The Nation 1885-11-12: Vol 41 Iss 1063
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
a8 a> dete Giattnabate PRADA te He: ; Lhe Nation ——————— VOL. XLL—NO. 1063. THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 12 po PRICE to CENTS. ALL CLASSES OF MEN _ ARE LIABLE TO Accadent and Disease, and their Families to Destitution, AGAINST WHICH INSURE IN THE TRAVELERS Against Disabling Injury, Provide by a General Accident Policy, indemnifying the Professional or Business Man for his Profits, the Mechanic for his Wages, lost * 4 2 Accidental Injury, with Principal Sum in Case of Death. ‘ Mm, ° >, % Against Premature Death, nt Provide by a Life Policy. % Against Failing Powers, Or the time when children will have to be educated or started in business, provide by an Endowment Policy to accumulate a fortune for you. HOME OFFICE, HARTFORD, CONN.; Branch Agencies Everywhere. ASSETS, $8,055,000.00. SU RPLUS S, $2,089,000.00, Paid Policy-Holders, $1 1,300,000. JAS. G. BATTERSON, Pres'’t. RODNEY DENNIS, Sec’y. JOHN E. MORRIS, Ass't Sec’y.
Page 2
ae — The Nation. {Number 1063 The Nation. CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. isxtenaias 389 THe WEER...... SUMMARY OF THE WEEK'S NEWS,.....ccccccceee coeeenee 392 EDIroORIAL ARTICLES: The Repablican Lesson The New Opposition in Mexi The Dtsestaplishment Panic Hunters and Trotters i ' E inal ind. SPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE: England: Statesmen on the Stump. veveeeeeees BOT Prince W aldemar’s Marriage . cedasaeiasne ae Art Notes from Varis.. susie ° CORRESPONDENCE: Protection of the Yosemite Valley............ .«e«+- 401 Free Trade in South Carolina................+++ dul The ¢ anon of Criticism for “ Rooks ” and for “Li terature Ecebsadaele: esbencessneecasscdansebans 401 SEG OO TONG nero ccccscasccescngesveecses ‘ ane 402 Religious Instruction at Harvard..... ........ ann 402 More Tele athy........ccccccecccscseececcseeseereneees 402 NOTES. ...ccccccee Ovescceces Petec cee coccccooseoce cosces 402 REVIEWS: Tilden’s Writings and Speeches .............00.65. » 406 fecent French Books. .........%000 cecceccccsccsseeees 406 CORORO TD CGNs oo ods cccccccccccagocccecccsscesscosse 407 Gosse’s Classical English Pi oetry Bie i inka Baad 409 WUBCAN CHICS .... . ccccccrcc ccccccccccseccesscoccces 410 The Tale of Gamelyn ... bacasecdeeveneseaseeen 410 Paris in Old and Present ‘Times. ...........0ceeeeeee 410 BOOKS OF THE WEEK. .. 6. ccccsecececeececeeneeceeeees 410 TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three Dollars per year, in advance, postpaid to any part of the United States or Canada; to foreign coun- tries comprised in Postal Union, Four Dollars. The date when the subscription expires is on the Ad- dress Label of each paper, the change of which to a sub- s*yuent date becomes a receipt for remittance. No other receipt is sent unless requested. The paver is stopped at expiration of the subscrip- tion, unless previously renewed. Kemittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter or by check or postal order payable to Publisher of the Natio ¥ hen a change of aldress ts destred, both the old and new addresses should be given. Address TH NATION, Box 794, New York, Publication Office, 210 Broadwau. *,* Copies of THE NATION may be procured in Sondon of B. F. Stevens, 4 Trafalgar Square; George Strect, 30 Cornhill, E. C. - HF. Gillig & Co., 449 Strend, and American News Reading Room, 8 Haymarket For convenience «f subscribers wishing to perma- nevtly and uniformly bind their volumes, we can now urnish Covers for the Nation, in regular book form, ready for use by any bookbinder, who wil! put in the numbers for a small charge. These have black cloth sides, roan back and corners, and are stamped in gold on back 7he Nation and the num- ber of the volume. Price 60 cents each. postpaid. These covers will fit all volumes from XXXIII. to XL., {. ¢., since the increase in size to 24 pages each issue. (For the earlicr volumes we cannot furn! b covers.) In order- er Wanted, jox 704, New York. A General Index to the N, ation, From July 1865, to September, 1880, Net peice (no trade discount), $2 5°. Purchasers will lease »nilt with order. Address tublisher of the Na- ion, Box i¥4, New York, or y. P. INDEX, Bangor, Maine. ing state the volume-num! Address Publisher of the Nation Schools. Alphabetized, first, by States; second, by Towns. CALIFORNIA (Southern) San Diego. e (*; JL AND MILITARY COLLEGE.— Full Collegiate Course for both sexes: Commercial, Scientific, Classical, and amines? . . climate in the world; no heated terms; no cold spell 7 7 General STUART STANLEY, Principal. — “Coswacticvt, Lyme. LACK HALL SCHOOL.—A family and Preparatory School for a few boys. Thorough ee tion and careful Best of references al ven. ARL#S G. BARTLETT, Principal. CONNECTICUT, Middletown. : WW ZILSON GRAMMAR SCHOOL GIVES i a superior preparation for Coilege. The Princt- pal has served a term of three years as tutor in Yale Col- ege. Send for circular. E. H. WILSON. District oF COLUMBIA, Washington, 1916 35th St. HE CEDARS,” GEORGETOWN Heights.—A Home and Day School for Young Ladies. Extensive grounds; superior scholastic advan- tages. Miss EARLE. MARYLAND, Anna ols. yy F ANNAPOLIS FEMALE INSTITUTE. —Boarding and Day School for Young Ladies and Little Girls. Mars. Ric HARD WwW ELSH, _ Principal. MASSACHUSETTS, Be TON UNI VERSITY Law School. Address the Dean, EpMUND H. Bennett, LL.D. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 259 Boylston Street. WAUNCY HALL SCHOOL (58th Year). Preparation for the Mass. Institute of Technolog isas 4 alty. Reference is made to the Institute Facul- ty. T e location is the most elegant | in Boston. Ff. 4 ° ror Harvard, Oxford, Cambridge, and other Uni- versities and ¢ ‘olleges, has now complete 8 plans and staff of teachers, so as to_meet the per on changes of siudies recently made at HARVARD and at the English Universities, and 1s now ready to receive into his family three well brought-up boys on inclusive terms, as mode- rate as the very liberal arrangements mace will allow. As to the success of his pupils at Harvard at the last Ex amination (October, 1885) and in former years, he refers, with permission, to President C. W. Elot, LL.D. Other references are in the prospectus. Pupils entering before Nov. 20 will have considerable advantages. Young women or men a advanced instruction only, can obtain First-Class buard and rooms afew doors oif. For prospectus, address E. R. HUMPHREYS, us above. Massac HUSE?TS, Boston, 129 West Chester Park. HUMPHRE TS, £L.2., 7OTOR MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, No, 68 Marlborough St. HEOLDEST SCHOOL ON THE BACK Bay. Miss Putnam will begin the twentieth year of her Family aud Day School for Young Ladies, Misses, and Little Girls on the 24th of September, 1885. Every requisite provided for the most thorough and practical English education: the Languages, both anclent and modern; the Sciences, History, and me ny Special students received in Music, art, Preparation for Foreign ‘Travel. and other departments. House made cheerful and healthful by 4 ood Fireson the Hearth. Kefers by per- mission to the Kight Kev. Henr ry C. Potter, Bishop of New York; Rev. A. P. Peabody, D..>.. Cambridge, Mass., and many other eminent scholars. Please send for circular. MASSACHU: ETrs, Boston, No. 68 Marlborough St. NSTRUCTION 1N THE ART OF Housekeeping.—“iss Putnam proposes to add a new department to her school, the object of which will be to teach young ladies how to conduct a household, select and manage servants, make necessary purchases— in short, to impart a thorough and practical training in all that —— to housekeeping and _ the science of domes tic economy. A limited number of parlor boarders will be received. Application must be made at once. MASSACHUSETTS, Bosto’ Fh X. ertizgUvzs£ OF TECHNOLOGY. Courses in Civil, Mechanical, Mining, and Electrical Engineering, Chemistry, Architecture, etc. Muveor Sec’s, FPRANCI* A. WALKER, MASSACHUSETTS, Boston, 18 Boylston Place. DREPARATION FOR THE INSTI f _tute of Technology. ALBERT HALE. iacaees HUSETTs, Cambridge, Larch St. H®: VE FOR BOYS.—UR. ABBOT AD- mits not more than three boys into his a + fit for college or educate privately. The only pupil ine sent to be examined last June entered harvard as Fresh- man, without “conditions,” and with “credite” in 12 out of the 17 subjects of examination. Separate tuition and best of care in all = Charming location, with fine tenvis-court. *. ABBOT, Ph.D. (Harv.). MASSACHU SFTTS, Ganbetien, 13 Appian Way. M?*:£ JOSHUA KENDALL'S DAYAND Family School for Boys fits for college. JAMES P. Circu- lars. MASSACHUSETTS, Lanesboro, Berkshire Co. y¥LMWOOD INSTITUTE, ESTAB.- a lished in 1849, fits for coliege or business. Rev. A A. GILBERT 4.M., Prin. MASRACHU SETTS, Ply Si ANAPP’S HO. VE SCHOOL FOR R. M Boys.—Fall term (nineteenth year) begins Sep- tember 24th, 1885. ~ MASSACHU SETTS, Quincy. JPAMS ACADEMY, — PREPARA- tory and boarding school for boys. New year be- gins lith se “ mber, 1885. For Catalogue and other in- formation address WILLIAM EVERETT, Ph_D. , , MASSACHUSErTS, S. W illiamstown, Berkshire Co. — REVLOCK INSTITUTE.—A PRE- paratory School for Boys. 44th year. Circulars on application. Geoxu@s F. MILLs, Principal. MASSACHUSETTS, West Bridgewater. p OWARD COLLEGIATE Institute.— Home and Day School for Girla and Young Women. Offers a full preparatory, with shorter college course, including all collegiate work essential to a tho- rough general education, or to advanced work tn Ameri- can or English Univ ersities. Age, 12-20. Will open eighteen new single rooms in November. For catalogue address the Principai, HELEN MAGILL, Ph.D., Graduate of Swarthmore College, Boston University, and Newnham College, Cambridge, England, NEw JERSEY, Morristown. nee *7. HILDA’S SCHUOL.—A BOARDING School for Girls. Under the charge of the Sis- ters of St. John Baptist. Sixth year begins September 23. For terms, etc., address THE SISTER IN CHARGE. NEW JERSEY, New Brunswick, 13 Livingston Ave. WE MISSES ANABLE’S ENGLISH, French, and Ge + a Boarding and Day School w wiil reopen § Se pte mbe ar ie NEw YORK, Canendatens. free T HILL SCHOUL (for Boys).— Second year. Enlarged accommodations. %600. Kev. JAMES Hartric KI L EE, » He ad Master. — New York City, 711 AND 713 FIFTH AVENUE, Op posite Dr. Hall’ s5C hure h. i a: Af tte. RUEL AND MISS ANNIE a V. Brown will reopen their English, French, and German Boarding and Day School for Girls | Oct. i. New York CIty, 231 E. 17th Z. JOHN BAPTIST SCHOOL FOR Girls.—The school is pleasantly situated on Stuy- vesant Square,and is a new building planned to supply all tnat can be required for the comfort and well -. of the pupils. Yesident French and English teachers. Pro- fessors for French, Science, etc. Address SISTER IN CHARGE, NEw York, Florida, Orange County. at : EWARD INST(tTUTE UPENS ITS 29th year; for both sexes. Address Mr:. M.S. PARKs, Principal. Lova IsLaND, Garden City. 7. MARY’S CATHEDRAL SCHOOL, having taken additional nee a can accommo- date a few more pupils. Apply early t Miss fH. CARROLL RaTEs, Prine ipal. NEw YORK, Suspension Bridge. = VEAUX COLLEGE.—A_ Military Boarding School for Buys. $350 per annum. WILFRED H. Muxro, A.M, President. NEW YORK, Utica. RS. PIATT S SCHOOL for YOUNG Ladies.—The next school year begins Thursday, Sept. 17, 1885. Applicatious shoul be made p early, 5128 Germantown PENNSYLVANIA, Germantown, Aveuue, Phila. ee SRANALIN SCHOOL.—AN ENGLISH and Classical School for boys. Six resident pupils. Prospectus sent on application. GEORGE A. PERRY, A. M., Head- Master. — PENNSYLVANIA, rs Ce 1350 Pine St. LSS ANABLE’S SCHOOL for Young li Ladies will reopen Sept. 2 23 » 1885. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, Norwood Avenue, Chestuut Hill : RS. WALTER D.COMEGYS and Miss Bell’s English and French Boarding and Day School for Young Ladies will reopen Sept. 21. PENNSYLVANIA, WEST PHILADELPHIA NIVERSITY OF PENNSYLVANIA. I. DEPARTMENT OF ARTS, four-years’ classical course. Degree A. Il. TOWNE SCIENTIFIC Sc HOOL, five-year courses in (a) Chemistry, (u) Geology and Mining, (c) Civil Engineering, (@) Dy mnainical Engineering, (e) Architecture, leading to B. S., and to technical degrees, P. C. (Practical Chemist), M. , Architect. ti: Wi HARTON SCHOOL OF FINANCE AND Economy. Courses in Constitutional Law and Public Administra- tion, Political Economy, Mercantile Law and Pructice, Finance, Bankin , Railroading. Degree Ph. B. IV. COURSE IN SHILOSOPHY, four years. English, Latin, French, German, Mental and Moral Philosophy, Mathe- matics,” General Sc fence, extended instruction in Biology with laboratery work. Degree Ph. B. Liberal elections in and between these courses at close of Second Year. V. COURSE IN Music. gree Mus. VI. MEpicaL ScHooL. Three- 4d graded course with optional fourth year. Degree M. DENTAL ScavoL. and AS graded course. De- Pyseern: VANIA, West Philadelphia, £903 Locust ‘MARTIN S SCHGOL. SPECIAL a with afternoon care of play and lessons. Two-years’ graded course. De- gree VIIL. VETERINARY SCHOOL. Three- -years’ graded course similar to European schools. Degree V. 8. Clinical and laboratory advantages a prominent feature a one three schools. LAW SCHOOL. Two-years’ ee diploma admits me, a Ivania Bar. Degree LL. X. BIOLOGICAL ScHoOoL. Two a course, with ex- tended laboratory work. Certificate admits to Medical School without examination. Special courses. XI. DEPARTMENT OF PHILOSOPHY. Two-years’ post- ~ 2 course in numerous subjects leading to degree ta anew inquiry aieete fom | a... Rev. JESSE University of Peonsvivania, w est ‘Phiadetphin Sa, Sesook PROPE R TIE S FOR “SALE andtorent. J. Ransom BRIDGE & Co., 110 Tremont St., Boston, Mass.
Page 3
ee a ATION—FULL NV%.
Nov. 12, 1885] The Nation. iii
School Agencies. ROCKWAY TEACHERS’ AGENCY, Times Building, Cones, will supply superinten- dents, grade teachers, specialists with positions in Cen- eral, W estern, and Southern States for ensuing year. RANSOM BRIDGE & CO., 110 TRE- + mo tSt., Boston Mass.—A reliable teachers’ agen Schools and Committees promptly supnited. Inter- view or correspondence solicited with qualified teachers looking for positions. School pr: perties for sale. Teachers. VOUNG LADY DESIRES A SITU- ation to teach young children and to assist in household du: ap 28 to be companion and heljer toa lady. . Address L. G. W., care of the Nation. GRADUATE OF YALE DESIRES x: afew peed WP. ils. Best Vale ee, , 17 E. Park St., Newark, (CHARL E S w. STONE, Tutor for Harvard, ~ 6s Chestnut Street, Boston.
STATUE OF “ LIBERTY ENLIGHTENING THE WORLD.” More Money Needed. The Committee in charge of the construction of the pedestal and the erection of the Statue, in order to raise tunds tor its completion. have prepared, from model furnished by the artist. a perfect fac-simile Miniature Statuette, which they are delivering to subscribers throughout the United States at the following prices: No. 1 Statuette, sex inches in height,—the Statue bronzed; Pedestal, nickel-silvered,—at One Dollar each. delivered. No. 2 Statuette, in same metal, twelve inches high, beautifully brouzed and nickeled, at ‘ive Dollars cach, delivered. No. 3 Statuette, dwe/ve inches high, tinely chased, Statue bronzed, Pedestal, Flea vil D4 Silver-Plated, with PLUSH sTAND, at Ten Dollars euch, delivered. Much time and money have been spent in verfecting the Statuettes, and they are much improved over the first sent out. The Com- mittee have received from subscribers many letters of commendation. The New York World Fund of $100 000 com- pletes the Pedestal, but it is estimated that $40.000 is vet needed to pay for the iron fasten- ings and the erection of the Statue. Liber.1 subscriptions for the Miniature Statu* ettes will produce the desired amount. Address, with remittance, RICHARD BUTLER, Secretary, Amcrican Committee of the Statue of Liberty, 33 Mercer Street, New York. GOLD MEDAL, PARIS, 1878, BAKER’S Breakfast Cocoa. Warranted absolutely pure Cocea, from which the excess of Oil has been removed. It has three times the strength of Cocoa mixed with Starch, Arrowroot or Sugar, and is therefore far more economi- cal, costing less than one cent @ cup. It is delicious, nourishing, strengthening, easily digested, and admirably adapted for invalids as well as for persons in health. Sold by Grocers everywhere. W. BAKER & CO., Dorchester, Mass
SET.—Fer sale « cheap AS. Fs LARK Park Row New York.
MERCANTILE LIBRAR ASTOR PLACE, NEAR BROADWAY BRANCH LIBRARY AND READING ROOMS, 431 FIFTH AVE... BETWEEN AN rits I 206,000 Volumes, over 400 Periodicals. New Publications (f ngiiah, French, ar ierman) pur soul As nh As iss TERMS: 8 PER YVEAR; $3 PER SIX MONTHS The following list contains some of the principal booXs just lied to t Li ry Clarise— Amateur Art. Reed — Evolution and Inv Greville -Memoirs, Part I! Pears— ball of Constantinoy Stedman— Poets of America Adams— ile Merry M Png! ! ries Hamerton Parts in Old and Present Times. i Gaye—The Worid'’s Lumber room ork. & sof - White— Stucies iu Shakespeare tioase — From Snakespeare to Pope. Wells — rractical Economics. ‘ asia Pontalis— Jonn De Witt. t : Holder— Marvels of Animal Life. r Sumner — Pr otectionism ; a Sheldon— History of Cbristian Doctrine gn Ss rk Knox— Boy Travellers in South A‘rertca Stowe— History of the Books of the Bible . ves an] Works Kacourt—Souvenirs of a Diplomat. Life of Louis Agassiz Gilman—astory of Kome Beecher— Evolution and Religion. ‘ ae Wilson —Bryant and His Friends Riswell—The Pentateuch ; its Origin and Structure } Butterworth—7Zizzag Journeys in the Levant i A Champney—Three Vassar Girls tn Italy Hays—City Cousins. Murfree— Propnet of the Great Smoky Mountains . Fawcett—Social Silhouett:s Grant—The Poyal Highlanders. Halsey — Scotland's Influence on Civilization ‘ rs Higxinson-—A Larger history of the U.S. of America t Moffat —Church History tn Brief « Payn—The Luek of the Darrelis RKussell—A Strange Voyage boar Harrison -Bric-\-Brac Stories. Craik—Mrs. Hollyer. «ff ) . ! Robinson--The Courting of Mary Smith Verne-- Mathias Sandorf Richards—The Jovous Story of Toto Mackay— Founders of the American Republi F Pfeiffer—Flsing Leaves from Fast and West f How to Re Happy, though Married ty . F
Tlf: GRE: 1 TLLE VWF2AJOTRS SECOND PART. if the FROM 1837 TO 182 Relen of Queen Victoria, 4 A Journal By THE LATE CHARLES GREVILLE, Clerk of the Council. Unrfort with Part 1 A Journal of the Reigns of King George IV. and King Witham 1\ * Mr. Greville’s Diary is one of the most imp rtant contributions w hewn ot ) the political history of the middie of the nin } I 1 wert writer; and his usual habit of making the record while the pres 11 events ’ t his mind gives his sketches of persons and places, and his nts of « versiut sare The volumes will be read with as much interest for their sketehes cf social Life as tor their] value."—London Daitu News Two vols., large 12my, cloth. Price, $4 00 *,.* For sale b 2)? > I ’ ' - . - ‘ : a ? blishers Sia > & ~ Bond Sstres L, For fifteen vears has been a standard remedy with all physicians who treat mental or nervous disorders. It aids in the bodily and wonderfally in the mental growth of childret It restores the energy lost by nervousness, debility, over-exertion, refreshes weakened vital powers in old or young It is used by Bismarck, Gladstone, and all great brain workers. _ ; , CROSBY CO., 56 West 25TH STREET, New York For sale by druggists, or mail, $1 g AEE ENE SORE NESE Dr. Sauveur’s Educationa Oy d wt cee Pals as vy ¢ 7 i Paya we o/| Street, Boston, M is Works. a _ : ix a gon ee, A copy of any of Dr. Sauveu ‘a Works will be sent wea x . . : post-paid to teachers by the author, on receipt of half the ieee athe retail! price Descriptive cirenlars, giving the retail price and the IT ¢ ants inf luction pr f each volume, Wil be sent to appli r . 7) rr roe — . yur pata ™ A dress DR. L. SAU VEUR, ieee i cid i beet’ ferences. A ~ hy a GERMANTOWN, Pa
F. W. CHRISTERN 37 West Twenty third Street, New York, ITEXKARV We RA VANTID (RE- ~ Viewing, special articles, corr <pon Metis e, reading for publishers, ete.) by a well known author and journal ist. Address “ CENTURY,” 241 Broadway, Room ( Importer of Foreign Books, Agent for the leading Marts , _ —. © . Publ ishers, Tauchnitz’s Dritikh Authors, beubner’s Greck vA 7. JOA ‘S$ WANT D—- Ws aid fa) Fé vik and Latin Classics. Catalyrue of stock n alled on de ally for Nas. 2to 15, 17 to 26,15 , and 437 mand A large assortment always on hand, are new the Station Cc. L. Cuarr, Carn ol iton, li books received from Paris and Leipzig a* soon as issued,
Page 4
iv The Nation. [Number 1063 Macmillan & Co.'s New Publications. COMMENCING A NEW VOLUME. Price, 30 Cents. Annual Subscription, $3.00. MACMILLAN’S MAGAZINE. - - - NOVEMBER. CONTENTS: 1. VASTNESS. Lord Tennyson. 5. THE DEPRESSION OF ‘“ ENGLISH.” 2. CULTURE AND SCIENCE. E. A.Sonnen- 6. SOME AMERICAN NOTES. echein, 7 GOUVERNEUR MORRIS AND THE 8. AUSTRIA’S POLICY IN THE EAST. FRENCH REVOLUTION. 4 ON CLASSIC GROUND. 8. MRS. DYMOND. Chap. XXXIIL-XXXV, 9. AN INDIAN VILLAGE, No. 313, - - Price, 15 Cents. Annual Subscription, $1.75. The English Illustrated Magazine. No. 26, - - : NOVEMBER. CONTENTS: 1. LADY SARAH BUNBURY. From the Picture by Sir Joshua Reynolds. 2. AN ADVENTURE IN AFGHANISTAN. M. Laing Meason. 8. NEWCASTLE-ON-TYNE. (Old Bits ina New City.) R.J.Charleton. With Illustrations. 4. LONDON COMMONS. Part2. Robert Hunter. With Illustrations. 5. ALCUMBE’S CHANCB. Fiederiek Boyle. 6. CHEESE FARMING AT CHESTER. Alfred Rimmer. With Illustrations. 7. LUVE AND FANTASY. LC. Milne. 8. AUNT RAC EL. (Continued) D. Christie Murray. ORNAMENTAL FRIEZES, HEADINGS, INITIALS, AND TAIL-PIECES. » snp mganmns has developed rapidly and strongly of late, and is now one of the most interesting of its class.” — on “Contains a surprisingly good supply of attractions for the money.’”’—Boston Daily Advertiser. “ Really a charming magazine, and easily holds the first rank among English magazines ’—Churchman, “ its iNustrations have particularly ained in merit—in every way admirable, and fine specimens of art work by artist and engraver.”’— Boston lranscripr. “The magazine has achieved a pronounced success, and has become a fixture in the current literature of the day.”—Saeramento Record-Union. Lectures Introductory to the Study of the Law of the Constitution. By A. V. Dicey, B.C.L. of the Inner Temple, Barrister-at-Law’ Vinerian Professor of English Law. 8vo, $3.50. In dealing with certain guiding principles which pervade the modern Constitution of England, the aim of the author has been te provide students with a manual which may imprtess these leading principles oa their minds. In furtherance of this desiga, the doctrines which are the fouadatiou of the existing Constitution are not only empha- size4, but Engliso coastitutionaliam is constantly illustrated by comparisous between it and the constitutionalism on the one hand of the United States and on the other of the French Republic. A New Novel by the Author of ‘ The Heir of Redelyffe.’ Nuttie’s Father. By Charlotte M. Yongs, author of ‘ The Heir of Radclyffe,’ etc., etc. 12mo, $1.50. “Distinguished. as are all her works, forite hightone. It might be put into the hands of any child, and yet there is suffictent in it to interest children of a larger growth.”—Academy. ” te issuing from the pen of Miss Yonge could fail to find a welcome from American readers.”—Church cord. “3ome of the safest and wisest stories ever written to divert, amuse, an‘ interest. Her admirers, both young and old, number up among the thousands in this country and in Eugland.”—Churchman. A New Story by the Author of ‘ Carrots.’ “US”: An Old-Fashioned Story. By Mrs. Molesworth, author of ‘ Carrots,’ ‘Cuckoo Clock,’ etc., ete. 16mo, $1 25. * Weare ~_ to find that Mrs. Molesworth has returned to an English nursery, while she has contrived to intro duce a new charm by calling back tolife the days when Pamela was not an impossible name.”—Churchman, “ Since the days of George Eliot there is none left whose touch is so exquisite and masterly, whosé love is so tho- roughly according to knowledge, whose bright and sweet invention is so fruitful, so truthful, or so delightful as Mrs. Molesworth’s.”—A. C. Swinburne. A Reasonable Faith. By Three ‘ Friends.” Revised Edition. 12mo, paper, 40 cents. “ [have read this little book with interest and full sympathy. Its views on the Bible are the only ones which seem to me at all compatible with a reasonable faith.””— Archdeacon farrar. “ | think the book was needed and thatit will do much good.”—J. @. Whittier. “ The main points in theology are handled clearly and concisely, so as to present in bright miniature the harmony established between Christianity and Reason by the best thinkers of the age.""—Litera ry World. “It 1s tmpoasible to speak too highly of these nine essays. To all searchers after truth we can cordially commend them. To peruse them is a religious education in itself, for while dominated by a commendable moderation of tone they are brimful of thought and suggestiveness.”— Glasgow Heralt. The English Citizen Series —New Volume, The Punishment and Prevention of Crime. By Colonel Sir Edmund DuCane, K.C.B , Surveyor-General], etc., of Prisons. 12mo, #1. “ Full of intererting and useful informatioa."—st. James's Gazette. Steele. Selections from the Zatler, Spectator, and Guardian, Edited, wita Introduction and Notes, by Austin Dobson. (Clarendon Press Series.) 16mo, $1.26. “ This unacsuming little volume possesses considerable value. The selections from Steele's essays include the best of his literary work, and they are arranged by subjects in a manner which the reader will find convenient. The notes are excellent. . . A work which 4S exceedingly well done and which must have cost the author much labor and research.” — Athen@um. P The volume deserves the hearty support of those assoeiated with the interests of the higher literary education.” —Academy. MACMILLAN & CO., 112 Fourth Avenue, New York. The Badminton Library F SPORTS anp PASTIMES A New and Very Attractive Series of Volumes devoted to Fiela Sportsand Games. Edited by His Grace the Puke of Beaufort, assisted by Mr. Alfred E. T. Wat- son. Dedicated ty permission to H.R.H. the Prince of Wales. Just Ready, the First Volume of the Sertes. Flunting. By His Grace the Duke of Beaufort and Mowbray Morris. With contributions frcm the Earl of Suffolk and Berkshire, Rev. E. W. L. Davies, Digby Collins, and Alfred E. T. Watson. Crown Svo, cloth extra. 385 pages, price $3 50, with a colored frontispiece and 53 beautifal wood engravings from designs by J. Stur- gess, J. Charlton, and Agnes M. Biddulph. CONTENTS : Chapter. I. The History and Literature of Hunting. II. Beasts of the Chase. The Stag. The Fox and his Habits. Harriers and the Hare. Beagles Hunted on Foot. III. The Stable. IV. The Kennel. V. Hunt Servanta. The Duties of a Huntsman inthe Field. The Duties of a Whip:er in. The Duties of a Kennel Hunts- man. The Dutiesof an EarthStopper. Compensa- tion for Dam: done by Horsemen and by Foxes. Artificial Fox VI. The Horse. IX. The Provinces. VII. The Rider. X. Hunting from London. VII. The Shires. XI. The Otter and his Ways. Appendices. A. List of Masters of Hounds and Ser- vants. B. Names of Hounds. c. Hunting Terms. D. Bibliography. Index. The object and scope of “The Badminton Library” are to supply to lovers of field sports and games a series of volumes devoted to these popular and attractive pursuits. There is no modern encyclopedia to which the inexpe- rienced man, who seeks guidance in the practice of the various sports and pastimes, can turn for information. Some books there are on Hunting, some on Kacing, some on Lawn Tennis, some on Fishing, and so on; but one library, or succession of volumes, which treats of these subjects is wanting. The Badminton Library is offered to supply this want. 1n its volumes those who are seek- ing for knowledge on any of the subjects dealt with will find the result of many years’ experience written by men who are in every case adepts at the sport or pastime of which they write. The publishers have placed the seve- ral volumes in the hands of writers possessing special qualifications in their respective departments, and the entire series is under the general supervision and editor- ship of His Grace the Duke of Beaufort, whose warm interest in field sports is well known, and who has been fortunate enough to secure in his editorial duties the valuable services and assistance of Mr. A. E T. Watson The volumes will consist of about 400 pages, published at about #8 50, and illustrated where necessary by colored illustrations or engravings by competent artists. The volumes may be had separately, but subscriptions will «be received for the entire series, which is intended to form a complete library of rural amusements The in- formation, it is desired, should be, before all things, thoroughly practical, but the subjects will be diversified with anecdotes and incidents of spor‘ing life. Nearlu Read» : FISHING. By H. Cholmondeley Pennell, etc. Vol, I.—Salmon, Trout, and Grayling. Vol. Il.—Pike and Other Coarse Fish. [Ready in No- vember } ¢#~ Volumes on Racing, Riding, and Driving, Shooting, Eoating, Cycling, Yachting, etc., are in preparatior. A New Fairy Book by Knatchbull Hugessen. FRIENDS AND FOES FROM Fairy Land. By the Right Hon. Lord Brabourne (Knatchbull-Hugessen), author of ‘Crackers for Christmas,’ ‘ Tales at Tea-Time,’ ‘ Higgledy, Piggle- dy,’ etc. 12mo, cloth, 360 pages, $1.50. With 24 i)- lustrations by Linley Sambourne. London: Longmans, Green & Co. BOSTON : Little, Brown & Co. wy | |
Page 5
i ; } 4 1 a The Nation. NRW YORK, THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 12, 1885 THERE are certain features of the late canvass which must not be forgotten by friends of re- form, no matter what they may think of Gov ernor Hill and his methods, One is that for the first time in the last fifty years we have had a canvass in which office-holders took no part. In the country districts, there are still a very large number of Republican postmasters who used to very active working politicians, and used to do a great deal for the party. This year they have been quiet as mice. They of course did not wish to serve the Demo- crats, and the Republicans, with the penalties of ‘‘ offensive partisanship” hanging over their heads, they dared not serve. be The Democratic postmasters, too, have been equally tranquil. They have not been called on for service by their superiors, and have been too doubtful about the consequences of political activity to volunteer it. In no place has the change been so marked as in this city. The Post-office and Custom- house used both to be great centres of politi cal activity. Everybody in both, down to the scrubbing women, used to be ‘‘as- sessed” for election expenses. The Post- master and his leading subordinates used to be occupied ail day during the canvass with **conferences” with politicians, or in mak- ing stumping tours round the State. In the Custom-house the state of things was ll worse The Collector’s office to be with ‘‘ workers” from morn ing till night, making reports or receiving instructions. Often enough used st crowded so many in spectors were sent off with a fortnight’s leave of to stump or ‘ organize,” that it was With difficulty the business of the port was carried on, Clerks who could not be spared, or absence, were less skilled in management, were mulcted mercilessly by assessments, and their ‘‘loy alty” was insured by the perpetual dread of peremptory dismissal, though neither loyalty nor assessments made any man sure of his place. This year none of these things have been witnessed. The ‘‘ Sterling incident” is the only sign of ‘‘politics” about the house during the late canvass. There were no assessments, no leaves of absence, no partisan Custom activity of any kind. The divorce of the Post-office from _ politics was even more complete. In both the business of the Government was carried on, like the busi- ness of private bankers and merchants, with«ut regard to the canvass or the election, and Gov ernment Clerks, like private clerks, did or did not make contributions to political funds,as their To crown all, there is probabhY not a man in New York to-day who can, in consequence of what means allowed or their sympathies dictated. he did or said during the late canvass, count on a place under the National Administration According to the predictions of the spoils- men during the last two or three years this ought to have resulted in a general public in diference to the election. Not only ought oftice-holders to have abstained from political but the hat there bulk of the voters ought, on activity, hearing t diy 1K and stayed away from. the polls ' no. Federal of} | wert ces to oe led, to have lost all interest in the res..lt, So far from however, it appears that about and Der actually voted, with no other motive coxcept the affairs of the State and a to strengthen their own party in the political tield. So that it is not yet true that Americans look on elections as simply a gambling opera tion, in which the stakes are places in the pub lie service. this, fS4 Gi) Republic ans about 495,000 ocrauts desire interest it One of the best things about the election in Virginia is the fact that the white Democrats are indebted in part to the negroes for the dimensions of their majority. Nothing has for the future of the blacks than the political slavery in which they were held until the How abject this slavery cannot le better illustrated than by the fact that even a man like General Hawley, who fought to make them freemen, has seriously proposed to take the census figures of the number of adult black males in any State as the number of votes which ought to be returned for the Republican ticket at every election, and to con been more discouraging election of Cleveland was sider any falling off as prima-facie evidence of Democratic fraud ! The worst indictment of the capacity for ever framed by Southern Democrats was not negro self-covernment so severe as this assumption of the party that every black man was its lifelong po that hone who captured a Republican nomination and anv rascal hke Ma litical vassal, might count with solid his entire confidence upon the The ignorance, Was not to blame the who told him that he hegro vote. colored man, in dk nse for believing unprincipled white | t would be put back it physical slavery if the Democrats came into ower; but this political slaverv was only less ital to his de velopime t fis ‘ . . } ‘ } wrvitude t is one of the greatest benefits « Cleveland's election that it has not Northern whites from their fears of ‘* Southern domination,” but that it has also em: Southern blacks, so that they are beginni divide their votes between the parties like treemen. en with- him. There irginia forever to uld think that r some part of Massachu he fe) live in Europe, but we shi Ohio, ¢ where could be in = close lowship with Sherman, or Foraker, or Hoat or Long, or Lode would ‘ 1 congenial for him As these tatesmi were so closely united to him in political life they ought not to be separated from 1 political death lis cause ought m less Worthy of support because it) has fa All these statesmen were, at last accounts, pr pared to stand by it forever, even af they tad to ‘' stand alone ind they ought to be 4 il to have Mahone come North and stand w them The Senate Safe is the tithe of a riousls but characteristically illogical article int Tribune of Friday morning, intended to show that the Republicans are sure ft contn ing the upper branch of Congress during U last half of President Cleveland Administra lion Proof ol this pProposith NH is stuupypre to be found in the fact that the De crats failed last week to carry the Les latures in New York, New Jersey ut Connecticul no one of which States clects a United States Senator until after anoth Legislature is chosen It is true tha ! State Senators chosen in’ New York and New Jersey last week will participate it the election of if hited St ites Senators early in ISN7, but the fact that the Re } ublicans have the advantage in bolding- over members by me } means decides the result When the } savs that ‘‘ the election of a Republican Senate in New Jersey insures the election of a Re publican wheu Senator Sewell’s term expires it ¢ V als} vs ith pte batural OTrAance ( po cal statistics which now days d tinguishes tl paper ed bv Horace cans sO Cu ( ( aT at Ss S¢ cured a De e y lead to ret a ret of that | c} ISSY when the lower branch Vas cl I ! cT \ i hie Demo ‘ ts dad « rh representatives to giv hmm at Vv « ‘ t d thus elect a Dereon o United States Senate Phe el CUS Ct i even that they wil } . x1 luca © Cle not TSs86 The SHOWS et | gnorance of facts re corded sundry / 1 s when i consoles f he very narrow Republican majority the Connecticut’ Legislature just chos bv the claim that ‘* the preponderance of the Republican vote in the small townis is ylwavs t when an election of United States is directly at The factis that the Con iblicans en je \ in a contest for the stake, advantage which eg : ; Legislature by reason of the unfan system of town re presentation, the Democrats carried the Legislature in 1874, when a Senatorship was ‘‘d rectly it stake,” and thus sent W. W. Eaton to Washington. As for New York, al though the Republicans carried the upper branch of the Legislature in 1873, a year before a Sen have done this the clecte d, as they ator was to be vear, and thus insured their control of upper branch in 1874, the Democrats got so large a majority in the lower branch in the latter year that they sent Mr. Kernan to the capital
Page 6
390 The Nation. {Number 1063 The truth is, that the contest for control of the United States Senate from 1887 to 1889 is going to be close and doubtful until after the 1886. Twenty-six Re- publicans and twenty-five Democrats will hold over from the Forty-ninth Congress. The Re- publicans have already secured the Legislature in Ohio which elects the next Senator, and the Democrats in Maryland, Virginia, and Missis- sippi, which makes twenty-eight Democrats and twenty-seven Republicans sure of seats after March 4, 1887, The Democrats are morally certain to carry next year’s Legislatures, and thus secure the Senatorships, in Delaware, Flo- rida, Missouri, Tennessee, Texas, and West Virginia, and the Republicans in Massachu- setts, Minnesota, Nebraska, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, and Vermont. This will carry the totals up to thirty-four Democrats and thirty-three Republicans, and leaves the nine States of California, Connecticut, Indiana, Maine, Michigan, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, and Wisconsin to be fought for. If the Democrats can add four of these nine to their previous November elections of thirty-four, they will have a majority with Vice-President Hendricks’s casting vote, while the Republicans must carry six of them to make their previous thirty-three a majority of the seventy-six members. The Repub- licans are pretty confident of carrying Maine and Wisconsin, while the Democrats are almost certain to secure Indiana. The Nevada seat will be again put up at auc- tion, and a Democrat is as likely to ‘‘ bid it in” as a Republican. California elected a Democratic Senator half-a-dozen years ago, and may do the same thing again. The Republicans came within a few votes of los- ing the Michigan Legislature last fall, and the State has become a doubtful one, while last week’s election in Connecticut shows that neither party can count upon that State next year. The Democrats seem to-day as likely as not to get the New Jersey Legislature in 1886, and may elect enough members of the lower branch in the New York Legislature next year to give them a majority on joint bal- lot even with a Republican Senate—although the present apportionment system gives the Republicans a great advantage. In short, to se- cure a majority in the Senate of the Fiftieth Congress the Democrats will only need to elect their men next year from four States like Cali- fornia, Connecticut, Indiana, Nevada, New York, and New Jersey, in which they have elected Senators when a Republican Adminis- tration was in power. They may not succeed in doing this, but it is the height of folly to maintain that they are certain to fail. ” President Cleveland has given no more con- vincing proof of his devotion to the cause of reform than by the course which he has pursued in the matter of reorganizing the Civil-Service Commission. He dismissed from consideration the professional oftice-seekers, who would have jumped at the chance of drawing a $3,500 sala- ry and at the same time doing all they could to make the system a farce, and made diligent search for men of character who were thoroughly committed to its principles. The fact that such aman as Mr. Charles R. Codman, of Massa- chusetts, was Mr. Cleveland’s original choice for one of the three places, spoke volumes as , to his sincerity. Unfortunately Mr. Codman, and more than one other man of equal fitness | whom the President sought to secure, could not serve, but he did not lower his standard. He has at last filled two of the vacancies with Mr. Mr. Alfred P. Edgerton, of Indiana. Mr. Tren- holm’s selection can be commended without the slightest reserve, since he has gained a national reputation by his earnest advocacy of sound doc- trine on the silver question, and is a pronounced believer in civil-service reform. Mr. Edger- ton is unknown to the general public, and the fact that he is an old gentleman of sixty-eight is certainly against him; but he is vouched for as being in full sympathy with the reform. Both of these gentlemen are Democrats, and it is a distinct gain to the movement that a ma- jority of the Commission should be members of that party. The examination for the Weighership at the Custom-house has terminated in a manner most painful for the Lifelong Democrats. It has pro- duced at the top of the list one of the assistant weighers, who has had long experience of the place, and would in any well-organized service be entitled to the promotion, even if there were no examination. This is bad enough, but it is not all. He is a disabled soldier, and, worse still, served in the Sixty-ninth Regiment. Moreover, his name is O’Brien, and he was educated at St. Francis Xavier’s College. The number of classes of the community who will be afflicted by this result is very large. The Lifelong Democrats will be pained at his getting the place as the result of a positive proof of fitness. The Irish Democratic blatherskites of the Bourke Cockran school will be afflicted at seeing an Irishman named O’Brien serving as an illustration of the virtue of the competitive system. The Irish Repub- lican blatherskites will be pained at seeing a Democratic President getting the credit of this mode of filling a weighership. The liquor- dealers will be enraged at seeing a good Gov- ernment place snatched from the hands of one of the best barkeepers in the country, who marched as chief mourner at the funeral of the lamented Jimmy Elliott, the pugilist and gambler, slain by Jerry Dunn in a saloon bat- tle. In fact, nobody of the spoils school will get any comfort out of it except those who maintain that college graduates get all the places under the competitive system. But even their mouths will be closed by the fact that it was at St. Francis Xavier's College he grad- uated, for they are always foreed to confess that the degree of a Catholic college does not hurt an office-seeker. The new anti-Chinese crusade on the Pacific Coast is approaching a crisis. The Federal authorities in Washington Territory have taken vigorous measures to enforce the laws which expressly guarantee protection to all Chinese in the country, and the national Administra- tion has thrown all the weight of its influence on the same side. Indictments have been found in the United States Court at Vancouver against no less than thirty-two citi- zens of Tacoma, including the Mayor and Police Judge and the editors of two news- papers, for inciting the recent outrages. There ' is abundant evidence that Chinese were dragged from their houses, cuffed, kicked, and beaten, and driven from the city in a cold storm, while their homes were burned by the mob. | The District-Attorney is confident of his ability William L. Trenholm, of South Carolina, and | | to secure the conviction of the offenders, and the trials will be watched with interest through- out the country, and indeed throughout the world. The honor of the Government is really at stake in this matter, for its faith has been pledged to the protection of these Chinamen. President Cleveland’s prociamation, warning evil-disposed persons in Washington Territory to desist from their designs against the Chinese, coupled with the above proceedings, is notable as the first attempt of the Government to fulfil its legal and moral obligations towards the Chinese, It furnishes, too, a fresh proof of ‘resident Cleveland’s stern and inflexible determination to enforce the law of the land against men of every race and condition, without regard to local feeling, and gives him a new claim on the respect and confidence of humane and patriotic men. In truth, in enforcing the law against the cattle-men, and now against the ‘‘leading citizens” of Washington Territory, he turns over a new leaf in American politics, and shows us the difference between an upright magistrate, who does not bear the sword in vain, and a tricky demagogue or weak and timid trimmer, who is always seeking for an excuse for not offend- ing powerful criminals. The instructions given to Mr. Marblein his late mission to Europe on behalf of the Govern- ment have been published. He was to ascer- tain, by ‘‘ personal conference with the expert advisers and statesmen of the principal govern- ments of Europe,” the ‘‘present opinions and pur- poses” of those governments with regard to the establishment of an international ratio of value between gold and silver,and the international use of both metals as unlimited legal tender. The main object of this mission was doubtless to have positive information of recent date as to the condition of the European mind about silver, to lay before Congress when it meets. Mr. Marble’s report has not been published. When it is »ublished, we suspect it will be found that the expert advisers and statesmen of Europe stand on this question about where they stood four years ago, when we sent Mr. Evarts over to convert them. Indiana furnishes a fresh illustration of the fact that nothing stimulates fraud better than liberal appropriations for pénsions. The Le- gislaturea few months ago made a grant of money to pay the services during the war of the State Legion, a sort of home guard organiza- tion. Claims immediately began to pour in upon the State Treasury in appalling numbers. One county professed to have had about two thousand men in the Legion, at which rate this compara- tively small force would have nearly equalled in number the State’s contributions of volunteer soldiers during the whole war. Men sent in affidavits declaring that they had served from five to eight months, when investigation showed that they had never handled a gun. The evidence of wholesale lying was so con- “es
Page 7
Nov. 12, 1885] The Nation. 391 —— clusive that the State officers had tocall a halt and stop payment altogether. There is nothing novel or surprising about such developments. Quite as disgraceful a showing was made early in the the century, when Congress voted pensions to all who had served in the Revolutionary army and were in need of assistance, only to find more applicants than the largest number of soldiers in Washington’s army at any period of the war for independence. The ordinary rules of conduct somehow appear to lose their influ- ence over people when there is a pension to be got, and men who are generally considered good citizens lie in the most shameless fashion. A noteworthy feature of agriculture in the West this year is the great increase in the pro- duction of flax. The reccipts of flaxseed in Chicago during October aggregated 1,875,000 bushels of fifty-six pounds each, and in one week of the month the receipts of the seed exceeded those of wheat. For the first three months of the current crop year the receipts were nearly 1,600,000 bush- els Jarger than in the same months of 1884, and the shipments were nearly as much in execss of those for the correspond- ing time last year. A quarter of a million bushels have already been exported, and as much more has been ordered for Europe, where the American seed is supplanting the crop of Dritish India. The immediate cause of the great increase in production is the low price of wheat last fall and winter, which discouraged many farmers as to the future of that grain, and induced them to try the raising of flax. The secd brings good prices, and the great danger is that the success of the experi ment will tempt too many farmers to go into the business next year. Flax exhausts the soil rapidly, and a few crops of it will leave a farmer with his Jand badly worn out. It will not be strange if the Western farmers who try it find themselves in the end as badly off as their New England brethren, who twenty years ago were induced to go into tobacco-raising by the high prices which the crop commanded, and before long dis- covered that their land would not produce a crop without such a quantity of fertilizers as made it hard to raise anything profitably. very The failure of the natural wells in Champaign, IIl., isa forcible reminder of the fact that we know next te nothing about the condition of things below the earth’s surface. There is not the slightest assurance that the people who are working up great schemes for the use of similar gas in Pennsylvania may not find the supply some day suddenly giving out. As to petroleum, there is accumulating evidence that the amountavailable is limited,and that before many years the home supply will be seriously trenched upon. The geologist in charge of the Pennsylvania survey, who fora de- cade has carefully studied the oil region in that State and across the New York border, points out that the production for each well is steadily di- minishing with the increase in their number; and as the area of possible operations is limited, he inchnes to the opinion that more than half of the supply is already exhausted. As the market for oil has been widening of late ras gas years, the end will come all the sooner; and while the question is not yet a pressing one, evervthing indicates that before many years a substitute for petroleum will be demanded, The wonderful development of invention, however, is calculated to keep people from worrying over the prospect, since we are fast coming to believe that man is capable of sup plying any deficiencies on the part of nature The motion made in the Common Pleas on Monday to have the Court adjourn out of re- spect for the memory of the late Judge Cardozo, was a curious illustration of the degree to which the friends of wrong-~doers in this city count on public forgetfulness. of the Common Pleas, and was translated to the Supreme Court. While there he became a member of the Tweed Ring, like Barnard, made of oftice It was proved against him, among things, that he gave references lawyer named Gratz Nathan, a connection of his, on condition of sharing in the fees, and did share them, and, to escape impeachment Cardozo was once Judge and, merchandise his other to a young and certain conviction, he resigned his office, and implored the Committee of the Bar Associa tion to forego further pursuit of him on condi tion that he would leave the State. They agreed to this, but, the danger he broke his pledge, and impudently resumed practice at the bar in this city, where he remained till f ics over, his death—a standing discredit to his pre One would expect that under these cit al all sion. cumstances his friends would ask at his death would be silence and oblivion on th¢ part cf the courts and the press. But one of them had the audacity on Monday to ask the Court of Common Pleas, which he had disgrac ed, to adjourn out of respect to his memory, Comically enough, too, the motion was sec onded by that very droll ex-Judge Richard Bustecd, formerly known in New York poli The Court the usual later tics as ‘‘galorious Dick Busteed.” denied the motion, and adjourned at hour, It ought than usual, with the bench draped in sack cloth. sat two hours to have edit tor abduction, has The conviction of Stead, the "ll Mall Gazette, lowed by his conviction for an indecent assault, and sentence to three months’ imprisonment, The Judge evidently shares the opinions of the London press about his goings on. The London morning papers are very savage in their comments him, and no for his ** based on stories told him over champagne by on wonder, revelations "seem to have been entirely brothel keepers. His one piece of practical demonstration he had to manufacture, and took for the purpose an innocent clild. Two months’ imprisonment would be an absurdly for such an offence. He is, however, hardly as much to blame after all— he light sentence because nalism "—+: was making a good stroke of ‘‘jour- s the | openin ‘Social Purity ” people who | have been cncouraging him. No profligates, or venders of obscene literature, have done as much to spread impurity through the Englist years as Stead has done in the last six months, The Londen 7imes accuses him of ‘‘stooping speaking world in the last hundred or procuresses to some of the arts of fourth-rate transatlantic journalism.” What can this mean? ’ fst ( A curious phase of the Sunday- ;uacs tion in England is prese nted in a recent letter . vty in the London Times The correspondent Writes that, in company with two friends, he service in the newly f Alban’'s Sunday, ‘‘ proposing afterward t attended afternoon stored nave of St i fortuight ago kk y see the sh cathe of one of the most interesting of Engl drals.” Service over, however, the Party were informed that it was impossible for them to carry out their plan, and = that it was forbidden even to walk round the nave after service exeept by special per mission from the Archdeacon This per sion was obtained by the correspondent, but upon returning to the Abbey, he found that his companions had meanwhile been turned out of the building ‘‘with but seant courtesy,” that the doors were locked, and th Ve vr one Having failed in their endeavor to inspect the interior, the visitors attempted to see the exterior, ‘in itself of extreme = in terest,” but they were promptly ordered out of the churchyard bv ais surly official, who told them that if they di ) } ’ the smkes of an they would have to climb over eight-foot railing Similar rules enforced at the interesting church of St. Michael in the same town, with its Bacon monument and shrine of Duke Humptires And we mav add that Americans know by perience that Shaksvere’s bust and ive ¢ Stratford church cat be viewed Sunday except during service Mh ss correspond ent is ind gnant at such nm ns, and we doubt not that nv rigid Sabbatarians will share his sentiments. Yet the truth is, that the clergy of St. Albans have o1 ly been consistent in carrying out to its logical conelusion the theery upon which is based the whol Opposition to the Sunday opening of li raries, museums, art galleries, and all such places. It is just as bad to visit St. Albans of a Sunday ‘‘to admire at Icisure mm mw y the grand old A gallery and enjoy the work of a great painter. The form with the people who oppese the Sunday of the Metropolitan Museum in Cen tral Park "as itisto goto a picture St. Albans clergy stand on the same plat The Conference of the Powers on the Balkan affairs has met at Constantinople, and is now in session It does not follow because there is a conference that there will be peace, because the war of IS77 was preceded by a conference. But Turkey is a great deal wiser now than she was then, and is really anxious to avoid war. A compre propose a by Austria, which that of a complete union between Bulgaria and Rume lia, there should be a personal union—that is, that they should remain separate principali- ties, but should each have Alexander of Bulga- ria for its Prince. The difference between this and the complete union would probably be found in the course of a year to be no greater than between tweedledim and tweedledee, but it would save Turkish pride and furnish some sort of answer to those who pretend to respect the Treaty of Berlin. mise has been proposes instead
Page 8
892 The Nation. [Number 1063
SUMMARY OF THE WEEK’S NEWS. | WEDNESDAY, November 4, to TuEspay, November 10, 1885, inclusive.)
DOMESTIC. Tut President on Wednesday appointed Mr. Alfred P. Edgerton, of Indiana, to succeed Mr. Dorman B Eaton, and Mr. William L. Trenholm, of South Carolina, to succeed Mr. John M. Gregory, as members of the United States Civil Service Commission. 3oth are Democrats. Mr. Edgerton was in early life a clerk in a mercantile house in New York city, but while still a young manremoved to North- ern Ohio as the agent of the Northern Land Company. He then served four years in Con- gress as a Democrat, and was the financial agent of the State of Ohio, with an office in New York city. In 1858 he moved to Indiana, and ten years later was the Democratic candi- date for Lieutenant-Governor, Vice-President Hendricks beiog the candidate for Governor. They were both defeated. As a Democrat, Mr. Edgerton refused to support Greeley in 1872, and came within six votes of being nominated for Vice-President on the O’Conor ticket over John Quincy Adams, jr. He was then nominated as the straightout Demo- eratic candidate for Governor of Indiana, but declined in a letter which urged all Democrats to support Mr. Hendricks, and the latter was elected. For fifteen years Mr. Edgerton has been unanimously elected by the Common Council of Fort Wayne as the President of the Board of Education of that city. He isa friend of civil-service reform. Mr, Trenholm is a commission merchant, about fifty years of age, and was warmly endorsed for the appointment by leading friends of the civil- service reform movement North and South. IIe is the son of the late Secretary of the Treasury of the Southern Confederacy, and has been brought into prominence lately by his addresses before numerous bankers’ con- ventions ov the silver question, and his writings on the same subject, which have attracted wide attention. He also is a_ civil-service reformer. On Thursday afternoon the President ap- pointed Dorman 8, Eaton as the Republican member of the Commission. It is believed that he will only hold the position temporarily, The Democratic spoilsmen in Washington, who are endeavoring to make it appear that the fall elections have resultedin a defeat and not in an endorsement of the President's policy, insist now that the President must hereafter more rapidly make removals from office and appoint politicians, and they assume that the changes in the Civil-Service Commission mean that the Administration will relax its vigilance in the execution of the Civil Service Law. In this there are the best of reasons for stating that the spoils hunters will be quite as much disappointed as they were before the election, President Cleveland has a definite policy, and it is his purpose to execute it. The fact that the fall elections have gone one way or another will not cause him to deviate from the course which he has marked out. The new Civil- Service Commissioners will be held to a strict responsibility, and while it is undoubtedly true that there will be some important changes in the rules, these changes will be intended to render the execution of the law more efficient, and not the contrary. President Cleveland has appointed Leverett Saltonstall Collector of Customs at Boston, in the place of Roland Worthington, removed. Mr. Saltonstall is a graduate of Harvard Uni- versity, and a lawyer, but for some years has not been engaged in active practice. He has been a Democrat since the disruption of the Whig party, and for many years has been an active and influential member of the party in his State, repeatedly representing it in the Democratic National Conventions. In 1876 he was one of Mr. Tilden’s trusted advisers. On Saturday the President issued a proclama- tion commanding all persons at Seattle and other places in Washington Territory who haye
assembled for unlawful purposes to desist therefrom, and to disperse and retire peaceably to their homes on or before 12 o’clock, Novem- ber 8. This referred to the proposed uprising of the people to drive the Chinese from that Territory. Indictments have been found against thirty two persons for participation in the outrages against the Chinese at Tacoma, Washington Territory. It is understood that among the persons indicted are Mayor Weisback, of Ta- coma, the Police Judge of the city, the editors of two newspapers, and other persons promi- nent in inciting outrage. The President’s proclamation and the advent of troops have had the effect of breaking the backbone of the riot at Seattle, and no further trouble is feared. The President has recently held conferences with leading Democrats with special refer- ence to the silver question. At one of these conferences he was very earnestly urged to take in his message the most radical ground in opposition to the silver dollar, and to declare fora single standard. The impression, how- ever, among those who have talked with the President is, that he will recommend in his message the repeal of the law which authorizes the coinage of the present standard dollar, and the enactment of a new law which will pro- vide for the coinage of a silver dollar so in- creased in weight asto be the present equiva- lent of gold. This is practically the John Sherman plan. These statements are not authoritative, and it may be that the President has not yet himself finally decided as to his recommendations; but this is the inference of those who have very carefully discussed this question with him. The final action of the Congress of the States comprising the Latin Union on bimetal- lism is announced by Minister McLane by cable to the State Departinent as follows: ‘‘ France, Greece, Italy, and Switzerland have renewed the monetary convention for five years ; silver coins redeemable in gold; no additional silver coinage permitted ; convention open to Bel- gium.” President Cleveland returned to Washington on Wednesday morning and immediately sent the following telegram to Governor Hill: ‘I have just returned from Buffalo and learned the result when nearly home. I heartily con- gratulate you on your election.” The hearing in the matter of the various pe- titions against the Bell Telephone Company was begun at the Interior Department in Wash- ington on Monday morning. The Board con- sisted of Secretary Lamar, Assistant Secreta- ries Jenks and Muldrow, and the Commis- sioner of Patents. The Creek Indians have decided not to sell Oklahoma at any price. A receiver was on Monday appointed for Mahone’s organ, the Richmond (Va.) Whig. This is accepted as the surest possible indica- tion that Mahone has bid farewell to politics in Virginia. He has controlled the Whig for twelve years, Full returns show that the election of local officers in this city resulted in the choice of the following: Sheriff—Hugh J. Grant, Tam- many. County Clerk—James A. Flack, Tammany. President of the Board of Alder- men — Robert B. Nooney, Irving Hall and Tammany. Supreme Court Judge—George C. Barrett, united Democratic and Republican. Superior Court—John Sedgwick, Republican and County Democracy. Common Pleas Court — Henry W. Bookstaver, Tammany. City Court—David McAdam, Tammany, and Simon M. Ehrlich, Tammany. The Republican majority in Iowa is about 6,000. The official census of Wisconsin just com- pleted shows: Total population, 1,568,423; white males, 806,342; white females, 748,810; negroes of both sexes, 5,576; Indians, 2,695. Roach’s shipyard at Chester, Pa., started work on Monday morning. 150 men were put to work on the cruisers,
The boycotting of the Knights of Labor against the Mallory Steamship Company and on the Gulf, Colorado and Santa Fé Railwa at Galveston, Tex., continued unchanged until Sunday. The commerce of Galveston was practically suspended, no freight entering that city. The white ‘longshoremen of the Mal lory Line struck about the middle of October. Negro laborers are doing their work. On Sun- day an agreement was reached to arbitrate the dispute, and the men went to work on Mon- day morning, breaking the freight blockade. Ex-President Franklin B. Gowen, of the Reading Railroad Company, has issued a mani-. festo to the stockholders, announcing himself as a candidate for the Presidency of the com- pany at the coming election. A storm accompanied by a cyclone passed over the region north of Selma, Alabama, on Friday night, causing great destruction. Thir- teen dead bodies have been found in the track of the storm, The iron steamer Algoma, of the Canadian Pacific Railway Company, was wrecked on Friday on Lake Superior. Forty-eight lives were lost, and only fourteen were saved. The steamer struck a reef in a great gale while try- ing to make a port of refuge. Ex-Judge Albert Cardozo died in this city on Sunday, at the age of fifty-seven. In 1866 he was chosen a Judge of the Supreme Court. In this position he soon attracted the attention of Tweed and his associates, and he was involved in the downfall of the Tammany Ring in 1871. Early in 1872 he was formally charged by a committee of the New York Bar Association with corrupt conduct in having illegally re- ceived for his own use a part of the fees of referees appointed by him. An Assembly committee of investigation made a majority report in favor of Cardozo’s impeachment, and on the very day upon which a vote would have been reached in the Assembly upon the ques- tion of impeachment, the Judge resigned from the bench. He was a prominent Tammany Sachem. John McCullough died at his home in Phila- delphia at 1 o’clock on Sunday afternoon. He was born on November 22, 1837, near Londonderry, in the North of Ireland. His father was a poor farmer. The boy came to America when fifteen years of age, and for a time worked at chair-making. <A fellow- workman persuaded him to join an ama- teur dramatic company. He was seen by a Philadelphia manager and engaged to play at $4 per week in 1857. E. L. Davenport en- couraged the young actor. In 1860 he won the favor of Edwin Forrest, and under bis tu- telage advanced rapidly to be his leading sup- port. When Forrest died, McCullough came to be acknowledged as in some respects his suc- cessor. He managed a theatre in San Fran cisco for ten years and prospered. Returning East, he met with general favor. For severa years his financial success has been very great. His most successful réles were Virginius, Payne’s Brutus, and Othello. He began to fail in health in 1884, and on September 30, while acting Virginius at Chicago, he completely broke down. He never appeared upon the stage again. His faculties were gradually eclipsed. He was one of the most popular men in the dramatic profession. FOREIGN. The first meeting of the Balkan Conference took place in Constantinople on Thursday. Zusiness was limited to the exchanging of cre- dentials and the appointment of officials. The Conference opened with accord among the Powers on the following bases: ‘That the treaty of Berlin be nominally maintained; that Rumelia and Bulgaria be kept separate, but be permitted a personal union under Prince Alex- ander; that an international commission fix a common code of laws for the two States; that their military budgets be kept separate; that the Rumelian militia be maintained, and that the Bulgarian troops be forbidden to cross their own frontier, Queen Victoria’s influence @
Page 9
Pr ee | eit ge + epnyeres Nov. 12, 1885] The Nation. 393 is used to keep Prince Alexander in power. On the other hand, it is rumored in Berlin that England and Russia have arranged for the Duke of Edinburgh to sueceed Prince Alexan- der. The Balkan Conference has accepted the proposal of Said Pasha approving the principle of a return to the status quo ante, At the next sitting of the Conference, France will propose to sauction the wishes of the people of Rumelia by conceding common organic statutes with Bulgaria, under one ruler, leaving open the question as to Prince Alexander. It is stated that a proposal has been made at the Conference to appoint a temporary Governor of Rumelia, and to request Prince Alexander to withdraw pending the settlement of the question. Lord Salisbury, in a speech at the Lord Mayor’s banquet in London on Monday night, predicted that the Balkan Conference would be a failure, and that its decision would be ad- verse to English views. He thought that if the status quo ante were restored, the Bul- garians would take Greece and Servia into their confidence, and Turkey would then have to combat three Powers instead of one. The Balkan movement was purely popular and not prompted by foreign influence. England earn- estly desired a settlement that would satisfy the Balkan States and preserve the integrity of Turkey, which was necessary for European peace. The London Standard on Tuesday asserted that Russia consented to the umon of Bulga- ria and Southern Rumelia on condition that Prince Alexander resigned, Russia has dismissed Prince Alexander from the honorary command which he held in the Russian army. Such action is highly signifi- cant, It shows, first, that Russia has given up hope of Alexander’s ever beg anything but hostile to her and the ruler of an independent principality, and, second, it foreshadows the probability of the Conference breaking up in dissension. The St. Petersburg Noroe Vremya on Fri- day said: ‘‘It has been learned that Prince Alexander intended to dismiss the Russian offi- cers in his service, but that Russia recalled them, and thus forestalled him, Russian inte- rests are closely united with those of Bulgaria. Russia, however, is not hostile to Prince Alex ander,” A conspiracy among the followers of Prince Karageorgevitch was discovered in Belgrade, Servia, on Thursday. Many influential men were involved. It was the intention of the conspirators to take the lifeof King Milan. A number of arrests were made, and intense ex- citement prevailed throughout Servia. There is reason to believe that the Servian conspiracy was the outcome of the revolutionary programme recently planned by the Pan Slavist Committee in Rumelia, which embraced a union of Bulgaria, Eastern Rumelia, Old Servia, and Macedonia under one sceptre. Parliament will be summoned to meet in January, and will then adjourn, During the interim, if there is a large Liberal ma- jority, the present Ministry will resign and anew Ministry will be formed. If the Con- servatives should have a majority in the new Parliament, they will prepare a programme for the session. If the parties are equally divided, the Conservatives will retain office. Lord Salisbury delivered a speech in Victo- ria Hall, London, on Wednesday evening. He denied that the Tories wished to tax cereals, but said that free trade should not pre- vent an arrangement of duties in order to place England on a footing with other nations. To take a hypothetical casé, if Spain refused to admit English manufactures, but admitted those of other countries, the raising of the du- ties on Spanish wines by England would not be an infringement of free-trade principles, but would be a justifiable retaliation. Nor should England be prevented from altering her tariffs in order to benefit her colonies. The speech is considered a bold bid for the protec- tionist vote. Mr. Gladstone left Hawarden for Edinburgh on Monday, in good health and spirits. Un precedented enthusiasm was shown all along the route. Mr. Gladstone made a number of short speeches by the way, arriving at Ed- inburgh at 4:40 Pp. M. Mr. Gladstone, in a short speech at Edin burgh on Monday, said: ‘‘ The Irish question isabout to assume a new position because it is not now a question of cruel grievances. Thanks to the patience, zeal, energy, and good sense of Parliament, the grievances have one by one been removed. But I know very well that my fellow-countrymen in Ireland still feel and be lieve that one grievance remains concerning the management of their own country as opposed to imperial concerns, Formerly, the electorate of Ireland was so limited that it was almost im possible to recognize its utterances as the voice of the nation. The members were split into three parties—Parnellites, Tories, and Liberals Now lreland’s electorate is as broad, as extend ed, as well qualified to speak of the wants and wishes of the people as are the clec torates of Scotland and England. I am con fident that England will never repent giving perfect equality to Ireland. We must look a step further forward, and expect the party which is probably in a vast majority in Lreland to demand large powers of self-government. Such will be a grave contingency. But let it not fill us with alarm, because as long as we give liberally, equitably, and prudently it will be needlessto fear the results, assuming always that nothing will be demanded that will jeopardize or compromise the unity of the em- pire. If such a demand be made, we shall know how to deal with it. It is unjust for the people of Ireland to suppose that any other basis is contemplated. To stint Ireland in powers necessary or desirable for the manage ment of purely Irish matters is a great error.” Mr. John Tyndall, the scientist, bas written a letter in which he declines to stand as a can didate fora member of Parliament for Ren frew. He says that the permanent atmosphere of the House would not suit him, He proceeds to denounce the Gladstone Cabinet, which, he says, head.d by an unstable ruler, caused tive years of humiliation abroad and confusion at home. Recalling the events in the Transvaal and in the Sudan, Mr. Tyndall says If there be a day of retribution for the misdeeds of men, I would not willingly accompany to the judg- ment seat the unpurged spirits of those who were responsible for the bloodshed in the Su dan, It was a damning and damnable business from beginning toend. Yet the man who is answerable beyond all others for this waste of blood, who sent Gordon to the wilds and there abandoned him to death and mutilation, now dares to talk to the people of Midlothian as if no tleck rested upon his workmanship.” Arch- deacon George A, Denison, of Taunton, in an election speech recently said: **T have known Mr. Gladstone forty-five years, and I would not trust him with a brass farthing.” The trial of Mr. Stead. editor of the 7a?! Mall Gazette; Mr. Bramwell Booth, of the Salvation Army; Mr. Sampson Jacques, of the staff of the Pall Mall Gazette; and Mrs. Jar rett, defendants in the Armstrong abduction case, was concluded in London on Saturday at the C-ntral Criminal Court before Justice Lopes. The Judge in his charge to the jury urged that they bring in a verdict according to the law, and not allow their personal sym- pathies to influence their decision. The only material question for the jury to decide was ‘whether the child Eliza Armsirong was taken away from her home against her father’s will.” They were also to deter- mine whether the mother sold her child to the prisoners as alleged by the defence: The jury brought in a verdict of guilty against Stead and Rebecca Jarrett, and acquitted Booth and Jacques. They agreed that Stead and Mrs, Jarrett took Elza Armstrong from her home against her father’s will, but could ane tt ; CIVILZADON | | de Fr Veinet, not agree as to whether Mrs. Jarrett obtained the child by false pretences, They also agreed that the mother did not see ber child allewed by the detence, and that Mi ban and Mr. Jacques were not parties to the ab duction, The Judge deferred passing sentence on the convicted prisoners until atte of the indictment for indecent assault agains Stead, Jacques, Mrs. Jarrett, and Louise Mou } rey on Tuesday, when he passed sentence o1 the prisoners as follows: Mr. Stead, three months; Rebecca Jarrett, six months, an Sampson Jacques, one month, all without hat labor; and Madame Louise Mourev, six months with hard labor Mr. Stead, in conversation on Mouday. sa 7 strongly ck precate any tlenipt t row on my behalf or to say that [have beet treated unjustly, because that is mot trux I made a blunder and am now pay t! for it. But still Lam upheld by the know ledge that my blunder was better than 1 \ dom of the others The British Government has de ‘ Mr. Matthew Arnold to Frank nd Gert \ to inquire into the syste f ft : those countries The reply of King Theebaw, of Burn the British ultimatum was hos ind quate. It was reported i \ Indian Government had declared war Burmah. The British expeditionary force w move immediately William Benjamin Carpente LU. 1), the eminent English physiologist, is dead. Hi Was the author of an important werk entitled ‘Principles of General and Comparative Phy sivlogy Hlis reputation was widely extended by his * Principles of Human Physiology Robert Thorburn, the eminent Seotech 1 niature painter, is dead at tl of Sixty seven tle was elected to the Rov \c a in 1848, Asaresult of the elections for members of the Prussian Diet the strengt partie ’ the lower house ts as follows: ( servaa Free Conservative eTicals $ Liberals 70, New German Liberals 44, Poles 14, Danes 3. } 3 "OO, Crue Iplis A semi-official notice published in Ber States that Count von Hatzfeldt will retain his post in the Foreign Otic is there is eandl date at present a ulable for the place This disposes of the rumor of the appointment of Count Herbert Bismarck The Paris Mat ASSt President Grevy's recent accident Was due to a slight tack of a} plexy, avd that this renders impos sible his retlection to the Presidency Marriotti, the would-be assassin of M has been pronounced a mono naniac The Pop has issued an enc vi lical letter quot ing the svllabus of Pius IX. against modern n and approving it. It popular government, nsisis upon the oly dic nee ot subje cts to thie il sovereigus, and uy n to the Pope. Reli thie Pox savs, ought to enter into daily life, He urges Catholics to take part in all muni- cipal political elections King Alfonso of Spain is seriously ill, denounces and sovereigns’ obedience 10n, The Russian harvest of ISS) is above the average for winter wheat, but below the average for spring wheat. The deficiency in spring wheat is due todrought. Rye is slightly above the average. The oat crop is bad. Other cereals are below the average, The beet and tobacco crops are good. Hay and fruit are in- ferior. The total wheat production is 36,900, 000 quarters, which 1s 20 per cent, under the average. Osman Digna is not dead, as has been several times reported. Six thousand Egyptian rebels are advance ing toward Wady Halfa. The last spike in the Canadian Pacific Rail- way was driven near Eagle Pass, Lb. C., on Saturday. Through trains will not be run un til May Ist, 1886,
Page 10
in RI Sly titi 894 ‘The Nation. [Number 1063 THE REPUBLICAN LESSON. Tue most important fact of American poli- tics for political managers, during the last twenty-five years, has been that New York is an uncertain State, with a large, loose, shift- ing, and independent vote. Other large States— Vhio, Illinois, Pennsylvania, Massachusetts,even Indiana with the aid of the post-office—could at any time since 1860 have been counted on With tolerable certainty. New York never could be. It went Democratic in 1862, the second year of the war, again in 1868, in 1870, in 1874, in 1876, in 1882, and 1884. It gave Cleveland a majority of 192,000 for the Gov. ernorship in 1882. It gave him only a majori- ty of 1,000 for the Presidency last year. And this fact must be taken in connection with the other most important fact, that the size of its vote in the electoral college gives it almost invariably, in the present divi- sion of parties, the power of awarding the Presidency every four years. Consequently, the Republican party, whatever else it may have, if it have not New York, is nothing but a sounding brass or atinkling cymbal. In order to do any of the great things it sets before itself in its platforms, or elect any of its great and good men to the Presidency, it must have a majority in this State. The application of this now well-settled rule to the late election seemed easy enough. The only possible hope of electing Davenport lay in catching the loose, shifting vote, which is not strongly attached to either party, and which, in spite of the defection of the Irish from the Democrats last year, put Cleveland in the Presidential chair. We care not of what kind of people this vote is made up. Call them In- dependent Democrats, or Independent Republi- cans, or Mugwumps, just as you please, What is important for the purposes of our argument is that they exist, that they hold the balance of power, and that any party which means to carry New York must somehow placate them, and that no party can count on their support in virtue of its past performances. Now, if there be anything certain in politics, there are two things certain in the polities of this State: one is, that this voters is sick of what is called ‘‘the bloody shirt’—sick, that is, of that queer claim of the Republicans that,although, according to their own story, they failed during their twenty years of power to secure to the negro the free exercise of the franchise, nevertheless the fact that he is still deprived of it isa capital reason why they should be kept in power indefinitely. Another is, that the Independents are not afraid of the Demo crats,and do not believe Republican stories about their wickedness, and about the ruin which is sure to follow their coming into power. Now, with these two facts before them, it seems as if ordinary business sense ought to have made the task of the Republican managers in the late canvass easy. They ought to have nominated a highly respectable candidate, who, as needing no apologics or whitewashing, would form a marked contrast to the grotesque class of personage whom they iried to force on the voters last year. This they did in Mr. Davenport. They ought then to have concocted a moderate platform, devoted to State affairs, avoiding or dwelling lightly on the topics on which public sentiment in this State is most divided, speaking strongly for reform, and proving the sincerity of their speech, and at the same time conciliating Democratic friends of civil-service reform by frank and generous recognition of the very remarkable contributions to the cause of reform which the Democratic President had made. The high-tariff idea, too, as the Gov- ernor and Legislature of New York have but little more to do with the United States tariff than the Prussian Landtag, might very well have been passed over lightly or dropped out of sight, that also being a topic on which the Independent voters are divided or uncertain. We do not need to say what kind of plat- form was drawn up. The Convention gave the drafting of it toa hack politician of the most mercenary and convictionless type, as impervious to new ideas as a janitor in a Do- minican monastery ; and something was pro- duced which seemed in every line intended to repel and _ disgust the voters on whom, at every election, victory in this State depends. It insulted the President, and in such an ingenious way as to insult also the majority which voted for him last year. It misrepresented and belittled what he had done for reform, in such a way as to convince people that Republicans cared nothing for any reform by which they did not profit. To crown all, it again thrust in our faces the af fairs of South Carolina, and Georgia, and Mis- sissippi. We felt, as our readers know, from the mo- ment that thisextraordinary document appeared, that the result of any opposition to the Demo- cratic spoilsmen in this State must be very doubt- ful, and that the grossly insulting references to the President would probably.as a matter of self- respect and personal pride, remove any luke warmness he may have felt about the Hill eandi- dacy. We did our best to minimize the influ- ence of the platform, nevertheless, and to fix the thoughts of the voters on the efforts made to minimize it by others, and on the good quality of the nominations, though the letters we re- ceived from Independents from both sides showed us it was very uphill work. If any success whatever attended these efforts, it was neutralized as soon as the Republicans began to produce their orators. General Carr no sooner appeared in public than ke denounced the President and his Cabinet, in language worthy of an insane person, as ‘traitors and rebels.” Soon afterwards Foraker and Logan were actually brought here to bellow about the ‘‘ bloody shirt,” on their way to support in Virginia the candidacy of one of the most worthless and dishonest adventurers ever seen in American politics—and this in _ spite of the acknowledged fact that a voter convert- ed or confirmed in the Republican faith by bloody-shirt oratory could not be found in the whole State, and in spite of the fact that thou- sands have been alienated or offended by the connivance of the late Administration and of the Republican Senators at Mahone’s ras calities. Then, too, in this city the Repub- lican organ devoted itself day by day to sneering at the reformers, and warning them away from the Republican ticket, and finally illustrated Republican principles by sup- porting the attack on Judge Sedgwick because he did not vote for Blaine, and trying to white- wash such local candidates as Gibbs. To all these thirgs must be added the fact that the Democrats are now in power and the country is still prosperous and bappy, and the Republicans are thus deprived of one of their most effective electioneering Weapons—the prediction of the ruin and disorder which would follow Democratic accession to power. The Democrats thus carry into every election some of the momen- tum of success. They will never be again overthrown in this State by opposition con ducted as the Republican opposition now is. The Republican party, if it means to regain New York, must get rid of its Blisses and O’Briens and Biglins, and discard ‘‘the bloody shirt ” finally and forever. Its orators must be tied down to things which New York voters can influence, and above all it must prove its sincerity in the cause of reform by praising reform wherever it sees it, instead of ridiculing and lying about all good things which it has not itself brought about. It may refuse to do these things in Ohio or Illinois, or Massachusetts, or may run a notorious rascal for high office in Pennsylvania, without exposing itself to defeat; but in New York it must do them or die out. THE NEW OPPOSITION IN MEXICO. Ir has been common to point to Mexico as the standing proof that a liberal and enlight- ened form of government, so far as Constitu- tion and statutes can secure it, may be easily perverted into a centralized and despotic oligarchy. This might be admitted without at all necessitating the conclusion that the temper and education and civilization of a people are of so much more importance than their form of government as to make the latter a matter of indifference. For, all other questions aside, it makes a great difference whether an agitation to better the condition of a country and to secure popular rights has to take the form of outright revolution, or that of an appeal to guaranteed but suspended liber. ties. Itis the difference between revolution and restoration, between anarchy and patriotism. President Diaz, as was the case with his pre- decessors, has found it easy to evade many a provision of the Mexican Constitution, as long as no great popular suspicion or feeling was excited. But now that he finds his Govern- ment confronted by a group of determined deputies who are vehemently appealing to un doubted constitutional rights, and evoking a growing sentiment among the people that their chartered liberties are in danger, he is realizing how different are the fasces of the Republic from the sceptre of the monarchy. It isin this light, in our opinion, that we are to look at the recent stormy sessions of the Mexican Congress, of which the telegraph bas given fragmentary accounts. A new phase of Parliamentary Government has been entered upon. A new Opposition has arisen. It is new in not being, as far as yet appears, personal—that is, allied to the fortunes of some political chief. It is new in its method, that of resolutely and incessantly demanding a return to the Constitu- tion. A mere handful of men, bold to reck- owns
Page 11
mere ee Nov. 12 1885| The Nation. aia ———————————————————— — ———— 2 lessness, ready to sacrifice their political future, and, apparently, in a fair way to doit, eloquent, thoroughly versed in legal and parliamentary procedure—this Opposition in the Mexican Congress is a new and notable phenomenon in Mexican politics. The Opposition press are not guilty of great exaggeration in calling it a re- surrection of Constitutional Government. The details of the attack which this Opposi- tion is making upon the Administration, while interesting and even exciting in themselves, are not, after all, of so much significance as the larger fact of the new spirit and method of attack. It is not one chief, nor even one party pit- ted against another, but the Constitution against its perversion. The new movement first took form in the last session of the Mexican Congress, over the question of approving the accounts of the Gonzalez Administration, resulting, as will be remembered, in presenting the ex-Treasurer of the Republic to the Grand Jury, and in bringing grave charges against Gonzalez bhim- self. Many were quick to say, at that time, that this was but a pew move inthe game of personal politics, being only a shrewd maneeu- vie on the part of Diaz to break with his old friend Gonzalez, and to cast discredit upon the jatter’s Administration. But that view is no longer tenable. In the present session of Con- gress the Opposition is as fiercely fighting Diaz as it before fought Gonzalez. The President no longer conceals his enmity to those men who are neither Gonzalists nor Porfirists, but Constitutionalists. He evidently laid his plans betimes to crush out this Opposition, in num- bers so contemptible, in methods and in the popular sentiment back of it for- midable. The first part of his programme was the muzzling of the Opposition press, un- dertaken and measurably accomplished last July. The gain effected in this way was slight, however, as it was offset by the intense popular indignation caused by the arbitrary measure. Having thus, as he thought, deprived the Oppo- sition of the powerful aid of the press, General Diaz went on to detach from his enemy the other ally, which had before lent such important as- sistance, the spectators in the galleries of Con- gress, Overwhelmingly outnumbered on the floor, the Opposition had been able to carry the galleries with them invariably. Now this has all been changed. Admission to the galleries is al- lowed only on tickets, which few but friends of the Government manage to obtain. The secret police swarm in all parts of the old theatre where Congress sits. No sooner does an Oppo- sition deputy rise to speak than he is assailed with cries and epithets from the claque in the so gallery. Nevertheless the fight has been kept up bravely. Bills are introduced, interpellations | are urged, speeches are made, which have no influence upon legislation, it is true, for the Opposition is always voted down fifteen to one, yet which are producing a tremendous effect upon public sentiment, The fearless deputies, Duret, Miron, Vifias, are hailed on all sides, as they walk the streets, as the only true patriots in Congress. "Always outvoted, they are never suppressed. For this Congress, at least, they will remain a thorn in the flesh of the Administration. The points of their attack may be stated briefly. The first was the scandals and abuses | that the recent enormous increase connected with the sales of public lands. the present financial straits of the Administra- tion no source of revenue has been overlooked It is charged, and apparently with some truth, in the sales of land belonging to the _ nation been due to the fact that the ment is in sore need of money, and that it has been disposing of these lands at ruinous rates, often on worthless security, to unprincipled speculators. Certain it is that in some of the States, for example Chihuahua and Zacatecas, a practical injustice on a large scale has been attempted in an order for the resurvey of all private holdings, and the lapsing to the nation of all estates to which the occupants cannot flawless title. Recalling the fact that the first titles were acquired by conquest has Govern show a that the frequeni civil upheavals have been at tended with confiscation and grants, renewed and reversed again and again until the legal status of vast tracts is involved in inextricable confusion ; also, that the measures of area in common use among the farming population are exceedingly vague, and it will be under stood with what indignation and alarm the order for a general resurvey with proof of title is looked upon by those interested The Opposition brought in two measur. s on this subject. The first was a bill enacting that the President should hereafter make no contracts for the sale of public lands without submi‘ting them to the approval of Congress overwhelmingly defeated. interpellation, addressed to the Secretary of the Interior, demanding a list of all the contracts hitherto made. Such a gress, but all debate upon it was cut off by a forced adjournment. The attack was renewed ina demand upon the Secretary of the Treas ury for the authority of law under which the President had of June 22. This interpellation precipitated a furious debate, which resulted, however, in no definite issue. Then came the revival of th old fight over the Gonzalez accounts, October 30, in the shape of specific articles of impeach ment against the ex-President for ' public funds. What may be the motives of these Opposi tion deputies, or what will be the outcome of their efforts, we do not undertake to say. The noteworthy thing is that they are working along a line and in a spirit which give hope of better methods in the Mexican experiment of representative government. phenomenon which cannot fail to be of inte- rest to the student of Mexican politics This was The second was an list was read to Con misuse of They present a THE DISESTABLISHMENT PANIC IN ENG LAND None of the probable results of the extension of the suffrage in England seemed less proba ble last spring than that the question of dises- tablishing the Church would be the leading question in the present canvass. None of the Liberal leaders have pushed it into the fore ground. In fact, most of them something to keep it in the background What little was known of the mind of the new county voters (and it was very little) led to the belief that they would be more attracted by some of the baits thrown out by Mr. Chamber have done In | | the connection between Church and State | lain—such as free education, a graduated taxa tion, the appropriation of land for rosak laborers in small lots, or some measure for the breaking up of large landed estates—than by anything in the nature of an Chureh attack on the As is so often the case in pelitics, howeve it is the The canvass only began in August, been ascertained by the Radical politicians unexpected which bas come to pass and it would now appear to h their own satisfaction at all events, that new voters mast of all desire is th: SEVETANCE « is the question which ts to-day uppermost i: England, and it is infusing a bitterness into t has not b has brought the canvass such as en Witnessed sine INSY; for it low into the arena clergy hig il and, as we all know. wl the clergy handle their opponents, as the become polemical in) politics, they saving is, witl has i fact already reached such a piteh that it has led out gloves. Their violence of languas one of their best Church organs, the London 8; tator,to address a remonstrance to them, entitled the ** Righteousness of Moderation,” which is under the circumstances, somewhat reading. It is neither more nor less tl ul monition addressed to bishops, priests, and deacons against the use of bad language on the political stump. The Bishop of Peterborough perhaps the foremost orator of the English Church, ts remonstrated with for chat } supporters of disestablishment with imap | denev, and malignant ingenuity with ‘‘rancorous hate.” and with concealed ce sire ‘‘to break up the Church into indefit groups,” and ‘‘to produce a crop of futu schisms T) Bishop of W inchester is taken enacted the funding measures | to task for denouncing disestabli . > ; | +? ° , ‘ ] } great national sit Worse still, the Bishop of Durham, better Known as Canon Light i foot scholars in’ En TOOT, One of the foremast land, has to be expostulated with for talking of disestablishment as net ‘‘ only a national dis aster, but also a national crime,” and, as ‘‘a ienation of property, a dis wholesale al ? ‘ Tt gard of and corporate rights, and f nll the tions and feelings as would ‘lacerated a persona na PA » nl such a Vieiavion oO most sacred associa ? eave England na In fact, much of the talk on the Church side is as passionate ] nd bleeding mass, and worldly, as extravagant, as little burdencd with qualifications or reserve, as an ‘* arraign ment” plank in one of our own political plat forms On the side of the extreme Radical politi | cians undoubtedly there is a good deal said and No thing could well be more so than the heaping up of proofs that the peasants of the counties who are now to have the vote, and whos« done to try the souls of the clergymen pro tectors and guides the clergy have been ina special degree for so many centuries, have no attachment to the Church, and as a general | rule no liking for the parson, who is, in their eyes, simply a sort of partnerof the squire, or, in other words, a member of a who preaches down to laboring men, without any caste, share in their joys or sorrows. This appears to be true of that portion of the laboring class who do not care enough for religion to care where they worship. Those who do care have almost universally, especially in the .
Page 12
896 The Nation. fNumber 1063 manufacturing districts, gone over to Dissent, where they are ministered to by a man nearer to themselves in sympathies and ideals, The of the moderate supporters of disestablishment has recently been stated in the London 7imes by Mr. Miall, the son, we be- case lieve, of the former editor of the Noncon- formist, for nearly fifty years perhaps the foremost Dissenting layman in England. Dr. Parker, too, the minister of the great Con- gregational Church in London known as the City Temple, appears in the same number to argue against the Bishop of Peterborough, on the deadening effect of the connection with the State on the Church’s spiritual life. Mr. Miall says that the very strong hold Protestantism and Evangelicalism still have on the people of Eng- land is due to the Nonconformists; that the na- tional Church is every year becoming more and more ‘‘sacerdotal” in its constitution and tenden- cies; that a recent episcopal consecration in St. ’aul’s, at which Canon Liddon preached the ser- mon,recalled *‘the days of Laud”; that these doc- trines and tendencies, from the Nonconformist point of view, offer a barrier to Christian union and codperation, and make the Church of England more and more ‘‘an exclusive sect.” He says that what has created the panic in the episcopal bench is, the discovery that 400 Liberal candidates are pledged to disestablishment, But, he asks— ‘* Why should this great fact excite surprise? Have not the clergy, especially in the rural dis- tricts, always been an effective corps of election agents for the Tory party, and have they not, for the most part. down to the time when the Pri- mate and a few Bishops voted for the Fran- chise Bill, steadfastly opposed every measure of civil and religious freedom which is now inscrib- ed on the statute book? If they had had their way, the Test and Corporation Acts would never have been repealed, Church rates abolished, or the universities thrown open. The most persistent efforts on the part of Dissent- ers were required to get these measures passed, owing to Church obstruction. It is barely seven years since the vehement protest of 12,000 of the clergy prevented Mr. Disraeli from throwing open the parochial churchyards to Nonconformist services, which two years later Mr. Gladstone carried. Dissenters and Liberals also cannot for- get these things. and naturally trace them to the supremacy conferred by law on one particular religious body. ‘Then we are told by the Bishop of Rochester that if the Church is disestablished our villages will become paganized. And this is said bya prelate of the richest Church in the world, Of course it is assumed that Nonconformists are of no account in these countrv districts. Is that so? Dr. Thorold can hardly fail to know that in rural England there is a _ perfect army of Free Church ministers and lay preachers, who, without help from the State, are zea- lously engaged in evangelizing the population. Their teachings may not be of a very refined nature ; but, looked at from the social point of view. they are analogous to, and as effica- cious as, those of the Welsh pastors maintain- ed out of the poverty of their flocks, which enable judges and chairmen of quarter sessions frequently to receive pairs of white gloves in re- cognition of the absence of crime in the Princi- pality. Would rural Wales be paganized by dis- establishment? If not, why should rural Eng- land be ? ** Another point in relation to our agricultural population must have been recently suggested to many of your readers. For generations they have been legally committed to the oversight of the country parsons—the ‘educated gentlemen’ of the district. ‘the peasantry are now enfran- chised, and what is the apparent result? From nearly every county comes the news that they are not only going to _ support the Liberal party, but that disestablishment is the first article of their creed. ‘This re- markable phenomenon admits of various ex- planations. One can be given in the words of the Rev. C. W. Stubbs, vicar of Grandborough, Bucks. ‘ That, as a body,’ he says in his ‘ Vil- lage Politics,’ ‘the country clergy have been benevolent, kindly, and charitable, goes, of course, without saying. Their philanthropic intentions have been for the most part admirable. Coal clubs, blankets, tracts, soup, castor oil, doles of all kinds—these have been giv- en with a free hand. But what has been the net result? I confess myself to some embarrassment when fam asked by Joseph Arch this question: ‘ You clergy of the Established Church have had the agricultural laborers in hand at any rate for 300 years, to do pretty much what you liked with, and what have you made of them?’ Until quite lately could the answer be anything but this—-‘A class of men the stolid helplessness of whose ignorance has become proverbial ’? ” The worst of this terrible indictment is that it is every word true. The connection of the Church with the State in England has pro- duced a body of clergy who have never been equalled in any country, taken as a whole, for culture, learning, and social gifts and graces. But as the agents for the diffusion of religion and morality among the poor, or for the recon- ciliation of religion with social and political progress, they have succeeded no better than, if so well as, the Catholic clergy of the Conti- nent, That the Church will be disestablished by the coming Parliament is, however, very un- likely. It has a powerful hold on the affec- tions of the aristocracy and of the upper mid- dle class. It is, in the minds, too, of a very large body of by no means religious Englishmen, iden- tified, in a manner which most of them would have some difficulty in explaining, with the story of English greatness and glory. And though last not least, the Church is one of the richest cor- porations in the world, and will have on its side, against any attempt to divert its reve- nues from their present uses, all that deep- rooted respect for vested interests which has been so great a power in English politics, and will probably outlive a good many years of the most Radical legislation. HUNTERS AND TROTTERS. Tue horse show which deservedly attracted so much attention last week in this city, has furnished a sort of battle-ground between what we may call two somewhat opposing horse- ideals, the English and the American, The show was got up and is managed in the main by gentlemen who have acquired English tastes about the horse and his uses, and there have consequently been numerous and often some- what bitter complaints about the greater en- couragement given by the distribution of the prizes to the English than the American type of horse—or, to put it concisely, by the preference shown for ‘‘the hunter ” over ‘‘ the trotter.” It issaid, and with a certain show of reason, that the trotter isthe true American horse; that he is one of the glories of the country, and the object of intense popular admiration everywhere; that the amount of money invested in him is enor- mous, and that he is not only American but sui generis. The horses of no other nation can compete with him at all in his own pecu- liar work. In fact, he may, not inaccurately, be called altogether a new type of horse, and, in any horse show held on American soil,ought to be the first object of attention. The hunter, on the other hand, it is said, is an animal which in this country numbers about 1 to every 1,000 of the trotter, and dis- plays his excellence only in a sport indulged in by afew dozen persons of foreign tastes, which the mass of the community look on as ridiculous, while the trotter is seen on every road, and is the pride and deiight of every village, and may be and is owned and enjoyed by tens of thousands who could no more “‘ ride to hounds ” than perform on the tight-rope. The truth of the matter, however, as is so often the case, lies between these two views. The trotter, dear as he is to the American heart, and much pleasure as he gives, and enormous as are the sums expended on him, is _Teally a less useful animal than the hunter. The enormous rewards which the national taste has offered during the last fifty years for breeding him, have really done a great deal to leave us worse provided with light-draught ani- mals than any country in the world. The ef- fect of the cultivation of the trotter on the Ame- rican working horse has been very like what the effect of racing two year-olds would have been in England had it not been neutralized by the demand for hunters. Our pleasure car- riages all over the country, when we leave the light wagon, are horsed by animals not up to their weight, either in size or bone—an evil which is aggravated by the heaviness of the roads. In some parts of the country, New Eng- land, for instance, where double teams are rare nothing is often more painful than the smallness and lightness of ‘‘the family horse,” compared to the size of the ‘carryall,” filled with the family, which he has to draw. Until a very recent period nearly every American horse, sold for light draught at a moderate price, was simply a horse which had failed to develop trotting speed; and as trotting speed was often found in very unpromising frames, and sometimes without any pedigree, breed- ing for points was very little attended to by the farmers who raise most of our horses. Then, too, it must be remembered that capacity to trot one or two miles as fast as an express train, curious and interesting as it is, is really no more useful to the public which does not own trotting horses, or go to see trot- ting matches, than the capacity to gallop a mile in a minute and a half in a flat race— that is, it is only useful so far as it keeps up the popular interest in horses, and causes breeders to produce horses which will have some of the qualities of great trotters. A trotting race, viewed from the utilitarian point of view, is not one whit more respectable than a fox hunt. One is, like the other, an amusement, and, as an amusement, has no ad- vantage over the other except in amusing greater numbers. Indeed, those who wish to see the breed of American horses improved for the ordinary uses of life, and especially for light draught, ought rather to encourage hunters than depre- ciate them. The American horse world is, in other words, far more in need of the hunter type to-day than the trotting type. The Eng- lish are much more indebted to hunting for their good carriage horses than they are to racing. The excellence of a hunter consists in his ability to ‘‘ jump, gallop, and stay,” or, in other words, in great power of limb and great endurance and courage. To breed good hunt- ers is to develop these qualities, and they are the qualities that make the best horse for har- ness as well as for the saddle, That they are
Page 13
BRN an Ae Nov. 12, 1885] The Nation. B9%
used by a small set of pleasure-loving young people in this country to enable them to en- gage in an amusement which the public con- siders ridiculous, does not lessen their value. If it in any degree fosters breeding for bone, and muscle, and short backs, and short legs, it does good service, considering the enor- mous encouragement which the trotting course gives to the ‘‘rangy,” long-legged small horse which one sees in the light wagons of the sporting men. The hunter type of horse isin fact the most useful in the werld for general purposes. It has been developed and is maintained in England by the hunting. On the Continent it receives most of its encourage- ment from the demand for cavalry horses for the huge armies. In this country it has lite- rally until very recently had no encouragement whatever. We ran entirely to trotters until the importation of the Percherons began. This, how- ever, is the otherextreme. It may be said with confidence, either to the American family man who wants a single horse for bis rockaway, or the expressman who wants one for his wagon, or the dyspeptic who wants one to shake his liver up in the Park or on the country roads, or the tourist who wants to drive forty miles a day with his wagon among the hills, that a good hunter, which can carry 175 or 200 pounds across country, is the best kind of horse he can buy, and he must not be deterred by hearing that he is ‘‘quite English, you know.” <A good horse is of no country or clime, and is not identified with any form of government.
ENGLAND: STATESMEN ON THE STUMP. Lonpon, O-tober 27, 1885. GREAT battles now usually begin with what newspaper correspondents call an “artillery duel.” Shots are interchanged at long range by the batteries of cannon, before the masses of infantry are moved up toward one another and the shock of encounter arrives. Similarly, our electoral contest here has opened with dis- charges of heavy shot from leading men on both sides, each answering the other, until the decisive days of polling are at hand, Those days will come about or soon after the 25th of November, lasting on till perhaps the 5th of December. Be- fore the end of November the issue will have been virtually decided, and the curiosity now so intense have received its satisfaction. The chief speakers on the part of the Ministry have been Lord Salisbury—who is for this pur- pose much their best man—Sir Michael Hicks- Beach, Sir Richard Cross, and Lord Randolph Churchill. The ex-Ministry, now in opposition, have been represented by Lords Hartington, Derby, and Rosebery, Mr. Childers, Sir William Harcourt, Sir Charles Dilke, Mr. Trevelyan, and, above all, Mr. Chainberlain. For the last three weeks, few days have passed on which the news- papers have not contained at least one or two speeches by these chieftains, while the number of minor combatants is infinite. At present, in every one of our English and Scottish ccnstitu- encies, over five hundred in number, there are meetings held almost nightly, at which the can- didates and their friends harangue the people. whose appetite for speeches does not seem to grow satiate with the abundance provided. Although the average intelligence and political knowledge of British are still below those of Ame- rican voters, there is less rhetoric and more rea- soning in the election speeches here than seems usual in one of your Presidential or Congressional campaigns. The reasoning may not be good—
very often it is not ; but the speaker professes to | reason, and seldom appeals, except when some religious question is involved, to the imagination or emotions of his audience. To the reader of the public press, nearly all these harangues are drearily dull ; but the masses, enjoying the ex- citement of an election and the sense of power it brings home to them, flock to the meetings and gladly listen to the same platitudes night after night. There are no brass bands, no banners, no processions ; for the two former of these things are forbidden by our election law, and the latter has never come into fashion in England. Hence a meeting is the only means of creating enthusi asm; and in the agricultural districts particu larly, where the laborers have never before en joyed the franchise, we are told that a candidate makes way in pretty exact proportion to the number of small local meetings which he holds. The amount of political education thus given is not to be despised, and patrictic aspirants find therein some consolation for the fatigues they have now to undergo in talking themselves hoarse in small, hot, ill-ventilated rooms, for weeks to- gether. On the other hand, while the number of meetings is three or four times as great as it was thirty years ago, the practice of visiting and so- liciting the vote of individual electors is dying out. The constituencies are now so large that it is scarcely possible to canvass personally any large proportion of them, and the candidate's time is deemed to be better spent in helping to organize ward or district committees and in hold ing evening meetings. In the main debate between the present Minis- try and the Opposition leaders the latter have the advantage of a larger number of well-known names and able orators. The minor members of the Tory Government, pers ns such as Mr. Chap- lin, or even Mr. Stanhope and Sir R. Cross, have no hold at all upon the country, are scantily re- ported, and produce little impression. They have, however, the advantage of harmony among themselves. Taking their cue from Lord Salis- bury, they have all held much the same lan- guage. The defence of the Established Church and of religion which depends upon that Church is their first theme; their second, the faults and follies, more often described as crinies, of the Gladstone Cabinet in its Egyptian policy: their third, the denunciation of the revolutionary schemes and methods of the Radicals. Cautious and temperate reforms they do not object to, and you may read many election addresses or speeches of Tory candidates whose language scarcely differs, so far as positive promises go, from that of the moderate Liberals. Indeed, Lord Salisbury’s programme, set forth in his tirst great speech, included most of Mr. Gladstone's proposals, although somewhat reduced in scope On [reland Conservative speakers are usually si- lent, or confine themselves to such safe generali ties as that the unity of the British Empire must not be destroved. Sometimes they take credit for having dropped the Crimes Act, and reproach the Liberals with their coercive legislation. This is the line taken by a few bolder spirits, follow ing the lead of Lord Randolph Churchill. Tothe great majority it is distasteful. They are secret- ly ashamed of Lord Randolph's behavior toward the Parnellite party, and would gladly give forth the fervid invectives against sedition and spolia tion which sprang formerly to their lips when- ever [rish subjects came up. However, the word bas gone forth not to quarrel with the Irish Na tionalists: it is right in itself, whether or not it is consistent; and it is pretty generally obeyed by Tory speakers great and small. Hence, as the Liberals have also no motive for saying any more about Ireland than they are forced to, and really do not quite know what to say, the whole topic of Ireland figures very little in the oratory | take the field in this campaign of either side, That the most serious and press ing of all our problems, and the one which fo reign nations watch with most curiosity, should be the one least discussed at this great crisis, may seem strange, indeed. Butit istrue. Every one fears the subject and hates the subject: it is away by common though tacit consent While harmony, at least external harmony reigns among the Tories, the Liberal ranks divided by a serious schism. There have always been two wings in that party—an advanced ot Radical group, and a moderate (now often called Whig) group. During Mr. Gladstone's late Goy ernment the tendencies to disunion werp 1 strained by his authority and popularity, and by the disposition of all sections of the party to fall into line for the sake of supporting its leaders against the attack: of an angry Opposition, Now however, that the Liberals are out of power the int. My Chamberlain was the tirst eminent politician t He hasb centrifugal forces operate with less rest
| an extremely telling speaker. Without an in } gination or giftof touching the emotions « parable to those of Mr. Gladstone and M: Bright, he is net inferior to them in the skill of putting a point clearly and forcibly and ps larly, so that it shall come right home to tx minds of those who listen or read, In a seri highly finished orations delivered in the sout! middle, and north of England, as well as in Soot land, he has unfolded a programme of na} hensive changes which has fascinated the masses alarmed the timid holders of property, and mad himself extremely popular with the more ad vanced, which is also by far the more numerous section of the Liberal party. He ts now the most conspicuous figure in the party after Mr. Glad stone, and in some quarters fully as influent because he is stillin middle life, while the cares of the nominal leader cannet be a verv long one Already many of the new candidates are profess- ing their allegiance to him, and commending themselves bv the real with which they advocat his platform. It goes beyond that set forth by Mr. Gladstone chiefly in two poiats, viz.: gratui tous education in elementary schools,and the sug gestion that local boards should have the power of taking land from its proprietors (possibly at less price than such land would fetch in open market) for the purpose of letting it out in small allotments to the rural laborers—a class whose | condition certainly calls for remedial measures. He has also advocated a graduated income tax and the payment of members of Parliament, but the latter of these proposals bas not been pressed, and a graduated succession duty will probably be accepted asa substitute for the former rhe most prominent representative of the other Liberal wing is Lord Hartington, who, as leader of the Liberals in opposition from 1875 till 1580, has been long regarded as Mr. Gladstone's heir apparent in the leadership of the party. Hé has intimated his dissent from several of Mr. Cham berlain’s views, and is indeed so far from being | a Radical that many Tories profess to hope he will some day move toward their ranks. No- thing is less likely, for he is a Whig by strong family as well as personal associations, with a | hearty dislike of the new Toryism invented by Disraeli, which Lord R. Churchill has been oecu- pied in rehabilitating. A position generally simi- lar to Lord Hartington’s is taken up by Lord Derby and Mr. Childers; it is that which most of the upper-class Liberals would like to hold, were they not afraid of being denounced as ‘*weak-kneed.” But the most powerful exponent of this more cautious policy is Mr. Goschen, A\l- though his dislike of the extension of the house- hold suffrage to counties prevented him from be- ing in Mr. Gladstone’s Cabinet, he has remained a member of the party, usually voting with it,
Page 14
398 The Nation [Number 1063 but exercising an iodependent aud sometimes severe crititism. The powerful election speeches he has been lately delivering have been directed chiefly against Mr. Chamberlain’s propositions, which he attacks from the point of view of a cautious economist, not always disapproving the ends which the latter seeks, but doubting the efficacy or condemning the dangers involved in the means toward those ends. Mr. Chamberlain and Sir C. Dilke reply by complaining of such criticism as cold and burren, and intimate that its author can hardl; be deemed a Liberal. Thus we see a sort of triangular duel in progress : Lord Salisbury and his friends are firing into Mr. Chamberlain ; the Jat‘er, while returning their fire, is maintaining a not less warm combat of his own with Mr. Goschen. The great, though dissimilar, powers of these two men, and the probability that if Mr. Gladstone returns to office he will invite both of them to join his Ministry, make their strife, which bas been conductei so far witnout personal acrimony, very interesting. It is the most noticeable feature of the present campaign, and may possibly foreshadow strug- gles inthe next Liberal Cabinet, perhaps to be followed by an open breach in the Liberal party. Impartial observers, while they regret that the Radical leaders should seein unwilling to accept as ally a man so capable as Mr. Goschen and so earnest a reformer in certain directions, declare that the latter would consult his own reputation and strengthen his future if he would put for- ward posi ive solutions for the social and moral evils that surround our poorer classes, instead of mainly occupying himself with destructive criti- cisms of the schemes of others. It might be concluded from the contents of our newspapers and the multitude of meetings and speeches all over the country, that the nation was ina state of bigh tension. So far as I can judge this iz not the case. The temperature will rise when the day of polling approaches, but I doubt whether even then it will reach that of 1880. In the general election of that year both the people and the candidates were thor- oughly excited. The enthusiasm for Mr. Glad- stone on the one side, for Lord Beaconsfield on the other, was intenze. Great principles were deem- ed to be at stake. Great and splendid results were anticipated by cither side from their vic- tory. Now, although the people flock to meetings and cheer lustily for their chiefs, one can per- ceive that they are not carried away by any tide of feeling. Many candidates have confessed to me that they found it hard to work themselves up to the point necessary to deliver a passionate declamation, and those particularly who stood in 1880 wish they could recover the élan which car- ried them along inthat year. 1 do not mean that there is » pathy, hke that which caused the Libe- ral defeat in 1874. The elections are being well fought on Loth sides, with organizations more perfect than ever before, with more speaking and less expenditure of money (for our new law against bribery and treating is very stringent), with an interest in the issue on the part of the new voters in the counties, particularly the agri- cultural laborers, exceeding what had been hoped for. But secret misgivings as to their strength and as to the wisdom of their Irish policy blunt the zeal of the Tories; while the Li- berals, remembering the lamentable errors of their Government in Ezypt aud Sudan, and contrast- ing the end of tbis dying Parliament with its be- ginning, cannot recover the joyous hopefulness of 1830. The appearance in tho field of Mr. Gtadstone, promised about the lich of November, may perhaps warm the feelings of friends and foes. L # PRINCE WALDEMAR’'S MARRIAGE. Paris, October 23, 1885. WE always feel a little shy about speaking of people whom we are fond of, and whose life has been to a certain extent interwoven with our own; we feel this embarrassment even when we have nothing to say but what is pleasant and agreeable. I am, therefore, obliged to make a certain effort to speak of the marriage of the oluest daughter of the Duc de Chartres with Prince Waldemar of Denmark. [ feel, ho.vever, a little encouraged by the thought that the Duc de Chartres bears an historic name, that ail the papers will be full of the details of this mar- riage, and that [ cannot commit anything ap- proaching an indiscretion in saying a few words on an event which belongs to newspaper noto- riety. I feel also encouraged by the remem- brance that the Duc de Chartres bas only friends in America. He undertook the defence of the American Union, with his brother, the Comte de Paris, and his uncle, the Prince of Joinville, at a time when the cause of the Union was l- most despaired of in Europe. He obeyed the chi- valrous instincts of his nature in the United States as he did in Italy, when he fought by the side of the French army on the staff of King Vic- tor Emmanuel; as he did afterward, in the un- happy war of 1870, when he rushed first to Paris on the 7th of September, and, not being allowed toremain there by the Government which called itself the Government of the National Defence, he concealed himself, assumed the name. of Ro- bert le Fort, made the campaign of France, and deserved to receive the cross of the Legion of Ho- nor from tbe hands of Gambetta. I hope I shall not be deemed a flatterer if Isay that the Duc de Chartres is essentially a chivalrous character. It seems as if all the chivalrous traits of his family had, by a sort of selection, concentrated in him; he is ardent in patriotism, in friendship, gene- rous, open-hearted. When Marseilles was in terror, during the last visitation of the cholera, he left Paris, went to Marseilles, entered every hospital, comforted the dying and the living. His character belongs to the public, and I only repeat here what everybody knows. I will only say a few words of his wife, the Duchess, who is the daughter of the Prince de Joinville. Sheisa devoted wife, a devoted mother, a devoted friend; she never allowed her personal senti- ments to stand between her husband and his na- tural or even self-imposed duties. She bas been well rewarded in her children. The eldest daughter, who was married yesterday to Prinze Waldemar of Denmark, has all the animation and spirit of her father, softened by the grace and dignity of her mother. This marriage was interesting in many re- spects. The Orleans family had not for a long time formed new ties with the royal families of Europe. It stood a little isolated, having none of the advantages of a reigning dynasty, and pre- serving its high position among the royal fami- lies by the mere force of tradition, as well as by the excellence of its members. As Prince Walde- mar is only a cadet, he bad to find his bride in her own country, and therefore the marriage had to take place in republican France. The reception given some time ago to the King of Spain in Pa- ris has not been yet forgotten, and, though itis certain to me that on an occasion like this the French Radicals would have remained quiet, and would not have tried to make any scandalous de- monstration, the diplomatic world became un- easy, and some of those who would have liked to assist at the ceremony at Eu were prevented, and followed the old proverb: *‘ In doubt, abstain.” The young Prince of Denmark is connected with the greatest houses of Europe—with England, with Russia, One of his sisters is the Princess | of Wales, another is the Empress of Russia; one of his brothers is on the throne of Greece; one of bis sisters is married to the Duke of Cumberland. {ft was expected that the Empress of Russia would come to Eu, but at the last moment she could not make the journey. Russia was repre- sented by the Grand Duke Alexis, a brother of the Emperor; the King of the Belgians, an uncle of the young Princess, did not come in person, and sent his brother, the Comte de Flandres. The father of Prince Waldemar, the King of Den- mark, did not come in person. as there is at the present moment a Parliamentary crisis in his kingdom; but the Queen of Denmark came, She wanted to attend her son’s marriage, and she was, in fact, the only crowned head present at the ceremony. The Prince and Princess of Wales also went to Eu with their children. The Prince is very popular in France and often comes to Paris, though not as often as inold times. The marriage was iuteresting in another re- spect: it was a marriage between a Catholic Princess and a Protestant Prince, ‘These mixed marriages, as they are called in France, have never been favored by the Catholic Church. When Louis Philippe was ou the throne, his son, the Duke of Orleans, married a Protestant Princess, Helen of Mecklenburg ; but Louis Phi- lippe was a liberal: his régime represented the principles of complete political and civil liberty. The Catholic Chirch regarded the marriage of the Duke of Orleans with great repugnance ; it has always tried to establish the principle that the marriage ceremony could not be celebrated in the Catholic rite if there was not a written promise, signed by the husband and the wife, that the children born of the union should be brought up in the Catholic faith. This obliga- tion has, to my knowledge, hindered many mixed marriages, as many people are unwilling to make such a solemn promise, and to take an engage- ment concerning unborn children. The rule is at variance with the tradition of the beginning of the century: from 1800 to 1848 there was no promise made in writing concerning the future children, and it was generally accepted by all parties that the sons should have the religion of the father, the daughters the religion of the mother. To give an example: the Duc de Bro- glie married the daughter of Mme. de Staél ; his sons, the present Duc de Broglie and the Abbé de Broglie, are Catholics ; his daughter, who died a few years ago, Mme. d’Haussonville, was a Protestant, and remained a Protestant to the end of her life. She was married to M. d’Haus- sonville, who was Catholic ; his son, the present Comte d’Haussonville, is Catholic ; his daughter was educated in the Protestant religion, and was even for some time among the Protestant dia- conesses (the name assumed by certain Protes- tant ladies who do not marry, and who devote themselves to good works). It is rather singular that the Catholic Church became much more exacting, in this question of the mixed marriages, after the Revolution of 1848. The Second Empire, though it did much indirectly against the temporal power of the Papacy, favored all the enterprises of the Church inside of France; and among these, the abandon- ment of a tradition which gave to the sons the religion of the fathers, to the daughters the re- ligion of the mothers. It allowed the establish- ment of the custom which now prevails, and which exacts a promise from both parents to have the children educated in the Catholic reli- gion. A prince of Denmark, belonging to the Lutheran Church, could not, by the laws ot the kingdom, educate his sons in any other but the Lutheran Church, without cutting himself and his sons off from the line of the succession. Prince Waldemar could make no promises con- trary to the Constitution of the country which
Page 15
- eer areneary Nov. 12, 1885] The Nation.
399
—<———= = . ! is under the sceptre of his father. A negotiation | study, is generally frank reminiscence, and thus | ble destiny. Most of the other nations—Italy was opened with the Vatican on the occasion of in the two-score canvases, each four feet high, | Spain, Germany, and the Low Countries—have the marriage of Princess Mary of Orleans with which composed the exibition, we could fairly | a creater natural aptitude for art than Franc Prince Waldemar, through the naturai channel of the Archbishop of Paris, Monseigneur Guivert, who entered upon it in a large and liberal spirit. The Pope, who has shown, since his accession to the throne of Saint Peter, great moderation of character, and who has done so much in various countries to make the relations of Church and State easier, responded readily to this spirit ; and the negotiation ended with a tacit convention, in virtue of which, though the sons of Prince Wal- demar would be Protestants, the Catholic Church would celebrate the marriage ceremony. There were, in consequence, two marriage cere- monies celebrated yesterday at the Chateau d’Eu: the Catholic ceremony in the private chapel of the castle, the Lutoeran ceremony in a drawing- room prepared for the occasion. I am sorry not to understand Danish, for the Danish parson must have been very elcquent, judging from the tears which were shed by the Queen of Den- mark, and even by the young bridegroom. The Catholic ceremony was performed by Monsei- gneur d’Hulst, a friend of the Orleans family, the son of one of the ladies-in-waiting of Queen Ma- rie Am¢che. I leave it to the newspapers to de- scribe the procession of the princes, who went first to the chapel, then to the Lutheran oratorio; the brilliant array of uniforms and of dresses in the long gallery which stretches bet ween these two places. After the religious ceremonies, all the company went to three banqueting halls. There was a large table for the princes aud princesses, who were, I believe, 37 in umber: there were in all 150 people seated at table. The young bride made atterward what is called the cercle : she joined all the guests in the long gallery. She was very charming in her wedding gown, trem- bling with a natural emotion at the idea of leav- ing her family. She had a kind word for every one; she kissed all the ladies, and allowed all the gentlemen to kiss her hand. And then she dis- appeared, followed by the warmest wishes of all those who were present.
ART NOTES FROM PARIS. Paris, October 22. Tue dead season for the public is here the pro- ducing season in art, and hundreds of uneasy ambitions are now straining their efforts for great effects to be admired and judged in the coming displays. This work-a-day term is not without its minor exhibitions, which have their interest for those who want to be beforehand with the verdict of the morrow, and study the promise of youthful talents in the bud. Last week the landscapists of the future, lads of great expectation from some forty French departments, competed for the Troyon prize. Constant Troyon: an unhappy, grudging, and miserable spirit, left his savings ostensibly for the rescue of worthy young animal-painters from misery, but really to secure the resonance of his own name through the time to come, and avenge the neglect of the first half of his artistic career. The style he in- vented—that is to say, animal art considered not anatomically, but in combination with the most advanced ideas of plein-air and landscape en- vironment—is understood to be the guiding in- fluence in the works to be judged, and the young man most hopeful of the Troyon purse is he who can most successfully subdue bis love of animals and consider them as atmospheric ‘ effects” or “envelopments.” Accordingly there was but little menagerie-study or comparative osteology in the forty-four fables we have just been con- templating in the pavilion Decaen of the Institut. The subject was the Wolf and the Lamb. The art of young men, even their sincerest nature-
judge what proportion of the rising young paint- ers adhere to Corot, how many of them emulate the more difficult Rembrandtism of Rousseau, how many affect the emblematic elegance of Francais, and how many can carry their beliefs away over to the transcendental and stained-glass dissected work of Harpignies and Puvis de Chavannes. As for the animals, they were either abstract and heraldic, or toylike and stuffy; it was a sign that not one of the essays showed the slightest imitation of Troyon himself. Has his full-bodied Decamps manner of painting ceased to please / We had Egyptian sand ravines, closed in with a threatening monumental Anubis-like wolf, domi nating a pale Ammoen-like lamb, and very gran diose and fatal-looking, hardly fit to remind <Esop of his native Phrygia; then there was the favorite chalk scenery of the environs of Paris, with lambs drinking fortuitously at gutters in the gypsum quarries; twilight among French poplars; rivulets spinning exag geratedly over concrete rocks, effects of land scape gardening stolen bodily from the Buttes Chaumont or the cascade in the Bois. On the whole, the American visitor went away with the notion that forty chance students in the United States would have collected an exhibition having fewer affectations and rather deeper percepticns of nature, The No. 42, which obtained the prize, and enabled its author to study for certain years at the expense of the late Troyon, was a tall bower of gray Corot-like saplings, designed from birch trees and colored (to be more fashionable from water-willows, amid which the real inci- dents of the subject, the animals and the stream let, were made as inconspicuous as possible. In no one of tbe efforts was there the slightest idea of carrying the animal expression out to an tlatness ‘impressions ” amusing and piquant suggestiveness, as Desportes or Oudry would have done in designing a set of La Fontaine tapestries. The picture that got the prize was a landscape showing the side of nature just now in the mode. But the the case, in illustrating this class of animal fa bles, would seem to be to make animals that look as if they could talk and deliver shrewd and concentrated apolougue. Is it quite the thing to award prizes to essays which most carefully over look their own subject ? The system of competition with purses, form- ing a vast hot-bed apparatus, is an interesting study for strangers in France, because here it is more thoroughly and authoritatively applied than in any other country. The care cf the Govern- ment is extended to every form of art, and t) smallest rat of the dancing school feels berself sustained and consecrated by State approval as she kicks up to the high bar or sketches out on her meagre face a convulsive smile under tor- ture. In the fine arts proper the machinery of encouragement and selection is so complete that it applies to the most distant French province, and the remotest corner is fairly constrained to yield up its speck of golden talent to the test, lke the sweepings of a goldsmith’s floor. M Kaempfen, Director of the Beaux-Arts, obedi- ently travelled down to Lyons the other day, to confer the prize on young M. Appian, securing to that youth a career in Paris, and afterward perhaps in Rome. Under this form of conscrip- tion—* nay, for be saith, compel them to come in”—Paris has become the university city of art that it is, and acquired all the importance of a chief arbiter of taste, besides providing for its opulent commerce in art, its annual export to the tune of millions, and its large home consump- tion. It is so much forcing and nursery-planting on the part of the nation, rather than any invinci- very necessity of
The intellect of cially creative the critical this it has always excelled rather in race has never been espe in refining on the ideas of others, in taste, in elegance in the Literal sense of the word That it has come to be s kind of forcing of fats famous a producer is a a mnost frugal an 1 minute improvement of every germ of creative principle produced by the soil. The nineteenth century will maybe never know what it has lost by the mere hap, the mere arbitrary maintenance of the centre of gravity of art in this emphatically tem perate zone ; whereas, if the preponderance of power had been destined to fall among the warm Italy and Spain have been designated te er and fruitier populations of future Such as it ows What can might our age time by art-works of fire and tlame is, the French nation as an artist sh be done ] tribute and genius by strength of will, as distinct from at The forcing apparatus is so complete that an to speak just and sculpture galleries, inspection turns one giddy Not now of picture of wea pons at the Artillery and armor at the Invalides of engravings and coins at the National Library, of furniture and domestic history at Cluny mat ters of which there are equivalents in most Eu ropean capitals—it is well to note the strictly school-room furniture kind f nerds nothing provided for the artist, a assistance which is of no cost, to bring it together but intelh gence and appreciation, and which can be cheap ly duplicated in newer countries, The collecti of plasters at the Beaux-Arts School certainly numbers thousands, and ranges in size from the f the Monte of a corner of the giant horseman Cavallo, and a copy Parthenon, with columns, me topes, triglvphs, and frieze complete—and so tall that to receive the i floor of the courtvard has been excavated down to the smallest casts hase from antique bronzes ; and the same institution shelters in its library every authority, every student Xtant important structures at Rome, the print, every photograph a wlels of the other can want, Roman theatres, The beautiful with clay nx circuses, and
cl Pincian, also contains a most veral Jection of casts, ample for all ordinary purposes of stady, and really bring ing back ancient civilization in quite a freshly convincing manner when seen against the ex- quisite garden views which fill the windows For Gothi lection of and Renaissance sculpture, the col t the anil almost a satiety Trocadéro is a revelation and these, taken with the moulding-reom of the Louvre casts a . Where an artist can buy any antique for a trifle, form a wealth which simply makes the student a millionaire of ideas, if is here, and for What educa l tional duty can be so obvious to the American } t world knows since all that the lim it 1s only to ask and have. hilant ropist—though this is quite by-the-by to he purpose of the present letter—as the forma tion of a society for the reduplication of these sets in half-a-dozen centres of the United States, with the understanding that the collections sha}} be complete, since the lesson lies in the complete- ness? The opportunity is so pat and so easy~ corresponding to what it would be, in hterature, if the curiosities of every famous library, Vati- ean uncials and British Museum illuminations and all, could be cheaply and adequately ac qvired in facsimile, so as to leave librarians of the New World with nothing to sigh for. Really, there is nothing else to be had for money w. erein money goes so far: antique civilization presented entire, in its most easily comprehended form, for a few thousand dollars. With such prepared food and knowledge made digestible is the student here stuffed, the inten-
Page 16
400 The Nation. [Number 1063 tion being that he shall take an invincible bent toward the academic form of art; and the test and outcome is the competition for the Prize of Rome. One would say that the Government had sworn the pupil should never hear of Velasquez, but should be cajoled into thinking the Madonnas of Giddoand the Romans of Hannibal Scratchey to be life’s chief boon,’ The plaster-cast educa- tion, admirable and indispensable as a detail, is perhaps made rather too much of a panacea, and finally affects the learner as eel pasty affected the appetite of a certain historic squire. The modern mind, at all events, is pulling away from the prescribed regimen with all the strength of its growth. The ambitious young artist of now- adays is constantly thinking over his beloved puzzles—landscape environment, how to make your figure proclaim the conditions of the open- air light which plays upon it, the values of ob- jects in half-lights and cross-lights, and other ef- fects demanded by the more subtle curiosity of our time. He acceptsthe education of the Beaux- Arts School because it is gratuitous, but he isa rebel and a Rousseaulater at heart. In the porch of the School, Ingres, with his Institut uniform and his screed of ‘‘ Goud drawing, the probity of art,” affects him with nausea, and, in the lecture- room, Delaroche’s hemicycle chills his marrow, while Ingres’s ‘‘ Triumph of Romulus” curdles his blood with disgust. Going thither to hear a lecture of Taine’s, I met one of the brightest of the pupils on the bridge, and on being asked if he was not bound to the course on the Philoso- phy of A&sthetics, he made a nique with his fin- gers and nose for all reply. While pursuing the studies, while being winnowed through a series of tests and moral sieves for admission to the course for the Prize of Rome, and when actually competing in his prison for that prize, and after- ward when kicking his heels in the joy of living in Italy at somebody else’s expense, the indus- trious apprentice is a hypocrite and a time- server, angrily cursing the whole bundle of in- fluences that has lashed him into obedience. The end of it is, that he probably does take on more or less of the fashion he deprecates, and becomes for life a mere “‘Italian”—some kind of a Bou- guereau or Cabanel. One of the standard figures of French ridicule is the Prize Student, with all his bubbles pricked,settling down at Nice to give lessons in water-color to English misses. The late exhibition of works competing for the Prize of Rome betrayed in distinct tints the ano- maly just pointed out. The Government in these affairs resembles the English tutor in ‘‘ Lakmé ”: ‘* When I undertook to form these children I was told to be apprehensive; I am paid to be appre- hensive; 1 am apprehensive.” The young French pupil, rejoicing in all his colossal igno- rance of ancient history, is made to paint an- tique Romans, extracted from the historian whom he calls, as De Quincey instructs us, Teet Leeve; these Romans, by the way, are to be made tolook as much like Greeks as possible, and if the composition bears some general resemblance to an Egyptian relief it is the more likely to get the prize. Every sentiment of out-of-doors, the trembling of outlines in the mist, the tossing of the breeze, the trembling of the light, is to be ex- cluded—these dangerous realities might lead to Corot and Millet, if not to Manet. It is a great day, the prime event of the dead season, when the ten pupils are delivered from their prisons, and the fruit of their seventy days’ seclusion comes to judgment. [ had lately the curiosity to inspect these cells, where the competitors prepare their themes in seclusion; a set of cloisters completely unknown to the public, and quite inaccessible except to pupils of the school, They form a row in the southern wing of the Beaux-Arts Palace, remote from the river-side and from the school-rooms. A guardian, sitting on the steps, was peaceably feeding a nest of young sparrows, his cares being over in the completion of the course for the year. When in function it is his duty to search the pu- pils as they enter or leave, to see that they carry in no privately-prepared life-studies, and to pre- vent all possibility of their spying on each other’s work, The rooms, resembling the dormitories of a convent, are bleak in the extreme: mere closets, stone-paved, with a chair and an easel for all furniture, and each provided with a com- mon window which affords none of the conve- nience of an ordinary studio light. The walls of the corridor are scrawled with painted or char- coal sketches, contributed by successive dynas- ties of pupils in the leisure of luncheon-time; there is at present noticeable a clever sketch by Courtois, and several dashes by appreciative friends at the tempting Aztec profile of Roche- grosse, whose ‘‘ Andromache” and ‘ Jacquerie” have now raised him tothe first rank of modern promise. The competition brings together youths from every section of the country, and it is strange if there are not found among the pu- pils types of the best kinds of picturesque- ness now left in Europe, from woolly Gascons and Auvergnats to yellow-haired Normans whose ancestors were Vikings. These specimens of the elect, each the hope of his village, have been tried out by many a fierce struggle before being admitted to endeavor for the Prize of Rome, Academic drawings in the evening classes, academic paintings under the day-professor, groups sketched from dictated historical subjects ; and the readiness of the pupil at historical group- ing must be proved by the very conditions of the great trial, which demand an impromptu sketch, thrown off on a paper without assistance from models, to be the basis of the painting put into competition. These sketches were each exhibited under the proper painting, on the exposure of the prize-themes. They are more summary than one would expect them to be, being the merest dia- grams; but they fix the arrangement of the com- position, no change being allowed in the cast of the figures or their relative position, though the action of a leg or an arm may be altered with- out blame. This year’s exhibition of subjects for the Prize of Rome was more conspicuous than usual for the desperate endeavor of some of the students to protest against academic art as such, and to bring in impressional painting by the head and shoulders. The real sympathy of the artist, if his knitted jacket could be unbuttoned and his heart laid bare, would be found to he for lines of art quite inadmissible in the illustration of Teet Leeve or Plutarch. What he really would enjoy competing for would be something like the hum- ble prize of Troyon, above described, or like the D’Attainville prize for classical landscape, for which M. Buffet has just (October 21) success- fully tried, with its benefit of 2,100 francs. But the Roman prize overshadows all others, with its governmental sanction, its fame and publicity, and its four years’ privilege of liberty and travel. The subject this year was Themistocles taking refuge with Admetus, a composition requiring four figures; the last I saw competed for, C2di- pus at Colonos, also required four persouages, and the pay of that many models out of the poor students’ allowance. What was curious was the determined manifestation by several of the pupils of principles outside of academic art. M. Thomas, for instance, was evidently in love with Japanese art; he arranged a sunny out-of-win- dow kind of vista, for which he could have got no warrant in the narrow casement of his prison, and into this he painted a fancy of Japanese plum-blossoms and the like, arranging his figures as a frame around this decoration, wherever they would go in easiest and not make any noise. He got a second prize for his pains, which in- cluded a purse of a thousand francs, derived from the Cambacérés foundation. M. Tollet, enamored of the cave-light affected by the paint- er Henner, a heresy very distasteful to the Aca- demicians, used this trick as nearly as he could remember it for two of his figures, but at that point his recollections failed him, and he painted the other two persons in ordinary daylight. He was indulged, after all, with a third prize. The lucky man of the year, M. Axetelle, pupil of Géréme, was the most entirely devoid of original- ity, and the most completely bathed in sopho- moric erudition, of all of them; in addition to his official first prize and purse, he benefits by an annual gift of three thousand francs, a fourth of the foundation created by Mme. Leprince. The remaining seven canvases were very much alike —groups that would have been praised by David and Benjamin West, feebly accentuated with bric-A-brac out of the museums of antique bronzes. Such were the features of a competi- tion at which every art-student in France laughs in the irritation of an uneasy scepticism, and to which in due time he presents himself with a beating heart. It ought at least to be granted that the prize founded by Colbert and Louis XIV.., if it fails to create genius and sometimes throttles it, is useful in keeping down insanities, and holding art to its grammar and its eternal intelligibulity and reasonableness. Where would painting go to if it quite forgot its classical de- rivation, and if its Olympic races were governed by the Manets and the Courbets ? In nothing, by the way, is the classical direc- tion of art more justified than by ceiling decora- tions and other kinds of mural painting, in which France seems at present to hold the lead incon- testably. The ceiling of the public crush-room of the French Theatre, just painted by young Guillaume Dubufe, is an illustration. Nothing has yet been found to combine so well with archi- tecture as the classically treated form of allego- rical art. I have seen in California a splendid dining-room of which the panels were decorated with thunderstorms and mountain landscapes; but, though they were executed by an artist of talent, Thomas Hill, they only succeeded in giv- ing everybody colds and suggesting draughts. The ease and grace of French wall-decorators, even when they are second-class men, are incon- testable in the specialty. The most perfect piece of daring in this line is the ceiling of the Eden Theatre, where clowns, circus-queens, and ballet- dancers are careering with an audacity mixed with elegance that has certainly not been sur- passed since the plays of Aristophanes. Only a century where frivolity is raised to an art and analyzed into a science could produce a masterly cobweb of this description, wherein nonsense is sternly divested of its impertinences and reduced to its eternal and delicious luws. Dubufe’s ceil- ing shows a cloud of shadowy spirits supporting the night-world, over which rises the naked form of Truth; Comedy and Tragedy, as little mis- chievous spirits, are pulling back her veil, Trage- dy being armed with a stage dagger and Comedy bearing a ball-room mask. Two modern ladies lean on a railing and look up at the vision. The composition, without any deep merits, is com- pletely decorative and satisfactory. And it is the direct outcome, to specify one of its qualities, of the system of plaster casts and antique docu- ments and themes of Greek art which is here dinned into everybody's head with ali the em- phasis of governmental authority. The artist was steeped in official classicism long before he was born, being the outcome of a dynasty of | painters of the elegant and the ornamental; his father, Edouard, was the painter of the ‘ Prodi- gal Son,” owned by Mr. A. T. Stewart and burned in America; his grandfather, Claude
Page 17
Nov. 12, 1885] The Nation. 401 the last present made to his audiences by the painter director of the Francais, the late M. Per- rin; in 1879 he conferred on them the painting of the theatre ceiling proper, by Mazerolle, rep- resenting the principal groups and situations of the old French drama. Correspondence. PROTECTION OF THE YOSEMITE VALLEY. To THE Eprror OF THE NATION : Sir: A recent visit to the Yosemite Valley ena- bles me to corroborate the testimony of Mr. Ed- wards, in the Nation of October 8, concerning the condition of the country surrounding the valley. If more authoritative testimony were needed, it is presented, in an official manner, by the Yosemite Valley Commissioners in their re- port for 1883-84, which gives a detailed descrip- tion of the devastation now going on in that re gion, and illustrates, ina forcible manner, how much more promptly members of Congress will respond to a personal appeal in favor of a private interest than they will to the request of a State or community to be protected against the en- croachments of lawless invaders. Permit me to make a single extract from the report of Mr. W. H. Hall, State Engineer, of May 20, 1882: “If it be asked, What is necessary to preserve the Yosemite Valley pruperty from deteriora- tion ? we have these answers: ‘* First. The control of the mountain watershed 3 tributary to the valley streams, to prevent the \ destruction of timber and vegetation generally thereon. **Second. The regulation of the use of the floor of the valley and its immediate surroundings, in order that the verdure be not altogether trampled out of existence, or useful vegetation supplanted by that less desirable but more able to resist the influences of civilized occupancy. ‘Third. The counteracting of natural dete- riorative action to be found in the movement of its waters: the ‘improvement’ of its streams. ‘*Tho Yosemite Grant does not cover nearly all the watershed of the valley, but, on the contrary, while according to the terms of the grant it ex- tends to a line drawn around the valley at an average distance of one mile from its edge, the real mountain basins from which drain the waters that constitute to most people the great charm of the place, are altogether outside of the grant, and the rim of high land contained within it is composed, for the most part, of rocky slopes that incline directly into the valley, or to its walls, and not to the cations and higher valleys from which issue the waters of the falls. ‘** According to the best information available at this time, the entire watershed srea of the Merced River, inclusive of the grant with the valley, east of a line drawn trom ridge to ridge, across the gorge, at a point on the spur just be- low the Cascade Falls, is about 558 square miles; or, in round numbers, 229,000 acres. Only about 30,500 acres of this territory are included in the grant as it now exists, leaving 198,5C0 acres which drain into the valley. ** This watershed line should form the limits of the grant.” That the area covered by the existing Yosemite Park is too small, is further emphasized by the fact that the sheep men are devastating conside- rable portions of country which one is obliged to traverse in order to get from one point to an- other within the park itself. In order to reach Cloud’s Rest from the Nevada Fall our party had to force its way through an immense herd of sheep. The remedy for the state of affairs here de- scribed is very simple. If Congress will devote a few minutes to the favorable consideration of the question at its next session, there is evidence that the California authorities will complete the work by a forcible ejectment of the invaders. Very respectfully yours, 8, BERKELEY, Cat., October 29, 1885, painted nymphs and odalisques. This ceiling is | a reform and reduction of our existing tariff, FREE TRADE IN SOUTH CAROLINA. To THE Eprror oF THE NaTION: Str: As you will doubtless have observed in the News and Courier of yesterday, the friends of * free trade” and “ tariff reform met in Co- lumbia on Saturday toform a State organization. This meeting was called by Col. John J. Dargan, the brother of one of our most intelligent and in- dependent Congressmen. The immediate object of the call, besides organizing a club, was to choose representatives to attend the Tariff Re- form Convention, to meet in Chicago next week. The notice of the meeting was brief, and but few of the papers had given it any attention, and as a consequence it was not so numerously attended as could Lave been desired ; but still, a considera- ble number of prominent gentlemen were pre sent, anil many others. including Governor Thompson, Senator Hampton, and Colonel Tren holm, sent in their adhesion to it. This meeting is the first organization of the kind formed in this State since the war. South Carolina will be remembered as always among the strongest free-trade States prior to the war, and if the attention of the people can be detached from the eternal race question, and led to take an interest in the question of the tariff, 1 have little doubt she will at no distant day resume ber old position, for the interests of a very large majority of her people are still clearly on the side of free trade. It is not to be denied, however, that cer tain interests in the State are in favor of protec- tion. A few hundred rice-growers in the lower part of the State insist on taxing the millions of rice consumers in the country to the extent of two and a quarter cents per pound for all the rice they eat; and some—though not all gaged in our important ‘infant industry,” cot ton manufacturing, are so ignorant as to think they still need protection at home, instead of having the markets of the world thrown open to them. But the question of the tariff not having been an issue before the people, and not having been discussed for so long atime, there is a vast amount of ignorance on the subject. of the people or of our public men have given any attention to it, and consequently their views, even where they Lave any, are very crude The principal discussion in the meeting at Co- lumbia was as to whether the club should be or ganized as a ‘Free Trade” or a ‘Tariff Reform” Club. Col. Dargan strongly advocated the former, and carried his point Asa matter of policy Iam inclined to think this was a mis- take, for no doubt many would accept “tariff reform” who either do not believe in absolute free trade, or who do not regard this as a practi- cal question, as we must doubtless continue to levy duties on imports for the sake of Govern- ment revenue. I should have been content as a beginning with an organization similar to that recently organized at New Haven by those emi- nent Connecticut economists, David A. Wells, Prof. Sumner, and others, declaring “in favor of a repeal of our antiquated and absurd navigation laws, and the adoption on the part of the Federal Government of a more liberal commercial policy in its intercourse with foreign nations.” of those en Very few ais After effecting an organization the meeting se- lected six delegates to represent this State in the Chicago Convention—among them Colonel Dar- gan, Colonel Trenholm, Captain Dawson, of the News and Courter, etc. The State press, like our people, is generally very poorly informed on the question, and but few of the county papers gave any notice of the meeting in Columbia atall. Of the three daily papers published in the State, the | Charleston News and Courier, the Columbia Register, and the Greenville News, the two for- mer heartily and strongly advocate the move ment, and were both represented in the meeting The Greeny ille New &, too, pretends ad thre at Columbia. to favor the movement, but at the same time vocates Mr. Blaine’s silly idea of dividing revenue obtained from liquors and tobacco among the States according to population. So its sup port or opposition will not amount to much BO. D NEWRERKY, S. C., Nowember Iss THE CANON OF CRITICISM FOR ° AND FOR “ LITERATURE BOOKS To THe Eprrorn oF Tur NATION Sirk: In an appreciative review of an Afla essay on “ Principles of Criticism n the Na tion for October LY, the doubt is) suggested whether ‘ordinary literature” subouts itself t the test proposed, namely, the amount of 4 manent contribution made bv a \ work to the reader's intellectual life fm t tual life of the write And th \ S OX Presse d that ‘** the acceptance of tt i “ i involvean unfortunate limitation of crit t an estimate of the worth of the personal « t involved This shrewd suggestion might | made the basis for a very pretty quarrel bet we the essavist and his friendly reviews the 1 obstinate and sanguinuarv, because they a I» right It is really only a question of what w mean—exactly—bv the terms w To begin with, what is ‘ realism 1 wr If this term signi the « ription of . as they are, wit! t t 1 " ‘ ar not all beoks of me fact—tl text book in mathemat tl 1 inl " natural science, the collection f statistics products f pur N would peetend to call these ‘ literat however : thev an books I ca f criticism for them covers relv a awe al clearness In representing t hare fa The t for literature prop suggested by the essay re ferred to, does not fail cx rning this fleld of writing, nor would it tend to let Sas ignore any corner of it; if sim} does 1 t h itor apply toitatall When wever, We come to real istic history, or fict Tr poet for there is such a thing; Shakspere’s, for instance,wh held the mir1 p to natur joes not this test f the amount of mtribu to tl nner life apply, and all the better the more the given work belongs to literature proper, rather than to the region of books in general What is the difference b scene, and a painting of it. mething ths the artist gives usin addition to the fact something that constitutes it a work of‘ art tween a colored photograph of a if not s at bare If any given page from the leader of French real- istic fiction differs from a perfectly non-literary and very disagreeable police report (and we would by no means affirm that they all do),-is it not by virtue of what the novelist gives us of hi self, plus his fact ? But this something is not by sarily the ‘* personal element” derstood intrusion of self any means neces as ordinarily un It need not be in the least an egotistic + 4 Shakspere was always realis tic, never personal. Yet it was always realistic art, never mere colored photography. That which the writer contributes to us may be only . his better eyesight and his better judgment of what tosee. Just so far as Shakspere saw more in the mad old King Lear, and the fool, and the tempest than we should have seen, just so far he imparts to us himself in addition to his picture, Who does not prefer a fine portrait of a friend toa photograph? Yet, one may ask , does not the latter give the fact more exactly as itis? Not so; the “ fact” is what our friend really is to us, and this the portrait may give with infinitely more truth than the skewed and staring photograph, His
Page 18
402 The Nation. [Number 1063 sight and insight into this is what the artist con- tributes of himself. Things-in-themselves we do not know, and canaot know, least cf all cana camera get at them, ora police report. Things- as-they-seem, superficially, the extremist non- literary realism may give us; but when we re- quire to know things-as-they-are—as they are to us, in all their relations, ordinarily seen, or ordi narily unseen—we go to art, that is (in the case of written products) to literature, either realistic or otherwise. Compare the statistical history of a country in a Government report with the nar- rative of one of our best and most impersonal historians. In both cases we have the realistic facts, but the historian adds his power and babit of reading between the lines of events, of com- prehendiog what he apprehends, of divining causes and explaining results; and these, or some measure of these, he gives as permanent contri- butions to our intellectual life. It is unfortunate that the term * idealism” is set over against ‘** realism,” in characterizing lite- rary products. For the word *‘ idealism,” being derived from ** ideal,” carries a certain implica- tion of what is un-real. Whereas, the other school in literature, whatever we may call it— the school that is not commonly called realistic— does not depict what is less real, but rather what is more real, than the scenes of the extreme real- ist. Which novelist, for example, would give to some visitor from another planet the most real and true understanding of our terrestrial life— Zola or George Ehot ? But the terms of criticism are used so confused ly that one needs to devote every other sentence to definition, in order to discuss these matters. Mr. Howells’s style, for instance, is by a recent British critic denominated *‘‘unvarnisbed real- ism.” Itiscertainly *‘ unvarnished,” for textures of so fine a grain need no varnish; but is it real- ism, in any literal sense‘ If he were to depict a dinner party, a drawing-room scene, a téte-ad-téte conversation, just as we have them in “‘ real” life—just as we have them ourselves—why go to the expense of buying the book or the magazine ? Depend upon it, it is Mr. Howells’s dinner-party, or scene, or conversation, that we buy, and not the ‘‘ real” one of our own. Such writers are real- istic only as Shakspere was so. Selective realists, we mighticall them; and that is tosay, ** idealists ¥?) For Wé-tse this contrasted term as if it came from “idea,” instead of “ideal.” The extreme realist gives the bare fact; the idealist gives the fact plus ideas. Nay more, he selects bis fact from the mass, under the guidance of ideas— ideas of what is significant and what is whole- some. And this delicate instinct of selection is one of the very most valuable contributions car- ried over from his intellectual endowment to our own. To take an examrle in another field of art, are not Mr. Du Maurier’s drawings in Punch ‘‘ realistic’? Yet is not he also a selective realist —that is to say, an idea-ist ? Contrast his work with a statistical ‘* Jenkins” portrayal of social life, or with a photograph. Yet it is the very reality of the Punch sketches that gives them their charm. The truth is, all the best fiction, and the best art of any sort, is realistic; that is to say, it represents to us what is real. It gives us what is universally and always true, and not merely what is locally and temporarily true; and so it furnishes what is more real than the reality— than the reality, that is to say, as our less perfect vision would have seen it. And to such realism the canon certainly applies very well. It furnishesa familiar practical test of the greatness of literary works that is none the worse for being applied more or less uncensciously by all of us. By a wise instinct we rate any book very high when its characters become a permanent addition to our eircle of acquaintance, or when the range, depth, and force of the author’s intellect have made per- manent accessions toourown. And, on the other hand, those nevels, poems, histories, or what not, that strain through the mental tissue and leave no residuum, except perhaps a slight muddy stain, are recognized by that token as being weak and worthless. They may be ‘‘ idealistic,” in the sense of being what our reviewer very righteously resents—the egoistic intrusions of self into matter where it had no business, by some weak person who should have *‘ burned his own smoke ”; or they may be “‘ realistic,” in the popu- lar sense of being mere unselected fact-photogra- phy—some unrelieved jargon of “dialect,” per- haps, which seems to be the fashionable mode of “realism” just at present, but which has value (if at all) as philology rather than as literature. We shoul? be badly off without the books of pure realism, the works that make no pretence of belonging to literature proper. It is of im- mense importance that when we want a bare fact we should know just where to lay our hands on it. But it is pretty important, too, that when we want a symphony, a poem, a novel, or a philoso- phical history, we should be able to have that lay its hands on us. And one value of the canon of criticism lies in its protecting us against wasting our time on people who have no superiority to us in any single endowment—not even eyesight— and who cun, therefore, contribute nothing of lasting value from their intellectual life to ours. E. R. SILL. CuyanhoGa FALLs, OnIO, November 4, 1885. UNBELIEF AT YALE. To THE EpIToR or THE NATION: Srr: In your issue of November 5, ** An Old Graduate” advances as his theory of the cause of the small Freshman Class at Yale the (alleged) growing belief that unbelievers hold prominent positions on the Faculty. It seems to me that both his theory and his argument are radically wrong, and tend to injure the College. Nothing will cause such a belief as he mentions to grow so rapidly as his public assertion in your columns of the general existence of such a belief. It is difficult to understand how any such im- pression could have originated or gained currency, since, as a matter of fact, there are not three pro- fessed unbelievers on the entire Faculty. But if there were, does ‘‘ An Old Graduate” make gocd his assertion that, although their convict:ons were never so much as hinted to their classes, they would constantly be doing harm to the Col- lege? Does any fair-minded person believe the startling assertion —made as if it were an axiom, without need cf proof—that unbelief is either a sin or the sign of mental obliquity? Can any one doubt that the day Yale College, or any col- lege, refuses to admit men of genius and learn- ing, reverent men, to ker Faculty because their secret convictions are not in accord with those of the majority, that day will ring her death- knell as an instrument of the highest, broadest culture of her students in mind and nature ? It is just such unwise, narrow criticism as that of ‘An Old Graduate” which is in great part responsible for whatever cloud Yale may at pre- sent rest under. H. R. G. New Haven, November 5, 1885 RELIGIOUS INSTRUCTION AT HARVARD. To THE EprtTor oF THE NATION: Sir: The implied, if not directly stated, idea, contained in ‘‘ Alumnus’s ” letter on ‘* Cause aud Effect at Harvard” (Nation, Nov. 5th}, that little mstruction was given in that institution in religion and allied subjects, has caused the pres- ent writer to examine the correctness of this statement. Further, he has been led to see how far similar subjects are taught in the other three leading universities in the country, so far as that can be told by their catalogues. The announced courses of instruction at Har- vard for 1885-86, open to undergraduates, offer eight hours a week throughout the year on the history of religion: twenty-seven hours a week in Metaphysics, of which eleven or more are given to distinctive religious and ethical topics; al o seventeen hours a week in the study of the ‘Semitic ” languages, eight at least being de- voted to Biblical interpretation and religious history. Atleast four of the professors giving instruction in the above subjects are clergymen, equally divided between the Baptist and Unita- rian denominations. Harvard, then, gives not less than twenty-seven hours a week instruction in exclusively religious and ethical subjects. The latest catalogue of Yale at my hand is that for 1883-84. At that time there were offered to the undergraduates two terms in the Senior year, devoted to Porter's ‘Human Intellect,’ But- ler’s * Sermons,’ Hopkins’s ‘ Law of Love,’ Schweg- ler’s ‘History of Philosophy,’ Natural The- ology and Evidences of Christianity. Time not stated; probably from four to six hours a week. Besides this, two optional exercises a week are announced in Mental and Moral Philosophy during the second term of the Senior year. It is also remarked that instruction is given by Presi- dent Porter and Professor Ladd in Intellectual Philosophy and Ethics to graduates, but neither courses nor times are specified. Johns Hopkins offers to the undergraduates four hours a week throughout the year in Ethics and Psychology, and to her graduates ten hours a week in the “Semitic” languages, six at least of which are devoted to Biblical interpretation. Two other courses are announced in Akkadian and Sume- rian, but no times are given. Tne University of Michigan gives two hours a week to New Testament Greek during the first semester; with seven hours during that semester and fourteen hours during the second semester devoted to Metaphysics, four of these hours being apparently given to ethical and religious subjects, but for the second semester only. After this statement of facts any comment on ‘** Alumnus’s” letter would seem unnecessary. Yours, for truth’s sake because it is the truth, M. E. WaDsworra. WATERVILLE, Marne, November 7, 1885. . MORE TELEPATHY. To THE EpIToR OF THE NATION : Sir: Your editorial on ‘ Telepathic News of Battles” has interested me very much because of a personal experience which happened when I was ten years of age. My father left home one morning with a team and wagon to be gone the whole day. During the afternoon I saw very plainly the horses backinz over the bank into a creek, and the escape of my father from danger. The sight was terrible and filled me with fore- boding. Late at night father returned and nar- rated the accident, which had befallen him just as the scene appeared to me. If it were only bovish imagination on my part there are some in- quiries which seem pertinent that do not admit ot a ready satisfactory answer. A. H. Harsnaw. 428 W. 581TH Street, New York Ciry. Notes. CuppLes, Upnam & Co. publish immediately « Literature,’ a series of essays on Emerson, Vol- taire, Frederick the Great, Albert Diirer, etc., etc., by Herman Grimm, translated by Miss Sarah H. Adams. Seadineeeieae
Page 19
{ | i Nov. 12, 1885] The Nation. ‘Under the Mendips,’ a story by Mrs. Emma Marshall, is announced by E. P. Dutton & Co. Estes & Lauriat put forth a long list of limited editions of holiday books and standard works elaborately attired: Moore’s *‘ Lalla Rookh,’ with 140 photo-etchings, mostly by American design- ers; Poe’s ‘ Lenore,’ in large paper, illustrated by H. Sandham; Keats's ‘ Eve of St. Agnes,’ also in large paper, and illustrated by Edmund H. Gar rett : ‘ American Etchings, a series of twenty ; Duruy’s ‘History of Rome and the Roman People,’ in sixteen sections; Carlyle’s works in twenty volumes; Richardson's works in twelve volumes; and George Eliot’s works. Oue cf the same series we can name as already published: ‘The Modern Cupid (Fn Chemin de fer),’ verses by M. Mounet-Sully, of the Comédie- Francaise, and illustrations (in varying tints) by Charles Daux. Neither the comedian’s stanzas nor their pictorial settings strike a high level of poesy or art, but they accord very well. and these cupids and flower-stalks and birds have a certain Gallic daintiness without profundity. Each photogravure has a sheet and an ocean of margin to itself, and the sixteen or seventeen of them are loosely thrown together in a portfolio, Love, like death, has all seasons for its own, but as a gift ‘The Modern Cupid’ suggests rather St. Valentine’s Day than Christmas. We cannot help contrasting the superficial quality of the verse with Clough’s treatment of the same sub- ject in his ‘‘ Natura Naturans. Mr. Andrew Lang is preparing the selections from the poems of Scott and Burns for the Parch- ment Library, for which he has already edited a volume of Poe's poems. As if to leave nothing of Lippincott’s Magazine but the name, the January number will show an abandonment of the double column, a large and bold-faced special type, and a changed design for the cover. In this last respect the room for im provement bas always been great. Longman’s Magazine, almost the youngest of the popular English monthlies, has been especially hospitable to American authors. The November number contains a paper by Mr. Grant Allen, who is a Canadian by birth; and an admirable short story, ‘‘The Stone Dog,” one of the best of the recent attempts to reproduce Poe’s uncanny effects, by Mr. Charles G. D. Roberts, editor of the Toronto Week. It was a curious coincidence, due to the absurd and mischievous condition of our law of copyright, that an English story, ‘The Dark House,’ by Mr. George Manville Fenn, was pub- lished on the same day in New York by two leading houses, Its chief ‘ effect,” by the way, is to be found in Mark Twain’s * Adventures of Huckleberry Finn.” Some months ago we reviewed the revised edi- tion of Labberton’s Historical Atlas, published by Townsend MacCoun. We have now a new revision, or rather an edition with very consider- able and very valuable additions. In the first place, each map has a page of commentary op- posite to it, so that the Atlas can be used by itself as a complete text-book of territorial history. In the next place, there have been added eight bis. torical maps of England (one of which supersedes one in the older edition), mostly founded of course upon Green and Freeman. Thirdly, the table oi contents, always excellent, has been inyproved by the addition of a carefully prepared biblio- graphy to each map,,.giving review and maga zine articles, as well as books. The mistakes that we pointed out in our former notice have been corrected. We regret that the map of the Roman Empire in the century before Christ (No. xv_ does not give the precise organization of pro. vinces as they existed, say, at the accession of Augustus, when there were, for example, two 2 provinces of Spain, while Mauretania and Cap- | padocia, although “ vassal states,” were not yet incorporated in the Empire. We are sorry, too, that map lii will helo to keep up the delusion that the Louisiana purchase extended to the Pa cific. A reprint of views appears under the title of * The New Godi va’ (Scribner & Welford). One of the essays sets forth the purpose of the “Social Purity Al jiance,” another urges the importance of the * Association for the Care of Friendless Girls,” and the remainder are devoted to kindred sub jects. The writer is extremely earnest, and no convictions could be more intense than hers, but her arguments will hardly do more than encou rage those already like-minded doubt, to win opponents, a great deal more is necessary than mere repetition of moral com monplaces, however emphatic the repetition or however true the assertions An earnestness that constantly runs into extravagance overreaches itself. The writer's own estimate of the impor tance of the subjects with which she deals should have been enough to put her on her guard. The widest and wisest experience, the deepest study several essays in English re To overcome of the history of morals, ought to be the prepara- tion for arguments hke these. It is the lack of even the beginnings of these things that makes so much of honest and well-meant effort futile. Babyhood completes its tirst volume with the current number. The course which its editors marked out in the beginning has proved entirely successful in producing a highly useful periodical for mothers, in which the practical, as it should, predominates over the theoretical. The hterary interest of the magazine has been fully main tained. Science for November 6 takes up the Burman dispute, and furnishes its public with a map of the possible seat of war. Book News (Philadelphia: John Wanamaker). an eclectic review of current literature, is pub lishing portraits of eminent American writers, that for November being Emerson’s—a rather work, and a not unpleasing likeness of the poet in his latter years. * The Cruise of the Panda,” by J. S. Bacon, in tne Overland Monthly for November, recalls a fa- mous trial for piracy in Boston, in 1854, in which the late David Lee Child’s sympathies and pro- fessional services were enlisted on behalf of the Spaniards implicated. The block calendars, whose name is now legion, favorable specimen of ** process” are beginning to appear in force for 1SS86, Houghton, Mifflin & Co Emerson calendar, with fresh selections or arrangemen’, and add a Whitney Calendar in honor of Mrs. A. D. T. Whitney, the cardboard back being filled with a colored design in reminiscence of Miss Greenaway—four damsels with garlands: but without the customary portrait of the author. More sober is the decoration of the Louisa M. Alcott Calendar issual by Roberts Bros, Miss Alcott’s kindly face being set between a picture of her residence andone of the Concord one-arch bridge. Another auctioneer bas burnt his fingers by playing with a language he did not understand. One in Philadelphia sends out a catalogue under the title ‘Bibhotheca Curioso.* renew their Probably he has * Bibliotheca Curivoso- magica,’ and, imagining himself at a fcast of languages. has made off with one of the scraps. The Société de somewhere seen the title Histoire du Protestantisme Francais has commemorated the two hundredth anniversary of the Revocation of the Edict of Nantes by republishing Jean Claude's eloquent *Plamtes des Protestans, cruellement opprimez dans le royaume de France, edited by M. Frank Puaux, who has added numerous notes, includ- 408 ing many hitherto unpublished documents which illustrate and confirm the statements of the great Huguenot preacher. The Society bas als» pub- lished, among other interesting documents bear ing upon this event, the ¢ t enue of the Synod of the Churches of the Desert. It was at first preposed to send delegates to ail meetings held in Europe and this country by the deseend ants of the Huguenot exiles, but the design was abandoned for fear of reviving th Preh is animosities The principal reason, however, was probably that survested by ft i . the necessity of accepting — the Witations the Prussian descendants These are credited with “intense German sentiments, almost al ing to the idea that they have not forriven France for the crime of her monarch On tl other hand, there are no stronger patriots tha French Protestants, and it was hardly to be ex pected that they could listen with equanimity ¢ the most guarded reflections made by Germans upon their country In 1 great tive meeting held tn Paris, it was noted that none of the speakers referred tna hostile spirit to the Cathohe Church of the ya nt day—a Diam of religious harmony which was al shown i the recent elections, where, in ne instaney at least, the Protestants voted for a forvidl cler cal.’ At the public meeting held in London at. the Mansion House by the English dese Huguenots, it was voted to strike a commen tive medal, and to raise a fund for the endow ment of two scholarships, to be held at the Pro testant Theological Coll of Montauban bv young men of Huguenot parentage, te prepar for the ministry in rar There will be courses of lectures on railway SCLOTICE cisenbahn fachwiss scart é i sunge in several German universities this win ter. In Berlin thev are to treat of the Prussian law of railways, and also particularity of then tariffs and management In the Nerue Scienting for October 34th, M A. Gervais finishes his account of the conquest of Tonkin, drawn from unpublished documents From it, savs the editor, one can form some idea of the difticulties whi errors Which have been made, and, above all, of h have been overcome, the } ‘ the crand results whi have been obtained } { The writer closes with a description of the.cere monies attending the reception of the French envoy by the new King of Annamat Hu“. The absolute refusal of the Annamite ministers to submit to a radical change in these ceremonies demanded by the French commander is said to cause of the revolution in that country in July last & Lossing’s * History of the United States’ has have been th been mad» the basis of an illustrated history in German, edited by Paul Heichen (Leipzig: Albert Unflad; New York : complete, or, at the buyer's option, in fortnightly Christern). The issue is parts. A German translation of Lossing bas been on the market for some time in this country The death last week in Boston of Mr. John A. Lewis, at the age of sixty-five years, deprived the Nation of one of its most valued contributors. He was a native of Plymouth County, Massachu setts, and owed to his birthplace a fondness for and familiarity with the early history of Massa chusetts, which made him an authority in many particulars. Practical acquaintance at one time with the art of printing, and ashort experience in journalism on the Pacific Coast, directed his antiquarian taste to the collection of early pro- ducts of the Bay press, and he especially affected (with an imtrinsic delight in them) the works of Cotton Mather, of which he accumulated more numerous examples than (so far as we know) are to be found in any other private hands. His re- searches were restricted and his writing unpeded
Page 20
404 The Nation. [Number 1063 by steadily failing eyesight, which he bore with remarkable cheerfulness. His learning was cau- tious but sure, and could be trusted implicitly for its accuracy. Mr. Lewis was a man of great modesty and a most genial disposition, warmly attached to his friends, and drawing them to him- self with hooks of steel. —‘“E, 8.” writes us from Washington, November 3, 1885: ‘* What is the origin of the expression ‘ bloody shirt ’ as used in American politics? Léon Fou- cher, in criticising Guizot’s ‘ Washington,’ says : ‘It is by spreading out the miseries of the work- men, the bloody shirt of some victim, the humi- liation of all, that the people are excited to take arms,’ General Cass, in commenting on this (*‘ France, its King, Court, and Government.’ pp. 49, 50), adds: ‘ Most assuredly the Americans did not want a visible signal to Te them on; and he who should have displayed a bloody shirt tor that purpose would have been followed by the contempt of the spectators and saluted with stones by every idle boy in the streets.’” — The United States spent in 1884 through the office of the Public Printer close upon $3,000,000 ; and yet it is next to impossible for public libra- ries to get documents that they want very mucl» though they often get sacks of documents which they do not want. These latter the library and its groaning shelves keep, unless they are dupli- cates. If they are, itis as hard to get rid of them as it is to get the more desired volumes. They cannot be exchanged (the best resource for the disposal of duplicates), for other librarians say to themselves, Why should I give anything for this when I can get it for nothing by simply asking my Representative for it? They cannot be sold at auction, because the auctioneer says that they will not pay for the cata- loguing. Did not Senator Anthony’s two thousand volumes of Congressional documents sell for 8 cents a piece? The librarian’s con- science will not let him sell them for old paper, and so they accumulate. But now an outlet has been furnished. The Department of the Interior, having very successfully acted as Clearing-house for libraries in the matter of the Congressional Record, receiving duplicates from those libraries that had them, and from the stock thus formed supplying deficiencies wherever they existed, has resolved to apply the same system to all public documents. Mr. J. G. Ames, Superintendent of Documents, Interior Department. if informed that any lbrary has duplicates which it is willing to contribute to the common fund, will furnish wrappers which will enable the library to dis- patch the volumes free of expense, and if the library will send a list of its wants, he will sup. ply them so far as the volumes in his possession allow. Let every library hasten to assist in this good work. —The announcement in our last issue concern- ing the Catalogue of Government Publications just issued from the Government Printing Office, while correct if taken literally, perhaps needs to be supplemented by an account of the origin and nature of the undertaking. It is more than two years since that Congress made the first appro- priation for the purpose, and the sum appropri- ated to date amounts to $21,500. This sum was to be paid for clerical labor alone, the printing being otherwise provided for. No one will say that the end to be accomplished was not impor- tant enough to justify the expenditure of this large sum, provided it could not be done for a less sum; but in view of the fact that the Public Library of Boston prepared, with the greatest care, a similar catalogue many years ago, which has been continued to date, and which the library has repeatedly asked Congress to publish, the re- doing of the work seems to have been an alto- gether unnecessary expense. Many titles found in the Washington libraries are doubtiess absent from the Boston list, but this shows only that a revision of that was desirable. It is worth men- tion, moreover, that at the time of the first ap- propriation it was estimated by competent per- sons in Washington, familiar with the subject and accustomed to similar work, that a (from a bibliographical standpoint) thoroughly accepta- ble catalogue could be prepared for $5,000; while the present work, we are informed, is, when so judged, lamentably deficient. But, however im- perfect, it will prove of great use, and we advise those of our readers who have the opportunity to secure acopy. We caution them, moreover, that it is the early bird which catches the worm, for there are indications that a ‘‘corner” in the work is to be attempted for the benefit of those who have no political connections. The act which authorized the publication modi- fies, with reference to this work, the general rule relating to Government documents, viz., that any one may order of the public printer, within a specified time, as many copies as he may wish at 110 per cent. of the cost ; where- as in the present instance only 500 copies can be so ordered. Further, the rule is suspended which requires a considerable number of copies of each ‘‘ Congressional” document to be furnished to the Interior Department for gratu- itous distribution among public libraries. This last rule is indirectly evaded by providing that this is not to form one of the ‘** Congressional set” of documents. A hundred or more copies were erroneously printed so as to correspond with the Congressional set, but, the error being discovered, those not already disposed of to Con- gressmen were at once recalled. Congressmen have, however, provided for the distributicn of 800 copies on their order by the Interior Depart- ment, and thus will be able to favor the smaller libraries at the expense of the greater. The Cata- logue is printed in the same style as the Congres- sional Record, and contains 1,592 pages—the in- dex, which may be exhaustive, but which is con- structed in a manner by no means convenient for consultation, occupying pages 1245-1592. — The wonders of the world have become almost commonplaces of popular knowledge, and among the few that remain fabled yet untold the jealously guarded city of Petra has a preémi- nence both in the danger of its approach and the marvelof its ruins. Thestory of the picturesque defile in which the city lies, and the strange beau- ty of the rainbow-hued cliffs in which the tem- ples are cut, have given a fascinatiou to this an- cient metropolis of the desert that pertains to half-mythical creations; and it hasa peculiar in- terest as a development of the rock tombs, which makes its structures one of the most attractive episodes in architectural history. Everything yields at last; and now the Century opens its new volume with a profusion of photographs and an intelligent sketch about it, by Mr. Wilson, who penetrated to it by a stratagem in 1882. From his graphic account it would seem to have surpassed expectation, and _ the illustrations, even without the magic of that fantastic coloring, awake a lively curi- osity. Besides this, two papers will attract much attention—one a discussion of socialistic tendencies, and the other a plea for a closer union of the Church, in our country. The former is a broad-minded and well-informed article on a matter which presses for most careful thought. In the beginning, perhaps, the author makes too | much of the anarchist division of the Socialists, who are at most only guerrillas of the great movement, whose operations may be wanton and savage, but are after all incidental. In the main part of his subject he is not too emphatic, how- ever, and he grasps clearly the obscured charac- teristic of labor organization as a growing im- perium in imperio, a voluntary tyranny in the midst of our democracy, using methods which are essentially those of warfare; and while call- ing attention to this rise of a military system in trades-unionism, he is not less vigorous in his declaration that there is a real injus. tice at the root of it which must result, through violence or peace, in a readjustment in the industrial organization, probably througn the Government's assuming new functions. In the other paper a basis of consolidation for the churches is sought in their dogma, their govern- ment, and their ritual. In the first, little encour- agement is found; in the second, only an incom- plete interpenetration of the same principles; and in the third, a marked gradual approxima- tion to uniformity in the modes of worship. The author expends his energy in urging a more per- fect consent in the last field, by adopting formu- laries for prayer and Scripture reading, and accenting the festivals of the Christian year. The reconciliation of the Protestant churches of America is likely, from the showing of facts here made, to be as constant a subject in the future as that of the Anglican and the Roman Catholic. The subject is, we believe, to be continued. The papers on dogs are renewed in this number, and, in connection with them, in addition to the en- gravings already mentioned, those by Mr. Gas- ton Fay call for praise on account of their tech- nical excellence. —The war paper in this number is an extract from General Grant’s forthcoming autobiogra- phy, and contains his description of the battle of Chattanooga and the events which immedi- ately preceded it. Like everything written by Grant, it is absolutely clear in narration and simple in style. Some new and very interesting facts are told of the circumstances of Grant’s ap- pointment to command the Military Division of the Mississippi, and of his interviews with Mr. Stanton at Indianapolis and Louisville in regard to it. Mr. Stanton’s giving him the choice of two orders, one leaving Rosecrans in his com- mand and the other removing him, with Grant’s selection of the latter, is a dramatic incident, as characteristic of both men as it is striking. The story of the battle itself can hardly be said to contain anything not in Badeau; but its con- densation and its modesty make one wish that all his campaigns may thus be read, free from the extravagant panegyrics, and assertions of more than human wisdom, which disfigure Gene- ral Badeau’s otherwise able volumes. In the ‘*memoranda,” General W. I. Smith, who was chief engineer of the army at Chattanooga, takes perhaps unnecessary pains to show the evident incorrectness of Badeau’s assertion that the bat- tle was fought exactly as it had been planned. It is better praise of Grant to say that he modified his plan as often and as far as the changing cir- cumstances demanded. — The Mexican press was filled, during the last summer, with a controversy caused by the revi- val of some old charges against the honor of Jua- rez. The accusations were brought, this time, by so respectable an authority as the Italian histo- rian, Cesare Canti, in his ‘ History of the Last Thirty Years.’ The charges are, briefly, that Juarez obtained his recognition as President from the United States by a promise to cede the State of Sonora, and that he exacted a large ransom from the Emperor of Austria for the body of Maximilian. The Mexican Government has con- sidered the matter serious enough to call for the publication of an official refutation. This has been issued in three languages ; and the English edition, ‘ Juarez and Cesare Canti,’ has come to hand. It isa pamphlet oi fifty-five pages, giv- ing a thorough and satisfactory review of the whole case, The calumnies are first traced to OEP
Page 21
Nov. 12, 1885] The Nation. 405 their original sources, which are shown to be pre- judiced and untrustworthy, and then their groundlessness is conclusively shown by extracts from the national archives. The truth is, that as the passage of time is giving us the proper per- spective, we are seeing more clearly that the figure of Juarez is to be one of the heroic ones of this century. The pamphlet is thickly strewn with typographical errors, misspelled words, and amusing instances of *‘ English as she is wrote.” A specimen of the latter is the repeated phrase, ‘‘an attenuating circumstance.” Nothing of that nature can be urged, we fear, even by the most charital.le, for such an extraordinary number of blunders in a Government publication. —The recent appearance of the concluding parts of Prof. Dr. Reusch’s ‘Der Index der ver- botenen Biicher’ completes a work which isa monument of well-directed toil. The infinite ca- pacity for minute detail which we are disposed to regard as a peculiarly German characteristic, has rarely received a more practical demonstra- tion than in these 1,900 large octavo pages, most- ly in small type and condensed to the utmost ex- tent. All the precautions which the Latin church has found necessary in order to prevent the faithful from being contaminated by the misuse of the arts of writing and printing, are here set before the student in the most satisfac- tory manner. The result is such that no one here- after can seriously investigate the struggles of human intelligence toward development and en- lightenment without making abundant use of Doctor Reusch’s labors. Many unexpected side- lights are also thrown incidentally on dark cor- ners of literary history, which have interest for the general reader as well as for the special stu- dent. [tis satisfactory to observe that, so faras the United States is concerned, the Congregation of the Index has been content to rely upon the in- telligence of readers, and has not sought to fence them in from forbidden pastures. The only books originating in this country which have been ‘*Indexed” appear to be the pamphlets which were published in Philadelphia in 1822, during the fierce strife over St. Mary’s Church between Pastor Hoggn and Bishop Conwell, and a Spa- nish translation of one of Doctor Hollick’s noto- rious books, printed in New York in 1864, presu- mably for the Central and South American mar- ket. This confidence in the robust faith of our Catholics is turther manifested in the fact that when in 1876 translations of Professor Draper's ‘History of the Conflict between Religion and Science’ appeared in Spain and Italy, the public in those countries was protected by promptly placing them in the Index, though the original work has never been so treated here. As the Congregation must necessarily depend upon re- ports and applications sent to it by the ecclesias- tical authorities of distant countries, all this would seem to show that in this country the Church has wisely adopted the Anglo-Saxon aphorism, that error is harmless when truth is lett free to combat it. —When foreign vocalists, on appearing for the first time in an American hall or theatre, sing out of tune, the defect is commonly ascribed to the ‘“‘nervousness attendant on a first appear- ance.” More commonly, however, itis due to the fact that the standard pitch used by our orches- tras is apt to be higher than in foreign cities, though the Philharmonic lowered its pitch a year ago. There is a constant antagonism between vocalists and instrumentalists on this point, the former desiring a high pitch because that adds to the brilliancy of tone, while the singers object to it as involving greater effort and possible injury to the \»ice. Not only does the pitch vary be- tween different countries, but in the same coun- try, and even city, a common standard is rarely | | accepted. Dr. Hanslick, inthe Neue Freie Presse, gives an amusing illustration of this: On one occasion, in presence of the Austrian Court, two military bands united their forces to play the na tional hymn; but the result was so ear-splitting that one of the bands had to be commanded to stop. An absolute standard cannot be established, for the pitch of an orchestra is apt to undergo a change even during a single performance, when the instruments become heated. Thus Nike showed, by precise measurement, that during a performance of **Norma™ the a of that period was raised from 952 to 936 vibrations; and im a modern opera the result would doubtless be great er, at least if the instruments got as warm as the players. But such minor deviations would not be apt to cause trouble if a uniform standard were once generally adopted. France is most fortunate in this respect. In 1858, the French Government, in order to regulate the matter, appointed a commission, including physicists, di rectors, and eminent composers (Berlioz, Auber, Rossini, Meyerbeer, Thomas, Halévy), who, after taking intoaccount all circumstances of impor. tance, adopted a standard of 870 vibrations for a. This was made obligatory by throughout France, and its advantages were so apparent that many foreign cities, includ law ing Berlin, Vienna, Munich, Leipzig, Dres den, Hamburg, Frankfort. Stuttgart, Malan, Naples, etc., adopted it in course of time England, which toa native weakness of musical instinct adds a peculiar obstinacy in clinging to antiquated methods and forms, failed to accept the benefits of the diapason normal, thanks larguly to the opposition of Michael Costa, though it has been introduced in Covent Garden. Quite recently, following the appeal of the Zeitschrift fiir Instrumentenbau, a number of German mu- sicians signed a petition to Bismarck to make the French pitch obligatory throughout the German empire ; and at Vienna there is soon to be an in- ternational convention of musicians to discuss the methods of introducing further reforms. The preliminary circular issued in behalf of this Con vention leads Dr. Hanslick to suspect that the in tention is to advocate a still lower pitch than the French, the so-called Milan or Pythagorean pitch ; and he justly opposes this undertaking, not only because vocalists as well as instru mentalists would suffer by having too low a pitch. but because the advantages derived from the wide acceptance of the French system would be jeoparded. —Advocates of the theory that tobacco is harmless to adults have failed so far to explain away the explicit testimony of the Greely expe- dition, that those addicted to its use possessed lower powers of resistance and perished sooner than the abstainers; nor have they met the sus- picion, suggested by General Grant's death, and rendered plausible by other circumstances, that tobacco is to some extent responsitde for the alarming increase of cancer. As compared with most foreign countries, America has hitherto been a paradise for non-smokers, owing to the great deference paid to ladies; yet there is no question that there is everywhere a growing toleration of smoking. In Germany, on the other hand, where the smoker has always been more offensive and ubiquitous than in any other country, noteworthy is the result of a recent dis- pute between the managers and the passengers of the Berlin-Potsdam railway. To save time and trouble in the rush of business, the railroad officials took off the obligatory cars ‘‘ for non- smokers,” but this caused such a commotion that they were compelled to change their policy and to introduce a few separate coupés ** for smokers, ” Apropos of this fact, the Berlin correspondent of the Cincinnati Volksblatt notes various other | symptoms showing that the German non-smoker may hope, in course of time, to secure the priv: lege of breathing pure air in all public places Iu the and omnibuses smoking has been prohibited altogether, and the miner concert halls it is only allowed on certain eve- He als: remarks a large increase in the number of men who have given up smoking economic, wsthetic, or hygienic motives; and | street cars in pings, or in certain parts of the ball young either from seems remark there He further explains a mystery has puzzled many tourists the fact that Americans cannot, for love or money (and ciz are cheap), is that the American preference is for a fresh states the fact, which certainly in nine non-smokers to three smokers able for Germany, that his office ate which in Germany namely, irs procure any to suit them. The reas cigar, while the Germans keep theirs for sore time before they are considered fit for ase This but opinion of this correspondent, prefer the stronger makes them milder, Americans, in. the article, just as they would rather have whiskey than lager Paul Bert is known as a passionate politicia: Aan aggressive orator, a combative statesman, and an iconoclastic reformer, and to some also as the author of scientific works with tithes forbidding to the vulgar, such as * De la Gretfe animal ‘Recherches sur le Movement de la Sensitive.’ of however, on ‘La Pression barométrique” Few this side of the Atlantic, would expect of hun pleasant causertes, soft descriptions of scenery and village hfe, and optimistic tourist observa tions. A very agreeable medley of all these can be found in his last little volume, containing ‘Lettres de Kabvlie and ‘La Politique A rienne* (Paris). The letters, written in April and May last, form the main portion of the volume The tour described is not the author's first in Algeria. It does not embrace the capital, nor Constantine, Bona, Oran, or other creat centres but 1s almost completely limited to the land of the Kabvies in the narrow sense, that is, the mountain quadrilateral comprisee between Colh and Dellvs on the seashore, and Aumale and Sétif in the interior. This magnificent highland terri torv M. Bert looks upon as the kev of Algeria As long as its intrepid inhabitants lation on fertile slopes or in romantically saclud adense popu ed recesses—remain quietly disposed, France's hold on her greatest colony is safe, ‘even if the rest Were on fire And the Kabvies can be ly pacitic and friendly through equal justice, strict protection of property, rural — self government, the construction of roads and bridges, and the spread of such education as they easily rendered permanent- need. These Berber cultivators of the soil, ‘* sed entary, industrious, monogamous, eco nomic, fond of equality, jealous of municipay liberty,” must not be confounded with “the Arab eavaliers, aristocrats dwelling in tents,” with whom ‘they really have nothing in common but sobriety and bravery.” M. Bert has a strong dis like for the Arab as an aristocrat and a foe to France. The Kabyle he hopes to see converted into a useful auxiliary at the coming of *‘ the great European war, the necessary war, which every- body expects, hopes for, and dreads,” Formerly his hostility was but too often justifiable; he was often designedly driven insurrection by French commanders greedy of promotion and confiscation. The Republic treats him fairly now, if not yet wisely; and should he, at the wrong moment, rebel, the chastisement must be ‘“‘termble,” involving ‘the deportation of en- tire tribes to the Senegal, or toGuiana”! Thus speaks the enlightened scientist, who can write charming idyllic pages, but confesses himself to be guided solely by the interest of France, “‘étant into
Page 22
preg ; ‘ i 406 me ey eee The Nation. “ | Number 1063 chauvin de nature et peu enclinda Vhu- manitairerie.” TILDEN’S WRITINGS AND SPEECHES. The Writings and Speeches of Samuel J. Tilden. Edited by John Bigelow. 2 vols. Harpers. 1885. Mr. BiGELOw has done his work as editor ot Mr- Tilden’s state papers—if such is their proper title ~—very thoroughly. Each document or speech (the series begins as early as 1835, when Jeffer- sonian Democracy was a living creed, and comes down to these latter days of ‘* Peculation Tri- umphant,” and Electoral Commissions, and other things undreamt of by Silas Wright or Azariah C. Flagg) is introduced by a short note showing the circumstances which led to its composition or delivery ; and thus the papers with the notes make a tolerably connected history of the life and times of the subject. The collection will probably become more and more valuable as time goes on. Just now the early papers are too remote from the interests of the day, and the re- cent ones deal with matters too familiar to every one to attract a great deal of passing a'tention. It must be said, too, that Mr. Bigelow’s zeal has run away with him a little, and led him to speak of Mr. Tilden in a vein of prefatory laudation which is inappropriate. This raises anticipations of a higher degree of enjoyment in the perusal of the volumes than they are actually calculated to produce. We have ourselves always had a high appreciation of Mr. Tilden’s intellectual capacity, wisdom in public affairs, and professional skill ; but to most of his sincere admirers it must seem a little forced to suggest a comparison between him and La Bruyére and Vauvenargues ; or to say, as Mr. Bigelow does : ‘“While disclaiming on behalf of Mr. Tilden any special pretensions as a man of letters, it would be doing him signal injustice to imply that as great distinctions were not within his reach in the walks of pure literature, if he had chosen to turn his talents in that direction, as have re- warded his exertions as a political leader. Noone can run his eyes over the following pages with- out discerning mm them abundant evidence of the rarest literary faculty.” Under ordinary circumstances it would per haps seem too early during Mr. Tilden’s life to attempt an impartial estimate of his public ser- vices and position as a statesman; but, on the other hand, his public life has ended, and the passions aroused by his Presidential candicacy have subsided, and most of the facts in the case are already beyond dispute. It is curious to no- tice, for instance, that even with regard to the dis- pute that once raged over the question of the credit! which belonged to Mr. Tilden for breaking up the Tweed Ring, there is little or no question as to what he actually did. His admirers do not pretend that he did the work which fell to the press, the very courageous and difficult work of arousing public sentiment and promoting in- vestigation; on the other hand, his critics do not deny that he performed, or helped to perform, the invaluable service of preparing the ingenious device by which the cohesive power of the Ring was first broken—the sud- den substitution in the Comptroller's office of Mr. A. H. Green for Connolly; nor that it was through his masterly analysis of the Ring bank- accounts that legal evidence against its mem- bers was brought within reach. It is surely enough that the credit for these services—and most characteristic pieces of work they were, too—belongs to him; nobody really believes that Mr. Tilden was a leader in the preliminary agi- tation. A dispute as to tho relative importance of bis work and that of a newspaper in sucha matter is like a dispute as to the relative merits of the early abolitionists who preached the crusade against slavery when that institution seemed a part of the natural order of things, and the lawyers and stitesmen who afterwards guided the country on the road to abolition by legislative paths. Both played their parts and played them well, but their parts are too different to be compared; nor do we believe, now that the fury of the contro- versy is abated, that any one does think of com- paring them. Here, again, the phraseology em- ployed by Mr. Bigelow—especially the implica- tion in the use of the word “storming party ”"— seems a little extreme. Mr. Tilden has been a great leader in his day, but ‘‘ storming parties ” have not been the sort of operations that he has conducted or for which he was by nature quali- fied. Mr. Bigelow calls attention to the extraordi- nary hold which Mr. Tilden obtained upon the imagination and affections of his party—a hold which was so tenacious that when he came to feel the necessity of retirement, he had conside- rable difficulty in shaking his party off. But the fact is not so extraordinary when we reflect that the only instance in which the party had secured a victory in twenty-five years had been under his leadership, while his wealth was, in a period like ours of enormous election expenses and cam- paign funds, calculated to impress the minds of the organizers of conventions in a way that no amount of wisdom, purity, or intrepidity would ever have done. But, whatever the causes, the factis indisputable; and it has always seemed to us to place Mr. Tilden in a position as a public man which might have taught his most bitter critics the folly of attempting to depreciate him in the eyes of the public by heaping upon him coarse and indiscriminate abuse. The brutality, vulgarity, and irrelevance of these attacks in the case of a distinguished man who never replied to them made them soon seem to his admirers like the barking of curs at the triumph of a hero; and when really serious charges were subsequent- ly raised against his character, his fcllowers found that for a long time they could afford to treat them as merely a new form of vilification. Fifty years hence, in estimating the character and services of Mr. Tilden, what will be the ver- dict of posterity ? Without attempting to an- swer this question, we may say that Mr. Bige- low’s volumes wiil afford some of the best mate- rial for its solution. A good many of the papers relate to the economical questions which were so prominent in the days of Mr. Tilden’s youth, and in which he was especially strong. It was here that he laid the foundation of that mastery of finance and political economy which stood him in such good stead in his later years, when he un- dertook the difficult task of uniting on a sound financial platform the discordant factions of a party filled with illusions and hallucinations on this subject. It is always necessary to remember that there are two Tildens—the one a publicist and economist, the other a practical politician. In his former capacity he was without arival. No one had anything to teach him about the science of government, or about what is vaguely termed ‘* business.” He was essentially a ‘ business” lawyer—that is, a lawyer with the krowledge of business details and management which few law- yers have; he was, as every one knows, a tho- rough accountant; while he wasas well versed in the theory of economical science as he was in the practice of affairs. He might, however, have been all this and never risen to the height he at- tained in 1876. It is not simply intellectual greatness or knowledge which commands success in such contests as divide the American people every four years. He was also a master inthe art of practical politics as it had been taught him ia his youth and as he had practised it throughout his life. He knew how to use men so as to obtain hisends. All great states- | men must have this knowledge; the difference | between them, the difference in their characters, is shown in their methods of using their tools. Now it is not unfair to say—and we believe that there is no dispute among candid people about this either—that there were peculiarities in Mr. Tilden’s manner of making use of his fellow- creatures which up to a certain point helped him, and beyond that greatly interfered with his suc- cess. Without saying that he was fond of in- trigue, it can hardly be disputed that both his friends and himself have always regarded finesse as one of his strong points; and while we would not for a moment throw doubts on his moral courage or readiness to sacrifice himself for the sake of principle, this is very different from bold- ness—and Mr. Tilden was nota bold man. He consequently was inclined to finesse too much; and when the Presidency bung in doubt he finessed so much that he left his own partners in doubt as to what he meant or could or wanted to do—a fault as unpardonable in politics as in cards. He was pitted against bold men who were playing for high stakes, and who won the game the moment they perceived that their ad- versaries were growing timid and confused. Thus it was that Mr. Tilden lost the prize he had played for so long and patiently—the prize which nine-tenths of the fair-minded people of both parties thought he was honestly entitled to; and thus it was that in the crisis cf his life the characteristic vein of character which he dis- played so successfully in private affairs, which had proved of such great use to him and the pub- lic in his proceedings against the Ring, ended by becoming his stumbling-block, and involved him in irretrievable disaster. RECENT FRENCH BOOKS. M. Paut JANET has published, with additions, under the title of ‘ Victor Cousin et son ceuvre’ (Calmann Livy; Boston: Schoenhof), the inte- resting series of articles upon his former master and friend which appeared not long ago in the Revue des Deux Mondes. Tothese he has added, as an appendix, the article published in the same review in 1867, a few days after the death of Cou- sin, in which most of the very few personal de- tails contained in the volume are to be found. M. Janet has attempted to present to his readers only the relations which Victor Cousin bore to philosophy, and especially to philosophical study in France, during the first half of the present cen- tury; but these relations were socomplicated, so changing under the various influences and con- ditions through which he passed, that the at- tempt was an unusually difficult one. The result has been a work written with the clearness and simplicity of a master not only of style, but of thought, and full of interesu even for the general reader. All those portions which relate to the early philosophical teaching of Cousin, not only in his chair at the Sorbonna, but as maitre de conférences at the Ecole Normale, are especially new and valuabie. Itis difficult at the present time to understand the enthusiasm excited in France, and to a certain degree throughout Eu- rope, by the teaching of this young suppléant, who at twenty three took the place of such a man as Royer-Collard in one of the chairs of philosophy at the Sorbonne. In the most di- rect and striking manner M. Janet has shown that brilliant phase of Cousin’s genius which made him for his contemporaries the greatest of modern teachers, the creator of a school of philo- sophical thought if not of a new philosophy. The influence of Cousin dates from these early years of his teaching, between 1815 and 1820. Then the reactionary course of the Government led first to the suspension of his lectures at the Sorbonne, and, two years later, by the suppression of the CREE
Page 23
Nov. 12, 1885 | The Nation. * o m , Ecole Normale, to the loss of his place there as maitre de conférences. In 1828 another political crisis restored him to his chair at the Sorbonne; and that year and the succeeding one, in his fa- mous courses upon the history of philosophy, he obtained his most brilliant successes, and closed bis short career of only seven years’ duration as a public lecturer. After 1850, as a member of the Government of July, his activity was turned towards the organization of the public teiching of philosophy in France. What M. Janet calls the grande époque of his philosophical work closes at about the time of the Revolution of 1848, * Les jeunes générations qui ne savent pas l'his- toire” know him only 1m his later period, after he had corrected and modified his doctrines in the same way that he did his writings, under many complicated influences. M. Janet indicates this with a clearness of insightand a generosity which never fail, even when be sums up in a few forci- ble sentences the fatal results which followed both for his own fame and for the interests of philosophical study itself. There is necessarily but very little space devoted by M. Janet to Cou- sin’s writings outside of philosophy, but there is no chapter in the book in which his profound and delicate appreciation is shown to greater ad- vantage thanin the one entitled ** Cousin, litt«ra- teur et écrivain.” The passion for literature and literary art which took possession of Cousin from the period ot Lis studies upon Pascal, and the in- fluence of this new ardor upon his philosophical writings, is here brought out with fine critical in- sight. Renan said of bim toward the close of his life that he belonged even mcre to literature than to science. No one has disputed bis rank asa great writer; M. Janet says: ‘‘ Quelques-uns méme disent qu’il n’a été que cela.” He has cer- tainly shown, however, that if Victor Cousin has invented no new system, created no original doctrine, his services to philosophy place him among its most faithful disciples. M- Jules Simon has made good use of the forced leisure which bis retirement from political life has given him, and has turned his thoughts to academic labors. Not long ago he published ‘Une Académie sous le Directoire,’ in which he gave the history of the section of the Institut suppressed by Bonaparte and reéstablished in 1832 under the ministry of Guizot. Now he gives us the biographies of three of the most emi- nent members of the section, recently deceased. ‘Thiers, Guizot, Rémusat’ (Calmann Lévy; Bos- ton : Schoenhof) contains, besides a long preface which is by no means the least interesting part of the book, three historical notices read before the Académie des Sciences Morales et Politiques, at its annual public sessions in 1882, 1883, and 1884. These notices are very different from the eulogiums pronounced by a récipiendaire of the French Academy upon his predecessor at his pub- lic reception into that body. The Secretary, on whom devolves the duty of preparing one his- torical notice annually, unlike the new member of the Académie Francaise, does not have his subject imposed upon him by circumstances, but chooses freely from among the most eminent of the recently deceased members, as his own sym- pathies and opinions incline him. The historfan Mignet, who preceded M. Jules Simon as _ per- petual Secretary of the Académie des Sciences Morales et Politiques, did not hesitate to omit even so important aman as Michelet. M. Jules Simon was the personal and political friend and associate of both Thiers and Rémusat, and his notices of them are the ardent and sympathetic appreciations of a friend rather than the critical opinions of even an impartial and kindly judge. Political and personal feeling enters less into his account of Guizot, and just so far this is more moderate in tone and nearer the ideal of what such a notice should be. The thread which con- nects the three notices and gives unity to the volume is the important part played by these eminent men in the polttical history of the pre sent century. The book is full of information, and, in spite of the author's personal bias, which shows especially in the treatment of the political career of Thiers, it is accurate and valuable M. A. de Pontmartin belongs to a class of writers who have been justly called * prophets of the past.” He is more Catholic than the Pope, and more Royalist than the King; nor hav: He has just published the sixth series of his *Souvemrs d‘un vieux critique’ (Calmann Lévy: Boston: Schoen hot), which is simply a collection of his critical notices of recent In articles upon the Due de Broglie, Louis Veuillot, Camille Rousset, he can freely give vent to his monarchical and these tendencies lessened with age. books. religious feelings ; while in speaking of Victor Hugo, Edmond About, Richepin, Daudet, and Paul Bourget he takes every opportunity to lay the blame of the corrupt state of letters and manners upon the republican government of France. It is not necessary to agree with M. de Pontmartin to enjoy his writing. He hates all that is new so cordially, and yet, in spite of all, he is so thoroughly modern himself, that the con trast is amusing and instructive. devoted to Sarcey are full of sympathetic ad- miration: and yet Sarcey, outside of his thea trical criticisms, is one of the bitterest oppo- nents of the party which has M. de Pontmartin’s prayers. The volume of M. Augustin Challamel, * Nou- venirs d'un Hugolatre’ (Jules Lévy ; Boston : Schoenhof), looks very uninviting, nor do the con- tents satisfy the expectations raised by the glar- ing title. The sub-title, ‘La Generation de 1830,” indicates more truly the nature of the work, which gives the personal recollections of the author, who came in contact with many of the men celebrated in the reign of Louis Philippe, but who bas very little to say of Victor Hugo himself. He has some pleasant things to report of his own literary beginnings, but he ts very reticent in regard to the genesis and com position of the only work by which he deserves to be classed among French historians, his * Me- moires du Peuple francais,’ in eight volumes It will not be enough to say of M. Guy de Maupassant that he writers for whom morality is something that may be neglected. He not satistied with ignoring certain rules of action, as M. Bourget He deliberately chooses his characters, all his characters and situations, so as to be in com- plete disaccord with what to him is the Philistine view of right and wrong. If, therefore. vou wish for a novel that will give an ideal picture of anything that is good or noble in man or wo- man, do not choose one of M. Guy de Maupassant’s, especially the last, * Bel-Ami’ (Victor-Havard ; Boston : Schoenhof). The title suggests the un- savory plot. Bel-Ami is the handsome animal who succeeds in life through the influence of wo- men. The author has surpassed his previous efforts and those of the school to which he be- longs, the successors of Flaubert, in the force and intensity with which he presents the excep tional as well as exceptionable phases of life in which this literature delights. M. Catulle Mendés, in ‘La Légende du Par- nasse contemporain’ (Brussels: Brancart ; Bos- ton: Schoenhof), nas endeavored to present the rise and progress of a school of French poets, most of whom are still living, who have received the name of parnassiens. The author is himself The articles belongs to the class of 1s does. } one of the lesser lights of this constellation, which boasts already of two Academicians, Sully Prudhomme and Coppée. poetical beginnings of the vagabond Glatigny, he passes to his own friends, Léon Dierx, José- After relating the Maria de Herédia, Albert Merat, and others sti less k “ ri severa t! r Poems a 1 Many h ’ These | s, he tells us, bay ney Li tat formu new ‘ perry att mest they are only 1 group What he does not tell us is that this group or sehool though wo ‘ g directly from Vi r Huge has maiack verse a mere handicraft in w ! the highest importance is attached to form and sound, Even in the best of them, S Prad homme, there is but a ve ni thread of thought. The vounger disciples have been de votees of art ‘or art's sake rhing many things which most people reve and lov These hav gloried in the ua { But wl ther they | lj s ‘ ‘ es fat ! s tl ) ite’ W their pla 1 now tl have t r perteartica their p I rre) and even their paradis who but lately gave them a new man : decad f All this M. Me + es not tell But he has u re ne piges upon their first journal, La ii } fiaisist aml upou the publication of *Le Parnass ontetuporain” it ISU, a how rare \ fy sin wh by the side of mans uready celebrated, several poet the new s ml ’ t naely es known, and which was the oocas { «les tat ing wu “ t rap as ' ss ’ L Piatti not very it 1 asthe wont was never seri ously ay xl to a poet, but has always had and may continue to have only the meaning { powt aster CHILDRENS BOOKS Puiny’s ‘Natural History, a work remarkable at the time when it was composed, more than eighteen hundred vears ago, is to-day a literary fossil, interesting for its record of the myths and errors of that ancient time, full of data for the ethnologist and student of manners, but practi cally barren for anv one seeking information of what we pow call natural bistory For well grown vouth (if there are any left). who have some knowledge of animals and of comparative history, Mr. John S Plinv’ (Putnam the mifusion whi White's ‘Boys and Girls’ will have an interest as a pre the The wuld follow the reading sentation of iwhorance of ancients h wr hiren voung enough to take it in earnest, and it should be kept out of adults it literary learned editor, presumabiv a tiable, For UPriositVy, AS The would be + their hands prese. ts a *classicist “ of the deepest dve, seems to suppose that bv a dozen or two of references to Swam merdam and Cuvier he has called attention to all instances where the author's statements have proved in the hight of modern science to be erroneous,” ‘‘ unless evidently preposterous.” To make it a complete manual of natural history, doubtiess, the publishers have included nume- rous excellent woodcuts of the reindeer, walrus, phant, musk-ox, and other animals not known to Pliny or referred to in the text. The make-up of the book is excellent ‘Four Feet, Two Feet, and No Feet; or Furry and Feathery Pets and How They Live,’ edited by Laura E. Richards (Boston: Estes & Lauriat), is one of the most attractive books for children which have lately come to our notice. It is crammed with illustrations remarkable for their truthfulness and beauty; and accompanied by short stories, prettily told, and which convey much information about the birds, beasts, and insects whose portraits appear in the cuts. We can heartily recommend it. A considerable amount of geographical infor- mation is given in an attractive form in the ‘Boy Travellers in South America,’ by Thomas W. Knox (Harpers). Two cousins, accompanied by an uncle, visit most of the countries and large cities SCAU
Page 24
eas 408 The Nation. { Number 1063 of South America, crossing the continent in doing so twice, descending the Amazon in the one case and going over the pampas in the other. They study up the history of the places they visit, as well as the accounts of other travellers, abstracts of which are given in the form of letters home or in conversations. Much attention is also paid to a description of the natural products of the va- rious countries. The narrative is skilfully inter- woven with this solid information, and the book is almost always interesting. Occasionally the author errs in giving unimportant tails. He has evidently been car -ful to get the latest infor- mation on the subjects he discusses, and in only one instance have we noted an important omis- sion. In his account of Chimborazo he errs in stating that no one has ever reached the top. Mr. Whymper ascended it twice in 1880 The pictures are mostly good and well illustrate the text. In some cases, however, it would seem as if the text had been written for the pictures. The book would have been far more useful had the author taken the pains to add anindex. A table of contents, however full, by no means takes its place. The same author has adapted the * Travels of Marco Polo for Boys and Girls’ (Putnams). One of the young members of a ‘“* Reading and Gec- graphical Society ’ reads at each meeting one or two chapters of the ‘ Travels,’ and another fol- lows with explanations of obscure passages and additional information in regard to the countries and people described. In this way the greater part of the book is read “ with very slight reduc- tion or alteration.” The additions to Marco Po- lo’s story are generally well chosen and interest- ing, but, notwithstanding all Mr. Knox’s care, a considerable knowledge of the geography of Asia is absolutely necessary for the understand- ing of many passages. The illustrations are ad- mirable, with a few exceptions, and give the book a very attractive appearance. The title of the ‘ Boy Travellers in Arabia,’ by the Rev. Dr. Wise (Phillips & Hunt), is mislead- ing, in that their journey from Aleppo to Bag- dad and back by Damascus and Beirut is not in Arabia, but in the Syrian Desert and Mesopota- mia. The descriptions of the scenery and the life of the Bedouins are fairly well done, but the author has not been very successful in the ar- rangement of his materials. In ‘ Historic Boys,’ by FE. 8. Brooks (Putnams), there are accounts of incidents in the lives of twelve boys, all of whom were or became mo- narchs, with the exception of the last, Stephen Van Rensselaer, the Patroon. The most noted are Mareus Aurelius, William the Conqueror, Henry V. of England, Leo X., Louis XIV., and Charles XI. of Sweden. Most of the sketches are interesting, but the author's style is too am- bitious and is marred by archaic affectations. With regard to the typography and the beauty of the illustrations, this book deserves high praise. It is to be regretted that so many books for the young, like those for older readers, should be made up of short disconnected sketches or stories. Little mental effort is required to read them, and the mind passes rapidly from one topic to another entirely different without dwell- ing at length upon any. There is serious dan- ger that the power of prolonged and concen trated thought will thus be greatly diminished, and that the ability to read a book, in che old and highest sense of the term, will become one of the lost arts. With this reservation we can heartily commenl ‘Some Noted Princes, Au- thors, and Statesmen of Our Time,’ edited by James Parton (T. Y. of fifty sketches nearly all of which originally appeared in the Youth's Companion. Though ostensibly written for the young, we are inclined Crowell & Co.), con-isting to think that these essays may be read with even | thor, Mr. W. O Stoddard, has never been so suc- greater pleasure by the old. Some of them, | especially those by Mr. E. P. Whipple on the college days of Macaulay, Prescott, Choate, and Charles Kingsley, are above the heads of all but the most thoughtful of young readers. Canon Farrar writes pleasantly of Dean Stanley and Westminster Abbey and of Disraeli. Especially interesting is the account of Victor Hugo’s homes at Guernsey and Paris, and the poet’s intense so- licitude for bis manuscripts. ‘‘Tea with Car- lyle” is a capital bit of descriptive writing. The accounts of the royal families of England, Den mark, and Bavaria are entertaining, but not of much value. The best paper is on ‘* Dickens with his Children,” by Mamie Dickens, his daugh- ter. In so large a collection of articles by dif- ferent writers there will inevitably be some much inferior to the rest; but the editor has done his work well and has admitted few which have not some merit. He should not have per- mitted, however, Mr. G. P. Lathrop, 1n his ac- count of Hawthorne, to put Brunswick on the Penobscot River. The portraits and illustra- tions are very good. ‘Lives of Poor Boys Who Became Famous,’ by Sarah K. Bolton (T. Y. Crowell & Co.), con- sists of twenty-eight short sketches fairly well written, beginning with Geo. Peabody and end- ing with Lincoln. This well-intentioned and in places stimulating book is marked by several inaccuracies of statement which detract from its merit. It is of no great importance that Joseph Addison, Samuel Johnson, and Garrick did not go to school together, and that Garibaldi was not ‘‘ born in Southern Italy,” and that the date of Gambetta’s birth is incorrectly given; but it is important that a writer for boys, as much as a teacher, should be accurate in matters of fact. We suspect that some of our author's youthful readers will experience a different emotion from that intended by the writer when they read that, after Gambetta’s death, ‘‘ fifteen thousand per- sons calied to see the great statesman as he lay upon his single iron bedstead”; end again when, in describing Ole Bull’s narrow escape from d ath while playing, they are tole that “he ruptured a blood vessel, and his coat had to be cut from him.” Mr. Edward E. Hale, in his ‘ Stories of Inven- tors’ (Boston: Roberts Brothers), begins with Archimedes and Friar Bacon, and ends with Nasmyth and Bessemer. His method is to allow the inventors themselves, if possible, to tell their own stories in their own language. With some he has been fairly successful, but with others the materials at his disposal were not so egsily used. Much in the account of the steatn-engine, for instance, is beyond the intelligence of his read- ers. There is no harm in this, provided it makes them think; but Mr. Hale would have done better either to have omitted some technical de- tails, or to have greatly simplified his explana- tions. His chorus of children, who, under the guidance of our old friend, Colonel Ingham, get all the facts from the cyclopadias and biogra- phies, are a very remarkable group, talk fa- miliarly of dividends and Agnostics, and are probably equally conversant with the intricacies of mechani’s and chemistry. The account of Goodyear’s invention should hare been clearer, and a better representative of the inventors of bis age than Benvenuto Cellini could, we think, readily have been found. There is hardly a better class of books for boys and girls to-day than those which awaken a love for nature, and make them long to be in the fields and the woods, on the mountains and by the seashure ; which teach them to enjoy, not country sports simply, but life merelv in the country. ‘Winter Fun’ (Scribners) is such a book, and, so far as our experience goes, the au- | | cessful as in this account of life in a mountain village during the winter season. He writes as if he thoroughly enjoyed the scenes which he pictures, and as if they were chapters from his own experience. His boys, it must be said, have exceptional luck in their hunting, getting a wild- eat, several deer, two wolves, and a bear in the course of a single winter. Besides the hunting scenes, there is sleighing, coasting, skating, fish- ing through the ice, a donation party, and a spelling match. But there 1s no singing school, we regret tosay. If the publishers had put upon the title-page, ‘‘ Reprinted from St. Nicholas,” our satisfaction in it would have been complete. Of a similar character to the preceding is * Birchwood, by Jak’ (T. Y. Crowell & Co.). A city boy hires himself out to a farmer to pick berries, and spends his summer vacation on a farm. With other boys and girls im the neigh- borhood, he forms a natural-history society. They tit up an old house for their collections of wood, minerals, birds, and insects, and start a library and reading-room. The story is natu- rally told, and the children whose doings are re- corded are thorough boys and girls. We cer- tainly hope that the author will be encouraged to give a further account of the ‘‘ Riverside Mu- seum ” and its founders. Mrs. Burton Harrison established at one stroke her reputation as a singularly graceful writer for children in her ‘Old-Fashioned Fairy-Book’ of last season. Her present volume of ‘ Bric-d-brac Stories’ (Scribners) is a virtual continuation of the ‘ Fairy-Book,’ giving, as did that, a new dressing to stories borrowed from all nations. As the title intimates, the ingenious device is adopt- ed of making the various objects in a richly fur- nished drawing-room on Fifth Avenue relate, to a little boy, tales appropriate to their several na- tionalities, the Russian samovar leading off. The only fault we have to find with Mrs. Harrison's performance is the melodramatic finale. Mr. Walter Crane furnishes a great number of illus- trations in his usual vein. A large constituency of little people are in debt to Mr. Howard Pyle for his version, literary and pictorial, of ‘Robin Hood.’ He now appeals afresh to their gratitude with his handsome quar- to‘ Pepper and Salt, or Seasoning for Young Folk’ (Harpers). Like Mrs. Harrison's, Mr. Pyle’s invention is contined chiefly to reéditing the stories he takes from standard collections. Some of these he puts in verse, not bad of its kind, yet not remarkable. His designs, however, are quite up to his high level, and are at once humorous and picturesque, and decorative to a degree and with a certainty unrivalled by those of any other illustrator of books in this country. The title- page in red and black is a good example. A closer attention to the distinction between shall and will is the sole desideratum in this agreeable writer’s style. For a frank imitation of * Alice in Wonder- land,’ Mr. Charles E. Carryl’s ‘Davy and the Goblin’ (Ticknor & Co.) is undeniably clever—a remark which might be spared any reader of St. Nicholas, in which the story first appeared. The humor and the ingenuity are unflagging, and one only feels that the metamorphoses are rather too rapid. The illustrations are exceptionally good, Lord Brabourne’s ‘Friends and Foes from Fairy Land’ (Little, Brown & Co.) deals alto- gether with elves and witches, in three stories of unequal length, but all markedly original in treatment, well sustained in interest, and excel- lent in style, though there is no condescension to the infant vocabulary, There is true imagina- tion in developing the several characters, wheth- er human or brute, and it is seldom that descrip- tions of natural scenery are so felicitous without
Page 25
Nov. 12, 1885]
The Nation.
e- 409
being labored or conscious. The author’s amuse- ment in his own inventions will certainly be shared by his youthful readers. His artistic co- laborer, Linley Sambourne, known to all lovers of Punch, bas a corcesponding individuality of conceit and draughtsmanslip, and, thcugh he has made but an ugly cover piece, has done much to heighten the attractiveness of the volume. Mention of Kate Greenaway will serve to cha- racterize the now customary crop of juvenile pic- ture-books consisting of colored prints cf little folks, and appropriate verses. There is much that is graceful and feeling in the full-page illustra- tions by M. E. Edwards in ‘Through the Mea~ dows’ (E. P. Dutton & Cc.), and some of the vignettes in sepia by J. C. Staples can be «om- mended. Mr. Weatherly’s serio-comic verses are not remarkable, and their frequent allusions to Mr. Mundella will be quite lost on the American youngster. Both the coloring ard the designs in Virginia Gerson’s ‘ Rosebuds’ (White, Stokes & Allen) are inferior to those of the foregoing, but now and then tbere is a bit of cleverness, as on page 25, and some of the ornamental borders show a fair decorative sense. The rhymes are of the nursery orcer. From Shakespeare to Pope. An Inquiry into the Causes and Phenomena of the Rise of Classical Poetry in England. By Edmund Gosse. Dodd, Mead & Co. 1885. THE subject-matter of these lectures, which were delivered last year in America, is narrower than the title implies The discussion does not include the body of English letters between Shakspere and Pope: it is limited to a single current of the poetic movement, sometimes called the classical from its supposed deference to ancient, and par- ticularly Latin, theory and practice, or more commonly the Queen Anne, from the era of its culmination. Waller, the inventor or the new verse-form, is very fully treated, and Denham, Cowley, and Davenant, who continued it, and a few starveling bards who refused to conform, are also considered more or less thoroughly; but here, too, the author is further restricted, and the completeness of his survey is broken by his previous excursions in the same field, for which he refers to another publication. The scholar- ship displayed, the comprehensive and minute knowledge of facts, the antiquarian research and patienc , are notable characteristics of his labor, and they result in some positive additions to the extensive fund of information in our possession. Investigation, however, has been practically subordinated to a kind of philosophizing, and the work makes its claim on our attention not on the score of its fresh finds of fact so much as on that of new views. The lines of these are simple Three points are aimed at: that the origin of the school was not French but native ; that the body of the literature does not represent a lapse into stupidity, but a reform and advance over bar- barism; and that this movement was both neces- sary and beneficial—‘‘ the basis of style, in prose and verse, upon which all more recent lterature has been elevated.” These statements nave a revolutionary look. The existence of the French influence in our clas- sical period is as firmly established in our con- ce} tion of that time as that of the Italian or Spanish in other portions of our literary history. The exile of the wits of.Charles IT. at the French court, the traces of France in the versitiers of the Restoration, and the growing reference to French criticism at the end of the century, give a strong color of truth to the common view. Mr. Gosse himself declares that he should ‘* be sorry to seem to underrate the part taken by France in the de- velopment of English classicism.” What, then,
is the fact he particularly emphasizes? Merely that Waller had worked in the rhymed penta- meter, which does not allow the sense to overflow beyond the couplet, and had brought it to the form in which it was handed on to Dryden, with out apparent aid or suggestion from abroad. This was worth bringing out, but its effect on the general view regarding the French influence in the period, as a whole, is slight. Distichs, having the meaning complete within themselves, had been written before Waller; and whether he had the talent to see that here was an unde- veloped verse-form, or whether he merely felt it out by virtue of its aptitudes for his own limita- tions, as proverb rhymers find their measures, he was a lucky discoverer of the use of a common thing. The form had already been made essen- tially English, never to be confused with a truly adopted one such as the rondeau. What is really importent in the accepted opinion is, that the cast of poetic thought in the classical period was in ttre direction of a logic and intelligence which were characteristic of a literary taste that came over with Charles II. Logic and intelligence are English, too; but the placing them above passion and imagination in the region of poetry seems to have been confirmed by a town predilection which began to rule at that time. Let Waller havé all the credit for originating ‘the square- toed rhyme” out of his unassisted brain; but to emphasize unduly a fact which dates from before Charles I. lost his head, would warp our notions of the character of a long age, and of a literature which summons up the name of Queen Anne Mr. Gosse, however, does not rely on this point alone to reduce the tradition of the French in- fluence to humbler pretensions. The invasion of logic and intelligence, he tells us, took place si- multaneously throughout the West; it was a movement common to the modern world. In England he refers it to the lassitule following a great age, and toa disgust for the current writ- ings in which, to use his phrase, only the barba- rism of the Elizabethan period survived. By dwelling mainly on the rawness of tne work which was displaced, he almost strikes out a new way of putting the case. To say that our litera- ry task after Shakspere was to create a good prose isa commonplace; Mr. Gosse says it was to destroy a bad state of both prose and poetry. It is true that minor literature, meaning by that all except the literature of genius, was in gene- ral barbarous until the intellectual age set in. The literary movement after Shakspere was the reform of this minor literature, ot what may be conveniently named bookcraft. So much of truth there is in the dictum that English class:- cism was not a lapse but an advance. It is not to be allowed, however, that this new rational- ism was a reform of the literature of gemwvs it self, of the creations of passion and imagination: it was the abandonment of it. The prose instinct was supreme in the circles which were the nur- series of the modern spirit. The poets who werc curious about politics, morals, criticism, events, occasions, town and society topics, were smaller men than their Nestors knew—not of the make of the former age—citizensof the world, not chil- dren of Parnassus. They took the rhyming dis- tich, of which the hmitations were not narrower than those of their own minds; their subjects were to be talked of rather than sung, and pro- fessional poetry seized the mould in which verse comes nearest to prose. Poetry, the divine art, suffered: the Muse—dea incedif—would not put her feet into the Chinese slippers. But thoughat the end even the verse which was the bead- string of intellectual brilliants, came to naught, the reform of the barbarous common literature was complete: restraint, temperance, conformi- ty were wrought into our bookcraft, and they bad come to stay. How much of this change
— ee and he goes on to drive the nail home by adding “and if we have chosen to cover it upand for get it, and to return in our poetical architecture to selected models from earlier schools, it is not the less due to the labors of Waller, Dryden, Pope that we have sohd groundwork on which to support these brilhant nation.” movement underlies the romant is not vet at planation, and fabrics of the tmag This seems to mean that the clasacal period which anend. The statement needs ex History is consecutive, we know but Mr. Gosse can hardly be suspected of wis! the ages by his high-keved sentence = It ing to convey only consecutiveness of the Is cConcely able that some reference may be intended to the existence of a cultivated publi in the au dience ; but this is bardly likely Tr! as we understand it, is that the: tast« ¢ assertion, manticists are indebted to the classical writers for some undk ha belief ther terl fined training in style. For su The romantic pemod is as ut cut off from the classical as was that from the Shakspenan. In no intelligible sense was Bu indebted to Waller, Dryden, and Pope, any more is no ground, than was Rossetti Ail more recent litera ture’ isa comprehensive phrase. Similarly with Wordsworth, Coleridge, Shelley. Keats, Tennv- son, Browning, and Swinburne—the earlier of these came nearest failure whenever they aj proached the paragons referred to, as did Byron also, and succeeded when they forgot all excep the hft of their own Ivric song. In other werds, while English classicism was a reform in the bookcraft, whether prose or verse, it never af fected the literature of genius, of passion and imagination, then nor now, In its own days the muse was with Donne and Herbert and Vaughan, and watched with Milton till song was silent: and when the new age came, it was not the resurrection of dry bones—at least not bones so dry as Waller's. In prose, toc : was Bi lingbroke the ** basis of style” of Carlyle? But there is no need to pursue these queries. The scholarship and faculty of research shown 1n these and warmest which the a feeble mastery and sweep of great lectures merit the highest praise but whole is involved, indicate only of the nature and influence welcome, the general views, in agencies. Mr. Gosse might well called his book ‘The Life and Literary Influence of Edmund Waller. That is its real subject. The biogra phy of this forturately born poct is tullv told, and some of the details of his plot against Par have a are given from unpublished researches by Professor Gardiner, Certain it 1s that his poetry, once in undisputed *‘ immortal” vogue, will never be revived for his own sake. In a certain shamelessness he will retain preéminence among English poets, unless the oblivion of his works should prove the safety of his character. It is in this part of the field that Mr. Gosse ex- cels—in the portraiturs of decayed literary fash- ions, in sesthetic understanding of a lost taste. His muse, as shown in the opening dedication to
Page 26
aE Rn oe eS ag nor Pogeme aA rae ee ee SrA eee re 410 The Nation. {Number 1063 Mr. Howells, is of a modest kind ; his attempts in the higher region of ‘‘the source and pheno mena” of things are too apt to experience the uncertainties of Icarian flights. Tuscan Cities. By William D. Howells. With illustrations from drawings and etchings by Joseph Pennell and others. Boston: Ticknor & Co. 1886. WE have already commented upon these sketches as they have appeared from time to time in the magazine whose pages they have made delight ful; and it has been a pleasure to read them once more, and to note the skilful blending of beauty and humor, of romance and history and contem- porary progress, of the mediaval and the modern genre, all of which give such propriety to their designation as an Italian ‘‘ mcsaic,” whether in Florentine stones or Siennese candy. Mr. How- ells is the prince of magazine travellers in Italy. The collection of these papers in a book, how- ever, compels us to take notice of their combined effect ; and in this there is a weakness which is indicated above by our restriction of his royal right to the magazine provinces. The fault be- longs to his method, and is confessed by the sub- titles, which prepare the reader for an incongru- ous mixture of scene and incident. It is true that thus a sense of the incongruity of Italy is very perfectly given, and the impression which is left on the mind is no more confused than it would actually be in the case of a tourist in his first perplexities. The author does accurately represent the state of mind of an intelligent American under the circumstances, with all his hesitations, his sense of lurking humbug (not to be overcome by hisown self-distrust), his acknow- ledgment of practical discomforts and ever-pre- sent comedy, his shy sentiment suffering from frequent betrayal, his temptations to be insin- cere, and all such qualities. Now, our obvious criticism is that in this book this state of mind is the final one. There is, perhaps, too much readiness in the suggestion which one cannot help entertaining, that this is a cropping out of the vice inherent in the modern realist’s theory of work, or bent of mind, as the case may be. The genius of dis- crimination is not among the presiding literary deities of the school. Here, in the study of a group of Italian cities, there are many values in- volved, and they are treated as if equal. The better Italian travellers, those whose pages are most instructive, have reduced their impressions to some sort of order, and have made the reader feel a difference in the worth of the various ele- ments. Mr. Howells pours out his wealth, jew- els and pebbles and glass and pinchbeck, all to- gether. This ignoring of any principle of selec- tion, this democratic assumption that one fact is as good as another, this universal suffrage which gives one vote and only one to each impression, is a denial of real inequalities as patent as any ip politics, and much ha der to defend as a work- ing theory of literature. But we gotoofar. In the present case there does seem to be a choice exercised in the subjects, and the criterion plain- ly is what an editor wou!d call freshness, Certain things are left out, or incidentally mentioned, which are leading features, central facts, in the ensemble of Tuscan towns, because th@y have been over-written, just as the illustrations are no- ticeable rather for the scenes they avoid than for those they give. This may have been astringent necessity of trade, but the result of it isthata character of incompleteness is given to a volume which seems to be at first sight a monograph, These two reservations one is forced to make, on final consideration: one is dissatisfied with the lack of discrimination and with a too exclu- sive novelty. We *ould have soared some of the green paint for alittle more of Giotto’s Tower’ and the dingiest and most bewritten of Cima- bue’s Madonnas would have been quite as wel- come to us as the bride blowing her nose on her new-made husbana’s handkerchief. This discon- tent, however, is not very deeply seated, and when the author leaves his note-books and breathes the air of the [taly that is dear to him, we are at once transported by bis imagina- tion. There are many Italys; each traveller makes one for himself, and that of Mr. Howells is a very charming one, full of passive enjoy- ments of nature and human nature as they are, and faintly touched with the sentiment of tbe past. Notwithstanding his strong historical ia- terest, one feels that his horizons are contempo- rary. His Italy is not the scholar’s or the poet’s, but the modern tourist’s of however high degree; and the tourist has possession of such a multitude of delights there that he cannot fail to please, if he has anything of the raconteur in him. Mr. Howells makes the most of these, and his own tolerant amiability under his trials helps to pass off the unpleasant inconveniences of which he keeps the reader mindful. The artists have not succeeded so wel]. Their work is uneven, inac- curate in effects, not wisely chosen in subject. It is always hard to give ltalian life and scenes in black and white, but when the sketchesare so ragged, broken, and Jean as these, the illustra- tions become a travesty. The Tale of Gamelyn. From the Harleian MS. No. 7554, collated with six other MSS. Edited with Notes and a Glossarial Index by the Rev. Walter W. Skeat. Oxford: The Clarendon Press. In the small compass of sixty-four pages Pro- fessor Skeat has given us a very handy edition of the ‘Tale of Gamelyn,’ which deserved this separate reproduction both from a linguistic and a literary point of view. While it is no longer regarded as written by Chaucer, having been in fact written about the time of Chaucer’s birth (1540), 1t was, doubtless, found by some copyist among his papers, and, if he had lived to com- plete the ‘Canterbury Tales,’ we should, in all probability, have had it worked over and put into the mouth of the Yeoman, to whom Urry (1721) would assign it, as does Mr. Skeat also in his Introduction to the ‘ Prioresse’s Tale.’ The misnomer under which it usually nppears, ‘ The Cokes Tale of Gamelyn,’4s due to its position in the MSS., immediately after the imperfect Cook’s Tale’; but Mr. Skeat says (p. xiv, uote) that this title in the best MS., Harleian 7334, from which he prints, ‘‘ is merely scribbled, as a headline to the pages, in a much iater hand than trat of the original scribe.” From three of the best MSS. of the ‘Canterbury Tales,’ and one other, it is omitted altogether, though it is found in at least ten MSS. The metre alune is suffi- cient to warrant its denial to Chaucer, but the language also has a more archaic cast than his, and justifies the earlier date. Mr. Skeat has provided an excellent Introduc- tion, with notice of the grammar and metre, notes, and a glossary. The Tale belongs to the Robin Hood series, shows close connection with ‘A Poem on the Times of Edward IL ,’ assigned to about 1320, and was written probably not long after the poem. Its language resembles the later writings of Robert of Brunne, and it is a good representative of the East Midland dialect of that period. It has few Scandinavian words —not more than twenty, half of which occur in Chaucer ; and not very many Norman-French words—about a hundred and sixty in the 902 lines of the Tale. It is valuable in literature from having supplied the prototype of Lodge’s novel, ‘ Eupbues’ Golden Legacy,’ on which Shak- spere based his ‘‘ As You Like It.” Mr. Skeat gives a short sketch of the story as it appears in the novel, the latter part of which is unlike the ‘Tale of Gamelyn.’ All other necessary help in understanding the poem is supplied, and it is needless to add that no knowledge of older Eng- lish is required to appreciate it thoroughly. T.e language is no more difficult than that of Chau- cer, but it is surprising how many are deterred from reading even his works merely by the ap- pearance of the antique spelling. The book is well edited and will further the study of Middle English. Faris in Old and Fresent Times. By Philip Gilbert Hamerton. Boston: Roberts Bros. TuIs interesting book is made up of papers con- tributed to the Portfolio by its eoitor. Paris is so rich in historical association, so full of im- portant buildings, so carefully planned and ar- ranged, so brilliantly decorated, and so perfectly cared for and kept up—in short, is so clearly the nearest approach yet made to the ideal city— that one is never weary of reading about it. Mr. Hamerton knows his Paris well, her kistory and her aspect, without being so narrow in his ex- elusive devotion as the pure Paris-lover gets to be, and he is a very observant and sagacious judge of architectural effects, even if a little too catholic. The book is in nearly all respects just what that fortunate person needs who means to reside in Paris a while, with leisure to study it; it can hardly fail to give him generally sound notions of what the famous city has that is most admirable in its external aspects. And yet we have one exception to take: the author is, as we have said, too catholic. Iiis words of praise for the glittering splendor of the new Paris streets are too nearly of equal value with those be gives to really noble architecture. It is to be feared that he really admires far more than they deserve the facades on the Avenue de YOpéra, which seems to be his favorite street. He has missed a chance to appraise properly that curious lack of power over details, that disposi- tion to content themselves with few and poor ideas, if only the exe ution of them is perfect, which marks the Paris-bred architect—the most skilful planner and the best builder of modern times, but a terribly commonplace designer. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Allen, J. G. Topical Studies in American History Rochester: Scranton, Wetmore & Co. Arnold, Matthew. Dramatic and Later Poems. Macmil- lan & Co. Beale, C -E. Gately ’s World’s Progress. Part L M. R. Gately & &Co. 1. Beaufort, Duke of, and Morris, Mowbray. Hunting. Bos- ton: Little. Brown & Co Burne, F. S. J. and Miles, 4. J. A. Tiles from Dame Mar- jorie’s Chimney-: ‘orner. E. & J. B. Young & Co. Chase, W. 1. Civil Governme at in Theory and Practice. Chicago: W. 1. Chase. 75 cents. Colquhoun M.J, Primus in Indis: A Romance. Harper ros. 25 cents. D’Anvers, N. Heroes of American Discovery. George Routledge & Sons. $1.50. D’Alviella, Count G. The Contemporary Evolution of Religious aaa in England, America, and India. Translation. P. Putnani’s Sous. 85. Dargenty, G. Euge ne Delacroix, par lui-méme. Paris: J. Rouam. Duplessis, G. Les Emblémés d’Alciat. Paris: J. Rouam. Du Can, Sir E. F. ‘the Punishment and Preventivn of Crime. diacmillan & Co. $1.00. I rey? Sermons and Outiines on the Old Testament. sameness & Son. $1.54 auuevey. A. Le Style de Louls XIV.: Charles Le Brun, Décorateur. Parts: J. Rouam. Gilder, R. W. | Lyrics and Other Poems. Charles Scrib- ner’s Sons. $1.75. Hadley, A. T. Kailroad Transportation: Its History and its Laws G. P. Putuam’s Sous. $1.50. Heilwag, Chr. Fr. Dissertatio de Formatione Loquele. (1781) Heilbronn: Gebr. Henninger. Hiideburn, C. &. The Issues of the Press in Pennsylva- nia. mene 3 84. Vol I. Philadelphia. Hedgkin, T. Italy and Her Invaders. Vols. I[I. and IV. Oxford : "ihe Clarendon Press. ' Hutchinson,J. The Pedigree of Disease. William Wood &Co. $1.25 In a Good Cause: A Collection of Stories, Poems, and Illustrations. E. & J. B. Young & Co. Ingelow, Jean. Favorite Poems. lllustrated. Boston: Roberts Bros, $5. Ireland, W. W. The Blot yom the Brain. Studies in History and Psychology. P. Putnam’s Sons. $5. Lathbury, Mary A. Idyis ‘of the Months: Foems and Drawings. George Routledse & Sons. $..5¢ La Rounat, C. de. tudes Dramatiques: Le Théatre- Francais, I. Paris: J. Kouam Sleek to sewbatallialad|
Page 27
aa Zs nb PRB fathact naib anager wettest ae 1885 | The Nation. autt LEISURE HOUR SHAKE- SPEARE. The Text of Dyce, with an arrangement of his Glossary, also with a Life of the Poet and an account of each play by A. R. Macfar- lane. In seven volumes. 16mo. §1 per vol. FALCKE'’S GREECE AND ROME. A new and cheaper edition, with over 400 illus- trations. 4to, $10. HENRY HOLT & CO., N. Y The Shakespe Shakespeare Library. Collected by the Eminent Shakespearean, JOSEPH CROSBY, Esq., of Zanesville, Ohio, is now offered forsale en bloc. It contains upwards of 500 titles, embracing more than 1,500 volumes, about equally divided between text and ana. Almost all the principal editions from Rowe's (1709) to the Riverside (1883) are present, and most of the standard Shakespearean criticism and illustrative litera- ture in the English language. Mr Crosby’s studies lay principally in the field of textual criticism. and many of nis books are enriched by numerous marginal notes and emendations neatly written by him in pencil. These, of course, render the Library unique, and, it is believed, ma- terlally increase ita value. The present owners dislike to disperse this valuable collection without giving some gentleman or institution the opportunity to possess it en- tire. Inquiries should be addressed to JOHN J. INGALLS, Zanesville, Ohio. IMPRESA di VENDITE \ SA di Viti : IN ITALY. 37 Corso VITTORIO EMANUELE MILAN. Sale of the splendid GALLERY MOLINARI de CRE MONE. PICTURES by the most distinguished masters of Flemish, Dutch, German, French, Spanish, and Italian schools of the XIVth, XVth, XVIth, and XVIIth centu- ries. The sale at auction will take place in the roomsof the establishment, 37 Corso Vittorio Emanuele, Miian, on the 80th of November, 1885, and following days. On Monday, Rac. 14, 1885, will be sold the collection AGUJARI de TRIESTE of COINS—Roman, Greek, and Italian of Middle Ages. Catalogues will be sent FREE on application to Mr. GENOLINI, Director, at the above address. At prices lower than ever before quoted. Send your address on a postal card, and we will mail you, FREE, a cop: of our 3d ANNUAL FALL CATALOWZE, embracing a choice collection of NEW & OLD old books from private libraries and standard new books, all offered at SWEEPING REDUCTIONS from former prices. ESTES & LAURIAT. 301 Washington St., Boston. r any family, whether large or small, but es- pecially where the number of children is large, a record of the constitutional peculiarities of each one, and the whole course of its physical development in sickness and in health, is certain to be instructive and may prove invaluable. Such a record is Professor J. B. Fonssagrives’s ‘ Mother’s Kegister,’ consisting of a series of tables scientifically arranged for brief and convenient entries. A separate volume for boys and for girls. Price, post-paid, 75 cents per volume, or $1 25 for two volumes Address Publisher of the Nation. f ECORD OF POLITICS and Foliticians in the United States, 1865-1882: An analytical in- dex » the Nation for that period (with occasional paral lel references to McPherson's Political Handbooks and other sources). This index supptems nts the chiefly lite- rary index to the Nation published in 1880. Valuable to all libraries, students, and editors. Price, in paper, #1 00. (Purchasers will please remit with order; ac- counts cannot be cpened.) Address PUBLISHER of the Nation, Box 704, New York City. Unmounted Photographs OF ANCIENT AND MODERN WORKS OF ART, Embracing reproductions of famous original paintings, sculpture, architecture, etc. Price, cabinet size, $1.50 per = Send 6-cent stamp for new catalogue. 5,000 sub ects. SOULE PHOTOGRAPH CO., Publishers, 388 Washington Street, Boston, Masa. Please mentio the Nation. German Simplified. An eminently practical new method fer learning the German language, especially adapted to self-tustruction. 12 Numbers at 10 cents each, sold separately. For sale by all booksellers; sent post paid on receipt of price by Prof. A. KNOFLACH, 140 Nossau St., New York Houghton, Mifflin & Co.'s NEW BOOKS. ran a. - fhe First Napoleon. A Sketch Political and Military. By John Codman Ropes, member of the Massachusetts Historical Soct ety. With Maps, 1 vol., crown Svo, $2.00 Mr. Ropes ts widely known as one of the most compe tent and Jucid writers on military topics. In this book he describes the condition of the great European Powers in Napoleon's time, the circumstances to France which enabled him to vault so snddenly to the supremacy ; anid depicts with worderful vigor and clearness those cam paigna and battles which shook the thrones and changed the map of Europe, and which have an frresistible fasci nation for readers of bistory. ‘ +7 ) n+ "Te . Italian Popular Tales. By T. F. Crane, Professor of the Romance Languages and Literatures in Cornell University. 1 vol, Svo, may A book of curious interest, like Grimm's German Tales containing over a hundred Fairy laies, Tales of Oriental origin, Legendary Tales, Nursery Tales, and Jesis, col lected from all parts of Italy. Equally engaging to young folks and their parents. Bird-Ways. ky Olive Thorne Miller, author of ‘Little Folks in Feathers and Fur,’ ete. 1 vol., 16mo, €1.25 A book describing the daily life and habits of the Robin, the Wood Thrush, the European Song Thrush, the Cat Bird, the Redwing Blackbird, the House Sparrow, and other birds. These essays are at once accurate and de lightfully fresh and interesting. Myrtilla Miner. With a fine Steel Portrait by Wilcox. 16mo, $1.00 This is a story of the heroic age in the struggle between Freedom and Slavery in this country. Myrtilla Miner opened the first school for colores children in Washing ton, and, amid great opposition, persisted in her humane effort. ‘The story of her experience and achtevements in this enterprise is well told, and ought to find a large cir cle of interested readers. 2 . . . > 1g . "10°" The Oldest School in America. An Oration by Phillips Brooks, D.D., and a Poem by Robert Grant, at the celebration of the Two Hundred and rifvieth Anniversary of the Foundation of the Boston Latin School. 1 vol., 16mo, $1.00 The exceedingly interesting address of Dr. Phillips Brooks fitly commemorates the long and noble work of the Boston Latin School, which has trained a muititude of men distinguished in all honorable professions. Missy. Happy-Go-Lucky. Novels by the author of ‘ Rutledge.’ limo, $1.25 each. New Edition *.* For sale by all booksellers. Sent by mai’, post-paid, on receipt of price by the publishers, HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO, BOSTON. 11 East 17th St.. New York. Have } Ou a Ci lection of Books? The Library Catalogue and Index ts intended for pri vate collections. it is arrange so that any book can be entered under author and tite of work. Highly aj proved by those who have used it. The Library Cat logue and Index fs handsomely bound and lettered tn one volume, quarto (63g x84 inches), made of the best paper, and will be mailed, post-paid, to any aadress on receipt of $2. 5u by the publishers, SHEPARD & JOHNSTON, 146 Monroe St., Chicago, I) NO. SEVENTY-EIGHT. A Random Catalogue of CHEAP BOOKS In various de partments of literature, all perfect and in good condi tion. unless otherwise described, and all offered at ex ceptionally low prices to effect a clearance. Sent free by DAVID G. FRANCIS, 17 Astor Place, N. Y. TASH & PIERCE, 8 NASSAU ST., 4 New York, have now ready an interesting Cata logue of books, Inciuding Americana, Local History, Genealogy, and Miscrllaneovs, which will be sent to any address upon application. ” ke YES Fitted with proper Glasses, Field, _ Marine, and Opera Glasses, Telescopes, Micro- a 4 Acoustic Cane for De ess, Ear Cornets, etc E ALDSTEIN, Optician, 41 Union Square, New York. Catalogues by enclosing stamp. 1840. NEW BOOKS Mrs. Herndon's Lucome. A Novel. By HELENS CawreeitL, author of * The What t do Club.’ Gne volume, lOémo Cloth Price, #1 Thisisa story witha purpose a purpose to dogo and it must take its place beside *‘ Ramor Mrs Jack son, Who Was reading tt during | pressed with it that she wrote to the aut ill to write, but l must thank vou for sour eloque pica lf the down-trodden, Your story is tremendousiy strong Nature's Teachings. Human Invention Anti ited by Nature Ry Rev Woop, M. A., author f Hiomes Withou!l hande ‘Natural History,” e « With nearly il rations Svo Cloth. Price, ‘A glarce at almost any pageof this work v « ita object Itis to show the hie oOnnecthen te twee Nature and buman inventions, a that there ts scarcely an invention of man that has not its prototype in Na and it is worthy of notice that tl t vaults has been obtafned from means apparentiy thet s Preface - s pur fre >s Alcott ( GiChAa) ik , 1880. cant The Containing a selection for every day tn t year a] from the writings of the author of e Won y F. Aloutt Pratt ( Demij hn mounted on a cant lustrated with a porireidtof Mise A tranda view of her present residence tn Cor mi. Price, 8 A MAGNIFICENT GIFT BOOK / iT. ; Se VI « Rl ( i HT 4 “ ] if ef i f. The complete Bible text beautifully engrossed and graved, cach page wit a decorative border, the wl illustrated by the most gifted artists with soot es he Holy Land, and imaginativ rterpretations of the read ing. Saysthe Art Ama it ts net inferior t uy American publ tion we know of sit r scopx ustructive historteal introduction by Rev. Kdwa } Hale adds greatly (to Its interest diva One royal querto volur prieted on satin finish pap r and bound in cloth, with elaborate cover design Price 87 SO; mor antique or tree calf, €15 O Favorite Poems. By JEAN INGELOW, Containing three of this gifted author's most admired poclis The Song f Seven The High Tide on vie Coast of Lin shire,” and The Shepherd tady,’ with many of her shorter pieces, in one roval vo vol rds of 100 engravings bys the most celebrated artista, Printed « finish neloth gilt, bevellea with a tolph Church tnserted in the side ume. illustrated with upw n fine satin paper and bout boards bas-relief of St.l Price $5 00 Sold by all lishers, ROBERTS BR‘ booksellers. Matled, postpald ITHERS, 1 by the pub wton KERR PAVEMENT Company, 22 Pine St, New York, September 15. 1885. § MEETING OF THE STOUCKHOLD- 4 era will be held at the ofice of this company on thursday, November 19, at 12 ™., for the purpose of voting on the reduction of the capital stock of the com ny to the sums of two hundred and five thousand dol an Jous H. GaPNEY, F. S. HEISER, . , Ricw. B. TUNSTALI Trustees. R. 8. Ririey, BROTHERS & CO. ee WN, 59 WALL STREET, Iaeve COMMERCIAL anp TRAVELLERS’ CREDITS Yor use tn THis COUNTRY AND ABROAD ORATIO SEYMOUR, /R., LAND Agent of the Michigan Land & Iron Co, (limited) Marquette, Michigan Advice given as the purchase of mineral and timber lands in the Upper Peninsula of Michigan. CHOOL BOOKS IN FOREIGN LAN- guages. Miscellaneous Books In Foreign Languages, Catalogues on application, Fore Periodicals, Caal ScBHOENHOF, Importer, 144 Tremont St., Boston.
Page 28
412 The WNation. [Num Scribner & Welford’s NEW BOOKS. Flying Leaves from East and West. A Journal of Travel in the Orient and through the United States and Canada. By Emily Pfeiffer. Crown 8vo, cloth, #2.25. *.* This book is not a mere repetition of the guide-book, but is a volume of vivid interest and real merit, by a keen-sigated, quick-witted woman. Madame de Maintenon: AN ETUDE. By J. COTTEP MORISON. Square 16mo, parchment, 50 cents. *,* A vivid sketch of the life and times of Ma- dame de Maintenon. Introductory Studies in Greek Art. By J. E. HARRISON, Author ef * Myths of the Odyssey.’ With maps and illustrations. Thick crown 8vo. cloth, $3.00, How to Be Happy, though Marned. BEING A HANDBOOK TO MARRIAGE. By a Graduate in the University of Matrimony. Crown 8yo, cloth, $2 40. *,.* The book is dedicated “to those brave men and women who have ventured, or who intend to venture, into that state which is a blessing toa few, acurse to many, and a great uncertainty to all.” THE DECLINE AND FALL OF WHIST: An Old-fashioned View of New-faugled Play. By the author of ‘ Whist or Bumblepuppy.’ 16mo, cloth, 75 cts. CIRCULATING CAPITAL: INQUIRY INTO THE FUNDAMENTAL LAWS OF MONEY. An Essay by an East India Merchant, author ot ‘The Homology of Economic Justice.’ Small crown 8yo, cloth, $2.40. *,* The volume contains a review of the silver question in the United States, proceeding on the last report of the Comptroller of the Currency, etc., ete, BEING AN Preparing for Immediate Publication : THE MOON: Considered as a Planet, a World, and a Satellite. By JAMES NASMYTH, C.E., and JAMES CARPENTER, F.R.A.S, A NEW AND CHEAPER EDITION. With 26 illustrations of Lunar Objecis, Pheno- mena, and Scenery, produced from Drawings made with the aid of powerful Telescopes, and numerous Woodcuts. Medium 8yo, cloth, $7.50. *,* The above books will be sent upon receipt of advertised price. to those interested. stock will be mailed, if desired, Bohn’s Libraries. A Series of Standard Works of European Literature in the English Language. Full Catalogue sent, post-free, to all parts of the world on application. RECENT ADDITIONS TO THE LIBRARIES. A Guide to the Study of Eng- lish Coins. From the Conquest to the Present Time. By H. W. Henfrey. New and revised edition by C. F. Keary. With a Historical Introduction by the editor. Nume- rous plates. 12mo, $2.40. CENTENARY EDITION. Boswell’s Life of Johnson, With the Tour in the Hebrides and Johnsoniana. New Edition, with Notes and Appendices by the Rev. A. Napier, M.A., Trinity College, Cambridge. Witb Frontispiece to each vol. 6 vols., $8.40. Goldsmith’s Works. A New Edition in 5 volumes, containing pieces hither- to uncollected, and a Life of the Author, with Notes from various sources, By J. W. M. Gibbs. Vol. IV. (just published). Biographies, Criticisms, Later Col- lected Essays. Vols. I., II., [L1. (previously published). Each vol. in 12mo; per vol, $1.40. Coleridge's Miscellanies, Zsthetic and Literary: to which is added The Theory of Life. By Samuel Taylor Coleridge. Collected and arranged by T. Ashe. 12mo, $1.40. | COLERIDGE’S AIDS TO REFLECTION. Con- fessions of an Inquiring Spirit, and Essays on Faith and the Common Prayer Book, New Edition. $1.40. COLERIDGE’S LECTURES AND NOTES ON Shakespeare and other English 4 including Mr. Collier’s transcript of the Lectures of 1811, and the Bristol Lectures of 1813, now first collected. By T. Ashe, B.A. $1.40. COLERIDGE'S FARO S4AEE and OMNIANA. dited by T. Ashe, B.A. $1.4 WALTON’S LIVES -OF DONNE, HOOKER, etc. New Edition. Revised by A. H. Bullen. Wi numerous illustrations. 32. GRIMM’S GERMAN TALES. With the Notes of the Uriginal. A New Translation, by Mrs. A. Hunt. 32 ro Introduction by Andrew Lang, M.A. 2 vols. VASARI’S LIVES OF THE PAtNTERS. (In 6 vols) Vol. Vi., jus’ t panes. being a Commentary, containin, Notes and Emendations from the I[talian Edition of Milaaesi and other sources. By J. P. Rich- ter, Pb.D., autuor of ‘The Literary Works of Leonardo da Vinci,’ &c. $1.40. PLUTARCH'’S LIVES. Newly Transiated with Notes and a Life, by A. Stewart, M.4., late Fellow of Trinity College, Cambridge, and the late George Long, M.A. 4 vols. $5.60. ——— GILBART’S THE HISTORY, PRINCIPLES, = Paw ~ of Banking. Revised to the Year 188] 8. Michie, Deput = r of the Royal Bank a Scotland, London. ortrait of Gilbart. 2 vo —_—— SPINOZA’'S CHTEF WORKS. Translated with introduction, by R. Elwes. 2 vols. ol L Tractatus Theoldyico-Politicus, Political ‘Lreatise. it. a of the Understanding, Ethics, Let- ters. .00, Catalogues of our regular NEW CATALOGUE OF CHOICE, RARE, AND SECUND-HAND BOOKS, READY. New Musical Catalogue ready. SCRIBNER & WELFORD, 743-745 Broadway, N. Y. Charles Scribner's So HAVE JUST PUBLISHED: Children’s Stories in Ameri- can History. By Henrietta Christian Wright. J. Steeple Davis. 1 vol. Illustrated by , 12mo, $1.50. A book which is likely to gaina great popularity for the peculiar charm of its author’s way of story- telling. The spirit and romance with which the stories, from those of Columbus and Balboa and Ponce de Leon and De Soto down to those of the old French War and the Revolution, are presented to the fancy of a child, remind one of Hawthoroe’s treatment of the old myths in the *‘ Wonder-book * and ‘Tanglewood Tales.’ There are aamirable, soirited, and, above all, unhackneyed illustrations of the stones drawn by Mr. J. Steeple Davis. Lyrics and Other Poems. By Richard Watson Gilder. 1 vol., 12mo, $1.75. The volume is divided into five parts: I. Lyrics and Hymns: II. Ballads; LI. Sonnets; IV. Odes and Meditative Poems: V. The New Day. Like the others, it will be handsomely bound and decorated with head and tail pieces, und vignettes between the parts. Stories by American Au- thors. “Cabinet Editiun.” 10 vols., beautifully bound’ gilt top. Ina box, $7.50. This fine edition has been made necessary by the repeatedly expressed demand for this standard collection of American short stores in a form ae for preservation on the library shelf or for gifts. “Never has an equal number of first-rate short stories appeared in the same compass.”—N. Y. Journal of Com- merce. * The series is a capital one, well edited, and evidently meeting a well-defined desire on the part of the reacing public.”—Bos.on Courier. “We co not abate our enthusiasm f@ these stories. py can be relied upon to be the very best.’’—Hartford st. “This well-chosen series of the best short stories Ameri. can literature affords.”’— Boston Adverttzer. The Illustrated Library of Wonders. A new and revised issue ot twenty-four volumes, containing over a thousand beautiful illustra- tions. Each volume 12mo, complete in itself. Sold separately at $1.00 per volume. NEW VOLUMES: BODILY STRENGTH AND SKILL. WONDERS OF OPTICS. WONDERS OF GLASS-MAKING. POPULAR DOLLAR NOVELS. THE LAST MEETING.. By Brander Mat- thews. ROSES OF SHADOW. By T. R. Sullivan. COLOR STUDIES. By T. A. Janvier (Ivo- ry Black). A WHEEL OF FIRE. By Arlo Bates. WITHIN THE CAPES. By Howard Pyle. ACROSS THE CHASM. A Story of North and South, ae *,* These books for sale by all booksellers, or sent, ' post-paid, on recetpt of price, by Charles Scribner's Sons, 743-745 Broadway, New York. ' é H ' meee ILE sp Geter TRE 8 5 ACRE NEA SRG LER LE IAP LOL £ tay
Page 29
oes