, 1884, just issued by the Secretary of State, Lansing, Mich., are of peculiar interest. In Michigan in the year 1884, 80,131 persons, ten years of age or over, were returned as unable to read or write. Of this number 225 were of un- known nativity; 15,743 were born of native pa- rents; 6,338 had foreign-born parents; 2,559 had one parent foreign-born; and the remaining 53,- 053 were themselves foreign-born. The total population of the State was 1,853,658, and the total of inhabitants whose parents were one or both foreign-born was 975,144. In other words, 54 per cent. of the population furnished 80 per cent. of the illiteracy. The number of saloon-keepers and bar-tenders was returned at 3,894, and the number of brew- ers and malsters at 557. ‘‘ Expressed approxi- mately, the foreign-born inhabitants who form but 26 per cent. of the total population, furnish , 57 per cent.of the saloon-keepers and bar-tenders, and 78 per cent. of the brewers and malsters.” In the light of such a showing, the wisdom of the aggressive immigration policy pursued by Michigan until recently appears to have been foolishness, if not something worse.—Respect- fully, ERWIN F. SMITH. WASHINGTON, D. C., October 9, 1886. THE MADISON POST-OFFICE AGAIN. To THE Eprror oF THE NATION: Sm: Your issue of September 30 contains a let- ter?from ‘ Civil-Service Referm” which, uncon- tradicted, might mislead many of your readers and give forth wrong impressions. He says: ‘* The Post-office here had been pretty thorough- ly cleared of its old employees before this,* and their places given to inexperienced men; but there remained a Mr. Hastreiter, mailing clerk, — and a Mr. Helen, superintendent of the special delivery, likewise possessed of informa- tion which it takes years to acquire.” He says, further : ‘‘ These men were notified that after the first of the month they would no longer be want- ed, and new and inexperienced men were ap- pointed in their places—a most flagrant disre- gard of the city’s interests,” etc. As to Mr. Hastreiter, he is one of those good- natured souls the public would rather not have disturbed—but he is a Republican, and must go. As to Mr. Helm (not Helen), he is a younger brother of the Assistant Postmaster, and, before his ad- vent to the position of one of the four roate-car- riers, was delivery clerk—a place in which he rendered himself so obnoxious to those who had business at the “ general delivery,” that his dis- placement was loudly clamored for by Repub- licans and Democrats, women and children. To appease this clamor, Gen. Bryant, then Post- master, relieved him from the delivery window and put him upon one of the carrier routes. That he has been faithful in the discharge of his du- ties, I have never heard questioned ; but it goes without saying among those with whom he came in contact that he was always grouty, ill-tem- pered, and never deigned to give a civil answer to any one on any occasion. There never has been an employee in the Post-office here about whom there has been so general and warrantable complaint as this same man Helm, and it is im- mensely gratifying to all who have any business with the Post-office that his head has gone to the basket ; and there is little doubt that ‘“ Civil-Ser- vice Reform” is as pleased over it as any one else, only that he is shy of acknowledging it. ‘*Civil-Service Reform” suggests that ‘if the public generally is so thoroughly disgusted with its dose as the better class of citizens of this city are with this incident,” then ‘‘even Mr. Cleve- land’s chances of reélection are few.” The writer hereof is a Republican, always has been, and is free to say there are hundreds of other Republi- cans in this city who vigorously applaud the au- thor of ‘‘ this incident,” and only regret that it came not sooner. REFORMER. MapIson, WIs., October, 1886. RESULTS OF BAD TEACHING, To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Srr: I was lately in a company of well-to-do gentlemen, a sort of circle of culture, in which the Anarchists of Chicago were discussed, and from them by an easy transition the conversa- tion turned to the strikers and their evil ways. With singular unanimity the opinion was ex- pressed: (1.) That every man has the right to refuse ter-General Vilas’s recent visit * Referring to Postmas here—about the middle of September, working at wages which he thinks too low, or on any other conditions which he dislikes. (2.) That workingmen have the right to com- bine in such refusal in any numbers, in order to make this refusal effective; in short, they have the right to strike. (3.) That they have, however, no right to pre- vent others who are willing to work at lower wages, or on less favorable conditions (in short, rats or scabs), by force from taking the places which they vacate; nor even to use the pressure of a “boycott” for any such purpose, though without such force or conspiracy their strike might fail. Hence, the strikers at Milwaukee, Chicago, and on the Missouri Railroad system were in the wrong; and any violence committed by them, if it resulted in death, was murder,both in Jaw and in morals. I agree with the reasoning and in the result reached; but I maintain that there are strong mitigating circumstances for all the violence and murder that was instigated by Martin [rons and August Spies, and their ignorant or crackbrained associates—reasons why society, why the people of the United States, should judge their doings mildly. I find these mitigating circumstances in the bad teaching which has come from the lead- ers of both of our great political parties, in the emission of false doctrines from the high places where wisdom and truth should have been ex- pected. In Chicago itself, where mob violence took the most dread-inspiring form and the most colossal dimensions, these false and misleading doctrines had been most loudly and most authoritatively preached. Not to speak of the platform of the Republicans, we need only look among the reso- lutions of the Democratic National Convention, held in the great City of the Lakes in the summer of 1884, to find such socialistic rant as this: that in order to secure the American laborer (say, an unnaturalized Bohemian or Slovak) against the pauper labor of Europe, a customs duty should be imposed on imported articles sufficiently great to make up for the difference in the scale of wages. Translate this into the language of the strikers: (1.) A hand in a pig-iron furnace can refuse to work for less than $2 a day. (2.) All the hands in all the American pig-iron furnaces can combine in this refusal, and thus keep the rate up to $2a day. (3.) If any workman in England, Sweden, or Belgium propose to work at $1 a day and thereby furnish to the American consumer cheaper pig iron—ah, what then? Then the ships bringing the product of this labor of scabs or rats to our shores are to be forced by the revenue cutters of our Government to turn back, and if they diso- bey, ships and cargo will be sunk rather than that scabs should be allowed to compete with that great trades union which the tariff has establish- ed among all pig-iron workers in the United States. Or say, instead of pig-iron workers, all the silk-weavers, all the wool-growers, all the cot- ton-spinners, etc. (By the by, the Oleomargarine Bill has extended this socialistic principle a little; the ‘‘ bull-butter men ” are simply scabs trying to compete with the Dairymen’s Association.) Now, what is the difference in morals between Martin Irons and his followers, who ditch trains and ‘‘ kill” locomotives, to prevent men not be- longing tothe order of Knights of Labor from working for Gould’s railroad companies, or Au- gust Spies, seeking to drive underpaid scabs out of the McCormick Reaper Factory, on the one hand, and Randall and Kelley, using the armed vessels of the United States to prevent English and Belgian miners or French weavers from working for the American iron or cloth market ? There is a marked difference in law between them ; Martin Irons and August Spies have not
Page 13
Oct. 14, 1886] yet succeeded in shaping State or Federal legis- lation in favor of “organized” labor ; Randall and Kelley pretend that they have shaped Fede- ral laws in favor of the ‘‘ American” working- man, though it is very doubtful if those laws do any class of American workingmen any good. Maybe, after a while—having started out briskly with the Oleomargarine Bill—we shall have a perfect system of laws protecting the laborer in the right to earn such wages as he demands, no matter whether any one wants his services or those of a cheaper competitor for employment ; and then Martin Irons and August Spies will be looked on as the forerunners of the better time— the latter, if hung in the meantime, as a sort of John Brown, a martyr to his premature zeal. But even then I shall maintain that the men up- holding those laws will, in the forum of morals, be just as much in the wrong as Irons and Spies and as Randall and Kelley arenow. L. N. D. LOUISVILLE, Ky., October 8, 1886, WHY WE NOTICE THE LABOR AGITA- TION, To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION : Sir: For eight months past the Nation has given more space to the labor question than to any other. The last number, for instance, con- tained about ten columns of matter bearing in one way or another upon this topic. The great dailies are filled with reports of the doings of the labor world. The columns of the religious press and the magazines are crowded with labor litera- ture, Now, all this writing is either about something. and therefore proper, or it is about nothing, and therefore destined to become very tiresome as soon as it ceases to be droll. If the labor movement is half as strong as it is represented to be, then dis- cussion and criticism should go on in season and out of season. But if it is weak,as the Nation would have it believed, why should so much attention be given toit? The action of the Nation is hard to understand in this matter. Henry George, who, we are told, is a harmless theorist with a ‘*handful” of followers, gets two columns of space in the last number; Mr. Powderly, a sui- cidal blatherskite, gets two more; Dr. Ely,whose writings are compared to those of a ‘‘ raving An- archist,” gets four columns. This lengthy treatment might be ascribed to the necessities of journalism, but that would not explain the intensity of feeling displayed by the Nation in its discussions of this question during the past year. It cannot bear tothink of Mr. Powderly—who, by the by, is considered a very worthy gentleman in these parts. It would cast him into jail, where Dennis Kearney has been and ought to be now. It would throw poor Prof. Ely out of his position just because he shows a bias towards labor organizations, How can the Nation be justly considered any- thing but an ‘‘ enemy to labor,” when it attacks so furiously everybody who dares to lift his voice in behalf of laboring men? Enmity towards the leaders of a cause is prima facie evidence cf en- mity towards the cause. When did the Nation ever have a kind word for any advocate of labor organizations When did it ever go tothe work- ingmen with any other message than * the per- petual, monotonous lie, ‘it is all very good and right’” ? S. E. FoRMAN. CARLISLE, Pa. October 9, 1886, [The action of the Nation is not hard to un derstand by those who read the Vetion with any care, which, apparently, you do not. The Nation has repeatedly—say twenty-five times—spoken of the labor movement as the == —_—SS==aS=_—_—_—> most important with which the American peo- The Nation. ple has had to deal since the extinction of slavery. This is the reason why so much appears in its columns about the labor movement, .But can you not understand that a movement may be a very great movement, and some of the men who figure in it very small and very foolish ? Look at the history of any movement, and you will find this to be the case. The French Revolution was a great movement, but Robespierre was not wise or great, nor Marat either, nor was Theroigne Méricourt an ideal woman. Your assertion that the Vation ‘cannot be considered anything but an enemy to labor” because it ‘attacks furiously everybody who dares to lift his voice in behalf of laboring men,” we prefer to consider silly rather than malicious. It is not true that the Nution ously,” etc.; therefore your ** bocause is ab surd. If the Nation attacked you, ior in stance, it would show that it was the true friend of labor, and it would attack you if it thought that you were a real and not a merely careless reader. —Ep. NATION. | ‘attacks furi THE ANDOVER CONTROVERSY To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION : Srr: ‘* The doctrinal quarrel in the Congrega tional Church known as the Andover controver sy,” noticed by you on the 50th ult., will contintte for atime, and its vital points should be under stood. Upon one of these you, with most secular writers, seem to have fallen into error concerning Congregational views. You seem to think that Congregationalists believe thet ** those who have never known the teachings of Christ are as badly off after death as those who, baving known them here, neglected or refused to order their lives in accordance with them”—i. ¢., that they are be yond hope. In the absence of correction by another band please accept the following Dr. J. L. Withrow of Boston delivered the an nual sermon this week before the Board, a representative man before a represen- tative assembly. On the following three points preacher and hearers seemed to be in emphatic agreement: (1.) ** Itis not the intellect but the will taat is at fault” in all that God recognizes as wrongdoing (2.) The heathen are not utterly unconscious or ignorant of duty. ‘Lighthouses stand along every dangerous coast; beacons blaze from every cliff"; ** Stars are shining where there is no sun.” (5.) Some pagans Aare gladly walked in the light, and all may, can do so. “It is nof the doctrine of the Church that the entire mass of the pagans have gone down to endless impenitence and death.” It is the belief, doubtless. of the American Board, of intelligent Congregationalists, and of thinking Christendom, that, helpful as a know- ledge of ** the historic Christ “ and His words may be in building character pleasing to God and to all who love moral good, it is not essential to it. Congregationalists generally believe that, if a “second probation ~ is necessary for the hea- then, it is just as necessary for the entire world, yet unnecessary for either. They believe that the realm of hopelessness is entered only through the gate of known and neglected duty, is entered thus from India as from America. L. F. PARKER. American Iowa Crry, October 8, 1884, FRENCH HUMOR, To ras Eprrorn or THE Nation: Str: We are always told that ‘ familiarity 307 like unfamiliarity for this purpose, at least in li terary matters, People who area little weak on French literature are apt to bestow on it two con temptuous criticisms, neither of them fust, One is to the effect that French stories are unpleasant the other, that with all their wit they are devoid of true humor. The trouble is that theese critics judge from too small a number of examples Emerson says, I know, that it is the mark of g: nius to generalize from a single case ; also the mark, much more infallibly, of character largely treated of in the Proverbs of Solomon! The Gallic mind is rather a imtafis if not fa Speicies ‘plex organ, very lively and very expansive, and must not get hold of its literature by the wrong handle. T have just been reading, with unadulterated delight, a book which I should hke to recommend to all persons who have accepted the two advems judgments above mentioned, It is Daudet's:' Ta: tarin sur les Alpes “he exquisite little Ulustra tions are themselves a sufficient evidence of both the sense of beauty and the sense of humor in tl French mind; but the scenes as sketchad by the pen are even more delicious, Take, for example the faithful chamois peacefully lapping bis warm wine In the kitchen after his exhausting chase the Alps: or the two seared gasconaders confess ing each other in the a or the ticklish situa tion of the party in the crevasse—one of the ricl est I know of in any literature-—where the sui dal Swede hangs by one listless hand at the head ft the line, discussing the temptetson to pitch of into the abyss, while Tartarin (aware that if one goes all go) expends his best eloquence in con batting the untimely pessimisin of tis meughtor If there is any good definition of humor that would exclude such conceptions as Tartarin and his companions, it would be tnteresting to hear ober 4, 188 THE TRANSFORMATION OF SURNAMES, To trae Eprron or Tur Natron SIR A reference ina late number of the Nu fron tothe origin and development of surnames leads me to offer the suggestion that, before it 1s too late, some one should collect the various *hanges of names ameng the French emigrants to New England \ few instances from a single village will illus trate the richness of the field for investigation. In afew years M. Du Bois has become Mr. Wood: M. Boisvert is now Mr. Greenwood ; M. Papillon has changed his name to Mr. Butterfly; M. An toine Changras is now known as Mr. Oughtney Jangraw, and the whole family has changed ita name to Jangraw. The first three changes are obvious enough; the last results from the manner in which a school teacher wrote down a pupil's name as she understood the pronunciation. Here isone more: M. Michel St. Onge was informed, when he came to this country, that people here were called by their Christian names, So be be- came, not Mr. Michael, but Mr. Mitchell, and his descendants all bear the name of Mitchell. Similar examples of odd changes could easily be multiplied. A few years hence it will not be as easy to recognize the origin of the names of the descendants of these French immigrants. Very respectfully yours, M October 4, 1886. Notes. Harper & Bros. will shortly issue ‘ A Demigod,’ a romance of Greece; ‘School Elocution,’ by John Swett; and a popular edition of Dr, W. M. Thomson's ‘ The Land and the Book,’ breedscontempt”; but, after all, there is nothing Charles Scribner's Sons have in press the first
Page 14
308 volume (of three) of H. Morse Stephen's ‘ History of the French Revolution,’ with a special preface and map; and ‘The Huguenots and Henry of Navarre,’ by Prof. Henry M. Baird. ‘The Bankside Shakspere ” is the title adopted by the Shakspere Society of New York for an edition which Mr. Appleton Morgan will edit and Houghton, Mifflin & Co. will manufacture. Itis to consist of ‘‘an arrangement of the earliest known text printed in parallel pages with the 1623 Heminges and Condell text, thus illustrat- ing the growth of a Shakespearean play during the lifetime of the Dramatist himself.” The cri- tical apparatus will be peculiar to this edition. ** No readings (so called) will be incorporated into the text itself.” Twenty plays will be included in as many volumes. The edition is limited to 500 copies. Mr. Frank R. Stockton’s latest story, ‘The Casting Away of Mrs. Lecks and Mrs. Aleshine,’ will be issued in paper covers and in cloth binding on the 20th of October by the Century Co. ‘Souvenirs of My Time,’ by Jessie Benton Fré- mont, isin the press of D. Lothrop & Co., Bos- ton. Funk & Wagnalls announce ‘The Buddhist Diet Book,’ by Laura C. Holloway. Mr. George Parsons Lathrop launches his first story-book for children, ‘ Behind Time,’ through Cassell & Co. Thomas Whittaker publishes shortly ‘A Hand- book of Biblical Difficulties; or, Reasonable So- lutions of Perp'exing Things in Sacred Scrip- tures,’ by the Rev. Robert Tuck. J. B. Lippincott Co. have in press ‘ Othello and Desdemona: their Characters, and the Manner of Desdemona’s Death’ by Dr. Ellits; and ‘ House Plants as Sanitary Agents,’ by J. M. Anders, M.D. The latest work from the fertile pen of Mr. Benson J. Lossing bears the somewhat sensa- tional title, *Mary and Martha, the Mother and the Wife of George Washington’ (Harper & Bros.) It isa literary museum of all the current anec- dotes of the various branches of the family, be- ginning, intrue Knickerbocker spirit, with John Ball, of fourteenth-century fame, from whom the mother of Washington was possibly descended. To these are added descriptions of the personal appearance, wardrobe, plate, household furni- ture, and daily routine life of a well-to-do Vir- ginia family, the whole spiced with the early love affairs of the different members, and ‘‘ padded” with much wholly irrelevant matter. It is a pleasantly told story, though marred by diffuse- ness and the ever-present personality of the au- thor, and possesses some antiquarian but no his- torical interest. Doubtless our forefathers in their younger days would have read it with zest, but if the modern schovl of historians have done nothing more, they have at least shown that his- tory need not be given in the homceopathic form in order to be acceptable. A work issued in a second edition in 1866, and now freshly put upon the market, speaks for it- self as meeting the approval of thuse for whom it was intended. Such has been the fate of ‘ Po- ems of Sorrow and Comfort,’ selected by Prof. F. J. Child (Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co). This time there has been no enlargement, whether be- cause the compiler is too much occupied with weightier labors, or whether the additions to de- votional verse have been meanwhile insignifi- cant. ‘The Influence of Clothing on Health’ (Cassell & Co.), by Frederick Treves, an English surgeon and lecturer on anatomy, reinforces what pbysi- ologists and hygienists are always insisting upon. We observe nothing new in it, but it is a conve- nient reference-book for this branch of the do- mestic sciences. The Adams and especially the Eves of society, who continue to yield to the The Nation. temptations of subtle tailors and dressmakers, promising that they shall be as gods in the fash- ionable world, sin against warning and in the midst of abundant light. . Sir Henry Thompson’s paper in the Nineteenth Century for May, 1885, on ‘‘ Diet in Relation to Age and Activity” has been reprinted (Scribner & Welford), and in this convenient form is com- mended for both its matter and its style to all who eat, especially to men, whether of active life or of uncertain appetite. A different style of book from the foregoing is ‘Household Remedies,’ by Dr. Felix Oswald (Fowler & Wells Co), a rambling treatise on fresh air, exercise, sunlight, and abstinence from alcohol, as a practical armamertarium against most of the ills that beset the flesh. Despite ex- aggerations of style and statement, its teachings tend toa rational simplicity of life and to the avoidance of disease. Mr. Edward Money’s ‘Tbe Truth about Ame- rica’ (London: 8S. Low) is one prolonged growl; the national remedy for a grievance, ‘‘a letter to the Times,” being expanded into a book. Induced by glowing advertisements, backed by specimens of fruit *‘in wax,” the author went last year to take up some land in southern California, and, finding the promised Eden to be a desert, writes an account of his experiences to prevent his countrymen from falliug victims to the same de- lusive hopes. To do him full justice, however, ,not everything in this country meets witb his disapproval. The climate of California is per- fect, and the advantages of Colorado Springs as a ‘‘cure-place” are unequalled. But the blame far overbalances the praise. The impression is even given that Mr. Money in some way holds us responsible for the extremes of heat and culd in New York, and especially for the amount of sandy desert in the Southwest. At times he gives vent to his feelings with great energy: ‘* Oh, this beastly want of courtesy in America, how [ did loathe it!” With especial abhorrence does he regard the Yankee, ‘‘the worst type on earth.” Some of our peculiar customs are described with great fulness of detail. For instance, a page is given to the “naughty” practice, which we are assured is universal at the West, of getting a light. A man “takes out a match, lifts up the right leg, bent at the knee to draw the trousers tight, and ignites it on the lower part of the thigh.” In his efforts to tell the truth about us Mr. Money touches upon a great variety of sub- jects, nothing seeming to escape his critical eye— not even the fact that the Western tea-cups ** have no handles.” The bound volume of the English Illustrated Magazine for 1885-86 (Macmillan) has the usual comely appearance of this periodical. Local top- ics, such as London Commons, the Charter-house, Leicester Fields; places, domestic and foreign, as Decayed Seaports, A North Country Fishing Town, Newcastle-on-Tyne, Yarmouth and the Broads, Old Chester, Ulm, Umbria, the Valley of the Arno, Sicily, Cétes du Nord, the Jotun- heim, Afghanistan, the Equator ; personal asso- ciations, as Charles Kingsley and Eversley, Charles Lamb in Hertfordshire ; customs and industries, like Fox Hunting, Cheese Farming at Chester, Ostrich Farming in the Cape Colony, Japanese Tea Cultivation—such is a suggestion of the nature of the contents. A few of the full- page engravings, such as Watts’s ‘‘ Pygmalion,” are notable, and clever are Mr. H. Furniss’s pen- and-ink sketches that accompany Mr. H. W. Lu- cy’s paper on the House of Lords. The second number of the Proceedings of the American Society for Psychical Research (Bos- ton: Cupple:, Upham & (C).) has-a very general interest. It gives in full the address of President Newcomb, a sane, sceptical, and almost discou- raging survey of the field and of the probability [Number rrr of success in it. Dealing chiefly with thought- transference, he suggests that juries might be ex- pected to obtain in this way from the prisoner himself a clue to his guilt or innocence; but they donot, consciously. He thinks the reality of this phenomenon almost disproved by the Society's researches hitherto. There is no increased facili- ty in producing it nor in investigating it. The report on hypnotism, by Dr. Wm. James and G. M. Carnochan, is a valuable contribution. It tells of one subject made to believe he saw, ona blank sheet of paper unmarked in any way, a pho- tographic portrait. This imaginary object he was then made to follow in its travels over the sides of the room back to the paper,which mean- time had been secretly turned upside down. The restored image thereupon appeared inverted to the subject of the experiment. The upward and downward passes of the magnetizer seem to have the power ascribed to them. Dr. James for himself relates his experience with a trance-me- dium, which satisfied him that she was honest, that her trance was real, and that she possessed ‘a power as yet unexplained.” It is instructive to turn from meditations on the present furore for Russian novels to what we may call a Unitarian vote on the ‘ten great novels, the noblest available to English readers” (‘Ten Great Novels: Suggestions for Private Reading.’ Chicago: Charles H, Kerr & Co.). The vote was taken in 1884, or before Tolstoi’s ‘War and Peace’ dawned on the English hori- zon, and this author’s name is of course unmen- tioned. Three of Turgeneff’s works received at most two votes, against twenty-three for Auer- bach’s ‘ On the Heights,’ the lowest on the result- ing list. The “ Elite Engagement Calendars” issued by E. P. Dutton & Co. make a prettily framed or- nament for the shelf or table. A lady who is content with nine engagements a month could wish nv better memorandum. Notes on Verrocchio as the master and pre- cursor of Leonardo da Vinci, by M. Eugéne Miintz, are the most noticeable portion of the contents of L’Art for September 1. They are il- lustrated. The Revue Internationale de Vl Enseignement, a monthly magazine of solid worth published in Paris by Armand Colin & Cie., has in its Septem- ber number an unusually attractive table of con- tents. We remark a sketch, by M. Louis Leger, of the beginnings of Russian literature; an article on the utility (or say rather inutility) of Greek in the study of botany, in which tbe writer summa- rizes an essay on this subject by Dr. Wilbelin Petrold of Brunswick; thespeech and formal ad- dress on behalf of the Institute made by its Presi dent, M. Zeller, at the Heidelberg festival; and the text of the decree by which M. Paul Bert bas created the Tonkin Academy (Bac-ki-han- lam-vien). Mr. Henry Harrisse is about to give a perma- nent form and value to his investigation of the dilapidated library of Fernando Columbus. From B. Westermann & Co. we have his prospectus for subscriptions to ‘ Excerpta Colombiana: Biblio- graphie de 400 Pitces Gothiques, Frangaises, Italiennes et Latines du commencement du XVIe Siécle’ (Paris: H. Welter). These early works, in prose and verse, were printed before 1559 at Paris, Lyons, Avignon, in Germany and the north of Italy. Mr. Harrisse’s notes will be co- pious and authoritative; and in the case of Co- lumbus’s books ‘four-fifths of the collection) he wili reproduce this bibliophile’s inscriptions of price, place of purchase, and sometimes personal details. The edition will be limited to 288 copies. —Proposals have been issued by Joel Munsell’s Sons, Albany, for a work entitled ‘ America He- raldica’ to be edited by E. de V. Vermont. It is i i i ae
Page 15
mpage soe errr Oct. 14, 1886] to consist of six parts, costing $15.00 in all, to contain 192 colored coats-of-arms. The 12 coats have been selected, and the list is appended to tne circular. It is said that undoubted facts only will be stated; yet in a preceding paragraph it 1s said that there will be ‘‘a short argument con- cerning the family connection, if any, between the European and American possessors of said coats-of-arms.” The list is not encouraging. Many of the families named never used a coat- of-arms, and many more have no evidence of a right to use one. Of course there are two hun- dred families now residing in America who are armigeri, Reckoning in those of other than British nationality, probably there are two thou- sand such families, possibly very many more. But this list does not treat of these true cases. It is confined almost entirely to British families, and is incorrect even in regard to them. We see no good purpose to be served by this publication; certainly, no excuse for the very costly form it 1s to assume. Printing in gold and colors does not add to the historical value of the work, though it does to the expense. As the project now looks, it would be emphatically an American Book of Snobs. It would aid nothing to our knowledge of the past, it would in no way justify the title of ‘America Heraldica ’; it would foster and perpetu- ate error; and it would properly point many a sneer from transatlantic writers. We sincerely trust that the misguided promoter of the scheme will drop it, and do some honest literary hard work. We suggest to him, for example, an inquiry as to the number of noblemen now resident in the United States. It seems that emigration has nearly extinguished the Norwegian nobility. France, Germany, and Italy have sent many genuine bearers of titles here. Let us havea register of these, and we shall get facts, whether they be valuable or not. —The Century closes the year with a brilliant number. Something of the romance and a good deal of the hardship to be found in a Gloucester fishing voyage give occasion for the broad sea- effects of the leading illustrations, and for a well- written description of the sailors’ lives, with their wives and families (in the Kingsley vein of feel- ing) in the background. This article is, perhaps, “timely”; but, politically, the topic of our fishery interests is handled with much clearness and vigor in a communication by Capt. J. W. Collins to the ‘‘Open Letters” department. He re- views the situation from the standpoint of the fishermen, and explains exactly why they do not desire a renewal of the conditions of the expired treaty. We have space here only to direct atten- tion to it es an able and succinct exposition of the Cape Ann case. There are agreeable articles on Bjérnson’s home and private life, and on the Assos expedition, though the illustrations are by far the most valuable portion ot the latter. Edu- cation is attended to by President Gilman, who makes a plea in favor of the introduction of manual training into the public schools, lending the weight of his authority toa growing cause; and Matthew Arnold contributes some results he has reached in thinking over his observations on foreign common schools, which he hopes may be as serviceable in America as in England. This is the address recently delivered by him before the University of Pennsylvania. He reinforces his well-known views in favor of a consolidation of State education, with the purpose of bringing the influence of the centres of the higher education, and the heads of opinion in them, more directly into connection with the common schools, This is the ideal of the Western universities, and in Michigan at least Mr. Arnold could study some of the practical results on American soil. The instinct of home rule and local independence is too deeply set in our people to allow of any such The Nation. close educational bonds between universities and common schools as are possible in bureaucratic communities. The Century's Prospectus of an nouncements for the next year is very loug, and is partly made up of articles crowded over from this year, and of others which are not expected to appear until after another twelvemonth has gone by. The most important is the Life of Lincoln, i 809 tify “ history” and tradition in regard to this singular character, examining those statements regarding his fortunate which have been accepted, as coming from Dex ter himself, though inherently as improbable as they were foolish. He thus disposes of the tales of his sending warming-pans and (English) Hibles ventures commercial | to the West Indies. In illustration of the un by his secretaries, Messrs, Nicolay and Hay, which | will be one of the monuments of our history. Mrs. Oliphant, Mrs. Van Rensselaer, Dr. Eg gleston, Cable, and Stockton are prominently put forward, and there are to be serials on the Food Question, Spiritism, and the War, though the last subject is to occupy less space, —-Americans who visit Stratford. on-Avon have henceforth a new motive and a new object of cu riosity. Their countryman, Mr. Henry F. Wa- ters, has discovered in ** Ye Ancient House,” now standing in admirable preservation on High Street, and ‘‘the best specimen now left in that | street, or perhaps in the borough,” the home | built for himself in 1596 by Thomas Rogers, the | maternal grandfather of John Harvard. This truly elegant specimen of the domestic architec- ture of the pericd is shown in a heliotype plate prefixed to the October number of the New Eny- land Historical and and it is pleasant to observe next door to what might be called the cradle of Harvard College the store of a well-to-do printer, bookseller, and sta tioner. Here in Shakspere’s time lived Kathe rine Rogers till she married Robert Harvard, ‘‘and to it she may have come with her little son John to attend the obsequies of her father,” a prominent citizen, ‘‘one of the Aldermen,” who died February 20, 1610-11. Mr. Waters pro duces the probate act of Thomas Rogers's will, and prints a large number of wills of Harvari's ancestors and connections, broadening out our knowledge of him till it toyches the New World again through his step-father, Richard Yearwood, who was related to Sir George Yeardley, the Gov- ernor of Virginia. The record of Yeurwood’s marriage to ‘‘ Katherine Ellettsone” has also been found in the parish register of Wandsworth, Surrey, and proves that this thrice-married dame was widowed each time less than a year before plunging again into matrimony. The will of her sister Rose, who married Ralph Reason, is given, wherein she calls herself ** Raysings.” ** Rasing ™ was another form of her husband's name, the fa- mily crest being a bunch of grapes; and Mr. Wa- ters pertinently recalls Falstaff’s jest—** If rea sons were as plenty as blackberries.” Thanks to these intelligent and almost instinctive researches, as Mr. J. T. Hassam remarks in the Register, ‘from being almost a semi-mythical figure in our early colonial history, John Harvani bids fair to become one of the best known of the first generation of settlers on these shores. No better illustration could be given of the importance of the work Mr. Waters is doing in England; no more striking instance could be found of the ex- traordinary success which is attending his labors there. The Committee earnestly hope that funds sufficient to carry on still further these va- luable investigations may be speedily raised.’ Genealogical Register ; —This number of the Register 1s notable also in other ways. It closes the fortieth annual vol- ume of a work which is the pioneer of its kind, and has been maintained with extraordinary vigor and interest, never greater than now under the editorship of Mr. John Ward Dean, whose con- tinuous connection with it covers thirty-two years. By a pleasing coincidence, the present month witnesses the commemoration in England of the eight-bundredth anniversary of the com. pletion of the Domesday Survey of Evgland. In a paper on Lord Timothy Dexter, Mr. William Cleaves Todd of Newburyport attempts to ree- trustworthiness of history, Mr. Todd cites Prof J. D. Butler of Madison, Wis., father, an eye-witness, often told him, in regant to Ethan Allen's ‘In the name of the Gteat Je hovah and the Continental Congress,” that what whose grand the surprised commander at Ticonderogn actually heard was, ** Come out of here, vou d-—d old rat This matches Taylor's reply to Santa Anna ‘General Taylor never surrenders,” transiated by a skilful aide from the vernacular, ** Tell bim to go to hell.” Rev. George M. Bodge. is Another important paper, by the nthe Sudbury fight of which the date is fixed bevond cavil, and mans fresh particulars given. As this is the chapter on “Soldiers in King Philip's War more are to come, there ts plenty of material for sixteenth and a book of permanent value, and we hope one is intended. The eighth volume of Mr. Henry Laxize’s edition of the Works of Alexander Han ilton (Putnams The ninth and final volume will consist of the Federalist 17TNO- IN high degree of interest and value, and exhibit the Calaot concludes the Correspondenc These letters p> Sess 8 writer's dispassionate character under the very strongest personal which he composed his letter to Philp Schuyler (February 18, 1781 under unjust reproof, quitted Washington's nih provocation The heat in . informing him of bis having, tary family, does not seem to us, as it does to the editor, completely to invalidate its judgment of Washington. We are not bound t judgment, but there seems no reason to doubt that it was genuine. mentary passion and Hamilton's accounts of the defeat of Arnold's treachery, and of Andre's execution might well be borrowed almost textually for our school-books of history; just as his autobiographical sketch for the information of a Scotch relative might be adopted by the shorter dictionary makers. In one of the letters, never before published, by the way, is this singular reference to his father ‘Though, as I am informed, a man of respecta ble connections in Scotland,” etc. As early as 1788, it is noting. Hamilton prudence in procuring the admission of Vermont, because the South was jealous of any increase of Northern votes in Congress; and in 1795, writing to Pickering. who was about to leave the Cabi- net, he urged the absolute necessity of choosing a successor ‘‘ from some State south of Pennsylva nia. All the great offices in the hands of men from Pennsylvania northward do the Lord knows what mischief. 1 speak as to pub lic opinion.” In his disgust at the state of par- ties in 1802, Hamilton proposed to James A. Bayard the formation of *‘ The Christian Consti- tutional Society,” whose objects should be: ‘1. The support of the Christian religjon. 2. The support of the Constitution of the United States.” The year after his death, was born the future leader of a party which held that the support of the Christian religion was incompatible with the support of the United States Constitution as Hamilton had helped to make it—the Constitu- tion which the civil war destroyed. Hamilton did not propose to ‘‘ put God in the Constitution,” but he had the queer notion that his C. C. Socie- ty might promote ‘‘institutions of a charitable and useful nature, in the management of Fede- ralists.”. The revival of this idea wovld perhaps not be hard for our stalwart Republicans. Our sooept this and not dictated by mi resentment, Gates, of worth advises would
Page 16
[Number 1111 310 recent legislation over the Presidential succession is recalled by this passage in a letter of 1792: ‘You know how much it was a point to establish the Secretary of State as the officer who was to administer the government in defect of the Presi- dent and Vice-President. Here, I acknowledge, though I took far less part than was supposed, I ran counter to Mr. Jefferson’s wishes,” etc. Mr. Lodge is somewhat unlucky in his tart rebuke (p. 512) of Mr, J. C. Hamilton’s slovenly editing, which made him print Gouvion for Gouvernet: for on the opposite page (513), on page 523, and in the index he prints Harrison Grey Otis (for Gray). This first letter to Otis is omitted from the Correspondence index, which is far too mea- gre, dealing only with the names of the persons addressed by Hamilton. The general index is open to a like censure, and is wrougly said to em- brace vols. i-viii, though a separate index is ex- pressly provided for the latter (in connection with a part of vol. vii). —‘*The American Publication Society of He- brew” at Chicago have issued an ‘ Assyrian Manual,’ by Prof. D. G. Lyon, of Harvard. It is designed for those ‘‘who desire to become ac- quainted with the Assyrian language, but who cannot readily have access to oral instruction.” It contains tables of the different classes of cha- racters used in writing Assyrian, a grammar of the language, transliterated texts, texts in the cuneiform character, translations, notes, and glossary. The preface contains instructions for the use of the book by those who have no teach- er. To such persons, and to many other stu- dents, this Manual, the first of the kind that has appeared in Assyrian, will be of very great service. The only formidable thing in learning the Assyrian language is the difficulty of mastering the written charac- ters. In other respects it is comparatively easy, especially for those who have studied Hebrew. Those who fully master the less than two hun- dred pages of this book will have accomplished the most irksome part of their task. The trans- literation in Roman characters, though it may of- fend some eyes, will doubtless be found, all things considered, to be advantageous. And, with a nearly complete list of signs and a not inconsi- derable vocabulary, the student will be fairly equipped for the examination of the already great mass of Babylonian-Assyrian literature, and for the investigation of the important his- torical and other questions that yet await solu- tion. There are several chairs of Assyrian in this country, and the Wolfe expedition has brought cuneiform material to New York. An ever- widening field, embracing the beginning of Greek art, as well as the illustration of the Old Testa- ment and the reconstruction of Western Asiatic history, is opened to the young men of this gene- ration. Professor Lyon has performed his task with conscientiousness and skill. —The English Eclipse Expedition, whose per- sonnel was given in No. 1104 of the Nation, ar- rived in Grenada about two weeks before the eclipse, and divided into two, so as to eliminate as far as possible any local effects of unfavorable weather. Their observations were wholly suc- cessful, and it was noticed that the corona ex- tended nearly two diameters from the sun, ex- hibiting a feathery structure at the poles. Good photographs were obtained of the spectrum of the corona at the blue end, this spectrum being similar to that of the eclipse of 1853, as observed in the Caroline Islands of the South Pacific. The recent observations are also confirmatory of those in Egypt of the eclipse of 1882. Capt. Darwin’s work with the coronagraph is reported as dis- appointing, the glare of irradiation from the body of the sun being visible on his plates, and not the true corona, Many astronomical physi- The Nation. we will be greatly disappointed to know that Dr. Huggins, the inventor of this instrument, regards its failure as fatal to the method which seemed to promise so much new knowledge of the corona. The partial phases of the eclipse fur- nished conditions which would put the success of the method beyond doubt, if the plates showed the corona partially cut off by the moon during its approach to and passage over the sun. Not only at Grenada, but at the Cape of Good Hope, where a coronagraph was also used by Dr. Gill, this partial cutting off of the corona fails to ap- pear in the photographs taken, and Dr. Huggins hastens to be himself the first to make known this untoward result. Mr. Common, however, con- siders it quite possible, and indeed probable, that this is entirely due to the state of the sky, for we have the positive evidence that the moon has been seen so projected in various solar eciipses, and in one case it was so photographed. The fact of greatest importance brought to light by the observations of this eclipse appears from the work of Prof. Tacchini, who found that the prominences as observed during the eclipse, and after the eclipse by the usual full-sunshine me- thod, are entirely different objects; the latter be- ing, in fact, only a part of an intricate phenome- non, while the former, as seen only during eclipses, are, wholly or in part, downrushes of relatively cool material. The prominences seen during the eclipse itself had the same character as the filamentous or so-called ‘‘ white promi- nences” observed by Prof. Tacchini at the Caroline Islands in 1883; and they appear whiter and dimmer as the distance from the photosphere in- creases. The curious prolongation of the coro- na observed on several previous occasions to oc- cupy the sun’s equatorial plane does not appear in any of the photographs taken, though it was visible at all of the stations except Mr. Lock- yer’s. + ADMIRAL PORTER'S NAVAL HISTORY. The Naval History of the Civil War. By Ad- miral David D. Porter, United States Navy. New York: The Sherman Publishing Company. Pp. 843. At the present time, when correct methods of historical investigation are being gradually ap- plied to the study of the war, the appearance of a naval history by Admiral Porter has, or should have, asingular importance. In the multitude of books treating of the Rebellion, there is to be found no adequate account of naval operations as a whole, much less a discussion of their strate- gic merits from a competent professional critic. This is all the more remarkable as the war at sea presents a novelty and an interest absolutely sui generis. Apart from its merely dramatic fea- tures, it is the first, and, but for the struggle be- tween Chili and Peru, one might almost say the only, contest in which the modern appliaaces that have revolutionized the art of naval war- fare—marine engines, ironclads, rifled guns, rams and torpedoes—have been employed, and its bat- tles are as far removed from Trafalgar as Water- loo is from Agincourt; so much so, indeed, that for the student of naval science as it exists, there is little or nothing to claim his attention before 1861. . In many respects Admiral Porter is exception- ally well equipped for his task. He was actively employed from the very beginning in the most responsible duties, and his service ended only with the fall of Richmond. The Gulf, the Mis- sissippi, the Atlantic coast, the James River be- came in turn the field of his operations, and the operations were upon a more extended scale than those of any other commander. His relations with the great military and political leaders were close and confidential. He had no serious differ- ences with his colleagues of the army except Gen. Butler, and none at all with those of the navy, either superiors or subordinates. His energy and tenacity, his resource, his readiness to take responsibility, his cool strategic judg- ment, his game-cock pluck, which made fighting only the keenest sport, and, finally, his success, which culminated in the two great victories of Vicksburg and Fort Fisher, have given him a place in the history of the navy second only to that of Farragut. Admiral Porter's book, from which we had reason to look for so much, is in different parts of very unequal merit, and on the whole is a dis- appointment. The most satisfactory chapters, as might be expected, are those narrating events that came under the author’s own eye. In the campaign on the Mississippi he is at his best. His story is clear and simple, and, telling of events with which he is personally familiar, he writes rapidly, with a firm hand, and with a certain de- gree of power. The account of New Orleans is reasonably full, and is supplemented by copies of the official reports. In the description of the first attack on Fort Fisher, Gen. Butler comes in for his full meed of censure. The second attack, especially that part of it in which the Naval Brigade was concerned, receives a somewhat im- perfect treatment. There is a strong opinion am ng professional men that a better organiza- tion and more thorough preparation would have given a very different aspect to the forlorn hope which Breese led to the assault of the northeast bastion, but the Admiral’s account tells little more than his official report, sent in immediately after the action. Aside from the narrative of personal expe- rience, the most valuable part of the ‘ Naval His- tory’ is to be found in the critical opinions upon operations directed by other commanders. In passing judgment upon his contemporaries the Ad- miral is outspoken, but always fair and free from prejudice or partisan feeling. He cordially unites in the popular judgment of Farragut, and dwells on the great merits of Du Pont, showing how that most brilliant officer was sacriticed to the misguided policy of the Navy Department. Goldsborough gets the faint praise he deserves; the fine sailor-like qualities of Rowan are applaud- ed, and the conduct of the officers at the Norfolk Yard, at the Head of the Passes, and at Galveston in 1863 is stamped with unmeasured ceondemna- tion. Full justice is done to Foote, Davis, Rod- gers, and Worden, and a warm commendativn is given to Bailey, who became the victim of Farra- gut’s unintentional misstatement. But it is espe- cially when discussing operations from a profes- sional standpoint that the Admiral’s criticisms are important. The opinions that he expresses of Stringham’s attack upon Fort Hatteras, of the engagement at Donelson, of the naval assault on Fort Sumter, of Buchanan’s action in the Ten- nessee, of the escape of the Florida from Mobile and of the Sumter from New Orleans, are the ma- ture judgments of the greatest living master of naval warfare, given without reserve, and as such their value to the critical student of naval history can hardly be overestimated. Side by side with its merits Admiral Porter's book has some very serious defects, both of form and matter. Its clumsy shape, its double col- umns, its glaring covers, and its abominable woodcuts are needlessly repelling, and many es- sential maps are wanting. Insome parts of the book there is an almost inconceivable carelessness about names and dates, Thus the Pembina is half the time called the “ Paulina”; the Tyler always figures as the ‘‘ Taylor,” Col. Vogdes as ‘“Vodges,” Chas, H. Marshall as ‘‘ Chas, H. Max- well,” Gen. Lloyd Tilghman as ‘Loyd Tighl- man.” On p, 184 the Admiral says: “Tn April, 1862, after the war had progressed
Page 17
Oct. 14, 1886] The Nation. for a year, Gen. Leonidas Polk seizei upon the heights near Belmont, Ky., and, mounting heavy guns there, blocked the way for army transports from Cairo to the sea.” It would be difficult to crowd more gross blun- ders into a single sentence. Belmont is not in Kentucky, but in Missouri ; the heights that Polk seized were at Columbus, on the opposite bank of the river ; the date at which Polk seized them was early in September, 1861, and they were abandoned in the following February. How a writer who describes in detail all the operations at Belmont, Fort Donelson, and Island No. 10 could make such an error and crystallize it by the phrase, ‘‘after the war had progressed for a year,” is something that passes comprehevsion. The succeeding events, oscillating at random be- tween 1861 and 1862, are reduced to hopeless con- fusion. Of course, heedlessness like this makes the book wholly untrustworthy as to names and dates. Other errors of a no less glaring kind serve to throw serious doubt upon all the Admi- ral’s statements. Thus he says that ‘in cases of non-condemnation [of prizes], compensation was always allowed by the courts”; which is very wide of the truth. Of the 7rent affair, it is said, rather audaciously, that ‘‘the wires under the sea were flashing the news to England about the outrage to the British tlag,” when there was no submarine cable in operation. According to the Admiral, the best evidence of the illegality of England's action in reference to the Alabama is to be found in the fact that the “* English Com- missioners,” animated by a sense of fair play, concurred in the Geneva award—a fact that will be new to most of his readers. The Admiral’s method of presentation, as well as his matter, leaves much to be desired. When he is off his own ground, his narrative is dis jointed, involved, sometimes almost incoherent. Inconsequential statements, repetitions, interrup- tions, bits of information thrown in pell-mell, give parts—and a good many parts—of his big volume the effect of notes transcribed from a scrap-book. He proposes in his preface to ‘* put the records in plain shape and write them down in plain English.” Unfortunately, in too many places he has done neither. Admirals may be allowed a good deal of latitude in literature, but such phrases as the resolution ‘* was never resur- rected,” ‘each vessel fighting on her own hook,” and ‘‘Semmes began to breathe a little easy,” would hardly be tolerated in a schoolboy ; while the rhetorical flights, as where “the army and navy wiped out the foul blow that had been struck,” or men were * carried away by the gla- mour of a great contest,” or the rebels forgot ‘‘that the men they were slaying not long before may have met them in amity at the festive board,” are worthy only of a dime novel. There are innumerable passages of this character, but one example will suffice. On page 42 the Admi- ral says : ‘* It was only when these deaths of gallant offi- cers occurred that the country began to realize the Secessionists were animated with a fell pur- po-e which would not be appeased until the whole land was saturated with blood and sorrow walked over the battle-fields where friends and foes lay mingled together in the arms of death.” This is a fair sample of the rubbish that fills page after page of the Admiral’s book, when he gets away from the Mississippi. Nevertheless, some portions of the work have real merit ; and though, as a whole, it cannot be considered well done, either from a popular or a professional point of view, both the popular reader and the naval student, if they have time and patience to separate the wheat from the chaff, will find them- selves repaid by its perusal. —— — 4 ENGLISH EXPLORATIONS IN NORTH AMERICA. English Explorations and Settlements in North America, 1497—1689. (Narrative and Criti- cal History of America. Volume iii.) Edited by Justin Winsor. Boston: Houghton, Mif flin & Co. THE present volume, the second in course of pub lication, and apparently the first written, bids fair to prove of wider interest than its pre decessor, That followed the course of Span ish discovery and conquest, this depicts the foundation of English colonies; and though there is fascination still in travellers’ tales, readers to-day find a keener zest in watch ing the unfolding of political formations, The earlier chapters, indeed, rehearse the begin nings of Arctic exploration, the records of which vie in interest with those of any land; but the bulk of the book is devoted to an exposi tion of the process whereby Englishmen wrested from the wilderness the secret of colonization, and learned amid new conditions to separate the germ from the wrappings of government. The papers show a uniformity in style and structure. Nearly all are pitched in the low business like tone of modern historical writing. which may soothe but cannot exhilarate the reader. None of the writers have “ sacriticed fact to rhetoric”; the majority have made no at tempt at literary effect. Nor is this all: the point of view, the method of treatment, have a re semblance which is explained when we observe that, in selecting his collaborators, the editor has availed himself largely of the assistance of those historical societies whose tield of action lay with iu the limits of the volume. Mr. Charles Deane, Vice President of the Mas sachusetts Historical Society, isthe author of two valuable articles. He opens the volume with an exhaustive account of the Cabots, comprised in a narrative of seven pages and a critical essay of fifty—a fine illustration of the law of the discus sion of sources, viz.: that the length of the exami nation of materials must be in inverse ratio to | the square of their extent. It is interesting to | compare with this monograph the book recently | published by M. Harrisse, entitled ‘Jean et Sa- | bastien Cabot’ (Paris, 1882), and to note a sub stantial agreement in conclusions, while in ful ness of bibliographic detail the advantage is cer- tainly with Mr. Deane. Both writers give the chief credit of the discovery of North America to Jobn Cabot, and place the discovery in 1497 and | not in 1494, as the ‘Cabot " map hasit. As to the landfall they are at variance, Mr. Deane re- garding the claim made for Cape Breton on the map of 1544 as sufficient, in the absence of other testimony, to make that a working hypothesis, while M. Harrisse. from an examination of the topography of that region and a calculation of Cabot’s rate of sailing, is inclined to put the landfall further north, and to consider the entry on the map as resulting from an attempt made by Sebastian Cabot to revise his fading recollec- tions of the discovery in the light of Cartier's explorations. To our mind, this view has much to recommend it. In his second article Mr. Deane has set some order in the tangle of royal grants in New Eng- land, made in the happy days when the geography of that region had scarcely asserted its claim to regard, and has sketched the political history of the several colonies down to 1689 rather more briefly than the limits of the volume required. In the critical chapter, a copy of the ‘‘ Win- throp” map of Boston, the earliest known, dis- covered in the British Museum since the chapter was written, has been inserted. A fuller account | | of the Massachusetts public records than is here 311 given can now be found in the report of the Com- mission on the Records, recently printed It is a little odd, in view of the course adopted elsewhere in the book, that all the New England Plymouth treated by one band, and we look. for protests from several quarters, particularly the small but sensitive State that borders Narragan Deane nor the editor is imbued with sufficient hatred of the oppressors of Roger Williams. . “It is interesting,” says Dr. Hale in his essays » Hawkins and Drake, very sizing a well known part of the former's carver colonies eacept should have bees fren sett Bay, since neither Mr properly empha “to observe that in all these early narratives of the slave trade there is no intimation that it in volved cruelty or any form of wrong. Hawkins sailed on the ship Jesus with faith as serene as if he had sailed on a crusade. His sailing orders to his four ships close with words which remind one Serve God daily preserve your victuals iv company shall yom in of Cromwell love one an oOtber ; beware of (ire and keep good company serve God’ it is meant that the ship's and this In one of their incursions on the Guinea coast they were aln Thos religious services morning and evening these slave-traders regularly did destroved vy the native negroes, as they well de served to be. Hawkins narrates the adventure with this comment God, who worketh all things for the best, would not have it se, and by him we escaped without danger His nani be praised for it And again, when they were nearly starved, becalmed ino mid ocean \} mighty God, who never suffereth his elect perish, sent us the onlinary breege All who intend to dip into the late anti-slavery cont: versy are advised to keep the above pmragraph before them. Dr. Hale, who has devoted much study to the question, is convinced that Drake, in 157M, discovered the present Bay of San Kyan cisco, and holds out hope of the speedy and de should be H. Bancroft's lifferent opi finitive decision of the question. It stated that the author of Mr. H tirst volume on California is of a nieuw With the chapters by C. ¢ and Fox inthe Northwest Santh on Frobisher and W. W. Henry of Virginia on Raleigh, we leave for a time the pe riod of discovery and enter upon that of coloniza tion, guided by Robert A. Brock of the Virginia Historical who the bungling struggle of the Jamestown colony for existence. He refuses to accept the story of, the rescue of South by Pocahontas, and brings the history of Virginia down to 1680. He is followed by Dr De Costa, who upholds his peculiar views re- garding Weymouth and Gosnold in an interest ing chapter on Norumbega Society, relates This is supplement ed by an editorial note containing a valuable list of the earliest English publications on America (1508-1509). From a somewhat perfunctory and nebulous chapter by Dr. Ellis on the religious element in New England, wherein he has not done by the subject what we rightfully expected from him, we pass toone of the best bits of work in the book, an article on the Pilgrim Church and Ply mouth Colony by Prof. F. B. Dexter of Yaie Col lege—altogether admirable, and a model of what such a summary should be. Jobn Austin Stevens treats of New York from 1664 to 1689 in an agreeable essay, notable for an unusual estimate of Sir Edmond Andros. This is not shared by Mr. W. A. Whitehead of the New Jersey Historical Society, who relates the confused story of the Jerseys. The,founding of Pennsylvania is described by Mr. F. D. Stone, Librarian of the Historical Society of that State, and the volume closes with a chapter on the Bal- timore Colony by William T. Brantly of the Ma- ryland Historical Society, who takes the usual
Page 18
local view of the religious tolerance practised by the Proprietary. We must not omit reference to a short but very complete monograph by G. B. Keen on Plowden’s Colony of New Albion, which will be new to many. As a whole, the volume is well up to the stan- dard already set. The editor has not written much for it, but marks of his supervision abound. If the number of maps and cuts bas fallen off, it is partially due to the subject-matter. It is much to be regretted that modern reference- maps have not been more freely inserted, both in this and the former volume. With a work in octavo or smaller it is permissible, and often ad- visable, to relegate maps to an atlas ; but where, as here, the page is abundantly large, it is a pity that readers should be forced to refer from one cumbersome volume to another. The effect of having the history of a colony treated by a loyal resident of the locality is good, and, in spite of # compensatory lack of continu- ity, necessitati:.z an unpleasant dependence upon the index, the codperative method may score an- other success. If it be said that the colonial pe- riod is peculiarly adapted to such treatment, and that it will fail to secure a faithful picture of na- tional life, we cannot agree. We believe that the United States can have its past most truth- fully portrayed by a siriiful blending of local, sectional monographs. That it may at some time be given to one man to write the philoso- phy of our history, we do not mean to deny ; but the history itself will be best told by a union of writers, so long as the national motto shall retain its truth. RUSSIAN AUTHORS FOR FRENCH READERS. UNDER the title ‘Le Roman russe’ (Paris: Plon & Nourrit; Boston: Schoenhof), M. le vicomte ». M. de Vogiié has now collected and arranged the very interesting studies upon Russian litera- ture which he has contributed to the Revue des Deux Mondes during the past three years. He has prefixed to them a general introductory chap- ter upon the present condition of literary art in France, which appeared in the same periodical in May last, only a few weeks before the com- plete work was published. Another short, but for the purpose of the author very complete, sketch of the poets who illuminated the years be- fore ‘‘ the forties,” the great era in Russian lite- rary history, and of whom the central figure is Pushkin, which appeared about the same time in the Revue Bleue, was taken from the chapter upon the influence of Byron and the Romantic school during the earher years of the century. Thus the entirely unpublished matter that a reader will find in looking through the newly is- sued volume is not very great. The most impor- tant and interesting portion of it is what relates to Bielinsky and the critical tempests of the mid- dle of the century, the wars of the Slavophiles and the Occidentals, of the literary coteries of Moscow and St. Petersburg; and, closely con- nected with this, the half-philosophical, half-po- litical disturbances which influenced all the lite- rary life and work of the period. Much of this was originally scattered through the papers upon the four great masters, Gogol, Turgeneff, Dos- toyevsky, and Tolstoi, which were published in the Revue des Deux Mondes at long intervals, and the final form in which the whole appears is rather a rearrangement of the material already prepared than a revision and condensation of it, as at first it seems to be. Nothing more interesting and more instructive could be found for a critical study of the methods of a writer who cares very much for the form in which he clothes his thought, than a comparison of the article in the Revue upon Turgeneff,for in- [Number 1111 stance, with the chapter in ‘Le Roman russe’ upon the same writer. All that had a merely temporary interest (the article appeared just af- ter the death of Turgeneff in 1883) has been care- fully removed, as well as many eloquent passages which, though uot inappropriate where they were, injured the unity and simplicity of the im- pression. These passages all find their place in an introduction to the chapter, which prepares the way for what is to come, and leaves no neces- sity for explanatory remarks. The fine literary sense of M. de Vogiié, developed by his classical training and sympathies, has thus brought out the figure of the master by very simple means, with far greater clearness and vigor than before. It is a much better literary performance, and if it is not so spontaneous, the reader forgives an author who understands so well how to conceal the labor he gives to the perfecting of his work. At a time when so many books are made up hastily, by a gathering together of fugitive pa- pers published here and there, such conscientious care is worthy of all praise. When M. de Vogiie first addressed the readers of the Revue des Deux Mondes, Russian litera- ture was an almost unexplored field, and it is not too much to say that it is to his articles that French and English readers are indebtel fora knowledge of Tolstoi and of Dostoyevsky and even of Gogol. The article upon Tolstoi appear- ed only a few days before the republication in Paris of the French translation of ‘War and Peace,’ which, though published in St. Peters- burg ten years before, was known to very few outside of Russia. The enthusiasm with which the new writer was received was owing in a great measure to the clearness and beauty of the presentation of his works by M. de Vogiié. When the translation of ‘Crime and Chastisement ’ was published in Paris, the readers of the Revue des Deux Mondes were prepared for its reception by the very interesting and sympathetic article up- on Dostoyevsky which M. de Vogiié contributed to its pages not long afterwards. It is from the publication of these two works in Paris that the present great interest in Russian imaginative li- terature dates. Other translations had been made before, others had written of them with admira- tion and sympathy, but the public had never un- til then been moved and interested. More than thirty years ago Mérimée had written with en- thusiasm of Pushkin and Gogol, and bad publish- ed translations from both; Viardot, with the as- sistance of Turgeneff and other Russians, had also given some of their most interesting work, in translations far more faithful and expressive than much that is now being done; but the inte- rest in the literature did not extend beyond a small literary circle. Even Turgeneff, so well known and so much talked and written about, was comparatively unread during his lifetime, and Turgeneff is the most Occidental of Russian writers. M. de Vogiié bas not attempted to write a his- tory of Russian literature or even of the Russian novel. Such a work, for foreign readers, would be an impossibility, so wide and unexplored is the field, so numerous the writers, so unknown the literary and political and social history of the times. He has instead taken the four greatest writers of the last half century, all of whom are accessible by means of translations, more or less complete and satisfactory, of some, at least, of their writings. With sincere admiration, and ge- nerally with fine appreciation of all that is best and noblest in their writings and in their lives, he has presented to his readers both the writers and their principal works, their lives and the world in which they lived. 1f all this is interest- ing and attractive from its unlikeness to every- thing with which we are familiar, it is still more so from a certain simplicity and grandeur of soul, a sincerity and uprightness, alike in the au- thors and in the creations of their imaginations, which charms and subjugates us. This M. de Vogiié has felt, and bas made his readers feel, with a sympathetic and, to a certain extent, a po- etic fervor, ia his chapters upon Turgeneff and Tolstoi, and especially in that upon Dostoyevsky. He is not always so happy in what he says of Go- gol, or rather of his earlier writings, for no one has shown a greater depth of insight or a finer appreciation of all his later work, the work of his second manner, than M. de Vogiié. But the fantastic imagination of the supernatural legends of the Ukraine, the epic grandeur of ‘ Taras Bul- ba,’move him but little. He acknowledges his lack of sympathy in both cases, and he only touches upon the works of the author during this period of his literary life in order to show the transformation which took place in this most comprehensive and representative of writers, whose earlier work continued the romantic tra- dition of Pushkin and of Lermontoff while trans- forming it, and who later was the creator and the precursor of the modern school of Russian writers. All the latter partof M. de Vogiié’s study of Gogol, that part which relates to this second period of his literary life, is in his very best manner. M. de Vogiié is not a literary critic who is seek- ing to form and direct the opinions of his readers, much less to impose his own; but a student of literary history, seriously and enthusiastically impressed by the beauty and excellence of the new literature which he is in a great measure revealing to them. The reader does not always assent either to his literary or to his moral judg- ments, but the purity and elevation of purpose in all that he writes are so great that he does not offend even at such times. Turgeneff’s well-known story, ‘On the Eve,’ which originally appeared in Russia in 1859, has recently been translated into French by M. E. Halpérine, and published by Hetzel (New York : Christern), under the title ‘Un Bulgare,’ with the sub-title *‘ A la veille.” Itis strange that it should never have been translated into French before, as was announced at the time of its pub- lication, if such is really the fact. It is certainly one of the most exquisite of Turgeneff’s stories, as Helen is one of the most exquisite of his lovely young girls ; and nowhere has he drawn a character more successfully than that of Shubin. With his finest and most delicate touches he cre- ates this Russian Hamlet, whose melancholy is not sad but gay. From the opening chupter, where he lies in the shade on the river bank and discourses upon art and love and the rest of life, to the last page, he is in a sense the central figure of the book, the most sympathetic, the most hu- man of them all. Every one of his many inter- views with the good, serious, upright Bersenieff is a masterpiece; equalled only by the later ones with Uvar Ivanovitch. And who but Turgeneff could have created and used with such artistic skill this last expressively sitent personage ? The book is a poem from beginning to end in concep- tion and in treatment ; but that is only saying that it is written in Turgeneff’s customary fash- ion. Two of the earlier works of Count Leo Tolstol, ‘The Cossacks’ and ‘ Sebastopol during the Siege,’ have recently been translated into French and published in a volume together, with the titles ‘Les Cosaques’ and ‘Scénes du siége de Sébas- topol’ (Paris: Hachette; Boston: Schoenhof). In his early manhood Tolstoi served in a regiment of artillery for several years—at first, in 1851 and 1852, in the Caucasus, in which the scene of ‘ Les Cosaques' is laid; and afterwards, during the Crimean war, in Sebastopol. it was here, dur- ing the siege, that some portions, at least, of the ‘Scénes du siége de Sébastopol’ were written, |
Page 19
andl Sarai sin tania. Oct. 14, 1886] and from here that they were sent to Moscow for publication in the Russian Messenger while the siege was going on. The complete work is com- posed of three detached portions, entitled respec- tively Sebastopol in December, in May, and in August. These are neither personal recollections nor imaginary adventures, but sometbing be- tween the two: the personal impressions of the writer given under a slight veil of partly uureal circumstances. All the characteristics of the battle-scenes of ‘War and Peace’ are in these thrilling narratives of the events of the three periods chosen, and the personal emotion of the young officer of twenty-six, who relates what be sees passing around him constantly, moves his readers just as the sympathetic imagination of the mature author of ‘War and Peace’ does twelve years later, when he shows them, through the minds of his various heroes, his own impres- sions of war by means of the great battles of Na- poleon. After the Crimean war was over, Tolstoi published another semi-autobiographical work, ‘Childhood, Boyhood, and Youth,’ a translation of which, by Mme. Arvéde: Barine, under the title ‘Enfance, adolescence, jeunesse,’ is an- nounced as in preparation, and of which frag- ments have already been published in the Rerue Blewe. This work, as we have had occasion to point out, apropos of the American version, has all the charm of a biography without actually re- lating the events of the author's external life. In all that is essential, however, the young Nicolas seems to reflect the growth of the moral and in- tellectual nature of Tolstoi himself, as in the nar- ration of his boyish faults and vanities and self- reproaches, in the minute and vivid descriptions of his life and companions, we divine the personal experience of the author. A little later than this, but during the same period of his life, in the years between his re- tirement from the army and his marriage, Tolstoi published his third work of importance, the ex- quisite idyl whicb has now appeared, under the title of ‘ Les Cosaques,’ in the same volume with the ‘Scénes du siége de Sébastopol.’ As long agoas 1878, Mr. Eugene Schuyler gave to Eng- lish readers a translation of this work, which Turgeneff is said to have considered * the finest and most perfect production of Russian litera- ture”; but it is only within afew months that it has been made accessible to French readers. ‘Les Cosaques’ contains the first fresh impres- sions made upon Tolstoi during his years of mili- tary service in the Caucasus, by the free and un- civilized life into which he was thrown, and by the wild and magnificent scenery surrounding him. It is the poetic expression of the feelings of a very young man, filled with delight and astonishinent at the new existence revealed to him. The story itself is slight, but the interest never flags ; for here, as in all his later works, it does not depend upon events but upon the analy- sis of character and of feeling, the passionate ad- miration of the young man for everything around him, and his instinctive repulsion for the old life which he had left. Though published some time after this life in the Caucasus was over, and only after several other books, * Les Cosaques ’ has a certain freshness and joyousness of youth which none of the other works of Tolstoi possess ; and if it was revised and arranged at the time of its publication, it was probably written, in its essen- tial parts, in the midst of the scenes and the per- sons pictured in it. In 1860, at the age of thirty-two, Tolstoi mar- ried, and very soon after retired to his estates in the country, where he has lived ever since, in the midst of bis family and tenants, a life which the readers of ‘Anna Karénina’ might easily imagine for themselves, even without the revelations of his later works. At some time during this long The Nation. period of retirement from the world, but proba bly not during the earlier years, he wrote the charming story which has been translated fy M. lecomte d’Hauterive under the title of * Katia’ (Paris: Perrin; Boston: Schoenhof). This trans lation was first published in IS7S8, when Tolstoi had scarcely been beard of outside of Russia, and it was only when the book was republished a few months ago that it began to be read. Another translation, with the title * Mon mari et moi, ap peared last winter; but it was buried in the pages of the Rerue Internationale and was read by few. Nothing that the author has ever done contains more exquisite writing than this; none among his charming young lovable than Katia; none of his men more simply noble than Sergiei; and nowhere has he revealed with so tender and sympathetic a touch the most delicate and evanescent shades of sentiment and of feeling as in this exquisite little story. The latest translation from the writings of Tolstoi is a volume containing half-a-dozen short stories with the collective title ‘A la recherche du bonheur’ (Paris: Perrin; New York: Chris tern). If the preceding works represent and sum up all the literary life of the author, this one is the expression of the moral and religious beliefs and feelings which now govern all his actions. These popular stories, legends, and parables are written for the Russian peasants, with the same simplicity and directness of purpose that he has shown 1n other directions. If his readers of an other class regret the author they have lost, they ‘annot help respecting and admiring the moralist who writes for the poor and humble with so much single-minded devotion. ‘Souvenirs de la maison des morts’ (Paris Plon & Nourrit; New York: Christern) is the expressive title of the book in which Dostoyevsky women are more has related his vears of exile and imprisonment in Siberia, in consequence of supposed complicity ina political conspiracy. A slight veilis thrown over the reality; a few unimportant modifica tions of facts place it beyond the limits of the se vere rules of the Government censure, which, without some such disguise, would have prevent- ed its publication, But in everything of impor tance it is the veritable ‘Souvenirs’ of Dosto yevsky himself. At twenty-eight vears of age, in December, 1849, after eight months of imprison ment, he was led out with his companions to hear the sentence which had been pronounced upon them. It was immediate death. As the prisoners stood together upon the scaffold waiting the exe cution of the sentence, a white flag was raised between them and the file of soldiers whose guns were already directed towards them. lt wasa signal of respite; they were to be sent to Siberia Dostoyevsky'’s sentence was four years of hani labor ip prison, and afterwanis incorporation for lifeina Siberian regiment as a common soldier, with the loss of civil rights and his rank as a gen tleman. It was during these four years spent in irons and constantly guarded, in the midst of the worst criminals, never for an instant alone, with no books but a Testament, no knowledge of the outer world, tuat the young author, who had al ready begun to be famous, laid up the materials for his ‘Souvenirs de la maison des morts,” It seems as if he had reproduced in the pages of this book all the events, all the companions, all the agonies of these years. [tis done with the utmost patience and submission of spirit on bis own part; with the finest insight into the cha- racters of his companions. But what is most im- pressive is not the wonderfully minute and searching analysis of the inmost souls of the mi- serable beings who people this Inferno: itis the inexhaustible sympathy and compassion with which the author writes of them, revealing the divine spirit in the most degraded—a sympathy and compassion which never relieves itself in | words, but which inspires the whole book and gl rifles it. Whoever has read the strange and thrilling work of Dostoyevsky can perhaps imagine something of the manner in ‘Crime and Chastisement which he would treat such a subject as that of Plon & Nourrit; New York ‘Imagine a husband in the presence Krotkaia’ (Paris Christern of the body of his dead wife. a few hours only after she has thrown herself out of a window Dostovevsky begins his exposition in this Way in a short preface to the book. The busbaud ts in extreme trouble, unable to collect his thoughts going over to himself all that bas happened con fusediy, justifving himself, accusing his wife fos the past, recalling all their life together Cron the beginning, all that has led to the catastropt Gradually all the past becomes clear to hin, he sees it truly and his own part init The ¢ romancier, as M. de Vogiie calls bum, has here a subject suited to his powers. Such an exposition might seem to promise a repulsive book, sonic thing tumultuous and borritle. It ts alapost cal and all the more impressive It is not pau read. [tis not agreeable, but if shows the strange and powerful writer in ons of bis most chars teristic moods, and it is a marvellous study of the human soul, In a recent namber of the A ratne there appeared some very striking pag entitled * Le taken from the last work written by Dostoves sky, ‘Les Frores Karamasoff which Mo Victor Derely is now translating, and wh Grand Inquisiteur Thev were au ois an nounced for approaching pablication by Pion & Nourrit in their series of the complete works o the author. The passage published is complete in itself. One of the brothers relates to the other tne subject of a kind of philasophical or theologi The simplicity and cal poem, ‘Christ in Spain.’ unadorned directness of the style in which he ex presses his thought, the grandeur of the form im which heembodies it, the gradual gathering up and unfolding of the idea in one unbreken con ception without a flaw or stain upon its unity, Is It is the highest point to which Dostovevsky bas attained in anything vet something marvellous translated. The luminous beauty of this pros« poem can best be realized by a comparison which readily suggests itself with the. Torque mada’ of Victor Hugo. or his * Fin de Satan. Richard Steele. By Austin Dobson. (English Worthies.] London: Longmans, Green & Co. TSS, THE discovery of Stecle in the character of an English Worthy, instead of Man of Letters, has a touch of the same humorous surprise in it that his comrades of the mess must have felt at his Original appearance in literature as The Chris tian Hero. In hisown day he found it a hard matter to deserve that reputation the coffee-house was the easy thing; now the ta to bea wit of bles are turned, it seems, and the too humanly complying Captain of the Life-Guards, denied the boon companionship of Swift and Addison under the literary editing of our century, turns up among the worshipfuls. His heart, we may be sure, would swell with the new title, could he be made to think it belonged to him. Mr. Dobson does his best to make the reader think so. He knows very well, however, that his is not the usual task of the biographer of a previous age, merely to evoke the spirit of a dead mortal: the historian and the novelist have been beforehand with him, and when the literary imagination has seized upon a character of the past, truth has as little chance against its illusions as against a popular hero. Macaulay’s sinister dislike and Thackeray’s warm affection have created a Steele for us; and, different as their judgments are, the divergence
Page 20
314. springs rather from their temperaments than from their conceptions of the culprit’s career. Mr. Dobson suggests that Steele, in this character of the culprit, whether graceless or humbly apolo- getic, is not a justifiable representation of the whole man, and that the flings of the one and the condonements of the other of the great literary portrait painters are too much in one tone of co- lor. For himself, he has tried, though against tremendous rhetorical odds, to give us only a na- tural picture. Had it not been for some intricacies in his ca- reer, and the entanglement of his fame in con- sequence of that famous foreign alliance by which he called Addison to his aid, Steele’s cha- racter would never have seemed anything but simple. It is not even rare, except for the ex- cess of its attractiveness and tbat subtle power which the literary gift seems to blend with the other elements of human nature. Indeed, Thack- eray was able to idealize it so plausibly because it approaches so near to a general type. Mr. Dub- son analyzes it briefly into a weak will and an honest purpose; and this conjunction, as in the case of other people, frequently brought Steele into trouble. Furthermore, his own lips and the lips of his enemies, and fortune in the shape of hundreds of his familiar letters, made his affairs the open gossip of Queen Anne’s taverns and our own libraries. It was perhaps a disadvantage to him that he always ‘‘owned up” and ate hum- ble pie. His reputation affords a striking in- stance of the damaging effects of self-deprecia- tion, not only in bis life, but in literature. Of the trio, Swift had more mind, Addison more cultivation—vastly more; and Steele was as des- titute of the contemplative serenity of the one as of the intellectual fury of the other. But he was distinguished from both as being the man of heart, the lovable one, the one ‘‘like unto ourselves.” Mr. Dobson has indicated this primary quality in Steele while discussing Addison’s superiority as a “classical” writer; ‘‘ but,” he says, ‘* for words which the heart finds when the head is seeking; for phrases glowing with the white heat of a ge- nerous emotion; for sentences which throb and tingle with manly pity or courageous indigna- tion, we must turn to the essays of Steele.” Style, of this sort, is one of the great virtues of a writer. Nor did Steele lack a second great virtue, inven- tion. If one were disposed to cavil, he might smile at this, and remind us of the search Steele made in the beginning of his career for the philosopher's stone, and of the fish-pool patent he took out at the end of it ; and truly he had his share of the follies that attend projectors, among whom he is placed by his fertility and the restless practical energy that belonged to his mercurial tempera- ment. But the eighteenth-century essay was a project of another sort, and Steele did originate and conduct it—one of the distinct historic forms of English literature ; and, moreover, this in- volved the invention of light social satire, do- mestic genre-painting, and all the other forms in which he was the adventurer before Addison came to occupy the land. Though the country perpetuated the name of Americus, let us remem- ber who discovered it. And Steele, in doing this, was not only the forerunner of Addison, to whom at his best he 1s as superior in feeling as at his worst he is inferior in finish; he wrote what Gold- smith read, and ushered in the novelists. But one should not push too far the advantage a man holds by virtue of his historical position in the tendency of a literary age, and we fear that we are too readily faliing into the strain of those writers whose papers on Steele are made up of apologies and claims —a strain which Mr. Dobson himself, with all his watchfulness, cannot wholly avoid. It is so natural to love Steele, and to feel that in the world’s hurly-burly for justice he)is The Nation. {Number 1111 irretrievably the under-dog, that one’s pen pleads for him before the head is aware, and, like Lord Finch, “‘ could fight for this man.” Mr. Dobson masks his batteries, but they are there, and they play silent havoc on all those who have undervalued Steele’s part in the Queen Anne time, whether in the hen-pecking manner of Ma- caulay or with the patronizing charity of our much-beloved Thackeray. It behooves the reader to be wary, or he may suddenly be believing that possibly Steele was a better man than he thought himself ; that the political fervor which made him a partisan, and drew the rancor of faction on his name, was patriotic duty ; that the moral sense which made him denounce gamblers and duelling, his indignation at wrong, his pity for the suffering, and the quick alliance of his sym- pathy with the weak, which made him in no sen- timental sense the friend of humanity ; and espe- cially that his loyalty to an ideal yet human virtue, which made him such a censor of the town that he pleased them with the wholesome truth about themselves—the reader, we say, may begin to know that these are in fact the traits of an English Worthy, and not of the traditional Culprit, the Steele of fiction. He may even find himself admiring instead of forgiving him ; and if at the end, when all is done, and the pretty Welsh scene near the death, and the dance after- piece which Mr. Dobson provides, are both over, he coolly remembers the Captain of Life-Guards and the Lover-Gazetteer and the Sir Knight at Edinburgh, and cannot quite make up his mind that Steele was a hero, after all, yet he will sure- ly think of him more truthfully, and recognize in him more manhood for this Life of him. That one prefers to think of him as a man of letters, with the failings and brilliancies and the human charm that belong to that quality, is no diminu- tion of praise. Par Jean 1886. S8vo, La Religion a Rome sous les Séveres. Réville. Paris: Ernest Leroux. pp. 302. STUDENTs of the history of religion will find in M. Réville’s treatise a very interesting and, we think, to most a wholly novel chapter of that history. The reign of Septimius Severus formed, as readers of Gibbon know, an important epoch in the Roman Empire. Since Gibbon wrote, we have been taught more fully and precisely the nature of the constitutional and social changes at this period which gave it this importance. From M. Réville we learn that the religious and theological changes of these years were no less marked and decisive. The principal facts in this connection are, to be sure, not wholly new. That Elagabalus was a priest of the sun, end that he did not cease to be a priest by being crowned Emperor ; that Alexander Severus had in his chapel images of Christ and Abraham by the side of those of Or- pheus and Apollonius of Tyana—are familiar facts. But their bearing, as parts of a great syn- cretic movement which culminated at this period, has, we think, never been so fully shown before. Even *‘Syncretism "—the sense of the oneness of religions—was not really new. It was the same thing when Greeks or Romans adopted the dei- ties of other countries, or identified their own deities with them. When the Romans borrowed Apollo from Greece and Isis from Egypt ; when they recognized that Athena was Minerva and Thor Jupiter, these were acts of syncretism—a distinct step towards an understanding of the universality of law and the unity of the deity. The growth of this conception was slow and gra- dual. It reached its culmination at the begin- ning of the third century ; and when the pa- gan syncretism of the Severi broke down, it found Christianity just prepared to occupy the ground which it was itself incapable of filling. The pointing out of the relation between this pagan syncretism and the growth and triumph of Christianity is one of the most interesting points in this book. The character of pagan syncretism appears well displayed in this sentence (p. 108) : ‘Where we say at the present time, ‘ to the sovereign God who reigns in the heavens, who disseminates light and inspires wisdom, the God who dispenses war and peace,’ etc.; the pagan syucretist said, ‘to Jupiter Greatest and Best, to Juno, Apollo (or Sol), Minerva, Mars (or the Ge- nius of Victory), Peace,’ etc.” An interesting point of detail (p. 93): ‘The cult of Mithra offers the greatest analogy with that of the gnostics. It was in reality a pa- gan gnosticism, with its theories upon the evolu- tion of souls and its procedures to assure their return to the upper world. It had its vast ambi- tions and its puerilities, its combination of ele- vated views and superstitions.” The closest analogies with Christianity are ex- plained in the following passages : ‘* A new sentiment thus takes possession of the religious conscience of paganism. Itisa moral conviction which offers the greatest analo- gies with the sense of sin among Christians, and which is, so to speak, its pagan éxpression. It is believed that there are in human nature bad, im- pure elements; appetites and passions which, while natural, are none the less impious—only, instead of attributing the origin of these bad tendencies to a bad use of liberty, they are ex- plained from the very constitution of buman na- ture. They abandon themselves more and more to dualism: matter on one side, source of evil, and spirit on the other side, source of good and of life; on the one side the body with its passions, on the other the soul with its higher aspirations ” (p. 152). ‘** Apologists for and detractors of Christianity would have spared themselves many discussions if they had taken account of the numerous facts which testify to this truth [the existence of this sentiment}. It is no more suitable to pay honor to Christianity alone for this awakening of the religious conscience, than to hold it alone re- sponsible for the ascetic customs and institutions which were its consequence. Christiamty and paganism were carried along in the same current, but the bark of Christ was better suited to such navigation than the vessel of paganism, which was accustomed to sail in other waters” (p. 155). The details of this pagan revival are narrated with great fulness and vivacity. It was, as is shown, inspired and guided by four women of Asiatic birth, whose relations to the imperial throne gave them an opportunity to exert an un- usual influence upon the religious thcught of their age. These were Julia Domna, wife of Septimius Severus and mother of Caracalla; her sister, Julia Mesa: and the two daughters of the latter, Julia Soemias, mother of Elagabalus, and Julia Mamea, mother of Alexander Severus. The characterization of these four women is very interesting from a purely historical point of view. The two elder sisters, Domna and Mesa, were alike ambitious and imperious. Domna exercised great influence in the reigns of her hus- band and son, while Mesa ruled in the name of her grandson, Elagabalus. The two younger sis- ters were very unlike: Soemias was weak and voluptuous, like her worthless son ; Mamea, of the purest and noblest type of women, worthy of her virtuous son. In each of these three again— leaving out Julia Soemias, who appears to have been a nullity—syncretism took an individual and peculiar shape. It was under Julia Domna that the name and sanctity of Apollonius of Tyana came into currency—as a kind of rival to Christ, some think, but M. Réville thinks not. Julia Mzsa aimed, through the priest-emperor Elagabalus, to introduce a syncretism resting upon the supremacy of the sun-god, El] Gabal. Julia Mamea and her son, Alexander Severus, worshipped a syncretism composed of the saints of all times and all religions. Of this culminat- ing period of paganism—a higher religious level,
Page 21
Zz % soc Oct. 14, 1880] it would seem, even than that of Marcus Aure- lius—we are told (p. 275), ‘*No intolerance (intransigeance)! Peace be- tween all forms of worship! For all have their ground in history, and all are legitimate from the moment their adherents find in them the satisfaction of their religious needs. For this reason Alexander Severus, even supposing him to have had more energy and other advisers, could not have accomplished the work of Con stantine. He was too honest to be converted for political reasons like Constantine, and too sin- cerely syncretic to agree to the intolerance of the Christians towards other cults. No matter. The Christian church owes as much perhaps to Alex- ander Severus and those of his school as to Con- stantine, not only by reason of the great tolera- tion which they exhibited towards it, and which permitted it to acquire a power without which the work of Constantine would have been impos- sible, but also by reason of the religious impulse which they gave to the pagan syncretism, pecu- liarly fitted to prepare minds for Christianity.” History of the Reformation in England. By George G, Perry, M.A., Canon of Lincoln and Rector of Waddington. A. D. F. Randolph & Co. 1886. TuIs volume, one of the ‘‘ Epochs of Church His- tory” series, is in much better accordance with the title of the series than ‘The English Church in Other Lands,’ the only other volume of the series so far published. While it glances back- ward for a moment at the remoter causes of the English Reformation, it is devoted mainly to the .period from the fall of Wolsey to the establish- ment of the national Church, in substantially its present form, in the second decade of Elizabeth's reign. It may be objected that the writer stops half way; that the Puritanism, Presbyterianism, and Independency of the seventeenth century were the completion of the Reformation, But it was just as well for Canon Perry to stop where he did. It is evident from his tone, wherever he speaks of Puritanism, that he could not treat of it with justice or with temperance ; while his book, as it now stands, is remarkable for its general exhibition of these qualities. The tre- mendous influence of Henry VIII. on the estab- lishment of the English Church is not underrated in the usual manner of the Anglican historian. It is made perfectly evident that the “act of supremacy ” subjected the clergy to him as they had never been subjected to the Papal power. Nor is there any glossing of the sordid elements that entered into the new establishment, and largely influenced and controlled the direc- tion of events. No attempt is made to palliate the baseness of Henry’s Vicar-General, Crum- well (sic, and a convenient spelling which de- serves general adoption), and, in acknowledg- ing that Cranmer was the fairest product of the Reformation period, the weakness of his character is not disallowed, but indicated with the utmost clearness. The much-vexed question of the spoliation of the monasteries is treated with less of partisan bias than in the his- tories of Mr. Froude. But while the reasons there as elsewhere assigned for it are declared false and insufficient, it is argued that the time for the cessation of monachism in England had fully arrived. The treatment of Mary has less of bitterness, and that of Elizabeth less of sickening adulation,than we generally find in histories writ- ten from the Anglican point of view. The rhetoric of closing paragraphs is apt tobe somewhat tur- gid, and Canon Perry’s is no exception to the rule, as when he calls the Reformation ** the parent of all that is greatest and best in the triumphs of the human intellect.” Homer and Dante should cer- tainly be included in that ‘‘ all,” and there is no- thing in Shakspere that reflects the influence of the Reformation on his mind. Canon Perry has the easy conscience of his order generally in the matter of subscription. He says: “It is clear that, fairly considered, the affixing of a signature to along doctrinal confession is not equivalent to an assertion that the signer admits and believes every statement in that confession clear to him, but it is very far from being so to It may be many thoughtful persons Addresses and Speecies on Various Occasions, from IS7S to 1886, By Robert C. Winthrop Boston: Little, Brown & Co, — 1SS86. IN one of the many obituary notices im this vol ume, Mr. Winthrop has occasion to refer to the * Bloges* of Mignet, and he takes the opportanity to say that he had beard that eminent orator pro nounce two of these discourses, which he regard ed as models of their kind, in diction and de livery; and he adds, ** The remembrance of them has often given me the inspiration and the exam ple for efforts in the same line.” Mr. Winthrop’s field has less distinction than Mignet’s, as his portraits historiques et littéraires are less ela- borated. A few foreign names of the great world of literature, it is true, adorn the roll of his mor tuary record, and at Yorktown and at the cele bration of the completion of the Washington Monument he had oecasions to satisfy the highest oratorical ambition, whether the concourse of people, the national signiticance of the event, or the splendor of the subject, be regarded. A pe riod of incessant centennials, not only of Revolu tionary, but of scientific and colonial, and even earlier beginnings, as far back as Wycliffe, and a period, moreover, when many of bis own life long associates were falling off from old age, could not fail to make his utterances in the mam reminiscent and votive, and largely commenda- tory of the worthies of bis own circle. Itisa wide circle, such as could grow about one man only by virtue of public position and exceptional private respect. From the early days of a political novitiate under Clay, Everett, and Webster, whom he is proud to remember, and of an introduction to European celebrities through the learned Ba ron de Circourt, to the later time of philanthro pic labor in connection with the Boston charities and the Peabody Education Fund, and his last visit abroad, which is linked with the inherited names of Rochambeau and Lafayette, a host of the personages of the age emerge and detile upon the page: and the pleasing part, to a literary reader, is the judgment, the ease and opportune ness of Mr. Winthbrop’s remarks about each new- comer. What is said is not much more than a greeting to the living and a farewell to the dead, but it is enough; and, taken with the longer and more labored orations, it serves to remind us that Mr. Winthrop ts a distinguished continuer of the memorable line of occasional orators in which Massachusetts has been, and still is, so fruitful. If these addresses are, with two or three great exceptions, brief and transitory. pro- ceedings and contributions rather than speeches, they are such as belong to a serviceable old age, engaged in Christian benevolence of both munici- pal and national scope, interested in local or- ganizations and entertained by colonial antiqua- rianism, old buildings. old portraits, and old graveyards, Nota little of ihe more permanent interest of the volume lies in those parts from the proceedings of the M issachusetts Historical Society, with which Mr. Winthrop has almost merged his literary identity, and especially in those small medallions of the Mignet pattern, as the writer says—those tributes to members or (as it were) conpections of that body, the lesser known gentlemen of Boston and the vicinity, to whom that city owes much of its silent history. Mr. Winthrop, who has withdrawn from several of the posts which drew forth these occasional utterances, announces that this, the fourth volume of the series, will be the last. Assyrische Lesestucke nach den originaien theils revidirt, theils zum ersten male herausgegeben nebst Paradigmen, Schrifttafel, Textanalys und kleinem Worterbuch, von Dr. Friedrich Delitgsch, Auflage. Leipzig: J. C. Hinrichs Dritte durchaus neu bearhbeitet: THE third edition of Prof. Delitzsch’s © Lesestiicke is easily the most important Assyriological work of the past year. Io a new science, where th results constantly coming in are hiddeu away tn dissertations, reviews, and scientific journals, the collection of the discoveries is more epoch-mak ing than the discoveries themselves, But to have this collection made and enhanced by one who is himself one of the most active workers in the field, gives it a scientific value which few text books possess, The ‘ Lesestiicke’ was always in tended for self-instruction. In the past aditions a pupil not guided by a teacher would have been somewhat of a genius to have mastered the ditt! cult cuneiform characters, But in the thint edi tion Dr, Delitgsch has come nearer to his ideal in this reganil. He transliterates a teat, gives a brief statement of the principal grammatical facts, and appends a very full vocabulary, se that with suflicient industry and a knowledge of Hebrew (always presupposed) any theological student can be initiated in the mystertes of A» svriology The vocabulary, Prof. Delitesch savs he determined to add only at the last moment He has been promising an Assvrian dictionary ever since IS7S, and asserts that the present vo cabulary (of a thousand words or more) was Written “‘entirely from memory This state ment he deems important enough to emphasire by itahes and repetition; but one cannot com mend his prudence The first end mast noticeable improvement is ch eon the three pages on Assyrian grammar, wi tain tables of pronouns and particles, of verbal and nominal suffixes, together with paradigms of the strong and weak verb. While we might have preferred to have the prvferstum known as. the imperfeefum, Semitic syntax, especially with re gard to the tenses, is in so confused a state that names are of almost no significance. The only statement in the grammatical portion really open to question is that concerning the verha tertia infirmar, to the effect that they cannot practical ly be distinguished, on which account the third stem consonant, after the practice of the Hebrew Schrader and Haupt have in a number of cases been en abled to determine, through the help of Hebrew lexicographers, is set down as he, and Arabic, what the last stem consonant in such eases is, and there seems to be no valid reason why the “Sanskrit of the Semitic languages * should be modelled after the unscientitic method of the Hebrew lexicographers. In the Schriftia fel the changes are numerous, the most signifi cant being that words of aborigina! derivation are simply callei ‘‘non-Semitic.” Dibbeira, as the reading of the name of the pest-god, has been abandoned. The meaning of * bullock’ for pard is still retained, though it has been pretty con clusively shown that parti means ‘ mule ’—pury being the word for bullock. Prof. Haupt’s dis cussion of the word gablu seems to prove that it ineans ‘ waist, ‘ coast,’ rather than ‘ middle.’ A significant change is to be found m the mean ing given to the common term salmat qaqqadi, This is literally ‘the black-headed,’ and was for merly taken as applying to the Sumero-Akkadi- ans, but our author is now inclined to think that it is the ordinary phrase for * people.’ The most welcome addition is the list of Babylonian signs ranged alongside of the ordinary Assyrian forms. Leaving this portion, we find a great improve- ment in the pieces selected for reading. The Eponym Canon is left out, and its place is taken by historical inscriptions, incantations, and
Page 22
316 The Nation. [ Number 1111 hymns. So good is the selection that one can get a very fair idea of Assyrian literature by read- ing through the ‘ Lesestiicke.’ The vocabulary is the largest yet published, and though some of the etymologies are open to criticism, and the ab- sence of references is rather tantalizing, it is both useful and serviceable. The mechanical labor of preparing such a work is very great. The whole book is but a lithographic transfer from the au- thor’s own manuscript. That a few mistakes should creep in was inevitable. The most impor- tant for a beginner to note is that the sign No. 100 has the syllabic value ta. With so excellent a guide as the ‘ Lesestiicke,’ and with the help of the promised dictionary, Assyrian will be placed on a footing with the Semitic languages, and its study proportionately increased. A Romanized Japanese Reader. (Easy written style.) By Basil Hall Chamberlain, Professor of Japanese and Philclogy in the Imperial Uni- versity of Tokio, etc. London: Triibner & Co, Tue second half of Prof. Chamberlain’s work on the Japanese written language has at last ap- peared, unavoidable delays in going through the press having separated it from its companion. It consists of a triplet of little books, containing, one of them, the Japanese text ; another, an Eng- lish translation ; and the third, notes. The first is made up of a collection of short stories, select- ed partly for their intrinsic interest, partly as specimens of the various Japanese written styles, and ranging from the “‘zokubun,” or common style, to the classical. Thus we have examples of extremely simple Sinico-Japanese, of easy classical, of easy Sinico-Japanese, of the histori- cal (a mixture of classical and Sinico-Japanese), of the popular narrative, of the ordinary Sinico- Japanese of modern books and newspapers, of the higher narrative, and finally of the semi-episto- lary style. The pieces are derived from all man- ner of sources, and comprise proverbs, poems, and prose. The names sufficiently suggest the subjects—for instance: ‘‘The Mother of Men- cius,” ‘The Crows’ Conversation,” ‘“‘ A Family of Fools,” ‘‘The Great Earthquake of Yedo,” ‘* Parting,” ‘‘ The Heart Itself is Buddha,” etc. There are sixty-four of them inall. The second volume—if we can use the term for what has weight without bulk—is a translation of the first, intended as a key to it. The author has (we think most wisely) made this as literal as is possible between two tongues so radically dif- ferent as Japanese and English. The judgment shown in the choice of the pieces and in the man ner of their translation is excellent, but it is in the third book of the trio, the notes, that the learning and the research of the author are most apparent. These notes are of various kinds. Those devoted tothe primary purpose of gram- matical explanation serve it admirably; they are at once full and succinct, and, from being nu- merous at the start, disappear insensibly as the reader progresses. The construction of the in- flected words is carefully pointed out, and the constitution of the uninflected ones is as critical- ly analyzed, while the structural peculiarities of the language are thoroughly explained. {t is, however, for the less perfunctory portions of his task that we are especially in debt to Prof. Chamberlain. Much more clearly than is true of English to-day, Japanese words tell their own history of development in meaning. To a com- petent scholar the original significations of most of them are still decipherable, and these signifi- cations underlie and serve to explain the uses of the words at the present time. Examples lie scattered throughout the book. We will quote two: ‘* Machi does not correspond exactly either to ‘street’ or to ‘town.’ It signifies rather ‘a street , in the mercantile quarter.’ For ‘ town’ there is no satisfactory Jap. equiv. The nearest are fu or tofu, * capital’; mura, ‘ village’; minato, ‘ sea- port’; and machi, as above ” (p. 52). Machi is perhaps derived from ma, ‘a space’ and chi, ‘a way’; just as michi, ‘a road,’ is, as the author has elsewhere pointed out, derived from mi, ‘honorable,’ and chi, ‘a way,’ therefore ‘the honorable way’ and hence ‘a highway.’ The meaning ‘town’ may have arisen from the fact of the natural development of a village along one main street, as is still peculiarly the case in Japan; the name having been first applied to that part of the highway, and thence extended by implication to the village itself. The expres- sion is common as a factor in the compound proper names of towns, as Harumachi, ‘‘ Spring- ville.” Again, on page 69, we find; ‘* Note how the word kami denotes what is up- permost or superior in the most various ways— the hair of the head, a lord, the government, a god, ete,” The last quotation is pregnant, for kami is no isolated case. It is but one of many such in- stances of what we may call primitive words. They are words which, without being in the least abstract, are, from their very simplicity, necessarily general, such, in fact, as were suited to the early concepts, and which in course of time came to be applied to many different ob- jects, having in common only the general dis- tinguishing property in question. Kasa, ‘any round top-covering,’ and thence, ‘halo,’ ‘ bow]- cover,’ ‘acorn-cup,’ ‘ hat,’ ‘ umbrella,’ etc., is an- other instance of the same class. One primitive word came thus to be the ancestor in meaning to a whole clan of later ideas. In the spoken lan- guage the context furnishes the key to the par- ticular idea in any given case, and in the written language the Chinese ideographs are called in to do the same duty. Besides notes of this character there are com- plete explanations of the sources and the general meanings of the various stories, so that the stu- dent gathers no mean amount of knowledge about Japanese literature by the way. And finally, the book, as its name foretells, is a Ro- manized Japanese Reader, that is, the Japanese words are printed in Roman characters, in ac- cordance with the reform initiated by the Ro- maji Kai,or Roman Letter Association, in the founding of which, about a year ago, Prof.Cham- berlain was one of the leaders. Living Paris and France. A Guide to Man- ners, Monuments, Institutions, and the Life of the People; and handbook for traveliers on an entirely new and original plap. By Alb. With maps and plans. London: Ward & Downey; New York: Scribner & Welford. ‘‘ Je serai votre guide dans la ville splendide,” says or sings the young man in “ La Vie Parisienne” of MM. Meilhac and Halévy ; and Mr. White- ing makes the same promise in his rather clumsy title-page. There is already an abundance of guide-books to the capital of France, from the pair of stout tomes of the ‘ Paris Guide,’ which M. Louis Ulbach edited in 1867, and for which Victor Hugo wrote a grandiloquent preface, to the inadequate and antiquated Galignani’s ‘Guide’; but Baedeker’s remains the best, the simplest, the most concise, and the most com- plete. Mr. Whiteing’s is rather a supplement to Baedeker’s than a substitute for it. He has en- deavored to make the descriptions of places and things secondary to the account of people and customs. This is an excellent endeavor. Too many people rush through Paris, seeing the sights in a week or a month or even a year, and quitting the city by the Seine as ignoraut as ever about the life of its inhabitants. Mr. Whiteing describes society, the salons, the clubs, the news- papers, sport, art, literature, and the drama. He has a chapter on dining in Paris (this is by Mr. Theodore Child—it is useful, but flippant and su- perficial). He considers politics, the constitution and the working of the government, the army and the navy, and the administration of justice. These are surely subjects important enough to fill a book by themselves, and we think ‘ Living Paris’ would have gained by omitting the chap- ters reduplicating the information to be found in every other guide-bosk—descriptions of monu- ments and galleries, and notes on the environs of Paris and the French watering-places. In the main, Mr. Whiteing’s work is very well done. Its chief fault is a certain journalistic flavor, not often unduly obtrusive. We may as well note a few slips for future correction. Mlle. Pierson is not ‘‘a queen of tragedy” (p. 212); Paul de Saint Victor’s ‘Deux Masques’ is not ‘‘an authority on classic and modern art” (p. 158), because it is not about art, but about dra- matic literature; ‘ Autour du Mariage’ was not, as a play, ‘‘ the delight and scandal of a season” (p. 42), because the play failed dismally and was immediately withdrawn. Virginia Carolorum. 1625-1685. By Edward D. Neill. Albany : Joel Munsell’s Sons. 1886. WHEN a stately house bas been built, and an ad- miring public applauds and congratulates the architect, few think of the humble quarrymen who toiled to get together the stones. And it is a fortunate thing, for historians as well as for architects, that men exist with ransacking and burrowing instincts, like those whom Epistemon saw, ‘‘touts occupés & chercher les espingles rouillées et vieulx clous parmi les ruisseaulx, .» » « Mais de ce travail et de mal-heureté il ne leur soubvient, tant ils sont actifs”—men whom an irresistible impulse urges to search musty records and forgotten books, to glean some overlooked scrap of fact that may at some time find a place in history. A codicil toa will, a marginal note, a casual mention in a letter, are veritable treasure-trove to these modest and unappreciated journeymen of the day of small things. To this useful class Mr. Neill belongs. The instinct which impels the vos-non-vobis crea- tures to their disinterested iabors, drives him to ransack, with praiseworthy industry, the sources of Southern colonial history: not only such thrice- sifted heaps as Hening and the Calendar of State Papers, but other and less known repositories ; and apart of the fruits of these researches he gives to the world in his ‘ Virginia Carolorum.’ It is no imputation on Mr. Neill that we dis- cover no new fact of historical importance in this work : that was hardly to be expected. But the small facts he has unearthed are not without in- terest. When we read of a wealthy burgess, in 1630, bequeathing to one friend a thousand pins and to another six pounds of soap, we gaina livelier idea of the trials of the early colonists. When we learn that Joan Butler was judicially ducked for calling Marie Drewe an unmention- able name, we are glad to think that some de- scendant of Mistress Drewe muy rejoice at this vindication of the fair fame of his ancestress from undeserved aspersion. In fact, there is hardly anything here—even to the information that in 1635, in digging a well near Jamestown, the workmen found a large bone eighteen feet below the surface—but may some time be of use to somebody. One historical error, evidently the result of hasty reference, we have noticed. On page 188, referring to the overthrow of the Ingle insurrec- tion in Maryland, the author says: “ In Decem- ber Governor Calvert returned from Virginia
Page 23
— Oct. 14, 1886]
The Nation.
with an armed force and took Hill [the acting Governor] and the Assembly, then in session, prisoners”; and he refers to, and partly cites, a letter from Baltimore to the Assembly. If he had looked more closely at his authority, he would have found that the letter he is citing is not from Baltimore, but from the Assembly, and that both letters controvert this statement. When Governor Calvert resumed power, he not only did not molest Hill’s Assembly, but continued it in office, as the Jetter referred to states. Hill re- turned to Virginia, and for some time pestered the Maryland authorities for the arrears of his salary while acting Governor; and tke claim was, in part at least, allowed. In some of Mr. Neill’s earlier publications he has tried to generalize facts, to draw inferences, and to reach conclusions ; but in the volume be- fore us he has, very judiciously, almost entirely abstained from such attempts, and thus deserves our double gratitude.
The Round Year. By Edith M. Thomas. Bos- ton: Houghton, Mifflin & Co. 1886. THE wwhabitants of ‘the leafy coverts of New England” have had it all their own way for a long time in the matter of these books of poetic wood-craft, wild-life, and the changes of the sky and the seasons; from the Maine border to the Adirondacks, along the Bay, by the Merrimac, the Connecticut, and the Hudson, in the Berk- shire, the White, and the Green Hills. In all these selected observatories, as well as on Boston Common, the diary of nature has been minutely kept. It is consequently with pleasure that one finds that Miss Thomas’s ‘ Round Year’ went cir- cling through the months on the southern shore of Lake Erie. This assures us a new field, though not a new fauna and flora; and with the advan- tage of a great object of nature, the Lake—still undescribed after the Thoreau fashion—to serve for a perennial background. But Miss Thomas is not a naturalist; her temperament is poetic, and nature is more plastic to her fancy and obe- dient to her call than in the case of a true ob server. Moreover, she is harmed by literary con- sciousness, which leads her to seek variety, as it seems, in a way nature does not, and to cut up the seamless garment into ‘‘ subjects.” In one or two essays the authoress makes much of the Lake, deals with it as a native and familiarly, and tells us things novel, impressive, and stirring about it, until the imagination does begin to take hold of it and come face to face with its power. Neverthe- JUST READY. BIOLOGY. GENERAL BIOLOGY. By W. T. Sedgwick, Professor in Massachusetts Lusti- tute of Technology, and E. B. Wilson, Pro- fessor in Bryn Mawr College. S8vo, $2.00. RHE TORIC.
A PRACTICAL RHETORIC. For Colleges and Intermediate Schools. By J. 8. Clark, Professor in Syracuse University. 12mo, $1.50. Whitney's Practical French Grammar. With Exercises and IJustrative Sentences from
| price. The second part isa directory not merely of the business men, but of all the inhabitants, wt less she writes of it as a landsman would about the | ocean ; she does not seem at home. This lack of nearness to nature and intimacy with it is not unrelated to the literary consciousness of which | mention was made above; and the same flawing | In each town are numbered, and after each pet influence affects the workmanship of the writer. | son's name fs the number of the road upon which She shows too plainly that she is mistress of her | he lives, as, for instance, under Lisbon is“ Wi rich vocabulary, and uses it too lavishly, as if | Phillips,r 23 cor 21." From the portrarts in this syllabification were style. Keats himself suffer- | volume we fancy a composite portrait: could ts ed by his love for a fine word. But this criticism goes too far afield ; and we must return to say that though it is true that this is a poet's rather : than a naturalist’s book, fuller of deft fantasy ce : ‘ : ; BOOKS OF THE WEEK than of ornithology, and dropping more easily into a moral homily or a rustic characterization than into forest-lore or the babits of squirrels and chipmunks, it is a studious and, in a literary homes are designated in a very clear and ing: nious way. Onthe accompanying map the roads made which would well represent the typical Yankee, A Roston Girl: A Story of Boston, Rar Harbor, and Parts Belford, Clarke & Oo Alexander, Rishop W. The Divinity of Our Tom sell & Co. 40 cents Atkinson, J. The Shah Nameh of the Persian Powe
2 z é dausi, Translated and Abritmeed Prove att Ver way, painstaking volume of observations of na Frederick Warne & Co. $2.60 . x P . Ayres, A. The Mentor: A Little Rook for Men aud ! tural surroundings, of the real inland beach, with Funk & Wagnalls ents the creek, the fields, and the sky over it, * the | "nan, GS civil service Reform versus ines rain and the fine weather”; and is besides a near | Burnett, Frances’ Hoxtgson. | Little Lomt Fauntier R : : Charles Seribner's Sons, 82 and neighborly view of a new region. Champlin, J. D., jr. The Chrontcle of the Ooaeh) Cha ring Cross to Li fracombe Charles Sertts: s . #2 00) Farmer, Lydia Hoyt. The Boys’ Book of } ws Kuler Gazetteer of Grafton County, N. H. 1700-1888. - en nag A — — ee ere : . 0 er, Sac talle wre ‘ ve cmd th Compiled and published by Hamilton Child A Rover Palladelphta HON. Fowlor & ¢ > er > ‘ ve i yon, « Clare of 4 res tres te A Rot t ia Syracuse, N. Y. 1886. Pp. 644, 380. Por Franklin Square Library. Scents : Soe - Guernsey, Lucy Ellen. Through Unknowd Wars traits, map, large Svo. The Journal Rooks of Mrs Dorathea Stu fr . P Whittaker. $1 THIS volume contains more than the word “ga Hoffman's Tricks with Cards Excelsior Publish ” ee a ee Berd House retteer generally implies. Following a descrip- | yoiger.¢. F. The Ivory King: A Popular tlstory of tion of the physical feat ires of the county, which ee ae See: SmnnnareUnee e . . . . TLS abs includes the Franconia and a bit of the White | Jones, Cuptd. The Crary History of the Unites! Stat . . . G. W. Dillinghar M) oon ts Mountains —the geological part being from | Kirkus Rev We Rellaion A Revelation a the pen of Prof. C. H. Hitchcock—there are | , [ie , eee See . t w te ser ith! the aane ' 4 sketches of all its prominent lawyers. This has | !timer, Eiieabeth Wormetey Panitita: ks . . . abr of Shakspeare’s Comedies, Bost Rot = ? evidently been prepared with considerable care, 2 s . : AUT ton ” «© Uae of irists tr ur Tkvst and is a noteworthy contribution to the legal bis gy on : edie tumae, tory of New Hampshire. The most famous of all | i{fcl"s artey tee Nob l July --Septonnt mn hoeeton {tei the cases which have arisen in the county was | Louts, A 1s Here | r Sens \ Tale of Every Da . . Life in England and Amertoea. Frentano Brothers that of Dartmouth College, a full account of | Man Abrow A Yara of Some Other Century, GW Dillingham. 2 cents Mason, & T Humorous Masterpieces from Amertean Literature, Swolea. G. PP. Putnam's sons & McLennan, J. F. Studtes fn Anctent History. New ed 40) which is given. From it we also learn that the old court-house at Plymouth, in which Daniel Webster made one of his earliest, if not his first, Macmillan & Co Morrill, J. S. Self-Consciousness of Notes] Persons Bos
plea, has, after having been used as a wheel ton: Ticknor & Co ; oo . . = Panl, Howant. Smart Sayings of Rright Childret wright’s shop, been restored to its original ap a -" pearance at Senator Blair's expense, and is now — = flectt . ee y. Wit, Love, the Poet's Gander 6 " : i ait? ope, and Charity 6 miniature vols GP. Put used fora library. Short histories of the towns nam's Sons, #000 : : Preston, H.W. Documents Mlustrative of Ame an His in alphabetical order, with numerous biographi tory, 108-1888. G. FP. Putnam's Sons, #240, cal and genealogical details, especially of the ear- BSS) R, Pleasures of a Book Worm. at ed. George ly inhabitants, and accounts of the principal in- | Shelton, Mary D. Studies in Greek and Roman Histor: oat . . or, Studies In General History from loo p 4 dustries complete the first and largest part of the pb. Roston: D.C. Heath & Co. #110 : : . ° hore er assell § “ “ nts volume, It is interesting to note from the census Oy Ree AR Co a cant Elite Engagement Catendars. FE. P. Dutton & Co tables that the population in ISSO, 38,788, wasless | pS ey siete in ) , - all ~ La Langue Francaise, a Ry PAUL BERCY, B.L.LD., Is the best and most comprehensive practical work for the study of French by the Natural Method. It is simple and thorough, and helps the teacher and student alike. Sample pages free ee ee rere | 25 WILLIAM R. JENKINS, PUBLISHER AND IMPORTER OF FRENCH BOOKS, &50 Sixth Avenue, New York
Page 24
318 Scribner & Welford’s NEW BOOKS. A History of Parliamentary Klections and Electioneer- ing in the Old Days: Showing the State of Political Parties and Party Warfare at the Hus- tings and in the House of Commons from the Stuarts to Queen Victoria. lliustrated from the Original Political Squibs, Lampoons, Pictorial Satires, and Popu- lar Caricatures of the Time. By JOSEPH GREGO, Author of * Rowlandson and his Works,’ ‘The Life of Gillray,’ ete. Demy Svo, cloth extra, with a Frontispiece Color- ed by Haod, and nearly One Hundred [llus- trations, $6.00, AUSTRALIAN PICTURES. Drawn with Pen and Pencil. By HOWARD WILLOUGHBY, of “The Melbourne Argus.” With a large Map and 107 Illustrations from Pho- tographs and Sketches, engraved by E. WHYMPER and others. Imperial 8vo. Cloth, gilt edges, $3.50. The New Volume of the “Pen and Pencil” Series, It is written by a well-known member of the Australian Press who is thoroughly acquainted with the scenery, life, products, and business capa- bilities of the different parts of Australia. Great efforts have been made to award adequate space and treatment to each of the Colonies, THE HANDY NATURAL HISTORY. By the Rey. J. G. Woop, author of ‘Homes With- out Hands,’ ete., etc. With 224 Engravings. Small quacto, cloth boards, gilt edges. $3.50. Written in Mr. Wood’s happiest vein, 1t gives an enormous amount of accurate and interesting in- formation about the life and habits of animals and birds. It is also written with the serious pur- pose of showing how wonderfully the Creator has adapted the bodies of these different creatures to their habits and needs, by 1a Py TUTIONY Te) FINE ART JUVENILES. VHE LANDof LITTLE PEOPLE. Poems by FREDERIC E. WEATHERLY. Pictures by JANE M. DEALY. Beautifully printed in colors and monotone. Oblong 4to, gold and brown, boards, $2.09. The children have their favorites as well as their elders, and certainly no book has been more popu- lar among them than * Told in the Twilight.’ That the same authors are again associated is a sufficient introduction of * The Land of Little People,’ which is even more beautitul than its predecessor. It is an ideal children’s book, with the most daintily conceived verses and the most beautifully exe- cuted pictures, THE GIRL'’S OWN ANNUAL FOR 1886. Coataining 832 pages of interesting and useful reading, profusely Iltustrated by eminent Art- ists. In handsome cloth. $3.75. THE BOVY’S OWNANNUAL for 1886, Con- taining 832 pages of Tales, Sports, Travei, Ad- venture, Amusement, and Instruction. Colored and Wood Engravings. Handsome cloth. $3.75. The Nation. “The respectable and sometimes excellen® translations of Bohn’s Library have done for Literature what railroads have done for inter- nal intercourse.”"—R. W. Emerson. “T may say in regard to all manner of books, Bohn’s Publication Series is the usefullest thing I know.”—Thomas Carlyle. Bohn’s Libraries. Containing Standard Works of European Literature in the English Language, on History, Theology, Natural History, Biography, Antiquities, Poetry, Topography, Science, Art, Archeology, Philosophy Fiction, With Dictionaries and other Books of mKeference, com- prising in all Translations from the French, Spanish, Anglo-Saxon, German, Scandinavian, Latin and Greek. Italian, $1.40 or $2 per volume (with exceptions). Complete sets in 677 volumes. Special prices on application. The following works are recommended to those who are forming public or private libraries. The volumes are sold separately: ADDISON’S WORKS. 6 Vol8...............45 $'.40 each. BACON’S ESSAYS, MORAL AND PHILO- SOPHICAL WORKS, 2 vols. ...$1.40 and 2.00 each. BOSWELL’S LIFE OF JOHNSON and TOUR IN THE HEBRIDES, &c.(Napter). 6 vols. 1.40 each. BURKE'S WORKS AND LIFE. 9 vols.... ... 1.40 each. BURNS’S LIFE. By Lockhatt................+- 1.40 each. CERVANTES’ DON QUIXOTE. 2 vols... .... 1.40 each. CHAUCER’S WORKS (Prof. Skeat). 4 vols... 1.40 each, COLERIDGE’S WORKS. 6 vols.............++. 1.40 each. DEPOTS WGORERS. F POM. ccccccccccsesccsccses 1.40 each. GIBBON'S ROMAN EMPIRE, 7 vols.......... 1.40 each. GOETHE’S WORKS, 14 VolIS............csceeee 1.40 each. GOLDSMITH’S WORKS. 5 vols............... 1.40 each. HAZLITT’S WORKS. 6 vols........... ceveesee 140 each. LAMARTINE’S WORKS. 8 vols............... 1.40 each. LESSING’S LAOKOON, BC.......0..ccccccceseee 1.40, LESSING’S DRAMATIC WORKS. 2 vols.... 1.40 each. MILTON’S PROSE WORKS. 5b vols........... 1.40 each. MOLIERE’S DRAMATIC WORKS. 3 vols... 1.40 each. PLUTARCH’S LIVES (new translation by Long and Stewart). 4 VOIs............-...005 1.40 each, SCHILLER’S WORKS. 6 vols................ 1.40 each. VASARI’S LIVES OF PAINTERS (with new appendix by Dr. Richter). 6vols.. ......... 1.40 each. BURNEY’S( Mme, D’ Arblay’s) CECILIA, 2 vols 1.40 each. BURNEY’S (Mme. D’ Arblay’s) EVELINA...... 1.40, FIELDING’S NOVELS. 4 vols...... $1.40 and 2.00 each. PRETRARCIFS SONNETG.....vcccecceccscccceseses 2.0€. MANZONTS BETROTHED.([ promessi Sposi). 2.00. BE a Re 6 WO iancicisscinsiscccdesces 2.00 each, KANT S CRITIQUE OF PURE REASON ...... 2.00 each. SPINOZA’'S CHIEF WORKS. 2vols.......... 2.00 each. HUMBOLDT’S COSMOS AND TRAVELS. 8 WE sce evccveccrigecetsicce cascentns $1.40 and 2.00 each. STAUNTON’S WORKS ON CHESS. 4 vols... 2.00 and 2.40 each. GILBART ON BANKING, 2 vols.............. 2.00 each, LOWNDES’S BIBLIOGRAPHER’S MAN- CRI i ccicceviccccnncande $1.40 and 2.00 each. *,* The above books will be sent upon receipt of advertised price. Catalogues of our regular stock, also of Bohn’s Libraries, will be mailed, if desired, to those interested. New Catalogue of Choice and Rare Books ready. Musical Literature ready. New Catalogue of SCRIBNER & WELFORD, 743-745 BROADWAY, N. Y. {Number 1111 Charles Scribner's Sons WILL PUBLISH ON SATURDAY: The Huguenots and Henry of Navarre. By Henry M, Baird, Professor in the University of New York. Uniform with the author's ‘The History of the Lise of the Huguenots of France.’ 2 vols., 8vo, with maps, $5.00. Prof. Baird gives an account of the struggle of the Huguenots of France to secure a fair degree of religious liberty. The work narrates the story of the heroic and unflinching determination which finally secured the Edict of Nantes, the last chapter giving a sketch of the halcyon days of Protestantism in France under the Edict, and down to the death of Henry 1V. The work,while distinct in itself, is supplementary to the author’s ‘The Rise of the Huguenots of France,’ Children’s Stories of Ame- rican Progress. By Henrietta Christian Wright. 1 vol, small 8vo, illustrated, $1.50. CONTENTS : The Beginning of the The Story of the Rail- Western Settlement. road. The Barbary Pirates. Indian Troubles in Flo- The Purchase of Louisi- _ rida. ana. The Story of the Tele- The expedition of Lewis graph. and Clarke to the Pa- The Annexation of Tex- cific Ocean. as. The First Steamboat. The Mexican War. The Battle of Tippecanoe The Settlement of the The War of 1812. Northwest Boundary. The Purchase of Florida. The Discovery of Gold. The Story of Slavery. The Rebellion. The South after the War Miss Wright has the rare faculty of writing history in so entertaining a way that young peo- ple are led to read it with quite the same interest that they would devote to a romance. In this book the author touches upon the important events in our history in so graphic a way as to firmly impress them upon the minds of young readers. The book is a companion volume to Miss Wright’s ‘Children’s Stories in American History,’ published last year. Tr watra Dalitar Sy . Woolsey's Political Science By Theodore D, Woolsey, lately President of Yale College. New and revised edition, at a greatly reduced price. 2 vols., 8vo, $5, ‘*Such a work from such a publicist will not only be of great value, and do important service in this country, but will be accepted the world over as an authority on its topic, and a credit tu the national literaturein which it is produzed.”— Boston Advertiser. The Creoles of Louisiana. By George W. Cable, author of ‘The Grandis- simes,’ ‘Old Creole Days,’ etc. 1 vol., 4to, richly wlustrated, extra cloth. New and Cheaper Edition. $2.50. ‘*Vivid, discriminating, picturesque; an ad- mirable piece of literary work.”’—Hoston Jour- nal. *,* These books are for sale by booksellers, or will be sent, postpaid, on receipt of price, by Charles Scribner's Sons, 743-745 Broadway, New York. ' t i