The Nation 1883-12-27: Vol 37 Iss 965

Page 1

‘Lhe N ation VOL. XXXVII.—NO. 966. Seinaks Alphahetized, first, tad States ; second, by Towns. CONNECTICUT, Ly LACK HAL i "SC HOOL.—A family ana Preparatory Schoo! for a few boys. Thorough instruction and careful training. Best of references given. CHARL¥s G. BARTLETT, Principal. CONNECTICUT, Stamford. ISS ISABELLA WHITE'S School for Young Ladies. Recommended by Pres. Seélye as preparatory to Smith College. INDIANA, Terre Haute YOSE POLYTECHNIC INSTITU TE. A School of Engineering. ‘HARLES O. THOMPSON, President. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston. OSTON UNIVERSITY Law School. Address the Dean. Epmvunp H. Benxnett, LL.D. MASSACHUSETTS, ‘Boston. No. 68 C hestnut Street. HARLES W. STONE, Tutor for Har- vard. Home pupils receive “y Send for circular. MASSACHUSETTS, Bost NSTIT UTE 0 TECHNOLOG Y. Courses in Civil, Mechanical, and Mining Fngineering, Che- mistry, Architecture etc. -WEPSTER WELLS, Sec’y. FRANCIS A. Walxen. Pres. MASSACHUSETTS, Bosto \ ISS PUTNAM “opened the eighteenth Fi year of ber English and Classical Family on Day School for Young Ladies, Thursday, September 2 1883, at No. 68 Marlborough Street. Terms for boarding pupils, $500 per annum. attention given to little girls. cation to Principal. Circulars sent on appli- THURSDAY, Special ~~ — i —— Rk. KNAPP’S HOME SCHOOL for | f Boys.—Next (seventeenth) school year begins September 19. MASSACHUSETTS, Quincy. DAMS ACADEMY. — Hon. Charles Francis Adams, LL.D., Chairman of Managers. r at Harvard and Boarding School. This year’s record arvard College is higher than ower. al bay ants— ng-house panning. 10 without conditions. = ng the past year has been Me in a most com- fortable and satisfactory manner. New year begins September 19. For all information address Dr. WILLIAM Sveneee. MAssACHU SETTS, s, W est Bridgew ater ayo COLLEGIATE Institute.— | Boarding and Day School for Girls and Young Address the Principal, HELEN MAGILL, Ph.D., Graduate of Swarthmore Coll., Boston Univ., Newnham Coll., Cambridge, England. Women. and Massacnv SETTs, S. Williamstown, Berkshire Co 0. REYLOCK INSTITUTE.—A Prepara- | J tory School for Boys. Terms, $450. Catalogues on application. GEORGE F.’ MILLs, Principal. MIcHIGAN, Orchard Lake. ICHIGAN MILITARY ACADEMY. —A thorough Classical and Scientific School. Graduates admitted to University upon diploma. Loca- tion, 26 miles from Detroit; pleasant and healthful. For catalogue address Lieut. H. A. SCHROEDER, Fourth Artillery, U. S. Army, Adjutant. NEw JERSEY, New Brunswick, 13 Livingston Ave. HE MISSES ANABLE'S English and French Boarding and Day School for’ ‘Young La- dies. One hour from New York, and an hour and a half from ae ep on the Pennsylvania Railroad. The school will open September 1 12. ~~ New Youk, Osweg in oe =. 7 INDERGART. NERS TRAINED at State Normal School. Oswego, N. Y. Rare induce- ments offered. Send for circular. NEw York, Salem. 7. PAUL’S HALL.—A happy Home School for 14 boys under 14. Four instructors. ~~ York, Suspension Bridge. E VEAUX COLLEGE.—Prepares for the Universities, etc. me $350 per annum. WiI-rrep H. MUNRO, A A.M. ., President. New York, Uti RS. PIA TTS SCHOOL for Young A Ladies. The next school year begins Wednesday, Sept. 19, 1883. Applications should be made early. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, 1350 Pine Street. ISS ANABLE'S English and French Boarding and Day School — Young Ladies. The thirty-fifth year begins Sept. 19, 1883. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, Chestnut Hill, | ; M*s WALTER D. COMEGYS and Miss Bell's French and English Boarding and Day School for Young Ladies will reopen, Sept. 21. Norwood Avenue Prov INCE OF QUEBEC, Sorel. INCOLN COLLE GE, Sorel, Lower Can- .« ada.—Preparation for business and the Universi ties. All the regular masters Oxford and Cambridge men, or from the University of France. Great facilities for le arning thoroughly French, Ger man, Classics, Mathematics, English, and Science. Tr hirty- five ac res of play grounds ; good boating.on the St. Lawrence and Kichelleu Rivers. Boys received from nine to sixteen ; may stay till nineteea. Terms, $320 to $100 per annum. Circulars on , yy to the Prin cipal, ENRY JULIAN LYALL. GERMANY, Hannover, £ 52 Grosse Rarlin, Mess HILKEN'S Boarding- ‘School Sor re. Md. Address H. G. HILKEN, Box 728 Baltimore. M IROCK WAY TEA( HERS’ AGENCY, 4 Times Building, Chicago, will supp! superinten dents, grade teachers, specialists with positions in Cen tral, Weste rn, and Southern States for ensuing year. Tue HARV. ARD UNIVERSITY CAT-: alogue for 1883-84 1s for sale by Charles W. Sever, Cambridge; Cupples, Upham & Co., Pan W ashington St., Boston; and F. W. Christern, 37 West 23d St., New York Price, 50 cents. Wants. IBRARY AGENT.—Mr. James M, Hub « bard, having had long experience in library work, is ready to act as agent for libraries, to furnish lists of desirable books with 1 prices annexed, and to give ad vice in regard to the arrangement of libraries, the con struction and s ost of catalogues 2 MARLBORO’ STREET, Boston, Mass. ‘O EDITORS OF TRADE JOURNALS. —A London journalist thoroughly familiar with the iron, steel, and hardware trades and possessing many facilities for reliable information, is open to supply a letter toa good trade journal. Terms moderate. Ad dress “JOURNALIST ” care Street & Co., 30 Cornhill, L ndon, Engiand. Portraits of Gen. Sherman, In Photograph and Phototype from Negatives justtaken. Photographs, 50 cents each. Phto- | type, 25 cents each. Miniature Picture Gallery. A series of Pictures in Phototype, 5 in number, from choice subjects, on best plate paper, 10x12, band-omely encased in Porttolio. Price $4 00 per copy—just the thing for the Holidays. F. GUTERUNST, 712 Arch Street, Philadelpbia. Forty-Third Year. DIAMOND HAMS S. DAVIS, Jr. A few HAMS on sale this week by leading houses. A fuller supply next week. » Unmounted F hotographs OF ANCIENT AND MODERN WORKS OF ART Embracing re ductions of famous 0 a ee sculpture. architecture, ete. Price. cabinet size, $1 he perdozen. Send 6cent stamp for new catalogue ¢ .000 subjects. SOULE PHOTOGRAPH CO., Publisbers, S& Washington Street, Boston, Mass. Please mention the Nation, CINCINNATI. DECEMBER 27, 1883. | edited by Edward F. De Lancey. PRICE 10 CENTS pm sine of American FHis- fory. FOR JANUARY 1884 READY ( STMAS PDA) One year's subscription an admirable holiday gift for vour friend. * Parents wishing to present a Christmas gift to their children cannot find one where usefulness and pleasure are so happily combined asin this maga zine.’ —The Young Churchman. The New Year's number contains “THE VAN RENSSELAER MANOR,” handsomely illustrated, vy Mrs. Martha J. Lamp. BEGINNINGS OF THE NEW ENGLAND SO CIETY OF NEW YORK, with two portraits. By Woolsey Rogers Hopkins. THE POLL TAX IN MARYLAND. By L. W. Wilhelm, HISTORY OF THE LOCATION OF OURNA TIONALCAPITOL. By Davis Brodbead The Private Intelli Papers, chapter TV four curious fam- yonce ily letters of Washington, never before pub- ished: and the numerous departments are all | crowded with interesting matter, Subsertbers wishing to renew for [S84 should send in their | pames early to avo delays in the delivery of the magazine. Soid by ne wedealers everywhere. Terms, $5 a year, or 50 centsa pumber. Bound volumes ready for ISS, PUBLICATION OFFICE, 30 Lafayette Place, New York City ’ f. * . . a? aT Books Stationery. Clos- oe . Oe I Potae! ae ing-Out Sale. Retati Prices Laliehaodl Yee ree sreIee C¢ l aw Abolished. Prices NROUCKY SC LOW as No. ey Books of Books for wood, Brooks & din St., Boston, now. Send for Catalogues— of Standard and Holrday in fine bindings, and No. New and Standard people. Lock- Co., 17 Frank- Qk 1] the Vou ne Vadsworth Bros. & Howland, IMPORTERS AND DEALERS IN ARTISTS’ MATERIALS And Architects’ and Engineers’ Supplies of every description, 84 WASHINGTON STREET, BOSTON. andl Catalogues free on application. New Catalogue of Old and New Books (No. 68), Containing many Rare, Valuable, Curious, and Out of the-way Books, in almost a branch of Literature, at very moderate prices, just lished by DAVID G. FRANCIS, Dealer in New and Old Books, 17 Astor Place, sew York. ECOND - HAND SCHOOL - BOOK s 1 4 Exchanged. Send f cata- ae Dek es Sap of the Nation fur nished. A. 8. CLARK, 34 Park Row New York.

Page 2

The Nation. [ Number 965 : The Nation. CONTENTS OF TINS NUMBER. Petts WRT. oc cs ccccccccccccccccccccesosescsscccesseoe.cses 519 EDITORIAL ARTICLES : How the Reform its Working ane 522 The Voting Power of Stock - He Art Unions........... cebdbecees neseauawaes ‘ 523 SreciaAL CORRESPONDENCE : A Southern “ Experience Meeting”’............... 524 CORRESPONDENCE : State and Local Taxation wie Political Algebra..... oece Our Coast Defences and the Navy Devay of ~ ey in the Adirondacks a New England.... Other-Woridliness NOTES .... REVIEWS : James’s Wild Tribes of the Sudan.. Lifeof William Rollinson Whitting Telegraphic Determination of Longitu Cnina, and the Kast Indies..... Slavonic Literature........ os Political Recollections Index Canonum...... rere “mee the Prometheus Bound of A’schylus. Recuell de Lettres Allemandes. Newspaper Reading-Book............. The Story of my Heart... ‘ : Books OF THE WEEK TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three Dollars per year, in advance, postpaid to any part of the United Statea or Canada; to foreign coun- tries comprised in Postal Union, Four Dollars. The date when the subscription expires is on the Ad- dress-Label of each paper, the change of which to a aub- sequent date becomes a receipt for remittance. No other receipt is sent unless requested. The paper is stopped at expiration of the subscrip- tion, unless previously renewed, Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter or by check or postal order payable to Publisher of the NATION. When a change of address is desired, both the old and new addresses should be given. Address THE NATION, Box 794, New York. Publication Office, 210 Broadway. Seale of TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Agate lines, | No deviation.) On any page not specified, 15 cents per line each insertion ; with choice of page, 20 cents. A column (140 lines), $20 each insertion ; with aie choice of page, $27. A page (3 columns), $60 each insertion; with — chotce of position, $80. —" Double rates for top of column or other pre-— ferred position, when specified ; where positions — are not specified, advertisements are classified as — far as possible and arranged in order of size, 15 the largest at the top. c Double rates for cuts, fancy or other letters not — comprised tn THE NATION fonts, and all other speciai typography. (Subject to approval.) Cuts are inserted only on inside pages of cover or fly-leaves not on out- side of cover, nor on pages numbered for binding. DISCOUNT on yearly accounts amounting to $500, 10 per cent.; $750, 15 per cent.; $1,000, 20 per cent. ; $1,250, 25 per cent. Credits are made December 31. On a yearly account amounting to 52 pages the discount ts one-third. Advertisementa must be acceptable tn every respect. Copy received until Tuesday, 5 P.M. THE NATION ts sent free to those who advertise tn it, as long as advertisement continues. The EDITION of THE NATION this week ts 8,000 coptes. The Subscription List is always open to inspec- tion, Lill Domestic. [/( VES Fitted with proper Glasses. Field, _¢ Marine, and Opera Glasses, Telescopes Micro- scopes, Acoustic Cane for Deafness, Ear Cornets, etc. H. WALDSTRIN, Uptician, 41 Union uare, New York. Catalogues by enclosing stamp. Established 1840, MESES. COTTIER & CO., Domestic ; Artistic Furniture-makers 144 Fifth Ave., N. Y. Decoration. GSSSeS. COTTIER & CO., High-class Interior Decoration, 144 Fifth Avenue, New York. Artists in Stained Glass. ary ISS A. C. CONGDON.—Decorative and Domestic Shopping of all kinds for ladies, gentle- men, and children. Address 25 Pine Street, New York. 440 Tremont Street, Boston. OOD MANTELS AND MIRRORS, Open Fire-Places for Wood or Coal, Tiles, ete. l ete, T. BR. Stewart & Co.. 75 W. Twenty-third St. N. V A7 I. McPHERSON, Painter, Decorator, + Designer, and Stained-Glass Manufacturer, For Sale. T MESSRS. COTTIER & CO.’S, Im- ported Pictures, highest class. 144 Fifth Ave., N.Y. Professional. HARLES W. HASSLER, Attorney and Counsel in Railway Litigations, 120 Broadway, N.Y. Bes ARK CHURCHILL, Attorney-General, Arizona Law Office, Prescott, Arizona Territory. Ty ae F. RANDOLPH. New Jersey Law Offices, Jersey City, N.J.,& 120 Broadway, N.Y. Vj ESSRS. COTTIER & CO., Designers in 4 - iutertor Decoration and all Art-work, 144 Fifth ve., N. . W . J. McPHERSON, Interior Art Designer, 440 Tremont Street, Boston. E KNAB GRAND, SQUARE and UPRIGHT PIANOS, Unequalled in Tone, Touch, Workmanship, aud Durability. We call attention to our choice assortment, including a number of entirely new styles, fin- ished in mahogany, English oak, ebony, ruse- wood, coromandel, and Hungarian ash, with brass ornamentations, marquetry, etc, of the most artistic and recherche designs, especially adapted for Floliday Presents. WM. KNABE & CO., Baltimore and New York. Warerooms, 112 Fifth Avenue, New York. GOLD MEDAL, PARIS, 1878. BAKER’S Breakfast Cocoa. Warranted ABSOLUTELY PURE Cocoa, from which the excess of Oil has been removed. It has three times the strength of Cocoa mixed with Starch, Arrowroot, or Sugar, and is therefore far more economical. It is delicious, nourishing, strengthening, easily di- gested, and admirably adapted for in- valids as well as for persons in health. Sold by Grocers everywhere. W. BAKER & CO., Dorchester, Mass. ™ -— & A Leading London Physician estab- = lishes an Office in New York wJe for the Cure of EPILEPTIC FITS. From Am. Journal of Medicine: Pr. Ab. Meserole (late of London), who makes a spe- cialty of Epilepsy, has without doubt treated and cured more cases than any other living physician. His success has simply been astonishing: we have heard of cases of over 20 years’ standing successfully cured by him. He has published a work on this disease, which he sends, with a large bottle of his wonderful cure, free, to any sufferer who may send their express and P. O. address. We advise any one wishing a cure tu address ‘ Dr. AB. MESEROLE, No. 96 John St., New York. ( PIUM AND ALCOHOLIC HABIT.— Dr. A. M. MATHTAS(three years associated with Dr. Joseph Parrish at Pennsylvania_Sanitarium) re- ceives patients in his residence, 242 Clermont Avenue, Brooklyn, N. Y. W.-. WILL FURNISH A SAMPLE Cc ase (12 quart bottles, no two pine ee Call- fornia Wine, price $5. RAND SONOMA WINE AND CO., 30 Warren Street, New York. THE GREATEST LIVING Authors, such as Vrot Max Muller, Jas. a. Frouce, Prot. Huxley, Kt. Hon. W. >. Giad- stone. RK. .. Proctor. Kdw. a, Freeman, Prof." ynéali, Dr.W. KH. Carpenter, Frances Power Cobbe. vrot. Gelawin *mith, The Dukeof Arayll,. Wm. Black, Miss Thackeray, "rs. Hulock- Craik, Geo. MacDonald, rs, Oliphant, Jean Invelow. Thos. Hardy, Francis Galten, W Ww. Story.MatthewArnole, Ruskin Teupnysou. Browning, and many others, are represented in the pages of Littell’s Living Age. Jan. 1, 1884, THE Livina AGE enters upon its 169th Volume, admittedly unrivalled and continuously suc- cessful. A Weekly Magazine, it gives more than Three and a Quarter Thousand double column octavo pages of reading-matter yearly. It presents in an inexpensive form, considering its great amount of matter, with freshness, owing to its weekly issue, and with a satisfactory completeness at- tempred by no other publication, the best Essays, Re- views, Criticisms, Se: fals and Short Stories, Sketches of Travel and Discovery, Poetry, Scientific, Biographical, Historical and Political Information, from the entire body of Foreign Periodical Literature. It is therefore invaluabie to every American reader, asthe only satisfactorily fresh and COMPLETE com- pilation of an indispensable current literature,— indispensable because it embraces the productions of THE ABLEST LIVING WRITERS, in all branches of Literature, Science. Politics and Art “ We know of no equal to Tne LivisG AGE for variety of information, depth of interest. and purity of tone. Its pages are sufficient to keep any reader abreast with the best printed thoughts of the best of our contempo- rary writers. It is the great eclectic of the world.”— Eynscoyal Register, Philadelphia. “It flourishes ineven more than youthful vigor. It has become indisvensable.”—Nvir York Observer. “Its reagers are ee with the best literature of the day. ... here is nothing noteworthy in science, art, literature. biography, philosophy, or religion, that cannot be foundinirt, . . . It gives in accessible form the best thought of the age.’’—The Churchman, New York. “It becomes more and more necessary as the ficid of periodical literature broadens.”’—Zion’s Hicrald, Boston, “No other periodical gives so diversified a view of current literature, not by abridgmerts but by pub lishing entire the best essays, critic'sms, discussiuns, short stories, ano serial romances of the day. .. . It is tor readers of limited leisure or purse the most convenient and available means of possessing them- seives of the very best results of current criticism, egy , Science, and literature.” — Presby/fcrian Banner, Pittsburgh. “Throughits pages alone, it is possible to te as well informed in current literature as by the perusal of a long list of monthlies.”— Philadelphia Inquirer. “Whatever there is of interest in the literary and sci- entific world is spread before its readers.”’—Buston | Journal, “No reader who makes himself familiar with its con- | tents can lack the means of a sound literary culture.” New York Tribune. “It furnishes a complete compilation of an indis- pensable literature.”—Chicago Evening Journal. “Remarkably chea,y for the quality and amount of reading furrished.”— Montreal Gazette. “Itis by odds the best periodical in the world,”’— Morning Star, Wilmington, N.C. PUBLISHED WEEKLY at $8.00 a year, free of postage; or for $10.50 THE Livina AGE and any one of the Ameri- can $4 Monthlies (or Harper's Weekly or Bazar) will be sent for a year, postpaid: or for $9.50 THE LIVING AGE and the St. Nicholas, or Lippincott’sMonth!y. _Now is the time to subscribe, beginning with the New Year. Address LITTELL & CO., Boston. Binder for the Nation (RUSSELL’S PATENT), To receive the current numbers in a convenient form. Substantially made, bound in cloth, witb The Nation stamped on in gold. Holds one volume. Papers easily and neatly adjusted. Sent, post-paid, on receipt of $1, Address Publisher of the Nafion, Box 794, New York. CONSUMPTION. I have a positive remedy for the above disease. By its use thousands of cases of the worst kind, and of long standing, have been cured. Indeed, so strong is my faith in its ye! that I will send TWO BOTTLES FREE, together with a VALUABLE TREATISE on this disease, to any sufferer. Give Express and P. O. address. Dk, T, A. SLOCUM, 18i Pearl Street, New York.

Page 3

& Sab th he se eto The Nati ion. The Nation, Established in highest order, conducted free from the authority at home and abroad. every department, enlarged its size to twenty-four pages, and added many management has been unchanged from the first, and before the medium of the best thought of the country and time. found below. Its Departments are The Wi eek, 1865, was a pioneer in the United States as Since its consolidation with the a weekly journal « control of party, school, o New rest ot York £ inte its projectors intend that The nat nes of the week’s news in six columns of brief paragraphs. Editorial and Miscellaneous Articles. Special Correspondence. Occastonal Correspondence. Letters to the editor on every subject g Careful and moderate rermane discussion of leac able wri Brief comments on the most important current events, domestic to the > scope of ny sort 1 » Dp t a i ‘ ‘ iters to its the Va: s of the prir ind. fore ‘v1 ling politica Notes. Short paragraphs, chiefly on literary, scientific, musical, and dramatic topics Reviews of Books. By able writers and scholars (mainly specialists) of both hemispheres Fine Arts. Competent criticism of art exhibitions and works of art, the drama, ete. The form and style of the paper are chosen with a view to the most suitable ipe fo Nation preserved, bound, and indexed makes one of the most complete and readable r importance in the political and literary world available. Two volumes are completed annually accompany.the last issue of each volume. Terms, $3 per annum, post-paid. Specimen copies sent on application Pu tio New York. A PARTIAL LIST Alex. Agassiz, Harvard University. Frederic b. Allen, J. A. Allen, F. Bécher, “ H. P. Bowditch, = F. J. Child, - Wm. Cook, me J. P. Cooke, Jr., “ Louis Dyer, F. Emerton, “ Samuel Garman Geo. L. Goodale, W. W. Goodwin, Asa Gray, J. B. Greenough, | W. Gurney, A. Hagen, wv ‘illiam antes, Geo. M. Lane, Chas. R. Lanman, - Theodore Lyman, Jas. Russell Lowell, Charles H. Moore, - Charies Eliot Norton, * Geo. H. Palmer, = Cc. S. Sargent, N.S. Shaler, F, H. Storer, = H, W. Torrey, ni J.T. Trowbridge, fe Sereno Watson, yi J.D. Whitney, * Justin Winsor, sg Francis Bacon, Yale College. W. H. Brewer, ” D. C, Eaton, « ge orge P. F isher, = k. Lounsbury, - oe R. Packard, 333 Tracy Peck, ee T. D. Seymour, - W.G. Sumner, = J. + Thacher, = A. Van Name, = W.D.W hitney, = 8S. Wells Williams, - Theodore D. W oolsey, * - Henry P. Wright Lucien Carr, abode } Museum of Archeology. F. W. Putnam, *% D. P. Todd, Amherst. Herbert B. Adams, Johns Hopkins University. Wm. Hand Browne, 5 Richard T. Ely, ee B. L Gildersleeve, ” - D. C. Gilman, a H. C. G, Brandt, ai Alexander Johnston, Princeton. Of T. F. Crane, Cornell U ni versity Willard Fiske, . Hale, W. T: Hewett, B. G. Wilder, : Alfred M. Mayer, Stevens Institute, Hoboken. H. H. Boyesen, Columbia C rllege. Wm. R. Ware, Henry M. Baird, University of the City of New York Kussell Sturgis, College of City of New York J. H. McDaniels, Hobart College. O. M. Fernald, Williams College. F. A. March, Lafayette College, Easton. J. M. Hart, University of Cincinnati ze Greene, Universit y. of Michigs . H. Pettee c K. Adams,’ H. Cc, Adams, = W. F. ‘Allen, U niversity of Wisconsin. R. B. Anderson, og J. D. Butler, » W. W. Daniells James A. Harrison, W shin rton and Lee University, Va J. K. Hosmer, Washington University, St. Louis, M: J.C. Welling, Columbian University, Washington, D. « Simon Newcomb, U.S. Nautical Almanac Off E. S. Holden, Washburn 0 bee rvatory, Madis n, Wis. John S. Billings, U. S. Surgeon-General’s Office Charles H. Davis, U. S. N H. H. Gorringe, . F. V. Greene, U.S. A. Garrick Mallery, A. A. Woodhull, 8S. F. Emmons, CU. 8. Geologic al Su rvey S. F. Baird, Smithsoni an Insti Fmil Re asels, Elliot Coues, William H. Dall, Theodore Gill, Charlies Rau, si Angelo Heiiprin, Phila. Academy Natu Robert P. Keep, Fast! pton. Mass Charlies Fremcls Adams, Jr., Boston Gamaliel Bradford, : J. Elliot Cabot, Charles A. Cutter, Henry W. Holland, John A. Lewis, H. C. Lodge, Luigi Monti, F. W. Palfrey, tral Sciences J.C. Palfrey, Franc is Parkman, Perkina, y atod C. Ropes, Henry Van Rrunt, Wm. H. Whitmore, WRITER. G \ Linton, New t David A. Wells, Nx J. liam nd Tru erick Sheide Albert Stickney, Wm. Haye Horace White, Theodore Racon W. FE Robert Lowell, Raphael! Pumpell) Horace ik n, s Ward, R iy From all quarters of the globe, by intelligent and trustworthy observers ochester New yor Grimis, Schenectady, Newport yward Furness, Philadelphi d rt: fienry A¢ lame, w ashing rton. A. S. Gatschet, W. M. Griswold, 4 ». Cox, Goldwin Smith, H. von Holst, Friedrich Kapp, W. J. Stillman, | Chandler Harris | Cincinnat! A. F. Bandelier, Highland, Il Toronto. University of Freiburg, Atlanta, Gex Berlin Karl Hillebrand, Flor once Fugene Schuyler, Athens James Bryce, London. “ Albert V. Dicey, Fitzedward Hall, “ Robt. D. Osborn, Robinson Flilis, Oxford Samuel Beal, Wark-on-Tyne. Auguste Laugel, Paris. She don Amos, Alexandria. regia. Baden ped 0 died me

Page 4

1V The Nation. {Number 965 OFFICE OF THE Atlantic Mutual INSURANCE COMPANY. New York, January 25, 1883. The Trustees, in conformity to the Charter of the Company, submit the following Statement of its affairs on the 31st December, 1882. Premiums on Marine Risks from Ist Janu ary, 1882, to 31st December, 18: Premiums on Policies not marked off Ist FREES, BEER... cco cccsccsccvcccecsevcesceses rr $4,412,693 58 1,516,844 85 | Total Marine Premiums.......... ......++++ $5,929,! 538 4 43 Premiums marked off from list Jenmaey, 1882, to 31st December, 1882............... $4,390,305 90 Losses we during the same DONTRE s cccccccccce seccccccese 2,013,767 35 Returns of Pre- miums and Ex- The Company has the following Assets, viz. : United States and State of New York Stock, City, Bank, and other Stocks.............. $8,974,558 00 Loans, secured by Stocks and otherwise... 1,575,500 00 Real Estate and Claims due the Company, GHEIINS GB. oc cccccccncccccevcccesceeccoces 531,118 15 Premium Notes and Bills Receivable....... 1,725,575 02 is he cccas ccccccccesesanccsesecdecs 364,923 85 II, 0.5064 64000entddcdes cocdcctatesosncecns $13,171,675 02 Six per cent. interest on the outstanding certificates of profits will be paid to the holders thereof, or their legal representatives, on and after Tuesday, the sixth of February next. The outstanding certificates of the issue of 1878 will be redeemed and paid to the holders thereof, or their legal | | representatives, on and after Tuesday, the sixth of | February next, from which date all interest thereon will | cease. The certificates to be produced at the time of payment and cancelled. A dividend of forty per cent. is declared on the net earned premiums of the Company, for the year ending 3ist December, 1882, for which certificates will be issued | on and after Tuesday, the first of May next. By order of the Board, J. H. CHAPMAN, Secretary. TRUSTEES. Royal Phelps, Thos. F. Youngs, C. A. Hand, Samuel Willets, John D. Hewiett, Chas. D. Leverich, William H. Webb, William Bryce, Chas. P. Burdett William H. Fogg, Horace Gray, T. B. Coddington, E, W. Corlies, Horace K. Thurber John Elliott, William Degroot, Adolph Lemoyne, John L. Riker, Robt. B. Minturn, N. Denton Smith. Chas. H. Marshall, Geo. W. Lane Edwin D. Morgan, Jas. G. De Forest, J. D. Jones, Charles Dennis, W. H. H. Moore, Lewis Curtis, Chas. H. Russell, James Low, David Lane, G. W. Burnham, A. A. Raven, Wm. Sturgis, Benj. H. Field, Josiah 0. Low, Wm. E. Dodge, J.D JONES, President. CHARLES DENNIS, Vice-President. W. H. H. MOORE, 2d Vice-President. A. A. RAVEN, 3d Vice-President LOCK WOOD, BROOKS & CO.’S Great Sale of BOOKS and ST tet TIONERY. Wholesale Rates. Re- tail Prices Abolished. Catalogue No. 2 now ready, and Catalogue No. 3, of Il- lustrated and Standard Books in fine bindings only, including all the new Books, and Catalogue No. 4, of Books for Young People only, including all the new Books, will be ready December 13th. Send for them. LOCK WOOD, BROOKS & CO., 17 Franklin St., Boston, Mass. W. O. DAVIE & CO., 16 East Fourth Street, Cincinatti, Ohio, DEALERS IN OLD AND NEW BOOKS; atso, BOOK AUCTIONEERS. Books of any kind, and in any quantity, bought La sold at auction on c ommission. Occasional Catalogu issued in each department, and will be mailed upon request. | | | | turn now to the critical part of the book, we | are impressed not simply with the erudition of | ~ PERRY & CO., Lonvon, F1listorical Poetry Appletons | dence in the treatment of his themes.”— Rev. S HOW TO BECOME OF UNITED A MEMBER STATES Mutual Accident Association, And thereby save one-half the usual cost of Accident Lnusurance. THE Write for Circular and Application Blank, and when received fill out your Application, inclose $4, and forward it to the Secretary at New York, on receipt of which a policy will be promptly mailed to you. CH ARLES B. PEET (of Rogers, Peet & Co.), Pres JAMES 22 Broapway, = 9 R. PITCHER, Secretary. New York. READY DECEMBER 29. Lllustrated Guide to Mexico. INCLUDING A Chapter on Guatemala, and a Complete English-Spanish Vocabulary. we to Oo | > a ios) OF THE Ancient Hebrews TRANSLATED AND CRITICALLY EXAMINED. By MICHAEL HEILPRIN. and IT, 8vo, cloth, volume, $2. Vols, f. price of each By ALFRED R. CONKLING, Member of the New York Academy of Sciences, and formerly United States Geologist. Extracts from Remarks of the Press : ‘“*Mr. Heilprin’s book . . . has a double interest for us; both as a translation and as an historical criticism. The deviations from the common translation are sometimes quite marked ; but they are generally well supported by eminent authorities, and show the latest re- sults of Hebrew scholarship. When we LETtER FROM GENERAL GRANT. New York City, December 3, 1883. DEAR SiR: I have read over the advance sheets of your excellent “ Guide-Book to Mexico” with great pleasure. It supplies a want now for the first time being felt. Mexico, with all ber resources of soil, climate, and mines, bas not at- tracted much of the attention of people of other lands until within the last three or four vears, Now, with the rapid strides she is making—and is destined to make—toward a commercial pros perity rarely equalled by any nation in the past, travel to that country will increase many fold, and your book will give the traveller the information he wants. Information is wonder- | fully condensed in it, and I wonder at its com- pleteness in so little space, Very truly yours, U. S. GRANT. ALFRED R. CONKLING, Esq. the writer, but also with his thorough indepen- J. Barrows (‘‘ Christian Register,” Boston). ‘The notion has somehow got abroad that the scientific study of the Bible 1s inconsistent with the most tender reverence for its a, or | with their persistent fascination. But the reve- rence of Mr. Heilprin for the subject-matter of his criticism could hardly be surpassed ; and that it has not lost its power to interest and charm, his book itself is ample evidence, which will be reénforced by the experience of every intelligent reader of its too brief contents.”— Nation, New York. “With all his critical freeness . . . he deals reverently with the religious thought of the Old Testament.’ "—Prof. C. H. Toy (** Ame- | rican Journal of Philology”). New York: D. APPLETON & CO., With a Railway Map and Numerous Illustra- tions. 12mo, cloth. Price, $200. Sent post paid on receipt of price. D. APPLETON & CO., Publishers, 1, 3. end § Bend Street, New York. FW. CHRISTERN, 37 West Twenty-third Street, New York, rter of Foreign Books, Agent for the leading Paris lishers, Tauchnitz’s British Authors, Teubner’s 1, 3, and 5 Bond Street. NICKEL, AND GILT Falcon Steel Pens. Sample card containing TWELVE different styles of pens sent, post-paid, for trial, on receipt of two 2-cent stamps. IVISON, BLAKEMAN, TAY LOR & co., Seog and Latin Classics. Catalogue of stock mailed on SOLE AGENTS, demand. A large assortment always on hand, and new 753-755 Broadway, New York. | books received from Paris and Leipzig as soon’as issued. SILVER, Oe ee iPr is

Page 5

acne alg: ia ate > 9 carob cnananatiiita — Lote, Ae > Pea OaTE RS

The Nation.

NEW YORK, THURSDAY, DECEMBER 27, 1883. » a The Week. SPEAKER CARLISLE’S committees are arranged very nearly as they had been guessed at by the Washington newspaper correspondents. Mr. Morrison is Chairman of the Ways and Means, and his colleagues are divided in such manner, politically and otherwise, that the country need feel no alarm on the subject of the tariff. Apparently Mr, Abram 8S. Hewitt will have the casting vote on the committee as between the extremists on either side, and jt may be added that this responsible position could not be held by one better fitted in the present condition of things to fill it. Mr. Hewitt’s views were given at length and with precision during the last session of Congress. Ilis standing as a manufacturer ought to as- sure the protectionists that their interests will not be wantonly attacked by his vote, while his speeches will satisty most of those who are classed as revenue reformers. Mr. Morri son was entitled to the Chairmanship upon grounds of long service as well as of fa- miliarity with the business appertaining to the committee. It will be remembered that he was Chairman of the Ways and Means under Speaker Kerr. Mr. Randall is at the head of the Appropriation Committee, and Mr. Tuck- er leads the Judiciary. The latter is evidently a strong committee in its personnel. We re- gret profoundly that the Banking Committee should have at its head an enemy of the na- tional banking system, and that the Coinage Committee should be under the lead of the author of the Bland bill.

of Mr. Ker from the prosecution of the Star-route cases, and the rumored withdrawal of Mr. Merrick, have started afresh the old charge that there is no sincerity in the Government’s course in this matter. John A. Walsh appears as the chief spokesman of this view now, and declares positively that the ‘‘ prosecution is not honest as a whole, and has not been since the death of President Garfield and the retirement of Mr. MacVeagh.” He says there bas never been any intention to bring Kellogg to trial, and intimates that he will be allowed to es- cape in order to secure for the Administration the Louisiana delegation to the next Republi- can Convention. He charges especial insin- cerity upon George Bliss, through whose con- duct of the cases ‘‘all the wealthy mail contractors have escaped altogether, or had their cases referred to arbitrators.” It is im- possible to say how much truth there is in these charges. Much that Mr. Walsh asserts is clearly unjust to the prosecuting officers of the Government, and is evidently the outcome of bitter personal animosity. While it cannot be denied that the prosecution as 4 whole is a lamentable failure, and that all the big rogues have escaped justice, it must be said that the ablest and most sincere prosecu- tion possible might not have bad any better The withdrawal | success, so long as the final decision had to be made by a Washington jury. The process of ¢ xpoundiog the Democratic doctrine of ‘‘a tariff for revenue only” is going on steadily in the Democratic papers, and it is very interesting reading. Some of them con | tinue to say that a tariff for revenue only means | gold, pauper labor, and all

much committed to fret a British Nashville out-and-out free trade—Cobden Club The American takes this view and denounces the great Democratic commentator, Mr Watterson of the Louisville Cov J Democratic Day id A accordingly as the secret enemy of the party and, in fact, just as Wells. The Courier-Jor acknowledges that this is ment,” and proceeds toexplain how the matter stands. This is how it is cratic party trade.” In 1876, it demanded revenue only.” After the publicans, in spite of their boast that the tariff for revenue only had defeated Hancock, felt that they could not rest safely on the existing tariff, and got upa_ Tarit? make a sham revision of the Democrats, however, them and drove them from the Senate chamber. Now the Detmocrats bad as “a serious arraign In 1856 the Demo demanded = ‘‘ progressive — free ‘a tariff for election the Ri: Commission to tariff. The thoroughly exposed ** speechless ” have come forward again to perform the tariff revision which the Tariff Commis- sion defeated. been for the Repubheans if they had spared

t cessityv for bv v m t i AP PTs i snub t t! ‘ { Tt } the t pty hi T ‘ be The al tettet { \ ATM ¢ sp 1¢ cer ippeared on Friday, but addecs { g ma eT il t l ‘ veTsy \s Mr kr 4 huvsen seems to rely greatly on legal doctrines cling or ary contracts between man and man wma con unlly alks about the col sidera of the Clavton-Bulwer treaty, ain voidat * character of the agre¢ ment owing to a ‘failure of consideration, we may sugecst that there is another legal principle which in an ordinary court of law would be conclusive Blackstone and Kent long ago s wed that there can be no t y coniuact Without a thing to contract abour Now in this case the thing which the parties intended to contract about—the Canal —is wholly non-existent. There is no canal, { puently and no contract. If Mr. Blaine had thought of this, how it would there is COTISCE have delighted him' There was some interesting discussion of the Mormon prob!em at the dinner of the Brook- Ivn New England Society on Friday. Mr. who was the principal speaker, against the Beecher, took strong what popular notion that polygamy can be ground some- suppressed by the army and navy, and said, very truly. other moral question, has got to be treated ‘‘that this question, like every by moral means, and not by the law of violence. Every man,” he added, ‘‘ that wants to extirpate any form of mistaken belief in politics or religion by law and stricture and force, is a Puritan pure and simple,” but be might better have said that

Page 6

520 [ Number 965 The Nation. he is a bad politician, who knows little either of human nature or of the history of his race. The speech was all through good reading for those clergymen who are fond of the bayonet asa reformatory implement. The Rev. Dr. Newman, who followed him and apparently t lease, such a disclosure might, it is thought, | prove fatal to them, by showing that there | had been a departure from its terms. As private corporations they bave no legal ex- As public corporations they have complaint. It is difficult to istence, no cause of | say what character the Court will give them, represented the other view, whatever that may be, held that the first thing to be | done in this matter was to declare that Cannon, the Utah delegate, “had no right to a seat in the Congress of the United States.” W hat the second thing to be done was, he did not clearly state, but as well as we can make out it was ‘‘to legislate against polygamy on the ground that it 1s a fraud, that it defrauds a man of his rights,” because ‘‘if one man has aright to twenty-five wives, he thereby de frauds twenty four men out of their natural rights.” The way in which this legislation is to suppress polygamy he did not explain, probably by makingthe Mormons ashamed of themselves. The polygamists would put away their extra wives, we suppose, on learn- ing that they were evidence of fraud towards unmarried men. The ‘‘ convict’ case which has lately been argued at great length in the Supreme Court of Georgia, has cast grave doubts upon the legal character of the several penitentiary companies who control the convict labor of that State. These companies, having ob tained leases of convicts for twenty years from the State, have sought to enjoin the keeper of the penitentiary from delivering to the Mari- etta and North Georgia Railroad Company a certain number of convicts granted it by legis- lative acts and resolutions passed after the making of their lease. 1t was maintained that these acts and resolutions impaired the obli- gation of the State’s contract with the peni- tentiary companies. It is perfectly clear that if they are private corporations, they can with propriety complain of any legislative interfer- ence with their property rights. But it was beyond question proved that the act which sought to incorporate them was un- constitutional, and one of the companies had in effect acknowledged it by having secured a | _, ; | Culture Acts. charter from the Superior Court, which alone has power to create such corporations. If these companies, then, are corporations, they are public corporations. As such, it is to be supposed, the Supreme Court of Georgia is anxious to consider them, wishing to upholda | lease pecuniarily advantageous to the State,and | yet being unable to do so without confessing | that the lessees are mere money-making cor- porations, to whom has been transferred the | police power of the State; for if it holds that they are what Georgia is pleased to have them considered, mere governmental agents, it will be constrained, of course, to decide that con- tracts with such may be altered and even abrogated at will by the State. This would, indeed, be alarming to the lessees, for there are plain indications in Georgia of a growing desire to resume legislative control of convicts. The lessees cantot be sustained in this action upon the idea that they are part- nerships, for the names of no partners are disclosed, as is required in pleading. As the original contractors with the State were forbid- den by the Act to transfer their interest in the for it is well known that, though pre- sumed to be governmental agents, they have the odd features of stockholders. It is not improbable that every difficulty may be es- caped by calling them quasi-public corpora- tions. The Boston Civil-Service Reform As:ocia- tion have called Mr. Long and Mr. Ranney to account for voting for Mr. Keifer for the Speakership, by asking them for what reason consistent with their avowed support of civil- service reform, they voted for him. They both answer that they had no idea that the issue of civil-service reform was in any way involved in the contest. Both say, too, that they understood that Mr. Keifer had rendered important aid in passing the Civil-Service Re- form Act. He may have done so, but they apparently forgot his own performances as a civil-service reformer in his dealings with the House stenographers. The Financial Chronicle has an important article on ‘‘ Government Land Sales,” show- ing the amount of public lands disposed of during the past six years in the several States and Territories, as indicating the direction in which population is moving. The total num- ber of acres disposed of in the year 1883 was 16,830,455. The table of largest sales, in the order of magnitude, is as follows: Acres. Acres. eee 6,689,595 Mississippi....... 516,514 Nebraska . oe deh 2OS ORSON. ..000cc0000 499,770 Minnesota.......1,"92.269 Louisiana... ..... 487,549 Kansas........... 808,655 Arkansas.... 460,656 Washington T’y. 763,779 Wisconsin.... ... 454,002 Cahifornia........ 704,274 Florida........... 434,749 Texas is not embraced in the list, as the United States bave no public lands in that State. The list includes lands sold for cash, and taken under the Homestead and Timber The sales for six years have been as follows: Acres, Acres, oe ee GBGE.7TCL IBSh.....cccce 8,379,518 1879 $,.649,259 1882. ........12,526,262 Rr 9,090,495 1883,......... 16,830,455 The increase of sales during the past two years has been very marked, being at the rate of 50 per cent. in 1882 over 1881, and 40 per cent. in 1883 over 1882. This extraordinary addition to the producing power of the nation, the Chronicle argues, must soon tell favorably on | the existing business depression, for although | the opening of new territory cannot be expect- | ed to show full results in the first or even the second year after settlement, ‘‘ yet when it is | remembered that during the two years since the depression set in, more than twenty-nine and a quarter millions of Government acres have been entered upon, it will readily be seen what a wonderful recuperative power this continued opening of new territory offers.” As the new year and the meeting of the Legis:ature approach, the railroads are no doubt getiing their free passes ready and pre- paring to correspond with members on the subject. Politicians have recently discovered a way of making a little reform capital out of this effort to corrupt them by spurning the | offer of a pass in the press, publishing the ‘*tender,” and also the scornful refusal with which it is met. Such correspondence is instructive as far as it goes, but in the case of legislators of good reputation it it is unnecessary, as they are not suspected, while suspected members are not cleared of suspicion, even by the most thorough ad- vertisement of their little spurn. The only way to let the public fully behind the scenes, as we have suggested before now, is to make the companies publish a dead-head list every year, after the adjournment. A comparison of votes with rides enjoyed would probably throw a flood of light on the winter’s work. The hanging of O'Donnell hss led to a meeting in Washington in which two or three Congressmen paid their tribute to the Irish vote. Mr. Robinson, of New York, demanded the recall of Lord J. Russell Lowell, Mr. Calkins, of Indiana, maintained that O’Don- nell had been illegally convicted, and Mr, Finnerty declared that the President ought to have demanded the respite of O’Donnell for ninety days, and, in default of it, have sus- pended the diplomatic relations. He predicted that if, in consequence of this stern course, England had sent her flcet out here, she would have got the worst of it, as in the war of 1812. Mr. Belford, of Colorado, maintained the right of every man to kill a ‘‘sneak,” and declared that had O’Donnell been tried in Colorado he would have been promptly acquitted. The bitterest rebuke, however, called forth by O’Donnell’s execution, is the formal resignation by Mr. John Joseph Ryan of his American cit- izenship, and the return by him of bis natural- ization papers to the judges of the Court of Common Pleas. He scorns to be any longer the citizen of a republic which allows American citizens to be hanged abroad when they com- mit murder, or allows them to be imprisoned when they blow buildings up, under sentences which have not been approved by Irishmen in this country. The movement for the protection of Ameri- can labor against foreign emigration seems to be spreading. According to a despatch from Pennsylvania, the miners in the Connellsville coke regions bave determined that ‘‘ the Hun- garians must go.” If it were not for the anti- Chinese law and the well-known feeling in this city about the cheap Italian laborer, we should | have taken the anti-Hungarian movement to be | &@ joke of some free-trader. The complaint against them is that they are crowding out the local Pennsylvanians, who we presume are of Irish extraction, that they are ‘‘ filthy in their habits, living on what Americans could not eat,” that they are very immoral, and ** unscrupulous,” and igno:ant, and also that they ‘‘ will not become naturalized citizens,” | and cause a general loss of time and labor in attempts to elevate them in the social scale. Therefore they must go. After all, is this ' @ ‘‘crusade,” or is it a joke ? ; oe Saat A ERR R48 €2 hid Ai och RT 8 BE

Page 7

se ta

sie iit:

1s orth ln ee A Baa PA ACR . ; j

Dec. 27, 1883] The Nation.

Interesting and edifying information about Mr. Blaine continues to accumulate. A cor- respondent of one of bis most devoted organs visited him in his ‘‘ workshop ” in Wasbing- ton a day or two ago, and found him at a ‘‘great big table” loaded with manuscript, proofs, and documents. The ‘‘ great states- man sremed to be engaged in revising some proof sheets of his book,” and was not overjoyed to be interrupted. He was polite, however, and was gracious enough to say that ‘‘ he was in Jove with his present work, and should hereafter follow the pursuit of writing. Nothing he had ever done was so in harmony with his tastes, and he was never so contented and happy.” Another correspondent been exumining the State of Maine on the subject of Blaine as a Presidential candi- date, and has found a great cooling off in enthusiasm for him there. He discovered that Blaine does not ex- pect to be nominated next year; that he looks forward to 1888, and intends in the meantime to complete his ‘‘history,” which ‘‘willbe his monument.” His chief aspira- tion outside of the monument is to be Secre- tary of State under the next President, in order to give the American Jingo policy that fair trial which he does not believe it has yet had , has has also The Hebron clergyman who, in the guise of a powerfu] sermon on *‘ Polygamy,” made a ratiing attack upon one of his church members who had recently married a fourth wife, is in danger of losing bis position. It will be remembered that the situation in which the assailed man was placed was an extremely trying one. His divorced third wife was present in the church when the sermon was preached, and was seated where she could fix her eyes upon the victim and see how he stood the He was naturally much displeased by the occurrence, but, after calling the pastor a ‘liar and a bypocrite,” he sold his house and left the town, leaving the pastor apparently master of the field. This retreat was, it seems now, a mere ruse on the part of the polygamous member. He took up bis abode in a neighboring town, and began operations for undermining the minister. He has well that it is now believed in Hebron tbat the minister will have to ‘‘go.”’ All the people of the commu- pity who bave been divorced, and all those who hope to be, have joined forces against him. The prevailing feeling among them is that the present tendency of the rural pulpit to descend to personulities must be checked attack. succeeded so by a decisive rebuke of some sort. The business of drawing pen-photographs or paragraph portraits of eminent authors, statesmen, dry-goods men, monopolists, prima- douvas, tenors, and poets, for the press is now well established, but the vocabu'ary of these word-pictures is hardly as definite and exact as it might be made. We have before usa column and a half of such sketches, recently published in an esteemed Boston contempora- ry, admirable in their way, but in which the description would hardly enable the reader to identify the person described on a casual meet- ing. For instance, we find a lady described as “medium-complexioned,” ‘‘pleasant-featured,

comfortable-looking,” and ‘‘ middle a Another is put down as ‘‘a magnificent blonde

of generous proportions, with charming eyes of a hazel cast.” A good deal of pains seems to be taken, in the case of men, to muke the ce scription hinge upon the way of wearing the beard, though sometimes without much result é.g., ——'s ‘‘gray hair and side whiskers are sometimes allowed to grow as they please, free from the pruning of the tonsorial shears,” and this is followed by the extraordinary statement that ‘‘ bis ears are not always observable on ac count of this capillary growth.” The remark able thing about the that them refer to a ‘‘ medium assumed to be generally known, descriptions is so many of or average, the persons described being characterized by their approach to a medium stature, a medium height, or amedium complexion. Work of when really good, is always or departure from this sort anonyme us ut the sex of the writer may generally be made It 1s an unfailing mark of the masculine pen-photographer that he dwells with interest out, upon the weight of the person described, whilk the so, usually makes more of age and dress, par ticularly in the case of her own sex. Thus, in the list before us, one lady is put down as “very fond of dress, . . not invariably lady personnellist, if we may call her suited to her advancing years.” \ is apt to be a good judge of such these, but how the men in the business get at the weight of their subjects it is hard to con jecture. woman matters as A novel method of forging a will has come to light in England in Priestman Thomas Whalley died, leaving a will writ } many wills against named ten, as by which he $300,000 to his attendant, Thomas, an ex are, on white paper bequeathed a railway porter. to Mr. Priestman, a natural son of the tests had good property himself; but everything appeared to be regular, and Thomas taking $85,000. This so turned Thomas's head, that he piece of blue paper at Mr latter drove by bis window This Was a& great surprise tor’s, who reason to expect the compromised by : . large sum tT money Priestman as the For some Mr. Priestman jumped at the conclusion that this piece of paper was the missing will 1n his own favor. The result was a lawsuit in which it appeared that the only genuine part of the “white” will was the signatur ; been induced by Thomas to dictate a letter in pencil on a sheet of white paper to Priestman

but had signed itin ink. Thomas had then rubbed out the pencil marks, written in a will, and got some friends to witness it. The percil marks were rubbed out with hread crumbs, but, as the this was a bad plan. The effect of rubbing pencil marks out by such means is not to de stroy them altogether, but to raise the fibres of the paper so asto cover them. After a time they get smoothed down, and then the concealed marks come to hgbt again. This, at least, is the testimony of Mr. Holmes, the Queen's librarian, in the pearance of the old marks in the “white” will corroborated what he said case, and the reap 521 The disorders often produced in court-rooms nowadays, by the repiles f the pris ner to the question whether he has anything to say why idgment should not be passed upon him, b ed tos ! rv into the reason for the prac t Ther s litt 1% bt that it Was or ally ced bef prisoners were al wed « nsel, t ible them to movein ar rest of idgment As all such matters are now in the hands of insel, the oppor tunity veu to ft I ner ¢ 8 t seem tk hely b inv Wa but t ¢ ibles l n ra has i I { nake it intl: matory » Ss} ch n tl famous wavin which he is b perse 1, which s sure t nd a pron nt piace 1 of tre papers next 1 rr i \ ilters al issue, however xactly Ww thev wer ne ) we ¢ \ ) * t in for the murcer of K \ Dut ! 8 ( er, | ny ¢a | 1 this WAV ears to have . t ‘ t tion ‘ } r 1 , \f MUP sp \ W ip with pr t} : t Ir iN public It w 1 see matter to get rid of f buse by T t! ive to wl re - h = = ito ’ Ss 4 ul sel instead of t ris t Phere is hard ship in this, as it rely s t] fuct of this | ir {1 the ha s which control all the rest of it Tt capture f & iv bv tl Frene} with trifl Ss is 1 i at) so military OXt t s Vv for the French Ministry t T t | ‘ eX It era hles ' ‘ ‘, ‘ uk ) ‘ ‘ , the Chambers 1 show somet! the large \ s of v wi t have been re ( tiv Ww h have lye 1 t s \ The cay tur { Bac h will pr iblv soon follow but the i t les w not then be over It remains t st what 1} ceupation of a w territerv will cost, and what China is ing to do in the matter Admiral Courbet Chi nese 1 ifs Teaily wi British But the bulk of the party seem

Page 8

The Nation. [ Number 965 HOW THE REFORM IS WORKING. Some of the Civil-Service Reform Associations have begun to take testimony with yegard to the practical working of the act, and more particularly with regard to its effect in re- lieving members of Congress from the pur- The New Haven answers to its of _ oflice-seekers. Association received questions from Messrs. Hawley, Edmunds, Kasson, and Platt, all four conspicuous men, who are likely to observe the working of the law without any special bias either way. Mr. Hawley says ‘‘emphatically” that it has relieved him from the pressure of office- seekers, and it is securing the end for which it was enacted. Mr. Edmunds says that it has notdofe him much good in the way of relief, for the simple reason that seven years ago he relieved himself by declining abso- lutely tomake any recommendations or re- The only fault suit has quests on anybody’s behalf. he bas to find with the act is that it is not enough, and that the President may break through it whenever he pleases. stringent Mr. Kasson, who is a convert of the elev- enth hour, bears much the same testi- mony Ile suys members of Congress ure relieved from pressure with regard to all those offices which are covered by the act, and that its effect with regard to offices which it does not cover has undoubtedly been to diminish the eagerness and zeal with which applicants pursue them; but he doubts whether the law is improving the personnel and efliciency of the service, or rather says the question is ‘‘involved in doubt,” with- out saying whose doubt. Senator Platt of Connecticut says that Connecticut Congress- men were troubled less than most others by office-seekers even before the act was passed, and that they are now not troubled at all by applicants for clerical offices, but he is as much troubled as ever by applications for “influence” in the matter of pro- motion, and it seems to him that it would be peculiarly appropriate that the right to pro- motion, as Well as fitness for an original ap- pointment, should be determined by competi- tive examination, and he will be glad to see the operation of the act extending just as fast and far as itis practicable. On the other hand, the testimony of the Democratic Senators, although it has not been published in detail, is said to be very unfavorable. They have apparently ex- perienced no relief from pressure whatever. If his they are subjected to pressure, however, it is | undoubtedly due to the fact that they are ex- | pected to disregard or overturn the law at the earliest possible moment. There bas been no indication at any Democratic meeting or con- vention of any general acceptance of the law by the party, or of any intention of en- forcing it, or allowing it to be enforced, one minute longer than can be helped. The orthodox party doctrine, in fact, seems to be that the whole thing is a piece of Republican | | humbug, intended for the sole purpose of en- | abling the party to retain possession of the offices after having gone into opposition. Mr. Platt’s suggestion with regard to the use of competitive examinations, for the purpose of promotion, touches on what is probably one of the most serious difliculties in the practical working of the reform. There are certain fields in some of the departments—that of the Interior, for instance—in which the main element in the excellence of an employee lies in his special knowledge, and in which other qualifications count for comparatively little. In such fields a man’s comparative fitness for a higher place can probably in most cases be ascertained by competitive examination with almost complete accuracy. But in most others to make promo- tion dependent altogether upon his ability to answer written questions better than rival vandidates would strike a very serious blow at the responsibility which must be lodged in the hands of every head of the department. The chief of any office or establishment who does not know better than anybody else the relative value of his subordinates in almost all cases, is not fit for his place. As long as he retains it he must be assumed to know better, o1 he cannot be held with any fairness accounta- ble for the way in which the work is done. The difficulty of fixing responsibility on the right person is the weak point in the whole American system of admiuistration. The tendency of a/] changes in the nature of administrative reform for some years back in all the States has been in thedirection of mak- ing this responsibility more clear and distinct, or, in other words, in the direction of making it easier for the voler to say, when things go wrong, who is to blame. If it should turn out that there was anything in the working of the Civil-Service Reform Act to hinder or divert this tendency, it would be unfortunate, both for civil-service re- form itself and for the Government of the country. If the day should ever come when high officials would be able to say that short- comings in their office were due to the unfit- bess of persons forced upon them for re- sponsible positions by the new law, it would go far to condemn it utterly, and to commence a_ reaction which might carry us back irretrievably to the spoils system. It is in this matter emphaticaliy better to rely upon the gradual dying out of the whole system of Congressional ‘‘ influence ” through the general discouragement given to it by the working of the act, aided by the increasing power of the resistance of Congressmen them- selves, than to make any addition to the law which would be likely to interfere with the proper discipline and control of persons already in oflice. It is not at all likely that Congres- sional pressure about promotion will last very long after it has ceased to be of any use in procuring entrance to the éervice. The addition to or extension of the act which we now need, isthe repeal of the four years’ limitation which the law of 1820 now places upon the tenure of offices not covered by the Pendleton bill. The mischief which this works has often been pointed out. There is probably no way in which it works so much mischief as in keeping alive the spirit or state of mind among office-seekers which made the Civil-Service Reform Act necessary, | and which, in fact, created the spoils system. The reform will never be complete as long as there is a large body of persons of all ages in the country who are constantly think- ing of the Government service as a means ei- ther of repairing broken fortunes, or escaping the sharp competition of ordinary business. It is this class which pesters Congressmen and makes politics corrupt, and it will not disap- pear until the whole service, as well as the clerical offices, is practically put out of their reach. We do not mean by this to say that places not now covered by the Pendleton bill, and held under the four years’ tenure, should be thrown open to competitive examina- tion, but simply tbat they should be held during good behavior, so that it should not be known to any one but the appointing power when a vacancy would occur, and that vacan- cies should not be made except for reasonable cause. As long as the whole country knows when an officer is to be turned out, there will be hundreds of persons kept from betaking | themselves to some honest industry by the ex- pectation that they can intrigue themselves into his place. It is right to add that those who advocate the repeal of the four years’ tenure do not mean, as some have believed or tried to believe, any extension of tenure in the | offices now covered by the Pendleton bill, but in those with which the Pendleton bill has nothing to do, and in which appointments are not made through competitive examina- tion. THE VOTING POWER OF STOCK. SoME attention has been drawn recently in England to a plan for protecting the rights of minority stockholders in corporations, by do- ing away with the old rule which gives one vote for every share of stock. It is this which enables a single stockholder, by getting a ma- jority of the stock into his hands, to outvote the whole host of little stockholders, and ‘‘run” the concern as he pleases. Formerly it was supposed that no harm could result from the majority principle, because the interest of the majority and minority would after all be only the interest of the corporation. But this, al- though true enough in the case of ordinary business concerns like a factory or an insur- ance company, does not seem borne out by the facts when we get into the region of the corporations whose stock is daily bought and sold in Wall Street, like railroads and mines. In these we frequently see a powerful opera- tor get possession of a majority of the stock for the purpose of furthering some private scheme of his own, and it is possible for the great speculators by such means as this to ruin the minority interest, under guise of man- aging their property for them. In the Ele- vated Railway case now going on in this city, for instance, it is supposed that Jay Gould first depressed the stock in one of the companies, by a “ bear” raid, helped by legal proceedings which he set on foot, then bought up the stock at low figures, and then, through the Board of Directors, made contracts with the other companies which he also controlled, the result being his own pecuniary advantage and the great injury of minority stockholders. Accord- ing to testimony taken or offered in this litigation, notice in advance of an intention to ‘* crack” the company was privately given,

Page 9

ene et i 3 SRS ev See nee a + ‘Cas es sdinbiiaancies tal at Dec. 27, 1883] The Nation. Without going into the merits of these accu- sations, however, the precise truth of which will probably never come out, it is enough that operations which fall far short of a con- spiracy to ‘‘crack” a company, and which are usually regarded as legitimate, may result in serious sacrifices of the minority’s rights. The mere fact that one man can get possession and control and management of the entire pro- perty belonging, it may be, to a thousand small stockholders, and to a very great ex tent do what he pleases with it, is a serious matter, and this is what has recently hap- pened in the case of a great English cor- poration, the Hudson’s Bay Company; and something very like 1t always happens, unless the public is greatly mistaken, whenever a new railroad passes into the hands of the Brown, the Jones, or the Robinson ‘* party.” In England, attempts have been made, by a very simple device, to increase the power of the minority by limiting the voting power of stock. Thus, in the case of one railway, the London and Northwestern, every $500 of the stock gives one vote, up to $5,000; after that the voting unit is $2,500 up to $50,000; then one vote for every $5,000 beyond. In the London and Westminster Bank, a holder of ten shares has one vote, but a holder of fifty has only two. The equality plan in stock elections evi- dently rests upon the idea of identity of inte- rest, and is inherited from a time when most of the extraordinary phenomena of modern corporate life were undreamt of. The old idea of a corporation was a concern which would need for its creation and development an aggregution of capital contributed in small amounts by several people, and it seemed only proper that the amcunt of voting power should be exactly proportioned to the amount of money subscribed. But most of the money-kings and monopolists of our day do not get their immense wealth through corporations of this sort. In a large proportion of cases, the money contributed is thinks expedient, and that the corporation will submit to. But undoubtedly the phenomenon of the capture of corporations by the money-kings for private purposes, which we so constantly Witness, is due in great measure to the fact that there are always so many thousands of millions of stock on® the market which rep- resent, not the actually expended in the development of the property, but the chances of its yielding great pro fits in the future, owing to the extraordi nary growth of the country. As the expan sion of the country slackens, and corporate goleondas become impossible, and the rate of progress becomes steady, instead of consisting of leaps and bounds alternating with dead stand-stills, stock will more and more represent invested capital; and, as every one Knows, regu lar dividend-paying stocks are not those out of which money-kings are generated. money But even then it will be very questionable whether there isany sense or reason in giving every share a vote. Theideaof one man being able to outvote forty in the management of the | joint property, merely because he owns more | differs represented by bonds, which have no voting | power, while the stock represents notbing | more than the probability of profit after the encumbrances have been provided for. Stock in this condition is the natural football of speculation, and of that sort of speculation which leads to all kinds of frauds and irregu- larities, as no one who recollects the bistory of the Erie, the Hartford and Erie, or the Crédit- Mobilier disclosures will question. In the case of corporations already chartered in this country without restriction of any kind, it is, to say the least, doubtful whether the Legislature could interfere with the voting pow- er of stock. The right to cast a vote for each share is a valuable property right under the charter, and a change in it designed to give small stockholders greater power, wou'd be met with determined resistance in the courts. But the right to alter and amend corporate charters is now generally reserved by the Legislature,and whenever this is the case there can hardly be any legal objection to the change, for it would be in the interest of the good management of the concern. In the case of new corporations there is nothing to pre- vent the Legislature from making any rule as to the relation between votes and stock that it of it, rests ona false idea of equality, and seems essentially undemocra‘ic, as it makes numbers even when united powerless, leaves the management of the to be determined by the wealth. and interests power of joint brute ART UNIONS. THE experiment 1s about to be tried again in New York of hot-bedding art. The exhibition which opered to a private view on Wednesday week is the first display of an institution which somewhat which we bave had experience, being organized and con ducted entirely by artists. We who remem- ber the old Art and its effects on the interests of art in general, may be pardoned a doubt as to the desirability of a repetition of the experiment. We may be sure that in the bands of the experienc: d artists who compose the *‘ Board of Control,’ from any of Union disastrous there will be as good taste 1n the selection of prizes as in the direction of the ilvustrated monthly journal which forms an unexceptiona- ble part of the programme. But artists are noto- riously bad business men, and itis in the work. ing out of their plans that the hitch is generally found. ducted entirely by business men,and financially The elder extinct institution was con- was a great success. If itsintluence on art was that men imagined that the laws of trade, which they never would bave lost sight of in reference to coffee had nothing to do with pictures, and the new claimant for the old not show indications in the programme of hav- ing clearly in view the blunders of its adverse, it was probably due to the fact those rood business or cotton, title does pre cde cessor, An ‘Art Union” means to the ordinary ap- prehension a lottery of works of art drawn by the subscribers to the funds of the institution; and the ‘‘American Art Union,” while it does not hold this as the peculiar object of its formation, allows it to be implied as an out- come of the organization. Now, a permanent lottery, in no matter what, means: firstly, the derangement of the Jaws of supply and de mand; secondly, the | both direct and indirect consequences of thi pushing of more than there is a healthy demand for; and thirdly, the stimulation of the tendency of the young possible artists to adopt art as a live ’ articles on the hood beyond the point to which the taste and means of our commumty will sustain th in normal ways andtimes. Works of art fol- low the same law of the relation of supply and demand that rules the pric f diamonds and potatoes; and when by means of a lotterv a larger number of pictures are market than the community wants, t! falls just as certainly as does that of diamonds in similar cases. And this is brought at by the operation of three distinet a firstly, men not buy pictures w they think that they can get them for the of a lottery will ticket; second!v, thev value a work pretty much according to the price they paid for it; and thirdly (as we know ft the workings of the old Art lt pictures rarely to the taste { them, and, being thrown drawn are those who draw the market sometimes for a fraction of the price the artist ACAIN Al Ale NM shies ire s 1 received for them, with the ine) a of knockivg down the prices of all the artist's unsold works. To foster art we times discourage the artist. Healthy prut and cutting out the weaker grow?! forests and for art—both natura wths and not to be stimulated by any art 1 pot cess, If art is to become a feature of A can life, it can only be so by tivation under the laws which ceptrol industrial activ any other branch, and thst means a growth in response to a genuine a as opposed to any syste t ¢ y which induces men to take pietures that they do not want, or to regard them as of speculation Phe picture dealer and the art lottery are the chief enemies of art, and all the more dangerous as they appear in the beginning as the great friends of the artist The new Art Union, howev s ut of grace yet, and there is a direction for its oper tions in which we can see no danger of ship wreck, and which is, programme as & possi re it ought to be placed as a finality ¢., the formation, from the prizes, of local art-gallerics will have the double of the This , 47 + good effect of putting out market the works of art drawn, and therefore out of the danger of influencing prices; and of developing a taste for art in those localities so favored, and conduc ing to private patronage on a healthy basis. Any other of the various plans indicated by the programme published by the American Art Union will certainly be disastrous to art, what ever may be its momentary effect on the in dividual artist. the general vote If the subscribers should, by provided for in the pro gramme, decide to distribute the pictures, etc., by a lottery among themselves, the public morality, which imperiously militates against lotteries of any kind, and the interests of art alike, would demand the rigorous application of the legal remedies already provided, to the new institution as they were applied to the old,

Page 10

D224 A SOUTHERN “EXPERIENCE MEETING.” MADISON, Wisconsin, December 12, A FITTING close to the volume of suggestions af- forded bythe recent meetings of the National Con- ference of Charities and Corrections at Louis- ville, wasmy visit toaseminary for colored girls and women at Atlanta,Ga. While under the con- trol of the Baptist Home Mission Society, it owes its existence to two Baston women who, about eighteen months ago, went South with benevo- lent purpose. At first they gathered around them a few colored pupils in the basement of a church. The contagion of ambitious hopes soon spread itself not only among scores Of Atlanta freedwomen, but far beyond the limits of that city. Today there are nearly three hundred scholars availing them- selves of the educational privileges offered, and young girls are flocking thither from many dif- ferent places in the South. The old United States barracks are now used instead of the smal] church basement, which soon proved inad- equate. Thecottages of the row once orcupied by army officers are now connected by a long covered piazza, and eachis a cosey dormitory under the charge of one of the seven lady teach- ers at the present time employed. The large, beautifully located building, formerly known as | a hospital, has been converted into a chapel with adjoining recitation rooms. The ages of the scholars now in attendance range from eight to fifty years. The school was to me one of the most interesting and thought-awakening institutions I ever visited, Pitiful indeed is the mental and moral condi- tion of the colored people of the South to-day. More especially deplorable seems the profound moral as well as mental ignorance of the fe- male population, for it is one of the strongest barriers to successful efforts for the elevation of the colored race. According to the census there are nearly six millions of ne- groes in ‘‘the South”; nearly a million and a half of the colored children are girls, prospective wives and mothers of millions of future voters, who, unless properly trained, can but perpetuate degradation and greatly ag- | gravate national immorality. Is there, at the present time, any field for the howe missiona- ries where woman’s influence and peculiar tact are more needed, than among ber ignorant and naturaily depraved colored sisters in the South? The work required in this field is, in fact, such as only women can perform. The preceding statements have been used for | a background to numerous illustrations of the needs of our colored girls and women as they were revealed to me at an “‘ experience meet- ing” which I attended while among them. Un- like our white scholars—whose natural timidity or self-consciousness prevents them from speak- ing even a carefully committed ‘ piece,” and much more seriously from expressing their own convictions witbout the most painful embarrass- ment—those colored girls were eager and anxious to rise in their seats and give utterance to their inmost thoughts. The bour devoted to vacation ‘‘experiences” was, for them, alas, too brief. Those wbo had to wait for their turn until the next Friday were very solemn in their necessarily enforced silence. As I con the leaves of my little note-book, which I used free- ly that morniog, feeling that the recitals were too valuable to be forgotten in the many dis- tractions of travel in the suggestive South, I see again the faces of those three hundred col- ored girls and women, and once more hear their plaintive voices. After singing a number both of plantation and gospel songs, among which were “T heard a voice, I couldn’t tell where,” and “Child of sia and sorrow,” they began their re- last | | souls to Christ. ; The Nation. [ Number 965 marks and narratives. From the many ‘ expe- riences “in my collection, I submit the following specimens—ali based upon fact, and culled from as faithful a record as my swift pencil could make: Number 1, ‘Ts been a workin’ fur Jesus all de summer vacation. | don’t ask fur no better times dan ( bas in dis yeah school where we al] come to learn to work fur Jesus”; and number 1, a tall, gaunt girl, who seemed to be made up of knuckles, elbows, and faded pink ribbons, raised ber voice to a high pitch and sang, ‘* Never be afraid to work for Jesus,” the whole school joining in the chorus. Number 2. ‘*‘ Vs been a workin’ fur Jesus too. I’s ben teachin’ forty-five miles from yeah, an’ | I had twenty-seven scholars, most of ’em older | than me, but they didn’t know anythin’ til: I tole ’em all bout Jesus. They wanted to study ’rithmetic and geography—to please Jesus; an | dey was so glad I come back yeah to learn I was sv sad and sosorry kase | more *bout him, I didn’t know bow to count furder. Jes’ as we'd get on a piece, I'd have to stop. Ob, [I was so ‘shamed, I cried sometimes all night kase I couldn't help’em more ’bout Jesus.” And she sat down with eyes full of tears, because of her realization of the fact that she knew but little about Jesus—her synonym for the common English branches. Number 3. ‘Dis chile didn’t do no teachin’ in vacation,” said a big mulatto woman, with great pomposity. ‘’Twan’t cos she didn't know nuff ’xactly, nor cos there wan’t beaps cat needed to be teached. On every side iggorant niggers is as thick as flies. But my preferment was doin’ sutbin’ else fur my blessed Saviour. Needn’t think [ didn’t work for Jesus, my young sisters. I tell ye I worked mighty bard! I vis- ted heaps o’ sick niggers, an’ I ‘low I wan't lazy. Don’t win ye no crown jes to go an’ look at sick folks, unless ye do suthin fur um. I fee) like as if my stomach was light and freed from bile, cos I nussed the sick, an’ puttin my shoulders to the wheel, didn’t look back like Lot’s wife an’ turn unto a pillow of salt, but minded my blessed Lord an’ Saviour an’ visited the sick—fur to please Jesus. I likes dis yeah school. Laws! I’s mo’n fifty years ole or thar-’bouts, an’ till I kum yeah [ nebber know’d dat workin’ fur Christ meant nussin’ sick folks an’ goin to see the widowers an’ childless in affliction, an’ keepin’ unspotted from de world.” Number 4. ‘“‘My bredrenand sisters,” began a young girl (and as there were no ‘‘bredren” pres- ent of coursethe school indulged in laugbter, but she was not intimidated), ‘‘I’ve tried hard all de vacation to bea light to sinners. I’m proud, in meekness, to say dat I've converted twenty Since I’se learned to read in dis yeah school I feel like as ef de Bible is so sprin- kled in my soul dat I can’t stan’ roun’ doin notbin’: I must nudge all dem as sits , in darkness. dey want to come yeah too, an’ I see six of ‘em yeah now. count an’ read, kase dey bas gib dere souls to Jesus. I hupe an’ pray dat dese yeah white ladies from de Norf (yeah jes’ to teach us cullud girls), will feel like as ef we bad all done our duty in vacation an’ come back to dis yeah place with our dues to Jesus all paid up.” The room was perfectly quiet for several moments, but suddenly a sweet young voice led off end all joined in singing, ‘‘Jesus keep me near the Stream.” Number 5, “T's was nebber here before. me to git introduced to Pinkie Starks, she dat’s jes’ been speakin’, an’ my ideas is open. I race to git yeah. I long fur to know as much as she a stranger in disschool. I | does. 1 tole many ob my friends "bout | de Atlanta Female Seminary fur girls, an’ | Dey’ll werry soon learn how to But de Lord helped | I lopg fur to please Jesus, an’ 1 pray fur an education so dat I kin read my Bible. Seems like asif I'd read it day and night when I once find out how to git acquainted wid my Lord and Saviour. Dat’s what I’s missed so much, young’s I be, not knowin’ how to read my Bible an’ be a light tosinners like Pinkie Starks.” She started the tune, ‘* I’m in astrange land tar frum home,” but only a few were familiar with the words, and most of the song was feelingly carried on alove. Number 6. ‘T's been teachin’ down in Florida, ’way down in de country. But ob, IL knowed sich little! I could vn’ only count up to five, and there I bad to stop an’ think an’ think what shouldI do? Oh, I was so ’shamed! I had twenty-five scholars, They was all poor, but it made um happy to hear “bout Jesus. I showed um how tocount andread. Ob, I tell you they was mighty proud! If you could only of seen me in the ole tumble-down meetin’-house tryin’ fur tobelp my bredren and sisters in the Lord, you'd of laughed, I know. Fur I hadn’t nothin’ to teach with—none of the inconveniences that we bave yeah: I had nothin’ in my hands or head to boast of, but I had heaps yeah,” laying her big black hand on ber heart. ‘* I consorted to all the means in my power. I made a black- board out of a piece of dry-goods box, an’ I blacked it with chimney-soot. One of my scholars brougbt me some vinegar to set the soot. It didn’t work very well. Afterwards a boy got some shoe-blackiv’ fur me. I pounded on an ole tin pan tocall the scholars together. Ob, how I longed to bear the sound of the little bell at this school! The colored folks ina city hke Atlanta don’t begin to know what ‘tis for dem poor darkies to live way off in the country, so fur from any churches or schools, an’ ob, so awfully poor. When they git money to spend anywheres tbey’re cheated. They don’t know anythin’, ’specially how tocount money. They is hundreds of um jes’ dyin’ and wastin’ away ail the days, ’kase they can’t get to learn “bout Jesus.” At this period a certzin white lady in the room requested the school to favor ber with the popular melody ‘“ Golden Slippers.” After a long and somewhat ominous silence, a girl in the rearof the large chapel slowly arose and said: ‘‘ You'll have to excuse us from singing dat song “bout ‘ Golden Slippers.’ We don't consider dat very religious.” The “experience” of Sopbronia Heard, who told us that she had learned how to carry her- self, and instead of yielding to the influence of a certain “sinner-map,” pamed Smuitb, had “converted” him during vacation; that of In- diana Turner, who bad mastered the multiplica- tion table, and was as pretty, interesting, and lady-like a young woman as one would care to meet anywhere; that of Missouri King, whose superstitious notions were a source of perpetual amazement to herself and pitiful amusement to the more enlightened; and, last but not least, the personal and private reminiscences of Miss Bug, who, after a really sad recital, plaintively sang— **Don’t be like de foolish vergens when dey came, when dey came, “For dey bad to go and borry when dey came,’, etc., etc,,and then led in the depressingly hopefu, chorus, in wbich the whole school joined: ‘* What can wash away my sins? ‘Nothing but the blood of Jesus "— all combined to show how great, and indeed how imperative, 1s tbe call for missionary work among the colored girls and women of the South. ELLA A, GILES, Odie ances

Page 11

Nhat PR INR pn i i 2 4 5 x oy ree wT Peete wT LAS aan OF eS thy Sa. a ee Correspondence STATE AND LOCAL TAXATION. To THE EpiTror OF THE NaTION: Srr : It would be wellif Mr. Blaine’s letter asto the disposition of the Federal excise tax upon h quors should lead to a reform or a revolution of the present methods of State and local taxation. They are very onerous. Although direct, they do not meet the economic conditions of direct taxation. They violate at least three of Adam Smith’s fourcanons, They are not umform, nor do they promote the economy and vigilance in public expenditure whicb the economists claim attend direct taxation. Every taxpayer in your city and State will doubtless grant that. If there is a surplus Federal revenue, reduce the taxation that produces it. Thatisa plain case. There is no surplus revenue so long as there is a national debt and interest charge. There is, I believe, no proposition made by acy free-trader for any tariff system that would not yield enough from customs to pay the expenses of the national gov ernment economically conducted. So there is no need to take alarm at Mr. Blaine’s suggestion as though it were a plan to bolster up protection, or to maintain the collection of a surplus revenue by distmbuting it among the States. The American people now raise easily froma tax on liquors, cigars, tobacco, etc., one hundred and forty-five millious of dollars a year for their Federal needs, and onerously, by a so-called div rect tax, about an equal amount for their State and county needs. Does not the ease of the one method and the burdensomeness of the other suggest that the former method can be well and wisely put in place of the latter now, or when the former is no longer needed by the people for Federal purposes? I ask your aid to bring this —the only material phase of the subject in my opinion—before public attention, because you and your correspondent, Mr. Bourne, are chiefly insistent on that view which makes the proposed plan a distribution of surplus Federal revenue among the States. It thus becomes, and 1 think wrongly, a present and revived form of the plans to distribute the proceeds of the public lands and then of the treasury surplus which unprofitably occupied and perplexed the atten tion of Congress and the country from the ad ministration of the younger Adams to that of Tyler. The American people should be as willing to use Federal as State or local methods of doing anything if the former are the best. If Federal metbods are the best for maintaining an excise tax on liquors, cigars, tobacco, etc., for State and local purposes, those methods should be adopted, and the officials of thesystem should be elected by the people in the respective districts Every Federal official should be elected save the judges. A local election of officials would obviate all dangers of centralization from this method of collecting a revenue. Sam. M. CLARK, KEOKUK, Iowa, Dec. 17, 1883, POLITICAL ALGEBRA, To THE EpIToR OF THE NATION: Sir: Tbe Administration bas recommended a policy which indicates the dictation of Wall Street bankers and the complete ignoring of the ** exploded heresy ” known as ‘‘the Ohio idea.” As a citizen of Ohio [ would like to ask whetber this new policy does not bear the marks of a re- actionary spirit. The Comptroiler of the Currency, after show- ing that 4 per cents have risen until it barely pays national banks to retain their charters, proposes to repeal the tax on circulaticn and allow acirculation of 90 per cent. on the market The Nation. value of the bones. Here we have & system which reguiates the amount of currency by a fluctuating standard, and insures contraction as the market value of the bonds descends to par This same system has the still worse feature of converting the Government into a= stock-ex change bull. It is impossible that money in vested ine4 per cents should pay better than If these bonds could remain at 121 the national banks would be ena money invested elsewhere. bled by the Comptroller's proposition to realize a bonus of $2,023 per annum instead of $46. This is shown by the following table: Given 100,000 of 4 percent. bonds having ) Yolg years to run Annual inter S40 Cir, #0 per cent. on market v ‘ $1 Deduct 5 percent. redemp. fund id $1 t $103,455 loaned at 6 per cent t ; Total receipts $1 Deduct cost of redemption & 0 “L238, of premiun iM Fert P Net receipts $9,283 $121,000 loaned at} per cent 7 yet Profit on circulation $° If 4 per cents, as in times past, rise until they are no more profitable for investment than other securities, we can find by a simple aigebra ic calculation what they will soon be worth Let y represent the market value of £100,000 of bonds. Then $4,000+6 perce. of 85.5 perc. of y—30 ~ oar (y—100000 ) = 6 per cent. of y + 46 Working out the equation, we find that y= $159, 55. Under the proposed laws, therefore, 4 per cents at 159%. would be as good an investment as they now are at 11. lf the Administration would concede that there was a certain amount of common sense in the ideas which received the assent of Tburman, the support of Pendleton, and the whole souled devotion of Ewing, I hardly think they would propose to repeal the tax It is the national credit which gives value to our currency, and the nation ought to reap the benefit. Some of us in the West cannot help calculating that if one per cent, bonds were made the basis of cir- culation the national banks would still bavea } bonus. Verv respectfully, CHAS, B. SPARR OUR COAST DEFENCES AND THE NAVY To THE Epitor oF THE NaTion: Str: In his cown Nation on the su ation in 61 of the of the pavy, Mr. Chap pel seems to have missed the point of the quota tion he makes from the letter from **Cc. H. 8.," in No. 957, and proceeds to demolish a theory which was not advanced. ‘C. H. S.” merely said that ‘‘the well-known defenceless state of ourcoasts . . . would lead to an attack on our rich maritime cities.” The Is Dothing in this about ‘‘a European state insporting an army sufficient to retain” them. Such But tbe fact st‘ll + + these cities are unpprote & propo sition 1s absurd remains that and that an ar mored fleet of moderate power uld enter any one or all of them and sail away unmolested, after exacting a heavy indewnity, which all the strength of this rich republic would be powerless to prevent in the present state of its navy and land fortitications. In IS79 the Ad miral of the English Mediterranean Squadron said toan American naval officer that inthree ‘ration of war between tbe United States and England, fleets would ap- pear before our great Atlantic cities demanding not money alone, but wheat and flour. Under such circumstances we should lose in a day the cost of an efficient navy five times over. Far weeks after a dec better that the premium on our national insur ance, as your correspondent aptly term should be spent in yearly instalments in build ing a navy, and so paid to American artisans for American sbips, than that it should be paid down on the nail toan enemy vering our cities with his guns. Granted thats a ‘state of things is extremely improbable Wa 5 never improbable ; this historv teaches teaches anything, and in war it is ¢ pss which takes place. * The United Stat ht not to ind ‘ persuasion that, contrary to the order of } an events, they will forever keep at a dista thos painful appeals to arms with which tt . ‘ of other nations abounds If w to avoid insult we must be able t | 1 we desire to secure peace { the “ erful instruments of our ri ‘ must be known that we are at all ¢ ‘ for war.’ This is as true to-day as wt Wa said it ninety vears ago. W hav from the civil war a dangerous cont ! | South had no naval power at a no var which to build ships, no works t tt when hostilities commenced 1 Nort ad nearly a vear in which to prepare, at heterogene us fleet f vessels f every from an ocean steamer t s Fulton { These served their purpose and were s half their cost when the war was o1 The progress in naval science tn tt t tw \ years is greater than in t tw ceding, and measures which w feasible in S61 would be useless now I cisive point of a war of tay * tirst few months There will | t war is upon us to think of ins ‘ 1} Peace is the time for that Our national defences are a star against us. Our forts are worthless ‘ would be as effective against modern arn i vessels as bean blowers the hands bovs Our navy is composed 1 few slow solete wooden corvettes We do not: i « ! A NAVY as several of the Furopean nat S 6 to consider if necessary to suy rt We hav no outlying « nies to protect, no vig eign policy to sustatn, no possible enemy o1 t borders. We require an armored fleet of fl cient defensive strength to protect I ist cities, and swift cruisers powerful e1 gh of fensively to destroy the enemy's miner time of war, and protect our own in time of peace. They should be equal to any vess f their kind in the world. The latte «s Ww give us an ample number of ships for yx cruising, the former a reserve capable in a few weeks of passing from a peace to a war f in short, a navy that wouli be efficient, one that would require no increase in the number of officers now allowed by law, but a slight one in the present force of enlisted men, and at no greater annual cost to support than is now ap propriated yearly by Congress for the purpose. In case of a foreign war it would be on the navy unt of the fighting must fall The personnel of our naval scrvice is equal to that of any in the world. Our cfficers are a patri otic, well-educated, fine body of men. Lhey only ask for modern weapons to fight a modern war—weapons that they will not be ashamea of and with which they will bave some reasonable hope of winning the battle. E. B. R BETHLERTM, Pa., Dec. 10, 1885, DECAY OF SPRUCE IN THE ADIRON- DACKS AND NORTHERN NEW ENG LAND. To THE EpriTor OF THE NATION : Sir: The suggestion of your correspondent in last week's Nation that the spruce throughout the

Page 12

526 greater part of the Adirondack region is dying so fast that the region will be bereft of its tim- ber through natural causes much sooner than by cutting it down for lumber, is certainly a strong reason why no lumbering should go onin that region at all. Onthe other hand, the own- ers would do well to send lumbering parties into the Adirondacks to cut down the dead tim- ber, and thus prevent the further spread of tbe disease, whatever it be, whether constitutional to the tree, climatic, or entomological. When our spruce forests suffer thus, the best treatment would appear to be to clean out the dead and dying trees allow a new growth to springup. That this would be worth trying may be seen from the following historical so as to facts: During the years 1878-80 large tracts of spruce and fir on the coast of Maine, from Portland to Warren, were killed outright by a little cater- pillar known as the spruce bud-worm, The trees died en masse over large areas, The dead trees have by the more intelligent owners been cut down and used as fire-wood. The injury was most marked on the shores of Casco Bay. It now appears, from statements made to us by a clergyman of unusual powers of observation, and loss of a fine forest of spruve on his own woodlands, and was sbrewd enough to at once cut it down and sell it for fire- wood before it got too rotten—it now appears that the same woodlands were, early in this cen- tury, ravaged by the same ora similar cater- pillar. According to two farmers well known to our informant, the spruces of Harpswell and Orr’s Island were destroyed by worms in 1807. This was during the embargo, when no salt could be had. The owners of the woodlands turned the dead spruce and fir to good account. For six weeks they toiled, cutting down the trees and using the wood as fuel to boil the sea- water, and thus supplied themselves with salt. who suffered the As we have reason to know, those woodlands were thirty years ago covered with a flourishing growth of valuable spruces, many of them a foot in diameter at the butt. It is thus a fact that when spruce trees die down over large areas, by removing the dead or dying trees, leaving the healthy and slightly affected trees, and especially the young small trees and shrubs, a new growth will certainly spring up within thirty or forty years. This treatment,if applied to the valuable spruce forests of Northern New York and New England, will, it seems to us, certainly save these forests from This, if we mistake not, has been the remedy applied in Europe. But to add to the calamity by lumbering in these spruce forests would be folly. It would be the total and irretrievable destruction of these val- uable possessions, to say nothing of the conse- quent partial dying up of the sources of our rivers, and the diminution of our water power, A. 8. PACKARD, JR. I., December 20, 1883, otherwise bopeless ruin. PROVIDENCE, R. OTHER-WORLDLINESS, To THE Epitor OF THE NATION: Sir: It is Leigh Hunt who says (see ‘ Religion of the Heart,’ published by John Chapman, Lon- don, 1853, page 60) : ** Other-worldliness is the piety of the worldly. It is the same desire for the advantages of the world to come which the world)v-minded feel for those of the present, and it is manifested in the same way.” This, in answer to your correspondent from Easton, Md., who, in your last, questions cor- rectly the soundness of Dr. Phelps in ascribing the invention of the word to Lowell, who can ————————————————— [Number 965 The Nation. well afford to resign this one word to a brother- poet. W. O. WHITE, BROOKLINE, Mass., December 21, 1883. TO THE EpIToR OF THE NATION : Sir: Mr. Stearns is right in tracing “ other- worldliness ” as far back as Coleridge. Heury Crabb Robinson, in his Diary and Correspond- ence (II., 215), quotes the following sentence from Allsop’s ‘ Letters of Coleridge’: “As there isa worldliness, or too much care for this life, so there is another worldliness, or other-worldli- ness, equally hateful and selfish.” Respectfully, ROLLO OGDEN. CLEVELAND, O. Notes. THE English Publishing Co., 23 Park Row, having made arrangements with the London publishers, will begin next week the reissue in this coun- try of the Fortnightly, Nineteenth Century, and Contemporary Reviews at half the price of the original editions. Under the title of ‘English Rambles, etc. (Boston: James R, Osgood & Co.), Mr. William Winter has put together some pleasant letters recently written in England, and bound with them a number of agreeable verses, many of them of the ‘‘ occasional” kind. The art of fower-painting is one which, if fol- lowed as a specialty, demands thorough botani- cal knowledge, so far as flower construction is concerned, and tbe rendering of the specific cburacters. This may be done through either of two methods of representation, that of pure local color unmodified, of which Japanese flower-paint- ing is the’ best example; and that which gives the actual optical color, 7. e., the local tint as in- fluenced by light and shadow, reflection, etc. The former is, for purely scientific purposes, unques- tionably the best, and that in which the artist is least likely to fail from want of aztistic training, although the results of the other method, when thoroughly successful, contain all that botany requires, with an added grace of art. But it requires a sense of color of the great- est delicacy, and a training which, when obtained, does not often leave the artist in the flower-garden. To attempt a compromise between the two, as does the painter of ‘ Flowers from Hill and Dale, by Susie Barstow Skelding,’ is certain to accomplish but mediocre results. To follow a pure local color through varying sbadows and never disturb its purity, is not so easy asitseems, Of the still-life painters who accomplish it, the English William Hunt is the master. To give, in place of true fone color, a deeper shade of the same finf, as the painter of these flowers does, is one of those compromises which must be relegated with good intentions unfulfilled. The publishers (White, Stokes & Allen) have made a showy holiday book of them, which is also produced in the fringed Christmas-card form, each number containing four plates called ‘ Fiower-Song Series,” and each plate being accompanied by appropriate selected poems, the whole of the parts being pleasant gift books, but not reaily artistic work. Painting on porcelain is becoming a popular amusement with us, and a little book care- lessly entitled ‘China Painting,’ by Florence Lewis (Cassell & Co.), will serve to introduce to the technical mysteries of that branch of deco- rative art those who already know something of painting. Itspatterns are carefully executed chromos, which perhaps serve as well as any on paper could, but which will not show what troubles the beginner most, the change of color in firing. Thetaste of using realistic design in purely decorative work is debatable, but we do | | | | | | | not accept it as in accordance with the best tra- ditions and examples, or with the rationale of decorative art. Such work, to perform its func- tion, must avoid all pretext of utility, and not try todo what it cannot do better than can be done by other methoes, The best decorative art the world has yet seen, and the best schools of decoration to-day—the Japanese, Chinese, Persian, and Indian—employ designs either geo- metric or conventicnal. This is owing toa sound and correct taste (not to use the disputable term ‘‘art-ipstinct”). Naturalism is almost una- voidably the death of that freedom and play ful- ness which ougbt to be theelement of true deco- rative design, and good ornament is consistent with the widest departure from nature. John Wiley & have issued the last two numbers of Ruskin’s Fors Clavigera. ‘** Dust of Gold” (apparentiy a reply to sundry hectoring letters, from young women who fear that they are plain, about the Jate number in which he prescribes seven beaux for every belle: ‘* What are plain girls to do ?”) and ‘‘Ashestiel,” a medley on Mungo Park and Sir Walter Scott. As the truest picture of the man Rus- kip which be bas ever permitted to be published, Fors Clavigera merits study of a more serious cbaracter than it has generally found. Tbe November Portfolio comes with two bril- liant and exceptionally good etchings, one of the interior of Westminster Abbey, a good specimen of printing as well as etching; the other, of “Meadows at Marlow on the Thames,” by Brandard, a plate which distinctly betrays the taste and traivuing of a line engraver. The arti- on Glasgow and Ravenna are needlessiy weak in the illustrations, and that on Parisian arcbitecture very well illustrated as usual. The Magazine of Art for January (Cassell & Co.) contains, as usua!, a large number of wood- cuts not notable for apy superlative quality. rhe most taking article is that on Carlyle, with all the known portraits, of which the only good one (as rendered) is Boehm’s statue. Whistler’s portrait is villanously mistranslated. The frontispiece is a block-photcty pe print after Burne Jones's **Evening Star”—more interesting as reproduction than as picture. The uncovering of the new facade of the Duomo at Florence took place on the 5th, ac- companied by immense enthusiasm. The con- clusion of this really admirable work, so long awaited, and which effaces one of the most an- noving distigurements of Florentine architec- ture, will as a whole be a great pleasure to visitors to Florence, whatever exception to the ensemble may be taken by the anti-restoration- ists. D. Appleton & Co, have issued a revised edition of their ‘ Hand-book of Winter Resorts,’ which is well calculated to give one a general survey of the field if not to determine one’s choice. Those who have visited Monterey (Cal.) will find the account of it bere given an understatement. If the editor, too, will read the last report of the State Geologist of New Jersey, he will perhaps feel justified in grouping the resorts of this State by themselves, as in the case of those of South Carolina, Florida, etc.; more of them, at least, ought to be mentioned. Grace Greenwood has provided American girls with a volume of interesting and healthful reading, in her life of Queen Victoria in the “Exemplary Women ” series (New York: John R. Anderson and Henry S. Allen). If exem- plary means suitable toseive as an example, it may be asked whether the surroundings of royalty may not so far obscure the native elements of character, that the book, however entertaining and instructive, will fail of its direct moral purpose, This can only be an- swered by giving the book atrial, The autho Sons cles here ? ee _ Goce nthe ea eee! De Pe oe i ny ee ete

Page 13

| 4 s > ST a eR AE onli tae ths ie ta Ce Dien ahd OBS cdi abe. Dec. 27, 1883] The Nation. §2'7 herself, in the preface, expresses her opinion on this matter with excellent sense: “I have done my work, if lightly, with entire respect, though always as an American and arepublican. 1 could not do otherwise, for, though it has made me in love with a few royal people, it has not made me in love with royalty. ] cannot but think that so far from its be ing a condition of itself ennobling to human character, those born into it bave often to fight to maintain a native nobility—as Queen Victoria has fought, as Prince Albert fought for I find the ‘ blameless Prince’ saying: ‘ To my mind, the exaltation of royalty is only possible through the personal character of the sovereign.’” These words of Prince Albert express the spirit in- which the work bas been done; and they indicat also, we think, the real greatness of Victoria as a queen—tbat, for almost the first time on a large scale and for a long series of years, the morai standard of pri vate life bas been carried into the government of a great nation, and given it its character. A statesman of Mr. Gladstone’s type is a fitting outcome of the Victorian period. The book, if it sometimes aims too directly at liveliness, 1s always entertaining and ina good spirit. One can bardly open at a page without being drawn ou to read further. There are three portraits of Queen Victoria, one of Prinve Albert, and one of the Duchess of Kent, mother of the Queen. To teach athletics to the British nation would seem presumptuous on the part of Americans. The London firm of Sampson Low & Co., how ever, bave bespoken of the Messrs. Harper a set of plates of Mr. Blaikie’s new manual for home and school, ‘Sound Bodies for Our Boys and Girls.’ Information comes to us from England that Mr. R. H. Shepherd proposes tu issue shortly a reprint of the now very rare Boston Is27 edition of ‘Tamerlane and Other Poems,’ in which Poe’s poems were for the first time collectively published. Not more than three or four copies are known to have survived an untoward fate. Mr. Shepberd’s edition is limited to 100 copies. A work deserving the attention of students of art history isthe finely iliustrated historical study by J. Rolland, on the Catbedral of Ste. Cécile, at Albi, France (Toulouse, 1855), This cathedral, which contains some rewarkable art productions, including statues of the Apostles, and a painting of the Last Judgment, was begun during the troublous time in the Albigenses country about 1282,under the Bishopric of Bernard di Castanet, and completedin 1583. Many of the paintings and decorations show an Italian influence, some as late as the fifteenth century. The massive construction of the building, with its donjon-shaped towers, bas a decided military aspect. The building has lately been restored, andthe admirable photographs accompanying the work show it in allits primitive beauty and grandeur. Outing and the Wheelman have become one— the latter absorbing the former, and remaining a very handsome and ieadable magazine (Bos- ton: The Wbeelman Co.). We regret to read in the Atheneum Belge for December 15 an announcement of the discon- tinuance of that excellent journal, which has had a modest but useful existence fur six years. Its continuance by other hands, the editors hope, is assured. From across the water comes the news that the publication of the British jcurnal of as tronomy, Copernicus, is to be discontinued. This is much to be regretted, as Copernicus has held a unique place among scientific journals, the ps pers and articles which it contained being such as were found in no other periodical, and, more- over, being invariably of a very high order of excellence. The reason given for its discontin- uance is that the editors cannot find contributors, and if this is the case it surely is a sad com tentarv on the present state of astronomical science in England. The great comet which appeared in the autumn of ISS. is destined to take its place among the most remarkable of these celestial Visitants, and it is satisfactory to know that per manent contributions to its literature are be gipning to appear. The most recent of these is a quarto paper by Mr. William C. Winlock, assistant astronomer atthe Naval Observatory, in Which he bas made a careful discussion of all the observations of this comet taken at the Naval Observatory, and arranged them in the most convenient form for future use. The paper is illustrated with several plates, contain ing drawivgs of the nucleus and head of the comet, and with diagrams showing the manner in which the observations for position were made. These diagrams will be of much value, as the chief dithculty in investigating the orbit of this comet bas been due to the fact that different ob servers used citferent parts of the nucleus to ob serve on, and in many cases failed to mention the part which they used. A remarkable lately in this city. it is vothing new that a auction sale occurred large and valuable library should be accumu lated in Providence, vor that it should be sold by auction, But it is new that the owner of such a Collection of books should give five thousand dollars’ worth apiece to ten libraries to be bought at the sale. The effect of the innovation on the prices was striking, and probably not foreseen by the donor. Ten dange: ous competitors were added to the usual number of buyers at such sales. Modest of the libraries to whom the bequest was made were poor, and would, in the ordinary courseof things, not have sent any bids, It is always doubtful whether buyers at an auction have a right to agree not to bid against one another; in the present case it would have been in the highest degree dishonorable. Accordingly no such agreeinent was made. The ten beoeficiaries bid independently, and, as each wisbed to spend the whole of his tive thousand, and felt afraid that if he did not secure sumething early he should be left in the latter sessions with much money and few books that he cared to buy, the bidding was active aud the prices unusually bigh from the very start. Many books brought from fifty to a bundred per cent. above their market value—that is, ordinary books, for the great rarities were not extrava gantly dear. The consequence is that the ten libraries find that their nominal five thousand dollars has brought them about three thousand dollars’ worth of books, for which it would be only human nature that they should not feel quite as gratefulasif it had been called only three thousand at the beginning. The arrange ment was an experiment. We sball be curious to see if itis repeated. It seems to bave worked chiefly for the benetit of the auctioneer. —Harper’s for January opens with three good illustrated articles, ‘The Quaker Poet,’ with a portrait of Whittier, by Harriet Prescott Spofford; “‘At Mentone” (first instalment) by Constance Fenimore Woolson, and * The Old Packet and Clipper Service,” by G. W. Sheldon- There is very little critical or essayistic writing except in the “Easy Chair,” from which post of observation Mr. Curtis discusses several topics of the day, among others that of popular city government, If we havea bad government, he says, it is because we do not care to have a better one, or even ‘‘to try to have” one, ‘‘No device can supply the want of public spirit,” This is true enough, but on the other band public spirit can not be pumped into a city by demonstrations that the city would be the better for a larger supply of it. Public spirit, like private spirit, grows ofa feeling that political work will tell, w produce results. New York political evnicist which among certain classes is pretty d seated, is the product of experience, and as such deserves respect from those who bave a regard forthe Veracities. Has the New York by the way—the amiable cvn who believes not merely in the general corruption of the tines but that corruption is the motive power by which the citv is carried on, and that the very reformers who get up ‘citizens’ movements” a Wass Meetings are Dot themselves beyond s piclon—has this type ever ber put t ‘ novel Mr. E. V. Swmallev bas in tt very good account of General S wm, Ww name will undoubtedly remain as greatest produced by the war I King k to that period, itus bard t rary impressions produced by believe that the time when | Was bea little out of his head by : “ the critical moment in which he wa ing his right to the title of reat * Husbandry in ul Times by Edw Eggleston, is ao good illustrat aniong th serials 1 t re magazines wil l surprised t i concluding number of ‘The Breada ers \\ sav surprised, because tt story were broad enough to suggest a lounger novel lies inthe portrait of Maud Mat t i that had not before made its way Asa product of American | M 1 isar sive figure The o1 attraction is r i The other respect for ber parent {Y as itis by her supert als ri smiatte ing of knowledge, ber gree { I eV r jewels and dress and irriage-ridit luxuries that money implies), het mate vulgarity nake her mor lious than many a character of amor! nventionaliy de praved sort; and vet it cannot be denied that the author h result of conditions of life bardlv to be found anywhere except in this untry Phe Forty Immortals” of the French Academy (ty \ D.") is a good illustrated article, and among the pen letters will be found a disputation 1 good old subject of ‘‘New York as a field fiction.” by Mr. W. H. Bishop and Mr. H junber. After all, the only way to solve this problem is that which bas been adopted in all large cities—to try it. This both these gentk men have done, and for that very reason we are the more surprised that they should care much about the question in the abstract. No amount of critical writing will ever convince usthat New York is really a good field for fiction, as the appearance of a thoroughly good New York novel wiil. —Mr. Henry James contributes to the Janu ary Atlantic some pleasant reminiscences of Turgeneff, of whom he saw a good deal in Paris. A strange and interesting figure he seems to have been in the little literary coterie of which he wasasort of honorary member, and in no thing stranger, evidently, than in his lack of vanity. Mr. James is so much at home in Paris, he sees things so easily and quickly from the Parisian point of view, that he noticed in Tur- geneff just what his French friends probably noticed—besides other matters of which they would have taken no thought. A genius with ' out vanity, a man “impersonal ” to the point of

Page 14

N28 The Nation. === : ——— heing far more interested in the subjects he dis- cussed than in his own relation to them, remain- ed to the last something of a mystery to most of the clever but decidedly ‘* personal” Frenchmen with whom he associated. He was in truth, as it is easy to see from his stories, more of a poet than a literary ‘‘artist.”. His poetry was that of buman character and destiny, and it is inter esting to learn that he had no methodical system of novel-writing, but was inspired, as we fancy many gieat novelists have been before him, by What first presented itself to bis mind was not a plot or story, but a living buman being, out of whose character a naturally None but ge- his characte1 dramatic povel evolved itself. biuses can write in this way. In Thackeray, in Flaubert, we recognize the breed to which Turgeneff belonged. little practical interest in the George Eliot, in He seems taken flerce strife over literary theories which shakes to have Paris to its centre from time to time, and wrote without any theory simply what came into his head. Doctor Holmes has a poem on the Satur- day club, which recalls the days of Agassiz, Emerson, and Lorgfellow, and might be taken as a text for the next article on the ‘‘ decadence of Boston.” Certainly a great change bas come over Buston since their day. There are Darwin- ians and Evolutionists where the great Swiss naturalist used to stand; there is a lecturer on Emerson who denies him the first place as a phi- losopher, and as for poets, the Boston seems to bave nearly died out. The feeling that race in the niches left vacant will never be exactly filled is a very natural one; but what is called the de- cadence of Boston as a literary centre, i. e., the failure of any signs of a new intellectual growth comparable to the old one in the hold which it took upon the popular imagination, is a phe- peculiar to that city, but one which extends all over the world. The general modern industral feeli-g that literature is a poor sort of business to be in, and one which does not pay, accounts for it in part. As we leave New England and go west we find this nomenon Dot anti-literary feeling stronger and stronger, but inthe last twenty years it has begun toaffect even Boston very powerfully, and to lead the young Bostonian to look upon a life devoted to things not material more, perhaps, after the manner of the bright Chicago drummer than he would have done a There is some- thing very silly about writing for a living, when geveration ago, you cousider how muca you bave to write, and how poor a living you get, and how much more rapidly and easily you could succeed if you would drudge for a few years at dry-goods, or, better still, get the right ‘‘ points” in stocks. Mr. Louis Judson Swinburne has an article on ‘Matthew Arnold in America,” in the last num- ber of Lijpincott’s, in which he insists upon the importance of Mr. Arnold’s visitas that of the lirst gevuine critic who has been overhere. The function of criticism isso doubtfully regarded by most of us that bis trip bas already been pro- ductive of much comment of a curious sort. Che early generation of travellers who came to this country and afterward amused themselves shing accounts of what they had seen g i by publi critics in the sense in which we now employ the word. From Mrs, Trollope to Dickens, they brought with them not a desire to “‘ see the thing 4s it is,” but to compare what they found they had been accustomed to at home, aud with what we promised they should find and their prejudices, favorable or unfavorable, played a most important part in their mental equipment. Mr. Arnold,on the other hand, is what may be called a cosmic critic of the modern school, whose only prejudice is against prejudice itself. The number of people in the entire world who really believe in criti- were not with what here ; cism of the cosmic sort is very small, and probably smaller in the United States than in England, and in England tban in France or Germany. Mr. Norman Pearson writes on undergradvate life at Oxford, and gives a curious account of the way in which he says the ‘ Tom Brown’ literature has reacted upon the tendencies of manners at Kugby: ‘ The Rugbeian cbaracter is of a very distinct and is ‘Tom Brown’ pushed to a morbid* excess. The ideal set up in that admirable book is that of an Eng- lish school-boy par exce/lence—sturdy, straight- forward, truthful, firm to his principles, and witb an honest scorn of anytbing mean or trick- In the Rugby school-boy of the present not always very agreeable type. It some, day these qualities are apt to degenerate intoa certain priggisbness, combined with an arrogant contempt for the feelings and opinions of others, an unpleasant roughness of manner, and a habit of flat contradiction which verges on the inso- lent.” — The November number of the Antiquary contains the second part of an article by Mr. G. Lawrence Gomme, upon “ Primitive Agricul- tural Implements.” The purpose of the article is expressed in the speaks of the instructiveness of a method of ar- chological study which traces ‘‘ step by step any branch of culture or opening sentence, which the development in ‘bis idea is carried out by tracing of agricultural implements, the bronze, industry.” the development first in the stone age and then in Both papers have interesting engravings, those of the second part being especially so. One il- lustrates a method of described by Pliny and Palladius, in which a sort of cart, with a toothed edge, is pusbed by an ox against another, a process of reap- reaping, the standing corn ; ing depicted in an Anglo-Saxon manuscript. An article by Clapton Rolfe upon the coloring of illuminated manuscripts vindicates the accu- racy of these against a newly advanced theory. The argument rests mainly upon the fact that the illuminvations give, in ecclesiastical vestments, only the five colors which are known to have heen employed in England for this purpose— gold, blue, purple, red, and white. Two arti- cles, one of them by J. King Watts, contain in- teresting facts in relation to early land tenures, ete.. and an anonymous article proposes in ‘* Measure for Measure,” Act iii, Scene 1, the reading “deleted spimt” for delighted, An ar ticle by C. E. Keyser describes the various por- trayals of St. Christopher in England. The Revue llistoriqu »forSeptember-October contains an article by M. Xenopol upon the ori- gin of the Rumanian or Wallachian people—a subject which bas been ardently debated since the publication of Rosler’s treatise in 1871, which undertook to prove that these people are not the descendants of Trajan’s colomsts in Da- cia, but migrated across the Danube from the South in the thirteenth century. This theory has been generally accepted by German scho- lars, altbough it has always appe ared to us un- satisfactory: a population of 3,000,000 in Hun- gary alone, to say nothing of Rumania, is not so easily accounted for by a mizration which has neither distinct record nor adequate cause, Neither is it easy to believe that a community which bas occupied a territory 150 years should disappear from itso completely as Rosler’s tneory assumes to have been the case. The Romans struck deep roctsinevery country which they oc- cupied, and when we find in the nineteenth cen- tury several millions of peovle, speaking a lan- guage of Latin derivation, in a country which the Romans held for a century and a half, it would require the most positive evidence to make us believe that there was no connection [ Number 965 between the two facts. M. Xenopol shows in this article that there is no such overwhelming weight of testimony, and, in fact, tbat there is pretty good evidence of the persistency of the Romanized population during the Middle Ages. He considers the opposing arguments in detail: The fact that the Rumanians have the Bulga- rian form of Christianity he explains by their country having formed part of the first Bul garian kingdom (ending 1018); the Slavonian character of the Slavic el+ments in their language (ratber than Ruthenian), by the same circumstance ; the paucity of Dacian or Roman proper names, by pointing to the names of several rivers, and especially of mountains. Names of cities would, of course, not be preserved by a which took refuge in the mountains, but it is noticed that the Rumanians give to the cities of Transylva_ nia their Slavic names rather than the German or Magyar, from which it is inferred that they occupied the country after the Slavs entered it, and before either Germans or Magyars came. Che Albanian elements of the language he attri- butes to the native Dacians of Thracian or Al- banian race; and, in fine, he adduces several al- lusions to Wallachians in this region which seem inconsistent with the alleged migration. The same number of the Revue contains the sec- ond and concluding part of a very valuable ar- ticle by M. Fustel de Coulanges upon the Im- munities of the Merovingian period. alleged people A year and a day ago we called the atten- tion of our mirth-loving readers to the oddest of all eccentricities in book-making, namely, the ‘Schlau, Schliuer, am Schiiusten’ of C. M, Seyppel, or the tale of King Rhampsinitus and his treasure-house, printed on torn, stained, al_ most mouldy leaves, as if an Egyptian fiod of remote antiquity. The success of this ‘* Egyp- tische Humoreske,” with German verse, and its screaming illustrations after the Nile monuments, bas inspired a still more elabo- by the same artist and its comical rate joke, ‘Er, Sie, Es,’ the same publisher (Disselacrf: Felix Bagel ; New York: Westermann). In the present case, Seyppel bas abanduned Herodotus, and trusted to his own wit ip inventing a sequel to his for- mer work, He (in the person of a would-be poet laureate, ready to lampcon the reigning mon- arch if his ambition is not gratified) tells how the clever thief who married the daughter of the late Rhampsinitus contrived to obtain a pleé- biscite in his own favor, as against bis wife, for the succession to the throne. A final spree on the eve of bis coronation involves biim in perils requiring all his craft to extricate bimself. In the civil dissension Arimsa/ ucts as moderator, readily recognized as Bismarck by the three The fun 1s very good, but the ingenuity is not quite spikes on his helmet and by otber signs. on a par with that of the legend of Herodotus, Tbe archeological wake-up, however, even sur- passes last year’s performance, particularly in the cover, which is an excellent imitation of mummy cloth, and bears a solid green seal of King Ruppsippos (the “ Er” of the story). Dr. Georg Ebers, in a published letter, testifies to his enjoyment of this burlesque, all the more because of its fidelity to Egyptian art. Carica- turist as he is, Sey ppel here and there—as in tbe picture of Ruppsippos crawling tbrough the drain, and in the laughable design et the very end of the book—indulges his sense of beauty, which may never, however, win him greater re- nown than his invention of this extraordinary mode of “illustration.” —The large attendance at the first concert for young people, which Mr. Theodore Thomas and his orchestra geve on Saturday afternoon at Steinway Hall, proved ttat there was a real $ i | ! ' ' a i ry

Page 15

a bietias De ih ln tenets Sate

Dec. 27, 1883 / “

demand for such a series of entertainments. The audience consisted of young and old ebil dren in about equal proportions, and all the pieces on the prcgramme were wel comed with signs of appreciation. There i: plenty of pianoforte music specially designed for youtbful performers and bearers, but for the orchestra the range of juvenile literature is not extensive, and the programmes have to be chosen, therefure, from the standard works of the great masters, preference being given to what is graceful in melody, simple in harmony and rhythm, and, if possible, connected with some tangible image yr story which facilitates comprehension. These characteristics were found in Saturday's pro gramme, which was as follows: Overture to ‘* Preciosa”; Larghetto, Beethoven's Second sym phony; an aria from ‘“ Magic Flute”; Scherzo and Wedding March, from ‘* Midsummer Night's Dream”; ballet air, “Paris and Helene” (Gluck); Waldweben, from Wagner's ‘Sieg fried.” The Beethoven and Waguer selections might seem at first sight rather “keavy” for children, but they are not. The larghetto is as simple in melody and structure as one of those fairy tales, of Grimm or Andersen, which old and young alike appreciate; and Wagner's Waldweben is such a realistic translation into tones of the idyllic scene where Siegfried lies under a_ tree and histens to the rustling of the leaves and the twittering of tbe birds, that no one cvuld fail to appreciate this tone-poem. The vocal numbers were sung with clear voice and distinct enunciation by Miss Amy Sherwin. None of the children showed any signs of fatigue to the end of the pr gramme, and the best proof that the concert was appreciated was shown inthe mannerin which the ticket-office was surrounded at the close for seats for the next concert, which will take place on January 12, at 2 p.M. It will consist of the fcllowing programme, which Is, if anything,even more appropriate than the first: Overture, ‘*Magic Flute”; airs de ballet from Gluck’s ‘‘Orpheus”:; Allegretto, Beethoven’ Eighth sympbony ; Schubert songs (Miss Ella

Earle); Weber-Berlioz’s ‘‘ Invitation to Dance” Rossini’s ** Tell” overture : variations on ‘‘God Save the Emperor,” Haydn: Schumann’s *‘ Two Grenadiers” (Mr. Remmertz); Gounod’s * ral March of a Marionette”; Strauss’s ‘* Blue Danube Waltz.” JAMES’S WILD TRIBES OF THE SUDAN, The Wild Tribes of the Soudan: An Account of Travel and Sport, chiefly in the Basé C Being Personal Experiences and Adventures during Three Winters in the Soudan. By F. L. James, M.A., F.R.G.S. Dodd, Mead & Co. Fune ountry. THE appearance of this book at this particular time is certainly very opportune for the author and the publisher, Alleyesare turned towards tb Sudan, to see what new move will be made by El Mahdi and his horde of fanatical followers. Every one is anxious to know all that can learned about those savage tribes which could, in asingle battle, completely destroy an Egy] tian army of 10,500 men.oificered and cominand ed by Englishmen of rank and distinction, And if the book we have under consideration con- tained any information concerning the country and people of that part of the Sudan which ts the field of the False Prophet’s operations, the author’s apology, in his preface, ‘** for adding another to the numerous books of travel that have been written during the last few years on Africa,” would be entirely unnecessary. Unfortunately, however, for the reader in search of hnowledge of the Sudan, the title is

‘The Nation. misleading and deceptive in the highest degree The mongrel people which our author very sparingly describes, are really not Sudanese at all. Th are a very insignificant tribe dwell ing ina border land which lies between Atys Sinia and the Sudan Abyssinia is a high mounta is plateau region The S hisa vast re n of mvers and plains, deserts and jungles, which extends frem the Nile indefinitely westward, and mprehends ma $ and peoples tween thes twe 5 s hilly broken country, in a part of wt iw the Ba Like their « ntry, thev area balf-and half-race, the result of a mixture of the Abys lians withthe real vegroes of t ‘ terior, with perbapsasmallinfi nof l i in their veins Phere are ! ilar tribes the vicir f At The Bogos tr { the Shobos, who bit tl try between the northern ] vinces Abys a and the Red Sea ist ( I ! f M wa tVeryv simuary] ! ited and similar in appear waube! and general iracteristics | bor tribes, living thus between I . | 1, nomin i Coristian Abyssinians the e side, and t rafty, w rar 1 t decaying Mohammedan Arabs the I joy the ur Viable } ono rvsort of buf fers between nation powers greater t! themselves The Swis rs ewhat s lar circumstances, bave been compre i and consolidated into a n h rene I whose internal strength bas been alt to resist centuries of external attriticn TI \t ean border tribes, on the contrary, are g } into a kind of ethnical powder, and are almost entirely devoid of tribal ce ‘ As M James says of tl every mat ind is against them, and their hand ay, . \ they are not 1 1 gy t 1 can ba! yt sa V ze i x ele Sut when tl n} wits i i Vv i S Possess I i! of certain characteristics V are designated by a comm tribal nan Ss are t Bas whose « try r auther \ ‘ i t during three His sons for se their try were twofold { ise W W peop ind t ta, No shman had ev \ tex t iMr. Powelland his wife.w were murdere . tl crea is t I 4 i whicl red Mr. J s and i! t table FT ! t r I nd ted was that the untrs Pad . and was 1 shot \ t sw other parts Af v “ S atti tive | > Ard > i ‘ s : = t f the 1 7 t l eV ! t sias \ . \ in th i i . \\ i \ - i i pos se sé r y va >, W s 1 Ss ad it . . v v fa t wl roved t i : sev fi t ret é < ? < XI I ea s le f Eng } s q f Arab att j s Ca ~ thet te Suak acd g z ofca s, horses t rs il S, a stlers, and r g at 8 with allthe usual hi drances and avscaused by haggling traders Wit f s s readers of African travel are fauuliar a s¢ But we are CH © “~~ wr

I t f as i t { t " A 1 \ } ts vel ‘ iii " ( nil f t brigt to be rea but dis lu of t part s hile t { Ab nians bh 1 ivor to 4 ( ind feolisbly asign of peaceful inten Aby lans pounce upon ree ip tbe hunters of dsome of their clothing, who offers some resist whole party about in a But thev ange tor SCA pA jus assailants, and make

Page 16

The Nation. [ Number 965 Here confusion and Camel-drivers their way back to camp. fear reign supreme for a while. are about to stampede; guides are grumbling: servants are trembling. The Englishmen suc- ceed in restoring order, but find in a few days that it is inexpedient to remaiu longer where they are, and impossible to advance, So their steps are retraced toa station named Haikota, about three days’ march from Cassala. From tbis point the party moves across the country to the Settite River, and spends three weeks more in hunting and fishing, the Settite being a beauti- This part of the narrative interesting, but it is gone before to From the Set- made to ful running stream. is perhaps the most too has it. long and tiresome journey nearly a repetition of what justify an extended notice of tite a 1s Massowah, via the Egyptian posts of Amideb and Keren or Sanheit. Such isa brief outline of Mr. James’s storv, We to of the manner and style in which that story is told. Briefly, it is very badly told. The descriptions of scenery and topography are not at all graphic, shall now have something say though the excellent woodcuts, made from pho tographs taken from nature, show that a real easily been stirred toenthusiasm in making pen-and-ink pictures. lover of nature might bave The account given of the Basé tribe is altogether inadequate, considering the fact that Mr. James the first European to make Even the bunting experi- remarked, form the burden of the book, are told in a sty le claims to have been their acquaintance, ences which, az has been already so tame and halting that one feels grieved that After reading Captain Cumiming’s spirited descriptions so good material should be so badly used. of his famous hurtivg exploits, one follows Mr. James’s feeble narrative with a feeling of impa- tience. Sir Samuel Baker, too, not only stot well, but wrote well, and carried his reader with a rush through his bardy adventures. It is true, some critics who knew Sir Samuel well declare that the accounts of his deeds are too highly colored, or are even apocryphal in some Yet no one denies that bis books are very Mr. James's style is often cases, entertaining reading very clumsy, sometimes even ungrammatical, and generally colloquial and inelegant. The publishers’ part in the manufacture of this book is, if we except the more gaudy than tasteful cover, worthy of all praise. The paper and print are both excellent, and few palpable The illustrations are generally beautifullv engraved. typographical errors mar the letterpress. The maps are well executed, and the one con- taining the author’s itinerary through the Basé country contains some new and valuable geo- graphical information. Rollinson Whittingham, of Maryland. By William With portrait and facsimiles, 1Ss83. Life William Fourth Bishop Francis Brand E. & J. B. Young & Co. THE interest of these almost exclusively for Bishop Whittingham’s co religionists, and more particularly for such of these as are more deeply interested in ecclesias- Bishop or 2 vols. bulky volumes will be tical than in moral and spiritual things. Whittingham was an ecclesiastic in every fibre of his mind. Whatever of personal, social, or do- mestic interests he may have had, they were sub- ordinate to his ecclesiastical vocation. Such, at any r is the impression that we get from this biography. But the reason of this may be that his biographer was attracted to him mainly on the ecclesiastical Certain it is that be has given us hardly a glimpse of any otber. We f of official correspon- or and we have hardly ate, side. hundreds pages have denee, memoranda, ete., anything besides. The life of Bishop Whittingham had a remark- able consistency. He wasa Nazarite from the The impulse of his character and career came from his mother, a woman of remarkable abilities, who assumed the sole responsibility of shaping his wind, resenting any interference, and she never abdicated her original position. So long as she lived she claimed the first place the in his affairs. Unable as a child to enjoy her Christmas pres- this in- religiosity marked every period of her It is aston ishing that he was ever able to hold an active womb, in his affections, first voice ents because thinking ‘‘ We must die,” tense life and was transmitted to her son. and influential position among men, his child- hood and his youth were nursed in such inviola- ble Seeking entrance to the theolo- gical seminary, he was asked at what college he seclusion, had graduated, and answered, ‘‘None;my mother has always taught me.” ‘‘But who taught you Latin, Greek, and Hebrew?” continued the ex- aminers. ‘‘ My mother,” he replied. At this time he is described as being nearly six feet in height and very thin, wearing a round-about jacket and a wide turn-over collar, making a most unclericaiappearance. His fellow-students were at first inclined to laugh at him, but his genuine manliness soon compelled their admira- tion, The account given of his wedding-day is as characteristic of the mau as any passage in his It wason the 1th of April, 1850, He arose ” biography. when he was twenty-four years old. at a quarter after five, and after exercises of de- votion read the last of Bishop Ravenscroft’s ser- mons and commented on it. After breakfast he drovefrom New York to Orange, New Jersey, witha friend, the two conferring as they went “on the test of Christian standing from St. John v. 30, and also on the power of grace in the destruction of evil tempers from Luke iv. 33-36.” Arrived at Orange, he spent an bour at the piano with his parents and sisters. After dinner he wrote out a sketch of a sermon on ‘“ Overcoming evil dispositions through the grace of God,” ‘thus fixing the thoughts of the forenoon.” Then he visited a sick parishioner and solaced him with prayer and Scriptural exposition. The re- mainder of the afternoon be spent alone in meditation and prayer. In the evening he wrote a sketch of a sermon on ‘The example of Christ,” finishing it just in time to proceed to the marriage ceremony at the church. At the wedding supper he obtained from a hesitating parishioner ‘‘ an almost promise to receive bap- tism, anda full acknowledgment of the neces- sity of so doing.” Here we have in little all the sphere of the good Bishop's life. Holding an office to which the taint of worldliness has frequently attached, a less worldly man than he, it would be safe to say, has never been a servant of the Church, He was narrow in his culture and his sympa. thies, but he brought to his ecclesiastical labors au entire devotion, an unwearying consecra- tion. The temper of the man was as ascetic as that of Dominic or Francis; its habit different from theirs only because he fell upon a different time. His abjuration of the ‘‘pomps and vani- ties” was no verbal matter. Not only the theatre but the oratorio he denied himself, as not tending to edification. Here was a nine- teenth-century Puritan, an American Calvin, who would fain have made his diocesan rule as strict as Calvin’s at Geneva. But he was a Puri- tan with a difference. He was very far from Puritanism in bis delight in ceremonial obser- Romanizing tendencies, so called, were He mag- Houses vances. conspicuous in his speech and action. nified the ritual and the sacraments. of religious celibates found favor in his eyes. His earliest work was for the Sunday-School | Union. A rectorship in Orange followed; then work in New York at denominational editing and publishing, andthe rectorship of St. Luke's. An incident of bis labors here was the great fire in New York, on which he preached a sermon for which a captivated listener gave bim $20,000 cash for charitable purposes. Sickness, threat- ening consumption, drove him abroad in 183 for fifteen mouths. He came back to a theologi- cal professorship, which he exchanged in 1840 for the bishopric of Maryland, and he held this office till his death, October 17, 1879. He was born December 2, 1805, The Maryland bishopric was no sinecure. Its affairs at Bishop Whittingham’s coming were iu the most depressed condition. Gradually he brought order out of chaos, and established a cule that reflected ample credit on his adminis- trative ability. When the civil war broke out he threw himself cautiously but firmly on the Union side. A reviewer of these volumes in the American Church Review wishes “that the re- cording angel might drop a tear upon this epi- sode of Bishop Whittingham’s career and blot it out forever.” But to many it will wear a very different appearance, His biographer is careful to inform us “how utterly he abborred that spirit which was cherished as philantbropy and called abolitionism.” Yet he held that the white population was wore injured by slavery than the black, and the slaveholding portion most of all; also that its abolition was impossi- ble, “and its attempt in any way by tbe North, an enormous crime.” Here was an astonishing position fora man to bold, But more astonish- ing was his assertiov that while holding slavery to be a great social evil, the wisest and best of the Southern people had “no hope of its beng removed from their posterity.” The war was not for him the dawn of such abhope. It was not slavery but secession that put the South in the wrong, and justitied national coercion. The Bishop’s thinking here was of a piece with all his thinking: authority, prescription, custom, tra- dition were his ultimate foundations. To finda rational basis for doctrine or conduct was no part of his ambition; but what seemed to bim right, for any reason, to that he beld fast. His adherence to the Union cost him many friends. He would not have swerved if it had cost him all. So immersed was Bishop Whittingham in ec- clesiastical affairs that his life, by whomsoever written, could not have been very interesting to the general reader; but his present biogra- pher bas made the worst of a bad matter. His style belies him if he does not hold that the use of language is to conceal our thoughts. A judi- cious writer could have made a book not half so large as this which would have helped to make the Bisbop’s fame endureawhile. This is a pre- mium upon the waters of oblivion, for except by a few ecclesiastical Dryasdusts it will not be read. Telegraphic Determination of Longitudes in Japan, China, and the East Indies; with the Latitude of the Several Stations. By Lieut.- Commanders F. M. Green and C. H. Davis, and Lieut. J. A. Norris, U. S. N., in 1881 and 1882. Washington: Government Printing Of- fice. 1883. THE earlier geographic work of Lieutenant- Commander Green and his parties, in determin- ing with modern precision the longitude and latitude of a large number of points on the globe, chiefly in the West Indies in 1877, and on the eastern coast of South America in 1878 ana 1879, is well known. He has now added very largely to his already enviable record by the publication of the results of his later labors,

Page 17

tan Dec. 27, 1883] which establish the precise positions of a dozen eastern Asiatic stations with a probable accu- racy far exceeding all the demands of vaviga- tion, and which will meet the needs of astrono- my for a century to come. The longitudes of very nearly all the promi- nent positions in the East Indian Archipelago, and on the shores of the China and Japan Seas and the Western Pacific Ocean bave been referred by surveyors and hydrograpbers to one of the following points, viz.: Singapore, Batavia, Ma- nila, Hong Kong, Shanghai, Nagasaki, and Yo- kohama, the accuracy of the chronometric meas. urements from these central points to the various capes, islets, mountains, towns, light-houses, and other prominent positions,some 35,000 in number, leaving little to be desired, were the longitudes of the initial points exactly known. Unfortu- nately this has not been the case. The longi tudes of these secondary meridians, which have been accepted for the last forty years, have de- pended mostly upon observations of moon-cul mipations, made doubtless with great care, and with the best appliances available at the time, but liable, in common with all such determina tions, to an uncertamty of from one to four minutes of arc. This uncertainty has, of course, affected in an equal degree all chronometric meas- urements from the meridians in question, and longitudes have consequently been sbifted back ward and forward by hydrographers of differ- ent nations on their respective charts, according as a greater or less weight was theoretically at- tached to various determinations of the initial point. The proposed publication of new charts of the China Sea, on a large scale, by the Hydro- graphic Office afforded an additional induce- ment to attempt the removal of the uncertain- ties attending the longitudes in this part of the world; and the completion of the measurement from Europe to the Atlantic ports of South America having liberated the instruments used for that purpose, a party of officers was organized by the Chief of the Bureau of Navigation in the winter of 1880 1881, with the object of deter- mining telegraphically, from one or more es- tablished meridians, the longitudes of the points in Eastern waters from which American, Eng- lish, French, Spanish, and Dutch surveyors had made several thousand chronometric measure ments. This work bad been urged upon the Navy Department by the National Academy of Sciences by resolution at its April meeting in Washington, in 1880, The established points were at Madras, in sritish India, and at Vladivostok, on the Sibe rian coast. The observatory of Madras bas been for many years the point from which the longitudes of British India have been reckoned. The position of Suez was determined witb great care in 1874, by the English transit-of-Venus as- tronomers ; and in 1876 and 1877, officers of the great triconometrical survey of India connected Madras with Suez, through the cables by way of Aden and Bombay. The cables of the Great Northern Telegraph Company in Eastern waters extend from Vladivostok to Nagasaki, Shanghai. Amoy, and Hong Kong, while those of the East_ ern Extension Company join Hong Kong, Ma- nila, Cape St. James, Singapore, and Madras, a branch extending from Singapore to Batavia, and to Port Darwin on the northern coast of Australia. In pursuance of the execution of this work, the necessary instruments and were despatched from New York to Yokohama by way of London and the Suez Canal, to avoid the frequent crans-shipment of the trans- Pacific route, and arrived safely in Japan in the middle of April, 1881. The U. 8. S. Palos, a small gun- boat attached to the Asiatic Squadron, was se- observatories The Nation. lected to transport the officers and instruments from port to port, and Lieut.-Commanders F. M. Green and C. H. Davis, and Lieut. J. A Norris, were detailed to make the observations, permission having been previously obtained from the companies owning the telegraph lines to use them for the exchange of time-signals, and from the various governments to set up instruments and make astronomical observations at the re spective points. It is not a little remarkable that, standing repeated applications notwith regarding the subject, the officers of the Japanese Government authorita tively as the prime meridian of Japan. A per manent monument was, therefore, established on the grounds of the United States Naval Hos pital at Yokohama, in such a position that when the meridian is decided upon, it can be con veniently and precisely connected with the chain of measurements, neglected to designate some point The first exchange of signals took place between Nagasaki and Yokohama on May 27, dSS1, and the last measurements were Madras and Singapore, forming the completion of a chain 6,450 miles in length. Tbe prime meridian of India passes through the observatory at Madras, and the kindness of Mr. Norman Pogson, the Government astronomer, greatly facilitated the made January 27, 1882, between connection of this long chain with the Indian meridian. The uniformly generous courtesy with which these officers of the American Govern ment were attended is handsomely acknow ledged by Mr. Green, and is worthy of especial note here: “Our experience in other parts of the world,’ he says, ‘‘ nad prepared us for a cordial rece; tion and efficient assistance at the bands of the gentlemen in charge of the various telegraph cables, and our anticipations were nos in the least disappointed. Not only was every assist ance given in the execution of the work, but at stations away from the cities, Where the officers would otherwise have been obliged to live very roughly, the kindest hospitality was extended to them. The names of all to whom acknowledg ments are due would include a complete list of the officials of the cable companies at each sta tion, . . . The fact cannot be too strongly expressed that without the zealous and perse- vering cooperation of the telegraph officials, no such undertaking as this can be successful, and no one Without absolute experience can realize tbe discouraging delaysand difficulties which woul be almost msurmountable without the cordia assi-tance of the members of the cable staf **[t may not be out of place to state that the completion of this report terminates the associa tion on duty of the three ofticers who bave been principally engaged in the work, and who have successfuliv carried on similar undertakings together since IS77, two of them since S74, Without the shgbtest misunderstanding breach of perfect harmony.” The conclusion of Mr. Green's lot in the Eastern seas affords a result of no incor siderable moment, as illustrating the ac with which distant positions on tbe globe are telegrapbically determinable. The cable-lines through Madras, Singapore, Hong kK hai, and Viadivostok, emploved by Mr. Green, give for the longitude of this last station Sh. 47m. 30.92s. Viadivostok bas also been rea Europe telegraphically across the of Siberia, and its position determined in IS75 by Colonel Scharnhorst, of the Russian Engineer Corps, to be Sh. 47m. 31.528. The ditfereuce of the measurements by Siberia and by India thus is 0.59s.—a discrepancy of no great magnitude when the inevitable difficulties of the work and the vast lengths of longitude-chains are considered. Mr. Green has pretixed to bis volume a chart of the world, showing in an admirable way the principal lines of submarine cables f used for longitude determinations by all the different governments which have been engaged in such enterprises The globe has now been measured in arc, with a degree of accuracy closely approximating to modern instru east of west), the limit attainable with the ments, from Yokohama about 140 Greenwich) to San Francisco (about 1% leaving thus an are of somewhat more thana quadrant, across the Pacific Ocean, still to be tneasured to complete the entire circuit, Slavonie Literature By W. R. Morfill, M.A Published tee of General Literature and Education, uy under the direction of the Commit pointed by the Society for Promoting Ct tian Knowledge. Londot ISS Pais little book heation, } +) lish literature, for, as the authy “there is nothing in our lapguage on the sub sa verv tuvely and iseful pr It supplies a deeply felt want in En except the work of Mrs. Robinson (Tals put lished in INDO, at New York, which is now out of date Mr. Mortill treats of the “Classification of the Slavonic Ra of thei ture “ of the * Nomenclature {the “Early Litera Russians, the Mal Russians, t and Slovenes together forming eastern branch of the Slavs the “Karly 7 ture” of Poland and In Saxony and Pr: at ter of the Wends net Pola a t lower Elbe anc bes on the subjects are the gt opment of the various Slavic lar lore, and their earliest iMerary Compositions these exclusively —and the real title of | to be found inthe ruuniz tle, * Ear Literature On the title pag however, the word " Ear y ” has been dropped is work is Vv Slav a serial bead Dawn of European Literature placed above the tithe. Advertisements shorn t any a peader and pur haser anxious t tain information about the and the master} esof Lermontoff and nVshevski, Mickiewi and Krasinski, or other famous Slavie A lives Puspkin, Tolstot and Teher Writers of he. Such a pur ito bis surprise that the works of these autbors are completely ignored, but will ver that the lt k contains sound *Coristian knowledge” fully worth the price, and much curious information about things he never dreamed of. For Mr. Mortill has executed his ‘compilation from original authorities ” us dllizgerce, and with ec: mipre hensive linguistic and hterary fact. if he bas erred, it is by learning. In presenting to the ‘ non reader t n that interesting only to tl assiduous student of Slavic lore. His sources are the vVerv best, and his topics well selected, but he is t fond of names, original terms, and titles His unrbymed translations of Slavic songs are neatly executed) Among them are two gems f Serb popular poetry, ballads referring t the fatal battle of Kosovo, or prop- erly Kosovo Polve (Blackbird Field), in which the army, the King, and the independence of Servia perished by the sword of the Turk. The date of this battle, rectiv given ** the 10th « June 15, 1389, is cor a p. 8, on page 15s it is changed into f June, 1583." We have noticed sev eral other slips, mostly owing to careless re vision—such as ‘tFa/merayer” (page 3) for Fall merayer, and “Sinews” (page 26) and ‘‘ Sine- us” (page 2S) as identical names—but they are not numerous. The author has made a very laudable attempt ‘to speil the proper names of those Slavonic nations which use the Cyrillic alphabet on a fixed and accurate plan”— which is very rarely done, as we have repeatedly pointed out in the columns of naturally “ this journal—and has retained the original orthograpby ” of ‘‘the names of those Slavonic peoples who use the Latin alphabet.” But the want of the neces-

Page 18

~ sary diacritical marks used by the Western Slavs —which it is surprising that the publishing so ciety did not find means to procure—compelled him to use such misleading spellings as ‘* caso- tchasopis), and ** Jagic” for Jagié (pronounced yayhit)/). Why for Slavic, while pis” for éasopis (pronounced he invariably uses ** Slavonic” he constantly uses “ Slavs,” which was formerly avoided on account of its un-English termination, It ing to this constant use of ‘‘Slavonic” for Sla- we are at a loss to explain. IS, perbaps, Ow- vic (Ger. Slavisch, which is different from Slaiwo- nisch) that he serupulously refraios from intro- ducing Slavonia proper (S/awounien) among the countries and districts inhabited by the Slavs, covering it by the Croatia, Austria, each in its widest sense. references of the author On page 2, Northeast- always term Hungary, or The geograpbical are altogether very lax. ern Hungary is forgotten as one of the seats of the Ruthenes (‘‘ Rousines”), and the Serbo-Croats are made to inbabit the “ Principality” of Servia, following a Russian author who wrote before Servia became a kingdom. According to page 6, “the Russian language is hemmed in on the west by Polish, Magyar, and Rumanian, on the south by Little-Russian” ; but Russian, in the sense of Great-Kussian, in contradistinction to Little-Russian—as here spoken of—is hemmed in west by the latter idiom, and separated by it from both Magyar and Rumanian. On 39, Budais explained to be *‘ the name of one of the parts of Pesth called for and incorrect: Buda and Pesth form now one municipality, the capital city Buda- Pesth, but neither is a part of the other, and both may be presumed to be equally well knuwn to page ” an explanation equally un- readers of so learned a book as the one before us* Political Recollections : 1840-1872 W. Julian. Chicago: Jansen, McClurg & Co, 12mo. by George Mr. JULIAN was one of the earliest of the anti- slavery men who took the question into politics by the organization of the old “ Liberty Party.” He was also one of the first who gained a seat in He continued an active and honorable career in the Republi- can party down to 1872, when he supported Mr. Greeley for the Presidency, and has since con- tinued to act with the Democratic party, though he has held His therefore confined to the time when he was in Congress upon anti-slavery issues. no office. * Recollections’ are close relations with those whom he now opposes, and was among the most unsparing of the de- nouncers of the principlesand policy of those with whom he now fraternizes. The publica- tion of this book is very good evidence, however, that he is not ashamed of his earlier career, and sees little in it to regret or apologize for. A few casual admissions that he was probably led by partisan heat to judge too harshly of some things, are the only indications that he has changed his point of view. This is honorable to him, for it implies that bis present political atti- tude does not seem to him inconsistent with his former one, and that he looks upon the political questions of to-day as so different from those of twenty years ago that party lines cannot be quite the same, or have the same significance. Mr. Julian was always a man of strong opin- ions, and has a vigorous and generally clear way of stating them. His loves and bis hates were also intense, It is quite natural, therefore, that we should find the story of his personal share in the conflicts of his active career spiced with sketches of his great contemporaries, in which they are painted with the colors they had to him, and not always those in which their own friends would have presented them, It 1s plain, for instance, that no love was lost between him- ' The Nation [ Number 965 self and Governor Morton. together in tbe same district school in Indiana, t They had been boys but their friendship turned to rivalry when Ju- | lian became an Abolitionist, while grew into a Democratic politician. Morton was never thoroughly “reconstructed” in his eyes, or, if so, it was but a short time before Julian | himself learned to look upon the work of the Re- publican party as done. Morton’s hostility within the party was hardly less galling than his opposition when they were in rival camps, the picture of the “ great war Governor ” is not unfairly drawn, and will be of use in helping the reader to form a true conception of the man who is placed by his friends almost too bigh for frail humanity. Interesting incidents concerning Lincoln, Thaddeus Stevens, Stanton, Chase, and other contemporaries are pleasantly told, and are worth a place in the literature of the time. The judgment of history will hardly give Mr. Julian credit for the sagacity and leadership which he perhaps feels should be accorded him; but bis book will be found a useful narrative of the per. sonal experience of a public man with just claims to consicerable prominence. It some- times tries too much to be a history, and so loses something of the zest of autobiography without grasping questions and events with the strength which real history demands. The line may not be easy to draw, but the reader becomes conscious at times of the treatment being some- thing short of either style of writing. A fuller stock of personal incident might easily bave been gathered, as it strikes us, and the work would have been improved by it. The history would then be chiefly the assumed thread on which the narrative would be strung, and we should not have the sense of disappointment that we have mentioned at finding the historical questions unsatisfactorily discussed. Index Canonum, the Greek Text, an English Translation, and a Complete Digest of the En- tire Code of Canon Law of the Undivided Primitive Church, Second edition, revised and enlarged: with a Dissertation on the Seventh Canon of Ephesus and the Chalce- donian Decree of Doctrinal Liberty. By John Fulton, D.D., LL.D., ete. New York: E. & J. B. Young & Co. 1883. 1 vol. 8vo. It is creditable to American theological scholar- sbip that so learned and purely technical a work as thisshould have been called to a second edi- tion. Yet we cannot but regret that the pecu- liar views of the author should have forced him to limit its usefulness by restricting it to those councils of the early Church which he regards as having been rendered binding on the whole body of Christians by the decrees of Chalcedon. The distinction practically is factitious. The canons of Ancyra, Neo-Cesarea, Gangra, Antioch, and Laodicea, which he admits, were never respect- ed by the Latin Church when it chose to disre- gard them; while the proceedings of the local councils of Africa and of the West, which he excludes, are quite as interesting as the others in the light which they shed upon the organiza- tion and customs of the Church. obtain an acquaintance with the development of doctrine and practice without an attentive study of the whole; and if Dr. Fulton had extended his scope to that of the excellent and convenient manual of Bruns—‘ Canones Apostolorum et Con- ciliorum Sece. iv.-vii.’--with an alphabetical di- gest of subjects on the same admirable plan which he has applied to bis more limited selec- tion, he would have performed a work which would have entitled him to the thanks of al] scholars, Morton | No studentcan | From this larger enterprise, however, he is excluded by the very object aud purport of the work, which seems, from his Preface, to be the proving that all the subtleties of orthodox theo- logy are useless; that the definit ons of the really cecumenical councils —the only ones under the un- disputed guidance of the Holy Ghost—concerned themselves alone with the nature and divi- nity of Christ; that, consequently, this the only tenet necessary to salvation in Christ, and, therefore, that the largest liberty of conscience and freedom of thought may be safely enjoyed by Christians who hold to the Niceno-Constantinopolitan symbol, difference of views upon all else being comparatively unim- portant (pp. xxi-vi.). So far as it goes, Dr. Fulton’s object is a most praiseworthy one, and if he could persuade the chu:ches to adopt it the world would be spared much objurgation and unseemly cousigning of fellow-Christians tothe bottomless pit. Yet it is not easy for a lay- man to enter into the frame of mind which evables a theologian to decidein detail what was meant by Christ’s promises that the gates of hell should not prevail against His Church, and that he would send the Holy Ghost to guide His Church unto all truth (pp. xii., xiii.). The latter promise, especialiy, would appear to be so gen- eral in its character, that it seems rather a beg- ging of the question to decide ex cathedra that it did not refer to historical truth, or scientific truth, or truth about tbe creation, or even truth about the authorship of the canon of Scripture; and it is, perhaps, an abuse of the argument by exclusion when we are gravely assured that it is thus proved that the definitions of faith by the General Councils are not merely the absolute truth, but the whole truth. Neither can we exactly share Dr, Fulton’s pious exultation when he contemplates the wisdom of Providence in divinely preserving the Cathu- lic Church from all doctrinal aberrations by pre- venting the holding of any real General Council since the Third of Constantinople, and thus pre- ciuding any definitions of faith, since the seventh century, by an authoritative body acting under the guidance of the Holy Ghost. To use his own words (p. xxi.): “The way in which the provi- dence of God actually has saved the Church has been by suffering the holding of General Coun- cils to become impossible. Thus the wrath and sinfulness of men hus been made to subserve the safety of the Church.” This new utility of schism and error is well worth recognition, but perbaps the mnumerable multitude of souls which have incurred perdition through this schism aud error would have preferred to be preserved from it by occasional Gene- ral Councils, which, under the operation of the Holy Ghost, could certainly not have im- perilled the safety of the Church. In fact, it is not easy to determine in what consists this saving of the Church, or how it has enured to the salvation of mankind. There appears to be some mysterious entity, known as “ the Catholic Church,” which “ alone bath not erred, but bath been wonderfully saved from error.” This, as well as we can make out, consists of the whole body of Christians ; but in this case the whole is not the sum of its parts, for all its parts have erred, and thus have not been saved from error— “as the Churches of Jerusalem, Alexandria, and Antioch have erred, so a'so the Church of Rome hath erred, avd the Church of England hath erred.” We part from Dr. Fulton with the sincerest re- spect for his learning, and for the objects to which he devotes that learning, but we greatly fear that bis methods savor too much of the sixteenth century to produce their wished-for effect upon generations that baveso far outgrown them. It will require other arguments than his to reunite is

Page 19

Dee. 27, 1883]

ing sects, and to bring about the reconcilia- of science with religion. Prometheus Bound of otes and an Introduction by R. H f Amherst College. 383. Ex hylus ; with Mather, boston: John Aliyn. [ .KERS of classical text-books are prone to for get the important difference between what be- longs in the text-book and what should be re- served for the class-room—between what a stu dent should have before him as he prepares his lesson, and what should be used to quicken his wits and broaden his views after the lesson has been prepared. Many editors put into their notes all that they have found useful in their own instruction. Theanswer to every question is given before it is raised, the clue to every diffi- culty is offered te the student before he appre- ciates the difficulty, and the appropriate illus- tration is presented before bis appetite awakened. His wits and his judgment are not properly trained. Elementary text-books have long been of the character which has been described. In orderto meet the wants of young men who are preparing 1s themselves for college, most of the common edi- tions of the ‘Anabasis’ of Xenopbon are ar rapged with full grammatical references and notes to explain all but the simplest construc- tions. They area system to teach * Greek with- out a master.” This is a great injury to the preparatory schools, of late vears, but there is fartoo much reciting and not enough teaching. Boys go to college without knowing bow to attack a difficult sen tence in Greek or Latin. Their commentaries have rendered it unnecessary for their teachers to instruct them in It is much as it would be if mathematical problems were fur nished with notes referring to this and that principle and rule whicb had been already stated, in orde: to enable every careful student to solve each problem without the teacher’s aid. Such text-books make possible wbat is known as a brilliant recitation—a fluent translation ready answers to all ordinary questions. Methods have improved methods. and They are popular with teachers and pupils. They re- duce the mental exertion and mental gymnas- tics to a minimum. The effort of conduct- ing a recitation where one of these books is used, is far less than that of leading the class on from principle to principle by the Socratic method, until the solution of tbe difficulty is evi dent. The books are sometimes made so perfect as to kill the recitation. to the notes more than gleanings of wisdom. Cramming upon the notes is the sole end of work, in'some cases, The recitation is madea mere examination to make sure that the notes bave been carefully studied. It is considered warm praise of a text-book to say that it bas brought the work within the comprehension of a learner; but this is the teacher’s business, not the editor’s. The editor should prepare the way for the teacher. Most of our college students have competent teachers in Latin and Greek, and the experienced teachers are the very men whose instruction is most deadened by too full information in the notes. Atypical example of exuberant text-books is the handsome volume before us, filled with matter with which teachers have been wont to interest their classes, The class-room origin of the work is manifest on every page in chatty sentences and fervid eloquence. appreciative smile of the class which woula greet the remark (when the ocean nympbs say that they have put away shamefaced molesty to visit the fettered Titan), that ‘this training by Few teachers can add simply } ~ sess We can imagine the quiet,

Oceanus of his children to be retiring and re lern spectful is quite in contrast with certain mi manners of the young’: and when, in another 560, he would tell them that in later the m of b Wives was reversed. ‘‘ In fact, parents were so anxious to dispose of their daughters that ors advanced in years were quite accept place, on v. ages in Greece Homeric cust ving able Se Such remarks and side-bits at toe modern ger tion are unappreciated in the quiet of a boy's study. The book evidently is intended t rium of our elementary knowledge of this play be a reperto } The editor is over-anxious to say all that « t an said, to leave nothing forthe teacher to do. This is rding t but it leads him to fields with which he seems t not only an error in itseif, ace be unacquainted. EF. y., « ‘Eschylus the arly in the | called by new pryfta f gods. This promptsa note which tells us about the prytanes at Athens (including some details which rested on the weakest foundation and wer refuted long ago), not considering that Zeus 1 represented not as one of a college of officers | those of Atbens, but as ruling alone as tl pry tanis did in other Greek cities, of which the note does not atford a bint A more striking ex ample of the working of the editor’s method ts where the Titan Prometheus, bated by tl 1s and bound in an untrodden wilderness, far f " the race of men which be has befriended upon the elements—the ‘swift-winged bi the ‘“ many-twinkling smile of ocean,” and the * all-seeing orb of the sun “—to behold bis wrongs This mention of the sun suggests to Pr . Mather a note on sun worship, and next t colussal statue of the sun-god at Rhodes, which he says was 7U feet (sic, for cubits) hig nda *t strode the barbor’’ By the shades ot Ly ' and Chares, in what attitude did the editor. ceive that statue of Helios The entrance t the harbor is something over 600 feet w at the narrowest place, anda statue 70 or even 105 feet high could bardly bestride it and preserve the grace and dignity of the sun-god \ lit ! t Vivid imagination in this case would plied the lack of the learning which we ex] It is almost unnecessary to add that at t authority countenances Professor Mat sex traordinary statement. In general, the editor's knowledge f ant quities seems very superficial. He says t Argus was “probably represented as a herds man with formonly dimly visible tot ence.” How that would be possible in the clear light of the Athenian stage it is not ey f understand. The introduction is filled wit! matter which strikes us as so strange that w the : special revelation, on gold pi: theatre. But the novelties are crudities cies, r wonder whether uthor bas not received the Greek we find that most of ir long-exploded fan say that it was Eschvlus w

the rude chorus quiet and refined, and in place of their boistercus, extempore effusions taught them regular dances and w r pr s to forget Aleman, Stesichorus, Simondes i the rest. The statement that G play was given tillit had met the app: select body of critics” is unsupported That certain cune f the theatre w : ail assigned * to women s s to he } ‘ an old edition of Becker's *( . t was refuted in IS4. That a part ar spot the centre of the stage “ was raised i was used in the most important recitative passages,” is cor trary to reason, and has po support ancient or modern authorities. That the “thymele was of square form, raised as high as the stag Was rendered in probable wl the r soft great theatre at Athens were ur vered, in 186 rhe editor seems to bave learned little from the ex- | —¢ 533 cavation of this theatre, as he knows nothing of the excavat sat Dodona Of new interpretations there are but few This is rhapst =s if hers we to be like that of v. O80. where we read her ad TI s addressed to Pr } by the el s whose | ity s! sed by t storv of lo, and thev wish to ay ia act with s in Aa Curst t Lt sit t sas f Ws Promett s bad been relat to the cl s the woeful fat lo until they break out Hold tl oC thy ta it say that they rs leht ¢ t tra a story s ld to their ea t such woes st i chill t ss Not a ‘ i ites that their ‘'y " The ¢ . whet { t ia ‘ i . “ ' t t ? { ‘ < l ba ‘ the play {rT t i Wie t s ‘ ‘ ‘ t } } t) t} pla tead of ! t ex . ef tot M u A" . s ‘“M Ils and Te Ss SALTY ‘ ! s 7! | ‘ It te the ft { rig i not ‘ \ nA t tor . t iw ! i) } eit yt { tt rh i bad tl t G Vi s Mat vers Vv AN “ f ¢ i . l b iy G } } 8 i ow hy ¢ +) ? t “ t n \ al f s < i nmi mu vet u \ Most erm w , ’ that < : t i . ( " i ( | 1 ? i n . es | OX 1 a s s Quouat ‘ I P. Lévy © ( ] \ Con t vr extracts If f Hewspayp« The ? 3} \ vised g ft l new } S ( 1 ed } Ww. T. defi t ; boss l s fia tfe A ¢ Bos Sel “s T ria te ‘ f ins f t pre t erat t ykKNOW : ¢ +) wes nong recent W shav i t pul itions of Ha x& ) as specimens of r al enter M. Levy, an inspector gen S ! nlanguages, who has iy f Germa n French s : i ti ling the principal Ge Stes ! eighteentl entury, bas prepared a German Jetters auto grat re} 1, in order to afford op ty f i ) reaging German script, be work t pages in a great variety fh writiog, embracing 208 letters, many of w ba facsimiles of communications from the! t familiar names in German literature. Excellent judgment has been displayed in se lecting the subject-matter. In the first part of the v me the usual assortment appears of invi- tations and announcements, episties of condo- lence, of inquiry and of apology, which one ex- pects to discover in the complete letter-writer; but many of the originals have become historic.

Page 20

534. The Nation. [Number 965 = Among the letters of reproach, for instance, one finds the well-known remonstrance addressed by Klopstock to Goethe in referen_e to the latter’s wild career with the Duke in the early days at Weimar, and Goethe's equally well-known in- cisive reply. The second part contains speci- mens of commercial letters, circulars, drafts and receipts, while the third part is devoted to mili- tary instructions, despatches, and orders of the day. signed by the Emperor William! is primarily intended for use in school at Saint-Cyr, as a kind of modern diplomatics; and we can conceive no more ready aid agreeable method of familiar- izing one’s self with the intricacies of German chi- Liévy’s collec is unique in The closing document is a facsimile order The volume the military exercise in rography tran by the use of M. tion, which, so far as variety and extent. The second work alluded tois intended to ac quaint the with the and style peculiar to current newspaper literature, and forms the companion toa similar work is- sued recently in French. Originally intended to acquaint the reader with the livipg language of daily life without the necessity of introducing the obnoxious French novel or the equivocal French journal, the latter publication was found to beso successful that its companion bas soon followed. The joint editors are two English scholars. It is a compilation of use to those de- siring to enter well as to those who wish to become acquainted with thecurrent vocabulary The style of the extracts is correct if not classic, and the variety is entertaining. Items from Klad- deradatsch, the Berliner Wespen, and other com- ic sheets, alternate with the more serious contents of the Kdlnische Zeitung and the Neue Freie Among the topics discussed are Cete- wayo's captivity, the Egyptian war, Garfield’s assassination, the Panama canal, President Ar- thur, the Irish troubles, and American strikes. Several pages of well-arranged advertisements conclude the selections. we are aware, reader vocabulary competitive examinations, as of the press. Presse, Henry Holt & Co. PUBLISH Champlin's Books FOR Young Lolks. CYCLOPADIAS OF COMMON THINGS. $3. PERSONS AND PLACES. §3 50. * Should be placed wherever children meet for study and reading.” —Doston Advertiser. HISTORY OF — 8vo, illustrated, $2 75. WAR FOR the Union. OUR FAMILIAR SONGSand those who made them. Edited by Helen Kendrich Jobn- son. Svo. 86 00. My December Monthly List OF Choice €& Rare Books and Prints will be sent to any address = B apeite ation. LINDSAY, 828 Walnut eure et, P hiladelphia. ' Bee TALOGUE for PRIVATE LIBRARY. , A blank-book of 240 pp., arranged with columns for entering Title, Author, Publisher, ete. Indexed through, alphabetic _y-. one = boards, with leather back and corners; size, *rice $2 50, post-paid. Sent, on receipt of pelos, B P ‘ublishe r of the Nation, The Story of My Heart. An Aut Richard Jefferies, author of ‘The at Home,’ etc. Boston: Roberts Bros. ‘ Wuat it has pleased Mr. Jefferies to call “an autobiography ” is actually a discussion of prob- lems in psychology, tive of personal experience. hy. By The ordinary read- under the guise of a narra- | mékeeper | er will hardly follow the passionate subtlety of | his arguments, but no one can read without ad- | miration his exquisite descriptions of nature. They have that wonderful accuracy and inii- macy of knowledge which made the author’s | remarkable, and they have something more. Choose which we may, the lonely splendor of mid-day on the great downs, or the crowded rush of mid London—‘‘ the vor- tex and whirlpool, the centre of human life to- day ”—they are all, we know not whetber to say earlier books so } | | | | exalted or illuminated by the intense desire to | surprise the secret of Nature, the mystery of | life. ‘‘ Full well aware that all has failed, yet, side by side with the sadness of that knowledge, there lives on in me an unquenchable belief, | thought burning like the sun, that there is yet something to be found, something real; some- thing to give each separate personality sunsbine | } | | | | and flowers in its own existence now—something | to shape this million handed labor to an end and outcome, leaving accumulated sunshine and flowers to those who sha!] succeed.’ THE VWEEK. Parts 105-112. B. BOOKS OF Brehm’s Thierleben. Chromo ed. Westermann & Co, Caddy, Mrs, Adrian Bright : A Novel lyn Square Library. Yo cents. Carrel, L. Rhyme? and Reason? #1 50. Christmas Folio: Music. Claretie, J. French Celebrities. nalis. 15 cents. Edward, Cardinal hood. Baltimore Encyclopedia Britannica. Scribner’s Sons. Genung, J. F. Tennyson's In Memoriam, its Purpose and its Structure 3 a Study. Boston: Houghton, Mif- flin & Co. &1 2 Goldsmid, E. “bibliotheca Curiosa. An Account of King Charles the Second’s escape from Worcester, From the Pepys MSS. Edinburgh: Privately Printed. Greenwood, Grace. Queen Victoria. Her Girlhood and Womanhood, Illustrated. John R. Andersou and Heury 8. Allen. Harper’s Frank- Macmillan & Co. Richard S. Saalfleld. 59 cents. Part Il. Funk & Wag- Archbis hop H. The Eternal Priest- : John Murphy & Co, Vois. xv., xvi. Charles P. TURNER & co.,| 50 THREADNEEDLE STREET, LONDON, F. C. ; A. 207 WALNUT PLACE, PHILADELPHIA, Pa. RAILWAY INVESTMENT SECURITIES. CORRESPONDENCE SOLICITED, § PHILADELPHIA STocK EXCHANGE. } NEW YORK STOCK F XCHANGE, TUtr -_ fT , Cc INVESTORS SHOULD CONFER WITH THE WESTERN FARM MORTGAGE Co., Lawrence, Kansas. First-Mortgage Real Estate Loans paid in New York: Absolute satisfaction 4 aranteed. For reliability, con suit Tnird Nat. Bank, . City, or Nat. Bank, Lawrence. Kan. Security large. Pint rest promptly paid. Send for pamphlet with testimonials, ns forms, etc. F. M. PERKINS, Pres. N. F. Hart, | L. H. PERKINS, Sec. J.T. WARNE, V.-Pres.| Auditor. | C. W. GILLETT, Treas Members RINCE & WHITELY, No. 64 Broadway, New York. (Branch Office, 180 Fifth Avenue.) All classes of Railway and Mining Stocks bought and sold on Commission. Private telegraph-wires to Philadelphia, Wilmington, Baltimore, Washington, Boston, Bridgeport, New Haven, and Richmond, Va. _ WN IssuE COMMERCIAL anp TRAVELLERS’ CREDITS For use in TuHIs COUNTRY AND ABROAD, BROTHERS & CO., 59 WALL STREET. | | } *Trumbull, Rev. Jenkins. 60 Charles oo ~ vy, L. L’Abbé Constantin. W. R. ts. en Koestlin, J. Life of Luther. Scribner's Sons. $7.50. Lawson, J. D. The Law of Expert and Opinion Fvi- dence Reduced to Kules. St. Louis: F. H. Thomas & Co, Lacy, W.M. An Examination of the Unknowable, as Expounded by Phiiadelphia: Be ajamin F. Lacy. Linton-Stoddard, nglish Verse : and Characters; Translations; Ballads and Ro- mances. 3 vols. Charles Scribner’s Sons, $1.00. Lorne, Marquis of. Memories of Canada and Illustrated. Philosophy of the Herbert Spencer. Dramatic Scenes Scot- land: Speeches and Verses. Montreal : Dawson Proth ers Lowe, Martha P. Memoir of Charles Lowe. Boston: Cc upples, Upham & Co Maudsley, Pr. H.. Body and Will: an Essay Concern ing Will in its Metaphysic al. Phy mologic al, and Patho- logical Aspects. D. Appleton & C¢ Metz, Prof. V. de. Hand-Book of Modern Palmistry. Thompson & Moreau. ar Tee J. O Abolicionismo, London: Abraham King- on. Oberholtzer, Mrs. S. L. Hope’s Heart — ° Romance. Philadelphia: J. B. L Ap pincott & Co One of the Shepherds of Bethlehem, A P + m. Pittsfield, Mass.: J. B. Harrison. Dtis, J. Kaising the #earl: a Story. Narper & Bro- thers. $1 “Ouida.” Frescoes, etc. yee Ske tches. Philadel- phia: J ri Lipp ine ott & Co. Owen, N. Her Second Love. hil: ade Iphia: T. B. Peter- son & Brothers. 21.00, Peterson, Dr. F. Poems and Swedish’ Translations. Buffalo: Peter Paul & Bro. $1 50, Reiss and Stiibel. The Nec ropolis of Ancon in Peru. Part 9. —— Mead & Co. Rhiter, F. L. Mt iwic in Eeoland. Charles Scribner's Sons. $1,50. Ritt r, F. L. Music in America. Charles Scribner's sons. $2.10, 0, Rolfe, W. J. Shakspere’s Tragedy of Titus Andronicus. Harper & Brothers. Ruskin, J. Dust of Gold. Ashestiel. [Forse Clavigera ; new series.} Jonn Wiley & Sons. 10 cents each. Scott, Sir Walter. The Surgeon's Dauchter. Philadel phia. T. B. Peterson & Brothers. 15 cents. "a mer, G. H. Ww here Did Life Begin? Charles Scrib er "s Sons. $1 2 Seyppel, « M. Er, reske. Diisseldorf : Felix Bagel. Skeiding, Susie B. Mapie Leaves and White, stokes # Allen. $1.50. Skelding, Susie B. Songs of Flowers. White, Allen, $1.40 Souvenirs d’Amé¢rique et de France. Par un Cr ‘ole. Paris: Bourget Cales; New York: F. W. Chvistern. Stewart, Mrs. G. E. The Burnhams: a Novel. G. W. Carleton & Co. Thiersant, P.D. de. De VOrigine ces Indiens du Nou- Sie, Es. 4to. Agyptische Humo kod. £ tokes & Golden veau-Monde et de leur Civilisation. Paris: Ernest Leroux. Thomas, Annie. Jenifer: a Novel. Harper & Brothers. 20 cents Townsend, Gen. E.D. Anecdotes of the Civil War in _D. Appleton & Co. Kadesh-Barnea: its Importance and probable Site. Charles Scribner’s sons, $5. Tuttle, Prof. H. History‘of Prussia to the Accession of Freder ic the Great. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co. Vandegrift, Margaret. The Queen’s Bods Philadelphia: Porter & Coates $1 5 Wickes, Dr. . Sepulture: its einters, Methods, and ioe Requisites. Philadelphia: P. Blakiston, Son 10. the United States. iH. guard: aStory. | GAS FIXTURES, NEWEST AND CHOICEST DESIGNS Metal and Porcelain La won ete. | Stee Clocks. An entirely new assortment of the choicest productions of aris, Vienna, Rerlin, and other European cities, selected by us with great care this season- are now on exhibition in our Artistic Bronzes. showrooms, which have been fitted up with special regard to the exhibiton of Art Pro- ductions, and to an inspection of which a cordial invita- tion is extended. Also articles of Ornamental Metal Work, both antique and modern, in great variety and elegance of workman ship. "MITCHELL, VANCE & CO., re 836 and 838 Broadway and 13th Street, N. Y. ; SHORT ROUTE TO LONDON, “NORT H GERMAN LLOYD MAIL S. S. LINE. The steamers of this C —y will sail every Wednes- lay and Saturday from Bremen Pier, foot of Third Street, Hoboken KATES OF PASSAGE TO LONDON, HAVRE, AND I. Cabin, $80 and $100; II. Cabin, $60; Steerage, $20. VELRICHS & Cu. , AGENTs, Q Bowling Green. — TIDDER, PEABODY & CO. 1 Nassau St., N. Y.; 113 Devonshire St., Boston. EXCHANGF AND LETTERS OF CREDIT ON GREAT BRITAIN AND THE CONTINENT, Correspondents : BARING BROTHERS & Co., London; PERIER FRERES & Co., Parts ; MENDELSSOHN & Co., Berlin. Mantel Sets.

Page 21