The Nation 1884-02-21: Vol 38 Iss 973

Page 1

That each of the one hundred lives THE UNITED S JOSEPH M. GOUDHUE, 3 JAMES H. SLEDGE, Commercial Traveller. . CHAS. S. BOYD, Merchant............ BRACKETT H. BADGER, Merchant... CHAS. J. KING, R. R. Passenger Agent DAVID C. BALLANTINE, Salesman Thomas H. Farr sane W. B. F. Wood William Bennett John O. Marsh........... A. B. JObNSOR.......... George S. Baker Stephen Waldron. > ere , Frank Krender..... ‘ A eee P ’, Hadley James 8. Leeds i eS ay _XXXVIIL—NO. d. Bee. 7O S lost on the ** THURSDAY, FEBRI City of Columbus ” or in the * The United States Mutual Ac It would be necessary, by a like And that every man, woman, and child in the United States were members of said Association ; , VEASONINE, ONE MILLION RECENT DEATH LOSSES PAID BY O'BRIEN, RALZAS. LEE, JUDSON J EXAMPLES ..Philadelphia, Penn. ee ee eT Camden, N. J. Daniel H. Hawes............. .. Detroit, Mich. re Grand Rapids, Mich. Claus Theiessen........... New Holstein, Wis. CHARLES em en Albany, N. Y. 5,000 00 Pena St. Louis, Mo. 5,000 v0 J .Philadelpbia, Penn, 5,000 00 -Fond du Lac, Wis. 5.00000 ALMONB EDWIN A. ROSS, Mere THOMAS RICHARDSON, Salesman $342 86 300 00 Cold Water, Mich. Detroit, Mich. Ithaca, N. Y. New York, N.Y. Portage, Wis. Albany, N. H. ctessneced Chicago, Tl. ..New York, N. Y. Woburn, Mass. Ann Arbor, Mich Macedon, N. Y. .. Toledo, Ohio. Wa Bs OOO. oc cecccccoseces New Haven, W.S. McElree 421 43 432 14 Conn, ..Philadelphia, Penn. .New York, N. ¥ ccccccce New York, N. Y. .. Brooklyn, N. Y. B. PEET, upon the one hundred lives could and would have been paid by atax of Two Cents up THE UNITED § pace Urbano, Ohio, $5,000 00 P. J Waukesha, Wis. 5,000 00 .La Grange, Ga. 5,000 00 Littleton, N. H. . Lincoln, Neb. 5.000 OO 5,000 (0 OF WEE smashed fo infes and when rece RY 22, 1dS4 ’@ CASE in whi _The Nation PRICE PRPOSE Crested Butte Mine” bad been insured in cident As Tmalag Nil DOLLARS n each member STATES MUTUAL ACCIDENT ASSOCIATION had no risks upon that ill fate: although it has fifteen thousand policy-holders, residents of twenty-five hundred different towns and citi gent insurance experts in the United States agree that, by such a system of general average, to the minimum, thus indicating the scund and conservative business management of this Association STATES MUTUAL ACCIDENT ASSOCIATION carries a surp! of proof, and at a saving to the insured of one-half the usual cost of accident insurance in stock com} dred claims, aggregating more than a quarter of a million dollars, and bas no contested nor unpaid with $25 weekly indemnity, is about $12 per annum for assessments, which may be paid at one time To become a member, write for circular and application blank ; \ Secretary at New York, on receipt of which policy will be promptly mailed to you. liability us sufficient t ived, fill out vour THE Travelle BOSTWICK, INDEMNITY Cl Frank C. Lay AIIIE own, N ; Ss Rev. C. W. Powell _...Flatbush, N ao oR 550 00) W. H. Orchard Noroton, Cor s 325 00 George D. Gould Moline Nv 32142 Francis T. Leach nica, Arthur C. King rn M s Henry A. Davis nver, | 4 OO =Wnhm. Storer sai } th, N ( 7500 a. J, Wilkinson Keokuk, Iowa P86 P. Yates Port Brron, N. ¥ ‘ OO Jennie Brownscombe Honesda Penn. 4 Ww ”) George M. Barber Whitehall, N.Y ( oon M. Snow, jr Boscobel, Wis. 448 57 550 00 = Miles T. Houk Norwieh, N.Y Lawrence Geraghty Albany, N. ¥ 4 W. W. Richey Watertown, N.Y 5 John Hammond ph. N. ¥ J.J. Robbins Walcott, Vt " M J. H. Knox roy, N. ¥ . ‘ H.C. Cook 1 k H Pen * 86 Geo. D. Gould n of Rogers, Peet & Co., President. JAMES R. OFFICE, 320 AND 322 BROADWAY, NEW YORK. p claims. The st of ASSOCIA Salesman HOUGH, Ins, W. HIGGINS, Trave EDWIN S BAYNOR, Me DAVID LEWIS. Attorne er pay every valid clain es. It bas paid uy f preferred, Member application, enclose Act and Adjuster hant coo. DG Trave AIMS Kvley an Spear am Rr kerhoff t Straus H. i Ww ft M. Russ 34 W Houg ' Walker as. M. At woo n Hartmann Frees as. Chaskeil Iter I jage J hn ( Ww lins sa nes H. I n PITCHER, sociation, BLN ‘ie ‘Cres 1 es i ‘ tiat ‘ ately ward {twet A’ a ent p fee, $ $5, and forwa Philadelphia, Penn lis, MJ New York, Dallas, Peekskill, N. Y. Grand Kapids, Mich tonwood Springs, Neb W hitveaville Portsmouth, Ohio Waterloo, N. ¥ Secretary. 10 CENTS rnen, N Ringhamton, ? ckport, N Piymouth, Mass Brooklyn, N

Page 2

The Nation.

[ Number 973

The Nation. CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. PE WE oc ccciccccccc ccccccccccccccececsccccesoosese. cece 153 SUMMARY OF THE WEEK's News. covces 156 EDITORIAL ARTICLES: The Aldermen and the Appointing Power.... ..... 158 Stealing News ie 159 The Cape Cod AEE Cok 159 The Oyster In Sctence and Politics oa asae 160) The Fate of Louis XVIL. een besieetiuwnd 16) SPECIAL CORRESPONDENCE Irish Troubles and English Opinion about Them. 162 Vitrolles and the Bourbon Restoration ° 163 German Politics.. ; ‘ : CORRESPONDENCE : The ‘Breadwinners’ and ‘Democracy.’............ 165 Mongolian and Indian Noses Ee Guides to Whist-Playing. seve ee The Abuse of Law-Making............00..sseeeseeeees 166 IRE MEIING nn gcavanabeese ceceeccacesdece 166 The New Public Lands Problem..............s00+. 166 The Cause of the Depression in Business sone 167 Cabinet Officers in Congress . seeescee ae OEE, ciinne Sadccectaddomssenneessussinacssacsedocdseses 168 REVIEWS : Schiiemann’s Troja.—I penedneedaneesudadenenenes 170 Books About the Stage éneennus n ince: ae Coéperative House keeping oxane éinwe éesaue. Ge Sepulture ease 173 Aboriginal American Authors and their Produc- CIOS... ccc ° ° ‘ . 174 BooKS OF THE WEEK. inacttnberéndesedinseeneandneesten 460 174 FINE ARTS The Water-Color Exhibition.—II.............. « 8S TER MS. OF SUBS( 'RITPION. Three Dollars per year, in advance, postpaid to any part of the United States or Canada; to foreign coun- tries comprised in Postal Union, Four Dollars. The date when the subscription expires is on the Ad- dress-Label of each paper, the change of which to a aub- sequent date becomes a receipt for remittance. No other receipt is sent unless requested. The paper is stopped at expiration of the subscrip- tion, unless previously renewed, Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter or by check or postal order payable to Publisher of the NATION. When a change of address is desired, both the old and new addresses should be given. Address THE NATION, Box 794, New York. Publication Office, 210 Broadway. Scale of Agate lines, 7ERMS OF ADVERTISING. | No devtation.]| On any page not specified, 15 cents per line — each insertion ; with choice of page, 20 cents. A column (140 lines), $20 each insertion ; with ~ —+s choice of page, $27. — A page (3 columns), $60 each insertion; with — chotce of position, $80. ae 10 Double rates for top of column or other pre-— ferred position, when specified ; where positions — are not specified, advertisements are classified as — far as possible and arranged in order of size, the largest at the top. = Double rates for cuts, fancy or other letters not — comprised tn THE NATION fonts, and all other special typography. (Subject to approval.) Cuts are inserted only on inside pages of cover or fly-leoves not on out- side of cover, nor on pages numbered for binding. Marriage and Death Notices, 50 cents each. DISCOUNT on yearly accounts amounting to $500, 10 per cent.; $750, 15 per cent.; $1,000, 20 per cent.; $1,250, 25 per cent. Credits are made December 31. On a yearly account amounting to 52 pages the discount ts one-third. Advertisementa must be acceptable tn every respect. Copy recetved until Tuesday, 5 P.M. THE NATION ¢s sent free to those who advertise in tt, as long as advertisement continues. The EDITION of THE NATION this week is 8,000 coptes. The Subscription List ts always open to inspec- tion. 15

- Domestic. YES Fitted with fester Glasses. Field, 1 _« Marine, and Opera asses, Telescopes Micro- scopes, Acoustic Cane for Deafness, Ear ag ete. H. WALDSTEIN, Uptician, 41 Union uare, Mew York. Catalogues by enclosing stamp. Estab ished 1840, ESSRS. COTTIER & CO., Domestic Artistic Furniture makers 144 Fifth’ A Ave., N. Y.

Decoration. ESSRS. COTTIER & CO., High-class Interior Decoration, 144 Fifth Avenue, New fork. Artists in Stained Glass.

) OOD MANTELS AND MIRRORS, Open Fire- Places for Wood or Coal, Tiles, ete., ete. T B, Stewart & Co.. 75 W. Twenty- third St., N. Y. Painter, Decorator, W. J. McPHERSON, Designer, and Stained-Glass Manufacturer. 440 Tremont Street, Boston.

For Sale. T MESSRS. COTTIER & CO.’S, Im- ported Pictures, highest class. 144 Fifth Ave., N.Y. I he SALE. — VILLON SOCIETY’S Book of the snaeennd Nights and One Night. John Payne. Aadress H. &. R., care of Nation. Professional. HARLES W. HASSLER, Counsel in Railway Litigations, 120 Broadway, N.Y. OSEPH F. RANDOLPH. New Jersey Law Offices, Jersey City, N.J., & 120 Broadway, N.Y. Vein SRS. COTTIER & CO., Designers in 4 npfertee Decoration and all Art- ‘work, 44 Fifth ve., N. W. ie Me PHER SON, , Inter ‘shania 440 Tremont Street, Boston.

Schools. Alphahetized, first, by States; second, by Towns. CONNECTICUT, Lyme. , Bruce HALL SCHOOL.--. ou the Pennsylvania Railroad. Th he school wi lopen September 12. “New York, Nanuet, Roc —" Co. : : OUNTRY HOME.—A_ small family, without children, offer a good home and best of care for two or three children, or invalids. Tuition for children if desired. Terms moderate. Highest refer- ences. Address : : Box 32, Nanuet, N. Y. NEW YORK, salem. “ZT. PAUL’S HALL.—A happy Home School for 14 boys under 14. Four instruc tors.

New Youx, Suspension Bridge. E VEAUX COLLEGE. —Prepares for the Universities, ete. Terms, $350 per annum.

WILFRED H. Munro, A. M., President. “NEW York, Ut A RS. PIAT T° *'s SCHOOL for Young Ladies. The next school year begins Wednesday, Sept. 1f 19, 1883. _ Applications should be made early.

NNSYLVANIA, 4 hiladelphia, 1350 Pine Street. iss ANABLE’S English and French Boarding and Day Sc hool +8 Oe Ladies. The thirty- fifth year begins Sept. 19, 188: PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, Chestnut Hiil, RS. WALTER D. COMEGYS and Miss Bell’s French and English Boarding and Day School for Young Ladies will reopen, Sept. 21. — Spring term, hte VERMONT, Barre. f ARRE ACADEMY. 4 second year, begins March 4. Classical and Eng- lish courses. German, French, elocution, military drill. Board, with room, and ———. course, $43 per term. Healthful and charm bie E DW ARD Z. DU Tel HE Ry A.B., Prine Ipal. — PROVINCE OF Qu EBEC, Sorel. as INCOLN COLLE GE, Sorel, Lower Can- « ada.—Preparation for business and the Universi- ties. All the regular masters Oxford and Cambridge men, or from the University of France. Great facilities for learning thoroughly French, Ger- man, Classics, Mathematics, English, and Science. Thirty- five acres of pla ygrounds ; ood boating on the se Lawrence and Hichelieu Rivers. Noys received from nine to sixteen; may stay till nineteen. Terms, $320 to $400 per annum. Circulars on —— ation to the Prin- cipal, ENRY JULIAN L YALL. — GERMANY, Hannover, | 52 Grosse Barlinge. TSS HILKEN’S Boarding- School Youns' Ladies. Address H. G. HILKEN, Box $33, Baltimore, M Norwood Avenue

ROCK WA- y -TEACHE RS’ “AGE NC y, Times Building, Chicago, will qupply superinten. dents. grade teachers, specialists with positions in Cen- tral, W W estern, and | Sout ern States for ensuing year. THE HARVARD UNIVERSITY CAT- alogue for 1883-84 1s for sale by Charles W. Sever, Cambridge; C upples. Upham & Co., 283 W ashington St., passen ; and W. Christern, 37 West 23d St.. New York Price e, 50 cents. OARD A BROAD. —For full partic ulars s as to residence, gentlemen, ladies, or children, in German families in Berlin, Dresden, Hanover, ad dress L. MITCHELL, ?2 Beck Hall, Cambridge. g4RST CLASS BOARD, in a small Capital of Germany, especially recommended to parents wishing to fs the ir children a Europea an education. Address BERNHARD GERHAKD, 53 Arndt Strasse, Leip zig, Germany. fe the g ure of FITS Seg From Am, june vy Medicine: Dr. Ab. Meserole (late of London), who makes a spe elalty of Epilepsy, has without — treated and cured more cases than any other living physician. His success has simply been astonishing: we have heard of cases of over 20 years’ standing successfully cured by him. He has published a work on this disease, which he sends, with a large bottle of his wonderful cure, free, to any sufferer who may send their express and P. O. address. We advise any one wishing a cure tu address Dr. AB. MESEROLE, No. 96 John St... New York. CONSUMPT ION. I have a positive remedy for the above disease. its use thousands of cases of the worst kind, and a ong standing, have been cured. Indeed, so strong is my faith in its —- that I will send TWO BOTTLE FREE, together with a VALUABLE TREATISE on this disease to any sufferer. Give Express and P. O. adc>ess. Dk. T. A. SLOCUM, 181 Pearl Street, New@ja tm

A Leading London Physician estab- lishes an Office in New York

Page 3

Feb. 21, 1884)

The Nation.

GAS I 1X’ r U RES NEWEST AND CHOICEST DESIGNS, Metal and Porcelain Lamps, Fine Clocks.

Anentirely new assortment of the choicest productions of Paris, Vienna, Berlin, and other European cities, selected by us with great care this season ea _,. are now on exhibition in our Artistic Bronszes. showrooms, which have been fitted up with special regard to the exhibiton of Art Pro ductions, and to an inspection of which a cordial invita tion is extended. Also articles of Ornamental Metal Work, both antique and modern, in great variety and elegance of workman ship. Mantel Sets. MITCHELL, VANCE & CO., 836 and 838 Broadway and 13th Street, N. Y.

PIANOS » Preferred by Leading AWARD CENTENNIAL 1570. AWARD 1881 and 1882. Artists. HIGHEST HIGHEST MONTREAL 149 to 155 East 14th St. New York. FERRY S SEEDANNUAL FOR 1884 Will be mailed FREE to all applicants, and to customers of last year without ordering it. It contains illustrations, prices, descriptions, and directions for planting all Vegetable and Flower Seeds, Plants, ete. INVALUABLE TO ALL, D. M. FERRY & CoO., Detroit, Mich. NRA ea SS 1884-—SPRINCG—1884. Now is the time to prepare your orders for NEW “and KARE Fruit and Ornamental shrubs, Ev SEereene. ROSES, VINES, ETC. Beside smany desirable Novelties; we offer the largest and most « ‘omple te general Stoc kK of Fruit and Orna = nts ulTreesinthe U.S. Abridged Catz gio ue mailed Address ELLWANGER ARRY,. Me. Hope Nurserics, R oN Bg N.Y.

The earliest and most valuable Raspberry; arly Harvest Blackberry, Atlantic & ! aw berries; send for details. The largest ondp xo SD ALL FRU TS in the U.S.. inclu- Jllustrated catalogue, t, Row to plant, and how to getand grow Feuit Jan te filjed with useful tnformation on fruit culture, free. OVETT, Little Silver, New Jersey. . yeti bert Kaspberry and Mancheate: Strawderne

SHORT ROUTE TO LONDON, NORTH GERMAN LLOYD MAIL S. S. LINE. The steamers of this Company will sail every Wednes lay and Saturday from Bremen Pier, foot of Third Street, Hoboken. KATES OF P ASSAGE Ra LONDON, HAVRE, AND BREMEN Lc - $80 and §100; II. Cabin, $60 ; Steerage, at low est rate OELRICHS & CO., AGENTs, F. W. CHRISTERN, 37 West Twenty-third Street, New York, importer of Foreign Books, Agent for the leading Paris Pub lishers, Tauchnitz’s British Authors, Teubner’s Greek and Latin Classics. Catalogue of stock mailed on jemand. A large assortment always on hand, and new books received from Paris and Leipzig as soon as issued. 7 THIRTY-NINTH ANNUAL REPORT ~ New-York Life Insurance Co. OFFICE, Nos. 346 and 348 BROADWAY, N.Y. JANUARY 1, Amount of Net Cash Assets, January 1, REVENUE > LSsa4 1883 ACCOUNT. S&S.OLS,5L5.01 Premiums $11,489 042 68 Less deferred premiums January 1, 1883 540,555.91 $10,948 48¢ Interest and Rents (including realized gains on real estate sold) 3,038,863 95 Less Interest accrued January 1 1883 326,000.06 2.712. 863 $9 -$13.66!.350 66 8S62,579,865.77 DISBURSEMENT ACCOUNT.

Losses by death, including reversionary adait $s to same $2.263.092 29 Endowments, matured and discounted, includu } reversi ary additions to same 452 229 80 Annuities, dividends, and returned premiums on cancelled policies 3,984,068 31 Total Paid Policy-holders $6.699 390 40 Taxes and re-insurances "62. 492.94 Commissions, |brokerages, agency expenses and physicians’ fees 1.6902 13 Office and law expenses, salaries, advertising, printing, &&c 449 9275 44 $9 8s 833.177.819.809 ASSETS. Cash in bank, on hand, and in transit (since received $1,.393.615.02 Invested in United States, New York City and other stocks (market value $25,455,743.81) 2 390 690 a8 Real Estate 4.508.779 39 Bonds and mortgages, first lien on real estate, (buildings th sured for $18,316,000.00 and the policies assigned to the com y as ad ditional collateral security y 20 681 47! Temporary loans, (secured by stocks, market value, $1,624 887 { 393 * Loans on existing policies, (the reserve held by the ¢ yMpany these policies amounts to $2,570,617.00 ; aot 445 *Quarterly and semi-annual premiums on existing policies, due subse quent to January 1, 1884 645.047 46 *Premiums on existing policies in course of transmission and e is S Agents’ balances 104,216 55 Accrued Interest on investments, January 4, 1884 362.272.15—$53.477.849 89 Excess of market | value of sec nities over cost 2.06 2.83 “4 detailed sch 7 filed with the insuran Cash Assets, January 1, 1884, - $55,542,902.72 ' ' . Appropriated as follows: Adjusted losses, due subsequent to January 1, {SS4 $751.493 43 Reported Losses, awaiting proof, &c 359 368 60 Matured endowments, due and unpaid (claims not presented 29 ; Reserved for re-insurance on existing policies: pa “ipating insurance at 4 per cent. Carlisle net premium; non-participating at 5 per cent Carlisle net premium 47.6238.7347 Reserved for contingent liabilities to Tontine Dividend Fund, January 1, 1883. over and above a 4 per cent reserve on existing policies of that class $2 ¢.372.%¢ Addition to the Fund during 1883 for surplus and matured reserves 1.416 939 00 DEDUCT— $5,. 3S ARCHIBALD H WELCH, HN M. FURMAN EDWARD MARTIN, WILLIAM H. BEE} THEODORE M. BANTA. Cashier MORRIS FRANKLIN, President, D. O'DELL, Superintendent of Agencies. HENRY TUCK, M.D., A. HUNTINGTON, M.D., WILLIAM H. BEERS, Vice-President and Actuary. HENRY TUCK, 2d Vice-President. ; Medical Examiners

Page 4

lv NOW READY. Life and Times of the Rt. Tlon. Fohn Bright. “The 1 volume, large Svo, nearly 600 By William Robertson, Historian of Rochdale.” portrait of Extra cloth, pages, with an elegant etched John Bright as a frontispiece. beveled boards, £2.50. A complete and exhaustive biography of one of England's greatest orators, brought down to the pres ent time.” f:nergy im Nature. By William Lant Carpenter, B.A., B.Sc., Fellow of the Chemical and Physical Societies, and of the Society of Chemical Industry; Lec turer for the Gilchrist Educational Trust. With eighty illustrations. 1 volume, 8vo, $1.25. The purpose of this book is to to the general reader, in simple and untechnical language, an exposi tion of the modern doctrine of Energy (in organic as well as inorganic nature), and of the meaning and con- sequences of that very important principle known as the Conservation of Energy. Great pains Rave been taken to bring the book fully up to date in the subjects of which it treats, to avoid as far as possible the use of technical terms, and to explain them very clearly whenever they are used for the first time. "a a ae finglish Poetesses. By Eric 8S. Robertson, M.A. tup, 12mo, $1.50, Extra cloth, gilt This volume takes up an interesting and hitherto ne- glected chapter tn the history of our literature. Begin ning with an account of Katherine Philips—the “Match less Orinda” of Charles I1.’s time—it brings us down to the youngest of ourliving poetesses. The life of each writer is given; her work is illustrated by characteris tic extracts; and her merits as a writer are critically exemined. The book is thus at once a collection of in teresting biographies and an anthology of the poetry written by Englishwomen. Send for Complete Catalogue. CASSELL & CO., 739 & 741 Broadway, New York. AGENTS WANTED TO SELL DRAKES New tingland Legends. For the first time the old Romantic Legends, Weird Chronicles, Popular Superstitions, and Vulgar Errors of our ancestors are collected by an authority thoroughly competent. Quaint and spirited illustratiors of the topics, costumes, or manners, lend a charm of their own, and make this a book of great interest and value to every American, while to every New Englander, whether at home or located elsewhere, it is an heirloom absolutely indispensable LIMITED, Sold only by subscription. Sample copies mailed on receipt of price—$3.50, cloth; $4.00, gilt; $5.00, morocco, Apply for terms to ROBERTS BROTHERS, Publisbers, Boston, Mass. Unmounted Photographs OF ANCIENT AND MODERN ART Embracing reproductions of famous original paintings, sculpture, architecture,etc. Price, cabinet size, $1 5u perdozen. Send 6-cent stamp for new catalogue, 5,000 subjects. SOULE PHOTOGRAPH CO., Publisbers, 338 Washington Street, Boston, Mass. Please mention the Nation. WORKS OF ( UATALOGUE NO. 17, BEING ODDS - and Ends from the Literary Junk shop of A.S. CLARK, 34 Park Row, ready in a few days and mailed to any address. [Number 973

NOW READY. Price 30 cents ; annual subscription, $3. ° 9 ° Macmillan’s Magazine. No, 292, FEBRUARY. Contents : 1. ™ Expansion of England. ey. 2. The Winter Exhibition. 5. The Literature of Introspection, II. 4. The Wizard’s Son. By Mrs. Oliphant. Chap. 45-48, 5, A Serbian Poet. 6. A Lady’s Railway Journey in India. By C. F. Gordon Cumming. 7. Note on a Good Work. 8 Review of the Month. By Jobn Mor- Price 15 cents ; yearly subscription, $1.50. THE ENGLISH ILLUSTRATED MAGAZINE. No. 5. FEBRUARY. Articles. Frontispiece. —The Loving Cup. Engraved by J. D. Cooper from the painting by D. G. Rossetti. Authors. The author of ‘John An Uvsentimental Journey Halifax, Gentle through Cornwall. With Ii man.’ lustrations, The Post-office. With Illustra- tions by Harry Furniss. R. L. Stevenson. The «character of Dogs. Tlus- trated by Randolph Caldecott. Grant Allen. The Humming Bird’s Relatives. Illustrated by Whymper. Walter Besant. Julia. Chap. L.-IV. Augusta Webster. The Campagna. Charlotte M. Yonge. The Armorer’s Prentices. Chap. X.-XII. Ornaments, Initial Letters, etc. A NEW ENGLISH DICTIONARY ON HISTORICAL PRINCIPLES. Founded mainly on the Materials collected by the Philological Society. Edited by JAMES A. H MURRAY, LL.D., President of the Philological Society. Part I, A—Ant. 4to, $3.25. Oxford: Clarendon Press; New York: Macmillan & Co. Will be ready on Saturday: THE CUP AND THE FALCON. By ALFRED, LORD TENNYSON. 16mo. $1.00, Also, The Works of Alfred Ten- nyson, Poet Laureate. Witb Steel Portrait. 12mo, cloth, plain, $1.50; extra gilt, with gilt edges, $2. This new Popular Edition of the Poet Lau reate’s writings has been corrected throughout by the author, is printed from new type, and contains a new Portrait engraved on steel. Notes on the Caucasus. By WANDERER. 8vo, $2.50. ‘**A most valuable, and, in addition to that, a most entertaining, account of the Caucasus of to-day, by one wbo has lived in it and knows it well. Tbere is no bock extant which so happily and so accurately describes the Russian charac- ter.”"— Vanity Fair. MACMILLAN & CO., 112 Fourth Avenue, New York.

Scribner & Welford’s NEW BOOKS. THE PHILOSOPHY OF WHIST. An Essay onthe scientific and intellectual aspects of the modern game. In two parts. Part l—The Philosophy of Whist Play. Part IT.—The Philoso phy of Whist Probabilities. By William Pole, au thor of ‘The Theory of Whist.’ 16mo, cloth, full gilt, $1.40. HORACE WALPOLE, AND HIS World. Select Passages from his Letters. Edited by L. B. Seeley, M.A. With eight fine portraits after Sir Joshua Reynolds and Sir Thomas Lawrence Crown 8vo, cloth, $2. A few copies on large paper, $5. *,* We offer tothe general reader some specimens of Walpole’s correspondence. Students of history and students of literature are familiar with this great mine of facts and fancies, but itis too extensive to be fully explored by the general reader, and these selections from letters which Walter Scott pronounced the best in our language, and which Lord Byron declared incompa rable, will open to the many a wide field of entertain ment and instruction. ra

Bohn’s Libraries. New Volumes. I. DYER’S|Dr.| THE CITY OF Its Structure and Monuments. With illus trations. 12mo, cloth (lilustrated Library), $2. TIT, COLERIDGE’S LECTURES and Notes on Shakspere and other English Poets, in cluding Mr. Collier’s Transcript of the Lectures of 1811, now first collected. By T. Ashe, B.A. Post 8vo (Bohn’s Standard Library), $1.40. Rome:

y , . rc7™pD " DON JOHN OF AUSTRIA; OR, Passages from the History of the Sixteenth Century, 1547-1578. By the late Sir William Stirling-Maxwell, Bart., author of ‘Annals of the Artists of Spain,” ete. With very numerous illustrations engraved on wood, including portraits, drawings of shipping, pieces of armor, weapons of war, costumes, ete. iaken from authentic contemporary sources. Li brary Edition. 2 vols., royal 8vo, cloth, $20, “This is a work of monumental learning and indus try, and as such deserves the highest respect. It is the fruit of a life of learned leisure, and has all the com- pleteness which is the result of entire devotion toa task by one who was free from the hindrances which too often prevent a student from reaching the thorough- ness to which he aspires. Sir William Stirling-Max well had the opportunity of searching everywhere for literary and artistic memorials of his hero. He has gathered together everything that can be found rela ting to Don John of Austria, and has arranged his ma terials in an ample and orderly narrative. . . . Itisa fascinating subject for an inquiring mind, and affords scope for much curiosity, and leads into many fields of research, Into all of these Sir William Stirling-Max well has gone, and has left nothing untouched by his industry.”—Academy TURENNE, SA VIE ET LES Institutions Militaires de son Temps. Ouvrage con tenant il planches en chromolithographie et 131 gravures sur Bois. Imperial 8vo, morocco back, cloth sides, full gilt, $13.50. THE ROYAL COOKERY BOOK. (Le Livre de Cuisine). By Jules Gouffé, Chef de Cuisine of the Paris Jockey Club. Translated from the French and Adapted for English use by Alphonse Gouff:, Head Pastry Cook to the Queen. Compris ing domestic and high class cookery. With 16 large colored plates and 161 woodcuts, from drawings from nature. New edition. Imperial 8vo, cloth, extra gilt, $15.00. “By far the ablest ard most complete work on cook ery that has ever been tubmitte i to the gastronomical worla.”—FPall Mall Gaze icc. HISTORY OF THE KNIGHTS of Malta; or, Order of St. John of Jerusalem. By Whitworth Porter. Revised edition, with portraits, maps, and other illustrations. 8vo, cloth, $8.40. *,*The above books are for sale by all booksellers, or will be sent upon receipt of advertised price. Catalogues of rare and curious second-hand books, MUSICAL LITERA TURE, and detailed lists of our reguiar stock, will be- sent, on application, by SCRIBNER & WELFORD, 745 Broadway, New Ss >

<n sry coldbiieade bs a ae

Page 5

ae ENOL PO +3 karate

The Nation.

NEW YORK, THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 21, 1884. The Week 1e Cek, [ur story of the Berlin correspondent of thi London / , that Prnee Bismarck had re turved the Congressional resolution of condo ence over Herr Lasker's death, has been con firmed Bismarck is not a well-mannered man, but we believe it will be found on ex amination that he never bitherto has pub licly insulted any body gratuitously or witbout an object. He bas made much use of publicly insulting language in his remarkable career, but always when he wished eitber to drive somebody out of office, or produce a diplo matic complication. If Lasker were still liv ing and a power, however smail, in German politics, we should be quite prepared to see Bismarck insult or snub even the American Congress, if he wished to discredit him, or express his contempt for him. But Lasker is dead, and before be died had ceased to be formidable to the Government, and in fact was atthe time of his death only the shadow of a great name—the wreck of a man who had played a part in German politics of which, as an intellectual feat simply, any Ger man might be proud, and Bismarck 1s a very good German. Morcover, he knows enough of Congress to know how readily resolutions like these are voted, and how little acquaint nee the bulk of the members possess with foreign polities, and, therefore, how unneces- ry it is to take them in bad_ part His csent performance appears to be unlver i!!y condemned both at home and abroad, nd it rema ps thus far inexplicable. Weare, suld appear, bowevcr, to have an explana tion of it from himself, and must wait for that before discussing it moretully. It is reported that he bases bis action on “thigh political prin ples,” but, until he is beard from, the world will incline to the belief that it is based on sciatica, or some form of the indigestion from whieh bis friends and admirers bave heard with so much regret that he has of late been a sufferer. There has been no material improvement in business during the past week, although symptoms of the usual stirrings of spring trade have been felt here and there. The floods in the Obio Valley have caused enor mous losses to the agricultural, manufac- turing, and mining interests within sweep of the waters, altbough resulting in very litue loss of life considering the magnitude of the The demand for iron, which is a fairly good index of the state of trade, is steady at the reduced output, but cannot be calamity. said to be increasing. It is probably safe to say that changes from this time forward must be for the better. The demand tor cotton goods shows some slight improvement. The indica tions are that ** hard pan” has been reached in this trade also. Business failures for the week are reported by Bradstreet at 243 in number, being 14 less than the previous week, and 22 more than the corresponding week of last year. It is noticeable, however, that the average habilities to each failure are smal sustained through the abset S82 per cent. being traders whose capital was f\) \ under $5,000, Business at the S < Exchar fr \ has been entirely under th ! f pulators Phis meons eh thi sama ~ pus 1 demand ‘ })! es bave b I urs \ { instance of the lar speculators, S mi I | as there was might be denominat market, but only in’ the sense tl the bear W appear to be willing to see a higher range of | should t te \ prices established before ** gettin on top of Vil nv then iv” agai Sterling exchange advanced to astonishment of thes ! s the specie-shipping point one day,and remains showed such R close to that point now, but no gold has been cratic majority of nearly actually exported—or none worth mentioning Vious year Was nearly ot | ! been no canvass “ s The bill under discussion in the Senate to and little money, vet the ‘ amend the National Banking law sothat cir unusual spirit and culating notes may be issued upto the par value of the bonds deposited, is an improv: a , ‘ ment on the existing law, which limits such Wiestals tae ‘. ‘ circulation to 90 per cent. of the par thet “tty value, yet it is doubtful whether this amend a} Reiner Qe \ ment will suftice to check the retirement ot : «the G - bank circulation as the per cent. t sal i . cailedin and redecmed. Furtber rehef might ; * easi'y be granted by repealing the tax : ; W bank circulation in whole or in part, v : is one of the things which Congress! ubpaccountably reluctant to d W body is erving out for measures t ss : pu rever found ; \ there is no plac \ touch the tarifl : ‘I protected 1 ! r Ww or copper miners, or sugar planters, or W choppers will suffer. You must the bank tax, becaus I . \ : \\ i = un by it You 1 st not X on whiskey and 1 b s thes a : 41 articies Of vice i Xur ind s i : last is a perfectly valid reasot ! existing taxes, and because it is so there ts ae the more reason for getting 1 supe . , : - eX duties and imposts on other things rt X : on bank circulation is abso!ut I lless f ‘ \ t t ! purposes of venu s “ ind just to retain it if t <s \ : . i pr s fr their cir vi ) es | be proper to reta ‘ . . . are A Mahone oven if the Govern t I t »® ( vith vet, with the pros : i ‘ \ 6 ail 7 traction ¢ \ POUL I : aro , : quite UbDACK ( s ss s i ; be So ppos \ it iX I | s Repu i st Committee Senator Hawley ssvs R i Ex l 1a ( wwoon Wedresduy, and cutive Congress ( . i : smem't ealed a strenvth YY he ¢ | wl has | ed Ss an indication So v ow R \ y be w swe] | ( like a burricanc pay of Gov I I rs s vere f Lio} n his favor t!at it n x ; i i pur rae it he was sure to have thirty ibe | “ = . " ' ’ siblv forty-one of the State’s dele have State Committees s nstituted as not to ites to the National Convention As there include «-fice-bolders. We trust tbat these i will be only forty-tour delegates, this will bes tentions wil be strictly carried out. If thev | handsome majority. Not many reasons were are, we bave not the least doubt that the gain | given for this flattering support, but the Sena in moral force to the Republican Presidential | tor’s gallant fight agair st Fitz-John Porter was

ticket will fully equal whatever loss may be universally regarded as constituting an all-suffl

Page 6

154 cient issue This canvass strikes us as giving the Logan boom a powerful impeti and we Shall be very much surprised if some demon stration is not made by Mr. Blaine’s friends to counteract. it A fresh bulletin about the exact condition of the ‘historical work ” at th moment, coupled with a deelara tion that Mr. Blaine will under no circum stances consent to be a candidate, because it would break up his practice of going to bed at 9:30, would undoubtedly have a powerful effect The verdict of the 7? places the blame for the bad management of teus Court of Inquiry the Greely Relief Expedition mainly upon General Hazen, of the Signal Service. The court is of the opinion that while he had the best and in some of the gravest latentions, ‘‘in many particulars, moment, he failed in an of the the measures and means essential to meet them.” This coincides with the view of all impartial persons who have followed the de- A more recklessly adequate comprehension necessities of the case, and of velopments of the inquiry. mismanag¢d expecition than this one was it would be difficult to conceive. It is to be hoped that in sending out the second one, as now proposed, General Hazen will be allowed to have nothing whatever to do with the arrangements, The court of inquiry, while blaming bim, leniently exonerates bim from ‘‘wilful neglect or intentional dereliction of duty,” and, after mature deliberation, con- cudes that no further proceedings before a general court-martial sre called for. The least punishment which can be accorded him is a retusal to allow bim tobave any official con trol over tuture expeditions Mr. Babb, an Iowa legislator, has forwarded usacopy of a joint resolution he has intro duced inthe Legislature of his State on the subject of divorce It declares our present system one of “‘legalized polygamy,” and adds that the trouble mainly grows out of the *‘diverse systems of procedure and causes of l’urther, it declares reform by constitutional amend imapracticable, and that ‘‘the method of procuring the divorce” in the different States. ment to be only practical desired uviformity of action on this subject, as well as on laws pertaining to mer- cantile paper, methods of conveyancing, and other subjects upon which such uni formity is so necessary to the good of the common whole, is by concert of action on the part of the several States and Territories themselves.”’ Therefore, it directs the Gover nor of lowa to call for a general convention of States and Territories (each to send two representatives), to be held at the capital of lowa a year from next May, to take all these subj: cts into consideration, and to recommend ) suitable legislation to the various States. When the convention meets, if it ever does meet, it will apparently, by the terms of tbe resolution, be precluded from recommending any constiiutional amendment on the sub- Babb that The study of our institu- tions has no doubt made him familiar with ject. We would suggest to Mr this is unwise. The Nation. | Number 973 the fact that even the Constitution of the United States was tbe result of a movement started by a convention of a few States, cailed to consider tbe necessity of a uniform commer cial system; and that in those early days there were conservatives who dreaded, just as he does now, any change in the fuvuda. meptal law. Yet it was fousd, as Ban croft and other hitstoriaus have shown, that could not be obtained without anew Constitution. This was felt to be a dreadful step toward centralization, and yet uviformity we have survived it, and so it is possible that we might survive a change giving Congress the right to pass a uniform law, at least on the subject of marriage and divorce. — Is it wise, we would ask Mr. Babb, in the light of history, absolutely to preclude his con- vention trom considering whether a consti- tutional amendment would not be better than the plan of giving advice to State Legisla Lures 7 Our Japanese contemporary, the Jiyu Shiin- bun, commenting on the treatment of the Chi- nese by the United Siates Government, quotes the suggestion of the Nation that the only way to make the law for their exclusion really efficacious is to ‘* authorize the summary slaughter of ali Cbinamen found within the couutry after a certain date, and to offer a re- ward for the heads of all Chinamen caught after another siill later date,” and_ that ‘‘in no other way can our Christianity be saved from the debasing influence of these heathen.” The Jiyu Shimbun is much shocked by this, and though ‘tit does not believe that the Government will adopt such a pian, its being publicly urged strikes it with astontsh ment.” Not satistied with prohibiting the entry of the Mongolian race on their territory, contemporary, of the Celes- murderous measures,”’ f the Amcricans, ‘clamor for the tials by the most All this shows how necessary a knowledge ¢ says our expulsion foreign manners is to the proper understand ing of foreign figures of speech. The editor of the Jiyu Shimbun, without knowing how rare wholesale slaughter of foreigners was ameng us, could of course see nothing ironi- cal in the suggestion that Chinamen found But he may have been reading accounts of ‘‘ fam- ily feuds” in the Soutbern papers, and been thus prepared to consider ‘‘ murderous mea- a favorite American solution of troubles among us should be slaughtered. sures” of one sort or another. Mr. Thomas’s bi!] to prevent stock-watering was discussed in the State Senate on Thurs- cay. We believe it passed tbe Senate last year, and it is a very stringent measure. It prevents the issue or sale of any part of the stock of any corporation ‘‘ until the nominal (par) value sball have been paid in money into such corporation.” By another section every corporation is obliged to keep its share list open to inspection by sharebolders, the Attorney-General, in person or by proxy, or, in the case of railroads, by the Railway Commissioners. Any violation of the law is made punishable by fine and imprisonment. The second of tbe provisions seems a very good one, but the first is open to serious ob- In all legislation hitherto designed to prevent stock-watering the company has jection. been allowed to represent, not only money but money's worth, in the shape of plant,land, etc , by stock. However wicked it may be to water stock, po one has ever insisted before that everything except grcenbacks or coin is water. **‘Water ’ docs not mean eve rytbing not money, but merely fictitious value of any kind, as Where a corporate stock is suddenly doubled in order to make it appear that the profits are half what they are realy. There is probably not a sipgie corporation in the State where the stock only represents *‘ money.” The Half-Breeds in the Newman cburch, wo have with them, we believe, five of the pine deacons, tried to hold a meetivg in the church on Thursday night, but the Stalwarts were too smart for them, having bad the doors locked with new Jocks. They then adjourned to a ‘*hall,” and formally dismissed Dr. Newman, and arranged for the callicg of a Congrega- tional Council, The Stalwarts formed a cump of observation in a neigbboring privste parlor, and had ice cream, while scouts brought in frequent reports of the Half-Breed aoings, which were freely denounced and declared nuly and void. Beth parties are evidently moving rapidly towards alaw suit in the secular courts, Dr. Newman is still armed with that $100,000 legacy, but, as we understand the matter, the testator is still living, sothat he can only hold it over the heads of the enemy as a remote ter ror. It would not be a bad plan for the Half Breeds to meet this by getting some of their pumber to make a will too, and leave Dr. Ranvey h»#lf a million or so for the church in case Dr. Newman was made lo go. The Rev. James Fincb, A. M., bas come tothe rescue of the Christian at Work in its trouble atiout murder for reveuge, with a lit- “Goel ism,” he says, “is from the Hebrew goel, and tle device Which he calls ‘‘Goelism,” it means the doctrine that the nearest rela tive of the person murdered has the right and that it is bis duty to avenge his kinsman’s death.’ Goelism 1n process of time,it appears, ‘merged into legalism”; that is, the duty of killing the murderers of relatives was trans- ferred to the magistrate. Now listen to Mr. Finch in his own words, and remember that he isa Christian minister and an A. M.: ‘‘Now the Mosaic legislation, which has the element of goelism in it, was, of course, in part, forarude age. As soon as civilization had sufficiently advanceato admit of the ad- ministration of punhe justice through the forms ot law, the primiuive mode ot admipis- t ring justice by goelism would naturally be of less frequent occurrence. But the principle of administration 1n ei'ber case was, and is, the same, viz., the security of the per- son in bis rigbts and possessions. The mere forms of law make nothing right ; if rightcan be secured through them, it is well; bu’ if pot, the law of pature—.be law ot the com- mon consciousness—declares that rights may } > . hy adnear kinsm tn's bee ming a N¢ red even homicidec—a GOKL—an avenger of b'ood. ‘Here 1s the proper ground for the justifica tion of young Nutt. Cloudy as mev may be with respect to their reasons, argue as tbey may with respect to the obligation. of statute laws, provab y ninety-vine out of a hundred justify the homicide. Itis not that they are lawless men, nor that they favor lawlessness; 3 ¥ ®

Page 7

2 deal aac) MMR: SLE TOE ESE

Feb. 21, but the law having 1884 |

failed of its end, viz., the security of the individual and society, it is ‘ ( } It to be the right 1 d thing forthe ‘avenger of to slay the monster of wickedness richest of and education n " er istl is that should gravely assume thing in the foregoing is an exclusively Jewish ** doc should not know that it was and } bold that it can, is the doctrine of all barbarous tribes, and that in our time in Chris be revived by anybody who thinks that in a particular case the courts bave not G him j j } u stice. ‘* Goelism ” in eXists Afghanistan to-day, in its original form > Tl der is very curious. YY two hada quarrel about the former's sister The nan 1e 10 k tive is ht ist

soldiers in the ia British have for army furlough to had family duty to ask ro slain a Nutt somebody who solemn as well look for bis justification ion We in Jerusalem We advised 1t Work some weeks ago to venture to offer Mr , the same suggestion, in the hope little ré st and refreshment will bring 1 saner notions of law and morality 1@ §S mbered, SiSt¢ the ably has murdered Haverstick becaust murderer r, whe shootit vr, n inferred from the fact that her husband, Mr because Ubler, ver her, h \y deduced from the ugh its appearance in a nditions under which that journal is pt Lilie { ber buried j n that dead. iated, humanly gs} 1 - } Ww die at or V she i, fi I vas quel to the Conkling-Haverstick mur Conkling, it will be re the released the only witness not be found, was not locked for. her character ITis to prob She be was on bail could and may rst undecided whether to bave 1ot. I \ I Ww ~ ¥ ‘ wl } : . : ( r of mank a rat . ' VY. , ’ q ] r \ y<saes ‘ t 4 treaty } < ¢ r < r ‘ ’ ; cort () } oe ’ f ASS 1 } <( t) ther <« } woe f { guilty Le ealed to tl ris, } | have w ided that they have n t do with the matter—that extradition tr e3 are adi strativ icts dsp ers not claim the benefit of 1 “ i latter f right Cyvoct will there for } hung inless the [re nt f the Republic pardons him, The case ‘ trates 11 striking wav the difference between French and American law Yet " few vears since the attempt was mad mothe irts in New York to set up this French trine, and to deprive prisoners of their right to a trial in accordance with the pro visions of the treaty.

Page 8

156 — [Se — SUMMARY OF THE WEEK'S NEWS [WeEDNEsDaY, February 13, to Turspay, February 19, 1884, inclusive. } DOMESTIC. lal Tne Protevs Court of Inquiry, in its report, places the blame for the failure of the Greely Relief Exp dition priveipally on the Chief Signal Officer, General Hazen, because be did not take the proper preliminary s.eps or give proper directions Secretary Chandler has selected Commander W. 8. Schley to command the new Greely Re- lief Expedition. He is forty-four years of age, and has never been on the sick list since he entered the service in 1856. The House of Representatives on Wednes- day considered the Mississippi contested elec- tion case of Chalmers against Manning. Mr. Turner (Dem., Ga.), Chairman of the Com- mittee on Elections, spoke in support of the majority report, wbich declared that on a prima-facie ease neither of the contestants was entitled to the seat. Neither the majority nor mioority report is signed, but Mr. Turoer stated that ten of the members of the Com- mittee were in favor of the former, while only five supported the latter. After several days’ debate the majority report was adopted on Friday. The House on Monday passed a bill fixing the postage on transient newspapers at one cent for four ounces, There was an all-night session of the House, lasting from Monday night till Tuesday morn- ing at nine o'clock. There was a deadlock, owing to the fact that the Republicans de- clined to vote on a motion to fix February 21st for the consideration of the bill to pension Mex ican veterans and the survivors of some Indian wars. The Republicans felt themselves called upon to protest, by witbholdivg their votes, against a bill which proposes not only to pen- sion the veterans of the Mexican war, but any person who may have served no longer than thirty days in the Creek war or disturbances. The Republican theory was tnat the Demo- crats, 1f they desired to enter upon such legis- lation as tbat, must secure a quorum of their own number to do so. Mr. Hiscock made a severe speech artaigning the Democrats, which created great excitement. The latter finally secured a quorum, and passed the resolution. In the louse on Monday Mr. Harrison (Rep., Ind.) introduced a bill for the admission of the State of Dakota into the Union. It was referred to the Commiitee on Territories, The investigation of the Danville, Va., elec- tion riots was begun in Washington by the Senate Sub Committee on Thursday. Several nevroes testified as to the aggression of the whites and the shooting on thatday They also said that in consequence they had been intimidated from voting. The white witnesses testified generally as to the imsolence of the negroes and their intention to put a stop to it. They made rather frank admissions as to their actions ou the day of the riot. The hearing was continued on Friday, on Monday, and on Tuesday. Absslom Koiner,a member of the Vir- ginia Senate, submitted to that body on Mon- day a proposition asking Virginia’s Congress- men ‘‘to bripgto the attention of the Na- tional Government the prepriety or the ne- cessity of providing a territorial reservation for the exclusive use and local government of such of the negro race of the United States as may prefer negro population and local ne- gro government to demonstrate their capacity of self goverament.” It went over under the rules. Governor Hoadly, of Obio, has written to Speaker Carlisle urging the restoration of the duty on wool. At Albany, in the Senate, on Wednesday, the bi!) abolishing the Staie paper was ordered to a third reading by a vote of 14 to 10. In the Assembly a resolution was debated | in the [Number 973 directing the Committee on Siate Charitable Institutions to investigate the cause of the re- cent death of Evan D. Hughes while confined Utica Insane Asylum. Mr. Burns (Dem.) declared that the institution was a great political machine used by both par- ties. It made or unmade politicians. The resolution was amended so as to provide for a Special Committee of Five, and was then passed. The Chairman of the Committee on Ways and Means submitted the annual ap- propriation bill, the total of which is about $7,000,000, or $200,000 in excess of last year, The Prohibition Amendment was again debated vigorously in the Assembly on Thurs- day and was ordered to athird reading. The bill reducing pilotage fees at New York was also advanced toa ubird reading. The widow of Theodore Roosevelt, the well-known philanthropist of this city, and the wife of her son, Theodore Roosevelt, jr., the Republican Assemblyman, died 10 this city on Thursday. The New York Assembly adjourned on Friday out of regard to Mr. Roosevelt, after passing resolutions of con- dolence. A mass meeting was held at Cooper Insti- tute on Thursday evening, at which resolu- uons were adopted appointing a committee of fifty prominent citizens of this city to visit Albavy to secure the necessary legislation for the concentration of power in the hands of the Mayor for the appointment of municipal officers without the approval of the Aldermen. Speeches were made in favor of the project by William M. Evarts, Judge Noah Davis, and others. The Assembly on Monday evening disagreed to an adverse report on the bill extending the five-cent hours on the elevated railroads of this city. On Tuesday they pussed the Gener- al Appropriation Bill. During a debate on that day Mr. Hooley (Labor member) said the State paid a large amount to the bumbug known as the Civil Service Commission, which only existed for the purpose of keeping many a good man out of office. Mr. Little- john (Rep.) entirely agreed with this view, pronouncing the Civil-Service Bureau not only useless, but one of the veriest humbugs in existence. This statement was greeted with warm applause. The New York Republican Committee is called to meet at the Fifth Avenue Hotel in this city on March 4th to take action regard- ing the State Convention. The Supreme Court of Illinois has affirmed the judgment of the lower Court in the case of Timm vs. Harrison, Mayor of Chicago, thereby asserting the constitutionality of the Harper High License law. The high waters began to subside on Satur- day, and railway traffic was resumed on a number of roads leading into Cincinnauu on Monday. There is wide-spread distress in many places, along the Ohio River, which the Government is endeavoring to relieve with its appropriation. Subscriptions of money and collections of clothing have been made in | all parts of the country, those from the South being noticeable. There was an almost general resumption of work this week in the iron mills, glass facto- ries, and river coal mives around Pittsburgh. Many thousand men were given employ ment. The Senior class of Hamilton College, Clin- ton, N. Y., left the institution 1n a body on Friday because the Faculty bad suspended two of their members, leaders in a general | college ‘‘ bolt’ of recitations on the day pre- ceding the funeral of ex-President North. The Harvard Faculty and the Princeton Trustees have adopted the stringent resolutions for the regulation of inter-co!legiate sports which were recommended by the late confer- ence of college faculties on the subject. Five colleges must adopt them to make them bind- ing. In the suit brought by L. L. Nightingale, one of the characters in the vovel, ‘Cape Cod Folks,’ against Alexander Williams, its pub- | lisher, in Boston, the jury on Thursday gave the plaintiff $1,095 damages. The will of Wendell Phillips leaves his property, aggregating $250,000, to his widow, with a reversionary interest to his adopted daughter, Mrs. G. W. Smalley. Professor 8. Wells Williams, LL.D.. of Yale College, died on Saturday after an illness of two weeks. He was seventy-two years of age. After being graduated at the Troy Polytechnic Institute he went to Canton, China, as printer to the American Board of Foreign Missions. He studied Chinese, and published a number of standard books on the subject. He was the editor for many years of the Chinese Repository. In 1842 he pub- lished ‘Easy Lessons in Chinese.’ He return- ed to the United States in 1845. In 1848 he publisbed ‘The Middle Kingdom,’ a standard work on China, of which a new and carefully revised edition was published a few months ago. He returned to China in 1848. He re- sided there and in Japan for many following years, publishing va'uable works, and holaing office under the U.S. Government. In 1874 he brought out at Shanghai the great work of his life, ‘The Syllabic Dictionary of the Chinese Language,’ and in 1876 he returned to the United States, having been appointed lecturer on Chinese at Yale College, where he remain- ed until bis death. Prior to his Jast illness he bad been an occasional contributor to the Nation. FOREIGN. Active preparations for British interference in the affairs of the Sudan were announced on Wednesday. Lord Wolseley, Adjutant-Gene- ral of the British army, telegraphed to Lieu- tenant-General Stephenson, commanding the forces in Egypt, to collect a force for the re- lief of Tokar, if this was possible, aud if not, for the defence of the Red Sea ports. General Grabam took the supreme command of this force, with Colonel Buller in command of the infantry and Colonel Stewart of the cavalry. General Lord Wolseley ordered that the greatest publicity be given to the determina- tion to relieve Tokar by British troops. A body of British troops was ordered to Suakim, and the British garrison at Alexandria was transferred to Cairo. The news of the de- spatch of British troops spread rapidly and had a good effect in tending to disperse the rebels. General Gordon, with several powerful chiets, left Berber on Wednesdav for Khar- tum, proceeding very slowly, in order to negotiate with the people along tbe river. On his arrival at Khbhartum on Sunday thousands crowded to kiss his hands and feet, calling him ‘‘Sultan of the Sudan.” Address- ing the people General Gordon said: ‘‘I come without soldiers, but with God on my side, to redress evils. I will not fight with any weapons, but will mete out justice. There | Shall be no mote Bashi-Bazouks.” Tbe popu- lace say that General Gordon is giving them more than El Mahdi could give. His influ- ence is so great that no fears are now felt for the safety of the garrison and the people at Khartum. Colonel Coetlogon, Commander at Khar- tum, was on Saturday created Pasha and made acting Governor-General of the entire Sudan. He summoned the notables to meet General Gordon in council on Sunday. General Gordon has posted a proclamation recognizing E] Mahdi as Sultan of Kordofan, | remitting half the taxes, and placiog no restriction on the slave trade. The Arabs of Khartum express great satisfaction with it, | The proclamation was sent to all the tribes. The London Times on Monday said that Gen- eral Gordon’s proclamation, as regards slavery, meaus that his present mission has nothing to | do with slaves, and not that he desires to lg pus ites Fetes ,

Page 9

SR aa Pi as i ees aE ietats ee ine Bern a WHORE ere ae aie BRIM Avice’ at emg) Feb. 21, 1884] _ The Nation. encourage slavery. Mr. Gladstone, in the House of Commons, said that the appointment of El Mahdi as Sultan of Kordofan, and the remission of taxes, were within General Gor- don’s powers. The true meaning of the or- der regarding the slave trade could not be understood from the telegraphic summary which had been published. The Government preferred to await the receipt of the full text of the ongipal order. Papers were presented to Parliament on Thursday regarding General Gordon's mission in the Sudan. Among them were Sir Eve- lyn Buriog’s instructions to General Gordon with respect to the evacuation of the Sudan. General Gordon is given the fullest liberty to use his own discretion in the premises. One hundred thousand pounds have been placed to his credit, and additional funds will be granted if necessary. General Gordon’s memorandum of January 2, in which he unfolds bis plan for restoring the petty Sultans to their ancestral power, Jeaving El Mahdi out of the calculation, is also among the papers. He advises that the arsenals be handed over to the various Sul- tans. His greatest difficulty will be in dis posing of the arsenals at Khartum, Dongola, and Kassala, where there are no Sultans, he- cause those pluces have sprung up since Me- bemet’s conquest. England has refused Gen- eral Sir Evelyn Wood's proposal to sanction the codperation of the Egyptian army in the relief of Tokar, for the reason that this army was raised forthe defence of Egypt outside of the Sudan. England approves, however, of the despatch of the Egyptian battalion, which is furnished with English officers, to Assuan, if this proves necessary. The orders governing the expedition for the relief of Tokar provide that the troops are to take with them provisions suflicient to last two weeks. They will bivouac upon the line of march. Each man will carry seventy rounds of ammunition in bis pouch, and there is to be a reserved supply of 250 rounds per man. Official letters have been sent to Tokar ury- ing the garrison to bold out until the troops arrive. If they succeed in relieving the town, the forts will be blown up and a retreat made to the Red Sea coast. There was an unconfirmed rumor in Sua- kim on Monday night, brought by scouts from Trinkitat, to the effect that the rebels carried Tokar vy storm on Sunday night and massacred the garrison. On Tuesday advices were received from Tokar that 2U0 of the gar rison mane a sortie, attacked the enemy, and killed and wounded several of them. They also captured a number of cattle and camels. Osman Digma, the rebel leader, was re ported on Sunday to be massing his troops near a defile where he dfeated Tabir Pasha, on the road between Trinki- tat and Tokar. If he fails to reduce the latter city before tbe arrival of the British troops, he will, itis said, give battle there. Or- ders have been given by the British Govern- ment to contine the British expedition to the relief ot Tokar. It isexpected that a decisive battle will be fought on February 24. The rebels fired on the forts at Suakim on Sunday Baker Pasha bad a narrow escape. The com mander at Tokar has written that he has sup- plies to last him until the end of the month He wants arms and ammupition. Four Egyptian private soldiers presented to the Kbedive on Saturday a protest against the despaich of Egyptian soldiers to the Sudan, and a demand for the removal of British mil: tary officers. General Wood was immediately sent for. He confronted the mutinecrs, and arresied them. The petition purported to be approved by the whole Egyptian army. Some correspondents considered the incident of grave import, while others said that it was trifling, and had not shaken the contiaence of English officers in Egypuan troops. There were rumors thatthe Egypiian army was to ~ disbanded on account of its worthlessness, but they were no' covfirmed. The stripping of Alexandria and Cairo of British tro« for the operations in the south has caused lively fears of an Cmeute. It was reported in Lon une on Wednesday thata majority of the Cabinet were urging more vigorous action in Egypt. Mr. Glad stone, Earl Granville, and some other mem bers are opposed to increasing England's re sponsibility. Conservative meetings were held in many English towns on Wednesday night, in all of which the Government po'icy in Egypt was atlacked. Coufidepce was ex pressed that) Parliament would soon be dis solved, and the Conservatives would triumph atthe next election. The London Times on Thursday rebuked the Conservatives for not boldly declaring their policy Mr. Gladstone said in the House of Com mons on Thursday that Turkey bad proposed an interchange of views regardiog Egyptian affairs. Meanwhile the negotiations continue The debate on the motion of censure was re sumed. Sir Wilfrid Lawson, Radical, moved aun amendment that the House decline to ex press an opinion of the Goverpmeut’s Egyp lian policy. In proposing this amendment he suid that be trusted that hereatter English men would not be employed to interfere with the Egyptians in their selection of a Govern ment. Mr. Labouchere, advanced Liberal, seconded it. Mr. Gladstone sy ke in Opt Osi tion. The debate was continued on Friday without special incident, The debate on the motion to censure the Government for its Egyptian policy was re sumed in the House of Commons on Monday W. T. Marriott, a Liberal, made a violent at tack upon the Goverpment, accusing it of vacillation aad inconsistency The Irish Parliamentary pariy he'd a meeting in the evening to decide how to vote on the motion of censure. Mr. Parnell was absent Phere was a disagreement as tothe course to be pur sucad Mr. Sexton moved to vote against the Government, which was carried Mr. Par nell was present at another meetiog of his party on Tuesday morning, and it Was again decided to vote against the Government. The debate was concluded on Tuesday evening, and Sir Stafford Northcote’s motio sure was defeated by a vote of 31 majority of 49 for the Governmen standivg the opposition of the Pars eilites Lord Randolph Churebill has been elec ck ‘d President of the National Conservative Ur Which is considered an indication that be wi it tuke the place of Sir Stafford Northcote as Conservative leader in the House of Commons The latter, it is said, is willing to accept a peerage. Mr. Bradlaugh issued on Wednesday an address to the electors of Nortban pton tor a reflection Mr. Richards, who once before gave him aclose run, was the candidate of the Covservatives Mr. Braclaugb was re turped on Tuesday by a larger vote U before, and will take the oath at once Mo ever A bill was introduced in the House of Lords on Friday to afford bet er protection aguinst the importation of diseased cattle. While walk Commons or ing unattended tothe House of Thursday, Mr. Gladstone was suddenly seized by the collar, and brougbt to a standstill py aman. Wiib some aittculty he shook off his assailant lt is said the at tack Was made on a wager The Cob copies of the ib will circulate 20,000 pblet by Mr. Giffen devoted to the ‘Progress of the Working Clisses,” which Mr. Gladstone pronounces to be the best answer to tnedoctriues proclaimed by Mr. Henry George Tue strike of the weavers has come to an end everywhere throughout East Lancasbire, England. 157 At a meeting of the company of authers, established to obtair a coy vricht convention with the United States, which was beld London on Monday, Cardins! Mani pok at some length upon the injustice dene by American publishers in pirating Feglish works. Mr. Wolter Besant moved tl i company of authors be founded in Americs and that the matter be brought betore Amer ican authors. he motion was carried Matthew Arnold will publish impressions of America, along with the lectures he delivered while in the United States Ten thousand copies of the first edition of Queen Victor Diary were soid th st day after publication Admiral Carr Glyp, who was legsatee to the estate of Adelaide Neilson, the actress The Merv tribes bave submittedt to Russia The German press says the submiss tribes of Mery to Russ Iswore for | land than the disasters in the Sudar l ments upon the remarkable success of ‘ Russian policy in Cevira! Asi ‘ \ " always directed against Pogland | | SIAN DeEWSpapers express the of "! submission of the Merv. tribes to) Russia vetber with theevents in the Sudan, mesures } the downtall of Mr. Gladstone The Lowe r Llouse of the Aus rian lke th has } issedd the exveephiotr “ Hired j against Anarchists bv a vot An erican iffairs were br ugl t nenee in Germany on Thursday bv an.at in the B riit \ ) { ( f R mark © organ) in which it was sar l t gard to bog products which is pow before the Ametican Congress is cal Meal parptulls ect Gern s wl has } ests at hear The sting tt spay \ firected against Germany alot Wi ! assume that Amen states ‘ spose d tfocontert the opi t t G \ be ed by reprissls bres \ ures epiolr { tt It ts { pal healt) A dependent Government can ouly reply to ADV atfempt at intimidation by counter repri sais Dsl ng of inereased cust s nd eventually bv legal meas s otherwise affect or the ere Tse Line wo t . The Berlin correspondent of the Loneon 7 s on Sat inv r ported that Prince Bis mar A ed peorcceomae hos g -ancogtnene Kise ndecher. the German Minister at wslhingt«) n, ibe re solution of condolence o1 r Lusker’s death passed by Congress cht he request to re turn the resolutior to the House of Re presen tatives, as the position of Herr Lasker in Ger many Was Bot such s to justify the resolution Lhe 7 s added that sithough the tt ng appears incredil the fact is that the relarions between Wasbmngton end Perlin tension, chiefly ow ng Latcr advices contirm arein a state of great to the pork question The commercial convention between the United States snd Spain was signed in Madrid on Wednesday The Bev of Tunis bas given M. Roudaire autboruy to carry out bis scheme for trans forming a portion of the Desert of Sabara into an inland sea Manv Christians bave been massacred in Apvam since the beginning of January. The Anumite Minister of War is implicated, Two mandarins who were instigators of the recent massacre of Christians in ‘lopquin have xen taken to Huc, tried, and executed. President Gréevy on Tuesday received a tele gram from the King of Anam. The Kirg expresses the hope tbat the newly completed cable connecting Haiphong with Ttunnan and Ssigon will sirepgihen the friendly rela tions existing between France 91d Avum. He also trusts that tbe treaty will be rauticd,

Page 10

158 The Nation. [Number 973 THE ALDERMEN AND THE APPOINT ING POWER. THE meeting at Cooper Union on Thursday both in. and it named an excellent com last Was a great success numbers and in enthusiasm mittee togo to Albany to secure the passage of the Roosevelt bill and such other legislation as may be neccs ary to concentrate responsibility in the Mayor, men their share of the appointing This change undoubtedly does not include the and take away from the Alder- power. whole of municipal reform, but it promises more of it, in our belief, than anything else which this accomplished We have city about is likely to see had in this experience of the seneration now forty years’ great centres of population by universal suffrage. What the difficulties of this problem are is better known to New Yorkers to-day than to any people inthe world. We bave learnt all that the lowest tribe of demagogues ever seen ina modern problem of governing civilized community can accomplish through We have actually seen the creation among us, as Judge out, of an aristo- liquor dealers—that a large body of ignorant voters Davis forcibly pointed cracy or oligarchy of the most odious modern callings. We is, of members of one of and disreputable of have tried, too, all sorts of remedies for the evils of our condition, all of which have failed The great remedy tried after Fernando Wood's appearance—State has failed utterly, and with un- fortunate results for the State city. We have discovered, too, in the of the Tilden amendments, that no remedy in a greater or less degree. interference as well as the case which seems in the smallest degree to attack the principle of universal suffrage stands much chance of being tried, however prom- Salvation must come apparently through the good tendencies of uni itself, and the best and most hopeful of these tendencies is the tendency to put men of mark in high places and trust them greatly. We know how readily illustrations of the ising it may seem. versal suffrage contrary can be furnished—Butler’s success in Massachusetts is the most conspicuous; but they are exceptions and only feeble ones. In this city the tradition that the Mayor must be aman in good standing, has really, through all our troubles, never been broken. In mu- nicipal as wellas State politics, too, it has been found that the abuses and corruption most complained of have nearly always resulted from the success of politicians in getting be tween the people and the candidates, and so diviaing popular attention that nobody shall the effect of the election on the machinery of the government know anything as to what will be. The present condition of New York exhibits the working of this system under peculiarly favorable Roosevelt bill would go far to overturn it. It bring in the Millennium, or drive conditions, The success of the would not liquor-dealers out of politics, but it would strip them of their power over municipal administra- tion, and reduce them to insignificance. It would, moreover, at stated intervals array the intelligence, virtue, and order of the city against ignorance, vice, and corruption, for | a fair trial of strength over an issue which | eminent in | everybody could understand, and which no dickering or dealing could cbscure. We have ourselves no doubt as to what the result of such would be. The liquor-dealers would be worsted every time. We should — every Mayoralty, not a saint or a sage, but a man identified with some one of the reputable interests of the municipality, and more or less talentsand character; and once in he would have power to govern, and his failure to govern well would cover bim with a disgrace which he would feel deeply, and he could not escape by throwing the blame on some one else. We were sorry that none of the speakers addressed himself to objection, which weighs a good deal with many people, to the withdrawal of the power of confirmation from the Board of Aldermen. We mean the apparent analogy which exists, as regards its relations to the appoisting power, be- contests time put in the which one tween the Board and the Senates of the United States and of the various States. There are many very bonest and _intelli- gent men in this city, who have no lik- ing whatever for the Aldermen, and who deplore as much as anybody the use they make of their power, who nevertheless are persuaded that the participation of some sort of legislative body in the work of selecting office-holders is an essential feature of the American system of government. They see it in operation in all the States, and they find some difficulty in understanding why the chief executive officer of a community con- taining over a million of population, and raising over $30,000,000 a year in taxation, can be safely released from restrictions which are held to be absolutely necessary in the case of Governors of States containing not half as many inbabitants and ais ing not over a third as much revenue. This point has been discussed to some ex- tent, but not as much as is desirable. Its apparent gravity illustrates one of the great difficulties of the situation. The mu- nicipality has never had the importance in America which it has had in Europe, simply because America has had no Middle Ages. The foundations of American freedom were not laid in walled towns held by armed artisans. Cities here have been of late growth, and have played but little part in our political development. It is only about fifty years since Boston received a charter or bad a mayor, | and since the Mayor of New York ceased to be appointed by the Governor, as a State officer. Down to this moment this city has never been recognized by the State as a separate or even partially independent political corporation, in any way resembling a State. Inthe Legislature, and by the very men who are so sensitive about the rights of the Board of Aldermen as a ‘legislative branch,” the city is always treated as a mere creature of the State, and the charter as a temporary arrangement, which has no better motive than the convenience of each passing year. The Board of Aldermen has had its constitution altered half-a-dozen times within the last fifty years. Moreover, the Legis- | | question, just as it enlarges or restricts its powers, and raises, lowers, or abolishes its salary. In fact, it is impossible to find at Albany among the politicians of any party the slightest trace of the argument so freely used against the reformers down here, that the Aldermen are a IJegislative body, with functions.and immunities like those of State Senates. The thought that New York city isan imperium in imperio apparently never enters into their heads. If it did they would undoubtedly concede to the people of this city some voice in framing their charter, but there is nothing for which they are less pre- pared. The truth is, the theory that the municipali- ty isa quasi-State, is a theory concocted, as far as politicians are concerned, for the simple purpose of defending and maintaining the Board of Aldermen as an instrument of corruption. No politician uses it seriously, or uses it against any other politician. It is reserved entirely for the confusion of good people down here, who skow sigas of reach- ing the conclusion that the Board isa public nuisance and disgrace, and ought to be abolish- ed, or at ajl events be so shorn of power as to be rendered entirely harmless. The American city is peculiar in its his- tory as well as in its needs. In fact, it has no history, and there is but little analogy between its governmental needs and those of the State. But there is one great principle of American politics which is applicable to it, and which meets all its requirements, and that is that each city should be managed by its own inbabitants; that they should, with proper recognition of State supremacy, be the most potent influence in framing the muni- cipal constitution; and that they should bave full power to change it as their necessities may dictate. The object of city government is to give the inhabitants of a certain district clean streets,good wharves and drains, good light at night,a good police and good police magistrates, good jails, hospitals, and schools—or,in other words,to give them comfort and safety in their houses and streets. It is not its object to give them political rights, or gratify their political ideals, or in any manner provide for their wel- fare as members of a political community. All this is done by the State and the Union. The Mayor, the Aldermen, the Comptroller, the Register, the Sheriff,are all, just like the street cars and the ferry boats and the mud-scows, contrivances intended to increase the personal comfort of the men, women, and children liv- ing within the city limits. No part of the mu- nicipal machinery, whether person or office, | exists as part of the eternal fitness of things, | a “legislative branch, or in virtue of some municipal ideal entering into the foundations of society. There is no- thing sacred in or about the City Hall,nothing which ought not to go as soon as it is found | to interfere in any degree with giving the peo- ple of the city an economical and efficient ad- ministration of city affairs. We need hardly say that the Board of Alder- men comes under thisrule. There is hardly in African theology amore absurd superstition than the notion that if a body of men get themselves, either by accident or design, called ” the right to have a lature might abolish it to-morrow, without | voice in the selection of the city officers be, -— ok 2 SR RR SEE te Aga urBiignd 2p: —

Page 11

ae

1, 1884]

comes so firmly vested in them that, though they sell itin open market as tbey sell their whiskey, and use the proceeds in debauchery, itcannot be taken away from them. To «a knowledge this would be really to introduce a totally new and most destructive principle into American politics, namely, the old medieval doctrine that there are arrangements in government so sacred that they can under no circumstances be changed, no matter how badly they work, or how much human suffer ing they cause. The American doctrine is that whatever in politicsdoes not work well, must ‘go,’ and that no institution must be allowed to work human misery. This of course covers ignorant, corrupt, and liquor-dealing Aldermen. STEALING NEWS. Mr. HENRY WATTERSON is about to intro duce into Congress, in the interest of the press, @ measure which he very incorrectly calls a newspaper ‘“‘copyright” law His language, as given in the 7ridune, is as follows “It simply operates to protect property in news from piratical concurrent publication This can be done by a clause in the copyright laws making collected news, the product of skilled labor and outlay, exclusive to those who pay for it, for twenty-four hours. I mean all news and news of every description and every association. As matters are, news 1s not recognized as property at all. Everything abcut a newspaper office, from the perfecting press tothe newsman’s pot of paste, is property, and he who steals it falls within the reach and ccmpass of the law. But that which consti tutes the real value of a newspaper property— its news franchises—costing vast sums of money and years of special enterprise, train ing, and labor—has no legal status whatever It is practically outlawed; anybody can steal it wiih impunity. The proposed measure pro tects it from pirated use and concurrent publi cation for twenty-four hours. It creates, in decd, a new property; tbat is, property in news. Noone can oppose it ¢ xcept those who want to rob others of their labor and money.’ In ‘‘news,” he continues, he would include “all original, special, and general matter ex ceeding ove bundred words, sent by post or wire, and embracing the original communica tion of information of any and every descrip- tion.” The copyright laws of the United States all rest upon a provision in the Constitution giving Congress the right tosecure to *‘authors”’ the ‘‘exclusive right” to their ‘‘ writings ” Const. U.S. Art. I., sec. 8). Mr. Watter son’s measure may perhaps, in a certainsense, be said to secure rightsto the “authors” of despatches, through the newspapers which buy of them ; that is to say, any one who collects and sells news to the press might be able to get a slightly better price for it, if the newspaper purchasing it could prevent its being stolen by other news papers But this does not meet the great difficulty in the case, which lies in the fact that it is absurd to talk of a man who picks up a piece of news or an ‘‘item” as an author” at all. The reason why copyright laws are passed is to secure the fruits of original, intellectual Jabor. But the proposed copyright in ‘‘ news” does not do this. Any one may collect news without any original intellectual effort, and with very little effort of any kind, Some people do it by listening at The Nation. 1 + } keyholes, most people in the ordinary irs of conversation with the persons whom they meet in the way of business or pleasure If a : : ( lector of hewsin Lor York that Sir Stafford livered a lecture on Nothin t that Lord Cairns has offered Miss Fortes ) release bis son from his marriage engagement who is the person whos property " in the news ought to be protected, or wh is the ‘‘author” of it Is it the collector of the ‘‘item If so, any one who has ears and eyes isan ‘‘author.” On the other hand, if any one can be said to have pri perty in such news, it would seem to be those whose pecuniary interests or reputations are affected—Sir Stafford Northeot Lord Cairns, his son, and Miss Fortescue The fact is, that protection against the theftof news has nothing more to do with copyright than it has with patents. Indeed, the persons who could most fairly claim protection from Congress as authors of news are the fabricators of tictitious de spate hes, the pre ducers of the extraordinary bear stories, or dog stories, o1 romances ot real lite,” or anecdotes of remarkable long: vity, extraordinary instances of long periods of , a ; ; ; siecp, or stience, or abstinence from f i which do somuch to render lively the lumus of country newspapers. These are really th result of literary labor of a certain kind. B this is not the sort of ‘‘news” that Mr. W terson Wants to protect What bis bill is really intended to prevent

i IS the theft of news from one newspaper bv another d cl vy of s ‘| . domestic or for It S i \ ivine despatches the prot tT other kinds of pr rtv., every ‘ i newspaper in the | i St tes ¥ t he glad to sup rt ¢ ] } a oe , enormous d s the wav w Ww make themselves f momen s Is put into the form of iw. J st ser s of these is the fact that the p1 rty by anv human it ty 1 | gipal r! in W s rst | ils bd psequently « t r i t expanding “ des Ss suy s \ me nc tn th n Ws . y } $ i! it the < ’ \ y y Ss K pletely, or so ¢ I vast ofas cess LT Pros t Were tl 1 ! bv 1 t 1 i fow 3 i \ hye ¢ esown,a mas i is t ency¢ Pix ri \ T i he <o sg sed t Ww . rea r ‘ t W Ww i +1 ( ‘ Tr properiv But this is 1 ! s a tin ~ \ s Ne it way . vs eT ae j ‘ - , stat Ww t I Ww r as a ‘‘spe ‘ rs \ i he Wwe Y — r i I Ng r ‘ . ] S re masa a crit Y 7 : rs would be i i th y r words vspaper in «} Ness ( tried I oe vr i tly provable form of Y W Mr. Watterson } wishes to reach is the habitual fraudulent re , | } . ‘ ha ae o . }*? " proguchion Of Gespalcnes as special which it reaiiyv s \ iW _ } iu ha ‘ j rv, sf ¢ S ws 1 I \\ t i x exXpans . \\ WW nrol proba s y ),) ‘ the y at | Which s \ i THE CAl ) Mi NI \ ‘ vered { = ‘ 1 { \ eX lv w , , | l e¢ ‘ ‘ ‘ cw " \ \ vl \ ‘ \ ‘ \| \ 1 i _ i = : - sa ) iy ’ A i i te vw ( { f 4] 1 i ‘ hit f tormentor . a ( n r cars I 1 I ira I t e hand 1 Bice , ' L hie i | “ } ae { a manner. or i i ee | man r, on t < Lh t { ithat he bad kissed the auth of the book then or at any rt \ he plaintiff! denied ma s T ir his ta y I mother for it i id not wear er her otton gown, on « sions when she went out, a very ld-fashioned mantilla, bordered with a deep black fringe, and consequent was not true, as the author alleged, that ‘‘ this pathetic remnant of gentility, borne rudely about by the Cedarville winds, with Lydia’s refined face and melancholy dark cyes , gave

Page 12

160 The Nation. [Number 973

her a very interesting and picturesque appear- ance.” But no evidence was brought forward on the trial to show that Mr. Nightingale was really injured in pocket, person, or reputation | by the book. to the process known to photographers and novelists as ‘‘idealization,” so that it is at least open to doubt whether his position in the world was not improved by the publica tion in some respects, plained of, and what the jury decided was a just complaint, was that bis name had been ‘* made free with” in print, or, in other words, that his rigbt to privacy and obscurity had been invaded. He summed up his injuries very concisely by saying that he had been ‘* pointed at’ at the railroad station. The author of ‘Cape Cod Folks’ has, there- fore, done the public a good turn in showing that there is a point beyond which a novelist may not go in bringing private persons into his books. He may not doit byname. That she and the publishers should have supposed that this might be done with impunity is, perbaps, not a matter of surprise, when we re- member that the press is doing something very similar, and indeed much worse, all the time. Not a week passes that purely domestic and family affsirs are not publisbed in the news- papers with the names of the persons affected in full, and generally in connection with mat- ters which are sacred from public intrusion not only in morals but in law. No one, however, can read the evidence in such a case as that of the ‘Cape Cod Folks’ wi' bout seeing that a suit for damages must in the long run be a poor sort of redress, Any tirm of publishers, though en- tirely innocent, mi,ht be put in the awkward precicament in which this Boston firm now fines itself. They might, perhaps, relieve them- selves by suppressing the book altogether, but in that case the persons injured are left without redress. Moreover, for au injury of this sort, where it is real, along civil] suit with all the ex- pense incident to it, and the worry and harass of cross-examination to which the plaintiff is always subjected, is a bad remedy. It isa case, not for damages, but for punishment of the guilty person; and whatever the guilt of the publishers, the author must always be guilty in such a case. Probably crimival proce:dings were out of the question in this case because the author was a woman, and a jury would not be lkely to send a woman to prison for such an _ offence. We believe, bowever, tbat it is women He was, we believe, subjected What he really com- | pork. The part which pork has taken in in- ternational! affairs is now assumed by the oys- ter in domestic politics. It reminded us of the civil war when we read in the news from Baltimore, a few days ago, after a startling head-line, ‘‘ Ye dredgers, beware; the police boats are after you,” these belligerent items: “The oyster police steamer William T. Hamilton, Captain Gordy in command, ar- rived in the harbor sbortly after dark last night. She came tothe city by order of the Governor to get the arms necessary for the | ss : P zodilogist and of a practical oysterman, in | war to be waged against the illega] dredgers

in Fishing Buy and Honga River. The day | was too far advanced for the fitting out, and the preparations were postponed until this morning. The steamers William T. IHamilton and tbe Leila, and the sloep Juliu Hamilton, will be thoroughly stocked with ammunition. . . . A special despatch to the American from Annapolis last night said: ‘The Board of Public Works had a meeting to-day to take action regarding the Dorchester oyster war.’ ” “In accordance with the action of the Board of Public Works, Governor McLane is- sued a requisition yesterday to Adjutant- General Watkins for a supply of arms tor the oyster boat. The order of the Adjutant General was presented to Mr. D. H. Leaming at the Fifth Regiment Armory yesterday afternoon about balf past four o'clock, and he delivered twelve 45-calitre rifles and 1,000 rou.ds of cartridges, which will be loaded on the steamers this morning.” Anotber item of about the same date in- forms us that the envoys sent from the Government at Annapolis to the Government at Richmond have returned without making an adjustment of the difficulties between Maryland and Virginia. A day or two later came further intelligence, from the seat of war, under these headlines: ‘‘ DREDGERS TAKEN In.—Captain Gordy on the war patb—Capturivg tbe violators of the law in Honga River—Their vessels in tow— Work of the police—Cause of the trouble— The Jack of Arms”: ‘* CRISFIELD, February 10.—When the oys- ter police boat Wm. 7. Hamilton steamed into Hooper’s Straits this morpving at half-past eleven o’clock Captain Gordy gazed intently tbrough a telescope toward a fleet cf vessels sailing in the mouth of Honga River, where dredging for oysters 1s not permitted.” On Sunday morning, just as ‘‘in the old war times,” a special notice was issued for a illustrated with numerous engravings, and with several maps of the oyster beds of the Chesapeake. In this blue-book the Chesa- peake oyster is discussed from every point of view except the orainary one, the gastro- nomic. It is treated statistically, econo- mically, legally, historically, geographically, microscopically, embryologically. All that is known of the origin, development, multipli- | cation, diminution of the bivalve is brought an essential together, with the suggestions of a scientific order that the people of Maryland, and espe- cially the Legislature of the State, may be in- formed upon the dangers which now tbreaten traffic. and of the remedies | which are within reach, if suitable legislation | tory, and others elsewhere. can be secured. With the codperation of two associate Commissioners, Messrs. Waddell and Legg, this report has been prepared by Dr. W. K. Brooks, the Chairman of the Commission, who has been for several years past the Director of the Chesapeake Zodélogical Labor- atory, a department of the Johns Hopkins | University devoted to the seaside study of marine life. His scientific memoirs are well known to zodlogists, one of them having been published by the Royal Society of London, others by the Boston Society of Natural His- His recent vol- ume on ‘ Heredity’ is pronounced by a compe- tent critic the most considerable contribution which has been made in this country to the Darwinian theory of the origin of species. We mention these facts that those who are unfamiliar with his work may perceive that he has aright to speak with authority. The most important part of the investiga- tion was made prior to the appointment of an oyster commission. When Dr. Brooks or- ganized the Chesapeake Zodlogical Labora- tory, it was with the hope and belief not only | that he could advance the science of zodlogy, | but that he could throw some light upon what | duction of the American oyster. mass meeting to be held on Thursday for the | discussion of ‘* the oyster question.” ‘‘ Live and eloqnent speakers,” says the call, ‘‘ will address the meeting.” Similar despatches | have come from the scat of war since we made far more than men who need a lesson in this | respect. We douht if any man living would have dared to write ‘Cape Cod Folks’; and certainly, in the press, it is the anonymous female contributor who always makes the most irresponsible use of her ‘‘ chance” to say whatever into friends and acquaintances. comes THE OYSTER IN SCIENCE AND PO- LITICS. Nort long ago the writer saw a distinguished European diplomatist standiog before a bul- letin in acolleze class-room, where, under the words ‘Tbe Hog in Politics,” there were pu- merous extracts from the newspapers of the day on the diplomatic discussion of American her head about her | | tance. | infantile growth. the foregoing extracts. The key to this bellicose excitement is to be found in tbe fact that the oysters of the Chesapeake are rapioly diminishing in num bers, and foresizhted canners, dealers, mer- chapt:, and staiesmen see that a very important branch of traffic is indanger. An oyster fleet is requisite to keep off intruders from a dis- Diplomacy is called into negotiate be- tween the claims of different States. More noteworthy still, science is invoked, and an | expert morpbologist and embryologist has de- voted many months to studying the life of tbe young oyster and the natural conditions of its We would here call atten- tion to a remarkable book which bas just been printed in Balumore, the ‘ Report of the Oys- ter Commission of tbe State of Maryland,’ a quarto volume of nearly two bundred pages, | hermapbrodite, like was then a very obscure matter, the repro- His success was cven greater than any of his friends anticipated. By prolonged and accurate ob- servations, repeated in successive brecding seasons, he discovered the fact that the American oyster (Ostrea virginiana), is not the European oyster (Ostrea edulis); on the contrary, the sexes are separate, the eggs are fertilized outside the body, and the young can be reared arti- | ficially in enormous numbers. These inter- | esting statements were published in 1879, in an elaborate paper, illustrated by numerous | drawings which show the development of the oyster germ, as seen under the microscope at very brief intervals from its impregnation on through two or three days—showing also that independence of parental care which is sometimes thought to be characteristic of young America. These discoveries (to which, by the way, Mr. Lowell, the American Minister, made a humorous allusion when he spoke, ov the American day, in the Interna- tional Fish Exhibition, at London, last sum- mer) attracted attention far and wide, and led to various attempts to fertilize artificially the oyster eggs, and to bring the young to maturi- ‘ty. The practical difficulties are now almost i ‘ < $

SRS peck

Page 13

CR ye

Feb. 21, 1884] The Nation.

and perhaps completely overcome, and there is every reason to believe that before long oysters may be bred artificially with greater certainty than trout and shad and others of the finny tribe. No better illustration can be found in the annals of natural history of the general good to the public which may follow the prosecution of a delicate and difficult microscopical research on an obscure question in embryology. The exact share of credit to which the various students of this problem are entitled, we need not attempt to determine, but among those whose development of Dr. Brooks’s dis- covery has been most efficient, a few names should be mentioned. Lieutenant Winslow, U.S. N., who had seen Dr. Brooks’s experi- ments at Crisfield in 1879, was stationed the next year at Cadiz, and there experimented with the Portuguese oyster (Ostrea angulata), fiading it to be like the American, and capable of artificial propagation. A French naturalist, M. Bouchon Brandeley, referring to the encouragement he bad received from Brooks’s experiments, took the next step for ward with further attempts to produce the Portuguese oyster, and he succeeded in rais- ing a very great number of seed oysters fit for planting. The paper on this subject was trans- lated by Mr. J. A. Ryder, and printed under the direction of Professor Baird in the Bulle- tin of the United States Fish Commission. Mr. Ryder then constructed at Stockton, on the coast of Maryland, a pond similar to those of Bouchon Brandeley, and in September last mace public the welcome announcement that the young from eggs artificially impreg- nated had been kept alive forty-six days, un til they had become from one-fourth to three-fourths of an inch in diameter, ‘‘ demon strating that the young would grow just as rapidly in a pond as in the waters of the open bay,” and that ‘“‘it is perfectly feasible to rear oysters fiom artificially feftilized eggs.” The further development of this possibility now goes into the hands of practical men. If they do their part with as much skill as the scientitic investigators have done theirs, the oyster will not perish, The Oyster Commissioners of Maryland, after giving the facts which we bave quoted, and many more, pertaining to the decline ot the oyster productivity and the need of legis- lation to prevent further interference with the oyster industry, declare it to be their opinion that the natural fertility of the oyster beds must be increased by some method of artificial oyster culture, and that gradua’ly the oyster property of the State should be put into the hands of private farmers, in ordcr that private enterprise may secure the best returns. THE FATE OF LOUIS XVIL Our Paris correspondent, when writing of the last days of Louis XVIL( Nation, No. 969), stated that there are many people in Europe“ who still believe that the unfortunate soo of Louis XVI. and of Marie Antoinette did not die in the Temple,” and that ‘‘there have been several false Louis Seventeen'hs.” He may or may not have been aware that America once bad ber Louis XVII. in the person of the Rev. Eleazar Williams, a missi nary among the Indians, and a clergyman in good standing of the Episcopal church. Thirty years ago a fair-sized contro- versy raged in our newspapers and periodicals concerning his rights, and the Rev Jobn H Hanson published a vigorous work of 5) pages or thereabout, while a translation of the work of Beauchesne was brougbt out by the Harpers and became the adverse authority Whatever the Rev. Mr. Williams's origin, there certainly bad been some strange phases in his life The first thing known of bim was that he was an idiotic boy aboutthe age of the Dauphin, the reputed halt-breed son of an Oneida woman in the State of New York. The shock of a fall in Lake Champlain restored his faculties, and soon after this he was taken from his supposed Indian mother and placed under the charge of an intelligent New England farmer. Money for his education was regularly supplied, but from what mysterious source it came no one knew Thus the Indian boy year after vear wassup ported for some unknown reason and by son unknown person, until, at Jengtb, he became a clergywan and a missionary among his own people. But be possessed the manners and ap parently the tastes of a gentleman, and some of ourreaders may remember hearing bim preach from the pulpit of the late Rev. Dr. Wasbburn In the Kuickerbocker Ma yazine of 1S>4 there appeared a somewhat judicial review of the con troversy, entitled *‘ A Charge to the Jury of the Public in the Dauphin Case.” The claims of the Rev. Mr. Williams were regarded as the weak est part of thecase; but the escape of the Prince was deemed possible, and circumstances were adduced whichat that day could bardly be re conctled with his death in the Temple. Whether the recent historical discoveries in Paris throw light on these discordant circumstances may be worthy of our correspondent’s further cecsid eration. In the meanwhile we extract and transcribe the more important of them from the old review iv the Anichkerbocker stantially as follows They are sub Two witnesses, according to M. Beauchesne, testify positively as to the death of the Prince, viz.: Lasne and Gomin. They tell us that they were his attendants, the one from the Sist of March, 1793, the otber from the Sth of Noven ber, 1704, to the day of his death. They furtber minutely descmbe the condition of the Prince from the 5tb to the Sth of June (there is a blank in Beauchesne’s account from the Ist to the Stt and then bis last moments, and the bour and the minute when be died. inthe el guage of bis biegrapher, ** Lasue put bis bar upon the beart of the child. The beart of Louis Seventeenth bad ceased to beat It was tw hours and a quarter after midday As these persons were both in the Temple before the 2Urt ot May, 1775, it is evident that they both krew the real Pripee. solely in attendance, 1f Is evident that no ex As thev were constantiv and change could have been brought about witbout ther knowledg As they testify explicitly and positively that no exchange dio take place, and that Louis XVII. died on the Sh of June Temple, there is po ground for mistake. We must therefore conclude, either that Louis XVIT

died as they describe, or that their statements are wilfully false. What, then. are the facts, in the nature of circumstantial evidence, whic tend to discredit tbis positive testimony and throw a doubt upon the alleged death of Louis XVIL ? The eminent physician Desault attended the f 77>. He had known bim and been bis medical attenoant be Prince up to tre With fore his imprisonment. Huis character is beyond suspicion, and his eviderce beyond doubt, Botb parties agree tbat b's testimony is to be taken as absolute truth. Desault found the Prince worn aud emaciated, showing little intelhgence, and preserving a continued silenes Atel at he made every effort to arouse bis fa ies and win his affection, the 1 gave r sign of mental power than feebiv takirg bold of his coat as he was about to leave the ro ( the night of the 2Uth of Mav, Des t Es f ts . ; Asis show by a ast Last G in, Bellange and phy ‘ Pelletan and LD ta N ha < been sul ttosudcen changes, a ! f the first visit of Laurent, nearly a year? his death, sufficient!v¥ shows Ther en 1 him,” says Laurent, “made 2 I lid t sti Hie anse WAS CopSscloUuS of I 4 lis pen eves bad 1 X ess changed Hie hsd t! ‘ an j t In addit this es 4 the | Vs ans shows the brain and its dey . vs t were in the ‘ t ‘ evide t il t Ver biy s ‘ ‘ about the first of . ts TaN i place, a t i t \ Next in the cha stl Bie t ‘ f the | It uv bes ‘ te es: First, Desa t t had tt germ . . Y eid a tLe malady had ‘ \ | s a his st t I os w \ Violent svinpt &s—B va s bell sopbthal . ‘ ha nt Ss \ s wl aft +) la v ¢ f " " | exan it 4 i il S Were “evict \ t t a . SEM st ] sta v.a tow f he i ‘ 7 ft ft ost yl s Tes Ve “ af sa ta ‘ t { May, ara x : i lpg t | \ took t t Ss I ta t x hat t i tina phy M. Dumag phy f I f bel \ The t ! ‘ t ies ail isto] @ss i) s ’ " srepres t We Pav ¢ | bted pr F , Next as to the sta te anton the j th or Lisa ppn rance of the 1) pl I The Gover ent separated the Pri fr I Tes f bis fan s IN Lhe, KI te a keeper, a friend of Marat, known frem his ba red e TOVA I Tr I \ This ma bliged to be mie prisone in the Temple be Was 1 even allowed to go tohis ownt t Kce; when guarded } 1 fie f vrs Fourthly The Government set apart as large expenses of keeping and guard ing the child as for all the other members of ily Fifthiv—A system of espionage was established, intricate, troublesome, and ex- pensive Paris was divided into forty districts from each district one Commiss'oner was elect- ed. A Commissioner visited the Temple each ay, and each Commissioner visited it but once With bis single visit bis term of office ended, Sixthly — Toward the end of the supposed exist- ence of the Prince, the three most eminent phy- sicians In Frarce were appointed bis attendants, Whatever was the motive, an intent of preser- vation 1s apparent. It is next to be noted that the Comte de Pro- vence, the uncle of the Prince and bis heir, en

Page 14

162 deavored (whatever his motive may have been) to obtain possession of his nephew. It is an un- loubted fact that he at that time had emissaries in Paris, foremost among whom was the Comte de Fenouil. Now, of the three persons who were in attendance on the Prince, Gomin was a royalist, Lasne a moderate republican, after- ward employed by the Comte de Provence, while Bellanger had been his ornamental painter. It ged that these persons obtained an to the prison of the Dauphin through the intrigues of the Comte de Fenouil; and all this raises a presumption of the intent on the part of the Comte de Provence to procure the escape of the Dauphin, and on the part of the has been alle ntr . envuran Dive at it. But at this time a very startling event oc- Desault, within a few hours of his last visit to the Prince, died. It is again to be remarked that be was personally ac- quainted with the Prince; was a physician of reputation and aman of stainless in- M. Beauchesne asseits that he died Mr. Hanson, that he was poi- soned by the Government. Aside from the sud- denness and the singularity of his death at this particular time, there is no evidence indicating that it was unnatural, unless we except state- ments said to have been made in this country several years ago, by M. Abeille, the pupil of But there is one circumstance tobe noted, whichis,that the death of Desault was falsified in the of the Government, Whatever may have been the motive, it was registered (as is shown by Beauchesne) four days later than it actually occurred. During these four days no pbysician attended the Prince, and of them tbe account of Beauchesne is silent. rhe conduct of the royal family, itis alleged, Was equivocal, suspicious, and irreconcilable with a belief in the death of the Dauphin. Although the highest marks of respect were paid to the memory of Louis XVI.,Marie Antoinette, and the Duc d’Enghien, none were given to the last, though youthful, King. Inthe graves of the two former quick-lime bad been emptied, and hundreds of victims buried over them and The grave of the Dauphin could have been easily discover ed, and the surgeons’ examination of the skull alforded certain proof to identify the remains: yet while the supposed dust of Louis XVI. and Marie Antoinette was exhumed, to be reburied with stately pomp and studied mourning, the bones of Louis XVIL., in an obscure cemetery, unmarked by a single memorial, still rest like those of a common pauper. Again, Pelletan, the physician, carried from the post-mortem examination the heart of the child who died in the Temple, aud he offered it to the King asthe heart of the Daupbin. An inquiry was instituted,in which Lasne testified that he was present at the examination, and no- thing was carried away. The evidence, althoug contradictory, can be reconciled; for the state- ment of Lasne amounts to nothing more than that he observed closely, and did not see any- thing taken, Pelletan was a physician of the highest and entitled to belief, yet Louis X VILL adopted the statement of Lasne, and rejected the relic. More interesting, if not more clear, are the admissions to be derived from tbe conduct of the Duchesse d’'Angouléme. She was a woman of dauntless energy, unwavering resolution, and possessed of self-command beyond the ordinary measure of her sex or race. She was dignified, sterp, conscientious, believing fully in the re- lizgion which she professed, and devoted to the system of which her family was the exponent. So greatly, indeed, did she possess these quali- tics, that Bonaparte is reported to have said of Government to « curred in this drama. eminent tegrity. of ataxic fever; Desault, records around them to obliterate the spot. standing, The Nation. [Number 973 her that she was the only man in her family. Her position was as peculiar as her character. She was the daughter of the murdered King, the niece of the reigning one, the sister of the rightful Prince, and the wife of,,the heir-appa- rent. Like Louis XVIII, she erected no,monu- ment and allowed the beart produced by Pelle- tan to be retained by bis family. We cannot discover asingle act indicating the sisterly re- gard which would naturally be shown toward the remaios of a brother. Yet to the other members of her family who had been the vic- tims of the Revolution, no testimonials that an affection almost fanatical could prompt were unpaid. For her cousin, the Duc d’Enghien, once a week for months she had formed, and repaired to her chapel to pray for his soul. It is truly said, m reply to this, that the like offices were unnecessary, according to the tenets of the Catholic faitb, for the soul of achild. But, while this is true, it nevertheless shows a carelessness in regard to her brother strangely at variance with the fervor of the de- votion which she rendered to what she deemed the sacred victims of an unholy rebellion. To the Duchesse, Naundorff preferred his claim. Repeated were his applications for a personal ‘To every masses per- interview, and repeated ber refusals, request she returned not a decided negative, but a condition that he should send her the docu- mentary evidence he pretended to possess. At one time she appears to have deemed a personal interview with the King of Prussia necessary to resolve her doubts. Whenever this subject was brought to her notice, strong agitation is said to bave shaken her enduring frame. From her character and conduct, two inferences may be drawn—firstly, that she would never bave con- sented to deprive her brother of his rights, and that her agitation was due to the love she Lore him and the horrors be bad endured ; secondly, that she did assent to the surrender of his rights from motives of state policy, bur, in the unbend- ing pride of her nature, scorned to render those testimonials of and love to the un- known dust of the supposititious Prince which she would eagerly have given to a murdered brother and the heir of ber kingly race. re spect IRISH TROUBLES AND ENGLISH OPINION ABOUT THEM. LonbDoN, January 25. Dcrinc the last six or eight months Ireland Las been more free from agrarian and political crime than for a long time before. Whether owivg to the benefits extended to the tenants by the Land Act of 1881, or to the terror inspired by the Prevention of Crimes Act of 1882, or to the reaction that naturally followed upon the violent agitation which prevailed from the the Land League until the passing of the latter measure, or to all these causes taken together, there have been singularly few murders or other outrages, and also, through establishment of the three most frequently disturbed provinces, singularly few conflicts between the police and any section of the people, or between different Nevertbeless the Lrish problem has not [t still overshadows the factions. become less menacing. other troubles which our statesmen have to con- front, and is mixing it-elf up in a bothersome way with political questions which formerly affected England and Scctiand only. In the Parliamentary session on whose brink we now stand, Irish affairs are likely to become prominent in three forms, The first of these re- lates to the administration of Lord Spencer, and particularly to the probibition of political meet- ings in the northern counties. Ever since Mr. Healy, one of the ablest and most bitter mem- bers of the Parnellite party, was elected to the | House of Commons last spring for the County of Monaghan in Ulster, it has been the prime ob- ject of that party to win Ulster, and to eject from Ulster constituencies the Liberals and Tories who divide its representation between them, Although the upper classes iu that province are nearly all Tories, and the middle classes, espe- cially the tenant farmers, mostly Presbyterians, Scotch by descent and Liberals in politics, there is a large substratum of Roman Catholics who would support an extreme Home-Rule can- didate, and the enterprise of gaining over to the same side a part of the Protestant ten- antry does not seem hopeless. Accordingly the Parnellite party has begun to hold meetings and preach Home-Rule doctrines in the Ulster counties. This incensed the Tory party in the North, a party whose composition deserves to be explained. It is led by tbe nobility and squirearchy, who are nearly all Episcopalians and fierce Conservatives, while the rank and file are supplied by the artisans and small shop- keepers in the towns, with some tenant farmers in the country districts—persons who areeither Episcopalians or Presbyterians, and largely belong to the Orange organization. The Orange- men have thus the force which belongs both to an aristocratic and a demccratic body. Their chiefs are men of rank, wealth, and influence, who have, unfortunately for the peace of the country, been permitted to keepin their bands the local government and the best places. The rest, the humbler followers, have the strengto which comes of obedience to leaders, good organization, ignorant fanaticism, and the fierce courage which fanaticism pro- duces in men of a hardy race. They are fond of a figbt, and formidable ina fight, hav- ing on their side the recollection of two centu- ries of domivation over the Roman Catholic aborigines. The smouldering rage of the Ulster Orangemen at the progress of the Home Rule agitation was kindled into a flame by the visit of Sir Stafford Northcote, who had been taken into Ireland on one of those talking tours which have grown so common lately among us. Though he, being a mau of peace and gentleness, and knowing the dangerous nature of the soil he was treading on, carefully abstained from irritating or inflammatory lunguage, the mere fact of his presence as the leader of the Tory party, and of their assembling in large meetings to welcome him,stirred the susceptible hearts of the Orange- men, whose landlord chiefs took every opportu nity of appealing to them to show their batred to Mr Parnell and their loyalty to the British Crown. The opportunity was given when the Par- nellite meetings began. A_ certain toss- more, a zealous Orange squire, called on his brethren not to permit disloyal meetings to be held, and ever since then every political gather ing held by the Home Rulers in Ulster or on its borders has been threatened with attack. In some instances the Government have forbidden the mestings, not necessarily as disapprov- ing of them, but conceiving that they are likely to lead to breaches of tbe peace. In others they have allowed them to go on, and sought to protect them by putting large bodies of troops on the ground, charged to repel any onslaught of the so-called Loyalists. Such conduct seems tolerably good evidence of impartiality. No one but an Orangeman can suppose that Lord Spencer desires to favor and assist tbat National- ist party which kas continued to inveigh against his administration for the last eighteen months, and which accuses him of causing the death of many innocent victims, viz., the persons executed for agrarian and political assassina- tions. No one but a heated Nationalist can fail to recognize the wish to see fair play which has j

Page 15

“ys fila ERE Ye eee o Feb. 21, 1884] D.. led bim to protect Home-Rule meetings, even at the risk of incensing tbat part of the population which is most attached to the British connection. However, Lord Spencer and the are attacked from both sides with equal vebe Government menece. The Orangemen say that be is playing into the hands of Mr. Parnell. The complain that their meetings have occasionally Parnellites been prohibited, and declare that no justice can be bad from bim or his chief secretary. In any country but Ireland it would be felt that these opposite accusations, the one set as sincere as the other. answered each other, and proved that the aim of the Viceroy had been to treat both par ties alike and seek only the preservation of But in Ireland this is not felt. The middle party is small there. People have mostly ranged themselves in one or other of the two hostile camps: that moderating influ ence of an uncommitted public opinion, which order. judges public men according to their tebavior from day to day, is all but extinct. We hear, therefore, that in the first nights cf the session two attacks are to be made by Irish members on The demn its whole policy since the passing of the the Government, Nationalists will con- Crimes Act. The Orange members, seconded will complain of its leniency to the Nationalists, and the dise Protestants ” by the weight of the whole Tory party, uragement it hasinflicted onthe * of the North, At this numerous addresses are being presented by the loyal moment Orangemen to Lord Rossmore, commending bis action in calling on the Frotestants to rise and the holding of Home-Rule meetings, and sympathizing with bim under the punish ment which the Government inflicted on him by striking his name out of the list of magistrates. He isa young man of no personal or political note, but for the moment he is the representative of the principles which triumphed at prevent Londou derry and on the banks of Boyne Water, and is cheered at the stations through which he travels to Belfast to receive the homage of bis fellow Epise What do England and Sec this? In sober class of minds which Ireland wants. in England the mass of the C sympathizing with the Irish palians, ‘tland think of all fortunately exists that Well, nservative party, landlords and the disestablished Episcopal Church, and bating the Parnellites and their works, applauded the Or- angemen, yet without strongly censuring Lord Spencer, who is personally esteemed for the cool and firmness The Liberal them there shown in his whole atti urage tude. party is divided in The majority approve tbe policy of the Government, holding that order must be naintained at all hazards, that the Nationalists are entitled to summon their meet more pinion, ings solong as they do not preach outrage or sedition, and tbat the Orangemen are inflicting the heaviest blow future of Ireland the embers of strife. But there are also many among the Liberals, and among thcse moderate men who can hardly be re on the when they stir up religious ‘koned to either party, whoown to a sneaking sympathy They are attitude of the not (as they think) to Mr. Gladstone’s G has done for the dium it has with the Orangemen. nuch incensed at the Parnellites, who have friendliness vernment after all it Irish peasantry, and tbe encountered on their behalf: admitted the justice of the ces passed on assassins, and whose sole shown any never 1 Uf senter object is to embarrass the Cabinet and Par liament by every possible means. ‘‘ These in iters of outrage,” they say, ‘and apostles ¢ i sedition, ing the having succeeded in demoraliz- peasantry of Leinster, Munster, Con- naught, bave come into Uister to stir up strife and disaffection among a hitherto quiet popula- The Nation. tion. Itisonly natural that the loyal subjects in that province, anxious to maintain law, or der, and the connection of the three kingdoms. should rise up to oppose these revo lutionaries, keep them out present of the north, prevent England from supposing that the sentiments of the Roman Catholies of the north are suared by the people of Ulster. Their zeal may have out run their discretion, but after all it is good cause, and, though the Government must zeaiin a discountenauce violence, it need not be sorry to see these demonstrations, which prove bow far the Parnellite purty are from being a truly na tional party.” This vein of feeling among the English has always to be reckoned with, and any recrudescence of crime in Ireland would make it far stronger. Meantime the Orangemen are making bay while the sun shines. They are holding meet ings nominally to protest their loyalty to the Crown, but really to denounce Mr. Glad Government. They bave not suggested any counter policy, and, indeed, admit that under Lord Spencer’s rule the country is unusually But they apprehend when the question of comes up for quiet, serious wiscbief Irish local government K and declare that the Ministry is secretly in league with Mr. Parnel settlement, and has by no means exhausted its budget of concessions to agitation. In the midst of these ‘ontending cries of Nationalist and Tory, the Irish Liberals are silent. It looks, indeed, as if Irish Liberalism would soon come to a perpetual end, ground to powder between the upper and nether mill-stones of the two extreme parties. Theseats which the Minis terialists bold, already few in number, will be contested at the next election, sosay the Naticnal ist papers, of Mr. Parn three Roman Catholic provinces these « will probably succeed. In Ulster the P1 bv followers Liberals who r¢ Tyrone, When a few weeks ago the Irish Solicitor-G ral offered himself for the county of | derry, the cause present the counties of and Donegal may h Parnellites cid not oppose h they were incensed at the outbreak of Orangeism, and feared, by runnirg a candidat of their own, to let an Orangeman in. may decide upon different tactics general election arrives, and conclude that the best plan is at all bazards to weaken the present Government, so tbat between two nearly equally balanced English parties they may the mor easily secure their ow ! s Tt res i t r deciding t contest t s mons, and leave s seventy or eighty I’a nellites nfronting some thirty ( en, [wo or three individual Liberals would survive in respect of their personal popularity, but the party would have va 1, and with it I siderable element of moral as well as voting strength, which Mr. Gladstone bas hitberto been able to countupon. There would tb 1llv no Lrish representatives wh his P yr, but y two sets of ener kK ing it fron posite points of view—not a pleas abinet bringing forward 1s topics for debate which Ireland is lkely to furnish to Parliament, re late to the enlargement of the electoral franchise er boroughs and coun he populariza l t t tion and reform of her local self-governing in stitutions. These are, however, too important to be dealt with at the end of a letter. Y. VITROLLES AND THE Bol T t RESTORATION I \ Ta iry aes ' M. I NE | vhohasa vj : ed tt corres pounder of Lame " ‘ w publist y the Me rsand } t alk i . if the Bar e\ s Vitu ¢ Was t the wost im amt f . ! N territ 1 Was & ‘“ pear rdcte vy, Wi tisa ira st as and wh ave \ tra t g action has | " tad \ pare {tot i 4 1 tors are « the s 1 ky» ure secl nk ‘ \ st “ se if int ist of i is sa d sters I . R \ f the : ft i Bourbons, ata \ t i , was still ta Ile was i s fn ged t VAS | T ‘ t { ‘ whe \ ( tle s ‘ i ‘ the shores of t I i a great s hay v 4} cs es sa \ ti r 1 M v “ w“ t ed i ter f tray ed iw \ D tt ‘ ‘ ——_ : l M : \ ‘ ‘ t I \ | t wi t » ‘ > bd S| i a . t > w s \ i a f \ s : 1 1 4 s i s t \ “ t ‘ | t “ ‘ ! \ wit I i “ t i ~ ; what } t vw ct I V8 gera ve of the Rev 4 row | . t s} 3 i Tt s t ex s f r f y tier had weak« thet t Ss he bat f Mar there | en r Fra s and tbe vy t s Bor t I \ y of N con st } ssifa bert, M i I ~ 1d 8 i l 1s { 1 few w al to express bts 1 ft ] tr ftre Na | r. @ f ther west bu ] £ of the Ay s Mair vi ad been le Duke and ( r tf Sta by thers were the Aly I sand the far is lalleyrand, Ww wasa fri f Dalbes Mme. de Vaude nt, the last representative in France of the old t s I e, bad a salon where they often met. 1 secret enemies of Napoleon had no reia ns With the Bourbon princes, One evening furi the Emperor for an insulting speech made to bis at Mme. de Vaudemont’s, Dalberg, us With wife, spoke f the to Talleyrand ** Well, said he, ‘‘how will they be for us? ‘Have they,” jded t Abl Lou forgotten the mass of t ith of July [the mass of the Federation, at alleyrand had officiated as Bishop of Autur The English papers were prohibited in France, hou- M. le Comte d@’Ar Charles X.) had left for the Continent on the 25th of January, 1814; the Duc d’Angouléme had also left England for the From anumber which fell into his hands, ever, Vitrolles learned that who became tos

Page 16

The Nation. [Number 973 164 south of France. Vitrolles resolved to leave Paris and to try to find Monsieur. When he took this resolution, negotiations were beginning at Chatillon between Napoleon and the allies. ‘You sea,” said Calleyrand to Dalberg, ‘Show ignorant Europeis of our situation—ignorant of what she cau do, ignorant of what she ought to do. Sne opens negotiations with the man sbe ought to crush, and at the moment when sbe coull end with him. He will be more clever than Evrope; peace will besigned, and what will become of us¢ He suspects our wistes, he will never forgive us. We must at any price in- struct the allied sovereigns, and let them know the danger of these negotiations. But how? How can we flod a person who can come near them, inform them, reassure them, and give them courage and hope?” In vain did Dalberg ask Talleyrand to give Vitrolles some letter of introduction, or even a seal with bisarms. Dalberg himself wrote in sympathetic ink two words on a portfolio, which were to be shown to Count Stadion, Minister of Austria at the Congress of Chatillon (these two words were the names of two ladies whom Stadion and Dalberg bad known at Vi- enna); he gave Vitrolles also two lines for Nes- selrode, and a seal with his arms. Vitrolles was not accredited in any other way, and Dal- berg even asked him not toname bim to Metter- nicb, with whom he was not on good terms. Vi- trolles took a passport for the Basses-Alps, and started under the pretext of going to his fam- ily. He left onthe 6th of March by diligence. I will not relate here all his adventures on the way. He succeeded in reaching Count Stadi- on, who told him atonce that Metternich could not be kept out of the secret. Stadion was very hostile to Napoleon, and entered readily into the views of Vitrolles; he put him in communication with Metternich and Nesselrode. The two names which Vitrolles had shown had convinced him. Metternich was at first more doubtful,but he said to Vitrolles: ‘If you were sent here by Bonaparte or by Savary, I would speak to youas I will now: all is open now, our intentions are known; we wish them to be made public.” He explained how the alliance had been formed agaiost the boundless ambition of Napoleon, The conditions of peace could only be such as would secure the equilibrium of Europe: Rus- sia, Austria, France must be well balanced; Prussia must acquire new territories; Holland must be again a nation. Vitrolles answered that *‘ ‘no diplomatic combinations, no treaties could secure peace; the wishes of France must also be consulted. Sbe was tired of Napoleon, who had himself been obliged to prorogue bis Chambers. . . . In short, there could be no peace with Bonaparte, and there could be po France without the Bourbons. . The ministers looked at each other: it was the first time tbat the name of Bourbon had been pro- nounced. After a little silence, Metternich spoke first ard said: ‘We have been in France for two montbs,and we find among the people no- thing to justify your declarations. There seems to be no regret for the past, no expressions of discontent with the present. We have, itis true, seen a few émigrés, whoask us very timidly if it is our intention to bring back the King. But they leave us withcut a word when we tell them that we have nosuch desire,’ ” Vitrolles was playing a terrible game, It was quite clear that bis mission could not long be kept secret from Napoleon. If the kings and emperors made their peace with bim, Vitrolles was a lost man: he could only save his head by a voluntary exile. We cannot wonder if, once engaged in bis dangerous enterprise, be put all his energy into bis work, What Metternich said was very true, and we have seen the same thing in our times. So many revvlutions have swept the soil of France that the peasant is al- ways cautious and uneasy ; he dares not say what he hates or what he loves, what he fears or what he hopes. After the war of 1870, « hen the Ger- mans covered the third part of France, I went from Brittany to Bordeaux, and from Bordeaux to Paris, and I was not able any where to discern what were the real sentiments and wishes of the peasantry touching the future of France. Metternich in 1814 felt how dangerous it would be for the allies themselves to give a new gov- ernment to a conquered pation. The stigma of foreign pressure was always on the Restoration Government, and it soon became a vulgar invec tive to say that the Bourbons bad been brought back in the *‘ fourgons des Cosaques.” The con- versations of Metternich with Vitrolles possess deep interest, as they show us the principal statesman of the Coalition face to face with numberless difficulties. Metternich discussed with Vitrolles the new frontiers of France. Vitrolles said that it would be fatal to the Bour- bons not to give them as much as would be given to Napoleon. Metternich did not deny it; he admitted vaguely the possibility of giviug to France a part of the countries lying between the Moselle and the Rhine, and even to add Luxem- bourg to it. As for Belgium, he would not hear of it, especially on account of Antwerp. Vitrolles’s mission was two-fold: it was not enough for him to see the allies, he wished to see the Comte d’Artois. He first wrote to him, and Metternich offered tosend the letter through the Austrian generals who were in Franche Comté. While be was waiting for an answer, be had an interview with the Emperor Alexander; he spoke to him as he had done to Metternich. The Em- peror was cold. He praised Vitrolles’s loyalty to the French royal family, but added: ‘‘ The ob- stacles which now separate the Princes of the house of Bourbon from the throne seem to me insurmountable. They would come back embit tered by misfortune, and, even if they could sacrifice their resentment, they could not mode- rate those who bave suffered for them and by them. . . The spiritof the army, so power- fulin France, would be opposed to them; the new generations would have a spirit adverse to theirs, The Protestants would not see their return without fear and without opposition. The spirit of the times is not with them.” Then he added suddenly: ‘* Besides, do you know the Pricces of the royal family?’ Vitrolles said that he did not; that as a soldier in the army of Condé he bad only known tbe three gene- rations of this family. The Emperor said: “Tf you knew them, you would be persuaded that the burden of such a crown would be too heavy for them.” He then spoke of other can- didates—of Bernadotte, of Eug?ne Beauharnais —even of a republic: ‘‘A republic, wisely or- ganized, would perbaps suit the French mind. It is not in vain that ideas of liberty bave germinated solong ina country like yours.” Vi- trolles was astounded ; be almost despaired of bis cause. He spoke with eloquence, with fire, and he saw by degrees that his emotion was communicative. He told Alexander not to make an ordinary war, a strategical war—to mae it political; to go straight to Paris, and, once there, to allow French opinion to manifest itself: ‘‘I will leave my head in the hands of your Majesty if this opinion does not pronounce | itself for the reéstablisbment of movarcby.” | | | Alexander was seduced by this idea of making | the war more politica) than strategical, and to show himself in Paris, not as the enemy but as the friend of the French people. **I leave to- | nigbt,” said be, ** for the beadquarters of Prince | Sch wartzenberg. versation will have great results.” The negotiations at ChAtillon soon came to an end. Vitrolles became al] the more important. I promise you tbat our con- | The allied mini-ters were so isolated that they were extremely anxious to enter into relations with Frenchmen. The sovereigns declared that they would treat no more with Napoleon, and Vitrolles was among them the voluutary advo- cate of the Bourbons. They all felt or thought tbat behind Vitrolles was Talleyrand, who had so long been the arbiter of Europe. Vitrolles bad gained much, but so far be bad not bound bis action with the action of the Princes. He saw Monsieur for the first time at Nancy. His credentials to him were a few words written on a piece of gauze by Mme. de Durfort, a letter of Metternich, and a ring with the device ‘*God and the King.” M.de Vitrolles was well re- ceived. He says himself, not very modestly: ‘IT brought a kingdom, and it was felt” He urged Monsieur to seize at once the royal au- thority in the provinces in the name of the King, to summon all his friends, to form an administration. He explained to bim men and things in France. All was new to Monsieur ; he was a stranger in his own country. On bis side, he explained to Vitrolles who these Bourbons were whom he bad undertaken to replace in their old station. GERMAN POLITICS. BERLIN, January 29, 1884. OvrR political situation bas not undergone any essential change since the beginning of the new year. People begin to enjoy peace, and the ap- prehensions of war into which tbey had been frightened last year are lusing ground. The ge- neral aspects are, in fact, more cheerful, ,altbough the Government continues to undo what was done in the decade of 1868 to 1878, The Lard- tag is discussing new taxes, which in the inte- rest of our agrarians are tu be laid on the cani- talists and the ‘‘ bloated bondbolders ”; and Bis- marck, although daily receiving his own minis- ters and foreign ambassadors, passes his leisure hours in reading the works of the Abbé Lamen- nais. Thiok of that mystical, obscure, and vi- sionary priest, and the sober, empirical, and clear-headed Chancellor! Whoever takes part in public affairs is uneasy if not despondent, ard nobody knows how the present state of affairs willend One expects wonders from tbe death of the Emperor; anotber waits for the retire- ment of the Chancellor, or for the return to bis policy of former days, although these latter events will never happen. The transactions of our patliamentary bovies are dull and uninterest- ing; in short, itis tbe reaction of the popular mind against the entbusiasm of tbe late war, and against the excitement of roused passions. The same state of feeling prevails in otber na- tions, too, which have undergone heavy convul- sions and internal revolutions, Under another pame, perbaps, but in essentially the same way, you likewise witnessed the same anxieties and the utter sterility of the law-making power for several years after your war was over. Whatever Bismarck coula do he bas done to dis- card the laws of his liberal period; but he is far from having been successful. Here and there a new reactionary plank has been inserted into a section of an old liberal law: but as yet he bas not been able to destroy the ground and frame- work. On Javuary Ist the new law regulating the industrial and professional trades (Gewe) be- Ordnung) went into effect. One of its cbief amendments is the restriction of the bicherto upnembarrassed movements of peddlers and com- mercial] travellers. The police bave succeeded in dealing with them as severely as possible. The peadler, by tbe new law, is required to show his stock to any police authority, and to give a cata- logue of bis books. In Frankfort on the Oder our holy Hermandad took offence at and confis- PETS Mee ¥ ;

Page 17

Feb, 21, 1884] cated, among others, two prominent and (to use the police slang) two ‘*moral” magazines, viz., Spemann’s Vom Fels zum Meer, a monthly of the character of Harper's Magazine; and Scbo- rer’s Familien-Blatt, a weekly, beautifully illus- trated, and full of useful information. The former has 48,000 and the latter 75,000 subscrib ers. The police did not consider thetn moral enough, and forbade their sale by peddlers. The ery against this outrage was so loud that the Regierungs-Priisident (Chief of the Government Circle) had to apologize for bis subordivates. In the Kingdom of Saxony the provision of the law, that peddlers infected with contagious dis eases, and of a revoltiog (abschreckenden) ap- pearance shall not be allowed to solicit custom- ers, was, witbout a shadow of law, extended to commercial travellers, who were without no- tice taken before the police and stripped, in or- der to be searcbed and exumined. In this in stance, too, the Government was compelled by general indignation to revoke an unjust inter pretation of tbe law. You bave no idea of the indifference, if not stupidity, of those whose interest lies in this direction. If they are not injured personally, they do not move, and eveu take delight in the damages suffered by otbers. It is a sorry tri- bute to the intellect of German publishers tbat, instead of fighting betimes the attacks of the reactionary parties on the free sale of books, and instead of standing hke one man in the maintenance of their common interest, the most prominent among them pointed out those whose publications ought to be prosecuted—provided, of course, that their own books and periodicals remained undisturbed. A friend of mine who is a member of the Reichstag, and manfully tought for free colportage, told me that be bad received dozens of remonstrances alleging that he had been too radical in bis views, that he had better confine himself to the confiscation of obscene literature: and now the first blow of the police has fallen upon one who remonstrated in this way. Tbe new bill for regulating hunting (Jagdord- nung), too, now before the Prussian Lardtag, has no prospect of passing. It is dictated by the most feudal views, for tbe exclusive benefit of the large eastern landholders. You can have no idea of the ravages made by the deer and wild boar on the fields of poor people in the neighborhood of deer parks, who nevertheless are not allowed to guard themselves against the game by shooting it, and are even criminally punished for so doing. A majority of Liberals and Conservatives bave declared themselves against that bill, the latter in anticipation of their defeat in the coming campaign if they should sustain suchalaw, One after another the Conservatives dropped off when they saw the impossibility of carrying the measure for the Government. The conflict with Rome is further than ever from being settled. geant, and the Uitramontanes are still asking more, while the Government answers that it has dene enough to show its good-will toward the Roman Cbureb. The agitation of our U! tramontaues is therefore kepc up with tbe old phrases and with empty declarations. On the other baud, Minister Gossler, a few days ago, in reply to an interpeliation of the Centre in tne Landtag, positively declared that the two most obnoxious archbhishops—viz.: those of Cologne and Posen—would never be pardoved, while the Bishop of Miioster nad lately been allowed to return to his flock. This is the first sign of manbovud which a Prussian Minister bas mani- fested in this respect for the last four years. The “ Chaplain’s Press” of course cried out that the days of Fulk had returned, and that the Liappétit vient en man The Nation. Roman Catbolic Church was still a victim of Prussian cruelty. This is sheer nonsense. I thivk that the Government has yielded much more than was necessary. The charge, too, that Catholics, in consequence of the removal of their disobedient priests, were unable to wor ship, 1s just now a shallower pretext than ever, since hundreds, if not thousands, of clergymen (as Many as have applied for reinstatement) have been reappointed. Besides, a Government cannot reasonably be called partial, and unjust toward the Catholics, which among its com manding generals, ministers of state, and high civil dignitares numbers proportionally as many Catholics as Protestants, The real fact is that even the most tolerant grows tired of conces sions. Bismarck, of course, is only indulgent so far as he can gain valuable considerations. If he gets them, he will do everything— quan ’ tum mutatus ab illo !—to please Rome. He holds a few more trumps in his band, and if he can play them to advantage he will do so without the least scruple. His end is to gain the parlia mentary support of the Centre, which at present, by codperating with the Conservatives, com mands a small majority in the House. Any other reasun does not influence bim. have consequently lost all confidence in their former leader. already stagnant. appeals to the Liberals, he will meet with utter coldness and indifference. of interest in this diplomatic game of bluff is People The whole conflict with Rome ts If the Chancellor ever again The only question which of the antagonists will be prompt and sharp enough to outwit the other. [n all otber respects the details of the struggle are disgust ing, and do not deserve notice Tae Conseil Supérieur (Volkswirthsehafts rath) has once more been in session during the last few days and will shortly close its sittings It was convened to give its opinion on the bil of accident insurance by and for the different trades. What distinguishes this august body from parliamentary assemblies is, that even be fore arriving in Berlin they are earnestiv en treated to despatch business, and not to sit longer than afew days. As even tne Landtag refused to grant salaries and travelling expenses to these geutry, they are politely invited by the minister to come at their own expense, and, de spite all obloquy, to sacrifice their valuable time for so patriotic a purpose. But,alas! in this sinful world, appeals of this sort are ata heavy dis count, and only 50 per cent. of the immortsl or ginal nuoiber packed their lunch boxes and purchased a ticket for Berlin. The Stettin por ter who had been appointed by the King’s plea sure, could not afford toc petty cash, aud to another of th’s meritorious me, being short of class of private officers the company in whose service he earns bis daily bread refused bim the desired furlough, under the pretext that be was such a copsummate blockbead that be would dis ne. W hv the other councilors do not defray the travelling credit the town from which be ‘ ’ expeoses of their poorer bretbren, [ cannot un derstand. In my opinion a inan, if he be obly a porter, Woo knows ail about trade and commerce, manufacturing and shipping, agri- culture and finarce, railroad matters and telegrapbic improvements, and can make apy number of speeches or give opinions on them, is worth at least a dozen crowns. Let me, finally, state that the majority of these sages Were from the beginning in conflict with their creator, aud were evem so disrespectful as openly to oppose bis bill. The fact 1s, thet at the head of this ccnspiracy (in Bismarck’s eyes every male citizen isa conspirator who does Lot ful'y and most unequivocally endorse bis views) stand the manufacturers [bey smell the rat: there ls money in the biul—not for, but against them; and the Government will finally compe them to foot it. +44 Correspondence. THE ‘BREADWINNERS* AND ‘DEM RACY To THE Epitror oF THe Nation Sin: The autborship of the ‘ Kreadwinners is,as lL see by a paragraph now going the rounds of the press, to be kept from the put White I do not intend to bavard any guess as to w the author is, | would hke to surmise that the ‘Breadwinpners*® is by the same band as mocracy,’ the novel which sot years ayo had a certain degree of success this try i avery great success in England Let wey was a sketch of Washington sectal andy tical life, evidently written by some one familiar with it. Tne *‘ Breadwinners’ is a sketch of Cleveland social and political life, also written by one quite at bome toit. Tam bv no means an admirer of either book : vet in both there ts the same strong, arse, Nast li irawing of aspect and characters in s al and pol ‘ which comes directiv bome to every people Tbe work is crude, and there are few fine touches to it. It is alwavs provoking|ly i the verge of being verv good, and vet distinetly never Is Verve good In * Den t v, as tn the ‘Breadwinners,’ we feel cor iseof the same keen, observant eve, working thr ghoa hand which is quite lacking im training, and which also, either naturally or f ndolence, is un equal to a sustained eff l fanev it would be safe to guess that the author bad worked ona De Ws per He certaioly ha seen ag ideal f polit ins, and was never a ma f busines That he was e inthe army is plain. Who he s, Lbavex tt re otest idea A Roerosn arv 8 MONGOLIAN AND INDIAN NOSES wsition that their flat noses may have arisen Allow me to say that itis the custom of the wild sioux } from their peculiar wav of eating meat to partake of flesh in this wayv—in fact, was the universal custom, but their noses have remained a most prominent feature, and the more one *knows” of the Dakotas, the more the exceed- ing great number of extremely large noses im presses bim. Roman noses are a prevailing feature, but the booked cr (what we are led to suppose from illustravions of the nose of our Jewish biethren) Je@ish nose is well represented. The “iurped up,” or Milesian, also is not uncom mon,but always largeand prominent. So the per us mode of conveyance that Mr. Gilmour de scribes carnot have modified tbe size of his Very traly yours, M. A. Swirt. Mongolian’s nose. GUIDES TO WHIST- PLAYING. To TRE EpiTOR OF THE NATION: Stk: Tam past forty and have begun intime to prepare for a happy old age by learnivg whist. the name of a manual which makes asharp dis tinction between those playing-rules leid down Now, can sny of your readeis give me for thesake of securing uniformity of practice among viayers, aud those other play ing-rules by following which a man wins moretricks tban he otherwise would? Allow me w make my mean-

Page 18

166 [Number 973 The Nation. ing clearer by referring to two practices which prevail among drivers, Tbe driver turns to the right (ia America) on meeting another vehicle, and not to the left (as they do in Rome), just because the rightand not the left; but he sits on a high cushion for another kind of reason— namely, inorder that he may see the road bet- ter.—Yours truly, V. R. CAMBRIDGE, Mass., February 11, 1884. quite [So far as our information goes, there is no work on whist which treats separately the two classes of rules; but as all good books on whist give the reasons for the rules,the learner may and classify for himself without great difliculty. In Mr. Buckland’s most elementary and excellent ‘ Whist for Allen; New York: Welford), the advice as to playing and the advice as to ‘‘ uniformity distinguish Beginners’ (London: Scribner ¢ is ample of practice,” by which we suppose our corre- spondent means the scientific method of play- ing both partners’ hands as one, is necessarily Both ‘‘ Cavendish” and the sligutly bumptious but very acute book on ‘American Whist’ (Boston: Osgood) ought also to be consulted.—Ep. Nation. ] very slight. THE ABUSE OF LAW-MAKING, To THE Epitror oF THE NATION : Sir: The excellent article in last week’s Nation on the subject of “Excessive Legislation” leads me to call attention to the mischievous competition, especially manifest of late among members of the Legislature, in passed, to the end, chiefly, of gaining credit with constituents for industry and efficiency. At the close of each sessicn, lists of achieve- ously adjudged a person insane, when such dect- | sion is questioned. “stern custom bas decreed” it shall be | It seems almost self-evident that men who have devoted much of their time to the study of mental diseases, and who have had long experi- | THE NEW PUBLIC-LANDS PROBLEM. | To THE EpiTor oF THE NaTION: ence in dealing with the insane, should be better | qualified to decide whether or not a man is in- sane than a jury as ordinarily composed. Yet | any one would naturally infer from reading the | article entitled “Doctors in Court,” which ap- | peared in your issue of the 7th iost., that you | believe that the scientific study of mental dis- | eases naturally disqualifies a man for holding | the position of an arbiter between the person suspected to be of unsound mind and those who have caused him to be confined in an asylum. Certainly you will be the last to admit that training in any other vocation, except that of the “alienist,” di:qualifies a man for forming a sound opinion upon questions connected with that calling. Why an exception to the general rule should be made in this particular case it is hard to understand. The rights of the insane must be respected, but the safety of the community at large must be respected as well. If, therefore, a man has been proved to be under the delusion that he is constantly annoyed by imaginary enemies, and | shows a tendency to mistake real persons for gettinz laws | these imaginary enemies—as I believe was actu- ally the case with regard to youvg Meredith— the responsibility of givivg bim entire freedom of intercourse with his fellows is a very grave one, Such a person demands and spould re- ceive our warmest sympathy, but it is not a case that should be put onthe same footing as the case of a reel or supposed criminal, The fact of the existence of such a form of insanity being once satisfactorily proved by tbe unani- mous consent of those best qualified to give an | opinion upon the subject, it would seem that an ments inthis line are paraded by members or their friends, with something of the pride shown by savages in multiplying the scalps of enemies | on their belts, Last year most of the newspa- pers hereabouts publisbed such lists, and the public were called upon to admire their lawgiv- ers according to the degree of their activity and success in lumbering the statute book. Tbe worth, the need, of the laws thus held upas passports to popular confidence and esteem seemed to be regarded as of secondary import- ance, or of no importance at all. bers of the Legislature are not alone at fault here. The voters must take a good share of blame to themselves for the establishment of this foolish test of legislative usefulness, and this fact shows the necessity of just such work as is being done by the Society for the Promo- tion of Pohtical Education. JoHN H, MAGEE. TrseunaH, N. Y., February 17, 1884, DOCTORS IN COURT, To THE EpiTror OF THE NATION; Sin: That doctors have in some cases forfeited the confidence of all respectable people by con- sentirg to certify to the insanity of people whom they knew to be sane, is doubtless true. That they bave also frequently made mistakes in their diagnosis of insanity is likewise true. The true remedy against the evils of the pre- sent system would, it seems to me, be found in the appomtment of a Commission on Lunacy in each State. This Commission might be com- posed both of medical and non-medical men; but it should be composed of men of recognized integrity, intelligence, and impartiality. To this Commission appeals should be taken from the decision of the physicians who have previ- Now, mem- | appeal to the sympathy of the jury was no longer in place, and that an intciligent judge could no longer have any doubt as to the action that should be taken in the matter. In conclusion, the writer must confess that he was surprised to find that the editor of the Nation, a journal which has always borne the reputation among American journals for en- lightenment and liberality of judgment, gave countenance to the vulgar prejudice against trained medical experts. S. H. PHILADELPHIA, February 9, 1884, {‘‘S. IL.,” it is hardly necessary to say, is a physician. We shall not attempt to discuss his “surprise” at our giving countenance to what he calls the ‘‘ vulgar prejudice” against medical experts, because he does not under- take to give any reason for this emotion on his part. thinking that the prejudice has a good deal to rest upon; ¢. g., that cases paid to make out a case of insanity or the reverse. If we areright,the prejudice is not vulgar. On the other hand, ‘‘S. H.” should, if We have given several reasons for alienists are in most | ming and much of Montana and Idaho. Srr: In your issue of January 24th, vou re- fer to the resolution passed by the House, under the lead of Mr. Holman, which moots the ques- tion that all the public domain sball be ‘‘dis- posed of under the provisions of the Homestead law only.” Itisa sad misfortune that so many questions of real importance prove the foot-ball of supposed partisan advantage. The dealing of | the Government with the public lands is not even discussed in Congress according to its merits, but wholly on the supposed effect upon the voting public of the speeches made and policy pursued. During the present session of Congress one bill looking toward a reconsideration of the public. land question bas been offered by one of the new members from Kansas, Judge Peters. It provides for the classification of the public lands into agricultural, grazing, timber, and mineral lands. Whether its provisions are wise and practicul I know not, as I have not seen the bill; but the idea of thus classifying the lands is wise. In Kansas the lands west of tbe 100th meridian are utterly unfit for agriculture un- less the land be irrigated, and yet the present policy of the Government assumes that all these lands are as good for agricultural uses as those 100 miles east of them; and there are bills be- fore Congress which propose to repeal all modes by which any one can secure title to any of said lands save ‘‘under tbe provisions of the Home- stead law only.” There are settlhrs at Dodge City, almost on the 100th meridian, who bave for ten years tried to raise fruit and vegetables without the use of irrigation, and in no year has it proved possible. West of Dodge City, forty miles, is the settlement of Garden City, which depends wholly upon water from the Arkansas River to raise the crops. Professor Snow, of the Kansas State University, in a recent article on the ‘‘ Climate of Kansas,” says: ‘‘ Kansas may be divided into three sec- tions iu reference to its rainfall. West- ern Kansas has from ten to fifteen inches of an average annual precipitation,” which is alto- getaer inadequate for agriculture. Kansas ties between longitude 94° 45’ and 102°; hence, west of 99° 35’ of longitude, according to Professor Snow, the rainfall is less than sixteen inches. In Colorado, with its 106,475 square miles, New Mexico, with 124,450 square miles, Arizona, with 130,800 square miles, Utab, with 109,600 square miles, Nevada, with 83,500 square miles, as well | as the western tbird of Kansas, with 24,335 square miles—in all 579.158 squsre miles—there are no lands (or so nearly none as not at all to influence the problem) which can be cultivated for agri- cultural uses, save by irrigation; and to this 1m- mense aggregate may probably be added Wyo- One would suppose the time had arrived for the | statesmen at Washington to at least devise a new | Government has now to deal, we are wrong for reasons whith he is able to | state, give them, and not confine himself to | expressing surprise—an inconclusive species of | argument. That a Commission on Lunacy, composed of medical and non-medical men, vould give us any better machinery than the courts of justice, aided by physicians, now afford, we doubt. | are generally constituted,it would be inferior. But if ‘‘S. H.” thinks the prejudice against | alienists vulgar, why in the world does he want any non-medical men on his commis- sion 7—Ep, Nation. | public-land policy for the so nearly wholly chavged character of the lands with which the The bill of Judge Peters, above referred to, may be the beginning of some sensible consideration of the question, by classification of the lands; and this need not | be either an expensive or a difficult matter. Probably, as such bodies | The amount of land in the States and Territo- ries last above named which may be irrigated is not, relatively to their aggregace areas, large, but very smal]. That these lands should be held for disposal only ‘‘ under the provisions of the Homestead law” is undoubtedly wise; but the limit of acreage to be taken by any one person should be eighty acres, in lieu of one hundred and sixty acres; for settlement must be more dense when irrigation is used, and eighty acre’ —- Diesel Siknais

Page 19

Feb. 21, 1884] The Nation.

would be all an ordinary farmer could utilize. The rest of the lands—nine-tenths at least of the total area—not counting the inconsiderable num ber of square miles of mineral and timber lands, are fit only for grazing. The natural grasses found will not sustain more than one steer to each ten or fifteen acres of land—or sixty-four to thirty-tbree steers tothe square mile. This seems a smal! number of animals to be supported onatract of land one mile square, and yet the number here stated is too large rather than the reverse. I should doubt the wisdom of selling these lands outright; but why not lease them for a term of years? Is not the whole coun try interested in the production of abundant, healthy, and cheap beef? Nowhere in America, at least, if in the world, can cattle be bred and put into the market so cheaply as upon the great plains which lie at the foot of the Rocky Moun tains and the ranges west of them. These cattle are not the fat cattle from which the choice cuts are made, but the common meats of the packing barrel or the cheaper meats of the butcher; or they supply to the feeders of cattle, at less price than the farmer of Obio or further e st can raise them. the animals which are fatted for export or the tables of those able to pay for good meat. To-day the castle men are buying up the wa ter fronts, and great corporations or men of large means are securing control of the water, and push the man of moderate capital off the plains. All this be obviated, and men of small capital can embark in the grazing of cattle, if the Government will only icsure them some right of possession through a lease; and with the right to fence, pot only more cat- tle can be raised, but at a less cost, for the mar- kets of the East. Besides, the Government, leasing the Jand for not more than fifteen years at a time. can watch the effect -f grazing on the wild grasses and prevent their destruction, whieh is far more important than will seem to persons unacquainted with the plains. Asa na- tion we have dealt with our forests on the prin- ciple of “after us the deluge”, and unless a halt is called upon the grazing of the plains, and the of its grasses is regulated, we sball see our can use cattle interests rise very high and rapidly, and then collapse as suddenly. FRONTIERSMAN, LAWRENCE, Kansas, February 14, 1884.

OF THE DEPRESSION BUSINESS. To THE EpITOR OF THE NATION: THE CAUSE IN Sr: In your issue cf this week you state that the present depression in trade has been caused by abnormal activity and overproduction in certain bravuches of business, and that what is needed is “a redistribution of employments” This is in accordance with the accepted theories of political economy. If we would accept these theories, we must believe that the cause of the present troubles lies inthe fact that we have been busy producing the wrong articles; that we have produced what was not wanted, and bave failed to produce what was wanted; and that all we have to do now is to turn round and producé the things that are really called for, and all will be well again. The difficulty with this theory is that it requires us to believe that there are certain wants and demands now un- satisfied and unsupplied, not because of the lack of means to purchase but because of the scarcity of the thing to be purchased. But if there are any productions of buman labor that are now scarce, they must command high prices and furnish large profits to the producers ; and any ‘apital that might now be unemployed would be hastening to secure a share of those profits. As a matter of fact, however, there is in this

—— —$—<—$——$ — $$$ —— ae —- = = country at the present time an immense amount There are three attitudes w N e a cf unemployed capital, and there are no symp sumed by Cabinet officers toms tbat even the sbrewdest and most enter First, they might be prising of its owners have any idea that there is in publi Ss1o1 st as now e any possible field in which they can employ it mmiutt I that w with profit to themselves. song, as the Se tarics W y If, however, we consider the cause of our the Opposit and taunt “ present troubles to be anabnormal activity and policy, while the ! overproduction, not in errtain classes of busi- to base their : ness, but in business general if we consider taries, t ‘ that the wealtby and thrifty among our people ed to as e £ ‘ have endeavored to do more business than the Course, no Sr condition of the country permitted, to create his place wt t . more productions than the pecuniary ability of f the House: and, t the rest of the community enable i thet it cor nal : ! s t be sume, we bavean explanation that fits the pres resign and Dew a ent state of the facts. A large portion of the Pres nt Now in ; community have been esger to ac the Ca td ’ . wealth, to make profitable investments, to save 1 gene ACTS ASA W up their income or their e irnings and put them sponsible f where they should bring annual returns greatin ven People have seen that factories produced for 1 y 1 . , their owners large profits, and they bave forth set a Minis ‘ , 8 with proceeded to build new factories in the the t f ’ hope of securing for themselves similar protits seen any sa keTOry ‘ In like manner capital bas bastened to build | but pr be \ new railroads, toerect new warehouses, and t Ministry is pra extend and multiply all branches of trade and lepe nt business. But the fact bas beer verlooked that Prenaiic i , profitable business aud protitable pi iclion nd that the cannot be increased indetinitely without a ex ment. Leans responding increase of customers and copsum nt, wi - . ’ ers. While there bas been recent!y an it must Linately ™ 5 mense increase of production, the wages of the SS Is poor, Which fix the limit of their ability toy sip, wl chase and to consume, bave not been largely . here tr t increased, and the rich bave sought rat! an in Lrrevy $ creased accamulation of wealth than a fuller President's | . gratification of their daily wants and desires The ditt ( M y Thus, instead of one factory producing and sel] fa defeat, w ‘hey , irgataproetita supply of products tbat rather lie ats fell short of than exceededthed and for them ment, ant y of we have had two or three factories producinga try it ; 24 supply much in excess of the demand, and stance that the | ‘ sequently competing with each ctherintheen- Without the sent of deavor to seli their surplus stock, and < git defeated Minist ; at no prctitorat a loss. Finally the factories | ‘ dis } . bave cut down tbe wages of theiremployees or =! bashed . ° have dismissed them altcgetber 1 the espa re BOY . city of the poor to purchase and ns is Ministry is met i i thus been largely taken away fr: them, w , ya hostile s “ ‘ the inclination of the rich in that direction bas 5 a , s been lessened by the loss of their al div j ¢ rat dends, and thus the original miscbief of over Cie - preduction bas been increased and intensified r $ A Brie fly, the theorv here suggested ts this Cal et 1 } “ that our people heave been trving ¢t vest erent from wt Cis t ¢ capital protitably, to do more business, than actly what M. Grevy , { ul their capacity and inclivation to consume made ty in Frat Na} i possible, and that the result bas been to seriously posit ina stit ‘ reduce that capacity and inclination, andt Sieyes, as that ol mut stroy the annual returns that capital bopest then we do not want a va M , receive from its investments and fr business, not the President be a : a» U. measure independ f par res} ’ BosTos ‘ v fort eneral I ‘ 7 Anothe i i fr it fact ‘ , f } + CABINET OFFICERS IN CONGRESS ee oe papi - the House, they mig ta | feat To THE Epitorn oF THE Nation be sent into private life, and mei rs might be Str: In bis letter of Januarv 14 Nat _No unwilling t risk t eir seats by a pti flice. 9) Mr. C. A. Towne, after stating with great Is it not conceivable that a distr pa 1 of force the advantaces of giving to the Cabinet having its member a Cabinet officer, mignt seats in Congress, gives expression to doubt on make some arrangement for keeping t at ne point ‘Whether it would also in time ren- at his disposal in case of need ? der necessary the incorporation of the other These things show that it is impossible to for principle, ministerial responsibility, into our sys see just what the course of development of the tem, and whether such a result is to be desired, measure would be. Moreover, it is useless to are questions pregoant with importance, and try to pave the way by any kind of constitu from whose iscussion no harm can come.” Up- tional amendment. In the first place, supp on this mild encouragement, and asthe subject ing the end to be desired, there would be an seems to be attracting some attention, I should endless and irreconcilable disagreement as to like to say 8 word,

what amendments were required to obtain the

Page 20

168 The Nation. [Number 973 end. But the end is by no means desired. Con- gress, for obvious—or, if not obvious, yet in- flexible—reasons, will be not only indifferent | but hostile; and the bostility of Congress to avy increase of responsibility, and therefore of power, in the Executive 1s mi'd compared with that which exists in the State Legislatures. To expect, tberefore, to obtain favorable action in advance in this direction from twenty-seven State Legislatures would be considerably more visionary than to advocate a constitutional amendment probibiting the manufacture and sale of liquor. The first and simplest step in the process, and that which would give the country a taste that would soon grow intu an appetite—namely, the presence of the Cabinet on regular days of the week on the floor of the House, just as they now appear before the committees—might be brougbt about any day by a simple resolution of the House. first step cancelled if not satisfactory. But even this step, simple as it seems, will never be taken by Congress of its own motion. The interests bound up with the present methods of doing business are too many and too strong to be overcome from the inside When some stropg public man shall become disgusted with the present anarcby and helplessness in Con- gress, aud have the courage totake the stump and tell the people just what he wants, he will— provided he is of the requisite calibre, intel- lectual, moral, and pbysical—be astonished at the gigantic furce which will place itself at his disposal. Butler’s career in Massachusetts is pregnant with instruction; and if good men refuse to learn the lesson, they may be sure that bad men will take it out of their bands. Boston, February 15, 1884. Notes. THE literary event of the week has been the actual appearance of ‘‘ Part I—A—Ant” of the ‘New English Dictionary on Historical Princi- ples,’ edited by Dr, J. A. H. Murray for the Philological Society (Macmillan & Co.). This is not the time todo more than advise every one who can afford it to procure it straightway. The price of each part is $3 25, and this part, for example, deals with 8,365 words, of which 6,797 have separate articles. Its 352 pages repre- sent a quarter of one volume of the six which the work is expected to fill. Dr. Murray’s ap- preciation of bis colaborers is very hearty and generous, and it is gratifying to observe his in- debtedness to many Americans, foremost among whom is Mr. Fitzedward Hall. American au- thors, likewise, have been freely laid under contribution in the illus'rative quotations, The typograpbical arrangement and impression are excellent, and wortby of the Clarendon Press. The division of the page is into three columns. Townsend Mac Coun, 744 Broadway, publishes immediately ‘ The James Madison Letters, 1769- 1838,’ in four volumes, 8vo, areprint of the Philadelphia edition published by orcer of Con- gress in 1865. D, Lothrop & Co, Boston, will publish next month ‘American Explorations in the Ice Zones,’ by Professor J. E. Nourse, U. 8. N. Henry Holt & Co. bave in press ‘ The Life and Poems of Theodore Winthrop,’ edited by his sister. Scribe’s “ Bertrand et Raton’ the French plays published by William R. Jen- kins in the series “ ThéAtre Contemporain.” , The fifth part of Mr. N. Ponce de Leon’s | ‘Englisb-Spanish Technological Dictionary ' The rest might be left to time, or the | is the latest of | | reaches the word Diamagnetism and the 240th of a special American political economy.” page. The submission of the Merv kbans to Russia | gives timeliness to the reprint by Funk & Wag- | nalls of O’Donovan’s ‘ Merv Oasis.’ Such is not exactly the new title, which is ‘ Merv,’ the abbre- really is. to the naif dependence of the Turcomanus on their very mixed and limited ordnance to meet “the possible arrival of the Russians,” will repay rereading just now. Charles Scribner’s Sons have issued a very pleasing new edition of Dean Stanley’s ‘ Lectures on the History of the Eastern Church.’ The English-reading public are to be congratu- lated on baving an early translation of Diintzer’s ‘ Life of Goethe,’ by far the most valuable life yet produced. The task bas been accomplished by Mr. Thomas W, Lyster, of the National Library of Ireland, who has proceeded in a very 1utelli- gent way, exercising considerable freedom in improving upon tbe original—as in quoting literally where Diintzer paraphrased—supply- ing foot notes which add decidedly to the value of the work, and a choice Goethe bibliography Above all, he has furnished a copious index, which Diintzer, »nore Germanico, bad neglected. The original illustrations are retained. The whole makes a plump 12mo volume of nearly 600 pages (Macmillan & Co). Mr. Charles Francis Adams, jr., has put fortb a new (third) edition of his ‘College Feticb,” with supplementary matter in confirmation of his views derived from a speech to Yale Alumni by Mr. George 8S. Merriam, a paper by Prof. E. J. James, in the Popular Science Monthly, and from editorial articles in the same magazine. In Science for February 1, Mr. Samuel Garman, of the Museum of Comparative Zodélogy at Cam- bridge, pictures a shark newly found in Japan- ese waters, which he is inclined to regard as typical of a new order, if not the possible ‘‘ sea serpent ” whose existence has given rise to so much controversy in our time. The head and sbape of the body (which Is less than four inches in its greatest diameter) make this a plausible suggestion, though the length of the individual in question is only five feet. Mr. Garman gives a fuller aescription of it, with a larger plate, in tbe Bulletin of the Essex Institute. The Art Interchange of January 3 has a taste- ful repeating design of Azaleas, which follows ahappy mean between the realistic and the Morris types of decorative flower work. The ‘ Plant Studies’ of Mr. Haité. which we no- ticed some weeks since upon the prospectus, as an English publication for the use of artists ‘London, Quaritcb), bas in the first number quite justified our deprecatory prevision. The plates are poor realism and worse design, needlessly coarse in execution (considering the facility of getting good reproductions at present), and as a whole not so good as any second-rate draughtsman could do for bimself. Parts 95.100 of the new Brockhaus’ Conversa- tions-Lexikon (New York: L W. Scbmidt) are double numbers, and, for an exception, bave no maps, but the usual plates—on fowls, galva- nism, garden tools, gas-macbines, ordnance, etc. They carry the work well into the letter G. Among the I6nger articles are Prisons (Gefdng- | niswesen) and Free-Trade, in which latter we find the following statement about our own | country, to be denied or confirmed by those who | think the task easy in tbe present condition of | parties: ‘Since then (1861-67) the American tariff bas, despite numerous changes, maintained | a high protectionist character; and though a counter free-trade current is not lacking, the majority ot the people are friendly to the pro- tective system, because they see in it the basis viation suggesting tbe epitome which thisreprint | Under Birth Statistics some suggestive compari- sons between Germany and France occur. In 1872 tbe number of living birtbs in the two countries was respectively 1,626,037 and 966,000, In the next | eight years Germany never fell below its figure, The passages on pp. 184, 185, relating | France never equalled or surpassed its own but once, viz., in 1876, * ben 966 682 were born, against Germany's 1,757,701 (also a high water mark), Since that year France bas steadily and alarm- ingly fallen off, ia 1880 producing only 920,177, Four pages, or eight columns, are given to Gali leo, which exceeds the space devoted to Frede- rick the Great. Gambetta (whose name Léon is said to stand for Napoléon) is disposed of in five columns, and Garibaldi in four and a half. Both characters are fairly judged, but the Italian, botwithstandiug his anti-German filibustering in 1870, more sympathetically. Gallia is the chief geographical article. Fremont, Margaret Fuller, Fulton, Garrison, and Gartield are among the American names. The late President is com- memorated as the ‘‘dark horse” of the conven- tion of 1880, and just censure is passed upon his attitude toward civil-service reform in the closing year of his life. The current number of the Réforme Sociale states that the correspondence of Le Play with M Charles de Ribbe, a prominent disciple of the founder of the school called ‘‘de la Paix Sociale,” will shortly be published by the latter, who will prefix a study of M. le Play. In the same pumber we read that on moving day in Paris (January 8), 4,500 families went out of the city to 3,200 thut came in—a hopeful sign, thinks the editor. The Bulletin de Correspondance Hellénique, organ of the French school at Athens, for De- cember, reaches us late. It has a double belio- gravure of a pedimental series of Myrina statu- ettes, and one of a bas-relief found at Peirzus, witb its usual récolte of inscriptions, articles on the Myrina discoveries by Pottier and Reinach, and inscriptions from Asia Minor, with a very interesting dissertation on the worship of Zeus Milicbios (Baal Mihk), by M. Foucart, head of the school. Ferdinand Avenarius’s ‘Deutsche Lyrik der Gegenwart seit 1850’ (noticed in No. 907 of the Nation) bas deservedly reached a_ second edition. Owing to the Jimited scope of this anthology, vo considerable accession to its list of poets was to be expected in a second edition; still, it is rather surprising to find it ricber than the first by only two names and about twenty- five pages or poems. This slight addition hardly bears out the publisher’s claim of ‘greatly en- larged” (sehr vermehrte); nor does it represent pure gain, for the admission of Wolfgang Kirch- bach cannot be considered a compensation for the omission of Ernst Eckstein, who appeared in the first edition, and whose rising fame as a yromancer may ~be_ supposed to stimulate interest in bis poetry, entitled to recognition on its own merits, Wiltelm Hertz, the other new writer admitted, has de- servedly found a place in this collection. The extract from bis ‘Bruder Rausch” awakens a desire to see more of it—an unusual sevsation in the case of the humorous pseudu-medieval epic so successfully created by Scheffel, but worn threadpare by imitators. Herr Avenarius the editor hasshown some not unpardonable par- tiality for Herr Avenarius the poet, toree of whose poems are given in this edition, wbereas the first contained only one. The two new ones are neither better nor worse than most imitations of Heine. Herr Avenarius has also given the | biographical data concerning himself modestly withheld before. He is but twenty-eight years of age, and is, we believe, a nepbew of Richard Wagner,

Page 21

Feb. 21, 1884] The Nation. 169 — —We referred lately toa paper inthe Revue Historique on Napoleou’s scheme for making San Domingo the keystone of the French colo nial system. Cromwell, before him, bad built some hopes on the seizure of the same island, and bad seen his expedition, too, end in failure. The story is retold inthe January number of the New England Historical and Genealogical Register, by Mr. G. D. Scull, of Oxford, Enog., apropos of Edward Winslow's share im the ex- pedition as one of three commissiovers appointed by the Protector. This number of the Register is exceptionally rich io interesting matter, Mr. Dean’s memoir of the late Col. J. L. Chester adds considerably to our knowledge of the ca- reer and character of this indefatigable anti quariau. His successor, Mr. Henry F. Waters, furnisbes another batch of “Genealogical Glean- ings n England,” a large part of which relate to Maryland and Virginia, and bave been anno- tated by a local authority. While many of the pames are obscure, we meet with the Lees, of Virginia; Gov. Sir George Yardley, of that colopy ; John Rolfe (wbose son Thomas, by Po- cabontas, has numerous descendants in Eng- land): a collateral ancestor of Natbaniel Haw- thorne; and Jose Glover, of the Harvard Class of 1650, ‘* who was much beloved of the most if not alJ, and his departure much lamented of the most if not of all.” That these ‘ Gleanings” are beginning to bear fruit, is shown by the communicated ‘‘notes on abstracts already pricted.” Uoder the head of *‘ Historical In- telligence” we read that Mr. Lyon Gardiner Tyler, of Richmond, a son of the ex President, has ready for publication the ‘ Letters and Times of the Tylers, Father and Son,’ a work in two volumes, 8vo, obtainable by subscription. — The latest report of the Boston Record Com- missioners, their ninth, contains every entry of birth, death, and marriage recorded for that city in its own records and in those of the First Church from 1630 to the close of the century—the two often overlappivg and checking each other. This task has been admirably performed by Mr. William 8. Appleton, and the mass of names is made available for research by a full index, in which all the eccentricities of spelling are pre- served, as, Mirack, Mireck, Mirecke, Miriack, Mi- rick, Miricke, Myrick. Occasionvally,but notasa rule,the occupation or station of the deceased was recorded, as, “Paul Mitchell a fisherman living at Craftbold in England,” ‘‘ Richard Done neger servant to Capt Robt. Keayne”—that Keavne to whose generosity Boston owes her Old State House. The relationship was now and again quaintly indicated, as, ‘‘ Ruth of John Ruggles husband toour sister Ruggles sometime wife of Nicholas Phillips.” The clergyman’s name fre- quently occurs in case of marriage, or the ma- gistrate’s, as, ‘‘Mr. Richard Matber Pastor to the Church of Dorchester & Mrs. Sarah Cot- ton widow were married 26th—6tb month by John Endecott Govr.” (1656); or, “Samuel Veazey & Mary Virgoose [the name has been sought to be associated with Mother Goose] were married by Sam]. Sewall Esq. Assist. Nov. 25” (1691). Sewall’s own rapid progeny may be traced here. So we find the birth record of ‘Cotton of Mr. Increase & Mariah Mather born Feb, 12” (Feb. 15, First Church baptismal date), 1662; and of his first child, “ Abigail of Cotton & Abigail Mather, born Aug. 22” (1687); and find him already uniting others in wedlock in 1692, “Stephen Cross & Mary Lawrence” ap- pearing to bethe first couple. The volume affords endless scope for excursicns Jike these, and is an invaluab!e sid to those who derive their descent from the early settlers of the Bay capital. —The knowledge of the excellence of Ameri can manufactures is permeating the world. Poole’s Index, for instance, bas found an Ita- lian admirer. Sig. Chilovi, librarian of the Marucelliava at Florence, has reviewed it (un der the title ** Una Curlosita Bibliografica ™) in the Nuova Antologia. After some just remarks on the utility of indexes, be sketches the history of Poole’s, payiag a compliment, on the way, to the “interest, originality, and practical wis dom” with which the contributers to the Li- brary Journal have studied ‘tbe most intricate problems of the management of large libraries.” He commends tbe execution of the Index, only wishing that when there were several entries under a single heading they bad been arranged more scientifically, and that,in the preliminary list of reviews indexed. more bibliographical de- tails bad been given for the sake of foreigners not familiar with English and American peri Sig. Chilovi of course turns to the Ita han names, Where be finds enough, both in the index and in the monthly supplements, to in terest bis countrymen. (He objects, by the way, to the eutry of two articles about * Nic- cold de’ Lapi,’ one under Niccold and one under Azeglio.) the success of the coOperative method. odicals, But bis greatest wonder is excited by That nearly fifty libraries of the most diverse charac ter, and stretching over & vast continent, should combine voluntarily to execute a work which no one of them could bave undertaken single handed, seems to him a fact worthy of note and imitation of the kind undertaken by the Italian libraries One might, indeed, suppose that it would be much easier for them than for Americans to accomplish such a work, being all under the control of the Government. But it is not so. Europeans feel the inconveniences of central ization, and do not yet know they have no initiative, because they expect everything to come down tothem from above, so that their organization cannot effect as much as the American independence. Moreover, the Italian libraries, be complains, have not as yet even the periodicals to index. periodical reading-room. They are, it appears, rich in materials for the study of the past ; they offer few facilities for learning what is now go ing on in the world. But he despairs of seeing anything its advantages: Only one bas a —Mr. Paul Lindau enjoys the reputation of being the cleverest literary man Germany has produced since Heine, so that the reader might fairly expect something exceptionally amusing and pevetrating in the observations on this country which he has recently published in bis magazine, Nord und Siid. The reader, how- ever, who takes up the article in the expectation of finding sometbing akin to Heine's remarks on England, will be disappointed—rot, we fancy, from avy inability on the part of Mr. Lindau to write a piquant article, but simply from the re ticence patural to a courteous man who has eaten the salt of Mr Villard’s countrymen. This is to be regretted, for while we have been fa- vored with an endless variety of British judg ments, and a considerable number of French, in telligent and reada*le German criticism has been rare. Some of the national features which struck Mr. Lindau—such as the vast scale of our public works and the intense commercial energy ofthe American character—have so often been remarked as to make comment needless. But after these, be thinks, our predominant charac teristic is hospitality, the enjoy ment of which is marred, ifmarred at all, only by the necessity of paying for it. It is not. of course, vulgar, ma- terial payment which Mr. Lindau bas in mind, nor yet personal flattery; but the appreciation of everything American demanded, not by indi- vidual, but, so to say, by corporate vanity. Our essay ist seems almost painfully conscious of a the obligation imposed by bospitality received, avd could pot be more coreful to avoid saving what might prove disagreeable. Butin view of the fact that he obtained recognition at nome by his amusing satire on A leinstidterei, viewed from the standpoint of a Wet? itis prob able that be would privately attribute this fea ture of American life, which be here explatns by the newness of the country, to the want of corporate self-respect and individual s faire, Of politics and literature, Mr. Landau has nothing to say—he did pot look even upon the outside of Wasbington and Boston, tt gh be bas a good deal to say of Katsas City Bat be thinks our sleeping cars vastly toferior t European, and regards the existence of t! vated railwaysas a proof of the malada tra tion of Justice, Whose guiding privciple see be that individuals bave no rights as opposed | the interest of the community Lie appears deed, to agree with the receutiv-expressed vy " of Herbert Spencer that the tendeney of ce cratic government is not toward liberty toward despotism under another vame The English universities bave of late vears been roused to gr eater activity rat alley ‘ to a greater semblance of activity eal work, as distinguished f: ere s book manufacturing Those w Snow th stitution of those extraordinary . plodkes i excuse enough faw scant produ nin t / tracting engagements f boards, ¢ rshijps evudicates, but German professors, when they once attain to high pos n, have at least as wmanv entanglements Ritsebl Piained the high tide of his professorial life, that be tad mily a couple of hours a day fer pl gical Work proper, and ¢ “A i - al by teacher after teacher at all the great Versities The Germans must make better ‘ if their Vacations than do English and American scholars. But, bowever this mav ?! itis ples sant to see that there is son phil logical act Vity atthe great centres of English university life, and the second volume of the Transactions of the Cambridge Philological Society (ISS] ISS.) gives a fairsample of the work that is done at one of these certres To be sure, the niost considerable paper, by Prince L. L. Bonaparte, on ** Words in Latin and the Neo Latin Dia lects connected with the Vine,” does not belong exactly tothe Cambridge sphere.and is published al Society of Lon don. The othersare nearly all scrappy in concert with the Philol notes on points or authors; materials tbat one likes to putin print as a preparation for an extended work, « the oblivion of the class room. The valuable feature for those who rcomments that one likrs to save from reviews are an especially have not access to the many German urnals, Mr. Leaf Giscusses Homer in ISSI-1S82: Mr. Hicks, Plato in England for the Nettleship, Virgil: Mr. Postgate, Propertius same time:-Mr, all approved specialists. English Etymology is written, as we should expect, by a German, Professor Zupitza Everybody has read of the wonderful pro ficiency in thelanguages of the East of the late lamented Palmer, Lord Almoner’s Professor of Arabic in the University of Cambridge, who ex plored and described the ‘ Desert of the Exo dus,’ and was finally murdered by the Arabs of the desert. Few people, comparatively, know that the former Lord Almoner’s Professor of Arabic in the University of Oxford, aad late chief editor of the London Times, Thomas Che nery, whose death was announced last week by the cable, was an equally rare linguistic phe- nomenon. Newspaper readers, unfamiliar with the circumstances, who beard at the close of 1877 thata Professor of Arabic had been cbosen

Page 22

170 The Nation. [Number 973 ] to succeed Mr. Delane as manager in chief of the | ‘“‘Thunderer” may naturally have doubted whether the Lord Almoner’s chair at Oxford had not been occupied for some years by a sham Orientalist. The very contrary, however,was the ease, of which there is living—one might almost evidence in Chenery’s Ori- ental publications, including bis translation from the Arabic of Al-Hariri’s ‘Assemblies,’ with notes, historical and grammatical (1867), and his edition of Al-Harizi’s Hebrew translation of the ‘Assemblies,’ entitled ‘Machberoth Ithiel’ (1872). The introduction, partly in what we may call medieval Hebrew rby med prose,prefixed by Mr. Chenery to the latter work, Isa masterpiece say, monumental of imitative style,entirely wortby of the famous | medieval Hebrew translator himself, and, as | the production of a non-Jew, bas no parallel in all Hebrew literature. The consummate skill with which he there handles the mixed Biblico- rabbinical idiom of which the Jewish writers of Spain, in the best Moorish times, were the great masters, equals that displayed by Riickert in translating the same Arabic poet (‘Die Maka- men des Hariri’) into the most surprisingly play ful strains of his own living tongue. M. Auguste Vitu has followed up his consid- erable work on the house in which Moliére died by a slighter one on the theatre in which be first acted in Paris. ‘Le Jeu de Paume des Mes- tayers’ (Paris: New York: F. W. Christern) is thus the second volume of a series of books on the **Archéologie Moliéresque,” of which a description of the houses in the Halles or Market where Molitre and Régnard were born is to be the third. M. Vitu notes (p. 57) that in the general reconstruction of Old Paris, and its transmogrification into the spick-and- span American paradise, many interesting Jand- marks have disappeared, and that the buildings which sheltered Molitre between two bundred and two hundred and fifty years ago have now nearly all disappeared. In the present beauti- fully printed little book, as delightful in its typography as are all of M. Lemerre’s publica- tions, M. Vitu succeeds in showing that the ten- nis court in which the little company of actors, amateurs, and professionals who called them- selves magniloquently tbe “Illustre Théatre,” acted from December 31, 1643, to December 14, 1644, occupied the space now covered by Nos. 10, 12, 14 Rue Mazarine and 11, 15 Rue de Seine. Sufficient attention has never been paid to the influence on the development of the theatre in England and France exerted by the places in which the stage was originally set up, and from which the theatre as we now know it has been In England the theatre began in the open court of an inn and got itself a roof only in Shakspere’s time. In France, it was put up inside a tennis court, and the effect of the oblong parallelogram may be detected in many French theatres to the present day. According to M. Vitu, the last theatre in Paris made out of a tennis court was the ThéAtre Déjazet, which is still standing. Lemerre; slowly evolved. —Thbe programmes bave been arranged for the three Wagner concerts which will be given at the Metropvlitan Opera House, under the di- rection of Mr. Theodore Thomas, on April 22, 24,26. The soloists will be the three leading vocalists of the Vienna Imperial Opera—Frau Materna, Herr Winkelmann, Herr Scaria—who were chosen by Wagner to create the principal roles in *‘Parsifal” at the Bayreuth festival, and who may therefore be considered the best living interpreters of the Wagnerian vocal art. Besides these Miss Emma Juch, Miss Emily Winant, Messrs. Theodore Toedt, Franz Remmertz, and others, will take part in the performances. The orchestra will be the Philharmonic, augmented to | lation of Briinnhilde—a musical synopsis of the | I 150 musicians. The choruses will be sung by the New York Chorus Society and Liederkranz. The programmes contain the musical gems of Wagner’s best operas and music dramas, and have been arranged with Mr. Thomas’s usual skill and tact. Briinnhildeis Wagner's most perfect character, and Frau Materna the best interpreter of the réle; and it is therefore of interest to note that those who attend the three concerts will become familiar with her whole career. In ‘Die Walkiire” Wotan puts her to sleep and surrounds her with magic fire on the Rock of the Walkyries. Siegfried finds her ia the drama following, and she becomes bis wife; while in the last act of “Die Gotterdimmerung” will be heard the wonderful music accompanying the self-immo- whole trilogy. At the first concert will be given the overture and Baccbanale, first three scenes, march and chorus of the second act of “Tann- hiiuser”; Ride of the Valkyries, Woufan’s Fare- well, Magic Fire Scene, from “ Walkiire”; Fi- | nale of Act IIL, “Siegfried” (the famous duo of Briinnhilde and Siegfried), At the second con- cert: Centennial March; Love Duo, from Act IT. of “Tristan and Isolde”; “Die Meistersinger,” the greater partof Act IIL., including prize song, choruses of guilds, quintet, etc. Third concert : overture, “Flying Dutcbman,” and Introduc- tion, Ballad, spinning chorus, Act If., Vorspiel and Pogner’s Address from ‘‘ Die Meistersinger” Act IIL. of Gétterdimmerung complete (Sieq- fried and the Rhine-Maidens; Sieyfried’s parra- tive; Murder Scene and funeral music; Briinn hilde’s Self-Immolation). Most of the selections from Gotterdiimmerung,” ‘ Walkiire,” ‘Sieg- fried,” and ‘‘Tristran”’ will be heard for the first time in America. —The public of Boston appears to be agitated and divided on theadvisability of the purchase of Regnault’s ‘ Automédon” for their Museum. If the publicof Boston don’t know what it waats it will wisely postpone the purchase of this particular picture until it does, and if then it decides to purchase it, all that one can say is, de gqustibus non disputandum, The picture is not indecent, which is, we opine, the best thing that can be said of it, and might safely be seen by the picture-seeing people in Boston; and if those who supply the money see fit to give the price demanded, which we believe is $12,000, why, Boston can afford it, though it seemsan exorbi- tant price for a second-class work of asecond- rate painter. If sums like $12,000 are scarce in Boston (which we do not believe to be the case if areally noble object is to be served), it seems a poor use tomakeof one tobuy the ‘“Automédon.” It is no disparagement to the cities of America to say that zesthetic education has been carried fur- ther in Boston and on sounder principles (and this wesay even remembering that the SouthKensing- ton drawing-school system was once established there) than anywhere else in America; and if the Bostonians cannot settle this question without out- | side help, we feel no little diffidence in express- | ing an opinion, and certainly shall not pretend to advise. But as to the abstract question of the | position of the painter of the ‘‘ Automédon” we | bave no hesitation in adding our word to the dis- cordant discussion. Regnault was an uncom- monly clever painter, clever especially in that executive power which is entirely unrelated to | | great thought, and which indeed ncver appears | in men of the grave and large type to which Millet and Delacroix belonged. It is a superficial excellence, which a truly great painter would | carefully avoid, if he bad the capacity for it, as likely to divert attention from the essential qualitiesofhisart. Inthe“Alhambra Execution” this power was carried to such a point that it ‘ Here | | becomes phenomenal and worth placing in any collection, as is any supreme attainment in any vein of art; but it belongs distinctly to an infe- riorgrade of art if we judge iteven by the greatest modern work. And the ‘* Auntomédon” is far from the hest work of Regnault—it is an academica] study, melodramatic in conception and extravagant in realization. Whoever com- pares it with Homer's ideal can bardly perceive the difference between Homer and Poe. This Au- tomédon has struck an attitude which even the unguestionably excellent drawivg and _ bril- liant execution of the painter do not make | other than theatrical. The horses are pbantasms—Automédon, a tamer of nightmares. | Asa whole, the picture is an «stentatious exer- cise of executive ability which, in a young painter, may be condoned, but which Regnault even, had he lived to his artisticmaturity, would kave deprecated and probably destroyed. The heroic death (from the French point of view) and brilliant brief career of Regnault have given bim an ¢clat in the art world of bis day which we do not believe bis works will maintain. Tomistake him fora master, even in the modern schools, would be unfortunate, but to reject bis really good work from a collection of modern pictures wouid be a still greater error. If the ‘‘Automé dou” were really one of his best pictures, Boston would be fortunate to bave it. SCHLIEMANN'S TROJA.—I. Troja; Results of the Latest Researches and Dis coveries on the Site of Homer’s Troy, and in the Heroic Tumuliand other Sites, made in the year 1882; and a Narrative of a Journey in the Troad in 18%1. By Dr. Henry Schliemann, Hon.D.C. L., Oxon.,ete. Preface by Professor A. Hi. Sayce. With 150 woodcuts, and 4 Maps and Plans. London: John Murray; New York: Harper & Brothers, 1884. Pp. x1.-434. THIS volume gives us Dr. Schliemann’s latest word about Troy. Itis really a supplement to the author’s larger work, ‘ Ilios,’ published in 1880, and it resumes the descriptions and discus- sions where the earlier volume left them. Dr. Scbliemann’s work at Troy, as he reminds us, has already passed the period of ten years, ‘“‘ which has a fatal connection with the legend of the city,” and it is now quite time to ask the decisive question, whether the new besieging army has really captured Troy, and can hold it against al) attack from without. We propose bere to pass by all lesser controversies, except so far as they affect the main issue; and to attempt to answer the real question which every reader of Homer is asking—What new evidence does Scbliemann’s work at Hissarlik in 1882 afford to justify his belief that he bas found the city of Troy whose siege was the subject of the Iliad? As ‘Troja’ isa supplement to ‘Tlios,’ our review must be in many respects a supplement to our review of ‘Tlios’ in Nos, $15, 816 of the Nution. Wethere examined the evidence upon which “‘an_ historic existence” could be claimed for the Troy of Homer ; and we came to the conclusion that, as the case then stood, Schliemann might fairly | claim to have discovered a city which could be said to be the original of the Homeric Troy in | the same sense in which the fortress in Argolis | is said to represent the Homeric Mycene. We doubted, however, the sufficiency of the argu- ments by which he sought to prove that Troy never extended beyond the hill of Hissarlik. The present writer visited Hissarlik in Sep- tember, 1882, after Schliemann bad finished his work there, but before the results of his last ex- cavations had been published. It was difficult for one who had formed his ideas of tbe ruins | from reading ‘IJlios’ to find his bearings within ces: aR es, ~ Art

Page 23

So varia eee ee Feb. 21, 1884) tbe bill after the great changes which bad been made during the precedipg summer. These changes involved notbing Jess than removing the greater part of the remains of the third set tlemenr, which in ‘Ihos’ is called the Homeric Troy, and uncovering the foundations of tbe second, wbich bad now proved to be the only impcrtant prehistoric town onthe hill. It was also perplexing that the great city walls of stone, which at once strike the visitor as the strongest proof of the identity of Troy, and the double gateway (wbicb had become widely known as the ‘‘Scwan Gate” from being so ealled in ‘Troy aud its Remains’), all belonged to the second city, while this city was, according to ‘llios,’ only the predecessor of Trov. The double gateway itself, inoreover, is not suffi ciently imposing to have been the outer gate of a very powerful city; it isa great step from this to the Lion Gate of Mvcenw. But the saddest diss ppointment of all to those who visited Hissar lik under the ivfluence of ‘ [lios’ was the ** man sion of the Town Chief or King,” a building about fifty-three feet long and twenty-three feet wide, whose lower walls (of which about four and a-half feet are now standing) were built of small stones and clay, like most house walls in the modern villages of the Troad, This surely could not be the prosaic reality of which Priam’s splendid palace, with polished cor- ridurs and fifty cbambers of polished stone for Priam’s fifty sons and their wives, is the poetic ideal! And the city of which this was the royal palace was contined to the little hill of Hissarlik, and was hardly large enough to bouse 3,000 inbabitants, even if the houses were six stories bigh (‘Ilios,’ p, 514; * Troya,’ p. 2) All these difficulties have been cleared up by the later excavations, Dr. S:hiiemann’s reasons for his conclusions respecting the extent of ancient Troy. which seemed to us in 1551 to be au unnecessary and almost fatal obstacle to the acceptance of bis great discoveries, are given in * Liios’ (pp. 38, 514); the decisive proot seemed to be that he bad sunk twenty sbafts on the east, southeast, southwest, and west of Hissarlik in 1873, and bad fuund no prehistome pottery house walls, showing that the ancient city could not have extended beyond the hill, No one who reads Dr. Schlemaon's argument on this point in ‘Thos’ acd his confession of error in‘ Lroja’ pp. l, 2) can hereafter accuse bim of stubborn ness or unwillingness to be conviuced of bis mis takes. But no one who understands the true nature of the problem—certainly no one who has seen the confused mass of ancient ruins which fill the inside cf the hill of Hissarlik—will deny that changes of opinion, even on such vital points as those just mentioned, are both justifiable and even creditable, The truth iz, Dr. Scbliemann bas opened more serious questions than Science cap answer in the next fifty years; and it is not a mark of wisdom to maintain fixed and exact doctrines about the details of these perplexing matters, or to expect them even of those most experienced in the discoveries themselves. He who makes the fewest positive statements about many of the points still in dispute will probably have the fewest mistakes to correct Dr. Schlemenn was accompanied during his last campaign at Troy by two eminent German architects, Dr. Willham Dorpfeld, wei] known for his services at Olympia. and Mr. Jo seph HoOfler. Besides Dr. Schliemann’s oan accountof his work in L882, we have two letters of Dr. Dorpfeld, in the Al for September 29, 1882, and Mareh 30, 18s toe ae emeine Zeit 7 latter appears ip English in the Times of Mareb 22. 1883. These letters are valuable for tbeir clear and concise statements of the results of the work at Hissarlik from an architect's point of view. We hope, indeed, that Dr. Dorpfeld The Nation. has still much to say about Troy, and the world will hear it with interest, We must here make a remark by way of cau tion, which may be needed by some who discuss the ruins of Hissarhk, but would suggest it-elf at once to every ol wl st Many w talk f Sch mann'’s dis \ ind ba i generai idea of six rs j . vin upon anotber on Hissarlik, see not I stand tbat there are grea > the i portance of the successive settler lifts rirsts Dr. Schliemann, says cof * the sixth or Lydian city”: “All Tam able to sbow of this city Is its pottery: there is no wall of defence nor even any bouse-walls which I uld with avy degree of probability attribute to it (‘Llivs,’ p. 587). The other six settlements which Dr. Schliemann distipguishes have all let! their ruins in separate strata upon the bill Dr. Dorpteld says (Allgemeine Zeitung of Sep tember 30, ISS82): “All scholars who visited Hissarlik during tlhe last excavations were ¢ vinced of the existence of the six distinct strata of ruins.” But it must not be imagined that there is now apy one place where six layers of ruins can be distinctly seen in @ perpendicular line, at least by the untutored eye. The lowest stratum of all, resting on the native rock, 52°, feet below the later summit of the bili, contains ruins cf a very ancient town, of which we have very little knowledge, as its remaios are mostly covered by tnore of the second city, and cannot now be examined except where tbev appear at tbe bot tom of the great central trench dug directly through the hilt from north to sout! Lt Schliemann thinks “its length does not exceed 46 metres and its breadth can barely have been greater,’ although he thinks it protabiv hada lower city on the plateau besides its buildings the hill (Troja, po. 2, Cif the se 1 city we shall speak below. The third, fourth, and fitth settlements were, a rding to Dr. Dorpfe little better than v izes pta goulvs dwelling-bouses”; the third and fourth rtait never extended bey ithel i i x of the fifth our knowledge (as Dr. Dorpfeld say is still imperfect Phe topmost stratum belongs to the bistor city f lilo Lhis Vv Was founded by -Eolie Greeksat avery early per probably before the seventh century it remained an Insig int tow Was enlarged oy Lysimacbus early int third cen tury B.Cc., Who built for ita wall vearly tive miles in circuit It again fell into decay, was captured and burned by the Roman General Fimbria in 85 B ,wass ret t by S " and was made into a large and flourishbiog city by the early Romar em} Dr. Dorpfeld speaking as an arcoitect, calls the upper stratum of ruins those of the “Roman Ilium,” as the buildings there found tn sifu, so far as their age can be ascertained, all belong to the R pertod (Times of March 22, 18S According to him, there are no remains of the Greek I i earlier than the Macedonian period (after Lysimachbus) anywhere to be found in sifu or Hissarlik ; and it is impossible to determine the Sites of fhe two temples of the Macedonian ag as their i 1 . v t been f and 7 Ms fy ¢ : at sip W De row t . s wl was large and st giv f i hasn 58 i prow v of zg t yuity Des . t $ this g it Vist t i t \ fissAritk " thal these two st b> t s this s “ ba left the i : . v ent Ire f tt first res sot Work of iSSl was the discov ery tia s nd and tt third settlement was realiv tbe * Burnt City,” to which belonged all the important prebistoric stone walls with t rgates, w hav 4.Wway pa t “ i > s i a i ed I ta \ “ a} i ‘ ‘ wins “wl “ ind ‘ ¢ it . . A sity spe i ‘ fe v " it Was t t hiv ’ andthenby biv i ‘ “ ofthe lings. Mos ita ’ ac } is ‘ t ‘ ‘ ‘ i intl «ay . x wa sbow their pla \ { ’ I soft ty t | il ass { t “ thre showed w ‘ t gx bad s l Vering tt t . n } Pian Ll Lhios t x \ parts { ‘ \ wn . ‘ burnt ber Ke abd Ww ‘ “ ‘ t ed Ube s T i } \ i longed to the great \ s«t their sera t ‘ sta . es, t s { t t t the pre t s ‘ a t eN t va . oN t I t t v ‘ . at . t ‘ I t i t . \ . vs t a “ ‘ \ snow \ v t t ’ SIX 4 . ‘ , . » ’ ‘ ‘ te fa : s i ‘ S 4 s P w Zz ( \ t AS A ' STAGHI \ £ il Sket I 4 S aM 1. 4to, py i Actorand Manager a (Crit n facri sr uv. | in ivVingite HOOT RE I tiedge AS s LOMO, pp. & ' Les Tiéatres de soci¢t rovale pendant les e derpie Par Adolphe Jullien Paris Firmin- Didot & Chie; New York: F. W. ¢ stern fo, pp ] Les | si! le j 1 Par Th. de Lajarte. Paris: Calmann Lévy; New York: F. W Christer S4 a 1 Tt in be no betterevidence of the firm hold wl Mr. Henry Irv hason the theatre ers vy thant Appesrance aly ft sit ta neously of ur books in which } areer as an and asa manageris sketched and his art [Two of these books sppeared before Mr. Irving arrived in this country, and tave already beer nsidered in these columns, ‘They f na cur is contrast to the two now before is, as Mr. Brereton does well what the anony mous author of the Am:rican biograpby of Mr. Irving did very ill, and as the criticism of the Irvingite is avowedly an answer to the acute and admirablecrticism of Mr. William Archer

Page 24

172 The Nation. [ Number 973 Mr. Brereton’s biograpbical sketch is excel- lent within its simple and modest limits. It is a plain and straightforward account of Mr. Irvieg’s career from bis birth to his departure from England for America. We have pointed out before now the great inconvenievces of writing tbe biograpby of a living celebrity, and certaioly Mr. Brereton has been hampered by them, vet less than we bad supposed possi- ble. His qualified success seems owing to the rigid restraint which he wisely imposed on him- self Mbere is bo attempt at tine writing or at the higher criticism ; indeed, there is very little original criticism of any kind. The facts are set forth succinctly and in order, and without digression. There is a useful avd instructive list of the four bundred and twenty-eight parts acted by Mr. Irviog during his first three years on the stage. It is to be regretted that a full list is not given of the bundred and sixty parts he acted after leaving Edinburgh 1n 1859, and before appearing in London in 1866 The list of the parts acted in London since the latter date is given in the appendix, which contains also an ample report of the dipner given to Mr. Irving in London on the 4th of July last, at which Lord Col-ridge pre-ided and Mr. Lowell maae one of his most delightful speeches. Mr. Brereton has further provided an index of twenty-six columns, made with greater care than we are wont to see in British books. Almost the only error we have noted in the text is the assumption (p. 57) that Mr. Irving was the first to discard Colley Cibber’s bighly-effective perversion of ** Richard 11I.”—an honor which belongs of right to Mr. Edwin Booth. The book is adorned by seven- teen full page illustrations. The best is a photo gravure after Mr. Long’s portrait of Mr. Irving as I/umlet, and the worst is a hideous coricature of Mr. Irvivg as Charles J. The portrait as Vunderdecken is taken, without acknowledg- ment, from a striking drawing which appeared int! Century Magazine, and which is, in fact, doubly American, sivce the bold pbotograph from which it was drawn was the work of Colo- nel Van der Weyde, of Dighy Grant (in the ** Two Roses”) and of Mr. F, Barnard’s sketches Shylock are characteristic, which is more than can be said for bis sketch of Miss Ellen Terry as Portia. A slip of the pen, by the way, in the list of illustrations (p. xi.) promises pictures of Miss Terry as Dig'y Grant and as Benedict. It is said that Jobn Wi:kes declared toat he was nevera Wilkite. Weincline to the belief that Mr. Henry Irving is not an Irvingite, and that be will searcely thank the zealous friend who bas rashly hurried to the assault of Mr. Archer. lt seems to be an open secret in Lon- don that “ An Irvingite” is Mr. Frank Marshall, the author of a comedy called ‘ False Shame,” and coeditor with Mr. Irving of Shakspere. A\l- ready be bas thought best to circulate a printed apology for having ascribed to Mr. Archer tbe authorship of anunymous articles which he called ‘‘ vile and scurrilous.” It is, however, only fair to say that the most of ‘An Irving- ite’s ’ criticism of Mr. Archer is courteous. Like Mr. Brereton’s book, bis is calculated exclusive- ly fur the meridian of London—e. g., it credits Mr. Irving with the death of Cibber’s “ Richard IiL.,” and declares that Hamlet and Iago had never been acted naturally and colloquially un- til Mr. Irving attempted tbem. There are twe books for which the shelves of every dramatic hbrary are yawning, and for the making of which tbe materiats are abun- dant. One is a history of scere-painting, with an account of the evolution and development of the manifold devices of scenic illusion. The otber is a bistory of private theatricals, of which M. Adolpbe Jullien bas now brought together three chapters in the sumptuous and stately volume on the ‘Court Comedy of France in the Eigbteenth Century.’ The author is the musical critic of the Paris newspaper Le Frangais, and on musical matters he speaks as one having au- thority. He is, moreover, an investigator of wide erudition and inexhaustible patience, as his frequent monographs on the music and the musiciaus of the past bave already proved, and as we have seen in his excellent ‘ Histoire du Costume au TheAtre,’ The present volume is a pew edition, greatly elaborated and thorougtly revised, of tbree separate studies, each pab lished in limited editions and now out of print and scarce. One was on the performances given ou the grand nigbts at Sceaux, when the Duchess of Maine was aspiring and consp*‘ring. The second was devoted to the dramatic essays and exercises of Mme. de Pompadour on the stage of the ‘‘ Theatre of the Little Cabinets.” The third set forth the history of the theatre of the Trianon under Marie Antoinette. Taking the three together, we have a good view of three typical phases of the Regency and of the reigns of Louis XV. and XVI. The only other private theatre in France during the eighteentb century which has any claim to rivalry with tbese three is that of the Demoiselles Verriéres, and of tbis M. Jullien bas already been the bistorian in his delightful little book on ‘La Comédie et la Ga- lanterie au dix-huititme Siécle.’ It was the Duchess of Maine who brought out at Sceaux the first ballet d'action, as distinguished from the preceding ballets, in which there was much singing, and which, indeed, were not unlike the ballet opéra reinvented by Scribe. It was at Sceaux, too, that Voltaire brought out his comedy ‘‘La Prude,” imitated from Wycber- ley’s ‘‘ Plain-Dealer,” which in turn was a rough-snd-ready version of Moliére’s *‘ Misan- thrope.” It was at the theatre of the Chateau de Bellevue that Mme. de Pompadour sang and acted divinely in Roussenu’s comic opera, ** Le Devin du Village,” after the performance of which the composer fled in confusion to avoid a preseptation to the King. It was at the little theatre of the Trianon that Marie Antoinette, despite the repeated protests of Maria Theresa, persisted in acting even ip the *‘ Barber of Se- ville” of the iconociastic Beaumarchais. M. Jullien’s book is illustrated with the la- vishbnessand the skill we expect in all works pub- lished by MM. Firmin-Didot. There is a chro- molithograpbie frontispiece representing a ceil- ing painted by Lebrun at Sceaux. There are etchings and photogravures and woodcuts in abundance, some of them being large folding plates. Add tbe graceful bead and tail-pieces copied from contemporary decorative sugges- tions: an etching after Boucher, representing a ballet of Mme. de Pompadour’s, and a heliogra- vure after Cochin, showing both the stage and the auditorium of Mme. de Pompadour’s little theatre durivg a performance. Fivally there is a most interesting photogravure of the Trianon theatre as it wasin 1882. A portrait of Marie Antoinette after Bartolozzi has lost something in the transfer to wood, M. de Lajarte is the second in command to M Charles Nuitter in the care of the new library of the Paris Opéra, and the most entertainirg and instructive of the half-dozen essays be bas just put forth as ‘Curiosités de POpéra’ is his ac- count of the inception and growtb of this library, and of his ownsbare in the rescue of the precious musical autographs, in which the Opéra was ricb, but of which no one was taking any care. To M. Lajarte, also, we owe the accurate and exhaustive catalogue of the operatic sccres now in this hbrary. From the treasures of the li- brary of the Opéra he has drawn the illustra- tions of his pleasant volume, most of which are facsimiles of musical autographs, of play-bills, or of titlepages. After the first essay and an- other on Spontini and his ‘‘ Vestal” and ‘ Fer- vando Cortez ”—in the second of which was in- troduced a charge of Spanish cavalry represent- ed by borses and men from Franconi’s Circus— the most valuable paper is one on historic dances, in which M. Lajarte gives us an account of the dances of suciety and of the stage as they followed and borrowed from one another. Coiperative Housekeeping How Not to Do it, and How toDoit. A Study in Sociology. By Melusina Fay Peirce. Boston: J. R. Osgood & Co. 1584, THIS scheme of reform in the social status of women seens tous at once too wide and too nar- row; it promises to women the monopoly of cer- tain functions which they will probably have some difficulty in usurping, while it would ex- clude them fromall other fields of activity. In other words, Mrs. Peirce’s project is vitiated by the arbitrary spirit which pervades opinion on the woman question, and which bere, as so often, assumes the form of a lingering desire to confine woman’s activity within the boundaries of domestic life, although Mrs. Peirce’s concep- tion of domestic life bas httle in common with the old ideal. We are, in fact, inclined to doubt—monstrous us such adoubt would seem to Mrs. Peirce—whether there be uny essential con- nection between the housekeeping problem and the woman question. We are inclined to think that this *‘Study in Sociology” itself uncon- sciously points to a near future in which house- keepiug wil indeed be relegated to the domain of organized activities, butim which it will be- long to Women as much as any otber work that they are willing and competent to do, and no more, Mrs. Peirce regards the division of labor, as applied to the labor both of superiors and subor- dinates, both of mi-tress and maid, as the fun- damental desideratum of housekeeping. Sne claims, and berclaim willbe generally endorsed, tbat vo housekeeper should be required, or can be expected, to master the three srts of * cook- ing, laundermeg, ard sewing fourth art of ‘fighting dirt”?) so as to practise them or superintend their application without a vast waste of efficiency. In order, however, to perfect the division of labor, both of workers and superintendents, the domestic economy of several families must be centralized, each branch of domestic labor being superintended by one or more persons who devote their atten- tion to it. So far the public is rapidly becoming prepared to agree with Mrs, Peirce; but is the codperation of housekeepers the only or the most probable mode of attaining a division of domestic labor? To answer this question, we must consider what is meant by codperation. Now a vodperative society of the kind described by Mrs. Peirce is practically an unprofessional body of retail middlemen, engaged in the supply of their own wants only; that is to say, a body of persons occupied in otber pursuits who, in addition to those pursuits, combine to supply certain articles for their own consump- tion, in order to save their pockets the middle- man’s profits. Thus, by ‘‘codperative hc use- keeping,” Mrs. Peirce understands tbe busiuess of conducting what are already well known as *‘codbperative stores,” and the additional busi- ness of performing the collective cooking avd washing of the codperators’ families. From the very nature of tbe enterprise—i e ,from the fact that the coOperators are not experts in what they undertake—it is essential that at first, until they bave learnt their new business, the whole work of superintendence should be done by (bow about the al — 7 Magi Aals if a

Page 25

— AR eT OT

Feb. 21, 1884] members of the association, in order that their want of knowledge and experience may not be abused by hired managers and subordinates: and subsequently, as in all enterprises, much pers nal attention must be given to insure suc cess, In codperative societies, as in most other joint undertakings, the main stress of adminis tration inevitably falls upon a limited number of individuals; but Mrs. Peirce seems to us to injure her cause in speaking of the labor of these ‘ flicers asa ‘‘sacritice,” and of coOperative un dertakings as ‘“‘the business of supply conducted by the few for the good of all.” If coOperative so cieties are conducted on business principles, ‘the few ” should be compensated for their extra exertions, and their labors should no more be re garded as a ‘“‘sacrifice” than the labor of the officers of any corporation or joint-stock com- pany. And here we must stop to notice the vein of communistic sentimentality which per vades Mrs. Peirce’s writings, and which, with her professed adherence to Mr. Henry George's philosophy, is likely to prejudice many persons against her really usefulsuggestions. She remarks (Appendix C, p. 179), ‘The first grand demand of every kind of successful coGperation is SELF-SA‘ RIFICE. Tocodperate successfully we must be ac tuated by that love for others which can‘ smite the chord of self’ and ‘ make it pass in music out of sight.’ Now, except this statement by Mrs Peirce, which savors more of sentiment tban science, we do not know of any evidence that the successful cooperative efforts to whichshe refers have bad any other motive than enlight ened self-interest; and indeed we doubt whetber any successful enterprise involving large num bers of persons has ever been based on other in centives than self interest in the ordinary sense, or else some species of ‘‘ other-worldliness.” We are therefore of opinion that, in estimating the probability that such ascheme of codperatiou as Mrs Peirce describes will commend itself to a certain class, it is only necessary to consider whether the class in question would deem the pecuniary profit a compensation for the effort involved When, then, the class in question is the wealthy class of American women resident in large cities, we believe that they would not consider the pe cuniary gain any offset to the requisite training and exertion. The ordinary fatigue and worry to which a woman who can command trained service is liable in governing ber own house, are trifling compared to the exigencies of adminis tering a large “laundering” or catering estal- lishment. The majority of American women of the wealthy class are at present totally unfitted by their education and habits for such heavy responsibilities as Mrs. Peirce would impose upon them; and long before women of this class are likely to be prepared for wider func tions, we fear that remorseless Man (who has already, as Mrs, Peirce mournfully records, usurped the spinning and weaving, ‘the mak- ing of women’s and children’s dresses and un- derwear, the laundering of shirts, collars, and cuffs, the canning of fruits and vegetables, the preparing of soups and pressed meats, together with twenty such trifles as the roasting and grinding of coffee, the mixing of indigo with water for the bluing purposes of the laundry, etc.”) will also seize the profits to be made by relieving the rich of the remaining details of domestic industry. Unsuitable, however, as Mrs. Peirce’s scheme is to the wealthy class of American wemen, it may well be extremely useful tothe less afflu- ent classes—to all classes, in fact, which com bine with small means general intelligence and education, as well as practical skill in the do mestic avocations. Especially to the dwellers in country towns, we can imagine that *‘co The Nation. operative housekeeping ” would be a boor r Women In these circumstances, it w 1 proba bly offer a positiv lecrease fa bined with Pp hiary gal low el t igricultura iss peration can sear v offer succor in the present: sparsely-populated tion of the country They bave more tot from the progress of mechanical invent al let us add, from improved physical babits, The practice of adequately ventilating wW gz houses during the cold season, and of eating Wholesome food, would go far toward saving the farmer's wife from fainting at her work To sum up the relation of “cooperative house keeping” to the woman question, We should say that instead of being, as Mrs. Peirce would clain a panacea for all the ills of Woman’s present it is, at the most, a specitic. The thought, bow ever, Which underlies the special scheme, is that which must eventually work the regenerats

the sex—we mean the organization of female dustry in its fullest development by women. It is scarcely possible to estimate the et! i} the social status of women in yeneral wi might be exerted by a class of womet npara ble in many-sided intelligence and power class of meu who rule the thought and industry of men: but such a class of women can only | created by equal opportunities lea i Itisto be regretted that Mrs. Pei not have entered more into detail with regar to her system of housekeeping apart f1 woman question, She does not, for star consider the diftliculties of serving meals } from a common kitchen to seattered d we and yet in Jarge towns this would see ave! serious difficulty, since in large com: nities neighborhood has tie ft | Ww a quaintance or with similarity of tastes ar umstances; while such ass i s as Mrs Pen I mime s WwW i more ] iblyv i formed, at east in the rs sta t | . i “tl \ i i he tt re s ithat is res] ! for PAS ( stia re t that there are es and + terrestriai, there bas < th i . l \ eal effort to I the phys he earth in the InacKkbDaow 2 but éeris 1 U¢ f if rruption will t it ilternative reading Jot f my ftlest is forgotten, and upon ' tex y sha I see God” many 1 an articl f faith Numerous epi taphs make it plain that the subjacent corpse expects to rise in its proper form from that spot ita dav of judgment: and growing out of tbis sel s unconscious feeling that ano er dispositi fthe deai ng with rtality Devout people who ar ensible have no fear that accidental death by flame or vl creates a flaw in their title to eternal! life; but the superstitious shrink from voluntarily transmuting into ash the combustible frame, And vet ouly fire or chemical action completely solves a problem that affects both health and

Page 26

a + In the one direction burial fills the burtful products of ani- sentiment, soil with the ordinary mal decay, and frequently with the special seeds of virulent diseases, which, in detiance of time and frost, lie in wait year after year to repro- duce the fatal crop. In the other, the fervent heat of the furnace, clean and potent, speedily volatilizes the tenantless body into invisible and harmless gases. But the way to the best is travelled slowly, and the public advances with faltering Meanwhile, fortunately, subur ban cemeteries are generally substituted for the af ps. intramural burial places of earlier years. But, in our villages, graves and dwellings have a too frequent proximity, and many a well is cbarged with solutions of animal débris, while the air above the misnamed God’s Acre and the soil itself are poisoned, On the Continent in many burial grounds there is no pretence that the body will remain in either solitary or per petual Such resting places are Dut partial and temporary, Other instead of occupancy of a@ grave. tenants invade them, and time, strengthening the possessory rights, weakens the claim, until finally a rude eviction into an uncertain limbo is all that is sure. From such tainty cremation is a definite and plenary relief. Itis the modern realization of the old Hebrew vision, in which the ecstatic prophet exclaimed, *‘ My father, my fatber, the chariot of Israel and the horsemen thereof ! By fire, indeed, does corruption put on incorruption, The book that has brought out these remargs leads up to but stops short of advocating the furnace. Written with the laudable and public spirited motive of warning against the dangers a certain unce of interment, it presents in a desultory way many historical facts, and fairly depicts the evils to the living from the burial of the dead, but inconsequentially concludes that an innova tion upon the traditioval sentiments of the peo- ple is pot now demanded, whatever may be re- quired in the future. But its very last para graph is the foot-nete: “In Modena, Italy, ex cavations made through a part of the city where the victims of the plague were buried three bun dred vears before, caused an immediate out break of the disease in the neighborhood.” Are we, to wbom yellow fever and cholera are not strangers, to say nothing of typhoid and scariet fevers, and others that are always with us—are we to await the plague before we purify instead of poisoning our surroundings? On side this work bas been written so as to leave, another unfortunately, the impression of feebleness or of inexactness in mauy parts. It opens with a speculation upon the burial of Abel’s body by Cain (if he did bury bim), and other Biblical bis tory is used freely and devoutly, but not always with proper care. For instance, the author speaks (p. 16) of Saul as buried under trees, and two pages Jater cites bis as a body that was burned (misprinted “ buried”), Saul’s case, in fact, is a multiple example. After his suicide his enemies first fastened his decapitated body to the wall of Beth shan; his friends took it thence, and, baving burned it (whether in honor or for security does not appear), interred it un- der a tree at Jabesh; and ultimately it was laid in the sepulchre of his father, Kisb, at Zelah. In describing the Towers of Silence, our author quotes Monier Williams as writing from Cal cutta so as to imply that this peculiar cemetery Really, as the final para graph (three pages later) shows, it is at Bombay, where the Parsee population of India centres. The prototype of these towers is used by the Guebres, near Ispaban. Again, referring to the law of the twelve tables, Dr. Wickes explains that the enacting Decemviri flourished “ a.p. But the real date is a.v.c. 300, or is near that city. about 200,” B.C, 450, | The Nation. [Number 973 Aboriginal American Authors and their Pro ductions ; especially those in the native lan- guages. By Daniel G. Brinton, A.M., M.D., etc. Philadelphia, 1883. In the body of this little volume, Mr. Brinton has given us a partial list of aboriginal Ameri can authors, together with a brief summary of what they have accomplished in the several walks of literature. In its original shape, it was prepared andsubmitted to the Congrés des Amér- icanistes, at the meeting held last summer in Copenhagen, for the purpose of calling attention to the existence of “a number of relics of abo- riginal American literature,” and of bespeaking “the aid and influence of that learned body in the preservation and publication of these rare documents.” Since then the work bas been en- tirely rewritten, and in giving it to the public in the form in which it now appears, Mr. Brin- ton not only makes it the occasion of renewing his appeal for tbe perpetuation of these records, but he seems also to have intended it asa proof of ** the existence of the literary faculty in the native mind.” Of the importance of preserving these docu- ments there cannot, we imagine, be much doubt, and so far as this little volume is designed to serve that end it is well-timed and bas our hearty approval; but when we are asked to go further, and regard it in the light of an argument, sober- ly and seriously made for the purpose of demon strating the Indian’s capacity for ‘literary cul ture,” we begin to hesitate. As well might we be expected to listen patiently to a refutation of Parson Jasper’s theory that “the sun do move.” As a matter of fact, the proposition is undenia ble and needs no proof. A hundred years or so ago, when the Indian was regarded, by suint and sinner alike, as anything but a man and a brother, things were very different, and an ar- gument of this charac‘er then would have had its uses; but to-day, with Indian schools and newspapers flourishing among us, it is an ana- chronism, and, so far as we know, is not war- ranted by anything that has been recently said by any advocate of evolution whose opinion is worth the paper on which it is printed. But even if this were not the case, and a discussion of this subject were still possible, a question might arise as to the soundness of that portion Svo, pp. 63 of the argument which classes a writer like Gar cilaso de la Vega among the aborigines. So far from being an Indian, he was, as is well known, of mixed (Spanisb aad Indian) blood, was edu cated a Catholic, passed the most of his life ia Spain, and his works are written in that lan guage; and to speak of him as an aboriginal au- thor, or as proving the Indian's capacity for literary work, is to extend the system of classifi- cation beyond all legitimate bounds, Carried one or twosteps further, it would make an Indian of John Randolph of Roanoke. In speaking of ‘“‘the literary efforts of the aborigines of this continent” as furnishing the material for ‘‘a chapter in the general history of literature hitherto wholly neglected,” our author is not as clear as might be wished. If he means to say that these efforts, taken as a whole, have never been treated as forming, by and of themselves, a literature, using that word in the sense that we do when we speak of English or French literature, he is probably correct. At all events, except the history of Maya literature referred to on page 30, we do not know of any work in which they have been so considered ; neither do we see any urgent necessity for treat ing them in this manner. But if our author in- tends us to understand, as the language would seem to imply, that these works, or a majority of them, as well those written in a native as in a foreign tongue, were unknown or unused, or that many of them have not been discussed and described much as they are in this volume, then he is very wide of the mark, as must be appa- rent to any one who will examine the book it- self. Literally speaking, there is scarcely a page that is not full of references to writers who have treated this subject in some shape. To say nothing of bibliographers like Field, or his- torians like Hubert H. Bancroft, who certainly record the names of many of the native writers mentioned by Mr. Brinton and indicate the character of their works, we must not forget that Bandelier has delved in the same field, and that, a century or more ago, Clavigero cov- ered more or less of the same ground, and, all things considered, did it well. Aside from these imperfections, which are not necessarily connected witb the subject-matter of the volume, and may be passed over without marring its harmony, we bave none but words of commendation for this little book. It is not exhaustive and does not profess to be, but it is sufficiently complete to satisfy the demands of the average student. It is, withal, well ar- ranged and so thoroughly indexed as to make a reference to these forgotten worthies and their works comparatively an easy matter. If to this we add that its real purport is to enlist the aid of ‘‘scholarly men, of learned societies, of en lightened governments, of liberal institutions and individuals, not only in our own country but throughout the world,” in the preservation and publication of these records, enough will bave been said to show our appreciation of the work and our sympathy with its object. As an act of justice to Mr. Brinton—and we make the acknowledgment with pleasure—it must be said that, of all our American scholars, be is the one from whom this appeal comes with the best grace. When made by him we know that it is not the perfunctory statement of a platitude, but that it is the earnest cry of one who under stands the importance of the object for which he strives, and who has repeatedly given proofs of devotion tu the cause for which he pleads. In the publications which, from time to time, he bas made, and is still making, in the “ Library of Aboriginal American Literature,” be has not only ventured into an unusual field of literary activity, but he has set an example of scholar ship and, we may add, of enlightened liberality which, it is to be hoped, will not lack fol- lowers, BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Avenarius, F. Deutsche Lyrik der Gegenwart, seit 1850, 2ded. Dresden: Louis Ehlermann; New York: b. Westermann & Co, Berownson, H. F. The Works of Orestes A. Brownson. Vol. V. vetroit: Thorndike Nourse. $3. “Cavendish.” The Laws and Principles of Whist. Fourteenth edition. Scribner & Welford. James, H. Portraits of Places. Boston: J. R. Osgood & Co, Johnston, R. M. Old Mark Langston: a Tale of Duke’s Creek. Harper & Brothers. Johnson, F. The Dies Ire: an English Version in Dou ble Rhymes, with an Essay and Notes. Cambridge, Mass. Kosti'ng, K. : in fiinf Biichern. York: Westermann. Lea, H.C. An Historical Sketch of Sacerdotal Celibacy in the Christian Church. Secona edition, enlarged, Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co, Mead, E.D. Martin Luther: a Study of Reformation. Boston : G. H. Ellis. $1.25. McLean, Sarah P. Some Uther Folks. ples, Upham & Co. Nichol,J. Tables of European History, Literature, and Art, from A. D, 200 to 1882; and of American History, Literature, and Art. Macmillan & Co. Oute, E.c. A Simplified Grammar of the Danish Lan guage. London: Triibner & Co, Peirce, Melusina FF. Coédperative Housekeeping. Bos- ton: J. K. Osgood & Co, Reed, LG. Erring, Yet Noble. The Story of a Woman's Life. Philadelphia: T. B. Peterson & Bros. $1.25. tichardson, Dr. B. W. The Field of Disease. A Book of Preventive Medicine. Philadelphia: Henry C. Lea’s Son & Co. # Roman, A. The Military Operations of General Reau- regard in the War between the States; including a brief Personal Sketch and a Narrative of his Services in the War with Mexico, 1846-8. 2 vols. Harper & Brothers. $7.00. Russell, W.C. Little Loo: a Novel. Harper & Brothers. 20 cents. Ruskin, J. St. Mark’s Rest. John Wiley & Sons. 81. Ruskin, J. Sesameand Lilles. John Wiley & Sons. 50 cents. Schliemann, H, Der Weg nach Eden. Epische Dichtung Leipzig: Ernst Giinther; New Boston: Cup- Troja. Harper & Bros.

Page 27

tps Feb. 21, 1884] Fine Arts. THE WATER-COLOR EXHIBITION. —II. THERE are in the exhibition of the Water-Color Society a few drawings which it is impossible to classify and not easy to characterize. The cbiet of these is the life-size drawing by Weir, ‘‘Sun day Morning,” a half-length female figureina peasant’s Sunday costume, apparently just set ting out forchurch. While not free from pose plastique, it is largely drawn, and,while qualitied asan “illustration,” is more ambitious in size and treatment than as an illustration it need be, but not so thorough as its scale demands. It ts hardly an excuse for the flimsiness of the back ground that it was intended for an illustration, since a drawing the size of an octavo page would answer every purpose and enable us to overlook many technical defects. This negligence on a large scale is a greater fault than when in minimis, as the only reason for painting a gal lery picture, and especially a water-color, large, is the desire to get more ideas or finer expression There is a popular misapprehension and misestimation of small works of art like those of Meissonier, based on the erroneous notion that this minute painting means refinement of delineation, greater delicacy of execution, or finersense of truth The fact is, that if we should reduce any first rate portrait by Titian or Raphael, perhaps even Velasquez, to the small size of a Meissonier, we should see that the great masters had a finer per ception of the value of detail than Meissonier, and had given more of it. Toattain such minuteness of them than is possible on a small scale. of execution as bis is not an artistic quality but a physical one, and tbe true standard compels an idea to be valued not by its scale of representa tion but by its intellectual and artistic quality. Henry Holt & Co. HAVE READY IN THE AMERICAN NOVEI No. 2. The Pagans. By Arlo Bates. And a SECOND EDITION of No. 1 Al Latter-Day Saint. Being the Story of the Conversion of Ethel Jones, related by berself. 16m THE QUEEN OF ROUMANIA’S ory. "eee Pilevim Sorrow. A Cycle of Tales by Queen Eliz: Sq. 12mo, with an etched } $1.50 SERIES l6mo, 31,00, », SLOO, toumania. trait by Lalanze. “A charming book—patbetic, graceful, and touching. ’—London Spectato ‘The last story is almost avewedly an alle gory of the writer's own hfe. An admirable etcbing of the royal author is prefixed to tl book, which will tind many readers, partly fron its undoubted merit and partly from its queenly origin. "—John Bull, HABBERTON’'S George Washington. 3y John Habberton, sutbor of

bies,’ etc. No. 4 inthe Series of Lives of American Worthies. Imo, $1.25, Readers will not respect Washington less, but they will love him more for being enabled ss to see him in flesh and blood as well as in mar ble. We heartily commend the volume to voung and to old. Itis veritable bistorv, but it is his tory in undress and not in court clot Ch hman, les,” l } The Nation. Both the ambition to paint smaller, and that t paint larger, than the full and facile expressi if the idea requ

ires, are equally affectations and executive vanities, of which, however, that ¢ paint large is the more pardonable, as the suc cess implies a broader and better artisti ing. Thies alone stands Mr. Weir in stead, for his large figure might just as well have been put on It is able: but the afte tation of negligence as to mett / i collar rubbed through and making a hole a board of 8x10 inches the drawing, with false shadow) is a weakness Mr. Weir's position and talents ought to make bim avoid all such examples of affectation of manner. It is well to know that he can do work on such a scale, bift he might have learned at the same time tbat large thoughts are requisite for large forms Mr. Millet’s excellent vein of art, and is marked by a “Cymbal genuine mastery over action, which is one of the most valuable qualities in figure painting To catch a fleeting action is as much rarer a gift than the simple posing of one well and grace fully, as shooting on the wing is more dif! t than shooting at a target, and is a quality » qua nonin the highest range of design There are two good water-color studies of ‘ orthodox style by Walter Paris, the ‘ Church of St. Laurent * and ** A Bit of Sussex A naive and really clever, though not in any commen surate degree effective, drawing is ** Mom my and Her Old Man,” by Alfred Kappes Tuere 1s nothing conventional, notbing ber rowed even, in quality or treatment in ti bit of negro life, which is humble and rust

without being vulgar: and real issuch a subject demands, without any pretension or exaggeration The essential element, the cha racter of the two negroes, is well given, and if there is a little crudity in the makeup we MARCH ATLANTIC, Ready everywhere, contains THE WAY TO ARCA ' Tht ‘ RY 4’ , 4 } MAN N Vv ford I Ss AIMONIA \ THI NA A SSIAN RARONFSS DRIFTIN N s s ad K DON N AUST \ Alex x I RDLEI FRIENDS H es I Ss s 4 ¥ IS I S < I Wicke ; I \TE MANS s NR \ in & () dos Ss S PATENT Tor the current ers in a convenient f Substa ‘ ade, tx i th, with 7 Nat stamped in gold. Holds on volume. Papers easily and neatly adjusted. Sent, post-paid, on receipt of @1. Address Publisher of the Nation, Box 794 New York.

CREDIT A "IDDER, PEABODY & CO 1 Nassa N er { Y 1} evonshire St., Boston St EXCHANGF A® FRS OF TT ( AND THE CONT ‘orrespondents RakING BrotTHEers & Co., London; PERIER FRERES & Co., Paris MENDELSSOHN & Co., Heriin.

Page 28

176 The Nation. [ Number 973 The Society for Political G. P. Putnam's Sons, liducation. ORGANIZED 1880.) ( DAVID A. WELLS, Executive Committee,- GEORGE S COE, ' HORACE WHITE. OBJEC -The citizens who believe that the success of our Gov rs. SOCIETY was organized by active political influence intelligence, and that It is entirely non-partisan in any awakening of an intel ernment depends on the of educated means, parties are not ends, its organization, and is not to be used for other than the ligent interest in government methods and pur- purpose poses, tending to restrain the abuse of parties and to premote party morality. MEMBERSHIP.—ActTIVE MEMBERS are such persons as will pledge themselves to read the Constitution of the United States, that of the State in which they reside; who will agree to read at least one of and the annual courses as in cluded in the Library of Political Education, and who will pay an annual fee of 50 cents (which may be forwarded in postage stamps), entitling the member to receive the tracts and lists published by the Society during the year. CoO-OPERATING MEMBERS, $5.00 or more, which shall entitle such member to receive the tracts and lists put lished by the Society, to nominate two Fellowship Members, pay annually, and to take part in the control of the Society. PUBLIC Education, ATIONS.—The First Series, 4 vols., Series, 3 vols., Third Series, reduction of about published prices of the separate volumes). Tracts, First, Second, and Third numbers, price per series 50 cts, Library of Political Second S35. 00 $5.00 : $5.00: + vols., (being a 20 per cent. from the The Economic Series, twelve sith n by the See Full pre the public itions ispectus of Society, u titles of » Se t on applicatic re tary, W.C. FORD, 4 Morton St., N. Y. ¢ Or the Publishers, P 27 an 7 20 Putnam's Sons, West 23d St., C G. AND OUTDOORS irnal issued by the NATIONAL ASSO SANITARY AND RURAL IMPROV! upon its second vol Its ITNDOORS A monthly jot CIATION FOR MENT just entered edito . has ime, Wingate, Sani Fn Ino. Y rs are Charles F. ary Parsons, jr., and Culyer, Landscape Samuel Archit It aims to ects. rive simple, practical information to all string healthful and beautiful homes;in short, to tell the average householder with asmall piece of ground how to ornament the latter at a moderate cost; how to irrange fences, hedges, vines, flowers, trees, walks, lawns, andto show bow plumbing may be made safe, drains and spools constructed, and to advise about warming, lighting, and ventilation. Send for sample py. Subscription price 50 cents Editorially commended by Geo. W. Curtis in Harper’s Weekly, N. Y. Sun, the Nation, and the Country Gentlk man, Office. 119 Pearl Street, New York Fohus Hopkins University, BALTIMORE, JO RNAL OF Vol. Vi., No. L. Publication Agency Baltimore. MATH- Now ready. AMERICAN EMATICS. Address the kins University, of the Johns Hop 27 and 29 West 23d St., New } HAVE NOW READY: THE UNITY OF NATURE. By the Duke of Argyll, author of ‘The Reign of Law,’ &c., &c. Authorized Ame- rican Edition. Octavo, cloth extra, $2.50. General Contents: General Definitions and Illustrations of the Unity of Nature—What it Is and What it Is Not—Man’s Place in tbe Unity of Nature—Animal Iovstinct in its Relation to the Mind of Man—On the Limits of Human Truthfulness of Human Knowledge—On the Elementary Constitution of Matter in Relation tothe Inorganic—The Ele mevutary Constitution of Matter in Relation to the Organic—Man as the Representative of the Supernatural—On the Moral Character of Man —On the Degradation of Man—QOn the Nature and Origin of Religion—On the Corruption of Religion—Recap:tulations and Conclusions. THE WORLD'S PROGRESS. An Index to Universal History, and a Cyclopx dia of Facts, Dates, and Informa- Knowledge—On the General tion. Compiled by George Palmer Putnam, A.M. New Edition. Revised and extended to the present time by Frederick B. Perkins and Lynds E, Jones. Large octavo, witha fine portrait.on steel of the compiler. Cloth extra, $6.00, ‘lalf morocco, extra, $10.00, The work contains a d Al phabetical Record of all e f in the progress of societv from the be om: ‘Hg ux bis- tory to the present time. I[t is accompanied by achart of history representing the rise, revolu tions, and falls of the principal empires of the world. Of this work, which has been standard fora number of years, some 50,000 copies have been sold. NEARLY READY: THE STU YVESANT EDITION of Irving’s Works to be issued in seven large handsomely printed from new large type, with frontispiece on steel, and tastefully in cloth and in half leather. The set will comprise Bracebridge, Knickerbocker, Albambra, Bonneville, Traveller, Granada, Wolfert’s Reost, Asto- ria, Sketch Book, Mahomet, Columbus, Goldsmith, and Crayon. 7 vols., cloth extra, $12.00; one-half leather, $15. Messrs. Putnam’s Sons publish the only autho- rized editions and the only ones which contain 12mo volumes, bound the author’s final revisions. *.* Putnams’ New Catalogue forwarded upo1 application. JUST PUBLISHED. Linguistic Cui. IVolf's Vadeie- and modern) and including History, (ancient Linguistics, Part I: Oriental American etc. 1l2mo, 224 pages, 55 cents, The handiest bibliographical help, containing the most important publications of the world down to December, 1883, alpbabetucally and sys tematically arranged. WESTERMANN & CO., 838 BROADWAY, NEW YORK. Wadsworth Bros. Flowland, IMPORTERS AND DEALERS IN ARTISTS’ MATERIALS Architects’ and Engineers’ Supplies of every description, BOSTON, And 84 WASHINGTON STREET, gz Catalogues free on application. | our i ARTHUR GILMAN'S [Tistory of the American People. * We have nothing as good, and are not likely to have.” says the very critical editor of the New York Independent. “The most attractive one-volume history of the United States that we have seen.”—Buston Lite rary World, ‘Nothing better exists as a compendium of couvtry’s bis ry¢ says the editor of the Boston Transcript, in the course of a lovg and careful review. ‘Its script accuracy will stand.” — Boston Tran- ‘*Considering the general brevity of the book, it is marvellously full; and, considering the long story to be told, crowded with fact and detail. The graceful style, warm coloring, and general life-like animation of the book is a still greater marvel.”—N. ¥. Independent, “ The extreme care with which the facts have been collated, and the attention shown to the latest results of investigation and discussion, even in minor matters, make it very valuable as a book of reference.” Pittsfield Eugle. Sixth thousand now ready. Price, 12mo, cloth, illustrated, $150; crown Svo, cloth, illus- trated, gilt top, §2.50. ' For sale by all hooksell rs, Lothrop & Co., Franklin Street, Lippincotts Magazine MARCH, CONTAINS: D. Boston. FOR NOW READY, THE BERLIN OF 0-DAY. By Anna Maynard Butler. Jilustrated. SEBIA’S TANGLED WEB. A Story. Concluded. By Lizzie W. Chamopney. ACROSS THE ISTHMUS OF TEHUAN. tepec on Horseback. By Laura King Swartz. Illus trated. THE BROWN LADY. A Story. A WINTER CAMPAIGN IN THE Black Hills. By H. H. B. THE PERF é 4 TREASURE. Four Parts.—i. By F. ylor. HEALTH) HOME S. Ii1.—Rooms and Halis. By Felix L. Oswald. AN AMERICAN FATHER MATHEW. By the author of * Study and Stimulants.” : WASHINGTON S HEAD-QUARTERS., A Story. By Hope Ledyard. MY DOGS. By A. mm ©. THE HOME OF NAST. By Mary Dean. Together with other Short Stories, Poems,and Articles of "hoe rest upon Current Topics. The Charming Little Comedy, PLACE AUX DAMES, is reprinted as a Supplement in this Number. FOR SALE BY ALL NEWSDEALERS. 25 Cents Copy ; $3.00 per Annum. J. B. LIPPINCOTT & CO., Publishers, 715 and 717 Market St., Pbila. ik VLE BANDS (Improved) are more than a substitute for rub be r bands, for filing Letters, Bills, &«., where the latter are folded and filed in bun- afford space for endorsing the package dies, in that they and date; they are easily fastened or as to contents loosened, and, be ing made of astrong tag-board, they will not rot, but last as long as the ers that they os Send 25 cents for a sample dozen to . G. HUTCHINSON, Manufacturer, 44 Maiden I vane, N. Y. Fad any family, whether large or small, but es- pvecii ity where the number of children is large, a record of the constitutional peculiarities of each one, and the whole course of its physical development in sickness and in health, is certain to be instructive and may prove invaluable. Such a record is Professor J. B. Fonssagrives’s ‘ Mother’s Kegister,’ consisting of a series of tables scientifically arranged for brief and convenient entries. A separate volume for boys and for girls. Price, post _ 75 cents per volume, or $1 25 for two volumes Address Publisher of the Nation. hold togethe ..

Page 29

¥